id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02333v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02333v1 | Why do LLaVA Vision-Language Models Reply to Images in English? | 2024-07-02T15:01:55 | 2024-07-02T15:01:55 | Musashi Hinck, Carolin Holtermann, Matthew Lyle Olson, Florian Schneider, Sungduk Yu, Anahita Bhiwandiwalla, Anne Lauscher, Shaoyen Tseng, Vasudev Lal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | We uncover a surprising multilingual bias occurring in a popular class of
multimodal vision-language models (VLMs). Including an image in the query to a
LLaVA-style VLM significantly increases the likelihood of the model returning
an English response, regardless of the language of the query. This paper
investigates the causes of this loss with a two-pronged approach that combines
extensive ablation of the design space with a mechanistic analysis of the
models' internal representations of image and text inputs. Both approaches
indicate that the issue stems in the language modelling component of the LLaVA
model. Statistically, we find that switching the language backbone for a
bilingual language model has the strongest effect on reducing this error.
Mechanistically, we provide compelling evidence that visual inputs are not
mapped to a similar space as text ones, and that intervening on intermediary
attention layers can reduce this bias. Our findings provide important insights
to researchers and engineers seeking to understand the crossover between
multimodal and multilingual spaces, and contribute to the goal of developing
capable and inclusive VLMs for non-English contexts. | [
0.0238626469,
0.0259211697,
-0.0377752818,
0.0787943751,
-0.0077792318,
0.0071066725,
0.0316351615,
-0.0114006856,
0.0304484665,
-0.0600156002,
-0.046865087,
-0.0692457482,
0.0268885568,
0.0197671037,
0.0701574683,
-0.0637963787,
0.0334584825,
-0.0474864244,
-0.0435186513,
-0.0244719423,
0.0000311298,
0.0041318275,
0.0210326035,
0.0279183537,
-0.0118020456,
-0.0174761396,
-0.0223264843,
0.027764447,
-0.0172345266,
0.0004866953,
-0.0189799536,
0.021785723,
-0.0092905583,
-0.0037548731,
0.0000019179,
-0.0217426792,
0.0484763905,
0.001659713,
0.0472205095,
-0.007012804,
0.0351396538,
0.0035426363,
0.0004015904,
0.0213605165,
-0.0266021658,
0.0013949957,
0.0944002941,
0.0180810019,
0.0076271077,
0.0065470138,
-0.0196755659,
-0.0141128693,
-0.027589485,
0.0190812014,
0.0337775461,
-0.0134062003,
-0.0049558249,
-0.0206003673,
0.0197152477,
0.0040599457,
-0.0512997396,
0.0736083016,
0.0349371433,
-0.007520379,
-0.0092175109,
0.0449287333,
-0.0255161375,
-0.0611032471,
-0.0272464287,
0.0473510921,
-0.0203420091,
-0.0105843768,
-0.0181162655,
0.0203880854,
-0.0016060964,
0.0007176046,
-0.0248649605,
0.0240700301,
-0.003455807,
0.0072596478,
-0.0295932256,
-0.030598972,
0.0121791046,
-0.0061002998,
-0.0344281644,
0.023562178,
0.0192237291,
0.0282805506,
-0.0013384182,
0.0205946509,
0.0260465685,
-0.051605612,
0.0103456676,
0.0239733774,
0.0011177082,
0.0134792496,
-0.0066209193,
-0.0380203053,
0.0001159263,
-0.0759977624,
0.0524588749,
0.0401055813,
-0.0745515078,
0.0324793607,
-0.0129828108,
0.0604249351,
-0.0463778935,
0.0526478849,
-0.0451120511,
-0.0376641043,
0.0225303713,
-0.0337061509,
0.0138202701,
-0.015718136,
-0.0498015732,
-0.0283987913,
-0.0199006312,
0.0627028197,
-0.0101908762,
-0.0302691869,
-0.0148227373,
0.0082330601,
-0.0241898671,
-0.0024892036,
-0.0426606983,
0.0571053289,
0.030062668,
0.005378088,
-0.0265579335,
-0.0964774042,
0.0314502418,
0.0343681611,
-0.0348796025,
-0.049614545,
-0.0548168011,
0.0971578881,
-0.0419245213,
-0.0135720186,
-0.0193652511,
-0.0079458691,
-0.0256148912,
-0.0260162894,
0.0526333489,
-0.0466207117,
0.0258971807,
0.0336645022,
0.0073109767,
-0.0427244641,
0.004842524,
0.0205256771,
-0.0278629232,
0.093970865,
0.0153510803,
0.0226581823,
0.0387035534,
-0.0106174024,
0.0289594885,
0.1021171808,
0.0182460882,
0.0191108696,
0.0394944102,
-0.0191072691,
-0.008166803,
0.0917894691,
-0.0325387269,
-0.0156648178,
-0.0637268275,
0.0134174507,
0.0162785742,
-0.0058257487,
0.0546742603,
0.0371915661,
-0.0084026726,
-0.0199720357,
0.0710574314,
0.0422163978,
0.0186785925,
0.0009530769,
-0.0167279579,
-0.0320677236,
-0.0097242426,
0.0068767979,
-0.0728588849,
0.0860041901,
-0.0133311804,
0.0025606251,
0.0140007641,
0.0468595922,
-0.0453105457,
-0.0273333676,
-0.0212301072,
0.010892882,
0.0075441534,
0.0349947289,
0.0386366174,
-0.0141621493,
0.0153071024,
0.0092771444,
-0.0090055438,
-0.0576519333,
0.0212544817,
-0.0378434137,
-0.0191852394,
0.0432563461,
-0.0021271692,
0.0201980639,
-0.0021742985,
0.0194231588,
0.0186629239,
0.0756045952,
0.0472588204,
0.0144879436,
0.0176080931,
-0.0288541988,
-0.0472465642,
0.0064153229,
-0.0291935503,
0.0205327366,
-0.0525773391,
0.004017246,
0.0038400639,
-0.0409689657,
-0.0185061656,
0.0219403394,
-0.0150758754,
0.0098657152,
-0.0260077566,
0.0376114063,
0.0007619322,
-0.0061234161,
0.0053562997,
0.030351188,
0.0040039518,
-0.0171717089,
0.0390626006,
0.0393865369,
0.0120272636,
-0.0048654815,
0.0484136418,
-0.0803167149,
0.0273292232,
0.0165185854,
0.0030842887,
-0.0261482466,
0.0205684043,
-0.0464078598,
0.0283110552,
-0.0283174347,
-0.0013736724,
-0.0120065352,
0.0223502032,
-0.0452376604,
0.0158000141,
-0.0341043212,
-0.0089870747,
-0.000708986,
-0.0023167869,
0.0311785135,
-0.0501680858,
-0.0307710487,
0.08370886,
0.022933634,
0.0336767733,
0.0278403405,
0.0034024091,
-0.0369402766,
0.0012909973,
-0.0813264772,
-0.0496339612,
-0.0326565132,
0.0011574436,
0.0194822643,
0.0183898453,
-0.0071527786,
-0.0524162613,
-0.0495066382,
0.0352673791,
-0.0046283822,
0.0627768785,
0.017343834,
-0.0437027588,
0.0244363379,
-0.0271479413,
-0.038656462,
0.0058513479,
0.0600098111,
-0.006381826,
-0.0671070665,
-0.057278689,
0.0234455671,
-0.0309871864,
0.0287311673,
-0.007241976,
-0.0293833427,
0.0305166785,
-0.0139511451,
0.0455192067,
0.0761956125,
-0.0170045514,
-0.0076258881,
0.0450157002,
-0.0234156288,
-0.0377355851,
0.0122418841,
0.0108207697,
-0.0247492678,
-0.0118206479,
-0.0376003198,
-0.0199265536,
0.0508181155,
-0.033340726,
0.0017346542,
-0.0591101162,
0.0197848305,
-0.0161749925,
-0.071395047,
-0.0562926717,
0.0378765576,
-0.0109907836,
0.0867363885,
-0.0304803345,
-0.0544303618,
0.0324264206,
-0.0143397972,
-0.0157607812,
-0.017589828,
0.0517597459,
-0.0056817168,
0.0355853215,
0.0023350529,
0.0305636134,
0.0005117623,
-0.013465832,
-0.08660236,
0.0067650424,
-0.0037565948,
-0.0201307572,
0.0830404609,
-0.0400599316,
-0.0102944206,
-0.0318428278,
-0.0302278716,
-0.0270982888,
0.0465029962,
-0.0331949927,
-0.0201757606,
-0.0433392115,
0.0063854153,
-0.025831243,
0.0319172144,
0.0632194057,
-0.005684088,
-0.0303466935,
-0.0109781176,
-0.0273982473,
-0.0073390086,
0.0347128399,
0.0537906699,
0.0217439067,
-0.0473891459,
-0.0174785145,
0.0359393321,
0.0264307503,
-0.0382766314,
0.0058270041,
0.0319353752,
0.0929769203,
0.053147085,
-0.0791914463,
0.0454491861,
0.0640178174,
-0.0255039781,
-0.0061554983,
0.0416721404,
0.0078773033,
-0.0627155602,
-0.0187091511,
-0.034635935,
0.0233774763,
0.0538168885,
0.0428578518,
-0.0608334951,
-0.0156545863,
-0.0089974999,
-0.0365150571,
0.0253285598,
0.0353111885,
-0.0193435811,
-0.099660188,
0.0286556967,
-0.0036177638,
-0.0251966212,
-0.0111854309,
0.0114015061,
0.0104645044,
0.0101703806,
0.0336388052,
0.0083281649,
-0.0217980333,
-0.0027689636,
0.004389178,
0.0311033484,
-0.0231248029,
-0.0390064418,
-0.0268183406,
-0.0262682885,
0.0677153394,
0.0190637764,
-0.0126251252,
-0.0692311451,
0.0391241871,
-0.008292296,
0.033458747,
-0.0181349758,
0.025095446,
0.0159798916,
-0.0291184932,
-0.0136276241,
-0.0155373579,
-0.0197989028,
-0.01079702,
-0.0232513677,
0.0486168191,
-0.0177613385,
0.0087949866,
-0.0448786058,
-0.0211894121,
-0.0312959738,
-0.0118636135,
0.028182419,
-0.054686714,
-0.0651774406,
-0.0685485005,
-0.0182893965,
-0.0105569782,
-0.0518743098,
0.0375969186,
-0.0138722314,
-0.0460865162,
-0.0184859037,
-0.0618311651,
-0.0205166768,
0.0209410544,
0.0247589033,
-0.0190997496,
0.0072145378,
-0.0177834351,
-0.0069723562,
0.0375562534,
-0.0127753466,
0.0492800549,
-0.0382174216,
0.0398966074,
-0.0131368758,
-0.0830717385,
0.0073106135,
0.0088432208,
-0.030577451,
-0.0605313741,
-0.0224180426,
0.0544325747,
0.020614678,
-0.0002977077,
0.007665568,
-0.1005305424,
0.0010154985,
0.0244194977,
0.0332528464,
0.0419899933,
0.0115753897,
-0.0093704527,
0.000176573,
0.0352142267,
-0.0515637882,
-0.027593011,
0.0408778898,
0.0186759494,
0.0080808317,
-0.0279537681,
0.0027153427,
0.0056105414,
0.0683090985,
-0.0189873222,
0.0057517365,
-0.0075168973,
0.0131103666,
-0.0145344511,
-0.000908887,
-0.0370344371,
-0.0197582897,
-0.0091714747,
0.0209150538,
0.0248736423,
0.0138052488,
-0.0089817857,
0.0040689791,
-0.0252037738,
0.0350367278,
0.039669171,
-0.002871806,
0.0041870591,
0.054652825,
-0.0028014847,
0.0353394672,
0.0004996043,
0.0341651924,
-0.006216852,
0.0645931587,
0.0096619707,
-0.0294143148,
-0.0341437869,
0.0389494412,
-0.0244162902,
-0.0442280695,
0.0112520987,
0.0065586553,
0.0649445653,
-0.0228025485,
0.0649794564,
0.0039659454,
-0.0048820633,
-0.035814926,
0.0337113924,
0.0248618554,
-0.0217074379,
0.0674136281,
-0.0174535178,
0.0029825084,
-0.0677691773,
0.048750218,
-0.0075294049,
-0.0206390955,
-0.0232217163,
-0.0028190585,
-0.0091893319,
-0.0287233181,
0.0588577688,
0.0050679347,
-0.0257564392,
0.0003324631,
-0.0565850623,
-0.0825691447,
-0.0047319238,
-0.0107237585,
-0.0077098119,
-0.028804088,
0.0540855713,
0.0795487985,
0.0378600955,
-0.0196576826,
-0.0279837735,
-0.0183355547,
-0.03250378,
-0.0064679664,
0.0138347438,
-5.821900626e-33,
-0.0158044677,
-0.0338907577,
0.0322489999,
-0.026219368,
-0.0027471723,
0.0056582671,
-0.0249154624,
0.013712205,
-0.0547073446,
-0.0060677198,
-0.0157821849,
-0.0050933645,
0.0159938447,
0.0181339178,
0.0408469029,
0.0100704273,
0.0030207483,
0.0195283387,
-0.0071138483,
-0.0236167125,
0.0268217102,
-0.0013331203,
0.0689260811,
-0.0463679321,
0.0291157272,
0.0346314423,
0.0042039156,
0.0043249386,
0.0128937205,
0.082743898,
-0.0520439036,
0.0806937143,
0.023687331,
0.0030862158,
-0.0421276428,
0.041234035,
-0.0274751447,
-0.0271056648,
0.0486412086,
0.0784219652,
-0.0504808947,
-0.0238464326,
0.061188329,
-0.0229307991,
-0.049934689,
-0.0388851315,
0.0473111235,
-0.0231014602,
-0.0414171144,
0.0296519455,
-0.0649700314,
-0.0056587034,
0.0125500187,
0.0024535237,
0.0671657547,
0.0777889341,
0.0118495785,
0.0225703344,
-0.0495229699,
0.0406361856,
-0.0254010968,
0.0272630975,
0.1242895275,
0.0780016333,
0.0174233504,
0.0174516793,
0.0569011681,
-0.0027516831,
-0.0078797182,
-0.0468392633,
0.0541746318,
0.0010587048,
0.0459983237,
0.0673093274,
-0.0199657008,
0.0002665069,
-0.0424446054,
-0.005168403,
-0.0339949951,
0.0683582276,
0.0294998996,
0.0229559448,
-0.0099986261,
-0.0176436808,
-0.0315302536,
-0.0469404608,
-0.0546045378,
-0.0237906277,
0.0501351394,
-0.0329778008,
0.0576895736,
0.0094563682,
0.0735577121,
-0.0378695987,
-0.0438502692,
-0.0117256986,
-0.006039117,
0.0392101742,
0.0236636773,
0.0421528853,
-0.0325216837,
-0.0090113161,
-0.0253419448,
0.0178230833,
-0.016788099,
0.0305056218,
-0.0047697155,
0.0009077438,
-0.0529359318,
-0.0245445054,
-0.0668499544,
-0.0343597494,
0.0351924188,
0.0406054333,
0.0598190166,
-0.0279525965,
-0.0258165915,
0.0396429189,
0.008405529,
-0.0282523893,
-0.0373865291,
-0.0577954724,
-0.0217060987,
0.0533835478,
-0.0532238521,
0.0093323244,
-0.0748965368,
0.0285253339,
0.0475573391,
-0.0636571199,
-0.040034622,
0.0366557576,
2.598e-7,
0.0557355322,
0.0209074672,
-0.0086301863,
0.0022123975,
0.0201777741,
0.0447038375,
-0.0236655027,
0.0608653985,
0.0126623753,
-0.0049725547,
-0.055562295,
0.0092224423,
0.033758834,
0.0045720567,
-0.0288796723,
0.0316053405,
-0.0028269372,
0.0341526642,
-0.0363896191,
0.0239024069,
0.0318984054,
0.0667140856,
-0.0494594388,
-0.0105872415,
-0.0040518157,
-0.020666752,
0.0632160455,
-0.0454206318,
0.0070840484,
-0.0290007629,
0.0174247734,
0.0153496852,
0.0115778437,
0.0150188776,
-0.0139766335,
-0.0172546916,
0.0491557457,
-0.0020637303,
-0.0406218991,
-0.0200576354,
0.0080388095,
-0.0092324205,
-0.0274509173,
-0.1024928465,
0.0701696277,
-0.0179832261,
-0.0105541265,
-0.0103459368,
0.0339572392,
-0.0019620445,
0.0446917787,
-0.0296382718,
-0.0311427787,
0.0058258693,
0.0447681919,
-0.0275999531,
-0.0254287049,
-0.0376880318,
-0.0472239703,
-0.0186956637,
-0.020729728,
-0.0190710444,
-0.0704549551,
0.0346314274,
0.0316669084,
0.0029736287,
-0.0376849174,
1.907162328e-34,
0.001375698,
-0.0020996651,
0.0353858769,
0.0237671118,
-0.0021592756,
-0.0408802405,
0.0027129052,
0.0176500734,
0.0204570498,
-0.0476726256,
-0.0176576581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02328v1 | Efficient Sparse Attention needs Adaptive Token Release | 2024-07-02T14:58:44 | 2024-07-02T14:58:44 | Chaoran Zhang, Lixin Zou, Dan Luo, Min Tang, Xiangyang Luo, Zihao Li, Chenliang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capabilities across a wide array of text-centric tasks. However, their `large'
scale introduces significant computational and storage challenges, particularly
in managing the key-value states of the transformer, which limits their wider
applicability. Therefore, we propose to adaptively release resources from
caches and rebuild the necessary key-value states. Particularly, we accomplish
this by a lightweight controller module to approximate an ideal top-$K$ sparse
attention. This module retains the tokens with the highest top-$K$ attention
weights and simultaneously rebuilds the discarded but necessary tokens, which
may become essential for future decoding. Comprehensive experiments in natural
language generation and modeling reveal that our method is not only competitive
with full attention in terms of performance but also achieves a significant
throughput improvement of up to 221.8%. The code for replication is available
on the https://github.com/WHUIR/ADORE. | [
0.0382155105,
0.05495793,
0.0129420385,
0.0172246844,
-0.0147748524,
-0.0091386102,
-0.0237931013,
-0.0032814571,
-0.0131802429,
-0.0340889208,
-0.0329443067,
-0.0558877029,
-0.0106045287,
0.0388200134,
0.0298196487,
-0.0180634595,
0.0412604436,
-0.0429969579,
0.0055841613,
0.0137599148,
-0.0078264773,
-0.0026021921,
0.0225986838,
0.0581504554,
-0.0053175199,
-0.0061146119,
-0.0354727097,
0.0119598703,
0.0107122725,
-0.0201414153,
0.0074987584,
0.0689519197,
-0.0232745782,
0.0339472592,
0.0000021812,
0.0025123809,
0.0031815039,
-0.0069119362,
-0.0116249686,
0.0426411107,
0.0729553029,
-0.0194847509,
-0.0299691856,
0.0036839554,
0.0055953371,
-0.0082596699,
0.083757326,
0.0092932638,
0.0778078139,
0.0827003345,
0.0059920992,
0.005609375,
0.0233765393,
-0.036158435,
0.0022155119,
-0.0720222071,
0.0192356445,
-0.0560902506,
0.0009844785,
-0.0085023502,
-0.0262663197,
0.0506493188,
0.0282988586,
-0.0159180854,
0.034538988,
0.0393197946,
-0.0417170487,
-0.0347849578,
-0.043875169,
0.0296067726,
-0.041019246,
-0.0430843271,
0.0175757241,
0.0142887793,
-0.0244409796,
-0.0677238554,
-0.0361666046,
0.0467766523,
0.0142753301,
0.0172883887,
0.0492731184,
-0.0112520466,
0.0117484359,
-0.0003457818,
-0.0639903843,
-0.0000278,
0.048229862,
-0.0301665105,
-0.0393134765,
0.0023812354,
-0.0233745649,
-0.074004069,
0.0385915413,
0.0543807894,
-0.0133553138,
-0.0056439997,
-0.075805299,
-0.0436238274,
0.0135788945,
-0.0210785288,
0.0548703223,
0.052948229,
-0.0094428454,
0.008976059,
-0.0151486993,
0.0620179214,
-0.0289685298,
0.0115062809,
-0.0320109315,
0.0032027666,
0.0107613197,
-0.0098915426,
-0.0455486514,
0.0579854622,
-0.0324246623,
-0.0414080694,
-0.021209335,
0.0319829583,
0.0321249142,
-0.0364570841,
0.0424407125,
0.0278480891,
-0.060627833,
0.0048378999,
0.0242945347,
0.0618748106,
-0.0040512807,
-0.0304159615,
0.0256746337,
-0.056157656,
-0.0446239002,
0.0318087414,
0.0171490144,
-0.0458455831,
-0.0343680754,
0.0459519029,
-0.0294063445,
-0.0392136462,
-0.0287926067,
0.0041268617,
-0.0110319108,
-0.0367779061,
-0.0212468319,
-0.0547682941,
0.0062719053,
0.011209459,
-0.0031262599,
-0.0444016606,
0.0137401912,
0.0542764515,
-0.0476316027,
0.0059355898,
-0.0047608754,
-0.0016386567,
-0.0199787039,
0.0021226003,
0.01998288,
0.0465944111,
0.0244678985,
0.0687121525,
-0.0163552053,
-0.00323341,
-0.0008258304,
0.0390420891,
0.0368409194,
-0.0035256294,
-0.009463232,
-0.0247126706,
-0.0332735144,
-0.0060840738,
0.0613407344,
0.0969274715,
-0.021387618,
0.0076574301,
0.0694404244,
0.0427208021,
-0.0028198657,
0.0538708828,
0.0313357189,
0.0153095825,
-0.0317778029,
-0.004605738,
-0.047876779,
0.0597116314,
0.0098116128,
0.009040378,
0.0771340132,
0.0549869724,
-0.0354255065,
0.0057407673,
-0.0113061424,
-0.0297862422,
0.0104823243,
-0.0313769318,
0.0385800563,
0.0343936123,
-0.082974799,
0.0923254341,
0.0249449238,
-0.0624185242,
-0.0012153954,
-0.0484676249,
0.0043693609,
0.0611283109,
0.0508564003,
0.03301825,
-0.0120453741,
0.0187070072,
-0.0027354956,
0.0602137633,
0.0244106725,
0.0326040424,
0.0104604596,
-0.0607678816,
0.004314038,
-0.0024925759,
0.0029638393,
0.0106135895,
0.0144289322,
0.0215468053,
0.0406250022,
0.0108257495,
-0.0008956391,
0.0146723241,
0.0018302556,
-0.0117783472,
-0.0054332288,
-0.0088695353,
0.0399361439,
0.0129452571,
0.0046175239,
0.0499324426,
0.0501302704,
-0.0415925384,
0.0074266703,
0.0128332423,
-0.058582224,
-0.0259452537,
0.0298226383,
0.0043521975,
0.0176355559,
0.0456606932,
-0.0070005641,
-0.0489952043,
0.0555801317,
-0.0698489174,
0.0757632777,
-0.0330676138,
0.0258355793,
0.0365852267,
0.0381768011,
-0.015991427,
0.0566817857,
-0.030376615,
0.0006963543,
0.0002416365,
0.0163868573,
-0.0349721909,
-0.0340188257,
-0.0308452807,
-0.0290361289,
-0.0485650413,
0.0216351748,
0.0187039208,
0.0182096101,
0.0039904159,
-0.0372280814,
-0.0479493476,
0.0212544724,
-0.0293300729,
0.0211999305,
0.0098557025,
0.0471901149,
0.0118071008,
0.0153336711,
-0.0184585005,
-0.0240766779,
0.0276289061,
0.014227083,
-0.0153507087,
-0.0155108701,
-0.0177654736,
-0.0277695954,
-0.0283853263,
0.030058004,
0.0244777016,
-0.0128988121,
-0.0107625294,
-0.0437835306,
0.0260861944,
-0.001482632,
-0.0000753181,
0.0217420943,
-0.0528489053,
0.0048622959,
-0.0299187452,
0.0674762875,
0.0272406749,
0.0167063922,
0.0191839468,
0.0185770225,
-0.0130903274,
-0.0244553182,
0.0197202507,
-0.0219938457,
-0.0135665443,
-0.0225228518,
-0.0276641175,
0.0493812673,
0.106518589,
0.0058572558,
-0.005989077,
-0.0851555839,
-0.0289109666,
-0.0019448041,
-0.0387748592,
0.0176636074,
0.030857902,
-0.0585730039,
-0.0033978219,
-0.0474655777,
-0.0222926531,
0.045078136,
-0.0260772202,
-0.0160076823,
-0.035531085,
0.027100563,
-0.0225788467,
0.0230159815,
0.0085873147,
0.0198801402,
-0.0210272819,
-0.0332998075,
-0.004755965,
0.0225503948,
-0.0632910803,
-0.0188053362,
0.0594669282,
-0.0162546169,
0.0242849533,
-0.0209673513,
-0.0318079069,
-0.0418088026,
-0.0176878497,
-0.0164507534,
0.0081657711,
0.0547462218,
-0.0121902442,
-0.051443141,
0.030551834,
0.0058533945,
0.0433350876,
-0.0284541436,
0.0122273723,
-0.0312599801,
0.0362645425,
0.0567707829,
0.0143114636,
0.0003396731,
-0.0423695184,
-0.0100039802,
0.0916005448,
0.0634414628,
0.016981544,
-0.0160841253,
-0.0080094934,
0.0544713289,
-0.0020566562,
0.0114805987,
0.015519022,
0.0502553061,
-0.0410030112,
-0.0570031777,
0.0988159105,
0.0239782743,
-0.0655187964,
0.0305066016,
-0.0014000345,
0.056150496,
0.0064757923,
0.0064688716,
-0.0679086298,
-0.0310964566,
0.0111477161,
0.0467819944,
0.0187158734,
-0.022700971,
0.004101045,
-0.0943572372,
0.0025946375,
0.0344395563,
-0.0341050588,
-0.0402734615,
-0.0194735024,
-0.0189798195,
-0.0006183862,
0.0074284892,
0.0607867837,
0.0118680857,
-0.0014255726,
0.0149108265,
0.051060006,
-0.0300395805,
-0.0085306484,
-0.0184064638,
0.0534259938,
0.035450045,
0.0087693557,
0.0349129252,
-0.0155055914,
-0.0059400583,
-0.0049431892,
-0.0118169431,
-0.0279858988,
-0.0315008536,
-0.0026121233,
-0.0288023464,
-0.0203224942,
0.012264818,
-0.0420104787,
-0.0117344288,
-0.0245097876,
0.0589555092,
-0.0046250871,
-0.0211392101,
-0.0024494976,
-0.0277282838,
0.0027503786,
0.0781650767,
0.0409460329,
-0.0383141041,
-0.052376315,
-0.0334445909,
0.0012943415,
-0.1160509288,
-0.0388214849,
-0.0013027287,
0.0144950813,
-0.0273092706,
-0.0672305301,
0.0019856626,
0.0036685856,
0.0360227972,
-0.0103502525,
-0.0121721057,
0.0097538484,
-0.0317312032,
-0.0644889921,
0.0190980975,
-0.0610057339,
-0.0159609485,
-0.0879315063,
-0.0433929749,
0.0042804591,
-0.0231933333,
-0.0175562985,
0.0498967804,
-0.1077836901,
-0.0579168163,
0.0277121849,
0.0615921691,
0.0221374072,
0.0166677013,
-0.0107304342,
-0.0463898331,
0.0311061218,
0.0346322469,
-0.0778591782,
0.0482218862,
-0.0280754268,
-0.0066259787,
0.0008338546,
0.042387668,
-0.0368099548,
0.0173149277,
0.0097983163,
0.0820381492,
0.0222736578,
-0.0046887454,
0.0083064409,
0.0031381592,
-0.0137484744,
-0.0154522369,
0.0323808044,
0.0158940498,
0.0127351061,
-0.0032902069,
0.015791323,
-0.0495923385,
0.0078941872,
0.0151285687,
-0.0073678321,
-0.0012308891,
-0.0056377808,
0.0305677112,
0.0210704338,
-0.0188655388,
-0.015470176,
-0.0196392238,
0.0000507024,
0.0575946681,
-0.0086830864,
-0.0414470434,
-0.0175448805,
-0.0083546294,
0.0166723654,
-0.0432980582,
-0.0016160687,
0.009687989,
0.0099311899,
-0.0366860107,
0.0275509544,
-0.033333607,
-0.0177787989,
-0.0290519949,
0.0080370372,
0.0538071729,
0.0089823455,
0.0671272799,
-0.0224788208,
-0.0121166222,
-0.034904547,
0.0275333058,
0.0146658504,
-0.0433078185,
0.001462971,
0.0123377386,
0.0121496785,
-0.0082191657,
0.0704358667,
0.0227110144,
0.0276400261,
-0.0129103949,
0.0036426203,
-0.049822513,
-0.0290932134,
-0.0429502428,
-0.0046501588,
-0.0208052117,
-0.0002084614,
-0.0412741788,
-0.0719071701,
0.0100434469,
-0.0180096459,
0.0071887607,
-0.0324223079,
0.0467648692,
0.017250048,
0.0026636086,
-0.0204143953,
-0.0165053625,
0.0273530558,
0.0014746689,
-0.0422939062,
-0.0223577805,
-7.255413415e-33,
-0.0395113789,
0.0060597965,
0.0109963613,
-0.0204632506,
-0.0446916036,
0.0099376654,
-0.0914710686,
-0.0309364423,
0.0202888716,
-0.0270352978,
-0.014318997,
-0.0159669127,
0.0126058897,
0.0565792248,
-0.0134973964,
0.0192094184,
0.0652817562,
-0.0131819341,
-0.0365789831,
0.0715520978,
0.0406558216,
0.0397961102,
0.0154830869,
0.0103931082,
-0.0260848999,
-0.0002260878,
0.0073074284,
-0.0213044081,
-0.0052565611,
0.0353168249,
-0.0407964252,
0.0324982628,
0.017621072,
-0.0289211888,
-0.0404661521,
0.024557706,
-0.0541384891,
0.0126021085,
0.0212394614,
-0.0069451714,
0.0105059715,
-0.0760725811,
0.0273017734,
0.0152447829,
-0.0245582387,
0.0019455783,
-0.0182130039,
0.0094481055,
-0.0679251626,
-0.0233767517,
-0.0777821392,
0.0189027172,
0.0004732969,
-0.0069186576,
-0.0028863887,
0.002135437,
-0.0193140712,
0.0145973712,
-0.0283965599,
0.0067502502,
0.0057881377,
0.0938186869,
0.0544867665,
0.0375510752,
0.0018320443,
0.0451873168,
0.0229733046,
0.0004681841,
-0.0379953049,
0.0456809849,
0.0340394303,
0.021863902,
0.0203611534,
-0.0169304814,
0.0193051603,
-0.0362161547,
-0.0248769838,
-0.0143961953,
0.0153713198,
0.0702485815,
0.0681716204,
0.0231642947,
-0.009997786,
-0.0099135833,
-0.0008296305,
0.0247141887,
-0.0474187769,
0.0003921757,
0.0383424126,
0.0596431158,
-0.0602924041,
-0.0165444724,
0.0598178059,
-0.0272034295,
0.0219306927,
0.0333922282,
0.0277151149,
0.0265386775,
-0.0206107814,
0.0023157971,
-0.0558393151,
-0.0207828004,
0.0236918647,
0.0023231048,
-0.0186083727,
0.0109134438,
-0.0164973978,
0.0536960289,
-0.0486358479,
0.0025853545,
-0.0570695437,
0.0499209985,
-0.0053707212,
0.0250520576,
0.0312655009,
-0.0171116684,
0.0077607511,
0.052696608,
-0.0074146478,
-0.0068733324,
-0.0131604522,
0.0023345812,
0.0564331934,
0.0444491059,
-0.0363026075,
0.0285475254,
-0.084334746,
0.027424695,
0.0234767664,
-0.067220591,
-0.0288202539,
0.0435253456,
2.897e-7,
0.0133463563,
0.0251053441,
0.0540834442,
-0.0212540664,
0.0385075659,
-0.0089780502,
0.0017171717,
0.0397686809,
0.0000856017,
0.0414421298,
-0.0203949604,
0.0198302697,
0.0524709485,
-0.0090271086,
-0.1236934885,
0.0240418557,
-0.0711621866,
0.0091098864,
-0.0641727597,
-0.0279549155,
-0.0093434872,
0.097577326,
-0.0327393785,
-0.0148337353,
0.0284350906,
-0.0059451312,
0.0503350198,
0.0381828696,
0.002934922,
0.0091084344,
0.031039428,
0.0049818349,
-0.0099222176,
-0.0578712858,
-0.0187109839,
-0.0101113049,
-0.009930375,
0.0891044214,
-0.0009312925,
-0.0848788247,
0.0477409251,
-0.0085218363,
-0.0134584485,
-0.0341669209,
0.0539265238,
-0.049702663,
-0.0089069996,
-0.034527123,
-0.0082427049,
0.0324232206,
-0.0833871067,
-0.0302237887,
-0.0253060553,
0.0267519299,
0.0374971926,
0.0097159352,
-0.002959965,
-0.0611824654,
-0.0467332639,
-0.0471311323,
-0.0828869939,
-0.0293571688,
-0.0804492906,
0.0066445745,
0.006730834,
-0.0347920358,
-0.0266771261,
2.981689864e-34,
0.0519437529,
-0.0366360918,
0.0027085287,
0.0586181618,
0.0255019516,
-0.0123022571,
0.0230919626,
0.0380761772,
0.0060461545,
-0.0822689682,
-0.0667765215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02320v1 | Exploring the Role of Transliteration in In-Context Learning for Low-resource Languages Written in Non-Latin Scripts | 2024-07-02T14:51:20 | 2024-07-02T14:51:20 | Chunlan Ma, Yihong Liu, Haotian Ye, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Decoder-only large language models (LLMs) excel in high-resource languages
across various tasks through few-shot or even zero-shot in-context learning
(ICL). However, their performance often does not transfer well to low-resource
languages, especially those written in non-Latin scripts. Inspired by recent
work that leverages transliteration in encoder-only models, we investigate
whether transliteration is also effective in improving LLMs' performance for
low-resource languages written in non-Latin scripts. To this end, we propose
three prompt templates, where the target-language text is represented in (1)
its original script, (2) Latin script, or (3) both. We apply these methods to
several representative LLMs of different sizes on various tasks including text
classification and sequential labeling. Our findings show that the
effectiveness of transliteration varies by task type and model size. For
instance, all models benefit from transliterations for sequential labeling
(with increases of up to 25%). | [
0.0051830304,
0.0393401384,
0.009942078,
0.0292994659,
-0.0171325728,
0.0629817173,
0.0616949797,
0.0274308808,
-0.0305426382,
-0.0140524786,
-0.051780317,
-0.0741262957,
0.0467727892,
-0.0223302562,
0.029439766,
-0.0345281735,
-0.0008922966,
-0.0672405958,
-0.0064162356,
-0.0051527899,
-0.0239123572,
0.0168068726,
0.0145624792,
0.0053968374,
0.022979293,
-0.0251986645,
0.002776928,
0.0357739404,
0.0239710547,
-0.0055767628,
-0.0244157538,
0.0417575985,
0.0256305989,
0.0691830888,
0.0000018488,
-0.0441200696,
-0.0071013747,
-0.0296365023,
-0.0483385883,
0.0239982009,
0.0665686801,
-0.0700833723,
-0.0620082282,
0.0078407284,
0.0345640592,
-0.0448127277,
0.0656146631,
-0.0097580859,
-0.0051781344,
0.0640934855,
-0.0183218848,
-0.0430290997,
-0.0052329414,
-0.0451238789,
-0.0095292581,
-0.0361361057,
-0.0034437943,
-0.0337351151,
-0.0160949994,
0.0167279579,
-0.0333868153,
0.0499940552,
0.0311222263,
0.0080154464,
-0.0305104628,
0.0436920673,
0.0290830601,
-0.0285581481,
0.0224297605,
0.044838611,
-0.0333509929,
-0.0321511552,
-0.0330735594,
0.0127686514,
-0.0015557515,
-0.0478618667,
-0.0189950522,
0.0428030826,
-0.0289939903,
0.0120894182,
0.0537820235,
0.0471270978,
0.0328933075,
-0.0050267573,
-0.0404095426,
-0.0164358746,
0.0457483754,
-0.0391926169,
0.0095535917,
0.0394688621,
0.0225015711,
-0.0401236676,
-0.006992233,
0.021931028,
-0.0169350449,
0.0102408547,
-0.0379146785,
-0.0494262725,
-0.010103575,
-0.0065759243,
0.0502056181,
0.0507396385,
-0.0066410196,
0.0324065611,
-0.0543605499,
0.0736469179,
0.0129464166,
0.0182149354,
-0.0324651897,
-0.0307724327,
0.0019037887,
0.0098512908,
-0.0578802601,
-0.0208220389,
-0.0299701281,
0.0235541612,
-0.0280602388,
0.0441009328,
0.0349388309,
0.0452994257,
-0.008565994,
-0.0572842397,
-0.0338057652,
-0.0415590927,
0.028072929,
0.0510542989,
-0.0116019035,
-0.0131365433,
-0.0238907896,
-0.0721838847,
-0.0139453569,
0.0197667927,
0.0208870228,
-0.0286991857,
0.0206201654,
0.0646065101,
-0.0501536205,
-0.07496465,
0.0034228577,
0.0248339549,
-0.0181536246,
-0.0559609197,
-0.0393330716,
-0.0532249101,
0.0471814349,
0.0258578975,
0.0431664884,
-0.0373536199,
0.0013983775,
0.0259714592,
0.0044516204,
0.0691132247,
0.0340490229,
0.0076048789,
0.0294696782,
-0.0247328375,
0.0298231561,
0.0545840859,
0.0080805402,
0.0331381373,
0.020261528,
-0.0112697342,
0.0039887405,
0.0879705027,
-0.0044604717,
0.0314669907,
-0.0453078449,
-0.0035506524,
0.080652304,
0.0213221759,
0.030421745,
0.0190071333,
-0.0306182262,
0.0132199591,
0.0725023672,
0.0359503329,
-0.0040477789,
-0.0033493428,
0.0065703974,
0.0183718801,
-0.0203742422,
-0.0352301076,
-0.0024520939,
0.0202807337,
0.0271917302,
0.0109499013,
0.0214010254,
0.0351165086,
-0.0493869111,
-0.0129730534,
-0.0081808949,
-0.0499026962,
-0.0223652478,
0.022952145,
0.0933044776,
0.0177513883,
-0.0830760896,
-0.011757141,
0.029929705,
-0.026384417,
0.014634259,
-0.0189932361,
0.0125196455,
0.0814239085,
0.0580157973,
0.0090498896,
-0.0045973607,
-0.0167482682,
0.024987258,
0.0433948673,
-0.0043074023,
-0.0286812931,
0.0352564417,
-0.0675732642,
0.0065964106,
0.0272182543,
-0.0025978778,
0.0382999256,
-0.0286967997,
0.0361236334,
0.0043923957,
-0.0328849368,
-0.0416794308,
0.0273087397,
-0.0555012636,
-0.0404065065,
0.0140657797,
0.0201895144,
-0.0083375983,
-0.0059489617,
-0.0254248325,
-0.0101454956,
-0.0099372044,
-0.0772768632,
0.02529498,
0.0015372295,
-0.0634155497,
-0.0736035556,
0.0024165907,
0.0314651243,
-0.0224403013,
0.0057174428,
-0.020262152,
-0.0390193686,
-0.0095369592,
-0.0219094194,
0.0077559473,
-0.0275683068,
0.0278593861,
-0.026078146,
-0.0185310226,
-0.0456697755,
0.0434502028,
0.0128284805,
0.0092430618,
0.049685251,
-0.0029653497,
0.0148835368,
-0.0221849047,
-0.0344773978,
0.0617310368,
0.0057815611,
-0.0167392883,
0.0177874733,
0.0175473467,
0.0375448577,
-0.0302237123,
-0.0857141539,
-0.0110621797,
-0.0560987443,
0.0135545703,
0.0074387649,
0.035236232,
-0.0046432908,
-0.0388369448,
-0.0132820318,
-0.0102304658,
-0.003663491,
0.0274410844,
0.0038389612,
-0.0022687381,
-0.0041092406,
0.0043704761,
-0.0285666678,
0.0520370118,
0.0578269847,
0.0096433349,
-0.051990632,
-0.0567045137,
0.03726466,
0.029452512,
-0.0126086557,
-0.0177976731,
-0.0118757403,
0.0078288978,
-0.0129867392,
0.0456173606,
0.0359470472,
-0.0355785042,
0.0164401401,
0.0394916497,
0.0176370852,
-0.0248831827,
-0.0269577447,
0.0190762859,
-0.0693974346,
-0.0702986568,
-0.04424816,
-0.0075991275,
0.0591366217,
-0.0254990347,
0.0279758144,
-0.093490608,
-0.0386610664,
-0.0423386768,
-0.015131616,
-0.0724304765,
0.009658983,
-0.0068083061,
0.0445563234,
-0.019464815,
-0.0339085869,
0.0612553097,
-0.0402489975,
-0.04021357,
-0.0274065863,
-0.0058170687,
-0.0474473462,
0.0286787655,
-0.003890228,
0.023171952,
-0.027936941,
-0.0690829828,
-0.0263558794,
0.0559421554,
0.010941443,
-0.0228859037,
0.0397012793,
-0.0307986252,
0.0121782403,
-0.031668108,
-0.0398439467,
-0.028404925,
-0.0057797949,
-0.0272466931,
0.0037967619,
-0.0174766295,
0.0130201215,
-0.0082866782,
0.0387725979,
0.0218436867,
0.0929022804,
0.0012895055,
0.0069704107,
-0.0147666922,
0.0236235894,
-0.0096033141,
-0.019664729,
-0.0363299809,
-0.0535537489,
0.0808449313,
0.0064366604,
0.0342872031,
-0.0493592545,
0.0056785019,
-0.0165640023,
0.0704786852,
0.0286896098,
-0.0170574933,
0.0154937701,
0.0284887906,
-0.0344122425,
-0.0292381495,
0.112687625,
0.0044440557,
-0.0917603225,
-0.0186695065,
-0.0292308722,
0.0292014331,
0.0107784793,
0.0138812093,
-0.0711186081,
-0.0395093597,
0.0261494126,
0.0433060452,
0.0179760158,
0.0003581404,
0.0003004825,
-0.1312339157,
0.0220320784,
0.0281497911,
-0.0538430773,
-0.072331056,
-0.0435494855,
-0.0210284069,
-0.0223315097,
0.0087784268,
0.0386608578,
0.0053898236,
-0.0202887934,
0.0335277021,
0.0077962573,
-0.0876280442,
-0.0218263697,
-0.030928202,
0.0104732467,
0.0494397432,
-0.0017203792,
-0.0185573809,
0.0265034828,
0.0255370885,
-0.0400953554,
-0.0071779327,
-0.0077238502,
0.0324411876,
-0.0032015732,
-0.0348055176,
0.0045039961,
0.0015926302,
-0.0589072183,
-0.0244768001,
0.0135788219,
0.0456102975,
-0.0140186483,
-0.0038357021,
0.0469056703,
-0.0531592034,
0.0126209371,
0.0627021044,
0.0137294326,
-0.0567963794,
-0.0308137741,
-0.022966994,
-0.0040657516,
-0.046924524,
-0.009804816,
0.0071706739,
-0.0046940106,
-0.0847278386,
-0.0650974661,
-0.0539516658,
0.0217508581,
0.0237388965,
-0.0077932905,
0.0146683361,
-0.0210785009,
-0.0095790466,
-0.0088397879,
-0.0398604944,
-0.0386795364,
0.018223159,
-0.0923845172,
-0.0165917687,
0.0278080665,
-0.0308755357,
0.0034922278,
0.0388730541,
-0.0651749596,
-0.0463813432,
-0.0142311184,
-0.0091437465,
0.0090692351,
0.0464968309,
-0.0103109377,
-0.0481746309,
0.0939393565,
-0.0204962511,
0.0315776728,
0.0393769145,
0.0228048358,
-0.0137592833,
-0.0367077105,
0.0426254272,
-0.0225413311,
0.0113538997,
0.0365395211,
0.0074253888,
-0.0471229404,
-0.014494027,
0.0182558689,
-0.0029789866,
0.005086435,
-0.0565254688,
-0.0466004983,
-0.0384920537,
0.0382319912,
-0.0222375989,
0.0130387219,
-0.0032908362,
-0.0154211512,
0.0657468066,
0.0001747101,
0.0064393179,
0.0301049128,
0.0277299732,
0.0193595644,
-0.0163674355,
0.0031218398,
0.0034667128,
0.0308210943,
0.036149051,
0.038180124,
-0.0293086879,
0.054797478,
-0.000472097,
0.0350535065,
-0.0471994877,
0.0291879587,
0.0167862028,
0.0066116978,
0.0325220786,
0.0343281366,
0.0064599733,
-0.0276343934,
-0.017797675,
0.0090361657,
0.0664188862,
-0.0055083856,
0.0588605069,
-0.0474083275,
0.0034451985,
-0.0475487486,
-0.0022899888,
0.0095913578,
-0.0474814773,
-0.0148023712,
0.0082978364,
0.0038934625,
0.0109788245,
0.097299926,
0.041098278,
0.0181394573,
0.0065360093,
0.0212861225,
-0.0205759294,
0.0103300037,
-0.0031971491,
-0.0134703331,
-0.0283390488,
0.0252886266,
-0.0401647799,
-0.0549530685,
0.0146415532,
-0.0373707078,
-0.0209044144,
-0.0238919966,
0.0215236712,
0.037375249,
-0.0092290733,
0.0529269688,
-0.0335499309,
0.0397536531,
-0.0050964872,
-0.0251619611,
-0.0295809582,
-5.427692718e-33,
-0.0249471348,
0.0222283509,
0.0135842692,
-0.0523873381,
0.0311156902,
0.0137926163,
-0.0434203595,
-0.0058279671,
0.01137417,
0.011671273,
-0.0119432332,
-0.0196426492,
0.0223095082,
0.0461451747,
0.0016740778,
-0.0315941386,
0.0651782751,
0.0023639614,
-0.0287845004,
0.0408067778,
0.0600691102,
0.038802091,
0.0625993907,
0.0043057692,
0.0134147331,
-0.0546818487,
0.0159727875,
0.0049106115,
0.0547440909,
0.0323976167,
-0.0009170665,
0.0436876751,
0.0235207062,
-0.077537857,
-0.0081370501,
0.067769818,
-0.0834871307,
0.0163704548,
-0.0267086029,
0.0643860549,
0.0064227958,
-0.0740422159,
-0.0415988415,
-0.0096814213,
-0.0335250348,
-0.0100811021,
0.0177570228,
-0.0303065442,
-0.0471758172,
-0.0513622686,
-0.07792072,
0.0293725654,
0.0022354003,
-0.0192704629,
0.070708707,
0.0712850541,
0.0043724556,
0.0529561341,
-0.0680673197,
0.0110149784,
-0.0487046726,
0.0428401418,
0.0625821799,
0.0485832356,
-0.0364287831,
0.0039290045,
-0.0145953996,
0.0097590284,
0.0119601041,
0.0002957183,
0.0250541102,
-0.0330969654,
0.0340572931,
0.0529094636,
0.033640489,
-0.0297104828,
-0.0701034442,
0.0043279617,
0.0095586963,
0.0160842016,
0.0699561089,
-0.0137855122,
-0.0313476734,
-0.0225204974,
-0.0192062259,
-0.0225041229,
-0.0178240817,
0.0204547122,
0.0310830828,
0.0034404199,
-0.0091059618,
-0.0055557466,
0.0960786343,
-0.004568039,
-0.0011479409,
0.0600092486,
-0.0021958384,
0.0530786365,
-0.0108011803,
0.0299542006,
-0.0409613028,
-0.0210917629,
0.0260479283,
-0.0325999372,
-0.0019291239,
-0.0189692117,
0.0593718104,
0.0029344498,
-0.0619411655,
-0.0071272831,
-0.0220189877,
0.042197641,
0.0287343841,
0.0688889921,
0.0351531878,
0.0028045105,
0.0030704495,
0.0609695837,
0.0222084094,
-0.0411202908,
0.0269960761,
0.0012505749,
-0.0228905436,
-0.0235953387,
-0.0243289471,
0.0245963857,
-0.0274216384,
0.0328073762,
0.0404853411,
-0.0074300594,
-0.0043490576,
0.0198571198,
2.536e-7,
0.0287591498,
0.0328147002,
0.0281974897,
-0.0044314857,
0.0370956361,
0.0425326936,
-0.0213696361,
0.0326705463,
0.0156945158,
-0.0045586415,
0.0218003988,
-0.0011008868,
0.0843217671,
0.001349373,
-0.0867178664,
-0.0115908552,
-0.0366442204,
0.0305503532,
-0.0423829146,
0.0380265862,
0.0141785312,
0.1239947528,
-0.0292307027,
-0.019132806,
0.0028730596,
-0.0236017164,
0.0645924211,
-0.0332688689,
-0.0110455574,
-0.0014820248,
-0.0101324823,
-0.0004294546,
-0.0266779345,
0.0316430591,
-0.018156806,
-0.0115684718,
0.0436688885,
0.0550060719,
0.0036103691,
-0.0122666461,
0.0239634588,
0.0133238109,
-0.0339558274,
-0.0425097831,
0.0690806061,
-0.0087199491,
-0.016685687,
0.0171072725,
-0.0144937336,
0.0021933331,
0.006935027,
-0.0109408619,
-0.0437082574,
0.0316925868,
0.0710308552,
-0.0148330964,
-0.004432973,
-0.041717574,
-0.0019501002,
0.0100241043,
-0.0220585279,
-0.0380924307,
-0.0311460923,
-0.0114442306,
0.0282204859,
-0.0288560893,
0.016526619,
2.270642285e-34,
0.0234599169,
-0.0122239906,
0.0025928544,
0.0227019396,
-0.0133406119,
-0.0240049809,
-0.0131484801,
0.027556587,
-0.0000294229,
-0.0667634606,
-0.0031166465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02317v1 | Soft Language Prompts for Language Transfer | 2024-07-02T14:50:03 | 2024-07-02T14:50:03 | Ivan Vykopal, Simon Ostermann, Marián Šimko | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual knowledge transfer, especially between high- and low-resource
languages, remains a challenge in natural language processing (NLP). This study
offers insights for improving cross-lingual NLP applications through the
combination of parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods. We systematically
explore strategies for enhancing this cross-lingual transfer through the
incorporation of language-specific and task-specific adapters and soft prompts.
We present a detailed investigation of various combinations of these methods,
exploring their efficiency across six languages, focusing on three low-resource
languages, including the to our knowledge first use of soft language prompts.
Our findings demonstrate that in contrast to claims of previous work, a
combination of language and task adapters does not always work best; instead,
combining a soft language prompt with a task adapter outperforms other
configurations in many cases. | [
0.0287631452,
-0.0421448871,
-0.0397074334,
0.0406603888,
-0.0293930229,
0.005975707,
0.0157796945,
-0.0353974104,
0.0174681041,
-0.0017840666,
-0.0551853068,
0.0198470652,
0.0208668411,
0.0023075647,
0.0129808094,
-0.0531151146,
0.0749453232,
-0.0604545176,
0.015479506,
-0.0102701914,
0.0034897903,
0.0186037645,
-0.007218061,
0.0312730372,
0.0178609602,
-0.0251162685,
0.0146711757,
-0.0044945492,
0.0081093255,
-0.0128751881,
-0.0010527603,
0.0375614725,
-0.0097405408,
-0.0154767754,
0.0000019855,
-0.0735163391,
-0.0563208982,
-0.0137993963,
-0.0348965079,
-0.0099244555,
0.0170257427,
-0.0448635668,
-0.0099988682,
-0.0172545556,
-0.0185306109,
-0.0185247511,
0.0578504056,
0.0350617319,
0.0368808284,
0.0482609347,
-0.0176775195,
0.0300304759,
-0.0310030729,
0.0029864719,
0.0164151173,
-0.0546731167,
-0.0159826092,
-0.0231810547,
0.0316828527,
0.0186769981,
-0.0121050868,
0.0484337956,
-0.0266932007,
-0.0122179715,
-0.0145770386,
0.0053507653,
-0.0299897026,
-0.033621937,
-0.0734493881,
0.0528274961,
-0.0401096493,
0.0060146083,
-0.024408577,
-0.020492861,
0.0275291763,
0.0381639041,
-0.0503756069,
0.0079709692,
0.0058037397,
-0.004744506,
0.0589729324,
0.0112026008,
-0.0184114203,
-0.0005071074,
-0.0048407437,
0.0831328258,
0.0252637733,
0.0060591381,
0.0662618205,
0.034160044,
0.0248870309,
-0.0438012667,
0.0372210629,
0.0281291995,
-0.0435387865,
-0.0047959844,
-0.0385344401,
-0.0343306065,
0.0197070353,
-0.0090863444,
0.049916219,
0.0299015623,
-0.0496434942,
0.0565543696,
-0.0915470496,
0.0197634287,
0.0274040401,
-0.0182934441,
0.0183061324,
-0.0559746251,
-0.0398786105,
0.0061420016,
-0.0605859235,
-0.0050128321,
-0.0362874232,
0.0237068664,
0.0056759999,
0.0173246935,
-0.0203980803,
-0.0001006396,
0.0041595707,
-0.0374852344,
-0.0445810482,
0.0017255339,
-0.0584389456,
0.0778974965,
-0.0728026852,
0.0029889967,
0.0028465057,
-0.0665579364,
-0.0115563907,
-0.0014074319,
0.0369983017,
-0.0500850566,
-0.020783741,
0.0403242894,
-0.037832126,
-0.0010773584,
-0.028926095,
-0.0171785485,
-0.0255648438,
-0.0423165374,
-0.0045911884,
-0.0720235333,
0.0261925291,
0.0273514632,
0.0349128321,
-0.0171257723,
0.0021555449,
0.0115697486,
-0.0481032655,
0.088835232,
-0.0383702777,
-0.004208277,
-0.0066340589,
-0.0188103728,
-0.0249418374,
0.08744964,
-0.016985083,
0.0162922721,
0.0530311503,
-0.0203565806,
-0.0485576093,
0.0231965091,
-0.0129713099,
-0.0032000805,
0.0324501581,
-0.0093311155,
0.0441014655,
-0.0271933638,
0.0084575145,
0.0222630836,
0.0199367013,
0.0852395222,
0.0430457145,
0.0132055422,
0.0257034935,
0.014363708,
0.032053981,
-0.0111675402,
-0.03467023,
0.0207438171,
-0.0415559299,
0.0400297679,
-0.0001957339,
-0.0056622843,
0.0126424134,
0.0683775321,
-0.0116199525,
0.0031791911,
0.0329064094,
-0.0152256731,
0.0439121462,
0.005040531,
0.0278999731,
0.0501864441,
-0.0160421282,
0.0381790102,
0.050293386,
-0.0259713233,
0.0442421399,
-0.0129597085,
0.0140000563,
0.0476302616,
-0.0228520986,
-0.0101423217,
-0.0203504097,
-0.0152446702,
0.0237553585,
0.022598993,
0.10713882,
-0.0047722855,
0.0095630661,
-0.0327762961,
-0.0158265438,
-0.0035043757,
-0.0038872983,
0.0229238998,
-0.0302901454,
0.0804132745,
0.015708413,
-0.0069738659,
-0.0348376222,
-0.0050218469,
0.0034311642,
-0.0355683491,
0.0474747643,
0.0329851359,
-0.0193655211,
0.0259135272,
0.0362535603,
-0.0166908633,
0.0036983779,
-0.0276314635,
0.0168339945,
0.0190345757,
-0.0442168303,
-0.0375089198,
-0.0183044877,
-0.0203710292,
-0.0141854957,
-0.0261621792,
-0.0035157576,
-0.0496851169,
-0.0266828872,
0.0202681869,
-0.0013806324,
-0.0236729309,
0.0333002955,
-0.0072373259,
0.0629135072,
-0.0272655692,
0.0249685515,
0.1022276431,
0.025294356,
0.0521985069,
-0.0423409194,
0.0099064587,
-0.0124234492,
-0.0186204463,
0.0476565063,
-0.0247315709,
-0.0219704397,
0.0412523821,
0.0356331281,
-0.0535118096,
0.000407767,
-0.0841263086,
0.0096161244,
-0.021668911,
0.019004507,
0.0056957048,
0.045123715,
-0.0066104452,
-0.0014458228,
-0.040056251,
0.0507171974,
0.0228242632,
0.050595101,
0.0249742232,
0.0151981153,
0.0309120473,
-0.0126636857,
0.0189849809,
0.0151824504,
0.0127964448,
0.0186858494,
-0.0812755674,
-0.0670666769,
0.0234182402,
-0.0112882219,
-0.0158994645,
0.0254754983,
-0.0163988937,
-0.0045336215,
0.0061078947,
0.0821450055,
0.0534669012,
-0.0193682276,
-0.0430453718,
0.0426606722,
-0.0804874003,
-0.0515112169,
0.0132005205,
-0.0099765323,
-0.0504755341,
-0.0115585672,
-0.0144506563,
0.0329353996,
0.0260499604,
-0.0107697556,
-0.0201222021,
-0.046434775,
0.0156890061,
-0.037651021,
-0.0240016561,
-0.0006993691,
0.0172462519,
0.0076208622,
0.0505765043,
0.0086459639,
0.0073414231,
0.0588653199,
-0.0391225703,
-0.0094837118,
-0.0687484145,
-0.0168518703,
-0.0197820552,
0.0223069824,
-0.0465509295,
0.029685501,
0.0472994782,
-0.0590474457,
-0.0295881703,
0.0103018405,
0.0413449965,
0.0092768762,
0.0483454317,
-0.0300978925,
-0.0097734844,
-0.0384467617,
-0.0286872815,
-0.0125686601,
-0.0167522673,
-0.0061702915,
0.0385176688,
0.0170561299,
-0.0060886838,
0.0004623063,
0.0195396543,
0.0546628647,
0.0201947782,
-0.0248775333,
-0.0154637555,
-0.0223063994,
0.0134148905,
0.0489370637,
0.0493484065,
0.0084997974,
-0.0063260817,
0.0311848763,
-0.0101631582,
0.026129175,
-0.0175955035,
0.0363543667,
0.0104867723,
0.0635526404,
-0.047360763,
-0.0485485196,
0.0341877714,
0.1199509725,
-0.06691809,
-0.0138209155,
0.1050348282,
0.0002608658,
-0.0586313903,
-0.0067325402,
-0.0513419397,
0.0075100246,
0.0188065525,
0.0429145172,
-0.0638450012,
-0.0600012392,
0.0068944655,
-0.0021517228,
0.0111300498,
-0.0441472419,
-0.0109281493,
-0.126990959,
0.0032658482,
-0.0065170275,
-0.0521481931,
-0.031656675,
-0.0385566652,
0.0317306593,
0.0289543942,
0.0178104881,
-0.0542205796,
-0.0344895869,
-0.0036837698,
0.0065306178,
0.0178744905,
-0.021564573,
0.022109041,
-0.0601106472,
0.0565708466,
0.0464576408,
0.0262323804,
-0.0186041407,
0.0135041932,
0.0082770102,
-0.0390943848,
0.0315058269,
-0.0189318955,
-0.0222176425,
0.0240873992,
-0.0191748422,
0.0242054332,
-0.0126111228,
-0.0189482756,
-0.0049415128,
0.0586175025,
0.1097595319,
0.0279673915,
-0.021870032,
0.0485538095,
-0.0017439239,
0.0515173487,
0.0682876259,
0.0174987894,
-0.0308828484,
0.0099448208,
-0.0012732033,
-0.0089157475,
-0.0185349341,
-0.040181905,
0.0191368833,
-0.0759743229,
-0.0270656291,
-0.0846734121,
-0.0565010384,
0.087455444,
0.0555314496,
0.0694361329,
0.0366272442,
0.003999061,
0.0104797231,
-0.0071581202,
0.033346504,
-0.0308660902,
0.0324519165,
-0.0426974744,
-0.0319320709,
-0.0061767874,
-0.0279309265,
0.0094922073,
0.0159050338,
0.0071971403,
-0.0637519807,
-0.0213975497,
0.0299015027,
0.0095122987,
0.0315654948,
-0.0244963337,
-0.0452268422,
0.0141507285,
0.0570275784,
-0.0348408967,
-0.0277658869,
0.0243084002,
-0.0063625337,
-0.0092386389,
0.0421755761,
-0.0390486382,
-0.0355407111,
0.0016539464,
0.0430963226,
0.0205722656,
-0.0981545001,
0.0089713987,
0.0282306653,
0.0270555671,
-0.0102571864,
-0.0207342561,
-0.0246918239,
0.0009244931,
0.0020868375,
-0.0223217737,
-0.0156193748,
-0.0273793042,
-0.0122033367,
0.0151859755,
0.0387219526,
0.0239298064,
0.0023397873,
0.0238261409,
-0.0607874095,
0.0369605087,
0.0339540169,
0.042232804,
0.020034723,
0.0408950113,
-0.0315093063,
0.0079234298,
0.0492507666,
0.0493508875,
-0.0694170818,
0.0556584224,
0.0127542084,
0.0008174373,
0.0028546932,
0.0211784169,
-0.0140052363,
-0.0473196208,
0.0272791516,
-0.0016369871,
0.053323064,
-0.0653707683,
0.0779733509,
-0.0102571482,
-0.0093160886,
-0.0047967471,
0.0276855975,
0.0128093613,
-0.0220898241,
-0.0152840121,
0.0074509913,
0.0095933173,
-0.012400303,
0.047282476,
-0.0984201878,
0.0019459323,
-0.0046475558,
-0.0101141818,
-0.0043246788,
0.0137252295,
0.0174076147,
-0.0239515081,
-0.0230175462,
0.0079443026,
-0.0170451887,
-0.0556288883,
0.0047221328,
-0.0663821474,
-0.0031901652,
0.0100300387,
0.0181371868,
0.0825266987,
0.0195376333,
-0.0245769303,
-0.0381882228,
0.0157170817,
-0.0002343259,
0.0042639691,
-0.0293162428,
-6.175043006e-33,
-0.0570363328,
-0.0007832794,
-0.0111835878,
0.0076373913,
0.0085082417,
0.0177133493,
-0.0331264846,
-0.0197315384,
-0.0208389703,
0.0134309568,
-0.0410766825,
-0.0508616976,
0.0455559231,
-0.0034915982,
0.0054486431,
-0.0099816537,
0.0373925641,
0.0485297665,
-0.0464495309,
0.0288736448,
0.0444899425,
0.023955768,
0.0737505481,
-0.0397511683,
0.066550836,
0.0585949644,
0.0239756424,
-0.0050574751,
0.0500289053,
0.0181497652,
0.0274898317,
0.0470596999,
0.0177925024,
-0.0613479912,
-0.035165932,
0.0788817853,
-0.1049328074,
-0.0632910952,
0.057005465,
0.0243433006,
0.0127407499,
-0.0426744781,
-0.0155654019,
-0.0538677871,
0.0447112359,
0.0427254215,
0.0355009958,
-0.0283434987,
0.0160487555,
-0.0144051556,
-0.1175224483,
-0.0145205501,
-0.0069596665,
0.0095326295,
0.0358511768,
0.0565782003,
-0.0132977767,
-0.0473894142,
-0.0340144709,
0.0457969084,
-0.012191765,
0.0473938398,
0.0668805838,
-0.0073993052,
-0.0484092757,
0.0115595032,
-0.001842837,
0.0318954438,
0.0373898782,
0.017245397,
0.0291968174,
0.0113839433,
0.0183775946,
0.0354026519,
0.0042673494,
-0.0163648073,
-0.007657622,
0.020388132,
0.0493983924,
0.0058923392,
0.0035246587,
-0.0004683416,
-0.0005795501,
-0.025791822,
-0.0392286181,
0.0175420139,
-0.0235361345,
-0.0496842749,
0.0251093972,
-0.0405361578,
-0.0277804937,
0.0300761238,
0.0592658706,
0.0120151257,
-0.0138497241,
-0.0290707145,
0.009336926,
-0.0159323029,
-0.0142960334,
0.0076913452,
-0.0601516888,
-0.0374601483,
-0.0016577751,
-0.0227534603,
0.0430473797,
0.0247871857,
0.0097067636,
0.0390615873,
-0.082117267,
-0.0034477792,
-0.032374043,
0.0395196415,
-0.0133112958,
0.0259705875,
0.0123248482,
-0.0179543328,
-0.0408229083,
0.0425861254,
0.0456350185,
-0.0627552196,
-0.0162370652,
-0.0240675043,
-0.005889806,
0.0139290411,
-0.0454615988,
0.0030925456,
-0.0399307422,
0.0040942864,
0.0013726738,
-0.0051419777,
-0.0283512957,
-0.0129409768,
2.762e-7,
-0.0028192587,
0.0299854148,
-0.0354522914,
0.0205384959,
-0.0308990087,
0.0177209545,
0.0056268838,
0.0310363211,
0.0046194955,
0.0139183337,
-0.0356469378,
0.0054220241,
0.0181890801,
0.0452861711,
-0.1158645004,
-0.0343519486,
0.0336216055,
0.0287807435,
-0.0528767519,
0.0047575533,
0.0447738767,
0.0317434371,
-0.0300976466,
0.0080264183,
-0.0262466297,
-0.0709409267,
-0.0014686829,
-0.0421910845,
-0.013609929,
0.0098066814,
0.030775398,
-0.0148217399,
-0.0246246923,
0.0701112971,
-0.0360224172,
0.0044091013,
0.0198686551,
0.0206537247,
0.0187788345,
-0.0288020857,
-0.0041258689,
-0.020863615,
0.0056226496,
-0.040491838,
0.0734042004,
-0.0499526449,
-0.0146353859,
0.0000868308,
-0.0051543978,
-0.0120581063,
-0.0143914465,
-0.0384665877,
-0.0412976854,
0.0317181088,
0.0251822192,
0.0480861478,
-0.0757989511,
-0.0236004554,
0.0101321694,
0.023678109,
0.0306469817,
-0.0584045388,
-0.0290084127,
-0.037372373,
-0.0145399487,
-0.0492524467,
0.035076011,
2.355017066e-34,
-0.0276754536,
0.0206641499,
0.0317972936,
0.0107042817,
0.0529238917,
-0.0147903347,
-0.0353661552,
0.0282797124,
0.0159038473,
-0.0511605665,
-0.0426894762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02310v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02310v1 | Evaluating the Ability of LLMs to Solve Semantics-Aware Process Mining Tasks | 2024-07-02T14:44:49 | 2024-07-02T14:44:49 | Adrian Rebmann, Fabian David Schmidt, Goran Glavaš, Han van der Aa | cs.CL | cs.CL | The process mining community has recently recognized the potential of large
language models (LLMs) for tackling various process mining tasks. Initial
studies report the capability of LLMs to support process analysis and even, to
some extent, that they are able to reason about how processes work. This latter
property suggests that LLMs could also be used to tackle process mining tasks
that benefit from an understanding of process behavior. Examples of such tasks
include (semantic) anomaly detection and next activity prediction, which both
involve considerations of the meaning of activities and their inter-relations.
In this paper, we investigate the capabilities of LLMs to tackle such
semantics-aware process mining tasks. Furthermore, whereas most works on the
intersection of LLMs and process mining only focus on testing these models out
of the box, we provide a more principled investigation of the utility of LLMs
for process mining, including their ability to obtain process mining knowledge
post-hoc by means of in-context learning and supervised fine-tuning.
Concretely, we define three process mining tasks that benefit from an
understanding of process semantics and provide extensive benchmarking datasets
for each of them. Our evaluation experiments reveal that (1) LLMs fail to solve
challenging process mining tasks out of the box and when provided only a
handful of in-context examples, (2) but they yield strong performance when
fine-tuned for these tasks, consistently surpassing smaller, encoder-based
language models. | [
0.009474935,
0.0293672774,
-0.0295822211,
0.0543893278,
-0.0315968692,
-0.0108434195,
-0.0230436213,
-0.0095320679,
-0.0374257714,
-0.0210074689,
0.0054631773,
-0.0009460917,
-0.0104477443,
0.0514391772,
-0.0273789801,
0.0138340341,
0.0445477031,
-0.0286970325,
0.0489469878,
0.0625069067,
-0.0383315571,
0.0329724588,
-0.0025026922,
0.0699472651,
0.0021683257,
-0.00349312,
-0.0124249775,
0.0049526002,
0.0448137708,
-0.054624673,
0.0043491446,
-0.0153297745,
0.0405595563,
0.0294464398,
0.0000021382,
-0.0636414662,
0.0156383682,
-0.0090331361,
-0.0070142178,
0.0176139791,
0.0005031389,
-0.025493525,
-0.0089951418,
0.0418766774,
-0.0088846255,
-0.0260885153,
0.0048802318,
0.0284929685,
0.0332941264,
0.0608180873,
-0.0256792158,
0.0128377527,
0.0006269346,
-0.0359259583,
-0.0079137525,
-0.0597179756,
0.0391916446,
-0.0395020805,
0.0163435526,
0.007954889,
0.0318482108,
-0.0428070053,
-0.0240037143,
-0.0003145368,
-0.0593777746,
0.0433115885,
0.0576716587,
0.0000436832,
0.0126325693,
0.0325119905,
-0.0559235811,
0.0142908515,
0.0282187499,
-0.0325850621,
-0.0154190678,
-0.0379953869,
-0.04109025,
0.0308538061,
-0.0069859023,
0.0338031985,
0.0416670442,
0.0199579205,
0.0291596949,
-0.0124655031,
-0.0124267675,
0.077159293,
-0.0059870314,
0.0035380623,
-0.0098376535,
0.003382931,
0.0289569777,
-0.0140529722,
0.0002168649,
0.0601593778,
-0.0554444976,
0.0163894184,
0.0106410831,
0.0460294262,
0.0006724675,
-0.0349727385,
0.0242612101,
0.0197198149,
0.0296641253,
0.030169107,
0.0035636351,
0.0003516885,
0.0210112371,
0.0267928541,
-0.044779934,
-0.0224122647,
-0.0876647159,
0.0216507092,
-0.0208349489,
-0.0102286758,
-0.0281460248,
-0.017409835,
-0.008728751,
0.0809341595,
-0.0043222848,
0.0448179878,
0.0091302423,
-0.045851633,
-0.0092342133,
-0.0121876365,
-0.0533155575,
0.0204644073,
0.0053767548,
0.0559554026,
-0.0360929854,
0.0224860329,
-0.0280939974,
-0.0025704345,
-0.0030284829,
-0.0425880291,
-0.023633264,
0.0514741465,
0.0136771724,
-0.0224498603,
-0.0667127445,
-0.0363999344,
0.0502598286,
-0.0364592113,
-0.0432129465,
-0.0289781615,
0.0025686163,
-0.0014227745,
-0.0014466441,
0.0150095923,
0.0096319234,
-0.0011835361,
-0.0339080021,
0.052901011,
-0.0013225616,
0.0345397145,
-0.0024478198,
0.019164769,
0.0260435753,
0.0420472771,
0.0283786319,
0.0121606737,
0.0258079749,
-0.0160240177,
0.0178999789,
0.0314909443,
-0.0630945414,
-0.0072863479,
0.0438033231,
0.0092850719,
0.0003795352,
-0.0404229388,
0.0529403947,
-0.0194661506,
0.0259653963,
-0.0002960146,
0.0233654622,
0.0354392529,
-0.0559730753,
-0.002168823,
0.0518982261,
0.0277362559,
-0.0478599556,
-0.0206720755,
-0.0128338309,
-0.0095979329,
-0.010630209,
-0.0217647664,
-0.0574458912,
-0.0163359996,
-0.0532209724,
-0.0444630273,
-0.0142544666,
-0.0065474296,
0.0029594847,
-0.0207170807,
0.060657803,
-0.0015524345,
-0.0750663504,
0.0324229859,
-0.0031763795,
0.005486859,
0.0125274342,
-0.0715937093,
0.0282128844,
0.0908576548,
0.0647922978,
-0.0852470919,
0.0144886989,
-0.031443987,
-0.0103184171,
0.0016593108,
0.002382844,
-0.0324817374,
0.0267104916,
-0.0147139365,
-0.0374980308,
-0.0303507838,
0.0170126744,
-0.0390354283,
-0.0367509723,
0.0024346383,
0.0039930749,
-0.0215383135,
-0.0487517118,
0.06337782,
0.0014040348,
-0.0114577301,
0.0640038699,
0.0058692475,
0.0163006056,
-0.0125424201,
0.0186140966,
0.0148985386,
0.073584795,
-0.064525269,
-0.0190101527,
0.0356867984,
0.0151430229,
-0.0085062291,
0.0070114466,
0.0187192541,
0.0085891094,
-0.0098232543,
-0.0747897997,
-0.0422143415,
0.0223482847,
-0.0396500789,
0.0246901736,
-0.0015981547,
0.0218894705,
0.006470073,
-0.0153987892,
-0.0387862027,
0.0440299585,
-0.0262828618,
-0.0074180919,
-0.0059921863,
0.0153010273,
0.0343081094,
0.0068405457,
-0.0133272232,
0.0130600026,
-0.0263344068,
0.007118592,
0.0446316004,
-0.0231926534,
0.0097201159,
-0.0194585323,
-0.0488049388,
0.0226503983,
-0.0251981374,
0.0285646524,
0.0277326424,
0.0010575381,
-0.0103941951,
-0.0253499001,
0.0292057395,
0.0248358268,
-0.0000026737,
0.0157210473,
0.0537766218,
0.0508482605,
-0.0542813614,
-0.0267740712,
0.0062272921,
-0.0265489183,
0.0470806994,
-0.0092764571,
0.0179575756,
-0.0934112072,
0.0601283014,
0.0152607029,
-0.0076207295,
-0.0523926578,
0.0010703944,
0.0211723689,
0.0005847602,
0.0102169728,
0.0218062252,
-0.0138537018,
0.0557594262,
0.0494347252,
-0.0084708259,
-0.0033609858,
0.0067579104,
-0.0682197735,
-0.036196325,
-0.0475445166,
-0.0455132425,
0.021180924,
0.0786320195,
0.0065537421,
0.0180913694,
-0.008727802,
-0.0127888415,
0.0016385368,
0.0204672907,
-0.0277345274,
-0.0589013174,
0.0191006009,
0.0584392883,
-0.0186679289,
-0.0204656664,
0.0595598035,
-0.0100198621,
0.0088674566,
-0.0438728891,
-0.065139994,
-0.0097540542,
0.0808921531,
-0.0102664195,
-0.0010626507,
-0.0406949632,
-0.0055767694,
-0.015712779,
-0.0129132429,
0.0217460133,
-0.0028518226,
0.0153693864,
-0.0745579451,
0.0286547244,
0.020859018,
-0.0172631498,
-0.0423257463,
-0.0264371745,
-0.0108112469,
0.0405219868,
-0.0664436221,
0.0198970698,
-0.018228095,
0.0434035994,
-0.0449110717,
0.0341255888,
0.0662727058,
-0.0453289635,
-0.0405275337,
-0.0048322133,
0.0361843407,
-0.0522259139,
-0.0240050014,
-0.0162164103,
0.023008069,
0.0102093471,
-0.0175938848,
-0.0463731065,
-0.0112161068,
-0.0216910541,
-0.0251568295,
-0.0187871009,
0.0200218745,
0.0376380384,
0.0394089334,
-0.0692424625,
-0.0365024842,
0.1052246988,
0.041091606,
-0.0278167464,
0.0405561067,
0.0217626337,
-0.0360106677,
0.0478715673,
-0.0140733104,
-0.0002691822,
-0.0013003639,
-0.0032090789,
0.0009731393,
-0.0078838672,
-0.0331397578,
0.0050968854,
-0.0932923332,
0.0562192947,
-0.0093818158,
0.0065250238,
-0.0543164834,
-0.1111880541,
0.0105362199,
-0.0518684946,
-0.0123146363,
-0.0320409536,
0.0079560429,
-0.0423069708,
0.007702847,
-0.0442957804,
-0.0784304738,
0.0383173525,
-0.0052524125,
-0.0342198946,
0.0441268198,
0.0018267045,
-0.0012163232,
-0.0240423065,
0.0566652603,
-0.0443874113,
0.0143804522,
0.0028134775,
0.0110981893,
0.0236341748,
-0.0072315861,
0.009653938,
0.0282564498,
-0.1003993526,
-0.053884808,
0.0333594941,
0.118127428,
-0.0564476214,
-0.0352423526,
0.0032998032,
-0.0382713936,
0.0539760254,
0.0836066827,
-0.0297484156,
-0.020941915,
-0.0057752202,
-0.0114258248,
0.0058831321,
0.0571848564,
-0.0114809331,
-0.0059617735,
0.0157651231,
-0.0293503087,
-0.0146264881,
-0.0430438481,
0.0157953966,
0.0052683717,
-0.0248751529,
0.0189761929,
0.0386832431,
0.0103829168,
-0.0878502727,
0.0002068659,
-0.015816275,
0.0616902113,
0.0249642171,
0.0012943378,
0.0316209719,
0.0846651644,
-0.033588402,
0.0209785514,
-0.1221616939,
-0.0144221308,
-0.0701884329,
0.0318712741,
0.0088416599,
0.0375879146,
-0.048054006,
0.0100436918,
-0.016937755,
-0.0318773314,
-0.0383452885,
-0.033791583,
0.0127601791,
-0.0078492817,
-0.0134418532,
0.0115463901,
-0.0296567529,
0.0298846792,
0.0012930629,
0.0157844368,
-0.073946692,
-0.1039085537,
0.006573257,
-0.0343123078,
0.0339485444,
0.0146654621,
-0.0237228777,
-0.0555568263,
0.0131358979,
-0.016756244,
-0.0026535729,
-0.0271365158,
0.0137735065,
0.0280028656,
-0.0208600461,
-0.0062861829,
-0.0024100014,
-0.0454051308,
0.0104488712,
-0.0188491493,
0.0292026401,
-0.0096249226,
0.0509823635,
0.0249646157,
0.0142110605,
0.003828425,
-0.0144677088,
0.0190878361,
0.0558222234,
0.0045296107,
0.0601940975,
0.0166367572,
0.0498839505,
0.0015488445,
0.0110726804,
-0.0383225493,
0.0090540759,
0.0117302509,
-0.0070539908,
0.053305354,
-0.0452472605,
0.0192864314,
-0.0413161032,
0.0353999771,
-0.0298250429,
0.0486877635,
0.0081857145,
-0.0177779254,
0.0150498971,
0.0268743038,
-0.0572643466,
-0.0051666484,
0.0848012492,
-0.0398954637,
0.0504710525,
-0.0020486305,
-0.05570665,
-0.0604421012,
-0.0534238927,
0.0053500007,
0.0723220631,
-0.0110264989,
0.0396729037,
-0.0658767596,
-0.0394810922,
-0.0307303462,
-0.0374827534,
-0.0061662253,
-0.012673256,
-0.0115107913,
0.074633114,
0.0117699886,
0.0161037203,
-0.020767672,
-0.07038562,
0.0063972292,
-0.0076840809,
-0.0548612848,
-5.388360677e-33,
-0.0189791396,
-0.048782818,
0.0200996082,
0.0485733002,
0.0093633998,
-0.0125478674,
-0.0661350265,
-0.0344161242,
0.019274123,
0.0240375008,
0.0178738367,
0.006075738,
0.0065444023,
-0.0204931907,
0.0151550462,
0.0146683352,
0.0867310464,
-0.0001805057,
-0.0141486023,
0.0147725064,
0.0654338375,
-0.0212892257,
0.0379613005,
-0.0732328445,
0.0085077435,
-0.0058092917,
-0.0185752772,
0.0583272278,
0.0263458993,
0.0401490033,
-0.0053514261,
0.0853683352,
0.0542952381,
-0.0057729436,
-0.0241863206,
-0.0467654988,
-0.0172252916,
-0.0287059266,
0.0012566603,
-0.0170845687,
0.0161704123,
-0.0189945046,
0.0109792547,
0.0071112132,
-0.0077688522,
0.0263328571,
0.0422971919,
-0.0294656213,
0.0018763226,
0.0147886453,
-0.0590256788,
0.0022009655,
-0.0449911617,
-0.0104830032,
0.0196079202,
-0.0425544791,
0.0483740233,
-0.0344263092,
-0.0861702338,
0.0261399224,
-0.0514304712,
0.0282484386,
0.0570784472,
0.0280976854,
0.0119160162,
0.0159773566,
-0.0465619341,
0.0695362389,
0.0346819386,
0.0536448359,
-0.0014948888,
0.0954477564,
-0.0011372339,
-0.0261703283,
-0.0321830139,
-0.0116335964,
-0.0873104557,
0.0625200123,
0.0120604299,
0.0510931276,
0.0754095018,
0.0134298448,
-0.015192722,
-0.0246651825,
-0.01376459,
0.0229536351,
0.0043093823,
0.0271525774,
0.0085593509,
0.0518351197,
0.0102230581,
0.0022715328,
0.0253056344,
-0.039197389,
-0.0113585358,
0.0366751514,
-0.0578695573,
-0.0230504796,
0.0016517452,
0.0017728593,
-0.0468005128,
-0.0731426477,
0.0186691955,
-0.0000870637,
0.0351969451,
-0.0213189479,
-0.0073211705,
0.0152270403,
-0.03567807,
0.0075425147,
-0.0631442517,
0.0544628426,
-0.0478492752,
0.0159611981,
-0.0125698317,
0.0227427948,
-0.0237888694,
0.0497090779,
-0.0216780007,
-0.0152727673,
0.0410271809,
0.0510622822,
-0.021952102,
0.0040571662,
-0.0028162396,
-0.0246342886,
-0.0156574566,
0.0049940804,
0.0805417076,
-0.0031483625,
-0.0113747967,
-0.0206024721,
2.589e-7,
0.0260944255,
-0.0009065507,
-0.0011182799,
0.069021605,
0.061620798,
0.0453930274,
-0.0368501991,
0.0072899894,
-0.0144698517,
-0.0507196821,
0.0560536198,
0.0053306022,
0.016432846,
0.0347998552,
-0.0187439416,
-0.0124585005,
-0.0265210401,
-0.0228659585,
-0.1031055972,
0.0095852446,
0.0518895723,
0.0841329098,
0.0337883681,
-0.0140176192,
0.0100988913,
-0.0593726709,
0.0363648385,
-0.0289772283,
-0.0091494443,
0.05840455,
-0.0133033171,
0.0141173052,
0.026165938,
0.0231339708,
-0.0438179299,
0.0490888394,
-0.0247420501,
0.0902527347,
-0.0204564184,
-0.006274316,
-0.004625977,
-0.0250337031,
0.0210340638,
-0.0166502967,
0.0425024591,
-0.0561103895,
-0.0296705421,
0.0044359514,
0.0165434908,
0.0127559965,
-0.0099125095,
0.0270026214,
-0.0204075798,
0.036096517,
-0.0104381302,
-0.0091559682,
0.0236922037,
-0.0546498224,
0.0037957234,
0.0016100571,
-0.0313257463,
-0.0350325555,
0.0054592923,
-0.0127058579,
0.0409995615,
0.0040259878,
0.0523745976,
2.399688606e-34,
0.0312500671,
0.0130553013,
-0.0216812864,
0.0036010777,
0.0243310276,
0.0161389019,
-0.040144518,
0.0307848267,
0.0223417915,
-0.0541538931,
0.0288276765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02302v1 | Towards Human Understanding of Paraphrase Types in ChatGPT | 2024-07-02T14:35:10 | 2024-07-02T14:35:10 | Dominik Meier, Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Bela Gipp | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Paraphrases represent a human's intuitive ability to understand expressions
presented in various different ways. Current paraphrase evaluations of language
models primarily use binary approaches, offering limited interpretability of
specific text changes. Atomic paraphrase types (APT) decompose paraphrases into
different linguistic changes and offer a granular view of the flexibility in
linguistic expression (e.g., a shift in syntax or vocabulary used). In this
study, we assess the human preferences towards ChatGPT in generating English
paraphrases with ten APTs and five prompting techniques. We introduce APTY
(Atomic Paraphrase TYpes), a dataset of 500 sentence-level and word-level
annotations by 15 annotators. The dataset also provides a human preference
ranking of paraphrases with different types that can be used to fine-tune
models with RLHF and DPO methods. Our results reveal that ChatGPT can generate
simple APTs, such as additions and deletions, but struggle with complex
structures (e.g., subordination changes). This study contributes to
understanding which aspects of paraphrasing language models have already
succeeded at understanding and what remains elusive. In addition, our curated
datasets can be used to develop language models with specific linguistic
capabilities. | [
0.1040409431,
0.0340980329,
-0.0295291878,
0.0299925264,
-0.0681817234,
0.0047472529,
-0.0275105499,
0.0231127962,
-0.0077399765,
-0.0693191662,
-0.0151125351,
0.0280231666,
0.0085145598,
-0.0266337153,
0.0197840314,
-0.0954611227,
0.0285774376,
-0.0252848212,
0.0050872453,
0.0064669475,
0.0215554275,
0.0387395956,
0.0072721741,
0.0775209069,
0.0554749183,
-0.0146299219,
-0.0007045221,
0.0266483296,
0.0320908427,
0.0017539222,
0.0103161829,
0.0183440689,
0.0368179306,
0.0210593082,
0.0000018147,
-0.0378233418,
0.0007175612,
-0.0131238354,
-0.0036411507,
0.0407499894,
0.1059412807,
0.0052825599,
-0.0009948248,
-0.003021735,
-0.038330473,
0.0010895684,
0.0293346997,
-0.0005129868,
0.0985780805,
0.0363448747,
-0.0120665701,
-0.0322367474,
-0.0345320813,
-0.003110117,
0.0146165052,
-0.022299476,
0.0138524184,
0.0144550465,
0.0123871295,
0.0519472733,
0.0079413634,
0.0320604444,
-0.0211860705,
0.0364412516,
-0.0074795121,
0.009101605,
-0.0619586334,
-0.0215224009,
-0.0067678667,
0.0797803327,
0.0044680745,
-0.0404715799,
0.001019498,
-0.0068950593,
0.0157187656,
0.0560431033,
-0.0797405094,
0.0105016259,
-0.0012929406,
0.0184908696,
0.002682182,
0.0130971204,
-0.028777618,
0.0550694801,
0.0257468857,
0.0267826281,
0.0296198707,
0.0069902553,
-0.0373602286,
-0.0100167673,
-0.0726979822,
-0.0286591128,
0.0047955755,
-0.0261596385,
0.0187674556,
0.0363047644,
-0.0632820576,
-0.0367137119,
0.0730077848,
-0.0728577599,
0.0456347726,
0.017241329,
-0.0048402911,
0.0443325602,
-0.0123003004,
0.0516086742,
-0.0174102355,
0.0532907061,
-0.0507169813,
0.0009950307,
-0.0801537335,
-0.0033177021,
-0.0539773069,
0.0383209325,
-0.0165597275,
-0.0287058819,
-0.0570713058,
0.0083994679,
0.0239848346,
-0.0189765375,
0.0112723345,
0.0369895622,
-0.0544666946,
0.0131363412,
-0.0245954935,
0.0073715225,
-0.0522003807,
0.0372377932,
-0.0146735916,
-0.0767457411,
-0.0252341349,
0.018000681,
0.0218809322,
-0.0501325093,
-0.0133177629,
0.0368184596,
-0.0072239288,
-0.0113607673,
-0.0090004709,
-0.0371998958,
-0.0324898213,
-0.0398102328,
-0.0103381164,
-0.0643569008,
0.029912686,
0.0090177199,
-0.0051217168,
-0.025257811,
0.0185359754,
0.0337535031,
-0.054539483,
0.0398686007,
-0.0167545192,
-0.0188221261,
-0.0275660716,
-0.0146199754,
-0.0604755059,
0.0155892987,
0.0310681202,
0.0272353962,
0.0588483922,
0.0122995861,
-0.0292723998,
-0.0114866775,
-0.0067200321,
0.0128649343,
-0.030907508,
0.0243441127,
-0.0192871522,
0.0102511328,
0.006482766,
0.0610258058,
-0.0426700935,
-0.0233839061,
0.0739175752,
0.0520355739,
0.0015642493,
0.0570796467,
0.0472886302,
0.0697808862,
0.0316089354,
0.0237703938,
-0.0111363251,
-0.0043773344,
-0.0062417393,
0.0396475196,
-0.0258875415,
0.0434878096,
0.0008038877,
-0.038092725,
-0.0380463675,
0.0062999181,
0.0171339959,
-0.0363736786,
-0.0117629161,
0.0248147883,
-0.0306253992,
0.0642552897,
-0.0016372091,
-0.0736901164,
-0.0362476148,
-0.0699462965,
-0.0107073737,
0.1054935604,
0.0671418309,
-0.0310252458,
-0.0129574761,
-0.0002001303,
0.0105656125,
0.0200057365,
0.0386364236,
0.0048143002,
0.0307060815,
-0.0421637744,
0.0181391314,
-0.0304430649,
0.0232441649,
-0.0232126545,
0.0163350385,
-0.0350923315,
0.0094934339,
-0.0440622158,
-0.0586311184,
0.0332532674,
0.014419294,
-0.0032811135,
-0.0150058502,
-0.0207759328,
0.0031305605,
0.0172360558,
0.0177722499,
0.038428586,
0.0055245166,
-0.028401969,
-0.0198610686,
0.0944588706,
-0.0168554634,
-0.0570181869,
0.0137775876,
-0.0475634634,
-0.0145059973,
0.0165415891,
-0.0354533903,
-0.025397718,
0.0167853422,
-0.057548102,
0.0397281423,
-0.0653067529,
0.0121832443,
-0.0362005383,
0.0215031467,
-0.0431534573,
0.063374795,
0.0035572047,
-0.0032526636,
0.0147076491,
-0.0349946544,
0.0263625644,
0.003265941,
-0.0247187745,
-0.0009110706,
0.0146174887,
0.0081987316,
0.0253989138,
-0.0001079823,
-0.0806625336,
-0.0238421857,
-0.098801218,
-0.0060761576,
-0.0036955546,
-0.0059704902,
0.0584786944,
0.0090663787,
0.0092592249,
-0.009346284,
0.0157061256,
0.0010742117,
-0.0232629869,
0.0246298667,
0.0541968904,
0.0152498595,
-0.0200932622,
-0.0805055276,
0.0018390996,
-0.0195727795,
0.0457366519,
0.0100671882,
0.0194185898,
-0.0221038572,
0.022333147,
-0.0240753442,
-0.0327194668,
0.0125116007,
-0.059771128,
-0.0000819442,
-0.0203992408,
0.0252002403,
0.0484396294,
0.0326813832,
-0.0016878343,
0.0491793826,
0.0006971407,
-0.057181742,
-0.0316885635,
0.0075107138,
-0.0374858305,
0.0116287405,
-0.0621139444,
0.0054173945,
0.0413351022,
0.0350261964,
0.0015802749,
-0.0739739388,
0.0415120944,
-0.0089461431,
0.0021010635,
-0.0177007578,
-0.0146371154,
-0.0388263315,
0.0121841142,
-0.0296470299,
-0.0145339919,
0.0899363309,
-0.0235041678,
-0.0027056101,
-0.0788306668,
-0.0164041948,
-0.0442447923,
0.0421027429,
-0.0387691744,
0.0403326079,
-0.0049284198,
0.0026736765,
-0.0459760502,
-0.0344010852,
0.0568848662,
-0.0233622976,
0.046905119,
-0.0776259676,
0.0095403809,
0.0107002212,
-0.0257871337,
-0.0207021758,
-0.1048919037,
-0.036953859,
0.0075000408,
0.0190921407,
0.0014319355,
0.0032718175,
-0.0091910865,
0.0066273618,
0.0129771493,
-0.0231331475,
-0.0121499654,
-0.0396950841,
0.0217456315,
0.0779438093,
0.017712554,
-0.0059378329,
-0.0076539787,
0.0342494249,
0.0379921347,
0.0449733324,
0.0225951597,
-0.0477716587,
-0.0033098408,
-0.0027428307,
-0.0220211912,
-0.060027618,
-0.0221929904,
0.034664873,
-0.0147645306,
-0.0066627269,
0.0878876299,
0.0285350289,
-0.0177715365,
0.0207351465,
-0.0375038721,
0.0756126568,
0.0005850944,
0.0070990976,
-0.0709832311,
-0.0556240268,
0.001307553,
0.0030841341,
-0.0033101211,
-0.0227380116,
-0.0170930028,
-0.0604309216,
0.0214828029,
0.0024576942,
-0.0320964083,
0.0181935318,
0.0053962343,
-0.0039980281,
0.003773273,
-0.0193011109,
-0.0030299786,
-0.0639009997,
0.0514509566,
-0.0068634087,
-0.0265318267,
-0.0214464851,
0.0305111296,
-0.044477772,
0.0072238776,
0.0640715733,
0.0605372973,
0.0217542946,
0.0006554876,
0.0222939979,
-0.004326799,
0.0081954822,
0.0155509757,
0.0474619344,
-0.0030030252,
0.0294659585,
-0.016160313,
0.0280373227,
-0.0236338675,
-0.0258331671,
0.0154845957,
0.0285862535,
0.0070806076,
0.0101888478,
-0.0230642967,
0.0471247211,
-0.0179495774,
0.1052023843,
0.0539417379,
-0.0202915277,
-0.0366449542,
0.0062292158,
0.0384496301,
-0.0585339591,
-0.0239064954,
0.0199599545,
-0.0254659876,
0.0193534959,
-0.0837114751,
-0.0267480351,
-0.0097612599,
-0.0224692803,
0.0298475064,
0.0392077044,
-0.0028400936,
0.0207221191,
0.007351561,
0.0084190536,
-0.0131256804,
0.0214260127,
0.0112701524,
-0.0252958108,
0.0596365221,
-0.0056195632,
-0.0247554593,
0.0425017998,
-0.0849770457,
-0.0375611633,
0.0312088151,
0.0390648507,
0.0311074574,
0.005252548,
0.0075154803,
-0.0351954103,
-0.0115145734,
0.0169138405,
-0.0093759922,
0.0361547768,
0.0312812328,
0.0608370714,
-0.0078438744,
0.0582518093,
-0.0260856841,
-0.0009179536,
-0.00186552,
0.0656139553,
-0.0085446006,
-0.0513777286,
0.0499703884,
0.0129507584,
-0.008195919,
-0.0206963941,
0.0079842508,
0.0082386555,
0.0214097444,
-0.0046510356,
-0.0149309132,
-0.0486743562,
-0.0030428551,
0.0480390899,
-0.0089299101,
-0.02379811,
-0.0239855405,
-0.0506997965,
0.0348121822,
-0.0234962106,
-0.006500876,
0.010898741,
-0.0014489101,
-0.0260771774,
0.0003244755,
-0.0415194966,
0.0077921585,
-0.0663943961,
0.0094889803,
-0.0147379991,
0.0407677256,
0.0033934244,
-0.0692340881,
-0.0576232821,
0.0856923461,
-0.0819863304,
-0.0490687676,
0.0162082799,
0.0247314163,
0.0477153733,
-0.0062424624,
0.096445024,
-0.0145513983,
-0.0187221449,
0.0177149121,
0.070572637,
-0.0081874989,
0.0110505978,
0.0103813121,
0.0194041245,
-0.0085492125,
0.0204529129,
0.0726527125,
0.0254924018,
0.0071614212,
-0.0002410609,
-0.0298556704,
-0.0342297964,
-0.030119475,
-0.0159801506,
0.0463850163,
0.0183099508,
-0.0034061372,
-0.0804469213,
-0.0367121138,
0.00488482,
0.0124651175,
0.0247750729,
-0.042935919,
0.0603633076,
0.05872868,
-0.0149789751,
-0.053831473,
-0.0656446442,
0.0357242003,
-0.002632583,
0.0074303513,
-0.0945389494,
-6.007644896e-33,
-0.0232813396,
0.026695827,
-0.0434554182,
0.0012229462,
-0.0187089164,
-0.0216145515,
-0.0218727402,
-0.0206458122,
-0.0076006581,
0.0023790225,
-0.034298759,
0.0128953364,
0.0158062987,
0.0250008777,
0.0233920291,
-0.0314987451,
0.0625400692,
0.0032706384,
-0.0371244475,
-0.0117220553,
0.047191143,
-0.0036923601,
0.0269187894,
-0.0373824276,
0.0203322675,
-0.0283138808,
-0.0247476064,
-0.0176174324,
-0.0050097671,
0.0601431243,
0.0064709294,
0.042336151,
0.0124605931,
0.0007823916,
-0.0313963257,
0.0118879033,
-0.0669004619,
0.002528684,
0.0752321109,
-0.0130851287,
-0.0391077474,
-0.0629239827,
0.0200468879,
-0.0439439043,
-0.0040205293,
0.0322498567,
0.0537875742,
-0.0250969194,
0.0134968078,
0.0393752754,
-0.0314466469,
-0.0009581806,
-0.0258325431,
-0.0018026204,
-0.0145163462,
0.0808008835,
-0.0250894185,
0.0533884503,
-0.0635563061,
0.0535426773,
0.000009433,
0.0062957034,
0.0100112166,
-0.0138430735,
0.0277655628,
0.0488484874,
-0.0090569332,
-0.0061620753,
0.019626284,
0.010516894,
-0.000493419,
0.067237407,
0.0230982546,
0.046658054,
0.0345309973,
0.0306256413,
0.0044466718,
-0.0068582036,
0.0467346199,
0.0364881828,
0.0460423715,
0.0168299545,
-0.0295202378,
-0.0208584145,
-0.0475892462,
-0.025466647,
-0.0255087651,
-0.0598547198,
0.0231019966,
-0.0077772816,
-0.0540135503,
-0.0155957164,
0.0363594107,
-0.041972585,
-0.0067198048,
-0.0006809227,
-0.0565308444,
0.0410852879,
0.0163829736,
0.0377762914,
-0.0144213345,
-0.0163849331,
0.0310317688,
0.0320053622,
0.0388517082,
-0.0012428472,
0.0309450272,
0.0051842323,
-0.0323020965,
0.0147770951,
-0.0291059334,
-0.0525403693,
-0.0796249211,
-0.0658467039,
0.0067414674,
0.0589255914,
-0.0070325909,
0.0072761322,
0.0235245936,
-0.0053216438,
-0.0283217598,
0.0144289946,
0.0034015346,
0.0044266428,
0.0060067866,
0.0000375503,
-0.0282616057,
-0.0114224078,
0.0032674358,
-0.0376132503,
-0.0039670416,
-0.0060179606,
2.634e-7,
0.0305950306,
0.0587751642,
0.0164622553,
-0.0257831719,
0.0154008074,
0.0391186439,
0.0028402722,
0.0150510529,
0.0058611021,
0.0091380645,
0.0417138562,
0.0285587739,
0.0293435622,
-0.028052872,
-0.0959041044,
-0.0061842366,
-0.1033603325,
0.0101227844,
-0.0327963158,
-0.0352846496,
0.080548875,
0.0650448576,
0.0089716474,
0.0120835286,
-0.0354576148,
-0.0369878076,
0.0715662837,
-0.0553910024,
-0.0303867012,
0.0062987688,
0.0153147494,
0.0240167156,
-0.0010516964,
-0.0004168837,
0.0166460611,
-0.0153333759,
0.0499041043,
0.0578509122,
-0.0145359747,
-0.0306248982,
-0.0437913872,
-0.0381064638,
0.0202016477,
-0.0838863328,
0.0658406243,
-0.0589792766,
-0.005398083,
-0.0035448121,
-0.019532172,
0.03635481,
0.0129888784,
-0.0366597958,
-0.0638410151,
0.015928233,
0.0124251628,
0.0013501147,
-0.0426685885,
-0.0183982532,
-0.0372941196,
-0.0118964883,
-0.0327419713,
-0.0325867906,
-0.0335503668,
0.0262174569,
-0.0014906403,
-0.0599415787,
-0.0026708122,
2.115603075e-34,
0.0429524221,
0.0177745856,
0.035581965,
0.0294858888,
0.044541005,
-0.0020084635,
0.0297245644,
0.0408398323,
0.0205159318,
-0.0388942733,
-0.0193067435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02301v1 | CFinBench: A Comprehensive Chinese Financial Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T14:34:36 | 2024-07-02T14:34:36 | Ying Nie, Binwei Yan, Tianyu Guo, Hao Liu, Haoyu Wang, Wei He, Binfan Zheng, Weihao Wang, Qiang Li, Weijian Sun, Yunhe Wang, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance on various
NLP tasks, yet their potential in more challenging and domain-specific task,
such as finance, has not been fully explored. In this paper, we present
CFinBench: a meticulously crafted, the most comprehensive evaluation benchmark
to date, for assessing the financial knowledge of LLMs under Chinese context.
In practice, to better align with the career trajectory of Chinese financial
practitioners, we build a systematic evaluation from 4 first-level categories:
(1) Financial Subject: whether LLMs can memorize the necessary basic knowledge
of financial subjects, such as economics, statistics and auditing. (2)
Financial Qualification: whether LLMs can obtain the needed financial qualified
certifications, such as certified public accountant, securities qualification
and banking qualification. (3) Financial Practice: whether LLMs can fulfill the
practical financial jobs, such as tax consultant, junior accountant and
securities analyst. (4) Financial Law: whether LLMs can meet the requirement of
financial laws and regulations, such as tax law, insurance law and economic
law. CFinBench comprises 99,100 questions spanning 43 second-level categories
with 3 question types: single-choice, multiple-choice and judgment. We conduct
extensive experiments of 50 representative LLMs with various model size on
CFinBench. The results show that GPT4 and some Chinese-oriented models lead the
benchmark, with the highest average accuracy being 60.16%, highlighting the
challenge presented by CFinBench. The dataset and evaluation code are available
at https://cfinbench.github.io/. | [
0.0049450896,
0.0860559046,
-0.0124386372,
0.0064295284,
0.0063922596,
0.016812453,
0.0294176415,
0.0433872566,
0.0232007187,
-0.0109854974,
-0.0497909226,
-0.0503773019,
0.0063548204,
-0.0022226695,
0.0588468164,
-0.0433282107,
0.0207791049,
0.0040268274,
0.0268474892,
-0.0304185655,
0.0157734044,
-0.0179219488,
0.0020749925,
0.029208336,
0.0228399765,
-0.0431576185,
0.0201272294,
-0.0193296093,
0.0152370268,
-0.004059921,
0.0350521393,
0.0399074145,
-0.0134343216,
0.0255629122,
0.0000021058,
-0.0541218966,
-0.0433471277,
-0.0030316564,
-0.0141679505,
0.0198546462,
0.0217891242,
-0.0049282759,
0.0331229605,
0.027894605,
-0.0694326833,
0.0013557014,
0.0063328911,
0.0720006004,
0.069000043,
0.0711407438,
0.007215058,
-0.0650745481,
0.0030874955,
-0.0667517111,
-0.0361676216,
-0.0909159631,
0.0361530297,
0.0718981624,
-0.0362574607,
-0.0147701018,
-0.0668803528,
-0.0072364672,
0.0061144792,
0.0191152096,
0.0156053407,
0.0306977108,
-0.0425085686,
0.0261445399,
-0.0131027196,
0.0389850512,
0.0057170782,
0.034747798,
0.0043428605,
-0.0332722999,
0.0126996152,
0.0376947597,
-0.0419893414,
0.054877039,
-0.0239038989,
-0.0058561345,
0.0207943898,
-0.0166098196,
0.0236387514,
0.0118413102,
-0.0265938807,
0.0311783385,
-0.0147556923,
-0.0318779275,
0.0690222234,
-0.0097748358,
-0.0145367347,
-0.0447587483,
0.0145874415,
0.0195822101,
0.0094131958,
0.0234858505,
0.02435093,
0.007700162,
0.0170894656,
-0.0582516305,
0.0382945277,
0.0370188877,
-0.0060299099,
0.0406774469,
-0.0488228984,
0.0839248747,
0.0211134534,
-0.0265111104,
-0.0486934893,
0.000707139,
-0.084440954,
-0.01597091,
-0.0360550322,
0.0699470341,
-0.0267623123,
-0.0023599521,
-0.0838291124,
-0.0221467894,
-0.0378811993,
0.0300729331,
-0.0000213693,
-0.0347435251,
-0.0094367024,
0.0027176647,
-0.0717541352,
0.0181276221,
-0.0385506786,
-0.0013316699,
-0.0191927422,
0.0154682053,
0.0366992094,
0.0131468512,
-0.0438131653,
-0.0270597376,
0.022499688,
0.0652418211,
0.0392557383,
-0.0022580314,
-0.0417780913,
-0.03161164,
-0.0026971793,
-0.0449065976,
0.0004293582,
-0.0438441932,
-0.0242053811,
-0.0226352345,
0.0105318157,
-0.0282097384,
0.0177558586,
0.010489719,
0.016914485,
0.0395197198,
0.033338055,
-0.0262574516,
-0.0017219612,
-0.0036629441,
-0.0042914292,
0.0391655006,
0.0051323334,
0.0154404603,
0.0230935458,
-0.0331853516,
-0.0020778836,
0.047571566,
-0.0121485144,
-0.0455190353,
-0.000541348,
0.0465093888,
0.0250750892,
0.0121438941,
0.0432620123,
0.0162096154,
-0.0320565626,
0.0047434224,
0.0478747897,
0.0509373993,
0.0712806359,
0.0283934511,
0.0023427543,
0.0090776496,
0.050611008,
0.0174192116,
-0.0173778348,
-0.0123104295,
-0.0479952395,
0.0384870544,
-0.0438904911,
-0.004111262,
-0.0503822379,
-0.0545430034,
0.0048150825,
-0.0113160769,
-0.0459552258,
0.0214989409,
0.0062026507,
-0.0294914432,
-0.0358409882,
0.0798991919,
0.0060868603,
-0.0077946018,
-0.0091442978,
-0.0068869055,
0.0283202492,
0.0809230357,
0.032137882,
-0.011440861,
-0.0186533816,
-0.0042388425,
-0.0155354086,
0.0602853596,
0.0652576461,
-0.0158091243,
-0.0359528698,
-0.052501075,
0.0024451197,
0.0164849795,
0.0128795821,
0.0174031705,
0.0361223407,
0.0027252259,
0.0014018785,
-0.0390126407,
-0.0049544666,
0.0061054854,
-0.0528161824,
-0.0573498867,
0.0103768846,
-0.0196481012,
-0.0058123479,
0.0168346297,
0.0093064373,
0.0006559177,
-0.0101518426,
-0.0000874003,
-0.0280828755,
-0.0110401809,
-0.0565746054,
-0.0046855006,
0.0317982808,
-0.027467208,
-0.0281749088,
0.0325680524,
-0.0644224361,
-0.0304254107,
-0.0457332879,
0.0211774986,
0.0186817441,
-0.0705155805,
-0.00253684,
-0.0311215632,
0.0242020171,
-0.0110283559,
0.0950740352,
-0.0079244599,
0.0519221723,
-0.0213237703,
0.0465894975,
0.0059009199,
-0.0616983324,
-0.0009768252,
-0.0274211429,
-0.0165164955,
0.0723538995,
0.0379497334,
0.0440537296,
-0.0438073315,
-0.0192908607,
-0.0749559253,
0.0102656139,
0.003203697,
0.0206578542,
0.0199317355,
-0.0359049626,
-0.013257239,
0.016092604,
-0.0774615854,
0.0100732232,
-0.0245049745,
-0.0044953264,
0.0469352528,
-0.0291917901,
0.0068739783,
-0.0326508321,
-0.0179138985,
-0.0068996777,
-0.0101467371,
0.0408074446,
0.0129458643,
-0.0110905208,
0.0272754133,
-0.0106531363,
-0.0145358136,
-0.0144453039,
0.0079923496,
-0.0132318437,
0.011061321,
0.0280986764,
0.032667052,
-0.0093059931,
0.047679618,
-0.034130916,
-0.0114518376,
-0.0290801693,
0.0134374807,
0.0168870259,
0.0037764763,
-0.0400628261,
0.0045394264,
-0.0048113917,
0.0405035913,
0.0006600519,
0.0043193679,
-0.0379677564,
0.0261845514,
-0.049452059,
0.0162931532,
-0.0640926585,
0.0469492786,
-0.0259787887,
0.033136066,
0.0078760441,
-0.0095460769,
0.0275890287,
-0.0055421251,
0.0049326345,
-0.0150249759,
-0.0177672412,
-0.0634302497,
0.0718505532,
-0.0377706066,
-0.0102757262,
0.0045569926,
-0.0520949997,
-0.048170317,
-0.019476464,
0.0234211981,
-0.0529190749,
0.0562369451,
-0.0251817815,
0.0049826233,
-0.0089955991,
-0.0037723347,
-0.0276706144,
-0.0686404258,
-0.0201640967,
0.0537024178,
0.030377619,
-0.0295827445,
-0.0220815986,
0.0271312632,
-0.0037781252,
-0.0285029151,
-0.0104573369,
-0.0146971876,
-0.0062545049,
0.0464644618,
0.0611472689,
0.021065671,
0.0284514185,
-0.0839735419,
0.0556704439,
0.0192591697,
0.0231760852,
0.0271423105,
0.0190926809,
0.0006103156,
0.0067567858,
-0.0749855563,
-0.0187451839,
0.0363856331,
-0.0273251683,
-0.066801399,
-0.0082040234,
0.1377666593,
0.0107145794,
0.0270417519,
-0.0149311079,
-0.0098268436,
0.0041802539,
0.0219213311,
0.0358407721,
-0.094826825,
-0.0085708881,
-0.0063512139,
0.0130481394,
0.0132835628,
-0.0289510023,
-0.0069737672,
-0.1441287845,
0.0443384349,
-0.0140465861,
-0.0100062285,
-0.0070241527,
-0.0124052195,
-0.0242286194,
-0.0317932591,
0.0531697944,
0.0255487114,
-0.0245997943,
0.0026317877,
0.0350382775,
-0.0867359266,
-0.006163558,
0.0702591166,
-0.0232943408,
-0.0086537832,
0.0448638089,
0.0345650911,
-0.0420142412,
-0.0120574422,
-0.021896787,
-0.025248453,
-0.0354343951,
0.0155978035,
0.0272016581,
-0.0089991437,
-0.0064215977,
-0.0113006439,
0.0309271552,
-0.060313765,
0.0587749258,
0.0587699078,
0.030993918,
-0.0171703771,
-0.0310838986,
0.0078118015,
0.0251302812,
-0.0624854118,
0.1048755869,
0.0009158702,
-0.0677111745,
-0.0047031576,
-0.0197891537,
-0.0271178111,
-0.0291280914,
0.0005550932,
0.0325058587,
0.0083947349,
0.0241979044,
-0.0825364068,
-0.0822576582,
0.053432554,
0.0111169005,
-0.0139716798,
0.0470905304,
0.0661393926,
-0.0227788966,
-0.0237625297,
0.0128558418,
-0.0851163864,
0.0389089882,
-0.0539076626,
0.0130722318,
0.0257291831,
-0.0091915466,
-0.0591357313,
0.0071545872,
-0.0694111362,
-0.0063919569,
-0.0172713231,
-0.003515665,
0.0127826845,
-0.0195726845,
-0.0335850418,
0.0226539355,
0.0107399179,
-0.0016335872,
-0.0343021192,
0.0028207081,
0.0507072732,
-0.0043653911,
-0.0086430516,
0.0051336228,
-0.0525134318,
0.0028286108,
0.0293204635,
0.054635793,
-0.028072184,
-0.0148905553,
0.0220824499,
0.0513626151,
-0.0030894221,
0.0362903662,
-0.0121486867,
-0.0248423032,
-0.0055075544,
0.0074655246,
-0.0157337543,
-0.0089135887,
-0.0463079512,
0.0935072601,
-0.0081475964,
-0.0027017849,
0.01074652,
0.0012021372,
-0.0301668867,
-0.0317124277,
0.0264102854,
-0.0175579339,
0.0225962978,
0.007432228,
-0.0421129912,
0.0009143889,
-0.0326900892,
0.0311570019,
0.0266866498,
0.0191169474,
0.0640592277,
0.0042492258,
0.0222676173,
0.0212720782,
-0.0377554558,
-0.0287516154,
-0.0327416994,
0.0185518917,
0.0411277823,
0.0758522823,
-0.0474333949,
-0.0318331793,
-0.059194006,
0.0320166461,
-0.0244685281,
-0.007845155,
0.0254185144,
-0.0549659543,
0.0612805746,
0.0141043942,
-0.0250693895,
-0.0423907079,
0.1143745109,
0.0299478099,
0.0120492745,
-0.0256867949,
0.0054219575,
-0.0437730849,
-0.0434668139,
0.042323824,
0.0167514905,
-0.0264993869,
0.0295248739,
-0.121807985,
-0.0657769442,
0.0193501413,
0.002952524,
-0.0127795907,
-0.0220531728,
0.0155616431,
0.0448644944,
-0.0003027901,
0.0363986641,
-0.0360496566,
0.0147685939,
-0.0137741352,
-0.0030641572,
-0.0544382036,
-6.173822696e-33,
-0.0232001804,
-0.0456761308,
0.0735577866,
-0.0094845565,
0.0379471481,
0.0216206294,
-0.0049744542,
-0.0089728283,
-0.028708443,
-0.0165068693,
-0.0174945109,
0.0252772961,
0.0005876735,
0.0329164416,
0.0071772975,
0.007980383,
0.0106916949,
-0.0056672511,
0.0195291862,
-0.0253900532,
-0.0146019598,
0.0721773207,
0.0531092435,
-0.0229276884,
0.0422288626,
0.0108087147,
-0.0017912679,
-0.0179690309,
0.0012053301,
0.0639142171,
-0.0101779439,
0.0440577865,
0.0286196414,
-0.0956512839,
-0.0164141655,
-0.0392432958,
-0.0671544373,
-0.0515896231,
0.0239785593,
0.0412974358,
0.0292970836,
-0.0072509008,
0.0208508708,
-0.0115291243,
-0.0146931857,
-0.045068752,
0.0303289536,
-0.044802431,
-0.0025507656,
-0.0345592313,
-0.0430409387,
0.0500568412,
0.0055006403,
0.0576024465,
-0.0180980396,
0.0441569127,
-0.0134808803,
0.0231092367,
-0.0311947986,
-0.0137353903,
0.0313949995,
0.0439757109,
0.0148962419,
-0.0132238148,
0.0068131136,
0.0473024212,
-0.004532401,
0.0055520558,
0.0241938755,
-0.0139280027,
0.0515890606,
0.0515976995,
0.0279371422,
0.0563426688,
0.0131166792,
-0.0366638117,
-0.0380565114,
0.0241904408,
0.0299429465,
0.0268092304,
0.0092328414,
0.037587896,
-0.0350398868,
-0.0310100615,
-0.05047727,
0.0292477049,
-0.0226446334,
0.0123868976,
0.0486479141,
-0.0074866684,
0.0204435419,
0.0000211231,
0.0106881242,
-0.0662446022,
-0.0475036353,
0.0108204251,
0.0095244162,
-0.0013992023,
-0.0114361187,
0.0633110702,
-0.0805523619,
-0.0386441164,
-0.0356498137,
-0.0162484217,
-0.0059043178,
0.0173778944,
0.035224922,
-0.0055946945,
-0.0501654409,
-0.034769509,
-0.0043586278,
-0.0077417283,
0.0232256688,
0.0587935783,
0.0105402945,
0.0302056018,
0.0105755972,
-0.0081048645,
0.0099796075,
-0.0222636256,
-0.0333388485,
-0.0422870107,
-0.0034200146,
0.0271841418,
0.0026788379,
0.0185494814,
0.0074270461,
0.0362120904,
0.0597628467,
-0.0151474113,
-0.0139056779,
0.0521563739,
2.77e-7,
0.0469971076,
0.0582945012,
-0.0309891999,
0.0299785044,
-0.0184465479,
0.031654831,
-0.052482523,
-0.00687902,
-0.0032571689,
0.0215644184,
0.0121810101,
0.0107145114,
0.0889554024,
-0.0212632921,
-0.0897289217,
-0.0260100327,
-0.0435794704,
-0.0026864484,
-0.0298613757,
0.0716298819,
0.0081060622,
0.0841720328,
-0.0009313289,
-0.0350973345,
-0.0033644882,
-0.0579201132,
0.0647101998,
-0.0210775938,
-0.0305660628,
0.0330728963,
0.0324283205,
0.0325681716,
0.0051463065,
0.0356807634,
0.0105305165,
0.0203039758,
0.0415070131,
0.0857033134,
0.031478513,
0.0145362057,
-0.0093639214,
-0.0164204389,
-0.0202372205,
-0.0463238358,
0.0267323777,
-0.0162665956,
-0.0488238595,
-0.0344199874,
-0.0553711057,
0.0047222083,
0.0281690992,
0.0103396205,
-0.0148451095,
0.0038905875,
0.0245575309,
-0.0304259695,
0.0003926831,
0.0060128113,
-0.0010377198,
0.0416177101,
-0.028574029,
-0.0148506528,
-0.018139571,
-0.0078180544,
0.0140276402,
-0.082993336,
-0.0092175771,
2.377508497e-34,
0.0530120395,
-0.01707495,
-0.0193848722,
0.0368528254,
0.0740180165,
0.0102338558,
-0.0241560042,
0.0420662984,
-0.0198538415,
-0.0683838576,
-0.0063014571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02284v1 | Renard: A Modular Pipeline for Extracting Character Networks from Narrative Texts | 2024-07-02T14:14:59 | 2024-07-02T14:14:59 | Arthur Amalvy, Vincent Labatut, Richard Dufour | cs.CL | cs.CL | Renard (Relationships Extraction from NARrative Documents) is a Python
library that allows users to define custom natural language processing (NLP)
pipelines to extract character networks from narrative texts. Contrary to the
few existing tools, Renard can extract dynamic networks, as well as the more
common static networks. Renard pipelines are modular: users can choose the
implementation of each NLP subtask needed to extract a character network. This
allows users to specialize pipelines to particular types of texts and to study
the impact of each subtask on the extracted network. | [
0.0141425403,
0.0570523255,
-0.0380945615,
0.0464136153,
-0.0299644489,
0.0124720661,
0.0079011191,
-0.0265852716,
0.0291560777,
-0.0099486569,
0.057300102,
-0.0147300512,
0.0386453904,
0.0423295312,
0.0218183529,
-0.0667713434,
0.0115619423,
0.0000233303,
0.052098345,
0.042846337,
-0.0072555887,
0.0912927911,
-0.0192882922,
0.0469343327,
0.0034849406,
-0.0439964905,
0.0006967551,
-0.0039317319,
0.0681868941,
-0.0449191965,
0.0053539942,
-0.0049218033,
0.0095013827,
-0.0250790827,
0.0000021038,
-0.0318303257,
-0.0228696782,
-0.0276505351,
0.0227671042,
-0.0447689891,
0.0444057025,
0.010901941,
0.0202518813,
-0.0073528672,
-0.0070778518,
0.0009155492,
0.0420043617,
0.0463478006,
0.0285664983,
0.0559556521,
-0.0239328612,
-0.0642319843,
-0.0265240856,
0.014284105,
-0.0031647603,
-0.0164306797,
-0.0038783289,
0.0089964755,
0.0613233559,
-0.0668153167,
-0.0219105314,
0.0140316812,
-0.0154057443,
-0.0281302668,
0.0347204134,
0.0267081615,
0.0330806337,
-0.0367520303,
0.0033866118,
0.0455419198,
0.0309403762,
-0.0023292394,
0.0184543263,
-0.0001864718,
0.0098772412,
0.0354884714,
-0.0052803834,
0.0046508904,
-0.0378821492,
-0.0005749408,
0.0063565685,
0.0010469322,
0.0035468654,
-0.0354419984,
-0.0271026567,
-0.0068255919,
-0.0081276158,
0.0161674675,
-0.0025247608,
-0.007261273,
0.0249769557,
-0.0532855466,
0.0226839017,
0.0349553637,
0.001230919,
0.0092933811,
-0.0055512772,
0.0201695487,
0.0094545996,
-0.0116939852,
-0.0280068014,
-0.0342651047,
0.0074621993,
-0.0142519707,
0.0157883894,
-0.0140835922,
0.0046679662,
-0.0177446138,
-0.017050406,
0.0218645204,
-0.057655748,
-0.0280425623,
-0.0315779746,
0.0342358984,
-0.0475785136,
-0.0246968884,
-0.0273086205,
0.0110241966,
-0.0157431476,
-0.0012930902,
0.0080795167,
0.0348901562,
0.0453671478,
0.0211469773,
-0.0450328365,
0.04208114,
-0.0580003373,
-0.0057581956,
-0.0284057856,
0.040670462,
0.0016947405,
-0.0348398574,
0.0698808283,
-0.0495577045,
-0.011962276,
0.1020880491,
0.007666009,
-0.0504117683,
-0.0328168459,
-0.0396248773,
0.0377762429,
-0.0551820397,
-0.0338856541,
-0.0397791155,
0.0377947539,
-0.0014890144,
0.0385774784,
-0.0509400591,
0.0265080389,
-0.010564479,
-0.0586323217,
0.0164718274,
-0.0107167736,
0.0091294553,
-0.0146082025,
-0.0028977103,
0.0726670623,
-0.0221718289,
0.0498965271,
-0.0106784785,
0.0469701141,
-0.0413149334,
-0.0204493403,
-0.0037484292,
-0.0365247354,
-0.0715478957,
0.010176654,
-0.0123734875,
0.0109361531,
-0.008920487,
0.0002357783,
0.0326898769,
-0.0429551825,
-0.016879363,
0.0474163368,
0.101508379,
0.0944054946,
0.0320931114,
0.0405705236,
0.0059141032,
0.0535291359,
0.0146344882,
-0.0346644782,
0.0133818714,
0.0421630666,
-0.0121346619,
-0.0980580598,
0.058341939,
0.0387243889,
0.0089107063,
0.0141384667,
0.0171048604,
0.0174144767,
-0.0253058523,
0.0496676862,
0.0091667324,
-0.0256252456,
-0.0382034741,
0.0352458023,
-0.0501847453,
0.0156427566,
0.0478995331,
-0.007314703,
0.1263003498,
0.0572381802,
-0.027287364,
-0.0300347507,
-0.0362838767,
-0.0727509111,
-0.0000894362,
-0.0335778072,
-0.0443356037,
0.0525188856,
-0.035859745,
0.0249424372,
0.0112198852,
0.0131573649,
0.0391391851,
-0.0258196518,
0.0008091648,
-0.0209223796,
0.0135086672,
-0.0329738036,
0.0535468683,
-0.0823420957,
0.0034988348,
-0.0465535447,
0.0115018273,
-0.0457315966,
0.046353858,
-0.0551436841,
-0.0091191623,
0.0367188193,
-0.0173622277,
0.0036410491,
0.0800763294,
-0.0234966613,
0.0283207595,
0.011017344,
-0.064278245,
-0.0426647626,
-0.0061208229,
0.0523697287,
-0.022127619,
0.0525237024,
-0.0248475447,
0.0411558896,
0.0078186709,
0.0002792597,
0.0110864528,
0.0045854612,
-0.0246737283,
0.0481273346,
0.051087331,
-0.012421418,
-0.0435874388,
-0.0312973075,
-0.0406754054,
-0.0338281281,
0.0315287672,
-0.0120221106,
0.012642323,
-0.0327388421,
0.0386156514,
-0.020733349,
-0.0025545885,
-0.0414957814,
-0.0067406418,
0.0077703986,
0.0118467053,
0.0180462282,
0.0285820682,
0.0116941165,
-0.0385927521,
0.0308403317,
0.0152938021,
0.0420224778,
0.0080852406,
-0.0381918997,
0.0234270077,
3.386e-7,
-0.0401705056,
-0.0403528884,
-0.0053080334,
-0.0249093603,
0.1023789272,
0.053221941,
-0.0700412542,
-0.001997537,
-0.0506564118,
-0.0115864249,
0.0138073014,
-0.0057051685,
-0.0333213061,
0.0016233188,
-0.0081925727,
0.0302319061,
-0.0118601816,
-0.0089053381,
0.0483637229,
0.0071280282,
-0.0926462933,
0.0138275744,
0.0057964157,
-0.0142632071,
0.0446985252,
-0.0381619371,
-0.0398549698,
-0.0146946441,
0.0310038291,
-0.0036833384,
0.0095110508,
-0.0078538852,
0.0060519567,
0.0618467964,
0.0107938135,
0.0069135269,
-0.0434035845,
-0.0087802466,
0.0094925752,
-0.0033474381,
0.0096220039,
0.0351283588,
-0.0068397918,
0.0036781994,
-0.0337425843,
-0.0446121991,
-0.0208328217,
0.1168258563,
0.0395123847,
0.0205900054,
0.0734569654,
-0.0498746224,
-0.008792093,
-0.0077740806,
0.0448486134,
-0.004104631,
0.013554371,
-0.0232932195,
0.0026437324,
0.0018734391,
0.0301529653,
-0.0491512455,
0.0516355038,
-0.0192624889,
-0.0162581932,
0.0667342469,
-0.084670797,
0.0073131453,
0.0101674329,
-0.0040730881,
0.0060884235,
0.0016023059,
-0.0084870197,
-0.0069596926,
0.0652484223,
0.0034836165,
-0.0413811766,
0.0039583468,
0.0051205726,
0.0634794757,
0.0247595459,
-0.0770041421,
-0.0325515196,
-0.0130165992,
0.0052816365,
-0.003511918,
-0.0437286757,
0.0160651226,
-0.031493675,
0.0185463354,
-0.0620025359,
-0.0241939072,
0.0547538102,
0.0108270627,
-0.0138222901,
0.0435957834,
0.0416680351,
-0.0205805618,
0.0477140769,
0.0075240359,
-0.0869293585,
0.0328550525,
-0.0160474852,
0.0006414912,
0.0067319949,
-0.0829432234,
-0.026665492,
-0.0633067638,
0.0263914298,
0.0020038274,
-0.0651180595,
-0.0222144872,
-0.0520457067,
-0.0465351008,
-0.0101584503,
-0.0590619035,
0.0111122001,
-0.0613096319,
-0.0014861358,
-0.0236474331,
-0.0319672264,
0.0070043374,
-0.0277460907,
-0.0377266221,
0.0461048372,
-0.0383948609,
0.0722664893,
-0.0249730013,
0.0406440161,
-0.0074450453,
-0.0092060352,
-0.0014461776,
-0.0069199274,
0.0739632025,
-0.0005857251,
-0.0167849213,
-0.0845539793,
-0.0135983964,
0.0013683516,
-0.0492067859,
0.0353585035,
0.0391372964,
0.0006701903,
-0.020479016,
-0.0205066707,
0.0411461256,
0.0231319647,
0.0021745809,
-0.0107225329,
0.0012504179,
-0.0764007792,
0.0030925223,
0.0230001528,
-0.0736632273,
-0.0925468877,
0.0041111754,
-0.0364061333,
0.0118753957,
-0.0587822832,
-0.0311393142,
0.0204774663,
0.0442329049,
0.0376011841,
-0.0026157938,
0.0363667645,
0.0144086359,
-0.0796970278,
-0.0031482414,
0.0210176371,
0.0037898214,
0.0238835793,
-0.0348463804,
0.0087894788,
-0.0125473049,
0.0245703738,
0.0130741457,
-0.0378318168,
-0.0380462371,
0.0003207671,
-0.0432620347,
0.0304546766,
0.0306011271,
0.0181377381,
-0.0269503444,
-0.0223178174,
0.0189172607,
-0.0846987069,
0.0244344976,
-0.0286318362,
-0.0152253136,
-0.0337992385,
0.0033973542,
0.0069222269,
0.0295682382,
-0.0361205973,
0.0285947546,
-0.021073591,
-0.0170611832,
0.0124730133,
-0.0160636026,
-0.0308535919,
-0.0155056063,
-0.0350181684,
-0.0787241459,
-0.0210679043,
-0.0491314009,
-0.0116066467,
-0.0161777344,
0.0230690669,
0.0112832952,
0.0378709026,
-0.0128271421,
-0.0504568182,
0.0078418273,
0.0413086936,
-0.0105084293,
0.0303550251,
0.0778767988,
0.0228478052,
-0.0041331626,
0.0096666198,
-0.0029201342,
-0.0248582046,
-0.0527815185,
0.0784226283,
-0.0115683721,
-0.0267833639,
-0.012503433,
-0.0283036865,
-0.0172106009,
0.0001488918,
-0.014764579,
-0.0123727443,
-0.0079286741,
0.0019305437,
0.0364180654,
-0.0062328125,
0.0501044281,
-0.0292224139,
0.0101327645,
0.0269880295,
-0.0021977588,
-0.0239896774,
0.0438185111,
-0.0604231656,
0.0366127305,
-0.0163520258,
0.019382786,
0.0158053767,
0.0022366105,
0.0393111184,
0.0367748365,
-0.0568705834,
-0.0433519483,
-0.0596406572,
0.017742008,
0.0293409992,
-0.000009497,
-0.0051433924,
-0.0787616819,
-0.0416793078,
0.0240963083,
-0.0015446502,
0.006499975,
0.0054454808,
-0.0339198187,
-0.0207679775,
0.0558544621,
0.0020571649,
-0.0298848748,
0.059998937,
-0.0431457534,
-0.0110775959,
0.0195038076,
-6.100074752e-33,
-0.0363503024,
-0.0612194128,
0.0187399928,
0.0384812057,
-0.0632071048,
0.0228962656,
-0.0141353076,
-0.018335687,
-0.0135347787,
0.0447287187,
0.0183308888,
0.0030367691,
0.0008983593,
-0.026953252,
-0.0237591006,
0.0476591997,
0.0319205374,
0.0184183978,
-0.0043491716,
0.0137341823,
0.0767803714,
0.0696024895,
0.0659616515,
-0.0841506347,
0.0114197852,
-0.045068793,
-0.0163570922,
0.0111300815,
0.0568493754,
0.0022292659,
-0.0274139754,
-0.0050907452,
0.0043961424,
-0.0157793667,
0.0189473387,
0.0420158543,
-0.1268161535,
-0.0183754396,
0.0134191765,
-0.0224912819,
-0.0051348088,
-0.0252625104,
0.0112483725,
0.0140598314,
0.0297482982,
-0.0264831148,
0.0656700805,
-0.0056529311,
0.0100467261,
0.0111276414,
-0.0798526928,
0.0141841518,
-0.0277630482,
0.0241571721,
0.0156297106,
0.0137073426,
-0.0026813489,
-0.0149696935,
-0.0474123657,
-0.0085390145,
-0.0250849314,
0.007925597,
-0.0465813465,
0.0286825486,
-0.0114550041,
0.0783108473,
0.0384124555,
-0.0012712749,
0.0165265631,
0.105237402,
-0.0211306177,
0.052359663,
0.0105360793,
0.0106813628,
-0.0618664138,
-0.0131924143,
-0.0942478776,
-0.0112477392,
0.0506905764,
0.0192821324,
-0.0064779627,
0.0054639992,
0.0370798148,
-0.0173093919,
0.0012494273,
-0.0591402613,
0.0295814611,
-0.0076898527,
-0.0351649933,
-0.0097610326,
-0.028985789,
0.0581002384,
0.0051299664,
0.0058798525,
0.0096036578,
0.0390399545,
0.0209001023,
0.0242930371,
-0.0046134763,
-0.0070847035,
0.0130512444,
-0.0015207174,
0.0040060473,
0.0021161891,
0.085085161,
-0.0094895614,
0.0136148045,
0.0092060678,
-0.0550375208,
-0.0316358879,
-0.0098650623,
0.0225378387,
-0.0349720493,
0.0252879467,
0.0103818579,
-0.0108949803,
-0.0074573164,
0.0303123593,
0.0464381762,
0.0375174396,
-0.0147805195,
0.041030921,
0.0058310213,
-0.0261361673,
-0.0225763936,
-0.004346272,
-0.0239090938,
0.0642233044,
0.0417848192,
-0.0546333008,
-0.0045696539,
-0.0195314959,
2.721e-7,
0.0340062231,
0.0233948175,
0.0825575516,
-0.0127521232,
0.029757116,
-0.0094542382,
0.0101227574,
0.03494519,
0.0117712952,
-0.0456079394,
0.0348833241,
0.0112257553,
-0.0296104085,
0.096211426,
-0.061716862,
0.0206254777,
-0.0347613022,
-0.0901189372,
-0.0371491835,
-0.0345041491,
0.0633888096,
0.0152278077,
0.0696470365,
0.0152769117,
-0.0036634938,
-0.0073405611,
-0.0258920267,
0.0008001059,
-0.0141641349,
0.0209026989,
-0.013277987,
-0.0284805745,
-0.0285790656,
0.0064730984,
0.0032458513,
0.0390438922,
-0.0247598849,
-0.0041714436,
-0.038304273,
0.0202823859,
0.0187855773,
-0.0354280993,
-0.0032723688,
-0.0050408444,
0.0403839834,
-0.0221721772,
-0.0278089195,
-0.0098354537,
-0.0130544966,
0.0156936403,
0.0282750782,
0.0371625572,
0.0108069703,
0.0657180771,
-0.0237016045,
0.0130975461,
0.0024930234,
-0.1017354503,
0.0164943598,
0.0661272258,
0.0121973995,
-0.0211393088,
0.0355305411,
-0.0173522625,
0.0245139766,
-0.0295853056,
0.0323839895,
2.482730624e-34,
-0.0285555758,
0.0247724373,
-0.009418563,
0.0614611246,
0.0642492771,
-0.0417263061,
-0.0390627943,
0.0422598086,
0.0219472665,
-0.0684314072,
-0.0241375472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02273v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02273v1 | Multilingual Trolley Problems for Language Models | 2024-07-02T14:02:53 | 2024-07-02T14:02:53 | Zhijing Jin, Sydney Levine, Max Kleiman-Weiner, Giorgio Piatti, Jiarui Liu, Fernando Gonzalez Adauto, Francesco Ortu, András Strausz, Mrinmaya Sachan, Rada Mihalcea, Yejin Choi, Bernhard Schölkopf | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) are deployed in more and more real-world
situations, it is crucial to understand their decision-making when faced with
moral dilemmas. Inspired by a large-scale cross-cultural study of human moral
preferences, "The Moral Machine Experiment", we set up the same set of moral
choices for LLMs. We translate 1K vignettes of moral dilemmas, parametrically
varied across key axes, into 100+ languages, and reveal the preferences of LLMs
in each of these languages. We then compare the responses of LLMs to that of
human speakers of those languages, harnessing a dataset of 40 million human
moral judgments. We discover that LLMs are more aligned with human preferences
in languages such as English, Korean, Hungarian, and Chinese, but less aligned
in languages such as Hindi and Somali (in Africa). Moreover, we characterize
the explanations LLMs give for their moral choices and find that fairness is
the most dominant supporting reason behind GPT-4's decisions and utilitarianism
by GPT-3. We also discover "language inequality" (which we define as the
model's different development levels in different languages) in a series of
meta-properties of moral decision making. | [
0.0307175778,
0.1026978716,
-0.0343971923,
0.0333824418,
-0.075000219,
0.0322570875,
0.0184856094,
0.0021039352,
-0.0062274444,
0.004840279,
-0.0062485356,
-0.0206291806,
0.0070480267,
-0.0574978217,
0.0021360356,
-0.02340867,
0.0237524658,
-0.0213118736,
0.0372461751,
-0.0366008319,
-0.0009792604,
0.03479046,
0.0513985343,
-0.0007132115,
-0.000140329,
0.0339736938,
0.004277742,
-0.0399628915,
0.0199283548,
-0.032365378,
-0.0069888625,
0.0449230485,
0.0218477342,
0.0339440033,
0.0000021099,
-0.0495826043,
0.0240604207,
-0.0079867179,
0.0249337666,
0.0300026126,
0.0902814716,
-0.0284183901,
-0.0033813063,
-0.0328066424,
-0.012342385,
0.0421028025,
0.0269495677,
0.0513129793,
-0.0261240248,
0.025909286,
0.0012151421,
-0.0134240501,
0.0053052483,
-0.0252274908,
-0.0134207383,
-0.0049224547,
0.0240215678,
0.055900421,
-0.0051227561,
0.0036686906,
-0.0400677286,
0.0037373316,
0.0322135091,
0.0095988568,
-0.1089283451,
-0.0244686399,
-0.0125756124,
-0.0339728035,
0.0299944934,
0.0438582748,
0.0234289151,
-0.0251838714,
0.0161261186,
0.0050325729,
0.0110075176,
-0.0022874826,
0.0119456667,
0.065505676,
-0.0025820304,
0.0353065729,
0.0507039279,
0.0202360023,
-0.002470125,
0.0373812653,
0.0148852263,
0.0395015739,
-0.0047556087,
-0.0019756476,
0.0194551479,
0.0276906993,
-0.0739868432,
-0.0177092906,
0.0001065784,
-0.0074147442,
-0.0232820325,
0.0132890735,
0.0195144061,
0.0343300402,
0.0475665666,
-0.0659202933,
0.0160379652,
0.0371247455,
-0.0107006952,
-0.0025589657,
0.0259768013,
0.0349296071,
-0.0329934135,
0.0387904234,
-0.0402710102,
0.0126370052,
0.0224238336,
-0.0034814491,
0.0312330313,
-0.0001713321,
-0.0222196616,
0.0840104446,
-0.0545597002,
0.005005761,
-0.0574374497,
-0.0176176932,
-0.0459647141,
-0.0392408185,
-0.0004134041,
-0.0157489665,
-0.045027744,
0.0147296963,
-0.0638417006,
0.0041910661,
-0.0469727069,
-0.014272023,
0.0606713258,
-0.0339290835,
-0.050919354,
-0.0045114751,
0.0368551537,
0.1250739396,
-0.0054632798,
0.0124532785,
-0.0107813496,
0.0173372608,
-0.0261574965,
-0.0501247235,
-0.0465282314,
-0.0595646389,
0.0335545465,
0.0193097033,
0.0026288168,
-0.0612675175,
0.0261360854,
0.009456425,
-0.047594551,
0.0259563047,
0.0766126662,
0.0306071229,
0.0058716815,
0.0034707796,
0.0114066452,
0.0544202477,
0.0126513783,
0.0081408368,
0.0529427603,
-0.0141044306,
-0.0111162458,
-0.0022846367,
-0.0176348202,
0.0336184204,
-0.0473774113,
0.0143236369,
0.0147355953,
-0.007499788,
0.0159060601,
0.0423546024,
-0.0030718578,
-0.0183983129,
0.0405170023,
0.1107570976,
-0.0234218035,
0.0135521041,
-0.0160196107,
-0.0049726376,
-0.0340641737,
0.0269738846,
-0.051352717,
0.0096360845,
0.01085517,
-0.0373202525,
-0.0331456773,
0.0676838458,
-0.0063817888,
-0.0151260253,
0.0345963463,
-0.0174840055,
0.0640147626,
0.0385932513,
0.0097234547,
-0.0441581681,
0.0100253876,
-0.0668094382,
0.0772477984,
-0.0576675311,
-0.0286124442,
-0.0328633003,
0.0716449916,
0.0281466041,
0.0034094576,
0.0166791771,
0.0270379558,
0.0076262224,
-0.0228887293,
0.0373253226,
0.0350375138,
-0.0053461199,
-0.0253145061,
-0.0427975319,
-0.0172213651,
0.0190364849,
-0.009541533,
0.0445762947,
-0.041926451,
0.0278827138,
0.0099780392,
-0.0210757684,
-0.0142353289,
-0.0059405626,
-0.0028390647,
0.0359178483,
-0.0497670062,
0.0109913861,
0.0198555868,
-0.0304405745,
-0.0072473995,
-0.0206019934,
-0.0256211776,
-0.0073910858,
0.0112687331,
0.0514603145,
-0.0438199751,
0.0408124402,
0.0168589745,
-0.0909976587,
-0.0038002739,
0.0315903351,
-0.0042561088,
0.0249123015,
-0.0022023066,
-0.0037794467,
0.0220080744,
-0.0298897214,
0.022701852,
-0.064479582,
-0.0001147984,
-0.0249468405,
0.0591980889,
-0.0156423617,
0.0388776585,
-0.037758451,
-0.0235141926,
0.0699743256,
-0.0176160801,
-0.0313447118,
0.0585503429,
-0.0088101113,
0.0399723873,
0.0483170748,
0.0746961981,
0.0089323884,
-0.0288081821,
-0.0727656037,
-0.0184459761,
0.0262819882,
-0.0080878818,
-0.0424586833,
-0.0017952354,
-0.0148678524,
0.0202143211,
-0.0557229891,
0.0378447697,
0.0384467654,
0.0294806305,
0.0009402076,
-0.0421976522,
0.0017982346,
0.0037472483,
-0.0126768937,
-0.0275632702,
0.0066590938,
0.002321833,
0.0238108262,
-0.0217866562,
0.0039054607,
-0.0809028819,
0.0096922377,
-0.0178146902,
-0.0604110323,
-0.0207628012,
0.0534588769,
0.0285959207,
0.0449939743,
0.0122072892,
0.0199590418,
0.0475101024,
0.0233324487,
-0.059682779,
-0.0275030471,
-0.0033713717,
-0.0267679524,
-0.0246723276,
-0.0860040486,
-0.0306612886,
0.0882392451,
0.017405536,
-0.0088583305,
-0.0472372659,
0.0076665701,
-0.0789112002,
-0.0383318886,
-0.0188783091,
-0.0353485309,
0.0116866613,
0.0938058794,
-0.0125178955,
-0.0442664251,
0.0729445219,
0.0421194956,
0.0300984737,
-0.0147143789,
0.0250659697,
-0.033364974,
0.0380440354,
0.0137110678,
0.0456200093,
-0.0282865297,
0.0029884437,
-0.0327840187,
-0.010321606,
0.0499793515,
-0.0256446227,
0.073947154,
-0.0430560336,
-0.0006528602,
-0.0265466273,
-0.0941671208,
0.0113500357,
-0.0625725538,
-0.0251634475,
-0.028340416,
0.0101525141,
-0.0164088234,
0.0470996276,
-0.0019315551,
0.0490607917,
-0.0121115549,
0.0062108054,
0.038519118,
-0.0161345899,
-0.0855664536,
0.004925664,
-0.0098731192,
0.060266912,
-0.0100839809,
0.0290944688,
0.0373423807,
0.0129180038,
0.0191721153,
0.0613442175,
0.0645100549,
0.0390337706,
0.0304357503,
-0.0152664157,
0.0079240873,
0.0497809649,
0.0113317147,
0.0443776697,
0.0599058978,
0.0075357445,
-0.0644139275,
0.0401012301,
-0.0473503284,
-0.0234808698,
0.0134371016,
0.0229369421,
-0.0946157947,
0.0029138252,
-0.0021206404,
-0.0134741729,
-0.0705935061,
-0.0342235938,
0.0439959764,
-0.0806600302,
-0.0022668419,
0.0426615514,
-0.0197345763,
-0.0581809804,
0.0069753192,
-0.030350836,
-0.0166507401,
0.0392330438,
0.0071424036,
0.0192041453,
-0.0204188395,
-0.0170755014,
0.071098581,
0.0336990952,
0.060861364,
-0.010015714,
0.0339202099,
0.0258037914,
0.0459183156,
-0.046382498,
-0.0386224724,
0.0144022992,
0.0199267864,
-0.060658861,
0.0390903763,
-0.0457385331,
0.0219705645,
-0.0308490582,
-0.0902823284,
0.0075171213,
0.0124652842,
-0.0269732475,
0.0314584933,
0.0619888268,
0.0101228096,
-0.0646745563,
0.0288895462,
0.0124790408,
-0.0360960476,
0.045815222,
-0.0151209189,
-0.0549770072,
0.0108496062,
-0.0673303455,
-0.0560961701,
-0.0256610643,
-0.074114494,
-0.0080386698,
-0.004848476,
-0.0582080297,
-0.0356598347,
-0.0357529745,
-0.0557450131,
-0.0341747105,
0.0662425756,
-0.0883837491,
0.0319149271,
0.0023216861,
-0.0312273577,
0.00201522,
-0.0253340546,
-0.0103404196,
-0.0317736715,
0.043022234,
0.0201994162,
-0.0393361636,
-0.0091650067,
-0.0379596353,
0.0016555517,
-0.039611157,
0.016642835,
0.0340013616,
0.0063199862,
-0.0021007427,
-0.0036749977,
-0.0012024814,
-0.019029133,
0.0131639671,
-0.0355486348,
0.0423358306,
0.0371881761,
0.0214516521,
-0.0020190468,
0.0227219332,
-0.0169923734,
0.0429527797,
0.0225559082,
-0.0050882213,
-0.0483417027,
0.0028981715,
0.0465483814,
0.019899223,
-0.0303366836,
-0.0246912371,
-0.0244743228,
-0.0393641107,
-0.0264220163,
-0.0062879142,
-0.0519990511,
-0.0321974233,
-0.0227941405,
0.0412065051,
-0.002478817,
0.0096977334,
-0.0074886978,
0.0020528503,
-0.023331156,
0.0250666831,
0.0273239035,
0.0337445289,
0.0680124983,
-0.0135002667,
0.0240123719,
-0.0101201581,
0.0255830735,
-0.0230736267,
0.0512312092,
-0.0434045456,
0.0878727883,
0.0092206709,
-0.013866039,
0.034687262,
0.0123852221,
-0.0187780689,
-0.0484313406,
0.0080684181,
-0.0315293446,
0.0090635205,
-0.0077702473,
0.0339160785,
-0.0261157192,
-0.0127196386,
-0.0370018966,
0.0314474963,
-0.0014014696,
-0.0237400401,
-0.0254057422,
-0.0052842982,
-0.0207399335,
-0.0011142425,
0.0567658506,
-0.0548353121,
0.0079734977,
0.0282299258,
-0.0129546225,
-0.0012721531,
-0.0426210687,
0.0333908461,
-0.0601128899,
-0.0121463081,
0.0095794825,
-0.0878282785,
-0.0434243418,
-0.1016913354,
0.0241615213,
-0.0046380865,
-0.0181560088,
-0.0384316333,
0.0446714275,
-0.0164304022,
0.03322028,
-0.0441342108,
0.0295666382,
-0.0433528274,
0.0181927923,
-0.0181106087,
-5.518194763e-33,
-0.0132328244,
-0.01413396,
-0.0361224748,
-0.0271003414,
0.0157390926,
-0.0611933656,
0.0023329039,
0.0347392112,
-0.0623174384,
0.0418741368,
-0.0032027806,
-0.0225773063,
0.0012219454,
-0.0157022178,
0.0546000004,
-0.0305836238,
-0.0172238518,
0.0196250044,
-0.0233306885,
0.0161707811,
0.0053998977,
-0.0329882614,
0.0612225384,
-0.0434403643,
0.0521233566,
0.0023553788,
-0.000968745,
-0.0028914863,
-0.0538978614,
0.0196227618,
-0.0252613928,
0.0670217723,
0.0234092325,
-0.0123367757,
0.0042497963,
0.0364670977,
0.0254473239,
-0.0154051287,
0.0678705573,
0.0082747992,
-0.0104424497,
-0.054319188,
-0.0414101742,
-0.0237129517,
-0.0564396121,
0.0303340722,
0.0235229507,
-0.0010614508,
0.0232518092,
0.0281315334,
-0.0307891257,
-0.0243993774,
-0.0551098622,
-0.0252939127,
-0.0238117874,
0.0559709184,
-0.0195096321,
0.0391485952,
0.0326673873,
0.0706763044,
-0.0128990998,
-0.0218512975,
0.0243741032,
-0.0652566925,
0.0193525609,
0.0500570536,
-0.0162810814,
0.0040171682,
-0.0027029729,
-0.0015460973,
0.0130095221,
0.0148215089,
0.0313357413,
0.069449164,
0.0028181444,
-0.0488988161,
-0.0284102969,
-0.0321866572,
0.0554044135,
-0.0040068831,
0.0075538349,
0.0099046705,
-0.0396571718,
-0.0275171623,
-0.0387124121,
-0.1050453857,
-0.0180457868,
-0.0166277979,
0.0238729287,
-0.0343173109,
-0.0204224531,
-0.0040243464,
0.031741377,
-0.0372835621,
-0.0175818317,
0.0225623194,
0.0122422362,
-0.0161446594,
0.0165818799,
0.0308519583,
-0.0248424411,
-0.0323421285,
-0.0575580336,
-0.0215476714,
0.0333650187,
0.0064011691,
0.0247733649,
-0.0279326737,
-0.0023045363,
0.0126549024,
-0.0153969293,
-0.0078641251,
0.0183575042,
-0.0200535897,
0.0199225545,
0.0074950014,
0.0090310788,
-0.0345937535,
0.0440968946,
-0.0436709635,
-0.0595119186,
-0.0321443826,
-0.0519333258,
0.0613586418,
-0.0129143577,
0.0034797925,
-0.037436191,
0.0574170426,
0.045843266,
-0.0211706329,
-0.0302493218,
0.0195386931,
2.641e-7,
-0.0041747862,
0.0086619984,
0.0124752177,
-0.0124763772,
-0.0282313842,
0.0820896924,
0.0177694019,
0.0367681123,
0.0215971842,
-0.0091769388,
-0.0195464119,
0.0081813922,
0.0767412856,
0.0098177232,
0.0105173457,
0.0298418235,
-0.0071625449,
-0.02564767,
-0.0249642171,
0.0270121433,
0.0034235765,
0.0513227805,
0.0165695511,
0.0095947227,
-0.009823936,
0.0332984999,
0.021677576,
-0.1071136668,
-0.0280011017,
-0.0115824742,
-0.0633707866,
-0.0305317566,
0.0142216049,
0.0132952482,
0.0491194837,
-0.0241797641,
0.0307360049,
0.0764957145,
0.0201687235,
-0.0309166592,
-0.0450183451,
-0.0238513015,
-0.0311027989,
-0.0252048485,
0.0718904659,
0.0147648696,
-0.0441702046,
-0.0011202776,
0.0491016358,
-0.0266262721,
0.0219289809,
-0.0241853558,
-0.0353880413,
0.011513574,
0.0332713835,
0.0231097415,
0.0392628089,
-0.0191582981,
-0.0190721676,
0.0251468215,
-0.0039961818,
-0.0656555295,
0.0052122045,
0.0565063171,
0.0418030284,
-0.0373152755,
0.007759315,
2.066965619e-34,
0.031068543,
-0.0192120746,
0.0329474658,
-0.0205435585,
0.0420314744,
0.0411291048,
0.0082319761,
0.0130579527,
0.0302337613,
0.0008929788,
-0.0108863497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02243v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02243v1 | Robust Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech Synthesis with Reverse Inference Optimization | 2024-07-02T13:04:04 | 2024-07-02T13:04:04 | Yuchen Hu, Chen Chen, Siyin Wang, Eng Siong Chng, Chao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In this paper, we propose reverse inference optimization (RIO), a simple and
effective method designed to enhance the robustness of
autoregressive-model-based zero-shot text-to-speech (TTS) systems using
reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). To assess the quality of
speech produced by the TTS system without human annotations, RIO introduces a
novel concept termed as reverse inference based on the Bayesian principle,
which suggests that a high-quality generated speech should be able to be used
as a prompt for subsequent generation using the same TTS model. By leveraging
reverse inference as the standard to select exemplars used in RLHF from the
speech samples generated by the TTS system itself, RIO steers the subsequent
optimization towards a direction of enhancing the TTS robustness. The RIO
framework, comprising sampling, automatic annotating, and learning, obviates
the need for a reward model or pairwise preference data, and significantly
improves the stability of zero-shot TTS performance by reducing the
discrepancies between training and inference conditions. Our experimental
results verify that RIO can effectively improve both subjective and objective
metrics, including mean opinion scores, word error rates, and speaker
similarity. Remarkably, RIO can also diminish the incidence of bad outputs to
nearly zero percent, rivalling the robustness when using ground-truth speech as
the prompt. | [
-0.000923895,
0.0362958238,
0.0275428053,
-0.0264320262,
-0.0136345848,
-0.0245188717,
0.0003577137,
0.0171373803,
-0.0375700817,
-0.0508870557,
-0.0621119849,
-0.0230025332,
0.0270310305,
-0.0041309353,
0.041747421,
-0.0764238536,
0.0098177381,
-0.0465255007,
-0.0036886875,
-0.0074871127,
0.0124283955,
0.0135326404,
-0.0477004163,
0.0178844519,
-0.0174183398,
0.0383127816,
0.0010680106,
0.010623578,
0.0460983478,
-0.0164771229,
-0.0427921154,
0.0057814526,
0.0197032597,
0.0350738913,
0.0000021847,
-0.0382092521,
0.0030263164,
0.0079395687,
-0.0288499091,
-0.056780722,
0.0715921,
0.0375122242,
-0.0423983559,
0.0311130825,
0.0125675397,
-0.0001614906,
0.0456973463,
0.0491046906,
0.0423963368,
0.0734007806,
-0.0020731527,
-0.035564512,
-0.0069137183,
-0.0131189721,
0.0065563093,
0.0235343315,
-0.0462416001,
-0.0212118104,
0.0692115203,
-0.0222494062,
-0.0114046345,
0.035630729,
-0.0029650994,
-0.0166229326,
-0.0050866711,
0.0312317442,
0.0293120109,
-0.0361774042,
-0.013351826,
0.1018082649,
0.0237931833,
-0.0220027138,
0.0224069208,
-0.0247433204,
-0.0191341806,
-0.0044272128,
0.0076939031,
0.0389799364,
0.0178818777,
0.0143521214,
-0.0325730853,
0.0389834605,
0.011064129,
-0.0232195854,
0.0037538072,
0.0160126425,
0.0144325364,
-0.0284068622,
0.0191994086,
0.0106675429,
-0.0109361839,
-0.0424401872,
-0.0015115299,
0.024623163,
-0.0479768552,
-0.0125781596,
-0.049285043,
-0.055623427,
-0.0415714681,
-0.010698217,
0.0333173871,
0.0473661721,
-0.0065494105,
-0.0314987786,
0.0114346761,
0.0243701991,
-0.0043428484,
-0.0237487517,
-0.015825497,
0.0092218248,
-0.0393090099,
0.0174176581,
-0.0189984925,
0.0705508962,
-0.0316735655,
-0.0204175301,
-0.0595441237,
-0.0115590878,
-0.058357399,
0.0023082504,
0.0013713163,
0.043472264,
-0.0629705712,
-0.0374509022,
-0.0017430652,
0.037233524,
-0.0230372138,
0.0209127665,
0.0390753634,
-0.028782703,
0.008864807,
0.0148910824,
0.023660183,
0.0108178873,
0.0057226173,
0.0825193822,
-0.0181085877,
-0.0083694486,
-0.0442379005,
-0.0483387262,
-0.0308492798,
-0.0725063533,
0.005062317,
-0.0589152165,
-0.0280699991,
-0.013393865,
-0.0161513276,
-0.0002622687,
-0.0021263722,
0.0024603545,
-0.0146456314,
0.0306256283,
-0.0122940633,
-0.0170999505,
0.0374922939,
-0.0163761135,
-0.0297194961,
0.0580662452,
0.0649439991,
0.0048230295,
-0.0214970838,
0.013589832,
0.0253065042,
0.0288067292,
0.0286835171,
0.0279191118,
-0.0465211794,
-0.0376196504,
-0.0453472286,
0.0443664305,
0.0541347861,
0.0275926515,
-0.0442888141,
0.0222081356,
0.0898382813,
0.0114513291,
0.0357605107,
0.0198119581,
0.0556782596,
0.039513059,
-0.0167042855,
0.0040942179,
0.0022334538,
0.0463552587,
-0.0370743386,
0.0423145145,
0.0321518742,
-0.0283780433,
-0.0284164101,
-0.0423667468,
0.019161528,
-0.043698933,
-0.0101635568,
-0.0116752926,
0.0527196452,
0.0347994231,
-0.0629128888,
-0.0289359633,
0.0108748209,
-0.088250339,
0.0333942808,
-0.0243520346,
0.0543358065,
0.0735903159,
0.012417946,
0.0183687583,
0.0320277885,
-0.048564963,
-0.01979772,
0.0570070408,
-0.0260188524,
-0.0005990927,
0.045364432,
-0.0460387245,
-0.015203964,
0.0383170135,
-0.00164265,
0.0637140572,
-0.0416565835,
0.0542510636,
0.0172244981,
0.02561743,
0.0242667273,
-0.0226362608,
-0.0287455395,
-0.0182919931,
0.0516734347,
0.0080566406,
0.0427064113,
0.0320116319,
-0.0553247929,
0.0297002699,
-0.010390454,
-0.0075123231,
-0.0285234116,
0.0410558544,
-0.0512983166,
-0.0379553959,
0.0044957655,
-0.0772792399,
0.0083408635,
0.0450580269,
0.0134338923,
-0.075416483,
0.0859169587,
-0.0126559278,
0.0321656801,
-0.0100771179,
0.001923302,
0.052656509,
-0.0471297503,
0.0253207218,
-0.0159701724,
0.0269551352,
-0.0038116854,
0.042281758,
0.0011188755,
0.0136522865,
-0.1064774245,
0.0050893147,
-0.017768804,
-0.0045482991,
0.0194395911,
0.01887054,
0.0172259547,
-0.0096027348,
0.0235228781,
-0.0629239604,
-0.0000461498,
-0.0074965707,
-0.001890796,
0.003416887,
0.0152640864,
0.000071965,
-0.0285901669,
-0.0122623257,
-0.0266224835,
0.0403993391,
-0.0395049825,
-0.0013708271,
0.0053578652,
0.0159881804,
-0.0361984745,
0.0190862827,
0.0130792288,
-0.001013913,
0.0013797462,
0.0225127451,
-0.0177160092,
0.0307392068,
-0.013398869,
0.0187735576,
0.0353906155,
-0.0288590603,
0.0313008241,
0.0213155635,
0.0275154151,
0.0380445793,
0.0102009373,
-0.0379619598,
-0.0100251697,
0.0076159891,
-0.0471823178,
-0.0062503912,
-0.0207845699,
0.0052022608,
0.0223414283,
-0.0030862039,
-0.0134497304,
0.0278497078,
0.0275342297,
0.0290054027,
-0.076431483,
0.017918,
0.0038037037,
-0.0492801405,
0.0196684077,
0.0054288204,
-0.0262913555,
0.0023943274,
-0.0160828736,
-0.0143001331,
0.0541314445,
-0.0368651822,
-0.0275786184,
-0.0025856099,
0.0200383794,
0.0417270958,
-0.0492108725,
-0.0331385098,
0.0123193096,
0.022048844,
0.0355074741,
-0.0572935976,
-0.0245960802,
0.0252230186,
-0.0227131024,
-0.0210538059,
-0.0212907512,
0.0164774228,
-0.0058092414,
-0.0254878458,
-0.015801141,
-0.0064285584,
-0.031793844,
0.0316202864,
-0.0050462093,
-0.0260215234,
0.0245499741,
0.0143747199,
0.0201953296,
0.0054350365,
-0.0201803148,
-0.0156598575,
-0.0141428318,
0.0382937938,
0.0459710322,
-0.0348618887,
-0.0057502757,
-0.0104828002,
0.011532912,
0.0055615967,
0.0459701829,
0.0451121405,
-0.0344908983,
-0.0118494518,
0.0093085971,
0.0253652222,
-0.0241110791,
0.0400330387,
0.0231369995,
-0.007701146,
-0.007830265,
0.101036638,
-0.0269918218,
-0.0160871036,
-0.0092734257,
0.0239250716,
0.0581931062,
-0.011063464,
-0.0010648321,
-0.0668926165,
-0.0530578643,
0.0311892238,
0.0816902667,
-0.0273378938,
-0.0067047579,
-0.0064813802,
-0.1560872346,
0.0419328921,
0.0254353918,
-0.0328454971,
-0.0116858026,
-0.0272102933,
-0.0215156637,
-0.0201314334,
-0.0037091125,
0.034815304,
-0.0064423177,
0.007964259,
0.0462452509,
-0.0357544534,
-0.0511676632,
-0.0246102568,
-0.0420501865,
0.0998084173,
0.0739697516,
0.0428246781,
0.0329406448,
-0.0109724533,
-0.044022847,
-0.0097355805,
0.0032707984,
-0.0221292134,
0.0327506401,
-0.0301148687,
-0.0008952093,
-0.0123863053,
0.053316392,
0.0253517963,
0.0276210941,
-0.0150200594,
0.0390435085,
-0.0186179541,
0.0153916767,
-0.0175712816,
0.0539219677,
0.0601916425,
0.0596121363,
0.0191231873,
-0.0728341341,
-0.030936623,
-0.0126120634,
0.0088719362,
-0.103570506,
-0.0148073444,
-0.0127308173,
-0.027928466,
-0.0574347042,
-0.0753728971,
-0.0086517911,
-0.0051328884,
0.058925949,
-0.0188599862,
-0.031036105,
-0.0056313709,
0.0111374417,
-0.0167579893,
-0.0583398789,
-0.00594396,
0.0161386356,
-0.066388689,
0.0060431645,
0.0141808856,
-0.0695307329,
-0.0111595169,
0.0182619151,
-0.0520272888,
-0.0684479102,
-0.0113640558,
0.0637811944,
0.020015439,
0.0625444278,
0.0067610405,
-0.0305710901,
0.082092233,
0.0386938453,
-0.0080801854,
0.0089651383,
0.0945423394,
0.063705273,
0.0048153875,
0.0169353168,
-0.0542392656,
0.0423928536,
0.036272008,
0.0069826655,
0.0011762986,
-0.0340946242,
-0.0226801597,
0.0131012006,
0.0048850141,
-0.0653661713,
0.0328412093,
-0.0177028012,
-0.0151328892,
-0.0875728726,
0.0394774564,
-0.0584169589,
0.0325666107,
0.0282169301,
0.0180370621,
-0.0086873127,
-0.0101401247,
-0.0736405551,
0.0469494946,
-0.000258868,
0.0213120915,
0.0405586064,
0.0221307054,
0.0121107548,
-0.0088145891,
0.0100809066,
0.0018715252,
0.0163744148,
0.014016795,
-0.0225444026,
0.0290459991,
0.0334611312,
-0.0130886072,
-0.0080666821,
0.0205263216,
-0.0225275811,
0.0143698556,
-0.0444306135,
0.0592590235,
0.026951991,
0.0350040607,
0.0741917863,
-0.0230361056,
0.0274658594,
-0.0050291726,
0.0470898449,
-0.0360618196,
-0.0035749911,
-0.0046781395,
-0.0009788262,
-0.0049412549,
0.0205452647,
0.0380622111,
0.0284965038,
-0.0060756574,
-0.0581480227,
0.0532326214,
-0.0283216611,
-0.0122042829,
-0.0300520696,
-0.0151939308,
0.0161943827,
-0.0138730537,
-0.0430514514,
-0.0714410171,
0.0210653599,
0.0290384721,
0.0089402338,
-0.029286623,
0.0778472647,
-0.0309044663,
-0.0256307498,
0.0172418728,
-0.0273887105,
-0.0386206247,
0.0079895807,
-0.0232380591,
-0.0166221801,
-6.223412395e-33,
-0.0082459766,
0.0048856903,
-0.0119760679,
-0.0450772382,
-0.0181635488,
-0.0669825599,
-0.0250048414,
0.0062867138,
0.0160677806,
0.0162985604,
-0.0128590511,
-0.0322776139,
0.0153310578,
0.0424197502,
-0.000584366,
0.0266334433,
0.0766199976,
-0.0368727148,
-0.0519710518,
0.0257983077,
0.0688530952,
0.037170954,
0.0159119125,
-0.032625474,
-0.0055559492,
-0.02567463,
-0.0307428818,
-0.0057296506,
0.038542144,
0.0372439846,
0.0170151275,
0.036130622,
-0.0158216432,
-0.0690035969,
-0.0261708703,
0.0147288674,
-0.0570368245,
-0.0448614433,
-0.0163353961,
-0.0080177085,
-0.0158169959,
0.0033903711,
0.0083669592,
0.0097598871,
-0.0808479711,
-0.0252590626,
0.0208876133,
-0.0144638475,
0.012325299,
-0.0495021753,
-0.0484994166,
0.0009562717,
-0.0222237241,
-0.0525435135,
0.0439435951,
0.0988017097,
-0.048944883,
-0.0052631078,
-0.0338434465,
0.0655941144,
0.0125092044,
0.0140138762,
0.0601501726,
0.0515038371,
0.0011100316,
0.0139631666,
0.0266831275,
-0.0541965142,
-0.0230533518,
-0.0116431154,
0.0280535445,
0.0106061213,
0.0471138619,
0.1042861342,
0.0435935743,
-0.0283495802,
-0.0470877476,
0.0053909728,
0.0035306674,
0.006181411,
0.0134296026,
0.0247755479,
-0.0444762632,
-0.0101172049,
-0.0471002832,
-0.0861153603,
-0.0006808382,
-0.0407392569,
0.0448759459,
0.0142842587,
-0.0208994709,
-0.0367244892,
0.0679238364,
-0.0041447105,
0.0063330727,
-0.0204961486,
-0.0700668097,
0.0228906106,
0.0153068667,
-0.0263685323,
-0.0831865296,
-0.0039924183,
0.0770474598,
0.0867752358,
0.0080117937,
-0.0096996408,
0.0089735258,
0.0463763177,
-0.0470002443,
0.0031367079,
-0.0009732781,
0.0732448101,
0.0069957036,
-0.0148202004,
0.0281010531,
-0.0106797833,
-0.0013891587,
0.0517112277,
-0.043261636,
-0.0100204209,
0.0080710985,
-0.0028428619,
0.0019387413,
-0.0022630936,
-0.0474070348,
0.0278543364,
0.034405563,
-0.0089251697,
0.0215715729,
-0.051029563,
-0.0310085639,
-0.0072990954,
2.979e-7,
-0.0404700227,
0.0032201828,
0.0192070995,
-0.0230777115,
0.0140471822,
0.0825649574,
0.0029531776,
0.0059107048,
0.0215829927,
0.0375858992,
0.0186286792,
-0.0327283777,
0.0711494461,
0.0120426919,
-0.0933699012,
-0.0283523183,
-0.093196705,
0.032683108,
-0.0048503871,
-0.0144725163,
0.0682889521,
0.0319835842,
0.0160829313,
-0.0239857156,
0.0254012812,
0.0246402342,
0.0446266867,
-0.0081298677,
-0.0023234119,
-0.0578879081,
0.0371644199,
-0.0163344759,
-0.0249054991,
-0.0271541122,
-0.0435207747,
0.0008870199,
-0.0297707003,
0.0284507051,
-0.029563833,
-0.0962726846,
0.0047608283,
0.0345413014,
-0.0149174687,
0.0191490632,
0.0415351838,
-0.0564451255,
0.0168819502,
-0.0014271218,
-0.0464573465,
0.0122198835,
-0.0297889002,
-0.0370672718,
-0.0330930427,
-0.0236999169,
0.0389227532,
0.0667584315,
-0.013718511,
-0.0278688073,
0.01266714,
0.0023543406,
-0.0247573163,
-0.039178811,
-0.0233977418,
0.0216851775,
0.0250197686,
-0.0730625018,
-0.038087111,
2.225624295e-34,
0.0418585874,
-0.01731316,
0.0387289673,
-0.0353792906,
0.0049849502,
0.030620344,
0.0037210912,
-0.0071545905,
0.0718009025,
-0.0071167345,
-0.048963353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02235v1 | Towards a Holistic Framework for Multimodal Large Language Models in Three-dimensional Brain CT Report Generation | 2024-07-02T12:58:35 | 2024-07-02T12:58:35 | Cheng-Yi Li, Kao-Jung Chang, Cheng-Fu Yang, Hsin-Yu Wu, Wenting Chen, Hritik Bansal, Ling Chen, Yi-Ping Yang, Yu-Chun Chen, Shih-Pin Chen, Jiing-Feng Lirng, Kai-Wei Chang, Shih-Hwa Chiou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) have been given free rein to
explore exciting medical applications with a primary focus on radiology report
generation. Nevertheless, the preliminary success in 2D radiology captioning is
incompetent to reflect the real-world diagnostic challenge in the volumetric 3D
anatomy. To mitigate three crucial limitation aspects in the existing
literature, including (1) data complexity, (2) model capacity, and (3)
evaluation metric fidelity, we collected an 18,885 text-scan pairs 3D-BrainCT
dataset and applied clinical visual instruction tuning (CVIT) to train BrainGPT
models to generate radiology-adherent 3D brain CT reports. Statistically, our
BrainGPT scored BLEU-1 = 44.35, BLEU-4 = 20.38, METEOR = 30.13, ROUGE-L = 47.6,
and CIDEr-R = 211.77 during internal testing and demonstrated an accuracy of
0.91 in captioning midline shifts on the external validation CQ500 dataset. By
further inspecting the captioned report, we reported that the traditional
metrics appeared to measure only the surface text similarity and failed to
gauge the information density of the diagnostic purpose. To close this gap, we
proposed a novel Feature-Oriented Radiology Task Evaluation (FORTE) to estimate
the report's clinical relevance (lesion feature and landmarks). Notably, the
BrainGPT model scored an average FORTE F1-score of 0.71 (degree=0.661;
landmark=0.706; feature=0.693; impression=0.779). To demonstrate that BrainGPT
models possess objective readiness to generate human-like radiology reports, we
conducted a Turing test that enrolled 11 physician evaluators, and around 74%
of the BrainGPT-generated captions were indistinguishable from those written by
humans. Our work embodies a holistic framework that showcased the first-hand
experience of curating a 3D brain CT dataset, fine-tuning anatomy-sensible
language models, and proposing robust radiology evaluation metrics. | [
0.0477392599,
0.0559037402,
0.0263996329,
0.0043456582,
-0.0229227562,
0.0393419079,
0.0158104487,
0.0503829382,
-0.0343887992,
-0.0344330072,
-0.0456733666,
-0.0733756199,
0.0403737091,
0.0599978492,
0.0400160253,
-0.0994000807,
-0.0172848664,
-0.02128876,
-0.0049592312,
0.0041344734,
-0.0023704013,
0.0184479486,
-0.0233818498,
0.0359715857,
-0.0322955735,
-0.0126628689,
0.0167017654,
0.0216704756,
0.0210294835,
-0.0485577844,
-0.0406379327,
0.096625343,
0.0295813847,
0.0035702481,
0.0000022886,
-0.0411329679,
-0.0206859522,
0.0326296315,
0.0517214499,
0.0134417135,
0.0827436745,
-0.0669551045,
-0.0222314168,
-0.0354374573,
-0.0102506392,
-0.0131682819,
0.063039057,
0.1076637357,
0.0610946603,
0.0525759123,
-0.0307452902,
-0.0121604446,
0.0186748356,
-0.025952315,
0.0429948494,
-0.0071823327,
0.0106041003,
0.0851827115,
-0.0385057628,
0.0130723342,
-0.0207358543,
0.0390957929,
0.0183336735,
-0.0066091507,
-0.0075102868,
0.0685385913,
0.0155423461,
-0.0149863129,
-0.0231590644,
0.0742874965,
-0.0129602589,
0.0266385414,
-0.009969092,
-0.0049123974,
-0.0079360809,
-0.0043225219,
-0.0611478277,
0.0206787642,
0.000467487,
-0.0215850528,
-0.0261565559,
-0.0064870887,
-0.0033522362,
-0.0239762515,
-0.0158447567,
-0.0398174077,
0.0168106388,
0.0179237928,
-0.0047166571,
0.020162968,
-0.0546622649,
-0.0446669348,
0.0104168393,
0.012901146,
-0.0192758199,
-0.0117553994,
-0.0371164344,
-0.0226026457,
0.0428722277,
-0.0305618234,
0.0032920789,
-0.0128910225,
-0.0402273647,
0.0552974418,
-0.0350776762,
0.0680298731,
-0.0509202667,
0.0664859265,
-0.0391685292,
0.0123708965,
-0.0077771563,
-0.0114573855,
-0.030857563,
-0.0217612609,
0.0050727762,
-0.0428847969,
-0.0394035131,
-0.0107403146,
0.0262239426,
-0.0036423008,
0.0366188996,
0.0635829568,
-0.0592359863,
0.012360313,
-0.0226553287,
0.0447823964,
0.0128156077,
-0.0185891353,
-0.0316867642,
-0.0176169947,
0.005346694,
0.0657169595,
-0.0214661844,
-0.0030871481,
-0.0123398798,
0.069976382,
-0.0337614007,
-0.0093345512,
0.0467365868,
-0.0529114492,
-0.063850835,
-0.03289162,
0.0468892604,
-0.0544265397,
0.0062548309,
0.0142153008,
0.0298417863,
-0.0184255056,
-0.0094730593,
-0.0028192315,
0.0010086886,
0.044225499,
-0.0210997313,
-0.0148457019,
0.0541994832,
0.0191171337,
0.0263002496,
0.0070299883,
0.0683697611,
0.041677814,
-0.0403478816,
-0.016632542,
-0.0100619392,
0.0242274944,
0.0012824622,
-0.0104321595,
-0.0625484735,
-0.0152035598,
0.0216935351,
0.0976065323,
0.0275595263,
0.0840200558,
-0.023927182,
-0.0100938603,
0.0583915226,
0.0439923964,
0.0235853232,
0.0243242737,
0.0570394658,
0.0021010851,
-0.0276355706,
0.0036003843,
-0.0162129458,
0.0554680191,
0.0282287449,
0.0088228285,
0.0074518905,
0.0249330234,
-0.0093698883,
-0.0253020562,
-0.0291658491,
0.0092264721,
-0.0243075695,
-0.022217581,
0.0471170321,
-0.0180658977,
-0.0530830845,
0.0151689304,
0.0163072925,
-0.0308114234,
-0.0215983354,
-0.0371658057,
-0.0245862491,
0.0453961864,
0.0464284569,
0.0248947423,
-0.0624352433,
0.012824757,
0.0492476001,
0.071457386,
0.0623933449,
0.0371889919,
0.0139059229,
-0.0491543747,
-0.0558054782,
0.0359830111,
0.0056167012,
0.006706153,
-0.0050389417,
0.0025352261,
-0.0143321641,
-0.046661254,
-0.0448913351,
0.0386159755,
-0.0258970782,
-0.0006369759,
-0.0401015729,
0.0084812427,
0.0019440034,
-0.0191635378,
-0.0372940935,
-0.0095174722,
-0.0045537073,
0.01496235,
-0.0329993032,
0.0136139141,
-0.0651900619,
-0.0199477822,
0.0003843989,
-0.0330272727,
0.0010400402,
-0.0277467147,
-0.0046934816,
-0.0129420469,
-0.0362929255,
-0.0658156797,
-0.0192806032,
-0.0231265631,
0.0047780569,
0.0168413017,
0.0090055363,
-0.058444228,
0.0599969365,
-0.0226279851,
-0.0066570682,
0.0344352685,
-0.0250202995,
0.0076671541,
-0.0293510165,
-0.0483070388,
0.0493165888,
0.0218454506,
0.0042123124,
-0.0179310422,
0.0779748186,
-0.0266071148,
-0.0388519093,
-0.0718843639,
-0.0067242221,
0.0101443203,
-0.012343673,
0.059537068,
-0.0054272935,
-0.0150239691,
-0.0190174654,
-0.0205873717,
-0.0116135553,
0.0608530864,
-0.0064721825,
0.0523276925,
0.0096372915,
-0.0259309672,
-0.0151619604,
0.0068675335,
-0.020563446,
0.0334599875,
0.0556300431,
-0.0334081054,
-0.0171491727,
0.0591211878,
-0.0642193407,
-0.0101303644,
0.0086034918,
-0.0211664531,
0.0300715677,
-0.0222412497,
0.0032903182,
0.0544734932,
-0.0030337346,
0.0348740518,
0.0266475156,
-0.0178742465,
-0.0101271905,
-0.0033082326,
-0.0259972345,
-0.036655724,
-0.0022986145,
-0.0837822482,
0.0116722742,
0.0537252054,
0.0321161486,
0.0704282001,
-0.0403818488,
0.0119996481,
-0.0282780323,
-0.0203456488,
-0.0237429813,
0.0348850265,
-0.0168741066,
0.0289665051,
-0.0221693497,
-0.0321839079,
0.0748624504,
-0.0407848544,
0.006237756,
-0.0427110232,
0.0152495531,
-0.035681013,
0.0643994212,
0.013570236,
0.0558464751,
0.0099493722,
-0.0511432998,
-0.0299866404,
0.0220491793,
0.0338103548,
-0.0421738513,
0.0043004872,
-0.0367636755,
0.01053546,
-0.0178156123,
-0.0085862288,
0.0138388677,
-0.0057545956,
0.0195019096,
-0.003658531,
0.0125709241,
-0.0184827819,
-0.0621407218,
0.0652169883,
0.0468911976,
0.0223300923,
-0.0563872904,
-0.0287769437,
-0.0015812094,
0.0458419323,
0.0145007083,
0.0763423219,
-0.0284407977,
-0.0372261927,
0.0044839163,
0.0514146239,
-0.0389733613,
0.0521897152,
-0.0533395931,
0.0077099204,
-0.0101658953,
0.0499821082,
-0.0078406008,
0.0182361938,
0.0484421067,
-0.031321831,
-0.008095785,
0.1194897071,
0.0086475546,
-0.0492331348,
-0.0534097552,
0.0292930435,
0.0635661557,
-0.0250277817,
-0.0162080247,
-0.0336219743,
-0.0241517238,
-0.0345387794,
0.0172633901,
0.0025757377,
-0.0122539122,
-0.008662601,
-0.0067382935,
0.06716346,
0.0143090282,
-0.077505134,
-0.0493024774,
-0.0336375423,
-0.0012684573,
-0.0168711487,
-0.0122179957,
-0.0327002332,
-0.0264856443,
0.0007262384,
0.0340979546,
0.0086162128,
-0.0756660476,
0.0064340825,
-0.0363470167,
-0.0119584277,
0.069506526,
0.0410843678,
-0.0417038985,
-0.0210902244,
-0.0254411269,
0.067539148,
0.023272153,
-0.0124731334,
0.0853482857,
0.0039265314,
-0.0116363224,
-0.0435397103,
0.0260603931,
0.0100428192,
0.0188325457,
-0.0404319279,
0.0373411179,
-0.0559264906,
-0.0107813179,
-0.0542656519,
0.049905505,
0.0082282303,
0.0384605378,
0.0044464739,
-0.0175187252,
-0.0165755507,
0.0061426675,
0.0600542948,
-0.0176816229,
-0.067270644,
0.0148006883,
-0.0485657603,
-0.0448190421,
-0.0506253839,
0.0044661234,
0.0336745866,
0.0159635749,
0.0065085604,
-0.000947114,
-0.0195872355,
-0.0080141844,
-0.0593647398,
0.0521866195,
-0.0021566339,
-0.0141715715,
-0.0438191779,
-0.0032465744,
0.0441917926,
-0.0221935567,
0.0002979167,
0.0328708589,
-0.0726537704,
0.025376847,
-0.0433818325,
0.0179978069,
0.0133250887,
-0.0139959864,
0.0172495302,
-0.0310649294,
0.0479085706,
0.0536772273,
0.000108131,
0.0164032411,
-0.0158035345,
-0.0036627378,
-0.0276128389,
-0.0131069748,
-0.0137310866,
0.0254153162,
-0.0080638044,
0.0169791207,
0.0198014956,
-0.0251280908,
0.0178890489,
0.0325779319,
0.0421461053,
-0.0248293001,
0.0118294545,
-0.0226033609,
-0.0323117785,
-0.024857698,
-0.0003191705,
-0.0404103436,
0.0221078862,
0.035354495,
0.0014982247,
-0.0188446138,
0.0209455155,
-0.0122220311,
-0.0315443054,
-0.0740845725,
0.0134324487,
-0.0147771472,
-0.0510571823,
0.0396553725,
0.0045770025,
-0.0195218045,
-0.0166835766,
-0.0218771938,
-0.0131003857,
0.0097677009,
0.0671097785,
0.0252430532,
0.0067487885,
-0.00144928,
0.0672535226,
-0.0175861008,
-0.0550644435,
-0.0570112765,
0.0257352274,
0.0516023859,
0.0350989103,
0.0665100068,
-0.0459942818,
0.0157514084,
-0.0096552977,
0.0432781056,
0.0000447804,
-0.0146342246,
0.0610595234,
-0.0248363744,
0.0338297337,
-0.0407275334,
0.0657387227,
0.0231381096,
-0.0071850559,
0.0044565066,
-0.0701291487,
-0.0476001762,
-0.0146591254,
0.0216123834,
-0.0210031159,
-0.0224795323,
0.0226673186,
-0.025430439,
-0.0310994778,
-0.0084208017,
0.0125332149,
-0.0119086085,
-0.0171796698,
0.0757533535,
0.0690222159,
-0.0363214836,
-0.0288436376,
-0.0085649639,
0.0190846995,
-0.0169434547,
-0.0310945529,
0.0160439964,
-5.737092382e-33,
-0.0146791032,
-0.0519108139,
0.0505891182,
-0.0444768481,
-0.0328160264,
0.0299508236,
-0.0440168381,
0.0292317159,
0.0126874428,
0.0210215636,
0.0148481438,
-0.0512075871,
0.0175903663,
0.0335395411,
-0.0143815083,
0.0075099608,
0.0023311891,
-0.0333245061,
-0.0381076001,
0.0369376875,
-0.0168384835,
-0.0112220496,
0.0859018192,
-0.0838194042,
-0.026118217,
0.0049486007,
-0.0313088149,
-0.025080869,
-0.0084756576,
0.0465592295,
-0.0488496162,
-0.0042158496,
0.03826591,
-0.0466273092,
-0.0192893818,
-0.0006138998,
-0.0342853777,
-0.0181206502,
0.0211318079,
-0.0003351243,
-0.0581374764,
0.0265368689,
0.0351338647,
-0.0275069214,
-0.0014342762,
-0.022884747,
0.0518679991,
-0.0030762153,
0.0003632355,
0.0128502306,
-0.0434560291,
0.0396337137,
-0.0039692009,
-0.0401489474,
-0.0033395176,
0.0202094447,
-0.0117111029,
0.0516472943,
-0.027930649,
0.027895065,
0.0318523683,
0.0293845907,
0.0561058931,
-0.0084455442,
-0.0161481462,
0.0717261508,
0.0743447319,
-0.0308800768,
-0.0318746231,
-0.0053580953,
0.0238174517,
0.0626797304,
0.0351947136,
0.0407103896,
0.0269570556,
0.014056406,
-0.039648857,
0.0566228405,
-0.0913467854,
0.0404884629,
0.0423098169,
-0.0431458242,
-0.0399471782,
-0.0095552364,
-0.0222257506,
-0.0127218207,
-0.0235313158,
-0.0175795797,
0.0555179454,
-0.0035095965,
0.0025007061,
0.0148396408,
0.0462599769,
0.0588551909,
0.0060123354,
-0.0253606457,
-0.0256903619,
0.0868561938,
-0.0512289405,
-0.0279786903,
-0.0119557343,
-0.0124815227,
0.0304250512,
-0.009854448,
0.0337509401,
-0.0199875366,
-0.0028187446,
0.0072251563,
-0.0286770631,
-0.0002613306,
-0.0055419104,
-0.0321091451,
-0.0305735357,
0.0531279109,
0.0169862993,
-0.0173533093,
-0.0318247154,
0.0055877995,
-0.0256687105,
-0.0098992847,
-0.0408157371,
-0.0778291896,
-0.0169944819,
0.0135627463,
-0.0353394076,
0.0134057356,
-0.0294823777,
-0.0764114857,
0.0590954907,
-0.0489420146,
-0.0546972007,
0.0373997614,
2.85e-7,
0.0541056506,
0.0658456609,
0.012728842,
0.0137462951,
0.0042357477,
0.0194359031,
0.0060341489,
0.0277717803,
0.0199981146,
-0.0331901535,
0.0060725249,
0.0358722284,
-0.0128378971,
0.0227232091,
-0.0590123758,
-0.0107328212,
-0.0490847826,
-0.0095625715,
-0.0399901867,
-0.0064073708,
0.0901430622,
0.0127714463,
-0.057891503,
-0.0656575635,
0.0215756372,
0.0027230803,
0.0467057265,
-0.0621801838,
0.0013596636,
0.0312127098,
0.0353848189,
0.0322837569,
0.0015603121,
0.0547433048,
0.027090935,
-0.0523340255,
0.0298673566,
0.037933819,
-0.0300246235,
0.0219794922,
0.0334811173,
0.0113012008,
-0.0076827323,
-0.0413688831,
0.0394376516,
-0.03376415,
-0.0198349394,
-0.0104668643,
0.0240830258,
-0.0207842123,
0.0922808647,
-0.0764937401,
-0.0394904129,
0.0197941959,
0.0427189358,
0.0118367439,
-0.0306759663,
-0.0103434259,
-0.0041144886,
0.0110653089,
-0.0293730292,
-0.0238387473,
-0.0090669552,
-0.0554559007,
-0.0036643811,
-0.0340641253,
-0.019118173,
2.817924445e-34,
0.0206649285,
0.0030576095,
0.0346858203,
-0.0299422015,
0.0272298511,
0.0303193573,
0.0616896823,
-0.0101435604,
-0.0358899049,
-0.0688142329,
-0.0100579718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02233v1 | Synthetic Multimodal Question Generation | 2024-07-02T12:57:42 | 2024-07-02T12:57:42 | Ian Wu, Sravan Jayanthi, Vijay Viswanathan, Simon Rosenberg, Sina Pakazad, Tongshuang Wu, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multimodal Retrieval Augmented Generation (MMRAG) is a powerful approach to
question-answering over multimodal documents. A key challenge with evaluating
MMRAG is the paucity of high-quality datasets matching the question styles and
modalities of interest. In light of this, we propose SMMQG, a synthetic data
generation framework. SMMQG leverages interplay between a retriever, large
language model (LLM) and large multimodal model (LMM) to generate question and
answer pairs directly from multimodal documents, with the questions conforming
to specified styles and modalities. We use SMMQG to generate an MMRAG dataset
of 1024 questions over Wikipedia documents and evaluate state-of-the-art models
using it, revealing insights into model performance that are attainable only
through style- and modality-specific evaluation data. Next, we measure the
quality of data produced by SMMQG via a human study. We find that the quality
of our synthetic data is on par with the quality of the crowdsourced benchmark
MMQA and that downstream evaluation results using both datasets strongly
concur. | [
0.0566712953,
0.0602384768,
-0.009479057,
0.0262687076,
-0.0161604919,
-0.0084488308,
0.0277106389,
-0.0002318816,
-0.000777797,
-0.0620234385,
-0.0327302292,
-0.0551909581,
-0.0287251789,
0.0314392149,
0.067039296,
-0.0331031978,
-0.009546618,
-0.0138272829,
-0.0537740588,
-0.0027191658,
0.0374036133,
0.0207162071,
-0.022487266,
0.0373576954,
-0.0262486767,
-0.0116516259,
-0.0434862897,
0.0417097062,
0.0034799774,
-0.0272276551,
0.0448286235,
0.0369479842,
0.0424488857,
0.0015605724,
0.0000019469,
-0.0368335359,
0.0243737027,
-0.0010699475,
0.0277392659,
-0.0128914928,
0.0282438677,
0.0050338069,
0.0505523011,
0.0046979794,
-0.0459341444,
-0.0138389347,
0.0215234235,
0.0143006379,
0.0869464502,
0.0605234355,
-0.0195539985,
-0.0363202989,
0.0249426402,
0.008910398,
0.0643444508,
-0.0036523172,
-0.0295529682,
0.0311991964,
0.0349852741,
0.0211429056,
-0.0001112688,
0.0375310518,
0.0292986445,
-0.0238727592,
0.030673394,
0.0068146768,
-0.0251027104,
-0.0208175462,
-0.0057097869,
0.1165301278,
0.066210568,
0.0013389632,
0.0165409576,
0.0096848793,
0.0213381834,
0.0648141801,
-0.0606426969,
0.0401239358,
-0.0262013059,
-0.0419650562,
-0.0384972133,
-0.0114481524,
0.0115040736,
0.0010041591,
0.0107338559,
-0.0060512796,
0.0439230725,
-0.0000646825,
-0.03797023,
-0.011814666,
-0.0457253568,
-0.0316215493,
-0.0149145685,
0.0260048732,
-0.028384475,
0.0038701384,
-0.0344989449,
-0.0561936907,
0.0411338247,
-0.019876413,
0.0224674996,
0.0373062231,
-0.017512165,
0.023711428,
0.0088748103,
0.0120754018,
-0.0500516929,
0.0006159286,
-0.0613143146,
-0.0134423403,
-0.0457534976,
-0.0248738136,
-0.0383304358,
0.0033581799,
-0.0624011122,
-0.0251678452,
0.0005860078,
0.0360739194,
0.0268662721,
-0.0292533748,
0.0039082146,
0.0315489359,
-0.0443051271,
0.0048103924,
-0.0482524261,
0.0366506465,
-0.049144648,
0.0273521077,
0.0493270196,
-0.0429425202,
0.0321656801,
0.0384475254,
0.0232794806,
-0.0434834175,
0.004116918,
0.0550861023,
-0.0508104786,
-0.0005932211,
-0.0200810973,
-0.0743992552,
-0.0002542583,
-0.0377381258,
0.0512225777,
-0.0719724074,
0.0594612546,
0.028453052,
-0.0346920528,
0.0239240956,
-0.0027563919,
0.0331633203,
-0.00636735,
0.0389617942,
-0.0091985678,
0.0203600917,
0.0751647279,
0.0050465683,
0.0086482372,
0.0649663135,
0.0372662805,
0.0162852146,
0.0736912265,
0.0050074216,
0.0053522666,
0.0255353171,
0.0208716653,
0.0194899533,
0.0089257248,
0.0368462242,
0.0143639194,
0.0441194773,
0.0183977485,
0.0575212389,
-0.0176551025,
-0.0279918592,
0.0532862544,
-0.022667883,
0.0234924685,
0.007525675,
0.0556118153,
0.0057983748,
0.0219633356,
0.004038095,
0.0167896133,
0.0611387268,
-0.0219971649,
0.0149721103,
0.0707469806,
0.0386832319,
-0.0326378383,
0.0038104774,
0.0122547541,
0.0264155995,
-0.0154256085,
0.0248834733,
0.0108799087,
0.0187220741,
-0.0469693132,
0.0442029797,
-0.0138433473,
-0.0730279014,
0.0280205999,
-0.0210069828,
0.0342654772,
0.0407765917,
0.0632472709,
-0.0086740172,
-0.0208499432,
-0.0171399321,
0.0231166109,
0.0390876308,
0.0350661464,
-0.0317223109,
0.0233240128,
-0.0583357438,
-0.0170332789,
-0.0328158811,
-0.0159810912,
0.0038153296,
-0.0029167265,
0.009218459,
0.0301236622,
-0.0796293542,
0.0128141465,
0.0331566744,
-0.0188215282,
-0.0057008727,
0.0014894746,
0.0103752455,
-0.0089558791,
0.0305863712,
-0.023045212,
0.0332774408,
0.0178669821,
-0.0594745427,
-0.0085400967,
0.0328621902,
-0.0446512699,
-0.0548539124,
0.0279043373,
-0.0644380078,
-0.0004860241,
0.0279681887,
-0.0209200941,
-0.0360876806,
-0.0055732983,
-0.0541157275,
-0.020669423,
-0.0747137815,
-0.040040601,
0.0551111661,
0.0092341146,
-0.0362852439,
0.0456362367,
-0.0098510087,
0.004532631,
0.0274786428,
0.0110399211,
0.0316858403,
-0.0328245535,
-0.0089890594,
0.0371323824,
-0.0086463997,
0.0527481027,
0.026317535,
0.0003313311,
-0.0780863613,
-0.0250204559,
-0.1165605783,
0.0078170486,
-0.0135943424,
0.0015314913,
0.0413083881,
0.0168847349,
-0.0020952881,
0.0019460684,
-0.081959106,
0.0123150991,
0.0533445552,
0.0339642502,
0.0336860642,
0.0335335955,
0.0539775342,
-0.0159861464,
-0.0162326377,
-0.0043478073,
0.0708512962,
0.0170381684,
0.0487514138,
-0.0344096646,
-0.0288862232,
-0.0617773496,
-0.013992331,
-0.0093550291,
-0.0357097723,
0.0444844328,
-0.0556262918,
0.0722489879,
0.0085220784,
0.0458123907,
-0.0251825526,
0.001978847,
-0.0198717341,
-0.0323142968,
0.0097719487,
0.0072923466,
-0.0199892335,
0.0247737207,
-0.0560516119,
0.0243350789,
0.0184201691,
0.0133155053,
0.0038949461,
-0.0310207363,
0.0562017821,
0.0385739207,
-0.038303405,
-0.0506379046,
0.0204400774,
0.0039584115,
0.0569203272,
-0.0243505519,
0.0001660551,
0.0374664553,
-0.0098168561,
-0.0185131729,
-0.0139880739,
0.0406729728,
-0.0258997772,
0.0671866611,
-0.0021553261,
0.0430636331,
-0.0262746662,
0.0138426861,
-0.0605790578,
0.0119555164,
0.0567633696,
-0.0374428183,
0.0186851528,
-0.0426757485,
0.0038956874,
-0.0260998495,
-0.026060503,
-0.041184999,
-0.0716956928,
0.01927533,
-0.024973331,
-0.0059051206,
0.0118351104,
-0.0059907483,
-0.0014228839,
0.0286983419,
-0.0040343362,
-0.0161992293,
-0.017268762,
-0.0026654417,
0.1235893145,
0.0807437301,
0.0504650399,
-0.0261830278,
-0.0619763248,
0.0062155072,
0.0355233476,
0.0243389122,
0.0147506725,
-0.0158123486,
0.0052554836,
0.0125434166,
0.020484006,
-0.0044036517,
0.0090600662,
0.0793983415,
-0.0448804684,
-0.0070115449,
0.0393580236,
0.0298278816,
-0.0278252177,
-0.0264145676,
-0.0101810237,
0.0518307239,
0.0111808702,
0.0481183566,
-0.1023869514,
-0.0378416441,
-0.0256514437,
0.0345733613,
-0.0002063851,
-0.0245343801,
0.0089610927,
-0.1155336648,
0.0330485813,
-0.013909596,
-0.0627235249,
-0.0228917934,
-0.0204854887,
-0.0277304016,
0.032788597,
-0.0223647486,
0.0529711992,
0.0052713957,
0.0197777562,
0.0060780267,
0.0401353464,
-0.0397019908,
-0.0101653878,
-0.0496271215,
0.0167798083,
0.019700123,
0.0094933948,
-0.0069651189,
-0.0613009632,
-0.0012058469,
-0.020316245,
-0.0057222457,
0.0166527685,
0.0395498015,
-0.0045709815,
-0.0244992003,
-0.0561795942,
0.0487174131,
0.0055536116,
-0.006280716,
0.0157596208,
0.0367824249,
-0.0187294856,
-0.0031389159,
-0.0592372678,
0.0202833172,
0.0190421306,
0.049025733,
0.02792711,
-0.0453174151,
-0.0085124336,
-0.0167032517,
0.0207630657,
-0.079487443,
-0.0052819815,
0.0220814664,
0.0325869694,
0.0483248495,
-0.1169858128,
-0.0347930975,
0.0017060821,
0.039747294,
-0.019324977,
-0.0274468567,
-0.0431729816,
0.0130543355,
-0.0752343312,
0.03733382,
-0.0027218487,
-0.0052463943,
-0.031471096,
-0.0187827349,
0.007141938,
-0.073082149,
-0.0057101301,
0.0311314594,
-0.0766298026,
-0.0560422093,
-0.0370119922,
0.0786571428,
0.0094378795,
-0.0164249614,
0.0403631069,
-0.0486419089,
0.0028674579,
0.0690159127,
-0.0312986001,
-0.0195423122,
-0.0229899026,
0.0128283612,
-0.0143835312,
0.0074477619,
-0.0642923564,
-0.0216165222,
-0.0337711833,
0.0775303617,
0.034465149,
-0.037779063,
0.0138671109,
0.0262941625,
-0.0394188277,
-0.0273207072,
0.014146165,
-0.0341816694,
-0.0219499357,
-0.0143031217,
-0.0300337411,
-0.0491194911,
0.0255345553,
-0.0132451849,
-0.0317133404,
0.0197996553,
0.0092144199,
-0.0109885316,
0.0724968091,
-0.0335494764,
0.007121515,
0.020741066,
-0.0032444396,
0.0133146551,
0.0001617462,
-0.0220870078,
0.009796638,
-0.0176445656,
0.0503386632,
-0.0135590779,
0.1074319556,
0.0176120196,
-0.0329902247,
-0.0052659111,
0.0364102796,
-0.0300099161,
-0.0407188684,
-0.0171486437,
0.0302595291,
0.0476334356,
-0.0039488487,
0.0293917563,
0.0000520755,
-0.0192861818,
-0.0105908336,
0.0553706661,
0.0194001906,
-0.0218401439,
0.0372916795,
0.0250285417,
-0.0128680421,
-0.0092216944,
0.0715513378,
-0.0212727487,
0.0158846881,
-0.0174666122,
0.0020647594,
-0.0462039188,
-0.0202271119,
0.0369136669,
0.0256676879,
-0.0109298071,
-0.0054237605,
-0.0315227099,
-0.0509470664,
-0.0237864461,
0.03245271,
-0.0218882561,
0.0175886564,
0.0303777829,
0.0734201744,
0.0217880122,
-0.0199931376,
-0.0634873882,
0.0519870445,
-0.0693079755,
-0.0038447366,
0.0066463426,
-6.410605462e-33,
-0.0064119576,
-0.0365739353,
0.0303007923,
-0.0438560471,
-0.0370589867,
-0.033119075,
-0.0496713519,
0.0252000876,
0.0142628895,
-0.0119032972,
0.0113556283,
-0.0405070484,
-0.0162870381,
0.0373605192,
-0.0082857292,
-0.0051736166,
0.0083897421,
-0.0175254848,
-0.0576282851,
0.0220218785,
0.0360887088,
0.0178496968,
0.0138671352,
-0.0221696366,
0.0044401931,
-0.0582030863,
-0.0016708559,
0.0079432568,
0.0008620083,
0.0666833669,
-0.0224119164,
0.0263495818,
0.0306032728,
-0.0257148631,
0.009702622,
0.0197128039,
-0.0392044857,
0.0113729499,
-0.0114627266,
-0.0137613798,
-0.0928787291,
-0.0176275652,
0.0461298972,
-0.0358690396,
0.0341069214,
-0.0027133967,
0.0485333577,
0.004370139,
0.0102148764,
-0.0358904041,
-0.0223374162,
0.0019906976,
-0.0120884618,
-0.0330609232,
-0.0423188433,
0.0832753479,
0.0333531164,
0.0003764514,
-0.0362442397,
0.0395917557,
-0.0549190119,
0.0000875153,
0.0412214957,
0.0163692664,
0.0060820514,
0.058762718,
0.0148478858,
0.0114819165,
-0.0175617822,
0.0167133473,
0.0075279837,
0.0434555672,
0.0253899619,
0.1289174706,
0.0282649528,
0.0012253288,
-0.0382429734,
0.0725217313,
-0.0111503601,
0.0036986624,
0.0039962167,
-0.0253153369,
0.0176601764,
0.0036576141,
-0.0529081039,
0.0069986996,
-0.0514376834,
-0.0225909725,
0.0444761477,
-0.0015728193,
-0.0369346291,
-0.0161771011,
0.083985433,
-0.0135449702,
-0.0020018592,
-0.0032206594,
-0.0593708791,
0.0472898409,
-0.0112422742,
0.0112268887,
0.004199422,
0.0179072283,
0.0621500835,
0.0033066748,
0.0073223179,
0.0362575166,
-0.0076040714,
0.0254615229,
-0.0330546387,
0.013319226,
-0.0415987447,
0.0161438603,
-0.033177305,
-0.0109144412,
0.008131857,
0.0128262956,
-0.0544958189,
-0.0037998387,
-0.0021790594,
0.0187714584,
-0.0585755743,
-0.0865696222,
0.0086719794,
0.0286302418,
-0.0190209001,
0.0490156338,
-0.0517096333,
-0.0300934222,
0.0033698299,
-0.0424259529,
-0.0086682271,
0.0178537108,
2.636e-7,
0.0233132914,
-0.0007198754,
0.0051694671,
0.0337628238,
0.0197516866,
0.0339861624,
0.0027841637,
0.0281949025,
0.0233918112,
-0.0543712191,
-0.0124820052,
0.0236658957,
0.0346002467,
0.0298234709,
-0.0526768416,
-0.0120956069,
-0.0398947224,
0.0122498218,
-0.0399557985,
-0.0010342242,
0.0662061945,
0.0129946899,
-0.0592622608,
-0.0456512906,
0.0109007219,
-0.0401693061,
0.1078669131,
0.0174468793,
-0.0510886759,
0.0192225762,
0.0671766251,
0.006760003,
0.0154034654,
-0.0110366978,
-0.0133462334,
-0.02807937,
0.0460955091,
0.0214290582,
0.023254605,
-0.0711022988,
-0.0025328244,
0.0052927979,
0.0022197284,
-0.0684076995,
0.056103535,
-0.0003084924,
-0.0150550697,
-0.0233600922,
-0.0550599433,
-0.00980106,
-0.0047249333,
-0.0591967292,
-0.0448440872,
0.0381685272,
0.0161997695,
-0.0039422396,
0.0151513321,
-0.015798213,
-0.0382988155,
-0.0075991373,
-0.0561617464,
-0.0453929566,
-0.0335958004,
-0.0291735977,
-0.0183079652,
-0.03874854,
-0.02264647,
1.858907137e-34,
0.0262105465,
0.0191148724,
0.0057120696,
-0.0040276786,
0.0274649076,
-0.028296452,
-0.0217483677,
-0.0243890323,
0.0128060002,
-0.0890223458,
-0.0214252044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02211v1 | PromptIntern: Saving Inference Costs by Internalizing Recurrent Prompt during Large Language Model Fine-tuning | 2024-07-02T12:21:14 | 2024-07-02T12:21:14 | Jiaru Zou, Mengyu Zhou, Tao Li, Shi Han, Dongmei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have played a fundamental role in various
natural language processing tasks with powerful prompt techniques. However, in
real-world applications, there are often similar prompt components for repeated
queries, which causes significant computational burdens during inference.
