id
stringlengths 9
15
| text
stringlengths 1.28k
134k
| reference-summary
stringlengths 244
1.81k
|
|---|---|---|
hep-lat0003018 | simulations of lattice qcd use either the quenched or the partially quenched approximations , where internal fermion loops are omitted or at least suppressed by giving the dynamical ( ` sea ' ) quarks a mass heavier than that of the propagating ( ` current ' ) quarks @xcite . such an approximation turns out to be necessary , since presently available update algorithms with dynamical fermions tend to slow down rather dramatically if the fermion mass is taken light . from a physical point of view this unwanted feature does not come as a surprise , as it reflects the very nonlocal nature of the fermion determinant . the quenched and the partially quenched approximations amount thus to a suppression or reduction of the nonlocal self - interaction of the gluon configuration brought by the sea quarks . though this seems reasonable , there are specific problems brought by the quenched and to a milder extent the partially quenched approximations : it has been noted very early that quenched qcd lacks reflection positivity @xcite which is just the euclidean analog of unitarity . this means that green s functions computed in the quenched theory can not be rotated back to minkowski space and hence there is no hamiltonian formulation . attempts to construct a low - energy theory adapted to the quenched and partially quenched approximations have shown that these constructs give rise to unphysical degrees of freedom which persist in low energy observables and render the whole theory sick , if the chiral limit is taken @xcite . the computational overhead , though , of full qcd with phenomenological quark masses is so dramatic that without tremendous progress at the algorithmic front both the quenched and the partially quenched approximations are likely to stay with us for the foreseeable future . since the ultimate goal simulating full qcd is fixed , any potential alternative to the standard path ` quenched partially quenched full qcd ' can only imply a different starting point and/or a different way to interpolate between the measure one starts with and the full one . ideally , one would like to begin with a measure which keeps costs per configuration essentially at the quenched level , but tries to incorporate as much of the fermion dynamics brought by the functional determinant as possible . a specific attempt in this direction goes with the name ` topologically unquenched qcd ' @xcite . the basic idea is to split the functional determinant into two factors @xmath3 the first of which is computationally cheap and as good an approximation to the whole determinant as possible . this factor is then absorbed into the measure . on the other hand , the right hand factor is too expensive to be determined for each link update and henceforth this second factor is either discarded of or just included into the observable . of course , this concept can only work if it is possible to come up with a simple ( i.e. computationally cheap to evaluate ) and reasonably accurate choice for the first factor . in the original publication @xcite it was proposed to define the first factor as the determinant of a suitably chosen background which shares with the actual configuration nothing but the overall topological charge . below two modifications are proposed , but the basic concept remains the same : the first factor in ( [ detfac ] ) is nothing but a statistical guess of the total determinant which uses as input only global gluonic quantities . the first suggested change concerns the size of the database the guess is based on . originally the idea was to compute the first factor in each topological sector once on a well chosen configuration @xcite . in @xcite it was already mentioned that in practice it proves useful to construct the guess as the geometric average of the determinants of few configurations which are quite typical both in their gauge action and in the logarithm of their determinant . here it is suggested to feed the database with the combination @xmath4 for each ` complete ' configuration , i.e. after the entire lattice has been swept through a few times . the point is that the ` complete ' configurations are those which are used for measurements , i.e. those in which the determinant emerges as a byproduct of the dirac operator inversion and thus comes for free . ] . the second suggested change concerns the argument being used to ` read out ' the guess for the first factor in ( [ detfac ] ) from the database . the original proposal was to make a guess based on @xmath0 only . in the present work it is eventually proposed to use the combined input from @xmath0 and @xmath1 . the basic idea is still , when a specific link update is proposed , _ not to compute _ the change in the determinant implied , but rather to use the databases knowledge regarding the determinant ratio the proposed change in the gluon configuration brings _ on average_. the original task to compute , for each local link update , a _ global fermionic _ quantity is thus traded for the task to compute the actual change in one or two _ global gluonic _ quantities . the latter , however , reduces to the stunningly simple task to determine , for each link update , one or two _ local gluonic _ quantities , since @xmath0 and @xmath1 can easily be kept track of by computing , for each proposed update , the corresponding contribution from the staple around the link under consideration , before and after it is modified . in other words , the connection between the desired global quantity and the readily accessible local gluonic quantity is made via a two - step procedure : the database stores the correlation between @xmath5 and @xmath6 , i.e. on a global - to - global basis . in an updating sweep the actual value of these integrated quantities is constantly kept track of a task which , at any time , requires only looking at the lattice versions of @xmath7 and @xmath8 in the immediate neighborhood of the link under consideration . the price to pay is that the guess for the change in the determinant the proposed link update would bring about is not accurate but only correct on average . from this outline it is clear that the concept can only work if there is a correlation in fact , for practical purposes , a sufficiently strong correlation between the logarithm of the determinant and , on the other side , the combination of topological index and gluonic action of a configuration generated in a monte carlo process . in addition , a few practical issues must be resolved , e.g. the question how each configuration can be assigned a topological index in a such a way that the costs ( in terms of cpu time ) for its determination are small compared to the savings from the fewer determinant evaluations . while the idea of ` topologically unquenched qcd ' was originally put forth @xcite and successively advertised @xcite with a strong focus on theoretical aspects ( merely arguing that in the continuum a correlation between the functional determinant and the topological index is to be expected from the instanton liquid model @xcite ) , a fair assessment of its potential can only come from a practical test . since it is desirable to have direct comparison to simulation data obtained with an exact algorithm in the full theory , a first account may well stem from a test implementation in a suitable model field theory . a toy theory where the issue of ` topological unquenching ' can be studied without having to worry about many technical aspects of the implementation ( which do indeed matter in qcd ) is the massive multi - flavour schwinger model , i.e. qed(2 ) with @xmath9 light degenerate fermions . the physics of this theory resembles in many aspects qcd(4 ) slightly _ above the phase transition _ ( see refs . @xcite and references cited in the second of them ) , i.e. the chiral condensate vanishes ( in the chiral limit ) and the expectation value for the polyakov loop is real and positive . like in qcd the gauge fields in the continuum version of the schwinger model quantized on the torus fall into topologically distinct classes @xcite , i.e. they can be attributed a topological index . the latter agrees with the number of left- minus right - handed zero - modes of the massless dirac operator , i.e. the index theorem holds true . a closer look reveals , however , that there is no precise analog of the instanton , i.e. no topologically nontrivial solution which is both a local minimum of the classical action and localized in space - time . there are ` instantons ' , i.e. topologically nontrivial minima of the classical action , but they are completely delocalized . on the other hand , there are ` vortices ' , i.e. topologically nontrivial localized objects , but they do not represent local minima of the classical action . an obvious consequence for the intended test is that ` topological unquenching ' can only work here , if it relies only on very general features , shared by a broad class of qcd inspired theories . in order to test the ` topological unquenching ' idea , i have chosen to implement the schwinger model with 2 dynamical staggered fermions both with the full and with the ` topologically unquenched ' measure , as well as the quenched approximation . in all three cases the unimproved gauge action @xmath10 has been used . to compare the three theories to each other 2000/4000/4000 ( full/ topologically unquenched/ quenched ) independent configurations have been generated on a lattice with volume @xmath11 with periodic / thermal boundary conditions . the common coupling is @xmath12 and the fermion mass is @xmath13 ( everything in lattice units ) . these values are chosen such that the ` pion ' ( pseudo - scalar iso - triplet ) has a mass has the dimension of a mass and , unlike in qcd , the power by which @xmath14 depends on @xmath15 is specific for @xmath16 , the general formula is @xmath17 . ] @xmath18 as to fit into the box . the formula used is the prediction by the bosonized ( strong - coupling ) version of the theory ( see refs . cited in @xcite ) , which seems adequate , as @xmath19 . since the staggered dirac operator is represented by a small ( @xmath20 ) matrix with 5 entries per row or column , i have decided to compute the determinants exactly , using the routines zgefa and zgedi from the linpack package . finally , since the staggered formulation has a remnant degeneracy , a square root ( in two dimensions ) must be taken to get an object associated with @xmath21 in the continuum . for the topological charge , i have implemented both the lscher geometric definition @xmath22 and the rescaled naive @xmath23 with @xmath24 @xcite . a configuration is assigned an index and used for measurements only if the geometric and the naive definition , after rounding to the nearest integer , agree which , at @xmath25 , holds true for more than @xmath26 of all configurations . this fraction being so high means that in practice an assignment can be done _ without cooling _ by simply taking @xmath27 and rounding it to the nearest integer @xmath28 . of course , this means that some configurations are assigned an index which , strictly speaking , are nt continuum - like enough as to have one , but , since the latter fraction is so tiny , such a simple definition may be tried first . + + + + + + in order to find out whether the ` topological unquenching ' shortcut has a chance to provide a reasonable approximation to the full theory it seems useful to check whether the underpinning assumption a correlation between @xmath5 and @xmath29 holds true in the full theory . the result which merely extends work initiated in the literature @xcite is shown in figs . 1 and 2 . from the scatter plots one notices that @xmath27 tends to accumulate near integer values , both in the full and the quenched theories . the obvious difference is that @xmath30 reaches up to 3 in the quenched approximation , but up to 2 in the full theory , i.e. quenching results in a broadening of the distribution of topological indices if @xmath31 is kept fixed . the center of the clouds representing the gauge action in a given topological sector shifts upwards , if @xmath30 increases . regarding the correlation between @xmath5 and @xmath0 one realizes that the center of the clouds at @xmath32 in the central plot on the l.h.s . of fig . 1 is substantially higher than the center of the cloud at @xmath33 . it is interesting to note that the same correlation holds true even in the quenched approximation , as one can see from the central plot on the r.h.s . of fig . 1 . the difference is just that in the quenched updating process this information hasnt been made use of . in order to assess the shifts on a more quantitative level , the same information is presented in figs . 2 and 3 in the form of histograms for the full and the quenched theories , respectively . they show the distribution of the gauge action [ per plaquette ] , of @xmath34 times the logarithm of the staggered determinant [ per plaquette , after an overall shift to have it centered at zero in the topologically trivial sector ] and of the weighted sum [ first plus twice the second , @xmath35 . the latter quantity represents the total action the full sample was generated with , while in the quenched case it is an artificial construct . considering the situation in the full theory first ( fig . 2 ) , one realizes that going from a configuration with @xmath33 to another one with @xmath36 the gauge action per plaquette increases , on average , by 0.0134 , 0.0213 . in the same transition minus the log of the single - flavour determinant per plaquette increases , on average , by 0.0082 , 0.0157 . hence in the simulation with a staggered pair the total action increases by 0.0299 , 0.0527 . this means that in the full theory the functional determinant is more efficient in suppressing the higher topological sectors than the gauge action . considering the analogous shifts in the quenched run ( fig 3 . ) , a transition @xmath37 increases the gauge action per plaquette by 0.0038 , 0.0309 . simultaneously the sign - flipped logarithm of the single - flavour determinant per plaquette increases by 0.0032 , 0.0100 . in spite of numerical values being somewhat different , the basic phenomenon happens to be the same in either theory : going from the lowest to the highest sector , only the shift in the distribution of the log of the determinant is comparable to its total width , the shift in the gauge action is almost negligible on the scale of its total width . hence the correlation between @xmath5 and @xmath30 seems to be a robust phenomenon superseeding the choice of measure in the functional integral . + from the discussion above it is clear that knowing the topological index @xmath28 of a configuration allows for a ( modestly accurate ) ` guess ' of its functional determinant . if , in addition , a correlation between @xmath5 and @xmath1 holds true , a more accurate guess would become possible . the result of an investigation in the full theory on this topic is shown in fig . the first three plots show the sign - flipped logarithm of the single - flavour determinant ( normalized per plaquette ) as a function of the gauge action ( per plaquette ) for @xmath38 . one finds that within a given topological sector these two quantities are indeed correlated . besides the vertical shift discussed above , a transition @xmath39 implies a slight reduction in the slope of the regression line . from this one concludes that , to a first approximation , the functional determinant leads to a _ reweighting of the topological sectors _ and to a _ sectorally different renormalization of @xmath31_. the last plot in fig . 4 shows that , without separation into different topological sectors , the correlation is weaker and the statement that the functional determinant results in an overall - renormalization of @xmath31 is less useful . a practical issue in a ` topologically unquenched ' simulation is the strategy adopted for building up the databases knowledge about @xmath40 as function of @xmath28 in the simple form of the method or as a function of @xmath28 and @xmath41 in the more elaborate form . the point is that the desired correlation parameters [ offset and slope in the linear dependence of @xmath40 on @xmath41 for fixed @xmath28 ] are those in the full theory , but doing first a run with the full measure is , of course , not an option . the practical answer is that the ` topologically unquenched ' algorithm builds up knowledge about the situation as it emerges in the ` topologically unquenched ' run itself . first one starts with a quenched pre - pre - thermalization , thereby acquiring knowledge about offsets and slopes in the quenched theory . + next follows a pre - thermalization phase where the number of ` topologically active ' flavours increases , by small fractional steps , from zero to the desired number of dynamical flavours . accordingly , the databases values for offsets and slopes will tend closer towards those appropriate in the full theory . finally , the system is given time to thermalize with the true number of ` topologically unquenched ' flavours , before actual measurements take place . 5 shows the offsets for the centers of the distributions of the gauge action , the sign - flipped logarithm of the single - flavour functional determinant and the total action in a ` topologically unquenched ' 2-flavour system , data being collected during the measurement phase . as expected , numerical values lie in between those in the quenched and in the full theory ( see figs . 2 and 3 ) . in order to assess the implications for physics the ` topological unquenching ' idea brings about , the static quark - antiquark potential has been determined using the full , the quenched and the ` topologically unquenched ' measure . + + in the latter case , the more elaborate version has been used , i.e. the database keeps track of the best linear fit for @xmath40 as a function of @xmath28 and @xmath41 . the result is presented in the l.h.s . of fig . as one can see , the quenched potential raises linearly short - distance tail . ] , while in the full theory the test charges get seriously screened at large distance . the ` topologically unquenched ' recipe generates a sample in between ; the potential as it emerges from the unaltered sample shows insufficient yet nontrivial screening at long distances . what constitutes the primary difference between the samples is shown in the r.h.s . of fig . 6 : the distribution of @xmath27 is much broader in the quenched chase ( middle ) than in the full theory ( top ) , while the ` topologically unquenched ' run ( bottom ) nearly reproduces the full distribution . up to this point the option of eventually including the ` correction factor ' [ i.e. the @xmath43-fold power of the second factor in ( [ detfac ] ) ] into the observable has not been used . an attempt to reconstruct the potential in the full theory from the ` topologically unquenched ' sample by including this factor into the observable yields the result shown in the l.h.s . of fig . 7 . a detailed comparison shows that the potential agrees ( within error bars ) with the one obtained from the full sample . the only difference between the first plots in fig . 6 and 7 is a technical one : the full potential reconstructed from the ` topologically unquenched ' sample was cheaper , in terms of cpu time , by a factor @xmath44 than the one won from the full sample . it should be mentioned , however , that it was not clear a priori that including the correction factor into the observable would be an option . the point is that the correction factor is the ratio of two determinants each of which scales exponentially with the total lattice volume . this means that the extra fluctuations brought by the ` correction factor ' grow exponentially as the lattice gets large . in the present example the distribution of the log of the correction factor is sufficiently narrow as to allow for a reconstruction of the full potential . as one can see from the r.h.s . of fig . 7 the majority of the configurations has a log between -3.2 and 0.0 , i.e. most configurations receive a reweighting factor between @xmath45 and 1 . at fixed @xmath46 this width grows linearly with @xmath47 , thus making such a reweighting impossible for sufficiently large @xmath47 . it should be emphasized , however , that even on a large lattice the part of the functional determinant which has been absorbed into the ` topologically unquenched ' measure results for most observables in an improvement on the quenched approximation ( see fig . 6 again ) . an extreme ` counterexample ' where the part of the functional determinant which has been absorbed into the ` topologically unquenched ' measure does not result in any improvement at all is shown in fig . the expectation value of the polyakov line is still zero , like in the quenched theory , whereas in the full theory it is real and positive . in this case the entire shift between the quenched and the full theories emerges from the factor which , in the ` topological unquenching ' framework , is considered a ` correction factor ' . it should be noted , however , that this particular test is extremely hard to pass , because the difference between the quenched and the full theories is much more severe than in the case of qcd . this holds true because the quenched schwinger model is always in the confined phase , while the full multiflavour schwinger model is always in the deconfined phase regardless of the actual temperature . in other words : the effect of the determinant in the massive multiflavour schwinger model is not merely renormalizing masses and lengths ; quenching results in qualitative changes for any values of @xmath46 , making it a more drastic approximation than in qcd . + it is interesting to elucidate the physical reason why at least for the standard observable of the heavy quark potential ` topological unquenching ' results in a substantial improvement of the behaviour at long distance . to this end the configurations generated in the full theory have been re - analyzed in different classes , according to the absolute value of their topological index @xmath28 . as one can see from fig . 9 , the ` sectoral ' potentials for @xmath48 and @xmath49 differ quite drastically . comparing the l.h.s . of fig . 9 to the first plot in fig . 6 one notices that the sectoral potential with @xmath48 almost agrees with the unseparated ` true ' potential . the big surprise , however , is that the error bars are smaller now , even though the ` topologically trivial ' potential emerges from a subset of the configurations used for the full potential . it seems that in this particular case the higher sectors primarily add some ` noise ' . it should be noted , however , that the topologically trivial sector does not always yield the right result . in a previous run in a ( physically ) larger box , the ` topologically trivial ' potential was found to lie substantially below the true potential @xcite , i.e. a strict constraint to the trivial sector would not always prove beneficial . this is reminiscent of the situation in qcd with @xmath50 , where leutwyler and smilga have shown that in a sufficiently small box ( @xmath51 ) the partition function is dominated by the topologically trivial sector , whereas in a sufficiently large box ( @xmath52 ) a global quantity like @xmath0 has vanishing influence on physical variables @xcite . in this language the current simulation is in the regime @xmath53 whereas the previous one @xcite should likely be associated should be traded for @xmath54 . ] with @xmath55 . from the combined simulation data it is natural to conjecture that , if the box - volume increases gradually so as to leave the regime @xmath53 , _ several mutually inconsistent sectors _ start to yield _ sizable contributions _ ; only as @xmath56 goes beyond 1 , the differences between the sectoral contributions start fading away . since the regime @xmath57 is not uncommon in current lattice simulations , it seems desirable to respect the relative weight of the different topological sectors in the full theory even if importance sampling is done w.r.t . to a different measure . summarizing our investigations in the massive multiflavour schwinger model , one might say that the basic concept of ` topological unquenching ' including the first factor in ( [ detfac ] ) into the measure results for several observables in a substantial improvement on the quenched approximation at virtually no costs , whereas the option of including the second factor into the observable is likely to be limited to very small lattices . finally , a few comments and speculations on a possible extension of the ` topological unquenching ' idea to qcd are in order . it is clear that the basic feature the approach relies on a correlation between the logarithm of the determinant and one or several global gluonic quantities which may be kept track of from looking at their respective local changes holds true in the case of qcd too . what is not so clear is whether this correlation is strong enough as to make this a practical way of guessing the change in the logarithm of the determinant if a link in a phenomenological simulation is updated . of course , there is the possibility that further quantities , besides @xmath0 and @xmath58 , are found which correlate with the determinants logarithm , thus allowing for a more accurate guess . an obvious question , however , is which definition for the @xmath59 operator should be chosen on the lattice , since , with any practical implementation , @xmath0 is not an integer . to make the situation even worse established techniques to render a configuration more continuum - like [ e.g. blocking inverse - blocking cycles , link fuzzing or cooling ] are known to cause any field - theoretic definition of the topological charge ` jump ' one or several times about roughly integer values until it finally settles close to an integer . from a physical point of view , however , such a stability requirement is not really useful as it leads to a determination of the topological charge in a configuration which agrees in its instanton content with the original one only modulo instantons smaller than a certain critical radius @xmath60 , as discussed in the appendix of @xcite . it is thus preferable to apply as little cooling as possible and to allow for some uncertainty , but to strive for the topological charge of the original configuration . in other words : in the ` topological unquenching ' context there is no need for the peaks and valleys in the @xmath27-distribution to be so much pronounced as in the beautyful plot shown in fig . any determination which results in a distribution which takes values in the valleys not more than half of the values in the neighboring peaks will do fine for ` topological unquenching ' purposes . if improved operators are used , both @xmath61 and @xmath59 should be dealt with in comparable manner . it is believed that even with moderate improvement one or two cooling sweeps will be sufficient to satisfy the valley - peak - criterion for current @xmath31-values . in practical terms more cooling sweeps would be unpleasant anyways , since 2 cooling sweeps require permanently carrying along the 1- and 2-cooled versions of the actual configuration in order to minimize time spent on local cooling , when an individual link is updated . it should be noted , however , that the situation improves with increasing @xmath31 . eventually , for sufficiently high @xmath31 , even the wilson action and the corresponding unimproved @xmath59 operator will satisfy the criterion , thus allowing for a way to keep track of @xmath0 which does not require cooling at all . regardless of how much local cooling is needed for @xmath31-values used over the next few years , what is important is the following : since the computational overhead of the ` topologically unquenched ' over the quenched approximation stems entirely from local efforts to keep track of the topological charge , costs per configuration get increased by a fixed factor and the number of cooling cycles . with 2 sweeps and not more than next - to - nearest neighbor couplings , it might be @xmath62 . ] which is independent of the size of the lattice . it is also instructive to consider the effect of accidental ` misidentifications ' of the topological charge on the ` topologically unquenched ' sample : in the extreme case where the charge determination yields a normal distributed random number which has nothing to do with the actual configuration the simple version of the algorithm finds no correlation between @xmath5 and @xmath0 and produces , for this reason , a quenched sample . under the same circumstances the more elaborate version finds just a modest linear correlation between @xmath5 and @xmath58 and produces , for this reason , a quenched sample with an overall - rescaled @xmath31 ( see fig . 4 , last plot ) . in this paper the idea of ` topological unquenching ' has been transformed into a general scheme applicable to qcd inspired theories : the algorithm tries to ` guess ' the change in the determinant a proposed link update would bring . this is done using statistical information how the logarithm of the determinant correlates with global gluonic quantities like @xmath63 and @xmath58 which may easily be kept track of by looking at their respective local changes . compared to the quenched approximation ` topological unquenching ' seems to bring considerable improvement if the observable under consideration depends sensitively on the structure of the long - range green s functions in the full theory and if , in addition , the simulation is done in the small ( @xmath64 ) or intermediate ( @xmath65 ) leutwyler smilga regime . obviously , a test - implementation like the one presented in this study can not prove that the idea of ` topological unquenching ' would be successful in the case of qcd . nevertheless , the method seems interesting because of its sampling speed and its potential field - theoretic virtues : even an expensive formulation respecting chiral symmetry may be used for the sea - quarks and the latter do naturally have exactly the same mass as the current - quarks . it is hoped that these features look promising enough as to persuade at least one lattice group to give ` topological unquenching ' a try for the case of qcd . 15 h. hamber and g. parisi , phys . 47 , 1792 ( 1981 ) ; e. marinari , g. parisi and c. rebbi , phys . 47 , 1795 ( 1981 ) ; d. weingarten , phys . 109 b , 57 ( 1982 ) . n. eicker et al . 407 b , 290 ( 1997 ) . a. morel , j. phys . ( france ) 48 , 1111 ( 1987 ) . c. bernard and m. golterman , phys . d 46 , 853 ( 1992 ) ; s. sharpe , phys . rev . d 46 , 3146 ( 1992 ) . c. bernard and m. golterman , phys d 49 , 486 ( 1994 ) ; s. sharpe , phys . d 56 , 7052 ( 1997 ) ; m. golterman and k. leung , phys . d 57 , 5703 ( 1998 ) . s. drr , phys . rev . d 59 , 094501 ( 1999 ) . s. drr , nucl . b ( proc . suppl . ) 83 - 84 , 443 ( 2000 ) . s. drr in : a.w . schreiber et al . ( eds . ) : nonperturbative methods in quantum field theory , proceedings of the workshop in adelaide ( australia ) , 2 - 13 february 1998 ( world scientific , singapore , 1999);s . drr in : a. astbury et al . ( eds . ) : proceedings of the 29th international conference on high energy physics ( ichep98 ) , vancouver ( canada ) , 23 - 29 july 1998 ( world scientific , singapore , 1999 ) . t. schfer and e.v . shuryak , rev . 70 , 323 ( 1998 ) . a.v . smilga and j.j.m . verbaarschot , phys . d 54 , 1087 ( 1996 ) ; s. drr , ann . 273 , 1 ( 1999 ) . h. joos , helv . acta 63 , 670 ( 1990 ) ; i. sachs and a. wipf , helv . acta 65 , 652 ( 1992 ) . m. lscher , comm . 85 , 39 ( 1982 ) ; j. smit and j.c . vink , nucl . b 303 , 36 ( 1988 ) ; j.c . vink , nucl . b 307 , 549 ( 1988 ) . c.r . gattringer , i. hip and c.b . lang , phys . b 409 , 371 ( 1997 ) and nucl . phys . b 508 , 329 ( 1997 ) ; c.r . gattringer and i. hip , nucl . b 536 , 363 ( 1998 ) . h. leutwyler and a.v . smilga , phys . rev . d 46 , 5607 ( 1992 ) . b. alls , m. delia and a. di giacomo , nucl . phys . b 494 , 281 ( 1997 ) . | the concept of simulating a variant of qcd with sea quarks which interact with the gluon configuration only via global gluonic quantities like @xmath0 and @xmath1 is tested for the case of the massive 2-flavour schwinger model . it is found to amount to an importance sampling method which generates at essentially the costs of a quenched run an ensemble in between a full and a quenched one , thus providing a competitive alternative to the quenched approximation . * topologically unquenched qcd : prospects + from@xmath2an@xmath2explorative@xmath2study@xmath2in@xmath22-flavour - qed(2 ) * * stephan drr * + _ paul scherrer institut , theory group _ + _ 5232 villigen psi , switzerland _ + [email protected] |
1301.0344 | the advent of novel video services with multiple views of the same video scene , e.g. , 3-d tv or free - view point video , poses many novel challenges in terms of coding , processing and transmission of the multimedia content . as far as encoding techniques are concerned , the iso / itu - t joint video team has recently finalized the h.264 multiview video coding ( mvc ) standard , which is explicitly devoted to efficient compression of a multiview source @xcite . it is expected that multiview video communication services will be traffic intensive , which raises important questions in network dimensioning . in addition , the encoding dependencies between the different views renders resource allocation quite challenging in a mvc communication system . both problems of network dimensioning and resource allocation are usually addressed with the help of traffic models in classical video delivery services . such tools have proved to be a valid support for efficient and accurate allocation of network resources by characterizing the compressed video content through statistical models . video traffic models have been derived for different applications in teleconferencing @xcite , video broadcasting @xcite , or streaming @xcite . different stochastic models based on autoregressive processes @xcite , transform expanded sample ( tes ) processes @xcite , and hidden markov models ( hmms ) @xcite have been considered for network design , resource allocation , buffer dimensioning , and performance evaluation @xcite . there is however a lack of traffic models for multiview video communication services . we propose here a new traffic model for mvc content in order to characterize the frame size sequence observed at the output of an mvc variable bit rate ( vbr ) source . specifically , building on our preliminary work @xcite , we design a doubly stochastic source model , namely a poisson hidden markov model ( p - hmm ) @xcite , in which the first ( hidden ) layer consists of a non - stationary chain modeling the video activity level and the second layer represents the frame sizes of the different mvc encoded views . besides , we extend the p - hmm parameter estimation algorithm for short observation sequences presented in @xcite and adapt it to long sequences such as those encountered in video communication services . we assess the model performances by extensive numerical simulations on classes of mvc sequences sharing common properties . we apply our model to predict the traffic load generated by two different network services based on a client - server video communication paradigm . in the first one , that we name multiview tv , the server simultaneously streams all the mvc encoded views to the client . our model is shown to be able to predict the state of sender and receiver buffers in multiview tv . in the second one , named interactive tv , the client dynamically selects the views during the streaming session by means of a feedback channel . due to the mvc encoding dependencies , the server transmits a composite stream encompassing all encoded data required to correctly decode the selected view . finally , we introduce an interactive tv user service request model , in order to mimic the sequence of requested views selected by the user . in fact , the traffic generated during the interactive tv session depends both on the mvc encoded video traces and on the user s view selection . we show that the combination of our two models is able to accurately characterize the traffic in interactive multiview applications . the main contribution of this paper can be summarized as follows : * a non - stationary traffic model for vbr mvc sequences is introduced , with the ability to characterize different classes of mvc streams at different encoding settings . the model can predict actual network load in network applications ; * a maximum likelihood ( ml ) estimation procedure suitable to derive the traffic model parameters in long sequences is derived ; * a user behavior model for interactive view selection is combined with our traffic model to characterize interactive multiview traffic . the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : phmm ] , we introduce the poisson hidden markov model ( p - hmm ) and discuss its feasibility ; we also describe the p - hmm parameter set estimation procedure . in section [ sec : mas ] , we validate the model in different stream settings . network applications of our model are studied in section [ sec : buf ] , along with the view switching model . section [ sec : conc ] concludes the paper . a mvc stream jointly encodes different video sequences captured by multiple cameras with overlapping fields of view . let us denote by @xmath0 the number of such sequences . one view , denoted as reference view , is independently encoded using temporal motion compensation and transform coding techniques , similarly to a classical video sequence encoded with the h.264 encoder @xcite . the other @xmath1 views are encoded using inter - view prediction in addiction to temporal prediction , in order to further improve the compression performance . in h.264 mvc @xcite , inter - view prediction is allowed between frames referring to the same time instant , whereas intra - view encoding dependencies are usually set to permit temporal scalability @xcite . the encoding dependencies give rise to a generalized groups of pictures ( gop ) structure of duration @xmath2 , constituted by @xmath3 frames . figures [ fig : gop8 ] and [ fig : gop4 ] show two examples of such mvc gops . given the complete mvc encoded bitstream , up to @xmath0 flows are transmitted and decoded by the client . in most applications , all the views are transmitted together in a simulcast mode . gop structure and encoding hierarchy ( @xmath4 ) . ] gop structure and encoding hierarchy ( @xmath5 ) . ] in order to control the size of the bitstreams , different rate control algorithms @xcite can be implemented in mvc encoders . we however focus in this paper on variable bit rate ( vbr ) streams , where the quantization step sizes are fixed . their value only depends on the frame type , as commonly employed in most mvc applications @xcite . we propose now a new model that is able to characterize the frame sizes in gops of an mvc compressed stream with a given gop structure . in vbr operating mode , the bit - rate of the mvc encoded views varies according to the video activity level , and the traffic model should match this non stationary stochastic process . we propose a two - layer stochastic process model inspired from @xcite . we build a new poisson hidden markov model ( p - hmm ) @xcite , in which the first ( hidden ) layer is a discrete time markov chain whose states represent different video activity levels ; the second layer represents the frame size sequence corresponding to a given activity level . we make the following assumptions about the non - stationarity of the sources : 1 . the activity level of the video content varies in time according to a poisson distribution ; 2 . the hidden layer state transitions , ( _ i.e._,the change of the activity level ) occur at the beginning of a gop ; 3 . the activity level is the same in all views since views are correlated . with these simplifying assumptions , we approximate the duration of scenes with a given activity level , by a simple one parameter distribution . we discard the possible changes in the average frame size due to activity level changes observed in the middle of a gop . we will show that , in spite of this approximation , the model closely matches the mvc source characteristics . let us denote the number of states ( _ i.e._,different video activity levels ) in our model as @xmath6 . the state duration obeys a poisson distribution denoted by @xmath7 } = \frac{e^{-{\lambda}_i}{\lambda}_i^k}{k!}.\ ] ] when a state transition occurs , the model is described by a state transition matrix @xmath8 , whose element @xmath9 denotes the probability of transition from state @xmath10 to state @xmath11 . because of the explicit modeling of the state duration time distribution , @xmath12 for all @xmath10 . finally , @xmath13 denotes the initial probability of the model being in state @xmath10 . the second layer in our model describes the frame sizes in an entire gop . formally , let us consider the random vector @xmath14 } = [ { { { x}}_{0}[n ] } , \dots , { { { x}}_{{n_{f}}-1}[n]}]\ ] ] representing the set of frames sizes in the @xmath15-th gop of the compressed multiview content . the vector @xmath16}$ ] is emitted in accordance to a multivariate probability mass function ( _ pmf _ ) depending on the actual hidden layer state . given the current state in the first layer of the model , say @xmath10 , a random vector @xmath16}$ ] is generated according to the _ pmf _ @xmath17}]$ ] . for the sake of compactness , each _ pmf _ @xmath18 $ ] , @xmath19 , has a different number of bins depending on the coding mode ( namely i , p , or b - frames ) of the compressed picture to be generated . this choice is motivated by not imposing that the frame size _ pmf _ follows a fixed probability distribution ( _ e.g._,gaussian , gamma , ) , but instead by adapting the distribution shape to the actual mvc sequences . moreover , by allowing a different number of bins for different frame types , we can adaptively control the model s complexity ( _ i.e._,the parameter set ) according to the desired accuracy performance . the estimation of the model parameters is a crucial step in traffic characterization . since the model belongs to the wide hmm family @xcite , we can resort to one of the estimation algorithms employed for such models . in particular , an estimation procedure called expectation - maximization ( em ) algorithm @xcite is widely used for hmms . a version of the em algorithm has been proposed for p - hmms in @xcite . however , it exhibits numerical instability when used for long data sequences @xcite . we derive here a new em algorithm for stable parameter estimation in long sequences . our algorithm extends the method of @xcite to the case of non - stationary hidden state durations . we present the parameter estimation in detail below . suppose that we observe a video sequence composed of @xmath20 gops . let @xmath21 } \}_{n=0}^{n-1 } $ ] denote the observed video traffic and @xmath22 the parameter set of our model , where @xmath23 is the parameter space and @xmath24},{\pi_{1 } } , \dots , { \lambda}_{{n_{s } } } , { b_{{{n_{s}}}}[\cdot]},{\pi_{{{n_{s } } } } } \}$ ] . the em algorithm comprises two iterative computational steps . the first one is an expectation step that computes the auxiliary likelihood function @xmath25 , in which @xmath26 represents a plausible state sequence and @xmath27 is the @xmath28-th estimate of the parameter set . then , a maximization step maximizes the likelihood function , _ i.e._,@xmath29 the algorithm iterates between the two steps until convergence of the parameter set . before getting into more details , let us define a function @xmath30}$ ] representing the state duration distribution and taking into account the finite length of the observed sequence , as @xmath31 } = \begin{cases } 1-{d_{i}[k-1 ] } & \text{if } \;\;k = { n}- n - 1\\[10pt ] { d_{i}[k ] } & \text{otherwise } \end{cases}.\ ] ] the parameter @xmath32}$ ] is the cumulative distribution of the state duration times . then , the computations in our em algorithm , as applied to p - hmms , comprise i ) the computation of forward probabilities , ii ) the computation of backward probabilities , iii ) the estimation of the parameter set . the first two steps calculate three auxiliary variables , namely the conditioned probabilities of the state sequence to the observed sequence , representing the expectation steps of our em algorithm ( see @xcite for further details ) . then , the parameter set is expressed as function of these auxilary variables . we first define the following forward probabilities for @xmath33 @xmath34 & { \alpha_{n}(i ) } { \mathop { = } \limits^{\text{def}}}p(s_n = i| { { y}}_0^n,{\theta}^{(m)})\label{eq : alfa}. \ ] ] for @xmath35 the definitions above are slightly different in order to take into account the finite length of the actual sequence @xmath36 those quantities are calculated by the recursive algorithm illustrated in algorithm [ tab : alfa ] is calculated by summation over @xmath10 and @xmath37 . ] . they represent the probability for the system to be in state @xmath10 at time @xmath15 and to stay in the same state for the next @xmath37 instants , given the sequence observed till time @xmath15 . 1.5 @xmath38}{b_{i}[{{{y}}[0 ] } ] } $ ] @xmath39}]}(\sum_{\substack{j = 1\\j \ne i}}^{{n_{s}}}{\alpha_{n-1}(j,0)}{\pi_{ji}}{\dot{d}_{i}[k ] } + { \alpha_{n-1}(i , k+1 ) } ) $ ] @xmath40 then , the following backward probabilities are defined in a similar way @xmath41 & \begin{aligned } { \xi_{n}(i , j , k ) } & { \mathop { = } \limits^{\text{def}}}p(s_{n-1 } = i,\ s_{n } = j,\\ & \dots , s_{n+k } = j , s_{n+k+1 } \ne j | { { { y}}_0^{n-1}},{\theta}^{(m)}),\\ & n = 1 , \dots , { n}- 1;\ k < { n}- n - 1.\label{eq : xid } \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that we resort to a different definition for the backward probabilities with respect to the usual @xmath42 notation @xcite . in @xcite , a @xmath42 backward probability is defined representing the likelihood of the observed sequence , and @xmath43 and @xmath44 are calculated by means of @xmath45 and @xmath42 . here , we calculate directly @xmath43 and @xmath44 in a backward iteration in order to avoid numerical issues arising from the sequence length . the algorithm [ tab : xi ] illustrates the backward probabilities computation , where @xmath46 denotes the kronecker function . 1.5 @xmath47 @xmath48 @xmath49 @xmath50}+ { \delta_{i}^{j}}{\alpha_{n-1}(i , k+1)}}{\sum_{l = 1}^{{{n_{s } } } } { \alpha_{n-1}(l,0)}{\pi_{lj}}{\dot{d}_{j}[k]}+ { \delta_{l}^{j}}{\alpha_{n-1}(l , k+1)}}\cdot{\gamma_{n}(j , k)}$ ] finally , the parameter set @xmath51 in the maximization step can be calculated with the help of the forward and the backward probabilities above . we can write the initial probability of being in state @xmath10 as : @xmath52 then we can express the transition probabilities as : @xmath53 the frame size distribution in each state is given by : @xmath54 } = \frac{\sum_{n=0}^{{n}-1}\sum_{k=0}^{{n}-n-1}{\gamma_{n}(i , k)}{\delta_{{{x}}}^{{{{y}}[n]}}}}{\sum_{n=0}^{{n}-1}\sum_{k=0}^{{n}-n-1}{\gamma_{n}(i , k)}}.\ ] ] finally , the state duration is expressed as : @xmath55 note that a single iteration of the estimation algorithm consists of calculating first the state sequence probabilities - , which is the expectation step . subsequently , we compute the new parameter estimates by averaging the observations weighted with the state probabilities - , which corresponds to the maximization step of an iteration of the algorithm . convergence is assured by jensen s inequality @xcite . in this section , we assess our model by comparing statistics evaluated on a pseudo - random synthetic traffic generated according to our p - hmm , with the statistics evaluated on a composite mvc test sequence . the p - hmm parameters are estimated by applying the em algorithm of section [ sec : em ] on the observed composite sequence . we also test the case in which the test sequence is different from the sequence used to train the model , in order to show the model ability to represent not only the training sequence , but also other sequences with similar content . a comparison with a well - known single view vbr model is also carried out . the composite mvc sequences considered in the model assessment are generated by concatenating several tests sequences with very different activity levels , as reported in table [ tab : seq ] . all the sequences are in cif format , with a frame rate of 25 fps , and @xmath56 views . the resulting mvc composite sequence is approximately 6 minutes long . we encode the sequence using the two different gop structures reported in figures [ fig : gop8 ] and [ fig : gop4 ] . both structures exhibit motion compensation dependencies among the views for anchor and non - anchor frames @xcite . the large number of dependencies accentuates the difference between mvc traffic and simple aggregations of single view traffic . the two gop structures differ in the number of i and p frames . the bit - rate variability of sequences encoded using the gop in figure [ fig : gop8 ] is mainly due to the residuals of the motion compensation whereas for sequences encoded using the gop in figure [ fig : gop4 ] ; the bit - rate variability depends on the large number of intra or p frames . for each gop structure , different mvc bitstreams have been generated by setting the quantization parameter of the reference view to 10 ( high quality ) , 20 ( medium quality ) , or 40 ( low quality ) , and by adjusting the temporal layers quantization parameter accordingly . we use jmvc v7.0 to encode the sequences @xcite , then we use the different mvc bitstreams to build traffic models . . [ tab : seq]test sequences used to generate the compound sequence . [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] as we discussed in the previous section , the number of bins in the _ pmf_s of the model may be different for different frame types in order to have a trade - off between performance and model complexity . in our tests we use the number of bins shown in table [ tab : binsss ] and for the gop structures in figures [ fig : gop8 ] and [ fig : gop4 ] , respectively . the bins are placed in the interval between the minimum and the maximum observed frame size for each frame type . in the simulations , we employ a 3-state model in order to represent low , medium and high level activity . a first coarse estimation of the model parameter is performed by labeling each gop of the actual sequence as low , medium or high according to its average frame size . the thresholds are set in order to have the same number of gops in the three states . then , a coarse estimation is obtained by evaluating frame size histograms related to each state . zero - valued bins are set to a low fixed value and the histograms are normalized accordingly . the transition probability matrix is initializated with positive random values , and the poisson mean values are set to 1 for each state . after that , the em algorithm is performed as described in section [ sec : em ] using the coarse estimation as starting point . estimation ends when the difference between the log likelihood of the two most recent iterates is smaller than 0.01 . finally , synthetic traffic is produced by first generating a state sequence according to the model and then producing synthetic traffic for a gop for each state of the sequence by means of the frame size _ pmf_s . the bins are converted to the mean frame size of the interval they represent . the synthetic traffic generation is described in algorithm [ alg : syn ] . 1.5 initial state @xmath10 extracted according to the distribution @xmath57 @xmath58 @xmath37 extracted from the poisson distribution belonging to the current state , i.e. , @xmath59}$ ] @xmath60 generate a synthetic gop @xmath61}$ ] according to @xmath18 $ ] ; perform state transition according to transition matrix @xmath8 . we now assess the model s accuracy by first comparing the autocorrelation function ( acf ) and the q - q plot computed on a sequence of frame sizes of the actual mvc encoded sequence ( comprising all the views ) with the respective statistics evaluated on a pseudo - random traffic sequence generated by the p - hmm with parameters estimated from the corresponding composite sequence . figures [ fig : sta4 - 10 ] , [ fig : sta4 - 20 ] and [ fig : sta8 - 20 ] show the acf and the q - q plot for different compressed mvc sequences . q - q plot measures how two distributions are similar by comparing their quantiles . the closer the q - q plot to the bisector of the first and third quadrant , the more similar the two distributions are.it is clear that the statistics evaluated on the synthetic traffic ( p - hmm - a ) closely follow the statistics of the actual mvc sequences , for every gop structure and quantization parameter . the close match with the actual data is due to the fact that we do not constrain the frame size _ pmf_s to have an explicit probability distribution and that we employ the poisson distribution for the state durations , thus forcing a non - stationary recurrence of the activity levels . in order to validate these conclusions , we compare our model to the well - known single view vbr model described in @xcite . specifically , we focus on the `` model a '' in @xcite , whose main differences with our p - hmm model relate to the frame size distribution and the hidden chain describing the activity level . the model a employs three shifted gamma distributions for the sizes of frames ( i , p , b ) and a stationary 7-state markov chain for the activity level . moreover , an ad - hoc parameter estimation procedure is used in @xcite . we see in the figures [ fig : sta4 - 10 ] , [ fig : sta4 - 20 ] and [ fig : sta8 - 20 ] that model a is not able to describe it correctly . in particular , we can see that model a does not depict accurately the shape of the actual sequence , both for the q - q plots and the autocorrelation function . we finally consider the case in which our model is trained with a different sequence with respect to the test sequence , we denote the synthetic traffic generated by this model as p - hmm - b . p - hmm - a outperforms the other models in mimicking the overall frame size distribution while p - hmm - b also achieves good adherence performance . the same statistics have been calculated separately on the traffic related to each view in mvc streams . figures [ fig : sta8 - 20 - 1 ] and [ fig : sta8 - 20 - 3 ] show these statistics for the view # 1 and view # 3 , respectively . similar results have been obtained for different encoder settings . again , it is clear that model a @xcite is not able to capture the statistics for each single view . conversely , our models can characterize efficiently the traffic for each view . the characterization of the first and second order statistics for every view makes the model attractive to describe real mvc traffic in network applications , where a subset of the views are transmitted to the receivers . the good results obtained with phmm - b show that the model is able to capture features that are not only related to a single mvc stream , but also to a class of sequences sharing similar content characteristics . finally , we remark that the slight divergence in terms of autocorrelation function is caused by neglecting the intra - gop correlation in the model design . we examine the accuracy of our model in the context of multiview services . we consider two case studies illustrated in figure [ fig : sys ] . in the first one , called `` multiview tv '' , the server sends all the mvc content to the user . in the second one , denoted as `` interactive tv '' , the user requests one view at the time and can switch dynamically among the available views during the playout , exploiting an out - of - band feedback control channel . due to the coding dependencies , the reference views still have to be transmitted along with the target view in the interactive tv service . from the point of view of the mvc source model , the above services differ in that the traffic generated during the multiview tv session depends only on the encoded video , whereas the traffic generated during the interactive tv session depends also on the view selection process . thereby , in order to fully characterize the latter scenario , we develop a new model of the view switching sequence , inspired by related models in the context of channel switching in iptv systems @xcite-@xcite . in the design of our view switching model , we employ the following assumptions : 1 . a user watches the reference view most of the time ; 2 . other views are occasionally selected by the user because they represent added content with respect to the main view ( _ e.g._,in a football game , these views may describe the foreground of the players ) ; 3 . a user selects views with preferences that depend on the present view the user is currently watching ( first order dependency ) . we model the view switching sequence as a chain in which the states represent different views . the duration of stay in each view is explicitly modeled with a probability distribution . according to the above assumptions , we select sample values for the view transition probabilities , which are reported in table [ tab : swmat ] . the average and standard deviation of state durations are also set to sample values corresponding to the above assumptions ( see table [ tab : swmat ] ) . we have found that the gamma distribution is suitable and flexible for modeling the duration time , since it takes only non - negative values with mean and standard deviation that are features independent . formally , let @xmath62}$ ] be the density function for the duration time in state @xmath10 : @xmath63 } { \mathop { = } \limits^{\text{def}}}\frac{\beta_{i}^{\alpha_{i}}}{\gamma(\alpha_{i } ) } k^{\alpha_{i}-1 } e^{-\beta_{i } { k } } \text { for } k \geq 0\ ] ] the parameters @xmath64 and @xmath65 are derived from the mean and the standard deviation of duration time for the corresponding state , respectively @xmath66 and @xmath67 , according to the following expressions : @xmath68 & \beta_{i } = \frac{{\mu_{i}}}{{\sigma_{i}}^2 } \end{cases}\ ] ] note that the specific model of user behavior employed in the performance analysis is however not critical , and a similar study could be conducted with other behavior models . we compare the traffic load due to the h.264 mvc source and the synthetic video traffic trace generated by our p - hmm model in both network scenarios defined above . we consider that the mvc traffic is fed into the transmission buffer @xmath69that is characterized by a buffer size @xmath70and an output rate _ ( see figure [ fig : sys ] ) . the transmission buffer adopts a first in first out ( fifo ) scheduling policy . the buffer output is encapsulated into networks packets in accordance with network packetization rules and transmitted to the destination through the channel . each packet might be affected by a different ( random ) delay during transmission . the delay @xmath71}$ ] is the sum of the channel delay @xmath72}$ ] and the transmission buffer delay @xmath73}$ ] . for modeling the channel delay @xmath72}$ ] , we resort to the quite general and complete channel model introduced by miao and chou . ] after an initial prefetch delay _ ( namely _ d_= 2 sec . in our study ) from the arrival time of the first frame , the playout buffer is drained at a rate given by the mvc compressed stream . if frames are not available in the playout buffer at their decoding deadline , they are considered as lost . we consider three different values for the channel rate , namely 1 , 1.5 , or 2 times the average bitrate of the mvc source rate . we denote the ratio between the channel rate and then average source rate by the factor @xmath74 . we have generated a 25 minute long multiview test sequence , by concatenating the streams described in table [ tab : seq ] , similarly to the sequences used in section [ sec : simset ] . a 3-state model is built by running the em algorithm on the actual sequence using the same procedure as section [ sec : simset ] . for each sequence , we generated two streams with high ( q=10 ) and low ( q=40 ) quality , respectively . we then study the accuracy of our model by comparing the traffic and more particularly the loss rate due to late packets , for both the synthetic traffic and the actual mvc sequence . the loss rate is defined as the ratio between the number of lost frames and the number of transmitted frames at both the sender and receiver buffers . the frame loss rate is averaged over 10 monte carlo simulations . first , we compare the sender buffer frame loss rate for different values of the buffer size . figures [ fig:3dtvq40tx ] , [ fig:3dtvq10tx ] and figures [ fig : inttvq40tx ] , [ fig : inttvq10tx ] show respectively these results for the multiview tv and the interactive tv cases , at different channel rates and stream quality values . it can be seen that the actual mvc sequence and the synthetic sequence share a similar frame loss rate for different channel rates and transmission buffer sizes . note that the close similarity is due to the model s capability to describe higher order statistics by means of the non - stationary activity level chain . finally , we compare the overall frame loss rate , i.e. , the sum of lost frames at both the sender and receiver buffers , divided by the total number of frames , as a function of the receiver buffer size . figures [ fig:3dtvq40rx ] , [ fig:3dtvq10rx ] and figures [ fig : inttvq40rx ] , [ fig : inttvq10rx ] show these results for the multiview tv and interactive tv cases , respectively . table [ tab : flr ] summarizes these results for other test settings , quantifying the model s accuracy as the average absolute difference @xmath75 of the frame loss rate , between the real sequence and the synthetic sequence . the average is taken over the different buffer sizes under consideration and the frame loss rate is expressed in percent . it can be seen that the synthetic sequence closely follows the behavior of the actual mvc source ; specifically , the difference between the frame loss rate of the model and the one of the actual sequence is smaller than 0.03 for most of the playout buffer sizes under examination . since the frame arrival time at the play - out buffer depends on the size of the previous frames that are transmitted , the close similarity between the synthetic and the actual traffic demonstrates the accuracy of the model in characterizing mvc traffic statistics . in addition , even the p - hmm - b model , which is trained on different sequences than the test sequences , is able to capture relevant traffic features of actual data thus providing a good frame loss rate estimation for both transmission and play - out buffer , as seen from table [ tab : flr ] . therefore , the p - hmm can replace real mvc sequences in the dimensioning of transmit and receive buffers . it can be employed both for synthetic trace generation as well as for theoretical network performance analysis . in this paper , we have presented a new stochastic model characterizing the frame size sequence for mvc variable bit rate ( vbr ) sources . the model exploits a poisson hidden markov model representing the random frame sizes of the different mvc encoded views as a function of the random real video scene activity variations . we have also derived a stable em algorithm that is applicable to long data sequences for the p - hmm parameter estimation . we have shown through extensive simulations that our model accurately predicts the sequence of frame sizes in an mvc stream . we have also applied our model to traffic load prediction in two different network scenarios , namely a multiview tv service and an interactive tv service . simulation results show that the synthetic traffic generated by the proposed model strongly resembles the traffic due to real mvc video traces . the model is able to accurately characterize a class of mvc streams sharing similar content characteristics with the training data . the model is therefore an appropriate tool for different networking problems , such as network dimensioning , resource allocation , and call admission control . 99 y. chen , y. wang , k. ugur , m.m . hannuksela , j. lainema , and m. gabbouj , `` the emerging mvc standard for 3d video services , '' _ eurasip journal on advances in signal processing _ , vol . 2009 , article i d 786015 , 13 pages , 2009 . s. xu and z. huang , `` a gamma autoregressive video model on atm networks , '' _ ieee trans . circuits syst . video technol . _ , vol . 8 , no . 138 - 142 , apr . 1998 . n. ansari , h. liu , y. q. shi , and h. zhao , `` on modeling mpeg video traffics , '' _ ieee trans . _ , vol.48 , no.4 , pp.337 - 347 , dec . 2002 . d.p . heyman and t.v . lakshman , `` source models for vbr broadcast - video traffic , '' _ ieee / acm trans . _ , vol.4 , no.1 , pp.40 - 48 , feb 1996 . s. colonnese , s. rinauro , l. rossi , and g. scarano , `` markov model of h.264 video traffic , '' presented at the 4th int . sym . on im./video comm . ( isivc 08 ) , bilbao - spain , july 9 - 11th , 2008 . a. matrawy , i. lambadaris , and c. huang , `` mpeg4 traffic modeling using the transform expand sample methodology , '' in _ proc . of 4th ieee iwna4 _ , 2002 , pp . 249 - 256 . s. colonnese , s. rinauro , l. rossi , and g. scarano , `` h.264 video traffic modeling via hidden markov process , '' in _ proc . euspico-09 _ , 2009 , pp.2221 - 2225 , 2009 . z. zang , j. kurose , j.d . salehi , and d. towsley , `` smoothing , statistical multiplexing , and call admission control for stored video , '' _ ieee j. sel . areas commun . _ , vol . 15 , no . 6 , pp.1148 - 1166 , aug . l. rossi , j. chakareski , p. frossard , and s. colonnese , `` a non - stationary hidden markov model for multiview video traffic , '' in _ proc . 17th ieee international conference on image processing ( icip ) _ , 2010 , pp.2921 - 2924 . m. russell and r. moore , `` explicit modelling of state occupancy in hidden markov models for automatic speech recognition , '' icassp 85 , 1985 . h. schwarz , d. marpe , and t. wiegand , `` overview of the scalable video coding extension of the h.264/avc standard , '' _ ieee trans . on circuits and system for video technology _ 1103 - 1120 , september 2007 . s. park and d. sim , `` an efficienct rate - control algorithm for multi - view video coding , '' _ ieee 13th international symposium on consumer electronics _ , 2009 . doulamis , a.d doulamis , g.e . konstantoulakis , and g.i . stassinopoulos , `` efficient modeling of vbr mpeg-1 coded video sources , '' _ ieee trans . on circ . and sys . for video tech _ , vol.10 , no.1 , pp.93 - 112 , feb . 2000 . rabiner , `` a tutorial on hidden markov models and selected applications in speech recognition , '' _ proceedings of the ieee _ , vol . 2 , pages 257 - 286 , 1989 . a.p . dempster , n.m . laird , and d.b . rubin , `` maximum likelihood from incomplete data via the em algorithm , '' _ b _ , vol . 1 , pp . 1 - 38 , 1977 . y. ephraim and n. merhav , `` hidden markov processes , '' _ ieee trans . inform . theory _ 1518 - 1569 , june 2002 . h. xiong , h. lv , y. zhang , l. song , z. he , and t. chen , `` subgraphs matching - based side information generation for distributed multiview video coding , '' _ eurasip journal on advances in signal processing _ , vol . 2009 , pp . 1 - 18 , 2009 . joint multiview coding ( jmvc ) v7.0 , available via cvs at garcon.ient.rwth-aachen.de . u.k . sarkar , s. ramakrishnan , and d. sarkar , `` modeling full - length video using markov - modulated gamma - based framework , '' _ ieee / acm trans . 638 - 649 , 2003 . lee , c.k . hong , and k.y . lee , `` reducing channel zapping time in iptv based on user s channel selection behaviors , '' _ ieee trans . on broadcasting _ , 321 - 330 , sept . 2010 . a.m. kermarrec , e. le merrer , y. liu , and g. simon , `` surfing peer - to - peer iptv : distributed channel switching , '' in _ proc . of europar _ , 2009 , pp . 574 - 586 . h. joo , h. song , d.b . lee , and i. lee , `` an effective iptv channel control algorithm considering channel zapping time and network utilization , '' _ ieee trans . broadcast . 208 - 216 , june 2008 . m. cha , p. rodriguez , j . crowcroft , s. moon , and x. amatriain , `` watching television over an ip network , '' _ proc . of acm internet measurement conference _ , 2008 . chou and z. miao , `` rate - distortion optimized streaming of packetized media , '' _ ieee trans . 390 - 404 , apr . 2006 | multiview video has recently emerged as a means to improve user experience in novel multimedia services . we propose a new stochastic model to characterize the traffic generated by a multiview video coding ( mvc ) variable bit rate source . to this aim , we resort to a poisson hidden markov model ( p - hmm ) , in which the first ( hidden ) layer represents the evolution of the video activity and the second layer represents the frame sizes of the multiple encoded views . we propose a method for estimating the model parameters in long mvc sequences . we then present extensive numerical simulations assessing the model s ability to produce traffic with realistic characteristics for a general class of mvc sequences . we then extend our framework to network applications where we show that our model is able to accurately describe the sender and receiver buffers behavior in mvc transmission . finally , we derive a model of user behavior for interactive view selection , which , in conjunction with our traffic model , is able to accurately predict actual network load in interactive multiview services . digital video broadcasting , three dimensional tv , hidden markov models , multiview video . |
1011.0654 | the analysis of the electronic properties of semiconductors often requires considering the presence in their band structure of multiple degenerate valleys , centered around different , symmetry - related positions in reciprocal space @xcite . at low energy , the dynamics of electrons in each of these valleys can be modeled in terms of a long - wavelength effective hamiltonian , an approach suitable to describe the vast majority of the transport phenomena that are measured experimentally . one interesting question which is particularly timely in view of the intense research effort focusing on so - called topological insulators @xcite is whether there exist non - trivial topological properties associated to the individual valleys that can be described in the framework of a long - wavelength effective hamiltonian . $ ] ( integrand of eq . ) as a function of momentum @xmath0 over the entire brillouin zone , obtained from the tight - binding description of gapped blg . @xmath1 is nonvanishing only close to the @xmath2 and @xmath3 points ( valleys ) , where it is well approximated by the expression for @xmath4 that enters the long - wavelength effective hamiltonian ( see eq . ) . the integral of @xmath1 over the entire brillouin zone vanishes , owing to the equal and opposite contributions of the two valleys ( @xmath5 , corresponding to the quantized hall conductivity of the individual valleys).,scaledwidth=35.0% ] to start addressing this question , here we focus on the case of two - dimensional ( 2d ) electronic systems . the two best known examples of non - trivial topological insulators in two dimensions are provided by integer quantum hall systems @xcite and by spin - orbit induced topological insulators @xcite . in these systems , the non - trivial topological properties of the bulk band structure result in a quantized hall conductivity when the fermi level is located in a bulk energy gap ( for spin - orbit induced topological insulators , spin - hall conductivity is quantized only when the spin is a good quantum number and one can consider the hall conductivity for each spin state separately ) . indeed , it is well established that the expression of the bulk hall conductivity @xmath6 given by the kubo formula for linear response corresponds to the chern number that characterizes the topological structure of the mapping from the brillouin zone to the space of the bloch states @xcite . if we confine ourselves to the simplest case where only two bands are relevant , the physics of these systems can be described in terms of an effective hamiltonian of the form @xmath7\psi_{\bm{k}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath8^t$ ] is the itinerant electron field operator , @xmath9 is a vector of the pauli matrices , and @xmath10 is a real vector . if the bulk band structure is fully gapped , and the chemical potential @xmath11 lies inside the gap , the hall conductivity ( in units of @xmath12 neglecting spin degeneracy ) , equal to the chern number associated to the occupied band , is given by @xcite @xmath13 with @xmath14 ( again , for spin - orbit induced topological insulators with conserved spin , these expressions hold separately for the two spin directions ) . the integral has to be performed over the entire brillouin zone . the system is topologically non - trivial if @xmath15 . the physical manifestation of the topological non - triviality , which discriminates between topological and trivial insulators , is the appearance of @xmath16 gapless states at the system edges , which can transport current even when the fermi level is located in the bulk energy gap . this statement , true for both integer quantum hall and spin - orbit induced topological insulators with conserved spin , relates the bulk electronic structure ( which determines the chern number ) to the edge properties and is known as _ bulk - edge correspondence _ @xcite . the integrand in eq . ( [ eq : intro2 ] ) is often sharply peaked in the regions of the momentum space where @xmath17 , and hence the gap , becomes small these are the valleys of the band structure . thanks to the fast convergence , the integral in eq . ( [ eq : intro2 ] ) over the brillouin zone can be calculated using the long wavelength approximation for the hamiltonian valid in the individual valleys . in this case one can associate an index @xmath18 to each one of the valleys ( @xmath19 labels the valley ) , and the chern number is then the sum of the @xmath18 . this sum can vanish even if the individual @xmath18 do not , in which case the system is according to the definition given above topologically trivial . however , the question arises as to whether the non - vanishing of the @xmath18 associated to the individual valleys has observable consequences . indeed , a non - vanishing @xmath18 implies that valley @xmath19 gives an non - zero contribution to the hall conductivity , and the appearance of @xmath18 gapless edge states associated to each individual valley may be expected by a naive extension " of the bulk - edge correspondence . it may be argued that due to the overall triviality of the system ( i.e. , the fact that the chern number defined over the entire brillouin zone vanishes ) these states localize because they are not protected against disorder at the edge , which causes inter - valley scattering @xcite . nevertheless , the fundamental question remains , whether in a system with ideal edges ( i.e. , edges that preserve the _ valley quantum number _ , well defined at low energies ) there exists a bulk - edge correspondence for individual valleys . here we consider the case of gapped bilayer graphene ( blg ) as a model system for the case in which two symmetry - related valleys are present ( the @xmath2 and @xmath3 valleys with non - vanishing @xmath20 depending on the valley , see fig . [ fig : tcd ] ) , and investigate the low - energy electronic states at its edges . specifically , we consider different crystalline edges which do not couple the valleys , and we find the corresponding edge states in the different cases ( we have discussed elsewhere the effect of disordered edges , which is experimentally more relevant@xcite ) . if the bulk - edge correspondence could be generically extended to single - valley hamiltonians , one would expect that @xmath20 should imply the presence of exactly one gapless mode per valley per spin at an ideal edge of gapped blg , for all edges that do not couple the valleys . in contrast to this expectation , we show through an explicit analytical solution in complete agreement with full tight - binding calculations , that the number of the gapless edge modes depends on the boundary conditions , even when no mixing between valleys exists at the edge@xcite . in other words , _ the valley - specific bulk - edge correspondence is not fulfilled for plain blg - vacuum interfaces . _ in order to understand this result , we examine the geometrical meaning of @xmath18 associated to a particular valley hamiltonian , and find that , contrary to the case of the chern numbers in topological insulators ( defined over the entire brillouin zone ) , @xmath18 in blg does not correspond in itself to a well - defined topological invariant of a mapping . nevertheless , the non - vanishing of @xmath18 still signals that the properties of the electron states in individual valleys are non - trivial , and we discuss how this non - triviality manifests itself at interfaces between different domains where the gap of blg changes sign @xcite . in this case , the number of zero - energy states corresponds to the difference of @xmath18 on opposite sides of the blg - blg interface ( @xmath21 , where we denote with @xmath22 the value of @xmath18 at the left and at the right of the blg - blg interface ) , in agreement with expectations based on bulk - edge correspondence . indeed , we show that for a blg - blg interface the difference @xmath21 is a well - defined topological invariant of a mapping , even though the individual @xmath23 and @xmath24 are not . these results reveal the _ marginal _ character of individual valleys in gapped blg : the _ difference _ of @xmath18 across an interface may or may not be topologically well defined , depending on the specific kind of interface . it is a well defined topological invariant across a domain wall where the gap changes sign , but it is not for a blg - vacuum interface . such a marginal topological character of a single valley is likely to be not only characteristic of blg , but is a more general property common to many other multi - valley systems . we start by briefly reviewing the known properties of the band structure of bilayer graphene , emphasizing the specific aspects that will be relevant later . in blg a gap between valence and conductance bands can be opened controllably by applying a perpendicular electric field , while maintaining the fermi energy in the middle of the gap@xcite ( the sign of the gap is determined by the orientation of the field ) . the continuum low - energy , long - wavelength limit hamiltonian for each individual valley can be obtained from the tight - binding description of blg with bernal stacking @xcite . with the four inequivalent atoms in a unit cell labeled by a(b)1(2 ) ( see fig . [ fig : lattice](a ) ) , the dimensionless hamiltonian matrix for the wave function @xmath25 reads @xcite : @xmath26 here , @xmath27 is the ( dimensionless ) wave vector , the valley index @xmath28 , and @xmath29 ( @xmath30 ) defines the size of the bulk gap . the excitation spectrum is @xmath31 , with @xmath32 and @xmath33 . this implies a splitting of an order of magnitude @xmath34 between the high energy bands ( @xmath35 ) and direct gap @xmath29 between the low energy bands ( @xmath36 ) . the original four - component hamiltonian can be inconvenient to work with , especially when one needs to find solutions with specific boundary conditions . therefore , bearing in mind that the energy range of our interests would only involve the two low energy bands , we reduce to a two - component hamiltonian by rewriting the schrdinger equation @xmath37 in the following form : @xmath38 \varphi = e(1+k^2 ) \varphi , & \label{eq : phi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath39 and @xmath40 . as we are interested in the subgap edge state solutions with @xmath41 , only terms up to linear order in @xmath42 and @xmath43 are kept . if we further neglect @xmath44 and @xmath45 terms , we obtain @xmath46 which is the reduced hamiltonian , describing the low energy bands to the lowest order in @xmath43 and @xmath47 . this reduction procedure is essentially identical to that used by mccann and falko @xcite . here we emphasize two important aspects : first , the nontrivial topological properties of the original four - component model are fully inherited by the reduced two - component model this will be shown in section [ ssec : bulk ] ; second , the relation between the low - energy ( @xmath48 ) and high energy ( @xmath49 ) components of the wavefunction [ eq . ] is essential to impose the correct boundary conditions at edges this will be shown in section [ ssec : edge ] . starting from the effective hamiltonians given previously and following the logic explained in the introduction , we examine the nontrivial topological properties of a single valley of gapped blg by calculating the corresponding ( single - valley ) contribution to the hall conductivity @xmath50 . we consider the case when the fermi energy is lying in the middle of the bulk energy gap , so that we are dealing with one completely full and one completely empty bulk bands of . the valley - specific hall conductivity @xmath50 ( in units of @xmath12 ) corresponds , through kubo formula , to the quantity @xmath18 defined previously . here we present calculations for both the original four - band model and the reduced two - band model , and show that these calculations yield consistent results . this consistency implies that the nontrivial momentum topology of the original four - band model is fully inherited by the two - band model , which lends itself more easily to a geometrical interpretation of our results . the hall conductivity ( in units of @xmath12 ) associated to a fully - gapped model is generically given by@xcite @xmath51 where the non - singular propagator @xmath52 is defined as @xmath53 . for the four - component single - valley hamiltonian of blg , we find @xmath54 , which is equal and magnitude but opposite in sign ( @xmath55 for two valleys ; therefore , the chern number defined over the entire brillouin zone vanishes . this result is expected for blg , which is strictly speaking topologically trivial , despite the fact that the individual valleys possess nontrivial @xmath56 . for the reduced two - component model given by eq . , we can write the hamiltonian as @xmath57 , where @xmath58 . in this case , using the simplified form of the above formula for two - band models@xcite , given by , we find @xmath59 , in agreement with the calculation based on the full four - band model . this agreement indicates that the nontrivial topological properties of the individual valleys are due solely to the low energy bands . it is worth noting that the integral ( divided by 2 ) in eq . can be also identified as the berry phase acquired by an electron adiabatically transferred along the path enclosing the area of the integral @xcite . in this sense , the quantized hall conductivity is equivalent to the quantized berry phase ( in units of @xmath60 ) associated with the single - valley hamiltonian @xcite . we now proceed to calculate the exact solution of the edge states in gapped blg , for different edge structures that do not mix the valleys . we will only consider one of the two valleys , with @xmath61 , and the results for the other valley can be inferred through a symmetry transformation similar to time reversal . . the upper panel case corresponds to the edge shown in fig . [ fig : lattice ] ( a ) , and contains only one branch of gapless edge modes ; the lower panel case corresponds to fig . [ fig : lattice ] ( c ) , and contains two branches of gapless edge modes.,scaledwidth=42.0% ] the generic constraint for boundary conditions in the present model is imposed by vanishing probability current across the boundary . this constraint allows for a variety of boundary conditions which are physically valid ( see appendix [ app : bc ] ) . in order to base our investigation on concrete physical examples , we illustrate the boundary conditions that will be discussed in the following in the tight - binding picture of blg [ fig : lattice ] shows the edge structure for four cases , where the blg lattice terminates at different sublattices , either a or b , in each of the two layers . indeed , each of these combinations corresponds to a distinct boundary condition imposed in the continuum model , similar in spirit to what has been discussed by brey and fertig @xcite for single layer graphene . a significant difference is that in blg the boundary conditions in general involve both low ( @xmath48 ) and high ( @xmath49 ) energy components of the wavefunction . still , thanks to eq . , the latter can be written in terms of the low energy components and their derivatives , which is why a description in terms of the low energy components only is possible . for the structure in fig . [ fig : lattice](a ) where the blg lattice terminates at the edge with sublattices a1 and a2 , this corresponds to imposing @xmath62 ( the blg is infinitely long in the @xmath63 direction and semi - infinite in the @xmath64 direction , i.e. the edge is located at @xmath65 ) . the general solution of for @xmath66 is @xmath67 with @xmath68 and @xmath69 ( @xmath70 ) are coefficients that need to be determined . using , the boundary conditions lead to two coupled equations for @xmath69 with the secular equation for the existence of nontrivial subgap solutions @xmath71 this equation gives the dispersion relation @xmath72 for one sub - gap edge mode . when @xmath73 ( as is true for the @xmath74 mode ) eq . can be simplified ( since @xmath75 ) to : @xmath76 in fig . [ fig : solutions](a ) the analytical solution is compared with the full tight - binding solution , from which we see that the continuum model represents an excellent approximation . we conclude that for the edge just considered , one zero - mode exists ( per valley and spin ) @xcite , i.e. the result expected if the bulk - edge correspondence for single valley holds . we now consider the edge shown in fig . [ fig : lattice](c ) . the corresponding boundary conditions are @xmath77 , which lead to the new dispersion relation for the subgap edge modes , given by @xmath78 this equation has two solutions related by transformation @xmath79 and @xmath80 , which comes from the symmetry of the wave equation under @xmath81 . it is this symmetry , which is also preserved by the boundary conditions in the present case ( whereas it is broken by the boundary conditions considered in the previous example ) , that guarantees the existence of _ two _ subgap edge modes . the dispersion relation given by can be further simplified when @xmath73 , to @xmath82 which explicitly shows a pair of gapless edge modes propagating in the same direction , plotted in fig . [ fig : solutions](b ) ( again , in excellent agreement with the tight - binding solution ) . without presenting the details of the solutions for the other cases , we only state that the edge shown in fig . [ fig : lattice](b ) ( @xmath83 ) leads to a single branch of subgap edge modes , similar to the first example above , and the one shown in fig . [ fig : lattice](d ) ( @xmath84 ) yields no subgap modes . we therefore have to conclude that the number of zero - modes at the blg - vacuum interface depends on the specific edge considered , i.e. , the bulk - edge correspondence relating the hall conductivity and gapless edge modes does not hold in general for individual valleys @xcite . finding that bulk - edge correspondence does not hold for an individual valley , even though the contribution that each valley gives to the hall conductivity is integer ( in units of @xmath12 ) may seem surprising . specifically , one may wonder why the argument based on laughlin s gedanken experiment @xcite which is normally invoked to justify the existence of edge states in integer quantum hall systems does not apply to individual valleys in gapped blg . the answer to this question has to do with the fact that laughlin s gedanken experiment considers the adiabatic flow of electric charge , which is a conserved quantity ( in the context of laughlin s argument conservation of charge is so obvious that this assumption is not normally emphasized ) . contrary to the charge , the valley quantum number is not in general conserved . in particular , it is not conserved even in the presence of ideal edges if one considers the process the adiabatic insertion of flux , which is the basis of laughlin s gedanken experiment . as we outline below , the non - conservation of the valley quantum number allows for the possibility of a quantized valley hall conductivity in the absence of zero - energy edge modes . upon varying the magnetic flux @xmath85 in the usual cylindrical geometry involved in laughlin s argument , the allowed @xmath86 values of momentum along the edge flow according to @xmath87 , where @xmath88 is the circumference of the cylinder . upon insertion of flux @xmath89 , the set of allowed @xmath86 values returns to the original one . from the generic form of the electron wave function it follows that the wave - function weight is redistributed in the direction perpendicular to the edge in the process of flux insertion . the redistribution occurs in the opposite directions for the states near two valleys , with states in one valley flowing towards the edge , and states in the other valley flowing away from the edge . this is the microscopic mechanism for the transverse valley current flow implied by the non - zero value of the valley hall conductivity , @xmath90 . the fact that the valley current flows perpendicular to the edge , according to continuity equation would imply accumulation of the valley density at the edge . this apparent valley charge accumulation can be accommodated in two ways . the first is by creating valley charge imbalance at the edge , in direct analogy to quantum hall and quantum spin hall effect with conserved spin . clearly , for that to occur , the gapless edge modes have to exist . alternatively , the valley current influx at the edge can be compensated by the adiabatic transfer of the electrons between the valleys induced by the flux insertion , which converts @xmath91 for states in the _ entire _ 1d brillouin zone of the cylinder . this is possible due to the fact that the valleys are indeed connected by the bands that extend deep below the chemical potential . as a consequence , the spectral flow can not be fully described in terms of the long - wavelength effective hamiltonian in the neighborhood of the @xmath2 and @xmath3 points , but it requires considering the hamiltonian of the system over the entire brillouin zone . this is how the non - conservation of the valley quantum number can account for the seemingly paradoxical result that non - zero @xmath92 can exist even when gapless edge modes are completely absent @xcite . for gapped blg . panel ( a ) shows @xmath4 for a single valley as a vector field on the @xmath93 plane of @xmath0 . panel ( b ) shows the solid angle @xmath94 that @xmath95 covers when @xmath0 runs over the whole plane , the double arrow signifying the double covering of the ( upper ) hemisphere . panel ( c ) shows how two marginal topological mappings can be glued " to form a well - defined topological mapping , which is the case for a blg - blg domain wall with opposite mass signs on the two sides.,scaledwidth=37.0% ] next , let us give a geometrical reason for the the absence of a valley - specific bulk - edge correspondence at gapped blg edges ( blg - vacuum interfaces ) . it originates from the fact that the quantity @xmath18 associated with a given valley is not a well - defined topological invariant . this statement may appear to be in conflict with the case of domain wall interfaces , across which the sign of the mass ( @xmath43 ) in blg changes sign@xcite . in this latter case , bulk - edge correspondence predicts " that gapless states should be present , whose number corresponds to @xmath21 . when the gap @xmath43 changes sign across the domain wall , @xmath96 and indeed two gapless states are found at the interface . the conflict is only apparent , because @xmath21 does correspond to a well - defined topological invariant , even though @xmath18 does not . to understand the difference between @xmath18 and @xmath21 we look at the integrand function that is used to calculate these quantities , which , from eq . , is given by @xmath97 $ ] . this expression corresponds to the jacobian of the transformation from the region @xmath93 of the momentum space in the vicinity of a given valley point , to the unit sphere @xmath98 on which @xmath99 resides . for blg , at large @xmath47 ( @xmath100 ) , the vector @xmath95 lies on the equator , and therefore the integral of @xmath1 does not represent a topological invariant since the mapping between non - compact @xmath93 and compact @xmath98 is topologically trivial . indeed , as shown in fig . [ fig : topo ] ( a ) and ( b ) , the vector @xmath95 wraps around half of the unit sphere twice , but does not cover the entire sphere . that is despite the fact that the integral rapidly converges for latexmath:[$k^2 \gg @xmath43 ; it is @xmath102 for the opposite valley or for opposite sign of @xmath43 ) . for massive dirac fermions such non - compact behavior has been discussed by volovik , and is known as _ marginal _ @xcite . in the same sense , the massive chiral fermions in blg are marginal as well . the marginality implies that a small perturbation in the hamiltonian ( e.g. momentum - dependent mass term @xmath103 ) or boundary conditions can have a big effect on presence or absence of the gapless modes ( e.g. @xcite ) . now , for a domain wall such that @xmath104 and @xmath105 , despite the marginal character of @xmath18 on the two sides of the domain wall , their difference is a well - defined topological invariant . that is because at @xmath106 , the @xmath43 in the hamiltonians becomes irrelevant and the textures of the @xmath107 vectors for the two insulators seamlessly connect on the equator of @xmath98 , thereby compactifying the momentum space _ within the same valley_. the connection of the textures is shown schematically in fig . [ fig : topo ] ( c ) . similar considerations are not only valid for blg , but can also be extended to individual valleys in ( gapped ) single layer graphene @xcite , as well as to interfaces between gapped single layer graphene and kane - mele topological insulators with conserved spin @xcite . in these cases , the differences in the single - valley @xmath18 across the interface is a well defined topological invariant , corresponding to number of gapless states present ( or more precisely , the difference between the numbers of left and right moving gapless modes in a given valley ) . mathematically , this is a consequence of the index theorem discussed in this type of contexts by volovik ( see section 22.1.4 in @xcite ) . our work shows that the long wavelength hamiltonians that describe the low - energy electronic states in individual valleys of gapped blg possess non - trivial topological features . in contrast to integer quantum hall systems and quantum spin hall systems ( with conserved spin ) , these non - trivial valley - specific properties can not be described by a topological invariant . rather , they require the analysis of the specific interfaces ( in the present case the blg - vacuum interface and the domain wall ) in order to establish whether a topological invariant that determines the number of gapless edge modes can be defined . this is the characteristic signature of marginal topological insulators . it is certainly the case that the low - energy edge states that can be predicted through these topological considerations are not robust against short - range disorder that couples the valleys ( even though they are stable against long range disorder that scatters electrons within the same valley ) . in the presence of inter - valley scattering , the gapless modes associated to individual valleys will couple , leading to the opening of a transport gap . nevertheless , this does not mean that the low - energy states at interfaces and domain walls are experimentally irrelevant . in fact , for sufficiently pure materials when the fermi energy is in the gap , the states originating from the localization of the gapless modes can provide a dominant path for transport in the insulating state , because no other states are available deep in the bulk gap of the material @xcite . finally , even though all calculations presented here have been performed specifically for gapped blg , our arguments do not rely on the particular form of the valley hamiltonian , or the number of valleys . consequently , similar treatment based on other effective valley hamiltonians should be applicable to many other materials and interfaces , and may provide a convenient tool for determining the interfacial electronic properties . this work has been supported by the swiss national science foundation ( projects 200020 - 121807 , 200021 - 121569 ) , by the swiss center of excellence manep , and the european network nanoctm . the work of i m was carried out under the auspices of the national nuclear security administration of the u.s . department of energy at los alamos national laboratory under contract no . de - ac52 - 06na25396 and supported by the lanl / ldrd program . in this appendix we derive the most general boundary conditions from the continuum model given by or , by imposing current conservation through a hard - wall boundary . we show that the boundary conditions associated to the edge structures considered in the main text are specific realization of the general case . let us start from the original four - component model , for which the current operator is given by @xmath108 where @xmath109 and we have let @xmath110 . without losing generality , we consider a boundary at @xmath65 with unit normal @xmath111 ; then , the current conservation implies @xmath112 we immediately see that the above condition can be naturally satisfied by letting in each layer the wave amplitude on either a or b component vanish at @xmath65 . this leads to four choices of combinations each finding an exact correspondence to the cases listed in fig . [ fig : lattice ] . indeed , the same amount of freedom in choosing " boundary conditions is also inherited by the reduced model , for which , by the same token , the vanishing current across the boundary requires @xmath113 where @xmath114 . noticing that the leading order approximation of eq . yields @xmath115 eq . is nothing but eq . . in other words , the reduced model shares the same choices of boundary conditions as the original one , and the edge modes it allows for may vary accordingly . these derivations indicate that for a generic multi - component hamiltonian , considerable freedom exist in selecting boundary conditions associated to the wave - equation , reflecting different possible structures of the edges . to demonstrate the dependence of the gapless edge modes on boundary conditions , which serves the purpose of the current work , however , the four cases presented in the main text are already sufficient . | we study the correspondence between the non - trivial topological properties associated with the individual valleys of gapped bilayer graphene ( blg ) , as a prototypical multi - valley system , and the gapless modes at its edges and other interfaces . we find that the exact connection between the valley - specific hall conductivity and the number of gapless edge modes does not hold in general , but is dependent on the boundary conditions , even in the absence of intervalley coupling . this non - universality is attributed to the absence of a well - defined topological invariant within a given valley of blg ; yet , a more general topological invariant may be defined in certain cases , which explains the distinction between the blg - vacuum and blg - blg interfaces . |