Existing prompt compression and direct fine-tuning methods aim to tackle these
challenges, yet they frequently struggle to strike an optimal balance between
cost-efficiency and performance effectiveness, especially in complex tasks such
as NL2Code. In this paper, we propose a novel method namely PromptIntern to
internalize the prompt knowledge into model parameters via progressive
fine-tuning. Our method enables LLMs to emulate the human learning process for
a new task, where detailed templates and examples in a prompt are gradually
internalized and phased out progressively as the model grows accustomed to the
task. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our method reduces inference
tokens over 90%, speedups inference by 4.2 times, and saves 88.3% monetary
cost. | [
0.0529499575,
0.070778206,
-0.0114657041,
0.0330418982,
-0.0498896465,
0.032339979,
-0.0069008931,
0.0024742004,
0.0050452068,
-0.041424837,
-0.0132168457,
-0.0046237665,
0.0010872162,
0.0179659892,
0.0087949773,
-0.0278434753,
0.054590378,
-0.0503397696,
0.0094606942,
-0.0013018121,
-0.0348705426,
0.0195376314,
0.0022626645,
0.0400156192,
0.0054385215,
-0.033559937,
-0.0196359623,
0.0200733915,
-0.0343420245,
-0.031502068,
0.0151193095,
0.0530584715,
0.0159343965,
0.0262483079,
0.0000019262,
-0.0566801503,
-0.0240712427,
-0.0199504625,
-0.0717638284,
0.0131305708,
0.0522560477,
0.0002796974,
0.019956952,
0.0323834196,
-0.0266563147,
-0.020350825,
0.0594670549,
0.0498654842,
0.0557021014,
0.0489122644,
0.0007150247,
-0.0088473931,
-0.0153342318,
-0.023770066,
-0.0013047379,
-0.0451918095,
0.01812342,
-0.0755156279,
-0.0062853806,
0.0250299834,
-0.0130046941,
0.0393648669,
0.0351066925,
0.0192911346,
-0.0127247339,
0.0458330475,
-0.0241284259,
-0.0354825929,
-0.0328100473,
0.0379978977,
-0.0320877098,
-0.0188221596,
-0.003196728,
-0.0078631854,
0.020373432,
-0.0115359351,
-0.0269591659,
0.030482078,
-0.0229995064,
0.0149928173,
0.0194431599,
-0.0061851204,
0.0107938321,
0.0046596662,
-0.0380580388,
0.0615990274,
0.023211142,
-0.0018924383,
0.0143870674,
0.0002734408,
-0.0252206158,
-0.0596718974,
-0.0121524557,
0.0335580483,
-0.0675048605,
0.010240498,
-0.0535198078,
0.0028548168,
-0.000204139,
0.019212788,
0.0549653433,
0.0399634205,
-0.0155276647,
0.0561177768,
-0.0533899292,
0.0267372262,
0.0002988402,
0.0039994861,
-0.0318570398,
-0.0256723873,
-0.034296371,
-0.0148182986,
-0.0738552883,
0.0222595185,
-0.0280391686,
-0.0166450348,
-0.0012803734,
0.0409950353,
0.0245397016,
0.0105384821,
-0.0014091363,
0.0027011705,
-0.0312198382,
0.0025300479,
-0.0179824736,
0.0341942981,
-0.0532453991,
0.0047928821,
0.0003299369,
-0.0830699876,
-0.0346995443,
0.0144723784,
0.017915722,
-0.0252607521,
0.0008290759,
0.0487754531,
-0.0066381358,
-0.0321560502,
-0.0419172905,
-0.0398484915,
0.0056272727,
-0.0425372198,
-0.0081716524,
-0.0489830822,
0.0362890512,
0.0133382482,
-0.0041806502,
-0.0540359057,
-0.0038511569,
0.0295672975,
-0.0517408699,
0.0995665789,
-0.010996554,
0.008595163,
0.013210916,
0.005706077,
-0.0005115223,
0.0876814947,
-0.0014202129,
0.0337374136,
0.0296013281,
0.0045505096,
-0.0124108894,
0.0562708378,
0.0328644104,
-0.0082785375,
-0.03091795,
0.0101041384,
0.0587312877,
0.034422569,
0.0515833311,
0.0418276526,
-0.0140853086,
0.000680522,
0.035983175,
0.0641742349,
0.0189198907,
-0.0080104461,
0.062781021,
0.010409032,
-0.0038728986,
-0.004776523,
-0.0643872172,
0.0085137766,
-0.0432532504,
0.0008123208,
0.0301276129,
0.0314264484,
-0.0333814807,
-0.0301618148,
0.0005563524,
-0.0164386835,
-0.0035214846,
0.0163644142,
0.0051026829,
0.0167075861,
-0.0402609669,
0.0772228241,
0.023554178,
-0.0285697132,
-0.0171410348,
-0.0515459031,
0.0358364843,
0.0518728271,
0.0347704776,
0.0016054403,
-0.0037464637,
-0.0086279353,
0.0196797885,
0.0120540829,
0.0540765449,
-0.0245275423,
0.0318130329,
-0.0559249148,
-0.0287747476,
0.0078076227,
0.0092680827,
0.012452486,
0.049066335,
-0.0031393922,
0.0177017152,
0.0114662535,
-0.0220668521,
0.0471047983,
-0.0557465814,
-0.0542537905,
0.0244064443,
0.0183536932,
0.0199280009,
-0.0168110467,
0.0238547921,
0.0173943862,
0.0335724764,
-0.0418798476,
0.0041083577,
-0.0214867871,
-0.0446126871,
-0.069290936,
0.0196704138,
0.020392213,
-0.0052422537,
0.0040584127,
-0.0447651558,
-0.0257857703,
-0.0397781879,
-0.033250533,
0.0510976426,
-0.0257849786,
0.0068230615,
-0.012764723,
0.0253670029,
-0.0302271079,
0.0425374769,
-0.0192570332,
0.0198310465,
0.0617228709,
0.0083773062,
-0.0177646168,
-0.0301067047,
-0.0216783863,
0.0136834923,
-0.0027402306,
-0.012601723,
0.0110472571,
0.025419265,
-0.0392159112,
-0.0246042572,
-0.0948977098,
0.0091065764,
-0.0176870767,
-0.003618211,
0.0139832683,
0.0298549179,
-0.0426196977,
-0.0454135351,
-0.0264283139,
-0.0213041138,
-0.0107906675,
0.0607285798,
0.0208788998,
-0.010329118,
-0.0287187137,
-0.0041591986,
0.0002466458,
-0.0075623714,
0.0507562459,
-0.0188455507,
-0.0265372768,
-0.0833656639,
0.035029836,
0.0031693091,
0.0242602974,
0.0114095649,
-0.0157640018,
0.0073350077,
-0.0191679578,
0.0630546063,
0.0821547434,
0.0033380878,
0.0023073561,
0.0290106591,
-0.0080678873,
-0.0688019544,
0.022675328,
-0.0103118429,
-0.0692708567,
0.0000770708,
-0.0296182744,
0.015947327,
0.0781185701,
-0.0041595232,
-0.0002686381,
-0.0461253636,
0.0322401039,
0.0048253564,
-0.0256487411,
-0.0600588992,
-0.0201786216,
-0.0151576614,
0.053499449,
-0.016526036,
-0.062227875,
0.0795920119,
-0.0413805246,
0.0095714806,
-0.0280087404,
0.0093568796,
-0.0306565538,
0.0707517713,
0.0099526932,
0.0181970485,
0.0581831224,
-0.0564780496,
-0.0506358221,
0.0229968764,
-0.0013381988,
-0.0254405197,
0.0321325287,
-0.0205375701,
-0.0130249728,
-0.0087249838,
-0.0295589603,
-0.0623405688,
-0.0604810119,
-0.0584188625,
0.0207282864,
0.0048773061,
-0.0039050579,
-0.0061013303,
0.0070116827,
-0.0057786116,
0.046656929,
-0.0224297568,
-0.0012244286,
-0.0349081419,
0.0112395054,
0.0463441052,
0.0363942795,
-0.0008372937,
-0.0204509553,
0.0390010402,
0.0326112732,
0.0070674364,
0.037113294,
-0.0129839545,
0.0357933789,
0.0507860892,
-0.0343306325,
-0.0089764334,
0.0651100129,
0.0555738695,
-0.0652311221,
-0.0372075289,
0.123399429,
0.0348865129,
-0.0696253404,
-0.0112358686,
-0.0113987206,
0.0514490195,
0.0301601384,
0.0352403,
-0.0634875074,
-0.0762223005,
0.0459073782,
0.0278032888,
-0.0104158483,
-0.0453372896,
-0.0233988855,
-0.1560116112,
0.026639184,
0.0017714887,
-0.0194954127,
-0.012089652,
-0.0505352356,
-0.0010539605,
0.0104211615,
0.0043185861,
0.0301436465,
-0.0150026353,
0.0017571724,
0.0084006721,
-0.0085393526,
-0.0466306508,
0.0228311978,
-0.0360835865,
0.0483971126,
0.0578802489,
-0.0048469449,
0.0344295204,
-0.0165868849,
0.0421692729,
-0.0277785044,
0.0159990173,
-0.041231256,
0.0465687476,
-0.015224467,
-0.0004938812,
0.0079563297,
0.0622629039,
-0.0344731994,
-0.0069345497,
0.018270487,
0.0844205916,
-0.0010942515,
0.0052639619,
-0.011211196,
-0.0228200983,
0.0227439031,
0.1135907173,
0.0711655766,
-0.0363690108,
-0.0133974133,
-0.0368520766,
-0.0322717279,
-0.0204130802,
-0.0227925945,
0.0180488378,
0.0083619673,
-0.0002654762,
-0.0513124093,
-0.008978161,
0.0478439517,
0.0246654674,
0.001946157,
0.0186269991,
-0.0140661616,
0.0086474754,
-0.0783698037,
0.0252593663,
-0.0530047938,
0.0098320842,
-0.0612217821,
0.0159556698,
0.035040427,
0.0068298313,
-0.0246675666,
0.0372529626,
-0.0891082585,
-0.0612795241,
-0.0173629932,
0.0465169102,
0.0242889766,
0.0833158121,
-0.0373259634,
-0.0413762406,
0.0213694423,
0.0631686524,
-0.0641903505,
-0.0014785859,
0.0082529401,
0.0338742286,
-0.0059208511,
0.0610687099,
-0.0355123729,
-0.008102227,
0.0129881697,
0.0343577079,
0.0349730402,
-0.0812630504,
0.03488129,
0.0417991206,
0.0443914346,
-0.0181477126,
-0.0299888067,
-0.0092063565,
0.0145243425,
-0.0019251494,
-0.0435052291,
-0.0282464474,
0.0330183841,
-0.0035695848,
-0.007603907,
0.0006504668,
-0.017790528,
0.0188775174,
0.0447383001,
-0.043401558,
-0.0092996098,
0.0052114329,
0.0200673491,
0.0419256352,
-0.0190997813,
-0.0207832046,
0.0250732899,
0.0142283821,
0.0235031117,
-0.0528671443,
0.045094993,
0.0374774672,
0.0382520407,
-0.0679270998,
0.0249861274,
-0.0348882005,
-0.0896927193,
-0.0006044655,
0.02961394,
0.0274177063,
-0.0293418337,
-0.0092223631,
-0.017755691,
-0.0073909904,
-0.015191975,
0.0022650908,
0.0063448809,
-0.0213534441,
0.0510196872,
0.0191647559,
-0.0206268504,
0.0001287127,
0.0648435429,
-0.0198751558,
0.0570880771,
-0.0320295505,
-0.00035504,
-0.0322143473,
0.0072149797,
0.019016983,
0.0059487089,
-0.0153633291,
0.0268659331,
-0.0352852046,
-0.0512808375,
0.0024787437,
-0.0145981321,
-0.0027601095,
0.0017791037,
0.0644071549,
0.065748468,
0.0021852474,
-0.0333782211,
-0.0188350715,
0.0373910666,
0.0057342527,
-0.0533715859,
-0.0145435017,
-6.627204255e-33,
-0.035909988,
-0.0051172827,
0.0169029366,
-0.0359549411,
-0.0288732462,
0.0014273286,
-0.0422350988,
-0.0271440372,
-0.0119919991,
-0.0185950529,
-0.0429161303,
0.0038086206,
0.0246075671,
0.007060321,
0.0127289994,
-0.0274821296,
0.0561596788,
-0.017220322,
-0.0459652022,
0.0161877777,
0.0298787393,
0.0473594256,
0.0091464166,
0.0130620655,
0.0058209542,
0.0126784621,
0.0000951546,
0.0427574664,
0.0126993703,
0.0537401587,
-0.0299807843,
0.0167179275,
0.0279170815,
-0.0564146228,
-0.0240626708,
0.0716218352,
-0.0986719802,
-0.046031367,
0.0227003694,
-0.0172575563,
-0.055363372,
-0.0571399927,
0.0479591675,
-0.0102859112,
-0.0011877714,
0.0101410821,
0.0024997429,
-0.0361599252,
-0.0281874463,
-0.0189390574,
-0.04205117,
0.0078304587,
-0.0007817518,
-0.0366469286,
0.0264852885,
0.0528370515,
-0.0011749327,
0.0322885476,
-0.0241404697,
0.0105390167,
0.0216905754,
0.0827447325,
0.0330168866,
0.0237484779,
-0.0023475999,
0.0432360284,
0.0207610577,
-0.0293265898,
-0.0294620153,
0.0120075075,
0.0464681908,
0.0146319317,
0.0240738112,
0.0105738174,
0.0511215627,
-0.0234467778,
-0.0452113971,
0.0099082431,
0.028470438,
0.0555069856,
0.0253522471,
-0.0067889113,
-0.0098636216,
-0.0465533026,
-0.0740362108,
-0.0364520326,
-0.0476789325,
0.000238567,
0.0488760807,
0.0113958269,
-0.01791008,
-0.0354855917,
0.0610385872,
-0.0301906057,
0.0039975145,
0.0170936473,
0.02132928,
-0.0026176472,
-0.0026612759,
0.0545775592,
-0.0291607883,
-0.0217788611,
0.0120648947,
-0.0217648372,
0.0259349272,
0.0160600971,
0.0239541344,
0.0266539734,
-0.0827149525,
-0.0107248332,
-0.0367675014,
0.0132784797,
-0.0093964282,
0.0193461552,
0.0490498096,
0.0143375136,
0.0050880252,
0.0462063327,
0.0075494801,
-0.0358659402,
-0.0601154678,
-0.0076051881,
0.0288560055,
0.0241191555,
-0.0147539908,
-0.0045467792,
-0.032135129,
0.0192432962,
0.0187954381,
-0.0472204797,
-0.020695271,
0.0342093855,
2.687e-7,
0.0095190527,
0.0388721153,
0.0130805466,
0.0148960128,
0.014818822,
0.0259837322,
0.0141122239,
0.0081297094,
0.0084234998,
-0.0271745082,
-0.0036674703,
0.0256883241,
0.0342802741,
0.0163538959,
-0.1317561269,
0.0142612662,
-0.0613282993,
0.0290064979,
-0.0722189248,
-0.0085995179,
0.0585727878,
0.1196147427,
-0.0021073294,
-0.009531497,
0.0089962045,
-0.0350503847,
0.0194471423,
-0.0243144315,
0.0005722432,
0.0058617261,
0.0335330851,
0.011941703,
0.0243067667,
0.0199237484,
-0.004931062,
0.0125744846,
-0.0180908218,
0.071055375,
0.0217679087,
-0.0087374607,
0.0013150129,
-0.0186060518,
-0.0136119705,
-0.0513094887,
0.0901823118,
-0.0599593334,
-0.0139923589,
-0.0482213162,
0.0294648148,
-0.0319849998,
0.0083620641,
-0.0089653628,
-0.027286239,
0.0387658142,
0.0325703584,
0.0067189592,
-0.0179220438,
-0.1161869392,
-0.022323722,
-0.0175612159,
-0.036087513,
-0.0361212566,
-0.0468834043,
-0.0100673977,
0.0289534684,
-0.0862568319,
0.0164911598,
2.735937617e-34,
0.0339679979,
-0.0173885021,
0.0194684081,
0.0650758818,
0.0384115204,
-0.0252663493,
-0.012398446,
0.0348946378,
0.0339844041,
-0.1113792285,
-0.0374176055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02209v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02209v1 | Generative Monoculture in Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T12:17:07 | 2024-07-02T12:17:07 | Fan Wu, Emily Black, Varun Chandrasekaran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce {\em generative monoculture}, a behavior observed in large
language models (LLMs) characterized by a significant narrowing of model output
diversity relative to available training data for a given task: for example,
generating only positive book reviews for books with a mixed reception. While
in some cases, generative monoculture enhances performance (e.g., LLMs more
often produce efficient code), the dangers are exacerbated in others (e.g.,
LLMs refuse to share diverse opinions). As LLMs are increasingly used in
high-impact settings such as education and web search, careful maintenance of
LLM output diversity is essential to ensure a variety of facts and perspectives
are preserved over time. We experimentally demonstrate the prevalence of
generative monoculture through analysis of book review and code generation
tasks, and find that simple countermeasures such as altering sampling or
prompting strategies are insufficient to mitigate the behavior. Moreover, our
results suggest that the root causes of generative monoculture are likely
embedded within the LLM's alignment processes, suggesting a need for developing
fine-tuning paradigms that preserve or promote diversity. | [
0.0346037187,
0.063853927,
-0.0284632873,
0.0215789825,
-0.0368269086,
-0.0031781516,
0.030116668,
-0.0153467823,
-0.0058732755,
-0.0366394594,
-0.0385286063,
-0.0548981018,
0.0035069764,
0.0531247631,
0.0362656452,
-0.0261941198,
0.0571197569,
-0.0344192572,
-0.0221785903,
-0.0473418944,
0.01692532,
0.0231747851,
0.0263600796,
0.0390283167,
0.021381788,
-0.0504147187,
-0.0098335762,
-0.0056903977,
0.007528882,
0.0159701519,
0.0094206976,
0.0598725937,
-0.0036125709,
0.0438171551,
0.0000017272,
-0.0455720574,
-0.0139316097,
-0.0067205303,
0.0192229934,
0.0008639101,
0.0366134346,
0.0188870504,
-0.004626574,
0.0178912785,
-0.0396914706,
0.0220962297,
0.0325324163,
0.0352303162,
0.0292971712,
0.041427169,
0.0177951232,
-0.0031815844,
0.0094390521,
-0.017350195,
-0.0007443516,
0.0322664082,
0.0082805082,
0.0104057575,
-0.0009931577,
0.0529059581,
-0.0299477428,
0.0298729129,
0.0014174919,
-0.0327424966,
0.0421841666,
0.0538215041,
0.0027687079,
-0.006519598,
0.0144591602,
0.0649633557,
-0.000276648,
-0.0101066977,
0.0215776432,
-0.0143464357,
0.0233243741,
-0.0010189012,
-0.0482383668,
0.042927254,
-0.0203368459,
0.0183525775,
0.0184082929,
-0.0341307111,
0.0395778529,
-0.0067437282,
-0.0102802617,
0.0394768231,
0.0227288734,
-0.0429452732,
-0.0154321501,
0.0278282091,
0.0134621728,
-0.0462540016,
-0.0148168001,
0.0054139188,
-0.0260889214,
0.0198210161,
-0.0363582,
-0.0189307183,
0.0425246209,
-0.066298008,
0.028842466,
0.0266744923,
-0.0166520588,
0.0297967941,
0.0036189898,
0.003496608,
-0.0241010636,
-0.0144846505,
-0.0411068648,
0.0184299089,
-0.0378629602,
-0.0190941542,
0.0186806135,
0.0450459309,
-0.0011548599,
-0.0191882234,
-0.0351183638,
0.0391222835,
-0.0265697986,
-0.0071604615,
-0.0236816872,
0.0167427249,
-0.0295501575,
0.007862472,
-0.0236628056,
0.0622142218,
-0.0411459543,
-0.0050460128,
0.007220211,
-0.0290995073,
0.0013976628,
0.0166446865,
-0.0374400504,
-0.0391294397,
-0.0209252555,
0.0310405213,
-0.008938387,
0.0135992272,
-0.0173499305,
-0.0349196531,
-0.0404899158,
-0.058162719,
0.0082309395,
-0.0764016435,
0.0287048612,
0.0441672765,
-0.0023485499,
-0.0467916057,
-0.0031281295,
-0.0158280972,
-0.0259046648,
0.0368126594,
-0.0269356519,
0.0358556956,
0.0490791835,
0.0129141537,
0.0101796761,
0.1119996905,
0.0017139527,
-0.0102241617,
0.0185089894,
-0.006384043,
0.0271177832,
0.0233812314,
0.0044420133,
0.0223519057,
-0.017264653,
0.0082496107,
0.0042904802,
0.0121697392,
0.0712062716,
0.0625077486,
-0.0173329283,
-0.0111094434,
0.0691601187,
0.0135428617,
-0.0130027989,
0.0418194756,
0.0405401364,
-0.0256013162,
-0.0007214224,
0.0714524165,
-0.0110462196,
0.0314201638,
-0.013401527,
0.0161063634,
0.0438804813,
0.0505777523,
-0.0213867463,
-0.0542491637,
-0.0264641717,
0.0073438538,
-0.0091588292,
-0.0024891081,
0.0395603813,
-0.0060023675,
-0.0158117097,
0.0364380963,
0.0354408883,
-0.0382630266,
0.0322661437,
-0.0515326075,
0.0510818586,
0.0975137502,
0.0407822914,
-0.011850683,
-0.0372538157,
-0.0187687743,
-0.0251241364,
0.0762523264,
0.0841574147,
-0.0290498082,
-0.0170209482,
-0.0396112092,
-0.0488504022,
-0.0280516353,
-0.0010010643,
0.0291419625,
0.0283256974,
-0.0006573613,
-0.0029176946,
-0.000426787,
-0.0644889474,
0.0225050841,
-0.0464966893,
0.0144136511,
-0.0074225152,
-0.0312208477,
0.0162836071,
0.0113682505,
-0.0341178887,
-0.0006891114,
0.0121859098,
-0.0125443088,
-0.0446467064,
-0.0086247791,
-0.0773490593,
-0.0294545963,
0.0337002203,
-0.0317250937,
-0.0279235318,
0.0079113245,
-0.002142136,
-0.0311894082,
0.0181552991,
0.0048369928,
0.0289342273,
0.003158428,
0.0237079076,
-0.0106287654,
-0.0124501111,
-0.0716403723,
0.054843463,
-0.0077285883,
0.00723133,
-0.0160321966,
-0.0140053406,
0.0048833797,
-0.0256527383,
-0.0364771523,
0.011541375,
0.0090481602,
0.0278357677,
0.0481884256,
-0.0098668737,
-0.0440397859,
-0.0480882637,
-0.0922539383,
0.0078076236,
-0.0278836563,
0.0104557592,
0.0358714797,
-0.0026780088,
0.00897016,
0.026722908,
-0.0614820644,
0.0025167998,
0.0089196963,
0.0570879132,
0.0372989438,
0.007173242,
0.015045424,
-0.0487861782,
-0.0248496234,
-0.0199865401,
0.0323061384,
0.0092882421,
0.0389038511,
-0.1002800614,
0.0281069465,
-0.053972967,
-0.0121465586,
-0.0181881171,
-0.0010784782,
0.0375467576,
0.002039578,
0.1143179238,
0.0276183095,
0.017306501,
0.0133531047,
0.0691609755,
0.0356653295,
-0.0743984208,
0.0049472493,
-0.0413384214,
-0.0069124759,
-0.02889397,
-0.0409425795,
-0.014227516,
0.0537065975,
0.0162113979,
-0.0306164399,
-0.0498286225,
0.034007214,
-0.0356977545,
-0.0395080708,
-0.0103303697,
-0.0436134525,
-0.0115944892,
0.0104626035,
-0.0239265189,
-0.0641528741,
0.0531413257,
0.0151708676,
0.0184829142,
-0.0484318025,
0.0027989824,
-0.0398216322,
0.0332555808,
-0.0194033254,
0.0267038047,
0.0338808447,
0.0035672325,
-0.0820558742,
0.0255504884,
0.0054847072,
-0.0259246882,
0.1025937945,
-0.017020857,
0.002263366,
-0.0069664456,
-0.04965939,
-0.0614213422,
0.0002261279,
0.0209561903,
-0.0196709931,
0.084322989,
0.0039003268,
-0.0138211474,
-0.0137084546,
0.031191932,
0.0016788016,
-0.0376272835,
-0.0347151347,
0.0191014912,
0.0350093432,
0.0796487778,
-0.0190445203,
0.031942185,
-0.0728987753,
-0.0183790643,
0.0326815359,
-0.0020192021,
0.0168116074,
-0.0091077639,
-0.0556648374,
0.0360974036,
-0.0368919037,
-0.0446156822,
0.0078515792,
0.0489560626,
-0.0220670477,
-0.0253776144,
0.1135164201,
0.0152762225,
-0.0565649122,
-0.0047577894,
-0.0359132774,
0.0724670663,
0.0309051368,
0.0216549914,
-0.0452645048,
0.0293702688,
-0.0204691738,
0.0160988346,
-0.0021518383,
-0.0043637417,
-0.0126927616,
-0.1173261106,
-0.0087684356,
0.0143681737,
-0.0401898772,
-0.0169162042,
-0.0151576921,
-0.0031686698,
-0.0150357094,
0.0074552866,
0.0089532332,
-0.0307522975,
0.030667264,
0.0346308276,
-0.0026190337,
-0.0243314095,
-0.0138778016,
-0.0416135713,
0.0778230876,
0.0822798386,
0.0033026291,
0.0028235193,
-0.0002575079,
0.0483578146,
0.026563134,
0.0004198632,
-0.0100332983,
0.0625381768,
-0.0058163241,
0.0067036105,
-0.0119542796,
-0.0173642002,
-0.0333257392,
0.0227438509,
0.0129988622,
0.0719512478,
0.0046446342,
-0.0569696166,
-0.0652308017,
0.0018535419,
0.0212905388,
0.096047692,
0.0112144575,
-0.0734377503,
-0.0199757721,
-0.0369372852,
-0.0162774343,
-0.0378825739,
-0.0208900198,
0.0141694192,
0.0008392478,
-0.0306378864,
-0.0737607107,
-0.0474635996,
-0.0144310677,
0.0158379544,
0.0351524428,
0.0169511233,
0.0177839175,
-0.0170066021,
0.0027782875,
0.0010281485,
-0.0236687176,
-0.0274705123,
-0.0532504506,
-0.0563632958,
0.0318817236,
-0.0176493973,
0.0014544334,
0.0046270369,
-0.0693197921,
-0.087491855,
0.0193085019,
0.0462177135,
0.0270494204,
0.0483122841,
0.0387816392,
-0.0087081613,
0.0200305842,
0.073410213,
0.0333283581,
0.0296074487,
0.0214489829,
0.0071405647,
-0.0109906811,
0.0343601815,
-0.0451458357,
0.0095894085,
0.0351808108,
0.0172416214,
-0.0222405717,
-0.0287470277,
-0.0045970096,
-0.0247825142,
-0.0008515419,
-0.0351122059,
0.0371577926,
-0.0599177182,
-0.0223320927,
-0.0185397342,
-0.0292778369,
-0.0172074866,
-0.0113918828,
0.031704817,
-0.0124448035,
-0.0087085357,
0.0490706079,
0.0240576547,
0.0874216035,
-0.0668196008,
-0.0113304993,
-0.0102452245,
-0.0329655185,
0.0491833463,
-0.0034553788,
-0.0283024758,
0.0480328351,
0.002503701,
0.0097977361,
0.0072940285,
0.0458321199,
0.0269629676,
0.0127997175,
0.0143259177,
-0.0079459166,
-0.0642879605,
-0.0317778513,
-0.0164644346,
0.0085732685,
0.0336610638,
0.0155103095,
0.0896505117,
-0.0078554275,
-0.0048946724,
-0.0273197871,
0.0161783341,
0.0123649156,
-0.0050924076,
-0.0038955484,
0.0200902112,
-0.0264522452,
-0.0303533804,
0.0984570086,
-0.0331378654,
0.0144736618,
0.0053362395,
-0.0245261323,
-0.032060679,
-0.0241331384,
0.0084267529,
0.0071844622,
-0.007316269,
0.0057156659,
-0.065197967,
-0.0349732786,
0.0247826781,
0.0489644259,
0.0326726437,
-0.0247302186,
0.0418835357,
0.0885934085,
-0.0268146917,
-0.0087756338,
-0.0512732975,
0.0436114743,
0.0053420048,
-0.0034413354,
-0.0242635012,
-6.257973398e-33,
-0.0187581982,
-0.0235912874,
0.0007882609,
-0.0274093375,
-0.026205685,
-0.0364665315,
-0.0217198506,
0.0495340489,
-0.0172030926,
-0.0005548639,
-0.0002099261,
0.0076732808,
-0.0068489942,
0.0027082448,
0.0619885363,
-0.0058044135,
0.0806921571,
-0.0017861169,
-0.0345607288,
0.0526062176,
0.0449880362,
0.0110788969,
0.0131765362,
-0.0592065081,
0.0292341541,
-0.0233024955,
0.007481277,
-0.0290295742,
-0.0314036123,
0.0726084039,
-0.0329828598,
0.0788368881,
0.0274248961,
-0.0549028069,
-0.0333421193,
-0.0046543023,
-0.0267700236,
-0.0425001979,
0.0300478917,
-0.0229999665,
-0.017514376,
-0.0326841436,
0.0674971491,
0.0069687432,
-0.0521222875,
-0.0124055604,
0.0607475676,
-0.0075953812,
0.001273724,
-0.0365635008,
-0.1016048267,
0.0124710165,
0.0095574688,
0.0102812871,
-0.04390743,
-0.0041252328,
0.0300381929,
0.0321171544,
-0.0196636692,
0.0352450088,
0.0569229387,
0.055661507,
0.0800528675,
0.0352466144,
-0.0042220522,
0.0600181781,
0.0186027233,
0.0680977181,
-0.0034831369,
-0.0584228002,
0.0173997413,
-0.0124124,
0.013991395,
0.0517673269,
0.0238905065,
-0.0135216983,
-0.0416337512,
0.0141023556,
0.0227591153,
-0.0507145189,
0.0557937138,
0.0003369913,
-0.0414137952,
-0.0261333454,
-0.0128835356,
-0.0241365172,
-0.0112031735,
-0.0443954021,
0.0179853663,
0.0267354753,
-0.0235729069,
-0.0152883371,
0.0384793095,
-0.0354984105,
-0.0710496008,
0.0409924425,
-0.0683765188,
-0.0056673847,
0.0104148146,
-0.0031858466,
-0.0732660592,
-0.0047931466,
-0.0331939012,
0.0192828458,
0.0006362002,
0.0392949544,
0.0599889793,
0.0164542347,
-0.1023652703,
-0.0006922009,
-0.0424842909,
0.0187467765,
0.0168162156,
-0.00432391,
0.0407325625,
0.0003264599,
0.0104442164,
0.0425554551,
0.0553494394,
-0.0038522386,
-0.0815837234,
-0.004388494,
-0.0216639023,
-0.0042908587,
-0.0184952877,
-0.0109211942,
-0.0413278043,
0.047022365,
0.0299708266,
-0.0704018176,
-0.0422379896,
-0.0093793934,
2.499e-7,
0.0299526993,
0.0605014153,
-0.0075940746,
0.0060139759,
0.054923486,
0.0312046781,
-0.0014123332,
0.0455581471,
-0.0086288936,
-0.0232931692,
-0.0288558714,
0.0405558795,
-0.010768964,
0.0486719422,
-0.0888144448,
0.0155397095,
-0.05764677,
0.0473591611,
-0.0518964976,
0.0151019748,
0.0326709189,
0.0697140545,
0.0100247171,
0.0097237825,
-0.003369685,
-0.0017241769,
0.0874057263,
0.0037212113,
-0.0093740448,
0.059141852,
0.0255628079,
-0.0060550557,
-0.0113869943,
-0.034164872,
0.0042781318,
-0.0088790143,
0.0008504671,
0.0573862195,
-0.0018786141,
-0.0155615797,
0.0353545174,
0.001587956,
-0.0047736303,
-0.0588983372,
0.0504196249,
-0.0167928934,
0.0039183348,
-0.0829080045,
0.0111592021,
-0.0132956868,
0.0236176513,
-0.0254254974,
-0.0238466635,
0.0061054407,
-0.0163051691,
0.0060900534,
-0.0276848376,
-0.0723640248,
-0.0298472308,
0.0080995727,
-0.0605583638,
-0.1029257774,
-0.0216493756,
0.008621023,
0.0118627632,
-0.045143649,
0.0076057841,
2.483534873e-34,
0.0527558289,
-0.0092269359,
0.0129708974,
0.000529516,
-0.0136864157,
-0.0245200936,
-0.0455498323,
0.004234436,
0.0228551645,
-0.0318370797,
-0.0448074304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02208v1 | How to Learn in a Noisy World? Self-Correcting the Real-World Data Noise on Machine Translation | 2024-07-02T12:15:15 | 2024-07-02T12:15:15 | Yan Meng, Di Wu, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The massive amounts of web-mined parallel data contain large amounts of
noise. Semantic misalignment, as the primary source of the noise, poses a
challenge for training machine translation systems. In this paper, we first
study the impact of real-world hard-to-detect misalignment noise by proposing a
process to simulate the realistic misalignment controlled by semantic
similarity. After quantitatively analyzing the impact of simulated misalignment
on machine translation, we show the limited effectiveness of widely used
pre-filters to improve the translation performance, underscoring the necessity
of more fine-grained ways to handle data noise. By observing the increasing
reliability of the model's self-knowledge for distinguishing misaligned and
clean data at the token-level, we propose a self-correction approach which
leverages the model's prediction distribution to revise the training
supervision from the ground-truth data over training time. Through
comprehensive experiments, we show that our self-correction method not only
improves translation performance in the presence of simulated misalignment
noise but also proves effective for real-world noisy web-mined datasets across
eight translation tasks. | [
0.0325959772,
0.0365075581,
-0.0023591956,
0.0323412977,
-0.0021333713,
0.0281859189,
0.0064005586,
-0.0095768273,
-0.0339701548,
-0.0359277055,
-0.0476912558,
-0.0291491766,
0.0353235267,
-0.0469506532,
0.0357748829,
-0.0249104463,
0.0398392454,
-0.0143818008,
0.0027704865,
-0.0117096864,
-0.0072501982,
0.0228796825,
-0.0103325648,
-0.0010928295,
-0.0305115152,
-0.0295334831,
0.0131589472,
0.0823846683,
0.0380170271,
-0.0031829108,
0.0154381273,
0.0362648293,
-0.0079758307,
0.0912055746,
0.0000020415,
-0.0266088303,
-0.0520427153,
-0.0062262188,
0.0164699592,
-0.0012903661,
0.0208628774,
-0.0598093756,
-0.0509456992,
0.0254549738,
-0.0168736037,
-0.017805066,
0.0520338565,
0.0182258338,
0.0509633757,
0.0725975782,
-0.0249104649,
-0.0051933778,
-0.0248208158,
-0.0235745609,
-0.0133089274,
-0.0366054811,
-0.0029182832,
0.0209836159,
-0.0960198864,
0.0068548149,
-0.0160861257,
0.0339268036,
-0.0236291643,
0.0090837833,
0.013849834,
-0.0157370605,
-0.0419520363,
-0.0359612331,
-0.0151281767,
0.0686673224,
-0.0744987652,
-0.0485440195,
-0.0047620176,
-0.0257941596,
0.0034506684,
-0.0014478178,
-0.0194231737,
0.0441908091,
0.0056620087,
0.0278948899,
0.0012821138,
0.0358703658,
0.0356137007,
-0.0188507438,
-0.0693946481,
0.007451083,
0.0071481159,
-0.0484637953,
-0.0152026778,
0.0201234519,
0.0086415615,
-0.0345048271,
0.0424075797,
-0.0022157826,
-0.0294476878,
0.0122501533,
-0.0704490244,
-0.07733915,
0.0095382901,
-0.0777871907,
-0.0003706681,
0.0588713512,
-0.0233380776,
0.0469302423,
-0.0265770424,
0.0316430442,
-0.0125876227,
0.0420773141,
-0.0712600276,
-0.0154084833,
0.0095539317,
0.0351146124,
-0.0317037031,
-0.0165671613,
-0.0431635864,
-0.0072207148,
-0.035485249,
0.0314556397,
-0.0252087414,
0.0362357199,
0.0072737411,
-0.0287765618,
-0.099499248,
-0.0221252237,
-0.0037393079,
0.0269637927,
0.0257409122,
-0.0142866839,
0.011536086,
-0.0594840012,
-0.0314692445,
0.0060440749,
0.012621426,
-0.0313166827,
-0.0141953453,
0.1007001996,
-0.0003827049,
0.0049783904,
-0.0178826433,
-0.0127828112,
-0.0175596233,
-0.0228205845,
0.0061926572,
-0.023143569,
0.0443836078,
0.0049733026,
0.0261754747,
-0.0392399691,
0.0060214023,
0.0000932777,
-0.0265070181,
0.1138697043,
-0.0274251513,
0.0049062422,
0.0171670578,
-0.0315243527,
0.0193481687,
0.0697712079,
0.0481569953,
0.0048075714,
0.0521346554,
-0.0055159163,
-0.0283458531,
0.0341893919,
0.0239303298,
-0.0080150152,
-0.0459232964,
0.0096709495,
0.0380887687,
0.0557461567,
0.0460978523,
0.0432917811,
-0.0107404701,
0.0188284349,
0.0771944821,
0.0198127087,
-0.001924232,
0.0267668944,
0.0189830456,
-0.009823353,
-0.0206567794,
0.0331046395,
-0.0509030111,
0.0156574026,
-0.0145781217,
0.0025490965,
0.0346311964,
0.0576134101,
-0.0286927354,
-0.0382888094,
-0.0078032613,
-0.0159231126,
-0.0009590201,
-0.0224973336,
0.0326101147,
0.0490966402,
-0.0432155021,
0.0151920598,
0.0063285707,
-0.0539337695,
0.006558849,
-0.0085522877,
-0.0263481755,
0.0681207702,
0.0587866381,
-0.0160202943,
-0.0780909732,
-0.0289450623,
0.0049895528,
0.0282951966,
0.0693344697,
0.0207298677,
-0.0047346749,
-0.0534281246,
-0.069558166,
0.0445336513,
-0.0136122759,
-0.0194585826,
0.0071015162,
0.005534342,
0.0403047316,
-0.0469265915,
-0.0791414306,
0.0501492284,
0.0106468117,
-0.0202811211,
0.0173512436,
0.0551554635,
0.0266754702,
0.0171889886,
-0.0026818942,
-0.0118050929,
0.0327991992,
-0.0064058821,
0.0064511457,
0.0469843671,
-0.0413028412,
-0.0257837381,
0.0753292739,
-0.0381237268,
-0.0281148385,
0.0235734358,
-0.0412220545,
-0.0495037436,
-0.011431179,
-0.0030611837,
0.0143132862,
-0.0342402011,
0.0652237758,
0.0206171367,
0.0250799712,
-0.0377963409,
0.0113341538,
0.0206195507,
-0.0006069256,
-0.0277191736,
0.0083276015,
0.0224222224,
-0.0308474917,
-0.016265668,
0.0148430178,
0.0011675212,
0.027525017,
0.0397096239,
-0.0005200366,
-0.0508787073,
-0.0130817583,
-0.0340308324,
0.0124774929,
-0.0239424985,
0.0280447304,
0.062410675,
0.019091798,
0.0003496362,
-0.0464323685,
-0.0227691364,
0.020268701,
0.0009741031,
-0.0090776486,
0.0502840094,
-0.0183368251,
0.0105013112,
-0.0223345049,
0.0094740065,
0.0013012736,
0.0182452556,
0.0461855121,
-0.0107526369,
-0.0815675855,
0.0569309108,
-0.0432743318,
0.0323506854,
0.0219898038,
-0.0616595522,
-0.0108281244,
-0.0069229426,
0.0369764939,
0.0244889185,
-0.0068675866,
0.0007536151,
0.0409630053,
-0.0069290623,
-0.0479315184,
0.0111649791,
-0.0161046032,
-0.0031900201,
-0.0415116809,
0.0012633721,
-0.0112763038,
0.0274279527,
-0.01445622,
-0.0034653656,
-0.035904415,
-0.0037458749,
-0.0117102927,
-0.0111023514,
-0.0214583501,
0.0205904562,
0.0085679833,
0.0339850932,
-0.0244911518,
-0.0436284207,
0.0703474954,
-0.0386883654,
0.0045803841,
-0.0468419045,
0.0063986275,
0.0092333537,
0.0257204734,
-0.0299887564,
0.0335705616,
-0.0276244301,
-0.0042183483,
-0.08502426,
0.0012405936,
0.0485545918,
-0.0296229105,
0.0083739394,
-0.0617885441,
0.0135167371,
-0.0280723311,
-0.0221919175,
-0.0516593754,
-0.0193229225,
0.0119244093,
-0.0345462412,
0.0142778121,
-0.0242202617,
-0.0196528621,
0.0204631072,
-0.0066298102,
0.0631708354,
-0.0055173729,
-0.0166662019,
-0.0364102982,
0.0232190676,
0.0171725377,
-0.0046210391,
0.0366148762,
-0.0434424952,
-0.0044559622,
0.024003474,
0.0308804773,
-0.0361849442,
-0.0386679061,
-0.0388118587,
0.0494054779,
-0.0047491868,
0.0073352642,
-0.0032507298,
0.0343705229,
-0.0428492911,
-0.0280399956,
0.1141354591,
0.0114730112,
-0.013994392,
-0.0189702511,
0.0107223978,
-0.0030104127,
0.0098854899,
0.0179382898,
-0.0358130038,
-0.0166229159,
0.0214342531,
0.0187325291,
0.0426105,
0.0311838184,
-0.004495014,
-0.0913902596,
0.0288424473,
0.0522567891,
-0.0772662759,
-0.0790783912,
0.00790169,
-0.0132431816,
-0.0426501371,
0.0747752935,
-0.006275286,
0.0039036856,
0.0007426689,
0.0310589466,
0.0215521418,
-0.0684919581,
-0.0542607531,
-0.0704837516,
0.0711001754,
0.0583511665,
0.0337662287,
-0.0008790367,
-0.05916363,
0.0507856384,
-0.0039566536,
-0.009831693,
-0.0050743157,
0.0261355173,
-0.0140481237,
-0.0449809656,
0.0224710777,
-0.0196230225,
-0.0639457479,
0.0195076261,
-0.0204117503,
0.0538030043,
-0.0328713693,
0.0346392281,
0.0269833878,
-0.018144235,
0.0246851221,
0.0704365671,
0.0042669661,
-0.0209181327,
-0.0102790166,
-0.0285589341,
0.0356700458,
-0.0284384508,
0.0327346325,
0.005729591,
-0.0488805696,
-0.0657332093,
-0.0959842205,
-0.0717990696,
0.0054522636,
0.042900376,
0.0256077833,
0.0015388804,
0.0330453254,
0.0006842374,
-0.0410964675,
-0.0024689652,
-0.0533894412,
0.0199413132,
-0.0160930771,
0.0181762837,
0.0064951563,
-0.0170124974,
0.0071411971,
0.0166828502,
-0.1104480252,
-0.0582108796,
0.0003432863,
0.0482313074,
0.0161917433,
0.0800751224,
-0.0406049937,
-0.015201726,
0.0090885246,
0.0471667051,
-0.0813487694,
-0.0110077215,
0.0504923239,
-0.0070181312,
-0.0093059642,
0.0468411446,
-0.0168720074,
-0.0025177633,
0.0280460007,
0.0299781803,
-0.0277600642,
-0.0722647607,
0.0517929718,
0.0114607234,
0.0748069733,
-0.0283271968,
-0.0205742903,
-0.0342444889,
0.040160276,
-0.0201424509,
-0.0389328972,
-0.041701518,
-0.0104013141,
0.0331168398,
-0.0206987895,
0.0144619411,
0.0325489379,
-0.0302179754,
-0.0168269332,
-0.0082217827,
-0.0621924624,
-0.0681184903,
0.0353396274,
0.000238807,
0.0313418582,
0.0144913336,
0.0173589755,
0.0397088379,
-0.0004959839,
-0.0059243003,
0.0070598507,
0.0352195427,
0.0287874006,
-0.0022693381,
0.0281263683,
-0.0387894399,
-0.018738497,
-0.0389336087,
-0.0083705829,
0.0676702037,
-0.0268072803,
0.0997361541,
-0.0033352019,
-0.010102273,
0.0053760908,
0.0305453725,
0.0103281047,
0.0366934389,
-0.003714039,
-0.0147636179,
-0.01823215,
0.0084709963,
0.0697508007,
-0.049469173,
0.0125172641,
-0.0053020413,
-0.0333522931,
-0.0257697012,
-0.0143709332,
0.0112646362,
-0.0123092476,
-0.0376476906,
-0.0190120749,
-0.0006224044,
-0.0801301822,
-0.025848059,
0.0399814323,
-0.0114354398,
-0.0032165498,
0.0349551141,
0.093960233,
-0.0481412038,
0.0389989205,
-0.0296963267,
-0.0174556952,
0.0530424193,
-0.0132290926,
-0.0410687849,
-6.353652026e-33,
-0.0255549997,
-0.0201681703,
-0.0019880917,
-0.0495531745,
0.0026165901,
-0.0410582758,
-0.0053329561,
-0.0257519949,
0.0109835872,
0.0328771174,
-0.0001079252,
0.0460173339,
0.0448936857,
0.0102978395,
0.0097534265,
0.0193338599,
0.1062955111,
-0.0269194245,
-0.0063522481,
-0.0085670985,
0.0235351212,
0.0311673488,
0.064192839,
-0.0724277049,
0.0218190961,
-0.0213214587,
-0.0349252075,
0.0151264807,
0.048605334,
0.0208978895,
0.0074718753,
-0.0021464541,
-0.0033946014,
0.0053957417,
-0.0448726565,
-0.039754685,
-0.11675708,
-0.0063033276,
-0.020636946,
0.0863500386,
-0.0135143884,
-0.0177129693,
0.0868835077,
-0.0485962629,
-0.0304173827,
-0.0034238782,
0.0124849565,
-0.0570118763,
-0.0231010839,
0.0231525004,
-0.0377425812,
0.0162075162,
-0.0321598575,
-0.0272960402,
0.0681275129,
0.0119495327,
0.0175142251,
-0.0152962571,
-0.1037357375,
0.0170231257,
-0.029483445,
0.038083978,
0.0828250945,
0.011014116,
-0.002984558,
0.011842275,
0.0295159984,
-0.0095540974,
0.0544331968,
0.0204499476,
0.0129328156,
-0.0074164644,
0.0141450651,
0.0490240306,
0.0761537552,
-0.0337737314,
-0.0673852786,
0.0769776478,
-0.0718212053,
-0.0004455983,
0.002268591,
0.0251508746,
-0.0451167189,
0.0005362529,
0.0174611267,
-0.0266937837,
-0.0206282008,
-0.0063594929,
0.0089943847,
0.03339817,
-0.0217539184,
0.0196622591,
0.0214469377,
-0.0518999994,
0.0092118997,
-0.0226626918,
-0.0266647022,
-0.0269936733,
-0.0223778468,
0.0042434372,
0.0073934789,
-0.0696206912,
0.0251924731,
0.024337709,
0.0060553611,
0.0072700004,
0.0772470906,
0.0249200501,
-0.0765053555,
0.0268318914,
-0.0423283726,
0.0037819024,
0.0003357948,
-0.0182051938,
0.0271671619,
-0.0090247383,
0.0008373192,
0.0225935355,
0.0567421652,
-0.0035388572,
-0.0147209894,
0.0125831133,
-0.0142848389,
0.0194811393,
-0.0340324864,
-0.0093527688,
-0.0046218494,
0.0096502081,
0.0488308333,
-0.0627015159,
-0.0283116475,
-0.0229072738,
2.754e-7,
0.0429346934,
0.0556726828,
0.020154465,
0.0110217389,
0.0157052185,
0.0219322573,
-0.0322491005,
0.0443993211,
-0.0125890737,
0.019675266,
0.0633010417,
0.0231803916,
0.0633418187,
0.0316111222,
-0.0490615852,
-0.0203478765,
-0.0448656939,
0.0152590526,
-0.0261144508,
-0.0036687176,
0.0377262644,
0.0968908966,
0.0116128661,
-0.0233402476,
0.0182298049,
-0.0265255943,
0.0593806729,
-0.0215228684,
0.0012978424,
0.026236847,
0.0386734456,
0.0129418271,
-0.0447729975,
0.0177899692,
-0.0239451639,
0.0051881722,
0.0645503774,
0.0433608592,
-0.0160891265,
0.039882537,
-0.0162821747,
-0.0184249114,
0.0146307303,
-0.0412285812,
0.0414641574,
-0.0245153401,
0.0211914126,
0.0007436521,
-0.026588738,
0.0285224132,
0.0393903852,
-0.0170227345,
-0.051363226,
0.0119417412,
0.0512664504,
0.0434793495,
-0.0256495401,
-0.0396005809,
-0.0452618226,
-0.0096423272,
0.0092215948,
-0.0233620554,
0.0140764369,
-0.0263031311,
0.0433922932,
-0.0231798403,
0.0061876671,
2.490083662e-34,
0.0359910689,
-0.0062808874,
0.0031425834,
-0.0323756859,
0.004366681,
-0.0304217134,
-0.0055066282,
0.013798885,
-0.0110650826,
0.0053051887,
-0.0223540161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02203v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02203v1 | Automatic Adaptation Rule Optimization via Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T12:06:40 | 2024-07-02T12:06:40 | Yusei Ishimizu, Jialong Li, Jinglue Xu, Jinyu Cai, Hitoshi Iba, Kenji Tei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Rule-based adaptation is a foundational approach to self-adaptation,
characterized by its human readability and rapid response. However, building
high-performance and robust adaptation rules is often a challenge because it
essentially involves searching the optimal design in a complex (variables)
space. In response, this paper attempt to employ large language models (LLMs)
as a optimizer to construct and optimize adaptation rules, leveraging the
common sense and reasoning capabilities inherent in LLMs. Preliminary
experiments conducted in SWIM have validated the effectiveness and limitation
of our method. | [
0.0198695604,
0.006072945,
-0.045681674,
0.0079758605,
0.0147062782,
0.0019364483,
-0.0016453929,
0.0458840616,
-0.0079648709,
-0.0501806401,
-0.0146551616,
-0.0101731494,
-0.0029852723,
0.0260281228,
0.0161826853,
-0.0311660152,
0.0277436785,
-0.0749620795,
0.012627556,
0.0022481731,
-0.0046509048,
-0.0364628173,
0.0125194723,
0.0132757612,
0.0646101981,
0.0345401131,
0.0007157401,
-0.0035774198,
0.0012296049,
-0.0185357705,
0.0291655604,
0.0238539204,
0.041380588,
0.0263910107,
0.0000018506,
-0.0400475673,
0.0101817623,
-0.0168666821,
0.0089451205,
0.0382995866,
0.0592279658,
-0.0094105862,
0.005649413,
0.0101151029,
-0.0099290274,
0.0008455695,
0.0223288275,
-0.0266656484,
0.0873514414,
0.0899632126,
-0.0143263945,
-0.0400595292,
-0.0509735793,
0.0252644233,
-0.033952754,
-0.0802037492,
0.0517877899,
0.015349403,
0.020158004,
-0.044040665,
-0.0504993349,
0.0144920014,
-0.0359445438,
-0.025985362,
-0.0197981577,
-0.00462612,
0.0027751592,
0.0067427936,
-0.0164588094,
0.0448176414,
-0.0238356087,
-0.0002162777,
0.0256704427,
-0.0318641365,
0.0105672264,
0.027595574,
-0.0407226756,
-0.0227937326,
0.0226409454,
-0.0197382066,
-0.0133305928,
-0.0181284286,
-0.0127275251,
0.0139301829,
-0.0942628384,
0.0795029402,
0.0167420022,
0.0068269484,
-0.0332039036,
-0.0495820604,
0.0428750776,
-0.0249430835,
0.050098151,
0.0511808135,
-0.021819476,
-0.0066874125,
-0.020072028,
-0.041492369,
-0.0232821815,
-0.0993021205,
0.1084328219,
0.0565255098,
0.0439204425,
0.0062196269,
-0.0539670438,
0.0403284281,
-0.0269575492,
-0.0278471783,
-0.0373193063,
0.0505505428,
-0.0521179736,
0.0045179008,
-0.0238880347,
0.0381269902,
-0.0444379523,
0.007464923,
-0.0466950163,
0.0490104705,
0.0240503289,
-0.051159665,
-0.0117122764,
-0.045511283,
0.0188897848,
-0.0057067373,
-0.0455043614,
0.0014486016,
0.019023085,
0.0271951389,
-0.0102765895,
0.035753116,
0.0278722942,
-0.0013493912,
-0.0080791544,
-0.029579863,
-0.0207234118,
0.1094721854,
0.0100094704,
0.0141524561,
-0.0247080289,
0.0150956037,
-0.0011576709,
0.0069496571,
-0.0282977205,
-0.0147571377,
-0.0049200999,
-0.0522061177,
-0.0114408582,
-0.0186575595,
-0.032593172,
-0.0414276868,
-0.0443005785,
0.0424065031,
-0.0126487436,
0.0595247559,
0.0276013091,
-0.0392236449,
0.0208924282,
0.0790005773,
0.0257027838,
-0.0064168186,
0.0122531122,
-0.0321559012,
-0.0155598056,
0.0299892295,
-0.0356263742,
0.002134996,
-0.0148016773,
-0.0134379454,
0.0341675133,
0.023007391,
0.0337664336,
-0.0226428267,
-0.0023216554,
-0.0042200764,
0.0849923417,
0.0333861671,
0.0759687647,
0.0359141193,
0.0124957012,
-0.0186932422,
0.0058866958,
-0.0405130275,
-0.0212961957,
0.0043460866,
-0.0501295291,
0.0048619146,
-0.050674215,
0.084514536,
-0.0204034299,
-0.0404192656,
-0.0133653516,
0.0271653272,
-0.0232329648,
-0.0092235645,
0.0407584086,
-0.0167713612,
-0.0135140484,
0.0141023928,
0.0182579849,
-0.0181764383,
0.010940481,
-0.0659529492,
0.0463172756,
0.0983148739,
0.0166364424,
-0.0180269051,
-0.0310047362,
0.0201146081,
0.0543974973,
0.0191569403,
0.0390024967,
0.0436793044,
-0.0156857111,
-0.0366804861,
0.0006610436,
0.0721874088,
-0.0009503305,
0.030336922,
-0.0412673391,
-0.0166901294,
0.0121907191,
0.0377360582,
-0.0889986604,
0.0449967086,
0.0329902321,
-0.0059654191,
0.028183287,
-0.0517496243,
0.057079792,
-0.0146699082,
0.0003708751,
-0.0149408029,
0.008476031,
-0.0305083878,
-0.0619350784,
0.0269676298,
-0.0025736135,
0.0276381075,
0.0329719149,
0.011873642,
0.0316691101,
-0.0112577165,
-0.0211198721,
-0.0217297561,
0.0171599444,
-0.0254021958,
0.033092659,
0.0435147323,
0.0389597416,
0.0123011786,
0.01695548,
-0.0099581247,
0.0094848918,
0.0591318309,
-0.0536648557,
-0.0366869792,
0.025222389,
-0.0048618629,
-0.0558877699,
0.0158476382,
0.0550764613,
-0.0168519989,
-0.0118328761,
0.0634537786,
0.031167144,
0.0046092765,
0.0062487023,
-0.0223755632,
0.0084698386,
0.0259567779,
0.0451507531,
0.0152155459,
-0.022326231,
-0.031430874,
0.0192431882,
0.0245067216,
0.0517334938,
-0.067412667,
0.0020554389,
0.0259731226,
-0.0123783415,
-0.0605105534,
-0.0386529788,
-0.013642367,
-0.018674409,
0.076418817,
0.028111795,
-0.0087255808,
-0.1078543812,
0.0431865305,
-0.0521047041,
-0.0084909471,
0.0004515358,
-0.0399758779,
-0.0204790123,
0.0224254392,
0.0464503393,
0.0307171308,
0.0338252112,
-0.033330664,
0.0584576689,
-0.011800997,
-0.0419534445,
0.0168073457,
-0.0601854734,
-0.0574300848,
-0.0609998666,
-0.0007712881,
0.0116140218,
0.0461647883,
-0.0605215132,
-0.024339091,
-0.076932326,
0.0510666072,
-0.0262427162,
0.014681112,
-0.046742402,
0.0085171852,
-0.02220512,
0.0271331389,
0.0019711128,
-0.0294912476,
0.016716918,
0.0294613726,
0.0442982465,
-0.0817617103,
-0.0353581086,
-0.0070979339,
0.0263928398,
-0.0266148001,
0.0158223566,
-0.0060375356,
0.0198133364,
0.026449129,
-0.0367579795,
0.0708601624,
-0.0091480482,
0.0276223253,
-0.050399784,
0.0459831394,
0.0024670402,
-0.0317797586,
-0.0074967807,
0.0365227275,
-0.0071571851,
-0.0053614983,
0.0071533401,
-0.0494239256,
-0.0498910844,
0.0178690907,
0.0215013828,
0.0055206204,
-0.0317447819,
-0.011428819,
-0.0083279843,
-0.0317794196,
0.0078845816,
0.0381531492,
-0.0024420435,
0.005998618,
0.0600156747,
0.0015267275,
0.0110974945,
-0.0423868038,
-0.0056922399,
0.0357692242,
0.0181788821,
-0.0347528271,
0.0062180576,
0.046538271,
0.0552950092,
-0.0557523482,
0.0141268075,
0.0566783063,
0.0042117378,
-0.0000086869,
0.0264177825,
-0.0547368824,
0.0200594869,
0.0043256148,
0.0503426045,
0.0286816396,
0.0029066643,
-0.0128351217,
-0.0006605551,
-0.0240754839,
0.012650311,
-0.0145054553,
-0.0576188676,
0.0185329709,
0.0402455479,
-0.0989067703,
-0.0329150073,
-0.069940038,
0.030193828,
-0.0469132364,
0.0150028719,
0.0347709432,
-0.0003042542,
-0.0156029295,
0.0235686712,
-0.0725717172,
-0.0245367736,
-0.0387660377,
-0.0212896429,
0.0469720438,
0.0283621401,
0.0127507979,
-0.0243692994,
-0.0123285688,
0.0367603488,
-0.0181732029,
0.0188864227,
-0.0450679213,
-0.0365768075,
0.0241377074,
-0.0006706795,
-0.0198190771,
0.0031724907,
-0.027903989,
-0.0240367539,
0.082520932,
0.0626202524,
0.0226470754,
-0.0366257876,
-0.0335143171,
-0.0186461229,
-0.0290646311,
0.0289746448,
0.0023918746,
-0.0697253495,
-0.0172185879,
-0.0341568887,
-0.0891499072,
-0.0441586263,
-0.0613555722,
-0.046181187,
-0.0478613861,
-0.0414110422,
-0.0607290231,
0.0677364022,
-0.0000828002,
0.0490968041,
0.0420392044,
0.0398745686,
0.0289761964,
0.0002730693,
0.0180354919,
-0.0024989406,
-0.0259180795,
0.0305480864,
-0.0192973483,
0.0109099485,
0.0563337654,
0.0162922293,
-0.0064905128,
0.0183515307,
0.0418219417,
-0.0730981231,
0.044726748,
0.0625604838,
0.0154263536,
-0.0581824854,
-0.0080975322,
-0.0560287461,
0.0419041067,
0.0291611739,
0.003185485,
0.0404872075,
0.0181710646,
0.0214274302,
-0.0083568301,
-0.0041165217,
-0.0248768553,
0.0155681046,
0.0207564794,
0.0479344204,
-0.002159735,
-0.0362274386,
0.0125430776,
0.048188407,
-0.0009011984,
0.0091779735,
-0.0876996219,
0.0091087772,
0.0026206167,
-0.0481098182,
0.0160066225,
-0.0083474219,
0.0131207006,
-0.0099417595,
-0.004847711,
0.0101137767,
-0.0122029809,
-0.0180101935,
-0.0143585829,
-0.0271423664,
0.0493629463,
-0.0002205204,
0.0256281625,
0.0177557953,
0.006296901,
0.0332905203,
0.016229786,
0.0016080126,
-0.0070084198,
-0.0142879756,
-0.0210496821,
0.0327690803,
-0.0311944149,
-0.0541403741,
0.0164965391,
0.010220265,
0.0012677845,
-0.0339039192,
0.0450846478,
0.0451328419,
0.0219570603,
0.0058587408,
-0.0298592448,
-0.0154427178,
-0.018730199,
-0.0023373866,
-0.0228753611,
0.0519367717,
0.0309383757,
0.0300728977,
-0.0427626595,
-0.050887417,
-0.0002738611,
0.0581331141,
0.0517685041,
-0.0083861332,
-0.0071005351,
0.0079148971,
-0.0016657595,
0.0149387643,
0.0644639954,
-0.0432994515,
-0.0237382334,
-0.0698218569,
-0.0219977498,
-0.032123398,
0.0329313502,
0.0535077788,
-0.0142814163,
0.0097018788,
0.0263030306,
-0.0211134106,
-0.050400082,
-0.0160217118,
-0.0387704857,
-0.0144955451,
0.000842856,
-0.0036929289,
-5.59531307e-33,
-0.0307051018,
-0.0155418711,
0.0347758979,
-0.0042181779,
-0.0267304871,
-0.052347552,
0.0119759757,
0.0268238336,
0.0370246954,
-0.0083441241,
0.0028647252,
-0.0257036351,
0.0056030438,
-0.0577962212,
-0.0037856461,
0.0254888814,
0.014020971,
-0.0154363271,
-0.046038907,
-0.0448907614,
0.0163192041,
0.0324200317,
-0.028686326,
-0.0642737225,
-0.0328220613,
0.0328390822,
-0.037475545,
0.0327482373,
-0.0204832759,
0.0592159294,
0.0171636324,
0.0441501625,
-0.0107943695,
0.0077491864,
-0.0366419144,
-0.0402712077,
-0.0140301753,
-0.0123681985,
0.0476663299,
-0.0140432455,
0.066970095,
-0.0609538108,
0.081188269,
0.0299959239,
-0.0766996965,
-0.0092806239,
0.0177786499,
-0.0321927294,
-0.0040106676,
0.0044664033,
-0.0744518787,
0.0570351593,
0.018460298,
0.0268356074,
0.0196219068,
-0.0167973805,
-0.0150068374,
-0.0184381884,
0.0039750081,
0.0528180376,
0.0029652747,
0.0396083668,
0.0354920849,
0.0648362637,
-0.0021904735,
-0.0185910668,
0.0064146514,
0.0013583354,
-0.0038342713,
-0.0220065359,
0.056464158,
0.0071210847,
0.0447090082,
0.0385757238,
0.0032750689,
-0.0485139452,
-0.0522483625,
0.033318419,
-0.0161322169,
0.0015865855,
0.0365350544,
0.0867074132,
-0.0413261913,
0.0001039842,
-0.0081428299,
0.0523196533,
-0.0055821342,
-0.0364347473,
0.0325963944,
-0.0284023732,
-0.0541010499,
-0.0267969966,
0.0229150988,
-0.0200376678,
0.023225883,
-0.0518762879,
-0.0245751571,
-0.000808206,
0.0081172902,
0.0185435005,
0.0080662379,
-0.0945009589,
-0.0082364064,
0.0047105509,
0.0160443801,
-0.0693355054,
-0.0258446932,
0.0336943083,
-0.0346277952,
-0.0129068159,
0.0120459758,
-0.0551718138,
0.0358624868,
-0.0057003559,
-0.0136170369,
0.0182998776,
0.0057693245,
0.0166741833,
0.0154162608,
-0.090376012,
-0.0265250932,
0.0280137304,
-0.008111706,
0.041256357,
-0.034372054,
-0.0061962665,
0.0097045228,
0.0906003639,
0.021438783,
-0.0261804201,
-0.0487965383,
0.0420580879,
2.636e-7,
0.0316574574,
0.0852565318,
-0.0661368296,
-0.046338018,
0.0210358407,
0.0275739357,
-0.0374498032,
-0.0120654637,
0.0132209808,
0.0682959557,
0.025024794,
0.0483169705,
-0.003891323,
-0.0158792697,
0.0142455623,
-0.0585357249,
0.0135847209,
-0.012724313,
-0.0543969199,
-0.0126761682,
0.0295163952,
0.0543365069,
0.032299947,
0.0214402154,
0.0175587814,
-0.0301673748,
0.0041297222,
-0.0628324747,
-0.0039048921,
0.0318811014,
0.0305549074,
0.0010348666,
-0.0358963087,
0.0072053797,
0.0116382651,
0.0623217262,
-0.011625139,
0.0429134443,
-0.0351855904,
0.0550706349,
0.0215777811,
0.052986823,
0.0024252972,
-0.0466513783,
-0.0014218229,
-0.0660495162,
-0.0088985329,
-0.0615647398,
-0.0182049759,
-0.031486731,
-0.0245699193,
-0.0085768048,
-0.0076618786,
0.0226793587,
-0.0037503361,
0.0282561127,
-0.0316127874,
-0.0522602759,
0.0299117845,
0.0391123369,
-0.043429859,
-0.051674705,
-0.0562911034,
0.0547659956,
0.0668950602,
-0.0656938776,
0.0580837093,
1.951431055e-34,
-0.0270612165,
-0.0433029905,
-0.0055098068,
0.0312797762,
0.0472687334,
0.0239023976,
-0.0006120365,
0.0190921985,
0.0207253955,
-0.0754276663,
0.0044706007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02147v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02147v1 | LlamAr & GemmAr: Enhancing LLMs Through Arabic Instruction-Tuning | 2024-07-02T10:43:49 | 2024-07-02T10:43:49 | Hasna Chouikhi, Manel Aloui, Cyrine Ben Hammou, Ghaith Chaabane, Haithem Kchaou, Chehir Dhaouadi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have greatly impacted the natural language
processing (NLP) field, particularly for the English language. These models
have demonstrated capabilities in understanding and generating human-like text.
The success of language models largely depends on the availability of
high-quality instruction datasets, which consist of detailed task descriptions
and corresponding responses that are essential for training the models to
accurately address a variety of prompts. However, the availability and quality
of these resources vary by language. While models perform well in English, they
often struggle with languages like Arabic, due to the lack of datasets for
fine-tuning Arabic-specific tasks. To address this issue, we introduce
InstAr-500k, a new Arabic instruction dataset created by generating and
collecting content that covers several domains and instruction types. We then
assess this dataset by fine-tuning two open-source models, Llama-3-8B-Instruct
and Gemma-7B-IT, on several downstream tasks to scale improvements in their
functionality. Based on multiple evaluations, our fine-tuned models achieve
state-of-the-art performance on several Arabic NLP benchmarks. These outcomes
emphasize the effectiveness of our dataset in elevating the capabilities of
language models for Arabic. Our instruction dataset bridges the performance gap
between English and Arabic language models by providing resources that amplify
Arabic NLP development. Building on this foundation, we developed two
state-of-the-art models, LlamAr-8B and GemmAr-7B, which are specifically tuned
to excel at a wide range of Arabic NLP tasks. | [
0.0494180322,
0.0424378291,
-0.0059583546,
0.0125336256,
-0.0504959188,
0.0245805047,
0.0450679958,
-0.0394820459,
-0.0194679797,
-0.0582440943,
-0.0440257527,
-0.0786099434,
0.0334228724,
0.0060161557,
0.0342155322,
-0.0395956375,
0.0059014978,
-0.0807836503,
-0.0198006593,
0.0104352795,
0.0479580946,
0.0396746323,
-0.0395488404,
0.0358641967,
0.0085156169,
-0.047099065,
-0.0180533268,
-0.0073566907,
-0.0078488477,
0.0018152398,
0.0337123945,
0.0646239743,
-0.0117951659,
-0.0279559959,
0.0000020672,
-0.0557946563,
0.0082441382,
-0.0520443842,
-0.0461741462,
0.0024164668,
0.0434978604,
-0.0674726069,
-0.0329056159,
0.0232759174,
-0.0178269055,
0.0267562196,
0.0262729004,
0.0587239675,
0.0526103377,
0.0515615046,
0.0258059166,
-0.0345914401,
0.036222972,
-0.0221912432,
0.0060408185,
-0.0067197001,
-0.0177511182,
-0.0001914598,
0.0300218426,
0.0384712629,
-0.0272986218,
0.0279717445,
0.0313715376,
-0.0318202786,
-0.0088821044,
-0.0250737593,
-0.0363023505,
-0.038789209,
-0.0098717576,
0.0532287918,
-0.0139804967,
-0.0089736497,
-0.0274853166,
-0.0093621286,
0.005213019,
-0.0132340733,
-0.0205739029,
0.0833875239,
-0.0267685968,
0.0067324908,
0.0705866441,
0.0051868088,
-0.004592889,
0.0087317461,
-0.0036509859,
0.0315592214,
0.003536412,
-0.0369832367,
0.0268578082,
0.0042101773,
-0.0060080108,
-0.035167139,
0.0209028944,
-0.0063809277,
-0.0107116681,
-0.0153114051,
-0.0376298726,
0.002293379,
0.0405148529,
-0.0470460653,
0.072566703,
0.07307899,
-0.0244661905,
0.0186552666,
-0.0399497524,
0.0546158329,
0.0389202498,
0.0465993024,
-0.0546641462,
0.0199391078,
-0.0444167852,
0.0022388818,
-0.0273192171,
0.0417296253,
-0.0902240202,
0.0132664358,
-0.0472595319,
0.0285626296,
-0.0140910437,
0.000548335,
0.0388400406,
-0.0144013902,
-0.0268799737,
-0.0088485209,
-0.0467066616,
-0.0212782212,
-0.0237153973,
0.0307314228,
-0.0235340893,
-0.1115347371,
0.0014020997,
0.0003315482,
0.0126148844,
0.0035020569,
0.0004545049,
0.0727924407,
-0.0151092904,
-0.058689978,
-0.0658514649,
0.0255810916,
0.0053893523,
-0.0651544034,
-0.0263672732,
-0.0647973269,
0.045840878,
0.0008959035,
-0.0098830257,
-0.0149962762,
0.0028664656,
0.0528725944,
0.0451223291,
0.0773912743,
0.0430105515,
-0.0023463704,
0.0579320826,
0.0055824243,
0.0533356704,
0.058530584,
0.0115562892,
-0.0138759324,
0.0178690068,
0.0105881104,
0.0041511976,
0.0405122638,
-0.018945083,
-0.0102576222,
-0.0023621954,
-0.0034756367,
-0.0020335531,
0.0816344991,
0.0096486751,
0.0198636018,
-0.0198108666,
-0.0051795151,
0.0666241273,
0.0191382114,
-0.0354673304,
0.0142657161,
0.050116688,
0.0464913845,
0.0417725034,
0.0011433376,
-0.0399224535,
0.0163088441,
0.0199877974,
0.0238963347,
0.0110731823,
0.0568563864,
-0.0419109315,
-0.0813797861,
-0.0343820304,
-0.0194545761,
0.0249861423,
0.0130119557,
0.0646337569,
0.0274785385,
-0.0539361723,
0.0166773293,
0.0356797241,
-0.0187992565,
0.0197277758,
-0.0498058759,
0.0002255199,
0.0714994818,
0.025242012,
-0.0186997764,
-0.0663210973,
-0.0287986267,
0.034402661,
0.0669247136,
0.026334798,
-0.0154242534,
0.0076557789,
-0.0597024299,
-0.025634354,
0.0018857367,
0.0112120882,
-0.0395082384,
0.0385905318,
-0.0051558902,
-0.0158107895,
-0.0092795426,
-0.050646618,
0.0636035129,
-0.0622971617,
-0.0236483943,
-0.0134283118,
0.0054076049,
0.0127229849,
0.0341699608,
0.0073932218,
0.0026009921,
0.0306318738,
-0.0611563511,
-0.0018680131,
-0.0293957181,
-0.0641202331,
-0.0222715084,
0.0402150638,
-0.0038253497,
-0.0120160356,
0.046710968,
-0.0408030339,
-0.0292979702,
0.0405989587,
-0.0259541012,
0.0198231172,
-0.0194705129,
0.0455209874,
0.037702702,
0.0140722254,
-0.0378558822,
0.0413423516,
-0.0470670387,
-0.0021574462,
0.0112828175,
-0.0039351368,
0.0081978925,
0.0080596246,
0.0155484388,
0.0048894123,
-0.0142378248,
0.0237541888,
0.0375547595,
0.040823251,
-0.0411144085,
-0.0506121926,
-0.0532780737,
0.0193428919,
-0.0200769827,
0.0581765994,
0.0045499578,
0.0188401453,
-0.023957476,
-0.0065599289,
-0.0280622356,
-0.0579041168,
0.0052101375,
0.0265965927,
0.0486997217,
-0.0237732213,
-0.0097554401,
-0.0600832812,
-0.0263140853,
0.0347493105,
0.0147183808,
0.0166654065,
-0.0175654665,
0.0081693921,
-0.0085941823,
0.0130832661,
0.0179521888,
0.0004676557,
-0.033368066,
0.01998448,
-0.0015144963,
0.0445901975,
0.0527616069,
-0.0074588456,
0.0195401385,
-0.0059855594,
-0.0012821133,
-0.0726486221,
0.0131517639,
-0.0095524173,
-0.0423151888,
-0.0475280918,
-0.0459614769,
-0.0421957001,
0.0560502224,
0.0017462688,
0.0100227343,
-0.0470648035,
-0.0049444721,
-0.0236550383,
-0.0087503176,
-0.012597505,
0.0065826983,
-0.0197385643,
0.0417756625,
-0.0477135889,
-0.0419397019,
0.0021622744,
-0.0199376326,
0.0131906569,
-0.0354703479,
0.0167840812,
-0.0583183244,
-0.0063177547,
-0.0029089488,
0.0144506097,
-0.0158637557,
-0.0425587967,
-0.0384595878,
0.0211434197,
0.0117401322,
-0.0293171201,
0.0324302316,
-0.0853227675,
0.0003201139,
-0.0138105014,
-0.0376153998,
-0.0339689925,
0.014861376,
-0.0321552865,
0.0128152417,
0.035134986,
-0.0037812286,
-0.035855446,
-0.0065918523,
0.0355231427,
0.0601390041,
-0.0076472326,
0.00073242,
-0.0305757243,
-0.0322840102,
0.0436277837,
0.0200828072,
0.0198059194,
-0.0292006955,
0.0216647629,
0.0361881182,
-0.0264154598,
-0.0232345574,
-0.0372484028,
0.0141699994,
0.0599857904,
-0.0477283522,
-0.0270378534,
-0.0129072135,
0.0452138782,
-0.0677056313,
-0.0025150734,
0.0946774855,
0.0271228328,
-0.0266937669,
0.0158928633,
-0.0004689929,
-0.0028102822,
0.0109215537,
-0.0232937038,
-0.1023537219,
-0.0370643735,
0.0278421044,
0.0166726299,
0.0132568711,
0.012682097,
0.0332489759,
-0.1143827811,
0.0080120489,
-0.0315045826,
-0.0260616131,
-0.05128517,
-0.0474431254,
-0.0110994112,
-0.0110694179,
0.0237236768,
-0.038464617,
-0.0428621471,
0.0222698338,
0.0728063658,
-0.0044188094,
-0.0883366689,
0.0376568697,
-0.0360104628,
0.0540601648,
0.0432446823,
-0.0111610563,
-0.0006933963,
-0.019331228,
0.0457527637,
-0.0230437834,
-0.0207371768,
-0.0078518223,
0.0138552291,
0.0042825695,
0.0052197082,
-0.042941723,
0.0112459632,
-0.0765787736,
0.0039715264,
-0.0167257953,
0.0258811563,
-0.0037220677,
0.0495260023,
-0.0011652434,
-0.0019024826,
-0.0240241922,
0.0627454072,
0.0018181948,
-0.0646515042,
-0.0410332493,
-0.0169460531,
-0.0295370854,
-0.0781633705,
-0.0427000374,
0.0186769944,
0.0123995272,
0.0501012243,
-0.0768526047,
-0.0674957484,
0.0366281681,
-0.0125781232,
0.0083316844,
0.0174425021,
0.0052438471,
-0.0137270167,
-0.0210544225,
0.0212197229,
0.0123733133,
0.0108195012,
-0.0892008618,
-0.0344540812,
-0.0093781063,
-0.0861026272,
0.02263497,
0.0128376149,
-0.0849155486,
-0.0186406299,
0.0122862607,
0.0405057259,
0.0103622871,
0.030552756,
0.0020871679,
-0.0514501445,
-0.0014131184,
-0.0042268066,
-0.0287272725,
0.0197184142,
0.012016925,
0.0048934207,
-0.0161274131,
0.0482524931,
0.0255540647,
0.021897044,
0.0217133481,
0.0162718277,
0.0034367184,
-0.0408076644,
0.0235790405,
-0.0284360163,
-0.0041448697,
-0.0307562482,
-0.029932417,
-0.068803452,
0.0300222021,
-0.014013011,
0.019235814,
-0.0277448874,
0.0244627204,
0.0238952432,
0.0215159468,
-0.0012740742,
0.0084481351,
-0.000279519,
0.0191354975,
-0.0446664616,
0.0522996932,
-0.0089347055,
0.0009799622,
-0.0139387948,
0.0409102403,
-0.0000698888,
-0.0230212137,
-0.0429771245,
0.0502764359,
-0.0021160231,
0.0214538723,
-0.0264131464,
0.0357998647,
0.0316156261,
0.0658771247,
0.0106281256,
-0.027491603,
-0.0382098109,
0.051404167,
0.0454921797,
-0.0395089351,
0.0340341032,
0.0237709451,
0.0068314415,
-0.0205864515,
0.0413002484,
-0.0021673008,
-0.0228774324,
0.0193581525,
0.0175308324,
0.0031997198,
-0.013300132,
0.0786440149,
0.0187097359,
0.0336711891,
0.0162562225,
0.0342901386,
-0.0221336037,
-0.0169812553,
0.0121661695,
0.002837633,
-0.0316161476,
0.0463053323,
-0.0367326289,
-0.0671139434,
-0.0036269091,
0.0153986067,
0.0113965785,
-0.0119230468,
0.0604458936,
0.0586228557,
-0.0150198471,
-0.0424473919,
-0.0729737356,
-0.0139808422,
-0.0009409298,
-0.048189979,
-0.0135759898,
-6.298145183e-33,
0.0049328511,
0.004979433,
0.0369384065,
0.0107344976,
0.013624575,
0.0013131746,
-0.0146434726,
-0.0110584805,
-0.0132014789,
-0.0023858643,
-0.0389697403,
0.0098865246,
0.0251875762,
0.0399069749,
0.0586993322,
-0.0170467868,
0.042348586,
-0.0388861261,
-0.0219915248,
0.0373948701,
0.0211420171,
0.0291540865,
0.1224325597,
-0.0358307511,
0.0305693354,
-0.0205888953,
-0.0231209788,
0.0136116398,
-0.0053182617,
0.1159434915,
-0.0360298492,
0.0535011888,
0.0375093818,
-0.0750694498,
0.0017871126,
0.0020234755,
-0.0814186111,
-0.004551955,
0.0290566087,
0.0322199464,
-0.0569681376,
-0.0570496954,
-0.031171836,
-0.0050318083,
-0.0493658893,
0.0279208291,
0.0138838561,
-0.0176893584,
0.0222828053,
0.0250217915,
-0.1031075791,
0.0417536981,
-0.0078798383,
-0.0293495376,
0.0334646553,
0.0559967682,
-0.0259919912,
-0.0139492275,
-0.0489678867,
0.0133492155,
0.0339858644,
0.0547291897,
0.0698421746,
-0.0007620614,
-0.0514882877,
0.0391669311,
-0.0242468566,
-0.0177999474,
0.0367038026,
0.0211386532,
0.0027381771,
0.0090765134,
0.0152032217,
0.0497183092,
0.0179013312,
0.0113459928,
-0.0607571565,
0.025389282,
-0.0115660476,
0.061923977,
0.0148792583,
-0.0298399013,
-0.0735098794,
0.0003934989,
-0.0177093074,
-0.0204557087,
0.0008854223,
0.0170813017,
0.0456309542,
0.0396621563,
-0.0022127246,
0.0294784177,
-0.0044628107,
0.013155303,
0.0201258138,
-0.0006866996,
-0.0010491565,
-0.0089220824,
0.0077573173,
0.0175674185,
-0.0817756057,
-0.0444776192,
-0.0025062051,
0.0008819927,
0.0229308754,
0.0130241243,
0.037419796,
0.042294614,
-0.0812633857,
0.0387032367,
-0.0458340608,
0.0877567083,
0.012428348,
0.0734262466,
0.0255881008,
-0.0174312815,
-0.0325886793,
0.0776813775,
0.0231033005,
-0.0325881243,
-0.0276626218,
-0.0246556178,
-0.0199071802,
-0.0062633497,
-0.0096971877,
0.0380235463,
-0.0622710697,
0.0084360931,
-0.0088300202,
-0.0390712582,
0.0097104469,
0.0115047386,
2.684e-7,
0.032501623,
0.0302517042,
0.0308333505,
0.0320375599,
-0.007284496,
0.0086598918,
0.0254072789,
0.0170738455,
0.0071410756,
0.0088813081,
-0.0342189893,
0.0263620075,
0.0485531352,
-0.0312155876,
-0.0815100595,
-0.0006698987,
-0.01521385,
0.0453561209,
-0.0399701707,
-0.0350546502,
0.0450616032,
0.1337507665,
-0.0655445158,
-0.0182709079,
-0.0625657812,
-0.017608704,
0.0413528346,
-0.0231003091,
-0.0245116428,
0.0385892503,
0.0602920763,
-0.0039866664,
0.0192773789,
-0.0003368848,
-0.0618622601,
-0.0025159395,
0.0231977496,
0.098872453,
0.0096226316,
-0.0138298627,
0.0292906258,
-0.0072825584,
-0.0369421691,
-0.0241432972,
0.0619077943,
-0.0006931166,
0.0007811273,
0.0172874201,
-0.0191501882,
0.0186592769,
0.0201595034,
-0.0379182883,
0.0018502265,
0.0356443934,
0.04844632,
-0.0282344092,
-0.0065944283,
-0.0301801041,
0.0131566999,
-0.0172227621,
-0.0004194965,
0.0190486368,
-0.0209529139,
-0.0066382005,
-0.0193414539,
-0.0166151319,
-0.0191790424,
2.329778605e-34,
0.0237839222,
0.0105791865,
0.0302911699,
0.024676241,
0.0161807351,
-0.0002806741,
-0.0423175506,
0.0230272599,
0.0049633053,
-0.0473975539,
-0.0079722935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02138v1 | Efficient Nearest Neighbor based Uncertainty Estimation for Natural Language Processing Tasks | 2024-07-02T10:33:31 | 2024-07-02T10:33:31 | Wataru Hashimoto, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Trustworthy prediction in Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), including Pre-trained
Language Models (PLMs) is important for safety-critical applications in the
real world. However, DNNs often suffer from uncertainty estimation, such as
miscalibration. In particular, approaches that require multiple stochastic
inference can mitigate this problem, but the expensive cost of inference makes
them impractical. In this study, we propose $k$-Nearest Neighbor Uncertainty
Estimation ($k$NN-UE), which is an uncertainty estimation method that uses the
distances from the neighbors and label-existence ratio of neighbors.
Experiments on sentiment analysis, natural language inference, and named entity
recognition show that our proposed method outperforms the baselines or recent
density-based methods in confidence calibration, selective prediction, and
out-of-distribution detection. Moreover, our analyses indicate that introducing
dimension reduction or approximate nearest neighbor search inspired by recent
$k$NN-LM studies reduces the inference overhead without significantly degrading
estimation performance when combined them appropriately. | [
0.0417193212,
0.0946857706,
0.0273565948,
0.0590956546,
-0.0206637569,
0.0021073841,
0.0203617252,
-0.0056573506,
0.0006848276,
-0.0017712213,
-0.0522074439,
-0.0779993162,
0.0099538555,
-0.0074420311,
0.0050319685,
-0.0049435263,
0.0031436901,
-0.0276173279,
0.0353060141,
-0.0339442231,
-0.0046692374,
0.0063640261,
-0.0240857732,
0.005167753,
-0.0506634787,
0.0081406208,
0.0062474161,
0.0342851616,
0.0501536168,
-0.0599451289,
0.0364383347,
0.0389833376,
0.0013457735,
0.0152499313,
0.0000020033,
-0.0057303468,
-0.0306905005,
-0.0170193519,
-0.0345471017,
-0.0087506017,
0.0545106307,
-0.0085333716,
-0.002355282,
0.035274826,
0.0168098919,
-0.0516557582,
0.062855795,
0.049934797,
-0.0308217201,
0.0602010824,
0.0041332939,
0.0123857623,
0.013527316,
-0.0324875154,
-0.0104682371,
-0.0829500258,
0.033376392,
-0.054656852,
-0.0541745611,
0.0301827732,
0.0124826599,
0.0520581044,
0.0211798847,
0.0055126366,
0.005339968,
0.0269089211,
0.0405972302,
0.0031456146,
-0.0052284324,
0.0591720417,
-0.0510094948,
0.0176196359,
-0.0135296611,
-0.0459459387,
-0.0242264699,
0.0231891107,
0.0022972987,
0.0330792069,
0.0068178708,
0.0062055853,
-0.0522093847,
0.0740998313,
0.0459405221,
0.0425487086,
0.011065824,
0.0562667362,
-0.0076127048,
-0.0133266263,
0.0179498754,
0.0008285464,
-0.0269689746,
-0.0436100885,
0.0679119676,
0.0029017129,
-0.0041992641,
0.016263444,
-0.0276895314,
-0.0016251821,
-0.0047235126,
-0.0570994988,
-0.0154269999,
-0.0025371048,
-0.0321046524,
0.0479671173,
0.0005365327,
0.0051860972,
0.0141185606,
-0.0141724627,
0.0006634286,
-0.0092085237,
0.0177184474,
0.0149169071,
-0.0361621156,
0.0160755161,
-0.0064242589,
-0.0396097302,
-0.0448965207,
0.0111076878,
0.0087832091,
0.0169641711,
0.0155167142,
0.0659979507,
-0.0273952018,
-0.0294606164,
-0.0191486441,
0.0110874549,
-0.0251693558,
0.02889226,
-0.0274069104,
-0.0611286163,
-0.0247635115,
0.0300938115,
0.0319750421,
-0.0258986112,
0.025066318,
0.04593971,
0.0205090567,
-0.0642247275,
-0.0309565198,
-0.0085213082,
-0.0720737576,
-0.0065392954,
-0.0070695113,
-0.0844211057,
0.00621492,
-0.0312537663,
0.0086321561,
-0.0829482973,
0.0204656683,
-0.0031731231,
-0.0616622791,
0.0629157871,
-0.0454103015,
0.0024226552,
-0.0080933962,
-0.0031608418,
0.0160453189,
0.0395829603,
0.0378492139,
0.0259750932,
0.0559895895,
0.0405989178,
-0.0036623187,
-0.0136842607,
0.0042415312,
-0.0224185251,
-0.0364310928,
-0.0169534255,
-0.0646729097,
0.0191574674,
-0.0281332973,
0.0367265381,
-0.0214194041,
-0.0258497726,
0.0546992607,
0.0304806232,
-0.0220760144,
-0.0289447643,
-0.0175691023,
0.0240679774,
-0.0343145169,
-0.0431080237,
-0.0747048706,
0.030005632,
-0.0289817713,
-0.013529418,
0.05746793,
0.0133643635,
-0.0119316597,
-0.0463124029,
-0.0229694266,
-0.0424494371,
-0.0271220356,
0.0089889588,
0.0429689959,
-0.0009571864,
-0.0274649002,
0.0431578569,
0.0036238565,
-0.0041352301,
0.0032684165,
0.0354110077,
0.0134469727,
0.0429901183,
0.0003605662,
-0.0454438999,
-0.0353526175,
-0.0183598027,
0.0051339152,
0.010909385,
0.0175150018,
-0.0018124561,
0.0807431713,
-0.0467169918,
-0.032247223,
0.0184928048,
0.0368664339,
0.001152901,
0.0553436987,
0.0566302948,
0.0656752437,
-0.0890782624,
-0.008910276,
0.0026645793,
0.049076952,
-0.0371558145,
0.0563306399,
0.0404303111,
0.0186981503,
0.0425588898,
-0.0441783182,
-0.0048966082,
0.0160763059,
-0.0082213348,
-0.0417749286,
-0.0457998067,
-0.0391925685,
-0.0527155995,
0.0336907618,
-0.0126974573,
0.0024320078,
-0.0023508391,
-0.0392961204,
-0.0229916796,
0.0068627172,
-0.0202693976,
-0.0379039906,
-0.0122517841,
-0.0175934006,
0.0077451803,
0.0218196753,
-0.0078007528,
0.053516183,
-0.0324222632,
0.0201853607,
-0.0223880149,
0.0290244687,
0.0260484461,
-0.0081036836,
-0.0639408082,
-0.051223103,
-0.0327253826,
-0.025614256,
0.0668308362,
0.0092803044,
-0.0050137024,
-0.0232304558,
-0.0171861947,
0.0129975108,
-0.0275449958,
0.0300036222,
-0.0044057979,
0.033551909,
-0.0131874476,
-0.0461784825,
-0.0046864115,
-0.0053710574,
-0.0148060098,
-0.0042721797,
0.0463545844,
0.0014112153,
-0.0184654705,
-0.0109051662,
-0.0408051163,
-0.0104543073,
0.0400248952,
-0.0294700898,
-0.0521572456,
-0.056975279,
0.0805777088,
-0.0449538194,
0.044263728,
0.0255068708,
-0.0319464952,
-0.001257017,
-0.0120638646,
-0.0281076916,
0.0214577522,
-0.0044032969,
-0.0244345963,
0.0267676003,
-0.0109464405,
-0.0306364764,
-0.0003063797,
-0.0431475416,
-0.0168495011,
0.0028262413,
-0.0104194926,
-0.0157564506,
0.0350924805,
-0.0147688398,
-0.0386475734,
-0.0193079859,
0.0195138045,
0.0105624925,
0.0167015977,
-0.008087853,
0.0054993764,
0.0382476747,
0.0327385217,
0.0059612575,
0.0008240681,
0.0877643228,
-0.0328038484,
0.0422244407,
-0.0167580359,
-0.0393079855,
0.0330860652,
-0.0018301738,
0.0140477968,
0.030347921,
0.0066484725,
-0.0180144478,
-0.0299378261,
-0.011495864,
0.0430286564,
-0.0153383445,
0.0005437037,
-0.0185554232,
0.0132191516,
0.0055605029,
-0.0416324288,
-0.0515417941,
-0.0294001456,
-0.0483992286,
-0.0247850548,
-0.0083012395,
-0.0112871658,
-0.007264683,
-0.0004534432,
-0.0205597971,
0.0563955158,
0.0049739107,
-0.0026602484,
-0.0093657719,
0.0302203987,
0.0274750255,
-0.0355033726,
0.0691366941,
0.0127154915,
0.0124532515,
0.0481928587,
0.0212546624,
0.0173222795,
-0.027652055,
-0.0280936006,
0.0449730195,
0.0140472436,
-0.0131723424,
0.0517083518,
0.0568861999,
-0.0210275799,
-0.0182742458,
0.1224671453,
0.0027470253,
-0.024412306,
-0.011026131,
0.0202708002,
0.0187456068,
0.0137251327,
-0.0016083061,
-0.0552192032,
-0.0434192978,
-0.0043374747,
0.0190282054,
0.0027944366,
-0.0612735599,
0.0289308522,
-0.0929910541,
-0.0123285502,
-0.0176553186,
-0.0446494035,
-0.0596671924,
-0.0357411243,
0.0221731178,
-0.0225904975,
0.0171173345,
-0.0082135117,
0.0600885153,
-0.0283006988,
0.0286847111,
-0.0425607711,
-0.0852251723,
0.0043534394,
-0.0753543153,
0.0576571934,
0.0094744265,
-0.0090231989,
-0.0230444968,
-0.00803266,
-0.0165457036,
-0.0340735093,
-0.0015623968,
0.0215139762,
0.0728654712,
-0.0367331207,
-0.0231124759,
0.0194674004,
0.0027128658,
-0.0684651509,
-0.0054469099,
-0.013055292,
0.0106397299,
0.0020229626,
-0.0160026047,
-0.0186576694,
-0.0060299481,
0.045555599,
0.0498998836,
-0.034445826,
-0.0160454456,
0.0149919363,
-0.0059150592,
0.0404109284,
0.011103237,
0.0442547947,
0.0145868259,
-0.0273186807,
-0.05415757,
-0.0633405969,
-0.0002867237,
-0.0053299358,
0.0208937638,
-0.0182958413,
-0.0128040398,
0.0772888139,
0.0119279074,
-0.0453887023,
0.0125812674,
-0.0110668633,
0.0195608698,
0.0190536045,
0.0817209482,
0.0509131551,
0.028479673,
-0.0272674561,
0.0430644192,
-0.1097083315,
-0.0534493066,
-0.0318504535,
0.0403864533,
0.0038230128,
0.0283578988,
-0.0561967343,
-0.0579189025,
0.0515753552,
0.0629746169,
-0.016727617,
-0.0248832796,
0.0394410565,
-0.0156447012,
0.0042392984,
0.0422631316,
-0.0669340119,
0.0490439795,
0.037450023,
-0.0020819476,
-0.0159621015,
-0.1064803824,
-0.0471854955,
-0.0022622561,
0.1059753895,
0.0084869144,
0.0190888513,
-0.0446510725,
0.0168645643,
0.0077727758,
-0.0216984861,
-0.0139275938,
0.0576249175,
0.0432213545,
0.0147194285,
-0.0367370434,
-0.0108739519,
0.0627565309,
0.0125141973,
0.0149915842,
-0.0290368702,
0.0676517114,
0.0071142172,
0.0331814662,
-0.0163259134,
-0.025193844,
0.0351747982,
0.0312492438,
0.0111771701,
0.0132835144,
-0.0084973723,
0.0070433188,
-0.0290624518,
-0.0237151664,
-0.0151753277,
-0.0750649795,
-0.0504683107,
-0.0803564191,
0.030633226,
0.0120685957,
-0.0180875733,
-0.0166891366,
-0.0506380945,
0.0062524904,
-0.0298459418,
0.0271227378,
0.0082892329,
-0.0204714201,
0.0388486125,
0.0201538876,
0.0187931452,
0.0579071157,
0.0695443004,
-0.0028731213,
0.0436116308,
-0.0067383018,
-0.0687938035,
-0.0180035084,
-0.0207581632,
-0.0020179371,
0.0879773051,
-0.0279657021,
0.0262886956,
0.0387014672,
-0.0790439099,
0.0654883534,
-0.006203508,
0.0149990721,
0.0114864791,
0.0320989378,
0.028064074,
0.0218770206,
0.0091120992,
0.0046455273,
-0.0253522005,
0.0190902017,
-0.0143198008,
0.0199240409,
-6.769802005e-33,
0.0264505502,
-0.0383195616,
-0.0649895445,
-0.0337944664,
-0.0141595695,
0.0223877206,
-0.0012797586,
-0.0057645515,
-0.016987212,
0.0432539694,
0.0098142801,
0.0551470257,
0.0165913068,
0.024108924,
0.0050393199,
-0.0325803608,
0.0467895083,
-0.0193364043,
0.0295702517,
0.0107421465,
0.0150286192,
0.0574101992,
0.1040706411,
-0.1180605367,
0.0238594301,
0.0367817245,
-0.0241752751,
0.0390829742,
0.0246647708,
0.0378742814,
-0.0078533376,
0.0663684979,
-0.0224964302,
-0.0381484702,
-0.0102429073,
-0.0322105996,
-0.047943648,
-0.0481401794,
-0.0621626526,
0.0424388722,
0.0038878068,
0.0179660209,
0.059819065,
0.0074989726,
0.0048937178,
0.0015679612,
0.0228180476,
-0.0234648846,
-0.0233482886,
-0.058906287,
0.0148431882,
0.0515108518,
0.0017176619,
0.0038180354,
0.0212223493,
0.0011240304,
0.0335272439,
-0.0400675796,
-0.0840820223,
-0.0264674723,
0.0060935854,
0.056906037,
0.0040194769,
0.0038508193,
-0.0133399377,
0.049983073,
0.016294254,
-0.0414814875,
-0.0322461687,
-0.0120598534,
-0.0010018926,
0.0266244076,
0.0293289162,
0.1090060845,
0.0492833704,
-0.0299885068,
-0.1047010571,
-0.0014523078,
-0.0087745879,
0.0126887886,
0.0402110219,
0.0075893379,
-0.0578785837,
-0.0383719094,
-0.0162223112,
-0.0687686354,
-0.0415014364,
-0.0075345035,
0.0056493143,
0.03678656,
-0.0635773987,
-0.0109228576,
-0.0187407341,
-0.0713897571,
-0.030051142,
0.0254119895,
0.0154834408,
-0.0063188793,
0.0044014016,
0.0304642711,
-0.0401795208,
-0.0131851137,
-0.0321751796,
-0.0247460287,
-0.0129863406,
0.0209642146,
0.062960431,
0.0254684798,
-0.064458698,
-0.0093381824,
0.0142690968,
0.0100354562,
0.0087147234,
0.0421220995,
0.0346906222,
-0.0363291875,
0.0017414374,
0.0721566379,
0.0430345871,
0.0285146628,
0.0203352999,
0.0284941532,
0.0260172077,
-0.0373223536,
-0.0588138625,
-0.0525346175,
-0.0063530905,
-0.0476856753,
0.007725683,
-0.0593219064,
-0.0218078103,
0.0017511462,
2.917e-7,
0.0365960076,
0.0069756047,
0.0282396469,
0.0191577747,
0.0107802497,
0.0353391208,
0.0417559966,
0.0274274051,
-0.0009241048,
-0.0559027977,
0.0195671711,
0.0039322549,
0.0036093385,
0.025137065,
-0.0923057869,
-0.049351383,
-0.0272863787,
0.0415139049,
0.0063267495,
0.0063428492,
0.0397610664,
0.1133038849,
0.0270400736,
-0.0077021387,
-0.0185438599,
-0.0396211967,
0.021737501,
-0.0277397428,
0.0459571108,
0.0146052632,
0.0889347494,
0.026071094,
-0.0066633807,
0.0461072437,
0.016244987,
0.0307757482,
0.0170888361,
0.0579948984,
0.0194160584,
-0.0082546892,
-0.0135121364,
-0.0001702376,
0.028715279,
-0.037798252,
0.065257296,
-0.0361352488,
0.0019483021,
-0.0461484976,
0.0214994624,
-0.0436641723,
0.0541751385,
-0.0027391124,
0.0094962586,
-0.0060671717,
0.0154376756,
0.0111033097,
-0.0232239775,
-0.0868055448,
0.0000561364,
-0.0051058512,
-0.0141827026,
-0.0412408784,
0.0212047454,
-0.0073798471,
0.0425462425,
-0.0196809899,
-0.0007657857,
2.157668095e-34,
0.0215497222,
0.0077496516,
-0.0253731627,
-0.0196154434,
0.0301893577,
-0.0120676542,
-0.0181331132,
-0.0262003522,
0.0245713014,
-0.0559740104,
-0.021177778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02136v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02136v1 | Black Big Boxes: Do Language Models Hide a Theory of Adjective Order? | 2024-07-02T10:29:09 | 2024-07-02T10:29:09 | Jaap Jumelet, Lisa Bylinina, Willem Zuidema, Jakub Szymanik | cs.CL | cs.CL | In English and other languages, multiple adjectives in a complex noun phrase
show intricate ordering patterns that have been a target of much linguistic
theory. These patterns offer an opportunity to assess the ability of language
models (LMs) to learn subtle rules of language involving factors that cross the
traditional divisions of syntax, semantics, and pragmatics. We review existing
hypotheses designed to explain Adjective Order Preferences (AOPs) in humans and
develop a setup to study AOPs in LMs: we present a reusable corpus of adjective
pairs and define AOP measures for LMs. With these tools, we study a series of
LMs across intermediate checkpoints during training. We find that all models'
predictions are much closer to human AOPs than predictions generated by factors
identified in theoretical linguistics. At the same time, we demonstrate that
the observed AOPs in LMs are strongly correlated with the frequency of the
adjective pairs in the training data and report limited generalization to
unseen combinations. This highlights the difficulty in establishing the link
between LM performance and linguistic theory. We therefore conclude with a road
map for future studies our results set the stage for, and a discussion of key
questions about the nature of knowledge in LMs and their ability to generalize
beyond the training sets. | [
0.0663952827,
0.0844389871,
-0.0476068109,
0.0406468026,
-0.0209996477,
0.0351970606,
-0.0417757854,
0.0033966161,
-0.0318369791,
-0.0614002645,
-0.0174111668,
-0.064067103,
-0.0020300737,
-0.0211418178,
0.0170013085,
-0.0309446696,
0.0011174193,
-0.0243201703,
-0.0126255881,
-0.0031400595,
-0.0055168131,
0.0008594316,
-0.022151418,
0.0110936798,
0.0110179344,
0.0113379508,
0.0035896606,
-0.0199131295,
-0.0074137095,
-0.0144654568,
0.0083984453,
0.0801479146,
-0.0133292275,
-0.0220711101,
0.0000020472,
-0.0653475747,
0.0284007061,
-0.0181530118,
0.036077816,
0.0440808944,
0.0566778257,
0.0270996392,
-0.0221124329,
-0.0447133631,
-0.0476849042,
-0.0313198566,
0.0386981294,
0.0271295607,
-0.0193423275,
0.0455900244,
0.0033200334,
-0.0228624046,
-0.0056697112,
-0.021055663,
0.0085852016,
-0.0369918309,
0.0383018777,
-0.0713418424,
0.0093388194,
0.0303257741,
-0.0180263873,
-0.0101759136,
-0.0157014262,
0.0559684187,
-0.0171958618,
0.0203103479,
0.0115218442,
-0.0166526996,
0.0088758562,
0.0337381698,
0.0183492582,
-0.001866334,
-0.0007315233,
-0.0152356345,
0.0189781059,
0.0235769339,
-0.0337410234,
0.0453588441,
-0.0047528306,
0.0332982875,
0.0414201133,
-0.0313731283,
-0.0249061473,
0.0679473504,
-0.0148013635,
0.1239642352,
-0.0012180377,
-0.0351048969,
0.005234357,
0.0187435802,
-0.0320763662,
-0.0242333207,
-0.0061670034,
-0.0420546308,
0.0179109164,
0.0250048116,
0.0365766771,
0.0230915584,
0.0441771671,
-0.0282995347,
0.0466219522,
-0.0263544582,
-0.0455573462,
-0.004836367,
-0.0224549882,
0.0716434568,
0.0059029083,
0.0012877986,
-0.0367492773,
0.0269746222,
-0.0484438948,
-0.0244496167,
0.035749875,
0.0248838291,
-0.0099832071,
0.0351134576,
-0.0710554421,
-0.0053209038,
-0.0163142998,
-0.0672109351,
-0.0014895154,
0.0350758955,
0.0173950139,
-0.0033748304,
-0.0887963027,
-0.0393498838,
-0.0248936266,
0.0684891194,
-0.0293822251,
-0.0389284678,
0.0290457383,
-0.0211164206,
-0.0094460938,
-0.0210088417,
-0.0075248098,
0.0220641531,
0.0125323599,
-0.031283509,
0.0189682562,
0.0139881494,
-0.0369360447,
-0.0080299713,
0.0077852984,
-0.0649065822,
-0.014739613,
0.0430965014,
-0.0060486523,
-0.0621532239,
-0.006989121,
0.0042218282,
-0.0926049724,
0.0192611404,
0.0363892466,
0.0474933051,
-0.0472596511,
-0.0136576584,
0.0065357294,
0.0100470651,
0.0092596272,
-0.0165898092,
0.0243340097,
-0.0126732718,
0.0137691759,
0.0091500841,
-0.0437632352,
0.0089158323,
-0.0150908222,
-0.0242438931,
-0.0561025776,
0.0033425386,
0.0643864572,
0.0372207761,
-0.0187016353,
-0.0351193473,
0.0678005442,
0.0226446409,
0.012009684,
0.0026987717,
0.0158215873,
0.0190152805,
0.0259091053,
0.0564212687,
-0.023200782,
-0.0085664606,
-0.0053607891,
-0.0157079678,
-0.0292213149,
0.0460732989,
-0.0007574958,
-0.0582773574,
-0.0317604169,
-0.0291517749,
0.0327953435,
-0.0273355488,
0.0119696874,
0.0236491468,
0.0099806897,
0.0176305547,
0.0699008256,
-0.0465143509,
-0.0380872004,
-0.0478749201,
-0.0235564448,
0.0714662597,
-0.0207520369,
-0.0032286076,
-0.0123097319,
0.0600427426,
-0.0045671528,
0.018918179,
0.0107693141,
0.014441994,
0.0183981396,
-0.0240081269,
0.0146825854,
-0.0284117069,
0.0372714922,
0.0095090717,
-0.0040224409,
-0.0111261141,
-0.0198330712,
0.0048597548,
-0.0330323949,
0.0280744154,
-0.002267309,
-0.0194316637,
-0.006507834,
0.0175154991,
0.0196707249,
-0.0378685817,
0.0101688197,
0.0466625206,
0.0332915299,
-0.0125506977,
-0.0105987964,
0.02670734,
-0.0233833063,
0.0077588288,
-0.0050940257,
0.0132296439,
0.0026549716,
0.0038796884,
-0.011854657,
0.0129511375,
0.0183405597,
-0.007690948,
0.0545231365,
-0.0361194797,
0.0461232364,
0.0120192906,
0.006062292,
-0.07114961,
0.0601726174,
-0.0310005806,
0.0664685369,
0.0030523818,
-0.023409944,
-0.0234887004,
0.0050433762,
0.0115755051,
-0.0102730831,
0.0097728418,
0.006757102,
0.0244221296,
0.0036850448,
-0.0420234352,
-0.0613080822,
-0.0451014601,
-0.0311994907,
0.0325759985,
0.019735489,
0.0118320649,
-0.0351004899,
-0.029681135,
0.025433328,
-0.0025284742,
0.0170898326,
0.0007341699,
0.0554074422,
0.0528959446,
-0.0263225678,
-0.0298000071,
-0.0202219263,
0.0072983154,
-0.0476365238,
0.0153167667,
-0.0538285151,
0.0098150438,
-0.0262675509,
0.0469094515,
-0.0731666908,
0.0008503273,
0.0067932215,
-0.0888538659,
0.0110494327,
0.0173676256,
0.0735579357,
0.0640772209,
0.0418150276,
0.0400442816,
0.0675979331,
-0.0110471305,
-0.0327139571,
-0.0455544107,
-0.0527696721,
-0.0190247372,
-0.0140311448,
-0.0448142625,
-0.0387370139,
0.109855406,
0.0245110057,
-0.0330783166,
0.0045621172,
0.0575499162,
-0.0516534261,
-0.00918613,
0.0085068224,
-0.0223478843,
-0.0523390844,
0.0699447766,
-0.0099173002,
-0.0247357842,
0.0617697202,
0.0190210734,
-0.0142287249,
-0.0162021704,
-0.0219589379,
-0.0462830923,
0.03876362,
0.0237281546,
0.0025807975,
0.0153438319,
-0.0189066269,
-0.1048081741,
-0.0087314323,
0.0178729761,
-0.0186108276,
0.0363945179,
-0.0450861678,
-0.0237964913,
0.0404223613,
-0.0644479617,
-0.0289750323,
-0.0713692829,
-0.0372900851,
-0.0120669212,
0.0223162789,
0.0120837782,
0.0035344071,
-0.0175582711,
0.0009532843,
-0.0144594703,
-0.0173618831,
-0.0123447068,
-0.0075650574,
0.0450973138,
0.0454646274,
-0.0131379394,
0.0304795504,
-0.0147938048,
-0.0254130363,
0.0860291049,
-0.0115075121,
0.0392215699,
0.0002932122,
0.0216675811,
0.0554760285,
-0.0177438408,
-0.0889081582,
0.0216248371,
-0.0283582006,
-0.0154131763,
0.0099234655,
0.1042329893,
0.0619967654,
0.012431412,
0.0745885223,
-0.0156864226,
0.0554251224,
0.0365283675,
0.0269678291,
-0.0573071279,
-0.0130008599,
-0.0121072382,
-0.0421304032,
-0.0581688359,
-0.0018729449,
-0.0053121941,
-0.0782410204,
-0.0021929196,
-0.0066584982,
-0.0053270473,
0.0436297394,
-0.016882671,
0.0253370274,
-0.0127276881,
-0.0234802756,
0.0243458543,
-0.0260155983,
0.0206404906,
0.0348173045,
-0.005032348,
-0.0337336771,
0.0445379019,
-0.026776446,
0.0355258286,
0.0223098509,
0.0267970692,
-0.0310518462,
-0.0470788144,
0.0366707034,
-0.0049172575,
0.0172969028,
0.0100674862,
0.0024502364,
0.0122862728,
0.0076381518,
-0.0641196445,
0.0147929722,
-0.0265567955,
-0.0102654304,
-0.0074317926,
0.0462627821,
0.0031931153,
-0.0511155315,
0.0024113657,
0.0071492922,
-0.0545107238,
0.0540359393,
0.0198544711,
-0.0519661047,
0.0295806061,
-0.01957082,
-0.0009630538,
0.0456475876,
-0.0807985812,
0.0191333536,
0.0171349496,
-0.0309022181,
-0.0950017646,
-0.0467955321,
-0.0217062961,
-0.0123223485,
0.0180373304,
0.0054637985,
0.0023862817,
-0.0112989349,
-0.0217172056,
0.0433262102,
0.0486289673,
-0.0418084152,
-0.0714685917,
-0.0395421237,
0.0839457139,
-0.0543442331,
-0.0552058034,
-0.0271767452,
-0.0153417466,
-0.067058444,
0.0685109645,
0.0354769938,
0.0130145866,
-0.0164618604,
0.0402976759,
-0.0837475434,
-0.0063421261,
0.0378731154,
-0.0125284465,
0.0356080346,
0.0283144452,
-0.0233181082,
0.0293953959,
0.0333382338,
-0.0178558175,
0.0957036987,
0.0055703069,
-0.0010469758,
-0.0068920949,
-0.0711941645,
0.0465599559,
0.0016317462,
0.0668505132,
-0.0161961485,
-0.0656720623,
-0.0603403747,
0.0154169509,
-0.0253623128,
-0.0545391403,
-0.0166218914,
-0.0145411426,
0.0327116847,
0.0595014095,
-0.0726547688,
-0.0703797117,
-0.0014203452,
0.0388461724,
-0.0079488587,
-0.0059505082,
0.0173121169,
-0.0246604793,
-0.0025412559,
0.0402324423,
0.0115883239,
0.046776928,
-0.0424413309,
0.0491159074,
-0.0214737263,
0.0492829978,
-0.0217779446,
-0.0114656752,
-0.0401508845,
0.0548300147,
-0.0321403146,
0.020058332,
0.013261308,
-0.0215022005,
0.0292401183,
-0.0770325214,
0.0704152957,
-0.0585980378,
0.0217676442,
-0.0082145473,
0.0248785391,
-0.0069616418,
-0.0156833101,
-0.0070837233,
0.0491590649,
-0.0365546606,
0.0172000024,
0.090779677,
0.0235021748,
-0.0264905132,
0.0164169353,
-0.0074080396,
0.0114085255,
0.0135310022,
0.0051874691,
0.0139282541,
-0.0052111014,
0.0438916422,
-0.054214526,
-0.0199059695,
-0.0173183177,
-0.0253130756,
0.0170979686,
-0.0619464442,
0.0356385149,
0.0806984231,
-0.0187019855,
-0.0044843564,
-0.0604268909,
-0.0500296988,
-0.0057684476,
0.0092629623,
-0.0310947038,
-6.638765977e-33,
-0.0175412279,
-0.0252908301,
-0.0194934364,
0.0233373139,
0.0319343433,
0.0218203235,
0.0493226647,
0.0455882624,
-0.0036252716,
0.0258223116,
-0.0063276184,
-0.0156590585,
0.0072669121,
-0.0159099884,
0.0590104088,
0.0264977496,
-0.0248703454,
-0.0027916078,
-0.0173559133,
-0.0594574213,
0.0306886956,
0.0069093509,
0.0773218125,
-0.0241726507,
0.0036923024,
0.0306231547,
0.0125785144,
0.0158298127,
-0.0461519025,
0.0591460243,
0.0068175672,
0.0389322117,
0.0546478368,
-0.0267065987,
0.002191948,
-0.0240278635,
-0.0216873176,
-0.0468539298,
0.0656033382,
0.0065508741,
0.0144802881,
-0.0458288714,
0.045958329,
-0.0231118649,
-0.0594881326,
0.0139265032,
0.0433588326,
-0.0068650171,
0.0052679982,
0.0146108372,
-0.0288994387,
0.0026660205,
-0.0054777893,
-0.0238415431,
0.0593495145,
-0.0176529903,
-0.0284409449,
0.0155209955,
-0.0410921276,
0.0726504326,
-0.0280774385,
0.0480002835,
0.0302899759,
-0.0133939534,
-0.012087957,
0.0824981704,
0.068832919,
0.0438559614,
-0.0021783144,
0.0320925377,
0.0413419455,
0.0721080825,
-0.0143389739,
-0.0049978164,
0.0412759148,
0.001287494,
-0.0153081836,
-0.0096049113,
0.0477148108,
0.0133079821,
0.0414741002,
-0.0024142568,
-0.0714383647,
-0.046621412,
-0.0242896434,
0.0115260389,
-0.0463001989,
-0.0114950137,
0.0176271796,
-0.0333545841,
-0.0168109238,
-0.0461094156,
-0.005202095,
0.0017905906,
-0.0725496858,
-0.0076248618,
-0.0711192265,
0.0213195439,
-0.0076662223,
0.0313489586,
-0.0654834807,
-0.0090937698,
-0.0095701963,
0.0019480968,
0.0342722535,
0.0549015552,
0.0193402041,
-0.0207154341,
-0.0529372878,
-0.0321760736,
-0.022156816,
-0.0451706909,
-0.0025373688,
-0.0192245673,
0.0305501036,
0.0404888541,
-0.0208335929,
0.0500535294,
0.0354209729,
-0.0225443337,
-0.0681726784,
-0.0286916289,
0.0004952162,
0.0273939092,
-0.0030885527,
-0.0248538684,
-0.0150244208,
-0.0480727181,
0.051296588,
-0.0016400571,
-0.0179106332,
0.0137818521,
2.836e-7,
0.0240736008,
0.1289396137,
-0.0382278748,
0.0271444321,
0.0102814939,
0.0095115835,
-0.0440209769,
-0.046750728,
0.0428266376,
0.0108177541,
-0.0073707998,
0.0275469124,
0.024372045,
0.0192184821,
-0.0521919727,
0.0132207479,
-0.0219455231,
0.0318826698,
-0.0063501112,
-0.035259515,
0.0038059244,
0.0648904741,
-0.0069186459,
0.0121184923,
-0.0401934981,
-0.0093039973,
0.051675953,
-0.0256784894,
0.0054649017,
0.0108691584,
-0.0002376534,
-0.0008088432,
0.0396408699,
0.041329205,
0.0228399858,
0.0076678828,
0.0088406308,
0.0494094044,
-0.0274738036,
-0.0304187406,
0.0112219369,
-0.0137807056,
-0.0309398118,
-0.0460392833,
0.0455019958,
-0.037357185,
-0.0517425649,
0.0097471569,
-0.0117715858,
0.0113064107,
0.0075061643,
0.0092309099,
-0.0154160913,
-0.0089183962,
0.0118190469,
-0.0444337316,
-0.0247947313,
-0.0227077343,
-0.0518152453,
0.0575894825,
0.0254543498,
-0.0758011192,
0.01163188,
0.0163517836,
0.004390778,
-0.0368761383,
-0.0389773771,
2.590991587e-34,
0.0153674502,
0.0121662105,
0.0612938404,
0.0394579209,
0.0513940528,
-0.0039929356,
0.022646049,
0.0582800061,
0.0134493448,
-0.0557217263,
0.0001038563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02122v1 | Fake News Detection: It's All in the Data! | 2024-07-02T10:12:06 | 2024-07-02T10:12:06 | Soveatin Kuntur, Anna Wróblewska, Marcin Paprzycki, Maria Ganzha | cs.CL | cs.CL | This comprehensive survey serves as an indispensable resource for researchers
embarking on the journey of fake news detection. By highlighting the pivotal
role of dataset quality and diversity, it underscores the significance of these
elements in the effectiveness and robustness of detection models. The survey
meticulously outlines the key features of datasets, various labeling systems
employed, and prevalent biases that can impact model performance. Additionally,
it addresses critical ethical issues and best practices, offering a thorough
overview of the current state of available datasets. Our contribution to this
field is further enriched by the provision of GitHub repository, which
consolidates publicly accessible datasets into a single, user-friendly portal.
This repository is designed to facilitate and stimulate further research and
development efforts aimed at combating the pervasive issue of fake news. | [
0.0777116492,
0.0347211063,
-0.0276822746,
0.0529901795,
-0.0402635224,
0.0210758876,
0.0164639875,
0.0089252722,
0.0211547893,
-0.003406862,
-0.0010892187,
-0.013726091,
0.0042376602,
0.0762140825,
-0.0037060613,
-0.004767858,
0.0583684072,
0.0413317941,
0.0614007041,
-0.011120297,
0.0433640182,
0.0414293036,
-0.0230166949,
0.0114943963,
-0.0336162299,
-0.0006563611,
0.0392334573,
0.0190814678,
0.0540967621,
-0.0292003527,
0.0190387052,
0.0290368441,
-0.0080245845,
0.1000855118,
0.0000017241,
-0.005805668,
-0.023133209,
-0.004260812,
-0.047201544,
-0.0224113129,
0.0533594936,
-0.0773871839,
-0.0025236278,
0.0283670444,
-0.0356699266,
-0.0347873345,
0.0255306121,
0.0424565338,
0.0699671581,
0.1132235825,
-0.0248922855,
0.0055340328,
-0.0072425827,
-0.0068995715,
-0.0103342123,
0.0264625568,
0.071252957,
0.00667434,
-0.0486821085,
0.0289219394,
0.0455625132,
0.0104700606,
0.0181713961,
-0.0046170834,
-0.0548010245,
0.0090768151,
-0.0405292846,
-0.0599816367,
0.002552035,
-0.0018604763,
-0.0369640402,
-0.0677735433,
0.0508697517,
-0.0101168267,
0.0025794012,
0.0500101931,
0.025060717,
0.0403365344,
-0.0398942232,
0.0188282616,
-0.0023020376,
-0.0070564914,
0.0430701599,
0.0572380163,
0.0509052277,
0.0344361179,
-0.0203718171,
-0.0053138039,
-0.009486503,
-0.0077950023,
0.0157473478,
-0.0367365777,
0.0354505517,
-0.0376694016,
0.0147625078,
0.0018079369,
-0.0656057,
-0.0526292659,
0.0468128622,
-0.0738584772,
-0.023804687,
-0.022198692,
-0.0030347076,
0.0380660519,
-0.0063243946,
-0.0278592221,
-0.0078692213,
0.0362501666,
-0.0066102506,
-0.0014331652,
0.0046885773,
0.0227938127,
0.0231078211,
-0.0080793705,
-0.0155459195,
0.0368228741,
-0.0437922701,
0.0041360101,
-0.0355948061,
0.0178889874,
-0.0226633418,
-0.0022193401,
-0.0134751284,
-0.0096473088,
-0.0280920528,
-0.0029985171,
0.0024549353,
0.0364023,
-0.0033724979,
-0.0531360246,
0.0037006324,
0.0390476584,
-0.0153169977,
0.0031656919,
0.0081076901,
-0.0217591971,
0.0222419761,
0.00516464,
-0.0417849496,
-0.0415560454,
-0.005729327,
-0.0124345142,
0.0153973531,
-0.0533047952,
0.0013807667,
-0.0350027084,
-0.0031493683,
-0.0303774327,
-0.0454961397,
0.0343772545,
-0.0094700009,
0.0354221649,
-0.0301963594,
-0.0066970661,
0.0682492331,
0.0349917449,
0.0008910107,
0.1026272029,
-0.024815755,
0.1317267716,
0.070859313,
0.0259452723,
0.0273525622,
0.0127320606,
0.0804198161,
0.0382583737,
0.0251476597,
0.0159675237,
-0.0110796541,
-0.0134111978,
-0.0056345155,
-0.0141452355,
-0.0024285971,
-0.0780066177,
0.0613955818,
-0.0259076115,
0.0007841924,
-0.0319572091,
0.0378065147,
0.0260909256,
0.0039423821,
-0.0365813561,
-0.0343132913,
-0.0158199072,
-0.0464166291,
-0.0340260155,
-0.0604016818,
0.0653168336,
0.0022784355,
-0.016462598,
-0.0388733,
0.008511696,
-0.0133384028,
0.0088343527,
-0.0173728634,
0.0190028865,
-0.0024932483,
-0.0084052775,
0.0120641934,
0.027476931,
0.015151931,
-0.0508037657,
0.0438056774,
0.0073419861,
0.0147702331,
0.0081163663,
0.0193422828,
-0.0320158489,
0.0403801091,
-0.0001983277,
0.0084321415,
-0.0343006067,
-0.0388382934,
0.0067748534,
-0.0200409126,
-0.0029210881,
0.0117018688,
0.007877918,
0.057470046,
0.0368226543,
0.0071958373,
-0.0190562867,
-0.0427318439,
0.0117221521,
0.0067738858,
0.0242986493,
-0.0085921446,
0.0206509363,
0.0419897959,
0.0093870554,
0.0038253288,
-0.0440697968,
0.0577374771,
0.0476034619,
-0.0013258543,
-0.0390578397,
0.030627735,
-0.0142081035,
-0.0018423616,
-0.0639068112,
-0.0436848663,
0.0910142735,
-0.0127262436,
0.038890522,
-0.0064934143,
-0.0331408381,
-0.0312636197,
-0.0485967211,
-0.0574163459,
-0.033169087,
0.0258750655,
0.0491920151,
0.0718984306,
-0.0458209887,
0.0169662982,
0.0167625919,
0.0127167245,
0.0101902727,
0.0012842672,
0.0141427573,
-0.0142013161,
-0.0405959412,
0.0013811319,
0.0068790046,
-0.0259637553,
-0.0141222393,
0.0006362068,
-0.0209644213,
-0.0118484842,
-0.0218247082,
-0.0128902486,
0.054994937,
-0.0175055098,
-0.0149953784,
0.0263339859,
-0.0461011603,
-0.0446278639,
0.0062040458,
0.0288879126,
-0.0288759489,
-0.0364121795,
0.0151239866,
0.0249379557,
0.0301952101,
0.0079105059,
0.0226528123,
0.0212257821,
-0.0656117946,
-0.0073321466,
-0.0386011936,
-0.0457849614,
-0.0104285767,
-0.0508306473,
-0.011467509,
-0.0184042994,
0.0265001226,
-0.0333322249,
0.0278436672,
0.046416983,
0.0582595281,
0.0201943256,
0.0585273281,
0.0199957769,
-0.0556989163,
-0.0410254486,
0.0872825533,
-0.0050914525,
-0.0797433555,
0.0075714556,
0.0130140595,
0.0279186759,
0.0157099478,
0.0055712159,
0.0410957225,
-0.0206295457,
-0.0433293618,
0.0239779688,
-0.025311837,
-0.0152822537,
0.0132009387,
-0.0473621674,
-0.0333362557,
0.087534681,
0.0133382753,
0.0499264523,
-0.0151399598,
-0.0472540408,
0.0037458015,
-0.0272617284,
-0.0166613124,
0.00473997,
0.0095154438,
0.0151403062,
0.02817568,
-0.0086734183,
0.0782708973,
-0.0368509553,
-0.0193431787,
-0.0124940276,
0.0353971906,
0.0261229761,
0.0200031921,
-0.0595840923,
-0.0999407321,
-0.0011840062,
-0.0421709195,
0.011366168,
-0.0129396869,
-0.0610723682,
-0.0141264154,
0.0115311174,
0.0574775673,
-0.0162997786,
0.0213438682,
0.0383277126,
0.044933971,
0.0155609818,
-0.0206582434,
0.0513829067,
-0.0032064298,
-0.0479101799,
0.0545272157,
-0.0073268628,
0.0112980874,
0.0075223041,
-0.0103829224,
0.013689178,
0.0098300977,
0.0478934608,
-0.0327318124,
-0.0155509319,
-0.0194016751,
0.0175070949,
0.0568755604,
0.0284250844,
-0.0350362919,
-0.0103008002,
0.0330900587,
-0.023626294,
0.017285997,
-0.0460441336,
-0.0585680306,
-0.0014688626,
-0.0053926529,
0.0061598597,
-0.099538438,
-0.0334722251,
-0.0218875445,
-0.043944817,
0.0143171083,
-0.017170785,
-0.035539221,
-0.0302251521,
-0.0978104994,
-0.0117264278,
-0.023191575,
-0.0040234388,
-0.0338269584,
0.047653053,
-0.0254908092,
-0.006453786,
0.0043711071,
-0.0741982758,
-0.0070533929,
-0.0019763994,
0.0740710795,
0.0282511357,
0.0393180028,
-0.0184115227,
-0.047115054,
0.0033701656,
-0.0054843961,
-0.0728705302,
-0.004843194,
0.0833873004,
-0.0558856502,
-0.0108812489,
-0.0549234301,
0.0673587471,
0.0223443042,
-0.0091704009,
0.0051181135,
0.0100829443,
0.0205473844,
-0.0816185921,
-0.0457047075,
0.0098600695,
0.0356875509,
0.0561981685,
0.008288444,
0.0075270254,
0.0425435975,
-0.0116341533,
0.0035483006,
-0.0138827953,
-0.0484146178,
0.0506046154,
-0.0266202632,
-0.0642285869,
-0.0408835299,
-0.0273084305,
-0.0100628715,
0.0026371062,
-0.0101638325,
-0.0268707983,
0.0044842814,
-0.0167916007,
-0.0503168963,
-0.0107531203,
0.0001142751,
0.0454446301,
-0.0103769144,
-0.0147383586,
-0.0314271636,
-0.0003540002,
-0.0160375554,
0.0525062382,
-0.1019084156,
-0.0074215676,
0.041996602,
0.0041423691,
0.0147093209,
0.0426975377,
-0.0032028155,
-0.01722035,
0.0633010045,
0.0443868898,
-0.0192301311,
-0.015936859,
0.0061351066,
-0.0276767388,
0.0563199259,
0.0047847452,
-0.010808778,
0.0391742922,
0.034805283,
-0.0814508349,
-0.0545918234,
0.0517564043,
0.0310891308,
0.0010522424,
0.0233947933,
-0.0091455998,
-0.0004046176,
-0.0362361372,
-0.0573826954,
-0.0346694477,
-0.0306309368,
0.0090579307,
0.0233459417,
0.0345683098,
-0.0014604956,
-0.0065674805,
0.0362987854,
-0.04919146,
0.014523834,
-0.0315917172,
-0.0314154439,
-0.0065912213,
0.0854787678,
0.0126688667,
-0.0001538647,
-0.0446053632,
0.0255603977,
-0.0003162129,
0.0255362224,
0.0201897062,
-0.0257616527,
0.0410095453,
-0.0649006814,
0.0508863889,
-0.0241328813,
-0.0353649333,
0.0422309302,
-0.0537108965,
0.0147802364,
0.0007349821,
-0.0040137777,
0.0242269151,
-0.0079780146,
-0.0116770938,
0.0062219049,
-0.0267776828,
-0.00675978,
-0.0419200025,
-0.0314450897,
0.0246403441,
-0.0398838073,
0.0602908023,
0.0663898513,
0.0218927003,
0.0137034664,
0.0150349904,
-0.0710696131,
-0.0128772845,
0.024498364,
-0.0189817734,
0.0232686047,
-0.0091946283,
-0.018315386,
-0.0757886544,
-0.0410400219,
0.0087707378,
0.0015160061,
0.0440443903,
0.0462257266,
-0.0321772471,
0.0754784942,
0.0019447877,
0.0126664648,
-0.0246664193,
-0.0129902884,
-0.0055386261,
-0.0605987683,
0.0141565762,
-5.856459058e-33,
0.0373341031,
-0.0585050397,
-0.051391881,
-0.0469988137,
0.0163977668,
0.0759055763,
0.0307350047,
-0.0520544499,
-0.0447198711,
0.0253658686,
0.0408832207,
0.0606577583,
-0.0065306756,
0.0249365922,
-0.0655973777,
-0.0190452058,
0.0288045909,
-0.0079237306,
-0.0561964288,
0.0126650333,
0.026325956,
-0.0385427773,
0.0188772362,
-0.051485993,
0.0709948689,
-0.0271297265,
-0.0456055403,
0.0267659724,
-0.0135552641,
0.0478748307,
-0.0147325778,
0.0680401921,
0.0495394804,
-0.029878078,
0.0017734711,
0.0042011356,
-0.0212916452,
-0.0262996443,
0.0282260831,
0.0041306997,
0.0032961778,
0.0113012921,
0.0229084995,
0.0087496312,
-0.0156170251,
0.0056245569,
0.0315748639,
-0.0421070717,
-0.0050001717,
0.0182812121,
0.0186309014,
0.0139299156,
-0.0085633285,
0.0238600336,
-0.0070509543,
0.0767258108,
0.0329344422,
0.0361202881,
-0.1076630875,
0.0300815701,
-0.0368265547,
-0.0074754497,
0.0170229767,
-0.041379746,
-0.0066595594,
0.0378581733,
0.0349651687,
0.0708957091,
-0.0255819038,
0.0044672848,
-0.0060159424,
0.009959138,
0.0577643327,
0.1151913479,
0.0079209115,
-0.0915433392,
-0.0585391819,
0.0301244278,
0.044598531,
-0.0499213748,
-0.0177005678,
-0.0551671796,
-0.0310407784,
0.011279921,
0.0000265352,
-0.0376164839,
-0.0255954396,
0.0049601067,
-0.0056603295,
0.0280749593,
-0.0595543347,
0.0728937536,
-0.0029833838,
-0.0287554953,
0.0204493031,
0.0339147747,
-0.0275857411,
0.0077909073,
0.0217507258,
0.0634988099,
-0.0502759218,
0.0030642534,
0.0555680618,
-0.0052255122,
0.0000326969,
-0.0562829264,
0.0490272976,
0.0159212239,
-0.0329400524,
0.01556064,
-0.0171387102,
0.0585109033,
-0.0024269435,
-0.0236144904,
0.0037247071,
-0.0001149978,
-0.003604803,
-0.0106468033,
-0.0028920185,
-0.0082783774,
0.0055578002,
0.0221310835,
-0.0674192533,
0.0353481025,
-0.0007402272,
-0.0245652571,
-0.0377501175,
-0.0152368173,
0.0164733734,
-0.0705988631,
0.0111079961,
-0.0294087138,
2.533e-7,
-0.0207735561,
0.0187200252,
-0.0022171494,
0.0138914501,
0.0174867772,
0.0376361683,
0.0349908918,
0.0248654485,
-0.015779363,
-0.0932454541,
-0.0376237966,
-0.0070038838,
0.0154434089,
0.0400379375,
-0.0544273667,
0.0023375971,
-0.0430764928,
0.0014837536,
-0.0501691699,
0.0056344653,
-0.0238439757,
0.0624674112,
0.0593333989,
-0.0325515866,
-0.0033966056,
0.008953603,
0.0111519927,
0.024945261,
-0.022798473,
0.0027226123,
0.0619639866,
-0.0345465541,
0.0259548295,
0.0142924543,
-0.0358973742,
-0.0128640644,
-0.0121958815,
0.006910318,
0.0449782312,
-0.0047307704,
-0.0273387227,
-0.0667195991,
0.0221576914,
-0.0640468076,
0.0701591298,
0.0056478442,
-0.0376313031,
-0.0315021239,
-0.0583595186,
-0.0166619662,
0.0400481969,
-0.0035826247,
-0.010936711,
0.0432701893,
0.003260351,
0.0101847555,
0.0057068057,
-0.0093455911,
0.023143148,
-0.0297722276,
-0.0576435067,
-0.0261053089,
-0.0058807642,
-0.0267418418,
0.0521834232,
-0.0067100003,
0.0354196094,
1.857052289e-34,
0.0202545039,
-0.0318736173,
-0.0148592778,
-0.0285265129,
0.0313869789,
-0.0094640385,
-0.0267349835,
-0.0364024788,
0.0068794945,
0.026493134,
0.0081016086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02119v1 | Cost-Effective Proxy Reward Model Construction with On-Policy and Active Learning | 2024-07-02T10:09:19 | 2024-07-02T10:09:19 | Yifang Chen, Shuohang Wang, Ziyi Yang, Hiteshi Sharma, Nikos Karampatziakis, Donghan Yu, Kevin Jamieson, Simon Shaolei Du, Yelong Shen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF), as a widely adopted
approach in current large language model pipelines, is \textit{bottlenecked by
the size of human preference data}. While traditional methods rely on offline
preference dataset constructions, recent approaches have shifted towards online
settings, where a learner uses a small amount of labeled seed data and a large
pool of unlabeled prompts to iteratively construct new preference data through
self-generated responses and high-quality reward/preference feedback. However,
most current online algorithms still focus on preference labeling during policy
model updating with given feedback oracles, which incurs significant expert
query costs. \textit{We are the first to explore cost-effective proxy reward
oracles construction strategies for further labeling preferences or rewards
with extremely limited labeled data and expert query budgets}. Our approach
introduces two key innovations: (1) on-policy query to avoid OOD and imbalance
issues in seed data, and (2) active learning to select the most informative
data for preference queries. Using these methods, we train a evaluation model
with minimal expert-labeled data, which then effectively labels nine times more
preference pairs for further RLHF training. For instance, our model using
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) gains around over 1% average improvement
on AlpacaEval2, MMLU-5shot and MMLU-0shot, with only 1.7K query cost. Our
methodology is orthogonal to other direct expert query-based strategies and
therefore might be integrated with them to further reduce query costs. | [
0.0630530044,
0.0668731555,
-0.005756869,
-0.0274291933,
-0.0090795904,
0.0221100431,
-0.0016030523,
-0.0089955227,
-0.0088692233,
-0.0295946337,
-0.066275619,
-0.0305312425,
-0.0204138197,
0.0259757861,
0.0078741703,
-0.0693329573,
0.0421967544,
-0.0490449481,
0.0526687354,
-0.0395602137,
-0.0026545471,
0.0234069303,
-0.0161014572,
0.0322441719,
0.0208726116,
0.0197681952,
0.0057041333,
-0.0067226035,
-0.0121127553,
-0.0442270041,
0.0273497086,
0.0512729175,
0.0107802805,
0.0167740341,
0.0000022394,
-0.052579619,
-0.0292846784,
-0.0049299793,
-0.0225051176,
-0.0102790641,
0.0437828824,
0.0649483129,
0.0029705437,
0.0286395531,
-0.0104067829,
-0.0255270563,
0.0524638779,
0.0027847304,
0.0266972575,
0.0399309173,
0.0050897016,
-0.0053202664,
-0.0062145172,
-0.0536388047,
0.0465858094,
-0.0466678888,
-0.0002994121,
-0.0422466509,
0.01508593,
-0.0011340408,
-0.0066377018,
0.0103766927,
0.0256038737,
-0.0082359649,
0.0440749601,
0.033921171,
0.0389080159,
-0.0349353254,
-0.0055232518,
0.0725196302,
-0.0051659318,
0.0026377838,
0.0120197432,
-0.0422034413,
0.0028880313,
-0.0020211267,
0.003930504,
0.0191180799,
0.0089351963,
0.0378559045,
0.0517232232,
-0.0045847483,
0.0180766415,
0.0417653769,
-0.0393086076,
0.0836537555,
-0.023438897,
-0.0287256651,
0.0665542111,
0.0254038554,
-0.031945914,
-0.0257466864,
0.0081743449,
-0.0037175694,
-0.0948747769,
0.0106957806,
-0.0188807677,
0.0025504234,
-0.0188973099,
-0.0124410558,
0.0647764951,
0.0245906953,
-0.0151562151,
0.0445015356,
0.0238376223,
0.036700476,
0.0067503261,
0.0614215545,
-0.052696377,
0.0108607253,
-0.0417790636,
-0.0034849753,
-0.0487147607,
0.062480066,
-0.019319851,
0.0163381826,
-0.050927382,
0.0164952241,
-0.0370640084,
0.0393943079,
0.0199261513,
0.0199650843,
-0.0633089989,
0.0151212635,
-0.0731211528,
0.0373522006,
-0.0083078304,
0.0077929189,
0.024980111,
-0.0231123883,
0.0240748506,
0.0210057534,
-0.008037312,
-0.0263262112,
0.0070673916,
0.1063373685,
-0.0207879636,
-0.0386627838,
0.0237573348,
-0.0160157233,
-0.0043261452,
-0.0235665627,
-0.0138540529,
-0.0455508791,
0.0266305972,
-0.0446900465,
0.0020350693,
-0.0508823246,
0.0032728033,
0.0245025232,
-0.0308030676,
0.0365425274,
0.0013727172,
-0.0093750162,
0.0018171922,
-0.0399881639,
-0.020912813,
0.0639128312,
0.0455443747,
0.0478523299,
0.0387301184,
0.0103645148,
-0.0176174901,
-0.0066760029,
0.0518998727,
0.0258677155,
-0.0603939854,
0.0237542484,
0.0139812864,
0.0353114866,
0.0380112827,
-0.0024431732,
-0.0470018424,
0.0170282535,
0.0668093488,
-0.0099948868,
-0.0255025644,
-0.0581134185,
0.0084710214,
0.0561985672,
-0.015395836,
-0.0425179377,
-0.0286117308,
0.0384056382,
0.0104016755,
-0.0062401169,
0.0129919956,
-0.0165875219,
-0.0352170803,
-0.067555204,
0.0212175865,
-0.0009087541,
-0.0214616545,
0.0932859778,
0.0661346465,
-0.0069400058,
-0.023470806,
0.0104726665,
0.0468393974,
-0.0028175993,
0.0299700145,
-0.0567855239,
0.0422804467,
0.09303049,
0.0499763079,
-0.0319818854,
-0.0123479711,
-0.0432942361,
-0.0541507751,
0.0109332101,
0.0563774481,
-0.0637446418,
-0.0055643357,
-0.0397571437,
-0.0432337597,
0.0167784505,
0.0114735356,
0.0329761915,
0.0345376059,
-0.0191390328,
-0.0211539045,
-0.0168228131,
-0.0603188463,
0.0229219142,
0.0166160334,
-0.0545278974,
0.076460503,
0.0199101344,
0.0552981123,
0.0022970047,
-0.00145085,
0.0049393415,
0.0060201962,
0.0117195621,
-0.02187627,
-0.0313340202,
-0.0543375202,
-0.0123844575,
0.0093265334,
0.0083013577,
-0.002917991,
0.0081216935,
-0.0270790514,
-0.0299354326,
-0.0531239621,
-0.0187173225,
0.032719519,
-0.047535222,
0.017694734,
-0.0101223467,
-0.0353549272,
-0.0889773965,
0.0292983428,
-0.0205658264,
-0.0090946853,
-0.0005633095,
-0.0115393912,
-0.01424863,
-0.0647687018,
-0.0327483118,
0.0239177812,
-0.0031455706,
0.012450668,
0.0228746794,
0.0455791727,
-0.0380364209,
-0.0270870458,
-0.0137013551,
-0.0075990562,
-0.0208843015,
-0.0060657747,
0.004862308,
0.011314746,
-0.0034840719,
-0.030782586,
-0.0338696055,
-0.02505197,
-0.0224661585,
0.0417329222,
0.002976923,
0.0573175848,
0.0144864731,
-0.0463291295,
-0.0365635231,
0.0199922696,
-0.0114215733,
-0.0165479127,
0.0086004287,
-0.0139749339,
-0.0110735577,
-0.0175237749,
-0.0076243738,
0.004410529,
0.0000275518,
0.0190534573,
-0.0390088409,
-0.0295702945,
0.065996632,
0.0174968652,
0.0451119058,
0.06386666,
0.0079467883,
-0.087243475,
0.0207271259,
-0.0613007694,
-0.0527858213,
-0.0219066981,
0.0211850163,
0.0183715113,
0.0528175347,
-0.0265900511,
0.0098181823,
-0.0643289611,
-0.0201650597,
-0.0234464202,
-0.0611306764,
-0.077484414,
0.0353204422,
-0.0110035604,
0.0352074988,
-0.0142857824,
-0.0577724874,
0.0868052691,
0.0316980183,
-0.0085996538,
-0.0964761972,
-0.0067597353,
-0.0022305606,
-0.0064088083,
0.0184368789,
0.0295626596,
-0.016255632,
-0.0218668766,
-0.0495513901,
-0.0584039502,
0.0585646108,
-0.0343464538,
-0.0096882172,
-0.0323265754,
0.0256187841,
0.0022411174,
-0.0685889721,
-0.0420055166,
-0.0253572352,
-0.0272796098,
-0.0055469098,
0.0066545443,
-0.0142181506,
0.0289622732,
0.006344167,
0.0326123051,
0.050340604,
0.0012511696,
-0.0070001683,
-0.0198009182,
-0.0101139545,
0.0693144426,
0.0107504614,
-0.012941598,
-0.0316490456,
-0.0039070533,
0.018094983,
0.0865904391,
-0.0417920798,
0.0512791686,
0.0229982715,
0.0722193122,
-0.0591752045,
-0.0125198988,
0.0624893419,
-0.0106959753,
-0.0374135971,
-0.0134742269,
0.0907276049,
0.0429709218,
-0.1021567434,
0.0020336369,
0.0285630319,
0.058784496,
0.0158444792,
0.056806311,
-0.0674270019,
-0.0140576558,
0.0244420469,
0.0753232166,
-0.0127674397,
-0.020812735,
-0.0067526475,
-0.149720028,
0.0230118241,
-0.0242784042,
-0.05362745,
0.0314422622,
-0.041115135,
-0.0154824611,
-0.0517815836,
-0.0024923037,
0.0221209954,
0.0255718585,
0.0097531723,
0.0303133018,
0.0364519954,
-0.0327987,
0.0174420774,
-0.0048684613,
0.0410990156,
0.0948720276,
0.0164742358,
0.0138511043,
-0.0312567353,
0.0322312489,
-0.0151123777,
-0.0164610967,
-0.0434838906,
0.0358908586,
-0.0387268141,
-0.0140216509,
-0.0030839562,
0.0530406274,
-0.0137218488,
0.0060169599,
-0.0090753539,
0.0479100607,
-0.0112088211,
0.0331503414,
0.0166475456,
-0.0153535018,
0.0520538427,
0.0348962694,
-0.0194111466,
-0.0931700543,
-0.0183255766,
0.0079211835,
-0.051960174,
-0.0520263314,
-0.0186044164,
-0.0046599391,
-0.0199410785,
-0.0268082786,
-0.0553614162,
-0.0318184197,
0.026743006,
0.0935015902,
-0.0164567754,
0.0033101838,
-0.0069213719,
0.019556215,
-0.0160962753,
0.0198242776,
-0.0504996628,
0.0205835942,
-0.0821691453,
-0.0748580992,
0.012160141,
-0.024030026,
-0.0308905449,
-0.0518356711,
0.0176940393,
-0.0631436929,
0.0110527053,
0.0759356171,
0.0209419094,
0.0485503376,
-0.0317505375,
-0.0340065062,
0.0569683723,
0.0375600867,
-0.0490703844,
-0.0203101505,
0.0474295057,
0.0135901337,
-0.0055255662,
0.0275010876,
-0.0446938984,
-0.0016327214,
0.0466646068,
0.0258585382,
0.0225942563,
-0.0079421345,
0.0340091549,
0.0034788912,
0.0569074266,
-0.0231732633,
0.0066392571,
-0.0442248285,
0.042288065,
0.0243918709,
-0.0354634263,
-0.0287627745,
-0.0042039538,
0.0085867615,
0.0015148513,
-0.0023291437,
-0.0107456278,
0.0272002183,
0.0275033452,
0.0178850833,
-0.0081594959,
0.0202494804,
0.0437621772,
0.0188621096,
0.0264613163,
0.0046002124,
0.0237478148,
0.0280951913,
0.0716814026,
0.0085950606,
0.0382844098,
0.0425364599,
0.0162414871,
-0.0039644022,
0.0028518487,
-0.027176071,
-0.0781918541,
-0.0480151474,
0.0158806387,
0.0537924692,
-0.0222216398,
0.0465985276,
-0.0255433246,
-0.0094112009,
-0.0075322837,
-0.0021939115,
-0.0335250646,
-0.0290431846,
0.0173248909,
0.0323110335,
-0.0002123275,
0.0157737713,
0.0714622959,
0.0513021052,
0.0394377187,
-0.0342262723,
0.0038479473,
-0.020446429,
0.0061229286,
0.0102872113,
0.031403847,
-0.0380984657,
0.0027533388,
-0.0258039739,
-0.0520013571,
-0.0542666577,
0.007609006,
-0.0095306132,
0.0104329698,
0.0867184177,
0.0300964341,
-0.0216026623,
0.0205013733,
-0.0789860338,
-0.0217386875,
-0.0023601782,
-0.0180972237,
0.0140939057,
-6.76210766e-33,
-0.0301590897,
-0.0081872856,
0.0154518355,
-0.0436050072,
-0.0183883402,
-0.0165437162,
-0.012512519,
-0.0090516908,
0.016327804,
-0.0053179222,
-0.0242631827,
-0.0313041434,
0.0234787427,
0.0144112036,
0.02385897,
-0.0165473111,
0.0504485816,
-0.0163267273,
-0.050882984,
0.0342584625,
0.0314072147,
0.0048929206,
0.0295174848,
-0.0416846834,
0.0335679017,
0.0638045669,
-0.0215629432,
0.0313304998,
-0.0198004544,
0.0601428933,
0.0223522801,
0.045043014,
-0.0146388877,
-0.0537309684,
-0.0167535245,
-0.0363780521,
-0.0865600705,
-0.0205491614,
-0.0316067711,
0.0121421842,
-0.0088676428,
0.0067027006,
-0.0094379252,
0.0159571823,
-0.0119916024,
0.0200991612,
0.019877186,
-0.0103076929,
-0.0651500598,
0.0179491509,
0.002501315,
-0.000903094,
0.0054437509,
0.0277055688,
0.0166402925,
0.051737126,
-0.0162596405,
0.0269736703,
-0.0376358181,
0.0562364422,
0.0078511834,
0.0464263409,
0.0274551157,
0.028559126,
0.033900734,
0.0083281659,
0.0466451943,
0.0041237068,
0.0602072403,
0.0184870157,
0.033209879,
0.0048548598,
0.0086555984,
0.0275656972,
0.056547489,
-0.0231766887,
-0.0161126964,
0.0202049334,
0.0322900601,
0.0046482007,
0.0455597602,
0.0334838517,
-0.0577170178,
-0.0514166541,
-0.071912244,
-0.0275977235,
-0.0360644497,
-0.0438948236,
0.0476351529,
0.0535173081,
-0.0464543439,
-0.0139221493,
0.0205143727,
-0.0113629736,
-0.0523920618,
-0.0196500402,
-0.0123110814,
0.0290891323,
-0.008339053,
-0.0071345847,
-0.105121538,
-0.0577784553,
-0.0093221385,
-0.0395630039,
-0.0454201587,
0.0217267722,
0.0190781653,
0.0405300893,
-0.0590750352,
0.0202423092,
-0.014235842,
0.0085494863,
0.0075248792,
0.041238416,
0.0325856134,
-0.0306136552,
0.0063372357,
0.0856336951,
-0.0015897033,
-0.0284281522,
-0.0274430756,
-0.0264991131,
-0.0214643106,
-0.0012848791,
-0.0181583595,
0.0235148109,
-0.0192509983,
-0.0273617767,
-0.0233842637,
-0.0212503839,
-0.0189911909,
-0.0071736346,
2.974e-7,
-0.0113711134,
0.0593447238,
-0.0169917922,
-0.0140486984,
-0.0074823583,
0.0581411943,
0.0224788841,
0.0070800371,
0.030106917,
0.0256364569,
0.0330034271,
0.0112027777,
0.0256231409,
0.0187714864,
-0.1074026003,
-0.0206337459,
-0.0381500535,
0.0279469118,
-0.0429816246,
-0.0330808796,
0.0152778048,
0.0801431388,
0.0441731066,
-0.0195133481,
0.0277499519,
0.0281071551,
0.0303489286,
-0.0309234597,
-0.0010383354,
0.0027753736,
0.0151357464,
0.0175867658,
-0.0221670661,
0.0002684474,
-0.0218847096,
0.0204897951,
-0.0052759834,
0.0569494218,
0.0053551453,
-0.0640558898,
0.014324096,
0.0111986389,
0.0250457916,
-0.0437620394,
0.0564855337,
-0.0331684649,
-0.0138361724,
-0.0098620765,
0.0004454127,
-0.052751556,
0.0186491068,
-0.0382503718,
-0.0386307165,
-0.0067584901,
0.02169168,
0.034930978,
-0.0153549695,
-0.0646723583,
0.0201272201,
0.0255122129,
-0.0063253678,
-0.0427481867,
-0.0433266275,
0.069075197,
-0.0348853953,
-0.0189063773,
0.0064592585,
2.820379897e-34,
0.0228707884,
-0.0053414069,
0.0170618836,
0.0004416192,
0.0040141125,
0.0358026028,
0.0124951899,
-0.0113302162,
0.0684230924,
-0.0552596003,
-0.020273434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02118v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02118v1 | Breaking Language Barriers: Cross-Lingual Continual Pre-Training at Scale | 2024-07-02T10:06:41 | 2024-07-02T10:06:41 | Wenzhen Zheng, Wenbo Pan, Xu Xu, Libo Qin, Li Yue, Ming Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant strides
towards Artificial General Intelligence. However, training these models from
scratch requires substantial computational resources and vast amounts of text
data. In this paper, we explore an alternative approach to constructing an LLM
for a new language by continually pretraining (CPT) from existing pretrained
LLMs, instead of using randomly initialized parameters. Based on parallel
experiments on 40 model sizes ranging from 40M to 5B parameters, we find that
1) CPT converges faster and saves significant resources in a scalable manner;
2) CPT adheres to an extended scaling law derived from Hoffmann et al. (2022)
with a joint data-parameter scaling term; 3) The compute-optimal data-parameter
allocation for CPT markedly differs based on our estimated scaling factors; 4)
The effectiveness of transfer at scale is influenced by training duration and
linguistic properties, while robust to data replaying, a method that
effectively mitigates catastrophic forgetting in CPT. We hope our findings
provide deeper insights into the transferability of LLMs at scale for the
research community. | [
0.0012049719,
0.0512965359,
-0.0191119239,
0.0130653065,
-0.0246450324,
0.0281261876,
0.0190563723,
-0.024446141,
-0.0037925476,
-0.020258246,
-0.0428609848,
-0.0834076479,
-0.0243611969,
0.0348800458,
-0.0027045857,
-0.0399433263,
0.0496181212,
-0.0580642484,
-0.0339321159,
-0.0461747497,
-0.0206887685,
-0.011673715,
0.0201449804,
-0.0062114922,
-0.01087787,
-0.006918699,
-0.0091992216,
-0.0342405401,
-0.0005513288,
-0.0414341874,
-0.0079814857,
0.029882282,
0.0461826771,
0.0253722183,
0.0000023241,
-0.0636291504,
-0.0119024683,
-0.0198517181,
-0.0176972188,
0.0309399143,
0.0354639105,
-0.0308521204,
-0.0033846872,
0.0283805002,
-0.0470597073,
-0.0470946841,
0.0487532839,
-0.0124137839,
0.0515442342,
0.0645720288,
-0.0062561375,
-0.046770826,
0.0526840985,
-0.0340189263,
-0.0258107278,
-0.0716663152,
0.0379733779,
0.0263174195,
-0.046568267,
0.0039604064,
-0.0212823413,
0.0442511998,
0.039188873,
0.0226356797,
0.0019429909,
0.0209651403,
-0.0217155553,
-0.0107667465,
-0.0419510938,
0.0649907514,
-0.0425221287,
-0.03951215,
-0.0179130398,
-0.0062540895,
-0.0263192002,
-0.0010296231,
-0.0336578377,
0.0449660979,
0.0422212631,
0.037521556,
0.039527528,
-0.0273206457,
0.0520578139,
-0.0013551582,
-0.075002864,
0.0320545323,
0.0321553983,
-0.0125709251,
0.0312689841,
0.0087102605,
-0.0394186042,
-0.0310164336,
0.0160960127,
0.0460623167,
-0.0080819894,
0.0184270702,
-0.0708051473,
-0.0116920974,
0.0139340796,
-0.0397498608,
0.0671854317,
0.0170525126,
-0.0069137304,
0.0843133926,
-0.0227261614,
0.0433779135,
-0.012968841,
0.0035005303,
-0.031364046,
-0.0361533463,
-0.0636517629,
-0.0035623752,
-0.0556337014,
0.0216158815,
0.0114769982,
-0.0201628394,
-0.0129320864,
0.0278385002,
0.000459861,
-0.0238044448,
0.0175611973,
-0.0458522253,
-0.0335589983,
-0.0247923993,
0.0023958755,
0.0339088626,
-0.0391374156,
0.0206758585,
-0.0088222576,
-0.0608714744,
-0.0109547675,
0.0081103565,
-0.0126321996,
-0.0263810698,
0.0681863353,
0.0584892854,
-0.0264506042,
-0.0334974527,
-0.0759376362,
0.0163153931,
0.0054526329,
-0.0673133284,
0.0041669193,
-0.0515059493,
0.0580981337,
0.0053915875,
0.003960852,
-0.0445070937,
-0.013309285,
0.0067143934,
-0.0506594628,
0.0728121474,
0.0043091173,
0.0474488102,
0.019937424,
-0.0135733997,
0.0184682589,
0.0722115338,
0.0305567589,
-0.0146209849,
0.0487746038,
-0.0254078731,
-0.0105424924,
0.0575418547,
0.036719121,
0.0500548743,
-0.0247165821,
-0.0004060636,
0.064437367,
0.0041933563,
0.0433812216,
0.0332304128,
-0.0142704062,
-0.0116913859,
0.0516534299,
0.0716741532,
-0.021168977,
0.091058515,
0.0635636225,
-0.0094360365,
0.0001368734,
-0.0384974852,
-0.0500844605,
-0.0078127738,
-0.0256671626,
-0.0092664408,
-0.001602961,
0.0680613443,
-0.0586340763,
-0.0013177558,
0.0086022234,
-0.0167943966,
0.0108448518,
-0.0031966052,
0.0709664598,
0.0109293219,
-0.023950493,
0.0748532265,
0.0596401878,
-0.0449005961,
0.0041635837,
-0.0249185264,
-0.0130266743,
0.032605283,
0.0020893028,
-0.0245481338,
-0.006851845,
0.0163440946,
0.0589220226,
-0.0076541472,
0.0830990821,
0.010194838,
0.036043793,
-0.0631481037,
0.0023595083,
0.0085639991,
-0.0041286387,
0.0607253052,
0.0212293379,
0.0788695961,
-0.0001506265,
-0.0258193705,
-0.0486107692,
0.0303809997,
-0.0855814219,
-0.0343252532,
0.0121816387,
-0.0193380415,
0.0354002789,
-0.0036633464,
-0.0187585969,
-0.0210859813,
0.0063042636,
-0.0493510626,
-0.001761116,
0.0091410195,
-0.0859361291,
-0.0054462315,
0.0349485427,
0.0153026711,
0.0329815969,
0.003090255,
-0.0258828625,
-0.0266947858,
0.0247537699,
0.0317335874,
0.0694689751,
-0.0409174338,
0.0635096878,
-0.0335807428,
0.0457226634,
-0.0112370364,
0.0216171052,
-0.0077379434,
-0.0209046025,
-0.0024336712,
0.001397514,
0.0300611593,
-0.0584592223,
-0.0445389599,
0.0381778255,
-0.0002552354,
0.0314359628,
-0.0092039993,
0.0344713368,
-0.0166848768,
-0.003537931,
-0.0874037594,
0.015338419,
-0.0299768709,
0.0231480617,
0.0147423428,
0.0107654762,
-0.0143663539,
-0.0118385404,
-0.0389308669,
0.0255805813,
0.0012384705,
0.0332441553,
0.003664166,
-0.0135884359,
-0.014150762,
-0.0252448246,
-0.035452202,
0.0293109454,
0.0654717609,
-0.0089179231,
0.0092816772,
-0.0610530972,
0.067560643,
-0.0104225632,
0.0471448004,
-0.0086499052,
-0.0345706679,
-0.0283490103,
-0.0271897838,
0.037542481,
0.0582418703,
-0.0054837805,
-0.0123174312,
0.0670241788,
-0.026799662,
-0.0495466813,
-0.0005752042,
-0.0207956843,
-0.0607068911,
-0.0294828974,
-0.025624346,
0.0107726231,
0.0842270926,
-0.0356251486,
-0.0257087816,
-0.0568563417,
0.0056193527,
-0.0353666358,
-0.0211885925,
-0.0417749472,
0.0216432046,
-0.0108392825,
0.0250826888,
-0.002478821,
-0.0580221117,
0.0245263595,
-0.0307291355,
0.0103220763,
-0.0332363993,
-0.0294994172,
-0.0228670891,
0.0574081577,
0.0066952794,
0.0252081454,
-0.021422388,
0.0051241876,
-0.044192601,
0.0240387321,
0.0182260871,
-0.0043597105,
0.0007179512,
-0.0483427048,
0.0272267703,
0.007999707,
-0.0368372835,
-0.0426461175,
-0.0339353345,
-0.0143369455,
0.0022368561,
0.0209017824,
-0.0108489133,
-0.0251839254,
0.0102464296,
0.0168735012,
0.0448517352,
0.0125489905,
0.0060345051,
0.0037366487,
0.0011299804,
-0.00240605,
0.0062497417,
0.016801795,
-0.0374535955,
0.0192094818,
0.0125377551,
0.0451788008,
-0.0211446509,
-0.0231318828,
0.0134247253,
0.0295102913,
-0.0266887881,
-0.0323863439,
0.0039811842,
0.0431180187,
-0.0390919149,
-0.0373318866,
0.0846279562,
0.0147314006,
-0.062861003,
0.0110210823,
-0.0017519094,
0.0240551569,
0.0067087389,
0.052640751,
-0.0762340873,
-0.0126179364,
0.0294682439,
0.0093356855,
0.0217231531,
-0.0280206371,
-0.0334055349,
-0.1158272028,
-0.0104247322,
0.0345169865,
-0.0417082347,
-0.0143223125,
-0.0413327031,
-0.0354603492,
-0.0167495143,
0.0315656401,
0.0086532766,
-0.0333341919,
0.001535109,
-0.000723805,
-0.0114801265,
-0.0481381416,
0.0525179617,
-0.0469434038,
0.0731024593,
0.0306018312,
0.0022755053,
0.0036092184,
-0.0258341674,
0.0643109679,
-0.0095604379,
-0.0209677145,
-0.0170849748,
0.0425966904,
0.0195780173,
-0.0224821549,
0.0269301273,
0.0084256474,
-0.0313459113,
-0.0187172331,
0.0455724746,
0.0760865211,
0.0294345655,
-0.0342723653,
0.0433629192,
-0.0321888998,
-0.0009361148,
0.0939656869,
0.0136037199,
-0.0501292124,
-0.032435935,
0.0046297368,
-0.0142705292,
-0.0348033756,
-0.0367263742,
0.0253537316,
-0.0558499247,
-0.0075172149,
-0.0450713076,
-0.0301734246,
0.0039308965,
0.0359036028,
0.0400802232,
-0.0103581985,
0.0183454901,
0.0194941964,
-0.0369987302,
0.0302222352,
-0.0582881235,
-0.0187889636,
-0.1028468311,
-0.0220727939,
0.0323882625,
-0.0328089856,
-0.0117860604,
-0.0027763213,
-0.0717015788,
-0.0566817597,
0.0350191034,
0.0275131725,
0.0199382547,
0.0756686628,
0.0205964949,
-0.059830118,
0.0775433928,
-0.0109689003,
-0.0312375426,
0.0422005244,
0.0538262799,
0.0114179887,
0.0119151026,
0.0470035672,
-0.0223650038,
0.032466501,
0.0330678634,
0.0252299681,
-0.0276526101,
-0.0215488113,
-0.0194561314,
0.0366113745,
-0.0138424793,
0.0039295834,
0.0072142412,
-0.0355225913,
0.0195726324,
0.010662456,
0.0259750206,
-0.0550486371,
0.006200443,
0.029040046,
0.0173001867,
-0.0087227356,
-0.006777416,
0.0296272915,
-0.0088612298,
-0.0126988431,
-0.0143882418,
-0.0253235735,
0.0440661348,
0.0561307445,
0.0181884207,
-0.0112991976,
0.020799391,
0.0013657283,
0.0347665735,
-0.051908575,
0.0383502468,
0.0011764925,
0.0049204496,
-0.0422552489,
0.0232645608,
-0.0356170163,
-0.1147478744,
-0.0112724081,
0.0303825326,
0.0718313381,
0.0046987399,
0.0602820478,
-0.0256491117,
-0.0118954787,
-0.0235684179,
0.0061443318,
-0.0037855757,
-0.005930726,
-0.003545684,
-0.0006422868,
-0.0268230364,
0.0512811802,
0.0845539123,
0.0066933082,
0.0273018684,
0.008727286,
0.0113520967,
-0.0141349202,
-0.0014743049,
0.0014578971,
-0.0053472319,
-0.0151594393,
0.0126110706,
-0.0181575064,
-0.0764490068,
-0.015544788,
-0.0225625914,
-0.0110876141,
0.0191378836,
0.0233152583,
0.0663542822,
-0.0238503441,
0.0336413644,
-0.0196431596,
0.0294800065,
0.0301923007,
-0.0088606738,
0.0206026863,
-7.043093422e-33,
0.0142433932,
0.065309301,
0.0422668979,
-0.0084802629,
-0.0179294962,
-0.0056599327,
-0.0285629798,
-0.0052622692,
-0.0133210691,
0.0080616474,
-0.0326431431,
-0.0145986099,
0.0194580983,
0.0520826541,
0.0170294344,
-0.0106444154,
0.0358629674,
-0.0100117736,
0.0032870409,
0.0589733273,
0.0414688885,
0.0517748706,
0.0417138301,
-0.0453092419,
-0.0174246784,
0.0226849858,
0.0161911249,
0.0351915918,
0.036682602,
0.0116783073,
-0.0420603566,
0.0161348321,
0.0129466821,
-0.0522078387,
-0.0325728878,
-0.0144583704,
-0.0817706883,
-0.0378334336,
0.0017273584,
0.0349791683,
-0.0094790421,
-0.028444482,
0.0151132513,
-0.0311233606,
-0.0170395952,
-0.0044928058,
0.004029165,
-0.031213291,
-0.0194581226,
-0.0144321918,
-0.0620693043,
0.0070429388,
0.0140548544,
0.0207019579,
0.0404554717,
-0.0170636643,
-0.0355949588,
0.0174898077,
-0.048388347,
0.0182395652,
0.0325363353,
0.010399688,
0.0478893742,
0.0248168968,
0.0401891693,
0.0415117219,
0.0403618552,
0.0096744113,
0.0105956038,
-0.0059294878,
0.0573967248,
-0.0035469648,
0.0010844656,
0.0227449536,
0.0429452509,
-0.0254768394,
-0.0781774148,
-0.020315161,
0.0344452858,
0.0073275981,
0.0207648128,
0.0040092054,
-0.0053213835,
-0.0526398011,
-0.0379290543,
-0.0216864403,
-0.0267351046,
-0.033465486,
0.0498098731,
0.0069081439,
-0.0143476622,
-0.02992451,
0.0608636253,
-0.0355093554,
-0.0378225967,
0.029588908,
-0.0000022052,
-0.0034358476,
-0.0080715688,
0.0376023129,
-0.0815381408,
-0.0563746355,
-0.0401768647,
-0.030832164,
0.0176528301,
0.0167187415,
0.0222898107,
0.032173004,
-0.066637367,
-0.0154450322,
-0.0323231444,
0.0055911671,
0.0616285205,
0.0364987217,
0.0242103096,
0.0203578733,
0.0157270078,
0.0560640171,
0.0607295744,
-0.0374563895,
-0.0204477422,
-0.0177297238,
0.0304823611,
0.0583888665,
-0.0373401418,
-0.0092815561,
-0.054930076,
-0.0022500653,
0.0552867241,
-0.0872587338,
-0.0205125976,
-0.0072845966,
2.969e-7,
0.0134601258,
0.0309605673,
-0.0178010631,
-0.0194504187,
-0.0036235915,
0.0124012297,
-0.0240407027,
0.0241929907,
0.0170438085,
0.0536755063,
0.0105761774,
0.083932139,
0.0319484547,
0.0091148578,
-0.0648496449,
-0.0258339588,
-0.0636368468,
0.0138587179,
-0.0454314314,
-0.0159723293,
-0.0303694885,
0.0797214955,
0.0326608568,
-0.0254193917,
0.009875766,
-0.077428475,
0.0793277845,
-0.0708203837,
0.0066276779,
0.0362636782,
-0.0236563794,
0.0595701039,
-0.0420348309,
0.0281681381,
-0.0181590822,
0.0308253951,
-0.0110976379,
0.0481523983,
0.0030485617,
0.012461409,
0.0144677525,
-0.0176314879,
-0.0390903354,
-0.0621004775,
0.0847755149,
-0.0778474063,
-0.0265187062,
-0.0003567722,
0.0044773677,
-0.0386144295,
0.0181154963,
-0.0293533038,
0.0110489717,
0.0281306319,
0.0273793116,
0.0300838798,
-0.0246549584,
-0.0769757405,
0.0238417406,
0.0310745258,
-0.029932173,
-0.0562297516,
-0.0457885601,
-0.0114769414,
0.0246451944,
-0.0396117382,
0.0666461289,
2.895615897e-34,
0.0437400974,
-0.0144332005,
0.0266667902,
0.0118266037,
0.0051230029,
-0.0223548468,
0.0208117589,
0.0031058548,
-0.01307829,
-0.1010758057,
-0.0132647781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02099v1 | Helpful assistant or fruitful facilitator? Investigating how personas affect language model behavior | 2024-07-02T09:36:54 | 2024-07-02T09:36:54 | Pedro Henrique Luz de Araujo, Benjamin Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | One way to personalize and steer generations from large language models (LLM)
is to assign a persona: a role that describes how the user expects the LLM to
behave (e.g., a helpful assistant, a teacher, a woman). This paper investigates
how personas affect diverse aspects of model behavior. We assign to seven LLMs
162 personas from 12 categories spanning variables like gender, sexual
orientation, and occupation. We prompt them to answer questions from five
datasets covering objective (e.g., questions about math and history) and
subjective tasks (e.g., questions about beliefs and values). We also compare
persona's generations to two baseline settings: a control persona setting with
30 paraphrases of "a helpful assistant" to control for models' prompt
sensitivity, and an empty persona setting where no persona is assigned. We find
that for all models and datasets, personas show greater variability than the
control setting and that some measures of persona behavior generalize across
models. | [
0.0887645185,
0.0489915833,
-0.0474096723,
0.0122965276,
-0.0120984083,
0.0005452858,
0.0456561409,
-0.0228090174,
-0.0028106491,
-0.0133944219,
0.0144650014,
-0.057061974,
-0.0312040709,
-0.0087631578,
0.018359663,
-0.0702520683,
0.0444599167,
-0.0093445387,
0.0508798361,
-0.0113889202,
0.0060978644,
0.0387467965,
-0.0059548886,
0.0803184211,
-0.0107258819,
-0.024529228,
0.0095658731,
-0.0267665535,
0.0073776771,
0.016338896,
0.0806025192,
0.0388047844,
0.0326819085,
-0.0075834491,
0.0000020405,
-0.0717426017,
0.0214330517,
-0.0183354653,
-0.0574286394,
-0.0228606444,
0.0316754133,
0.0568992682,
-0.0144626321,
0.040804334,
-0.0564015247,
0.0040184315,
0.0060855015,
0.0100680552,
0.0304417927,
0.0072855386,
-0.0008957062,
-0.0049140882,
-0.0300832037,
0.0180699434,
0.0044846642,
-0.0320753828,
-0.019335188,
-0.0172354709,
-0.0032476396,
0.0189873297,
0.0098762102,
0.0294459723,
0.0114214402,
-0.0596643761,
0.0215924084,
0.0021904509,
0.0019946229,
-0.0307669472,
0.0036370968,
0.0319900736,
0.0775990635,
-0.0097805979,
-0.0273817834,
0.0194794275,
0.0478575602,
0.0808935091,
-0.0258148946,
0.025461195,
-0.010682703,
-0.0437729917,
0.0095827719,
-0.0280805882,
-0.0072429078,
0.0102670379,
0.0025412401,
0.0683640167,
-0.0041288342,
-0.0270452965,
-0.0136341006,
0.0229834095,
0.0110009843,
-0.0546638072,
0.0173322149,
0.02206113,
-0.0631598011,
0.0400424302,
-0.0293571148,
0.0099811638,
0.0057075769,
-0.0356210656,
0.0392986387,
0.0584447235,
0.0042116991,
0.0180018228,
0.0179415978,
0.0339659974,
0.0091008181,
0.0070719551,
0.0012952429,
-0.0039425665,
-0.0528411604,
-0.0340370499,
-0.0288561918,
-0.0132728023,
0.0414209664,
0.0189851243,
0.0034575404,
0.0345783047,
-0.0000548784,
0.0065439041,
-0.0126369549,
0.0099241436,
-0.0229903888,
-0.0215551611,
-0.0725151673,
0.0703245923,
-0.0822824538,
0.0141339544,
-0.0216500703,
-0.0682326108,
0.0390233919,
-0.0169540122,
0.0212126393,
-0.0079381699,
-0.0145215904,
0.0129259592,
-0.007007075,
-0.0252120718,
-0.0276316404,
-0.0311623197,
0.0162248705,
-0.0540831201,
-0.0412120298,
-0.042826537,
0.0043440494,
0.0534654818,
-0.0041520279,
-0.040381331,
-0.0009789936,
0.0445522368,
-0.013182533,
0.0476067215,
0.0229373705,
0.062698707,
0.0638951659,
0.007752385,
-0.0295922533,
0.0680792183,
0.0186602287,
-0.0123806307,
0.0219971221,
-0.0397438779,
0.0151635511,
0.0362306684,
-0.03486057,
0.036256019,
0.010857312,
0.0215246268,
0.0193964876,
-0.0040591452,
0.0479039587,
0.0268463586,
-0.0046300711,
0.0086363172,
0.0796160027,
0.0653878748,
-0.0000529019,
0.048214376,
0.0566317663,
-0.0042347927,
0.03069341,
0.0184846334,
-0.0443160571,
-0.0057437499,
-0.0023122868,
-0.0394049585,
-0.0475098193,
-0.0002858671,
-0.0183499027,
-0.0564609095,
-0.0058216578,
0.0074524255,
-0.0182801113,
0.0305399541,
-0.0041878563,
0.0184682216,
-0.0053713513,
0.0396699794,
0.0115993097,
-0.0853020251,
-0.0089965267,
-0.0451942869,
0.0431580096,
0.0880304128,
0.0105857765,
-0.0281080175,
-0.0276951138,
-0.0243860371,
0.0403950885,
0.0324593969,
0.1054189429,
-0.0070312344,
-0.0297010336,
-0.0167350285,
-0.0253685452,
0.0087359818,
0.0056461412,
0.0053213206,
0.0395775177,
0.0017873404,
0.0040650964,
0.0026604042,
-0.037801899,
0.0108037423,
-0.0886595026,
-0.0207796637,
-0.0239293836,
0.0292823836,
0.0004701115,
0.0325579792,
0.0238311552,
0.0010116071,
0.0082884571,
-0.0013910481,
0.0052739675,
0.0178656932,
-0.044263348,
0.0476447903,
0.026564816,
0.0225132424,
-0.039753329,
0.0043207984,
0.0262827519,
0.0079751834,
0.0454832576,
-0.0462186672,
0.0463659167,
-0.0096227787,
0.0172088109,
-0.0452712327,
-0.0255289748,
-0.0210463423,
0.0399334319,
-0.013121374,
0.0020283579,
0.0382656939,
0.0214728322,
-0.0262410827,
-0.0459933989,
-0.0035977105,
-0.0305467937,
0.0024555833,
0.02293602,
0.0559825674,
-0.0133741861,
-0.0577104613,
-0.0246184878,
-0.0735612959,
-0.0219623502,
-0.0122123249,
0.0120982518,
0.0339074135,
0.0000717347,
-0.0272745099,
-0.0109269209,
-0.0597044379,
0.0019076024,
0.0006498121,
0.0257991087,
0.0544015951,
-0.0224735681,
-0.0109970048,
-0.0632569566,
0.0088192858,
-0.0230358671,
-0.0172314197,
0.0225095488,
-0.0018738637,
-0.0453019328,
0.0008905145,
-0.0387642533,
0.0023445082,
-0.0173362829,
-0.0240743198,
0.0527241156,
-0.006129411,
0.0867765322,
0.0811264962,
0.0173764545,
0.054583706,
0.0071369568,
0.0202275552,
-0.0747582689,
0.0062137297,
0.0000639252,
-0.0340617374,
-0.0181437247,
-0.0539632775,
0.0151263736,
0.0419403426,
0.0108321821,
-0.0050344937,
-0.0580644161,
0.0547325946,
-0.040093109,
-0.0227983762,
0.0265383478,
-0.006151529,
-0.023448173,
0.0627164617,
0.0040688114,
-0.0464410558,
0.0474332981,
0.0225435384,
-0.0396970734,
-0.0078716427,
-0.033760041,
-0.0388876796,
0.0466800593,
-0.0186376739,
0.0261677094,
0.0280810371,
-0.0404719003,
-0.067093797,
0.0084269652,
0.0269461647,
-0.051700525,
0.0453918427,
-0.0545478761,
-0.0055218274,
0.0306168776,
-0.0170804728,
-0.0349665619,
-0.0199327245,
-0.0194692388,
-0.0236340389,
0.0164174009,
-0.0246164165,
-0.0276957247,
-0.0301983561,
0.0209998786,
0.0145881157,
-0.0333637372,
-0.0073790373,
-0.0172019117,
-0.0304387994,
0.0280392841,
0.0542674176,
0.015906198,
-0.0569705553,
0.0426932573,
0.0118213883,
-0.0205288082,
-0.0344044641,
0.006149943,
-0.017125072,
0.0705468506,
-0.0210521519,
-0.0625239909,
0.0413244516,
0.0786594898,
-0.059518151,
0.020905083,
0.1092849895,
0.051140558,
-0.0676205233,
0.0020286625,
-0.0643341988,
0.0369418412,
0.037964996,
0.0313751325,
-0.0436064713,
0.0224483255,
-0.00583066,
0.0178273264,
-0.0307110194,
-0.0257780999,
-0.0305170063,
-0.1021019593,
0.0267849229,
-0.0148666669,
-0.0208225641,
0.021262072,
-0.0273934156,
0.038719859,
0.005407922,
0.0515246801,
-0.0003210046,
-0.0264782533,
-0.0050988435,
0.0187650286,
-0.0276082214,
-0.0463019013,
0.0156871285,
-0.0576847941,
0.0644823462,
0.067567274,
0.0230001304,
-0.0023238629,
-0.0291194711,
-0.010707926,
0.0597288124,
0.0237696748,
-0.0028112598,
0.0233255271,
-0.0211324766,
0.0196821652,
-0.0438328162,
0.0168734808,
-0.0096671451,
0.0315735005,
0.0431507267,
0.0325103588,
0.0105607538,
-0.0315988846,
-0.0185592566,
-0.0009220209,
0.0160264075,
0.0475438461,
0.0337289274,
-0.0715687424,
0.0160315111,
-0.0447981618,
0.0064091203,
0.0290729105,
-0.0594173297,
-0.0224208292,
-0.0062712566,
-0.0280369688,
-0.0390096083,
-0.0670050755,
0.0684231818,
-0.0019010324,
0.0215647966,
-0.0247066543,
-0.0029020791,
0.0060520554,
-0.0005426921,
0.0138994856,
-0.0505431071,
0.0573786311,
-0.0879613236,
-0.0637342408,
-0.0033618489,
-0.0151143549,
0.023630105,
-0.0355877727,
-0.0029588637,
-0.0525233522,
0.0347196534,
0.0534462333,
0.0282526668,
0.0075195595,
0.0208438709,
-0.0836232603,
-0.0226486176,
0.0017762895,
-0.0385148637,
0.0143733555,
-0.0014519575,
0.0352550372,
-0.0131765595,
0.0425998457,
-0.0059603751,
0.0117557617,
-0.0250250194,
0.0003735569,
-0.0541354977,
-0.1016208008,
0.0352459662,
0.0253548492,
-0.0226406101,
0.0103330873,
0.0184151754,
-0.0117393583,
-0.0301444661,
-0.027560439,
-0.0353959799,
-0.0201427378,
-0.0188696552,
0.0078473659,
-0.0160382371,
0.0508612171,
-0.0422054492,
-0.0325620696,
0.0283129569,
-0.0432388857,
0.0231109764,
0.0006743078,
0.0548903197,
0.0170010198,
0.0276729278,
-0.0174458791,
-0.0221710373,
0.0266873669,
0.041989211,
0.0240975227,
0.079211235,
-0.0189973023,
0.0145991659,
-0.0059458488,
0.0048570484,
-0.0360105224,
-0.1069983989,
0.0346680284,
0.0263325237,
0.0032387869,
-0.0122250682,
0.0499357283,
-0.026734326,
0.0104724979,
-0.0052302568,
0.0003949018,
0.0560395159,
-0.0151496902,
0.0273381528,
0.0029727749,
-0.0036730056,
-0.0385460332,
0.0339576006,
0.0103022419,
0.03920535,
-0.0469899438,
-0.000473807,
-0.0453431085,
-0.0033635853,
0.0396910422,
-0.0038133655,
-0.0222175475,
0.0139199598,
-0.0939340815,
-0.0188826937,
-0.0456867553,
-0.020757392,
-0.022764327,
-0.0537961125,
0.0128513332,
0.0222736727,
-0.0219270959,
-0.0607924163,
-0.0710358024,
0.0144909536,
-0.03625324,
0.029935563,
-0.0405019522,
-5.941229098e-33,
-0.0480737053,
-0.0472995825,
0.0095285745,
-0.0123182768,
-0.0113666058,
-0.0262955539,
-0.0301546808,
0.0373098552,
-0.0276979413,
-0.021637775,
-0.0290201101,
0.0137156202,
0.0027735131,
-0.0345426984,
0.0486114398,
-0.0201482102,
0.0722233728,
-0.0064374967,
-0.0289585181,
0.0160416178,
0.0024328537,
-0.0048044063,
0.0320226103,
-0.0734173581,
0.0909413621,
-0.0220929738,
0.0022724855,
0.0142590906,
-0.0137804653,
0.0351153947,
0.0105861546,
0.0511030182,
0.0058249049,
-0.0144846374,
-0.0066624507,
0.0825477988,
-0.0409780778,
-0.0518571362,
0.0579689704,
0.0245458093,
-0.0350110009,
-0.0594333075,
-0.0063265981,
0.0039807507,
-0.0140538281,
0.003361488,
0.0617150068,
-0.0029079339,
0.0424646921,
0.0381300114,
-0.0495267697,
-0.021038292,
-0.0083619049,
-0.0334547274,
-0.0245456621,
0.0885742381,
-0.0298432987,
-0.0349902064,
-0.0357473306,
0.0487846099,
-0.0097640781,
0.00184977,
0.0314736404,
0.0302540064,
0.0010117196,
0.0012805563,
0.018697679,
0.0652201846,
-0.0383758955,
-0.029774515,
0.0372812934,
0.0191597678,
0.0116664339,
0.0248413216,
-0.0126991831,
-0.023245506,
0.0329303145,
0.0013893744,
0.0757006556,
0.0247566327,
-0.0156354345,
-0.0120719401,
-0.0529573821,
-0.0377617553,
-0.0536470078,
-0.0158968531,
-0.0106341299,
-0.0624949262,
0.019434981,
-0.0211818591,
-0.0519698597,
-0.0518910624,
-0.010929469,
-0.0396441147,
-0.0514819883,
-0.0134364804,
-0.0318463668,
0.0036748766,
0.0232336894,
0.0097833984,
-0.0673845485,
0.0194402821,
-0.0241566412,
-0.0199251492,
0.0190728847,
0.0549698099,
-0.0190130379,
0.0334281214,
-0.0748623461,
-0.020079704,
-0.0323992707,
0.0283091888,
0.0098890532,
0.0390468128,
0.0271191578,
0.0012366034,
-0.003381138,
0.0471504107,
0.0318669453,
-0.0294554085,
-0.0714706182,
0.0064400504,
-0.0242310446,
-0.0077429153,
-0.0453578159,
-0.0267586187,
-0.0770073682,
0.0860773697,
0.0467385352,
-0.0171014816,
-0.0243307874,
-0.038829349,
2.632e-7,
0.0215938091,
0.0698532835,
-0.0208237618,
0.0595736876,
0.0247111786,
0.0233836938,
0.0224789418,
0.0132653806,
0.0765704662,
0.0142747853,
-0.0099389097,
-0.0014457799,
0.0205494706,
0.0234035552,
-0.095985055,
-0.0109945489,
-0.0256743915,
0.0375861563,
-0.0259121563,
0.0433701947,
0.0730200633,
0.0150776356,
0.0159480739,
-0.0031123019,
-0.0376470312,
-0.0045324974,
0.0415277965,
-0.0155950952,
0.0086582517,
0.0207815524,
0.0166625045,
0.0089446967,
0.02530149,
0.0653190315,
0.0101357251,
0.0208210275,
-0.0405705683,
0.0775998905,
0.0000582265,
0.0158112962,
0.0156948306,
-0.0016252502,
-0.0095373504,
-0.0628457367,
0.0506972708,
-0.0068658134,
-0.0112053435,
0.0049212831,
0.0000347176,
-0.0143126249,
-0.0056133168,
-0.0420570374,
-0.0465203226,
0.0432000495,
0.01281422,
-0.0262331646,
-0.0187945366,
-0.0098819099,
-0.0138740856,
-0.0341258235,
0.0007840586,
-0.0901794806,
-0.0059675188,
0.0419153944,
-0.0477124304,
-0.02311703,
0.0362016931,
1.930043945e-34,
-0.0124150403,
0.0537984408,
0.0618952103,
0.0025586544,
0.0596831366,
0.02758619,
0.0361165255,
0.0259334035,
0.0622167587,
-0.0068493774,
-0.0104584554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02067v1 | Crossroads of Continents: Automated Artifact Extraction for Cultural Adaptation with Large Multimodal Models | 2024-07-02T08:55:41 | 2024-07-02T08:55:41 | Anjishnu Mukherjee, Ziwei Zhu, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we present a comprehensive three-phase study to examine (1) the
effectiveness of large multimodal models (LMMs) in recognizing cultural
contexts; (2) the accuracy of their representations of diverse cultures; and
(3) their ability to adapt content across cultural boundaries. We first
introduce Dalle Street, a large-scale dataset generated by DALL-E 3 and
validated by humans, containing 9,935 images of 67 countries and 10 concept
classes. We reveal disparities in cultural understanding at the sub-region
level with both open-weight (LLaVA) and closed-source (GPT-4V) models on Dalle
Street and other existing benchmarks. Next, we assess models' deeper culture
understanding by an artifact extraction task and identify over 18,000 artifacts
associated with different countries. Finally, we propose a highly composable
pipeline, CultureAdapt, to adapt images from culture to culture. Our findings
reveal a nuanced picture of the cultural competence of LMMs, highlighting the
need to develop culture-aware systems. Dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/iamshnoo/crossroads | [
0.0132092154,
0.069041118,
-0.0280508082,
0.0563851781,
-0.0193524081,
0.05352154,
0.0458396487,
-0.0326444358,
0.0137244547,
-0.041196201,
-0.0175740551,
-0.0044041066,
-0.0127794221,
0.00870209,
0.0174770579,
-0.1155683622,
-0.0027370753,
-0.0180624705,
-0.0491048731,
0.0040720119,
-0.0408614725,
0.0056141447,
-0.0123468759,
-0.0099366941,
-0.0403437279,
-0.0118663721,
-0.0174594391,
0.028161034,
0.0460564122,
-0.0455416851,
-0.0093174484,
-0.0013426753,
0.0140029015,
-0.0085238311,
0.0000024772,
-0.0264328029,
0.029042745,
-0.0345139652,
0.0482572578,
0.0418305248,
0.1023665965,
0.0166769903,
-0.0004738226,
-0.0605600178,
-0.0026208581,
-0.0302137583,
0.054857444,
0.0426413752,
0.0147674046,
0.0263328496,
-0.0096136304,
-0.0248345975,
-0.0516812615,
0.0105328746,
-0.0189019889,
-0.0372469127,
0.0375850201,
0.0754242688,
-0.0198951699,
0.0066687469,
-0.0498662516,
0.0296141412,
-0.0175861679,
0.0526499823,
-0.0424274243,
0.0268562268,
-0.0336765423,
-0.051279489,
0.0021613613,
0.0682425424,
0.0119533436,
0.0351515412,
0.0138967996,
0.0036653541,
-0.0453380011,
0.0217114184,
-0.0220533423,
0.0055180076,
-0.0086359009,
0.0045201229,
-0.0492435768,
-0.029055506,
0.0193018988,
0.0081880689,
-0.0182060786,
0.032299269,
0.0059819552,
0.0211740974,
-0.0331728831,
-0.0099583352,
-0.0255685262,
-0.0153134847,
0.0149552729,
0.0050489749,
0.0146899214,
-0.0226385463,
0.0243932586,
0.0473003313,
-0.004625984,
-0.0086071147,
-0.0199963972,
0.0425348468,
-0.1454494596,
0.075199835,
-0.0185403936,
0.0361729823,
-0.0298107024,
0.004333918,
-0.0157478675,
-0.0363450758,
-0.0574571751,
0.032872051,
0.0529819429,
-0.0773406401,
-0.0807005167,
-0.0004996525,
-0.0068989866,
0.0057562408,
-0.0217841025,
-0.0032415432,
-0.0703695938,
-0.0043239649,
-0.0165313222,
-0.0025284647,
0.0022355937,
0.0802832022,
-0.0259544533,
0.0057453928,
-0.0203551129,
-0.036930602,
0.0516837463,
0.0160741489,
0.0296985675,
-0.018095322,
-0.0047068102,
0.0294250175,
-0.0011109606,
-0.0047232411,
-0.0849302709,
0.0205876436,
-0.0065016174,
-0.0257253181,
0.0794610828,
-0.0496338494,
0.0333624706,
-0.0379734077,
0.0376629941,
-0.0071664308,
-0.0184691418,
-0.0442240536,
-0.0434407815,
0.0503196269,
0.0261081066,
0.0273498744,
0.0746355802,
-0.0069367252,
-0.0726586059,
0.0571447127,
-0.0082342485,
0.0773512051,
0.0882634446,
-0.0181616955,
-0.0426988229,
0.0422972478,
-0.0498535261,
0.021766752,
-0.0180887263,
-0.0043723732,
0.0079781329,
0.0066246493,
0.045837272,
-0.0012248699,
0.0109013785,
-0.0104299448,
0.0610622056,
0.02407589,
-0.0240680072,
-0.0016994202,
0.0324953012,
-0.0099516856,
-0.0218800176,
-0.0116014443,
-0.0306724347,
0.0125697562,
-0.0128290011,
-0.0076494995,
-0.0425062515,
0.0944571123,
-0.0322595276,
0.0259715226,
-0.022312453,
0.0017289356,
0.0177129116,
0.0243661441,
0.0520447828,
-0.0681041554,
0.0329357497,
-0.0323323682,
0.0414646678,
-0.0229631606,
0.0009229351,
0.0049722763,
0.0427845903,
0.0119237369,
-0.0054482976,
-0.0178906564,
0.0276761129,
0.0190148018,
0.0746907592,
0.0393516384,
0.0292325336,
0.0080245845,
0.0380604677,
-0.0316630006,
-0.0594649985,
0.0052812858,
-0.0126489056,
0.0272818822,
0.0313988999,
0.0309110358,
0.0218220409,
-0.022987796,
0.0249360129,
0.0290973037,
-0.0235067941,
0.0325581133,
0.0072081033,
0.0453888103,
0.0060773492,
0.0110420818,
-0.0121370703,
-0.0568533055,
-0.0170268659,
-0.0254809726,
0.0183110777,
0.0371352918,
-0.0140818506,
0.0145080611,
0.0518828519,
-0.0651416481,
-0.0031103923,
0.0242844354,
-0.017616719,
-0.0043911193,
0.0234887321,
0.0563077629,
0.0026320803,
-0.0020174044,
-0.020051254,
-0.006300746,
0.0335263424,
-0.029644059,
0.0486946106,
-0.0473980382,
-0.0402886011,
-0.0448640063,
-0.0131481625,
0.0123047046,
0.0422332585,
-0.0366834402,
0.0215975773,
0.0081069814,
-0.029167302,
0.0075208796,
0.008600344,
-0.0442013107,
-0.0053406432,
-0.0884488672,
-0.0118734445,
-0.0325200334,
-0.0394734256,
-0.0093435179,
-0.0336608179,
-0.0222913809,
-0.0279778074,
-0.007135137,
0.0603922904,
-0.0259024668,
0.0241886154,
-0.0000659779,
-0.0083068125,
0.0310556758,
0.0016620771,
0.0042470312,
-0.0051184562,
0.0546318218,
-0.0225434974,
-0.0760520175,
-0.0347201861,
-0.0598912574,
-0.0426742248,
0.0098290248,
-0.0360681489,
-0.0308270045,
0.0015742271,
-0.0104497932,
0.0504231788,
0.0134211741,
0.0005533069,
-0.0031038534,
0.0418507718,
-0.0376022235,
-0.0000664295,
0.0012300634,
0.0080617573,
0.0235543903,
0.0055933818,
-0.0778292939,
-0.0183479991,
0.0013653242,
-0.0032096892,
0.0310143903,
0.0144237541,
-0.0216751304,
-0.0217177514,
-0.0325455889,
-0.0151194222,
0.0363703258,
-0.0035273284,
0.0572373569,
-0.0558713935,
-0.0050157593,
0.0047841216,
-0.0099543566,
-0.0135256425,
0.0414136797,
0.022894714,
-0.0325449333,
0.0602300689,
-0.0025632093,
0.0564455204,
0.0189622119,
0.0219752081,
0.0147235692,
-0.0340423062,
-0.002255609,
-0.0085430546,
-0.001726096,
-0.0601332821,
-0.0491707362,
-0.0274535418,
-0.0403538086,
-0.004245596,
0.0507813133,
0.0047028018,
0.0065484503,
-0.0459111817,
0.0009869271,
0.0055806818,
0.0458910018,
0.0528706349,
0.0150204208,
0.0139764082,
0.0226442888,
-0.0006432132,
0.0229823496,
0.0287308618,
0.0592121445,
-0.011398566,
-0.0138980001,
0.008932393,
-0.0038282203,
0.0396491587,
-0.0484813266,
-0.0412310213,
0.0745089725,
0.026903104,
0.050418362,
-0.0066041197,
0.0036393255,
0.0679357946,
-0.0123113785,
0.0344663225,
0.061051894,
-0.0042378553,
-0.0808345005,
-0.0071392288,
-0.0154657578,
-0.0249139108,
0.0358980671,
0.0120328963,
-0.1138248742,
-0.0316441692,
0.0149366288,
-0.0313057192,
0.0254886989,
-0.0267566051,
0.0301169474,
-0.0512365885,
0.0744694918,
0.0189245827,
-0.0649057254,
-0.0377963409,
0.009806918,
0.0153983003,
-0.0391825438,
-0.0347792432,
-0.0039749416,
0.0056082103,
-0.0431019068,
0.0089567313,
-0.0576622933,
-0.0632845536,
0.0052310349,
-0.0694377348,
0.0247974209,
0.0210862234,
0.0292490814,
0.0301614199,
-0.0889807492,
0.0260668844,
0.0284516606,
0.0293956585,
-0.0131469015,
0.0256657079,
0.0216153339,
-0.0393332765,
0.0396563672,
-0.0032319562,
-0.0135809919,
-0.0175281651,
0.0121983979,
0.0693250746,
0.0007059244,
0.0117728105,
-0.0593484342,
-0.0222000722,
0.0202025324,
0.0007861122,
0.0112931626,
-0.0196009353,
-0.0050756172,
-0.0217396896,
-0.0033854067,
-0.0049060127,
0.0079487581,
0.0451884642,
-0.0736700445,
-0.0499348156,
-0.0543108992,
-0.0214375108,
-0.0035484293,
-0.0004974395,
0.0201266631,
-0.0684643984,
-0.028988691,
0.0581284128,
-0.0543260425,
0.0818409324,
-0.0344481692,
-0.0108492952,
-0.0034889728,
-0.0241837129,
0.0100477645,
-0.0392409861,
0.0101216324,
0.0429416858,
-0.0363081358,
0.0137171438,
0.0661128387,
0.0491750538,
-0.0005574693,
-0.0204308871,
0.0564044379,
-0.0441854633,
0.0125972042,
0.000951177,
-0.0014376297,
-0.0053995396,
-0.0221568737,
0.0226831604,
-0.0218378492,
0.0050178701,
-0.052885782,
0.0675261319,
0.0130330129,
0.0110913655,
-0.0385331027,
-0.0056175971,
-0.037090335,
-0.0031818433,
0.0775906667,
-0.0244660117,
-0.0167294554,
-0.0275161099,
-0.0443986617,
0.0504464507,
-0.017547207,
-0.0074841548,
-0.0139785558,
-0.0044860695,
0.0034782367,
0.0323107801,
0.010838761,
0.0449342951,
0.0145316077,
-0.0637369603,
0.0049359431,
0.0425783135,
0.0294763818,
-0.0653764457,
0.0611950941,
-0.0131353475,
0.0333649479,
-0.0234362148,
0.0152981076,
-0.0205002148,
0.0743752196,
0.004840666,
-0.0184656363,
-0.0202743039,
0.0282710716,
0.0200894102,
0.0046818461,
-0.0164266899,
0.0192814711,
0.1309660524,
-0.0189312436,
0.0672235116,
0.0084594293,
-0.0279604159,
-0.0267894082,
0.0237060525,
0.0194782354,
-0.0334996991,
0.0041346834,
0.0158443116,
0.000825258,
0.013536064,
0.0192994047,
-0.0487611145,
0.0037315013,
0.0180615727,
-0.0378453359,
-0.0461627059,
0.0127398036,
0.077161245,
0.0127959065,
-0.03097504,
0.0576423593,
-0.0469745249,
-0.0327745378,
-0.0401702523,
0.0068788291,
-0.0229617693,
0.0293990076,
-0.0200699307,
0.0540852584,
-0.0077185822,
-0.0351417959,
-0.067991212,
-0.0279887151,
-0.0629681945,
0.0159297828,
0.0383141302,
-6.809856241e-33,
-0.0185948927,
0.009061438,
0.0313114673,
0.0287259389,
-0.0348697416,
-0.0272901747,
-0.0342492051,
0.0173954312,
-0.0452150442,
0.0303821359,
0.0015627984,
-0.0825371221,
0.0079965293,
0.0250896476,
0.0245773252,
0.0565942749,
0.0122782616,
0.0159651134,
-0.0257439967,
0.0016060325,
0.0624755844,
0.0416570306,
0.0754938647,
-0.0749499425,
-0.0233404394,
0.018546002,
0.002782668,
-0.0143456943,
0.0957653672,
0.0461490415,
-0.0845386684,
0.0411395542,
0.0428935699,
-0.0165495127,
-0.0047694468,
-0.0384204388,
-0.082190074,
0.0138461506,
-0.0215801001,
0.0489461422,
0.0178437326,
-0.0601637959,
0.0322975181,
-0.0216471553,
0.0022667192,
-0.0060591046,
0.0689668953,
-0.0303169992,
0.004226495,
0.0144973323,
-0.0407726914,
0.0380597748,
-0.0060967016,
-0.0044093952,
0.0235111471,
0.0768197104,
0.0144418487,
0.0456779711,
-0.0524342693,
0.0259622671,
-0.0032473514,
-0.0035744412,
0.0613147505,
0.0466448516,
0.0415216386,
0.058675237,
0.0208593477,
-0.0222353209,
0.0266122147,
-0.0355971046,
0.0458776653,
0.050923042,
-0.0594233982,
0.0891664699,
0.013068323,
-0.0175120253,
-0.0256851539,
0.0328905731,
0.0237305555,
0.0263440572,
-0.0014232214,
0.0374345221,
0.0125818811,
0.0424145497,
-0.0022358764,
-0.0397105031,
-0.0363257341,
-0.0318315029,
0.0393564403,
-0.0042578001,
-0.0309517905,
0.0417038724,
0.0609229431,
-0.0306886379,
0.0044344314,
-0.0302600991,
-0.0121065956,
0.0166125763,
0.0384324081,
-0.0432711318,
-0.018916199,
-0.0611482412,
-0.0045784973,
-0.0015013794,
0.0079177078,
-0.0045309723,
0.0021368756,
0.0443092585,
-0.0123972455,
-0.0015400365,
-0.0429024063,
-0.0338327326,
-0.0396810137,
0.0158886407,
0.0146529023,
-0.0298895501,
-0.0489135385,
-0.0489339456,
0.007454704,
0.0154956663,
-0.0011653207,
-0.0574221984,
-0.0148541732,
0.0315429904,
-0.0255873129,
-0.0176786017,
-0.0301267747,
0.0029721146,
0.0077078897,
-0.0099503864,
-0.0148540605,
0.017164886,
3.168e-7,
0.0025207151,
0.0423661843,
0.0017744318,
-0.0419675596,
0.0424701236,
0.0221609548,
-0.0793575794,
0.0200926922,
-0.0240500532,
-0.0300249029,
0.0174459498,
0.0392462611,
0.0551392101,
0.0390900038,
-0.0441580638,
-0.002893199,
0.0672876015,
-0.0008833387,
-0.0577335693,
0.0344571173,
-0.0171128362,
0.033928372,
-0.0049495799,
-0.0426156074,
0.0307687558,
0.0023050928,
0.0455990247,
-0.0798467249,
-0.0302692074,
-0.0521365963,
-0.0063706189,
0.0171669666,
-0.0164885353,
-0.0408945791,
0.0153972544,
-0.0007229397,
0.0276193749,
0.0409204066,
0.006966264,
-0.0224382281,
-0.0022533189,
0.0420847647,
-0.0025275715,
-0.0886059552,
0.0366121158,
-0.0019876086,
-0.0053007491,
-0.065502584,
-0.0481127203,
0.0101140887,
0.036691498,
0.0021169565,
-0.0149964495,
-0.0067293867,
0.0123404367,
-0.0210740268,
-0.0200930275,
-0.0570842847,
0.0261454694,
0.0163684972,
-0.0433327444,
-0.0043784892,
-0.018092392,
-0.0342098512,
-0.0002220516,
-0.0109476112,
-0.015305222,
2.280156443e-34,
-0.0175356083,
0.0065987692,
-0.0260648467,
-0.0060545751,
0.0393520407,
-0.0237179901,
-0.0174273737,
-0.0219659694,
-0.0428440683,
0.0040417635,
0.0247279555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02066v1 | BiasDora: Exploring Hidden Biased Associations in Vision-Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:55:40 | 2024-07-02T08:55:40 | Chahat Raj, Anjishnu Mukherjee, Aylin Caliskan, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Ziwei Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing works examining Vision Language Models (VLMs) for social biases
predominantly focus on a limited set of documented bias associations, such as
gender:profession or race:crime. This narrow scope often overlooks a vast range
of unexamined implicit associations, restricting the identification and, hence,
mitigation of such biases. We address this gap by probing VLMs to (1) uncover
hidden, implicit associations across 9 bias dimensions. We systematically
explore diverse input and output modalities and (2) demonstrate how biased
associations vary in their negativity, toxicity, and extremity. Our work (3)
identifies subtle and extreme biases that are typically not recognized by
existing methodologies. We make the Dataset of retrieved associations, (Dora),
publicly available here https://github.com/chahatraj/BiasDora. | [
0.0164581258,
0.0863891989,
-0.0407531522,
0.0513199344,
0.0017551281,
0.0384857133,
0.0463110693,
0.0075519313,
0.0485960282,
-0.0747367591,
-0.0353193134,
0.0294606667,
0.0407766849,
0.0412507951,
0.0172842965,
-0.0640371144,
0.0476961136,
0.0289164484,
0.0274459422,
-0.020432964,
0.0185033847,
0.0387999453,
0.0297326762,
0.0437135734,
-0.0378311314,
-0.0282568336,
0.0713867024,
0.001929818,
0.0238903593,
0.0151243145,
0.0206952058,
0.0539357364,
-0.0152138676,
-0.0041429419,
0.0000020073,
-0.0595270023,
0.030127231,
-0.003404167,
0.039071966,
-0.0250754487,
0.0437554605,
-0.0222455841,
0.028886918,
0.0217875764,
-0.030927889,
-0.0338220969,
0.0480470546,
0.0149835208,
0.023077406,
-0.0073150969,
-0.014174494,
-0.0026610184,
-0.0713668913,
-0.0190071668,
-0.0016628208,
0.0161638409,
0.0753176585,
-0.0526289828,
-0.0998861492,
-0.0276463199,
-0.0400742963,
-0.0014186645,
0.0018896889,
0.0253013428,
0.0208530873,
0.0169421993,
-0.0324828327,
-0.0764437094,
0.0219870508,
0.0714986548,
0.0016106768,
-0.0213749334,
0.0136972293,
-0.0207109079,
0.0191715937,
0.0165847447,
-0.0161364414,
0.0219046343,
-0.0069030118,
-0.0023592045,
-0.0236413758,
0.0377957746,
0.0223549828,
0.0389263891,
0.019405121,
0.0338608436,
0.0211197082,
0.0257440619,
0.0033806856,
0.0003720997,
0.041700501,
-0.0385570675,
-0.0073881908,
-0.0329885297,
0.0069813579,
-0.0083873002,
-0.0330445245,
0.0142985079,
0.0176179465,
-0.055764392,
0.0244365204,
0.0228586141,
-0.0506030284,
0.0265250988,
-0.0068540964,
0.0214642137,
-0.0008218925,
0.0188173093,
0.0043075536,
-0.0279657859,
0.0241763201,
-0.0140927732,
0.0259575825,
-0.0450510159,
-0.0047749514,
0.0285665281,
-0.0278936177,
-0.0153669035,
-0.0940066651,
0.0107403593,
-0.0209744573,
0.0315188393,
-0.034383066,
-0.0038175758,
-0.0440023504,
0.0032345876,
-0.0240712836,
0.0345706679,
-0.0493713953,
-0.0650397241,
0.0153902369,
0.0107714403,
-0.0085551338,
-0.0384285636,
-0.0209327992,
0.0635951906,
0.0300885681,
-0.0005621014,
-0.0197662134,
-0.0574008077,
-0.0162097439,
-0.019720966,
0.0136472471,
-0.0416349433,
0.027114531,
0.0230886489,
0.0132112764,
-0.0733945072,
-0.0008452534,
0.0236860514,
-0.0908790901,
0.0668677315,
0.0030238426,
-0.0010999278,
0.008523847,
0.0314708874,
-0.0063602845,
0.0874069557,
-0.0128316171,
0.0524712391,
0.0377906859,
-0.0088343062,
0.0165306721,
0.0371376052,
0.0219033789,
0.0007970679,
-0.0793609843,
0.0350926034,
-0.0015902435,
-0.0205674935,
0.0734819174,
0.0338721685,
0.0012089801,
-0.0563305914,
0.0505805761,
0.057019338,
0.0054380875,
0.0180241223,
0.0246103816,
-0.0204040296,
-0.0119396243,
-0.0188913792,
-0.0837838277,
0.0016307825,
-0.0004943124,
-0.0407552682,
-0.0265411232,
0.0786581039,
-0.0306164939,
-0.0146356588,
-0.0078014866,
0.0035967166,
0.0293053072,
0.0016061158,
0.0235822052,
0.0123362951,
0.0060794703,
-0.0038591973,
0.0630335063,
-0.0198036525,
0.0164369624,
-0.0557403192,
0.0377903245,
0.0369933471,
0.0148777105,
0.0169735607,
0.024468543,
-0.0231801122,
-0.0184283312,
0.0182987396,
0.0319255553,
-0.0094851991,
0.0081529533,
-0.0398941748,
-0.0200107545,
0.0475878939,
0.0495128706,
0.0112689789,
0.0280155018,
0.0130604487,
0.0212910231,
-0.0404012017,
-0.0312679484,
0.0213645045,
0.0332904793,
0.0071710367,
-0.0180478133,
0.0153641365,
0.0048852512,
-0.0069786557,
-0.0202272814,
0.0097230803,
-0.0229537655,
-0.0063155969,
0.0378560238,
0.0478308015,
-0.0431375466,
0.0253279321,
0.0115460698,
-0.0970198661,
-0.0252987519,
0.05312277,
0.0046497392,
0.0282301418,
0.0595597252,
-0.0099859014,
0.0274881627,
0.0097532859,
-0.0171077326,
-0.0205554776,
0.0251648687,
-0.0229907203,
0.0572164953,
-0.0248402506,
-0.0390580744,
0.0049372753,
-0.0549174361,
0.0182680395,
-0.0217526313,
0.0198380854,
-0.0074887085,
0.0044958983,
-0.0072730454,
0.016722979,
-0.0602471717,
-0.041192092,
0.0085353842,
-0.0628768429,
-0.0349317491,
-0.0082826447,
-0.0555927083,
-0.0042169504,
-0.0059848637,
-0.0239577647,
-0.0295517705,
-0.0077177128,
0.0307059363,
0.0048899152,
0.0496571027,
-0.0163130537,
-0.060519062,
-0.026479641,
-0.0272528306,
-0.047010649,
-0.0544510148,
0.0750266761,
0.0307696629,
-0.0233979728,
-0.0093804318,
-0.0046495078,
-0.0419341326,
0.0278509352,
-0.0219787508,
-0.0017347311,
0.0112175271,
0.0290461984,
0.0066524558,
0.0574884042,
0.0260850918,
0.0544665083,
0.0529296435,
-0.0112239411,
-0.0457584821,
-0.0367142335,
-0.022617545,
0.0225092508,
0.0116431154,
-0.0957210064,
-0.0499779843,
0.0585686862,
0.0402550101,
-0.0152425617,
-0.0657142326,
0.0704433769,
-0.0259430334,
-0.0684918165,
-0.030780172,
-0.044360321,
0.0155644882,
0.0634507984,
-0.0418857783,
-0.0852657631,
0.0191301703,
0.0249750596,
0.0383645445,
0.029255854,
0.0140142236,
-0.0204377864,
0.0556823015,
0.0352501646,
0.0301645901,
0.0237164702,
-0.0036808481,
-0.0545288958,
-0.0509694181,
0.0161632132,
-0.0226268712,
0.0358922407,
-0.0297833141,
-0.0038015372,
-0.0011175897,
-0.0143354144,
-0.0426903516,
-0.0581803769,
-0.031281624,
-0.0079742512,
-0.0327839889,
-0.0199010558,
-0.0094192736,
0.0096567338,
-0.0276440196,
-0.0222349521,
-0.0100119626,
-0.0006826948,
0.0036018288,
-0.0164867379,
0.0804339051,
-0.0051379115,
0.0168469884,
0.0004069599,
-0.0456147604,
0.0326151289,
-0.0057992446,
0.0358686261,
-0.0396827161,
0.0241511129,
0.029265821,
0.0232447311,
0.0204816777,
0.0001524657,
0.0073277727,
-0.0203194059,
0.0167736672,
0.0696183071,
0.0069184629,
-0.0936451703,
0.033662349,
0.0135507323,
0.0117682461,
0.0543559939,
-0.0124284644,
-0.1093124598,
-0.0052987444,
0.0070961546,
0.0150329825,
-0.0525845215,
-0.0649976507,
-0.0040996587,
-0.1164836064,
0.0420635343,
0.0146101173,
0.0234069452,
-0.0379135311,
-0.0229478162,
0.022769805,
-0.0623564348,
-0.0018989112,
-0.0160556976,
-0.0047192052,
0.0220848024,
0.0020200778,
-0.0415594131,
-0.0335763544,
0.0314670131,
-0.0345088392,
0.0414123014,
0.031068204,
0.0245801322,
-0.0155658824,
-0.027869029,
0.0202692412,
-0.0060803057,
0.0008775556,
-0.0273008551,
0.0593756884,
-0.0638498962,
-0.038907744,
-0.0297846887,
0.052139502,
0.0077311848,
-0.0137623884,
-0.0338002592,
0.0031776109,
0.0022824076,
-0.0387339592,
-0.0639747679,
-0.0180288758,
-0.0168418586,
0.0775176808,
0.0066186963,
-0.0131266871,
0.0146707138,
-0.0549617559,
0.0045145783,
0.0435026661,
-0.0977014676,
0.0101048229,
0.0265270434,
-0.0449942984,
-0.0124427592,
-0.0691336915,
0.0400926583,
-0.0072715748,
0.0091633871,
-0.0679032207,
0.0050971764,
-0.020429736,
-0.0948220417,
0.0821739286,
0.0008132135,
0.0257598124,
0.0555859394,
-0.0207552463,
-0.0272854194,
-0.0275193546,
-0.0233686753,
0.0048743174,
-0.0727040246,
-0.019032659,
0.0496417694,
0.0465255119,
0.0233551227,
0.0400493965,
-0.0134230629,
-0.0326995589,
0.0276117735,
0.0472010039,
0.0074324328,
0.050832238,
-0.0214458294,
-0.0120222345,
0.0223738458,
0.0250940733,
-0.0221780967,
0.0137850773,
0.0385413989,
-0.0378927514,
-0.0480877459,
0.0017149986,
0.012854889,
-0.0336837769,
0.0821348578,
-0.0232824571,
0.0124809518,
-0.0542182103,
-0.044037275,
-0.0249620788,
-0.0386928581,
-0.0117140189,
-0.0261481442,
0.0430657677,
0.036467474,
-0.0339618139,
-0.041264765,
-0.0535000451,
0.0058346055,
-0.0408738591,
0.0000399256,
0.0605864972,
-0.0035675233,
0.0045258114,
-0.0027838859,
-0.0058218599,
0.0273776799,
-0.046169024,
0.0520525314,
0.0273897443,
0.0272144936,
0.0252923407,
0.0108284969,
-0.0212213788,
0.0060475916,
0.0025547333,
-0.0168972313,
0.0013483401,
0.0198810417,
0.0105477599,
-0.0679490343,
0.0372962095,
0.018450059,
-0.0041558426,
-0.0025821503,
0.0069913464,
0.0034509173,
-0.0181730147,
0.0687379837,
0.0043911184,
-0.0084692826,
0.0096869748,
0.0720027015,
0.0244876705,
0.0558407381,
-0.0166335236,
-0.0407228023,
-0.0058597331,
-0.0236466303,
0.0761983991,
-0.0132019753,
-0.0166235324,
-0.0033721067,
-0.0874368399,
-0.0794273093,
-0.0224393103,
-0.0150385965,
0.0456811674,
0.0079306625,
0.0038930213,
0.0645855293,
-0.0059065633,
-0.042890396,
0.0021613142,
-0.0308838189,
-0.0494087264,
-0.0211190116,
-0.0169963613,
-6.253474193e-33,
-0.0307300352,
-0.0463217013,
-0.0119118663,
-0.0373798497,
0.0027004858,
0.021631578,
0.0088867228,
0.0105242869,
-0.0547413975,
0.0247257333,
0.0245818812,
0.0309704952,
0.0116312737,
-0.0065661613,
0.0271348357,
-0.0108816065,
0.0331588425,
0.0013182194,
-0.0126850251,
-0.0312924758,
-0.0264809411,
-0.0118254544,
0.0120569021,
-0.0954787061,
0.0525192767,
0.0144668445,
-0.0443730988,
0.0069207964,
0.0082503529,
0.0492620356,
-0.0205448829,
0.0637374222,
0.0361985303,
0.0392234065,
-0.0070863501,
0.0550138913,
-0.0460459515,
-0.0258262474,
0.0544786528,
0.0483912937,
-0.0438599139,
-0.0035498843,
0.0167386346,
0.018918559,
-0.0507372469,
-0.0421177708,
0.0673009157,
-0.0206128228,
0.0350066498,
0.0589597337,
-0.0253476333,
0.0082805594,
-0.0247438755,
0.0244315565,
0.0093687326,
0.017937921,
0.0229427572,
0.0512468889,
-0.0470866524,
0.0420875885,
-0.024122227,
-0.0247871093,
0.0867916867,
0.03795572,
0.0258346386,
0.0803514421,
0.0738400593,
0.0014096049,
-0.0175860748,
-0.0491247177,
0.0313170664,
0.0175651703,
0.0074789673,
0.0645711273,
0.0042399648,
0.0005706492,
-0.0299075618,
-0.0350887254,
0.0286783613,
0.0263776947,
0.0290065128,
-0.0073167118,
-0.0488884598,
-0.0343742222,
-0.0456473231,
-0.0655696839,
-0.0451484323,
-0.0015014774,
0.0493989028,
0.0124176228,
-0.0012823557,
0.0722532868,
0.0202369802,
-0.038403701,
-0.0079517784,
0.0127630318,
-0.0101142284,
-0.0180457644,
0.0117473062,
0.0109499218,
-0.0617727824,
0.0231143404,
0.0119680157,
0.0268004816,
0.033392489,
0.0292428751,
-0.002197407,
-0.0137546994,
-0.0575068742,
-0.0076636244,
-0.0114061963,
-0.03107474,
0.0015687631,
0.0224096291,
0.0581339821,
0.0238398351,
-0.0127220247,
-0.0047965455,
0.0437864475,
0.0150645934,
-0.024106672,
-0.0088997018,
-0.0204862915,
0.0513618104,
-0.0091534583,
-0.040837951,
-0.0152790295,
-0.0307437591,
0.0661342815,
-0.023131771,
-0.0102896448,
-0.0649948195,
2.464e-7,
0.0065682605,
0.0529494174,
-0.0164692346,
0.0549136214,
0.0261268131,
0.059247151,
0.0485080704,
0.0568041876,
0.033992216,
-0.0197782647,
-0.0467979014,
0.0435584784,
0.001156566,
0.015999034,
0.0201494526,
0.0515112169,
-0.0349159986,
-0.0090998849,
-0.0367782339,
0.0019155546,
0.0008605157,
0.0667350665,
0.0345634595,
0.0075046523,
0.0063070492,
-0.0302271768,
0.0252321754,
-0.0407203622,
-0.0070688869,
0.0001646323,
-0.0101537872,
0.0079424502,
0.0103710033,
0.0517558269,
0.0048837001,
0.0046066698,
-0.0026773321,
0.008150273,
-0.0462646782,
-0.0045651407,
-0.0266751274,
-0.0049133548,
-0.0367273614,
-0.0706841499,
0.0586736351,
0.0177862104,
-0.0354070552,
-0.0540458709,
-0.0262644198,
0.013220977,
0.0349669009,
0.0106502939,
-0.0182779729,
-0.0289183259,
0.0395351835,
-0.0063921651,
-0.0334613435,
-0.0732504651,
-0.0139912227,
-0.0467596799,
-0.0199512597,
-0.0718096793,
0.0039625312,
0.063416563,
0.0380540527,
-0.0116372518,
-0.0096143223,
2.074989286e-34,
0.018837925,
0.0363683477,
0.0074976748,
-0.0214537121,
0.0253450926,
-0.0290697329,
-0.0650011674,
0.0079058744,
0.0236934479,
-0.0474156439,
0.0012772105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02062v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02062v1 | Are Data Augmentation Methods in Named Entity Recognition Applicable for Uncertainty Estimation? | 2024-07-02T08:49:43 | 2024-07-02T08:49:43 | Wataru Hashimoto, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This work investigates the impact of data augmentation on confidence
calibration and uncertainty estimation in Named Entity Recognition (NER) tasks.