1105.3427 | -0.3 cm consider a parametric optimization problem of the form : @xmath0 where @xmath1 , @xmath2 is a nonlinear function , @xmath3 is a convex set , the parameter @xmath4 belongs to a given set @xmath5 , and @xmath6 is a given matrix . this paper deals with the efficient calculation of approximate solutions to a sequence of problems of the form [ eq : param_prob ] where the parameter @xmath4 is varying slowly . in other words , for a sequence @xmath7 such that @xmath8 is small , we want to solve problem @xmath9 in an efficient way without requiring too much accuracy in the result . in practice , sequences of problems of the form [ eq : param_prob ] can be solved in the framework of nonlinear model predictive control ( mpc ) . mpc is an optimal control technique which avoids computing an optimal control law in a feedback form , which is often a numerically intractable problem . a popular way of solving the optimization problem to calculate the control sequence is using either interior point methods @xcite or sequential quadratic programming ( sqp ) @xcite . a drawback of using sqp is that this method may require several iterations before convergence and therefore the computation time may be too large for a real - time implementation . a solution to this problem was proposed in @xcite , where the real - time iteration ( rti ) technique was introduced . extensions to the original idea and some theoretical results are reported in @xcite . similar nonlinear mpc algorithms are proposed in @xcite . rti is based on the observation that for several practical applications of nonlinear mpc , the data of two successive optimization problems to be solved in the mpc loop is numerically close . in particular , if we express these optimization problems in the form [ eq : param_prob ] , the parameter @xmath4 usually represents the current state of the system , which , for most applications , does nt change significantly in two successive measurements . the rti technique consists of performing only the first step of the usual sqp algorithm which is initialized using the solution calculated in the previous mpc iteration . 0.1 cm * contribution . * before stating the main contributions of the paper we need to outline the ( full - step ) sequential convex programming ( scp ) algorithm framework applied to problem @xmath10 for a given value @xmath11 of the parameter @xmath4 : 1 . choose a starting point @xmath12 and set @xmath13 . 2 . solve the convex approximation of @xmath9 : @xmath14 to obtain a solution @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is the jacobian matrix of @xmath17 . if the stopping criterion is satisfied then : stop . otherwise , set @xmath18 and go back to step 2 . the real - time sequential convex programming ( rtscp ) method proposed in this paper combines the rti technique and the scp algorithm : instead of solving with scp every @xmath9 to full accuracy , rtscp solves only one convex approximation @xmath19 using as a linearization point @xmath20 , which is the approximate solution of @xmath21 calculated at the previous iteration . therefore , rtscp solves a sequence of convex problems corresponding to the different problems @xmath9 . this method is suitable for the problems that contain a general convex substructure such as nonsmooth convex cost , second order or semidefinte cone constraints which may not be convenient for sqp methods . in this paper we provide a contraction estimate for rtscp which can be interpreted in the following way : if the linearization of the first problem @xmath22 is close enough to the solution of the problem and the quantity @xmath8 is not too big ( which is the case for many problems arising from nonlinear mpc ) , rtscp provides a sequence of good approximations of the sequence of optimal solutions of the problems @xmath9 . as a byproduct of this result , we obtain a new proof of local convergence for the scp algorithm . the paper is organized as follows . section [ se : rtscp ] proposes a description of the rtscp algorithm . section [ se : estimates ] proves the contraction estimate for the rtscp method . the last section shows an application of the rtscp method to nonlinear mpc . -0.3 cm as mentioned in the previous section , scp solves a possibly nonconvex optimization problem by solving a sequence of convex subproblems which approximate the original problem locally . in this section , we combine rti and scp to obtain the rtscp method . the method consists of the following steps : * * initialization . * find an initial value @xmath23 , choose a starting point @xmath12 and compute the information needed at the first iteration such as derivatives , dependent variables , . set @xmath24 . * * iteration . * 1 . solve @xmath25 ( see section [ se : estimates ] ) to obtain a solution @xmath26 . 2 . determine a new parameter @xmath27 , update ( or recompute ) the information needed for the next step . set @xmath28 and go back to step 1 . one of the main tasks of the rtscp method is to solve the convex subproblem @xmath25 at each iteration . this work can be done by either implementing an optimization method which exploits the problem structure or relying on one of the many efficient software tools available nowadays . [ re : init_point ] in the rtscp method , a starting point @xmath29 in @xmath30 is required . it can be any point in @xmath30 . but as we will show later [ theorem 1 ] , if we choose @xmath29 close to the true solution of @xmath22 and @xmath31 is sufficiently small , then the solution @xmath32 of @xmath33 is still close to the true solution of @xmath34 . therefore , in practice , problem @xmath22 can be solved approximately to get a starting point @xmath29 . [ re : sqp ] problem @xmath10 has a linear cost function . however , rtscp can deal directly with the problems where the cost function @xmath35 is convex . if the cost function is quadratic and @xmath30 is a polyhedral set then the rtscp method collapses to the real - time iteration of a gauss - newton method ( see , e.g. @xcite ) . [ re : measure ] in mpc , the parameter @xmath4 is usually the value of the state variables of a dynamic system at the current time @xmath36 . in this case , @xmath4 is measured at each sample time based on the real - world dynamic system ( see example in section [ se : example ] ) . -0.3 cm the kkt conditions of problem [ eq : param_prob ] can be written as @xmath37 where @xmath38 if @xmath39 and @xmath40 if @xmath41 , is the normal cone of @xmath30 at @xmath42 , and @xmath43 is a lagrange multiplier associated with @xmath44 . note that the constraint @xmath39 is implicitly included in the first line of . a pair @xmath45 satisfying is called a kkt point and @xmath46 is called a stationary point of [ eq : param_prob ] . we denote by @xmath47 the set of kkt points at @xmath4 . in the sequel , we use @xmath48 for a pair @xmath49 , @xmath50 is a kkt point of [ eq : param_prob ] at @xmath11 and @xmath51 is a kkt point of [ eq : subprob_x ] ( defined below ) at @xmath52 for @xmath53 . the symbols @xmath54 and @xmath55 stand for the @xmath56-norm and the frobenius norm , respectively . now , let us define @xmath57 and @xmath58 , then the kkt system can be expressed as a parametric _ generalized equation _ @xcite : @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the normal cone of @xmath61 at @xmath48 . let @xmath62 be a solution of @xmath25 at the @xmath63-iteration of rtscp . we consider the following parametric convex subproblem at step 1 of the rtscp algorithm : @xmath64 -0.1 cm if we define @xmath65 then the kkt condition for @xmath66 can also be represented as a parametric generalized equation : @xmath67 where @xmath68 plays a role of parameter . suppose that the slater constraint qualification condition holds for problem [ eq : subprob_x ] , i.e. : @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the set of the relative interior points of @xmath30 . then by convexity of @xmath30 , a point @xmath71 is a kkt point of the subproblem [ eq : subprob_x ] if and only if @xmath72 is a solution of [ eq : subprob_x ] with a corresponding multiplier @xmath73 . for a given kkt point @xmath74 of @xmath9 , we define a set - valued mapping : @xmath75 and @xmath76 for @xmath77 is its inverse mapping . note that @xmath78 is indeed the kkt condition of @xmath79 . for each @xmath53 , we make the following assumptions : * * ( a1 ) * the set of the kkt points @xmath80 is nonempty . * * ( a2 ) * the function @xmath44 is twice continuously differentiable on its domain . * * ( a3 ) * there exist a neighborhood @xmath81 of the origin and a neighborhood @xmath82 of @xmath50 such that for each @xmath83 , @xmath84 is single - valued and lipschitz continuous on @xmath85 with a lipschitz constant @xmath86 . * * ( a4 ) * there exists a constant @xmath87 such that @xmath88 , where @xmath89 . assumptions ( a1 ) and ( a2 ) are standard in optimization , while assumption ( a3 ) is related to the _ strong regularity _ concept introduced by robinson @xcite for the parametric generalized equations of the form . it is important to note that the strong regularity assumption follows from the strong second order sufficient optimality in nonlinear programming when the constraint qualification condition ( licq ) holds @xcite . in this paper , instead of the generalized linear mapping @xmath90 used in @xcite to define strong regularity , in assumption ( a3 ) we use a similar form @xmath91 , where @xmath92 these expressions are different from each other only at the left - top corner @xmath93 , the hessian of the lagrange function . assumption ( a3 ) corresponds to the standard strong regularity assumption ( in the sense of robinson @xcite ) of the subproblem [ eq : subprob_x ] at the point @xmath94 , a kkt point of at @xmath95 . assumption ( a4 ) implies that either the function @xmath44 should be `` weakly nonlinear '' ( small second derivatives ) in a neighborhood of a stationary point or the corresponding langrage multipliers are sufficiently small in this neighborhood . the latter case occurs if the optimal value of [ eq : param_prob ] depends only weakly on perturbations of the nonlinear constraint @xmath96 . [ th : contract ] suppose that assumptions * ( a1)*-*(a4 ) * are satisfied . then there exist neighborhoods @xmath97 of @xmath11 , @xmath98 of @xmath50 and a single - valued function @xmath99 such that for all @xmath100 , @xmath101 is the unique kkt point of @xmath102 in @xmath98 with respect to parameter @xmath52 ( i.e. @xmath103 ) . moreover , for any @xmath104 , @xmath105 we have @xmath106 where @xmath107 , @xmath108 are constant , and @xmath109 is a kkt point of [ eq : subprob_x ] . -0.2 cm the proof is organized in two parts and step by step . the first part proves @xmath110 for all @xmath53 by induction and estimates the norm @xmath111 . the second part proves the inequality . -0.5 cm ( 60 , 40)[fig : proof ] ( 20 , 0)(0 , 1)33 ( 21,32)@xmath112 ( 20 , 0)(1 , 0)50 ( 68 , 2)@xmath4 ( 25 , 5)(35 , 27)(70 , 28 ) ( 25,12.2)(2,3)5 ( 25,0)(0,1)13 ( 30,0)(0,1)20 ( 45,27.5)(6,1)15 ( 46,0)(0,1)28 ( 61,0)(0,1)31 ( 25,12 ) ( 25,5 ) ( 30,20 ) ( 30,13 ) ( 45,23.7 ) ( 45,27.5 ) ( 60,30 ) ( 60,27.5 ) ( 30,20)(1,0.5)16 ( 24,-3)@xmath113 ( 29,-3)@xmath114 ( 44,-3)@xmath11 ( 59,-3)@xmath52 ( 21 , 12)@xmath115 ( 20 , 5)@xmath116 ( 44 , 29)@xmath51 ( 45.3 , 20.5)@xmath50 ( 59 , 31)@xmath109 ( 60.5 , 24.3)@xmath117 ( 18.5,-3)@xmath118 ( 42.0,25.5)(0,0)@xmath119 ( 62.3,28.8)(0,0)@xmath120 ( 45,0)@xmath121 ( 51.5,2.2 ) ( 45,23.5)(1,0)15 ( 58.4,25.3)(0,0)@xmath119 ( 20,20)(0,1)11 ( 20,31)(0,-1)11 ( 19,31)(1,0)2 ( 19,20)(1,0)2 ( 21,25)@xmath98 ( 42,5)(1,0)21 ( 63,5)(-1,0)21 ( 42,0)(0,1)6 ( 63,0)(0,1)6 ( 52,5.8)@xmath97 ( 76,22 ) : @xmath122 ( 76,18 ) : @xmath123 ( 76,14 ) : @xmath124 ( 76,10 ) : @xmath125 0.5 cm * fig . 1*. the approximate sequence @xmath126 along the manifold @xmath127 of the kkt points . 0.2 cm * part 1 : * for @xmath128 , @xmath129 by assumption ( a1 ) . suppose that @xmath130 for @xmath53 , we will show that @xmath131 . we divide the proof into four steps . _ . _ we first provide the following estimations . take any @xmath132 . we define @xmath133 since @xmath134 by ( a4 ) , we can choose @xmath135 sufficiently small such that @xmath136 . by the choice of @xmath137 , we also have @xmath138 . since @xmath44 is twice continuously differentiable , there exist neighborhoods @xmath139 of @xmath11 and @xmath140 of a radius @xmath141 centered at @xmath50 such that : @xmath142 , @xmath143 , @xmath144 , @xmath145 and @xmath146 for all @xmath147 . next , we shrink the neighborhood @xmath97 of @xmath11 , if necessary , such that : @xmath148 -0.1 cm _ . _ for any @xmath149 , we now estimate @xmath150 . from we have @xmath151\\[-1.5ex ] & & = \int_0 ^ 1b(z_t;\bar{x}^k)(z'-z)dt\nonumber , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath152 and @xmath153 using the estimations of @xmath154 and @xmath155 at _ step 1.1 _ , it follows from that @xmath156^{1/2 } \nonumber\\ [ -1.5ex]\\[-1.5ex ] & & \leq \kappa + \sqrt{3}\varepsilon \equiv c_0.\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting into , we get @xmath157 -0.15 cm _ . _ let us define @xmath158 . next , we show that @xmath159 is a contraction self - mapping onto @xmath98 and then show that @xmath160 . indeed , since @xmath142 , applying ( a3 ) and , for any @xmath149 , one has @xmath161 since @xmath162 ( see _ step 1.1 _ ) , we conclude that @xmath159 is a contraction mapping on @xmath98 . moreover , since @xmath163 , it follows from ( a3 ) and that @xmath164 combining the last inequality , and noting that @xmath165 we obtain @xmath166 which proves @xmath167 is a self - mapping onto @xmath98 . consequently , for any @xmath168 , @xmath169 possesses a unique fixed point @xmath170 in @xmath98 by virtue of the _ contraction principle_. this statement is equivalent to @xmath170 is a kkt point of @xmath102 , i.e. @xmath171 . hence , @xmath131 . _ . _ finally , we estimate @xmath172 . from the properties of @xmath167 we have @xmath173 using this inequality with @xmath174 and noting that @xmath175 , we have @xmath176 since @xmath177 , applying again ( a3 ) , it follows from that @xmath178 * part 2 : * let us define the residual from @xmath179 to @xmath180 as : @xmath181 -0.15 cm _ . _ we first provide an estimation for @xmath182 . from we have @xmath183- \left[\varphi(z;\xi_{k+1}\ ! ) - \varphi(\bar{z}^{k}\ ! ; \xi_{k+1})\right ] \notag\\ & & \!\!\ ! - \left[\hat\varphi(z ; x^k , \xi_{k+1 } ) - \varphi(z^k ; \xi_{k+1})\right ] + \left[\varphi(z ; \xi_{k+1 } ) - \varphi(z^k ; \xi_{k+1})\right]\nonumber\\ & & \!\!\!=\int_0 ^ 1b(z^k_t;x^k)(z -z^k)dt - \int_0 ^ 1b(\bar{z}^{k}_t ; \bar{x}^{k})(z-\bar{z}^{k})dt\\ & & \!\!\!=\int_0 ^ 1\!\!\!\!\left[b(z^k_t;x^k)-b(\bar{z}^{k}_t;\bar{x}^{k})\right](z -z^k)dt\!-\ ! \int_0 ^ 1\!\!\ ! b(\bar{z}^{k}_t ; \bar{x}^{k})(z^k-\bar{z}^{k})dt,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath184 , @xmath185 and @xmath186 is defined by . using the definition of @xmath187 and the estimations of @xmath154 and @xmath155 at _ step 1.1 _ , it is easy to show that @xmath188^{1/2}\nonumber\\ [ -1.5ex]\\[-1.5ex ] & & + \left[{\verte_g(\bar{z}^{k}_t\ ! ) \!-\ ! e_g(\bar{z}^{k})\vert}_f^2 \!+\ ! } \leq 2\sqrt{3}\varepsilon.\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] similar to , the quantity @xmath189 is estimated by @xmath190 substituting and into , we obtain an estimation for @xmath191 as @xmath192 -0.15 cm _ . _ we finally prove the inequality . suppose that @xmath109 is a kkt point of [ eq : subprob_x ] , we have @xmath193 . this inclusion implies @xmath194 by the definition of @xmath195 . on the other hand , since @xmath196 , which is equivalent to @xmath197 , applying ( a3 ) we get @xmath198\\[-1.5ex ] & & \leq \gamma{\vert\delta(z^{k+1};x^k , \xi_{k+1})\vert } + \gamma{\vertm(\xi_{k+1}-\xi_k)\vert}.\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] combining this inequality and with @xmath199 to obtain @xmath200 using the triangular inequality , after a simple arrangement , implies @xmath201\\[-1.5ex ] & & + \frac{\gamma}{1 - 2\sqrt{3}\gamma\varepsilon}{\vertm(\xi_{k+1}-\xi_k)\vert}.\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] now , let us define @xmath202 , @xmath203 $ ] . by the choice of @xmath137 at _ step 1.1 _ , we can easily check that @xmath204 and @xmath205 . substituting into and using the definitions of @xmath206 and @xmath207 , we obtain @xmath208 which proves . the theorem is proved . @xmath209 if @xmath210 then the rtscp method collapses to the full - step scp method described in section [ se : intro ] . without loss of generality , we can assume that @xmath211 for all @xmath53 . the following corollary immediately follows from theorem [ th : contract ] . [ co : scp_conver ] -0.2 cm suppose that @xmath212 is the sequence of the kkt points of @xmath213 generated by the scp method described in section [ se : intro ] and that the assumptions of theorem [ th : contract ] hold for @xmath211 . then @xmath214 where @xmath215 is the contraction factor . consequently , this sequence converges linearly to a kkt point @xmath216 of @xmath217 . -0.3 cm in this section we apply rtscp to the control of an underactuated hovercraft . we use the same model as in @xcite , which is characterized by the following differential equations : @xmath218 where @xmath219 is the coordinate of the center of mass of the hovercraft ( see fig . [ fig:1 ] ) ; @xmath220 represents the direction of the hovercraft ; @xmath221 and @xmath222 are the fan thrusts ; @xmath223 and @xmath224 are the mass and moment of inertia of the hovercraft , respectively ; and @xmath225 is the distance between the central axis of the hovercraft and the fans . the problem considered is to drive the hovercraft from its initial position to the final parking position corresponding to the origin of the state space while respecting the constraints @xmath226 to formulate this problem so that we can use the proposed method , we discretize the dynamics of the system using the euler discretization scheme . after introducing a new state variable @xmath227 and a control variable @xmath228 , we can formulate the following optimal control problem : @xmath229 + { \vert\xi_n\vert}_s^2 \\ \text{s.t.}~~~~~~~~ & \xi_0=\bar\xi , \\ & \xi_{n+1 } = \phi(\xi_n , u_n ) \quad \forall n=0,\dots , n-1,\\ & ( \xi_0,\dots,\xi_n , u_0,\dots , u_{n-1 } ) \in \tilde\omega , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath230 represents the discretized dynamics and the constraint set @xmath231 can be easily deduced from . by introducing a slack variable @xmath232 and using the convex constraint : @xmath233 + { \vert\xi_n\vert}_s^2,\ ] ] we can transform into @xmath234 of a variable @xmath235 and the objective function @xmath236 . note that @xmath237 is an online parameter . it plays the role of @xmath11 in the rtscp algorithm along the moving horizon ( see section [ se : rtscp ] ) . we implemented the rtscp algorithm using a primal - dual interior point method for solving the convex subproblem @xmath25 . we performed a simulation using the same data as in @xcite : @xmath238 , @xmath239 , @xmath240 , @xmath241 , @xmath242 , @xmath243 , @xmath244 , @xmath245 , @xmath246 and the initial condition @xmath247 . this research was supported by research council kul : coe ef/05/006 optimization in engineering(optec ) , goa ambiorics , iof - scores4chem , several phd / postdoc & fellow grants ; the flemish government via fwo : phd / postdoc grants , projects g.0452.04 , g.0499.04 , g.0211.05 , g.0226.06 , g.0321.06 , g.0302.07 , g.0320.08 ( convex mpc ) , g.0558.08 ( robust mhe ) , g.0557.08 , g.0588.09 , research communities ( iccos , anmmm , mldm ) and via iwt : phd grants , mcknow - e , eureka - flite+eu : ernsi ; fp7-hd - mpc ( collaborative project strep - grantnr . 223854 ) , contract research : aminal , and helmholtz gemeinschaft : vicerp ; austria : accm , and the belgian federal science policy office : iuap p6/04 ( dysco , dynamical systems , control and optimization , 2007 - 2011 ) . | this paper proposes real - time sequential convex programming ( rtscp ) , a method for solving a sequence of nonlinear optimization problems depending on an online parameter . we provide a contraction estimate for the proposed method and , as a byproduct , a new proof of the local convergence of sequential convex programming . the approach is illustrated by an example where rtscp is applied to nonlinear model predictive control . |
cond-mat0608361 | acoustic vibrational modes in nanoparticles are impulsively excited by a rapid heating of the lattice that takes place after laser excitation@xcite . after initial period of rapid expansion , a nanoparticle undergoes radial contractions and expansions around the new equilibrium . the periodic change in nanoparticle volume translates into a modulation in time of the surface plasmon resonance ( spr ) energy that dominates nanoparticle optical absorption spectrum . the spectrum of vibrational modes manifests itself via coherent oscillations of differential transmission at spr energy measured using ultrafast pump - probe spectroscopy@xcite . since the size of laser spot is usually much larger than nanoparticle diameter , the initial expansion is homogeneous so that predominantly the fundamental ( @xmath0 ) breathing mode , corresponding to oscillations of nanoparticle volume as a whole , is excited . the lowest excited ( @xmath1 ) mode has weaker oscillator strength ( @xmath2 of that for @xmath0 ) and thus is more difficult to observe . when nanoparticle is embedded in a dielectric medium , the oscillations are damped due to the transfer of latice energy to acoustic waves in surrounding dielectric . in solid and bimetallic particles , the size dependences of eigenmodes energy and decay rate are similar both are inversely proportional to nanoparticle radius@xcite . here we study the vibrartional modes of metal nanoshells . these recently manufactured metal particles with dielectric core@xcite attracted much interest due to unique tunability of their optical properties . by varying the shell thickness during the manufacturing process , the spr can be tuned in a wide energy interval @xcite . recent pump - probe measurements of vibrational modes dynamics in gold nanoshells submerged in water revealed characteristic oscillation pattern of differential transmission . however , the oscillations period and amplitude as well as their damping were significantly larger than those for solid nanoparticles . we perform detailed analysis of energy spectrum of lowest vibrational modes of a nanoshell in a dielectric medium . we find that the modes eigenenergies exhibit a strong dependence on nanoshell aspect ratio , @xmath3 , where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are inner and outer radii , respectively . specifically , for thin nanoshells , the fundamental mode energy is consirerably lower than for solid particles while the damping is significantly larger . at the same time , in the thin shell limit , the fundamental mode carries the _ entire _ oscillator strength which results in an enhanced oscillations amplitude as compared to solid particles . the analysis also reveals two regimes , where the spectrum is dominated by nanoslell geometry or by surrounding medium , with a sharp crossover governed by the interplay between aspect ratio and impendance . we consider radial normal modes of a spherical nanoshell with dielectric core extending up to inner radius @xmath4 in a dielectric medium beyond outer radius @xmath5 . the acoustical properties of the system are characterized by the densities @xmath6 and the longitudinal and tranverse sound velocities @xmath7 , where @xmath8 stands for core , shell , amd medium , respectively . the radial displacement @xmath9 is determined from helmholtz equation ( at zero angular momentum ) @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the wave - vector , with the boundary conditions that the displacement @xmath12 and the radial component of stress tensor , @xmath13 , \label{stress}\ ] ] are continuous at the core / shell and shell / medium interfaces . in the three regions divided by shell boundaries , the displacement has the form @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the phase mismatch . the corresponding eigenenergies are , in general , complex due to energy transfer to the outgoing wave in the surrounding medium . after matching @xmath9 and @xmath16 at @xmath17 , we obtain the following equations for eigenvalues @xmath18 @xmath19 where @xmath20 is nanoshell aspect ratio , and the parameters @xmath21 characterize the metal / dielectric interfaces . in the ideal case of a nanoshell in vacuum , described by stress - free boundary conditions at both interfaces , we have @xmath22 and @xmath23 . for a thin nanoshell , @xmath24 , we then easily recover the known expression for the fundamental mode @xcite @xmath25 the eigenvalue is , of course , purely real since no energy leaks through the interface . in the realistic case of a nanoshell in a medium , the role of dielectric core is diminished . the laser pulse causes faster expansion of the metal shell than of dielectric core . indeed , the heating of au lattice is due to the cooling of electron gas that occurs during several ps , while the heating of dielectric core due to heat transfer from metal to dielectric takes place on a longer time scale@xcite . because a larger metal thermal expansion coefficient as compared to that of core dielectric , the shell expands to a greater extent than the dielectric core . as a result , in the new equilibrium , the core and the shell are , in fact , no longer in contact , so the boundary conditions at he core / shell interface should be be taken as stress - free . this can be accomplished by setting @xmath26 . for a thin nanoshell , @xmath27 , eqs . ( [ breathmodes ] ) can be then reduced to @xmath28 . \label{simple}\ ] ] typically , the density of the metal shell is much larger than that of the surrounding dielectric medium , i.e. , the parameter @xmath29 is small . for @xmath30 , using @xmath31 and @xmath32 , we obtain @xmath33 , \label{simple2}\ ] ] where @xmath34 . note that although both @xmath35 and @xmath29 are small , their ratio can be arbitrary . it is now easy to see that there are two regimes governed by the parameter @xmath36 for a very thin nanoshell , @xmath37 , the lowest eigenvalue is given by @xmath38 in this regime , the energy and damping are comptetely determined by the surrounding medium and are independent of nanoshell aspect ratio . note that if the medium transverse sound speed is zero ( e. g. , in water ) , then @xmath39 and both the energy and damping rate vanish . in the second regime , corresponding to @xmath40 , the spectrum can be obtained as @xmath41 , \label{lambda - small}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here the real part , in a good approximation , is given by @xmath42 , and is independent of medium or aspect ratio , while the imaginary part , although small ( @xmath43 ) , depends on both . putting all together , we obtain in this regime @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the shell thickness . thus , for thin nanoshells , the damping rate is determined by the shell thickness rather than the overall size . here we present the results of our numerical calculations of vibrational mode spectrum for au nanoshells in water . the following material parameters were used : longitudinal sound speed in gold @xmath46 m / s , transverse sound speed @xmath47 m / s , the density of gold @xmath48 kg / m@xmath49 ; corresponding values for water are @xmath50 m / s , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 kg / m@xmath49 . in fig . [ fig : spectrum - sym ] we show the energy and damping rate for fundamental ( @xmath0 ) breathing mode versus aspect ratio @xmath53 . after the initial drop by factor of two , the frequency changes weakly for thin nanoshells in the aspect ratio range 0.6 - 0.9 . in the same range , the damping rate increases by factor of four . a sharp change in behavior for very thin nanoshells with @xmath54 indicates the transition to overdamped regime when stored energy is instantly transferred to the surrounding medium . note that for water ( @xmath55 ) both energy and damping rate vanish in the thin shell limit . in contrast , for @xmath1 mode , no such transition takes place , and both energy and damping rate increase with aspect ratio , as shown in fig . [ fig : spectrum - antisym ] . spectrum for fundamental breathing radial mode in gold nanoshell versus its aspect ratio @xmath53 . ( a ) solid line : eigenfrequency versus @xmath53 in the model with free inner boundary and ideal contact between outer shell and matrix . dashed line : eigenfrequency in the model with free boundaries . ( b ) solid line : normalized damping rate versus aspect ratio . , width=240 ] spectrum for @xmath1 radial mode in gold nanoshell versus its aspect ratio @xmath53 . ( a ) eigenfrequency calculated with free inner boundary and ideal contact between outer shell and medium . ( b ) normalized damping rate versus aspect ratio . , width=240 ] oscillator strengths for symmetric ( solid line ) and antisymmetric ( dashed line ) breathing modes of nanoshell versus nanoshell aspect ratio @xmath4/@xmath5 . at @xmath4 = 0 oscillator strength coincide with that for solid nanoparticle . , width=240 ] let as now turn to oscillator strengths of fundamental and excited modes . the radial displacement @xmath56 of a pont parcticle inside the shell from its equilibrium position @xmath57 is given by a general expansion @xmath58 , where @xmath59 is normalized eigenfunction of the mode with frequency @xmath60 . to find coefficients @xmath61 that determine the relative contribution of @xmath62th mode , one has to specify the initial condition . we assume that the laser spot is much larger than the nanoshell overall size so that the intial rapid expansion is homogeneous , @xmath63 . then the expression for the @xmath62th mode oscillator strength has the form @xmath64^{1/2 } } , \label{oscill}\ ] ] where @xmath65 and @xmath66 is the shell volume . in fig . [ fig : oscillator ] , we show calculated oscillator strengths for @xmath0 and @xmath1 modes versus aspect ratio . in contrast to solid particles , where the relative strengths of two modes is constant , @xmath67 , here @xmath68 vanishes in the @xmath69 limit . for @xmath24 , the aspect ratio dependence of @xmath70 can be found analytically as @xmath71 in the @xmath69 limit , @xmath70 reaches it maximal value , @xmath72 , i.e. , the fundamental mode carries the entire oscillator strength . as a result , in nanoshells , excitation of the fundamental mode should results in a greater amplitude of oscillations as compared to solid particles , while the @xmath1 mode should be considerably weaker . | we study the spectrum of vibrational modes in metal nanoparticles with a dielectric core . vibrational modes are excited by the rapid heating of the particle lattice that takes place after laser excitation , and can be monitored by means of pump - probe spectroscopy as coherent oscillations of transient optical spectra . in nanoshells , the presence of two metal surfaces results in a substantially different energy spectrum of acoustic vibrations than for solid particles . we calculated the energy spectrum as well as the damping of nanoshell vibrational modes . the oscillator strength of fundamental breathing mode is larger than that in solid nanoparticles . at the same time , in very thin nanoshells , the fundamental mode is overdamped due to instantaneous energy transfer to the surrounding medium . |
hep-th0308116 | within five - dimensional kaluza - klein theory , negative energy initial data configuration at a moment of time symmetry have been presented in the past @xcite . among the reasons for considering negative energy solutions is that naked singularities are associated to them . therefore studying such solutions is an attractive problem to further test the cosmic censorship conjecture @xcite . additionally , as these bubbles can be obtained via semiclassical tunneling ( following witten s construction @xcite ) , it is important to understand their dynamical behavior . to obtain a better feeling for the dynamics of the solutions presented in @xcite , which describe a bubble spacetime , corley and jacobson @xcite analyzed the initial acceleration of the bubble ( which can be calculated analytically with the information contained on a single hypersurface . ) they found that negative mass bubbles start out expanding and consequently argued a naked singularity would be unlikely . this conjecture is backed by the calculations at the initial hypersurface together with the intuition gained from a time symmetric scenario . namely , that if the bubble were to reverse its behavior it will go through another time - symmetric phase , which would also suggest the bubble should expand ( assuming the solution at this time of symmetry still belongs to the family presented in @xcite ) . recently however , a numerical study was presented @xcite which computed explicitly the solution to the future of the initial , time - symmetric , initial data . in the negative mass case , the solution found appeared to indicate a very puzzling development . namely , that as the bubble expanded , it would encounter a naked singularity on its way . in the present work we reexamine the dynamical behavior of the data presented in @xcite via numerical simulations , and further study a more general case where the initial data describes an initially collapsing bubble with negative mass . we restrict our simulations to the context of homogeneous spherically symmetric spacetimes . to summarize our findings , we see that negative mass bubbles will not lead to a naked singularity . by choosing different members of the initial data family , these could start out either expanding or collapsing . in the former case , the bubble continues on expanding while in the latter case , the bubble bounces back without ever collapsing . we additionally study the case of a positive mass bubble which starts out collapsing . here , depending on the strength of the gauge field at the initial hypersurface , the bubble collapses to a black string or bounces back to expand `` forever '' ( i.e. for as long as we let the simulation run ) . furthermore , these two distinct possibilities give rise to critical behavior on the threshold of collapse or expansion . we consider a generalization of the time symmetric family of initial data presented in @xcite . we start with a spacetime endowed with the metric @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the standard metric on the unit two - sphere @xmath2 and @xmath3 is a smooth function that has a regular root at some @xmath4 , is everywhere positive for @xmath5 and converges to one as @xmath6 . the coordinate @xmath7 parametrizes the extra dimension @xmath8 which has the period @xmath9 . the resulting spacetime @xmath10 constitutes a regular manifold with the topology @xmath11 . the bubble is located where the circumference of the extra dimension shrinks to zero , that is , at @xmath12 . additionally , we consider the presence of a * u(1 ) * gauge field in the following form , @xmath13 with @xmath14 an arbitrary constant and @xmath15 an integer greater than one . it is important to point out two things . first , the gauge field here considered has a more generic dependence than those previously considered in @xcite , where only the case @xmath16 was discussed . second , the symmetries of the problem would a priori allow for the gauge field to have non - trivial @xmath17 and @xmath18 components . however , it follows from maxwell s equations that those contributions would lead to a coulomb - like electric field which is divergent at the location of the bubble . for this reason we set those components of @xmath19 to zero . in the time - symmetric case , initial data satisfying the hamiltonian constraint obeys @xmath20 where @xmath21 . the parameter @xmath22 is related to the adm mass via @xmath23 . the fact that the bubble be located at @xmath12 requires that @xmath24 , where @xmath25 , @xmath26 , @xmath27 . we also require @xmath28 and avoid the conical singularity at @xmath12 by fixing the period of @xmath7 to @xmath9 . repeating the analysis in @xcite one finds that the initial acceleration of the bubble area is given by @xmath29 . \label{eq : ddota}\ ] ] for @xmath16 this agrees with the formula found by corley and jacobson , and as they discussed , for negative mass bubbles , the initial acceleration is positive , and only if chosen appropriately can a positive mass bubble have negative initial acceleration . as we will see later , in the vacuum case , this acceleration remains negative leading to a collapse of the bubble and the formation of a black string . in the non - vacuum case however , the strength of the gauge field can modify this behavior completely . for weak enough @xmath14 the bubble continues to collapse whereas when @xmath14 is large the bubble area bounces back and expands . furthermore , by fine - tuning the parameter @xmath14 we will show that the solution approaches a static bubble solution to the five - dimensional einstein - maxwell equations . we also consider non - vacuum initial data with @xmath30 which allow for richer scenarios . a particularly interesting case is that describing an initially negative acceleration with negative mass . if this were possible , and the bubble continued to collapse , this would likely give rise to a naked singularity . thus , we are interested in data for which @xmath31 . in view of the inequality ( [ eq : reghor ] ) and eq . ( [ eq : ddota ] ) this means that @xmath32 from this we see that for @xmath33 the mass can only be positive . in contrast to this , for @xmath30 and @xmath34 large enough such that @xmath35 , negative mass bubbles can be considered . a detailed description of the numerical techniques used in our code will be presented elsewhere @xcite . here we point out its salient features . 1 . the equations are written in first oder symmetric hyperbolic form , with a gauge choice that is such that the characteristic speeds are given by @xmath36 , @xmath37 or @xmath38 . these properties facilitate achieving a stable implementation of the equations . regularity conditions are enforced at the bubble and employed to design a numerical scheme that satisfies a discrete energy estimate @xcite . this discrete energy estimate guarantees numerical stability for a related toy model problem . constraint preserving boundary conditions are enforced at the outer boundary to ensure no constraint violating modes are fed through it @xcite . the equations are implemented using second order accurate finite difference techniques . a non - uniform radial coordinate is employed to improve the resolution near the bubble . for all cases presented here , the radial grid covered @xmath39 $ ] with a total of @xmath40 points . the outer boundary s location is chosen so as to have _ always _ less than a crossing time in our evolutions , guaranteeing outer boundary conditions ( though consistent with the constraints ) will not affect quantities at the bubble . second order convergence is checked in all runs . as an example , the convergence of some of the simulations representing expanding bubbles is illustrated in fig . [ fig : conv1 ] . similar behavior is observed in all cases . here we evolve the brill - horowitz initial data in the case of vanishing gauge field . the bubble area @xmath42 as a function of the proper time @xmath43 at the bubble is shown in fig . [ fig : area ] for different values of the mass parameter @xmath22 . ( figure [ fig : conv1 ] illustrates the convergence of the solution throughout the evolution ) . as expected , the lower the mass of the initial configuration , the faster the expansion . empirically , and for the parameter ranges used in our runs , we found that at late times the expansion rate is given by @xmath44 where a dot denotes the derivative with respect to proper time @xmath43 . in particular this approximation is valid for the bubble solution exhibited by witten @xcite which describes the time evolution in the case @xmath45 . we monitored several curvature invariant quantities ( the kretschmann invariant in particular ) for our numerical spacetimes and found no sign of divergence . next , we analyze the brill - horowitz initial data for the case in which the bubble is initially collapsing ( notice that for @xmath16 this implies that the adm mass is positive ) . while our numerical simulations reveal that in the absence of the gauge field such a bubble continues to collapse , we also show that when the gauge field is strong enough , the bubble shrinks at a rate which decreases with time and then bounces back . obviously , if the collapse trend were not halted , a singularity should form at the origin . since the adm mass is positive , one expects this singularity to be hidden behind an event horizon , and one should obtain a black string . in fact , for the solutions which are initially collapsing and which have vanishing gauge field , we observe the formation of an apparent horizon . furthermore , we compute the curvature invariant quantity @xmath46 at the apparent horizon ( as discussed in @xcite ) , where @xmath47 is the kretschmann invariant and @xmath48 the areal radius of the horizon . for a neutral black string , this invariant is @xmath49 . figure [ fig : blackstring ] shows how this value is attained after the apparent horizon forms for representative vacuum cases ( with @xmath50 and @xmath51 ) , thus providing strong evidence for the formation of a black string . ( we also find apparent horizons forming , or already present in the initial data , when a nontrivial gauge field is considered and the parameters are appropriately chosen . the corresponding bubbles will likely collapse to charged black strings and will be analyzed elsewhere @xcite . ) + + as mentioned , for strong enough gauge fields , the previously described dynamics is severely affected . figure [ fig : criticalonset ] shows the bubble area vs. proper time for different values of @xmath14 . for large values of @xmath14 the bubble `` bounces '' back and expands while for small ones the bubble collapses . there is a natural transition region separating these two possibilities . tuning the value of @xmath14 one can reveal an associated critical phenomena , the ` critical solution ' being a member of the family of static solutions given by @xmath52 where @xmath53 and @xmath54 . these solutions can be obtained by a double analytic expansion of the black hole solutions described by eqs . ( 2.13 ) and ( 2.15 ) of ref . @xcite followed by the transformations @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 . the parameters @xmath58 and @xmath59 @xmath60 are related to the period of the @xmath7 coordinate and to the adm mass via @xmath61 and @xmath62 . since these parameters are conserved throughout evolution , the initial data fixes the member of the static family the dynamical solution approaches to . details of the critical behavior exhibited by this system will be presented in @xcite . + + we here restrict to cases with negative masses that start out collapsing . interestingly enough we find that even when starting with large initial negative accelerations , which in turn make the bubble shrink in size to very tiny values , it bounces back without ever collapsing into a naked singularity . as an example , fig . [ fig : notnakediii ] shows the bubble s area versus time for different values of @xmath15 and @xmath14 . the initially collapsing bubbles decrease in size in a noticeable way but this trend is halted and the bubbles bounce back and expand . although we have not found a simple law as that in eq . ( [ simplerelation ] ) , clearly the bubbles expand exponentially fast . therefore , it seems not to be possible to `` destroy '' the bubble and create a naked singularity . this situation is somewhat similar to the scenarios where one tries to `` destroy '' an extremal reissner - nordstrm black hole by attempting to drop into it a test particle with high charge to mass ratio . there , the electrostatic repulsion prevents the particle from entering the hole @xcite . we have performed numerical simulations to investigate the dynamics of spherically symmetric , homogeneous bubble spacetimes . these have revealed several interesting features . in the vacuum case , negative mass bubbles do not form singularities , rather they continue on expanding and the asymptotic rate of expansion obeys the simple relation ( [ simplerelation ] ) . positive mass cases , as pointed out previously can start out either expanding or contracting . in the former case , they continue on expanding and its asymptotic rate obeys the same simple relation . for the collapsing case we have evidences that the bubble will collapse to a black string . it is interesting to note here that the ratio of a circle at infinity over the adm mass is given by @xmath63 since @xmath64 this value is always larger than that needed for the gregory - laflamme `` instability''@xcite . thus , a slight @xmath7-dependent perturbation of the scenario considered here could indeed give rise to a naked singularity . this would require infinite time to appear as shown in @xcite , but certainly would give rise to rich dynamics as illustrated in @xcite . in the non - vacuum case , the presence of a gauge field gives rise to additional features . first , for the positive mass case , it can `` halt '' the collapse and subsequently induce an expansion . furthermore , by fine - tuning the strength of the field , the solution approaches a static bubble . this critical solution separates the collapsing bubbles ( which , likely , collapse to a charged black string ) from the one that expand at late times . in a subsequent paper @xcite we will show that the dynamical behavior near the static bubble exhibits critical phenomena . note that clearly the solution does encounter another moment of time symmetry at the critical value . however , for field strengths larger than the critical one , this is not the case . the bubble bounces but the solution does not go through a time - symmetric phase . last , the gauge field can also make _ negative _ mass bubbles start out collapsing if its radial dependence is steeper than that originally considered in @xcite . intuitively this happens due to the contribution of the energy in the gauge field overcoming the repulsive gravitational effect of the negative mass bubble . however , as part of the field is radiated away , the collapse is halted and a subsequent expansion results . by choosing both the strength of the field or its radial dependence appropriately ( with @xmath65 ) , we could make the bubble start out collapsing at a very rapid rate . in these cases , the bubble shrinks to very small sizes but eventually bounces back without forming a naked singularity . we thank robert myers for calling this problem to our attention and for pointing out the influence a steeper radial dependence in the gauge field could have . additionally , we thank him and gary horowitz for many interesting discussions . we acknowlege the lsu gravity group for comments on the manuscript . we benefited from the hospitality of the kavli institute for theoretical physics . l.l . thanks the perimeter institute for theoretical physics for hospitality . this research was supported in part by the nsf under grant numbers nsf - phy0244335 to louisiana state university , phy99 - 07949 to the university of california at santa barbara and by the horace hearne institute for theoretical physics . l.l . has been partially supported by the alfred p. sloan foundation . g. calabrese , l. lehner , d. neilsen , j. pullin , o. reula , o. sarbach and m. tiglio , _ novel finite - differencing techniques for numerical relativity : application to black hole excision " _ , gr - qc/0302072 , to appear in _ class . quantum grav_. g. calabrese , j. pullin , o. reula , o. sarbach , and m. tiglio , `` well posed constraint - preserving boundary conditions for the linearized einstein equations '' , gr - qc/0209017 , to appear in comm . | we study the evolution of bubble spacetimes in vacuum and electrovac scenarios by numerical means . we find strong evidence against the formation of naked singularities in ( i ) scenarios with negative masses displaying initially collapsing conditions and ( ii ) scenarios with negative masses displaying initially expanding conditions , previously reported to give rise to such singularities . additionally , we show that the presence of strong gauge fields implies that an initially collapsing bubble bounces back and expands . by fine - tuning the strength of the gauge field we find that the solution approaches a static bubble solution . |
astro-ph0005161 | the starting point lies with the narrow absorption lines ( nals)/x - ray warm absorbers in the well - studied seyfert 1 galaxy ngc 5548 . accepting for a moment the identity of the uv and x - ray absorbers , then the absorber must lie @xmath010@xmath1 cm from the continuum source , but is only @xmath010@xmath2 cm thick ; i.e. a thin shell . ( this is also needed to have a single ionization state fit the data . ) this shell has an outward velocity of 1200 km s@xmath3 ( figure 1 ) , yet in 20 years has not changed its ionization state . ( being a trace ion , n(civ ) should have increased by a factor 100 , unless density changes precisely matched the declining ionizing continuum , yet the civ ew has been constant . ) mathur , elvis & wilkes ( 1995 ) explained this constancy by invoking a flow of absorbing material across our line of sight to the continuum . so the structure remained constant , although the particular gas atoms changed . a flow across the line of sight implies a conical structure ( figure 1c ) , so from some directions no absorbers will be seen . a cone angle of 60@xmath4 divides the solid angle equally , and could explain why half of seyfert galaxies have ionized absorbers and half do not ( figures 3a , b ) . there is a third viewing direction : directly down the flow . this too will show a highly ionized absorber , but with much larger column density and higher velocity . recent work on broad absorption line ( bal ) quasars suggests that they have such conditions ( e.g. mathur , elvis & singh 1996 ; hamman 1998 ) . if the flow opens at a half angle of 6@xmath4 then 10% of agn will be seen as bal quasars , as observed . this is appealing since both warm absorber outflows ( see above ) and bals are likely present in all quasars ( to explain , among other reasons , the strong continuum polarization in bal troughs , ogle 1998 ) . however the velocities in bals are @xmath010 times those of the nals . the simplest modification to figure 1 that accomodates this is to bend the flow ( figure 2 , figure 3a ) . at first glance this geometry appears unlikely ; however , it can arise quite naturally . symmetry requires that a disk wind will first rise vertically . once exposed to radiation pressure from the continuum source the flow will begin to bend outward , giving the @xmath01000 km s@xmath3 nal outflow velocity , and will become radial when @xmath5 . the ` detachment velocities ' of bals measure this critical velocity to be 0 - 5000 km s@xmath3 , so @xmath6 , the disk orbital velocity at the wind ejection point . conditions in the ` warm ' absorber are likely to be high density ( @xmath710@xmath8@xmath9 ) , and truly warm ( @xmath010@xmath10k , nicastro et al . , 1999 , 2000 ) , hence the name ` warm highly ionized medium ' ( whim ) . the whim pressure is comparable with that in broad emission - line clouds . the geometry removes the objection that a belr confining medium would be compton thick , while the bulk co - outflowing of both whim and belr means that the belr clouds will not be destroyed by shear forces . in addition : @xmath11 and @xmath12 , about 10@xmath1 cm in ngc 5548 . the cylinder / cone geometry of the wind naturally divides the belr into a high ionization ( cylindrical ) region , and a low ionization ( conical ) region shielded from x - rays by the whim . along the flow ( in the bal direction ) the whim is compton thick . scattering from the rear of the flow ( figure 3c ) produces the polarized continuum in bals ( ogle 1998 ) . compton thick scatterers are also needed to make : ` polarized bel ' seyfert 2s ( e.g. ngc 1068 ) ; uv continuum polarization below ly@xmath13 ( beloborodov & poutanen 1999 ) ; and the x - ray reflection features , the ` compton hump ' and fluorescent fe - k line . could these could arise from the whim ? the uv continuum polarization needs semi - relativistic outflow , which the conical bal part of the wind has . the ` polarized bel ' might work if there is dust in the outer part of the wind . ( if this happens only in low luminosity agn , then the missing ` quasar 2s ' are the bal quasars . ) however hst has resolved some of the ` mirrors ' in seyfert 2s on @xmath010 parsec scales , too large to be the whim . the whim will necessarily produce x - ray features , proportional to the whim covering factor of 10% 30% , i.e. almost half the observed fe - k line strength . the whim fe - k component can not vary on timescales @xmath14 weeks . high luminosity quasars differ from the lower luminosity agn in several features . changes in the outflow opening angle and the height of the cylindrical region , e.g. from increased radiation or cosmic ray pressure at high luminosities , may explain : the lower civ ew ( baldwin effect ) , the rarity of nals , and the weakness of x - ray scattering features in high luminosity quasars . the need for an ` obscuring torus ' is weaker in this model : ( 1 ) the seyfert 2s with polarized bels could be viewed through a dusty bal ; ( 2 ) the conical shell outflow could itself produce the bi - cone structures , which would then be hollow , matter bounded , cones rather than filled , ionization bounded , structures ; ( 3 ) the more common ` no polarized bel ' seyfert 2s could be made in several ways ( lawrence & elvis 1982 ) . the complete structure proposed here and in elvis ( 2000 ) is shown in figure 4 . this ambitious proposal draws together a number of previously disparate areas of quasar research into a single simple scheme . the broad and narrow absorption line ( bal , nal ) regions , the high and low ionization broad emission line regions ( belr ) , and at least some of the five compton thick scattering regions can all be combined into the single funnel - shaped outflow , while on large scales this outflow could produce the bi - conical narrow emission line regions . this unification gives the model a certain appeal . | we propose a simple unifying structure for the inner regions of quasars and agn . this empirically derived model links together the bals , the narrow uv / x - ray ionized absorbers , the belr , and the compton scattering / fluorescing regions into a single structure . the model also suggests an origin for the large - scale bi - conical outflows . some other potential implications of this structure are discussed . galaxies : active ; quasars : general ; quasars : absorption lines |
1209.1310 | [ [ general - context . ] ] general context . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + linear boundary problems are a crucial concern of applied mathematics @xcite . one might thus expect a rich _ algebraic theory _ with _ symbolic algorithms _ , so as to support the exact solution and manipulation of a suitable class of boundary problems . alas , this is not the case yet . there may be two reasons for this . one is that the classical algebraic theory of ( nonlinear ) differential equations , the _ differential algebra _ built up by ritt @xcite and kolchin @xcite , does not lend itself easily to boundary conditions : the elements of a differential ring or field are not functions but abstract objects that can not be evaluated at a boundary point . the other reason is of a pragmatic nature . if a differential equation can be solved at all , one tends to delegate boundary conditions to _ adhoc postprocessing _ steps that would adapt the integration constants / functions of the `` general solution '' . while this may be viable for linear ordinary differential equations ( lodes ) , the notion of general solution is much less useful in the case of partial differential equations ( lpdes ) : for example , there is not much point in solving the @xmath0 per se , but there are useful representations of those solutions that satisfy dirichlet boundary conditions on the unit disc ( poisson kernel ) . so even though we will be dealing only with lodes in this paper , the larger context of lpdes should be kept in mind . in the admittedly modest case of _ boundary problems for lodes _ , an algebraic theory was set up in @xcite . the decisive step was to expand the well - known structure of a differential ring , complementing its derivation by a compatible baxter operator ( integral operator ) . this solves at once two problems : it provides the algebraic structure needed for expressing green s operators ( solution operators for boundary problems ) , and it yields an evaluation ( a multiplicative functional ) . the notion of evaluation is the key for imposing boundary conditions on the otherwise abstract objects of a differential ring ; one supplies as many evaluation as needed ( in addition to the one coming from the baxter operator ) . in @xcite , the basic theory of @xcite was refined and generalized . moreover , the authors have introduced a multiplicative structure on boundary problems that will also be crucial for our buildup of the heaviside calculus . the multiplication of boundary problems corresponds to the composition of their green s operators in reverse order ; see equation . the framework of boundary problems of @xcite was _ implemented _ several times : the first implementation was coded in mathematica / th@xmath1orem@xmath2 as an external package for boundary problems with constant coefficients . this version was superseded by a new implementation as an internal th@xmath1orem@xmath2 functor for generic integro - differential algebras in @xcite . now in the third generation , the most recent implementation is the maple package _ intdiffop _ @xcite , which provides additional support for singular boundary problems ( all previous packages being restricted to regular boundary problems ) . [ [ heaviside - calculus . ] ] heaviside calculus . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + our main concern in this paper is to build a bridge from the framework of symbolic boundary problems to the classical heaviside calculus @xcite . since o. heaviside s main idea , subsequently made rigorous by j. mikusiski , was to treat the differential operator as a _ symbolic multiplier _ , it is perhaps natural to reflect on possible connections to contemporary symbolic methods for differential equations . but why to symbolic boundary problems ? the answer lies in heaviside s so - called _ fundamental formula _ , the algebraic analog of a well - known relation for the laplace transform . if @xmath3 is the `` symbolic multiplier '' representing the differential operator and @xmath4 is a suitable function , then one has @xmath5 . the point is that @xmath3 , which is supposed to be invertible in this calculus , must somehow `` remember '' the integration constant that is lost in differentiation . we will come back to this point in more detail ( section [ sec : methorious - functions ] ) . at this point it suffices to say that an appropriate action of @xmath3 on functions involves an evaluation operator . it is used in the heaviside - mikusinski calculus for incorporating the initial values associated to a differential equation , thus yielding at once the solution of the whole initial value problem . it is thus natural staying in the frame of lodes to ask if one can build up a more general calculus that would allow to incorporate multiple boundary values , given by several evaluation operators . the basic ideas of heaviside and mikusiski have been vastly extended , specifically by l. berg @xcite and i. dimovski @xcite . the latter has also broached a question closely related to the one raised above , namely the setup of _ nonlocal convolutions _ @xcite and _ custom - tailored convolutions _ for boundary problems @xcite . as far as we know , however , there are no direct generalizations of the fundamental formula from one to more evaluation operators acting on univariate functions . [ [ basic - setup . ] ] basic setup . + + + + + + + + + + + + our own approach is different in many respects . it does not qualify as an _ operational calculus _ in dimovski s understanding @xcite , for whom its crucial feature is that `` operators '' and `` operands '' are merged in a single data structure , whereas algebraic analysis keeps the module of operand functions separate from the ring of operators . in this sense , we follow the line of algebraic analysis since we distinguish the ring of methorious operators ( section [ sec : localization ] ) from the module of methorious functions ( section [ sec : methorious - functions ] ) . moreover , our approach is genuinly algebraic while the hallmark of the heaviside - mikusiski tradition is an ingenious mix of algebra and analysis . nevertheless , we believe that our setup is close in spirit to the original heaviside - mikusiski setup , enjoying the following attractive features : * its _ basic philosophy _ follows closely in heaviside s footsteps , making the differential operator invertible by `` remembering '' suitable boundary data . * it provides an algebraic structure that accommodates boundary problems for an _ arbitrary number of evaluation points _ as well as _ nonlocal conditions_. * all boundary problems are covered _ uniformly _ , so one need not set up custom - tailored multiplications ( convolutions ) for each type of boundary conditions one wants to consider . * it illuminates the passage from one to several evaluations algebraically : localization takes place in a _ noncommutative ring_. in contrast , convolution algebras are commutative by definition @xcite . * the construction is _ generic in the coefficient algebra _ ( it works for the class of umbral integro - differential algebras ) . from the viewpoint of analysis , however , the class of umbral coefficient algebras is rather limited compared to mikusiski s setup ( continuous or even @xmath6 functions on the positive half - axis ) . while this might be relaxed by suitable limit considerations , this is not in the interest of the present paper , where we want to focus on the algebraic aspects . our goal in this paper is to build a _ first bridge _ between the algebraic theory of boundary problems @xcite and heaviside s tactic of using `` symbolic fractions '' ( localization in a suitable convolution ring ) for integrating differential equations with initial / boundary data . in fact , it gives a new justification ( see after proposition [ prop : greensop - localization ] ) for a notational device initiated in @xcite : since then we have written @xmath7 for the green s operator associated to a boundary problem @xmath8 , originally chosen in view of the anti - isomorphism mentioned above . the work in this paper may also be seen as an answer to an ( implicit ) question originating from @xcite . the setting there was restricted to @xmath9 $ ] coefficients and treated via ore algebras . the object of central interest was the _ integro - differential weyl algebra _ , which has shown to have two important quotient algebras : the ring of localized differential operators @xmath10[x]$ ] and the usual ring of integro - differential operators @xmath9[{\partial } , { { \textstyle \varint}}]$ ] . the former has @xmath11 as a two - sided inverse , but no action on @xmath9 $ ] ; the latter has the action , but @xmath12 is only a right inverse of @xmath11 . now the question arises : can one build up a structure , with an action on @xmath9 $ ] or other coefficient algebras , such that the derivation has a two - sided inverse ? we show in this paper that the answer is affirmative , provided the derivation is enhanced in a way similar to heaviside s symbolic multiplier @xmath3 . as always in algebra , localizing a ring sheds new light on its structure , especially in the noncommutative setting ( here the theory of fraction rings is somewhat more delicate due to the ore condition , see section [ sec : localization ] ) . we hope this will also be the case for our present construction . but one must bear in mind that the subject has only been touched and various issues remain in a preliminary and unsatisfactory state ( see the conclusion ) . nevertheless , a wealth of new relations has been uncovered , and we are confident that they will allow interesting generalizations and refinements . [ [ structure - of - the - paper . ] ] structure of the paper . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we start out by summarizing the basic theory of symbolic boundary problems , giving special emphasis to their monoid structure ( section [ sec : monoid - bp ] ) . our construction is based on a certain kind of boundary conditions , which we have called `` umbral '' because of certain relations to the umbral calculus ( section [ sec : umbral - bc ] ) . after this preparation , we tackle the task of localization for an integro - differential algebra with an umbral character set ( section [ sec : localization ] ) . for the resulting ring of fractions , we construct a module of functions on which it acts naturally ( section [ sec : methorious - functions ] ) . we conclude with some remarks about possible extensions and generalizations ( section [ sec : conclusion ] ) . [ [ notation . ] ] notation . + + + + + + + + + all rings are with unit but not necessarily commutative . a domain is a ( commutative or noncommutative ) ring without zero divisors . the zero vector space of any dimension will be denoted by @xmath13 . we use the notation @xmath14 for indicating that a vector space @xmath15 is a subspace of a vector space @xmath16 . our basic setting is that of @xcite . we review the main results here for making our present treatment more self - contained and for introducing various pieces of notation and terminology in their proper places . we start from the notion of _ integro - differential algebra _ , a natural generalization of differential algebras that permits the algebraic formulation of linear boundary problems . [ def : intdiffalg ] we call @xmath17 an _ integro - differential algebra _ over @xmath18 if @xmath19 is a commutative @xmath18-algebra with @xmath18-linear operations @xmath11 and @xmath12 such that the three axioms @xmath20 are satisfied , where @xmath21 is the usual shorthand notation for @xmath11 . this definition differs from definition 4 in @xcite as it uses as the _ differential baxter axiom _ rather than the variant @xmath22 used earlier . in fact , one checks immediately that for commutative @xmath19 both axioms are equivalent ( assuming the other axioms ) . the advantage of is that it is more symmetric and that it also sufficient for the noncommutative case , where must be supplemented by the corresponding dual axiom . nevertheless , _ we will from now on tacitly assume that all integro - differential algebras are commutative , as in @xcite . _ incidentally we note the following _ convention on precedence _ : the scope of an integral sign @xmath12 covers all factors to its right , unless otherwise specified . therefore the above term @xmath23 is to be parsed as @xmath24 . this helps avoiding the proliferation of parentheses in nested integrals . the differential baxter axiom is in general stronger than the following _ pure baxter axiom _ @xmath25 which is the defining axiom for the so - called rota - baxter algebras @xcite . ( in fact , one may relax the conditions on @xmath19 to include noncommutative algebras over arbitrary commutative rings with one . moreover , one may add a so - called weight term for incorporating the discrete setting where @xmath12 is , for example , the operator of partial summation . in that case , one must of course also adapt to account for the weight . remarkably , the differential baxter axiom is the same with or without weight . ) every integro - differential algebra comes with a multiplicative projector , namely the _ evaluation _ @xmath26 . in fact , the strong baxter axiom is equivalent to the weak one combined with the multiplicativity of @xmath27 . the presence of the character @xmath27 leads to the direct sum decomposition @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the usual _ ring of constants _ while @xmath30 is called the _ ideal of initialized functions _ ( one checks immediately that the multiplicativity of @xmath27 is equivalent to @xmath31 being an ideal ) . so @xmath27 is the projector onto @xmath32 along @xmath31 . moreover , both @xmath11 and @xmath12 are @xmath32-linear rather than just @xmath18-linear ( for @xmath11 this is of course trivial , but for @xmath12 this is again equivalent to the multiplicativity of @xmath27 ) . in this paper , we want to restrict ourselves to boundary problems for lodes . for reflecting this property in the ( integro ) differential structure , in @xcite we have called a differential algebra @xmath33 ordinary if @xmath34 . _ we will henceforth assume that all integro - differential algebras are ordinary in this sense . _ restricting ourselves to ordinary integro - differential algebras has a number of pleasant implications . first of all , the evaluation is now a multiplicative linear operator @xmath35 , meaning a _ character _ ( in the sense `` multiplicative linear functional on an algebra '' ) . another consequencence , which will be of some importance later , is that the polynomials behave as usual . for any integro - differential algebra @xmath19 , we set @xmath36 . now the pure baxer axiom ensures that @xmath37 , and so on . it turns out that the elements of @xmath9 $ ] are `` really '' polynomials , and they satisfy the usual differential equations ( see before eq . ( 6 ) and also eq . ( 8) in @xcite for more details ) . [ prop : pol - ring ] let @xmath19 be an integro - differential algebra over @xmath18 , and let @xmath9 $ ] be the subalgebra generated by @xmath38 . then @xmath9 $ ] is isomorphic to the univariate polynomial ring over @xmath18 . if @xmath19 is an ordinary integro - differential algebra , we have moreover @xmath39,\ ] ] and @xmath9 \le { \mathcal{f}}$ ] is an integro - differential subalgebra . [ ex : standard ] the _ standard example _ of an ( ordinary ) integro - differential algebra is @xmath40 with @xmath41 in the usual sense and @xmath42 . this integro - differential algebra contains many important integro - differential subalgebras , for example the analytic functions @xmath43 , the exponential polynomials , and of course the polynomial ring @xmath44 $ ] . an important integro - differential subalgebra of @xmath43 is formed by the holonomic power series @xcite . given a differential algebra @xmath33 , one may form the ring of differential operators @xmath45}$ ] . it is therefore natural to expect a similar ring of _ integro - differential operators _ @xmath46}$ ] , which contains differential operators ( needed for specifying differential equations ) as well as integral operators ( needed for specifying green s operators ) . the evaluation @xmath27 can be used for writing a condition like @xmath47 in the form @xmath48 . but for boundary problems one usually needs more than one evaluation ( see example [ ex : second - order ] below ) . for algebraizing general boundary conditions , we start from a _ character set _ @xmath49 , meaning each @xmath50 is a multiplicative linear functional just as @xmath27 is . in fact , we will always assume @xmath51 . based on the characters of @xmath49 , we can from arbitrary _ stieltjes conditions _ ( * ? ? ? 14 ) ; their normal form is @xmath52 with @xmath53 and @xmath54 almost all zero . the summands with @xmath12 make up the so - called global part , those without the local part . the _ order _ of a boundary condition is the largest @xmath55 such that @xmath56 in the normal form . in the standard setting of example [ ex : standard ] , a typical stieltjes condition like @xmath57 is encoded as @xmath58 with @xmath59 , where we have written @xmath60 for the standard character @xmath61 . henceforth we shall always consider example [ ex : standard ] with the character set @xmath62 . for each character set @xmath49 one may then build up the corresponding _ operator ring _ @xmath63}$ ] . the details are given in @xcite ; at this point it suffices to note that the operator ring is given by the quotient of a free algebra modulo a certain ideal of relations like the leibniz rule , and also as well as . the resulting operator ring decomposes nicely into a direct sum ; see ( * ? ? ? 17 ) for a proof . [ prop : intdiffop - direct - sum ] for any integro - differential algebra @xmath17 and character set @xmath49 , we have the decomposition @xmath63 } = { { \mathcal{f}}[{\partial}]}{\dotplus}{{\mathcal{f}}[{{\textstyle \varint}}]}{\dotplus}(\phi)$ ] . here @xmath64 is the two - sided ideal generated by @xmath49 in the operator ring @xmath65}$ ] . we refer to its elements as _ boundary operators _ since they may also be described in terms of stieltjes conditions : one checks first that the collection of stieltjes conditions can be characterized as the right ideal @xmath66 . it turns out that @xmath64 is then the left @xmath19-module generated by @xmath67 , so every boundary operator can be written as @xmath68 for some functions @xmath69 and stieljes conditions @xmath70 . in particular , every stieltjes condition is also a boundary operator . the decomposition @xmath63 } = { { \mathcal{f}}[{\partial}]}{\dotplus}{{\mathcal{f}}[{{\textstyle \varint}}]}{\dotplus}(\phi)$ ] reflects the basic needs for an _ algebraic formulation of boundary problems _ : we need @xmath45}$ ] for the differential equation , @xmath64 for the boundary conditions , and @xmath71}$ ] for the solution ( green s operators ) . let us see how these ingredients look like for the simplest possible boundary problem in the standard setting of example [ ex : standard ] . [ ex : second - order ] the boundary problem @xmath72 can be encoded in the standard setting @xmath40 by the differential operator @xmath73}$ ] and the boundary conditions @xmath74 . here we can choose @xmath75 or any character set containing that . the green s operator can be written as @xmath76}$ ] , where we use the standard abbreviations @xmath77 and @xmath78 . note that @xmath79 is the integral from @xmath80 to @xmath81 , and @xmath82 the integral from @xmath81 to @xmath83 . in the @xmath6 setting , @xmath79 and @xmath82 are adjoint operators . the algebraic description in terms of the two functionals @xmath84 and @xmath85 contains some arbitrariness since we can clearly form any linear combination of the two functionals without changing the solution operator @xmath86 . in general , a _ boundary space _ is a finite - dimensional subspace of @xmath87 generated by stieltjes conditions . so the boundary space of example [ ex : second - order ] is @xmath88 $ ] . the lattice of all boundary spaces will be denoted by @xmath89 . we will usually restrict the coefficient functions of the differential operators to a differential subalgebra @xmath90 so as to ensure solutions in the ambient algebra @xmath19 . this means we require that @xmath91 be _ saturated _ for @xmath19 in the sense of ( * ? ? ? _ whenever an integro - differential algebra @xmath17 is specified , it is understood that a saturated coefficient algebra @xmath91 is set aside . _ [ def : boundary - problem ] a _ boundary problem _ is a pair @xmath92 consisting of a monic differential operator @xmath93 $ ] and a boundary space @xmath94 . so the boundary problem in example [ ex : second - order ] is given by @xmath95)$ ] . conversely , we can think of a boundary problem @xmath92 as finding a solution @xmath96 such that @xmath97 for an arbitrary forcing function @xmath98 . of course it suffices that @xmath99 ranges over any @xmath18-basis of @xmath100 ; this is how the boundary conditions are normally given in the first place . the _ traditional formulation _ in terms of @xmath101 and @xmath4 is more intuitive , but it conceals the fact that we are really working in the operator ring @xmath63}$ ] . clearly every differential operator @xmath102 has a certain order written as @xmath103 , which as in example [ ex : second - order ] usually coincides with the number of given boundary conditions ( the dimension of @xmath100 ) . in fact , this a necessary but in general not sufficient condition for the boundary problem to be _ regular _ in the sense that there is a unique solution @xmath96 for every given forcing function @xmath98 . in turns out that this is equivalent to the following formulation in terms of the relevant spaces . [ def : regular - bp ] a boundary problem @xmath92 is called _ regular _ if @xmath104 , and _ singular _ otherwise . here we have written @xmath105 for the _ orthogonal _ , meaning the space of all @xmath98 such that @xmath106 for all @xmath107 . in other words , @xmath105 is the space of admissible functions : those that satisfy the given boundary conditions . the orthogonal , together with the analogous notion @xmath108 for subspaces @xmath109 , establishes a galois connection between @xmath19 and its dual @xmath87 . this is similar to the situation in algebraic geometry with its galois connection between affine varieties and radical ideals . see @xcite for more details . the above definition of regularity is not suitable for algorithmic purposes . however , it turns out to be equivalent to the following explicit _ regularity test _ 6.1 ) , which is well - known in the special case of local boundary conditions @xcite . [ lem : regularity - test ] let @xmath92 be a boundary problem over @xmath19 and choose bases @xmath110 for @xmath100 and @xmath111 for @xmath112 . then @xmath92 is regular iff @xmath113 and the _ evaluation matrix _ @xmath114 \in k^{n \times n}$ ] is regular . regular boundary problems are exactly those that have a _ green s operator _ in the classical sense ( see @xcite on generalized green s operators for singular boundary problems ) . in our algebraic setting , green s operators can be defined within the operator ring @xmath63}$ ] . [ def : greens - operator ] let @xmath92 be a regular boundary problem over an integro - differential algebra @xmath19 . then @xmath115}$ ] is called its _ green s operator _ if @xmath116 and @xmath117 . the two conditions for green s operators are just that @xmath118 satisfies the differential equation @xmath119 as well as all boundary conditions @xmath58 for @xmath120 . since we have assumed a coefficient algebra @xmath91 saturated for @xmath19 , one can prove ( * ? ? ? 26 ) that _ every regular boundary problem _ has a green s operator in @xmath63}$ ] . in a leap of faith , we write @xmath121 just as in @xcite . the relation to actual inverses will become clear in proposition [ prop : greensop - localization ] . apart from the localization , there is another good reason for the notation @xmath122 . it turns out that boundary problems can be multiplied in such a way that @xmath123 is satisfied . for that purpose , we have defined the multiplication of boundary problems in the fashion of a semi - direct product by @xmath124 it is easy to check that one obtains a _ monoid _ @xmath125 \ltimes k\phi}$ ] in this way , with @xmath126 as the neutral element . furthermore , it turns out that the regular boundary problems form a submonoid @xmath125_{\phi}}\subset { { \mathcal{e}}[{\partial } ] \ltimes k\phi}$ ] , and means that @xmath127 is an anti - isomorphism from @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] to the multiplicative monoid of green s operators . for a proof of these facts , we refer to ( * ? ? ? the monoid algebra @xmath128_{\phi}}$ ] will be called the _ ring of boundary problems _ ( we suppress the qualification `` regular '' since we will not investigate the singular case in the frame of this paper ) . its elements will supply the numerators in the localization to be constructed below ( section [ sec : localization ] ) . at this point we should also note that a regular boundary problem @xmath129 need not be _ well - posed _ in the sense that its green s operator @xmath86 is continuous in the standard setting of example [ ex : standard ] . for example , consider the regular boundary problem @xmath130 or @xmath131 in traditional notation . one checks immediately that @xmath132}$ ] is its green s operator , meaning the general solution is given by @xmath133 clearly , this green s operator @xmath86 is not continuous , at least not if one endows @xmath134 with the usual topology induced by @xmath135 . following hadamard , a well - posed boundary problem @xcite must be regular ( meaning the solution @xmath101 exists and is unique for each given @xmath4 ) as well as stable ( meaning the solution @xmath101 depends continuously on @xmath4 ) . in the example above , the source of the instability is clear we have imposed a second - order condition for a first - order differential equation . going back to the algebraic setting then , we call a boundary problem @xmath129 well - posed if it is regular and @xmath100 can be generated by stieltjes conditions whose order is smaller than that of @xmath102 ; otherwise @xmath92 is called _ ill - posed_. as one easily checks , the well - posed boundary problems form a submonoid of @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] . the green s operator @xmath86 of a regular boundary problem @xmath92 of order @xmath136 factors naturally as @xmath137 where @xmath138 is the so - called _ fundamental right inverse _ of @xmath102 , defined as the green s operator of the initial value problem @xmath139 $ ] , and @xmath140 is the projector onto @xmath112 along @xmath105 . the fundamental right inverse @xmath138 exists since initial value problems are always solvable ( * ? ? ? * prop . we may thus think of as a two step process : using @xmath138 one solves first the initial value problem ( which is usually much easier ) , then one incorporates the boundary conditions via the projector @xmath140 . the submonoid relation @xmath125_{\phi}}\subset { { \mathcal{e}}[{\partial } ] \ltimes k\phi}$ ] means that multiplying regular problems leads to regular problems again . it is interesting to note that the converse is also true , provided the order condition of lemma [ lem : regularity - test ] holds . [ lem : reg - factors ] let @xmath141 be boundary problems over an integro - differential algebra @xmath19 with @xmath142 and @xmath143 . then @xmath144 and @xmath145 are regular whenever @xmath146 is . let us write @xmath147 and @xmath148 . choose fundamental systems @xmath149 for @xmath150 and @xmath151 for @xmath152 . take @xmath18-bases @xmath153 of @xmath154 and @xmath155 of @xmath156 . then @xmath157 is a fundamental system for @xmath158 , and a @xmath18-basis of @xmath159 is given by @xmath160 , @xmath155 . the latter fact follows since the sum @xmath161 in is always direct ( * ? ? ? * prop . 3.2 ) . by lemma [ lem : regularity - test ] the regularity of the boundary problem @xmath162 means that its evaluation matrix @xmath163 is regular . but this is only possible if both diagonal blocks @xmath164 and @xmath165 are regular , and these are just the evaluation matrices of @xmath144 and @xmath166 . for practical applications , one is not so much interested in multiplying boundary problems thus increasing their order as to factor them into lower - order problems . interestingly , factorization will also be instrumental in the localization process ( lemma [ lem : regularization ] ) . we repeat here as the main result the so - called _ factorization theorem _ [ thm : fact - bp ] given a regular boundary problem @xmath167_{\phi}}$ ] , every factorization @xmath168 of the differential operator lifts to a factorization @xmath169 with @xmath141 regular and @xmath170 . we note that the right factor may be chosen to be an arbitrary subspace of @xmath100 as long as regularity holds for @xmath166 ; in particular one can always choose initial conditions for @xmath171 to ensure regularity . in contrast , @xmath172 is determined by the choice of @xmath150 and @xmath152 alone . this is the content of the following uniqueness result ( * ? ? ? 31 ) , called the _ division lemma _ for boundary problems ( see below for the notion of subproblem ) . [ lem : division ] given a regular boundary problem @xmath167_{\phi}}$ ] and any factorization @xmath168 of the differential operator , there is a unique boundary problem @xmath144 such that for any regular subproblem @xmath173 we have the lifted factorization @xmath174 . the _ notion of subproblem _ was defined ( under the name `` right factor '' , which is avoided here due to the ambiguity in cases like example [ ex : embed - single - cond ] ) for regular boundary problems in ( * ? ? ? 29 ) , but it can be extended naturally to all boundary problems . hence a subproblem of a boundary problem @xmath167 \ltimes k\phi}$ ] is any @xmath175 \ltimes k\phi}$ ] with @xmath152 a right divisor of @xmath102 and @xmath171 a subspace of @xmath100 . we denote this relation by @xmath176 . we conclude this section with a few remarks on _ algorithmic issues_. while at the present stage of our work we do not aim at a computational realization of the localization , we see this nevertheless as a mid - term goal . in fact , most of the results in this paper are algorithmic , with two exceptions : ( 1 ) the ore condition is needed in @xmath177 $ ] for monic operators ; this is not supported by customary packages but appears to be adaptable ( see the remarks after proposition [ prop : left - ext ] ) . ( 2 ) one would need an algorithm for determining the monomials required in definition [ def : umbral - characters ] . once these two gaps are filled , one should be able to compute in the localization since all the constructions reviewed in this section are themselves algorithmic @xcite : * the _ operator ring _ @xmath63}$ ] is defined as a quotient by a certain ideal of relations . this ideal is described by a noncommutative grbner basis for an ideal with infinitely many generators ( on another view : a noetherian and confluent rewrite system ) . * if the _ ground algebra _ @xmath19 and the _ character set _ @xmath49 are computable , the normal forms of @xmath63}$ ] are computable as well . typically , @xmath19 is an algorithmic fragment of @xmath134 like the exponential polynomials @xcite , while @xmath49 consists of finitely many point evaluations @xmath178 . * the _ green s operator _ of a regular boundary problem ( and hence the solutions for arbitrary forcing functions up to quadratures ) can be computed as long as one has a fundamental system for the underlying homogenous differential equation . for the latter , one can in principle rely on the vast body of results from differential galois theory @xcite . * the _ multiplication and factorization _ of boundary problems can be computed as long as the same is true for the constituent differential operators . in this way one can often solve higher - order boundary problems by decomposing them into smaller factors such as in a recent application to actuarial mathematics @xcite . for the algorithmic theory of factoring linear differential operators , we refer to @xcite . as detailed in the introduction , the algorithms addressed above are _ implemented _ in mathematica and maple packages . we have seen that for a given integro - differential algebra @xmath19 and character set @xmath49 , the natural choice of boundary conditions is the _ stieltjes conditions _ , defined in @xcite as the right ideal @xmath67 of @xmath63}$ ] and characterized by their normal forms . the choice of @xmath67 is vindicated by theorem [ thm : fact - bp ] , which asserts that stieltjes conditions are sufficient for describing arbitrary factor problems ( and they are clearly also sufficient for multiplying boundary problems ) . in fact , stieltjes conditions with nonzero global part appear in the left factor problem even if the original boundary problem has only local conditions ; see e.g. example 33 in @xcite . for the purpose of localization we must isolate a subclass of stieltjes conditions . first of all , we must distinguish carefully between the zero condition @xmath179 and degenerate boundary conditions that only _ act _ as zero : we call a stieltjes condition @xmath99 _ degenerate _ if @xmath180 for all @xmath181 . in the standard setting of example [ ex : standard ] , there are plenty of degenerate boundary conditions . if @xmath4 is a bump function supported , say , on an interval disjoint from @xmath182 $ ] , the stieltjes condition @xmath183 is clearly degenerate . in contrast , the integro - differential subalgebra of analytic functions @xmath43 does not have degenerate global conditions of this form as we shall see below ( example [ ex : complete ] ) . the subclass of stieltjes conditions to be chosen must be so as to ensure a sufficient supply of regular boundary problems . in particular , we shall find ourselves in the situation of embedding a singular boundary problem @xmath92 into a surrounding regular problem ( lemma [ lem : regularization ] ) . hence we must enlarge @xmath184}$ ] by a suitable differential operator @xmath185}$ ] and the boundary space @xmath100 by _ new boundary conditions _ @xmath186 in such a manner that the resulting evaluation matrix is regular ( lemma [ lem : regularity - test ] ) . the key for solving this problem is found in the fortunate fact every integro - differential algebra @xmath19 contains the polynomial ring ( proposition [ prop : pol - ring ] ) , so the _ initial value problem _ @xmath187)\ ] ] is a natural choice for extending the given boundary problem @xmath129 . then the monomials @xmath188 are a fundamental system by proposition [ prop : pol - ring ] , and the corresponding evaluation matrix is @xmath189 . but this is not enough for embedding singular problems since the evaluation matrix of the surrounding problem involves combining the _ given _ boundary conditions @xmath120 with the monomials of the fundamental system . indeed , the crucial step in the proof of lemma [ lem : regularization ] needs that @xmath190 for _ some _ monomial @xmath191 $ ] . this is the motivation for the following definition . [ def : umbral - characters ] a stieltjes condition @xmath192}$ ] is called _ umbral _ if @xmath190 for some monomial @xmath193 $ ] . furthermore , we call @xmath49 an _ umbral character set _ if every nondegenerate stieltjes condition is umbral . the reason for our terminology is that there is an interesting link between stieljes conditions @xmath192}$ ] with @xmath190 and the _ umbral calculus_. indeed , every umbral condition defines a nontrivial shift - invariant operator ( proposition [ prop : umbral - cond ] ) . this is clear for the local parts @xmath194 but needs some justification for global terms @xmath195 with arbitrary @xmath196 $ ] . the point is that one may apply the following special case of the well - known `` antiderivative leibniz rule '' . ( in the general setting of analytic functions one writes @xmath197 as an infinite series of iterated integrals of @xmath4 times iterated derivatives of @xmath198 . here we have @xmath199 so that only finitely many derivatives are nonzero and the series terminates . ) [ lem : int - part - pol ] in any integro - differential algebra @xmath17 , we have the formula @xmath200 for all @xmath98 . here @xmath201 is defined by @xmath202 and @xmath203 . this is essentially the special case @xmath204 of equation ( 14 ) in @xcite , but the proof is short enough to present here . we use induction over @xmath136 . the base case @xmath205 is clear , so assume for @xmath206 ; we prove it for @xmath207 . since @xmath208 we have @xmath209 by the pure baxter axiom . using the induction hypothesis , the right summand becomes @xmath210 after an index transformation . adding the extra term @xmath211 means extending the summation to @xmath212 , which yields for @xmath207 . [ lem : umbral - global - cond ] let @xmath213 be a global condition in @xmath63}$ ] . then we have @xmath214 as a functional @xmath9 \rightarrow k$ ] , where @xmath215 \rightarrow k[x]\ ] ] is a shift - invariant operator with expansion coefficients @xmath216 . by a well - known result of the umbral calculus ( 2.1.7 ) , incidentally also presented in ( * ? ? ? 92 ) , the operator @xmath217 is shift - invariant . for seeing that @xmath218 , we apply lemma [ lem : int - part - pol ] to obtain @xmath219 . the _ operator expansion _ allows us to associate a shift invariant operator with a stieltjes condition of the special form @xmath213 . but this association generalizes immediately to arbitrary stieltjes conditions since the local conditions are unproblematic . [ prop : umbral - cond ] let @xmath99 be a stieltjes condition in @xmath63}$ ] . then there is an _ associated shift - invariant operator _ @xmath220 \rightarrow k[x]\ ] ] with coefficients @xmath221 such that @xmath222 . clearly , the associated operator @xmath217 is nonzero iff @xmath99 is an umbral condition . let @xmath223 \rightarrow k[x]$ ] be the shift operator @xmath224 with @xmath225 . using the normal form we can write the given boundary condition as @xmath226 where @xmath227 is clearly shift - invariant while @xmath228 is the shift - invariant operator corresponding to @xmath229 according to lemma [ lem : umbral - global - cond ] . then the terms @xmath230 in the second sum are shift - invariant , hence we have @xmath231 with the shift - invariant operator @xmath232 and the formula @xmath233 for its expansion coefficients follows from the general result referred to in the proof of lemma [ lem : umbral - global - cond ] . umbral boundary conditions appear to be _ abundant _ , at least in the cases most crucial to us , especially in the @xmath234 setting ( containing many important integro - differential subalgebras notably the analytic and holonomic functions as well as the exponential polynomials ) . [ prop : cinf - weierstrass ] in the standard setting of example [ ex : standard ] , the point evaluations form an umbral character set . consider an arbitrary nondegenerate stieltjes condition @xmath235 so that there is a function @xmath96 with @xmath236 . let @xmath237 be the maximum of @xmath238 for all @xmath239 with @xmath240 or @xmath241 . we consider now the banach space @xmath242 on the compact interval @xmath243 $ ] . its norm @xmath244 is given by @xmath245 for all @xmath246 . there is a little known generalization of the weierstrass approximation theorem due to nachbin @xcite , which asserts ( in a simple special case ) that @xmath44 $ ] is dense in @xmath242 . hence we may choose a polynomial sequence @xmath247 that converges to @xmath248 in the @xmath249 topology . one checks immediately that @xmath250 is a continous functional with respect to the @xmath249 norm . in detail , one has @xmath251 with operator - norm bound @xmath252 therefore we have @xmath253 . this is impossible if @xmath99 vanishes on all of @xmath44 $ ] . hence there is some @xmath254 $ ] with @xmath255 . clearly there exists a smallest monomial @xmath256 in @xmath257 with @xmath190 . not every character set is umbral , though . it is natural to introduce the following _ necessary conditions _ for a character set @xmath49 to be umbral ( we write @xmath258 for the canonical value @xmath259 of a character @xmath50 ) : 1 . the character set @xmath49 must clearly be _ separative _ in the sense that @xmath260 implies @xmath261 . otherwise @xmath262 is a nonzero stieltjes condition with @xmath263 ) = 0 $ ] . 2 . every character @xmath50 must be _ complete _ in the sense that every global condition of the form @xmath213 is umbral whenever it is nondegenerate . this may also be expressed as @xmath264 \rightarrow f = 0 $ ] . here orthogonality refers to the nondegenerate bilinear form @xmath265 . if this bilinear form is positive definite with @xmath266 or @xmath267 , we have a pre - hilbert space @xmath268 . following the terminology of ( * v.24 ) , completeness of @xmath239 then means that any @xmath239-orthonormal basis of @xmath9 $ ] is complete in @xmath268 . these conditions are most likely not sufficient . at the moment we can not give a counterexample for corroborating this claim . but it is intuitively clear that the completeness properties associated with each @xmath239 separately can not prevent linear dependencies between the actions of distinct global conditions @xmath195 . it remains an interesting task to formulate stronger conditions on @xmath49 that ensure an umbral character set in a natural way . [ ex : separative ] as an example of a _ nonseparative character set _ , consider the exponential polynomials @xmath269}$ ] with the nonstandard character @xmath239 defined by @xmath270 and @xmath271 for all @xmath136 , effectively mixing evaluation at @xmath272 for monomials with evaluation at @xmath273 for the exponential . choosing @xmath266 for simplicity , let @xmath27 be the honest evaluation @xmath274 . then clearly @xmath239 and @xmath27 coincide on @xmath9 $ ] while they are in fact distinct characters on @xmath269}$ ] since @xmath275 . this shows that separativity is necessary but not sufficient . nevertheless , it ensures that all _ local boundary conditions _ are indeed umbral . [ prop : local - bc - umbral ] let @xmath49 be a separative character set for an integro - differential algebra @xmath17 . then every local boundary condition is umbral . using , every local boundary condition can be written in the form @xmath276 assuming @xmath263 ) = 0 $ ] , we show that all coefficients @xmath277 are zero . collecting them in the vector @xmath278 we obtain @xmath279 linear homogeneous equations for the unkowns @xmath277 by applying @xmath99 to the monomials @xmath280 . the matrix of the corresponding system @xmath281 is given by @xmath282 with blocks @xmath283^{n \times s } \ ; .\ ] ] since @xmath49 is separative , the values @xmath284 are mutually distinct . then we may apply the subsequent lemma [ lem : det ] to obtain @xmath285 , hence @xmath286 has the unique solution @xmath287 . [ lem : det ] the determinant of @xmath288^{n \times n}$ ] , with @xmath279 and blocks , is given by @xmath289 where @xmath290 is the @xmath291 vandermonde determinant and @xmath292 denotes the superfactorial . the determinant is a special case of ( * ? ? ? 1.1 ) or ( * ? ? ? 20 ) , apart from the linear factor @xmath293 in @xmath294-th row of @xmath295 . thus we have @xmath296 which is . let us now turn to _ completeness_. in the analysis setting , every @xmath239 is complete since we know already the stronger result that every stieltjes condition is umbral ( proposition [ prop : cinf - weierstrass ] ) . it is nevertheless instructive to have a closer look at this case . [ ex : complete ] consider the point evaluation @xmath297 in the _ standard setting _ of example [ ex : standard ] . here we get an inner product @xmath298 which can be extended to all continuous functions @xmath299 on @xmath300 $ ] and so gives rise to the pre - hilbert hausdorff space @xmath301 , { \langle \cdot | \cdot \rangle}_\phi)$ ] . it is well - known that @xmath302 is a complete sequence in this space ( * ? ? ? we may assume @xmath303 by a scale transformation . by the usual gram - schmidt process , the monomials @xmath256 can be transformed to an orthonormal basis @xmath304 of @xmath305 $ ] , which consists in this case of the legendre polynomials @xmath306 in every pre - hilbert hausdorff space @xmath307 , an orthonormal basis @xmath308 has the following well - known property ( * ? ? ? v.2.5 ) : if @xmath309 is nonzero , we have @xmath310 for some @xmath311 . applying this to @xmath312 \supset c^\infty[0,1]$ ] and fixing any @xmath313 \subset c^\infty({\mathbb{r}})$ ] , we see that @xmath239 is complete in the sense defined above . for if @xmath314 for all @xmath311 , then @xmath4 vanishes on @xmath315 $ ] and hence @xmath195 is degenerate . the above argument shows in fact that every global condition @xmath316 over @xmath134 is umbral or degenerate . working over @xmath43 , we can exclude the degenerate case . indeed , the identity theorem of complex analysis ensures that @xmath317 whenever @xmath4 vanishes on @xmath315 $ ] . this is in stark contrast to the @xmath234 case , which has plenty of degenerate global conditions @xmath195 as we have observed at the beginning of section [ sec : umbral - bc ] . it becomes clear from the above example that completeness is really an _ analytic property _ of some sort . it is therefore not surprising that one can construct `` purely algebraic '' examples lacking this property . [ ex : incomplete ] to give an example of an _ incomplete character _ on @xmath318}$ ] with @xmath266 , we proceed similar to example [ ex : separative ] . define @xmath319 for @xmath320 and @xmath321 , @xmath322 . then clearly @xmath323 is nondegenerate since @xmath324 . but we have @xmath325 for all @xmath311 . as noted above , separativity and completeness are most likely not strong enough to ensure an umbral character set . note that umbrality of @xmath49 implies that two stieltjes conditions in @xmath63}$ ] are _ linearly independent _ on @xmath9 $ ] whenever they are linearly independent on @xmath19 . if one of the two conditions is local and the other global , it is reasonable to expect this property to follow from completeness . this expections is fulfilled . [ lem : global - not - local ] let @xmath17 be an integro - differential algebra with a complete character @xmath239 . then a nondegenerate global condition @xmath195 never coincides on @xmath9 $ ] with any local condition based on @xmath239 . assume @xmath213 coincides on @xmath9 $ ] with @xmath326 , where @xmath3 is chosen minimal . then the umbral expansion breaks off at @xmath327 , and we have @xmath328 for @xmath329 . for @xmath330 , we get @xmath331 for all @xmath332 , so the condition @xmath333 is degenerate since @xmath239 is complete . for showing that this can not happen , it suffices to prove that all @xmath334 are nondegenerate whenever @xmath195 is . we use induction on @xmath332 . the base case @xmath335 is trivial , so assume the claim for fixed @xmath294 . by the induction hypothesis we can choose @xmath336 with @xmath337 . using with @xmath198 in place of @xmath4 and @xmath338 in place of @xmath198 , we have @xmath339 so our choice of @xmath198 entails @xmath340 . if the first summand on the right - hand side is different from @xmath83 , then @xmath341 witnesses to @xmath342 being nondegenerate , and the induction is complete . otherwise @xmath343 must be nonzero , and we may use the special case @xmath344 of the pure baxter axiom to derive @xmath345 and again the induction is complete . let us start by reviewing the general setting for localization in a noncommutative unital ring @xmath237 , following @xcite . as in the commutative case , the denominator set @xmath346 ( the elements that should become invertible ) must clearly form a _ multiplicative set _ @xmath346 , meaning a submonoid of @xmath347 . clearly we must stipulate @xmath348 , otherwise the localization is the zero ring . if @xmath237 is a domain , one might want to take @xmath349 . while this is always possible in the commutative setting , one needs an additional condition if @xmath237 is not commutative . indeed , let us strive for a localization @xmath350 on the left , meaning all elements have the form @xmath351 with @xmath352 and @xmath353 . since @xmath354 this must also be possible for the reverse product so that @xmath355 for some @xmath356 and @xmath357 . multiplying out , we get the necessary condition @xmath358 known as the _ left ore condition _ ; the set @xmath346 is then called _ left permutable_. if @xmath237 is a domain , this condition is actually sufficient for guaranteeing the existence of a unique localization @xmath359 , which can be constructed essentially as in the commutative case . however , if @xmath237 has _ zero divisors _ , in general one does not get an embedding @xmath360 . in this case , the _ extension _ @xmath361 is a ring homomorphism that is not injective ( and of course not surjective ) . its kernel contains at least those @xmath362 that yield @xmath363 for some @xmath352 since this implies @xmath364 and hence @xmath365 , due to @xmath366 being invertible in @xmath350 . in the classical localization @xmath350 , the kernel should be optimal in the sense that it contains no other elements than these necessary ones . [ def : localization ] let @xmath237 be an arbitrary ring with @xmath367 . then @xmath361 is called a left _ ring of fractions _ if 1 . all elements @xmath366 with @xmath352 are invertible in @xmath350 , 2 . every element of @xmath350 has the form @xmath368 for some @xmath352 , @xmath369 , 3 . and the kernel of @xmath370 is given by @xmath371 . the ring homomorphism @xmath370 is called the _ extension_. the missing condition is now easy to establish . assume @xmath352 is a right zero divisor so that @xmath372 for some @xmath362 . then also @xmath373 and hence @xmath365 since @xmath366 is invertible in @xmath350 . but this implies @xmath374 for some @xmath356 by item ( c ) of definition [ def : localization ] . accordingly , one calls a set @xmath346 with the property @xmath375 _ left reversible_. together with the left ore condition , this turns out to be sufficient for the existence of a left ring of fractions . [ thm : ore - localization ] let @xmath237 be an arbitrary ring . then for any @xmath376 , the left ring of fractions @xmath350 exists iff @xmath346 is multiplicative , left permutable and left reversible . see ( * ? ? 