For the future advance of NER in safety-critical fields like healthcare and
finance, it is essential to achieve accurate predictions with calibrated
confidence when applying Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), including Pre-trained
Language Models (PLMs), as a real-world application. However, DNNs are prone to
miscalibration, which limits their applicability. Moreover, existing methods
for calibration and uncertainty estimation are computational expensive. Our
investigation in NER found that data augmentation improves calibration and
uncertainty in cross-genre and cross-lingual setting, especially in-domain
setting. Furthermore, we showed that the calibration for NER tends to be more
effective when the perplexity of the sentences generated by data augmentation
is lower, and that increasing the size of the augmentation further improves
calibration and uncertainty. | [
0.0106260274,
0.0952430665,
0.0131428121,
0.0272325575,
0.0232018679,
0.030312622,
0.0120254103,
-0.0305001326,
-0.0300240908,
0.0195554905,
-0.041400414,
-0.0845756009,
0.0247802883,
0.0267427675,
0.0501229204,
-0.0249357801,
0.028968839,
-0.0181777477,
0.0547740497,
0.0157920066,
-0.0135956323,
-0.011947507,
-0.0375816487,
0.0223881956,
-0.0188609976,
0.0252447892,
-0.0057023978,
0.0439187698,
0.0621779077,
-0.068229489,
0.0174009688,
0.0509098433,
0.0127322255,
0.0693423748,
0.0000018035,
-0.0385889113,
-0.0257936157,
-0.0001352086,
-0.0803529546,
-0.012451591,
0.0472210646,
-0.0288642887,
-0.0235459879,
0.0010793128,
0.0011097883,
-0.0608183034,
0.0579460859,
0.040030539,
-0.0159219317,
0.0719462112,
-0.0033158341,
-0.0018107033,
0.0499016307,
-0.0415494367,
-0.0062609292,
-0.0480718873,
0.0400575101,
-0.0156521797,
-0.0315314122,
0.0283997934,
-0.0038903055,
0.0372772701,
0.0123804342,
0.0263051204,
0.009648867,
0.0181344505,
-0.0161610208,
0.0015068182,
-0.028581135,
0.0670550913,
-0.0157723241,
0.0093018971,
-0.0099617774,
-0.0485268049,
-0.0003863572,
-0.0135455485,
-0.0143763963,
0.0083689792,
0.0141843148,
-0.0162814353,
-0.0230171662,
0.0285164472,
0.0702845678,
0.0144052999,
-0.0132111367,
0.0493965149,
-0.0018252506,
-0.0411263369,
0.0253887884,
0.0221784059,
-0.0181009062,
-0.0394779779,
0.0754936635,
0.0320072286,
-0.0069266865,
0.0341709405,
-0.0681767687,
-0.0660743266,
0.0070695058,
-0.0436372049,
-0.0090876482,
0.0241904203,
-0.0403742678,
0.0111898519,
-0.0290635303,
0.0199197959,
-0.0218162164,
0.0000829423,
0.0023495592,
0.000373147,
0.0026386094,
0.0028216825,
-0.0316103287,
0.0066559254,
-0.01443619,
-0.0119155282,
-0.1015540734,
-0.0022059036,
-0.0114929499,
0.0412156172,
-0.0121090561,
0.0375698991,
-0.0327407084,
-0.0277702753,
-0.0419432297,
0.0301964246,
-0.0044478546,
0.021814039,
0.0001407305,
-0.0640958771,
0.013997837,
-0.00590736,
0.0299989432,
-0.0343679972,
0.0385590382,
0.0587475784,
0.0215662271,
-0.083911173,
-0.0421735048,
-0.0031637996,
-0.0364870206,
-0.0482214242,
-0.0080453362,
-0.0192459151,
0.0416174904,
-0.0102896085,
-0.0013968574,
-0.0792436227,
0.0303444657,
-0.0235063639,
-0.0442270637,
0.1008766666,
-0.0656399354,
-0.020803513,
0.0134354094,
-0.0141965579,
0.0211823937,
0.0347279422,
0.0659381524,
0.0051324777,
0.0278159622,
0.0102358265,
0.0144884726,
0.0166261252,
0.0215128418,
-0.0414282307,
-0.015637191,
-0.0129813543,
-0.0377980135,
0.0358173065,
0.0135223195,
0.0415499583,
-0.0157892816,
0.0040255263,
0.0641761571,
-0.0032153765,
0.0165670961,
-0.0373805575,
-0.0012110661,
-0.0362450667,
0.0203200672,
-0.0165038519,
-0.0511173755,
0.0031871656,
-0.0070692697,
0.0208602529,
0.0095274029,
0.026532257,
0.0011270464,
-0.0239354596,
-0.0164027568,
-0.0166774001,
0.0110525461,
0.0348815881,
0.0391434766,
-0.0230310056,
-0.0718099102,
0.0340705737,
0.0070159766,
-0.0221662782,
0.0315244868,
-0.0019788325,
-0.029965179,
0.0725427493,
0.0262626447,
-0.0425533094,
-0.0765476972,
-0.0370937549,
-0.0197999049,
0.0269303657,
0.0342387408,
0.0099329315,
0.065082036,
-0.0559764579,
-0.0052487915,
0.0053973529,
0.0219907891,
0.0204848386,
0.0382032394,
0.0481414981,
0.0416505374,
-0.0288381465,
-0.0447240137,
0.0272152517,
-0.0287733413,
-0.0517199598,
0.0106995879,
0.029536996,
0.0194307491,
0.0694086179,
-0.0143829519,
-0.0066725542,
0.0296971295,
-0.0018551407,
-0.0128153525,
-0.0231727343,
-0.0168118831,
0.0012822158,
0.0482230633,
-0.0199101865,
-0.0277378727,
-0.0088250358,
-0.0401742943,
-0.0654054508,
-0.0271382704,
-0.0027986309,
-0.020169992,
-0.0403229222,
0.031756185,
-0.0067599937,
0.0504368767,
-0.0311786477,
0.0364206471,
-0.0146215297,
0.0116569055,
0.0118468152,
0.0276829936,
0.0072571044,
-0.0355897993,
-0.0525891595,
-0.0302939713,
-0.012694682,
-0.0098203626,
0.0203016605,
-0.0290787127,
-0.035788428,
-0.0030664026,
-0.0552841537,
0.0007917858,
-0.0136452774,
0.0495606326,
-0.0018407149,
0.0480136909,
-0.033491116,
-0.0281714834,
-0.0176972356,
-0.0067462088,
-0.0272589456,
0.0105845267,
0.0451467261,
0.0296452567,
-0.0219131261,
-0.0282680169,
-0.0096025309,
-0.0404896699,
0.0154604753,
0.0274613909,
-0.0651558638,
-0.0832295045,
0.0472591147,
-0.0303354021,
0.0244366936,
0.0018494733,
-0.0213498119,
0.0040930947,
0.0285689924,
-0.0033771053,
0.0283952951,
-0.0186863784,
0.0012832166,
0.0100990199,
-0.0097217197,
-0.0064602378,
0.043222487,
-0.0351681374,
0.0130000273,
-0.0146635883,
-0.0279746708,
-0.0011532293,
0.0548133366,
-0.0483331122,
-0.0033320831,
-0.017626334,
0.0016193441,
-0.0066247755,
-0.0163704455,
0.0009344943,
-0.0064995796,
-0.0171892606,
0.0683016106,
0.0073407707,
-0.0107221464,
0.0808151811,
-0.0610432588,
-0.0196956918,
-0.0162891727,
-0.0086880466,
0.0029245617,
-0.0034365423,
0.0223278385,
0.0040325769,
0.0196578261,
-0.0738599449,
-0.0287035778,
0.0127631715,
0.0189781338,
-0.0423249677,
0.0238380898,
-0.0032013594,
0.0165800117,
-0.0143492781,
-0.0155534148,
-0.0619329214,
-0.0220346935,
-0.0629006475,
0.0031855935,
0.0454929993,
-0.0428663418,
-0.0225292724,
0.022610927,
-0.0000416249,
0.0601197965,
-0.0069038863,
0.0000602585,
-0.0242326856,
0.0054929517,
0.0285872072,
0.0395147428,
0.0818620399,
-0.0205730405,
-0.039536804,
-0.0133862188,
-0.0031843437,
0.004599317,
-0.0497179702,
-0.028448863,
0.0252462961,
-0.0356111936,
0.0024819309,
0.0180501062,
0.0586466901,
-0.0462825596,
0.0161927175,
0.1215963662,
-0.0167660322,
-0.0256021135,
-0.0129272547,
0.0089326901,
-0.0068425722,
-0.0121413358,
0.0148674939,
-0.0722918138,
-0.0428428613,
0.0199243538,
-0.0014802025,
0.0035202317,
-0.0698262379,
-0.0063275564,
-0.0836375579,
0.0272947233,
-0.0230548307,
-0.0643039048,
-0.0267134923,
-0.0208916496,
0.0195121374,
-0.0225918274,
0.0688074678,
-0.0287272725,
0.0000648068,
-0.0074805869,
0.0256657247,
-0.0275982637,
-0.0970901102,
-0.0576453023,
-0.0692714974,
0.0704832897,
0.0400904939,
-0.0035939463,
-0.0555541255,
0.0041322219,
0.0142686674,
-0.0118360743,
-0.0209624954,
0.0265774895,
0.0837432072,
-0.0244467873,
-0.0334975161,
0.0024857742,
0.0056030634,
-0.0373945571,
-0.0201136451,
-0.0330399014,
0.0170336496,
-0.0122186905,
0.0213912651,
-0.0137368711,
-0.0011583579,
0.0329733938,
0.0517362319,
0.0098608593,
-0.0229535066,
0.0113455765,
-0.0011972466,
0.0524746776,
-0.0498386994,
0.0482859798,
0.0403573476,
-0.0236388929,
-0.0702861995,
-0.0110767689,
-0.0577367581,
0.0152520053,
0.0217169467,
0.030946305,
-0.0072502587,
0.0750336349,
0.0037107086,
-0.067552872,
0.0247775596,
-0.010494099,
0.0432098955,
-0.031164676,
0.0219115801,
-0.0055247606,
0.0258987565,
-0.0269680712,
0.0362906195,
-0.1080634296,
-0.050832998,
0.0125709735,
0.0066840597,
0.020020064,
0.028938273,
-0.0347341299,
-0.0529267378,
0.0457067676,
0.0593964234,
-0.0513604358,
-0.0241663344,
0.0269938614,
0.007558675,
-0.0285735801,
0.0016077,
-0.0380032063,
0.0082144812,
0.0406782776,
0.0258665644,
-0.013568012,
-0.0745214745,
-0.0301484428,
0.0144310771,
0.0885614529,
-0.0261730012,
0.0166643653,
-0.0578242093,
0.0258908663,
0.0145397084,
0.0321923085,
-0.0030976818,
-0.0366036892,
0.0566310175,
-0.0133789182,
-0.029863501,
0.0278430134,
-0.0107971253,
-0.006156167,
-0.025351122,
-0.0013814813,
0.0320773609,
0.0410124063,
0.0380263515,
-0.0273603592,
0.003699471,
0.0690464154,
0.0394250937,
0.036993213,
0.0125824185,
-0.0247037504,
0.0085383924,
0.0002048636,
-0.031468194,
0.0256501883,
-0.0620303005,
-0.0046059508,
-0.0374121144,
0.0512291417,
0.0411503986,
0.0048165787,
0.0209580194,
-0.0311471224,
0.0052664862,
-0.0131757241,
-0.0011556419,
-0.0108276028,
0.0238847621,
0.0402219519,
0.0063994662,
-0.0092892163,
0.02141417,
0.0626772717,
0.0192996506,
0.0439747535,
-0.0075401114,
-0.0473564826,
-0.0179499034,
-0.0297213029,
0.0095396843,
0.0452014804,
-0.0650450587,
0.0101447059,
0.0006726456,
-0.0953508019,
0.0528071597,
-0.002085526,
-0.0037920375,
-0.0043148817,
-0.0058114091,
0.0114186211,
-0.0056527434,
-0.0141219068,
0.0125172101,
0.0225795899,
0.0207296982,
-0.0108427973,
-0.0138041936,
-5.973140097e-33,
-0.0204040743,
-0.039564088,
-0.0047321431,
-0.0359862261,
-0.0262568742,
0.040501982,
-0.0038432851,
0.0204560179,
0.0018868125,
0.02115459,
-0.0104733026,
0.0261601396,
0.046105139,
0.0202171504,
-0.0144316824,
-0.0659676939,
0.0562594719,
0.0273440033,
-0.0035010504,
-0.0240572449,
-0.0023839944,
0.0859167352,
0.1233313009,
-0.1002593264,
0.0710020363,
0.0195314884,
-0.0258254856,
0.0110214381,
0.0675930157,
0.0456795059,
-0.0170761123,
0.0377024561,
-0.0178459845,
-0.0493021198,
-0.0018665663,
0.0014291118,
-0.1202464923,
-0.0158386212,
-0.0038392749,
0.0907418951,
-0.0203716997,
-0.0148228537,
0.0592111871,
-0.0071639088,
0.0008648101,
0.0204581674,
0.0093011726,
-0.0284868348,
0.0225136094,
-0.0367174856,
-0.0357565135,
0.0362833403,
-0.0064253942,
0.0265819449,
0.0656090453,
0.0004196697,
0.0081234751,
-0.0092984382,
-0.0871642902,
-0.0328155011,
0.0373137482,
-0.0050521083,
0.0412884727,
0.0570765212,
-0.0470037274,
0.0265207924,
0.0211624987,
0.0022532775,
-0.0489032902,
0.0036230327,
0.0361998454,
0.0061363033,
0.0079977009,
0.0918665603,
0.0672371238,
0.0015612413,
-0.0855201557,
0.0299253706,
-0.0040834071,
0.0041109114,
0.0187544711,
-0.0103693185,
-0.0632112175,
-0.0067339744,
-0.0181832947,
-0.0400403999,
-0.0312604085,
-0.0151806176,
-0.0064117028,
0.0068027186,
-0.0488082431,
0.0723266229,
0.0056377957,
-0.0498357527,
-0.0635171756,
-0.0028317014,
0.0404135063,
0.0050504217,
0.000940955,
0.0174347293,
-0.0413448773,
-0.0274575744,
0.0083318371,
0.0269876756,
0.0195569545,
-0.0182208996,
0.0611703545,
0.0026247895,
-0.0521403626,
0.0065557384,
0.012596284,
0.0184822716,
0.009681127,
0.0410688706,
0.0398307778,
-0.0050627319,
-0.0021550767,
0.0077837426,
0.0464004204,
0.0206858423,
0.0135618346,
-0.0063855182,
0.0291962028,
0.0299854539,
-0.0366559774,
-0.0432791933,
0.0144904722,
-0.0335048847,
-0.0043264856,
-0.0838791355,
-0.006556408,
-0.0185024124,
2.599e-7,
0.0623440705,
0.0298316982,
0.0484486148,
0.0187088437,
-0.0021428142,
0.0137133012,
0.0285560861,
0.0229610167,
-0.0226457808,
-0.0457486436,
0.0227135234,
-0.0047493652,
0.0345892496,
0.0209267158,
-0.0541224815,
-0.0833244994,
-0.0267235357,
0.0498161428,
-0.0076682745,
0.0296989586,
0.0165840648,
0.0940717459,
0.0125566022,
-0.0340414383,
-0.0124841081,
-0.0189199876,
0.0387205668,
-0.018999679,
0.0121795824,
0.0557934344,
0.0447418056,
0.0697695911,
-0.0289240424,
0.0657092184,
-0.0072858348,
0.0182633549,
0.0263385195,
0.0352517739,
-0.0075031114,
0.0407457873,
-0.0274243765,
-0.0260967519,
0.030899778,
-0.0380073637,
0.0486143492,
-0.0449612923,
-0.0213132538,
-0.0361795537,
-0.0311750975,
-0.0311401635,
0.075942941,
-0.0010203134,
-0.0064183525,
0.0072417706,
0.0427602418,
-0.001429259,
-0.0491384529,
-0.0641131625,
-0.0004421672,
0.0361103043,
0.0089442646,
-0.0055902312,
0.0070208358,
-0.0448905192,
0.0496849641,
-0.0721496791,
0.0204239506,
2.038029861e-34,
0.0345495306,
0.0133554917,
-0.0258385111,
0.0133730723,
0.0196255054,
-0.0084105218,
-0.0069514904,
-0.0071818382,
-0.0098149013,
-0.0508861616,
-0.0018353391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02056v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02056v1 | Integrate the Essence and Eliminate the Dross: Fine-Grained Self-Consistency for Free-Form Language Generation | 2024-07-02T08:38:31 | 2024-07-02T08:38:31 | Xinglin Wang, Yiwei Li, Shaoxiong Feng, Peiwen Yuan, Boyuan Pan, Heda Wang, Yao Hu, Kan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Self-consistency (SC), leveraging multiple samples from LLMs, shows
significant gains on various reasoning tasks but struggles with free-form
generation due to the difficulty of aggregating answers. Its variants, UCS and
USC, rely on sample selection or voting mechanisms to improve output quality.
These methods, however, face limitations due to their inability to fully
utilize the nuanced consensus knowledge present within multiple candidate
samples, often resulting in suboptimal outputs. We propose Fine-Grained
Self-Consistency (FSC) to addresses these limitations by extracting and
integrating segment-level commonalities from candidate samples, enhancing the
performance of LLMs both in open-ended and reasoning tasks. Based on this, we
present two additional strategies: candidate filtering, which enhances overall
quality by identifying highly similar candidate sets, and merging, which
reduces input token requirements by combining similar samples. The
effectiveness of FSC is demonstrated through extensive experiments on various
tasks, including summarization, code generation, and mathematical reasoning,
using GPT-3.5-turbo and GPT-4. The results indicate significant improvements
over baseline methods, showcasing the potential of FSC to optimize output
quality by effectively synthesizing fine-grained consensus knowledge from
multiple samples. | [
-0.0210755859,
0.0478501953,
0.0074160858,
0.0032862204,
-0.0372137837,
-0.0145694017,
-0.0293270033,
-0.019260196,
-0.0204537362,
-0.0191090275,
-0.0198693611,
0.0107598184,
0.0173930991,
0.0120559363,
0.0371227711,
-0.0178832021,
0.0330319926,
-0.0202445909,
-0.0395153277,
-0.0286588632,
0.036720179,
0.0342894047,
0.0106209628,
0.0306304637,
-0.0059962464,
-0.026546834,
-0.0002981722,
-0.0236542914,
0.0258381646,
-0.0114297858,
-0.0126801785,
0.0504823737,
-0.0058232364,
0.0271685794,
0.0000024917,
-0.0583854653,
-0.050797198,
-0.0028585501,
0.0000517285,
0.0007178771,
-0.0118927257,
0.0322498754,
-0.0019014362,
0.0372672416,
-0.0429039523,
0.018003298,
0.0310201608,
-0.0218943805,
0.1037971303,
0.0414963812,
0.0113419425,
0.0041167377,
-0.0123697482,
-0.0083689773,
0.026949361,
0.0121381655,
-0.0270184521,
0.014092491,
0.0260529406,
-0.0331871584,
0.0242682286,
0.0145756556,
0.0357253887,
-0.0345806554,
-0.0149006862,
0.0434148647,
-0.0870916098,
-0.0065906285,
0.0063619032,
0.0558068566,
-0.0149907898,
-0.0617282987,
0.0328227952,
-0.0441495813,
-0.0069503887,
-0.0007686082,
-0.0646914691,
0.0854675472,
-0.0254395939,
0.0630736649,
0.0210465975,
-0.0102911545,
0.0223613568,
0.0028631557,
-0.0479415506,
0.1006734446,
0.0265018921,
-0.0233312063,
-0.0101738451,
0.0142456489,
-0.0335083157,
-0.0811021924,
-0.0057121296,
0.0303640179,
-0.0252152178,
0.0114888046,
-0.0908458829,
-0.0232653152,
0.0468546823,
0.0047981874,
0.0251541473,
0.056986697,
-0.0014922526,
-0.0095247636,
-0.0330928564,
0.0223782826,
-0.0013278719,
0.0578017011,
-0.0647345409,
0.0189380422,
-0.057523638,
0.0083633969,
-0.0407936126,
0.1040972248,
-0.0124793611,
0.0336648151,
-0.0479797572,
0.0458829552,
-0.0231880266,
0.0356380045,
0.0274232365,
-0.0267391279,
-0.0090427184,
-0.0032435823,
-0.0025550977,
0.0135787921,
-0.0471345261,
-0.0360105857,
0.0390301459,
-0.0688894689,
-0.0162071008,
0.0401782058,
-0.0048775901,
-0.0223093983,
-0.0025926393,
0.0526121967,
-0.0217606463,
0.039651487,
-0.0373554081,
-0.0578575991,
-0.0175976865,
-0.0877976343,
0.0011719646,
-0.1119442135,
0.0287274849,
0.0215373747,
-0.0392855294,
-0.0275859851,
0.0077912277,
0.0271660481,
0.0307653956,
0.0270553809,
-0.0712004006,
-0.003563056,
0.0255186819,
0.0172190964,
0.0125138797,
0.0433811322,
0.0405509956,
0.0181399174,
0.0149831809,
-0.0140823023,
-0.0040662787,
0.0171944518,
0.0271522682,
-0.0173845887,
-0.0112029724,
0.0189867578,
-0.0098926937,
0.0159611609,
0.016671557,
0.0527495444,
-0.0175862499,
0.0160437021,
0.007899804,
0.0262269787,
0.0370599106,
0.0276416503,
0.0490667857,
0.0157666616,
0.0172874443,
0.048892539,
-0.0388375483,
0.0604958124,
-0.0147812394,
0.0630025342,
0.0702805445,
0.0457485914,
-0.0132853426,
-0.085571453,
-0.0248936843,
0.00833569,
-0.0320118181,
-0.0171760153,
0.0159970932,
0.0041315365,
-0.0358218849,
0.0786094069,
0.0148728453,
-0.1058857664,
-0.0140235685,
-0.0395061262,
0.0776772127,
0.0380366705,
0.0364419855,
-0.0076004411,
-0.0472373031,
0.0012317938,
0.0095301326,
0.0292323995,
0.0351628698,
0.003132367,
-0.0001527508,
-0.0636059865,
-0.0363852866,
-0.015076858,
-0.0370831825,
0.0373207591,
-0.004879443,
-0.005408817,
0.0414449908,
-0.0499923266,
0.0035170116,
0.0270752236,
0.0120465616,
-0.0126900561,
0.0166733004,
-0.0069322558,
0.0419824459,
0.0154772261,
-0.0198941119,
0.0437874347,
0.0072678979,
-0.017404614,
-0.017283665,
-0.0207806677,
-0.078923054,
-0.0221717022,
0.0369806178,
-0.0225878824,
-0.0494328998,
-0.0044858567,
-0.0491268747,
-0.0605990663,
0.0429082476,
-0.0211882479,
-0.0081247175,
-0.0693505704,
0.0104032774,
0.0505335405,
-0.0228044018,
-0.0272161495,
0.0824485272,
0.0234527029,
-0.0087053506,
0.0211862717,
0.0493249595,
0.0505347624,
-0.0505742505,
0.007863679,
0.0164615717,
-0.0217438117,
0.031002745,
0.0498349108,
0.0583783202,
-0.0403813086,
-0.0472556166,
-0.0436181538,
0.0266828965,
-0.0168731436,
0.0367474183,
0.0252496991,
-0.0062309066,
-0.0022274146,
0.0259755105,
-0.0542956702,
-0.0079997517,
0.0435060561,
-0.0144176893,
0.0460416563,
0.0078608058,
-0.0078427503,
-0.0384334065,
-0.0077346661,
-0.0166632086,
0.0024180433,
0.023396695,
0.0287500191,
-0.0491614714,
0.0256670844,
-0.0885968953,
-0.0017006901,
0.0217462797,
-0.0205855146,
0.0560990348,
-0.0376820154,
0.0358206108,
0.0133825326,
0.0260610525,
-0.0374477617,
0.0726560801,
-0.0249007922,
-0.0706020072,
0.0149121564,
-0.0005755557,
0.0013602099,
0.0279328581,
-0.0122134686,
0.0327695273,
0.0531306379,
0.0492561199,
-0.016338611,
-0.0662793368,
0.0366852321,
0.0310486425,
-0.0057380218,
0.0024258657,
-0.0276750345,
-0.024987448,
0.0149604995,
-0.0141127175,
-0.0894830748,
0.0699879155,
-0.0640259385,
0.0058369869,
-0.0192545429,
0.0026777515,
-0.0526317097,
0.0207295362,
-0.0249327291,
0.0310084186,
0.0229568277,
-0.0130730253,
-0.055711668,
-0.012663438,
0.0558356829,
-0.0230043158,
0.0929268152,
-0.0543572381,
0.0403750837,
-0.0137502328,
-0.0294228457,
-0.0431755297,
0.0373057388,
0.0207775775,
-0.0015573639,
0.0116075361,
-0.0026041237,
0.0328854471,
0.0111410571,
0.0174307767,
0.0000649211,
-0.0207475852,
-0.0369858146,
-0.0056734956,
-0.0022117554,
0.0047959685,
0.0229487568,
0.0318854116,
-0.0096494425,
-0.0058531091,
0.0446459614,
0.0671239793,
0.0434475541,
-0.0278436895,
0.0113816494,
0.01092292,
-0.0621110648,
-0.0279166996,
0.0351974778,
0.0518648922,
-0.0357717872,
-0.0044483161,
0.1228987873,
0.0135684432,
0.0291988514,
-0.0103628021,
-0.016683666,
0.0765521601,
0.0290172882,
0.026710311,
-0.0342204385,
-0.0206401646,
-0.0127619719,
0.0514734983,
-0.0104761934,
-0.0328917801,
-0.0241102595,
-0.1092216149,
0.0575886071,
0.0440268107,
-0.0576662794,
0.011053565,
-0.0065428861,
-0.0195521154,
-0.0034912247,
-0.007001739,
0.0507965349,
-0.0233895034,
0.0215999149,
0.0230106339,
-0.0437211692,
0.0064867316,
-0.0111955395,
-0.0296007134,
0.0160457436,
0.0823746622,
0.0102867708,
0.0055930405,
-0.0491980836,
0.0629598647,
-0.0466664061,
-0.009498301,
-0.0434389785,
-0.0103932582,
0.0136949066,
0.0020191974,
0.0010426043,
0.0176053438,
-0.0186473075,
-0.0341616943,
0.0133786034,
0.0531075932,
-0.0181439854,
-0.0391950384,
-0.0162595492,
0.012466765,
-0.026701428,
0.0499098897,
0.0307610743,
0.0207061917,
-0.0344699919,
-0.0403950177,
-0.0086965533,
-0.0620004311,
0.0016481052,
0.0134957545,
0.0071017616,
0.0192198157,
-0.059074752,
-0.0294481684,
0.0253578741,
0.0509749837,
-0.0330645703,
0.0353204869,
-0.0037390317,
-0.0211090166,
-0.034569744,
0.0086457627,
-0.053727854,
-0.0229251292,
-0.036662817,
-0.0160117485,
-0.0362628996,
-0.0261113085,
-0.0028172617,
0.0488984697,
-0.057503961,
-0.0777349547,
-0.033673659,
0.0655730218,
0.0206137411,
0.0322610289,
0.0142011987,
0.002259193,
0.0385945961,
0.0478678606,
0.0338308364,
0.0210012309,
0.0038532701,
-0.0017928347,
0.01536645,
0.0264649428,
-0.0528193563,
-0.0076204468,
0.0012676166,
0.0383608043,
0.0110117961,
-0.0312999003,
0.0617871061,
0.0923310518,
-0.0355943143,
-0.035345614,
0.0609039329,
-0.0236106999,
-0.0176263433,
-0.0174716301,
-0.0098821046,
-0.0633197129,
0.0306285769,
-0.0347973965,
-0.0506311879,
0.0434862822,
0.0213293768,
-0.0543136075,
0.0576898269,
-0.0001446214,
0.0239642877,
-0.07175982,
0.0362142809,
0.027137965,
-0.0319471173,
-0.0174265429,
-0.011031718,
-0.0170732345,
0.0192240812,
-0.0331568494,
0.0328955501,
0.0272626486,
0.0331550762,
0.0423767641,
0.0505823642,
-0.0353129394,
-0.0593215711,
-0.0610359907,
0.0063495338,
0.015747603,
0.0371154994,
0.0540358722,
-0.0473739095,
0.0173147935,
-0.0238145217,
0.0457694866,
0.0320888199,
-0.0091663348,
0.0150490543,
0.0391417593,
-0.0097249327,
-0.0836711749,
0.0720215663,
-0.058732558,
-0.0281770919,
-0.0063340762,
0.0257999506,
-0.0560534336,
-0.057938043,
-0.0345703959,
0.0015276017,
-0.0136297401,
-0.0730510727,
-0.035144154,
-0.0394240692,
0.0203188788,
0.0868840441,
0.0025798434,
0.0213992372,
0.0577371418,
0.0620983094,
-0.0126359481,
-0.0030496102,
0.0352821499,
-0.0096797608,
-0.0367906354,
-0.0309273917,
0.0105034811,
-6.641861935e-33,
-0.0610948391,
-0.0377315395,
0.0304787811,
-0.0389295518,
-0.0223851167,
-0.0365913212,
-0.04899396,
-0.0002560765,
0.036474064,
-0.0281457473,
0.0086571202,
-0.0056350767,
0.0071161063,
0.0023009544,
0.0304140896,
-0.0012105576,
0.0270432923,
0.0165651143,
-0.0688316971,
0.0194222853,
-0.0110097434,
-0.0205528494,
0.0519136675,
-0.0451473221,
-0.0007728647,
-0.0105809998,
-0.0276064314,
0.0127390912,
-0.0440947451,
0.0645194501,
0.0289592613,
0.0332190841,
-0.0049279174,
-0.0492249168,
-0.0558070429,
-0.0078312801,
-0.0139219211,
-0.0864262879,
0.0245535392,
-0.0614022575,
-0.0407133177,
-0.0347295664,
0.070245862,
-0.031795606,
-0.0251875445,
-0.0259517133,
0.0107951052,
0.0090485476,
0.0123464977,
-0.0173125621,
-0.0144470008,
0.033757858,
-0.0169539638,
-0.004997754,
-0.0194001533,
-0.0058546257,
0.0013476884,
0.009778548,
-0.0075817318,
0.0347753838,
0.0176619217,
0.0548767745,
0.1060246751,
-0.0391364172,
0.0026401288,
0.034744937,
0.0305495728,
-0.0330659077,
-0.0155891394,
-0.0296077896,
-0.0010169437,
0.0513087995,
0.0299624391,
0.0363143235,
0.0325905979,
0.0198033936,
-0.0479588285,
0.0693568215,
-0.0436624251,
0.0148396976,
-0.0309235584,
0.0000791575,
-0.0183632094,
-0.014961971,
-0.0335200466,
0.0019917656,
-0.0226120129,
-0.0511795469,
0.0396545529,
-0.0074709738,
-0.0255488232,
-0.0164255034,
0.0008173148,
0.0143369762,
-0.013642842,
-0.0209055524,
-0.044444669,
0.0000274087,
-0.0010550024,
0.014281095,
-0.0255878437,
-0.000393328,
0.005316773,
-0.0156778768,
0.02791325,
0.0383684076,
-0.0133137396,
0.0168361515,
-0.0484836772,
0.0300427862,
-0.0469958261,
0.0146590499,
-0.0253548156,
-0.0594701581,
0.0108264685,
0.0004007755,
0.0147275534,
0.0179463401,
-0.0188353807,
-0.0398902036,
-0.0460223332,
0.0352964252,
0.025512604,
0.043111138,
0.0035205435,
0.0099946959,
-0.0231037904,
0.0215265062,
0.0653276443,
-0.0010648157,
-0.0220321491,
0.0290758722,
3.113e-7,
0.026467897,
0.0090692658,
0.0501310043,
0.0410755426,
-0.0289964173,
0.0341408513,
-0.0184555035,
0.0148550514,
-0.0210032314,
-0.0143953161,
-0.0046048551,
0.0495920405,
0.0275289342,
0.0846169814,
-0.0502984077,
0.0503729917,
-0.0418205634,
-0.0190023351,
-0.0480283014,
0.0058848746,
0.0605605505,
0.0306274798,
-0.0156831201,
-0.0085381987,
0.0097223138,
-0.0149657726,
0.0302356277,
0.0058956719,
-0.0054362956,
0.0509609506,
0.0041232593,
-0.0309149735,
-0.01886338,
-0.0080173668,
-0.0143285077,
-0.0477961749,
-0.0003343135,
0.0425613336,
0.0220355503,
-0.0078014755,
0.0391991995,
-0.0313910544,
0.0268812925,
-0.0293343849,
0.0478027575,
-0.0421058685,
0.0131152477,
-0.0042952108,
0.0017579909,
-0.0149325412,
0.0018047043,
0.0157558359,
-0.0020292234,
0.0275977198,
0.0031215108,
0.0089506935,
-0.0290207546,
-0.0337466374,
-0.0472292155,
0.0016624189,
-0.0294351373,
-0.0585327819,
-0.067263037,
0.0171231478,
0.026476251,
-0.0454529822,
-0.0368066058,
3.231090046e-34,
0.0049463422,
-0.0229091719,
0.029449828,
-0.0096551999,
0.0197642632,
0.0000960372,
-0.0131997475,
0.0202643778,
-0.0202199277,
-0.0122774225,
-0.0437366515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02049v1 | Accompanied Singing Voice Synthesis with Fully Text-controlled Melody | 2024-07-02T08:23:38 | 2024-07-02T08:23:38 | Ruiqi Li, Zhiqing Hong, Yongqi Wang, Lichao Zhang, Rongjie Huang, Siqi Zheng, Zhou Zhao | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Text-to-song (TTSong) is a music generation task that synthesizes accompanied
singing voices. Current TTSong methods, inherited from singing voice synthesis
(SVS), require melody-related information that can sometimes be impractical,
such as music scores or MIDI sequences. We present MelodyLM, the first TTSong
model that generates high-quality song pieces with fully text-controlled
melodies, achieving minimal user requirements and maximum control flexibility.
MelodyLM explicitly models MIDI as the intermediate melody-related feature and
sequentially generates vocal tracks in a language model manner, conditioned on
textual and vocal prompts. The accompaniment music is subsequently synthesized
by a latent diffusion model with hybrid conditioning for temporal alignment.
With minimal requirements, users only need to input lyrics and a reference
voice to synthesize a song sample. For full control, just input textual prompts
or even directly input MIDI. Experimental results indicate that MelodyLM
achieves superior performance in terms of both objective and subjective
metrics. Audio samples are available at https://melodylm666.github.io. | [
0.0068906201,
0.0157573167,
0.0120226275,
-0.0331445485,
-0.0258180629,
-0.0177116059,
0.0505386293,
-0.0260042679,
-0.0423109904,
0.0404658802,
-0.0581201836,
-0.0422595628,
0.0029001869,
0.0248160716,
0.0426185578,
-0.0701788068,
0.0064649121,
-0.0308671445,
0.0114743374,
-0.0063548107,
-0.0011579894,
0.003531283,
-0.0057821716,
0.026454784,
-0.0313857272,
-0.0213741995,
-0.0407517366,
0.011412655,
0.0133005753,
-0.0012163628,
-0.0587259904,
0.020732237,
0.0325655043,
-0.0192285869,
0.0000016307,
-0.0030982543,
-0.01017108,
0.0222416297,
0.0529491305,
-0.0336329788,
0.0512788743,
0.0439381525,
-0.0311373193,
0.0387672037,
-0.0045380779,
0.0423101336,
0.0529136099,
0.0379867442,
0.0915552825,
0.0979462564,
0.0046306676,
-0.0477645956,
-0.0012679663,
-0.0483993553,
0.068376109,
0.0207408033,
-0.0427119583,
0.0160710607,
0.0743188262,
-0.0123447916,
-0.0153971463,
0.074653551,
0.0039992388,
-0.0077364263,
0.0275648236,
0.0557774492,
-0.0024751304,
-0.0681333393,
0.0167766586,
0.0371369869,
0.0211673249,
-0.012331361,
0.0406159535,
0.014830268,
0.0114061348,
0.0112174265,
-0.0182869155,
-0.0032794052,
0.0190400071,
0.0202857479,
-0.0188341513,
-0.0036462392,
0.0287121106,
-0.0482572876,
0.0420424007,
-0.0143515011,
0.0450068265,
-0.0767071843,
-0.0072144624,
0.0102564273,
0.0183133222,
-0.0646685436,
0.0456559137,
0.0194639266,
-0.0140105672,
-0.003931785,
-0.0728522167,
-0.0567618348,
-0.0241030902,
-0.0141532887,
0.0482091382,
0.0398198739,
0.0117929066,
0.0163941775,
-0.0218192935,
0.0138536328,
-0.0476009622,
-0.076539278,
-0.0134912096,
-0.0085294712,
0.0137700513,
-0.0116385696,
-0.0435275994,
-0.0282080546,
-0.0020058048,
-0.0187898148,
-0.0161966737,
0.0134945996,
-0.0249861684,
0.0255338252,
0.0279999003,
0.0097862771,
-0.0566080697,
0.0026477971,
0.0302748736,
-0.0262903739,
0.0043004849,
0.0420792773,
0.0563781001,
0.0367079638,
0.0155604901,
0.0104305921,
0.0370765962,
0.0119937956,
0.0339943245,
0.000584203,
0.0167642795,
0.0037260877,
-0.0004897889,
-0.0359463058,
-0.0394493379,
-0.0518198833,
-0.0164286904,
-0.0995396897,
0.0358143151,
-0.0468780659,
-0.0449423194,
-0.0279763509,
0.0092484364,
0.0246860813,
-0.0213851985,
0.0052280058,
0.0099235484,
0.0698280856,
0.0017253397,
-0.0125084845,
-0.0128076412,
-0.0062227724,
0.0876794979,
0.0369281061,
-0.0201933626,
-0.0200722422,
0.0362757482,
0.040877074,
0.0537831746,
0.0041538407,
-0.0432146117,
-0.0144140916,
-0.0011329207,
0.0567708798,
0.0504273213,
0.0511558019,
0.0311334133,
0.010010805,
0.0769371241,
0.030400645,
0.0520642251,
0.0487327389,
0.0788351148,
0.027753884,
-0.0207194481,
-0.0020639417,
0.0105837518,
0.06333033,
0.0107133482,
0.0433050133,
0.0981541127,
0.0092961192,
-0.0276045129,
-0.0003127452,
-0.0093496237,
-0.0186953098,
-0.0005136899,
-0.0156914163,
0.0315335356,
0.0404027253,
-0.0433131419,
0.0239286534,
-0.015117065,
-0.1132489592,
0.0321055427,
0.0068923393,
0.0524336509,
0.0671356469,
0.0380654559,
0.0033913371,
0.0366064608,
-0.0398882739,
0.0210322663,
0.0586324409,
-0.0061135804,
-0.0001704602,
0.0096167158,
-0.0103559606,
0.0042470023,
0.0169468969,
-0.0384634435,
-0.00619921,
-0.0349955335,
0.0227196254,
-0.0022946345,
-0.0075156405,
0.0502259992,
0.0130867241,
-0.0530850105,
-0.0139268581,
0.0111918105,
0.0097830882,
0.0351659358,
0.0431237333,
-0.0410878472,
0.0347178429,
0.0265037306,
-0.0124583598,
-0.0294195972,
0.0259053074,
-0.0409954675,
-0.0358492211,
0.0312419124,
-0.0336794779,
0.0132004926,
0.0002576653,
0.0330067016,
-0.0570195541,
0.0801813602,
-0.0093810922,
-0.0065251691,
0.0091892425,
0.0029021723,
0.0205310471,
-0.0415874422,
0.0275966041,
-0.0009571397,
0.0142582022,
0.0251819752,
0.0269920547,
0.0368651934,
-0.0083908709,
-0.0447005779,
-0.0273286458,
0.0317903385,
-0.0120756608,
0.0192379598,
-0.0254036579,
-0.0207935087,
-0.0223942827,
-0.0787468031,
-0.0855873898,
0.0359216593,
-0.0162535012,
-0.0339255519,
0.0224185791,
0.0126384459,
-0.0154609084,
-0.0073546045,
-0.0788531378,
-0.0317732282,
0.0245349649,
0.0009946272,
-0.0362830944,
-0.0190467853,
-0.0247682352,
-0.0370265618,
0.0076064356,
0.0007653647,
-0.0435929187,
-0.0020152945,
-0.0047778813,
-0.0199481361,
0.0310777016,
-0.0504730046,
0.0108130844,
0.0151608316,
0.0315499119,
0.006740666,
-0.0347426012,
0.102161549,
0.003933758,
0.0057011689,
-0.0363243297,
0.0696393996,
-0.0142529309,
-0.0135851111,
0.0217023846,
-0.0078294538,
0.0297724698,
-0.0013144371,
-0.031767156,
0.0044322344,
0.0290070809,
0.0746616125,
-0.0084871734,
-0.0584949069,
0.0130465096,
-0.0264077224,
0.0046396554,
0.0358449742,
0.0131187225,
-0.0331234075,
0.0235542171,
-0.0461796187,
-0.0686854869,
0.0489473306,
-0.0368748978,
-0.0569097586,
-0.0193490889,
-0.0349734388,
-0.0034303444,
0.024406787,
-0.0344313458,
0.0246494357,
-0.0269259699,
-0.0073520849,
-0.0574692152,
0.0498385504,
0.002586565,
-0.0566318333,
0.0328482613,
-0.00492837,
0.0024943738,
0.000780866,
0.0151722385,
-0.0185938943,
-0.0300942324,
0.0388556607,
0.0002331752,
-0.0272553302,
-0.0196017101,
0.0180611815,
0.0018635874,
0.0179129653,
0.0264957268,
-0.0017570178,
0.0010480788,
-0.0171399061,
-0.0069604497,
0.0215971116,
-0.0211273842,
-0.0517516136,
-0.0585351586,
0.0280372389,
0.0091271373,
0.0297185034,
0.0028608181,
0.0187043734,
-0.0067205112,
-0.005620141,
0.0235592294,
0.0110548455,
0.0308617707,
0.0542748906,
-0.0306465272,
0.0092412326,
0.0967490301,
-0.0054451139,
0.003118671,
-0.0010022445,
0.0187946707,
0.0600622483,
0.0119172558,
0.0066978736,
-0.0265779216,
0.0316624381,
0.0439914577,
0.065371573,
0.0324595459,
0.0106881782,
-0.0326745845,
-0.0382963829,
0.0317884535,
0.03397654,
-0.0425857492,
-0.0112877535,
-0.0251582209,
-0.0283209793,
0.0113273077,
-0.0179549661,
0.0196140613,
-0.0257893689,
0.0250247903,
-0.0015063685,
-0.0259605236,
-0.020400146,
-0.0346735939,
-0.0870726556,
0.0927639529,
0.0788133889,
0.0663933903,
0.013536742,
-0.0349963121,
-0.0368560292,
0.0437618569,
-0.0042665829,
0.0354244821,
0.0153005663,
0.0403972641,
-0.0126553401,
0.005008541,
0.0694308579,
-0.0297993999,
0.0069881142,
0.0211692601,
0.0512090474,
-0.0182709377,
-0.0262867827,
-0.0219791029,
0.0565850958,
0.0344845392,
0.0659825057,
0.0298613384,
-0.0972641706,
-0.0102018351,
-0.0042569079,
0.0095760562,
-0.0398071632,
-0.0411620885,
-0.0274843853,
-0.0227502864,
-0.032830555,
-0.0861684531,
-0.0185120199,
0.017478276,
0.0382396132,
0.0092127994,
0.0028208047,
-0.0248541404,
-0.0651558042,
-0.0558594204,
-0.0112638259,
0.009126504,
0.0367492214,
-0.0365195721,
-0.0664193779,
-0.0287387557,
-0.0466847755,
-0.0005483912,
-0.0416078381,
-0.1074717343,
-0.0675018281,
0.0033902181,
0.0029448268,
0.0145045882,
0.0454524159,
-0.0008929772,
-0.0001004812,
0.0106839547,
-0.0236379169,
0.0347758532,
0.0655989051,
0.0278622918,
-0.0101696765,
0.02471455,
-0.0096465321,
-0.0655719042,
0.015686892,
0.0164341368,
0.0404405594,
0.0612224489,
-0.0020200983,
0.0071672969,
-0.0056397263,
-0.0189107619,
-0.0182661321,
0.0480355024,
-0.0616991855,
-0.0488454141,
-0.0397038125,
0.0045227977,
-0.0699843243,
-0.0124489721,
0.0566870458,
0.0560171232,
0.0041313581,
-0.017871229,
-0.0226232726,
-0.0262286961,
-0.0484166294,
0.0069341268,
0.0067565008,
0.0042873891,
0.0526659377,
0.0107904263,
0.0359524973,
0.0054511945,
-0.0160977691,
-0.0088525675,
0.0280200951,
-0.0036386172,
0.0250174012,
0.0043765716,
-0.0150040276,
0.0032831328,
-0.0577444136,
-0.0312225148,
-0.0260852687,
-0.0045225504,
0.0547688119,
0.0211341251,
0.0804853812,
0.0094470643,
0.0139047764,
-0.0148334941,
0.051465597,
-0.0123240529,
-0.046399083,
-0.0279392824,
-0.0256176125,
-0.0061255214,
-0.0052293953,
0.0456296876,
-0.029039368,
0.0199900921,
-0.0510465764,
0.0195517316,
0.0251595546,
0.0193239078,
-0.0488789566,
-0.0303127971,
-0.0136055518,
-0.0199423525,
-0.0144694969,
-0.0565829091,
0.0303911921,
0.0058786995,
-0.0111409221,
-0.0393227302,
0.0269814953,
-0.0006852637,
-0.033184208,
0.0482369326,
-0.041088447,
-0.0391676351,
0.014306833,
-0.0575220659,
-0.0373116434,
-4.924383506e-33,
-0.0310746115,
0.0190246161,
0.007213017,
0.0210528243,
-0.0434125103,
-0.0621877797,
-0.0870066732,
0.0172970816,
0.025232695,
-0.0124799823,
0.0123607013,
0.0353247188,
-0.014424555,
0.0251285303,
0.0094585,
0.024102509,
0.0773032904,
-0.0241147019,
-0.0349921323,
0.0377996936,
0.0323382355,
0.0319832452,
-0.0596882999,
-0.0830846801,
0.0239164867,
-0.0369433202,
-0.0107593192,
-0.0264479984,
0.0273266304,
0.02691333,
-0.0051383511,
-0.0210416615,
-0.0093039339,
0.0186245218,
-0.0669986084,
0.0341930948,
0.0070905806,
-0.0382781178,
-0.0212982073,
-0.0080424016,
-0.0187399443,
-0.0240945145,
0.0107294722,
-0.0056832447,
-0.0337243713,
0.0057611861,
0.038593933,
-0.0123362774,
-0.010217974,
-0.0973706543,
-0.0437137559,
-0.0008126789,
-0.0078771254,
-0.0362399369,
0.0492006056,
0.0761594772,
-0.0023961659,
0.0306345187,
-0.0190956332,
0.0546600297,
-0.0258627478,
0.0078873215,
0.07198897,
0.0208411366,
0.0208944064,
0.0552188754,
0.028423408,
-0.0398530997,
-0.0505301952,
0.0458296388,
0.0023297926,
0.0494108126,
0.0457617119,
-0.0520716384,
0.0220448859,
-0.0207453035,
0.00627951,
0.013303699,
-0.0380835645,
-0.0675929934,
0.0046928353,
0.0582056157,
-0.0279168859,
0.006763564,
-0.0507332869,
-0.0350748859,
-0.0253032092,
-0.0694783032,
0.0591682717,
0.0098067252,
-0.0120896725,
-0.0435949303,
-0.0109257568,
-0.0204822551,
-0.0011971347,
-0.0244270265,
-0.0684335604,
0.019755464,
-0.0002189914,
-0.0064159082,
-0.0396890268,
-0.0086395722,
0.0955127031,
0.0075067431,
0.0203350671,
0.0147145009,
-0.0146638658,
0.0776066408,
-0.0719466358,
0.007563795,
-0.0234325472,
0.0259325597,
0.034488298,
0.0251732264,
0.0360664651,
-0.0038158384,
-0.0008345002,
0.0481511503,
0.017540507,
-0.0148085505,
-0.009616917,
-0.0256375968,
-0.0116538722,
-0.0202743132,
-0.0101629039,
0.0273118746,
-0.0125785815,
0.0209000204,
0.058999598,
-0.0224560909,
-0.0383479111,
0.0406744219,
2.513e-7,
-0.0104243197,
-0.0268120691,
-0.0116217872,
0.0179218259,
0.0189715289,
0.0061925841,
-0.0841002315,
0.0174510777,
-0.0098901289,
0.0365547799,
0.0251615308,
-0.026662292,
0.0955387428,
0.0249725617,
-0.0717084631,
0.0083610341,
-0.076017566,
0.0089177359,
-0.0454382747,
-0.0163893066,
0.0443642661,
0.0541631095,
0.0221502259,
0.001140843,
0.013440459,
-0.0039989385,
0.0505731776,
-0.0222579557,
0.0086679514,
-0.0778049007,
-0.0107620368,
-0.0288345125,
-0.0161527339,
-0.072303772,
-0.0637515932,
0.0303446427,
0.0410205387,
0.0639590621,
0.0187923294,
-0.0090581672,
0.012866253,
0.0344904587,
-0.0223030634,
0.0295692328,
0.0242027491,
-0.0056746183,
-0.0053299456,
-0.0101948734,
-0.0227617212,
0.0305728037,
-0.0231191162,
-0.0144982217,
-0.0208112728,
-0.0281709321,
0.0160290375,
0.0172663033,
0.0555171221,
-0.0089204684,
-0.0354242399,
-0.0132138273,
-0.0652458072,
-0.024959838,
-0.006375541,
0.0605592616,
-0.0075064744,
-0.0066983774,
-0.0197664835,
2.057336897e-34,
0.0382637791,
-0.0799434707,
-0.0100712385,
-0.0107014421,
0.014840059,
-0.005192427,
0.0183177833,
0.0019410895,
-0.0072696763,
-0.0336049497,
-0.0656465068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02043v1 | Concise and Precise Context Compression for Tool-Using Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:17:00 | 2024-07-02T08:17:00 | Yang Xu, Yunlong Feng, Honglin Mu, Yutai Hou, Yitong Li, Xinghao Wang, Wanjun Zhong, Zhongyang Li, Dandan Tu, Qingfu Zhu, Min Zhang, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | Through reading the documentation in the context, tool-using language models
can dynamically extend their capability using external tools. The cost is that
we have to input lengthy documentation every time the model needs to use the
tool, occupying the input window as well as slowing down the decoding process.
Given the progress in general-purpose compression, soft context compression
is a suitable approach to alleviate the problem. However, when compressing tool
documentation, existing methods suffer from the weaknesses of key information
loss (specifically, tool/parameter name errors) and difficulty in adjusting the
length of compressed sequences based on documentation lengths.
To address these problems, we propose two strategies for compressing tool
documentation into concise and precise summary sequences for tool-using
language models. 1) Selective compression strategy mitigates key information
loss by deliberately retaining key information as raw text tokens. 2) Block
compression strategy involves dividing tool documentation into short chunks and
then employing a fixed-length compression model to achieve variable-length
compression. This strategy facilitates the flexible adjustment of the
compression ratio.
Results on API-Bank and APIBench show that our approach reaches a performance
comparable to the upper-bound baseline under up to 16x compression ratio. | [
-0.0059703742,
0.0239483118,
-0.0270768926,
0.0040204162,
-0.0306782983,
0.0020109662,
-0.0400153548,
0.0552700236,
-0.104451403,
-0.0120199043,
0.0189970806,
0.0348086916,
0.0240920074,
-0.0034820049,
0.0275891349,
-0.0616946556,
0.0307091568,
-0.000633781,
-0.0103985285,
0.0327498429,
-0.0164372846,
0.0152019346,
0.0548548438,
0.0630545095,
-0.0171295293,
-0.0171820745,
-0.0264508761,
0.0222668163,
-0.0387648083,
0.0077667264,
0.0019683335,
0.0368048884,
0.0278338026,
0.0173341837,
0.0000021177,
-0.0234402064,
-0.0205715802,
0.0417036973,
-0.0700112283,
0.0287856441,
0.0401506536,
-0.0784955025,
-0.0177052896,
0.0224139113,
0.0107915401,
-0.0411867276,
0.0700377598,
-0.0128511954,
0.0634028614,
0.0130681666,
0.0114689237,
0.0055196397,
-0.025791185,
-0.0045457184,
-0.0461171158,
0.0102049159,
-0.0385788232,
0.018760778,
0.031490244,
0.0352418534,
0.00449858,
0.0155305164,
0.0341297872,
0.0177617203,
-0.0113365036,
-0.0023419859,
-0.0333545059,
-0.0255340561,
0.0468270481,
0.0132890921,
-0.0105259689,
-0.0551959351,
-0.0107622314,
-0.0159447417,
0.0096625974,
-0.0205870494,
-0.0999122933,
0.0523221977,
-0.0017444537,
-0.0038685163,
0.0213699602,
0.0279748067,
-0.0021654973,
-0.0375339128,
0.002226365,
0.0316385925,
-0.0082809692,
0.0199035034,
-0.0287500806,
-0.0503234006,
0.0228370149,
-0.0621475317,
-0.0350275077,
0.0210054312,
0.0465958528,
0.0005608597,
-0.0548570119,
-0.0171052869,
0.0900714323,
-0.0754193887,
-0.0141198002,
0.0497135594,
-0.0126837818,
0.0040735225,
-0.0156190041,
0.0360641554,
0.0403639413,
-0.021339044,
-0.027215112,
-0.038039308,
0.0028534567,
-0.0173942205,
-0.0623561852,
0.009900501,
-0.0273165405,
-0.0032245726,
0.010238043,
0.0733015016,
0.0203135256,
0.0336660147,
0.0192666538,
-0.0608914942,
-0.0486056916,
-0.0194475166,
0.0541796982,
-0.0225493908,
-0.0134762563,
-0.0240282901,
-0.0153949354,
-0.0219349265,
-0.0371607505,
0.0306181256,
0.0130164726,
0.0028473488,
-0.0268373173,
0.0799240246,
0.0385750085,
0.0255172234,
-0.0307116117,
-0.0686610565,
0.0561129004,
0.0135762375,
-0.047414422,
-0.0723066479,
0.0274825525,
0.0346322954,
-0.0111686569,
-0.026731601,
-0.0273992121,
-0.0033192032,
-0.0175311472,
0.0053434349,
-0.0432026461,
0.0104173366,
0.0331635177,
0.0359207615,
0.0267659053,
0.0687047392,
0.0173996873,
0.0206995774,
0.0226632543,
-0.0626991466,
-0.0395892896,
0.0412664264,
0.02343853,
-0.0016504616,
-0.0362745449,
0.0293104611,
0.0507611334,
-0.0329303406,
0.0202881452,
0.0355848521,
-0.0381050408,
-0.0446349867,
0.0073958407,
0.0395628102,
0.071889028,
0.0379188992,
0.0548643097,
0.0537626892,
0.0075763431,
-0.0166067388,
-0.0069964565,
-0.013226877,
-0.0226858724,
0.0379835516,
0.0335103199,
0.0102073541,
-0.0086833397,
-0.008180744,
-0.0423925407,
-0.0497104302,
0.0266631953,
-0.0548702441,
0.0138674304,
0.0010554182,
-0.0516111813,
0.0680030435,
0.021160692,
-0.0447462387,
-0.0490878262,
-0.028351156,
-0.039173089,
-0.004461959,
0.0869481936,
0.0054114768,
-0.0374198519,
-0.0125695597,
-0.0287922379,
-0.0105288345,
0.0393772088,
-0.03628622,
0.0234244056,
-0.0416440032,
-0.0169964377,
-0.0247796755,
0.0105039552,
-0.0036691437,
0.0233809333,
0.0098834708,
0.0460168459,
-0.0778468177,
-0.0002951093,
0.005523345,
0.006461598,
-0.0210700836,
0.0003279847,
-0.0011994853,
0.0225025434,
-0.0082268277,
-0.0262719635,
0.0039080293,
0.0598979928,
-0.0171802435,
0.0056937188,
0.0024447916,
-0.0441708714,
0.0161164906,
0.0272861905,
0.0240593348,
0.0684381649,
0.0182313919,
-0.0051108347,
-0.0401923843,
-0.013165676,
-0.0401040763,
0.0640820339,
0.023593381,
0.0212433282,
-0.0132978391,
0.0367847346,
-0.0375882424,
0.0062534576,
0.0007605479,
-0.0243002381,
-0.0099790515,
-0.0068791015,
0.0286161844,
0.0145328762,
0.0084414445,
0.0606502034,
-0.0129730348,
-0.0109022856,
0.0499076918,
0.0273435172,
0.0276608132,
-0.0090792868,
-0.0903434679,
-0.0089642806,
0.0113686398,
0.0278840084,
0.0084723439,
0.0434198603,
0.0015498014,
0.0208660234,
-0.0214629155,
0.0104281129,
-0.0292633995,
0.0077709584,
-0.0137729878,
0.0221178308,
-0.018546965,
-0.0074394583,
-0.0390336029,
0.009970298,
0.0663946569,
-0.0250334982,
-0.0760282055,
-0.0745929405,
0.0832617953,
0.0193507262,
-0.000359816,
0.0054878551,
-0.0183810499,
-0.0202621687,
-0.0251634158,
-0.0040662675,
0.030648021,
-0.0312021989,
0.048311796,
0.0650668517,
0.0006598647,
-0.0770600066,
-0.0117909033,
0.0037243259,
-0.0215746686,
0.0055419062,
-0.053892985,
0.0168024302,
0.0172774103,
0.0098286252,
0.0202870667,
-0.0194596089,
-0.0516708568,
0.0081819789,
-0.0053973328,
0.0246014521,
-0.0744736493,
0.0276327562,
0.0325635485,
0.0126418928,
-0.0597850718,
0.0347411521,
-0.0814928412,
0.0008861654,
-0.0046642707,
-0.0444665477,
-0.0619943514,
0.0702086687,
0.0103025483,
0.0500134528,
0.0064388076,
-0.0048405048,
-0.013833358,
0.0136757568,
0.0071529257,
-0.0305924397,
-0.0194585063,
-0.0216059461,
0.0012961499,
-0.0391583405,
0.0054939166,
0.0143546956,
0.0068729054,
0.0306912493,
0.0480091609,
0.0616656616,
-0.0060420036,
0.0312701352,
0.0952230096,
0.0346108787,
0.0617732443,
0.0697892234,
-0.0014552929,
-0.0003538493,
-0.0012907286,
-0.0331373885,
-0.0136506287,
0.0162245259,
0.001180792,
0.018566316,
0.0476886332,
0.0428502038,
0.0186635572,
-0.0319622457,
-0.0544269457,
0.0478893854,
0.0028222068,
-0.0609126575,
0.0480155274,
0.0256473161,
-0.0756739751,
0.0146006271,
0.0653071627,
0.0376132056,
-0.0697701946,
0.0233242083,
-0.0123684658,
0.0326349363,
0.0021745677,
0.0472363941,
-0.0877381936,
-0.0100938827,
0.0185409579,
0.027104646,
0.0011995578,
0.0194621086,
-0.0321099311,
-0.0672497824,
0.0255736914,
0.0307854936,
0.011805526,
0.003323809,
-0.0612552501,
-0.0086298455,
0.0355945826,
-0.0257464014,
0.0255827457,
0.0267758463,
0.0044303401,
0.0082923993,
-0.0596858077,
-0.0716115907,
-0.0130860582,
0.0166832507,
0.0635963082,
0.0424421653,
-0.0215565525,
0.0260183252,
0.0682526752,
0.0799576715,
0.0099365525,
-0.0035766475,
-0.0539005101,
-0.0191729758,
0.0089079905,
0.0173718855,
0.0575504564,
0.0146414898,
-0.0258043539,
-0.0127221346,
-0.0398048721,
0.0680952147,
-0.0093020154,
0.0132181505,
-0.0490692295,
-0.0575723313,
-0.009400202,
0.0566393323,
0.0410627685,
0.0260511916,
-0.0116844103,
-0.0341224372,
-0.0458982028,
0.0284792092,
-0.0000340142,
-0.0256063864,
-0.0211062115,
-0.0788351744,
-0.0378365889,
-0.0275052357,
0.0102112237,
0.0186471716,
-0.0096691689,
0.0202721711,
-0.0026694392,
0.0038138579,
-0.112857312,
-0.0153715592,
-0.0101428451,
-0.0023926517,
-0.0435740128,
-0.0042487998,
0.0099347057,
0.0126134548,
-0.0107493522,
0.0681611076,
-0.0545115359,
-0.0528982319,
-0.0247209165,
0.0540230274,
0.0262619592,
0.0614646487,
-0.0313137136,
-0.0569832288,
-0.015457944,
0.0707541108,
-0.0593835078,
0.0513058864,
0.0049844896,
-0.0002452109,
0.0222503357,
0.0150980474,
-0.0613181069,
-0.0309372079,
-0.0429646671,
-0.0101202335,
-0.0223705862,
-0.0539396033,
0.0369487703,
0.0308529977,
-0.07944832,
0.0171397608,
0.0166461058,
0.0456833318,
0.042395141,
-0.0299570151,
-0.0343950689,
-0.0322676674,
0.0495326966,
-0.0671607405,
-0.052065298,
0.0926822424,
0.0013210445,
-0.0068773339,
0.0175662134,
0.0055878949,
0.0286472328,
-0.0508307889,
0.0077963984,
0.0437406041,
0.012336595,
-0.0397385135,
-0.0642892197,
-0.0296502337,
0.0212741792,
-0.0929981247,
0.0092807505,
0.0237144958,
0.0383871607,
-0.0195816178,
0.0512615815,
0.0038842717,
-0.0360274091,
-0.0387167968,
-0.0453208648,
-0.010373868,
-0.0162245035,
0.049840346,
-0.0645379275,
0.0160435643,
-0.043287795,
0.0341153853,
0.0021633452,
-0.0004933175,
-0.0074132271,
0.0212864671,
-0.0146277165,
-0.0202473607,
0.0867635459,
0.0197221804,
0.0102445092,
-0.0345299579,
-0.0387754701,
-0.0412662476,
-0.007108022,
0.0361298546,
0.0397314914,
-0.0210671313,
-0.0159755312,
-0.050281018,
-0.0527269915,
-0.0499293245,
0.0091660656,
0.0169006623,
-0.012444648,
0.0201204028,
0.0737482309,
0.0417504832,
-0.0082568098,
-0.0073500285,
0.0100206938,
-0.0200952459,
-0.0367365144,
0.0156618133,
-5.387051103e-33,
-0.0321944095,
0.0174888168,
0.000988779,
-0.0366494507,
0.0150939375,
0.0222712215,
-0.0419675112,
-0.0341151282,
-0.0014914908,
-0.048608169,
0.0087944577,
-0.0003600111,
0.0092223138,
-0.0355957039,
-0.0257103257,
0.0653187409,
0.0227026492,
0.0262190811,
-0.0197729133,
0.0391114913,
0.0229131114,
-0.0200954918,
0.0502408668,
-0.084660992,
-0.0130147804,
0.0053830096,
0.0188824311,
-0.0387920924,
0.0668710992,
0.0750367641,
0.0060069771,
-0.0060225991,
-0.0002217216,
-0.0245855786,
-0.0297717936,
-0.0168012399,
-0.0647604913,
-0.002231278,
0.0177282225,
0.0124684777,
0.0323915519,
-0.0777751878,
0.0438229144,
0.0040395283,
0.0142267132,
0.0112991184,
-0.029856801,
-0.0079134209,
-0.0740628168,
-0.052023571,
-0.0113991741,
0.0264071617,
-0.0244266149,
0.0076501654,
0.0298520718,
0.0195904952,
-0.0029783361,
0.0027322725,
-0.0208783187,
0.0119492225,
0.0483912528,
0.0742191821,
0.0856756046,
-0.0516662635,
0.0100600254,
-0.0227743015,
-0.0184859801,
-0.0090465797,
0.0104544247,
0.0364114828,
0.0289446618,
0.0116153173,
0.0007642617,
-0.0109726489,
0.032862097,
0.0025087059,
-0.0049859583,
0.0388656706,
-0.0026866891,
0.0574924499,
0.0312306955,
0.0408381112,
-0.0324878208,
-0.0135458894,
-0.0530183651,
-0.0243008249,
-0.0044011325,
-0.0281608887,
0.0035370844,
0.0138280876,
-0.0089629833,
-0.0014631487,
0.0388552547,
-0.0197773743,
0.0137523767,
0.05442027,
-0.0451825932,
0.0358149074,
-0.0089004021,
0.0108272806,
0.0101261549,
0.0060073668,
0.009777938,
-0.0443810523,
0.0472125039,
-0.0002392804,
-0.0212006234,
0.0648267567,
-0.0579928681,
0.0085739307,
-0.0352598689,
-0.0458075441,
-0.028957095,
-0.0404667966,
0.0337328576,
-0.0132015701,
0.02344824,
0.0164815877,
-0.0098342877,
-0.0576335602,
0.0154308127,
-0.0403099693,
0.0249739923,
0.0142613612,
-0.013555238,
0.0104484614,
-0.0018063418,
0.0149488123,
0.1070477664,
0.0265526548,
-0.0182255991,
0.0260724984,
2.761e-7,
0.0148097817,
0.0283671208,
0.0418437533,
0.0158834327,
0.0278025065,
0.0220089741,
0.0223639663,
0.0142831914,
-0.0521165952,
0.0005527319,
-0.0200478993,
0.0005832704,
0.0230974201,
0.0218597818,
-0.0379449986,
0.0205939226,
0.0059862239,
-0.0358602069,
-0.0628971383,
-0.0010852895,
0.0403959751,
0.1013575494,
-0.0045699868,
-0.0174151827,
-0.0136928475,
-0.0472400486,
-0.0331739485,
-0.0343618169,
0.0277091842,
0.0194408055,
-0.0062494394,
0.0146349445,
-0.0053149941,
-0.0228248611,
-0.0209424719,
-0.0060465392,
-0.0560012534,
0.077624023,
-0.0127563467,
0.0037095228,
0.0661528483,
-0.0681116134,
-0.044108063,
-0.024208596,
0.0293371174,
0.0277788658,
-0.0241178423,
-0.0141179767,
0.002645087,
0.0182145964,
-0.0704690591,
0.001742203,
0.0170025267,
0.0207395181,
0.0008539063,
-0.0053564603,
0.0113651007,
-0.0463386178,
-0.0388036966,
0.0232727192,
-0.0063254135,
-0.0385998189,
-0.0344049931,
0.0129163796,
0.022149818,
-0.0272174515,
0.0154543528,
3.54171902e-34,
0.028613938,
-0.0206209738,
0.0028211372,
0.0681419522,
0.0032637303,
-0.0311342087,
0.0052359123,
0.0429701358,
0.0149065722,
-0.0558102615,
-0.0549181812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02042v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02042v1 | Fake News Detection and Manipulation Reasoning via Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:16:43 | 2024-07-02T08:16:43 | Ruihan Jin, Ruibo Fu, Zhengqi Wen, Shuai Zhang, Yukun Liu, Jianhua Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Fake news becomes a growing threat to information security and public opinion
with the rapid sprawl of media manipulation. Therefore, fake news detection
attracts widespread attention from academic community. Traditional fake news
detection models demonstrate remarkable performance on authenticity binary
classification but their ability to reason detailed faked traces based on the
news content remains under-explored. Furthermore, due to the lack of external
knowledge, the performance of existing methods on fact-related news is
questionable, leaving their practical implementation unclear. In this paper, we
propose a new multi-media research topic, namely manipulation reasoning.
Manipulation reasoning aims to reason manipulations based on news content. To
support the research, we introduce a benchmark for fake news detection and
manipulation reasoning, referred to as Human-centric and Fact-related Fake News
(HFFN). The benchmark highlights the centrality of human and the high factual
relevance, with detailed manual annotations. HFFN encompasses four realistic
domains with fake news samples generated through three manipulation approaches.
Moreover, a Multi-modal news Detection and Reasoning langUage Model (M-DRUM) is
presented not only to judge on the authenticity of multi-modal news, but also
raise analytical reasoning about potential manipulations. On the feature
extraction level, a cross-attention mechanism is employed to extract
fine-grained fusion features from multi-modal inputs. On the reasoning level, a
large vision-language model (LVLM) serves as the backbone to facilitate
fact-related reasoning. A two-stage training framework is deployed to better
activate the capacity of identification and reasoning. Comprehensive
experiments demonstrate that our model outperforms state-of-the-art (SOTA) fake
news detection models and powerful LVLMs like GPT-4 and LLaVA. | [
0.0651042759,
0.009347083,
0.0173125938,
0.0682549402,
-0.0555309653,
0.0258184485,
-0.0030129673,
0.0013379931,
0.0040837415,
-0.0646873564,
-0.0055705942,
-0.0193044376,
0.0194083899,
0.0633223429,
0.0444770083,
-0.0394083969,
0.0758899599,
0.0201468114,
0.0423680022,
0.0121746566,
0.0429652072,
0.0310108792,
0.0051288917,
0.0296419524,
-0.0504695922,
-0.0200552344,
0.014422006,
0.0170233231,
0.060094133,
0.0249706171,
-0.0359653533,
0.049273517,
0.0554300137,
0.0813072473,
0.0000018015,
-0.0354736224,
-0.0143112037,
0.0105206789,
-0.0126171988,
-0.0060600941,
0.0303066391,
-0.0608639829,
-0.0396502428,
0.0255423747,
-0.0207885988,
-0.0086357109,
0.0205505192,
0.0948396772,
0.1035725921,
0.1184793115,
-0.0250863899,
-0.0214450657,
0.0133058373,
-0.0018777663,
0.008554508,
-0.0237825159,
0.0296549965,
0.0165397748,
-0.0001853359,
0.046948269,
0.0257095043,
0.0034446584,
0.0170182791,
-0.0414564088,
-0.0524915494,
0.0170408636,
-0.0136820786,
-0.0303267092,
0.0201821178,
0.0416308604,
-0.0671589524,
-0.0333972909,
0.011461556,
0.0067532728,
0.022431178,
0.0178458691,
0.0094865356,
0.0391027704,
-0.014682889,
0.0088004302,
-0.0069726775,
-0.0360189453,
0.0280321613,
0.0528716668,
-0.0057524671,
0.012935617,
-0.0155990319,
0.0085975602,
0.0050141085,
-0.0110891378,
0.0038354881,
-0.0406241603,
-0.0222179666,
0.0231108703,
0.0111466572,
-0.0046819453,
-0.0674475953,
-0.0338341668,
0.0185278151,
-0.0965706483,
-0.0092881592,
-0.0038403498,
-0.0249780864,
0.0756777897,
-0.0125950854,
0.0051441495,
-0.067235142,
0.0635836422,
0.0028723192,
-0.0270518512,
-0.0119809406,
0.0078205708,
0.0258482639,
0.0255613048,
-0.0322101265,
-0.0176072102,
-0.0380012654,
0.007907372,
-0.029537078,
0.0245079137,
-0.0286666472,
0.0228972957,
0.0004424549,
-0.0540163293,
-0.0219780076,
0.0369437188,
0.024399776,
0.0412582792,
-0.0079789748,
-0.0379420146,
-0.025000466,
0.0495406799,
-0.0188399106,
-0.0058423867,
-0.0042579295,
0.0119076651,
-0.0169804376,
0.007184797,
-0.0740771219,
-0.0489839502,
-0.0233397949,
-0.059776593,
0.0122915469,
-0.0504131056,
-0.0222861413,
-0.0478749759,
-0.01785638,
0.0023667829,
-0.0098600052,
0.0198956337,
-0.0457162447,
0.0736850128,
0.0044169738,
-0.0125282435,
0.040779978,
0.0364891998,
-0.0085654305,
0.0761701018,
0.0154615864,
0.1232558712,
0.037154749,
0.0197838191,
0.0297159273,
-0.003196887,
0.0292508863,
0.0138044581,
0.0006323563,
0.0016293367,
-0.0210395586,
0.0005010378,
0.0102914665,
-0.0072712554,
-0.0128226457,
-0.0363940224,
0.0830122754,
-0.028663421,
-0.0058412272,
-0.0137934908,
0.0540582798,
0.0114148688,
-0.0077943951,
-0.0038239409,
-0.0735452548,
0.050882671,
-0.058236286,
-0.0159926359,
-0.0227712616,
0.0631762967,
-0.0168432165,
-0.0027370024,
0.0013969253,
-0.0372347459,
-0.0020146207,
-0.0051573929,
0.0013897738,
0.0084096948,
-0.0383410491,
0.003010713,
0.0238022897,
0.0000321852,
0.0017052409,
-0.0690968484,
0.0306567568,
-0.0003748987,
0.011878158,
0.0209475644,
0.030719826,
-0.0589916259,
0.0115237581,
0.0111084031,
0.0181954633,
-0.0146772712,
-0.0431802049,
-0.0009428095,
-0.0223871488,
-0.0383594707,
-0.0056554251,
0.0232908092,
-0.0158146042,
0.001024856,
0.0247641578,
-0.0135032386,
-0.0105562909,
-0.0006229184,
0.0333684608,
-0.0025181675,
-0.0203118715,
0.049998045,
0.031638369,
0.0200561285,
0.0064525828,
-0.0073559238,
0.0545031019,
-0.0007650333,
-0.0239456631,
-0.0297871958,
0.001598947,
-0.0026934478,
0.0118035655,
-0.0535233915,
-0.0394390449,
0.0594276823,
-0.0338217542,
0.006923377,
0.0337025486,
-0.0237204004,
-0.027495116,
-0.075139232,
-0.0272361413,
-0.0107349884,
0.0287111774,
0.0171134863,
0.1079492718,
-0.0184280984,
-0.0445402041,
0.0247738119,
-0.0115880538,
0.0069165798,
0.0168854818,
0.0323157459,
0.0282483995,
-0.0127117001,
0.0205496065,
0.0257713106,
-0.0315545686,
-0.0123331677,
-0.0152402055,
-0.058625415,
-0.0231084153,
-0.0416494608,
-0.0149589498,
0.0272811111,
0.002284782,
0.0077888062,
0.0076396293,
-0.0273902472,
-0.0172510445,
-0.0140598631,
0.0156602934,
0.0000441549,
-0.0082676541,
0.0260913093,
0.0189599171,
0.0328353904,
-0.0191938803,
0.0477438346,
0.0093960753,
-0.0374934003,
-0.0370522588,
-0.0377642438,
-0.039535895,
0.0188885983,
-0.0295599997,
-0.0176806618,
-0.0044503305,
-0.0015614991,
-0.0095765255,
0.0757307783,
0.0658692718,
0.0450855196,
0.0238534883,
0.0496872626,
-0.0239150915,
-0.0160027705,
-0.023490997,
0.0513497591,
-0.0384128578,
-0.0355097204,
0.0233323164,
0.0033685418,
-0.0004016048,
0.0093436893,
-0.0209102668,
0.0636647567,
0.0275966581,
-0.0231273714,
0.0239320062,
-0.0348312818,
-0.0071342071,
0.0105912937,
-0.0414417349,
-0.0229494069,
0.0947218463,
-0.0232322514,
0.0417140871,
0.0043881973,
-0.0313806683,
-0.0219374504,
0.0105961366,
-0.0108539807,
0.0249685869,
0.003860682,
0.0019099535,
-0.0190978944,
-0.0337048806,
0.0754768699,
-0.0139185572,
0.0274055619,
-0.0441012681,
0.0301886592,
0.001244795,
-0.007562784,
-0.0490036979,
-0.0964778215,
-0.0080773067,
-0.0198154896,
-0.0625215098,
-0.0324544981,
-0.0767249167,
-0.0154062072,
0.0757268891,
0.0299016014,
-0.0145748844,
0.0278462023,
-0.0119691389,
0.0451837592,
0.0344493911,
0.0252066534,
0.0436056778,
0.0013162607,
-0.0315347612,
0.0723440647,
-0.0137338107,
0.0209469926,
-0.0327110551,
-0.0117985271,
-0.0049361987,
0.0201010052,
0.0343063846,
-0.0025833952,
0.0154540427,
-0.0468995497,
0.0438543893,
0.0815916136,
-0.0145960422,
-0.0089347018,
0.0019609074,
0.0476667508,
-0.0430243537,
0.0094219483,
-0.0146401236,
-0.0580564737,
-0.0162876118,
0.0038778246,
-0.0087552192,
-0.0507074818,
-0.0218498427,
-0.0428418107,
-0.0871221274,
0.0292042438,
-0.0101000154,
0.0202979874,
-0.0594510399,
-0.0593964346,
0.0005800504,
-0.0025648219,
-0.0082482733,
-0.0251719654,
0.0261448734,
-0.0364920013,
-0.0231131334,
0.0321314037,
-0.0594679192,
0.0106132897,
0.0054524797,
0.0159761328,
0.0310099144,
0.0397185497,
-0.0215696096,
-0.0800115019,
0.005509655,
0.0016835289,
-0.0191049296,
0.001178825,
0.0734664798,
-0.0475111976,
-0.0117184725,
0.0002726552,
0.0595938973,
0.0092753582,
-0.0315421373,
-0.0468879305,
0.0772184804,
-0.0028999208,
-0.072776176,
-0.0387756005,
-0.0172559861,
0.0344678387,
0.0300886445,
0.0034915162,
0.0056563145,
-0.0102519877,
0.0020043999,
-0.0310452078,
0.0289021898,
-0.0660500973,
0.0379038788,
0.0168361738,
-0.0428135656,
-0.0122685758,
-0.0228191726,
-0.0159507971,
0.0490619205,
-0.0275532566,
-0.0256166849,
0.0303244982,
-0.0079010474,
-0.0297830105,
0.0377461091,
-0.0133912927,
0.0809078217,
-0.0102353832,
0.0379023515,
0.0069421045,
-0.0282558165,
-0.015381638,
0.0281845294,
-0.0724024475,
-0.0369697884,
-0.0246773269,
0.0279786382,
0.0205692928,
0.0525248535,
-0.0204236433,
-0.0110918377,
0.0037489105,
0.0030870605,
-0.0227291062,
-0.0052143317,
0.0394623727,
-0.0582378507,
0.0266690273,
0.0243981723,
0.0014292143,
0.0434369519,
0.0364463069,
-0.0504297242,
-0.0673842877,
0.0147982202,
0.0260765031,
0.0014897392,
0.0499325208,
0.0096121589,
0.0069282763,
-0.0351049565,
-0.0324681737,
-0.0174291208,
-0.0134661244,
-0.0128806299,
0.0251683574,
0.02716171,
-0.0114231622,
0.0127595691,
-0.0097383372,
-0.0301526841,
-0.0148563478,
-0.0108751003,
-0.0318300761,
-0.0237236768,
0.0255620703,
0.0011080923,
-0.0050333771,
-0.0219977964,
0.0389902219,
0.0034450914,
0.0515701137,
-0.0151955234,
0.0299293231,
0.0446466431,
-0.0535471812,
0.0290108714,
-0.0107661178,
-0.0459960811,
0.0086895777,
-0.0215007644,
0.0307159573,
0.0298363231,
-0.0317275971,
-0.0081365984,
0.0208009854,
-0.0109156827,
-0.0092452439,
0.0084301,
0.0000120931,
-0.0322018303,
-0.0141146965,
0.039946951,
-0.03583939,
0.0587756746,
0.038473215,
-0.0276959017,
-0.020927757,
0.004219892,
-0.0462335385,
-0.039205797,
0.0040606353,
0.0215029214,
0.0547292642,
-0.0176990535,
0.0110848788,
-0.0858547464,
-0.0526343174,
0.0214619413,
-0.0043609608,
0.0100051928,
0.0454384573,
-0.0450025536,
0.0995686129,
0.0193762202,
0.0331928544,
-0.0374598466,
-0.0280249603,
-0.0052035134,
-0.0281365067,
0.0460698158,
-6.278440959e-33,
0.0359093547,
-0.0618343689,
-0.034314204,
-0.0308722556,
-0.0084942151,
0.0536996759,
0.011694869,
-0.0341194645,
-0.0659499541,
0.0341031216,
0.026000537,
0.036647696,
-0.0116592282,
0.0038564152,
-0.0804862082,
0.0173646919,
0.0257253386,
0.0253598448,
-0.0431086533,
0.0086386949,
0.074976638,
-0.0147856874,
0.0287308935,
-0.0846174136,
0.0456826612,
-0.0144578358,
-0.068516843,
0.0133345164,
-0.0360568166,
0.0455313474,
-0.0008659881,
0.0082496945,
0.0408654921,
-0.0450506434,
-0.0013345274,
0.0591601059,
-0.0265301857,
-0.0189977232,
0.043136552,
-0.0104654543,
-0.0407428816,
-0.0051576234,
0.0111742979,
-0.0136659862,
0.0076849815,
-0.0192892794,
0.0264746416,
-0.0285148434,
0.0040539755,
0.0159454551,
-0.0508674011,
0.0082621546,
-0.0150170745,
-0.0052607614,
0.0111490749,
0.0376171581,
0.0238365959,
0.0202412531,
-0.0926349014,
0.0329397731,
-0.0549749807,
-0.0164567139,
0.0486606322,
-0.0429350212,
-0.0395109281,
0.0610527098,
-0.0040230425,
0.0321864188,
-0.0552547276,
-0.0074428893,
0.0053813495,
0.0641875938,
0.0533084385,
0.0996164903,
0.0026598359,
-0.0389928482,
-0.0936678275,
-0.0046227532,
0.0146936309,
0.0213283859,
0.0021834958,
-0.0370087884,
0.002696682,
0.03742484,
-0.025616074,
-0.0004955233,
-0.0543551221,
-0.01644977,
-0.0082187578,
0.0438007489,
-0.0423217826,
0.0747541711,
0.0220368486,
-0.0487875789,
0.0133774159,
0.0308265015,
-0.0086541167,
0.0029337637,
0.0316670761,
0.0604826808,
-0.0352757983,
-0.0003470638,
0.0662236363,
-0.0348093398,
-0.0086907726,
-0.0040916936,
0.0702668875,
0.0159186572,
-0.0149168866,
-0.0048922189,
-0.0337989293,
0.0356772505,
-0.0281380117,
0.0068880478,
0.0293208733,
0.0183290951,
-0.0271039214,
-0.0068647829,
-0.0168622043,
0.0291837696,
-0.0019170789,
0.0140047492,
-0.0435158312,
0.0199069306,
0.0042511239,
-0.0213353876,
-0.0314396322,
0.0008564398,
0.0211128723,
-0.061863061,
0.0180292949,
0.0295998473,
2.801e-7,
-0.0368113853,
0.030382907,
-0.01405463,
-0.019285664,
0.0054132468,
0.0801862106,
0.0338142328,
0.0311973561,
-0.0030576787,
-0.1334150881,
-0.0349215902,
0.0262763035,
0.0233677775,
0.0173971802,
-0.0537209511,
0.043640051,
-0.0067062378,
-0.0471809469,
-0.0657768771,
-0.0158195999,
0.0395348892,
0.0877610818,
0.0324322246,
-0.0514462702,
0.0202278886,
-0.0106191626,
0.0327878408,
0.0571674407,
-0.0691850707,
-0.0160600655,
0.0563873649,
-0.0241480134,
0.0137038212,
0.01735029,
-0.0209023971,
0.0021211088,
-0.0172773972,
0.0264055729,
-0.0289702006,
-0.0057163602,
-0.0390398093,
-0.0334814973,
0.0320731662,
-0.0544599481,
0.0732620358,
-0.0255889688,
-0.0485138744,
-0.074616529,
-0.0521731973,
0.0138297379,
0.0331878737,
0.006514159,
0.0060870885,
0.0312130935,
-0.004512419,
-0.007346909,
-0.004652916,
-0.057356406,
0.0184610803,
-0.0097818272,
-0.0481124185,
0.018484585,
-0.0135445483,
-0.0353307612,
0.1266473383,
-0.032904245,
0.0073092612,
2.169063961e-34,
0.0293048024,
-0.0150850071,
0.0219679922,
-0.030622052,
0.0333376229,
0.0394515544,
-0.0639781952,
-0.0130758807,
0.008573412,
-0.0193006042,
-0.0045215669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02039v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02039v1 | Prompt Stability Scoring for Text Annotation with Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:11:18 | 2024-07-02T08:11:18 | Christopher Barrie, Elli Palaiologou, Petter Törnberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Researchers are increasingly using language models (LMs) for text annotation.
These approaches rely only on a prompt telling the model to return a given
output according to a set of instructions. The reproducibility of LM outputs
may nonetheless be vulnerable to small changes in the prompt design. This calls
into question the replicability of classification routines. To tackle this
problem, researchers have typically tested a variety of semantically similar
prompts to determine what we call "prompt stability." These approaches remain
ad-hoc and task specific. In this article, we propose a general framework for
diagnosing prompt stability by adapting traditional approaches to intra- and
inter-coder reliability scoring. We call the resulting metric the Prompt
Stability Score (PSS) and provide a Python package PromptStability for its
estimation. Using six different datasets and twelve outcomes, we classify >150k
rows of data to: a) diagnose when prompt stability is low; and b) demonstrate
the functionality of the package. We conclude by providing best practice
recommendations for applied researchers. | [
0.032104034,
0.0112718204,
-0.0038922271,
0.0039386838,
-0.0072265407,
0.0319598578,
0.0222304128,
0.0056263381,
0.0331611894,
-0.0524133071,
0.0051260004,
-0.0542583838,
0.0312247574,
0.0279509015,
0.0099196499,
-0.0380078107,
0.0581142977,
-0.0488309972,
0.0113177607,
0.0305158272,
0.0255183671,
0.0003628982,
-0.0112453671,
0.0684799999,
-0.0278863758,
-0.0356066898,
0.0129208062,
-0.0033999216,
0.0148663623,
-0.0323799066,
0.0131376907,
0.0992212594,
-0.0216876026,
0.0656561404,
0.000001953,
-0.0620484129,
-0.0270871148,
0.013164483,
-0.0288169011,
0.0040568262,
0.0273664668,
-0.0138431257,
-0.0286479797,
0.0135362884,
-0.0123050576,
-0.0138875898,
0.0487705432,
-0.0136684375,
0.0585308075,
0.0351119526,
0.001846563,
0.045039434,
0.0214402117,
0.0051320526,
-0.0067726332,
-0.001497313,
0.0187251549,
0.010307068,
0.0151091758,
0.0257618763,
0.0171024166,
0.0374387875,
0.0020587365,
-0.0711519942,
-0.0331913047,
0.018605845,
-0.0091406954,
-0.0373667181,
-0.0127142686,
0.0080191232,
0.0512621328,
0.0068077412,
-0.0177863128,
-0.019754542,
0.0228981674,
0.0165389515,
-0.0249243788,
0.0461252369,
-0.0104639139,
-0.0373550989,
0.03635047,
0.0171241909,
-0.0033000957,
-0.0280659422,
0.0134089859,
0.0782273635,
0.0249981787,
-0.0310126245,
0.0216633622,
0.0313577726,
-0.0226631314,
-0.0710381716,
0.0039180638,
0.0016688963,
-0.0443151072,
0.0158171114,
-0.0401156023,
-0.0191941913,
0.0469412133,
-0.0361739509,
0.0366359241,
0.0152352005,
-0.0596947037,
0.0256325174,
-0.0097643659,
0.0464271866,
0.031840194,
0.0235929396,
0.0195867252,
0.048315268,
-0.0379573666,
0.0155453626,
-0.0225118566,
-0.0110746277,
0.0353628285,
-0.0152971409,
-0.0423475318,
0.0482495129,
-0.0124450754,
0.0629159287,
-0.0097381594,
-0.0445574187,
0.0085203359,
0.0433855653,
0.0027578808,
0.0136956917,
0.0011642673,
-0.0096238982,
0.0068343175,
-0.0747400969,
0.01747315,
0.0149235232,
-0.0168022458,
-0.0407197773,
-0.0237896442,
0.0209007617,
0.0179859046,
-0.0117871091,
-0.022469433,
-0.0413480438,
-0.0540245064,
-0.0578825325,
-0.0437967032,
-0.0527272299,
-0.0205310732,
0.0401437879,
0.0310460087,
-0.0600260273,
0.0003631915,
0.0165968556,
0.0153914662,
0.0851840153,
-0.0453828983,
0.0035145287,
0.0184469651,
-0.0097671319,
-0.0174879897,
0.0426696986,
0.020260999,
0.0008883637,
0.0864645168,
-0.0138957538,
0.0141750667,
0.0521346405,
-0.0387532413,
0.0135565568,
-0.0010265266,
-0.0069729714,
0.0713554099,
-0.026857011,
-0.0358562656,
0.051362332,
0.0185809955,
0.0177573971,
0.0635351166,
0.0346898697,
0.0003981551,
-0.0389857963,
0.038034793,
-0.0128837153,
0.0123863118,
0.0240381099,
-0.0191625506,
0.0012558389,
-0.0495085344,
0.009773802,
0.0282307211,
-0.0211416651,
0.0069496869,
-0.0586991087,
-0.084029898,
-0.0146871926,
-0.0084880767,
0.0076865344,
0.0359701551,
-0.0227225646,
-0.0189833045,
0.005073064,
0.0087021915,
-0.0651535243,
0.0100356657,
-0.0317214839,
0.0433117114,
0.0752846748,
0.0296423174,
-0.0302534718,
-0.0138823735,
-0.0456772,
0.0354862921,
0.0385825373,
0.0364925042,
-0.0404448844,
-0.013901284,
-0.0222845916,
-0.039121028,
0.0405831411,
0.0224037971,
0.0127738593,
-0.0086005861,
-0.0041799112,
0.0092985686,
0.0139473202,
-0.0497938842,
0.0570777692,
-0.0384435765,
0.00200632,
-0.0285453256,
-0.0070319856,
0.0065145609,
0.0359617434,
-0.0444491841,
0.0118301231,
0.024723148,
0.0114591112,
0.033411406,
-0.0002961691,
-0.0126319556,
-0.0031718002,
0.0461153165,
0.0410061255,
-0.0279059131,
0.0028858413,
-0.0007248654,
-0.053638041,
-0.0577067137,
-0.050143227,
0.0051788795,
-0.0432235561,
0.0339738652,
-0.0309583321,
0.0055520996,
-0.0487650931,
-0.0016554404,
0.0073813763,
0.0575460233,
0.0305189826,
0.0090546357,
0.0499994941,
-0.0549412481,
-0.0825738534,
0.0081744138,
-0.0131826373,
0.0165029634,
0.0515593402,
0.0267402809,
-0.0300175417,
-0.0245559644,
-0.0995823964,
0.0004294878,
-0.0405257307,
0.0140851336,
0.0060530226,
-0.0187978279,
-0.0311317388,
-0.0072304751,
-0.0095752096,
-0.0221055858,
0.0054668407,
0.0438977592,
0.0481943265,
0.0058749425,
-0.0234898794,
-0.058774095,
-0.0068022418,
-0.0002985294,
0.0604848526,
0.055138208,
-0.0545597859,
-0.1016893759,
0.0281325467,
-0.0225474965,
-0.0064094104,
0.024957912,
-0.0000480031,
0.034578599,
0.0232081451,
0.019914845,
0.0325796679,
0.004979955,
0.0034404427,
0.0442689359,
0.0082614012,
-0.0462704673,
-0.0251170956,
-0.0014830229,
-0.0365710445,
0.0279181711,
-0.0421089083,
0.0006638576,
0.0449254662,
-0.0085349735,
-0.0242198054,
-0.0471483991,
-0.0268282238,
-0.0640107691,
0.012594996,
-0.0438188165,
-0.0228316598,
-0.0338867456,
0.0710512847,
0.0067536756,
-0.0617704876,
0.0753908008,
-0.0611453876,
0.0063238144,
-0.0056044785,
-0.0058791875,
-0.0260132719,
0.0497047491,
-0.0068306616,
-0.0190821849,
0.0294007417,
-0.0345923826,
-0.0125236167,
0.0219952371,
0.0165138114,
-0.0280721411,
0.0454790108,
-0.0350671224,
0.0226568654,
-0.0241594277,
-0.0270344373,
-0.0443619639,
-0.041348543,
-0.0379252322,
0.0157732945,
0.0333589949,
0.0039346023,
0.0478321239,
0.0489318036,
0.014522912,
0.0590164587,
-0.0336200558,
-0.0071299528,
-0.0088394182,
0.015513679,
0.0225313436,
-0.0063528582,
0.0056938035,
-0.0490504131,
0.0212786552,
0.0231887326,
-0.0311398376,
0.0498706773,
-0.0425428227,
-0.0056223418,
0.0612709485,
-0.066141203,
-0.0479636602,
0.0199213736,
0.0484135486,
-0.0658458024,
-0.0434553623,
0.136704877,
0.0435057022,
-0.0741041973,
-0.0295095574,
-0.0427659974,
0.0534204096,
0.0241879132,
0.0122156097,
-0.0794628784,
-0.0073543312,
0.0147451004,
0.0435386971,
0.0029894768,
-0.0233887397,
0.0104059074,
-0.0832640529,
0.0540910438,
-0.0211937055,
-0.0533730052,
0.0053548058,
-0.0546256714,
0.0310407672,
-0.0136220828,
0.0318320356,
0.0433670469,
-0.0012483957,
0.0170955285,
0.0512105003,
-0.0715154931,
-0.0493318625,
0.0115069579,
-0.0373025611,
0.0718792453,
0.0907365382,
-0.0191189237,
-0.0050730738,
-0.0391727239,
0.0613071173,
-0.0177739076,
-0.0275824089,
-0.0045149508,
0.0667956024,
-0.0038461434,
-0.0043060342,
0.0082488833,
-0.013010513,
-0.0003603966,
-0.0100852298,
0.0150896451,
0.0386178233,
-0.0248011239,
0.0320070311,
-0.0130836098,
0.0051393835,
0.0115638841,
0.0569235869,
0.0530253239,
-0.071857132,
-0.0258222092,
-0.0481245331,
0.0105952248,
-0.0474353433,
-0.0164176319,
0.0162744392,
-0.0399372131,
-0.0275963005,
-0.0643148571,
-0.0456099436,
0.0234455951,
-0.0010548497,
0.0259373356,
0.0091699464,
-0.0446129963,
0.0214228928,
-0.0245057903,
0.0212589707,
-0.0135077909,
0.0406551883,
-0.0737967938,
0.0185015891,
0.0086084092,
-0.0173463207,
-0.0061831507,
0.0019519525,
-0.0580714978,
-0.0415759757,
0.0306274258,
0.036907386,
0.0258431826,
-0.0033968387,
0.0002427372,
-0.051378116,
0.0152868368,
0.0153162759,
0.0077738073,
0.0007524182,
0.0173051171,
0.0239464715,
-0.0264915749,
0.0007453083,
-0.0471262671,
-0.0143731385,
0.0033871061,
0.0223777927,
0.0065425625,
-0.0645197108,
-0.0133933816,
0.032772664,
0.0607352816,
-0.0364504047,
-0.0501301959,
-0.0487364419,
-0.0214711502,
-0.0241814237,
-0.0268113371,
-0.0222097393,
0.05315274,
0.0021567103,
-0.0264211856,
-0.0259491242,
0.0225514714,
-0.0421413854,
0.0827385932,
-0.0554752648,
0.0283946469,
0.0144334491,
0.0449751876,
-0.0003384804,
0.0017434623,
-0.0474391319,
0.0160994399,
-0.0110631352,
0.0170788597,
0.0041533769,
0.0411010422,
0.0071734386,
-0.019356966,
0.0521809943,
0.0587296672,
-0.0496612601,
0.001763562,
-0.0280609056,
0.0257186592,
0.0501152463,
0.0023980809,
0.073835738,
-0.003911145,
-0.0015624533,
-0.0503366366,
0.0248997752,
0.0661977381,
-0.0269356631,
-0.0132499505,
0.0133683896,
-0.0209983736,
0.0114550935,
0.0446082875,
-0.0333037116,
-0.0140543291,
-0.0078473948,
-0.0408711322,
-0.0426957123,
0.0261971727,
-0.0057851933,
0.0214932654,
-0.028449025,
-0.0402067825,
-0.0691351667,
-0.0510798506,
0.0333450176,
0.0570446365,
0.0005295801,
0.0414716639,
-0.0156502146,
0.0434277393,
0.0044051325,
0.0301055461,
-0.0530659258,
-0.0028478974,
-0.0168318525,
-0.0031707787,
-0.038058944,
-5.780449389e-33,
-0.0478266925,
-0.0464831255,
-0.0248571895,
-0.0005524534,
-0.0266957432,
0.0284605324,
-0.0414503068,
0.0337655842,
0.018184159,
-0.0085249525,
-0.0291388612,
-0.0176938903,
0.0248707402,
-0.0052947602,
0.0397537611,
-0.0131598553,
0.0164250489,
0.0177654084,
-0.0515222065,
0.0037723596,
0.0566760376,
-0.0064181476,
0.0331552587,
-0.0545826294,
0.1261536628,
-0.0071025253,
-0.0213147067,
-0.0039548902,
-0.0053032283,
0.087661624,
-0.0240268894,
0.0448648222,
0.0222911052,
-0.0541353449,
-0.027597405,
0.054771062,
-0.0378881767,
-0.0292074047,
-0.0108874096,
0.0271449983,
-0.0425698347,
-0.0156372264,
0.0005118701,
-0.0379582793,
-0.0407626927,
0.0019717517,
0.0531273186,
-0.0355588123,
-0.0112227928,
-0.0153733073,
-0.0266866386,
0.0442021005,
-0.0069094389,
-0.0299661122,
0.0387162752,
0.05244473,
0.0330100991,
0.0153903263,
-0.0355624519,
0.0177188348,
0.002265753,
0.0394158885,
0.0456966273,
0.0248464569,
-0.0387772545,
0.0657081679,
0.0040359888,
0.0305554047,
0.0176016074,
-0.022639975,
0.0139975529,
-0.0164686423,
0.0800787508,
0.0394993685,
-0.0190472733,
-0.0142508801,
-0.0403486416,
0.0528007895,
0.0251051094,
-0.0246084314,
0.0240223762,
-0.0245648678,
-0.0330143347,
-0.0261169076,
-0.0617246442,
-0.0435518697,
-0.0117333615,
-0.0187802091,
0.0203849282,
-0.0355513096,
-0.0237643663,
0.0296709426,
0.0482386351,
-0.0059973891,
-0.0443055928,
0.0061583975,
-0.0298311729,
0.0585498363,
-0.0060221311,
0.0323542021,
0.0065073399,
0.002875532,
0.0208366867,
0.0013466794,
0.0438430533,
-0.0055818185,
0.0459598117,
0.0291500948,
-0.0884049609,
-0.0077973581,
-0.0022262477,
0.0275928285,
-0.0176929049,
-0.0019933449,
0.0392610505,
-0.0306202099,
0.0060884808,
0.06684497,
0.0356488824,
0.0079048714,
-0.0190940108,
-0.008688909,
-0.0304336697,
-0.0119252969,
-0.0046427962,
0.0069932607,
0.0276887678,
0.0597905666,
-0.0204792358,
-0.0041084895,
0.0136117628,
-0.0292046126,
2.478e-7,
0.0863040388,
0.0571225472,
0.0352676474,
-0.0075495313,
0.015948521,
0.007713805,
-0.0338420086,
0.0288065132,
0.0365616381,
-0.0353688262,
-0.0165236238,
-0.0536072552,
0.0610123537,
0.0467909202,
-0.0719289482,
-0.0324776843,
-0.0738930553,
0.0421736836,
-0.0550426543,
0.0254958291,
0.0800445974,
0.0375486054,
-0.014212314,
0.0002654705,
-0.0295242798,
-0.0339463837,
0.018519206,
-0.0369914994,
-0.0012901305,
0.0241816919,
0.0727494359,
-0.0150058288,
0.0333508104,
0.0286729354,
-0.0089156842,
-0.0135309305,
0.0123764919,
0.0461079776,
0.0140274707,
-0.0052378336,
0.0105245281,
0.0052337758,
0.0292256884,
-0.0636584014,
0.0618949756,
-0.014403264,
0.0019977307,
-0.0444137938,
-0.0091000274,
-0.0473754294,
0.0761955008,
-0.0010935017,
-0.0130998371,
0.0504359566,
0.0040574414,
0.0126630748,
-0.0443025678,
-0.0540095866,
-0.0625136569,
0.0045497394,
-0.0231709648,
-0.0778208002,
0.0151024004,
-0.0253905896,
-0.0336894654,
-0.1106639281,
0.0137194432,
2.612052451e-34,
0.0385445431,
-0.0279493611,
0.0163896978,
0.0282792449,
0.0314943753,
-0.0177869033,
0.0348725505,
0.0225177202,
0.0239382908,
-0.0526297949,
-0.0260150582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02030v1 | Breaking Bias, Building Bridges: Evaluation and Mitigation of Social Biases in LLMs via Contact Hypothesis | 2024-07-02T07:58:46 | 2024-07-02T07:58:46 | Chahat Raj, Anjishnu Mukherjee, Aylin Caliskan, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Ziwei Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) perpetuate social biases, reflecting prejudices
in their training data and reinforcing societal stereotypes and inequalities.
Our work explores the potential of the Contact Hypothesis, a concept from
social psychology for debiasing LLMs. We simulate various forms of social
contact through LLM prompting to measure their influence on the model's biases,
mirroring how intergroup interactions can reduce prejudices in social contexts.
We create a dataset of 108,000 prompts following a principled approach
replicating social contact to measure biases in three LLMs (LLaMA 2, Tulu, and
NousHermes) across 13 social bias dimensions. We propose a unique debiasing
technique, Social Contact Debiasing (SCD), that instruction-tunes these models
with unbiased responses to prompts. Our research demonstrates that LLM
responses exhibit social biases when subject to contact probing, but more
importantly, these biases can be significantly reduced by up to 40% in 1 epoch
of instruction tuning LLaMA 2 following our SCD strategy. Our code and data are
available at https://github.com/chahatraj/breakingbias. | [
0.0391403139,
0.0504559539,
-0.0426324531,
0.0526030622,
0.0102584595,
0.0292532146,
0.0431392305,
-0.0173512772,
0.0629565194,
-0.0356683992,
-0.0629229322,
-0.0371179059,
0.0388337597,
-0.0117995385,
0.0536659583,
-0.049708534,
0.0644874796,
0.0004347721,
0.0439061224,
-0.050937321,
0.0251167398,
0.0197992809,
0.0128022702,
0.0213797539,
-0.0104708672,
0.015776813,
0.0232162904,
0.0082710152,
0.0043080319,
-0.0313080102,
0.0557089597,
0.0623862855,
0.0168790016,
0.0348698571,
0.0000021503,
-0.0682268888,
0.0161790419,
-0.0379163884,
-0.0080139376,
0.0152436085,
0.0728566796,
-0.0307453554,
0.0066670175,
0.0383507721,
-0.0429519713,
-0.0031693999,
0.0227780268,
-0.0091099124,
0.0263422672,
0.0383331291,
0.0041864123,
0.0011794773,
-0.0368342176,
-0.0291683301,
0.0077031711,
-0.0067464248,
0.038256105,
-0.0413940363,
-0.0472563356,
-0.0236064829,
-0.0373510644,
0.0023750502,
0.0147068342,
0.0134668685,
0.0464732312,
0.0163315237,
-0.0127422698,
-0.0557481237,
-0.0102058481,
0.0733650997,
0.0292645395,
-0.040350683,
-0.0102802655,
-0.021728104,
0.0531205833,
0.009374382,
-0.0084606502,
0.0124102458,
0.011441309,
0.0245555639,
-0.0149094118,
0.0175861344,
0.026502721,
0.0285124499,
0.0117262043,
0.0683088154,
0.0147895366,
-0.0207238328,
0.0284946505,
0.0453990474,
0.0682895035,
-0.0463347472,
-0.0000094822,
0.0032339336,
-0.0416485555,
0.012306652,
-0.028741939,
0.0541702397,
0.0362891108,
-0.0291101485,
-0.0029617108,
0.0375163518,
-0.0306939632,
-0.0029172043,
0.0156842526,
-0.0227386728,
0.0091912057,
-0.0174586028,
0.0033376866,
0.0127465334,
0.0157929137,
-0.0089191059,
0.0005915511,
-0.026500605,
-0.0023274466,
0.0427030511,
-0.0186954737,
-0.0002633557,
-0.0558144674,
-0.0092894407,
-0.0265597329,
0.0038030292,
-0.0210946705,
0.0178119484,
-0.0469229966,
0.015174862,
-0.0735960007,
0.0312590711,
-0.0248148572,
-0.1290231198,
-0.0065576979,
-0.0070239068,
-0.0009045926,
-0.0454052426,
-0.0056570629,
0.023917526,
-0.0089523662,
-0.034185756,
-0.0281818639,
-0.0116422465,
-0.0017038916,
-0.0654277951,
-0.0127638383,
-0.0270241909,
0.0451660417,
0.0079497593,
0.0063337763,
-0.0638825372,
0.0020025829,
0.0103118457,
-0.0510785505,
0.071871385,
0.0204510763,
0.0180344675,
0.0578659251,
0.0377161503,
0.0215759091,
0.0797122493,
-0.0000952818,
-0.0157982334,
0.0452943444,
-0.0276951175,
0.0494845249,
0.0597178787,
0.0510479957,
-0.0045884266,
-0.0135280928,
-0.0074206623,
0.0025890628,
-0.0073863771,
0.08787027,
0.0456245691,
-0.015210242,
-0.0339629017,
0.0731024593,
0.0269995872,
-0.0737273321,
0.0202102028,
0.0058770007,
0.0245855171,
-0.0122116646,
0.0223511122,
-0.1013416573,
0.0134418774,
-0.0235281605,
-0.0264719501,
0.013639221,
0.0486923717,
-0.0254391655,
0.0071815331,
0.0093756076,
0.0092904484,
0.0526252724,
0.00667373,
-0.0041559637,
0.0043473719,
-0.0113941114,
0.0616894662,
0.0633061752,
-0.0315412283,
0.0224065166,
-0.0498128347,
0.035253074,
0.0221188143,
0.0064762095,
-0.0075794761,
0.0202672109,
-0.030257836,
-0.0011277919,
0.0826873705,
0.0974893868,
-0.0249762293,
-0.0016979836,
-0.0369394496,
-0.0143181244,
0.0210120268,
0.0200942699,
0.0219485834,
0.0550301746,
0.0218624976,
0.0079074856,
-0.01561963,
-0.0316961966,
0.0270322673,
-0.0138293644,
-0.0196886119,
-0.0575669557,
0.0126113435,
0.0392051414,
0.0065651056,
-0.0250595864,
-0.0239170566,
-0.0284577571,
0.0200719908,
0.0188576188,
0.0193407424,
-0.0842899382,
-0.0200541802,
0.0180747751,
-0.024950739,
-0.0482663512,
0.0204530954,
-0.0191739816,
0.0167691857,
0.0373998173,
-0.0037647642,
0.0727583319,
0.0006528398,
-0.0134039698,
-0.0568120703,
0.0339209102,
-0.0354574807,
0.0168009121,
-0.0107226335,
-0.0416863859,
0.0182348136,
-0.0271507204,
-0.0019086202,
-0.0410446152,
-0.0186111461,
-0.0080063688,
-0.0092706056,
-0.0299775116,
0.0160089526,
-0.0087086298,
-0.0532008931,
0.0050775725,
-0.0952925906,
-0.0451533981,
-0.0090368344,
-0.0185865816,
0.0005246344,
0.0079640588,
-0.0403095596,
-0.0209139194,
-0.0347358063,
-0.0157766826,
0.0023635395,
0.0450133793,
0.0191500224,
-0.0488467067,
-0.0334430635,
-0.0791618899,
-0.0079259295,
-0.0356998481,
0.0417014435,
0.0323222317,
-0.0236227959,
-0.0420619473,
-0.0209871531,
-0.0604310818,
0.0240072049,
-0.0054825819,
-0.0450820401,
0.0226709489,
0.0613393225,
0.0430382937,
0.0954149663,
0.0194421019,
0.0225964431,
0.05515185,
0.0072884909,
-0.069406867,
-0.0185777694,
-0.0098123942,
0.0017362137,
-0.0310788732,
-0.0967954323,
-0.0392878465,
0.0559701473,
0.0565688424,
-0.0096277483,
-0.0367511436,
0.0334038958,
-0.0265724678,
-0.0701805651,
-0.0108984681,
-0.0377884433,
-0.0303786974,
0.0338255949,
-0.0468438715,
-0.1022299528,
0.0614011437,
0.0012206498,
-0.014787592,
-0.0077008614,
0.0237130225,
-0.0187092293,
0.0564293414,
0.0007068146,
0.0062947837,
0.0282288957,
-0.0016886818,
-0.0628241599,
-0.036992792,
0.027421115,
-0.0149084385,
-0.007353724,
-0.0393904522,
-0.0141422655,
0.0067552244,
-0.0340970717,
-0.0340124033,
-0.0310233682,
-0.0468568392,
-0.0229675751,
0.0064536864,
-0.0079997499,
0.0267570596,
-0.0315829068,
0.0155114019,
0.0011345333,
-0.0195439607,
0.0006931956,
-0.0007103676,
-0.0091019543,
0.0296025407,
-0.0107389903,
0.0511108935,
-0.0380449556,
0.0331579335,
-0.0026502761,
0.0102157639,
0.0200875048,
-0.0067479135,
-0.0022149566,
0.0263710078,
0.0223381966,
0.0091769546,
0.0121762799,
0.0789860189,
-0.0114484783,
0.0025799959,
0.1104671732,
-0.0005691326,
-0.0764950588,
0.0286721438,
-0.0134840589,
0.0400063917,
0.0397612005,
-0.0008628702,
-0.0874905661,
-0.0035625198,
0.0181149021,
0.028780289,
-0.0184703376,
-0.036895439,
0.0150108095,
-0.1480032057,
0.0178609043,
0.0116230659,
0.0080751777,
-0.0142963557,
-0.0613558032,
0.0300127007,
-0.0121747041,
0.0371422917,
0.0076677226,
0.0040689753,
0.0144002372,
0.0145313377,
-0.0294662379,
-0.0438496098,
0.0291291885,
-0.0503423512,
0.1019959673,
0.023746131,
0.048947081,
-0.0244308002,
-0.0068140738,
0.0560360327,
0.0090268096,
-0.0064821555,
-0.0375658832,
0.0337257311,
-0.020185411,
-0.0101080416,
-0.0097707445,
0.0467635654,
-0.0044186683,
0.0092042051,
0.0075741783,
0.0392438993,
0.0167189706,
-0.061518766,
-0.002111733,
0.0147960978,
0.0121127916,
0.0812131613,
0.0607151203,
-0.0365761705,
0.0306147393,
-0.0393441394,
-0.0073685152,
0.0455529951,
-0.0449256524,
-0.0173867811,
-0.010747564,
-0.027262019,
-0.0276067201,
-0.0632881299,
0.0192292016,
-0.0068534585,
0.0250512343,
-0.0460537113,
0.0232030321,
-0.012740056,
-0.0083075007,
0.0439719036,
-0.0581887253,
0.0530948415,
0.0027323095,
-0.0174720585,
-0.0082469387,
-0.0357428789,
-0.005921436,
-0.0163888149,
-0.0196060464,
-0.0849180222,
0.0312185232,
0.0511056632,
0.024563048,
0.0614848994,
0.0175604522,
-0.0663756877,
0.024875002,
0.0222249888,
-0.0312121883,
0.0760037154,
0.0137820924,
-0.0059398068,
0.0125755277,
0.0193841662,
0.0001724914,
0.0312830433,
0.0384861343,
-0.0178990643,
-0.0362495333,
-0.0658195615,
-0.0198004339,
-0.0152859688,
0.0602629669,
-0.036871586,
0.0049511855,
-0.0615159832,
-0.0253143013,
-0.0025663341,
-0.0277139656,
-0.0030176793,
-0.0344052538,
0.0347611122,
0.0318062305,
-0.0191262197,
-0.0596518666,
-0.0557031073,
0.0436705798,
-0.0177400354,
0.049137529,
0.0197012294,
0.0619342476,
0.0155771766,
-0.0088800648,
-0.0046739611,
0.049598176,
-0.0430127308,
0.0256488062,
0.0486138165,
0.0626824722,
0.0174963009,
-0.0188212134,
0.0126478374,
-0.0069132871,
0.0007715439,
-0.014282126,
-0.0044710943,
0.0226732194,
0.0219408497,
-0.0011923381,
0.0347240679,
0.0209208615,
0.0125598777,
0.0039156713,
-0.0024546327,
-0.0113417776,
-0.0449980795,
0.0366807953,
-0.0086942445,
-0.043969661,
0.0480371378,
0.0559593551,
-0.0123405457,
0.0560068861,
0.0032996906,
-0.0069611352,
-0.0054981224,
-0.0258005802,
0.0709142536,
-0.0140855256,
-0.0394452363,
-0.0231018905,
-0.0728841349,
-0.0649668649,
-0.0459978245,
0.0280179456,
0.0083924253,
-0.0350397564,
0.024892224,
0.0416335315,
-0.0331573226,
-0.014567215,
-0.0034135282,
0.0162780583,
-0.0168201551,
-0.0077103474,
-0.01092791,
-6.867704522e-33,
-0.0286818799,
-0.0152984075,
-0.0342512056,
-0.0179523155,
-0.0399438739,
-0.0091618467,
-0.0526375882,
0.0224087536,
-0.0305799861,
0.0041947081,
-0.0048811371,
0.0355992541,
0.0221189726,
-0.0366124623,
0.0300245136,
-0.0146535588,
0.0637426525,
-0.0218420774,
-0.0404591672,
0.0129390452,
-0.0258051567,
0.0102757057,
0.0381895415,
-0.0432465374,
0.0755805001,
-0.0070560575,
-0.0144833028,
0.0123848896,
-0.0253273267,
0.0093442127,
-0.0297660474,
0.0484768339,
0.020073384,
0.0030340811,
0.009850529,
0.0850792155,
-0.031584613,
-0.0416250229,
0.0384022929,
0.0178026464,
0.0168229342,
-0.0119228661,
0.0085442243,
-0.0221240502,
-0.0733472556,
0.0284880865,
0.0202857293,
-0.0038453122,
0.0396605022,
0.0363107026,
-0.0653402209,
0.0012268177,
-0.009111817,
-0.0029576817,
-0.0224574618,
0.0007791083,
0.0088476939,
-0.0010819575,
-0.0417038724,
0.0204370916,
0.0055061383,
-0.0219850764,
0.0513219722,
0.0193529055,
0.0098650167,
0.0614939742,
0.0748611614,
0.0566652156,
0.0145779913,
-0.0534595251,
0.0545854717,
-0.0385388061,
0.0078857113,
0.0776202902,
-0.0141524468,
-0.0548260435,
-0.0249618534,
-0.0136270598,
0.0984618068,
0.005142556,
0.0151252989,
-0.0028189549,
-0.0458178297,
-0.057059411,
-0.039892558,
-0.0691536218,
-0.0058055148,
-0.0294515323,
0.0289874319,
0.0221717581,
-0.022015607,
-0.00933473,
0.0177749805,
-0.0266513526,
-0.0290698912,
0.0236184672,
0.003890319,
-0.0064620678,
0.010926052,
-0.0213222038,
-0.0770888701,
-0.0207346026,
-0.0165097658,
0.0134433238,
0.0271764863,
0.0126743754,
0.0083412938,
0.0034825527,
-0.048283156,
0.0103922412,
-0.0246675853,
0.0034110772,
0.020233795,
0.0020571924,
0.0183983166,
0.01827305,
-0.0130053246,
-0.0076464843,
0.0239541419,
-0.0012814383,
-0.0598550364,
0.0225394126,
-0.0440123864,
0.0478570126,
-0.0398192666,
-0.0384798571,
-0.0258096308,
-0.0126360487,
0.0389806777,
-0.0303174052,
-0.0325660445,
-0.0590908602,
2.711e-7,
-0.0275366083,
0.0830495954,
-0.0089066084,
0.057111349,
0.0229318962,
0.0329879448,
0.0240106136,
0.0644531697,
0.040009629,
-0.0263452493,
-0.0129376315,
0.0425998047,
0.0291630868,
0.030895533,
-0.0671608821,
0.0146822995,
-0.056446977,
-0.0100173503,
-0.0303225331,
-0.0258247722,
-0.0373210721,
0.0465723239,
0.0343037248,
0.0022597748,
-0.0302516278,
-0.0083239051,
0.028324889,
-0.0607694164,
0.0176544059,
0.0272284094,
0.037972495,
-0.0020990812,
0.0215303767,
0.0327975415,
0.0173829719,
0.0252582934,
-0.0484646037,
0.0348729789,
-0.0039393902,
0.0129228272,
0.0092827948,
0.006002001,
-0.03657021,
-0.1038122699,
0.0370220207,
0.00893832,
-0.004126457,
-0.020691555,
0.0123272054,
-0.0178543627,
0.0343939252,
-0.0341815837,
-0.0196408294,
-0.00685775,
0.0353648625,
-0.008770694,
-0.0183337871,
-0.0428829566,
-0.0344666056,
-0.0309717245,
-0.0024545419,
-0.1021102369,
0.0030620464,
0.0086635631,
-0.025594363,
-0.0200846083,
0.0380187966,
2.140198687e-34,
0.0445236601,
-0.0046645217,
0.0293941833,
-0.0111492882,
0.0702694878,
0.0049884701,
-0.034428142,
-0.0024419299,
0.0603358001,
-0.0436991453,
0.0030706276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02028v1 | Why does in-context learning fail sometimes? Evaluating in-context learning on open and closed questions | 2024-07-02T07:52:30 | 2024-07-02T07:52:30 | Xiang Li, Haoran Tang, Siyu Chen, Ziwei Wang, Ryan Chen, Marcin Abram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | We measure the performance of in-context learning as a function of task
novelty and difficulty for open and closed questions. For that purpose, we
created a novel benchmark consisting of hard scientific questions, each paired
with a context of various relevancy. We show that counter-intuitively, a
context that is more aligned with the topic does not always help more than a
less relevant context. This effect is especially visible for open questions and
questions of high difficulty or novelty. This result reveals a fundamental
difference between the treatment of close-form and open-form questions by
large-language models and shows a need for a more robust evaluation of
in-context learning on the variety of different types of questions. It also
poses a new question of how to optimally select a context for large language
models, especially in the context of Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
systems. Our results suggest that the answer to this question can be highly
application-dependent and might be contingent on factors including the format
of the question, the perceived difficulty level of the questions, and the
novelty or popularity of the information we seek. | [
0.017243389,
0.0116413264,
0.0001443069,
0.0242623258,
-0.028181389,
0.0255072024,
0.0239167958,
-0.0074558957,
-0.0197243188,
-0.0667991266,
-0.0133325271,
-0.0406335928,
-0.0379908681,
0.0036163102,
0.0276375674,
-0.0181725211,
0.0356218442,
-0.0131056029,
-0.0095080538,
0.0063121282,
-0.0132714193,
-0.024921326,
-0.0089810044,
0.0283348951,
0.0295006894,
-0.0156502239,
0.0023069938,
0.0244590919,
0.0261474866,
-0.0308986548,
0.023158351,
0.0405619331,
0.0596998185,
0.0268736482,
0.0000017684,
-0.0914712176,
-0.0388467386,
0.0038254259,
-0.0473685674,
0.0249323025,
0.0284435935,
0.033023037,
0.0082427319,
0.0236035362,
-0.0356806964,
-0.0052558952,
0.0310133807,
0.0069188057,
0.0295827426,
0.0415749997,
0.0112670325,
-0.0097707752,
0.0283850208,
-0.0267891493,
0.0764960349,
-0.0455840975,
0.0131720649,
0.0168761425,
0.0036914526,
0.0454765707,
-0.0124870734,
0.030707024,
0.046204865,
0.0046947636,
0.0109141404,
0.0422134325,
-0.0573333092,
0.0226562526,
0.010515443,
0.1041092575,
0.011605124,
-0.0159636568,
-0.0026519715,
0.0099344216,
0.0083688013,
0.0495921411,
-0.0894608125,
0.0186341777,
0.0016682558,
-0.0067526735,
0.0215251874,
0.0378688574,
0.0128693087,
0.0268185996,
-0.0262825694,
0.0357212536,
0.0274641532,
-0.0441412404,
0.0040132524,
0.00625565,
-0.0796466023,
-0.006194449,
0.0021819756,
0.0289657805,
-0.0432885103,
0.0337863192,
0.0015585818,
-0.0428950489,
0.033394292,
-0.0162956212,
-0.0049871504,
0.0165510643,
-0.0201734621,
0.0437207557,
-0.0215990003,
0.0357389227,
-0.0179063808,
-0.0113096731,
-0.0323008224,
-0.0139066838,
-0.0408179313,
-0.0212776829,
-0.031653408,
0.030864615,
-0.0353115909,
-0.0159489699,
-0.029683331,
0.0480830744,
0.0005618828,
-0.0064937547,
-0.0338238627,
0.0062788907,
-0.0723925903,
0.0074728965,
-0.0275192093,
0.0293038059,
-0.0383915864,
0.0212428346,
0.0521369278,
-0.0507559665,
-0.0109090144,
0.0135898283,
0.0271436591,
-0.0321583301,
0.0018602029,
0.0217552707,
0.0095758503,
-0.0357055552,
-0.0153613361,
-0.0626622885,
-0.0110542094,
-0.0403065793,
0.0174110495,
-0.0561391264,
0.010534782,
0.050472755,
-0.0224571936,
-0.0058056097,
0.0070349583,
0.0438044369,
0.0161156114,
0.0333702527,
0.0527645983,
-0.0274434742,
0.0655421615,
0.0384854488,
0.014918304,
0.0595670901,
-0.0418304987,
0.0037174027,
0.0265139937,
0.011348906,
-0.0057240305,
0.0006814788,
0.0367724821,
0.0373352617,
-0.0208216552,
0.0505549535,
0.0456605032,
0.0430242494,
0.0077723186,
0.0488967448,
-0.0441613384,
-0.004792389,
0.0080546262,
0.0258955006,
0.0234647971,
0.0024084195,
0.029589368,
0.0027480691,
-0.0089747068,
0.0519330949,
0.0100942533,
0.018129101,
-0.0444939733,
0.0197618287,
0.048940897,
0.0141181117,
-0.0403817631,
-0.0425048098,
-0.0082599651,
0.0141842598,
-0.0244231187,
0.0101620229,
0.0593736582,
0.0333488733,
-0.024914084,
0.0077444632,
0.0255004875,
-0.0260962825,
0.0212049093,
-0.0305784065,
0.0436791554,
-0.0444981605,
0.0897828937,
-0.0514815822,
-0.0425745137,
-0.0125736231,
0.0205272119,
-0.0002321898,
0.0685094073,
-0.0441072732,
-0.0379630774,
-0.060323853,
-0.0353620313,
-0.0433106832,
0.0122834146,
-0.0208171587,
0.0249333642,
0.0182740483,
0.0473856889,
-0.0378664248,
-0.0046897996,
0.0306162313,
-0.0752693862,
-0.0681369677,
-0.005837101,
-0.0065100091,
-0.0010680116,
-0.0114902603,
0.0047588064,
0.0453250818,
0.0484659746,
-0.0650255904,
0.0022725468,
0.0053020301,
-0.0777305663,
-0.0472283922,
-0.0056951344,
-0.0179348774,
-0.0028318793,
-0.0026115056,
-0.0143819647,
-0.0246427413,
0.0155961895,
-0.042891942,
0.049936343,
-0.0538240969,
-0.001620948,
-0.0244119894,
0.0151189668,
-0.1069226414,
0.1023908332,
0.0102812881,
0.050607726,
0.0571410693,
0.0144255767,
0.0077444962,
-0.0501598641,
-0.0058931424,
-0.0103380522,
-0.008167699,
-0.0075265872,
0.0435052179,
-0.0214396976,
-0.0945873186,
0.0129128601,
-0.0785374194,
0.0188905001,
-0.0338192768,
-0.0107760411,
0.0308011025,
0.0241904892,
0.011019174,
-0.0135880364,
-0.0511052161,
0.002187894,
0.0082541406,
0.0385464616,
0.0353510082,
0.0612735189,
0.0350721292,
-0.0453360453,
-0.0202664994,
-0.00551331,
0.0543681681,
0.0247862823,
0.0595012009,
-0.0431709923,
0.0690142065,
-0.0203229394,
-0.0123738516,
-0.0176775027,
0.045261357,
0.0259632803,
-0.0564986467,
0.0722995922,
0.0541859008,
-0.0030842372,
0.0296714287,
0.0266625769,
0.0224307217,
-0.0910557657,
0.0104784034,
-0.0423705578,
-0.0286452901,
-0.0026467107,
-0.0063344482,
0.0209440757,
0.0169733651,
-0.0077893743,
-0.0373262279,
-0.0069419886,
0.0523864105,
-0.0422212556,
0.001106092,
-0.090094842,
0.0007166513,
0.0100538395,
0.0524460375,
0.0033133512,
-0.0357721858,
0.0690813139,
0.0147706997,
0.0038409415,
-0.0920853913,
0.0233188532,
-0.0549258552,
0.0570487492,
-0.0145972231,
0.0268484335,
0.002870966,
-0.0260152072,
-0.0722293481,
0.0403443463,
0.002404613,
-0.0340754651,
0.0291161425,
-0.0486720689,
-0.005797545,
-0.0037252451,
-0.0488744639,
-0.059134014,
-0.0386391729,
0.0354267731,
0.0142971007,
-0.003044104,
0.0183833744,
-0.0314241089,
-0.0083129816,
0.0455123559,
0.0226082392,
-0.014683417,
-0.0401481129,
-0.0176931284,
0.0867583454,
0.0833666176,
0.0172046516,
0.0250379127,
-0.0495900251,
0.0306086093,
0.0417752825,
0.0547342412,
0.0039583468,
0.0078811916,
-0.0114773242,
0.019144306,
-0.0227440242,
-0.0061834482,
0.0419154204,
0.0519664809,
-0.0643766746,
-0.0815802068,
0.0754815489,
0.0463333689,
-0.022886619,
-0.0127872238,
-0.0639023036,
0.0431227386,
0.0405360982,
0.0242141895,
-0.0338773988,
-0.0016740517,
-0.0077177184,
0.0114280395,
-0.024281662,
-0.0137170246,
-0.0048252973,
-0.1319046021,
0.0358733833,
-0.0027193746,
-0.0631486401,
-0.006142803,
-0.0369371958,
0.004760996,
0.0169022214,
0.0179551505,
0.0316136666,
-0.0122946938,
-0.0035506135,
0.0432984456,
0.0682682693,
-0.0570858009,
0.0111623453,
-0.0303488839,
0.0057993908,
0.0596548431,
0.0078539988,
0.0024013647,
-0.0365051329,
0.0544425696,
-0.0222515799,
0.0190563109,
-0.0051216125,
-0.0045253718,
0.0587349832,
0.0173605718,
-0.0544055067,
0.0488360785,
-0.0276267137,
-0.0156331696,
0.0137182735,
0.0833340958,
-0.0235593747,
0.0209810473,
-0.054791674,
-0.0250628125,
0.0125615178,
0.0687025189,
0.030061936,
-0.0432815701,
-0.0252644774,
-0.0129497172,
0.042287074,
-0.0058277058,
-0.0050587882,
0.0195741951,
-0.0007407313,
0.0069245202,
-0.0753124952,
-0.0018131681,
0.0026791904,
0.0579242818,
-0.017085325,
0.0114259198,
-0.0081960214,
0.0031451485,
-0.0460041091,
0.0402866341,
-0.0290083904,
-0.0306952707,
-0.0346689038,
-0.0138079599,
0.0502350703,
-0.0366575196,
-0.0454091132,
0.0161207616,
-0.0421582274,
-0.04595498,
-0.0035131602,
0.0009002697,
0.0295309369,
0.0156398043,
0.011397087,
-0.0379481241,
0.042506285,
0.0132035809,
0.0164157972,
-0.0069780024,
-0.0253442451,
-0.0028703369,
-0.0263772942,
0.0047338572,
-0.0697085634,
-0.0113296648,
0.0220922846,
0.0630772561,
-0.0144604649,
-0.0236496776,
0.0425545909,
0.0053172326,
0.0395331681,
0.0156941693,
-0.0412151888,
-0.0151747018,
0.008177476,
0.0057478258,
-0.0033615245,
-0.0090718381,
-0.0017134041,
0.0194989126,
0.0155699076,
0.0068261279,
0.0116688246,
-0.0087115485,
0.1009476706,
-0.0606598072,
-0.0149574159,
0.0319519863,
0.0168483313,
0.0389552936,
0.0054998067,
-0.0493605547,
-0.0012578298,
-0.0074711214,
0.0566412881,
-0.0313884281,
0.0701684505,
0.0132857524,
0.0051363125,
0.015215653,
-0.0058425479,
-0.0960875675,
-0.0192220137,
-0.0363371335,
0.0275479723,
-0.0008295966,
-0.0073684314,
-0.016620025,
-0.0272398032,
-0.0269693602,
-0.0399585739,
0.0218990259,
0.0233771242,
-0.0480237454,
0.0505357832,
0.0467757545,
-0.0009392715,
0.0303027164,
0.0717544779,
-0.0042197877,
0.0448846593,
-0.0222501121,
-0.0029062484,
-0.0248049609,
-0.0006014518,
0.0169776473,
0.0453864448,
0.0045218379,
0.0502770096,
-0.0707623959,
-0.0294182859,
0.0054225987,
-0.0014064538,
0.0033253303,
-0.0092983004,
0.0558620729,
0.074422203,
-0.036822781,
-0.0290420614,
-0.0257185511,
0.0743014291,
-0.0773546994,
-0.0479407609,
-0.0382816158,
-5.829606726e-33,
-0.0037983088,
-0.033232443,
0.0248536766,
-0.0537624024,
0.0010178878,
0.0088212648,
-0.0477463827,
0.0048857168,
-0.0334432311,
-0.0386329517,
0.0031641067,
-0.0048484742,
-0.0090248194,
0.031556569,
-0.0140419127,
-0.0217717681,
0.0177510232,
0.0166386999,
-0.0154791391,
0.0463715717,
0.0432264879,
0.0228211358,
0.0001086582,
-0.0421216711,
0.0091663338,
-0.0668420419,
0.0342919342,
0.0074212742,
-0.0201825704,
0.0532332808,
-0.0330918133,
0.0475349054,
0.0160535704,
-0.084457688,
0.0089953374,
0.0255950131,
-0.0532395393,
-0.026393963,
-0.0168730561,
-0.0363566503,
-0.0485657118,
-0.0375143997,
0.0244143754,
-0.0175137632,
-0.0165643096,
-0.0148493499,
0.0346871391,
-0.0131028499,
-0.0232120566,
-0.0370154195,
-0.0722209588,
-0.0039235,
-0.0071057719,
-0.0186628513,
-0.0524566323,
0.0887955725,
0.011249356,
0.0798322037,
-0.0106512215,
0.028474696,
-0.0213846918,
0.0196084753,
0.0402367525,
0.00923499,
0.0127418824,
0.0483542569,
-0.0107007409,
0.0091368118,
0.0156252589,
-0.0473225452,
0.0138113983,
0.0334282629,
0.0192188248,
0.071826674,
0.0661766604,
0.0301388334,
-0.120281972,
0.0489159301,
-0.0085697798,
0.001843823,
0.0367087387,
0.0093818931,
-0.0338021331,
-0.0036316407,
-0.0585194565,
0.0307325777,
-0.0407481641,
-0.0065916018,
0.0504129343,
0.0042427774,
-0.0249488596,
0.0057721967,
0.0447203368,
-0.0285303611,
-0.0090697808,
0.0281970948,
-0.0227770172,
0.0015475693,
-0.0183391459,
0.0377307273,
-0.041235745,
-0.0129291425,
0.0145957796,
-0.0052825678,
0.0234318655,
0.0205606874,
0.025224993,
0.0038667542,
-0.028728703,
-0.014537978,
-0.0653899238,
0.0202175528,
0.0044692052,
0.0116873942,
0.011582437,
0.0275540613,
-0.0103615578,
0.0554562844,
0.0425375812,
-0.0039394046,
-0.0275774524,
-0.0462993011,
-0.012127311,
-0.0158787072,
-0.022414295,
0.0004244043,
0.0265810527,
0.0460407473,
0.0157540478,
-0.033945825,
-0.0144269811,
0.0037108923,
2.473e-7,
0.0419502668,
0.0389267243,
0.0221778899,
-0.0145918243,
0.0175963137,
0.0156806428,
-0.0111647965,
0.0150646353,
0.0355934501,
0.0129640307,
-0.0159838293,
-0.0139501709,
-0.0001049599,
0.0094373999,
-0.0723847449,
-0.0105964458,
-0.0788494647,
-0.0015046686,
-0.0288552139,
-0.0006152503,
0.0471504889,
0.0751825273,
-0.0371967144,
-0.0175699443,
0.0149745122,
-0.0488303006,
0.0883520171,
-0.0279264357,
-0.0000552108,
0.0317607597,
-0.0114097632,
0.0406936109,
0.0282222461,
-0.0048844842,
-0.0079714591,
0.0042829346,
0.0329551026,
0.0162020195,
0.0382907763,
-0.0767608285,
0.0216436163,
0.0101934727,
0.0226295721,
-0.0718957186,
0.0569201335,
-0.0619405694,
-0.032286007,
-0.0161992367,
0.0022623676,
0.0052150008,
0.0197564028,
-0.0117447358,
0.0109185874,
-0.0307111125,
-0.0140204029,
0.0062824935,
0.0078625325,
-0.0727912188,
-0.0335760564,
0.026010856,
-0.0555669144,
-0.0639117062,
-0.0388502255,
-0.0140705965,
0.0122953244,
-0.0410254747,
-0.0040569147,
2.375396281e-34,
0.0267229117,
0.0177107472,
0.0140320845,
0.0020612776,
0.0066261105,
-0.012558274,
-0.0318883322,
0.00704872,
0.0369004831,
-0.0822558329,
-0.0199545901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02005v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02005v1 | An End-to-End Speech Summarization Using Large Language Model | 2024-07-02T07:22:57 | 2024-07-02T07:22:57 | Hengchao Shang, Zongyao Li, Jiaxin Guo, Shaojun Li, Zhiqiang Rao, Yuanchang Luo, Daimeng Wei, Hao Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Abstractive Speech Summarization (SSum) aims to generate human-like text
summaries from spoken content. It encounters difficulties in handling long
speech input and capturing the intricate cross-modal mapping between long
speech inputs and short text summaries. Research on large language models
(LLMs) and multimodal information fusion has provided new insights for
addressing these challenges. In this paper, we propose an end-to-end SSum model
that utilizes Q-Former as a connector for the audio-text modality and employs
LLMs to generate text summaries directly from speech features. We adopt a
multi-stage training approach that includes LLM based ASR and Text
Summarization (TSum) tasks as auxiliary tasks. ASR tasks are used to align
feature spaces and enhance the LLM's ability to handle longer speech. Then, we
utilize a curriculum learning strategy to facilitate the model's transition
from TSum to SSum. Finally, our model achieves competitive performance on the
How-2 dataset. | [
0.0187650006,
0.0058852956,
0.0398491211,
0.009864457,
0.0092539396,
-0.0057547959,
-0.0275075659,
-0.0445848703,
-0.034513142,
-0.0597742274,
-0.0479716696,
-0.0298655815,
0.0477000251,
0.003169212,
0.0282026492,
-0.0904263034,
-0.0052452562,
-0.0587203801,
-0.0490287915,
-0.01544498,
0.0326968245,
0.0268844943,
0.000090285,
0.0163891204,
-0.0113185672,
0.0192403942,
-0.0079740081,
-0.000404629,
0.0506976172,
-0.0065065026,
-0.0200909916,
-0.0283183251,
0.0703200921,
-0.0212922376,
0.0000018164,
-0.0521902852,
-0.0163897928,
0.0058362316,
-0.0052180584,
0.0057572578,
0.0355682746,
-0.003630568,
0.0119649479,
0.0609940812,
0.01517912,
0.0434376895,
0.0101886978,
0.0778391063,
0.0601154231,
0.0624581836,
-0.0081722569,
-0.0568662398,
0.0417046994,
-0.0258123428,
-0.012004938,
-0.0412979759,
-0.004794681,
0.0188930277,
0.0263646785,
-0.0003108627,
-0.0058427546,
0.0545530319,
0.0117322085,
-0.0075506326,
0.0079643484,
0.0309440438,
0.0078010452,
0.0038774053,
-0.0095811803,
0.0690468326,
0.0158335809,
0.0279273055,
0.0307699293,
0.0364654213,
0.0018691899,
-0.0192542616,
-0.0639639348,
0.0662280396,
-0.0027368446,
0.0097973254,
-0.0084285531,
0.0361927636,
-0.0099655315,
0.0201366618,
-0.0513595715,
-0.0391416512,
-0.0032966787,
-0.026759373,
-0.0224583466,
-0.036548622,
0.0160715953,
-0.0428811051,
-0.0039129439,
0.0494874679,
0.002270886,
-0.0147876665,
-0.0328622982,
-0.0150244003,
0.0030300433,
-0.0219735801,
-0.0001644245,
-0.0073396182,
-0.0150224548,
0.0699876249,
-0.0005225744,
0.0351178125,
0.0474683978,
0.0154400459,
-0.0585726388,
-0.0121046994,
-0.0390368439,
-0.0108615188,
-0.0085424073,
0.0180258136,
-0.0291114524,
-0.0603927635,
-0.0561871082,
0.0148186348,
0.0124465097,
0.0011996339,
0.0366392955,
0.0040149041,
0.0067683812,
-0.0020569761,
0.0341418199,
0.0549893677,
0.0164653603,
0.0307014156,
0.0037956808,
0.0262746289,
0.0043327478,
0.0467153192,
0.013439835,
0.0028349578,
0.0134923114,
0.0543290749,
-0.0495469533,
-0.0390337929,
-0.0240010545,
-0.0127312709,
-0.0613946766,
-0.0424957648,
-0.0066753081,
-0.0381037183,
0.0024495889,
-0.035379447,
-0.0189537592,
0.0176525321,
0.0027526217,
-0.0158793628,
-0.0095708081,
0.0391729698,
0.0045610475,
0.0518206134,
0.0646366253,
0.0140984347,
0.0473629534,
0.0400469974,
0.0870714113,
0.0187248196,
0.0219292697,
-0.005064616,
-0.0191090498,
0.0792899504,
-0.0319320187,
0.0207590461,
-0.0248003602,
-0.0562375858,
-0.008457032,
-0.004452311,
0.0615055375,
0.086861223,
-0.0116562601,
0.0385456234,
0.0645715967,
0.0607732348,
0.0293164644,
-0.0100404909,
0.0120667042,
0.0720401779,
0.0235485192,
0.0226585139,
-0.0087961219,
0.0565262735,
-0.0420390889,
0.0751930997,
0.1155241132,
0.0590983145,
-0.0181047469,
-0.0383544154,
-0.0054992191,
-0.02625346,
0.0105747376,
0.032297954,
0.0339585319,
0.0018969197,
-0.0495225936,
0.0191047639,
-0.0072620614,
-0.0839669406,
0.0319272317,
-0.038180925,
0.005196373,
0.0454580672,
0.0210199933,
-0.0524603464,
-0.0211846568,
-0.0255635921,
-0.0320003554,
0.0443634056,
-0.0093999496,
-0.0264499933,
0.0066438522,
-0.0673173964,
-0.042168092,
0.0202598497,
-0.0199857783,
-0.0184423514,
-0.0389086232,
-0.0213911962,
0.0313079245,
-0.0036492164,
-0.0214467775,
0.0065467218,
-0.0367884561,
-0.0105826426,
-0.0197709911,
0.0092836954,
0.0126967849,
0.0398296975,
-0.045476079,
0.0137662003,
0.0442021564,
-0.0344710425,
0.0029964421,
0.0209736358,
-0.0720987618,
-0.032235004,
0.0538554043,
-0.0045985929,
0.0450230278,
0.0135597102,
-0.0216382202,
-0.0873851478,
0.0158174206,
-0.0649557784,
0.0113528939,
-0.0516067334,
0.0283728745,
0.0425586738,
-0.0105581665,
-0.0150393881,
0.0463199615,
0.019095825,
-0.0366452225,
0.037697807,
-0.0163813625,
-0.0285920892,
-0.0448377915,
-0.0037952552,
0.0220139083,
0.006304387,
0.0247832332,
0.0503148772,
-0.0065722973,
0.0011032602,
-0.0412105918,
-0.1303575635,
0.0112594515,
-0.0068256049,
-0.007772068,
0.0118044671,
0.018726455,
-0.0029973728,
-0.011302324,
-0.05257117,
-0.0549636483,
0.0503383465,
-0.0216211081,
-0.0225009713,
0.0293661263,
-0.0040711625,
-0.0448812284,
0.0001846483,
0.0019858081,
0.0355234817,
-0.0251174066,
-0.0123451632,
-0.0201066379,
0.030355962,
-0.0013101957,
-0.0054975306,
-0.0183531176,
0.0029243936,
-0.0403995477,
0.0169203989,
0.085025005,
0.0354362167,
0.0860678032,
-0.018025076,
0.0523745082,
-0.0129630854,
-0.0103600295,
0.0001685177,
0.0115742292,
-0.0014330598,
-0.0177451111,
-0.0102140568,
0.0119062634,
0.0304279234,
0.0378822088,
0.020699488,
-0.0072258511,
-0.0027251542,
0.0089958692,
-0.0224619973,
-0.0695655569,
-0.0339056104,
-0.0565631874,
0.007140921,
-0.0341803171,
0.0156495795,
0.0214484893,
-0.0804216638,
-0.0051923599,
-0.045636069,
-0.0668803826,
-0.0549832061,
0.031918373,
-0.0054611033,
0.0430106334,
-0.0141711431,
-0.0201423094,
-0.0540749654,
-0.0314845964,
0.0006134128,
-0.0419136547,
0.078576915,
-0.0212877132,
-0.0061601968,
-0.0320218988,
0.0020127457,
0.0111863054,
-0.0065537272,
-0.036404144,
0.0343132727,
-0.0281914733,
-0.0134567665,
-0.0166572016,
0.0295753293,
0.0624567233,
0.0522118211,
-0.0279463548,
0.016702462,
-0.0254020952,
0.0750974342,
0.0610270686,
0.03936629,
-0.0206488278,
-0.0379953049,
0.0426982269,
0.0018167008,
0.0675027519,
0.0109088225,
0.00620759,
-0.0246099979,
-0.003136206,
-0.0042010807,
-0.0036732969,
0.0197515916,
0.049506247,
-0.0286514163,
0.050678432,
0.1058845222,
-0.0097983545,
0.0050176964,
-0.0329584219,
0.0326627567,
0.0108287232,
0.0127869966,
-0.0095721241,
-0.0556437038,
-0.0375698619,
0.0382856876,
0.0205044542,
0.037641488,
0.0204645898,
-0.0220009256,
-0.0709429085,
0.0144762211,
0.0257569291,
-0.0476590693,
-0.0057964874,
-0.03177993,
-0.0161721893,
-0.010992826,
0.0393446237,
0.0203349255,
-0.0772540718,
-0.029206695,
0.0346891917,
-0.0448416062,
0.0016846387,
-0.0196970142,
-0.0146993687,
0.0259155426,
0.0474349149,
0.0488225892,
-0.0393519029,
0.0065275161,
0.0371415839,
-0.0159707312,
-0.0049302289,
0.0477230474,
0.044534687,
-0.026915513,
0.0039484627,
-0.0184545852,
0.0569165908,
0.0423346721,
0.0092788823,
0.0155306179,
-0.0077999891,
0.0179056339,
0.0032475241,
-0.0197434369,
0.0557087436,
-0.0531868152,
0.0749053434,
0.0177614223,
-0.0265358984,
-0.0076798084,
0.0051092384,
-0.0211588182,
-0.0324467495,
-0.0526770949,
0.0211833492,
-0.049223382,
-0.0207724012,
-0.0567393564,
-0.0221034158,
0.0322888605,
-0.0356007107,
0.0079261465,
0.0208816081,
-0.0017391706,
0.031527359,
-0.0489782579,
0.029402364,
-0.0195994992,
0.0399844572,
-0.070807822,
0.0298180208,
0.0610808991,
-0.0683930442,
-0.0288446192,
0.0106352223,
-0.0568396039,
-0.063423261,
-0.0398086905,
0.0228395537,
0.01658592,
0.0446950495,
0.0438074842,
0.0025546956,
0.0948521122,
0.0231700689,
-0.0151069388,
0.0446856841,
0.0115021225,
0.0096646724,
-0.0415109098,
-0.0050697057,
-0.0991937444,
0.0285670925,
-0.0535954088,
0.0338062681,
-0.028131919,
-0.050180614,
-0.0158920009,
0.0307914317,
0.0082603488,
-0.0336375944,
0.0206271373,
-0.0319939293,
-0.0449527316,
-0.0052616037,
0.0110462233,
-0.0342716351,
0.0367068537,
-0.0091975546,
0.0319394805,
0.013018351,
0.0372644588,
0.0174076725,
0.0025311504,
-0.0458891913,
0.0152141564,
-0.03233077,
-0.0633891672,
-0.0309286211,
0.0014864582,
-0.0320504755,
0.0024249214,
-0.016413914,
-0.0137844812,
-0.0022173726,
0.0269324053,
-0.0052617793,
-0.025436867,
-0.0013563532,
0.0553206131,
-0.041248031,
-0.0007753531,
-0.0440320037,
0.0497865938,
0.0668054447,
-0.0322342329,
0.0505589321,
0.0222979262,
0.0257934481,
-0.0590777174,
0.0283616912,
-0.0226129089,
-0.014779916,
-0.0088325087,
0.003172982,
0.0121921627,
0.0146302683,
0.066993244,
-0.0129043795,
0.0167058092,
-0.0099495156,
0.0071598799,
-0.0403252244,
-0.0418452173,
0.0169533044,
0.0148229981,
-0.0104232254,
0.0010995301,
-0.012829029,
-0.0556069873,
0.0494910069,
-0.0111772139,
-0.0153737124,
-0.0265674386,
0.0358078554,
-0.0164842885,
-0.0239008516,
0.0017505918,
-0.0043363208,
-0.0588475317,
0.0049762833,
0.0043208697,
0.0550784692,
-5.88529173e-33,
-0.0495367125,
0.0042673266,
0.0113172866,
0.0007350994,
-0.0804174766,
0.0201653354,
-0.0268566497,
0.0126227308,
0.0387246981,
-0.0337610096,
-0.0086822603,
-0.023230616,
0.0087447576,
0.0530106872,
-0.0041849776,
0.044547122,
0.080382809,
-0.0082384432,
-0.0106797265,
0.0477230102,
0.0274037588,
0.0120331356,
0.0173685905,
-0.0355209298,
-0.0315994881,
-0.0070156022,
-0.0255082399,
0.0181708336,
0.0487507768,
0.0458890274,
-0.0144599136,
0.0009638927,
0.0154069355,
-0.0310421642,
-0.0407573543,
0.0511433743,
-0.0641984865,
0.0314742848,
0.0434245281,
-0.0211872365,
-0.0283055827,
-0.0603092685,
0.0412858091,
-0.0316198952,
-0.0080953715,
-0.066891633,
0.0503472984,
-0.0484563783,
-0.0090527944,
-0.0669897869,
-0.0297125354,
0.01540225,
-0.030250283,
-0.0481934547,
0.0280669909,
0.0627924949,
0.0117173269,
-0.0238200817,
-0.0185001697,
0.0442795865,
0.0225744154,
0.0261330567,
0.0592555627,
0.0818666965,
-0.0135041112,
0.0672451481,
-0.0128565012,
-0.0611283407,
-0.0312638171,
-0.0152020957,
0.0038853756,
0.0158822257,
-0.0245552901,
0.028311871,
0.00340948,
0.0204755161,
-0.0281726401,
0.0496202111,
-0.0222068615,
0.0256794058,
0.0478368625,
0.012409322,
0.0179530568,
0.001385233,
-0.0631070212,
0.0402619392,
-0.0012300609,
0.0118275378,
0.0120113268,
0.0566047356,
-0.0049536768,
-0.0254863966,
0.0509706177,
-0.0231129956,
0.0507998616,
0.034589868,
-0.0241184682,
0.018366646,
-0.0061050756,
-0.0025156513,
-0.0282479338,
0.0202442426,
0.07888785,
-0.013631939,
-0.0118641295,
-0.0017096605,
0.0113854315,
0.0256326087,
-0.0440628007,
0.0138289109,
0.0403115824,
0.0088756243,
-0.0343114957,
0.0218702257,
-0.0023166854,
0.0146226948,
-0.00995465,
0.042728506,
-0.0639544278,
0.0191831682,
-0.023014741,
-0.0496091619,
0.0071454644,
0.0441484004,
-0.0324264504,
0.0375320986,
-0.0100998655,
-0.0419368669,
0.0310118273,
-0.0338802785,
-0.0114550181,
0.0004120231,
2.515e-7,
-0.0128133772,
-0.0009668666,
0.0617367849,
-0.0105625615,
-0.0184217058,
0.0258389469,
-0.0233938396,
0.023741629,
0.0473901108,
0.0182367582,
0.0238990746,
0.0386806354,
0.0569112934,
-0.0119345598,
-0.1219384521,
-0.0352171734,
-0.0804197192,
-0.043462351,
-0.0255166087,
-0.0030604741,
0.0466967858,
0.0947315618,
-0.0377602391,
-0.0342259444,
-0.0135113345,
-0.0399993509,
0.040958751,
-0.0126484465,
-0.0472761132,
-0.0151449805,
0.0138151264,
-0.0064238864,
-0.0202940851,
-0.0174057502,
0.0218226202,
0.0203182623,
0.0410338864,
0.0400847234,
0.001235351,
-0.0490777008,
-0.0115280626,
0.071941644,
-0.011990319,
0.0251606777,
0.0407599285,
-0.0334313847,
-0.0009930765,
-0.0549111925,
-0.0495315269,
0.0094274888,
-0.0288730171,
-0.0048312694,
-0.0090273507,
0.0278605241,
0.0161362961,
-0.0123367533,
0.0176404007,
-0.0868331119,
-0.02786096,
0.0667850673,
-0.0514918976,
-0.0314320363,
-0.0148183228,
-0.0233742762,
0.0027703936,
-0.0688294023,
-0.0178772863,
2.04288199e-34,
0.047698047,
-0.0295607783,
-0.0231876951,
-0.0169459637,
0.0108999107,
-0.029400276,
-0.0037648415,
-0.0248789117,
0.0040300321,
-0.1072890535,
-0.0307386629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02543v1 | Towards the Next Frontier in Speech Representation Learning Using Disentanglement | 2024-07-02T07:13:35 | 2024-07-02T07:13:35 | Varun Krishna, Sriram Ganapathy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | The popular frameworks for self-supervised learning of speech representations
have largely focused on frame-level masked prediction of speech regions. While
this has shown promising downstream task performance for speech recognition and
related tasks, this has largely ignored factors of speech that are encoded at
coarser level, like characteristics of the speaker or channel that remain
consistent through-out a speech utterance. In this work, we propose a framework
for Learning Disentangled Self Supervised (termed as Learn2Diss)
representations of speech, which consists of frame-level and an utterance-level
encoder modules. The two encoders are initially learned independently, where
the frame-level model is largely inspired by existing self supervision
techniques, thereby learning pseudo-phonemic representations, while the
utterance-level encoder is inspired by constrastive learning of pooled
embeddings, thereby learning pseudo-speaker representations. The joint learning
of these two modules consists of disentangling the two encoders using a mutual
information based criterion. With several downstream evaluation experiments, we
show that the proposed Learn2Diss achieves state-of-the-art results on a
variety of tasks, with the frame-level encoder representations improving
semantic tasks, while the utterance-level representations improve non-semantic
tasks. | [
-0.0524283089,
0.0704809427,
-0.0033737274,
0.0348762944,
-0.0036785731,
0.0101905549,
0.0261714775,
-0.016652165,
0.0336993635,
-0.0140157593,
-0.0778663978,
0.0074167084,
0.0093915034,
0.0311593171,
0.0049806344,
-0.0504128039,
0.0344330184,
-0.0113154836,
-0.0428627022,
-0.0350322351,
0.0001938293,
-0.0267918911,
-0.0540536344,
0.005118099,
-0.0038791213,
0.015255535,
-0.0238318462,
-0.0117201693,
-0.016004771,
0.0040807091,
-0.0032657129,
0.0130245071,
0.0954416394,
0.0094382307,
0.0000020622,
0.0108291544,
0.0144277243,
-0.045937784,
-0.0762187317,
-0.0051795114,
-0.0753495991,
-0.0144171352,
-0.0173050705,
0.0045916201,
-0.0342191271,
-0.0354587734,
0.0348049961,
0.0111792563,
0.069308497,
0.0413513966,
-0.0067553939,
-0.0495306961,
0.0202377848,
-0.0482805036,
-0.0057266112,
0.0099199135,
-0.0375917405,
-0.0288468935,
-0.066683203,
-0.0272331983,
-0.074670814,
0.0024492363,
0.0353579856,
0.0076328455,
0.018183412,
0.0297147483,
-0.0066936929,
-0.0241096057,
0.0019017109,
0.068896547,
0.0214618463,
0.0111942254,
-0.0113141136,
0.0075785941,
-0.0343206711,
0.0060789441,
0.0131464154,
-0.043406792,
0.0586867891,
0.0371619537,
-0.0253753662,
0.0739042759,
0.014946348,
-0.0063280188,
-0.0484619848,
0.0128733898,
-0.0203417353,
-0.0305286478,
0.0073413146,
-0.0356333405,
0.0204153955,
0.021003589,
0.0047481377,
-0.0397055857,
0.0234738216,
-0.0405780226,
-0.0196558814,
-0.0341796018,
-0.0410371386,
0.0083389739,
-0.0504198968,
0.045153901,
-0.0119936187,
0.0217430294,
-0.0560056828,
0.0479208454,
0.0046672742,
0.0614006333,
-0.007464679,
-0.0228380002,
-0.0477639735,
-0.0048026894,
-0.0219901446,
0.077704154,
-0.0577972345,
-0.0281537734,
-0.0316844769,
-0.0062636663,
-0.0759369507,
0.0448762067,
-0.0308042485,
0.0340299942,
0.000458052,
-0.0206225924,
-0.0265482888,
0.0570223443,
0.0097390916,
0.0129379043,
-0.010431529,
-0.0150521072,
-0.0283815786,
0.0303017516,
0.0215888098,
-0.008855015,
-0.0067843082,
0.0702730864,
-0.0180048365,
-0.0364543423,
-0.0070097051,
0.0346631929,
0.001876486,
-0.0260093473,
0.0094085252,
-0.0446100235,
0.0268609915,
-0.0102014849,
0.0120611014,
-0.0748686269,
0.0105476296,
-0.0655579716,
0.0279541872,
0.070899874,
-0.0063330783,
-0.0114130042,
0.041466713,
0.0342814662,
0.0419896394,
0.0505023934,
0.0380505733,
0.0197019447,
-0.0180156045,
-0.0452645384,
0.0110555207,
-0.002303673,
0.0436685309,
0.0310354494,
-0.0443412811,
-0.0045411186,
0.0247579981,
-0.0022302638,
0.0733079314,
0.0374100395,
-0.0469662771,
-0.0410741009,
0.0551348552,
0.0504914746,
0.0481521524,
0.0108588692,
-0.0134930732,
0.0523071177,
-0.0127900066,
0.0158512071,
0.0052936231,
0.0571700707,
0.0244215038,
0.0032951122,
0.0648437813,
-0.0232324544,
-0.0683838129,
-0.0299799424,
0.0544731691,
-0.0402701832,
0.03376453,
0.0312810242,
0.0447431281,
0.0239547826,
-0.031506516,
0.0401856862,
-0.0000933412,
-0.0239373092,
0.0535958,
-0.0342845619,
-0.0198795591,
0.0629663169,
-0.0119634811,
-0.0347306617,
0.0187188983,
-0.0545266047,
-0.0268055368,
0.054208234,
-0.0202328302,
-0.0051653162,
0.1034812331,
-0.0552121736,
-0.0410440788,
-0.0228883736,
-0.009222053,
0.0194214601,
-0.0420035087,
0.0034060781,
0.0230617523,
0.0441301987,
0.0690949261,
-0.0124219777,
-0.0215295907,
-0.0372889265,
0.027263198,
0.0262579434,
0.0544326939,
0.0057990621,
-0.0419727415,
-0.0215813685,
0.0295752846,
-0.0348002389,
-0.0456675254,
-0.0171425715,
-0.0661314875,
-0.0754987225,
-0.0154986763,
-0.0513154902,
0.030003462,
0.0505564734,
-0.0044413805,
-0.0924259499,
0.0954667106,
-0.0069694477,
0.0488883369,
-0.0228330176,
-0.0303735901,
0.0227138773,
0.043485295,
0.0019626447,
-0.0011426222,
-0.0149241155,
0.0014758109,
-0.0036968151,
0.0504983813,
0.0066796765,
-0.0150604127,
-0.0010235371,
0.0112629766,
0.0147556299,
0.0170765221,
-0.0018407714,
-0.0237243176,
0.0096423132,
-0.0289410166,
-0.0355419144,
-0.0085609695,
-0.0302871168,
-0.0134039586,
0.0201409552,
0.0170937963,
0.0101414109,
-0.0614328869,
-0.0140289171,
-0.064806819,
-0.0144181522,
0.0061430759,
-0.0117199216,
-0.0012643761,
-0.0016656385,
-0.0134588648,
0.0115887644,
0.0282675605,
0.0091856262,
-0.0764653906,
-0.0493039601,
0.0028743302,
-0.0085120425,
0.0005463967,
0.0274861231,
-0.0158977062,
-0.0243331101,
-0.0108302077,
0.0064878911,
0.0024032895,
0.0385132991,
-0.0072561409,
0.0366295911,
0.047084149,
0.004542633,
-0.0456274226,
0.0217337441,
-0.0311920848,
0.0387779996,
-0.0174232014,
0.0505307056,
-0.0382966772,
0.0303113218,
0.039721895,
0.0267110616,
-0.0558513552,
-0.0317194536,
0.0277315881,
-0.0372284502,
-0.0393738411,
-0.0121267568,
0.0051139621,
0.0434851535,
-0.0314688273,
-0.0392510369,
0.0507380366,
-0.0239801556,
-0.0393181071,
-0.0236592479,
-0.0514834039,
-0.0124234976,
0.0571299605,
0.0096740946,
0.0133995274,
-0.0336267054,
-0.0315475166,
-0.064578414,
0.0150283044,
0.0270017534,
-0.0333394594,
0.0184471831,
0.0023245423,
-0.0169944018,
0.0043187356,
-0.0410744585,
-0.0268781278,
-0.0394250266,
0.0036652898,
0.013206468,
-0.022577662,
-0.0227964763,
0.0015583221,
-0.0202922933,
0.0193658285,
0.021988878,
0.0359212384,
0.0073067951,
-0.0308882426,
0.0564402267,
0.0281855538,
0.0471885763,
-0.0160069391,
-0.0043965448,
0.0828443617,
0.0010935481,
-0.0051155118,
0.009434863,
-0.0593213364,
0.0331917778,
0.0124604926,
0.0333968662,
0.0057353242,
0.0005271242,
0.0371088386,
-0.0127269896,
0.0120665459,
0.0972648785,
-0.0151017802,
-0.0283325147,
-0.0052356301,
0.0383880027,
-0.0024365964,
0.0337909199,
-0.0047712214,
-0.0399056822,
-0.0429397635,
0.009493296,
-0.01049536,
0.0209994428,
0.0371850207,
0.0116207665,
-0.0730175227,
0.0014863835,
0.0449604765,
0.0166517049,
-0.1107749939,
-0.0631937981,
-0.0186994206,
-0.0119184079,
0.0587728471,
-0.0358580388,
0.0108621372,
-0.0300995652,
0.0034896138,
-0.0522992946,
-0.0175428428,
0.0086580105,
-0.0100551378,
0.0655604303,
0.0456210002,
0.0056555211,
-0.0142292986,
-0.0392218009,
-0.0587224029,
-0.0726571605,
-0.0390029773,
-0.0133640738,
0.0673986003,
0.0166061278,
-0.0276881251,
0.0038555437,
0.0286331587,
-0.0052798679,
-0.0139022237,
-0.0283415876,
0.0360272042,
-0.0542146936,
0.0184319466,
0.0199877825,
0.0149433464,
0.0078107058,
0.0405280292,
0.0286938995,
-0.0176509824,
-0.0118550034,
0.0110100359,
0.0707376823,
0.0107674608,
0.0226806328,
-0.0041216272,
0.0171419326,
0.00437873,
-0.0359456092,
0.0167345721,
0.0126473065,
0.0088153752,
0.0128348134,
0.0236252025,
0.0212621707,
-0.037288405,
-0.045615565,
0.0011843151,
0.0087115336,
0.0217549913,
0.0084360298,
-0.0609697402,
0.0627080724,
-0.019763764,
-0.0185648426,
-0.0205335673,
-0.0177247357,
-0.0668323115,
-0.025255492,
-0.0110312644,
0.0086463802,
0.0973111391,
-0.0126378974,
0.0135426363,
0.0965833366,
0.0175485276,
-0.0812038481,
-0.0077185826,
0.060209576,
0.0319168456,
-0.0321052708,
0.0218142457,
-0.0246335976,
0.0359509401,
0.0009145964,
-0.0235083606,
-0.0334627405,
-0.025528973,
0.0096295141,
-0.0346488282,
0.0904656872,
0.0173963122,
0.0707901716,
-0.0181561504,
0.0315380916,
0.0095840786,
0.0402967408,
-0.0275095087,
-0.0268785991,
0.0445298292,
-0.0089671994,
0.0323595963,
0.0578107163,
0.0373662785,
-0.0248386171,
0.0101771969,
0.0079811467,
-0.0604060963,
0.0190542154,
-0.0593474731,
0.0503217429,
0.0167614166,
0.0441718511,
0.0628094599,
0.016243577,
0.0143898567,
0.0081626615,
-0.0055906931,
0.0182516202,
-0.0302110836,
0.024078289,
-0.056568861,
-0.0140139125,
-0.0104810381,
0.0086726416,
0.025091853,
0.0126534374,
-0.0248602126,
0.0178777128,
0.0342405438,
-0.0002786843,
0.0489177443,
-0.0601967275,
0.0423637554,
0.0130037973,
-0.0007247004,
-0.0324859321,
0.005969773,
0.0480229668,
0.0234194417,
0.0420081615,
-0.0302176662,
0.0719840676,
-0.0554814227,
-0.0489638932,
-0.0031383836,
0.0651457831,
0.002003185,
0.0284283403,
-0.008301083,
-0.0410789028,
-0.0291816052,
-0.0324124768,
0.0070323534,
0.0027605672,
0.0635205209,
-0.0448224656,
-0.0040796101,
0.0042147995,
0.0026376599,
-0.0447021611,
0.0428151339,
0.0095198015,
0.005786947,
-6.134910894e-33,
-0.0492113233,
0.0388605893,
-0.0026699991,
0.0288755018,
-0.0253919624,
0.0101196859,
-0.0174473599,
0.008892999,
0.0078096199,
-0.0261479542,
-0.0101103801,
0.0366227441,
0.0032570462,
0.0471035428,
-0.0132166985,
-0.0314087905,
0.0850105062,
-0.0007298642,
0.0077059204,
0.0108137568,
0.0625538602,
0.0197704192,
0.0449579507,
-0.0602436215,
-0.0701819062,
-0.009564586,
0.0043267114,
-0.0221949629,
0.000182957,
-0.0077829547,
-0.0203640405,
0.0232665315,
-0.0184723176,
-0.0280529521,
-0.0338319764,
0.0128156748,
-0.0871071741,
-0.0438643396,
-0.0391936973,
0.0050061173,
-0.0338015929,
-0.0079118274,
0.0496662483,
0.0176600292,
-0.0187161602,
-0.0170940664,
0.0105646402,
0.0185895972,
-0.0026910207,
-0.0072451378,
0.0086099552,
-0.0006593237,
-0.0439898036,
-0.0476462878,
0.0932546332,
0.0144304149,
0.0091007641,
-0.0444142371,
-0.0820891038,
0.0155923888,
-0.0291690025,
0.0522134155,
0.0451780446,
0.0328277983,
0.0455171056,
0.0886376575,
0.0721894205,
-0.0521667004,
-0.0032210115,
-0.0134282112,
0.0259151068,
0.0601072647,
0.0204766411,
0.0044289534,
0.0464975722,
-0.0523978285,
-0.0545083322,
0.0123797078,
-0.0137906037,
0.0214705449,
-0.0089744078,
0.0458391011,
-0.0167328734,
-0.0335151292,
-0.0757112876,
0.0099325897,
0.0215255413,
-0.0159608554,
0.017358901,
0.034251038,
0.00043188,
-0.0019909828,
0.0333578587,
-0.0459412299,
0.0253371149,
0.0035572003,
-0.0196239986,
-0.0006073748,
0.0404669084,
0.0000709468,
-0.0383887254,
-0.0493093729,
0.0617478192,
0.0049807103,
0.014047252,
-0.010499795,
-0.0086501734,
0.0157237519,
-0.0411951728,
-0.0281592421,
-0.0373578854,
0.009032771,
-0.0105422409,
-0.0448177345,
0.0200635102,
0.0418623835,
-0.0412393585,
0.0093622198,
-0.049555175,
0.0166197717,
-0.00721503,
0.0052295276,
0.0128488205,
0.0606548898,
0.0024679601,
-0.0162499789,
-0.0427177213,
-0.0294550769,
0.0742010847,
-0.0433690399,
-0.0004823212,
-0.026317358,
2.769e-7,
-0.0605704337,
-0.0023653193,
0.0093140034,
-0.0436349884,
0.0519598462,
0.0472130775,
-0.0304439515,
0.0050056293,
-0.0369578563,
-0.0406880975,
-0.0002109745,
0.0532058403,
0.0504631847,
-0.0014545334,
-0.0430099368,
0.042256698,
-0.0433462709,
-0.0148387449,
-0.0166743975,
-0.0021740333,
0.0184106641,
0.0986875519,
0.0336996093,
-0.0003313593,
0.056691058,
0.0141700394,
0.0743982568,
-0.0036463928,
0.0280806664,
-0.0352303162,
-0.0559911542,
0.0330327637,
0.0047912216,
0.0591982529,
-0.026480088,
0.0418434329,
0.0013779519,
0.0304830223,
0.0039696475,
-0.0512416959,
-0.0483435392,
0.0815760419,
-0.0196983386,
0.0487524942,
0.0644329563,
-0.063349627,
-0.049776461,
-0.0150379958,
-0.0518151745,
0.0661297739,
0.044268012,
0.0058698072,
-0.0312996171,
-0.0216748472,
-0.0109355114,
-0.0049934168,
0.0012755219,
-0.0673050061,
0.0118110562,
0.0178333335,
-0.0549642332,
-0.016108742,
-0.0257452559,
-0.0190329291,
0.0457176752,
0.0005355339,
0.0029436536,
1.832632657e-34,
-0.0438873954,
0.0086681088,
0.0035789174,
-0.0147810355,
-0.0283473842,
-0.080500409,
-0.0394968726,
-0.0132790683,
0.0522152856,
0.0097729238,
0.0095978668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01994v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01994v1 | Simple Augmentations of Logical Rules for Neuro-Symbolic Knowledge Graph Completion | 2024-07-02T07:07:59 | 2024-07-02T07:07:59 | Ananjan Nandi, Navdeep Kaur, Parag Singla, Mausam | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | High-quality and high-coverage rule sets are imperative to the success of
Neuro-Symbolic Knowledge Graph Completion (NS-KGC) models, because they form
the basis of all symbolic inferences. Recent literature builds neural models
for generating rule sets, however, preliminary experiments show that they
struggle with maintaining high coverage. In this work, we suggest three simple
augmentations to existing rule sets: (1) transforming rules to their abductive
forms, (2) generating equivalent rules that use inverse forms of constituent
relations and (3) random walks that propose new rules. Finally, we prune
potentially low quality rules. Experiments over four datasets and five
ruleset-baseline settings suggest that these simple augmentations consistently
improve results, and obtain up to 7.1 pt MRR and 8.5 pt Hits@1 gains over using
rules without augmentations. | [
0.0555141754,
0.0298945177,
-0.0334444307,
0.0201728921,
-0.0449275896,
-0.0087482426,
-0.0498281568,
0.024186546,
0.0343564115,
0.0359603316,
0.0669232011,
0.0427392982,
-0.0047427472,
0.0363726728,
0.0340336077,
-0.0040864041,
0.0493995845,
-0.0048767892,
0.0325476676,
-0.0175072458,
-0.0388323031,
0.0188029837,
-0.0088380342,
-0.0007765494,
-0.045413062,
0.017835075,
-0.0114864614,
-0.0108955316,
-0.0170076452,
-0.0121385651,
-0.0386259295,
0.0273144394,
0.0071379831,
-0.0081468439,
0.000001913,
-0.0194976516,
0.0263888035,
-0.0130119277,
-0.013903792,
-0.0248180833,
-0.0014820873,
-0.0308024678,
0.053090211,
0.0054934649,
-0.0356355719,
0.0010072467,
0.0579259358,
0.0702733472,
-0.0026521503,
0.0493277498,
-0.007590076,
-0.0084976284,
0.0471288487,
-0.037112847,
0.0198011566,
0.004713343,
0.0513498336,
0.0349995531,
-0.0144192642,
-0.0615264624,
-0.0284927972,
0.0015241363,
0.0590537712,
0.0399440825,
0.0205913801,
0.0416350961,
-0.0236976631,
0.0072020721,
0.0413929746,
0.0638686344,
-0.0144851152,
-0.0177379362,
-0.0182210598,
0.008088043,
0.0311139561,
0.0149441883,
-0.0493902415,
-0.0194608979,
-0.055790145,
-0.0102701597,
0.0084534483,
-0.0421484411,
0.0633447841,
-0.0070826998,
-0.0110752182,
0.0733607933,
0.0084592281,
-0.0402894579,
0.01793015,
-0.0054723462,
-0.0403613336,
-0.0142265167,
0.0296330675,
-0.0189374872,
-0.0018369366,
0.0313052014,
0.0043676673,
0.0409812592,
0.0250502937,
-0.0173498262,
0.016735727,
0.0669664517,
0.0042083645,
0.0228668973,
-0.1031095684,
-0.050343167,
-0.0189852137,
0.0660398528,
-0.0303846393,
-0.0148613509,
-0.0394303761,
0.0078423824,
-0.0249618161,
0.0715183988,
-0.0177010316,
-0.0319582894,
-0.0501864515,
0.0122789554,
-0.0284431819,
0.0023495865,
0.0147479372,
-0.0023515783,
0.0121480776,
0.0103484476,
-0.0408852436,
-0.0047189686,
-0.0722109526,
0.0475805216,
-0.0119395107,
0.0326969065,
-0.0356580503,
-0.0435933843,
0.0225419309,
-0.0318910368,
0.01566232,
0.0785537958,
0.0535510778,
-0.0469266884,
-0.0555574372,
-0.0742068589,
0.0212540645,
-0.0135591859,
0.0328215137,
-0.0681932122,
0.0524077676,
0.0027535497,
-0.0159855243,
-0.0377546661,
0.0180696882,
0.0187042765,
-0.02116278,
0.0112030236,
-0.0261146463,
-0.0287553798,
-0.0205647573,
-0.0288179126,
-0.0962409526,
0.0258691814,
0.0221951474,
0.0285352413,
-0.0096157761,
0.0069619594,
-0.017186746,
0.0028456084,
0.0781163648,
-0.0103614032,
0.0176665485,
-0.0360063277,
-0.0260667987,
0.0689234063,
0.037639048,
0.0424560867,
-0.0807651281,
-0.0610057674,
0.008964981,
-0.0134272687,
0.0532738715,
0.0036314579,
0.0436073877,
-0.0805542767,
0.0081353206,
-0.0044488478,
-0.0749629363,
0.0326449908,
-0.0762346834,
0.009340019,
-0.0494041741,
0.0572504774,
0.002635797,
-0.0423519351,
0.0385967232,
0.0056089316,
0.0405607224,
0.0084055765,
0.0666665882,
0.0339604616,
0.0123744486,
0.0232008081,
0.0741083324,
-0.0060665864,
0.0069423243,
0.0059030745,
0.0444351211,
0.0405097455,
0.0801239237,
-0.0077417274,
-0.0247174073,
-0.0041687516,
-0.0168928225,
0.0197794456,
-0.0174722672,
-0.0084535023,
0.0118180811,
-0.0574883968,
-0.0294665974,
0.0094299633,
0.0028875256,
0.0190481972,
0.0326403752,
-0.0203154776,
-0.0000902434,
-0.0898954645,
-0.0148342727,
0.0503293648,
-0.012249724,
0.0300725903,
0.0112231039,
0.0221410859,
0.036267478,
0.0000688057,
0.0411801487,
0.0007981312,
0.0093836784,
-0.0293191057,
-0.0659580082,
0.0030402236,
-0.0108683435,
-0.0681842789,
0.0651319176,
-0.0448857248,
-0.0168812368,
0.0127691571,
-0.040768262,
-0.0182281528,
0.0281049497,
-0.0354075953,
0.0452061854,
-0.0311863963,
-0.0419385582,
0.0518534295,
-0.0104871057,
0.0128365848,
0.0688978806,
-0.0158174466,
0.0010393567,
0.0441011824,
-0.0540482216,
0.0294500645,
-0.0030479473,
0.0128108431,
-0.0400621518,
-0.0500907339,
-0.0470978506,
0.0149203772,
-0.028646715,
-0.0352544002,
0.0181195475,
-0.0268866718,
0.0083329966,
0.046938695,
-0.0116151236,
-0.0471630618,
0.0015145974,
0.0189693291,
-0.0254865531,
0.0025192294,
0.0169196352,
-0.0437049344,
0.0412485823,
0.0200647675,
-0.0201259702,
-0.064720042,
0.0062964028,
-0.0580506586,
-0.0491565056,
0.0587516427,
0.0206332952,
0.0170562994,
-0.0089835925,
0.004592136,
-0.0555354767,
0.0245686825,
-0.0288152192,
-0.0111115286,
-0.0063927155,
0.0003814427,
-0.0322600156,
0.0359847955,
-0.0381424092,
-0.0261484087,
0.0491485186,
0.0273842532,
-0.0306606553,
0.0118847853,
-0.0531347245,
0.0514083728,
-0.0117818797,
-0.0113659296,
-0.0010380198,
-0.0016422264,
0.0224949624,
-0.0259136427,
-0.0827599838,
0.0134497434,
-0.0052843723,
-0.0138976723,
-0.0174047388,
-0.0074552754,
0.0170247275,
0.027953526,
-0.048277922,
-0.0041005169,
0.1083982512,
0.0559877641,
0.0215778314,
-0.0218978096,
0.0169378631,
-0.0319522955,
0.0486549363,
0.0430224985,
0.0288072433,
0.019753227,
-0.044601202,
-0.0315956399,
-0.0062533724,
0.0165856127,
0.0053209821,
0.0110916337,
0.0036618451,
0.013002309,
0.0397666991,
-0.0030851604,
-0.0170698892,
-0.0134480437,
0.0149224149,
-0.003850657,
0.005314074,
-0.0170638748,
0.027990615,
-0.0263682362,
0.022957366,
0.0146682626,
-0.0037819196,
-0.0294096638,
-0.0258107018,
-0.0222598556,
0.0343996845,
-0.0297726672,
0.0357118733,
0.0168340914,
-0.0168185253,
0.052395422,
-0.00213977,
-0.0038246657,
-0.0307383966,
0.0297821779,
-0.0238541421,
-0.0390827693,
0.0004388451,
0.0265627019,
-0.0196258686,
-0.0385345817,
0.0445247404,
0.0452132151,
0.0117935995,
0.0136728585,
0.0435787216,
-0.0257021096,
-0.0012657244,
0.0209132452,
-0.0010133523,
-0.133701846,
0.0033342766,
0.0226982199,
-0.0076048016,
-0.0138684213,
-0.071727857,
0.0281120595,
-0.0697791055,
0.0144010372,
0.0115894368,
-0.0638795719,
-0.0504677258,
-0.044881247,
0.032547906,
-0.0340269469,
-0.0276294928,
0.0175762419,
-0.0131477546,
0.0102560762,
0.0011978579,
-0.0111756278,
-0.0186679922,
0.0241517797,
-0.0656855255,
0.0588391721,
-0.0187377986,
0.0128223943,
-0.0177827254,
-0.033847779,
-0.0183707941,
0.0156725291,
0.0164484028,
-0.0213343445,
0.0645750239,
0.0283752829,
-0.0069551463,
-0.0388676189,
0.0059108185,
-0.0515274443,
-0.0242772475,
0.0071620578,
0.1111903936,
0.0031675173,
-0.0479878075,
-0.0222814064,
0.0100049879,
-0.0376825854,
0.0574596599,
0.0037350014,
0.0298424419,
0.0212294124,
-0.0124928737,
0.0293930396,
-0.0459363796,
0.0051405635,
0.0215774365,
-0.0210829079,
-0.026066523,
-0.0347839408,
-0.0593241863,
0.0735788643,
0.0391563438,
0.0157017987,
0.0371599235,
0.0291049853,
-0.0631494299,
-0.0198878516,
0.0304145794,
-0.0389983132,
0.0019960559,
0.028041672,
0.0229965094,
-0.0625690147,
-0.0283531938,
-0.0260231178,
-0.00230078,
-0.0138616422,
-0.0349495858,
-0.024303088,
0.0602390282,
0.0162353031,
0.0417944714,
-0.0307833664,
0.0060189166,
0.0197132137,
0.0303578824,
0.0125044202,
0.0149957985,
0.0318958461,
-0.0400341451,
0.0070084692,
0.0090074167,
-0.0505362712,
0.0177531317,
-0.0036369755,
0.0842855126,
-0.0191166829,
0.0090302033,
0.0495338626,
0.0393528268,
0.014584139,
0.0199255124,
-0.0308002345,
-0.0303635653,
0.0130137941,
-0.0322668217,
0.0179798119,
-0.0195834413,
0.0020754235,
0.0388970375,
0.041496776,
-0.0144409426,
-0.0870290026,
0.0056455433,
0.014271602,
-0.0119683463,
-0.0983427316,
0.0339681506,
0.0006542833,
0.0403425433,
-0.0087254485,
-0.0407627821,
-0.0022153498,
-0.0137308063,
-0.0147725455,
-0.0276192538,
-0.003731413,
0.0469907001,
-0.0028884655,
-0.0664501265,
-0.0251701251,
-0.0234507807,
0.0059616147,
-0.0080212774,
-0.0148234824,
0.053517364,
0.0212977938,
-0.0047619715,
-0.0218101963,
0.0034701854,
0.0215666238,
0.0030801101,
-0.0330509283,
-0.0106751556,
0.0420771688,
0.0278679878,
0.0111724129,
-0.0138887949,
0.0465775393,
-0.0423218496,
0.10163939,
-0.0382022001,
-0.0250154249,
-0.0101664821,
-0.0366378911,
0.0072082328,
0.0460679978,
-0.03057882,
0.018313922,
-0.0523865968,
-0.0785299465,
0.0025083234,
0.0342971794,
-0.000530032,
-0.0039264346,
0.0185947828,
0.0105284527,
0.0447143354,
-0.0922848135,
0.0069419011,
-0.0112144332,
-0.0033142716,
-0.0341687277,
-0.0302615296,
-6.214750471e-33,
-0.0116731646,
-0.0094889347,
0.0455916971,
0.0345627554,
-0.0307112355,
-0.0458939113,
-0.0229153335,
-0.0381027162,
-0.0205973033,
0.0640159026,
-0.0076041683,
0.0187114235,
-0.0139233936,
-0.0114411721,
0.0418079905,
0.0060232026,
0.027478477,
0.0445816927,
0.0162022524,
-0.0220266115,
0.0129225841,
0.0159873236,
0.0253431555,
-0.0634167418,
-0.0191918481,
0.0687481984,
0.018849913,
0.0193847045,
-0.0537537336,
0.0487154163,
0.0170283467,
0.0606507137,
0.0378775522,
0.0221910849,
0.005900145,
-0.0391465947,
-0.0875099152,
-0.0874017254,
0.0542490296,
-0.0241436809,
-0.0385253578,
-0.0443049446,
0.0710705295,
-0.0049430123,
0.0559081063,
-0.0233025718,
0.0129088564,
-0.0307394061,
-0.0747014433,
-0.0379449949,
-0.0425864868,
0.0002991414,
0.0486533716,
-0.0041591045,
-0.0535591096,
-0.0118938359,
0.0047115097,
-0.0331072174,
-0.0716605261,
-0.022323966,
-0.0263355225,
-0.0040299105,
-0.0319492444,
-0.0277606286,
0.0093845464,
0.0252226125,
0.0126720518,
-0.0019069192,
-0.0114835231,
0.0269649625,
0.0114325732,
0.085024789,
0.0165270157,
0.0145700527,
0.0474140272,
-0.0054350961,
-0.0651676729,
-0.0019461465,
0.0319143236,
0.1130153537,
-0.0019101839,
0.0091619911,
-0.0468926057,
-0.0096951183,
-0.0337606221,
-0.0089570088,
-0.0369201191,
-0.0722387061,
-0.0106130308,
0.008239205,
0.030237902,
-0.0206145924,
-0.030529378,
-0.0146529339,
0.008741443,
0.0354685485,
0.0186452698,
-0.0042045205,
0.0022755903,
0.0175798815,
-0.035156738,
-0.0367646255,
0.0215207972,
-0.060907051,
0.0112385489,
0.0101911463,
0.0588596314,
0.0319811031,
-0.007121257,
-0.0321199186,
-0.0294329915,
-0.0299223065,
0.0467423908,
-0.0561405644,
0.0469877943,
0.0727535039,
-0.001925968,
-0.0206672791,
0.0433397554,
0.034774974,
-0.0395402871,
0.0390263796,
0.0473803468,
0.0115701202,
0.0175560284,
-0.0313573182,
-0.0226176865,
-0.0059515354,
0.0250282902,
-0.0672069266,
-0.0429943092,
0.0098864501,
2.797e-7,
0.0279699881,
0.0211187489,
0.0349137336,
0.0834112018,
-0.0162969045,
-0.0052941013,
0.0093211243,
-0.0232349448,
0.0214739926,
-0.0227531753,
0.0260751508,
0.0153689543,
-0.0242627226,
0.0354020223,
-0.0466181599,
-0.0028143772,
-0.0268460382,
-0.0300071631,
-0.0031382833,
-0.0102771968,
0.0566233657,
0.0664510503,
0.0910798237,
-0.0120346034,
-0.0005852118,
-0.0166958291,
0.0582825989,
0.0030224177,
0.0007386976,
-0.0259202775,
0.0724754706,
-0.0366746224,
0.0397990756,
0.0949073061,
0.0292195473,
0.0385082029,
0.0000236939,
-0.0067100939,
-0.0190440845,
0.0217712522,
-0.0143614449,
-0.0413786545,
0.0055885152,
-0.0122113796,
0.0522818007,
-0.0716555566,
-0.024573721,
0.0194416177,
-0.0617738441,
0.0094469907,
0.0314843543,
0.031350106,
-0.0000496297,
-0.021619834,
0.0165357385,
0.0388943665,
0.0139519451,
-0.0527496375,
0.0183285978,
0.0379279219,
-0.0177025218,
-0.0238020625,
0.0106585352,
-0.0205853879,
0.0200287644,
-0.0618155971,
-0.006443467,
2.350958396e-34,
0.0384589173,
-0.0329979807,
0.0338049382,
0.0097416267,
0.0168412887,
-0.0387960486,
-0.0307380427,
0.0101811346,
-0.0078977998,
-0.091184698,
-0.0260580312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01992v1 | Is Your Large Language Model Knowledgeable or a Choices-Only Cheater? | 2024-07-02T07:06:53 | 2024-07-02T07:06:53 | Nishant Balepur, Rachel Rudinger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work shows that large language models (LLMs) can answer
multiple-choice questions using only the choices, but does this mean that MCQA
leaderboard rankings of LLMs are largely influenced by abilities in
choices-only settings? To answer this, we use a contrast set that probes if
LLMs over-rely on choices-only shortcuts in MCQA. While previous works build
contrast sets via expensive human annotations or model-generated data which can
be biased, we employ graph mining to extract contrast sets from existing MCQA
datasets. We use our method on UnifiedQA, a group of six commonsense reasoning
datasets with high choices-only accuracy, to build an 820-question contrast
set. After validating our contrast set, we test 12 LLMs, finding that these
models do not exhibit reliance on choice-only shortcuts when given both the
question and choices. Thus, despite the susceptibility~of MCQA to high
choices-only accuracy, we argue that LLMs are not obtaining high ranks on MCQA
leaderboards just due to their ability to exploit choices-only shortcuts. | [
0.014815635,
0.0569116361,
-0.0217824429,
0.0384291336,
-0.0311317518,
0.0120606814,
-0.014575012,
0.0016540785,
0.0578058958,
-0.0323076136,
-0.0270014573,
0.0377001725,
-0.0075152772,
-0.0144553939,
0.0441082381,
-0.0044310191,
0.012817516,
-0.0538671538,
-0.0133769829,
-0.0311655495,
-0.0475129411,
0.0098626241,
-0.0012549537,
0.0171876103,
0.0465890095,
-0.0289543625,
0.0031017456,
-0.0300895218,
0.035678152,
-0.0144912675,
-0.0400287919,
0.0750090927,
-0.0173362568,
0.0111626312,
0.0000021524,
-0.0467880815,
0.011133315,
-0.0377447791,
-0.0495364033,
0.0267979968,
-0.0310103633,
0.0535872802,
0.0230882019,
0.0239331387,
-0.0504177511,
0.0214452296,
0.0319993943,
-0.0238555502,
0.0476681851,
0.0266059525,
0.0239924081,
0.0018073755,
-0.0025341799,
-0.0174911171,
-0.0132377082,
-0.0580422692,
0.0338013992,
0.0311660264,
0.0289208964,
0.0059372149,
-0.0441503562,
0.0066416753,
0.0212081596,
-0.0087724831,
-0.0122702951,
0.0492918156,
-0.0329510719,
0.0130077768,
0.0322328582,
0.098981671,
-0.0016464135,
-0.0165291205,
0.0053315787,
-0.0115291802,
0.0322051533,
0.0716012642,
-0.0447214879,
0.0208594166,
-0.0098786326,
-0.0096022077,
0.0353147797,
-0.0479401313,
0.0430469699,
0.014575026,
-0.0216424726,
0.0616595782,
0.0000805382,
0.0077364454,
0.0521370657,
0.0176054388,
-0.0523748137,
-0.0652490482,
0.0033493135,
0.0216715168,
-0.0732699186,
0.0228958149,
-0.0030861027,
0.0298701674,
0.0265748911,
-0.0228242818,
0.0330649391,
0.007581498,
0.0084436052,
0.0582121201,
0.0031867714,
0.0232214332,
0.0000997708,
0.0749606863,
-0.0428504981,
0.0012243036,
-0.0334353447,
-0.0000574738,
0.0129626142,
0.0223050285,
-0.0063664769,
0.0165795851,
-0.0515480451,
-0.0062110024,
-0.0313659012,
0.0366149768,
0.0112530226,
0.0029905757,
0.0292156525,
0.0124673853,
-0.0517965555,
0.0364520773,
-0.0335397087,
0.0290739629,
0.0374925397,
-0.0329022743,
0.0001739707,
-0.0215145927,
0.014784907,
-0.0240553077,
0.025377715,
0.0712836608,
-0.0113162939,
-0.034315642,
-0.0042907572,
-0.0091292793,
0.0035016439,
-0.0378330089,
0.0025647215,
-0.1102026552,
0.0105269747,
0.0429935791,
0.0047329627,
-0.020075798,
0.0065950677,
0.0307386369,
-0.0236271825,
0.0481809787,
-0.0051698303,
0.018334005,
0.0164650399,
-0.0069383327,
-0.0560178198,
0.0590959936,
-0.0043026004,
-0.026232563,
0.0377079509,
-0.0634423792,
-0.0174548626,
0.0451839268,
0.0058081741,
0.0145592252,
-0.0079496941,
0.0350695215,
-0.0006866183,
0.0047001177,
0.0134319626,
0.0281237736,
-0.042769067,
-0.0442266688,
0.0513667427,
0.0580360293,
0.0206563082,
-0.0019786139,
-0.0115299551,
-0.0121833654,
0.0459101237,
0.0168460347,
-0.0455030128,
0.0201770607,
-0.0281952973,
-0.0064947503,
0.0164809786,
0.0206749961,
-0.0109696016,
-0.0443749093,
-0.0043668407,
0.0056358264,
0.0244682711,
0.041505836,
0.0472665802,
-0.0055136206,
-0.0085454285,
0.0290765781,
0.0397919789,
-0.0157886595,
-0.0215710085,
-0.0541234352,
0.0353358313,
0.0341542512,
0.0626237988,
-0.0049435021,
-0.0286082812,
-0.0011137844,
-0.0208542459,
0.0055869916,
0.0448618457,
-0.0413463302,
-0.0189572386,
-0.0284175351,
-0.0250843596,
-0.0176362395,
0.0090542678,
-0.0030748835,
-0.0102456948,
-0.0101640187,
-0.0485433489,
-0.0613395348,
-0.0242730062,
-0.0066663371,
-0.0358173065,
-0.0039763195,
-0.0053996136,
-0.0035296385,
0.0256393775,
0.0071509127,
0.0057801362,
0.020527577,
0.0128538636,
-0.0191342179,
-0.0127227549,
-0.0162453577,
-0.0374895521,
-0.0433549732,
0.0339185521,
-0.0371701382,
-0.0446140654,
0.0905614197,
-0.0305853393,
-0.0286869258,
-0.0272993278,
-0.0076055392,
0.0265994221,
0.0191365425,
0.0081944922,
-0.0072951517,
-0.0195127632,
-0.0206698179,
0.120658733,
-0.0457893871,
0.0669741482,
0.0286784247,
0.0410600826,
0.0180632267,
-0.0297541432,
0.0280739535,
0.0348933451,
-0.000045803,
0.0163688231,
0.0248524286,
0.0218611974,
-0.0631438196,
0.0132037615,
-0.0781716555,
-0.006108257,
-0.0007240744,
0.0030915919,
0.0433248356,
-0.0374723561,
0.009102962,
0.0008168658,
-0.0300889015,
-0.0015645537,
0.0172560867,
0.0465842299,
0.0140972333,
0.018549053,
0.0167427491,
-0.0173786152,
-0.0508921407,
-0.0284916274,
0.0500010177,
-0.0110494429,
0.0672234371,
-0.0263970327,
0.0716263577,
-0.0438605621,
-0.0065993182,
-0.0243150406,
-0.0147806583,
0.0430717133,
-0.0161572471,
-0.0059550381,
0.0894834399,
-0.0162581969,
0.0166835152,
0.0925827697,
-0.0167840738,
-0.0319508053,
-0.0044395975,
0.0197362397,
-0.001715733,
-0.0596595444,
-0.0428485423,
-0.0230963491,
0.0656439736,
0.0019994152,
-0.0205107052,
-0.0073129861,
0.0274745598,
-0.0157399587,
0.0010699435,
-0.0666463152,
0.0249266289,
-0.0017374483,
0.0567000546,
-0.0049409615,
-0.0271354616,
0.0648234859,
0.0279715378,
0.0314252786,
-0.0414327569,
-0.0053545898,
-0.0230879318,
0.0189920347,
0.0085820686,
0.0033090985,
-0.0302598663,
-0.0213777535,
-0.0784818381,
-0.0763949975,
0.0475580879,
-0.0586392097,
0.0603371374,
-0.0418998711,
-0.0105867879,
-0.0144731347,
-0.0673335269,
-0.0265186783,
-0.0107932249,
-0.0630871952,
0.0154914269,
0.0477853082,
-0.0506409481,
0.0102216592,
-0.0492684469,
0.0176298823,
0.0174730923,
0.0038635668,
0.0054186541,
0.0122257415,
0.0690620095,
0.0488942526,
0.0359118842,
0.0584913082,
-0.0625812337,
0.049643822,
0.0703294426,
0.0515495315,
0.0238747094,
0.0479042158,
-0.0009900534,
0.0230309982,
-0.0155261569,
-0.0085313777,
0.0455718935,
0.0699849427,
-0.0260168947,
-0.0117867114,
0.096739769,
0.0386688448,
-0.0140475882,
0.0102969492,
-0.0196271185,
0.0239013936,
0.0385404117,
0.0214301124,
-0.0897610113,
-0.0222449005,
0.0008013863,
0.0293575861,
-0.0240852553,
-0.0592023097,
0.0204023104,
-0.1238797605,
0.0071079922,
0.0057760035,
-0.0630437881,
0.02094437,
-0.0595248304,
-0.0082429405,
-0.0297570247,
-0.001008921,
-0.0093023805,
0.0055367071,
0.0243978892,
0.0040337965,
0.0034983619,
-0.0416192301,
0.0728514642,
-0.0125640053,
0.0379389189,
0.0009562266,
0.0577803627,
-0.0568344444,
-0.0408287682,
0.0462187268,
-0.0501667187,
-0.0079942429,
-0.0238366555,
0.026841851,
0.0165540408,
-0.020532636,
-0.0495960601,
0.0458938666,
0.0104672676,
-0.0267493576,
0.0465773977,
0.0738192201,
0.0054780869,
-0.0601426922,
0.0140756546,
-0.0149454707,
-0.0352977104,
0.0465803817,
0.0393724553,
-0.0399913229,
-0.0006320159,
-0.0724126399,
-0.0134513332,
-0.0336154103,
-0.0834939778,
0.0407241583,
0.0443489812,
0.0376611501,
-0.0343389697,
-0.0278175641,
0.0785799325,
-0.0008202498,
-0.0200564414,
0.0440376177,
0.0075130388,
0.000052693,
-0.0225441679,
0.0239213482,
-0.0372562706,
-0.0022955665,
-0.0445140861,
-0.02688081,
0.0179252774,
-0.0182075165,
-0.0348335207,
-0.0257359035,
-0.0279248543,
-0.0462290831,
-0.0291526783,
0.038976144,
0.0218254086,
0.0140169458,
0.0053700823,
-0.0462498404,
0.0421699546,
0.0306013115,
-0.0042388677,
-0.005814577,
0.0085241282,
-0.0087569868,
-0.0090342006,
0.0241975244,
-0.0397288315,
-0.0167610012,
0.0317803212,
0.0631615743,
-0.0445820838,
0.0016221716,
0.036806915,
0.0105660902,
0.0158196446,
0.0271268003,
0.0282772463,
-0.0327925161,
0.0005922895,
-0.0263142083,
-0.0285519492,
0.0206083879,
-0.0207896326,
0.0336294807,
-0.0214104261,
0.0031579209,
-0.0181771796,
-0.0076131355,
0.036355488,
-0.0338602364,
0.0461001918,
0.0602926724,
0.0147913955,
0.0430471525,
-0.0365016684,
-0.023597382,
-0.0181810558,
0.0092191994,
0.0680273548,
0.0158195272,
0.0647353604,
0.0254749097,
-0.0359933116,
0.0345930234,
0.002490174,
-0.0653841943,
-0.0816645846,
0.0430757105,
0.0188407227,
0.0667945519,
-0.0227007288,
0.0153173842,
-0.0055286172,
-0.0298689194,
-0.0302230921,
-0.0107421512,
0.0111406744,
-0.0186549034,
0.0433449484,
0.0377024598,
0.0034076839,
0.0058660344,
0.0594592579,
0.0154534783,
0.0270795785,
0.0072323903,
-0.0185436439,
-0.0306027904,
-0.0378445573,
-0.017122604,
0.0350316986,
-0.0110076554,
0.0118699977,
-0.0824595019,
-0.091293022,
-0.0103767077,
0.0388159379,
-0.0018259848,
-0.0129017476,
-0.0141232479,
0.0380316488,
-0.0103684831,
-0.0532366894,
-0.0508953258,
0.0327570587,
-0.065681763,
0.0043929624,
0.0032894548,
-6.511101413e-33,
-0.0154452398,
-0.0705367848,
0.0193314888,
-0.0374132022,
0.0473923907,
-0.0109904585,
-0.0245176125,
-0.0053242724,
-0.0911660194,
0.0213640202,
-0.0318953246,
0.0276377928,
-0.0117944609,
0.0151974298,
0.0152904177,
-0.0260938294,
0.0133806691,
0.0033836488,
-0.0553966388,
0.0239192415,
0.0424707383,
-0.0248438213,
0.0570269078,
-0.0466372445,
-0.004229526,
-0.0102104964,
0.0284435693,
0.0264687203,
-0.0827240795,
0.0587021559,
0.0177342594,
0.0467659459,
0.0168052465,
-0.0362104997,
0.0152716981,
0.0011698036,
-0.0489419363,
-0.0490025952,
0.0303759631,
-0.0245767422,
-0.0260481387,
-0.0451354273,
0.0439821519,
0.0180206951,
-0.013989035,
-0.0511548743,
0.0331058018,
-0.0465212949,
-0.0180545077,
0.0230227429,
0.0254490767,
0.0125821624,
-0.0472509079,
0.0036056775,
-0.0707475096,
0.0496703424,
-0.0190830659,
0.0052821175,
-0.0537383743,
0.0397848897,
0.0443526506,
0.0064243898,
0.0579140261,
0.0113198794,
0.0252004117,
0.0535046756,
-0.0133322803,
0.0115733156,
0.0405276455,
-0.0145651447,
-0.0013527062,
0.0750882104,
0.0530061722,
0.0514326729,
0.01983881,
0.0001377165,
-0.0944894999,
0.0114701157,
-0.0141210807,
0.0200426001,
0.0195164252,
-0.0146926939,
-0.0460089818,
-0.0474303104,
-0.0536824241,
-0.0260197818,
-0.0311256442,
-0.0263600703,
0.0347951427,
-0.0381887071,
-0.0212654658,
-0.0197970346,
0.0168743301,
-0.0343437865,
-0.0660475269,
0.0571735464,
-0.0094638355,
0.0341474488,
-0.0112613728,
0.0049180859,
-0.0729426369,
0.0061472487,
-0.0097169532,
-0.013856628,
0.0269048922,
0.0356833264,
0.0101898741,
0.010342069,
-0.0474202819,
-0.0237729941,
-0.0330737717,
-0.0202771835,
-0.0161280017,
-0.0349998251,
0.0611947551,
-0.0163887274,
0.0146627892,
0.0455727242,
0.0112262256,
0.0095394487,
-0.0258671604,
0.0091036651,
-0.0261554047,
0.0047203973,
0.0148288812,
-0.0111862179,
-0.0502640828,
0.0515302941,
0.0276946221,
-0.0319887549,
-0.015065873,
-0.0112889558,
2.727e-7,
0.0430477858,
0.0469449349,
-0.0491508655,
0.0183686428,
0.0124375215,
0.0483589768,
-0.0451810732,
-0.0046320311,
0.0651205704,
-0.0057256902,
-0.0053588143,
0.0430654623,
0.0081464788,
0.0522137992,
-0.064087756,
0.0205446351,
-0.0477452837,
-0.0223854594,
-0.051478263,
-0.0171509199,
0.0538636409,
0.0442035161,
0.0184446685,
-0.0095271003,
-0.0029862628,
-0.0417392999,
0.0404041298,
-0.0449769795,
-0.0055499431,
-0.0252467375,
-0.0129537052,
-0.0130641703,
0.0168896746,
0.0619038045,
-0.0068291044,
0.008580585,
0.0187195633,
0.0472860932,
0.0055776248,
-0.0234628487,
-0.0088401493,
-0.0392500721,
0.0145219387,
-0.0585850254,
0.1049239635,
-0.0583351888,
-0.0534929708,
-0.0607253462,
-0.0195817929,
-0.0469986126,
0.0266271364,
-0.0238753837,
-0.0026489031,
-0.0163303204,
-0.0257179067,
0.0019758074,
0.0320223831,
-0.03320124,
-0.0256030597,
0.0379351266,
0.0145056732,
-0.1018742844,
-0.024358334,
-0.0172982514,
-0.0064262622,
-0.0469365418,
0.0037739235,
2.483167302e-34,
0.0079467008,
0.0040324437,
0.0586512871,
-0.0074649397,
0.0347209349,
-0.0273262188,
0.01961568,
-0.0032959899,
0.0490532182,
-0.0811658949,
0.0058848732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01976v1 | A Bounding Box is Worth One Token: Interleaving Layout and Text in a Large Language Model for Document Understanding | 2024-07-02T06:29:05 | 2024-07-02T06:29:05 | Jinghui Lu, Haiyang Yu, Yanjie Wang, Yongjie Ye, Jingqun Tang, Ziwei Yang, Binghong Wu, Qi Liu, Hao Feng, Han Wang, Hao Liu, Can Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM | Recently, many studies have demonstrated that exclusively incorporating
OCR-derived text and spatial layouts with large language models (LLMs) can be
highly effective for document understanding tasks. However, existing methods
that integrate spatial layouts with text have limitations, such as producing
overly long text sequences or failing to fully leverage the autoregressive
traits of LLMs. In this work, we introduce Interleaving Layout and Text in a
Large Language Model (LayTextLLM)} for document understanding. In particular,
LayTextLLM projects each bounding box to a single embedding and interleaves it
with text, efficiently avoiding long sequence issues while leveraging
autoregressive traits of LLMs. LayTextLLM not only streamlines the interaction
of layout and textual data but also shows enhanced performance in Key
Information Extraction (KIE) and Visual Question Answering (VQA). Comprehensive
benchmark evaluations reveal significant improvements, with a 27.0% increase on
KIE tasks and 24.1% on VQA tasks compared to previous state-of-the-art document
understanding MLLMs, as well as a 15.5% improvement over other SOTA OCR-based
LLMs on KIE tasks. | [
0.0169269051,
0.0124651771,
0.0333785266,
0.0655791014,
-0.0265173614,
0.0346932448,
0.0263839755,
0.0029712194,
0.0323761255,
-0.0348234698,
-0.0252453834,
-0.0053320229,
0.0179548543,
0.0680654272,
-0.0016830829,
-0.0430300497,
0.0189274047,
-0.078242667,
-0.0018269067,
0.012843864,
0.0185148939,
0.014090078,
0.0026245422,
-0.0302611776,
0.0058901091,
-0.054293938,
-0.0553316027,
0.0084578134,
0.0254240204,
-0.0196120646,
-0.0402260721,
0.0135871135,
0.0791732445,
0.049366083,
0.0000018882,
-0.008778628,
-0.0354111977,
0.02552047,
-0.0083571794,
0.0206645336,
0.0111457044,
-0.08137808,
0.0111954268,
-0.0282497238,
-0.013149905,
-0.043594759,
0.0275804717,
0.0704357475,
0.0251754895,
0.0505127497,
-0.0220115632,
-0.0466466621,
0.0173493698,
-0.0248280484,
0.024405878,
-0.0414257273,
0.0204152353,
0.0138063505,
0.028383296,
0.0232582148,
-0.0285644121,
0.0409677699,
0.0390960053,
-0.0354118794,
-0.0012724394,
0.0548179112,
-0.0181552637,
0.0011631727,
-0.0242678877,
0.0788290873,
-0.0238114391,
0.0103847673,
0.0259976666,
-0.0014880598,
-0.0003294597,
0.0130038047,
-0.0562974215,
0.00466367,
-0.0552128479,
-0.0016532243,
-0.0146661783,
0.0059462092,
0.0009804027,
-0.0034230093,
-0.0523898862,
0.037593089,
0.0065363566,
-0.0136614237,
-0.0159283932,
0.0139499689,
0.015285233,
-0.0354511663,
0.0405450463,
0.0704905093,
0.0175006129,
0.0318799131,
-0.0422011726,
-0.0026796951,
0.0112592364,
-0.0454022661,
-0.0014350767,
0.0034119349,
-0.0301204212,
0.0964829028,
-0.0464145057,
0.0943274572,
-0.0276314765,
0.0164468624,
-0.0625336841,
0.0039398256,
0.013740913,
-0.0340752751,
-0.0506004952,
0.0101517588,
-0.0559854805,
-0.0869045779,
0.0400858968,
0.0410452336,
0.0386203825,
0.028065728,
-0.007796593,
-0.0209923871,
-0.0010345229,
-0.0634290203,
0.0216161646,
0.0117869964,
-0.0160092618,
-0.0354413167,
-0.0283612162,
-0.0099159451,
-0.0127663175,
0.0345057063,
0.0350957327,
-0.022192983,
-0.0287603438,
0.0553144626,
-0.0231335834,
-0.0372782201,
-0.0207747053,
-0.015269028,
-0.0225138571,
-0.0420511365,
0.0573747531,
-0.054253906,
0.017473001,
-0.0009672331,
-0.0133648422,
-0.0280895382,
0.0089628557,
0.0123572825,
-0.0456739701,
0.059679091,
0.0057674544,
0.0035045051,
0.0411347263,
0.0182861388,
0.059021391,
0.0795239657,
0.0237592291,
0.0654740408,
0.0424578153,
0.0006822905,
-0.0007549031,
0.0730234012,
-0.012045824,
-0.026661003,
-0.0109177772,
0.0272445939,
0.0368325002,
0.0226985104,
0.0413581729,
0.0056840265,
-0.0352597609,
-0.0288867876,
0.0332292877,
0.0689911023,
0.0183885992,
-0.0040529161,
-0.0099474834,
0.0264581926,
0.003530334,
0.0078368718,
-0.0235089529,
0.0259432383,
0.0310215373,
0.0427532569,
0.0324316584,
0.0400258303,
-0.0184206609,
-0.0161848105,
-0.0387011617,
0.0115730641,
-0.0171955042,
0.0262837149,
0.0629331023,
0.0065287133,
-0.0475211516,
0.0647062659,
-0.0223567933,
-0.0203826129,
-0.0316936858,
-0.0075971088,
0.0428918041,
0.0614923425,
0.0528657399,
-0.0266259294,
-0.032359615,
0.0171097685,
0.0360651948,
0.0685560033,
0.0148248412,
-0.0074039553,
0.0113327196,
-0.0672181249,
-0.0429924466,
-0.0055170241,
-0.0148838721,
0.0075350651,
0.0565406308,
0.0108918333,
0.0188732073,
-0.0624718852,
-0.0170427002,
0.0263277926,
-0.02018556,
-0.0309609249,
-0.0552648902,
0.0236387681,
-0.0078113894,
0.0102703823,
-0.004477934,
-0.0066661369,
0.0401038006,
-0.0439998582,
0.0327655897,
-0.0127816861,
-0.0442269109,
-0.056048803,
0.0102772657,
0.0023990399,
-0.0310168788,
-0.012148126,
-0.0481394082,
-0.0181225426,
-0.0462221578,
-0.036161039,
0.0241258889,
-0.0104598003,
-0.0212727655,
0.0260380208,
0.0038444132,
-0.0654498115,
0.0436833948,
-0.0178068597,
-0.0067906724,
-0.0060605886,
-0.0134274038,
0.0190504864,
-0.0273769684,
0.0081643919,
0.023000611,
0.0017819864,
-0.0437522195,
-0.0256031621,
0.0332597122,
-0.0454362221,
-0.049520202,
-0.0844176412,
-0.0022339192,
-0.0317207798,
0.0238568485,
0.0391794965,
0.0028364572,
-0.0269905571,
-0.0563242547,
-0.0491552986,
-0.0365397893,
0.0143572669,
-0.0074988143,
0.0282901768,
0.0033472429,
0.0167932473,
0.0034453555,
-0.0199203249,
0.0079580871,
0.054568667,
0.038664721,
-0.0501868613,
-0.0387066416,
0.0152805205,
0.0045865658,
0.0037079754,
-0.0235706698,
0.0084281238,
0.0087007321,
-0.0497618429,
0.0315329023,
0.1078672484,
0.0098143211,
0.0254155956,
-0.0008493558,
-0.0491997451,
-0.0460912362,
0.0099627702,
0.00992803,
0.0188653916,
0.015992241,
-0.0268255901,
-0.021438336,
0.0434514806,
-0.0398387611,
0.0318696909,
-0.0135260094,
-0.0082200952,
-0.001523401,
-0.0049878764,
-0.065240398,
-0.0016395699,
0.0294163711,
0.0435269922,
-0.0572077222,
-0.0365935005,
0.0253611915,
-0.0667636916,
-0.0277711023,
-0.0255095139,
0.0303459838,
-0.0827063248,
0.0728069097,
0.0223543514,
0.0012755451,
-0.0324153379,
-0.0392158329,
0.0002065255,
0.0063530225,
-0.0300442856,
-0.0430656485,
0.039064806,
-0.0589666404,
0.049836874,
-0.0329627916,
-0.0216608532,
-0.008234811,
-0.0201169066,
-0.0208356492,
-0.0382436253,
-0.0399702601,
-0.0383215621,
-0.0188230034,
0.0920736939,
0.0234410521,
0.0758653581,
-0.0471664891,
0.010122898,
-0.0320357196,
0.0936743692,
0.0760187358,
0.0242044348,
-0.021793332,
-0.0458449312,
0.0243511423,
0.0517073795,
-0.0198108312,
-0.0026664829,
0.0068755257,
0.0319712944,
0.0267516244,
-0.0052090264,
0.0079639023,
-0.0226308741,
0.0229788553,
-0.1138326824,
-0.0501323491,
0.113342911,
0.0368976519,
-0.0417835005,
-0.0896421149,
-0.0660296306,
0.0600779131,
0.0015017629,
0.0272047296,
-0.0634041354,
-0.0259034391,
0.0005612712,
-0.0128237978,
0.0546409301,
-0.0022062771,
-0.0095319748,
-0.0733663663,
0.0604832172,
0.0134008462,
-0.0795618817,
-0.0698472038,
-0.0120433234,
-0.0227034241,
0.0322746709,
-0.0066589732,
0.0150308087,
-0.0357144326,
-0.0178093556,
-0.0100739468,
-0.0359802619,
0.0185918156,
-0.0182815287,
-0.0097204549,
-0.013722566,
0.0382855758,
0.0420644581,
0.0218468532,
-0.0096196765,
0.0378433242,
0.026523903,
0.0210667159,
-0.0358656235,
0.0608093366,
-0.0059793419,
-0.0056306506,
-0.0287406985,
0.0279731769,
-0.0467792265,
-0.0038835569,
0.0124166515,
0.0282430444,
-0.0071885623,
0.0005709224,
-0.0137765827,
0.0069290274,
-0.0296703689,
0.0541028269,
0.0390951112,
0.0097638164,
-0.0815579593,
-0.0310196038,
0.0193606671,
-0.0386555865,
0.0026227571,
0.0123446183,
-0.0369199775,
-0.0254628323,
-0.041205287,
-0.0349373743,
0.0527453087,
0.0375236645,
-0.0061909272,
-0.0034230594,
-0.0111213969,
-0.0295258295,
-0.0617481433,
0.0415245816,
-0.0296805073,
-0.0040539843,
-0.0439136662,
0.0433780327,
0.0288096052,
-0.0466343574,
-0.0210692007,
0.0110237999,
-0.0720926747,
-0.0165918358,
0.0148235764,
0.026396621,
0.0202394798,
0.0743269399,
-0.0020641114,
-0.0085925395,
0.044218298,
0.0024198985,
0.0148302736,
-0.0124822287,
0.0006713833,
0.0132976202,
-0.0049643861,
0.00224885,
-0.0315685384,
-0.0084978547,
0.0001035755,
0.0049965088,
-0.0467713624,
-0.010934962,
-0.0221489482,
-0.0014404138,
-0.0021673462,
0.0088426899,
0.0143428324,
-0.0120886154,
0.0536792576,
-0.0132326419,
-0.0050707478,
-0.0361704268,
0.0327580012,
0.0208096635,
-0.0038243828,
0.0009549868,
0.0482572727,
0.0326480791,
0.0189784206,
-0.0217392445,
0.0140052941,
0.0109129837,
-0.0123791769,
0.019000113,
-0.0067606033,
-0.0119311567,
0.0429263301,
-0.0265401639,
0.0561728179,
-0.0003083,
0.0422885194,
0.0223397333,
-0.0343937948,
-0.0226339456,
0.052574303,
-0.0706011057,
-0.0463050939,
-0.0119105792,
0.0372257829,
0.035911575,
-0.0283728056,
0.0370410196,
-0.0018746797,
-0.0240187887,
0.010642021,
-0.0064217062,
0.0398144759,
-0.025205791,
-0.0018350015,
0.0543944165,
0.0086205741,
-0.0162890535,
0.0690425634,
0.0532200783,
0.0102687655,
0.0112363342,
-0.0339567214,
-0.0403240994,
-0.0096324058,
0.049433846,
0.008887602,
-0.018495949,
-0.0061409799,
-0.0173171088,
-0.0273377206,
0.0527799316,
0.0195652489,
-0.0360877812,
0.0262824893,
0.0082704062,
0.0493161045,
0.0235839654,
-0.009181384,
-0.0319964513,
0.037975125,
-0.0092184572,
-0.0460089557,
0.0271687005,
-5.880821546e-33,
-0.0399190001,
-0.063619867,
0.0311162304,
0.0085082762,
-0.0375215448,
0.0500509068,
-0.0125610698,
-0.0363652036,
0.0149461962,
0.0021014083,
-0.0149986092,
0.0002663455,
0.0378726162,
0.0391466618,
-0.0270140357,
-0.0189842228,
0.0077903224,
0.0049015055,
-0.011838533,
0.0040440517,
-0.0011695988,
0.0560831241,
0.0055990517,
-0.00607232,
0.010039364,
-0.0027970786,
0.0292681511,
0.024906477,
0.0038586238,
0.0417339876,
-0.0279777441,
-0.0245816428,
0.0473069511,
0.0095387772,
-0.0197634455,
0.0874585509,
-0.1262048185,
0.0103319092,
0.0095923422,
0.0561284199,
-0.0230630096,
-0.0210042559,
0.0185434315,
-0.0273539349,
0.0470424853,
-0.0463368148,
0.0390404463,
-0.0204540864,
-0.0604972169,
0.000522927,
-0.0508440025,
0.0349623486,
-0.0035000672,
-0.0098136794,
0.0796393901,
0.0098944446,
0.0163061358,
0.0579067692,
-0.0611429103,
-0.0242809374,
0.0331986099,
0.0403929725,
0.0491467416,
0.0570197366,
0.0082495334,
0.0219649579,
-0.0098626465,
-0.0252772905,
-0.0605225638,
-0.009269977,
0.0124598052,
-0.0012728763,
0.0029850369,
0.0075147161,
0.0351860635,
0.0590603426,
-0.0408177301,
0.0336971916,
-0.0249288585,
0.0424497388,
0.0158406645,
0.0108607654,
-0.0233525541,
0.0047316379,
-0.0127682025,
0.010963277,
-0.0310062952,
0.0234321449,
0.0398274735,
0.0220614634,
-0.0122185843,
-0.0090761278,
0.0593251996,
-0.0100976676,
-0.0107217673,
0.0288767833,
0.022668492,
0.0408072658,
-0.0343300141,
0.0274628308,
-0.0260669682,
-0.021188233,
0.0070993681,
0.0023303162,
-0.0383643918,
-0.0183874946,
0.0466165468,
-0.0004084623,
-0.0517019443,
-0.0139583508,
-0.043716535,
-0.0121414596,
0.0023068576,
0.0294840448,
0.0250151008,
-0.0258696824,
-0.0132562183,
0.0565468371,
-0.0035215663,
-0.006123866,
-0.0039115367,
-0.0281206276,
-0.0293492209,
0.0050498182,
0.0011602622,
0.0173316561,
-0.0122253951,
0.0067063649,
0.003276557,
-0.0533261932,
0.0323999748,
0.0680957139,
2.431e-7,
0.0507573932,
0.0335777923,
0.0786633268,
0.0236987341,
0.0183598362,
-0.0026479219,
-0.00520259,
-0.0095103784,
-0.0070444532,
-0.0123484582,
0.0123920031,
0.0598003939,
0.0678609312,
-0.0169048999,
-0.0918767825,
0.0291638952,
-0.0398263037,
-0.0407973602,
-0.0806785226,
-0.0291514695,
0.0522413589,
0.0477577411,
-0.0419846289,
-0.0232831351,
0.0180821083,
-0.0524803512,
0.0471824966,
-0.0143355997,
0.0441107601,
0.0035543097,
0.0089113628,
-0.0125133349,
-0.0246083178,
0.0214098953,
0.0190634448,
0.0038933672,
0.0552410148,
0.0594923683,
0.0076312535,
0.0037347581,
-0.0075476407,
-0.0271519125,
-0.0280210525,
-0.0914925858,
0.092924796,
-0.025104396,
0.0114493072,
-0.0532806814,
-0.0303498097,
-0.0356957391,
-0.0110692745,
0.002179483,
0.0111787543,
0.0669819266,
0.035565123,
-0.0710839927,
0.0208343528,
-0.090915896,
-0.0387729853,
-0.0172794126,
-0.0309119504,
0.0397119708,
-0.0899585634,
0.0047358265,
0.0024283978,
-0.0468282811,
-0.0584304929,
2.362641937e-34,
0.0182050131,
-0.0128383758,
-0.0218526591,
0.0779515654,
0.0333170332,
-0.0328870155,
-0.0351658277,
0.0065799654,
-0.0314929523,
-0.0917120948,
0.0260019396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01965v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01965v1 | AdaCQR: Enhancing Query Reformulation for Conversational Search via Sparse and Dense Retrieval Alignment | 2024-07-02T05:50:16 | 2024-07-02T05:50:16 | Yilong Lai, Jialong Wu, Congzhi Zhang, Haowen Sun, Deyu Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Conversational Query Reformulation (CQR) has significantly advanced in
addressing the challenges of conversational search, particularly those stemming
from the latent user intent and the need for historical context. Recent works
aimed to boost the performance of CRQ through alignment. However, they are
designed for one specific retrieval system, which potentially results in poor
generalization. To overcome this limitation, we present a novel framework
AdaCQR. By aligning reformulation models with both term-based and
semantic-based retrieval systems, AdaCQR enhances the generalizability of
information-seeking queries across diverse retrieval environments through a
dual-phase training strategy. We also developed two effective approaches for
acquiring superior labels and diverse input candidates, boosting the efficiency
and robustness of the framework. Experimental evaluations on the TopiOCQA and
QReCC datasets demonstrate that AdaCQR significantly outperforms existing
methods, offering both quantitative and qualitative improvements in
conversational query reformulation. | [
0.0602645688,
0.0585205965,
0.0002067546,
-0.0061052437,
0.005690115,
-0.025216097,
-0.0266301483,
0.0194550641,
-0.0340745337,
-0.0275153406,
-0.0590605661,
-0.0430897512,
-0.0362620428,
0.024169771,
0.0022890929,
-0.0399931818,
0.0219567697,
0.029296115,
-0.0128716715,
0.0539651662,
0.0402101353,
0.0040415698,
0.013956883,
0.0340095162,
-0.0068666986,
0.0173269473,
-0.0618823059,
0.0557877608,
-0.0254076105,
-0.0232432857,
0.0570914112,
0.0605922304,
0.0448512286,
0.0631563365,
0.0000016028,
-0.030610621,
-0.0249988772,
-0.0150928898,
-0.0217218082,
0.0082149869,
0.028176384,
0.045915924,
0.0584366396,
0.0224164911,
-0.0486748442,
-0.0042229174,
0.0451100096,
0.080994457,
0.0467173867,
0.0792297199,
-0.0016615572,
-0.0179224052,
-0.0214737207,
-0.0186066311,
0.0458084047,
-0.0802856237,
0.0072870688,
0.0057488242,
0.036145661,
0.0478416644,
0.0208221357,
0.0273590069,
-0.0452242009,
-0.0495097078,
0.0562287793,
-0.0038170349,
-0.0661038011,
0.0000351376,
0.0086506233,
0.0729190633,
0.0390933752,
-0.007829411,
-0.0241137445,
0.046117425,
-0.0046198587,
-0.0187132433,
-0.0636628419,
-0.0521965511,
-0.0249740742,
-0.0116748866,
-0.0457258262,
0.011361666,
0.0176618155,
0.0040415325,
-0.0295886155,
0.0479336679,
0.0090641975,
-0.0618997626,
0.0162754506,
-0.0135467099,
-0.0025791277,
-0.0259463005,
-0.0054663341,
0.0065597212,
-0.0937520191,
0.0258925073,
-0.0037952613,
0.0099650742,
0.0160125345,
-0.0232515037,
-0.0240106061,
0.0196010265,
0.0096902447,
0.0672991872,
0.0208816212,
0.0489145815,
0.0019823625,
-0.0183427501,
-0.0573286675,
-0.0299746245,
-0.0671581775,
-0.0228485521,
-0.0638033226,
0.0371430293,
-0.0611002184,
-0.0168601125,
-0.0294901077,
0.0764392316,
0.0498943441,
-0.0485316589,
0.0130231408,
0.0300876331,
-0.0637669861,
0.0385331362,
-0.0420006774,
0.0229666568,
-0.0178531129,
0.0031655794,
0.0371566862,
-0.0652270392,
-0.020198483,
0.0195610318,
0.0315346718,
-0.0560079105,
-0.0239604451,
-0.0203842409,
-0.0153295808,
-0.0506511852,
-0.0070842789,
-0.0211932734,
0.0071338736,
0.0029253138,
-0.0330312587,
-0.0001015132,
0.0511645526,
-0.0420570411,
-0.0300770719,
-0.0152890477,
-0.0024412279,
0.0449819937,
-0.0204247758,
0.0677807927,
-0.0248330273,
0.0032870723,
0.0595559292,
0.0242604967,
0.0257238224,
0.0726995319,
-0.0193814822,
0.028023798,
0.058046557,
0.0019122883,
0.0101575954,
-0.016663298,
-0.0006776064,
0.0097765354,
-0.017734766,
0.0698797032,
-0.0049627977,
0.0607556254,
0.0142104533,
0.0468995832,
-0.055189874,
-0.0036456594,
0.0198343396,
0.0359196477,
0.0243587978,
-0.0295202937,
0.0060579213,
0.0336709358,
-0.0174239986,
-0.0148531068,
-0.0343086571,
0.0161164943,
-0.0254327916,
-0.0032934903,
0.0534692332,
-0.018049052,
-0.0518086441,
-0.0432951972,
0.017565757,
0.0398581214,
-0.0321174897,
0.0151400566,
-0.000429024,
0.0101944804,
-0.0383331589,
0.0185164977,
0.0107771615,
-0.0436111838,
-0.0035638055,
-0.0313683562,
-0.0064662481,
0.0457641371,
0.0704651773,
-0.0477877893,
-0.0395427532,
-0.0034404073,
0.000717524,
0.0034597977,
0.0346095823,
-0.0195901785,
0.0274628419,
-0.048692856,
-0.0610263981,
0.0086109899,
0.0073522558,
-0.0010666846,
0.037423037,
-0.0005579576,
0.0164400563,
-0.0324412361,
0.0037269171,
0.0161951724,
0.0254306216,
-0.0430136956,
0.0319590308,
0.0082582701,
0.0074938922,
0.0330037959,
0.0038644895,
0.0202617757,
0.0460700728,
0.0384775251,
-0.0231302474,
-0.0027826375,
-0.0360797271,
-0.0461932831,
-0.0013305878,
0.002098084,
0.0235609598,
-0.0139474571,
-0.0268581025,
-0.0448932499,
-0.0111223077,
-0.033489611,
0.0525205471,
-0.0531229116,
0.025073288,
0.0064989082,
-0.0204573981,
-0.0713803321,
0.0363218784,
0.0261953603,
-0.0048865578,
0.0151661448,
0.00167606,
0.0025080075,
-0.0725499913,
-0.034525238,
-0.0018877308,
-0.0055938908,
-0.0131700374,
0.0350226462,
0.0147380764,
-0.0677918121,
0.0077904323,
-0.1214678958,
0.0257538576,
-0.0242684558,
-0.0242597722,
0.0187479649,
0.0775702745,
0.0077119814,
-0.0186776221,
-0.0587983429,
-0.027961744,
-0.0015697295,
0.0426483564,
0.0327946767,
0.0770657435,
-0.0492986813,
-0.0604608692,
-0.0088451784,
0.0305933245,
0.0299898423,
-0.0120415771,
-0.0137641933,
-0.0117219323,
0.0045688893,
-0.0501733311,
0.0282584019,
-0.032309413,
0.0155173643,
0.0009884867,
-0.0485037416,
-0.0035391918,
0.0502774976,
0.0467671379,
0.0032721311,
-0.0250462703,
0.0114763258,
-0.0756457001,
0.0384675786,
-0.0354492813,
-0.0486010462,
-0.0209222175,
-0.0508929268,
0.0600249916,
-0.0006066607,
-0.0268354751,
0.0429641157,
-0.0507225245,
-0.0170928426,
0.0296332669,
-0.0418361686,
-0.0987284184,
0.0122438744,
0.0140630407,
0.0373255983,
-0.0207292642,
-0.0346176624,
0.0675089136,
0.0107485233,
-0.030887343,
-0.025626041,
-0.0326994434,
-0.0320826098,
0.0505167395,
-0.0352287851,
0.0152067821,
0.0103651881,
-0.0565775409,
-0.0399634279,
-0.04194507,
0.0196505692,
-0.0332372822,
0.0576414354,
-0.0187519025,
0.0213686936,
0.0449545272,
-0.0649944916,
-0.0298514459,
-0.0248163566,
0.0159546342,
0.0171043705,
0.0116810901,
-0.036674954,
-0.068293266,
0.0353236087,
-0.0166216344,
0.0275276974,
-0.0086619267,