10.6 ) . the setting would become much nicer when the extension @xmath377 is injective so that we can regard @xmath378 as an _ embedding_. unfortunately , the localization of @xmath63}$ ] that we will work out in the sequel is not of this type . in fact , one can easily show that the injectivity of @xmath370 is equivalent to having only regular elements in @xmath346 . following @xcite , we call an element @xmath352 regular if it is both left and right regular , where left regular means @xmath372 implies @xmath379 for all @xmath362 while right regular means @xmath380 implies @xmath379 for all @xmath362 . as @xmath63}$ ] contains plenty of zero divisors , it is hard to achieve a regular denominator set @xmath346 . of course there are analogous definitions for the _ right ring of fractions _ @xmath381 , but in general the existence of @xmath350 does not imply the existence of @xmath381 or vice versa , and even when both exist they need not be isomorphic . in fact , we shall be dealing with a case that is left permutable ( lemma [ lem : prob - left - permutable ] ) but not right permutable ( proposition [ prop : not - right - permutable ] ) . the localization that we shall construct is based on the monoid @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] of regular boundary problems over an integro - differential algebra @xmath17 with umbral character set @xmath49 . the ring @xmath237 to be localized is the _ ring of boundary problems _ @xmath128_{\phi}}$ ] , which is a monoid algebra . for such cases , the above setting can be somewhat simplified . a monoid @xmath346 is called _ left permutable _ if it satisfies the ore condition with respect to itself , meaning @xmath382 for all @xmath383 . in the absence of addition , the analog of condition says that for all @xmath384 with @xmath385 there must exist @xmath356 with @xmath386 ; in this case we call @xmath346 _ left reversible _ ( as a monoid ) . we call @xmath346 a _ left ore monoid _ if @xmath346 is both left permutable and left reversible ; cf . also ( * ? ? ? the following lemma is a special case of ( * ? ? ? * lem . 6.6 ) but we include its proof since it dispenses with the technical machinery used there . it tells us that we can _ transfer left permutability _ from @xmath346 to the monoid algebra @xmath387 . [ lem : per - from - mon ] if @xmath346 is a left permutable monoid , then @xmath346 is a left permutable subset of @xmath387 . similarly , if @xmath346 is a left reversible monoid , then @xmath346 is a left reversible subset of @xmath387 . given @xmath388 , @xmath389 and @xmath352 , we have to find @xmath390 , @xmath391 and @xmath356 such that @xmath392 using the ore condition in @xmath346 , we can successively find @xmath393 and @xmath394 such that @xmath395 is fulfilled . multiplying these equations by @xmath396 , @xmath397 , @xmath398 , @xmath399 on the left yields the system @xmath400 if we set @xmath401 and @xmath402 with coefficients @xmath403 . summing these equations gives the desired ore condition . the proof of the second statement follows immediately by induction on the number of terms . [ cor : ore - from - mon ] if @xmath346 is a left ore monoid , the left ring of fractions @xmath404 exists . immediate from lemma [ lem : per - from - mon ] and theorem [ thm : ore - localization ] . we shall now prove that @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] is a left ore monoid . the multiplication of boundary problems is realized by the semi - direct product of the multiplicative monoid @xmath177 $ ] acting on the additive monoid of boundary spaces . projecting onto the first factor , it is then clear that the monic differential operators of @xmath177 $ ] must form a left ore monoid . a coefficient algebra with this property shall be called _ left extensible_. [ ex : gcd - diffop ] left permutability requires _ some _ common left multiple for given differential operators @xmath405 $ ] . hence it may seem tempting to restrict ourselves to those coefficient algebras @xmath406 that even have a _ least common left multiple _ @xmath407 . but this setting is not suitable for our purposes : as far as we know , there are only two natural examples : the rational functions @xmath408 allow an adaption of the euclidean algorithm @xcite , and of course one may always take @xmath409 . the first case yields a differential field , which excludes the existence of an integro - differential structure @xcite . the second case restricts us to differential operators with constant coefficients , which is excessively restrive . fortunately it turns out that we do not need least common left multiples since left extensible coefficient algebras are easy to come by , as the next lemma shows . in particular , any integro - differential algebra @xmath19 allows @xmath410 $ ] so that @xmath177 = a_1(k)$ ] is the _ weyl algebra_. as another example , consider the standard setting of example [ ex : standard ] , where for @xmath91 one may take the larger ring of _ analytic functions _ @xmath43 . [ prop : left - ext ] any left noetherian differential domain @xmath406 is left extensible . if @xmath91 is a left noetherian domain , it satisfies left permutability by ( * ? ? ? 5.4 ) and is therefore a left ore domain . but @xmath177 $ ] is a special case of a skew - polynomial algebra and therefore inherits the property of being a left ore domain by ( * ? ? ? but this is not enough since we need the _ monic _ differential operators of @xmath177 $ ] to form a left ore monoid . hence assume @xmath411 for some monic differential operators @xmath412 $ ] . since @xmath177 $ ] is a domain , @xmath413 implies @xmath414 because @xmath415 is not possible . hence the monic differential operators from @xmath177 $ ] form a left reversible monoid . but this monoid is indeed a left ore monoid : according to ( * ? ? ? 1.5.1 ) , the set of all monic polynomials in the skew polynomial ring @xmath177 $ ] is left permutable whenever @xmath91 is a left noetherian domain . let us remark that the generalization from _ least _ common left multiples to common left multiples is crucial even for the basic case @xmath410 $ ] . for example when @xmath416 and @xmath417 , the least common left multiple of @xmath150 and @xmath152 in @xmath418 $ ] is @xmath419 and so gives @xmath420 when taken in @xmath177 $ ] . this shows that the least common left multiple of two monic operators in @xmath177 $ ] need not be monic . the conventional computation tools for the weyl algebra are therefore not directly applicable for computing monic common left multiples in @xmath177 $ ] , but some recent methods @xcite can be adapted to this purpose [ a. bostan , private communication ] . as explained at the beginning of section [ sec : umbral - bc ] , the main tool for ensuring the left ore condition in @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] is the embedding of singular boundary problems into regular ones . this will be achieved in the regularization lemma [ lem : regularization ] , by successively embedding the stieltjes conditions generating a given boundary space . hence the crucial step is to embed a _ single stieltjes condition _ , which we require to be umbral so that we can build up a polynomial fundamental system . [ lem : one - cond - high ] let @xmath192}$ ] be an umbral stieltjes condition over a given integro - differential algebra @xmath19 . then there is a @xmath332 such that @xmath421)$ ] is a regular boundary problem since @xmath99 is umbral , there is a minimal mononomial @xmath422 with @xmath423 . clearly , @xmath424 is a fundamental system for @xmath425 . using the boundary conditions @xmath426 , we obtain the @xmath427 evaluation matrix @xmath428 where the off - diagonal bottom entries vanish by the assumption on @xmath422 . note that @xmath294 in lemma [ lem : one - cond - high ] can also be _ zero _ , for example if @xmath429 . in that case , it is not necessary to add any initial conditions since the first - order problem @xmath430)$ ] is already regular . [ ex : embed - single - cond ] as a more or less typical case consider @xmath431 . here the minimal mononomial is @xmath81 , which leads back to our standard example [ ex : second - order ] , the regular boundary problem @xmath432 ) = ( { \partial}^2 , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_0 , { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1])$ ] . as mentioned earlier , we can not split off the first - order subproblem @xmath433)$ ] since it is singular ( this is an example of a _ subproblem that is not a right factor _ ) : if it were not , we would know from the division lemma [ lem : division ] that the corresponding unique left factor is @xmath434)$ ] , as shown in ( * ? ? ? 28 ) and also below ( example [ ex : ore - quad ] ) . but of course multiplying out just gives the degenerate problem @xmath435 ) \cdot ( { \partial } , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1-{\text{\scshape\texttt e}}_0 ] = ( { \partial}^2 , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1-{\text{\scshape\texttt e}}_0])\ ] ] and not the desired regularized problem @xmath95)$ ] . based on the case of a single boundary condition , we can now embed an arbitrary boundary problem into a regular one provided we work with an umbral character set . this is the subject of the following _ regularization lemma_. [ lem : regularization ] let @xmath49 be an umbral character set for an integro - differential algebra @xmath19 . then for an arbitrary boundary problem @xmath436 \ltimes k\phi}$ ] there is a regular boundary problem @xmath437_{\phi}}$ ] that has @xmath92 as a subproblem . let @xmath167 \ltimes k\phi}$ ] be an arbitrary but fixed boundary problem with @xmath102 a differential operator of order @xmath320 and @xmath438 \le { \mathcal{f}}^*$ ] of dimension @xmath439 . we write @xmath440 for the space of initial conditions @xmath441 $ ] and @xmath442 for the partial boundary space @xmath443 $ ] with the convention that @xmath444 . we will now prove that for each @xmath445 there is a regular boundary problem @xmath446 that has @xmath447 as a subproblem . taking @xmath448 , the theorem follows . we use induction on @xmath294 . the base case follows by setting @xmath449 . for the induction step , assume @xmath450 is a regular boundary problem that has @xmath451 as a subproblem . we have to construct a regular problem @xmath446 that has @xmath452 as a subproblem . letting @xmath453 be the green s operator of @xmath450 , assume first that @xmath454 is degenerate . since @xmath454 vanishes on @xmath19 , we obtain @xmath455^\perp } \qquad\text{and hence}\qquad [ \beta_k ] \le \tilde{\mathcal{a}},\ ] ] so we may set @xmath456 in that case . now assume @xmath454 is nondegenerate and hence umbral . lemma [ lem : one - cond - high ] yields a regular problem @xmath457)$ ] . we define the boundary problem @xmath458 + \tilde{\mathcal{a}})\\ & = ( \tilde{t } \tilde{s } , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}\tilde{s } , \dots , { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}{\partial}^{r-1 } \tilde{s } , \beta_k ] + \tilde{\mathcal{a } } ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the last equality follows since the conditions @xmath459 and @xmath460 are equivalent for @xmath461 . the boundary problem @xmath446 is clearly regular since it is the product of two regular problems , and it has @xmath447 as a subproblem because @xmath462 by the induction hypothesis . we are now ready to prove _ left permutability _ for the monoid @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] by merging the given factors into a singular problem that is subsequently embedded into a regular problem by virtue of lemma [ lem : regularization ] . [ lem : prob - left - permutable ] let @xmath49 be an umbral character set for an integro - differential algebra @xmath19 with left extensible coefficient algebra @xmath91 . then @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] is a left permutable monoid . given @xmath463_{\phi}}$ ] , we must find @xmath464_{\phi}}$ ] such that @xmath465 . since @xmath91 is left extensible , proposition [ prop : left - ext ] yields a common left multiple @xmath102 and cofactors @xmath466 and @xmath467 such that @xmath468 . now set @xmath469 . by lemma [ lem : regularization ] there is a regular boundary problem @xmath446 that has @xmath92 as a subproblem . but then the boundary problem @xmath446 has @xmath144 and @xmath166 as regular subproblems , and lemma [ lem : division ] yields regular boundary problems @xmath470 and @xmath471 such that @xmath472 as claimed . lemma [ lem : prob - left - permutable ] is also true if one replaces @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] by the monoid of well - posed boundary problems defined before eq . this can be seen readily by inspecting the above proof ( and the proofs of lemma [ lem : division ] and [ lem : regularization ] ) . let us give a simple example of a nontrivial _ ore quadruple _ @xmath144 , @xmath166 , @xmath473 , @xmath474 that will also serve a good purpose later on . [ ex : ore - quad ] in the standard setting of example [ ex : standard ] , consider the two simplest first - order problems on @xmath315 $ ] , namely @xmath475 ) \qquad\text{and}\qquad ( t_2 , { \mathcal{b}}_2 ) = ( { \partial } , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1]).\ ] ] in that case , we have of course @xmath476 , and we apply lemma [ lem : regularization ] to the boundary problem @xmath477)$ ] . we end up with @xmath435 ) \cdot ( { \partial } , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_0 ] ) = ( { \partial}^2 , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_0 , { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1]),\ ] ] which is already regular . the corresponding cofactors are then @xmath478 ) \qquad\text{and also}\qquad ( \tilde{t}_2 , \tilde{{\mathcal{b}}}_2 ) = ( { \partial } , [ { { \textstyle \varint}}_0 ^ 1])\ ] ] since clearly @xmath479 ) = ( { \partial}^2 , [ { { \textstyle \varint}}_0 ^ 1 { \partial } , { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1 ] ) = ( { \partial}^2 , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_0 , { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1])$ ] . as mentioned before , @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] is left permutable but _ not right permutable_. this means there are boundary problems that do not have a common right factor . actually , more is true : even if we start from two distinct problems with the same differential operator , _ any _ common right multiple comes from a singular factor . [ prop : not - right - permutable ] let @xmath49 be an arbitrary character set for an integro - differential algebra @xmath19 with coefficient algebra @xmath91 . assume @xmath480_{\phi}}$ ] have a common right multiple @xmath481 for some right factors @xmath482 \ltimes k\phi}$ ] . then both @xmath483 and @xmath484 are singular whenever @xmath485 . assume @xmath485 . projecting onto the boundary spaces , we have @xmath486 . if @xmath487 or @xmath488 , we have @xmath489 , so in fact @xmath490 . choosing @xmath491 we have @xmath492 but @xmath493 . hence we can write @xmath494 for some @xmath495 and nonzero @xmath496 . but then @xmath497 implies that @xmath484 is singular . by symmetry , we see that @xmath484 is singular as well . having established that @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] is left permutable , the only thing missing for the localization is left reversibility , which is very easy in our case . hence we obtain the desired _ left ring of fractions_. [ thm : localization ] let @xmath49 be an umbral character set for the integro - differential algebra @xmath17 with left extensible coefficient algebra @xmath91 . then there exists a left ring of fractions @xmath498_{\phi}^\star}$ ] of the ring of boundary problems @xmath128_{\phi}}$ ] with denominator set @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] . by corollary [ cor : ore - from - mon ] it suffices to check that @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] is an ore monoid . since left permutability of @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] has been shown in lemma [ lem : prob - left - permutable ] , it remains to show that @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] is a left reversible monoid . so assume we have @xmath499 for some regular problems @xmath500 . by left extensibility of @xmath91 we have @xmath501 for some monic @xmath502 $ ] of order @xmath136 . let @xmath503 $ ] be the corresponding space of initial conditions so that @xmath504 is a regular problem . then we obtain the regular product problem @xmath505 where the two parenthesized factors have the same differential operator by the choice of @xmath506 . since @xmath92 is a regular right factor of this problem , the division lemma [ lem : division ] implies that @xmath507 . we conclude that the monic differential operators of @xmath177 $ ] are indeed left reversible . the fraction ring @xmath498_{\phi}^\star}$ ] shall be called the _ ring of methorious operators _ ( from the greek word meaning `` making up a boundary '' ) . note that it exists in particular in the smooth setting : if one chooses @xmath40 , every character is umbral ( proposition [ prop : cinf - weierstrass ] ) , and any noetherian domain can be used for the coefficient algebra ( proposition [ prop : left - ext ] ) , in particular @xmath410 $ ] or @xmath508 . in the sequel , we shall confine ourselves to the latter setting . as already observed after theorem [ thm : ore - localization ] , we must expect that @xmath509_{\phi}}\rightarrow { k{\mathcal{e}}[{\partial}]_{\phi}^\star}$ ] _ is not an embedding_. for example , we have @xmath510 ) - ( { \partial } , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1 ] ) \in { \operatorname{ker}(\epsilon)}$ ] in the standard setting of @xmath40 . for checking this , we use the characterization of @xmath511 given in definition [ def : localization ] : it suffices to find a regular problem that annihilates @xmath512 from the left . indeed , we have @xmath434 ) n = 0 $ ] since we know from example [ ex : ore - quad ] that @xmath435 ) ( { \partial } , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_0 ] ) = ( { \partial}^2 , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_0 , { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1 ] ) = ( { \partial } , [ { { \textstyle \varint}}_0 ^ 1 ] ) ( { \partial } , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1 ] ) .\ ] ] at the moment we do not know @xmath511 in explicit form . however , we have the following conjecture . [ conj : extension - kernel ] let @xmath49 be an umbral character set for an integro - differential algebra @xmath19 with left extensible coefficient algebra @xmath91 , and let @xmath509_{\phi}}\rightarrow { k{\mathcal{e}}[{\partial}]_{\phi}^\star}$ ] be the extension into the ring of methorious operators . then we have @xmath513 iff @xmath514 , where @xmath515 is the green s operator of @xmath516 . the previous example is a case in point . the _ intuitive reason _ for our conjecture is this : generically , a linear combination of green s operators has a finite - dimensional cokernel ( meaning its image is annihilated by just finitely many functionals in the case of a single operator these functionals are the given boundary conditions ) . such an operator is in some sense `` almost invertible '' . but if a linear combination degenerates into an element of @xmath64 , its image becomes one - dimensional , and we can not expect to invert such an `` operator '' . extending an operator ring is much more useful if its elements may still be viewed as _ operating _ on some presumably extended domain of `` functions '' . as explained in the introduction , the operational calculus of mikusiski avoids this problem by merging `` operators '' and `` operands '' in the mikusiski field . in contrast , we shall follow the algebraic analysis approach of keeping operators and operands in separate structures . to this end we construct a suitable _ module of fractions _ that extends a given integro - differential algebra @xmath17 . in analogy to the mikusiski approach we would have to start from a ring @xmath237 of integral operators acting on @xmath19 , construct its localization @xmath517 and let it act on the corresponding localization @xmath518 . however , this does not work for the following reason : the natural candidate for @xmath237 would be the @xmath18-algebra of green s operators for regular boundary problems ( since this is the only ring over which we have sufficient control ) . but this monoid / ring is dual to the regular boundary problems , as we know from . since @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] is a left ore monoid but not a right ore monoid , @xmath237 is a right but not a left ore ring . hence we can only create a _ right _ ring of fractions @xmath517 and correspondigly only a _ right _ module of fractions that should extend @xmath19 . but the given integro - differential algebra @xmath19 only has a natural _ left _ action of @xmath519}$ ] . in fact , it is not quite true that one can not construct a left module of fractions from a given left module @xmath520 over a right ore ring @xmath237 . if @xmath521 is the right ring of fractions , one may of course construct the _ usual scalar extension _ . one may then refer to @xmath523 as a left module of fractions ( * ? ? ? but the problem with this construction is that we do not know anything about its structure . for example , there is no useful characterization of the kernel of @xmath524 as in the ore construction of theorem [ thm : fraction - module ] below . we must therefore take the _ differential operators _ as our starting point , and this is why we have constructed the localization @xmath498_{\phi}^\star}$ ] of the ring of boundary problems @xmath525_{\phi}}$ ] . one might be tempted to take just the simpler ring @xmath177 $ ] instead of the unwieldy monoid ring @xmath525_{\phi}}$ ] . but this would be too simplistic : in that case one gets a two - sided inverse @xmath526 of the differential operator , no new functions are generated , and of course we can not tackle boundary problems in such a setting . it is essential to work with the richer structure @xmath525_{\phi}}$ ] , for which we will have to set up a suitable left action on @xmath19 . but first let us briefly review the general setting for the _ localization of modules_. as in theorem [ thm : ore - localization ] , we go back to the setting of general rings @xmath237 . in this case we can construct the module of fractions in pretty much the same way as the ring of fractions ( * ? ? ? ii.3.3 ) . [ thm : fraction - module ] let @xmath520 be a left @xmath237-module , and let @xmath376 be a multiplicative , right permutable and right reversible denominator set @xmath376 . then there exists a left @xmath350-module @xmath527 , and the kernel of the extension @xmath528 consists of those @xmath529 for which there exists an @xmath352 with @xmath530 . now let @xmath17 be an integro - differential algebra and @xmath63}$ ] its ring of operators . for setting up a suitable left action of @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] on @xmath19 , we recall the _ fundamental formula _ @xcite of the mikusiski calculus @xmath531 where @xmath3 denotes the inverse of the standard convolution operator @xmath532 , defined by @xmath533 , and @xmath534 is simply the multiplicative identity generated by the construction of the mikusiski field . of course one may write @xmath535 but we keep the explicit notation for intuitive reasons since we can interpret as the distributional derivative of a function @xmath536 that is continuous except for a jump at @xmath80 . in that case , @xmath534 is the dirac distribution concentrated at @xmath80 . at any rate , the intuitive content of is that @xmath3 is a kind of enhanced differential operator that memorizes the function value at @xmath80 that is otherwise lost . taking this clue , we define the action of @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] on @xmath19 by @xmath537 where @xmath140 is the projector onto @xmath112 along @xmath105 . in the special case of @xmath476 , this recovers if we think of @xmath538)$ ] as some kind of algebraic representation of the dirac distribution @xmath534 . the definition has the consequence that we must extend @xmath19 so that it contains the new elements @xmath92 , prior to the extension effected by the localization . this is somewhat _ unsatisfying _ but appears to be inevitable in view of the facts pointed out at the opening of the section . perhaps in the future one can find a more powerful localization that generates at once the extension objects needed in the fundamental formula . at any rate , we must now also define the action of @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] on the new elements , but this is clearly @xmath539 where the boundary problem on the right side is the usual product in the problem monoid @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] . this will ensure that the action is well - defined . the _ intuitive meaning _ of the ideal element @xmath540 is that it records various integration constants that were lost under differentation . when the element is created by , it encodes all the boundary values @xmath164 for @xmath120 , and the function @xmath4 is confined to the kernel of @xmath102 . further action by a boundary problem @xmath541 according to leads to a new differential operator @xmath542 while leaving @xmath4 intact . hence we see that the function inside an ideal element is always in the kernel of the associated differential operator . we may therefore restrict the ideal elements @xmath540 to those with @xmath543 . after the action of , the new boundary space is @xmath544 , so the old boundary conditions @xmath107 are retained ( the ones for which we have boundary values ) . the new boundary conditions @xmath545 for @xmath546 give zero on @xmath4 since actually @xmath543 . in some sense , we have added redundant boundary data . we must therefore _ regulate redundancy _ in the ideal elements . this can be achieved by declaring that @xmath540 should be the same as @xmath547 for any @xmath548_{\phi}}$ ] with green s operator @xmath453 . this can be understood as follows . the boundary conditions in @xmath547 are @xmath546 and @xmath549 with @xmath120 . the former yield zero on @xmath550 since @xmath453 is the green s operator of @xmath541 , the latter give back @xmath551 just as for the ideal element @xmath552 . this leads to the following definition . let @xmath553 be the subspace of @xmath554_{\phi}}$ ] generated by the ideal elements @xmath555 with @xmath543 . furthermore , let @xmath556 be the subspace of @xmath553 generated by the elements @xmath557 then we define the _ module of methorious functions _ to be @xmath558 . let us now check that @xmath559 is indeed a module . [ prop : prob - action ] let @xmath17 be an integro - differential algebra with character set @xmath49 . the definitions and induce a monoid action of @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] on @xmath559 such that it becomes a @xmath525_{\phi}}$]-module . any monoid @xmath307 acting on a @xmath18-algebra @xmath79 extends to an action of the monoid ring @xmath560 $ ] that makes @xmath79 into a @xmath560$]-module . hence it suffices to verify the statement about the monoid action . first of all we must check that does not depend on the representative @xmath561 , meaning it maps the subspace @xmath556 into itself . this follows immediately from the associativity of the multiplication in @xmath125_{\phi}}$ ] . clearly we have @xmath562 and @xmath563 , so the unit element is respected . associativity is immediate in the case of , so it remains to check that @xmath564 and @xmath565 are equal . the former is @xmath566 where @xmath140 is the projector onto @xmath112 along @xmath105 and @xmath567 is correspondingly the projector onto @xmath568 along @xmath569 . if @xmath86 and @xmath453 are the green s operators of @xmath92 and @xmath541 , respectively , one can easily check that the projector associated with the composite problem @xmath570 is @xmath571 , meaning it projects onto @xmath572 along @xmath573 . hence we obtain for the other side of the prospective equality @xmath574 where the first and the last term is identical to the corresponding terms on the left hand side while the middle terms are equal since their difference is in @xmath556 . since @xmath559 is a @xmath525_{\phi}}$]-module , we obtain the @xmath498_{\phi}^\star}$]-module @xmath575 of _ methorious hyperfunctions _ by localization via theorem [ thm : fraction - module ] . we can not expect the extension @xmath576 to be injective since its kernel @xmath577_{\phi}}\colon ( t , { \mathcal{b } } ) \cdot \phi = 0 \}\ ] ] contains elements like @xmath578 ) - ( { \partial } , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_0])$ ] , which is annihilated upon multiplying with @xmath434)$ ] from the left ( see the example before conjecture [ conj : extension - kernel ] ) . but fortunately no elements of @xmath19 are lost . [ prop : hypfun - extension ] let @xmath17 be an integro - differential algebra with character set @xmath49 . then we have an embedding @xmath579 . assume @xmath580 for some @xmath98 and @xmath581_{\phi}}$ ] . then @xmath582 implies that @xmath543 and @xmath583 . but the former means that @xmath584 and the latter that @xmath585 . since @xmath92 is a regular problem , we have a direct sum @xmath586 and so @xmath317 . in the module of methorious hyperfunctions , we can finally justify our earlier notation @xmath587 for the _ green s operator _ of a regular boundary problem @xmath167_{\phi}}$ ] . to avoid confusion with @xmath588_{\phi}^\star}$ ] we refrain from the reciprocal notation for green s operators in the scope of the following theorem . but the result of the theorem is of course that it anyway does not matter how we interpret @xmath589 since it amounts to the same . [ prop : greensop - localization ] we have @xmath590 for all @xmath591 . moreover , if @xmath543 then @xmath592 . we have @xmath593 since @xmath594 and @xmath595 . multiplying by @xmath596_{\phi}^\star}$ ] yields the first result claimed . now assume @xmath543 . we obtain @xmath597 since @xmath598 for @xmath584 . again we multiply by @xmath599 to gain the result . we conclude with an example that hints at possible applications of our noncommutative mikusiski calculus . the classical mikusiski calculus has only one _ fundamental formula _ since boundary values ( or rather : initial values ) are only processed at @xmath80 . in contrast , there are plenty of fundamental formulae in the noncommutative mikusiski calculus . [ ex : fundamental - formulae ] let us write @xmath600 and @xmath601 as abbreviations for the problems @xmath602 ) \in { k{\mathcal{e}}[{\partial}]_{\phi}^\star}$ ] and @xmath602 ) \in { { \mathcal{f}}_{\phi}^\star}$ ] , respectively . then we have @xmath603 by the definition of the action . so we have algebraic representations for all the dirac distributions . but there are other methorious functions that do not have any distributional counterpart . for example , let us consider @xmath604 ) \in { k{\mathcal{e}}[{\partial}]_{\phi}^\star}$ ] and @xmath605 ) \in { { \mathcal{f}}_{\phi}^\star}$ ] . this yields the fundamental formula @xmath606 so @xmath370 is a kind of `` smeared out '' distribution that keeps the mean value of a given function @xmath4 . [ ex : inhom - bp ] finally let us see how one solves _ inhomogeneous boundary problems _ in the noncommutative mikusiski calculus . we use the standard setting of @xmath40 and consider the problem @xmath607 for given boundary values @xmath608 . we know how to compute the green s operator @xmath86 of the homogeneous problem @xmath609)$ ] as mentioned at the end of section [ sec : monoid - bp ] . in this case the projector @xmath140 onto @xmath610 $ ] along @xmath611^\perp}$ ] is given by @xmath612 . hence we have @xmath613 ) \ , u & = u '' + \big ( u(0 ) \ , ( 1-x ) + u(1 ) \ , x \big ) \ , ( { \partial}^2 , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_0 , { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1])\\ & = f + \big ( a \ , ( 1-x ) + b \ , x \big ) ( { \partial}^2 , [ { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_0 , { \text{\scshape\texttt e}}_1]),\\[0.5ex ] u & = gf + a \ , ( 1-x ) + b \ , x \end{aligned}\ ] ] by proposition [ prop : greensop - localization ] . as already indicated at various points above , our construction has several _ loose ends_. to begin with , it would be preferrable to localize in a subring ( or even all ) of @xmath63}$ ] rather than the monoid ring @xmath525_{\phi}}$ ] . this would have the advantage that one has a natural action on the underlying integro - differential algebra @xmath17 , and the somewhat artificial action on the module of methorious functions @xmath559 would be unnecessary . regarding the latter , we have already remarked in section [ sec : methorious - functions ] that the current two - stage process of creating the localization @xmath575 is unsatisfactory : in mikusiski s setup , all the `` ideal elements '' like @xmath3 and @xmath534 are an immediate result of the localization while we have to supply them offhand , prior to localization . we would like to find a better formulation in the future that will avoid this kind of inadequacy . one possible path towards such an improved localization is suggested by the prominent appearance of _ singular problems _ in the proof of lemma [ lem : prob - left - permutable ] . it may be worthwhile to expand the ring @xmath525_{\phi}}$ ] to include ( all or some ) singular boundary problems . of course this will also increase the kernel of the corresponding extension ( we can not expect to invert singular problems ) , but perhaps the resulting ring of fractions is more natural . in particular , it may be possible to interpret the sum of two ( singular ) boundary problems in some useful way , in contrast to the formal sums of @xmath525_{\phi}}$ ] . the results of @xcite will be useful for the work in this direction . staying with the current construction , there are some obvious open questions : fist of all , the _ kernel of the extension _ @xmath370 into the methorious operators should be determined , possibly by proving cojecture [ conj : extension - kernel ] . likewise , the kernel [ eq : kernel - hypfun ] of the extension @xmath614 into the methorious hyperfunctions is to be computed . finally , we would like to draw attention to the interesting link between integro - differential algebras and the umbral calculus ( section [ sec : umbral - bc ] ) , which deserves to be studied in more depth . there is also an intriguing relation @xcite between the umbral calculus and the rota - baxter algebras ( both of these being favourite topic of g .- rota ) , which might benefit from the new perspective afforded by boundary problems in integro - differential algebras ( since the latter are special cases of differential rota - baxter algebras and hence of plain rota - baxter algebras ) . as a more mundane goal , it would also be important to find a better characterization of umbral character sets that strengthens the separativity and completeness conditions given before example [ ex : separative ] . first of all we would like to acknowledge georg regensburger , who has worked with the first author on an earlier ( much more specialized and mathematically flawed ) version of localization . we thank him also for his insight about monic common left multiples and the corresponding reference ( last paragraph of proposition [ prop : left - ext ] ) . we express our gratitude also to a. bostan for his pertinent remarks on left common multiples in the weyl algebra ( see the remark after the proof of proposition [ prop : left - ext ] ) . furthermore , we are grateful for illuminating discussions with i. dimovski and m. spiridonova . | we set up a left ring of fractions over a certain ring of boundary problems for linear ordinary differential equations . the fraction ring acts naturally on a new module of generalized functions . the latter includes an isomorphic copy of the differential algebra underlying the given ring of boundary problems . our methodology employs noncommutative localization in the theory of integro - differential algebras and operators . the resulting structure allows to build a symbolic calculus in the style of heaviside and mikusiski , but with the added benefit of incorporating boundary conditions where the traditional calculi allow only initial conditions . |
physics0510085 | the time projection chamber ( tpc ) for the future international linear collider will need to measure about 200 track points with a resolution of better than 100 @xmath1 m . the resolution goal , close to the fundamental limit from ionization electron statistics and transverse diffusion in the gas , is nearly two times better than what has been achieved by conventional wire / pad tpcs . a tpc with a micro pattern gas detector ( mpgd ) readout could , in principle , reach the target resolution . however , it may require sub - millimeter wide pads resulting in a large increase in the number of electronics channels , detector cost and complexity over conventional tpcs . we have recently developed a new concept of position sensing from charge dispersion in mpgds with a resistive anode @xcite . with charge dispersion wide readout pads similar in width to the ones used with proportional wire / cathode pad tpcs can be used without sacrificing resolution . this was demonstrated recently with cosmic ray tracks for a tpc read out with a gem with a resistive anode @xcite . we present here new results on the cosmic ray track resolution of a tpc read out with a micromegas instrumented for charge dispersion with a resistive anode . the gem and the micromegas tpc resolution measurements made with the resistive readout are compared to our earlier gem - tpc resolution results with a conventional readout @xcite and to the expected resolution from transverse diffusion and ionization electron statistics in a gaseous tpc . a small 15 cm drift length test tpc used earlier with a conventional direct charge gem readout @xcite was modified for charge dispersion studies . the readout endcap was modified such that it could accommodate either a gem or a micromegas with a resistive anode @xcite readout system . the gas used , ar : co@xmath2/90:10 , was chosen to simulate the reduced transverse diffusion conditions of a tpc in a magnetic field . charge signals on 60 pads , 2 mm x 6 mm each ( see figure [ simulation ] ) , were read out using aleph wire tpc preamplifiers and digitized directly using 200 mhz custom built 8 bit fadcs . track reconstruction techniques used for the conventional direct charge gem - tpc readout @xcite can not be used for the resistive anode mpgd readout since non charge collecting pads nearby also have measurable signals . not only the observed amplitude , but also the pulse shape depends on the relative location of the pad with respect to the track path . in theory , a first principle determination of the track prf is possible . for the present , we have chosen to determine the prf empirically from the internal consistency of cosmic ray track data . for the purpose of analysis , the cosmic ray data were divided into two parts ; one used for calibration and the other for resolution studies . we use the calibration data set to determine the prf associated with the pads in a given row . the prfs were determined for 15 seperate 1 cm wide regions in drift distance . figure [ prfs ] shows examples of prfs for the gem and the micromegas readout . the measured prfs have been parameterized with a ratio of two symmetric 4th order polynomials : @xmath3 the coefficients of the two 4th order polynomials @xmath4 and @xmath5 , and @xmath6 and @xmath7 can be expressed in terms of the fwhm @xmath8 , the base width @xmath9 of the prf , and two scale defining parameters a and b. the track fitting parameters @xmath10 and @xmath11 are determined by fitting the prf to the pad amplitudes for the full event by @xmath12 minimization . the position in a row @xmath13 is determined from a seperate one - parameter track fit to this row only using the known track angle @xmath11 . figure [ bias ] shows examples of bias in position determination with gems and micromegas . the bias is the mean difference @xmath14 as a function of @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is the @xmath17 position of the row . a bias of up to 150 @xmath0 m is observed which may be attributed to a non - uniform rc constant due to inhomogeneities in the gap size and the resistivity of the foil . however , this bias is due to geometry only and can easily be corrected . figure [ bias ] also shows the remaining bias after correction , which is negligible . figure [ res1 ] shows the measured resolution for ar : co@xmath2/90:10 . with gems we have results with and without the resistive anode ; for micromegas we have results with the resistive anode only . the resolution is fitted to the function : @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the resolution at zero drift distance @xmath20 . here @xmath21 is the diffusion constant and @xmath22 is the effective number of track ionization electrons over the length of a pad . @xmath22 is not the average number of electrons . rather , it is given by : @xmath23 , where n is the number of electrons following the landau distribution . n is determined from the measured pad - signal amplitudes scaled using the most probable number of track ionization electrons obtained from simulation . electronic noise and remaining systematic effects contribute to the constant term @xmath19 . the constant term @xmath19 is about 75@xmath1 m for the resistive readout for both the gem and the micromegas . it can be compared to the larger 97@xmath1 m constant term for the normal gem readout . as shown in figure [ res1 ] , the tpc resolution obtained with the resistive anode readout for both the gem and the micromegas is better than our previous result with a conventional gem readout @xcite , where at long drift distance the observed resolution was about 40% worse than expected . apart from the constant term , the dependence of resolution on drift distance with the resistive readout follows the expectation from transverse diffusion in the gas and electron statistics . in summary , the charge dispersion on a resistive anode improves the mpgd - tpc resolution significantly over that achievable with conventional direct charge readout for 2 mm wide pads . bias errors due to rc inhomogeneities can be corrected . with no magnetic field , the measured dependence of resolution on drift distance follows the behavior expected from transverse diffusion in the gas . we wish to thank ron settles for lending us the aleph wire tpc amplifiers used in these measurements . the research was supported by a project grant from the natural science and engineering research council of canada and the ontario premier s research excellence award ( iprea ) . 9 m.s.dixit , j. dubeau , j .- p.martin , and k.sachs , `` position sensing from charge dispersion in micro - pattern gas detectors with a resistive anode '' , nuclear instruments and methods in physics research a518 ( 2004 ) 721 . r.k.carnegie , m.s.dixit , h.mes , e.neuheimer , a.rankin , k.sachs and j .- p.martin , `` 1st tracking experience for mpgd tpc readout with charge dispersion on a resistive anode '' , international conference on linear e@xmath24e@xmath25 colliders , lcws2004 , paris ( 2004 ) r.k.carnegie , m.s.dixit , j.dubeau , d.karlen , j .- p.martin , h.mes , and k.sachs , `` resolution studies of cosmic ray tracks in a tpc with gem readout '' , nuclear instruments and methods in physics research , a538 ( 2004 ) 372 . | ( 0,0 ) ( 120,88 ) the time projection chamber ( tpc ) for the international linear collider will need to measure about 200 track points with a resolution close to 100 @xmath0 m . a micro pattern gas detector ( mpgd ) readout tpc could achieve the desired resolution with existing techniques using sub - millimeter width pads at the expense of a large increase in the detector cost and complexity . we have recently applied a new mpgd readout concept of charge dispersion to a prototype gem - tpc and demonstrated the feasibility of achieving good resolution with pads similar in width to the ones used for the proportional wire tpc . the charge dispersion studies were repeated with a micromegas tpc amplification stage . we present here our first results on the micromegas - tpc resolution with charge dispersion . the tpc resolution with the micromegas readout is compared to our earlier gem results and to the resolution expected from electron statistics and transverse diffusion in a gaseous tpc . |
0906.2190 | non - gaussianity of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) is progressively becoming a crucial probe of the inflationary dynamics , since models beyond single field slow - roll inflation predict large distinct non - gaussianities above the current limit of measurement ( lyth et al . 2003 , 2006 ; bartolo et al . 2004 ; dvali et al . 2004 ; chen 2005 ; seery & lidsey 2005 ; chen & szapudi 2006 ; seery & hidalgo 2006 ; ling & wu 2008 ; senatore et al . 2008 , 2009 ; chen et al . moreover , up - to - date a number of plausible alternative early universe models also predict skewed primordial fluctuations , and are in principle distinguishable from other scenarios through the shape dependence of high - order correlation functions ( alishahiha et al . 2004 ; arkani - hamed et al . 2004 ; creminelli & senatore 2007 ; brandenberger 2008 ; buchbinder , khoury & ovrut 2008 ; lehners & steinhardt 2008 ; mcallister & silverstein 2008 ) . an even small degree of primordial non - gaussianity would indicate a quite different structure formation scenario from the concordance cosmological model in which density perturbations are assumed to be a gaussian random field , and alter significantly the statistics of voids ( kamionkowski et al . 2008 ; song & lee 2008 , for example ) . imprints of primordial non - gaussianity can manifest in the statistical properties of the lyman-@xmath0 forest qso spectra at intermediate redshift ( viel et al . 2008 ) , in the large - scale distribution of neutral hydrogen ( pillepich et al . 2007 ) , in the reionization history of the universe ( crociani et al . 2008 ) , and in the abundance , clustering and biasing of dark matter halos ( kang et al . 2007 ; carbone et al . 2008 ; dalal et al . 2008 ; desjacques et al . 2008 ; grossi et al . 2008 ; loverde et al . 2008 ; matarrese & verde 2008 ; mcdonald & seljak 2008 ; pillepich et al . 2008 ; seljak 2008 ; slosar et al . 2008 ; jeong & komatsu 2009 ) . topology of the large scale structure is also very sensitive to the initial conditions of the matter density field , and potentially represents a strong and independent test of deviations from the gaussian hypothesis ( park et al . 1998 , 2001 , 2005 ; gott et al . 2008a , b ; hikage et al . 2008b ) . hence , there is significant interest in quantifying the gaussianity of the cosmic background radiation , and a multitude of non - gaussian estimators have been applied so far . in particular , data from the _ _ w__ilkinson _ _ m__icrowave _ _ a__nisotropy _ _ p__robe ( wmap ) mission has been used to constrain primordial non - gaussianity . recent measurements of the one- and three - point probability functions , the bispectrum and trispectrum , the genus statistic and the other minkowski functionals ( cabella et al . 2005 ; hinshaw et al . 2007 , 2008 ; creminelli et al . 2007 ; gott et al . 2007 ; spergel et al . 2007 ; curto et al . 2008 ; hikage et al . 2008a ; komatsu et al . 2008 ; vielva & sanz 2008 ; pietrobon et al . 2009a ) from the first three or five years of wmap data are all consistent with gaussianity . however , a considerable number of anomalies like asymmetries , intrinsic alignments in the data or the presence of unusual cold spots have also been reported ( cruz et al . 2006 ; tojeiro et al . 2006 ; chiang et al . 2007 ; naselsky et al . 2007 ; rth et al . 2007 , 2009 ; vielva et al . 2007 ; hansen et al . 2008 ; dickinson et al . 2009 ; diego et al . 2009 ; li et al . 2009 ; pietrobon et al . 2009b ; rossmanith et al . 2009 ) , as well as some claims of non - gaussianity ( jeong & smoot 2007 ; yadav & wandelt 2008 ) , which , if confirmed , would rule out a large class of inflationary models . in this paper we investigate the gaussian hypothesis using the clustering statistics of pixels that lie above or below a threshold . for a gaussian field , the scale dependence of this statistic , and its dependence on threshold , have been predicted ( jensen & szalay 1986 ) . it turns out that a careful accounting for the effects of noise is crucial to performing this test . kashlinsky et al . ( 2001 ) and hernndez - monteagudo et al . ( 2004 ) presented an analysis of the problem when the noise is spatially homogeneous . in the case of wmap , the noise is spatially inhomogeneous ; the present work shows how to incorporate this complexity into the analysis . the layout of the paper is as follows . in section [ noise_model ] we outline the theoretical framework for the two - point statistics above a temperature threshold , and show how to incorporate the complexity of inhomogeneous noise into the two - point formalism . some details on errorbar calculations are left in appendix a. in section [ wmap5 analysis ] we test our theory against wmap five - year data . we study and quantify the inhomogeneous noise properties and show that the abundance and clustering of pixels ( both scale and dependence on threshold temperature ) appears to be inconsistent with the gaussian prediction if one ignores the fact that the noise is spatially inhomogeneous . we compare the number density of pixels above threshold and the one- and two - point statistics measurements with the theory , allowing for inhomogeneous noise . while this improves the agreement between measurements and predictions , discrepancies remain . although this may be an indication of primordial non - gaussianity , we discuss a variety of other possibilities , among which the effect of smoothing the map . we inspect all the wmap five - year channels , but we present in the main text results only for the w1 differencing assembly ( da ) , and leave in appendix b results for other da s . a final section summarizes our findings , and highlights ongoing and future studies . denote the observed value in a pixel by @xmath1 , which is the sum of the true signal @xmath2 plus noise @xmath3 , both of which have mean zero . we consider a model in which the signal is homogeneous and may have spatial correlations whereas the noise , which is independent of the signal , may be inhomogeneous and have spatial correlations . by this we mean that the rms value of the noise @xmath4 may fluctuate from pixel to pixel and these fluctuations may be correlated , and that the actual value of the noise in one pixel could depend of that in another . let @xmath5 denote the observed one - point distribution of @xmath6 , @xmath7 the distribution of @xmath2 , @xmath8 the distribution of the rms value of the noise in a pixel , and @xmath9 the distribution of the noise when the rms value of the noise is @xmath4 . note that @xmath10 . our convention is to use capital letters for average quantities , and lower case letters for actual ( varying ) quantities . later on in the paper we will also drop the ( understood ) subscript @xmath3 of the rms of the noise , for clarity of notation . since the distribution of the noise @xmath11 is independent of the signal @xmath2 , @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the dirac delta and @xmath14 the variance of @xmath6 is : @xmath15 where we have used @xmath16 to denote the rms value of the signal , and @xmath17 to denote the variance of the noise upon averaging over all pixels . it is also straightforward to show that @xmath18 , as expected . the fraction of pixels above some threshold @xmath19 is @xmath20 if @xmath21 denotes the mean value of @xmath6 in such pixels , then @xmath22 two point statistics may be computed similarly . for two pixels separated by the angular distance @xmath23 , @xmath24 where @xmath25 notice that if we integrate over all pixels then @xmath26 where @xmath27 and @xmath28 this is because the signal and noise are uncorrelated , and so @xmath29 for all @xmath30 . clearly , if the noise is not spatially correlated , then @xmath31 and @xmath32 . if the rms values of the noise are perfectly correlated , meaning @xmath33 , then it is convenient to write @xmath34 and replace @xmath35 with a delta function centered on @xmath36 . one then averages over the distribution of @xmath4 , namely : @xmath37 if , in addition , one replaces @xmath8 with a delta function centered on @xmath38 , then @xmath39 , and the homogeneous case is recovered . the noise distributions @xmath8 and @xmath40 are measured directly from the wmap five - year data . the two - point unweighted correlation function @xmath41 estimates the excess of probability of finding a pair at a distance @xmath23 , compared to a random catalog ( e.g. jensen & szalay , 1986 ) . similarly , one can define the two - point weighted correlation function @xmath42 , which differs from @xmath41 only because each member of the pair is now weighted by some ( average ) mark . in this study , the mark is given by @xmath43 . two - point correlation functions of regions above some threshold are readily obtained by integration above the threshold level . within the formalism previously outlined , the two point correlation function of pixels above some threshold @xmath19 is @xmath44 and the associated weighted function is @xmath45 where @xmath46 , @xmath47 and @xmath48 have been previously defined . to gain intuition , it is helpful to define @xmath49 and @xmath50 in terms of which @xmath51 \label{xiintuit}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath52 . \label{wiintuit}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this shows that @xmath53 and @xmath54 can be thought of as weighted averages over the values at fixed @xmath55 and @xmath56 . this re - writing shows clearly that the key quantity of interest are @xmath57 , which is the convolution of the signal and noise distributions , and @xmath58 . this rewriting also allows one to study two limiting cases . if the rms values of the noise are perfectly correlated , meaning @xmath59 , then : @xmath60 and @xmath61 if , in addition , one replaces @xmath8 with a delta function centered on @xmath38 , then @xmath62 and @xmath63 we are particularly interested in the case where the signal @xmath64 is bivariate gaussian with @xmath65 , and @xmath66 and the noise @xmath9 is gaussian with rms @xmath4 . then @xmath67 with @xmath68 , @xmath69 , and @xmath70 @xmath71 @xmath72 where @xmath73 is the covariance matrix of the temperature field , @xmath74 the power spectrum of the noise map , @xmath75 the _ wmap _ window function and @xmath76 the additional smoothing due to finite pixel size , mask influence and an optional additional gaussian beam smoothing . if the noise is spatially uncorrelated , then clearly @xmath77 and therefore @xmath78 . in the approximation where @xmath33 , rms noise varies spatially on scales much larger than those of interest , then @xmath79 . the `` standard '' approximation , rms noise independent of position , has @xmath80 and we recover the hernndez - monteagudo et al . ( 2004 ) formula . uncertainties in the correlation functions above threshold are estimated from the optimal variance limit , containing cosmic variance , instrumental noise ( knox 1995 ; hernndez - monteagudo et al . 2004 ) , and finite binsize effects . see appendix a for more details . the data from the five years of the wmap mission are available online at _ _ _ a__rchive for _ _ m__icrowave _ _ b__ackground _ _ da__ta ( lambda ) website ( http://lambda.gsfc.nasa.gov/ ) , nasa s cmb thematic data center . for the purposes of this study , we use the wmap five - year full resolution `` foreground - reduced '' coadded sky maps ( produced by performing a weighted pixel - by - pixel mean of the five single year maps , see hinshaw et al . 2008 ) for the w ( the 94 ghz channel ) , v ( the 61 ghz channel ) and q ( the 41 ghz channel ) differencing assemblies . we show results for the w1 channel in the main text , and leave in appendix b major results for all the other individual da s . the data consist of four fields for each pixel : 1 . the thermodynamic temperature in mk , 2 . the q polarization temperature in mk , 3 . the u polarization temperature in mk , and 4 . the effective number of observations , @xmath81 . the maps are provided in the healpix scheme ( grski et al . 1999 ) at a resolution of @xmath82 , giving a total of 3145728 pixels separated on average by @xmath83 . the maps have been cleaned of galactic foreground emission using external templates , as explained in gold et al . it is indeed necessary to mask out regions of strong foreground emission . of the different masks provided from the lambda legacy archive , which allow for the selective exclusion of portions of the sky at different flux levels , we chose the most conservative , kq75 essentially an extension and improvement of the standard kp0 cut in the 3-yr data release . this choice removes about 28% of the pixels . point sources are masked based on a combination of external catalog data and wmap - detected sources ( wright et al . note that point sources are the largest astrophysical contaminant to the temperature power spectrum . our theory predictions ( section [ noise_model ] ) depend on the tt power spectrum , on the shape of the wmap beam , and on the noise properties . we used the beam and window transfer functions from the five - year wmap data , which have been significantly improved with the 5yr data release ; models of the instrument gain and beam response are now accurate to better than @xmath84 , and errors in the five - year beam transfer functions are reduced by a factor of @xmath85 as compared to the three - year analysis ( hill et al . the wmap5 tt power spectrum we use comes from a weighted combination of 153 individual cross - power spectra , and has been improved by using a gibbs - based maximum likelihood estimate for @xmath86 ( dunkley et al . 2008 ) and a pseudo @xmath87 estimate for higher @xmath88 ( nolta et al . the pixel - pixel covariance matrix is essentially diagonal ( hinshaw et al . 2003 , 2008 ) , so the rms noise in pixel @xmath89 is @xmath90 , where the noise per observation , @xmath91 , is provided for each coadded channel . this value for @xmath91 is obtained by averaging the values of the five possible year - by - year difference combinations ( jarosik et al . 2007 ; hinshaw et al . 2008 ) . the data reduction process should be free of contamination induced by foregrounds , and should be insensitive to monopole and dipole moments . at @xmath82 , the generic data pipeline involves the following main steps : 1 . dipole and monopole removal outside kq75 ; 2 . selection of pixels above a temperature threshold ; 3 . healpix coordinate and pixel - noise assignment . for the five - year coadded wmap data ( w1 channel ) , after application of the kq75 mask , in mollweide projection . the scale is logarithmic , in mk units i.e. @xmath92 is shown.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] for the wmap5 w1 coadded channel , after application of the kq75 mask.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] the distribution of the rms noise values in a pixel at @xmath82 is shown in mollweide projection in figure [ psigma_map ] , and as histogram in figure [ psigma_hist ] , for the wmap5 w1 channel . the distribution is reasonably broad , indicating that the noise is inhomogeneous . this is a direct consequence of the fact that not all pixels were observed the same number of times . the evident symmetrical pattern present in figure [ psigma_map ] is due to the scanning strategy of the wmap satellite . at @xmath82 resolution for four different choices of @xmath23 as indicated in the panels , from the wmap5 w1 coadded channel . [ psigma12],scaledwidth=49.0% ] in particular , equations ( [ xiintuit ] ) and ( [ wiintuit ] ) show that the clustering of pixels separated by @xmath23 depends on the joint distribution of @xmath93 given @xmath23 . figure [ psigma12 ] shows an example of how the joint distribution @xmath40 varies as a function of separation @xmath23 for the resolution @xmath82 . the four panels were constructed by randomly selecting @xmath94 pixels , and for each selected value of @xmath95 , looking at the corresponding @xmath56 distributions at four different angular distances . note that the scatter around the one - to - one line increases with increasing @xmath23 . this is not surprising ; nearby pixels have similar @xmath81 whereas more widely separated ones do not ( figure [ psigma_map ] ) . figure [ sigma12fits ] shows some examples of the corresponding conditional distributions @xmath96 . when inserted into equations ( [ xiintuit ] ) and ( [ wiintuit ] ) , such fits allow a prediction of how the clustering of pixels above a certain threshold temperature should depend on threshold if the signal is gaussian and the noise is inhomogeneous . the histogram in figure [ pdobs ] shows the distribution of temperature in the data , for the w1 coadded channel . for homogeneous noise , the predicted distribution would be given by convolving the expected signal ( in this case gaussian with variance determined by smoothing the best - fit power spectrum on the scale of a pixel ) with that of the noise ( gaussian with average rms @xmath38 ) . for inhomogeneous noise , the predicted distribution ( i.e. equation [ pd ] ) is given by convolving the expected gaussian signal with the noise of rms @xmath97 , and then weighting by the distribution of @xmath97 shown in figure [ psigma_hist ] . the dotted line in figure [ pdobs ] shows a gaussian with the same rms as the data . this fit has shorter tails than the data . while this may be indicating that the signal is non - gaussian ( in fact , the sample skewness of the temperature distribution is @xmath98 mk@xmath99 , and the sample excess kurtosis 0.12698 mk@xmath100 ) , the solid curve in figure [ pdobs ] shows the predicted distribution when inhomogeneous noise effects are included : it provides substantially better agreement with the measurements . nevertheless , the one - point distribution itself can not rule out a priori the presence of a non - gaussian signal , for reasons made explicit in fang & pando ( 1997 ) ; hence it is not a suitable statistics to investigate departures from gaussianity . this is also relevant for the detection of non - gaussianity claimed by jeong & smoot ( 2007 ) , where the one - point distribution was used . we also note that their equation ( 9 ) is missing one integration over the distribution of the noise ( see again our equation [ pd ] for comparison ) . for the wmap5 w1 channel ( histogram ) . solid line shows the expected distribution ( equation [ pd ] ) given the distribution of the noise . dotted line is a gaussian with the same rms as the data . [ pdobs],scaledwidth=45.0% ] , for the wmap5 w1 channel . points are measurements from the data . dotted line is the theoretical prediction for homogeneous noise , and solid line includes inhomogeneity . different temperature thresholds are considered , as explained in the main text.,scaledwidth=49.0% ] the number density of pixels above ( below ) a given temperature threshold is simply obtained by multiplying the fraction of pixels above ( below ) the threshold @xmath101 ( eq . [ fdt ] ) by the total number density after masking ( i.e. the total number of pixels after masking over the `` available '' or `` unmasked '' area ) . if the noise were homogeneous , then this prediction is rather straightforward : equation ( [ fdt ] ) simply reduces to @xmath102 , where @xmath103 . in practice , due to the inhomogeneity of the noise , one needs to integrate ( [ fdt ] ) numerically , using the distributions @xmath104 measured from the data ( figure [ psigma_hist ] ) . the solid lines in figure [ number_density_512 ] are the results of this integration , when accounting for inhomogeneous noise . dotted lines are the theoretical predictions which assume homogeneous noise . points in figure [ number_density_512 ] show measurements from the wmap5 w1 channel , for pixels above or below a threshold , where @xmath105 , respectively . errorbars are from a poisson analysis . while the solid lines slightly improve the fits , significant departures still remain , especially at higher thresholds . we have measured the correlation function of pixels above and below a threshold temperature from the wmap five - year coadded maps , for a range of thresholds . in each case , we measured the signal in two ways : one in which all pixels are treated equally , and another in which the pixels are weighted by their temperature . we adopt here the standard estimator @xmath106 for the correlation function ( jensen & szalay 1986 ) , where @xmath107 and @xmath108 are the number of data and random pairs , respectively . in particular , the number of random pairs is computed by distributing random points on a unit sphere , and then by applying the same procedures ( i.e. kq75 masking and healpix coordinate assignment ) as for the data pipeline . for the weighted correlation estimates , the number of data pairs , @xmath107 , is simply replaced by its temperature weighted counterpart , @xmath109 . we also tested the landy & szalay ( 1993 ) and the hamilton ( 1993 ) estimators , and found no significant differences in the calculations . figures [ xihi ] and [ wihi ] show an example of the results for pixels with @xmath110 , @xmath111 , @xmath112 , @xmath113 , @xmath114 and @xmath115 , respectively . in all panels , symbols show the measurements of hot and cold pixels at the fixed threshold ; errors are from a poisson analysis . dotted curves in all the left panels show the results based on homogeneous noise , solid curves in all the right panels account for the fact that the noise is inhomogeneous ( equations [ xitheta ] and [ wtheta ] ) . shaded areas are derived as explained in appendix a ( see also hernndez - monteagudo et al . 2004 ) , and represent the @xmath116 optimal variance errors . accounting for inhomogeneity significantly improves the fit to the data . however , discrepancies between the observed correlation functions and the theoretical predictions still remain , especially for pixels at higher thresholds , or at small angular scales . in particular , we note the interesting fact that hot and cold pixels cluster differently within the same temperature thresholds . this feature is also present in all the other wmap5 channels ( see appendix b ) , but we find that our theory is always in good agreement with the clustering of cold pixels in the q and v frequency bands , and only in slight disagreement with the hot patch clustering , especially for pixels at higher thresholds . moreover , the fact that the wmap5 data appear to be systematically stronger ( weaker ) at small ( large ) angular scales than the theoretical predictions , even at lower temperature thresholds ( figures [ xihi ] and [ wihi ] ) , is particularly true in the w channel ( see figure [ cf_512_nu_0.25_0.75_app ] for comparison ) . we suggest some possible interpretations in the discussion section and in appendix b , and present a more detailed investigation of this effect using realistic non - gaussian mock simulations in a forthcoming paper . while the detected trend may be a unique signature of primordial non - gaussianity ( i.e. a primordial non - gaussianity would in fact enhance the clustering of the cold pixels and reduce that of the hot ones ) , we study the effect of smoothing the map next , and provide some other plausible explanations for these anomalies in the final section . we have investigated the effect of smoothing the wmap five - year maps with a gaussian beam . in particular , we have tried different smoothing scales , corresponding to a fwhm of @xmath117 , @xmath118 , @xmath119 and @xmath120 , respectively . we have repeated the same analysis as for the unsmoothed maps , and characterized the number density and the clustering statistics of pixels above threshold . figure [ number_density_512_smooth ] summarizes the results for the number density ( w1 channel ) , after smoothing with different gaussian beams . the number of pixels above or below the considered temperature threshold is reduced ( a function of the smoothing scale ) , and measurements from the data and theoretical predictions appear now in agreement within about @xmath116 at the threshold levels considered . finally , we have characterized the clustering statistics and showed in figure [ clustering_smooth_512 ] the case of inhomogeneous noise , for an arbitrary choice of the threshold ( @xmath121 ) . the gaussian smoothing is included in our theory via equations ( [ ctheta_eq ] ) and ( [ ctheta_noise ] ) , in addition to the change of the noise variance distribution . after smoothing the map with a gaussian beam , the pixel noise may be no longer independent among different pixels ( i.e. @xmath122 ) . however , accounting for this contribution ( equation [ n1n2_cov ] ) resulted in no significant difference , even at small angular scales . in fact , the average variance of the noise in the w1 channel is 0.0213 mk@xmath123 , which is about 0.32@xmath124 of the typical variance of the corresponding cosmological signal . since the zero - level amplitude of the noise is already very low with respect to that of the signal , the mean amplitude of the correlated noise will be also very low . in addition to that , note that the wmap mission has been designed to have uncorrelated pixel noise , and if such correlations arise when smoothing the maps , their amplitude is expected to drop quickly with the smoothing scale . when the smoothing scale is @xmath120 , we find that the tension between data and theory is alleviated . the observed distribution of temperatures in wmap5 pixels is slightly non - gaussian ( figure [ pdobs ] ) . this departure from gaussianity is not unexpected if the intrinsic signal is gaussian but the noise distribution is inhomogeneous white noise ( figures [ psigma_map ] and [ psigma_hist ] ) . in fact , when accounting for inhomogeneous noise ( section [ noise_model ] ) , we find that the one - point statistics is substantially in better agreement with the measurements . however , the predicted dependence of clustering on pixel height is not in good agreement with the data , even after accounting for the inhomogeneity of the noise ( figures [ xihi ] , [ wihi ] ) . although we found that an appropriate smoothing scale would be able to alleviate the discrepancy between data and measurements ( figures [ number_density_512_smooth ] and [ clustering_smooth_512 ] ) , other possible reasons for these discrepancies are : + _ masking procedure_. in our analysis we adopted the kq75 mask , which allows for selective exclusions of bright portions of the sky ( @xmath125 pixel cut ) . although this is rather a drastic cut and the mask was significantly improved with the wmap five - year data release ( hill et al . 2008 ) , it may not completely account for all the galactic foreground effects . however , cutting out all the galactic plane ( @xmath126 strip ) and repeating our analysis resulted in no significant change . edge effects due to pixels which lie very close to the mask could also affect our analysis . + _ cold spot contamination_. inoue & silk ( 2007 ) suggest that the presence of low density regions in the southern galactic cap could account for our anomalies , but restricting our analysis to @xmath127 , the northern galactic cap , resulted in no significant change . + _ contamination by point sources_. lopez - caniego et al . ( 2007 ) detected 98 new sources ( i.e. @xmath128 ) not present in the wmap three - year catalog . at higher frequencies wmap estimates neglect the deviations of the point spread function from a gaussian shape , and carry out a blind search for sources . with the wmap five - year data release , the mask for point sources has been significantly improved ( wright et al . 2008 ) , and other studies ( gonzalez - nuevo et al . 2008 ; chen & wright 2008 ) updated the point source catalog . however , massardi et al . ( 2008 ) recently provided a new version of the catalog based on wmap5 data and found new point sources ( 484 sources detected ) , carrying a complementary blind and non - blind approach . this may be important to our analysis , since even a very low level contamination in the maps can produce spurious non - gaussianities . in fact , we find some discrepancies at small angular scales ( around 20 ) especially in the w band , and their origin may be associated with extragalactic dust emission ( one type of point - source contamination ) , which peaks at high frequencies . in a forthcoming study , we will be addressing the effect of contamination induced by point sources in more depth , using an updated version of the source catalog and mock simulations . + _ foreground subtraction contamination_. uncertainties in the external foreground template model used for the foreground subtractions ( gold et al . 2008 ) may introduce anomalies at the percentage level . the template itself has noise , which may be correlated at small separations . this is a delicate issue , since galactic foregrounds are non - gaussian and anisotropic , and even low level contamination in the maps can produce detectable non - gaussianities ( park et al . 2002 ; naselsky et al . 2005 ; kim , naselsky & christensen 2008 ) . on the other side , it is also worth noticing that recently vio & andreani ( 2008 ) showed that the benefits of using more sophisticated methods for foreground cleaning , such as the harmonic internal linear combination , are overestimated . we are also addressing the foreground subtraction systematics in a forthcoming study . + _ wmap beam , window function , absolute calibration and pixel - noise uncertainties_. window functions were computed from the symmetrized beam profiles following the hermite method in page et al . a typical wmap window function has an uncertainty of @xmath129 ( hill et al . 2008 ) , and these uncertainties add in quadrature in the cosmological analysis . absolute calibration uncertainties in the five - year wmap data are estimated to be @xmath130 ( hinshaw et al . recent studies ( groeneboom et al . 2009 ; kathrine wehus et al . 2009 ) have also pointed out that the noise levels of these maps are underestimated , and that there are some problems with the standard wmap transfer functions as well . it may be that these facts play an important rule in our study ( see also colombo et al . + _ secondary anisotropies and phase transitions in the early universe_. spurious non - gaussianities could arise from secondary anisotropies , such as gravitational lensing , sunyaev - zeldovich effect or sachs - wolfe effects ( babich & pierpaoli 2008 ; carbone et al . phase transitions in the early universe may also introduce a new source of non - gaussianity ( silvestri & trodden 2008 ) . all these effects may be difficult to disentangle from a pure primordial non - gaussian signal , even after a clear detection of primordial non - gaussianity . _ real non - gaussian signatures at small scales_. a better understanding of all the previous points is necessary before we can claim that the signal we see is due to primordial non - gaussianity . however , we found an interesting difference in the clustering of hot and cold pixels within the same temperature threshold level ; this fact may be a unique signature of primordial non - gaussianity . we present a detailed investigation of this feature in a forthcoming study . we finally note that , as this work was being refereed , hou et al . ( 2009 ) presented a frequentist analysis of the correlation functions of the local extrema , and also found inconsistency with gaussian simulations plus differences in the clustering of hot and cold peaks although comparison with their work is not direct since they considered bigger angular scales . while seeking for primordial non - gaussianity is at the moment a new frontier in cosmology , ongoing efforts are currently devoted to the characterization of non - gaussian confusion effects , to reliable theoretical predictions of non - gaussianity from models ( see for example boyle & steinhardt 2008 ; fergusson & shellard 2008 ; munshi & heavens 2009 ) , till the extraction of information from data ( i.e. raeth et al . 2008 ; gong et al . 2009 ) or the search for observational signatures of primordial non - gaussianity imprinted in the large - scale structure of the universe . even a small degree of primordial non - gaussianity can be a crucial probe of the inflationary dynamics or alternative universe models , hence studies of non - gaussianity may eventually become a powerful and solid probe of ultra - high energy physics and inflation . we note that our model for the effects of inhomogeneous noise may be useful in other studies ( see for instance yu & lu 2008 ) . extending our formalism for inhomogeneous noise to peak rather than pixel statistics ( for example heavens & sheth 1999 ; heavens & gupta 2001 ) is more complicated ; this will complement numerical monte - carlo analyses of this problem ( larson & wandelt 2004 ; tojeiro et al . 2006 ; ayaita et al . 2009 ; hou et al . 2009 ) , and is the subject of work in progress . we thank an anonymous referee for helpful comments and suggestions . gr thanks fernando atrio - barandela , pravabati chingangbam , jacek guzik , mike jarvis and licia verde for many useful discussions . gr is grateful to the organizers of the 24th texas symposium on relativistic astrophysics for their kind hospitality in vancouver , during which time he had interesting conversations with eiichiro komatsu and the final stage of this work was completed . gr would also like to thank kitpc and in particular robert brandenberger for hospitality in beijing during the 2009 workshop `` connecting fundamental physics with observations '' . cbp acknowledges the support of the korea science and engineering foundation ( kosef ) through the astrophysical research center for the structure and evolution of the cosmos ( arcsec ) . we acknowledge the use of the _ _ l__egacy _ _ a__rchive for _ _ m__icrowave _ _ b__ackground _ _ d__ata _ _ a__nalysis ( _ lambda _ ) , support for which is provided by the national aeronautics and space administration ( nasa ) office of space science . some of the results in this paper have been derived using the _ healpix _ package ( grski et al . this work was partly supported by nasa grant nng05gk81 g , and partly by the project of knowledge innovation program ( pkip ) of chinese academy of sciences , grant no . kjcx2.yw.w10 . 99 alishahiha , m. , silverstein , e. , & tong , d. 2004 , phys . d , 70 , 123505 arkani - hamed , n. , creminelli , p. , mukohyama , s. , & zaldarriaga , m. 2004 , journal of cosmology and astro - particle physics , 4 , 1 ayaita , y. , weber , m. , & wetterich , c. 2009 , arxiv:0905.3324 babich , d. , & pierpaoli , e. 2008 , phys . rev . d , 77 , 123011 bartolo , n. , komatsu , e. , matarrese , s. , & riotto , a. 2004 , phys . rep . , 402 , 103 bond , j. r. , & efstathiou , g. 1987 , mnras , 226 , 655 boyle , l. , & steinhardt , p. j. 2008 , arxiv:0810.2787 brandenberger , r. h. 2008 , arxiv:0808.0746 buchbinder , e. i. , khoury , j. , & ovrut , b. a. 2008 , physical review letters , 100 , 171302 cabella , p. , liguori , m. , hansen , f. k. , marinucci , d. , matarrese , s. , moscardini , l. , & vittorio , n. 2005 , mnras , 358 , 684 carbone , c. , verde , l. , & matarrese , s. 2008 , apj , 684 , l1 chen , g. , & szapudi , i. 2006 , apj , 647 , l87 chen , x. 2005 , phys . rev . d , 72 , 123518 chen , x. , & wright , e. l. 2008 , arxiv:0809.4025 chen , x. , hu , b. , huang , m .- x . , shiu , g. , & wang , y. 2009 , arxiv:0905.3494 chiang , l .- y . , naselsky , p. d. , & coles , p. 2007 , apj , 664 , 8 colombo , l. p. l. , pierpaoli , e. , & pritchard , j. r. 2008 , arxiv:0811.2622 creminelli , p. , senatore , l. , zaldarriaga , m. , & tegmark , m. 2007 , journal of cosmology and astro - particle physics , 3 , 5 creminelli , p. , & senatore , l. 2007 , journal of cosmology and astro - particle physics , 11 , 10 crociani , d. , moscardini , l. , viel , m. , & matarrese , s. 2008 , arxiv:0809.3909 cruz , m. , tucci , m.,martnez - gonzlez , e. , & vielva , p. 2006 , mnras , 369 , 57 curto , a. , martinez - gonzalez , e. , mukherjee , p. , barreiro , r. b. , hansen , f. k. , liguori , m. , & matarrese , s. 2008 , arxiv:0807.0231 dalal , n. , dor , o. , huterer , d. , & shirokov , a. 2008 , phys . rev . d , 77 , 123514 desjacques , v. , seljak , u. , & iliev , i. t. 2008 , arxiv:0811.2748 dickinson , c. , et al . 2009 , arxiv:0903.4311 diego , j. m , cruz , m. , gonzalez - nuevo , j. , maris , m. , ascasibar , y. , & burigana , c. 2009 , arxiv:0901.4344 dunkley , j. , et al . 2008 , arxiv:0803.0586 dvali , g. , gruzinov , a. , & zaldarriaga , m. 2004 , phys . d , 69 , 083505 fang , l .- z . , & pando , j. 1997 , arxiv : astro - ph/9701228 fergusson , j. r. , & shellard , e. p. s. 2008 , arxiv:0812.3413 grski , k. m. et al . , 1999 , in proc . mpa / eso conf . `` evolution of large - scale structure : from recombination to garching '' gold , b. , et al . 2008 , arxiv:0803.0715 gong , y. , wang , x. , zheng , z. , & chen , x. 2009 , arxiv:0904.4257 gonzlez - nuevo , j. , massardi , m. , argeso , f. , herranz , d. , toffolatti , l. , sanz , j. l. , lpez - caniego , m. , & de zotti , g. 2008 , mnras , 384 , 711 gott , j. r. , colley , w. n. , park , c .- g . , park , c. , & mugnolo , c. 2007 , mnras , 377 , 1668 gott , j. r. i. , et al . 2008 , apj , 675 , 16 gott , j. r. i. , choi , y .- y . , park , c. , kim , j. , & for the sdss collaboration 2008 , arxiv:0812.1406 groeneboom , n. e. , eriksen , h. k. , gorski , k. , huey , g. , jewell , j. , & wandelt , b. 2009 , arxiv:0904.2554 grossi , m. , branchini , e. , dolag , k. , matarrese , s. , & moscardini , l. 2008 , mnras , 390 , 438 hamilton , a. j. s. 1993 , evolution of galaxies and their environment , 15 hansen , f. k. , banday , a. j. , gorski , k. m. , eriksen , h. k. , & lilje , p. b. 2008 , arxiv:0812.3795 heavens , a. f. , & gupta , s. 2001 , mnras , 324 , 960 heavens , a. f. , & sheth , r. k. 1999 , mnras , 310 , 1062 hernndez - monteagudo , c. , kashlinsky , a. , & atrio - barandela , f . 2004 , a@xmath131a , 413 , 833 hikage , c. , coles , p. , grossi , m. , moscardini , l. , dolag , k. , branchini , e. , & matarrese , s. 2008 , mnras , 385 , 1613 hikage , c. , matsubara , t. , coles , p. , liguori , m. , hansen , f. k. , & matarrese , s. 2008 , mnras , 389 , 1439 hill , r. s. , et al . 2008 , arxiv:0803.0570 hinshaw , g. , et al . 2003 , apjs , 148 , 135 hinshaw , g. , et al . 2007 , apjs , 170 , 288 hinshaw , g. , et al . 2008 , arxiv:0803.0732 hou , z. , banday , a. j. , & gorski , k. m. 2009 , arxiv:0903.4446 inoue , k. t. , & silk , j. 2007 , apj , 664 , 650 jarosik , n. , et al . 2007 , apjs , 170 , 263 jensen , l. g. , & szalay , a. s. 1986 , apj , 305 , l5 jeong , d. , & komatsu , e. 2009 , arxiv:0904.0497 jeong , e. , & smoot , g. f. 2007 , arxiv:0710.2371 kamionkowski , m. , verde , l. , & jimenez , r. 2008 , arxiv:0809.0506 kang , x. , norberg , p. , & silk , j. 2007 , mnras , 376 , 343 kashlinsky , a. , hernndez - monteagudo , c. , & atrio - barandela , f. 2001 , apj , 557 , l1 kathrine wehus , i. , ackerman , l. , eriksen , h. k. , & groeneboom , n. e. 2009 , arxiv:0904.3998 kim , j. , naselsky , p. , & christensen , p. r. 2008 , arxiv:0810.4008 knox , l. 1995 , phys . d , 52 , 4307 komatsu , e. , et al . 2008 , arxiv:0803.0547 landy , s. d. , & szalay , a. s. 1993 , apj , 412 , 64 larson , d. l. , & wandelt , b. d. 2004 , apj , 613 , l85 lehners , j .- l . , & steinhardt , p. j. 2008 , phys . d , 77 , 063533 li , t .- , liu , h. , song , l .- m . , xiong , s .- l . , & nie , j .- y . 2009 , arxiv:0905.0075 ling , y. , & wu , j .- p . 2008 , arxiv:0809.3398 lpez - caniego , m. , gonzlez - nuevo , j. , herranz , d. , massardi , m. , sanz , j. l. , de zotti , g. , toffolatti , l. , & argeso , f. 2007 , apjs , 170 , 108 lo verde , m. , miller , a. , shandera , s. , & verde , l. 2008 , journal of cosmology and astro - particle physics , 4 , 14 lyth , d. h. , ungarelli , c. , & wands , d. 2003 , phys . d , 67 , 023503 lyth , d. h. , & riotto , a. 2006 , physical review letters , 97 , 121301 massardi , m. , lpez - caniego , m. , gonzlez - nuevo , j. , herranz , d. , de zotti , g. , & sanz , j. l. 2008 , arxiv:0810.2338 matarrese , s. , & verde , l. 2008 , apj , 677 , l77 mcallister , l. , & silverstein , e. 2008 , general relativity and gravitation , 40 , 565 mcdonald , p. , & seljak , u. 2008 , arxiv:0810.0323 munshi , d. , & heavens , a. 2009 , arxiv:0904.4478 naselsky , p. , chiang , l .- y . , olesen , p. , & novikov , i. 2005 , phys . d , 72 , 063512 naselsky , p. d. , christensen , p. r. , coles , p. , verkhodanov , o. , novikov , d. , & kim , j. 2007 , arxiv:0712.1118 nolta , m. r. , et al . 2008 , arxiv:0803.0593 page , l. , et al . 2003 , apjs , 148 , 39 park , c. , colley , w. n. , gott , j. r. i. , ratra , b. , spergel , d. n. , & sugiyama , n. 1998 , apj , 506 , 473 park , c. , gott , j. r. i. , & choi , y. j. 2001 , apj , 553 , 33 park , c .- g . , park , c. , & ratra , b. 2002 , apj , 568 , 9 park , c. , et al . 2005 , apj , 633 , 11 pietrobon , d. , cabella , p. , balbi , a. , de gasperis , g. , & vittorio , n. 2009 , mnras , 682 pietrobon , d. , cabella , p. , balbi , a. , crittenden , r. , de gasperis , g. , & vittorio , n. 2009 , arxiv:0905.3702 pillepich , a. , porciani , c. , & matarrese , s. 2007 , apj , 662 , 1 pillepich , a. , porciani , c. , & hahn , o. 2008 , arxiv:0811.4176 rth , c. , schuecker , p. , & banday , a. j. 2007 , mnras , 380 , 466 rth , c. , morfill , g. e. , rossmanith , g. , banday , a. j. , & grski , k. m. 2009 , physical review letters , 102 , 131301 raeth , c. , morfill , g. , rossmanith , g. , banday , a. j. , & gorski , k. m. 2008 , arxiv:0810.3805 rossmanith , g. , raeth , c. , banday , a. j. , & morfill , g. 2009 , arxiv:0905.2854 seery , d. , & lidsey , j. e. 2005 , journal of cosmology and astro - particle physics , 9 , 11 seery , d. , & hidalgo , j. c. 2006 , journal of cosmology and astro - particle physics , 7 , 8 seljak , u. 2008 , arxiv:0807.1770 senatore , l. , tassev , s. , & zaldarriaga , m. 2008 , arxiv:0812.3658 senatore , l. , smith , k. m. , & zaldarriaga , m. 2009 , arxiv:0905.3746 slosar , a. , hirata , c. , seljak , u. , ho , s. , & padmanabhan , n. 2008 , journal of cosmology and astro - particle physics , 8 , 31 silvestri , a. , & trodden , m. 2008 , arxiv:0811.2176 song , h. , & lee , j. 2008 , arxiv:0811.1339 spergel , d. n. , et al . 2007 , apjs , 170 , 377 tojeiro , r. , castro , p. g. , heavens , a. f. , & gupta , s. 2006 , mnras , 365 , 265 viel , m. , branchini , e. , dolag , k. , grossi , m. , matarrese , s. , & moscardini , l. 2008 , arxiv:0811.2223 vielva , p. , wiaux , y. , martnez - gonzlez , e. , & vandergheynst , p. 2007 , mnras , 381 , 932 vielva , p. , & sanz , j. l. 2008 , arxiv:0812.1756 vio , r. , & andreani , p. 2008 , arxiv:0811.4277 yadav , a. p. s. , & wandelt , b. d. 2008 , physical review letters , 100 , 181301 yu , b. , & lu , t. 2008 , phys . rev . d , 78 , 063008 wright , e. l. , et al . 2008 , arxiv:0803.0577 we estimate the uncertainties in the correlation functions above threshold from the optimal variance limit , containing cosmic variance , instrumental noise , and finite binsize effects . in more detail , the ultimate accuracy with which the cmb power spectrum can be determined at each @xmath88 is given by ( knox 1995 ) : @xmath132 \equiv \delta c_{\rm l}\ , \label{opt_var}\ ] ] where @xmath133 is the number of pixels , @xmath38 the average pixel noise , @xmath134 the wmap window function , and @xmath135 the fraction of the sky covered by the experiment . the uncertainty in the angular correlation function for narrow bins in @xmath23 is then ( hernndez - monteagudo et al . 2004 ) : @xmath136 ^ 2\big\}^{1/2 } \label{delta_c_theta}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath137 and @xmath76 is the additional smoothing due to finite pixel size , mask influence and an optional gaussian beam . however , in practice @xmath138 is not measured at a point , but smeared out over a region of size @xmath139 . in the limit of large @xmath88 and small @xmath23 , @xmath140 $ ] ( bond & efstathiou 1987 ) . if the bin size is not infinitesimal , one must replace : @xmath141 & \rightarrow & { 2 \over ( t_{\rm max}^2 -t_{\rm min}^2 ) } \int_{t_{\rm min}}^{t_{\rm max } } j_0 [ ( l+1/2)t]~t~{\rm d}t \nonumber \\ & = & { 2[t_{\rm max } j_{1}(k t_{\rm max } ) - t_{\rm min } j_1 ( k t_{\rm min } ) ] \over k ( t_{\rm max}^2 -t_{\rm min}^2 ) } \label{j0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath142 and @xmath143 . this expression should then substitute @xmath144 $ ] in ( [ delta_c_theta ] ) , to give @xmath145 . the uncertainties in the correlation function above threshold are finally derived from : @xmath146 we have inspected all the wmap five - year channels ( w band at 94 ghz ; v band at 61 ghz ; q band at 41 ghz ) , and performed the same analysis described in the main text for each single differencing assembly ( da ) . for this study , it is ideal to consider individual da s rather than their combinations , as wmap beams and noise properties are well - defined within each single da . figure [ psigma_map_app ] shows the distributions of the rms noise values for all the da s considered ; note the characteristic bi - modality of these histograms , present in all the channels . figure [ pdobs_app ] shows the distributions of temperatures in the data at different frequencies . dotted lines in the figure are gaussians with the same rms as data , solid curves show the predicted distributions when inhomogeneous noise effects are included . departures from the gaussian fits are more significant in the w frequency range . figure [ number_density_512_app ] shows the number density of pixels above ( below ) different temperature thresholds . dotted lines are theoretical predictions with homogeneous noise , solid lines include inhomogeneity . points are measurements from all the wmap5 da s . finally , figure [ cf_512_nu_0.25_0.75_app ] highlights some examples of the unweighted correlation functions from the wmap5 pixel - pixel temperature fields , at @xmath82 . two pixel - thresholds are considered ( @xmath110 and @xmath147 ) , as indicated in the panels . solid curves show the predictions associated with gaussian signal plus inhomogeneous noise . points are measurements of the clustering of hot and cold pixels at corresponding temperature thresholds , and shaded areas are the @xmath148 optimal variance errors . essentially , we find that the difference in clustering between hot and cold pixels is still present in all the other da s . however , our theory is always in good agreement with the clustering of cold pixels , and in slight disagreement with that of the hot ones , both in the q and in the v channels . therefore the 94 ghz frequency ( w band ) seems to be the most discrepant one , with respect to our theoretical predictions . in particular , we checked our small - scale theory expectations against wmap mock measurements from simulations with identical beam and noise properties , and found full consistency . hence , we suggest that those small - scale discrepancies may be due to extragalactic dust emission ( one type of point - source contamination ) , which has a peak at high frequencies and is not accounted in our analysis . | we present measurements of the clustering of hot and cold patches in the microwave background sky as measured from the _ _ w__ilkinson _ _ m__icrowave _ _ a__nisotropy _ _ p__robe ( wmap ) five - year data . these measurements are compared with theoretical predictions which assume that the cosmological signal obeys gaussian statistics . we find significant differences from the simplest gaussian - based prediction . however , the measurements are sensitive to the fact that the noise is spatially inhomogeneous ( e.g. , because different parts of the sky were observed for different lengths of time ) . we show how to account for this spatial inhomogeneity when making predictions . differences from the gaussian - based expectation remain even after this more careful accounting of the noise . in particular , we note that hot and cold pixels cluster differently within the same temperature thresholds at few - degree scales . while these findings may indicate primordial non - gaussianity , we discuss other plausible explanations for these discrepancies . in addition , we find some deviations from gaussianity at sub - degree scales , especially in the w band , whose origin may be associated with extragalactic dust emission . [ firstpage ] methods : statistical methods : data analysis cosmology : cosmic microwave background , correlations cosmology : observations . |
astro-ph9709306 | dwingeloo 1 is a nearby barred spiral system discovered in the line by kraan - korteweg ( 1994 ) during the dwingeloo obscured galaxies survey for galaxies hidden in the zone of avoidance . subsequent optical and infrared observations by loan ( 1996 ) , aspin & tilanus ( priv . comm . ) , and mccall & buta ( 1996 ) , as well as interferometric observations by burton ( 1996 ) , describe dw1 as of morphological type sbb at an inclination of @xmath2 , with a systemic velocity with respect to the lsr of @xmath3 , and at a distance estimated to be 3 mpc . the small galaxy dwingeloo 2 was discovered by burton ( 1996 ) in the primary beam of the westerbork observations as pointed towards dw1 . in view of its angular and kinematic proximity to dw1 , and in view of distortions in its velocity field , it seems likely that dw2 is a companion of the larger system . the two galaxies are probably members of the group containing maffei 1 & 2 and ic@xmath4342 and may influence the motions and morphology of that group and , by the group collectively , of our own local group . there is yet but little information on the star - forming potential of dw1 and dw2 . loan reported numerous regions in dw1 . li ( 1996 ) detected what they characterised as weak co j = 10 emission from the core of dw1 . the ratio of co to emissivity varies widely in galaxies , especially in barred galaxies ( see e.g. young & scoville 1991 ) . but li were not able to conclude from their single spectrum if the ratio in dw1 is unusally low , or if the galaxy belongs amongst those that show a central hole in the molecular gas distribution . the results of the exploratory survey reported here indicate that dw1 is not a strong co emitter , but that both its co emission and the co to ratio fall within the range exhibited by ordinary galaxies . rather than showing a central hole the molecular emission from the core is in fact more intense than that from beyond the core . we were unable to detect any co emission from dw2 . the observations of dw1 and dw2 were made with the james clerk maxwell telescope atop mauna kea in july and august of 1995 . we used the a2 receiver which employs a lead alloy sis mixer and a carlstrom gunn local oscillator ; it has a noise temperature of about 95k . the typical single sideband system temperature is about 350k at 230ghz . the das digital autocorrelator backend was used with 2048 channels and configured for a total bandwidth of 500mhz ; during data reduction the velocity resolution was subsequently smoothed to 5mhz , about 6.5@xmath5 . the size of the beam of the jcmt 15m attenna at the frequency ( 230.5380 ghz ) of the co j = 21 transition is 21@xmath6 . the absolute pointing of the observations was good to about 2.5@xmath6 rms ; relative pointing was better than this . the dw1 spectra were obtained by position switching the telescope to reference positions which were in general also located on that galaxy , but at the opposite side of the bar . since galactic rotation shifts the signals from the two sides well apart in frequency , this strategy seemed a valid one to optimize the use of telescope time . in order to guard against accidental subtraction of emission due to an overlapping signal at the reference position , several different reference positions were commonly used with each ` on ' position , and the profiles from each set carefully compared . the spectra were calibrated in units of the main beam brightness temperature ( ) , and corrected for sideband gains , for atmospheric emission in both sidebands , and for telescope efficiency . the rms surface accuracy of the jcmt is of order 30@xmath7 m . at the co j=21 frequency , the forward - scattering and spillover efficiency , , has a value of 0.8 ; the main - beam efficiency , , is 0.69 . residual baseline offsets were corrected by polynomal baseline removal . we observed a total of 15 positions in dw1 with the inner 11 on a cross which had 34@xmath6 spacings and was rotated over a position angle of 118@xmath8 to align it with the central bar of dw1 . the grid corresponds to an ( @xmath9 ) cell of @xmath10 by @xmath11 . the center of dw1 , our ( 0,0 ) position , was taken as @xmath12(1950 ) = 02@xmath1353@xmath14 , @xmath15(1950 ) = 58@xmath1642@xmath1738@xmath6 @xmath18 at an lsr velocity of 110@xmath5 , corresponding to the values determined initially by kraan korteweg ( 1994 ) and confirmed by the wsrt observations by burton ( 1996 ) . the remaining 4 positions were located at larger distances at @xmath19 and @xmath20 along the direction of the bar . the jcmt co spectra are shown in figure 1 , superposed on the spectra observed by burton ( 1996 ) using the wsrt . the data were convolved to the spatial resolution of the current co data prior to the extraction of the spectra . shown in the center of the figure is a ukirt k band image of dw1 observed by colin aspin and remo tilanus and provided to us in advance of publication . of the 15 positions searched for co , 5 are located on the central bar . co emission was detected at most of the positions observed with peak main beam brightness temperatures of @xmath0 70 . the kinematics revealed by the co data are consistent with those seen in at the positions where both tracers were detected . it is interesting to note that the strength of the co line relative to that of the line decreases with increasing distance from the nucleus ; thus dw1 is generally not a strong molecular emitter , nor is it a galaxy with an anomalously low molecular component in the core . the sky conditions on successive nights at the jcmt were quite variable , and thus so were the integration times invested in each observation ; the rms noise level varies from profile to profile . the spectra have been smoothed in velocity to a resolution of 6.5 @xmath5 . the spectra have also been interpolated across a velocity range extending from @xmath21 to @xmath22 in order to blank out some co emission contributed by a foreground molecular cloud located in the milky way ; this foreground emission was also evident near zero velocity in the spectrum observed by li ( 1996 ) . we can not rule out additional contamination from low level milky way emission at velocities less than @xmath21 . in addition , the spectral values have been blanked at those velocities where a strong emission feature was present at the reference position . it is necessary to have accurate positional information to assist superposition of data garnered at different wavelengths . table 1 lists astrometric positions of stars located around the direction of dw1 , as determined from poss prints . the accuracy of the positions is about one second of arc . rrr i d & @xmath23 & @xmath24 + & ( @xmath25 ) & ( @xmath26 ) + + 1 & 02 53 08.54 & + 58 43 08.6 + 2 & 02 53 07.09 & + 58 42 28.8 + 3 & 02 53 08.44 & + 58 42 11.6 + 4 & 02 53 04.23 & + 58 42 14.8 + 5 & 02 53 01.08 & + 58 42 35.6 + 6 & 02 52 53.09 & + 58 42 34.8 + 7 & 02 52 51.82 & + 58 42 32.5 + 8 & 02 52 50.46 & + 58 42 31.6 + 9 & 02 52 53.54 & + 58 41 55.4 + 10 & 02 52 56.55 & + 58 41 36.9 + 11 & 02 53 07.55 & + 58 41 31.0 + 12 & 02 52 57.13 & + 58 43 57.5 + 13 & 02 52 21.07 & + 58 43 44.2 + [ cols= " > , > , > , > , > , > , < " , ] the overall appearance of the co j = 21 spectra supports the conclusion of li ( 1996 ) that the co emission from the nucleus of dw1 is relatively weak , but only in the sense that it is much weaker ( by an order of magnitude ) than the strong co emission from its neighbours , ic 342 and maffei 2 . li speculated that the co emission from the nucleus of dw1 might not be typical of the galaxy as a whole , but that dw1 might be characterised by a central hole in the distribution of molecular gas . the present observations show , however , that the co emission from the nuclear region is actually substantially more intense than that detected along the bar or from the spiral arms . along the bar , there is a general decline of the co emission towards the start of arms at the end of the bar . just beyond the bar arm intersections in the interarm regions the co emission becomes undetectable . the profiles observed perpendicular to the bar at 68@xmath6 distance from the nucleus , especially north , show some indication that co emission is associated with the arms . further support for this comes from the profiles observed along the bar at @xmath27 which may be located along the continuation of the spiral arms visible in the k band image and show emission at the expected velocities . in contrast , the two positions closer in ( @xmath28 ) , which are clearly interarm locations , show no detectable co emission . however , the coverage of the current observations is insufficient to support a firm statement on the detailed association of co emission with the spiral arms . these conclusions are supported by figure 2 , which shows the integrated co emission as a function of galactocentric radius . figure 2 also shows the radial distribution of from the observations of burton ( 1996 ) . to ratio by mass observed in many other galaxies covers a wide range of values . the lower panel of figure 2 shows that in dw1 the and h@xmath29 masses are rather similar outside of the nucleus , where h@xmath29 dominates by a factor of about 2.5 . the relative amount of atomic and molecular gas in dw1 is thus not very different from the situation pertaining in the more familiar galaxy m33 . figure 3 shows the co spectrum observed toward the nucleus of dwingeloo 1 , together with a three component gaussian decomposition of the observation . the integrated intensity of @xmath30 k[]@xmath5 is about 45% higher than the value for the integrated co j=10 line found by li ( 1996 ) with a 55@xmath6 beam ( and after multiplying our number by /@xmath31 for the comparison ) . their profile , which was smoothed to a resolution of 15@xmath5 , does not show the double peaked structure which our observation does . the two principal gaussians peak at 106.5@xmath5 and 122.0@xmath5 , respectively , suggesting a systemic lsr velocity of about 114@xmath5 , which is a velocity close to the fitted center of the broad component , at 118@xmath5 , and which agrees well with the center of a single component gaussian fit , at 115@xmath5 . the single component fwhm width is about 40@xmath5 . the + 34@xmath6 profile also is double peaked like the nuclear profile . most likely these spectra show non - circular streaming motions of the gas caused by the presence of a bar . the observations by burton ( 1996 ) place the dynamic center of the galaxy 5 arcseconds east and south of our ( 0,0 ) position . if we adopt a value of the co(21)/co(10 ) intensity ratio of 0.8 as found for the milky way by sanders ( 1992 ) and the co(10)to h@xmath32 conversion factor of @xmath33 h@xmath34@xmath35 @xmath36 advocated for the milky way by scoville ( 1987 ) and by bloemen ( 1986 ) , we find that the average h@xmath32 column density and the assumed co(21)/co(10 ) intensity ratio of 0.8 ] within the central 21@xmath6 of dw1 is @xmath37 n(h@xmath32)@xmath38 corresponding to a surface density of @xmath39 and a total h@xmath32 mass of @xmath40 . correcting for an inclination of 50@xmath16 , one finds a deprojected average h@xmath32 surface density and total h@xmath32 mass for the central 300pc of dwingeloo 1 of @xmath41 and @xmath42 , respectively . we also attempted to detect co j=21 emission from dwingeloo 2 . the small total velocity width of dw2 shown in the data of burton ( 1996 ) , its small size ( assuming it is located at the same distance as dw1 ) , and the fact that it has been detected only at a weak level in the infrared , together lead one to expect that the co signal , if detected at all , would be very weak . we confined the jcmt observations to integrations towards the nucleus of dw2 , but were not able to detect co emission above a 3@xmath43 threshold of 40mk . the molecular emission observed from the nearby galaxy dw1 in the co j=21 line is relatively weak compared to its neighbours ic342 and maffei 2 , but is in the normal range for an ordinary galaxy . the emission could be followed in the jcmt observations reported here over the extent of the bar and into the spiral arms emanating from the ends of the bar . thus it seems that dw1 does not belong to the category of barred systems with a central hole in the molecular distribution ; the molecular emission is comparable throughout the galaxy , although relatively more intense in the core than in the bar or spiral - arm regions . outside of the nucleus , where h@xmath32 dominates by a factor of about 2.5 , the atomic and molecular masses are rather similar . we were unable to detect co emission from the nucleus of dw2 ; this negative result is not unexpected for a dwarf companion system . the james clerk maxwell telescope is operated by the observatories on behalf of the particle physics and astrophysics council of the united kingdom , the netherlands foundation for research in astronomy , and the national research council of canada . we are grateful to chris dudley ( ifa , university of hawaii ) for help with the stellar astrometry , to colin aspin ( ukirt ) for agreeing that we use the aspin / tilanus k band image of dwingeloo 1 , and to marc verheijen ( groningen ) for providing the wsrt spectra in the form used here in figure 1 . we also thank an anonymous referee for constructive comments . ) | we present an exploratory survey of the central regions of the nearby spiral galaxies dwingeloo 1 and dwingeloo 2 made in the co j=21 line at 230 ghz using the james clerk maxwell telescope . in dwingeloo 1 , which is probably the nearest grand design barred spiral , the co emission was sampled along a cross with its major axis aligned with the bar . the co emission is an order of magnitude weaker ( peak @xmath0 70 ) than in its neighbours ic 342 and maffei 2 and appears to be confined to the nucleus , bar , and spiral arms . in dwingeloo 2 , a small system quite likely to be a companion of dw1 , a 3-sigma upper limit of 40@xmath1 for the co j=21 emission from the nucleus was obtained . 2cm^-2 3cm^-3 2pc^-2 34sc^34s 3cs^13cs _a&a _ |
0804.1179 | one of the simplest and most common ways to categorize an entity as living or non - living is to stipulate that if we were to decompose that entity into its constituent parts and could then reconstruct the whole by assembling the parts , it is non - living ; otherwise , it is living . that is , a living thing is more than just the collection of its parts , but a non - living thing is not . then how is the gap between living and non - living things expressed ? r. rosen @xcite claims that a central feature of living things is _ complexity _ , where a system is said to be _ complex _ if its behavior can not be captured by models of that system ; otherwise , that system is said to be _ simple_. ( that is , the complexity of a system depends primarily on the models of the system , and only secondarily on the system per se . ) in rosen s description , use of the term _ complex _ in reference to a system is equivalent to use of the term _ incomputable _ or _ notwell - formed _ in reference to its models . in his model of living things , rosen considers a logical paradox ( such as russell s paradox @xcite ) as a _ metabolism - repairsystem _ ( _ mrsystem _ ) @xcite . an mr system consists of two sets ( a set @xmath6 of _ rawmaterials _ and a set @xmath7 of _ behaviors _ ) and three functions ( a _ metabolicfunction_@xmath8@xmath9 , a _ repairfunction_@xmath10@xmath11 , and a _ replicationfunction_@xmath12@xmath13 ) , where @xmath14 and @xmath15 are onto functions and @xmath16 . ( for sets @xmath17 denotes the set of all morphisms from @xmath18 to @xmath19 @xcite . ) one remarkable feature of rosen s model is the following : 1 . there do not exist such onto functions @xmath20 and @xmath21 . if they are assumed to exist , we obtain a contradiction . one way to treat such a contradiction is to invoke hyperset theory @xcite . a _ hyperset _ is defined as a graphable set in particular , one that can be represented by a hyperset diagram , which is a digraph ( directed graph ) with the property that every node is either a set contained in the hyperset or an element of such a set , and every edge is directed from some set @xmath22 contained in the hyperset to one of the elements of @xmath22 @xcite . thus edge @xmath23 expresses the relationship @xmath24 , i.e. , @xmath25 is an element of @xmath26 . for example , the hyperset diagram of @xmath27 is shown in fig . [ fighyperset1_p5 ] . there are two directed edges : @xmath28 and @xmath29 . a relationship of the form @xmath28 leads to the well - known contradiction known as russell s paradox @xcite ; however , such a relationship is interpreted as just a loop structure in hyperset theory . , width=132,height=43 ] property ( i ) can be expressed in hyperset theory by its way . let us represent @xmath30 by the set @xmath31 ; thus @xmath32 and @xmath33 are represented by the sets @xmath34 and @xmath35 respectively . then we obtain the hyperset diagram of mr as shown in fig . [ fighyperset2_p5 ] @xcite . accordingly , a system can be said to be complex if it can not be well - formed in standard set theory but it can be well - formed in hyperset theory . matsuno and gunji , in their theory of internal measurement ( i m ) @xcite , propose a different way , called a _ perpetualequilibratingmechanism_. they address property ( i ) as follows : 1 . any solution to a problem ( paradox ) is inevitably a pseudo - solution , and the pseudo - solution at any given time step `` always '' triggers a problem that that is to be solved at the next time step . this leads to an evolutionary process that goes on forever and thereby allows for emergent properties . therefore , the paradox is treated as the force that drives the time evolution of the system . in i m , the gap between the whole and the aggregation of the parts drives the time evolution of the dynamical system . therefore , i m can be understood as a proposal of a dynamical system which is based on the idea of a perpetual loop between two different logical layers , such as the parts and the whole , with a decomposition @xmath36 of the whole into the parts , and an integration @xmath37 ( as a pseudo - solution ) of the parts into the whole . thus we may express an i m model in terms of a triad : the two different logical layers and a mediator / interface to adjust the two layers in an _ inconsistent _ manner @xcite . i m claims that the relationship between the two layers ( or the relationship between @xmath36 and @xmath37 ) is not consistently determined , and for this reason they are perpetually changing relative to each another , where the term inconsistent means that we obtain a logical paradox if we assume consistency between them . any finite boolean network ( bn ) has a fixed transition matrix , hence a finite bn ultimately reaches an attractor and stays there ( i.e. , the computation ends ) . in section [ secvbn_p5 ] , we define a virtual boolean network ( vbn ) as a bn in which the set of incoming nodes for every node is the entire set of nodes of the bn , and we show that every finite bn can be treated as a vbn . in section [ secexpansions_p5 ] , we introduce a labeling function to label the states of a vbn , and we discuss the probabilistic boolean network ( pbn ) and the hidden markov model ( hmm ) as extensions of a vbn . the purpose of an hmm is to find an optimal solution ; in the case of a living thing , however , it is not always possible to find such a solution . thus , in section [ secdbn_p5 ] , we abandon the attempt to find an optimal solution , and we introduce a dynamical boolean network ( dbn ) , which is a vbn whose set of nodes is fixed but whose transition matrix can change from one time step to another . thus even a finite dbn does not necessarily have any attractors . in our dbn , a labeling function plays a role in maintaining a perpetual loop between the of the vbn at different time steps . in section [ secdbn_p5 ] , we present a construction of a dbn a construction that incorporates stochasticity in a number of respects . in section [ secsimulation_p5 ] , we present the results of a number of simulations of a dbn with two nodes . the purpose of each simulation was to investigate the set of rule vectors actually visited by the dbn , which is equivalent to the set of transition matrices actually visited by the dbn . in subsection [ subsectype1_p5 ] , we present the results of a simulation of a dbn based on the construction in section [ secdbn_p5 ] , which we call a type 1 simulation . the simulations presented in the remaining three subsections of section [ secsimulation_p5 ] use dbn constructions which are similar to the one in section [ secdbn_p5 ] , the only difference being that , for @xmath38 , we chose the transition matrix @xmath0 of the dbn for time step @xmath1 to be @xmath39 , where @xmath3 is the transition matrix in our original construction and @xmath40 is the matrix representation of some permutation @xmath41 of the states of the dbn . those three simulations correspond to three different classes of permutations . in our type 2 simulation , @xmath41 was randomly chosen from the set of permutations that consist of either the identity or a single 2-cycle or the product of two disjoint 2-cycles . in our type 3 simulation , @xmath41 was randomly chosen from the set of all 24 permutations of the four states of a dbn with two nodes . in our type 4 simulation , @xmath41 was constructed from a labeling function . there are 81 rule vectors ( out of a total of 256 possible rule vectors for a dbn with two nodes ) that were not visited at all after the fifth time step of any trial in the type 1 and type 2 simulations . however , all 256 rule vectors were visited in every trial of the type 3 simulation , as well as in slightly more than half of the trials of the type 4 simulation . indeed , six of the 81 aforementioned rule vectors were the ones visited most frequently of all in the type 4 simulation . a total of six single - node transition rules are associated with those six rule vectors ( each rule vector corresponds to an ordered pair of single - node rule vectors ) . three of those six single - node transition rules are transition rules of a linear vbn ( lvbn ) ; the other three are the negations of the first three . thus our conclusion is that the type 4 simulation presents new insight into linearity of a vbn . a boolean network ( bn ) @xcite is a digraph in which each vertex has an internal state and a transition rule . the vertices of a bn are hereinafter referred to as nodes . each internal state has a value of either 0 or 1 at any given time . the transition rule for a given node specifies the next state of that node as a function of the current internal states of its incoming ( input ) nodes . a bn can be finite or infinite . the discussion of bn s in this paper is limited to finite bn s ( i.e. , those that have finitely many nodes ) . some of the assertions made herein about bn s do not extend to the infinite case . an example of a bn is shown in fig . [ kauffman1_p5 ] . there are three nodes ( @xmath42 ) , so the bn has a total of @xmath43 ( @xmath44 ) possible states:@xmath45 the set of incoming nodes for each node of a bn is specified by the digraph . here , the sets of incoming nodes for @xmath46 , and @xmath47 are @xmath48 , and @xmath49 , respectively . since nodes @xmath26 and @xmath25 have just one incoming node apiece , each of them has just two possible input states : @xmath50 and @xmath51 . node @xmath47 has two incoming nodes , hence it has four possible input states : ( 0,0),(0,1),(1,0),(1,1 ) . given the initial state of a bn , we obtain the time evolution of the system ( the sequence of states visited ) by repeated application of the transition rules . since the number of nodes is finite , the number of possible states is finite , so for every initial state the system evolves to some finite cyclic sequence of states , i.e. , a finite sequence of states of the bn which is visited _ ad infinitum from some time on , with no other states intervening_. such a sequence is called an attractor . clearly , each state evolves to one and only one attractor . thus the set of states of a bn can be partitioned in such a way that states in the same block of the partition evolve to the same attractor , and states in different blocks evolve to different attractors . all possible states and attractors of the bn in fig . [ kauffman1_p5 ] are depicted in the transition diagram in fig . [ kauffman2_p5 ] . in this particular bn , only four of the states are visited infinitely often , and there are two attractors : one of length 3 ( @xmath52 ) and one of length 1 ( @xmath53 ) . ( the length of an attractor is the number of states in the cycle . ) the set of states can be partitioned as @xmath54 , where @xmath55 and@xmath56 and every state in @xmath57 evolves to the attractor of length 3 . , width=415,height=113 ] a digraph with node set @xmath58 is specified by assigning to every node a set of incoming nodes . assigning a set of incoming nodes to a single node can be regarded as selecting an element of @xmath59 , where @xmath60 denotes the set of all morphisms from @xmath18 to @xmath19 @xcite . ( here , 2 denotes the set @xmath61 . ) the term _ morphism _ as used here is synonymous with _ function _ ; hence @xmath59 is the set of all binary functions ( functions whose values are elements of the set @xmath62 ) with @xmath58 as domain . each such binary function can be represented as a binary sequence ( a sequence of 0 s and 1 s ) in which the @xmath63th term is the value of the function at node @xmath63 . the set of incoming nodes for node @xmath64 is represented by the binary sequence in which the @xmath63th term is 1 if node @xmath63 is an incoming node for @xmath64 , and 0 otherwise . thus assigning to every node in @xmath58 a set of incoming nodes ( i.e. , selecting an element of @xmath59 for every node ) can be regarded as selecting an element of @xmath65 . alternatively , specification of a digraph can be regarded as selecting an element of @xmath66 , since @xmath67 via the mapping of @xmath68 to the element @xmath69 of @xmath65 which is defined by @xmath70 . for every @xmath71 , denote @xmath72 by @xmath73 . then @xmath74 and , for every @xmath75 , @xmath76 note that @xmath77 the internal states of the nodes of a bn with node set @xmath58 can be regarded as the components of a state @xmath78 , where @xmath79 is the number of nodes in @xmath58 and @xmath80 is the internal state of node @xmath64 ( i.e. , @xmath81 ) . there are two ways to specify the transition rules for a bn . the first method is completely general . [ deffirstruledescription_p5 ] the transition rule @xmath82 for node @xmath64 assigns the next internal state ( either 0 or 1 ) to node @xmath64 . the assignment is a function of the current internal states of the nodes in the set @xmath83 of incoming nodes for @xmath64 . let @xmath84 , where @xmath85 is the number of nodes in @xmath83 . then@xmath86 where @xmath87 the transition rules for the nodes of a bn can be regarded as the components of a rule vector @xmath88:@xmath89 the second method of specifying the transition rules applies only to a bn for which @xmath90 ( hence @xmath91 ) for every node @xmath64 , where @xmath92 denotes @xmath93 . we will refer to such a bn as a virtual boolean network ( vbn ) . [ defsecondruledescription_p5 ] if @xmath90 for every @xmath64 , then the transition rules @xmath82 for the individual nodes can be incorporated into a single transition rule @xmath94 : @xmath95 for node @xmath64 , denote @xmath96 by @xmath97 . for @xmath98 , we will say that node @xmath63 is _ virtually disconnected _ from node @xmath64 if @xmath99 is invariant with respect to substitution of input @xmath100 with @xmath101 , where@xmath102 we will say that the nodes which are not virtually disconnected from node @xmath64 are _ virtual incoming nodes _ for node @xmath64 , and we will denote the set of virtual incoming nodes by @xmath103 ; hence the set of nodes which are virtually disconnected from node @xmath64 is @xmath104 . any bn can be regarded as a vbn , by defining @xmath97 in such a way that it extends @xmath82 and all the nodes in @xmath92 are virtually disconnected from @xmath64 . [ ex1_p5 ] let @xmath105 , and fix a node @xmath64 . suppose that @xmath106 and @xmath107 , and that the transition rule @xmath82 for node @xmath64 is @xmath108\ ] ] the domain of rule @xmath82 is just the set of states of node @xmath26 , but @xmath82 can be embedded into rule @xmath97 defined by @xmath109\begin{array}{lc|cccc } \emph{in}&(x_{a},x_{b},x_{c})&(1,0,0)&(1,0,1)&(1,1,0)&(1,1,1)\\\hline \emph{out}&(x_{i})&0&0&0&0\end{array } \end{array}\right]\ ] ] the domain of @xmath97 is the set of states of all the nodes . note that , for all @xmath110 , the embedding satisfies @xmath111 hence nodes @xmath25 and @xmath47 are virtually disconnected from node @xmath64 . we can translate a specification of a vbn into a specification of a bn , though the resulting bn is not necessarily unique ( since @xmath83 can be any superset of @xmath103 ) . for node @xmath64 in example [ ex1_p5 ] , we could define @xmath83 as @xmath49 , and the transition rule @xmath112 for node @xmath64 as @xmath113\ ] ] note that , for all @xmath114,@xmath115 furthermore , both @xmath82 and @xmath112 embed into the transition rule @xmath97 given in example [ ex1_p5 ] . the transition diagram of a bn is a digraph in which the vertices are the states of the bn and every vertex has just one out - going edge . if the set of nodes of the bn is @xmath58 , then the bn has a total of @xmath116 states . thus the transition diagram can be represented as a @xmath117 _ adjacency matrix _ . the adjacency matrix @xmath3 of any digraph is a binary matrix ( i.e. , a matrix of 0 s and 1 s ) such that @xmath118 if there is an out - going edge from the vertex labeled @xmath64 to the vertex labeled @xmath63 ( and @xmath119 otherwise ) . since each state of a bn has just one out - going edge , exactly one of the entries in each row of the adjacency matrix of a bn is a 1 . in the case of a bn , the adjacency matrix is also called the _ transition matrix_. [ proprules2trans1_p5 ] the transition matrix @xmath3 of a bn with vertex set @xmath58 can be obtained from the rule vector @xmath88 ; however , @xmath88 can not be recovered from @xmath3 . * proof * ( @xmath120 ) : label the rows of @xmath3 with the states of the bn , and use the same labels ( in the same order ) for the columns of @xmath3 . let @xmath78 be a state of the bn . then , in the row of @xmath3 which is labeled with state @xmath121 , the unique 1 is located in the column labeled with state @xmath122 , where , for every @xmath123 is computed by applying transition rule @xmath82 to @xmath121 . + ( @xmath124 ) : to determine transition rule @xmath82 , its domain ( namely , @xmath83 ) must be known ; however , @xmath83 can not be derived from @xmath3 . @xmath125 the following proposition follows from the fact that , for every node in a vbn with node set @xmath58 , the set of incoming nodes is @xmath58 . [ proprules2trans2_p5 ] in a vbn , the transition matrix @xmath3 can be derived from the transition rule @xmath94 , and @xmath94 can be derived from @xmath3 . * proof * by proposition [ proprules2trans1_p5 ] , it suffices to prove that @xmath126 . assume that the rows and columns of @xmath3 are labeled with the states of the vbn , as indicated in the proof of proposition [ proprules2trans1_p5 ] , and let @xmath127 . the output of transition rule @xmath97 , which is the next internal state of node @xmath64 , is a function of the current state of the bn , so let @xmath121 be a state of the vbn . furthermore , let @xmath63 be such that , in the row of @xmath3 which is labeled with state @xmath121 , the unique 1 is located in column @xmath63 , and let @xmath122 be the state that labels column @xmath63 . then @xmath128 is the output of @xmath97 that corresponds to input @xmath129 from this point on , we assume that every bn is a vbn , so we need not specify the set of incoming nodes for any node . every state @xmath121 of a vbn with node set @xmath58 is an element of @xmath59 , and the transition rule @xmath94 for such a vbn is an element of @xmath130 . [ deflbn_p5 ] a vbn is said to be a _ linear vbn ( lvbn ) _ if , for every node @xmath64 , transition rule @xmath97 is of the form @xmath131 where @xmath121 is the current state of the vbn and @xmath132 is a vector whose components are 0 s and 1 s . ( clearly , the number of components of @xmath132 must be equal to the number of nodes in the vbn . ) [ propmbn1_p5 ] in an lvbn , node @xmath64 is virtually disconnected from node @xmath63 if and only if the @xmath63th component of the vector @xmath132 in definition [ deflbn_p5 ] is 0 . * proof*the output of transition rule @xmath97 ( namely , @xmath133 ) is invariant under the transformation that consists of replacing the current internal state @xmath134 of node @xmath63 with @xmath135 ( and leaving the current internal states of the other nodes unchanged ) if and only if the @xmath63th component of @xmath132 is 0 . @xmath125 for a vbn with set of states @xmath22 and node set @xmath58 , the number of possible single - node transition rules is @xmath136 . in the case of a vbn with two nodes , this is @xmath137 . the output of each of the 16 possible single - node transition rules for a vbn with two nodes is given in table [ tablerule_p5 ] as a function of the input state of the vbn ; tabulated along with the output of each transition rule is the number @xmath138 of virtual incoming nodes for each of the node(s ) to which that rule would be applied . there are only four possible transition rules for a node of an lvbn with two nodes ( namely , the rules which are presented in boldface in the table ) . those four transition rules ( 1 , 7 , 11 , and 13 ) correspond to the vectors @xmath139 , and @xmath140 , respectively , where @xmath141 is as in definition [ deflbn_p5 ] . if nodes 1 and 2 of an lvbn are @xmath26 and @xmath25 ( in that order ) , then the sets of virtual incoming nodes for each of the nodes to which rules 1 , 7 , 11 , and 13 would be applied are @xmath142 , and @xmath143 , respectively . .outputs of the transition rules for a vbn with two nodes . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the 1,000 trials of the type 4 simulation can be grouped into two classes : * trials in which a handful of rule vectors were visited very frequently ( visited at roughly 1,000 or more different time steps ) and the remaining rule vectors were visited very infrequently ( visited at roughly no more than 30 different time steps ) * trials in which the variation in the number of visits per rule vector was very small about 70@xmath144 of the trials of the type 4 simulation fall into class ( i ) ; the remaining 30@xmath144 are in class ( ii ) . all 94 trials with less than 90@xmath144 coverages are in class ( i ) . the numbers of time steps at which rule vector @xmath145 was visited in two specific trials of the type 4 simulation with at least 90@xmath144 coverage apiece are shown in the maps in fig . [ figresulttype4_3_p5 ] . the map in ( a ) is for a typical class ( i ) trial , and the map in ( b ) is for a typical class ( ii ) trial . only six rule vectors ( namely , @xmath146 , and @xmath147 ) were visited very frequently ( visited at roughly 1,000 or more different time steps ) in the class ( i ) trial associated with fig . [ figresulttype4_3_p5](a ) . white is used for the remaining 250 rule vectors , each of which was visited no more than 22 times . in about 20@xmath144 of the class ( i ) trials , at least one rule vector other than those six was among the rule vectors visited very frequently ( visited at roughly 1,000 or more different time steps ) . the map shown in fig . [ figresulttype4_3_p5](b ) , for a class ( ii ) trial , bears a much greater resemblance to the maps for the trials of the type 3 simulation than to those for the class ( i ) trials of the type 4 simulation . was visited in two trials of the type 4 simulation with at least 90% coverage apiece : ( a ) a typical class ( i ) trial and ( b ) a typical class ( ii ) trial , width=491,height=229 ] all six of the rule vectors enumerated earlier are from fig . [ figresultiti3_p5](a ) . each of those six rule vectors was visited a total of more than 300,000 times in the class ( i ) trials of the type 4 simulation , while each of the 175 rule vectors not from fig . [ figresultiti3_p5](a ) had a total of fewer than 50,000 visits in the class ( i ) trials . the total number of visits ( in units of @xmath148 ) of rule vector @xmath145 in the class ( i ) trials of the type 4 simulation ( summed over all 1,000 trials ) is shown in the map in fig . [ figbc_p5](a ) . only 54 of the 256 rule vectors were visited very frequently in at least one of the class ( i ) trials : 41 of the 81 rule vectors from fig . [ figresultiti3_p5](a ) , including the six rule vectors enumerated earlier ; and 13 of the other 175 rule vectors . those 54 rule vectors are depicted by red squares in fig . [ figbc_p5](b ) . ) of rule vector @xmath149 in the class ( i ) trials of the type 4 simulation . ( b ) the 54 rule vectors ( indicated by red squares ) that were visited very frequently in at least one of the class ( i ) trials.,width=491,height=245 ] the maximum time step at which rule vector @xmath145 was visited in the type 4 simulation ( where the maximum is taken over all 1,000 trials ) is shown in the map in fig . [ figmaxtimestep4_p5 ] . of the 256 rule vectors , 203 were visited at the very last ( 10,000th ) time step of at least one trial ; those rule vectors are depicted in white in the figure . red is used for the other 53 rule vectors , each of which was visited at some time step in the range 9,9929,999 but was never visited at the last time step . was visited in the type 4 simulation ( where the maximum is taken over all 1,000 trials),width=302,height=238 ] fig . [ figresulttype4_4_p5 ] shows a graph of the cumulative percentage of rule vectors visited in our type 4 simulation , averaged over the 550 trials in which all 256 rule vectors were visited , vs. the number of time steps . again , the blue curve is the result of our simulation , and the green curve is the parametric curve given by @xmath150 . the number of time steps actually taken to visit all 256 rule vectors ( in the 550 trials of our simulation with 100@xmath144 coverage ) was about 4,500 , which is about 2.9 times as large as the theoretical value and 2.7 times the number of steps taken in the type 3 simulation . , where @xmath151 varies from 1 to 256 and @xmath152 is given by ( [ eqvisitratingfunction2_p5]).,width=283,height=223 ] at each time step in our simulations of a dbn , we incorporated randomness into several processes : in generating pseudo - transition diagrams from the output digraph , in choosing a pseudo - transition diagram and then transforming it to the transition diagram of a vbn , in choosing a labeling function for the states of the dbn , and ( in types 2 , 3 , and 4 ) in choosing a permutation of the states of the dbn . in every trial of the type 1 simulation , fewer than 70@xmath144 of the rule vectors were visited . furthermore , the 256 rule vectors split into two groups : the set of 81 rule vectors that were not visited after the fifth time step in any trial of the first type 1 simulation ( and not visited at all in the two additional type 1 simulations ) , and the set consisting of the other 175 rule vectors , each of which was visited considerably more frequently than those in the set of 81 . those features of the type 1 simulation were largely preserved under the kinds of permutations of the states of the dbn which were chosen at random in the type 2 simulation ( namely , the identity permutation , the 2-cycles , and the products of disjoint pairs of 2-cycles ) . the salient features of the type 1 and type 2 simulations were not preserved under the kinds of permutations chosen in the type 3 and type 4 simulations . ( any permutation could be selected in type 3 ; however , the permutation @xmath41 selected at time step @xmath1 in the type 4 simulation depended in part on the labeling function @xmath153 . ) a remarkable contrast was found between the results of the type 3 and type 4 simulations on one hand , and those for type 1 and type 2 on the other . all 256 rule vectors were visited in every trial of the type 3 simulation , and six of the 81 rule vectors which were not visited after the sixth time step of any trial in the type 1 and type 2 simulations were the rule vectors visited the most frequently of all by far in the type 4 simulation . the results of the one simulation we ran in which @xmath41 was randomly chosen from the complement of the set of permutations used in type 2 were similar to those for our type 3 simulation , in that the total number of visits per rule vector varied little from one rule vector to another . fully 41 of the aforementioned 81 rule vectors were visited very frequently ( visited at roughly 1,000 or more different time steps ) in at least one class ( i ) trial of our type 4 simulation . six of those 41 rule vectors had a total of over 300,000 visits in the type 4 simulation . each component of every one of those six rule vectors is a single - node transition rule from the set @xmath154 . three of those ( rule numbers 7 , 11 , and 13 ) are transition rules of an lvbn ; each of the other three ( 4 , 6 , and 10 ) is the negation of a single - node transition rule of an lvbn . the only single - node transition rules of an lvbn which are not a component of any of those six rule vectors are rule numbers 1 and 16and both of those transition rules correspond to a node of an lvbn that has no virtual incoming nodes . thus it appears that we can regard the class ( i ) trials of the type 4 simulation as a restriction of the single - node transition rules of a vbn to the single - node transition rules of an lvbn and their negations , hence that linearity may have played a significant role in our type 4 simulation . therefore , linearity may be a worthwhile topic for further study . | we propose a dynamical boolean network ( dbn ) , which is a virtual boolean network ( vbn ) whose set of states is fixed but whose transition matrix can change from one discrete time step to another . the transition matrix @xmath0 of our dbn for time step @xmath1 is of the form @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is a transition matrix ( of a vbn ) defined at time step @xmath1 in the course of the construction of our dbn and @xmath4 is the matrix representation of some randomly chosen permutation @xmath5 of the states of our dbn . for each of several classes of such permutations , we carried out a number of simulations of a dbn with two nodes ; each of our simulations consisted of 1,000 trials of 10,000 time steps each . in one of our simulations , only six of the 16 possible single - node transition rules for a vbn with two nodes were visited a total of 300,000 times ( over all 1,000 trials ) . in that simulation , linearity appears to play a significant role in that three of those six single - node transition rules are transition rules of a linear virtual boolean network ( lvbn ) ; the other three are the negations of the first three . we also discuss the notions of a probabilistic boolean network and a hidden markov model in both cases , in the context of using an arbitrary ( though not necessarily one - to - one ) function to label the states of a vbn . [ thm]note internal measurement ; boolean network ; probabilistic boolean network ; hidden markov model ; linearity |
quant-ph0209094 | the no - cloning theorem is one of the most important characters of quantum information , which is different from classical information . on the basis of superposition principle , wootters and zurek@xcite pointed out that it is impossible to find a way to copy an arbitrary unknown state perfectly . they introduced a cloner which is named wootters - zurek copying machine ( w - z cm ) . this machine can copy orthogonal state perfectly , but copy the superposition states badly . since determinately perfect copying is impossible , the approximate cloning is necessary . buek and hillery@xcite have first shown that the universal cloner is possible and introduced a copying machine which is called buek - hillery copying machine ( b - h cm ) . this machine is deterministic and does not need any information about the state to be cloned . it can copy every state equally well . then it has been proved@xcite that the b - h cm is the optimal cloning machine for universal cloning , that is , this machine attains the largest local fidelity . there is another kind of cloner which is named state - dependent cloner . it needs some information about the cloning state . there are three types of this kind of cloner : deterministic , probabilistic and hybrid cloners . probabilistic cloner has been introduced by duan and guo@xcite . they found the states could be cloned perfectly with some probability less than 1,when the states are linearly independent . the deterministic state - dependent cloner was first investigated by bru _ et al._@xcite and it was solved completely when the state - set contains only two states which have equally _ a priori _ probability . then chefles and barnett@xcite generalized this problem to the two states which have different _ a priori _ probability and the global fidelity is used to measure of the cloning process instead of the local fidelity . they gave the optimal strategy to make the global fidelity maximal and found this fidelity is larger than the universal cloner . several months latter , chefles and barnett@xcite hybridized the former two types of cloners to get the hybridized cloner . so the former two cloners can be viewed as a special case of it . when the state - set contains only two states , there is a analytic solution of the optimal strategy . when the number of the states is more than two , there is no analytic solution for this problem . before the exact solution of 2-state - dependent quantum cloner was found , some scientists had already began to study the bound of these processes . the original work was proposed by hillery and buek@xcite , they derived a lower bound for the amount of the noise introduced by quantum cloning process . more recently , rastegin@xcite gave another lower bound for the noise by a new method . since solving this problem exactly is impossible when state - set contains more than two states , it is necessary to find the bound of the global fidelity of the quantum cloning process . by the way , when the number of the states is increasing , these states are no longer linearly independent . so the duan - guo cloning machine does not work . even though the bound can not tell us what we can do , it can only tell us what we can not attain . in this paper , some bounds on the multi - state - dependent quantum cloning process are given . we study the three - state - dependent ( that is , the state - set contains three states ) quantum copying more carefully and generalize the method to the multi - state - dependent cloning process . in section ii , some necessary lemmas are introduced . in section iii , the upper bound of the global fidelity of 3-state - dependent quantum cloning process is given . in section iv , some upper bounds for n - state - dependent quantum copying process are introduced . the conclusion is given in section v. consider a set of @xmath0 nonorthogonal quantum states @xmath1 . if there are @xmath2 quantum systems , they are prepared in the same unknown quantum state @xmath3 which is taken from the given set . the task is to find an optimal process to get @xmath4 identical approximate cloning states from the @xmath2 initial states @xmath5 . this process is a symmetric cloning , which can be denoted by @xmath6 . the optimal process means the global fidelity is maximal . the global fidelity is defined as follows : @xmath7 where @xmath8 denotes the actual @xmath9 copies of cloned state of @xmath10 , @xmath11 denotes the exact @xmath9 copies of cloned state of @xmath12 which is a n - fold tensor and @xmath13 stands for the _ a priori _ probability of the state @xmath14 , and @xmath15 denotes the @xmath16 blank copies . the case of the state - set only containing two states has already been solved by bru _ et al._@xcite and chefles and barnett @xcite . when they derived the optimal strategy , the following fact is crucial : the optimal outputs @xmath17 lie in the subspace spanned by the exact clones @xmath18 . it is also held when the state - set has more than two states . in fact , we have the following lemma : _ lemma 1 . _ for any state set @xmath19 ( assume the _ a priori _ probability of each state are @xmath20 ) and for the quantum cloning process @xmath21 the optimal outputs @xmath22 lie in the subspace spanned by the exact clones @xmath23 _ proof . _ this proof is following the method introduced by bru _ et al._@xcite_. _ at the beginning of this proof , we can define a matrix @xmath24 of the state - set as @xmath25 this matrix is necessary in the following and the definition shows that it is a hermite matrix . suppose that the optimal outputs have the other components which do not lie in the subspace spanned by the exact clones . then the optimal outputs can be written as @xmath26 where the vectors @xmath27 are normalized and orthogonal to the subspace spanned by the exact clones , and @xmath15 denotes the @xmath16 blank copies . since the transformation is unitary , the following constraints must be held . @xmath28=0 , \eqnum{4}\ ] ] @xmath29=0,\ ] ] where @xmath30 , @xmath9 denotes the number of copies and @xmath2 denotes the number of initial identical states . particularly , when @xmath31 , there is the following constraints @xmath32 the global fidelity is @xmath33 \nonumber \\ & = & \frac 1n\sum\limits_{i=1}^n(1-\left| b_i\right| ^2)+\frac 1n% \sum\limits_{i=1}^n[\sum\limits_{k , l}(\xi _ { ik}^n\xi _ { il}^{*n}-\xi _ { lk}^n)a_{il}^{*}a_{ik}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the constraints ( 5 ) have already been used . now we can use the lagrange multipliers for the other constraints and get these equations @xmath34 @xmath35 @xmath36 etc , where @xmath37 denotes the constraints , and the lagrange multipliers are @xmath38 . since the constraint when @xmath39 has been used before , the index @xmath40 and @xmath41 in all of the equations must satisfy @xmath42 . we suppose that @xmath43 and @xmath44 . due to the equality of @xmath37 and @xmath45 , we can only consider one of them . then ( 8) and eq . ( 9 ) can be written as @xmath46 @xmath47 let us multiply eq . ( 10 ) by @xmath48 we get @xmath49 after multiplying eq . ( 11 ) by @xmath50 , we find @xmath51 that is , @xmath52 then we sum them over the subscript @xmath53 from@xmath54 to @xmath0 and get @xmath55=0 . \eqnum{13}\ ] ] substituting eq.(13 ) into eq . ( 12 ) and changing the subscript @xmath53 to @xmath40 , we can find that @xmath56 , that is , @xmath57 . this is the end of the proof . note that the lemma is also held when the _ a priori _ probability is not equal for all of the states . the proof is the same as before . what we need to do is to change the _ a priori _ probability @xmath20 by the new _ a priori _ probability @xmath58 now we consider the global fidelity formula eq . ( 6 ) . for convenience , let @xmath59 . if we assume that the elements of matrix @xmath24 are real , in order to make the global fidelity maximal , factors @xmath60 and @xmath61 must be the same . so we can write the eq . ( 3.1 ) in a new form . @xmath62 where @xmath63 are real numbers . so it is sufficient to consider the real number coefficients to find the maximum of the global fidelity . in the next section we only study the global fidelity in this sense . now we consider the situation that the state set contains three states @xmath64 . we assume that the three states are taken from state - set @xmath65 @xmath66 the elements of the matrix @xmath24 are naturally real . we consider the quantum cloning process @xmath67 . the quantum state in the space spanned by @xmath68 is a point on the complex spherical surface ( in general , the states @xmath69 are linearly independent and can span a 3-dimensional space ) . with the reason pointed out before , when considering the optimal cloning strategy , we can only consider the states which have real coefficients , and these states span the spherical surface @xmath70 . finding the optimal clone is equal to finding three points on the @xmath70 which make the distances between them and the idea copies minimal this situation is described in fig . 1 . in this figure , the edge of the outer triangle @xmath71corresponds the angle between @xmath72 and @xmath73 , that is , @xmath74 . the edge of the inner triangle @xmath75 corresponds the angle between @xmath76 and @xmath77 , that is , @xmath78 . and so on . in order to get the optimal approximate of the global fidelity , we must give some characters of the spherical surface @xmath70 . _ lemma 2 . _ for the triangle on the spherical surface , there is a fundamental formula@xcite @xmath79 where @xmath80 are the length of the three edges of this triangle and @xmath81 is the angle between edge @xmath82 and @xmath83 . from lemma 2 , the following equations can be obtained from fig . 1 ( we suppose @xmath84 @xmath85 @xmath86 @xmath87 @xmath88 @xmath89and @xmath90 ) @xmath91 @xmath92 and @xmath93 @xmath94 now we can calculate out that @xmath95 we have already used the condition @xmath96 , and inequalities @xmath97 ( it is proven in the following ) , that is , @xmath98 . substituting eq . ( 14 - 1 ) into eq . ( 16 ) and rearranging it in order of @xmath99 and @xmath100 , we get @xmath101 for the same reason , we can get @xmath102 now inserting eq.(15 - 1 ) into this formula and using the fact that @xmath103 we get @xmath104\cos b^{^{\prime } } + \sin ( b+l)\sin b^{^{\prime } } \eqnum{20 } \\ & \leq & \cos ( b - b^{^{\prime } } ) \cos l+[\sin b\cos b^{^{\prime } } \cos \alpha \cos \theta + ( \sin b\cos b^{^{\prime } } \sin ^2\alpha + \cos b\sin b^{^{\prime } } ) ] \sin l \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the definition of the global fidelity , we insert eq . ( 14 ) and eq . ( 15 ) into the fidelity formula to get @xmath105 ^ 2 \nonumber \\ & & + [ \cos ( b - b^{^{\prime } } ) \cos l+[\sin b\cos b^{^{\prime } } \cos \alpha \cos \theta + ( \sin b\cos b^{^{\prime } } \sin ^2\alpha + \cos b\sin b^{^{\prime } } ) ] \sin l]^2 ) . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] so the upper bound of the fidelity must be less than the maximum of the right hand of eq.(16 ) . before getting the result , let @xmath106 @xmath107 @xmath108 @xmath109 @xmath110 @xmath111 then the maximum of the right hand of eq . ( 16 ) is @xmath112 ^ 2+[b_1\cos l+(b_2+b_3)\sin l]^2 ) , \eqnum{22}\ ] ] where @xmath41 satisfies the condition @xmath113 it can be seen from these formulas that they are symmetric for @xmath114 and @xmath115 . we can find another interesting thing from this spherical surface @xmath116 we can attain all of the results of rastegin@xcite succinctly and directly from cauchy lemma , which has obvious geometric meaning . the cauchy lemma on the @xmath70 is very important and useful . it is given out as the following . _ lemma 3 . _ ( _ cauchy _ lemma _ ) _ there are two polygons @xmath117 and @xmath118 . if the lengths of the edges in these two polygons satisfy @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath121 , @xmath122 and the angles satisfy @xmath123 , @xmath124 , @xmath125 , @xmath126 . then @xmath127 this lemma looks very simple , but its proof is rather difficult , the proof of this lemma can be found in@xcite . this lemma is useful to get some inequality . when @xmath128 , we get the familiar inequality for spherical surface triangle @xmath129 the left part of this formula is the edge of a special triangle @xmath130 whose angle @xmath131 is @xmath132 . while any angle of a triangle must be not less than @xmath132 , the left inequality is held . for the same reason , the right inequality is also hold . this inequality is just the same as @xmath133 which was introduced by rastegin@xcite . when @xmath134 we can get some useful inequality ( fig . 1 ) @xmath135 this inequality is the same as @xmath136 @xmath137 in the rastegin s paper@xcite . using cauchy lemma , we can make the condition weaken to @xmath138 , and get the useful new inequality @xmath139 . from these new inequalities we can get a new upper bound of the three states global fidelity @xmath140 this bound of the global fidelity is symmetric to the three edges of the triangle , that is , symmetric to the three states . this formula is more simple than eq.(17 ) . the equal sign is held when the states in the state - set are orthogonal . when the state - set contains more than three states , they can span a space more than three dimensions . in this situation , the actual quantum cloned states are points on a spherical surface more than @xmath141-dimension . the method which we used to get eq . ( 17 ) on @xmath70 is not available . fortunately , the inequality ( 19 ) for any four states on the same spherical surface is still correct . so we can use this inequality to get some upper bounds of the global fidelity of multi - state - dependent quantum cloning . assume the state - set contains @xmath0 states @xmath142 . and these states are taken from @xmath143 @xmath144 . at first , we divide the state - set @xmath145 into several groups @xmath146 , @xmath147 , @xmath121 , @xmath148 , and every group constitutes a convex polygon on the same @xmath70 ( we can obtain this result by the following step . at first , we can take any three states from the state - set and they must constitute the spherical surface @xmath70 . then put all of the vectors which are linearly dependent on the three states and make the points of all of these vectors constitute a convex polygon . do the same operation to the rest vectors until the number of the vectors is less than 3 . at this situation , we take some vectors from the group which has more than three vectors to get a new spherical surface @xmath70 ) . on the spherical surface @xmath70 , we can use the cauchy lemma to get the inequality ( 19 ) and insert them into the formula of the global fidelity . @xmath149 \eqnum{26 } \\ & \leq & \frac 1{2n}[(i+\sum_{p=1}^i\cos ( a_{p+1,p}-a_{p+1,p}^{^{\prime } } ) ) + \sum_{q = i+1}^j((j - i)+\cos ( a_{q+1,q}-a_{q+1,q}^{^{\prime } } ) ) + \cdots \nonumber \\ & & + \sum_{r = k+1}^n((n - k)+\cos ( a_{r+1,r}-a_{r+1,r}^{^{\prime } } ) ] \nonumber \\ & = & \frac 12+\frac 1{2n}[\sum_{p=1}^i\cos ( a_{p+1,p}-a_{p+1,p}^{^{\prime } } ) + \sum_{q = i+1}^j\cos ( a_{q+1,q}-a_{q+1,q}^{^{\prime } } ) + \cdots \nonumber \\ & & + \sum_{r = k+1}^n\cos ( a_{r+1,r}-a_{r+1,r}^{^{\prime } } ) ] , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath150 and @xmath151 , @xmath152 and @xmath153 ; @xmath154 ; @xmath155 ; @xmath156 are vertexes of a convex polygon on @xmath70 respectively . it can be seen from the deriving process that the result is dependent on the partition of the states and the choice of the loops . it is not good enough for us since it is not uniquely determined by the state - set . since the eq . ( 19 ) is correct for every four vectors , we can get a more symmetric result . we can average all of the possible divided sets and get @xmath157 . \eqnum{27}\ ] ] even though this inequality is the most symmetry for every state - set , it is not the tightest bound which we can get by this method for the quantum cloning process . there are some methods to refine the bound . first , we construct the @xmath158 matrix @xmath2 whose elements are @xmath159 , so the matrix is @xmath160 it should be pointed out that the diagonal elements of this matrix are zero . the first step of our refining process is to find the maximal element @xmath161 in the upper triangle of the matrix which is denoted by @xmath162 . then we replace the row and the column in which the element @xmath162 lies by zeroes . at the end of the first step we get an element and a new @xmath158 matrix . ( if there are @xmath163 maximal elements which are denoted by @xmath164 @xmath165 @xmath166 in the upper triangle of the matrix @xmath2 . then we denote the secondary maximum element of upper triangle elements within the rows @xmath167and columns @xmath168 as @xmath169 . thus we denote the minimal element @xmath170 of @xmath171 as @xmath162 ) . we can iterate the operation to get the elements @xmath172 , @xmath173 , @xmath174}$](@xmath175 $ ] is the integer part of @xmath176 ) . then a more stringent bound can be attained with our method @xmath177}[\sum_{j=1}^{[\frac{n+1}2]}\cos e_j ] . \eqnum{29}\ ] ] in the practical quantum information processes the state - dependent cloning is more important than the universal cloning . in fact , we can view the universal cloning as the lower bound of the state - dependent cloning . if we have no information about the state - set , the optimal strategy we can chose is the universal cloning . but if we know something about the state - set , that is , we have some information about the state , we can find the strategy no worse than the universal cloning . in fact , we always have some information about the states in the practical information processes . so it is very important to find the strategy of the state - dependent cloning which is better than universal clone . at the same time we want to know _ how much _ we can improve the quantum cloning process when we know something about the state - set . unfortunately , it is too difficult to solve this problem completely . we can only find some bounds for this process and partly answer this question . there are close relations between state - dependent cloning and eavesdropping in quantum cryptography . cloning is a method for eavesdropper to eavesdropping ( but it is not necessarily the optimal one ) . when the state - set only contains two states , the situation has already been completely discussed by bru _ et al . _ @xcite . because of the relationship between the quantum cloning and eavesdropping , the bound of the multi - state - dependent quantum cloning can be considered as a bound for the eavesdropping when the eavesdropper use the cloning strategy to get the information of the communication process . this work was funded by the national fundamental research program ( 2001cb309300 ) , the innovation funds from chinese academy of sciences . @xmath178 are the vertexes of the idea copies of @xmath179 and @xmath180are the vertexes of the virtual copies of @xmath181 . they are on the same spheral surface . @xmath182and @xmath183 are arcs on this spheral surface . we suppose @xmath184 , @xmath185 , @xmath186 , @xmath187 , @xmath188 . | due to the no - cloning theorem , the unknown quantum state can only be cloned approximately or exactly with some probability . there are two types of cloners : universal and state - dependent cloner . the optimal universal cloner has been found and could be viewed as a special state - dependent quantum cloner which has no information about the states . in this paper , we investigate the state - dependent cloning when the state - set contains more than two states . we get some bounds of the global fidelity for these processes . this method is not dependent on the number of the states contained in the state - set . it is also independent of the numbers of copying . pacs number(s ) : 03.67.-a , 03.65.ta , 89.70.+c |
1508.06215 | observing extra solar planets transiting their host stars has become an important tool for planet detection and is used to obtain and constrain fundamental system parameters : the inclination has to be close to @xmath0 , while the planet to star radius ratio is constrained mainly by the transit depth . also , in combination with spectroscopy , the semimajor axis and the absolute planet and star radii can be obtained as well . several years ago , when the first results of the _ kepler _ mission were published ( see @xcite for first scientific results , @xcite for an instrument description ) , studying the transit timing became one of the standard techniques in the analysis of transit observations . since space based missions are able to observe many consecutive transit events with a high precision , one can detect even small variations of the transit intervals indicating deviations from a strictly keplerian motion and thus yet hidden planets in the observed system . furthermore , with the discovery of multi - planetary systems , transit timing variations ( ttvs ) are used to find the masses of the companions without the need of radial velocity measurements due to the influence of planetary interaction on ttvs . since many planet candidates found in photometric surveys are too faint for radial velocity follow - up even with bigger telescopes , ttv analyses can be considered as a photometric work - around to estimate masses . although the existence of ttvs can be shown in already known exoplanetary systems , only a few additional planet candidates have been found using ttvs so far ( for recent examples of a proposed additional body indicated by ttv analyses see e.g. @xcite and @xcite ) . this is not suprising , since large bodies often can be found using radial velocity measurements or direct transit detections , while small ( e.g. earth - like ) objects result in small ttv amplitudes and therefore high precision timing measurements are needed . these measurements can already be acquired with medium size ground - based telescopes . commonly the transit mid - time of each observation is plotted into an observed minus calculated ( o c ) diagram @xcite , where the difference between the observed transit mid - time and the mid - time obtained using the initial ephemeris is shown versus the observing epoch . in such a diagram remaining slopes indicate a wrong orbital period , while e.g. periodic deviations from a linear trend indicate perturbing forces . besides the discovery of small planets , the amount of known massive planets on close - in orbits increased as well . first studies on a larger sample of planet candidates detected with _ kepler _ suggest that hot giant planets exist in single planet systems only @xcite . however , @xcite analysed a larger sample of _ kepler _ hot jupiters and found a few cases where ttvs can not be explained by other causes ( e.g. artificial sampling effects due to the observing cadence ) but the existence of perturbers additional planets or even exo - moons in the respective system . in addition @xcite point toward the planet candidates koi-338 , koi-94 and koi-1241 who are all hot jupiters in multi - planetary systems , as well as the hat - p-13 system with a hot jupiter accompanied by a massive planet on an eccentric outer orbit ( see also * ? ? ? * ) and the wasp-12 system with a proposed companion candidate found by ttv analysis @xcite . the origin of those planets is yet not fully understood . one possible formation scenario shows that close - in giant planets could have migrated inwards after their creation further out @xcite . in that case , inner and close outer planets would have either been thrown out of the system , or caught in resonance . in the latter case , even small perturbing masses , e.g. earth - mass objects , can result in ttv amplitudes in the order of several minutes ( see @xcite or @xcite ) . though _ kepler _ is surveying many of those systems , it is necessary to look at the most promising candidates among all close - in giant planets discovered so far , including stars outside the field of view of _ kepler_. in our ongoing study of ttvs in exoplanetary systems we perform photometric follow - up observations of specific promising transiting planets where additional bodies are expected . the targets are selected by the following criteria : * the orbital solution of the known transiting planet shows non - zero eccentricity ( though the circularization time - scale is much shorter than the system age ) and/or deviant radial velocity ( rv ) data points both possibly indicating a perturber . * the brightness of the host star is @xmath1mag and the transit depth is at least @xmath2mmag to ensure sufficient photometric and timing precision at 1 - 2 m class ground - based telescopes . * the target is visible from the northern hemisphere . * the target has not been studied for ttv signals before . in the past the transiting exoplanets wasp-12b @xcite , wasp-3b @xcite , wasp-10b ( * ? ? ? * maciejewski et al . 2014 in prep . ) , wasp-14b @xcite , tres-2 @xcite , and hat - p-32b @xcite have been studied by our group in detail . in most cases , except for wasp-12b , no ttvs could be confirmed . here , we extend our investigations to search for ttvs in the hat - p-18 , hat - p-19 , hat - p-27/wasp-40 and wasp-21 planetary systems . in section [ sec : targets ] we give a short description of the targets analysed within this project . section [ sec : dataaquisitionandreduction ] explains the principles of data acquisition and reduction and gives an overview of the telescopes used for observation . the modeling procedures are described in section [ sec : analyses ] , followed by the results in section [ sec : results ] . finally , section [ sec : summary ] gives a summary of our project . [ cols="<,<,<,<,^",options="header " , ] all data has been reduced in a standard way by applying dark / bias and flat field corrections using iraf . the respective calibration images have been obtained in the same night and with the same focus as the scientific observations . this is necessary especially if the pointing of the telescope is not stable . when using calibration images obtained with different foci , patterns remain in the images that lead to distortions in the light curve . besides our own observations , we also use literature data . this involves data from the respective discovery papers mentioned in section [ sec : targets ] , as well as data from @xcite in case of hat - p-18b , @xcite in case of hat - p-27b , @xcite and @xcite for wasp-21b , and @xcite for wasp-38b . the light curve extraction and modelling is performed analogous to the procedure described in detail in @xcite . the julian date of each image is calculated from the header information of the start of the exposure and the exposure time . to precisely determine the mid - time of the transit event these informations have to be stored most accurate . the reliability of the final light curve model thus also depends on a precise time synchronization of the telescope computer system . observing transits with multiple telescopes at the same time enables to look for synchronization errors which would otherwise lead to artifacts in the o c diagram ( as shown for hat - p-27b in epoch 415 , see section [ subsec : ergh27 ] ) . we use differential aperture photometry to extract the light curve from the reduced images by measuring the brightness of all bright stars in the field with routines provided by iraf . the typical aperture radius is @xmath3 times the mean full width half maximum of all stars in the field of view ( fov ) . the best fitting aperture is found by manually varying the aperture radius by a few pixels to minimize the photometric scatter . the final light curve is created by comparing the star of interest against an artificial standard star composed of the ( typically 15 - 30 ) brightest stars in the fov weighted by their respective constantness as introduced by @xcite . the final photometric errors are based on the instrumental iraf measurement errors . the error of the constant comparison stars are rescaled by their photometric scatter using shared scaling factors in order to achieve a mean @xmath4 for all comparison stars . the error bars of the transit star are rescaled afterwards using the same scaling factors ( for further details on the procedure see * ? ? ? due to atmospheric and air - mass effects transit light curves show trends . they can impact the determination of transit parameters . to eliminate such effects we start the observation about 1 hour before and finish about 1 hour after the transit itself . thus we can detrend the observations by fitting a second order polynomial to the out - of - transit data . to model the light curves we used the transit analysis package ( tap ; * ? ? ? the modelling of the transit light curve is done by using the exofast routines @xcite with the light curve model of @xcite . for error estimation tap uses markov chain monte carlo simulations ( in our case 10 times 10@xmath5 mcmc chains ) together with wavelet - based likelihood functions @xcite . the coefficients for the quadratic limb darkening ( ld ) law used by tap are taken from the exofast / quadld - routine of @xcite that linearly interpolates the ld tables of @xcite . for comparison we also use jktebop ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) which is based on the ebop code for eclipsing binaries @xcite . to compare the results with those obtained with tap , we only use a quadratic ld law which is sufficient for ground - based data . for error estimation we used monte carlo simulations ( @xmath6 runs ) , bootstrapping ( @xmath6 data sets ) , and a residual shift method as provided by jktebop . as input values we use the system properties presented in the respective discovery papers ( see table [ tab : allinputvalues ] for a summary ) . for both light curve fitting procedures we took the original light curve as well as a threefold binned one . though the binned light curves result in a lower rms of the fit , no better timing result can be achieved due to a longer cadence . as free parameters we use the mid - transit time @xmath7 , inclination @xmath8 , and planet to star radius ratio @xmath9 ( with @xmath10 and @xmath11 being the planet and stellar radius scaled by the semimajor axis , respectively ) . in case of tap the inverse fractional stellar radius @xmath12 , in case of jktebop the sum of the fractional radii @xmath13 is fitted as well . both quantities are an expression of the transit duration and can be transformed into each other according to the following equation : @xmath14 the fitting procedure is applied two times . first keeping the limb darkening coefficients fixed at their theoretical values , and afterwards letting them vary . for tap we set the fitting interval to @xmath15 . in case of jktebop we use the option to set the ld coefficients fixed for the initial model , but let them being perturbed for the error estimation . thus the fitted model does not change , but the error bars are increased . the eccentricity was fixed to zero for all our analyses . since all data are obtained using jd@xmath16 as time base , we transform the fitted mid - transit times to bjd@xmath17 afterwards using the online converter provided by jason eastman ( for a detailed description of the barycentric dynamical time see * ? ? ? * ) . finally , we derive the photometric noise rate ( pnr , * ? ? ? * ) as a quality marker for all light curves , which is defined as the ratio between the root mean square of the model fit and the number of data points per minute . for further analysis we took data with @xmath18 into account for every light curve we get six different models , four from tap ( for the binned and unbinned data with the ld coefficients fixed and free ) and two from jktebop ( for the binned and unbinned data , ld coefficients set free for error estimation only ) . to get one final result we averaged those six results . as for the errors , we got four different estimations from tap and 12 from jktebop . as final error value , we took the maximum of either the largest of the error estimates , or the spread of the model fit results to use a conservative error estimate . it has to be noted , though , that the spread between the different models has always been below size of the error bars . binning the light curve threefold using an error weighted mean in principle still leaves enough data points during ingress and egress to be able to fit the transit model to the data while reducing the error bar of an individual measurement . however , comparing the results of the threefold binned and unbinned data we do not see significant differences , neither in the fitted values , nor in the error bars . the same counts for the differences between the tap models obtained with fixed ld values and those obtained with the ld coefficients set free to fit . for a detailed discussion of the influence of the ld model on transit light curves see e.g. @xcite . for hat - p-18b we obtained five transit light curves ( see fig [ fig : h18_erg ] ) . all light curves show some features which could be caused by stellar activity , e.g. spots . however , the quality of the data does not allow to draw further conclusion . moreover , there is only a small number of suitable comparison stars available in the respective fov of each observation , hence this could also be an artificial effect . except for one but not significant outlier the differences in the o c diagram ( see fig . [ fig : h18_erg ] ) can be explained by redetermining the published period by @xmath19s . hence we find a slightly larger period compared to the originally proposed period of @xcite . regarding the transit depth , and thus the planet to star radius ratio , we do not see any changes . however , having a look at the data provided in the exoplanet transit database ( etd ; * ? ? ? * ) one can see that the values for the transit depth reported there vary by several tens of mmag . such transit depth variations can be caused by close variable stellar companions placed within the aperture due to the pixel scale of our detectors and the defocussing of the telescopes . thus we took a more detailed look at the long term variability of the parent star . over a timespan of 12 months we obtained 3 images in four bands ( b , v , r , i ) in each clear night using the jena 0.6 m telescope . as shown in fig . [ fig : monitoring_h18 ] , the mean variation of the r band brightness is @xmath20mmag taking the individual error bar of the measurements into account . however , this variation is too small to be responsible for the seen transit depth variations . the monitoring of the remaining bands is not shown but leads to a similar result . having a closer look at the light curves listed for hat - p-18b in etd , one can see that a large number is of lower quality . this is especially true for those light curves responsible for the spread in the tabulated transit depth . taking only the higher quality data into account the spread is much smaller . depending on the quality cut the variation can even reach the order of the error bars of the measurements . thus we believe that the transit depth variation is negligible . despite a spread in the data , which can be explained by the quality of the light curves , we do not see any significant difference for @xmath21 , @xmath8 and @xmath22 between the respective observations . a summary of all obtained parameters can be found in table [ tab : allnewproperties ] at the end of the paper , as well as a comparison with literature values . for hat - p-19b we got two light curves using the jena 0.6 m and one light curve from the caha 1.2 m telescope ( fig . [ fig : h19_erg ] ) . in all three cases we obtained high precision data . the light curves show no artifacts that could be ascribed to e.g. spots on the stellar surface . plotting the mid - transit times into the o c diagram , we can redetermine the period by @xmath23s . as for the inclination and the reverse fractional stellar radius we can confirm the values reported in @xcite . the radius ratio of @xmath24 , however , seems to be smaller than assumed by @xcite ( @xmath25 ) . hat - p-27b planetary transits were observed six times . an advantage of a network such as yeti lies within the possibility of simultaneous observations using different telescopes . this enables us to independently check whether the data is reliable . for hat - p-27b simultaneous observations could be achieved at epoch 415 using two different telescopes ( antalya 1.0 m and osn 1.5 m ) . as one can see in fig . [ fig : h27_erg ] the best - fitting transit shapes differ . since some data has been acquired using small telescopes under unfavorable conditions , this might be an artificial effect . however , these shape variations can also be seen in the literature data . while @xcite fitted a flat bottom to the transit they observed , the transit of @xcite shows a rather roundish bottom and so does the @xcite transit . both @xcite and @xcite claim , a roundish bottom is in good agreement with a grazing transit . our most precise transit light curve of hat - p-27b at epoch 415 the osn 1.5 m telescope also shows no flat bottom . thus , we would agree with the previous authors that the planet is grazing . the epoch 540 observations also shows a v - shape . however , due to a connection problem parts of the ingress data is missing , thus precise fits of the transit parameters are not possible . in addition to our own data we added data from @xcite and @xcite . the latter one only lists system parameters without giving an epoch of observation , thus we artificially put them to epoch 200 . since we do not see any systematic trend in the remaining data , this does not effect the conclusion on the system parameters but improves the precision of the constant fit . the system parameters @xmath8 , @xmath26 and @xmath21 can be determined more precisely than before taking the errors of the individual measurements into account . all three parameters are in good agreement with the results of previous authors . furthermore , we do not see any significant variation . the larger @xmath21-value of the epoch 540 observations are due to the quality of the corresponding light curve . looking at the mid - transit time we see that a period change of @xmath27s explains the data quite well . the mid - transit time of one of the epoch 415 observations was found to be @xmath28min ahead of time , while the other one is as predicted . this way we could identify a synchronization error during one of the observations . this example shows the importance of simultaneous transit observations . unfortunately this was the only sucessful observation of that kind within this project ( for a larger set of double and threefold observations see e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . four transit light curves of wasp-21b are available , including one light curve from @xcite ( see fig.[fig : w21_erg ] ) . in addition , the results of the analysis of two transit events of @xcite and one transit observation of @xcite are also taken into account . concerning the o c diagram , we found that a period change of @xmath29s removes the linear trend which is present in the data fitted with the initial ephemeris . as in the previous analyses no trend or sinusoidal variation in the system parameters can be seen . however , regarding inclination and reverse fractional stellar radius we do see a significant difference between our results and the initial values published by @xcite . this was also found by other authors before . as discussed in @xcite this result is a consequence of the assumption of @xcite that the planet host star is a main sequence star , while @xcite found that the star starts evolving off the main sequence and thus its radius increases . this in turn leads to corrections of the stellar and hence planetary properties . we presented the results of the transit observations of the extra solar planets hat - p-18b , hat - p-19b , hat - p-27b / wasp-40b and wasp-21b which are part of our ongoing project on gound - based follow - up observations of exoplanetary transits using small to medium sized telescopes with the help of yeti network telescopes . during the past three years we followed these well chosen objects to refine their orbital parameters as well as to find transit timing variations indicating yet unknown planetary companions . table [ tab : allnewproperties ] contains an overview of the redetermined properties , as well as the available literature values , while table [ tab : fitresults ] lists the results of the individual light curve fits . in all cases we could redetermine the orbital parameters . especially the period could be determined more precise than before . so far , we can not rule out the existence of ttv signals for the planets investigated within this study due to the limited number of available high quality data . also the parameters @xmath22 , @xmath30 and inclination have been obtained and compared to the available literature data . despite some corrections to the literature data , we found no significant variations within these parameters . to distinguish between a real astrophysical source of the remaining scatter and random noise as a result of the quality of our data more high precision transit observations would be needed . hat - p-18b was also part of an out - of - transit monitoring for a spread in the transit depth was reported in the literature that could be due to a significant variability of the transit host star . regarding our transit data we can not confirm the spread in transit depth . looking at the quality of the literature data showing the transit depth variation , it is very likely that this spread is of artificial nature . thus it is not suprising that we did not find stellar variability larger than @xmath20mmag . however we do see some structures in the light curves that could be caused by spot activity on the stellar surface . @ll@@xmath31ll@@xmath31ll@@xmath31ll@@xmath31ll@@xmath31l & & & & & + + our analysis & @xmath32 & @xmath33 & @xmath34 & @xmath35 & @xmath36 & @xmath37 & @xmath38 & @xmath39 & @xmath40 & @xmath41 + @xcite & @xmath42 & @xmath43 & @xmath44 & @xmath45 & @xmath46 & @xmath47 & @xmath48 & @xmath49 & @xmath50 & @xmath51 + @xcite & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & @xmath40 & @xmath60 + + our analysis & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 & @xmath64 & @xmath65 & @xmath66 & @xmath67 & @xmath68 & @xmath69 & @xmath70 + @xcite & @xmath71 & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath45 & @xmath74 & @xmath75 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 + + our analysis & @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & @xmath49 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 + @xcite & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & & @xmath93 & @xmath94 & + @xcite & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & @xmath49 & + @xcite & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & & & @xmath106&@xmath107 + @xcite & & @xmath108 & @xmath45 & & & @xmath109 & @xmath110 + + our analysis & @xmath111 & @xmath112 & @xmath113 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & @xmath116 & @xmath117 & @xmath118 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 + @xcite & @xmath121 & @xmath122 & & & & + @xcite & @xmath123 & @xmath43 & @xmath124 & @xmath125 & & & @xmath126&@xmath127 + @xcite & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 & @xmath131 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 & @xmath134&@xmath135 & @xmath136 & @xmath137 + @xcite&@xmath138&@xmath139 & @xmath124 & @xmath125 & @xmath140 & @xmath141 & @xmath142&@xmath143 & @xmath144 & @xmath145 + lcll@@xmath146ll@@xmath146ll@@xmath146ll@@xmath146lc date & epoch & telescope & & & & & @xmath147(mmag ) + + 2011/04/21 & 174 & trebur 1.2 m & @xmath148 & @xmath149 & @xmath150 & @xmath151 & @xmath152 & @xmath153 & @xmath154 & @xmath155 & @xmath156 + 2011/05/24 & 180 & trebur 1.2 m & @xmath157 & @xmath158 & @xmath159 & @xmath160 & @xmath161 & @xmath162 & @xmath163 & @xmath164 & @xmath165 + 2012/05/05 & 243 & rozhen 0.6 m & @xmath166 & @xmath167 & @xmath168 & @xmath169 & @xmath170 & @xmath171 & @xmath172 & @xmath173 & @xmath174 + 2012/06/07 & 249 & ca - dlr 1.2 m & @xmath175 & @xmath176 & & & & @xmath177 + 2013/04/28 & 308 & antalya 1.0 m & @xmath178 & @xmath167 & @xmath179 & @xmath180 & @xmath181 & @xmath182 & @xmath183 & @xmath47 & @xmath184 + + 2011/11/23 & 199 & jena 0.6 m & @xmath185 & @xmath186 & @xmath187 & @xmath188 & @xmath189 & @xmath190 & @xmath191 & @xmath192 & @xmath193 + 2011/12/09 & 203 & jena 0.6 m & @xmath194 & @xmath81 & @xmath195 & @xmath196 & @xmath189 & @xmath197 & @xmath198 & @xmath75 & @xmath199 + 2011/12/17 & 205 & ca - dlr 1.2 m & @xmath200 & @xmath72 & @xmath201 & @xmath202 & @xmath203 & @xmath204 & @xmath205 & @xmath206 & @xmath207 + 2014/10/04 & 460 & jena 0.6 m & @xmath208 & @xmath209 & @xmath210 & @xmath211 & @xmath212 & @xmath190 & @xmath213 & @xmath75 & @xmath214 + + 2011/04/05 & 155 & lulin 0.4 m & @xmath215 & @xmath216 & @xmath217 & @xmath218 & @xmath219 & @xmath220 & @xmath221 & @xmath222 & @xmath223 + 2011/04/08 & 156 & lulin 0.4 m & @xmath224 & @xmath225 & @xmath226 & @xmath227 & @xmath228 & @xmath229 & @xmath230 & @xmath231 & @xmath232 + 2011/05/05 & 165 & trebur 1.2 m & @xmath233 & @xmath234 & @xmath235 & @xmath236 & @xmath237 & @xmath238 & @xmath239 & @xmath240 & @xmath241 + 2012/04/01 & 274 & tenagra 0.8 m & @xmath242 & @xmath243 & @xmath244 & @xmath245 & @xmath246 & @xmath247 & @xmath248 & @xmath249 & @xmath250 + 2012/04/25 & 282 & xinglong 0.6 m & @xmath251 & @xmath252 & @xmath253 & @xmath218 & @xmath93 & @xmath254 & @xmath255 & @xmath256 & @xmath257 + 2013/06/03 & 415 & antalya 1.0 m & @xmath258 & @xmath259 & @xmath260 & @xmath261 & @xmath262 & @xmath220 & @xmath263 & @xmath264 & @xmath265 + 2013/06/03 & 415 & osn 1.5 m & @xmath266 & @xmath267 & @xmath268 & @xmath269 & @xmath270 & @xmath271 & @xmath272 & @xmath41 & @xmath273 + 2013/06/18 & 540 & antalya 1.0 m & @xmath274 & @xmath275 & @xmath276 & @xmath227 & @xmath277 & @xmath278 & @xmath279 & @xmath280 & @xmath281 + + 2011/08/24 & 244 & swarthmore 0.6 m & @xmath282 & @xmath283 & @xmath284 & @xmath285 & @xmath286 & @xmath287 & @xmath288 & @xmath289 & @xmath290 + 2012/08/16 & 327 & trebur 1.2 m & @xmath291 & @xmath292 & @xmath293 & @xmath294 & @xmath295 & @xmath287 & @xmath296 & @xmath297 & @xmath298 + 2013/09/18 & 420 & ca - dlr 1.2 m & @xmath299 & @xmath300 & @xmath301 & @xmath302 & @xmath303 & @xmath204 & @xmath304 & @xmath305 & @xmath306 + all the participating observatories appreciate the logistic and financial support of their institutions and in particular their technical workshops . ms would like to thank all participating yeti telescopes for their observations , as well as g. maciejewski for helpful comments on this work . jgs , ap , and rn would like to thank the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( dfg ) for support in the collaborative research center sonderforschungsbereich sfb tr 7 `` gravitationswellenastronomie '' . re , mk , sr , and rn would like to thank the dfg for support in the priority programme spp 1385 on the _ first ten million years of the solar system _ in projects ne 515/34 - 1 & -2 . rn would like to acknowledge financial support from the thuringian government ( b 515 - 07010 ) for the stk ccd camera ( jena 0.6 m ) used in this project . mm and cg thank dfg in project mu 2695/13 - 1 . the research of dd and dk was supported partly by funds of projects do 02 - 362 , do 02 - 85 and ddvu 02/40 - 2010 of the bulgarian scientific foundation , as well as project rd-08 - 261 of shumen university . was supported by the chinese national natural science foundation grant nos . the research of rc , mh and mh is supported as a project of the nordrhein - westflische akademie der wissenschaften und knste in the framework of the academy programme by the federal republic of germany and the state nordrhein - westfalen . mf acknowledges financial support from grants aya2011 - 30147-c03 - 01 of the spanish ministry of economy and competivity ( mineco ) , co - funded with eu feder funds , and 2011 fqm 7363 of the consejera de economa , innovacin , ciencia y empleo ( junta de andaluca , spain ) we also wish to thank the tbitak national observatory ( tug ) for supporting this work through project number 12bt100 - 324 - 0 an 12ct100 - 388 using the t100 telescope . ms thanks d. keeley , m. m. hohle and h. gilbert for supporting the observations at the university observatory jena . this research has made use of nasa s astrophysics data system . this research is based on observations obtained with telescopes of the university observatory jena , which is operated by the astrophysical institute of the friedrich - schiller - university . this work has been supported in part by istanbul university under project number 39742 , by a vega grant 2/0143/14 of the slovak academy of sciences and by the joint fund of astronomy of the national science foundation of china and the chinese academy of science under grants u1231113 . 99 adams f. c. , laughlin g. , 2006 , apj , 649 , 992 anderson d. r. , et al . , 2011 , pasp , 123 , 555 bakos g. , noyes r. w. , kovcs g. , stanek k. z. , sasselov d. d. , domsa i. , 2004 , pasp , 116 , 266 barros s. c. c. , pollacco d. l. , gibson n. p. , howarth i. d. , keenan f. p. , simpson e. k. , skillen i. , steele i. a. , 2011b , mnras , 416 , 2593 barros s. c. c. , et al . , 2011a , a&a , 525 , a54 bky b. , et al . , 2011 , apj , 734 , 109 borucki w. j. , et al . , 2011 , apj , 728 , 117 bouchy f. , et al . , 2010 , a&a , 519 , a98 bodenheimer p. , laughlin g. , lin d. n. c. , 2003 , apj , 592 , 555 broeg c. , fernndez m. , neuhuser r. , 2005 , an , 326 , 134 brown d. j. a. , et al . , 2012 , apj , 760 , 139 carter j. a. , winn j. n. , 2009 , apj , 704 , 51 ciceri s. , et al . , 2013 , a&a , 557 , a30 claret a. , bloemen s. , 2011 , a&a , 529 , a75 eastman j. , gaudi b. s. , agol e. , 2013 , pasp , 125 , 83 eastman j. , siverd r. , gaudi b. s. , 2010 , pasp , 122 , 935 esposito m. , et al . , 2014 , a&a , 564 , l13 etzel p. b. , 1981 , in carling e. b. , kopal z. , eds , proc . study inst . , photometric and spectroscopic binary systems , reidel , dordrecht , p. 111 ford e. b. , holman m. j. , 2007 , apj , 664 , l51 fulton b. j. , shporer a. , winn j. n. , holman m. j. , pl a. , gazak j. z. , 2011 , aj , 142 , 84 gazak j. z. , johnson j. a. , tonry j. , dragomir d. , eastman j. , mann a. w. , agol e. , 2012 , adast , 2012 , 30 ginski c. , mugrauer m. , seeliger m. , eisenbeiss t. , 2012 , mnras , 421 , 2498 hartman j. d. , et al . , 2011 , apj , 726 , 52 knutson h. a. , et al . , 2013 , arxiv , arxiv:1312.2954 koch d. g. , et al . , 2010 , apj , 713 , l79 kovcs g. , et al . , 2010 , apj , 724 , 866 maciejewski g. , et al . , 2010 , mnras , 407 , 2625 maciejewski g. , et al . , 2011a , mnras , 411 , 1204 maciejewski g. , errmann r. , raetz st . , seeliger m. , spaleniak i. , neuhuser r. , 2011 , a&a , 528 , a65 maciejewski g. , et al . , 2013b , a&a , 551 , a108 maciejewski g. , et al . , 2013a , aj , 146 , 147 mandel k. , agol e. , 2002 , apj , 580 , l171 mugrauer m. , berthold t. , 2010 , an , 331 , 449 neuhuser r. , et al . , 2011 , an , 332 , 547 poddan s. , brt l. , pejcha o. , 2010 , newa , 15 , 297 pollacco d. l. , et al . , 2006 , pasp , 118 , 1407 popper d. m. , etzel p. b. , 1981 , aj , 86 , 102 raetz st . , 2012 , phd thesis university jena raetz et al . , 2014 , mnras , 444 , 1351 sada p. v. , et al . , 2012 , pasp , 124 , 212 seeliger m. , et al . , 2014 , mnras , 441 , 304 simpson e. k. , et al . , 2010 , mnras , 405 , 1867 smalley b. , et al . , 2011 , a&a , 526 , a130 southworth j. , et al . , 2009a , mnras , 396 , 1023 southworth j. , et al . , 2009b , mnras , 399 , 287 southworth j. , 2008 , mnras , 386 , 1644 southworth j. , 2012 , mnras , 426 , 1291 steffen j. h. , et al . , 2012 , pnas , 109 , 7982 szab g. m. , et al . , 2010 , a&a , 523 , a84 szab r. , szab g. m. , dlya g. , simon a. e. , hodosn g. , kiss l. l. , 2013 , a&a , 553 , a17 van eylen v. , et al . , 2014 , apj , 782 , 14 von essen c. , schrter s. , agol e. , schmitt j. h. m. m. , 2013 , a&a , 555 , a92 weber m. , granzer t. , strassmeier k. g. , 2012 , spie , 8451 , winn j. n. , 2010 , arxiv , arxiv:1001.2010 wu z .- y . , zhou x. , ma j. , jiang z .- j . , chen j .- s . , wu j .- h . , 2007 , aj , 133 , 2061 | as part of our ongoing effort to investigate transit timing variations ( ttvs ) of known exoplanets , we monitored transits of the four exoplanets hat - p-18b , hat - p-19b , hat - p-27b / wasp-40b and wasp-21b . all of them are suspected to show ttvs due to the known properties of their host systems based on the respective discovery papers . during the past three years 42 transit observations were carried out , mostly using telescopes of the young exoplanet transit initiative . the analyses are used to refine the systems orbital parameters . in all cases we found no hints for significant ttvs , or changes in the system parameters inclination , fractional stellar radius and planet to star radius ratio and thus could confirm the already published results . [ firstpage ] planets and satellites : individual : hat - p-18b , hat - p-19b , hat - p-27b / wasp-40b , wasp-21b |