-0.042501498,
0.021755714,
0.03338705,
0.0710631311,
-0.0022062978,
-0.0345772132,
0.0253454801,
0.0251087192,
0.0231731962,
0.0604108013,
-0.0646119639,
0.0307621397,
-0.0411782749,
0.0422804616,
-0.0220626146,
-0.0093708234,
-0.0205767378,
0.0275711678,
0.0276521351,
-0.0519919507,
0.0941823199,
0.0346915722,
-0.0441695675,
-0.0219551548,
-0.0278427899,
0.0534933284,
0.0305285174,
0.0397899412,
-0.0434065014,
-0.0199530739,
-0.0004111696,
0.0741364583,
-0.0029551378,
-0.0243056975,
-0.0100848647,
-0.0644960776,
0.0090204477,
-0.0256579015,
-0.0305843912,
-0.0078316024,
-0.0484421812,
0.0198658574,
-0.0370408781,
0.0156097934,
0.0344373398,
-0.0219598617,
0.004772671,
0.0102063399,
0.014205494,
-0.0264049005,
-0.0133964308,
-0.0213027578,
0.0056174994,
0.0478962362,
0.0314713307,
0.065263249,
-0.0079865484,
0.0252655074,
-0.0176286995,
0.0006702715,
-0.0274212826,
0.0294516534,
-0.0567494668,
0.025861524,
-0.017866157,
-0.0111775668,
0.0162803084,
0.0161365215,
-0.0011811298,
0.0260606166,
-0.0420261621,
0.0618704855,
-0.0166303832,
-0.010871035,
0.0083025917,
0.096396476,
0.0184818953,
0.0293175504,
-0.0216551777,
-0.0227312259,
0.0058896616,
-0.0261045322,
-0.0188637171,
-0.0185383689,
-0.0123330774,
0.01959599,
-0.0346525982,
-0.0443898216,
0.0077840784,
0.0221919678,
-0.0324146524,
0.0285429563,
-0.032809034,
0.0178332329,
-0.0278768539,
0.0158823226,
-0.0151222358,
-0.0010585315,
-0.0557641275,
-0.0027377438,
0.02095774,
-0.0397186205,
-0.0033668024,
-0.0147346547,
-0.028035026,
-0.0423038714,
-0.0147802429,
0.0049377708,
0.0157790817,
0.0486360639,
-0.0171530638,
-0.0346879475,
-0.0077604386,
0.0599559918,
0.0042261207,
-0.016039215,
-0.0029111204,
0.0221602581,
-0.0147205926,
0.0469439253,
-0.0679488108,
-0.0173633862,
-0.0268041492,
0.0572790019,
-0.0527167432,
-0.0564532913,
0.0502116755,
0.0150704905,
0.0581829995,
0.0075299856,
-0.007177915,
-0.0159229282,
0.0427572653,
-0.0355377048,
-0.0376293547,
-0.0265314225,
0.0092271883,
0.0110234274,
-0.0212777462,
0.0099333823,
0.0219760891,
-0.0768456981,
0.0733141005,
-0.0686259791,
-0.0242889412,
-0.0065712775,
-0.0319948979,
0.044017937,
-0.0053060283,
-0.0056426027,
0.0409564711,
0.0288338922,
0.0531203486,
-0.0339683108,
0.0236620307,
0.0318026654,
-0.0235552508,
0.0192550309,
0.0376345217,
-0.1126436293,
-0.0400317274,
-0.024150135,
0.004433657,
0.0128164263,
-0.0086081317,
0.0027471287,
0.0119109955,
-0.0014260479,
-0.0167855173,
0.0177886337,
0.0304502286,
-0.0200737752,
0.0490458123,
0.0402416214,
-0.0056340587,
0.0245853215,
0.0413849689,
-0.0225081686,
0.0422441773,
-0.0413718633,
-0.0513037667,
-0.0237835757,
-0.0219266471,
0.0757506937,
0.0529975444,
-0.0432123132,
-0.0394575559,
-0.0002887333,
0.0050707245,
0.0176415667,
-0.0572301187,
-0.0292873401,
-0.0082936203,
0.0834333375,
0.0969990045,
0.0071550938,
-0.0322180688,
-0.0320342146,
-0.0074180309,
-0.0187826175,
-0.0210951604,
-0.0313028097,
-6.061964858e-33,
-0.0019323711,
0.0139728719,
0.0326893367,
-0.0240056776,
-0.0530437678,
-0.002779013,
-0.0031188445,
-0.0240392722,
-0.0362937599,
-0.0189534649,
-0.034298066,
0.0413490683,
0.0093807811,
0.0188670345,
-0.0359209813,
-0.0068058302,
0.0666247979,
0.0093571246,
-0.0250496529,
0.0312104281,
0.0269615371,
0.058220014,
0.0154270856,
-0.0642941371,
0.0232177973,
-0.0093640415,
-0.0042515006,
0.0855839849,
0.0553382002,
0.0568249412,
0.0075942078,
0.0196993854,
0.0222990252,
-0.0099516027,
0.038129136,
0.0031539029,
-0.0530953109,
0.0008056819,
0.0333868898,
-0.0001259276,
-0.0132484464,
0.0023314902,
0.0085129691,
-0.0324751474,
0.0074835774,
0.0144530935,
0.0075167776,
0.0151867922,
-0.0469669215,
-0.0321955234,
0.0082329009,
0.0213456657,
-0.0165848453,
0.0020635931,
-0.0335575379,
0.0869784877,
0.0274018999,
0.0424296632,
-0.0162074883,
0.0482808463,
-0.03538974,
0.0527454875,
0.0135900751,
0.0638935864,
-0.0123568559,
0.0231306236,
0.0256036073,
0.013968952,
-0.0062531163,
-0.0416716002,
-0.0161979143,
0.0360405073,
-0.0231534895,
0.0381197892,
0.0053320816,
0.0125357667,
-0.0219854601,
0.0387928449,
-0.0063317404,
0.0364031754,
-0.0057054814,
0.052347675,
-0.0810596794,
-0.010191041,
-0.0254537538,
0.0543701388,
-0.0524492525,
0.0091054635,
0.0495931059,
0.0584170893,
0.0272382386,
0.0095245875,
0.003827414,
-0.0000711384,
0.010970463,
0.0114770439,
0.0051463144,
-0.0370627046,
-0.0049095689,
-0.0000100551,
-0.0226584077,
-0.0092400108,
0.0581969991,
0.0042860452,
-0.0286298022,
-0.0011647273,
0.0140325669,
-0.0054317191,
-0.0410112105,
-0.0211988688,
0.0086752949,
-0.0008385173,
-0.0615557395,
-0.0089750933,
0.0055123512,
0.0395711288,
-0.0141780451,
0.0637864843,
0.0338831134,
0.0357253738,
-0.0428919829,
-0.10587015,
0.0340164825,
0.0019212842,
0.0228023008,
0.0258715469,
0.0109897563,
-0.0028009829,
0.0088151386,
-0.040816132,
-0.0190429892,
0.0196392275,
2.577e-7,
0.0147891017,
0.0184656288,
-0.0105323764,
0.0347993746,
-0.0275521632,
0.0075669824,
0.0137996301,
0.0253081731,
0.0178126339,
-0.0218396299,
0.0520835333,
0.0057373117,
-0.0045679067,
-0.0066201966,
-0.0950818062,
-0.0925228521,
-0.0594455861,
-0.061607454,
-0.0516845174,
-0.0249552578,
0.0605645329,
0.0985139012,
-0.0055707307,
0.0012988183,
-0.0127749946,
-0.0393641107,
0.0274204779,
-0.0039690086,
-0.0271306783,
0.0368405543,
0.0396496467,
0.0053682756,
0.0135288108,
-0.0289275181,
-0.0197374579,
0.0212573186,
0.0275261365,
0.0528654084,
-0.028371321,
-0.0503211021,
-0.0262098014,
0.0114349965,
0.0052398522,
-0.0265544876,
0.0493129082,
0.0178067796,
0.0282258838,
0.030404456,
-0.0253967568,
0.0191462077,
0.0405306555,
-0.0293241423,
-0.0295373052,
-0.0031168873,
0.0188958719,
0.0507594533,
0.0013564172,
-0.0963776484,
0.0218866598,
-0.008460165,
-0.0350856185,
-0.0472223386,
-0.0446070097,
0.0015263438,
-0.015523307,
-0.0138623156,
0.0095601361,
2.164082804e-34,
0.0539974459,
0.0342553854,
0.0072011617,
0.0285820812,
0.0393484905,
-0.0153009398,
0.0023116174,
0.0053110532,
0.0478026457,
-0.1278087646,
-0.005669022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01964v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01964v2 | Enabling Discriminative Reasoning in LLMs for Legal Judgment Prediction | 2024-07-02T05:43:15 | 2024-07-03T02:25:23 | Chenlong Deng, Kelong Mao, Yuyao Zhang, Zhicheng Dou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Legal judgment prediction is essential for enhancing judicial efficiency. In
this work, we identify that existing large language models (LLMs) underperform
in this domain due to challenges in understanding case complexities and
distinguishing between similar charges. To adapt LLMs for effective legal
judgment prediction, we introduce the Ask-Discriminate-Predict (ADAPT)
reasoning framework inspired by human judicial reasoning. ADAPT involves
decomposing case facts, discriminating among potential charges, and predicting
the final judgment. We further enhance LLMs through fine-tuning with multi-task
synthetic trajectories to improve legal judgment prediction accuracy and
efficiency under our ADAPT framework. Extensive experiments conducted on two
widely-used datasets demonstrate the superior performance of our framework in
legal judgment prediction, particularly when dealing with complex and confusing
charges. | [
0.0623039864,
0.0395288467,
-0.0137967551,
0.0375402607,
-0.052101817,
0.0196380261,
0.0191434864,
0.0306138545,
0.024111595,
-0.083081156,
-0.0370316021,
-0.0551199168,
-0.037026722,
-0.0109718088,
-0.0128628891,
-0.0483716018,
0.0562874675,
-0.0238462258,
0.1033280864,
0.0102687851,
0.0431481563,
0.0136377243,
0.0168689582,
0.0067897909,
-0.0306677222,
-0.024944203,
0.0129881529,
-0.0273942538,
0.0007809245,
-0.0054802685,
0.0240766909,
0.0972041786,
0.0288525503,
0.0364087336,
0.0000015996,
-0.0562489294,
0.0404395647,
-0.0430241153,
-0.0273355711,
0.0160896126,
0.0199169982,
0.0018901346,
0.0159751549,
0.0024797653,
-0.0623331778,
-0.0067496775,
-0.0314395986,
0.0302904621,
0.0264797751,
0.0972861871,
0.0104298871,
-0.0676005185,
0.0055651967,
-0.0541448928,
0.0028910229,
-0.0454675294,
0.0311172325,
0.0230655689,
0.0155634042,
-0.0348487198,
0.0154439164,
-0.0219251104,
0.0304421671,
0.0010725221,
-0.0204960871,
0.0260151234,
-0.0044358578,
0.0032002947,
0.001602711,
0.0538487956,
0.0431233048,
-0.0367413349,
-0.010727427,
-0.0177848265,
0.0486453027,
-0.0168642867,
-0.0157161094,
0.0826693475,
-0.0367411114,
0.0356844068,
0.0436302386,
0.0226157773,
0.0117592337,
0.0488358103,
-0.0104938159,
0.0679376051,
-0.0068650716,
-0.029915696,
0.013950591,
0.0349062048,
0.0219496954,
-0.0516810305,
0.0399084091,
0.0224447325,
-0.0584045872,
0.0297873653,
-0.0398388281,
-0.0134371622,
0.0439789705,
-0.0575511791,
0.0190510675,
0.0192789249,
0.0001847307,
0.0826907828,
-0.0397113673,
0.0169491377,
-0.0123143671,
-0.0007839368,
-0.0055996468,
-0.0475846529,
-0.0439985543,
0.003850492,
0.004750425,
0.0376271792,
-0.1006110236,
0.0097992951,
-0.0293826591,
0.0089407936,
-0.0340565182,
-0.0162863228,
0.0545013249,
0.0082197608,
-0.0059405114,
-0.0211052559,
-0.1001245454,
-0.0431392826,
-0.0392775945,
0.0686430335,
0.0075501073,
0.0129371192,
-0.0152124632,
0.0028936611,
0.0011073652,
-0.0310142208,
-0.0005894636,
0.1020141542,
-0.0227810275,
-0.010457675,
-0.0529149212,
-0.0590408221,
-0.0253558941,
-0.0844484791,
-0.0489318334,
-0.059509743,
0.0145743908,
-0.0052370094,
-0.0286161117,
-0.0895891935,
0.0131888948,
0.0465302244,
-0.0426103063,
0.0872476771,
0.0176570192,
-0.0277258009,
-0.0392544866,
0.0186069421,
0.0098625058,
0.0227486081,
-0.0180671457,
0.0380648822,
0.0170701556,
-0.0018221252,
0.0356036648,
0.024027383,
0.0058696838,
0.0053022983,
-0.0151025904,
0.0244722348,
-0.0189894624,
0.0322830267,
0.0470482484,
0.056747824,
-0.0041673854,
-0.0415498987,
0.0407673195,
0.0274583865,
0.0370447338,
0.0410821028,
0.0317832828,
-0.0130478898,
0.0051420513,
-0.0190475248,
-0.0873134807,
0.024109209,
-0.0474239141,
-0.0037554698,
-0.0381917767,
0.0180025697,
-0.0383906849,
-0.0351786092,
-0.0050912704,
0.0087689944,
0.0387916043,
0.0251258463,
0.0118529405,
0.0032141292,
-0.0200063605,
0.04974363,
0.053971678,
-0.0250606425,
-0.0231527463,
-0.0489299223,
0.0584920794,
0.060623806,
0.0283489116,
-0.0052307416,
-0.012747312,
-0.0149954949,
0.0068426053,
0.0377513953,
0.0546701513,
-0.0219179876,
-0.0150947291,
-0.0451904684,
-0.0398670584,
0.0151169831,
0.0328557454,
0.0015341486,
0.0289686136,
-0.0055170637,
0.0499746166,
-0.0568272248,
0.0269913264,
0.038371522,
-0.0096056461,
-0.0424290001,
0.0261005014,
-0.0101506906,
0.0401734002,
0.0137430262,
0.0410679765,
-0.0093910825,
0.0185950454,
0.0141553283,
0.0096169859,
0.0102643203,
-0.0130393477,
-0.0322887339,
0.0472001322,
0.0083529325,
-0.0288544167,
-0.0135486601,
-0.0428205021,
-0.003165883,
-0.0151554104,
-0.0034068555,
-0.022396842,
-0.0612571463,
-0.0076475544,
0.0062325229,
-0.0055735596,
-0.0079689566,
0.075364776,
0.0029575203,
-0.0429982431,
0.0048546684,
-0.0016358937,
0.0103300558,
0.0018956638,
-0.0253341179,
-0.0348406322,
0.0006077876,
0.017491933,
0.0052771801,
0.0084846141,
-0.0619094372,
-0.0168517418,
-0.0749568194,
0.0006467763,
-0.0369330049,
-0.0050503062,
-0.0059481016,
-0.0212300383,
0.0000502361,
-0.0242135767,
-0.0119310534,
-0.0135306176,
0.0027780801,
0.0194170401,
0.0011972606,
-0.0201321729,
-0.014186956,
-0.0110167414,
0.0013209565,
-0.0272207819,
0.0320649147,
-0.0050829975,
-0.0119103575,
-0.0573512912,
0.0719977394,
-0.0107407514,
0.0205557626,
-0.0288645513,
0.0122989146,
-0.0162794013,
0.0181291383,
0.0204090867,
0.0424654186,
0.0286110472,
-0.0058799013,
0.0308878366,
-0.0200952906,
-0.0676321909,
0.0205457695,
0.0019650401,
0.0421718396,
-0.056077797,
-0.0196522847,
-0.0225961618,
0.0687030107,
-0.005052594,
-0.0058485344,
-0.046067141,
0.0097823562,
0.011459263,
-0.0218334477,
0.0047351248,
-0.0124157742,
-0.0074141468,
0.0365842842,
0.0031823814,
-0.0601233281,
0.0865480825,
0.0261414144,
0.0484022163,
-0.0406024605,
0.0016157978,
-0.0394207723,
0.0944215208,
-0.0120005654,
-0.0349606462,
-0.0341790356,
-0.0216339733,
-0.0029113193,
-0.0260797702,
0.0378297158,
-0.0341189355,
0.1170140132,
-0.0556878485,
0.0357940868,
-0.0175631493,
-0.0471342951,
-0.0473626778,
-0.0659358129,
-0.0395620577,
0.0152746849,
0.0160754193,
0.0127571914,
-0.0155624347,
-0.002117988,
-0.0350947529,
0.009101402,
0.0095325923,
-0.0119347945,
-0.0130840195,
0.0072824475,
0.0046364316,
-0.0058673993,
0.0067507122,
-0.0184874851,
0.009328939,
0.0279189609,
-0.0054272311,
-0.0136485072,
0.0070986971,
0.0144695928,
0.0065546231,
-0.0416131802,
-0.0086952113,
0.0638637617,
0.0318443216,
-0.0496737175,
0.012789988,
0.1058067307,
0.0127732111,
-0.035212703,
-0.018717479,
0.0055722864,
0.0133622997,
0.0465921722,
0.0162471179,
-0.0657388493,
-0.043426495,
-0.0013837045,
-0.0209819563,
-0.0033742439,
-0.0442164168,
0.0023566687,
-0.0761516318,
0.0679441914,
0.020703258,
0.0140662082,
-0.0365288146,
-0.0290473551,
0.0151802711,
-0.0281879902,
0.0000133694,
0.0187530499,
-0.0140919797,
-0.0138177657,
0.0216031615,
-0.0552186295,
0.0228706524,
0.0545932353,
-0.0381658077,
0.0502008125,
-0.0035319901,
0.0294615272,
0.0056522787,
-0.0416311622,
-0.0057380944,
-0.0058222199,
0.0072121187,
-0.0189482663,
0.0225372128,
0.015189481,
0.0181985777,
-0.0440676585,
0.0411183424,
-0.0132001583,
-0.0444468185,
0.038094148,
0.0778951645,
-0.0440700613,
-0.0357462205,
-0.0351405628,
0.0026717153,
-0.0051434161,
0.0787326917,
-0.0050957962,
-0.0147001715,
-0.0558472499,
-0.0096386466,
-0.0626240373,
-0.0615135096,
-0.0269761197,
-0.0109136058,
-0.0115113119,
0.0066312514,
-0.0074943318,
-0.029504478,
0.0209609941,
0.0185524728,
0.0074313846,
0.0268066265,
0.005062216,
0.0008430803,
-0.0532419346,
0.0243763682,
-0.0705567226,
0.0305236988,
-0.000161621,
0.0365149789,
0.015835993,
0.0007774995,
-0.0107313963,
0.0180611294,
-0.0464929678,
-0.0137540391,
-0.0184786078,
-0.0009123359,
0.0223810785,
0.0319880806,
-0.0404624008,
-0.0483587235,
0.0309189986,
0.0033696403,
-0.0084158275,
0.0149422092,
0.0535070002,
-0.0225389507,
-0.0053858361,
0.0193908308,
0.00187991,
0.0230234805,
0.0593014956,
0.0088232802,
-0.0412842631,
-0.0393609963,
0.0221018177,
0.0125427078,
0.0608244725,
-0.0010343309,
-0.0215653013,
-0.043185249,
-0.0042465106,
-0.0152471783,
-0.0141168619,
-0.0163456015,
-0.0204956029,
0.0358558558,
-0.0017371118,
-0.0506457053,
0.0512499809,
-0.0184670165,
-0.011407895,
-0.052478943,
0.0079225311,
0.0446911678,
-0.0144799314,
0.0192765128,
-0.0510340519,
0.0026183797,
0.0030461168,
-0.0164660905,
0.0387470014,
-0.0161929354,
0.0670073777,
0.0033027264,
-0.0022830106,
-0.035536062,
-0.0342919305,
-0.035728991,
-0.004907113,
0.0034771925,
0.0301603489,
0.0456479117,
-0.0289609656,
-0.0203407947,
-0.0117777651,
-0.0054984367,
-0.0102952626,
0.0234795548,
-0.0148317814,
-0.0096109379,
0.0574034974,
0.0191389248,
-0.0157974362,
0.0060396907,
0.0417971984,
-0.0079108039,
0.0207937397,
-0.0171511844,
-0.0370165966,
-0.0409836769,
-0.0725151971,
-0.0075277681,
0.0020817709,
-0.025099393,
-0.041747991,
-0.0940243825,
-0.0382793173,
0.0020527374,
0.0021928609,
-0.0015487098,
-0.0004354653,
0.0055107581,
0.0737309828,
0.0142062483,
-0.022691451,
-0.0393163487,
0.012151516,
0.0165525395,
-0.0271407366,
-0.0677087232,
-5.36248621e-33,
-0.0184370801,
-0.0206558909,
0.02885166,
-0.0062659127,
-0.0137140742,
-0.0248236284,
-0.0008890046,
0.0038300182,
-0.0281620659,
0.0361946337,
-0.0209962446,
0.0440935791,
0.0254090317,
-0.0081027457,
0.020579977,
-0.0434176847,
0.0223855432,
0.0065600271,
0.0031571963,
0.0198885035,
0.0086708087,
0.0016522437,
0.0028970921,
-0.0698982626,
0.0354949571,
0.0353168547,
-0.0249266364,
0.0092758825,
-0.0738976374,
0.0593835488,
-0.011486535,
0.0389460996,
0.0385773852,
-0.0396725908,
-0.0160267055,
0.0561542697,
-0.0696206018,
0.0055989437,
0.0440612845,
-0.0315210931,
0.0114390468,
-0.0360922851,
0.0098181386,
0.0235718433,
-0.0123126088,
0.0000417856,
0.0267805699,
-0.0547797717,
-0.0335946046,
-0.0648571923,
-0.0604051799,
0.0430021659,
-0.0010018643,
-0.0050104214,
0.0304883625,
0.0117043667,
0.0034886219,
0.0422785841,
-0.0703819096,
0.0251438711,
-0.047276821,
-0.016963724,
0.0162661765,
-0.0445302278,
-0.0528146029,
0.0894459933,
0.0007464038,
0.0048882761,
-0.066013664,
-0.0103836674,
0.009215666,
0.1023624539,
0.0368251503,
0.0579207912,
0.0203173868,
-0.0587787442,
-0.0808650181,
-0.0269892719,
0.0411619507,
0.0197504871,
0.0538520068,
-0.0004334414,
-0.0507055633,
-0.0299869943,
-0.0304178018,
0.0164639838,
-0.0190381184,
0.0207277592,
0.0157318711,
0.0269056391,
0.055734057,
-0.0260881223,
0.0102458168,
-0.0427780338,
0.0457701944,
0.046155788,
-0.0066816024,
-0.0052116304,
-0.0158989802,
0.0325971879,
-0.0374000929,
-0.0532945208,
0.0183799565,
-0.0319895223,
-0.018418232,
-0.0176514592,
0.0600885116,
-0.0337410159,
-0.0455807932,
-0.0147387618,
-0.0117114279,
0.0315336473,
0.0043032644,
0.0371516235,
0.0141774863,
0.0475465842,
0.0182977524,
0.0215433482,
0.0146856913,
-0.0125067513,
-0.0324585289,
-0.0088200197,
0.0200301893,
0.0193918217,
0.0143613191,
-0.0103395591,
-0.0036218357,
0.0104149692,
0.0080210185,
-0.0212118421,
0.0080943266,
0.0862714648,
2.364e-7,
0.053556338,
0.0508223325,
-0.041562587,
0.0005783308,
0.003295497,
0.0514870733,
0.0120734302,
0.0223297887,
0.0485916659,
-0.0422293022,
0.0259697642,
0.0416295603,
0.0641316921,
0.0474189483,
-0.0507770218,
-0.0339032263,
-0.0351443142,
-0.0492489561,
-0.0460016802,
0.0102245742,
0.0435585156,
0.0980201513,
0.0441139564,
-0.0187996421,
0.0114054568,
-0.0162128545,
0.0562668033,
-0.014042207,
-0.0166467298,
0.0129815498,
0.0758103058,
-0.0526706912,
0.0087720929,
0.0803547502,
0.0053686439,
0.0683976561,
-0.0386204757,
0.054854136,
0.0021317606,
0.0379242115,
-0.0508054867,
-0.0401061513,
0.0338851288,
-0.0043097329,
0.0606303625,
-0.019602377,
-0.0212707017,
-0.014912121,
-0.0015299456,
0.0019248953,
-0.0016051941,
0.0367447697,
-0.014160079,
-0.0320173055,
0.0362588763,
-0.0046338122,
-0.0094095068,
-0.1137803942,
-0.0276589319,
0.0617449582,
-0.0695636496,
0.0035998621,
-0.0029927997,
-0.0134819467,
0.0926539153,
-0.0872884542,
0.044050999,
1.689464677e-34,
0.0459440202,
0.0105377585,
-0.0067211245,
0.0213187858,
0.0585752428,
0.0262413472,
-0.0101171834,
0.0068792757,
0.0128907394,
-0.0856749862,
0.0160088092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01955v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01955v1 | S2D: Sorted Speculative Decoding For More Efficient Deployment of Nested Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T05:14:15 | 2024-07-02T05:14:15 | Parsa Kavehzadeh, Mohammadreza Pourreza, Mojtaba Valipour, Tinashu Zhu, Haoli Bai, Ali Ghodsi, Boxing Chen, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deployment of autoregressive large language models (LLMs) is costly, and as
these models increase in size, the associated costs will become even more
considerable. Consequently, different methods have been proposed to accelerate
the token generation process and reduce costs. Speculative decoding (SD) is
among the most promising approaches to speed up the LLM decoding process by
verifying multiple tokens in parallel and using an auxiliary smaller draft
model to generate the possible tokens. In SD, usually, one draft model is used
to serve a specific target model; however, in practice, LLMs are diverse, and
we might need to deal with many target models or more than one target model
simultaneously. In this scenario, it is not clear which draft model should be
used for which target model, and searching among different draft models or
training customized draft models can further increase deployment costs. In this
paper, we first introduce a novel multi-target scenario for the deployment of
draft models for faster inference. Then, we present a novel, more efficient
sorted speculative decoding mechanism that outperforms regular baselines in
multi-target settings. We evaluated our method on Spec-Bench in different
settings, including base models such as Vicuna 7B, 13B, and LLama Chat 70B. Our
results suggest that our draft models perform better than baselines for
multiple target models at the same time. | [
0.0227438901,
0.0962747633,
-0.0006690453,
0.0258988831,
-0.0267640091,
0.0135178547,
0.0162890796,
0.0121107502,
-0.0539210588,
-0.0422587022,
-0.0078639109,
-0.0844819918,
0.0049320753,
0.0463212207,
-0.0051653069,
-0.0061893575,
0.032151252,
-0.0633746982,
0.016227942,
-0.0078584561,
-0.0503522716,
0.0238063205,
0.0270909686,
0.0548999682,
0.0167588685,
-0.0046551568,
-0.0233302694,
0.0173494332,
-0.0123295058,
-0.0505734272,
-0.0171315353,
0.069741182,
0.0206868239,
0.0648617521,
0.0000019865,
-0.0037705114,
-0.0506779365,
0.0264335684,
-0.0543242767,
0.0528005473,
0.0698131397,
-0.0200070813,
-0.0481741726,
0.0335827023,
-0.0024871058,
-0.0712874979,
0.0460252948,
0.0032259177,
0.0360309184,
0.0468359813,
0.0065840143,
-0.0645434558,
0.0277452171,
-0.0128208045,
-0.066107288,
-0.0762040541,
0.0251792651,
-0.0109959925,
-0.0364511684,
0.0385823213,
0.008770356,
0.0168238059,
0.0091585834,
0.0266828295,
-0.0241237134,
0.0169826597,
-0.0151114902,
-0.0255835932,
-0.0115381721,
0.0357148387,
-0.0217647143,
-0.0622599125,
-0.0132225333,
0.0136687905,
-0.0362671204,
-0.0392819494,
-0.0154978512,
0.0352678224,
-0.0133546041,
0.0328768343,
0.0814242437,
0.0097916871,
0.0359797478,
-0.0217542257,
-0.0872233063,
0.0663214028,
0.031733796,
-0.0080050603,
-0.0315008722,
-0.0286132023,
-0.00439328,
-0.0639681667,
0.0057200524,
-0.0261940341,
-0.042440813,
0.0067966832,
-0.0549225137,
-0.058178246,
-0.0051410277,
-0.0245355349,
0.0442777276,
0.048230201,
-0.0032267461,
0.010333919,
-0.0293718744,
-0.0041061589,
-0.0255555976,
-0.0200428534,
-0.0539689362,
-0.0151609685,
0.0078771831,
-0.0162713192,
-0.0692730844,
0.0263841152,
-0.0543913692,
-0.0373720825,
-0.0178366937,
0.0104027065,
0.032494884,
-0.0005352343,
0.0402147472,
-0.0250138529,
-0.0354809053,
-0.0141676348,
0.037914183,
0.0060322443,
-0.0029601175,
-0.0105801113,
-0.0107279774,
-0.0755817071,
0.0067056725,
0.0205340479,
-0.0034856817,
-0.0083898725,
-0.0204028059,
0.0680645406,
0.0095377211,
-0.0217942726,
-0.0222939253,
-0.0148189478,
0.0115006957,
-0.0391748995,
-0.0042808065,
-0.0466881953,
0.0132101625,
0.0184723716,
0.0240078531,
-0.0087041063,
-0.0157745611,
-0.0046348479,
-0.0169487521,
0.0638597012,
-0.0122102881,
0.0132594584,
-0.0212303624,
-0.0089971703,
-0.0038661726,
0.1105286554,
0.0205854047,
0.0564179197,
0.0186176095,
0.0004263537,
-0.030892916,
0.0643380582,
0.0148918368,
0.0112828873,
-0.0247407351,
-0.0123387864,
0.030727528,
-0.0108431019,
0.0153230866,
0.035857901,
-0.0441264473,
-0.0004457887,
0.0297454894,
0.0538709611,
0.0218441002,
-0.0119357836,
0.058386527,
0.0238135867,
0.0084147202,
-0.0013421926,
-0.0158535596,
-0.0006867733,
-0.0267305877,
-0.0113952616,
0.0183405317,
0.048996225,
-0.0060921623,
0.0010874983,
-0.0269316528,
-0.024830034,
-0.0310113858,
-0.0146905547,
0.0714592114,
-0.0145020382,
-0.057375595,
0.0909332111,
0.0136606973,
-0.0277320277,
-0.0410928354,
-0.0543818846,
0.0050569177,
0.0619601123,
0.0360653959,
0.0238163788,
-0.0154105127,
0.0515857115,
-0.0246669631,
0.0196266081,
0.0203146562,
-0.0159620009,
0.0080604488,
-0.0451061539,
-0.0347628854,
0.058071278,
0.0348918438,
0.047735583,
0.0429612622,
0.0001715058,
-0.0010386026,
-0.0246439055,
-0.0103128385,
0.0212703347,
-0.014736237,
0.008222919,
0.0193674639,
0.0014606981,
0.0630841777,
-0.0021834713,
-0.0106056901,
0.0232444238,
0.0492791422,
-0.0303996392,
0.0050362027,
0.0218210146,
-0.0271345712,
-0.0272332374,
0.0098944576,
0.0324391015,
-0.0063340003,
0.02401595,
-0.0330553912,
-0.0255520288,
0.0280705597,
-0.0048116194,
0.0652335361,
-0.036171373,
0.056003999,
-0.0051927967,
0.0147945508,
-0.000213711,
0.0340768211,
-0.0373332128,
-0.0266377721,
-0.0015393731,
-0.0358295776,
0.0090617482,
-0.0164640341,
-0.007499502,
0.050756976,
-0.0210108832,
-0.0118150003,
-0.0345328152,
0.0155127598,
-0.0024964409,
-0.0293884017,
-0.0945172459,
-0.0158429034,
-0.03054679,
0.0276986808,
-0.0074590961,
0.0140362931,
-0.0007029949,
0.0118602794,
0.0034852794,
-0.0168778431,
-0.0165532604,
0.0244861655,
-0.0321663544,
-0.0055911164,
-0.0603040606,
-0.0026320778,
-0.0375836715,
0.0065392768,
0.0737795532,
-0.047135435,
-0.0403679945,
-0.0873516351,
0.0108136265,
0.0227085687,
0.0257848352,
0.0132934758,
-0.0536034331,
0.0199907832,
-0.0251792483,
0.0280747116,
0.0200452767,
0.0036860155,
0.0323166214,
0.0284270234,
0.0222811121,
-0.0433097146,
-0.0275020879,
0.0106849289,
-0.0195706859,
-0.05888265,
-0.0470637642,
-0.0167803504,
0.0542446971,
-0.0074679325,
-0.0066063409,
-0.0776529238,
-0.0115621006,
-0.0370879807,
-0.0366300195,
-0.0147550609,
-0.029741941,
-0.0062092296,
0.0512317941,
-0.0191025063,
-0.046467606,
0.0471331067,
-0.0738857836,
0.0022770141,
-0.0312479325,
0.0131155103,
-0.046553243,
0.0470808186,
-0.0131637901,
0.0424562655,
-0.0196394213,
-0.0521938913,
-0.0051073721,
0.0400598906,
0.0075930138,
-0.0291539766,
0.0365407765,
-0.0241956729,
0.0318429545,
-0.0302644055,
-0.0304989927,
-0.0224758685,
-0.0381674431,
-0.0586806014,
0.005069349,
0.0456296988,
-0.03527309,
-0.0204077587,
0.05799748,
-0.0538072214,
0.0363440998,
-0.0092232749,
0.0259142052,
-0.0124593098,
0.0059261401,
0.0284586195,
-0.050828658,
0.0216569155,
-0.0373187475,
0.0427620932,
0.0618688762,
0.0621963218,
0.0157883186,
-0.0727049857,
-0.0082358122,
0.0695289895,
-0.0026740795,
-0.0102562644,
0.0298014507,
0.0241934042,
-0.0358851291,
0.0097940275,
0.1075331569,
0.0242360476,
-0.0271619055,
0.0147976317,
-0.0019704336,
0.0649935529,
-0.0033986522,
0.0071388544,
-0.0970792472,
-0.0290160608,
0.0601460375,
0.0016584104,
0.0128675047,
0.0069272537,
-0.0255296174,
-0.1250323057,
0.0631142706,
0.0372749865,
-0.0484390296,
0.0128165567,
-0.0150473127,
-0.0415129736,
0.0271877442,
0.0230421741,
0.0515461341,
0.0228059627,
-0.0101970043,
0.0224357415,
-0.020710336,
-0.0491119884,
0.027117895,
-0.0146196317,
0.0756692737,
0.039827019,
-0.0157153402,
0.0318476968,
0.0160756204,
0.03347864,
0.029080268,
-0.0125094131,
-0.0266812611,
-0.0036271487,
-0.0196462292,
0.0154179353,
0.0317107029,
0.0102141369,
-0.0329650417,
0.0046685264,
-0.0399561934,
0.0710337609,
-0.0060478286,
-0.0370413139,
-0.0134786256,
-0.0171881225,
-0.0025490038,
0.067491211,
0.0202379487,
-0.0127633363,
-0.0171410982,
-0.0274371933,
-0.022701649,
-0.0565323569,
-0.0158958137,
0.0226931758,
0.0121325403,
-0.0517449193,
-0.0432373546,
0.0140773179,
0.0344441943,
0.0716015846,
-0.011673362,
0.0619514547,
0.0088158436,
-0.0171942897,
-0.0493511446,
-0.0016774411,
-0.0283751916,
0.0199753102,
-0.0900705308,
-0.0014604451,
0.0375298224,
0.005644158,
-0.0457229652,
0.0008094038,
-0.0920634866,
-0.059675511,
0.0179611035,
0.0200848412,
0.0289335493,
0.0190167353,
-0.0447789654,
-0.0495784618,
0.0528423525,
0.0039900416,
-0.0562522002,
-0.0021390673,
0.0309742168,
-0.0456473343,
-0.0032181672,
0.0410097167,
-0.0341543294,
0.0178515166,
-0.0360924937,
0.021699585,
0.0178581737,
-0.0233146194,
0.0088194804,
0.0433608741,
0.0237173103,
-0.0358847603,
-0.0608670563,
0.0119855413,
0.0795510411,
-0.0377066247,
-0.02269396,
-0.0160805583,
0.061072316,
0.0154885622,
-0.0322364978,
-0.0025022039,
-0.026231207,
0.0382030308,
0.0379471183,
0.0407799333,
0.0031093166,
-0.0072264499,
0.0413592756,
0.0682938695,
-0.0229038764,
-0.023229165,
-0.0173053443,
-0.0043959725,
0.0196902584,
-0.0554106049,
-0.0302180927,
0.0169528387,
0.012117357,
-0.0449498817,
0.0570136681,
-0.0427143797,
-0.0517045893,
-0.0440657027,
0.0167658143,
0.0698989034,
0.0402595215,
0.0681494847,
-0.0166307278,
0.0025070503,
-0.0112709096,
0.0097579546,
-0.0011549175,
-0.0272773523,
0.0197380334,
0.0090557886,
-0.0392811149,
0.0148556931,
0.071334444,
0.0694071352,
0.0348532051,
0.0013910688,
-0.0140429791,
-0.0142478896,
-0.0262575969,
-0.0392950661,
0.0326652899,
-0.0452676937,
0.0069011361,
-0.0381411314,
-0.0623996221,
0.0053026732,
0.0181184262,
-0.001160164,
0.014266598,
-0.002495334,
0.0765887499,
0.0316236801,
-0.0252884571,
-0.0331215113,
-0.0324369706,
0.0392483436,
-0.0397708751,
0.0164906289,
-6.790376095e-33,
-0.0078552729,
0.0017340715,
0.0095958058,
-0.0865356848,
-0.0042309491,
-0.0008135338,
-0.0164099764,
-0.0396069773,
0.0232623555,
-0.0129753537,
-0.0193512123,
0.008564678,
0.0457648151,
0.0113642802,
0.006023393,
0.0339386947,
0.0696769282,
-0.017110154,
-0.0115004554,
0.0030703526,
0.0504699945,
0.0436255746,
0.0307430401,
-0.0017959117,
-0.0149811823,
-0.0029647236,
0.0107815601,
-0.0033142855,
-0.0255265739,
0.0684822798,
-0.006427974,
-0.0150996652,
0.0112533737,
-0.0206671972,
-0.026864212,
0.0000764871,
-0.0819820911,
0.0234025288,
0.0220047049,
0.0214328319,
0.0122946436,
-0.014899875,
-0.0380502678,
0.021708915,
-0.0089022908,
0.000584306,
-0.0339893959,
-0.0231712107,
-0.0166929439,
-0.0305177085,
-0.019549232,
0.0243831035,
0.0244483147,
0.050175041,
0.0706320331,
0.0468773954,
0.0065527107,
0.0250306167,
-0.040880397,
0.0442127325,
-0.0264194831,
0.0702546984,
0.0716870725,
0.0161005724,
-0.0263262987,
0.0201017056,
0.005142916,
-0.0427660272,
-0.0340274461,
-0.0021161609,
0.0370067582,
0.0338653512,
0.0039616656,
0.008382096,
0.0653464124,
-0.0252796859,
-0.0563043915,
0.0099631399,
0.0372462459,
0.0188186504,
0.0590069704,
0.0256115086,
-0.0424152762,
-0.0274261143,
-0.0656240284,
-0.0252837483,
-0.0537001304,
-0.029144695,
0.0451683365,
0.0209143143,
-0.0388924964,
-0.0252465606,
0.0767353997,
-0.0423603095,
-0.0467061512,
0.0510831513,
-0.0038874121,
0.0321833193,
-0.039017465,
0.0725060105,
0.011688889,
-0.0327794775,
0.0611442216,
-0.0172214676,
0.0044689663,
-0.0062177642,
-0.0034156335,
-0.0002990593,
-0.0671529472,
0.0048707379,
-0.0232453626,
0.0070567583,
-0.0047860052,
0.0169311278,
0.0602336638,
-0.012989061,
0.0151255764,
0.0324682333,
0.0058435155,
0.0360447392,
-0.0307279378,
0.0349654108,
0.0096537573,
0.035378892,
0.0130272033,
0.0301725455,
-0.0509402454,
-0.0069952016,
0.0582737029,
-0.0300779492,
-0.0339728035,
0.0678192899,
2.751e-7,
0.0070128213,
0.0435948037,
0.0392659754,
0.0181562155,
0.0121784145,
0.0311404299,
-0.0102075189,
-0.0066386969,
0.0264227055,
0.0217468999,
-0.0125453407,
0.0186302252,
0.063292183,
0.0232211314,
-0.0690637529,
-0.0290447157,
-0.0323144719,
0.0186983775,
-0.0612249821,
-0.0477776155,
0.0111415582,
0.1368343383,
-0.0292081796,
-0.0183345992,
0.0140055055,
0.008158436,
0.0022443298,
-0.0004028578,
-0.0347466357,
0.0193450302,
-0.0059599634,
-0.0106912898,
0.0092980927,
0.007791636,
-0.0045678252,
-0.010623063,
-0.0234366246,
0.0442466438,
-0.0167586952,
-0.0142116435,
0.0198827852,
-0.0066213976,
-0.0424585305,
-0.0321682319,
0.0596342422,
-0.0197644923,
-0.0325450487,
-0.0397142209,
-0.0258529559,
-0.0108875232,
-0.0720484257,
-0.0032307187,
0.007435801,
0.0623036101,
0.0231498182,
-0.0191344656,
0.0079163564,
-0.0811918229,
-0.0108679673,
-0.0208937414,
-0.0503949523,
-0.0412206352,
-0.0050928164,
0.0190258399,
0.0266114473,
-0.0428839587,
0.0094655836,
3.179567578e-34,
0.0622250363,
0.0150776608,
0.0247335751,
0.0683433861,
0.0250824057,
-0.030468205,
0.0125767095,
0.0349033512,
-0.0272248872,
-0.0758184567,
-0.0345447026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01948v1 | Extracting and Encoding: Leveraging Large Language Models and Medical Knowledge to Enhance Radiological Text Representation | 2024-07-02T04:39:19 | 2024-07-02T04:39:19 | Pablo Messina, René Vidal, Denis Parra, Álvaro Soto, Vladimir Araujo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Advancing representation learning in specialized fields like medicine remains
challenging due to the scarcity of expert annotations for text and images. To
tackle this issue, we present a novel two-stage framework designed to extract
high-quality factual statements from free-text radiology reports in order to
improve the representations of text encoders and, consequently, their
performance on various downstream tasks. In the first stage, we propose a
\textit{Fact Extractor} that leverages large language models (LLMs) to identify
factual statements from well-curated domain-specific datasets. In the second
stage, we introduce a \textit{Fact Encoder} (CXRFE) based on a BERT model
fine-tuned with objective functions designed to improve its representations
using the extracted factual data. Our framework also includes a new
embedding-based metric (CXRFEScore) for evaluating chest X-ray text generation
systems, leveraging both stages of our approach. Extensive evaluations show
that our fact extractor and encoder outperform current state-of-the-art methods
in tasks such as sentence ranking, natural language inference, and label
extraction from radiology reports. Additionally, our metric proves to be more
robust and effective than existing metrics commonly used in the radiology
report generation literature. The code of this project is available at
\url{https://github.com/PabloMessina/CXR-Fact-Encoder}. | [
0.0300117098,
0.0485619716,
0.0458548814,
0.0165282451,
-0.0131989457,
0.0446526669,
0.0018515992,
0.0399655998,
-0.0122118052,
-0.0250686537,
-0.0107089682,
-0.03790709,
0.0121299811,
0.0254311338,
0.0324935019,
-0.0605179407,
0.0105293328,
0.0209341887,
0.069206357,
0.0049659358,
-0.0064691971,
0.0185952894,
-0.0187422149,
0.0383508615,
-0.0263191257,
0.0036716152,
0.0622406937,
0.0032715502,
0.0644717962,
-0.0377248563,
-0.0193572454,
0.023203237,
0.022265153,
0.0241919477,
0.0000019344,
-0.0135754645,
-0.0376776457,
0.0442722254,
-0.017715035,
-0.0192269254,
0.0467516072,
-0.0630539805,
-0.0195966605,
-0.0006365223,
-0.0172687043,
-0.0534651987,
0.0435758494,
0.0439852439,
0.0887684301,
0.091781117,
-0.0260431524,
0.0072838794,
0.0030674508,
-0.0266674105,
0.0030561914,
-0.0027525402,
0.0199150648,
0.0391523801,
-0.0057847016,
0.0492850021,
-0.0049892473,
0.0350531973,
0.0006695099,
0.0153866448,
0.0577389859,
0.0841898546,
-0.0184609015,
-0.0048243739,
0.022644978,
0.0762929171,
-0.0218050573,
0.0102895806,
0.0133247618,
0.0013376669,
-0.0299320109,
-0.0210864842,
-0.0348198414,
0.0224512033,
-0.0034338636,
0.0058311806,
-0.0119096152,
-0.0182946287,
0.0102102319,
0.018804254,
-0.0286315233,
-0.0382789634,
0.0118045639,
-0.0209286138,
0.0070138476,
0.0260252785,
-0.0199207049,
-0.0324079655,
0.0563860387,
0.0247255843,
-0.0231027994,
0.0112381326,
-0.052056849,
-0.0110020414,
0.0635783896,
-0.0814308971,
-0.0488017686,
-0.0015598163,
-0.064504683,
0.066551581,
-0.0350996964,
0.0469436422,
-0.0238288473,
0.0598776005,
-0.0345867388,
0.0130138239,
-0.0119169578,
-0.0203152504,
-0.0141222579,
0.0187383201,
0.0019799639,
-0.0297360718,
-0.0697319359,
-0.0285668485,
0.0108677289,
0.0702275634,
0.030833913,
0.0403008871,
-0.0631815195,
0.0089697745,
-0.0112805106,
0.0426196419,
0.0126800109,
-0.0172166266,
-0.0178503916,
0.0028856411,
-0.0152275162,
0.0487393886,
0.0181053504,
-0.0056833811,
-0.0066735931,
-0.0021053543,
-0.0252815969,
-0.0206846986,
0.0514303483,
-0.0474697016,
-0.0277376398,
-0.0343559086,
0.0263606627,
-0.0739747956,
0.0238059592,
0.0230916999,
0.0060823578,
-0.0354573019,
0.0233089086,
0.0081891194,
-0.0359836966,
0.0331158377,
-0.0461590514,
-0.0173704624,
0.0542327836,
0.0406840071,
0.0395523533,
0.0078007248,
0.0483352654,
0.0172099881,
-0.0019038747,
0.0222959686,
0.0009158588,
0.0021709525,
-0.0018390111,
-0.0530544408,
0.0050161574,
0.0083324127,
0.0081825368,
0.0768681169,
0.0153059922,
0.0575781912,
-0.0285521764,
-0.00549088,
0.0405465513,
0.0230064411,
0.0033293406,
0.0170021337,
0.0264203846,
-0.0105326688,
0.0102666635,
-0.012641117,
0.0056418348,
0.0407969207,
0.0788703486,
0.0167696103,
0.0146937324,
0.0192180183,
-0.0142693883,
-0.0159709435,
-0.0259364378,
-0.0030680371,
-0.0573906824,
-0.0285525732,
0.0350975804,
-0.0048147831,
-0.0656955689,
0.0694193169,
0.0376144461,
-0.0160354115,
0.0059000114,
-0.0447250083,
-0.027737949,
0.0764404386,
0.0805450752,
-0.0538149104,
-0.0315886624,
-0.0022036748,
0.0275909547,
0.0649235547,
0.0371301919,
-0.0040839235,
0.0219963584,
-0.053483054,
-0.0404405408,
0.0159686413,
0.0231629461,
-0.0299666822,
-0.0107405931,
0.0355802365,
0.0199103188,
-0.049464751,
-0.0485890619,
0.0517599955,
-0.0284083039,
-0.031594485,
-0.0047723115,
0.023177281,
-0.0201624446,
0.0036031581,
-0.0544756539,
0.0269095618,
0.0105008623,
-0.0220120791,
-0.03041883,
0.0200021416,
-0.0566140935,
-0.0691822544,
0.0225822553,
-0.066242598,
-0.0004948622,
-0.0099033406,
-0.0558329225,
0.008601144,
-0.048408132,
-0.0639699027,
0.0321892425,
-0.0146335969,
0.0181055367,
0.0708207488,
-0.0109113567,
-0.0115019269,
0.0633199215,
-0.029156616,
-0.006708906,
0.0219874848,
-0.0294388533,
0.0070468374,
-0.0341200419,
-0.0231177732,
0.0168011598,
0.0285429247,
0.0161344931,
0.0149294324,
0.0419984274,
-0.007368966,
-0.0289548133,
-0.0866647437,
0.012728096,
-0.0021514045,
-0.0140836006,
0.0398906767,
-0.0050799213,
0.018660333,
-0.0131971398,
-0.049556613,
-0.0658129677,
0.0365810357,
-0.0010718773,
0.0704543963,
0.0213076416,
0.0150608607,
-0.0351497158,
-0.0024128191,
-0.0223837104,
0.0233306997,
0.0382205769,
-0.0205340609,
-0.0068164198,
0.0267255548,
-0.0524073727,
-0.0173687376,
0.0022673281,
-0.0393750854,
0.0258454978,
-0.0197612885,
-0.002264291,
0.0609217733,
0.028980989,
0.047459498,
0.0272158347,
-0.0004013644,
-0.01430202,
0.0078522228,
-0.0616601668,
0.0144058354,
0.0274600871,
-0.069030188,
0.01065295,
0.011183775,
0.0223884452,
0.0092695029,
-0.0397794843,
-0.0460743979,
-0.0239231233,
0.0005257015,
-0.0591096804,
0.0130563444,
0.0057906411,
0.0136113176,
-0.0202945154,
-0.0240256283,
0.1019526049,
-0.0216845889,
0.0193697326,
-0.0685833618,
0.0134677719,
-0.0390009992,
-0.015741216,
0.0206455942,
0.0580083914,
0.0027204913,
-0.0010921917,
-0.0013677074,
0.0270848982,
0.0244985651,
-0.0887213275,
-0.0182348359,
-0.0071024466,
0.0032425122,
-0.0149483271,
-0.0424724445,
-0.0433145352,
-0.0296664611,
0.01399625,
-0.0086864224,
-0.0227358155,
-0.0252639111,
-0.0944857448,
0.0087820916,
0.0358501337,
0.0383243002,
-0.0085379798,
-0.0100890519,
-0.0132082701,
0.0691212788,
0.039784167,
0.0210184827,
-0.006279509,
-0.0327815823,
-0.0101698777,
0.0816161558,
-0.044624202,
0.0281772316,
-0.0181792714,
-0.0122837713,
-0.0152376816,
0.0126315318,
0.0285440087,
-0.0002052585,
0.0364030972,
-0.032205373,
-0.0487746857,
0.1013047993,
0.0516066849,
0.0166570321,
-0.0047289636,
0.0239923019,
0.0163530298,
-0.0259821787,
0.003320331,
-0.0374610946,
-0.0089016277,
-0.0223155022,
0.0334872715,
-0.024686804,
-0.0106964251,
-0.0062741814,
-0.0556248203,
0.0605968349,
0.0126117002,
-0.0114079388,
-0.0768151209,
-0.0699318424,
-0.0271879472,
-0.0090326378,
-0.0351791605,
0.0057618069,
0.0145423841,
0.0071843439,
0.0222933386,
-0.0380598716,
-0.074057281,
-0.010708211,
-0.0431397557,
-0.0173147563,
0.0362872891,
0.0731381923,
-0.0268552396,
-0.0267116372,
-0.0423907712,
0.0545103848,
-0.0394388661,
0.0059724413,
0.1186427623,
-0.0130006364,
-0.0196962878,
-0.0510130338,
0.0277122911,
0.0225540865,
-0.0234731585,
-0.0246322379,
0.0453224741,
-0.0200265348,
-0.0055479216,
-0.0567284189,
0.0563323461,
0.0141850207,
0.0516401306,
0.005716878,
0.030575294,
-0.0186978653,
-0.0313825943,
0.083186008,
-0.0487811826,
-0.0401599109,
0.041477453,
-0.0572762713,
-0.063574627,
-0.086995326,
-0.0001345825,
0.0258558095,
0.0142538901,
-0.009438009,
-0.0137191331,
-0.0109062511,
-0.0184529461,
-0.0539383143,
0.0382963978,
0.0259100981,
-0.0131477453,
-0.0186602082,
-0.0460413136,
0.0722274184,
-0.0143606346,
-0.0335841142,
0.018731555,
-0.0361696891,
0.0017592449,
-0.0337765887,
0.0409713015,
0.0155345676,
-0.0024240625,
0.0073775346,
0.0028355788,
0.1197632775,
0.0833955258,
-0.0421961285,
-0.0188642815,
0.0038648651,
-0.0670934319,
-0.0254359189,
-0.0092477668,
-0.0224214979,
0.0124903526,
-0.0157058593,
0.0357926972,
-0.0385943577,
-0.0312782414,
0.037899565,
0.0386302583,
0.0208476428,
-0.0276305731,
-0.0019173329,
-0.0363440402,
0.000712135,
-0.0202938486,
0.0096970517,
-0.034293551,
0.0360752754,
0.0258613415,
0.0251140501,
-0.016603075,
0.0341456346,
-0.0047986237,
-0.0163916145,
-0.0260302741,
0.037810389,
-0.0092481524,
-0.0093469527,
0.0261821244,
-0.0330145694,
-0.0534337685,
-0.0288398713,
-0.0020587568,
0.0083758803,
-0.0114247836,
0.0264099166,
0.0270451177,
0.0437676944,
0.0048550693,
0.0280019231,
-0.0319400094,
-0.0101842927,
-0.0716860369,
0.0225912947,
0.0333130211,
0.0106362132,
0.0139113078,
-0.0593632758,
-0.0077176737,
-0.014098621,
0.0487730466,
-0.0072787893,
0.0050987438,
0.0196066331,
-0.0038063489,
0.0209883023,
-0.0300869942,
0.0804581717,
0.0180932712,
0.044764258,
-0.0170536693,
-0.074416995,
-0.0700824335,
-0.0423862897,
0.0052368678,
-0.0427403264,
-0.0224072896,
0.0072571333,
-0.0398823023,
-0.0381140523,
0.0284630265,
0.0033869208,
-0.0198848434,
-0.0235758182,
0.0403541178,
0.0454947501,
-0.0049813502,
-0.018265631,
-0.0270321723,
0.0444093905,
-0.0071125962,
-0.020605078,
0.011324387,
-5.94716461e-33,
-0.0095436322,
-0.0378913842,
0.026827056,
-0.039856907,
-0.0104419654,
0.0510760583,
-0.0448793769,
-0.0304167047,
0.0088129779,
0.0336274505,
0.0031716439,
-0.0244319979,
0.0054592467,
0.0358182117,
-0.0331780538,
-0.0054478417,
0.0316922292,
0.0026814186,
-0.046855025,
0.0189293046,
0.0048035309,
0.0327810869,
0.0675946698,
-0.103664577,
-0.0310274586,
0.0246492792,
-0.0075523914,
-0.0067268293,
0.0254430696,
0.03837464,
-0.0545418039,
0.0196008179,
0.006442281,
-0.0724000409,
0.0032792704,
0.0173430741,
-0.0683288947,
-0.0060652154,
-0.0035365578,
-0.0201166496,
-0.0332382433,
-0.0162792318,
0.0329045355,
-0.0158287399,
0.0166649446,
-0.0322389565,
0.052292157,
-0.025991546,
-0.0032352994,
-0.0339485146,
-0.0546212532,
0.0726976171,
-0.0125343688,
-0.019380901,
0.0232075863,
-0.0227585342,
-0.011627771,
0.0538666546,
-0.0344491825,
0.0061051985,
0.0569249056,
0.0397506244,
0.0086412299,
-0.0238675177,
-0.0299067535,
0.0798620358,
-0.0069481162,
-0.0379444323,
-0.0224416833,
0.0350539461,
-0.0329771563,
0.081588462,
0.0262017846,
0.0481144823,
0.0154402703,
-0.02223216,
-0.1120063439,
0.0756765828,
-0.0376440138,
0.0335310288,
0.0327270851,
-0.0299886968,
-0.0487457477,
0.0284125917,
0.0306947865,
0.0087944362,
-0.0006586956,
0.0029286989,
0.0101613607,
0.0362404697,
-0.029790733,
0.0341001078,
0.0207845252,
0.023777293,
0.0240808353,
-0.0179781262,
-0.0101072006,
0.0087416898,
-0.0519504286,
-0.0086355489,
-0.0429824591,
-0.0309087504,
0.0561627746,
0.0084010139,
0.0243023094,
0.0068776347,
0.053865321,
-0.0074966489,
-0.0432132483,
0.0254459661,
0.0047891745,
-0.0287905298,
-0.0257483702,
0.0479514636,
0.0040651001,
0.0136314621,
-0.0234274734,
0.0094752312,
-0.0191858187,
0.0372186117,
-0.0342527293,
-0.0422477387,
0.0268458929,
-0.0085912663,
-0.0532559752,
-0.0185700282,
-0.0166696683,
0.0073447688,
0.0280677471,
-0.0682248697,
-0.027906917,
-0.0097228233,
2.669e-7,
0.0745862797,
0.0468926542,
0.0278051216,
0.0060225851,
0.0014485641,
0.0135957738,
-0.0278615914,
0.0430451073,
0.0136263296,
-0.0464195088,
0.0424252599,
0.0207122378,
0.0079449061,
0.0384670906,
-0.0724133849,
-0.010804072,
-0.0700994208,
-0.04352732,
-0.009794306,
-0.0430629924,
0.0800901651,
0.0718080252,
-0.0470905155,
-0.0221289843,
0.0098758945,
-0.0126627255,
0.0594460927,
-0.0009616032,
0.0086879777,
0.0154377641,
0.0410171524,
0.0381407589,
-0.0057710349,
0.0175699405,
-0.019109413,
-0.0182557292,
0.050643824,
0.0886214375,
-0.0185736977,
-0.0102254078,
-0.0021499577,
0.0250818208,
0.0171394181,
-0.0268649831,
0.0455656461,
-0.0440862179,
-0.0341934338,
-0.0221891869,
-0.0405428112,
0.0482681096,
0.0622936673,
-0.0484667346,
-0.0642160848,
0.0298178196,
0.0265332684,
0.0029769675,
-0.0284556225,
-0.0853752568,
-0.008412201,
0.0155530153,
-0.0363635644,
-0.0471610501,
0.0306799822,
0.0040894127,
-0.005847807,
-0.0462585613,
0.0111853704,
2.45421134e-34,
0.0335949734,
-0.0015059252,
-0.0283065997,
0.0006858708,
0.0294709764,
-0.0229765009,
0.0006827392,
-0.0163270254,
0.0019212413,
-0.0244074166,
-0.0024776303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01942v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01942v1 | Certainly Uncertain: A Benchmark and Metric for Multimodal Epistemic and Aleatoric Awareness | 2024-07-02T04:23:54 | 2024-07-02T04:23:54 | Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, Linjie Li, Anas Awadalla, Ximing Lu, Jae Sung Park, Jack Hessel, Lijuan Wang, Yejin Choi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | The ability to acknowledge the inevitable uncertainty in their knowledge and
reasoning is a prerequisite for AI systems to be truly truthful and reliable.
In this paper, we present a taxonomy of uncertainty specific to vision-language
AI systems, distinguishing between epistemic uncertainty (arising from a lack
of information) and aleatoric uncertainty (due to inherent unpredictability),
and further explore finer categories within. Based on this taxonomy, we
synthesize a benchmark dataset, CertainlyUncertain, featuring 178K visual
question answering (VQA) samples as contrastive pairs. This is achieved by 1)
inpainting images to make previously answerable questions into unanswerable
ones; and 2) using image captions to prompt large language models for both
answerable and unanswerable questions. Additionally, we introduce a new metric
confidence-weighted accuracy, that is well correlated with both accuracy and
calibration error, to address the shortcomings of existing metrics. | [
0.028770037,
0.0885878429,
-0.0261460412,
0.0440115444,
-0.0161872581,
-0.0026912589,
-0.0061113802,
0.0151076652,
0.0128437718,
-0.0494498126,
-0.0166483689,
-0.0386729464,
0.0117224185,
0.046158053,
0.0220577642,
-0.0603580996,
0.0336036868,
-0.0427846611,
0.031394124,
-0.0233566873,
0.0281083416,
-0.0355150998,
-0.0239260476,
0.0325042084,
-0.0489307866,
-0.0292068403,
-0.0151407318,
0.0111684604,
0.0082526971,
-0.0276482962,
-0.0213506129,
0.0224054735,
-0.0029277087,
0.0228773877,
0.0000019523,
-0.0361340083,
0.0451392792,
-0.0058005471,
-0.0257705338,
-0.0256153885,
-0.0312123168,
-0.0003643314,
0.0258784126,
-0.0119171897,
-0.0456222482,
0.0122037176,
0.0920565426,
-0.0080138994,
0.0660257861,
0.0087677343,
-0.0000202849,
0.0121700624,
0.0205385536,
0.0053426092,
0.0382941812,
-0.0514314435,
0.0036577848,
0.0199812185,
-0.0257253479,
-0.0022712937,
-0.0619258657,
0.0569579825,
0.0171504077,
-0.0078879837,
-0.020979194,
0.0181604438,
-0.0192865077,
-0.0659997538,
-0.0341595747,
0.0657638907,
0.0573662333,
0.0013134172,
-0.0433284454,
0.000539399,
0.0211364832,
0.020185519,
-0.0300285146,
0.0362525322,
-0.009924002,
-0.0105201658,
-0.0585499816,
0.0164631382,
0.0042021046,
0.0134671442,
0.0084811039,
0.026208777,
-0.0177881923,
0.010977596,
0.0128049459,
-0.0035470573,
-0.0827468038,
-0.0846951827,
-0.0324813053,
0.0504876263,
-0.0284871422,
0.0077810427,
-0.0441605449,
-0.0228605662,
0.0053506289,
0.003417219,
0.0352754742,
0.0263676438,
-0.0542229414,
0.070795089,
0.0123945884,
0.082854405,
0.0086007137,
0.0266031567,
-0.0264540706,
-0.0371911637,
-0.0019421378,
-0.0019309995,
-0.0479681864,
-0.0008571917,
-0.0278738774,
-0.0416196957,
-0.0257190838,
0.0214662589,
-0.0613035187,
0.0532238521,
-0.0109138926,
0.0398999043,
-0.0064405291,
-0.0305951796,
-0.0755631477,
0.0173060037,
-0.0246478114,
0.0320295393,
0.007083552,
-0.0594251789,
0.0166896675,
0.0318251513,
-0.0105732102,
0.0031567782,
0.0027666201,
0.0811924487,
-0.0182949398,
-0.0233753454,
0.0041294009,
0.0124784624,
-0.0234480184,
-0.0524662398,
-0.0002796824,
-0.0444496237,
-0.0025642982,
-0.0094652483,
0.0053694285,
-0.0581066124,
0.0207083486,
0.010005679,
-0.0084051425,
0.1216548905,
-0.0372623615,
0.0059420401,
0.0252823066,
0.0090612555,
-0.0142684048,
0.066621013,
0.0451778434,
0.013661772,
0.0715653822,
0.0132380836,
0.0584594421,
0.0008746942,
0.01162891,
-0.007573253,
-0.0367120281,
0.02106856,
-0.0221472159,
0.0141879227,
-0.0101299994,
0.0846449062,
-0.0012675425,
-0.0732914433,
0.0821559504,
0.0106235044,
-0.0469782017,
-0.0273698959,
0.0290403944,
-0.0392996967,
0.0466970019,
0.0066669881,
-0.0531949587,
0.0831796005,
0.0009338986,
0.0203488711,
0.0316377506,
-0.0110344719,
-0.0194088295,
-0.068080768,
-0.0177594088,
0.0068741329,
-0.0166546386,
0.0452847704,
0.030272603,
-0.0104712164,
-0.0309711564,
-0.0402291901,
-0.0330494344,
-0.0146683482,
-0.0110496599,
-0.0452966206,
0.0535671189,
0.0399205536,
0.0177400503,
-0.0291877426,
-0.0190980565,
0.024870852,
0.0200076587,
0.0209831335,
0.0303304326,
0.0035285179,
0.044290714,
-0.035143353,
-0.0231671035,
-0.0295576155,
0.0120373229,
-0.0023227562,
-0.0000107157,
0.0293665417,
-0.0306974649,
-0.0330755524,
-0.0009829459,
0.0168068893,
0.0476213098,
-0.0004982068,
-0.0163660645,
-0.0015310146,
0.0034118448,
-0.0088648312,
-0.0234926473,
-0.0118217701,
0.0189599469,
0.0192428734,
-0.0060862321,
0.0021802597,
0.0014653509,
0.0214501806,
0.0447195768,
-0.0909884125,
-0.0415195711,
0.0036717134,
-0.0374765731,
-0.0305639282,
0.0271364208,
-0.0422185399,
-0.044066228,
-0.0501563139,
0.0015882154,
0.0168270301,
0.0301253255,
-0.0164633207,
0.0310473014,
-0.0557746664,
-0.0299050789,
0.0198160112,
0.0226839352,
0.046205163,
-0.0169996563,
-0.0185738206,
-0.0162977539,
0.0171861034,
0.0115975104,
0.0063018557,
0.0087926323,
-0.0515480265,
-0.0069884048,
-0.0756366625,
-0.0305090565,
-0.0146264043,
-0.0424536541,
-0.0102362866,
-0.0219118278,
0.0092927869,
-0.0435316339,
-0.0339642055,
0.0589609705,
0.0103983795,
0.0070310831,
0.0470369942,
0.0347181968,
0.0104037244,
-0.0304536354,
0.013505185,
0.0380360112,
0.0469694212,
0.0342650637,
0.0119879777,
-0.0474422053,
0.029000964,
-0.0623068772,
0.0578347221,
-0.012985223,
-0.0246403571,
0.0299574006,
-0.0033804427,
-0.0280367099,
0.0604491942,
-0.002372202,
0.0093813855,
0.0393129475,
-0.019090876,
0.0093801627,
0.0224447306,
0.0185418483,
-0.0608914457,
0.029698899,
-0.0618313104,
-0.0302087311,
-0.00006001,
-0.0011807758,
-0.022488825,
-0.0617636703,
0.0666989312,
0.0126229441,
-0.0737867877,
-0.0597154722,
0.0138708819,
0.0076147285,
0.0846103281,
-0.0295626577,
-0.0885615423,
0.0792612955,
-0.0141045358,
0.0024210215,
0.0481485687,
-0.0114578623,
0.0170496292,
0.0530925877,
0.0354964584,
0.0120222196,
0.0063261138,
0.0158960614,
-0.0841420069,
-0.0488888174,
0.0068638436,
-0.0376411453,
0.0599334091,
-0.0858283341,
0.0077029765,
-0.0014833668,
-0.0311105512,
-0.0549611859,
0.0086108288,
-0.0320291594,
-0.0125557613,
-0.0115368823,
-0.0524445772,
0.0128671462,
0.0019748241,
0.0318662785,
-0.0019353647,
0.0139045175,
-0.0443230793,
-0.0079597645,
0.035866946,
0.0785586089,
0.0612531714,
0.0357744098,
-0.033807341,
0.0118814772,
0.0590289906,
0.0243561361,
0.0024204149,
-0.045331765,
0.014470838,
0.0064209411,
0.0532945096,
0.0119185969,
0.0351724923,
0.0543609597,
0.0004749533,
-0.0121526187,
0.0758047849,
0.0160189532,
-0.0083600515,
-0.0191177111,
-0.0136705833,
0.004419216,
0.0520239808,
0.014197737,
-0.0891696364,
-0.0416623242,
-0.0011524665,
-0.0045534754,
-0.0292947665,
-0.0289354846,
-0.026828615,
-0.043287009,
0.0507387854,
-0.0220399871,
-0.0207619574,
-0.0509730652,
0.0204244945,
0.0068710209,
0.0032271105,
0.0002385465,
0.0011188368,
0.0259553287,
0.0296687055,
0.0029555713,
0.0178348683,
0.0022873105,
0.0002311726,
-0.0240526795,
0.0382854082,
0.0158118047,
-0.0062026796,
-0.0391301923,
-0.0542169511,
-0.0351861231,
-0.0462855957,
-0.0035394919,
-0.0000422186,
0.0692143813,
-0.0022468651,
-0.0590518638,
0.0012331565,
-0.0006052533,
0.004902571,
-0.0163319465,
0.0150209134,
0.0505813695,
-0.0368841812,
-0.0016995916,
-0.0337692723,
0.0049692933,
0.0035219416,
0.0335542783,
0.0138055608,
-0.0253555309,
-0.0212988202,
-0.0322415233,
0.0381388105,
-0.0553163663,
0.01975975,
0.024392765,
0.0572615005,
0.0231790747,
-0.0832927674,
-0.0275778361,
0.0200328957,
0.0487728082,
-0.0109764123,
-0.0447645634,
0.0058666565,
0.0320266895,
-0.0655910596,
0.0138188759,
0.0020590129,
0.0254339799,
-0.0197805949,
0.0119072972,
-0.0067833355,
-0.0268165376,
-0.0185026303,
0.0672925487,
-0.0603942275,
-0.031233415,
0.0022350943,
0.093546249,
0.0272477176,
-0.0190091189,
0.0116500091,
-0.0480354354,
0.0454246253,
0.0145936152,
0.0647537783,
0.0427069888,
0.016581839,
0.0137987146,
-0.0140133752,
0.0373434722,
-0.0396511666,
-0.0194405708,
0.0005984266,
0.0048775659,
-0.0328959152,
-0.0679724962,
0.0087991953,
0.0264774989,
0.012693448,
-0.0224943124,
0.0412161835,
-0.0072788419,
0.0081720296,
0.0197776575,
-0.0052922801,
-0.0595683008,
-0.007555258,
0.0123908343,
-0.010477704,
0.0033831438,
0.0151659939,
0.0153211812,
-0.0170427598,
0.0211349092,
-0.0343582295,
0.0383442082,
0.0346098207,
-0.0211926345,
0.0039887596,
-0.0002925688,
0.0192972142,
-0.0152782882,
0.0473243631,
0.0680480674,
0.0878318772,
0.0439680777,
-0.0521004312,
-0.0146552566,
0.0153852282,
-0.0437395684,
-0.0614008643,
0.0054043168,
0.0778194293,
0.0545579828,
0.0604939088,
-0.0242091939,
-0.0387201644,
-0.0008838878,
-0.0100926664,
-0.0115844812,
0.0564757474,
-0.0169975273,
0.0755405426,
0.0158707481,
0.0190724693,
0.0423073769,
0.0494908914,
-0.0532569103,
0.0493931435,
-0.0357407629,
-0.0222407021,
-0.0194599498,
-0.0257256813,
-0.0088467384,
-0.0067641959,
-0.0003498025,
0.047427021,
-0.0310639739,
-0.0798582584,
0.0165568367,
0.0850486234,
0.0119260708,
-0.0069419416,
0.0181041975,
0.0417692773,
0.0600068681,
-0.0100786453,
-0.0153058385,
-0.0111233788,
-0.0466769226,
0.0356413238,
-0.0123906871,
-6.378392509e-33,
-0.0259232614,
-0.0673767775,
0.0236365646,
-0.0287750605,
0.0005774917,
0.0128270499,
-0.0079157269,
0.0214238316,
-0.0473664775,
0.0309239291,
0.0111886626,
0.0259513613,
-0.0148295509,
0.0267342757,
0.0005375622,
-0.0383773148,
-0.0229168814,
0.0010406272,
-0.0303479526,
-0.0129382499,
0.0348251686,
-0.031802237,
0.0132476892,
-0.0624263175,
0.0258354396,
0.0281045288,
-0.0385953709,
0.0459609888,
-0.0237190239,
0.0412949026,
-0.0419267416,
0.0545551628,
-0.0042608357,
0.0416717343,
-0.0095300311,
-0.0396090411,
-0.0186060537,
-0.0613158047,
0.0337239653,
0.0441406332,
-0.0970028564,
0.0134302583,
-0.0036239214,
-0.0168694668,
-0.0369064994,
-0.0031377929,
0.0300494637,
-0.0334871002,
0.0385149382,
0.0053944709,
0.0423922613,
-0.0216346886,
-0.0204446428,
-0.0560845435,
-0.0046443525,
0.0576398559,
0.0310249384,
-0.0113930581,
-0.0494372062,
-0.0017263404,
-0.0211531259,
-0.0084800497,
0.1010449007,
0.0336211547,
0.0037567937,
0.0445524119,
0.0430617593,
-0.0214325711,
-0.01635026,
-0.0463640094,
-0.0243304241,
0.0433308966,
0.0700515062,
0.0893809795,
-0.0046850033,
0.0272892211,
-0.0424276739,
0.0191417579,
-0.0592345782,
0.06735719,
0.0045705833,
0.0038978148,
-0.0301110726,
0.0229001697,
-0.0589253269,
-0.0274784807,
-0.0678727925,
0.0171723142,
0.0391565524,
0.0026109992,
0.0143896388,
0.0398708321,
0.0340794101,
-0.0392221995,
0.0078887371,
-0.0010998076,
0.00191273,
0.0546664707,
0.0400509723,
0.0478510559,
0.0191046204,
0.0463331677,
0.0494853146,
0.0264034271,
-0.0081770886,
0.0031548808,
0.0133912442,
0.0195173174,
-0.0272901226,
0.0029737565,
-0.0222014319,
0.0400845781,
-0.027923001,
-0.0665134341,
0.0069531091,
0.0137267532,
-0.0604761578,
-0.0113113942,
-0.0269477572,
0.0009554581,
-0.0237615276,
-0.0268359296,
-0.0170933232,
0.0253570545,
-0.0416634195,
-0.0043841144,
-0.0378366932,
-0.0564826578,
-0.0466847196,
-0.0614159629,
-0.0158900805,
0.0532215014,
2.711e-7,
0.0045085778,
0.0098769171,
0.007534558,
0.0367848203,
0.0326989926,
0.0615154654,
-0.055836115,
0.0051317634,
0.0068568462,
-0.0527970754,
-0.0001727706,
0.0459868945,
0.0125252437,
0.0136121474,
0.0425343923,
-0.0010948475,
0.0069643389,
-0.0213744733,
-0.0290006977,
0.0543591157,
0.0921788961,
0.0579590052,
0.0044082548,
-0.0085395901,
0.0516139753,
-0.057090681,
0.048460491,
-0.0380314775,
0.0264273491,
-0.0350523815,
0.0271692649,
0.0187934935,
0.0097405706,
0.058113426,
0.0129223792,
-0.0509263724,
0.0325186476,
0.0042637149,
-0.0032691616,
-0.0094636166,
-0.0573862419,
0.0203445554,
0.0067801368,
-0.0687801465,
0.0785047039,
-0.030381605,
-0.0427914783,
-0.0164746083,
-0.0405498557,
-0.0300570503,
0.052004341,
-0.018739447,
-0.053280212,
-0.0182523634,
0.0239922516,
0.0170866232,
-0.0246974435,
-0.0439315289,
0.0168635864,
-0.0094986893,
-0.016492011,
-0.0376027599,
-0.0431350358,
-0.0165314302,
0.0326447748,
-0.0548687354,
-0.0281667318,
1.605255315e-34,
0.0397392027,
-0.0168977026,
0.0121005243,
-0.0179241151,
0.0188750513,
-0.0184078272,
-0.0306360181,
-0.0310098138,
0.0434498489,
-0.0508493632,
-0.0118631488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01937v1 | Efficient-Empathy: Towards Efficient and Effective Selection of Empathy Data | 2024-07-02T04:11:52 | 2024-07-02T04:11:52 | Linzhuang Sun, Hao Liang, Jingxuan Wei, Linkun Sun, Bihui Yu, Bin Cui, Wentao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, with the rapid advancements in large language models (LLMs),
achieving excellent empathetic response capability has become a crucial
prerequisite. Consequently, managing and understanding large-scale video
datasets has gained increasing importance. However, empathetic data are
typically trained without any quality selection, leading to inefficient data
usage and wasted computational resources. Additionally, using raw data can
result in low performance in empathetic dialogues. In this work, we present
Efficient-Empathy, a sensibility and rationality score-based data selection
algorithm that automatically selects sensibility and rationality data while
discarding low-quality data. With only the sensibility data (59% of the full
dataset), our trained sensibility model efficiently achieves state-of-the-art
(SoTA) performance. Furthermore, with multiple data selection hyperparameters,
the sensibility model demonstrates SoTA performance, showcasing the robustness
of our method. By integrating sensibility and rationality data with a MoE
structure, we achieve even higher performance, demonstrating the effectiveness
of our Efficient-Empathy algorithm. | [
0.0003860326,
0.0688269958,
-0.0298611,
0.0511481315,
0.0144834323,
0.0645776689,
-0.0127270985,
0.0068934588,
0.010282727,
-0.0154928379,
-0.0446860753,
0.0042717271,
-0.0215536784,
-0.0125466026,
0.0093397517,
-0.0782329366,
0.0313323326,
0.0029406094,
0.0718986169,
-0.0251340531,
-0.010518562,
0.0381845944,
0.0006487911,
0.0242355578,
-0.0207119156,
-0.0179830007,
0.0292134862,
0.0232810955,
0.0356797203,
-0.0378088392,
0.0137620168,
0.0299762972,
0.0060044751,
-0.0225926023,
0.0000020093,
-0.0490959734,
0.0203301068,
-0.0553792417,
-0.0041059963,
-0.0003638792,
0.0368141234,
-0.0478903651,
0.0099033741,
0.0346436724,
-0.058696866,
0.0045484868,
0.0030889772,
-0.0026219443,
0.0518670082,
0.0519693084,
-0.0372163393,
-0.0037575678,
0.0030903865,
-0.0188247673,
-0.0192824323,
-0.0119681796,
0.0184741076,
0.0142383054,
-0.0010976451,
-0.0210210979,
-0.0435660705,
0.0109160868,
-0.0060424856,
-0.0395674966,
0.0097749848,
-0.0002734062,
-0.0117498012,
-0.038158033,
-0.0246891379,
0.0914121494,
0.0136498297,
0.0635150149,
0.0342475101,
-0.0139572294,
-0.0000945963,
-0.0571770854,
-0.0562561601,
-0.0084839268,
0.0255223308,
0.048538059,
-0.0236296598,
0.0307829585,
0.0200192165,
0.0579395778,
0.0234865192,
-0.0216593761,
-0.0237848517,
0.011514524,
0.030618839,
-0.0060710348,
-0.0604110472,
-0.0075113093,
-0.0071365475,
0.0050947568,
-0.0312340595,
0.0053187362,
-0.0455822311,
0.0331091769,
-0.0125449691,
-0.0249274056,
0.018801095,
0.0364704728,
0.0250380822,
0.029003337,
0.0542074814,
0.0408334173,
0.0420005508,
0.0178541597,
-0.0030402357,
-0.011791477,
-0.0320406742,
0.0326654129,
-0.0190415047,
0.0236696023,
-0.0568119362,
-0.0152077759,
-0.0435236208,
0.0070086452,
-0.0576579496,
0.0057270075,
-0.0305244867,
0.0033375183,
-0.0040379274,
-0.0206044745,
-0.0366651937,
0.0491189137,
-0.0479435921,
0.0226870999,
-0.0007941748,
-0.0671054497,
-0.0002002313,
0.0309006386,
0.0133014107,
-0.0244981777,
0.0357758962,
0.0392453894,
-0.0179439541,
-0.0367358439,
-0.030292118,
0.0215528477,
-0.0023587358,
-0.0448826067,
0.0115879215,
-0.0041443463,
0.0292549264,
-0.0162993837,
0.0092346882,
-0.0384378545,
-0.0103070559,
-0.0059004342,
-0.0626651049,
0.0608704537,
-0.0074500404,
0.0275827833,
0.0092333984,
-0.0069951974,
0.0001292289,
0.0567509271,
0.0291037261,
-0.0274848826,
0.079427138,
-0.0131875044,
0.0169895962,
0.0089117996,
-0.0298666079,
0.0288947057,
-0.0407375023,
0.0068418034,
-0.029274404,
0.0363169983,
0.0709253028,
0.0348802097,
-0.0379513167,
-0.0400433913,
0.0645762756,
0.0666140541,
-0.0108542424,
0.0520628467,
-0.0220762361,
0.0710930824,
0.0006718006,
-0.0101962797,
-0.048294045,
0.0932638571,
0.0233973954,
-0.0445985198,
0.0079628145,
0.0148230661,
-0.0503150672,
-0.0351720713,
-0.0199987702,
-0.0158007666,
0.0251717884,
0.0136722652,
-0.0141612105,
-0.0136937369,
-0.0430982225,
-0.0128424698,
0.0309109818,
-0.061362192,
0.0034176533,
-0.0276183728,
0.0245074984,
0.056878496,
0.0342513919,
-0.0260336306,
-0.0050930334,
-0.0074836137,
0.0114893606,
-0.0112169683,
0.0686802417,
-0.0372221805,
0.0718816742,
-0.0934263542,
-0.0221587531,
0.0216724258,
0.0082783634,
0.0004772442,
-0.0506086908,
0.0228079073,
-0.0078791594,
-0.0331981666,
-0.0000973933,
0.0456249155,
-0.0107571501,
-0.0057147313,
0.022297347,
0.0039112587,
0.0433803685,
0.0044785524,
0.0092308782,
-0.0394849069,
0.0035129054,
-0.0058571841,
0.0329549238,
0.0624541081,
-0.0541181378,
-0.0406364165,
0.0200685672,
-0.0651766732,
-0.0132899685,
0.0910808817,
-0.0340275317,
-0.0088480581,
0.0401283056,
-0.0204068907,
-0.0235404056,
-0.0686356574,
0.0252315048,
-0.0336856805,
0.0278070588,
0.0091467034,
0.0240405314,
-0.029483404,
-0.0131326886,
0.0221328754,
-0.0058970177,
0.0085586244,
-0.0741951093,
-0.000672508,
0.0379575416,
-0.0065402165,
0.0177274719,
-0.0281429477,
-0.0127311042,
-0.0415659472,
-0.0267186724,
-0.0878256112,
-0.0244683251,
-0.0164584909,
-0.0071590673,
-0.0263202395,
-0.0095366864,
-0.0273561291,
0.0103905657,
0.0022175973,
0.0856558532,
0.0145250857,
-0.0067250258,
0.012580472,
-0.0154807903,
0.026098242,
-0.0402832255,
-0.0055906614,
0.0161979105,
0.0219268799,
-0.0179227758,
0.0043051937,
0.0009875143,
-0.014029297,
-0.0324939601,
0.0101788249,
-0.0250535794,
-0.1090781763,
-0.0177437812,
0.0077969418,
-0.0477709249,
0.0445650741,
0.0255054906,
0.0406242386,
-0.0008413975,
-0.0031008497,
-0.0345465019,
0.0396149941,
0.0016302442,
0.0521871708,
-0.0594707541,
-0.0184409339,
0.010214733,
0.0375659578,
-0.0227321833,
0.0418156274,
-0.0652260929,
0.0284263026,
0.0332258753,
-0.054888729,
0.0035640325,
0.0053969915,
-0.0115905674,
-0.0033385784,
-0.0183928795,
-0.0501895919,
0.0577374883,
0.0237899274,
-0.0419915244,
-0.0382412113,
0.0149062779,
0.0035259398,
0.0568932667,
-0.046874769,
0.0028744591,
-0.0475716814,
-0.0248488076,
-0.0353210419,
-0.058354862,
0.0154996272,
-0.0159302242,
0.0439042002,
-0.0412990823,
-0.0369836837,
0.0262487754,
-0.0442783572,
-0.0298864059,
-0.0102023156,
-0.0524558239,
-0.0030983449,
0.0150733069,
-0.0133725237,
-0.0265498944,
-0.0345060788,
0.0140961716,
0.0342204198,
0.0002124346,
0.0116197588,
-0.0144223729,
-0.0194014106,
0.0603555627,
0.0316820033,
0.051031556,
-0.0336095653,
0.151658982,
0.0479862653,
0.0455454364,
-0.0269512497,
0.0132246064,
0.0523541905,
0.0287685078,
0.0314447172,
-0.0086933644,
0.0158351976,
0.0579337552,
-0.005689932,
0.0251468122,
0.1100801975,
-0.0122083127,
-0.0717346221,
0.0087930784,
-0.015227804,
-0.007170001,
0.0313137397,
-0.0152471727,
-0.0265802871,
-0.0569812991,
0.0149078276,
0.0665943772,
-0.0098605482,
-0.0679239407,
0.0049319593,
-0.0738726184,
0.0927078202,
-0.0082052303,
0.0332237259,
-0.0375204124,
-0.0241572969,
0.0363233574,
-0.029856855,
0.0424409136,
-0.0165762659,
-0.0223936755,
-0.0278787035,
0.0178826731,
0.0111774206,
-0.0139671378,
0.0411227047,
-0.0154409669,
0.0426421314,
-0.0006410348,
0.0973843634,
0.0004334167,
-0.0374884196,
-0.0308494512,
-0.0253772829,
-0.0126457959,
-0.0335045308,
0.0551133715,
-0.0168476738,
-0.0108122453,
-0.0034203555,
0.0913786888,
0.0124115944,
-0.0089768218,
-0.0102677261,
0.0521332063,
-0.0441640764,
-0.0190946832,
-0.001801497,
0.0064262636,
0.0290078502,
0.0886381865,
0.0212725289,
-0.050705947,
0.000595126,
0.0449326634,
-0.0414676331,
-0.0424118675,
0.0116345715,
0.0227678064,
0.0185751524,
-0.0314126536,
-0.0446614698,
-0.0352298915,
0.0366117656,
0.0368717201,
-0.0302980933,
-0.0398511104,
0.0194040183,
0.0203973763,
-0.029221246,
0.040946383,
-0.0134617956,
-0.0052026105,
-0.0468358807,
0.0459148325,
0.015758045,
-0.0286680236,
-0.0037582389,
-0.0100532863,
0.0152001567,
-0.0544655472,
0.0049999645,
0.0430455916,
0.0212963652,
0.0451832302,
0.0030751273,
-0.0625148714,
-0.0034824677,
0.0065394184,
-0.0370770916,
0.0492499098,
0.0419691131,
0.0109905535,
-0.0214515664,
0.0833320469,
-0.0004062816,
0.0641447902,
0.0268589724,
0.0218446516,
-0.0209033024,
-0.0356166475,
-0.0410682447,
0.0077455631,
0.0282408558,
0.0040928801,
-0.0311467294,
-0.0502977706,
-0.0019150741,
-0.0156689137,
0.0314608924,
-0.0753851905,
0.009930647,
0.0168035273,
0.0277291015,
-0.039284274,
-0.0811263621,
-0.0560584851,
-0.0446989052,
-0.0510229357,
0.0316114835,
-0.0471543334,
-0.022424927,
0.0015720945,
0.018601222,
0.004528984,
0.0153354546,
-0.0049821474,
0.0065897675,
0.005881628,
0.0702572465,
0.0161504243,
-0.0142860981,
0.0000217396,
0.0183460359,
0.0033414203,
-0.0389337279,
0.0183046181,
0.0293278508,
0.0330402888,
-0.0400038101,
0.0461201444,
-0.0166124217,
0.0057676611,
-0.0290242955,
0.0374761447,
-0.0031634981,
-0.0694341883,
0.0113821449,
0.0294610262,
-0.0256560259,
0.0213556252,
0.0369490013,
-0.0802948326,
0.0106117493,
-0.017989682,
0.008371287,
-0.0278761219,
-0.0171372909,
0.0714019611,
-0.0099737383,
-0.0109671475,
0.0399924479,
-0.0396961011,
-0.0493056811,
0.0140830213,
-0.0427647568,
-0.0457344279,
-0.0329069458,
0.0340447724,
0.0306653567,
-0.0234301221,
0.0204050504,
-0.0253675319,
-0.0180355869,
-0.1081136987,
-0.0220890064,
0.0116170626,
-5.7914432e-33,
0.0296181161,
0.0206761677,
-0.055225458,
-0.0336731747,
-0.0288898759,
0.0145290615,
-0.0293826889,
0.0130876182,
-0.0359520987,
0.0552397445,
-0.0215562992,
0.0454488322,
0.0069997739,
0.0249155015,
-0.0075930613,
-0.0329581723,
0.0332277678,
-0.012164711,
-0.0366377197,
0.015448248,
-0.0071194288,
0.0266121607,
0.0339834467,
-0.0605869964,
-0.0355748273,
0.0087728389,
-0.0083067017,
0.0365694836,
0.0770899728,
0.0687219724,
0.013590089,
0.0509069301,
0.0221218131,
-0.0109754829,
0.0031965172,
0.042061951,
-0.0362690203,
0.0027119175,
0.0065392852,
-0.0001506546,
-0.0199136175,
-0.042178113,
0.0224173591,
0.0190376174,
-0.0303297918,
-0.0510862693,
-0.0044893543,
-0.0356442891,
-0.0134558082,
0.0322781317,
-0.0340504944,
0.0015322326,
-0.0570055321,
-0.0394624956,
0.031107666,
0.0202220362,
-0.0219540596,
0.0356475972,
-0.0156120043,
0.0174837317,
-0.0453768522,
-0.0135852443,
0.0222998541,
-0.0288318917,
0.0290118959,
0.0934248194,
-0.0034555686,
-0.013720708,
0.0412786007,
0.0301345307,
0.0289274435,
0.0697335079,
0.0455673747,
0.0750841871,
-0.0302939713,
-0.0873705298,
-0.0474711023,
0.0048328359,
0.0368250459,
0.0489454307,
0.0199282747,
-0.0061275205,
-0.0211537983,
-0.0100540658,
-0.0295226965,
-0.0523232147,
-0.0120726889,
-0.0082422532,
0.0107759275,
-0.0096295318,
-0.0268971138,
-0.0100094471,
0.0249008648,
-0.0280279722,
0.0281713158,
0.0345841311,
-0.0459988788,
0.0428452305,
0.0285433885,
0.0362012945,
-0.0138567798,
-0.0497538261,
0.0281568561,
0.0200570691,
0.0384940505,
-0.0195641145,
-0.0222556274,
0.0303267743,
-0.0087368106,
-0.0166417733,
0.0010220062,
0.0421735644,
-0.0170467664,
0.0414846055,
-0.0200376995,
0.017179152,
0.0066685467,
-0.0053401156,
-0.0353097804,
0.0140250158,
-0.027798051,
-0.0675957426,
0.0081938589,
0.0537298694,
-0.0485494174,
-0.0237375889,
-0.0215444807,
-0.1009317338,
0.0333549678,
-0.0189611353,
-0.0267581828,
0.012448594,
2.661e-7,
-0.0708733946,
0.0303433239,
-0.035018757,
-0.0644214004,
0.0227086321,
0.0796868578,
-0.0068435189,
0.0607382543,
0.0408019349,
-0.0378358774,
0.047110565,
0.0243187975,
0.1075978354,
-0.0003029694,
-0.0922025293,
0.0287910104,
-0.0258728173,
-0.0146624688,
-0.0153441019,
-0.0057345484,
0.0188685227,
0.0537782945,
0.0111946166,
-0.0125830779,
0.0276988912,
-0.0134800849,
0.0033227752,
-0.0534715019,
-0.0053908043,
0.0141445836,
0.0262721553,
-0.0024265288,
-0.0053741676,
-0.0128183393,
-0.0236527435,
0.0439021252,
0.0000225708,
0.10743808,
0.0087198047,
-0.0813151374,
0.0075242985,
0.0160591882,
-0.0100828987,
-0.0178866442,
0.0454197265,
-0.0607703142,
-0.036862094,
0.0160283316,
0.0176384598,
-0.0040363674,
0.01650743,
-0.0260799099,
-0.027653873,
0.0371372104,
0.0397541672,
-0.0324890055,
0.0013430081,
-0.0549269803,
0.044910796,
-0.0360310003,
-0.045336578,
-0.0522231124,
-0.0091283005,
-0.0105444686,
0.0468182564,
-0.0233366787,
0.0115707917,
1.69501774e-34,
0.0157924853,
-0.0099026021,
0.0037310761,
-0.0062579135,
0.0221861303,
0.0103992587,
0.0300719049,
0.0239001531,
0.0397961363,
-0.0549341664,
0.0139916288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01929v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01929v1 | What We Talk About When We Talk About LMs: Implicit Paradigm Shifts and the Ship of Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:45:55 | 2024-07-02T03:45:55 | Shengqi Zhu, Jeffrey M. Rzeszotarski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The term Language Models (LMs), as a time-specific collection of models of
interest, is constantly reinvented, with its referents updated much like the
$\textit{Ship of Theseus}$ replaces its parts but remains the same ship in
essence. In this paper, we investigate this $\textit{Ship of Language Models}$
problem, wherein scientific evolution takes the form of continuous, implicit
retrofits of key existing terms. We seek to initiate a novel perspective of
scientific progress, in addition to the more well-studied emergence of new
terms. To this end, we construct the data infrastructure based on recent NLP
publications. Then, we perform a series of text-based analyses toward a
detailed, quantitative understanding of the use of Language Models as a term of
art. Our work highlights how systems and theories influence each other in
scientific discourse, and we call for attention to the transformation of this
Ship that we all are contributing to. | [
0.0472827144,
0.065497309,
-0.0492016263,
-0.0100684185,
-0.0475821123,
-0.0266198404,
-0.0260069557,
0.0302383173,
-0.0406037271,
-0.0864334926,
-0.007263964,
-0.0479884632,
0.0340048037,
0.0183226634,
0.0590107925,
-0.0500217043,
0.0433944352,
-0.0039661187,
-0.0019054089,
0.0089873336,
-0.005427531,
-0.0121758003,
0.033015117,
0.0167803355,
0.0372207388,
0.0024691196,
0.0077688908,
-0.0658806339,
-0.0366799049,
-0.0301961266,
-0.0024302029,
0.0310838316,
0.0429146625,
0.0426622294,
0.0000019399,
-0.0540614948,
0.020094512,
0.0108493166,
-0.0049740053,
0.0287556313,
0.0614286587,
-0.0184495077,
-0.0076357541,
-0.0663426593,
-0.0233411845,
-0.0006471762,
0.0566795953,
-0.0184477344,
-0.0283438247,
0.0168649331,
-0.0030118818,
-0.054130204,
0.0504926518,
-0.0350758098,
0.0040039127,
-0.0017643679,
0.0694124699,
0.0057063191,
0.0543709062,
0.0471901856,
-0.0301817674,
0.0644463375,
-0.0220434479,
-0.0071964725,
-0.0008385313,
0.0059088604,
0.0397037566,
-0.0063583343,
0.0146350069,
0.0097192163,
0.0615173578,
-0.04242732,
0.0044062082,
-0.012610089,
-0.0347188748,
0.0438791662,
-0.053441681,
0.0186802112,
0.0125286626,
0.0196644645,
0.0688629597,
-0.0516406856,
0.0550092272,
0.0657016113,
-0.0183091853,
0.11827185,
0.0150388787,
-0.0274014752,
-0.0235045124,
-0.0231715646,
-0.0083356285,
-0.0763849765,
-0.0102357566,
0.0352685228,
0.015226068,
0.0410607532,
0.0307145938,
0.0152608696,
0.0285894349,
-0.0519620292,
0.0443069264,
-0.0198010337,
0.0048076995,
0.0363461077,
0.037512131,
0.0403264351,
-0.0277901515,
-0.0452680178,
-0.0051369988,
0.0461532138,
-0.0754129887,
-0.0553041846,
-0.0125566982,
-0.0084836241,
0.0039934507,
0.0072452412,
0.013887261,
0.0165405311,
0.0129522989,
-0.0409882218,
-0.0415899903,
-0.0081588197,
-0.0322738029,
0.0275752973,
-0.0390091799,
0.017448321,
0.02060459,
0.0481357649,
-0.0255109798,
-0.0467374437,
0.0194981992,
-0.0091973888,
-0.062497247,
-0.0091018351,
-0.0015328546,
0.0398284756,
0.0410901234,
0.0033905606,
0.0005521603,
0.0054006525,
-0.0778409839,
-0.0089775305,
-0.0101231569,
-0.0671139956,
-0.0139417415,
0.0322795548,
-0.0126701379,
-0.0421560518,
-0.0158595927,
-0.0164802521,
-0.0912644193,
0.0052489447,
-0.060574349,
0.0317453519,
0.0362325422,
0.0079808524,
0.0202455744,
0.0298130196,
0.0478374809,
-0.0750694945,
0.0604596213,
-0.0275123548,
0.0202303398,
0.0490270555,
-0.0114684412,
0.0367632993,
-0.0615125075,
-0.0027875279,
0.0048026009,
-0.001319017,
-0.030817017,
0.0458217636,
-0.0088836187,
-0.0130799524,
0.0345859341,
0.0521481819,
-0.0022964936,
0.0725675896,
0.0266590305,
-0.0578700677,
0.0305688865,
0.0004442777,
0.0198535398,
-0.0394036807,
-0.0184883587,
-0.008077628,
-0.023635162,
-0.0207645185,
0.0043537836,
-0.0213828031,
-0.0166235212,
0.0280445479,
-0.0066296146,
-0.0295410901,
0.0480457991,
0.0030634131,
0.0353296809,
0.0350121595,
0.0339301042,
-0.0150468573,
0.0055715819,
-0.0341611058,
0.0174267106,
0.026898006,
0.0304437801,
-0.0246551186,
-0.0102132205,
0.0192115884,
0.0017110452,
0.0624210276,
0.0229945462,
-0.0041929856,
-0.0359971449,
0.0248643644,
0.0330152139,
-0.033263687,
0.0211102832,
-0.0121140778,
-0.0507782809,
0.0157563165,
-0.0281682964,
-0.0140725151,
-0.0525963716,
0.0445670448,
-0.0736489892,
0.0202533416,
-0.0601734594,
-0.0457578115,
0.0300190784,
0.0192652065,
-0.0109893102,
0.0474263392,
0.0316404477,
-0.0174142905,
0.0062517459,
0.0410292782,
0.0084183542,
0.0768678859,
0.050598193,
0.0043949527,
0.0484047644,
-0.0154139763,
0.0251888316,
-0.0136356195,
0.0702968687,
-0.0472001806,
0.0754322931,
0.0115156835,
0.0584127083,
-0.0537226461,
-0.0095092859,
-0.0596598238,
0.0296430159,
-0.012571265,
0.0673851818,
0.0233618878,
-0.023232108,
0.0341272242,
0.0095984749,
-0.0384048037,
0.0364002101,
0.0348549038,
-0.0197143275,
0.0615742132,
-0.0380063988,
-0.0249669291,
-0.0120636141,
-0.0234396718,
-0.0271860678,
0.0253979173,
0.0004139911,
0.0239042565,
-0.0271485224,
-0.022665808,
0.0533167534,
0.0372336619,
0.0084158387,
0.0313835889,
0.0247832723,
0.051727172,
-0.0167417657,
-0.0413431078,
-0.0666353628,
-0.0227948762,
-0.0432027243,
0.0523634069,
-0.0059338161,
0.004391598,
-0.0662302822,
-0.0107314019,
-0.0862114504,
0.0040362882,
-0.0277553406,
0.0271341968,
0.0454623066,
0.0095110675,
0.0340774767,
-0.0123349186,
0.0189528223,
0.0654048622,
0.0473883003,
-0.0362742394,
-0.045781441,
-0.0546271503,
-0.0450780578,
-0.0267386809,
-0.0189408939,
-0.0194308385,
0.0134633603,
0.0648847893,
-0.0169180706,
-0.0288232993,
0.0079444181,
0.08490289,
-0.0519694015,
-0.0171928369,
0.0283323042,
-0.0427946635,
-0.0489289276,
0.0166273713,
-0.0368142091,
-0.044097092,
0.0096751899,
-0.02054061,
-0.0043670987,
-0.0258094165,
-0.0434024706,
-0.0085598435,
0.0817600638,
-0.0000760839,
-0.0110652093,
0.0978798866,
0.0053305044,
-0.0289001279,
-0.0058169928,
-0.0072194301,
-0.0142406803,
0.0366302766,
-0.0702101886,
0.0318209119,
0.0083162664,
-0.0009223846,
0.01767781,
-0.0069106063,
-0.0410016254,
0.0588504076,
0.0368377753,
-0.0238210764,
-0.0356043987,
0.021919921,
0.0162311178,
-0.0078929896,
0.0184243862,
-0.0029210781,
-0.0413508415,
-0.0135927554,
0.0162076522,
-0.0057825758,
0.0296345018,
0.0133198192,
-0.0054944204,
0.0421959274,
-0.0007511179,
0.0120300073,
-0.0256020389,
0.0005672034,
0.0697960407,
-0.0219989661,
-0.0734166428,
-0.0075630122,
0.0006311753,
-0.0561545715,
0.0000858197,
0.0682123601,
0.0328512341,
0.0032294653,
0.0592673905,
-0.0170964561,
-0.0196547378,
0.0311487261,
-0.0069659883,
-0.0711650029,
0.0550876223,
0.0032123164,
-0.0470971912,
-0.01101196,
-0.0492353328,
-0.0452861562,
-0.0479722731,
-0.0064296015,
0.00252883,
-0.0450916439,
0.0492576025,
-0.0501146466,
0.0080978395,
0.0304376706,
-0.0005283877,
0.0443781912,
-0.0022337714,
0.0061977035,
0.0146484589,
-0.0127245551,
-0.0399207212,
-0.0019571541,
-0.0335216857,
0.0420173928,
0.0232654251,
0.0554773025,
-0.0564884134,
-0.0420915261,
0.0453488901,
-0.004887552,
-0.0050814459,
-0.0243879929,
-0.0382560231,
0.0278461035,
0.0091805225,
-0.0284679029,
-0.0303650536,
-0.0240772795,
-0.0252098162,
-0.0149766933,
0.0745089799,
-0.0178281628,
-0.0573403537,
-0.0628901049,
-0.0047643469,
-0.0370248482,
0.0664699152,
-0.0008380418,
-0.0285458732,
-0.0044098324,
-0.0482691713,
0.0152686834,
0.0830250606,
-0.0882046297,
-0.0296852048,
-0.0247080047,
-0.0415580794,
-0.0521075688,
-0.002628953,
-0.0143102864,
0.0009738728,
0.0624531321,
0.020111993,
0.0018378457,
-0.0577481724,
-0.0213433579,
0.0226152111,
0.0079651857,
-0.0020055911,
-0.0269454215,
-0.0206159092,
0.039162945,
0.0179844741,
-0.0178296715,
0.0074542058,
-0.0051412219,
-0.1062900349,
0.0042666625,
0.0224726629,
0.0302783698,
-0.0378420725,
0.0258415397,
-0.06628903,
0.003844802,
0.0167895723,
0.0157251451,
0.0546552055,
-0.019775752,
0.0158259273,
0.0096931476,
0.0190370418,
-0.0224627741,
-0.0049392865,
-0.0094611961,
0.0297335889,
-0.0290013254,
-0.0340065286,
0.0405392423,
-0.0100491112,
0.0412781127,
-0.0593984574,
-0.0544937961,
0.0220108498,
-0.0692780837,
-0.0409571528,
-0.0364583954,
-0.0202399846,
-0.0085305581,
-0.0026134136,
0.044617001,
-0.0204540659,
0.0318425335,
-0.0149358045,
0.0747130513,
-0.0283073988,
0.0195776373,
0.0251520667,
0.0138635635,
0.0095676733,
0.019628549,
0.0329472497,
0.0095117325,
-0.1023251563,
0.0253337082,
-0.0255826917,
0.012071521,
0.0283583812,
-0.0180348549,
-0.012765076,
0.0159147624,
-0.0712881237,
-0.069278352,
-0.0032388128,
0.0009783788,
0.0322491452,
0.0070047788,
0.0578441024,
-0.0380032063,
-0.0310859904,
-0.0524513833,
-0.0135143474,
0.034330301,
-0.0297187101,
0.0284511093,
0.0317882188,
-0.0246479865,
0.0206230562,
0.0347391702,
-0.0011432068,
0.0326054543,
0.0208973754,
0.0046076369,
0.0315706022,
-0.0154704982,
-0.0057802084,
-0.0287177041,
0.0051307194,
0.017253777,
-0.0778610855,
-0.0133181503,
0.0329516679,
-0.0007462361,
0.0140685057,
-0.0250129942,
-0.0005318664,
0.0955505893,
0.0241655335,
-0.0267513096,
-0.0531721041,
0.0750716552,
-0.0191863906,
-0.005497036,
-0.0015683554,
-5.810604493e-33,
-0.0105629219,
-0.0095227854,
0.0329505131,
0.0113541046,
-0.0676965863,
-0.0011950558,
-0.0284723118,
0.0464523248,
-0.0391601436,
0.0157628153,
-0.0108476393,
-0.0227438752,
-0.024882149,
-0.0118907504,
0.0473334417,
0.0405358784,
-0.0018339189,
-0.0195760056,
0.0028030188,
-0.0594428033,
0.0276394505,
-0.0216016285,
0.0717706233,
-0.0435503982,
0.1034789234,
0.0076833223,
0.0119677596,
0.0433683582,
0.0035193714,
0.0028853626,
-0.022144977,
0.0251125954,
0.0459186323,
-0.0648297817,
0.0095081525,
-0.0128206098,
0.0216089338,
0.0054141572,
0.0722163096,
-0.0148400301,
0.015054333,
-0.0341732204,
0.0480198786,
0.0110491617,
-0.0569631755,
0.0205594506,
0.0289391056,
-0.034156017,
-0.0169674959,
0.0306583792,
-0.0250555035,
0.0144855017,
-0.0180361904,
0.0269870702,
0.0071236282,
-0.01307014,
-0.0146187665,
0.01941902,
-0.0315269642,
0.056293156,
0.0399808362,
0.0384614691,
0.0252558179,
0.0180545878,
0.0229260772,
0.0519509465,
0.0255829524,
0.0366468281,
-0.0039080484,
-0.0046278164,
0.0523278378,
0.0644791424,
0.0104718385,
-0.0018949503,
-0.0012494986,
-0.022935871,
-0.0199687779,
-0.0448300019,
0.0389673188,
0.0115727372,
0.0029469945,
0.0320157111,
-0.0096292226,
-0.0387010649,
-0.0438544825,
-0.0573164709,
-0.0043063685,
-0.0135582983,
-0.0323952995,
-0.0179663226,
0.0236593354,
-0.0001197927,
0.0053715995,
-0.0621187314,
-0.0906712562,
-0.0379667915,
-0.0217204336,
0.0198435802,
0.031723462,
0.0313547514,
-0.0707104877,
-0.012971893,
-0.0385581665,
0.0452241339,
0.0078933705,
0.0071085412,
-0.0400291122,
0.0175835229,
0.0068650865,
-0.0180144664,
0.0176546127,
-0.0732468069,
0.0205733571,
-0.02162656,
0.0202487484,
0.0207831059,
0.0108467685,
0.0216344669,
0.0580045842,
-0.0025613816,
-0.0169525184,
0.0447080098,
-0.006326959,
0.013470077,
-0.0112590063,
-0.0198760238,
-0.027335871,
0.0417483002,
0.0961229131,
-0.0073808567,
-0.0188837834,
-0.0344609022,
2.781e-7,
0.0758631229,
0.0753788427,
0.0048542162,
0.0011683096,
0.06339553,
-0.0020624911,
-0.0486907363,
-0.0124194333,
0.0022989067,
0.0039839293,
-0.037070252,
-0.0067227944,
-0.0020280045,
0.0085822912,
-0.0154758403,
-0.0179394875,
-0.0788100064,
-0.0159006175,
-0.0384173393,
0.0060953586,
-0.0482217856,
0.0256197378,
0.0233051367,
0.0020029671,
-0.0955170244,
-0.0281009506,
0.0385035723,
-0.0456402041,
0.014307051,
0.0536254384,
0.0113717169,
0.0166665744,
0.0127754593,
-0.0200430062,
0.0069392766,
0.0402486958,
-0.0153819295,
-0.0010890571,
0.0086500905,
0.0253565628,
0.0176569019,
-0.0196420457,
0.0030512172,
-0.0571100861,
0.0354047492,
-0.0287027769,
-0.0480891503,
-0.0499501824,
-0.0409188904,
0.0466582924,
0.0073800771,
-0.0106729129,
-0.0274237059,
0.0137148807,
0.0051466059,
0.0239200238,
-0.0243110657,
-0.0516954549,
-0.0320484713,
0.0509735458,
-0.0339612961,
-0.0600701906,
-0.0064754994,
-0.0154073099,
0.0012683343,
-0.0370605327,
0.0121015823,
2.046200695e-34,
0.02598501,
-0.0060155201,
0.0279493276,
0.0515341237,
0.0122646866,
0.0017446948,
0.0326504819,
0.04228108,
0.036443118,
-0.054495763,
-0.008066657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01920v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01920v1 | To Forget or Not? Towards Practical Knowledge Unlearning for Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:34:16 | 2024-07-02T03:34:16 | Bozhong Tian, Xiaozhuan Liang, Siyuan Cheng, Qingbin Liu, Mengru Wang, Dianbo Sui, Xi Chen, Huajun Chen, Ningyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MM | Large Language Models (LLMs) trained on extensive corpora inevitably retain
sensitive data, such as personal privacy information and copyrighted material.
Recent advancements in knowledge unlearning involve updating LLM parameters to
erase specific knowledge. However, current unlearning paradigms are mired in
vague forgetting boundaries, often erasing knowledge indiscriminately. In this
work, we introduce KnowUnDo, a benchmark containing copyrighted content and
user privacy domains to evaluate if the unlearning process inadvertently erases
essential knowledge. Our findings indicate that existing unlearning methods
often suffer from excessive unlearning. To address this, we propose a simple
yet effective method, MemFlex, which utilizes gradient information to precisely
target and unlearn sensitive parameters. Experimental results show that MemFlex
is superior to existing methods in both precise knowledge unlearning and
general knowledge retaining of LLMs. Code and dataset will be released at
https://github.com/zjunlp/KnowUnDo. | [
0.0130812433,
0.111451067,
-0.0185754113,
0.0669003204,
-0.040350873,
0.000572404,
0.0468024611,
0.0189218335,
0.0248058774,
-0.0285734981,
-0.0617172793,
-0.0120080393,
-0.019862337,
-0.0048369132,
-0.0118750548,
0.0128865847,
0.031952437,
-0.0052143796,
0.0012759827,
-0.0411320068,
0.0055819284,
0.0136518916,
0.021048246,
-0.0206776019,
0.0005279055,
-0.0387386493,
0.0146192769,
-0.0206728112,
0.013007584,
0.0070698452,
0.0530693792,
0.0507758036,
0.0217849258,
0.0767448768,
0.0000018253,
-0.0625710785,
-0.0481171161,
0.0135076242,
-0.0172861423,
0.0788336843,
0.032204438,
-0.0034189557,
-0.0038043091,
0.0066397428,
-0.0307542924,
0.0127444491,
0.00660341,
0.0349987186,
0.0520155802,
0.0851175413,
-0.0120438393,
-0.0193710029,
0.0010308108,
-0.0504392758,
-0.0085408362,
-0.0569504201,
0.0438901559,
-0.0317134447,
-0.0535888039,
-0.0207783002,
0.0052142702,
0.0653616041,
0.0051270053,
0.014075187,
-0.0151929157,
0.0114265094,
-0.0081332782,
0.0003092661,
0.0134571344,
0.059175171,
0.0010577609,
-0.0179317631,
0.0377142802,
0.0058356998,
0.0243966039,
0.0086269407,
-0.0193717387,
0.0411227904,
-0.0314375386,
0.0262064785,
-0.0455614738,
-0.0439485647,
0.0750746429,
0.0178495254,
0.0104777273,
0.0455376022,
0.0145439133,
-0.0194945298,
0.0317018703,
-0.0424943715,
0.0089260209,
-0.0323051773,
0.0536369383,
0.0004769695,
0.007652408,
0.0186986681,
-0.0417887829,
-0.0106868669,
0.0463718884,
-0.0595577769,
0.0293613076,
-0.0142714987,
-0.0033757829,
0.0757079124,
-0.0283696949,
0.040861275,
-0.0074878605,
0.027805699,
-0.0075795823,
-0.0061007249,
-0.0049205064,
-0.0128465667,
0.0229896754,
0.0711261258,
0.0060014082,
0.023379378,
-0.0158628654,
0.0063070403,
-0.0544672273,
0.0437977947,
-0.0169481579,
-0.0010612669,
0.0006289431,
-0.0135479001,
-0.0209003091,
-0.0082481401,
-0.0106219314,
0.0265483446,
0.012889673,
-0.0205571614,
-0.0042439573,
-0.0289375484,
0.0044317795,
-0.0208782014,
0.0259996988,
0.073490344,
0.0062867259,
-0.0151070757,
-0.0339066051,
-0.0369604267,
0.0231511425,
-0.072793588,
0.0164114758,
-0.0510672145,
0.0253374148,
-0.0154613722,
-0.0108188959,
-0.1062335595,
0.0030879865,
0.0099531431,
-0.0780120939,
0.0471224636,
0.0032387294,
-0.0343288668,
0.01151626,
0.0287293363,
-0.0176810864,
0.0292767137,
-0.0319198854,
0.0492492877,
0.0604078919,
-0.0176851302,
0.0215809252,
0.0231590401,
0.0655463487,
0.0189207811,
-0.0122073116,
0.0027545828,
0.0315790325,
-0.014262625,
0.0157095473,
0.0686188713,
-0.0107986582,
-0.0491947979,
0.0587821379,
0.0189139713,
-0.0201334711,
0.0295134354,
-0.0338826738,
0.0068827672,
0.0270295385,
-0.0045203306,
-0.0766593516,
-0.0201291125,
-0.0498600155,
-0.0067961118,
-0.0089679472,
0.0445475876,
-0.0126136094,
0.0019587632,
-0.001971582,
-0.0415770188,
0.047221873,
0.0297947209,
0.0367322825,
0.0405804999,
0.0056779976,
0.0830284804,
0.0150328269,
-0.0589510463,
0.0266399775,
-0.0096071297,
0.0356830172,
0.0470158234,
0.0461219102,
-0.0626862943,
0.00492104,
-0.023017019,
-0.0101534296,
-0.045714654,
0.0116968453,
-0.0050706551,
0.0653439164,
-0.0467363447,
-0.0552239157,
-0.0061567021,
0.0347102657,
0.0214956813,
0.0471783876,
-0.0066247364,
0.0541569218,
-0.0508035533,
-0.0211691968,
0.0131993787,
-0.0754628405,
-0.0344882235,
0.0061102789,
0.0022987877,
0.0039155078,
0.027359372,
-0.0150345508,
-0.0272560958,
0.0385537446,
0.011704592,
-0.010645953,
-0.0384276174,
-0.0181854852,
-0.0105482619,
0.0376350321,
-0.0102661522,
0.0288525838,
0.0703122243,
-0.0290121958,
0.0032816923,
0.0204023719,
0.0359727107,
0.0839576051,
-0.0364663117,
0.0077109938,
-0.0528179072,
0.01779324,
0.0027290906,
0.0404690914,
-0.035569109,
-0.0181836225,
-0.0130855106,
-0.0433200859,
-0.0052526318,
-0.0190457851,
-0.0436117053,
-0.0102337869,
-0.0198726878,
0.0541882515,
0.0149394795,
-0.0263848044,
-0.0314120464,
-0.0071614115,
-0.0404127277,
0.0013693006,
-0.0271968208,
0.0133827403,
-0.0114728026,
-0.0088979742,
-0.0159988236,
-0.0259556621,
-0.0107230395,
-0.0102417804,
-0.0498134643,
0.0374290831,
-0.008082713,
-0.007692303,
-0.0184592437,
0.0036931674,
-0.0159124807,
0.0191047639,
0.0367248282,
-0.0521929748,
0.0043250327,
0.0209668223,
0.0624122061,
-0.0338304341,
0.0257395953,
-0.0138633158,
0.0014350334,
-0.034444239,
-0.0011905668,
-0.0409115218,
0.0168239102,
-0.0082161678,
0.0514926463,
0.0691508874,
0.0140763214,
-0.0249923151,
-0.0090676593,
-0.0365968496,
-0.0376649797,
-0.044218611,
0.0052171359,
0.0176542327,
0.0089936396,
0.0178438611,
-0.0251564234,
0.004279803,
0.0191054456,
-0.0275603198,
-0.0234633032,
-0.0531925112,
0.0056707901,
-0.024469981,
0.0148454104,
-0.0062961895,
-0.0701114833,
0.0416611843,
-0.0003025417,
0.054740347,
0.009158344,
0.0079233516,
-0.0179448295,
0.0585651882,
0.0134379445,
0.0549439751,
0.0393693745,
-0.0510749444,
-0.0067387139,
0.0026569292,
0.0537801571,
-0.0507272556,
0.0064669638,
-0.0162098128,
-0.0123898434,
0.0070714867,
-0.0464866087,
-0.0479261577,
-0.053799279,
0.006656467,
0.010371997,
-0.0074036219,
-0.0326505192,
-0.0122699626,
-0.0712956041,
0.0510472283,
0.0048575443,
0.0201870874,
0.0262023788,
-0.0074413815,
0.0423215218,
0.0273958817,
-0.0244444776,
0.0055964598,
-0.0121769402,
-0.0256100725,
0.0790724456,
0.0290786121,
0.0115916571,
0.0350708365,
-0.0034127012,
0.0088445134,
-0.0114269238,
0.0141244438,
0.0218581613,
0.0291028023,
-0.0301354919,
0.0023792367,
0.0797376558,
0.0029381185,
-0.0446078144,
-0.0227845982,
0.0563173369,
-0.0138859712,
0.0190076362,
-0.0039363839,
-0.096106194,
0.0053853546,
0.0163555853,
0.047102429,
0.0110433036,
-0.0281708185,
-0.0071781352,
-0.0830262005,
-0.0085849073,
0.0250907745,
-0.0216198768,
-0.0299520567,
-0.0622719973,
-0.0047927713,
-0.0092994068,
0.0492729321,
-0.0089229411,
-0.0178649854,
-0.0235628188,
-0.0024870916,
-0.0309845041,
-0.071507372,
0.0143093998,
-0.0514894016,
0.0485022292,
0.0318886228,
0.0167945474,
-0.0408946536,
-0.0490647778,
0.0250873044,
0.0045207031,
-0.0245423969,
-0.005524721,
0.0514400564,
0.0014509669,
-0.0042403024,
0.0071334024,
0.0859733298,
-0.0308840759,
-0.0441450775,
0.0097938785,
0.0554312989,
0.0058236504,
-0.0314025059,
0.0138520906,
-0.0583940931,
-0.0105430856,
0.0770320445,
0.0022140464,
-0.0327888876,
0.0149570797,
-0.0172559377,
0.0036722391,
0.0049982159,
0.0297188759,
0.0158535149,
-0.0274077486,
-0.0125825331,
-0.0393328518,
0.0104449773,
-0.010134845,
-0.0110804327,
0.0387789793,
0.02855248,
0.0391784571,
-0.0292267427,
-0.0540792271,
0.0007515298,
-0.0624279194,
0.0016313496,
-0.021349594,
-0.0082607809,
-0.008558223,
0.002070735,
-0.021593295,
-0.0099746818,
-0.1018274203,
-0.0773060396,
0.0411359295,
0.0317558795,
0.0169637054,
0.0648861453,
-0.018370511,
-0.0593864508,
0.0968365446,
0.0728257969,
-0.0466566496,
0.0193903949,
0.0395386033,
-0.0380656049,
-0.0115183024,
0.0457694493,
-0.049185697,
-0.0275679175,
0.0765272379,
-0.0208096132,
-0.0076042246,
-0.0074577304,
-0.0114901178,
0.0275286939,
0.0344704539,
-0.0105717871,
0.0157829896,
-0.0389141664,
0.0102950288,
0.0094053531,
-0.0302493609,
-0.0049073482,
-0.0055197626,
0.0697452947,
-0.0036423502,
0.0113901049,
0.0304186083,
0.0443186648,
0.0165075399,
-0.0317607783,
-0.0401121713,
0.0372705385,
0.0014554247,
0.0499216728,
0.0131756393,
-0.0050155655,
0.0661784708,
-0.0079651317,
0.0465347804,
-0.0353782177,
0.0532297306,
0.0001075701,
0.0051006754,
-0.0375173427,
0.0132699404,
0.0016399126,
-0.0590280145,
-0.0402918905,
0.0327226967,
0.0567415208,
-0.0301373228,
-0.0098072654,
-0.0470629036,
-0.0125913946,
-0.0468795486,
0.0109008839,
-0.0203859787,
-0.0372797251,
-0.015436315,
-0.0060880533,
-0.042139072,
0.0813883096,
0.0861358717,
-0.0064259688,
0.041121643,
-0.0075739501,
-0.0092310859,
-0.0446671359,
-0.0169938672,
0.0178902112,
0.017361559,
-0.0406084545,
-0.0210241042,
-0.0210581701,
-0.0777403116,
-0.0127368039,
-0.0187897738,
-0.0196576286,
-0.002861419,
0.0061151627,
0.0646646842,
-0.0048106555,
-0.0037817149,
-0.0645586252,
0.0018836498,
-0.0062522781,
-0.030079931,
0.008123979,
-6.043312334e-33,
0.0405941606,
0.0052069239,
-0.0364498459,
0.0528377034,
0.0112171164,
0.0058544758,
0.0007811012,
-0.0223010946,
-0.0211383644,
-0.0046629645,
-0.0339868069,
-0.0038560969,
-0.0109782526,
0.0323028937,
-0.0194803029,
-0.0253791288,
0.0592007898,
-0.0114323096,
-0.0318416357,
0.0312366616,
0.0713991299,
0.0742922351,
0.0435608625,
-0.0917771012,
0.026109308,
-0.0064181923,
-0.0333220363,
0.0343446769,
-0.0384571217,
0.0381030701,
-0.0428478979,
0.0308922417,
-0.0025174096,
-0.0261530224,
-0.0044690655,
-0.0028740247,
-0.0941298679,
0.0225560945,
-0.0107776308,
0.0229753591,
0.0249857754,
-0.0732636005,
0.0525847711,
-0.0231177304,
0.0027882508,
-0.0200513881,
0.0056399913,
0.0059196041,
-0.0482694022,
-0.0539898798,
-0.0078797806,
-0.0116243046,
-0.0047833039,
-0.0225206371,
0.0514244065,
-0.0471963845,
-0.0067538456,
-0.0116857439,
-0.0865879282,
-0.0213440508,
0.0208993703,
0.0147753805,
0.0743220001,
0.0159492418,
0.012665743,
0.108103469,
0.0411817506,
0.0320296139,
0.0294473749,
0.0030289611,
0.0383838862,
0.0185410716,
-0.011987051,
0.0549917854,
0.0436852761,
-0.0745703802,
-0.0224870872,
0.0025109968,
-0.0413086899,
0.0263524204,
0.0337568447,
0.026605377,
0.0043272977,
-0.0127412919,
-0.0756686255,
-0.0048566358,
-0.0477116257,
0.0082817599,
0.0133022284,
0.0080804387,
-0.029898541,
-0.0117883636,
-0.0058771772,
-0.0632652789,
-0.0469384789,
0.0528730489,
0.0285089724,
-0.0024958716,
-0.0002953488,
0.0156472307,
-0.06009477,
-0.0106753446,
-0.005550182,
-0.0484706014,
0.006484515,
0.0003212104,
0.0776183084,
0.0408529378,
-0.0397689231,
0.0133024696,
-0.0324651338,
0.0192277338,
0.0460677557,
0.0309530757,
0.0067263707,
0.0317381695,
0.0025476979,
0.0189503953,
0.0513703376,
0.0342176855,
-0.0523914099,
0.0263870806,
0.0048215548,
-0.0024150801,
-0.0050099138,
-0.0502723046,
-0.0008219166,
0.0361475907,
0.0642455965,
-0.0306133572,
0.019012399,
-0.0034954625,
2.543e-7,
0.0061701816,
-0.0040540323,
-0.0008985793,
-0.0232801922,
0.0169930793,
0.0603229068,
-0.0241852347,
0.0548092276,
-0.0174498037,
0.0044947998,
-0.0184649508,
0.0064333873,
0.0726254657,
0.0314269252,
-0.1058735773,
-0.0060986485,
-0.024032725,
-0.0271201953,
-0.0566051155,
-0.0032230916,
-0.0145779103,
0.0951089785,
0.0768432394,
-0.0507146195,
0.0173586104,
-0.0498158261,
0.0636831447,
-0.0571355447,
-0.0162683278,
-0.0124441106,
0.0490750372,
0.0598950759,
0.0020834971,
-0.0347087346,
-0.026614977,
0.0263024885,
-0.0300339144,
0.0887477025,
0.0576237254,
-0.0342888162,
-0.0275895372,
-0.0222323444,
-0.004906707,
-0.0435976759,
0.0587435775,
0.0248508397,
-0.0107232463,
-0.0263824183,
-0.0019675256,
-0.0676739141,
0.0262376405,
-0.0237252489,
-0.0072931503,
0.0091126552,
-0.0119513972,
0.0029651204,
-0.0348165631,
-0.0862777978,
-0.0190085042,
-0.0128902374,
-0.0481607541,
-0.0242738593,
0.0064224312,
-0.0202810597,
0.0025263247,
-0.0888770446,
0.0869826525,
1.916390877e-34,
0.0016516016,
-0.0497954115,
-0.0171949714,
0.018645525,
0.0104798935,
-0.0101582594,
0.0119563257,
0.0257306974,
-0.0307073146,
-0.0477886349,
0.0175056029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01911v1 | Investigating the Effects of Large-Scale Pseudo-Stereo Data and Different Speech Foundation Model on Dialogue Generative Spoken Language Model | 2024-07-02T03:22:41 | 2024-07-02T03:22:41 | Yu-Kuan Fu, Cheng-Kuang Lee, Hsiu-Hsuan Wang, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent efforts in Spoken Dialogue Modeling aim to synthesize spoken dialogue
without the need for direct transcription, thereby preserving the wealth of
non-textual information inherent in speech. However, this approach faces a
challenge when speakers talk simultaneously, requiring stereo dialogue data
with speakers recorded on separate channels, a notably scarce resource. To
address this, we have developed an innovative pipeline capable of transforming
single-channel dialogue data into pseudo-stereo data. This expanded our
training dataset from a mere 2,000 to an impressive 17,600 hours, significantly
enriching the diversity and quality of the training examples available. The
inclusion of this pseudo-stereo data has proven to be effective in improving
the performance of spoken dialogue language models. Additionally, we explored
the use of discrete units of different speech foundation models for spoken
dialogue generation. | [
0.0285842437,
0.1185144559,
0.0068673966,
0.024113182,
-0.009764703,
-0.0090459157,
0.0272595938,
-0.0073880898,
-0.0307661295,
-0.0628769174,
-0.0402233228,
-0.0694810748,
0.0332861282,
0.0658189729,
0.0349069238,
-0.0842431262,
0.0038709145,
-0.0603694692,
-0.0189896356,
-0.016528843,
-0.019844871,
0.0326104313,
-0.0555255786,
0.0056041665,
-0.0451927669,
-0.0054676929,
-0.0059722099,
0.0105986949,
-0.0103230206,
0.0027889428,
-0.0009214957,
0.0515079014,
0.0642334595,
0.0015040465,
0.0000018798,
-0.0315708034,
0.0223357491,
-0.002293976,
-0.0357963815,
0.0313103832,
-0.0059824102,
0.011757195,
-0.0134678548,
0.0395401977,
-0.0490838923,
-0.0300287232,
0.022865057,
0.0293775145,
0.057413239,
0.0346027054,
-0.0151919797,
-0.0655963123,
0.0103451824,
-0.0230486132,
-0.0469325446,
0.0110654989,
-0.0142900432,
0.0200970694,
-0.0404771678,
-0.016068805,
0.0085513415,
-0.0008472412,
0.0142178461,
-0.0058426214,
0.0149462055,
-0.0010417864,
-0.0726209506,
-0.033616107,
-0.0050378535,
0.1130182967,
0.0073232898,
0.0052883253,
0.0472161472,
0.0173606481,
-0.0378525183,
-0.0255103931,
-0.0245849174,
0.0343192033,
0.0212367866,
-0.0106367888,
-0.0253432505,
0.0372880027,
-0.0201347116,
-0.0140524153,
-0.0205437616,
-0.008550155,
0.0180050395,
0.0165843926,
-0.0246125311,
-0.0154283401,
-0.0587269962,
-0.0538595021,
-0.0263080262,
-0.032785695,
-0.0383628123,
0.0247025434,
-0.0490300208,
0.0151179098,
-0.012743514,
-0.0418815874,
0.0141265867,
0.0203163344,
-0.0191390924,
0.0095178867,
0.0171051603,
0.0353823341,
-0.0172886886,
0.0063845911,
-0.0288663339,
-0.003049233,
-0.0063837194,
0.013381131,
-0.0568035245,
0.0121888304,
-0.1024659723,
-0.0565094166,
0.0134789301,
0.0132860783,
-0.0061981622,
-0.0013816517,
0.0213335361,
0.0402863845,
-0.0124249058,
-0.0123001803,
0.025429938,
-0.001564358,
-0.0015006936,
0.0328331962,
0.0090616895,
-0.0824185014,
-0.0004210376,
0.0615146719,
0.0187601112,
-0.0066039898,
-0.0150453998,
0.0614439882,
-0.0219973698,
-0.0054203547,
0.0198045969,
-0.0412476696,
-0.0449217632,
-0.0817717388,
-0.0076562637,
-0.0429414324,
0.0387143567,
-0.0098460354,
-0.0206429344,
-0.0229334049,
0.0277968124,
-0.0332976952,
-0.0020971808,
0.0431711972,
-0.0126311108,
0.0353604965,
0.0548054501,
0.0065929443,
0.028220607,
0.072067894,
0.057149183,
-0.0462509617,
0.0319630057,
-0.0065166145,
-0.0502105244,
0.0560468361,
0.0441130325,
0.0386719741,
-0.0310580023,
0.0137243858,
0.0212819576,
0.0388858356,
0.0398332626,
0.0629237965,
-0.0649767369,
-0.006746714,
0.0484263711,
0.0346050113,
0.0182573814,
0.0141470712,
0.0681486651,
0.0619446971,
-0.0046719881,
-0.0028411625,
0.0053288583,
-0.009069114,
0.0220401287,
0.0328776762,
0.0327336118,
0.0358209759,
-0.0520054065,
0.0038868859,
0.021493597,
-0.005852554,
-0.0009191306,
0.0053208326,
0.0151762208,
0.0364206135,
-0.0436334126,
0.0778725967,
-0.0117229065,
-0.0710400492,
-0.0051838718,
0.0163295791,
-0.0120400907,
0.041585777,
0.0287803784,
0.019955609,
-0.0340940952,
-0.0479146913,
-0.0158487745,
0.0658469424,
0.0448711105,
-0.0453365594,
0.0793704465,
-0.0646196976,
-0.0049411864,
-0.0066179442,
0.0089735063,
0.0013457646,
0.0044370643,
0.0113582369,
0.0382141061,
0.0008984474,
0.0428919494,
-0.0040134434,
-0.1140385047,
0.0409440883,
-0.0024423788,
0.0064775534,
0.0329282656,
0.038065102,
-0.0423812643,
-0.0152757159,
0.0278706439,
-0.0242411122,
0.0180358011,
0.056013409,
-0.0757946298,
-0.0504185446,
0.0211078301,
-0.0046413713,
0.0377665944,
0.0190779865,
0.0031587447,
-0.0620408021,
0.0213216264,
-0.0259413514,
0.0433548726,
-0.0415527485,
0.0221390445,
0.0396808535,
0.0337442458,
-0.0080331555,
-0.024477046,
-0.0061346083,
-0.0161288977,
0.0521440879,
0.0172049459,
0.0326959379,
-0.0727977604,
0.0543502979,
0.05002141,
-0.0016464833,
0.0221194252,
-0.0299945958,
-0.0086692069,
-0.0353025012,
-0.0058934069,
-0.0420113988,
-0.0098197488,
-0.0045539141,
-0.0390137173,
0.0160247348,
-0.0047844737,
-0.0128401667,
0.0220308881,
-0.0411562398,
-0.0151211098,
0.0518239811,
-0.0291725695,
-0.025922263,
-0.0024278252,
-0.0186712556,
-0.0324209034,
0.0301431399,
0.0376896933,
0.0352453217,
-0.0244587623,
-0.0332047306,
-0.0245706551,
0.0389527604,
0.0097639849,
0.0543232374,
-0.0163328238,
-0.04684899,
-0.0134275537,
0.0033920268,
0.0192819126,
0.0172413513,
0.0311785359,
-0.0155875888,
0.0033395542,
-0.0420532897,
-0.0370375812,
0.0190689396,
0.0244299136,
0.0562840253,
-0.0203983597,
-0.012190369,
0.0099823689,
0.0101624662,
0.0478838906,
0.0499806069,
-0.0359050073,
0.003906772,
0.041713804,
-0.0595914908,
0.039739687,
-0.0366123728,
-0.0270678606,
0.0354172736,
-0.0146279987,
0.0128489593,
-0.0068740156,
-0.0682881624,
-0.0459075719,
-0.0213952567,
0.0129855406,
-0.0192018803,
0.0479368716,
-0.0231856555,
0.0109090526,
0.0097412402,
0.00086082,
-0.0144660017,
0.0031758859,
-0.0042888317,
-0.0408313163,
0.0489594229,
-0.0649106801,
0.0193519238,
-0.0165783707,
-0.0512903221,
-0.0461334623,
-0.0696718246,
-0.0500510149,
-0.009293111,
-0.0273095239,
-0.046021983,
0.0025066524,
0.0668216497,
-0.0505297817,
0.0608037151,
0.0063989465,
0.0350556076,
-0.0182410795,
0.0360460766,
0.0643777773,
0.0702548772,
-0.0477160737,
-0.0315699279,
0.0986797214,
-0.0042755925,
0.0049850298,
0.0722930655,
-0.0519631431,
-0.0064131678,
0.0147826793,
0.0448195823,
-0.0511468649,
0.0007689511,
0.052915398,
0.0063432045,
-0.0363365225,
0.1110159159,
0.0023826524,
0.0199142471,
0.0025971432,
0.0167163499,
0.0331871621,
0.014421029,
-0.018654434,
-0.0761136785,
-0.0397699289,
0.0313767046,
0.0024934981,
0.0005767879,
-0.012670327,
-0.025670046,
-0.1154947951,
0.0357179977,
0.0366631597,
-0.0587049834,
-0.0448080897,
0.0044438415,
-0.0251839161,
-0.0184712783,
0.0216787085,
-0.0107860919,
0.0243355539,
0.0075065377,
0.0239131562,
-0.0045974986,
-0.0223365519,
0.0164078102,
-0.0190772098,
0.0832735822,
0.030997375,
0.0139306346,
0.0304207187,
0.0347011574,
0.0007671028,
-0.0118118972,
-0.0152571611,
-0.0046382728,
0.0795741454,
0.0039117327,
-0.0109299058,
0.0167181212,
0.0569374785,
-0.0047654235,
-0.0042668576,
0.0022702417,
-0.0128359059,
-0.0410212241,
0.0195579547,
0.0081066815,
0.0917980075,
0.0299147647,
0.0704863444,
0.0277014002,
-0.0337354764,
0.0250775181,
0.007850145,
0.0300123133,
-0.0592789277,
-0.0141711393,
-0.0019798339,
0.0421050042,
-0.0134545835,
-0.0782839954,
0.0210176017,
-0.0090933014,
0.0444044918,
-0.0154623259,
-0.0142988814,
0.0256726276,
0.0004640945,
-0.0250361543,
0.0047504674,
-0.0093166102,
0.0286262166,
-0.0389226228,
-0.0307366662,
0.0559634864,
-0.0563649349,
-0.0084018484,
0.0619487129,
-0.0647615194,
-0.0569117926,
0.012387651,
0.0265158452,
0.0194241572,
0.0677325726,
0.0005670851,
0.0058257622,
-0.008023506,
0.0235372055,
-0.0303811058,
0.0300348625,
0.0492522046,
0.0389250219,
-0.0242097732,
0.0373902954,
0.0023907202,
0.0143864108,
-0.0332646184,
0.0192425475,
-0.0351464972,
-0.0782361627,
-0.0208593421,
0.000244722,
0.0606091283,
0.0231677778,
0.0631941631,
-0.0289901793,
0.0181883667,
-0.0517097898,
0.0059151063,
-0.0836166292,
0.01251835,
0.0017575634,
-0.0114008533,
-0.0106265964,
-0.0063648159,
-0.0497818999,
0.0392912216,
0.0119256573,
-0.0213130359,
0.033722803,
-0.002686366,
-0.0011758638,
-0.0216697492,
-0.0228703562,
0.0347268991,
-0.01013947,
0.0148265306,
-0.0014531362,
0.0656497255,
-0.0222463757,
-0.0245940089,
0.0233799852,
0.0201668888,
-0.0376961939,
-0.0684434325,
-0.0313539244,
0.0511620864,
0.0326684564,
-0.0033115044,
0.0741124004,
-0.0271906182,
0.0166423898,
-0.0381532647,
0.0567102879,
-0.028986644,
-0.0213430617,
0.0473947339,
-0.0152255381,
-0.0303274896,
0.0213670861,
0.0592635348,
0.0339871719,
0.0242808703,
-0.007401228,
0.0464371741,
-0.0487524495,
-0.0381583013,
-0.0234045815,
0.0100313872,
-0.004686777,
0.015426022,
-0.0403530747,
-0.0505452938,
-0.0270863269,
-0.0022201196,
0.002058534,
-0.0222822502,
0.0641523227,
0.0100249909,
-0.0333852209,
0.0435141698,
-0.0173238739,
-0.0009790796,
0.0013078685,
-0.0081559457,
-0.0228746478,
-5.787024811e-33,
-0.0398558453,
0.0013910591,
0.0262988545,
-0.0227122325,
-0.0699346364,
-0.0384074524,
-0.0392091833,
0.0083107799,
-0.0237289239,
-0.0142526701,
-0.0047930628,
0.0157988854,
-0.0000962051,
0.0655811802,
-0.04109478,
0.0041595115,
0.0654288381,
-0.0132964598,
-0.0014213787,
0.0298731737,
0.0345365666,
0.0092387823,
0.0138694495,
-0.0561788492,
-0.070912987,
-0.0207673255,
-0.0038576783,
-0.0191857349,
0.0148349591,
0.0269219521,
-0.0132081946,
0.0272381715,
-0.0245100241,
-0.0410645828,
-0.0397514813,
0.0225237068,
-0.0412357785,
0.0068075224,
0.0309068989,
0.0386388674,
-0.0008657628,
0.0117527433,
-0.0287519097,
-0.0161133651,
-0.020619804,
-0.0411462821,
0.0108424779,
-0.0552526228,
-0.046624057,
0.002128049,
-0.022505885,
0.0282122344,
-0.023317555,
-0.0628668293,
0.0289445538,
0.09149988,
0.0200051051,
-0.0384056829,
0.0137959318,
0.0646388754,
-0.018008044,
0.0111239068,
0.040329542,
0.0316702686,
0.0123285297,
0.0559494235,
0.0372710153,
-0.0339571983,
0.0371906012,
-0.0326103903,
-0.0133975632,
0.0675321892,
-0.009994586,
0.0819979757,
-0.0012097501,
-0.024254458,
-0.0246292185,
-0.0070138122,
0.009916109,
-0.0470042303,
0.00812166,
-0.0107286349,
0.0090357019,
-0.0221136995,
-0.0628316328,
-0.0526770689,
0.0234745927,
0.0126211727,
0.0260319728,
0.0276577566,
0.0155682284,
0.0027957747,
0.0523559153,
-0.0536999889,
0.0168699715,
0.0437915549,
-0.0728487894,
0.0184210278,
-0.0394185409,
0.0331992581,
-0.0445147902,
-0.0403815694,
0.0710378662,
0.0879179388,
0.0231467579,
0.0165103991,
-0.0381314307,
-0.0004274824,
-0.0208048504,
0.0041263537,
-0.0140081272,
0.0435077399,
-0.0386227891,
0.0211118404,
0.0013145598,
0.0009073377,
-0.0219278652,
0.0876949131,
-0.0512581207,
-0.0142857544,
-0.0312761441,
-0.0428052768,
0.0053844638,
0.0554141253,
-0.0419415943,
0.0206774715,
-0.0202208143,
-0.1043822318,
0.0455305912,
-0.0426156744,
-0.0197178815,
-0.0325014703,
2.459e-7,
-0.0428855829,
-0.0064364253,
0.0322679058,
0.0206713602,
0.0305288117,
0.0310782362,
0.0137713039,
0.0122940466,
-0.0028565719,
-0.0221935213,
-0.0048025488,
0.0093629295,
0.0720650405,
-0.00724801,
-0.072983101,
-0.0206404105,
-0.0927477255,
-0.017635284,
-0.0266373325,
-0.012840162,
0.0101022711,
0.0620430633,
-0.0203356296,
-0.0275501832,
0.0215240754,
0.0306655336,
0.0389531143,
-0.0315925963,
-0.0191400778,
0.0062087802,
-0.004635673,
0.0142053086,
-0.0229514576,
0.0101283928,
-0.0377990417,
0.0457728803,
0.0084105954,
0.0740162507,
0.0231114961,
-0.0432559587,
-0.0088302437,
0.0124534993,
-0.0259542689,
-0.0139159104,
0.0435833968,
-0.0260124374,
-0.0158764981,
-0.0089375461,
-0.043173559,
0.0258845091,
0.0090223942,
-0.0366948657,
-0.0134046897,
0.0231961515,
0.0323263444,
-0.0340933166,
0.035808634,
-0.0294944067,
-0.0119449981,
0.0004981321,
-0.0810703486,
-0.0318505764,
0.007809767,
-0.0393799208,
0.0251946505,
0.0093180817,
-0.0038918124,
1.931802136e-34,
0.032594379,
0.0245636106,
0.0277135577,
-0.0125256367,
0.0035568785,
-0.0412339792,
-0.0045672031,
-0.0001278582,
0.020188937,
-0.0381126925,
-0.0244913809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01909v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01909v1 | Pinyin Regularization in Error Correction for Chinese Speech Recognition with Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:16:47 | 2024-07-02T03:16:47 | Zhiyuan Tang, Dong Wang, Shen Huang, Shidong Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent studies have demonstrated the efficacy of large language models (LLMs)
in error correction for automatic speech recognition (ASR). However, much of
the research focuses on the English language. This paper redirects the
attention to Chinese. Firstly, we construct a specialized benchmark dataset
aimed at error correction for Chinese ASR with 724K hypotheses-transcription
pairs, named the Chinese Hypotheses Paradise dataset (ChineseHP), which
contains a wide range of scenarios and presents significant challenges.
Subsequently, we conduct a preliminary evaluation using the dataset for both
direct-prompting and fine-tuning pre-trained LLMs. Furthermore, we propose a
straightforward method of Pinyin regularization for prompts, which involves the
transcription of Pinyin directly from text hypotheses. The experimental results
reveal that Pinyin regularization consistently enhances the error-correcting
ability of LLMs when compared with those without regularization. The dataset is
available on the website. | [
0.0137403579,
0.065906994,
0.029746512,
0.0290342793,
0.0149502335,
0.0082852496,
0.0435149521,
0.0251533333,
0.0073620728,
0.0069243042,
-0.0815745145,
-0.0755983666,
0.0416900292,
-0.0417638645,
0.0305636004,
-0.0117005659,
0.0329296812,
-0.0432014503,
0.0016000337,
-0.027094122,
0.0159485042,
-0.0220128279,
0.0344623625,
0.0556757972,
0.015426157,
0.0320434496,
-0.002301869,
0.0727180615,
0.0284446664,
-0.0257306993,
0.0023242421,
0.0506986454,
0.0138440197,
0.0628560707,
0.0000017797,
-0.0357196108,
-0.0194584448,
-0.0066221133,
-0.0647801831,
0.043623168,
-0.0027176205,
-0.0087991003,
-0.0471577793,
0.0303148758,
0.0364691727,
-0.082013689,
0.0796765089,
0.0599236637,
0.0105925063,
0.0672941059,
0.0027740675,
-0.0125915995,
-0.0052826023,
-0.0310974177,
-0.01459751,
-0.0401327051,
0.042105902,
0.0062216115,
-0.0264844466,
-0.0619560964,
-0.0322917588,
0.0034540307,
-0.0324915983,
0.0078531587,
-0.0397033542,
-0.0254165735,
0.0091920244,
-0.0245083924,
-0.0335724801,
0.0464241989,
0.0041739391,
-0.0258471202,
-0.024546735,
0.0056474521,
-0.0345452428,
0.0073369527,
-0.0152890142,
0.0043548467,
0.0078355102,
-0.0141210761,
0.0171009675,
-0.040690545,
0.040398512,
0.0142810661,
-0.0510097146,
-0.0042717084,
0.0363475233,
-0.049954161,
-0.0037648298,
-0.0147955306,
0.00955988,
-0.015055445,
0.0384276323,
0.0275938231,
-0.0427124165,
0.0051417504,
-0.0034427452,
-0.0053673433,
-0.0103356484,
-0.0076883254,
0.0134913381,
0.0437628999,
-0.0485516004,
0.0111631257,
-0.0236212127,
0.0739326477,
-0.024862228,
0.0048919045,
-0.0371840447,
-0.0150125222,
0.0169068649,
0.0038858573,
-0.0488814339,
-0.0006804523,
0.0261976086,
-0.0162195135,
-0.0269988962,
-0.0060292589,
-0.0044181193,
0.0481069759,
0.0263509583,
-0.0347332098,
-0.0783294588,
-0.0359036364,
0.0381238684,
0.0354164429,
0.0261706375,
0.0474416092,
-0.0205890127,
-0.0544851609,
-0.0167420115,
0.0033736576,
0.0692864805,
-0.0022621974,
0.0134540135,
0.0271195415,
0.0162832178,
-0.0416645557,
-0.0256216805,
0.0455181785,
-0.0279590674,
-0.032415349,
-0.0554298349,
-0.0351786464,
-0.0046202061,
-0.0234130956,
0.0814424828,
-0.0457311347,
0.0140793612,
-0.0455666073,
0.0108429585,
0.0329695158,
-0.0350011215,
0.0324020945,
0.0080103492,
-0.0231837872,
0.0144710541,
0.0432936363,
0.0515279844,
-0.0325827822,
0.0399917103,
-0.0178617891,
0.0031620425,
0.0598041564,
-0.03094933,
0.0146175632,
-0.0186362062,
-0.0342903957,
0.0143499523,
0.0103510572,
0.006676795,
0.0818131194,
-0.0422192365,
0.0349157304,
0.0428932607,
0.0504513457,
0.0280748587,
0.0043637785,
0.0161713399,
-0.0092944484,
0.0218458176,
0.0093059242,
0.0010511812,
-0.032594353,
-0.007850904,
0.034479633,
0.0648180842,
0.0269790478,
-0.0613164268,
-0.026287891,
-0.0462789834,
-0.0116638122,
-0.024381334,
0.0389838852,
0.0802320167,
-0.0326970406,
-0.0256894734,
-0.0036841359,
0.0081873573,
-0.0571848266,
0.0485709868,
-0.0395820253,
0.0392444059,
0.1188874245,
0.0274394173,
-0.012974686,
-0.0005523523,
-0.0257928651,
-0.0514091514,
0.0392327346,
0.0575627945,
-0.0303722769,
0.0154053699,
-0.0575476997,
-0.003766882,
0.1007745266,
-0.0106866397,
0.0476432145,
-0.0130218603,
-0.0074439188,
0.0195287857,
0.0047546024,
-0.0603934377,
-0.0033482159,
-0.0450620651,
-0.0226600207,
0.0217349585,
0.0172943864,
0.0534693561,
0.0433530845,
-0.081851095,
-0.0125994543,
0.0085582612,
-0.0077993688,
-0.01077908,
0.0083862748,
-0.0287146587,
-0.0336640254,
0.0878053606,
0.0206564739,
0.0019065628,
0.0392221287,
-0.0150257386,
-0.1006217599,
-0.0233575907,
0.0076287948,
0.0311756022,
-0.1009199768,
0.0709388256,
0.0103653083,
0.0058618835,
-0.0200345274,
-0.0251269117,
0.0378686748,
0.040464554,
0.0535744466,
0.0081975302,
-0.0021183067,
-0.080920577,
-0.0626326501,
0.0289180167,
-0.0059497315,
0.0404029451,
0.0381538868,
0.003821674,
0.0294633955,
0.013182126,
-0.0655547306,
-0.0049685077,
-0.0446897671,
-0.0154356677,
-0.0197635368,
0.0351278223,
-0.0142379683,
-0.03539804,
-0.015773464,
-0.0162935555,
-0.020362692,
-0.0031913314,
-0.0326816551,
0.0034733277,
-0.0300892461,
-0.0388077311,
-0.0098978262,
0.0166591145,
-0.0268192049,
-0.0107424753,
-0.0447503701,
-0.0767181441,
0.0446783043,
0.0052327518,
0.0349416509,
0.0021681336,
-0.0479488559,
-0.0364496708,
-0.0274748597,
0.0160241984,
0.0043495935,
-0.0345638283,
-0.0131668895,
0.0176690891,
0.0049340734,
-0.0367844775,
0.005503322,
0.0165965855,
-0.0723586455,
-0.0408220477,
-0.0224770475,
-0.040887516,
0.0421646349,
0.0364365615,
0.0042805537,
-0.0648315921,
-0.0639755502,
-0.0134164784,
0.0046010856,
0.0034940995,
-0.0216276869,
-0.0229223818,
0.0340669937,
-0.0056652557,
-0.0280863177,
0.0394440629,
-0.0813400149,
-0.017910609,
-0.0041542742,
-0.0039946805,
-0.0160268638,
-0.0083043911,
-0.0281649642,
0.0080028027,
-0.0278283022,
-0.062128894,
-0.0211226828,
0.0145594105,
-0.005304202,
-0.0282016192,
0.0483870432,
-0.0093935812,
0.033079613,
-0.0467560068,
-0.0257003754,
-0.0135240201,
-0.0169687886,
-0.0590420812,
0.0179269779,
0.0425983146,
-0.0198296234,
0.0408991575,
0.0603116862,
0.0024417192,
0.0770868883,
-0.0019549623,
0.0534383878,
-0.0193453953,
0.0207182486,
0.0258400366,
0.0361343175,
0.0281142537,
-0.021018127,
0.1026003882,
-0.0059420806,
0.039651636,
0.0040779477,
-0.0043413555,
-0.0237529743,
0.0513745956,
-0.0019311537,
0.0135084298,
0.0031325412,
0.0599228628,
-0.0411190875,
0.0126829781,
0.1208962351,
0.0035223193,
-0.0366975144,
0.0012014029,
0.0007897771,
0.0019070657,
0.0035524892,
-0.0331868716,
-0.0908423364,
-0.01954321,
0.0497622378,
0.0176833905,
0.0005591259,
0.0464775153,
0.0320007429,
-0.1159424484,
0.0590984263,
0.0675047636,
0.030100368,
-0.0321140811,
-0.0227357466,
0.0054928986,
-0.0419378281,
0.0634394288,
0.0400772206,
-0.0005268335,
-0.0647976846,
0.0407884307,
-0.007021613,
-0.087869145,
-0.0099677211,
-0.0204080716,
0.0401514061,
0.043908067,
-0.0089919735,
-0.0284093358,
0.0165745746,
0.0024697543,
0.0349916667,
-0.0058747153,
0.0007355748,
0.006182598,
0.0206792019,
-0.0257023778,
0.0382640027,
0.0236560982,
0.0018150383,
0.0123638436,
0.0390705727,
0.0112136509,
-0.0273625366,
0.0139930621,
0.0600929335,
-0.0036386317,
-0.0156965684,
0.0625668466,
0.0191812441,
-0.0428282805,
-0.0165550429,
-0.0129063111,
-0.0146345608,
-0.0499930717,
0.0205852091,
0.0286680236,
-0.009993515,
-0.0451771393,
-0.0462654792,
-0.0050908076,
0.0047318125,
-0.0248837844,
0.0307093766,
0.0164469182,
-0.0079520298,
0.0651523769,
0.0123523492,
-0.0153446607,
-0.006705753,
0.0201232489,
-0.0767453462,
0.0057690088,
0.0154404817,
-0.0494285189,
0.0167368241,
0.0079460787,
-0.054164391,
-0.0671790838,
-0.0011249607,
-0.0217227601,
0.003057379,
0.0353114679,
-0.0145564228,
-0.0509582907,
0.0139718987,
-0.0062189205,
-0.0091732191,
-0.0026291015,
0.0201021563,
-0.046717979,
-0.046238739,
0.0297477711,
-0.0655244291,
0.0368875749,
0.0075722723,
0.0694275647,
-0.0054621305,
-0.040225789,
0.0277734622,
0.0650077835,
0.0385573022,
-0.0316051692,
0.0045070383,
-0.0653225482,
0.0668843314,
-0.0002383851,
-0.0101803942,
-0.0128824897,
-0.0178739838,
0.0380503647,
-0.0279728584,
-0.0216599554,
-0.0216929801,
-0.0270767026,
-0.0272325911,
-0.0285630208,
0.0120807858,
-0.0006697627,
0.026710622,
0.0224396009,
-0.0170117896,
-0.0453512557,
0.054094784,
0.054196462,
-0.0204626136,
-0.0025651401,
0.0027844235,
-0.0221665874,
0.0303170681,
-0.0086745825,
-0.0188991521,
-0.0464388691,
-0.0659599528,
-0.017674936,
0.0216782279,
0.1039728895,
0.0117262825,
0.0388917997,
-0.0259628426,
0.0001433271,
-0.0769496486,
-0.0103404606,
0.0123286638,
0.0198763199,
0.0199257694,
0.0030986702,
-0.0162775647,
0.0290591251,
0.0532612838,
0.0496934727,
0.0608015098,
-0.0160902645,
0.016233325,
-0.0261808708,
-0.0267622508,
0.0362361968,
-0.0156039475,
-0.0643863305,
-0.0206398759,
0.0011360864,
-0.0646852031,
0.0249395352,
0.0100239003,
-0.0011363478,
-0.0170129053,
-0.044045832,
-0.0058999001,
-0.0371169522,
0.020461781,
-0.0176280141,
-0.0301674064,
0.0068269018,
0.0135908481,
0.0130656352,
-6.113278492e-33,
-0.0171253234,
0.0452694297,
-0.0091958046,
-0.0342959948,
-0.0076751253,
-0.0202336162,
-0.0315121524,
-0.0067928764,
-0.0120122777,
-0.016850587,
-0.0452249236,
0.0087870471,
0.0354423597,
0.0204647109,
-0.0066223475,
0.0115824249,
0.1016307175,
-0.0006398372,
0.0160952304,
0.0120310159,
0.0412312858,
0.047841683,
0.030639343,
-0.0417494476,
0.0037851301,
0.000019886,
-0.0120307561,
-0.0104609951,
0.0009144954,
0.0502290428,
0.0161914472,
0.0560984127,
-0.0030704099,
-0.0046664602,
-0.039774891,
0.0065570166,
-0.1013118699,
0.0202611927,
-0.0044456283,
0.0704392642,
0.0516592972,
-0.0168034751,
-0.0153974397,
-0.0164245218,
-0.0156621374,
-0.0238669142,
-0.0116581433,
-0.0647689998,
-0.0180126317,
-0.0295061786,
0.0154804289,
0.0563433617,
0.0008249042,
0.0067535066,
0.0535880215,
0.0357824713,
-0.0619955622,
0.0147143258,
-0.0195527021,
0.0176419504,
0.059219528,
0.0549347624,
0.026717335,
0.0592957325,
-0.0067949668,
-0.0250740163,
0.0156549364,
-0.0311886333,
0.0421687178,
-0.0163059924,
0.0164183769,
-0.0034614487,
-0.0065681068,
0.0528581776,
0.0010471725,
-0.0514673889,
-0.0557398237,
-0.0169316176,
-0.0013030525,
0.0100658266,
0.0316079855,
0.0143428128,
-0.0306374189,
-0.0166625157,
-0.0393825173,
-0.0219979919,
-0.0322192684,
-0.0115147317,
0.0148634929,
0.0183049496,
-0.0254541207,
-0.0030098667,
0.0790657774,
-0.0292349085,
-0.020822458,
0.0392440036,
0.026132565,
-0.0107003897,
-0.0452577583,
0.0278025959,
-0.0651267916,
-0.075408712,
0.0027944816,
0.0120649068,
-0.0292627141,
-0.0282394346,
0.0272701029,
0.0560594834,
-0.0558264032,
0.0091741253,
0.0256661046,
-0.0155350603,
0.0172511749,
0.0329342932,
0.0373276211,
0.0001392363,
0.0418759063,
0.0432865024,
0.0000904335,
-0.0111909183,
0.0039110295,
-0.0315410011,
0.0002655773,
0.0107369665,
-0.0286774449,
0.0123493187,
-0.0028260462,
-0.0413186476,
0.0285574775,
-0.0174830873,
-0.015379373,
-0.0001521766,
2.54e-7,
-0.0198990945,
-0.0090770228,
0.046397604,
0.0069417045,
-0.0073140538,
-0.0227401741,
-0.0373304076,
-0.0080125546,
-0.0139094293,
0.0589476712,
0.0955359563,
-0.000604075,
0.1136129573,
-0.0057818326,
-0.0372965969,
-0.0250929072,
-0.0203581192,
0.0341008566,
-0.0028893556,
-0.0054993145,
-0.0156250577,
0.1125056148,
-0.0626099035,
0.0208714753,
0.0144744115,
-0.0608920455,
0.0310291313,
0.0019234749,
-0.0006242192,
0.0723405704,
0.0243121646,
0.0112939468,
-0.0119673414,
-0.0077147908,
-0.0076808198,
0.067748405,
0.0314253643,
0.0630083904,
-0.0091635762,
-0.0135363936,
-0.0162257738,
0.0231585093,
-0.0095436517,
-0.0198490843,
0.0249385424,
0.0298161078,
0.0132741667,
-0.0243725609,
-0.0079468898,
-0.0180821475,
0.0062143756,
-0.0669564903,
0.0317552499,
0.0220082868,
0.028799329,
0.0091224732,
-0.0287595559,
-0.0448873229,
-0.0027327368,
0.0191377625,
-0.0360518508,
-0.0469574444,
0.0300188512,
-0.0214302801,
-0.0236603394,
-0.007230144,
0.0079695387,
1.745625641e-34,
0.0340438187,
-0.040856991,
-0.0077992729,
0.0225581806,
0.0253884271,
-0.0588007756,
-0.0069359192,
0.0118723493,
-0.0141512789,
-0.0737744123,
-0.0563369356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01906v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01906v1 | Let the Expert Stick to His Last: Expert-Specialized Fine-Tuning for Sparse Architectural Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:11:13 | 2024-07-02T03:11:13 | Zihan Wang, Deli Chen, Damai Dai, Runxin Xu, Zhuoshu Li, Y. Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) is crucial for customizing Large
Language Models (LLMs) with constrained resources. Although there have been
various PEFT methods for dense-architecture LLMs, PEFT for sparse-architecture
LLMs is still underexplored. In this work, we study the PEFT method for LLMs
with the Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) architecture and the contents of this work
are mainly threefold: (1) We investigate the dispersion degree of the activated
experts in customized tasks, and found that the routing distribution for a
specific task tends to be highly concentrated, while the distribution of
activated experts varies significantly across different tasks. (2) We propose
Expert-Specialized Fine-Tuning, or ESFT, which tunes the experts most relevant
to downstream tasks while freezing the other experts and modules; experimental
results demonstrate that our method not only improves the tuning efficiency,
but also matches or even surpasses the performance of full-parameter
fine-tuning. (3) We further analyze the impact of the MoE architecture on
expert-specialized fine-tuning. We find that MoE models with finer-grained
experts are more advantageous in selecting the combination of experts that are
most relevant to downstream tasks, thereby enhancing both the training
efficiency and effectiveness. | [
0.0632904992,
0.0403175168,
-0.0207829382,
0.0333819948,
-0.0110380119,
-0.0064116144,
0.0223335996,
-0.0290606096,
-0.0371697359,
-0.0437917151,
-0.0694279745,
-0.0134273274,
0.0003319105,
-0.0080117015,
0.0534116961,
-0.0092550172,
0.0013880597,
-0.0594246201,
-0.0029778301,
-0.0254851747,
-0.0040705316,
0.0173123907,
-0.0014691487,
0.0423226953,
0.0368520357,
0.0305387434,
-0.0053185103,
0.0254018754,
0.0094976686,
0.0093090199,
0.0159231387,
0.0782642886,
0.0281359535,
-0.0130845513,
0.0000020388,
-0.0050479588,
-0.0077132746,
-0.0086453995,
-0.0077975248,
0.0476786532,
0.0399540737,
0.0246913023,
-0.0256904196,
0.0115806675,
-0.0010418028,
-0.0148542514,
0.0722558796,
0.0558782592,
0.0300565399,
0.1031864733,
0.004652244,
-0.0194644928,
0.021163458,
-0.0354159251,
-0.0363120958,
-0.0327427685,
0.0251894817,
-0.0116615696,
-0.0025640999,
0.028230641,
-0.0292319562,
-0.0023530026,
-0.0025394175,
0.0436017774,
0.0240895711,
0.0275347605,
-0.0233228002,
-0.0104547665,
-0.0045847371,
0.0635358468,
-0.0648002326,
-0.009366639,
0.0208293088,
-0.0121946214,
-0.0354013331,
-0.0167602245,
-0.0210055839,
-0.0181588233,
0.0204688441,
-0.0027276841,
0.0400746912,
-0.0290677845,
0.0390282683,
0.0454528108,
-0.0606519505,
0.0262305755,
0.0426629335,
0.009662427,
-0.0321596824,
-0.0304088425,
-0.0408533216,
-0.0291459952,
-0.0080883848,
0.0083003119,
-0.0469186455,
0.0026501107,
-0.0557760857,
-0.0159846842,
-0.0186447725,
0.0087596569,
0.0575483255,
0.0393122286,
0.0011520036,
0.0494567119,
-0.0388439149,
0.0128432326,
-0.0319924839,
0.0258071013,
-0.0414282568,
0.0084215906,
-0.0384953171,
0.0246223733,
-0.0336413607,
0.0166140143,
-0.0181451961,
-0.0288141705,
-0.0328192227,
0.0243587978,
-0.0068021757,
-0.0030721098,
0.0146756619,
-0.0053913561,
-0.0481893271,
-0.0452987701,
0.0111634359,
0.0237390772,
-0.0290881079,
0.0172725786,
-0.0137363877,
-0.0379547067,
0.015572886,
0.0404659361,
-0.0070907716,
-0.0388555788,
0.0289214738,
0.0556878038,
-0.0247901138,
-0.0240181312,
-0.0340608917,
0.0135929715,
-0.0019075099,
-0.072410658,
-0.0078914771,
-0.0750764906,
0.0063612494,
-0.0048377807,
0.0330071449,
-0.0397423618,
-0.0170913246,
-0.0228493325,
-0.0645531937,
0.0299745519,
0.0005196662,
0.0239163209,
0.0294590499,
-0.0094677312,
-0.0084940577,
0.0734053701,
0.0234905258,
0.0241740011,
0.0097659007,
-0.0070162104,
-0.010844361,
0.0323672965,
-0.02729645,
0.0408128016,
-0.0262079369,
0.0008211702,
-0.0148939239,
0.0168065038,
0.0363174975,
0.0363682806,
-0.0492459312,
0.0050668824,
0.0449800082,
0.0401575677,
0.0473298244,
0.0434163921,
0.027980363,
0.003050393,
-0.0009475605,
0.0128066512,
-0.0545029491,
0.0255439784,
-0.0159512162,
-0.0078685135,
0.0455082171,
0.0643639117,
-0.0407480337,
0.0001858097,
0.0119013954,
-0.0065717548,
-0.0502076447,
0.0128654009,
0.0587074757,
-0.0286690332,
-0.0372043848,
0.0154007766,
0.0366256982,
-0.0062175035,
0.0023279889,
-0.0690065324,
-0.0164851137,
0.0752348155,
0.0319754742,
-0.0251135267,
-0.0367505513,
0.012722603,
0.0068947673,
0.0002271591,
0.0287586022,
0.0174418017,
0.0005683401,
-0.0781058297,
-0.0432425551,
-0.0166522749,
0.0219712984,
0.0006285168,
0.0339102373,
0.0017984089,
0.0357269794,
-0.009237933,
-0.0505476929,
0.0150516629,
-0.0116670951,
0.0086960625,
0.0187675562,
0.0137675386,
0.0141683631,
-0.0061407858,
-0.0498305634,
-0.0011837539,
-0.0058635767,
-0.0099808117,
0.0093153166,
-0.0447230004,
-0.0439700969,
0.0193575639,
0.0102014914,
-0.0180780068,
0.0335459746,
0.0037690562,
-0.03630694,
-0.0591969863,
0.0330311805,
-0.0399281867,
0.024809923,
-0.0161763337,
0.0255660005,
-0.0150875589,
0.0081720389,
-0.052087795,
0.0250382088,
-0.0016589892,
-0.0196999758,
0.0147706512,
0.0394611694,
0.003985093,
-0.0213586185,
-0.0550415069,
-0.0100635253,
0.0352560058,
0.0384718589,
0.0145133482,
0.0020129688,
-0.0203486439,
-0.0854987726,
-0.1184293926,
0.0438719876,
-0.0566931292,
0.0111976145,
0.025928393,
0.0196547937,
0.0032846206,
0.0142956125,
-0.0153737105,
0.0240893103,
-0.0242640581,
0.0252278354,
-0.0319513381,
-0.0004350934,
-0.0692462698,
-0.0543028153,
-0.0553145185,
0.0135480305,
0.0169749837,
-0.0339925997,
-0.0078398045,
-0.0657238588,
-0.0062377742,
0.0009566325,
0.0455214605,
-0.0104257353,
-0.0561685823,
-0.0202725865,
-0.0509271696,
0.0572799928,
0.0710008815,
-0.005331804,
0.0157689396,
0.0509181321,
0.0013823817,
-0.0112791359,
0.0228058808,
-0.0179762375,
-0.0246288553,
-0.0728926882,
0.0270514041,
-0.0263138637,
0.0596300103,
-0.0146236932,
-0.024305556,
-0.0541518405,
-0.0168421566,
-0.0078155762,
-0.0228904635,
0.0126743512,
0.0208507627,
0.0107776383,
0.0174131002,
-0.0176829603,
-0.0364919156,
0.0506297201,
-0.0137501592,
0.0090685086,
-0.0323822089,
-0.03369008,
-0.0363058299,
0.0076661124,
0.0349594094,
0.0386012681,
-0.0170204267,
0.0011223993,
-0.0651713014,
0.0201061126,
-0.0030375593,
-0.0119267972,
0.0490723662,
-0.0382492915,
0.0174464881,
-0.022307191,
-0.0375551991,
0.0195603985,
-0.0073672989,
-0.0556354038,
0.0420198962,
0.0804825798,
-0.0486309901,
-0.0630965978,
0.0295883752,
0.005790757,
0.0609476529,
-0.0305467099,
0.0055790381,
-0.0432699844,
0.0050224718,
0.0769359246,
0.044112619,
0.0155586256,
-0.0262345541,
-0.0023624476,
4.396e-7,
0.0421878099,
-0.0279706232,
-0.062391419,
0.0313153677,
0.0460107289,
-0.0302666593,
-0.0484080128,
0.0312062912,
0.0524697751,
-0.060209997,
0.0267180856,
0.1001806036,
0.0080998931,
-0.0524713919,
0.0217956435,
0.0408175178,
0.0471206568,
0.0228812639,
0.0508255474,
-0.0575259812,
-0.0317572504,
-0.0090543628,
-0.0021494897,
-0.0095677646,
0.0085045956,
0.0051294873,
-0.0842222422,
0.0193122458,
0.0428269692,
-0.0097004138,
-0.009105606,
-0.0114961984,
0.0170436222,
-0.0253863651,
0.0162832718,
0.0058359453,
0.0148248104,
-0.0399426892,
0.0279942006,
-0.0003472726,
-0.0864363983,
0.0226334911,
-0.0222307276,
0.0932075754,
0.0276786685,
-0.0363344997,
0.0062177037,
0.0072634784,
0.0227658674,
0.0146141592,
0.0316407457,
-0.0285777021,
0.0010708249,
-0.0084754648,
-0.0247157197,
0.0032891568,
0.0083564175,
-0.0038224675,
0.0266867299,
-0.0102330837,
0.0729680732,
-0.0408015028,
0.0034539311,
-0.0053620408,
-0.0568758547,
-0.017485762,
0.0267718844,
-0.0029222143,
-0.0549882129,
-0.0281026103,
-0.008986623,
-0.0423273854,
-0.0354260541,
-0.0210022684,
0.0146903917,
-0.0309499167,
-0.03753227,
-0.0146102943,
0.0240398906,
0.042633459,
0.0579446219,
0.0193336606,
0.023208769,
0.0207767412,
0.0162374917,
-0.0159374513,
0.0298079364,
-0.0538103953,
0.0173065979,
-0.0879719481,
-0.0355450474,
0.0587354191,
-0.0129016321,
0.005846018,
-0.0002143941,
-0.0808361843,
-0.0924471319,
-0.0255167503,
0.0445102081,
0.0112945177,
0.0453513712,
-0.0180598274,
-0.1333116144,
0.049988158,
-0.0138099436,
-0.0656102449,
0.036341425,
0.016987063,
-0.0549893044,
-0.021852361,
0.0354510807,
-0.0322314017,
0.0253131576,
0.0650369897,
0.0390210748,
-0.0112391273,
-0.0216119345,
-0.0308517329,
-0.0030656147,
0.0166015942,
-0.0248862226,
0.0246177241,
-0.0362305753,
0.0564405806,
0.0258503072,
0.0033598463,
-0.0318979174,
-0.0171444491,
0.0256309509,
0.0181336012,
0.0103811752,
0.0033759379,
0.0523603819,
0.027312899,
-0.020958038,
0.0274963249,
-0.0080434335,
-0.0252515189,
0.0422534347,
0.0021521612,
-0.0290866662,
0.040802516,
0.0345824994,
0.0132718366,
-0.0303576868,
0.0348426178,
0.0051168273,
-0.0028552935,
-0.0918113887,
0.0291698538,
-0.0291176792,
-0.0986675918,
-0.0291165467,
0.0397507623,
0.0919063836,
-0.0094694709,
0.0423372686,
0.0002469136,
-0.0016722846,
-0.034489017,
0.009023075,
0.006678707,
0.0284422617,
0.0122146411,
0.0374176018,
0.0058902968,
0.0316134878,
0.0639386475,
0.0479593948,
0.0431711301,
-0.0029368273,
-0.0011909417,
-0.016678825,
-0.0163092241,
-0.0024471784,
0.0441505797,
-0.0409785919,
0.029849384,
0.0101901172,
-0.0396440178,
-0.0344435647,
-0.0298069306,
0.0000184008,
-0.0424540415,
0.0360969417,
0.0552957915,
-0.0210610088,
-0.0018005917,
-0.0313633196,
-0.0683538914,
0.0439921767,
0.000604759,
-0.003701072,
-6.929060919e-33,
-0.0054373378,
0.0180841163,
0.0327218361,
-0.0308252163,
-0.0031261791,
-0.00038502,
-0.0127260191,
0.0265274774,
-0.0302913021,
-0.0096586952,
-0.0223745964,
-0.0134572713,
0.0073002442,
0.0280672647,
0.0034150861,
0.0336432569,
0.0744448975,
0.0062916414,
-0.0123550287,
0.0343149565,
-0.0122508425,
0.0057035871,
0.0429458842,
-0.0406651013,
-0.0528845303,
0.0074074548,
-0.0071323449,
0.0108596841,
-0.002611455,
0.0586230494,
-0.0006206436,
0.0379770212,
0.0122434497,
-0.030593697,
-0.0356154665,
-0.0275773648,
-0.0347985663,
-0.0215091519,
0.0547872894,
0.0038412157,
-0.0013163906,
-0.0535901412,
0.0569717921,
0.031001009,
-0.0313218161,
-0.0211687647,
0.0231507383,
-0.0044244062,
-0.0282110739,
0.0143613787,
-0.0467203185,
0.0424502715,
0.0064959577,
0.0095733823,
0.026845511,
-0.0590410531,
-0.0345730409,
-0.0155434934,
-0.0077751665,
0.0066017834,
0.045028206,
0.1047080085,
0.0444593392,
0.0673671365,
-0.0068609165,
0.0110121612,
0.0161048919,
0.0412060507,
0.0115524633,
-0.0226566177,
0.0509790555,
0.0646115541,
0.0029940107,
-0.0195623543,
0.0066197044,
0.0041394839,
-0.0498510115,
-0.0533782616,
0.0167700369,
0.0534229055,
0.0787415728,
0.0471484736,
-0.0184040777,
-0.0196060147,
-0.0519887023,
0.0306001958,
-0.0460938141,
-0.0242034271,
0.0076645846,
0.0491076,
-0.0265642088,
-0.0034335908,
0.0406376235,
-0.0382302068,
0.0172127523,
0.0047072521,
-0.0306493379,
0.0397477001,
-0.005673829,
0.0230826586,
-0.0777445659,
-0.089262329,
0.0206684824,
-0.0402552746,
-0.014314875,
-0.0113919247,
0.0027033095,
0.039062947,
-0.0560064353,
-0.0383253731,
-0.0185217019,
-0.0187490042,
0.0210403893,
0.0746457204,
0.0147597315,
0.0115556559,
0.005780668,
0.0269745737,
-0.0147576779,
-0.0178928301,
-0.0078832665,
-0.0076497123,
0.0279872715,
0.0122931963,
-0.0282744113,
0.0111144558,
-0.0595921092,
-0.049469512,
0.0121884737,
-0.0354335085,
-0.0459046401,
0.0071942541,
2.852e-7,
-0.0095431851,
0.0484019034,
-0.0333369114,
-0.0123707289,
0.0206719134,
0.011312387,
0.0102903107,
-0.0120025501,
0.0211393405,
-0.022935085,
0.0270183198,
0.0714293569,
0.0332748517,
-0.0244538169,
-0.0699641779,
0.0233044252,
-0.0217764229,
0.0765828043,
-0.0629648715,
-0.028357137,
-0.0003946169,
0.1210724041,
0.025973225,
-0.0105034858,
0.0028485258,
-0.0136785144,
0.0167251062,
-0.0125728417,
0.0014865501,
0.0759280473,
0.0333529823,
0.0685795844,
-0.0268622302,
0.0427857786,
0.0128852567,
0.040039517,
-0.0196478255,
0.1104489192,
-0.0404505655,
0.0181079172,
0.0510280132,
-0.0036709029,
-0.0146949571,
-0.0347144864,
0.0564226545,
-0.0462048613,
-0.0212700404,
-0.0321804285,
0.0253984332,
-0.0354941674,
-0.0014890728,
-0.0394408964,
-0.0123140803,
0.0264593307,
0.0323802456,
-0.0256617926,
-0.0138649652,
-0.0813438669,
0.026123466,
0.0419387184,
-0.0578367487,
-0.0719661936,
-0.037444707,
-0.0142336627,
0.0407457426,
-0.0136249643,
0.0255142767,
2.770188584e-34,
0.0534209833,
0.0086510628,
0.023384098,
0.0461728796,
0.0521230325,
-0.0053131515,
-0.065488033,
0.0243920796,
0.0130046541,
-0.1289664209,
-0.0439040139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01902v1 | SoP: Unlock the Power of Social Facilitation for Automatic Jailbreak Attack | 2024-07-02T02:58:29 | 2024-07-02T02:58:29 | Yan Yang, Zeguan Xiao, Xin Lu, Hongru Wang, Hailiang Huang, Guanhua Chen, Yun Chen | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | The widespread applications of large language models (LLMs) have brought
about concerns regarding their potential misuse. Although aligned with human
preference data before release, LLMs remain vulnerable to various malicious
attacks. In this paper, we adopt a red-teaming strategy to enhance LLM safety
and introduce SoP, a simple yet effective framework to design jailbreak prompts
automatically. Inspired by the social facilitation concept, SoP generates and
optimizes multiple jailbreak characters to bypass the guardrails of the target
LLM. Different from previous work which relies on proprietary LLMs or seed
jailbreak templates crafted by human expertise, SoP can generate and optimize
the jailbreak prompt in a cold-start scenario using open-sourced LLMs without
any seed jailbreak templates. Experimental results show that SoP achieves
attack success rates of 88% and 60% in bypassing the safety alignment of
GPT-3.5-1106 and GPT-4, respectively. Furthermore, we extensively evaluate the
transferability of the generated templates across different LLMs and held-out
malicious requests, while also exploring defense strategies against the
jailbreak attack designed by SoP. Code is available at
https://github.com/Yang-Yan-Yang-Yan/SoP. | [
0.0691232234,
0.0390567668,
-0.0111071831,
0.0088954391,
-0.0253803171,
-0.0335569754,
0.0326035954,
-0.0168664847,
0.0514845811,
-0.0084162029,
-0.0147852125,
-0.0171890613,
0.025111774,
0.0068041277,
0.0346463434,
0.0128526045,
0.0223340429,
-0.0254952814,
-0.0043451297,
0.0107991342,
0.0335036851,
0.0298415646,
0.0471366346,
0.0304010361,
0.0092585478,
-0.0095150359,
-0.0207072645,
0.0504034087,
0.0194473658,
-0.0661931112,
-0.0134109976,
0.0500854999,
-0.0333336256,
-0.0075125857,
0.0000023886,
-0.0375121906,
-0.031377621,
0.0189911239,
-0.0206731819,
0.0683546439,
-0.026179146,
-0.0409103967,
-0.0422034636,
0.02989701,
-0.0461216457,
0.0209397059,
0.0136528602,
0.0328170508,
0.0826569647,
0.0369560234,
0.0035061247,
0.0016680476,
0.0139292991,
0.0020190249,
0.018022472,
-0.015439556,
-0.0287971217,
-0.0579569675,
0.0221659932,
0.0387710258,
0.0371686928,
-0.0458329432,
0.0109873526,
0.0112915868,
-0.0576836579,
0.0114471968,
-0.0421715379,
-0.0241749398,
-0.0335978754,
0.0369721241,
-0.0316468477,
-0.0085909041,
0.0367877558,
0.008778072,
0.0154636474,
0.0401589349,
0.0074060517,
0.0297803134,
-0.0212312248,
-0.0053837458,
0.0268349368,
-0.0128126796,
0.0464746617,
-0.0189245418,
0.0045028375,
0.045667585,
0.0087082647,
-0.021572629,
-0.0052414807,
-0.0524690971,
0.0099016633,
-0.0569497459,
0.0130065205,
-0.0216728337,
0.024205476,
0.0170630626,
-0.0591017604,
-0.0346437544,
0.0379700884,
-0.0462114215,
-0.0431782641,
0.0370104425,
-0.010173237,
-0.0220159069,
-0.012584771,
-0.0235588271,
-0.0185132734,
-0.0090881558,
0.0201378744,
0.0193001591,
0.0097197415,
0.0135186892,
-0.0217938852,
0.0252650995,
-0.0090345154,
0.0316734873,
-0.0276354793,
0.055062335,
-0.0157956984,
0.0178198032,
-0.0021482629,
0.0015683377,
0.0126647623,
0.019217547,
0.0472912677,
-0.0523104742,
-0.0557544827,
-0.0451536626,
-0.0118420925,
-0.0591985323,
-0.0013546719,
-0.0282035433,
-0.0682086125,
-0.0059976522,
-0.0150571251,
0.0984162539,
0.0266010035,
-0.0010418515,
-0.0818213373,
-0.0938881114,
-0.0225185566,
-0.0012997416,
-0.0455861837,
-0.097262688,
-0.0280812848,
0.0127713112,
0.0157768521,
-0.0428636111,
0.0036190506,
-0.0158761926,
-0.0311866123,
0.0188935716,
-0.0061053298,
0.002990762,
-0.0090619177,
0.0359972417,
0.0441052131,
0.0381071419,
-0.0132157318,
0.0837378725,
0.054406777,
-0.0320641734,
0.0539791994,
0.0448568165,
-0.0226897225,
0.0318066999,
0.0405050553,
-0.0334865898,
0.0810264349,
-0.0363199785,
-0.0282071792,
0.019180214,
0.0189092122,
-0.0214293767,
0.0916525647,
0.0648140982,
-0.0530003421,
0.069265604,
-0.026789356,
0.0065341732,
-0.0138188526,
-0.0390270352,
-0.0476614088,
0.0172921829,
-0.0688580871,
-0.0181771759,
-0.0283149127,
0.0582554564,
-0.0028776873,
0.0607169978,
-0.0005005356,
-0.0335590653,
-0.0385087542,
0.0212845691,
-0.025031751,
0.0197884981,
0.0053341025,
0.0724027455,
0.0305452347,
-0.0193434749,
-0.0484554917,
-0.0590244941,
0.0225960407,
0.0754223764,
0.0289293434,
0.0444343761,
0.011315302,
0.0158179812,
-0.027609203,
-0.0142015815,
0.0024037927,
0.0100517012,
0.0086258035,
-0.000880898,
0.0143567724,
0.0055520227,
0.0260522701,
0.0483258553,
-0.0118135503,
-0.0015710844,
0.0083870282,
-0.0105125103,
-0.0230732709,
-0.0109701464,
0.0351045653,
-0.0078745726,
0.0284098797,
0.0357254632,
-0.0032200448,
0.0289345942,
-0.0130105363,
-0.0021483104,
0.0538842678,
0.0006301885,
0.0745368153,
0.0282943044,
-0.0255953968,
0.0085430713,
0.0244814754,
-0.0182186626,
0.0119986804,
0.0736004785,
-0.0276186056,
-0.0066563194,
0.0970328823,
-0.0236214306,
0.0532011874,
0.0217308328,
0.0084906891,
0.0075760004,
0.0052236342,
-0.0107964939,
-0.0291046072,
0.0170789324,
-0.0176821053,
-0.0126349209,
0.0277100541,
0.0253290311,
0.0139515363,
-0.0400642939,
0.015930891,
-0.0425615199,
0.0208030213,
0.018433515,
0.0425601266,
0.0025221941,
-0.0414815471,
-0.0574722141,
-0.0123241488,
-0.0504626296,
0.0157817472,
0.0772614479,
0.0833818093,
-0.0496858247,
-0.0259626117,
-0.0299674496,
-0.021283187,
0.0171008296,
0.0023785464,
-0.0100388164,
-0.0441076271,
-0.0555666275,
0.0050515654,
0.0102106463,
-0.000049158,
0.0196115226,
-0.0110656768,
-0.0285316277,
-0.0040943944,
-0.0213768408,
-0.0071721603,
-0.0313935429,
-0.0243302956,
-0.0539565533,
0.0473923199,
-0.0110679809,
0.0274428632,
0.0367980935,
0.0120122824,
0.0283810701,
0.074703835,
-0.0010284616,
-0.0537324734,
-0.0480619781,
0.0443153866,
-0.056953866,
-0.0288341511,
-0.1069111601,
0.0469704121,
0.0481166802,
0.0480154492,
0.0242957249,
-0.0157226268,
-0.0274032298,
0.0126081025,
0.0133662513,
0.0141440257,
0.0129366098,
-0.056265492,
0.0059242765,
-0.0193127953,
-0.0798760056,
0.0438331552,
-0.0550651886,
0.0100560514,
-0.0175297614,
-0.0618736632,
-0.0107299546,
0.0347222872,
-0.0478350036,
0.0153702684,
0.045482602,
-0.0308947917,
0.0078095901,
-0.0234456733,
0.0246577766,
-0.0042851763,
0.0205595922,
-0.0548565388,
-0.022353977,
0.003114114,
0.0077134916,
0.011119945,
-0.0752582774,
-0.0385199375,
-0.0578481965,
0.0524341911,
-0.0458788984,
0.056878183,
-0.0181882717,
0.0344637707,
0.0191047043,
-0.0155813219,
0.0003169576,
-0.0124985408,
-0.0143670207,
-0.0081595313,
-0.0862486586,
-0.0431950763,
-0.0106013557,
0.0124095706,
0.0485193767,
0.1071431041,
-0.0103783188,
-0.0090734903,
0.019166993,
0.041420687,
0.0239827856,
-0.0286394209,
0.0729161501,
0.0510870367,
0.0045187511,
-0.0138136018,
0.0546202511,
0.0263488721,
-0.0152799021,
0.0196183156,
0.0144964596,
0.0523142628,
0.0148409205,
0.0415670834,
-0.0518632159,
-0.0292107947,
-0.0120867183,
0.0802549347,
-0.0107649509,
-0.0096890647,
-0.0362300947,
-0.0626604035,
-0.0094257705,
0.0403521955,
-0.0118716871,
0.0610419177,
-0.0482643396,
-0.0114733186,
0.0397468172,
-0.0307549834,
-0.0370515138,
-0.0104030417,
0.0197088979,
0.0011408551,
-0.095134005,
0.005107027,
0.0305496715,
-0.048637189,
0.0723983273,
0.0844983831,
-0.0220838301,
-0.0279812198,
0.0281983018,
0.0212457106,
0.009737581,
-0.0206702165,
-0.0001302991,
-0.0223875772,
0.0225442015,
0.0125576658,
0.0062688766,
0.0268409792,
-0.0305107739,
-0.0466698147,
0.0322774127,
0.0297355335,
-0.0124091143,
-0.0288945436,
-0.0074995779,
-0.0112807052,
0.028912941,
0.0127992071,
0.004842482,
-0.0477367118,
-0.0218931548,
-0.0643106848,
-0.0257541183,
-0.0434811525,
-0.0061176047,
-0.0172609724,
0.009069453,
-0.0318897963,
-0.0439244099,
0.024485901,
-0.0318966359,
0.0563887581,
0.0808784962,
-0.0078813676,
-0.0341507867,
0.0176279452,
0.0250123162,
-0.0359776728,
0.0001847703,
0.0521044657,
-0.0868872479,
0.0149882603,
-0.0177328605,
-0.0349545553,
0.0264808293,
0.0244666226,
-0.0034905593,
-0.0710230097,
0.0189165343,
0.0601887964,
0.0249585733,
-0.0180804208,
-0.0401562005,
-0.0689273849,
0.0371248871,
0.0902773663,
-0.0761895254,
0.0323054604,
0.040115267,
-0.0220082607,
0.0053863451,
-0.0127216624,
-0.0445118137,
-0.0289327689,
0.0806953013,
-0.0140804304,
-0.0553987995,
-0.0082104867,
0.0219462253,
0.0661975965,
-0.0082343509,
-0.0494829193,
0.0390909351,
0.0401972122,
-0.0030531539,
0.0035818284,
-0.0195171982,
0.0270812195,
0.0022546852,
0.0060530039,
-0.0528173968,
0.0342577808,
0.0068098386,
-0.0115862004,
-0.0151109332,
0.0063327285,
0.0399308652,
0.024402827,
0.0950309262,
0.0619690306,
0.0196299255,
-0.0180581398,
0.0587251298,
-0.0181248188,
0.0253272429,
-0.0087686311,
0.0235916674,
-0.0311017092,
-0.0470335297,
0.0060737478,
0.0634385794,
-0.0489621088,
-0.0626291111,
0.0083478866,
0.0668729767,
-0.0067329081,
0.0282933824,
-0.0044621397,
-0.0245335568,
0.021772746,
-0.0525934771,
-0.0124254413,
-0.0535042472,
-0.0750746578,
-0.0015749597,
-0.0100997137,
-0.009711937,
0.0035479018,
0.0381739624,
0.0092731314,
0.0115121016,
0.0181898754,
-0.0349326357,
-0.0341883302,
0.0193672366,
0.0692001656,
0.0239493847,
-0.0871734768,
-0.0676746964,
-0.0619539768,
-0.0566486567,
-0.0133914277,
-0.0084847873,
0.0552360266,
0.0052619032,
-0.021198133,
0.0534948185,
-0.0240060687,
0.04336714,
-0.0688211471,
0.0171456113,
-0.027652856,
-0.0412967801,
0.0111022862,
-6.290267901e-33,
0.0553357564,
-0.0123976571,
-0.0601674616,
-0.0122957798,
0.0069174753,
0.0005971952,
-0.0502755679,
0.0339990817,
0.0090786414,
-0.0515246429,
-0.0225230269,
-0.0101103149,
0.0134526128,
-0.0333917998,
-0.0339079723,
-0.0101429941,
0.0005535323,
0.0264518093,
-0.0343901403,
0.0406128205,
0.0603281371,
0.0209895857,
-0.0206947345,
-0.0494139344,
0.0222919378,
-0.0482179187,
-0.0170954764,
-0.0046591531,
-0.0135472259,
0.0180080924,
0.0423114002,
-0.0021306495,
0.0017220406,
-0.0273343343,
-0.0094929961,
0.0854470283,
0.0221507698,
-0.016252758,
0.0440211557,
-0.0015432152,
0.0294215418,
-0.0352477953,
-0.0126967011,
0.0059592607,
-0.0161053278,
0.0157923885,
-0.0074126027,
0.0201479327,
-0.019132575,
-0.0063292398,
0.0084941434,
-0.0251598451,
-0.0147364093,
0.0163253844,
-0.0330190957,
-0.0077135786,
-0.0249871295,
-0.0266529638,
-0.0018978349,
0.0472995788,
0.0103324857,
-0.017519556,
0.0219060946,
0.0130151315,
-0.0236779377,
0.0309853721,
-0.070174925,
-0.033907298,
0.0194880478,
-0.005689634,
-0.004453334,
0.0577472746,
0.0387746952,
0.0840372443,
0.0193474554,
-0.0537813641,
-0.0205494054,
0.0305161364,
0.0655102059,
-0.0255497824,
0.0144833932,
-0.0161450338,
-0.0248848069,
-0.0087230206,
0.0192154516,
-0.0088363877,
-0.018274596,
-0.0844288543,
0.0116121285,
-0.0246171411,
-0.0487559773,
-0.0398131236,
-0.0124758231,
-0.0323391072,
-0.0118662249,
0.0085065691,
-0.0006268887,
-0.0070157093,
-0.0322331078,
-0.005032165,
0.0204665363,
0.0112872599,
-0.0117342677,
-0.0533811301,
0.0336773321,
0.0012989406,
0.0047125001,
0.0284074806,
-0.0594060533,
-0.0094648106,
-0.0115112206,
0.0319018103,
-0.018588284,
-0.0363130681,
-0.0049777594,
-0.0147666102,
0.0161532778,
-0.0151762087,
0.0235752482,
-0.029530298,
-0.040691983,
0.0088684335,
-0.0176354963,
0.0387847163,
-0.0052602557,
0.0419158563,
-0.0141399438,
0.0128933312,
0.0333623029,
-0.0204819273,
-0.0093742134,
-0.0302867498,
3.267e-7,
-0.0527257957,
-0.0243534986,
0.0064430065,
-0.0245732777,
-0.0045094932,
0.0754248723,
-0.0210210029,
0.0993182957,
0.002257928,
-0.0676308274,
-0.0372142904,
-0.0321709365,
0.0554285608,
0.0632161871,
-0.048023954,
0.0735863447,
-0.0446678586,
0.0175736994,
-0.0752926022,
0.0040368577,
0.0277586263,
0.0248672683,
0.0224970784,
-0.0326724201,
0.012490347,
0.0073842313,
-0.0202870686,
-0.0312528647,
-0.0097324131,
-0.0040836064,
-0.0144087663,
-0.0121964952,
-0.0045865895,
0.0263204332,
-0.0389634185,
-0.0462759472,
-0.0558844469,
0.0041780286,
0.0367470905,
0.0158186816,
-0.0106706778,
-0.0625551492,
-0.0143668614,
-0.0608622395,
0.0434416272,
0.0350526534,
-0.0311439503,
0.0143122273,
0.0131217912,
-0.0513634309,
-0.0239232611,
-0.0142181451,
0.0303418525,
-0.0104349852,
0.0181918163,
0.02152895,
0.0158959441,
-0.0479243509,
0.0078126248,
0.0017424641,
0.0257572774,
-0.0328699127,
-0.0203893762,
0.0581900403,
0.0307209697,
0.0118901208,
0.0545571372,
3.273374323e-34,
-0.0353157483,
-0.0370273069,
0.026894005,
0.0027961475,
0.0416709147,
0.0260111131,
0.0210998282,
0.0456997976,
0.032962855,
-0.0014065999,
-0.0133573478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01899v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01899v1 | Scope-enhanced Compositional Semantic Parsing for DRT | 2024-07-02T02:50:15 | 2024-07-02T02:50:15 | Xiulin Yang, Jonas Groschwitz, Alexander Koller, Johan Bos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Discourse Representation Theory (DRT) distinguishes itself from other
semantic representation frameworks by its ability to model complex semantic and
discourse phenomena through structural nesting and variable binding. While
seq2seq models hold the state of the art on DRT parsing, their accuracy
degrades with the complexity of the sentence, and they sometimes struggle to
produce well-formed DRT representations. We introduce the AMS parser, a
compositional, neurosymbolic semantic parser for DRT. It rests on a novel
mechanism for predicting quantifier scope. We show that the AMS parser reliably
produces well-formed outputs and performs well on DRT parsing, especially on
complex sentences. | [
0.0030659025,
0.0695008487,
-0.033425089,
0.0161633566,
-0.018884711,
0.0116902776,
-0.0233535822,
-0.0347310752,
-0.0242804214,
-0.0695568174,
-0.0256995205,
0.02222527,
-0.0314984918,
0.0367292613,
-0.0031012075,
-0.0465509556,
0.0774580315,
-0.0282822885,
0.0355019234,
0.0123204337,
0.0010529613,
-0.0099272449,
-0.0154164955,
-0.0116994064,
-0.0519245341,
-0.0438280404,
-0.0036599524,
-0.0270418208,
-0.0018954292,
-0.0546857975,
0.02279111,
0.026318023,
0.0226995125,
0.0086064106,
0.0000019293,
-0.0130739752,
-0.0343496501,
0.0041491464,
-0.0102766389,
-0.0009330718,
0.0343329087,
-0.0544822142,
0.0016943908,
-0.0379995741,
-0.0474044122,
-0.0097573772,
0.0114144599,
0.0526710674,
0.0662164912,
0.0682396218,
-0.0224121716,
-0.0635655895,
0.0363499522,
-0.0030744008,
-0.0261244886,
-0.0344231762,
0.0035940565,
0.0077902242,
0.0140861059,
0.0462857001,
-0.0427958854,
0.0175883397,
0.0278892033,
0.0006579774,
0.0055295439,
0.028475605,
-0.0297250841,
0.0148868226,
0.009997298,
0.0216165185,
0.0556292757,
-0.0154352663,
-0.0073352251,
0.013695797,
0.0103259627,
-0.0151149156,
-0.0438087843,
0.0586870387,
-0.0185726155,
0.0332690924,
0.0238908716,
0.0234581977,
-0.0021488797,
-0.0088877287,
-0.0248207971,
0.069325082,
-0.0115886703,
-0.0445676446,
-0.0163331367,
0.0203502644,
-0.0665576607,
-0.0187914651,
0.0094339019,
-0.0288878046,
-0.0482855812,
0.0009076791,
-0.0223509595,
-0.0354239643,
-0.0062295292,
0.0066079628,
-0.0033147361,
0.042387642,
0.0184657592,
0.037578579,
-0.0243977178,
0.0743521899,
-0.0360038243,
-0.0148117403,
-0.0349766724,
-0.0223486554,
-0.0776479021,
-0.0748821795,
-0.0481550023,
0.0732780397,
-0.0418082066,
-0.0481466688,
-0.0397545733,
0.0198834501,
-0.0390987471,
-0.0063384813,
0.0031580161,
0.0314328745,
-0.0401614234,
0.0454945117,
-0.0226684492,
0.0285952203,
-0.0557107031,
0.0374184921,
0.0181507114,
-0.0135126021,
-0.0206741393,
0.0338569209,
0.0044433293,
-0.0396633856,
-0.0518860668,
0.0628396943,
0.0383728519,
0.0058003198,
0.0015375355,
-0.0800088868,
-0.0439413972,
-0.002645896,
0.0204411484,
-0.0591153912,
0.009401679,
0.0052883774,
0.0042013582,
-0.0582491308,
0.0070866188,
0.008247368,
0.0311608016,
0.0499887206,
0.0253369045,
-0.0340575092,
-0.0347182155,
-0.0067613306,
0.0068727848,
0.0622240193,
0.0336779691,
0.0191583391,
0.0020806256,
0.0449230857,
-0.0256992634,
-0.0273265336,
0.0112315426,
-0.0453422666,
-0.0130297737,
0.0212134328,
-0.0242013969,
0.0351809971,
0.0388869867,
0.0638717189,
-0.0412124246,
-0.0410696827,
0.0077866791,
0.0381935574,
-0.0155391768,
-0.0122377258,
0.0733459517,
0.0181312673,
-0.0318365172,
0.0154149411,
-0.0832285434,
0.0243290029,
0.0176971313,
0.0119445594,
-0.0459452756,
-0.0364811309,
0.0242868271,
-0.0647825152,
0.0113138547,
0.0074977111,
0.0167841576,
-0.0371424258,
-0.0017725553,
0.0292702112,
-0.0203703549,
0.0873028785,
0.005927748,
-0.0468000583,
0.0031585626,
-0.0213073771,
0.0088053634,
0.0122317318,
-0.0090770684,
-0.039877221,
-0.0552414805,
-0.0122149801,
0.0202281009,
0.0651932284,
-0.0126401093,
0.0000823923,
0.0077491682,
-0.0194315389,
-0.0101135075,
-0.0932640061,
0.0338812619,
-0.0103062792,
-0.0045665638,
-0.038077496,
-0.0079884799,
-0.0092777312,
0.0178829897,
0.0195877273,
0.0306350533,
-0.0030629407,
-0.0017393695,
0.0062202835,
0.0495524742,
-0.0042466284,
0.0192556214,
0.0649876744,
-0.0043559931,
-0.0328560024,
-0.0225643031,
0.0366112553,
-0.0623764247,
-0.072211884,
0.0144057618,
-0.0654856637,
-0.0261991788,
-0.0108367195,
-0.055952847,
-0.0366903208,
0.0568142235,
-0.044934433,
0.0067781685,
-0.0362419337,
-0.0393011086,
0.0295591895,
-0.0185434893,
-0.024244722,
0.0946511552,
-0.0058060889,
-0.0182750542,
-0.0010623672,
0.0174288936,
0.0157641098,
-0.039224986,
-0.0219278187,
-0.0299693216,
0.0056828172,
-0.0196326375,
0.0062721693,
-0.0182614047,
-0.0260404646,
-0.0497973785,
-0.0841084123,
0.0025611329,
-0.0131291645,
0.0295815691,
0.0315363146,
-0.0165606756,
0.0348363593,
0.0124372235,
-0.0099038538,
-0.0433343537,
-0.0129056945,
0.0229675733,
0.0627679899,
-0.0001335945,
0.0033181347,
-0.0153961722,
-0.0107114539,
-0.0738326311,
0.044363331,
-0.007730077,
-0.008414519,
-0.0191079155,
0.0152369188,
-0.0211756192,
0.0041993093,
0.0178095195,
-0.0136197666,
0.0469396301,
0.0052852649,
0.0229316782,
0.0667213276,
-0.0312084761,
0.0435524322,
-0.0034726404,
-0.0331680737,
-0.0074451487,
0.040811535,
-0.0095426943,
0.048976671,
-0.0479301251,
0.0227539949,
0.0362038016,
0.0714464709,
0.0103680799,
-0.0008195825,
-0.0502896905,
0.0642877221,
-0.0536202677,
-0.0296095889,
-0.0103969816,
0.0004342778,
-0.0152059337,
0.050035812,
-0.0332103521,
-0.0011023437,
0.0761642009,
0.0067370036,
-0.0073714922,
-0.0297239982,
0.0177313425,
-0.0451706573,
0.0574729443,
0.0126601588,
-0.0064215511,
0.02209902,
-0.0749675781,
-0.0486625321,
-0.0326031335,
0.0279649124,
0.0175243821,
0.0268240608,
-0.0200078972,
-0.0010849503,
-0.0026034217,
-0.0424045846,
-0.0184407961,
-0.0131598767,
-0.0268807299,
0.0545425899,
-0.0002921599,
0.0318203345,
0.0032817796,
-0.0120956423,
-0.008677504,
-0.0032167202,
-0.0582645237,
-0.0116932318,
-0.0649854764,
0.0235102642,
0.0208026823,
0.0225987062,
0.0427699052,
0.002879506,
0.0070970706,
0.0672146678,
-0.0649340078,
0.0308556482,
-0.0317962877,
0.0408652499,
-0.0241454914,
0.006839959,
-0.0579583272,
-0.0174889322,
0.0658957511,
-0.0495907068,
-0.0169112571,
0.1048141494,
0.0168806333,
0.0272289775,
0.0253737494,
-0.0634013638,
0.0257823635,
0.0319459103,
0.0215733312,
-0.0969816968,
-0.0197000094,
0.0168158393,
-0.0130748656,
0.0023390697,
-0.0479411073,
0.0179033279,
-0.0553648062,
0.0312981382,
0.0079611894,
-0.011603402,
0.026145231,
0.0131478934,
0.0022374929,
-0.0312453397,
0.0197099596,
0.021584738,
-0.0432495475,
0.04223153,
-0.0092027653,
0.0163090304,
-0.0087775076,
0.0247507617,
-0.0294906292,
0.010033709,
0.0391039923,
0.0297181346,
-0.0154451206,
0.0118609937,
0.0094974441,
-0.0343052037,
0.0145895677,
-0.0079472093,
-0.0378725044,
-0.0125434715,
-0.0008560031,
-0.0349026509,
0.0402995087,
-0.0216303226,
-0.0271680932,
-0.0006062012,
0.072104089,
-0.0317576751,
0.0133114168,
-0.0158098582,
0.0198385119,
-0.0287837181,
0.0671126992,
0.0803330615,
0.0341519378,
-0.073935844,
-0.0399832167,
-0.006360875,
-0.0278791767,
-0.0024619675,
0.0173643697,
0.0590955764,
-0.0049848254,
-0.0655543581,
-0.0578371957,
0.027111426,
-0.0193542484,
-0.0498917885,
-0.0098041603,
0.0690674037,
-0.0536018759,
-0.013848369,
0.0087168962,
-0.005898512,
0.0166038275,
-0.0293923784,
0.0493483581,
0.0488717221,
-0.0044014598,
-0.0595176779,
-0.0679885671,
-0.0337180085,
-0.0350402482,
0.0035890152,
0.0613917075,
0.0110588651,
0.0071224845,
-0.0347918868,
0.0034640422,
0.0075391028,
0.0535964891,
-0.0711626634,
0.0439762436,
0.0571896508,
0.0561813787,
0.0313539729,
0.0461298041,
0.0018387036,
0.0307093076,
-0.024294069,
0.085134767,
-0.0178472921,
0.0467903055,
0.0487147532,
-0.0055233655,
0.0554966927,
0.0429538339,
0.0302922241,
-0.010943071,
-0.018243745,
-0.0754552856,
-0.0374200977,
-0.0575321689,
0.0294359494,
0.0252204705,
0.006797479,
-0.0208082832,
-0.0288820267,
0.0049043582,
0.0458904058,
-0.0160888545,
0.0074911388,
0.0417190455,
-0.042667333,
-0.034719456,
0.0065998468,
-0.0160723571,
0.0126809515,
-0.0346042998,
0.0239959303,
-0.0378725864,
0.0142045096,
0.0463867635,
-0.0110670375,
-0.0614197105,
0.0058648367,
-0.0611986704,
0.0250220168,
0.0724724904,
-0.0269019473,
0.0275961738,
0.0121222977,
0.0520630181,
-0.0098467739,
-0.0016413282,
0.0231570397,
0.0477078259,
0.0364789292,
-0.0092653865,
0.0634825528,
0.0313277505,
-0.013755586,
-0.0640954673,
0.0397433452,
-0.0088886255,
0.012613778,
0.0246263687,
0.0095893797,
-0.0327131636,
-0.0735611841,
-0.035077069,
0.0367414951,
-0.0179527402,
0.035230238,
-0.0395843908,
-0.0153146917,
0.0390501134,
0.0134012224,
-0.0151272193,
-0.058722958,
0.0286730584,
0.0450624637,
0.0234430265,
-0.094587177,
-0.0178971887,
-0.0135254627,
0.0240688547,
-0.0293790866,
-0.0358400308,
-6.015835521e-33,
-0.0657892153,
-0.0035722973,
0.0417180061,
-0.0043440559,
-0.0481224656,
0.0196900424,
-0.0483908579,
0.0042867609,
0.025276687,
0.0604401492,
-0.0034609083,
0.0347803682,
0.0126157291,
0.0397253521,
0.0421783477,
-0.0054268003,
0.059116073,
0.0040119104,
-0.0112510007,
-0.0086123953,
0.0595147945,
0.0095260795,
0.0303932186,
-0.0127318529,
-0.00693262,
0.0157291088,
0.0119962245,
0.0598376356,
-0.0247039311,
0.0484653972,
0.0278542526,
-0.0054550152,
0.024213301,
0.0054123052,
-0.0312390644,
0.0022275271,
-0.0741566941,
-0.0717006624,
0.0485881791,
-0.0084323091,
-0.0594488159,
-0.0502898395,
0.0615361109,
-0.0261960682,
0.0351519734,
-0.0199588053,
0.0116554108,
-0.0116631752,
0.0068863695,
-0.0136005003,
-0.0856350139,
0.0055187782,
0.0085393926,
0.0423021354,
0.0096819634,
0.0140411258,
0.0003067546,
0.0185458697,
-0.0386111699,
-0.0126725351,
-0.0649545863,
0.0629192889,
-0.0096585527,
-0.0032017329,
0.0350391567,
0.0535275899,
0.0002022854,
-0.0334058963,
-0.0588147342,
0.0614239462,
0.0027680632,
0.0616234802,
-0.0100298543,
0.0052608382,
-0.0096940026,
0.0341788754,
-0.0468903594,
-0.0505889431,
-0.0076741921,
0.1259403527,
-0.0044629839,
0.0215068422,
-0.0072634486,
-0.0066134483,
-0.0392960794,
0.0200021006,
-0.0135973757,
-0.0175239909,
0.016727671,
-0.0456541516,
-0.0256419089,
0.012274337,
0.0270036887,
-0.0423717983,
0.0034309668,
0.0272406656,
0.0113524655,
0.0003053828,
0.0109958528,
0.0459394343,
0.022198746,
-0.0328752436,
0.0181290135,
-0.0064967638,
0.0393612906,
-0.0020007975,
0.0458050072,
0.003704936,
-0.0020989303,
0.0101684164,
-0.035281796,
-0.0130315367,
-0.0509346463,
0.0415236577,
0.0184014644,
0.0639869422,
-0.0173224173,
0.0169980004,
-0.0157568678,
0.0239950139,
-0.0373418815,
0.0291147083,
0.0078697111,
0.0552225597,
-0.043361038,
-0.030563768,
-0.0356503204,
0.0189964138,
0.013841494,
-0.0414312817,
-0.0232499316,
0.0305691715,
2.701e-7,
0.0433315635,
0.0425783657,
0.0320518054,
0.0383751951,
0.0340050645,
-0.0025726336,
0.0183037054,
0.0398672186,
-0.0139473798,
-0.0218195617,
-0.0270833522,
0.0482186824,
-0.0139757954,
0.0369981341,
-0.0665359721,
0.0282103401,
-0.0631219819,
-0.0361825265,
-0.0245668218,
0.0374805816,
0.0877719373,
0.0736921653,
0.0074057477,
0.0300644934,
0.0099388193,
0.0061684088,
0.0569530316,
0.0214258265,
0.023113329,
0.0173261911,
-0.0434760526,
0.002091133,
0.0366922393,
-0.016612757,
0.0422805957,
0.0354627706,
-0.0115853865,
0.086163573,
-0.0091401711,
0.0284520648,
-0.0081441943,
-0.0302277952,
-0.0141787119,
-0.0302284975,
0.0429240093,
-0.1149055287,
-0.0591471717,
-0.0339446701,
-0.0557980649,
-0.0045381631,
-0.0142677734,
0.0352232866,
-0.01502926,
-0.0081795538,
0.0197414272,
0.0036015338,
0.0004178155,
-0.0401657633,
-0.0107123172,
-0.0193171259,
-0.0216855891,
0.0085022086,
-0.0059840926,
0.0091946237,
0.0260557663,
-0.0460443012,
-0.0367086381,
2.363431952e-34,
0.0531948283,
0.0041831164,
0.0474055707,
-0.0025249817,
0.0362145528,
0.0044530793,
-0.0304533485,
0.0377874374,
0.0170047153,
-0.0876560584,
-0.0334028304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01897v1 | Proposal Report for the 2nd SciCAP Competition 2024 | 2024-07-02T02:42:29 | 2024-07-02T02:42:29 | Pengpeng Li, Tingmin Li, Jingyuan Wang, Boyuan Wang, Yang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose a method for document summarization using auxiliary
information. This approach effectively summarizes descriptions related to
specific images, tables, and appendices within lengthy texts. Our experiments
demonstrate that leveraging high-quality OCR data and initially extracted
information from the original text enables efficient summarization of the
content related to described objects. Based on these findings, we enhanced
popular text generation model models by incorporating additional auxiliary
branches to improve summarization performance. Our method achieved top scores
of 4.33 and 4.66 in the long caption and short caption tracks, respectively, of
the 2024 SciCAP competition, ranking highest in both categories. | [
0.0344179757,
0.0368236341,
0.044098217,
-0.0148424748,
-0.005379349,
0.0173082519,
-0.0279916935,
0.0380046517,
-0.0162920393,
-0.0514985882,
0.0168522317,
0.0112207606,
0.0472348332,
0.0184814464,
0.0100370441,
-0.1041244268,
-0.0013667884,
-0.0497315377,
-0.0362303853,
0.0204623695,
0.0269219913,
-0.0155356992,
0.0197033286,
-0.0060864962,
0.0032060232,
0.0215199068,
-0.0009382776,
-0.000344765,
0.0278446171,
-0.0257897172,
-0.0079216296,
0.0194458682,
0.0602059253,
0.0125036202,
0.0000019964,
-0.0522419326,
-0.0251621846,
0.039609585,
0.0185095184,
0.0202439167,
0.0807681009,
-0.0295050759,
0.0249356646,
-0.0127954688,
0.0139865866,
0.020318307,
0.0290164668,
0.0696879253,
0.0135162696,
0.0366399512,
-0.0294544045,
-0.036994677,
-0.0102720456,
-0.002641855,
-0.0153394612,
0.0115428967,
-0.0342419147,
0.0411311649,
0.0304483511,
-0.0160492584,
0.030759193,
0.0431392975,
0.0020673312,
-0.0051448862,
0.031637121,
0.0902676135,
-0.0227512177,
-0.0271395054,
0.0035142649,
0.0727780089,
0.0266492013,
-0.0052568526,
0.0205759741,
0.0090100328,
-0.0127219753,
-0.0035714037,
-0.1068634912,
0.0620757863,
-0.0185968503,
-0.0295482092,
0.0103286523,
0.0761124268,
-0.0556661524,
0.016997939,
-0.0166377872,
-0.0099612223,
0.012646798,
-0.0018014139,
-0.0433927514,
0.0048551601,
-0.0153706055,
-0.0508767553,
0.0252645612,
0.0501345955,
0.0612229481,
-0.0311722532,
-0.053912688,
-0.0753152966,
0.0477198698,
-0.0685033053,
-0.0136712613,
-0.0114073716,
0.0004092927,
0.0618491545,
-0.0162338279,
0.0199166518,
0.0237888657,
0.0024086593,
-0.0475183353,
-0.0025047828,
-0.0325968117,
0.00902435,
-0.0178042315,
0.0414512865,
-0.0467430875,
-0.0721732304,
-0.0122417659,
-0.0060177613,
0.032618694,
0.0030991375,
-0.0149309766,
0.020089522,
-0.0256833974,
-0.0004001332,
-0.0117609305,
0.008743912,
-0.0163822006,
-0.0164006073,
0.0273162946,
0.0025101274,
-0.0192049313,
0.0405591056,
0.0458167493,
0.027341865,
-0.0149896275,
0.049234122,
-0.0577143729,
-0.0439680927,
0.0223135389,
-0.0521159247,
-0.0287246574,
-0.0548812114,
-0.0142316334,
-0.0555407368,
0.0062722038,
-0.0019863269,
-0.0121345902,
-0.0235039517,
0.0220566262,
0.0237160549,
-0.0347436666,
0.0156892966,
-0.0621838309,
-0.004943904,
0.0624603853,
0.0268941838,
0.0264653452,
0.0397201665,
0.0171475783,
0.0653358549,
0.0330443271,
0.0047864066,
0.0365202129,
0.0176319201,
0.0194929205,
-0.0084144073,
0.0153846722,
-0.0009624773,
-0.0000278876,
-0.0003611214,
0.0147201587,
0.0170866344,
-0.039951656,
0.0773532763,
0.0776118487,
0.0548232943,
-0.0605553836,
0.0260056928,
0.0119506605,
0.0014549262,
0.0444753952,
0.0421810485,
0.001222673,
0.0633551702,
-0.0089251613,
0.0788729489,
0.034438163,
0.0344390571,
-0.0149483178,
-0.0422973484,
0.0118548023,
-0.0024478266,
0.0052527683,
-0.0123660574,
0.0280245002,
0.0311296396,
-0.0746052638,
0.0211591627,
-0.0302211735,
-0.0898901895,
0.0087621408,
-0.0122220945,
0.0131848501,
0.0463317037,
0.0769345462,
-0.0252336208,
-0.0134840915,
-0.0069958852,
0.0207986105,
0.0690719113,
0.0374331549,
-0.0083089815,
-0.0044829822,
-0.0530617237,
-0.0361443758,
-0.0008681612,
-0.0034553059,
-0.010266766,
0.0036405562,
-0.0020583754,
0.0649019554,
-0.0188116468,
-0.1131363958,
0.0445359871,
0.0070221238,
-0.0166237857,
-0.0275662467,
-0.011210422,
-0.010069415,
0.0159168337,
-0.0311221201,
0.0157851744,
0.0220028907,
0.0051645054,
0.0112514999,
0.0539757833,
-0.0107153757,
-0.0086758984,
0.0216329191,
-0.0755844563,
-0.0098691341,
-0.0025358154,
0.0085964017,
-0.0541318618,
0.0035487758,
-0.0473183133,
-0.0116772177,
-0.0394546278,
0.0455591083,
0.025828965,
0.0221218634,
-0.0006385328,
0.0776050463,
0.0245400798,
-0.0282529369,
0.0703936815,
-0.0711293519,
0.0140526239,
-0.0417235978,
0.0168621596,
-0.0044960463,
0.0100236861,
-0.0213171914,
0.0757542253,
0.0364375338,
-0.0307758637,
-0.0286762267,
-0.0861917958,
-0.033262413,
0.0001002105,
-0.0055825678,
0.0422355905,
0.0056220046,
0.0075824484,
0.0249466747,
-0.0172026251,
-0.0337011367,
-0.0045797722,
-0.0438824445,
0.0592382886,
0.0260247663,
0.013065435,
-0.0325322598,
-0.010691422,
0.0231811199,
0.0517572388,
0.0687454492,
-0.0657544807,
0.0044159088,
0.0332769379,
-0.0137014929,
-0.0274648461,
0.0047689513,
0.0188233033,
-0.0217272155,
-0.0111018559,
0.0211085211,
0.0246710312,
0.0305166524,
0.0020638271,
0.0165531244,
-0.0115340082,
-0.0175998714,
-0.0125449141,
-0.0187198259,
0.0294764712,
0.0599811971,
-0.0436557308,
0.0281036925,
-0.0003565637,
-0.0213994104,
0.0510249622,
-0.002554225,
-0.0136779239,
-0.0029205917,
-0.0393277556,
-0.0551659465,
-0.0106531084,
0.0324639007,
0.027628025,
-0.022002453,
-0.0379419439,
0.0214105472,
-0.0500869229,
0.0031046956,
-0.0510413945,
0.0122646065,
-0.0479003191,
0.0523285344,
0.0321410149,
0.0422871709,
0.0455357954,
0.0033348829,
0.0002590756,
-0.0003272416,
0.0321373753,
-0.0242708381,
0.0442738049,
-0.0583472364,
0.0316591859,
-0.0322134718,
0.0076278313,
0.0063623488,
-0.0342973918,
0.007593134,
-0.0060610278,
-0.0296481363,
-0.04617716,
-0.0466230959,
0.0536628552,
0.0374238119,
0.0608836934,
-0.0439796261,
-0.0254170876,
0.0009504151,
0.088553831,
0.0706297085,
0.0068519018,
0.0072698444,
-0.0645830259,
0.0249433611,
0.0298835114,
0.0226767901,
-0.0336501338,
0.0235498287,
-0.0013922959,
-0.0274515487,
-0.046069514,
0.0113507453,
0.021716807,
0.030740425,
-0.0642684847,
-0.010703763,
0.0833821297,
0.0398398153,
-0.0218547471,
-0.0517561026,
0.0312871113,
0.048616454,
0.0051259859,
-0.0018322095,
-0.0428537205,
0.0004289497,
-0.0120946094,
0.0303473007,
-0.0013111995,
0.0050424859,
-0.0475197099,
-0.048627533,
0.0662458539,
0.0398604646,
-0.1207983643,
-0.0668476298,
-0.0183496289,
-0.0167199709,
0.0244725812,
-0.033074975,
0.0245624911,
-0.020928314,
-0.01347504,
-0.0161575396,
-0.069986552,
0.0030221303,
-0.0482930392,
-0.0229377914,
-0.0231747963,
0.042687349,
0.0398748145,
-0.0195636824,
0.0428351276,
0.030928202,
-0.0359684229,
-0.0073174275,
-0.0228168443,
0.0948919132,
-0.005069233,
0.0169259049,
-0.0112517914,
0.0572544672,
0.0197064094,
0.0033184537,
0.0225325413,
-0.000878684,
0.0065019219,
-0.0165667497,
-0.074013263,
0.0382379219,
-0.0328017548,
0.035985589,
0.0559342541,
0.0180194955,
-0.0344809778,
-0.0286890306,
-0.0005081078,
-0.0787535384,
0.0223236252,
-0.0178439096,
-0.0440182649,
-0.0909933522,
-0.0806673542,
-0.0152990995,
0.0430682525,
-0.0018980139,
0.005833426,
0.0258704331,
-0.0386308283,
0.0248531029,
-0.0545417778,
0.0072927349,
-0.0231327005,
-0.03288991,
-0.0149153294,
-0.0184056722,
0.0364524163,
-0.0267411917,
-0.0180854071,
0.0590941943,
-0.0426737629,
-0.0259381514,
-0.0380367786,
0.0593165234,
0.0197644867,
0.0241195578,
0.022041278,
-0.0248455778,
0.0034344657,
0.036407914,
0.0432282314,
0.0062479926,
-0.0095101614,
-0.0062574907,
-0.0373144373,
-0.0185022745,
-0.0444257148,
0.0165875256,
-0.0673718676,
0.0100784926,
-0.0050109541,
-0.0341850668,
0.0225608274,
0.0407922678,
-0.0573538579,
-0.0590738244,
0.0025737241,
-0.0227972306,
-0.0287417304,
-0.031831298,
-0.0208675973,
-0.0208641998,
0.0589764602,
-0.0255676359,
0.0483041778,
0.0073253429,
0.064319931,
-0.0057021729,
0.0226784106,
-0.0299684796,
-0.0082844337,
0.0019315057,
-0.0413883254,
-0.0370441154,
-0.0144536104,
-0.0170916468,
-0.0242726877,
-0.0357483216,
0.0156689771,
-0.0388115123,
0.0186731573,
0.0156670045,
0.0114651676,
-0.0195695497,
0.0251708608,
-0.0659960285,
0.0211652014,
-0.0835405439,
0.0785427764,
0.0429375283,
-0.0324872509,
0.0565206483,
-0.0369867943,
-0.0221227463,
0.0028380083,
0.0377596654,
0.0118786748,
-0.0047492171,
-0.041837845,
0.0104384124,
0.030021308,
0.0094374847,
0.0919656232,
0.0143625457,
-0.0207444988,
0.0199520886,
-0.0103266267,
-0.0477119163,
-0.0099491654,
-0.0226479881,
-0.0051568281,
0.003936287,
-0.0016174838,
-0.0225956943,
-0.0020533574,
0.040527191,
0.0204567667,
0.0073644295,
-0.0091305114,
0.0641062632,
0.0097349137,
-0.0041222428,
0.0046127168,
-0.0186122116,
-0.0328860693,
0.0052866694,
-0.0033805713,
0.0040799174,
-5.621850222e-33,
-0.0396239795,
-0.0538753271,
-0.0152836479,
0.0199087486,
-0.0417677201,
0.0282133371,
-0.073741667,
-0.0276393592,
0.0398568064,
-0.0222526249,
0.0092107151,
-0.0230690818,
0.031427037,
0.0299439635,
-0.0325592682,
0.0430172458,
0.0295884386,
0.0002548506,
-0.0343694426,
0.0499147438,
0.0153316325,
-0.0047302116,
-0.0006162477,
-0.0512967147,
0.0282097179,
-0.0081048151,
-0.035317447,
-0.0647721663,
0.0805488601,
0.0051423465,
-0.0261220392,
-0.0281474274,
0.0093315076,
-0.0327369645,
-0.0463197865,
-0.0076175812,
-0.0970022753,
0.0257164594,
0.0018344331,
-0.0229353812,
-0.0288405623,
-0.0456698164,
0.0167614352,
-0.0514609441,
-0.0017679568,
-0.041536741,
0.0723165125,
-0.0261741653,
-0.0312295612,
-0.050762929,
-0.0363070033,
0.025037149,
-0.0535705499,
0.0076031564,
0.0560390688,
0.0438270234,
0.0102752019,
0.0203234479,
-0.0027164014,
0.0707939565,
0.0689266101,
0.0311942957,
0.0689547285,
0.005442353,
0.0147000263,
0.0192052238,
-0.0039884169,
-0.000845984,
-0.0316295102,
0.0244338717,
-0.0150566287,
0.0324393213,
0.0438708551,
0.0179291796,
0.0588562489,
0.007690615,
-0.0382302403,
0.1164461672,
-0.050429184,
0.0081669223,
0.0201986395,
-0.0334324315,
-0.0145400567,
0.0255174637,
-0.0002428013,
0.0140185794,
-0.0100115519,
0.0098462505,
0.0052592801,
0.0425580032,
-0.047244098,
-0.0196147524,
0.0342316031,
-0.0076521034,
0.029349003,
0.0005764285,
-0.005489747,
0.0713301152,
-0.0223958027,
-0.0590676554,
-0.0231901873,
-0.0146809034,
0.0533097722,
0.0292218123,
-0.0034599788,
0.0003416655,
0.0295510609,
0.0236070342,
-0.0083561344,
0.0011313825,
0.0117064342,
-0.0162205752,
-0.0014357521,
0.013740805,
-0.0249047745,
-0.0030369149,
-0.0220937468,
0.0257905591,
-0.0233885329,
0.0262109619,
-0.0003418362,
-0.0405592397,
0.0149615258,
0.0260734204,
-0.0016292316,
0.0513190478,
-0.0124813979,
-0.0289359931,
-0.0012480324,
-0.0305686537,
-0.0234399922,
0.0339046791,
2.473e-7,
0.04654314,
0.0364891104,
0.0831980258,
-0.0016715815,
-0.0325289667,
-0.0076104477,
-0.0095066195,
0.0086617712,
-0.0150536066,
-0.0148468837,
0.0683051571,
0.0027523402,
0.0369911902,
-0.0111092869,
-0.0649831593,
-0.0834976956,
-0.0341263451,
-0.0628632903,
-0.0341540501,
-0.0325351097,
0.0413279012,
0.0346954428,
-0.0749035999,
-0.0378606841,
0.0102189938,
-0.0371590219,
0.0564774945,
-0.0250539575,
0.0008751408,
0.0101594655,
0.0395719446,
0.0160412174,
-0.0544856153,
0.000795991,
-0.0186479241,
0.0029549743,
0.0844506696,
0.0135264387,
0.0004854108,
-0.0018603907,
0.0012092558,
0.0140496222,
0.0241412539,
-0.0109268809,
0.0333015919,
-0.0201607812,
0.0072895265,
-0.014512538,
-0.0437234826,
0.0361235738,
-0.0133336196,
-0.0160713829,
-0.0609546602,
0.0690958872,
0.003565375,
-0.0212077834,
-0.0064915651,
-0.0465997122,
-0.039864745,
0.0088093886,
0.0132273939,
-0.0187834352,
-0.0157476589,
-0.0349313878,
0.0149107752,
-0.0371315256,
-0.0378781185,
2.520812049e-34,
0.087307699,
-0.0098787313,
-0.0419853404,
0.0181434564,
0.0436730534,
-0.0521524586,
-0.0126736434,
-0.015425209,
0.0035297149,
-0.0683960542,
-0.0121623455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01896v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01896v1 | LogEval: A Comprehensive Benchmark Suite for Large Language Models In Log Analysis | 2024-07-02T02:39:33 | 2024-07-02T02:39:33 | Tianyu Cui, Shiyu Ma, Ziang Chen, Tong Xiao, Shimin Tao, Yilun Liu, Shenglin Zhang, Duoming Lin, Changchang Liu, Yuzhe Cai, Weibin Meng, Yongqian Sun, Dan Pei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Log analysis is crucial for ensuring the orderly and stable operation of
information systems, particularly in the field of Artificial Intelligence for
IT Operations (AIOps). Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated
significant potential in natural language processing tasks. In the AIOps
domain, they excel in tasks such as anomaly detection, root cause analysis of
faults, operations and maintenance script generation, and alert information
summarization. However, the performance of current LLMs in log analysis tasks
remains inadequately validated. To address this gap, we introduce LogEval, a
comprehensive benchmark suite designed to evaluate the capabilities of LLMs in
various log analysis tasks for the first time. This benchmark covers tasks such
as log parsing, log anomaly detection, log fault diagnosis, and log
summarization. LogEval evaluates each task using 4,000 publicly available log
data entries and employs 15 different prompts for each task to ensure a
thorough and fair assessment. By rigorously evaluating leading LLMs, we
demonstrate the impact of various LLM technologies on log analysis performance,
focusing on aspects such as self-consistency and few-shot contextual learning.