astro-ph0105525 | hard x - ray surveys can permit to resolve directly the sources making the hard cosmic x - ray background ( xrb ) and so provide strong constraints on unification schemes and agn synthesis models for the xrb . according to these models a large fraction of the 2 - 100 kev xrb energy density is due to obscured agn ( setti & woltjer 1989 ; madau , ghisellini & fabian 1994 ; comastri et al . 1995 ; gilli , risaliti & salvati 1999 ; wilman & fabian 1999 ; pompilio , la franca & matt 2000 ) , emerging at high energies . a major step forward in the study of the hard x ray sky has been achieved by asca ( georgantopoulos et al . 1997 ; cagnoni della ceca , maccacaro 1998 ; boyle et al . 1998 ; ueda et al . 1998,1999 ; della ceca et al . 1999 ) and bepposax ( giommi perri & fiore 2000 ) . at the flux limit of the deepest asca and bepposax surveys in the 210 kev band ( @xmath7 5 @xmath8 10@xmath9 ) about 30 % of the xrb is resolved into single sources . _ chandra _ and xmm_newton _ pushed the 210 kev flux limit @xmath10 times fainter , resolving between 70 and 100 % of the hard x ray cosmic background ( mushotzky et al . 2000 , giacconi et al . 2001 ; hasinger et al . 2001 ) . optical follow up observations ( akiyama et al . 2000 ; fiore et al . 1999 , 2000 ; mushotzky et al . 2000 ; giacconi et al . 2001 ) , revelead that a large fraction of these sources are agn and that a sizeable fraction of them show evidence of x ray and optical obscuration . absorbed agn can be detected , of course less efficiently , also below 2 kev . indeed , the optical identification process of deep and ultra deep rosat pspc and hri surveys ( resolving @xmath11 of the 0.52.0 kev xrb , hasinger et al . 1998 ) , finds that about one fourth of the sources are intermediate agn or narrow line galaxies , likely sites of high obscuration ( the remaining sources being broad line quasars , schmidt et al . 1998 , lehmann et al . 2000 ) . in order to investigate the nature of the sources of the hard xrb we have carried out a systematic search of x ray sources in the 510 kev energy range , the hardest band accessible with imaging instruments . the high energy large area survey ( hellas ) is described in detail by fiore et al . ( 2001 , paper ii ) . the hard x ray selected sources have been extensively observed also at other wavelengths . the results of optical identifications are reported by fiore et al . ( 1999 , paper i ) and la franca et al . ( in preparation , paper v ) ; the search for soft x ray counterparts in the rosat pspc archive is reported by vignali et al . ( 2001 , paper iv ) , while the results of vla radio observations are discussed by ciliegi et al . ( in preparation , paper vi ) . here we show that the bepposax and xmm_newton _ source counts in the 510 kev energy range and the average spectral properties of hellas sources provide further constraints on the absorption and luminosity distribution of the sources making the hard xrb and on agn synthesis models . we also show the need of a large number of highly obscured ( log@xmath3 = 2324 cm@xmath2 ) , high luminosity sources to reproduce the xrb spectrum and the number counts . @xmath12 = 50 km s@xmath6 mpc@xmath6 and @xmath13 = 0 are adopted throughout this paper . the survey is presented in the companion paper by fiore et al . ( paper ii ) . briefly , the high energy large area survey ( hellas ) covers about 85 square degrees in the 510 kev band down to a flux limit of @xmath14 . sources were detected and characterized statistically using the methods described in the companion paper . the quality of the detection has always been checked interactively . the count rates were converted to fluxes using a fixed conversion factor equal to 7.8@xmath15 ( 510 kev flux ) per one `` 3 mecs count '' ( 4.510 kev ) . due to the narrowness of the band this factor is not strongly sensitive to the actual spectral shape . the sample used for computing the logn - logs includes 147 sources . optical identifications are available for about one third of the sample ( la franca et al . the increasing amount of observational data concerning both the xrb spectral intensity and the source counts in several energy ranges obtained by rosat , asca and bepposax surveys coupled with the optical identification of sizeable samples of hard x ray selected sources ( fiore et al . 1999 , 2000 , akiyama et al . 2000 ) have revived the interest on agn synthesis models for the xrb ( gilli et al . 1999 ; wilman & fabian 1999 ; pompilio et al . 2000 ) . a detailed treatement of xrb synthesis models using the most recent observational constraints , including the agn luminosity function derived from rosat deep surveys ( miyaji et al . 2000 ) and the column density distribution of seyfert 2 galaxies in the local universe estimated by risaliti et al . ( 1999 ) , is extensively discussed by gilli et al . ( 2001 ) , while a comparison between the different approaches is reviewed by comastri ( 2000 ) . even though a large fraction of the xrb spectral intensity and the source counts are fairly well reproduced by agn synthesis models , a self consistent description of the xrb constituents has yet to be reached as most of its ingredients have to be extrapolated well beyond the present observational limits . in almost all the agn synthesis models for the xrb it is assumed that the space density and evolution of the unabsorbed population can be modeled by the qso x ray luminosity function computed from rosat surveys ( boyle et al . 1993,1994 ; miyaji et al . obscured sources are then added with a distribution of column densities and with the further assumption that their luminosity function and evolution are the same of unobscured population . even though this approach seems reasonable , it is however plausible that absorbed objects could slip into deep rosat surveys at faint fluxes and thus skew the interpretation of the luminosity function and the modelling of the xrb . the possible `` contamination '' of absorbed objects is minimized using the luminosity function parameters obtained from relatively shallow rosat surveys above @xmath7 10@xmath9 erg cm@xmath2 s@xmath6 in the 0.52 kev band ( boyle et al . 1993 , 1994 ) which are essentially dominated by unabsorbed objects ( see also fig . 4a ) . the lack of a trend for a change in hardness ratio with redshift ( almaini et al . 1996 ) adds further weight to the assumption that this is a fair `` unobscured '' sample . for the purpose of the present paper we adopt the comastri et al . ( 1995 hereinafter c95 ) model with a few variations and improvements and test its prediction against the hellas and xmm _ newton _ survey findings . with respect to c95 the spectrum of heavily absorbed agn ( log @xmath3 @xmath16 24 ) is now computed taking into account compton scattering effects by means of a montecarlo code ( matt , pompilio & la franca 1999 ) . the luminosity evolution , parameterized with a power law model @xmath17 , stops at @xmath18 = 1.8 and then stays constant up to @xmath19=3 . the shape and normalization of the luminosity function are slightly different from those adopted in c95 and consistent with the values of boyle et al . the choice of these parameters is consistent with the more recent estimates of the high redshift agn evolution and also fits well the first _ _ measurements . a more detailed comparison with observational data will be discussed in the following section(s ) . the input agn spectra , including the subdivision in the @xmath3 classes centered at log@xmath3 = 21.5,22.5,23.5,24.5 , are as described in c95 , while the best fit absorption distribution of obscured agn in the four @xmath3 classes normalized to the space density of unobscured agn , turned out to be 0.35,1.5,2.3,2.0 which is slightly different from that reported by c95 for two reasons . the first is that some input parameters have been changed as described in the previous paragraph , the second concerns the intensity of the 18 kev xrb spectrum which has to be fitted by the model . the asca ( gendreau et al . 1995 ) and bepposax ( vecchi et al . 1999 ) observations of the xrb spectrum below 8 kev are significantly higher than the average level measured by heao1a2 ( marshall et al . the maximum discrepancy is between the bepposax and heao1a2 observations , the level of the latter being lower by 3040 % in the overlapping 38 kev band , the best fit asca spectrum lies approximately in between and thus we choose to fit the xrb spectral intensity as measured by asca . the best fit absorption distribution is compared with that derived by risaliti et al . ( 1999 ) in fig . [ abs_comp ] . even though the relative fraction of objects in the various @xmath3 bins is different the overall shape of the two distributions is similar . the peak in both cases is in the log@xmath3 = 2324 bin and a large fraction of the objects ( 7080 % ) is obscured by column densities greater than 10@xmath20 cm@xmath2 . as a consequence the large fraction of highly obscured objects needed to fit the xrb spectral intensity is consistent with the absorption distribution of seyfert 2 galaxies in the local universe . sources with column densities in excess of 10@xmath21 cm@xmath2 are not included in the present model as their contribution to the xrb is never energetically relevant ( see e.g. gilli et al . 1999 ) even if they could constitute a sizeable fraction of the obscured agn population ( risaliti et al . 1999 ) . figure [ lnls510 ] presents the integral 510 kev logn - logs of the 147 hellas sources . the logn - logs can be represented by a power law model @xmath22 below a flux of @xmath23 . the best fit power law index is @xmath24 . errors represent the 90 % confidence interval , errors in brackets include systematic uncertainties . the normalization @xmath25 of the best fit power law at 10@xmath26 erg cm@xmath2 s@xmath6 is 5.24 deg@xmath2 . above @xmath27 the logn - logs steepens significantly . this is probably due to a selection effect . the probability to find a bright source near a , usually , bright target is small , and therefore the number of bright sources in a serendipity survey like the hellas survey tends to be underestimated . the derived shape of the logn - logs may be affected by several biases which are extensively discussed in paper ii . for the purposes of the present discussion we compare the model predictions with the best estimate of hellas counts taking into account both statistical and systematic errors . the solid thick line in fig . [ lnls510 ] represents the expectation of the model described in the previous section . this includes both agn and clusters . the expected number counts relation for cluster of galaxies has been computed assuming an average temperature of 6 kev and the local luminosity function of piccinotti et al . ( 1982 ) with no evolution . the cluster contribution , which is never dominant at the 510 kev fluxes sampled by bepposax , is reported only for completeness . we note that a detailed calculation of cluster source counts using more recent estimates for the clusters xlf ( ebeling et al . 1997 ) provides similar results . the predicted hard x ray counts are also consistent with the recent xmm_newton _ observations in the lockman hole reaching 510 kev fluxes about an order of magnitude fainter ( hasinger et al . 2001 ) . the expectation of the same model are also compared with a compilation of number counts in the 210 kev band ( fig . [ lnls210 ] ) from bepposax ( giommi et al . 2000 ) , asca ( ueda et al . 1999 , della ceca et al . 1999 ) and chandra ( mushotzky et al . 2000 , giacconi et al . 2001 ) surveys . a good agreement between model predictions and observations is obtained with the bepposax and asca 210 kev number counts , and with the mushotzky et al . ( 2000 ) _ chandra _ counts while the measurements of giacconi et al . ( 2001 ) are slightly overpredicted . the key parameter of all the xrb models is the space density of obscured agn and their absorption distribution . it is customary to adopt a ratio between obscured and unobscured objects consistent with the value measured for samples of nearby ( often optically selected ) type 2 and type 1 seyferts galaxies . in the model discussed here such a ratio is not assumed a priori but determined from the xrb fitting procedure and thus it is obviously dependent on the column density adopted to divide absorbed from unabsorbed objects . the ratio between obscured and unobscured agn is thus about 4.3 if such a value is set to @xmath28 cm@xmath2 and about 2.4 for @xmath3 = 3 @xmath8 10@xmath29 cm@xmath2 . we stress that such a ratio is independent from optical classification and thus the relative fraction of x ray obscured agn in a flux limited survey could be different from the fraction of optically narrow lined type 2 objects . it is important also to note that the above quoted values for the ratio between obscured and unobscured objects are referred to the entire agn population responsible for the xrb intensity and that such a number would be recovered only when the full xrb is resolved into single sources . the fraction of objects with a given column density actually included in a survey depends on the flux limit of the survey and on the energy range . figure [ fraction ] shows these fractions as a function of the 0.52 , 210 and 510 kev fluxes . the dependence of the fractions on the flux is smoother in the harder bands ( see comastri 2000 ) . as a consequence , 5 - 10 kev surveys can better probe the real fraction of obscured object going down to fluxes comparatively higher than in the 2 - 10 kev and 0.5 - 2 kev bands . as an example at 510 kev fluxes of the order of 10@xmath26 erg cm@xmath2 s@xmath6 the fraction of objects in the log@xmath3 = 2324 bin is of the order of 25% while is some @xmath30 15 % in the 210 kev band and negligible in the soft 0.52 kev energy range . in order to investigate to what extent the present data can be used to constrain the absorption and luminosity distribution of the sources making the hard xrb , additional tests of synthesis models have been carried out . more specifically we have computed 2 models which both reproduce the xrb spectral shape over the 3100 kev energy range with somehow `` extreme '' assumptions on the absorption and luminosity distribution of the obscured sources . in the former case we have maximized the number of obscured compton thick sources ( about a factor 2 with respect to the baseline model ) , while in the latter a cut off in the luminosity function of absorbed agn has been introduced for luminosities greater than 10@xmath31 erg s@xmath6 . these attempts are motivated by both theoretical and observational evidence as described below . an xrb model dominated by a population of almost compton thick ( @xmath32 1 ) sources has been worked out by wilman et al . ( 2000 ) based on the suggestion of fabian ( 1999 ) who argued that significant obscuration might be associated with the growth of massive black holes in proto galactic bulges . the wilman et al . ( 2000 ) model predicts a similar contribution from obscured and unobscured objects at about 30 kev . in order to reproduce the xrb spectrum below about 10 kev additional obscuration with an average column of @xmath3 = 10@xmath33 cm@xmath2 is introduced for 70% of the remaining objects . we have computed a synthesis model with an absorption distribution dominated by compton thick sources . the contribution of these sources to the xrb is normalized to that obtained by wilman et al . ( 2000 , see their figure 1 ) while the absorption distribution for sources with lower column densities is tuned to keep the overall number of objects in the various @xmath3 classes equal to that of our baseline model and to fit the xrb spectrum . the 510 kev predicted counts are reported in figure [ sns ] and compared with the observed hellas counts and with the baseline model predictions . the y scale is the product of the integral counts times the flux . in this representation the fluxes contributing most to the xrb are around the peak of the distribution . the contribution of compton thick sources is never dominant in the 510 kev band , as a consequence , the bright part of the logn logs is not well reproduced by the model where their contribution is maximized . even though the uncertainties associated with the hard hellas and xmm_newton _ counts do not allow to rule out a large number of highly obscured agn , it is clear that on the basis of present data an @xmath3 distribution peaked at lower column densities has to be preferred . the evolution of the luminosity function of absorbed sources is assumed to be the same of unobscured one in almost all the xrb synthesis models . the lack of luminous narrow line quasar ( type 2 qso ) in optical surveys has lead several authors ( see the discussion in halpern et al . 1998 ) to conclude that either they are very rare or even do not exist . we checked the importance of high luminosity highly absorbed agn by fitting the xrb with a mixture of unabsorbed agn at all luminosities and low luminosity absorbed agn with an approach similar to that described by gilli et al . ( 2001 ) . here a sharp cut off in the luminosity function of obscured agn is introduced for luminosities greater than 10@xmath31 erg s@xmath6 . the shape of the absorption distribution is the same of the baseline model ; however , in order to reproduce the xrb spectral intensity , the number of sources in each absorption class has to be increased by 20% . the predicted 510 kev counts are reported in fig . [ sns_l44 ] and compared with the observational data and with the baseline model . it is clear that with such a model the hellas counts at relatively bright fluxes are severely underestimated since most of the xrb energy density is due to low luminosity agn emerging only at lower fluxes ( comastri 2000 ) . to evaluate the absorbing column density of the hellas sources from the x - ray count ratio , the redshift of the source should be known ( assuming that the absorber is at the same redshift of the source , see fiore et al . 1998 ) . to this purpose we plot ( s@xmath34h)/(s+h ) as a function of redshift ( figure [ hrtz ] ) for a subsample of 51 sources with optical spectroscopic identification ( la franca et al . the dotted lines represent the expectation of unabsorbed power laws with @xmath35 and 0.4 . the dashed lines represent the expectations of power law absorbed by columns of @xmath36 , @xmath37 and @xmath38 cm@xmath2 , respectively , _ in the source frame_. as expected , the softness ratio of constant column density models strongly increases with the redshift . many of the identified hellas sources have ( s h)/(s+h ) inconsistent with that expected from an unabsorbed power law model with @xmath35 . substantial absorbing column densities are implied . not surprisingly , almost all the sources in the nearby universe ( @xmath39 0.3 ) , which are likely to be obscured by column densities @xmath40 cm@xmath2 , are narrow line , type 1.8 - 2 agn ( fiore et al . 1999 , 2000 ; la franca et al . 2001 ) , while broad line agn are relatively unabsorbed in agreement with popular agn unification schemes . the situation is different at high redshift where several broad line agn appear to have strongly absorbed x ray spectra . the statistics in the present observations are not good enough to definitely assess this point . xmm_newton _ observations may easily confirm or disprove a significant absorbing column in these sources . the presence of highly x ray obscured quasars with broad optical lines implies a dust to gas ratio or a dust composition strongly different from the galactic one ( maiolino et al . alternatively , the x ray absorber could be much closer to the central source than the broad line region within the dust sublimation radius . this radius depends on the central source luminosity and thus if the x ray absorbing gas lies at the same distance from the ionizing source , the higher the x ray luminosity the lower the dust extinction is . although the nature of x ray absorption in broad lines blue continuum quasars is not well understood , it is interesting to note that large column of cold gas have been detected in broad absorption line quasars ( gallagher et al . 1999 ) , bright pg quasars ( gallagher et al . 2000 ) and high redshift quasars ( elvis et al . 1994 ; cappi et al . 1997 ; fiore et al . 1998 ; yuan et al . 2000 ; fabian et al . 2000 ) . the column density distribution inferred from fig . [ hrtz ] is compared with the baseline model predictions in fig [ abs_pred ] . given that the 510 kev band is not sensitive to column densities below about @xmath36 cm@xmath2 , sources with lower column densities are grouped in a single bin . the two bl lac objects have been neglected in the calculation as this class of objects is not included in the synthesis model . the two boxes correspond to the observed fraction ( @xmath11 @xmath41 ) of hellas sources for each absorption class and cover the flux decade @xmath0@xmath42 corresponding to the fluxes of the large majority of the sources in fig . [ hrtz ] . in order to take into account the relatively large errors in the softness ratio values a source is included in the corresponding @xmath3 class only if its softness ratio value plus one sigma error is below the @xmath3 value indicated by the dashed lines in fig [ hrtz ] . according to this prescription there are no sources with column densities greater than @xmath38 cm@xmath2 , the corresponding upper limit was obtained assuming that the two objects with a `` best fit '' column density @xmath43 cm@xmath2 are indeed compton thick . it is important to note that the relatively good agreement between model predictions and observed @xmath3 distribution is obtained without considering the optical classification . the hellas survey described in the companion paper by fiore et al . ( paper ii ) provided a statistically well defined and flux limited sample of 147 hard x ray selected sources used to estimate the 510 kev logn logs and the average x ray spectral properties of the objects responsible for a significant fraction of the 510 kev xrb ( from 20 to 30% depending from its normalization ; vecchi et al . 1999 , comastri 2000 ) . the analysis of x ray colors indicates that hellas sources have rather hard spectra , harder than the average spectra of sources in the 0.710 kev asca surveys ( ueda et al . 1999 , della ceca et al . this hardness may be due to substantial absorbing columns . in fact , a large fraction of identified type 1.8 - 2 agn and also a few broad line seyfert 1 galaxies and quasars show softness ratios similar to those expected from power law models reduced at low energy by column densities of log@xmath3=2224 , at the source redshift . the relatively high number of hard sources discovered by bepposax in the hardest band accessible with imaging instruments makes the hellas survey extremely well suited to test agn synthesis models predictions . the baseline model described in detail in previous sections is able to reproduce the 510 kev counts as observed by bepposax and xmm_newton _ and is also consistent with the 210 kev logn logs as measured by several instruments . the bright tail of the 510 kev logn logs as measured by bepposax is best fitted by a model with a significant fraction of highly obscured , high luminosity agn in good agreement with the findings of gilli et al . ( 2001 ) based on the 210 kev counts . a large fraction of compton thick sources , as envisaged in the model by wilman et al . ( 2000 ) and fabian ( 1999 ) , does not adequately reproduce the hellas counts , however the presence of a sizeable number of sources with @xmath44 cm@xmath2 can not be strongly ruled out based on the 510 kev counts . imaging observations at energies greater than about 20 kev , such as those planned with the energetic x ray imaging survey telescope ( exist , grindlay 2000 ) , are required to test such possibility . the baseline model can be considered as the simplest version of agn synthesis model . in fact the absorption distribution adopted to fit the hard xrb spectrum and the source counts in different energy ranges are independent from source redshift and luminosity . moreover , such a distribution is also in good agreement with that derived from observations of nearby agn ( risaliti et al . 1999 ) . the optical identification of a sizeable number of hellas sources allowed to further constrain the absorption distribution , for column densities lower than @xmath45 10@xmath46 cm@xmath2 , over a large range of redshifts and luminosities . the most important result concerns the optical appearence of x ray obscured agn as a function of redshift . in the local universe absorbed objects are almost always associated with narrow line optical spectra while at high redshifts ( @xmath47 0.3 ) the presence of x ray obscured sources with broad optical lines strongly suggest a decoupling between the x ray and optical classification . we note that such a result does not affect the agn synthesis model which is entirely based on the x ray properties . it is concluded that , as far as the present observational constraints are concerned , there is no need for a significant revision of the baseline model assumptions which turn out to adequately reproduce both the xrb spectrum and the source counts . the optical identification of a sizeable sample of hard x ray selected sources from _ chandra _ and xmm_newton _ surveys coupled with high quality x ray spectroscopy , especially for high redshift quasars , will provide new insights on the nature and the physics of the sources of the xrb . we thank the bepposax sdc , soc and occ teams for the successful operation of the satellite and preliminary data reduction and screaning . we also thank r. maiolino , s. molendi , f. pompilio , m. perri , m. salvati and g. zamorani for useful discussions and g. hasinger for providing the xmm_newton _ counts in the 510 kev band in a computer readable format . this research has been partially supported by asi contract ars9975 and murst grants cofin98032 and cofin000236 . | the bepposax high energy large area survey ( hellas ) has surveyed several tens of square degrees of the sky in the 510 kev band down to a flux of about @xmath0 . the source surface density of [email protected] deg@xmath2 at the survey limit corresponds to a resolved fraction of the 510 kev x ray background ( xrb ) of the order of 2030 % . the extrapolation of the hellas logn logs towards fainter fluxes with an euclidean slope is consistent with the first xmm_newton _ measurements , in the same energy band , which are a factor 20 more sensitive . the source counts in the hardest band so far surveyed by x ray satellites are used to constrain xrb models . it is shown that in order to reproduce the 510 kev counts over the range of fluxes covered by bepposax and xmm_newton _ a large fraction of highly absorbed ( log@xmath3 = 2324 cm@xmath2 ) , luminous ( @xmath5 erg s@xmath6 ) agn is needed . a sizeable number of more heavily obscured , compton thick , objects can not be ruled out but it is not required by the present data . the model predicts an absorption distribution consistent with that found from the hardness ratios analysis of the so far identified hellas sources . interestingly enough , there is evidence of a decoupling between x ray absorption and optical reddening indicators especially at high redshifts / luminosities where several broad line quasars show hardness ratios typical of absorbed power law models with log@xmath3=2224 cm@xmath2 . = -0.5 in x ray : background galaxies agn |
1610.00371 | stars born with initial masses up to 8.510.6 m@xmath8 @xcite , corresponding to at least 95% of all stars , become white dwarfs when they can not fuse nuclear elements in the core anymore . for single star evolution , the minimum mass of the white dwarf is around 0.30@xmath9 ( e.g. * ? ? ? considering the mass - radius relation of white dwarfs , this corresponds to a @xmath10 . progenitors that would become lower mass white dwarfs live on the main sequence longer than the age of the universe . we therefore determine our mass distribution only for white dwarfs with @xmath11 . we estimated the masses of all da white dwarfs found by @xcite , @xcite and @xcite among the 4.5 million spectra acquired by the sloan digital sky survey data release 12 . for the mass distribution we only consider spectra with s / n@xmath12 to have reliable mass determinations . the spectra were fitted with synthetic spectra from model atmospheres of @xcite , using ml2/@xmath1 for das , and ml2/@xmath3 , for dbs . we use the mass radius relations of @xcite , @xcite and @xcite , to calculate the mass of our stars from the @xmath13 and @xmath14 values obtained from our fits , after correcting to 3d convection following @xcite . figure [ dadb ] shows the mass distribution by number for das with @xmath15 k , where convection is unimportant , and for dbs with @xmath16 k reported by @xcite . because our surface gravities show an unexplained decrease below @xmath17 k , figure [ histv10 m ] shows the mass distribution for different cutoff temperatures . considering white dwarfs with larger mass have smaller radius , and therefore can only be seen to smaller distances in a magnitude limited survey as sdss , we calculated the density by correcting the visible volume with the @xmath6 method of @xcite , up to a maximum g=19 magnitude , shown in figure [ histv10 m ] . the distribution shows that the da and db distributions have very different shapes . the da s has a tail to larger masses , while the db s is extended to lower masses . this is probably reflecting some limitation in the progenitors that can undergo very - late thermal pulses and become dbs . with our population synthesis analysis , we computed a theoretical mass distribution through a monte carlo simulation fitting single star initial mass functions , initial - to - final mass relations for masses @xmath18 , to obtain a history of star formation for the das with @xmath19 k. figure [ histv13ps ] shows the mean mass around 0.64 @xmath20 requires a burst of star formation in the last 2 gyr , as a white dwarf with such mass has a short lived progenitor mass with a mass around @xmath21 . this is in contrast with the uniform star formation estimated by @xcite from the ml2/@xmath22 mass distribution of @xcite . convolving the intensities from the theoretical models with filter transmission curves , and appropriate zero - points , we estimated the corresponding absolute magnitudes . comparing with the observed g - filter photometry we estimated the distance modulus , obtaining the distances . from distances and the galactic latitude , we estimated the distance of each star from the galactic plane z. figure [ z ] shows the distance above the galactic plane for each star studied , showing the disc scale height is around 300 pc for das and a few parsecs larger for dbs . finally , using the distances , our measured radial velocities and the proper motions obtained from apop @xcite only for those stars which has a measured proper motion larger than three times its uncertainty , we estimated the galactic velocities u , v , and w for each star ( e.g * ? ? ? we compared the proper motions from apop @xcite with those of @xcite and they are very similar . in figure [ uvws ] , we show the galactic velocities we infer for each star . as expected , most white dwarfs observed by sdss belong to the thin and thick disk . because of the saturation limit around @xmath23 , nearby white dwarfs only if very cool are included . the sdss observations are also preferentially for directions across the galactic disk . lccccrccrr sdss j & s / n & g & @xmath24&@xmath13&@xmath25&@xmath14&@xmath26&dist&z & & ( mag ) & ( mag ) & ( k ) & ( k ) & ( cgs ) & ( cgs ) & ( pc)&(pc ) 081514.42 + 511311.39 & 33 & 17.647 & 0.014 & 74528 & 644 & 7.354 & 0.027 & 1142 & 634091734.49 + 020924.37 & 15 & 18.882 & 0.015 & 16261 & 268 & 7.660 & 0.053 & 448 & 24113219.73 - 075441.94 & 22 & 19.068 & 0.033 & 33820 & 256 & 7.240 & 0.057 & 1431 & 109115045.04 + 191854.61 & 15 & 19.112 & 0.026 & 19135 & 247 & 8.122 & 0.040 & 407 & 39121731.31 + 610520.36 & 31 & 18.075 & 0.017 & 41495 & 443 & 7.895 & 0.038 & 655 & 54123827.80 + 312138.30 & 26 & 17.743 & 0.022 & 60285 & 1551 & 7.730 & 0.080 & 802 & 79125816.99 + 000710.24 & 20 & 18.135 & 0.015 & 14910 & 159 & 7.870 & 0.035 & 256 & 22152658.83 + 021510.19 & 17 & 18.871 & 0.016 & 48853 & 1297 & 7.200 & 0.098 & 1739 & 123225513.66 + 230944.14 & 36 & 17.771 & 0.024 & 30007 & 118 & 7.522 & 0.020 & 529 & 28230228.08 + 231747.90 & 21 & 19.441 & 0.010 & 40716 & 720 & 7.740 & 0.064 & 1054 & 57 sok , adr , go and ip are supported by cnpq - brazil . dk received support from program science without borders , mcit / mec - brazil . this research has made use of nasa s astrophysics data system and of the cross - match service provided by cds , strasbourg . funding for the sloan digital sky survey has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the u.s . department of energy office of science , and the participating institutions . the sdss web site is www.sdss.org . althaus , l. g. , garca - berro , e. , isern , j. , & crsico , a. h. 2005 , , 441 , 689 cataln , s. , isern , j. , garca - berro , e. , & ribas , i. 2008 , , 387 , 1693 johnson , d. r. h. , & soderblom , d. r. 1987 , , 93 , 864 kepler , s. o. , kleinman , s. j. , nitta , a. , et al . 2007 , , 375 , 1315 kepler , s. o. , pelisoli , i. , koester , d. , et al . 2015 , , 446 , 4078 kepler , s. o. , pelisoli , i. , koester , d. , et al . 2016 , , 455 , 3413 kepler , s. o. , koester , d. , & ourique , g. 2016 , science , 352 , 67 kilic , m. , stanek , k. z. , & pinsonneault , m. h. 2007 , , 671 , 761 kleinman , s. j. , kepler , s. o. , koester , d. , et al . 2013 , , 204 , 5 koester , d. 2010 , memsai , 81 , 921 koester , d. , & kepler , s. o. 2015 , , 583 , a86 kordopatis , g. , recio - blanco , a. , de laverny , p. , et al . 2011 , , 535 , a107 munn , j. a. , harris , h. c. , von hippel , t. , et al . 2014 , , 148 , 132 qi , z. , yu , y. , bucciarelli , b. , et al . 2015 , , 150 , 137 renedo , i. , althaus , l. g. , miller bertolami , m. m. , et al . 2010 , , 717 , 183 romero , a. d. , campos , f. , & kepler , s. o. 2015 , , 450 , 3708 schmidt , m. 1968 , , 151 , 393 tremblay , p .- e . , ludwig , h .- , steffen , m. , & freytag , b. 2013 , , 552 , a13 woosley , s. e. , & heger , a. 2015 , , 810 , 34 | we present the mass distribution for all s / n@xmath015 pure da white dwarfs detected in the sloan digital sky survey up to data release 12 , fitted with koester models for ml2/@xmath1 , and with @xmath2 k , and for dbs with s / n@xmath010 , fitted with ml2/@xmath3 , for @xmath4 k. these mass distributions are for @xmath5 stars , i.e. , excluding the extremely low mass white dwarfs . we also present the mass distributions corrected by volume with the @xmath6 approach , for stars brighter than g=19 . both distributions have a maximum at @xmath7 but very distinct shapes . from the estimated z - distances , we deduce a disk scale height of 300 pc . we also present 10 probable halo white dwarfs , from their galactic u , v , w velocities . |
1401.5487 | variable c in m33 , one of the original hubble - sandage variables is a known s doradus variable / classical luminous blue variable ( lbv ) in m33 @xcite . a classical lbv in quiescence ( minimum visual light ) resembles a moderately evolved hot star with the spectrum of an early b - type supergiant or of / late wn star @xcite . during an lbv eruption , the mass loss rate increases , the wind becomes opaque and cool , and its spectrum resembles an a f - type supergiant . since this is a shift in the bolometric correction , the star brightens in the visual and appears to move to the right , to lower temperatures on the hr diagram . this is the lbv s optically thick wind stage or maximum visual light . var c s historic light curve is discussed by @xcite . it has shown two relatively long periods of maximum light ; from 1940 - 1953 @xcite and 1982 - 1993 @xcite with two shorter maxima in 1964 - 1970 @xcite and again beginning in 2001 and lasting until about 2005 based on the photometry and spectra reported by @xcite . var c entered another lbv eruption or maximum light phase apparently beginning close to 2011.0 when it brightened about two magnitudes in the visual reaching v @xmath0 15.6 mag @xcite . in this _ we describe its spectrum obtained just before the onset of its current brightening and recent spectra from its present maximum . interestingly , we find that its outflow or wind speed shows little change between these two states and is slow even during quiescence ; much slower than the winds of comparable b - type supergiants . this observation may be a significant clue to the lbv instability in general . variable c was observed on 03 october 2010 and on 07 october 2013 with the hectospec multi - object spectrograph ( mos ) @xcite on the 6.5-m mmt on mt . hopkins as part of a larger program on luminous stars in m31 and m33 @xcite . the hectospec has a 1@xmath1 fov and uses 300 fibers each with a core diameter of 250@xmath2 m subtending 1@xmath35 on the sky . we used the 600 l / mm grating with the 4800 tilt yielding @xmath4 2500 coverage with 0.54 / pixel resolution and r of @xmath5 2000 . the same grating with a tilt of 6800 was used for the red spectra with @xmath4 2500 coverage , 0.54 / pixel resolution and r of @xmath5 3600 . the spectra were reduced using an exportable version of the cfa / sao specroad package for hectospec data . the spectra were all bias subtracted , flatfielded and wavelength calibrated . because of crowding , the sky subtraction was done using fibers assigned outside the field of the galaxy . blue and red spectra were also observed on 06 january 2014 with the mods1 spectrograph on the large binocular telescope ( lbt ) . mods1 uses a dichroic to obtain blue and red spectra simultaneously with the g400l and g750l gratings for the blue and red channels , respectively , yielding wavelength coverage from 3200 in the blue to more than 1@xmath2 m in the red . the spectra were reduced using a pipleine provided by r. w. pogge for mods spectra and standard routines in iraf . figure 1 shows the recent light curve based on photometry from @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and from martin s ccd observations with the 20-inch telescope at the barber observatory . although there are gaps in the present photometry , we suspect that the current eruption began approximately 2011.0 rather than in mid-2010 . this is on based var c s spectrum in oct 2010 when it was still in its hot or quiescent state , and because at the beginning of the 1982 1993 eruption it showed a rapid rise to maximum in only a few weeks @xcite . soon after the announcement that var c had brightened , several groups obtained low resolution spectra of variable c. all of the known spectroscopic observations beginning with the 2010 spectra are listed in table 1 . both sets of our blue and red spectra from the mmt / hectospec are shown in figure 2 . var c s spectrum in october 2010 shows the absorption line spectrum of an early b - type supergiant plus emission lines of hydrogen with p cygni profiles , and he i , fe ii and [ fe ii ] . the multiplet 42 fe ii lines also have prominent p cygni absorption profiles . the presence of absorption lines of n ii 3995 , several he i absorption lines and s iv 4089 in the blue suggest a corresponding b1 - b2 spectral type . the n ii lines 4600 4640 and 5666 5710 and s iii 4553 4575 are also present in absorption . the relative strengths of the nebular [ n ii ] emission lines indicate that var c has a circumstellar nebula @xcite . its spectrum three years later , after the rise to maximum light , shows the transition in apparent spectral type that characterizes the classical lbv or s doradus variability ( figure 2 ) . its absorption line spectrum now resembles a late a - type supergiant with prominent ca ii h and k absorption lines , strong mg ii @xmath64481 , and numerous absorption lines of fe ii . the luminosity sensitive o i triplet at @xmath67774 is quite strong . the si ii doublet at 6347 and 6371 and the three n i lines from 7423 7468 are present in absorption in its red spectrum . the he i emission and absorption lines are gone . the balmer emission line strengths have decreased , by a factor of two in equivalent width for h@xmath7 . the hydrogen lines have developed broad wings extending to @xmath4 800 km s@xmath8 , most likely due to thomson scattering in the dense wind , and the p cygni absorption is now much stronger indicating that the mass loss rate has increased . the wings contain roughly 20% of the h@xmath7 and h@xmath9 emission ( figure 3 ) . likewise the lines of fe ii multiplet 42 have prominent p cygni absorption features and asymmetric red wings , a characteristic of thomson scattering . a spectrum from january 2014 confirms the above description and also shows the ca ii triplet in emission in the far red ; two of the ca ii line have p cygni profiles . thomson - scattered line wings almost automatically appear when a hot star s mass outflow becomes opaque . in such a case the diffuse continuum photosphere roughly coincides with the thermalization depth , located where @xmath10 . with likely opacities , this occurs near scattering depth @xmath11 2 to 5 @xcite . naturally the strongest emission lines are formed in the region outside the diffuse photosphere , i.e. , with an average @xmath12 of the order of 1 or 2 ; and this is about the right depth to produce the observed line wings . @xcite have noted this generality for other types of objects . var c was observed during its previous extended maximum , 1982 1993 @xcite . comparison with spectra from that time shows that the current spectrum is somewhat warmer than the 1985 spectrum obtained when the star was about two years past the onset of the eruption . at that time , it had the spectral characteristics and absorption line strengths of an early f - type supergiant . instead the current spectrum is more like spectra from 1986 and 1987 when it resembled an a - type supergiant and had an apparent temperature of @xmath4 9000k . this is consistent with the light curve . like other well - observed lbvs in eruption , var c s apparent spectrum / temperature is correlated with the amplitude of its visual brightening @xcite . var c has not gotten as visually bright as it did in 1985 . as of this writing , its maximum visual magnitude is 15.6 compared to 15.2 mag in 1985 . its brightness and colors are essentally the same as the 1986/1987 photometry and the spectra are likewise very similar . thus the dense wind during this maximum may not get as cool , although of course that will depend on how the light curve develops in the future . lbv s are well known to have low wind or outflow velocities of 100 - 200 km s@xmath8 in their cool , dense winds during their eruptions or maximum light phase . to examine var c s wind , we measured the velocity at the blue - edge of the p cygni absorption profiles in the balmer and fe ii emission lines . this velocity is usually referred to as the terminal velocity ( @xmath13 ) , but since we are not using a stellar wind model to fit the profiles , here we call it the blue - edge velocity . we also measured the velocity at the absorption minimum in the p cygni profiles . this second method is less subjective than the blue - edge and permits a well - controlled differential measurement . the velocity of the absorption minimum is of course smaller , but when comparing the velocities from different times , the results are consistent with the behavior of the terminal or blue - edge velocity . the average velocities with their standard deviations are summarized in table 2 for the quiescent and maximum light spectra . the h@xmath7 and h@xmath9 line profiles at the two epochs are shown in figure 3 . for comparison , we also include the wind speeds from the p cygni profiles in the balmer lines in the spectra of normal early b - type and late a - type supergiants in m31 and m33 observed with the hectospec at the same time as var c in 2010 ( 1 and paper i ) . the line profiles were measured the same way as for var c. wind speeds are expected to have some dependence on metallicity . although we do not have a measured metallicity for var c , we expect it to be similar to the other supergiants in m33 which has a metallicity like the lmc while m31 stars have galactic abundances . furthermore we do not find a significant difference in the wind velocities for the m31 and m33 stars in this small sample . var c s outflow velocities are significantly less , by at least 70 km s@xmath8 or about 30% than for the normal b - type supergiants in m31 and m33 even in quiescence when the lbv s apparent spectral type and spectroscopic temperature are like that of the hot supergiants @xcite ] . during the dense wind or maximum light phase the outflow velocities are similar to those of the a - type supergiants , which var c resembles spectroscopically , although still somewhat lower . _ var c thus has a slow wind even during the quiescent stage in comparison with the normal hot supergiants with similar temperatures . there is also only a small decrease in the wind speeds between these two states . _ we also find a relatively low wind velocity in the other lbvs in m31 and m33 in their hot or quiescent state , discussed in paper ii in our series on the luminous stars in these galaxies @xcite . thus a slower and presumably denser wind , even in quiescence or minimum light , may be another distinguishing characteristic of the classical lbvs / s doradus variables . a hot star should have a wind speed related to the escape velocity . lbvs are presumably close to the eddington limit @xcite having already shed much of their mass in previous s dor - type maxima or possibly in enhanced mass loss during a previous giant eruption . their effective gravities and therefore their escape velocities are now much lower . the var c observations support this concept , i.e. that it is fairly close to the eddington limit . we thank u. munari and r. mark wagner for communicating the results of their early spectra with us . research by r. humphreys and k. davidson on massive stars is supported by the national science foundation ast-1019394 . martin s collaborative work on luminous variables is supported by the national science foundation grant ast-1108890 . burggraf , b. et al . 2014 , , to be submitted clark , et al . 2012 , , 541 , 146 crowther , p. , lennon , d. j. & walborn , n. r. 2006 , , 446 , 279 davidson , k. 1987 , 317 , 760 fabricant , d. g. , hertz , e. n. , szentgyorgyi , a. h. , et al . 1998 , proc . spie , 3355 , 285 hubble , e. & sandage , a. 1953 , , 118 , 353 humphreys , r. m. , leitherer , c. , stahl , o. , wolf , b. , & zickgraf , f - j 1988 , , 203 , 306 humphreys . r. m. & davidson , k. 1994 , , 106 , 1025 humphreys , r.m . , davidson , k. , jones , t.j . , et al . 2012 , 760 , 93 humphreys . r. m. , davidson , k , grammer , s. , kneeland , n. , martin , j. c. , weis , k. & burggraf , b. 2013 , , 773 , 46 ( paper i ) humphreys , r. m. , weis , k. , burggraf , b. , bomans , d. , martin , j. c. , & muesinger , h. 2013 , astronomer s telegram , 5362 humphreys . r. m. , weis , k. , davidson , k. & bomans , d. 2014 , to be submitted to , ( paper ii ) mokiem , m.r . , et al . 2007 , , 465 , 1003 munari , u. & ochner , p. 2013 , private communication rosino , l. & bianchini , a. 1973 , , 22 , 453 stahl , o. 1997 in luminous blue variables : massive stars in transition . asp conference series ; vol . 120 , eds . a. nota & h. lamers , pg 100 szeifert , t. , humphreys , r. m. , davidson , k. , et al . 1995 , , 314 , 131 valeev , a. f. , fabrika , o. & sholukhova , o. n. 2013 , astronomer s telegram , 5538 viotti , r. f. , rossi , c. , polcaro , v. f. et al . 2006 , , 458 , 225 viotti , r. f. , rossi , c. , montagni , f. , & gualandi , r. 2013 , astronomer s telegram , 5403 wagner , r. m. & woodward c. e. 2013 , private communication weis , k. , bomans , d. j. & humphreys , r. m. 2014 , in preparation lllll 29 sep 02 oct , 2010 & wht / wyffos & 9h , 6.5h & 40005000 , h@xmath7 & @xcite + 03 oct . 2010 & mmt / hectospec & 120 m & 600l , 4800 & this paper + 03 oct . 2010 & mmt / hectospec & 90 m & 600l , 6800 & this paper + 05 sept . 2013 & mdm / ccd & 30 m & 3650 7250 & @xcite + 06 sept . 2013 & asiago 1.2 m /b&c & 30 m & 300l , 34007980 & @xcite + 05 oct . 2013 & bta / scorpio & & 3800 7200 & @xcite + 07 oct . 2013 & mmt / hectospec & 120 m & 600l , 4800 & this paper + 07 oct . 2013 & mmt / hectospec & 90 m & 600l , 6800 & this paper + 01 - 02 nov . 2013 & bta / scorpio & & 4100 5800 , 5800 7400 & @xcite + 07 nov . 2013 & asiago 1.2 m /b&c & 30 m & 300l , 34007980 & @xcite + 06 jan . 2014 & lbt / mods1 & 6 m & 3200 1@xmath2 m & this paper + lcccc var c oct . 2010 & @xmath14238(4)@xmath15 10 & @xmath14249(3)@xmath15 15 & @xmath14157(4)@xmath15 8 & @xmath14158(3)@xmath15 3 + b - type supergiants(b0-b3 ) & @xmath14351(7)@xmath15 9 & & @xmath14227(7)@xmath15 9 & + var c oct . 2013 & @xmath14233(4)@xmath15 10 & @xmath14234(8)@xmath15 8 & @xmath14141(4)@xmath15 3 & @xmath14136(8)@xmath15 3 + a - type supergiants(a5-a8 ) & @xmath14266(6)@xmath15 20 & & @xmath14162(7)@xmath15 14 & + | we discuss the spectrum of var c in m33 obtained just before the onset of its current brightening and recent spectra during its present `` eruption '' or optically thick wind stage . these spectra illustrate the typical lbv transition in apparent spectral type or temperature that characterizes the classical lbv or s dor - type variability . lbvs are known to have slow , dense winds during their maximum phase . interestingly , _ var c had a slow wind even during its hot , quiescent stage in comparison with the normal hot supergiants with similar temperatures . its outflow or wind speeds also show very little change between these two states . _ |
0906.4075 | positron emission tomography ( pet ) is a functional imaging technique of growing importance in medical diagnostics . its powers lie in the ability to reveal biologically significant processes that can be used , for example , in cancer screening and in studying neurodegenerative diseases . conventional pet detectors employ scintillating inorganic crystals @xcite as the gamma ray detection media . while crystal - based pet systems perform adequately for many applications there is motivation for seeking improvements of resolutions in energy , position , and time response to improve image quality and increasing overall sensitivity . liquid xenon ( lxe ) is another gamma ray detector technology @xcite applicable to high resolution pet which may result in improved performance and reduced noise in images due to superior energy resolution , true 3-dimensional position reconstruction , and the capability for determining the compton scattering sequence @xcite . energy resolution of 7% ( fwhm ) has been reported in small lxe detector tests by combining scintillation light and ionization charge measurements @xcite . measuring charge in a drift chamber has been shown to provide 3-d sub - millimeter spatial resolution @xcite because electron diffusion is very small @xcite . in addition , sub - ns timing resolution has been achieved by measuring the scintillation light @xcite . liquid xenon is also inexpensive compared to crystal detectors commonly used for pet . liquid xenon pet systems have the potential to reduce detector contributions to pet to the level of intrinsic limitations due to positron range and non - colinearity of the emitted photons . this paper deals with the energy resolution obtained from light and charge signals observed in a small lxe prototype detector as well as an investigation of the components influencing it and the sources of uncertainty which may inform the design of future detectors for pet . we have developed a concept for a micro - pet detector shown in fig . [ fig_pet ] that takes advantage of all the high resolution capabilities of lxe gamma ray detectors . scintillation light is measured by arrays of large area avalanche photodiodes ( laapd ) , which have been found to work well in lxe @xcite . charge measurement is achieved by using a time projection chamber ( tpc ) , an approach successfully demonstrated in @xcite . photons entering the lxe produce prompt scintillation light and ionization which drifts under an electric field applied between the cathode and the anode of the tpc . the anode module ( not shown in fig . [ fig_pet ] ) consists of a shielding grid followed by an array of wires preceding the anode which is segmented into strips perpendicular to the wires . the electron signal induced on the wires and collected by the strips provides a two dimensional ( x - y ) position measurement of the charge . the third coordinate ( z ) is obtained by measuring the electron drift time i.e. the difference between the time of the light flash and the electron arrival time on the anode . since every interaction is precisely recorded , compton scattering can be reconstructed giving information on the direction of each incoming photon providing the possibility to suppress accidental coincidences and scattering prior to reaching the detector . the expectations for performance under operating conditions for pet include sub - millimeter 3-d position resolution from charge , timing resolution of @xmath1 ns from scintillation light , energy resolution @xmath0% ( fwhm ) combining light and charge signals , and the ability to reconstruct compton scattering . spatial location of events obtained from the prompt distributed light signals will be used to reduce the ambiguities of associating the scintillation light and charge at high levels of activity . a simulation of the imaging performance of this system will be presented in a future publication @xcite . as an initial step in studying lxe detectors for pet , we constructed a small test chamber ( 27 @xmath2 ) for simultaneous measurements of light and charge . the test chamber is shown schematically in fig . [ fig_chamber ] . scintillation light was detected by two 1.6 cm diameter windowless laapds ( advanced photonics inc . the laapds were located at the center of the drift region as shown in fig . [ fig_chamber ] , 1.5 cm above the grid wires and 1.5 cm below the cathode . charge was collected on a central 1 cm diameter electrode ( a1 ) or on an outer electrode ( a2 ) . an electric drift field was applied between the cathode and a shielding grid separated by 3 cm . the electric field was formed by a field cage consisting of 9 wires with a spacing of 3 mm strung along the four walls of the chamber . the voltage was distibuted by 100m@xmath3 resistors . the apds were outside the field cage and the distance between the field cage wires and the apds was 2 mm . the shielding grid consisted of 0.1 mm dia . wires spaced by 3 mm located 3 mm from the anode charge collection plane . the electric field between the grid wires and the anode was set higher than the drift field ensuring that all the electrons pass through the grid @xcite . in order to study the influence of the drift field on quantities like charge and light production and the energy resolution several settings were used . with the grid at ground potential measurements were made with the negative cathode voltage set to 1 , 3 , 6 , and 8 kv , with the respective anode voltages set to 300 , 600 , 1200 and 1200 v. photons of 511 kev emitted after annihilation of positrons from a @xmath4na source with an activity of @xmath5 bq and situated in a collimator with an opening angle of 2@xmath6 positioned 30 cm away from the cathode entered the test chamber ( along the z axis ) through the cathode plane . the trigger was generated by selecting signals in coincidence of both apds and an external nai detector placed at a distance of 50 cm from the source observing the full energy of the other 511 kev photon from the positron annihilation . the probability to detect more than one event in the chamber at the same time was less than 3% . the detector was operated at 15 psia and at temperatures between 168 and 169 k. before inserting the liquid in the vessel holding the detector a bake - out in vaccuum at 7.6@xmath7 t was performed for 6 days at 60@xmath6c to clean the components . the purification of the xenon was done in the gas phase using two stages both with equipment from from nupure corporation @xcite : first , the heated getter ( nupure omni 600 ) was used to remove h@xmath80 , o@xmath8 , co , h@xmath8 , and n@xmath8 to sub - ppb levels followed by a room temperature getter ( eliminator 600 cg ) to remove h@xmath80 , o@xmath8 , co , h@xmath8 , and hydrocarbons to @xmath9 0.5 ppb . the lifetime of drifting ionization electrons was used to indicate successful operation of the purification as discussed below . the two anodes segments and the grid wires ( ganged together ) were connected to charge - sensitive amplifiers followed by a 1 s time constant rc - cr shaper . the amplifier was calibrated using a narrow pulse input charge with a precision of 5% . the amplifier outputs were fanned out into three branches : 1 . a constant fraction discriminator followed by a time - to - digital converter ( tdc ) caen model v1190b ; 2 . a charge sensitive analog - to - digital converter : 12 bit qdc caen model v792 with gate adjusted to the drift time and pulse shape ; and 3 . a 20 mhz sampling waveform digitizer vf48 @xcite . to get absolute charge values , the digitized waveform measured with the vf48 was used for the analysis presented in sections [ sec_q ] and [ sec_l ] . because the qdc had a better signal to noise ratio it was used to determine the energy resolution in section [ sec_e ] which did not require absolute charge calibration . the other reason the qdc was not used for absolute values was due to the very short pulse used for calibration . the longer chamber signal would not have been fully integrated within the window set . the observed range of noise of the amplifier was 700 - 1100 electrons due to varying external sources of induced noise . to reach the optimal position resolution , a signal to noise ratio larger than 5 was desirable requiring the electronics noise to be kept below 1000 electrons equivalent noise charge ( enc ) . a typical signal was expected to be at least 10 000 e- , as long as the electron attachment during the drift was small . the laapd voltages were set so that their gains were 500 and each was connected to a current - sensitive preamplifier with a pulse width of 50 ns and @xmath10 electrons enc . the amplifier signal was split into 3 branches : 1 . discriminator and tdc ; 2 . qdc caen model v792 with a gate of 100 ns ; and 3 . 1 ghz waveform digitizer caen model v1729 . solid angle calculations showed that 12% of the scintillation photons reached the laapds when the gamma interaction took place in the center of the chamber . the grid wires shielded the anodes from the current induced by the drifting electrons . once the ionization electrons passed the grid wires the signal on the anode started to build up with a pulse shape that was largely independent of the z position of the primary interaction although electrostatic calculations showed that the current pulse shape depended on the x - y distance of the electron cloud from the individual grid wires . furthermore , depending on the drift velocity ( typically 0.15 to 0.21 cm / s ) , the current induced on the anodes lasted 1.5 to 2 s. the waveforms measured on the grid and on the two anodes provided information about the location of charge creation and compton scattering if multiple charge pulses were observed . the time of charge arrival relative to the light signal gave information about the position along the drift direction of the electrons . figure [ fig_wave ] shows examples of four charge waveform events recorded by the 20 mhz waveform digitizers chosen to illustrate several types of events . in the upper two plots the charge was created roughly at the same z position ; in the left plot the signal of the central anode ( a1 ) integrated to zero and the anode a2 collected the charge , whereas in the right hand plot the interaction deposited the full charge on the central anode a1 . the lower left panel shows an event originating close to the cathode plane , resulting in a measured drift time of 15 s. the charge was collected by the central anode . the bipolar shape of the grid signal is clearly visible . the waveform measured on the grid depends on the z position of the interaction and is also influenced by electrons collected by the grid . the lower right panel shows two photon interactions , presumably one compton scattering and one photo - electric interaction . one interaction took place above a1 and one above a2 . the interactions were also separated in the drift direction so that a two peak structure is visible in the grid waveform . simulations of the setup showed that only a small fraction ( less than 5% ) of events fully contained on a1 have mutliple hits that can be detected . the total charge for these events however is not significantly different from the events with just one interaction . for this analysis we did not treat them separately since we were primarily interested in the total charge deposited on the anode . better separation of multiple photon interactions on an event by event basis will be possible with finer segmentation of the readout electrodes and shorter shaping time . the purity of the lxe has an impact on charge collection . in the current setup we achieved an electron lifetime of 200 s using purification in the gas phase with heated getters . we estimated that the level of purity obtained would result in a loss of 8% of the electrons due to attachment . for the analysis in this paper we selected events where no net charge was measured on a2 . by demanding the absence of charge on a2 the region of a1 in which events were accepted was smaller than its physical size since charge depositions close to the edge of a1 induced charge on a2 . the effective radius of the tube in which events were accepted was estimated to be 0.45 cm compared to the a1 radius of 0.5 cm . figure [ fig_charge ] shows the distribution of charge due to 511 kev photons incident on the chamber as measured on a1 as a function of the drift time for a 1 kv / cm drift field . the shape of the distribution is the same for all drift fields . the 511 kev band rises sharply in less than 1 s , and then falls slowly until the cutoff which corresponds to the edge of the chamber . the sharp rise corresponds to photons interacting between the grid and anode . in that case the electronics , which is not sensitive to the charge induced by the much slower drifting ions , measures only a fraction of the charge which is approximately proportional to the distance between the anode and the interaction point . when the interaction point is between the grid and the cathode , the measured charge should be independent of the interaction position . the decline of measured charge with increasing drift times is due to electron attachment by impurities in the lxe . compton scattering interactions are evident below the 511 kev band . they are due to photons entering the chamber with less than 511 kev because they have scattered in the passive detector material , mostly the 2 cm of lxe between the vessel wall and the cathode , and to photons escaping after a compton scattering interaction in the liquid . we performed a fit of the 511 kev band to extract the drift velocity @xmath11 , the total charge @xmath12 produced in the photon interaction and the attenuation length . the values obtained for these quantities are listed in table [ tab_qresults ] with their statistical uncertainties from the fits . the charge yield @xmath13 is also shown along with @xmath12 which is the measured charge corrected for attachment and electronics calibration and @xmath14 is the ratio of the energy deposited by the @xmath15-ray and the average energy to produce an electron ion pair : @xmath16 with @xmath17=15.6 ev @xcite . .drift velocity ( @xmath11),number of electrons ( @xmath12 ) , electron lifetime @xmath18 and charge yield observed for different electric fields ( @xmath19).[tab_qresults ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] measurements have been made of the response of a liquid xenon drift chamber to irradiation by 511 kev photons . using a model accounting for the sources of uncertainty in the energy resolution we also determined values for the intrinsic energy resolutions . figure [ fig_eres ] summarizes the results for charge , light and combined energy resolution as a function of the drift field . the main error contribution to the combined energy resolution , apart from the solid angle fluctuations which can be eliminated by utilizing the position measurement , originated from the apd gain fluctuation and the anode noise . both were about of 2.7% . figure [ fig_interes ] depicts the values for the intrinsic energy resolutions obtained by subtracting the detector contributions from the values in fig . [ fig_eres ] . the error bars given are statistical . based on these results , the combined energy resolution of @xmath93.5% ( or @xmath20 fwhm ) would be anticipated in a detector configuration suitable for applications to pet which would have comparable light collection efficiency to the prototype detector described above and @xmath91 mm spatial resolution . reducing the anode to grid spacing to 1 mm and the grid wire spacing to 1 mm will reduce the width of the pulses and minimize the dependence of the pulse shape on the location of the electron cloud . further improvements are foreseen in areas including purification and low noise electronics . we thank r. bula , m. constable , and c. lim for their technical contributions to this work and p. gumplinger for assistance with simulations . we also thank e. aprile and e. conti for providing information about their work . this work was supported in part by the canada foundation for innovation , the university of british columbia , and triumf which receives federal funding via a contribution agreement through the national research council of canada . | in order to assess the performance of liquid xenon detectors for use in positron emission tomography we studied the scintillation light and ionization charge produced by 511 kev photons in a small prototype detector . scintillation light was detected with large area avalanche photodiodes while ionization electrons were collected on an anode instrumented with low noise electronics after drifting up to 3 cm . operational conditions were studied as a function of the electric field . energy resolutions of @xmath0% ( fwhm ) were achieved by combining the scintillation light and ionization charge signals . the relationship between scintillation light and ionization signals was investigated . an analysis of the sources of fluctuations was performed in order to optimize future detector designs . liquid xenon , pet , medical imaging , tpc 29.40.gx , 87.57.-s , 87.57.uk |
astro-ph0008339 | weakly interacting massive particles ( wimps ) are leading candidates for the dominant form of matter in our galaxy . these hypothetical , relic particles from an early phase of the universe are predicted independently from cosmological considerations by supersymmetric particle physics theories as neutralinos - the lightest supersymmetric particles . direct wimp detection experiments exploit the elastic wimp scattering off nuclei in a terrestrial detector @xcite . however , detecting wimps is not a simple task . as their name suggests , their interaction with matter is very feeble ( @xmath0 ) and predicted rates in supersymmetric models range from 10 to 10@xmath1 events per kilogram of detector material and day @xcite . moreover , for wimp masses between a few gev and 1tev , the energy deposited by the recoil nucleus is less then 100kev . thus , in order to be able to detect a wimp , an experiment with a low energy threshold and an extremely low radioactive background is required . since the reward would be no less than discovering the dark matter in the universe , a huge effort is put into direct detection experiments . more than a dozen of experiments are running at present and even more are planned for the future ( for recent reviews see @xcite ) . the focus of this paper is to present first results of the heidelberg dark matter search ( hdms ) prototype @xcite , which took data over a period of about 15 months in the gran sasso underground laboratory ( lngs ) in italy . after a description of the experimental setup , its performance is discussed in some detail . the last 49 days of data taking are analyzed in terms of wimp - nucleon cross sections and a comparison to other running dark matter experiments is made . the status and the prospects of the full scale experiment are discussed and finally conclusions and an outlook are given . hdms operates two ionization hpge detectors in a unique configuration @xcite . a small , p - type ge crystal is surrounded by a well - type ge crystal , both being mounted into a common cryostat system ( see figure [ detindet ] for a schematic view ) . to shield leakage currents on the surfaces , a 1 mm thin insulator made from vespel is placed between them . two effects are expected to reduce the background of the inner , wimp target detector with respect to our best measurements of the heidelberg - moscow experiment @xcite . first , the anticoincidence between the two detectors acts as an effective suppression for multiple scattered photons , second , the detection crystal is surrounded by ge , which is one of the radio - purest known materials . from previous measurements we know that the main radioactive background of ge detectors comes from materials situated in the immediate vicinity of the crystals , i.e. from the copper parts of the cryostats @xcite . in order to house both ge crystals , a special design of the copper crystal holder system was required . the idea was to construct a pyramidal structure made of copper on top of the crystals , allowing to establish the two hv and two signal contacts , which are fixed by springs made from vespel ( see figure [ holder ] ) @xcite . in the prototype version three of the four contacts were unfortunately soldered by the manufacturer . the cryostat system was fabricated in heidelberg from low radioactivity , electropolished copper . the fets are placed 20 cm away from the crystals so that their effect on the background is minimized by a small solid angle and by 10 cm of copper shielding . for the prototype experiment both inner and outer detector are made of natural high - purity germanium . the data acquisition system of the hdms experiment allows data sampling either in a calibration mode ( filling a histogram in a memory module , fast data acquisition ) or in an event - by - event mode where in addition the pulse - shape of an individual event can be recorded . the energy outputs of the preamplifiers are divided and amplified with two different shaping time constants ( 3@xmath2s and 4@xmath2s ) and different gains at the spectroscopy amplifiers in order to record low energy ( from threshold to 400kev ) and high energy ( from 70kev to 8mev ) spectra . the spectra are measured with 13bit adcs , which also release the trigger for an event by a peak detect signal . further triggers are vetoed until the complete event information ( arrival time with an accuracy of 100 @xmath2s , energy and eventually the pulse shape ) has been recorded . the dead - time of 200 @xmath2s ( without pulse shape ) is negligible for a typical event rate of 1.4@xmath310@xmath4 hz in the outer detector . the anticoincidence between the two detectors is performed off - line . first tests of detector performance were done in the heidelberg low level laboratory using standard calibration sources like @xmath5ba , @xmath6co , @xmath7am and @xmath8eu-@xmath9th . the sensitivity of the detectors in their geometrical arrangement was tested by a scan measurement with a collimated @xmath5ba source . the achieved energy resolutions and thresholds are shown in table [ detindet - data ] along with other detector properties . the concentric configuration of the two ge - crystals gives rise to cross - talk events @xcite . using @xmath5ba and @xmath9th calibration sources , we recorded data in an event - by - event mode , to obtain two - dimensional scatter plots of deposited energies in each detector . these plots clearly visualize a linear correlation between energies in the inner and outer crystal , although in different strengths ( see figure [ cross ] ) . the linear correlation between the energy depositions in the two crystals is corrected off - line . if e@xmath10 and e@xmath11 are the true ionization energies deposited in the inner and outer detector and e@xmath12 , e@xmath13 the measured energies , then one can write : e_i = , e_o = , where k@xmath14 and k@xmath15 are the slopes of the correlation lines . the width of the correlation lines is determined by the energy resolution of the detectors . the slopes are determined to be : k_io = 0.00375 0.4310 ^ -4 + k_oi = 0.12850 0.2710 ^ -3 the error in the energy determination arising from the cross - talk correction is a function of the error of the measured energy deposition and of the magnitude as well as the error of the slopes of the correlation lines . it can be inferred directly by comparing the widths of energy peaks in the two detectors after the cross - talk correction ( for peaks with simultaneous energy deposition in the other detector , e.g. 511kev or the @xmath6co lines ) with the widths of the same peaks for energy depositions in a single detector only . while for the inner detector the effect is negligible ( note that k@xmath15 is much smaller than k@xmath14 ) , for the outer detector the energy resolution worsens by 0.3% to 0.4% at 1332kev . as we will see later , this has no influence on the anticoincidence spectrum between the two detectors . the cross - talk correction requires the stability of the slopes of the linear correlations . this stability has been monitored and confirmed . another possibility to remove the cross - talk would be to introduce an extra grounded shield between the detectors . we refrained from applying this hardware solution because of strongly reduced anti - compton capability and the additional contamination risk . the hdms prototype was installed at lngs in march 1998 and successfully took data over a period of about 15 month , until july 1999 @xcite . figure [ hdms - gs ] shows the detector in its open shield . the inner shield is made of 10 cm of electrolytic copper , the outer one of 20 cm of boliden lead , both lead and copper having been stored for several years below ground at gran sasso . the whole setup is enclosed in an air tight steel box and flushed with gaseous nitrogen in order to suppress environmental radon diffusion . finally a 15 cm thick borated polyethylene shield surrounds the steel box to minimize the influence of neutrons . the individual runs were about 0.9 d long . the experiment was stopped daily and parameters such as leakage currents of the detectors , nitrogen flow , overall trigger rate and count rate of the individual detectors were checked . energy calibrations were done weekly with standard @xmath5ba and @xmath8eu-@xmath9th sources , introduced through a teflon tube . the energy resolution of both detectors ( 1.2kev at 300kev inner detector and 3.2kev at 300kev outer detector ) were stable as a function of time . the zero energy resolutions , which are determined by extrapolating the full widths at half maximum ( fwhm ) to 0kev , are ( [email protected])kev and ( [email protected])kev for the inner and outer detector , respectively . another way to specify the zero energy resolution is given by the cross talk correction . the cross talk generates ` fake ' events beyond the energy thresholds of both detectors , which are then shifted to 0kev by the correction . this allows a direct measurement of the energy resolution at 0kev ( see fig . [ nullpkt ] ) and a cross check of the quality of the cross - talk correction at the same time . the values of 0.94kev and 3.34kev are fully consistent with the ones obtained by the fwhm - extrapolation . to determine the energy threshold , a reliable energy calibration at low energies is required . the lowest - energetic lines observed in the detectors in the calibration mode were the @xmath5ba line at 81kev in the inner detector and the 121.8kev line of @xmath8eu in the outer one ( all lower energetic lines are absorbed in the copper of the crystal holder system ) . however , intrinsic radioactivity of the crystals and/or of the surrounding copper such as the 10.37kev line of @xmath17ge and the 46.5kev line of @xmath18pb allowed to check the calibration down to low energies . the energy thresholds are 2.0kev and 7.5kev for the inner and outer detector , respectively . after correction for the cross talk and re - calibration to standard calibration values ( according to the weekly determined calibration parameters ) , the spectra of the daily runs were summed up . figures [ sum - outer ] and [ sum - inner ] show the sum spectra for the outer and inner detector , respectively . the most important identified lines are labeled . in the outer detector the lines of the cosmogenic isotopes @xmath17ge , @xmath19co , @xmath20co , @xmath21mn , @xmath6co , @xmath22zn , of the natural decay chains @xmath23u and @xmath24th , of the primordial @xmath25k , of the anthropogenic radionuclide @xmath26cs and the annihilation line at 511kev can be identified . the statistics in the inner detector is lower , however the following lines can be clearly seen : @xmath17ga k@xmath27 at 10.37kev , @xmath18pb at 46.5kev , external @xmath19co at 122.1kev and internal at 143.6kev ( + x - ray ) , 511kev annihilation , @xmath21mn at 834kev , @xmath6co at 1173kev and 1332kev and @xmath25k at 1460kev . the region below 10kev is dominated by the x - rays of @xmath28ti ( 5kev ) and @xmath29mn ( 6.5kev ) . in addition to the outer detector , a structure centered at 32kev with a fwhm of 2kev is identified . its origin is not yet fully understood , but could be a @xmath18pb contamination at the inner contact with incomplete charge collection . figure [ time - inner ] shows the energy depositions in the inner detector as a function of measuring time . no microphonic events ( bursts ) can be seen beyond 2.0kev . the decreasing activity of @xmath17ge is nicely visualized . after 363 days of pure measuring time the statistics in the inner detector was high enough in order to estimate the background reduction through the anticoincidence with the outer detector . in order to obtain true anticoincidence spectra , the energy thresholds for computing the anticoincidence must lie at least 3@xmath30 away from zero , where fwhm@xmath31=2.35@xmath30 is the zero energy resolution . table [ nullpkt_tab ] gives the energy thresholds and the zero energy resolutions for both detectors , after the cross talk correction . the energy thresholds lie in both cases about 5@xmath30 away from zero , so they count as cuts for computing the anticoincidence between the crystals . thus , the fact that the zero energy resolution of the outer detector is worsened by the cross - talk correction does not affect the anticoincidence spectra between the two detectors . figure [ low - inner ] shows the low - energy spectrum of the inner detector before and after the anticoincidence . the anticoincidence has no influence on the cosmogenic x - rays below 11kev , as well as on the structure at 32kev . the @xmath32spectrum from the cosmogenically produced @xmath33h with endpoint at 18kev is most likely present as well . if the compton suppression is applied in the energy region between 40kev and 100kev , the background reduction factor is 4.3 . the counting rate after the anticoincidence in this energy region is 0.07events / kgdkev , thus very close to the value obtained in the heidelberg - moscow experiment with the enriched detector ang2 @xcite . in the energy region between 11kev and 40kev the background index is a factor of 3 higher ( 0.2events / kgdkev ) . the evaluation for dark matter limits on the wimp nucleon cross section @xmath34 follows the method described in @xcite . because the cosmogenic radionuclides produced in the ge crystals and in the surrounding copper have typical half - lives of 300 days , we consider only the last 49d of measurement of the hdms prototype . the total exposure corresponds to 9.9kgd . the number of counts per 1kev energy bin are listed in table [ inner - counts ] . the background index in the energy region between 230kev is 0.5events / kgdkev . no background subtractions were applied . the parameters used in the calculation of expected wimp spectra are given in table [ tab : parameter ] . the resulting upper limit exclusion plot in the @xmath35 versus m@xmath36 plane is shown in fig . [ dm_limits ] . at this stage , the limit is not yet competitive with our limit from the heidelberg - moscow experiment for large wimp masses . however , the cross section limits for wimp masses below 40gev are considerably improved . this is mainly due to the lower energy threshold of 2kev , compared to 9kev in the heidelberg - moscow experiment . also shown in the figure are limits from the heidelberg - moscow experiment @xcite , the neuch@xmath37tel - experiment @xcite , the dama experiment @xcite and the most recent limits from the cdms experiment @xcite . the filled contour represents the 2@xmath30 evidence region of the dama experiment @xcite . the dashed line is the expectation for hdms having a background index equal to the one of the heidelberg - moscow experiment @xcite extended down to an energy threshold of 2kev . the experimental limits are compared to expectations ( scatter plot ) for wimp - neutralinos calculated in the mssm parameter space at the weak scale ( without any gut constraints ) under the assumption that all superpartner masses are lower than 300 gev - 400 gev @xcite . for the second phase of hdms , important changes were already made . first , the inner crystal made of natural germanium was replaced by an enriched @xmath38ge crystal . in this way , we will be sensitive also to spin - dependent wimp - nucleon interactions , since @xmath38ge is the only germanium isotope with spin . in addition , the @xmath39ge isotope , which is the source of @xmath17ge by the @xmath39ge(p , t)@xmath17ge reaction , is now strongly depleted . although the exact depletion is not measured yet , we expect at least a factor of 50 ( we measured a factor of 60 depletion in @xmath39ge for the enriched @xmath40ge detectors in the heidelberg - moscow experiment @xcite ) . second , the copper crystal holder system was replaced by a holder made of extremely radio - pure copper ; soldering of the signal and the high - voltage contacts was not applied . we believe that both facts will have a large impact on the background of the hdms detectors , since monte carlo simulations based on geant3.21 showed @xcite , that besides the cosmogenic activation of the crystals , the u / th contamination of the copper and solder were the main background sources of the prototype . the @xmath38ge - hdms detector has been assembled and transported by ship to heidelberg , where its performance was tested in the low - level laboratory . both inner and outer detector are working well , the ( not optimized ) energy resolutions being around 1.9kev and 4.0kev at 1332kev . we will install the full scale experiment at lngs in august 2000 . the prototype detector of the hdms experiment successfully took data at lngs over a period of about 15 months . most of the dominant background sources were identified . however , the origin of a structure centred at 32kev in the inner detector is still unclear . due to its low energy and the fact that it is not removed by the anticoincidence with the outer detector , it is most probably located in the inner crystal itself or at the signal contact . the future measurement with the @xmath38ge - hdms detector will hopefully help to clarify its nature . the background reduction factor through anticoincidence in the inner detector in the energy region 40100kev is 4.3 . it is less then previously expected @xcite , due to the smaller diameter of the outer , veto ge - detector than originally planned . nevertheless , the background in the energy region between 40kev and 100kev of the inner detector is with 0.07events / kgdkev already now at the level of the heidelberg - moscow experiment . in the region between 230kev it is with 0.5events / kgdkev a factor of 7 higher , mainly due to the cosmogenic activation of the natural ge crystals . however , due to the smaller energy threshold of 2kev , the limits on wimp - nucleon cross sections were improved for wimp masses below 40gev with respect to the heidelberg - moscow experiment . they are currently the most stringent spin - independent limits at low wimp masses for using raw data without any background subtraction . the expectation for the @xmath38ge - hdms detector is shown in fig . [ dm_limits ] . it is based on a background index of 0.07events / kgdkev in the region between 230kev . the aim of hdms is to test the ` evidence region ' singled out by the dama experiment @xcite in the mssm parameter space after about two years of measurement . it would be an independent test by using only raw data and a completely different detection technique . l. baudis , h.v . klapdor - kleingrothaus , astro - ph/0003434 and in proceedings of beyond the desert 99 , second international conference on physics beyond the standard model , castle ringberg , tegernsee , germany , 6 - 12 june 1999 , eds . klapdor - kleingrothaus , i.v . krivosheina ( iop bristol , 2000 ) p. belli et al . , in proc . of the second int . conference on dark matter in astro and particle physics ( dark98 ) july 1998 , heidelberg , eds . klapdor kleingrothaus and l. baudis , iop , bristol & philadelphia , 1999 , p. 711 . | the heidelberg dark matter search experiment ( hdms ) is a new ionization germanium experiment in a special design . two concentric ge crystals are housed by one cryostat system , the outer detector acting as an effective shield against multiple scattered photons for the inner crystal , which is the actual dark matter target . we present first results after successfully running the prototype detector for a period of about 15 months in the gran sasso underground laboratory . we analyze the results in terms of limits on wimp - nucleon cross sections and present the status of the full scale experiment , which will be installed in gran sasso in the course of this year . |
astro-ph0307433 | agile , the 4@xmath1 gamma - ray satellite , is a bridge between the compton gamma ray observatory ( cgro ) , switched off in 2000 , and the gamma ray large area space telescope ( glast ) to be launched at the end of 2006 . the agile instrument is designed to detect and image gamma - ray and hard x - ray photons by means of the gamma ray imaging detector ( grid ) and the hard x - ray imager super - agile ( sa ) . grid , sensitive in the energy range 30mev@xmath050gev , is made of 12 si - w planes and the mini calorimeter , sensitive in the energy range 0.3@xmath0100mev and positioned at the bottom of the instrument . sa , sensitive in the energy range 10@xmath040kev , with its 4 si - detectors and the ultra - light coded mask system is positioned on top of the first grid tray . the asi science data center ( asdc ) will host the agile data center ( adc ) . the adc includes the agile team processing group and the agile science support group . agile data from the malindi ground station will be received by the operational and control center ( aocc ) in italy and then they will be transfered to adc . + the adc@asdc will be in charge of the following tasks @xcite : * running the quick look analysis * running the standard data reduction analysis * performing , when necessary , the interactive data analysis * managing announcement of opportunities * contributing to the agile management of the pointing program * archiving the data ( raw , cleaned and calibrated , scientific ) * distributing the data to the scientific community * providing scientific support to the users community * interfacing the project for both data and proposals + via dedicated web pages * providing the standard software support for data analysis the pipeline that will be running at asdc will drive the automated data analysis for both grid and sa data . figure [ memola1 ] shows a preliminary flow chart concerning the grid data analysis . the software modules needed to process the data are under development by the agile team , while the pipeline itself will be built by professional programmers of the agile science support group at asdc , in collaboration with the agile team . the grid telemetry packets will be pre - processed in order to get files in the standard fits format . the event list undergoes a complex process of background subtraction and track reconstruction analysis in order to get a cleaned @xmath2-photon list . then , standard products as spectra , light curves and images will be made available to the scientific community via a set of dedicated web pages . agile data will be part of the permanent multi - mission interactive archive at asdc . the scientific goals of the agile mission include the detailed study of active galactic nuclei . figure [ memola2 ] ( _ top _ ) shows the simulated all - sky intensity map above 100mev @xcite as well as the spectral energy distributions ( seds ) of the blazars mkn 501 ( _ bottom , left _ ) and 3c 273 ( _ bottom , right _ ) . the multi - frequency data have been retrieved from the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) , the second version of the guide star catalog ( gsc - ii ) and from _ beppo_sax . by accounting for agile - grid and super - agile limiting sensitivity we plan to select the blazars currently known that might be suitable candidates for agile observations . according to the predictions of a synchrotron - self compton ( ssc ) spectral model ( _ dashed _ , _ dashed - dotted lines _ ) , mkn 501 and 3c 273 would be visible to both agile - grid and super - agile . the seds of all the blazars observed by _ beppo_sax during its first five years of operations @xcite and the corresponding ssc predictions together with the plotted agile - grid and super - agile limiting sensitivity can be found at the following web address : http://www.asdc.asi.it/blazars/ agile science management plan , asi document , 2002 + giommi p. , capalbi m. , fiocchi m. , memola e. , et al . , 2002 , in _ blazar astrophysics with bepposax and other observatories _ , frascati , italy , december 2001 , p. giommi , e. massaro , g. palumbo eds . , asi special publication p.63 + science with agile , agile document ap , issue 25 , march 6 , 2003 : http://agile.mi.iasf.cnr.it/homepage/index.shtml | agile ( astro - rivelatore gamma ad immagini leggero ) is a small scientific mission of the italian space agency ( asi ) with a science program open to the national and international community . its main goal is to develop and operate a scientific satellite devoted to gamma - ray ( 30mev@xmath050gev ) and hard x - ray ( 10@xmath040kev ) astrophysics during the years 2005@xmath02007 . asi plans to handle agile data through the asi science data center in collaboration with the agile team . |
1202.2400 | supernova ( sn ) 2006 oz ( leloudas et al . 2012 ) is a newly - recognized member of the class of h - poor , super - luminous supernovae ( i.e. sn2005ap - like ; quimby et al . the bolometric light curve shows a precursor plateau " with a duration between 6 - 10 days in the rest - frame and it is followed by a dip , after which the luminosity begins to rise . this subsequent rise was fit using three different models ( see chatzopolos et al . 2011 ) : ( i ) input from radioactive decay ; ( ii ) a magnetar spin - down model ; ( iii ) a circum - stellar matter ( csm ) interaction . the nickel decay model is least likely since it requires unreasonable amounts ( 10.8@xmath0 ) of @xmath1ni in a total ejecta mass of 14.4@xmath0 . in addition the sn was not detected nine months later , inconsistent with the standard decay curve for @xmath2co . the magnetar and csm models present a decent but not accurate fit to the data ( see figure 7 leloudas et al . 2012 ) . in general , to explain sn 2005ap - like objects ( chomuik et al . 2011 ) the suggested models require rather extreme additional conditions . the magnetar model requires initial spin periods near break - up ( 1 - 2 ms ) while csm interaction models require expelling several solar masses of h - poor material in the few years before the explosion : this has never been observed from w - r stars ( see chomuik et al . 2011 for details ) . existing models for the precursor ( dessart et al . 2011 ) are too dim to explain it . the only explanation offered by leloudas et al . ( 2012 ) was a recombination wave in oxygen around the progenitor star with no physical cause for the wave suggested . at the current stage , none of the above models can account for the precursor . this begs for other alternatives which can explain the precursor and the main peak of sn2006 oz self - consistently . the energy in the precursor we estimate to be @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the duration of the precursor in units of 10 days ( limited by the observations from about 7 days to 12 days ) . we note that this energy is typical of brighter type - ii sne ( e.g. young 2004 ) suggesting that the precursor could in fact be the sn explosion proper . this would require that the main peak has a separate physical origin . the quark nova ( qn ) was proposed as an alternative explanation for sn 2006gy and other slsne including sn 2005ap ( leahy & ouyed 2008 ) . in ouyed et al . ( 2009a ) , we also emphasize the lightcurve of the preceding sn , giving a double - humped " lightcurve very much reminiscent of that of sn2006 oz . in this paper we focus on studying the lightcurve of sn2006 oz in the context of our model : the dual - shock qn ( dsqn ) model . the paper is organized as follows : in 2 we give a brief review of the dsqn model . in 3 we show that the main peak and the precursor of sn2006 oz are self - consistently fit by the dsqn . we briefly conclude in 4 . the quark nova ( qn ) was proposed as an alternative explanation for sn 2006gy ( leahy & ouyed 2008 ; ouyed et al . a qn is expected to occur when the core density of a neutron star reaches the quark de - confinement density and triggers a violent ( ouyed et al . 2002 ) conversion to the more stable strange quark matter ( itoh 1970 ; bodmer 1971 ; witten 1984 ) . the novel proposition was made , that during the spin - down evolution of the neutron star , a detonative ( ouyed et al . 2002 ; niebergal et al . 2010 ) phase transition to up - down - strange triplets would eject the outer layers of the neutron star at ultra - relativistic velocities ( kernen et al . 2005 ; ouyed & leahy 2009 ) . studies of neutrino and photon emission processes during the qn ( vogt et al . 2004 ; ouyed et al . 2005 ) have shown that these outermost layers ( of @xmath5-@xmath6 in mass ) can be ejected with up to @xmath7 erg in kinetic energy . if the time delay ( @xmath8 ) between sn and qn explosions is lengthy the sn ejecta will have dissipated such that the qn essentially erupts in isolation . however , when @xmath8 is on the order of days to weeks , a violent collision occurs reheating the extended sn ejecta ( leahy & ouyed 2008 ; ouyed et al . the emission from the re - shocked sn ejecta declines as the photosphere recedes , eventually revealing a mixture of the sn and qn material with unique chemical signatures ( jaikumar et al . 2007 ; ouyed et al . 2009a ; ouyed et al . 2010 ; ouyed et al . 2011 ) . the basic physical processes involved in our model are : ( i ) a sn explosion at time @xmath9 with homologously expanding ejecta with the outermost velocity at @xmath10 ; ( ii ) a qn explosion at time @xmath8 which launches a shock at velocity @xmath11 into the preceding sn ejecta . this second shock reheats the sn ejecta to @xmath12 ; ( iii ) the qn shock breaks out from the sn ejecta at time @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the time for the qn shock to propagate through the sn ejecta . the reheated sn ejecta expands while radiating and undergoing adiabatic expansion losses . we approximate the evolution of the photosphere using photon diffusion in a pure thompson scattering medium ( see leahy&ouyed 2008 ) . a key feature of this model is that the shock reheating occurs at large radius ( because of the time delay ) so that standard adiabatic losses inherent to sn ejecta are far smaller . in effect the sn provides the material at large radius and the qn re - energizes it giving the large luminosity compared to a normal sn . figure 1 shows the observed sn2006 oz light curve from leloudas et al . ( 2011 ; their table 3 ) . we use the g - band data which has the best time coverage and also lowest errors for most times . the data is plotted in days at the source using the measured redshift of @xmath15 . we converted apparent g - band magnitudes to absolute g - band magnitudes using the corresponding luminosity distance for the standard model ( wright 2006 ) . we converted the suggested extinction correction ( b - v ) from leloudas et al . ( 2011 ) to ( g - v ) and included it , even though it was small . our model also agrees with the early and late upper limits from leloudas et al . ( 2011 ) although they are not plotted here because we chose to show better the firm detections . for the sn lightcurve ( i.e. the first hump ) , we prefer to compare to an observed light curve . we use the light curve of sn1999em from bersten&hamuy ( 2009 ) which has good time coverage in the first 50 days . bersten et al . ( 2011 ) fitted hydrodynamic models to sn1999em and derived a progenitor mass of @xmath16 ( similar in mass to the sn progenitor we used in our qn model ) , radius of @xmath17 , explosion energy of @xmath18 erg and @xmath1ni mass of 0.056@xmath0 . this gave a luminosity at @xmath19 days of @xmath20 erg s@xmath21 . we scaled the bolometric magnitude by + 2 to represent a more energetic sn . this is not unreasonable since the range in brightness of type ii sne varies considerably with many models giving brighter sn than 1993em ( e.g. young 2004 ) . in the qn model the progenitor initial mass is in the range of 20 - 40@xmath0 ( leahy&ouyed 2009 ; ouyed et al . 2009b ; ouyed et al . 2010 ) to create a massive neutron star with core density near the instability to convert to quark matter ( niebergal et al . this motivates our choice of sn ejected mass of 20@xmath0 . best fits from our previous studies of slsne yielded time delays of @xmath22 days which motivates the time delays that we explored . for sn2006 oz the shown fit ( see figure 1 ) uses @xmath23 days , @xmath24 km s@xmath21 and a preceding sn ejecta with an average velocity of @xmath25 km s@xmath21 . the combined light from the sn and from the qn - reheated sn ejecta give a reasonable fit to the observations with a self - consistent model . and @xmath26 days ( see text for other parameters ) . the proto - type sn light curve ( connected squares ) is a scaled version of that observed for sn1999em ( see text).,scaledwidth=46.0% ] recent observations ( such as the texas sn search ; quimby et al . 2005 and the catalina real - time transit survey ; drake et al . 2009 ) have revealed a new class of supernovae , the slsne and among these are the sn2005ap - like ( h - poor ) slsne . these events have proven challenging to explain . sn2006 oz was the first to have clearly shown a bright precursor with absolute magnitude of @xmath27 -19 to -20 . we suggest this precursor is a type ii sn and the main event is the qn ( i.e. the sn envelope re - heated by the qn ) . we note from leloudas et al . ( 2012 ) the intriguing possibility of an intrinsic precursor event in sn 2005ap - like objects . in our model , there must be a normal sn ( @xmath28 ) preceding the slsn if the delay is long enough that the sn light curve is not buried in the qn one . the precursor sn should be detectable in sensitive and early enough observations of sn 2005ap - like explosions . sn 2005ap - like objects occur at a rate of @xmath29 core - collapse sne ( quimby et al . dsqne are expected to be rare : the qne rate is estimated to be @xmath30 core - collapse events with 1/10 of them having time delays in the appropriate range to produce dsqne ( @xmath31 5 - 30 days ; staff et al . 2006 ; jaikumar et al . 2007 ; leahy&ouyed 2008 ; leahy&ouyed 2009 ; ouyed et al . this order of magnitude estimate is consistent with the rate of sn 2005ap - like events . our model applies to both h - rich and h - poor slsne the key ingredient is a progenitor in the right mass range to produce a massive enough ns but not a black hole . we note that in both cases , the qn shock reheats the sn envelope so h - poor / h - rich progenitors would give h - poor / h - rich spectra . in this context , we expect h - poor slsne to occur in higher - metallicity environment ( i.e. higher stellar mass loss - rates ) . low - metallicity progenitors would lose less mass and would more likely be h - rich and should in principle have more massive envelopes . upcoming observations from the large sn surveys should reveal more slsne and more of these with precursors . in our model , these precursors are type ii sne which should be verifiable with good enough photometry and/or spectroscopy . in addition , the overall shape of the slsn lightcurve should vary from a single hump to a double hump depending on the time delay between the sn and the qn explosions . ouyed , r. , leahy , d. , & jaikumar , p. 2009a , proceedings for `` compact stars in the qcd phase diagram ii ( csqcd ii ) '' , may 20 - 24 , 2009 , kiaa at peking university , beijing- p. r. china , [ http://vega.bac.pku.edu.cn/rxxu/csqcd.htm ] , [ arxiv:0911.5424 ] | sn2006 oz is a super - luminous supernova with a mysterious bright precursor that has resisted explanation in standard models . however , such a precursor has been predicted in the dual - shock quark nova ( dsqn ) model of super - luminous supernovae the precursor is the sn event while the main light curve of the slsn is powered by the quark - nova ( qn ; explosive transition of the neutron star to a quark star ) . as the sn is fading , the qn re - energizes the sn ejecta , producing a double - humped " light curve . in this paper , we show the dsqn model successfully reproduces the observed light curve of sn2006 oz . |
1106.3090 | the fundamental magnetic behavior at the nanoscale has attracted considerable attention due to potential technological applications such as magnetic data storage@xcite and energy storage lithium ion batteries.@xcite because of the finite size of nanoscale magnetic materials , the large surface - to - core ratio becomes significant and , in some cases , explains the fascinating nanoscale behavior . the number of nearest neighbors for an atom at the surface is significantly reduced compared to the bulk with the consequence that the magnetic exchange is lessened . consequently , the magnetization and the transition temperature to magnetic order may be substantially reduced when compared to the bulk . theoretical calculations have predicted this behavior.@xcite experimentally , this behavior has been observed in both 3@xmath4 metals@xcite and oxide samples such as mno@xcite and nio.@xcite in contrast , an increase has been observed in the magnetic ordering temperature and magnetic moment in several nanoscale materials.@xcite for example , in some nanoscale 3@xmath4 metals , the moment is enhanced as a result of band narrowing at the surface resulting from the reduced coordination number . this behavior has been observed experimentally in iron , cobalt and nickel clusters@xcite and has been supported by theoretical calculations.@xcite on the other hand , in ionic oxide compounds , due to the relatively localized electronic distribution the moment is less affected by the surface and surface disorder results in a reduced average moment.@xcite a reduced moment and enhanced transition temperature have been observed in mno particles@xcite and in the spinel ferrites ni(mn)fe@xmath5o@xmath6.@xcite in either case , the origin of the moment and ordering temperature enhancement or reduction is unclear and , consequently , further study of magnetic nanoparticles is important . the classic antiferromagnetic ( afm ) oxide compound mno is a good candidate for studying finite size effects due to its relatively simple structure and well - studied bulk properties . bulk mno shows an afm transition at @xmath0 @xmath7 118 k-120 k@xcite that occurs concomitantly with a rhombohedral structural distortion from the high temperature nacl structure.@xcite previous studies have shown that the antiferromagnetic order and structural transition of mno survive into the nanoscale regime.@xcite the nature of the effect and its root cause remain unresolved because in some studies an enhanced @xmath0 has been observed for confinement particles@xcite and core - shell particles@xcite while a suppressed @xmath0 is reported in so - called ultrafine particles.@xcite in another example of mno nanoparticles , only short range afm order is reported.@xcite the degree to which this difference in behavior is related to the magnetic domain size or to the surface preparation remains unclear . hence , studies that compare multiple sizes of nanoscale mno with similar surface preparations can shed light on the intrinsic magnetic behavior that results from size confinement . in this paper we report neutron diffraction measurements on two different sizes ( 8 nm and 13 nm ) of monodisperse spherical mno nanoparticles . the 8 ( 13 ) nm sample is denoted as sample a ( b ) in the following discussion . our results show that in sample a the afm transition temperature @xmath0 is suppressed while in sample b , @xmath0 is almost the same as bulk mno . the mn magnetic moment is similar in both samples and is about 80@xmath3 of the bulk value of 4.89 @xmath2/mn.@xcite from polarized neutron diffraction data we estimate that the surface to total ratio is about 20 % which appears to explain the reduction in the moment . monodisperse mno nanoparticles were synthesized through a modification of non - injection synthetic schemes.@xcite an important aspect of the synthesis process is the attachment of capping ligands which provides size control , minimizes interparticle interactions , and passivates the surface . to minimize difficulties associated with the large incoherent neutron scattering cross - section of hydrogen , deuterated capping ligands were used . approximately 10 batches for each sample size were combined to produce samples large enough for neutron scattering experiments(@xmath8 0.5 g each ) . two distinct sizes were studied , an 8 nm sample ( sample a ) and a 13 nm ( sample b ) . these particle sizes are determined from transmission electron microscopy ( tem ) of @xmath850 - 100 particles per sample . as will be discussed further below , a limitation of tem is the low number of particles sampled , however despite this limitation the tem can provide some information concerning the polydispersity of the samples studied here . the tem results on sample a give a particle size of 7.9 @xmath1 1.6 nm ( ref . 25 ) and for sample b give a particle size of 13 @xmath1 2 nm ( see insets fig . 3(a ) and ( b ) ) . the shape of nanoparticle samples is an important consideration . aside from the difficulty in forming anisotropic particles of mno using our methods , there are two primary lines of evidence for the production of spherical particles . the first comes from tem images . if other shapes are formed , projection in two dimensions will reveal other geometries . for example , cubic nanoparticles will occasionally ( for suitable orientation ) reveal hexagonal shapes based on the 2d projection . additionally , if plates are formed , these are generally transparent in tem imaging and this was not the case here . furthermore , if growth occurs along a particular crystallographic face , this will be revealed in x - ray and neutron diffraction patterns . indeed , preferred growth directions will be associated with different peak widths for different reflections . in this case , no such divergence was found , consistent with the formation of isotropic ( _ i.e. _ , spherical ) particles , in strong corroboration of our tem results . x - ray diffraction with cu @xmath9 radiation ( @xmath10=1.5406 ) , and polarized and unpolarized neutron diffraction experiments were performed . the neutron diffraction experiments were performed on several instruments : the hb1a triple - axis instrument with @xmath10 = 2.364 at the high flux isotope reactor ( hfir ) , oak ridge national laboratory ; the c2 diffractometer at the canadian neutron beam centre ( nbc ) in chalk river , canada , with neutron wavelength of @xmath10 = 1.3306 and 2.3721 ; the general purpose neutron polarization analysis spectrometer , d7 , with @xmath10 = 3.073 at the institut laue - langevin in grenoble , france ; and the dns polarized diffuse scattering instrument with @xmath10 = 4.74 operated by the jlich centre for neutron science ( jcns ) at the forschungsneutronenquelle heinz maier - leibnitz ( frm ii ) , tu mnchen , germany . to carefully extract the particle size as well as the magnetic domain size from a diffraction pattern , it is important to properly account for instrumental resolution . a standard run on a mixture of nist si 640c and annealed yttria was performed to determine the instrumental resolution of c2 . similarly , a y@xmath11fe@xmath12o@xmath13 standard was used to determine the instrumental resolution of the d7 . for hb1a the instrumental resolution was obtained by comparing with a si standard and with a sample of bulk mno . the particle size and magnetic domain size were obtained from analysis of the ( 1 1 1 ) and ( 1/2 1/2 1/2)(pseudo cubic notation ) peak width using the standard scherrer formula@xcite and refinement of the diffraction pattern using fullprof.@xcite in particular , two methods were used to extract the particle size and magnetic domain size from the neutron diffraction data . in the first method , the instrumental resolution obtained as described above was convolved with the fitted gaussian peak width . in the second method , the instrument resolution peak shape parameters were fixed and a peak broadening parameter , to account for finite size effects , was included in the fullprof refinements of the data . all particle sizes determined from the neutron diffraction data are reported with the instrumental resolution taken into account . fig 1(a ) shows the x - ray diffraction pattern of sample a. the diffuse background is likely a consequence of the capping ligand . analysis of the widths of the ( 111 ) , ( 002 ) and ( 022 ) reflections using the scherrer formula@xcite yields particle sizes of 9.5 @xmath1 0.2 nm , 9.7 @xmath1 0.1 nm and 9.2 @xmath1 0.1 nm , similar to the values determined from transmission electron microscopy ( tem ) of 7.9 @xmath1 1.6 nm.@xcite note that in contrast to the tem data , the error bars on the particle size determined from the x - ray data ( as well as the neutron data discussed below ) reflect a statistical error of the mean particle size and do not provide information concerning the polydispersity of the samples . in fig . 1(c ) we present neutron diffraction data collected on the triple - axis instrument hb1a with @xmath10 = 2.3639 at 20 k. as shown in fig . 1(b ) , the peak width of the nanoparticle sample is obviously broadened when compared to the bulk material . the particle size determined from the nuclear peak(accounting for instrumental resolution ) is 9.9 @xmath1 0.5 nm in good agreement with the x - ray values . here we note that the amount of material used differs significantly for the different techniques . tem measurements sample the fewest particles ( @xmath8 50 - 100 particles ) followed by x - ray diffraction ( @xmath8 50 mg ) and , finally , neutron diffraction ( @xmath8 0.5 g ) . given this , we use the neutron derived values of the particle size as being most representative of the samples measured . in a similar fashion , the effective magnetic domain size can be determined from the width of the magnetic bragg peaks . in sample a at 20 k this analysis yields a magnetic domain size of 9.2 @xmath1 0.4 nm . within the experimental resolution of this measurement we are unable to determine a shift in lattice constant compared to the bulk , however the x - ray data ( higher resolution ) on samples from this batch indicate a somewhat smaller lattice constant ( 4.439(1 ) ) . ( color online ) ( a ) x - ray diffraction pattern of mno nanoparticle sample a. ( b ) the temperature dependence of the ( 1/2 1/2 1/2 ) magnetic bragg peak for sample a. the solid line is the scaled data for the bulk material and the horizontal bar indicates the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of the instrumental resolution . ( c ) neutron diffraction data for sample a at 20 k. the data were collected on hb1a . the broad hump between 30 to 40 degrees is likely the contribution from the capping ligand and/or residual solvent . this hump is also observed in the coherent + isotope incoherent scattering channel for sample b at @xmath14 1.5 ( see fig . 3(c ) ) , indicating that this scattering is of nonmagnetic origin . the solid line is the result of the rietveld refinement . the short vertical lines indicate the nuclear bragg peak ( upper ) and magnetic bragg peak ( lower).,scaledwidth=40.0% ] in fig . 2 , we present the temperature dependence of the magnetic moment for both bulk mno and sample a. no significant thermal hysteresis was observed in either the bulk or nanoparticle material indicating that the samples were in thermal equilibrium . the moment was obtained by scaling the integrated intensities of magnetic and structural bragg reflections , assuming a moment of 4.89 @xmath2/mn@xcite for bulk mno . this results in a low temperature magnetic moment for sample a of 4.07 @xmath1 0.11 @xmath2/mn at 20 k. note that this analysis assumes the magnetic structure of the nanoparticle and the bulk is the same aside from the magnitude of the ordered magnetic moment - justification of this assumption is given below . from fig . 2 , we can clearly see that not only is the magnetic moment suppressed in the nanoparticle sample relative to the bulk , but that the afm transition temperature @xmath0 decreases from 118.7 k in bulk to 113.6 k in sample a. a similar suppression of @xmath0 has been reported in ultrafine mno particles with sizes in the range of @xmath83.7 to @xmath8 5.4 nm.@xcite ( color online ) the temperature dependent magnetic moment of the mno bulk and nanoparticles of sample a. the solid lines are guides for the eye . ] to provide further insight into the above results , models of both the crystal and the magnetic structure were fit to the neutron diffraction data of sample a and a sample of bulk mno at 20 k , through rietveld refinement using fullprof to determine the magnetic moment , particle size , and domain size . a model including the rhombohedral structural distortion ( r @xmath15 m)@xcite was used for the refinement and the bulk diffraction pattern was used to specify the instrument resolution function for the sample a refinement . fitting the bulk neutron scattering data yields a magnetic moment of 4.8 @xmath1 0.3 @xmath2/mn , consistent with the previously reported value.@xcite the resulting refinement for sample a is indicated by the solid line in fig . 1 ( c ) . the results yield a magnetic moment of 4.2 @xmath1 0.3 @xmath2/mn , a particle size of 10.3 @xmath1 0.5 nm and a magnetic domain size of 9.1 @xmath1 0.7 nm , consistent with the analysis above using the scherrer formula . here we note that the magnetic domain size is almost as large as the nuclear particle size ( @xmath81.5 magnetic domains per nanoparticle ) , thus the dominant magnetic behavior appears to come from a single magnetic domain per nanoparticle , this point will be discussed further below . ( color online ) the observed ( open circles ) and calculated ( solid lines ) neutron diffraction data for nanoparticle sample b at room temperature ( a ) and 4 k ( b ) . the weak peaks indicated by the star in ( a ) are due to a mno@xmath5 impurity . the data were collected on c2 . the short vertical lines indicates the nuclear ( upper ) and magnetic ( lower ) bragg peak position . ( c ) the separated polarized neutron diffraction data . the intensity is presented in units of barns per steradian per formula unit . the data were collected on d7 . the solid line is the sum of the coherent and isotope incoherent , the solid triangle is nuclear spin incoherent scattering and the open circle is the magnetic scattering . the inset in ( a ) is the tem image . the inset in ( b ) is the particle size distribution . ] in fig . 3(a ) room temperature diffraction data are presented for sample b. analyzing the ( 1 1 1 ) nuclear reflection yields a particle size of 13.1 @xmath1 0.7 nm . 3(b ) shows the diffraction pattern at 4 k. a similar analysis of the width of the magnetic peak ( 1/2 1/2 1/2 ) gives a magnetic domain size of 10.0 @xmath1 0.2 nm . polarized neutron diffraction data allows for the unambiguous separation of the magnetic from the nonmagnetic scattering . in fig . 3(c ) we present polarized neutron diffraction data separated into various components of the neutron scattering cross - section . here the single peak analysis yields a magnetic domain size of 9.7 @xmath1 0.4 nm and a particle size of 12.6 @xmath1 0.8 nm . thus in this case , there appears to be the possibility of 2 magnetic domains per nanoparticle . to thoroughly analyze the diffraction data , fullprof was used for the refinement of the entire diffraction pattern . the solid lines in fig . 3(a ) and ( b ) are the results of the refinement . as in the bulk material , at a temperature above the afm transition the diffraction pattern can be well - described by a nacl structure ( f m @xmath15 m ) while below the transition temperature , a structural model including a rhombohedral distortion ( r @xmath15 m ) best describes the data . ( color online ) temperature dependence of the lattice parameter ( a ) magnetic moment ( b ) and the structure distortion angle , @xmath16 ( c ) for sample b. the results are obtained through refinement of models of the crystal and magnetic structure to the neutron scattering data from c2 as described in the text . the solid lines in ( b ) and ( c ) are guides for the eye . ] in fig . 4 we present the results of structural refinements as a function of temperature for sample b. the temperature dependent lattice parameter is shown in fig . 4(a ) ; the stars are the results for the high temperature nacl phase . the temperature dependence of the magnetic moment is shown in fig . this allows us to extract an afm transition temperature of 120 @xmath1 0.3 k , comparable , or perhaps slightly larger than that of the bulk material . at 4 k the magnetic moment saturates at a value of 3.9 @xmath1 0.2 @xmath2/mn , which is similar to the previous reported value for mno nanoparticles embedded in porous glass.@xcite fig . 4(c ) shows the temperature dependence of the rhombohedral distortion angle , @xmath16 . @xmath16 increases with decreasing temperature saturating at a value of 0.44 @xmath1 0.01@xmath17 . this value is slightly smaller than both the nanoparticles embedded in porous glass@xcite and the bulk@xcite where @xmath16 @xmath8 0.6@xmath17 . however , a smaller value of about 0.43@xmath17 has also been reported in bulk.@xcite the temperature dependence of the distortion angle indicates a structural transition temperature of 120 @xmath1 0.3 k , which is the same as the @xmath0 obtained from the evolution of the magnetic order parameter . ( color online ) ( a ) ( 1/2 1/2 1/2 ) magnetic peak width ( open symbol ) and the ( 1 1 1 ) nuclear peak width ( solid symbol ) for sample b. inset is the ( 1/2 1/2 1/2 ) peak at different temperatures . the data were collected on the c2 instrument . ( b ) the temperature dependent magnetic domain size ( open symbols ) and particle size ( solid symbols ) for sample b. circles are unpolarized results from c2 and diamonds are polarized results from d7 . inset is the evolution of the ( 1/2 1/2 1/2 ) magnetic peak with temperature from the d7 polarized neutron scattering data . horizontal bars in the insets represent the instrumental resolution . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] the temperature evolution of the ( 1/2 1/2 1/2 ) magnetic bragg peak is displayed in the insets of fig . 5(a ) and fig . 5(b ) , respectively . in fig . 5(a ) the temperature dependence of the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of the ( 1/2 1/2 1/2 ) peak is shown for sample b. above @xmath0 , there is no obvious signal at ( 1/2 1/2 1/2 ) ; we include the ( 1 1 1 ) nuclear peak width for comparison ( solid symbol ) . the magnetic peak width shows a drastic change at @xmath0 and becomes progressively narrower below @xmath0 indicating that the magnetic domains emerge and grow progressively with decreasing temperature . the temperature dependence of the refined average domain diameter is shown in fig . 5(b ) . for comparison , above @xmath0 , the average particle size is plotted ( solid symbols ) . a similar domain size is determined from the polarized neutron scattering data . the results obtained from both c2 ( unpolarized ) and d7 ( polarized ) are plotted together in fig . 5(b ) for comparison . the summary of the particle and magnetic parameters are listed in table i. both samples exhibit a suppressed magnetic moment compared to bulk mno . this behavior is also observed in confinement geometry and core - shell mno particles@xcite and is believed to be the result of disordered spins on the surface of the nanoparticles.@xcite however , whether the actual moment for the mn site is the same as in the bulk has not been directly determined yet . to test this , polarized neutron scattering data which is sensitive to both the ordered and disordered moment is required . previous polarized neutron scattering data on average 7 nm confinement geometry nanoparticles indicated that only 40@xmath3 of the mn atoms were ordered.@xcite however , the average magnetic moment is not reported . in the polarized data presented here on sample b at 1.5 k , from the peak - to - diffuse scattering ratio we can estimate that about 80 - 85@xmath3 of the mn atoms in a nanoparticle are magnetically ordered . assuming the actual magnetic moment of mn atoms in the nanoparticle is identical to the bulk value and scaling by the percent of the particle that actually participates in magnetically ordered state , the expected average moment in this sample would be 3.9 - 4.1 @xmath2/mn . this is consistent with the values of the magnetic moment derived from the neutron scattering data reported in table i. in sample a , the average magnetic moment is about 85@xmath3 of the bulk material . the polarized diffraction results collected using dns ( not shown ) show that about 75 - 80@xmath3 mn atoms order at 3 k , again , implying that the ordered moment of mn site is similar to the bulk . one possible explanation for this observation is that the nanoparticles studied here contain a core which acts like bulk mno and a shell with random spins . .[tab : table ] summary of the particle and magnetic parameters obtained through x - ray , tem and neutron scattering analysis . d@xmath18 and d@xmath19 are the diameter of particles and magnetic domain size respectively . error bars in the x - ray and neutron diffraction results represent statistical standard deviation @xmath20 of the mean particle size while the tem results represent the standard deviation of the size distribution . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] the nature of the surface spins has been discussed frequently in the literature . in particular , magnetic susceptibility measurements have been interpreted in terms of weak ferromagnetism and related superparamagnetic like behavior of uncompensated surface spins.@xcite however , the size dependence of the superparamagnetic behavior appears to be inversely related to particle size in contrast to the direct relationship expected for a superparamagnetic particle . morales , _ _ et al.__@xcite have proposed that the mn residing on the surface is subject to a noncubic crystalline electric field and this provides an additional source of anisotropy effecting the superparamagnetic behavior . in this lower symmetry crystal field environment , a low - spin configuration is energetically favorable resulting in a moment of @xmath21 on the surface mn atoms . unfortunately , the neutron scattering data here can not contribute significantly to the discussion concerning the nature of the surface spins . the diffuse magnetic scattering in the polarized neutron scattering data ( fig . 3(c ) ) shows a weak magnetic diffuse component that suggests the presence of disordered spins , but we stress though that the measurement itself provides no information whether or not these spins are on the surface . moreover , if there were significant ferromagnetic moments we would expect depolarization of the neutron beam . no obvious depolarization of the neutron beam was observed , but it is difficult make a quantitative estimate on a limit of the a ferromagnetic moment size without further systematic measurements . a comparison of t@xmath22 for bulk mno to that of sample a ( 8 nm ) , shows that t@xmath22 is suppressed by about 4@xmath3 compared to the bulk value . on the other hand , sample b ( 13 nm ) , exhibits a @xmath0 comparable to the bulk . suppression of @xmath0 is also observed in ultrafine mno particles @xcite as well as in other nanoscale afm compounds such as nio and coo thin films,@xcite and nio disc shaped nanoparticles.@xcite a mean field approach with finite size effects for the magnetic transition has been used for the explanation of the suppression of @xmath0 . in this theory , the transition temperature is suppressed when the sample size / thickness decreases to small value . for mno a prism model of ultrafine particles , the calculations predict @xmath0 will be suppressed at small size due to the decrease of the average coupling constant which is induced by the decrease of coordination number on the surface.@xcite similar arguments are likely to apply to the nanoparticles studied here and thus @xmath0 suppression is likely due to decreases in the coordination number and the average coupling constant . in sample b , @xmath0 remains the same as bulk material suggesting that size confinement effects in mno nanoparticles appear at only relatively small sizes . in apparent contradiction to the preceding arguments , an enhanced @xmath0 is reported in confined geometry nanoparticles.@xcite for these nanoparticle systems the worm - like particle morphology@xcite and the surface interface of glass@xcite or another magnetic species@xcite is the likely cause of the differences in behavior with those studied here . as mentioned above , the coordination number on the surface affects the transition temperature and by adjusting the coordination number t@xmath22 can be increased or decreased.@xcite the effect of size confinement on the order of the magnetic / structural phase transition is another interesting issue in nanoscale mno . it has been suggested in the confined geometry mno nanoparticles that the afm transition is a continuous phase transition.@xcite in these samples the critical exponent @xmath23 describing the ordered magnetic moment , m(t ) @xmath8 ( 1-@xmath24)@xmath25 , ranges from 0.3 up to almost the mean field value of 0.5 . these values are in reasonable agreement with monte carlo simulations for the finite size ising model and heisenberg model where @xmath23 is 0.3258 and 0.3616 , respectively.@xcite in the reduced temperature range of 1-@xmath26/@xmath0= 0.02 - 0.5 , fitting our temperature dependent moment to a power law of ( 1-@xmath26/@xmath0)@xmath27 yields a much smaller @xmath23 of [email protected] for sample a and [email protected] for sample b. this could be interpreted as lower dimensional critical behavior but is more likely the result of a discontinuous phase transition . in conclusion , we have studied two different sizes of monodisperse mno nanoparticles using unpolarized and polarized neutron diffraction . both the magnetic and crystal structure are similar to the bulk , but with substantially reduced average magnetic moment . moreover , the results show that in the 8 nm sample the antiferromagnetic transition temperature @xmath0 is suppressed while in the 13 nm sample , @xmath0 is comparable to bulk . the suppression of @xmath0 is attributed to the exchange coupling reduction induced by the finite size effect . the observations presented here are consistent with the core of the mno nanoparticles behaving much like the bulk with a disordered surface layer . we acknowledge useful discussions with j. musfeldt and i. swainson . research work at ornl was sponsored by the laboratory directed research and development program of ornl , and was supported by the scientific user facilities division office of basic energy sciences , doe . a portion of this research was conducted at the center for nanophase materials sciences , which is sponsored at ornl by the office of basic energy sciences , u.s . d. u. lee , t. h. lee , e. k. kim , j. w. shin , w. j. cho , aip conf . proc . * 1199 * , 509 ( 2009 ) , physics of semiconductors : 29th international conference on the physics of semiconductors ; c. egami , n. nishimura and t. okawa , optics express * 18 * , 15901 ( 2010 ) . a. lpez - ortega , a. tobia , e. winkler , i. v. golosovsky , g. salazar - alvarez , s. estrad , m. estrader , j. sort , m. a. gonzlez , a. surinach , j. arbiol , f. peir , r. d. zysler , m. d. bar , and j. nogus , j. am . soc . * 132 * , 9398 ( 2010 ) . c. n. chinnasamy , a. narayanasamy , n. ponpandian , r. j. joseyphus , b. jeydevan , k. tohji , k. chattopadhyay , j. mag . mag . * 238 * , 281 ( 2002 ) ; c. n. chinnasamy , a. yang , a. d. yoon , k. hsu , m. d. shultz , e. e. carpenter , s. mukerjee , c. vittoria and v. g. harris , j. appl . phys . * 101 * , 09m509 ( 2007 ) . | we have performed unpolarized and polarized neutron diffraction experiments on monodisperse 8 nm and 13 nm antiferromagnetic mno nanoparticles . for the 8 nm sample , the antiferromagnetic transition temperature @xmath0 ( 114 k ) is suppressed compared to the bulk material ( 119 k ) while for the 13 nm sample @xmath0 ( 120 k ) is comparable to the bulk . the neutron diffraction data of the nanoparticles is well described using the bulk mno magnetic structure but with a substantially reduced average magnetic moment of [email protected] @xmath2/mn for the 8 nm sample and [email protected] @xmath2/mn for the 13 nm sample . an analysis of the polarized neutron data on both samples shows that in an individual mno nanoparticle about 80@xmath3 of mn ions order . these results can be explained by a structure in which the monodisperse nanoparticles studied here have a core that behaves similar to the bulk with a surface layer which does not contribute significantly to the magnetic order . |
1603.00527 | starting from the 2007 crisis , one of the most striking features of today s financial environment is represented by the segmentation of interest rate markets . more specifically , while the pre - crisis interest rate market was well described by a _ single _ yield curve and interbank xibor rates associated to different tenors were simply determined by no - arbitrage relations , nowadays the market is segmented in the sense that distinct yield curves are constructed from market instruments that depend on a specific tenor , thus giving rise to _ multiple _ yield curves . the credit and liquidity risks existing in the interbank market , which were perceived as negligible before the crisis , are at the origin of this phenomenon . this is also reflected by the emergence of spreads between ois rates and xibor rates as well as between xibor rates associated to different tenors . in this paper , we propose the most general tractable approach based on affine processes to model multiple yield curves . in our view , it should be understood as _ the affine framework _ for this modeling purpose and not as a specific model class , such as the affine libor models considered in @xcite . we provide a unifying affine methodology within which all interest rate modeling approaches , i.e. , ( i ) short rate , ( ii ) libor market , and ( iii ) heath - jarrow - morton modeling , can be consolidated . on the one hand , this allows us to embed in our framework all affine multiple curve models proposed so far in the literature . on the other hand , the approach allows for novel developments , for instance multiple curve short rate models based on wishart processes as well as interest rate models under alternative numraires . moreover , the generality of the setting does not preclude tractability and appealing practical features , as will be made precise below . we model a general numraire process and , inspired by our previous work @xcite , _ multiplicative spreads _ between ( normalized ) spot xibor rates and ( normalized ) simply compounded ois rates . besides being directly observable from market quotes , multiplicative spreads represent the most convenient modeling quantity in an affine setting and admit a natural interpretation in terms of forward exchange premia . we consider a general interest rate market where ois zero - coupon bonds and fra contracts are traded , for a finite set of tenors and for all maturities , and assume the existence of a numraire - martingale measure couple , thus ensuring absence of arbitrage in a sense precisely specified below . we then model the logarithm of the multiplicative spreads and of the numraire process as affine functions of an underlying affine process . in the special case where the numraire is chosen as the ois bank account , our framework can be regarded as the natural extension of classical affine short rate models to the multi - curve setting . in the special case where the numraire is chosen to be the ois bond with terminal maturity , we can recover an extension of the affine libor market model of @xcite . the proposed framework fully exploits the analytical tractability of affine processes and exhibits several desirable modeling features . indeed , besides its generality , it allows for * an automatic fit to the initially observed term structures of ois bond prices and spreads ; * a transparent characterization of order relations between spreads associated to different tenors ; * efficient valuation formulae for caplets and swaptions in a multi - curve setting . the driving affine process is allowed to take values in a general convex state space . in particular , we analyze a specification based on wishart processes and we derive a novel closed - form formula for the price of a caplet , expressed in terms of the distribution function of weighted sums of independent non - central chi - square - distributed random variables . beyond that , we test the empirical performance of two simple specifications of our setup and show that they achieve a satisfactory fit to market data . referring to the introductory section of @xcite and to the monographies @xcite for a more detailed overview of the relevant literature , we mention here that affine processes have been used to model multiple yield curves in @xcite by adopting a short rate approach and , more recently , in @xcite by extending the affine libor model originally introduced in @xcite . as already mentioned , the flexibility of our approach is highlighted by the fact that , to the best of our knowledge , all existing affine multi - curve models can be recovered as special cases of our framework . for this reason , the present work structurally differs from papers on specific affine modeling approaches , as previously considered in the literature . beyond that , it also provides a broad class of tractable specifications of the abstract hjm approach based on general it semimartingales proposed in @xcite for arbitrage - free modeling of the term structures of ois bonds and multiplicative spreads . the paper is organized as follows . section [ sec : intro2 ] starts by introducing the main market rates and multiplicative spreads and then presents an abstract approach to the arbitrage - free modeling of a general multi - curve interest rate market . in section [ affinespecification ] , we develop a general framework driven by affine processes as well as possible specifications based on a short rate approach . moreover , we relate our setup to several affine multi - curve models recently proposed in the literature . in section [ sec : aff_pricing ] , we derive general semi - closed valuation formulae for caplets and an approximate formula for the price of a swaption . section [ sec : wishart ] contains a detailed analysis of a tractable specification based on wishart processes , deriving an analytical pricing formula for caplets . section [ sec : aff_examples ] presents the calibration results for two specifications of the framework . finally , appendix [ sec : gen_pricing ] presents general pricing formulae in terms of the quantities used in our framework and appendix [ app : proof_prop ] contains the proof of proposition [ prop : bonds_spreads ] . the underlying quantities of most interest rate products are represented by xibor rates . we denote by @xmath0 the xibor rate prevailing at date @xmath1 for the time interval @xmath2 $ ] , where the tenor @xmath3 is typically one day ( 1d ) , one week ( 1w ) , or several months ( 1 m , 2 m , 3 m , 6 m or 12 m ) . referring to ( * chapter 1 ) for a more detailed presentation of post - crisis interest rate markets , we just mention that xibor rates are reference rates determined by a panel of primary financial institutions for unsecured lending and are not based on actual transactions . in the post - crisis fixed income market , xibor rates associated to different tenors started to exhibit distinct behaviors , leading for instance to non - negligible basis spreads ( see appendix a.1 ) . in this paper , we shall consider xibor rates for a generic set of tenors @xmath4 , with @xmath5 , for some @xmath6 . the reference rates for overnight borrowing ( i.e. , for the shortest tenor of 1d ) correspond to the eonia ( euro overnight index average ) rate in the eurozone and to the federal funds rate in the us market . unlike xibor rates , the eonia and the federal funds rates are determined on the basis of actual overnight transactions in the interbank market by a panel of banks ( in the case of the eonia rate , this is the same panel determining the euribor rate ) . overnight rates represent the underlying of overnight indexed swaps ( ois ) , whose market swap rates are referred to as ois rates ( see appendix [ sec : noopt ] ) , typically considered as the best proxy for risk - free rates in market practice . by bootstrapping techniques ( see @xcite ) , ois rates allow to recover the ois term structure @xmath7 , where @xmath8 denotes the price at date @xmath1 of an ois zero - coupon bond with maturity @xmath9 . we define the simply compounded ( risk - free ) ois spot rate by @xmath10 for @xmath3 . in particular , note that the right - hand side of the above formula corresponds to the pre - crisis textbook definition of xibor rate . our main modeling quantities are the following _ spot multiplicative spreads _ : @xmath11 corresponding to multiplicative spreads between ( normalized ) xibor rates and ( normalized ) simply compounded ois spot rates . the multiplicative spreads @xmath12 can be directly inferred from the quoted xibor and ois rates . indeed , the numerator of is determined by the xibor rate quoted on the market , while the quantity appearing in the denominator can be bootstrapped from quoted ois rates , as mentioned above . in the post - crisis environment , the quantities @xmath12 are usually greater than one and increasing with respect to the tenor s length @xmath13 . neglecting liquidity issues , this is related to the fact that xibor rates embed the risk that the average credit quality of the banks included in the xibor panel deteriorates over the term of the loan , while ois rates reflect the average credit quality of a newly refreshed xibor panel ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . as will be shown below , a key feature of our modeling framework is the facility of generating multiplicative spreads satisfying such requirements . in comparison to additive spreads ( as considered for instance in @xcite ) , multiplicative spreads admit a natural economic interpretation in a multiple curve setting and , as shown in the following sections , represent a convenient modeling quantity in relation with affine processes . referring to ( * ? ? ? * appendix b ) for full details , xibor rates can be associated with artificial risky bond prices @xmath14 , so that @xmath15 , for @xmath16 . if risky bonds are interpreted as bonds of a foreign economy , with @xmath14 representing the price ( in units of the foreign currency ) of a foreign zero - coupon bond , and ois bonds are interpreted as domestic bonds , then the quantity @xmath12 corresponds to the _ forward exchange premium _ between the domestic and the foreign economy over the period @xmath17 $ ] . in this sense , the multiplicative spread @xmath12 can be regarded as a market expectation ( at date @xmath1 ) of the riskiness of the xibor panel over the period @xmath17 $ ] . related foreign exchange analogies have been proposed in @xcite and @xcite . let us now make precise the financial market considered in this paper . among all financial contracts written on xibor rates , forward rate agreements ( fra ) can be rightfully considered as the basic building blocks , due to the simplicity of their payoff and to the fact that all linear interest rate derivatives ( such as interest rate swaps and basis swaps ) can be represented as portfolios of fras . as usually done in the literature , we consider standard `` textbook '' fras , in contrast to the cash - settled fras traded in the market ( compare with ( * ? ? ? * remark 1.3 ) ) . while the payoff of market fras is non - linear , the discrepancy between the two versions of fras is typically negligible for practical purposes , as documented in @xcite . motivated by the above observation , we shall consider a general financial market consisting of the following families of _ basic traded assets _ , with @xmath18 denoting a fixed time horizon : * ois zero - coupon bonds for all maturities @xmath19 $ ] ; * fra contracts for all maturities @xmath19 $ ] and for all tenors @xmath4 . note that , differently from the pre - crisis single - curve setting , fra contracts have to be considered on top of ois bonds since they can not be perfectly replicated by the latter any longer , due to the discrepancy between xibor rates @xmath20 and simply compounded ois rates @xmath21 . moreover , ois bonds play a particularly important role in collateralized transactions . indeed , the collateral rate adopted in collateralized transactions in interest rate markets is typically specified as the ois short rate and , hence , ois bonds represent the natural discount factors for the valuation of interest rate products ( see , e.g. , @xcite and ( * ? ? ? * appendix a ) ) . we denote by @xmath22 the price at date @xmath1 of a fra contract starting at date @xmath9 with maturity @xmath23 , rate @xmath24 and unitary notional , for @xmath25 and @xmath16 . we denote by @xmath26 the corresponding _ fair fra rate _ , i.e. , the rate @xmath27 fixed at date @xmath1 satisfying @xmath28 . we say that a fra contract written at @xmath1 is _ fair _ if its rate @xmath27 is set equal to @xmath26 , i.e. , if the price of the fra contract at the inception date @xmath1 is zero . extending definition of the spot multiplicative spread , we define ( forward ) _ multiplicative spreads _ @xmath29 , for @xmath25 and @xmath16 , by @xmath30 multiplicative spreads of the form have been first introduced in @xcite and further considered as main modeling quantities in @xcite ( see also @xcite ) . we refer to ( * ? ? ? * appendix b ) for the interpretation of the forward multiplicative spread @xmath29 in terms of the foreign exchange analogy introduced at the end of section [ sec : rates ] . a first and fundamental issue is the absence of arbitrage in the financial market composed by the basic traded assets introduced above . to this end , we let @xmath31 be a measurable space endowed with a right - continuous filtration @xmath32 and formulate the following definition . [ def : couple ] let @xmath33 be a probability measure on @xmath31 and @xmath34 a strictly positive adapted process with @xmath35 . we say that @xmath36 is a _ numraire - martingale measure couple _ if the @xmath37-discounted price of every basic traded asset is a martingale on @xmath38 . in other words , if @xmath36 is a numraire - martingale measure couple , the price of every ois zero - coupon bond and fra contract is a @xmath33-martingale when discounted with respect to the numraire process @xmath37 . definition [ def : couple ] is in the spirit of @xcite , where the authors consider term structure models generated by a numraire - martingale measure couple in the above sense . note that we do not assume that @xmath37 is a traded asset and it can therefore be interpreted as a state - price density process when @xmath39 corresponds to the physical probability measure ( compare with @xcite ) . in the present paper , we shall work under the following standing assumption . [ ass : couple ] there exists a numraire - martingale measure couple @xmath36 . in particular , assumption [ ass : couple ] suffices to exclude the existence of arbitrage profits , in the sense of _ no asymptotic free lunch with vanishing risk _ ( naflvr , see @xcite ) , in the large financial market composed by all basic traded assets , i.e. , by all ois zero - coupon bonds and fra contracts . [ rem : ois_num ] in the literature on multiple curves , the numraire is typically chosen to be the ois bank account and @xmath33 is the corresponding ( spot ) martingale measure . while this choice of @xmath36 will be considered in detail in section [ sec : short_rate ] , we want to point out that our framework is not limited to this specification and allows to consider several alternative settings , depending on the choice of the numraire - martingale measure couple ( see section [ sec : aff_model ] below ) . for the moment , we just think of the couple @xmath36 in abstract and general terms . assumption [ ass : couple ] implies that the arbitrage - free price of every basic traded asset can be computed by taking the conditional @xmath33-expectation of its @xmath37-discounted payoff , similarly as in the classical risk - neutral valuation paradigm is the ois bank account and @xmath33 the corresponding martingale measure , as considered in remark [ rem : ois_num ] , computing the price of a derivative by taking the conditional @xmath33-expectation of its @xmath37-discounted payoff corresponds to computing its _ clean price _ , i.e. , neglecting counterparty risk and assuming a funding rate equal to the ois rate ( compare also with the discussion in ( * ? ? ? * appendix a ) ) . ] . throughout the paper , unless explicitly indicated , expectations are taken under the measure @xmath33 , while the measure @xmath40 denotes the @xmath9-forward measure with density @xmath41 , for @xmath19 $ ] . we can now state the following proposition , which is a simple consequence of definition [ def : couple ] ( for completeness , the proof is given in appendix [ app : proof_prop ] ) . [ prop : bonds_spreads ] suppose that assumption [ ass : couple ] holds . then the following hold : 1 . ois zero - coupon bond prices satisfy @xmath42 , \qquad \text { for all } 0\leq t\leq t\leq { \mathbb{t}};\ ] ] 2 . for every @xmath16 , the fair fra rate satisfies @xmath43 , \qquad \text { for all } 0\leq t\leq t\leq { \mathbb{t}};\ ] ] 3 . for every @xmath16 , the multiplicative spread satisfies @xmath44 , \qquad \text { for all } 0\leq t\leq t\leq { \mathbb{t}}.\ ] ] from the modeling perspective , proposition [ prop : bonds_spreads ] together with representation implies that , in order to give an arbitrage - free description of the financial market composed by all ois zero - coupon bonds and fra contracts , it suffices to model the numraire process @xmath37 together with the spot multiplicative spreads @xmath45 , under some reference measure @xmath33 . in the next section , this will be achieved in a flexible and tractable way by letting the numraire process and the spot multiplicative spreads be driven by a common underlying affine process . in this section we develop a general framework based on affine processes for modeling multiple curves . we first recall in section [ sec : aff_gen ] some general results on affine processes , mainly relying on @xcite . in section [ sec : aff_model ] , we provide the general definition of an affine multi - curve model with respect to an abstract numraire - martingale measure couple and derive its fundamental properties . this general setup is then specialized in section [ sec : short_rate ] to the typical setting where the numraire is given by the ois bank account modeled via a short rate . section [ sec : relations ] shows how our setup relates to the existing multi - curve models driven by affine processes . let @xmath46 be a finite - dimensional real vector space with associated scalar product @xmath47 . we denote by @xmath48 a non - empty closed convex subset of @xmath46 , which will serve as state space for the stochastic process to be introduced below , endowed with the borel @xmath49-algebra @xmath50 . typical choices for the state space are represented by @xmath51 or combinations thereof , for some @xmath52 , where @xmath53 denotes the cone of symmetric @xmath54 positive semidefinite matrices . and @xmath55 , the scalar product is given by @xmath56 $ ] , with @xmath57 $ ] being the trace operator . ] on a filtered probability space @xmath58 satisfying the usual conditions , we introduce a stochastic process @xmath59 , starting from an initial value @xmath60 belonging to the interior of @xmath48 . the process @xmath61 is assumed to be an adapted , time - homogeneous and conservative markov process taking values in @xmath48 and we denote by @xmath62;t\in[0,{\mathbb{t}}]\}$ ] the family of its transition kernels . to the process @xmath61 we associate the sets @xmath63<+\infty , \text { for all } t\in[0,t]\bigr\ } \qquad\text { and } \qquad { \mathfrak{u}}:={\mathfrak{u}}_{\mathbb{t}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] letting @xmath64\times(v+{\ensuremath{\mathsf{i}}}v ) : \zeta\in{\mathfrak{u}}_t\}$ ] , we define as follows the class of affine processes . [ def : affine ] the markov process @xmath65 is said to be _ affine _ if 1 . it is stochastically continuous , i.e. , the transition kernels satisfy @xmath66 weakly on @xmath48 , for every @xmath67\times d$ ] ; 2 . its fourier - laplace transform has exponential affine dependence on the initial state , i.e. , there exist functions @xmath68 and @xmath69 such that , for every initial value @xmath70 and for every @xmath71 , it holds that @xmath72 = \int_de^{\langle u,\xi\rangle}p_t(x , d\xi)=e^{\phi(t , u)+\langle\psi(t , u),x\rangle}.\label{affineproperty}\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ rem : convex_expmom ] 1 . definition [ def : affine ] slightly differs from the usual definition of affine process where the exponential affine form is only assumed to hold on the set of bounded exponentials . indeed , in most theoretical works the definition of affine process only refers to the characteristic function or laplace transform ( for processes with values in a cone ) . then a natural question arises , namely if the exponential affine form can be extended beyond the characteristic function or laplace transform , in our notation to @xmath73 . this important question has been answered positively in @xcite under general assumptions and , therefore , we modified the classical definition . in particular , in view of ( * ? ? ? * lemma 4.2 ) , it holds that @xmath74<+\infty\bigr\ } , \qquad\text { for all } t\in[0,{\mathbb{t}}].\ ] ] 2 . at the expense of greater technicalities , our setup can be extended to affine processes taking values in general ( possibly non - convex ) state spaces . however , the class of affine processes considered in definition [ def : affine ] is sufficiently rich to cover any affine multi - curve model of practical interest . the affine property together with the chapman - kolmogorov equation implies that the functions @xmath75 and @xmath76 have the _ semiflow property _ , i.e. , for every @xmath77 and @xmath78 $ ] with @xmath79 , it holds that @xmath80 the stochastic continuity of the affine process @xmath61 also implies its _ regularity _ , according to ( * ? ? ? * theorem 7 ) ( see also ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.3 ) in the case @xmath81 , for some @xmath82 , and ( * ? ? ? * proposition 3.4 ) in the case @xmath83 ) , in the sense that the derivatives @xmath84 exist and are continuous at @xmath85 . regularity implies that it is possible to differentiate the semiflow relations with respect to @xmath1 and evaluate them at @xmath86 , thus obtaining the following system of generalized riccati odes @xmath87 we state the following result ( see ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.10 ) ) , which will be useful for some specifications of our setup . we refer to @xcite for the notion of differential characteristics of an affine process and we denote by @xmath88 and @xmath89 two real vector spaces . [ mixedstate ] let @xmath90 be an affine process taking values in a state space of the form @xmath91 , with initial value @xmath92 and such that the differential characteristics of @xmath93 only depend on @xmath94 . then there exist functions @xmath95 and @xmath96 such that , for every @xmath97 , it holds that @xmath98=e^{\tilde{\phi}(t , u_1,u_2)+\langle \tilde{\psi}(t , u_1,u_2),x^1\rangle+\langle u_2,x^2\rangle}.\ ] ] typical examples where affine processes satisfying the assumptions of lemma [ mixedstate ] are employed are short rate models ( see section [ sec : short_rate ] ) and affine stochastic volatility models ( see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ? * chapter 5 ) ) . as explained in section [ sec : abstract_setting ] , our general setup assumes the existence of a numraire - martingale measure couple @xmath36 , meaning that the @xmath37-discounted price of every traded asset is a @xmath33-martingale . recall also that we consider as basic traded assets the ois zero - coupon bonds and the fra contracts , for all maturities @xmath19 $ ] and for a finite set of tenors @xmath4 , with @xmath5 , for some @xmath6 . letting @xmath65 be an affine process taking values in a state space @xmath99 under a measure @xmath33 , we are now in a position to give the general definition of an _ affine multi - curve model_. [ def : aff_model ] let @xmath100 be a family of functions @xmath101\rightarrow v$ ] , @xmath102 , such that @xmath103 and @xmath104 , for every @xmath16 and @xmath105 $ ] , and @xmath106 a family of functions @xmath107\rightarrow{\mathbb{r}}$ ] , @xmath102 . we say that the triplet @xmath108 is an _ affine multi - curve model _ if 1 . the logarithm of the numraire process @xmath109 satisfies @xmath110;\ ] ] 2 . the logarithm of the spot multiplicative spreads @xmath111 satisfies @xmath112 \text { and } i=1,\ldots , m.\ ] ] depending on the choice of the numraire - martingale measure couple @xmath36 and of the triplet @xmath108 , different modeling approaches can be obtained from the present general setup . for instance : * if the numraire asset @xmath37 is chosen to be the ois bank account , @xmath33 is the corresponding ( spot ) martingale measure and @xmath37 is modeled via an ois short rate @xmath113 , then definition [ def : aff_model ] embeds an affine framework for modeling the ois short rate and the multiplicative spreads . this specification will be analyzed in detail in section [ sec : short_rate ] ( compare also with section [ sec : rel_short_rate ] ) ; * if the ois zero - coupon bond with maturity @xmath114 is chosen as numraire and @xmath33 is the @xmath114-forward measure , then definition [ def : aff_model ] yields an extension of the affine libor model with multiple curves recently introduced in @xcite ( see section [ sec : rel_affinelibor ] ) ; * if @xmath33 is the physical probability measure and @xmath37 is chosen as the _ growth - optimal portfolio _ ( in the spirit of the _ benchmark approach _ to interest rate modeling , see , e.g. , @xcite and , for a general account of the benchmark approach , @xcite ) or , more generally , as a _ state - price density _ ( as recently considered in the rational multi - curve models @xcite ) , then definition [ def : aff_model ] leads to a _ real - world _ approach to the modeling of multiple curves . affine multi - curve models lead to a tractable structure for ois bond prices and multiplicative spreads . more precisely , affine multi - curve models can be characterized via the exponentially affine form of ois bond prices and spreads . to this end , let us give the following definition . [ def : qaffinemodel ] the affine process @xmath61 is said to _ generate exponentially affine ois bond prices and spreads _ if 1 . the @xmath37-discounted prices of ois zero - coupon bonds satisfy @xmath115 for some functions @xmath116\times[0,{\mathbb{t}}]\rightarrow{\mathbb{r}}$ ] and @xmath117\times[0,{\mathbb{t}}]\rightarrow v$ ] , and 2 . the multiplicative spreads satisfy @xmath118 for some functions @xmath119\times[0,{\mathbb{t}}]\rightarrow{\mathbb{r}}$ ] and @xmath120\times[0,{\mathbb{t}}]\rightarrow v$ ] , for all @xmath16 . the following proposition provides the announced characterization of affine multi - curve models , thereby showing that definition [ def : aff_model ] is equivalent to definition [ def : qaffinemodel ] . [ prop : qaffinecharacterization ] let @xmath61 be an affine process . then the following hold : 1 . if @xmath108 is an affine multi - curve model , then @xmath61 generates exponentially affine ois bond prices and spreads and the functions @xmath121 , @xmath122 , @xmath102 , appearing in - are given by @xmath123 for all @xmath25 and @xmath16 , where @xmath75 and @xmath76 denote the characteristic exponents of @xmath61 as in definition [ def : affine ] ; 2 . conversely , if @xmath61 generates exponentially affine ois bond prices and spreads , then @xmath108 is an affine multi - curve model , where the functions @xmath124 , @xmath102 , are given by @xmath125 for all @xmath105 $ ] and @xmath16 . suppose first that @xmath108 is an affine multi - curve model . then , in view of proposition [ prop : bonds_spreads ] , ois bond prices are given by @xmath126 = { \mathbb{e}}\left[e^{v_0(t)+\langle u_0(t),x_t\rangle}\bigr|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right ] = e^{v_0(t)+\phi(t - t , u_0(t))+\langle\psi(t - t , u_0(t)),x_t\rangle},\ ] ] where the last equality follows from together with the assumption that @xmath127 ( see also remark [ rem : convex_expmom ] ) . this proves that representation holds with the functions @xmath128 and @xmath129 being given as in . similarly , proposition [ prop : bonds_spreads ] together with the assumption that @xmath130 , for every @xmath19 $ ] and @xmath16 , implies that the multiplicative spreads satisfy @xmath131 = { \mathbb{e}}^{{\mathbb{q}}^t}\left[e^{v_i(t)+\langle u_i(t),x_t\rangle}\bigr|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right ] \\ & = \frac{b_t}{b(t , t)}{\mathbb{e}}\left[e^{v_i(t)+v_0(t)+\langle u_i(t)+u_0(t),x_t\rangle}\bigr|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right ] \\ & = e^{v_i(t)+\phi(t - t , u_i(t)+u_0(t))-\phi(t - t , u_0(t))+\langle\psi(t - t , u_i(t)+u_0(t))-\psi(t - t , u_0(t)),x_t\rangle},\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus showing that representation holds with the functions @xmath121 and @xmath122 being given as in . conversely , suppose that @xmath61 generates exponentially affine ois bond prices and spreads . then , for every @xmath105 $ ] , letting @xmath132 in - and recalling that @xmath133 , it follows that @xmath134 defining the functions @xmath135 and @xmath136 as in , this proves that representations - hold true . it remains to prove that @xmath137 and @xmath138 , for every @xmath19 $ ] and @xmath16 . this follows from proposition [ prop : bonds_spreads ] , since @xmath139 & = e^{-v_0(t)}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{1}{b_t}\right ] = e^{-v_0(t)}b(0,t ) < + \infty , \\ { \mathbb{e}}\left[e^{\langle u_i(t)+u_0(t),x_t\rangle}\right ] & = e^{-v_i(t)-v_0(t)}{\mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{s^{\delta_i}(t , t)}{b_t}\right ] = e^{-v_i(t)-v_0(t)}b(0,t){\mathbb{e}}^{{\mathbb{q}}^t}[s^{\delta_i}(t , t ) ] \\ & = e^{-v_i(t)-v_0(t)}b(0,t)s^{\delta_i}(0,t ) < + \infty.\end{aligned}\ ] ] together with remark [ rem : convex_expmom ] , this implies that @xmath127 and @xmath130 , for all @xmath19 $ ] and @xmath16 , thus proving that @xmath108 is an affine multi - curve model . in particular , proposition [ prop : qaffinecharacterization ] implies that affine multi - curve models admit explicit valuation formulas for all linear interest rate derivatives ( i.e. , fra contracts , interest rate swaps , overnight swaps and basis swaps ) , since their prices can always be expressed in terms of ois bond prices and multiplicative spreads , as detailed in appendix [ sec : noopt ] . a major issue when modeling multiple curves consists in characterizing when the multiplicative spreads are greater than one and ordered with respect to the tenor s length , as it is the case in typical market scenarios . to this effect , we can establish the following result ( compare also with ( * ? ? ? * corollary 3.17 ) ) . [ prop : x0y ] let @xmath108 be an affine multi - curve model . suppose that the process @xmath61 is of the form @xmath140 and takes values in a state space @xmath141 , with @xmath142 a cone . suppose that @xmath143 , for all @xmath105 $ ] and that the functions @xmath135 are of the form @xmath144 with @xmath145\rightarrow c_z^*$ ] , where @xmath146 denotes the dual cone of @xmath142 , for all @xmath16 . then @xmath147 for all @xmath148 and @xmath149 . moreover , if in addition @xmath150,\ ] ] with @xmath151 denoting the partial order on @xmath146 , then it holds that @xmath152 the assertion is a direct consequence of proposition [ prop : bonds_spreads ] , stating that the process @xmath153 is a @xmath40-martingale , for every @xmath16 and @xmath19 $ ] . it thus satisfies @xmath154={\mathbb{e}}^{{\mathbb{q}}^t}[e^{v_i(t ) + \langle w_i(t ) , z_t \rangle}|{\mathcal{f}}_t ] , \qquad \text { for all } t\in[0,{\mathbb{t}}].\ ] ] besides the modeling flexibility and tractability ensured by affine processes , this facility of generating spreads which are greater than one and ordered with respect to the tenor s length represents one of the main advantages of specifying multiplicative spreads via . the family of functions @xmath106 appearing in definition [ def : aff_model ] can always be chosen in such a way to automatically achieve an exact fit to the initially observed term structures of ois bond prices and multiplicative spreads . we denote by @xmath155 the price of an ois zero - coupon bond with maturity @xmath9 observed on the market at the initial date @xmath86 and , similarly , by @xmath156 the multiplicative spread of tenor @xmath13 observed on the market at @xmath86 , for @xmath16 and @xmath19 $ ] . we say that _ an exact fit to the initially observed term structures is achieved _ if @xmath157 \text { and } i=1,\ldots , m.\ ] ] the following proposition provides a necessary and sufficient condition for an exact fit to hold . if @xmath108 is an affine multi - curve model , we denote by @xmath158 and @xmath159 , for @xmath25 and @xmath16 , the theoretical bond prices and spreads computed according to the model @xmath160 via - , i.e. , with all the functions @xmath136 , @xmath102 , set equal to zero . [ prop : fitting ] an affine multi - curve model @xmath108 achieves an exact fit to the initially observed term structures if and only if the family of functions @xmath106 satisfies @xmath161,\\ v_i(t ) & = \log s^{m,\delta_i}(0,t ) - \log s^{0,\delta_i}(0,t ) , & \qquad & \text { for all } t\in[0,{\mathbb{t } } ] \text { and } i=1,\ldots , m,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath162 and @xmath163 denoting the theoretical bond prices and spreads computed according to the affine multi - curve model @xmath160 via - , for @xmath105 $ ] and @xmath16 . the claim follows by noting that , for all @xmath105 $ ] and @xmath16 , @xmath164 = e^{v_0(t)}{\mathbb{e}}[e^{\langle u_0(t),x_t\rangle } ] = e^{v_0(t)}b^0(0,t ) , \\ s^{\delta_i}(0,t ) & = { \mathbb{e}}^{{\mathbb{q}}^t}[s^{\delta_i}(t , t ) ] = e^{v_i(t)}{\mathbb{e}}^{{\mathbb{q}}^t}[e^{\langle u_i(t),x_t\rangle } ] = e^{v_i(t)}s^{0,\delta_i}(0,t),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where in the last equality we used the fact that the density of the @xmath1-forward measure @xmath165 is the same for both models @xmath108 and @xmath160 . indeed , for every @xmath105 $ ] , it holds that @xmath166 } = \frac{e^{\langle u_0(t),x_t\rangle}}{{\mathbb{e}}[e^{\langle u_0(t),x_t\rangle } ] } = \frac{1}{b^0_tb^0(0,t)},\ ] ] with @xmath167 denoting the numraire process corresponding to the model @xmath160 . we have so far introduced a general setup based on affine processes for modeling multiple curves . as outlined in the previous subsection , depending on the choice of the numraire - martingale measure couple @xmath36 , different modeling approaches can be obtained from definition [ def : aff_model ] . we now specialize the above general framework to a classical setting where the numraire is given by the ois bank account , defined with respect to the ( risk - free ) ois short rate process @xmath113 , and @xmath33 is the associated ( spot ) martingale measure . more specifically , in this subsection we shall work under the following assumption . [ ass : short_rate ] the numraire @xmath34 satisfies @xmath168 , for all @xmath105 $ ] , where @xmath113 is a real - valued adapted process denoting the ois short rate . the probability measure @xmath33 is such that the @xmath37-discounted price of every basic traded asset is a @xmath33-martingale . throughout this subsection , let @xmath65 be an affine process taking values in @xmath169 . we also introduce the auxiliary affine process @xmath170 defined by @xmath171 , for @xmath105 $ ] , and taking values in @xmath172 . the set @xmath173 is defined as in with respect to @xmath174 . we specialize definition [ def : aff_model ] as follows . [ def : short_rate_model ] let @xmath175 , @xmath176 \to \mathbb{r}$ ] such that @xmath177 , @xmath178 and @xmath179 a family of functions @xmath180 \to \mathbb{r}$ ] , @xmath181 . the tuple @xmath182 is said to be an _ affine short rate multi - curve model _ if @xmath183 is an affine multi - curve model in the sense of definition [ def : aff_model ] , where @xmath184 , \\ v_i(t ) & : = c_i(t ) & \text{and } \quad & u_i(t ) : = ( \gamma_i,0 ) , & \qquad&\text { for all } t\in[0,{\mathbb{t } } ] \text { and } i=1,\ldots , m.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if assumption [ ass : short_rate ] holds , so that @xmath185 , assuming that a tuple @xmath182 is an affine short rate multi - curve model in the sense of definition [ def : short_rate_model ] is equivalent to letting the ois short rate @xmath186 and the spot multiplicative spreads @xmath12 be specified as follows : @xmath187 , \label{eq : short_rate_1}\\ \log s^{\delta_i}(t , t ) & = c_i(t ) + \langle\gamma_i , x_t\rangle , & \text { for all } & t\in[0,{\mathbb{t } } ] \text { and } i=1,\ldots , m . \label{eq : short_rate_2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that definition [ def : short_rate_model ] implicitly requires ( via definition [ def : aff_model ] ) that the parameters @xmath188 and @xmath189 satisfy @xmath190 , for all @xmath102 , with @xmath191 . if the function @xmath192 is chosen to be constant and @xmath193 and @xmath194 set to @xmath195 , definition [ def : short_rate_model ] reduces to a classical ( i.e. , single - curve ) time - homogeneous affine short rate model . by additionally allowing @xmath192 and also @xmath193 to be deterministic functions we introduce a time - inhomogeneity which in turn enables a perfect fit to the initial term structures ( see proposition [ prop : deterministicshiftcharacterization ] below ) . definition [ def : short_rate_model ] thus already incorporates _ deterministic shift extended models _ first introduced in @xcite in the single - curve setting and recently taken up in @xcite in the multi - curve setting ( cf . section [ sec : rel_short_rate ] for the relation between @xcite and the present setting ) . in definition [ def : short_rate_model ] , the ois bank account is specified via a short rate modeled as in . by analogy , multiplicative spreads can also be specified via an instantaneous _ short spread rate _ , similarly as in ( * ? ? ? * remark 3.19 ) . this can be achieved by letting the affine process @xmath61 be of the form @xmath196 , where @xmath197 is an affine process on some state space @xmath198 and @xmath199 , with @xmath200 being an affine function , for all @xmath16 . the coefficients @xmath179 and @xmath189 are chosen as @xmath201 and @xmath202 , for all @xmath16 , with @xmath203 being the canonical basis of @xmath204 . the spot multiplicative spreads admit then the representation @xmath205 \text { and } i=1,\ldots , m,\ ] ] where the process @xmath206 can be interpreted as a short spread rate , for @xmath16 . similarly as in the case of general affine multi - curve models , affine short rate multi - curve models admit an equivalent characterization in terms of the structure of ois bond prices and spreads . more specifically , we can establish the following result , which specializes proposition [ prop : qaffinecharacterization ] . let @xmath61 be an affine process and suppose that assumption [ ass : short_rate ] holds . then the following hold : 1 . if @xmath182 is an affine short rate multi - curve model , then @xmath61 generates exponentially affine ois bond prices and spreads , in the sense that @xmath207 where the functions @xmath208 , @xmath209 , @xmath102 , are given by @xmath210 for all @xmath211 and @xmath16 , with @xmath212 and @xmath213 denoting the characteristic exponents of the affine process @xmath214 as in lemma [ mixedstate ] ; 2 . conversely , if ois bond prices and spreads admit the representation for some functions @xmath208 , @xmath209 , @xmath102 , with @xmath215 and @xmath216 differentiable , for all @xmath105 $ ] , then @xmath182 is an affine short rate model , where , for all @xmath16 , @xmath217 noting that the affine process @xmath214 satisfies the assumptions of lemma [ mixedstate ] , part ( i ) easily follows from definition [ def : short_rate_model ] together with proposition [ prop : qaffinecharacterization ] . conversely , if ois bond prices and spreads admit the representation with respect to some differentiable functions @xmath208 and @xmath209 , @xmath102 , then the instantaneous ois forward rate is given by @xmath218 so that the ois short rate @xmath186 satisfies @xmath219.\ ] ] representations - then follow by letting @xmath220 and @xmath221 , for all @xmath16 . finally , the condition @xmath190 , for all @xmath102 , with @xmath191 , follows by the same arguments used in the last part of the proof of proposition [ prop : qaffinecharacterization ] . in view of proposition [ prop : x0y ] , multiplicative spreads greater than one and ordered with respect to the tenor s length can be easily generated by affine short rate multi - curve models . in the current market environment , negative rates have been observed to coexist with spreads which are strictly greater than one and ordered with respect to the tenor s length . this market scenario can be easily captured by letting the affine process @xmath61 be of the form @xmath140 and take value in a state space of the form @xmath222 , for some @xmath223 and where @xmath142 is a cone . if @xmath192 takes values in @xmath224 , @xmath225 and the assumptions of proposition [ prop : x0y ] are satisfied , then spreads will be greater than one and ordered , while the ois short rate will not be restricted to positive values only . similarly to proposition [ prop : fitting ] , we can obtain a necessary and sufficient condition to achieve an exact fit to the initially observed term structures . let us denote by @xmath158 and @xmath159 the bond prices and spreads computed according to the model @xmath226 . moreover , we denote by @xmath227 and @xmath228 the initially observed term structures of ois bond prices and spreads . we also define the corresponding ois forward rates by @xmath229 the following result is a direct consequence of the above definitions together with proposition [ prop : fitting ] . [ prop : deterministicshiftcharacterization ] suppose that assumption [ ass : short_rate ] holds . then an affine short rate multi - curve model @xmath182 achieves an exact fit to the initially observed term structures if and only if @xmath230,\\ c_i(t ) & = \log s^{m,\delta_i}(0,t ) - \log s^{0,\delta_i}(0,t ) , & \qquad & \text { for all } t\in[0,{\mathbb{t } } ] \text { and } i=1,\ldots , m.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in view of proposition [ prop : deterministicshiftcharacterization ] , assuming that the spreads @xmath159 generated by the model @xmath226 are greater than one and ordered , it then easily follows that 1 . for any @xmath231 , if @xmath232 , for all @xmath233 $ ] , then @xmath234 , for all @xmath25 ; 2 . for any @xmath235 with @xmath236 , if @xmath237,\ ] ] then @xmath238 , for all @xmath25 . in this section , we discuss how our setup relates to several multiple curve models based on affine processes that have been recently proposed in the literature . we show that all the existing approaches we are aware of can be recovered as special cases of our framework . as mentioned in the introduction , short rate models based on affine processes have been proposed for modeling multiple curves , see @xcite . a general framework encompassing all the models introduced in these papers has been recently provided in ( * ? ? ? * chapter 2 ) . in that work , the authors assume that the numraire is given as usual by the ois bank account , modeled via a short rate @xmath113 , with a corresponding martingale measure @xmath33 . considering for simplicity of presentation a single tenor @xmath3 , spot libor rates @xmath0 are then specified by @xmath239 where @xmath240 denotes the price at date @xmath1 of an artificial risky bond with maturity @xmath241 . note that risky bonds are only introduced as a modeling tool , their riskiness being referred to the interbank market , and do not represent real traded assets . by analogy to the short rate approach in a classical single - curve setting , ois bond prices and risky bond prices are assumed to be given by @xmath242 \quad\text { and } \quad b^{\delta}(t , t ) = \mathbb{e}\left[e^{-\int_t^t(r_u+s_u)du}\bigr|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right],\ ] ] for all @xmath25 , where @xmath243 denotes an instantaneous spread . the ois short rate @xmath186 and the spread @xmath244 are modeled as affine functions of a common affine process @xmath65 taking values on some state space @xmath245 ( @xcite also consider the case of a wishart process @xmath61 and deterministic shift extensions , meaning that the constant part of the affine function is actually a deterministic function in time ) . this framework can be regarded as a special case of our affine short rate setup introduced in section [ sec : short_rate ] . indeed , it suffices to observe that in the present setting the spot multiplicative spreads can be represented as @xmath246}{\mathbb{e}\left[e^{-\int_t^{t+\delta}(r_u+s_u)du}\bigr|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right ] } = c_{\delta}(t ) + \langle \gamma_{\delta},x_t\rangle,\ ] ] where @xmath247\rightarrow{\mathbb{r}}$ ] and @xmath248 are determined in terms of the characteristic exponents of @xmath61 and the specification of the affine functions for @xmath186 and @xmath244 . this shows that representations - hold with respect to the underlying affine process @xmath61 . similar considerations allow to recover the gaussian exponentially quadratic model recently proposed in @xcite . since our spot multiplicative spread is an observable quantity , unlike the instantaneous spread @xmath244 , it seems to us more natural to define affine short rate multi - curve models directly with respect to spot multiplicative spreads as in definition [ def : short_rate_model ] . the general affine multi - curve setup of section [ sec : aff_model ] allows to recover a generalization of the model recently introduced in @xcite , which extends to a multi - curve setting the affine libor model originally proposed in @xcite . in this setting , the numraire - martingale measure couple @xmath249 is given by the ois zero - coupon bond with maturity @xmath114 and the corresponding @xmath114-forward measure , i.e. , @xmath250 . we explicitly indicate this measure in the expectations below . as in section [ sec : aff_model ] , consider an affine process @xmath251 ( under @xmath252 ) taking values in @xmath253 and denote by @xmath254 the @xmath252-martingale defined by @xmath255 $ ] , for @xmath105 $ ] . for each tenor @xmath3 traded in the market , @xcite consider a finite collection of ordered maturities @xmath256 . for any tenor @xmath3 and @xmath257 , the multiplicative spread @xmath258 is given by @xmath259,\ ] ] where @xmath260 is a sequence in @xmath261 such that @xmath262 , for all @xmath263 , in order to ensure non - negative ois forward rates , and @xmath264 is a sequence in @xmath261 such that @xmath265 , for all @xmath263 , in order to ensure that spreads are greater than one . by its own nature , the model of @xcite is formulated with respect to a finite collection of maturities . however , a continuous extension can be obtained by considering a function @xmath266\rightarrow{\mathfrak{u}}$ ] such that @xmath267 and a function @xmath268\times \mathbb{r}_+ \rightarrow{\mathfrak{u}}$ ] such that @xmath269 , for all @xmath263 and @xmath3 . the idea of a continuous extension first appeared ( in a single - curve setting ) in the unpublished note @xcite and , after the appearance of the present paper , has been further developed in the multi - curve setting in @xcite . in analogy to ( * section 6 ) , let ois bond prices be given as follows : @xmath270 with @xmath271 $ ] . in line with equation , we then model @xmath272 by @xmath273 with @xmath274 $ ] . observe that , in order to ensure that @xmath275 , for all @xmath25 and @xmath3 , it suffices to require that @xmath276 for all @xmath19 $ ] and @xmath3 . similarly , order relations among multiplicative spreads @xmath272 associated to different tenors can be obtained by imposing suitable requirements on the function @xmath277 . recalling that @xmath133 , for all @xmath105 $ ] , representation together with the affine property of @xmath61 implies that the numraire process satisfies @xmath278,\ ] ] where @xmath75 and @xmath76 denote the characteristic exponents of @xmath61 . similarly , representation implies that the spot multiplicative spreads satisfy , for all @xmath105 $ ] and @xmath3 , @xmath279 the model - thus represents a special case of our general affine multi - curve framework . indeed , representations - follow by letting , for all @xmath105 $ ] and @xmath16 , @xmath280 moreover , in view of ( * ? ? ? * lemma 4.3 ) , it holds that @xmath127 and @xmath130 , for all @xmath19 $ ] and @xmath16 , thus showing that this version of the affine libor model with multiple curves can be recovered as a special case of definition [ def : aff_model ] . in our view , our general framework presents significant advantages with respect to the model of @xcite , not only due to the flexibility in the choice of the numraire - martingale measure couple and of affine processes on general convex state spaces . indeed , even under the assumption that the couple @xmath36 is specified in terms of the ois bond with maturity @xmath114 together with the corresponding @xmath114-forward measure as above , our definition [ def : aff_model ] allows for greater generality . this can be seen by noting that , given a family of functions @xmath281 as in definition [ def : aff_model ] , it is not always possible to find a couple of functions @xmath282\times[0,{\mathbb{t}}]\times{\mathbb{r}}_+\rightarrow{\mathfrak{u}}\times{\mathfrak{u}}$ ] such that holds . moreover , as shown in proposition [ prop : fitting ] , our specification - always allows for an automatic fit to the initially observed term structures . in contrast , in @xcite this is only possible under some conditions , notably that the initial ois term structure is decreasing with respect to maturity together with the finiteness of suitable exponential moments of the driving process . furthermore , while in our specification the initial term structures univocally determine the family of functions @xmath283 , in @xcite this is not the case , so that all model parameters have to be jointly determined by fitting the initial term structures and by calibration to market data . multi - curve models based on affine processes have been briefly mentioned in ( * ? ? ? * section 5.3 ) as a simple example of _ hjm - type multiple yield curve models_. the affine specification proposed in @xcite represents a special case of the general setup developed in the present paper . indeed , an affine multi - curve model in the sense of definition [ def : aff_model ] belongs to the family of risk neutral hjm - type multiple yield curve models considered in @xcite only if @xmath284 is absolutely continuous . more specifically , the affine specification considered in @xcite ( see ( * ? ? ? * definition 5.3 ) ) represents a special case of our definition [ def : short_rate_model ] when @xmath192 and @xmath193 are chosen to be constant . for clarity of notation , let us denote all the ingredients appearing in ( * ? ? ? * definition 5.3 ) with fractur letters . then ( * ? ? ? * definition 5.3 ) can be embedded into definition [ def : short_rate_model ] by setting @xmath285 , @xmath286 and @xmath287 , for all @xmath181 . conversely , in the special case where @xmath192 and @xmath193 are constant , definition [ def : short_rate_model ] can be embedded into ( * ? ? ? * definition 5.3 ) by letting @xmath288 , @xmath289 , @xmath290 and @xmath291 , for all @xmath292 and @xmath16 . we now show that affine multi - curve models , in the sense of definition [ def : aff_model ] , lead to tractable general valuation formulae for caplets and swaptions . we compute _ clean prices _ and follow the pricing approach outlined in ( * ? ? ? * appendix a ) , in particular assuming that the collateral account is given by the numraire asset . for simplicity of presentation , we shall consider a fixed maturity @xmath293 and assume that @xmath108 is an affine multi - curve model in the sense of definition [ def : aff_model ] . in the present affine setting , caplets can be easily priced by means of fourier techniques . as a preliminary , let @xmath294 and define the stochastic process @xmath295}$ ] by @xmath296 where the second equality follows from proposition [ prop : qaffinecharacterization ] . we denote by @xmath297 the set @xmath298<+\infty\right\}^{\circ},\ ] ] and introduce the strip of complex numbers @xmath299 . for @xmath300 , we can compute the following expectation , which we call _ modified moment generating function _ of @xmath301 : @xmath302}\\ & = \exp((1- { \ensuremath{\mathsf{i}}}\zeta)(v_0(t+\delta_i)+\phi(\delta_i , u_0(t+\delta_i)))+ { \ensuremath{\mathsf{i}}}\zeta(v_i(t)+v_0(t)))\\ & \quad \times{\mathbb{e}^{}\left[\left.e^{\langle ( 1- { \ensuremath{\mathsf{i}}}\zeta ) \psi(\delta_i , u_0(t+\delta_i))+ { \ensuremath{\mathsf{i}}}\zeta ( u_i(t)+ u_0(t ) ) , x_t\rangle}\right|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right]}\\ & = \exp((1- { \ensuremath{\mathsf{i}}}\zeta)(v_0(t+\delta_i)+\phi(\delta_i , u_0(t+\delta_i)))+ { \ensuremath{\mathsf{i}}}\zeta(v_i(t)+v_0(t)))\\ & \quad \times \exp(\phi(t - t , ( 1- { \ensuremath{\mathsf{i}}}\zeta ) \psi(\delta_i , u_0(t+\delta_i))+ { \ensuremath{\mathsf{i}}}\zeta ( u_i(t)+ u_0(t))))\\ & \quad \times \exp(\langle\psi(t - t , ( 1- { \ensuremath{\mathsf{i}}}\zeta ) \psi(\delta_i , u_0(t+\delta_i))+ { \ensuremath{\mathsf{i}}}\zeta ( u_i(t)+ u_0(t))),x_t\rangle ) . \label{cfchi } \end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the case of an affine short rate multi - curve model as of definition [ def : short_rate_model ] , expression becomes @xmath303 similarly , expression becomes @xmath304 the sets @xmath297 and @xmath305 depend on the specific choice of the driving process @xmath61 . by relying on ( * theorem 5.1 ) , we now provide a general caplet pricing formula , which is valid for any choice of the underlying affine process @xmath61 and for different choices of the contour of integration . in particular , the next result highlights the tractability of our framework : caplets can be priced by means of univariate fourier integrals . in turn , this implies that a calibration may be obtained with a reasonable amount of computational effort ( which may be further reduced by means of an application of an fft algorithm ) . [ prop : capletbasicaffine ] let @xmath306 , @xmath307 , @xmath308 and assume that @xmath309 . then the price at date @xmath1 of a caplet with notional @xmath310 , reset date @xmath9 and payoff @xmath311 at the settlement date @xmath23 is given by @xmath312 where @xmath313 is given in and @xmath314 is given by @xmath315 as shown in appendix [ sec : option ] , the price of a caplet can be expressed as @xmath316}\\ & = n\,{\mathbb{e}^{}\left[\left.\frac{b_t}{b_t}b(t , t+\delta_i)\left(s^{\delta_i}(t , t)b(t , t+\delta_i)^{-1}-(1+\delta_i k)\right)^+\right|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right]}\\ & = n\,{\mathbb{e}^{}\left[\left.\frac{b_t}{b_t}b(t , t+\delta_i)\left(e^{\mathcal{y}_t}-(1+\delta_i k)\right)^+\right|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right]}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since the modified moment generating function of @xmath301 can be explicitly computed as in , the pricing of a caplet is thus reduced to the pricing of a call option written on an asset whose characteristic function is explicitly known . at this point , a direct application of ( * ? ? ? * theorem 5.1 ) yields the result . note that , in the terminology of ( * ? ? ? * theorem 5.1 ) , the present case corresponds to @xmath317 and @xmath318 , which is an element of @xmath297 by definition [ def : aff_model ] . in the present general setting , swaptions do not admit a closed - form pricing formula . indeed , on the one side , we consider general multi - factor models , so that the jamshidian trick " ( see @xcite ) is not applicable ; on the other side , in a multiple curve setting , a payer ( resp . receiver ) swaption can not be represented as a put ( resp . call ) option on a coupon bond . in this subsection , by relying on fourier methods and along the lines of @xcite , we provide a general analytical approximation which exploits the affine property of our framework . we work in the general setting of section [ sec : aff_model ] , noting that all formulas admit suitable simplifications in the case of affine short - rate multi - curve models . we consider a european payer swaption with maturity @xmath9 , written on a ( payer ) interest rate swap starting at @xmath319 , with payment dates @xmath320 , with @xmath321 for @xmath322 and @xmath294 , with notional @xmath310 . as shown in appendix [ sec : option ] , the value of such a claim at date @xmath1 is given by @xmath323.\ ] ] the general idea underlying our approximation consists in approximating the exercise region by an event defined in terms of an affine function of @xmath324 . more specifically , we have that @xmath325\\ & \geq n\mathbb{e}^{}\left[\frac{b_t}{b_t}\left(\sum_{j=1}^{{\mathcal{n}}}b(t , t_{j-1})s^{\delta_i}(t , t_{j-1})-(1+\delta_i k)b(t , t_j)\right){\mathbf{1}}_{\mathcal{g}}\biggr|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right]\\ & = : \widetilde{\pi}^{swptn}(\alpha , \beta),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath326 and @xmath327 . let us simplify the notation by introducing @xmath328 so that , in view of proposition [ prop : qaffinecharacterization ] , @xmath329 admits the representation @xmath330.\end{aligned}\ ] ] recall from definition [ def : aff_model ] that @xmath130 , so that @xmath331 and @xmath332 are well - defined . as shown in the following proposition , the quantity @xmath333 can be explicitly computed , analogously to proposition [ prop : capletbasicaffine ] . [ prop : swaptionbasicaffine ] assume @xmath334 @xmath335 . let @xmath307 such that @xmath336 , @xmath335 . then the lower bound in terms of @xmath337 for a payer swaption with notional @xmath310 , maturity @xmath9 , payment dates @xmath338 , with @xmath321 for all @xmath322 is given by @xmath339\right)d\zeta\big ) , \end{aligned } \label{eq : swaptionapproxgeneral}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath340 is given by @xmath341 , & \mbox{if } \epsilon<0 , \\ \frac{1}{2}\mathbb{e}\left[e^{v_0(t_l)+v_{i , j}(t_l)+\phi(t_l - t , u_{i , j}(t_l)+u_0(t_l))+\langle \psi(t_l - t , u_{i , j}(t_l)+u_0(t_l ) ) , x_t\rangle}\biggr|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right],&\mbox{if } \epsilon = 0,\\ 0,&\mbox{if } \epsilon > 0 . \end{cases}\ ] ] the claim is a direct consequence of ( * ? ? ? * theorem 5.1 ) , noting that each summand appearing in corresponds in the notation of @xcite to the case @xmath342 , @xmath343 , @xmath344 and @xmath345 . proposition [ prop : swaptionbasicaffine ] gives a general lower bound for the price of a swaption , parameterized in terms of @xmath346 . these parameters should be determined in such a way that the lower bound becomes as tight as possible , while at the same time ensuring the finiteness of suitable exponential moments of @xmath324 . as pointed out in @xcite , to which we refer for more details on the numerical implementation , the values of @xmath346 can be chosen in two ways : 1 . by maximizing with respect to @xmath347 , thus providing the lower bound @xmath348 note that this solution can be computationally demanding , especially for highly dimensional models . moreover , for a given choice of @xmath349 , the optimization procedure should be constrained in order to ensure the finiteness of joint exponential moments of @xmath324 . 2 . by considering hyperplane - like approximations and predetermining the best possible values of @xmath347 ( the well - known singleton - umantsev approximation constitutes an example in this sense , see @xcite and compare also with @xcite ) . for notational simplicity we consider here the case of one single tenor @xmath350 and suppose that the driving process @xmath61 is a wishart process on @xmath351 with state space @xmath352 of the form @xmath353 where @xmath354 is @xmath355 matrix of brownian motions , @xmath356 and @xmath357 are @xmath358 matrices . the particular appealing feature of wishart processes is stochastic correlation between the nonnegative diagonal elements of the matrix . on the classical canonical state space @xmath359 this property can not be achieved for positive factors . this possibility is however a crucial ingredient when it comes to modeling spreads which are highly correlated . we consider an affine short rate multi - curve model as of section [ sec : short_rate ] with short rate @xmath360 and spread @xmath361 , where @xmath362 and @xmath363 to guarantee positivity of the spreads . recall that the scalar product @xmath364 is here the trace . by choosing @xmath188 and @xmath365 to be diagonal matrices , the above model represents a natural extension of the classical cir model to the multi - curve setting since the diagonal elements of a wishart process are stochastically correlated cir processes . the goal of this section is to study the pricing of caps for this particular model . as shown in section [ sec : option ] , the price of a caplet with unitary notional can be computed via @xmath366\\ & \quad -(1+\delta k)b(t , t+\delta)\mathbb{q}^{t+\delta}\left[s^{\delta}(t , t)\geq ( 1+\delta k)b(t , t+\delta)\ , |\ , \mathcal{f}_t\right ] , \end{split}\ ] ] where the probability measure @xmath367 is defined via @xmath368 in the case of the above introduced model , it can be easily shown that the process @xmath61 follows under both measures @xmath369 and @xmath370 a non - central wishart distribution with time dependent parameters , which is stated in lemma [ lem : newwish ] below . as the density is ( up to the solution of odes ) explicitly known , this allows obtaining ( semi-)analytical pricing formulas for caplets , similarly as in the cir model . as a preliminary , let us introduce the following definition , in line with ( * ? ? ? * definition a.4 ) . suppose that @xmath356 , @xmath371 and @xmath372 is a @xmath355 matrix such that @xmath373 is symmetric positive semidefinite . a symmetric positive definite random matrix @xmath374 is said to be _ non - centrally wishart distributed _ with @xmath375 degrees of freedom , covariance matrix @xmath376 , and matrix of non - centrality parameter @xmath372 , if its laplace transform satisfies @xmath377=\det(i_d-2 u\sigma)^{-\frac{\delta}{2}}e^{- \langle u(i_d+2u\sigma)^{-1},\sigma\theta\rangle}.\ ] ] in this case , we write @xmath378 . [ lem : newwish ] let @xmath61 be a wishart process of the form under @xmath39 . 1 . under @xmath369 , @xmath324 has a non - central wishart distribution @xmath379 where @xmath380 and @xmath381 are solutions of the following system of ordinary differential equations @xmath382 where @xmath212 and @xmath213 denote the characteristic exponents of the process @xmath383 . the solution of is explicitly given by @xmath384 with @xmath385 . 2 . under @xmath370 , @xmath324 has a non - central wishart distribution @xmath386 , where @xmath387 and @xmath388 are solutions of the following system of ordinary differential equations @xmath389 where @xmath212 and @xmath213 denote the characteristic exponents of the process @xmath383 . the solution of is explicitly given as above . concerning ( i ) , note that the density process @xmath390 of @xmath391 is given by @xmath392= \frac{1}{s^{\delta}(0,t ) b(0,t)}\mathbb{e}\left[\frac{s^{\delta}(t , t ) b(t , t)}{b_t } \big| \mathcal{f}_t\right]\\ & = \frac{1}{s^{\delta}(0,t ) b(0,t)}\mathbb{e}\left[e^{c(t)+\langle \gamma , x_{t}\rangle-\int_0^t \ell(s)ds-\langle\lambda , \int_0^t x_{s}ds\rangle } \big| \mathcal{f}_t\right]\\ & = \frac{1}{s^{\delta}(0,t ) b(0,t)}\exp\left(c(t)-\int_0^t \ell(s)ds+\tilde{\phi}\left(t - t , \gamma,-\lambda \right)+\left\langle\tilde{\psi}\left(t - t , \gamma , -\lambda\right ) , x_t\right\rangle-\langle \lambda , \int_0^t x_{s}ds\rangle\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath212 and @xmath393 denote the characteristic exponents of @xmath383 . note that the diffusion part of @xmath394 is given by @xmath395 so that we can write @xmath396 by girsanov s theorem , under the measure @xmath397 , the linear drift of @xmath61 changes to @xmath398 so that @xmath61 becomes a wishart process with time - varying linear drift under @xmath369 . according to ( * proposition a.6 ) , @xmath324 has a noncentral wishart distribution @xmath399 , where @xmath380 and @xmath381 are solutions of . concerning ( ii ) , we have for the density process of @xmath400 @xmath401&=\frac{b(t , t)}{b_t b(0,t)}\\ & = \frac{1}{b(0,t)}\exp\left(-\int_0^t \ell(u)du+\tilde{\phi}\left(t - t , 0 , -\lambda \right)+\left\langle\tilde{\psi}\left(t - t , 0,-\lambda\right ) , x_t\right\rangle-\langle \lambda , \int_0^t x_{s}ds\rangle \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the assertion then follows similarly as for @xmath369 . in view of , we focus here on the computation of @xmath402 \qquad\text{and}\qquad \mathbb{q}^{t+\delta}\left[s^{\delta}(t , t)\geq ( 1+\delta k)b(t , t+\delta)\right].\ ] ] by the specification of our model , the first of the two quantities above becomes @xmath403\ ] ] and similarly for the @xmath370-probability . it thus amounts to compute expressions of the type @xmath404,\ ] ] for some matrix @xmath405 ( note that @xmath406 can be symmetrized to lie in @xmath407 ) and some constant @xmath408 . the following proposition relates linear combination of elements of non - centrally wishart distributed matrices with @xmath409-distributed random variables . [ prop : chisquare ] let @xmath410 with @xmath411 . then @xmath412 where @xmath413 are the eigenvalues of @xmath414 and @xmath415 are independent random variables with @xmath416 , where @xmath417 by ( * ? ? * proposition 6 ) , @xmath61 has the same distribution as @xmath418 where @xmath419 . therefore @xmath420 where @xmath421 . let us now compute the moment generating function of @xmath422 , which is given by ( see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ? * proposition a.5 ) ) @xmath423=\prod_{i=1}^d(1 - 2u\lambda_i)^{-\frac{\kappa}{2}}e^{\frac{u\lambda_iy_{ii}}{1 - 2u\lambda_i}}.\ ] ] however , this corresponds to the moment generating function of @xmath424 , where @xmath425 are independent random variables . indeed , it holds that @xmath426=\prod_{i=1}^d\mathbb{e}\left[e^{u \lambda_i v_{i}}\right ] = \prod_{i=1}^d(1 - 2u\lambda_i)^{-\frac{\kappa}{2}}e^{\frac{u\lambda_iy_{ii}}{1 - 2\lambda_iu}}.\ ] ] this proves that @xmath427 . since @xmath428 , the assertion is proved . [ cor : wish ] let @xmath405 and @xmath61 a wishart process of form . then under @xmath370 it holds that @xmath429 where @xmath430 are the eigenvalues of @xmath431 and @xmath432 are independent random variables with @xmath433 , where @xmath434 and @xmath435 and @xmath436 are given in lemma [ lem : newwish ] . the same assertion holds for @xmath437 with @xmath435 and @xmath436 replaced by @xmath438 and @xmath439 . the assertion is a direct consequence of lemma [ lem : newwish ] and proposition [ prop : chisquare ] . finally , by relying on the above results , we are ready to give a ( semi-)analytical formula for the price of a caplet in the above wishart model . let @xmath61 be a wishart process of the form . consider an affine short rate multi - curve model with * ois short rate @xmath440 , for all @xmath441 $ ] and * logarithmic multiplicative spreads @xmath442 , for all @xmath441 $ ] . then the price of a caplet at date @xmath195 with unitary notional , reset date @xmath9 and payoff @xmath443 at the settlement date @xmath444 , is given by @xmath445 where * the constant @xmath446 is given by @xmath447 with @xmath448 being the constant part in the characteristic exponent of @xmath449 , and * @xmath450 and @xmath451 denote the cumulative distribution functions of a weighted sum of non - centrally @xmath409-distributed random variables corresponding to @xmath452 and @xmath453 as of corollary [ cor : wish ] for @xmath369 and @xmath370 with @xmath454 and @xmath455 the constant part in the characteristic exponent of @xmath449 . the assertion is a consequence of equation together with corollary [ cor : wish ] . in order to practically implement the pricing formula , the following steps are necessary : * compute @xmath455 and integrate it over the interval @xmath456 $ ] to obtain @xmath457 ; * compute the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of @xmath458 and @xmath459 with @xmath454 to get the weights @xmath460 and the non - centrality parameters @xmath461 ; * compute @xmath446 as given in and the distribution function of a positive weighted sum of two independent non - centrally @xmath409-distributed random variables , e.g. , via a laguerre series expansions ( see @xcite ) of the form @xmath462 where @xmath463 is a function depending on @xmath464 and @xmath465 are the coefficients ( depending on @xmath466 ) of the laguerre polynomials @xmath467 ( evaluated at @xmath468 where @xmath469 denotes a constant ) . for an alternative computation based on fourier inversion we refer to @xcite . note that the weights @xmath460 and the non - centrality parameters @xmath470 depend on the maturity ( the degrees of freedom @xmath375 are constant ) while the arguments @xmath446 in the distribution function depend additionally on the strike . in the case where @xmath192 and @xmath471 are constants , @xmath408 only depends on @xmath27 and we write only @xmath472 . in this case the matrix @xmath473 for different maturities and strikes needed for calibration purposes can be obtained by a matrix product @xmath474 where @xmath475 and @xmath476 are defined by @xmath477 provided the initial term structure of spreads and bonds is known , this procedure then gives the prices for all maturities and strike rates . in this section , we discuss the calibration of two simple specifications of our general framework to cap / floor market data . this section aims at illustrating the practical feasibility of the proposed approach and it is not meant to suggest a particular specification of the framework . the first specification is based on a cir - gamma model , while the second specification is driven by a wishart process , as presented in section [ sec : wishart ] . in particular , this represents the first instance of calibration of a wishart short rate model in the multi - curve framework . moreover , we complement our results with a parameter stability analysis in the case of the cir - gamma model , showing a satisfactory degree of stability . we refer to @xcite for calibration results based on swaption data and to @xcite for a calibration approach which relies on atm european swaption and cap quotes . let us start by briefly describing our market data sample . we initially consider a fixed trading date , namely august @xmath478 , 2011 . the data sample consists of a cross section of market quotes ( corresponding to perfectly collateralized transactions ) of linear and non - linear interest rate derivatives . as far as linear products are concerned , we consider market data for overnight indexed swaps and interest rate swaps . on the basis of these market quotes , we construct the ois discount curve @xmath479 and the forward curves @xmath480 , for @xmath481 and @xmath482 . this has been performed by relying on the finmath java library ( see @xcite ) . concerning non - linear interest rate products , the market practice consists in posting a cap / floor composite surface : when the strike price is below the at - the - money ( atm ) level , quotes refer to out - of - the - money ( otm ) floors , whereas if the strike is above atm , quotes refer to otm caps . in this way , the whole surface is constructed from liquidly traded otm options . by relying on the put - call parity between caps and floors , we can however treat all implied volatilities as cap volatilities . to reduce the complexity of the calibration , it is convenient to construct a caplet implied volatility surface , suitably bootstrapped from cap implied volatility data . the surface refers to strike prices ranging between @xmath483 and @xmath484 and maturities between @xmath485 months and @xmath486 years . in the market , caps with maturity larger than two years are indexed to the @xmath485-month forward rate while those with lower expiry are linked to the @xmath487-month curve . a normal implied volatility is obtained by numerically searching for the value of @xmath488 ( where @xmath310 stands for normal ) such that the bachelier pricing formula for a caplet @xmath489}\\ & = b(t , t_i)\delta\sigma_n\sqrt{t_{i-1}-t}\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi}}e^{-\frac{z^2}{2}}+zn(z)\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath490 best fits the market price of a given caplet . we now provide a detailed description of the implementation of proposition [ prop : capletbasicaffine ] , by means of the fft algorithm ( see @xcite ) . in the present discussion , we express the integration variable as @xmath491 . let also @xmath492 and @xmath493 the integral term appearing in can then be written as @xmath494 we perform a first approximation by introducing a trapezoidal rule of the form @xmath495 , so that the effective upper limit of integration is given by @xmath496 . as we want to perform a simultaneous evaluation of the integral term for a grid of strike prices , we also introduce a grid for @xmath263 of the form @xmath497 , which gives a mesh covering the interval @xmath498 , with @xmath499 . since we want to apply the fft algorithm , we need to impose the nyquist condition , meaning that we set @xmath500 , thus introducing a tradeoff between the accuracy of the log - strike and integration grids . as suggested by @xcite , we introduce the weights of the simpson rule , in order to obtain a satisfactory accuracy even for large values of @xmath501 . in summary , the integral term ( along a grid of log - strikes ) is approximated via @xmath502,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath503 denotes a kronecker delta function which is @xmath504 for @xmath505 and zero otherwise . formula can be computed by a direct application of the fft algorithm . in our analysis , we set @xmath506 and @xmath507 . for a given vector of model parameters @xmath508 , belonging to the set of admissible parameters @xmath509 , we compute caplet prices using the above methodology and convert them into model implied normal volatilities , that we denote by @xmath510 . the aim of the calibration procedure is to solve @xmath511 where @xmath512 denotes the market - observed implied volatilities and @xmath513 the euclidean norm . in the following , we illustrate two candidate specifications along with their calibration results . note that both models allow for a perfect fit to the observed term structures via a suitable choice of the functions @xmath192 and @xmath471 in line with proposition [ prop : deterministicshiftcharacterization ] . we first calibrate the following model consisting of a two - dimensional process @xmath90 of the form @xmath514 where @xmath515 , @xmath354 is a brownian motion and @xmath93 is a gamma process with compensating jump measure @xmath516 , with @xmath517 . the short rate is specified as @xmath518 and the spreads are of the form @xmath519 , @xmath520 , with @xmath521 and @xmath522\rightarrow{\mathbb{r}}$ ] . table [ table : cir - vgparams ] reports the calibrated model parameters while figure [ fig : calibrationerrorsdataset08022011 ] illustrates the quality of the fit in terms of prices and implied volatilities . more precisely , the left panel shows the squared error in price while the right panel illustrates the squared error in implied volatilities . despite its simplicity , the model achieves a reasonably good fit to the observed market quotes . looking at squared error in implied volatilities , we observe that the quality of the fit is lower for higher strikes and for the first maturity we considered ( 6 months ) . however , the quality of the fit is acceptable as can be seen by looking at the left panel of figure [ fig : calibrationerrorsdataset08022011 ] , which highlights that the squared error in price in the @xmath485-month maturity and deep otm region is low . observe that the calibrated parameters satisfy @xmath523 , reflecting the fact that @xmath485-month rates embed a higher degree of interbank risk with respect to @xmath487-month rates . this was achieved without imposing a priori constraints in the optimization algorithm . note also that the computational complexity of the procedure is at the same level of a calibration of a standard affine stochastic volatility model for equities . .calibration result for the cir - gamma model . resnorm represents the sum of squared distances between market and model implied volatilites.[table : cir - vgparams ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] this appendix presents general pricing formulas for typical interest rate derivatives . as we are going to show , the quantity @xmath272 plays a pivotal role in the valuation of interest rate products . we here derive clean prices in the spirit of ( * ? ? ? * appendix a ) , assuming perfect collateralization with the collateral asset being equal to the numraire . the prices of linear interest rate products ( i.e. , without optionality features ) can be directly expressed in terms of the basic quantities @xmath8 and @xmath272 . + _ forward rate agreement . _ + a forward rate agreement ( fra ) starting at @xmath9 , with maturity @xmath444 , fixed rate @xmath27 and notional @xmath310 is a contract which pays at time @xmath444 the amount @xmath524 the value of such a claim at time @xmath525 is @xmath526}\\ & = n\bigl(b(t , t)s^{\delta}(t , t)-b(t , t+\delta)(1+\delta k)\bigr ) . \end{split}\ ] ] _ overnight indexed swap . _ + an overnight indexed swap ( ois ) is a contract where two counterparties exchange two streams of payments : the first one is computed with respect to a fixed rate @xmath27 , whereas the second one is indexed by an overnight rate ( eonia ) . let us denote by @xmath527 the payment dates , with @xmath528 for all @xmath529 . the swap is initiated at @xmath530 . the value of an ois at @xmath531 with notional @xmath310 can be expressed as ( see e.g. ( * ? ? ? * section 2.5 ) ) @xmath532 therefore , the ois rate @xmath533 , which is by definition the value for @xmath27 such that the ois contract has zero value at inception , is given by @xmath534 _ interest rate swap . _ + in an interest rate swap ( irs ) , two streams of payments are exchanged between two counterparties : the first cash flow is computed with respect to a fixed rate @xmath27 , whereas the second one is indexed by the libor rate . the value of the irs at time @xmath531 , where @xmath535 denotes the inception time , is given by @xmath536 the swap rate @xmath537 , which is by definition the value for @xmath27 such that the contract has zero value at inception , is given by @xmath538 _ basis swap . _ + a basis swap is a special type of interest rate swap where two cash flows related to libor rates associated to different tenors are exchanged between two counterparties . for instance , a typical basis swap may involve the exchange of the 3-month against the 6-month libor rate . following the standard convention for the definition of a basis swap in the euro market ( see @xcite ) , the basis swap is equivalent to a long / short position on two different interest rate swaps which share the same fixed leg . let @xmath539 , @xmath540 and @xmath541 , with @xmath542 , @xmath543 , @xmath544 and corresponding tenor lengths @xmath545 , with no constraints on @xmath546 . the first two tenor structures on the one side and the third on the other are associated to the two floating and to the single fixed leg , respectively . we denote by @xmath310 the notional of the swap , which is initiated at time @xmath547 . the value at time @xmath548 is given by @xmath549 the value @xmath550 ( called _ basis swap spread _ ) such that the value of the contract at initiation is zero is then given by @xmath551 note that , prior to the financial crisis , the value of @xmath550 used to be ( approximately ) zero . in this section , we report general valuation formulas for plain vanilla interest rate products such as ( european ) caplets and swaptions . _ caplet . _ + the price at time @xmath1 of a caplet with strike price @xmath27 , maturity @xmath9 , settled in arrears at @xmath444 , is given by @xmath552}\notag\\ & = n{\mathbb{e}^{}\left[\left.\frac{b_t}{b_t}\bigl(s^{\delta}(t , t)-(1+\delta k)b(t , t+\delta)\bigr)^+\right|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right ] } \label{eq : caplet_gen}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that , in the classical single - curve setting ( i.e. , under the assumption that @xmath553 is identically equal to one ) , the valuation formula reduces to the classical relationship between a caplet and a put option on a zero - coupon bond with strike @xmath554 . from , we see that the payoff of a caplet at time @xmath9 and notional @xmath555 corresponds to @xmath556 let us now introduce the following probability measure on @xmath557 : @xmath368 note that @xmath558 and @xmath559=1 $ ] , since @xmath560 is a @xmath39-martingale by proposition [ prop : bonds_spreads ] . by bayes formula , we therefore have @xmath561=s^{\delta}(t , t)b(t , t)\mathbb{e}^{\widetilde{\mathbb{q}}}\left[1_{\{s^{\delta}(t , t)\geq ( 1+\delta k)b(t , t+\delta)\}}\ , \bigr| \ , \mathcal{f}_t\right].\ ] ] similarly , we obtain @xmath562\\=(1+\delta k)b(t , t+\delta)\mathbb{e}^{\mathbb{q}^{t+\delta}}\left[1_{\{s^{\delta}(t , t)\geq ( 1+\delta k)b(t , t+\delta)\}}\ , \bigr|\ , \mathcal{f}_t\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , the price of a caplet can be computed via @xmath563\\ & \quad -(1+\delta k)b(t , t+\delta)\mathbb{q}^{t+\delta}\left[s^{\delta}(t , t)\geq ( 1+\delta k)b(t , t+\delta)\ , \bigr|\ , \mathcal{f}_t\right ] . \end{split}\ ] ] _ swaption . _ + we consider a standard european payer swaption with maturity @xmath9 , written on a ( payer ) interest rate swap starting at @xmath319 and payment dates @xmath564 , with @xmath528 for all @xmath529 , with notional @xmath310 . the value of such a claim at time @xmath1 is given by @xmath565.\ ] ] under assumption [ ass : couple ] , the process @xmath566 is a martingale , for all @xmath19 $ ] . since @xmath567 , this implies that @xmath568 = { \mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{1}{b_t}\bigr|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right ] , \qquad\text { for all } 0\leq t\leq t\leq { \mathbb{t}},\ ] ] thus proving part ( i ) . in particular , note that this implies that @xmath569 $ ] , thus ensuring that @xmath570 defines a probability measure @xmath571 , for every @xmath19 $ ] . recalling that @xmath572 , for all @xmath25 and @xmath16 , it holds that @xmath573 \\ & = { \mathbb{e}}\left[\frac{l_t(t , t+\delta_i)-l_t(t , t+\delta_i)}{b_{t+\delta_i}}\bigr|{\mathcal{f}}_t\right ] = \frac{b(t , t+\delta_i)}{b_t}\bigl({\mathbb{e}}^{{\mathbb{q}}^{t+\delta_i}}[l_t(t , t+\delta_i)|{\mathcal{f}}_t]-l_t(t , t+\delta_i)\bigr).\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath574 by part ( i ) , the last equality proves part ( ii ) . finally , by bayes formula , the process @xmath153 is a @xmath40-martingale if and only if the process @xmath575 defined by @xmath576 is a @xmath577-martingale , for every @xmath16 . by definition of @xmath29 , it holds that @xmath578 and the desired martingale property then follows from part ( ii ) . f. m. ametrano and m. bianchetti . everything you always wanted to know about multiple interest rate curve bootstrapping but were afraid to ask . preprint ( available at ` http://ssrn.com/abstract=2219548 ` ) , 2013 . g. bormetti , d. brigo , m. francischello , and a. pallavicini . impact of multiple - curve dynamics in credit valuation adjustments . in k. glau , z. grbac , m. scherer , and r. zagst , editors , _ innovations in derivatives markets _ , pages 251266 . springer , 2016 . c. cuchiero and j. teichmann . path properties and regularity of affine processes on general state spaces . in c. donati - martin , a. lejay , and a. rouault , editors , _ sminaire de probabilits xlv _ , volume 2078 of _ lecture notes in mathematics _ , pages 201244 . springer , 2013 . z. grbac , l. meneghello , and w. j. runggaldier . derivative pricing for a multi - curve extension of the gaussian , exponentially quadratic short rate model . in k. glau , z. grbac , m. scherer , and r. zagst , editors , _ innovations in derivatives markets _ , pages 191226 . springer , 2016 . j. kallsen . a didactic note on affine stochastic volatility models . in y. kabanov , r. lipster , and j. stoyanov , editors , _ from stochastic calculus to mathematical finance - the shiryaev festschrift _ , pages 343368 . springer , berlin , 2006 . l. morino and w. j. runggaldier . on multicurve models for the term structure . in r. dieci , x .- z . he , and c. hommes , editors , _ nonlinear economic dynamics and financial modelling : essays in honour of carl chiarella_. springer , 2014 . | we provide a general and tractable framework under which all multiple yield curve modeling approaches based on affine processes , be it short rate , libor market , or hjm modeling , can be consolidated . we model a numraire process and multiplicative spreads between libor rates and simply compounded ois rates as functions of an underlying affine process . besides allowing for ordered spreads and an exact fit to the initially observed term structures , this general framework leads to tractable valuation formulas for caplets and swaptions and embeds all existing multi - curve affine models . the proposed approach also gives rise to new developments , such as a short rate type model driven by a wishart process , for which we derive a closed - form pricing formula for caplets . the empirical performance of two specifications of our framework is illustrated by calibration to market data . |