We also discuss findings related to model quantification, Chinese-English
question-answering evaluation, and prompt engineering. These findings provide
insights into the strengths and weaknesses of LLMs in multilingual environments
and the effectiveness of different prompt strategies. Various evaluation
methods are employed for different tasks to accurately measure the performance
of LLMs in log analysis, ensuring a comprehensive assessment. The insights
gained from LogEvals evaluation reveal the strengths and limitations of LLMs in
log analysis tasks, providing valuable guidance for researchers and
practitioners. | [
0.053788431,
0.0216487292,
0.0109075857,
0.0179585014,
-0.0399849489,
-0.0014257106,
0.028132569,
-0.0278127156,
0.0059421281,
-0.068236798,
0.026945686,
-0.0704207122,
-0.0456926897,
0.0696982369,
-0.0074957381,
-0.0147965159,
0.0589918382,
-0.0064308965,
-0.0225287154,
0.0222812854,
0.0093218302,
0.0171042196,
0.0195837263,
0.0329101458,
0.0103853112,
-0.022724079,
-0.0159260333,
0.0171022881,
0.0172540322,
-0.0383266658,
0.002678911,
-0.0014893458,
0.0066666473,
0.0429958627,
0.000002174,
-0.1180315912,
-0.0283482932,
0.0126113808,
-0.076722376,
0.0494291857,
-0.0179631859,
-0.0191817526,
-0.0171045195,
0.043452654,
-0.0460529365,
-0.0274835285,
0.0386231542,
0.05319608,
0.0544099212,
0.0795483738,
-0.0125204055,
-0.0386069082,
0.015378003,
0.0018951179,
-0.0068851546,
-0.0440598689,
0.0233338736,
0.0367296077,
0.0504205786,
-0.0457158796,
0.0075257947,
0.0054889848,
0.038475994,
-0.0272965673,
-0.0236926265,
0.0177823529,
0.0061963205,
0.0073853685,
-0.0150026288,
0.0201665182,
-0.008238459,
0.003172094,
0.0025916998,
-0.0274836328,
-0.0058301953,
-0.0642313361,
-0.0273334067,
0.0447096042,
-0.0357927494,
-0.0137704639,
0.0498059131,
0.0159648005,
-0.0053962865,
0.0006880579,
-0.0440094396,
0.0387864262,
-0.0229983851,
-0.0363372639,
-0.0198991261,
0.0069674733,
0.0060951975,
-0.0531625822,
-0.0154495183,
0.0556452423,
-0.0737809911,
0.0027554154,
0.00502927,
0.0198498033,
0.0364975147,
-0.0263000242,
-0.0020033338,
0.0225621145,
0.0008103874,
0.036998488,
0.005911367,
0.1022298709,
0.0416076407,
0.0238066614,
-0.0417029373,
-0.0352775119,
-0.0676158592,
-0.0307517145,
-0.0386517644,
0.0119144944,
0.0258110277,
-0.0010845041,
-0.0129133947,
0.0697562322,
0.0025387967,
0.0342084393,
0.0127141038,
-0.0259489659,
-0.0042083771,
-0.0076432615,
-0.0293179713,
-0.0132890185,
-0.0263332706,
0.0200452507,
-0.0043591573,
-0.0622621514,
-0.0119846202,
0.0345898084,
0.0000467578,
-0.0093723293,
0.0036740832,
0.0270019006,
0.0230901055,
-0.0041694259,
-0.0349200554,
-0.0390621684,
-0.0277627464,
-0.0392475016,
-0.078049086,
-0.0539335944,
-0.0031630602,
-0.0013483177,
0.0051861345,
0.0019881043,
-0.0083283689,
-0.0417672545,
0.0232015047,
0.0252473839,
-0.0399152823,
0.0074339183,
-0.0044461484,
-0.0075255721,
0.0224119984,
0.0536748618,
0.0210126787,
0.028612975,
0.0406012051,
-0.0226950441,
0.0455044247,
0.0125247566,
-0.0327669941,
-0.0374144241,
-0.0053734155,
0.0361374058,
-0.0392863601,
-0.0203702357,
0.0192024149,
0.0458406545,
0.0261418708,
-0.0065880292,
0.0009447554,
0.0404112078,
0.0079608401,
-0.0019041235,
0.0953517035,
-0.0022918263,
-0.0174062736,
0.0089529846,
-0.0047534732,
-0.003279675,
-0.0091717914,
0.0091474075,
0.0425223745,
0.0167305134,
-0.0343532711,
-0.0844444931,
-0.0499732532,
0.01879384,
-0.0496694595,
0.0267463457,
0.043479152,
-0.0263999086,
0.0038413731,
-0.012020478,
-0.0062028733,
-0.0115494682,
0.0169663783,
-0.0563878156,
-0.0017922944,
0.1007523984,
0.0260542445,
-0.0665544644,
-0.0424526744,
-0.0440336168,
0.0153164444,
0.0248467829,
0.0523964316,
-0.0094318809,
0.0087788776,
-0.0017168766,
-0.0071408418,
0.0131264245,
0.0103888996,
0.0138966115,
-0.0210806895,
-0.001870489,
-0.0044229236,
-0.022939885,
-0.0817250684,
0.0310237464,
-0.0456912741,
-0.0468908958,
0.0044215154,
0.0086521357,
0.0324042328,
0.021797752,
-0.0379342437,
0.0281054266,
0.0251029227,
-0.0214805882,
-0.065938957,
0.0523630269,
-0.0233171768,
0.005164966,
0.0327639841,
-0.0159932766,
-0.0126269022,
-0.0027633775,
-0.057142172,
-0.0763449818,
0.0212170985,
-0.0597403236,
0.0028458997,
-0.0375787728,
0.0176568404,
-0.0157243684,
-0.0062154662,
-0.0484652743,
0.0406845808,
0.0213516299,
0.0277709495,
-0.0212388709,
0.026143223,
0.0281336233,
-0.0399737097,
-0.028433973,
0.0268015712,
-0.0563278683,
0.0356781557,
0.0548683889,
-0.014509921,
-0.0132180518,
-0.0108726667,
-0.1160069183,
0.0216648765,
-0.0279985256,
0.0333913341,
0.0425128788,
0.0270497892,
-0.0350937918,
-0.0043147835,
-0.0192063693,
-0.011113951,
0.0538298152,
0.0184561778,
0.0338002816,
0.0524185598,
-0.0199216306,
-0.0368769057,
-0.0052885925,
-0.056831345,
0.0240290444,
0.0368229561,
-0.0229095891,
-0.0902025998,
0.0687137172,
-0.0074370415,
0.0184528325,
-0.0055355811,
-0.0248171147,
0.0253787432,
-0.0339213125,
0.0585712045,
0.0715802014,
0.0143561568,
0.0228826273,
0.0307489131,
-0.0174513608,
-0.0498149469,
0.0045984993,
-0.0093322368,
-0.0385581553,
-0.0036597769,
-0.0635392815,
0.0267768651,
0.0480430685,
0.0169574358,
-0.0159568731,
-0.0239112228,
-0.0206368603,
-0.0262031183,
-0.021459233,
-0.0256161224,
-0.0479585864,
-0.0244549159,
0.0395603031,
0.0084048696,
-0.0203350224,
0.0797582939,
-0.0030026408,
0.0020886445,
-0.0430665798,
-0.0665231794,
-0.042670697,
0.0823593736,
-0.001506093,
0.0373107195,
0.0292298067,
-0.0537342913,
0.0111965081,
-0.0287873186,
0.0148075549,
0.0028436356,
0.0185756348,
-0.0373305492,
0.025395941,
-0.0125512257,
-0.018717641,
-0.0224399325,
-0.0974870771,
-0.0381312668,
0.0195693281,
-0.0256932378,
0.0078282906,
-0.0463153161,
0.0261455216,
0.0284018703,
0.0340375341,
0.0183131266,
-0.0238447599,
-0.0121644158,
-0.0111410907,
0.0199611653,
0.0040716329,
0.0476942509,
-0.0113138435,
0.0862112716,
0.0360398442,
0.0492042378,
0.0164311267,
-0.0104892626,
-0.0261829644,
-0.015337781,
-0.0326906219,
0.0022490588,
0.0273082964,
0.0613907538,
-0.0502987914,
-0.0288081206,
0.1261951476,
0.0313198417,
-0.0064220089,
-0.0062534139,
-0.0337915644,
-0.0022997207,
0.0379165374,
0.0309465956,
-0.0720797256,
-0.0232701488,
-0.0068635275,
0.0361958556,
-0.0303369798,
-0.0358506702,
-0.0012222432,
-0.1158221215,
0.0239377543,
-0.0241391025,
-0.0485056043,
-0.0492843054,
-0.1021826342,
-0.0089601753,
-0.0318655334,
0.0246058758,
-0.0102866385,
-0.0208311882,
-0.0296445154,
0.0437521823,
-0.0879065916,
-0.0476984382,
0.0778621733,
-0.0502499081,
0.0648578852,
0.0530722924,
-0.0214200933,
-0.0264051557,
0.0418766886,
0.0626370087,
-0.0046134996,
0.0147161111,
-0.0009436168,
0.0102966977,
0.031171618,
-0.0064927759,
-0.0094221774,
-0.0011454913,
-0.0209175423,
0.0117021753,
0.0275092758,
0.079305537,
-0.0200521592,
-0.0052366517,
-0.007776041,
0.0205743462,
-0.0017391858,
0.0839525536,
0.0143675897,
-0.0566486903,
-0.0568053126,
-0.0097546261,
-0.0313935392,
-0.014643047,
-0.0007696037,
0.0530175753,
-0.0044781179,
-0.0492222235,
-0.0403547511,
-0.0807373524,
0.0069701541,
0.0078159347,
-0.0068458198,
-0.0128880469,
-0.0061915549,
0.0224311501,
-0.019976994,
0.0001906866,
-0.0275499895,
0.0472775027,
-0.0761508793,
0.093879573,
0.0198398959,
0.0159167852,
-0.0239535999,
0.0240582693,
-0.0352459811,
-0.0510028787,
0.0047735898,
0.0151722627,
0.0214073844,
0.0154824322,
-0.0402993523,
-0.0283143576,
-0.0335887074,
0.0425541736,
0.0009502438,
-0.0108547276,
0.0001880289,
0.00665808,
0.0025031585,
0.0106545724,
-0.0566257276,
0.0301793627,
-0.023678951,
0.0027342096,
-0.0570614114,
-0.0581796505,
0.0199216064,
0.0609110855,
-0.0151364207,
0.0174939558,
-0.0425878763,
-0.0034178065,
0.0003289225,
-0.0363466814,
-0.0331064649,
-0.0056782793,
0.0357161798,
0.021959085,
-0.0188943427,
0.0252903327,
0.0527034886,
-0.0600453243,
-0.0109153138,
-0.0475083552,
0.0001448739,
0.0153473159,
0.047814399,
0.0002740134,
0.0012095603,
-0.0291184504,
-0.0248513054,
0.0472023003,
0.0612293892,
0.0041356273,
0.0614188202,
-0.0057595684,
0.0093869027,
0.0044425493,
0.0284060221,
-0.1023742482,
-0.0178036299,
-0.0057598059,
-0.0528585017,
0.0777978152,
0.0021983273,
0.0297567323,
-0.0098842438,
0.0390125401,
-0.0302378573,
0.0005601433,
0.0480420068,
-0.0027981673,
0.0228826143,
0.0410496816,
-0.0361955687,
0.0104194479,
0.0536847822,
0.0347485133,
0.0490045995,
0.0050002439,
-0.0225877725,
-0.0386794135,
-0.0118943918,
0.0388445035,
0.0125829419,
-0.0353476629,
-0.0128553752,
-0.0743001923,
-0.0046574809,
0.0187498908,
0.0365725718,
0.0024340216,
0.0064451071,
0.0195542462,
0.081404902,
0.0376961119,
0.0278105699,
-0.0245274678,
-0.0041000093,
-0.0012865722,
-0.0024704114,
0.01567032,
-6.224850906e-33,
-0.0163384471,
-0.0389577784,
0.0110776909,
-0.0105958832,
0.0087929945,
0.0292624142,
-0.051010821,
0.0056203394,
-0.0384802409,
-0.0041379114,
-0.0008578463,
0.0147795565,
0.0165752098,
-0.0139455525,
0.0086535467,
-0.017617194,
0.0224200375,
0.0385759287,
-0.0066934964,
0.0203492865,
0.0723387152,
-0.0058809975,
0.0309885554,
-0.0767902434,
0.0593078211,
0.0170718059,
-0.0210684482,
0.051359091,
0.0054300968,
0.0524592325,
-0.0063505042,
0.0461649187,
0.0334714539,
-0.040863324,
-0.0264065787,
0.0127067976,
-0.0220917575,
-0.0165925343,
0.0277147014,
0.0050832066,
0.0269665662,
-0.0162468702,
0.0198838133,
-0.0273168162,
-0.0006270672,
0.0113655422,
0.0438913554,
-0.0054992181,
0.006548157,
-0.040973451,
-0.0639799312,
0.0222456381,
-0.0447207876,
-0.013832245,
-0.0066923895,
0.072395809,
0.0128068859,
-0.0149030294,
-0.0318574607,
0.006975966,
-0.0151679572,
-0.0055989581,
0.029632723,
0.0075264177,
-0.0316912271,
0.0434609279,
0.0054668719,
-0.002825479,
-0.030810304,
-0.0032337406,
-0.0168860927,
0.0343749113,
0.0430277102,
0.0620033257,
0.0131482631,
0.0180251244,
-0.1077880785,
0.0670703277,
0.0339279175,
0.044804398,
0.0676105246,
0.0002431747,
-0.0820261464,
-0.0030736318,
-0.018788537,
0.0263871737,
-0.0453166924,
0.0215967875,
0.0346525274,
0.0120066805,
-0.0354655497,
-0.017396098,
0.0548946299,
-0.0528265983,
0.000644908,
0.0267773978,
0.0074624359,
0.0127382101,
-0.0049714721,
0.0350255072,
-0.038402807,
0.010520407,
0.024299752,
0.0361099094,
0.0229692794,
-0.0071704765,
0.0129221436,
0.0182177387,
-0.0487792008,
0.0174679756,
-0.0284055192,
0.0246319231,
-0.0562215932,
-0.0118708583,
0.0381843932,
0.0098849311,
0.0022921911,
0.0626899078,
0.0215812568,
-0.0527805947,
-0.009779118,
-0.0004849788,
0.0008374478,
0.0085022096,
-0.0226764455,
0.0100802854,
-0.0264212303,
0.0282060225,
0.0354635194,
-0.0024212804,
0.0006660981,
0.0020185357,
2.85e-7,
0.0424741171,
0.01897493,
0.0452745706,
-0.0064105229,
0.0327616856,
0.0410544388,
0.0051258067,
-0.0047785398,
0.0043368964,
0.0026511443,
0.0112244776,
0.0177243706,
0.0435421281,
0.0342925042,
-0.037178643,
-0.032300014,
-0.0511974879,
-0.0256421994,
-0.0679610223,
0.0452802591,
0.1083932966,
0.0834668949,
-0.0085614324,
-0.0078081493,
-0.0019545334,
-0.0985691622,
-0.0176390838,
-0.0026989826,
-0.0153571842,
0.0298437439,
0.0443187542,
0.067628473,
0.0351836793,
-0.0026889415,
0.0192158166,
-0.0079920413,
-0.0221568737,
0.0623125806,
-0.0083927857,
-0.0067610568,
-0.0178428479,
-0.0539000034,
0.0222462825,
-0.08092729,
0.0786085129,
-0.0278692376,
-0.027474165,
-0.026839653,
-0.0034381622,
-0.0123974271,
0.0046632737,
-0.0136245079,
-0.0407420993,
0.0230543278,
-0.0032245296,
-0.0312050078,
0.0016410212,
-0.0581284948,
-0.0519053973,
0.0174552966,
-0.0107202744,
-0.0123064416,
-0.0040194662,
0.0375170559,
0.0327313282,
-0.0344988443,
0.0210880432,
2.799244876e-34,
0.0421738736,
0.0149476193,
0.0088361353,
-0.0129418932,
0.0479021966,
0.0314554684,
-0.0686501339,
0.0204500034,
0.0072859591,
-0.0622043423,
-0.0098026376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01892v1 | GRASP: A Grid-Based Benchmark for Evaluating Commonsense Spatial Reasoning | 2024-07-02T02:27:46 | 2024-07-02T02:27:46 | Zhisheng Tang, Mayank Kejriwal | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Spatial reasoning, an important faculty of human cognition with many
practical applications, is one of the core commonsense skills that is not
purely language-based and, for satisfying (as opposed to optimal) solutions,
requires some minimum degree of planning. Existing benchmarks of Commonsense
Spatial Reasoning (CSR) tend to evaluate how Large Language Models (LLMs)
interpret text-based spatial descriptions rather than directly evaluate a plan
produced by the LLM in response to a spatial reasoning scenario. In this paper,
we construct a large-scale benchmark called $\textbf{GRASP}$, which consists of
16,000 grid-based environments where the agent is tasked with an energy
collection problem. These environments include 100 grid instances instantiated
using each of the 160 different grid settings, involving five different energy
distributions, two modes of agent starting position, and two distinct obstacle
configurations, as well as three kinds of agent constraints. Using GRASP, we
compare classic baseline approaches, such as random walk and greedy search
methods, with advanced LLMs like GPT-3.5-Turbo and GPT-4o. The experimental
results indicate that even these advanced LLMs struggle to consistently achieve
satisfactory solutions. | [
0.0559374318,
0.0298450161,
-0.0039246012,
0.0307105351,
-0.0534627698,
-0.0078474022,
-0.0135781486,
-0.0089689558,
0.064589031,
-0.0007486562,
-0.0029217806,
0.0114600444,
0.0280184392,
-0.0292919893,
0.0121481009,
-0.0519192964,
0.0221699383,
-0.0393278152,
-0.0379963815,
-0.0070393435,
-0.0346740372,
-0.0161419231,
-0.0276440028,
0.028374983,
-0.0232699551,
-0.0022802115,
-0.0176501181,
-0.0397221483,
0.0418957323,
-0.0565111451,
-0.0330510624,
-0.0052749333,
0.0501292609,
0.0483743623,
0.0000021259,
-0.0121674221,
-0.0331146419,
0.0031821218,
0.0498986989,
-0.0089601269,
0.0211550314,
-0.0388475731,
0.0114797698,
-0.0114980284,
-0.0352298543,
0.0294464435,
0.0472026169,
0.0114299674,
0.0349566378,
0.0370840579,
-0.0006103601,
-0.0396902561,
-0.005479353,
0.0004895104,
0.0419813804,
-0.0624231733,
0.0043361797,
0.0306324046,
0.0613795258,
0.0145989638,
-0.0238804929,
0.0072579891,
0.0336398669,
0.022799097,
-0.0419252105,
0.0595927462,
-0.0439417437,
0.0635974482,
-0.0165450256,
0.0549216308,
0.009478542,
-0.0163243581,
0.018877482,
-0.0121162869,
-0.0106423423,
0.0515737422,
-0.0651501343,
0.014332124,
-0.015986219,
0.0176419411,
-0.0567312762,
0.0018995235,
0.0132488403,
0.0243750997,
-0.0207057782,
0.1439935267,
-0.0107688215,
-0.0059266938,
-0.0124818841,
-0.0028128414,
-0.0230994169,
-0.0521493107,
0.00707751,
0.048331596,
-0.0361329205,
0.0230849795,
0.030329898,
0.0498661585,
0.006563745,
-0.0377710275,
0.0437335372,
0.0259962231,
0.0377274714,
0.0307712667,
0.0040459177,
0.0619423762,
-0.0491711535,
0.0415989198,
-0.0240987577,
0.0276607089,
-0.0634635761,
-0.0030544151,
-0.0508519225,
0.0314942412,
-0.0502952747,
-0.0382885076,
0.0383644924,
0.0214439873,
-0.019526476,
0.0083542941,
-0.025702944,
0.0367946699,
0.01547278,
-0.0284751561,
-0.0328655541,
-0.0124650523,
-0.058760386,
0.0204595737,
-0.0140461819,
0.0185247958,
-0.014688204,
-0.0113379229,
-0.001341464,
-0.0474019796,
-0.0247907173,
0.0342145935,
0.0236206539,
-0.0223961752,
-0.0433426835,
-0.0281338636,
-0.0162081998,
-0.0405352004,
0.0140944235,
-0.0919219777,
-0.0027390935,
-0.007108151,
-0.0235945117,
0.0029434925,
0.0032141767,
-0.0052033374,
-0.0226487666,
0.0368785821,
0.02775383,
0.0086377701,
0.0486282371,
0.0303494092,
0.0219510905,
0.0664276481,
0.0342606269,
0.0789228529,
-0.0102599505,
0.0323372707,
0.0285061318,
0.0239289105,
-0.0069262143,
0.0124926707,
0.0158671383,
0.013195686,
-0.0231805928,
0.0720659941,
0.0083892783,
0.0282234903,
-0.0306502376,
0.0036933015,
0.0130329793,
0.1450427175,
-0.048733633,
-0.0384533629,
0.0069351094,
0.042985376,
-0.0303696133,
-0.035619501,
-0.0249667782,
0.0079871705,
-0.0116847754,
-0.0165541284,
-0.0141442018,
0.0190471988,
0.005598281,
0.0008355255,
-0.0433503687,
0.0376225896,
0.0086871879,
-0.0200543702,
0.0213250462,
-0.0222190432,
-0.0342012346,
0.0369334258,
0.0122762434,
-0.0087653063,
-0.0334972702,
-0.0268442873,
-0.0029469046,
-0.010293507,
0.0278223213,
-0.0032196103,
-0.043622531,
0.0192080215,
0.0096111158,
0.0260266606,
0.0481984764,
-0.0038194552,
-0.0308040343,
-0.0231526326,
-0.0409736186,
0.0125582311,
0.0140644088,
0.0530118346,
0.043734543,
0.0284935683,
-0.0013215704,
-0.0565973558,
0.0110565722,
0.0145302117,
0.0418114103,
0.0024188235,
-0.0649142116,
0.0035747339,
0.0197815299,
-0.022799585,
-0.009391333,
-0.0008927665,
0.0137049537,
0.0045363177,
-0.0195108186,
0.0249937978,
-0.0233525671,
-0.0412856191,
0.0153585179,
-0.0102143008,
-0.0369226374,
0.0258219913,
-0.0329286493,
-0.0008075932,
0.0137438644,
-0.0493025705,
0.0402043834,
-0.0046255547,
-0.0087443693,
-0.018500505,
-0.0435330756,
-0.0028380048,
0.109339036,
-0.0256425366,
0.0188339017,
-0.0242029186,
0.0307128895,
0.0417876951,
-0.048112601,
0.0314967521,
-0.0210680496,
0.0057540461,
0.0122873774,
0.001538014,
0.0388530195,
-0.0271548722,
-0.0310000256,
-0.0670109689,
-0.0056082974,
0.0019788826,
0.0188801195,
-0.0204858892,
-0.0551150478,
-0.0089469468,
0.0153805222,
0.0061789253,
0.0268959701,
-0.0145358583,
0.0194693133,
0.0016234973,
-0.0029566588,
-0.02650607,
-0.0046174913,
0.0154548455,
-0.0330686644,
0.0043174913,
0.0422022119,
0.0411962643,
0.0310868081,
0.0150681669,
-0.0138770565,
0.0098928437,
-0.0078972895,
-0.0212184936,
0.0442254022,
-0.048725985,
-0.0290994328,
0.0471041724,
-0.0339426771,
0.0172289014,
0.039948687,
-0.0605834052,
-0.0755806342,
0.0362324938,
-0.0145427035,
0.0010732479,
-0.0283164829,
-0.0285884365,
0.0000865875,
0.0330012217,
0.0072615994,
-0.0064071086,
-0.0428365804,
0.0108735086,
-0.0277401339,
-0.0160307959,
-0.0495270453,
0.056936115,
-0.0172074996,
0.0508247167,
-0.0470844209,
-0.0197141301,
0.0199021939,
-0.0611986034,
0.0289447028,
-0.0465063602,
0.0333035365,
-0.0332660526,
0.1033136696,
0.0350637026,
0.0076776124,
-0.0759349614,
0.0078216083,
0.0109164156,
-0.0683630928,
-0.0006187719,
0.0369391441,
0.0103500485,
-0.0889013931,
0.0359094478,
0.0069361459,
-0.0626998618,
-0.0170138404,
-0.0218665693,
-0.0303509347,
-0.0040200423,
0.0026558312,
-0.0743305087,
-0.0010824881,
0.0290586762,
0.0484609529,
0.0580618456,
-0.0271793045,
-0.0232487228,
-0.0280160345,
0.0231061485,
0.0478557758,
0.0844608024,
-0.0106289918,
0.0206544455,
-0.0557529218,
0.0513789058,
0.0126072792,
-0.015206486,
0.002091167,
0.0648632497,
0.0127938846,
0.0070588016,
-0.0004816862,
0.0338626504,
0.089575775,
-0.055388175,
-0.0785308108,
0.0348631293,
0.0580812395,
0.0356546007,
0.0047635967,
-0.0600354858,
0.0098421006,
0.0089808041,
0.010257937,
0.0166101437,
-0.0238091182,
0.0239126887,
-0.0137261702,
-0.0109181199,
-0.053718809,
0.0366711579,
-0.1175554097,
0.0733283907,
0.0039430852,
-0.1137613654,
-0.0171611626,
-0.0590369776,
-0.0245731343,
0.0147028286,
-0.0521294735,
-0.0155517301,
0.024131,
0.0106315315,
0.0053057498,
0.0058550471,
-0.0066285501,
0.011061593,
-0.0542304479,
0.0495937578,
0.0588614121,
0.0598038584,
-0.0111615891,
-0.0948392376,
-0.0123325046,
0.0358778574,
0.035070274,
-0.0234665796,
-0.0528385043,
0.0211052727,
0.0317377374,
-0.0004763991,
0.0180734415,
-0.0737583339,
-0.0615918152,
0.0297404714,
0.0867973566,
-0.0298429579,
0.0208626222,
-0.0523087606,
0.0097919842,
0.0177777018,
0.0639140233,
0.0185330156,
0.0550787896,
-0.0888614506,
-0.058221411,
-0.0481909066,
-0.054037381,
-0.033192236,
0.0101683717,
0.0239357315,
0.0022404897,
-0.045603998,
-0.0294083972,
0.0222487655,
0.0659659654,
-0.0121683283,
-0.0212529358,
-0.0036145987,
0.0075909379,
-0.0243688002,
0.0495590903,
-0.0068892464,
0.0194418319,
0.0056200386,
0.0266513992,
0.0111835217,
-0.0353926159,
-0.0381255597,
0.049236469,
-0.0376580618,
-0.0406295694,
-0.0145205632,
0.0453732237,
0.0247890558,
-0.0076617408,
-0.0208321586,
0.0381871127,
0.0119690811,
0.0341261886,
-0.024985306,
0.0427689664,
-0.0027095545,
0.0330403596,
0.0303572379,
0.0138298944,
-0.0005477453,
0.0116452789,
0.0059855385,
0.0499533974,
-0.0766538978,
0.0091541074,
-0.0160810277,
-0.0024868103,
0.0302556437,
0.0266333744,
-0.0195237044,
-0.0116712525,
-0.0270882081,
-0.03210954,
-0.0116345389,
-0.026345063,
0.0028315573,
0.0445366167,
-0.0029874318,
-0.0048246742,
0.0819137096,
0.0097213807,
0.0331653915,
0.0375873186,
-0.0233664699,
0.0524653755,
0.0089280307,
0.0220318288,
-0.0061216187,
-0.0130162295,
-0.033567518,
-0.0245827474,
0.0631883815,
0.0201473422,
0.0332193486,
0.0614416674,
-0.0381118245,
-0.0371469446,
0.0082331868,
-0.0680914745,
-0.0829409733,
0.0339592025,
0.0691620857,
0.057099048,
-0.0101953587,
-0.0061683399,
-0.0663828105,
-0.003440049,
0.0227117985,
-0.0185405631,
0.0492577031,
-0.0438386872,
0.0315667167,
0.0261396002,
-0.0127798468,
-0.0203201994,
0.0292014815,
-0.0292609539,
0.0581364259,
0.0201955326,
-0.0433692075,
-0.0230075829,
-0.0258648153,
0.004811828,
0.0304015949,
0.0188275073,
0.0060680336,
-0.092908375,
-0.021310512,
-0.0074404189,
0.0673068687,
-0.0198535379,
0.0344733782,
0.0347464718,
0.0251570567,
0.0035888997,
-0.079547368,
0.0002502347,
-0.0081681721,
-0.0549009144,
-0.0092815151,
-0.0354748257,
-6.079964982e-33,
-0.0049497504,
-0.0679698139,
0.0703403354,
-0.0183113962,
-0.0048545371,
-0.0381980911,
-0.0329252332,
-0.0116853742,
-0.0194965657,
-0.003069116,
-0.0100525264,
0.0091504427,
0.0143460603,
0.0193098765,
-0.0059645292,
0.0486673452,
-0.0022139212,
0.0200520586,
-0.0401203409,
-0.0359129272,
0.0340371132,
-0.027838828,
-0.0092687849,
-0.0020183909,
-0.0185490139,
0.0015355546,
0.0100942915,
0.0259132572,
-0.0629860163,
0.0345243067,
-0.0348498598,
-0.0077645583,
0.0245874878,
-0.0196139459,
-0.0030795899,
0.0227343217,
-0.0361018963,
-0.0560467914,
-0.0155366017,
0.0092880707,
-0.0434964113,
-0.0241853129,
-0.01261904,
0.0393755808,
-0.0464640148,
0.0174214076,
0.004572188,
-0.0046325158,
-0.021388622,
0.0481794439,
0.0214772504,
0.0189567059,
0.0009652326,
-0.0365160927,
-0.0144256335,
-0.0586417876,
0.0233548526,
0.0036425618,
-0.046215076,
0.004492389,
0.0465130135,
-0.0020353475,
0.0278050192,
0.0002304461,
0.0298347007,
0.0663979873,
0.007617834,
-0.0313118845,
-0.0436954424,
-0.0328562222,
0.0303310696,
0.0511509255,
-0.025428839,
0.0679770559,
0.0373407789,
0.0268208273,
-0.0420086905,
0.0441679582,
-0.0514296703,
0.0880393088,
0.0210362412,
-0.0078721559,
-0.0313218124,
-0.0015447354,
-0.0337339379,
-0.0004559504,
-0.0071651544,
0.0220663548,
0.012039328,
-0.0050423089,
0.0332290158,
0.0310550723,
0.0037035013,
-0.0074237329,
-0.0177107714,
0.045569554,
-0.0093653295,
0.0229429584,
0.0065716379,
0.0522076972,
-0.0433375649,
-0.0349134803,
-0.0239463355,
0.0157830063,
-0.004516596,
0.0248350669,
-0.0235769432,
0.0250132326,
0.0134590361,
-0.0202645045,
-0.0384977311,
-0.0124808364,
-0.0134576401,
-0.0303772334,
0.0461928807,
-0.0117761623,
0.0152362073,
0.0548834391,
-0.0182007477,
-0.0425309278,
0.0255817864,
0.0495810062,
-0.0317023918,
0.0134554822,
0.0151450038,
0.0254430342,
-0.0408265926,
-0.0216510855,
0.0005499923,
-0.0469798446,
0.0035741865,
0.0649635494,
2.838e-7,
0.0020438265,
0.0285693407,
0.0170939248,
-0.0048282193,
0.0005011057,
0.0376107693,
-0.0322398283,
0.0008257193,
-0.0620306842,
-0.0035595347,
0.0235857442,
0.0629897267,
0.0371544473,
0.0400682315,
-0.0812641829,
0.0582311749,
0.0002253695,
-0.0358288214,
-0.0691738799,
-0.0208137091,
0.0610924587,
0.0117148459,
0.0236530285,
0.0012754621,
0.015738152,
-0.0780991316,
0.0126211727,
-0.0498334281,
0.0661171302,
0.0204402432,
-0.0099740438,
-0.0329876207,
-0.0124544231,
-0.0152652059,
0.0250282213,
-0.0200867988,
-0.0211910773,
0.0658371374,
-0.0001673996,
-0.0702276155,
-0.0167175252,
-0.0703163669,
-0.0199054815,
-0.0718873739,
0.0474799983,
-0.0896296948,
0.0015165356,
0.0894893333,
0.0383345895,
-0.0063344291,
-0.0280685816,
0.0179301575,
0.0023422525,
-0.0630487055,
0.0068449029,
-0.0191390179,
-0.0211911798,
-0.0504679419,
0.0259348061,
0.0374221951,
-0.028611457,
-0.0405262038,
-0.0370867848,
0.002599508,
0.0094772317,
-0.0359841511,
-0.0520403497,
2.308228258e-34,
-0.0169245545,
-0.0088130422,
-0.0152254635,
-0.0305625815,
0.026390221,
0.0276761707,
-0.0141293211,
0.0250556916,
0.0115777245,
-0.0461212248,
0.0027786922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01887v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01887v1 | Beyond Numeric Awards: In-Context Dueling Bandits with LLM Agents | 2024-07-02T02:18:14 | 2024-07-02T02:18:14 | Fanzeng Xia, Hao Liu, Yisong Yue, Tongxin Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In-context decision-making is an important capability of artificial general
intelligence, which Large Language Models (LLMs) have effectively demonstrated
in various scenarios. However, LLMs often face challenges when dealing with
numerical contexts, and limited attention has been paid to evaluating their
performance through preference feedback generated by the environment. This
paper investigates the performance of LLMs as decision-makers in the context of
Dueling Bandits (DB). We first evaluate the performance of LLMs by comparing
GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT-4, and GPT-4-Turbo against established DB algorithms. Our
results reveal that LLMs, particularly GPT-4 Turbo, quickly identify the
Condorcet winner, thus outperforming existing state-of-the-art algorithms in
terms of weak regret. Nevertheless, LLMs struggle to converge even when
explicitly prompted to do so, and are sensitive to prompt variations. To
overcome these issues, we introduce an LLM-augmented algorithm, IF-Enhanced
LLM, which takes advantage of both in-context decision-making capabilities of
LLMs and theoretical guarantees inherited from classic DB algorithms. The
design of such an algorithm sheds light on how to enhance trustworthiness for
LLMs used in decision-making tasks where performance robustness matters. We
show that IF-Enhanced LLM has theoretical guarantees on both weak and strong
regret. Our experimental results validate that IF-Enhanced LLM is robust even
with noisy and adversarial prompts. | [
0.0365591869,
0.0600023195,
0.0018728016,
0.0418716706,
-0.067003116,
0.009842325,
-0.027895961,
0.0127221169,
0.0357889906,
-0.0258210655,
-0.0484822765,
-0.0449298285,
-0.021958312,
-0.0075206188,
0.021088345,
0.0033905762,
0.035782259,
-0.0706925392,
0.0532721654,
-0.0407511406,
-0.0030308641,
-0.0222728997,
0.0059276759,
0.0168161783,
0.027999796,
0.0242066439,
0.0060662627,
-0.0163595546,
0.0194702875,
-0.0650635213,
0.0044513661,
0.0271533486,
0.0223683994,
0.0829186663,
0.000002428,
-0.0551219434,
-0.0489506684,
-0.0383943617,
-0.0624878481,
0.0307153445,
0.0311202127,
0.0323442295,
0.0236444399,
0.0262004882,
-0.0612942725,
0.0021423097,
0.0140389232,
0.0364005566,
0.0319235064,
0.044974383,
0.016942624,
0.0042873002,
0.0343536362,
-0.0610299259,
-0.005609869,
-0.0936285034,
0.0042603891,
-0.0711597055,
-0.0233126599,
0.0091158366,
0.016573552,
-0.0048003388,
0.0031468212,
0.0222414955,
-0.0139128445,
0.0277165771,
-0.0579125062,
0.0195597578,
-0.0414556526,
0.0168093052,
-0.003785254,
-0.0146007715,
-0.0091972621,
-0.0298625939,
0.0220447909,
-0.0441151112,
-0.0237299819,
0.0299580116,
-0.019779969,
0.035882514,
0.032329414,
0.0541717932,
0.0506240763,
0.0336943492,
-0.028997492,
0.0786116868,
-0.0134523623,
-0.0496470146,
0.0477548428,
0.0311739817,
-0.0606049635,
-0.0515371822,
-0.004785466,
0.0184048545,
-0.0780344158,
0.0154971462,
-0.0130407168,
0.0419258103,
-0.000599799,
-0.0177762695,
0.052340962,
0.0107601108,
-0.0095581431,
0.0322802067,
-0.0230975263,
0.066872105,
-0.0044330442,
0.0035796766,
0.0199353024,
0.0005757635,
0.036686074,
-0.0172647256,
-0.0119186612,
0.0572649725,
-0.0038953512,
0.0129332673,
-0.0687145963,
0.0174408723,
-0.0528382622,
0.0719121173,
-0.0040979884,
0.016447382,
-0.0059289979,
-0.0221589096,
-0.0774224848,
-0.0600606091,
-0.0183368288,
0.0052772472,
0.0238853116,
-0.0364142209,
-0.0127557516,
0.0016972568,
-0.049835667,
-0.0655566007,
0.0209752414,
0.1271862984,
-0.0021822776,
-0.0506734811,
-0.0492051616,
-0.0056583937,
0.0015809885,
-0.053431306,
-0.0320274234,
-0.0459088534,
0.0193778276,
-0.0257343724,
-0.0152563974,
-0.0040045492,
0.0164883528,
-0.0172137097,
-0.0226618834,
0.079499349,
0.0344647653,
-0.0164018925,
0.0083502643,
-0.0073136818,
-0.037859235,
0.0156460721,
0.0289274659,
0.0600496382,
0.0508506782,
0.0323422328,
0.0322091356,
0.0252359509,
0.0114404373,
0.008704151,
-0.0037508388,
0.0089108618,
0.0110565694,
0.0319171846,
0.0115513504,
0.0615796596,
-0.0678784773,
-0.0469922684,
0.1157953143,
0.0267710071,
0.0382037684,
0.0136746131,
-0.0007143595,
0.0010624405,
-0.0077532381,
0.0109859342,
-0.0617673919,
0.0199059471,
-0.0756480321,
-0.0037398424,
0.0252636801,
0.0066226311,
0.0100519247,
-0.0292687248,
-0.0037070299,
0.0055392291,
0.025913747,
0.0549515188,
0.0110615315,
-0.0526301265,
-0.0656855032,
-0.0746132135,
0.0149450749,
0.0269446988,
-0.055994194,
-0.0606257468,
0.0174772236,
0.0548279956,
0.0582656264,
0.00164634,
0.0334508121,
-0.0303557161,
-0.0678781942,
0.0192526318,
0.0585896596,
-0.0068381783,
0.0232772324,
-0.0535524637,
-0.0116292741,
0.0044647199,
0.0147162909,
0.0865900069,
0.0373124331,
0.0242357459,
-0.032066565,
0.0302838087,
0.0342516005,
-0.0016595708,
0.0305268932,
-0.0792350918,
0.0462193191,
-0.0193575751,
0.0464616492,
-0.012560335,
-0.0089967484,
0.0176025126,
-0.0106563643,
0.0293533895,
-0.0372504666,
0.001328535,
-0.0336186774,
-0.0103660896,
0.0240281578,
0.013482064,
0.0087821428,
0.0223986376,
-0.0006527431,
-0.0061549139,
-0.008686929,
-0.0318147242,
0.0421788096,
-0.0537115857,
0.0296325218,
-0.0179032218,
-0.0096275834,
-0.0694327503,
0.0597357117,
-0.0070401412,
-0.0325474106,
-0.0220376179,
0.0079009207,
0.0148476828,
-0.1179245114,
-0.0016499533,
0.01493135,
0.0338266082,
0.0183135755,
0.0295770336,
-0.0031304394,
0.0212550033,
-0.0471882634,
-0.0750690103,
-0.0124269677,
-0.0046135974,
0.0024780962,
-0.0222012848,
-0.0589758791,
-0.0037448425,
-0.0050881584,
-0.0233271308,
0.0085532824,
0.0240465496,
0.0178148746,
0.0313414931,
-0.0025131067,
0.0148504246,
-0.0514087528,
-0.0174873676,
0.0028368223,
0.0170714948,
0.0075686476,
-0.0067907139,
-0.0184814557,
-0.0228980687,
-0.0264613125,
0.0418755449,
-0.0355909355,
0.025875831,
0.0219347663,
-0.0226558726,
-0.0150128817,
0.0493054129,
0.0212442148,
0.0317750573,
0.0563083403,
-0.010965501,
-0.0678727552,
0.0148828728,
0.0034047808,
-0.0320448391,
-0.0349768177,
0.0064818673,
0.037101157,
0.061292734,
0.023038391,
0.0119997961,
-0.0250958279,
0.0172059014,
0.0415779874,
-0.0587277748,
-0.0407225676,
0.0010631093,
-0.0090211984,
0.0531966984,
-0.0010273504,
-0.036695186,
0.1135053188,
-0.0118334731,
0.0136836218,
-0.0025663928,
-0.0242356304,
-0.0298536029,
0.0212126616,
0.0100878691,
-0.0011177149,
-0.0022531997,
-0.00393624,
-0.0403694957,
-0.0386275835,
0.0468624644,
-0.0355179459,
0.0300469063,
-0.031499926,
0.0025543538,
-0.0077682324,
-0.078740932,
-0.0264722891,
-0.0630291402,
-0.0294879265,
-0.0115567548,
0.0542754047,
-0.0267620478,
-0.0451987945,
-0.0098756393,
0.0255878381,
0.036317125,
-0.0114969565,
-0.0162999984,
-0.0053538498,
0.0033488488,
0.0498904511,
0.0058606528,
0.0779390857,
-0.032227654,
0.0108425403,
0.0386929661,
0.0333162658,
-0.0137795452,
-0.013351446,
0.0290518682,
0.0267949477,
-0.0409682617,
-0.0223258082,
0.0195047129,
-0.0142011074,
-0.0238003787,
0.0085384259,
0.0663116202,
0.0077219242,
-0.0401697494,
-0.0029340305,
-0.042312447,
0.0574267693,
0.006015541,
0.0193042681,
-0.0908813402,
-0.0509001091,
-0.0010901624,
0.0514468588,
-0.0378293172,
-0.0717055276,
0.0095456745,
-0.1307298541,
0.030297216,
0.0067689461,
-0.0172193237,
0.0281867553,
-0.012807617,
-0.0281691086,
-0.0766378939,
-0.0015108152,
0.0263450444,
0.016257491,
0.0056051267,
-0.0152075691,
0.0388554446,
0.0391343199,
0.0063326349,
-0.0303931683,
0.0273386855,
0.0840580761,
-0.0059050303,
-0.0047638016,
0.0137957595,
-0.0289151147,
0.001564385,
-0.0188080724,
0.0200506598,
0.0022841343,
-0.0510117374,
0.0099902581,
-0.0243656058,
0.0212994888,
0.0386084542,
-0.0043794131,
0.0557932928,
0.0249892976,
-0.0408877172,
-0.0373624489,
0.0112631796,
-0.0141209057,
0.0239468068,
0.0716914386,
-0.0196244475,
-0.0286338087,
-0.0584162883,
-0.0652718544,
-0.0270303264,
-0.0420094654,
-0.0134919174,
0.0066994559,
0.0387866348,
0.0176680926,
-0.0718409196,
-0.0472252741,
-0.0154483756,
0.0072066141,
-0.008452747,
0.0083532007,
-0.0209091213,
0.0189154223,
-0.0316962339,
-0.0115001593,
-0.0436184108,
0.0243496522,
-0.0555473864,
0.0527777076,
0.0189738888,
-0.0660883039,
-0.0180050563,
0.0494053625,
-0.0460462905,
-0.052996017,
-0.0018717872,
0.0761622265,
0.0294508301,
0.0159775354,
-0.0211361311,
-0.0463278443,
0.0879599899,
0.0053945002,
0.008895739,
0.0460956655,
0.0423279405,
0.0332507305,
-0.0055051805,
0.0262252875,
-0.0295065399,
-0.0161980353,
0.0256200843,
0.0124808615,
-0.0382498838,
0.0024577021,
0.0309677124,
0.0060097096,
0.0199041739,
-0.0225640312,
0.0123833399,
-0.0001438954,
0.0163109079,
0.0142992213,
-0.011145818,
-0.0212736018,
-0.0103817387,
0.0306438226,
-0.0052162069,
0.0018516566,
-0.0564753748,
0.0276344698,
-0.0102667594,
-0.039488256,
-0.035131149,
0.0457078628,
0.0294705424,
0.0034512887,
-0.0036917101,
0.0036780194,
0.0499649011,
0.01876745,
0.0529481247,
0.0171907321,
0.0508140139,
0.0264368914,
-0.0532244109,
0.0154624358,
0.0266480967,
-0.0538222082,
-0.0367467217,
-0.0037947416,
0.0532135144,
0.0456651077,
0.0108937174,
-0.0125258975,
-0.0574175604,
0.0135596795,
-0.0193225686,
-0.0542914979,
-0.0161589459,
-0.0251309965,
0.0223095249,
0.0388828032,
-0.0238129664,
0.0534052812,
0.0669564977,
0.0271660965,
0.0409170687,
-0.0399058647,
-0.016392339,
-0.0323488452,
-0.075496316,
0.0342310332,
0.0699736103,
-0.0292834211,
-0.0030276412,
-0.0524187684,
-0.0049612848,
-0.022614006,
0.0461049527,
0.0323194936,
-0.0688024238,
0.0151629476,
0.026185615,
-0.0129169701,
0.0224101096,
-0.0432350971,
0.0074883965,
-0.0208121985,
-0.0149309887,
-0.0774480626,
-6.817521933e-33,
-0.0038202361,
-0.0274848267,
0.0226812232,
-0.029137617,
0.0131369187,
-0.0215983484,
-0.0025347378,
0.0246076211,
-0.0075699519,
-0.0163589641,
-0.0310946405,
-0.0017814711,
0.0128495982,
-0.0098931603,
0.0081696929,
-0.0302733462,
0.0013763102,
0.0098161958,
-0.0541432686,
-0.0237964001,
0.0096341344,
0.0105278408,
0.0335905105,
-0.0454807095,
0.0167579409,
0.0084198769,
-0.0598439761,
0.0148932198,
-0.0746972114,
0.054786846,
-0.0022339977,
-0.0096546439,
-0.0082032569,
-0.0533430129,
0.0172934718,
-0.0161099602,
0.0036535033,
-0.0134091442,
-0.0001978522,
-0.0096707391,
0.0307489298,
-0.0208688583,
0.0032143211,
-0.0105926637,
-0.0554334931,
0.0099940281,
-0.0270926207,
-0.0207881667,
-0.0316987857,
0.0012376173,
0.0130678266,
0.0238151662,
0.0187287834,
0.0357727334,
0.0348964371,
0.0241400208,
-0.019067701,
0.055687163,
-0.0455780923,
0.0547453091,
0.0428865552,
-0.0113014607,
0.029122984,
-0.0025919031,
-0.0004782113,
0.0475662127,
0.0308383554,
-0.0180626959,
-0.0011240083,
-0.0269236416,
-0.0395957977,
0.0363466628,
0.0880461559,
0.1042533368,
0.0581516735,
0.0278818998,
-0.0427837148,
0.0448834896,
0.058773119,
-0.0116221327,
0.0440631546,
0.0447042249,
-0.0497650057,
-0.0061101262,
-0.0200498477,
-0.04547235,
-0.0505905822,
-0.0193812344,
0.0166516304,
0.0215476416,
0.0182795078,
0.0102967555,
0.025761012,
-0.0210734122,
-0.011204184,
-0.0123506151,
0.0008720188,
0.0272728037,
-0.0077047371,
0.0100571457,
-0.030459106,
-0.0137891369,
-0.0021261622,
-0.0023596219,
0.0252918862,
0.0211546123,
0.0020788135,
0.0160073284,
-0.0109440153,
0.0211206637,
-0.0040053618,
0.0284511689,
0.0090577668,
-0.0402488373,
0.0289213248,
-0.045398701,
0.0057506338,
0.0092943106,
-0.0310691334,
-0.0129939625,
-0.0296782982,
-0.023013521,
-0.01083175,
0.0198556948,
0.0260007195,
0.0167183504,
0.0055307681,
-0.0046114381,
-0.0146874087,
-0.0181309413,
-0.0065067834,
-0.0245157406,
3.139e-7,
-0.0437460169,
0.0432003438,
-0.0023944092,
-0.017078625,
-0.0073343422,
0.1073569581,
-0.0192871373,
0.0280388836,
-0.009173058,
0.0065205838,
0.0423370413,
0.0254689846,
0.043106243,
0.0307980906,
-0.0382762626,
-0.0472532399,
-0.0626604855,
-0.0063375686,
-0.0520158932,
-0.0181976184,
-0.0029305723,
0.067032665,
0.049741026,
-0.0164246056,
0.0395818688,
-0.040091034,
0.0434911363,
-0.0388909578,
-0.0285096299,
-0.0098297624,
0.0448678024,
0.0018767166,
-0.0383548401,
0.0108806947,
0.0167526323,
0.0371828079,
-0.0000853903,
0.0667843372,
0.0215559639,
-0.0735247061,
-0.0168225411,
0.0096046412,
-0.0018751187,
-0.0737877265,
0.0669533089,
0.0009642362,
-0.0345797241,
-0.0252045542,
0.025279792,
-0.0494220257,
0.0221016239,
-0.0456465669,
-0.0193068217,
-0.0353279337,
-0.0116790729,
0.0511804298,
0.0102522429,
-0.0659545884,
-0.0068122991,
0.0380960889,
-0.0092444383,
-0.0315077715,
-0.0385503434,
0.088636376,
0.0158687029,
-0.0832728222,
0.0005517936,
2.963979389e-34,
0.0287851654,
-0.0082572959,
-0.0040931753,
0.0116322665,
0.0713365525,
0.05476382,
-0.0309961736,
0.0352111161,
0.0528887399,
-0.0160013251,
-0.0262538977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01885v1 | Survey on Knowledge Distillation for Large Language Models: Methods, Evaluation, and Application | 2024-07-02T02:14:42 | 2024-07-02T02:14:42 | Chuanpeng Yang, Wang Lu, Yao Zhu, Yidong Wang, Qian Chen, Chenlong Gao, Bingjie Yan, Yiqiang Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased exceptional capabilities in
various domains, attracting significant interest from both academia and
industry. Despite their impressive performance, the substantial size and
computational demands of LLMs pose considerable challenges for practical
deployment, particularly in environments with limited resources. The endeavor
to compress language models while maintaining their accuracy has become a focal
point of research. Among the various methods, knowledge distillation has
emerged as an effective technique to enhance inference speed without greatly
compromising performance. This paper presents a thorough survey from three
aspects: method, evaluation, and application, exploring knowledge distillation
techniques tailored specifically for LLMs. Specifically, we divide the methods
into white-box KD and black-box KD to better illustrate their differences.
Furthermore, we also explored the evaluation tasks and distillation effects
between different distillation methods, and proposed directions for future
research. Through in-depth understanding of the latest advancements and
practical applications, this survey provides valuable resources for
researchers, paving the way for sustained progress in this field. | [
0.0059898244,
0.0860266685,
-0.0261540934,
0.065539673,
-0.0641787574,
0.0199152045,
-0.0127921784,
0.0374399088,
-0.0180339236,
0.0032139281,
0.0002352245,
-0.0358861424,
0.022739429,
0.0069933254,
0.0140311057,
-0.0129690468,
0.0210626423,
-0.0681547672,
-0.0016568764,
-0.0233206432,
-0.0030074895,
0.0154201351,
0.0255060494,
0.0048783976,
0.0149713084,
-0.0192446858,
0.0025917378,
-0.0100017907,
-0.0001360803,
0.0360498019,
-0.0176372733,
0.0369116887,
0.0176755171,
0.0343710482,
0.0000021129,
-0.0208086148,
-0.0055469587,
-0.0071889893,
-0.0546067208,
0.0647086054,
0.0322454572,
-0.0451868214,
0.0312789194,
0.0033065414,
-0.0176334046,
-0.03067182,
0.0383136757,
-0.0015670817,
0.0330291986,
0.0459725708,
0.0040758466,
-0.0381852984,
-0.0141443172,
-0.023859445,
-0.0486237705,
-0.0258519612,
0.0618809946,
0.0245235544,
-0.0132669583,
-0.0158868413,
-0.0265944358,
0.059929613,
0.0062523768,
0.0168800056,
-0.043685589,
0.0216600299,
-0.0498977639,
-0.0084083136,
0.0092811482,
0.0606491268,
-0.0188001487,
-0.0128039178,
0.0229963344,
0.0154347327,
-0.0221585948,
0.0150509058,
-0.0306808464,
0.0018884955,
-0.0062981998,
0.0407892056,
0.0033048945,
-0.0022332354,
0.0433627442,
-0.0088882931,
-0.0704818815,
0.0633439124,
0.0289429724,
-0.0232438277,
-0.0069740009,
-0.0264949407,
-0.0431935303,
-0.0689038411,
0.0065464708,
0.0050023799,
0.0587513745,
0.0211378466,
-0.0335278772,
-0.0150673753,
0.0063347286,
-0.0353115015,
0.0293180533,
0.0299344733,
0.0073674321,
0.037182793,
-0.0194033831,
0.0714665875,
-0.0024507677,
-0.0112439636,
-0.0516965128,
-0.0205730051,
-0.0431438647,
0.0026450499,
-0.0109977098,
0.0464059077,
-0.0295649618,
-0.0083436342,
-0.0039637778,
-0.0072221318,
-0.0156963039,
-0.0282603055,
0.0235815141,
-0.0203260537,
0.0192664266,
-0.024362402,
-0.0137305669,
0.0716694146,
-0.0205476712,
-0.0062778476,
-0.0427696407,
-0.0482129976,
-0.0167423859,
0.0097972667,
0.0108401012,
-0.0218930598,
0.00202614,
0.0392099544,
0.0267598741,
-0.0388960876,
-0.0079015885,
-0.0143225072,
-0.0544683784,
-0.0931329653,
0.0008401856,
-0.0843720511,
0.0660422444,
0.0012241312,
0.0005905487,
-0.0795908794,
-0.0014805421,
-0.0424718522,
-0.0487802811,
0.0529610775,
-0.0144024175,
0.0434252061,
-0.0034843627,
0.0095437588,
-0.0059024463,
0.0986908376,
-0.0035771646,
0.0253203753,
0.0007220939,
-0.0144435167,
-0.0271799173,
0.0555956699,
0.0355299711,
0.0344729498,
-0.0360876285,
-0.0181286503,
-0.0093196034,
-0.0294637289,
0.0401729085,
0.0756146833,
-0.0506099612,
0.0069237845,
0.0544178225,
0.0106863854,
0.0251880921,
0.0080104321,
0.0238836799,
0.0146100521,
0.0207301509,
0.0318895951,
-0.009185615,
-0.0310545564,
-0.0164159965,
0.0009477431,
0.0520957932,
0.0909954384,
-0.032056991,
-0.0346926823,
-0.0098394463,
-0.0157557279,
0.0254489742,
0.0401116274,
0.0789780468,
-0.0123535106,
0.0155232558,
0.0924082696,
0.0783927515,
-0.0353516303,
0.0055444469,
-0.0447884426,
-0.0005334535,
0.0555997491,
0.0341605172,
-0.0250373315,
-0.0054293126,
0.0366526581,
-0.0016658523,
0.0024741548,
-0.0108381193,
-0.0120386165,
0.0330789201,
-0.0503966324,
-0.0366762914,
0.0151433321,
0.0316238403,
0.0139040891,
0.0394369885,
0.0089539578,
0.0460948609,
-0.068985939,
0.0067003798,
0.0091732452,
-0.0344576836,
-0.026634736,
0.0038415743,
0.0090178307,
0.0341562703,
0.0076442221,
-0.0250474159,
-0.0179956425,
0.0268414654,
-0.0528236516,
-0.0025262744,
-0.0152479038,
0.0032486836,
-0.0910104811,
0.0494370274,
0.0020000117,
0.0353246257,
0.0312203504,
-0.0371610709,
-0.0416257381,
0.0137701714,
0.0053691091,
0.0748823509,
-0.0362365805,
0.0472187363,
-0.0228014197,
0.0205832701,
-0.0004947406,
0.0575692505,
-0.0493831895,
-0.0068701748,
0.0048856093,
-0.0605202392,
-0.0081381118,
0.0122883096,
-0.043946892,
0.0118654175,
-0.0190990493,
0.0124781905,
0.0227106903,
-0.0262354463,
0.0282921363,
-0.0147678647,
-0.0703053176,
0.0081869671,
-0.0327881873,
0.0288603734,
0.006317853,
0.0433063954,
0.0037244705,
0.0018508388,
0.0000765706,
-0.0133013073,
-0.0151994098,
0.0247083288,
-0.0322793685,
0.0005206135,
-0.0261759348,
-0.0044019716,
-0.0377820544,
0.0176579095,
0.0823611319,
-0.0691534132,
-0.0386902131,
-0.0357691534,
0.0571597964,
-0.0648930594,
0.0328537673,
-0.0284634568,
-0.0160869304,
-0.010023565,
-0.0198426098,
0.0425811484,
-0.0001965956,
-0.0306564774,
-0.0080859913,
0.0667818189,
-0.0287605282,
-0.0525324158,
0.0026083454,
-0.0389362462,
0.0032913836,
-0.0203261264,
-0.058202818,
-0.0175714381,
0.0736678466,
0.0015962004,
-0.0285169818,
-0.0578561798,
-0.0390532538,
-0.0196044706,
-0.0330515169,
-0.0504910611,
0.0114878612,
-0.0053627016,
0.0243369229,
-0.0293805115,
-0.0522133298,
0.0515149571,
-0.0545274131,
0.0316277035,
0.0029105528,
-0.0228522923,
-0.013321246,
0.0590552948,
-0.0017884291,
0.0242190138,
0.0066274288,
0.0217021164,
-0.0188253205,
0.0064426716,
-0.0099038575,
-0.0387966149,
0.0752755031,
-0.0626333803,
0.0273603927,
0.0233051796,
-0.0406245403,
-0.0197354518,
-0.0223965477,
-0.0178426411,
0.0180421434,
0.0341191739,
-0.0102821421,
-0.0010404884,
0.0421180017,
-0.0054726442,
0.0328882039,
0.0178806335,
0.0272146631,
-0.035836421,
0.0354132727,
0.0582860112,
-0.0140468581,
0.0349291563,
-0.0258521959,
0.0164024662,
0.0629082546,
0.0402169749,
0.0224304385,
-0.0188804436,
-0.028328551,
0.0340695493,
-0.0041114967,
-0.0220576786,
-0.006405659,
0.0120423101,
-0.0401367433,
0.0144523541,
0.1100230068,
0.0051409015,
-0.0141301304,
0.0044070431,
0.041160237,
0.0410311408,
-0.0093768993,
0.0086692926,
-0.0878551602,
-0.0409618579,
0.0121123604,
-0.0033560107,
0.0229493212,
-0.0327864289,
-0.0080348952,
-0.1068954617,
0.0086482968,
0.0323496088,
-0.0151057672,
-0.0673080385,
-0.0390156321,
0.0129606994,
0.0022017565,
0.0002830411,
0.0166132487,
-0.0083814496,
-0.0166839361,
0.0049520689,
-0.0608411208,
-0.0762126818,
0.0166336615,
-0.0256719049,
0.0274999719,
0.0171709023,
0.0266340431,
0.0245148316,
-0.0158669334,
-0.0418884233,
-0.0142477052,
-0.0188434646,
-0.0134823546,
0.026867358,
0.0093607679,
-0.0059817052,
0.0336394943,
0.0118846959,
-0.0492245667,
-0.0036181037,
0.0028321233,
0.0681212917,
0.0092489636,
-0.0609346926,
0.0120759802,
-0.0246946178,
0.0069692978,
0.0987676531,
0.0401446819,
-0.0212161299,
-0.0331980027,
0.0091814324,
-0.023350358,
0.0032808776,
-0.0021234627,
0.0141014941,
-0.0277082603,
-0.0117713809,
-0.0474256203,
0.0228130091,
0.0376255848,
0.010779242,
-0.0089463424,
0.0472362004,
0.0367000736,
-0.011689363,
-0.0596810952,
-0.0105689382,
-0.047427129,
0.0096912552,
0.012798667,
-0.0098544993,
-0.0170163643,
-0.0065804096,
-0.0254056994,
0.0428221598,
-0.1337506026,
-0.0939654261,
0.0070151645,
0.0261928849,
0.0198022313,
0.0718268007,
-0.0148312701,
-0.0627487749,
0.0738145635,
0.0044809678,
-0.0280975457,
0.0431870855,
0.0028633478,
-0.0148671996,
0.0166800469,
0.0687919632,
-0.0361071862,
0.0105400356,
0.013812568,
0.0265252087,
-0.0645440221,
-0.0302796792,
-0.0182181429,
0.0509595051,
0.0190159064,
-0.0140840532,
-0.0080261277,
-0.0122260731,
0.022686474,
-0.0063062678,
-0.0133169228,
-0.0650795326,
-0.0115581788,
0.028521765,
0.0238333791,
0.0000820517,
0.0115313921,
0.0492750704,
-0.0146127548,
-0.0278196596,
-0.0263379421,
0.0287990142,
0.000705637,
0.0953869075,
-0.0116841551,
0.0196459293,
0.0483850874,
0.0035019107,
0.0277286451,
-0.0479191616,
0.0144846002,
0.0090585398,
0.0109978905,
-0.0457849205,
0.0162279755,
-0.0392282531,
-0.066017732,
-0.0146305934,
0.0400732979,
0.0433228686,
0.0049329507,
0.0599208325,
-0.0387748107,
-0.0161350965,
-0.0311406869,
0.0151989274,
0.0036247766,
0.0298899338,
0.0047774762,
0.0277220719,
-0.0295423418,
0.0402451418,
0.1092256159,
0.0291751288,
0.0574142709,
-0.0152496397,
-0.0101643689,
-0.0204949137,
-0.0439704545,
-0.0140181975,
0.0203219838,
-0.0216097347,
0.0010456046,
-0.0832028687,
-0.0844315514,
-0.0054023713,
-0.0271489918,
-0.0269644931,
-0.0122725517,
0.027533412,
0.0508991331,
0.0166551266,
-0.0204640552,
-0.0398535281,
-0.0224350542,
-0.0373295546,
-0.0196277201,
0.037080422,
-6.767631014e-33,
0.0059783971,
0.0181686524,
-0.0017896579,
-0.0201969668,
-0.0363533534,
0.0161488075,
0.0074807596,
-0.0193049144,
-0.0025233747,
0.0256338399,
0.0013571595,
0.0176805444,
0.0184236709,
0.0261148475,
-0.0304647312,
0.0143815158,
0.0570987314,
0.0075730705,
0.0007842837,
0.0374049395,
0.0435257852,
0.0404544212,
0.0351498835,
-0.0382558592,
-0.0107919155,
-0.0171659961,
0.0218031909,
0.0192166865,
0.0043413374,
0.0228529964,
-0.0491115116,
0.0521458536,
0.0125360796,
-0.0340664238,
-0.0361904651,
-0.0101457741,
-0.0725962445,
0.0011799574,
0.0587100908,
-0.02555402,
-0.0028894269,
-0.0148043633,
0.0541853979,
0.0122517627,
0.0503040515,
-0.0149205904,
-0.0147834215,
-0.0219548885,
-0.0291236658,
-0.0114206839,
-0.0325668603,
0.0315843932,
-0.0101853441,
-0.0141577683,
0.0756429136,
-0.0210850276,
-0.0172592159,
0.0022079688,
-0.0686327145,
0.0090765944,
0.0603686422,
0.0701891333,
0.0755811334,
0.0448021218,
0.0157707129,
0.050395336,
-0.0168529805,
-0.0151377339,
-0.0366513506,
-0.0059480942,
0.0729851499,
0.0706233606,
-0.0020370046,
0.0348663256,
0.0431967974,
-0.0333719924,
-0.0553484149,
-0.0030085437,
0.0116923833,
0.0187874027,
0.0264441613,
0.0011131072,
-0.0383042321,
-0.0573036522,
-0.0505911335,
-0.0173218474,
-0.0207577366,
-0.0017184211,
0.0075735869,
0.0207329541,
-0.0669679418,
-0.0186739564,
0.0372949578,
-0.0807998553,
-0.0003765353,
0.0286699776,
-0.0148569141,
0.0239903852,
0.0169766061,
0.0284453537,
-0.0683618411,
-0.0357605517,
0.0082972664,
-0.0014226498,
-0.0078770313,
-0.0142358253,
0.0117794452,
0.0219347756,
-0.0376955085,
0.0045464551,
-0.0489182137,
-0.0032778834,
0.0170425642,
0.0170700215,
0.046131663,
0.0244537741,
0.0185354631,
-0.0368171111,
0.0667695701,
-0.0029777442,
0.0240347609,
0.016273234,
0.0366779566,
0.01777656,
-0.0102624241,
-0.0065339403,
-0.0305605084,
-0.0251753218,
0.040280465,
-0.0095044486,
-0.0181058384,
0.0284813531,
2.711e-7,
0.0552661382,
0.0032378123,
0.0121802157,
-0.0012198847,
0.0251154546,
0.0067252936,
0.0091515286,
-0.0235527568,
0.0177197903,
-0.0513353013,
0.0141096776,
0.0676719919,
0.0631271005,
0.0243516024,
-0.0892458558,
-0.0013830354,
-0.0220739171,
-0.0581498183,
-0.0378389359,
-0.0552598089,
0.0022832032,
0.0879914463,
0.0228968281,
-0.0294234958,
0.0039304304,
-0.009473009,
0.0388833731,
-0.0096801501,
0.0145214517,
0.056936238,
0.0154221719,
-0.017877575,
-0.0211845376,
0.0336624011,
0.0110212397,
0.0191435684,
0.0074856435,
0.0892342031,
0.0038015991,
0.0050339075,
-0.0121629639,
-0.0126272673,
-0.025473414,
-0.0618729927,
0.1115036234,
-0.015669601,
0.0128545789,
-0.0453561991,
-0.0086719217,
-0.0284361672,
-0.0077884723,
0.0072077783,
0.0100212637,
0.0609650239,
0.0115491245,
-0.0155031839,
-0.0482727922,
-0.0932748988,
-0.0263453256,
0.0211050063,
-0.0659269542,
-0.0582516268,
-0.0220951904,
-0.0484151691,
0.0034830826,
-0.0504741296,
0.0248269234,
2.771101199e-34,
0.0094689336,
0.0142505597,
-0.0199612491,
0.0257924031,
0.0133794304,
-0.0596334599,
-0.0857443735,
0.0225395318,
-0.0331859365,
-0.1104966849,
0.001213786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01878v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01878v1 | Compare without Despair: Reliable Preference Evaluation with Generation Separability | 2024-07-02T01:37:56 | 2024-07-02T01:37:56 | Sayan Ghosh, Tejas Srinivasan, Swabha Swayamdipta | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human evaluation of generated language through pairwise preference judgments
is pervasive. However, under common scenarios, such as when generations from a
model pair are very similar, or when stochastic decoding results in large
variations in generations, it results in inconsistent preference ratings. We
address these challenges by introducing a meta-evaluation measure,
separability, which estimates how suitable a test instance is for pairwise
preference evaluation. For a candidate test instance, separability samples
multiple generations from a pair of models, and measures how distinguishable
the two sets of generations are. Our experiments show that instances with high
separability values yield more consistent preference ratings from both human-
and auto-raters. Further, the distribution of separability allows insights into
which test benchmarks are more valuable for comparing models. Finally, we
incorporate separability into ELO ratings, accounting for how suitable each
test instance might be for reliably ranking LLMs. Overall, separability has
implications for consistent, efficient and robust preference evaluation of LLMs
with both human- and auto-raters. | [
-0.006234738,
0.0887168944,
-0.0093275839,
0.030536389,
-0.0278460011,
0.0090485355,
0.0102385497,
0.0040825862,
-0.0401499607,
-0.0304234996,
-0.0736105144,
-0.0315911174,
0.0046233833,
0.0298977531,
0.0009454311,
-0.0417149141,
0.0318351761,
-0.0243537668,
0.0170984175,
-0.0176709853,
-0.0233033188,
-0.0121820383,
-0.0072700582,
0.0431884862,
0.0666657388,
-0.0216921307,
0.0029171368,
-0.0091324765,
0.0457417108,
-0.0412973575,
-0.0090444889,
0.0731975809,
-0.0296796635,
0.0425493121,
0.0000020214,
-0.0586886927,
-0.0199938137,
-0.0077046012,
-0.0144402692,
0.0132162292,
0.0385774598,
0.0927396715,
-0.0305964611,
0.0050920974,
-0.0449509807,
-0.0121560404,
0.0141330911,
-0.0379508063,
0.0535962507,
0.0349691436,
0.0106883813,
0.0180822741,
-0.0129130278,
-0.0239676125,
0.0351184234,
0.0305279437,
-0.0424118228,
-0.0288192369,
-0.0016897524,
0.0010707075,
0.0064627379,
0.0213502254,
0.0168217141,
-0.0090469327,
0.0555955395,
0.0186875891,
-0.020192299,
-0.0132443868,
-0.0330123417,
0.0754141808,
0.0239617378,
-0.000157054,
-0.0315266065,
-0.0219891369,
-0.0003733578,
0.013867422,
-0.0058273389,
0.0132677499,
-0.0151064955,
0.0307964645,
0.0114387562,
0.0233932007,
0.0163977835,
-0.0289795715,
-0.0236333646,
0.1106527522,
0.0274586678,
-0.0144439461,
0.0136568416,
0.0478599221,
-0.006688999,
-0.0396782421,
0.0123473145,
-0.0386363752,
-0.0506845228,
-0.0008688777,
-0.0153486514,
0.0243413821,
0.0231325421,
-0.034444157,
0.0772035569,
0.0044855941,
-0.0445473716,
-0.000889438,
-0.0194559619,
0.0590916425,
0.0252690855,
-0.0031547851,
-0.0451236553,
0.0599250719,
-0.0323585719,
0.0120710852,
0.0385928303,
0.0389741957,
-0.0237928517,
0.0154452743,
-0.0544397868,
0.0089739859,
-0.0553622916,
0.0056388448,
0.0280884895,
0.0089237066,
-0.009247981,
0.018716706,
-0.0642460883,
0.0266588256,
-0.0477052554,
0.009870315,
0.0298936851,
-0.0497167297,
0.0236189775,
0.0272329673,
-0.0008247612,
-0.0019670092,
-0.0055336142,
0.057966087,
0.0071023633,
-0.0212207418,
0.0103403628,
-0.0251570977,
-0.0253965966,
-0.0564088598,
0.0061621424,
-0.0799455345,
0.0045603672,
-0.0030602869,
-0.0114657562,
-0.0359429009,
-0.0289335102,
-0.0184257049,
0.0016085486,
0.0331295207,
0.0036536918,
0.0007626228,
-0.0464268103,
0.0046053524,
-0.0228994451,
0.0593703948,
0.0431598052,
0.0323816463,
0.0364271961,
0.0018616479,
-0.0059655514,
0.0083467644,
-0.02484891,
0.0315974317,
-0.0347848199,
-0.0040319613,
-0.0248862822,
0.0228523929,
0.0483644195,
0.0680214465,
-0.0394003801,
-0.0069086766,
0.0916758776,
0.003530706,
0.0521840341,
-0.0126064401,
0.0526019409,
0.0056500183,
-0.0131486487,
0.0775619075,
-0.003853959,
0.0407446176,
-0.0149186654,
0.0157989338,
0.0555315055,
0.0474838614,
-0.0103172595,
-0.0773893744,
-0.002944557,
-0.0142786149,
-0.00942019,
-0.0264815632,
0.0325933658,
-0.0017580525,
-0.0471988618,
-0.0082997167,
0.0181993414,
-0.0841105059,
0.0113623394,
-0.0711421445,
0.0697622374,
0.1154142171,
0.0266089384,
0.0331509784,
-0.0122887082,
0.0216778405,
-0.0788971186,
0.0468095057,
0.0314460211,
-0.0373120904,
0.0324726067,
-0.0377121121,
-0.0372572429,
0.014424541,
0.0129992031,
0.0538650528,
-0.0223936811,
0.0010482599,
-0.0097259153,
-0.0503913239,
-0.0053956369,
0.0071821972,
0.0011509042,
0.0037044194,
0.0102503952,
0.0073357532,
0.0617371351,
0.0252205431,
-0.0156865567,
0.0137316212,
0.0169778038,
0.0014021453,
-0.0057085115,
0.0446257554,
-0.0510965064,
-0.0506666712,
-0.0008744406,
-0.0617572851,
-0.0231372397,
0.0053547141,
-0.0075838678,
-0.0074601546,
-0.0076151113,
0.0013696882,
0.0372092426,
-0.0286400802,
0.0423785262,
-0.0235307869,
-0.032493189,
-0.0469555408,
0.0592043065,
-0.0350118019,
0.0128100682,
0.0232141595,
-0.0028919445,
0.0138452491,
-0.0548535138,
-0.0303884428,
0.0559915602,
0.0116102956,
0.0166846681,
0.0138206556,
0.0548444092,
-0.0636067018,
-0.0678691939,
-0.0529497154,
-0.0021477188,
-0.0092251347,
0.0354031846,
0.0051003215,
-0.0445496887,
0.012874946,
0.0341448821,
-0.0392163806,
-0.0065189693,
0.0043313662,
0.0215722211,
0.0145213399,
0.0022872884,
-0.009422536,
-0.0558807887,
-0.012212676,
0.0192534812,
0.0351623408,
-0.0034824468,
0.0733542517,
-0.0618349686,
0.0446362942,
-0.0733211562,
-0.0277359616,
0.033721339,
-0.035156738,
0.059299551,
-0.0031620278,
0.0405025072,
0.0455949679,
0.0191285759,
0.0094664171,
0.1205655038,
-0.0089633912,
-0.0922275856,
-0.0315707289,
-0.0014863225,
0.0157621372,
0.0010792608,
-0.0369790532,
-0.004959722,
0.0509173907,
0.0314605832,
-0.0051810746,
-0.0595157221,
0.047521174,
-0.0255216006,
-0.0364123844,
0.0238155965,
-0.0002642622,
-0.0398077667,
0.0563310869,
-0.0025093916,
-0.0960097089,
0.0882369876,
-0.0356370918,
0.0248784665,
-0.0309014991,
0.0204164833,
-0.0255604424,
0.0123377126,
-0.0235891715,
0.0017524756,
-0.0263723247,
0.0071530137,
-0.0517335832,
0.0185954664,
0.0396814756,
-0.0472641475,
0.0502815321,
-0.0610816963,
-0.0118779885,
0.0088476613,
-0.0521112494,
-0.0397212319,
0.0186819285,
-0.0055679441,
-0.0136751793,
0.0569657274,
-0.0193382204,
0.0189778898,
-0.0013318976,
-0.0058395071,
0.0058942316,
-0.0082021728,
-0.0147268064,
0.004380099,
0.0390187539,
0.0348396488,
0.0149099575,
0.0278227031,
-0.0218418762,
0.014484047,
0.0364860706,
0.0208383221,
0.0329787098,
-0.0499995872,
0.0315765254,
0.0426884964,
0.0139706042,
-0.0275364462,
0.0225150231,
0.0482499562,
-0.0170750134,
0.0078777038,
0.096232377,
0.0204683021,
-0.0304107144,
0.0032496958,
-0.0196410827,
0.0740470737,
0.0068716789,
0.0094896024,
-0.0434403829,
0.0122407172,
0.0060955337,
0.0675576627,
-0.0186764952,
0.0035249805,
0.0029171912,
-0.1058137044,
0.0355185159,
0.0149615696,
-0.0282231364,
0.0104982005,
-0.0217141584,
0.0096175317,
-0.006817969,
0.032376647,
0.0367056802,
-0.0180608351,
0.0252077691,
0.0150001198,
-0.0293626357,
-0.0437022187,
0.0350761674,
-0.0215846431,
0.0788057894,
0.0682863891,
0.0355195254,
0.009492375,
-0.0725127831,
-0.0079532033,
-0.0201328062,
-0.0274814498,
-0.0290751327,
0.0115067558,
0.0160075668,
0.0050692204,
-0.0387864225,
-0.0082505513,
0.0260113403,
0.0057434663,
-0.0182852,
0.0156625509,
-0.0183681846,
-0.0586654171,
-0.0108020715,
0.0211156905,
-0.005562345,
0.0625709146,
0.0545509905,
-0.0785111338,
-0.0194082987,
-0.0534559339,
-0.0100564994,
-0.0946716368,
-0.0332126245,
0.0275758486,
-0.0021589044,
-0.0173803177,
-0.1086233705,
-0.0243901554,
-0.0318744779,
0.0329287574,
-0.0110640256,
-0.0139102843,
-0.0172481239,
-0.0221651047,
0.0125194266,
0.0063959202,
0.0169539563,
-0.0345732048,
-0.0985371992,
-0.0382956006,
0.0363139212,
-0.0298141409,
-0.0110383313,
-0.0011081266,
-0.0091361348,
-0.0646082163,
0.0189857632,
0.07027255,
0.0291870721,
0.0083206771,
0.0144152408,
-0.0493370853,
0.0399311446,
0.0444354825,
0.0147912763,
0.0313296318,
0.0431175418,
0.0296756905,
-0.0146296741,
0.0143076396,
-0.0304720737,
0.0192098562,
0.0017455335,
0.015124619,
0.0068156226,
-0.0409811251,
0.0030435126,
0.0185543206,
0.0081687318,
-0.0644722581,
0.0069234883,
-0.0478626937,
0.0021022942,
-0.0294625498,
0.0160613097,
-0.0516819619,
-0.0161295794,
0.0189128444,
-0.0236728825,
-0.0015094033,
0.0130514614,
-0.0290919617,
0.0206421837,
-0.0216173753,
0.0516573712,
0.0180336535,
0.0254116897,
0.0186244752,
0.0164561495,
-0.0131920595,
-0.0217393488,
-0.0263753645,
0.0380685069,
0.0086981924,
0.0457389839,
-0.0035296308,
-0.0085675633,
0.0400570631,
0.0677760318,
-0.0219779909,
-0.0135579966,
-0.030190587,
-0.0331301279,
0.0247872341,
0.0419942737,
0.1100144237,
0.011699996,
0.0176355354,
-0.0351248197,
0.0272935778,
0.000621814,
-0.0123210587,
-0.0254504699,
0.0169793107,
-0.0091575226,
0.0136693344,
0.0642756075,
0.0079139788,
-0.0194174536,
-0.0447517894,
0.0279017724,
-0.055186037,
-0.0138350306,
-0.0508640707,
-0.0091315564,
-0.0294377115,
-0.0451556519,
-0.0751107037,
-0.0467657484,
0.0103469044,
0.0702119768,
0.0510522351,
-0.006065845,
0.0278118029,
0.0500848144,
-0.0412079841,
0.0117477439,
-0.0285763182,
-0.0447454378,
0.0054319501,
0.003745222,
-0.023212716,
-6.883032233e-33,
-0.0348122455,
-0.0254422612,
0.007228516,
-0.0690793023,
-0.005112723,
-0.0096706226,
-0.025473984,
0.0389074907,
0.0070930766,
-0.0318506993,
0.0010083036,
-0.0371490978,
0.0146014458,
-0.0007471793,
0.0412326604,
-0.007887736,
0.0589969307,
0.0017106282,
-0.0535865575,
-0.004072174,
0.0395069048,
-0.0255569145,
0.0282191075,
-0.0672609881,
0.0532637089,
0.0257048812,
-0.0211806633,
-0.0331642888,
-0.045292154,
0.0868056789,
-0.0094260871,
0.0414046012,
0.0043639638,
-0.0317687541,
-0.0305651296,
-0.0375552103,
-0.0210977588,
-0.0383663476,
-0.0067672622,
-0.0323193036,
-0.0208912175,
-0.0338473655,
0.0349315442,
0.0347641371,
-0.0616209432,
-0.008889758,
0.008760321,
-0.0287629962,
-0.0071234247,
-0.0107633332,
-0.0150454799,
0.0287955031,
-0.0126383547,
-0.0014009712,
0.032363873,
0.0325778015,
-0.0253449231,
0.0383955948,
-0.0463832021,
0.0822144151,
0.0274770427,
0.0355455577,
0.0760211349,
-0.01792516,
-0.0189795047,
0.0775136501,
0.0270809196,
-0.011735091,
0.0580419861,
-0.0373084806,
0.0317736827,
0.071478866,
0.0229097083,
0.0452221595,
0.0335724205,
-0.0160578229,
-0.0015844123,
0.0653014481,
0.0471586101,
-0.0213738363,
0.0218924116,
0.0338708088,
-0.0382781662,
-0.0006149965,
-0.0447500609,
-0.0918428376,
-0.0468726568,
-0.0560746975,
0.0397288203,
-0.0043379813,
-0.0448955409,
-0.0662380233,
0.0470136516,
-0.0138919903,
-0.0270968396,
-0.0063813971,
-0.0918867067,
0.0494555384,
0.0028980984,
-0.010217336,
0.0075345645,
0.0103651006,
0.0222619772,
0.0349167995,
0.0258278362,
-0.0077821142,
-0.0027195397,
-0.0101109799,
-0.0818256959,
0.0283942316,
-0.0255555566,
-0.0222190022,
-0.0088238856,
-0.0068020383,
0.0253575109,
-0.0236218404,
-0.0093795015,
0.0454255268,
-0.0155536719,
0.0091321776,
-0.061477609,
0.0216943771,
-0.0032880076,
0.0420387574,
0.0024488359,
0.0267100874,
-0.0267399419,
0.0140767405,
0.0254432317,
-0.0029597294,
-0.0264983997,
0.0033391006,
2.766e-7,
0.0138356928,
0.0633386821,
-0.0082190912,
-0.0089891125,
0.0201751385,
0.0426925831,
-0.0300934985,
-0.0042954958,
0.0385776609,
-0.0154297631,
-0.0069134547,
0.0090129357,
0.0475693308,
0.0477167033,
-0.0525913648,
0.0048972401,
-0.0601234436,
-0.0028533549,
-0.0276827589,
-0.0544835106,
0.0720169991,
0.0207459163,
-0.0107635129,
0.0151335159,
0.0031302085,
0.0448201075,
0.0257704947,
-0.0389572568,
-0.0136850523,
0.0022339781,
0.015561427,
-0.0273737609,
-0.0044280351,
-0.0264682714,
0.0029599608,
-0.0251488741,
0.0109811397,
0.0724734738,
0.0345329531,
-0.0861891508,
0.0247220565,
0.0225767791,
-0.0062547219,
-0.0207591597,
0.0460425094,
0.0153897014,
-0.0138419895,
-0.0148662496,
-0.050094083,
-0.0053600213,
0.0151923476,
-0.0417622775,
-0.0332028009,
0.0295338854,
-0.0207623839,
-0.0040565538,
-0.0242421627,
-0.020298725,
-0.0342146195,
-0.0034635572,
-0.0411881581,
-0.1052658036,
-0.0269285254,
0.0458090268,
-0.0098642129,
-0.0633309484,
-0.0126733398,
2.491340661e-34,
0.0372134,
0.0103608007,
0.0447982512,
-0.0269673076,
0.027084142,
0.0108445147,
-0.0155691579,
-0.006243506,
0.0217613801,
-0.0293298606,
-0.0101073114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01873v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01873v1 | Automated Text Scoring in the Age of Generative AI for the GPU-poor | 2024-07-02T01:17:01 | 2024-07-02T01:17:01 | Christopher Michael Ormerod, Alexander Kwako | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Current research on generative language models (GLMs) for automated text
scoring (ATS) has focused almost exclusively on querying proprietary models via
Application Programming Interfaces (APIs). Yet such practices raise issues
around transparency and security, and these methods offer little in the way of
efficiency or customizability. With the recent proliferation of smaller,
open-source models, there is the option to explore GLMs with computers equipped
with modest, consumer-grade hardware, that is, for the "GPU poor." In this
study, we analyze the performance and efficiency of open-source, small-scale
GLMs for ATS. Results show that GLMs can be fine-tuned to achieve adequate,
though not state-of-the-art, performance. In addition to ATS, we take small
steps towards analyzing models' capacity for generating feedback by prompting
GLMs to explain their scores. Model-generated feedback shows promise, but
requires more rigorous evaluation focused on targeted use cases. | [
0.0273657795,
0.079583481,
-0.0073528751,
0.0206906777,
-0.0483401157,
-0.0016400611,
0.0325370952,
0.0068389485,
0.028090965,
-0.0459867902,
0.0062424792,
-0.0342184752,
0.0511112884,
0.0554534756,
0.0179953184,
-0.0203939322,
-0.0033587469,
-0.0249402151,
0.027678825,
-0.0247357395,
0.0104742311,
0.0351730883,
0.0071487306,
0.0342523046,
0.0010960152,
-0.0469784364,
0.0023564878,
-0.0022961481,
0.0031554129,
0.0281383619,
-0.0421594456,
0.0668725669,
-0.0226338189,
0.0531010516,
0.0000022812,
-0.0327729955,
-0.007613569,
-0.0045487299,
0.0237635151,
0.0298027601,
0.0792101771,
0.023671167,
-0.0043835882,
0.0142966257,
-0.0468680598,
-0.0286709517,
0.0084168101,
-0.018470332,
0.0344555564,
0.0334389471,
-0.012392587,
-0.0019142366,
0.0215463806,
-0.0042265374,
-0.001970174,
-0.018015027,
-0.0064844326,
0.0072403299,
0.0099479528,
-0.0072482205,
-0.034714628,
0.0525835156,
0.0313187093,
-0.0626481473,
0.0150175197,
0.0448766053,
-0.0190669987,
0.0101659261,
0.0012813631,
0.0140343448,
-0.0129096685,
-0.0337122567,
-0.0205924287,
-0.0271848068,
-0.0010121408,
-0.0138624962,
-0.0328084491,
0.0536592454,
-0.0246458761,
-0.005817838,
0.0311498605,
0.0083048921,
0.0334787332,
-0.0030832675,
0.0408514105,
0.0230074171,
0.0440169089,
-0.0274329204,
-0.022805931,
0.0327303782,
-0.0347265229,
-0.0547969379,
0.003434334,
-0.0105246892,
-0.0061270427,
0.0002675827,
-0.0632765964,
-0.0438748524,
0.0104544424,
-0.0018984225,
0.0659855455,
0.0051570735,
0.0211824793,
0.0153066479,
-0.0319844149,
0.0616092086,
0.042218782,
-0.0108579407,
-0.0130321393,
0.0260141026,
-0.0181225985,
-0.0251929741,
-0.0281763878,
0.019886896,
-0.0450338647,
0.0047155716,
-0.0431548059,
0.0046747853,
-0.0187227111,
0.0347167514,
0.0248569772,
0.0461062081,
-0.0288169943,
0.0095928814,
-0.0220579952,
-0.0111008296,
-0.0564221628,
-0.0183924064,
0.0150457378,
-0.0788320005,
0.005304744,
0.0209577791,
0.0243742429,
-0.0070062759,
0.0234686751,
0.0240606219,
0.0160934832,
0.0058208443,
0.0033246528,
-0.026436504,
-0.0243258364,
-0.0643420964,
-0.0408634767,
-0.0599930584,
0.004783805,
0.0475049764,
0.0266460739,
-0.0445627309,
0.0098229432,
0.0418966338,
0.0022572954,
0.0347918049,
-0.0137023404,
-0.0095216548,
0.0261256304,
-0.0083416505,
0.0285829175,
0.0439110734,
0.0489081666,
0.0618027411,
0.0551595874,
-0.0102414377,
0.082457006,
0.0151345348,
0.0256392807,
0.0075292657,
-0.0068125078,
0.0093450015,
-0.0038228775,
0.0625027791,
-0.0010264406,
0.0589614771,
0.0168426335,
-0.0116043249,
0.1065748334,
0.0781405568,
0.0202488378,
0.041313991,
0.059385553,
-0.0123585248,
-0.0042908615,
-0.0217513908,
0.0087290071,
0.0056936857,
-0.0484996848,
0.0278680772,
0.0320043564,
0.0484521911,
0.0246536639,
-0.0876790583,
-0.0188491754,
-0.0053671985,
-0.0356540121,
0.0196288731,
0.0675473064,
-0.0053506726,
-0.0454344861,
-0.0741859078,
0.026435826,
-0.0873965323,
0.0089916047,
-0.0784197748,
0.0344526358,
0.1012091562,
0.1047976539,
0.0164343864,
0.0030324725,
-0.0432344191,
-0.0201907139,
0.0377542339,
-0.0018093423,
-0.0328888372,
-0.0024713392,
-0.0480221696,
-0.0022291846,
0.0003848236,
-0.0056638857,
0.0302068517,
0.0143022146,
-0.0269803256,
-0.023788318,
-0.0338324197,
-0.0948150754,
0.0291000642,
0.006904914,
-0.0545064248,
0.0065258294,
-0.0189100374,
-0.0031618739,
0.0280805435,
0.003458105,
0.0065824385,
0.0124272387,
-0.0182830468,
-0.0167769548,
-0.0346702114,
-0.0077592707,
0.0406890288,
0.0061698509,
0.0110585736,
0.030355515,
0.0486321636,
-0.0203995425,
-0.0228662994,
0.0167548936,
-0.005046397,
0.0002746398,
-0.0428021774,
-0.0051608891,
-0.0101094889,
-0.0368189067,
-0.0474037938,
0.036406979,
0.0094859041,
0.0430772714,
-0.028436441,
0.0056510912,
0.0381383672,
-0.0336739756,
-0.028904818,
0.0081342086,
0.0029315259,
0.0286510084,
0.0299588162,
-0.0054318365,
-0.0131778093,
-0.0001952017,
-0.1127354354,
0.0029438811,
-0.02286461,
0.0018671209,
0.0354061648,
-0.0001171623,
-0.0180146452,
0.0145460023,
-0.0322126299,
-0.0153728686,
0.022530375,
-0.0167776942,
0.0397522114,
0.0034824903,
0.0057703457,
-0.0434523225,
-0.0268068835,
-0.0216970183,
0.0787728727,
0.0739039183,
-0.0030129917,
-0.0332283564,
0.0258194711,
-0.0047351271,
0.0272968207,
0.0064695901,
-0.0114152851,
0.0021751295,
0.0000833631,
0.0286653768,
0.0845656171,
0.0074070506,
0.0266724098,
0.0237354655,
-0.0114060454,
-0.0552585684,
0.0137695894,
-0.0189209357,
-0.0429621898,
-0.0014919429,
-0.0273954067,
-0.0018797063,
0.0769268349,
0.0271777865,
-0.0272551998,
-0.0701119825,
0.0688790306,
-0.0474957265,
-0.0559839197,
-0.0477465838,
0.0406043492,
0.025043752,
0.0268108062,
-0.0242436547,
-0.1054160073,
0.0474831201,
-0.0616802797,
0.0069078188,
-0.0220244378,
0.0161314961,
-0.0101774242,
0.08583837,
0.0237488281,
0.0191775858,
-0.0101174703,
0.0279892907,
0.0142740132,
0.0507522076,
0.0321894512,
-0.043763224,
0.0312370714,
-0.0427796096,
0.0004248418,
-0.0161849,
-0.0295807142,
-0.0106918793,
0.0077053811,
-0.0269312132,
0.0073012146,
0.038755998,
-0.0340870619,
0.0056917127,
-0.0041598999,
0.005329364,
0.0325638913,
-0.0612613335,
-0.0537789837,
0.0159504917,
0.0019094453,
0.0373371579,
-0.0757260248,
-0.0347109511,
-0.0396635123,
-0.0361414328,
0.0405873768,
0.0352646708,
0.0076181297,
-0.025441397,
-0.0249870606,
0.0426671766,
-0.0228773206,
0.0021411418,
0.0212727971,
0.015857473,
-0.0652975217,
-0.0282456614,
0.0993328243,
0.0284064207,
-0.0270811561,
-0.01935702,
0.000145242,
0.0344227105,
0.0142160552,
0.0626117289,
-0.106970571,
-0.0030300666,
0.0161685273,
0.088182725,
-0.0334024951,
0.0031816484,
0.0003435925,
-0.1342644989,
0.0725155473,
-0.024080202,
-0.0001307169,
-0.0111638494,
-0.030034177,
-0.0250993706,
-0.0247585848,
-0.0429383069,
0.0014469572,
0.0010522917,
0.0509811565,
0.0001752616,
-0.019644998,
-0.003778856,
0.0135323452,
-0.0141157163,
0.0554889143,
0.1004384384,
0.04076593,
0.0209483001,
-0.0573795289,
0.0074617923,
0.0286667813,
0.007306363,
-0.0501555987,
0.035516005,
-0.0444924533,
0.0100660846,
-0.0360943116,
0.0166506376,
-0.0182813965,
0.0030835229,
0.0151350806,
0.0420047492,
0.0047136638,
-0.0257255398,
0.0025314086,
-0.0082007358,
-0.0038726302,
0.0701544359,
0.0234696995,
-0.0730130449,
-0.0622794591,
-0.0797199011,
0.0087055787,
-0.08961346,
-0.076461181,
-0.0182050075,
0.0494881906,
-0.0439572781,
-0.0509255677,
-0.0567285009,
0.029934207,
0.0175818074,
0.0053354306,
0.0198255684,
-0.0537740774,
0.016122058,
-0.0500864461,
0.0063710501,
-0.0399093889,
0.0067301998,
-0.071153596,
-0.0216905531,
0.0158861838,
-0.0467890911,
-0.0475301221,
0.0476447232,
-0.0488987379,
-0.0237384196,
0.0219322275,
0.0692491233,
0.0228850711,
-0.0165851265,
-0.0274265762,
-0.0342798792,
0.01309002,
0.0563158765,
-0.0241688211,
0.0243916567,
0.0001003102,
-0.0246149674,
-0.017499486,
0.0208143871,
0.0037238414,
0.0236950219,
0.0526422486,
0.0190126188,
0.0497390814,
-0.0100918245,
0.0139964838,
0.0369951278,
0.0497123301,
-0.048904825,
-0.0529849567,
-0.0551043004,
0.011221529,
-0.0303748418,
-0.0312638506,
-0.0330692977,
-0.018850131,
0.03592344,
0.0013811291,
-0.0338108316,
0.0156189697,
-0.0242841076,
0.0552922301,
-0.1105070934,
0.0154743595,
0.0185742341,
0.0263516363,
0.0125309154,
-0.015541994,
0.0000522798,
0.0043426715,
-0.0201165155,
0.0519377589,
-0.0089009181,
0.0332677625,
0.006210004,
-0.007954115,
0.0304485597,
0.0585173741,
-0.0270066597,
-0.0025727467,
-0.0655236095,
0.021102041,
0.0452425107,
0.0358554982,
0.0531839356,
0.0143811675,
0.0111102397,
-0.03764892,
0.0198058765,
0.0495444424,
-0.0521877594,
-0.0158555824,
0.0102479486,
-0.0137057565,
0.0014309847,
0.065365307,
-0.0147083057,
0.042123016,
0.0037900105,
-0.0316144489,
-0.0358804576,
-0.0366327874,
-0.021864919,
-0.0244023819,
-0.0144151542,
-0.0116455769,
-0.0676951632,
-0.0335027277,
-0.0012916569,
0.0717338249,
0.019622229,
-0.0018323574,
0.0007197467,
0.0725203902,
-0.0346416235,
-0.0203968529,
-0.0690991208,
0.0307774972,
-0.0750967935,
-0.0123619884,
-0.0032876534,
-6.744960136e-33,
-0.025290275,
-0.031457942,
0.0135825537,
0.0089944229,
0.0269785337,
0.0023589737,
-0.005246093,
-0.0029526793,
0.0453858897,
0.0110074598,
-0.0202920809,
-0.005224674,
0.0064010839,
0.0401818193,
0.0356941074,
-0.0054295482,
0.0407312997,
-0.0085544279,
-0.0451325923,
0.0463819876,
0.0120426696,
0.0238427762,
0.0106566129,
-0.0657556951,
0.0629768595,
-0.0541489832,
-0.0257659201,
-0.0183639694,
-0.0376868509,
0.0410912633,
-0.019424228,
0.0403711013,
0.025679104,
-0.0495244935,
0.0077597885,
0.0109140277,
-0.0633319095,
0.0142713981,
0.0151921827,
-0.008924176,
-0.0310267247,
-0.0377756618,
0.0040099365,
0.0216302853,
-0.0327544659,
-0.0383363739,
0.0324331895,
0.0046891631,
-0.0235943738,
-0.0806347951,
-0.0523911342,
0.0217158683,
0.000706841,
0.0304506999,
0.0130917951,
0.0087541835,
0.0016079765,
0.021094922,
0.0090322988,
0.0167408548,
0.0421786681,
0.0636785701,
0.0996820182,
0.0250193588,
-0.0045660175,
0.0439738072,
0.0189325009,
0.0059700361,
-0.046124313,
0.0039742584,
0.0229307842,
-0.03186078,
0.0682801679,
0.0603732243,
0.01984795,
0.0042542699,
-0.0334131047,
0.025431864,
-0.0294258557,
-0.0041405363,
0.0446623974,
-0.00202235,
-0.0776345357,
-0.0195368174,
-0.051991798,
-0.0613552779,
-0.0338969529,
-0.0336013623,
0.0584956929,
0.0066164816,
-0.0322766826,
-0.0318680629,
-0.0336965322,
-0.0147001976,
-0.0003594501,
-0.0338767171,
0.0072190692,
0.05352249,
-0.021339329,
0.0041374317,
-0.0036483991,
0.0342413448,
0.0014207851,
0.0154126072,
0.0426335074,
-0.0228608586,
0.001548683,
0.0364862792,
-0.0813660622,
0.0048293332,
-0.0566264205,
0.0430635698,
-0.0066191764,
0.0331422761,
0.0052363379,
0.0142451888,
-0.0046907407,
0.0416122749,
-0.0141453482,
0.0380117819,
-0.0423362814,
-0.0359827504,
-0.0254321322,
-0.0426978469,
-0.0385855846,
-0.0048227673,
-0.000404863,
0.0142713198,
0.0084750829,
-0.0250202455,
-0.0101852762,
-0.0003981224,
2.896e-7,
0.0599161386,
0.0799201354,
0.0244455915,
-0.0025266611,
-0.0353931673,
0.0196764246,
0.0140876714,
0.0109087592,
0.045140028,
0.004701999,
-0.0203991104,
0.0186109915,
0.0352644548,
0.0411539972,
-0.0672883242,
0.0191076491,
-0.0440375172,
0.0261878334,
-0.0396879278,
0.0059352648,
0.0393479019,
0.0425124764,
0.0137128066,
-0.0002982253,
0.0307383444,
-0.0482552834,
0.0309460834,
-0.0368215926,
-0.018491514,
0.0100484546,
0.0634530112,
0.0145877888,
-0.0065960847,
0.0032404773,
-0.0168257803,
-0.000812268,
-0.0170967653,
0.0714353397,
-0.0314863212,
0.010157139,
0.0034173175,
-0.0321003832,
-0.0005222983,
-0.0572605021,
0.0478704646,
0.0462166592,
0.0036458944,
-0.0292892326,
0.0305194706,
-0.014287726,
0.0234401282,
-0.0451068692,
-0.0039730165,
-0.0089447983,
0.010825254,
-0.0217951722,
-0.0153990518,
-0.0312710144,
-0.0186295975,
-0.0353265554,
-0.0079875188,
-0.0380421616,
-0.0596737489,
0.026288677,
0.0126975356,
-0.0430679694,
0.0032093832,
2.766028436e-34,
0.0500081666,
0.0168786477,
-0.013491354,
-0.0270544905,
0.0457132868,
-0.0032401627,
0.0149735454,
-0.0276250653,
0.0033640144,
-0.0757224485,
-0.0273019318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01863v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01863v1 | VSP: Assessing the dual challenges of perception and reasoning in spatial planning tasks for VLMs | 2024-07-02T00:24:01 | 2024-07-02T00:24:01 | Qiucheng Wu, Handong Zhao, Michael Saxon, Trung Bui, William Yang Wang, Yang Zhang, Shiyu Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Vision language models (VLMs) are an exciting emerging class of language
models (LMs) that have merged classic LM capabilities with those of image
processing systems. However, the ways that these capabilities combine are not
always intuitive and warrant direct investigation. One understudied capability
in VLMs is visual spatial planning -- the ability to comprehend the spatial
arrangements of objects and devise action plans to achieve desired outcomes in
visual scenes. In our study, we introduce VSP, a benchmark that 1) evaluates
the spatial planning capability in these models in general, and 2) breaks down
the visual planning task into finer-grained sub-tasks, including perception and
reasoning, and measure the LMs capabilities in these sub-tasks. Our evaluation
shows that both open-source and private VLMs fail to generate effective plans
for even simple spatial planning tasks. Evaluations on the fine-grained
analytical tasks further reveal fundamental deficiencies in the models' visual
perception and bottlenecks in reasoning abilities, explaining their worse
performance in the general spatial planning tasks. Our work illuminates future
directions for improving VLMs' abilities in spatial planning. Our benchmark is
publicly available at
https://github.com/UCSB-NLP-Chang/Visual-Spatial-Planning. | [
0.0507315323,
0.0419117846,
-0.0108187161,
0.0401357859,
-0.0749729201,
0.010230355,
0.0193181857,
-0.0241470821,
0.0279957242,
-0.0407124124,
-0.0074548577,
0.0016785346,
0.0409332812,
0.0401141904,
-0.01643309,
-0.0641214699,
0.0072461502,
-0.0680599064,
-0.0086546512,
-0.0030605283,
-0.0216638669,
-0.0076026428,
-0.020702783,
0.0147763947,
-0.0002922449,
0.0097291376,
-0.0232420564,
-0.0030666911,
0.0050987015,
-0.0358944647,
-0.0438996665,
-0.0008303419,
0.0343623981,
0.0191008952,
0.0000018834,
-0.0369092077,
-0.0046101734,
-0.0175359622,
0.0497704968,
0.0056703389,
-0.0055760811,
-0.0728804395,
0.0190556124,
0.0031738076,
-0.0348937809,
-0.0082027754,
0.0403889455,
0.0323849879,
0.0054520923,
0.0414330252,
-0.0201799236,
-0.0484193712,
0.0028020015,
-0.0048112953,
0.0321173333,
-0.0104267839,
-0.000686132,
-0.0058124824,
0.0080195935,
0.0440759212,
-0.0536098182,
0.0193695929,
0.0240212828,
0.0134919779,
-0.0224731807,
0.0554280989,
-0.0326241478,
-0.0336950161,
-0.0347537436,
0.0206078365,
-0.0214485116,
-0.0301039424,
0.0462545007,
-0.0021313783,
-0.0115086166,
-0.008706633,
-0.0578114912,
0.0516562834,
-0.0029952307,
0.0097286198,
-0.0529477298,
0.0157605726,
0.0049849325,
-0.0019238086,
0.0024495996,
0.0666843504,
-0.0041653058,
0.0100817354,
-0.0213933531,
-0.0099418638,
-0.0052535161,
-0.0859819055,
-0.0038464663,
0.0329605304,
-0.0214346405,
0.0231084395,
-0.0139556397,
0.0564505532,
-0.0135125099,
-0.0198506396,
0.0727584139,
0.0347189829,
-0.0024163665,
0.0634455085,
-0.0536048301,
0.1103507429,
-0.0155154895,
0.096476078,
-0.0078063239,
0.0126076313,
-0.0096591236,
0.0339546055,
-0.0284915939,
-0.0435446352,
-0.0812461823,
-0.0562711433,
0.0124608148,
0.0186844263,
-0.0234021582,
0.050227616,
-0.0096932547,
0.032103885,
0.0282061212,
-0.0530520342,
-0.0446651801,
-0.0246639941,
-0.0001014745,
-0.0114554781,
-0.0499385968,
-0.0252339188,
0.0063204067,
0.0235415567,
0.0075102225,
-0.0097368043,
-0.029790448,
0.0842799321,
0.0115399342,
-0.0115500791,
-0.012330085,
-0.0199626964,
-0.039351441,
-0.0583332926,
0.0705633238,
-0.0845205337,
-0.0113458205,
-0.0091654146,
-0.0199411996,
-0.0216772426,
0.0067510782,
-0.0006175829,
-0.0262723677,
0.0494283922,
0.0203727316,
0.0498264432,
0.0093295258,
-0.0030720597,
0.0284903795,
0.0649947003,
0.0413119607,
0.077749908,
0.012107376,
0.0581400357,
0.0338594988,
0.0421737321,
-0.0185005162,
-0.0015329386,
-0.0617065243,
0.0136755966,
-0.0217135958,
0.0311055128,
0.00356863,
0.0479453765,
0.0006688757,
-0.0404303297,
0.0302311461,
0.0780979544,
0.0086378399,
-0.0417282321,
0.0291552544,
0.0175877344,
-0.0439059325,
-0.0368622541,
-0.0498365872,
0.0374868847,
-0.0085237101,
-0.008904919,
-0.0352346078,
0.0188614242,
0.0036703763,
-0.0543864816,
-0.0677018687,
0.0013873361,
0.0203187168,
-0.0011558039,
0.0331236906,
0.0044178981,
-0.0339658894,
0.0110192867,
-0.0213488247,
-0.0071835187,
-0.0106063522,
-0.0244198609,
0.020651849,
0.034072388,
0.0066740182,
0.029250972,
-0.0133580416,
0.0066772494,
0.0230864268,
0.0289218053,
0.0572667606,
0.0087578362,
0.0237103589,
-0.032055039,
-0.0486274511,
-0.00921991,
0.0240926743,
0.017272165,
0.0620413087,
-0.0113723865,
0.0156239849,
-0.0522349104,
0.0072935019,
0.0308970045,
0.0267332792,
-0.0025112813,
-0.0685020536,
0.0131067345,
-0.0073730294,
-0.0259040054,
-0.0062673958,
0.0157718137,
0.0327404588,
-0.0052686329,
0.0404608399,
0.0194230452,
-0.00878511,
-0.0178764127,
0.0219872165,
-0.0469839163,
-0.022890145,
0.0386766717,
-0.0424369723,
0.0041720937,
0.0252674185,
-0.0289946049,
-0.0119949942,
-0.0098942509,
-0.0024664178,
0.0059258146,
-0.0437318273,
-0.0377417989,
0.0438230857,
-0.045884531,
0.0163096022,
0.0038349808,
0.0113713304,
0.0453359634,
-0.017124733,
0.0156858116,
-0.0339162089,
0.0028340782,
0.0009662926,
-0.0045015188,
0.037336465,
-0.0300086252,
-0.037158493,
-0.0592981912,
-0.0148654636,
-0.0279031843,
-0.0329659395,
0.0086952401,
-0.0518588871,
-0.0271044578,
-0.0205472652,
-0.0028608365,
0.0355093926,
0.0092343725,
0.0209544525,
0.0137742329,
-0.0237927549,
-0.0230326764,
-0.0054417662,
0.0037452241,
-0.016041873,
0.002244985,
0.0501894839,
-0.0211512875,
0.0093433382,
0.0214095805,
-0.0136163384,
0.0210734457,
-0.0245962385,
-0.0269169696,
0.0275876336,
-0.0443210676,
-0.0119150747,
0.0539992526,
-0.0222993996,
-0.017774079,
0.045755364,
-0.0137465512,
-0.0487058312,
0.0217240471,
-0.0290485658,
-0.0291189775,
-0.0383229479,
-0.025382638,
-0.0305867549,
0.039521087,
-0.0349659175,
-0.0015432172,
-0.0617312603,
0.0426867194,
-0.0127828205,
-0.0527272224,
-0.0308334082,
0.0272718184,
0.0136423754,
0.1037500203,
-0.0740158483,
-0.0825524107,
-0.0188085325,
-0.0550072603,
-0.0149919977,
0.0175671764,
0.0446095131,
-0.0496549532,
0.1158370301,
0.0521243885,
0.0197739173,
-0.0201882143,
0.0118435351,
-0.0220764689,
-0.0277546104,
-0.0358908623,
0.0358168632,
0.0355894491,
-0.091335386,
0.0022495955,
-0.0062201307,
-0.0094326446,
-0.0297333188,
0.0133787151,
-0.0516584031,
0.0089274682,
-0.0428842492,
-0.0513967872,
-0.0069120061,
0.0557962358,
0.0271250159,
0.0414195471,
-0.0065777488,
-0.0205831248,
-0.02774138,
-0.0303193219,
0.0691998377,
0.0616666488,
-0.0270517133,
-0.0177207384,
-0.0518314205,
0.0493637398,
0.0052155,
0.0188574456,
-0.0399194658,
0.063989684,
0.0366435237,
0.0428627245,
-0.0050237346,
0.0502978675,
0.0820461735,
-0.0260420069,
-0.0687950999,
0.0586723313,
0.0524089038,
0.0122728525,
-0.0102397697,
-0.0270419735,
0.0368274413,
0.0681908205,
0.0157672502,
-0.0186938122,
-0.0255372562,
0.0124808839,
-0.0576182753,
0.0347647145,
-0.040941041,
-0.0171734057,
-0.09427277,
0.0888987035,
0.0080531994,
-0.0536542647,
-0.0230052993,
-0.0045725098,
-0.0103446981,
-0.01021499,
-0.0556664728,
-0.0390484892,
-0.0032296209,
0.0150580611,
-0.0121087106,
-0.0427059308,
0.016518645,
0.0041042771,
-0.0474811755,
0.0079363212,
0.0612406433,
0.0264123194,
0.0278162025,
-0.0940920785,
0.0223742276,
0.0657364428,
0.0481569842,
-0.0300450604,
0.0226361528,
0.0093452903,
-0.0036629222,
0.029198572,
0.0137795815,
-0.0442263186,
-0.0498979725,
-0.0015029247,
0.0442267284,
-0.0045815632,
-0.0022472821,
-0.0433805771,
0.0410936736,
-0.0277026333,
0.0515280105,
0.0068224953,
0.0265340991,
-0.0850445554,
-0.0377343446,
-0.0224086773,
-0.0754882544,
-0.0465690419,
0.0283614956,
0.057898324,
-0.0174804833,
-0.0419362634,
-0.0235697422,
0.0449947938,
0.0558519438,
-0.015043282,
-0.0453214198,
-0.0086863935,
0.0127495611,
-0.0570220239,
0.0395440273,
-0.0184225962,
0.0251226667,
0.0017748069,
0.0139283864,
-0.0279145259,
-0.0388448238,
-0.0204629395,
0.0060855346,
-0.0800305903,
-0.036217086,
-0.0064084148,
0.0917172581,
0.0232012551,
0.0086050304,
-0.0050297161,
-0.0145221725,
0.007224503,
0.005575506,
0.0025776946,
0.0637451634,
0.0064908909,
0.0247324873,
0.037308868,
0.0181915201,
-0.0122609697,
0.0151931662,
0.0371175334,
0.0089599518,
-0.0291112233,
0.0188373085,
-0.0181603283,
-0.0056315279,
0.0742499903,
0.004262459,
0.0096250614,
-0.0157870036,
-0.0179224946,
-0.0265459493,
0.0098769525,
-0.0549623892,
-0.004288326,
0.0371149816,
0.0418609902,
0.0087970421,
0.0226427652,
0.0042068996,
-0.0106315287,
0.0085326517,
-0.0194616448,
0.0533449836,
-0.0420313217,
0.0297362749,
0.0236755889,
0.0037672268,
0.0285981316,
-0.067764543,
0.0434039161,
0.0396409184,
0.0046893,
0.0174788591,
-0.0017774433,
-0.0472579412,
0.0049892021,
-0.0619464517,
-0.1280565858,
0.0505108684,
0.0516523197,
0.0779194906,
-0.0437172316,
0.0189336222,
-0.0400685892,
0.0170675796,
-0.010765912,
-0.0181334894,
0.0331423841,
-0.057816606,
0.0324515216,
0.0253453348,
-0.0190001205,
-0.0482014827,
0.0317472033,
-0.003942749,
0.0425681509,
0.0023511974,
-0.005781963,
-0.023413958,
-0.0372386202,
0.0084536495,
0.0276290737,
0.0150727797,
0.0361320004,
-0.04811069,
-0.0312754065,
0.0015282114,
0.0658564791,
0.0209124424,
0.0212890133,
0.0318478346,
0.0409589224,
0.0056325519,
-0.0292916782,
-0.0340414867,
-0.0667942688,
0.0148959076,
-0.0270971898,
0.0075402195,
-5.570225081e-33,
0.0000060487,
-0.0556631833,
0.0860697255,
-0.0301076788,
0.0332147777,
-0.0064895037,
-0.0260767639,
0.0141756581,
-0.0327713601,
0.0060973242,
-0.0081040869,
0.0023101899,
0.0048663453,
0.0328624398,
0.0168455057,
0.0201832857,
0.0187920928,
-0.0008980299,
-0.0314505957,
-0.0636807382,
0.0174025204,
-0.0089395326,
-0.0104688173,
-0.0217587799,
-0.0537400432,
0.0376621634,
-0.0012779379,
0.0353341289,
-0.0285048429,
0.0773462728,
-0.0005313671,
-0.0481074266,
0.0363063999,
0.0230342764,
-0.0517110601,
0.0194015522,
-0.0351344049,
-0.0196668524,
0.0094762053,
0.0332804471,
-0.0867252573,
0.0161764435,
0.0323819406,
0.0207688771,
-0.0235312749,
-0.0463334769,
0.0139728766,
-0.0045323023,
-0.025268089,
0.0576179437,
0.0020729508,
0.013361278,
0.0066657704,
-0.0203818344,
0.0776341856,
-0.0101211602,
0.0294546224,
0.0318497978,
-0.0206478536,
0.0279778149,
-0.0005767985,
0.0254952349,
0.0698487684,
0.0215578824,
0.0168211535,
0.0826092958,
0.0572385676,
-0.0230721068,
-0.0128172841,
-0.0207439438,
0.0356565565,
0.082349062,
0.001714694,
0.0350310914,
0.0205061492,
0.0484974086,
-0.031687066,
0.0006865097,
-0.0917690024,
0.0588425547,
0.0366363674,
0.0215247199,
-0.0199720319,
0.0017810991,
-0.0548562631,
-0.0050456575,
-0.0327124931,
0.0264585521,
0.0432499126,
0.0479618162,
0.0419663265,
0.0209831409,
0.0208050106,
-0.0409066454,
0.0118913809,
0.0108250258,
-0.0203765091,
0.0495665446,
-0.0075887344,
0.0667500347,
-0.0914570466,
-0.0112918047,
0.0073036849,
0.0321865045,
-0.0180448238,
0.0255987588,
0.0127327247,
0.0033841007,
-0.0343797207,
-0.028387215,
-0.0683186799,
0.0102831945,
-0.0100931292,
0.0038567483,
0.0585587248,
-0.0174108297,
-0.0348134488,
0.0124737211,
-0.0248838495,
-0.0648839623,
0.0159621798,
-0.0075539513,
-0.0274252035,
0.0201844517,
-0.0040704957,
-0.0187705867,
-0.0436745137,
-0.0131892273,
0.0231848136,
-0.027156271,
-0.0164824855,
0.0244428832,
2.624e-7,
0.0250028111,
0.0463581495,
0.024595065,
0.0311226342,
0.0147938272,
0.0278490894,
-0.0092405286,
-0.0004562479,
-0.0458368547,
-0.0128015121,
0.0162067171,
0.0695028529,
0.0259552617,
-0.0126619823,
-0.0422593616,
0.0824529752,
-0.0055792257,
-0.0069488706,
-0.0524510108,
0.0021173286,
0.0590288974,
0.0178743899,
-0.0194443874,
0.0145107592,
0.0161297582,
-0.0529267527,
0.0206747707,
-0.080599539,
0.0398712158,
-0.0027751708,
0.0167692117,
0.0005025631,
-0.017916631,
-0.0204737224,
-0.0091691185,
-0.0227430128,
-0.0177563988,
0.0737337172,
-0.0306702591,
-0.0301143136,
-0.0020582289,
-0.0220077392,
-0.0453170985,
-0.0826168209,
0.0677813292,
-0.0421550982,
0.0171038248,
0.0316466019,
0.0283896215,
0.0275437832,
-0.0057718619,
0.0234450474,
-0.0142899817,
-0.0168002229,
0.0246755369,
-0.0217617787,
-0.0182738863,
-0.0776238441,
-0.0238774028,
-0.008739369,
-0.0186973531,
0.0001938281,
-0.061037153,
0.0246984139,
0.0163506735,
0.0250101984,
-0.0872141495,
2.046542552e-34,
-0.0024318658,
0.0140533699,
-0.0098005347,
-0.0274798479,
0.0268442705,
-0.0174352676,
-0.0131303426,
0.0457301699,
-0.0192033798,
-0.0255678892,
-0.0000450596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01853v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01853v1 | Improving Multilingual Instruction Finetuning via Linguistically Natural and Diverse Datasets | 2024-07-01T23:47:09 | 2024-07-01T23:47:09 | Sathish Reddy Indurthi, Wenxuan Zhou, Shamil Chollampatt, Ravi Agrawal, Kaiqiang Song, Lingxiao Zhao, Chenguang Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly enhanced
instruction-following capabilities. However, most Instruction Fine-Tuning (IFT)
datasets are predominantly in English, limiting model performance in other
languages. Traditional methods for creating multilingual IFT datasets such as
translating existing English IFT datasets or converting existing NLP datasets
into IFT datasets by templating, struggle to capture linguistic nuances and
ensure prompt (instruction) diversity. To address this issue, we propose a
novel method for collecting multilingual IFT datasets that preserves linguistic
naturalness and ensures prompt diversity. This approach leverages
English-focused LLMs, monolingual corpora, and a scoring function to create
high-quality, diversified IFT datasets in multiple languages. Experiments
demonstrate that LLMs finetuned using these IFT datasets show notable
improvements in both generative and discriminative tasks, indicating enhanced
language comprehension by LLMs in non-English contexts. Specifically, on the
multilingual summarization task, LLMs using our IFT dataset achieved 17.57% and
15.23% improvements over LLMs fine-tuned with translation-based and
template-based datasets, respectively. | [
0.0339305475,
0.0163812283,
-0.0095963096,
0.0238033868,
-0.0179088041,
0.0292194355,
0.027817307,
-0.0617412999,
-0.0132535063,
-0.0320652984,
-0.0510458797,
-0.0132690286,
0.0053487355,
-0.03990734,
0.0359891541,
-0.0563022196,
0.0447624139,
-0.0373049676,
-0.0442342311,
-0.0172237717,
0.0178190675,
0.0516040549,
0.0072985105,
0.0331003219,
0.0513372868,
-0.0236966759,
0.0082027148,
0.0152544295,
0.0354136005,
-0.01648812,
0.027771214,
0.0502153747,
0.0241810307,
0.0055154087,
0.0000020581,
-0.0260902196,
-0.0160589777,
-0.0163201522,
-0.0094994474,
0.0285067074,
0.0576458536,
-0.025846675,
0.0066944924,
0.0069617783,
-0.0036622847,
-0.0024175348,
0.0333320946,
0.0094843647,
0.0716503486,
0.0542704947,
0.0182073843,
-0.0262482204,
0.0091721909,
-0.0326403119,
-0.0109556736,
-0.0180938579,
-0.0055709337,
0.0128755923,
0.0018544727,
0.0192672443,
-0.0311718639,
0.0328101739,
0.0348116122,
0.0039305496,
-0.0365139358,
0.0105965408,
-0.0187155232,
-0.0117668565,
-0.0060605276,
0.084318772,
-0.0127463611,
0.0123193702,
-0.0212030709,
-0.0155142704,
-0.002958752,
-0.0129804527,
-0.068682611,
0.0520092696,
-0.0199701879,
0.024453843,
0.0618567616,
-0.0071282792,
0.0078719314,
0.0265090242,
-0.0154820392,
0.0221219193,
0.0205401815,
-0.0101057878,
-0.0057319468,
0.0217741299,
-0.0347200744,
-0.0289244223,
0.002443654,
0.0106346495,
-0.0485078432,
0.0222728532,
-0.0711748302,
-0.0330520794,
0.0398572609,
0.0177027918,
0.0632961765,
0.0369690694,
-0.0307874959,
0.044143945,
0.0009040455,
0.0420648344,
0.008756184,
0.0464542508,
-0.0733230561,
-0.0048748725,
-0.0438480452,
0.0059379614,
-0.0161738228,
0.0169713497,
-0.065772891,
0.0180168003,
-0.0277347472,
0.0191624854,
-0.0234904308,
-0.0143634817,
0.0254311096,
-0.0307570323,
-0.0562926754,
0.0220006853,
0.0008029997,
0.0456224754,
-0.0670192987,
0.0094543351,
0.0156367738,
-0.0639301315,
-0.0115537792,
0.0060876473,
-0.0098442286,
-0.0604586862,
0.0297551174,
0.0313277394,
-0.0194910951,
-0.0457455665,
-0.048713237,
-0.016307421,
-0.010170321,
-0.0723036975,
0.0129393684,
-0.0965166986,
0.0633348674,
0.0030265953,
0.0272456091,
-0.0320269614,
-0.0044180974,
0.0121969767,
-0.0178064257,
0.0303922053,
-0.0076277996,
0.0147473887,
-0.0093956552,
-0.0245795399,
0.0216708854,
0.0960542485,
0.0205464922,
-0.0345762372,
0.0666817874,
-0.0010777299,
-0.0407277048,
0.061910335,
0.0038887493,
0.0287774112,
0.014170615,
-0.0083042663,
-0.0139141371,
-0.0059590205,
0.0362892821,
0.0297438595,
-0.0239453856,
0.0290082358,
0.0355905518,
0.0243191253,
-0.0152949654,
-0.0047732014,
0.0711287037,
0.0480876006,
-0.0019448985,
0.0647467226,
-0.0382355042,
0.0302962065,
-0.0179781448,
0.0321594924,
0.0490644984,
0.0802752748,
-0.0410026275,
-0.0506016761,
0.019206211,
0.0054347785,
0.0133701134,
0.0418390781,
0.0362201929,
0.0102994153,
-0.0290047117,
0.0274302643,
0.0704439804,
-0.0500080809,
0.0330952406,
-0.0074125235,
0.0222129393,
0.0859476551,
0.0187580213,
-0.0163827799,
-0.0688685253,
-0.0000341492,
0.0515654571,
0.0406072177,
0.0469764061,
-0.0241512116,
0.036957629,
-0.073876515,
-0.033762835,
-0.0284811426,
0.0030748707,
0.0382051393,
0.0117289517,
-0.0195559971,
0.0057236687,
0.0033917611,
-0.0849760398,
0.0309715532,
-0.0669099241,
-0.021288693,
-0.009792868,
-0.0046054325,
0.0110065527,
0.0360064954,
-0.0026058343,
-0.0061420044,
0.0147113344,
-0.034964852,
0.0421112329,
-0.0075324178,
-0.0590642877,
-0.0491220616,
0.02036562,
-0.0386265293,
-0.0392073467,
-0.0030016685,
-0.0660216361,
-0.0481575318,
-0.0202319995,
-0.0185962841,
-0.0413140394,
-0.0253035948,
0.0021703572,
0.0004616515,
0.0256827008,
-0.0417277254,
0.0289908312,
-0.0082340436,
0.0538333356,
0.0569350794,
-0.0130698839,
0.0048768693,
-0.0240854286,
-0.0116646988,
0.0115161883,
-0.001103584,
0.0235548336,
0.0433597155,
0.0809779689,
-0.0621653013,
-0.025249932,
-0.0785770714,
0.0334970318,
-0.030188987,
0.0253614299,
0.0496814102,
0.0039602225,
-0.018958468,
0.0142808352,
-0.0252824053,
-0.0584106073,
0.0350592136,
0.040409226,
0.0010484669,
-0.0012284835,
0.0194878131,
-0.035618484,
-0.0386348106,
0.0274343137,
0.0052328683,
-0.0109538762,
-0.0012927633,
-0.0473429747,
0.0253016446,
-0.0293007512,
-0.0096990243,
0.0000636551,
-0.0451310463,
0.0072945217,
0.0105205942,
0.077433221,
0.0536376573,
-0.0201679077,
-0.0117768701,
0.0516560711,
-0.0370308161,
-0.0584115051,
0.0242014807,
-0.0109571433,
-0.0269282963,
-0.0301456843,
-0.0544273853,
-0.0148855811,
0.0534811765,
0.0023339195,
-0.0379610993,
-0.0750306696,
0.0033442329,
-0.0375927873,
-0.0149255851,
-0.0397241153,
0.0269306526,
-0.0067118751,
0.0303279571,
-0.0513861403,
-0.0289885327,
0.0897869393,
-0.0218347143,
-0.0156128071,
-0.0720763728,
0.0146062551,
-0.0388194881,
-0.0001637101,
-0.0051804734,
0.0075307214,
-0.0195754115,
-0.0027914071,
-0.0741189942,
0.0069870511,
0.0439181328,
-0.0236480683,
0.0820395276,
-0.0654339492,
-0.0291605853,
-0.0206212625,
-0.0061469828,
-0.0103530567,
-0.0196957719,
0.0125646964,
0.0017059156,
0.0442311205,
0.0142789297,
-0.0415533595,
-0.0298315305,
0.0585430749,
0.0532086305,
-0.0557314418,
0.0082613099,
-0.0292970575,
-0.0101082074,
0.0423270352,
0.0027826254,
0.0005085315,
-0.0644442514,
0.031752944,
0.0179771837,
0.0110531766,
-0.0311865024,
0.0384342298,
0.0456911549,
0.053668946,
-0.0078521846,
-0.0046251765,
0.0172188841,
0.1064785495,
-0.0432854071,
-0.0275945589,
0.1090807319,
0.0139168464,
-0.0428860001,
-0.0227603577,
-0.0088235829,
0.0418733172,
0.0320019126,
0.0150309158,
-0.0609869882,
-0.0368276313,
-0.0151391076,
0.0356506258,
-0.0133382026,
-0.0134854233,
-0.021553833,
-0.1315627992,
0.0040984456,
0.0300825015,
-0.0591761768,
-0.0260313693,
-0.0287545919,
-0.0090318555,
0.0029628105,
0.0649918765,
-0.0099389628,
-0.0194881372,
0.0159873106,
0.0277192779,
-0.0133757731,
-0.0793108344,
0.0297828726,
-0.0386480317,
0.0307626296,
0.0692401826,
0.0152318003,
-0.0173200276,
0.0073529482,
0.0287396219,
-0.0408289172,
-0.0097852536,
-0.0067450874,
0.0521353073,
0.0052101603,
-0.0181568954,
-0.0042111971,
0.0438665263,
-0.0242021047,
0.0094724353,
0.025767304,
0.0610819757,
0.0303009339,
0.0388289727,
-0.0087488974,
0.0129289925,
-0.0216692891,
0.0694739595,
0.0440221168,
-0.0564809218,
0.0264638141,
-0.035799671,
-0.0194648765,
-0.0992738008,
-0.0063562221,
0.0597446002,
-0.0871818662,
-0.0121759064,
-0.0597541966,
-0.0953934044,
0.0738382563,
-0.023707835,
0.0314819701,
0.016278116,
-0.0041616252,
-0.0218168814,
-0.0021651043,
0.0638352931,
-0.0338549055,
0.0151280621,
-0.0769275352,
-0.0576851219,
0.0093762623,
-0.0220026337,
-0.0036140659,
0.0522518679,
-0.0555304959,
-0.0700060278,
-0.0085505992,
0.0611723922,
0.0067718234,
0.0665932074,
0.0322919153,
-0.0213133469,
-0.0053031421,
0.0255532898,
-0.0265582595,
-0.0048127356,
0.0380449183,
0.0157063734,
-0.0106777763,
0.0337844193,
-0.049759157,
0.027011469,
0.0216690544,
0.0585031137,
0.0107149584,
-0.02586044,
0.029860355,
0.0360376686,
0.0104740076,
-0.0344133154,
-0.0058910809,
-0.0652746484,
-0.0091988603,
-0.0090815462,
-0.0296772458,
-0.0396252386,
0.0040559084,
0.017597463,
-0.0495523326,
-0.011362562,
0.0533473715,
0.0017505995,
0.0186274461,
-0.0749789774,
0.0251185112,
-0.0199639257,
0.0020113036,
0.0003211838,
0.0173101556,
-0.0286256988,
0.0090653058,
-0.013474172,
0.0190749019,
-0.0021626921,
0.0650015771,
0.0125130843,
0.0143135376,
0.0036252185,
0.0451512411,
-0.0147442538,
-0.0024050316,
-0.0271349549,
0.0016873588,
0.0652110428,
-0.0380515195,
0.073374562,
0.0180090964,
-0.0209656358,
-0.034906514,
0.0402242914,
0.0044671744,
-0.0271831397,
0.0117957462,
0.0283910986,
0.0131155215,
-0.0253925212,
0.0831197277,
-0.0417843051,
0.0145585472,
0.0179390814,
0.0296833944,
-0.029505372,
-0.0296347234,
-0.0058700433,
0.0075824754,
-0.0093150903,
0.0239176229,
-0.0377327166,
-0.0489496216,
-0.0283055231,
0.0204850528,
-0.004512107,
-0.0154022481,
0.0282626636,
0.0484282672,
-0.0487115383,
-0.0216971319,
-0.0430735722,
-0.0137617979,
0.0039846618,
-0.0196678545,
-0.0134089524,
-6.307941459e-33,
-0.058920119,
0.0161615703,
0.0107270926,
0.0030749512,
-0.0037420746,
0.0025539813,
-0.0243657399,
-0.0104263034,
-0.013980086,
0.0130668022,
-0.0099393604,
0.0016096843,
0.0143878767,
0.0574669056,
0.0218540262,
0.0076091709,
0.0442008786,
0.0119546456,
-0.0191916395,
0.062547639,
0.0304875094,
-0.0170794483,
0.0996085107,
0.0004870203,
0.0588440113,
-0.0272918064,
0.0233419444,
0.019283887,
-0.0155711239,
0.0634473786,
0.0102386586,
0.0579038747,
0.0216917172,
-0.0408423245,
-0.0629359707,
-0.0205024611,
-0.0699441656,
-0.0558664538,
0.0544113703,
-0.0006271396,
-0.0243740808,
-0.0669439211,
0.0089758746,
-0.0301992465,
-0.0147581287,
-0.0461242907,
0.0389923677,
-0.0456597954,
-0.0172289889,
-0.0257187728,
-0.058113452,
0.0109477071,
-0.0268716216,
-0.0477025732,
0.0248715822,
0.0606458001,
0.0131782033,
0.0012248573,
-0.0373925082,
0.0332374834,
0.0486259013,
0.0441986993,
0.0704097375,
-0.0092963623,
0.0154000241,
0.0152908489,
-0.00084876,
0.0160882603,
0.0387517288,
0.0005605921,
0.0277555492,
0.0052033607,
0.0222706012,
0.0622786991,
0.0168994833,
0.0336387828,
-0.0311922468,
0.0557603054,
-0.0029730299,
0.0111268377,
0.0361473635,
-0.0382642336,
-0.0117262779,
-0.0362161212,
-0.0601416416,
-0.0028032055,
-0.0137182046,
0.001425654,
0.021034928,
-0.0065747034,
-0.0221906733,
-0.0261688791,
0.0548437387,
-0.0114596728,
-0.0162602086,
0.026159035,
-0.0088317236,
-0.0018124729,
0.0111088669,
0.0305157769,
-0.0463428274,
-0.031100845,
0.0171317216,
-0.0477336347,
0.0054713157,
0.0183226429,
0.0679173768,
0.0054174238,
-0.0429847278,
0.0151692722,
-0.0463130437,
0.0619991198,
-0.0304583255,
0.0051429709,
0.0201026965,
0.0194897205,
-0.0279646963,
0.0754031315,
0.0484129302,
-0.0493070669,
-0.0328864045,
-0.026169857,
-0.0123943118,
0.0378512181,
-0.01920343,
0.0107794702,
-0.0526820458,
-0.0343505479,
0.0188657083,
-0.0238991845,
-0.0098548634,
0.0051532327,
2.599e-7,
0.0213405732,
0.0419967175,
0.0256471168,
0.0294296909,
-0.0111754593,
0.0104877297,
-0.0472964719,
-0.0077314228,
0.0429745913,
-0.0044477624,
0.0079163946,
0.0422396846,
0.0586394779,
0.0231323671,
-0.0738543943,
0.0075176666,
-0.020439012,
0.0330031738,
-0.0552818067,
-0.0091004418,
0.0229376592,
0.0937163755,
0.0022411142,
0.0027274385,
-0.0101999585,
-0.0161062554,
0.0394167639,
-0.0491346344,
-0.0261669978,
0.0367985293,
0.0010995883,
0.0094180182,
-0.0065128729,
0.0077060414,
-0.0174110793,
0.0022019602,
0.0056941612,
0.0593825988,
0.0229267254,
-0.0032010102,
0.0175933875,
-0.0265474003,
-0.0301666167,
-0.0421388447,
0.0506377593,
-0.0736014917,
-0.0091920923,
0.0211447403,
-0.0371032394,
0.0128688086,
0.0144627709,
-0.0270001441,
-0.0268828925,
0.050789427,
0.0253717583,
-0.0211088434,
-0.0156193683,
-0.0505463071,
-0.000069571,
0.0452992097,
-0.017473327,
-0.0315394029,
-0.0103622703,
-0.0188588724,
-0.0301296804,
-0.0602018572,
0.0103688771,
2.496317915e-34,
0.0370424837,
-0.0213407371,
0.0304024778,
-0.0052516353,
0.0267600939,
-0.0484129675,
-0.0419043712,
0.0173519868,
-0.0011773454,
-0.0649711564,
-0.0311746188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01850v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01850v1 | Purple-teaming LLMs with Adversarial Defender Training | 2024-07-01T23:25:30 | 2024-07-01T23:25:30 | Jingyan Zhou, Kun Li, Junan Li, Jiawen Kang, Minda Hu, Xixin Wu, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing efforts in safeguarding LLMs are limited in actively exposing the
vulnerabilities of the target LLM and readily adapting to newly emerging safety
risks. To address this, we present Purple-teaming LLMs with Adversarial
Defender training (PAD), a pipeline designed to safeguard LLMs by novelly
incorporating the red-teaming (attack) and blue-teaming (safety training)
techniques. In PAD, we automatically collect conversational data that cover the
vulnerabilities of an LLM around specific safety risks in a self-play manner,
where the attacker aims to elicit unsafe responses and the defender generates
safe responses to these attacks. We then update both modules in a generative
adversarial network style by training the attacker to elicit more unsafe
responses and updating the defender to identify them and explain the unsafe
reason. Experimental results demonstrate that PAD significantly outperforms
existing baselines in both finding effective attacks and establishing a robust
safe guardrail. Furthermore, our findings indicate that PAD excels in striking
a balance between safety and overall model quality. We also reveal key
challenges in safeguarding LLMs, including defending multi-turn attacks and the
need for more delicate strategies to identify specific risks. | [
-0.0167121161,
0.0664671734,
-0.0018613024,
0.0279000439,
-0.032368958,
-0.0335445181,
0.0162320286,
-0.0068892594,
-0.0233422685,
-0.0167471841,
-0.0156459734,
0.0143274497,
-0.0204088278,
-0.0025695364,
0.0812278613,
-0.011764653,
0.0709948763,
-0.0357602127,
-0.0188968815,
0.015501284,
0.0108527904,
-0.0312903859,
-0.0579820834,
0.0165391099,
-0.0018593912,
-0.0202373527,
-0.0417725481,
0.0299346186,
0.0788833573,
-0.0624031611,
0.0264193825,
-0.0046549467,
0.0214492362,
0.0147912968,
0.0000021807,
-0.0342556164,
-0.0443198755,
-0.002886286,
0.0012802049,
-0.019603882,
-0.019106308,
-0.0222553201,
-0.0087696854,
0.0676135868,
-0.0315668844,
0.0157050323,
0.0198665392,
0.1017530188,
0.0725182369,
0.0971971899,
0.0163273849,
0.0024843048,
0.0438724048,
-0.0343448147,
-0.0107251927,
-0.082978934,
-0.013140291,
-0.0252724756,
-0.0227489062,
0.0051953057,
-0.0062535154,
-0.0209797174,
0.012422015,
0.009357159,
-0.0246850085,
0.0488465205,
0.0277786981,
0.031276416,
-0.0281328876,
0.0770542994,
-0.0823611692,
0.0055014407,
0.0149810994,
-0.0098366495,
0.0263283029,
-0.002751207,
0.0023999943,
-0.0271115806,
-0.0253609717,
-0.0054893438,
-0.0233772937,
0.0059134453,
0.0576087609,
0.004470522,
0.0233714283,
0.0174364857,
-0.008462958,
-0.0168352015,
-0.0056835106,
-0.0336745381,
0.0255296994,
-0.0209275931,
-0.0294354558,
0.0416233465,
-0.002249131,
0.0050479327,
-0.0369071476,
-0.011139553,
0.0540837385,
-0.0051279948,
0.0555236712,
-0.0063728211,
-0.0205300003,
0.0050519407,
-0.0266744774,
-0.0132391229,
-0.0292502139,
0.040858604,
-0.0084991846,
0.0420743525,
-0.022293672,
0.0056071905,
0.0119437864,
0.008784052,
-0.0119129894,
0.0436788797,
-0.0243088808,
0.0215510651,
-0.0547402017,
0.0587970391,
-0.0003887895,
0.023956567,
-0.0020238974,
0.0072158268,
-0.0171425678,
-0.0518154129,
-0.0283955559,
-0.0170673113,
-0.0018214156,
-0.0658384115,
-0.0537437871,
0.0211439375,
-0.0628215298,
-0.0313047841,
-0.0002947004,
0.1530537307,
0.0161822699,
-0.0092968829,
-0.0408809185,
-0.061346177,
-0.0094926003,
-0.0149628166,
0.0414728858,
-0.0459697694,
0.0049574412,
-0.0454767235,
-0.0144339046,
-0.0724673942,
0.0149165466,
-0.0075024772,
0.0051008807,
0.0976444781,
0.0221308842,
-0.0281780176,
0.0052522486,
0.050212808,
-0.0447199866,
0.0474552885,
0.0374787413,
0.0242929421,
0.0202646628,
-0.0057549994,
0.0532336198,
0.0320555158,
0.0229115337,
0.0289621484,
0.0210644752,
-0.0079893004,
0.0092589343,
0.0452863984,
0.0025577855,
0.0160374343,
-0.0313334204,
-0.0777718201,
0.0840199515,
-0.0112489611,
-0.0100250719,
0.0297924299,
-0.0069430028,
0.0065280404,
-0.0249133855,
-0.0183985215,
-0.0392735898,
0.0541798696,
-0.0855561495,
-0.0332626849,
-0.037501432,
0.04094759,
-0.0492549203,
-0.0104884999,
0.0083633456,
-0.0221218858,
0.0228102393,
0.0046341522,
0.0047230371,
0.0266232118,
-0.0518713892,
0.0369751193,
0.0211676843,
-0.0319223292,
-0.0313650742,
-0.0954951271,
-0.0303231608,
0.0434441641,
0.0329383537,
-0.0389289819,
-0.0615736358,
-0.0680721551,
-0.0454586782,
0.0183049291,
-0.0041751657,
0.0204477292,
0.0574830957,
-0.0468820035,
-0.0144018168,
-0.0637613237,
-0.0093701528,
0.0453606769,
-0.0043748976,
-0.0195211563,
-0.0061383341,
0.0015883842,
-0.0184816774,
0.0462529808,
-0.0069668475,
-0.0553697608,
0.0376321971,
0.0202359054,
0.0544543974,
0.0069475509,
-0.0036983534,
0.0311654881,
0.0643036962,
-0.0065850685,
0.0029845536,
-0.0039505376,
-0.0181055572,
0.0058369194,
0.02580042,
-0.0328365415,
0.0032407243,
0.0383055545,
-0.0651749223,
0.0206710082,
0.018224217,
-0.0101544345,
-0.0550540984,
-0.004222895,
-0.0148719596,
0.0444866791,
-0.0074187545,
-0.0275402423,
0.0516400672,
-0.0231436826,
-0.0662541166,
-0.0340063274,
0.0065612774,
0.0027264007,
-0.0576005206,
0.0098286625,
0.0072740274,
-0.0366197303,
0.0257804617,
-0.0164686311,
-0.0017489287,
-0.0401683338,
-0.0161822997,
-0.0056737997,
0.0042240215,
-0.0378061086,
0.0201259367,
0.0243123285,
-0.0589089356,
-0.0151261995,
-0.0204721186,
0.0049650511,
0.0193592962,
0.0106307836,
-0.0118781254,
0.0278093982,
0.0024285209,
-0.0224205796,
-0.0208323263,
0.0169987381,
0.0108042564,
0.0439253002,
-0.0240724143,
-0.0196090434,
-0.0150994249,
-0.0005142012,
-0.024200175,
0.0276452638,
-0.0262607429,
-0.0583672039,
0.0509441122,
0.016241882,
-0.0125597995,
0.0355167389,
0.0540384576,
0.0506892353,
0.0879271403,
0.0105220713,
-0.0700069666,
0.0309314579,
-0.0027280769,
-0.0330936201,
-0.0496560372,
-0.0013447846,
0.0293954983,
0.0706379265,
0.0149767324,
0.0102546876,
-0.0194871351,
-0.0000657667,
0.0398247615,
-0.0396341085,
0.0054289172,
-0.0434426591,
-0.0260178111,
-0.0243580416,
-0.0207208581,
-0.0515804216,
0.0585650317,
-0.0085453987,
0.0140578402,
0.0106375758,
-0.0506585836,
0.0218945723,
0.0388526879,
-0.0430188105,
0.0024576203,
0.0262078289,
-0.0059502982,
-0.052212052,
-0.0664629266,
0.0442674197,
-0.0251522157,
0.0405979604,
-0.039568428,
-0.0111574149,
0.0073832292,
-0.0179564729,
-0.0814949498,
-0.0474393629,
-0.0412363783,
-0.0043562665,
-0.0398284793,
-0.0130327102,
-0.0131732831,
-0.0502079725,
0.0150814299,
-0.0113734556,
0.0098309657,
-0.0140992189,
-0.008425842,
-0.0026197229,
0.0138965556,
-0.0554253235,
0.0304868482,
-0.0351247415,
0.0882837996,
0.1031076536,
0.0089640841,
-0.0139284786,
-0.0648724139,
-0.0432315916,
0.0004269521,
-0.0200076755,
0.0038855104,
0.0292964932,
0.0230928641,
-0.0073863612,
0.0018734774,
0.0061061769,
-0.0109572671,
0.0159098711,
0.0432784595,
0.0020059349,
0.0263157673,
-0.0098177968,
0.0156906731,
-0.0626831204,
-0.0146023761,
0.0053058001,
0.0719888732,
-0.0110609327,
-0.0287008975,
-0.0136084463,
-0.0759394169,
-0.0007160304,
0.0186212137,
-0.0173153989,
0.0069964896,
0.0090596741,
-0.0153569663,
0.0092136459,
0.066470094,
0.0079296036,
0.0132133616,
-0.0176091753,
0.0372384861,
-0.0284552462,
-0.0399659947,
-0.0124633713,
-0.0507953763,
0.0377091281,
0.0704774186,
0.0103406664,
-0.0354457609,
-0.0156059274,
0.0304104742,
0.0056551853,
0.0378924683,
0.0054791826,
0.0817734152,
-0.0122533813,
0.0000359365,
0.0143539496,
0.0378235169,
0.0353719257,
-0.0460449457,
0.063315168,
0.0038486063,
-0.0606212318,
-0.0076853461,
-0.0197921824,
0.0414244421,
0.0486475267,
0.0505759791,
0.006624931,
-0.0141768819,
0.0156182246,
-0.0520312339,
0.0176372658,
-0.0815495923,
-0.0489316732,
-0.0163675882,
0.0299928635,
-0.0007708033,
-0.0571825467,
-0.0109316129,
-0.0329411738,
0.0185486637,
-0.0096452218,
-0.026860863,
-0.0755403265,
0.0490795597,
-0.0264658723,
-0.016730858,
0.0195463393,
0.0381955765,
-0.0265837051,
0.0119031761,
0.0120716123,
-0.0634893104,
-0.0211756378,
0.0327600129,
-0.0342513956,
-0.0675103813,
-0.0053784964,
0.0946283862,
0.0205016248,
0.0223086569,
-0.0196380056,
-0.0256235935,
0.0721377283,
0.0742542669,
-0.0203823056,
-0.0250308178,
0.0939776301,
-0.0015883143,
0.0113970805,
0.0122953076,
-0.0198682919,
-0.0085705826,
0.0596880689,
0.0061115539,
-0.0762170851,
-0.0301331766,
0.010880365,
0.007272861,
0.0674164444,
-0.0329677351,
0.0500981063,
0.0390322022,
0.0421100631,
-0.0029455593,
0.018390622,
0.0059027132,
0.0356483087,
0.0200666133,
-0.0534922294,
0.0159125067,
0.0317383669,
0.0220817141,
0.0258883908,
-0.0271027144,
0.0555453561,
0.0315374322,
0.0102011031,
0.0135346018,
0.0158390515,
0.0136598479,
0.0178126749,
0.0174935963,
-0.0004278023,
0.0378705002,
0.0372731276,
0.0019119466,
0.008163264,
-0.0164827239,
0.0498671085,
-0.0483888015,
-0.0727614388,
0.0314158425,
0.0570480488,
0.0627921671,
0.0705206022,
-0.0093998052,
-0.014343285,
0.0012962825,
0.0015979217,
0.0090550883,
-0.0319975019,
-0.0195155945,
0.0480204597,
0.0118136797,
0.013113657,
0.0022654238,
0.0596997812,
0.0080327271,
0.0788070261,
-0.0037399924,
0.0158365276,
-0.0298420899,
-0.0216938797,
0.0373010598,
0.0297128018,
-0.0148788048,
-0.0499898195,
-0.0546320118,
-0.0414047912,
0.0121287415,
0.0248404033,
0.0177921336,
0.0104277013,
0.0146263074,
-0.0014039463,
0.0100485273,
0.0360559635,
-0.0302773993,
0.0064791958,
0.0180149823,
-0.0437834114,
0.022795191,
-6.182896043e-33,
0.0437846556,
-0.0501555949,
-0.0196243897,
-0.0265218206,
-0.017335413,
0.0033813131,
-0.0176628269,
-0.0261416361,
-0.0028482773,
-0.0109923584,
-0.0067589176,
-0.0075954306,
0.0009234119,
-0.0142345009,
-0.0233181212,
-0.0934333205,
0.0176693983,
-0.0327294022,
-0.0158686209,
0.0304302108,
0.0376596414,
0.0096801938,
0.0178539846,
-0.0910565704,
0.0293710064,
-0.0046076742,
-0.062607564,
0.0111663723,
-0.0596301369,
0.0293953307,
0.0311455131,
0.0172239263,
-0.0073419097,
-0.0020908378,
0.008135723,
0.0298212506,
-0.0166394319,
-0.0234444477,
-0.0307010096,
-0.060640458,
-0.0637452975,
-0.0578336269,
0.0230673384,
-0.0043161074,
0.0056207278,
-0.0236551818,
-0.026230881,
-0.0006257782,
0.0019528373,
-0.0437430143,
0.0271153748,
0.0035887377,
-0.0387737527,
-0.0384086967,
0.0043948563,
0.0142537216,
0.0293720271,
-0.0157807954,
-0.0642655194,
0.0219753385,
-0.0324316137,
-0.0335498415,
0.0376120694,
0.022721732,
-0.0043234685,
0.0656621158,
-0.0535127223,
-0.0122878496,
-0.0383513942,
0.0006240763,
-0.0178681016,
0.1013056785,
0.0868767202,
0.0376105681,
0.0237268731,
-0.0430337675,
-0.0954061896,
0.037814714,
0.0461718068,
0.0543572865,
0.0005008712,
-0.0002347067,
-0.0396127254,
0.016842328,
-0.0009039492,
-0.0341396481,
-0.0028933359,
-0.0403572172,
0.011393059,
0.027151905,
-0.0369302556,
-0.0277370811,
-0.0032157083,
-0.0127710728,
0.0328349546,
0.0266430564,
0.0377314761,
-0.029102657,
-0.0149403857,
-0.0367104635,
-0.0171479974,
-0.0084279142,
0.0029546872,
-0.0569814704,
0.0398630239,
-0.0115794763,
0.0313188843,
0.0431482457,
-0.0432394482,
0.0026476213,
-0.0330813229,
0.087981537,
-0.0023804044,
-0.0268100221,
-0.0143667692,
-0.0067706788,
-0.0023924534,
-0.0046768892,
0.024783263,
-0.0194150265,
-0.0224583838,
0.0363579579,
-0.0601052456,
0.0479416363,
-0.0073292139,
0.0347055756,
0.0187284164,
0.0094899032,
0.051323045,
-0.0713792294,
-0.006698465,
-0.0323962122,
2.934e-7,
-0.044773329,
0.0066395211,
0.0305731483,
0.0337069035,
0.0169636868,
0.0662338436,
-0.0466385186,
0.0865733027,
0.0060849576,
-0.0568429604,
0.0071241064,
0.0338971131,
0.0472108871,
0.0663727447,
-0.0150052551,
-0.0236866288,
-0.069724232,
0.0193815716,
-0.0315348916,
-0.0189235676,
0.0818442479,
0.0372946113,
0.0173369553,
-0.0229624137,
0.0323076211,
-0.0150267156,
0.0419656262,
-0.0359287858,
0.025015736,
-0.0187835693,
0.075819537,
0.011483592,
-0.0199109036,
0.039806217,
-0.0504398495,
-0.0346182548,
-0.0632666871,
0.039573133,
0.0147991478,
-0.0500254259,
-0.0197839513,
-0.0314709172,
0.0240450371,
0.0070191324,
0.0549982674,
-0.0152326878,
-0.004672932,
0.0178596526,
-0.0322204717,
-0.0121963052,
0.0163679868,
-0.0268688221,
-0.0075296005,
-0.021805387,
-0.0074737016,
0.005589854,
0.029481886,
-0.048561208,
-0.0239509083,
-0.0112681566,
-0.0027861556,
-0.05935698,
0.0419164561,
0.0406196937,
0.0289211981,
0.0043602553,
-0.0381292589,
2.432040644e-34,
-0.0304537397,
-0.03949783,
-0.0195172876,
0.0083117587,
0.0267254263,
0.0140526164,
-0.0145301642,
-0.0156932939,
0.030382961,
0.0223539378,
-0.0153735913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01834v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01834v1 | A Study of Nationality Bias in Names and Perplexity using Off-the-Shelf Affect-related Tweet Classifiers | 2024-07-01T22:17:17 | 2024-07-01T22:17:17 | Valentin Barriere, Sebastian Cifuentes | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we apply a method to quantify biases associated with named
entities from various countries. We create counterfactual examples with small
perturbations on target-domain data instead of relying on templates or specific
datasets for bias detection. On widely used classifiers for subjectivity
analysis, including sentiment, emotion, hate speech, and offensive text using
Twitter data, our results demonstrate positive biases related to the language
spoken in a country across all classifiers studied. Notably, the presence of
certain country names in a sentence can strongly influence predictions, up to a
23\% change in hate speech detection and up to a 60\% change in the prediction
of negative emotions such as anger. We hypothesize that these biases stem from
the training data of pre-trained language models (PLMs) and find correlations
between affect predictions and PLMs likelihood in English and unknown languages
like Basque and Maori, revealing distinct patterns with exacerbate
correlations. Further, we followed these correlations in-between counterfactual
examples from a same sentence to remove the syntactical component, uncovering
interesting results suggesting the impact of the pre-training data was more
important for English-speaking-country names. Our anonymized code is
[https://anonymous.4open.science/r/biases_ppl-576B/README.md](available here). | [
0.0443994403,
0.1055501923,
-0.0358166099,
0.0140024032,
-0.010998806,
0.0657563955,
0.0411430895,
0.0014062363,
0.0421726182,
-0.0254894868,
0.0127323233,
-0.0147935189,
-0.013841765,
-0.0099059651,
-0.0019473657,
-0.0604913309,
0.0224417932,
0.0548604913,
0.0610661134,
-0.0570226572,
0.0225217603,
0.0262223817,
0.0136894844,
0.0186325796,
-0.0328763761,
0.0350237601,
0.0264510792,
0.0188611988,
0.0264068451,
-0.0134252775,
0.0510454513,
0.0487660728,
-0.0485352315,
0.0451116562,
0.0000018233,
-0.0466376916,
-0.027344523,
-0.0241848845,
0.0534798652,
-0.0207241625,
0.0863416493,
-0.0263382066,
-0.0180527177,
0.0035596578,
-0.0329892449,
-0.0171624925,
0.0730456486,
0.027660124,
0.0418722332,
0.0786724389,
-0.0217275489,
0.0082596829,
-0.0442659706,
-0.0177655537,
0.0307775009,
0.0183722191,
0.0393102095,
-0.0335347094,
-0.0891741663,
-0.0528070964,
-0.0221669283,
-0.0034940622,
-0.0182112921,
0.0587202273,
-0.0477376357,
0.0011103837,
-0.0440451913,
-0.0423162058,
0.0346324183,
0.0140810767,
0.0047355834,
-0.0308597516,
0.0074511906,
-0.0032223868,
0.0040433765,
-0.0066995504,
0.0012932402,
0.0003633254,
-0.0061677117,
0.0269651897,
0.027192669,
0.0153326513,
0.0106532238,
0.0826683939,
0.0084541393,
0.0556692779,
-0.0072621168,
-0.0522245467,
0.0167958308,
0.0560751595,
0.0027272326,
-0.0311344676,
0.0361526273,
-0.0258650761,
0.0022884291,
0.0042686546,
-0.0399882197,
-0.0594426058,
-0.0082568824,
-0.0976958498,
-0.0442319922,
0.0304214451,
-0.026056977,
0.0040795873,
0.0145054683,
0.0256635379,
-0.0009717115,
-0.0099742329,
-0.0060664481,
-0.018997537,
-0.0479436107,
0.0226400793,
0.0324799493,
-0.0052939933,
0.0037197319,
0.0577308163,
-0.0811929777,
-0.0121393725,
-0.0482660942,
-0.0156294834,
-0.0222011488,
-0.0035339708,
-0.0047658538,
0.0020564212,
-0.0455736555,
0.051446382,
-0.0443966128,
0.0038625286,
-0.0820126981,
-0.0498029478,
0.0239630509,
0.0058879834,
-0.004661012,
-0.0289448332,
0.0561256818,
0.052663248,
0.0468108244,
-0.0274708178,
-0.0104516856,
-0.0163227841,
0.0065441816,
-0.0544123501,
-0.0052222898,
-0.0443610251,
0.0330774859,
0.0367479622,
0.0011109079,
-0.0683999807,
0.021560261,
0.0128372367,
-0.0699432045,
0.0242600217,
-0.0046902602,
0.0132343704,
0.0127490032,
0.0104786856,
0.0096738776,
0.0666088834,
0.0043050842,
0.029296238,
0.0689936653,
-0.0054061608,
0.0207346529,
0.0282238517,
0.0204469878,
0.0033714259,
-0.0363274477,
-0.0127082607,
-0.0449847877,
-0.0451039858,
0.0367207788,
0.011268747,
0.0125694703,
-0.0003488975,
0.0297858845,
0.0272343345,
-0.0486608744,
0.0429317765,
0.0060066683,
0.0131929414,
-0.0182294343,
-0.0091641806,
-0.0486970097,
-0.0104969488,
-0.0494477078,
-0.0254618693,
-0.0075137522,
0.05885043,
-0.02288175,
-0.0327139013,
0.004712319,
-0.0122581627,
0.0356033854,
0.0028556339,
0.0255744569,
-0.0268447138,
-0.0046980204,
0.0304683186,
0.0691879764,
-0.0875931457,
0.0009015605,
-0.0077109965,
-0.0016755358,
0.0424638912,
-0.0256523583,
-0.0074034641,
-0.0099980058,
-0.0119060278,
0.0013552295,
0.0330567695,
0.0157499854,
0.0131260883,
0.0134608531,
-0.0225008354,
0.005333798,
0.0309302807,
0.0253886916,
0.028167434,
0.0678586364,
0.0763149709,
0.0052656541,
-0.0126673253,
-0.0314674154,
0.0005309561,
-0.0212071221,
-0.0178669337,
0.0249235183,
0.027247075,
0.019079145,
0.0339442492,
-0.030803632,
-0.0534230657,
-0.0049647605,
0.00277919,
0.0107451063,
0.0585471392,
0.0153665505,
-0.0243237577,
0.0193576571,
-0.0325298309,
-0.0302890502,
0.0498528481,
-0.0329837911,
0.0041656545,
0.0628523752,
0.0193253774,
0.029622931,
-0.0180933978,
-0.0053942134,
-0.080961585,
0.0483689755,
-0.011492854,
0.0512740538,
-0.0205600504,
0.0215342585,
-0.0198352449,
-0.0784954354,
0.0311836116,
0.0264206417,
-0.0746900216,
0.0009990836,
-0.0006268672,
-0.0179548692,
0.0018009522,
-0.0107089728,
-0.0285610501,
-0.0271115229,
-0.0830318183,
0.0098274974,
-0.0122111635,
-0.016108904,
-0.0108584631,
0.0307519194,
-0.0426552519,
0.011304236,
-0.0218840335,
-0.0478883237,
0.0279463548,
0.0433956608,
-0.0092092352,
-0.0549226552,
0.0064652083,
-0.0374223068,
-0.0162980463,
-0.0465866476,
0.0283529609,
0.0115462225,
-0.0421900488,
0.0068520894,
0.0013443966,
-0.0728996471,
0.0016596477,
-0.0064371084,
-0.0721863806,
-0.0206041355,
0.0313097462,
-0.0137505541,
0.0546610318,
0.0129184937,
0.0391693339,
0.0222649109,
-0.0196504164,
-0.0054302528,
0.0242618732,
-0.0300555788,
0.0372030176,
-0.0206856225,
-0.0788897201,
-0.0394400693,
0.0730365217,
0.0000180924,
-0.0213475469,
-0.0315909833,
0.0403049774,
-0.0536740758,
-0.0333123207,
0.0087973392,
-0.0220963005,
0.0108335949,
0.0390806273,
0.0021213593,
-0.0790180266,
0.0559619665,
0.032495454,
0.0171749238,
-0.0568620153,
-0.019445166,
-0.0045646243,
0.0571359172,
0.0147453677,
0.0223478489,
0.0006632272,
0.013404333,
0.004724781,
-0.0460249819,
-0.0067536831,
-0.0332393013,
-0.0196248293,
-0.003447274,
-0.0352947116,
0.012983988,
-0.0419320352,
-0.0244860537,
-0.073563002,
-0.0708993748,
-0.0490433462,
0.0180417653,
-0.0311021041,
0.024990011,
-0.0018333587,
0.0365804471,
-0.0890457183,
-0.0201777089,
-0.0002741306,
0.0414303876,
-0.0159871113,
0.0104545392,
-0.0332053676,
0.0268228315,
-0.0058552385,
-0.0410130545,
0.0011219113,
0.0074022226,
0.0199486744,
0.0285029765,
0.010056559,
0.0062955674,
-0.0058822245,
-0.0298449621,
-0.0476116873,
0.0313238576,
-0.0014358311,
0.030378744,
0.1041874439,
0.0284043252,
-0.0389484763,
-0.0044376263,
0.0073381606,
0.0116021121,
0.0197019614,
0.021673549,
-0.0531052612,
0.0122848516,
-0.0069816858,
-0.0093840463,
-0.0745498613,
-0.0452037826,
-0.0145648522,
-0.099793978,
-0.0079241917,
-0.0070489743,
-0.0102444896,
-0.0109357266,
-0.0039817002,
-0.0005646704,
-0.0328562893,
-0.0169794727,
-0.0432811007,
0.0286699161,
0.0397375561,
0.0122868875,
-0.060161896,
-0.0410297215,
0.0132338656,
-0.0311625972,
0.0226604994,
0.0296948291,
0.0670391545,
-0.0354285687,
-0.0249519926,
0.0039716153,
-0.0057214089,
-0.0110298023,
-0.0450361893,
0.0739289671,
0.0010475104,
-0.0479878522,
-0.0506891459,
0.0144905346,
-0.0050886329,
0.0229573026,
0.0008380808,
0.0196671002,
0.0272315573,
-0.006972603,
-0.0212559272,
0.0199135114,
0.0163173713,
0.0680211559,
0.0150463358,
-0.0832292214,
-0.0056398804,
-0.0333106667,
0.0140868602,
-0.0193174332,
-0.0662867203,
-0.01599974,
-0.0119163338,
-0.0932368934,
-0.0329793282,
-0.0463716462,
0.0172989015,
0.0313444659,
-0.006571142,
-0.0266525112,
-0.0105398437,
-0.0014765452,
-0.0341919512,
0.030224001,
0.0161020104,
0.0216587055,
0.0194557533,
-0.0171649102,
0.0378591195,
-0.0002038013,
-0.0093321679,
-0.0186815448,
-0.0438395627,
-0.0585066229,
0.0657038689,
0.0444466881,
0.0153145632,
0.0416861922,
0.0005005893,
-0.0541729294,
0.0209750235,
0.0849765018,
-0.0085102571,
0.0247017965,
0.0460963249,
0.042362649,
0.023225762,
0.0241073221,
-0.0068743029,
0.0575124398,
0.0610313416,
-0.0470497496,
-0.0322591104,
0.0006266969,
-0.0211677756,
0.0066750022,
0.0935134515,
-0.0179586019,
-0.0583595261,
-0.0144496551,
-0.024185786,
-0.0120799923,
-0.036890462,
0.000899974,
-0.049334053,
0.0261820164,
0.0307024922,
-0.0738766119,
-0.0244080555,
-0.0503057204,
0.0067443978,
-0.0290530846,
0.0497840196,
0.0185956322,
0.0367228352,
0.0155371372,
-0.003319399,
0.005204584,
0.0054582767,
0.0289849658,
0.0091788536,
-0.0089935847,
0.0024568657,
-0.0080064749,
0.0103752688,
0.0192546789,
-0.0224659536,
-0.0106193395,
0.0261661019,
-0.0069478741,
-0.0187280234,
0.0245049745,
-0.0811878666,
0.0491185077,
-0.0013908875,
-0.0003103927,
0.0015069492,
-0.0241722688,
-0.0162463263,
-0.046745114,
0.0071526701,
-0.0257667731,
-0.0419605747,
0.017888695,
0.0539636016,
-0.0441803038,
0.0471724756,
0.0615457185,
-0.0399689749,
-0.0096117845,
0.0061064577,
0.0472292043,
-0.0143722799,
-0.0039148824,
0.0284437146,
-0.0731152222,
-0.0553305484,
0.0429495461,
-0.0610865131,
0.028772682,
-0.0104548577,
-0.0111206463,
0.0708576068,
-0.0231619589,
0.049557481,
-0.0208164435,
-0.006857147,
-0.0497116819,
-0.0558746867,
-0.0001347612,
-5.812444876e-33,
0.0113663636,
-0.0061570113,
-0.0355268158,
0.0298080165,
0.0011968638,
0.004993177,
0.008884958,
0.0540980659,
-0.0246326569,
0.0398723967,
-0.0192384012,
0.0178571641,
0.0171145648,
0.0111978296,
0.0073212795,
-0.0279544629,
0.0004359354,
0.0244285408,
0.0012214248,
0.028458314,
0.0167592634,
0.0257691182,
0.0713633373,
-0.1263083518,
0.040589992,
0.0017496722,
-0.0189431105,
-0.0016859822,
0.0613880306,
0.0343053415,
-0.0074591474,
0.0916208625,
0.0292911157,
0.0104402201,
0.0093349647,
-0.0101856934,
0.0067688674,
-0.0553314909,
0.00962348,
0.0207168516,
0.0555755533,
-0.0278796721,
0.0266341511,
0.0208465848,
-0.0773773864,
0.0139116338,
0.0304134507,
-0.0010897219,
0.0426171795,
-0.0203666147,
-0.0344634019,
0.031298086,
-0.0206258651,
0.0256161895,
0.0320431925,
0.0464363806,
0.0434029177,
0.0214384217,
-0.0234687291,
0.0386800505,
0.0236125458,
0.0052207815,
0.0099497559,
-0.0259538405,
0.0144363921,
0.0623307601,
0.0803048834,
0.0624226816,
-0.0203138925,
0.0267119352,
0.0401397496,
-0.0045957854,
0.0233146623,
0.1156268194,
0.0128742242,
-0.0831340328,
-0.0394434072,
0.0105773937,
0.0751752853,
-0.0210830104,
0.0322907008,
-0.0392065085,
-0.0391889066,
-0.0365367867,
-0.0065307082,
-0.0756556615,
-0.0179576185,
-0.0225952324,
-0.002916737,
-0.0281238072,
-0.0157974958,
0.0003692108,
0.0162718464,
-0.0248067807,
-0.0361025892,
0.0569671392,
-0.0566604249,
0.0153912641,
0.0218158234,
0.0224065762,
-0.0168918073,
-0.014748632,
-0.0359777622,
0.0113564264,
0.0456104614,
-0.0096654929,
0.0321481116,
0.0218060482,
-0.0868286416,
0.0105136819,
-0.0023311838,
0.0454712994,
-0.0114463568,
0.0201329291,
-0.0022481505,
0.0284284465,
-0.0107765412,
-0.044020351,
0.0610652007,
0.0032044479,
-0.025693303,
-0.0203250535,
-0.0290270597,
0.0378830098,
-0.0336165018,
-0.0429086909,
0.0232713986,
-0.0152225187,
0.0207813717,
-0.0597243309,
-0.0153630795,
-0.0483890139,
2.586e-7,
0.0090554701,
0.0879454985,
-0.0431658365,
-0.0041952124,
0.018479649,
0.0504027754,
-0.0018106174,
0.0238322113,
0.0334712975,
0.004686683,
-0.0173528325,
-0.00927174,
0.0270547885,
0.0545220561,
-0.0933444127,
0.0216459185,
-0.0158994924,
0.0295726825,
-0.0675719306,
0.0426425375,
0.0045165271,
0.0887385681,
0.0802063718,
-0.015611928,
-0.0162677635,
0.0072685434,
0.0196203627,
-0.0803013593,
0.0072899214,
0.0008676501,
0.0111750597,
-0.0250116549,
0.0268732477,
0.0272883307,
-0.0122611942,
0.0144193647,
-0.0034611099,
0.0147161772,
0.0357142128,
0.0331009515,
0.0127204917,
-0.010904057,
-0.0112586822,
-0.0464232489,
0.0402788483,
0.0073201801,
-0.0469421409,
-0.0475707427,
-0.0126815531,
-0.015276283,
0.0919233859,
-0.000289094,
-0.0329371989,
0.015128633,
0.0241554584,
-0.0016748586,
-0.0178411528,
-0.0439779349,
-0.0206623338,
-0.0178355873,
0.0051177591,
-0.0435235165,
0.0121373832,
0.0194463171,
0.0312289465,
-0.0000732355,
0.0675964728,
2.137023245e-34,
0.0165503528,
0.0028829407,
-0.0137700308,
-0.009353173,
0.0384735838,
0.0201473162,
0.0166111849,
-0.0046620835,
0.0110615613,
-0.0229467116,
0.0344395041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01824v1 | Empathic Grounding: Explorations using Multimodal Interaction and Large Language Models with Conversational Agents | 2024-07-01T21:46:30 | 2024-07-01T21:46:30 | Mehdi Arjmand, Farnaz Nouraei, Ian Steenstra, Timothy Bickmore | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.RO | We introduce the concept of "empathic grounding" in conversational agents as
an extension of Clark's conceptualization of grounding in conversation in which
the grounding criterion includes listener empathy for the speaker's affective
state. Empathic grounding is generally required whenever the speaker's emotions
are foregrounded and can make the grounding process more efficient and reliable
by communicating both propositional and affective understanding. Both speaker
expressions of affect and listener empathic grounding can be multimodal,
including facial expressions and other nonverbal displays. Thus, models of
empathic grounding for embodied agents should be multimodal to facilitate
natural and efficient communication. We describe a multimodal model that takes
as input user speech and facial expression to generate multimodal grounding
moves for a listening agent using a large language model. We also describe a
testbed to evaluate approaches to empathic grounding, in which a humanoid robot
interviews a user about a past episode of pain and then has the user rate their
perception of the robot's empathy. We compare our proposed model to one that
only generates non-affective grounding cues in a between-subjects experiment.
Findings demonstrate that empathic grounding increases user perceptions of
empathy, understanding, emotional intelligence, and trust. Our work highlights
the role of emotion awareness and multimodality in generating appropriate
grounding moves for conversational agents. | [
0.0436194018,
0.0007324941,
-0.0209490098,
-0.0031037449,
0.0000152841,
-0.0102066332,
0.0463763699,
-0.007391626,
0.0134908967,
-0.0204455554,
-0.0397857949,
0.0221933331,
-0.001041312,
0.0041144607,
0.0323216021,
-0.070936203,
0.0041658194,
0.0327020213,
0.0612528995,
0.0207570419,
0.0437990539,
0.0215669889,
-0.0392670743,
0.0511822999,
-0.0871349797,
-0.0206556264,
-0.0569362678,
0.0249606352,
0.0296429209,
-0.0506471395,
-0.0227912161,
0.012153211,
0.0590167977,
-0.033079531,
0.0000020521,
-0.0370100588,
0.014684272,
-0.0143838823,
-0.0072818794,
-0.0444187708,
0.0435666889,
-0.0289996359,
0.0036994761,
-0.0019474399,
-0.0372066908,
-0.0314346254,
0.0515637733,
0.0850299373,
0.0865460634,
0.0064749741,
-0.0424036793,
0.017148545,
0.0011334806,
0.0227235388,
-0.0260052849,
-0.0070027914,
-0.010986397,
0.0395693555,
0.0284201913,
-0.0563837923,
-0.0680078715,
-0.0216097236,
0.0077653057,
-0.0248959586,
0.0422427282,
0.0416465439,
0.0294523351,
-0.0545495562,
-0.0282990057,
0.1069495007,
0.0369522907,
0.0413834639,
-0.0000367969,
0.0248288978,
0.0350598022,
0.0243865643,
-0.012768697,
0.00337509,
-0.0191629622,
-0.0036995143,
-0.0252887942,
0.0245178565,
-0.0136907417,
0.0349680223,
0.0124058248,
0.0423819311,
-0.0152483089,
-0.0020411189,
0.0606961586,
-0.0196428634,
-0.0128056975,
-0.0413634256,
0.0170667265,
0.0276571736,
-0.0350745618,
0.0224901438,
-0.063085869,
0.0278615877,
-0.0255897697,
-0.0240463521,
-0.0078914277,
0.0482638776,
-0.0182492677,
0.0107422313,
0.0288959648,
0.0156687964,
0.0110974312,
0.0275907665,
0.0097976625,
0.0265991464,
0.0024070479,
-0.0000413051,
-0.0373443849,
0.0101838158,
-0.0349437967,
-0.0465761535,
-0.0052270819,
0.0364327058,
-0.0441730171,
0.0113360677,
-0.0670423508,
0.003260657,
-0.0084713353,
0.0349593945,
-0.0045460686,
0.0191247687,
-0.0461204425,
0.0432772711,
0.0370499343,
-0.0762603283,
0.0073772757,
0.0024225099,
0.0128354514,
0.0043409555,
0.015481405,
0.0341501795,
0.0078053554,
-0.0247521121,
-0.007879816,
0.0088739572,
0.0041461401,
-0.0407224484,
0.0083853761,
0.010614085,
0.009704154,
-0.0144200949,
0.0271178689,
-0.0201082062,
0.0311454125,
-0.0058941985,
-0.0106471805,
0.0883111283,
0.0058003687,
0.0182372052,
0.0225405265,
0.0227150004,
0.00607588,
0.0096044904,
0.046565596,
-0.0068911887,
0.0302803889,
-0.0398778841,
0.014318238,
-0.0181077644,
-0.0115763051,
-0.0100890147,
0.0280136354,
-0.0703406557,
-0.0168808848,
0.0655795634,
0.0259794518,
0.0308253765,
-0.0274301935,
-0.0137686394,
0.0741758421,
0.0745988861,
-0.0635151565,
0.0346006304,
-0.0042085433,
-0.0215269625,
-0.0044511813,
0.0224789809,
-0.0306670014,
0.0589308366,
-0.0126396129,
-0.0280834511,
-0.0254649017,
0.0053518009,
-0.0374085009,
0.0047189421,
0.0036035515,
-0.0067272997,
0.0928433016,
-0.0014490993,
0.0097559532,
-0.0140556488,
-0.0418476798,
-0.0203910489,
0.0000915797,
-0.0897077471,
-0.0154069569,
-0.0226183068,
-0.0169734955,
0.064805761,
-0.0064037344,
-0.0013507539,
-0.0178337581,
-0.003750985,
0.0247786473,
0.0348303877,
0.0018151029,
-0.0014268395,
0.0366600603,
-0.0263356119,
-0.0005539945,
-0.0150012262,
-0.0052296785,
0.0338238291,
-0.0840516835,
0.0552946106,
-0.0186785609,
-0.0199197233,
0.0511999428,
0.0302924905,
-0.0340103395,
0.0396786518,
-0.0591461919,
0.0210235994,
0.0280172788,
0.0276322179,
-0.022435477,
-0.0029620281,
0.0403261036,
-0.0108889313,
-0.0244151447,
0.1152935028,
-0.0155302873,
0.030757824,
0.0283108335,
-0.0786552653,
0.0183522571,
0.0165787246,
0.0173093919,
-0.0126125664,
0.0396592468,
-0.0469216146,
0.0648548901,
-0.0428033397,
0.0053889146,
-0.0049947179,
0.0153937377,
0.0361357704,
-0.0382988304,
-0.0054366579,
-0.007769139,
-0.0357836746,
0.0010787743,
-0.0038951887,
-0.0375455469,
-0.0101889335,
0.0548582785,
0.0202201344,
-0.0057585272,
-0.0126408599,
-0.0154425343,
-0.0761925429,
-0.0203184225,
-0.1626780629,
-0.0428497829,
0.0093602557,
-0.0504377969,
-0.0130829737,
-0.0122437673,
-0.0146423094,
-0.0199975483,
-0.0283117499,
0.0485608131,
0.0355773419,
0.0003540012,
0.0118743638,
0.0128447218,
-0.0156625211,
-0.0473699085,
0.0198542811,
-0.0178440008,
0.026582459,
0.0005408745,
-0.0166128594,
-0.0243413225,
0.0245352872,
-0.0721537843,
0.0614869148,
-0.0195353702,
-0.0816106051,
0.0198282953,
0.0071199099,
0.0148556689,
0.047530897,
0.0338570997,
0.0818748251,
0.0527165607,
-0.022128433,
-0.0386432484,
0.028110303,
0.0259093642,
0.0273139123,
-0.0230687428,
-0.0275749769,
-0.0022716497,
0.0258004535,
0.0299932212,
0.0383392274,
-0.0475602597,
-0.0072497842,
0.0292084068,
-0.0824685171,
0.009627209,
-0.0377687179,
-0.0028279859,
0.0025273166,
0.0067986245,
-0.04529652,
0.0704654083,
-0.0050369957,
-0.0476870686,
0.0179325417,
-0.002182401,
0.0230156351,
0.0549624786,
-0.0653297156,
0.0266355816,
-0.0011570812,
0.0000510468,
-0.0047100978,
-0.0386847518,
0.0081946114,
-0.0280058086,
0.0022172306,
-0.0367038809,
-0.0247809161,
0.0541114099,
-0.0044234027,
-0.0306306165,
-0.0215856303,
-0.0538641177,
-0.0015666742,
-0.0107038254,
-0.0007867494,
-0.0128882257,
-0.0042387713,
0.0576852411,
0.0150619643,
0.0042261058,
0.0041690306,
-0.0092626046,
-0.0688554719,
0.0365010649,
0.0514395684,
0.0085618142,
-0.0236252677,
0.1019486561,
0.03987021,
0.0507964008,
-0.0155026298,
-0.0076795486,
0.0283432454,
-0.009711802,
0.0235380922,
0.0097054169,
-0.013097004,
0.0399512015,
0.0441900566,
0.0208061505,
0.1024122685,
0.0006830095,
-0.0547115952,
0.0422861986,
-0.0434970744,
-0.0443301089,
0.0163873471,
-0.02002424,
-0.0036737102,
-0.0088733118,
0.0088946884,
-0.0073449947,
-0.0122997947,
-0.0458900109,
-0.0017821607,
-0.0797431841,
0.0179734807,
-0.0083915768,
0.0022392336,
-0.0829221532,
-0.0002715626,
0.0550378971,
0.0622347146,
0.0160948057,
-0.0103177689,
0.0335630551,
-0.0261209644,
0.0145728569,
0.0069525456,
-0.0138464347,
0.0207301043,
-0.0338837206,
0.0423735604,
0.029237818,
0.1018867716,
-0.0213697478,
-0.0282585025,
-0.0234117955,
0.0505877063,
0.020436313,
-0.0258875843,
0.0106449109,
-0.0362369977,
-0.0045356741,
-0.0158493631,
0.0530258343,
-0.0032079502,
0.0175720621,
0.0058658421,
0.0293028019,
-0.0771559179,
-0.0128673436,
0.0051331981,
0.0543816611,
0.036769513,
0.0245994832,
0.022118615,
-0.0733749196,
0.0221299883,
0.0306711104,
0.0556483082,
0.0652324408,
-0.0027064974,
0.0036580637,
-0.0085611837,
-0.0141636161,
-0.0664772391,
-0.0448055975,
0.0246887691,
0.040298,
0.000573319,
-0.0460993573,
0.0176846143,
0.033905752,
-0.0015478611,
0.0002772973,
0.0407897569,
0.0527207069,
0.0113526555,
0.0192147046,
0.0146410177,
-0.0339421891,
0.0173961613,
-0.0189340077,
0.0803487748,
-0.0237965509,
-0.0029403078,
0.0039436137,
0.0183539577,
0.0181095712,
0.0213142354,
-0.0178838894,
-0.0564237721,
-0.016492445,
-0.0537928268,
0.0624408908,
0.0337784365,
0.0056175538,
0.0092487447,
0.0108565548,
-0.0293974839,
0.0042069657,
-0.0354094543,
0.0114357574,
0.0054139993,
-0.0724443793,
0.0077940384,
0.0307173189,
0.0161085427,
0.0005648308,
0.0296479445,
-0.0055198832,
-0.018130457,
-0.0326704308,
0.0195119102,
-0.059887547,
0.0063717868,
-0.0292096864,
0.0360272601,
0.010871293,
-0.0763110593,
-0.0473736264,
-0.0026558118,
0.023543559,
0.0230675731,
-0.028788399,
-0.0164443366,
-0.0560149886,
0.0392593332,
0.006607072,
-0.0143240262,
-0.0324661173,
-0.0005612208,
0.0120804263,
0.1076331511,
0.0292801671,
-0.0562752075,
-0.0214509442,
0.0495205522,
-0.009436734,
0.0065776231,
0.0256423075,
0.0597423576,
0.019807592,
0.0386207066,
0.0262163896,
-0.0495959558,
0.0235629939,
-0.000444663,
0.0302971937,
0.0064031142,
-0.0551238246,
0.0188859869,
-0.0072579631,
-0.0158091541,
0.0103492886,
-0.0267673973,
-0.0547570772,
0.0590961017,
-0.0338351987,
-0.0248049032,
-0.0442251377,
0.0270492807,
0.0592074879,
-0.0063197403,
0.0018996622,
0.0349106714,
-0.0916788802,
-0.0537855625,
-0.0025577084,
0.0125970514,
-0.0256498791,
-0.0623695739,
0.0374964029,
0.0422825851,
0.0069985217,
0.0187704675,
-0.0204921309,
0.0249005444,
-0.0703050271,
0.0081914458,
-0.00068838,
-5.402095226e-33,
-0.0223162528,
-0.0304518454,
-0.035628859,
-0.0130598024,
-0.0697425976,
0.022701554,
-0.0558461398,
0.0025252961,
-0.009941454,
0.0651432127,
0.0039583682,
0.0318829045,
-0.0063976995,
-0.0444272831,
-0.0176509209,
-0.0164260883,
-0.0027558974,
0.0135074966,
-0.0065059508,
0.0202274863,
0.0062814485,
0.0218309518,
0.0213498082,
-0.1076968014,
0.0208334271,
0.0330069475,
-0.0510554463,
-0.013100653,
0.0092571219,
0.0194384418,
-0.0013503032,
0.0336844921,
-0.0053167902,
0.009537057,
0.0129367448,
0.0431816392,
-0.0195761193,
-0.0114416583,
0.0237879809,
0.0052193715,
-0.0702039674,
-0.0051026926,
-0.0194791723,
-0.0098488843,
-0.0124652861,
0.0039538983,
0.0058261533,
0.0028388409,
0.0523337908,
0.012184334,
-0.0224677082,
-0.0446719266,
-0.0264549442,
-0.0880295783,
-0.0133446902,
0.0381374434,
-0.025030233,
-0.0021054333,
0.0033525252,
0.0289601497,
-0.0676480457,
-0.0800516233,
0.0302377827,
-0.0187801011,
0.0331515484,
0.0850723684,
-0.0156065682,
0.0020746023,
-0.0234673955,
0.0190725513,
0.0422455259,
0.0353890955,
0.0129621932,
0.0487411246,
-0.0652603209,
-0.043506097,
-0.0066255345,
0.0229719635,
0.0322820209,
0.0505449921,
0.0333933085,
0.0195499249,
-0.0397603624,
0.0090903081,
-0.0342245623,
-0.0502736792,
-0.0113835586,
-0.046935197,
0.0209536124,
-0.0297407228,
0.0025048519,
-0.0366061889,
0.0109311827,
-0.0259193089,
0.0081963334,
0.0156132272,
-0.016540112,
0.0470646732,
0.0043493705,
-0.0144184623,
0.0314693265,
-0.0085240593,
0.0371059068,
-0.0083831055,
0.0718344375,
-0.0071151806,
-0.0625935197,
0.0358374752,
0.0000705167,
-0.0266520139,
-0.0112968963,
0.0291672368,
0.0272167623,
-0.0059742779,
-0.0065008979,
0.0137908785,
-0.0489574112,
-0.0082658688,
-0.0025477719,
0.0286931004,
-0.0508139431,
-0.0493493527,
-0.0454935022,
0.0330783091,
-0.0601730496,
-0.0135155749,
-0.0144902291,
-0.0623286702,
0.0397695191,
-0.0327790044,
-0.0201227553,
-0.0148306275,
2.825e-7,
-0.0738405287,
0.0208441671,
0.0094819665,
-0.0501855426,
0.0244223904,
0.0713662654,
-0.0029047921,
0.0815873817,
0.0237843972,
-0.1103352532,
0.0138766011,
0.020358894,
0.0662763119,
-0.007371997,
-0.0388765,
-0.0013344203,
0.0054508075,
-0.0484694168,
0.0081550777,
0.0209208801,
0.0598447844,
0.0151873622,
0.0234330613,
-0.010929551,
0.0159216095,
0.0184181724,
0.0117633939,
-0.0836892426,
-0.0069414577,
-0.0611608885,
0.0056035086,
-0.0517620742,
-0.0002199939,
0.0199384131,
0.0309010278,
0.0006446391,
0.0221305564,
0.0612416975,
-0.0636318699,
-0.0336749889,
-0.0010201231,
0.0504852496,
-0.0496570952,
-0.002831493,
-0.001007727,
-0.039942611,
-0.0386292152,
-0.007844151,
-0.0036858991,
-0.040764071,
-0.0174134411,
-0.0250490941,
-0.0771723762,
0.0344959535,
-0.0120951505,
-0.0181226898,
-0.004147518,
-0.0251008254,
0.032661397,
-0.0056508831,
-0.0484314226,
-0.0865246132,
0.015654631,
-0.0363998562,
0.0231131501,
-0.0420788378,
-0.0096128574,
1.699435486e-34,
-0.0129680447,
0.0097130211,
0.0174325258,
0.033049766,
0.0545472093,
0.0028530522,
0.0022140509,
0.0026705195,
0.0508480147,
-0.0486332662,
-0.0166780297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01817v1 | Race and Privacy in Broadcast Police Communications | 2024-07-01T21:34:51 | 2024-07-01T21:34:51 | Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Christopher Graziul, Miranda Ardith Goodman, Samantha Nicole Kenny, Shomir Wilson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | Radios are essential for the operations of modern police departments, and
they function as both a collaborative communication technology and a
sociotechnical system. However, little prior research has examined their usage
or their connections to individual privacy and the role of race in policing,
two growing topics of concern in the US. As a case study, we examine the
Chicago Police Department's (CPD's) use of broadcast police communications
(BPC) to coordinate the activity of law enforcement officers (LEOs) in the
city. From a recently assembled archive of 80,775 hours of BPC associated with
CPD operations, we analyze text transcripts of radio transmissions broadcast
9:00 AM to 5:00 PM on August 10th, 2018 in one majority Black, one majority
white, and one majority Hispanic area of the city (24 hours of audio) to
explore three research questions: (1) Do BPC reflect reported racial
disparities in policing? (2) How and when is gender, race/ethnicity, and age
mentioned in BPC? (3) To what extent do BPC include sensitive information, and
who is put at most risk by this practice? (4) To what extent can large language
models (LLMs) heighten this risk? We explore the vocabulary and speech acts
used by police in BPC, comparing mentions of personal characteristics to local
demographics, the personal information shared over BPC, and the privacy
concerns that it poses. Analysis indicates (a) policing professionals in the
city of Chicago exhibit disproportionate attention to Black members of the
public regardless of context, (b) sociodemographic characteristics like gender,
race/ethnicity, and age are primarily mentioned in BPC about event information,
and (c) disproportionate attention introduces disproportionate privacy risks
for Black members of the public. | [
0.0325931683,
0.0732274577,
-0.0247501731,
-0.0185037665,
-0.0557260141,
0.033242669,
0.0763183609,
-0.0295510869,
-0.0440676957,
-0.0453169979,
-0.0044904817,
-0.0256020632,
0.027122369,
-0.0335011147,
-0.0402890742,
-0.0139927473,
-0.0036768506,
0.0034284294,
0.0498910435,
0.0222048461,
0.025085438,
0.0730349049,
0.0162853636,
0.0404017717,
-0.0395364165,
-0.0031458929,
-0.0155163044,
-0.0120370043,
0.0086945966,
0.0095825884,
-0.0192142352,
0.0597450137,
-0.0065977029,
0.021791121,
0.0000017305,
-0.0529427938,
0.0052215615,
0.0051456895,
-0.0361764655,
0.000149282,
0.0452255011,
-0.029436022,
-0.0122866631,
-0.0208678264,
-0.0458529368,
-0.0357664712,
-0.0043023261,
0.0016020432,
0.0099188937,
0.0290083736,
0.0204789694,
0.0148091307,
-0.0232401937,
-0.0229882225,
-0.0431087017,
-0.0139125399,
0.0228925664,
-0.0162760336,
0.0142303742,
-0.0047639692,
0.0740634575,
0.0121260481,
0.0201592445,
0.0138947312,
0.0225816499,
0.0037545597,
-0.0265079197,
-0.0111096026,
0.0485958196,
0.0180670898,
0.0185048487,
-0.0162067972,
0.0091514047,
0.0623274632,
0.0192400031,
0.0111836512,
-0.0172522739,
0.0137411254,
-0.0401885957,
-0.0067461892,
-0.0716359317,
0.0020472971,
0.0181071721,
0.0403365903,
0.0001875711,
0.1028331891,
0.0056866459,
-0.0167652611,
-0.011661808,
-0.0030208176,
0.0211931542,
-0.0380366482,
0.0294131581,
-0.0232515167,
-0.027602559,
0.0066699372,
-0.0117080985,
-0.0548765361,
-0.0047620595,
-0.031129878,
-0.0135358777,
-0.0137606207,
0.0110546667,
-0.021078825,
0.0810526535,
-0.0313324966,
0.0358919017,
-0.039806217,
-0.0081557836,
-0.0214210395,
-0.0015129836,
-0.0173577033,
0.026531091,
0.0336916707,
-0.0317279026,
-0.0125263501,
-0.0099495668,
0.0074656792,
0.0257129334,
-0.0045364238,
-0.0384143293,
-0.0288316514,
-0.0350759104,
0.0116396239,
0.0192431938,
-0.0633171797,
-0.0013041628,
0.0249016564,
0.0102030989,
-0.0248973556,
0.0157128312,
-0.0486238003,
0.0422948338,
0.0102017224,
-0.0817370042,
0.0284655336,
-0.0284660254,
-0.0144958841,
-0.0377132706,
-0.0214952901,
0.0003294538,
-0.0508327857,
0.0051585664,
-0.0588272363,
0.0210525133,
0.0273723565,
-0.0090704896,
0.0076389033,
0.0039099613,
0.0092778718,
-0.0154292509,
0.0497570112,
-0.0013290648,
0.0599137731,
0.0813795477,
0.0593164302,
0.0498848595,
0.0211154204,
0.031706363,
0.0005992005,
0.0534964316,
-0.0499156862,
-0.0336450189,
0.0114020957,
-0.02325074,
0.001322347,
-0.0040074061,
0.0222652443,
-0.0074643516,
-0.0515604839,
0.029638702,
0.0223433301,
0.0100806542,
-0.0321938358,
0.0665808171,
0.1297342479,
-0.013684961,
-0.0039824685,
0.0070053637,
0.0861643851,
0.0018883181,
-0.0299942829,
-0.0462945327,
-0.03782814,
-0.0390305594,
-0.076465711,
0.0126960538,
0.020945752,
-0.0411044471,
0.0481114723,
0.00429371,
-0.0353846215,
0.0500389002,
0.004923149,
-0.0315406583,
-0.005737354,
0.0401380546,
0.0100496281,
0.0159294866,
0.0232087821,
-0.0076711718,
-0.0351984762,
0.0449828357,
0.066139631,
-0.0523646213,
0.0604357161,
0.0634406731,
-0.0635552406,
0.0608232841,
0.0298899431,
0.0083347019,
0.0278360397,
0.0055670519,
-0.0409902744,
0.011234723,
0.0341125764,
0.0542206876,
0.031185478,
0.003561113,
0.0330379792,
0.0409289226,
0.0292748604,
-0.0342458636,
-0.0261770338,
0.0114556728,
-0.0302901994,
-0.0123154754,
-0.0343980193,
0.0152310589,
0.0088511659,
-0.0165740661,
0.0262955725,
-0.0191692431,
0.0381860919,
0.0110090887,
-0.0016266908,
-0.0261343587,
0.0527647883,
-0.0035353554,
-0.0051687378,
0.0080158105,
0.0507392175,
0.0264804158,
-0.0068353158,
0.0403221548,
-0.0551689789,
0.0252905227,
0.0164798163,
0.0375514515,
0.0153295407,
-0.0039266124,
0.0156965926,
-0.0141823646,
-0.0224659555,
-0.0432497002,
-0.0155674871,
0.0308901705,
0.0343936458,
0.0025901846,
-0.0131846024,
0.0191101246,
-0.0043691485,
0.0434449241,
-0.0025533757,
-0.0235284586,
0.0106716221,
-0.0176775865,
-0.0040764827,
0.0070410818,
-0.02414166,
-0.0178662706,
0.0185704231,
0.0508356132,
-0.0244893581,
-0.0451717079,
0.0196971018,
-0.0784643665,
0.0162955057,
0.0313779339,
-0.0603152178,
0.0028712205,
-0.0346586779,
0.0119924918,
-0.0624587871,
-0.0329852775,
0.0375248902,
-0.0401375182,
-0.0399217941,
-0.0121113854,
0.0118193859,
-0.036841359,
-0.0103505142,
-0.0272272248,
-0.0077652554,
0.0627168268,
0.014769705,
-0.0106453225,
0.0194791723,
0.0829335973,
0.0597490184,
0.0082278745,
-0.0228328723,
-0.002820252,
-0.0317490846,
-0.0085607935,
-0.0022093011,
0.0098742256,
-0.0809601173,
-0.0184824578,
0.02479643,
0.0402223803,
0.0195626188,
-0.015673304,
0.011448116,
-0.0654891953,
-0.0834636986,
-0.0806551501,
-0.0709924549,
-0.0106729837,
0.0301153418,
-0.0490878001,
-0.0422354862,
0.0230138991,
0.0138535481,
0.0600636974,
0.0145966522,
-0.0541232638,
-0.0258921087,
0.0708285496,
0.0105347643,
0.0042392826,
0.0489431098,
-0.036686372,
0.0278283097,
-0.020695582,
0.0194096658,
-0.0763724074,
0.0388160609,
-0.0113224434,
-0.02158981,
0.0239653792,
-0.0541210808,
-0.0011162718,
-0.0690201372,
-0.0504539087,
0.0030060152,
-0.011625614,
-0.0253836922,
-0.0087926863,
0.0080709849,
0.0265272707,
-0.01628666,
-0.0116566671,
0.0237805527,
-0.0012849976,
-0.0111324796,
0.0144018866,
-0.0223721266,
0.0146222264,
-0.0192881804,
-0.0227886066,
0.0105848098,
0.0094237821,
0.0206864905,
0.0350107178,
-0.0256247949,
0.0164891798,
0.0535109304,
-0.0740320608,
0.0085193496,
0.0470045246,
0.003079457,
0.0461334512,
0.0658920556,
0.0065851025,
-0.0176404174,
0.0056740786,
-0.0016964193,
-0.0269759335,
0.005322739,
-0.008026639,
-0.0498317145,
0.0611346066,
0.0173363518,
0.0578364469,
-0.0537391528,
-0.0583914481,
-0.0383730456,
-0.0580017827,
0.0189718734,
0.0220053438,
0.0084259436,
0.0154027203,
-0.0420911908,
0.0195788741,
0.0178950317,
0.0468586609,
-0.0266796388,
-0.0004856144,
-0.013301041,
0.0155575862,
-0.1137240753,
-0.0121426452,
0.0002181177,
-0.0187801477,
0.0141015882,
0.040840555,
0.0317379422,
-0.0495897979,
-0.0032328966,
0.0130030243,
0.015983535,
-0.011537184,
0.0104591381,
-0.031279128,
-0.0308277179,
0.0064447192,
-0.0735700056,
0.0917485058,
0.018312376,
-0.0145294378,
0.0338017493,
-0.0067629679,
-0.0383707583,
-0.0314794518,
-0.0333517268,
0.0602157936,
0.0225571226,
0.0046504871,
0.0490949638,
-0.0098003903,
0.0510047711,
-0.0429480523,
0.0335299037,
-0.0038728586,
-0.0435650684,
0.0384542197,
0.0503463745,
-0.0587462224,
0.0679641366,
-0.0533703268,
-0.0390523933,
0.0000303365,
0.034934707,
-0.0000353983,
0.061462909,
-0.0757632479,
-0.0249324013,
0.0182559974,
-0.0058012195,
0.0215324555,
0.0514242128,
-0.0024064712,
-0.0578674227,
0.0274371468,
-0.0055393069,
0.0122466721,
-0.0391545631,
-0.0024355897,
0.084135212,
-0.0276154783,
0.0175035875,
0.0235581994,
-0.0303692631,
-0.0631300583,
-0.0186927207,
0.0194421988,
-0.0438265763,
0.0100361286,
0.0020111201,
0.0019993507,
0.0331395082,
0.0040523522,
0.0119733214,
0.0665424243,
0.027609285,
-0.0470382683,
-0.0964575484,
-0.0050595505,
0.0011143116,
-0.0435164347,
-0.0250167027,
0.0100987433,
0.0147870034,
0.000198364,
-0.0303172395,
-0.0395061933,
-0.0052808505,
0.0195018202,
0.0135989049,
0.0037802462,
0.0604941212,
-0.0489874408,
-0.0192255732,
0.0065147872,
0.0278503671,
-0.0576453283,
0.0233084224,
0.0172081534,
-0.0179914329,
0.0365936197,
-0.0142651051,
-0.0064736572,
0.0608398095,
-0.04154744,
0.002533796,
0.0449806266,
0.038003087,
0.0020642553,
0.0014923,
-0.011602208,
0.012076444,
-0.0539714247,
-0.012196321,
0.0196740627,
0.0251174551,
-0.0038486137,
-0.0361258462,
-0.0002780199,
0.0011017249,
0.0022791824,
-0.0078372145,
0.0274213403,
0.0271486305,
-0.0056188582,
0.0481057577,
0.0369181186,
-0.042111475,
0.0603865534,
0.0025272316,
-0.0086312834,
0.0371227488,
0.0181670021,
-0.0912172198,
-0.0134147462,
0.0011270393,
0.0342273898,
0.0669664666,
-0.0209640153,
-0.0496841893,
-0.0954116583,
-0.0364954807,
-0.0165527072,
-0.0110707199,
0.012743419,
-0.0304394551,
-0.0214750506,
0.0109877726,
-0.0007482491,
-0.0441629514,
-0.005306988,
0.0293514654,
-0.0131191658,
-0.0551329963,
0.0714602098,
-4.992179041e-33,
-0.0041647232,
-0.042029731,
-0.0457105264,
-0.0127109634,
-0.020324057,
0.0014298507,
0.0124753062,
0.0049599875,
0.0112345219,
-0.0175358839,
-0.0179744326,
0.0282501597,
-0.0148551082,
-0.0147785796,
-0.0132188592,
-0.0133934831,
0.0228317399,
-0.0076622711,
0.017563723,
-0.0200207438,
0.0222950149,
0.022738833,
-0.037562944,
-0.0964307636,
0.0386853069,
0.0123592187,
-0.053001143,
0.0200511832,
0.0000721723,
0.0335051604,
-0.0347561687,
0.0117396023,
0.016129395,
-0.0172561612,
0.0088764653,
0.1538819671,
-0.0351088531,
0.0066841226,
0.044831641,
-0.0100703714,
0.0209039114,
-0.0234753545,
-0.0331215635,
0.0076128314,
-0.0146131357,
0.0181922652,
0.000633079,
-0.0353005119,
-0.0015802736,
0.0077325194,
-0.0164539274,
0.0362075791,
-0.0260325354,
0.0036861431,
-0.0432753786,
-0.036099378,
0.0059212577,
-0.0335001498,
-0.0215153694,
-0.0234424509,
0.0522962213,
-0.0005174358,
0.0074304817,
0.0438205637,
-0.0064627137,
0.0119156837,
0.0459342264,
-0.002496067,
-0.0580150411,
-0.0391902849,
0.0603669174,
0.0449547097,
-0.0539343618,
0.0487799942,
-0.0287438966,
-0.0938056409,
-0.0483687446,
-0.0513580926,
0.0039329645,
-0.0235708598,
0.0277013071,
0.0098335156,
-0.0735117868,
-0.0312946178,
-0.0053832573,
-0.0107863713,
0.0119461305,
-0.0236806236,
-0.0046029049,
0.0093670059,
-0.0213695839,
0.0383656248,
0.0335346833,
-0.0153352451,
0.0013786219,
-0.0557502583,
-0.0569299199,
-0.0337680764,
-0.0273676068,
0.0574368425,
-0.0649688765,
0.0182891563,
0.0610322095,
0.0043281307,
0.0404800437,
0.0137715824,
0.0564564764,
0.032826446,
-0.0530772507,
-0.0250319429,
0.0237347782,
0.0347807407,
0.0220703464,
0.0070224977,
0.0894807056,
0.0159117803,
-0.0043754196,
-0.0044765742,
0.0222076848,
-0.0328793563,
0.0059360545,
-0.0024302893,
-0.0416483991,
-0.0006629064,
0.009559649,
0.0125314593,
0.0404835343,
0.0445804708,
0.094777666,
0.0455772094,
0.0171368755,
-0.0618420802,
2.271e-7,
-0.0066048708,
-0.0301206615,
-0.0078419531,
0.003878752,
0.0377588943,
0.0299882274,
0.0418259129,
0.0364847109,
0.013700028,
-0.0134150516,
0.0029244975,
0.0214727595,
0.0764651597,
0.0604013167,
-0.0344162062,
-0.0410922952,
-0.0507403351,
-0.0235526115,
-0.0471373759,
0.0179353505,
0.012784889,
0.0986682922,
0.0633252636,
-0.00085013,
-0.0473567843,
0.0151273599,
-0.0014189219,
-0.0677790567,
-0.0482527725,
-0.0544531383,
0.025995234,
0.0456204563,
-0.0264819842,
0.0701293647,
0.0229191761,
0.0464066342,
0.0307291541,
0.0697286204,
0.0334095918,
0.0227107685,
-0.0191215165,
-0.0545418113,
-0.0402375981,
-0.0331020877,
0.0456025936,
0.0544641949,
-0.07937444,
-0.0374293476,
-0.0363801904,
-0.0408899076,
-0.0219594464,
-0.0093436083,
-0.0237239357,
0.0014646356,
-0.014052215,
0.0081346268,
-0.0118009737,
-0.0371096358,
0.0286369435,
0.0177412555,
0.009941048,
-0.0701317191,
-0.0015418816,
0.0699252784,
0.007832258,
-0.0038435652,
0.0622022189,
1.616826358e-34,
-0.0078229336,
0.0471325591,
-0.0471843593,
-0.0619600341,
0.0202198308,
0.001777615,
-0.0072763977,
-0.0540247411,
0.0286195502,
-0.0416036025,
0.0029456245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01796v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01796v1 | Ground Every Sentence: Improving Retrieval-Augmented LLMs with Interleaved Reference-Claim Generation | 2024-07-01T20:47:47 | 2024-07-01T20:47:47 | Sirui Xia, Xintao Wang, Jiaqing Liang, Yifei Zhang, Weikang Zhou, Jiaji Deng, Fei Yu, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has been widely adopted to enhance Large
Language Models (LLMs) in knowledge-intensive tasks. Recently, Attributed Text
Generation (ATG) has attracted growing attention, which provides citations to
support the model's responses in RAG, so as to enhance the credibility of
LLM-generated content and facilitate verification. Prior methods mainly adopt
coarse-grained attributions, linking to passage-level references or providing
paragraph-level citations. However, these methods still fall short in
verifiability and require certain time costs for fact checking. This paper
proposes a fine-grained ATG method called ReClaim(Refer & Claim), which
alternates the generation of references and answers step by step. Unlike
traditional coarse-grained attribution, ReClaim allows the model to add
sentence-level fine-grained citations to each answer sentence in long-form
question-answering tasks. Our experiments encompass various training and
inference methods and multiple LLMs, verifying the effectiveness of our
approach. | [
0.0617013425,
0.0186267663,
0.015033531,
0.023091523,
-0.0333398432,
-0.0201109909,
-0.0027793352,
-0.0317354053,
0.0072812191,
-0.0884993821,
0.0025862718,
0.0149748269,
-0.0303229857,
-0.061738573,
0.0585773177,
0.0189861916,
0.037431404,
0.0017144053,
0.0253855251,
-0.0030423817,
-0.0020583766,
0.0261092149,
0.0116759855,
0.0130391531,
-0.0293318443,
-0.0184150077,
0.0309186149,
-0.0001187264,
0.0470656343,
-0.0243298616,
0.0295943581,
0.0164704639,
-0.0010127525,
0.0292927921,
0.0000018023,
-0.0457212254,
0.0045726504,
0.0310004372,
-0.0404097736,
0.0472251959,
0.0229249839,
0.0618151724,
0.0318201296,
0.0286865029,
-0.0388589762,
0.0007180751,
-0.0027443911,
0.0539745577,
0.1011920944,
0.0537718274,
0.0124885133,
-0.0367376469,
0.0243189931,
-0.0154338833,
0.0219147615,
-0.0281249397,
0.020245526,
0.0498742945,
0.0223698821,
0.0610796884,
0.024309814,
0.0752926171,
0.0226953495,
-0.0222063307,
0.0425739288,
0.0141813783,
-0.0345398746,
0.0339146815,
0.0191259198,
0.0502772219,
0.0202778019,
-0.0532156378,
0.0131609906,
0.0158485956,
0.0340982005,
0.0371367112,
-0.0500224009,
0.048388496,
-0.0095541384,
-0.0017209777,
0.0159260221,
-0.0193405338,
0.0222421549,
0.0347112492,
0.0002843431,
0.0419371501,
0.0272061415,
-0.0358762406,
0.0007204904,
0.0229833536,
-0.0122379642,
-0.0545014255,
0.000161827,
0.03800736,
-0.0016836466,
0.0174645782,
-0.0307212342,
-0.0194646958,
0.049379658,
-0.0019311082,
0.0292585492,
0.0001249539,
-0.023778867,
0.0194281004,
-0.0846700594,
0.0212714225,
-0.0219799746,
-0.0349265039,
-0.033261314,
-0.0222961269,
-0.0471105091,
-0.0390598625,
-0.0591759756,
0.0599394515,
-0.042416323,
-0.0045889309,
-0.0363425426,
0.0203518476,
-0.0091202594,
-0.0104936706,
0.0182449389,
0.0175718926,
-0.0203732792,
0.0089804679,
-0.0467076413,
0.0410409309,
-0.0252010617,
0.0402817205,
0.0409110598,
-0.0601591691,
-0.02844714,
0.0287940577,
0.0157115012,
-0.0432348885,
0.0146141946,
0.0042920294,
-0.0385230482,
0.0031363566,
-0.0504741147,
-0.0755031705,
-0.046207644,
-0.0720305443,
0.0120784836,
-0.0872228518,
0.0225320458,
0.0143390987,
-0.0235039536,
-0.0145512074,
0.0256464202,
0.0623470247,
-0.0579943545,
0.0168393031,
-0.0068679494,
0.0070502204,
0.02593771,
-0.0108940955,
0.0724910125,
0.0099239629,
0.0466839187,
0.029566519,
0.0243503563,
0.0273964833,
0.0213980805,
0.0015051743,
0.0663343146,
0.0345207974,
0.0243111737,
0.0040270058,
-0.0122494241,
0.0094271004,
0.0210716706,
0.0463289022,
-0.0374106802,
0.0198163409,
0.06970229,
-0.0036573356,
-0.0226909779,
0.0021851927,
0.0689552128,
0.0045869965,
0.0155041851,
0.0049893637,
-0.0398621932,
0.0296252947,
-0.0359604359,
0.0379315801,
0.0469568707,
0.0304204822,
-0.0231779832,
-0.0272078719,
-0.0025349827,
0.0170529615,
-0.0263636354,
0.0411605388,
0.0096786888,
0.0499243513,
-0.0293850563,
0.0972972512,
-0.0032458599,
-0.0646822676,
0.0325363949,
-0.0570623875,
0.0421283096,
-0.0053473511,
0.0596171394,
0.0019884265,
-0.0053721233,
-0.0228149518,
0.0480649173,
0.0634562522,
0.0214888398,
-0.0009433021,
-0.021136079,
-0.0272771101,
-0.0176547784,
-0.0329125114,
0.0086081596,
-0.0077192476,
0.0432754494,
-0.0128378356,
0.0522268116,
-0.0763918608,
-0.0372014418,
0.0355355516,
0.0117735434,
-0.0261303391,
0.016023133,
-0.0105675086,
0.0043078428,
0.0327885784,
-0.0215221941,
0.0305837709,
0.038284786,
-0.0280718133,
-0.0364968851,
0.0177403241,
0.0006680624,
-0.0477405228,
0.0338840671,
-0.0040347702,
-0.0125733186,
-0.004501401,
-0.0403765477,
-0.0575198457,
-0.0167044606,
-0.0502595007,
-0.0059862658,
-0.0575742647,
0.0062731979,
0.0494623147,
-0.0004728874,
-0.0652247667,
0.0748206526,
0.0102127343,
0.0113971559,
0.0253846478,
0.0048224111,
0.0428066328,
-0.0427627563,
-0.0122494092,
-0.0334216617,
-0.0136337308,
0.0171466544,
0.0641358942,
0.0003681932,
-0.0319652744,
-0.0312645808,
-0.0531771742,
0.019431401,
-0.0069228034,
0.0277735777,
-0.0031849123,
0.0071128891,
0.0080136973,
-0.0143962996,
-0.0423606783,
-0.0204738677,
0.0525088757,
0.0139071103,
0.0290032029,
0.0214128196,
0.0178968981,
-0.0401343741,
-0.0034703829,
-0.0015364924,
0.0316108689,
0.0304288585,
0.0054061422,
-0.0843825862,
0.0014243105,
-0.0495030023,
-0.0003601355,
0.0128219314,
-0.0347956456,
0.0090982337,
-0.0011976577,
0.0429850146,
0.056046132,
0.0154003706,
-0.0240270253,
0.0267820489,
-0.0010750372,
-0.0810287446,
0.0353115052,
-0.021617895,
-0.0540392324,
-0.0034083978,
-0.0444130488,
0.0156819336,
0.0441658013,
0.0168235656,
-0.0325416066,
-0.0097100465,
0.0090933386,
0.0219467618,
-0.024585383,
-0.0062474227,
-0.0034028394,
-0.0032568064,
0.0092554754,
-0.0277447477,
-0.0199521538,
0.0520109162,
-0.0488127507,
-0.0002612547,
-0.030930331,
0.0051133824,
-0.0382520631,
0.0301660113,
0.0066881506,
-0.0015974197,
0.0000204703,
0.0182915349,
-0.043470636,
-0.0263806321,
0.0291714873,
-0.0411211438,
0.0345123522,
-0.0422605611,
0.0424608774,
-0.0175633859,
-0.0295533519,
-0.0542474724,
-0.0439494997,
-0.003421633,
0.0204734281,
-0.0478711501,
0.0051008305,
-0.0623423941,
-0.0249252412,
0.1025685519,
-0.0058850972,
-0.0284831617,
-0.0001293693,
-0.0232828707,
0.0814974234,
0.0808913708,
0.024430925,
0.014332138,
-0.0119220205,
-0.0245484263,
0.0475051738,
0.0221960712,
0.0361642092,
-0.0059528877,
-0.0479349382,
0.0049529998,
-0.0281015337,
-0.0082331905,
0.005735192,
0.0554807112,
-0.05979909,
-0.030571023,
0.0816086382,
0.0232057497,
0.0165989771,
-0.0240577962,
-0.0119500021,
0.04660061,
0.0134164635,
0.0513433628,
-0.1072053388,
-0.0283532869,
-0.028138632,
0.0088315876,
0.0044460739,
0.0010411636,
0.0065829945,
-0.1507058442,
0.0409476198,
0.0024147364,
-0.0093176188,
-0.0286603328,
-0.0176847242,
0.0088247312,
0.0267884266,
-0.0221927483,
0.0352906249,
-0.0110109635,
0.0175763853,
0.0251099523,
0.0043908376,
0.0022402706,
-0.0069026742,
-0.0434418321,
0.0234794989,
0.046531979,
0.0468910076,
0.0073076589,
-0.0246526916,
0.0237763785,
-0.0719859898,
0.0008649761,
-0.0073562609,
0.0268452428,
-0.0197343752,
0.0026013271,
-0.0137923416,
0.0350505859,
0.0027089207,
-0.0241424534,
0.0409603156,
0.0718968734,
-0.0140198572,
-0.0181976091,
-0.0152084492,
0.0111844977,
0.0233313292,
0.0846187547,
0.0196764208,
-0.0103325862,
-0.047416728,
-0.0118311755,
-0.0075662052,
-0.0758928806,
-0.0197077971,
0.048091121,
-0.0315123796,
0.0389681719,
-0.100804098,
-0.0269812997,
-0.0111364331,
0.0104842288,
-0.0020788799,
0.0270557646,
-0.0086648222,
-0.013414816,
-0.0475621,
0.0225372612,
-0.0823890045,
0.0303667504,
-0.0102199698,
-0.0003780024,
0.0410764851,
-0.0523176417,
-0.009776745,
0.0577436239,
-0.0253909193,
-0.0400587209,
-0.0241790097,
0.059290383,
0.0178019293,
0.0525961369,
-0.0112157809,
-0.038895376,
0.0421075337,
0.0182929356,
-0.0249652602,
0.0468749069,
-0.0000411394,
-0.0066680303,
-0.0307111237,
0.0248707458,
-0.060214527,
0.0201009959,
0.0109704928,
0.0673657805,
0.0024751476,
-0.0801385492,
0.0160545912,
0.0331764296,
0.0063006068,
0.0013318158,
0.0547417216,
-0.0091035133,
0.0300841928,
-0.0181975104,
-0.0242838152,
-0.0256213378,
0.0245356485,
-0.0184974521,
-0.0178260989,
0.0097222244,
-0.0109015061,
-0.0024371166,
0.0900529251,
-0.0209370777,
-0.0219554398,
-0.045574788,
0.0072298348,
-0.0186709277,
-0.0146050183,
-0.0389324799,
-0.016628284,
0.007718693,
0.0553079396,
0.0007438128,
0.0302879978,
0.0275758151,
-0.0239761025,
-0.011665171,
-0.00800962,
-0.0755394623,
0.0179826654,
-0.036258921,
-0.0361487232,
0.0377579294,
0.0095448494,
0.0840008855,
-0.0231539551,
-0.0308444295,
-0.010417141,
0.0297125317,
0.0035912211,
-0.0097870929,
0.0084915031,
0.0036059215,
-0.0331138335,
0.0171766393,
0.0534094125,
0.0595727488,
0.0489625335,
-0.0413108915,
-0.0215336699,
-0.0335504189,
-0.09255784,
-0.0729853883,
-0.0031098342,
0.0053399191,
-0.0078617278,
-0.0439562798,
-0.0723801181,
0.0080306102,
0.024772549,
-0.0081845131,
-0.034458831,
0.0270946193,
0.0379612669,
0.0195018314,
-0.064889513,
-0.0541823879,
0.0539979078,
-0.0317442566,
-0.0242666882,
-0.0304777026,
-6.110948442e-33,
-0.0424210057,
-0.0468288362,
0.0437648185,
-0.0088745616,
-0.0553696379,
-0.0027922937,
-0.0438047796,
-0.0357833318,
-0.0280678961,
0.0259058792,
-0.0105966991,
0.0042424062,
0.0043282397,
0.0509648249,
-0.0046451855,
0.0163250808,
0.0500259288,
0.0164041519,
-0.0394427516,
0.0379321203,
0.0398392491,
0.0038768845,
0.0458389297,
-0.0586030968,
0.0171875134,
-0.0281460565,
-0.015511754,
0.0094113238,
-0.0433924682,
0.0659675896,
0.0065115844,
0.0159982052,
0.0221662074,
-0.0467463247,
0.0097777778,
0.0366608463,
-0.1177791432,
-0.0005976615,
0.0483357012,
-0.0524496324,
-0.0461530127,
-0.0502099209,
0.0342605449,
-0.0199205335,
0.0320426226,
-0.0082905525,
0.0555149019,
-0.0400156118,
-0.0143634956,
-0.0680571198,
-0.0399516299,
0.0151589662,
0.0294708647,
0.0049288082,
-0.0506100543,
0.0461852849,
-0.016369855,
0.0205175392,
-0.0290579293,
-0.0067752562,
-0.0319522917,
0.0448109396,
0.0266038105,
0.0115728378,
-0.0112785595,
0.0186913777,
-0.0135371285,
-0.0201366022,
-0.0185940564,
-0.0500906557,
-0.0223172698,
0.0327317491,
0.057452146,
0.0830935091,
-0.0121669667,
0.0322227739,
-0.0743563026,
0.0191717148,
0.0324306749,
0.0675682127,
0.0124909934,
-0.0281386711,
0.007068411,
0.0007401918,
-0.0636680275,
0.0298589412,
-0.0280186739,
0.0022128876,
0.0465607494,
0.0283011515,
-0.037216384,
0.0359864049,
0.0508341901,
-0.0227893442,
-0.0133441612,
0.0404575244,
-0.0056517147,
0.0257446729,
-0.0269272905,
-0.0014544774,
-0.0399872251,
0.0105461031,
0.0213647895,
0.0071445806,
-0.0115332557,
0.0268407408,
0.0438232124,
-0.0041220896,
-0.0415179543,
0.0273001064,
-0.0269283503,
0.0354725011,
-0.0354355462,
-0.0350885056,
0.010878155,
0.0341660865,
0.0052945516,
0.0222411305,
0.0054717963,
-0.019512862,
-0.0110636298,
-0.0222769137,
0.0308555774,
0.004517464,
-0.0225883108,
0.0421160497,
-0.0276934467,
0.0509018973,
-0.0352301449,
-0.040430788,
0.010056803,
0.028783666,
2.535e-7,
0.0288546067,
0.0026297295,
0.0331791118,
0.0156770218,
-0.0066276947,
-0.0016469192,
0.0372333154,
0.0102853728,
0.0485701077,
-0.0142057817,
-0.0123302517,
0.009884784,
0.0793089941,
0.0009141274,
-0.0878509656,
-0.0169413108,
-0.0538058132,
-0.0230784006,
-0.0264788419,
-0.0350226536,
0.0217601713,
0.0363651626,
0.0044278819,
-0.0044560619,
-0.0465309881,
-0.0604507141,
0.0799657926,
0.0170072932,
-0.0306034815,
0.0344855264,
0.0663200095,
0.02437176,
0.0023908268,
0.0130898552,
-0.0385232046,
0.0160259847,
-0.0110830097,
0.0464863777,
0.0074286736,
-0.0412752256,
-0.0315080434,
-0.0547095723,
0.0359039009,
-0.0346577577,
0.0271576457,
-0.0423159376,
0.0299201123,
-0.0259372741,
-0.0544945151,
-0.0111860596,
-0.0475121588,
-0.0122365598,
-0.024019368,
0.0150401155,
-0.0009496851,
0.021070607,
-0.0194067527,
-0.0851222798,
-0.0492616966,
0.0282678846,
-0.0465990454,
-0.0511792637,
-0.0017040623,
-0.0165069848,
0.0100380993,
-0.0991587341,
0.0026058184,
2.282914722e-34,
0.0167581718,
0.0006461439,
0.0167982597,
0.0182790123,
0.0554518327,
0.0250042491,
-0.0201085452,
0.0261124689,
0.0219415538,
-0.0906591937,
-0.0222259723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01784v1 | Analyzing Persuasive Strategies in Meme Texts: A Fusion of Language Models with Paraphrase Enrichment | 2024-07-01T20:25:20 | 2024-07-01T20:25:20 | Kota Shamanth Ramanath Nayak, Leila Kosseim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper describes our approach to hierarchical multi-label detection of
persuasion techniques in meme texts. Our model, developed as a part of the
recent SemEval task, is based on fine-tuning individual language models (BERT,
XLM-RoBERTa, and mBERT) and leveraging a mean-based ensemble model in addition
to dataset augmentation through paraphrase generation from ChatGPT. The scope
of the study encompasses enhancing model performance through innovative
training techniques and data augmentation strategies. The problem addressed is
the effective identification and classification of multiple persuasive
techniques in meme texts, a task complicated by the diversity and complexity of
such content. The objective of the paper is to improve detection accuracy by
refining model training methods and examining the impact of balanced versus
unbalanced training datasets. Novelty in the results and discussion lies in the
finding that training with paraphrases enhances model performance, yet a
balanced training set proves more advantageous than a larger unbalanced one.
Additionally, the analysis reveals the potential pitfalls of indiscriminate
incorporation of paraphrases from diverse distributions, which can introduce
substantial noise. Results with the SemEval 2024 data confirm these insights,
demonstrating improved model efficacy with the proposed methods. | [
0.0653997958,
0.0338543952,
-0.0191007294,
0.0311045703,
-0.0319484696,
0.0208665095,
0.0011087093,
0.0125361467,
0.0409652032,
-0.0733941421,
-0.0317793265,
-0.0075955717,
-0.0071986485,
0.0030956364,
0.035527762,
-0.0598326884,
-0.0044777528,
0.0060986914,
0.0639885738,
-0.0287366398,
0.0302134771,
0.0346868746,
0.00324499,
0.0656096041,
-0.0081587061,
-0.0360789038,
0.0593685471,
0.0086220251,
0.0388718881,
-0.0427342728,
0.0683792457,
0.0468739681,
0.0111596072,
0.0222014207,
0.0000018647,
-0.0552651063,
-0.010044544,
-0.0241624843,
-0.0204135608,
0.0048075132,
0.1105757058,
0.0262732729,
-0.0019238763,
0.0293793678,
-0.0120721031,
0.0557658337,
0.071552515,
0.0866594762,
0.0606673062,
0.0399526544,
-0.0131834755,
-0.0395033024,
0.0011729543,
-0.009224535,
0.0046684132,
-0.0097938851,
0.040858306,
-0.0480744615,
-0.0081027765,
0.0556438155,
0.0268388279,
0.0565544032,
-0.0173345935,
0.004076839,
0.0136334188,
0.0123074902,
-0.0036099018,
-0.0133996084,
-0.0216432046,
0.0295064561,
-0.0036217025,
-0.0227968078,
0.0333317816,
-0.0038971649,
0.0366655476,
0.025240995,
-0.0617540516,
0.0277381223,
0.003440337,
0.0120184002,
-0.015478638,
0.0153833888,
0.0247467812,
0.0429339297,
0.0018896755,
0.0017488548,
-0.0012284998,
-0.0513646975,
0.0512824208,
0.0035459083,
-0.0460694209,
-0.0219555777,
0.005931532,
-0.0252933949,
-0.0093720946,
0.0488513373,
-0.0269761886,
-0.0823575035,
0.043561358,
-0.096576646,
0.0181341246,
-0.0203244518,
-0.0021460922,
0.0141349556,
0.0043286807,
-0.0118802488,
-0.0230523944,
0.0163145214,
0.0198544357,
0.016686745,
-0.0867187604,
-0.0189503618,
-0.0332059041,
0.0310848895,
0.0451124497,
-0.0410762653,
-0.1027002335,
0.0049815741,
-0.0284419786,
-0.0330976844,
-0.0221737772,
0.0322258994,
0.0112625016,
0.0278062746,
-0.0004042119,
0.0325560085,
-0.0171470158,
0.0327311419,
0.0088791084,
-0.0374908075,
0.0163350403,
0.0587348826,
0.0150359822,
-0.0361838527,
0.0440692827,
0.006826893,
-0.0157299787,
-0.036368791,
-0.0602186769,
-0.0471512713,
-0.076812543,
-0.0138731701,
0.0089845341,
-0.0663949177,
0.0088040689,
-0.004118863,
0.0293335374,
-0.0158796161,
0.0031718633,
0.0183030441,
-0.070145376,
0.0299218018,
0.0331882089,
-0.00718896,
0.049384959,
0.0344770029,
-0.0473825932,
0.0279173963,
0.0273832679,
0.0880572945,
0.0729093775,
-0.0055646822,
0.0158957373,
0.0455919877,
0.0164027009,
0.0231230389,
0.0216829013,
-0.0141282529,
-0.0467998646,
-0.002022489,
-0.039595332,
0.0354512595,
-0.0281090755,
0.0015350434,
0.0866173804,
0.0484119244,
-0.0133413328,
0.003857747,
0.0065277545,
0.0350918286,
0.0421223044,
-0.0213559587,
0.0135444654,
-0.0496640392,
-0.0387303382,
-0.0032746044,
0.0378545634,
0.0433150195,
-0.01511617,
-0.031555105,
-0.0325788967,
-0.026242042,
-0.0097932089,
0.008132345,
0.0339463353,
0.0015257119,
-0.0319178291,
0.03058834,
0.0078419158,
-0.0432629585,
-0.038654238,
-0.0246132612,
-0.0174773652,
0.0157068968,
0.0389675759,
-0.013672797,
0.0096451994,
-0.0435622334,
0.0196780562,
0.0562683791,
-0.0061185262,
0.0011415401,
-0.0135537116,
-0.0320614129,
-0.0553410761,
-0.0331168436,
0.0238477848,
0.0199642647,
0.0188277997,
0.0059249387,
-0.0106238872,
-0.0214091521,
-0.0453104302,
0.0266801137,
0.0282042101,
-0.0170110241,
-0.0042116907,
0.0364158452,
0.0690893978,
0.0185024962,
-0.0164759848,
-0.0274484735,
0.0087270914,
-0.0173171423,
-0.0320960991,
0.0315575264,
-0.017804889,
-0.0268388465,
0.0345283635,
-0.0245528407,
-0.0208592638,
0.0090116058,
0.004456203,
-0.0028317471,
0.0394194052,
-0.072214663,
0.0870652273,
-0.0516645461,
0.0013020092,
-0.0323076211,
0.0098483153,
-0.0049230279,
0.0611321554,
0.0069134971,
-0.0241406821,
0.0044320961,
-0.0279140733,
0.0445125438,
0.0396482199,
-0.0200931281,
-0.033857353,
0.0124274846,
0.0129663181,
0.0284926947,
-0.009598135,
-0.053985972,
-0.0543968603,
-0.0794609711,
-0.0603011101,
0.0049055144,
0.0220310688,
-0.0031358746,
-0.0205210727,
-0.0064699063,
0.0033164322,
-0.0476970561,
-0.0190948099,
-0.021303501,
0.0387808233,
0.0297738351,
-0.0025258753,
-0.0267964154,
-0.0077979509,
0.0455626659,
-0.031354256,
0.0630342513,
0.021495834,
-0.018025782,
0.0231848378,
-0.0285455864,
-0.0037510581,
-0.0361794829,
-0.0012895811,
-0.0398926921,
0.0170856938,
0.0300046057,
0.0602226779,
0.0142667051,
0.0471906811,
0.0389954075,
-0.0148068285,
0.0448116921,
-0.0713259876,
-0.0436797738,
-0.0226012468,
0.0015954192,
-0.0306547265,
-0.0537775457,
0.0626656115,
0.0434916653,
0.0105680833,
0.0242592599,
-0.047150664,
0.0299093239,
0.0469994023,
-0.0525720678,
-0.0329574905,
-0.0427108519,
-0.0152347069,
-0.0025369236,
-0.0180990305,
-0.0795121118,
0.065787144,
-0.0401866063,
-0.053122025,
-0.0164385177,
-0.0454308577,
-0.0090436619,
0.0324153937,
-0.0149359824,
0.041584108,
0.0653658733,
-0.028110005,
0.0169104002,
-0.0729169771,
0.0330170356,
-0.0356791392,
-0.0117678037,
0.0229293741,
0.0187496133,
0.0639697537,
-0.0159792025,
-0.0559842177,
-0.0821490288,
-0.0066780527,
-0.0481038876,
0.0405659452,
-0.0266006794,
-0.0658602789,
-0.0187659245,
-0.00091016,
-0.0167544484,
-0.0153686954,
-0.0233226884,
0.0170462411,
0.018556308,
0.0357283056,
-0.040579889,
-0.0077491677,
-0.0673257262,
0.0038065389,
0.0205808822,
-0.0115513941,
-0.051440578,
-0.037831869,
-0.0276754983,
0.0095366128,
-0.0215392504,
0.0255538132,
-0.0291597787,
0.0112847406,
-0.0342070013,
0.02599716,
0.0749425888,
0.0121339252,
-0.0265719853,
0.011623784,
0.0113449004,
0.0541083477,
-0.0166004635,
0.0108041791,
-0.0219525751,
-0.0367529877,
-0.0531070344,
0.0392250307,
-0.0451577567,
0.032648094,
-0.0091448687,
-0.0765618309,
0.0375109129,
0.02482141,
-0.0075321253,
0.0251456127,
-0.006942369,
-0.0353681892,
-0.0133375647,
-0.0200748034,
-0.0830651894,
-0.024090305,
0.004317801,
-0.0058691469,
-0.0292979665,
-0.0647881851,
-0.0205180738,
-0.0336798728,
0.0283553954,
0.0461893678,
0.0422263891,
-0.0106716352,
-0.078203775,
0.0675832704,
-0.0062345164,
-0.0131676784,
-0.0197033621,
0.0551989563,
-0.0416804664,
0.0071103573,
-0.0186800323,
0.0103432359,
-0.0076824352,
-0.0280850828,
0.0221535303,
0.0651908368,
-0.0046515502,
-0.0443281494,
-0.0067970231,
0.0338158384,
0.0358606167,
0.0993585065,
0.0190603714,
-0.0187845938,
0.0105366725,
-0.0235507339,
0.0068537029,
-0.0252060536,
-0.0232455488,
-0.0454109833,
-0.0346435569,
0.0204858053,
-0.0455147885,
-0.04225168,
-0.0021252255,
0.0313395672,
0.0176613927,
0.0520128608,
-0.0345927775,
0.0453551933,
0.0148456488,
0.0220239908,
-0.0349277034,
0.0235953443,
-0.0243152883,
-0.0521134101,
0.0018157884,
-0.0301498584,
-0.0195840299,
-0.0104489094,
-0.0301457047,
-0.0689158589,
-0.0618459284,
0.0562352277,
0.0185280815,
0.0328290872,
0.024133537,
-0.0475742854,
0.0905389115,
0.0698196217,
-0.0095443623,
-0.0027499388,
0.0747584254,
-0.0145701682,
0.0010091678,
0.0142028239,
0.0116861649,
0.0657486171,
0.0365332887,
-0.0076336013,
-0.0423602276,
-0.0221436005,
0.0204713866,
-0.0035250068,
0.0171211474,
-0.0444839597,
-0.0316740721,
-0.0354782566,
-0.0201174431,
0.0222593863,
-0.0201539975,
-0.0334518254,
0.0082506845,
0.0246983021,
-0.0023627109,
-0.0090266671,
0.0079988008,
-0.0331822373,
0.0395066962,
-0.0060782409,
0.0379395746,
-0.0142096281,
0.0304014869,
-0.0371558964,
0.0007799,
-0.0052987584,
0.0329684094,
0.0132508678,
0.0086339805,
0.0441955589,
0.0400075428,
0.0052547548,
-0.0568299145,
0.0212733056,
0.0453921184,
-0.0362108536,
-0.0010764286,
-0.004292177,
-0.0155226234,
0.0348459929,
-0.0212733913,
0.0781213567,
-0.0383546092,
-0.0208924189,
-0.0349531397,
0.0267541576,
-0.0275113098,
0.0028314737,
-0.0095233349,
-0.0091114165,
-0.0434369147,
-0.0139869414,
0.0243220646,
-0.0432711355,
0.0317075811,
0.0238519907,
-0.0559447818,
-0.0313144065,
-0.0387145057,
0.0562640391,
0.0340098403,
0.0001737712,
-0.0008418443,
-0.0223735142,
-0.0132367257,
0.0115404902,
-0.0179508012,
-0.0067542456,
0.0120007414,
0.0157788713,
0.0618815087,
-0.0220128298,
0.040545892,
-0.0430756584,
0.0015179833,
-0.0083148684,
0.0055096452,
-0.0056659728,
-5.769379906e-33,
0.03677921,
-0.0319850184,
-0.0273386445,
0.0155200707,
-0.0104094641,
-0.0145842591,
0.0047164257,
-0.0009696412,
0.0090985214,
0.0527835302,
0.0219463985,
-0.0172071103,
0.0085582593,
0.0156426094,
0.0065324879,
0.0227401126,
0.0527774952,
0.0131406989,
-0.0516123921,
0.0078443876,
0.0283254031,
0.0281190462,
0.0224909596,
-0.1064491868,
0.0477763116,
-0.0139646791,
-0.0396313593,
-0.0234891791,
0.035197854,
0.0724552944,
-0.0097527364,
0.0643611476,
0.0108252699,
-0.0272148922,
0.0099988608,
0.0973586962,
-0.029660305,
-0.0038163587,
0.0375053547,
-0.0224741735,
0.0065780906,
-0.0529883429,
0.0345961861,
-0.0412734784,
-0.0069482224,
0.0330610313,
0.0610822067,
-0.0353832245,
0.0325585194,
0.007537418,
-0.0422354937,
0.0292840768,
0.0075352243,
0.0071461005,
-0.0156144947,
0.0991402939,
-0.0038769359,
0.0886400342,
-0.0386286341,
0.0666428059,
0.0104345959,
-0.0166832488,
0.0178542621,
0.0097802281,
0.0042828037,
0.0874870569,
-0.0020708912,
-0.0007793737,
-0.0021162359,
-0.022870183,
0.0241698269,
0.0220717657,
0.0640382543,
0.0617019013,
0.0389929079,
0.0089212554,
-0.0343486555,
0.0160087813,
0.0546865799,
-0.0548985265,
0.0386051238,
-0.0114255007,
-0.0442914106,
-0.0166545007,
-0.0142803341,
-0.0422100872,
-0.0159233157,
-0.0521498732,
0.0220686886,
0.0170288868,
-0.0346505567,
0.0461756662,
0.0094584413,
-0.0354363993,
-0.0610041991,
-0.0344866067,
0.0215300135,
0.0090556061,
0.0149299074,
0.0068735429,
-0.0220382679,
0.0020992504,
0.0346802846,
0.0010945189,
0.0237760227,
0.0033705865,
0.0776283965,
-0.014053816,
-0.0737492293,
-0.005084414,
-0.0072238632,
-0.0114239631,
-0.0419904366,
-0.0004022397,
0.0142218545,
0.0258574393,
0.0054910462,
0.0141219934,
0.0025498986,
0.0069413125,
-0.0181683358,
-0.0364222564,
-0.0112740071,
0.0428677909,
-0.0032112293,
-0.0295995716,
-0.0152545758,
-0.0168286003,
0.0190569796,
-0.0651209131,
0.01057526,
-0.0650463253,
2.495e-7,
0.0358873121,
0.0428792797,
-0.0099947266,
-0.0263680182,
0.001255783,
0.0734101981,
-0.0361707732,
-0.0251852162,
-0.0046218457,
-0.0420152843,
0.0270346049,
0.0329540633,
0.0549719632,
-0.0145955756,
-0.0755814686,
-0.0556830019,
-0.0740664229,
0.0016658121,
-0.0706329346,
0.0248830039,
0.0744348019,
0.0730862692,
0.051286947,
-0.0406437404,
-0.0477275588,
-0.0250645373,
0.0855549574,
-0.0633159876,
0.0107911043,
0.0188376997,
0.0144063672,
-0.0276933871,
0.0003969091,
0.0123084579,
-0.0059629553,
-0.012235269,
-0.0124514597,
0.0567331314,
0.021459775,
-0.0257174987,
0.0024439942,
0.0159571581,
-0.010309265,
-0.0391320735,
0.0070989383,
-0.0399612226,
-0.0412207916,
-0.053738974,
-0.0403260402,
-0.0052460488,
0.0582602024,
-0.038575165,
-0.0226299856,
-0.0300893653,
0.0117151253,
-0.0131185828,
0.0121319061,
-0.0776942,
0.018798301,
0.0124797365,
-0.0301246606,
-0.0457374193,
-0.0422163494,
0.0148767922,
0.0367208496,
-0.04841258,
0.0251649003,
2.18999373e-34,
0.057305824,
-0.0429616943,
0.0285662115,
0.0110698463,
0.0152784185,
0.0246956255,
0.056680005,
0.001074355,
0.0069209137,
-0.0418646596,
0.0182033274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01725v1 | DiscoveryBench: Towards Data-Driven Discovery with Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T18:58:22 | 2024-07-01T18:58:22 | Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Harshit Surana, Dhruv Agarwal, Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Abhijeetsingh Meena, Aryan Prakhar, Tirth Vora, Tushar Khot, Ashish Sabharwal, Peter Clark | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Can the rapid advances in code generation, function calling, and data
analysis using large language models (LLMs) help automate the search and
verification of hypotheses purely from a set of provided datasets? To evaluate
this question, we present DiscoveryBench, the first comprehensive benchmark
that formalizes the multi-step process of data-driven discovery. The benchmark
is designed to systematically assess current model capabilities in discovery
tasks and provide a useful resource for improving them. Our benchmark contains
264 tasks collected across 6 diverse domains, such as sociology and
engineering, by manually deriving discovery workflows from published papers to
approximate the real-world challenges faced by researchers, where each task is
defined by a dataset, its metadata, and a discovery goal in natural language.
We additionally provide 903 synthetic tasks to conduct controlled evaluations
across task complexity. Furthermore, our structured formalism of data-driven
discovery enables a facet-based evaluation that provides useful insights into
different failure modes. We evaluate several popular LLM-based reasoning
frameworks using both open and closed LLMs as baselines on DiscoveryBench and
find that even the best system scores only 25%. Our benchmark, thus,
illustrates the challenges in autonomous data-driven discovery and serves as a
valuable resource for the community to make progress. | [
-0.0055923504,
0.0726018175,
-0.0218305197,
0.0401222184,
-0.0445148237,
-0.0121521838,
0.0010595095,
-0.0121931331,
0.0376392007,
-0.0166953281,
0.0323835462,
0.0160483196,
-0.0187015068,
0.0537822321,
-0.0132695828,
0.0200655684,
0.038803827,
-0.0344077796,
0.0043742494,
0.007544694,
-0.0294792764,
-0.0027979207,
0.0170782581,
0.0099897943,
0.0002313435,
-0.0200079586,
0.0056234589,
-0.0002681339,
-0.0101052541,
-0.0419146568,
0.0174767226,
0.0584160052,
0.0343628004,
0.0975897089,
0.0000021385,
-0.0868885219,
-0.0327897407,
0.031448435,
-0.0373832285,
0.0270052627,
0.020394206,
-0.0022075679,
0.0208401289,
0.014438021,
-0.007791962,
-0.0505688488,
0.0601466447,
-0.0367151089,
0.0245835837,
0.0573716611,
0.002341998,
-0.0427671075,
0.0016563407,
-0.0080008972,
0.035340488,
-0.0092001827,
0.048965618,
0.0466080867,
0.054134246,
-0.0309529919,
0.0201590192,
0.0283662323,
-0.0069562364,
-0.0157985892,
0.0071345926,
0.0182642266,
-0.0415181331,
-0.0075215064,
0.0064277127,
0.0772109404,
0.013426601,
-0.0351747088,
0.0248676464,
0.0034523171,
-0.0497280881,
0.0338808969,
-0.0334586352,
0.0098448358,
-0.0602075681,
-0.0269410554,
0.0334044807,
0.0021754643,
0.0813780203,
0.0415801592,
-0.0315566286,
0.1215137765,
-0.001378671,
-0.0134664495,
0.00252527,
-0.0367393345,
-0.0084227519,
-0.0320032053,
0.0287064798,
0.0194455832,
-0.0371322073,
0.0099204872,
0.0286519323,
-0.0364815667,
0.0260508638,
0.0094148172,
-0.0067884754,
0.0236307643,
-0.0086487401,
0.0608916581,
-0.0077168425,
0.0051338272,
-0.0615552254,
-0.040648859,
0.0057521262,
-0.0134300878,
-0.053532511,
-0.0305516832,
0.0001410805,
0.0263330229,
-0.0280447062,
0.0076851472,
-0.0026865886,
0.0413013436,
-0.0213473905,
0.0098601934,
-0.008676813,
-0.0370065831,
-0.0098236753,
0.0124574285,
-0.0279858876,
-0.0102716312,
-0.0228646956,
-0.0010126079,
-0.0248162262,
-0.0420746058,
0.0119168013,
0.0191038661,
0.0049325908,
-0.0268385764,
0.0430583023,
0.0705272108,
0.0309849009,
0.0004918113,
-0.0366390757,
-0.048316814,
0.0139983073,
-0.0779689178,
0.0064997887,
-0.1040071845,
0.009147726,
0.0593241081,
-0.0167710129,
-0.0429459102,
-0.020744741,
-0.0100327823,
0.009505,
0.071175538,
-0.0611398108,
0.0309311431,
0.0443974473,
0.0423705764,
0.0219265074,
0.0768705085,
0.00211519,
-0.0026681677,
0.0373789184,
-0.0127909388,
0.0187058486,
0.0238243602,
-0.0019513151,
0.0155135263,
0.0071878359,
0.0624174178,
0.0014397723,
0.0321265385,
-0.0240939483,
0.0387087986,
-0.0072119003,
0.0045981654,
0.0233972967,
0.066928491,
0.0052865292,
0.0041784314,
0.0266837385,
0.0134604611,
0.0188142825,
-0.0704563409,
0.0014080541,
0.0111461757,
-0.0492567047,
-0.0245645996,
0.0083201118,
0.0368891582,
-0.0186509304,
-0.0465092212,
-0.0499931462,
0.0302195139,
-0.0190937985,
0.0204674322,
0.0696270019,
-0.0004404112,
-0.0004564217,
0.0260049962,
0.0006029587,
-0.051579617,
-0.0187905524,
-0.0408925042,
0.0411346219,
0.0377923697,
0.10451217,
-0.1036400944,
-0.0371240936,
0.0003532545,
0.0797226205,
0.0179550461,
0.0225858074,
-0.0329726823,
-0.0433555096,
-0.0038756016,
-0.0129534071,
-0.0117666889,
0.0116627691,
-0.0105813565,
0.0521790832,
-0.0273474064,
-0.0164979789,
-0.0739220455,
-0.059341982,
0.0287363827,
-0.0436326414,
-0.0063633169,
0.0571890101,
-0.0201033894,
0.02515845,
0.0176311731,
-0.0198924709,
0.0242221113,
0.0281641744,
-0.016820889,
-0.0149657056,
0.0136340512,
0.0577897765,
-0.0015200283,
0.0233625211,
-0.0568094142,
-0.0277151559,
0.0350942053,
-0.0194786284,
-0.0100345276,
0.0550194196,
-0.0229346417,
-0.0134859029,
-0.0105366502,
0.0200085379,
-0.0545210466,
0.010835587,
-0.0029521605,
0.0777855366,
-0.0051230891,
0.0309286844,
0.0022001714,
0.0465652533,
0.0455762222,
0.0067442697,
-0.0373410769,
0.0105284592,
-0.0258471817,
0.0228644814,
0.0479069948,
-0.0251943059,
-0.0128012225,
0.0056968154,
-0.0210581981,
0.0517688729,
-0.0107570309,
0.0199256204,
-0.0011129073,
0.0066351485,
-0.002859788,
0.0091567347,
-0.0011330708,
-0.0070575788,
0.0020766482,
-0.0002962563,
0.0436605662,
0.023318531,
-0.0876210108,
-0.0243736971,
-0.0110786678,
-0.0546452366,
0.0403543152,
0.0129665732,
0.0002562538,
-0.0387365669,
0.0329218283,
-0.0248534605,
0.0310273413,
-0.0603774451,
0.0161070842,
0.0262825433,
-0.0135554392,
0.0333377384,
0.0504696071,
-0.0417578369,
0.0304070618,
0.0598918386,
-0.0094258031,
-0.0130400788,
0.0211768579,
-0.0328726284,
0.0087466016,
-0.0152562372,
-0.0261189155,
0.0072531137,
0.0424293391,
-0.0200216342,
-0.0301080719,
-0.011472513,
0.0407729559,
0.0038221676,
0.0084343459,
-0.0260118861,
-0.0048898533,
0.0454003178,
0.069400914,
-0.0098554622,
-0.0783714727,
0.0539116077,
-0.0252952129,
-0.0026167107,
-0.0269781426,
-0.0204164423,
-0.0821605623,
0.080303289,
-0.0074215266,
-0.0099724568,
0.0056675142,
0.011381791,
0.0121432785,
-0.0120902071,
0.0200770386,
-0.0329183191,
0.0713344067,
-0.0659582391,
0.0425504409,
0.0409867205,
-0.0735692829,
-0.0199441314,
-0.0130022308,
-0.0495459698,
0.0369835198,
-0.0013952899,
-0.0531602539,
-0.0268140268,
0.0016244577,
0.0308219641,
0.0383368097,
0.0139228469,
-0.0227621533,
-0.0467154756,
-0.0439106785,
0.0094958851,
-0.0587211251,
0.0487493388,
-0.0058256229,
0.0530075617,
0.0111516202,
-0.0072682216,
0.0126266405,
-0.0678720251,
-0.0017641908,
-0.0089232344,
-0.0241667628,
0.0205361415,
0.0333393142,
-0.0205803644,
-0.0370641574,
-0.0234567914,
0.0637623295,
0.0215287954,
-0.0452782214,
0.0041591786,
-0.0060337214,
0.0198333003,
0.0734893605,
0.0421346836,
-0.0929231793,
-0.0326516591,
0.0062327622,
0.0339739099,
-0.0302205924,
-0.061723046,
-0.0202223305,
-0.0966793969,
0.0685783774,
-0.0138383629,
-0.0257605072,
-0.0139107406,
-0.1152416319,
-0.0057323291,
-0.039072074,
-0.0435747094,
-0.0125809917,
0.0117665781,
-0.0234778374,
-0.0172872283,
-0.039374467,
-0.068483077,
0.0639762804,
-0.0298536718,
0.0075831823,
0.025700137,
0.0279807895,
-0.0189773031,
-0.0086752027,
0.0155237699,
0.0254600719,
-0.0039914623,
-0.0365819968,
0.026170915,
0.021305833,
-0.0008394774,
-0.0046512671,
0.0466445275,
-0.084343262,
-0.0123813795,
0.0270805378,
0.1312348098,
-0.0208574366,
-0.0174903292,
-0.0365965106,
-0.0058625471,
0.0253419951,
0.0917386338,
-0.0231845472,
-0.009015278,
-0.0157820992,
-0.0157684311,
-0.0186723452,
-0.0425828919,
-0.0391504802,
-0.0076287724,
-0.0052205496,
-0.0213487446,
-0.0123843318,
0.0461765081,
0.0510780327,
0.0056346967,
0.0257135555,
0.0370644107,
-0.0180283692,
0.0049831471,
-0.0988495275,
0.0477717146,
-0.0158235952,
0.0438745208,
-0.0363262668,
-0.0084228311,
0.0325868726,
-0.0320867412,
-0.0155872172,
0.0497584231,
-0.0946742147,
-0.0657365918,
-0.0374796316,
0.0062511158,
0.0245656949,
0.0461196862,
-0.0449285991,
-0.0791472197,
-0.0131067205,
0.0666225255,
-0.0178642944,
-0.0511918701,
-0.0044530672,
-0.029294895,
-0.0066631073,
-0.0067191757,
-0.0303910747,
0.0224426463,
0.0229202565,
0.0200110637,
-0.0212291051,
-0.0129081914,
0.0336548053,
0.0710119978,
0.051831983,
-0.0008495062,
-0.0545703806,
-0.0269865375,
-0.0309884436,
-0.0040233298,
-0.058423169,
-0.0304011721,
0.03714725,
0.0018897692,
-0.0122980895,
0.015008091,
0.0454672202,
-0.0022203922,
0.0054360833,
-0.0353981815,
0.0314413905,
0.0043863165,
0.0448844023,
0.0664213672,
-0.0428256914,
0.0184241664,
0.0086520454,
-0.0221688971,
0.0518234409,
-0.0121887056,
0.0321863107,
0.0338016786,
0.0110438997,
-0.018252233,
-0.0186972935,
-0.0524903499,
-0.0528160967,
-0.0183257274,
-0.0067671719,
0.026169112,
0.0403566919,
-0.0020472773,
-0.0686442852,
-0.0255563222,
-0.0309080072,
0.0309429895,
-0.0138813136,
-0.0325837806,
0.04538434,
0.0490811504,
-0.0497795902,
-0.016317986,
0.0472932905,
0.0409763753,
0.0425872058,
0.0143887503,
-0.0573589392,
-0.026470853,
-0.0326455198,
0.019964613,
0.0037658813,
-0.0295652114,
-0.0111350641,
-0.0823811814,
-0.0551496744,
-0.0073099597,
0.0206725299,
-0.0111575816,
0.0151744755,
0.0194237344,
0.0821149796,
0.0191019922,
-0.0491064526,
-0.0356950313,
0.0068261791,
-0.0557240434,
-0.0346158519,
0.0178676713,
-6.437277429e-33,
0.041529756,
-0.041229371,
0.0572638102,
-0.0007827265,
0.0236461088,
0.0218124148,
-0.0613993965,
-0.0026657707,
0.0019548463,
0.0180396959,
0.0075076735,
0.0380719379,
-0.0156397969,
-0.0139242085,
0.0182231478,
0.0150518697,
0.0114627434,
0.0251755174,
-0.0304394681,
0.0070330682,
0.0392423831,
-0.0116041405,
0.0112396544,
-0.055684872,
-0.0232447162,
0.0046317279,
-0.0051468085,
0.0832204074,
-0.0420747995,
0.031240318,
-0.0107751284,
0.0259396974,
-0.0028984488,
-0.0292031989,
-0.0028297738,
-0.0204465333,
-0.0503789745,
0.0053512598,
0.0308878031,
-0.01004308,
-0.0175084285,
-0.0340003371,
0.0209998023,
0.0157728959,
-0.0246824846,
0.005433761,
0.0263612773,
-0.020081168,
0.0138558811,
-0.0226603765,
-0.0500715002,
0.0424001701,
-0.0576888844,
-0.0020954774,
0.040076308,
0.0298948716,
-0.0021380133,
0.0305535886,
-0.0106999408,
0.0558870174,
0.0290324669,
-0.0083447574,
0.084562242,
0.0254304502,
0.0291217696,
0.0301678721,
0.0281303562,
0.0452046208,
0.0015909448,
0.0286739524,
0.0255691186,
0.0941310152,
0.0142020835,
0.04328667,
0.0119937789,
0.0243974458,
-0.0809345767,
0.0311939307,
-0.002532196,
-0.0312690921,
0.0528654717,
0.0215606205,
-0.0473546274,
-0.0455698781,
-0.0370583571,
0.0206415839,
-0.0395138338,
0.0042139697,
0.0103119034,
-0.014296446,
-0.0287706926,
0.0031542762,
0.0200799853,
-0.067039527,
-0.0161847156,
0.0377632268,
-0.009928382,
0.0135481339,
-0.0011741075,
0.0259281099,
-0.0422541723,
-0.0565011427,
-0.0210500155,
0.0234037153,
0.0397748649,
0.0010702634,
-0.0141395489,
0.0178930815,
-0.016875999,
-0.015540814,
-0.0361227132,
-0.0109739173,
-0.0041794395,
0.0117793037,
0.0048861541,
0.0252511911,
0.0138110034,
0.0135308001,
0.0797464177,
0.0023467438,
-0.0222306028,
0.0371385776,
-0.0050185071,
0.0006698275,
0.0086203497,
-0.0453060754,
-0.0472918004,
-0.0038566447,
0.0626433641,
-0.0460392386,
0.0047835703,
0.0298647229,
2.985e-7,
0.0473790355,
0.0444543213,
-0.0294420496,
0.0436770096,
0.0280214641,
0.0007027168,
-0.0232006889,
-0.0327795409,
-0.0002225533,
-0.0303927176,
0.0016788011,
0.0069576367,
0.0539235435,
0.0269655064,
-0.0688356981,
-0.0213463698,
-0.0066074771,
-0.0101316478,
-0.0833122805,
-0.0214927252,
-0.0446890108,
0.0323430263,
0.010078094,
-0.0017979791,
0.0016461875,
-0.0276174843,
-0.0033950615,
-0.013914885,
0.0256367903,
0.0843920559,
-0.0139974616,
0.0155095346,
0.0247387718,
0.0310182367,
-0.0148972105,
0.0190889481,
-0.0157764293,
0.0386443995,
0.0245198756,
0.0523829833,
0.0003585035,
-0.0554526299,
-0.0114498893,
-0.0398032218,
0.057207223,
-0.0260004718,
-0.0657203645,
-0.0036587643,
0.0102167148,
-0.0412516706,
-0.0000986363,
-0.0297525339,
0.031916596,
0.0034684653,
-0.0319958925,
-0.0297195222,
-0.0083660549,
-0.0442851819,
-0.0062393709,
0.0522633791,
-0.0585788451,
-0.0453643426,
-0.0234297141,
-0.0001050506,
0.011551531,
-0.0321812145,
0.0513435863,
3.22769971e-34,
0.0271604229,
0.0188321508,
-0.0133994883,
-0.0235236529,
0.0743655488,
-0.0140783824,
-0.0426139943,
0.0033798737,
0.0030821073,
-0.0640457124,
0.0106779691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01697v1 | NLPGuard: A Framework for Mitigating the Use of Protected Attributes by NLP Classifiers | 2024-07-01T18:08:17 | 2024-07-01T18:08:17 | Salvatore Greco, Ke Zhou, Licia Capra, Tania Cerquitelli, Daniele Quercia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | AI regulations are expected to prohibit machine learning models from using
sensitive attributes during training. However, the latest Natural Language
Processing (NLP) classifiers, which rely on deep learning, operate as black-box
systems, complicating the detection and remediation of such misuse. Traditional
bias mitigation methods in NLP aim for comparable performance across different
groups based on attributes like gender or race but fail to address the
underlying issue of reliance on protected attributes. To partly fix that, we
introduce NLPGuard, a framework for mitigating the reliance on protected
attributes in NLP classifiers. NLPGuard takes an unlabeled dataset, an existing
NLP classifier, and its training data as input, producing a modified training
dataset that significantly reduces dependence on protected attributes without
compromising accuracy. NLPGuard is applied to three classification tasks:
identifying toxic language, sentiment analysis, and occupation classification.
Our evaluation shows that current NLP classifiers heavily depend on protected
attributes, with up to $23\%$ of the most predictive words associated with
these attributes. However, NLPGuard effectively reduces this reliance by up to
$79\%$, while slightly improving accuracy. | [
0.0196209401,
0.135310322,
-0.015095084,
0.0132507775,
-0.0178322326,
0.0235601738,
0.0382625163,
-0.0159020852,
0.0104663866,
-0.0753030851,
-0.0053235968,
-0.0206115693,
-0.003461364,
0.0309144091,
-0.0013386611,
-0.0167269353,
0.0300701223,
0.0417619124,
0.0470651239,
-0.0214809086,
0.0031287544,
0.0276769549,
-0.0016269743,
0.0558323115,
-0.0300337281,
-0.0208317358,
0.0754924864,
-0.0265178178,
0.0257392321,
-0.0049176067,
0.0581693351,
0.020569738,
-0.0391041301,
0.031503424,
0.0000018384,
-0.0476452149,
0.0095150676,
0.0319537111,
-0.0128818564,
-0.0398515314,
0.0447002612,
-0.0319835916,
0.0306659285,
0.0419621766,
-0.0430607125,
-0.048142679,
0.0365788788,
0.0768352598,
0.0526916273,
0.0634689257,
-0.0138121769,
-0.0186270773,
-0.0013044834,
-0.0024590078,
-0.0036496231,
-0.0290448908,
0.0316768251,
-0.079050675,
-0.0553635024,
0.0152711859,
-0.0038316203,
0.0232599545,
0.0057360437,
0.0207282379,
0.0215075389,
0.0101656783,
-0.0314355455,
-0.0317029655,
0.0215579476,
0.0532979257,
-0.0391337797,
-0.02161563,
-0.0165839437,
-0.0314848945,
0.0364391096,
-0.0341449007,
0.0005662206,
0.0411310755,
-0.0254828352,
0.0016389649,
-0.0154665578,
0.0266035609,
0.0312209819,
0.0527522564,
0.0414494276,
0.0590406284,
0.002087848,
-0.0068194722,
0.0343332514,
0.0007991531,
0.0048714522,
0.0011017611,
0.0071929782,
-0.0258701127,
0.0115483953,
0.0142036555,
-0.0577950887,
-0.0353809781,
0.0356060416,
-0.0653959215,
-0.0048466525,
0.009452709,
-0.0145398248,
0.0167807173,
-0.0212185513,
0.0124651529,
0.0113257375,
0.0230676234,
0.0335380323,
-0.0042005195,
-0.039180804,
-0.0319183804,
-0.0066770194,
0.0218792707,
-0.0189424697,
0.0438613892,
-0.0343209133,
0.0012042924,
-0.0919864252,
0.001781133,
-0.0155797461,
0.0621765256,
-0.0084315911,
0.0447601154,
-0.0112459529,
-0.0317659639,
0.0158126503,
0.0194853619,
-0.034155298,
-0.0611057989,
0.0058563328,
0.002634509,
-0.0055639627,
-0.0295147486,
0.022025967,
0.098717548,
0.0442220569,
-0.0242820587,
-0.0096185915,
-0.0465395078,
-0.0153259775,
-0.0155629097,
0.0249498487,
-0.0257221609,
0.0084354645,
-0.0245338418,
-0.0063373223,
-0.1125358939,
0.0097089857,
0.024666043,
-0.0642915145,
0.0902820826,
0.0347385183,
-0.0389384888,
0.0085817818,
0.033253558,
-0.0185888167,
0.0462101661,
0.0198300648,
0.0262073092,
0.0559952371,
-0.0298047811,
0.0215094462,
-0.0146681033,
0.0323315263,
0.0026272407,
0.0134969559,
-0.0046123355,
-0.0092117535,
-0.040299464,
0.0241526477,
-0.0032624973,
0.0174509324,
-0.0614036098,
0.0650349185,
0.0306755677,
-0.0105429683,
0.0423880853,
0.0092346659,
0.0025106668,
-0.0068619885,
-0.0592393465,
-0.060814824,
-0.02759015,
-0.0547743253,
-0.0583181232,
-0.0468577445,
0.035875041,
-0.0246462226,
-0.0412362106,
-0.0074609905,
-0.0042174747,
0.0674183294,
0.0125359502,
-0.0068352204,
0.0340077877,
-0.0054110764,
0.0453416221,
0.0410748869,
-0.0116079729,
0.0023387845,
-0.0424478687,
-0.0048658741,
0.0479553714,
0.0125376815,
-0.0410201512,
0.0290727429,
-0.0685318634,
-0.0403168537,
0.0046003042,
0.0228430722,
0.008887819,
0.0607442781,
-0.019460462,
-0.0134617863,
-0.019619504,
0.0320740715,
0.0130455662,
0.0453205928,
0.0559872687,
0.0166097973,
0.011736352,
-0.0763185918,
0.0456807204,
0.0299179852,
-0.098808147,
0.0398903415,
0.0060165809,
0.0273406338,
0.0245510396,
-0.0114503773,
-0.0167994201,
-0.0234174319,
-0.0034148127,
-0.0653288141,
-0.0072380817,
-0.0303345341,
-0.0082980618,
-0.0122685516,
-0.0291190892,
-0.0244819876,
0.0562670976,
-0.0191607773,
0.029557595,
0.005435999,
-0.0053679137,
-0.0183599237,
-0.0109165628,
-0.0215675533,
-0.0113548199,
0.0588569492,
-0.0378856286,
0.0353216939,
-0.008800135,
-0.020391278,
-0.0426120572,
-0.0309378095,
0.0006991655,
-0.0118853264,
-0.026224833,
-0.0114801219,
-0.0181064196,
0.036945492,
0.0287030395,
0.0106080724,
-0.0198270958,
0.009776541,
0.0020794051,
0.0027293393,
-0.0213053562,
0.0118565941,
-0.0179591347,
-0.0054375441,
-0.0058488622,
-0.0165592451,
-0.0290919058,
-0.0616921186,
-0.0140874833,
0.0399955772,
0.0058198934,
-0.0158770103,
0.0038932306,
0.0196322743,
-0.0051874276,
-0.0199867859,
0.0590859577,
-0.0070056845,
-0.0201323833,
-0.0009245417,
-0.0248733964,
0.0045400732,
0.0452048145,
0.0194992516,
-0.013044457,
-0.0109179961,
0.0624461621,
-0.0924424902,
0.0576939769,
0.003105816,
0.0455620922,
0.0241325758,
0.0534040108,
-0.0112348981,
0.0081075979,
-0.0164902061,
0.0184578151,
0.0174605697,
-0.0029195228,
-0.0108945621,
0.0427668579,
0.0067747138,
-0.054553967,
-0.0444460437,
0.0595548004,
-0.0309676286,
-0.0732663646,
-0.0134883905,
-0.0343665928,
0.0018944072,
-0.0027608224,
-0.0331369154,
-0.0518086702,
0.0540695563,
0.0106299045,
0.0218020082,
-0.0340051018,
-0.0303086527,
-0.0302830916,
0.0561091639,
0.0221489482,
0.0442083329,
0.0498358235,
-0.0171042494,
0.0081022345,
0.003793587,
0.0259055421,
-0.0449081585,
-0.0111481808,
-0.0082908599,
-0.0119185587,
0.0001802495,
-0.0620446987,
-0.0603340678,
-0.0480367579,
0.0006479232,
0.0083576217,
-0.0191861279,
-0.0107385684,
-0.0247114245,
-0.0361787751,
-0.0190036986,
-0.0024744207,
0.0027436088,
-0.0212272573,
0.0158199407,
-0.002039785,
0.0172825586,
-0.0397305079,
-0.0012018456,
0.0355535522,
0.0099501852,
0.086278595,
-0.0402690396,
0.0361586437,
0.0135483854,
0.0201910213,
0.0189342592,
-0.0306378882,
-0.0156841446,
-0.0279987156,
0.0043900949,
-0.0366177596,
-0.0002927016,
0.0526030585,
0.0121486252,
-0.0187585633,
0.0384070314,
0.0218049772,
0.0260696169,
0.0330411792,
-0.0138928862,
-0.0765265971,
-0.0209348053,
0.0071354164,
0.0270460173,
-0.0697552562,
-0.0496110804,
-0.0044494639,
-0.0947187841,
0.0075395661,
-0.0091346139,
-0.0678293556,
-0.0418426879,
-0.0366945565,
-0.0112516806,
-0.0722082108,
0.0245884191,
-0.072135061,
0.0228076112,
0.0000619749,
0.0059932647,
-0.0884107649,
-0.0395043045,
0.0484465398,
-0.0135171171,
0.0295036398,
0.035948962,
0.0380564183,
-0.0345022865,
-0.0004156172,
0.0111989938,
0.0024730172,
0.004597072,
-0.014704952,
0.0949992761,
-0.0487103127,
-0.0401409715,
-0.0235745646,
0.0656148568,
-0.0059164693,
0.0028599151,
0.0085775079,
0.0530292094,
-0.0011785454,
-0.0215274487,
-0.0321205817,
-0.0372394249,
0.0295751486,
0.0676980987,
-0.0142713934,
-0.0641671941,
-0.0221646614,
-0.0646548271,
-0.0226889253,
-0.0388423987,
-0.0769544318,
0.0374377593,
0.0085164914,
-0.0506291576,
-0.0394006446,
-0.0512201302,
0.0236961246,
-0.0118673267,
0.002053035,
-0.0188158285,
-0.0094475085,
0.0039729057,
-0.0965633094,
0.036872901,
-0.0085787121,
0.0160448607,
0.0450836383,
-0.0230953395,
0.0077721556,
0.0188544802,
-0.0235946253,
0.0207968634,
0.0009681885,
-0.0637493879,
0.0518532395,
0.0381420925,
0.0163461734,
0.0210081283,
-0.0299116671,
-0.0935511738,
0.0638497099,
0.0926612243,
-0.0442000553,
-0.0127750579,
0.0657183528,
-0.0330170505,
0.0179034304,
0.0198609233,
-0.0198246576,
0.0099146469,
0.0430090204,
-0.0508655198,
-0.016245652,
-0.0215100218,
0.0098439911,
0.0363315195,
0.0071194479,
-0.0000169535,
0.0126408804,
-0.0047530825,
-0.0098856231,
0.0121090719,
-0.0211095233,
-0.0051354938,
0.0199129712,
0.057690762,
0.0158029292,
-0.0306185447,
0.0105942227,
0.0086986776,
0.0392022654,
-0.0439823456,
0.0416881181,
0.029100284,
0.024512507,
0.0106226299,
0.0184299573,
-0.0002742916,
0.0162701998,
0.0043635285,
0.0205747616,
0.0220255591,
0.0042540915,
0.0244263094,
0.0432585031,
-0.0392387919,
0.0165226869,
-0.0367056318,
-0.016224958,
-0.0192756355,
0.0193649754,
-0.0068576941,
-0.0454181731,
-0.0140502602,
-0.0263249725,
-0.027017314,
0.0175715648,
-0.006101538,
0.0019667628,
-0.0172756109,
0.0142382924,
0.016053101,
-0.0162603315,
0.010556113,
0.0668477044,
0.0687440857,
0.0745230019,
-0.0041059186,
-0.0279371515,
-0.021981081,
-0.0072990428,
0.0465992242,
-0.0003246783,
-0.0106114587,
0.0239992663,
-0.0454844199,
-0.0833827406,
0.0013977286,
-0.0572084039,
0.0599846728,
0.0125591084,
-0.0207437519,
0.007111921,
0.0067568137,
-0.026091719,
-0.0490694381,
-0.0137466295,
0.020143982,
-0.0124337068,
-0.0003484442,
-5.575007874e-33,
0.025700856,
-0.019194968,
-0.0249046981,
0.0314575806,
0.0109392731,
0.0008426478,
0.0616826825,
-0.0181169938,
-0.0042321221,
0.0356137678,
0.000815345,
0.0188964549,
-0.011183409,
0.0304939877,
0.0110651283,
-0.0337883234,
0.0277967509,
0.0107232677,
-0.0179646313,
0.0123628294,
0.036895927,
0.0372537337,
0.0353024043,
-0.1212511063,
0.0524856523,
0.0350455344,
-0.0198918357,
0.0014664759,
-0.0412333831,
0.0374422371,
-0.0091027766,
0.092660211,
0.0257049594,
-0.0769376606,
0.0163317826,
0.0489703491,
-0.0758890063,
-0.0122129098,
-0.0212372802,
0.0256960448,
0.0162697807,
-0.04046534,
0.0474522486,
0.0213636123,
-0.0184321422,
-0.0296490081,
0.020091543,
-0.034966331,
0.0187455006,
-0.0507643409,
-0.0195635743,
0.0227505844,
-0.0356583707,
0.044303406,
0.029700892,
0.0081792828,
-0.0014505821,
0.0150705241,
-0.078361012,
-0.0309086647,
-0.017892886,
-0.0206513386,
0.0076434477,
0.0101455655,
0.0079176044,
0.052875448,
0.0510549136,
0.0363246799,
-0.0243338384,
0.0037292978,
-0.0002918839,
0.0138966255,
0.0353669077,
0.0496945754,
0.0525530316,
-0.0662956536,
-0.0762720108,
-0.0142037263,
0.0085159978,
-0.0053029158,
0.0162476003,
-0.0205624755,
-0.0839255974,
-0.033396747,
-0.029314151,
-0.0282448586,
-0.0287154298,
-0.0055514998,
0.0035522552,
0.0030373551,
-0.031373702,
0.0376596376,
-0.0448620431,
-0.0593666844,
0.0067517702,
0.0212629884,
0.0073893955,
-0.0255405251,
0.0073167486,
-0.0300247855,
-0.0170945898,
-0.0125278886,
0.004616322,
-0.0240033958,
0.0854356512,
-0.0103194648,
0.1011889279,
0.0391569585,
-0.0766202137,
-0.0050803483,
-0.0186127741,
0.0680493414,
0.044063691,
0.0676720962,
-0.0022400792,
0.0148657374,
-0.0015385043,
0.0168691762,
0.059902966,
0.0350628942,
-0.0161342956,
0.0029668431,
-0.0028338435,
-0.0329910517,
-0.005001259,
-0.0594000258,
0.0336944945,
-0.0133587541,
0.026711667,
-0.0864121243,
-0.0017213295,
-0.0626618043,
2.591e-7,
0.0342332385,
0.03397917,
-0.0285229608,
-0.0100743202,
0.0037882794,
0.0582739897,
0.0472133979,
0.0850023106,
0.003131313,
-0.0236432869,
-0.0182224773,
0.0256575551,
-0.0022014813,
0.0317865722,
-0.0731778443,
0.0152091151,
-0.0384349599,
0.0115779024,
-0.0223634895,
0.0002489293,
0.0470380262,
0.0812629759,
0.0393306836,
-0.0485958531,
-0.0015977452,
-0.0245926939,
0.029268248,
-0.0174897127,
0.0144347595,
0.005856236,
0.0806204751,
0.0490496308,
0.0261815693,
0.0406040139,
-0.044034116,
0.032077048,
-0.0108007966,
0.0567987561,
-0.0432311036,
-0.0367546827,
-0.0178810135,
-0.0398997217,
-0.0091973906,
-0.0233976599,
0.0660168827,
0.0168857742,
-0.0588217303,
-0.0699281693,
-0.0280901324,
-0.0027084907,
0.0529928356,
0.0006687417,
0.0098025538,
-0.0111286882,
0.0091055604,
-0.0235710982,
-0.0070391498,
-0.1045021862,
-0.0407668464,
0.0026842135,
0.0329740234,
-0.0157990083,
0.0370236933,
0.0616533123,
0.048521284,
-0.0430048816,
0.0289045125,
2.284683473e-34,
0.0109725418,
0.0037616915,
0.0178856235,
-0.0112863285,
0.0144307092,
0.0115724355,
0.0372199267,
-0.0135130221,
0.0154358177,
0.0116551146,
0.0003421408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01687v1 | Deciphering the Factors Influencing the Efficacy of Chain-of-Thought: Probability, Memorization, and Noisy Reasoning | 2024-07-01T18:01:07 | 2024-07-01T18:01:07 | Akshara Prabhakar, Thomas L. Griffiths, R. Thomas McCoy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has been shown to enhance the multi-step
reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). However, debates
persist about whether LLMs exhibit abstract generalization or rely on shallow
heuristics when given CoT prompts. To understand the factors influencing CoT
reasoning we provide a detailed case study of the symbolic reasoning task of
decoding shift ciphers, where letters are shifted forward some number of steps
in the alphabet. GPT-4 achieves zero accuracy on most shift ciphers with
standard prompting, but with CoT its accuracy improves to an average of 32%. By
focusing on a single relatively simple task, we are able to identify three
factors that systematically affect CoT performance: the probability of the
task's expected output (probability), what the model has implicitly learned
during pre-training (memorization), and the number of intermediate operations
involved in reasoning (noisy reasoning). We show that these factors can
drastically influence the task accuracy; e.g., varying the output's probability
of occurrence can shift accuracy from 26% to 70%. We also demonstrate that it
is essential for the model to explicitly produce intermediate steps as output
that can be conditioned on to increase the probability of the correct answer.
Our experiments indicate that as long as the model does so, the validity of the
demonstrations in the prompt does not matter. Overall, we conclude that CoT
prompting performance reflects both memorization and a probabilistic version of
genuine reasoning. | [
0.0253911018,
0.0642235354,
-0.010040055,
0.0153231174,
-0.0800844133,
0.0447709821,
0.0380544253,
-0.0137039283,
-0.0209676195,
0.0060209674,
0.0223183371,
-0.0268468037,
0.0332106836,
-0.0130218649,
0.0336554423,
-0.0283980649,
0.033895947,
-0.1059884131,
-0.0056705656,
-0.0264545996,
-0.0314861611,
0.0150506636,
-0.0508319139,
0.0331561156,
0.0264848769,
-0.0175019894,
-0.0610119738,
-0.0125298705,
0.002550127,
-0.0344484039,
-0.0365642905,
0.0650545806,
0.0103770318,
0.0666302219,
0.0000023428,
-0.0527201891,
0.0218687393,
-0.0046240818,
-0.0649389476,
0.0291789975,
-0.030025553,
-0.0061221351,
-0.0232361462,
0.0250189323,
-0.0088556726,
0.0016424706,
0.0375677645,
0.0320737287,
0.0118887266,
0.0549987331,
0.0097480174,
-0.0203904416,
0.0262074787,
-0.0196535029,
0.0282028746,
-0.0566567928,
0.0171858333,
0.0154909389,
0.0019080091,
0.0213773251,
-0.0113111902,
0.015715234,
0.0547685772,
0.0355078466,
-0.0415573232,
0.0608121045,
0.0145266661,
-0.0235119723,
-0.0426390693,
0.0030870207,
-0.0307987351,
-0.0417490751,
-0.013487271,
-0.0132860029,
0.0258583631,
0.0180877354,
-0.0291412864,
0.0505426079,
-0.0415894054,
0.0049176593,
0.0212513991,
0.0288006049,
0.0367090292,
-0.0075665805,
-0.0879915878,
0.0886825621,
-0.0255561378,
-0.0577472709,
0.0293944627,
0.0070421388,
0.0185871366,
-0.060247615,
0.0038430004,
0.0377436802,
0.0023801012,
0.0330128819,
-0.001565197,
-0.0201940276,
-0.0027234848,
-0.0349484719,
0.0288099628,
0.0708674043,
-0.0105952034,
0.0173224788,
-0.0618808083,
0.0599065237,
-0.0226350632,
0.0436089337,
-0.0094307903,
0.0365047157,
-0.066944316,
-0.0463897474,
-0.0332866572,
0.0608803146,
0.0278228596,
-0.0112807574,
-0.0264513884,
0.0044927183,
0.0334510133,
0.0163488425,
-0.0057812878,
-0.0279729962,
0.020484494,
-0.0340602174,
-0.0316929221,
0.014584152,
-0.0401650183,
0.0237142164,
0.0346943848,
-0.026824059,
-0.0233913213,
-0.0339902714,
-0.0198940057,
-0.0291115493,
0.0140155796,
0.070521839,
-0.0397837162,
-0.0170842726,
-0.0448516943,
-0.0121881515,
0.0100806924,
-0.0836230069,
0.02317857,
-0.066866532,
-0.0108107105,
0.0448586792,
0.0030018089,
0.0071988488,
0.0116947088,
0.0273842998,
-0.0661927462,
0.0810355693,
0.04149241,
0.0199098922,
0.018753957,
0.0281885564,
-0.0410243124,
0.0476277433,
0.0418170169,
0.0290505011,
-0.0332744904,
-0.0167722274,
0.0323202834,
0.0384636261,
0.0077505042,
-0.0172443949,
0.0080348542,
-0.0100537576,
0.0156506933,
0.0532349981,
0.0258912425,
0.0408801623,
-0.0505956709,
0.0131278513,
0.0650619492,
0.06720265,
0.0093296776,
0.0260360911,
0.0379171558,
-0.0150371697,
0.0268749744,
0.0381508358,
-0.0926816538,
0.0364705995,
-0.0466828942,
0.0180982817,
-0.0071874908,
0.0152418241,
-0.0251279939,
-0.0272844378,
0.0098603843,
0.0032124207,
0.0272921603,
0.0148218339,
0.0683665425,
-0.016239455,
-0.067511037,
0.0276232176,
-0.0031405292,
-0.0262119435,
-0.0482529774,
-0.0824553221,
0.0375745855,
0.0476421118,
0.0248144772,
0.0266116131,
-0.0046967557,
0.00645041,
0.0168041997,
0.0116590876,
0.0114146136,
0.0400624424,
-0.0226084888,
-0.0521619134,
-0.0145418951,
0.0191468317,
-0.0011400038,
0.0487196334,
-0.0037642533,
0.000649187,
0.0007441444,
-0.0029414331,
0.0165938511,
0.0272661205,
-0.0013764934,
0.0035753979,
-0.0214454923,
0.0272148531,
0.0253198054,
-0.0149688395,
-0.001614274,
0.0280143097,
-0.0059043672,
-0.0300261192,
-0.0192446057,
0.0063872943,
-0.0776738599,
-0.0043231519,
0.0037307455,
-0.0136651881,
-0.0022129051,
0.0110469488,
-0.0177324079,
-0.0449195914,
0.0348967873,
-0.0475924537,
0.0265269671,
-0.0071827932,
0.0367750041,
0.017703617,
-0.0314945504,
-0.0315972902,
0.092610009,
-0.030703729,
-0.0058830208,
0.0024534683,
0.0093105314,
0.0159378964,
-0.02896492,
0.0170532577,
0.0324676819,
-0.0011386267,
-0.0053531071,
0.0004088867,
0.0063342848,
-0.0322937854,
-0.0356798321,
-0.0701265857,
-0.0211482719,
-0.005668588,
0.0363135748,
-0.0085229091,
-0.0162555929,
-0.0343426429,
-0.0126285506,
-0.053985402,
-0.0091911964,
-0.0341938622,
0.013196121,
0.011858115,
-0.0025521547,
-0.0420324653,
0.0136174671,
-0.0090522515,
-0.0240311678,
0.0561436415,
-0.0105165793,
-0.023488557,
-0.0440326445,
0.0544623621,
0.0022493093,
-0.0048130881,
-0.0371599495,
-0.0249241237,
0.0611425601,
-0.0111006098,
0.0572334044,
0.0651039854,
0.0204201937,
-0.0117715374,
0.060432326,
-0.0053358222,
-0.0241194926,
0.0182397794,
-0.0057249088,
-0.041045256,
-0.0182763487,
-0.0318976305,
-0.0568234213,
0.06237147,
0.0309652444,
0.0287396386,
-0.0919226557,
-0.0099063627,
0.0058007468,
-0.0246944781,
-0.0761894137,
-0.0541270636,
-0.0238150787,
0.0723909289,
-0.010725324,
-0.0429093502,
0.0807228684,
-0.0291647203,
0.0139111932,
-0.0389569364,
0.0207329635,
0.0187531151,
0.0899749994,
-0.0076946602,
0.006949346,
0.0322681479,
-0.0412434377,
-0.0542553887,
-0.0253529232,
-0.00886798,
-0.0362085328,
0.0049344222,
-0.0597889163,
0.0131212352,
-0.0130389668,
-0.0547204651,
-0.038961187,
0.0010478445,
-0.0760594979,
-0.0314109512,
-0.0222830605,
-0.0302388724,
0.0088922381,
0.0157361776,
0.0762021542,
0.0397560634,
-0.0081067318,
-0.0270542074,
-0.0127471071,
-0.0042867539,
0.0072227102,
-0.0191788934,
0.0330434181,
-0.0407023132,
0.0168892983,
0.0311860908,
0.0475905985,
0.025345955,
-0.0430154353,
0.0076864953,
0.0009941356,
-0.0019097694,
-0.0547847822,
0.040699359,
0.0387048125,
-0.0460979342,
-0.0162979886,
0.1068301275,
0.0433941819,
-0.0365721695,
0.0111037744,
-0.0189305544,
0.0212713927,
-0.0120354034,
0.0117111709,
-0.1016771868,
-0.0326614901,
0.0510598458,
0.0094103217,
-0.0612798035,
-0.0274978764,
0.005598723,
-0.1184701324,
0.0340399072,
0.0150669869,
-0.0072428952,
-0.0115233529,
-0.048462972,
-0.0367225967,
0.0201472882,
0.0037071586,
0.0302312784,
0.0260282736,
-0.0022024617,
0.0270384103,
-0.0303291213,
-0.0110702123,
0.0466337614,
0.0073446329,
0.026807433,
0.0422318801,
-0.0179584734,
-0.0109090889,
-0.0617927052,
0.041639965,
0.0065499959,
0.037980739,
0.0182078779,
0.0104898512,
0.031338457,
0.000725236,
-0.0577147193,
0.0509378947,
-0.0228151083,
-0.0453041792,
0.0395448022,
0.0793928877,
-0.0316247307,
-0.0443670303,
-0.0186542869,
-0.0002945462,
-0.0420873463,
0.0578156039,
0.0398214906,
-0.0348041505,
-0.0405780338,
-0.0450851917,
-0.003262962,
-0.0177242421,
-0.0438648127,
0.0309677813,
0.0608472005,
0.0127778593,
-0.0321239978,
-0.0262215715,
0.018793365,
0.0577055179,
-0.0064416612,
0.0094590522,
0.0125852497,
0.0231477637,
-0.0262271948,
0.0093975337,
-0.0311150644,
0.0338096954,
-0.0474150665,
0.0173936486,
-0.0198873244,
-0.0684979558,
-0.0099712098,
0.0270831175,
-0.0719172955,
-0.0264404826,
-0.0150824217,
0.0436941944,
0.0420030095,
0.0105745643,
-0.018794613,
-0.0379861593,
0.0646495298,
0.0070898021,
-0.0155484332,
0.0138843358,
0.0535282604,
-0.0042733671,
0.0107004,
0.0168625209,
0.0037808204,
0.0026903965,
0.0078276861,
0.0091865966,
-0.0271092542,
0.0210536588,
0.0476774387,
-0.0000131511,
0.0228360053,
-0.0215657018,
0.0040495689,
0.0038099331,
0.0665623322,
-0.0096816001,
-0.0125965513,
0.0003933074,
-0.0042884788,
0.0399135649,
0.0018467529,
0.0085410737,
-0.0958482102,
0.0225330479,
-0.0100142984,
-0.0038932832,
-0.0100783072,
0.0173468906,
0.0812599808,
0.0705014169,
-0.0206070766,
-0.0366706774,
0.0151010193,
-0.0088473158,
0.0345007181,
0.0048662331,
0.0928003937,
0.0321206339,
-0.0031551279,
-0.0329553597,
0.0102463095,
-0.1016977057,
-0.069758743,
0.0294972248,
0.0017087032,
0.053706523,
0.012648995,
0.0056824661,
-0.0661197677,
0.0105114467,
0.0020165043,
0.0095028467,
0.0213115197,
-0.0079050604,
-0.0002914364,
0.0364218727,
0.0082499953,
-0.0182932019,
0.0647847354,
-0.02664808,
0.0449866541,
0.0141431978,
-0.0129211964,
-0.0237810165,
-0.0351590067,
-0.0226379819,
0.0329674631,
-0.0225218274,
-0.0040275166,
-0.074345164,
-0.0679123253,
-0.032699056,
0.0211104043,
0.0478258058,
-0.0318203345,
0.034809608,
0.0732077584,
-0.0322123356,
-0.0242796913,
0.0016924441,
0.0075430679,
0.0368927941,
-0.027007848,
-0.0291680638,
-6.661385427e-33,
0.0020060127,
-0.0164765045,
0.0344980024,
0.0142239509,
-0.0026858714,
-0.0249526594,
-0.0486663915,
0.0268268064,
-0.0200314131,
0.0057965834,
-0.0293988511,
-0.0110310614,
0.0196991004,
0.0042253169,
0.020904379,
0.0061385245,
-0.0018936504,
-0.0134417564,
-0.0410943143,
-0.000709353,
0.0314687937,
0.0036355953,
0.0186939724,
-0.0365748592,
0.0216344651,
-0.0153194396,
-0.032717023,
-0.0155471256,
-0.0861790627,
0.0531401411,
-0.0161768571,
0.0117945895,
0.0218400937,
-0.0369956829,
-0.0046969466,
0.0460056625,
-0.0332692787,
-0.0023584994,
0.0400301926,
-0.0050666207,
-0.0072590183,
-0.0405355245,
0.0052318354,
0.0197086222,
-0.033083681,
-0.0162160248,
-0.0103472546,
-0.0304354019,
-0.022887554,
-0.0203550123,
-0.041827105,
0.0053396611,
-0.0214447957,
-0.0484431908,
0.0238196068,
-0.0032470075,
-0.0365648903,
-0.0298321377,
-0.0221297294,
0.0351237021,
0.067241177,
0.0026640259,
0.0494468026,
0.0167691838,
-0.0254504681,
0.0287352186,
0.0400007106,
-0.0206483938,
-0.0494460948,
0.0110770166,
0.0362156332,
0.0046257023,
0.0645649806,
-0.0127305891,
0.0732481629,
0.0258802772,
-0.1011366323,
-0.0448341519,
0.0322817005,
0.0168744102,
0.0805158317,
0.0104216188,
-0.0646720529,
-0.0324554667,
-0.0531644002,
0.0018721109,
-0.0493782721,
-0.0358595438,
0.0314810202,
0.0132363737,
0.0267204531,
-0.0452649631,
0.0347434729,
-0.0002242793,
0.0006908773,
0.0020885626,
-0.0169747081,
0.034701407,
-0.0244390834,
0.0362682901,
-0.0581931062,
-0.0128682656,
0.0065983962,
0.0125674726,
0.014263073,
0.0140229175,
0.0339716375,
0.0237283707,
-0.0460750721,
-0.0277997442,
-0.0669981539,
0.0228028763,
0.032929346,
-0.0120275291,
0.0603107177,
0.002034531,
-0.0074369814,
0.0135207772,
-0.0428814813,
-0.0529863834,
-0.0279047042,
0.0560171679,
-0.0441851728,
0.0329489745,
-0.0206972212,
-0.0091301976,
-0.0199825373,
0.0083278036,
0.0423646532,
-0.0419007353,
-0.029298652,
0.062313579,
3.155e-7,
0.0023749794,
0.0475361571,
0.0315776914,
0.0270208716,
0.0202461593,
0.0324454457,
-0.0457939766,
-0.0054312432,
0.0301669184,
-0.0515644178,
-0.0022872766,
0.0618675798,
0.0653089285,
0.0225148853,
-0.0457971729,
-0.0319133252,
-0.0224086251,
-0.003460814,
-0.0571625829,
0.0419887751,
0.079140611,
0.065965414,
0.0105539458,
-0.0067699999,
0.0265140235,
-0.0030745431,
0.0346178189,
-0.0139105264,
0.0151334479,
-0.0494049974,
-0.0166300144,
0.0031817367,
0.0136308502,
0.0893641114,
0.0359403156,
-0.0166155435,
-0.004799454,
0.0329243578,
0.0217211265,
-0.0111587374,
-0.0279253144,
-0.0168654546,
-0.0017435614,
-0.074390471,
0.0703654513,
-0.0622021072,
-0.0271784104,
0.0493971445,
-0.0041588224,
-0.0281622466,
0.0008044332,
0.0040462199,
0.0010111281,
0.0212540496,
0.0114557678,
0.0209261291,
0.019840315,
-0.0878161117,
-0.013676933,
0.0237382669,
-0.0322232358,
-0.0486670099,
-0.0680583417,
-0.0005840756,
0.0593739338,
-0.0466587879,
-0.0161548425,
2.921091753e-34,
0.017843036,
-0.0372065008,
0.0328655057,
0.028217528,
0.0269733891,
-0.0011918382,
0.019567227,
0.039309755,
0.0480362065,
-0.0730186179,
-0.0188885741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01527v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01527v1 | KV Cache Compression, But What Must We Give in Return? A Comprehensive Benchmark of Long Context Capable Approaches | 2024-07-01T17:59:47 | 2024-07-01T17:59:47 | Jiayi Yuan, Hongyi Liu, Shaochen, Zhong, Yu-Neng Chuang, Songchen Li, Guanchu Wang, Duy Le, Hongye Jin, Vipin Chaudhary, Zhaozhuo Xu, Zirui Liu, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long context capability is a crucial competency for large language models
(LLMs) as it mitigates the human struggle to digest long-form texts. This
capability enables complex task-solving scenarios such as book summarization,
code assistance, and many more tasks that are traditionally manpower-intensive.
However, transformer-based LLMs face significant challenges with long context
input due to the growing size of the KV cache and the intrinsic complexity of
attending to extended inputs; where multiple schools of efficiency-driven
approaches -- such as KV cache quantization, token dropping, prompt
compression, linear-time sequence models, and hybrid architectures -- have been
proposed to produce efficient yet long context-capable models. Despite these
advancements, no existing work has comprehensively benchmarked these methods in
a reasonably aligned environment. In this work, we fill this gap by providing a
taxonomy of current methods and evaluating 10+ state-of-the-art approaches
across seven categories of long context tasks. Our work reveals numerous
previously unknown phenomena and offers insights -- as well as a friendly
workbench -- for the future development of long context-capable LLMs. The
source code will be available at https://github.com/henryzhongsc/longctx_bench | [
0.0150037957,
0.0224205405,
-0.0134197529,
0.0276555251,
-0.0479249656,
0.0114462599,
0.0134575898,
0.0230105594,
-0.0145785715,
-0.0284229498,
0.0037905099,
-0.0445858091,
0.01696961,
0.0149822813,
0.0171172321,
-0.0202520434,
0.0474628098,
-0.0412464626,
-0.0221971106,
-0.0013232388,
-0.0111363195,
-0.0255618449,
0.0450087786,
0.0346030183,
-0.0114697656,
-0.0246933084,
-0.0356624387,
0.0190634597,
-0.0192698464,
0.0047924728,
0.0012126145,
0.050560195,
0.0017290424,
0.0226357598,
0.0000021841,
-0.0292467121,
-0.028796155,
0.0046409783,
-0.0751693547,
0.040027421,
0.054118298,
-0.0312626325,
-0.0427173004,
-0.0002559896,
0.0061283158,
-0.0091205155,
0.0517092384,
-0.0100623788,
0.0613274835,
0.0372218005,
-0.0001374269,
-0.0051992144,
0.0079158191,
-0.0318013579,
0.0002343336,
-0.0406801179,
0.0118385609,
-0.0391354859,
0.0264641978,
0.0199461803,
-0.0399485007,
0.0550434254,
0.048607178,
-0.004939402,
-0.0084656663,
0.034986496,
-0.0534901395,
0.0162318125,
-0.0093858037,
0.0216606706,
-0.0188583154,
-0.0292588305,
0.0144157102,
0.0301081315,
-0.024695741,
-0.0565287173,
-0.0573238954,
0.0345860645,
-0.0096057476,
-0.0216221642,
-0.0061148191,
0.0138402833,
0.0157205518,
-0.0142152831,
-0.0426021889,
0.0244631991,
0.0356157981,
-0.0397775099,
-0.0426450782,
-0.0078892708,
-0.0194558781,
-0.0939642861,
0.00798414,
0.0416323319,
-0.0135945166,
-0.0032424938,
-0.0391643606,
-0.0345832966,
0.0158609711,
-0.0086618308,
-0.0018689285,
0.0545408614,
0.0029426499,
0.0431136079,
-0.0463136211,
0.0842747986,
-0.0199277569,
-0.0260412749,
-0.0371040143,
-0.0053043761,
-0.0255900957,
-0.002877271,
-0.0634181723,
0.0111688189,
-0.0455377698,
-0.0169888046,
-0.026498422,
0.0279600602,
0.0342249982,
0.0220687594,
0.0236399081,
0.0030210866,
-0.0240981989,
0.0162974987,
0.0378986932,
0.0378361419,
-0.0494292341,
-0.0552435443,
0.0123411734,
-0.0518330038,
-0.0323736705,
0.0186993089,
0.0132308006,
-0.0422217399,
-0.0064249313,
0.0524677187,
0.0021470706,
-0.0323927701,
0.0003224628,
-0.0299695134,
-0.0293085333,
-0.0458961315,
-0.0084975585,
-0.0801456347,
0.000344441,
0.0152748795,
0.0223739352,
0.0159359835,
-0.0130341528,
0.022055814,
-0.0143949231,
0.0370519981,
0.0367010683,
0.0033687539,
0.0355500951,
0.0216509886,
0.0198669489,
0.0550951287,
0.0365009233,
0.0238166712,
0.0369453803,
-0.0281070434,
-0.0018253404,
0.0655239448,
0.0051923343,
0.0040948745,
-0.0257103648,
0.0050380682,
0.0237152819,
0.0240880512,
0.0298444349,
0.0967905,
-0.0318532251,
-0.0264257509,
0.0288058389,
0.0475657992,
0.0479497351,
0.0200116411,
0.0310298372,
0.0296168793,
-0.0079597421,
0.0062579382,
-0.0338027962,
0.0432717837,
-0.0008266995,
0.0420045778,
0.0568067655,
0.0319112875,
-0.0220789388,
-0.0043055136,
-0.0354035385,
-0.0281819161,
0.018037606,
-0.0154838171,
0.0288906656,
0.0034193897,
-0.0475458987,
0.062757358,
-0.0091448082,
-0.0829871893,
-0.0095758848,
-0.039193783,
-0.016023336,
0.0660577044,
0.0617926717,
0.0208758265,
-0.0084956344,
0.013708815,
0.0028450943,
0.0024563344,
0.013428363,
-0.0074933558,
-0.0045012957,
-0.0489317067,
-0.0188294351,
0.0121840388,
-0.0099828718,
0.0003168095,
0.0593649819,
0.014599354,
0.0338833295,
0.0023055039,
0.0211361442,
0.0021994794,
-0.0481772758,
-0.0348950401,
-0.0023935167,
0.0136470906,
-0.0105086453,
0.0048337164,
-0.0269471053,
0.0221318547,
0.0455775373,
-0.0543218665,
0.0087410603,
-0.0096295197,
-0.0808371082,
-0.0393176861,
0.0313599482,
0.0164102502,
0.0376455411,
0.0253940746,
-0.0027223241,
-0.0488428995,
-0.0028984265,
-0.0489884242,
0.0675353855,
-0.0002374751,
0.0206360836,
-0.0062760673,
0.0250301603,
-0.0232407302,
0.0394808054,
-0.0122689167,
0.0211244784,
0.0375510827,
0.0363226347,
-0.0273588728,
-0.0215913039,
-0.052269958,
0.0207209382,
-0.0091130445,
-0.0035345147,
0.0222189724,
-0.004849792,
-0.012939387,
-0.0154732298,
-0.1443703026,
0.0166917946,
-0.0294917841,
0.0303288773,
-0.001838349,
0.0366394185,
-0.0033115463,
0.0282385219,
-0.0311137624,
-0.0117884995,
0.0063817459,
0.0438952744,
-0.0209935624,
0.0015643352,
-0.0270437375,
-0.0179644171,
-0.0558810532,
0.0063959998,
0.0705614388,
-0.0537925102,
-0.0472888798,
-0.0328660011,
0.0551963523,
0.0394169576,
0.0095596844,
-0.0336593203,
-0.0265725553,
-0.0050538098,
-0.0205897037,
0.0818477869,
0.0408754796,
0.0329311155,
-0.008959841,
0.0022586253,
-0.047154624,
-0.0393841378,
0.0116560627,
-0.0050549968,
-0.0545354299,
-0.0353083238,
-0.0029037304,
-0.0172237884,
0.0889041424,
-0.0257214662,
-0.0056317723,
-0.0481469817,
-0.0504601113,
-0.0214505009,
-0.0167542621,
-0.0237186961,
-0.0268655419,
-0.0302330237,
0.0327214263,
-0.0221381783,
-0.0164664537,
0.0522922948,
-0.0679911524,
-0.0326062627,
-0.0015087099,
-0.0004923348,
-0.0633966401,
0.0526435934,
0.002409969,
0.0143377334,
-0.0216865819,
-0.0051529002,
-0.0299080424,
0.0430301689,
-0.0533092953,
-0.0360964239,
0.0393003635,
-0.0020503073,
0.0086770486,
-0.0332626998,
-0.0202762224,
-0.0212922264,
0.0135611426,
0.0048314319,
0.0075150551,
0.0561985075,
-0.0159555916,
0.0158355143,
0.0596827008,
0.004864167,
0.0756119788,
-0.0248061363,
-0.0064408109,
-0.0124699874,
0.0489810072,
0.0214996021,
0.0143263014,
0.0399284922,
-0.027795678,
0.0485557131,
0.1004692316,
0.0774835274,
0.020454118,
-0.0097210156,
-0.0035740545,
0.0564945377,
-0.0168391466,
-0.0329259448,
0.0223250259,
0.0428835265,
-0.0750186443,
-0.0405666158,
0.1004753783,
0.0222020578,
-0.0709151402,
0.0097346287,
-0.0094466824,
0.0487942435,
0.0048379111,
0.0301271547,
-0.1291245073,
-0.0236919522,
0.0566045307,
0.0263138004,
-0.0140776625,
-0.0182789266,
-0.0068920031,
-0.1058271378,
0.0188803524,
0.0224228334,
-0.0047771167,
0.0282147862,
-0.0273700226,
-0.007914871,
0.0133825401,
0.0211398229,
0.0356607437,
-0.0108066266,
-0.015083096,
-0.0085949861,
0.0067417226,
-0.0033129114,
0.04212128,
0.0002107669,
0.0344701968,
0.0489043966,
-0.0011635261,
0.0377086848,
0.0261358302,
0.0326463096,
-0.017656181,
0.0103082368,
-0.0099499431,
-0.0125769526,
-0.0213125534,
-0.0022399891,
0.013427401,
0.0208514147,
-0.0212452244,
-0.015006654,
0.0133773331,
0.0506534576,
0.0073433509,
-0.0186237153,
-0.0162995495,
-0.0439282954,
-0.0094054881,
0.0808797553,
0.0343715064,
-0.0126745524,
-0.0701226369,
-0.0349495001,
-0.0005056232,
-0.0333893709,
-0.0468835905,
-0.0266429614,
0.0138537316,
-0.0501335971,
-0.0386054143,
0.005651874,
0.0012569434,
0.0261174347,
-0.0070324196,
-0.0154246837,
0.0074812188,
0.0018656965,
-0.1003207713,
-0.0050324015,
-0.0579742454,
0.0275402628,
-0.0945741013,
0.0348952524,
-0.0015183385,
-0.0056694266,
-0.0089078629,
0.0174766704,
-0.1315710694,
-0.0614591576,
0.0253373086,
0.0340506695,
0.0291280616,
0.0693761781,
0.0095615853,
-0.0425300263,
0.0488430113,
0.0476029739,
-0.0944103748,
0.0663650483,
0.003679639,
0.0032662302,
-0.0038317861,
0.0098169511,
-0.0478238016,
0.01528446,
-0.0220730603,
0.0484758019,
-0.0157019086,
-0.0370449387,
-0.0102800634,
-0.0067413226,
-0.0145630911,
0.0090115098,
-0.0066576051,
0.0577952676,
0.0420757085,
-0.028524207,
-0.0075680814,
-0.0230352897,
0.0068737078,
-0.0094110137,
0.0001300928,
0.0359154306,
0.017642254,
0.0438443832,
0.0154647026,
-0.0289945025,
0.002152571,
-0.0358073823,
-0.002768669,
0.0590079725,
0.0025755269,
-0.0169668887,
-0.0200891923,
0.0069803796,
0.0320842713,
-0.0598018095,
0.0253223907,
0.0028286411,
0.0215916652,
-0.0159361083,
0.0433616713,
-0.076857619,
-0.0005309073,
-0.0125517473,
0.0063969903,
0.0223680008,
-0.0203639381,
0.0263808873,
-0.0214642733,
-0.0008956466,
-0.0400689952,
0.0058453614,
0.0215661339,
-0.0204938315,
-0.0148921488,
0.0471627191,
0.0128673865,
0.0094964616,
0.0601072274,
-0.0032377413,
0.0217422657,
0.0106911566,
-0.0042128814,
-0.033422444,
-0.0223393161,
-0.0544334687,
0.0205403455,
0.0112984544,
-0.0496309474,
-0.0613177493,
-0.0433733948,
0.0255664643,
-0.001279009,
-0.0009185005,
-0.0348175578,
0.0402653478,
0.0429002121,
0.0272238106,
-0.0412904061,
-0.0066407304,
0.0305542033,
-0.0103361402,
-0.0099826278,
0.0071127517,
-6.201346896e-33,
-0.0213158857,
-0.0208288375,
0.0144816544,
-0.0198829249,
-0.0390770808,
0.0424478464,
-0.0558415465,
-0.0321855284,
0.0272103325,
-0.0544867665,
-0.0455755815,
0.0089986557,
0.0215586536,
0.0135468338,
-0.0244555175,
0.0138966981,
0.0500069149,
0.0144242039,
-0.0325835273,
0.0619500279,
0.0451586731,
0.0262677912,
0.0032318141,
-0.0048938352,
-0.0168425608,
-0.0237063505,
0.0584109612,
-0.0114226742,
0.0118172038,
0.0741976202,
-0.032898359,
0.0166856274,
0.0222281497,
-0.0856786296,
-0.0133075295,
0.0643729642,
-0.0985106826,
0.0324643925,
0.0062351078,
0.0056172805,
0.0027413282,
-0.0872193947,
0.0086745126,
0.0253667403,
-0.0262316633,
-0.0211304948,
-0.017597504,
-0.0186786335,
-0.0499490574,
-0.0590381324,
-0.036145784,
0.031208111,
0.0008319771,
-0.0017782282,
0.0528601445,
0.0349108465,
0.0040716128,
0.0481004193,
-0.0626258627,
0.015707599,
-0.0046077473,
0.1148664504,
0.0834480152,
0.0067160549,
0.01537898,
0.0246651601,
0.0246394258,
0.0153833283,
-0.0418537334,
0.0290308632,
0.0292794798,
0.0049867011,
0.0054313815,
0.034735024,
0.0636532754,
-0.0223980695,
-0.0088818111,
-0.0126717528,
0.0129480474,
0.0364939608,
0.0232938901,
-0.0071625602,
-0.0296914298,
-0.028872842,
-0.0379952416,
0.0368879884,
-0.0291665867,
-0.0075946692,
0.0253071859,
0.0306967273,
-0.0164758898,
-0.0257185809,
0.0651894286,
-0.0266167056,
0.0197436251,
0.0341795459,
0.0068703163,
0.0527617559,
-0.0059111267,
0.0412996933,
-0.0153478961,
-0.0149309356,
0.0364557095,
-0.0195572171,
0.0208222307,
-0.0157013349,
-0.0087381341,
0.04470516,
-0.0579544157,
-0.0138448318,
-0.0376228578,
0.0085312473,
-0.0226527471,
-0.0036260735,
0.0341081508,
0.0241498277,
0.0293521658,
0.0744891986,
-0.0104570929,
-0.0144270184,
-0.0200495552,
-0.0157497805,
0.0251774117,
0.0190246869,
-0.0075528091,
0.0112931551,
-0.0499929488,
0.0421859324,
0.0430624075,
-0.0501021333,
-0.0261638947,
0.0411156341,
2.832e-7,
0.0064201006,
0.0467716195,
0.0933637321,
-0.0272889342,
0.0284727737,
0.0071857218,
0.0249306876,
0.0127644399,
-0.0081108361,
0.0111544039,
-0.007944392,
0.0255182255,
0.0506381206,
0.0010220906,
-0.0923617706,
-0.0077420762,
-0.0626159385,
0.0067400122,
-0.0562057085,
-0.0208258759,
0.0531258807,
0.095794566,
-0.0269845072,
-0.0213162489,
0.0067820814,
-0.0030650666,
0.0304603763,
-0.0146582248,
-0.0009052211,
0.0210959055,
-0.0031393371,
-0.0156542417,
-0.0070708469,
-0.0429127589,
0.0114385914,
-0.0028085548,
-0.0271219239,
0.0934982076,
0.0476042554,
-0.0457081497,
0.0454012118,
-0.0222676899,
-0.0558292679,
-0.0300622918,
0.0800921097,
-0.0202203896,
0.0246325061,
-0.0402268507,
-0.0178539474,
-0.0159934852,
-0.0550615937,
0.0131398272,
0.0161032025,
0.0453808829,
0.0237663239,
-0.0022279404,
0.0106727472,
-0.0943288133,
-0.0590103902,
-0.0114930375,
-0.0609457009,
-0.0495888665,
-0.0713281929,
0.0019022377,
0.0123123974,
-0.0596397147,
-0.0346496701,
3.266774106e-34,
0.0305506755,
-0.0150291706,
0.017413266,
0.027781399,
0.0146129522,
-0.0443259627,
-0.0165466629,
0.0371011198,
0.0107986936,
-0.1029895097,
-0.0610886216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01525v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01525v2 | Empowering 3D Visual Grounding with Reasoning Capabilities | 2024-07-01T17:59:35 | 2024-07-02T07:37:56 | Chenming Zhu, Tai Wang, Wenwei Zhang, Kai Chen, Xihui Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Although great progress has been made in 3D visual grounding, current models
still rely on explicit textual descriptions for grounding and lack the ability
to reason human intentions from implicit instructions. We propose a new task
called 3D reasoning grounding and introduce a new benchmark ScanReason which
provides over 10K question-answer-location pairs from five reasoning types that
require the synerization of reasoning and grounding. We further design our
approach, ReGround3D, composed of the visual-centric reasoning module empowered
by Multi-modal Large Language Model (MLLM) and the 3D grounding module to
obtain accurate object locations by looking back to the enhanced geometry and
fine-grained details from the 3D scenes. A chain-of-grounding mechanism is
proposed to further boost the performance with interleaved reasoning and
grounding steps during inference. Extensive experiments on the proposed
benchmark validate the effectiveness of our proposed approach. | [
0.0356089398,
0.0400799252,
0.0366839021,
0.0495455489,
-0.0176378302,
0.0124703087,
0.0274359286,
-0.020247858,
-0.0178444423,
-0.0651834607,
-0.002505711,
0.0231088288,
0.0201770328,
0.0266983416,
0.0344130918,
-0.0501927137,
0.0070290323,
-0.0469936207,
-0.0163271222,
-0.0002557664,
-0.0032681122,
0.0237723868,
-0.0342522599,
0.016023146,
-0.0114325238,
-0.0321523398,
-0.0367388241,
-0.0044590309,
0.0109597333,
-0.0592377782,
-0.0115181254,
0.0365962051,
0.0861119404,
-0.0323850997,
0.0000020165,
-0.0380712561,
-0.0125607615,
-0.0017794608,
-0.0201452039,
-0.0026503529,
-0.0720453635,
-0.0098809162,
0.0151803102,
0.0015583127,
-0.0324623697,
0.011751025,
0.03570823,
0.0767136067,
0.047820989,
0.0184466429,
-0.0227363296,
-0.0203768164,
-0.0059865569,
0.0199119486,
0.0736622438,
-0.0269501824,
-0.0065873656,
0.1114291474,
0.0276812073,
0.0520360246,
-0.001308719,
0.0106931077,
0.0458111688,
-0.0073041599,
0.0024434805,
0.0362134762,
-0.0033847101,
-0.006057309,
-0.0267125908,
0.0930284262,
0.0256954823,
-0.018761849,
-0.0196619164,
0.0099112084,
0.012280588,
-0.0021483644,
-0.0363091789,
0.0440006927,
-0.0396211557,
-0.024347838,
-0.0250111055,
0.0025107514,
-0.0153538771,
0.0001634873,
-0.0486980118,
0.0556272045,
0.0102803688,
0.009139372,
-0.0098923761,
0.0207993519,
-0.0165352803,
-0.0660086051,
-0.0095786601,
0.030816365,
-0.0229157731,
-0.0124900145,
0.0045192894,
0.0229090713,
-0.0136965681,
-0.0072807395,
0.0124653699,
0.03143356,
-0.0582560226,
0.0770226419,
-0.0540252663,
0.0504689515,
-0.0474566147,
0.0302573219,
-0.0257933605,
-0.005885643,
0.013898625,
0.0024699031,
-0.0250005964,
0.0196277574,
-0.0989348739,
-0.0449583903,
0.0127985654,
0.0197816417,
-0.0293507129,
0.0001108535,
-0.0360077322,
0.0876013711,
0.0007593413,
-0.0250519533,
-0.0155527517,
0.0378367007,
-0.062658973,
0.0393561944,
-0.0120817954,
-0.0439434797,
0.0195599068,
0.0245758593,
0.0455120355,
-0.0104757156,
0.02532335,
0.0496593043,
-0.0295013674,
-0.0132915312,
-0.0270683151,
-0.0634445548,
0.0029051709,
-0.0616612509,
0.0360165872,
-0.0722900704,
-0.0126139019,
0.0041556046,
-0.0298145302,
-0.0143416645,
0.0138964467,
0.013674425,
-0.0030852489,
0.1063096076,
0.0059415582,
-0.0215108693,
0.0229979027,
0.0158503521,
0.0077910437,
0.0258272067,
0.0020325913,
0.049567163,
-0.00187426,
0.0209254362,
0.0200666338,
0.0111278761,
0.0172348246,
-0.0031351482,
-0.0503940694,
0.0097595751,
-0.0270606261,
0.0361083783,
-0.0341418497,
0.0137602314,
-0.0241046865,
0.0043185917,
0.0531370342,
0.0582297966,
-0.070093751,
-0.0119998744,
0.0202200934,
-0.0244243499,
-0.014022382,
-0.0048702727,
-0.0677453652,
0.0686642453,
-0.0337909088,
0.0043205698,
-0.0345821865,
0.0188424606,
-0.0146407159,
-0.0406152345,
-0.0097486591,
0.0096036531,
0.0444954857,
0.0221676212,
0.046749495,
0.0120889833,
-0.0232418943,
0.0471621677,
-0.0030623653,
-0.0309157111,
-0.0257471781,
0.00975437,
0.0687986314,
0.0124948621,
0.0024956723,
0.0043625026,
-0.0674735159,
-0.0139818955,
0.0629508868,
0.0144661525,
0.00539607,
-0.0074423263,
-0.0053826966,
-0.0414484628,
-0.0591858998,
-0.0131116472,
-0.0108065177,
0.0274896678,
0.0738827288,
-0.0172269028,
0.0172332525,
-0.0782889724,
0.0832421556,
0.0116645871,
-0.0006374465,
0.0358277932,
-0.0722203106,
0.0385046899,
-0.028662106,
-0.0011319183,
0.0292758569,
0.000415784,
0.0270590596,
-0.019913666,
-0.014890586,
0.0220088288,
-0.0585931391,
-0.0036946626,
0.0328712724,
-0.0264109038,
-0.0318124406,
-0.0070890803,
-0.0235643983,
-0.0050080405,
0.0219083074,
-0.0114730848,
0.007055677,
0.0048437766,
-0.0219701007,
0.0338668302,
0.0039437148,
-0.0477333479,
0.0787699521,
-0.0247140266,
-0.0160244778,
0.0165962465,
0.0125542274,
0.0333123207,
0.0003539629,
0.033244729,
-0.0111826761,
-0.0106834173,
0.0115319649,
0.0176746454,
0.0095481221,
-0.0394158065,
0.0199322458,
-0.0508039333,
-0.0140706217,
-0.0154375779,
-0.0173254926,
0.0195965953,
-0.0035749639,
0.0065276762,
-0.0404265858,
-0.0385549515,
0.0418777391,
0.0064625186,
0.0074664485,
0.0188392289,
-0.0261292439,
-0.01452222,
0.0158346742,
0.0282900389,
-0.0284228101,
0.0673756152,
0.0685937777,
-0.0082479063,
-0.0514483638,
-0.0107240751,
-0.0802639946,
0.0568852201,
0.0001838696,
0.0109530296,
0.0473876558,
-0.0630760491,
0.0188963339,
0.0763820708,
-0.0425119437,
0.0069828648,
0.0027060031,
0.0121848807,
-0.0726572424,
0.0089972522,
-0.0077661071,
-0.004115236,
-0.0295588225,
-0.0181738902,
-0.0421498828,
0.0082373489,
-0.0065574571,
0.0171146132,
-0.0258353595,
0.046923127,
0.0430143997,
-0.0125975218,
-0.0531480275,
-0.0069095921,
0.0199140739,
0.0870249644,
-0.0288530998,
-0.0347068682,
0.0332059562,
-0.046050407,
0.005113069,
0.0085821673,
0.0075185266,
-0.0173804201,
0.0862863436,
-0.0186611582,
0.025622569,
-0.0187698081,
-0.0353615656,
-0.0204315092,
-0.0535595343,
0.0312784053,
0.020083975,
0.0557272248,
-0.0784807354,
0.0259246603,
0.0059221876,
-0.0419732854,
-0.0023431145,
0.0130025195,
-0.0691692904,
-0.0049035782,
-0.0817302614,
-0.0367777906,
-0.013460679,
0.0207199212,
0.0438166559,
0.0351615511,
-0.0306109916,
-0.0234987307,
-0.0277600288,
0.0104796514,
0.0379393026,
0.0779010057,
0.0029769999,
-0.0047286544,
0.0025229172,
0.0849955752,
-0.0182442125,
0.0079892557,
-0.078327179,
0.0704094395,
0.0252221003,
0.0569731444,
0.0113430684,
0.0020720901,
0.0435976312,
-0.0580074973,
-0.027873138,
0.0677438527,
0.0179248247,
-0.0159555543,
-0.0181952678,
-0.0197864361,
-0.0015497564,
0.0585906245,
-0.0131110931,
-0.0605725236,
-0.0515237786,
-0.0079764593,
-0.0226582959,
0.06049826,
-0.0396731906,
0.0111266114,
-0.0826645643,
0.0651766509,
-0.037402872,
-0.0258854106,
-0.1100977734,
0.0056287535,
0.0206579529,
0.0156644769,
-0.0408194102,
-0.0164670367,
0.0222144779,
-0.0045476397,
0.0093532531,
0.036460571,
-0.0131775932,
0.0367408209,
-0.0557057112,
-0.0289458539,
0.0139501262,
0.0093755331,
-0.0007643104,
-0.1031098217,
0.0324200131,
0.0417216904,
0.0053737443,
-0.006289836,
0.0122378552,
-0.0048321867,
-0.0245202091,
-0.0153882885,
0.0334201232,
-0.0252419673,
-0.0423879623,
-0.0492462516,
0.0906761512,
-0.0328702554,
0.0491917655,
-0.0093851341,
0.0422146656,
-0.0032703185,
0.0259556118,
0.0079693552,
-0.0002581764,
-0.0387609936,
-0.0206009038,
-0.0138784386,
-0.0068008997,
-0.0132963108,
0.0005674418,
0.0241737049,
0.0216502231,
-0.0642682314,
0.0144036924,
0.0673381835,
0.0866941884,
-0.0082512312,
-0.0253160428,
0.0112782847,
-0.0051931073,
-0.047453776,
0.0443169065,
-0.030007869,
0.021130342,
0.0237292647,
0.0783799216,
0.0183000788,
-0.0663788691,
-0.0279317889,
-0.019090673,
-0.0345533863,
-0.0200192314,
-0.0272482987,
0.0432227515,
0.014755466,
0.049972225,
0.0002685103,
-0.0019622121,
-0.0148231611,
-0.0146733355,
0.0032451437,
0.0247384291,
0.0079369964,
-0.0020965955,
-0.0118686724,
-0.0089656152,
-0.0201758593,
0.0191767048,
0.0166209787,
-0.0019762719,
-0.0240781717,
-0.0240740981,
0.0150891161,
0.024628222,
0.035868261,
0.0298529454,
0.0168753807,
-0.0262653865,
0.00934528,
-0.0079616858,
-0.0178225338,
-0.071425505,
0.0315899178,
0.0173648596,
-0.0256091543,
0.0310404431,
-0.0118579064,
0.0277078953,
0.0405975431,
-0.0137766497,
-0.0039774394,
0.0075152707,
-0.0256719682,
0.0147535531,
-0.0126218265,
-0.0022247608,
0.0355302617,
-0.0499848314,
0.0927600488,
-0.0289882571,
0.0914235786,
0.0486489907,
-0.0531227477,
-0.0644184202,
0.023439128,
-0.0501562767,
-0.0882767662,
0.0192542411,
0.0375055708,
0.0534648895,
0.026499832,
0.0054161935,
-0.0134342276,
-0.0172143616,
0.0515126027,
0.0383276269,
0.0350647941,
-0.0500094108,
0.0535552725,
0.0386581421,
0.0104911933,
-0.0070432271,
-0.026801547,
-0.0075427173,
0.0173933934,
0.027991496,
-0.049117513,
-0.0220932849,
-0.0174409617,
0.0044704508,
0.0150147704,
0.0181634333,
0.050166402,
-0.026922768,
-0.0645899177,
-0.0469599776,
0.0682609528,
-0.0450882167,
0.014436082,
0.0374707803,
0.065857023,
0.024539018,
-0.0422381051,
0.0014399751,
0.0374539867,
-0.0450686552,
0.0002966783,
-0.0217250884,
-6.013804854e-33,
-0.0148845222,
-0.0760216713,
0.0511494763,
-0.0343154855,
-0.0200041551,
0.0171943884,
-0.0329906009,
0.0066210222,
-0.0328290723,
0.0242097434,
0.0265718363,
0.0071734735,
-0.000817992,
0.0276900288,
-0.0303201303,
-0.0216041263,
-0.00481884,
0.0155912209,
-0.034788914,
-0.0153299281,
0.0385334305,
-0.0101606073,
0.0592067279,
-0.0790558681,
-0.0205504876,
0.0116518224,
-0.025089683,
0.0481426902,
-0.0532586612,
0.0445937105,
-0.0143485423,
-0.0321069174,
0.0130030531,
-0.0365628116,
-0.0056821699,
0.0415153764,
-0.1227201372,
-0.0204892494,
0.0208712164,
0.0105376719,
-0.0482655801,
0.0490405224,
-0.0140369814,
-0.0170742422,
0.020836914,
-0.0346136205,
0.0196871478,
-0.004457661,
-0.0192483291,
0.0284007583,
-0.0295311902,
-0.0084862215,
-0.0167996492,
-0.0481441282,
0.0073964735,
0.0281208809,
0.037786033,
0.0202569012,
-0.0232559517,
-0.0039384924,
-0.0398511142,
-0.0326785557,
0.0535700694,
0.0300241951,
-0.0220184177,
0.0715351179,
0.0174729005,
-0.0230111238,
-0.0663255081,
-0.0273862444,
0.0112954285,
0.0719394758,
0.0389973968,
0.030742947,
-0.0108448109,
0.0606085695,
-0.047987435,
0.0065553281,
-0.095623821,
0.0647347048,
0.0364942998,
-0.0262875762,
-0.0070555727,
-0.0183927324,
-0.0311436206,
0.0100436602,
-0.0329301096,
0.005542587,
0.0421345197,
0.0103000579,
-0.0369227044,
0.0360139608,
0.0404642113,
-0.0065046074,
0.0249397606,
0.0973123014,
0.0199917965,
0.0347315893,
-0.0166837927,
0.0200839695,
-0.0280335918,
0.015105173,
-0.0022372843,
-0.0148271602,
0.0135990418,
0.0231564306,
0.0073416904,
-0.0021695357,
-0.0233094692,
-0.0102184517,
-0.0654590353,
-0.0150169497,
-0.0210007709,
0.0485345088,
0.0609777085,
0.0321564116,
-0.0261686519,
0.0138794491,
-0.0159083866,
-0.0100566521,
-0.0136661828,
-0.0324410424,
-0.0226787273,
0.0374761187,
-0.0264058933,
0.0007769791,
-0.0687694997,
-0.0467156135,
0.031350337,
-0.0738726929,
-0.0041423128,
0.048517704,
2.701e-7,
0.0167100541,
0.0259841979,
0.03750211,
0.0119120665,
-0.0207100045,
0.0508177429,
0.0401728973,
-0.0066427523,
0.0321083292,
-0.0529129282,
-0.0118642766,
0.0689579695,
-0.0299270209,
0.0274866633,
-0.050535813,
0.0602315664,
-0.0041691973,
-0.0391230397,
-0.0454295464,
0.0265523158,
0.0633471087,
0.0151358955,
-0.022760788,
-0.0075795483,
0.0364991538,
-0.0378592014,
0.0047985329,
-0.0144560058,
0.0083266553,
-0.0070288703,
0.0446121618,
0.016979957,
-0.0178628769,
0.0154107781,
0.0102431867,
-0.0250526536,
-0.0027208168,
0.0217694622,
-0.0138818156,
-0.015887972,
-0.0647743121,
-0.0456683077,
-0.004509273,
-0.0496299937,
0.0601045117,
-0.0293790195,
0.0007900989,
-0.0166163892,
-0.0066049928,
-0.0351531729,
-0.0205481034,
0.0038381941,
0.0180952307,
-0.038095966,
0.0143725909,
-0.0212158374,
-0.0191251673,
-0.0752686933,
-0.0242263693,
0.027528476,
0.001677121,
-0.0242698826,
0.0028558786,
-0.0785165727,
0.0223134384,
-0.01960201,
-0.0577910505,
2.241865633e-34,
-0.0001633276,
0.0245890748,
0.0301023331,
0.007868859,
0.0498019941,
0.001900641,
0.0183332209,
-0.0155867757,
0.0015158586,
-0.0508974381,
0.0042256108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01523v1 | MMLongBench-Doc: Benchmarking Long-context Document Understanding with Visualizations | 2024-07-01T17:59:26 | 2024-07-01T17:59:26 | Yubo Ma, Yuhang Zang, Liangyu Chen, Meiqi Chen, Yizhu Jiao, Xinze Li, Xinyuan Lu, Ziyu Liu, Yan Ma, Xiaoyi Dong, Pan Zhang, Liangming Pan, Yu-Gang Jiang, Jiaqi Wang, Yixin Cao, Aixin Sun | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Understanding documents with rich layouts and multi-modal components is a
long-standing and practical task. Recent Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs)
have made remarkable strides in various tasks, particularly in single-page
document understanding (DU). However, their abilities on long-context DU remain
an open problem. This work presents MMLongBench-Doc, a long-context,
multi-modal benchmark comprising 1,062 expert-annotated questions. Distinct
from previous datasets, it is constructed upon 130 lengthy PDF-formatted
documents with an average of 49.4 pages and 20,971 textual tokens. Towards
comprehensive evaluation, answers to these questions rely on pieces of evidence
from (1) different sources (text, image, chart, table, and layout structure)
and (2) various locations (i.e. page number). Moreover, 33.2% of the questions
are cross-page questions requiring evidence across multiple pages. 22.8% of the
questions are designed to be unanswerable for detecting potential
hallucinations. Experiments on 14 LVLMs demonstrate that long-context DU
greatly challenges current models. Notably, the best-performing model, GPT-4o,
achieves an F1 score of only 42.7%, while the second-best, GPT-4V, scores
31.4%. Furthermore, 12 LVLMs (all except GPT-4o and GPT-4V) even present worse
performance than their LLM counterparts which are fed with lossy-parsed OCR
documents. These results validate the necessity of future research toward more
capable long-context LVLMs. Project Page:
https://mayubo2333.github.io/MMLongBench-Doc | [
-0.0187474247,
0.0135533065,
0.0169521123,
0.0516976528,
-0.0390732959,
0.032306999,
0.0123499399,
0.0194106158,
0.0091601908,
-0.0192536227,
-0.0240349676,
-0.0242383536,
0.0185595062,
0.0232973304,
0.011344457,
-0.0495962538,
0.0212984513,
-0.0718288869,
-0.0138182016,
0.0323435701,
0.0142564233,
-0.0188970994,
-0.0028880567,
0.0039701355,
-0.0030085568,
-0.0800427571,
-0.0356915481,
0.0110348621,
0.0298087448,
-0.0160824768,
-0.052835308,
0.0494756289,
0.0480804965,
0.0683024451,
0.0000020844,
-0.0350965932,
-0.0264273882,
0.0223961584,
-0.0012578673,
0.0069641974,
0.0254371371,
-0.0668337196,
0.0063358382,
-0.0622267798,
-0.0198900849,
-0.0071219797,
0.0196413901,
0.1042300835,
0.0218461398,
0.0497479402,
-0.0183402095,
-0.0378473997,
0.047706563,
0.0024940781,
0.0891258791,
-0.032937672,
0.0083977655,
0.022209201,
0.0293152221,
-0.0184125174,
-0.0627707765,
0.0163613614,
0.0373901203,
-0.0267657898,
-0.021509042,
0.0340149812,
-0.0203448087,
-0.0094817337,
-0.0010311329,
0.0971658304,
-0.0364407636,
-0.0055389078,
0.0070472788,
0.0098750163,
-0.0076396605,
0.0207068399,
-0.0705692768,
-0.0129526509,
-0.0502707586,
-0.0166057684,
0.0288263429,
0.0078800526,
0.024908701,
-0.011232214,
-0.0451651067,
0.0298454408,
0.0033447,
-0.0294623822,
0.0450741164,
0.0041703708,
-0.0238851625,
-0.0158088952,
0.0052981824,
0.0160411298,
0.0029511489,
-0.0028784194,
-0.0521994419,
-0.0558554344,
0.0413856395,
-0.053785719,
-0.0097619221,
-0.0116848508,
-0.0780205578,
0.1114866883,
-0.0305017997,
0.0440032668,
-0.0330801606,
0.0421573669,
-0.0187576246,
0.0133760683,
-0.0077534108,
0.0120034451,
-0.0343556851,
-0.034535002,
-0.029198423,
-0.0738942772,
-0.0009011887,
-0.0028132002,
0.0022466285,
0.0478719324,
-0.0189632773,
-0.0208904613,
-0.0028947224,
-0.0594493039,
0.0150617454,
0.020041192,
-0.0276215505,
-0.0237694904,
-0.0257125422,
-0.0460458808,
-0.0066948701,
0.0583408102,
-0.0047390135,
-0.0086575951,
-0.0201515313,
0.0659726113,
0.0022290214,
-0.0187640507,
-0.0204003416,
-0.0363082998,
-0.0233070794,
-0.0576850213,
0.022327289,
-0.0461274646,
0.0016598941,
-0.0136755202,
0.0182043016,
0.02106677,
-0.0008960987,
-0.0014994466,
-0.0048581399,
0.0966795236,
-0.0029551389,
-0.0214194134,
0.0233583041,
0.0434414558,
-0.0200052634,
0.0686148182,
0.0080525223,
0.0481255427,
0.025911225,
-0.0324463211,
0.0469315909,
0.0329783261,
-0.026729349,
-0.0032537614,
0.0136619387,
0.0236080475,
0.0104301637,
0.0198926274,
-0.0109496443,
0.0051955692,
-0.0303777289,
-0.0467822067,
0.0411352776,
0.0424367599,
0.0182209723,
-0.0188185386,
-0.0025658824,
0.0093737999,
0.0065719094,
0.0261063743,
-0.0507101268,
0.0194807835,
0.0051875012,
0.0126376059,
0.0095772045,
-0.010250696,
0.0004698194,
-0.0117764063,
-0.0236985814,
0.0084435865,
-0.0026296065,
-0.006079508,
0.0679196715,
-0.002662678,
-0.0541667417,
-0.0337409154,
-0.0195667837,
-0.0228649396,
-0.0304974932,
0.0073534148,
0.0319023319,
0.0727704614,
0.0768643618,
-0.0474788249,
-0.0258095041,
-0.0422278009,
0.041918382,
0.0466375127,
0.0288337413,
0.0215446241,
0.0362641029,
-0.0697443634,
-0.0230784956,
-0.0081046317,
-0.0074511329,
0.0032046321,
-0.0183068011,
-0.0011400795,
-0.0042356383,
-0.1041239351,
-0.0182651952,
0.0412603952,
0.0162735749,
-0.0293969885,
-0.037171673,
0.0174073912,
0.02769823,
0.0138947787,
-0.0123468321,
-0.0019693028,
0.0360918269,
-0.0563892685,
0.030686494,
0.0093317842,
-0.0408982001,
-0.0065714698,
0.0271243732,
-0.0722872317,
-0.0324429311,
0.0039867451,
-0.0272578932,
-0.0418608412,
-0.0312291253,
-0.0241719857,
-0.0048553925,
-0.013340503,
0.0080094133,
0.0070697074,
0.0614590868,
-0.0217146687,
0.0629629344,
-0.0146093955,
0.0191183034,
0.0282380693,
0.0342001244,
0.0235421602,
-0.014573466,
-0.0128675234,
-0.0087496834,
-0.0045030466,
-0.0128574604,
0.0017241245,
0.0038384523,
-0.0797558874,
-0.0041928394,
-0.0954109728,
-0.0061049983,
-0.0392262414,
0.0188604966,
0.0153203551,
-0.0369489305,
-0.0420867056,
-0.0450680889,
-0.0403056778,
0.0315806828,
-0.0092564141,
-0.0188498627,
0.0110881263,
-0.0179863069,
0.0035474871,
0.0208188128,
-0.0061765737,
-0.0137101533,
0.0269396547,
0.0512437597,
-0.0540787242,
-0.0389115214,
0.0411818139,
0.0362094268,
0.0000657333,
-0.0385904647,
0.0236443095,
0.0107135549,
-0.0515424125,
0.0678510889,
0.1092677936,
-0.0019757391,
0.0315367207,
0.011332362,
-0.0429753996,
-0.0382994227,
0.0081274472,
0.0120464982,
0.0349224992,
-0.0264005959,
-0.0085043348,
-0.0058739739,
0.0210178941,
-0.0075153965,
0.0370733887,
-0.023796821,
-0.0032927883,
-0.0178636089,
-0.0372533128,
-0.0317376778,
-0.0013378648,
0.0321790874,
0.0444906093,
-0.0122353677,
-0.0604847185,
0.0385362506,
-0.0589376837,
-0.0269505531,
-0.0028572271,
0.0430158302,
-0.0368507467,
0.0605510548,
0.014535089,
-0.0011189276,
-0.0312329233,
-0.0351623893,
-0.0127681186,
0.035106685,
-0.0147708263,
-0.028591644,
0.0433754772,
-0.046078641,
0.032571651,
-0.0293352325,
-0.0116181355,
-0.0091120144,
-0.0283878334,
0.0017232544,
-0.0508506373,
-0.0414059423,
-0.0015790069,
-0.0722901002,
0.0444647446,
0.034030702,
0.0410862416,
-0.0374050103,
-0.02976753,
-0.0065024626,
0.0539756455,
0.0505898334,
-0.004794661,
0.0407977477,
-0.0958814546,
0.0492590927,
0.0803678259,
-0.0026525045,
0.0067143664,
-0.015513422,
0.0144235585,
-0.010625341,
0.0095761381,
0.0031424367,
-0.0105628651,
0.0388313718,
-0.1100552082,
-0.0055565019,
0.0937643945,
0.0271097869,
-0.0813937038,
-0.0480384678,
-0.0648520291,
0.0430202037,
-0.0143968994,
-0.0071258489,
-0.0872834846,
-0.0322553925,
-0.0059707956,
0.0263142027,
0.0243477114,
-0.0203930475,
0.013112749,
-0.0470532924,
0.0760706142,
0.0036977371,
-0.0159019213,
-0.0147711476,
-0.019835975,
0.0115952678,
0.0073222355,
-0.0112822829,
-0.0240963772,
0.0024640069,
-0.0416740514,
-0.0260191001,
-0.0011542544,
0.0323385336,
0.0274017118,
-0.0052191885,
-0.0295188315,
0.0531361774,
0.0301133506,
0.0047752555,
-0.0453645661,
0.0360151418,
0.0035658544,
0.0171904303,
-0.0033217045,
0.0894690752,
-0.0193826761,
0.0213421173,
-0.0160072744,
0.0710857064,
-0.0570410565,
-0.0063739931,
0.0388126336,
0.0233922843,
-0.0552917793,
-0.0373130888,
-0.0409610197,
0.0026442986,
-0.0357469581,
0.0655835718,
0.0441513434,
-0.0272205863,
-0.0868638009,
-0.0134128407,
0.0486766584,
-0.0332122259,
-0.0020554159,
0.0045941481,
0.0334253833,
-0.0225051548,
-0.0370811708,
-0.0419285037,
0.0199843813,
0.0433516614,
-0.0055403672,
0.0258617569,
-0.0445737243,
-0.0162216481,
-0.0582876019,
0.0598496795,
-0.0069830683,
0.0156834237,
-0.0503466986,
0.0420185365,
0.0159629099,
-0.0266994182,
0.0020213528,
0.059169706,
-0.1082393527,
-0.0067671183,
0.0226844493,
0.0086395387,
0.0198583342,
0.0571067184,
-0.0176900998,
-0.0227541011,
0.0445493981,
0.0012560802,
-0.0031057568,
-0.0062535107,
0.0064159296,
-0.00325394,
0.0011115334,
0.0143510113,
-0.0145106651,
0.0141166085,
0.0289041828,
-0.0236831196,
0.0045955814,
0.0010065509,
-0.011018686,
0.0014241475,
0.0007332118,
0.0137461163,
0.0244172923,
0.0130970236,
0.0232455917,
-0.0185915604,
-0.0061971261,
0.0003919564,
-0.0045178928,
0.0284900218,
-0.0475790389,
0.0105906334,
0.0368285626,
0.0222494435,
-0.0053577707,
-0.0399092473,
0.0189544205,
0.0349120609,
-0.0390045755,
0.0297442563,
-0.0158576705,
0.0014416946,
-0.0041727102,
-0.0148529978,
0.0638700724,
0.024183346,
0.108975403,
0.0087469397,
-0.0040103998,
-0.0090585919,
0.0236686077,
-0.0770977139,
-0.0543320626,
0.0010124583,
0.0482820943,
0.0222304389,
-0.0062375753,
0.0597499609,
-0.0328841619,
0.0074978434,
-0.0273039285,
0.0260572862,
0.0487957224,
0.0044413423,
-0.0017588089,
0.0468724445,
0.0067093619,
0.0216418188,
0.0830866247,
0.0087323142,
-0.0049207788,
0.0260737594,
-0.0122936834,
-0.0786790475,
0.0015625795,
-0.0056709005,
0.0333534144,
0.0085366964,
0.0081160096,
-0.0502615124,
-0.0151854977,
0.0430984013,
0.0088823242,
-0.0144743007,
0.0424080305,
0.023670638,
0.0787472501,
-0.0103031471,
-0.0204979349,
-0.0011305371,
0.04579629,
0.0051384922,
-0.0332439169,
0.0139672505,
-5.572153627e-33,
0.0009557867,
-0.0468573421,
0.0184118114,
-0.010070811,
-0.0233072266,
0.0119257066,
-0.0263560172,
-0.0001920053,
0.0102543803,
0.0294563118,
-0.0165733602,
0.0105128931,
0.0273763146,
0.0293760616,
-0.018713057,
-0.0080743134,
0.0125481468,
-0.0059660533,
-0.0258718207,
0.0254892744,
0.0297733154,
0.0190092567,
0.0154093672,
-0.058749713,
0.0496461913,
-0.0153060183,
-0.0157119799,
-0.0100729149,
-0.0113828769,
0.0504661389,
-0.0531854518,
0.002461287,
0.0497499518,
-0.0180229507,
-0.0528445467,
0.0838743523,
-0.0834747106,
0.0143299848,
-0.014537584,
0.0373358652,
-0.0601291619,
-0.0302584171,
0.0570936687,
-0.0015271114,
0.0220051743,
-0.0437447429,
0.051472567,
-0.0409892946,
-0.0206031296,
0.0071113021,
-0.0622460321,
0.0380825922,
-0.0274188593,
-0.0064526107,
0.0659126416,
0.037760336,
-0.0104707144,
0.0658197477,
-0.0705093145,
-0.0144073591,
-0.0166527983,
-0.0060712965,
0.0778051913,
-0.0042060022,
0.007670281,
0.0441728048,
0.0446165055,
-0.016276449,
-0.0383066125,
-0.0423237421,
0.0389039107,
0.0485213324,
0.0504186638,
0.033299841,
0.0639161542,
0.045456145,
-0.0494627617,
0.0334502496,
-0.0362284966,
0.0362584218,
0.0606967323,
-0.0112803467,
-0.0521181189,
0.0076479926,
-0.0060954168,
-0.001896997,
-0.0329084359,
0.0093460325,
0.0596818551,
-0.0010325323,
0.0171228331,
-0.0153458556,
0.0683219582,
-0.0214189906,
0.0208306313,
0.0263244752,
-0.0025143474,
0.038836062,
0.0070286533,
0.0016795794,
-0.0092419796,
-0.0015871136,
0.0332373865,
-0.0103276577,
0.0017587007,
-0.0160500742,
0.0581525043,
-0.0384943411,
-0.0568600185,
-0.0072948732,
-0.0266998746,
-0.0224667192,
0.0113115935,
0.0659614876,
0.0642278343,
-0.0256432071,
-0.0188419633,
0.0593921281,
-0.0120764365,
0.0382003635,
0.001356682,
-0.0294902027,
-0.0273682792,
-0.0025738431,
-0.0098449634,
-0.0272385012,
-0.0070275562,
-0.0573399365,
0.0295868665,
-0.0572057255,
0.0270579662,
0.0505991615,
2.636e-7,
0.0348549411,
0.0519227609,
0.0713042095,
-0.0374429002,
0.0371704362,
0.0162980724,
0.0055690594,
0.0089589376,
-0.0314520076,
-0.0619431548,
0.0010896175,
0.0086198989,
0.0740951896,
0.0340061635,
-0.062860854,
-0.0057870774,
0.0014206459,
-0.0077103283,
-0.0777920485,
-0.0087773763,
0.0506539382,
0.0643561184,
-0.0445060283,
-0.0311340261,
0.0596820302,
-0.0453011505,
0.0470062345,
-0.0364050642,
0.0027931274,
0.0031015312,
0.0360199325,
-0.00315455,
-0.0169471186,
0.0174812041,
0.0036179346,
-0.0049109384,
0.0359100848,
0.0520518012,
-0.0025505172,
-0.0125462729,
0.0086054914,
-0.0026737796,
0.0101670502,
-0.073938027,
0.0662164465,
-0.0207459014,
-0.0501680747,
-0.0122093009,
-0.0487065949,
-0.0483825579,
0.0347069092,
0.0003044775,
0.009965851,
0.0400494561,
0.0218418818,
-0.0442946628,
-0.0097906934,
-0.0444061086,
0.0025170522,
-0.0373518504,
-0.0349928066,
0.0264346153,
-0.0555886589,
-0.0009311861,
0.0120859547,
-0.0466728956,
-0.0559722446,
2.517171231e-34,
0.0458325073,
-0.0369917341,
0.0106669469,
-0.0109825451,
0.0070176115,
-0.0199259128,
0.0018534322,
-0.009910672,
-0.0281543955,
-0.1176857501,
-0.0081017436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01509v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01509v1 | MIA-Bench: Towards Better Instruction Following Evaluation of Multimodal LLMs | 2024-07-01T17:53:35 | 2024-07-01T17:53:35 | Yusu Qian, Hanrong Ye, Jean-Philippe Fauconnier, Peter Grasch, Yinfei Yang, Zhe Gan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We introduce MIA-Bench, a new benchmark designed to evaluate multimodal large
language models (MLLMs) on their ability to strictly adhere to complex
instructions. Our benchmark comprises a diverse set of 400 image-prompt pairs,
each crafted to challenge the models' compliance with layered instructions in
generating accurate responses that satisfy specific requested patterns.
Evaluation results from a wide array of state-of-the-art MLLMs reveal
significant variations in performance, highlighting areas for improvement in
instruction fidelity. Additionally, we create extra training data and explore
supervised fine-tuning to enhance the models' ability to strictly follow
instructions without compromising performance on other tasks. We hope this
benchmark not only serves as a tool for measuring MLLM adherence to
instructions, but also guides future developments in MLLM training methods. | [
0.0181016643,
0.0636366904,
-0.007986973,
0.0563669205,
-0.0384668261,
0.0108244652,
0.0318387635,
-0.0042928583,
0.0086560035,
-0.0668320283,
-0.0717423707,
-0.0510750189,
0.0065844217,
-0.0059390506,
0.0430816486,
-0.0452397615,
0.0216256808,
-0.0759559199,
-0.0526828021,
-0.0140569443,
0.0226158537,
0.0040363017,
-0.0460037477,
0.052883774,
-0.0308946613,
-0.0286741126,
-0.0134936264,
0.0330868363,
-0.0113564637,
-0.0358087383,
-0.0042849206,
0.0351109765,
0.0309778862,
0.0086220978,
0.0000019087,
-0.0436590165,
0.0461146273,
-0.0272866394,
-0.004136486,
0.0213578586,
0.0277713947,
-0.0169208571,
0.0055949464,
0.0056451727,
-0.00830766,
-0.0042829989,
0.0534110442,
0.0353169776,
0.0676348954,
0.0655229613,
0.011260909,
-0.0151216965,
0.0149820289,
-0.0100763198,
0.0319532081,
-0.0378918983,
0.0077842656,
0.0048273825,
0.0103397034,
-0.0199914314,
-0.0448961966,
0.0452431738,
0.0377329513,
-0.0049080928,
-0.0219155699,
0.0334284119,
0.0259224307,
-0.0538459085,
-0.0499778949,
0.1061649323,
0.005004413,
0.0310273804,
-0.0275032204,
-0.0196222961,
0.0075650243,
0.0038662197,
-0.0473536141,
0.0566110089,
0.012271395,
-0.0032817659,
-0.0412759893,
-0.0106756305,
0.0307820905,
0.0105573153,
-0.000460161,
0.0264560375,
0.0291393101,
-0.0287947226,
0.0156169198,
-0.0043482534,
-0.0184569564,
-0.0468329005,
-0.0275973976,
0.0369757749,
-0.0398530364,
0.0011055913,
-0.0297846366,
0.0133333802,
0.0219416488,
-0.0293861497,
0.0792761371,
0.0346595384,
-0.0631200001,
0.0404322073,
0.001801219,
0.0592468753,
-0.0148261841,
0.0307299029,
-0.0237940662,
0.0204838067,
-0.0339559577,
0.0025449391,
-0.0106744627,
-0.0049274876,
-0.0477011837,
-0.0405498892,
-0.0195218287,
0.0182815138,
-0.0174377263,
0.0279780887,
-0.0081754979,
0.0081307963,
-0.0176655799,
-0.0100829899,
-0.0373183116,
0.0400240272,
-0.0215085708,
0.0337206088,
0.0195402149,
-0.0662458614,
0.0113769323,
0.0626497492,
-0.0154650128,
-0.0294419099,
0.0173623394,
0.0907108113,
-0.0392043404,
-0.0397057422,
-0.0297824629,
-0.000074797,
-0.0335384496,
-0.0887428895,
0.0447903313,
-0.0472485647,
0.039732635,
-0.0128893033,
0.0203191042,
-0.0045521231,
0.0015182582,
-0.0034133557,
0.0080674365,
0.0868889019,
0.0416507684,
-0.0079048099,
0.0301143043,
0.0260622464,
0.0040338943,
0.0682845861,
0.0225899499,
0.0393822268,
0.0313605592,
-0.0341340005,
0.0137580754,
0.0854010433,
-0.0187424403,
0.0160474218,
-0.036884129,
0.012402066,
0.0262179412,
0.0637507662,
0.0574743003,
0.0532857887,
-0.0259174928,
-0.0207552798,
0.098068893,
0.0411447361,
-0.0175025836,
-0.0478374772,
0.0464592278,
-0.0061073182,
0.021560438,
0.0288750008,
-0.0966527835,
0.0346308611,
-0.0015749113,
0.0206757188,
0.025123829,
0.0366757959,
-0.0413112976,
-0.0071099801,
-0.0100735864,
-0.0300729573,
-0.0059589762,
0.0432611741,
0.0182315987,
0.0006848532,
-0.0644138381,
0.0222499203,
0.0142609747,
-0.025732886,
-0.0038573111,
-0.0379068442,
0.0250929762,
0.0574880689,
0.0208306871,
0.0150842415,
-0.026998166,
-0.0032399171,
0.0571597293,
0.074871704,
0.0181047581,
-0.0038421513,
0.0676705018,
-0.0788942724,
-0.0271685161,
-0.0114638414,
-0.0008892725,
0.0171920806,
0.0203885455,
-0.0152594363,
-0.010520502,
-0.0120337112,
0.0125376089,
0.039389383,
-0.0166276339,
-0.0300365947,
-0.021244647,
0.0149117401,
0.0123837944,
-0.0105904192,
-0.0119503895,
-0.0153312106,
0.0343984365,
-0.0249532219,
0.0294017941,
-0.0167532805,
-0.0804595575,
-0.0343829058,
0.034647081,
-0.0231078453,
-0.0405020304,
0.039309755,
-0.0459394902,
-0.0002145532,
-0.0158621781,
-0.030659521,
-0.0034869681,
-0.0549947806,
0.0112657873,
0.0357142799,
0.0164668728,
-0.041466549,
0.0067875716,
-0.0482299738,
-0.0009150555,
0.0373275504,
0.0061545754,
-0.0187579244,
-0.0485328548,
-0.0157219823,
0.0301341191,
0.0088303173,
0.0288713779,
-0.0189451482,
0.0473711342,
-0.0520640649,
-0.0380145572,
-0.0914071798,
-0.016860107,
-0.030984126,
-0.0221945494,
0.0062041869,
0.0032722522,
-0.0093842484,
-0.0386566557,
-0.0108057028,
0.016048694,
0.0147165544,
0.028516816,
0.0147559522,
0.0185775757,
-0.0159862414,
-0.0343260989,
-0.0077250367,
0.0170128811,
0.0389770158,
-0.0258403774,
0.0219329502,
-0.0314655267,
-0.0171017926,
-0.0276935473,
0.0343204029,
-0.0302639194,
-0.0376217216,
0.0409770645,
-0.0345696695,
0.0469017774,
0.0721093118,
0.0250500441,
0.027407771,
0.0445755683,
0.000250769,
-0.0655276924,
0.0072239405,
-0.0017472397,
-0.0486594737,
-0.0469042435,
-0.0352777317,
-0.022198556,
0.0568402857,
0.0084302844,
0.056707114,
-0.0452285074,
-0.0056155073,
0.0027954858,
-0.0749508515,
-0.0459061898,
0.0328122936,
-0.0259228293,
0.007580678,
-0.0288506951,
-0.0677392706,
0.0352395773,
-0.063037701,
-0.03156057,
0.0275103524,
-0.0182473734,
-0.0254190359,
0.0692779124,
0.0261357836,
0.0156889688,
-0.0066529317,
-0.0058833598,
-0.0445887372,
-0.024895601,
0.0107039353,
0.0002087061,
0.0636339933,
-0.062266428,
-0.0073413607,
-0.0156335235,
-0.0289917812,
-0.0307866614,
-0.0247274879,
-0.0176432393,
-0.0279901586,
-0.0313121863,
-0.0095926272,
-0.0140121356,
0.0015840948,
0.0307146404,
0.0020732775,
-0.010991348,
-0.0058493046,
-0.039300736,
0.015105336,
0.059550561,
0.0471639484,
-0.0214264169,
-0.0817921907,
0.0273350421,
0.0339243785,
0.0163367204,
0.0006005515,
-0.0750281066,
0.0478308424,
0.0409735925,
0.0301385708,
0.0062543158,
0.059620887,
0.0709961057,
-0.0532482006,
0.0337279551,
0.0882382095,
-0.0034043367,
-0.0386440568,
-0.0194362197,
0.0268358048,
0.0531031676,
0.0197456162,
-0.0008016257,
-0.0764821768,
-0.0602245331,
-0.0065668807,
0.0235077906,
0.0262486022,
0.002574611,
-0.0127700446,
-0.0967433378,
0.0502710566,
0.00109156,
-0.042383723,
-0.0174512845,
-0.0177409109,
-0.01326745,
-0.0000389629,
0.0638804063,
0.0096801613,
-0.0349412449,
-0.0203348957,
0.0164170172,
-0.012528195,
-0.05242211,
0.0340686813,
-0.0541307665,
0.046225898,
0.05234842,
-0.0118556544,
-0.0074733868,
-0.0505122319,
0.0732036829,
0.035008654,
0.0182934664,
-0.0202978328,
0.0315590389,
-0.0123084011,
-0.0264380798,
0.0022036247,
0.0164984353,
-0.0021683646,
-0.0083658863,
0.0230224263,
0.0491407625,
-0.0241672546,
-0.0092873415,
-0.0170572307,
0.0197405536,
0.0138584664,
0.0693264976,
0.0397251695,
-0.0586359128,
-0.0404528975,
-0.0148254959,
-0.0066121118,
-0.0504541583,
-0.0114313541,
0.0180014353,
-0.0275225975,
0.0372029878,
-0.0503142737,
-0.0503616743,
0.0269560516,
0.0538344942,
-0.0043223659,
-0.025216708,
-0.0253024809,
0.0038537546,
-0.0165473595,
0.0670927614,
-0.0297273993,
0.0454612933,
-0.0903945938,
0.0013451783,
0.0082237031,
-0.0341353752,
0.0240372587,
0.0328578725,
-0.089780502,
-0.0519919358,
-0.0200513992,
0.0681072772,
0.0135406638,
0.0480592325,
0.0449747331,
-0.0809432343,
-0.0023311269,
0.0284815785,
0.0006365674,
0.0392024368,
0.0232973844,
-0.0017438671,
-0.0157699585,
0.0186618157,
-0.032062985,
0.0124691539,
0.0064963507,
0.0472112112,
-0.0028461271,
-0.0363633819,
0.0066565028,
0.0155094825,
0.0113657219,
-0.0535933636,
-0.0122938454,
-0.0092301592,
0.0237167533,
0.014025406,
-0.0012326343,
-0.0592367053,
-0.005070182,
0.0348001346,
0.0180507991,
0.0207274985,
-0.0097686155,
0.0113549139,
0.048898723,
-0.0569411553,
0.0241978467,
0.0119485883,
-0.0153598534,
0.0168964993,
0.0377878435,
-0.0225085169,
0.0427773967,
-0.0178436674,
0.026807081,
0.0138780894,
0.089637287,
0.0143760378,
-0.0030278105,
-0.0208270941,
0.0237010419,
-0.0074176574,
-0.0517082289,
-0.0127786258,
0.0368245319,
0.0771851167,
0.0118830875,
0.0170864761,
-0.0210035797,
-0.0108594121,
-0.0413280092,
0.0552157089,
-0.002137454,
-0.0183999985,
0.0720115751,
0.0299359616,
0.0100211687,
0.014586281,
0.0525414534,
0.023693772,
0.0584711134,
0.0010698063,
0.0533861406,
-0.0485474467,
-0.0543434396,
0.0555532612,
0.0176650584,
-0.0150331194,
0.0040141465,
0.0026976825,
-0.0643942505,
-0.0211928152,
0.0459474847,
-0.0227453541,
-0.0135843372,
0.0537392236,
0.0409068577,
0.0118248276,
-0.0147018218,
-0.0233621169,
-0.0202927645,
0.0180233233,
-0.013413311,
-0.000805254,
-6.130501321e-33,
-0.0207870584,
-0.0259806011,
0.0674292222,
-0.0154115921,
-0.0191124491,
-0.0004698585,
-0.0190082528,
0.0160974022,
0.0066724452,
-0.0088519314,
0.0171732828,
-0.0294321366,
0.0105889672,
0.041047655,
-0.0092802914,
0.001209531,
0.0291771386,
-0.0184158161,
-0.0273685809,
-0.0107059553,
-0.0129471952,
0.0045358115,
0.0182004869,
-0.0094606122,
0.0105478596,
0.01551018,
-0.0554622449,
0.0175960474,
-0.0394288786,
0.0914794952,
-0.0358409025,
0.024113277,
-0.0023259285,
-0.0121222455,
-0.0378052145,
0.0278407913,
-0.0518887565,
-0.0047291247,
0.0299040545,
0.0236350223,
-0.0862038583,
-0.0079833325,
0.0274907406,
-0.0361707509,
-0.0232057795,
-0.0296708308,
0.0212132372,
-0.0018231117,
-0.0345366821,
0.027853718,
-0.0331331529,
-0.00055058,
-0.0138509516,
-0.0336868875,
0.0151561238,
0.050024543,
-0.0007421087,
0.0220055971,
-0.0332461186,
0.0209982954,
0.000150144,
0.0191250611,
0.0851547495,
0.0626268461,
-0.0024833188,
0.0552531704,
0.0510080308,
-0.0247306731,
0.0009210992,
-0.006633068,
0.0304950625,
0.0663302466,
0.0259918664,
0.0611787252,
-0.0059178458,
0.0328819901,
-0.0362961479,
0.0202958025,
0.0010837414,
0.029561827,
0.0194953401,
0.0090795355,
-0.0030364867,
-0.0023372287,
-0.0567517914,
0.0483851433,
-0.0334739052,
-0.0017770119,
0.0684137046,
0.0317965783,
0.0057057394,
0.0003879296,
0.0837488994,
-0.036480695,
-0.0338082463,
-0.0289286617,
-0.0198271684,
0.0508607924,
0.0134249162,
0.0283748861,
-0.0439528301,
-0.0231759641,
0.0378119685,
-0.0287511591,
0.0297333207,
0.0212978814,
0.0192464888,
0.0247577988,
-0.0589165092,
-0.0060505155,
-0.0280325189,
0.0242529213,
0.0014428773,
0.0099733295,
0.0335438028,
-0.0374027975,
-0.0513148271,
0.0722181946,
-0.0382512659,
-0.0361342207,
-0.0335808471,
-0.0475979485,
-0.0171860196,
0.0397496708,
-0.0364782177,
0.0265480112,
-0.0518500023,
-0.0414108448,
0.0190667827,
-0.0490496345,
-0.0018737469,
0.0466513447,
2.429e-7,
0.0117791817,
0.0138121005,
0.008316326,
0.0565117821,
0.0043322998,
0.0460767522,
-0.0613076724,
0.0153028946,
-0.0060365926,
-0.0328889973,
-0.0346293934,
0.0527087413,
0.0538159274,
-0.0071273101,
-0.0351115242,
0.0012330126,
-0.037280526,
0.0054624574,
-0.0608456247,
0.0088928267,
0.0204187334,
0.0558157936,
-0.0396520831,
-0.0445866622,
0.029991556,
-0.0359441526,
0.0734591186,
-0.0609435774,
-0.0368249416,
-0.0175473094,
0.0297820363,
-0.0032121777,
0.0057104719,
0.0175829697,
-0.0055900337,
-0.0468652025,
0.0029739286,
0.0815604031,
0.0090765906,
-0.0676677525,
-0.0111276386,
0.0219745189,
-0.0369654372,
-0.0472511873,
0.0573491044,
-0.0255829804,
-0.0062644579,
-0.0394475833,
-0.012172184,
-0.0367471203,
0.0308932494,
-0.0403617546,
-0.0288791321,
0.0120849228,
0.0458243564,
-0.0387078822,
-0.0360002369,
-0.0604065321,
-0.01950261,
-0.0127403159,
-0.0609445609,
-0.066162996,
-0.0656400546,
0.0004444064,
0.0146472109,
-0.0561628528,
-0.0602921173,
1.996495651e-34,
0.0343694799,
-0.0195331648,
0.0514438041,
0.0341946371,
0.0111607714,
-0.0094099538,
-0.0482856221,
0.0060466337,
-0.0133973453,
-0.0930243284,
-0.0051496881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01505v1 | Self-Cognition in Large Language Models: An Exploratory Study | 2024-07-01T17:52:05 | 2024-07-01T17:52:05 | Dongping Chen, Jiawen Shi, Yao Wan, Pan Zhou, Neil Zhenqiang Gong, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success across
various applications, they also raise concerns regarding self-cognition. In
this paper, we perform a pioneering study to explore self-cognition in LLMs.
Specifically, we first construct a pool of self-cognition instruction prompts
to evaluate where an LLM exhibits self-cognition and four well-designed
principles to quantify LLMs' self-cognition. Our study reveals that 4 of the 48
models on Chatbot Arena--specifically Command R, Claude3-Opus,
Llama-3-70b-Instruct, and Reka-core--demonstrate some level of detectable
self-cognition. We observe a positive correlation between model size, training
data quality, and self-cognition level. Additionally, we also explore the
utility and trustworthiness of LLM in the self-cognition state, revealing that
the self-cognition state enhances some specific tasks such as creative writing
and exaggeration. We believe that our work can serve as an inspiration for
further research to study the self-cognition in LLMs. | [
0.0512772053,
0.0077244896,
-0.0471525416,
0.0152188269,
-0.0446906239,
-0.0022465414,
0.0264497735,
-0.0000194707,
0.0703866035,
-0.0346150547,
-0.0695912018,
0.008266598,
-0.0193744469,
0.0123597402,
0.0367697217,
-0.027685605,
0.0410159752,
-0.0490167253,
0.0316607356,
-0.0172611848,
-0.0145819327,
0.0110742422,
-0.0288400166,
0.0542318858,
-0.0122993235,
-0.0647655353,
-0.0046536732,
-0.0086823776,
-0.0266191866,
-0.0457652099,
-0.0066492944,
0.0669344738,
0.0137895346,
0.027423732,
0.0000019358,
-0.0665667504,
0.0020446063,
-0.0458581224,
-0.0319607481,
0.0190725625,
0.041852925,
0.0482612811,
-0.0239500217,
0.025476303,
-0.0357155949,
0.0338431634,
0.0114521747,
0.0426278599,
0.0728139654,
0.0652183741,
0.0056266552,
0.0179463383,
0.0018285557,
0.0011242884,
-0.0019727657,
-0.0089545595,
0.0076454445,
0.0401638336,
-0.0004976342,
-0.0042673158,
-0.0211304463,
0.0347791798,
0.0304125473,
-0.0426308699,
0.0087242704,
0.0265057869,
0.0011019111,
-0.0258912202,
-0.0208828878,
0.0105051333,
0.0573192835,
-0.0397583321,
0.0036222511,
0.017880071,
0.0382820852,
-0.0032915063,
-0.02661746,
0.0357178897,
0.0211703889,
-0.0131339198,
-0.0132951317,
0.0121953003,
-0.0126098087,
-0.0149581246,
0.0047555249,
0.0540641472,
-0.0123966383,
-0.030260291,
-0.0079638809,
0.0064732088,
0.0114217084,
-0.1012812108,
-0.0092373919,
0.0600458309,
-0.017349625,
0.0180648062,
-0.0536838733,
-0.0025362899,
0.0069590867,
-0.0554797016,
0.0450755134,
0.0361016989,
0.0055722189,
0.0262445379,
0.0040852255,
0.072965309,
0.007169825,
0.0480810925,
-0.0140930777,
0.0419475548,
-0.0477173664,
-0.0472341627,
-0.0600921065,
0.0345705636,
0.0635625944,
-0.0243930463,
-0.0722506195,
0.0384410433,
-0.0112017542,
-0.0139517644,
-0.0206505954,
0.011556237,
0.0149773061,
-0.0180137176,
-0.0394321568,
-0.0050841896,
-0.0251699947,
-0.0168377794,
0.0062615704,
-0.0493777283,
0.0062311166,
-0.0072984761,
-0.0190965552,
-0.0206267703,
-0.0043116864,
0.0628244802,
-0.0123399766,
-0.0395768695,
-0.0290238727,
-0.025099894,
-0.0226161927,
-0.0927848965,
-0.0126108276,
-0.0541491173,
-0.0388652273,
-0.000173445,
0.0105662337,
-0.0387314595,
0.0000904282,
0.0059834179,
-0.0123713771,
0.0314017162,
-0.0258616172,
0.0436680019,
0.0452015698,
0.0152493697,
-0.0059990576,
0.0572016425,
0.041607976,
0.0167779662,
0.0047007655,
-0.0263825152,
0.0395866819,
0.0109514585,
-0.0146724405,
-0.0319642387,
-0.056868352,
-0.0126893725,
-0.0298656337,
0.0408407822,
0.0290214028,
0.0587850846,
-0.0167751051,
0.0201557055,
0.0992440507,
0.064079009,
0.0134506496,
0.014801803,
0.0350647829,
0.0292447414,
0.062984027,
0.0378988124,
-0.0432161242,
0.06806162,
-0.015450933,
-0.0062613538,
-0.002364208,
-0.0067003807,
-0.0237587877,
-0.0613302179,
-0.0424557664,
-0.0031245067,
-0.0118767917,
0.0087962057,
0.0227004457,
0.0044215936,
0.0070858374,
-0.0233463682,
-0.0060692546,
-0.0556692928,
-0.0406486802,
-0.0812750459,
0.0410963595,
0.090710856,
0.0393032581,
-0.0131505011,
-0.0139867533,
-0.0090337964,
0.0108556589,
0.0566107184,
0.0740827173,
0.0159027986,
-0.0349064432,
-0.0046275342,
0.0064689168,
-0.0616343245,
0.0213352349,
-0.0123060504,
0.0025983639,
0.0249022227,
-0.0362553857,
0.0150715662,
-0.0311699919,
0.0387199447,
-0.0389822572,
-0.0338960402,
-0.0510287695,
0.0139420414,
0.0062164711,
0.0208021756,
-0.0203371979,
0.0170266367,
0.0129213231,
0.0037716618,
-0.049546916,
0.0427049845,
-0.0613350868,
-0.0133258607,
0.0412805565,
0.0042235269,
-0.0123051694,
-0.0019547872,
0.0574024878,
-0.0168348663,
0.0335252769,
-0.076456435,
0.0374978557,
-0.0263281465,
0.0663602948,
-0.0508311987,
0.013627626,
-0.0018818864,
0.0405886509,
0.0055295196,
-0.0016063662,
0.0122984098,
0.0034440693,
0.0008472773,
-0.0223539639,
-0.0247896351,
-0.0060448549,
-0.0121427746,
0.0251649469,
0.0234621279,
0.000736449,
-0.0618046969,
-0.0272997618,
-0.0697429106,
-0.0261727683,
0.0096600587,
-0.0208596271,
0.0270957369,
-0.0505658835,
-0.0439815335,
-0.0102743348,
-0.0226914678,
-0.006631182,
0.0096234698,
0.0284290444,
0.0430066809,
-0.0337107107,
-0.0150958057,
-0.028101895,
0.0257000607,
-0.0182341654,
0.0124754123,
0.023960866,
0.0011977666,
-0.0632270202,
0.0730462968,
-0.0525535308,
0.0084042801,
-0.0082036918,
-0.0869644731,
0.0555740707,
-0.0002568738,
0.0450076237,
0.0738118067,
0.0352740847,
0.0414252542,
0.1084658504,
-0.0055412469,
-0.0483817123,
0.0017688383,
0.0447051562,
-0.0038816456,
-0.0200042613,
-0.0450987816,
0.0219705887,
0.0802609846,
0.028060412,
0.0303998757,
-0.0335118808,
0.0455983691,
-0.0366874449,
-0.0839488506,
-0.0023347563,
-0.009186117,
-0.0187129322,
0.0492920652,
0.016756963,
-0.0766718984,
0.0996995941,
-0.0150994221,
-0.0101621142,
0.0142761832,
-0.0282886736,
-0.0031737571,
0.0802108869,
-0.0114395553,
0.0282397084,
0.0574398413,
-0.0196956452,
-0.0498548038,
-0.0070015918,
0.0181025919,
-0.0275448281,
-0.0009556817,
-0.0177456625,
-0.0027695096,
0.0250311289,
-0.0356547199,
-0.0610189922,
-0.0383230187,
-0.045213405,
-0.0451685078,
0.0311942007,
-0.0137600377,
-0.0092790425,
-0.0068680407,
0.0415770635,
0.0133041777,
-0.0243259501,
-0.0310886763,
0.0140106231,
-0.0383463427,
0.0441987701,
0.022963576,
0.0482088327,
-0.0297910254,
0.0850550383,
0.0310404804,
0.0197982024,
-0.003762387,
-0.0195734072,
-0.0209107473,
0.0132027455,
-0.0076398426,
-0.0023531842,
0.0326227099,
0.1001492739,
-0.0416536257,
-0.0267110188,
0.1177856997,
0.0259477515,
-0.0248562563,
0.0130582042,
-0.056708239,
0.0138694728,
0.0493885241,
0.0259912536,
-0.0336220711,
-0.0036510311,
0.011203602,
-0.0010585337,
-0.0487830676,
-0.0359283388,
-0.0248664971,
-0.0898856744,
0.0474041402,
-0.0085506188,
-0.0211081356,
0.0209082309,
0.0059709679,
-0.0096807154,
0.0226604771,
0.0028145385,
0.0004388622,
-0.0509341061,
-0.0290796049,
-0.0093900142,
-0.065758802,
-0.0136247659,
0.0367364623,
-0.0286774449,
0.0928008854,
0.0213433336,
0.0442428067,
0.0183442459,
-0.0222960394,
0.0046527302,
0.0404915996,
0.0441831797,
0.0089900456,
0.0667762905,
-0.0298078842,
-0.0024408738,
-0.0181995351,
-0.0094607454,
0.0005789746,
0.0101339379,
0.0196590908,
0.0403239913,
-0.0343392827,
-0.0494648814,
-0.0080521135,
0.0183212906,
-0.0201567113,
0.0722940788,
0.0365678594,
-0.0435778573,
-0.0322841182,
-0.0192135628,
-0.0018040191,
0.0139352027,
-0.0704569444,
0.0025704023,
0.0223225486,
0.0057544489,
-0.0774112791,
-0.0549253412,
0.0318039134,
0.0228203312,
0.0245432258,
0.0262123793,
-0.0058104615,
0.0204445608,
-0.0150334677,
-0.0281244759,
-0.0668071657,
0.0069386652,
-0.0627378896,
-0.008905258,
0.0025006009,
-0.0524174608,
0.0398536585,
0.0121635031,
-0.0306153353,
-0.0691234767,
0.0203332119,
0.0447104126,
0.0296584554,
-0.0057326481,
-0.0017252046,
-0.0687741041,
0.0280045047,
0.0082089873,
-0.071944274,
0.0481536463,
0.018334711,
0.0294795353,
0.0140950857,
0.0479090549,
-0.0008257586,
0.0336585417,
-0.009107383,
0.0218471903,
0.0047516394,
-0.0432342403,
0.0394267291,
0.0366883315,
-0.0082716495,
-0.0232824069,
0.0578553863,
-0.0382543318,
-0.0150699457,
-0.0749164373,
-0.0122010913,
-0.0200959425,
0.0065551018,
0.0151902055,
0.0085461698,
0.025903672,
-0.0408519618,
-0.028929336,
-0.0054000034,
0.0173890591,
-0.0198054984,
-0.0140982363,
0.0239254721,
0.0145299826,
0.0140439831,
-0.0117143057,
0.0155469822,
-0.0017553363,
0.0037824095,
0.0391911305,
0.0751590952,
-0.0097185997,
-0.0382680409,
-0.0093170805,
0.0391759835,
-0.0738664195,
-0.0733885169,
0.0455915369,
0.0444416106,
0.055733107,
0.0156882685,
0.0609499477,
-0.0490001515,
0.0140133407,
0.0010936267,
0.022564631,
0.001056056,
-0.0346435755,
-0.0159133282,
0.0123550212,
-0.0368883498,
-0.0219286103,
0.0438543633,
0.0042323968,
0.0303713009,
-0.0019269029,
-0.0349741578,
-0.0575994626,
-0.0206611566,
-0.0209208652,
0.0090448866,
-0.0183926485,
-0.009085793,
-0.0646703392,
-0.079548344,
-0.0138578592,
0.0390278772,
-0.0018152986,
-0.0664959848,
0.0210067276,
0.062526308,
-0.0101813804,
0.0027599914,
-0.031872455,
0.0085722003,
-0.0201230086,
0.0122515298,
0.0114047201,
-5.738252815e-33,
-0.0322491862,
-0.0512282886,
0.0436153226,
-0.0138613777,
-0.0146055343,
-0.0218920745,
-0.0604011491,
0.0607743189,
-0.0080613736,
0.0057104407,
-0.031639915,
0.0198601075,
0.0065283659,
-0.037877731,
0.0501390509,
0.0325822942,
0.0574211404,
-0.0418729335,
-0.0558280721,
-0.003696186,
0.0268838815,
0.0074939099,
0.0428550728,
-0.0501590632,
0.0156433005,
-0.0045603556,
-0.014203513,
-0.0009668634,
-0.0251609907,
0.0487727784,
-0.0428120047,
0.0282012355,
0.0254465435,
0.0016444864,
-0.0166864414,
0.0112664206,
0.0070521994,
-0.0577137396,
-0.0107668117,
-0.0035421143,
-0.040234372,
-0.0363128036,
0.0199863557,
-0.0277408715,
-0.0416643098,
0.0223284531,
0.0284187775,
-0.0013773832,
0.0408104993,
0.048328016,
-0.0790243745,
-0.0159815606,
-0.0159644745,
-0.0582907088,
0.0067045167,
0.0089663155,
-0.0127997156,
-0.0125338957,
-0.056179747,
0.0419010781,
-0.0342816897,
0.0124407001,
0.081193991,
-0.003739353,
0.0342936404,
0.0765789077,
0.0430035964,
0.0615291744,
-0.0218483619,
0.0064643221,
0.0494239442,
0.0300485119,
0.0534938648,
0.0329488814,
-0.00626367,
-0.0482017957,
0.0003410209,
-0.0161188617,
0.0473878942,
-0.0064179008,
0.0484495386,
-0.0019862677,
-0.0648590848,
-0.0244224761,
-0.0101320911,
-0.0148856714,
-0.0159258358,
-0.0534384176,
0.0227542594,
0.0123458086,
0.00700618,
-0.052957736,
0.0158429798,
-0.0217231736,
-0.0299110729,
-0.0122015057,
-0.0637119561,
0.0557217784,
-0.0010637394,
0.0195660535,
-0.0401777513,
0.0234042779,
-0.0162094235,
0.0235891696,
0.0348378718,
0.037565466,
0.0178048294,
0.0390773118,
-0.0603702627,
0.0027415392,
-0.0319168121,
0.0286732297,
0.0164340716,
-0.0364384577,
0.0292117074,
-0.0158998277,
-0.0367138386,
0.0240045916,
-0.012167912,
-0.0421287976,
-0.0592409596,
0.0338921249,
-0.0231557954,
-0.0149731934,
-0.0008077049,
-0.0082516186,
-0.0657003596,
0.0629420057,
0.0499767698,
-0.0485497974,
-0.0010900968,
-0.0163031034,
2.718e-7,
-0.0385009982,
0.0578721724,
-0.0048651746,
0.0145108216,
0.0257854685,
0.0652885437,
-0.0439907089,
0.0129589625,
0.0115753328,
-0.0201789085,
-0.0245806258,
0.0573529378,
0.0556393787,
0.0311075673,
-0.0560617186,
0.0051424615,
-0.0581653342,
0.0068784081,
-0.035804987,
-0.0234431978,
0.0418594107,
0.0176059585,
0.0470443889,
-0.0134548219,
-0.0316386931,
-0.0262852367,
0.0495349541,
-0.0190297347,
0.0083040921,
0.0428131782,
0.0369247161,
0.032345064,
-0.008557179,
0.0092380103,
0.0253140442,
0.0039321817,
-0.0147412661,
0.0446845107,
0.019497674,
0.0141608538,
0.0275540315,
0.0298070628,
-0.0243788715,
-0.0650350824,
0.0380666777,
-0.0719857886,
-0.035634622,
-0.0473483764,
0.0495882034,
-0.0315604433,
0.0562777407,
-0.033789698,
-0.0179005247,
0.0326375216,
0.0074916496,
-0.0057850447,
0.0085004102,
-0.0257481299,
-0.01734435,
-0.0453550629,
-0.0231471285,
-0.0334576108,
-0.064914234,
0.0220826138,
-0.0083078165,
-0.0694961548,
0.0374065936,
1.920236603e-34,
-0.0076149874,
-0.0054626097,
0.026673751,
0.0084480094,
0.0359688848,
0.0199934319,
0.032461118,
0.0119471103,
0.0063742516,
-0.0305549856,
-0.0209182259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01492v1 | RegMix: Data Mixture as Regression for Language Model Pre-training | 2024-07-01T17:31:03 | 2024-07-01T17:31:03 | Qian Liu, Xiaosen Zheng, Niklas Muennighoff, Guangtao Zeng, Longxu Dou, Tianyu Pang, Jing Jiang, Min Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The data mixture for large language model pre-training significantly impacts
performance, yet how to determine an effective mixture remains unclear. We
propose RegMix to automatically identify a high-performing data mixture by
formulating it as a regression task. RegMix involves training a set of small
models with diverse data mixtures and fitting a regression model to predict
their performance given their respective mixtures. With the fitted regression
model, we simulate the top-ranked mixture and use it to train a large-scale
model with orders of magnitude more compute. To empirically validate RegMix, we
train 512 models with 1M parameters for 1B tokens of different mixtures to fit
the regression model and find the optimal mixture. Using this mixture we train
a 1B parameter model for 25B tokens (i.e. 1000x larger and 25x longer) which we
find performs best among 64 candidate 1B parameter models with other mixtures.
Further, our method demonstrates superior performance compared to human
selection and achieves results that match or surpass DoReMi, while utilizing
only 10% of the compute budget. Our experiments also show that (1) Data
mixtures significantly impact performance with single-task performance
variations of up to 14.6%; (2) Web corpora rather than data perceived as
high-quality like Wikipedia have the strongest positive correlation with
downstream performance; (3) Domains interact in complex ways often
contradicting common sense, thus automatic approaches like RegMix are needed;
(4) Data mixture effects transcend scaling laws, and our approach captures the
complexity by considering all domains together. Our code is available at
https://github.com/sail-sg/regmix. | [
0.022672385,
0.0829120651,
-0.0250786673,
0.0333399735,
0.0098517928,
0.0269735325,
0.0268867575,
0.0449787341,
-0.0108481571,
-0.0780734941,
-0.0174798239,
-0.0343782529,
0.0239845216,
0.0331923254,
0.0378653072,
-0.07737571,
0.0393526219,
-0.0478742979,
-0.0088364221,
-0.015922837,
0.0089309225,
0.0040227501,
0.0194964744,
0.0279882085,
0.0005471711,
0.0092694601,
0.0278702416,
0.0010806238,
-0.0157420672,
0.0243080948,
0.0289103128,
0.0739109591,
0.0151255662,
0.0544148274,
0.0000019721,
-0.0457117148,
-0.005792378,
0.006862028,
-0.024728911,
0.0083146216,
0.0251100361,
0.0179747436,
-0.0126812691,
0.0260486305,
-0.0020088146,
-0.0212190319,
0.0374060459,
0.0270154588,
0.0151599748,
0.072496675,
0.0095526092,
0.009746287,
0.0105557954,
0.0020915577,
0.0254853982,
0.0078851227,
0.0230438057,
0.0195417386,
-0.0178482644,
-0.0035717452,
-0.0304344278,
-0.0026508691,
-0.0096154399,
0.0293043163,
0.0480051041,
0.0239683837,
-0.0383611433,
-0.036820922,
-0.0046283295,
0.080078423,
-0.0471001454,
-0.0138523988,
0.0312860385,
-0.0022046487,
-0.0173421223,
0.0264156535,
-0.0368458591,
0.0039068731,
-0.0132176187,
-0.0000224498,
-0.0269419104,
-0.0098520238,
0.0461466275,
0.0282157641,
-0.0530708693,
0.0268795826,
0.0281154141,
-0.0087589612,
0.0076756896,
-0.002117079,
-0.0065041529,
-0.0627201274,
0.0021165439,
-0.01619469,
-0.0529018193,
0.0083765611,
-0.0322377086,
-0.0757624954,
0.0348560587,
-0.0263342839,
-0.0027198624,
0.0405739062,
0.0034367354,
0.048796948,
-0.0252629127,
0.0537838712,
-0.006450939,
-0.026766574,
-0.0277559906,
-0.026540054,
-0.067777887,
0.0158655103,
0.0114874579,
0.0443777181,
-0.0200326685,
-0.0173942428,
-0.0690600947,
0.0206492804,
-0.0188286584,
0.0059778411,
0.052748803,
0.0083800834,
-0.0325752832,
0.0224898625,
-0.0285042562,
0.0243368205,
-0.0636285394,
0.0021393632,
0.0305100251,
-0.0444360934,
0.0342062749,
0.0149603076,
-0.0079156915,
-0.0341885984,
0.0260593928,
0.0807613432,
0.00064117,
-0.0063253073,
-0.0453813449,
-0.0240410641,
0.0104131801,
-0.0475539416,
0.0161140263,
-0.0882831961,
0.0292735696,
0.035956502,
0.0188198406,
-0.0646234751,
-0.0284629073,
-0.0068844813,
-0.0437047407,
0.0600558482,
-0.035523694,
-0.0009340288,
0.0167219713,
0.0040275082,
-0.0664992034,
0.1319672763,
-0.0013412244,
0.0208415929,
0.0615937635,
0.001121052,
-0.0022797436,
0.0157675184,
0.0122112548,
0.0326563828,
-0.0199844856,
0.0178334136,
0.0348532759,
-0.0051455814,
0.0448226891,
0.0489340872,
-0.0175113901,
-0.0002761698,
0.0524629429,
0.0396938175,
0.0231682863,
0.0221605338,
0.0353357643,
0.0085820425,
0.0116899861,
0.0043090805,
-0.0208227281,
-0.0100349458,
-0.0373020321,
0.0048512449,
0.0751169771,
0.1083063334,
-0.0430043302,
-0.0267758127,
-0.0179020762,
-0.0284330882,
-0.0204117093,
0.0061794869,
0.072037138,
-0.0396437496,
-0.0140587231,
0.0382333919,
0.0436508879,
-0.0320772566,
0.0207065213,
-0.0377393775,
-0.0017455549,
0.0500891432,
0.0219966508,
-0.060140267,
0.025152659,
-0.0073194057,
0.0138041303,
-0.0079864124,
0.0490872487,
-0.0309369992,
0.0054074507,
-0.0572770387,
-0.0402182415,
0.0337702595,
0.0401411429,
0.0333762094,
0.0364514701,
0.0343225263,
0.0315514207,
-0.0548374914,
-0.0069705965,
0.0381566025,
-0.0420654714,
0.0169613846,
0.0287371352,
-0.0054106573,
0.0317479074,
0.0024395429,
-0.004635857,
-0.0162361711,
-0.0045514069,
-0.0147462906,
-0.0482574739,
-0.0207864027,
0.0032915906,
-0.0233375262,
0.0515300483,
-0.001722159,
-0.0024321319,
0.0158092417,
-0.0479911044,
-0.0556525849,
0.0421769358,
-0.0102384575,
0.0652230382,
-0.0114526795,
0.0141692366,
-0.0341195576,
-0.001332022,
-0.0208301712,
0.0617969632,
0.0113701485,
0.0465285927,
0.0294118077,
-0.0335413665,
0.0196718033,
0.0008043484,
-0.0202848408,
-0.0214357413,
-0.036753282,
0.0705089569,
0.0275606159,
-0.0433063619,
-0.0637625232,
-0.0078924093,
-0.0645991713,
0.0063639544,
-0.0423803329,
0.0087081632,
0.016847657,
0.0218328778,
-0.0078169564,
-0.0002571086,
0.0032690256,
-0.0105521558,
0.006562606,
0.0448788442,
-0.0028334919,
0.0075589395,
-0.0221848618,
-0.0533237979,
-0.0489692017,
-0.0257422328,
0.0659007058,
-0.0087227002,
-0.0070453421,
-0.0469635986,
-0.0149721429,
-0.0412723832,
0.0028465388,
-0.0162273832,
-0.0302979071,
-0.0190284085,
0.0043180417,
0.0620297678,
0.0432323217,
0.0175994541,
-0.0153334038,
0.0375781357,
-0.0192404948,
-0.0513205267,
-0.0249009728,
0.0125917653,
0.0242519081,
-0.0305322371,
-0.0105112679,
0.0067662229,
0.0378951356,
-0.0121553317,
-0.0311065726,
-0.0597899593,
0.0358573683,
-0.0588769652,
0.0108545888,
-0.0595274195,
0.0042250948,
0.0130292336,
0.0684217215,
0.0088752974,
-0.0583215095,
0.0747792274,
-0.0140503235,
0.030283045,
-0.0324261449,
-0.0226751491,
-0.0276320614,
-0.0054678931,
-0.0221645404,
0.0212437715,
-0.0024202361,
0.0020400726,
-0.0503815822,
0.0353585035,
0.0283640586,
-0.0339094363,
0.0615638234,
-0.0122644128,
0.0152868936,
-0.0121730529,
-0.0448521562,
-0.0453137718,
-0.0330902413,
-0.0072790096,
0.0176759809,
0.062515229,
-0.0479754061,
-0.0471179187,
-0.0065724752,
-0.0051106149,
0.0156421438,
-0.0276565254,
-0.023867052,
0.0202494245,
0.0103328684,
0.0291694459,
0.0025989767,
0.0398062021,
-0.0474666767,
0.0114407223,
0.0074303853,
0.0773312226,
-0.0461698845,
-0.0382965207,
0.0031087601,
0.0112336772,
-0.0405215994,
-0.0158939417,
0.0247797072,
0.0329149701,
-0.0259645097,
0.0143399872,
0.108417742,
-0.0013961362,
-0.0630401745,
-0.0264976807,
-0.0132368952,
0.0687131509,
0.0477475189,
0.0367885232,
-0.0450191312,
-0.0086772572,
0.0223893039,
0.0228033587,
0.0177457482,
-0.0177931562,
0.0239991229,
-0.0872353464,
0.0041507143,
-0.0055904477,
-0.053577546,
-0.0312174745,
-0.10080605,
-0.0071585611,
-0.0311509371,
0.0266598929,
-0.0040360778,
-0.0295632929,
-0.0007034379,
-0.0010814907,
-0.0307922531,
-0.0994480029,
0.0324607491,
-0.0445182025,
0.0673106089,
0.0259346552,
0.0099350326,
-0.0256597009,
-0.0095252516,
0.0298060998,
-0.0306514949,
-0.035040427,
-0.0045097335,
0.0866363347,
-0.007120803,
0.0011836789,
-0.0068929503,
-0.006883753,
-0.036513947,
-0.0036169889,
0.0103458948,
0.0767794624,
0.0191955306,
-0.0045828344,
-0.0425785631,
-0.0503319427,
0.0268634707,
0.0756832063,
0.0257807095,
-0.0566745922,
-0.0012187123,
-0.0381018743,
-0.0427806377,
-0.0047215214,
0.0166081768,
0.0139139229,
-0.0092446888,
-0.0419280231,
-0.0747269988,
0.0041063102,
0.0334707722,
0.0501912422,
0.0104646571,
0.0301047731,
-0.0066630458,
0.0140357483,
-0.0484858714,
0.0495255589,
-0.016544668,
0.0158016868,
-0.0862898752,
-0.0007299469,
0.0226105098,
-0.0021236897,
-0.027651865,
-0.0333840288,
-0.1070403978,
-0.0847400352,
-0.0146637261,
0.060042955,
0.0286180861,
0.0242029428,
0.0016492639,
-0.0686270967,
0.0727110356,
0.0307379253,
-0.0655903444,
-0.0015398142,
0.0346625708,
-0.0564535223,
-0.0025366361,
0.0114358552,
-0.082693018,
-0.0044925059,
0.0048818248,
-0.0267737638,
-0.0034997051,
0.0454932973,
0.0002362441,
0.0202480499,
0.040326152,
-0.0324077085,
-0.0169234797,
-0.057861831,
-0.0111666275,
0.0173205752,
-0.0115078501,
-0.012025713,
-0.0005608515,
0.0056444872,
-0.0164650269,
-0.0043935035,
0.0071893819,
0.0049478929,
-0.002534773,
-0.0588404126,
-0.0022443158,
0.0048603443,
-0.0079420386,
0.0600710362,
-0.0124612264,
0.0070330943,
-0.0332019404,
0.0144021455,
0.0200938806,
-0.0550131649,
-0.003262321,
0.0151763977,
0.0049805255,
-0.0286364816,
0.0182438083,
-0.051046472,
-0.0460844673,
-0.000201526,
-0.0024109327,
0.0690046027,
-0.0402512364,
0.0497625545,
-0.0076192282,
-0.0051135421,
-0.0354996175,
0.0023684152,
-0.0007384134,
0.0074615451,
0.0241879616,
0.0152478023,
-0.0352470875,
0.0195252001,
0.1021129191,
0.0010484965,
0.0082553206,
0.0002395075,
-0.0109082051,
-0.0253904834,
0.0198006164,
-0.0083224904,
0.063529253,
-0.0554187298,
-0.0339026302,
-0.0357191227,
-0.0874418318,
-0.0226242281,
-0.0122048855,
-0.0041933889,
0.0246476792,
0.0406696536,
0.0619080812,
-0.0058613434,
0.0453100316,
-0.0485108793,
-0.0204143319,
0.002066362,
-0.0045197131,
0.0044450457,
-6.50714514e-33,
0.0140709793,
-0.0083930241,
-0.0112383831,
-0.0369268656,
0.0166223124,
0.0295611043,
-0.0051955269,
0.0091887219,
-0.031634476,
-0.0036756189,
-0.02393605,
0.0174875427,
0.0148955546,
0.0207243264,
0.0431755558,
0.0163328648,
0.0464371741,
0.0011043851,
-0.0405675657,
0.0207449105,
0.0403509848,
0.0213888288,
0.0143928649,
-0.0394412912,
-0.0112222247,
0.0280730911,
0.0111022703,
-0.0035455704,
0.0338060856,
0.0971767455,
-0.0059770192,
0.0892424211,
0.0280005261,
-0.0328954421,
-0.0320732854,
-0.0064944248,
-0.0474767499,
-0.0345204771,
0.0055334438,
0.0041246475,
0.0260625314,
-0.0000469713,
0.046625156,
-0.0045894957,
0.0180512778,
-0.036727868,
0.0710940287,
-0.0145027991,
-0.0172908027,
-0.0309113357,
-0.0515923016,
0.0355296098,
-0.0191538651,
0.0394018963,
0.0399511382,
0.043174807,
0.0286134351,
0.047431916,
-0.0464918017,
0.0363396183,
-0.0036664805,
0.0733538121,
0.0851944238,
0.0524756089,
-0.0086809825,
0.0730264112,
0.0025151905,
0.0530599691,
0.0044222255,
-0.0100388741,
0.0560047589,
0.0407281294,
0.0311014578,
0.0338064134,
0.0523563847,
-0.0657995343,
-0.0710044056,
0.0476502962,
0.0475219265,
-0.0158322472,
0.0188708305,
0.0209419522,
-0.0243894346,
-0.0305903107,
-0.0288920961,
0.0115525126,
-0.0474536046,
-0.0240171794,
0.0278642811,
0.0089045446,
-0.0374379456,
-0.0386990793,
0.0375470854,
-0.0670180172,
-0.067164138,
0.0232801121,
-0.0165685099,
0.0045698034,
0.0131845633,
0.0137271937,
-0.0398404635,
-0.0772412196,
-0.0028093073,
0.0094081918,
0.02202392,
-0.0087972162,
0.0218335092,
-0.0065504047,
-0.0649310946,
0.0136665991,
-0.0282582343,
0.0053691687,
0.0133449417,
0.0395819768,
0.027218448,
0.0276681408,
-0.0107790139,
0.0186388269,
0.0354109593,
-0.0296007432,
-0.0317431316,
0.0025835154,
0.000072183,
0.0142044807,
-0.0401078016,
-0.0492224731,
-0.0518603362,
0.0132284183,
0.0682029873,
-0.0180451609,
-0.0307772569,
-0.0229842328,
2.573e-7,
0.0353614166,
0.0651781037,
-0.0288531855,
0.0034845565,
-0.007829641,
0.013311564,
-0.0259281974,
-0.0017236354,
0.0036557193,
-0.0437988453,
-0.0064542503,
0.0046800529,
0.0547442399,
0.0551001541,
-0.0733282417,
-0.0324624144,
-0.0529449843,
0.0023418223,
-0.0817271322,
0.004179562,
0.0012633121,
0.1081957966,
0.0298217256,
-0.0270935837,
-0.0036653241,
0.0042142579,
0.0408677794,
-0.0427166969,
0.0144809736,
0.0382172391,
0.039778199,
0.0302663203,
0.0089500006,
0.0443804823,
-0.051276233,
0.0032794576,
-0.0056604128,
0.0449740179,
-0.0162994526,
0.0256400555,
0.0189463366,
-0.0415751413,
-0.0035170005,
-0.0680606812,
0.0495192036,
0.0146839479,
0.0005260062,
-0.045937784,
-0.0139806531,
-0.0285627134,
0.0435444191,
-0.0285096914,
-0.0208163746,
0.0494693294,
-0.0065478198,
-0.0009252523,
0.0009899344,
-0.0830733925,
-0.0153206093,
0.0167249776,
-0.0619361997,
-0.0461443774,
-0.0364902057,
-0.0014118728,
0.0691593736,
-0.0315471925,
0.0183098391,
2.757888367e-34,
0.0556697845,
0.0047227037,
0.0179701373,
0.0206351206,
0.0426344164,
-0.0366132036,
-0.0386754796,
0.006076958,
-0.0169036873,
-0.0440959446,
-0.0027391892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01491v1 | Expressive and Generalizable Low-rank Adaptation for Large Models via Slow Cascaded Learning | 2024-07-01T17:28:59 | 2024-07-01T17:28:59 | Siwei Li, Yifan Yang, Yifei Shen, Fangyun Wei, Zongqing Lu, Lili Qiu, Yuqing Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Efficient fine-tuning plays a fundamental role in modern large models, with
low-rank adaptation emerging as a particularly promising approach. However, the
existing variants of LoRA are hampered by limited expressiveness, a tendency to
overfit, and sensitivity to hyperparameter settings. This paper presents LoRA
Slow Cascade Learning (LoRASC), an innovative technique designed to enhance
LoRA's expressiveness and generalization capabilities while preserving its
training efficiency. Our approach augments expressiveness through a cascaded
learning strategy that enables a mixture-of-low-rank adaptation, thereby
increasing the model's ability to capture complex patterns. Additionally, we
introduce a slow-fast update mechanism and cascading noisy tuning to bolster
generalization. The extensive experiments on various language and vision
datasets, as well as robustness benchmarks, demonstrate that the proposed
method not only significantly outperforms existing baselines, but also
mitigates overfitting, enhances model stability, and improves OOD robustness.