0812.2597 | the _ quantum entropy _ ( or , equivalently , _ von neumann entropy _ ) was defined by von neumann around 1927 for proving the irreversibility of quantum measurement processes @xcite . precisely , the quantum entropy is an extension of the gibbs entropy to the quantum realm and it may be viewed as the average information the experimenter obtains in the repeated observations of many copies of an identically prepared mixed state . it has a fundamental role for studying correlated systems and for defining entanglement measures @xcite . in the present work we elaborate on the notion of quantum entropy applied to networks . since the quantum entropy is defined for quantum states , the first required ingredient is therefore a method to map graphs / networks into states ( while the converse is not necessary in our purpose ) . the literature comprises different ways to associate graphs to certain states or dynamics . notably , graph - states and spin networks , just to mention two major ones : graph - states are certain quantum error correcting codes , important for characterizing the computational resources in measurement based quantum computation @xcite ; spin networks are arrangements of interacting quantum mechanical particles , nowadays of great significance for the development of nanotechnologies @xcite . we take a straightforward approach , and take into analysis an entropic quantity for graphs on the basis of a faithful mapping between discrete laplacians and quantum states , firstly introduced by braunstein _ @xcite ( see also @xcite ) . in synthesis , we see the spectrum of an appropriately normalized laplacian as a distribution and we compute its shannon entropy @xcite ( which measures the amount of uncertainty of a random variable , or the amount of information obtained when its value is revealed ) . such a quantity finds a natural place among those _ global _ spectral parameters of graphs ( _ i.e. _ , involving the entire spectrum and not just a specific eigenvalue ) studied in connection to natural and social networks . for example , the estrada index , a measure of centrality @xcite , also used to quantify the degree of folding of long - chain molecules @xcite ; or the _ graph energy _ , that in hckel theory corresponds to the sum of the energies of all the electrons in a molecule @xcite . ( see the book chapter @xcite , for a general review on complexity measures for graphs . ) we give evidence that the quantum entropy is a measure of regularity for graphs , _ i.e. _ , regular graphs have in general higher entropy when the number of edges is fixed . moreover , entropy seems to depend on the number of connected components , long paths , and nontrivial symmetries . chosen the number of edges , entropy is smaller for graphs with large cliques and short paths , _ i.e. _ , graphs in which the vertices form an highly connected cluster . the remainder of the paper is organized as follows . in section [ two ] we introduce the required definitions and focus on some basic properties . by adding edges one by one to the empty graph , we try to construct graphs with minimum and maximum entropy . in section [ egs ] we explore the influence of the graph structure on the entropy . we consider different classes of graphs : regular graphs , random graphs , and the star as an extremal case of scale - free graph ( _ i.e. _ , graphs for which the degree distribution follows a power law ) . the asymptotic behavior for large number of vertices shows that regular graphs tend to have maximum entropy . we study numerically how the entropy increases when adding edges with different prescriptions . once fixed the number of edges , the entropy is minimized by graphs with large cliques . section [ conclusion ] contains remarks and open problems . the state of a quantum mechanical system with a hilbert space of finite dimension @xmath0 is described by a _ density matrix_. each density matrix @xmath1 is a positive semidefinite matrix with tr@xmath2 . as we have already mentioned in the introduction , there are many ways to associate graphs to specific density matrices or hamiltonian evolution ( _ e.g. _ , graph states , bosonic systems , _ etc . _ ) . here we consider a matrix representation based on the combinatorial laplacian . let @xmath3 be a simple undirected graph with set of vertices @xmath4 and set of edges @xmath5 . the _ adjacency matrix _ of @xmath6 is denoted by @xmath7 and defined by @xmath8_{u , v}=1 $ ] if @xmath9 and @xmath8_{u , v}=0 $ ] , otherwise . the _ degree _ of a vertex @xmath10 , denoted by @xmath11 , is the number of edges adjacent to @xmath12 . a graph @xmath6 is @xmath13-_regular _ if @xmath14 for all @xmath10 . let @xmath15 be the _ degree - sum _ of the graph , _ i.e. _ @xmath16 . the _ average degree _ of @xmath6 is defined by @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the number of _ non - isolated vertices _ , that is vertices @xmath12 such that @xmath9 for some @xmath19 . the _ degree _ _ matrix _ of @xmath6 is an @xmath20 matrix , denoted by @xmath21 , having @xmath22-th entry defined as follows : @xmath23 _ { u , v}=d(v)$ ] if @xmath24 and @xmath25 _ { u , v}=0 $ ] , otherwise . the _ combinatorial laplacian _ _ matrix _ of a graph @xmath6 ( for short , _ laplacian _ ) is the matrix @xmath26 . the matrix @xmath27 is a major tool for enumerating spanning trees ( via the matrix - tree theorem ) and has numerous applications ( see kirchhoff @xcite , biggs @xcite , and grone _ et al . _ @xcite ) . as a consequence of the gergorin disc theorem , @xmath27 is positive semidefinite . by these definitions , the laplacian of a graph @xmath6 scaled by the degree - sum of @xmath6 is a density matrix : @xmath28 . it is then clear that @xmath29 . the entropy of a density matrix @xmath1 is defined as @xmath30tr@xmath31 . now , given the notion of laplacian , we say that @xmath32 is _ the quantum entropy _ ( or , for short , _ entropy _ ) _ of _ @xmath6 . let @xmath33 and @xmath34 be the eigenvalues of @xmath27 and @xmath35 , respectively . these are related by a scaling factor , _ i.e. _ @xmath36 , for @xmath37 . the entropy of @xmath35 can be also written as @xmath38 , where @xmath39 , by convention . ( see @xcite for a survey on laplacian spectra . ) since its rows sum up to @xmath40 , then @xmath40 is the smallest eigenvalue of @xmath35 . the number of connected components of @xmath6 is equal to the multiplicity of @xmath40 as an eigenvalue . the largest laplacian eigenvalue is bounded by the number of non - isolated vertices , _ i.e. _ , @xmath41 ( see duval _ @xcite , proposition 6.2 ) ; thus it follows immediately that @xmath42 , for @xmath37 . it is important to remark that since @xmath43 , for @xmath37 , @xmath32 equals the shannon entropy of the probability distribution @xmath44 . if a general density matrix @xmath1 has an eigenvalue @xmath45 then the other must be @xmath40 and @xmath46 . in such a case , the density matrix is said to be _ pure _ ; otherwise , _ mixed_. for later convenience , we define the quantity @xmath47 . the _ disjoint union _ of graphs @xmath6 and @xmath48 is the graph @xmath49 , whose connected components are @xmath6 and @xmath48 . we denote by @xmath50 the complete graph on @xmath0 vertices . let @xmath51 be the set of all graphs on @xmath0 vertices . the next fact was proved by braunstein _ @xcite : let @xmath6 be a graph on @xmath52 vertices . then @xmath53 if and only if @xmath54 and @xmath55 if and only if @xmath56 . when @xmath57 , then @xmath58 and @xmath59 . for general density matrices , @xmath60 , if @xmath1 is a pure state ; @xmath61 if @xmath62 , _ i.e. _ , a completely random state . the analogue in @xmath51 is @xmath50 given that the spectrum or @xmath63 is @xmath64},0^{[1]}\}$ ] . the next result bounds the variation of the entropy under edge addition . let @xmath65 , where @xmath66 and @xmath67 . an alternative proof could be given by invoking eigenvalues interlacing @xcite . [ conc]for graphs @xmath6 and @xmath65 , we have @xmath68 . chosen a labeling of @xmath69 , for @xmath70 we can write @xmath71 , where @xmath72 is the adjacency matrix of a graph @xmath73 . we can then define an @xmath20 diagonal matrix @xmath74 such that @xmath75_{u , u}% = [ \delta(u , v)]_{v , v}=1 $ ] and @xmath75_{u , v}=0 $ ] if @xmath76 . it follows that @xmath77 . then @xmath78 . let @xmath79 be the standard basis of @xmath80 . by definition , @xmath81 . we associate the pure state @xmath82 to the edge @xmath83 . let @xmath84 be the projector associated to @xmath85 : @xmath86 . then @xmath87 and @xmath88 . it is well - known that the entropy @xmath89 is concave ( see ohya and petz @xcite ) : @xmath90 , where @xmath91 are density matrices and @xmath92 . . however , since @xmath94 , the claim is true . starting from @xmath95 ( the graph with zero entropy ) we can think of a discrete - time process in which we add edges so that the entropy is extremal ( resp . maximum or minimum ) at every step . let us denote by @xmath96 and @xmath97 , @xmath98 , the graphs with maximum and minimum entropy at the @xmath99-th step , respectively . figure [ min ] contains @xmath100 and @xmath101 ( resp . solid and dashed line ) as functions of the number of edges @xmath102 , for graphs in @xmath103 . the initial graph is @xmath104 ; the final one is @xmath105 . each edge labeled by @xmath106 in the graph @xmath107 on the left ( resp . right ) hand side of figure [ ksix ] is also an edge of @xmath96 ( resp . @xmath97 ) . this illustrates the steps for constructing every @xmath96 and @xmath97 . it turns out that the vertices of @xmath96 tend to have almost equal or equal degree . in fact @xmath96 is a @xmath108-regular graph , for @xmath109 . on the other hand , @xmath110 , if @xmath111 . the meaning is without ambiguity : entropy is minimized by those graphs with _ locally _ added edges , _ i.e. _ edges increasing the number of complete subgraphs ( also called _ cliques _ ) . even if we consider graphs with only six vertices , it is already evident that long paths , nontrivial symmetries and connected components give rise to a larger increase of the entropy . this property is confirmed by further numerical analysis in the next section . [ h ] minmaxl.eps let @xmath112 be the set of all @xmath13-regular graphs . for @xmath113 , we have @xmath114 , and hence @xmath115 , for @xmath116 , where @xmath117 denotes the @xmath99-th eigenvalue of @xmath7 . [ th1]let @xmath6 be a graph on @xmath0 nonisolated vertice . if @xmath118 then @xmath119 . in particular , if @xmath113 then @xmath120 . when @xmath70 , @xmath121 , where @xmath122 . since @xmath123 , we have @xmath124 . given that tr@xmath125 , by taking @xmath126 , the quantum entropy of @xmath6 is given by @xmath127 . since @xmath128 , we have @xmath129 . from this expression , we see immediately that if @xmath130 then @xmath131 . now , let us consider @xmath113 . since @xmath14 for every @xmath10 , it follows that @xmath132 and @xmath133 . given that for a @xmath13-regular graph @xmath134 , we have @xmath135 , for every @xmath37 . the quantity @xmath136 is now given by @xmath137 , where @xmath138 , and @xmath139 . the function @xmath140 assumes finite values in the range @xmath141 $ ] . thus @xmath136 is also finite . in particular , since @xmath136 is an average , it remains finite even if considering an arbitrary large number of vertices . this implies that the entropy for a @xmath13-regular graph tends to the entropy of @xmath50 in the limit @xmath142 . it may useful to remark two points : _ ( 1 ) _ the simplest regular graph is the _ perfect matching _ the density matrix of @xmath144 is then @xmath145{rr}% 1 & -1\\ -1 & 1 \end{array } \right ) $ ] and @xmath146 , because @xmath147}% = \frac{n}{2}$ ] and @xmath148}=0 $ ] . thus , @xmath149 . for @xmath150 we have @xmath151 . more generally , @xmath152 . _ ( 2 ) _ the entropy of @xmath153 tends to the entropy of @xmath50 if all the quantities @xmath154 remain finite , _ i.e. _ , @xmath130 . the _ complete bipartite graph _ @xmath155 has @xmath156 , where @xmath157 and @xmath158 , and each vertex in @xmath159 is adjacent to every vertex in @xmath160 . the graph @xmath161 on @xmath0 vertices is said to be a _ star_. let @xmath70 with @xmath12 such that @xmath162 for every @xmath163 , and let @xmath164 . then @xmath165 . in particular , the star @xmath161 saturates the bound , since @xmath166 , and @xmath167 . let @xmath6 be as in the statement . so , @xmath168 . for a graph with at least one edge , grone _ et al . _ ( see @xcite , corollary 2 ) proved that @xmath169 ; for a generic graph on @xmath170 vertices , we know that @xmath171 ( see duval _ et al . _ @xcite , proposition 6.2 ) . by these two results , @xmath172 thus , we have @xmath173 and @xmath174 . because @xmath127 , we have @xmath175 . now , the eigenvalues of @xmath176 are @xmath177}=\frac{n}{2n-2}$ ] , @xmath178}=\frac{1}{2n-2}$ ] and @xmath179}=0 $ ] . thus , the entropy is given by @xmath180 and in the limit @xmath142 we have the second part of the statement . since @xmath181 , it results @xmath182 and the bound is saturated . similarly to what we have done in the previous section , we observe how the entropy of a graph @xmath70 increases as a function of @xmath183 . starting from @xmath184 , we consider four different ways of adding edges : _ ( i ) _ random graphs with exactly @xmath185 edges . these are constructed by chosing @xmath185 pairs of vertices at random from the total number of pairs ; _ ( ii ) _ the graph @xmath186 ; _ ( iii ) _ the graph @xmath187 ; _ ( iv ) _ the graph @xmath188 , where @xmath189 $ ] . recall that adding isolated vertices to a graph does not change its entropy . figure [ plot ] shows the case @xmath190 . it is evident that the entropy is larger for graphs with an high number of connected components . in this sense , @xmath144 has relatively high entropy . the smallest entropy is obtained for complete graphs . next is a list of remarks and open problems : _ normalized laplacian . _ we have considered the combinatorial laplacian @xmath27 . there is a related matrix called _ normalized laplacian _ and defined by @xmath191 ( by convention @xmath192_{v , v}=0 $ ] if @xmath193 ) . it results that @xmath194_{u , v}=1 $ ] if @xmath24 and @xmath195 , @xmath196_{u , v}=-1/\sqrt { d(u)d(v)}$ ] if @xmath9 , and @xmath196_{u , v}=0 $ ] , otherwise ( see @xcite ) . if a graph has no isolated vertex then tr@xmath197 . therefore , we can define the density matrix @xmath198 . the entropy of @xmath199 is then @xmath200tr@xmath201tr@xmath202 . since the eigenvalues of @xmath203 are in @xmath141 $ ] @xcite , when limit @xmath142 , the quantity @xmath204 remains finite . we may then conclude that when the number of vertices goes to infinity , the entropy @xmath205 tends to @xmath206 . this fact provides a motivation for dealing with @xmath27 instead of @xmath203 . _ algebraic connectivity . _ let @xmath207 be the _ algebraic connectivity _ of @xmath6 @xcite . it is nonzero only if @xmath6 is connected . the value of @xmath208 quantifies the connectivity of @xmath6 . is there a relation between @xmath208 and @xmath32 ? consider @xmath50 and the @xmath0-_cycle _ @xmath209 , that is the connected @xmath210-regular graph on @xmath0 vertices . for these , @xmath211 and @xmath212 . by theorem [ th1 ] , @xmath213 . however the algebraic connectivity of the two graphs behave differently in this limit : @xmath214 and @xmath215 . _ eigenvalue gap . _ let @xmath216 be the _ eigenvalue gap _ of @xmath6 . this parameter determines the mixing time of a simple random walk on @xmath6 ( see lovsz @xcite ) . if @xmath217 then @xmath218 . hence @xmath219 and @xmath220 . we can therefore state that @xmath221 and @xmath32 describe different properties of @xmath6 at least on the basis of this basic observation . _ a combinatorial definition . _ it is unclear whether @xmath222 is related to combinatorially defined entropic quantities . for example , the krner entropy defined in @xcite ( see also simonyi @xcite for a survey ) or the entropies defined by riis @xcite and bianconi @xcite . intuitively , any relation should be weak , because the quantum entropy depends on the eigenvalues . for this reason it describes some global statistical behaviour , with only partial control over combinatorial properties . _ beyond cospectrality . _ graphs with the same eigenvalues have equal entropy . we have seen that also perfect matchings and complete graphs plus a specific number of isolated vertices have equal entropy , but are clearly noncospectral ( see section [ egs ] ) . determine families of graphs with the same entropy remains an open problem . _ relative entropy . _ the quantum relative entropy is a measure of distinguishability between two states ( see the review @xcite ) . given two graphs @xmath6 and @xmath48 , the _ quantum relative entropy _ may be defined as @xmath223tr@xmath224 . what kind of relations between the two graphs are emphasized by the relative entropy ? to what extent can this be used as a measure of distinguishability for graphs ? _ acknowledgments . _ the authors would like to thank michele arzano , alioscia hamma , dan lynch , yasser omar , federico piazza and samuel vazquez , for helpful discussion . fp was supported by the perimeter institute for theoretical physics . research at perimeter is supported by the government of canada through industry canada and by the province of ontario through the ministry of research & innovation . ss was supported by the institute for quantum computing . research at the institute for quantum computing is supported by dtoaro , ordcf , cfi , cifar , and mitacs . f. r. k. chung , _ spectral graph theory _ , cbms regional conference series in mathematics , 92 . published for the conference board of the mathematical sciences , washington , dc ; by the american mathematical society , providence , ri , 1997 . | we normalize the combinatorial laplacian of a graph by the degree sum , look at its eigenvalues as a probability distribution and then study its shannon entropy . equivalently , we represent a graph with a quantum mechanical state and study its von neumann entropy . at the graph - theoretic level , this quantity may be interpreted as a measure of regularity ; it tends to be larger in relation to the number of connected components , long paths and nontrivial symmetries . when the set of vertices is asymptotically large , we prove that regular graphs and the complete graph have equal entropy , and specifically it turns out to be maximum . on the other hand , when the number of edges is fixed , graphs with large cliques appear to minimize the entropy . |
1509.01646 | in this work , we investigate the aharonov - bohm phase difference picked up by charged particles that go around a closed space - time loop in the presence of the time - dependent potentials and fields of an electromagnetic plane wave . theoretical investigations of the aharonov - bohm effect @xcite generally involve time - independent potentials . the canonical example of the aharonov - bohm effect is that of charged particles in a two - slit experiment with an infinite solenoid , carrying a constant magnetic flux , placed between the slits . each charged particle picks up an additional phase due to the non - zero vector potential outside the solenoid , even though the electric and magnetic fields outside the solenoid are zero . the experimental tests of the aharonov - bohm effect have also generally been done with time - independent fields @xcite . in contrast to the time - independent aharonov - bohm effect , there have been only a few theoretical studies of the _ time - dependent _ aharonov - bohm effect . some of the works @xcite have focused on a solenoid with a time - dependent magnetic flux , while others @xcite have used an electromagnetic plane wave to obtain time - dependent potentials and fields . on the experimental side , there are only two cases that we have found where the time - dependent aharonov - bohm effect was tested experimentally . the first test was an accidental experiment by marton _ @xcite where an electron two - slit interference experiment was set up and the interference pattern was observed . however , it was later determined that the region through which the electrons traveled was contaminated with a 60 hz magnetic field of unknown strength . the question in regard to the results of the accidental experiment in @xcite are : why was the interference pattern seen at all ? why did it not shift back a forth at 60 hz ? " at first , it was thought that the result of marton _ et al . _ was evidence against the aharonov - bohm effect . however , two explanations have been put forward as to why the experiment in @xcite saw a static interference pattern . in @xcite , the idea was advanced that the time varying aharonov - bohm phase was compensated for by a phase shift coming from the direct @xmath2 force which acted on the electrons . in @xcite , the explanation given for the observation of the static interference pattern in @xcite was due to a cancellation between the time varying aharonov - bohm phase and a phase coming from the induced electric field that accompanied the time varying magnetic field . the second test of the time - dependent aharonov - bohm was the experiment in @xcite . this experiment used fields from an electromagnetic wave with a frequency in the microwave region and was along the lines of the set - up suggested in @xcite for testing the time varying aharonov - bohm effect . this experiment was also along the lines of @xcite , which studied decoherence effects due to the time varying aharonov - bohm phase coming from an electromagnetic wave . the results of the experiment described in @xcite were that evidence for an aharonov - bohm phase from the time varying fields and potentials was not observed thus these results were similar to the accidental experiment of marton _ et al . _ , where the effect of the time variation was not seen in the interference pattern . the explanation of the non - observation of the time variation in the experiment @xcite was that the parameters of the set - up were such that the time variation effect was too small to be seen @xcite . we come to a similar conclusion from our analysis in order to observe the time variation one must carefully chose the various parameters of the set - up : the frequency and amplitude of the electromagnetic wave , the size of the loop , the velocity of the particle , _ etc . _ in the conclusion , we give conditions under which one might see evidence of the time varying aharonov - bohm effect . there are two points to make before we move on to our detailed analysis . first , the time - dependent aharonov - bohm effect is invariably a type ii aharonov - bohm effect . the type i aharonov - bohm effect is when the charged particle develops a phase while moving through a region that is free of electric and magnetic fields , as in the original time - independent , infinite solenoid set - up . the type ii aharonov - bohm effect is when the charged particle develops an aharonov - bohm phase , but while moving through a region of space where the fields are not zero . a typical example of a type ii effect is the aharonov - casher effect @xcite , where a neutral particle with a magnetic moment moves through an electric field and , in doing so , picks up a aharonov - bohm - like phase . second , the set - up we study here is a combination and generalization of the time - dependent aharonov - bohm effect studied in @xcite and @xcite . in particular for our set - up , both the electric and magnetic aharonov - bohm effects are non - zero . in reference @xcite , the set - up was taken so that only the time varying magnetic field gave an aharonov - bohm phase , while in reference @xcite , the set - up was such that only the time varying electric field gave a non - zero contribution to the aharonov - bohm phase . further , these two prior works calculated the aharonov - bohm phase in different ways : reference @xcite used the line integral of the potentials to obtain the phase while reference @xcite used the area integral of the fields . here , we calculate the phase using both the line integral of the potentials and the area integral of the fields . this provides an explicit working out of stokes theorem in 4d . in the literature , we have found no examples of this , although there are of course plenty of explicit worked out examples of stokes theorem in 3d . in this section , we give the set - up for the potentials , fields and path that we will use . we consider a linearly polarized plane wave traveling along the @xmath3-axis in either the @xmath4 or @xmath5 direction . the covariant , four - vector potential for this is @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the amplitude and @xmath8 are the frequency and wave number for the wave . the @xmath9 sign is a wave traveling in the @xmath10 direction and the @xmath11 is a wave traveling in the @xmath12 direction . the electric and magnetic fields can be obtained from using @xmath13 with the result @xmath14 where prime means a derivative with respect to the argument of @xmath15 , namely @xmath16 . the electromagnetic wave in is polarized in the @xmath17 direction . we could consider a more complicated wave traveling in the @xmath3-direction , with the electric and magnetic fields having components in both @xmath17 and @xmath18 directions . the vector potential for such wave would have the form @xmath19 , where @xmath20 are amplitudes and @xmath21 are phases . for our purposes , the four - potential in is sufficient since for the closed loop path that we pick , with no motion of the particles in the @xmath18 direction , only the @xmath17 component of the four - vector potential will contribute . if we had picked our loop to be in the @xmath22 plane , then it would be a vector potential of the form @xmath23 which would give a non - zero contribution . the closed space - time path that we chose in evaluating the loop integral @xmath24 is shown fully in figure [ fig1 ] . the projections in the @xmath25 and @xmath26 planes are shown , respectively , in figure [ fig2 ] and figure [ fig3 ] . in the experiment , the charged particles would travel both paths @xmath27 and @xmath28 , and @xmath29 and @xmath30 , in the forward time - direction , _ i.e. _ the charged particles would leave the origin and travel forward along @xmath27 and @xmath28 and also forward along @xmath29 and @xmath30 , with each picking up some different aharonov - bohm phase along these paths . to take the phase _ difference _ between path @xmath27 and @xmath28 versus path @xmath29 and @xmath30 , one puts a negative sign in front of the integral along path @xmath29 and @xmath30 ( or as well one could put the negative sign in front of the integrals along path @xmath27 and @xmath28 , thus reversing the direction of the space time loop in figure [ fig1 ] ) . in this way , one ends with a closed space - time loop integral . this is what is done in the usual static aharonov - bohm analysis , but with purely spatial loop integrals . the paths start from the origin , @xmath31 , and then travel with velocity @xmath32 , for a time @xmath33 , to the two spatial points @xmath34 . this gives paths @xmath27 and @xmath30 . from these two points , one traces back to the point @xmath35 in a time @xmath33 ( this means a total time of @xmath36 ) ; this gives paths @xmath28 and @xmath29 . note , the total time from the origin to @xmath35 is @xmath36 , so @xmath37 . now , for the explicit evaluation of @xmath24 in the next section , we need to give the equations describing each path : @xmath38 the magnitude of the velocity along any path is @xmath39 . for the projections of the full space - time path from figure [ fig1 ] into the @xmath25 plane in figure [ fig2 ] , the slopes of the paths are greater than 1 since @xmath40 . for the aharonov - bohm effect with a plane wave background , both the electric and magnetic aharonov - bohm effects can be non - trivial at the same time . for the usual static magnetic aharonov - bohm effect , the line integral of the the 3-vector potential , @xmath41 , is related to the surface area of the magnetic field via stokes theorem in 3d , @xmath42 . in order for this magnetic aharonov - bohm phase to be non - zero , the magnetic field , @xmath43 , must have a component along the area normal direction , @xmath44 . for our space - time area , the spatial projection is in the @xmath45 plane , which therefore has a spatial area direction in the @xmath18-direction . this then gives a non - zero contribution for the magnetic field of the plane wave since @xmath46 . for the usual static electric aharonov - bohm effect , it is the time integral of the scalar potential , @xmath47 , which is important ( @xmath48 ) . using @xmath49 , one finds that the electric aharonov - bohm phase can be written as @xmath50 . note that the spatial area of the magnetic case , @xmath51 , is replaced by a space - time area @xmath52 . in order to get an electric contribution to the aharonov - bohm phase , the electric field must have a component along the direction of the path . for the wave traveling in the @xmath3-direction , and for the area of the loop which has a projection in the @xmath45 plane , both the magnetic field in the @xmath18-direction and the electric field in the @xmath17-direction will give non - zero contributions to the time varying aharonov - bohm phase . in the case studied in @xcite , the wave was taken to be traveling in the @xmath18-direction , the electric field was polarized in the @xmath3-direction , and the magnetic field was in the @xmath17-direction . the loop chosen in @xcite was also in the @xmath45 plane , so , in that situation , there was only a non - zero electric aharonov - bohm phase ; the magnetic aharonov - bohm phase was zero . in our set - up _ both _ the magnetic and electric ahronov - bohm phases play a role . using the above set - up , we now calculate @xmath24 , which gives the aharonov - bohm phase when multiplied by @xmath53 . we will calculate the phase picked up along the four path lengths given in figure [ fig1 ] and then add them . the electromagnetic wave has a frequency and wave number given by @xmath54 and @xmath55 , which satisfy @xmath56 . the velocity on any given leg of the path in figure [ fig1 ] is @xmath32 . in carrying out the calculation for the loop integral for the case in figure [ fig1 ] , we will first calculate @xmath24 in the frame where @xmath57 ; this is the upright diamond " loop of figure [ fig2 ] . then , to obtain the more general case , we will boost the result of the upright diamond so that the particle develops a velocity , @xmath58 , in the @xmath12 direction . + * the upright diamond " * : for the upright diamond in figure [ fig2 ] , we have @xmath59 and @xmath60 , and we take the wave number and frequency as @xmath61 and @xmath62 , respectively . the four paths are parametrized as : @xmath63 along each path , since @xmath64 , @xmath65 simplifies to @xmath66 . for path 1 , from , we find @xmath67 = a_0 \delta x ~\langle f(\zeta ) \rangle_{\rm i}~,\ ] ] where @xmath68 , @xmath69 , and @xmath70 is the integral function of @xmath15 . @xmath71 is the phase shift up to the half - way point , @xmath72 in the final expression in we have written the result in terms of @xmath73 , which is the average of @xmath74 in the interval @xmath75 . for path @xmath28 , we have , from , @xmath76 ~ \\ & = & - \frac{a_0 \beta_0}{k_0}\left [ f\left ( 2\delta \zeta_0 \right ) - f\left(\delta \zeta_0 \right ) \right ] = - a_0 \delta x ~\langle f(\zeta ) \rangle_{\rm ii } \nonumber ~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath77 is the average of @xmath74 over the interval @xmath78 . in a similar manner , for path @xmath29 and path @xmath30 , one finds @xmath79 altogether , the upright diamond loop integral is @xmath80 - \left [ f\left ( 2\delta \zeta_0 \right ) - f\left ( \delta \zeta_0 \right ) \right ] \right ) \\ & = & 2\frac{a_0 \beta_0}{k_0 } \left ( 2f\left(\delta \zeta_0 \right ) - f(0 ) - f\left ( 2\delta \zeta_0 \right ) \right ) \nonumber ~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] or in terms of the avergaes of @xmath74 , @xmath81 the loop integral is zero if the average of the vector potential in the first half ( i ) and the second half ( ii ) are the same . + * boost along @xmath3-direction * : in order to evaluate the loop integral for @xmath82 , we now boost the frame along the @xmath3-direction by @xmath83 . this gives the particle a velocity in the @xmath3 direction , and changes the upright diamond of figure [ fig2 ] to the tilted diamond of figure [ fig1 ] . in equation , the only parameters that change are the wave number @xmath61 and the @xmath17-component of velocity , @xmath84 . @xmath71 also transforms due to @xmath61 and @xmath84 changing . te parameters @xmath85 and @xmath7 do not change since they are perpendicular to the boost direction . after the boost , @xmath86 in equation , only the combination @xmath87 shows up . using we find @xmath88 setting @xmath89 , we get the final result @xmath90 \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{2a_0}{k ' } \left [ 2f\left(k'\delta x \right ) - f(0 ) - f\left ( 2k'\delta x \right ) \right ] \\ & = & \frac{2a_0}{k ' } \left [ 2f(\delta \zeta ) - f(0 ) - f(2\delta \zeta ) \right ] \nonumber ~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath91 is defined as @xmath92 and @xmath93 is the phase shift to the half - way point @xmath94 the last line of equation is the main result of this section and we want to make some comments / remarks about its physical meaning . first , we can look at an expansion of the function @xmath95 , where @xmath96 or @xmath97 , depending on which term in one is expanding . using this , one finds that becomes @xmath98 thus , to first order in @xmath93 , the time varying aharonov - bohm phase vanishes . this result can be compared to the result in @xcite @xcite , where the authors found that for a solenoid with a time varying flux , the time - dependent part of the aharonov - bohm phase vanishes to first order as well . next , if we take the particle speed to be much less than the speed of light , @xmath99 , then , from , @xmath100 . hence the condition @xmath101 is identical to @xmath102 , or equivalently @xmath103 , where @xmath104 and @xmath105 are the wavelength and the period of the electromagnetic wave . since the approximate vanishing of @xmath24 requires @xmath106 , the condition above imposed on the wavelength or the period of the electromagnetic wave is a condition for the approximate vanishing of the loop integral . at the end of the next section , we will comment more on the use of the result in to determine when the time - dependent aharonov - bohm effect is important / observable . one final question we want to address : under what conditions does @xmath24 vanish exactly " . according to and , if @xmath107 , the loop integral vanishes , which in turn means @xmath108 according to . thus , if the particle traverses the loop at close to @xmath109 and moves in the same direction as the electromagnetic wave ( in this case the @xmath3 -direction ) the time - dependent aharonov - bohm phase will vanish . this was the same conclusion reached for the time dependent , non - abelian aharonov - bohm effect @xcite using the time - dependent , non - abelian plane waves of coleman @xcite . however , in the present case , due to the constraint @xmath110 , @xmath111 means @xmath112 , the @xmath17-component of the velocity is vanishingly small , and that the diamond shaped loop becomes elongated in the @xmath3 direction since the ratio of the lengths goes as @xmath113 . there is another way that the loop integral vanishes exactly . rewriting in terms of the original function @xmath114 , we have @xmath115 where the notation is similar to equation and with the intervals defined as @xmath116 where @xmath117 , the phase change to the half - way point . this means that if the average of the vector potential experienced by the particle in the first half , @xmath118 , is the same as the average of that experienced in the latter half , @xmath119 , then the loop integral vanishes . this happens , for example , if @xmath74 is constant , i.e. the integrand function @xmath120 is linear with respect to @xmath121 ( this is another way of giving the result from that @xmath24 vanishes up to first order in @xmath122 ) , or if the particles travels at the speed of light ( riding the waves " ) along @xmath3 in the same direction as the waves ( as @xmath121 itself remains constant along the path for @xmath108 ) . the average vector potential of the first and second halves cancels each other out also if the periodicity of the waves is such that the particle on the path encounters integer number of the wavelengths in @xmath33 . in this section , we work out the aharonov - bohm phase using the electric and magnetic fields and taking the area " integrals . this is a 4d example of the usual 3d stokes theorem , where one finds @xmath123 . in the 4d case , we want @xmath124 , where we have written the 4d area @xmath125 , using the antisymmetric wedge product . concise details of this notation can be found in @xcite . taking only the components of electric and magnetic fields given in , we have @xmath126 in the right hand side , we have written the tensor components in three vector notation with @xmath127 and @xmath128 . the first term is a space - time area integral of the electric field , @xmath129 , and the second term is a purely spatial area integral of the magnetic field , @xmath130 . as in section iii we will do the upright diamond " area and show that this is equivalent to the loop integral of the upright diamond " from . then by boosting in the @xmath3 direction , one can obtain the area intergal for the general surface from figure [ fig1 ] . for the upright diamond loop one has a surface only in the @xmath131-plane ( see figure [ fig2 ] ) , and therefore only an electric contribution : @xmath132 we will split the upright diamond into left triangle and right triangles , evaluate these separately and then sum them up : @xmath133 for the upright diamond , @xmath64 and @xmath134 , so from we have @xmath135 . with this the left half of the surface integral is : @xmath136 dx \\ & = & \frac{a_0 \beta_0}{k_0 } \left ( 2f\left(\delta \zeta_0 \right ) - f(0 ) - f\left ( 2\delta \zeta_0 \right ) \right ) \nonumber ~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath137 . likewise , for the right half of the upright diamond , we have @xmath138 dx \\ & = & \frac{a_0 \beta_0}{k_0 } \left ( 2f\left(\delta \zeta_0 \right ) - f(0 ) - f\left ( 2\delta \zeta_0 \right ) \right ) \nonumber ~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] adding and gives the final result for the upright diamond of @xmath139 ~. \\\ ] ] this is the identical result for the upright diamond loop integral of equation , which confirms the 4d stokes theorem . to get the case with a general velocity in the @xmath3 direction , we can boost the result from equation , as we did in section iii , to obtain the final result of equation . the upright diamond area integral is solely due to electric field . however , after the boost , it gets a magnetic contribution . the ratio of the electric and magnetic contributions depends on the magnitude of the boost @xmath140 . one can calculate the electric and magnetic contributions separately . denoting the aharonov - bohm phase due to electric and magnetic field as @xmath141 and @xmath142 , respectively , one can derive ( see appendix ) @xmath143 the ratio only depends on @xmath140 . at any speed less then @xmath109 , the electric contribution is larger . this is the reverse of what was found in reference @xcite , under different conditions . in @xcite , the time dependent system was an infinite solenoid with a magnetic flux which was pulsed on over a short time . in this case , the magnetic aharonov - bohm phase was dominant over the phase shift due to the electric aharonov - bohm phase . in @xcite and @xcite , the case of an infinite solenoid with a slowly varying flux was considered . to linear order it was found that the electric and magnetic aharonov - bohm phase shifts were of equal magnitude but opposite sign and thus canceled . for the case of the electromagnetic wave , the magnetic contribution becomes equal to the electric contribution only when the particles travel at the speed of light . when they travel at @xmath109 _ against _ the waves , the two contributions add up ; when they travel at @xmath109 along the waves - riding on the waves " - the two contributions cancel completely and result in a zero time - dependent aharonov - bohm phase , as derived in section iii . in both cases , due to relativistic constraint , @xmath112 as @xmath111 . this behavior is different from the case of the solenoid , where reversing the magnetic field of the solenoid also reverses the direction of the electric field . thus , in the case of the solenoid , one has the same result whether the magnetic field points along the @xmath12 or @xmath10 direction . in contrast , reversing the direction of the electromagnetic wave only reverses the direction of one of the fields , so , in one case , the electric and magnetic contributions add up , while in the other case , the electric and magnetic contributions tend to cancel . using either the area integral of the fields or the line integral of the potentials , the aharonov - bohm phase picked up in going around the space - time loop in figure is @xmath144 ~.\ ] ] we now recall the expansion of the term in square bracket from , in terms of @xmath145 , and apply this to to give the aharonov - bohm phase up to @xmath146 as @xmath147 from the above equation , we can see that in order for the time - dependent aharonov - bohm effect to be observable , one wants to have @xmath148 in writing we have ignored the factor of @xmath149 and assumed that @xmath150 , which would be the case if @xmath151 and @xmath152 were sinusoidal . we now investigate a few different scenarios for the condition in . in regard to the spatial size of our loop , we could follow @xcite and estimate that @xmath153 , and take the speed of our particless to be non - relativistic with @xmath154 . thus , from , we have @xmath155 . under these assumptions , the condition in has two free parameters : @xmath7 and @xmath54 . combining all this , the condition in leads to @xmath156 for example , one could consider soft @xmath17-ray frequencies of @xmath157 hz , which would only require an amplitude of @xmath158 . as another scenario , one could consider a frequency of @xmath159 hz , which is in the infrared / optical part of the spectrum . this would correspond to the wavelength one order of magnitude less than the size of the loop considered here . for this choice of @xmath54 , equation implies that one would need @xmath160 . in general , this sort of condition sets a certain constraint on the experimental verification of the ab phase shift : if @xmath161 is too small , the ab - phase may be too small to detect , while if it s too large the electromagnetic force that deflects the electrons from the prescribed space - time paths may be not negligible , as the energy density is @xmath162 . some of the same conclusion were reached in @xcite . in this article , we have investigated the time - dependent aharonov - bohm phase of a charged particle traveling around a closed space - time loop , given in figures [ fig1 ] - [ fig3 ] , in the presence of em plane waves traveling in the @xmath163 direction and with a polarization in the @xmath17 direction . our work is a generalization of earlier works , @xcite and @xcite , in that we consider both the electric _ and _ magnetic aharonov - bohm effects and thus we are able to see the interplay between the two . in addition , we calculated the time - varying aharonov - bohm phase both in terms of the path integral of the vector potential , @xmath24 , and in terms of the area integral of the fields , @xmath164 . our overall conclusion is that the ab phase due to em plane waves vanishes under a broad range of conditions . thus one must carefully choose the parameters of the electromagnetic wave and of the loop that the electrons traverse in order to see the effect this is similar to the conclusion of the work in @xcite @xcite where the time varying aharonov - bohm phase was searched for experimentally but not observed . first , from , one finds that generally the time varying aharonov - bohm phase vanishes if the average of the wave form over the first half of the loop equals the average over the second half of the loop _ i.e. _ @xmath165 . second , from , we showed that expanding the time varying aharonov - bohm phase to the lowest order gave a phase with a magnitude of @xmath166 . in this long wavelength approximation , only the second order term in @xmath167 remained - the zeroth and first order terms vanished . this smallness of the time varying aharonov - bohm phase is similar to earlier results in a different context @xcite . third , ab phase vanishes when the velocity of the particle traversing the loop moves completely in the @xmath3 direction ( riding along " ) at the speed of light , @xmath168 . in order to see the time varying aharonov - bohm effect , we found a general condition under the perturbative approximation , equation . this condition depended on the wave amplitude , frequency , particle velocity and size of the loop - @xmath7 , @xmath54 , @xmath169 and @xmath85 . by making some reasonable choices for the speed of the particles and the loop size ( _ i.e. _ @xmath170 and @xmath171 m ) , we arrived at a more specific condition for the frequency and amplitude of the em waves : @xmath172 . due to the electromagnetic forces on the particle , this constraint may set a certain limitation on the experimental verification of the ab effect under the perturbative approximation . + + in this appendix , we derive the ratio @xmath173 given in . the total phase shift for the tilted diamond , given in , can be split into an electric and magnetic contribution as @xmath174 ~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] to find the ratio of the magnetic to electric contributions , we just need to find @xmath141 for the tilted diamond " and then use this in to obtain @xmath142 . as in section iv , we calculate the electric part of the tilted diamond by calculating the left and right sides and adding these together . using , the electric contribution for the left side of the tilted diamond is @xmath175 ~dx \nonumber ~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the above , we have replaced @xmath176 using and defined @xmath177 . next , performing the @xmath17 integration in , we find @xmath178 \nonumber \\ & = & a_0 \frac{\beta_x}{k(1\pm \beta_z)^2 } \left [ 2 f(\omega ' \delta t ) - f(2 \omega ' \delta t ) - f(0 ) \right ] \\ & = & a_0 \frac{1}{k ' ( 1 \pm \beta_z ) } \left [ 2 f(\delta \zeta ) - f(2 \delta \zeta ) - f(0 ) \right ] \nonumber ~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used @xmath179 from and @xmath180 from . in the same way , one can obtain the right half of the tilted diamond , @xmath181 ~dx \nonumber ~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] next , performing the @xmath17 integration in , we find @xmath182 \nonumber \\ & = & a_0 \frac{\beta_x}{k(1\pm \beta_z)^2 } \left [ 2 f(\omega ' \delta t ) - f(2 \omega ' \delta t ) - f(0 ) \right ] \\ & = & a_0 \frac{1}{k ' ( 1 \pm \beta_z ) } \left [ 2 f(\delta \zeta ) - f(2 \delta \zeta ) - f(0 ) \right ] \nonumber ~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] adding the left and right sides together , we get the total electric contribution for the tilted diamond as @xmath183 ~.\ ] ] from , this gives for the magnetic contribution @xmath184 ~.\ ] ] hence , @xmath185 which is the result given in . + ds is supported by a 2015 - 2016 fulbright scholars grant to brazil . ds wishes to thank the ictp - saifr in so paulo for it hospitality . ds also acknowledges support by a grant ( number 1626/gf3 ) in fundamental research in natural sciences by the science committee of the ministry of education and science of kazakhstan . ay wishes to thank the members of deptartment of physics , california state university , fresno , for thier hospitarity during ay s stay while this work was underway . | the canonical aharonov - bohm effect is usually studied with time - independent potentials . in this work , we investigate the aharonov - bohm phase acquired by a charged particle moving in _ time - dependent _ potentials . in particular , we focus on the case of a charged particle moving in the time varying field of a plane electromagnetic wave . we work out the aharonov - bohm phase using both the potential ( _ i.e. _ @xmath0 ) and field ( _ i.e. _ @xmath1 ) forms of the aharanov - bohm phase . we give conditions in terms of the parameters of the system ( frequency of the electromagnetic wave , the size of the space - time loop , amplitude of the electromagnetic wave ) under which the time varying aharonov - bohm effect could be observed . |
astro-ph0506644 | many young stars show thermal emission from solids in circumstellar disks with properties thought similar to the early solar system . early analyses of spectral energy distributions indicated disk radii of 10 s to 100 s of au @xcite and masses of gas and dust sufficient to form planetary systems like our own @xcite . statistical studies indicate disk dissipation on timescales of @xmath1 myr @xcite , compatible with the standard paradigm of giant planet cores forming by dust coagulation followed by planetesimal accretion @xcite . a mysterious aspect of this process is that interstellar dust grains overcome energetic obstacles to sticking and grow to sizes large enough to decouple from the disk gas and interact gravitationally @xcite . most models postulate a phase of collisional agglomeration mediated by such mechanisms as brownian motion and turbulence . numerical simulations of disk evolution indicate a bimodal distribution of particle sizes develops as millimeter size aggregates grow and settle to the disk mid - plane ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) , where the resulting dense layer becomes a reservoir for the formation of planetesimals and larger bodies . observations of dust emission over a wide range of wavelengths provide diagnostic information on particle properties @xcite . recently recognized nearby stellar associations offer prime targets for observations to address the evolution of dust towards planets @xcite . the tw hya association , which contains more than 20 stellar systems with ages estimated to be 5 to 10 myr , is the nearest known site of recent star formation activity @xcite . the classical t tauri star tw hya , an apparently single star of mass 0.8 m@xmath3 , has become the focus of considerable attention because of its proximity ( 56 pc ) , and because it retains a remarkable face - on circumstellar disk of radius 225 au visible in scattered light @xcite and in thermal emission from dust and trace molecules @xcite . the dust in the tw hya disk , like the dust in disks around many younger stars , has long been known to show evidence for size evolution from a primordial interstellar distribution . at optical and near - infrared wavelengths , the tw hya disk appears almost spectrally gray @xcite , indicative of grain growth from sub - micron sizes in the upper layers of the disk . at submillimeter and millimeter wavelengths , the spectral slope indicates a shallow dependence of the particle mass opacity on wavelength , @xmath4 , with @xmath5 . for the tw hya disk , well resolved images of thermal dust emission confirm that optical depth effects do not affect the determination of the spectral slope @xcite . for compact spherical particles of size @xmath6 , @xmath7 , while for particles of size @xmath8 , @xmath9 . in realistic astrophysical mixtures , @xmath10 also partly depends on grain composition , structure , and topology , though the particle size generally dominates , especially for common silicates @xcite . the shallow submillimeter spectral slope found for observations of tw hya has been robustly interpreted as evidence for particle growth to sizes of order 1 millimeter or more @xcite . since the particle size probed by observation is comparable to wavelength , detection of dust emission at centimeter wavelengths has the potential to reveal the development and location of larger `` pebbles '' within disks . two problems have historically thwarted this goal @xcite : ( 1 ) the opacity per unit mass decreases for larger particles and the resulting emission is weak , and ( 2 ) the centimeter wavelength emission of younger ( @xmath11 myr old ) stars is often dominated by hot plasma in the system , either gyrosynchrotron emission associated with chromospheric activity , or thermal bremsstralung emission from partially ionized winds . for tw hya , the close distance and the advanced age mitigate these problems . we present new observations of tw hya at centimeter wavelengths using the very large array ( vla ) that convincingly argue for emission from a population of large dust particles in the disk . we used the vla in late 2001 and early 2002 to observe tw hya at @xmath12=3.5 cm at approximately bi - weekly intervals over 8 epochs in the d configuration ( 2001.732 , 2001.770 , 2001.808 , 2001.847 , 2001.885 , 2001.923 , 2001.956 , 2001.999 ) , which provided @xmath13 ( 450 au ) maximum resolution , and at 7 epochs in the a configuration ( 2002.047 , 2002.088 , 2002.140 , 2002.186 , 2002.252 , 2002.340 , 2002.381 ) , which provided considerably higher @xmath2 ( 15 au ) resolution . the typical rms noise in the images obtained from each of these short observations was @xmath14jy . in addition , we observed tw hya at @xmath12=6 cm in the dnc configuration in 2001 september 24 , with beam size @xmath15 and rms noise 70 @xmath16jy , to provide supplemental spectral index information . the aips software was used for calibration and imaging of each vla data set following standard procedures . the systematic uncertainty in the absolute flux scales at these wavelengths is less than 10% . a previous vla 3.5 cm @xmath17 upper limit of 84 @xmath16jy @xcite for tw hya compared to a subsequent detection at @xmath18 @xmath16jy indicated that the emission at this wavelength was variable @xcite . this apparent variability , together with the discovery that tw hya is a source of strong x - rays , suggested that the emission was due to hot gas resulting from stellar magnetic activity , which is known to produce variations at radio wavelengths of an order of magnitude or more on timescales of hours to months to years @xcite . our initial impetus to monitor the tw hya 3.5 cm emission at frequent intervals was to investigate the variability , and to determine if the radio flux reached sufficient levels to be amenable to very long baseline interferometry . figure [ fig : xband_time ] shows the tw hya d configuration 3.5 cm measurements as a function of time . no variations from the 260 @xmath16jy mean were observed within the @xmath14jy rms uncertainties at each epoch . by contrast , a second radio source within the field of view with flux comparable to tw hya , presumably a background active galactic nucleus , showed variations by more than a factor of two during this period . the surprising lack of variability for the tw hya radio emission prompted us to check the previously reported upper limit . a re - analysis of these data from 1991 january 30 in the vla archive shows that the noise was significantly higher than reported , and excision of bad data results in a detection of tw hya at the @xmath19jy level . the early observations that were thought to indicate variability in fact are compatible with all of the subsequent ( constant ) measurements . the a configuration 3.5 cm tw hya observations spatially resolve the emission region . because the brightness distribution is strongly centrally peaked and falls off steeply with radius , this is best illustrated by examination of the interferometer data in the visibility domain . figure [ fig : xband_resolved ] shows the real part of the 3.5 cm visibility as a function of baseline length , annularly averaged in bins of 88 k@xmath12 width , combining data from all of the observed epochs to maximize the signal - to - noise ratio . the falloff in visibility at longer baselines is the signature that the emission is spatially resolved . the lack of time variability , together with spatial extent orders of magnitude larger than a stellar radius , provide strong constraints on the emission mechanism . in particular , chromospheric activity expected to arise from transient magnetic features comparable in extent to the star is not responsible for the 3.5 cm emission . more detailed x - ray data bolster this conclusion . observations of the x - ray spectrum with xmm - newton @xcite and chandra @xcite indicate electron densities two orders of magnitude higher than typically found in stellar coronae . in addition , the x - ray emitting material appears to be depleted of grain - forming elements like mg and si . the x - ray emission is more likely the result of accretion shocks at the star / disk interface . any radio emission from such accretion shocks would be on such small size scales that spatial extent would not be resolved by the vla observations . an ionized wind does not present a viable explanation for the 3.5 cm emission , either . while there is evidence for small amounts of ionized gas in the tw hya system provided by optical spectroscopy of e.g. h@xmath20 emission @xcite , there are no indications from direct imaging of a wind in the form of an optical jet , as found in younger stars with higher disk accretion rates . a persuasive scaling argument against significant wind emission has been made previously from tw hya s low inferred accretion rate of @xmath21 m@xmath3 yr@xmath22 , which suggests a low mass outflow rate , and therefore a 3.5 cm flux more than an order of magnitude lower than observed @xcite . the new vla observations provide two additional arguments against a wind origin for the emission . first , the @xmath17 upper limit at 6 cm constrains the spectral spectral index from 6 to 3.5 cm to be @xmath23 , which is incompatible with the nearly flat value of optically thin ionized gas , and steeper than typically found for the winds from young stars @xcite . second , and more important , the peak brightness temperature at 3.5 cm in the resolved data is only @xmath1 k , which is compatible with ionized gas only if the optical depth or filling factor of optically thick emission is very low , unlike any known ionized jet from a pre - main - sequence star . dust emission naturally accounts for all of the properties of the 3.5 cm emission : ( 1 ) lack of time variability , ( 2 ) large spatial extent , ( 3 ) low brightness at high spatial resolution , and ( 4 ) the spectral index constraint . we conclude that the 3.5 cm emission from tw hya is strongly dominated by thermal emission from dust particles in the disk surrounding the star . the full spectrum of tw hya from the infrared through the millimeter , has been matched very well by a self - consistent irradiated accretion disk model that assumes standard optical properties for a mix of spherical particle constituents and a single - power power law size distribution @xcite . this model does not fit the observations at 3.5 cm , however . the dashed curve in figure [ fig : twhya_spectrum ] shows that this previous model falls short of the observations at 3.5 cm by a factor of a few , which is much larger than the observational uncertainty . the basic reason is that many more grains that emit efficiently at centimeter wavelengths must be included in order to raise the level of dust emission at long wavelengths . a disk model that includes a plausible population of large grains can match the data . for illustration , we assume a simple model that contains two grain populations : ( 1 ) small grains with a size distribution ( as a function of particle radius @xmath24 ) @xmath25 between minimum and maximum sizes @xmath26 @xmath16 m and @xmath27 @xmath16 m , and ( 2 ) larger `` pebbles '' with size distribution @xmath28 , between minimum and maximum sizes @xmath29 mm and @xmath30 mm . the small grains , which contain only 0.1% of the particle mass in the disk , are needed to regulate the irradiated disk structure and to explain the infrared spectrum , including the silicate feature near 10 @xmath16 m @xcite . the solid curve in figure [ fig : twhya_spectrum ] shows that the model with large grains boosts the long wavelength emission to match the observed flux density . the same model also matches very well the observed brightness distribution . figure [ fig : xband_resolved ] shows the fourier transform of the brightness distribution derived from this model as a solid curve , and the model follows the falloff in the visibilities . note that the large grains that account for the 3.5 cm emission must be present to radii of at least 10 s of au to match the observed brightness distribution . the disk mass in this model is 0.1 m@xmath3 , assuming a standard dust - to - gas mass ratio . this disk mass lies below the limit beyond which gravitational instabilities are expected to set in . the parameters in this simple model are clearly not unique . the strictly bimodal and discontinuous particle size distribution used in this disk model is meant to be illustrative of grain growth and settling , and to capture the essential behavior of more sophisticated treatments that result in small grains floating above a dense layer in the mid - plane ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the detailed situation is complex , with faster particle growth in the inner disk , and competition between growth , settling and turbulence , at all disk radii . the new observations , which show elevated emission from dust at 3.5 cm and a _ change _ in the spectral slope of the dust emission from submillimeter to centimeter wavelengths , are difficult to explain unless substantial particle evolution has occurred throughout the disk . future observations with higher signal - to - noise at high resolution hold the promise to map the spectral index of the dust emission in the disk and locate regions of changing grain properties . independent of the details of the disk model , the detection of dust emission at centimeter wavelengths provides a strong indications that an early phase of the planet building process is underway in the tw hya disk . the inference of a @xmath31 au radius inner hole in dust disk from the mid - infrared spectral energy distribution has previously given rise to the suggestion that a planet may be present in the tw hya system @xcite . in this context , it is interesting to consider that changes in dust properties may affect the timescale for planet formation . a key result in recent studies of giant planet formation by core accretion is the extraordinary sensitivity of the time of onset of a rapid gas accretion phase to assumptions of disk surface density and dust opacities ; for example , @xcite show that decreasing dust opacity can reduce the formation time of gas giant planets by more than a factor of two from the canonical 8 myr of older models @xcite . this shorter giant planet formation timescale is more comfortably consistent with estimates for the age of the tw hya system . it would be extremely interesting if other classical t tauri stars showed invariate centimeter emission with spectral properties indicative of dust emission like tw hya . unfortunately , existing vla surveys of the large sample of sources associated with the most nearby dark clouds detect only younger class i objects or transition objects with high accretion rates that drive radio and optical jets , like hl tau and dg tau @xcite , and weak - lined t tauri stars with stellar activity ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . for classical t tauri stars , the upper limits at 6 cm are generally 160 - 300 @xmath16jy . a few sources have comparable or better limits at 3.5 cm , e.g. do tau @xmath32 @xmath16jy @xcite and dl tau and gg tau @xmath33 @xmath16jy @xcite . if tw hya were at 140 pc , then it would be among the stronger dust disks at millimeter wavelengths , but its 3.5 cm emission of only @xmath34 @xmath16jy would lie well below the existing detection limits for sources at that distance . more sensitive observations at a range of centimeter wavelengths are needed to determine what fraction , if any , of the disks around classical t tauri stars show evidence for extreme grain growth like that inferred for tw hya . the detection of dust emission at centimeter wavelengths from the tw hya disk provides direct evidence for much larger particles than have been detected before in a nebula like the one from which the solar system is thought to have emerged . this first observation points the way to a new field of investigation . next generation radio telescopes , in particular the the square kilometer array @xcite , will have a combination of sensitivity and angular resolution sufficient to image in detail the distribution of large dust particles emitting at centimeter wavelengths in the disks around hundreds of young stars in nearby dark clouds and beyond . | we present very large array observations at @xmath0 cm of the nearby young star tw hya that show the emission is constant in time over weeks , months and years , and spatially resolved with peak brightness temperature @xmath1 k at @xmath2 ( 15 au ) resolution . these features are naturally explained if the emission mechanism at this wavelength is thermal emission from dust particles in the disk surrounding the star . to account quantitatively for the observations , we construct a self - consistent accretion disk model that incorporates a population of centimeter size particles that matches the long wavelength spectrum and spatial distribution . a substantial mass fraction of orbiting particles in the tw hya disk must have agglomerated to centimeter size . these data provide the first clear indication that dust emission from protoplanetary disks may be observed at centimeter wavelengths , and that changes in the spectral slope of the dust emission may be detected , providing constraints on dust evolution and the planet formation process . |
1110.0125 | the microscopic nature of high-@xmath0 superconductivity in the cuprates is still under heavy debate after more than two decades of intensive studies . it has been widely accepted that the cuprates may be properly considered as doped mott insulators and the superconductivity arises after the antiferromagnetic ( afm ) long range order is destroyed by doping . the challenge is that a typical doped mott insulator is a strongly correlated electron system in which two electrons staying at the same lattice site will cost a huge energy as compared to other energy scales like the hopping energy . with the failure of conventional perturbative many - body methods , to tackle a doped mott insulator one usually resorts to either the so - called gutzwiller projected trial wavefunction or constructing an effective low - energy theory @xcite . in the latter approach , the electron fractionalization @xcite is often utilized in order to implement some key features of a doped mott insulator . indeed , the fractionalization due to the mottness is most transparent at half - filling where only the spin degrees of freedom of the electrons are left , with the charge part being totally frozen out . only by doping can charge carriers emerge which account for a small portion of the total number of the electrons at low doping . the real challenge is that there exist many different ways of introducing fractionalized elementary objects to implement the same local mottness , i.e. , the no double occupancy constraint . these elementary particles are generally further coupled to some emergent gauge field(s ) due to the uncertainty in the fractionalization @xcite . in the lack of precise energetic comparison , a full self - consistent development of a potential fractionalization / gauge theory becomes essential in order for it to be convincingly verified or falsified by experiment as well as by general theoretical considerations . in principle , an inappropriate fractionalization would always lead to strong gauge fluctuations rendering the effective theory intractable . therefore , a stable , well - controlled gauge theory description will be a highly desired candidate for the correct low - energy theory of cuprate superconductors . we will consider a particular electron fractionalization description with a mutual chern - simons gauge structure @xcite . specifically , an electron in this theory is fractionalized into an @xmath1 bosonic spinon and a charge @xmath2 bosonic holon , which are minimally coupled to u(1 ) gauge fields @xmath3 and @xmath4 , which do not have their own dynamics , but are entangled by a mutual chern - simons topological term @xmath5which is ( 2 + 1)d realization of the topological bf theory.@xcite physically it simply means that the spinons and holons will perceive each other as quantized @xmath6 fluxoids @xcite . in the limit of zero hole concentration , the spinon condensation can naturally lead to an afm long - range ordered state . at finite doping , the mutual chern - simons term in eq . ( [ lmcs ] ) captures @xcite a precise statistical sign structure identified @xcite in the @xmath7-@xmath8 model . by the @xmath6 fluxoids carried by the mobile holons , the afm state will be destroyed and eventually a superconducting will set in with the holon condensation , and a zero - temperature phase diagram as a function of doping concentration has been recently discussed in refs . ye1,ye2 . finally , there are other quantum systems dst96,galitski05,cho11,xu09 which have the mutual chern - simons gauge structures in different contexts . in this paper , we focus on the superconducting state to develop an effective description based on the mutual chern - simons gauge theory in sec . ii . instead of a conventional ginzburg - landau theory in description of the fluctuations of the pairing order parameter , we obtain a gauge description of the low - lying collective fluctuations of charge and spin currents , which are essentially the phase fluctuations of the superconducting order parameter . we show that the meissner effect in such a superconductor is basically controlled by a spin gap . in sec . iii , we further identify a non - bcs - type order parameter @xmath9 that characterizes the sc phase coherence . here @xmath9 is related to the correlation function of two wilson loops ( of @xmath4 and @xmath10 ) and is topological as it merely depends on the gaussian linking number under a continuous deformation of the loops . such a relation is similar to the connection between the chern - simons theory and knot theory first studied in ref . . but by coupling to the matter fields , we show that the spin correlations strongly renormalize @xmath9 such that the phase coherence terminates at a critical point where the spin gap vanishes . in sec . iii c , we shall propose a direct experimental probe of such a topological nature of the gauge interaction between the spin and charge degrees of freedom . finally , in sec . iii d , we show that a fermionic excitation can emerge in the superconducting phase , which is gauge neutral and thus coherent , resembling a bogoliubov quasiparticle . the lattice field theory formulation of the phase string theory@xcite for a doped mott insulator has been recently constructed in refs . in terms of partition function : @xmath11d[h^{\dagger } , h , b^{\dagger } , b]e^{-s } \label{partition}\]]in which the action @xmath12 ( @xmath13 denotes spacetime coordinates ) with @xmath14 here the first two terms , @xmath15 and @xmath16 , are the lagrangian densities for the matter fields , holon @xmath17 and spinon @xmath18 , which carry charge and spin degrees of freedom , respectively . they are given by @xmath19equations ( [ lh ] ) and ( [ ls ] ) show that the bosonic holon and spinon fields minimally couple to two lattice u(1 ) gauge fields , @xmath20 and @xmath21 , respectively , in 2 + 1 dimensions ( @xmath22 @xmath23 , with @xmath24 , @xmath25 ) . ( @xmath26 is the external electromagnetic field which solely couples to the holons@xcite . ) the parameters @xmath27 and @xmath28 are effective hopping integral and superexchange coupling , respectively , and @xmath29 is the difference operator defined along the imaginary time axis . the lagrangian multipliers , @xmath30 , control the total numbers of holons and spinons , and the last terms in @xmath31 describe the on - site repulsions , which soften the hard - core boson condition . it is noted that this effective theory is underpinned by a so - called bosonic rvb order parameter : @xmath32 , which describes a short - ranged spin liquid state in the spinion background in the underdoped regime of a doped mott insulator@xcite . the gauge fields , @xmath21 and @xmath20 , capture the essential physics of the phase string effect@xcite in a doped mott insulator via the following lattice mutual chern - simons term in eq . ( [ s ] ) @xmath33with @xmath34 the integer fields due to the compactness of the lattice field theory@xcite , which are important in restoring the spin symmetry . without @xmath34 , eq . ( [ lmcs ] ) is recovered the present theory reduces to the original mutual chern - simons gauge theory formulation of the phase string theory in ref . . superconductivity can naturally arise in a saddle - point state of the above mutual chern - simons gauge theory , in which holons become bose - condensed and spinons are gapped@xcite . in the folllowing , we shall derive a general effective theory governing the low - energy fluctuations of the gauge fields @xmath35 around this saddle - point . this new effective theory will replace the conventional ginzburg - landau theory to describe the generalized rigidity of a non - bcs superconducting state . by minimizing the action @xmath36 in eq . ( [ partition ] ) with regard to @xmath37 and @xmath38 , one can find the saddle - point solution of @xmath39 , i.e. , @xmath40 defined by @xmath41 in the presence of a uniform distribution of the holon condensate with @xmath42 as the holon concentration . one can always choose the temporal components @xmath43 by shifting @xmath30 in eqs . ( [ lh ] ) and ( [ ls ] ) . at the saddle point , one has @xmath44 . equation ( [ sp ] ) can be understood as that a fictitious uniform flux @xmath45 is generated by the average distribution of the holon condensate via @xmath46 , while the vanishing net flux in @xmath47 is due to the fact that the spinons are short - range paired with @xmath48 ( where @xmath49 denotes the expectation value at the saddle - point ) . around the saddle - point , the gauge field @xmath21 may be rewritten as @xmath50then an effective low - energy lagrangian of the weak fluctuations of @xmath20 and @xmath21 around the saddle - point can be derived as follows @xmath51=\frac{g_{\mu } ^{h}}{2\pi ^{2}}% ( a_{\mu } ^{s}+a_{\mu } ^{e})^{2}+\frac{g_{\mu } ^{s}}{2\pi ^{2}}\left ( \epsilon ^{\mu \nu \lambda } \partial _ { \nu } a_{\lambda } ^{h}\right ) ^{2}+% \frac{i}{\pi } \epsilon ^{\mu \nu \lambda } a_{\mu } ^{s}\partial _ { \nu } a_{\lambda } ^{h}\text { \ . } \label{effectivel}\ ] ] here the first term on the right - hand - side ( rhs ) of eq . ( [ effectivel ] ) arises from @xmath15 in eq . ( [ lh ] ) after considering the holon condensation@xcite , with @xmath52 and @xmath53 . note that the gauge field @xmath4 is fixed in the unitary gauge by absorbing goldstone boson field @xmath54 in the holon superfluid @xmath55 , and the superfluid density fluctuation @xmath56 has been integrated out around @xmath57 . the second term on the rhs of eqs . ( [ effectivel ] ) originates from the spinon term @xmath16 in eq . ( [ ls ] ) after integrating out the spinon field @xmath58 , with @xmath59 , @xmath60 ( the details are outlined in appendix [ appendix_s ] ) . here , @xmath61 denotes the spin mass gap which is an important parameter as discussed in appendix a below eq . ( [ ls-1 ] ) . the parameters @xmath62 and @xmath63 as given in eq . ( [ g ] ) . note that in refs . , by assuming that the state is deep inside the superconducting phase , the limit of @xmath64 has been taken such that @xmath65 there . equation ( [ effectivel ] ) corresponds to the general case for a finite spin mass gap @xmath61 . the last term on the rhs of eq . ( [ effectivel ] ) is the mutual chern - simons term with the high - energy fluctuations of @xmath66 omitted . note that the role played by @xmath67 in constructing a topological object like the magnetic flux quantization has been discussed in ref . and the references therein . to see that the effective lagrangian @xmath68 in eq . ( [ effectivel ] ) indeed describes a superconducting state , one may further integrate out @xmath4 and @xmath69 to arrive at a low - energy action @xmath70=\int d^{3}x\frac{m_{p}{}^{2}}{2}({\mathbf{a}}% ^{e\perp } ) ^{2 } , \label{seff}\]]where the summation @xmath71 is replaced by integration in the continuum limit , with the external magnetic field @xmath72 fixed in the coulomb gauge ( @xmath73 ) . here the transverse photon mass @xmath74 is given by @xmath75with the london penetration depth @xmath76 in which @xmath77 . therefore , so long as @xmath78 , the system does exhibit the meissner effect with a finite @xmath79 in response to an external magnetic field . the physical electric current @xmath80 satisfies the london equation : @xmath81}{\delta \mathbf{a}% ^{e\perp } } = \frac{1}{\lambda _ { p}^{2}}\mathbf{a}^{e\perp } \text{. } \label{london}\]]equations ( [ mp ] ) and ( [ lambda - p ] ) will recover the previous result@xcite obtained in the ideal superconductor limit of @xmath64 , where the london penetration depth @xmath79 approaches the shortest @xmath82 . namely , in the large spin - gap limit , the superfluidity of a holon condensate is well protected . however , in the opposite limit of @xmath83 , i.e. , with the spin gap closing up , one finds @xmath84 in eq . ( lambda - p ) such that the meissner effect disappears . it implies that the superconducting phase coherence can be destroyed by the gapless spin excitations at zero temperature , even in the presence of a bare holon condensate with a finite @xmath82 . this is a peculiar manifestation that the neutral spin degrees of freedom can strongly influence the superconducting condensate . the quantum phase transition of superconductivity occurring here is quit different from the conventional transition of bcs - type as in the latter a charge ( superconducting ) gap must be closed up at the fermi surface . physically , with @xmath83 , the proliferation of neutral spinons will disorder the superconducting phase coherence via the @xmath6-vortices bound to them in the mutual chern - simons gauge theory . such a superconducting phase transition can also occur at a finite temperature at @xmath85 @xmath86 which is of non - bcs - type ( see ref . ) . finally it is noted that @xmath87 with a spinon condensation is a necessary , but not a sufficient condition for the emergence of a true afm ordering in the mutual chern - simons gauge theory . a so - called _ bose insulating phase _ ( bi ) with @xmath87 but @xmath88 has been proposed@xcite to appear as an intermediate phase between the superconducting and afm phases . in other words , the present superconducting phase can be terminated at a critical point defined by @xmath83 before a true afm order can set in with further reducing doping concentration near the half - filling . the effective low - energy lagrangian @xmath68 in eq . ( effectivel ) has replaced the conventional ginzburg - landau equation to describe superconductivity in the mutual chern - simons theory . now we examine the following question : what is the essential physical quantity that captures the nature of superconductivity , since the bcs order parameter ( as governed by the conventional ginzburg - landau equation ) no longer explicitly appears in the low - energy effective theory ? to be sure , the off diagonal long order ( odlro ) of superconductivity is still described by the cooper pairing order parameter in the phase string theory of doped mott insulators@xcite . nevertheless , since the cooper pairing amplitude can persist well beyond the superconducting phase , as determined@xcite by the bosonic rvb parameter @xmath89 and the holon condensation @xmath90 , the low - lying excitations and the phase transition of superconducting phase are essentially characterized by the topological phase fluctuations via the mutual chern - simons gauge fields , @xmath4 and @xmath69 , in the low - energy effective lagrangian ( [ effectivel ] ) . physically , @xmath4 and @xmath10 are related to the spin and hole currents in the mutual chern - simon gauge theory by the following equations of motionkou05,ye2 @xmath91where the internal electric fields in the imaginary time representation @xmath92 and the spin and charge currents are defined as @xmath93 . hence the low - lying fluctuations of @xmath4 and @xmath69 in eq . ( [ effectivel ] ) actually describe the current fluctuations of the spin and charge degrees of freedom , while the amplitude fluctuations of the matter fields remain gapped in the superconducting phase . in order to characterize the gauge fluctuations of @xmath94 , a pair of wilson loops have been introduced@xcite : @xmath95\equiv \left \langle \hat{w}^{s , h}[\mathcal{c}]\right \rangle , \label{wilson}\]]where@xmath96e^{-\sum_{x}\mathcal{l}_{eff}} ... \]]and @xmath97\equiv \exp \big [ i\sum_{x}a_{\mu } ^{s , h}(x)j_{% \mathcal{c}}^{\mu } ( x)\big],\ , \ , \label{w - operator}\]]in which the ( 2 + 1)-dimensional unit current , for a test holon or a test spinon , @xmath98 @xmath99 for the link @xmath100 @xmath101 , and is zero otherwise on a close loop @xmath102 . physically , the wilson loop @xmath103 $ ] or @xmath104 $ ] probes the interaction of a pair of test holons or spinons at a distance @xmath105 , defined by @xmath106 or @xmath107 , via@xcite @xmath108 , \label{confinev}\]]if @xmath102 is taken as a spacetime rectangle with length @xmath109 ( @xmath105 ) in the imaginary time ( spatial ) direction . in refs . , in the limit of large spin gap ( @xmath64 ) , one finds @xmath110 and @xmath111 @xmath112 . namely the holons are deconfined while the spinons are logarithmically confined . it is consistent with the present saddle - point state of holon condensation discussed in sec . ii . in the presence of a finite spin gap @xmath61 , we find that the above conclusion remains true , with the the confining potential , between a test spinon and test anti - spinon , modified to @xmath113where @xmath82 is replaced by @xmath79 defined in eq . ( lambda - p ) ( @xmath114 is an ultraviolet cutoff of the distance ) . the result indicates that the spinons will experience a confinement - deconfinement transition at @xmath84 or @xmath83 , coinciding with the superconducting phase transition critical point at @xmath115 . on the other hand , @xmath106 for holons remains deconfined . the wilson loops , @xmath116 $ ] , can provide important information on the confinement / deconfinement of spinons and holons in the superconducting phase as discussed above . however , to understand why @xmath117 $ ] behave as such , the topological nature of the mutual chern - simons effective theory in eq . ( [ effectivel ] ) has to be further revealed . for this purpose we define @xmath118\ , \hat{w}^{h}[\mathcal{c}_{2}]\right \rangle \ , , \label{topo}\]]with the normalization factor @xmath119\,w^{s}[\mathcal{c}_{2 } ] . \label{k}\ ] ] let us first consider the case of a _ pure _ mutual chern - simons term ( [ mcs ] ) without coupling to the matter fields [ i.e. , omitting the first two terms in eq . ( [ effectivel ] ) ] , a straightforward calculation shows @xmath120where @xmath121 , denotes the gaussian linking number , which is the winding number of the close loops , @xmath122 and @xmath123 as shown in fig . [ figure_geometry ] ( a ) and ( b ) . to obtain eq . ( [ link number ] ) , we write down the explicit expression of @xmath124 in a pure mutual chern - simons gauge theory , @xmath125e^{-\int d^{3}x\left ( \frac{i}{\pi } \epsilon ^{\mu \nu \lambda } a_{\mu } ^{s}\partial _ { \nu } a_{\lambda } ^{h}-a_{\mu } ^{s}j_{\mu } ^{\mathcal{c}_{1}}-a_{\mu } ^{h}j_{\mu } ^{\mathcal{c}_{2}}\right ) } \]]where , the unit spacetime currents @xmath126 and @xmath127 keep track of spacetime loops , @xmath122 and @xmath128 , respectively . integrating over @xmath4 leads to a flux constraint on @xmath129 configuration , namely , @xmath130 . it means that the gauge field @xmath69 forms a spacetime closed @xmath131-fluxtube along @xmath122 . @xmath132 denotes the spacetime flux piercing @xmath128 . noting that there are @xmath133 times for the fluxtube @xmath122 piercing @xmath128 , one arrives at @xmath134 , with @xmath135 . ignoring the @xmath136-periodicity , we thus obtain eq . ( [ link number ] ) . in witten s seminal paper@xcite , a similar gaussian linking number structure was found in the chern - simons gauge theory , which is related to the jones polynomial in the knot theory . and @xmath128 in ( 2 + 1)-dimensional euclidean spacetime . @xmath137 is an arbitrary loop but restricted inside spatial plane ( i.e. , the xy plane ) at some imaginary time . @xmath128 is an arbitrary loop with a definite gaussian linking number @xmath138 ( @xmath139 in ( a ) ; @xmath140 in ( b ) ) that characterizes the number of times that @xmath141 winds around @xmath122 . the ball ( in blue ) and the arrow ( in red ) stand for the test holon and test spinon , respectively . the arrows on the two loops indicate the direction of test spinon current and test holon current.,width=377 ] in fig . [ figure_experiment ] , a gedankenexperiment is shown to illustrate the case of winding number @xmath139 in the ( 2 + 1)-dimensional euclidean spacetime , with a pair of test spinon and antispinon creating and annihilating on a close loop @xmath128 . if the background spin degrees of freedom are gapped with @xmath142 , the test spinons can not induce spin excitations from the ground state and thus the net contribution to @xmath143 comes from the @xmath6 flux phase shift ( with @xmath144 mentioned above due to the pure mutual chern - simons action . on the other hand , if the spin gap @xmath61 becomes finite , then the spin excitations can be induced from the spinon background to renomalize @xmath124 . now we consider the full @xmath68 given in eq . ( [ effectivel ] ) . by choosing the close loop @xmath122 of the test holon within the spatial @xmath145-plane , one finally arrives at the following compact result ( for the details , see appendix b ) : @xmath146we see that @xmath9 remains to be real and positive as a topological quantity , which is invariant under a continuous deformation of loops @xmath147 and @xmath128 for a given gaussian linking number @xmath148 , as illustrated in fig . [ figure_geometry ] . but @xmath9 is renormalized by a factor @xmath149 which is solely determined by the spin gap @xmath61 . in particular , in the limit of @xmath83 , one finds @xmath150 . for simplicity ) . ( a - d ) are four snapshots of spatial plane subsequently at imaginary time @xmath151 . ( a ) a pair of test spinons with opposite spin indices are created at a spatial site @xmath152 at @xmath153 . ( b ) two spinons arrive at new spatial positions at @xmath154 via the dashed trajectories . ( c ) at @xmath155 , a holon current circuit @xmath122 is located in plane , indicating that an aharonov - bohm phase around @xmath122 is picked up by the test holon . ( d ) at @xmath156 , the pair of test spinons meet each other again at some position and then are annihilated into vacuum simultaneously . , width=377 ] if one rewrites eq . ( [ i ] ) by @xmath157where @xmath79 becomes a function of topological order parameter @xmath124 for a given gaussian linking number @xmath139 , then the limit @xmath84 , i.e. , the disappearance of superconductivity , will correspond to @xmath158 . in other words , the topological quantity @xmath9 can be regarded as the superconducting order parameter in the effective theory of eq . ( [ effectivel ] ) , and the quantum phase transition at @xmath115 occurs when @xmath9 gets fully screened by the gapless spin excitations at @xmath87 . as illustrated in fig . [ figure_geometry ] , @xmath159 indicates that a test spinon can be always feltby a vortex - like current loop of a test holon if their mutual winding number @xmath160 . physically , since the holons are in the bose condensed state , a spinon excitation will then induce a supercurrent vortex response from the condensed holons throughout the sample to form a so - called spinon - vortex@xcite . this is the origin of spinon confinement discussed above , since each spinon - vortex composite is logarithmically divergent in energy which will result in vortex - antivortex confinement . in a non - superconducting phase where the spinons become deconfined due to the vortex - antivortex disassociation and proliferation , one finds @xmath161 in the gedankenexperiment shown in fig . [ figure_experiment ] . namely , @xmath158 describes a phase disordered superconductor . we propose an experimental setup to probe the topological characterization @xmath124 of the superconducting phase in fig . [ figure_prediction ] . note that @xmath159 reflects the mutual statistical interaction between spin and charge degrees of freedom ( cf . [ figure_geometry ] ) . by using the idea illustrated in the gedankenexperiment of fig . figure_experiment , one may inject free test spinons by heating up the middle semi - island part of the sample in fig . [ figure_prediction ] to a temperature slightly higher than @xmath0 , such that free spinons can be excited and flow towards the lower @xmath109 end connecting to the outside superconducting ring . with @xmath162 inside the ring , one expects that such an injection of free spinons can generate supercurrents in the superconducting ring in a form of significant noise spikes due to the unpolarized spinon - vortex effect . , while the outside part remains below @xmath0 and spinons are confined into vortex - antivortex pairs . the confinement is indicated by the black wavy line between two spinons . the small directional discs ( red arrows ) represent vortices ( spinons ) . in such a mutual chern - simons superconductor at @xmath163 @xmath164 , spinons become deconfined to form free spinon - vortices qi07 . then , the flow of such free spinons from the semi - island towards the cooler end connecting to the outside superconducting ring is expected to generate random supercurrents in the latter as indicated by @xmath80 ( blue dashed line ) . , width=302 ] instead of raising the temperature , one may also apply an in - plance magnetic field @xmath165 to reduce the spinon mass gap @xmath61 inside the semi - island part by @xmath166 , where @xmath167 is the land factor and @xmath168 is the bohr magneton . then a sufficiently strong @xmath165 may drive the semi - island part into a spinon - vortex liquid state with @xmath158 via the zeeman effectqi07 . at the same time , the gradient of @xmath165 can also naturally cause the free spinons flow into the superconducting ring to induce the similar supercurrent response shown in fig . [ figure_prediction ] . the mutual chern - simons theory given in eq . ( [ s ] ) is an all - boson description of doped mott insulators . in the above subsections we have studied the low - lying collective fluctuations of this theory based on the effective lagrangian ( [ effectivel ] ) . an important question that arises naturally is if and how a low - energy fermionic excitation can _ emerge _ in such an all - boson theory , which is independent of the above collective excitations . to give a proof of principle , we first note that the mutual chern - simons term in eq . ( [ effectivel ] ) can be replaced by an auxiliary lagrangian in real - time representation : @xmath169where @xmath170 is an auxiliary 4-component dirac spinor in ( 2 + 1)-dimensional spacetime with flavor indices @xmath171 . @xmath172 . here @xmath173-matrices are defined in 4-dimensional reducible representation of 2-dimensional clifford algebra , i.e. , @xmath174 , where @xmath175 and @xmath176 are pauli matrices . the covariant derivative @xmath177 is defined as @xmath178 the @xmath179 matrix @xmath180 , where @xmath181 is the @xmath182 unit matrix . the second term in eq . ( [ aux ] ) is mass term with @xmath183 . @xmath184 preserves a @xmath185 gauge symmetry where subscripts @xmath186 and @xmath187 denote axial vector type and ordinary vector type @xmath188 gauge invariance , respectively . it originates from the fact that @xmath20 is an ordinary vector field with gauge group generator 1 while @xmath69 is an axial vector field with gauge group generator @xmath189 @xcite . the parity and time - reversal symmetries are conserved even in the presence of finite mass gap which may be expressed as : @xmath190 , where , @xmath191 ( @xmath192 ) is upper ( lower ) 2-component spinor of @xmath170 . here , @xmath193 denotes the chiralityvafa84 . in the case of parity ( @xmath194 is parity operator ) , @xmath195it is easy to check that the mass term is invariant under such parity transformation in ( 2 + 1)-dimensional spacetime . integrating over @xmath170 leads to a pure mutual chern - simons term by ignoring maxwell terms ( @xmath196 momentum squared ) in the one - loop quantum correction ( fig . [ vertex ] ) in the long wavelength limit @xmath197 . the key steps of derivation are given as follows . , @xmath69 , and @xmath198 , correspondingly . the first two diagrams correspond to maxwell terms , while the last one gives the non - vanishing mutual chern - simons vertex.,width=302 ] as shown in fig . [ vertex ] , the vacuum polarization for @xmath4 and @xmath129 at one - loop level@xcite ( @xmath199 is a 3-dimensional euclidean momentum ) : @xmath200.\]]where the total flavor number @xmath201 . the expansion around small @xmath199 is given by @xmath202the propagators of gauge fields can be constructed in the landau gauge and the maxwell terms read out : @xmath203 with @xmath204 and @xmath205 . meanwhile , the nonvanishing mutual chern - simons term for @xmath4 and @xmath69 in fig . [ vertex ] is also radiatively generated without breaking parity and time - reversal symmetries . note that , upper(lower)-component spinor has mass @xmath206 ( @xmath207 ) : @xmath208where , the superscript @xmath209 denoting upper and lower 2-component spinor contributions respectively , and @xmath210 with identity : @xmath211 . in the sufficiently low momentum transfer limit ( @xmath212 ) , it is expanded as power series of @xmath199 : @xmath213 in eq . ( [ eq_sigma ] ) , the sign factor @xmath214 renders vanishing of abelian chern - simons terms ( @xmath215 and @xmath216 ) . but due to the structure of matrix @xmath189 , the crossing term , i.e the mutual chern - simons term survives as expected . mathematically , the above quantum corrections are organized as below : @xmath217where the maxwell terms are ignored in the long wavelength limit . it is important to note that the fermionic auxiliary field @xmath170 is not gauge - neutral as it still couples to @xmath20 and @xmath218 in eq . ( [ aux ] ) . a true fermion excitation of quasiparticle should be gauge - neutral without knowing @xmath4 and @xmath69 . it is only possible if there exists a residual attractive potential such that a holon and a spinon excited from the condensates can form a bound state properly with the auxiliary field @xmath170 . the resulting object @xmath198 will be both _ fermionic _ and _ coherent _ because all statistical gauge charges carried by @xmath170 can be exactly canceled by that of the spinon and holon partners . in fig . [ qploop ] , the spacetime loop of a composite - particle @xmath219 is illustrated as a gauge neutral and thus physically observable elementary excitation at low energies . in particular , it carries the right quantum number as a bogoliubov quasiparticle . as noted before , to produce the right prefactor @xmath220 of the pure mutual chern - simons term , @xmath170 has totally @xmath221 branches of positive energy solutions , which are consistent with the existence of totally four quasiparticle nodal regions in the brillouin zone , although the detailed energy spectrum depends on the residual attractive potential which goes beyond the present long - wavelength effective description . on the other hand , the existence of a _ nodal _ fermionic bogoliubov quasiparticle has been recently demonstrated based on a ground state wavefunction approach to the @xmath7-@xmath8 model in the phase string formulation , in which the quasiparticle as a similar bound state has been explicitly shown@xcite . therefore , the present field - theory formulation provides a _ proof - of - principle _ for a fermionic quasiparticle mode emerging in the mutual chern - simons theory . is composed by a spinon ( red arrow ) , a holon ( blue ball ) and a dirac fermion ( small grey ball @xmath170 ) . its spacetime loop is composed by three loops rendering gauge charge neutrality.,width=302 ] in this work , we have obtained an effective theory of the low - lying fluctuations in the superconducting state of the mutual chern - simons theory . in contrast with a conventional ginzburg - landau action for a bcs superconductor , the present effective description in eq . ( [ effectivel ] ) deals with peculiar phase fluctuations in the doped mott insulator via a pair of mutual chern - simons gauge fields , which are related to the fluctuations of charge and spin currents of the condensate . the superconducting phase coherence is found to be properly characterized by a topological order parameter which measures the mutual entanglement of the charge and spin currents in the low - energy effective theory . in particular , a zero - temperature quantum phase transition is shown to occur , due to the vanishing of this topological order parameter , when the spin gap is reduced to zero at low doping . we have discussed a possible experimental probe into the long - range entanglement between the supercurrents and the neutral spin excitations as a unique signature of this non - bcs superconducting state . we have also given a proof - of - principle how a fermionic quasiparticle can emerge in the mutual chern - simons theory . together with the previously identified flux quantization@xcite at @xmath222 , the non - bcs superconductivity in the mutual chern - simons theory is well established . we acknowledge stimulating discussions with z. c. gu , s .- kou , z .- x . liu , c .- s . tian , y. wang , z. wang , n. xu , and y .- z . you . this work is supported by nsfc grant no . 10834003 , by most national program for basic research grant no . 2009cb929402 , no . 2010cb923003 . 99 for a review , see , p. a. lee , n. nagaosa , and x. g. wen , rev . phys . * 78 * , 17 ( 2006 ) . s. a. kivelson , d. s. rokhsar and j. p. sethna . b * 35 * , 8865 ( 1987 ) . z. zou and p.w . anderson , phys . b * 37 * , 627 ( 1988 ) . t. senthil and matthew p. a. fisher , phys . b * 62 * , 7850 ( 2000 ) . z. y. weng , int . j. mod b * 21 * , 773 ( 2007 ) . p. ye , c. s. tian , x. l. qi , and z. y. weng , phys . lett . * 106 * , 147002 ( 2011 ) ; p. ye , c. s. tian , x. l. qi , and z. y. weng , nucl . b * 854 * , 815 ( 2012 ) . s. p. kou , x. l. qi , and z. y. weng , phys . b * 71 * , 235102 ( 2005 ) . d. birmingham , m. blau , m. rakowski , and g. thompson , phys . rep . * 209 * , 129 ( 1991 ) . z. y. weng , d. n. sheng , y .- c . chen , and c. s. ting , phys . b 55 , 3894 ( 1997 ) . k. wu , z. y. weng , and j. zaanen , phys . b * 77 * , 155102 ( 2008 ) . v. m. galitski , g. refael , m. p. a. fisher , and t. senthil , phys lett . * 95 * , 077002 ( 2005 ) . m. c. diamantini , p. sodano , and c. a. trugenberger , nucl . b * 448 * , 505 ( 1991 ) ; nucl . b * 474 * , 641 ( 1996 ) . g. y. cho and j. e. moore , ann . of phys . * 326 * , 1515 ( 2011 ) . c. xu and s. sachdev , phys . b * 79 * , 064405 ( 2009 ) . e. witten , commun . math . phys . * 121 * , 351 ( 1989 ) . j. w. mei and z. y. weng , phys . b * 81 * , 014507 ( 2010 ) . j. smit , _ introduction to quantum fields on a lattice_. ( cambridge , 2003 ) x. l. qi and z. y. weng , phys . b * 76 * , 104502 ( 2007 ) . c. vafa and e. witten , commun . math . phys . * 95 * , 257 ( 1984 ) . robert d. pisarski , phys . d , * 29 * , 2423 ( 1984 ) . s. deser , r. jackiw , and s. templeton , ann . phys . , * 140 * , 372 ( 1982 ) . z. y. weng , new j. phys . * 13 * , 103039 ( 2011 ) . for a review , see , c. schubert , phys . rep . * 355 * , 73 ( 2001 ) . greiner and reinhardt , _ field quantization _ , ( spinger - verlag , 1996 ) . first of all , we note that the spinon lagrangian @xmath16 in eq . ( [ ls ] ) may be further simplified to a cp@xmath223 form in the long - wavelength , low - energy regime as follows@xcite @xmath224\ , , \label{ls-1}\]]here the temporal component is rescaled by the spin wave velocity @xmath225 with the coupling constant @xmath226 , and @xmath61 is treated as a dynamically generated spinon mass enforcing @xmath227 . the problem of studying the fluctuation of @xmath228 , or @xmath229 , in eq . ( [ ls-1 ] ) is then transformed into calculating the vacuum polarization tensor in ( 2 + 1)-dimensional scalar quantum electrodynamics in the presence of a uniform background magnetic field of @xmath46 defined in eq . ( [ sp ] ) . the technical challenge arises from the fact that because of @xmath46 , the momentum is no longer a good quantum number . nevertheless the issue is resolved by using the so - called string - inspired formalism@xcite . following the procedures and conventions in ref . , we obtain the polarization tensor : @xmath230 \int_{0}^{1}d\ell i^{\mu \nu } \label{bubble}\]]where the prefactor @xmath231 comes from the summation over the spin index , @xmath109 denotes the schwinger proper time , and spacetime dimension @xmath232 . here @xmath233 is a @xmath234 matrix , defined by @xmath235 with @xmath236the determinant in eq . ( [ bubble ] ) can be simply factorized into : @xmath237 = \frac{\pi \ , \delta \,t}{\sinh ( \pi \ , \delta \,t)}\text{,}\]]and the transversality of lorentz tensor @xmath238 is given by @xmath239by further restoring the spin wave velocity @xmath240 , we arrive at the maxwell term on the rhs of eq . ( effectivel ) which describes the fluctuation @xmath241 , with the coefficients given by @xmath242 in which the dimensionless coefficient @xmath243 depends on the dimensionless quantity @xmath244 as follows @xmath245note that @xmath246 in the limit of the absence of magnetic flux@xmath247 in @xmath46 . to obtain @xmath9 , we first note that the lagrangian with holon and spinon currents circulating on loops @xmath248 ( @xmath249 ) @xmath250=\frac{\delta } { 2{m^*}}% \left(a_{\alpha } ^s\right)^2+\frac{1}{2u_1}\left(a_0^s\right)^2 + \frac{i}{% \pi } \epsilon _ { \mu \nu \lambda } a_{\mu } ^h\partial _ { \nu } a_{\lambda } ^s+% \frac{1}{2}\frac{g_{\mu } } { \pi ^2}\left(\epsilon _ { \mu \nu \lambda } \partial _ { \nu } a_{\lambda } ^h\right)^2-i a_{\mu } ^sj_{\mu } ^{\mathcal{c}_1}-i a_{\mu } ^hj_{\mu } ^{\mathcal{c}_2}\ ] ] is quadratic in the gauge fields thus allows rigorously integrating out @xmath251 and @xmath252 in the generating functional @xmath253\hat{w}^h\left[\mathcal{c}_2% \right]\right \rangle = \int d [ a^s a^h]e^{-\int d^3x l_{\text{sc}}\left[% \mathcal{c}_1 , \mathcal{c}_2\right ] } \\ = \text{const}.\times \int d [ a^h]\exp \left \{-\int d^3x\left(\frac{g_{\mu } % } { 2\pi ^2}\left(\epsilon _ { \mu \nu \lambda } \partial _ { \nu } a_{\lambda } ^h\right)^2-i a_{\mu } ^hj_{\mu } \right)\right \}\ ] ] in which we have defined @xmath254 and absorbed terms unrelated to mutual correlation between @xmath255 and @xmath256 into const . which will be canceled by the denominator in the definition of @xmath9 . adopting the `` deformed '' lorentz gauge condition , @xmath257 and integrating out @xmath252 in the feynman gauge@xcite , we get @xmath253\hat{w}^h\left[\mathcal{c}_2% \right]\right \rangle = \\ \text{const}.\times \exp \left \{-\frac{1}{2}\frac{\pi ^2}{g_0g_1g_2}\int d^3x\int d^3y\sum _ { \mu } g_{\mu } j_{\mu } ( x)j_{\mu } ( y)f(x , y)\right \ } \label{eq:6}\ ] ] in which @xmath258 given that @xmath266 , eq . [ eq:10 ] is greatly reduced if @xmath255 lies within a spatial plane , @xmath267 in which @xmath268 is the gaussian linking number of @xmath255 and @xmath269 loops . to obtain the last line of above identity , the definition of @xmath270 and @xmath271 in eq . ( [ lambda - p ] ) is applied . | in this work , we present a topological characterization of superconductivity in a prototype electron fractionalization model for doped mott insulators . in this model , spinons and holons are coupled via the mutual chern - simons gauge fields . we obtain a low - lying effective description of the collective current fluctuations by integrating out the matter fields , which replaces the conventional ginzburg - landau action to describe the generalized rigidity of superconductivity . the superconducting phase coherence is essentially characterized by a topological order parameter related to a gaussian linking number , and an experiment is proposed to probe this topological property . we further show that a gauge - neutral fermionic mode can naturally emerge in this model , which behaves like a bogoliubov quasiparticle . |