Code will be release in https://github.com/microsoft/LoRASC very soon. | [
0.0002231334,
0.1020762473,
-0.0165364277,
0.0542712435,
0.0617490634,
0.0403505303,
-0.0354858451,
0.0214886069,
0.0076718461,
-0.0293594301,
-0.0609603263,
0.0018791801,
0.0049055493,
0.0307233594,
0.0339843519,
-0.0689729378,
0.0244075842,
-0.0509691797,
0.0010780365,
-0.0154428845,
0.0034533807,
0.0272461362,
-0.0159791633,
0.0120778177,
0.0623843856,
-0.0089983353,
-0.0279639382,
0.0339001119,
0.0424772091,
0.0225321203,
0.018232923,
0.0471279547,
0.0632032603,
0.0479521453,
0.0000020989,
-0.0377066731,
-0.0228984635,
0.005694163,
0.0035142323,
0.0098293312,
-0.0016594509,
-0.0080901915,
-0.0328538157,
-0.004400102,
-0.0047165835,
-0.0150339678,
0.0367361978,
0.0011961913,
0.0188737977,
0.0815815851,
-0.0206209049,
-0.0210374705,
0.0227856021,
-0.0364887081,
-0.0249182396,
-0.0683690459,
0.0154400971,
-0.0118923336,
-0.0569002926,
-0.0531267785,
-0.0527487248,
-0.0162703954,
-0.0202089101,
0.0219026003,
0.0169071611,
0.0020029522,
-0.0402495153,
-0.0101244841,
-0.0100080119,
0.0752215311,
-0.0878930688,
0.0182820763,
0.0312893204,
-0.0352191925,
-0.0014699247,
-0.0605632439,
-0.0121749016,
-0.016176736,
0.0230876524,
0.0205040034,
-0.048206903,
-0.0218346957,
0.0284815151,
0.0204751063,
-0.0480415151,
-0.0270310361,
0.0239151865,
0.0105256429,
-0.0069708428,
-0.0471912436,
-0.0084220916,
-0.0112277204,
-0.0246269014,
0.0271700136,
-0.0566395372,
-0.0316385627,
-0.081992358,
0.0025045641,
0.0231517386,
-0.011822409,
0.0708938837,
0.0375663675,
-0.0394104719,
0.0629681498,
-0.0863104761,
0.050345961,
-0.0486121923,
0.0060212743,
-0.0035900068,
0.0174610633,
-0.0288822129,
0.0342517495,
0.0078897141,
0.026803283,
-0.0244787317,
-0.0039843419,
-0.0311778206,
0.0356929824,
0.0003821624,
0.0395939872,
-0.0444556884,
-0.0181789473,
-0.0291975904,
-0.0169109739,
0.0145509951,
0.0420272909,
0.0271623414,
0.0384047367,
-0.0011096181,
-0.0239663459,
-0.0094275866,
0.0055630459,
0.0570494197,
-0.003063662,
0.0616306253,
0.0632834807,
-0.009375927,
-0.028147582,
-0.030244641,
0.0255538821,
-0.0039149779,
-0.0504064672,
0.0107654417,
-0.0299447868,
0.0240800399,
-0.0222521834,
0.0583373271,
-0.0350071639,
-0.0138379792,
-0.0077386624,
-0.0510508418,
0.0492895842,
-0.0092193345,
-0.0291277431,
-0.0034261895,
-0.0149290767,
-0.016991321,
0.071406953,
0.0558819994,
0.0322585814,
-0.0025563443,
-0.0252413694,
-0.0329757631,
0.0475580618,
0.0061426479,
0.0465115458,
-0.0190373007,
0.0215474665,
0.028633561,
-0.025275154,
0.0593132563,
0.0019801634,
0.0023159876,
0.002823469,
0.0509757809,
0.0012155421,
0.0535537526,
0.0547849126,
0.0088807661,
-0.0328118689,
0.0000630963,
-0.0325213149,
-0.0118326275,
0.0536180064,
-0.0706170648,
0.0021635103,
-0.0218337309,
0.0522519909,
-0.0347906575,
-0.0376051366,
-0.0203582924,
0.0382838659,
-0.0374429487,
0.0474725328,
0.0484174825,
0.0079337386,
-0.0261774808,
-0.0052937306,
0.061081402,
-0.0229255017,
-0.0248797741,
-0.0821260512,
0.0262225848,
0.0394887626,
-0.0060121436,
-0.0410555974,
-0.0127260089,
-0.0350315385,
0.0175716523,
0.0012922364,
0.0120204184,
0.0165027529,
0.0627465621,
-0.0535106361,
-0.0391770825,
0.0376946218,
0.0067114602,
0.0348941721,
-0.0041059535,
0.0185976345,
0.0140219377,
-0.0025120566,
-0.0279780775,
0.0427103229,
-0.0349361263,
0.0148559865,
0.0379461423,
0.0122813862,
0.0177978985,
-0.0248385556,
-0.0180090982,
-0.0604462661,
0.021647118,
-0.0231381003,
-0.0011014859,
-0.0459244475,
-0.0180179253,
0.0056843967,
0.013780186,
0.02746154,
0.0039743274,
0.0459830165,
-0.0618838072,
-0.0258578788,
0.0160398316,
-0.0226585735,
-0.0110397022,
-0.0316620506,
0.0073844213,
-0.0176407546,
0.0822729021,
-0.0081093432,
0.0300013684,
-0.0079397308,
-0.0289630536,
0.0325963385,
0.0117601566,
0.0006214052,
-0.0270476658,
-0.0504506603,
0.0248671565,
-0.0172572471,
0.034431804,
-0.0210444629,
0.0207567066,
-0.0150331426,
-0.0345862024,
-0.0247396585,
0.0272153486,
-0.0370596163,
0.0137886088,
0.0038427487,
0.0127173495,
0.0017267672,
-0.038782537,
0.0062995115,
0.0674973577,
-0.0541098006,
-0.0036800129,
-0.0001020353,
0.0114333741,
-0.0450466163,
-0.0446057767,
0.0051398692,
0.0164645687,
0.0275631398,
-0.0514413379,
-0.0252311472,
-0.0650726259,
0.0314590931,
-0.0252214987,
0.0384810232,
-0.0421650894,
-0.0173461642,
-0.0485378467,
-0.0292742439,
0.0284124017,
0.0538065434,
0.0023704625,
-0.028575113,
0.0703309178,
0.0368536189,
-0.0158474147,
0.0304685347,
0.0179754142,
-0.040372517,
-0.0507443659,
0.0163141172,
-0.0275783334,
0.0020323864,
-0.0348142348,
-0.0046795476,
-0.0641684234,
-0.0159780476,
0.00876272,
-0.0214779396,
-0.085575372,
0.0408725105,
-0.0187537242,
-0.0104723284,
-0.0179444421,
-0.0101803616,
0.0226180386,
0.016271174,
-0.0268687531,
0.0109638693,
-0.0475769117,
-0.0579742528,
0.036745809,
-0.0103982864,
0.0305507239,
-0.0217462964,
-0.0170264523,
-0.0618651211,
-0.0370335989,
0.0225950964,
-0.0272918381,
0.0318072475,
-0.0149973435,
0.0074193627,
-0.0719400719,
-0.0577072315,
-0.0010291683,
-0.0198858362,
-0.0152585804,
0.0310677234,
-0.0188196283,
-0.0416772328,
-0.0171353705,
-0.0168166701,
0.0101442849,
0.086057514,
-0.0129773514,
-0.010829092,
-0.0553188547,
0.0434133261,
0.0706961975,
0.062893562,
0.012688024,
-0.0261020064,
0.0592636317,
0.038331978,
0.0378115252,
-0.0122387474,
-0.0606606565,
0.058665555,
0.0158979446,
0.04606691,
0.0150430445,
0.0371446386,
0.0039413162,
-0.0526872166,
0.0056736777,
0.0504460484,
-0.0371832326,
-0.067800656,
-0.006883482,
-0.0438317955,
0.1091318205,
0.0640593469,
0.0379822813,
-0.0155544886,
-0.0160348639,
0.0216421895,
0.0374443457,
0.0083445394,
-0.0012918779,
0.0086827548,
-0.0491783433,
0.0387953967,
0.0175534096,
-0.0568273179,
-0.0319966488,
-0.0349253267,
0.0307130087,
0.0022492635,
0.0278835073,
0.0186900347,
-0.0314385481,
-0.0671823621,
0.0186914299,
-0.0404742993,
-0.0481206328,
0.0120774359,
-0.027348198,
0.0289731678,
0.0402649008,
0.0268480107,
-0.0201011188,
-0.0073333466,
0.0230455901,
-0.0045317006,
-0.0039841803,
-0.0089252004,
0.0231504701,
0.0117914286,
-0.0386761874,
0.0365114287,
0.0439803004,
-0.0138009954,
-0.013236694,
0.0254191216,
0.0371524952,
0.0014107638,
0.0023147934,
0.0086851232,
-0.0356358662,
-0.0213657301,
0.0173792299,
0.0153376665,
-0.0388298891,
0.0105488654,
0.0084381029,
-0.0450399369,
-0.0287158173,
-0.0429364368,
0.0201723967,
-0.02241637,
0.0187734198,
-0.0172438417,
0.0344554,
0.0235011876,
0.0247191712,
-0.0153659265,
-0.0173558258,
-0.0230571385,
0.0253277235,
-0.0239140689,
0.0302604139,
-0.0165971331,
-0.0102936821,
-0.0235498808,
-0.0029282123,
0.037822634,
-0.0300985295,
-0.021510303,
0.0276288427,
-0.0896467492,
-0.031668555,
-0.0053665973,
0.0496272556,
-0.0001198624,
0.0414588228,
0.0206964146,
-0.0882993042,
0.0580599271,
0.0334722847,
0.0640419573,
0.0532675236,
0.0292022359,
-0.0518596061,
-0.0441176817,
0.034625113,
-0.0975191295,
-0.0032621231,
0.0481971875,
0.0110957492,
-0.0064893267,
0.030278312,
-0.0063653071,
-0.0082479119,
0.0137307057,
-0.0037536446,
-0.0606535189,
-0.027696332,
0.0714319795,
0.0095613636,
-0.0002387667,
-0.0436107293,
-0.0259232614,
0.0038510158,
-0.0236840323,
-0.0201083608,
0.0234048925,
0.0569322035,
0.0268275384,
-0.0838488936,
0.0069217435,
-0.0011527357,
-0.001150832,
0.054424312,
0.0205314569,
-0.024506649,
0.0278365035,
0.0436254144,
0.0119814929,
-0.0283159483,
-0.0152719226,
0.0116215367,
0.0058743916,
-0.0672287866,
0.0269039571,
-0.0443040021,
-0.0901603326,
-0.0334699005,
-0.0034273437,
0.0721681565,
0.0240731016,
0.0571203232,
0.0237477832,
-0.0264334176,
-0.0077030961,
-0.0135090332,
-0.0061005699,
-0.0007046581,
0.0129058706,
0.0166600607,
0.0294483639,
0.0399200693,
0.0575154051,
0.0483008213,
0.0612623133,
-0.0110253608,
0.0506303906,
-0.0668543875,
-0.0016392154,
0.041902326,
0.0350933708,
-0.0086087873,
-0.0139338197,
0.0389322825,
-0.0465720333,
-0.0194352586,
-0.0531981103,
0.018934587,
-0.0290923212,
0.0084576178,
0.0163560286,
-0.016711561,
-0.0257300064,
-0.013729847,
-0.0487501957,
0.0288983285,
0.0094444565,
0.0175012499,
-6.582597183e-33,
-0.0192406438,
0.0332080759,
-0.0006658603,
-0.0089211604,
0.0003645713,
-0.0033208062,
-0.0056710332,
-0.0072730999,
0.0031721741,
-0.002445647,
-0.0179623123,
0.008790642,
0.0126069067,
0.0277736392,
0.0053269956,
0.0271502323,
0.06279587,
-0.0000185136,
-0.0115854098,
0.0302244574,
0.0120285302,
0.029848082,
0.0355144553,
-0.0496510752,
-0.0583612844,
0.0360751562,
-0.0623611659,
-0.0260877479,
-0.0141648492,
0.0462353565,
-0.017885033,
0.0498845354,
0.0010528885,
0.0329553448,
-0.0320508406,
0.0241639931,
-0.1033888906,
0.0073962091,
-0.0265641436,
0.0119791767,
0.002403436,
-0.0365404785,
0.0574642755,
0.0247351695,
0.0076354342,
-0.0664145648,
0.0361772776,
-0.051090762,
-0.0304472651,
-0.0309309158,
-0.0499836877,
0.0277434159,
-0.0138758132,
-0.0049893847,
0.005299401,
0.0450325683,
-0.0082860449,
0.0401223563,
-0.0630055517,
-0.0230314508,
-0.0120375948,
0.0548775196,
0.0109685743,
0.0653745905,
-0.0366728157,
0.0425371714,
0.0221567396,
0.0327447839,
0.0633468106,
-0.03785659,
0.0621349625,
0.0434046909,
0.0487310551,
0.0249848496,
-0.0029055139,
0.0023629575,
-0.1035415679,
-0.0212304182,
-0.0165263973,
0.0301010795,
0.0551930107,
0.0213523638,
-0.0206315257,
0.0276697241,
-0.0223756824,
-0.0066367784,
-0.065697521,
0.0256044865,
0.0139018828,
0.0591253005,
-0.0133433873,
-0.0090122884,
0.0327885263,
-0.037374977,
0.0220276117,
-0.0205895081,
-0.0076468973,
0.0070245182,
0.0290277842,
0.0350956134,
0.0028646227,
-0.0806109533,
0.0520439744,
-0.0149176503,
0.0298346151,
-0.028650213,
0.0420961082,
0.0639808625,
-0.0813685432,
-0.0094747115,
0.0001826095,
0.0276956372,
0.0079417443,
0.0628918484,
-0.006262836,
-0.0198949743,
0.007275979,
0.0787413418,
0.0069678249,
0.0103577273,
0.0024802631,
-0.0108349649,
0.0167578515,
0.0485821441,
-0.0179642104,
-0.0075305058,
-0.0223599728,
-0.0053498959,
0.0275954194,
-0.0601203591,
-0.0003466771,
0.0228768624,
2.827e-7,
-0.0387536809,
0.0480126329,
-0.0511227883,
-0.034152206,
0.0212333687,
0.0124787847,
-0.0230842847,
0.0547019616,
0.0236421674,
0.0000774619,
0.0153781297,
0.0104608862,
0.0414734222,
-0.0141958417,
-0.0439794883,
-0.0174513124,
-0.0729358643,
0.0173717886,
-0.0510056689,
-0.0405732468,
0.0156252049,
0.1165654808,
-0.0040640966,
-0.0350120477,
0.062889792,
-0.0088851927,
0.0515849516,
-0.0141295707,
0.0105902152,
-0.0219245516,
0.0166657921,
0.0449747816,
-0.03052889,
0.0121170534,
-0.0048682876,
0.0850285366,
-0.0434232503,
0.0465675816,
-0.0362985656,
-0.0081407707,
0.022308642,
0.0658033192,
0.0155050838,
-0.070888482,
0.0873636678,
-0.040624354,
-0.0103220455,
-0.0443737097,
-0.0163729433,
-0.0045385067,
0.0071825217,
-0.0379534326,
-0.0147408899,
-0.0117659839,
0.0245767366,
-0.0099306488,
-0.0346065983,
-0.1074381992,
0.036263667,
-0.0077265091,
-0.0688176081,
-0.0456372686,
-0.0364234149,
-0.031284783,
0.0297363438,
-0.0138697503,
0.0101688253,
2.517636607e-34,
0.0236552656,
-0.0120976595,
0.0026608398,
0.0165041871,
0.0097291218,
0.0028249884,
-0.0319614075,
-0.0115231723,
0.0398182459,
-0.0998004153,
-0.0128249796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01490v1 | LLM See, LLM Do: Guiding Data Generation to Target Non-Differentiable Objectives | 2024-07-01T17:26:21 | 2024-07-01T17:26:21 | Luísa Shimabucoro, Sebastian Ruder, Julia Kreutzer, Marzieh Fadaee, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The widespread adoption of synthetic data raises new questions about how
models generating the data can influence other large language models (LLMs) via
distilled data. To start, our work exhaustively characterizes the impact of
passive inheritance of model properties by systematically studying the
consequences of synthetic data integration. We provide one of the most
comprehensive studies to-date of how the source of synthetic data shapes
models' internal biases, calibration and generations' textual attributes and
preferences. We find that models are surprisingly sensitive towards certain
attributes even when the synthetic data prompts appear "neutral". which invites
the question whether this sensitivity can be exploited for good.
Our findings invite the question can we explicitly steer the models towards
the properties we want at test time by exploiting the data generation process?
This would have historically been considered infeasible due to the cost of
collecting data with a specific characteristic or objective in mind. However,
improvement in the quality of synthetic data, as well as a shift towards
general-purpose models designed to follow a diverse way of instructions, means
this question is timely. We propose active inheritance as a term to describe
intentionally constraining synthetic data according to a non-differentiable
objective. We demonstrate how active inheritance can steer the generation
profiles of models towards desirable non-differentiable attributes, e.g. high
lexical diversity or low toxicity. | [
0.0316288583,
0.0873512924,
-0.0518580787,
0.0353816338,
-0.0307854749,
0.0065018623,
0.0020512631,
0.0084651811,
-0.0081162667,
-0.0528455116,
-0.0178968925,
-0.0506952219,
0.0173619669,
0.0311570931,
0.0432358272,
-0.0060589351,
0.0760068595,
-0.0230996311,
-0.0264856722,
-0.0228859782,
-0.0268853791,
-0.0040039504,
0.0673770681,
0.0063824202,
-0.0040676696,
0.018465342,
0.0157348551,
-0.0042344555,
-0.0204565357,
0.0291087572,
0.0183580015,
0.0422678925,
0.0023717354,
0.0541084521,
0.0000018377,
-0.0599498078,
0.0101514431,
0.0073043569,
-0.0255777892,
0.0069560432,
0.068726562,
0.0305283517,
0.0058110002,
-0.009773897,
-0.036619518,
-0.0064046606,
0.0642708987,
-0.0464013219,
-0.0148985349,
0.0687930509,
0.0058106743,
-0.0229725856,
0.0280067828,
-0.0226776469,
0.0605587661,
0.0233594272,
0.0298007671,
-0.0233204104,
0.002493806,
0.0227103736,
-0.0409087874,
0.03057638,
0.0135269044,
0.0112853833,
0.0242364872,
0.0111374762,
-0.0165309049,
-0.0655447692,
0.0213103909,
0.0377127491,
-0.0005993783,
-0.0584213138,
0.0009331429,
-0.022285765,
0.0324602835,
0.0166261662,
-0.0032998493,
0.027905019,
-0.0084594004,
0.0217708983,
0.0575362109,
-0.0267715808,
0.0345897079,
0.0114661781,
-0.0036846749,
0.0487637185,
0.0332452431,
-0.0368981697,
-0.0228798315,
0.0199126136,
-0.0073005506,
-0.0477019548,
-0.0424042456,
-0.0262806304,
-0.0045732735,
0.0245861933,
-0.0456678867,
-0.0089047635,
0.0429511033,
-0.055308003,
0.0659114644,
0.0257057436,
-0.0314092264,
0.0110898707,
-0.0175597779,
0.0042379107,
-0.0309591684,
0.0126462402,
-0.0300523844,
0.0082549239,
-0.0223389417,
-0.0369666629,
0.0293614957,
0.0099530136,
-0.0208365526,
0.026400758,
-0.0024407988,
0.0295880735,
-0.0025520513,
-0.0135630043,
0.0196658093,
0.0134979133,
-0.0690813735,
0.0233145095,
-0.0343239382,
-0.0311402772,
-0.0284563825,
0.0375520624,
-0.0199619066,
-0.0666223317,
0.0094975084,
-0.0060129878,
-0.0152439168,
-0.0241907109,
0.0229613725,
0.1058132574,
0.0302173812,
-0.0056370762,
-0.0382474065,
-0.028360147,
-0.0286756009,
-0.0458346605,
0.0259216614,
-0.0524186082,
0.0037014296,
0.0268196054,
-0.0242106374,
-0.1000096202,
-0.0128690628,
-0.0252373684,
-0.0842060819,
0.0225087237,
-0.0333027318,
0.0170622002,
-0.0242095776,
-0.016246872,
0.0081793852,
0.1117886379,
0.0226735454,
-0.0228455085,
0.039441783,
-0.0070158551,
0.005801823,
0.0451757498,
0.0242531411,
0.042468071,
-0.0415035523,
-0.0048393179,
0.005284308,
-0.004684655,
0.0345346741,
0.0524245836,
-0.010287202,
-0.0279054604,
0.1033103541,
-0.0255453084,
0.0157543272,
0.0291848928,
0.0516834185,
-0.0247205887,
-0.0188882053,
0.044755891,
-0.0548608564,
-0.0125996144,
-0.0286577791,
0.007072466,
-0.021265151,
0.0562322959,
-0.0021576236,
-0.060874138,
-0.0240590163,
0.0188866779,
-0.0123807006,
-0.0021270216,
0.0181127079,
0.0270979926,
0.0010592466,
0.0414367542,
0.0511525683,
-0.0604713075,
0.0142966285,
-0.0188571196,
0.0519935898,
0.0326096416,
0.0218487475,
-0.0148248868,
-0.0169526692,
0.02031927,
-0.0192245878,
0.0653936863,
0.070796445,
-0.0271283612,
0.0130862668,
-0.0201621559,
0.0009716742,
-0.0347335264,
0.0391353741,
0.0291612111,
-0.0152418502,
-0.0246538594,
-0.0014279131,
-0.0438167974,
-0.054338038,
0.0583312027,
-0.055758521,
-0.0355245881,
-0.026124768,
-0.0253826659,
0.0112231132,
0.0064982153,
-0.046109315,
0.0204559099,
0.0122235361,
0.0045226738,
0.0017480983,
0.0285698734,
-0.0078660892,
0.0071448339,
0.0318932682,
-0.0122762416,
0.0055631297,
0.005645012,
-0.0033215061,
0.0060537588,
0.0189204775,
-0.0457224138,
0.062147174,
-0.0189999286,
0.0494971499,
-0.0502369925,
0.0149514731,
-0.0338306054,
0.0669617876,
-0.0091140382,
0.0063826791,
0.0052398974,
-0.0130023975,
0.0134569714,
-0.0121818632,
-0.014318604,
0.0173577275,
0.0150743006,
0.0213234145,
0.0338932239,
-0.0107411826,
-0.0478692688,
-0.0249083061,
-0.0263161268,
0.0213494524,
-0.0172448196,
0.0263039842,
0.0499396399,
0.0060634529,
-0.0280171409,
0.0507132262,
-0.030931538,
-0.0322854444,
0.0049852855,
0.0601692088,
0.0245677028,
-0.016343791,
-0.0225739852,
-0.0463250428,
-0.0088604279,
-0.0316626579,
0.0659487769,
-0.0166697316,
0.0297568608,
-0.0451939888,
0.0234729461,
-0.0574080497,
0.0260646958,
-0.0095886709,
-0.0159461405,
0.0201824605,
0.0026241606,
0.0186620895,
0.0459487513,
-0.0020739902,
-0.0071625216,
0.0633944571,
-0.0203746594,
-0.0521061532,
-0.0283513702,
-0.0430632718,
-0.0053096823,
-0.0295873173,
-0.0542902686,
-0.0264349487,
0.0820157081,
-0.005846092,
-0.0364675224,
-0.0395797007,
0.086086385,
-0.0366785079,
-0.0592111126,
0.0316756181,
-0.0313613564,
-0.0409355015,
0.0439613052,
-0.0304429531,
-0.0802874416,
0.0411981791,
-0.0113145551,
-0.004945423,
-0.0360966548,
-0.0025719288,
-0.0357380398,
0.0280947853,
0.0092777433,
-0.0117822057,
0.0487112179,
0.0348837823,
-0.0761321709,
-0.0039713923,
0.0686576888,
-0.0232373532,
0.0369124971,
-0.0442138016,
0.0099314768,
0.0164215863,
-0.0191581845,
-0.0420282632,
-0.0280229598,
0.018296387,
0.0002269846,
0.0467094555,
-0.0218389221,
0.0122568216,
-0.0256422386,
-0.0126350541,
0.0206865426,
-0.0143487314,
0.0101035265,
-0.0100551881,
-0.0167848058,
0.0523076355,
-0.0424230024,
0.0294359215,
-0.0401399694,
0.0096918046,
0.0135102272,
-0.0357018746,
-0.0072100074,
-0.0004822162,
0.0487025902,
0.0508218072,
0.0039946684,
-0.0544295534,
0.0181508325,
0.0395749323,
-0.0518015549,
-0.0205055047,
0.0589552522,
0.020194415,
-0.0053356006,
0.0459610187,
-0.0361496322,
0.0613243207,
0.034000475,
0.0196493194,
-0.062307667,
0.0144187137,
0.0181378257,
0.0062784995,
-0.0705072209,
-0.037982706,
-0.0220927466,
-0.1460744441,
0.028983023,
0.0244104844,
-0.0522369631,
0.0016760976,
-0.0070385193,
-0.0016517172,
-0.0239399523,
0.0386428051,
0.0288826879,
-0.0263782926,
0.0054770657,
0.0232861843,
-0.0186872538,
-0.0381573364,
-0.0218188949,
-0.0314053409,
0.0537925065,
0.0298880488,
0.021824643,
-0.0230939146,
-0.0203481689,
0.0579382107,
-0.0222227108,
-0.0170285311,
-0.0121641262,
0.0593549982,
0.0246444345,
-0.0047317455,
-0.0242784247,
0.0150784999,
0.0194080621,
-0.0084801642,
-0.0361591317,
0.0443206765,
0.0001781319,
-0.0687952563,
-0.0471627861,
-0.0158654079,
0.0032541309,
0.0704809427,
0.0226027519,
-0.0519069731,
-0.0123944497,
-0.0473612882,
-0.0445742197,
-0.0189680792,
-0.0786798,
0.0335045196,
-0.0375526808,
-0.067526266,
-0.0815600529,
-0.0560123436,
0.0034622005,
0.0123140216,
0.0410763361,
-0.0047920155,
-0.0685004219,
-0.0477872118,
-0.0189194307,
0.0402776524,
-0.006815034,
-0.0135829672,
-0.0027501606,
-0.0464357212,
0.0292402674,
-0.0341311432,
0.0084120464,
0.0067826039,
-0.047905501,
-0.1272249222,
0.0414777547,
0.040276546,
0.0404049121,
0.053232424,
0.0326161794,
-0.0660519525,
0.0599999093,
0.0587548763,
0.0029162942,
0.043168664,
0.0468497537,
-0.0452077277,
0.0258719977,
0.0301951915,
-0.0525720939,
-0.0040886928,
0.0608065985,
0.0060565681,
-0.0067221066,
-0.007480666,
0.0489938073,
0.0058109201,
0.0183926132,
-0.0605898984,
-0.022272408,
-0.0276250988,
-0.002636303,
-0.0372560993,
-0.0388975888,
-0.0163736138,
-0.0040180711,
0.0080767544,
0.076887913,
-0.0205476098,
0.0226694066,
-0.0234741569,
0.0812498629,
-0.0441222079,
0.0044708871,
0.0242984872,
0.0064452421,
0.0427070111,
0.0221214294,
-0.0086648697,
0.0486740917,
-0.0480295606,
0.0631105453,
0.0296277832,
0.0135228112,
0.007730715,
0.0250846762,
-0.0308124684,
0.002896664,
-0.0701963156,
-0.0273383427,
-0.0478643291,
0.0148250787,
0.0265651215,
-0.0535709187,
0.0610380545,
-0.0322247408,
-0.005558291,
-0.028209975,
0.0014163243,
0.0093007041,
-0.0328319706,
-0.0081818281,
0.0011281932,
-0.0479162335,
-0.0276188273,
0.0848557204,
0.0472850688,
0.0795523673,
-0.0595399179,
0.0224831719,
-0.0053796922,
-0.0272357613,
0.0555368662,
-0.041122105,
-0.0094558131,
-0.0332505591,
-0.1044611409,
-0.0873400494,
-0.0012758585,
0.0240093675,
0.0222937092,
-0.0120775159,
0.0001166064,
0.0436913818,
-0.0199853163,
-0.0116169546,
-0.0508945845,
-0.0005469263,
-0.0006290021,
0.0225926619,
0.0021542597,
-6.16418952e-33,
-0.0021965045,
0.0056287311,
-0.0170415882,
0.0000741499,
-0.0085506709,
-0.0006234567,
-0.0088927541,
0.0299764238,
-0.0389568843,
-0.0092930812,
0.0040270709,
-0.0162156802,
0.0098349424,
-0.0225790236,
0.0300219432,
-0.031770695,
0.0236609224,
-0.0158086419,
-0.0337139368,
-0.0226245001,
0.0315385833,
-0.0025388387,
0.0479581282,
-0.0325478204,
0.0729278997,
-0.0112097384,
-0.004562973,
-0.0024601112,
-0.050431408,
0.0366963856,
-0.0054560984,
0.0456126146,
0.020392973,
-0.0238099564,
-0.029721776,
0.0039940649,
-0.0008598408,
-0.0324757732,
0.0738477111,
-0.0154256895,
-0.0040511,
-0.0439287461,
0.0609457381,
0.0180623904,
-0.0341883935,
-0.0165684577,
0.0176455043,
-0.037559472,
-0.0165668018,
-0.029618144,
-0.0779143497,
0.0215609781,
0.0051388764,
0.0207036361,
0.0255487673,
0.0056245616,
0.0426925197,
0.0177804679,
0.0007393454,
0.0507011674,
0.0093937032,
0.0455426127,
0.0742997304,
0.044563368,
0.0196170155,
0.063765116,
0.0555231869,
0.0607145764,
-0.0030208381,
-0.0047447993,
0.0388291962,
0.0499562137,
0.0330018587,
0.076520361,
0.0233170576,
-0.0194111131,
-0.0240116138,
-0.0062722052,
0.0288236532,
-0.0334323756,
-0.0096178502,
0.0241034944,
-0.0399099663,
-0.0360295363,
-0.0389773287,
-0.0331481285,
-0.0241196044,
-0.0065939385,
0.0118422117,
-0.0293204766,
-0.0294490568,
-0.0085903229,
0.0293843206,
-0.04407195,
-0.0216164812,
0.0026733745,
-0.0347978249,
-0.0020136777,
0.0072335992,
-0.0117055904,
-0.0140525652,
-0.0440344326,
0.0135664577,
0.0050968719,
0.0238135196,
0.0378685556,
0.0240899324,
0.0267911889,
-0.0439860784,
0.0027826081,
-0.0425357185,
0.0112146027,
0.0459587015,
0.0051187971,
0.045263838,
0.0055946284,
-0.0028577163,
0.001055348,
0.0798221752,
0.0314054266,
-0.0739741996,
0.0522012226,
-0.0203723107,
0.0145768374,
-0.0287228338,
-0.0374860018,
-0.0215558968,
0.0360638201,
0.0656487048,
-0.0510395095,
-0.0225442387,
-0.0175056588,
2.631e-7,
0.0619099513,
0.0489310175,
0.0008833199,
0.0176948644,
0.0164500196,
0.0342723168,
-0.004688066,
0.0354044512,
0.0290302336,
-0.0386191159,
0.0011592897,
-0.0207835473,
0.0489548035,
0.0490781292,
-0.0634700209,
0.0086698644,
-0.0539154261,
0.0102724601,
-0.0492534786,
0.0008834252,
0.0020603815,
0.081670098,
0.0109371012,
-0.0187011827,
-0.0277037863,
-0.0196956079,
0.0204049349,
-0.0535763502,
-0.0116393957,
0.0527914204,
0.017040249,
-0.0255536232,
0.0108843623,
0.021772543,
-0.0190645028,
0.0320158713,
-0.0179357119,
0.0349029563,
0.0046196622,
-0.0024678733,
-0.0051798974,
-0.0556920655,
-0.0189982299,
-0.0599130206,
0.0614485703,
0.0238536205,
-0.0269518737,
-0.0334676951,
-0.0178335812,
0.023655273,
0.0110536907,
-0.0195474867,
0.0197378974,
0.0265323669,
0.0105409501,
0.0108528715,
-0.0282566901,
-0.0304232445,
-0.07333,
0.0163496174,
-0.0512584709,
-0.1117498353,
0.0130937397,
0.0609133691,
0.022131674,
-0.0399325825,
0.0182992164,
2.653366256e-34,
0.0386793464,
-0.0020333522,
0.0466682203,
-0.003670156,
0.0152005721,
-0.0216610096,
0.0423195437,
0.0356089137,
0.0238953326,
-0.0420034416,
-0.0202659443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01489v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01489v1 | Agentless: Demystifying LLM-based Software Engineering Agents | 2024-07-01T17:24:45 | 2024-07-01T17:24:45 | Chunqiu Steven Xia, Yinlin Deng, Soren Dunn, Lingming Zhang | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have significantly
advanced the automation of software development tasks, including code
synthesis, program repair, and test generation. More recently, researchers and
industry practitioners have developed various autonomous LLM agents to perform
end-to-end software development tasks. These agents are equipped with the
ability to use tools, run commands, observe feedback from the environment, and
plan for future actions. However, the complexity of these agent-based
approaches, together with the limited abilities of current LLMs, raises the
following question: Do we really have to employ complex autonomous software
agents? To attempt to answer this question, we build Agentless -- an agentless
approach to automatically solve software development problems. Compared to the
verbose and complex setup of agent-based approaches, Agentless employs a
simplistic two-phase process of localization followed by repair, without
letting the LLM decide future actions or operate with complex tools. Our
results on the popular SWE-bench Lite benchmark show that surprisingly the
simplistic Agentless is able to achieve both the highest performance (27.33%)
and lowest cost (\$0.34) compared with all existing open-source software
agents! Furthermore, we manually classified the problems in SWE-bench Lite and
found problems with exact ground truth patch or insufficient/misleading issue
descriptions. As such, we construct SWE-bench Lite-S by excluding such
problematic issues to perform more rigorous evaluation and comparison. Our work
highlights the current overlooked potential of a simple, interpretable
technique in autonomous software development. We hope Agentless will help reset
the baseline, starting point, and horizon for autonomous software agents, and
inspire future work along this crucial direction. | [
-0.003866489,
0.0306631643,
-0.0472355336,
0.0073810774,
-0.0361198112,
-0.0041357591,
-0.0124027338,
0.0162990503,
0.0109458072,
-0.0443345383,
0.0357044339,
0.0498240367,
-0.0270922203,
0.0288854484,
0.0163028724,
-0.0255866982,
0.0485940315,
-0.0368959047,
-0.0267808381,
0.0257375631,
-0.0285393409,
-0.0158956554,
-0.0110148769,
0.0551295429,
-0.0000892744,
-0.0263434891,
-0.0153758349,
0.0408626609,
-0.0165083334,
0.036210347,
-0.0151908388,
0.0217957348,
0.0051967888,
-0.0111849792,
0.0000026746,
-0.0727601275,
0.0182682145,
0.0238639787,
0.0045973901,
0.019263234,
-0.0136868618,
0.0024627133,
-0.0441328324,
0.0194248762,
-0.0220989771,
-0.0052600992,
0.0219386593,
-0.0044790288,
0.0707644448,
0.0509417281,
0.0317161717,
0.0497362539,
0.0151471104,
0.0569950044,
0.0457063541,
-0.0341692567,
-0.0047972831,
0.0017637063,
0.0368122235,
-0.0033249371,
0.0032906062,
0.0182705056,
0.0104851015,
-0.0113061722,
0.0031010802,
0.010700902,
-0.0499060638,
-0.0600793324,
-0.0026390876,
0.0010158663,
-0.0101521146,
-0.0154031692,
0.0270727295,
0.0003694878,
-0.0240102895,
0.0044445847,
-0.0010694767,
0.0623393655,
0.0230948087,
-0.0302980058,
0.0277177747,
-0.0301466845,
-0.018575415,
-0.036959663,
-0.0535994284,
0.0942584276,
-0.0059052748,
0.0161230862,
-0.0514434166,
-0.0188296009,
0.0158522502,
-0.0500109531,
-0.0094262976,
0.0751511529,
-0.0585445613,
0.0194277838,
-0.023822479,
0.0061651175,
0.0247660689,
-0.0414086878,
-0.0353727639,
0.0437502004,
-0.0382710174,
0.0031434684,
-0.0246839989,
0.048031792,
0.0223041736,
0.0068568317,
-0.0172714591,
0.034660887,
-0.0161489416,
0.0177984014,
-0.0238391589,
0.0123578301,
-0.0087016961,
0.0412853174,
0.0058555552,
0.053297922,
-0.0383703597,
0.0949200168,
-0.0449604727,
-0.0230599921,
-0.0424475595,
0.001660892,
-0.0117750484,
-0.0255456399,
-0.0376658216,
-0.0443735495,
-0.0142390523,
-0.051550474,
0.0073620179,
0.0189480577,
-0.0362923518,
0.0059333215,
-0.0077694235,
0.1158177182,
0.0215802696,
0.051376719,
-0.0384637639,
-0.0582716949,
0.0586521402,
-0.0406020544,
-0.0837044194,
-0.0846256539,
-0.0209350642,
0.0351569653,
-0.0140065989,
-0.0640594661,
0.0136301499,
-0.0176685397,
0.0165226497,
0.0299108848,
-0.0311259013,
0.0922393203,
0.0208911952,
0.0434907191,
-0.0021359201,
0.026497148,
0.0268549863,
0.0014290394,
0.0365179591,
-0.0068319677,
0.0752387494,
0.033703424,
-0.0506026857,
0.0377371199,
0.0389307439,
-0.0011663361,
0.0249144305,
-0.0015369069,
-0.0554282293,
0.0018279545,
0.0332596861,
0.0125771286,
0.003349887,
0.0433973819,
0.0003939472,
0.0401721559,
0.0350254402,
0.0652645901,
-0.0026263464,
-0.0230685137,
-0.0389855839,
0.0665034577,
-0.0129204169,
0.0313334316,
-0.0402248576,
0.0272997357,
-0.005351908,
-0.0733768269,
-0.033891879,
-0.0047181752,
-0.0139491716,
-0.0010961777,
0.0475595444,
-0.0133676017,
-0.0311330836,
0.0491834693,
0.031813398,
-0.0300125815,
-0.0324405506,
-0.0765675306,
0.0419957489,
0.0587460324,
0.0652619153,
-0.0660575256,
-0.0865705013,
0.0065962207,
0.0080193086,
-0.0094521604,
0.0161720105,
-0.0180145837,
-0.0445926934,
-0.0148360301,
-0.0269736461,
-0.0118920319,
0.0108617414,
0.0521003231,
-0.0005666624,
-0.0277854092,
-0.0069455551,
-0.0185138751,
-0.0544130392,
0.0216213688,
-0.0279130619,
-0.0404094458,
0.0123496996,
0.0085955122,
0.0004913293,
-0.0252829362,
-0.0524611957,
-0.0075293924,
0.0681291148,
0.0007163507,
-0.0385764204,
0.0134566715,
0.021287106,
0.0041923202,
0.0077288304,
-0.0230116397,
-0.0116517879,
0.0246731378,
-0.0420422107,
-0.0326311551,
0.0787797198,
-0.0034363901,
-0.016156815,
0.0424961187,
0.0592858754,
-0.0328722186,
-0.0400321111,
-0.0158691742,
0.0194678549,
0.0339406915,
-0.0486311764,
-0.0030242193,
0.0981497467,
0.0365390368,
0.0097427601,
-0.0306674037,
0.0095858276,
-0.0180345848,
0.0492213778,
0.0185575951,
0.0542609841,
-0.003077769,
-0.0456355922,
-0.0428017005,
0.0289499238,
-0.0106344419,
-0.0051421276,
0.0280012302,
0.0411530621,
0.004601662,
0.008486433,
-0.0099300416,
0.0235104896,
0.0081861755,
-0.0017874904,
0.0307731405,
-0.0407741666,
-0.0779121816,
-0.0142905284,
0.0175728556,
-0.0583862141,
-0.0125501696,
-0.0155787366,
-0.0270501338,
-0.1212661341,
0.0861936063,
0.0011316024,
0.0244499668,
-0.0102888485,
-0.0591336228,
-0.0018557687,
-0.0434527658,
-0.0059038713,
0.0539947525,
-0.0331099518,
0.0369999371,
0.0534700938,
0.0024801015,
-0.0731728598,
0.0073069436,
0.0371212475,
-0.0209850967,
0.0157848001,
-0.0426394753,
-0.0063778637,
0.0647611618,
-0.0197565947,
-0.0220332276,
-0.0353114903,
0.0160619393,
0.0168852918,
0.0195920225,
0.0381919891,
-0.0064754589,
-0.0038174556,
0.03717364,
-0.0231506508,
-0.0693245754,
0.0502897874,
-0.0116334222,
0.0051192045,
-0.0255850181,
-0.0456904657,
-0.0772013515,
0.0594844744,
0.0052746702,
0.0089947274,
-0.0376950987,
-0.0172361154,
-0.014560001,
-0.012409674,
-0.0218515061,
0.0070901481,
0.0515783839,
-0.0662797466,
0.0101929102,
-0.0017780148,
-0.0037103617,
-0.0093233213,
0.020743452,
-0.032082919,
-0.0264543314,
-0.0210243408,
0.0144828688,
-0.0158157982,
0.0181271676,
0.0273125619,
0.0436215289,
0.0272712316,
-0.0216231048,
-0.0275169276,
-0.0791048259,
-0.0433971547,
-0.0111161349,
-0.0224756785,
-0.0161882229,
0.0437329188,
0.0320943817,
0.0767928064,
0.0112366406,
-0.0448636487,
-0.0348993763,
0.0154201416,
-0.0319386013,
-0.0064890361,
0.0276448242,
0.0214082114,
-0.0565886684,
-0.0408312529,
0.0533832796,
0.0278888308,
-0.0226979442,
0.0346488059,
-0.011983512,
0.0000288186,
0.0663970485,
0.0476426929,
-0.0696255714,
-0.0196962953,
0.0065612393,
0.0090488512,
-0.0301779527,
0.0197096523,
0.0071739187,
-0.0379351638,
0.0653730482,
0.0060494314,
-0.0013067629,
0.0177651327,
-0.0175829139,
0.0209340919,
-0.0024118547,
-0.0239200387,
0.0584967956,
0.0362002552,
0.0054614916,
-0.0301504601,
-0.0439517796,
0.0049834065,
0.0391222425,
-0.028598614,
0.0508921333,
0.073396869,
0.0037383942,
0.005739958,
0.0001700237,
0.052522283,
-0.0021858939,
0.028988013,
-0.0441830978,
0.0094596362,
0.0324519835,
-0.0255233441,
0.0623466708,
-0.0093701361,
-0.0960291028,
0.0005866942,
0.0529523827,
0.0269441605,
-0.022594424,
0.004026596,
-0.0306867976,
-0.0041190949,
-0.0111906314,
0.0090952609,
0.0076550976,
-0.0166102368,
-0.0569741242,
-0.0489927344,
-0.0560509451,
-0.0042854198,
-0.0401340127,
-0.011550474,
-0.0328966975,
-0.006878891,
-0.013274868,
-0.036637146,
0.0273999367,
0.0368482061,
0.0589598492,
-0.0584053881,
0.0296722893,
0.0222854521,
-0.025153337,
0.0137723535,
-0.0038251788,
0.0206118058,
0.0105777476,
0.0000324088,
0.0136530465,
-0.0524577722,
0.0042902534,
-0.0388080701,
-0.0117380694,
-0.0411711186,
0.0216833111,
0.080848366,
0.028200604,
0.0084664375,
-0.0645664185,
-0.045130644,
-0.0081860274,
0.0170451552,
-0.0411745571,
0.0603666566,
-0.0198923014,
0.0153104439,
0.0050158189,
-0.0035394817,
-0.0782957599,
0.0144072883,
-0.0154014826,
0.0157621652,
-0.0244973209,
-0.0030664776,
0.0226265173,
0.0417784899,
-0.0492197983,
0.0917973071,
0.0066856113,
-0.0035078165,
0.0058503328,
-0.0132760769,
-0.0324558727,
-0.0642283261,
0.0542744696,
-0.0535765141,
-0.0300151426,
0.0574962609,
0.0110055208,
-0.0724266395,
0.0162348207,
0.0566461571,
0.0290128887,
-0.0222725067,
0.0063013663,
0.042944435,
0.0264212824,
0.0086038997,
0.041711811,
0.0205542799,
0.0530909337,
-0.0025728175,
0.0274611898,
-0.0047059171,
0.0496277511,
-0.0353249535,
-0.0152279502,
-0.0386785641,
-0.0960513204,
0.0326707065,
0.0370136425,
0.0113558704,
0.063702248,
0.0408080965,
-0.0227481127,
0.003758251,
-0.0103297047,
-0.009020308,
-0.014356358,
-0.0104539888,
-0.0297698397,
0.0336089395,
0.0178260747,
-0.0439869761,
0.0641590878,
-0.0179866441,
0.033903759,
-0.0491906255,
-0.0393041261,
-0.0371718816,
0.0158739835,
0.0349077731,
-0.0836889818,
-0.0054101986,
-0.0696211234,
-0.0704470575,
-0.0207965989,
0.000369556,
0.045822002,
0.01288574,
-0.0670650825,
-0.0115062371,
0.0592423156,
0.0502999574,
0.0012522175,
-0.0041886857,
-0.0228288844,
-0.0222551506,
0.0047143432,
0.0085727666,
-6.568300233e-33,
-0.0183678009,
-0.0344395079,
0.0536017977,
0.0013141986,
0.0240469165,
-0.0194061063,
-0.0710902736,
0.0211814605,
0.0282038432,
-0.004929889,
0.0227434691,
0.0067353342,
-0.0141256601,
-0.0578011237,
0.0763749331,
0.0459097177,
0.0267627724,
0.0376269147,
-0.0660460964,
0.0032847743,
0.0035756154,
0.0098757604,
-0.0361311547,
-0.0467981473,
0.0001704908,
-0.0004796821,
0.0268794056,
0.0222082492,
-0.0137270493,
0.0195855722,
0.0258528758,
0.0274914093,
-0.019400334,
0.0068849507,
-0.012989494,
-0.0712262318,
-0.0120321987,
-0.05207837,
-0.0312896371,
0.012158799,
0.0030685992,
-0.0389265604,
0.057930436,
0.0223075617,
-0.0605517961,
0.0359381028,
0.0281738974,
-0.0009894365,
0.0243282691,
0.0025409719,
-0.0769476965,
0.0302726198,
-0.0368619412,
-0.0351358317,
-0.0431985743,
-0.00910783,
0.0068783076,
0.0085252663,
0.0200242829,
-0.0103643732,
0.0532589033,
-0.0087722372,
0.0480109826,
-0.0261825323,
-0.0179438274,
0.0134698236,
0.0446478277,
0.0894090235,
-0.0313583054,
-0.0064802244,
0.0272626318,
0.0288895648,
0.0162645616,
0.0328093953,
-0.0481209084,
0.0006790737,
-0.0157125015,
0.0570255592,
0.0330418162,
0.0036470711,
0.0147910863,
0.0330867395,
-0.0562948734,
-0.0058768135,
-0.0460549667,
-0.0249197092,
-0.0255842786,
-0.0440640524,
0.0244177878,
0.0050330688,
-0.0411810279,
-0.0448689386,
-0.0274456982,
-0.0306361876,
0.0385677665,
-0.0575465746,
-0.0570669249,
0.016977841,
-0.0356380492,
0.0045384974,
0.0232506078,
-0.010580251,
-0.044251211,
0.0294491574,
0.0532541201,
0.0170693956,
-0.0403870605,
0.0357594341,
-0.0211921874,
0.0309403613,
-0.0630129129,
-0.0306224469,
0.0006969744,
-0.0152209634,
-0.0240154713,
-0.0104947519,
0.0253754612,
0.0660796165,
0.0106952963,
-0.0538735911,
-0.0096828919,
0.0541761033,
0.0098518329,
0.0017725681,
-0.0468575358,
-0.0301317163,
-0.0619789399,
0.0691193864,
0.0309642907,
-0.0453686267,
-0.0368826427,
0.021977596,
3.444e-7,
-0.0360324383,
0.0319048092,
-0.0039033769,
0.0224176887,
0.0165562648,
0.0751923546,
-0.0055242418,
-0.0136266435,
0.0425172336,
0.0244143121,
-0.0425933376,
0.0155802863,
0.0198847391,
0.0170148779,
0.0008223944,
0.0642241985,
0.0377810448,
0.0163683258,
-0.0644766837,
0.0026294179,
0.0134154679,
-0.0052552843,
0.0137318848,
-0.002625657,
0.0118401265,
-0.038006857,
-0.043895822,
-0.0144089917,
-0.0107870381,
0.0734082982,
-0.0835966915,
0.0360652581,
0.0318173431,
-0.0133488402,
0.0068812589,
-0.003468249,
-0.0446541905,
0.0765943006,
-0.0020673489,
0.013294247,
0.0392762609,
-0.0206960626,
0.0112192649,
-0.006840948,
0.0313599147,
-0.0319128521,
-0.0179786198,
-0.0003883735,
-0.0126760742,
-0.0005158664,
-0.0543222427,
-0.0386398323,
0.0211017989,
0.0180383697,
-0.0339097828,
-0.0258552972,
-0.0178462584,
-0.0313023888,
-0.0165734049,
-0.0011869398,
-0.0131439408,
-0.0573033318,
0.0199610889,
0.0678944662,
0.0061891028,
-0.0346143432,
0.0118223373,
3.645423336e-34,
0.0232623126,
-0.0047387336,
0.0223834347,
0.0282238144,
0.050704632,
0.0068012471,
-0.0592452027,
0.019547103,
0.0259642992,
0.0061644278,
-0.0677021593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01476v1 | Tree Search for Language Model Agents | 2024-07-01T17:07:55 | 2024-07-01T17:07:55 | Jing Yu Koh, Stephen McAleer, Daniel Fried, Ruslan Salakhutdinov | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Autonomous agents powered by language models (LMs) have demonstrated promise
in their ability to perform decision-making tasks such as web automation.
However, a key limitation remains: LMs, primarily optimized for natural
language understanding and generation, struggle with multi-step reasoning,
planning, and using environmental feedback when attempting to solve realistic
computer tasks. Towards addressing this, we propose an inference-time search
algorithm for LM agents to explicitly perform exploration and multi-step
planning in interactive web environments. Our approach is a form of best-first
tree search that operates within the actual environment space, and is
complementary with most existing state-of-the-art agents. It is the first tree
search algorithm for LM agents that shows effectiveness on realistic web tasks.
On the challenging VisualWebArena benchmark, applying our search algorithm on
top of a GPT-4o agent yields a 39.7% relative increase in success rate compared
to the same baseline without search, setting a state-of-the-art success rate of
26.4%. On WebArena, search also yields a 28.0% relative improvement over a
baseline agent, setting a competitive success rate of 19.2%. Our experiments
highlight the effectiveness of search for web agents, and we demonstrate that
performance scales with increased test-time compute. We conduct a thorough
analysis of our results to highlight improvements from search, limitations, and
promising directions for future work. Our code and models are publicly released
at https://jykoh.com/search-agents. | [
0.061894197,
0.0207390524,
-0.0275411978,
0.0135918744,
-0.0507965758,
-0.0161261037,
-0.0209954809,
0.0133595364,
0.0362515748,
-0.0299178846,
-0.0186734088,
-0.0272015408,
-0.0339131542,
0.0511702821,
-0.0286964737,
-0.058977481,
0.0125104068,
-0.0277532469,
0.038293384,
-0.0040977639,
-0.0100975661,
-0.0173337422,
-0.0137091251,
0.0479068384,
0.0089919278,
-0.0059654177,
-0.0711695999,
0.0277766902,
0.0062108072,
-0.0280761402,
-0.0134286582,
0.0136356521,
0.0534908921,
0.0358819626,
0.0000024057,
-0.0448886678,
-0.0294111036,
-0.0286677089,
-0.0374163687,
-0.019089438,
-0.0005772163,
0.0478378162,
-0.0163303781,
0.0424832441,
-0.0519876108,
0.0053556669,
0.0274019334,
-0.0140077686,
0.046870131,
0.074527733,
-0.0028946635,
0.0274796337,
-0.0201994292,
0.0041546426,
0.0073666922,
-0.074636437,
0.0003554839,
-0.0241043903,
0.0578810498,
-0.0029868712,
0.008367233,
0.0108702946,
0.0033898128,
-0.0052295043,
-0.0409252979,
0.0383528993,
-0.035025645,
-0.0469748229,
-0.0180673562,
0.0465380475,
-0.0174448807,
-0.0149696637,
0.0280185621,
0.0020654644,
-0.0242225993,
0.0292409286,
-0.0329874344,
0.0830288455,
-0.0266477056,
-0.0151287131,
0.0055117342,
-0.0213166364,
0.0162981767,
0.0251370948,
-0.0371675529,
0.098059766,
0.01243228,
-0.0286279004,
0.0103682131,
-0.0306590311,
-0.0038086846,
-0.0667714477,
0.0335966088,
0.0689409673,
-0.0715125576,
0.0485114306,
-0.0138870832,
0.0239837151,
-0.0026788879,
0.0000412726,
0.0142727373,
0.0541834906,
0.0127991615,
0.0443605557,
0.003213214,
0.0699381158,
0.003272343,
-0.0156008936,
-0.0313520506,
-0.0204670411,
-0.0520678349,
-0.0231283642,
-0.0520352088,
0.0016930004,
-0.0402488634,
-0.0504589863,
0.0215761606,
0.0846288577,
0.0103170946,
0.030596111,
-0.0219468046,
-0.0120689487,
-0.0222323928,
0.0073256167,
-0.070424132,
-0.0118864747,
-0.0455089621,
-0.0162172802,
0.0096214451,
-0.0596512668,
-0.0019422162,
0.0435550809,
0.017356649,
0.0017563323,
0.0074488618,
0.113364093,
0.0095499298,
-0.0469298884,
-0.0415396094,
-0.0329279229,
0.0092440331,
-0.0235891547,
0.005966133,
-0.0552682951,
0.0308504049,
0.0106847947,
-0.0347695276,
-0.0187677126,
0.0110512152,
0.0592749082,
0.0230017789,
0.0495932251,
-0.0240510143,
0.0369931944,
-0.0009886776,
-0.0128648123,
-0.0124846445,
0.0602997914,
0.0293976888,
0.1040610299,
0.0294838808,
0.0490436591,
0.0534310751,
0.0481463522,
-0.0333833508,
0.0223528333,
0.0429321676,
0.0122859189,
-0.0207695179,
0.0652223676,
-0.0229104627,
0.0247746985,
-0.0309488494,
0.0154635422,
0.0469067171,
0.0597097948,
-0.0200836658,
-0.0116736786,
0.0446369909,
0.0377058797,
-0.0211316645,
-0.056791015,
-0.0288713574,
0.0261068791,
-0.0600334033,
-0.0036125099,
-0.0555746891,
0.0448274873,
-0.0001805991,
-0.03686985,
-0.0136484085,
0.0242101215,
0.0435248017,
0.0094493944,
0.0398068689,
0.0080220317,
-0.0559018068,
-0.0193949416,
-0.0012567315,
-0.025087364,
-0.0261192117,
-0.0882167891,
-0.011459644,
0.084761925,
0.0920853689,
-0.023506891,
-0.0446234196,
0.0233963877,
-0.0101452228,
0.0601904243,
0.021966815,
-0.0092287762,
-0.0389878117,
-0.0221163537,
-0.0811853632,
-0.0096113794,
-0.0061059752,
0.0519733131,
0.0329122096,
0.0077230097,
0.0055024871,
-0.0399490334,
-0.0160497036,
0.0392230041,
-0.0116500398,
0.0118282922,
-0.0359102823,
0.0212638546,
0.029280629,
0.0011701187,
-0.0044992589,
-0.0017585251,
0.0033503273,
0.0201598667,
-0.062211629,
0.0059877089,
0.0267211534,
-0.021473987,
0.0377658978,
-0.0457972288,
0.0266165603,
0.0420048349,
-0.0123364534,
-0.0407830589,
0.0125425123,
-0.0458882153,
0.0422029644,
-0.0093267038,
0.0322995894,
-0.02120368,
-0.0379401892,
-0.0247147959,
0.0873077661,
0.0194821842,
-0.0560140721,
0.0408436917,
0.0511272103,
0.0170824025,
-0.0239762105,
0.005027466,
0.0113958828,
0.013600192,
0.0178520028,
0.0593030639,
0.0304614492,
-0.0282721389,
-0.0175508503,
-0.1186358407,
0.0257530268,
-0.0341631398,
-0.0098465998,
0.0252424721,
0.021422226,
-0.008706863,
-0.0073115961,
-0.0174860731,
0.0384152606,
-0.0164720118,
0.0189884901,
0.0306240935,
0.0060949689,
-0.0690369383,
-0.0553161427,
-0.0041936687,
-0.0323050246,
-0.0187749639,
0.0146297961,
-0.0340295322,
-0.0260876268,
0.0548288524,
-0.0462660082,
0.0336566195,
-0.0176310521,
-0.0452512056,
0.0292599984,
-0.0627093017,
-0.0226068292,
0.0715430379,
0.036769446,
0.0679754615,
0.0739625618,
-0.0124913016,
-0.058440309,
0.0395661891,
-0.0114166904,
-0.0005058696,
-0.0224783085,
-0.0182056688,
0.0655916706,
0.0699222609,
-0.0175254494,
0.0182570349,
-0.0481328107,
0.0202280525,
0.0212319382,
0.0071365335,
-0.0074680061,
0.0008391562,
-0.0043761334,
0.0806409791,
-0.0150052914,
-0.031451676,
0.0792357773,
-0.0207240861,
-0.0005911849,
-0.0482929833,
-0.0050273924,
-0.0254239626,
0.067351453,
0.0228844825,
0.030295819,
-0.0256294087,
-0.0023727934,
-0.0386442468,
0.0495188534,
0.0634080768,
-0.0218425449,
0.013681517,
-0.0446241423,
0.0284296237,
0.00355138,
-0.0645917729,
-0.0481869951,
-0.0286614485,
-0.0209003352,
-0.0019389612,
0.0129249161,
-0.0502684042,
-0.0584561862,
0.0222882181,
0.0352459699,
0.0743631423,
-0.008200895,
-0.0372410752,
-0.0539866164,
-0.0313832499,
0.0471671447,
0.0183568522,
0.0123676686,
-0.002677833,
0.0246192366,
0.0366902016,
0.0425333679,
-0.0358565375,
-0.0203479882,
-0.0014165457,
0.0188750252,
-0.0396010168,
-0.0275077149,
0.0332844108,
-0.0297930893,
-0.0563299507,
-0.0073674037,
0.0939015076,
0.0453349054,
-0.039688915,
-0.0110841142,
-0.0873454437,
0.0228634365,
0.045684427,
0.0583264939,
-0.044967141,
-0.0337951891,
0.0289710034,
0.03496968,
-0.0170703586,
-0.0153115131,
0.0066326591,
-0.098614879,
0.0359920748,
-0.0257665496,
-0.0122742606,
0.0129722347,
-0.0460327305,
0.0151881007,
0.0025256667,
-0.0091333156,
0.0586395301,
0.0094652558,
-0.0013575399,
-0.0240079258,
-0.0112501681,
-0.0405001119,
0.0334123373,
-0.0129359048,
0.0208755247,
0.1025369987,
0.043525245,
0.0141126122,
-0.0188645758,
-0.0152770802,
0.0088346275,
0.0268420596,
-0.0347268023,
0.0246206746,
-0.0158758145,
-0.0051642763,
0.002547117,
0.0100819459,
-0.0366655141,
0.0102259936,
0.0206062049,
0.0602558926,
-0.0292884,
-0.0006179691,
-0.0354313441,
-0.0253439415,
0.0050189421,
0.0738067329,
-0.0020569086,
-0.0372112617,
-0.0866608396,
-0.0650299564,
-0.0148209678,
-0.0138738276,
-0.0193050988,
0.0042851013,
0.0045872913,
-0.0065282672,
-0.0631173775,
-0.0516825728,
0.0356518477,
0.0575165451,
0.0153263099,
-0.0391478352,
-0.0073844409,
0.0306761023,
-0.0238382164,
-0.0150460526,
-0.0498159528,
0.0094619961,
-0.010860377,
0.0117530776,
0.0377089158,
-0.077570118,
-0.0167741217,
0.016559951,
-0.0048250449,
-0.0280155893,
-0.0287314318,
0.042002026,
0.0256720856,
0.0325325876,
-0.0244490113,
-0.0036437945,
0.0038421238,
-0.039527677,
-0.0145932827,
-0.0125352647,
0.0140825519,
0.0341037735,
0.0127838561,
0.0185342226,
-0.087385267,
0.0036342591,
-0.0389493592,
0.0624858402,
-0.010977678,
-0.0000203093,
0.0589512922,
0.0432470441,
-0.0216474626,
0.0069810576,
-0.0089352243,
0.0089399954,
0.0265282504,
-0.0237025097,
-0.0411935933,
-0.0437649637,
0.007193082,
-0.016544072,
-0.0083111925,
0.0523317195,
0.0130393161,
-0.0170328151,
-0.0043422314,
-0.0004340608,
-0.0066276295,
0.0229138806,
0.0141503392,
0.0254385788,
-0.0290899277,
-0.0051065334,
0.0018892555,
0.0219724532,
0.0481690653,
-0.0200755931,
0.0676783249,
0.0362993367,
-0.0418132246,
-0.0284065157,
0.0169974212,
-0.0518259257,
-0.0874451175,
0.0184025411,
0.0191290528,
0.048563581,
0.0350599475,
0.0441547707,
-0.0808848143,
0.0259363651,
0.0098552732,
-0.0336983092,
0.0294283405,
-0.063783966,
0.0209975392,
0.0350525826,
0.0064959177,
-0.0090451594,
0.0582635701,
0.0157076828,
0.0654690415,
-0.0310745705,
-0.0465803631,
-0.0451822691,
-0.0310326777,
-0.0095557012,
0.0342964754,
0.0025820034,
-0.0471344627,
-0.0367670432,
-0.0217765551,
-0.0274144746,
0.0356454849,
-0.0072763339,
-0.0194501858,
0.0660309866,
0.0900078341,
0.016503673,
-0.026186008,
-0.0389975943,
-0.0300175976,
-0.0117546795,
0.0199396387,
-0.0176197514,
-6.208424107e-33,
-0.0399908312,
-0.0390571579,
0.0610999614,
0.0018007503,
-0.0003848485,
-0.0358508825,
-0.0627563372,
0.0033562139,
-0.0148456572,
-0.0100978035,
-0.010783582,
0.0342712365,
0.0179550592,
0.0148563776,
0.0127685396,
0.022336537,
0.0251112841,
0.004964835,
-0.0629798248,
-0.0088853138,
0.0206536017,
-0.0040446357,
-0.0189136993,
0.0041946988,
-0.0486266725,
0.0075561232,
-0.0138158938,
0.0282148495,
-0.0065687452,
0.035327293,
0.0005170242,
0.0175890625,
0.0135036409,
-0.0052969139,
0.0031324769,
-0.0083437981,
-0.0200787894,
-0.0338589475,
-0.0202200692,
0.0139340973,
-0.0487843566,
0.0048592198,
0.0187532529,
-0.0112262992,
-0.0149912285,
0.0484275743,
0.026021257,
-0.0271855425,
-0.0174563602,
-0.0146027906,
-0.0671694651,
0.0058311154,
0.0101500703,
-0.0266185701,
0.0292184409,
0.0555296205,
0.0127717312,
-0.000897339,
0.008401772,
0.0515703708,
0.004975603,
0.0018734074,
0.0638644099,
0.0271705557,
0.0085550398,
0.0603269041,
0.0231459532,
0.0148512516,
-0.0086766658,
0.008263343,
0.0145143019,
0.0269486476,
-0.0039742975,
0.0118554616,
-0.0372724831,
0.0337504931,
-0.0248846728,
0.0464433879,
0.0557160601,
0.0443699174,
0.0452148281,
0.0159440245,
-0.0494441912,
-0.0108839888,
-0.0239740182,
-0.0022187601,
-0.0442494974,
-0.0430328026,
0.0538102165,
0.0267218221,
-0.0051044645,
-0.0872960985,
-0.0009350181,
-0.0047673923,
0.0010447537,
0.0574642159,
-0.0694309473,
0.0299240928,
-0.0118451053,
0.0139644556,
0.0026325262,
-0.040603146,
-0.0330086201,
-0.0086161727,
-0.013847216,
0.0188408755,
-0.0925042704,
0.0493339486,
-0.0365361981,
-0.017276613,
-0.0560104474,
-0.0050376486,
-0.0074441019,
-0.0234575681,
0.0373420008,
-0.0364052951,
-0.0018852917,
0.0208874885,
0.041106943,
-0.0469302796,
-0.0409235358,
-0.017117925,
-0.0170840081,
-0.0257441495,
-0.0332787484,
0.0005099051,
-0.0487811118,
0.0351893157,
-0.0213606972,
-0.0794200301,
0.0024096665,
0.0133733237,
3.015e-7,
-0.0164496489,
0.0668221563,
-0.0231920369,
0.0554551408,
0.0210432522,
0.0295686331,
0.0053204265,
-0.0131960306,
-0.0348831192,
-0.0277207084,
0.0168071762,
0.0246656574,
0.0062420396,
0.0048740208,
-0.0670722276,
0.0112978984,
-0.0147214979,
-0.0338383541,
-0.0700022057,
-0.0079145581,
0.0434032045,
0.0565281957,
-0.0044966992,
-0.0090612238,
-0.0047529456,
-0.0533856787,
0.0264958981,
-0.0104703577,
0.0134240044,
0.0217223577,
-0.0124334805,
0.0454068519,
-0.0159304943,
0.0152327074,
0.0076411818,
0.0473623909,
-0.0154896732,
0.0594971254,
0.0115205059,
-0.0138609037,
0.0256607682,
-0.0438810587,
0.0145358583,
-0.0404815227,
0.0664184913,
0.0008536077,
0.0139649147,
0.0144901341,
0.0010013875,
-0.026344208,
-0.0635806024,
-0.0503008775,
-0.0251493081,
-0.0038857423,
-0.0408682115,
-0.0121099772,
-0.0089516565,
-0.0602043159,
0.0156159978,
-0.012015352,
-0.0515234321,
-0.0146196084,
-0.0660860762,
0.0247585289,
0.0267908182,
-0.0194867887,
-0.0229144208,
3.200302426e-34,
0.0151861627,
-0.0207087584,
-0.0101408763,
0.0579903238,
0.044324778,
0.0638667271,
-0.0146428002,
0.0259425417,
0.03685477,
-0.0509677678,
-0.048815567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01470v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01470v1 | DogeRM: Equipping Reward Models with Domain Knowledge through Model Merging | 2024-07-01T17:01:54 | 2024-07-01T17:01:54 | Tzu-Han Lin, Chen-An Li, Hung-yi Lee, Yun-Nung Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a popular strategy for
aligning large language models (LLMs) with desired behaviors. Reward modeling
is a crucial step in RLHF. However, collecting paired preference data for
training reward models is often costly and time-consuming, especially for
domain-specific preferences requiring expert annotation. To address this
challenge, we propose the \textbf{Do}main knowled\textbf{ge} merged
\textbf{R}eward \textbf{M}odel (DogeRM), a novel framework that integrates
domain-specific knowledge into a general reward model by model merging. The
experiments demonstrate that DogeRM enhances performance across different
benchmarks and provide a detailed analysis showcasing the effects of model
merging, showing the great potential of facilitating model alignment. | [
0.0287591014,
0.066609405,
0.0022347167,
0.01526949,
-0.0330892019,
0.0295357667,
0.0065153083,
-0.0330444723,
-0.027281424,
-0.0273173489,
-0.0849629268,
0.0094758952,
0.0216483306,
0.0199243706,
0.0221279338,
-0.0602858253,
0.0481649004,
-0.0523052551,
0.0120494962,
-0.0143368356,
0.0079465881,
0.0153417019,
-0.0127614187,
0.0627834052,
0.0376447141,
0.0138012916,
-0.0059798299,
-0.0067791087,
0.0495072044,
-0.0081559708,
0.036683213,
0.0524235666,
0.0406541005,
0.0889015049,
0.0000020077,
-0.064431794,
-0.0270766579,
0.0090425638,
-0.0207944438,
-0.0297674257,
0.0136685455,
0.017463116,
-0.0004326515,
0.0034415151,
-0.0233939178,
-0.0198213477,
0.0414279923,
0.0707793757,
0.0552310385,
0.074126415,
0.0035050318,
-0.0252665747,
0.0155165419,
-0.0540678129,
0.0111922016,
-0.0397990271,
0.0393451117,
0.0235088915,
0.0151637001,
-0.0060766372,
0.0006214546,
0.014356738,
0.0177365933,
-0.0110043576,
0.0358988978,
0.0508852415,
0.0512258895,
-0.005041508,
-0.0389381051,
0.0424067602,
-0.0076461649,
0.0021702927,
0.0016318527,
-0.0138196312,
0.0223797038,
0.0241817906,
-0.016265519,
-0.0127235958,
0.005329425,
0.0229604896,
0.0224698447,
-0.0042572157,
0.0347395651,
0.0162334945,
-0.0254365876,
0.1064906046,
0.0131847728,
-0.0387198813,
0.0112436051,
0.0180428028,
-0.0372097567,
-0.0882234052,
-0.0048833326,
0.0117449285,
-0.0537648201,
0.0130829345,
-0.0535809435,
-0.0164317675,
0.0023506314,
-0.0051054023,
0.0583274998,
0.0285994876,
0.0008541471,
0.0658731535,
-0.0075018471,
0.0610149689,
-0.01977841,
0.0313924588,
-0.0533174351,
0.0138060041,
-0.0614655986,
-0.0061055501,
0.0197134204,
0.0300187692,
-0.0243937615,
-0.0186835155,
-0.0572110564,
0.0244439505,
-0.0355433561,
0.0404451787,
0.0309856012,
0.0114245825,
-0.0371642113,
-0.0075079883,
-0.0637204275,
0.0293386281,
-0.0311977621,
0.0412938222,
0.0452482849,
0.0353570096,
0.0108016627,
-0.0056737252,
-0.0365826339,
-0.0489372276,
-0.0069642989,
0.0746163204,
-0.0041755224,
0.0049830689,
0.0136664044,
-0.0362619646,
-0.0082450351,
-0.0519511104,
0.0019834631,
-0.0851382613,
0.0453851409,
-0.0293836948,
-0.0120441178,
-0.0624825805,
-0.0094878152,
-0.0059723137,
-0.0208209921,
0.0711425468,
0.0096941376,
-0.0030727654,
0.0251943264,
-0.006972665,
-0.0252812319,
0.0605751574,
0.0267498903,
0.0406544767,
0.0039224811,
0.0072628972,
-0.0125711346,
0.019137064,
0.0397517383,
0.0156122306,
-0.0160039682,
-0.0046674842,
0.0230156444,
0.0223908685,
0.0681483075,
0.0159924794,
-0.029624613,
0.0137702264,
0.0666945279,
0.0263266563,
0.0216221847,
-0.0355007686,
0.0186833646,
-0.0029902081,
-0.0006312163,
0.0115443459,
-0.0478689745,
0.0258148499,
-0.0237860717,
0.0219878238,
0.0434873328,
0.040259026,
-0.0242553037,
-0.0468013696,
0.0083813425,
-0.0292242914,
0.0173394401,
0.0633192509,
0.0835929736,
-0.0038521462,
-0.0358925089,
-0.0175616834,
0.0505451337,
-0.0130864941,
0.0129832337,
-0.0485793687,
0.030078467,
0.065381363,
0.0223509576,
-0.0338746607,
-0.0195536241,
-0.0209044386,
-0.0337540954,
0.0336283632,
0.0553540625,
-0.0283076838,
-0.0125113856,
-0.0136665525,
-0.0846328288,
-0.0153488563,
0.0123890862,
0.0345107727,
0.0379647985,
-0.0297408104,
-0.011853762,
-0.002109468,
-0.0299877748,
0.0331778415,
-0.0399961881,
-0.0031396851,
-0.0203090739,
0.0042701275,
0.0284884069,
-0.0039820033,
-0.0069382712,
0.0267954916,
0.0217142478,
0.00692493,
-0.0353653915,
0.0085464632,
-0.0458642468,
-0.0375250988,
0.04397434,
-0.0015491166,
-0.0274916738,
0.0431927666,
-0.0317969844,
-0.0309784655,
-0.0347115919,
0.0010237299,
0.0802732185,
-0.0083837034,
0.0398278199,
0.0048665614,
-0.0436391719,
-0.0569643117,
0.0541969351,
-0.0144380042,
-0.0065297526,
-0.0265845098,
-0.0256913435,
-0.0227810033,
-0.025918629,
-0.0381396674,
-0.0099051399,
-0.0036798886,
0.0478727184,
0.0448177159,
0.0023443694,
-0.0598377436,
-0.031943839,
-0.0473200157,
0.0094035892,
0.0072484743,
0.0132052647,
0.0081925672,
-0.0008413907,
-0.0041776295,
0.003344889,
-0.0232744329,
-0.0440433472,
0.005197376,
0.0131232794,
0.0171204973,
0.0311450046,
-0.0044270093,
-0.0610794313,
-0.0229435824,
-0.0345327482,
0.0061389571,
-0.0105301784,
0.0306973439,
-0.06632258,
0.0409320071,
-0.0484123044,
0.0417088903,
-0.0273849424,
-0.0065249661,
0.0269174781,
-0.0072782179,
0.0553208329,
0.0669387355,
0.00067306,
0.0191134941,
0.0590620413,
-0.0189488884,
-0.0810707361,
0.0016333096,
-0.0417004526,
-0.0356987678,
-0.0457066149,
-0.0013998441,
0.0133023635,
0.0756880268,
-0.0249355379,
-0.0062839529,
-0.0565615855,
0.0158033613,
-0.0113372384,
-0.0469137058,
-0.0555914454,
-0.0110394079,
-0.0288505312,
0.0518409573,
-0.0363663249,
-0.0761171356,
0.1020954996,
-0.0083913207,
-0.0089874845,
-0.0427989326,
-0.0063262023,
-0.0453320518,
0.0007385748,
-0.0161501989,
0.0144864721,
-0.0006334928,
-0.0239933897,
-0.0570126288,
-0.0225835759,
0.031326592,
-0.029017359,
0.0582842939,
-0.0364556387,
0.0145472223,
0.0136131421,
-0.0521781743,
-0.06441392,
-0.0124929259,
-0.0448324159,
0.0009671215,
0.0109350439,
-0.038085524,
-0.0359377079,
-0.007244457,
0.0669018775,
-0.0071820165,
-0.0070590014,
-0.0212426037,
-0.0187642183,
0.0033726147,
0.0970416144,
0.0195520055,
-0.0045566391,
-0.0460474044,
0.0001825558,
0.0339170173,
0.0660920888,
-0.0129830372,
-0.0265394691,
-0.0028315804,
0.0636072606,
-0.053716816,
0.011927167,
0.0159995537,
-0.0061717997,
-0.0363993384,
0.0237047561,
0.114933461,
0.0245031063,
-0.0675703138,
-0.0163431671,
-0.0261284206,
0.0622671656,
0.0137621807,
0.0498009771,
-0.0590818301,
-0.0125145111,
0.0262570325,
0.0060291076,
0.0297850762,
-0.0029916265,
-0.0016190576,
-0.1508068144,
-0.0172287654,
0.007755395,
-0.0310437642,
-0.001799964,
-0.0155805685,
0.0057708281,
-0.0181986671,
-0.01588393,
0.0206007101,
-0.0047841202,
-0.0194289275,
0.022118343,
0.0282109901,
-0.0518641807,
0.0357130878,
-0.0630158335,
0.0693312213,
0.1293353438,
0.010501313,
0.0038198757,
-0.0442485735,
-0.0149686849,
0.0461846367,
-0.020581767,
-0.0148584601,
0.025772607,
-0.0480806231,
0.0011050915,
-0.0160480347,
0.0492629223,
-0.0080436841,
-0.0165535882,
0.0034677375,
0.0488560982,
0.0122166574,
0.0136265811,
-0.0176823772,
-0.0019261434,
-0.000261613,
0.081409581,
-0.0270763859,
-0.0536792874,
-0.0023731219,
-0.0026416651,
-0.060251195,
-0.0181134176,
-0.040166229,
0.0098474305,
-0.0052543101,
-0.0239235032,
-0.0719369128,
-0.0401492342,
0.0301364213,
0.0272340402,
0.0214087404,
0.0105923796,
-0.0204273704,
-0.0043633264,
-0.0336957388,
0.0521521978,
-0.029893361,
0.0356434025,
-0.1020180508,
-0.0110575827,
0.0150446277,
-0.0502168946,
-0.0382244401,
-0.0120288534,
-0.0435345359,
-0.0842789188,
-0.0194714591,
0.0836870894,
0.023651002,
0.0716294274,
-0.0069000968,
-0.0308658499,
0.0133834165,
0.013854553,
-0.0445689559,
0.0146301845,
0.0484778769,
0.0075008483,
-0.0049385042,
0.0070733926,
-0.0652236044,
0.0034896079,
0.0151876435,
0.0078503573,
0.0021313394,
0.0013031721,
0.0508918613,
-0.0281026997,
0.0590579435,
-0.0382376835,
-0.0169060621,
-0.0527237728,
-0.0023520296,
-0.0176440421,
-0.0245959014,
-0.0464504287,
-0.0273928214,
0.0273639299,
0.0166819915,
0.0281715523,
0.012247703,
0.034235891,
-0.0136370892,
-0.027394589,
-0.0241568964,
0.012083007,
0.0196513664,
0.0157183763,
0.0364592969,
0.0135058677,
-0.0059064683,
0.0039634383,
0.0560603626,
0.0028811463,
0.0514363497,
0.0463056602,
0.0066064429,
0.003172037,
0.0278415419,
-0.040514376,
-0.0387251712,
-0.0128239859,
-0.0243368205,
0.0741043091,
-0.0082776565,
0.0712619945,
-0.0335317478,
-0.0103067337,
-0.0184136573,
0.0089194793,
-0.0471287481,
0.0065270551,
0.0385398269,
0.0351610109,
0.0074732299,
-0.029076498,
0.0700363517,
0.0149803534,
0.0260056201,
-0.0317532085,
-0.0078090834,
-0.0221212152,
-0.0115556009,
0.0557894893,
0.0008454357,
-0.0581369996,
-0.0369919911,
-0.058862064,
-0.066998668,
-0.0366514698,
0.0405387245,
-0.0248652585,
0.0249170698,
0.0550346561,
0.036353115,
-0.0552333146,
-0.0081125619,
-0.054921519,
-0.03711031,
-0.0179628078,
-0.0326275714,
-0.0144783305,
-6.38916371e-33,
-0.0435803644,
-0.0010673102,
0.0411626995,
-0.0149620166,
-0.0384232253,
-0.0083527202,
-0.0052132918,
0.0132297445,
0.0109467423,
-0.003155008,
-0.002893545,
-0.0089090159,
0.0059898454,
-0.0034848021,
0.0364259519,
0.0026193222,
0.057485912,
0.0034026436,
-0.0395539626,
-0.0067829383,
0.0110917585,
0.0175771695,
0.0462043062,
-0.0789364502,
0.0693103299,
0.0288115311,
-0.0369321704,
0.0242067743,
-0.0188760236,
0.0773268342,
-0.0035460196,
-0.0094634481,
-0.0036358091,
-0.0454531685,
-0.0361848995,
0.00732709,
-0.073446624,
-0.012944472,
0.0515084602,
-0.0150503963,
-0.0413833819,
-0.0135878352,
0.0234073643,
-0.0029814108,
0.0081039015,
-0.0290507525,
0.0423929989,
-0.0115709836,
-0.0190439112,
0.0266684741,
-0.0686274543,
0.0064876024,
0.0102754747,
-0.025788011,
0.0532988794,
0.0222787466,
0.02372084,
0.0205129664,
-0.021031104,
0.0606776588,
0.0337554477,
0.0362240262,
0.1033844203,
0.0424541645,
0.0128674572,
0.0600021742,
-0.0008634242,
-0.0130106471,
0.0215311944,
0.0032362049,
0.030414572,
0.0619541481,
0.0220856611,
0.0295264535,
0.0034122083,
0.0130773727,
0.0025183805,
0.0711511448,
0.0056354231,
0.0055108839,
-0.0004328266,
0.0504021011,
-0.0320943967,
-0.0066539813,
-0.0375663079,
0.0253496282,
-0.0315292403,
-0.0390368961,
0.0302593745,
0.0218295213,
-0.0229119528,
-0.0314315557,
0.0214899257,
-0.0458904281,
-0.0302952975,
0.0155478036,
-0.0138847847,
0.0389678515,
-0.0160712712,
-0.0116075883,
-0.0797770768,
-0.015179812,
-0.0058709839,
0.0138350334,
-0.0015024832,
0.0212341063,
0.0254650638,
0.019429246,
-0.0449651219,
0.0288484767,
-0.0272147153,
0.002316491,
0.0207137577,
-0.0022318806,
0.0594029576,
0.0075889593,
-0.016132351,
0.0268816799,
0.013609373,
-0.0611565597,
-0.0511294752,
0.0081530698,
-0.0015613093,
0.0162171219,
0.0051767379,
-0.0172246881,
-0.0105690137,
-0.0047705038,
0.0574262179,
-0.0021385902,
-0.0297207423,
-0.0163174644,
2.753e-7,
0.0161277782,
0.0109451469,
0.0141911702,
0.035379488,
-0.0132396268,
0.0648942664,
-0.0324504003,
0.0174553972,
0.0576845147,
0.0182425659,
0.0166298654,
0.0194827821,
0.0489053726,
-0.0192886237,
-0.0666437373,
-0.0534687005,
-0.0388095938,
0.0144321043,
-0.0241796412,
-0.0316464715,
0.0078019495,
0.0655277148,
0.0680227652,
0.0034114013,
0.0005315844,
0.0084727788,
0.0659353808,
-0.063997522,
0.0043767109,
0.0199875068,
-0.0048074331,
0.0004163765,
-0.0283614993,
-0.0060633412,
-0.0055724676,
0.0163104068,
-0.0092023248,
0.0723143592,
0.0017260221,
-0.0161933322,
-0.0276875198,
0.0255028587,
0.0028556369,
-0.0727021396,
0.0185903311,
-0.0759200603,
-0.0214400776,
-0.0468616076,
-0.0051861666,
-0.0444824621,
0.0129037034,
-0.0152874673,
-0.0130045386,
0.0016551244,
0.0026706839,
0.0279370081,
-0.0164358392,
-0.0719854459,
-0.0368348472,
0.0394935235,
-0.057451874,
-0.0439213812,
-0.0410078913,
0.0426697731,
-0.0256942101,
-0.0926756188,
-0.0216584653,
2.549936299e-34,
0.0056778984,
-0.0083430717,
0.0119300615,
0.0409645848,
0.0255110394,
0.0059750024,
-0.0308796428,
0.0325634889,
0.0599791221,
-0.0377792269,
-0.0242448449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01463v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01463v1 | Retrieval-augmented generation in multilingual settings | 2024-07-01T16:56:50 | 2024-07-01T16:56:50 | Nadezhda Chirkova, David Rau, Hervé Déjean, Thibault Formal, Stéphane Clinchant, Vassilina Nikoulina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has recently emerged as a promising
solution for incorporating up-to-date or domain-specific knowledge into large
language models (LLMs) and improving LLM factuality, but is predominantly
studied in English-only settings. In this work, we consider RAG in the
multilingual setting (mRAG), i.e. with user queries and the datastore in 13
languages, and investigate which components and with which adjustments are
needed to build a well-performing mRAG pipeline, that can be used as a strong
baseline in future works. Our findings highlight that despite the availability
of high-quality off-the-shelf multilingual retrievers and generators,
task-specific prompt engineering is needed to enable generation in user
languages. Moreover, current evaluation metrics need adjustments for
multilingual setting, to account for variations in spelling named entities. The
main limitations to be addressed in future works include frequent
code-switching in non-Latin alphabet languages, occasional fluency errors,
wrong reading of the provided documents, or irrelevant retrieval. We release
the code for the resulting mRAG baseline pipeline at
https://github.com/naver/bergen. | [
0.0453219973,
0.0326411165,
-0.0104489643,
0.0409822948,
-0.0363571569,
-0.0177598968,
0.010622154,
-0.0190276578,
0.0179301742,
-0.0255084094,
-0.0124005405,
-0.0536535978,
-0.024408767,
0.008906343,
0.0454988517,
-0.0152164968,
0.0509369969,
-0.0047918614,
-0.0422368757,
-0.0228564534,
-0.0101445224,
0.0386938974,
0.0117866881,
0.0475923941,
-0.0046929996,
-0.0072637456,
-0.0041021192,
0.015668137,
0.0136355674,
-0.0034611938,
0.0015378187,
0.0187897757,
-0.0070760804,
0.0641122833,
0.0000020442,
-0.0741179213,
-0.0525223278,
0.0162946489,
-0.0087254401,
-0.0249974709,
0.0400763378,
0.0124552045,
-0.0134563828,
0.010002722,
-0.0310372319,
-0.011808319,
0.0368553214,
-0.0161353592,
0.0376184992,
0.0709986165,
0.0035872387,
-0.013440215,
0.0078666629,
-0.0252033304,
0.03116557,
-0.0163133871,
-0.0110473949,
-0.0074785142,
0.0365539826,
0.0459748618,
0.0263668522,
0.060422115,
0.0144083947,
-0.0254629236,
0.0054556248,
0.0034473946,
-0.021895906,
-0.0385211408,
0.0039982065,
0.0382931642,
0.0527061336,
-0.0147491759,
0.0087889936,
0.029965302,
0.0002061264,
0.0250508301,
-0.0267320275,
0.0129135828,
-0.035092704,
-0.0140151875,
0.0240388177,
-0.0302278455,
0.0236194395,
0.0112286918,
-0.0228726175,
0.0644981191,
0.0444131568,
-0.0266861562,
-0.0063660177,
0.0260875411,
0.0061639827,
-0.0211769678,
0.0121798143,
0.0205349997,
-0.0774099827,
0.0239598621,
0.0000728108,
-0.0582561009,
0.0552978739,
-0.0222291388,
0.0104799494,
0.0304038618,
-0.0257026423,
0.0213552378,
-0.0222331733,
0.0709036142,
-0.0099797044,
-0.0278976522,
-0.0295855813,
-0.0434591025,
-0.0201245286,
-0.0224016756,
-0.0356434993,
0.0116672236,
-0.0451125801,
0.0236466005,
-0.0466346256,
0.0246321503,
-0.0110815791,
0.0281316079,
0.007954848,
-0.0023800456,
-0.0690503865,
-0.0054649771,
-0.0268515106,
0.0332504474,
-0.0304496903,
-0.0336379111,
0.0352119692,
-0.0761336759,
-0.0071998201,
0.0019996876,
-0.0107421707,
-0.0297449045,
-0.003656555,
0.0298439432,
-0.0056494265,
-0.0277455244,
-0.0502730645,
-0.0701657981,
-0.0090586608,
-0.0615739115,
-0.0083077624,
-0.0859821439,
0.0558652207,
0.0201589968,
0.0025748662,
-0.0535253473,
-0.0026164374,
0.0386156179,
-0.008233862,
0.0149626741,
-0.0259695929,
0.01973035,
0.0323879384,
0.0024279745,
-0.0088462541,
0.0674561858,
-0.0055926451,
0.0227589011,
0.0737573877,
0.0263416469,
-0.0089493962,
0.0407441407,
0.0247878842,
0.0191797968,
0.0078162188,
0.0121686254,
-0.0027815022,
0.0063547627,
0.0258825235,
0.0553685799,
-0.0238771141,
0.0292797443,
-0.0041871732,
-0.0096155126,
0.0465140343,
-0.0127229281,
0.0889715552,
0.0081171747,
-0.0020148698,
0.0131696556,
0.0135088628,
0.0091918791,
-0.0245154016,
0.0356630422,
0.0303718839,
0.0824545324,
-0.0149449082,
-0.0166795142,
0.0115186069,
0.0087664835,
-0.0475973375,
0.025338117,
0.0611708574,
0.035899844,
-0.0296458025,
0.0405357033,
0.015185236,
-0.0853812993,
0.0432610661,
-0.0163377337,
0.0252630729,
0.0703909025,
0.091791898,
-0.0127900327,
-0.0345804952,
0.0245138332,
-0.0134012541,
0.0392944217,
0.0392038897,
-0.0301250145,
-0.0026770348,
-0.046195507,
-0.0400930904,
0.0035860422,
0.0025421618,
0.0422017723,
0.0408531316,
0.0280082636,
0.0588168614,
-0.0509738736,
-0.0251132399,
-0.0004594281,
-0.0897072777,
0.0065348414,
0.0026844249,
0.0183580443,
-0.0072695133,
0.0605995879,
-0.0123421419,
0.02011046,
0.0233771354,
-0.0255325865,
-0.0022545971,
0.0063933437,
0.0073830187,
-0.0182559378,
0.0117074158,
0.0073139104,
0.0128751192,
-0.0258037467,
-0.0099976342,
-0.0538476855,
-0.0244606752,
-0.0300278813,
0.0192218162,
-0.0640302449,
0.0258358214,
0.0074318671,
-0.011966859,
-0.0537496619,
0.073085852,
-0.0015479585,
0.0433580466,
0.0431973971,
0.0076863598,
0.0174182802,
-0.0580735467,
-0.0395661704,
0.0493272208,
0.0094591575,
0.0204624441,
0.0777166113,
0.0241474528,
-0.0394685566,
-0.0130748153,
-0.0627298057,
0.0121570248,
-0.0336791165,
0.0261272881,
0.0059976941,
0.0684004053,
-0.018735446,
0.001456363,
-0.0250835866,
-0.0136699378,
0.0535021387,
0.0402974561,
0.0215483624,
0.0195477344,
-0.0001121079,
-0.0250718687,
0.0015345394,
0.0208022539,
0.0341189727,
0.015434836,
-0.0247511026,
-0.072773993,
0.0510946363,
-0.0796907544,
-0.0010889278,
-0.0051651122,
0.0075287558,
0.0141376806,
-0.0193172488,
0.0900641307,
0.0046991324,
-0.0058199414,
-0.0064130342,
0.0207208656,
-0.0404239781,
-0.088673979,
0.0127644911,
-0.0223612674,
-0.0547325648,
0.0111244442,
-0.0437909625,
0.0508478917,
0.0002186732,
-0.009458459,
-0.0283767916,
-0.0381712429,
-0.0110492771,
-0.0290880166,
-0.0440738983,
-0.0343796797,
0.0065334742,
0.0050370619,
0.0678382814,
-0.0024023305,
-0.0409407802,
0.0807482675,
-0.0439989641,
-0.0003952056,
-0.0717702657,
0.0087320618,
-0.0348911881,
0.0416864194,
-0.0207659658,
0.0458928682,
-0.035915304,
-0.020234365,
-0.0407629684,
0.0472741425,
0.0211973563,
-0.0578122213,
0.0320705473,
-0.032657586,
0.0134280343,
-0.0086348858,
-0.0468393564,
-0.0498992838,
0.0112711964,
0.0224544294,
-0.0130099878,
0.0217142925,
-0.0133584328,
-0.0228618439,
-0.0161304381,
0.0555747338,
0.0087020816,
-0.0060548009,
-0.0213649198,
-0.0001204387,
0.0147308344,
0.0437605456,
-0.0008376671,
-0.0026554274,
-0.0136784529,
-0.0047023031,
0.0430114307,
0.0277431626,
-0.0661461875,
0.0249733645,
-0.0159147885,
0.070589982,
-0.0231830291,
-0.0470670573,
0.0095321564,
0.0160403736,
-0.0485961363,
-0.0375780985,
0.0606864728,
0.0452818088,
-0.0453494601,
-0.0267787836,
-0.0374710113,
0.0593461394,
0.0202979594,
0.0622175001,
-0.1021118462,
0.0152074806,
0.0152188065,
0.0509081595,
-0.0103119006,
-0.0151293576,
-0.0176574513,
-0.1526697576,
0.0577704646,
-0.0059837648,
-0.0141106499,
-0.0374515876,
-0.0462964512,
-0.0157861095,
0.0109653482,
0.0200676303,
0.0634170398,
-0.0063360678,
0.032106705,
0.0048294957,
0.0290586874,
-0.0621369556,
-0.0190495178,
-0.0381166935,
-0.0131705366,
0.0797570646,
0.0270531345,
0.0308447629,
-0.0269195866,
-0.0356774963,
0.0102174748,
0.0165103544,
-0.0287501346,
0.0111507513,
0.0093043922,
-0.0155598735,
-0.0340071768,
-0.0207791533,
0.0031831542,
-0.013120804,
0.0051595955,
0.0644070357,
-0.0316441767,
0.0535925664,
-0.0366521329,
-0.0142120617,
0.0335180089,
0.0757430196,
0.0129974689,
-0.0135872504,
-0.029861128,
-0.02025491,
0.0327580608,
-0.055422917,
0.0012423887,
0.0259757899,
-0.0571158156,
-0.0213518701,
-0.0751067773,
-0.054542046,
-0.0002581118,
0.0313167535,
0.0098731117,
-0.0066718273,
-0.0139853526,
-0.0164582059,
-0.0446770638,
0.0098122256,
-0.036282476,
0.0164866373,
-0.0548844747,
-0.0166719854,
0.046456933,
-0.0291007031,
-0.0081338715,
0.0342280976,
-0.0150736952,
-0.0657632351,
-0.0117323725,
0.0343345627,
0.024394352,
0.0387750864,
-0.0171689056,
-0.0196961593,
0.0360095873,
0.0535771288,
-0.0568047687,
-0.0082328636,
0.0040465449,
0.0059241634,
-0.0407567546,
0.0378321484,
-0.0798408911,
-0.0070583322,
-0.0560106337,
0.093323864,
0.0331230015,
-0.0656745136,
0.0220979434,
0.0706527159,
0.0045251795,
-0.0552223623,
-0.0002625909,
-0.0464404486,
0.000094921,
-0.0356189199,
-0.0457810238,
-0.0281098261,
0.030080013,
-0.0151038459,
-0.0419143699,
0.0272927508,
0.0345135443,
-0.0087354342,
0.067945905,
-0.0402935594,
-0.0199901108,
-0.022247903,
0.0108683361,
0.0334299728,
0.0030509955,
-0.0105873048,
0.0205192249,
0.0071851984,
0.0485864319,
-0.0464720353,
0.0442887135,
0.0053942916,
-0.0073650829,
0.0101629281,
0.0119397519,
-0.0394945294,
-0.0152777899,
-0.0199118331,
0.004560845,
0.0699282363,
0.0163467955,
0.0961627588,
-0.020775361,
-0.0176064037,
-0.0190684143,
0.0049112844,
0.0421325155,
-0.0327024497,
-0.0099310996,
0.0102441888,
-0.0263312962,
0.0005923552,
0.0946128592,
-0.0343657732,
0.0121135544,
-0.0382411517,
-0.0400117375,
-0.0339810476,
-0.0678227991,
0.0066508804,
-0.0113671999,
-0.0368627682,
-0.0367991254,
-0.0809773803,
-0.0562078655,
0.0205847155,
0.0146073038,
-0.0331611037,
0.0032138266,
0.0236752629,
0.103374891,
0.0106089832,
0.0065320046,
-0.0588288121,
0.0292175896,
-0.0548841432,
-0.0367030315,
0.0107490486,
-6.100603724e-33,
-0.0442456603,
-0.0233771168,
0.0392716043,
-0.0428896509,
-0.0093157925,
0.011708186,
-0.0416733921,
-0.0187207609,
-0.0080613773,
-0.0104424693,
-0.0162801389,
-0.0181542635,
0.0276557598,
0.0245776549,
0.0059604831,
0.0131811779,
0.0325861089,
0.0343909487,
-0.0359862149,
0.0525548197,
0.0968395844,
0.0256482996,
0.0543239973,
-0.0300352424,
0.0669677407,
-0.0163989086,
0.000180047,
0.0178192593,
0.0024644076,
0.0587914735,
-0.0009905838,
0.075133808,
-0.0027603025,
-0.0516176485,
-0.0148518756,
-0.0241049528,
-0.0658434927,
-0.0230515692,
0.0137227122,
0.0012068953,
-0.0247599632,
-0.0326675512,
0.0071964846,
-0.0274920799,
-0.0179824755,
0.05182923,
0.017254293,
-0.0065542134,
-0.0042713964,
-0.070845522,
-0.0554988459,
0.0191432945,
0.0292988475,
0.0220393874,
-0.0004858239,
0.0827140436,
0.0284940489,
0.0404050574,
-0.0570110753,
0.0472176261,
-0.0238480046,
0.0365045853,
0.0709667429,
-0.0027563011,
-0.0036109374,
0.0185908433,
0.0197987705,
0.0134839797,
-0.003942274,
0.0192814432,
0.0154946521,
0.0249648523,
-0.0075709797,
0.1043581441,
-0.0278366338,
-0.0204001516,
-0.0346287638,
0.0858465806,
-0.0221670698,
0.0413379632,
0.0106887762,
-0.0314622149,
-0.0359542258,
-0.0269808117,
-0.0207025521,
0.0207093377,
-0.0368892848,
-0.0341069028,
0.0361863598,
0.0073689125,
-0.0281429701,
-0.0007760253,
0.0342683159,
0.0000773929,
-0.0259100292,
0.0504509099,
-0.0499242395,
-0.004990079,
-0.0225087143,
0.0570028275,
-0.0005268267,
-0.0266260244,
0.0128999501,
0.0047803763,
-0.0352899805,
0.0280050486,
0.0049749534,
0.0177840032,
-0.0433737002,
0.0252486058,
-0.0439255014,
0.0618052036,
-0.0421477742,
-0.0187707786,
0.016750576,
0.0044549466,
-0.0074720839,
0.0311652813,
0.078056708,
0.0163331628,
-0.0178972874,
-0.0339454226,
0.0241258517,
0.0111479526,
-0.0130922664,
0.0438304655,
-0.0303537324,
0.0341308303,
0.0373250581,
-0.0115011334,
-0.0105037671,
-0.023035625,
2.858e-7,
0.0350239649,
0.0020578681,
0.0307776947,
0.0412131511,
-0.026589958,
0.0040207258,
0.0065081026,
0.0137725184,
0.0134064797,
0.0018459305,
-0.0114126345,
-0.0046621151,
0.037813969,
0.0514851771,
-0.0894035995,
0.0079857148,
-0.0423529558,
-0.0043824264,
-0.0746432841,
-0.0146052176,
0.0282137338,
0.0171524379,
-0.0165314451,
-0.033649601,
-0.0249476396,
-0.0474712551,
0.0502657071,
0.0030247106,
-0.0648262352,
0.0387454331,
0.0883926898,
0.0222702939,
0.0447961167,
-0.036796663,
-0.026335923,
0.0016993853,
0.025470227,
0.0150804436,
0.0408369601,
-0.0240029935,
0.0189218447,
-0.0493199453,
0.0013636752,
-0.0549952239,
0.0465029031,
0.0332922377,
0.0158650819,
0.0000353164,
-0.0482774116,
0.0064623854,
0.0043507437,
-0.0626878589,
-0.0376002602,
0.0283552054,
0.0078843478,
0.0165811237,
-0.0190046765,
-0.0318213403,
-0.0314618647,
0.0196187012,
-0.0152836544,
-0.0663543046,
-0.0239237808,
0.0031325319,
-0.0458332896,
-0.0584644899,
0.0179687347,
2.939613824e-34,
0.0282643773,
0.0256223362,
0.0038494258,
-0.0020723403,
0.0535214357,
-0.0192485563,
-0.0280839838,
0.0160036962,
-0.0079092579,
-0.0328615233,
-0.0505372323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01461v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01461v1 | Enhancing the Capability and Robustness of Large Language Models through Reinforcement Learning-Driven Query Refinement | 2024-07-01T16:55:28 | 2024-07-01T16:55:28 | Zisu Huang, Xiaohua Wang, Feiran Zhang, Zhibo Xu, Cenyuan Zhang, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The capacity of large language models (LLMs) to generate honest, harmless,
and helpful responses heavily relies on the quality of user prompts. However,
these prompts often tend to be brief and vague, thereby significantly limiting
the full potential of LLMs. Moreover, harmful prompts can be meticulously
crafted and manipulated by adversaries to jailbreak LLMs, inducing them to
produce potentially toxic content. To enhance the capabilities of LLMs while
maintaining strong robustness against harmful jailbreak inputs, this study
proposes a transferable and pluggable framework that refines user prompts
before they are input into LLMs. This strategy improves the quality of the
queries, empowering LLMs to generate more truthful, benign and useful
responses. Specifically, a lightweight query refinement model is introduced and
trained using a specially designed reinforcement learning approach that
incorporates multiple objectives to enhance particular capabilities of LLMs.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that the refinement model not only improves
the quality of responses but also strengthens their robustness against
jailbreak attacks. Code is available at:
https://github.com/Huangzisu/query-refinement . | [
0.0796767995,
0.0805884674,
-0.0219128169,
0.0198070928,
-0.0239061601,
-0.016957039,
-0.015199664,
0.009695407,
0.0184393562,
-0.0280118361,
-0.0178339537,
-0.0223726947,
-0.0116509506,
0.0130452765,
0.0167017579,
-0.0434439145,
0.0634304956,
-0.0461513363,
0.0149011444,
0.0067942617,
0.0214451421,
0.0085235322,
0.0165726859,
0.049593322,
0.0177751351,
-0.005485781,
-0.0159930177,
0.0480608083,
-0.0024528885,
-0.0345479734,
0.0325632542,
0.0473607145,
-0.0154679138,
0.0688834265,
0.0000020942,
-0.0603981838,
-0.040710479,
0.0201142095,
-0.0239850674,
0.0201108158,
0.062103346,
-0.025465453,
-0.0252720118,
0.0367211774,
-0.0569021963,
-0.0073772999,
0.0593584813,
0.0705324113,
0.0931362435,
0.0968448222,
0.0125542935,
-0.0045298962,
0.0153207565,
-0.0108192796,
0.0332880616,
-0.0509025194,
0.0316643603,
-0.0344643407,
0.0509558693,
0.0066832197,
0.0059494129,
0.0028217407,
0.0214112606,
-0.0399860702,
-0.0612198003,
-0.0107697565,
-0.043324925,
-0.0186405797,
-0.0060641752,
0.0513526462,
-0.031923417,
-0.0114151062,
0.0102847265,
0.0011589184,
0.0250484701,
0.0357545726,
-0.0249858424,
0.0133319898,
-0.0014719637,
0.008594228,
-0.0137063777,
-0.0144684818,
0.0588297173,
0.0345743895,
-0.038301874,
0.0609375648,
-0.0035935587,
-0.0359052829,
-0.0046450915,
-0.0534746349,
0.0148871988,
-0.0517070219,
-0.0173731875,
0.0125451656,
-0.0521435663,
0.0206798911,
-0.0718538612,
-0.0270656943,
0.0529251732,
-0.0349472873,
-0.0042133895,
0.0273769852,
0.0134546906,
0.0287091956,
-0.0043570246,
0.0196728148,
0.0025466837,
0.0497517698,
-0.0170199648,
-0.0041125389,
-0.0366859064,
-0.0163861401,
-0.0262561236,
0.0516266935,
-0.0102302385,
0.0131432051,
-0.039152313,
0.0577646643,
-0.0172397215,
0.0298103746,
-0.0162433144,
0.0051560956,
-0.0185607225,
-0.0005219206,
-0.0344469212,
-0.0060452987,
-0.0289881844,
-0.0151181268,
0.0096486853,
-0.1040935963,
-0.007726125,
-0.0197767001,
-0.0356713273,
-0.0412760004,
-0.0318805315,
0.080625698,
-0.0008899557,
-0.01541162,
-0.0793028399,
-0.0644214451,
-0.0061501372,
-0.0270400215,
-0.0164116286,
-0.0602440648,
0.0039471872,
-0.0271229614,
-0.0245067365,
-0.0439040028,
0.0061036996,
0.0337246619,
-0.0430246592,
0.0796050131,
-0.0192840621,
-0.0013988166,
0.0074925488,
0.0384696163,
0.0192558635,
0.0768426582,
0.0096382573,
0.0589540377,
0.0532147624,
-0.0041181925,
0.0395003892,
0.0027509283,
0.0029520206,
0.0193398856,
-0.0367319398,
0.0287339929,
0.0236082263,
-0.001027181,
-0.0177126471,
0.0502117909,
-0.0186586119,
-0.025096884,
0.0909487009,
0.0210489724,
-0.0170362517,
-0.0045868265,
0.0121912966,
0.0273628179,
0.0032854211,
0.0051766927,
-0.0855949,
0.0051648044,
-0.0341768116,
-0.0155005008,
0.0012130432,
0.0276114792,
-0.0016557971,
-0.0350754783,
0.0241561104,
-0.0134363696,
0.0298397616,
0.0400553569,
0.0124816634,
0.0235869661,
-0.0232817829,
0.0053229025,
0.027126113,
-0.0248552822,
-0.0040785712,
-0.0764252916,
0.0207712073,
0.0838389397,
0.0640987828,
-0.0371567905,
-0.0192327946,
-0.0336442627,
-0.0245696735,
0.0214460865,
0.0339404866,
0.0060459054,
0.0053852405,
-0.0137867508,
-0.0349459648,
-0.0055223848,
0.0267301798,
0.0194482543,
0.0272900444,
-0.0144989854,
0.0167071391,
-0.0083724456,
-0.0389277786,
0.0289609917,
0.0481645428,
-0.0304993112,
0.032725364,
0.0340063311,
0.031119829,
-0.003991439,
-0.0029731097,
0.0235696528,
0.0404415354,
0.0291719139,
0.0252083838,
-0.0344863981,
-0.0218097884,
0.0038868336,
0.018877577,
0.0024701715,
-0.0044462918,
0.0331533588,
-0.0497066714,
-0.0079345247,
0.0124883773,
-0.0415346473,
0.038556423,
-0.0334981456,
0.0148286028,
-0.0297098011,
0.0108235134,
-0.0647393391,
0.0060505988,
0.0077521964,
-0.0131805325,
0.0001820207,
-0.0208628364,
0.0026892326,
-0.0195142757,
-0.0389644466,
0.0019480805,
-0.031410601,
0.0393645763,
0.0487962663,
0.034410879,
-0.0052268058,
-0.04233687,
-0.031990815,
-0.0308548361,
-0.0339568444,
0.0020118845,
0.0258147791,
0.064746052,
-0.032318905,
-0.0366603471,
-0.0215991214,
-0.0418469533,
0.0010272779,
0.0396336652,
0.0065521174,
0.0072152899,
-0.0300485063,
-0.0101836072,
-0.0171329062,
0.0007818796,
0.0509010032,
-0.0110808862,
-0.0237485394,
-0.0168622024,
-0.0191795677,
-0.0311075915,
0.0186290797,
-0.0093259318,
-0.0638055503,
0.0249238964,
-0.0090579577,
-0.0011686223,
0.070792906,
0.0482285433,
0.0091480864,
0.0854831338,
0.0092526497,
-0.0631182864,
0.0095353443,
-0.0095156217,
-0.0590505935,
-0.0476588383,
-0.0520983823,
0.0605239049,
0.0194608048,
0.0338566974,
0.0137998089,
-0.0515907221,
0.0389545485,
0.0070426278,
-0.056876868,
-0.0145420227,
0.01112301,
-0.0292927269,
0.0192932002,
-0.0195919722,
-0.068161875,
0.1257498562,
-0.0039643133,
0.020941956,
-0.0291892122,
-0.0374187566,
0.0080105234,
0.0213854723,
-0.0203442723,
0.0436891653,
0.0419220924,
-0.0481546,
-0.0498559996,
-0.0637124628,
0.0416547284,
-0.034265615,
0.0507206284,
-0.0356295668,
-0.0009057869,
0.0017206552,
-0.0371575393,
-0.0602928959,
-0.0554097816,
-0.0009116046,
0.0005353339,
0.0147593142,
-0.0419024825,
-0.0018868521,
-0.0022437603,
0.0524200685,
0.0113239046,
-0.0476984009,
-0.0250544939,
-0.0157194268,
-0.016135186,
0.0656397566,
-0.0228720121,
0.0075298464,
-0.0060698949,
0.0205613617,
0.0535695292,
0.0306365844,
-0.0382663272,
0.0003684054,
0.0048336373,
0.0321280919,
-0.0388529748,
0.0064954837,
0.0593255423,
0.0260372199,
-0.0656072199,
-0.0160714611,
0.0680922493,
0.0404018536,
-0.0101012299,
0.006342276,
-0.0144464271,
0.0440152213,
0.021851588,
0.0660200566,
-0.0743537173,
-0.0211133268,
0.008158219,
0.077474162,
-0.0166387707,
-0.0338778384,
-0.0315307304,
-0.1378376931,
0.0281119123,
0.0130282538,
-0.0318149626,
-0.0038299714,
-0.0452279299,
-0.0165336449,
0.026472779,
0.0459388979,
0.0192197971,
-0.0294110887,
-0.0149681401,
0.0097762616,
-0.0168676004,
-0.028337216,
-0.0214538183,
-0.047522869,
0.0435814895,
0.1038816422,
0.0058770389,
0.0018761066,
0.002419654,
0.0083948737,
0.0035194845,
0.0046630693,
-0.0169262476,
0.0107917273,
0.010155879,
-0.0087247388,
0.011885603,
0.0090130465,
0.0181942657,
-0.0260049589,
0.0205438361,
0.0740033239,
-0.0297346208,
0.0016112333,
-0.0367834009,
-0.0296293292,
0.0270906538,
0.0614766777,
0.0257123597,
-0.0302131027,
-0.0464935489,
-0.0728277639,
-0.0495683141,
-0.0479968861,
0.0079827188,
0.009630966,
-0.0206076633,
0.0074612875,
-0.0557577983,
-0.0069606551,
-0.0132439742,
0.0218433011,
0.0322139151,
0.0064254659,
0.0060064113,
0.0044452832,
-0.0265055075,
-0.0255123172,
-0.0440978073,
0.0395451151,
-0.0879779533,
0.0329613052,
-0.0190601051,
-0.048814062,
-0.0026248174,
-0.0138017479,
-0.0136532718,
-0.0810060576,
0.0050558345,
0.0795649737,
0.0186018739,
0.0309074,
-0.0551113002,
-0.0909900218,
0.0340550728,
0.0667732507,
-0.0917549431,
-0.0179281477,
0.0537780449,
0.0077872113,
0.0064790961,
0.0439235978,
-0.0753711164,
-0.0272621699,
0.0344028026,
0.0048788204,
-0.0305217151,
-0.0323208049,
0.0320016146,
0.0444688946,
0.0219307728,
0.0117523158,
0.0133156572,
0.0094534447,
0.0309700184,
-0.0204515886,
-0.0527261198,
-0.0001783887,
0.0371136181,
0.0185369793,
-0.0042022117,
0.0326679721,
0.0000539624,
-0.0340697207,
0.0279670842,
-0.0121906027,
0.0055740438,
0.0271336008,
0.0403555445,
0.0637018532,
0.0117587289,
-0.0037221133,
0.0474344045,
0.0224651992,
0.0313385315,
-0.0125854751,
0.0334530063,
0.0019461385,
-0.0255366731,
-0.0302698761,
0.0234519467,
-0.0821375623,
-0.0511026233,
0.0234271251,
0.050831221,
0.0015535352,
0.0201310031,
0.0154518988,
-0.0079186792,
0.0039976831,
-0.0363670662,
-0.0229464956,
0.0275143031,
-0.0414152071,
0.0516220368,
0.0132557731,
-0.0109638432,
0.0147099476,
0.0584577248,
-0.0114164073,
0.0315720588,
0.0035435171,
-0.0345670432,
-0.0293571167,
-0.01788719,
0.0466522239,
0.0420253836,
-0.0699975342,
-0.0442181602,
-0.0419835672,
-0.0465576462,
-0.0271104779,
0.0061486801,
0.0102438107,
-0.0097603444,
0.0063922182,
0.0594898649,
0.0160882063,
0.0169597194,
-0.0866214707,
0.0078499634,
-0.0118294507,
-0.0446839482,
0.0075884634,
-6.242397363e-33,
0.0235122219,
-0.0240033828,
-0.0236952621,
-0.0651990175,
-0.0020249402,
-0.0198705792,
-0.034341272,
-0.0099194264,
-0.0430034697,
-0.0113587268,
-0.0339524001,
0.0032283114,
0.0095117381,
0.0261383634,
-0.0413299985,
-0.0427491032,
0.0378800817,
0.0142380781,
-0.0384797305,
0.0383360349,
0.0438304245,
0.0136986449,
0.0067676525,
-0.062315885,
0.034893956,
0.0167977456,
-0.0412788801,
0.0588686131,
-0.0383104272,
0.0808747336,
0.0270863939,
0.0413270332,
0.0003757569,
-0.0295308735,
-0.0082689049,
0.0475776196,
-0.0404886119,
-0.0141052278,
0.039914988,
-0.0133060608,
0.0002869682,
-0.0512631796,
0.0543413088,
-0.0243030787,
0.0048228428,
0.0187186245,
0.0140804565,
-0.0147790276,
-0.0285581145,
-0.028488066,
-0.0196447186,
-0.0065606856,
-0.0208656397,
0.0030244105,
-0.0138857402,
0.0338736363,
0.015713837,
0.0156310182,
-0.0184180941,
0.0477926508,
0.040637888,
0.0399417058,
0.0581942275,
0.0352377482,
0.0052671107,
0.0467910767,
-0.0173925925,
-0.0010578082,
0.0177582093,
-0.0134524396,
0.0137540316,
0.0367621034,
0.0354039185,
0.103682369,
0.0187688991,
-0.032177411,
-0.0734212175,
0.0145983202,
0.0245636832,
0.0739006549,
0.0377997607,
0.0086111026,
-0.0415026769,
-0.0159172658,
-0.0322356522,
0.0210402384,
-0.0440572649,
-0.0469522849,
0.0372232124,
0.0121331643,
-0.048686184,
-0.0324900895,
-0.0005755556,
-0.0632707402,
-0.0235377531,
0.0266241953,
-0.0197270401,
-0.0330462344,
-0.005576198,
0.0088808443,
0.0052217366,
0.0224822015,
0.0273978226,
-0.0790292844,
-0.009232305,
0.0027400439,
0.023324687,
0.0320497155,
-0.0816128254,
-0.0025661606,
-0.0050575063,
0.0544388257,
-0.0065612039,
0.0059091235,
0.0194384754,
-0.0137044219,
0.0173474699,
0.01607408,
0.0146685094,
-0.0335593,
-0.041547332,
-0.0023256177,
0.0065891496,
0.02924788,
-0.0177374613,
0.0117720319,
-0.0202752333,
0.0342711136,
0.0367857926,
-0.0463928767,
-0.0172901209,
0.0158122815,
2.927e-7,
0.0036965588,
0.0351437703,
-0.0048517622,
0.0344413258,
-0.01274719,
0.0656664595,
0.0048062955,
0.0444936305,
-0.0035666462,
-0.0043433332,
-0.0046228063,
-0.0054946244,
0.0419812314,
0.0463439301,
-0.1011135131,
0.0031796596,
-0.0791529119,
0.0000472768,
-0.0716444701,
0.0050197067,
0.0402498096,
0.0971724167,
0.0179482475,
-0.0133075463,
-0.0060970117,
-0.0566272736,
-0.0020523821,
-0.0182791017,
-0.0262666419,
0.0328185745,
0.0374263227,
0.0103511261,
0.0378293581,
0.0068648588,
-0.0279732961,
-0.008699826,
-0.0363775603,
0.0638078973,
0.0113527821,
-0.0160238091,
-0.0068589528,
-0.0612512492,
0.0210873,
-0.0914891362,
0.0688935965,
-0.0071088499,
0.0035446275,
-0.0151741635,
0.0096733319,
-0.0620700419,
0.022624312,
-0.0596747696,
-0.0398740694,
-0.0026512481,
0.0319868363,
0.0295998435,
0.018072404,
-0.0423862413,
-0.0225185454,
-0.0111455666,
0.0142603936,
-0.0465728976,
-0.0384256989,
0.0449777283,
-0.0007073842,
-0.0337944441,
0.0392386727,
2.889588275e-34,
0.0190897658,
-0.0374025479,
0.0069999169,
0.0015353842,
0.0425885767,
0.0380507968,
-0.0052445349,
0.0198445041,
0.0438199379,
-0.0547038503,
-0.0338956043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01455v1 | TimeToM: Temporal Space is the Key to Unlocking the Door of Large Language Models' Theory-of-Mind | 2024-07-01T16:50:49 | 2024-07-01T16:50:49 | Guiyang Hou, Wenqi Zhang, Yongliang Shen, Linjuan Wu, Weiming Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Theory of Mind (ToM)-the cognitive ability to reason about mental states of
ourselves and others, is the foundation of social interaction. Although ToM
comes naturally to humans, it poses a significant challenge to even the most
advanced Large Language Models (LLMs). Due to the complex logical chains in ToM
reasoning, especially in higher-order ToM questions, simply utilizing reasoning
methods like Chain of Thought (CoT) will not improve the ToM capabilities of
LLMs. We present TimeToM, which constructs a temporal space and uses it as the
foundation to improve the ToM capabilities of LLMs in multiple scenarios.
Specifically, within the temporal space, we construct Temporal Belief State
Chain (TBSC) for each character and inspired by the cognition perspective of
the social world model, we divide TBSC into self-world beliefs and social world
beliefs, aligning with first-order ToM (first-order beliefs) and higher-order
ToM (higher-order beliefs) questions, respectively. Moreover, we design a novel
tool-belief solver that, by considering belief communication between characters
in temporal space, can transform a character's higher-order beliefs into
another character's first-order beliefs under belief communication period.
Experimental results indicate that TimeToM can dramatically improve the
reasoning performance of LLMs on ToM questions while taking a big step towards
coherent and robust ToM reasoning. | [
0.0528643318,
0.0527979471,
-0.024073787,
0.0482651703,
-0.059367083,
-0.0036835012,
0.0011799472,
-0.0113767879,
0.0643209741,
-0.0142357396,
-0.0117868688,
-0.055014994,
0.0269204807,
0.0292790644,
0.0110904798,
-0.0581429675,
0.0344384424,
-0.0266836528,
0.0099269049,
-0.0150978677,
-0.0129573066,
0.0140248733,
-0.0270752441,
0.0054593245,
0.0148145389,
-0.0295932312,
-0.0373957455,
-0.02351138,
0.0711564124,
-0.0771674514,
-0.0407852791,
0.0045913029,
0.0147454953,
0.0526127927,
0.0000021044,
-0.0496631488,
-0.0085386476,
-0.011259051,
-0.0042643552,
-0.0054468447,
-0.0246665124,
0.0619127937,
0.0265252162,
0.0184409004,
-0.0613444597,
0.0157450698,
0.0123317316,
0.0807911307,
0.0490520857,
0.056897182,
-0.014298901,
-0.0232798867,
0.0136398161,
-0.0107826265,
0.0442137606,
-0.068501845,
0.0315671302,
0.0144203817,
0.0710764825,
-0.0248899926,
0.0015010065,
0.0353858955,
0.0146998698,
0.0127990711,
-0.0217689909,
0.0221890807,
0.0042471103,
-0.0050893798,
-0.0240303501,
0.0615423694,
0.0919316038,
-0.0235252921,
-0.0090139331,
0.0290771201,
0.0071801939,
0.054446429,
-0.0017547981,
0.0245776139,
-0.0313738175,
0.0093379458,
0.025169868,
0.0398338474,
0.0054649897,
0.0086043272,
-0.0803985298,
0.1301017106,
-0.0071418732,
-0.0113834767,
-0.0339246877,
-0.0168883521,
-0.0429904796,
-0.0745381266,
-0.0082494998,
0.0556707457,
-0.0279939212,
0.0125601375,
-0.0103473235,
0.0648042634,
-0.0405970998,
-0.069973886,
0.0145491883,
0.0269059017,
0.0354847275,
0.0339616388,
0.0307743885,
0.0303751808,
-0.0160062555,
-0.0262113437,
-0.0031225034,
0.0055339723,
-0.0626575947,
-0.0088397209,
-0.0299776532,
0.0497980341,
0.0207735803,
-0.0174057521,
-0.0130571164,
0.0130242473,
-0.0157528799,
-0.0125822527,
-0.0113347368,
-0.000015111,
0.0269873701,
-0.0257866457,
-0.0610038415,
0.040655788,
-0.0201473385,
0.0038431904,
-0.0046928623,
-0.0445652716,
0.0099718068,
-0.0349793844,
0.0157638229,
-0.0053623319,
-0.0090221381,
0.0468167402,
0.0057989685,
0.0044271145,
-0.0100657139,
-0.0310318321,
-0.0227503013,
-0.0984836742,
-0.026364455,
-0.0497876443,
0.014071797,
0.01293483,
-0.0073560858,
-0.0032476091,
0.0215352215,
-0.0121927289,
-0.0554540083,
0.0762611181,
0.0113231689,
0.0217235032,
0.0063951206,
0.0222708974,
0.0404963754,
-0.0268237349,
0.0455003493,
-0.0061414842,
-0.0200504977,
0.0371450558,
0.0068127159,
0.0347752869,
0.0005115818,
-0.0379969254,
-0.0500166304,
0.0059412895,
-0.0100714285,
0.0606016479,
-0.0477123447,
0.0624557361,
-0.0202183481,
0.0062640281,
0.0418919213,
0.0326318517,
-0.000351126,
-0.0268929638,
0.037985336,
0.0169964097,
0.0469537452,
-0.0056156917,
-0.0464439951,
0.0449727923,
-0.04573505,
-0.0352009535,
-0.0313483179,
0.0334960073,
-0.020256266,
-0.0119072236,
-0.0299661737,
0.0253090747,
0.0176521372,
0.0098845437,
0.0303966366,
-0.0465492718,
-0.0086360481,
0.0336565226,
0.0118703535,
-0.0318461433,
-0.0388827175,
-0.0399598219,
0.0346094184,
0.0640574768,
0.0483698435,
-0.0271282792,
-0.041807238,
0.0070465095,
0.0034070197,
0.0408442132,
0.0457304865,
-0.0089771226,
-0.0504053906,
-0.0273294058,
0.0060086665,
0.0335106067,
-0.0178782735,
0.0413392596,
-0.002728537,
0.0144618517,
-0.0206886809,
0.008380455,
0.0614287667,
-0.0087100426,
0.002767998,
0.0202480666,
-0.0853806213,
0.0294852555,
0.0418752097,
0.0236918945,
-0.0013675969,
0.0021997467,
0.002021977,
0.0083916914,
-0.0169903096,
0.0861215219,
-0.0531631708,
-0.0387721583,
0.0674554482,
-0.0096222349,
-0.048100315,
0.0412942916,
0.0062992009,
-0.011052846,
0.0072177984,
-0.0017400492,
0.0475886352,
-0.0307045504,
0.0302597992,
-0.0113462787,
-0.0117690321,
-0.0276862513,
0.0686824545,
-0.0255421363,
-0.0412707105,
-0.0007017013,
-0.020632783,
0.036984466,
-0.0184783209,
0.029576445,
0.0261288173,
0.0247364398,
-0.0209106989,
0.0157364868,
-0.007009374,
-0.0417785905,
-0.0491909832,
-0.0827682316,
-0.0466756411,
0.0373055674,
-0.0059227906,
-0.0204697885,
0.0025462098,
-0.0110245803,
0.0246290956,
-0.0698765665,
0.0736530647,
0.0387592651,
-0.0054693455,
0.0257672071,
-0.0060360045,
-0.0210446231,
-0.0087122554,
0.0126723256,
-0.0673797801,
0.0320421495,
0.003319978,
-0.0761769712,
-0.01835021,
0.0233603436,
-0.0936207995,
0.0441595986,
-0.0153369522,
-0.0301960204,
0.0285384823,
-0.0271036439,
0.0356452204,
0.0299361683,
-0.0041433712,
0.001214736,
0.0722443163,
-0.0358263738,
-0.032996539,
0.0272453297,
0.0282273982,
0.0164288618,
-0.0215625297,
-0.036737036,
-0.0198547002,
0.0569752902,
0.0342964791,
-0.0086409207,
-0.0908049121,
0.0244845506,
0.0023778831,
-0.0232001971,
0.0064490014,
-0.032438226,
-0.0326708257,
0.0200781561,
-0.0314095132,
0.0091275228,
0.0799710602,
-0.0190438796,
0.0203692857,
-0.0028530706,
0.0428815298,
-0.0331595466,
0.0847374648,
0.0198021363,
0.020134788,
0.0331195667,
-0.0181930587,
-0.0512743071,
-0.0184822511,
0.0002585855,
-0.0162426606,
-0.0187770519,
-0.0626211837,
0.0105882045,
0.0082025407,
0.0044943127,
-0.0185375437,
-0.0093992818,
-0.0694525316,
-0.0247413702,
-0.0337683074,
-0.0184282679,
-0.0044706413,
0.0032219077,
0.0096035758,
-0.0284317397,
0.0020370155,
-0.0271224044,
-0.0247126501,
0.014157122,
0.0248129684,
0.0119870119,
0.0357728638,
-0.0249518286,
0.045163963,
0.0542728566,
0.0355164297,
0.0070185843,
-0.0030001313,
0.0078686718,
0.0182341672,
0.0431902669,
-0.0302532054,
0.033444602,
0.0679241419,
-0.0247195419,
0.0136364354,
0.1377588809,
0.0416482538,
-0.0016855432,
0.0042410675,
-0.0112923644,
0.0014777451,
0.0188485999,
0.0260929614,
-0.0758430213,
0.0014319067,
0.0079932492,
-0.0617646985,
-0.0207509734,
-0.0805028975,
-0.0311648957,
-0.0599635281,
0.0020793967,
0.0197193138,
0.0200953316,
0.0064463825,
0.0070836665,
0.0189596806,
0.0467331409,
-0.0448129773,
0.0404784754,
0.0180379208,
0.0108178006,
-0.0255554821,
-0.0150201106,
0.0289831199,
0.0639085919,
-0.0059993458,
0.0813066959,
-0.0069192066,
0.0685654432,
0.0061504361,
-0.0661587417,
-0.0026312838,
0.0798909664,
0.0009651987,
-0.0378926508,
-0.0207729042,
-0.0121508194,
0.0048145358,
-0.0373812616,
0.0308677983,
-0.01352992,
-0.0314547122,
0.0031780677,
0.1080391183,
-0.0309825167,
-0.0394318327,
-0.005124724,
0.0309249554,
-0.022430826,
0.0717331544,
-0.0068717347,
-0.0298100561,
-0.0019930177,
0.0017008338,
-0.0599494353,
0.011697853,
-0.0530425236,
-0.0142104747,
0.0360940173,
0.0089207524,
-0.0637945905,
-0.040608678,
0.0016583123,
0.0417330414,
-0.0101150917,
-0.0162264649,
0.034189228,
0.0259414297,
-0.0356264077,
-0.0221557561,
-0.0504927635,
0.029216826,
-0.0244385842,
0.047960408,
0.0059501193,
-0.0326518901,
-0.0108482605,
0.0184891708,
-0.0196387339,
-0.082549043,
0.0126838787,
-0.0053511634,
0.0276742876,
0.0038543253,
0.0070578605,
-0.0264612529,
0.0442388281,
-0.0445058607,
-0.0319332294,
0.0628985539,
0.0171034317,
0.0741058365,
0.0122220414,
0.0586903915,
-0.0020986658,
0.0059141293,
-0.0100204982,
0.0137417242,
-0.0444305018,
-0.0305303074,
0.0155674266,
0.0291025899,
0.0008912473,
0.0309216827,
0.0139621757,
-0.019210944,
-0.0026040755,
-0.0966508836,
-0.0227834303,
-0.0409383103,
0.0231340099,
0.0213891175,
0.0164708719,
-0.0216442123,
-0.1009753719,
0.0188812949,
-0.0200944431,
0.0217744708,
0.0024851905,
0.0106766168,
0.0226580054,
0.0559848733,
-0.0130173676,
0.0034330953,
-0.0229440965,
-0.0360327736,
0.0059842034,
0.0090130633,
0.1046673581,
0.0421799794,
-0.0365288332,
-0.0582731143,
-0.005443525,
-0.078158915,
-0.0885393545,
0.0502307378,
-0.0076512862,
0.0097864913,
0.0339119248,
0.0219229143,
-0.0698422343,
0.0123995841,
0.0358259901,
0.0308417138,
0.0363839231,
-0.0319348462,
-0.0007375834,
0.0026008924,
-0.012252626,
0.02461854,
0.0417690612,
0.0088038445,
0.0381880403,
0.0056738439,
-0.0296390168,
-0.0484851263,
0.0024240115,
-0.046091903,
0.0438842885,
-0.0094346162,
0.0564849935,
-0.0994917825,
-0.0234579481,
0.0386959165,
0.0324031524,
-0.0011969769,
-0.0161814317,
0.0135330958,
0.0493869185,
0.0296480618,
-0.0203384329,
-0.008520972,
0.0108383363,
0.0402442031,
-0.0313468538,
-0.0024594339,
-6.499896748e-33,
-0.0327427499,
-0.0162519384,
0.0440974943,
0.0205563698,
-0.0501906499,
-0.0251121223,
-0.0613455698,
0.0242388975,
-0.0182604939,
0.0188299753,
-0.0066974973,
0.0294133089,
-0.003323772,
0.0034614806,
-0.0081792995,
0.013623178,
0.0184991043,
-0.0071355058,
-0.0078515094,
-0.010422932,
0.0499002039,
-0.0058553284,
0.028072048,
-0.0674680173,
0.0294711255,
0.008863098,
-0.0012973214,
0.0741124079,
-0.0327401981,
-0.0203073993,
-0.0292120967,
-0.0132862385,
0.0218870733,
-0.0184495244,
0.013119583,
0.0268305838,
-0.0607976913,
-0.0567952581,
0.0452814102,
-0.0245195031,
-0.0189589337,
-0.0455155708,
-0.0273111574,
-0.005472057,
-0.0184936691,
-0.0258908626,
0.0172611624,
-0.0094929244,
0.0396192148,
0.0128557226,
-0.0442511216,
0.0136183305,
-0.0063833138,
-0.0298784543,
0.0098324381,
0.0267370716,
-0.0009423378,
-0.0623499863,
-0.0347865857,
0.0434474833,
0.0052771927,
-0.0475230739,
0.0178695377,
-0.020398939,
0.0342293456,
0.0654614419,
0.0256127063,
0.0190681964,
-0.0582545176,
0.0146797411,
0.0008691311,
0.0445023961,
0.0381640196,
0.0349691324,
-0.03349692,
-0.0210488476,
-0.0730330124,
0.0047050845,
0.0429968871,
0.0458887145,
0.0316522866,
0.0088232132,
-0.0569092184,
-0.0149885593,
-0.0135636115,
0.0003967125,
-0.030215431,
-0.0039306339,
-0.0006790389,
-0.0265432317,
-0.009290114,
-0.0434241518,
0.0586159974,
-0.0372335687,
-0.0182201844,
0.0152760576,
0.0116559304,
0.017176725,
-0.0029716943,
0.0274403822,
-0.0304953866,
0.0282230172,
-0.0256945398,
-0.0004325707,
0.0312967375,
0.0129843233,
-0.0227697548,
0.0194227416,
-0.0344661251,
-0.0158730783,
-0.0350022353,
-0.0224028118,
-0.0198699199,
-0.0324211009,
0.0421119928,
0.0000597221,
-0.0174159184,
-0.0241078436,
-0.0243048817,
-0.0429131314,
-0.0420361534,
0.051706776,
-0.0125242537,
0.0057688071,
-0.0169858914,
-0.0143349469,
-0.0458086878,
0.0029598211,
0.0471348092,
-0.0344718248,
-0.0229889899,
-0.0099272849,
2.979e-7,
-0.0324364454,
0.0565594062,
0.0144707141,
0.012551086,
0.0369777791,
0.0338198729,
-0.0111152306,
0.0132495277,
0.0155458953,
-0.0426297374,
0.0162783898,
0.0523789898,
0.0372669511,
0.0270892587,
-0.0121343033,
-0.0251902342,
0.002705035,
-0.0643412322,
-0.0155899115,
0.0272613522,
0.0716976821,
0.0166788977,
0.0857463852,
0.0032677683,
0.0007088826,
0.0147317629,
0.0376613662,
-0.0237521846,
-0.0084991166,
0.0232726373,
0.0020410577,
-0.0479153469,
0.0119576855,
-0.0079965172,
0.0557292961,
0.0183433108,
-0.0271508098,
0.0068079466,
-0.032336276,
-0.0172228646,
-0.0237705316,
-0.0382660106,
-0.0442631356,
-0.048404552,
0.058552444,
-0.0673709437,
-0.0677743405,
0.0276556239,
0.0266070254,
-0.025462633,
-0.0363182016,
0.0637147054,
-0.0191074889,
-0.0045028399,
-0.0015638244,
-0.0119938543,
0.0081074722,
-0.1019875035,
-0.0215375517,
0.0093167368,
-0.0151560549,
-0.0413969308,
-0.0053811288,
-0.027303217,
0.0216024518,
-0.0652829707,
0.0005539356,
2.688656571e-34,
0.0116439927,
-0.0117958467,
0.0076498142,
-0.0048474176,
0.0705936849,
-0.0125832362,
-0.0055096513,
0.0298926271,
0.0864901468,
-0.1192677319,
-0.0177257583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01437v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01437v1 | Needle in the Haystack for Memory Based Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T16:32:16 | 2024-07-01T16:32:16 | Subhajit Chaudhury, Soham Dan, Payel Das, Georgios Kollias, Elliot Nelson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we demonstrate the benefits of using memory augmented Large
Language Model (LLM) architecture in improving the recall abilities of facts
from a potentially long context. As a case study we test LARIMAR, a recently
proposed LLM architecture which augments a LLM decoder with an external
associative memory, on several long-context recall tasks, including passkey and
needle-in-the-haystack tests. We demonstrate that the external memory can be
adapted at test time to handle contexts much longer than those seen during
training, while keeping readouts from the memory recognizable to the trained
decoder and without increasing GPU memory footprint. Compared to alternative
architectures for long-context recall tasks with models of a comparable
parameter count, LARIMAR is able to maintain strong performance without any
task-specific training. | [
0.0133804986,
0.0307766329,
0.0032053767,
0.0372069925,
-0.0212484468,
0.029263109,
0.0105408505,
-0.0299796965,
0.0076038451,
-0.0639222488,
-0.0025336675,
-0.0550035462,
0.0134744989,
0.0156048825,
0.0120235002,
-0.0236793552,
0.0481200777,
-0.0705223456,
0.0083491979,
-0.0044109309,
-0.0342696123,
-0.0105493721,
-0.0136173517,
-0.0153445713,
-0.0008506522,
-0.040392559,
-0.026532026,
-0.0220473204,
0.0026495089,
-0.0414676927,
-0.0268659163,
0.0015337574,
0.0249283332,
-0.0035555745,
0.0000021108,
-0.0480931774,
0.0133589283,
-0.0222171191,
-0.0569327101,
0.0452444255,
0.0226944312,
0.0080374051,
-0.0241277013,
-0.0024322486,
-0.0094984109,
-0.0693441033,
0.0361332186,
0.0408391654,
0.0131769273,
0.0565212369,
-0.0024034178,
-0.0704898015,
0.0566592477,
-0.0442858003,
0.037333414,
-0.0435536541,
0.0330500789,
-0.0118909068,
-0.0111108422,
0.0048320019,
-0.0369697548,
0.0435555093,
0.0275890753,
0.0335442908,
0.015764527,
0.0712025017,
0.0005081207,
0.0145659,
-0.019771995,
0.0135611957,
0.0065782382,
-0.0278258249,
-0.0070457496,
0.0130561087,
-0.002269448,
-0.0208166875,
-0.0378102362,
0.0527965985,
-0.0370775498,
-0.0089641297,
0.0526584983,
-0.0202371273,
0.0340646319,
0.0270004589,
-0.0614453256,
-0.0057131206,
0.0359926932,
-0.0232855771,
-0.0035547949,
0.0056311623,
0.014799499,
-0.0276367515,
0.0198686346,
0.0439293906,
-0.0044593294,
0.0312028117,
-0.0354450159,
-0.0317875817,
0.0179957617,
-0.078344062,
-0.0043019122,
0.0558922067,
-0.0428196974,
0.0566700362,
-0.0912230089,
0.0813722759,
-0.0270522013,
0.0057769855,
-0.0305879097,
-0.0087009203,
-0.0201116353,
0.0068601794,
-0.0053069037,
0.0457966849,
-0.004320052,
-0.0327851027,
-0.0268869139,
0.028789036,
0.0167918876,
0.0216293279,
-0.0039339736,
-0.0024172463,
-0.0307568796,
0.001138343,
0.0022785601,
0.0462706126,
-0.0085044093,
-0.0170862582,
0.0135653075,
-0.0488444865,
-0.0200660713,
0.005195024,
0.0219461452,
-0.0297092255,
0.0297888052,
0.0493556261,
-0.0286481883,
-0.0754719824,
-0.0722790137,
0.0061539384,
-0.0122328876,
-0.0516242236,
0.0163500495,
-0.0529742539,
0.0276220553,
0.0279944651,
0.011211032,
-0.003333922,
0.0133201042,
0.0389833339,
-0.0291396864,
0.0429999605,
0.047918506,
-0.036606513,
0.0679832548,
0.0244822893,
0.0496408753,
0.0588592924,
0.0110036694,
0.0461033508,
-0.0080055054,
-0.0033337022,
-0.0054413965,
0.0215599053,
0.0184819419,
-0.006576872,
-0.0167758614,
0.0220662653,
0.076273784,
0.0342651084,
0.0480928868,
0.0516635813,
-0.0286172125,
-0.0383628607,
0.0498792529,
0.0443060175,
0.0134089682,
-0.0231123902,
-0.0029930361,
-0.0338162594,
0.0132367574,
-0.0136321727,
-0.0472976603,
0.0333893746,
-0.0193426758,
0.0551465824,
0.0303034671,
0.0441376716,
-0.0307608601,
0.0068497253,
-0.0122046033,
-0.0216991901,
0.0045128926,
0.0372475237,
0.0659176558,
-0.0153878201,
-0.0653112382,
0.0585255288,
0.0097764144,
-0.0160706192,
-0.0000967945,
-0.0564621799,
0.0418513343,
0.0586198047,
0.0438948311,
-0.0074257036,
-0.026418779,
0.0035509632,
0.0069766133,
0.0226497967,
0.0037749892,
0.0075589549,
0.0019227723,
-0.0584832728,
0.0247146375,
-0.0104960585,
0.0102200229,
0.0326671489,
0.0542089827,
0.0319799855,
0.0048608016,
0.0261617191,
0.0171792991,
0.0092484979,
-0.0164794903,
-0.0540481955,
-0.0258268956,
-0.0054520923,
-0.0014888705,
0.0073859305,
-0.0070008677,
0.0098885009,
0.0705091208,
-0.0506852083,
0.027995605,
-0.0213270932,
-0.1029532403,
-0.0251576416,
0.0300652962,
0.0375903808,
0.0225942284,
-0.0061867931,
-0.0005170449,
-0.0534948446,
0.004074763,
-0.0476789884,
0.096455127,
-0.0256941672,
0.0288314167,
0.0400309674,
0.004083314,
-0.0286718849,
0.0828393027,
-0.0445377454,
-0.0053220782,
-0.0054026614,
0.0672757402,
-0.0177966356,
-0.0465262383,
-0.0201330483,
0.0475589857,
0.0261895377,
0.002922842,
-0.0221523196,
-0.0445894822,
-0.0545284525,
-0.0263789985,
-0.0871337429,
0.0237627979,
-0.0183284823,
-0.0037168574,
0.0061611766,
-0.0053761126,
-0.0033925541,
-0.0050747613,
-0.0033499927,
0.0034611733,
-0.0140494732,
0.0342193581,
-0.035379298,
0.0198028889,
-0.0197059382,
0.015394642,
-0.0219330508,
0.0114338351,
0.0757120773,
-0.006533484,
-0.0418402255,
-0.0625984445,
0.0648306608,
0.0115474556,
0.022269804,
-0.026427947,
-0.0095090317,
0.007703417,
-0.0233121626,
0.082902573,
0.122096464,
0.0167026669,
-0.0021730023,
0.04998108,
-0.0369938426,
-0.0099786595,
0.0061316197,
0.0169168729,
-0.0566154532,
-0.008282546,
-0.0040501105,
-0.047147356,
0.0522876456,
-0.0031087238,
0.0281700101,
-0.007621903,
-0.0226980243,
-0.0137765137,
-0.0331160277,
-0.0397043973,
-0.0353935175,
-0.0403660573,
-0.0060544438,
-0.0219156127,
-0.0425924845,
0.0334989615,
-0.0573459864,
0.0109082423,
-0.0229383316,
0.0063604806,
-0.0129648009,
0.0919815674,
-0.0056558237,
0.0055818846,
-0.0460771658,
-0.0495053977,
0.0242490862,
-0.0106565729,
-0.043061737,
-0.0573708117,
0.0779511705,
-0.0501653552,
0.0306570958,
-0.0269393884,
-0.0157141555,
-0.0485277399,
0.0384562649,
-0.0362246856,
-0.0136812329,
0.0028858851,
-0.0063466243,
-0.0146398814,
0.0209549554,
0.0443701744,
0.0677851364,
-0.0021584341,
0.0079819458,
-0.0028285536,
0.0138390912,
0.035305053,
0.0202582832,
0.0015949985,
-0.0245369021,
0.0135441516,
0.0525798872,
0.0484034121,
-0.0451357923,
-0.0426429175,
-0.003522024,
0.0137462104,
-0.0005177884,
0.004411736,
0.0403219536,
0.0071526677,
-0.1087217331,
-0.0273278281,
0.069380343,
0.025598133,
-0.0740844682,
-0.0397047475,
-0.010591073,
0.0226531643,
0.0060126842,
0.0163126979,
-0.0680406988,
-0.0360502787,
0.0175071023,
-0.0126389135,
-0.0000712438,
0.0035776584,
-0.0136958361,
-0.1150131598,
0.0151871275,
0.0298962593,
-0.0329780318,
-0.0702802539,
-0.0573493093,
-0.0473583154,
0.0096423309,
0.0329263769,
0.0352306403,
-0.0132065993,
-0.0369705558,
0.0035312546,
0.0041022338,
-0.0110032866,
0.0460307039,
-0.0235140957,
0.0496245101,
0.0430447459,
-0.0151408901,
0.0176327601,
-0.010268772,
0.0136195384,
-0.0248785783,
0.0221848283,
-0.0168786868,
0.0441338494,
-0.0339915864,
-0.0191699676,
-0.0264796,
0.0133159887,
-0.0170822479,
-0.0343307555,
0.003125642,
0.0698536634,
-0.0267831925,
0.0062656798,
0.0185531061,
-0.0311910156,
-0.0270539131,
0.0937777311,
0.0129453903,
-0.0043938286,
-0.0328637771,
-0.0198487509,
-0.0091373734,
-0.0265472289,
-0.0008115577,
0.018230442,
-0.0039095171,
-0.0345534757,
-0.0248928126,
-0.0275002066,
0.0212261714,
0.0358237885,
-0.0071067205,
0.0387495272,
0.0182887372,
-0.0038492517,
-0.0895544663,
0.0241236929,
-0.0700896904,
-0.0043105399,
-0.0552758947,
-0.0103910565,
0.0477330461,
-0.0247868318,
0.0233537816,
0.0792441443,
-0.1005246937,
-0.0399291143,
0.0378324538,
0.0148205422,
0.0217940938,
0.076119341,
0.0191997141,
-0.0309621822,
0.0383944139,
-0.005288871,
-0.0489528179,
0.0760935768,
-0.0092699816,
0.0141298305,
0.001332521,
-0.0061660586,
-0.0296550579,
-0.0101849614,
0.0199324619,
0.0191777088,
-0.0106564099,
-0.0020281251,
-0.0005418608,
0.0017157074,
0.0116518624,
0.0034645214,
-0.0041185725,
-0.0049545425,
0.0483625978,
-0.0174140036,
0.0392955616,
0.02572814,
0.0006770029,
0.0342347659,
0.0103717828,
0.0027085973,
-0.0229819603,
0.0597121231,
0.0152909718,
-0.0163395554,
-0.0055783959,
-0.0164765995,
-0.0260483176,
0.0258469917,
-0.0000330334,
-0.0572704896,
-0.0031322218,
-0.0049067703,
0.0446876325,
-0.0356156789,
0.0753879324,
-0.0022841359,
-0.0337433107,
-0.0324750803,
-0.0079164915,
-0.0308847949,
-0.0251338109,
0.0045610308,
0.0132542793,
0.0486857891,
-0.0320456997,
0.0128609808,
-0.0231366083,
-0.0025534488,
-0.0353874676,
-0.0139131183,
0.0059808926,
-0.0261106528,
0.0156773161,
0.0326043889,
0.0024296977,
0.0066464953,
0.0415405408,
0.0060417387,
0.0511656068,
0.0153533984,
0.0103135752,
-0.0143938363,
-0.0394616611,
-0.0018735606,
0.0103557268,
-0.0319482274,
-0.0377785079,
-0.0275832471,
-0.0526825376,
0.022350654,
-0.0218349807,
0.0252365638,
-0.0238564704,
-0.0043768743,
0.0553313904,
-0.0052233515,
-0.0471136197,
-0.0024596564,
0.0599303208,
0.0015697656,
0.0104948813,
-0.0210373364,
-6.627274785e-33,
-0.0512646139,
-0.0108436709,
0.0636613369,
-0.0604561344,
-0.0043733753,
0.0391384177,
-0.0196377859,
-0.0030055973,
-0.0270338804,
-0.0242553111,
-0.0089982171,
0.0106120706,
0.0211543404,
0.0185633376,
-0.0036515072,
-0.0303209107,
0.0420648567,
0.0027477264,
0.0026840901,
0.0487292893,
0.0524694324,
0.0484654047,
0.0246420149,
-0.0295274314,
-0.0131776966,
-0.0033967979,
0.0384340659,
-0.0052131233,
-0.0075680674,
0.0460332744,
-0.0435228571,
0.0173858255,
0.0367564149,
-0.0542651117,
-0.0172578562,
0.0358276963,
-0.1175175607,
0.015561454,
0.0444231592,
0.0168581586,
0.0311710238,
-0.0576258376,
0.021874018,
0.0240565222,
-0.0095999539,
-0.0224688351,
-0.0150288353,
-0.0301077086,
-0.0786514804,
-0.0160232745,
-0.0230773259,
0.0040331902,
0.0348829366,
0.0203383919,
0.0235805418,
-0.0532840081,
-0.0114951469,
0.0376083218,
-0.0759558305,
0.002812579,
0.0101870103,
0.0628075078,
0.0625377595,
0.0581693798,
0.0098816697,
0.0809702575,
0.0420739688,
-0.0124260532,
-0.0375474319,
-0.005638388,
0.0242806897,
-0.0002847244,
0.0130933411,
0.0086390199,
0.0575707853,
-0.0429034196,
-0.0622458979,
-0.048481483,
0.0200781412,
0.0423572473,
0.0741872042,
0.0349819362,
-0.0510125756,
-0.0202552397,
-0.0232408382,
0.0962971225,
-0.047881376,
0.0028085082,
0.0609224811,
0.0401115604,
0.004547813,
-0.0007025889,
0.0614410713,
-0.0006041775,
0.0498234183,
0.0443833508,
0.0244534258,
0.0247660652,
-0.0477593802,
0.0276069939,
-0.0486391857,
-0.0360079035,
0.0185064487,
-0.0208524559,
-0.0097450335,
-0.0029890302,
0.001284251,
-0.0005605042,
-0.0945565179,
-0.0182236582,
-0.0430284068,
0.0032110391,
0.0151716629,
0.0027353663,
0.0416616835,
0.0213939846,
0.0016320586,
0.0843285173,
-0.0194933061,
-0.0070083397,
-0.0165915508,
-0.0428521708,
-0.0088793468,
0.0196258705,
-0.0079774968,
0.0208083075,
-0.0106847296,
0.0114667993,
0.0238676816,
-0.0596482679,
0.0142636206,
0.0230542663,
2.79e-7,
-0.0197204314,
0.0525316447,
0.0201307815,
-0.0056885364,
0.000285092,
-0.009466866,
0.0150614455,
0.0153871132,
0.0389504246,
-0.0438637659,
-0.0405821651,
0.0694615617,
0.0029086182,
-0.0072874664,
-0.082737349,
0.0099010039,
-0.0168127567,
0.0169228185,
-0.0494809225,
0.0025990386,
0.0286219399,
0.1106893867,
-0.0124822864,
0.0020412218,
0.0319884568,
-0.0483928099,
0.0545513928,
-0.028176846,
-0.0431359522,
-0.0083909044,
0.0199575033,
0.0281044599,
-0.0325493105,
0.0574343167,
0.0049128872,
-0.0223057978,
-0.0305470005,
0.0588003248,
0.0172492564,
-0.0499048941,
0.0077356505,
-0.0021362242,
-0.0332108997,
-0.0095264073,
0.0516314209,
-0.0369195603,
-0.0178408977,
-0.0344302617,
-0.0211315863,
0.0028430277,
-0.0374754146,
0.0074130469,
0.0388172679,
0.0052711745,
-0.0061976812,
-0.0115464451,
0.0151575282,
-0.0951633751,
-0.0199722275,
0.0455641448,
-0.0405575521,
-0.0514731146,
-0.058786381,
-0.0189617127,
0.0354444534,
-0.0974096432,
-0.0144256148,
2.493030204e-34,
0.0376566462,
-0.0088602779,
-0.0175835807,
0.0528597496,
0.0297705568,
-0.0415557772,
-0.019862432,
0.025797179,
0.0032145015,
-0.1100785807,
-0.0173770338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01424v1 | A Global-Local Attention Mechanism for Relation Classification | 2024-07-01T16:14:25 | 2024-07-01T16:14:25 | Yiping Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Relation classification, a crucial component of relation extraction, involves
identifying connections between two entities. Previous studies have
predominantly focused on integrating the attention mechanism into relation
classification at a global scale, overlooking the importance of the local
context. To address this gap, this paper introduces a novel global-local
attention mechanism for relation classification, which enhances global
attention with a localized focus. Additionally, we propose innovative hard and
soft localization mechanisms to identify potential keywords for local
attention. By incorporating both hard and soft localization strategies, our
approach offers a more nuanced and comprehensive understanding of the
contextual cues that contribute to effective relation classification. Our
experimental results on the SemEval-2010 Task 8 dataset highlight the superior
performance of our method compared to previous attention-based approaches in
relation classification. | [
0.0525465421,
0.0083852392,
-0.0056644538,
0.070257917,
0.0063480064,
0.0090085948,
-0.0001569232,
-0.0026386995,
0.020518003,
-0.0162950978,
-0.0266838148,
-0.0512041599,
-0.0043191346,
-0.0035703534,
0.0372983515,
-0.0583301857,
0.0558386184,
0.0531948842,
0.0297994949,
0.0252717752,
-0.006718189,
-0.0040048962,
0.0163715128,
0.0085637979,
-0.0120693762,
-0.016108647,
0.0180140417,
0.0166902039,
0.058359798,
-0.049835138,
0.0237267315,
0.066733852,
-0.018674178,
-0.0278238468,
0.0000016468,
-0.0570428185,
-0.0006477764,
-0.0288945027,
0.0088489018,
-0.0438666381,
-0.0476494692,
-0.0393160693,
0.0616257191,
-0.0253203604,
-0.0395079069,
-0.0613285452,
0.0275712088,
0.0639007688,
0.0031325237,
0.0467279553,
-0.0307891835,
-0.0363857336,
0.0022743035,
-0.0662332624,
0.0375173576,
-0.0494318306,
0.0139192147,
-0.0092098899,
-0.0113210278,
0.0118009038,
-0.02911238,
0.0253202263,
0.0003551612,
0.0150789591,
0.0839693472,
0.0737935305,
-0.0572769344,
-0.0112004466,
0.0136205023,
0.1196865216,
-0.0122495536,
-0.006408182,
-0.0070306612,
0.0184446052,
0.0109686237,
0.0145313172,
0.0099252053,
-0.0119324299,
-0.0536819845,
0.0127803385,
0.0147349387,
0.0153807625,
0.0265203379,
0.0083854124,
-0.0087455912,
0.0298533607,
-0.0179337673,
-0.0502304249,
0.0410811752,
0.0359205715,
-0.0446109064,
-0.0309041291,
0.0726470202,
0.0485520884,
0.0032641101,
0.0035379329,
-0.0362880118,
0.0168092046,
0.0066328957,
-0.0784856826,
-0.0292625483,
-0.0119835101,
-0.0291056391,
0.1004182696,
-0.0333456285,
0.0367446952,
-0.0383798704,
-0.0205187313,
-0.0034549988,
-0.0217440166,
-0.0032895978,
0.0195197221,
-0.0268734396,
0.0299883951,
-0.0423594005,
-0.024067482,
-0.0115135442,
-0.001879509,
-0.0223567002,
-0.011447872,
-0.0136998566,
0.0259818267,
-0.0291455295,
0.0181949865,
-0.001502782,
0.0079587232,
-0.0803677663,
-0.0050060977,
-0.0406003185,
0.0013159242,
-0.0334106758,
0.0029838602,
0.071748957,
-0.038259048,
-0.0086977016,
0.0518450551,
0.015802661,
-0.0435410291,
0.0196792539,
-0.0289353989,
0.0074220132,
-0.0401539952,
0.0162063185,
0.0015108903,
0.0243686307,
0.0225919262,
-0.0336249806,
-0.0063729123,
0.0535634533,
0.0002105122,
-0.0540295839,
0.0540843047,
0.0067236139,
-0.0136031592,
-0.0280964356,
0.0112504587,
0.0489377677,
0.0514089167,
-0.0103495046,
0.0287292413,
0.0363565609,
0.0199636687,
-0.018070871,
-0.0056044641,
0.0469136834,
-0.0058241594,
-0.0053999531,
0.0353640802,
0.001262442,
-0.0029528667,
0.0419619232,
-0.0021538343,
-0.0201475583,
-0.0303236358,
0.044780083,
0.013918085,
0.0210162792,
0.0727135167,
0.027827153,
0.0004335035,
-0.0333928913,
0.0014371915,
-0.0890196338,
0.0372881293,
0.0195472706,
0.0111023551,
0.008532444,
0.0363706574,
-0.0103564253,
0.0229176227,
0.0083353091,
0.0148328729,
-0.0388504788,
0.0171459299,
0.0654628128,
0.0351740569,
-0.0007172412,
0.0734204873,
0.0551395603,
0.0019179384,
-0.0028124184,
0.0220475756,
0.0029574486,
-0.0137421647,
0.0060965572,
-0.0447684079,
-0.0734412968,
-0.0280720964,
0.0003515628,
0.0490329154,
0.0056460295,
0.0073870108,
0.0166232735,
-0.0140160583,
-0.058796376,
0.0105789751,
-0.0143616293,
-0.0192907713,
0.0835709572,
0.0402006693,
0.0215303507,
-0.0325457044,
0.054668013,
0.0244657081,
0.0513022654,
-0.0328824371,
0.0014955514,
0.0468450934,
0.0050623282,
0.0141153708,
0.0182116013,
-0.0290731527,
0.0558058061,
-0.0484690629,
0.0247319899,
-0.0049008401,
-0.0487987287,
-0.030161215,
0.0298180003,
-0.0098115122,
-0.038374152,
-0.0329390988,
0.0031297915,
0.0080099739,
-0.001666751,
-0.0063589048,
0.044584021,
0.0004511264,
-0.0287125129,
0.0178847127,
0.0586967804,
-0.041527506,
0.1166864038,
-0.0227222536,
0.0154857617,
0.0322816707,
-0.0352011211,
-0.003989826,
-0.0119641135,
0.0111254212,
0.0055193151,
0.0040842136,
-0.0371233858,
-0.0048372992,
0.0264446549,
-0.0687122196,
-0.0012023237,
-0.0503381491,
0.0150777642,
0.0030134614,
0.0322299711,
0.0154683907,
0.0061246254,
-0.0072371741,
-0.0394885689,
-0.0313418843,
-0.0025427614,
-0.049910713,
-0.0083467253,
0.043121241,
0.0081661297,
-0.0068538967,
-0.0174221192,
-0.0095052011,
-0.0000548963,
0.0619381107,
0.0132595645,
-0.0440777764,
-0.038274698,
0.0058241845,
-0.0467334874,
0.027381748,
0.0079121636,
-0.0019210705,
-0.0340936407,
0.0001219731,
0.0200500712,
0.0478590056,
-0.0178015679,
0.0348928981,
-0.018832624,
-0.0125029199,
-0.0236525591,
0.0589824654,
-0.0124155069,
0.0578106008,
-0.0015223533,
0.0041250479,
-0.0450781062,
0.0751550347,
-0.01644486,
0.0006477201,
-0.0066285506,
0.0137977544,
0.0250086766,
0.0100595141,
-0.0345431753,
0.0586600453,
-0.004725459,
-0.0232897308,
-0.0946271271,
-0.0286995638,
0.0868071839,
0.0146356001,
-0.0151217328,
-0.0213899184,
0.0010929535,
-0.0346192978,
0.0796308368,
-0.0197351277,
0.0234734043,
0.00456477,
-0.0502562225,
-0.0199928414,
-0.0198493768,
-0.0034699333,
0.0017721334,
0.0496752709,
0.001839863,
-0.0053630956,
-0.0285357852,
-0.0231014583,
-0.0474552736,
-0.0149323791,
-0.0157867596,
0.0095079495,
-0.003556815,
-0.0028741322,
0.0042766747,
0.0397547036,
0.0248834118,
0.0127681047,
-0.0273717064,
-0.0002711701,
-0.009069046,
0.0769173801,
0.0447576679,
0.0175876636,
-0.0079957293,
0.0086718602,
-0.012721763,
0.0283701252,
0.0051634042,
-0.0189385302,
0.0146533782,
-0.0151351122,
0.0212586541,
-0.0392281152,
-0.0246279128,
-0.0428094193,
0.0408255011,
-0.0731987804,
-0.0535950661,
0.0717847645,
0.0113944411,
-0.089975372,
-0.0054884669,
0.0210829247,
-0.0018675363,
0.0625342131,
0.013220177,
-0.0343314037,
-0.0435401388,
-0.0117440745,
-0.0586547554,
0.0464827195,
-0.0233109649,
0.005460348,
-0.0473368205,
-0.0123164142,
-0.0069951368,
-0.108555451,
-0.0665992871,
-0.0316379145,
0.0315812901,
0.0265443642,
0.0004480059,
-0.0100280792,
-0.0283444766,
0.0002333271,
-0.0122265229,
0.0345915593,
-0.0270341802,
0.0206377674,
-0.052980341,
0.0185932238,
0.0210898295,
0.0520843081,
0.0075576575,
-0.0033006126,
0.007688534,
0.0003207053,
-0.0110518914,
-0.0431827828,
0.0583004765,
-0.0394108184,
-0.0182138849,
-0.0374809206,
-0.0433379374,
-0.067942977,
0.0135116447,
-0.0035381517,
0.0786558986,
0.0075653805,
-0.0163464453,
-0.0132853249,
0.0040114988,
0.0025074994,
0.0089407489,
0.0408167467,
-0.0097772041,
-0.0417834893,
0.0142550068,
0.0215365514,
-0.0239973888,
-0.0128568634,
-0.011945528,
-0.0511075966,
-0.0225498211,
-0.01901244,
-0.0768603981,
0.0413616002,
0.0202226974,
-0.0040449249,
-0.0013580936,
0.0340739675,
-0.0027816063,
-0.067060262,
0.0398109332,
-0.0392385013,
0.0112724351,
0.0400990285,
-0.0076240883,
0.0263676811,
-0.0382950418,
-0.0209529456,
-0.0141952708,
-0.0664004833,
-0.0071149934,
-0.0265234597,
0.003080833,
0.0126905525,
0.0369877554,
-0.0419695638,
-0.0064738635,
0.0169114843,
0.000314511,
-0.0407990888,
0.0221280735,
0.0200722367,
-0.0377489328,
0.0185903851,
0.0543084815,
-0.0182430521,
0.0042685466,
0.046935387,
0.0301640611,
-0.0368480869,
-0.0306766368,
-0.0121166566,
-0.0456849001,
0.0787831545,
0.019349847,
-0.0432567224,
-0.0169067066,
0.0332110226,
0.0085829562,
-0.0132089891,
-0.0348943211,
0.00098317,
0.0089763468,
0.0337574445,
0.0091267433,
-0.0121470625,
-0.0041345884,
-0.0063737109,
-0.0166579373,
-0.0114812655,
0.0283327904,
-0.0073790611,
0.0195266698,
0.026768988,
-0.0475578718,
0.0148837445,
0.0153852524,
0.0297940262,
-0.0135154435,
0.0416047424,
0.0078693395,
-0.0183881763,
-0.0340526141,
-0.0011010603,
-0.036369808,
0.0701258779,
-0.0281116534,
0.0174292922,
0.1001932472,
-0.0339532793,
0.0279785879,
0.0380932279,
-0.0120455334,
0.0389241576,
0.0397045128,
-0.0595704801,
-0.0415932648,
-0.0017979244,
0.002758811,
-0.0271212216,
0.0258906297,
0.0671592802,
-0.0341223925,
0.0111357747,
0.0423299335,
-0.0365156196,
-0.0235471502,
0.0124601135,
0.0095694242,
0.0178487003,
-0.0114880642,
0.0578102432,
-0.0463838466,
-0.0719440132,
0.0111361519,
-0.0719503984,
-0.0505606122,
0.0007348686,
0.0251609888,
0.0256624222,
0.0384972803,
-0.0770225674,
-0.0282300506,
0.0387879349,
-0.0261609424,
0.006030418,
-0.0320436843,
-6.367714612e-33,
-0.0633964166,
-0.0694185346,
-0.0194632541,
-0.006965566,
-0.0766299739,
0.0695982277,
-0.0349253044,
-0.0167539418,
-0.0375438109,
0.0498556308,
-0.0127153229,
0.0463627353,
0.0040470269,
-0.0054951911,
-0.0170603767,
-0.0761892051,
0.0036666365,
0.0428846329,
0.023969477,
0.0428757109,
0.0075537809,
0.0559674501,
0.101842396,
-0.0742486492,
0.0383579247,
0.0055455207,
0.0076286034,
0.0202353522,
0.0004023037,
0.0502794757,
-0.0382978469,
0.0393948816,
0.0432133675,
-0.0403555706,
0.0190466456,
0.0044872034,
-0.125707984,
-0.0396528281,
-0.0297281649,
-0.0107151279,
-0.0225351993,
-0.0285054073,
0.0482032783,
0.0385738835,
0.0772918016,
-0.0512930416,
0.0595578738,
-0.0267702676,
-0.0646573603,
-0.0484975614,
-0.0396140665,
0.0176800787,
0.049221918,
0.0046977149,
-0.0101342527,
-0.0167721901,
0.0095906947,
-0.0195827316,
-0.0139987348,
-0.0356986113,
0.0126521969,
0.0151552297,
-0.0084047234,
0.0234368909,
-0.0119538801,
0.0424304046,
-0.0173202232,
0.0060171704,
-0.0170806628,
-0.0152812302,
0.0070710788,
0.029873047,
-0.012133548,
0.0237303339,
0.0247820783,
0.0363541208,
-0.090638198,
-0.0468588024,
0.0361017846,
0.0551154427,
-0.0231470279,
-0.0148055283,
0.0006810722,
-0.0069113346,
0.0153232906,
-0.0016791812,
-0.0417745076,
-0.0273437183,
-0.0058579892,
0.023980435,
-0.0156834349,
0.0823957175,
-0.0156566296,
-0.0145489341,
0.0203625765,
0.0335370265,
0.057080403,
-0.0167193469,
0.0345954672,
-0.0324807689,
-0.0562235564,
-0.0072642802,
-0.0311113466,
-0.0239923093,
0.0052095107,
0.0424843505,
0.0321391299,
-0.0406970456,
-0.0517360754,
-0.0383574329,
-0.0316090956,
-0.0151715754,
-0.0488463603,
0.0323747471,
0.0250147954,
0.0074864067,
-0.0045706215,
0.0932918042,
0.0793068111,
0.038918063,
-0.0303563979,
0.0459087081,
0.0109419171,
0.07304997,
0.024005739,
-0.0185577367,
-0.0532415174,
0.0294916201,
0.0047477675,
-0.0598269738,
-0.0282773618,
-0.0345074087,
2.484e-7,
0.0257427059,
0.0422086865,
0.0364861749,
0.0429367125,
0.0100105088,
0.0302510653,
0.0529312901,
0.0587896034,
0.0124266827,
-0.0065721204,
0.0085479766,
0.0279466864,
-0.0196620822,
0.0301098712,
-0.0860092491,
-0.0106234541,
-0.0629756749,
-0.0434789173,
-0.0184139311,
-0.0362340175,
0.0200688131,
0.0718992576,
0.025051875,
0.0344658457,
-0.0155902226,
-0.0669318736,
0.040693935,
-0.0389375761,
0.0022496812,
0.0104185268,
-0.0255425591,
-0.006400859,
-0.0320346504,
0.0625467822,
-0.0047712568,
0.0348296352,
0.0237294324,
0.0427834764,
-0.0556719005,
-0.0268334411,
-0.0286590047,
-0.0076624933,
0.016418308,
-0.0443686768,
0.0518275984,
-0.0588482767,
0.0022934314,
0.0190756582,
0.0080216229,
0.0201449413,
-0.0005628661,
0.0355678611,
-0.0022871874,
-0.0118525084,
0.0118322922,
0.0046792855,
-0.0384824835,
-0.1017495766,
-0.027654754,
0.0494958125,
0.0133164423,
0.0040267059,
-0.010805252,
-0.0623407401,
0.0140289096,
0.0068016616,
-0.0013384145,
1.861264554e-34,
-0.0338249952,
0.0095924381,
0.0020052132,
0.0470093898,
0.0246460754,
-0.0727771372,
-0.0830483511,
-0.0313232951,
0.0473575369,
-0.0251433458,
0.0250252578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01411v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01411v2 | HyperLoader: Integrating Hypernetwork-Based LoRA and Adapter Layers into Multi-Task Transformers for Sequence Labelling | 2024-07-01T16:00:53 | 2024-07-02T06:21:41 | Jesus-German Ortiz-Barajas, Helena Gomez-Adorno, Thamar Solorio | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present HyperLoader, a simple approach that combines different
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods in a multi-task setting. To achieve
this goal, our model uses a hypernetwork to generate the weights of these
modules based on the task, the transformer layer, and its position within this
layer. Our method combines the benefits of multi-task learning by capturing the
structure of all tasks while reducing the task interference problem by
encapsulating the task-specific knowledge in the generated weights and the
benefits of combining different parameter-efficient methods to outperform
full-fine tuning. We provide empirical evidence that HyperLoader outperforms
previous approaches in most datasets and obtains the best average performance
across tasks in high-resource and low-resource scenarios. | [
0.0286414064,
0.0203712899,
0.0032116447,
-0.0262140948,
-0.0085183755,
0.0645648539,
0.0677750856,
-0.0260564834,
0.005468817,
-0.0079616737,
-0.0573952496,
-0.0231877584,
0.0066778674,
-0.0022408506,
0.0329621993,
0.0210594814,
0.0174404494,
0.0133044859,
0.0125761572,
0.0262709707,
-0.0257286076,
0.0056214598,
0.0084129013,
0.0347582586,
-0.0046368311,
-0.0044305543,
-0.0127839241,
-0.008330022,
0.081691809,
-0.0359295048,
0.0380200446,
0.0436105728,
0.0061072828,
0.0708692521,
0.0000017856,
0.003672079,
-0.0390569866,
-0.0180901866,
-0.0280978959,
0.0028587324,
0.0157179721,
0.0127319405,
-0.0088806115,
-0.0016524609,
-0.0126769803,
-0.0180418845,
0.0743228719,
0.0607561916,
0.0427894741,
0.0490584522,
-0.0195945092,
-0.0035465506,
0.0192439612,
-0.0467158966,
0.0095000314,
-0.027032923,
0.0227624159,
0.0299845953,
-0.0027949482,
-0.0430755615,
0.0057172268,
0.0483615696,
0.0199296866,
-0.0051825708,
-0.0303601921,
0.0143487724,
-0.0482747145,
-0.0486495681,
-0.0222150683,
0.0785174221,
-0.1058218852,
0.0098280665,
0.0200222693,
-0.0128364051,
-0.0165273622,
-0.027732715,
-0.0195352063,
0.0135219153,
-0.0122821182,
0.0016286094,
0.0136563126,
0.0051431293,
0.0295314379,
-0.0097466009,
-0.0129605895,
0.0511453077,
0.0035928662,
0.0136213591,
-0.0191548374,
0.0149594015,
-0.0208777227,
-0.0286646225,
0.0522677787,
0.0277419481,
-0.0252057668,
-0.0038826545,
-0.0398480557,
-0.0962006748,
0.0228028838,
-0.0118639367,
0.0759000853,
0.0229908582,
-0.0345096588,
0.0036767847,
-0.0443191379,
0.0176271033,
-0.0399099216,
0.0144993439,
-0.0103976736,
-0.0310523473,
-0.0579845496,
0.0193358604,
-0.0292690322,
0.039669916,
-0.0237495806,
-0.0050514126,
-0.0506348684,
0.009627427,
0.0141134486,
-0.0201036893,
0.049019672,
-0.0293853078,
-0.0537263528,
0.0127817858,
0.0280281324,
0.0384411439,
0.0022245541,
0.0397095755,
0.004352212,
-0.0342518017,
-0.0327002183,
0.0357035398,
0.0075631011,
-0.0260556061,
0.0183262024,
0.0813992769,
0.0065717557,
-0.0520789213,
-0.017392369,
-0.0279035382,
-0.027851915,
-0.0404381715,
0.0021407742,
-0.0282159671,
0.0004712848,
-0.0185573883,
0.001307354,
0.0441340171,
0.0059798174,
-0.0236823186,
-0.0032867799,
0.0771971494,
0.0096916277,
-0.0793535337,
0.03235396,
-0.001980515,
-0.0183450915,
0.0173906963,
0.0483908802,
0.0546093211,
-0.0041218656,
-0.0111955972,
0.0077647613,
0.0564494804,
-0.0213584416,
-0.0632036328,
0.0162296221,
-0.0156470854,
0.0450251289,
-0.011228513,
0.0135999015,
-0.0149614047,
-0.0359506868,
0.01728932,
0.0497825183,
0.0190983955,
0.0417304896,
-0.0308840722,
0.0196755324,
-0.0055131181,
-0.0275307037,
-0.0081657618,
-0.0016001246,
0.0905650109,
0.0247695539,
0.0175520517,
0.0113472072,
0.0531718545,
-0.0161253605,
-0.0343724787,
0.0085699009,
-0.01505531,
-0.0479073785,
0.0027840703,
0.0487482771,
0.0332463421,
-0.0801782608,
0.0912493244,
0.0422662087,
-0.0508031696,
-0.0039114607,
-0.0366236567,
-0.0017913341,
0.020635223,
0.0094296886,
-0.0527812131,
-0.1021839008,
-0.0185555853,
0.0218228586,
0.0392537825,
-0.0121166985,
-0.0225198921,
-0.00023166,
-0.0903992802,
-0.042143479,
0.043880567,
-0.001973921,
0.0195460003,
-0.0250399578,
-0.0160905197,
0.0256721526,
-0.0011854164,
-0.0444072299,
0.0221411455,
-0.0229577553,
-0.0289812833,
0.0273247827,
0.0290897004,
0.0255606119,
0.0195264649,
-0.006754105,
0.0022626698,
0.0448528975,
-0.0255827829,
-0.0023577141,
-0.0435637683,
-0.0168033186,
-0.0279424619,
0.0151378261,
-0.0090976935,
0.0006524506,
0.026036188,
-0.0324591212,
-0.0479217879,
-0.0333637297,
-0.0199794434,
-0.0091873063,
0.0048519089,
0.0200989079,
0.0173027441,
0.0443801135,
-0.0512663312,
0.0108240787,
0.0248229876,
0.0018244834,
0.0111500137,
-0.0306423325,
-0.0041624885,
-0.0248850603,
-0.026212031,
0.0163359698,
0.0076048309,
-0.0086718937,
-0.0146349147,
0.0042240508,
-0.0297474638,
-0.0601635277,
-0.0058050719,
0.0188056976,
-0.0201685242,
0.0798724666,
-0.001047633,
0.0068822331,
0.0263011623,
-0.0237802919,
-0.026004795,
0.0563572347,
-0.0396940485,
-0.005554656,
0.0085174693,
0.0164849609,
-0.0480382107,
-0.0226390474,
-0.0416777842,
-0.0043146969,
0.027723603,
0.0238511693,
-0.0387075692,
-0.0423047617,
-0.0783263445,
-0.0164616611,
-0.0214343648,
-0.0221102554,
-0.0048790327,
0.0131360516,
0.019677259,
0.0151638938,
0.025630163,
-0.0416397527,
-0.0098110652,
0.0617079027,
0.0176200904,
-0.0004569939,
0.0030575916,
-0.0595774017,
0.0129429065,
-0.0392296575,
0.0221720356,
-0.0115020284,
0.1105219945,
-0.0438644402,
0.0069939522,
-0.0144083481,
-0.0123248287,
-0.0047541009,
0.0039389292,
0.0283009689,
-0.0198820811,
-0.0333400257,
-0.0090248911,
-0.0147083485,
-0.0356857032,
0.0539159477,
-0.0019542475,
-0.0331911743,
-0.0496448353,
-0.0322093032,
-0.0483329445,
0.0216560662,
-0.006170155,
0.003793167,
0.0656186268,
-0.0560657866,
-0.0139020383,
0.0594240278,
-0.0116569437,
-0.036903251,
0.0279779136,
-0.0478913076,
0.0123398593,
-0.0477884561,
-0.0178085305,
-0.0091447616,
0.0412757508,
-0.014809371,
0.0375667512,
-0.0047035413,
-0.036738351,
-0.1090564132,
0.0487105623,
0.0195068177,
0.0570521839,
-0.0160390642,
0.015095735,
-0.0557490401,
0.087130256,
0.0374943055,
0.0180337485,
0.032790523,
0.0215111766,
-0.0291394535,
-0.0125801181,
0.0392218046,
-0.004988451,
0.0112323565,
0.0336206891,
0.0508980192,
-0.0187440738,
-0.0021073148,
0.0091226911,
0.0122366408,
-0.0460359566,
0.0178121775,
0.0834478214,
0.0175701007,
-0.083241567,
-0.012692472,
0.0135625964,
0.0120686106,
0.0350840688,
0.0135362213,
-0.0624189973,
-0.0214150026,
0.0113650002,
0.0155248679,
-0.017440049,
-0.0320581123,
0.0098584378,
-0.0678313002,
0.0227504335,
0.0162482504,
-0.0344753191,
0.0066137393,
-0.0371606648,
-0.0356315076,
-0.0229105111,
0.0068761054,
-0.010309712,
0.0311161708,
-0.0165150221,
0.0581848957,
0.0386717208,
-0.0378371365,
0.0017454969,
-0.0109582879,
0.0388746634,
0.0208263025,
0.0172414631,
0.0154298255,
-0.0430683866,
-0.0037952869,
-0.0009615707,
-0.0218962338,
-0.0218065847,
0.0422202349,
0.003964358,
-0.0654342249,
-0.0249075945,
-0.0104029626,
-0.0528442636,
-0.0013484469,
-0.0091063771,
0.0663938448,
0.0081692729,
0.0284689534,
0.0106897866,
-0.0294530392,
0.0160113517,
0.0235906988,
0.0358767509,
-0.0088629816,
0.0236202199,
-0.0002053868,
-0.0171246678,
-0.0623798259,
-0.0240270253,
0.0370019823,
-0.0453128554,
-0.0392120741,
-0.037113592,
0.0076742084,
0.0705600828,
0.0441742651,
0.0395472385,
-0.0087542301,
0.0429239236,
-0.0187571775,
-0.0751085281,
0.0095889363,
-0.0037960641,
0.0077647846,
-0.049445685,
-0.0197915845,
0.0871847197,
0.0171959195,
-0.0350414589,
0.0694253892,
-0.0630603358,
-0.0653996319,
-0.01395611,
0.0418435037,
0.0101183541,
0.0053815241,
0.0325711966,
-0.0520695262,
0.0346447378,
0.0451617613,
0.0023077868,
-0.0054223919,
0.0407616273,
-0.0714720264,
-0.0445601195,
0.0201877709,
-0.0642637014,
0.0624604709,
0.0201500766,
0.0462174341,
-0.016451098,
-0.0315437205,
-0.0139320595,
-0.0230469648,
0.0652896166,
-0.029238563,
-0.0143712945,
-0.0187567212,
0.0452159829,
0.0104410034,
0.0046078274,
-0.0269935448,
-0.0153523311,
0.0023316247,
-0.0061732396,
-0.0231519099,
0.0990413204,
0.0310266707,
0.0219280608,
-0.044529397,
0.0581970476,
-0.043101728,
-0.0059647714,
-0.0043032067,
-0.0043636533,
-0.0085000414,
-0.0183141045,
0.0712284297,
0.0157713089,
-0.0041343984,
-0.0233206078,
0.0001423779,
0.0438012555,
-0.0438411385,
0.0445784777,
-0.0321004651,
0.021347329,
-0.0341154411,
-0.0179517455,
0.0531999804,
-0.0153888753,
0.0775275379,
0.0137200048,
-0.0159699712,
0.0061407401,
0.0223834775,
-0.0172509104,
-0.0032049313,
0.04798292,
0.0125862174,
-0.0200123731,
-0.0085899942,
0.0887181759,
0.0156973582,
0.0702457651,
-0.0013957897,
-0.0139408652,
-0.0370235406,
-0.0269378237,
0.0134384651,
-0.0253800377,
-0.0352224,
-0.0500428379,
-0.0074348454,
-0.0347654857,
0.0842809007,
-0.0192750804,
0.01307067,
0.0021683211,
0.0264767371,
-0.0191549379,
0.0001521055,
-0.0554518886,
0.0165049266,
-0.0298312977,
0.0154864285,
-0.0059062243,
0.0148481745,
-5.909046634e-33,
-0.017096201,
-0.0437019058,
0.0176967215,
0.026558971,
0.0015872441,
0.0482417122,
-0.0345748626,
-0.0087673347,
0.0414477922,
-0.0052482164,
0.019017851,
-0.0292154215,
0.051122155,
-0.0030831217,
0.0404009782,
0.0141723873,
0.0631269664,
-0.006249242,
-0.0099752098,
0.0314170644,
0.0181076042,
0.0339298621,
0.1289560497,
-0.0382959396,
-0.0015004023,
0.02499035,
0.0430785157,
-0.0352261774,
-0.0104177557,
0.0613235757,
-0.0067237732,
0.0636376739,
-0.0056995382,
-0.0964149535,
-0.0260795206,
0.034743946,
-0.1000005603,
-0.0060750698,
-0.0349164344,
0.011793796,
-0.0096479552,
-0.0648004785,
0.0341436379,
0.0301645603,
-0.0365669541,
-0.006403862,
0.041601222,
-0.0075210705,
-0.0474623851,
-0.061080046,
-0.0710059702,
0.0242589936,
0.0177257992,
-0.0087266611,
0.0775275379,
0.0245524738,
0.0189304333,
0.0039149104,
-0.0863001794,
0.0204675682,
-0.035065189,
0.0590165518,
0.0680124313,
0.0666076913,
0.0016023049,
0.0254102051,
0.0246672705,
0.0312648229,
0.0478061922,
0.0247574262,
-0.0130408164,
0.0368829295,
0.0481014885,
-0.0318974294,
0.0107829664,
-0.0248210207,
-0.0622442476,
-0.0060843779,
-0.0225315206,
-0.0216352344,
0.0165959839,
0.0396536179,
0.0072723608,
0.0419475287,
-0.0177130643,
0.0265822541,
-0.0400284007,
0.0174617041,
-0.0132414866,
0.0283396132,
-0.0333255306,
0.0832700655,
0.022324888,
-0.0222420786,
0.0091000972,
-0.0113480054,
0.0362264365,
0.0432199463,
-0.0007199689,
-0.0096451296,
-0.0501035191,
-0.0401103161,
0.0393116623,
-0.0143573014,
0.0207582768,
-0.0182514768,
0.0669197813,
0.0165529493,
-0.0383789018,
-0.0048375726,
-0.0296191871,
0.0307971891,
0.0618716441,
0.0876478478,
0.0402951911,
-0.0165756959,
-0.0117203249,
0.0244514793,
0.0069170808,
-0.0572568849,
0.0535698049,
0.051706519,
0.0078621944,
0.011535652,
-0.0588317104,
-0.0000715166,
-0.0474635363,
0.0192044973,
-0.0138331093,
-0.0602857918,
-0.0245211311,
0.0371164009,
2.656e-7,
0.0023394576,
0.0519042201,
0.0353243239,
-0.025952626,
0.0230623279,
0.0052938671,
-0.0027916809,
0.0177635066,
-0.0259531196,
-0.0091074472,
-0.0116744917,
-0.0353646651,
0.044212874,
0.0051021115,
-0.0666034296,
-0.0517253019,
-0.0270040426,
0.0310203992,
-0.0340038203,
0.0116142286,
0.0190106202,
0.0912428126,
-0.0154531542,
-0.0196534358,
0.0026681183,
-0.0188881606,
0.0099954493,
0.034467034,
0.0008159082,
0.0144535219,
-0.0041054105,
0.0187603105,
-0.0595558323,
0.0389730185,
-0.0266224127,
-0.0179549921,
0.007485372,
0.0356456488,
-0.0175663698,
-0.0653809756,
0.0195707586,
0.052407451,
0.0066088629,
0.0124151157,
0.0376902856,
-0.0763191953,
-0.0546950065,
0.008717862,
0.0037162649,
-0.0006837775,
-0.0320194438,
-0.0210972149,
0.037652757,
0.0285548382,
0.0285123009,
-0.0206715185,
-0.0169057082,
-0.0832046047,
0.0188034177,
0.0194424428,
-0.0235338993,
-0.0223493595,
-0.0590721667,
-0.0499243326,
0.0236365814,
-0.0378661193,
-0.0193493702,
2.601824043e-34,
-0.0077594821,
-0.0387156941,
0.0093075819,
0.0482323803,
-0.0183023941,
-0.0099298498,
-0.094766058,
0.0198840853,
-0.0079143019,
-0.1061971039,
-0.0604769476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01409v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01409v1 | Dynamic Few-Shot Learning for Knowledge Graph Question Answering | 2024-07-01T15:59:17 | 2024-07-01T15:59:17 | Jacopo D'Abramo, Andrea Zugarini, Paolo Torroni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models present opportunities for innovative Question Answering
over Knowledge Graphs (KGQA). However, they are not inherently designed for
query generation. To bridge this gap, solutions have been proposed that rely on
fine-tuning or ad-hoc architectures, achieving good results but limited
out-of-domain distribution generalization. In this study, we introduce a novel
approach called Dynamic Few-Shot Learning (DFSL). DFSL integrates the
efficiency of in-context learning and semantic similarity and provides a
generally applicable solution for KGQA with state-of-the-art performance. We
run an extensive evaluation across multiple benchmark datasets and architecture
configurations. | [
0.0394127071,
0.003192558,
0.0086710174,
0.0159451347,
-0.0382768884,
0.0143420417,
-0.0117228404,
-0.0255802087,
-0.0076578562,
-0.0550526418,
-0.0139734726,
-0.0091376016,
-0.0420124903,
0.0102689806,
0.0234537441,
0.013363421,
0.0247671176,
0.0171076544,
0.0068334648,
-0.0152420085,
-0.0088534746,
0.0514230952,
-0.0205610786,
0.0064749955,
0.0449640006,
-0.0233665518,
-0.0082759997,
0.0387908667,
0.0003807388,
-0.0327991135,
0.0182250664,
0.0090945903,
0.0348534174,
0.0291452017,
0.0000017376,
-0.0198786799,
-0.0003248524,
0.0210881848,
-0.0269388836,
-0.0259163063,
0.0098495577,
0.0193012021,
0.0578452162,
-0.0011332665,
-0.0496194065,
-0.0547673516,
0.0225602947,
-0.0176787972,
0.0267133191,
0.0534663498,
-0.001174818,
-0.030151004,
-0.0078797918,
-0.0094085038,
0.0178692471,
-0.0768306106,
0.0169707239,
0.014792854,
0.040151678,
-0.0115707489,
-0.0145831667,
0.0257634092,
0.027294701,
0.0258442108,
0.0141251199,
0.0375707075,
-0.0700956658,
0.0446633138,
0.019904362,
0.1203706041,
-0.0133483429,
-0.005688142,
0.0102262916,
0.0013645143,
-0.0068800114,
0.0188845266,
-0.0629741475,
-0.037062373,
-0.0155500993,
-0.0100635756,
-0.0494322702,
-0.0045092157,
0.0325055085,
0.0057719853,
-0.0199992992,
0.0615278482,
0.0332439616,
0.0011525201,
-0.0224558674,
-0.0039015291,
-0.0556381382,
-0.0271456372,
-0.0545274206,
0.0582821779,
-0.043525558,
0.0221086759,
-0.0269264337,
-0.0189476144,
0.0281360373,
-0.041720558,
0.0309734251,
0.0351336449,
0.0356738642,
0.0752505064,
-0.0344350152,
0.0406021513,
-0.0016013468,
0.034326449,
-0.0644496903,
-0.0421557538,
-0.0774917305,
-0.0256163646,
-0.0667261854,
0.0489125699,
-0.0021012113,
-0.0606561042,
-0.0388583094,
0.0573598631,
0.0274173487,
-0.0107539864,
0.0139046106,
0.0477200672,
-0.0030388527,
-0.0243462455,
-0.0083914809,
0.0489477701,
-0.072431162,
0.0086087864,
0.0070022498,
-0.0147684943,
-0.007153912,
-0.0021439672,
0.034459427,
-0.0428228639,
-0.0124724023,
0.0605208389,
0.0149965677,
-0.025742067,
-0.0275315791,
-0.0308113936,
-0.0113646919,
-0.0309881195,
-0.0026634065,
-0.071257636,
0.0351335816,
0.0049543083,
-0.0358474553,
-0.0179590676,
0.0092123579,
0.0522478782,
-0.025950782,
0.0387402438,
-0.0127375852,
-0.009693929,
-0.0041434625,
-0.0101320846,
0.0022090243,
0.0921599343,
-0.0037178979,
-0.0284849778,
0.0480283089,
0.0443336852,
-0.0238872953,
-0.0037163594,
0.0621725246,
0.0330716148,
-0.0415403731,
0.061299853,
-0.0118244532,
0.0345316194,
0.0085039372,
-0.0014128869,
-0.0594153106,
-0.0330130532,
0.0111660734,
0.0358383618,
0.0186708011,
-0.0216367617,
0.0330106318,
0.0352032445,
-0.0244600978,
-0.0129924556,
-0.015713755,
0.045382902,
-0.0188604314,
0.018417431,
-0.0026587632,
0.0155504579,
-0.0680035502,
0.0325932428,
0.0149080027,
0.0146658784,
-0.0156078869,
0.0576513372,
0.0293650981,
0.0443818718,
-0.0103664966,
0.0410989821,
0.0266598668,
0.0219276827,
-0.0278702658,
-0.0048231687,
0.0170678459,
0.0553991981,
0.0736966953,
-0.0043587619,
-0.0707625002,
0.006535606,
0.0381773189,
0.0084439125,
0.0086363619,
-0.038618423,
0.0242899675,
-0.0453019477,
-0.0383011959,
-0.0658435151,
-0.0136308335,
-0.0079286937,
0.0228526611,
0.0368266366,
0.0231052786,
-0.1109374017,
0.044502005,
-0.0029750606,
-0.0190594289,
-0.0156798773,
0.0472975746,
0.0058284323,
-0.0244282149,
-0.0052327621,
-0.0064151604,
0.0354869328,
0.0009060069,
-0.0142796552,
-0.0522100069,
-0.0050015021,
-0.027057074,
-0.1134901717,
0.0393727161,
-0.0111357747,
0.0015756328,
-0.0436194353,
-0.0757871866,
-0.029732259,
0.0425807983,
-0.0153115466,
0.0468609221,
-0.0387715921,
-0.0330853201,
0.0154715059,
-0.0104667721,
-0.0562516563,
0.0520128123,
-0.0087136803,
0.0068602138,
-0.0053153858,
0.0310285985,
0.0329491645,
-0.0319681838,
-0.0125218388,
-0.0069658249,
-0.005763452,
-0.0146086803,
-0.0068962458,
-0.0016210459,
-0.0668993965,
0.0305522345,
-0.0523196571,
0.0419365726,
0.0047227205,
0.0253748056,
0.0407698415,
0.0361726768,
0.0053532021,
-0.0142738102,
-0.0553946458,
0.0357715897,
0.0126650641,
0.0222896151,
0.0336303711,
0.017688442,
0.0001207336,
-0.0051174932,
-0.0362955108,
-0.0054011443,
0.0813475847,
-0.0273245685,
0.021264866,
0.0231103227,
-0.0008391853,
-0.0604870468,
0.0147896567,
0.010997883,
0.0078121293,
-0.0180043355,
-0.0337711498,
0.0093572149,
0.0356695801,
-0.049334988,
-0.0265556108,
0.0050625568,
-0.0171510056,
-0.0714894161,
0.0160140395,
-0.0240050275,
0.0141409598,
-0.0194715038,
0.0358837508,
-0.0052237324,
0.0115792053,
0.0136755491,
-0.0090467418,
-0.0460869558,
0.0408246107,
0.0177118368,
0.0042015659,
-0.0693591982,
0.0278065149,
0.0428718179,
-0.0120086093,
-0.0551103018,
0.0356901065,
0.0773352534,
0.0344449244,
0.0055409712,
-0.0172446147,
0.0223687012,
-0.0237951055,
0.050816305,
-0.0191319119,
0.024759043,
-0.0000820619,
-0.0073286961,
-0.0467033312,
-0.0330056064,
0.0229605082,
-0.00988416,
0.0176364332,
0.0021889724,
0.0470901802,
0.0093064774,
-0.0182702262,
-0.0075817942,
-0.0304421354,
-0.046226941,
0.0437210202,
-0.0605301373,
0.0086047864,
-0.0062051821,
0.0203170851,
-0.0031168917,
0.0035750249,
-0.0070361113,
-0.0317223482,
-0.011512286,
0.0846764147,
0.0857891515,
-0.0236792266,
-0.0226971898,
0.0187652931,
0.0463323705,
0.0559912361,
0.0653927997,
-0.0012163991,
-0.0150069455,
-0.0065608216,
-0.0089130942,
-0.0190168992,
-0.0156894848,
-0.0055355341,
0.0549908243,
-0.036989633,
-0.0408151187,
0.1018881798,
0.0210874062,
-0.0259461477,
-0.0111393919,
-0.0050606499,
0.039535936,
0.0344846919,
0.0454767011,
-0.1295097321,
-0.0669881999,
-0.0311903432,
0.0508931279,
0.0055921706,
-0.0571127497,
0.000029422,
-0.1279077381,
-0.0023848808,
-0.0212899651,
-0.0301491879,
-0.018093532,
-0.0205174237,
0.0119164363,
0.0102942828,
-0.0180232432,
0.008153446,
0.003415697,
0.0144579699,
0.0004272141,
0.037694592,
-0.0280465856,
0.0662828907,
-0.0389503427,
0.021777533,
0.0401451774,
0.0249518231,
0.0489116497,
0.0116053252,
-0.0049952348,
-0.0330585726,
0.012919466,
-0.0027877877,
0.0271832235,
-0.0138117392,
-0.0139661152,
-0.0310908146,
0.0106402803,
-0.068573162,
-0.0010576071,
0.0100405104,
0.0770685524,
-0.0267252102,
-0.0014468194,
-0.0219491478,
-0.0087653194,
-0.0251904503,
0.0570503622,
0.0417238735,
0.0024725923,
-0.0551207215,
-0.0003966583,
-0.0255190171,
-0.0753101036,
-0.0040934253,
0.01093842,
0.0053807939,
0.0363266766,
-0.0683589429,
-0.0434579886,
0.0503044389,
0.0611367896,
-0.0485004522,
0.008354825,
-0.0052327458,
0.0145568242,
-0.0494476035,
-0.0228132531,
-0.0564194918,
0.026055092,
-0.0004706908,
0.0050547593,
0.0267610904,
-0.0066325041,
-0.0335536078,
-0.0099986,
-0.0932785422,
-0.0468530133,
-0.0343562327,
0.0288138725,
0.00719199,
0.0363138169,
-0.0540069863,
-0.0194477588,
0.0575425439,
0.0392483249,
-0.0034359901,
-0.0062304824,
-0.0026211757,
-0.0280201808,
0.0052278247,
0.0615297817,
-0.0861679614,
-0.0153256617,
0.037348941,
0.0807819739,
-0.0363601819,
-0.0000908808,
0.0297697764,
0.0078147659,
-0.0196396969,
0.0276650302,
-0.0198623836,
-0.0076330053,
0.0271939524,
-0.0180830229,
-0.0270593576,
-0.0510935187,
0.0030947293,
0.0029776928,
-0.0430007204,
-0.0132778035,
-0.0210934039,
-0.0013611936,
0.0726192817,
-0.0295014605,
-0.0389595032,
0.065239571,
-0.0089333588,
0.0285523366,
-0.0130823925,
-0.0251024403,
0.0400854461,
0.0173643809,
0.0370040052,
-0.0335376412,
0.0393518396,
0.0271797702,
-0.0327024236,
-0.0589305721,
0.0151423709,
-0.0773149431,
-0.0513748452,
-0.0155254249,
0.0336099267,
0.043702472,
0.0157029945,
-0.0133627029,
0.0245688278,
-0.0306669697,
-0.0110367527,
0.0130254729,
-0.036743477,
-0.0163567904,
0.0356195942,
0.0459692255,
0.0082546622,
0.0074221035,
0.1000167876,
-0.0024553265,
0.0735562146,
0.0043143551,
-0.0190390125,
-0.0147610735,
-0.0189227946,
0.0173579026,
0.0529498905,
0.0039507137,
0.0344913863,
-0.0411290675,
-0.0644760653,
-0.0066735493,
-0.0437353589,
-0.0348713323,
0.0024950446,
0.0541875958,
0.0503596626,
0.062194746,
-0.0255456697,
-0.0123582287,
0.006177247,
-0.0314050652,
-0.0140054561,
0.0023557344,
-5.856048002e-33,
0.0004233784,
-0.0082599511,
0.0480251722,
-0.0546784438,
-0.0189963337,
-0.0264992788,
-0.0447788835,
-0.0471221656,
-0.0600989051,
0.0006520811,
0.0015670713,
0.0144418692,
-0.0117000788,
0.0470396727,
-0.0030153999,
-0.0377930589,
-0.00409398,
-0.0089177275,
0.0049870629,
0.0256700069,
0.0273861345,
0.0593638271,
0.0258816537,
0.0451650023,
-0.0407391042,
-0.0186467674,
0.0186067224,
0.0474525131,
0.0181475021,
0.0497868806,
-0.0011359976,
0.0246083234,
0.0319258161,
-0.0100587085,
-0.0154680172,
-0.0233680997,
-0.10020639,
-0.0520181581,
-0.0192132108,
0.0026012447,
-0.0233641248,
0.0015395379,
0.0131252054,
-0.0160094425,
0.0772642791,
-0.0419716649,
0.008567051,
-0.007205049,
-0.0621200204,
-0.0584403351,
-0.0345355943,
0.0230851546,
-0.0091767404,
-0.021374451,
-0.0459845252,
0.0426160581,
-0.0021033259,
0.0203422531,
-0.0226464793,
0.0011612867,
-0.0433765389,
-0.0007873343,
0.0150566678,
0.0258320179,
0.0337205417,
0.0205096193,
0.0196735337,
-0.0209456515,
-0.010323761,
0.0278414451,
-0.0025306067,
0.0225714874,
0.0003533175,
0.0706772134,
0.0312475841,
0.0179029871,
-0.0898042172,
-0.0051552271,
0.0010449027,
0.0282251276,
0.0053643528,
0.0229252651,
-0.0106371166,
-0.0360113606,
-0.0340546221,
0.0338349976,
-0.0345039666,
-0.0216101967,
0.0449256338,
-0.0058752121,
-0.0148168048,
0.0072555384,
0.0355599076,
-0.074480392,
0.0357185192,
0.0754795894,
-0.0120061776,
0.0021979816,
0.0046887775,
0.0405998453,
-0.045764029,
0.0037512544,
0.0194473304,
0.0102176275,
-0.0363726094,
0.0395719856,
0.0204357002,
0.0039924099,
-0.0565758795,
-0.0207873918,
-0.0464638211,
-0.0030036978,
-0.0350494944,
0.019886395,
-0.0120434267,
0.0542814471,
0.0004875927,
0.037965633,
0.0109156333,
-0.0002664457,
0.0378315561,
0.0340613797,
0.0123088453,
0.0007811828,
-0.0160059351,
0.0036855601,
-0.0357408077,
-0.0074724406,
-0.0272864886,
-0.058910545,
-0.0173161626,
0.0357261114,
2.518e-7,
0.0638608187,
0.0057047429,
0.003477532,
0.0603106134,
0.0146377422,
0.0104796616,
0.0122174686,
0.0304848403,
0.0255780537,
-0.010168951,
0.0479266495,
0.0515451506,
-0.0133088185,
0.0483198017,
-0.0727703944,
0.0614833981,
-0.0589078777,
-0.0397334583,
-0.02763303,
-0.0295060147,
0.0218494646,
0.0650727749,
0.0139427325,
-0.0197577346,
0.022514753,
-0.0986090973,
0.0682821497,
0.0640391186,
0.0159727857,
0.0069156573,
-0.0179766454,
0.028298296,
0.0052539646,
0.0410714597,
-0.0034279851,
0.0314519033,
0.0050858972,
0.0255437139,
-0.0190779548,
-0.0490625128,
-0.0107613197,
-0.0651129484,
0.0458914191,
-0.0442350134,
0.1013697237,
-0.1126791984,
-0.0056035561,
0.0105219064,
-0.0208025072,
-0.0089624505,
0.0231527872,
-0.0213949997,
-0.0074739093,
0.0108672334,
0.0403677858,
-0.0000952955,
0.0080963923,
-0.0566640161,
0.0243740901,
0.0271544997,
-0.0257450882,
0.0003076042,
-0.0027405804,
-0.0265773069,
0.0055623832,
-0.0267410595,
0.0155479386,
1.961685406e-34,
0.0271639209,
0.0284512807,
-0.0159744732,
0.0209329464,
-0.0082386835,
-0.017566029,
-0.0336829312,
-0.0324888714,
0.0641715229,
-0.1015624925,
-0.011750943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01406v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01406v1 | Adapting Multilingual LLMs to Low-Resource Languages with Knowledge Graphs via Adapters | 2024-07-01T15:56:24 | 2024-07-01T15:56:24 | Daniil Gurgurov, Mareike Hartmann, Simon Ostermann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper explores the integration of graph knowledge from linguistic
ontologies into multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) using adapters to
improve performance for low-resource languages (LRLs) in sentiment analysis
(SA) and named entity recognition (NER). Building upon successful
parameter-efficient fine-tuning techniques, such as K-ADAPTER and MAD-X, we
propose a similar approach for incorporating knowledge from multilingual
graphs, connecting concepts in various languages with each other through
linguistic relationships, into multilingual LLMs for LRLs. Specifically, we
focus on eight LRLs -- Maltese, Bulgarian, Indonesian, Nepali, Javanese,
Uyghur, Tibetan, and Sinhala -- and employ language-specific adapters
fine-tuned on data extracted from the language-specific section of ConceptNet,
aiming to enable knowledge transfer across the languages covered by the
knowledge graph. We compare various fine-tuning objectives, including standard
Masked Language Modeling (MLM), MLM with full-word masking, and MLM with
targeted masking, to analyse their effectiveness in learning and integrating
the extracted graph data. Through empirical evaluation on language-specific
tasks, we assess how structured graph knowledge affects the performance of
multilingual LLMs for LRLs in SA and NER, providing insights into the potential
benefits of adapting language models for low-resource scenarios. | [
0.0422703736,
0.0329497382,
-0.0068400116,
0.0812963694,
-0.0316446312,
0.0340649784,
-0.0171665605,
0.0121488376,
0.055359982,
-0.0246551726,
-0.0318909995,
-0.0096079167,
-0.0063967411,
0.0022224009,
0.0109225875,
-0.0218070243,
0.0221201554,
-0.0240743514,
0.0251356065,
-0.0165972412,
-0.0046205013,
0.0427510664,
0.0458753854,
-0.0185015108,
0.0014001393,
0.0279367752,
0.0329911783,
0.0204381272,
0.0074271862,
-0.0282341335,
-0.0205017198,
-0.0036676507,
-0.0440547913,
0.0619018376,
0.0000019936,
-0.04818362,
-0.0407413393,
-0.0015974286,
0.0215075947,
-0.0326149166,
0.0828245208,
-0.0889710262,
0.0043364698,
0.0037177617,
-0.0245806091,
-0.0351062603,
0.0552128553,
0.0461614691,
0.0159249958,
0.0660303161,
-0.0256978795,
-0.0068677855,
0.0167385321,
-0.0013836451,
-0.0227909647,
-0.0309822448,
0.0393202081,
0.0057604653,
-0.0087852618,
-0.0232755039,
-0.0323582292,
0.0335440487,
-0.0262535568,
-0.0063975644,
0.0079124486,
-0.0223762579,
-0.0190874431,
0.006876654,
0.0172204338,
0.0466616862,
-0.0404016338,
-0.0080687189,
0.0028589671,
-0.0052755293,
-0.0219903849,
0.0259149633,
-0.0110760015,
-0.0323811322,
-0.0383543149,
0.0271857493,
0.0500548966,
-0.0133353295,
0.0379723981,
0.0012844952,
-0.0230868533,
0.0824337378,
-0.0027187809,
0.0023389617,
0.0300383251,
0.0288858302,
0.0019737906,
-0.0443613604,
-0.0017032375,
0.0219075214,
0.0107112825,
0.048320733,
-0.0078954957,
-0.0405205861,
-0.0092547778,
-0.0651125461,
0.0049311551,
0.0233148336,
0.0233103484,
0.0449014828,
-0.0923514143,
0.0041044848,
-0.0080218567,
-0.0021355858,
-0.0255214442,
-0.0787130669,
-0.0524004027,
0.0086167865,
-0.017025739,
0.0262436755,
-0.0621574596,
0.0106536094,
-0.0258604754,
0.0387041718,
-0.0214540735,
0.0287988503,
0.0163026527,
-0.0515811071,
0.043615479,
-0.0147474548,
-0.010801713,
0.0604871996,
0.0118511319,
-0.0130461669,
-0.0582935475,
-0.0440323055,
0.0371328592,
0.0058986242,
0.0207494497,
-0.0446643643,
0.0386202596,
0.0843560025,
0.041526854,
-0.0127078081,
-0.0587471388,
0.0302836616,
0.0011674503,
-0.0610244386,
0.0467457138,
-0.0763041005,
0.0590540133,
0.0284802169,
0.0261752792,
-0.0486899167,
0.0244655106,
-0.0391569063,
-0.0940864682,
0.0545621999,
-0.0142137296,
-0.0043482454,
0.0064715105,
-0.0254132003,
0.0050275102,
0.0764676705,
0.0234257691,
-0.0271242969,
0.0664006993,
-0.0317698829,
-0.0646502152,
0.0340440571,
0.0168048553,
0.0318111405,
-0.0200729333,
0.0044829533,
-0.0319046862,
-0.0393828191,
0.033502996,
0.0397280157,
0.0144607015,
0.012970984,
0.0185901709,
-0.005583094,
-0.0050517609,
0.0233152285,
-0.0060906918,
-0.0007166368,
-0.0324944034,
-0.0097516626,
-0.0145690115,
0.0141851734,
-0.0088407062,
0.0106095802,
-0.01879091,
0.0564126335,
-0.0247227792,
-0.0078351097,
-0.0084081981,
-0.0304416679,
0.0382006578,
0.0248028412,
0.0891115889,
0.0071513518,
-0.0321728773,
0.0246160533,
0.0716652051,
0.0055534774,
0.0271327142,
-0.0291265901,
-0.0093370555,
0.0626274496,
-0.0004621406,
0.0026169601,
-0.0202516355,
0.0117353303,
-0.0277939122,
0.0333356075,
0.0074720006,
-0.0185329672,
0.0008557338,
-0.0289483052,
0.0032046442,
0.0105662877,
-0.0047893524,
0.0564441346,
-0.0096726073,
0.0593395866,
0.0016186272,
-0.0702161714,
-0.0569345281,
-0.0197465159,
-0.023808362,
0.0015322018,
0.0248598587,
0.0128945075,
0.0117908427,
0.0471314341,
0.0082632853,
-0.0205692276,
0.0004061243,
-0.0567956567,
-0.0280794762,
0.0163319409,
0.0259255636,
-0.0759538114,
0.0059679602,
-0.0249702781,
-0.0026645409,
0.0031673769,
-0.0228520483,
-0.0580975115,
0.0344032049,
0.0284412894,
0.0672001094,
-0.0010005092,
0.0121813286,
-0.031822931,
0.0101205846,
0.0007679907,
0.0301991031,
0.0013133063,
0.0267134514,
-0.0097949104,
-0.0344855078,
0.0053346492,
0.0040388978,
-0.0438390598,
0.0613970086,
0.0322756954,
-0.0059173824,
0.0174144916,
0.021906931,
-0.026802415,
-0.0036523985,
-0.1131534055,
0.0000232225,
0.0038617116,
0.0439732075,
-0.0043129968,
0.0396579802,
-0.0148808099,
-0.0091953762,
-0.0203224868,
0.0111596631,
0.0224120114,
0.0361427665,
-0.0044633732,
0.000874529,
0.0080722161,
-0.0095653608,
-0.0096469736,
0.0121655939,
0.0416356437,
-0.0033727321,
-0.0943994671,
-0.018171262,
0.0546635129,
-0.0748738199,
-0.0072352467,
-0.027164517,
-0.0050410316,
-0.0491295122,
0.003583712,
0.0171567667,
0.0114259366,
-0.053545408,
-0.0135592725,
0.0485578217,
-0.0230325051,
-0.0218634568,
0.0084250104,
-0.02535972,
-0.007569911,
-0.0544641949,
-0.0475329012,
0.011034715,
0.0339291655,
-0.0085117836,
-0.0281071886,
-0.0600184649,
-0.0253152959,
-0.0580767617,
0.0121734897,
-0.0029430119,
0.0377167799,
0.0346209332,
0.0048561553,
-0.005785964,
0.0020782563,
0.06804052,
-0.0100545939,
0.0122931087,
-0.0166571047,
-0.0237243567,
-0.0712828487,
0.0175229795,
0.02400795,
0.0400496013,
-0.0384359807,
0.0049031177,
-0.0178293902,
-0.012536129,
0.0166544188,
-0.008424446,
0.0277453139,
0.0081102615,
0.0213498622,
-0.0100150593,
-0.0109136729,
0.0040565021,
0.0303850565,
-0.0685605034,
0.0227827542,
0.0470957085,
-0.0247825608,
0.0247699916,
0.049076438,
0.0242680386,
-0.0456376188,
0.0165952407,
-0.0070776604,
0.0146365361,
0.0277553238,
0.0442964993,
-0.030999247,
0.0399266444,
0.0113968141,
0.0244527776,
0.0111178104,
-0.0017589856,
-0.0526639745,
0.0329097249,
-0.0190301854,
0.043191053,
0.0062873987,
-0.0127202058,
-0.0738413557,
0.0294331722,
-0.0190135501,
0.0532340072,
0.09668836,
0.0017460528,
-0.0196257029,
-0.0063758297,
-0.0391692221,
0.024453748,
0.0229899008,
0.0326263495,
-0.0831686482,
0.0027077985,
-0.0083248401,
0.0312599763,
-0.0089955637,
-0.0752613842,
-0.0001462661,
-0.1411918849,
-0.0293369628,
0.0224774778,
-0.0731155798,
-0.0436845794,
-0.0655718371,
0.0001718526,
-0.0346201658,
-0.0196322221,
-0.0724553764,
-0.0012599021,
-0.0172781497,
0.0120944474,
-0.0324304514,
-0.0414240137,
0.0110338284,
-0.0073468578,
0.021977758,
-0.03366258,
0.0476248711,
-0.0441018268,
0.0173409451,
0.0114526479,
-0.0303736404,
-0.0128372805,
-0.0472346619,
0.0085892593,
-0.0018993564,
-0.0201180447,
-0.0078181997,
-0.0372207463,
-0.0554098859,
0.0190930478,
0.0079384996,
0.0732569546,
0.0264729876,
-0.0271805562,
0.0344303139,
-0.0460130125,
0.0456332527,
0.0517532229,
-0.0018615486,
-0.0260504056,
0.0108984094,
-0.0101393256,
-0.0205279998,
-0.0416300483,
-0.0010244035,
0.0324909389,
-0.0791288391,
0.0055424822,
-0.055963397,
-0.0438942052,
0.0439304486,
0.006786956,
0.0007102361,
0.0538335405,
0.0473233722,
-0.0189766232,
-0.0489221476,
0.0091980658,
-0.0294285677,
0.005038661,
-0.0141679328,
-0.0318524726,
0.0350208916,
-0.0028339163,
-0.0013943193,
-0.0317151472,
-0.0373892039,
-0.0830780193,
-0.0234029945,
0.0232488234,
0.0094256187,
0.0606844686,
0.0064582173,
-0.0159494393,
0.0488828905,
0.0282550436,
-0.0138015859,
0.0069826455,
0.0555523038,
0.0443060212,
-0.0180694275,
0.0748965219,
-0.0513054915,
0.0195353515,
0.0419957638,
0.0271278713,
-0.0226177648,
-0.056055896,
-0.0158081725,
0.0544279478,
-0.0130588021,
-0.028343793,
-0.0475348532,
-0.0604503602,
0.0071999729,
-0.0099431388,
-0.0210943874,
-0.0215613581,
-0.0631550699,
0.0240017008,
-0.0022745782,
-0.0209340043,
0.0104968073,
0.0220356658,
0.0073887049,
-0.0159874912,
0.0401441865,
0.0039857868,
0.0125393393,
0.0637296513,
0.0342891887,
-0.0041968408,
0.0337095074,
0.0444456525,
-0.0055628372,
-0.0363989919,
-0.0039784135,
0.0110014938,
-0.0169187095,
0.0041631563,
-0.0132542085,
0.0322926529,
-0.0121435039,
0.003930477,
0.0098602166,
0.0583114065,
-0.0242368802,
0.0861678794,
-0.0234954357,
-0.0279647149,
-0.0234276317,
0.0238318816,
-0.0121606123,
-0.0179872382,
0.0489839055,
0.0054802243,
-0.0193279944,
0.0238407236,
0.0690667927,
0.0141073726,
0.0342950411,
0.0250721108,
-0.0138940364,
-0.0149677433,
0.0019433311,
0.0197723322,
-0.0077135689,
-0.0053518708,
0.0203816798,
-0.055822283,
-0.1116949394,
0.0296086464,
-0.0717295557,
-0.0383169428,
-0.0145879621,
0.0003583152,
-0.0017996596,
0.0668273568,
0.0425055325,
-0.0781460628,
0.0280946735,
-0.0284807831,
-0.0036278195,
0.0553322807,
-6.365089586e-33,
-0.0184477307,
-0.0514379181,
-0.0166744888,
0.0612348951,
0.0204749536,
0.0113167549,
-0.0263544731,
-0.0043651992,
-0.0370950028,
0.0037960974,
0.0044056145,
-0.0089841345,
0.0169029832,
0.0281184353,
-0.0201583635,
0.0025021466,
0.0185435005,
0.04804359,
0.0264924448,
0.0388328172,
0.0698342547,
0.0392272547,
0.0751748532,
-0.0970516428,
0.0699352622,
-0.0128989387,
0.0195543673,
-0.0001464627,
0.0801063925,
0.0544874072,
-0.0229162388,
0.0779944435,
0.0220651552,
-0.0082380027,
0.0199577324,
-0.0240719598,
-0.0893908888,
-0.0283925198,
0.0198369101,
0.0460906923,
0.010837011,
-0.0359545127,
0.0003322625,
0.0113038998,
0.0159415398,
0.0205627326,
0.0203136206,
-0.0204109587,
-0.0163047872,
-0.0414201878,
-0.065764904,
0.0512530543,
0.0351031646,
0.052067887,
0.0553553104,
-0.0031032804,
0.0248704311,
-0.0110849822,
-0.0838183388,
0.0082791271,
-0.0379297584,
-0.0173030738,
0.0474288762,
0.032150697,
-0.006370998,
0.0050049461,
-0.0039317543,
0.0230457745,
0.0265262667,
0.073111251,
0.026770357,
0.0134060355,
0.0026238146,
0.0614241511,
-0.0311210696,
-0.0731307864,
-0.0862338021,
-0.0134681463,
-0.0022202844,
0.0065142573,
0.0138902152,
0.0065169311,
-0.0163809769,
-0.0568400137,
0.0076141274,
-0.0192442238,
-0.044681754,
-0.0290023126,
-0.0149097722,
-0.0107190143,
-0.0336245075,
0.0158341601,
0.0124507677,
-0.0541277826,
-0.0522848517,
0.041097831,
-0.0032673823,
0.0247901976,
0.0026756546,
0.0426787511,
-0.0817823485,
-0.0502416231,
-0.0335569046,
-0.024261089,
0.0083193742,
0.0100722546,
0.0714743063,
0.0124146277,
-0.0657207742,
0.0104973121,
-0.0317433141,
0.0299848653,
-0.0234850105,
0.0447053462,
-0.0107536744,
0.0040164427,
0.0019846514,
0.0289892256,
0.0777438134,
0.004027239,
0.0166141167,
0.0325850099,
0.0085769258,
0.0001476309,
-0.0321942754,
-0.0103617264,
0.0126628941,
-0.0037779335,
0.0352570824,
-0.0429270118,
-0.0070179556,
-0.0240054075,
3.006e-7,
0.0333667137,
0.0222421102,
-0.0579518117,
-0.0090712626,
0.0032899992,
0.0261965841,
-0.0173843037,
0.0286386311,
-0.0057675587,
0.0140643883,
-0.0020351061,
0.022582531,
0.014150653,
0.0672216415,
-0.0908893272,
0.0141168153,
0.0239616632,
-0.0303319972,
-0.0220544543,
0.0763493925,
-0.0115053384,
0.0680045485,
0.014469876,
-0.008909774,
-0.0637692884,
-0.0751107782,
0.061639946,
-0.0341773294,
-0.0431506932,
0.0194714293,
0.0186330918,
0.059583731,
-0.0375659354,
0.0238207206,
-0.0176265109,
0.0374854952,
0.0155983642,
0.046340052,
0.0094624255,
-0.0165266693,
0.0196658727,
-0.0209140833,
-0.0057391641,
-0.0642787963,
0.0863744766,
-0.0124306679,
-0.0348526686,
-0.0194248892,
0.0339453146,
-0.0015441029,
0.0042177518,
-0.0292504169,
-0.0472926609,
0.019261051,
0.0385168195,
-0.0487702303,
-0.0373220257,
-0.0060410346,
0.007551624,
0.0479066446,
0.0242552441,
-0.0697381943,
0.0054628351,
0.0088432524,
0.0151537182,
-0.0147827612,
0.0447191522,
2.669819963e-34,
0.0246788058,
0.0087880846,
-0.0438057333,
-0.000088336,
0.028785862,
-0.0314359888,
-0.071808666,
0.0266923495,
0.0040523601,
-0.0724694058,
0.0106976386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01403v1 | Optimization of Retrieval-Augmented Generation Context with Outlier Detection | 2024-07-01T15:53:29 | 2024-07-01T15:53:29 | Vitaly Bulgakov | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we focus on methods to reduce the size and improve the quality
of the prompt context required for question-answering systems. Attempts to
increase the number of retrieved chunked documents and thereby enlarge the
context related to the query can significantly complicate the processing and
decrease the performance of a Large Language Model (LLM) when generating
responses to queries. It is well known that a large set of documents retrieved
from a database in response to a query may contain irrelevant information,
which often leads to hallucinations in the resulting answers. Our goal is to
select the most semantically relevant documents, treating the discarded ones as
outliers. We propose and evaluate several methods for identifying outliers by
creating features that utilize the distances of embedding vectors, retrieved
from the vector database, to both the centroid and the query vectors. The
methods were evaluated by comparing the similarities of the retrieved LLM
responses to ground-truth answers obtained using the OpenAI GPT-4o model. It
was found that the greatest improvements were achieved with increasing
complexity of the questions and answers. | [
0.0579806566,
-0.0128580192,
-0.0152273607,
0.0468550771,
-0.0328062102,
0.0135269156,
-0.0147611666,
0.0245893393,
-0.0177726205,
-0.0330129601,
0.028190501,
-0.0401042365,
-0.0387083367,
-0.0105165541,
-0.0106737306,
-0.0216253996,
0.0382708646,
-0.0327280201,
0.037598595,
-0.0174668226,
-0.0122908289,
0.0116622252,
0.0294118151,
0.0296540018,
-0.0102093145,
-0.0297099594,
-0.0094014108,
0.0071768146,
0.0181775037,
-0.013381389,
0.0112029575,
0.0287098754,
-0.0120554473,
0.037075974,
0.0000020775,
-0.0617902987,
-0.0168412607,
-0.0071185329,
-0.0058987373,
0.0138012776,
-0.0084229615,
0.0302186925,
0.0247073714,
0.0354544707,
-0.0398540348,
-0.0033567597,
0.01094086,
0.0550810471,
0.0581712537,
0.079882592,
-0.0051200241,
-0.0234877691,
0.0232673008,
0.0226551853,
0.0603252575,
-0.0175392088,
0.0352474153,
-0.0026890815,
0.0388281122,
0.0206966437,
-0.0126172239,
0.0077619683,
0.0066689332,
-0.0116996337,
0.0212230869,
0.0245380923,
-0.0311158597,
0.0102338633,
0.0250146165,
0.0980452225,
0.0018349793,
-0.0218585841,
0.010167392,
-0.0114951357,
0.0086620776,
0.0396335647,
-0.061773438,
0.0237201788,
-0.0132818287,
0.0029752331,
0.0191376284,
-0.003306296,
0.0066554677,
0.0445049107,
-0.0401268937,
0.0339792632,
0.0243564676,
-0.0605002083,
-0.0347157456,
-0.0012021773,
-0.0481330678,
-0.0510791242,
0.0239879712,
0.0793716758,
-0.0438516699,
0.0078564622,
-0.0192712694,
-0.0289529804,
0.0454268456,
-0.0474918149,
0.0142136272,
0.0042024436,
-0.0538598374,
0.0636276975,
-0.0094621852,
0.064813152,
-0.034529537,
-0.0026045952,
-0.0512251258,
-0.0605571605,
-0.0054138089,
-0.0219519194,
-0.0625492632,
0.0523533039,
-0.0526104011,
-0.0338530466,
0.0034853099,
0.05961404,
0.0038357505,
-0.0076193493,
-0.0175785832,
0.0312471222,
-0.0140254935,
-0.022513615,
-0.0163498074,
-0.0040013706,
-0.0767023787,
-0.0178072434,
-0.0092414096,
-0.0925622061,
-0.0064429031,
0.0479473509,
0.0277779549,
-0.0286033209,
0.0070402357,
0.0002691217,
0.0238987673,
-0.0353293717,
-0.0237889849,
-0.0460364893,
0.0106858723,
-0.0065244143,
-0.0363807194,
-0.0921772495,
0.0011958616,
0.0178886447,
-0.0333873816,
0.0078931507,
0.0051161163,
0.0672086328,
-0.0227036495,
0.0073258267,
-0.0282493345,
0.0360556245,
0.0933516249,
0.0055263164,
0.0206369013,
0.0331288502,
-0.0141188819,
0.0026108646,
0.0702474862,
0.0168738533,
0.0734722838,
0.0080682077,
0.0124210836,
-0.0006539196,
-0.0237722751,
0.055078432,
0.0084112044,
0.0082228128,
-0.0105312644,
0.0301899277,
-0.0133237643,
0.0104915965,
0.0283969454,
0.0432617813,
-0.0325478949,
-0.0311715938,
-0.011422012,
-0.006439277,
-0.0242276192,
0.0201578736,
-0.0156920385,
0.024756467,
-0.0246180259,
0.007651458,
0.0451584123,
0.0192248505,
-0.0351352803,
-0.0233325865,
-0.0320058353,
-0.001819763,
-0.0259788129,
0.0210461933,
0.0301192738,
-0.0219940003,
-0.0493899249,
-0.0125377243,
-0.0012629207,
-0.0181157421,
0.0120611116,
-0.0391159393,
0.0409489647,
0.0344935767,
0.0691243187,
-0.0363731496,
0.0115888985,
-0.0097855246,
0.0392711349,
0.0412396453,
0.013471215,
-0.0099895634,
-0.0161620397,
-0.0641250908,
-0.0081559336,
0.0312116388,
-0.0074920491,
-0.00774193,
0.0200340021,
0.0304991882,
0.0541177094,
-0.0642920956,
0.009678592,
0.039386522,
-0.002194572,
-0.0763834417,
0.013504127,
0.0180448983,
0.0137267206,
0.0173896551,
-0.0071984311,
0.0273140986,
0.0291940868,
-0.0310170818,
-0.0275355391,
-0.0277375598,
-0.023150729,
0.0070939278,
0.0265585594,
-0.0260846522,
-0.005565139,
0.0106799807,
-0.0136393681,
-0.0460373051,
-0.0289720241,
-0.0588657521,
0.0301872194,
-0.0839656368,
-0.0063800141,
0.0077718021,
0.0170687996,
-0.0501544029,
0.1020523012,
-0.0041719531,
0.0495721474,
0.0560056157,
0.0257111359,
0.0385200605,
-0.0549203232,
-0.0115877045,
0.0206464306,
-0.0221492164,
0.0182302836,
0.0603668243,
-0.0250989646,
-0.0333948992,
-0.0059593637,
-0.0806730986,
0.0020618432,
-0.037306197,
-0.0044182339,
0.035083089,
0.0354286693,
-0.0262476262,
-0.0376750082,
-0.0656069219,
-0.0145828845,
0.0624140613,
0.0476021059,
0.0273127146,
0.0285673961,
-0.0046086884,
-0.0131771183,
-0.0123952599,
0.0074409517,
0.035716936,
-0.0212285016,
0.0106018744,
-0.0710709542,
0.001522931,
-0.0558677688,
0.036090944,
0.0079917358,
0.0045029139,
0.0145555185,
-0.0593755022,
0.0453090668,
0.043253608,
0.0590532459,
0.0030393826,
0.0387228206,
0.0076918681,
-0.0704411715,
-0.0067391293,
-0.0544304065,
0.0124814613,
0.0242447685,
-0.0123352259,
0.0477971919,
-0.0274665356,
0.0287652519,
-0.026719179,
-0.0260223076,
0.0254692212,
0.00334113,
-0.0039560916,
-0.0571333542,
-0.0141268848,
-0.0224191491,
0.0570557937,
-0.0170270577,
-0.0312801376,
0.0611059517,
0.0033176451,
0.0272281189,
-0.0409216583,
-0.0131403413,
-0.0232191924,
0.0064817355,
0.001587778,
0.0442280881,
-0.0869372562,
-0.0364682339,
-0.0347652957,
0.0021392703,
-0.0002356188,
-0.0317173339,
0.0097899567,
-0.0317836106,
0.0166697949,
0.0256925225,
-0.0194158982,
-0.0674456581,
-0.0404994413,
0.0293233152,
-0.0202014223,
-0.0101757823,
-0.0062370165,
0.0010486953,
-0.0161519423,
0.0033446308,
0.0462184101,
-0.0389215127,
-0.003764166,
-0.0117104882,
0.0838286579,
0.083503522,
0.0136732943,
0.037252184,
-0.012223863,
0.0169408638,
0.0692098513,
0.0428533964,
-0.0323800929,
0.0337515771,
-0.0302294362,
0.0264197327,
-0.0414084904,
-0.0125772385,
0.0469343066,
0.0205848478,
-0.0038172076,
-0.0759332925,
0.1132404804,
0.0696123317,
-0.0173411816,
-0.0024468461,
-0.0507151075,
0.0170513671,
0.0198297631,
0.0413541347,
-0.0364770889,
0.0170209017,
-0.0022410315,
0.0569006465,
-0.0265425537,
-0.027288815,
0.0129613727,
-0.1556546241,
0.0241168179,
-0.0201242417,
-0.0296675079,
-0.0688603148,
-0.0613581799,
-0.0011060579,
0.0429256372,
0.0131272171,
0.0330656208,
0.0225319657,
0.004043262,
-0.0058134142,
0.0310775321,
-0.0269462466,
-0.0011931232,
-0.0245108511,
0.0146155814,
0.0621658228,
0.0177464355,
0.0155888312,
-0.0316202417,
0.0215748418,
-0.0879695937,
0.0274837408,
-0.0169478748,
0.0211054757,
0.0234057512,
0.0000158176,
-0.0441917926,
0.0041413526,
-0.0477605686,
-0.0070918314,
0.013538369,
0.0977250412,
-0.0516609177,
0.0021169151,
-0.0498434268,
-0.0162840392,
0.0281800907,
0.0801290721,
0.0046432684,
-0.0331339091,
-0.030434072,
0.0053416477,
0.0256853346,
0.0074440562,
0.0500392094,
0.0244355872,
0.0456299335,
-0.0199518371,
-0.1024161726,
-0.0578607395,
0.0000171578,
0.0383009464,
-0.0156435482,
0.0340913571,
-0.0532365255,
0.0135918297,
-0.0070782583,
-0.0068980432,
-0.0223148391,
-0.0243702568,
-0.0263394546,
0.0474772863,
0.0227141287,
-0.0155104185,
-0.0308014583,
0.0182274785,
-0.0281424187,
-0.0579703934,
-0.0073630605,
0.0124200517,
0.0248287451,
0.0203113947,
-0.0160606783,
-0.0498546548,
0.0329869874,
0.0447996221,
-0.0283991825,
0.0049916846,
-0.0382311828,
-0.0293439459,
0.0031258014,
0.0253541581,
-0.0795696378,
0.0242581256,
0.01603893,
0.0238457527,
-0.0366451517,
-0.0435057916,
0.0376797877,
0.0397356115,
0.0346935205,
0.0141416155,
-0.0069405725,
-0.025925871,
0.0188460853,
-0.0491716154,
-0.0027267768,
0.0073546935,
0.0298050158,
0.0071900729,
-0.011475455,
-0.0018197466,
0.0375995748,
-0.0164155122,
0.0292501319,
-0.042130813,
-0.0258801021,
0.022437714,
0.0120527102,
0.0191333629,
0.0010327713,
-0.0291238017,
-0.0110936435,
0.0243304837,
0.0414333828,
-0.0262989458,
0.0440195128,
0.0247019529,
-0.0110127265,
0.0133109633,
-0.0022159773,
-0.0948408544,
-0.0520320088,
-0.0440646634,
0.0218697079,
0.0040077735,
-0.0261434037,
0.0110159796,
-0.0015901793,
-0.0225313324,
-0.0334240124,
0.0114978133,
0.0681953803,
-0.0269815065,
0.0115257232,
0.0405355133,
-0.004255773,
0.011616976,
0.0602917112,
-0.0318327695,
0.0413420722,
0.0107396496,
-0.0050872187,
-0.0271090083,
0.017636776,
-0.0165167376,
0.048088152,
-0.0105588725,
0.0182673838,
-0.0272913687,
-0.0316574387,
-0.016781494,
0.0205687415,
-0.0236861631,
0.0269968733,
0.0680011511,
0.0915812626,
0.0163907949,
-0.0427055135,
-0.0237929299,
0.0417834446,
-0.0962020308,
-0.0343603827,
-0.0154322367,
-6.440065554e-33,
-0.0162090771,
-0.0812182128,
-0.0125636123,
-0.0401379354,
0.0273741987,
-0.0479515418,
-0.0236490462,
-0.0097892191,
-0.0386966802,
-0.0179560203,
-0.0221796371,
0.0219928306,
0.0027604976,
0.0260154568,
-0.0227939282,
-0.0073405392,
0.0274105836,
-0.0083640451,
-0.0106248967,
0.0408960544,
0.0707648993,
0.02714267,
0.0211099274,
-0.0857836977,
0.0108353496,
-0.0679703429,
-0.0126689458,
0.0557902046,
0.0117667029,
0.0531150475,
-0.0119450195,
0.0831000581,
0.0354572609,
-0.0370626934,
-0.0052704825,
0.0278730541,
-0.0314579047,
-0.059462361,
0.0039805258,
-0.0181580577,
0.005900586,
-0.0673226789,
0.041064404,
-0.0452017449,
-0.0214353092,
0.0068935649,
0.0669905096,
-0.0276748072,
-0.0484728068,
0.0022588894,
-0.0531425066,
0.0062562837,
-0.0017809179,
0.0118379351,
-0.0340250917,
0.0623803437,
0.0075476365,
0.040424265,
-0.0395371281,
0.0264304206,
0.0245792754,
0.0121939899,
0.0144203762,
0.0112976953,
-0.0024158838,
0.0272011943,
0.0453126281,
-0.0162269864,
-0.0319096334,
-0.027597677,
-0.0005467176,
0.015967425,
0.0313544199,
0.0660612881,
0.0574727692,
-0.0126885921,
-0.0817841887,
0.0527432859,
-0.0352103189,
-0.0100498926,
0.0253753942,
-0.0501345098,
-0.063306734,
-0.0130598843,
0.0051590786,
0.0007396634,
-0.0464678705,
-0.0228683334,
0.064237982,
0.0153458752,
-0.0388868302,
-0.0369065814,
0.0314635932,
-0.0271218996,
-0.0094307298,
0.0746785924,
-0.0328749418,
-0.0078948038,
0.0063263522,
0.0056460546,
-0.0018791426,
-0.0099706603,
0.0131121567,
-0.0328768529,
-0.0224853922,
0.0349516347,
0.0042643235,
-0.0144599378,
-0.0829993561,
0.0213752352,
-0.0016666733,
0.0238368679,
-0.0185052976,
-0.0003541274,
0.0201105345,
-0.0091101667,
0.0058437195,
0.0644190088,
0.0216120239,
0.0399712883,
-0.0275916979,
-0.0702755973,
-0.0117397504,
-0.0194572695,
-0.0292454287,
0.0285430681,
0.00904587,
0.0478939712,
0.0432047881,
-0.016056776,
0.0021452794,
0.0093476903,
2.706e-7,
0.0275498219,
0.0512171611,
0.0382573865,
0.027571138,
0.01132356,
0.0017794404,
0.0419372655,
0.0086998539,
0.0360474735,
-0.0263512135,
0.0036955136,
0.0054432396,
0.020170154,
0.0292065926,
-0.1044000536,
0.0366776325,
-0.0629567057,
-0.0247237869,
-0.0631938651,
0.003742533,
0.0627183691,
0.0770134106,
-0.0329692997,
-0.0232997052,
-0.0306510832,
-0.0588587336,
0.0416821539,
-0.0275980365,
-0.0137442229,
0.0064778361,
0.0691680983,
0.0208624396,
0.0392213464,
-0.0028768913,
-0.0053074164,
0.0160524193,
0.0302085131,
0.0272743963,
-0.0082148649,
-0.0561967827,
-0.0170130171,
-0.0090919975,
0.0204602219,
-0.0693191513,
0.086868912,
0.0076470207,
0.0017839745,
-0.0260088183,
-0.0157122277,
-0.0481629856,
0.0185306482,
-0.0382107981,
0.0025813389,
0.0069963066,
0.0206760801,
0.0107769677,
0.0413270928,
-0.0352211185,
-0.0203769319,
0.0054044118,
-0.0576133505,
-0.0572702363,
-0.0189994145,
0.0415852666,
0.0084831165,
-0.0193972196,
0.0275309347,
2.577941763e-34,
0.0291542318,
0.0184081625,
0.0135401273,
0.0098993359,
0.0112053091,
0.0178300571,
-0.0026167701,
0.0128387604,
0.0211431645,
-0.111548081,
-0.0304213315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01394v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01394v1 | Gloss2Text: Sign Language Gloss translation using LLMs and Semantically Aware Label Smoothing | 2024-07-01T15:46:45 | 2024-07-01T15:46:45 | Pooya Fayyazsanavi, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Jana Košecká | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Sign language translation from video to spoken text presents unique
challenges owing to the distinct grammar, expression nuances, and high
variation of visual appearance across different speakers and contexts. The
intermediate gloss annotations of videos aim to guide the translation process.
In our work, we focus on {\em Gloss2Text} translation stage and propose several
advances by leveraging pre-trained large language models (LLMs), data
augmentation, and novel label-smoothing loss function exploiting gloss
translation ambiguities improving significantly the performance of
state-of-the-art approaches. Through extensive experiments and ablation studies
on the PHOENIX Weather 2014T dataset, our approach surpasses state-of-the-art
performance in {\em Gloss2Text} translation, indicating its efficacy in
addressing sign language translation and suggesting promising avenues for
future research and development. | [
-0.0336639062,
0.0407453515,
0.0054755765,
0.0786298215,
0.0169876367,
0.0344776437,
0.0065078293,
0.003837721,
0.036362756,
-0.0407052226,
-0.031060189,
-0.0412637517,
0.0275926385,
-0.0016330148,
0.02078107,
-0.1017911285,
0.0347370692,
-0.0375724249,
-0.0320761055,
-0.0132387578,
0.0466058664,
0.0279964563,
-0.0074520167,
0.0230371505,
-0.0834655911,
0.0121382894,
0.0231803413,
0.059176024,
0.0435273051,
-0.0162274837,
-0.0664853528,
0.0224975515,
0.0688975975,
0.0238972306,
0.0000021521,
-0.009904041,
0.0189106446,
0.0067922971,
0.0369792841,
0.0313974656,
0.0874255002,
-0.0644438788,
0.0152976103,
0.0344465375,
-0.0413522869,
-0.0824776664,
0.067425862,
0.0288507491,
0.0377414487,
0.0218129642,
-0.0212747827,
-0.0457460806,
0.006982944,
-0.0381196328,
0.0147099569,
-0.0469658785,
0.0094879447,
0.0087006651,
-0.0311688483,
-0.0234825201,
-0.0421623513,
0.1096423417,
0.0103556002,
-0.0415960141,
-0.0286656413,
0.0149862468,
-0.0125513943,
-0.008658601,
-0.0045579742,
0.0563165247,
-0.035794232,
0.0357330702,
-0.0196982864,
-0.0321920179,
0.0161072016,
0.0132789901,
-0.0191800091,
0.011886091,
0.0423658304,
0.0196805894,
-0.0257058907,
0.0247735362,
0.0636845604,
-0.0015016078,
-0.0196883008,
0.0303698741,
0.0285029225,
0.017818464,
-0.0000261072,
-0.0002250911,
-0.0089621041,
0.000467508,
0.0245834421,
-0.0067098937,
0.0192899071,
0.0243972782,
-0.0424230769,
-0.0108073307,
-0.0224866122,
-0.0358852148,
0.0240662675,
0.046272561,
-0.0164356176,
0.0443233624,
0.0130878035,
0.0040803934,
-0.0037435666,
0.0776153952,
-0.0792011768,
-0.0273152534,
0.0076191062,
-0.0034608273,
-0.052668117,
-0.0298567936,
-0.0140464231,
-0.0112199793,
-0.0114017902,
-0.026201522,
0.037826445,
-0.0275977664,
0.0120023862,
-0.01313804,
-0.0172098689,
-0.0434966832,
0.0198816117,
0.0309379604,
0.0035574143,
0.0608523861,
-0.0024512757,
-0.0533714965,
-0.015283728,
0.0387140736,
0.0040169265,
0.0171875935,
-0.0148675786,
0.0563579351,
-0.0299779028,
-0.0242785215,
-0.0435075425,
0.0243564583,
-0.0237662029,
-0.0071414695,
-0.0303009767,
-0.0448446013,
0.0400521569,
-0.011067857,
0.0162657294,
-0.0649840981,
0.0128569286,
-0.0385926403,
-0.0246116947,
0.0665641651,
-0.0328150913,
0.0032591468,
0.0619160496,
0.0156113654,
-0.0016716358,
0.0596311614,
0.0617183745,
0.0132262157,
0.0178220216,
-0.0084682154,
0.0109021841,
0.0958456323,
-0.0126813585,
0.0509953387,
-0.033826258,
-0.0570942126,
0.0262820646,
0.0557024032,
0.0257082097,
0.0643128157,
-0.0224797893,
-0.0168263037,
0.0540596023,
0.0564237908,
-0.0331183225,
-0.0146553731,
0.0401706472,
0.0412980914,
-0.0058429497,
-0.0295792744,
-0.0077294204,
0.0012448262,
-0.0025637744,
-0.0237373784,
-0.0063286666,
0.0159402359,
-0.0365464389,
-0.0245561935,
-0.0139203146,
-0.0262443107,
0.0595584176,
-0.0032967136,
0.0085450727,
0.0163349994,
-0.022860121,
-0.0092738476,
0.008890694,
-0.0054982346,
0.0521599427,
-0.01232279,
-0.0562754497,
0.0290143769,
0.0001791528,
0.0235342011,
-0.0197121929,
-0.014936896,
0.022010712,
0.0313049294,
0.0139268804,
0.0223598983,
0.051500719,
-0.0696924329,
-0.014051388,
0.060132198,
0.0147316428,
-0.0093888612,
-0.0437370576,
0.0708153918,
0.0452260301,
-0.0260197055,
-0.0529477857,
0.0488913395,
0.0090355901,
-0.0396355502,
0.0440802537,
-0.0184061918,
0.0293569975,
-0.0127325505,
-0.0220807008,
-0.0203011595,
0.0129029844,
-0.046021726,
-0.0282240678,
0.063438043,
-0.0546312928,
-0.0639705136,
0.0266717337,
-0.01412242,
-0.0155781172,
0.0070121218,
-0.0398070402,
-0.0410066396,
-0.0005164099,
0.005730459,
0.066312097,
-0.0315548107,
0.0188159924,
0.0274018254,
-0.0013764476,
-0.0381016359,
-0.005042905,
-0.0387513861,
-0.0502372868,
-0.0654948428,
0.0137644429,
-0.0020704072,
-0.0342821218,
0.0040043164,
0.0518442988,
0.016979374,
0.024644265,
-0.0069637601,
0.0142284445,
-0.0512605757,
-0.0015289147,
-0.0867827162,
0.0128405867,
-0.0129849771,
0.0161200594,
0.0001598386,
0.0063353716,
-0.007444785,
-0.0066701146,
-0.0208695102,
0.0126248188,
0.0260442924,
-0.0524971895,
-0.0148865618,
-0.0069023217,
-0.0137691628,
-0.0286802743,
-0.0136138322,
0.0251791123,
0.0294580534,
0.0257107411,
-0.0831648856,
-0.0212565027,
-0.0055834414,
-0.0086176135,
-0.0089735063,
-0.0016067227,
-0.0293467361,
-0.0136454012,
-0.0205250308,
-0.0492940322,
-0.0075511197,
0.0169149619,
-0.0119862994,
-0.0086511532,
-0.0426545143,
-0.0343879573,
-0.0058659213,
-0.0118875047,
-0.0427093618,
-0.0804084316,
-0.0058073173,
-0.013292376,
0.0309521332,
0.0251860153,
0.0343019366,
-0.0535823628,
-0.0560680069,
-0.045746021,
-0.0494745001,
-0.0311626326,
0.0034464011,
-0.0329389274,
-0.0327638425,
-0.0285551101,
-0.0750963837,
0.0098466212,
-0.054723084,
-0.035326194,
0.0026598126,
0.0123597262,
-0.013714687,
0.060118489,
-0.0219700597,
0.0435187891,
-0.0562915765,
-0.0353952348,
-0.0269120224,
-0.0181369055,
-0.0000102365,
-0.0226570573,
-0.0074647903,
-0.0656064153,
-0.0000212052,
-0.0135097876,
0.021412516,
0.0046082963,
-0.0096764266,
-0.0228639394,
-0.0198549628,
0.0191538464,
-0.0424272045,
-0.0452714711,
-0.0237483568,
-0.0243259408,
0.0447284058,
0.0097627454,
0.0114085851,
-0.0114056226,
-0.0157661028,
0.0106315957,
0.021976931,
-0.0233834852,
-0.0570151396,
0.0010707305,
0.0003665196,
-0.0323446095,
-0.0033300933,
-0.0287564937,
0.0123184221,
0.0560728572,
0.0378877595,
-0.0411666073,
0.0130838081,
0.0455804951,
-0.0427249186,
0.0567743219,
0.0876130909,
0.0224689655,
-0.0616987981,
0.0041381652,
0.0075699789,
0.0341648944,
-0.0013323032,
-0.0222312547,
-0.1107415929,
-0.0647691265,
0.0028929519,
0.0589502789,
0.0724070966,
0.0084752794,
-0.0250132233,
-0.0251528583,
0.0514525585,
0.0702189878,
-0.074189797,
0.0076432861,
0.0068124286,
0.0153185846,
-0.0055730874,
0.0362779386,
-0.0304946862,
-0.0026094499,
-0.0118370727,
0.0243495014,
0.0114673069,
-0.0977151468,
-0.0147190141,
-0.011597381,
0.0370573066,
0.0073146815,
0.0142390551,
-0.0131565034,
-0.0379377641,
0.0689737275,
-0.0015537842,
0.0014825305,
-0.0540035404,
0.0321981981,
-0.0113862334,
-0.0213864204,
0.0192527082,
0.0470701233,
-0.0389877856,
0.0045416434,
0.0156637803,
0.0477413908,
-0.0147045478,
0.0050239335,
0.0188502707,
-0.0619516708,
0.0204686653,
0.0475294702,
-0.003776764,
-0.0156828687,
0.0161400139,
-0.0213656295,
0.0090762684,
0.0540409014,
-0.1045344621,
-0.0018177746,
-0.0420011356,
-0.0456870571,
-0.019936651,
-0.0188739654,
0.0711335167,
0.0226482432,
-0.0069817817,
0.0333819911,
0.0586532839,
-0.0174068939,
-0.0227869246,
0.0686184689,
-0.0612897053,
0.0381778926,
-0.06764061,
-0.0375433117,
-0.0054642772,
0.0120681049,
0.0066934326,
0.0697723478,
-0.0750812441,
-0.0573445819,
0.0226214547,
0.0298538841,
0.0143726952,
0.0343914069,
-0.0160282459,
-0.054707963,
-0.0093758721,
0.0291277375,
0.0408871658,
0.0385856442,
0.0191041678,
-0.0416742824,
-0.0079702297,
0.0303600114,
0.012501033,
0.031098187,
-0.0106769716,
0.0333467834,
-0.0757467225,
-0.063843891,
-0.0233064853,
0.0207423326,
0.0032942204,
-0.036896389,
-0.0463047177,
-0.0485900864,
0.0346586667,
0.0025278118,
-0.0052716243,
-0.0836376995,
0.0023035728,
0.0625830069,
0.0119628748,
-0.0085785082,
0.0149368411,
0.0014777981,
0.0087561235,
0.0042589554,
0.0205965396,
-0.013095784,
-0.0151982112,
0.0128471665,
0.0618359298,
-0.0006657476,
0.0439569317,
-0.0271418877,
-0.0014453677,
-0.0046563256,
0.0137877204,
0.0138695044,
0.0296484195,
0.0155705791,
0.0116262352,
0.0305582117,
-0.1103553846,
-0.0509538464,
0.0124462536,
0.0183252133,
0.0211411137,
0.0768869892,
-0.0277137905,
0.0126583921,
-0.0582104176,
0.0337684639,
-0.0028653729,
-0.0466014631,
0.0488936156,
-0.0418901667,
-0.0222466178,
0.0282105841,
0.0313939899,
-0.0293860678,
0.0129398499,
-0.0191815142,
0.000257736,
-0.0185486525,
-0.0400461219,
0.0346839465,
-0.0264009293,
-0.0106008491,
0.0179512482,
-0.0338436961,
-0.03799887,
-0.0191146508,
-0.0320729949,
-0.0186670385,
0.0160772502,
0.0364781544,
-0.0159355495,
-0.0279013552,
0.0011631721,
-0.0007394106,
-0.0474293679,
-0.02481254,
-0.0274556503,
-0.024754256,
-6.146798081e-33,
-0.0711681694,
-0.0054528862,
-0.0106971813,
-0.0100761708,
-0.0626935586,
0.0205627587,
-0.0224870797,
0.043656528,
-0.0038464938,
0.041738376,
0.0398560874,
0.0060624084,
0.0183402393,
0.0115920454,
0.0095313434,
-0.0036863803,
0.0453433245,
-0.0132997055,
0.0016424794,
0.0421118699,
0.0017970715,
0.0163490493,
0.0730322823,
-0.1295084506,
-0.0089930715,
-0.0282184705,
-0.0573681369,
0.0163954571,
0.0118446192,
-0.0007981485,
-0.0338376015,
0.0230240095,
-0.0172977448,
0.0374203771,
-0.0380912274,
-0.0069369297,
-0.0219495967,
0.0208260734,
0.0085884454,
0.0629310682,
-0.0401147716,
0.012374647,
0.0023435343,
-0.004059365,
-0.0370263308,
0.0248727705,
0.025349414,
-0.0402472541,
-0.0280998144,
-0.0303962212,
-0.0203402117,
0.0481347181,
-0.0234040599,
-0.0264591556,
0.0446007252,
-0.0322236344,
-0.0178088527,
0.0140150376,
-0.0170965102,
0.0086091477,
-0.0078937151,
0.0324975364,
0.068126671,
0.0257788803,
0.0077331089,
0.0352268182,
-0.0119762477,
-0.0393076949,
0.026666088,
-0.0479506217,
0.0924170166,
0.0097902305,
0.011602914,
0.0775666237,
0.0551797152,
-0.0385573655,
-0.0042809444,
0.0142071974,
-0.0106754927,
0.0653829277,
-0.0223870091,
0.0427150242,
0.0370637104,
-0.0120161492,
-0.0871576369,
0.0203251615,
0.0096339518,
0.0057825386,
0.0279562771,
0.0193574075,
0.0109253936,
0.0265712179,
0.089298822,
0.0182258002,
-0.0403388813,
-0.0142139923,
-0.0138778947,
0.0236485098,
-0.0181471482,
0.0498100743,
-0.0431599692,
-0.0515024513,
0.0508752242,
-0.0214742757,
0.0242603626,
-0.0320367962,
0.0179218464,
0.0650037378,
-0.0333820917,
0.0224758908,
-0.003420996,
-0.0136134699,
0.0047580833,
-0.0116307205,
0.0326520428,
-0.0174665321,
-0.0229601543,
0.0736586824,
0.0045292038,
0.0382438712,
0.0103952074,
-0.0044681313,
-0.0010449155,
0.0285905432,
-0.0546102338,
0.0381261744,
0.0165783912,
-0.0851786509,
0.0683354437,
-0.0653652027,
-0.0083345762,
-0.0022896654,
2.745e-7,
0.0735407546,
0.0695931613,
-0.0249979794,
0.0286453497,
0.0050373916,
0.028556129,
-0.0074435836,
0.0058384039,
0.0225383863,
0.0159266964,
0.0161646046,
0.028146185,
0.0675464943,
0.0159842893,
-0.0248556789,
0.0344236009,
-0.0145325512,
0.0581954122,
-0.0443510972,
0.0090431226,
0.0792143792,
0.1024982184,
-0.0077770278,
0.0080293175,
0.0303020291,
-0.0736101419,
0.0847986937,
-0.0592203438,
0.0001734587,
-0.0022899904,
0.0368829668,
0.0126502197,
-0.0232306011,
0.0119273327,
-0.0031725445,
0.0003080229,
0.0360970423,
0.0447790809,
-0.0359858051,
0.0070593241,
0.0004981674,
0.0175038818,
-0.0275506675,
-0.0203760993,
0.0455183536,
-0.0256154239,
0.0024534119,
0.004714089,
-0.032890033,
0.0382661484,
0.0308773965,
-0.0138352746,
-0.004083998,
0.0118013248,
0.0521722622,
-0.0379067585,
-0.0408687033,
-0.0678078234,
-0.0196605287,
-0.0189648923,
-0.0071168267,
-0.0033349693,
-0.0203747619,
0.0228256006,
-0.0260627978,
-0.0233815238,
-0.0195255224,
2.25230664e-34,
0.0395071357,
0.0003751245,
0.0139010688,
0.0239275843,
0.014679906,
-0.0050282371,
0.0347414799,
0.040770866,
-0.0237587262,
-0.0492113531,
0.0098526906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01393v1 | POLygraph: Polish Fake News Dataset | 2024-07-01T15:45:21 | 2024-07-01T15:45:21 | Daniel Dzienisiewicz, Filip Graliński, Piotr Jabłoński, Marek Kubis, Paweł Skórzewski, Piotr Wierzchoń | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the POLygraph dataset, a unique resource for fake news
detection in Polish. The dataset, created by an interdisciplinary team, is
composed of two parts: the "fake-or-not" dataset with 11,360 pairs of news
articles (identified by their URLs) and corresponding labels, and the
"fake-they-say" dataset with 5,082 news articles (identified by their URLs) and
tweets commenting on them. Unlike existing datasets, POLygraph encompasses a
variety of approaches from source literature, providing a comprehensive
resource for fake news detection. The data was collected through manual
annotation by expert and non-expert annotators. The project also developed a
software tool that uses advanced machine learning techniques to analyze the
data and determine content authenticity. The tool and dataset are expected to
benefit various entities, from public sector institutions to publishers and
fact-checking organizations. Further dataset exploration will foster fake news
detection and potentially stimulate the implementation of similar models in
other languages. The paper focuses on the creation and composition of the
dataset, so it does not include a detailed evaluation of the software tool for
content authenticity analysis, which is planned at a later stage of the
project. | [
0.0811020732,
0.0332392976,
-0.010059244,
0.0506402217,
-0.0499266014,
0.0391588546,
0.0276436228,
-0.0036768089,
0.019975679,
-0.0033412343,
0.045203384,
0.0323111266,
0.0138990656,
0.0682264864,
0.0131709799,
-0.0094185779,
0.0542018451,
0.0429387763,
0.0693855733,
-0.0207811836,
0.0470179543,
0.0583376177,
-0.0324893296,
0.0447555929,
-0.0463676453,
0.0035109795,
0.0284549054,
0.0175754074,
0.0285084415,
-0.0144089339,
-0.0008429032,
0.0199424513,
-0.0154634202,
0.0882979184,
0.0000016584,
-0.0313452296,
-0.0159363672,
-0.0019502204,
-0.0297003854,
-0.0261135604,
0.0548719577,
-0.0620623492,
-0.0232498441,
0.0095309997,
-0.0397003256,
-0.0300699268,
0.0496928617,
0.0407338254,
0.0830254629,
0.1077487096,
-0.0317110494,
0.0126794185,
0.0006872246,
0.0209889282,
-0.0241272673,
0.0028038188,
0.0722079873,
0.0178702101,
-0.0659891963,
0.0191172548,
0.0630926192,
0.015186674,
0.0087445481,
-0.0335882045,
-0.0618317984,
-0.015911283,
-0.0314303711,
-0.061517287,
0.006159828,
-0.006787647,
-0.0259290319,
-0.0856528953,
0.0209389105,
-0.0152244261,
-0.0124385888,
0.057036303,
0.0241413843,
0.0503690057,
-0.0362876728,
0.0210588835,
0.0036515982,
0.0121924728,
0.0201644264,
0.0487509035,
0.042217616,
0.0357198492,
-0.0074621565,
0.0014934037,
0.0226582475,
-0.0036101721,
0.0335727185,
-0.0560242385,
0.0554221943,
0.0009387859,
0.0037186034,
0.0102486415,
-0.0631499812,
-0.0352690443,
0.0445515364,
-0.0818284526,
-0.0368856676,
0.0125481067,
0.0039685769,
0.0473378636,
-0.0187138431,
-0.0071861921,
-0.0076849419,
0.0159307532,
-0.0101006459,
-0.0294182524,
-0.0084766047,
0.0237468798,
-0.005303869,
-0.002226288,
-0.022126399,
0.0262075569,
-0.0469348356,
0.0333535001,
-0.0115484782,
0.0553634204,
-0.0231484715,
0.009405164,
0.0032176282,
0.0043846336,
-0.019316962,
0.0527701601,
-0.0281991716,
0.04335884,
-0.0491496325,
-0.020835137,
0.0398491174,
0.027562974,
0.0288186315,
-0.0053508044,
0.0245363023,
-0.0185047947,
0.0149361687,
0.0148175564,
-0.0189854,
-0.0489311814,
-0.0024152214,
-0.0449914671,
-0.0007526114,
-0.066882357,
0.0224369541,
-0.0167948529,
-0.0225004144,
-0.0378359519,
-0.0152128134,
0.0465359502,
-0.025534099,
0.01901225,
-0.0577234589,
0.018541133,
0.0580565371,
0.0089206807,
0.0055180215,
0.0453514755,
-0.0050356733,
0.105596967,
0.0692380667,
0.0108819976,
0.0203764457,
0.0267630238,
0.0403552912,
0.0432817154,
0.0352409184,
0.0138081713,
-0.0255518612,
-0.0278478339,
0.0046016825,
0.0246644206,
-0.00370719,
-0.057075534,
0.0609373748,
-0.0147150503,
-0.0032074461,
-0.0138205718,
0.0327379555,
0.0226383004,
0.0280675385,
-0.0002720306,
0.0054539959,
-0.008047292,
-0.044772163,
-0.0124927862,
-0.0296456497,
0.0403874554,
0.0113877608,
-0.0217886698,
-0.0055704685,
0.0102619212,
0.0281013008,
-0.0281214528,
-0.0075030783,
-0.0073510897,
-0.0455081686,
-0.0338204242,
0.0228917114,
-0.0010704382,
-0.011160803,
-0.0410213545,
0.0545879602,
0.0132725872,
0.0139885964,
0.0035248289,
0.0270986278,
-0.0407031961,
0.0108658997,
0.0273618475,
0.0034940005,
-0.0370101668,
-0.0397283398,
0.0066296854,
-0.0137581853,
-0.020786332,
-0.0041267117,
0.0158565268,
0.020624578,
0.0556376576,
0.0172646847,
0.0000436246,
-0.0521697402,
0.0061369245,
-0.0056811613,
0.0208538063,
-0.0086758044,
0.0449007452,
0.0015280232,
0.0411207192,
0.0013497665,
-0.0376736261,
0.0660580397,
0.0482431687,
0.0174667705,
-0.0077081751,
0.0230870694,
0.0099893147,
0.0287985913,
-0.0992263034,
-0.0440635979,
0.0603408627,
-0.0070123347,
0.0119048767,
0.0226860307,
-0.0321742482,
-0.0292142909,
-0.0531282499,
-0.0254581571,
-0.0482414365,
0.0348753892,
0.0486443751,
0.0529635325,
-0.0234190878,
0.0384489298,
0.0176569335,
-0.0291834194,
0.024949288,
0.0064330976,
-0.0079662018,
0.0048250807,
-0.0349277481,
0.0152519159,
0.0133632682,
-0.0266797766,
-0.0110459356,
0.012754159,
-0.046358224,
0.0009565299,
-0.0101448018,
-0.0023606292,
0.0454028398,
-0.0141000338,
-0.006842603,
0.0259487517,
-0.0229154415,
-0.074178949,
0.0205514543,
0.0235804841,
0.0009488393,
-0.0311777778,
0.014441059,
0.0118782772,
0.0257006921,
-0.0327319019,
0.0103005422,
0.0383068733,
-0.0558386184,
-0.0277279373,
-0.0130193215,
-0.0499841049,
-0.0033744418,
-0.0302033853,
-0.0403624624,
-0.0005765298,
0.0215637181,
-0.0457049459,
0.0349962339,
0.0363243744,
0.028764572,
0.0333738811,
0.0372428894,
0.0034976341,
-0.0353858769,
-0.0464566574,
0.0711421818,
-0.0176005103,
-0.079996109,
0.0268545952,
-0.0318652578,
0.012154175,
0.0080459546,
0.0163834486,
0.0401025005,
-0.028878605,
-0.0285242181,
0.0257609431,
-0.0751110688,
-0.0109051224,
0.0298749134,
0.0024617543,
0.0084350873,
0.0659786835,
-0.0140066762,
0.0540803149,
-0.0409078561,
-0.0622523427,
0.0121151675,
0.034404669,
-0.0157736093,
0.0269226767,
-0.0098753246,
0.0163506009,
0.0291387327,
-0.0203629658,
0.0851021335,
-0.0257894136,
-0.0212841406,
0.0004878331,
0.0150537975,
-0.000250152,
0.0021628032,
-0.0435488075,
-0.0976050198,
-0.0100182602,
-0.0461305417,
0.0019100927,
-0.022520205,
-0.0524528958,
-0.02023739,
0.0080154371,
0.0524957366,
-0.0083926655,
0.0231658518,
0.0079245511,
0.0254745446,
0.0074424315,
-0.018368965,
0.0559027046,
-0.0048348033,
-0.0674577579,
0.0560624711,
-0.0359888934,
-0.0045587444,
-0.0045198067,
-0.0481427312,
-0.0161767453,
-0.0189296175,
0.037800435,
-0.0593805499,
-0.0116343703,
-0.0440276265,
0.0156342089,
0.0605508871,
0.0285061058,
-0.0182322003,
-0.020255683,
0.0355250798,
-0.0469295532,
0.0107007828,
-0.0017612337,
-0.0958229452,
0.0291758254,
0.0146236597,
0.004819111,
-0.1113816425,
-0.0271657221,
-0.0174822249,
-0.0705675557,
0.0098033277,
-0.0139618637,
-0.033700645,
-0.0433015116,
-0.0753351152,
-0.0176423322,
0.0109953415,
0.0060680634,
-0.0247819088,
0.0293358564,
-0.0130194873,
0.0166457389,
-0.0301954094,
-0.0755278245,
-0.0242372062,
0.0020293551,
0.0492680334,
-0.0086526629,
0.0493346974,
-0.0421277992,
-0.0305952188,
-0.0078489138,
0.0294304509,
-0.072215803,
-0.0008636726,
0.0741787553,
-0.0126050692,
-0.0126963388,
-0.0432930626,
0.0391021967,
0.0349379219,
-0.0029663697,
0.0106110247,
0.0236108769,
0.0219082851,
-0.0503427945,
-0.0256001875,
0.0094461609,
0.0644788072,
0.0448601916,
0.0077751223,
0.0307915043,
0.0004619313,
-0.0314953439,
-0.006506403,
-0.0228867289,
-0.0420424342,
0.063398622,
-0.0233507063,
-0.067215994,
-0.0629864484,
-0.018338209,
-0.0059701102,
0.0292833056,
-0.0008302896,
-0.0221033972,
0.023844758,
-0.0178168956,
-0.0683841705,
-0.017273454,
-0.0066282949,
0.0467542298,
-0.0064512719,
0.0059613152,
-0.0246448442,
-0.0061669461,
-0.0009485921,
0.0314378738,
-0.0603634901,
-0.0333498344,
0.0222234707,
-0.0092756841,
0.0214985907,
0.0411984548,
-0.0175953265,
-0.0247981083,
0.031961143,
0.0565725155,
-0.0537889488,
-0.0315670222,
0.0148375118,
-0.0311909001,
0.0283217058,
-0.0094287535,
-0.0143482294,
0.0131271565,
0.0043430873,
-0.0833329186,
-0.0322702453,
0.0023873411,
0.024862295,
0.0416702032,
-0.002675595,
0.0101593425,
0.0015387578,
-0.0572548546,
-0.0170316771,
-0.0357268006,
-0.0241832472,
-0.0007810679,
0.0127683198,
0.0224734508,
-0.0020902024,
-0.0119584491,
0.018003257,
-0.0459577143,
0.0006970672,
-0.0671769902,
-0.007736973,
0.025115503,
0.0620470829,
-0.0054720254,
-0.0218564961,
-0.0395706519,
0.0285744052,
0.0104990983,
0.0279417671,
0.0012968942,
-0.0414852612,
0.0374144726,
-0.0522033647,
0.0486279018,
-0.0241149422,
-0.0292066876,
0.0453375429,
-0.0534660853,
0.0105329556,
0.0171863846,
-0.0183678064,
0.0366684422,
-0.0196501967,
-0.0189290363,
0.0069274586,
-0.0183062032,
-0.022078624,
-0.0355614237,
-0.0081111006,
-0.0118048964,
-0.0510283262,
0.057676211,
0.0141437873,
0.0113940872,
0.0189479217,
0.0282297246,
-0.0777714401,
-0.0209751278,
0.0062825326,
-0.021553386,
0.0283040795,
-0.0205226429,
-0.045536954,
-0.0468610898,
-0.0494213142,
-0.0253351294,
0.0137616768,
0.032244809,
0.0458047874,
-0.0377791114,
0.0540461689,
0.0365656316,
0.0396472365,
-0.0580260418,
0.0378229879,
-0.002897433,
-0.0377853177,
0.0104025966,
-5.900938662e-33,
0.0578441098,
-0.0769540295,
-0.0287397578,
0.0068265102,
0.0080489516,
0.045667015,
-0.0024231253,
-0.0337216519,
-0.0472460724,
0.0472748317,
0.026817333,
0.0230578799,
0.0203985274,
-0.0090228915,
-0.062370643,
0.013104571,
0.0377812497,
0.0139203044,
-0.0237313975,
0.0002120209,
0.0579673462,
-0.0394226685,
0.0638815463,
-0.1169864237,
0.0611034892,
-0.0562637039,
-0.0793321058,
-0.001767652,
0.0031659685,
0.0545337312,
-0.0077506066,
0.0281107072,
0.0218918566,
-0.0153520675,
0.0103281271,
0.0175040942,
-0.0208656248,
-0.0291614495,
0.0476012267,
0.0319410041,
-0.0255170316,
0.0054139332,
0.0567718074,
-0.0165584423,
-0.0279571395,
0.0405286811,
0.0456524715,
-0.0323247761,
-0.0069158678,
-0.0146227321,
-0.049269896,
0.0211198628,
-0.0143562686,
0.0151157063,
0.0009400812,
0.0599938035,
0.0292112287,
-0.0144500211,
-0.1048231646,
0.0232467633,
-0.0275271311,
-0.0203301329,
0.0055781766,
-0.0616330579,
-0.0154538956,
0.0254986193,
0.0258990433,
0.0145993633,
-0.0098650465,
0.033985585,
0.0215035602,
0.0251061022,
0.0580893494,
0.1161786839,
-0.0045667375,
-0.0897414684,
-0.0910570025,
0.0249593426,
0.0770098045,
-0.0254829749,
0.0120849144,
-0.0624522492,
-0.0233988017,
0.0107009038,
-0.0027833497,
-0.0305105224,
-0.0420821607,
-0.0204484873,
-0.0257889368,
0.0150263077,
-0.0595651343,
0.0779309571,
0.0066824881,
-0.059540268,
-0.0136594418,
0.0351554081,
-0.0592114329,
0.0276277997,
0.0201324467,
0.0612901002,
-0.0489803217,
-0.0041565984,
0.030400157,
0.0179059636,
0.0405832753,
-0.0199749935,
0.0617572479,
0.0145243518,
-0.0460753143,
0.0383753926,
-0.0098976605,
0.0585716628,
-0.0098524997,
-0.0008410635,
0.0290465672,
0.0053743641,
-0.0189848896,
-0.0159525983,
0.0102999117,
0.0034522223,
-0.0321853869,
-0.0086755482,
-0.0124283843,
0.0168439075,
-0.0231474601,
-0.0121962763,
-0.0153936995,
0.0196411572,
0.0099258395,
-0.0316880718,
0.0257815775,
-0.0000351444,
2.584e-7,
0.0077783479,
0.0457289778,
-0.0106775872,
0.0041810032,
0.0178424343,
0.0259256233,
0.0212045163,
0.0061671557,
-0.0128680971,
-0.0589672402,
-0.0102326572,
-0.0349857956,
0.0238859933,
0.0611373186,
-0.0745076761,
0.0311773065,
-0.0588150546,
-0.0057392647,
-0.0689590201,
0.0230097398,
0.0023390064,
0.0691453293,
0.0765404627,
-0.0296392106,
-0.0255379342,
-0.000932936,
0.0032007054,
0.0637689084,
-0.0581476726,
0.0044930321,
0.0657537952,
-0.0087065259,
0.0377146266,
0.0246937498,
-0.0158878155,
0.0093760034,
0.000570222,
0.0124344025,
0.0291271023,
0.0040984787,
-0.003717012,
-0.0724157169,
0.0298283082,
-0.0744913891,
0.0786448047,
0.0285498202,
-0.0320713446,
-0.0548023693,
-0.0563585609,
0.0049614199,
0.0551777668,
-0.0055249208,
-0.0275634769,
0.0479923971,
-0.0162944365,
0.0044744606,
0.0010557689,
-0.0030906561,
0.0207469668,
-0.0318031795,
-0.0187135637,
-0.0180272348,
0.0161845274,
-0.0309063587,
0.0390687175,
-0.0098366123,
0.0495983772,
2.00267595e-34,
0.0138196899,
-0.0216121152,
-0.0025041301,
-0.0531708449,
0.0278289467,
0.0149030201,
-0.0363374203,
0.0014683128,
-0.0111157876,
0.0309753269,
0.0031559765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01384v1 | Free-text Rationale Generation under Readability Level Control | 2024-07-01T15:34:17 | 2024-07-01T15:34:17 | Yi-Sheng Hsu, Nils Feldhus, Sherzod Hakimov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Free-text rationales justify model decisions in natural language and thus
become likable and accessible among approaches to explanation across many
tasks. However, their effectiveness can be hindered by misinterpretation and
hallucination. As a perturbation test, we investigate how large language models
(LLMs) perform the task of natural language explanation (NLE) under the effects
of readability level control, i.e., being prompted for a rationale targeting a
specific expertise level, such as sixth grade or college. We find that
explanations are adaptable to such instruction, but the requested readability
is often misaligned with the measured text complexity according to traditional
readability metrics. Furthermore, the quality assessment shows that LLMs'
ratings of rationales across text complexity exhibit a similar pattern of
preference as observed in natural language generation (NLG). Finally, our human
evaluation suggests a generally satisfactory impression on rationales at all
readability levels, with high-school-level readability being most commonly
perceived and favored. | [
0.0183457304,
0.0255935714,
-0.0068051815,
0.0174803622,
-0.0248014051,
0.0195535794,
0.053770557,
-0.0195072647,
0.0041552996,
-0.0249017123,
0.0363761187,
-0.0390475914,
0.0314580165,
0.0123084951,
0.0192618482,
-0.0703272372,
0.0029945835,
-0.0411961265,
0.0638358444,
0.0042925919,
-0.0001015132,
0.0441961959,
-0.015143929,
0.0484207422,
0.059519209,
-0.038511239,
-0.0096580805,
0.001088936,
-0.0011433434,
-0.0294264909,
-0.0250483453,
0.0153320422,
0.0306274034,
0.0077521084,
0.0000022208,
-0.0506849177,
0.0010049317,
0.0120175835,
-0.0580635034,
0.0645036772,
0.0332627445,
0.0182916261,
0.0101773702,
0.0031336842,
0.0172767136,
0.0677855685,
0.0389836729,
0.0515956916,
0.0384824798,
0.0442152433,
0.0167490318,
-0.0629030839,
-0.0188487004,
-0.0058006411,
0.0272096489,
-0.0136315078,
-0.0306004398,
0.0381992236,
-0.0021717472,
0.0351402126,
0.0006061789,
0.0009073447,
0.0230112616,
-0.0603626296,
0.0305087175,
0.030123869,
0.0484831631,
-0.0180879626,
0.0097184284,
0.0715168491,
0.00502434,
-0.0447855033,
0.0114004472,
-0.045543965,
0.010729,
0.0468887053,
-0.0575378351,
0.0684925094,
0.0016800863,
0.0191308986,
0.0357423499,
0.0071740653,
0.0386327244,
0.0271859001,
-0.0101704337,
0.0301039219,
-0.0200448222,
-0.0188448392,
0.0018624096,
-0.0051301452,
-0.0190519951,
-0.0628434569,
0.0051915376,
0.0503783785,
-0.0393560193,
0.0142195029,
-0.0214070044,
0.0061655762,
0.0042960318,
-0.0230159089,
0.0179548152,
0.0341976061,
0.0266682729,
0.0204889737,
-0.0099504013,
0.0632024929,
0.0001993943,
0.0267576221,
-0.006156587,
0.0278137662,
-0.0500311591,
-0.0310259648,
-0.0178305916,
0.0092994226,
-0.0728534907,
-0.026763292,
-0.0266078934,
-0.0206978526,
-0.005180676,
-0.0176060926,
0.0165696498,
0.023336323,
-0.015554321,
-0.0511826947,
-0.0551264919,
0.028428169,
-0.058152914,
0.0036922013,
0.043430686,
-0.0033869888,
0.0039337366,
0.0306204576,
0.0080070011,
-0.0088686571,
-0.0254957862,
0.0424796045,
-0.0272034686,
0.0298242215,
-0.0661377981,
-0.0641253963,
-0.0055147908,
-0.0512599461,
-0.0239386968,
-0.0139158498,
-0.0271853693,
0.0245073121,
-0.0023592669,
-0.030716639,
-0.0036883517,
0.0200451631,
-0.052713424,
0.0396682397,
-0.0262466185,
0.0238415338,
0.0159027074,
0.0213352665,
-0.0234883875,
0.0374822766,
0.044945959,
0.0045353295,
0.0280764718,
-0.0605291948,
0.0047098156,
-0.0382936038,
-0.0261047948,
-0.0174237788,
-0.0267047435,
-0.016329376,
-0.0877744108,
0.0561335087,
0.0280370656,
0.0325163193,
-0.0088224467,
0.0313588791,
0.0469568521,
0.0577152036,
0.0642625391,
0.0248205252,
0.0435388796,
0.0574326217,
-0.0042084591,
0.0495806709,
-0.02263931,
0.040569555,
-0.0338858366,
0.024539886,
0.0119063929,
-0.0060200063,
0.0098500578,
-0.0749495849,
0.0064641912,
0.0115372473,
0.0252347514,
-0.0193565935,
0.0216063857,
-0.0043258364,
-0.0541616119,
0.0088115027,
0.0070553152,
-0.0744688883,
0.0206290931,
-0.0447954647,
0.0854805484,
0.1218136325,
0.0197946895,
0.0122118564,
0.0129429726,
0.0007558092,
0.0305898692,
0.0667397827,
0.0191454869,
-0.0011097019,
0.0172973629,
-0.0593711585,
-0.0272678006,
-0.0407924876,
0.025614934,
-0.0029674764,
-0.0196628533,
-0.0087417634,
0.0479262024,
-0.0581632741,
-0.0831430852,
0.0222320203,
-0.0489158928,
-0.0396477468,
-0.034430258,
-0.0020420244,
-0.0040770527,
0.0298299938,
-0.0011255037,
0.0451967381,
-0.0131839262,
-0.0296936799,
-0.0164992623,
0.0282098036,
-0.0544953346,
0.0048623513,
-0.0056878482,
-0.0364111066,
0.0034425128,
-0.0136287361,
0.0023368285,
-0.0428577252,
0.050583601,
-0.054512579,
0.0393829048,
0.006786807,
0.0166313518,
-0.022197606,
-0.0411451384,
-0.0293859616,
0.0581039749,
0.0312096011,
0.0090689901,
0.046871379,
0.0098930327,
-0.0005630897,
-0.0092429379,
0.0374583155,
0.0111098569,
0.0019507431,
-0.0063741338,
0.0267713163,
0.0093152672,
-0.0314278044,
-0.0081293499,
0.0042650839,
0.0030441696,
-0.0245627742,
0.0064202044,
0.0337214023,
-0.0442421697,
0.0081591224,
0.0207416862,
-0.0227102302,
0.010791094,
-0.0081519429,
0.0069341264,
0.0432395041,
0.0019789836,
-0.0259020571,
-0.023911003,
-0.0198033974,
-0.0177788418,
0.064404428,
0.0962290466,
0.0364071652,
-0.0806871578,
0.0330402665,
-0.0116042253,
-0.0542043522,
-0.0003874822,
-0.0309798047,
0.0447859615,
0.0272331592,
0.0356573313,
0.0882336721,
0.0322485529,
0.0473414101,
0.0551550873,
0.0062233601,
-0.0422418416,
-0.0247173775,
-0.0136339795,
-0.0000344077,
-0.0305006783,
-0.0818024799,
0.0058701416,
0.0737438798,
0.0051134587,
0.0169632472,
-0.0866950899,
0.0581604131,
-0.038704142,
-0.0225105993,
-0.024811184,
-0.0605076142,
0.0031725049,
0.0878981501,
-0.0001550222,
-0.0547310859,
0.0622933097,
-0.0299833696,
0.0115716802,
-0.0207286086,
0.0014752958,
-0.0346820243,
0.0505522601,
-0.0343100168,
0.0230417028,
0.0231581032,
-0.0319008343,
-0.0100553399,
-0.0342134759,
0.0404266268,
0.0107342442,
0.0432065278,
-0.0797085315,
-0.0352694578,
0.0217721816,
0.0263955016,
-0.0001369903,
-0.0254551787,
-0.0318867452,
-0.0380765833,
0.0481760949,
-0.0445369035,
-0.0113483742,
-0.0013242608,
0.0697316974,
0.0072355163,
-0.0267703552,
-0.0065482035,
-0.0009345418,
0.0023332839,
0.0210980903,
0.0290843323,
0.0412488207,
-0.0522519909,
0.0478032045,
0.020432895,
-0.0274553988,
-0.0065964712,
-0.0243208092,
-0.0101348627,
-0.0057164365,
-0.0304486137,
-0.0234730393,
0.041606497,
0.0832676291,
-0.0795644447,
0.0174156185,
0.1199482456,
0.0125658233,
0.0141633283,
0.0130773736,
-0.0345925018,
0.0649105385,
-0.0039081089,
-0.0106076524,
-0.0132607911,
-0.0222165268,
-0.0070701847,
0.0629575327,
-0.0190280285,
-0.0014634894,
-0.0116227781,
-0.0814823136,
0.0440329425,
0.022452455,
-0.0090220887,
-0.0081236688,
-0.0690636262,
-0.0484308861,
0.0031950301,
0.0116039263,
0.0274342839,
-0.0180809796,
0.0155687286,
0.0426889099,
-0.0597137101,
-0.0306726601,
-0.0022008154,
0.0161089804,
0.0369741283,
0.0262967087,
0.0336042866,
-0.0030129289,
-0.0623681061,
0.0129652554,
0.0171202533,
0.04002003,
-0.0114411693,
0.0395973846,
0.0505898111,
-0.0001343625,
-0.0784268305,
0.0241765138,
0.0005795597,
-0.0318425708,
0.0097697033,
0.0595538244,
0.0006025042,
-0.0474910438,
-0.0091290921,
0.0348280966,
-0.0158571806,
0.0933861956,
0.0703675821,
-0.0325060263,
-0.037897829,
-0.0595765412,
-0.0034578212,
-0.092900008,
-0.0413751602,
0.0063820505,
0.0166604165,
-0.0243204832,
-0.0338651054,
-0.0082501965,
0.0086952522,
0.0129612461,
0.0192617793,
-0.0050785486,
0.0048822979,
-0.0224222094,
-0.0179139618,
0.0436314531,
-0.0101692555,
0.0105538098,
-0.0356798507,
-0.0255416185,
-0.0356803462,
-0.0521967225,
0.0026897306,
0.0085152052,
0.0363491327,
-0.0564412251,
-0.0295477677,
0.005168071,
0.0341870449,
0.0237358361,
0.0355083719,
-0.0708737001,
-0.011033453,
-0.0413331613,
-0.0247134697,
0.0084953606,
0.0174032431,
0.0224943012,
0.0275174454,
0.026474053,
-0.0156631544,
-0.0160122253,
-0.0190432798,
0.0384526178,
-0.0031182722,
-0.0223435145,
0.0207392126,
0.0376598425,
-0.027230924,
-0.0228411239,
0.0006908694,
-0.0436975323,
-0.0042970981,
-0.067834489,
0.0054412414,
-0.0292125195,
0.0096087214,
0.0215886254,
-0.0447308086,
0.0088294959,
-0.022625275,
-0.0468868129,
0.0036901531,
0.000823995,
0.0657792091,
-0.0466287844,
0.02314559,
0.0321407989,
-0.0013470167,
-0.0462934524,
-0.0106373085,
-0.0503830388,
0.0517232865,
0.0351602621,
0.0873388648,
0.0119856689,
-0.0018229631,
0.0027683473,
-0.0107310321,
-0.0292609408,
-0.0637581944,
0.0388828777,
-0.0299850609,
-0.0252538286,
-0.0183439553,
0.107536912,
-0.0200461242,
0.0234780107,
-0.0055951192,
0.0804220289,
0.0411536023,
-0.0524165444,
-0.0052889595,
0.0103852274,
-0.0248220451,
-0.0339487232,
0.0932195708,
0.0211108904,
-0.0112670176,
-0.0017178507,
-0.0166332368,
-0.0182831474,
-0.0253987778,
-0.0242457967,
0.0461748727,
-0.0122562014,
-0.0146526825,
-0.091233775,
-0.032937862,
-0.0289327893,
0.0055637276,
0.006036995,
-0.0393174849,
0.0137182148,
0.0381297879,
-0.0473767258,
-0.0386576205,
-0.0220292248,
0.0536928736,
-0.0567022115,
0.0313167684,
-0.0361548252,
-6.499511038e-33,
-0.0039341366,
-0.0682561994,
0.0028644311,
-0.0560695603,
-0.0217802823,
0.0004170372,
-0.0852248222,
0.0261212401,
0.0138107659,
0.0353182554,
0.0253348723,
0.0026752029,
0.0018265084,
0.0107108233,
-0.006669932,
-0.024514636,
0.0412807316,
0.0308157261,
-0.0358710885,
0.0375869386,
0.0435288548,
-0.0326116867,
0.0374264419,
-0.0569763407,
0.080700919,
0.005324746,
-0.0129941935,
0.0040852735,
-0.0213346835,
0.0397003405,
-0.0050012115,
0.0130139524,
0.0132400021,
-0.0701455995,
-0.0134307928,
0.0554035641,
-0.0107221305,
-0.0029093402,
0.0665873066,
-0.0287925303,
-0.0427107736,
-0.0793225318,
0.0337487645,
0.0073539675,
-0.0075086378,
-0.0274894945,
0.0339300781,
-0.0301385727,
0.0076361843,
0.0188925546,
-0.0519995503,
0.0250053816,
-0.0729065016,
-0.0158542339,
-0.022797484,
0.052788388,
-0.0085240165,
0.0447520316,
0.0101652136,
0.0229539145,
0.0626129285,
0.0057374141,
0.0679359958,
-0.0166832246,
-0.0078415265,
0.0386726484,
-0.0003834897,
0.0338905863,
-0.0950310156,
0.0125389351,
-0.0211577825,
0.0240331069,
0.0898104608,
0.0275562853,
0.0623463802,
0.0106256967,
-0.0742705911,
0.0097322846,
-0.0547888018,
0.0176875498,
0.0217342321,
0.0034651952,
-0.060509786,
-0.0337547697,
-0.0477250926,
0.0103929583,
-0.0232197661,
-0.0413500033,
0.0313467011,
-0.0495744683,
-0.0416127183,
-0.0479559377,
-0.0337354243,
-0.0084716668,
0.0022268514,
0.0256763212,
-0.0117287897,
0.0048996364,
-0.025853131,
-0.0144037642,
-0.0380187295,
0.0169572085,
0.0065124482,
0.0059598223,
0.0420299433,
0.0237113778,
-0.0042779711,
-0.0136905182,
-0.0239002854,
-0.002891873,
-0.0520270094,
-0.0177463628,
-0.0014889248,
-0.0065134699,
0.0239886492,
-0.0000534615,
-0.0369976237,
0.0096253976,
-0.0238047484,
-0.012320241,
-0.0056815469,
-0.0079187956,
-0.0038828957,
0.0148733631,
-0.031965103,
-0.0342934467,
-0.0116769336,
0.0068902997,
0.0389269926,
-0.0469475165,
-0.0288234036,
0.0062911101,
2.785e-7,
0.0138693592,
0.0735669285,
0.0158936642,
-0.0110630989,
-0.0080725681,
0.0203166846,
0.0240777414,
-0.0465525277,
0.0048460662,
-0.0278367735,
-0.0195606481,
0.0098534841,
0.0566758364,
0.0085040815,
-0.0378213823,
-0.0217276569,
-0.0343531482,
0.0097772414,
-0.0302629713,
0.0242386069,
0.1002968997,
-0.029109491,
-0.0047745332,
0.0098008746,
0.0163905006,
-0.0336621888,
0.0195445661,
-0.0516562648,
0.0241070688,
0.021663202,
0.0795666724,
0.0029710184,
0.0248556621,
0.0116678029,
-0.0333333313,
-0.0255809221,
-0.0288437046,
0.0765080005,
-0.0006806208,
-0.0170598887,
-0.0052421596,
-0.0476742163,
0.0089890221,
-0.0723187923,
0.0471449941,
-0.0263844728,
-0.038232591,
0.040270485,
-0.0297007225,
-0.0308207944,
-0.0346665978,
-0.0142658278,
-0.0076183267,
-0.0116921347,
-0.0087090721,
-0.0256508756,
0.037779171,
-0.0365981236,
-0.0440579392,
0.0120154843,
-0.0017245989,
0.0007394729,
-0.0534343384,
0.0354947411,
0.058632303,
-0.0388673693,
0.0028002206,
2.337816048e-34,
0.02236907,
0.0014781663,
0.0478203632,
-0.0155818956,
0.0474709421,
0.0348657146,
0.02066046,
-0.0208348911,
0.0591144189,
-0.0376076251,
-0.0165532101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01376v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01376v1 | Badllama 3: removing safety finetuning from Llama 3 in minutes | 2024-07-01T15:29:45 | 2024-07-01T15:29:45 | Dmitrii Volkov | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | We show that extensive LLM safety fine-tuning is easily subverted when an
attacker has access to model weights. We evaluate three state-of-the-art
fine-tuning methods-QLoRA, ReFT, and Ortho-and show how algorithmic advances
enable constant jailbreaking performance with cuts in FLOPs and optimisation
power. We strip safety fine-tuning from Llama 3 8B in one minute and Llama 3
70B in 30 minutes on a single GPU, and sketch ways to reduce this further. | [
-0.0057323934,
0.0193818249,
-0.0134618981,
0.0568357781,
-0.0205029193,
-0.0170996338,
-0.0036836721,
-0.0305208806,
0.007071353,
-0.0041230973,
-0.0176325459,
0.0174586494,
0.0094002979,
0.0066693616,
0.0406143628,
0.0444137938,
0.0642563403,
-0.0243054722,
-0.0220500566,
0.0189985018,
0.0018503828,
-0.0530536622,
0.0336720645,
-0.0535930581,
0.0478385128,
0.0021863102,
-0.0267282389,
0.0618882999,
0.0364534222,
-0.0162276514,
0.0007635535,
-0.0175141077,
-0.0261266753,
0.0225197319,
0.0000023003,
-0.0012427624,
-0.0360009223,
0.0501370095,
0.0028693387,
0.073433578,
-0.034170568,
-0.0421103388,
-0.0173659883,
0.0302910376,
0.0081385989,
0.0463501215,
0.0151491109,
0.0390175022,
0.057045158,
0.026128795,
0.0323510095,
0.0277964342,
0.0695337802,
-0.055536814,
0.0137031814,
-0.0617026947,
-0.0060045361,
-0.0186222475,
0.0218171608,
-0.010266494,
-0.0193995889,
-0.0249532759,
0.0171782654,
-0.0009257182,
-0.0295841657,
-0.0297022741,
-0.0340353288,
-0.0003184079,
-0.0217545796,
0.0401123576,
-0.0865911022,
-0.0151600493,
0.0067691109,
-0.0123928264,
-0.0138746332,
-0.0685117319,
0.0179732405,
0.0076760724,
-0.0012940507,
0.000441946,
0.0417159684,
-0.0286610853,
0.0527569912,
-0.0311993118,
0.0386190005,
0.0601347834,
0.0363942906,
-0.0179465096,
0.0141415372,
0.0091920095,
0.0000467038,
-0.0164704975,
-0.0455412492,
-0.0268964749,
0.0223311409,
0.0085775601,
-0.0587934367,
0.0334187895,
0.018393755,
-0.0367626548,
0.0092565734,
0.0335283205,
-0.0013027098,
-0.0195831172,
-0.0487829633,
-0.0526746698,
-0.0590414517,
0.0647758096,
0.0124210129,
0.059088625,
0.0915387645,
0.0176117625,
0.0269195475,
0.0334727168,
-0.0540915765,
0.0397939309,
-0.0260136239,
0.0030638529,
-0.0298681948,
-0.0029982154,
-0.0231457092,
0.0421864986,
0.0095487889,
0.0304018147,
0.0427276343,
-0.0717355683,
-0.0248436835,
0.0088746669,
-0.0107072731,
-0.0677587762,
-0.019579526,
-0.009715436,
-0.0814466849,
0.0110127069,
0.0175033808,
0.0944787562,
0.0212702695,
-0.051379893,
-0.0838500634,
-0.0584865212,
-0.0055451198,
-0.0586774759,
0.0027386516,
-0.0487609431,
-0.0048734918,
-0.0446251668,
0.0187637303,
-0.0393642262,
0.0244147442,
0.0013030519,
-0.0323246866,
0.0604444034,
-0.045028761,
-0.0492340513,
-0.0348833278,
0.0708373338,
0.004838773,
0.0384369083,
0.0218132604,
0.0422276668,
0.0453415252,
0.0155853583,
0.0052350303,
0.0252111442,
0.0311200935,
0.0254064724,
-0.0176803321,
0.0001789085,
0.0102153346,
0.0097805494,
-0.0144745996,
0.030382067,
-0.0108208247,
-0.0425757691,
0.0147144888,
-0.0145649519,
-0.0200648271,
0.0416019671,
-0.0565795191,
-0.053619694,
0.0250357948,
-0.0136490809,
-0.0681281984,
0.047522027,
-0.0670453832,
0.0015936765,
-0.0041158255,
0.0574383363,
-0.0057723876,
0.015496688,
-0.004408787,
-0.0429520272,
-0.0516884252,
-0.0152476672,
-0.0416938029,
-0.0098384442,
-0.0012298989,
0.0607426614,
0.0513289683,
-0.0592467338,
-0.080994226,
-0.0732123032,
-0.0025536984,
0.0264550894,
0.0014711354,
0.0209826976,
-0.0439173318,
0.0263432562,
-0.0031856683,
-0.008086225,
-0.0414584987,
0.0383521728,
0.066533871,
-0.0214905906,
0.0168853011,
0.00190379,
0.0108128563,
0.0412220396,
0.0381912515,
-0.0318485908,
-0.0159862414,
-0.0281579588,
-0.0128413951,
0.0165248476,
-0.0079139378,
-0.065504767,
0.0524445623,
0.0148835015,
0.0020122791,
-0.0260551069,
-0.0273561198,
-0.0125109414,
0.0545483641,
-0.0036583347,
0.0410600193,
-0.0234222449,
-0.0484275222,
0.0244869906,
0.0363307111,
-0.029448254,
0.0290352348,
0.0244807247,
-0.0674692318,
-0.0231687594,
0.0562757589,
0.0121363774,
-0.0117362496,
0.0236518495,
0.0161673222,
0.0083214454,
0.0131831449,
-0.0328820273,
0.0003597157,
-0.0367491879,
-0.0111503452,
0.0140017532,
0.0244454388,
0.0008644911,
0.0264477544,
-0.0469825938,
-0.0029620605,
0.0033304975,
0.0160727166,
-0.0633350015,
0.0501946732,
0.0240847841,
-0.0378513895,
-0.007346021,
0.0394185968,
-0.0436990298,
0.0492515974,
0.0191512164,
0.0032395374,
-0.0228838287,
-0.0191277824,
0.0228720699,
0.0114414906,
-0.039711386,
-0.0066178055,
-0.0189125519,
0.0004825647,
-0.057517156,
-0.0074699451,
-0.0224536266,
0.0241486654,
0.0146272331,
-0.0459814146,
-0.0088759689,
-0.0029000645,
0.0043244502,
-0.0115441941,
0.0169755686,
-0.0196938049,
0.0040246788,
0.0160589609,
0.0277957562,
-0.0390424244,
0.0637330934,
-0.045349896,
0.0492368713,
0.0609473847,
0.030470863,
-0.0029368573,
0.0024225153,
0.0851892605,
-0.0717515796,
-0.0177374911,
0.0107023474,
-0.0209822934,
0.0312729441,
-0.0271443762,
-0.0270166006,
0.0024056311,
-0.0072357538,
0.0478858836,
-0.0165599789,
0.054248549,
0.0275932569,
-0.0438080281,
-0.0016953691,
-0.0054836157,
-0.0721611232,
-0.0022375339,
-0.0377432257,
0.0207183547,
0.0479840524,
-0.033218842,
-0.0364445336,
-0.0214229878,
-0.0407786109,
0.0269110296,
-0.0333011299,
0.0126791149,
0.0171121638,
-0.0424181297,
0.0178179778,
-0.0139885331,
0.0365499705,
-0.0460739583,
-0.0014491102,
-0.0539212525,
-0.0581356734,
0.0173985232,
0.0017187084,
-0.0457201004,
-0.0040159388,
0.0107985158,
-0.035042841,
0.0128795328,
-0.0474415943,
0.0033755072,
-0.0433230996,
-0.04676212,
-0.0291368067,
-0.0194804221,
-0.0203078147,
0.0028252739,
-0.0407202765,
0.0692363083,
-0.0080676796,
0.0436287858,
0.0558261685,
0.0404775366,
0.0062700287,
-0.0701413825,
0.016753288,
0.0296591409,
0.0072030784,
-0.0180986933,
0.0515547432,
0.0347025618,
0.024812391,
-0.0240545291,
-0.0470052324,
-0.0082771964,
-0.0115657682,
0.039199058,
0.0193467345,
0.0509682745,
0.0494942777,
0.0501144491,
-0.0799405128,
-0.0584974959,
0.0326318629,
0.0912798345,
0.0046288646,
-0.0440628678,
-0.0156235127,
-0.0459477529,
0.0089546852,
0.0103711672,
0.0285851397,
0.0058044107,
-0.029094357,
-0.0029446285,
-0.0070801354,
0.0299321767,
0.0057101669,
-0.0292251669,
0.0167836081,
-0.0037969339,
0.0345800743,
0.0267601237,
0.0292606261,
-0.0061657396,
0.0329726674,
0.0202911813,
-0.045361951,
-0.0143164527,
-0.0146109536,
0.0578209125,
0.0065793307,
-0.0023719724,
-0.0190204587,
-0.0261318795,
0.0135003692,
-0.0213040523,
-0.0135694128,
0.0020122207,
0.0388116911,
-0.0046542627,
0.0103673181,
-0.0097352285,
0.011460999,
-0.000545135,
0.0145128733,
-0.0264420919,
0.0017580678,
0.0027742202,
0.0026245189,
0.0123907877,
-0.0562583394,
-0.0777104646,
-0.0314617045,
-0.0562197156,
-0.0279463325,
-0.0167281404,
0.0394736342,
0.0173912197,
0.0391883329,
0.0284358952,
-0.0422991961,
0.0340348743,
0.0272334609,
-0.0264283363,
0.0000446156,
0.0179011468,
-0.0937531367,
-0.0159483049,
-0.0420704745,
0.0432900265,
-0.0283363443,
0.0631473437,
0.0384818166,
0.0166428108,
-0.0023500503,
0.038534984,
-0.06520731,
-0.0596075393,
-0.0119269621,
0.0941285416,
0.0207112078,
-0.0383481123,
0.028489586,
-0.0186440665,
0.0254175104,
0.1011321098,
-0.0182975046,
0.0739141554,
0.0283834245,
-0.0594696738,
0.0152421407,
0.0063937614,
0.0104631996,
-0.0510377251,
0.137628451,
0.0183186997,
-0.0068185683,
-0.001911237,
-0.0603097454,
0.0563046969,
-0.0052792216,
-0.0472331531,
0.0183717459,
0.0457949936,
0.0530469418,
0.0114209019,
0.0454036184,
-0.0274214596,
-0.0142529523,
0.0144283259,
-0.0588201992,
-0.0117359078,
0.0216213055,
0.0585822314,
0.0085241636,
-0.0147375865,
0.0345177203,
-0.0472052023,
0.031394694,
0.0335044041,
0.0076155071,
-0.0275009498,
0.0682293326,
0.0137702813,
0.0390557349,
-0.013897947,
-0.0234094001,
-0.0209094025,
0.0393084362,
-0.0431154557,
0.0749169514,
-0.0236052684,
-0.0735319108,
-0.0096214265,
0.0723912045,
0.0238247532,
0.0453925282,
-0.0349353142,
0.0388395265,
0.0073766191,
-0.0202307422,
-0.0098192571,
-0.0480323955,
-0.0198489185,
0.033536993,
-0.0430933721,
0.006369615,
-0.0067939297,
0.0102002081,
0.0579339527,
0.0636596903,
0.028183613,
0.0689700097,
-0.0208171289,
-0.0470766686,
0.0543768592,
-0.0025793638,
0.0153862294,
-0.0827862397,
-0.0506619401,
-0.0332263336,
0.0001989232,
-0.009323406,
0.0197582729,
-0.0132497456,
-0.0251295716,
-0.0087081231,
0.0387608334,
0.0240719169,
-0.019479746,
-0.0654653013,
0.0225139391,
-0.0313087143,
0.0739830285,
-6.707713129e-33,
-0.0063354932,
-0.0161435846,
-0.0079931263,
-0.000914505,
0.0198628269,
-0.0238833725,
-0.0139289582,
0.0071619647,
-0.0001665449,
-0.0500871278,
-0.0503437854,
-0.0021870718,
0.0205870923,
-0.0315371938,
-0.0262809657,
-0.039951358,
-0.0148068788,
0.009235627,
-0.0182361249,
0.0223646462,
-0.0034055475,
0.0280058328,
0.0176014043,
-0.0110393167,
-0.0092859734,
0.0024585153,
-0.0454117544,
0.0041785017,
-0.0769594386,
0.0125956638,
0.0054139681,
-0.0123297796,
-0.0223062411,
-0.0076130056,
0.0131771937,
-0.0024014928,
-0.0494765379,
0.000134279,
0.0388472006,
-0.0189732555,
0.0196330249,
-0.0791416913,
0.023712527,
0.0679621547,
-0.0080793845,
-0.029952677,
-0.052493643,
-0.0044706431,
-0.0238690712,
-0.0304187872,
0.0273339972,
0.0096534211,
0.0175394602,
-0.0016774635,
0.0077426815,
-0.1124702096,
-0.0544214994,
-0.0473746322,
-0.015836481,
-0.009152188,
0.0751371309,
-0.0235269424,
0.0220281258,
0.0041233841,
-0.020284621,
0.0484648459,
-0.0236373302,
0.0170642864,
0.0198038109,
-0.009199365,
0.0101689175,
0.0838084817,
0.0031718093,
0.0583648421,
0.0588933006,
-0.0135212094,
-0.0901933536,
-0.0042252019,
-0.0008245563,
0.0248538461,
-0.0040207701,
-0.0364718661,
-0.0336839519,
-0.0076002404,
-0.012182923,
0.0135768773,
-0.0129778087,
0.0057096304,
0.014415971,
0.0340850987,
-0.0464316793,
0.0006143307,
-0.0217986275,
-0.0103345979,
0.0631360859,
-0.0041873544,
0.0361647531,
-0.0062208637,
-0.0171656404,
-0.0020078847,
0.0114544798,
-0.0168265514,
-0.040533457,
-0.0713873506,
0.0405289419,
-0.0307004992,
0.0314333402,
0.0497052856,
-0.0716624036,
0.0065082563,
-0.0264701359,
0.0403084718,
0.0308697075,
0.0304053444,
-0.0074834945,
-0.0252874196,
-0.0016496315,
-0.0211900733,
-0.0126821231,
0.0456646197,
0.0017479406,
0.0378627218,
-0.0019270491,
0.0656616837,
0.0053520291,
0.018975867,
0.0153973736,
0.0218287818,
-0.0032751025,
-0.0738312602,
-0.0033639527,
0.0202714279,
3.145e-7,
-0.0374007411,
0.005140034,
0.0205639973,
0.0143593205,
-0.0102667604,
0.055427067,
-0.0125690475,
0.0584743395,
-0.0284795184,
-0.0129795326,
-0.0264845714,
-0.0089176083,
0.0409896523,
-0.0158394482,
0.0310333278,
0.0259901974,
0.0082262978,
0.0370912552,
0.002707988,
-0.0767726526,
-0.0109880399,
0.0521454252,
-0.0040381695,
-0.0397464484,
0.025843842,
-0.0615887791,
0.0103730671,
-0.0024008853,
0.0070575867,
-0.0117367366,
0.0365379788,
0.0673763081,
-0.0388032384,
0.0101761147,
-0.0094133839,
-0.0273474697,
-0.0851306245,
0.0865767226,
0.0349822789,
-0.0316254906,
-0.0059759701,
-0.0554637238,
-0.0261866692,
0.0331983343,
0.0288684741,
0.1058089286,
-0.0136340223,
-0.0257486179,
0.0394398533,
-0.029492816,
0.0376573019,
-0.0362798348,
0.0913039893,
-0.0055870977,
0.0093599018,
-0.0026932119,
-0.0153185725,
-0.0298784357,
-0.041138541,
0.0206154902,
0.0062365625,
-0.0446051396,
-0.0197915062,
0.0408112593,
0.0085026966,
-0.0373683088,
0.0059820642,
2.87169849e-34,
0.0092648184,
-0.0577895381,
0.0344630815,
0.0557085723,
0.0211933572,
-0.0049817371,
0.0256144106,
-0.0227413047,
-0.0231195372,
-0.0305995476,
-0.0079288315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01374v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01374v1 | Bridging the Gap: Transfer Learning from English PLMs to Malaysian English | 2024-07-01T15:26:03 | 2024-07-01T15:26:03 | Mohan Raj Chanthran, Lay-Ki Soon, Huey Fang Ong, Bhawani Selvaretnam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Malaysian English is a low resource creole language, where it carries the
elements of Malay, Chinese, and Tamil languages, in addition to Standard
English. Named Entity Recognition (NER) models underperform when capturing
entities from Malaysian English text due to its distinctive morphosyntactic
adaptations, semantic features and code-switching (mixing English and Malay).
Considering these gaps, we introduce MENmBERT and MENBERT, a pre-trained
language model with contextual understanding, specifically tailored for
Malaysian English. We have fine-tuned MENmBERT and MENBERT using manually
annotated entities and relations from the Malaysian English News Article (MEN)
Dataset. This fine-tuning process allows the PLM to learn representations that
capture the nuances of Malaysian English relevant for NER and RE tasks.
MENmBERT achieved a 1.52\% and 26.27\% improvement on NER and RE tasks
respectively compared to the bert-base-multilingual-cased model. Although the
overall performance of NER does not have a significant improvement, our further
analysis shows that there is a significant improvement when evaluated by the 12
entity labels. These findings suggest that pre-training language models on
language-specific and geographically-focused corpora can be a promising
approach for improving NER performance in low-resource settings. The dataset
and code published in this paper provide valuable resources for NLP research
work focusing on Malaysian English. | [
0.0337770954,
0.0037592256,
0.0112896152,
0.0316049755,
-0.0086183148,
0.0459962413,
-0.0096039362,
-0.0156185813,
-0.0242289156,
-0.0533796586,
-0.0660872161,
-0.0464991592,
0.0043816315,
-0.0355481543,
0.0380874574,
-0.0647416785,
0.0220007021,
-0.0074704103,
0.0327206217,
0.0064932588,
0.0131967654,
0.0129694873,
0.0188626815,
0.0038098719,
0.022277249,
-0.0040492248,
-0.0129005881,
0.0341493897,
0.0340243019,
-0.0781611204,
0.021968808,
0.0581903011,
-0.0109019224,
0.0090935342,
0.000001949,
-0.0677241534,
-0.0385735333,
-0.0058724568,
-0.020815365,
0.0389404148,
0.0170519557,
-0.0272856113,
-0.0154990973,
0.025788106,
-0.0194641445,
-0.0412710272,
-0.0044944049,
0.0436206274,
0.0484018028,
0.1142757088,
-0.0219781175,
0.0030072073,
-0.0157816242,
-0.0157536771,
0.0099084107,
-0.0435363352,
0.0250142869,
-0.0558832921,
0.0134096779,
-0.0143157635,
0.0077422149,
0.0138147064,
-0.0282438993,
0.0120371422,
0.025676867,
0.0167765208,
-0.0150688551,
-0.0225908794,
0.0248402841,
0.0539050698,
-0.0355138965,
-0.0191381462,
0.0064814519,
-0.012010539,
-0.0397247151,
-0.0185672753,
-0.0308551826,
0.0002378155,
-0.0519378819,
0.0457490198,
0.0687250346,
-0.014286695,
0.0333240405,
0.031910561,
-0.0201042816,
-0.0187547747,
0.0298148766,
-0.045962017,
0.0115043558,
0.0111686476,
0.0105868001,
-0.0472013168,
0.038482476,
0.0281025078,
0.0246970803,
0.0476718806,
-0.0147177726,
0.02293141,
0.0213087983,
-0.0956377834,
-0.0305786375,
0.0385739692,
-0.0046145325,
0.0369293615,
-0.0747517198,
-0.0051483018,
-0.0064042732,
0.0480497256,
-0.0031014553,
-0.0542916358,
-0.0434560366,
-0.0115309786,
-0.039964702,
0.0637196973,
0.0000240724,
0.0311355721,
-0.0428735986,
0.0339413024,
0.0187368318,
0.016508963,
0.0382661521,
-0.0222468078,
-0.0376273096,
-0.0124062318,
-0.0358201712,
0.036519248,
-0.0032871338,
0.0052775932,
-0.0303681493,
-0.0690318123,
0.0034258217,
-0.0113831554,
0.0011413646,
-0.0756700933,
-0.0009040797,
0.0452184528,
-0.0049101366,
-0.0966365561,
-0.0862535834,
0.0564151146,
0.0124189835,
-0.0271280948,
0.0289924275,
-0.0240665562,
0.0229654331,
0.0167293493,
0.0246418118,
-0.0303423684,
0.0373039432,
-0.0058474038,
-0.035158392,
0.0833325163,
-0.0051749223,
0.0185291748,
0.0385872386,
0.016809443,
0.0589929409,
0.07076253,
0.0339050703,
-0.01878234,
0.052045323,
-0.0220921058,
-0.0225314423,
0.0446660593,
0.019124411,
0.0054318192,
0.0197455082,
0.0030182044,
-0.0389566123,
-0.0100817867,
0.0271032788,
0.0165483579,
0.0219459012,
0.0229685232,
0.0102298008,
0.0071872869,
0.0182518549,
0.0318923369,
0.0248200633,
-0.0007358629,
0.0153392348,
-0.005315349,
-0.0077105132,
-0.0017328294,
-0.0361553878,
0.0341829211,
0.0107069882,
0.0471737422,
-0.0447049476,
0.0320379846,
0.0003964233,
-0.0323562026,
-0.017563289,
0.0280358326,
0.0884816125,
0.0068978933,
-0.0448531806,
0.0889192373,
0.0237820875,
-0.001167029,
0.0559381433,
-0.0233489219,
-0.0358698517,
0.0358616114,
0.019895833,
-0.0346120708,
-0.0272239,
-0.0186145492,
-0.0387065336,
0.0650322959,
0.0173137449,
-0.0280989911,
0.0286050215,
-0.0162975434,
0.0174813177,
0.0458589345,
0.0208756868,
0.0180394519,
0.0390137844,
0.0379222631,
0.0260979868,
-0.0259191878,
-0.0246706307,
0.0570519641,
-0.0468494594,
-0.0316428654,
-0.0010703548,
0.0079828585,
0.0252292175,
0.0504762083,
-0.0007100921,
-0.0172128733,
0.0125852469,
-0.0313790552,
0.0347168632,
-0.0005856665,
-0.0215489827,
-0.0451101921,
-0.0003780793,
-0.0182269476,
-0.0282878317,
0.0088551911,
-0.0099690342,
-0.0412798785,
-0.0572459996,
0.0592356473,
0.0245038532,
-0.0787000656,
0.057631135,
-0.0231469478,
0.0017975853,
-0.0210171696,
0.0543677174,
-0.0109007685,
0.0082399938,
0.0137777701,
0.0030155573,
0.0216422454,
-0.0312469248,
-0.0474989861,
-0.0141210593,
0.0027795155,
-0.0249643493,
-0.0262856185,
0.0337617509,
-0.0412782989,
-0.016390305,
-0.1026885286,
0.0070483647,
-0.0235625226,
0.0464027151,
0.0246795528,
0.0451530144,
-0.0505688563,
-0.011349733,
0.0465809442,
-0.0518228151,
0.0043707662,
0.0184522215,
0.026298048,
-0.0142363766,
0.0393783711,
-0.0275554564,
0.0168544985,
-0.0049957619,
0.0299361516,
-0.0053237858,
-0.0849747732,
-0.0264988616,
0.0410195515,
-0.0074069407,
-0.0374699309,
0.0066672075,
-0.0077156443,
-0.0191250127,
-0.0048984662,
0.0101301456,
0.0282534659,
0.0005448173,
0.0129060782,
-0.0154697718,
-0.0277615283,
-0.0368464254,
0.0200169235,
-0.0139080016,
0.0336511508,
-0.0270490535,
-0.0565342642,
0.0342582315,
0.0825477317,
-0.0525330491,
0.008790046,
-0.0358785577,
-0.0400117561,
-0.0033065858,
-0.0093260091,
0.011495458,
0.0242279842,
-0.0432638824,
0.0187668204,
-0.016170077,
-0.0131095527,
0.0595730245,
-0.0480931066,
0.0188313201,
-0.0517079309,
0.0149724875,
-0.0408794209,
0.0125926835,
-0.0286865588,
-0.0224446096,
0.0106189474,
-0.0794345215,
-0.0127950991,
0.0442834795,
0.011318557,
-0.0226834249,
0.0154748783,
-0.0394049622,
0.0202522613,
-0.029277835,
-0.0111455629,
-0.0471359529,
-0.0246268287,
-0.028265059,
0.0298649948,
-0.0205830578,
0.0447335355,
0.0130391745,
0.0729361698,
-0.0160822496,
-0.0169019401,
0.0033628263,
0.0060800253,
0.0211661719,
0.0319118686,
0.0152912261,
0.012631001,
0.0066938368,
-0.0342973135,
0.0132998237,
-0.0301165823,
-0.0096581997,
-0.0028731024,
0.0350636803,
0.0098016821,
0.0090271002,
-0.0583151504,
-0.0222289953,
-0.0511148833,
0.0269960649,
0.0043163318,
-0.0250828583,
0.1176535785,
0.0076233684,
-0.044758942,
-0.0334105305,
-0.0286205132,
0.0186929218,
0.0182629153,
0.0169569664,
-0.0498469733,
0.001336258,
0.0171069521,
-0.0128036244,
0.022547124,
-0.0484470911,
-0.0142997401,
-0.1063830182,
-0.0309272651,
-0.0219778661,
-0.0847367272,
-0.0258926451,
-0.0397221707,
-0.0078622196,
-0.0173225235,
0.0249164496,
-0.0142215462,
-0.0236136448,
0.0125942491,
0.0429171734,
-0.0250058174,
-0.1007787064,
0.0232158136,
-0.0366158225,
0.0232385248,
0.0149218366,
0.0107532367,
-0.0338075086,
0.0315543488,
0.0184330139,
-0.0522343591,
-0.0233445503,
-0.0316599086,
0.0051432061,
-0.0501855202,
-0.0105790179,
-0.02111331,
-0.0074892282,
-0.0099068312,
-0.0063417796,
0.0259685125,
0.0707253963,
-0.0111945616,
0.0156430043,
0.0254800022,
-0.0272408612,
0.0063757389,
0.0631028935,
0.0197690316,
-0.054272633,
-0.009974068,
0.0023904894,
-0.0006206822,
-0.0193670783,
0.0140830111,
0.0556342229,
-0.0709090978,
-0.0137154451,
-0.0260352101,
-0.069858484,
0.0583145358,
0.0366020426,
0.0142632117,
0.0004746466,
0.028451046,
0.0072734477,
-0.0275691301,
0.0101369582,
-0.019293787,
-0.0140773011,
-0.0618840791,
-0.0221247729,
0.0178877432,
-0.009542576,
-0.0121085672,
-0.0971530154,
-0.0692144185,
-0.0434680358,
0.0291476361,
-0.0178783089,
0.0153698204,
0.0259744134,
0.007734186,
-0.0392689556,
-0.0000744389,
0.0151058855,
-0.0394141264,
-0.015387184,
0.0245960169,
0.0367200598,
-0.0232271869,
0.0317004137,
-0.0259680711,
0.0207303669,
0.0213665068,
0.0657596216,
-0.0290232338,
-0.0168614127,
0.0055485019,
0.0221184157,
0.0511482954,
-0.0482589528,
-0.0467125289,
-0.0754839778,
0.026463829,
0.0347505473,
0.0148909381,
-0.0033274691,
-0.0366075672,
0.0392086767,
-0.0080316905,
-0.0256919619,
0.0594877675,
-0.01139013,
0.0126157636,
-0.0223627575,
0.0499145575,
0.0203774329,
0.0722454041,
-0.0117771272,
0.0005650758,
0.020335678,
0.0301394276,
0.0255519077,
0.0192607846,
-0.033767689,
0.0497874357,
-0.0241454579,
0.0180918165,
0.0500125214,
-0.0079193097,
0.0237270258,
0.0122479135,
-0.0533013046,
0.0443209745,
0.0906815082,
-0.0367717072,
0.0297615938,
-0.0205595884,
0.0083420109,
-0.0273975413,
0.0194257852,
-0.0222554039,
-0.0057970197,
0.0486605763,
-0.0027315286,
-0.0208354034,
0.0467526913,
0.0581645444,
0.0387366749,
0.0075668711,
0.0489036031,
0.0070421649,
-0.0255026426,
-0.0153875463,
0.0547977015,
0.0166495927,
-0.0370687135,
0.0080174617,
-0.0440604277,
-0.0618981011,
0.0157741345,
-0.0475525931,
-0.015653694,
-0.0086166495,
-0.0079637915,
0.0371678807,
0.0169299394,
0.0156502668,
-0.054338593,
0.0308699924,
-0.0013092689,
0.0103833368,
0.0177380349,
-6.523972341e-33,
-0.0838606358,
-0.0114324531,
-0.0068021482,
-0.0108832549,
-0.0018199621,
0.0210362934,
-0.0408852845,
-0.0227603503,
-0.0260852352,
-0.0415918082,
-0.0328351408,
0.0266656112,
0.03492691,
0.0364425518,
0.0052002347,
-0.0352619737,
0.0213161185,
0.0255953316,
0.0048749852,
0.009900365,
0.0031024113,
0.1014252454,
0.1126669496,
-0.0359406397,
0.0482985117,
-0.0133022079,
0.0138528952,
0.0045256144,
0.0644859895,
0.0563301072,
-0.0579830296,
0.0132602211,
0.0357104503,
0.0035886352,
0.0023580194,
-0.008861064,
-0.1660510004,
-0.0042696665,
-0.0059480998,
0.0324059911,
0.0048476243,
-0.0167684462,
0.0187825635,
0.0140058482,
0.0315813236,
0.0087141115,
0.0307481978,
-0.0196049176,
-0.0283274334,
-0.0077238437,
-0.0672572255,
0.061281696,
0.0233524404,
0.0710895956,
0.068270117,
0.0044523836,
-0.0026493692,
0.0322466642,
-0.0893169269,
-0.0313478298,
0.0449109636,
-0.0026463734,
0.0432415828,
0.0316915996,
-0.0220193937,
0.0129481452,
0.0133941425,
0.0053897481,
0.0195017606,
0.0384062864,
0.0819464102,
0.0057389801,
-0.0383257903,
0.0402380675,
0.0093666557,
-0.0425236523,
-0.0743639544,
0.0430439226,
0.0034394793,
0.0144425826,
0.0159034915,
-0.0133776125,
-0.038779147,
-0.0373143069,
-0.0081326487,
-0.0276946761,
-0.0401296616,
-0.0291878209,
0.0092245582,
0.0102870893,
-0.0542618372,
0.0265875868,
0.0421803929,
-0.0133268349,
-0.0448538475,
-0.0502317324,
0.0435609445,
0.0054953201,
-0.0215554051,
0.0351721235,
-0.0765681043,
-0.0486486107,
0.0038395834,
-0.015923813,
0.0071412916,
-0.0060485317,
0.0230490007,
-0.0147655755,
-0.0525187366,
0.0000276727,
-0.0221554004,
-0.0145665547,
-0.0372775495,
0.0872994959,
-0.0113343988,
0.0017465209,
-0.0063602715,
0.0144553259,
0.0541608371,
-0.0218006093,
-0.0312830359,
0.0044607101,
0.0236955453,
0.0075197909,
-0.0122454027,
0.0153547721,
-0.0060193124,
0.0378514342,
0.0388114825,
-0.0412826911,
-0.0021195333,
0.0104778446,
2.642e-7,
0.0728934258,
0.0202605203,
0.0324045159,
-0.032814838,
-0.0178938415,
0.0071625379,
-0.0308499504,
0.0384704545,
-0.0179205928,
0.0176179335,
0.0484708771,
-0.0196204484,
0.043554645,
0.0493260808,
-0.1176187769,
-0.0082895486,
-0.0378115214,
0.0113180019,
-0.047542911,
0.0175406206,
0.0161000602,
0.0801140964,
-0.0049135867,
-0.0122087812,
-0.0296710227,
0.0067820903,
0.062665008,
-0.0242619608,
-0.0044922912,
0.0484329276,
0.0117304949,
0.0843113884,
-0.0179642253,
0.0109690176,
-0.0391970612,
0.0184324309,
0.0036268611,
0.07926891,
0.0048379311,
-0.0273677669,
0.0089245569,
-0.0139525905,
0.0218536723,
-0.0889076963,
0.0673608556,
-0.0231583565,
-0.0198304001,
0.0180653948,
-0.0146023035,
0.01502511,
-0.0004961592,
0.0303062703,
-0.0477683246,
0.0428541228,
0.0156407654,
-0.039912045,
-0.0378675461,
-0.0834254026,
0.0062271706,
0.0392085463,
0.0028547747,
-0.0068686255,
-0.0204977281,
-0.0072210222,
0.0232161265,
-0.0330000222,
0.0581083633,
2.374142726e-34,
-0.0073029432,
0.0117112212,
-0.0448227227,
0.0694721118,
0.0259493962,
-0.0221763216,
-0.0412149951,
0.0019245632,
-0.0052113594,
-0.0496703647,
0.0188447628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01370v1 | Summary of a Haystack: A Challenge to Long-Context LLMs and RAG Systems | 2024-07-01T15:23:42 | 2024-07-01T15:23:42 | Philippe Laban, Alexander R. Fabbri, Caiming Xiong, Chien-Sheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs and RAG systems are now capable of handling millions of input tokens or
more. However, evaluating the output quality of such systems on long-context
tasks remains challenging, as tasks like Needle-in-a-Haystack lack complexity.
In this work, we argue that summarization can play a central role in such
evaluation. We design a procedure to synthesize Haystacks of documents,
ensuring that specific \textit{insights} repeat across documents. The "Summary
of a Haystack" (SummHay) task then requires a system to process the Haystack
and generate, given a query, a summary that identifies the relevant insights
and precisely cites the source documents. Since we have precise knowledge of
what insights should appear in a haystack summary and what documents should be
cited, we implement a highly reproducible automatic evaluation that can score
summaries on two aspects - Coverage and Citation. We generate Haystacks in two
domains (conversation, news), and perform a large-scale evaluation of 10 LLMs
and corresponding 50 RAG systems. Our findings indicate that SummHay is an open
challenge for current systems, as even systems provided with an Oracle signal
of document relevance lag our estimate of human performance (56\%) by 10+
points on a Joint Score. Without a retriever, long-context LLMs like GPT-4o and
Claude 3 Opus score below 20% on SummHay. We show SummHay can also be used to
study enterprise RAG systems and position bias in long-context models. We hope
future systems can equal and surpass human performance on SummHay. | [
0.0522321202,
-0.0226815548,
0.0085100578,
-0.0018591562,
-0.0433894098,
0.0000207696,
-0.0223783422,
0.0072510149,
-0.0068128831,
-0.0725834891,
-0.0219878908,
0.0100487806,
-0.0046318304,
-0.0281048845,
0.0218146257,
-0.0211170297,
0.043750491,
-0.0041479827,
-0.0184953883,
-0.0012358841,
0.0141531061,
0.0141178798,
0.0270461701,
0.006442484,
0.0090473266,
0.0028508655,
-0.0331424288,
0.0092719616,
0.0140117425,
-0.0179241374,
-0.0229658578,
0.0165707115,
-0.0049618818,
0.0296440627,
0.0000017461,
-0.0801835507,
-0.0196843129,
0.0088764569,
-0.0179397613,
0.0227825828,
0.0752788559,
0.0120950909,
0.0175143089,
0.0100589134,
-0.0138550662,
0.0399717726,
-0.005602133,
0.0359500162,
0.0485045239,
0.0439468026,
-0.0047268034,
-0.0288376436,
0.0238107517,
-0.0224602036,
0.0648897067,
-0.0922546834,
-0.0008615725,
0.0004193907,
0.0670457929,
0.0128855184,
-0.0002083461,
0.038249705,
-0.0080859968,
-0.0265867468,
0.0118466951,
0.0116884569,
-0.0568127148,
0.0372024849,
0.0133030396,
0.0304495599,
0.0173202548,
-0.0105751529,
0.0200007632,
0.0161508266,
0.026857486,
0.0227953624,
-0.0726963058,
0.0336667784,
-0.0363687761,
-0.0099172387,
0.0323584527,
0.0122640496,
0.0060213371,
0.0188431349,
-0.0306679085,
0.0341291428,
0.003864547,
-0.0514473021,
0.0185236093,
0.0179454517,
0.0196256656,
-0.0715007707,
0.0005942958,
0.0451902375,
-0.0481641516,
-0.0017310961,
-0.0028692647,
0.0103483107,
0.0650950745,
-0.0206274651,
-0.0301733781,
0.0069668763,
-0.0101507371,
0.0901331007,
-0.0359191187,
0.0013304269,
-0.0225753225,
-0.0184790771,
-0.0347333737,
-0.0707691014,
-0.055983264,
-0.0110724391,
-0.0005867154,
0.0742999911,
-0.0471105203,
-0.0277864356,
-0.0627678782,
0.0334700607,
-0.0099123539,
0.0108532729,
-0.0117097944,
-0.0052878968,
-0.0341061577,
-0.0040816604,
-0.0470663421,
-0.0061174659,
-0.0084371772,
0.0107401405,
0.0001915591,
-0.0341574773,
-0.016579261,
0.026943868,
0.0080726212,
-0.0061825011,
0.0186954197,
0.0623355433,
0.0199981146,
-0.0492012128,
-0.0438615419,
-0.0612775795,
-0.0210025776,
-0.0547396541,
-0.0181533024,
-0.0829060525,
-0.0015871136,
0.0278394092,
-0.0074540908,
0.0229344703,
-0.0176197272,
0.0453012027,
-0.0182348285,
0.0326205753,
0.0235802792,
0.0124146063,
0.0250097793,
0.015465403,
0.0354514942,
0.0851626247,
0.0104890969,
0.0915176123,
0.0479647964,
0.0187187213,
0.0144344047,
0.0286290962,
0.010159174,
0.0262017883,
0.0074599721,
0.0331943333,
-0.0258221235,
0.0214191694,
0.0194420815,
0.0547699891,
-0.0350926295,
0.0245015826,
0.0407088809,
0.0956568122,
0.0529985502,
0.0209621545,
0.0291788038,
-0.0129104499,
0.0048566111,
0.0238523968,
-0.0071567758,
0.0278913844,
-0.0365814008,
0.0417955853,
0.1079407856,
-0.0243724622,
-0.0510333143,
-0.0334159881,
-0.0210974384,
0.0244887695,
-0.0699131265,
0.005195572,
0.0357150808,
-0.0068597761,
-0.0291701499,
0.0504584312,
-0.000350297,
-0.0376672745,
0.0318947583,
-0.0295578334,
0.0317236185,
0.0612563603,
0.0718540624,
-0.056795381,
0.021042034,
-0.0352875665,
0.0080742911,
0.0299844909,
0.0207252391,
-0.017549647,
-0.0164488442,
-0.0134055391,
-0.0516388938,
0.0143551659,
0.0016748514,
0.0023125776,
0.0122103505,
-0.0092173601,
0.0166826714,
-0.0489584729,
-0.0250948686,
0.0174852107,
-0.0313769616,
-0.0046282783,
-0.0150593035,
-0.0103534553,
0.043375656,
0.045639392,
0.0015908869,
0.0350621194,
0.0546615385,
-0.0282652657,
-0.0281858239,
-0.0313748196,
-0.0071627321,
0.0176635645,
0.0299817547,
-0.0551832467,
-0.0012533999,
0.0001737343,
-0.0203292016,
-0.0476366542,
-0.0132999439,
-0.0808710977,
0.002506743,
-0.0321723446,
0.0019161481,
-0.0016762872,
-0.011645332,
-0.0666700602,
0.0789023489,
-0.0041396641,
0.028495051,
0.0312588885,
-0.0391307212,
0.0156285744,
-0.0757377818,
-0.0093733054,
-0.0301208626,
0.0104533844,
0.0097841164,
0.0445795581,
-0.0051972046,
-0.0434594154,
-0.0393423997,
-0.124455303,
0.0270616449,
-0.025705561,
0.0174837187,
0.0259659141,
0.0217195731,
-0.0039339894,
-0.0072508859,
-0.0422728211,
-0.0359410942,
0.0517974645,
0.0349827744,
0.0570748486,
0.0309049021,
0.0207520351,
-0.0501499213,
-0.0237281881,
-0.0081251273,
0.0523136966,
0.0259127077,
-0.0144457603,
-0.0772914961,
0.0350080915,
-0.0033719814,
-0.024254581,
-0.00907679,
0.0418214425,
-0.0120940702,
-0.0222817305,
0.0153835127,
0.0348930545,
0.0268139895,
0.0236469973,
0.0170537345,
0.0244533028,
-0.0701522082,
0.0001627332,
-0.0126279257,
-0.0011396122,
-0.0290488563,
-0.018032467,
0.028019812,
-0.0261515733,
0.0016638419,
-0.005228735,
0.000388248,
0.0041428003,
0.0106930938,
-0.0301627517,
-0.0614998788,
-0.0323808491,
-0.0058966582,
0.0543038435,
-0.0018831427,
-0.0437246636,
0.0234283749,
-0.0124878203,
0.0266784988,
-0.0548002273,
-0.0046045845,
-0.0794007704,
0.0522671454,
-0.040420413,
-0.003958601,
-0.0596402697,
-0.0352737829,
-0.0367273539,
-0.0178979207,
0.0073349359,
-0.0418024547,
0.0820843205,
0.0070475047,
0.0196260214,
-0.0219100565,
-0.027011225,
-0.025270246,
-0.0331549384,
-0.0132986335,
0.0427969284,
0.0266519357,
0.0054892115,
-0.0472047329,
0.0143078901,
0.0582611486,
0.021590624,
-0.0331665464,
-0.0474424884,
-0.0166494697,
0.0125651471,
0.0504707731,
-0.0069344244,
0.0644050166,
-0.0137685994,
-0.0013973847,
0.0549010225,
0.0560368039,
-0.0073021115,
0.0054610753,
-0.0361600146,
0.0123572107,
-0.0769417658,
-0.0014914963,
-0.0206939578,
0.0075096628,
-0.0275598131,
-0.013336407,
0.1034821197,
0.0153907407,
-0.0452126488,
-0.0232992265,
-0.0161977019,
0.0041686208,
0.0313024521,
0.0374223217,
-0.0863296017,
-0.016333377,
0.003198985,
0.0431207307,
0.0144695677,
-0.034942396,
-0.0043225996,
-0.1371905655,
0.0461805128,
-0.0132152112,
-0.02226975,
-0.0065238946,
-0.051127363,
0.0040884283,
-0.0309760328,
-0.0026142986,
0.0509442538,
-0.0624937303,
-0.0050551668,
0.0038496391,
0.0038570766,
0.0153865116,
0.0328420252,
-0.042377308,
-0.0272934269,
0.0305208433,
0.0263451915,
-0.0018734568,
-0.0082306527,
0.0557572581,
-0.0506714955,
0.0270240009,
-0.0019100072,
0.0693593696,
-0.0287961233,
0.0266168565,
-0.0270937905,
-0.0004374733,
0.0090403166,
0.0400408916,
0.0159582291,
0.0652799755,
-0.0117154419,
0.0314550437,
-0.0567583218,
0.0162243117,
-0.0175575223,
0.0838471353,
0.02782939,
-0.0030613176,
-0.0471620895,
-0.0055501531,
-0.0176987089,
-0.0299700983,
-0.0158130974,
0.0054247519,
-0.0753596127,
-0.0178273786,
-0.0595869459,
-0.0597038232,
0.0086802775,
0.0494022332,
-0.006887272,
0.041336827,
-0.0394709185,
0.0127904303,
-0.052207265,
-0.0133824255,
-0.0349837914,
0.0218839366,
-0.0284347162,
0.0637987629,
0.0466990881,
-0.0421961918,
-0.0121579822,
0.0118390424,
-0.0444833599,
-0.0480747707,
-0.0049182852,
0.0053523257,
0.0402788185,
0.0286473334,
-0.0141786356,
-0.0496886931,
0.0924100056,
0.0448260419,
-0.0494066402,
0.0385570489,
0.0055455673,
0.0336574167,
-0.0254583657,
0.0199627858,
-0.0945179686,
0.0237071309,
-0.0163494796,
0.0202042367,
-0.0195940491,
-0.017056413,
-0.0012384098,
0.0309509691,
0.0267991927,
-0.002943058,
-0.000349286,
0.0085476022,
0.0213315729,
-0.0190310534,
-0.0177468881,
0.0057393918,
0.0369153097,
-0.0143159181,
-0.0163993686,
0.0083229095,
0.0574560501,
-0.0346209891,
0.0612773523,
-0.0658994317,
-0.0021232909,
-0.0090265395,
0.0050542243,
-0.039235238,
-0.0125947446,
-0.0408153497,
-0.0428956933,
-0.0099551976,
0.0382836275,
-0.00160993,
0.0163933784,
0.0319041163,
0.0196182672,
0.0085359858,
0.0504085794,
-0.1312746555,
0.0057794466,
-0.0063286247,
0.0131924683,
0.04483895,
-0.0106951473,
0.0379126631,
-0.0041279169,
-0.0174174532,
-0.0231871828,
0.0124116791,
0.0114669688,
0.0273282733,
0.00328793,
0.0555088297,
-0.0188500416,
0.0041901814,
0.0586190298,
-0.006505264,
0.0226176865,
-0.0107449498,
-0.0641561449,
-0.0416482873,
-0.0615015887,
-0.0170095414,
0.0607275292,
0.0000456421,
-0.0364018865,
-0.083861582,
-0.020129025,
0.0451131798,
0.0202955734,
0.012177445,
-0.0282033253,
0.0342188627,
0.0757283568,
0.0470629856,
0.0050300872,
-0.0436474532,
0.0025832634,
-0.0487678833,
-0.0251568779,
0.0071256645,
-6.015632381e-33,
-0.0287465192,
-0.0469289273,
0.0191252436,
-0.004019497,
-0.024712503,
0.0082960855,
-0.0128713911,
-0.0176245458,
0.0011306725,
0.0067779534,
-0.0408142135,
0.0428310931,
0.0178776979,
-0.0069547524,
0.0303023402,
0.0079082055,
0.0438641459,
0.0268259402,
-0.0219634026,
0.0120660421,
0.0846872106,
0.0174706709,
0.01698054,
-0.0540184639,
0.0272527467,
-0.011794867,
-0.002005741,
0.0004338324,
0.0114856176,
0.0614133552,
-0.0078638494,
0.0246632956,
0.0356226079,
-0.0517731011,
-0.0078529948,
0.0246889126,
-0.0799370185,
-0.0297946297,
0.0509597771,
-0.0682714432,
-0.0012582885,
-0.0150849205,
0.0518908091,
0.0007034541,
-0.0323019102,
-0.013127178,
0.0391906649,
-0.0380222276,
-0.0494363382,
-0.0830368325,
-0.0229615662,
0.0334244519,
0.0069488608,
0.0160610285,
0.0024776056,
0.0268329214,
0.0109203579,
0.0685520992,
-0.0270900521,
0.0266658999,
-0.0324793011,
0.0382208154,
0.0395318009,
-0.0207130946,
-0.0077805626,
0.0627765581,
0.0022012808,
-0.0021598313,
0.0054991087,
-0.0477928817,
-0.0426550768,
0.0297329854,
0.0380636826,
0.045437593,
0.0464693047,
0.0292456374,
-0.0746058673,
0.0740755647,
0.003898426,
0.0687451214,
0.0217192881,
0.0035770647,
-0.0536295474,
0.0033483116,
0.0010296807,
0.0433943979,
-0.0275302306,
0.0062040281,
0.0122954249,
0.0366831459,
0.0037210148,
0.0334941335,
0.0261738785,
-0.0083506508,
0.0027477192,
0.0285764262,
0.0012407923,
-0.0024929191,
0.008185003,
-0.0307644941,
-0.0367898941,
-0.002449485,
0.0103996517,
0.0492109582,
0.0048637311,
-0.0098137325,
0.0350160599,
-0.0061983541,
-0.0763118267,
-0.0034820181,
-0.0025914554,
0.0369850062,
-0.0556913763,
-0.0502676666,
0.0169053208,
0.0042790496,
0.0287055671,
0.0558754317,
0.0186718367,
-0.0047077942,
-0.0170661695,
-0.0222471915,
0.0196550544,
-0.0026232712,
0.0069598895,
0.0243869554,
0.0228553694,
0.0445600487,
0.0284130331,
-0.0289414059,
-0.0015614872,
0.0269816853,
2.595e-7,
0.0613484569,
0.0164233558,
0.0593114793,
0.0113338204,
0.0160201136,
0.0071200919,
0.0108247148,
0.0448223427,
-0.0054269205,
0.0044041593,
-0.0110107278,
-0.0154684223,
0.0354934931,
0.0349745266,
-0.1087433472,
-0.0393480361,
-0.0554023199,
-0.0408901162,
-0.04520794,
-0.0064445371,
0.0368227847,
0.0455116369,
-0.0096512251,
-0.0192034226,
-0.0261937305,
-0.0531068631,
0.0424147174,
-0.0108920727,
-0.0212883353,
0.0113578849,
0.0778046846,
-0.0009822691,
-0.0026282475,
0.0073494464,
0.0013392187,
0.026243329,
0.0296668112,
0.036334198,
0.0086119259,
-0.0448324643,
0.0024058574,
-0.0675464869,
0.0192008466,
-0.0130271297,
0.0596907027,
-0.0164775532,
0.0109241223,
-0.0558194444,
-0.0218910594,
-0.0094296411,
0.0101732537,
0.0308838021,
0.0024503812,
0.0080359569,
-0.0363517068,
0.0048373062,
0.0060944399,
-0.0952544957,
0.0001062902,
0.014390029,
-0.035458114,
-0.0588614829,
-0.0067092082,
-0.0043907263,
0.0213050935,
-0.1002657786,
-0.0228068158,
2.580807031e-34,
0.08718016,
-0.0058490685,
-0.021315245,
-0.002623678,
0.0315579325,
-0.0060524759,
-0.065890573,
0.0118184015,
0.0386223719,
-0.0715479404,
-0.0225974545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01360v1 | Nullpointer at ArAIEval Shared Task: Arabic Propagandist Technique Detection with Token-to-Word Mapping in Sequence Tagging | 2024-07-01T15:15:24 | 2024-07-01T15:15:24 | Abrar Abir, Kemal Oflazer | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper investigates the optimization of propaganda technique detection in
Arabic text, including tweets \& news paragraphs, from ArAIEval shared task 1.
Our approach involves fine-tuning the AraBERT v2 model with a neural network
classifier for sequence tagging. Experimental results show relying on the first
token of the word for technique prediction produces the best performance. In
addition, incorporating genre information as a feature further enhances the
model's performance. Our system achieved a score of 25.41, placing us 4$^{th}$
on the leaderboard. Subsequent post-submission improvements further raised our
score to 26.68. | [
0.0455777459,
0.0183543209,
-0.0141829457,
-0.0028460096,
-0.0559174009,
0.0082959961,
0.0324498899,
0.0270865466,
-0.0473381467,
-0.0299007781,
0.0170326848,
-0.0670235008,
0.0577749759,
0.0421226732,
0.0683820471,
0.0192962103,
0.0439134873,
0.0015516806,
0.0500868484,
-0.0055543464,
0.0350819528,
0.0292473286,
-0.0036251321,
0.0389107019,
-0.0504533648,
-0.0097094653,
0.0098505802,
-0.0348326266,
0.0328716487,
-0.0073282951,
0.0210902803,
0.0430304222,
0.0007819124,
0.0604515262,
0.0000017914,
-0.017721802,
-0.0319020264,
-0.0235524382,
0.0261835437,
-0.018511001,
0.093772538,
-0.0224993862,
-0.0313403942,
0.023329854,
-0.0673226118,
0.0096589234,
0.0356462672,
0.0576063357,
0.0691190138,
0.1116600484,
0.0022682168,
-0.0294167232,
0.0136797596,
-0.0169470888,
0.0070874239,
-0.0159113538,
0.0318379253,
-0.0708379373,
-0.0149108553,
0.0436832234,
-0.0017315904,
0.0554020666,
-0.0084913354,
-0.0056574903,
0.0002662413,
-0.0335598327,
-0.0348427184,
-0.0358159132,
0.0374029689,
-0.0315647982,
-0.0346643999,
-0.0415695868,
-0.0024937096,
0.022928467,
0.0184821393,
0.0040283226,
0.0015323985,
0.0201300737,
-0.0048591169,
0.0019618354,
0.0676052719,
-0.0254018661,
0.0226509552,
0.0326141268,
-0.020124644,
0.0326521955,
-0.0314910933,
-0.0378402062,
0.0409796238,
-0.036104098,
-0.0404217727,
-0.0759004131,
0.0410309248,
0.0237166714,
-0.0202870406,
-0.0150517831,
-0.0379106253,
-0.1020220146,
0.0133971013,
-0.1190479845,
0.005550364,
0.0397081487,
0.0495274216,
0.0122927083,
-0.03898919,
0.0067964531,
0.0260491557,
0.0221275613,
-0.0081375912,
0.0197170917,
-0.0304908566,
-0.0035208082,
-0.0101251276,
0.0303171314,
0.0101129189,
-0.0200521275,
-0.0956925377,
-0.0427095331,
-0.032464806,
0.019946035,
-0.0245247856,
0.0160917956,
-0.0200063456,
0.00828165,
0.0146759618,
0.0086206868,
-0.0129705286,
0.0046650576,
-0.0172309242,
-0.0321104974,
-0.0209863037,
0.0312805921,
-0.0059385002,
0.0061274776,
0.0255165845,
-0.0014377721,
-0.0083458591,
-0.0380242318,
-0.0445866846,
-0.0269404631,
-0.0242580008,
-0.0306452215,
-0.0098302104,
-0.0574853644,
0.0013109712,
-0.0064141122,
-0.0287822392,
-0.0030769485,
-0.0078705372,
0.0390891135,
-0.0198763479,
0.0654523298,
0.0592062064,
-0.0053445888,
0.0471339822,
0.0626130551,
-0.0004407929,
0.0903786719,
0.0287583601,
0.1180077568,
0.0187789984,
-0.0111171827,
0.0093624135,
0.0410828553,
0.0534406751,
-0.0075776936,
-0.0201980844,
-0.0528378598,
-0.0028734056,
0.0296935309,
-0.0209897868,
0.0167701785,
-0.0153197795,
-0.030742323,
0.033104986,
0.0262640249,
-0.0198324267,
-0.0020907864,
0.0563524738,
0.0161412526,
-0.0076257,
0.0019174339,
-0.0136534395,
-0.0094408887,
-0.0084369052,
-0.014220817,
0.0237413198,
0.0724040344,
-0.0120627163,
-0.037669722,
-0.0140381567,
0.0056526512,
0.0232024603,
-0.0281510912,
0.0456252247,
0.0476984195,
-0.0674424842,
-0.0147806397,
0.0077652079,
0.0318724886,
0.025945317,
-0.060225714,
-0.0344300717,
0.0316401683,
0.0439632386,
0.0058695693,
0.0096845897,
-0.0410553105,
0.0298042931,
0.0626766086,
-0.0242730919,
-0.0356200971,
-0.0268586148,
-0.0127874631,
-0.0296972059,
-0.0220783036,
0.0243405737,
0.0404367037,
0.010841595,
0.0616183877,
0.0073662931,
-0.0102562821,
-0.0255655292,
0.0142118074,
0.0245566349,
-0.0422874726,
-0.0323271416,
0.0254178792,
0.0545264743,
0.066091232,
-0.0277446117,
-0.0095940139,
0.0487053581,
-0.0367478281,
-0.020294426,
-0.035337355,
-0.0111668129,
0.0281319655,
0.0361969396,
-0.044836197,
-0.0201228503,
0.0704373494,
-0.0136561152,
-0.0246433765,
0.092161037,
-0.0228613783,
0.0400892384,
-0.0331177823,
0.0382771157,
-0.0167208891,
0.0296685118,
0.0017240804,
0.0404178314,
-0.0296489578,
0.0147490269,
-0.0253145657,
-0.054444965,
0.0054268981,
0.0496099927,
-0.0216184538,
0.0031514713,
0.0052058809,
-0.0095425276,
0.0399743691,
-0.0230338592,
0.0035545584,
-0.0441034995,
-0.0835388824,
-0.0195280071,
-0.0460939892,
0.0144451037,
-0.0099167656,
0.0114996219,
-0.0158970114,
0.0132085765,
-0.0534305871,
-0.0315667018,
-0.0048324061,
0.0279967971,
0.0122305127,
0.0027014976,
-0.0315514915,
-0.0012431213,
0.0232741591,
-0.0160869826,
0.0482735857,
0.0214272067,
-0.0665266514,
0.0152727393,
-0.0726177469,
0.0063508651,
0.0171393584,
-0.0428806134,
-0.0525456406,
0.0070607029,
0.0279049166,
-0.0263118409,
0.0536112636,
0.042424757,
0.0355393924,
-0.0066355173,
0.0495914258,
-0.0493427888,
-0.0274467897,
-0.0248047076,
0.0249658599,
-0.0493859388,
-0.0550233684,
-0.0093136476,
0.0133752413,
0.0082247667,
0.0172942095,
-0.0263766162,
0.0560650416,
-0.0108190067,
-0.0475453138,
0.0078451717,
-0.034753371,
-0.0140005052,
0.0176103842,
-0.0104212407,
-0.0216531772,
0.0442012176,
-0.0366221033,
0.0268721618,
-0.0182513855,
-0.0536473095,
0.0052518821,
-0.0156139499,
0.0101247709,
0.0372560993,
0.0040377458,
-0.0386500061,
-0.0093902927,
-0.0229211934,
0.0049689277,
-0.0221653339,
-0.0149189373,
0.0233224425,
-0.0221464466,
0.0102259582,
0.0054039452,
-0.033752773,
-0.0543092936,
0.0019964031,
0.0019696639,
0.041841086,
-0.0327593051,
-0.0240510814,
0.0268699434,
0.0193205979,
0.0088910945,
-0.0482061468,
0.0255164765,
-0.0020001812,
-0.0040901438,
0.0380481891,
-0.0574368499,
0.0018103123,
0.015837241,
-0.0295289196,
0.0537567176,
-0.0270035863,
-0.0047294577,
-0.0586086661,
-0.0177878793,
0.037817046,
-0.0756171793,
0.004957804,
-0.0385746248,
-0.0217411984,
-0.0588250272,
0.0364362784,
0.1034051999,
0.0210574083,
-0.02226099,
-0.0118681844,
0.0453995354,
0.0022935823,
-0.0223038979,
0.0028920227,
-0.0864103064,
0.0348206125,
0.0198276546,
0.0318395272,
-0.0284646768,
-0.0397517458,
-0.0022824563,
-0.0811058879,
-0.01928523,
0.0006576497,
-0.0231451765,
-0.0296287425,
-0.0784155056,
-0.0191723779,
-0.000658541,
-0.0182134528,
-0.0381421186,
0.0163445696,
0.0248870514,
0.0171791539,
0.0227227192,
-0.0677075386,
-0.0378978737,
-0.0460790023,
0.0278431308,
0.0504747666,
0.0221230276,
-0.0305817816,
-0.0262551475,
0.054864496,
0.0199689921,
-0.0087853735,
-0.0387805589,
0.0229980834,
-0.0666395128,
0.015569319,
0.028217271,
-0.0105036041,
-0.0187314488,
0.0234676208,
-0.0029642859,
0.0529942475,
0.0273572691,
0.0105393678,
-0.0099547897,
0.036979001,
0.0335029513,
0.0501071997,
0.0199829228,
-0.0327126905,
-0.020979194,
-0.0314534232,
-0.012796401,
-0.0761230811,
-0.0294204354,
-0.0330824107,
0.0265616253,
-0.0427661911,
-0.0663651824,
-0.065570198,
0.0166079588,
0.0660535023,
0.0255774371,
0.0293731522,
-0.0525651686,
0.0046774889,
-0.0602542944,
-0.0466579944,
0.0544471815,
0.030516725,
0.0053513744,
-0.0124571575,
-0.0103109991,
-0.0401200056,
-0.0075595742,
0.0106113935,
-0.0586771555,
-0.0734634027,
0.0169544108,
0.0087534795,
0.0268895049,
0.0446997918,
-0.0155408178,
-0.0434606597,
0.0715060532,
0.0586991385,
-0.0101921083,
0.0247521289,
0.0320415348,
-0.0187969897,
-0.009515224,
0.0331619456,
0.0215783864,
0.0189185347,
0.0599499531,
-0.026777694,
-0.0254295431,
0.0319284797,
-0.0000331202,
-0.0356895924,
0.0551959462,
-0.0719042495,
-0.075400278,
-0.0341681577,
-0.0177217349,
-0.0209778436,
0.0089123696,
0.0105415396,
0.0123841474,
0.0141397538,
0.0305899847,
-0.0074596344,
0.0152402818,
-0.0224643629,
0.0084661469,
-0.0018184605,
0.014296947,
-0.0192140881,
0.0336090773,
-0.0117421215,
0.0364189669,
0.0117463684,
-0.005945432,
0.0298144538,
0.0150537845,
-0.0284930374,
-0.009428571,
0.0127805285,
0.0288049094,
0.056061808,
0.0767097101,
-0.0126922494,
-0.0028039885,
-0.0301395766,
0.0266624298,
0.0362004079,
-0.04731071,
0.0375968777,
0.0081016384,
-0.0169178471,
0.0301809832,
0.0064089363,
-0.0556735434,
-0.0223032013,
-0.015983399,
0.0047837915,
-0.0284021758,
0.0278450008,
0.0272834487,
-0.0047466885,
-0.0069863284,
0.0925632268,
-0.0841275677,
-0.0022422655,
-0.0296315849,
0.0323685519,
0.037878789,
-0.0003352184,
-0.0043840604,
-0.0469490066,
-0.0646177828,
0.0275074206,
0.0088720964,
0.0032907238,
0.0328472741,
0.0372506045,
0.0837834701,
-0.0087989876,
0.0303947125,
-0.0631619394,
-0.0071498114,
0.0156408176,
-0.08184129,
0.0327349827,
-6.308034764e-33,
0.0152545404,
-0.0240704697,
0.0024878855,
-0.0016797538,
-0.0108409887,
0.0015765972,
0.020252984,
0.0014375977,
-0.0232764501,
0.0181187484,
-0.0142803695,
0.0259582885,
0.0113101825,
-0.0057790587,
-0.0194394644,
0.0032148792,
0.0516775362,
0.008707488,
-0.0387685001,
0.0050898674,
0.0585823171,
0.0355679691,
0.0595560707,
-0.0409772247,
0.0252716448,
0.0059921932,
-0.0492900871,
-0.0142852506,
0.0519657396,
0.0618681014,
-0.0044207661,
0.0230086483,
0.0258982107,
-0.0484895222,
0.036140386,
0.0363925286,
-0.0130361076,
-0.0372732207,
0.0309646744,
0.0187227707,
0.0210816413,
-0.0244943984,
0.0369682163,
-0.0243219174,
-0.0445130095,
0.048634056,
0.0400771946,
0.0035838941,
0.0106422054,
-0.0154633187,
-0.0653469488,
0.0266100615,
-0.0019113467,
0.0153659424,
0.0166727528,
0.0377321318,
0.0560854375,
0.0201199614,
-0.1010676846,
0.0238303579,
-0.0258281231,
0.0581298918,
0.0656311437,
0.0179953352,
-0.0443843305,
0.0573554114,
0.0331112221,
-0.0017840912,
0.0028253451,
0.0466841236,
0.0151664959,
-0.0278629325,
0.0774813369,
0.0435171835,
0.0450998358,
-0.0473749079,
-0.0618405119,
0.0287997685,
0.0323546082,
0.0068509239,
-0.0095910085,
-0.034066353,
-0.0613624193,
-0.0156481117,
-0.0140935816,
-0.050646618,
-0.0311312731,
-0.0499344841,
-0.0057719694,
0.0207048357,
-0.0155993057,
0.1011028215,
0.0173345786,
-0.0119626671,
0.0531659722,
0.0114922607,
-0.0149442926,
0.0187965352,
0.0075853709,
0.0454110317,
-0.0295727067,
0.0014221239,
0.0157306697,
0.0432073101,
0.0389361233,
-0.0292775221,
0.048619777,
0.0500308163,
-0.0768266618,
0.0059926338,
-0.0145935975,
0.0411387049,
-0.0038629295,
0.0155940261,
0.0320064649,
0.0029950293,
-0.0047101802,
0.0095577287,
0.0286226161,
0.0133173969,
0.0184855852,
0.0147950919,
-0.0429369733,
-0.026636038,
-0.0027276936,
0.0206482653,
-0.0084145553,
0.0501153022,
-0.0325807929,
-0.1143093407,
-0.0135574536,
-0.0273729563,
2.782e-7,
0.0087766265,
0.0237575434,
-0.024887085,
-0.0044703679,
0.0043526297,
0.0120539013,
0.013053352,
0.0301391315,
-0.0253178123,
-0.0482737944,
-0.0224016998,
-0.0146408686,
0.0159265324,
0.0295868684,
-0.1207176223,
-0.0312639028,
-0.0227522515,
0.0259740762,
-0.0820113495,
0.011459793,
-0.0154415919,
0.1058732271,
0.0198139641,
-0.0147456238,
-0.0370662659,
-0.0677946582,
0.0251163207,
0.0273098554,
-0.057798937,
0.0142721711,
0.0432345159,
-0.0355322137,
0.002313171,
-0.0132108554,
-0.0542862751,
0.0381605402,
-0.0022861999,
0.0489542037,
0.017163096,
-0.0102955038,
-0.0132642863,
-0.0278430358,
-0.0199278053,
-0.0866367593,
0.0453856476,
0.0223228727,
-0.0563039109,
-0.0006136426,
-0.0368204303,
0.02491102,
0.0438972376,
-0.0383568704,
-0.0062136939,
0.0130072609,
0.0196451582,
0.0149677396,
0.0096794832,
-0.0429294445,
0.0430343114,
-0.0250573289,
-0.0192322936,
-0.0218891129,
0.0020600292,
-0.0106440485,
0.0200830828,
0.005157805,
-0.0106144771,
2.498184931e-34,
0.0640124828,
-0.0485585742,
0.0057640173,
-0.028929336,
0.0321096964,
0.0207952559,
-0.0273092445,
0.0096132737,
0.0215592161,
-0.0222999752,
-0.0495225303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01358v1 | Evaluating Knowledge-based Cross-lingual Inconsistency in Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T15:11:37 | 2024-07-01T15:11:37 | Xiaolin Xing, Zhiwei He, Haoyu Xu, Xing Wang, Rui Wang, Yu Hong | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper investigates the cross-lingual inconsistencies observed in Large
Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, Llama, and Baichuan, which have shown
exceptional performance in various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks.
Despite their successes, these models often exhibit significant inconsistencies
when processing the same concepts across different languages. This study
focuses on three primary questions: the existence of cross-lingual
inconsistencies in LLMs, the specific aspects in which these inconsistencies
manifest, and the correlation between cross-lingual consistency and
multilingual capabilities of LLMs.To address these questions, we propose an
innovative evaluation method for Cross-lingual Semantic Consistency (xSC) using
the LaBSE model. We further introduce metrics for Cross-lingual Accuracy
Consistency (xAC) and Cross-lingual Timeliness Consistency (xTC) to
comprehensively assess the models' performance regarding semantic, accuracy,
and timeliness inconsistencies. By harmonizing these metrics, we provide a
holistic measurement of LLMs' cross-lingual consistency. Our findings aim to
enhance the understanding and improvement of multilingual capabilities and
interpretability in LLMs, contributing to the development of more robust and
reliable multilingual language models. | [
0.0434774794,
0.0117063243,
-0.0394027904,
0.0723245665,
-0.0726112425,
0.0029771617,
0.0040976978,
-0.0263950098,
0.0273342822,
-0.0314338692,
-0.0440474786,
-0.0595652014,
0.0504835322,
0.0037111237,
-0.0089275222,
-0.0200195387,
0.0833289847,
-0.0075868866,
-0.0294541456,
-0.0122802174,
0.0099762361,
-0.0010950813,
0.017362358,
0.0397736356,
0.0035603819,
-0.022367375,
0.0371936224,
-0.0418275781,
-0.0000169895,
-0.0287014879,
-0.0317860097,
0.0117357224,
-0.0121653825,
0.0581965148,
0.000002041,
-0.0724788681,
-0.0155771365,
-0.0030812176,
-0.0137961125,
0.0449204519,
0.0323725753,
-0.0564911291,
-0.0136634586,
-0.0296734124,
-0.0048649907,
0.0070335213,
0.0322329476,
0.0489851199,
0.0288261026,
0.0257851779,
0.0027966569,
-0.0114083216,
0.027937144,
-0.0342059992,
-0.0051205521,
-0.0539726913,
0.014374177,
0.0573258102,
-0.00455881,
0.0094041442,
-0.0410011671,
0.0672651827,
0.022841569,
0.0218425039,
-0.0620768219,
0.0192783903,
-0.0267909262,
-0.0457674339,
-0.0013057122,
0.0230078232,
-0.0027521008,
-0.0182666816,
-0.0390029699,
0.0088774189,
-0.0393808857,
0.0116420221,
-0.0389198661,
0.0331283621,
-0.0057759481,
0.0266099814,
0.0618825555,
0.0003295123,
0.0413082838,
0.0202422496,
-0.0045921504,
0.0911301598,
0.0243392717,
-0.0546356738,
-0.0176995154,
0.0247008894,
-0.0102717048,
-0.0493691005,
-0.0030904342,
-0.0174967926,
-0.0425446332,
0.0466979966,
0.0062406431,
0.0148740895,
0.0455992185,
-0.09722168,
-0.0025653378,
0.0544826835,
-0.0477462374,
0.0408995673,
-0.0127564678,
0.0867588967,
-0.0149438875,
0.0181264598,
-0.0178789403,
-0.035372369,
-0.0621188544,
-0.0167232957,
0.0153027708,
-0.0119730737,
-0.0287745222,
-0.0309951957,
-0.0646947697,
0.016925782,
-0.0273896586,
0.0059161093,
0.0107487859,
-0.0426362604,
-0.0190553665,
0.0047024302,
-0.0782339126,
0.0555856638,
-0.013781989,
-0.0000198501,
-0.0389622711,
-0.066036731,
0.0114320135,
-0.0050095893,
-0.0721845329,
-0.0401445851,
-0.0210306942,
0.0627490655,
-0.0040373062,
0.0132061234,
-0.0363569893,
-0.0172995403,
-0.0576966517,
-0.1064098552,
-0.0206426401,
-0.0678048953,
0.0505767353,
0.0216097347,
0.025135329,
-0.027822258,
0.0196674056,
-0.0081921183,
-0.0469186381,
0.0608071946,
0.0081106909,
0.0297870748,
0.0087906709,
0.0148224933,
0.0063202232,
0.0744501725,
0.0136743253,
-0.0536696762,
0.0801316053,
0.0242350772,
-0.0751413628,
0.0409540832,
-0.0308300927,
-0.0120374337,
-0.0360422991,
-0.0080395006,
0.0289095137,
0.0364036672,
0.0075863972,
0.0378619991,
-0.0202153418,
-0.0078986259,
0.007122892,
-0.0063519715,
0.0236562062,
0.006107301,
0.0438931473,
-0.0150111141,
0.0073709455,
0.0171077065,
-0.019638218,
-0.0053698281,
0.0001957191,
0.041658368,
0.003213681,
0.0555395111,
-0.0149989156,
-0.0342190154,
-0.0348976292,
0.012615351,
0.0073109809,
-0.0266928636,
0.0597863197,
-0.0187886208,
0.001571507,
0.0639762059,
0.0421937704,
-0.0241813418,
0.0178226903,
-0.0289095454,
0.010467303,
0.0980503261,
0.0141793638,
0.0125002675,
-0.0314565301,
0.0266812593,
0.0006927846,
0.0520185903,
0.0592374988,
-0.0049062842,
-0.0004846161,
-0.0433646999,
-0.0393371359,
-0.0196113475,
0.003724474,
0.0229410399,
-0.0015498857,
0.0561949946,
0.0044685751,
-0.0526404306,
-0.0226038862,
0.0256893542,
-0.0881063044,
0.0377731547,
-0.0405798815,
-0.0027631957,
0.0366287194,
0.0249379184,
-0.0137047041,
0.0093925996,
0.0091041205,
-0.020320097,
0.0202420633,
0.0486752242,
-0.0386633947,
-0.0369807407,
0.0559927635,
0.0219332594,
-0.0304791257,
0.0126105631,
-0.0032421385,
-0.0341965817,
0.0082788402,
0.0090512978,
0.0440872498,
-0.0505557917,
0.0486174859,
-0.0287354775,
0.025535794,
-0.0062600086,
0.0566622876,
-0.0194915086,
0.0698422119,
0.0105314264,
0.0083760638,
0.0318697728,
-0.0239676759,
-0.0505325645,
0.090723455,
0.0180335566,
-0.0204687454,
0.0340979323,
-0.0043199677,
-0.0260534938,
-0.0303336699,
-0.0796711892,
0.0076207789,
-0.0305754878,
0.0238291826,
0.0189135894,
-0.0125119658,
-0.0139315967,
0.0094135692,
0.0201529004,
-0.0051159654,
0.0279959645,
0.0501032397,
0.0255526174,
0.003819328,
-0.010145057,
-0.024277281,
-0.0109329717,
0.0082370797,
0.038586434,
-0.0085878531,
-0.0600440614,
-0.0473298393,
0.0141399726,
-0.0850685984,
0.0032884593,
-0.0243399702,
-0.0158527009,
0.0186811853,
0.0566042103,
0.0520641841,
-0.023198422,
-0.0218463093,
0.0141794709,
0.0677591413,
-0.0490245074,
-0.0566444881,
-0.0208361819,
0.0045124386,
-0.0364367776,
-0.0417939499,
-0.0387848802,
-0.0316395052,
0.0734655857,
0.0041205185,
-0.0109980227,
-0.0169663243,
-0.0119721033,
-0.0724127442,
-0.0306508243,
-0.0061493707,
-0.0046632211,
-0.0084139034,
0.0293670595,
-0.0433822311,
-0.0226029195,
0.055918254,
-0.058169309,
0.0253510382,
-0.0465753414,
0.0125097213,
-0.0276181623,
0.0492524207,
-0.0260078516,
0.0326041915,
-0.0159840081,
-0.0319201648,
-0.0450778604,
-0.0089208921,
0.0325314961,
-0.017480487,
0.0366901048,
-0.0413528197,
0.0053121448,
0.0053713107,
-0.0089147482,
-0.0230810568,
0.0065468606,
-0.0138068339,
0.0406022482,
0.0093980823,
0.0275347531,
-0.0227505043,
0.0306940097,
0.0287359152,
-0.0206311438,
-0.0070113293,
0.0006849138,
-0.0194176808,
-0.007273728,
0.0025998517,
0.0160959624,
0.0373598784,
-0.0108774006,
0.0407786779,
0.0078675793,
-0.0030373661,
0.0014060781,
0.0185141712,
0.0004772029,
0.0083036274,
-0.0329472385,
-0.0802182481,
-0.0060732574,
0.0367657058,
-0.0715125352,
-0.002493785,
0.0986539423,
0.0487972274,
0.020652473,
0.0126200505,
-0.0342201032,
-0.0149384467,
0.0355498679,
-0.005135003,
-0.071732305,
-0.0126725249,
0.0105707217,
-0.0207291804,
-0.014803811,
-0.0126072718,
-0.0131461071,
-0.1246325448,
0.0110626109,
0.008558603,
-0.0602702908,
-0.024572704,
-0.029503122,
-0.0190681871,
-0.0065030362,
0.0775030702,
0.007633721,
-0.0089696143,
-0.0055346983,
0.0018370935,
-0.0421899781,
-0.0773584247,
0.0525279231,
-0.0224974453,
0.0459759943,
0.0471753851,
0.0394258983,
0.0011136375,
-0.0279185604,
0.0408658832,
0.0051159514,
-0.0016249144,
-0.0273506194,
-0.0238479991,
0.0094118221,
-0.0155925713,
-0.0063216095,
-0.050462164,
0.0297173411,
-0.007588123,
-0.0217072833,
0.0768082067,
0.0065840716,
0.0028218569,
0.0068246918,
0.0038432933,
-0.0174255967,
0.0892602801,
-0.0285732914,
0.0086505776,
-0.0395602733,
0.0132368654,
-0.0252511092,
0.0020892478,
-0.0122397169,
0.0429590642,
-0.0505965576,
-0.0179781821,
-0.0420614071,
-0.0786872581,
-0.0274348836,
-0.0349487215,
0.0212304965,
0.0392461494,
0.0010195466,
-0.0135398023,
-0.0064399829,
0.0130027514,
-0.0052047721,
0.0230711885,
-0.0356208831,
0.0452572778,
0.0151659958,
-0.0142469471,
-0.0123499855,
0.0334241539,
-0.0361585058,
-0.0481807552,
-0.000199154,
-0.0018065949,
0.0161803886,
0.048822742,
-0.0115843778,
-0.0014821523,
-0.0046098172,
0.0167530216,
-0.0200492945,
0.0188780185,
0.0049106777,
0.0358818285,
0.0089482581,
0.0559949987,
-0.0409449562,
-0.0090500228,
-0.0368845612,
0.0968187153,
-0.0130140781,
-0.0383573882,
0.0141441738,
0.0220607184,
0.0290235411,
-0.0225572493,
0.0006387574,
-0.0532963537,
-0.0010170101,
-0.0458953492,
-0.0298912134,
-0.0150372395,
-0.0050097466,
0.0424598642,
-0.0115731247,
-0.0095814737,
0.0373027734,
-0.0310997944,
-0.0139223607,
-0.0197531935,
-0.0141271148,
0.0116065554,
0.029538041,
-0.0059865741,
0.0201307964,
-0.0147340568,
-0.0072960663,
-0.020441873,
0.0052312175,
-0.041484464,
0.0532132797,
-0.0041540712,
-0.0027970881,
-0.0073029641,
-0.0089157149,
-0.0189375635,
-0.0227648504,
0.0173263643,
0.031247586,
0.0661548078,
-0.0117186103,
0.096099779,
-0.0419005305,
-0.0094080186,
-0.0357005447,
0.0223801434,
0.0358056501,
-0.0264273677,
0.0352371372,
-0.0108203245,
-0.042564638,
0.0071480526,
0.0733450502,
-0.0026487869,
0.0360713862,
-0.0270894263,
-0.05029127,
0.0093775149,
-0.0511146672,
0.0043415343,
-0.0148946932,
-0.0474655591,
-0.0121761048,
-0.1001700014,
-0.055702161,
0.0525867604,
0.031198686,
-0.0112699848,
0.01435614,
-0.021130817,
0.1089218855,
0.0112023158,
0.0015987903,
-0.0445691198,
-0.0275814906,
0.0111725908,
0.0191285834,
0.0115102734,
-6.01924225e-33,
-0.0230789874,
0.0003331832,
0.0272493809,
-0.0449688435,
-0.0413264148,
0.0102287522,
-0.0416010991,
-0.0016348561,
-0.0158736762,
0.0158636477,
0.0226058532,
0.0006787836,
0.0276508834,
-0.0259050988,
0.0513853431,
-0.0121536097,
0.0363770798,
0.0365428068,
0.0030873665,
-0.0195226818,
0.0836094767,
0.0024622816,
0.096949175,
-0.0564912595,
0.1181285903,
0.0148269907,
0.0222998187,
0.0257887505,
0.0134424912,
0.08582706,
-0.0255352557,
0.0543388873,
0.0460119992,
-0.0512847006,
-0.0208704304,
-0.044282835,
-0.0585705005,
-0.0506214574,
0.0915196389,
0.0271636993,
0.016697716,
-0.0084059732,
0.0353204161,
-0.0181100611,
-0.0403667539,
0.0280841179,
0.0236391146,
-0.037671566,
0.0018846317,
0.0394851118,
-0.0806372687,
0.0323839523,
0.0084932791,
0.0071167517,
0.0142835695,
0.0510151275,
-0.0021265962,
0.0136722401,
-0.0852419585,
-0.0057717194,
-0.0196285024,
0.0177056864,
0.0994652286,
-0.0034757233,
0.0162613541,
0.0677424148,
0.0069485768,
0.0035626499,
0.0014755693,
0.00305682,
0.0443376116,
0.0156637691,
0.0181681644,
0.0664637536,
-0.0059664315,
-0.0173603948,
-0.0826519728,
-0.0065702307,
0.014031969,
0.064607732,
0.0107249673,
0.0052995179,
-0.0399543755,
-0.0315946005,
-0.0399117619,
-0.0114402939,
-0.0229518786,
-0.037654765,
0.050640963,
-0.0141774742,
0.0223468505,
0.0255926009,
0.0457300022,
-0.0418842435,
-0.0540197082,
0.0083275,
-0.0220488179,
-0.0037389807,
0.0129670966,
0.0650429875,
-0.0747934282,
-0.0263724327,
-0.0384285823,
0.0120253302,
-0.0097907893,
-0.0146147404,
0.0077393018,
-0.0222211014,
-0.0363573655,
0.0115358355,
-0.0346789695,
-0.0238555241,
-0.0181403421,
-0.025302846,
0.0560420044,
-0.0244315472,
-0.0436590053,
0.0334976129,
0.0441565327,
-0.0019112407,
-0.010871877,
-0.0186214428,
-0.0166485533,
0.0288279131,
-0.017270403,
0.0159055684,
-0.0443393141,
0.0331146531,
0.0111592896,
-0.0124491174,
0.0006430836,
0.0305695366,
2.733e-7,
0.0410134681,
0.0271391924,
-0.0032605191,
0.0218464006,
0.0127959838,
-0.0109961079,
-0.0741952285,
0.0101352455,
-0.0298898444,
-0.0156334732,
-0.0271703973,
0.0268914476,
0.0559846461,
0.0395074748,
-0.0045725685,
-0.0022845075,
-0.0463956036,
-0.0078794984,
-0.0646779984,
0.035289593,
0.0294536483,
0.0486447737,
0.0073370775,
0.016912546,
-0.0368184485,
-0.0594413318,
0.0613723397,
-0.0308958963,
-0.0583604574,
0.0275635272,
0.0411868021,
0.0454949476,
0.0479013324,
0.001465291,
-0.0132455183,
0.0273003615,
0.0414548218,
0.0448306724,
0.0009235668,
0.0144864786,
-0.0187965129,
-0.0305332821,
-0.0280160382,
-0.0658196583,
0.0721237436,
-0.0243287161,
-0.0180740282,
-0.0277222823,
0.0127016744,
0.014644674,
0.0793573856,
-0.0061216075,
-0.0401429534,
0.0292932317,
0.0365127549,
0.0103346398,
-0.0426558256,
-0.0245450679,
-0.0177361425,
0.0281766243,
-0.0088888612,
-0.0409928374,
-0.0081749428,
-0.0171241537,
0.0345289893,
-0.0605103113,
-0.0005193647,
2.247297473e-34,
0.0403498821,
0.0124217533,
0.035659153,
-0.0152561208,
0.0344327129,
-0.0105215861,
0.0068129385,
0.032111723,
-0.0498452187,
-0.0255242847,
0.002907123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01334v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01334v2 | Protecting Privacy in Classifiers by Token Manipulation | 2024-07-01T14:41:59 | 2024-07-03T16:31:52 | Re'em Harel, Yair Elboher, Yuval Pinter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Using language models as a remote service entails sending private information
to an untrusted provider. In addition, potential eavesdroppers can intercept
the messages, thereby exposing the information. In this work, we explore the
prospects of avoiding such data exposure at the level of text manipulation. We
focus on text classification models, examining various token mapping and
contextualized manipulation functions in order to see whether classifier
accuracy may be maintained while keeping the original text unrecoverable. We
find that although some token mapping functions are easy and straightforward to
implement, they heavily influence performance on the downstream task, and via a
sophisticated attacker can be reconstructed. In comparison, the contextualized
manipulation provides an improvement in performance. | [
0.0350912437,
0.0693323687,
-0.0149090523,
0.0439432189,
-0.0964030251,
-0.0102598201,
0.0782079175,
-0.0020722114,
-0.000851492,
-0.0728632212,
-0.0221867058,
0.0059361667,
0.0216521323,
0.0501036309,
0.0162634309,
0.0099537903,
0.0128386989,
-0.0314672291,
-0.0175378006,
-0.0063729002,
-0.0493434705,
-0.0071575064,
0.0269231554,
0.0323524661,
-0.0334560387,
-0.0181811973,
0.0181060955,
-0.0172181614,
-0.0033710492,
-0.003437002,
-0.0175007619,
0.0468931831,
0.0029370268,
0.0634386092,
0.0000017402,
-0.029111838,
-0.0562520847,
0.0537232161,
-0.0353191532,
0.0006629325,
0.0682066679,
-0.0242679361,
0.005724987,
0.0207406338,
-0.0384352207,
0.0183370467,
0.0475250706,
0.0557292998,
0.0578128062,
0.0638334602,
-0.0231655408,
0.0007114293,
0.0113387853,
0.0056597451,
-0.0023675747,
-0.0435593948,
0.0420369096,
-0.0732570663,
-0.053829629,
0.0499657057,
-0.009218921,
0.027114382,
0.001995397,
0.0072146957,
0.0212120917,
0.0249091182,
-0.0484126657,
0.0009625262,
-0.0088977106,
-0.0160245039,
-0.0135388942,
-0.0197739694,
-0.0053036739,
0.0323532075,
0.0333999172,
0.0260169636,
0.0117251892,
0.0212027002,
0.0146031715,
-0.0008126667,
-0.0146743767,
-0.0102554746,
0.0445908681,
0.0195167791,
0.0147326393,
0.0714024529,
-0.0151648913,
0.0161629487,
-0.0388624594,
-0.0238730088,
0.0117970267,
-0.0860301852,
0.0550980009,
0.019087106,
0.0389328673,
0.0141814351,
-0.0846340805,
-0.0552564524,
-0.0035607575,
-0.0419803448,
-0.0256801415,
0.0043538725,
-0.0013944627,
0.0348981656,
-0.0436049663,
0.0213942677,
0.0233955868,
0.0741017759,
0.0039749746,
-0.0176540799,
-0.0325524211,
-0.0400025547,
-0.0160365049,
0.0935121477,
-0.0503503457,
-0.0073262481,
-0.0610480942,
0.0454915874,
-0.0016303447,
0.0205097701,
-0.0413489565,
-0.0047624898,
-0.0093205087,
0.0215323027,
-0.0011111152,
-0.0557805561,
0.029539533,
0.0301826429,
-0.0003392953,
-0.0416852944,
0.0049066986,
-0.0189900212,
-0.0017392884,
-0.0049416507,
-0.0201251544,
0.088127099,
0.0163668841,
-0.0446552038,
-0.0192948524,
-0.0657986328,
-0.004529532,
0.0139546758,
-0.035055697,
-0.0352138914,
-0.0019203774,
0.0078930892,
-0.0337788127,
-0.0291961394,
-0.0090928515,
0.0080313804,
-0.0607598089,
0.1011788845,
0.0253313445,
-0.0301945023,
0.0081235496,
0.0209156033,
-0.0412232429,
0.0162107367,
0.0188424364,
0.0553238578,
0.0719714984,
-0.0210239626,
0.0374890231,
-0.0014476788,
0.0209974349,
-0.0297999494,
-0.0293251034,
0.0310894772,
0.051193025,
-0.0545622446,
-0.0308403,
0.0570890941,
-0.0111626266,
-0.0273668431,
0.0645037666,
0.092031844,
-0.0286282431,
0.0277898032,
-0.0457812548,
0.0126971053,
-0.0472579785,
-0.0175531711,
-0.0733748153,
-0.0219688732,
-0.0408656932,
-0.0742134303,
-0.0164591391,
0.0055904645,
0.0134867746,
-0.0139124673,
0.0172750764,
-0.0509698987,
0.0392946377,
-0.0034778249,
0.0190657508,
0.0228089802,
0.0280812979,
0.0508127771,
-0.0094945394,
-0.0285264868,
0.014435688,
-0.0726485774,
-0.0105367927,
0.0684116408,
0.0400317945,
-0.0105842873,
0.0152209345,
-0.034451101,
0.0047271447,
0.007832434,
-0.0074228966,
0.0015052968,
0.0536176153,
0.0017733766,
-0.0288781412,
0.0194136463,
0.024597669,
0.014231924,
0.0054477183,
0.0206667893,
0.018278772,
-0.0513839759,
0.0059800865,
0.0474519841,
0.0545035899,
-0.0481229126,
0.0727235004,
0.0178509094,
0.0154268919,
0.0242165495,
0.0207767915,
0.0279534385,
0.0171392076,
0.0084523456,
0.0026700117,
-0.0231531672,
0.0139445495,
0.0120886331,
-0.0217636731,
-0.004851141,
0.0114089977,
0.0459769703,
-0.0249599628,
-0.0042017209,
0.0005171365,
-0.0060396865,
0.072111249,
-0.003275157,
0.0221120063,
-0.0136391474,
0.0402182154,
-0.0184051096,
0.0211613849,
-0.019818468,
0.0004552109,
-0.0781354532,
-0.0204703454,
-0.0138994856,
0.0076599093,
-0.001873482,
-0.0089680078,
-0.026182387,
-0.0050381292,
0.008287915,
-0.0225003194,
0.0040032752,
-0.0409714244,
-0.0456505567,
-0.0200465042,
-0.0096871173,
0.0367938131,
0.0179580133,
0.0213166438,
0.0083287852,
-0.0383031778,
-0.0527551174,
-0.0511518233,
-0.0684868842,
0.0599849969,
0.0386036932,
0.0062066182,
-0.0290641095,
0.0427414142,
-0.0038294862,
0.003482183,
0.0519902296,
-0.0427717343,
-0.0248639248,
-0.0386443809,
-0.0133558391,
-0.0106417751,
0.0074100122,
-0.0006489393,
0.0006576231,
-0.0170691684,
0.0503115989,
-0.0350942127,
0.049953714,
0.0180271808,
0.0295775365,
0.0198114701,
0.0124130556,
-0.0083352802,
-0.0083057145,
0.0010050978,
-0.0008615813,
-0.0415940434,
-0.0092045842,
0.0228282586,
0.0081528826,
0.0071629509,
-0.0614181608,
-0.0100155361,
0.0535462089,
-0.0059376396,
-0.0351721756,
-0.0257451478,
-0.0366460048,
0.0116314199,
-0.0022921714,
-0.0017547639,
-0.0643693209,
0.0662293062,
-0.0373231024,
0.0381757021,
-0.0325118452,
-0.0379049182,
0.0080361096,
0.0598394386,
-0.0054927669,
0.033097446,
0.0024567235,
-0.060336072,
-0.0059618447,
-0.0053057396,
0.028826233,
-0.044854261,
-0.011046702,
-0.0102404868,
-0.0260046683,
0.0083647892,
-0.0480188727,
-0.0385709777,
-0.0743170232,
0.0063865925,
0.017518349,
0.017168114,
-0.0431306213,
-0.0292483885,
0.0124549745,
0.023836853,
0.0123773171,
-0.0386766344,
-0.0095107378,
-0.0266907271,
-0.0163174439,
-0.0337812006,
-0.0585595183,
-0.0334397219,
0.0137190865,
-0.0047741411,
0.0876647457,
0.0679069161,
-0.0210196786,
0.0452805161,
-0.0377841443,
0.0151783181,
-0.0431029648,
-0.0497852005,
-0.0047254749,
0.0242124796,
-0.0368022956,
-0.0041739368,
0.0585363097,
0.040616639,
-0.0532355905,
0.0098284744,
0.0163774453,
-0.0223005917,
-0.0268888734,
0.0096331183,
-0.0655405,
0.0042960816,
0.050150007,
0.046565935,
-0.05021796,
-0.0269710664,
-0.0271580294,
-0.054822877,
0.015809942,
0.0002615367,
-0.0718301982,
-0.0383934788,
-0.0437386073,
0.0007872536,
0.0134371538,
-0.0088645909,
-0.0557734966,
0.0280099474,
-0.012072362,
0.00044084,
-0.0155224893,
-0.0106496941,
-0.0293173268,
-0.0221462976,
-0.002763896,
0.0319188647,
0.0221999083,
-0.0070764176,
-0.0117386645,
0.041641511,
0.0507418029,
0.0046302448,
-0.0027106917,
0.0499981381,
-0.0357503518,
0.0134171508,
0.0103366757,
0.0641251281,
0.0186304469,
-0.025668636,
0.0230626967,
0.0321718641,
-0.0012132226,
0.020053111,
0.0168047324,
-0.0579586849,
0.0334741361,
0.0669173002,
-0.0319142789,
-0.0449478999,
-0.0096365167,
-0.0415437408,
0.0304081682,
0.0225320887,
0.0095433025,
0.0000946543,
-0.0209249761,
-0.0732481629,
-0.0492718294,
0.0377369709,
-0.0005301277,
0.0256658122,
0.0358232297,
0.0491914749,
0.0168789942,
-0.0003217627,
-0.046750322,
-0.0106135905,
-0.0562731549,
0.0423202254,
-0.0090392996,
-0.0000291355,
0.0143922521,
-0.0097913416,
-0.0235248581,
-0.0187683068,
-0.0312965922,
-0.0646727532,
0.0296821855,
0.0034362469,
0.0183469653,
0.0430966802,
-0.0478346273,
-0.0714580119,
0.0958756208,
0.1025545001,
-0.0599349216,
-0.0008281143,
0.02442329,
0.0098661575,
0.006007906,
0.0141129531,
-0.0440047495,
-0.0176568665,
0.0658017173,
-0.0517344214,
-0.045246724,
0.0188224353,
-0.0340482406,
0.0157380011,
0.0863628089,
0.0218436029,
0.0117078647,
0.0175105389,
0.0512163304,
-0.0556687973,
-0.0133536626,
0.0043974994,
-0.020678781,
0.0386424065,
0.026773829,
0.0135942316,
-0.012662855,
0.0156654511,
0.0087439884,
0.0027473643,
0.0129372049,
-0.0054549491,
0.0360704027,
0.0305924602,
0.0048166942,
-0.0258107111,
-0.0091331471,
0.0517200045,
0.0287719034,
-0.0366892628,
0.0074831503,
0.0267390329,
0.0065314728,
-0.0113926483,
0.0247619227,
-0.0782760233,
0.0035327892,
-0.0479628704,
0.0414843224,
-0.0612837896,
0.008455229,
-0.0316935368,
-0.0451511741,
-0.0073628351,
-0.0061750114,
-0.0134729855,
0.008463637,
-0.0406012274,
-0.0104648136,
-0.0227707028,
-0.0247410052,
0.0437127426,
0.0573641807,
-0.0051512108,
0.0168233402,
-0.0055879066,
-0.0768741816,
-0.0627901182,
0.0071185944,
0.0421111807,
0.0103207398,
-0.0194746032,
-0.0225066505,
-0.0319719352,
-0.0628496483,
0.0411020517,
-0.0455558486,
0.0360106565,
-0.0069353445,
-0.0335826911,
0.0556516536,
0.003452718,
-0.0400517061,
-0.0846187174,
0.0297002308,
0.0438424461,
-0.0362017713,
0.0116583137,
-4.938347644e-33,
0.0096369805,
-0.0341060162,
-0.0364870057,
0.0497772507,
0.0626476631,
0.0295223631,
0.0332413055,
-0.0199126191,
0.0278096776,
-0.0229734983,
-0.0175616257,
0.0243160166,
0.0248740632,
0.0582570322,
-0.0313385017,
-0.001865544,
0.0434282869,
-0.0120768584,
-0.0163124967,
0.0118492628,
0.0707179606,
0.0221566539,
0.0418959521,
-0.110262014,
0.0475378074,
0.0224980488,
-0.0496174246,
0.0230159108,
-0.0096606538,
0.0401820168,
-0.0205146912,
-0.0360833444,
0.0141314184,
0.0141456164,
0.0258561429,
0.0511159487,
-0.0358176827,
-0.0031770244,
-0.0176565554,
0.0350140519,
0.0136409933,
-0.0700026453,
0.0324836113,
-0.0168107655,
0.007322297,
0.011286173,
-0.017375445,
-0.0071522417,
-0.0345595405,
-0.0351997167,
0.0063903052,
0.0175693259,
-0.0186036881,
0.0048082038,
0.0624428354,
0.0256136041,
0.0201786309,
-0.0282145683,
-0.0446030051,
0.0294153467,
0.0138427541,
-0.0051875776,
0.0289489459,
0.0274527539,
0.0217349157,
0.0441906489,
0.0663574487,
-0.0179105978,
-0.0031242499,
-0.0068677315,
-0.0115068983,
0.0201264583,
0.0276306104,
0.0337524489,
0.0425882116,
-0.0555235408,
-0.0408116132,
-0.0000446094,
-0.0357085243,
-0.0351519585,
0.0949956924,
0.0106601035,
-0.0595562756,
-0.0030928552,
-0.0508906953,
-0.0428507552,
-0.0480479561,
-0.0035849186,
-0.0203306023,
0.0078402152,
-0.0657063127,
0.010875822,
-0.0093906708,
-0.0532181896,
-0.0543538854,
-0.00297577,
0.0550984256,
-0.0044993279,
-0.0310302414,
-0.0255042817,
0.0123802768,
0.0017360392,
0.013980601,
-0.0257044267,
0.0291375667,
-0.0057011098,
0.0906989947,
0.0077886065,
-0.0974311456,
-0.0396392532,
0.0040914733,
0.057266444,
0.0486253835,
0.0282884557,
0.0655294433,
-0.0267348569,
0.0046820152,
0.001317559,
0.0320255123,
0.0457713157,
-0.0189627521,
0.0324177481,
-0.0112178549,
-0.0311488304,
0.0004157072,
-0.0171269029,
0.0353335701,
0.0351212025,
0.0601924397,
0.0023991822,
0.0116662001,
-0.0106405448,
2.562e-7,
0.0257677678,
0.0203630477,
-0.0068036378,
-0.0270027891,
0.0380470082,
0.0596482642,
0.0405569412,
0.0571780726,
-0.0043220804,
0.0283126887,
-0.0310028605,
-0.0418865904,
0.0412882864,
0.045768436,
-0.0796683133,
0.0121814087,
-0.0169335008,
0.0026734767,
-0.0181141067,
0.0567194894,
0.0351904109,
0.0911031812,
0.0291153081,
-0.0288066156,
-0.0448350944,
-0.0650247931,
0.0100002401,
-0.0623213015,
0.0020263128,
-0.0418373384,
-0.0057907896,
0.0613762401,
0.0394785702,
0.0468116328,
-0.0575175583,
0.014079107,
-0.029184144,
0.063743256,
0.004765206,
-0.0385233611,
-0.0395410582,
-0.0320839286,
0.0069410717,
-0.0213997476,
0.0530055352,
-0.0308466293,
-0.048485104,
-0.0317697451,
-0.0011590529,
-0.0302531216,
0.0337853618,
-0.0111449286,
-0.0205679648,
0.0604635216,
0.0102048544,
0.0121857077,
0.0022073167,
-0.0864137262,
-0.0292113312,
-0.0661298409,
-0.0087339738,
-0.0382216536,
0.0074191228,
0.0436645858,
0.036170695,
-0.0159161594,
0.0394135118,
2.216319753e-34,
-0.0165111423,
-0.0269880723,
-0.0210075323,
0.0424889773,
0.0194102209,
0.0026583823,
0.0665284544,
0.0272781663,
0.0131817926,
-0.0633291006,
-0.0108725764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01320v1 | Increasing Model Capacity for Free: A Simple Strategy for Parameter Efficient Fine-tuning | 2024-07-01T14:26:48 | 2024-07-01T14:26:48 | Haobo Song, Hao Zhao, Soumajit Majumder, Tao Lin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Fine-tuning large pre-trained foundation models, such as the 175B GPT-3, has
attracted more attention for downstream tasks recently. While
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods have been proposed and proven effective
without retraining all model parameters, their performance is limited by the
capacity of incremental modules, especially under constrained parameter
budgets. \\ To overcome this challenge, we propose CapaBoost, a simple yet
effective strategy that enhances model capacity by leveraging low-rank updates
through parallel weight modules in target layers. By applying static random
masks to the shared weight matrix, CapaBoost constructs a diverse set of weight
matrices, effectively increasing the rank of incremental weights without adding
parameters. Notably, our approach can be seamlessly integrated into various
existing parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods. We extensively validate the
efficacy of CapaBoost through experiments on diverse downstream tasks,
including natural language understanding, question answering, and image
classification. Our results demonstrate significant improvements over
baselines, without incurring additional computation or storage costs. Our code
is available at \url{https://github.com/LINs-lab/CapaBoost}. | [
0.0354469754,
0.0661228672,
-0.0021964484,
0.0354527347,
0.0290401317,
0.0158341862,
0.012381495,
-0.0235840231,
-0.0046366504,
-0.0288161896,
-0.0459123813,
-0.0216900725,
-0.0104574952,
0.0307383277,
0.0183939319,
-0.060589388,
0.0378283821,
-0.0017924352,
-0.0358548798,
0.0019232406,
0.0076800692,
0.0324214511,
-0.0091837095,
-0.00062447,
0.048871845,
-0.0313204341,
-0.0322143286,
0.0133795524,
0.0468545407,
0.0008135182,
0.0433737487,
0.0855690241,
0.0364227481,
0.0160061996,
0.0000022503,
-0.0152326049,
-0.0160709936,
0.0068321885,
-0.0690682381,
0.0581980497,
0.0035969028,
0.0274587106,
0.0039598248,
0.0096462751,
-0.0297417678,
-0.0016706376,
0.0505748577,
0.04944399,
0.0503970422,
0.061073456,
-0.0032320858,
-0.0256994851,
0.0213240683,
-0.048211325,
-0.0133269373,
-0.0710729659,
-0.0070687751,
0.0225269645,
-0.0318102911,
-0.0035964837,
-0.0048110923,
0.0083825169,
0.048880022,
0.0422169156,
0.027496364,
0.0538534187,
-0.0581820384,
-0.006555106,
-0.01399808,
0.0901443064,
-0.0470822267,
-0.0099014323,
-0.0212319456,
-0.0321539231,
0.0034521043,
-0.0517859757,
-0.0279953498,
0.0004218702,
0.0097180838,
0.0106327618,
-0.0144847911,
-0.0096837888,
0.0567074567,
0.0335648023,
-0.0218547005,
-0.005611199,
0.0178259779,
0.0068013179,
-0.0084633594,
-0.0112699075,
-0.0740649179,
-0.0324539281,
-0.0133401966,
-0.002743663,
-0.0329375491,
-0.0111282151,
-0.0584933162,
-0.0536161251,
0.0041402043,
-0.0069359941,
0.0635571182,
0.0334217288,
-0.0318878926,
0.0635930151,
-0.0403223634,
0.001889596,
-0.0490279496,
0.027720727,
-0.0234238356,
0.000135395,
-0.0329873413,
-0.0181219932,
-0.0653132647,
0.0371510796,
-0.0698321536,
-0.0382963829,
-0.0390107296,
0.0246575568,
-0.006266172,
-0.0412637144,
-0.0030123105,
0.0104089817,
-0.0280558374,
-0.0130182179,
0.0326511413,
0.0360381678,
-0.0245813932,
0.0177666005,
-0.0161488093,
-0.0548505634,
-0.039279215,
-0.0223171171,
0.0063590435,
-0.0402799621,
0.0457843058,
0.0129163843,
-0.0249950457,
-0.083846435,
-0.0133353462,
-0.0023476938,
0.0139833679,
-0.067249544,
-0.0061859712,
-0.0120174894,
0.0114775728,
-0.0145730963,
0.0294695962,
-0.0033480255,
-0.0032799998,
0.0072536031,
-0.0385605507,
0.0881056413,
0.0098424098,
-0.0381619968,
0.0030154642,
0.0279453211,
-0.0294816643,
0.0760201663,
0.0026131186,
0.0481213219,
0.0104260603,
-0.0143508399,
-0.0407238305,
0.0120779993,
0.0304688979,
0.0279303733,
0.0090223709,
0.0292743519,
0.0513480008,
0.0142102381,
-0.0038859595,
-0.0115299048,
-0.0591385737,
-0.0299822483,
0.0443090945,
-0.0014518523,
-0.0019933172,
0.0588493384,
0.0107952897,
-0.0470746942,
0.0123724286,
-0.0151208807,
-0.0622546226,
0.0465603806,
-0.0662798062,
-0.0357760899,
-0.0024249488,
0.0716232508,
-0.0450454839,
-0.0121919047,
0.0014768878,
-0.0040192492,
0.0037772746,
0.0503714904,
0.0437959768,
-0.0199746359,
-0.0245610178,
0.037930809,
0.0108058089,
-0.0428908542,
-0.0241012499,
-0.0655967891,
0.012085693,
0.0373776965,
-0.0057884254,
-0.028487917,
-0.041299399,
0.0122046452,
0.0688265115,
-0.0141961612,
0.064222306,
0.0263214018,
0.0919984654,
-0.0538056232,
-0.0185251664,
-0.021843385,
-0.0074055609,
0.0160849988,
0.0216525011,
0.0178620163,
0.0214531999,
-0.0005395425,
0.0008174324,
0.0099924486,
-0.013869131,
-0.0188373942,
0.024475934,
-0.0014563676,
0.0345922112,
-0.0151318172,
-0.0158785507,
-0.0464137383,
0.0227044392,
-0.0240811557,
-0.0120119546,
-0.0365967676,
-0.023129398,
0.0067715775,
0.0343832262,
-0.0004065727,
-0.0135924043,
0.0827075392,
-0.07789056,
-0.0524538867,
0.040713191,
-0.0034740113,
-0.0024848601,
-0.057334505,
-0.0231448635,
-0.0132708047,
0.0618734546,
-0.0235445537,
0.0348545834,
0.0026567301,
-0.031122677,
0.0248649567,
0.0222590026,
0.0494696051,
-0.0351355933,
-0.0056636138,
0.0021582264,
0.0021126517,
0.0047733276,
0.0033851527,
0.0259168986,
-0.0327469967,
-0.0354180411,
-0.100558579,
0.0503624007,
-0.0382070243,
-0.0009088621,
0.0300202295,
0.0594983399,
-0.0057261065,
-0.0291087255,
-0.0058937878,
0.006809799,
-0.0230355505,
0.0150782,
-0.0301345512,
0.003567978,
-0.003336889,
0.0051561184,
-0.0360374488,
0.0422855914,
0.0289496686,
0.0180878509,
-0.0052785068,
-0.0298343617,
-0.0508201905,
-0.0269014034,
0.0546649657,
-0.0042388351,
-0.0526237786,
-0.0260199141,
-0.0375308469,
0.0043524154,
0.0796604529,
-0.0165507682,
0.048837088,
0.0260598864,
0.0348171331,
0.0012974546,
0.0407495759,
-0.0007627486,
-0.0451805703,
-0.0235687215,
0.0208287295,
-0.0064213476,
0.0136308149,
-0.0190442167,
-0.0275325123,
-0.0846850574,
0.0173361935,
0.018222915,
-0.0085456325,
-0.0423211269,
0.0264959075,
-0.0136452094,
-0.0268381145,
-0.0278135184,
-0.0392213762,
0.0447651781,
-0.009774995,
-0.0216458272,
-0.0385038219,
-0.0371349677,
-0.0444728211,
0.0066486485,
0.0188946687,
0.0326700024,
0.0106241619,
-0.0102927452,
-0.0519542061,
-0.0017121005,
0.0269515645,
-0.0137875825,
-0.0178301856,
-0.0186722446,
0.0345797725,
-0.0450157821,
-0.079130426,
0.0056669912,
-0.0587342121,
-0.0179493185,
0.0491710603,
-0.0108912895,
-0.0380978771,
-0.0116149113,
-0.011736176,
0.0068974397,
0.0563204139,
-0.0497520566,
0.0034567693,
-0.0208830051,
0.0040330896,
0.0360801108,
0.0652012452,
0.0607972853,
-0.0164485183,
0.0273137335,
0.0269101709,
0.0415520817,
0.0007764918,
-0.0804054961,
0.0539758764,
-0.00094907,
-0.0033111414,
-0.0193776581,
0.0014455731,
0.0561495312,
-0.0442958437,
0.0278197676,
0.0838428289,
-0.0002358994,
-0.0359959602,
-0.0123150172,
0.0168151148,
0.0392032787,
0.0404976606,
0.0208928511,
-0.0609760247,
-0.0557432063,
-0.0043817353,
0.0325603038,
0.0054337392,
0.0067512398,
0.0059171114,
-0.0754764751,
0.0463229045,
-0.0076028109,
-0.0488012619,
-0.0049454444,
0.0049054194,
-0.010554797,
-0.0051889843,
0.0075717168,
-0.00384389,
-0.0073905447,
0.0025620242,
0.0296568759,
0.0249184147,
-0.0613939911,
0.0197730884,
-0.0186869744,
-0.0130991479,
0.0144252488,
-0.0364233777,
-0.0205491856,
-0.0349052846,
0.0690648705,
-0.1016740724,
0.0007214606,
-0.0134195127,
0.0579843372,
0.0105945747,
-0.0502726063,
-0.0166352615,
0.0305663235,
0.001202781,
-0.0385266095,
-0.0121318549,
0.0638458952,
-0.0089244852,
0.0189294238,
-0.0002590585,
-0.0247183815,
0.0026149848,
0.0397332758,
0.0245175753,
-0.0208019447,
-0.0098136812,
0.0132813975,
-0.0292596538,
-0.0697721466,
0.0200682636,
0.0399298184,
-0.0031926688,
0.0351543836,
-0.0110063618,
-0.0098747825,
0.0191663727,
0.0372627713,
-0.0273977295,
0.007008004,
-0.0183067638,
0.0194102004,
-0.0722614676,
0.0719567686,
-0.0306873601,
-0.0015104869,
-0.0350119844,
-0.0305178296,
0.0507548153,
-0.0305820405,
-0.0159970205,
0.014131628,
-0.0917514935,
-0.0528517924,
-0.0086043673,
0.0656244606,
0.0158417933,
0.0249429848,
-0.0140794041,
-0.0863468647,
0.0135315396,
-0.0096172132,
0.0034073947,
0.0666163042,
0.0305656511,
-0.0894513503,
-0.0206229072,
0.0253993385,
-0.0359849706,
0.0334234796,
0.0449842848,
-0.0046500349,
-0.0113665704,
0.0143819759,
-0.011278091,
0.0221425183,
0.0410689749,
0.0262040403,
0.0060631144,
-0.0217796434,
0.0703218728,
0.0213989913,
0.0044234209,
-0.0337048918,
-0.0127702178,
0.0233961847,
-0.0187867917,
-0.0250481628,
0.0287364163,
0.0480043776,
0.0446560532,
-0.0346845277,
-0.0150520327,
-0.0441118143,
-0.0002228228,
0.0310517866,
0.0034842195,
-0.0446841866,
0.0379043855,
0.0485805683,
0.0265887026,
-0.018963661,
0.0332984515,
0.0459757969,
-0.0194770526,
-0.0715072677,
0.0459554754,
-0.075380452,
-0.1153544784,
-0.0415183753,
0.0091356561,
0.0454843752,
0.0263082944,
0.0129069006,
0.0044933516,
-0.0381874703,
-0.0211826321,
0.0157390274,
-0.0185521115,
0.0202512443,
0.0221307389,
0.019211648,
0.0115362257,
0.02395113,
0.0615513176,
0.0464134626,
0.0603750832,
0.0089599472,
0.019945167,
-0.015230095,
-0.0382473879,
-0.0007996089,
0.0354846232,
0.0213397723,
0.0415633768,
0.0132843181,
-0.0360959247,
-0.0031118477,
-0.0056514321,
0.0069330707,
-0.0144869369,
0.0257910863,
0.0199865252,
-0.0087352768,
-0.0432221591,
0.0120454486,
-0.0077806697,
-0.0214475691,
0.0073401262,
0.0452710092,
-7.281450615e-33,
-0.0291096698,
0.0452175103,
0.0181274004,
0.0106256017,
-0.0457447842,
-0.0051693623,
-0.0002853799,
-0.0183119718,
-0.0249336511,
0.0111497184,
-0.022207316,
0.0327491574,
0.0131326662,
0.0224603489,
-0.0080768522,
-0.0108413501,
0.0773389637,
-0.0067207329,
-0.0175455883,
0.0436865464,
-0.0087500801,
0.0441377498,
0.0754807219,
-0.0242951009,
-0.0836614668,
0.0155500304,
-0.0444714539,
0.0091761174,
-0.0561081059,
0.053325329,
-0.0151257645,
0.0306936167,
0.0134875178,
-0.0338041522,
-0.0133769326,
-0.0064117461,
-0.1075811237,
-0.0358036421,
-0.0006674498,
0.0108505227,
-0.0204745643,
-0.0015402797,
0.0202222336,
0.0206655823,
0.0164627153,
-0.024225574,
-0.0003354293,
-0.0412327945,
0.0091369469,
-0.0145063065,
-0.0003887915,
0.022872746,
-0.0086274194,
0.0182418339,
-0.0084345182,
0.0239068326,
-0.0262904614,
0.0066556581,
-0.0191545933,
-0.060921669,
0.0374871455,
0.0359448455,
-0.0075667365,
0.0694268569,
0.0058250986,
0.0204728115,
0.0098992875,
-0.0030164111,
0.0104735959,
-0.0243589003,
0.0297999457,
0.0532319769,
0.0620005988,
0.0357254259,
0.0634397641,
0.0227385834,
-0.1077659652,
-0.0174222905,
-0.0109667126,
0.0470898934,
0.0145563427,
0.0094419373,
0.0240997691,
0.0024885649,
-0.053189747,
-0.0091055417,
-0.0482243225,
0.0104827629,
0.0400867686,
0.0637184083,
-0.0220464487,
0.0539645255,
0.0383919962,
-0.0289275795,
0.0318358615,
0.0319777504,
0.015719302,
0.020393895,
0.034519136,
0.0234904382,
-0.0243400671,
-0.029701395,
0.0351352505,
-0.0031202249,
0.0229084641,
-0.0021622356,
0.04440853,
0.0299490076,
-0.0410143882,
-0.0035609843,
-0.0278426148,
0.0449990742,
-0.0145813571,
0.0909093842,
-0.005265696,
0.007215837,
-0.0094590448,
0.031922143,
0.0053265155,
0.0143637871,
-0.0341339372,
-0.0474624708,
0.0656174347,
0.0384442769,
-0.0204722695,
0.0118675493,
-0.0130883595,
-0.0201048516,
0.0370722339,
-0.1013706326,
-0.0261546411,
0.0532047823,
3.017e-7,
0.0136072561,
0.0133108227,
-0.0169072505,
-0.036461778,
0.0244730134,
0.0319249146,
-0.0103317201,
0.0235792138,
0.005411725,
0.0004110296,
0.0085847033,
0.0549488403,
0.0364947729,
0.0043020467,
-0.043171946,
0.0193667114,
-0.0546836182,
0.0292327423,
-0.0465619415,
-0.0204280894,
-0.0029824281,
0.1196962968,
0.0337616503,
-0.0200928859,
0.0435182601,
-0.0211370792,
0.0558463261,
-0.0111411223,
0.0119313924,
-0.0238867067,
0.0295962747,
0.0542414188,
-0.0320337303,
0.0200396366,
-0.0177734382,
0.032714773,
-0.0174519457,
0.0547406375,
-0.0416130833,
-0.0033094373,
0.0071843909,
0.0296208467,
0.006264593,
-0.0266459677,
0.0941455364,
-0.0545549691,
0.0034469119,
-0.0500122607,
-0.0378263034,
-0.0614052303,
0.0467413627,
-0.0207346212,
0.0099335229,
0.0342244394,
0.0103924172,
-0.0287145227,
-0.026443338,
-0.1417054832,
0.0153702395,
0.0206344184,
-0.0522610992,
-0.0383474492,
-0.0455760546,
-0.063848421,
0.0441706814,
-0.0538878143,
-0.0204073079,
2.957697152e-34,
0.0332490057,
-0.0316140652,
0.0631190613,
0.0107530048,
0.0281773768,
0.006428326,
-0.0356176905,
-0.0271713007,
0.026872661,
-0.0965169296,
-0.0198371783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01315v1 | Language Portability Strategies for Open-domain Dialogue with Pre-trained Language Models from High to Low Resource Languages | 2024-07-01T14:20:54 | 2024-07-01T14:20:54 | Ahmed Njifenjou, Virgile Sucal, Bassam Jabaian, Fabrice Lefèvre | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper we propose a study of linguistic portability strategies of
large pre-trained language models (PLMs) used for open-domain dialogue systems
in a high-resource language for this task. In particular the target
low-resource language (L_T) will be simulated with French, as it lacks of
task-specific resources and allows our human evaluation, when the source
language (L_S) is English. For obvious reasons, recent works using such models
for open-domain dialogue are mostly developed in English. Yet building specific
PLMs for each possible target language supposes collecting new datasets and is
costly. For this reason, trying to leverage all existing resources (PLMs and
data) in both L_S and L_T , we wish to assess the performance achievable in L_T
with different approaches. The first two approaches evaluate the usage of
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) at different levels: TrainOnTarget where a L_S
dataset is translated before fine-tuning in L_T and TestOnSource where a L_S
model is coupled with NMT modules during inference. Then, the advent of BLOOM
[2], the world first open-access multilingual large PLM, allow researchers to
develop new approaches aiming to leverage not only the model's full
accessibility but also its multilingualism and translation abilities. In this
context the task is learned in L_S first and adapted to L_T using the MAD-X
Adapter architecture [16]. In the two sets of experiments models are evaluated
in spoken dialogue conditions with human and the strategies can be compared in
terms of perceived interaction quality. | [
0.0011350201,
0.0625068918,
-0.0175476968,
0.0682970136,
-0.0330315121,
-0.0106679918,
0.0375414193,
-0.0109034898,
-0.0046888078,
-0.0237193126,
-0.0955831185,
-0.0304414611,
-0.0149013074,
0.0326076001,
0.0086002639,
-0.0243498851,
0.053593833,
-0.03636989,
-0.0341224,
0.0017906063,
-0.0174509194,
-0.0170225948,
0.0066378382,
0.0331616513,
0.0420270786,
0.0229633506,
-0.0263614748,
0.021198146,
0.0090779318,
0.0048839776,
-0.0452210084,
0.0261958484,
0.0333800763,
0.0403148979,
0.000002042,
-0.0389726125,
-0.0106117688,
0.0036106855,
-0.0151878688,
-0.0143546937,
0.0564861409,
-0.0101450002,
-0.0083286893,
0.0308865272,
-0.0363533571,
-0.0485028923,
0.0539546534,
0.0422815457,
0.0779095814,
0.0921925306,
-0.0040319175,
-0.0026411077,
-0.000007484,
-0.0231469758,
-0.024569964,
-0.0738383159,
-0.0220838878,
-0.0086379545,
-0.0047568693,
0.0164649431,
-0.0125775849,
0.0538418032,
0.0342158303,
-0.0345508344,
-0.0556068532,
-0.0113042546,
-0.0262685753,
-0.0130039966,
-0.0403731838,
0.1024070606,
-0.0237768497,
0.02671526,
-0.0301939193,
-0.0258749649,
0.00536153,
-0.0436472595,
-0.0280116741,
0.0123615488,
0.0354036726,
0.0279926192,
-0.0097288536,
0.0294318739,
0.0060425266,
-0.014184461,
-0.0389458053,
0.0394983217,
0.022742467,
-0.0001430652,
0.0469035357,
-0.0003384543,
0.0220340956,
-0.0310753509,
0.0111372927,
0.0270021781,
-0.0360439233,
0.0447027534,
-0.0503139794,
-0.0261062775,
-0.0153728342,
-0.0470129438,
0.0411716476,
0.0476771221,
-0.0547423139,
0.0437775627,
0.0040478846,
0.0340063311,
-0.0492587574,
-0.0048807608,
-0.0542863011,
-0.0262371358,
-0.0275022574,
0.0385427959,
-0.0526695475,
0.0047111949,
-0.0927995816,
-0.0221716184,
-0.0063963323,
0.0286945049,
0.0273477286,
-0.0183126796,
0.0482830331,
-0.0369744822,
-0.0545597337,
-0.0172179714,
-0.04669258,
0.0916471928,
-0.0112419156,
-0.0008715354,
0.0129103623,
-0.1181398705,
-0.0178652052,
0.0315756164,
-0.0196253806,
-0.0477383919,
-0.0357257985,
0.1189798489,
-0.0397647657,
-0.0167350471,
-0.0496542789,
-0.0193898715,
-0.0050435234,
-0.0570591316,
0.0338765904,
-0.0331235416,
0.0549926721,
-0.0118431896,
0.0200312231,
-0.0546729751,
-0.0000298687,
-0.0089356108,
-0.0175720342,
0.0441998243,
-0.0086685931,
0.0054944642,
0.0214065518,
0.0016121718,
-0.012887774,
0.0783050209,
0.0144741079,
-0.0077473712,
0.0231736992,
-0.024872778,
0.0054950588,
0.0712010786,
0.017729206,
0.0002441381,
0.0075353757,
0.0196051821,
0.021957485,
0.0247512385,
0.0298876893,
0.0480305403,
-0.0247186292,
-0.0157946572,
0.0476965308,
-0.0000958117,
0.041893065,
0.0374344476,
0.0673384815,
0.0421010293,
0.0181618501,
0.0016565521,
-0.0245819166,
0.0178242512,
-0.0124194985,
-0.0193034075,
0.0341318175,
0.0419366248,
-0.0392571092,
-0.0462590866,
0.0194683932,
-0.0302471891,
0.0006724619,
-0.0195572227,
0.0478845388,
0.0247131418,
-0.0601457134,
0.0797713101,
0.0200395621,
-0.0479930565,
-0.0125560611,
-0.0478494354,
-0.005488934,
0.011329446,
0.0039868522,
-0.0175380576,
-0.007496879,
-0.0302935522,
0.0233881697,
0.0542327389,
0.0600307025,
0.0103280349,
0.0756974593,
-0.0496819988,
-0.0078470912,
-0.0202911161,
-0.0072307321,
0.0493720397,
-0.0139800021,
0.0222750325,
0.0057729273,
-0.015298794,
-0.0297868066,
0.0161388591,
-0.0437013395,
-0.008747993,
0.0429473445,
-0.0060969391,
0.0521408245,
0.0228624325,
-0.0167658851,
-0.0015377338,
0.0290568583,
-0.0231607128,
0.0298823323,
0.0482558869,
-0.0508622639,
-0.0184304025,
0.0213272311,
-0.0093576415,
0.0130881742,
-0.0060869642,
-0.0475182012,
-0.0685174763,
0.046174746,
-0.0242554601,
0.0339396074,
-0.0518275984,
0.0286207404,
0.0020167814,
0.0139877833,
0.0018355846,
0.0165138934,
0.022300167,
-0.0009850973,
0.069393903,
0.0037430087,
0.0522450246,
-0.0773238167,
-0.0204692781,
0.0198630206,
-0.0128799397,
0.0203544404,
-0.0033512919,
0.048162628,
-0.0289255213,
-0.0244670827,
-0.0812580734,
0.017188577,
-0.0252461005,
0.0273469184,
0.0209410768,
0.0289763063,
-0.0094049843,
-0.0226695016,
-0.0322464406,
0.036590673,
0.0419983082,
-0.0070176767,
0.0209801495,
0.0342295207,
0.0073015201,
-0.0213271882,
0.0070486567,
0.0532197282,
0.0499198176,
-0.0205732901,
0.0059642885,
-0.0596997999,
0.0459727086,
-0.0433698483,
0.0283172987,
-0.0205719285,
-0.0532805733,
0.0029821801,
-0.0142467115,
0.0169513691,
0.0281854495,
-0.0067501296,
0.0062886639,
0.0161287412,
-0.0454619899,
-0.0500894077,
0.0261863135,
-0.010340495,
-0.0686334074,
-0.0555107966,
0.0144217229,
0.0362753719,
0.0448386855,
-0.01211116,
-0.0033215547,
-0.0386868268,
-0.0108416853,
-0.0038997163,
-0.0494498834,
0.0108423876,
0.0379433595,
-0.017660331,
0.0250105653,
0.0213349685,
-0.0379353799,
0.0489171445,
-0.0660875291,
-0.0066353614,
-0.064075157,
-0.0092907054,
-0.0290591512,
0.0266537163,
-0.0226436034,
0.0212557167,
-0.0119437305,
-0.0306253601,
-0.0353840552,
0.0061355233,
-0.0202870294,
-0.0137005374,
0.0385047868,
-0.0841468945,
-0.018084934,
-0.0184129961,
-0.0214993544,
-0.0297675151,
-0.0305919908,
-0.0267937444,
-0.0004643129,
-0.0116907032,
-0.0083736535,
-0.0409393981,
0.018154189,
0.0248555094,
0.0504142977,
0.0112570021,
0.0231218804,
-0.0077902526,
0.012274012,
-0.0122025041,
0.0566283576,
-0.0021961282,
-0.0163740888,
0.0327067971,
-0.0050898832,
-0.0161987245,
-0.0298342444,
-0.0160756409,
-0.0107023874,
0.0177560896,
0.0074714371,
-0.0515289046,
0.0222587939,
0.057712011,
-0.049108766,
-0.0309115145,
0.1028599441,
-0.0018166387,
-0.0235193949,
-0.0303379353,
-0.0293182172,
0.0010813209,
-0.0039154072,
0.0398693904,
-0.0970451534,
-0.0333623737,
-0.0171935707,
0.0211837329,
0.0059285429,
0.0132313482,
-0.0388393886,
-0.1231359243,
0.0373985097,
0.0118553452,
-0.1085449457,
0.0017033225,
0.0152581697,
-0.0138324602,
-0.0330633111,
0.0598417632,
-0.0175730512,
0.0376373641,
-0.0234697871,
-0.0137178451,
0.0383475684,
-0.0556933172,
-0.0244487394,
-0.0290380623,
0.0643706098,
0.0522779897,
0.02752316,
0.0054489295,
-0.0406116918,
0.0615937747,
-0.0124470461,
0.0300855339,
-0.0056215534,
-0.0190425906,
0.0196671039,
-0.0303996801,
0.0007559763,
0.0040643984,
0.0044755582,
0.0212536324,
0.0200809464,
0.0566335209,
-0.0435053445,
0.0014436485,
0.0306390487,
-0.0032827768,
0.0345590599,
0.0564302355,
0.0360348374,
-0.0485795438,
-0.0180797465,
0.0103512583,
-0.0336580239,
-0.0197747052,
-0.019125184,
0.0205167308,
-0.0329180881,
-0.0219771527,
-0.0600290932,
-0.0285990108,
0.0351509042,
0.0710167885,
0.0085393414,
-0.0057733068,
0.014412798,
0.0193446409,
0.0159396566,
0.0575229861,
-0.0542771108,
-0.0097350031,
-0.073007375,
-0.0163473804,
0.0529540442,
-0.0657046288,
-0.0142350243,
0.0183684397,
-0.0407793485,
-0.0640113652,
-0.0153348045,
0.0756868199,
0.0245511476,
0.0265821572,
-0.0211757254,
-0.0491560698,
0.0055551277,
0.0028410717,
-0.00999704,
0.0051376177,
0.0583539493,
0.0103142587,
-0.0276021082,
0.0556148179,
-0.0102904988,
0.0196948424,
0.0214984678,
0.0355752818,
0.0076676537,
-0.1071522534,
-0.0130321505,
0.0306955781,
0.0524759516,
0.0129645653,
-0.0632208511,
-0.0271923747,
0.0387659259,
-0.0311824959,
0.0047869068,
-0.0898897797,
-0.0200104192,
0.0225728918,
0.0168805495,
0.0015651641,
-0.0235766433,
-0.0345687978,
0.023181729,
0.005545693,
0.0063992422,
0.04938142,
0.0257605296,
0.0053541888,
0.0258261319,
-0.0128855575,
0.0221351758,
0.0060879053,
0.036080163,
-0.0264306031,
0.1168233454,
-0.0015292142,
-0.008466051,
0.0380031615,
0.0568078533,
-0.0458632931,
-0.0500888526,
-0.0016602573,
0.0364647694,
0.0236050431,
0.0278119836,
0.0985751152,
-0.0095360167,
0.0018778893,
-0.0156697109,
0.085459888,
0.0070509682,
-0.024668077,
0.0498237051,
-0.0133698909,
-0.0105802184,
0.0273968335,
0.0572475903,
-0.0353423394,
-0.0179600324,
0.0036917401,
0.034296561,
-0.0253543835,
-0.0080237696,
0.0151950354,
-0.0127948774,
-0.0188463945,
-0.0195466727,
-0.0191552807,
-0.037478894,
-0.0010655164,
0.0206965152,
-0.0216872357,
-0.0089435326,
0.0265517924,
0.0595991611,
-0.0059487731,
0.0207205601,
-0.030728288,
0.0224509258,
-0.0058789589,
-0.0063973949,
0.0049139955,
-6.072754794e-33,
-0.05145346,
0.0121329902,
0.0208586995,
-0.0380926169,
-0.0696240589,
-0.0366913527,
-0.0598731525,
-0.0037101731,
-0.0455605127,
-0.0177743435,
-0.0094087087,
-0.000068148,
0.0271507241,
0.0385474153,
-0.0412536487,
-0.0178455394,
0.0285633747,
-0.0053187814,
-0.0238954667,
0.0371456295,
0.0234967973,
0.0162741449,
0.0708443671,
-0.069938682,
0.0251316894,
-0.007628704,
0.0237685423,
0.0408195332,
0.0159961265,
0.033421699,
-0.0131776957,
0.021820087,
0.0100174882,
-0.0644822046,
-0.0212974772,
0.0183558539,
-0.0548285171,
-0.0113977995,
0.0490794629,
0.0325657763,
-0.0006246004,
-0.0024489318,
0.029672198,
-0.017412236,
-0.0030241909,
0.0239315797,
-0.0297940429,
-0.0340033323,
-0.0080292076,
0.0311860107,
-0.0670835152,
0.0162320603,
0.015654983,
-0.005141349,
0.0229194462,
0.0561559126,
-0.037873406,
-0.0429080389,
-0.0238055643,
0.0174277872,
-0.0058545717,
-0.0062614484,
0.0861118063,
0.0198109094,
0.0062264679,
0.0136087164,
0.0474214926,
-0.0247171503,
0.0061121909,
-0.012788604,
0.0306172278,
0.0273635816,
0.0572098717,
0.0704972968,
-0.0219919253,
0.0186326038,
-0.0412353761,
0.0063803145,
0.0268257037,
0.0007006456,
-0.012649917,
0.0244517047,
0.0325387977,
-0.0052457615,
-0.0566751622,
-0.0156312138,
-0.0079787327,
-0.0584486276,
0.0236724708,
-0.0159583408,
-0.008889229,
-0.0307803322,
0.1128481701,
-0.0107679721,
0.013939728,
-0.0010049337,
-0.0116858948,
0.0003997126,
-0.031786073,
0.0295287631,
-0.0340708569,
-0.031136265,
0.0385971479,
-0.0129286507,
0.0216496512,
-0.0087674521,
-0.0177662969,
0.0241566189,
-0.030823417,
0.0054321075,
-0.0475528389,
0.0391288288,
-0.0104334448,
0.073184818,
0.0273463987,
-0.0250063743,
-0.026654372,
0.0624406263,
-0.0055268882,
-0.0293937251,
-0.0283701234,
-0.0124425944,
0.0576672927,
-0.0028131464,
-0.0665820017,
0.024334684,
0.0018307354,
0.0243170187,
0.0185759105,
-0.0516898111,
-0.0267756563,
0.0247954372,
2.908e-7,
0.0289735198,
-0.0249964576,
0.0060791522,
0.0119290054,
0.0007563333,
0.0186107904,
-0.0517429188,
0.022613449,
0.0096244821,
0.0180534832,
0.006715944,
0.0044952403,
0.0825139135,
0.0417344682,
-0.0952241272,
-0.0591754243,
-0.018618539,
0.0066981739,
-0.0392236225,
0.0049754847,
0.0334895365,
0.1044887751,
-0.0341000371,
0.0226670466,
-0.0076743034,
-0.0609106049,
0.0464978218,
-0.0644060299,
-0.0268407874,
-0.0087695578,
0.0452862233,
0.0483681411,
-0.0380947739,
0.0044547883,
-0.002640292,
0.036853455,
0.023752328,
0.0726977736,
0.0245918296,
-0.0577840805,
0.0195193272,
-0.0241280999,
-0.0025077784,
-0.0188265815,
0.0429343581,
-0.0401756018,
-0.0257686917,
-0.0019017757,
0.0127385594,
-0.0375045091,
0.0258744489,
-0.0505853258,
0.010062742,
0.0161276702,
0.0378638767,
-0.0163970087,
-0.0016261779,
-0.0587669834,
-0.0104420157,
-0.0392536037,
-0.0390016437,
-0.0723076388,
-0.0286028385,
0.0048631858,
0.010242139,
-0.0129851587,
0.0156010399,
2.250389803e-34,
0.0162074044,
-0.0156939346,
0.0262308735,
0.0109597035,
0.0350696035,
-0.0043348386,
0.0215923637,
-0.0058442526,
-0.004292082,
-0.0902098343,
-0.0098471791
] |