astro-ph0407206 | ever since the first gamma ray bursts were detected thirty years ago , their origin has been a subject of great interest . many more observations have occurred in recent years which point to exotic supernova as their astrophysical source ; for a review see @xcite . although the hydrodynamic details of the evolution of these objects is still under development , see e.g. @xcite , it is likely that the burst will originate from a configuration where an accretion disk surrounds a black hole . several models for these accretion disks have been examined @xcite . in addition to the highly collimated ultrarelativistic jet that produces the observed gamma rays , there will also be outflow from the accretion disk which has been studied by @xcite . this material begins at relatively high temperature ( a few mev ) and therefore will undergo a primary nucleosynthesis where free nucleons form heavy nuclei . since this is a different environment than that which occurs in the relativistic jet , different nucleosynthesis products will be produced . any analysis of the nucleosynthesis must begin with the evolution of the electron fraction in the accretion disk . this was done in @xcite by considering only electron and positron capture and by @xcite by considering neutrino and antineutrino capture as well . the disk is hot enough that for high accretion rates the neutrinos and even the antineutrinos can become trapped , creating a neutrino torus around the black hole that is in some ways similar to the neutrinosphere at the surface of the protoneutron star in a normal supernova . a preliminary analysis of the nucleosynthesis from the outflow of accretion disks was done in @xcite using a spherically symmetric neutrino driven wind model , and by @xcite using an outflow at fixed velocity and entropy . @xcite considered the nucleosynthesis that will occur from explosive burning in gamma ray bursts . @xcite concluded that iron peak elements will be produced in this outflow , while @xcite examined various rare isotopes that would point to grb disk outflow as a unique nucleosynthesis event . nucleosynthesis from accretion disks has also been discussed in @xcite . in this paper we examine the nucleosynthesis in the gamma ray burst ejecta by studying the effect of the neutrino flux on the electron fraction of the material as it leaves the surface of the disk . we examine the conditions under which the electron fraction is quite low and the heaviest , @xmath0-process elements are likely to be produced . we also examine the the conditions under which the lighter iron peak nuclei are likely to be formed . determining the trajectories followed by mass elements ejected from the gamma ray burst accretion disk is a complicated problem . the trajectories depend on the initial thermodynamic parameters of the material , and the manner in which energy is imparted to the gas . with different accretion disk parameters , such as the viscosity , @xmath1 , spin parameter @xmath2 and size of the black hole , the results are likely to vary . although disk winds have been studied extensively in the context of other astrophysical objects such as agns and x - ray stars , a complete discussion of the outflow from gamma ray burst accretion disks has not yet been attempted . in order to investigate the impact of neutrino interactions on the electron fraction and therefore the nucleosynthesis coming from gamma ray burst disk outflow , we approximate disk outflow trajectories by using a two component approach . at very large distance , we use spherical symmetry . initially , however , the forces pushing the material off the accretion disk will be closer to vertical and we assume cylindrical symmetry . at short distances , therefore , the material moves approximately vertically , whereas at long distances , it moves radially away from the black hole . the general hydrodynamic equations in steady state for matter conservation , momentum conservation and energy conservation are , e.g. @xcite : @xmath3 @xmath4 @xmath5 here @xmath6 is the density , @xmath7 is pressure , @xmath8 is the velocity , @xmath9 is the energy per unit mass and @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the photon and neutrino fluxes respectively . the gravitational potential is represented by @xmath12 , while the notation @xmath13 represents a convective derivative . as discussed above , we divide the outflow into two regions , and approximate the outflow in these regions as having a cylindrical or spherical symmetry . for the case of spherically radial flow , we rewrite the mass and the momentum equation , so we have : @xmath14 @xmath15 in these equations @xmath16 is the mass loss rate , @xmath17 is the gravitational constant , and @xmath18 is the mass enclosed within radius @xmath0 . we also rewrite these equations for cylindrical geometry for vertical flow off the disk : @xmath19 \label{eq : cyl1}\ ] ] @xmath20 @xmath21 in the above equations @xmath22 is the radial cylindrical coordinate . in principle one should solve eqs . [ eq : cyl1 ] - [ eq : cyl3 ] ( or eqs . [ eq : sph1 ] - [ eq : sph2 ] ) together with with eq . [ eq : energy ] . however , because of the complex geometry , this involves a lengthy numerical calculation which is not practical until more accurate disk models become available . still , we would like to understand the importance of neutrino interactions in the outflow and what sort of electron fractions can obtain in this environment . therefore , in place of eqs . [ eq : energy ] and eq . [ eq : cyl2 ] -[eq : cyl3 ] ( or eq . [ eq : sph2 ] ) , we use a parameterization for the velocity , @xmath23 where @xmath24 for the first , vertical part of the trajectory and the starting position of the material is @xmath25 . once we switch to spherical flow @xmath26 . we study the results as functions of the parameters @xmath27 to @xmath28 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 to 600 km . although all trajectories with the same @xmath31 asymptote to the same value at large distance , the ones with smaller @xmath32 have a greater initial acceleration and arrive there more quickly . three velocity trajectories are shown in fig . [ fig : velocity ] as a function of distance from the black hole , all for the same @xmath32 and final velocity @xmath33 , but for two different initial starting points . we use the mass conservation equations ( eq . [ eq : cyl3 ] or eq . [ eq : sph2 ] ) in order to determine the density given the position and velocity . in the cylindrical case we assume the velocity is completely in the @xmath34 direction , and therefore there is no expansion of the material in the radial direction along the disk . in our calculations we assume a constant entropy , since any heating of the material should be done at the surface of the disk . we take the entropy as an input parameter in the range of @xmath35 to @xmath36 , from which we calculate the temperature at each step using the expression for the entropy in units of the boltzmann constant @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the photon entropy , @xmath39 is the entropy of the electron - positron pairs , and @xmath40 is the entropy of the nucleons . the photon entropy is given by @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the temperature in units of mev and @xmath43 is the density in units of @xmath44 . the entropy of the electron positron pairs is @xmath45\ ] ] @xmath46 where @xmath47 , @xmath48 is the mass of the electron and @xmath49 is the chemical potential of the electrons , which is determined by the temperature , density and electron fraction of the material @xmath50\ ] ] where @xmath51 we take the complete expression for the electron and positron pairs since we are neither in the limit where they are fully relativistic or fully non - relativistic . the approximate expression for the entropy of the nucleons is @xmath52 we begin the calculations when the material is at the surface of the disk . we start with disk conditions from the disk models of @xcite ( hereafter dpn ) for disks with accretion rates @xmath53 and from @xcite for more slowly accreting disks . we take the disk surface to be at the density scale height @xmath54 we begin the outflow in the vertical direction so @xmath55 is zero , and @xmath56 . we take steps in vertical distance , at each point determining a velocity , a density , temperature and electron chemical potential . we turn from the vertical solution to the cylindrical one when the material has reached one , two or three vertical scale heights above the disk , although this is the least sensitive parameter in this model . the results of this formulation for a relatively high accretion rate disk model and wind parameters , @xmath57 and @xmath58 ( model 1 ) , @xmath59 ( model 2 ) and @xmath60 ( model 3 ) are shown in figs . [ fig : xz ] , [ fig : rho ] and [ fig : t ] . in fig . [ fig : xz ] , we plot two sample trajectories in position space . since we have fixed the turnover point at two vertical scale heights , the final trajectories appear to lie almost on top of each other . as mentioned above , we found little impact on the results when examining different turnover points . in fig . [ fig : rho ] , we show the densities for these trajectories . in fig . [ fig : t ] the effect of a larger entropy can also be seen as a greater temperature at a given distance . next we use the trajectories developed in the previous section to calculate the evolution of the electron fraction due to electron , position , neutrino and antineutrino annihilation : @xmath61 @xmath62 since the electrons and positrons are in equilibrium with the baryons and photons and therefore their distribution can be described with the temperature , @xmath63 , and electron chemical potential @xmath49 , the forward rates in eqs.[eq : ecap ] and [ eq : poscap ] are easy to calculate . however , the neutrinos are not in equilibrium and their flux at each point on the trajectory must be calculated by summing over the neutrinos which originate at every part of the disk . in @xcite , we calculated the evolution of the electron fraction of a mass element as it spiraled from the outer edge of the toward the center . this was done by summing all contributions form the neutrino flux at all points on the disk , taking into account regions where the neutrinos become optically thick . these calculated electron fractions are the starting @xmath64s for the material ejected from the disk . furthermore , these neutrino fluxes are used to calculate the spectrum at every point above the disk through which the ejected material passes . in fig . [ fig : ye ] we show the results of using the reactions eqs . [ eq : ecap ] and [ eq : poscap ] to determine the electron fraction for models 1 , 2 , and 3 . dashed lines show the true electron fraction while the dot - dashed lines show the electron fraction calculated without neutrino capture interactions . in the high entropy models ( @xmath65 ) the large electron fractions are due to the increased importance of electron and positron capture at higher temperature . with higher temperatures the electrons and positrons essentially reset the electron fraction to a new equilibrium value and the material `` forgets '' its original disk value and winds up consisting of nearly equal numbers of neutrons and protons . this is evident in the initial sharp increase in the electron fraction . however , when the neutrino interactions have been included , the situation is quite different . even at these high entropies , the neutrinos have a marked impact on the evolution of the electron fraction , bringing it down to @xmath66 . the reverse rates in eq . [ eq : ecap ] and [ eq : poscap ] overwhelm the forward rates . furthermore , due to the higher energies of the electron antineutrinos , the antineutrino capture on protons is larger than neutrino capture on neutrons . as can be seen from the figure , the release point of the material determines the degree to which neutrino capture influences the final electron fractions . for lower entropies we find less of an increase in the electron fraction when the neutrino capture reactions are turned off . the lower entropy means that the system is partially electron degenerate , and so even while the electron and positron captures are maintaining a weak equilibrium by themselves , the electron fraction is quite low . note that the low entropy model corresponds to essentially no heating of the outflow material since the disk has an entropy of order 10 . in this section we explore the qualitative effect of variables such as entropy and outflow timescale on the electron fraction and therefore on the nucleosynthesis . we also explore different disk models . in the previous section we discussed the importance of entropy on the electron fraction . the outflowing material becomes less neutron rich if it is exposed to more positron capture , which happens when the entropy rises and the chemical potential decreases . [ fig : yevss ] shows the electron fraction measured at @xmath67 for several different entropies , for trajectories that start at @xmath68 and two different outflow parameters @xmath32 . this figure shows that at the highest entropies @xmath36 and fast accelerations @xmath69 , where the neutrinos have the least influence , the electron fraction can become as high as 0.45 , while for slow accelerations ( @xmath70 ) the neutrinos insure that the electron fraction is very low ( @xmath71 ) . the effect of the time scale of the outflow through the parameter @xmath32 is shown in fig . [ fig : yevsbeta ] . the material accelerates much more quickly at lower @xmath32 providing less opportunity for the neutrinos to move the system toward weak equilibrium . in the case of the high entropy , the effect is most pronounced . the higher betas mean more time for the neutrinos to drive the electron fraction down . in the case of the lower entropy , as previously noted the electrons and positrons already favor a low electron fraction , and so the electron fraction never gets very high . so far we have considered disk models with accretion rates of @xmath72 , and spin parameter @xmath73 . this model is desirable because it produces many neutrinos which create a large energy deposition from neutrino - antineutrino annihilation . such high accretion rates may be expected in the case of neutron star - neutron star mergers , but lower accretion rates are suggested for the collapsar model @xcite . however , increasing the spin parameter or viscosity is similar to increasing the accretion rate as far as driving up the neutrino flux . so the high accretion rate model we have considered may mimic a lower accretion rate model with a large spin parameter . when the accretion rate becomes lower an interesting effect occurs . at @xmath74 , @xmath73 the neutrino surface is at 200 km but by @xmath75 , @xmath73 , it has shrunk to 40 km . similarly the antineutrino sphere shrinks from 140 km to around 32 km ; see figures 3 and 4 in @xcite . there are relatively few antineutrinos because the antineutrino surface is quite small , however the neutrino capture rates are still large and the net effect can be to drive @xmath64 to very high values . this can be seen in fig . [ fig : mdot1 ] which gives the electron fraction for a @xmath76 model for various entropies both with neutrinos and without neutrinos . note the difference in the slow acceleration ( @xmath70 ) curves in figs . [ fig : yevss ] and [ fig : mdot1 ] . this model is most sensitive to the outflow parameters because the neutrino capture rates , while still quite strong , are smaller than in the @xmath74 model , by a factor of 2 - 3 for the neutrinos and an order of magnitude for the antineutrinos . because of the extreme sensitively to the neutrino parameters a neutrino diffusion calculation is needed to better determine the spectra and luminosity of the neutrinos and antineutrinos emitted at each part of the accretion disk . in fig . [ fig : mdot.1 ] , electron fractions for models with lower accretion rate disks of @xmath77 , @xmath78 are shown . in this model the material starts off with a low density and temperature relative to that of the higher accretion rate models . although there is only a very small region where the neutrinos are trapped in this disk , and the antineutrinos are not trapped at all , the influence of neutrino capture is apparent . even here , the electron fraction changes by as much as 30% in the upward direction depending on the model . such changes will have an important impact on the nucleosynthesis in the iron peak region . since the parameterization discussed here is independent of the heating mechanism , these results can be used as a rough gauge of the electron fraction and therefore the nucleosynthesis for any type of wind model . the nucleosynthesis that may be produced from configurations that give a low electron fraction is shown in figure [ fig : rprocess ] . here we show the results of an @xmath0-process calculation for @xmath35 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 . for this choice of parameters , the outflow does result in @xmath0-process abundances . however , it can be seen from the figure that although the neutrinos initially helped to keep the electron fraction low , they actually cause the a=195 peak to disappear in an alpha effect @xcite . the neutrino driven wind models for low accretion rate disks ( @xmath81 were discussed in @xcite . these fall at around @xmath70 , @xmath82 in our parameterization and we estimate that the electron fraction may be increased by as much as 5% - 20% by the neutrinos . these conditions may lead to a large overproduction of elements such as @xmath83 and @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 as discussed in @xcite . for winds that accelerate quickly from an accretion disk of around @xmath89 and @xmath73 , the electron fraction can become as high as 0.8 . in this case the nucleosynthesis would be dominated by nickel , in addition to making nuclei on the proton rich side of the valley of beta stability , such as @xmath90 , @xmath91,@xmath92 and @xmath93 . we have presented a parameter study for outflow from gamma ray burst accretion disk and calculated the electron fractions produced in these outflows . we have considered the impact of charge changing neutrino interactions on the outflow , using our previously calculated neutrino fluxes from every point on the disk @xcite . complete hydrodynamic models for the outflow for various disk parameters will become available in the future and the parameter study presented here can then be used to determine which disk models and outflows are likely to produce different types of nucleosynthesis , such as @xmath0-process or iron peak nuclei . for example , we find that the conditions that are most conducive to making the @xmath0-process elements come from those disks with high accretion rates or spin parameters , e.g. @xmath94 , @xmath73 , such that they produce a sizable region of trapped antineutrinos . disk models with somewhat lower accretion rates and spin parameters , e. g. @xmath95 , @xmath73 may still have a significant region of trapped neutrinos , but a smaller region of trapped antineutrinos . this causes the electron fractions to become very high , potentially as high as 0.8 . still lower accretion rate models , e.g. @xmath96 , @xmath78 will have have very small region of trapped neutrinos , which can raise the electron fraction by 5% to 30% . several parameters determine the electron fraction in the outflow , the outflow timescale , the entropy and the release point on the disk . the effect of the high entropy is to raise the electron fraction through positron capture . a more slowly accelerating wind increases the importance of neutrino and antineutrino capture which can drive the electron fraction up or down . releasing the material closer to the center of the disk has a similar effect . in all cases there is interesting nucleosynthesis to explore . however , if the @xmath0-process is to come from gamma ray bursts , it is necessary for some of the outflow material to have a small electron fraction . this requires high accretion rate , high spin models , and small amounts of heating in the wind . future observations of emission lines from gamma ray bursts , when combined with studies such as this one may be an avenue toward understanding not only the nucleosynthesis originating from grbs but also the conditions in the outflow and in the accretion disk itself . we wish to thank a. ud - doula and j. pruet for useful discussions . g. c. m. acknowledges support from the us department of energy under grant de - fg02 - 02er41216 , and r. s. acknowledges support from the research corporation under grant cc5994 . dimatteo , t. , perna , r. , & narayan , r. 2002 , 579 , 706 . duncan , r. c. , shapiro , s. l. , & wasserman , i. 1986 , , 309 , 141 . fujimoto , s. , hashimoto , m. , arai , k. , & matsuba , r. 2004 , astro - ph/0405510 . fuller , g. m. & meyer , b. s. 1995 453 , 792 . macfadyen , a. i. & woosley , s. e. 1999 , , 524 , 262 . macfadyen , a. i. 2003 , astro - ph/0301425 . maeda , k. & nomoto , k. 2003 , , 598 , 1163 . mclaughlin , g. c. , fuller , g. m. , & wilson , j. 1996 , 472 , 400 . mszros , p. 2002 , , 40 , 137 . narayan , r. , piran , t. , & kumar , p. 2001 , , 557 , 949 . popham , r. , woosley , s. e. , & fryer , c. 1999 , , 518 , 356 . pruet , j. , surman , r. , & mclaughlin , g. c. 2004 , , 602 , l101 . pruet , j. , woosley , s. e. , & hoffman , r. d. 2003 , , 586 , 1254 . pruet , j. , thompson , t. , & hoffman , r. d. 2004 , , in press . surman , r. & mclaughlin , g. c. 2004 , , 603 , 611 . woosley , s. e. 1993 , , 405 , 273 . ccccccccc 1 & dpn & @xmath97 & 0 & 0.1 & 20 & 0.8 & 100 km & @xmath98 km /s + 2 & dpn & @xmath97 & 0 & 0.1 & 10 & 0.8 & 250 km & @xmath99 km /s + 3 & dpn & @xmath97 & 0 & 0.1 & 20 & 0.8 & 250 km & @xmath99 km /s | we examine the composition of matter as it flows away from gamma ray burst accretion disks , in order to determine what sort of nucleosynthesis may occur . since there is a large flux of neutrinos leaving the surface of the disk , the electron fraction of the outflowing material will change due to charged current neutrino interactions . we calculate the electron fraction in the wind using detailed neutrino fluxes from every point on the disk and study a range of trajectories and outflow conditions for several different accretion disk models . we find that low electron fractions , conducive to making @xmath0-process elements , only appear in outflows from disks with high accretion rates that have a significant region both of trapped neutrinos and antineutrinos . disks with lower accretion rates that have only a significant region of trapped neutrinos can have outflows with very high electron fractions , whereas the lowest accretion rate disks with little trapping have outflow electrons fractions of closer to one half . |
astro-ph9809314 | rx j2115 - 5840 ( euve 211658.6 ) was discovered during the _ rosat _ ( voges et al 1996 ) and _ euve _ ( bowyer et al 1996 ) all sky surveys . subsequent ground based observations confirmed the source as a polar . schwope et al ( 1997 ) suggested that the orbital and spin periods of rx j2115 - 5840 differ by @xmath01% . this would make it the fourth near synchronous polar and the first one below the 23 hr period gap . we obtained 2 weeks of white light polarimetric observations in july - aug 1997 at saao to investigate this possibility . the circular polarisation data are shown in fig . [ cpol ] : the circular polarisation is generally either close to zero or shows positive excursions . however , there are occasions when negative polarisation is seen ( hjd 2450000 + 659 , 666 and 672 ) . these observations suggests that rx j211558 is not fully synchronised . ( 6,8 ) ( -3,-2 . ) to investigate the circular polarisation data more closely , we used a discrete fourier transform to obtain an amplitude spectrum ( fig [ power ] ) . the highest amplitude peak corresponds to a period of 110.889 mins similar to the spectroscopic period of 110.8 mins reported by vennes et al ( 1996 ) . the second highest peak corresponds to a period of 109.547 mins similar to the shorter of the two possible optical photometric periods , 109.84 and 109.65 mins , reported by schwope et al ( 1997 ) . if we assume that the binary orbital period is @xmath1=110.889 min and the spin period of the white dwarf is @xmath2=109.547 min we find the following more complex frequencies in the amplitude spectrum : 3@xmath1 , 2@xmath2 , 3@xmath2 , @xmath3 , 2@xmath4 , 4@xmath13@xmath2 . any other frequencies which are present have amplitudes lower than 1% . the spin - orbit beat frequency corresponds to a period of 7.1 days . ( 8,7 ) ( -4,-28.5 ) to make a more detailed investigation of these data we folded the circular polarimetry on the proposed spin and orbital periods and the spin - orbital beat period ( the left hand panel of fig [ beat_phase ] ) . folding the data which correspond to a discrete beat phase on the proposed spin period of the white dwarf , we find that the polarisation curve shows a negative excursion lasting approximately half the spin cycle . at other spin phases the polarisation is close to zero ( the right hand panel of fig [ beat_phase ] ) . at @xmath5=0.20 the polarisation is not significantly modulated . at other beat phases a prominent positive hump is seen in the folded spin polarisation curves , the peak of which advances in phase as @xmath5 increases . ( 8,7 ) ( -3.5,-29.5 ) in fully synchronous polars , the accretion flow is locked with respect to the binary orbital rotation frame and the bulk of the accretion flow is thought to be directed onto the geometrically preferred magnetic pole of the white dwarf . however , in the case of near - synchronous polars , the accretion flow rotates around the magnetic field of the white dwarf on the spin - orbit beat period . this has the effect that the accretion flow will be directed preferentially onto first one then the other magnetic pole of the white dwarf . at two phases of the spin - orbit beat period we expect that the flow will be equally directed onto both poles . this ` pole - switch ' will manifest itself most obviously in the circular polarisation curves where the polarisation will change sign after the accretion flow has ` switched ' poles . this is seen in the right hand panel of fig [ beat_phase ] where at @xmath60.00 the polarisation is modulated with a positive hump , but at @xmath60.07 and 0.17 it is modulated with a negative hump . we consider two accretion scenarios which are described in fig [ scenario ] . the phasing of the data on the spin , orbital and beat phases requires that the accretion flow must be directed onto the same magnetic field line at all spin - orbit beat phases implying that at some phases the flow must follow a path around the white dwarf before accreting . this is difficult to reconcile with simple views of how the accretion stream attaches onto the magnetic field of the white dwarf . possible reasons for this are described in a more detailed paper that has been submitted to _ | schwope et al ( 1997 ) suggested that the newly discovered polar rx j2115 - 5840 is a near - synchronous system . we have obtained circular polarisation observations of rx j2115 - 5840 which show that the spin and orbital periods differ by 1.2% . we find the first direct evidence of ` pole - switching ' in a near - synchronous polar . further our data requires that the accretion flow must be directed onto the same magnetic field line at all spin - orbit beat phases implying that at some phases the flow must follow a path around the white dwarf before accreting . |
0905.2022 | the origin of the baryon asymmetry of the universe ( bau ) has been a great puzzle in particle physics and cosmology . from the latest observations of the cosmic microwave background radiations , the supernovae and the large scale structures , the baryon - to - photon ratio is given by @xcite @xmath6 the nonzero bau can be generated if the following three conditions are fulfilled @xcite : ( i ) baryon number ( @xmath7 ) violation , ( ii ) @xmath8 and @xmath0 violation , and ( iii ) departure from thermal equilibrium . electroweak baryogenesis is a scenario in which the bau is explained based only on electroweak physics @xcite . the standard model ( sm ) can in principle accommodate above three conditions . however , it turns out that the sm fails to generate the bau due to the lack of sufficient @xmath0 violation @xcite , and the electroweak phase transition ( ewpt ) is a smooth cross over for @xmath9 gev @xcite , which makes the condition ( iii ) infeasible . this failure motivates us to go beyond the sm . so far , many attempts of electroweak baryogenesis have been made in the various new physics models such as the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) @xcite , the two - higgs - doublet model @xcite , the singlet - extended mssms @xcite , and recently the fourth - generation models also have been paid much attention @xcite . among them , the mssm is a theoretically well - motivated model and a good candidate for successful electroweak baryogenesis . as far as the strong first order ewpt which is necessary for condition ( iii ) is concerned , the light higgs boson is generically favored . on the other hand , the negative results of the higgs boson(s ) searches at lep put the constraints on the higgs boson masses in the mssm @xcite . the analysis has been done based on several benchmarks rather than scanning whole parameter space . recently , it is pointed out that the lep constraints can be relaxed in the more general case . in ref . @xcite , it is found that the lightest higgs boson mass can be smaller than the @xmath1 boson mass . such a light higgs boson can be viable since its coupling to @xmath1 boson is modified by the additional higgs bosons and suppressed enough to avoid the experimental observed limits . we call a light higgs boson scenario ( lhs ) when the mass of the lightest higgs boson is less than 114.4 gev . this scenario can accommodate the @xmath10 excess around 98 gev higgs boson mass in the lep experiments @xcite and have parameter space that is consistent with the observed dark matter relic density @xcite . in ref . @xcite , it is claimed that the lhs can provide a solution for a little hierarchy problem as well . as for the electroweak baryogenesis context , since the neutral higgs bosons are relatively light , they may give a new window to a viable baryogenesis scenario . in the electroweak baryogenesis mechanism , a sphaleron process must be decoupled after the ewpt in order to avoid the washout of the generated bau . because of this requirement , the ratio of the higgs vacuum expectation value ( vev ) to the temperature in question should be greater than some value . to search for the region where the strong first order ewpt is realized , and which is also experimentally allowed , not only the theoretical calculations of the zero temperature observables but also those at the finite temperature are mandatory . the accuracy of the former calculations are already beyond at least the tree level . on the other hand , the sphaleron decoupling condition , which is derived using the tree - level higgs potential at zero temperature , has been frequently used to discuss the strength of the strong first order ewpt in the literature . namely , @xmath11 is adopted as a practical criterion , where @xmath12 is the critical temperature at which the higgs potential has two degenerate minima and @xmath13 is the higgs vev at @xmath12 . to obtain more accurate theoretical predictions , the refined calculation of the sphaleron decoupling condition is indispensable . the uncertainties of the condition is expected to be reduced up to about 10% level if we make the following improvements , i.e. , the sphaleron solution at finite temperature is used and the contributions from the zero modes of the fluctuations around sphaleron at finite temperature are taken into account . in addition , the sphaleron decoupling condition must be imposed at the temperature @xmath14 lower than @xmath12 , at which the ewpt terminates . in practice , since it is difficult to determine this temperature , we substitute @xmath15 , a nucleation temperature of the critical bubble , in place of @xmath14 . the critical bubble is defined as the bubble whose surface energy and volume energy becomes balanced . only such bubbles can nucleate and expand in the symmetric phase . in this article , the possibility of the strong first order ewpt in the lhs and the conventional decoupling limit is examined with a particular emphasis on the refinement of the sphaleron decoupling condition . the analysis is conducted taking the latest experimental data into account as well . it is well known that a light stop whose mass is smaller than that of top quark is required for the strong first order ewpt . we search for the parameter space that is consistent with such a light stop . in the lhs , since the masses of all the higgs bosons are relatively light , typically , @xmath16 gev , the @xmath7 physics observables data can restrict the allowed region . here , we consider the constraints from the following processes : @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 . the first two modes are relevant when the charged higgs bosons are light . the last one , which has not been observed yet , can give a significant limit when the neutral higgs boson is light . after finding the phenomenologically allowed region , we investigate the strength of the ewpt at not only @xmath12 but also @xmath15 . by using the one - loop effective potential at zero and finite temperatures , we calculate the sphaleron energy and the contributions from zero modes of the fluctuations around sphaleron to evaluate the sphaleron decoupling condition . it is then demonstrated whether or not such an improved sphaleron decoupling condition is satisfied at @xmath12 and @xmath15 . this article is organized as follows : in sec . [ sec : gh ] , we present the lagrangian of the gauge - higgs system for describing the statics and dynamics of the ewpt . the lhs is discussed in sec . [ sec : lhs ] . the qualitative evaluation of the ewpt is outlined in sec . [ sec : ewpt ] . the critical bubbles and the sphaleron decoupling condition are analyzed in secs . [ sec : cri_bub ] and [ sec : sph_dec ] , respectively . the experimental constraints are considered in sec . [ sec : ex_const ] . in sec . [ sec : numerical ] , we show the numerical results . section [ sec : con_dis ] is devoted to the conclusion and discussion . in the appendix [ app : mass_squared ] , we give the mass - squared matrices of the squarks to make our notation clear . to discuss the statics and dynamics of the ewpt , we consider the gauge - higgs system , which is governed by the lagrangian @xmath20 the covariant derivatives are @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the pauli matrices , @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the gauge couplings for @xmath25 and @xmath26 , respectively . @xmath27 is the effective potential , which is composed of the tree and one - loop parts @xmath28 the tree - level part is given by the f- , d- , and the soft supersymmetry ( susy ) breaking terms @xmath29 where @xmath30 the higgs doublets are parameterized as @xmath31 where we assume that @xmath32 is not broken at the vacuum . unlike the general two - higgs - doublet model @xcite , @xmath0 violation can not be accommodated in the higgs potential at the tree level , leading to @xmath33 . the one - loop part comprises the effective potentials at zero and nonzero temperatures @xmath34,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the zero temperature effective potential , which is regularized in the @xmath37 scheme , @xmath38 denotes the degrees of freedom of particle species @xmath39 , @xmath40 is the background - field - dependent mass , and @xmath41 is a renormalization scale , which is determined in such a way that the zero temperature one - loop correction to the effective potential vanishes in the vacuum . in what follows , the contributions of the weak gauge bosons ( @xmath42 ) , the third - generation quarks ( @xmath43 ) , and squarks ( @xmath44 ) are taken into account . the statistical factors of each particle is , respectively , given by @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the number of color . in this article , we use the one - loop mass formulae of the higgs bosons presented in ref . @xcite . to make a discussion on the lhs clear , we rotate the two higgs doublets @xmath47 into @xmath48 by @xmath49 . for simplicity , we assume that @xmath0 is conserved for the moment . the rotated higgs doublets are cast into the form @xmath50 where @xmath51 gev , @xmath39 is the @xmath0-odd higgs boson , @xmath52 is the charged higgs boson and ( @xmath53 ) are the nambu - goldstone bosons . @xmath54 and @xmath55 are related to the physical @xmath0-even higgs bosons ( @xmath56 ) via @xmath57 where @xmath58 is a mixing angle between @xmath59 and @xmath60 . it should be noticed that only @xmath54 possesses the higgs vev in the rotated basis , and we can identify it the sm - like higgs boson , i.e. , @xmath61 . at the tree level , the higgs boson couplings to @xmath1 boson normalized to the corresponding sm values are , respectively , given by @xmath62 from eqs . ( [ rotated_phi ] ) , ( [ rotated_h ] ) , ( [ higgs_zz ] ) and ( [ higgs_za ] ) , one can see that @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 for @xmath66 and @xmath67 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 for @xmath70 . the former case ( decoupling limit ) is realized by taking @xmath71 and the latter one ( antidecoupling limit ) is possible for @xmath72 , which corresponds to the lhs . depending on the theory parameters , some of the above four higgs boson couplings can be small enough to avoid the lep exclusion limits . in the lhs , for example , @xmath73 can be as light as about 100 gev for @xmath74 . however , from the sum rules among the higgs boson couplings , i.e. , @xmath75 , not all higgs bosons are allowed to be light . if the higgs boson is the sm - like , the mass of it should be larger than 114.4 gev since its coupling to the @xmath1 boson becomes the sm value . we will discuss the experimental constraints in more detail in sec . [ sec : ex_const ] . finally , we comment on the @xmath0-violating case . although @xmath0 is conserved in the tree - level higgs sector , it can be broken by the radiative corrections such as the top / stop loops . the realization of the maximal @xmath0 violation is called the cpx scenario @xcite . in this scenario , it is possible to accommodate an even lighter higgs boson . for instance , the mass of the lightest higgs boson can be as small as 40 gev , which is experimentally viable . it is interesting to discuss the phenomenological consequences of this scenario . however , the cpx scenario requires the relatively large ratios of @xmath76 assuming @xmath77 , which is not favored in the context of the strong first order ewpt that we will discuss in the next section . to explain how the first order ewpt is strengthened in the mssm , we here give a brief review on the light stop scenario . to simplify the discussion , we use the high temperature expansion in the effective potential @xcite . in the decoupling limit , @xmath73 is responsible for the electroweak symmetry breaking since @xmath78 . on the other hand , @xmath3 is mostly shared by @xmath79 in the lhs . if the ewpt is first order , the critical temperature @xmath80 is given by the temperature at which the effective potential has two degenerate minima . let @xmath13 be the nonzero vev at @xmath12 . from the argument using the high temperature expansion : @xmath81 in @xmath82 , one can see that @xmath83 can be enhanced when the quartic term in @xmath27 gets smaller and/or the coefficient of the cubic term with a negative coefficient ( denoted @xmath84 ) becomes larger . the former implies that the light @xmath85 is favored in the decoupling / lhs limit . the latter can be realized by the additional contributions from the bosons . in fact , the effect of the lighter stop @xmath86 on @xmath84 is sizable due to the large top yukawa coupling constant ( @xmath87 ) and the degrees of freedom , i.e. , @xmath88 . in the high temperature expansion , one can obtain @xmath89 where @xmath90 where @xmath91 and the @xmath92 contributions are neglected in the stop contribution , also the hierarchies between the soft susy breaking masses are implicitly assumed , namely , @xmath93 are taken to be consistent with the lep bounds on the higgs boson mass and the @xmath94 parameter . as a result of @xmath95 , which is necessary for the enhancement of the loop effect , the lighter stop mass becomes less than the top mass @xmath96 . from eq . ( [ dele_hte ] ) , one can easily see that the no - mixing case @xmath97 maximizes the loop effect . if we assume @xmath98 , we obtain @xmath99 , which is about 6 times as large as the sm contributions . to make the analysis on the ewpt precisely , the corrections from the daisy diagrams must be taken into account , which yield the temperature dependent terms in the field - dependent masses of particles . for the light stop , we effectively have the following mass shift to leading order : @xmath100 where @xmath101 is positive and composed of the relevant couplings in the theory . therefore , the ewpt would get weaker even if @xmath102 . nonetheless , as advocated in ref . @xcite the choice of @xmath103 , which can induce the charge - color - breaking ( ccb ) vacuum , may still realize the same enhancement of the stop loop effect as outlined above . for simplicity , we will not pursue this possibility and take @xmath104 putting the daisy diagrams aside in this article . our analysis on the strength of the ewpt is expected to be the same , or might be more optimistic than the more realistic case depending on the model parameters . the high temperature expansion makes it easy to see how the first order phase transition is strengthened analytically . it is , however , untrustworthy to use the approximation when the masses of the particles in loops are somewhat larger than @xmath12 . we thus adopt a different method . although the numerical integrations contained in the definitions of @xmath82 are the standard way , it is an extremely time - consuming task . therefore , we will use the following fitting functions in our numerical analysis : @xmath105 where the coefficients @xmath106 are determined by the least squared method . for @xmath107 , the errors of @xmath108 do not exceed @xmath109 for any @xmath110 , which is sufficient for our purpose . to determine @xmath12 and @xmath13 , we minimize @xmath27 with eq . ( [ i_fit ] ) in the three dimensional space @xmath111 numerically . the first order ewpt begins at somewhat below @xmath12 . for the ewpt to proceed , the radius of the bubble should be larger than some critical size , otherwise it would shrink by the surface tension of the bubble wall . the bubble of this critical size is called the critical bubble . after nucleation of the critical bubbles , they start to percolate and eventually convert the symmetric phase into the broken phase if the supercooling is not too large . from eq . ( [ gauge - higgs ] ) , the energy functional in the temporal gauge takes the form @xmath112.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we assume that the least energy has the pure - gauge configurations for @xmath113 and @xmath114 , hence @xmath115 . since a spherically symmetric configuration can give the least energy , the higgs fields depend only on radial coordinate @xmath116 . the classical higgs fields are parameterized as @xmath117 where the gauge - invariant constant phase @xmath94 will be taken to make the boundary value @xmath118 at @xmath119 to vanish . to remove the energy source for the @xmath1 boson from the higgs current , the so - called sourcelessness condition " @xcite @xmath120 must be satisfied . now let us introduce @xmath121 and @xmath122 . one can easily see that only @xmath123 is a gauge - independent phase . equation ( [ sourcelessness ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath124 which is used to eliminate @xmath125 . the energy functional is then reduced to @xmath126.\end{aligned}\ ] ] from this , the equations of motion ( eom ) for @xmath127 and @xmath123 are , respectively , given by @xmath128 the solutions can exist only when the temperature lies in the range @xmath129 , where @xmath130 is the temperature at which the higgs potential at the origin is destabilized in some direction . since we focus on the @xmath0-conserving bubble walls @xcite , @xmath131 is set to be zero in the following discussion . the studies of the @xmath0-violating bubble walls can be found in refs . the boundary conditions for eom are imposed in the symmetric ( @xmath119 ) and broken ( @xmath132 ) phases as @xmath133 it is convenient to parameterize the higgs profiles @xmath134 in terms of the dimensionless quantities @xmath135 then @xmath84 takes the form @xmath136,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath137 . correspondingly , the eom are rewritten as @xmath138 with the boundary conditions @xmath139 we will comment on the numerical method to solve the eom for @xmath140 and @xmath141 in sec . [ subsec : relaxation ] . the bubble nucleation rate per unit time per unit volume is given by @xcite @xmath142 where @xmath143 is the energy of the critical bubble at temperature @xmath4 . note that this is a rate per unit volume . we define the nucleation temperature @xmath15 as the temperature at which the rate of the nucleation of a critical bubble within a horizon volume is equal to the hubble parameter at that temperature . since the horizon scale is roughly given by @xmath144 , the nucleation temperature is defined by @xmath145 where @xmath146 is the massless degrees of freedom at @xmath15 and @xmath147 is the planck mass ( @xmath148 gev ) . since a single bubble nucleated within the horizon volume can not convert the whole region to the broken phase , the nucleation temperature defined by eq . ( [ def_tn ] ) simply gives an upper bound of the temperature at which the ewpt starts . to determine @xmath15 more precisely , simulations or the methods employed in ref . @xcite are needed . from eq . ( [ def_tn ] ) , it follows that @xmath149 roughly , @xmath150 is necessary for the development of the ewpt . to solve the eom ( [ eom_h1 ] ) and ( [ eom_h2 ] ) under the boundary conditions ( [ bc_h ] ) , we use relaxation methods . " to implement the relaxation methods successfully , the initial configurations of the bubbles are of great importance . here , we take the kink - type ansatz for them , i.e. , @xmath151 where @xmath152 is the radius of the bubbles and @xmath153 is the bubble wall width . since the best values of @xmath152 and @xmath153 can vary as the temperature goes down , it is impossible to know them in advance . nonetheless , it turns out that in most cases @xmath154 can give the successful initial configurations as long as @xmath4 lies somewhere between @xmath15 and @xmath12 . after obtaining the convergent solutions at some temperature , we use them as the initial configurations to search for the critical bubbles at the temperature which is near the previous one . by doing this process iteratively , we find @xmath15 . as shown by manton in ref . @xcite , the static and unstable classical solution with a finite energy can exist in the @xmath155 gauge theory . such a configuration is called sphaleron , which has a maximal energy along the least energy path . similar to the instanton process at zero temperature , the baryon number can be violated by the sphaleron process at finite temperature . although the instanton process , which is quantum tunneling , is highly suppressed and unobservable , the sphaleron process , which is thermal fluctuation , can be active at high temperature , especially before the electroweak symmetry is broken . in order to avoid the washout of the generated bau after the phase transition , the sphaleron process must be decoupled . this condition can be obtained by demanding that the baryon number changing rate be smaller than the hubble parameter @xcite @xmath156 where @xmath157 is number of generation , @xmath158 , @xmath159 is the negative mode of the fluctuations around sphaleron , @xmath160 is the @xmath161 coefficient @xcite , @xmath162 and @xmath163 are contributions from the translational and rotational zero modes , respectively , @xmath164 is the sphaleron energy . if we denote the sphaleron energy as @xmath165 , eq . ( [ sph_dec1 ] ) can be translated into @xmath166 . \label{sph_cond}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it should be noted that model dependent parameters other than the sphaleron energy in the right - hand side of eq . ( [ sph_cond ] ) contribute only logarithmically . in the sm @xcite , the sphaleron solution obtained with the tree - level higgs potential yields @xmath167 @xcite , @xmath168 @xcite , @xmath169 @xcite for @xmath170 . inserting these values into eq . ( [ sph_cond ] ) together with @xmath171 , @xmath172 , and @xmath173 gev , we find @xmath174 where @xmath175 @xcite is used . it is found that the contributions of the zero mode factors to @xmath2 can reach around 10% , while the contributions from the last three terms in the right - hand side of eq . ( [ sph_cond ] ) are only about 1% . now we discuss the sphaleron decoupling condition in the mssm . as an example , we take @xmath176 , @xmath177 gev , @xmath178 gev , @xmath179 gev , @xmath180 gev , @xmath181 gev . this parameter set is experimentally allowed as we will discuss in sec . [ sec : numerical ] . to see the effects of the temperature dependence of the sphaleron solution and the zero mode factors on the sphaleron decoupling condition , we consider the following three cases : * the sphaleron decoupling condition without the zero mode factors based on the zero temperature potential @xmath182 . * the sphaleron decoupling condition with the zero mode factors based on the zero temperature potential @xmath182 . * the sphaleron decoupling condition with the zero mode factors based on the full effective potential @xmath183 . the result of each case is summarized in table [ tab : sph_cond ] . @xmath184 is used in the right - hand side of eq . ( [ sph_cond ] ) . as we see from i and ii , the contribution of the zero mode factors to the sphaleron decoupling condition can be as large as 10% level , which is the same as in the sm case . in case iii , @xmath185 is obtained , which is about 40% stronger than the usual rough estimate used in the literature . we look into this case in more detail in the following . the temperature dependences of @xmath186 , @xmath162 and @xmath163 are plotted in fig . [ fig : sph_profile ] . the endpoints of those curves correspond to those at @xmath12 . the left panel shows that the sphaleron energy decreases as @xmath4 increases . the change of the sphaleron energy is sizable around @xmath12 , hence which can be the dominant error of the sphaleron decoupling condition if we neglect this effect . on the other hand , as shown in the right panel the temperature dependences of @xmath162 and @xmath163 are mild and thus have little effects on @xmath2 . from this analysis , we conclude that in order to evaluate the sphaleron decoupling condition within a 10% accuracy , the sphaleron solution and the zero mode factors at finite temperature must be taken into account . here , we comment on the earlier work @xcite . the authors have evaluated sphaleron at finite temperature using the one - loop finite - temperature effective potential with the daisy resummations . in their analysis , only the energy was calculated and the zero mode factors were missing . to search for the possible region where the ewpt is strong first order , they used the following sphaleron decoupling condition @xcite : @xmath187 in our calculation including the zero mode factors , this condition is translated into @xmath188 in case iii . .the sphaleron decoupling conditions in the three cases i , ii , and iii . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab : summary_dec ] we have reanalyzed the strong first order ewpt in the mssm considering the experimental results such as the lep and the latest @xmath7 physics data . @xmath2 was evaluated at both @xmath12 and @xmath15 in the lhs and ordinary decoupling limit . in the lhs with a light stop , the no - mixing scenario , which can maximize the stop thermal loop effect , can not be realized due to the severe constraint from @xmath18 . combining with the other experimental data , especially the lep and @xmath189 mode , the allowed region becomes more constrained . the sphaleron decoupling condition was also calculated using the one - loop effective potential at finite temperature . we found that the contributions of the zero mode factors coming from the fluctuations around sphaleron can be as large as about 10% . in the phenomenologically allowed region , the typical values of the sphaleron decoupling conditions at @xmath15 are found to be @xmath190 . it is observed that about 10% enhancement of @xmath2 is possible at @xmath15 in comparison with that at @xmath12 . we find that @xmath191 in the lhs and @xmath192 in the decoupling limit . however , such a strength of the ewpt is not enough to satisfy the sphaleron decoupling condition . although electroweak baryogenesis in the mssm seems to be infeasible , it may be possible to circumvent the above negative conclusion . some comments on the possible loopholes are in order . firstly , the sphaleron decoupling condition is supposed to be imposed at the temperature at which the ewpt ends , which can relax the decoupling condition . secondly , our calculations , which are based on the one - loop effective potential , can be modified by the higher - order loop contributions such as the two - loop effects @xcite . lastly , as we mentioned briefly in sec . [ sec : ewpt ] the scalar potential can be extended in such a way that the lighter stop also has the vev , which can develop the ccb vacuum . in ref . @xcite it is claimed that the ewpt is strong first order when the electroweak vacuum is metastable and the ccb vacuum is the global minimum . since the time scale of the decay of the metastable vacuum is longer than the age of the universe , this scenario is viable . the two - loop contributions are also included in their calculation . it is interesting to investigate whether or not the ewpt is still strong enough to satisfy the sphaleron decoupling conditions that we have considered in this article . a devoted study of the ewpt and the sphaleron decoupling condition based on the two - loop effective potential will be given elsewhere @xcite . here , we give the expressions of the mass - squared matrices of the stop and sbottom @xmath193 where @xmath87 and @xmath194 are the top and bottom yukawa couplings , respectively . c. amsler _ et al . _ [ particle data group ] , phys . b * 667 * , 1 ( 2008 ) . a. d. sakharov , pisma zh . fiz . * 5 * , 32 ( 1967 ) [ jetp lett . * 5 * , 24 ( 1967 sopua,34,392 - 393.1991 ufnaa,161,61 - 64.1991 ) ] . for reviews , see a. g. cohen , d. b. kaplan and a. e. nelson , ann . nucl . part . sci . * 43 * , 27 ( 1993 ) ; m. quiros , helv . acta * 67 * , 451 ( 1994 ) ; v. a. rubakov and m. e. shaposhnikov , usp . fiz . nauk * 166 * , 493 ( 1996 ) [ phys . 39 * , 461 ( 1996 ) ] ; k. funakubo , prog . * 96 * , 475 ( 1996 ) ; m. trodden , rev . phys . * 71 * , 1463 ( 1999 ) ; w. bernreuther , lect . notes phys . * 591 * , 237 ( 2002 ) . m. b. gavela , p. hernandez , j. orloff and o. pene , mod . lett . a * 9 * ( 1994 ) 795 ; m. b. gavela , p. hernandez , j. orloff , o. pene and c. quimbay , nucl . phys . b * 430 * ( 1994 ) 382 ; p. huet and e. sather , phys . d * 51 * ( 1995 ) 379 ; t. konstandin , t. prokopec and m. g. schmidt , nucl . b * 679 * ( 2004 ) 246 . k. kajantie , m. laine , k. rummukainen and m. e. shaposhnikov , phys . lett . * 77 * , 2887 ( 1996 ) ; k. rummukainen , m. tsypin , k. kajantie , m. laine and m. e. shaposhnikov , nucl . b * 532 * , 283 ( 1998 ) ; f. csikor , z. fodor and j. heitger , phys . lett . * 82 * , 21 ( 1999 ) ; y. aoki , f. csikor , z. fodor and a. ukawa , phys . d * 60 * , 013001 ( 1999 ) . m. s. carena , m. quiros and c. e. m. wagner , phys . b * 380 * , 81 ( 1996 ) . d. delepine , j. m. gerard , r. gonzalez felipe and j. weyers , phys . b * 386 * , 183 ( 1996 ) ; p. huet and a. e. nelson , phys . d * 53 * , 4578 ( 1996 ) ; b. de carlos and j. r. espinosa , nucl . b * 503 * , 24 ( 1997 ) ; m. s. carena , m. quiros , a. riotto , i. vilja and c. e. m. wagner , nucl . phys . b * 503 * , 387 ( 1997 ) ; a. riotto , nucl . phys . b * 518 * , 339 ( 1998 ) ; m. s. carena , m. quiros and c. e. m. wagner , nucl . b * 524 * , 3 ( 1998 ) ; k. funakubo , a. kakuto , s. otsuki and f. toyoda , prog . phys . * 99 * , 1045 ( 1998 ) ; a. riotto , phys . d * 58 * , 095009 ( 1998 ) ; k. funakubo , prog . theor . * 101 * , 415 ( 1999 ) ; k. funakubo , s. otsuki and f. toyoda , prog . phys . * 102 * , 389 ( 1999 ) ; j. m. cline , m. joyce and k. kainulainen , jhep * 0007 * , 018 ( 2000 ) ; m. s. carena , j. m. moreno , m. quiros , m. seco and c. e. m. wagner , nucl . phys . b * 599 * , 158 ( 2001 ) ; m. s. carena , m. quiros , m. seco and c. e. m. wagner , nucl . b * 650 * , 24 ( 2003 ) ; t. prokopec , m. g. schmidt and s. weinstock , annals phys . * 314 * , 208 ( 2004 ) ; t. prokopec , m. g. schmidt and s. weinstock , annals phys . * 314 * , 267 ( 2004 ) ; t. konstandin , t. prokopec and m. g. schmidt , nucl . b * 716 * , 373 ( 2005 ) ; c. lee , v. cirigliano and m. j. ramsey - musolf , phys . d * 71 * , 075010 ( 2005 ) ; v. cirigliano , m. j. ramsey - musolf , s. tulin and c. lee , phys . d * 73 * , 115009 ( 2006 ) ; t. konstandin , t. prokopec , m. g. schmidt and m. seco , nucl . b * 738 * , 1 ( 2006 ) ; v. cirigliano , s. profumo and m. j. ramsey - musolf , jhep * 0607 * , 002 ( 2006 ) ; d. j. h. chung , b. garbrecht , m. j. ramsey - musolf and s. tulin , phys . lett . * 102 * , 061301 ( 2009 ) . k. funakubo , s. tao and f. toyoda , prog . theor . * 109 * , 415 ( 2003 ) . m. carena , g. nardini , m. quiros and c. e. m. wagner , nucl . b * 812 * , 243 ( 2009 ) . k. funakubo , a. kakuto and k. takenaga , prog . * 91 * , 341 ( 1994 ) ; m. joyce , t. prokopec and n. turok , phys . d * 53 * , 2930 ( 1996 ) ; m. joyce , t. prokopec and n. turok , phys . d * 53 * , 2958 ( 1996 ) ; j. m. cline , k. kainulainen and a. p. vischer , phys . d * 54 * , 2451 ( 1996 ) ; j. m. cline and p. a. lemieux , phys . d * 55 * , 3873 ( 1997 ) ; s. kanemura , y. okada and e. senaha , phys . b * 606 * , 361 ( 2005 ) ; l. fromme , s. j. huber and m. seniuch , jhep * 0611 * , 038 ( 2006 ) . s. j. huber and m. g. schmidt , nucl . b * 606 * , 183 ( 2001 ) ; a. menon , d. e. morrissey and c. e. m. wagner , phys . d * 70 * , 035005 ( 2004 ) ; j. kang , p. langacker , t. j. li and t. liu , phys . rev . lett . * 94 * , 061801 ( 2005 ) ; k. funakubo , s. tao and f. toyoda , prog . * 114 * , 369 ( 2005 ) ; s. j. huber , t. konstandin , t. prokopec and m. g. schmidt , nucl . b * 757 * , 172 ( 2006 ) ; c. balazs , m. s. carena , a. freitas and c. e. m. wagner , jhep * 0706 * , 066 ( 2007 ) . w. s. hou , arxiv:0803.1234 [ hep - ph ] ; r. fok and g. d. kribs , phys . d * 78 * , 075023 ( 2008 ) ; y. kikukawa , m. kohda and j. yasuda , arxiv:0901.1962 [ hep - ph ] . r. barate _ [ lep working group for higgs boson searches and aleph collaboration and and ] , phys . b * 565 * , 61 ( 2003 ) . s. schael _ et al . _ [ aleph collaboration and delphi collaboration and l3 collaboration and ] , eur . j. c * 47 * , 547 ( 2006 ) . a. belyaev , q. h. cao , d. nomura , k. tobe and c. p. yuan , phys . lett . * 100 * , 061801 ( 2008 ) . m. asano , s. matsumoto , m. senami and h. sugiyama , phys . b * 663 * , 330 ( 2008 ) ; s. g. kim , n. maekawa , k. i. nagao , k. sakurai and t. yoshikawa , phys . rev . d * 78 * , 075010 ( 2008 ) . s. g. kim , n. maekawa , a. matsuzaki , k. sakurai , a. i. sanda and t. yoshikawa , phys . d * 74 * , 115016 ( 2006 ) . j. f. gunion , h. e. haber , g. l. kane and s. dawson , `` the higgs hunter s guide , '' ; `` errata for the higgs hunter s guide , '' arxiv : hep - ph/9302272 . a. pilaftsis and c. e. m. wagner , nucl . b * 553 * , 3 ( 1999 ) ; m. s. carena , j. r. ellis , a. pilaftsis and c. e. m. wagner , nucl . b * 586 * , 92 ( 2000 ) ; m. s. carena , j. r. ellis , a. pilaftsis and c. e. m. wagner , phys . b * 495 * , 155 ( 2000 ) ; m. s. carena , j. r. ellis , a. pilaftsis and c. e. m. wagner , nucl . phys . b * 625 * , 345 ( 2002 ) ; j. s. lee , a. pilaftsis , m. s. carena , s. y. choi , m. drees , j. r. ellis and c. e. m. wagner , comput . commun . * 156 * , 283 ( 2004 ) . j. s. lee , m. carena , j. ellis , a. pilaftsis and c. e. m. wagner , comput . commun . * 180 * , 312 ( 2009 ) . l. dolan and r. jackiw , phys . d * 9 * , 3320 ( 1974 ) . k. funakubo , a. kakuto , s. otsuki , k. takenaga and f. toyoda , prog . theor . phys . * 94 * , 845 ( 1995 ) ; k. funakubo , a. kakuto , s. otsuki and f. toyoda , prog . phys . * 98 * , 427 ( 1997 ) . j. m. moreno , m. quiros and m. seco , nucl . b * 526 * , 489 ( 1998 ) . s. j. huber , p. john , m. laine and m. g. schmidt , phys . b * 475 * , 104 ( 2000 ) ; s. j. huber , p. john and m. g. schmidt , eur . j. c * 20 * , 695 ( 2001 ) . a. d. linde , nucl . b * 216 * ( 1983 ) 421 [ erratum - ibid . b * 223 * ( 1983 ) 544 ] . m. e. carrington and j. i. kapusta , phys . d * 47 * , 5304 ( 1993 ) . n. s. manton , phys . d * 28 * , 2019 ( 1983 ) . p. arnold and l. d. mclerran , phys . d * 36 * , 581 ( 1987 ) . l. carson , x. li , l. d. mclerran and r. t. wang , phys . d * 42 * , 2127 ( 1990 ) . g. d. moore , phys . d * 59 * , 014503 ( 1999 ) . since the effects of the @xmath26 part on the sphaleron energy is less than a few percent @xcite , we neglect it in this article . f. r. klinkhamer and r. laterveer , z. phys . c * 53 * , 247 ( 1992 ) . f. r. klinkhamer and n. s. manton , phys . d * 30 * , 2212 ( 1984 ) . l. carson and l. d. mclerran , phys . d * 41 * , 647 ( 1990 ) . t. akiba , h. kikuchi and t. yanagida , phys . d * 40 * , 588 ( 1989 ) . j. m. moreno , d. h. oaknin and m. quiros , nucl . b * 483 * , 267 ( 1997 ) . m. e. shaposhnikov , nucl . b * 287 * , 757 ( 1987 ) ; m. e. shaposhnikov , nucl . b * 299 * , 797 ( 1988 ) ; a. i. bochkarev and m. e. shaposhnikov , mod . lett . a * 2 * , 417 ( 1987 ) ; m. e. shaposhnikov , phys . b * 277 * , 324 ( 1992 ) [ erratum - ibid . b * 282 * , 483 ( 1992 ) ] . t. n. phenomena , higgs working group , for the cdf collaboration and dzero collaboration , arxiv:0903.4001 [ hep - ex ] . y. okada , m. yamaguchi and t. yanagida , prog . phys . * 85 * , 1 ( 1991 ) ; j. r. ellis , g. ridolfi and f. zwirner , phys . b * 257 * , 83 ( 1991 ) ; r. barbieri and m. frigeni , phys . lett . b * 258 * , 395 ( 1991 ) ; y. okada , m. yamaguchi and t. yanagida , phys . b * 262 * , 54 ( 1991 ) ; h. e. haber and r. hempfling , phys . lett . * 66 * , 1815 ( 1991 ) ; j. r. ellis , g. ridolfi and f. zwirner , phys . b * 262 * , 477 ( 1991 ) . e. barberio _ et al . _ [ heavy flavor averaging group ] , arxiv:0808.1297 [ hep - ex ] . w. s. hou , phys . d * 48 * , 2342 ( 1993 ) . j. r. espinosa , nucl . b * 475 * , 273 ( 1996 ) ; d. bodeker , p. john , m. laine and m. g. schmidt , nucl . b * 497 * , 387 ( 1997 ) . k. funakubo and e. senaha , in preparation . | the electroweak phase transition and the sphaleron decoupling condition in the minimal supersymmetric standard model are revisited taking the latest experimental data into account . the light higgs boson scenario and the ordinary decoupling limit which are classified by the relative size between the @xmath0-odd higgs boson mass and @xmath1 boson mass are considered within the context of electroweak baryogenesis . we investigate @xmath2 at not only the critical temperature at which the effective potential has two degenerate minima but also the nucleation temperature of the critical bubbles , where @xmath3 is a vacuum expectation value of the higgs boson and @xmath4 denotes a temperature . it is found that @xmath2 at the nucleation temperature can be enhanced by about 10% compared to that at the critical temperature . we also evaluate the sphaleron decoupling condition including the zero mode factors of the fluctuations around sphaleron . it is observed that the sphaleron decoupling condition at the nucleation temperature is given by @xmath5 for the typical parameter sets . in any phenomenologically allowed region , @xmath2 at both the critical and nucleation temperatures can not be large enough to satisfy such a sphaleron decoupling condition . |
hep-ph0002124 | the solar neutrino problem and the atmospheric anomaly belong to the category of long base - line phenomena using natural neutrino sources . along with the short base - line oscillation experiments the long base - line projects with man - made neutrino sources are very promising . among them the recent chooz project using reactor neutrinos was completed with a negative effect @xcite . most others are planned for installation at high energy accelerators . the k2k project @xcite has taken the first run recently and has shown a preliminary first cc - event @xcite . minos at fermilab - soudan @xcite and icarus at cern - gran sasso @xcite are in a preparatory stage . the traditional interpretation of the origin of neutrino anomalies is the oscillation mechanism . another approach is the possibility of decay of conventional massive neutrinos , which may decay in some mixing components into a singlet majoron and another neutrino , as summarised in ref . this decay theory is restricted by very low upper limits on neutrino masses . as an alternative , we suggested in ref . @xcite a three - body decay mechanism to explain the existing oscillation hints , which considers neutrinos as time - like leptons and where the heavier neutrinos may decay according to the dual principle in the super - luminous lorentz transformation ( slt ) . the idea is based on the symmetry between space - like and time - like bradyons , following e. recami et al . @xcite , according to which we may suggest that in the super - luminous lorentz transformation the space and the time dimensions should replace each other . as a result , tachyons may travel in a 3-dimension time while moving in an unique space direction . a very severe problem is that no tachyon was ever observed in an experiment . on the other hand , neutrinos are an exception with the following appearances of tachyon properties : - there is a very high symmetry between neutrinos and space - like leptons which is enhanced in the electro - weak unification ; - each neutrino has its unique space direction , left or right , described by a definite helicity ; - neutrinos never stop in a space position , similarly as a space - like particle can never stop in a moment of time - evolution . a big challenge is the fact that all neutrinos seem to have very small mass , which disturbs the lepton - neutrino symmetry . to solve this problem we assumed in ref . @xcite that neutrinos are realistic tachyons , however due to weak interaction their transcendent masses m being complex have to be strongly suppressed . we suggested that the real part of mass is roughly equal to @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the decay width of the unstable lepton and @xmath2 is its rest mass . the imaginary part of tachyon mass is suppressed by the factor @xmath3 , i.e. to the first order by the fermi constant @xmath4 . this means that the imaginary part may be measured in parity non - conserving experiments by interference of the weak interaction and electro - magnetic or nuclear force . generally , we may vary the rest mass @xmath2 as a free parameter to fit the experiments . in this work , however , we prefer to test the first order approximation by making the extreme assumption of time - space symmetry , i.e. that the absolute value of the transcendent mass of a neutrino is equal to the rest mass of its bradyon partner . for unification of the formalism we extend a similar formula for @xmath5 of unstable leptons to the electron , which does not harm the conclusion that electron neutrinos as time - like electrons should be stable . as a result , we have got a formalism almost without free parameters in our calculation . in table [ tab : mass ] we show the observable transcendent masses of space - like neutrino - tachyons or time - like leptons : ' '' '' ' '' '' ' '' '' .observable transcendent masses of neutrino - tachyons [ tab : mass ] [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] ' '' '' ' '' '' ' '' '' 2 for @xmath6 protons on target ( p.o.t . ) at k2k , if the muon neutrino decay works , only @xmath7 cc - events will be collected and if the particle identification ( pid ) works well only electron - like events , but no muon - like events will be seen . here we can not exclude the possibility that the electron neutrinos are majorana . in this case only the dirac component may be detected , as in the solar neutrino flux and , as a result , the total amount of electron - like events may be decreased up to 50% ( for the maximum mixing @xcite ) . for the oscillation mechanism there are different possibilities : i/ when the ( @xmath8 ) version works , we may have more electron - like events @xmath9 from the oscillation and an amounts of muon - like ones @xmath10 from the survivors of the initial muon neutrino spectrum ; ii/ when the ( @xmath11 ) version works , we may see the same amount of muon - like events from the surviving muon neutrinos , however the rate of cc - events from the tauon neutrinos decreases significantly , due to the high threshold of the @xmath12n reaction and the low ratios of tauon decay into muon or electron , which are 17.9% and 17.4% , respectively @xcite . the first run of k2k at super - k has seen the first cc - event @xcite . we have to wait for the next run in year 2000 , for sufficient statistics before making any definite conclusion . according to table [ tab : ratev ] , minos will give more statistics to identify the origin of the oscillation hints . in the super - k long base - line detector we expect to identify muon - like events from electron - like ones as a criteria to test the three - body decay of muon neutrinos . the shape of the spectra and the quantity of cc - events are also sensitive to the origin of the oscillation hints . if the decay mechanism works , we suggest to the next long base - line experiments to use intensively the shorter base - line detectors . the optimal condition for observation is to get significant amounts of neutrino decays to see electron - like events , not to harm the intense flux to see also a proportion of muon - like events , that a decay rate larger than say 20% is desirable . it leads to a ratio @xmath13 and the base - line @xmath14(km ) equal to : 2.1 ; 15.3 and 41.8 km respectively , for the kek front detector , cosmos and jura . the experiments with modified shorter base - line detectors might collect a significant statistics for a short period . for example , 0.5 kton fiducial volume of the kek front detector at the distance 2.1 km may see @xmath15 muon - like and about ( 4 - 8)@xmath16 electron - like events for @xmath6 p.o.t . this work was funded by the basic research program of the ministry of science , technology and environment of vietnam . we appreciate prof . p. darriulat ( cern ) for very useful discussion . we thank dr . y. yano ( riken ) , prof . a. masaike ( kyoto ) and dr . y. suzuki ( super - k ) for supporting the first author to attend the present workshop . | considering neutrinos as time - like leptons one may estimate the three - body decay probability of muon neutrinos in long base - line accelerator experiments . in the extreme assumption of time - space symmetry the absolute value of the transcendent mass of a muon neutrino is equal to the rest mass of its bradyon partner which is , however , strongly suppressed in measurements using the weak interaction . this decay , neglecting small oscillations or other effects , leads to a strong dependence of the effect on the base - line distance . as a result , few hundred kilometre long baseline experiments might hardly see muon - like events . total rates of electron - like events from three - body decay are calculated for k2k , minos and icarus . shorter base - line experiments able to see clearly the effect of muon neutrino decay are very promissing component of long base - line projects . + to be submitted to the workshop on `` neutrino oscillations and their origin '' , fuji - yoshida , japan , 11 - 13 february 2000 . pnumwidth2em specialpagefalse oddheadv.v.thuan at al.neutrino decay ... evenheadoddhead oddfoot@font@page=1 evenfootoddfoot 2 |
astro-ph0103303 | there are several ubiquitous media in the central region of active galactic nuclei ( agn ) : surrounding the supermassive black hole ( bh ) , there are an accretion disc ( ad ) , an x - ray source , a photoionized broad line region ( blr ) and possibly a molecular torus at the scale of a few parsecs from the center ( antonucci & miller 1985 ) . despite years of efforts , the physics of these components is far from being completely understood as well as the possible interaction between them . for instance , the origin of the observed correlation between the size of the blr and the luminosity of the agn , which , under some hypothesis , translates into a relation between the mass of the central black hole and the disc accretion rate , is still mysterious . in this paper , we try to understand the links between the accretion disc ( at small and large radii ) , the optical , bolometric and eddington luminosities , and finally the broad line region ( blr ) . for this purpose , we use recent observational data which have led to the determination of the size of the blr , optical luminosity , and black hole ( bh ) mass in a few tens of objects spanning a large range of luminosity ( kaspi et al . 2000 ) . in section 2 , we briefly recall the emission mechanisms in active galactic nuclei ( agn ) , their link with the accretion disc , the main properties of the disc itself and those of the blr . in section 3 we discuss the relations between the observed optical luminosity , bolometric luminosity and bh mass . it is demonstrated that the standard disc emission can not account for the optical luminosity , and that narrow line seyfert 1 galaxies ( nls1s ) are the most extreme cases on this point of view . in section 4 , we model the outer disc and show that the occurrence of gravitational instability roughly coincides with the size of the blr . our conclusions are presented in the last section . since its discovery in agn spectra , the universal feature known as the big blue bump " ( bbb ) which represents the bulk of the bolometric luminosity , has been interpreted as thermal emission of an accretion disc ( shields 1978 , malkan & sargent 1982 ) . if this disc is keplerian and optically thick as generally assumed ( the so - called standard disc " model ) , then its emission reproduces roughly the bbb feature ( see for a review koratkar & blaes 1999 , and collin 2000 ) . moreover , the idea that a non thermal power law continuum dominates the near infrared band and contributes , together with the disc , to the total emission in the optical range , has been abandoned after the publication of the generic spectrum of radio quiet quasars by sanders et al . these authors have actually shown that the ir band is most likely due to hot dust emission peaking at a few microns . since hot dust sublimates at temperatures @xmath1 k , dust can not contribute to the optical emission . so , _ if one sustains the standard disc picture _ , one must admit that the optical continuum component is entirely emitted by the accretion disc . according to the standard model , the disc regions emitting in the optical band are located at a few 100 @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the gravitational radius of the bh with mass @xmath4 ( see fig . [ fig - disque ] , _ middle panel _ ) . since the accretion luminosity varies as @xmath5 , the optical luminosity should be only a small fraction ( @xmath6 ) of the bolometric luminosity . in contrast , the regions emitting the uv and euv components are located close to the bh , typically at distances of a few 10 @xmath2 . modeling the disc spectrum in the uv and euv ranges is a difficult task as radiation is subject to several processes such as comptonization . the emergent spectrum does depend strongly on the details of the disc vertical stratification which is not well known . on the contrary , in the optical range , one can show that the local spectrum is roughly a blackbody at the effective temperature corresponding to the conversion of gravitational energy into radiation ( collin 2000 ) . the bolometric luminosity @xmath7 is a robust prediction for a ( steady state ) standard disc : it is related only to the accretion rate @xmath8 and to the radius of the last , dynamically stable orbit , and corresponds to an efficiency of mass - energy conversion @xmath9 ( the value adopted throughout this paper ) , depending on the spin of the black hole . thus : @xmath10 and in principle , accretion stops if @xmath11 where @xmath12 erg / s is the eddington luminosity and @xmath13 is the mass in units of @xmath14 m@xmath15 . agn spectra also display a hard x - ray spectrum which extends up to a few hundred kev . this hard component which contributes a significant fraction of the bolometric luminosity ( typically 30@xmath16 ) can not be produced by a bare standard disc . this is why one generally invokes the presence of a hot gas close to the bh ( see fig . [ fig - disque ] , _ left panel _ ) , either in the form of a corona above the disc , or , instead of the inner disc itself , a quasi - spherical medium . in this case , the luminosities emitted respectively in the x - ray and optical - uv ranges relative to the accretion luminosity depend on the radius where this hot medium physically connects to the outer , standard disc . the likely change in the morphology of the accretion flow in the inner region ( thin disc @xmath17 thick disc / spherical medium ) is predicted by theory . the standard model probably does not work at small radii where the disc is radiation pressure supported because of thermal instabilities . in comparison , the standard disc as a model for outer regions ( @xmath18 a few @xmath19 ) seems more consistent : the disc is sustained by gas pressure , relatively cold , and much more stable . it is true that a thermal instability , possibly recurrent ( siemiginovska , czerny & kostyunin 1986 ) , is expected where hydrogen recombines / ionizes but such an instability is predicted to keep the disc in a geometrically thin configuration . at large radii ( roughly @xmath20 ; see below ) , the standard disc solution must be modified to account for the disc vertical self - gravity which may exceed the vertical component of the central gravity . the occurrence of vertical self - gravity is inescapable since it varies roughly as @xmath21 , that is less steeply than central gravity which varies as @xmath22 ( shlosman & begelman 1998 ; hur et al . 1994 ; hur 1998 ) . when the hydrostatic equilibrium is no longer controlled by the central object but by the disc , the surface density continuously increases whilst the disc gets thinner and thinner . but a self - gravitating disc is expected to be gravitationally unstable as soon as some criterion is fulfilled ( goldreich & lyndell - bell 1965 ; see also toomre 1964 ) , usually this is @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is the keplerian angular velocity and @xmath25 is the local mass density . the structure of the disc in the gravitationally unstable region is not known . it may become marginally stable again , if the viscosity self - adjusts in some fashion ( lynden - bell & pringle 1974 ) . gravitational instabilities increase random ( radial and vertical ) velocities and could lead to the disc fragmentation into clouds ( pacynski 1968 ; shore & white 1982 , shlosman & begelman 1989 ) . following this scenario ( see fig . [ fig - disque ] , _ right panel _ ) , it is often assumed that these clouds are moving with a high velocity , and that their chaotic motion and mutual collisions provide the support against vertical gravity and keep accretion at the required rate ( begelman & krolik 1986 , kumar 1999 ) . the clumpy disc could become geometrically thick again , and even , at very large distance ( @xmath26 pc ) , it could connect to the dusty molecular torus invoked in the unified scheme of seyfert nuclei ( antonnucci & miller 1985 ) . it is also possible that fragments in the unstable disc collapse to form protostars . because these protostars can trap a large amount of gas from the disc , they should rapidly evolve into massive stars , and then give rise to outflowing gas through winds and supernovae explosions ( collin & zahn 1999 ) . in both scenarios one would thus expect the presence of a dense medium above the accretion disc , with an azimuthal velocity close to the keplerian one , which could be identified with the blr . a major tool for studying the structure of the blr is reverberation mapping , through the study of correlated variations of the lines and continuum fluxes ( see the review by peterson 1993 ) . it has been used to determine the size of the blr in several tens of agn , and to correlate the mass of the central black hole with the luminosity of the agn , under the assumption that the blr is gravitationally bound to the black hole . though powerful for size determination , reverberation mapping does not provide the velocity field of the blr , and can generally not distinguish between radial and rotational motions . in some objects however , there are indications that rotational motions of the medium emitting the h@xmath27 line dominates over radial motions . on the other hand , the medium emitting high ionization lines ( or hils ) is sometimes observed as an outflowing medium . this is thought to be the case in ngc 4051 ( peterson et al . 2000 ) . however it is likely that the velocity @xmath28 does not differ strongly from a gravitationally bound , keplerian or virial motion ( peterson & wandel 1999 ) . then , the radius of the blr is approximately given by @xmath29 where @xmath30 cm / s . because there is no consensus about the dynamics of the blr , there has been little progress in understanding the physics of this region . the most commonly accepted picture , deduced from photoionization models , consists of an assembly of photoionized clouds that cover at least @xmath31 of the source emitting the incident , primary continuum . the number of blr clouds is probably very large because the volumic filling factor of the emitting medium is extremely small . this large population ensures a large total emitting area as well as a high density and a small individual size . the smoothness of the line profiles also requires a large number of clouds . if these clouds are not confined by any mechanism , they expand in a very short time scale ( less than one year ) . if the blr is stationary , new clouds must be permanently generated . alternatively , if the the clouds are formed uniquely then some form of confinement mechanism must operate . the thermal confinement by a hot medium as proposed in the `` two phase model '' by krolik , tarter & mc kee ( 1981 ) implies a thomson thick hot medium , which is difficult to reconcile with the very short variation time scale of the x - ray flux . a natural idea which does not address the confinement problem is that the blr is made of the atmosphere of giant or `` bloated stars '' , or by winds from giant stars ( edwards 1981 , penston 1988 , scoville & norman 1988 , alexander & netzer 1994 ) . this model however requires a very large number of stars to account both for the line luminosity and for the smoothness of the line profiles . another possibility that does not appeal to any special confinement mechanism either is that the lines are emitted by the accretion disc . dumont & collin - souffrin ( 1990 ) have proposed that low ionization lines ( or lils ) , like balmer lines , which require a high density emitting medium ( collin - souffrin et al . , 1986 ) are formed at the surface of the accretion disc . on the other hand , murray & chiang ( 1995 , 1997 ) proposed that the broad emission lines are emitted by a wind released at the top of the disc where motions are still mainly rotational . in this model , the broad absorption lines ( bals ) are produced by the high - velocity component of the wind . in both cases , the blr is dominated by rotation and its presence ( or at least , that of the region emitting the lils ) is linked to the accretion disc . kaspi et al . ( 2000 ) combined their own reverberation mapping study with other published data to determine the size of the blr , the bh mass and the optical luminosity . as it is usually done ( peterson 1993 , 2000 ) , they derived the size of the blr from the measurements of the time lags between the light curves relative to the h@xmath0 and h@xmath27 fluxes and the light curve of the underlying continuum which is assumed to follow the ionizing continuum . from the size of the blr , they computed the bh mass from the fwhm of h@xmath27 and h@xmath0 , assuming that these lines are emitted by a gravitationally bound medium . there is some uncertainty in the mass determination ( by a factor of a few ) since there are two different , non - equivalent methods to determine the fwhm of lines . the fwhm can be averaged on all spectra , giving a `` mean '' bh mass : this is the method preferred by kaspi et al . ( 2000 ) . in the method proposed by peterson et al ( 1998 ) , the fwhm is measured on the rms spectrum , giving a `` rms '' mass . to estimate the bolometric luminosity from the monochromatic luminosity , @xmath32 is generally assumed . for the agn generic spectrum ( laor et al . 1997 ) , one deduces : @xmath33 for each object in kaspi et al . sample , we have compared this optical - to - bolometric conversion with two _ non equivalent but both self - consistent _ methods of conversion based on the disc model : 1 . by computing the theoretical , monochromatic luminosity @xmath34 from the spectrum of an optically thick , steady state disc given the pair @xmath35 , assuming eq.([eq:9 ] ) , and eq.([eq : lboldef ] ) to estimate @xmath8 . figure [ fig - l5100calcobs - vs - m ] displays the ratio @xmath36 obtained with this method . it shows that , for all objects in the sample , the emission due to the disc can represent only a minor , and in most cases , a negligible fraction of the observed luminosity in the optical band . 2 . by finding the `` right '' accretion rate @xmath8 ( and then @xmath37 via eq.([eq : lboldef ] ) ) such that the observed monochromatic luminosity is only due to a standard disc ( that is @xmath38 ) . this method leads to extremely small ratios @xmath39 , as shown by fig . [ fig - l5100lbolcalc - vs - m ] . it implies a very large bolometric luminosity , and therefore a very large eddington ratio @xmath40 . to illustrate this last point the corresponding eddington ratio is plotted versus the central mass on fig . [ fig - lbolcalcledd - vs - m ] . it shows that almost all the objects would be _ radiating at highly super - eddington rates _ , proving that this second self - consistent optical - to - bolometric conversion is wrong . in other words , _ a relation of the form eq.([eq:9 ] ) should be roughly valid _ , meaning that _ the optical luminosity is not radiated by a standard disc_. note that we assume a face - on disc , thus overestimating slightly @xmath41 . these conclusions are unchanged if the inner disc is removed for some reason , that is , if the inner radius is larger ( in the limit of a few 10 @xmath2 ) than a few @xmath2 as considered here , since the optical emission is almost entirely produced in outer regions located much further away from the center . clearly the situation becomes even more extreme if the region emitting the optical band is not present in the disc , that is , if the disc is truncated for some reason , for instance due to self - gravity . there are at least four possible explanations for this result : 1 . the optical luminosity is not due to the disc , as quoted . this is plausible since the standard disc spectrum is well known to be flatter than the spectrum of seyfert 1 nuclei in the optical range ( koratkar & blaes 1999 , hubeny et al . 2000 , collin 2000 ) . this is also compatible with a recent study of the nls1 1 re j1034 + 396 by puchnarewicz et al . ( 2000 ) who conclude that an additional underlying power law connecting the ir to the x - rays is really necessary to fit the optical / uv continuum . they suggest that this extra component might be a non thermal blac - type component . this is indeed possible if for instance there is a strong magnetic field anchored into the disc . but it could also be due to a thermal process like the emission of dense clouds surrounding the x - ray source and reprocessing a large fraction of the x - ray luminosity , as proposed by celotti , fabian and rees ( 1992 ) , and by collin - souffrin et al . ( 1996 ) . this cloud system should be distributed quasi - spherically in order to reprocess a large fraction of the x - ray luminosity ( in the case of a disc , the reprocessed fraction decreases as @xmath5 , like the accretion luminosity , and is necessarily small in the optical range ) . the standard disc model is not valid . although the accretion luminosity does not depend on viscosity , the fact that the disc is effectively optically thick and radiates like a black body is not independent of the viscosity prescription . note , as a proof , that the optical thickness of a standard disc is a function of the @xmath0-viscosity parameter . either a completely different mechanism of angular momentum evacuation in the disc is at work ( e.g. density waves ) , or the formalism for turbulent viscosity must be reconsidered , or both . the accretion rate is not uniform . this possibility includes the presence of a non steady disc and the possible existence of some steady inflow involving an accretion rate decreasing with decreasing radius . concerning the first point , there are a few well known sources of instability that can perturb the equilibrium of a disc but this would mean that all objects are observed in a high optical state " . this is statistically somewhat doubtful . regarding the second point , this would mean that a huge amount of gas is accreted at large distances and then converted into an outflow at smaller radii . this is also unrealistic because it would imply massive super - eddington outflows , which are not observed . accretion is advection dominated in the inner regions . such a solution is still not demonstrated on theoretical grounds . stable advection dominated accretion flows ( adafs ) ( narayan & yi 1995 , and many other works ) take place for relatively low accretion rates , well below the eddington limit . at the other extreme , there are advective solutions for eddington rates ( slim discs " for instance , cf . abramowicz et al . 1988 ) or for super - eddington rates ( thick discs ) , but it is difficult to conceive a durable , super - eddington accretion rate , as it would imply a dramatic growth of the hole over cosmic time scales . in conclusion , even if the disc becomes geometrically thick in the inner regions , advection is not likely to be important in the seyfert galaxies and moderately luminous quasars considered here , and the gas should flow all the way down to the last stable orbit and radiate accordingly . figure [ fig - r - vs - l5100 ] displays the size of the blr , @xmath42 , versus @xmath43 for the kaspi et al . ( 2000 ) sample . in this figure and in figs . [ fig - l5100calcobs - vs - m ] , [ fig - l5100lbolcalc - vs - m ] , and [ fig - lbolcalcledd - vs - m ] , nls1 have been isolated km / s , instead of using fwhms , to avoid having to take into account a correction for h@xmath0 and h@xmath27 ] . we notice that they do not occupy any privileged region on fig . [ fig - r - vs - l5100 ] , contrary to figs . [ fig - l5100calcobs - vs - m ] , [ fig - l5100lbolcalc - vs - m ] and [ fig - lbolcalcledd - vs - m ] . on fig . [ fig - lbolcalcledd - vs - m ] they are concentrated in the top - left region corresponding to small masses and high bolometric luminosities . further , nls1s have the smallest @xmath36 ratios compared to other objects in the same range of bh mass , as shown by fig . [ fig - l5100calcobs - vs - m ] . how to explain these properties ? we know that nls1 galaxies have a strong soft x - ray excess compared to broad line seyfert 1 galaxies ( bls1s ) ( boller , brandt & fink 1996 for a review ; see also the proceedings edited by boller et al . this would suggest that the bbb is shifted towards the euv , and that the ratio @xmath45 is smaller in nls1s than in bls1s . meanwhile , this would mean that the ratio @xmath46 is larger in nls1s than in bls1s . however this is impossible , as it would imply super - eddington rates . indeed fig . [ fig - roverrg - vs - l95100overledd ] , which displays @xmath47 as a function of the eddington ratio , for @xmath48 , shows that with the conservative assumption of eq . [ eq:9 ] , nls1s are already radiating at eddington rates . nls1s occupy a privileged position on this figure , not only because of their small fwhm ( corresponding by definition to large @xmath47 values ) , but also because they display large eddington ratios . actually this was strongly suspected on the basis of their spectral and variability properties in the x - ray range , similarly to galactic bh candidates ( pounds , done & osborne 1995 ) . _ we conclude that nls1s have not only larger eddington ratios , but also probably a larger non disc " fraction of optical emission , compared to bls1s_. based mainly on distance arguments , we have suggested before that the blr is possibly related to the suppression of the disc by gravitational instabilities . we have investigated this idea more quantitatively by a series of bi - dimensional simulations of steady state , keplerian accretion @xmath0-disc ( hur 2000 ) . more precisely , the model includes convection in the framework of the mixing length theory , turbulent pressure that substantially thickens the disc and self - gravity within the infinite disc approximation . opacities and equation of state are realistic and corresponds to a gas at lte with cosmic abundances . external irradiation is not taken into account , for several reasons . first the discs considered here are optically very thick and moreover the irradiation flux is likely to decrease as the gravitational flux , having thus a relatively small influence on the disc structure ( collin & hur 1999 ) . second , as we shall see below , outer regions are in the shadow of the central regions due to self - gravity which pinches the disc vertically . figure [ fig-2dmap ] shows an example of internal structure of a disc computed for @xmath49 m@xmath15 , @xmath50 m@xmath15/yr and @xmath51 . we see that the disc becomes self - gravitating ( in the sense @xmath52 ) from @xmath53 which results in a significant decrease of the disc thickness and rise of the density . note however that the disc flaring vanishes at much lower radius @xmath54 . in order to determine the radius @xmath55 where the disc becomes gravitationally unstable , we have computed a series of disc models by varying @xmath4 and @xmath8 . there are many possible sources of uncertainties on the value of this quantity , including a lack of information regarding some physical processes like turbulent viscosity through the @xmath0-prescription and its @xmath56-dependency , convective transport , self - gravity , environment effects . in addition , the threshold value of the @xmath57-parameter which defines the instability criterion is uncertain in this context ( e.g. , it is not clear whether this criterion applies to the midplane quantities ) . we have attempted to estimate an absolute error on @xmath55 by considering @xmath58 and @xmath59 ( toomre , 1964 ; goldreich & lynden - bell 1965 ) . figure [ fig-2dmap ] shows the location of the unstable disc region ( @xmath60 ) . our results are displayed in figure [ fig - rcrit - vs - mdot ] which gives @xmath55 versus the accretion rate for four mass decades , obtained for @xmath51 and @xmath61 ( mean values ) . we see that @xmath55 is mainly determined by the central mass and weakly sensitive to the accretion rate @xmath8 . the @xmath0-parameter and threshold value for @xmath57 have rather minor effect for moderate and high eddington luminosities . the magnitude of the error on @xmath55 is given by the gap between curves corresponding to the same central mass but to different values of @xmath0 and threshold values for @xmath57 . it is comforting to see that the results are quite reliable , as the uncertainties do not produce an `` error '' larger than a factor say , @xmath62 on @xmath55 . figure [ fig - roverrg - vs - l95100overledd ] displays @xmath63 versus the eddington ratio for the same models . a crude fit in the domain @xmath64 gives @xmath65 we have plotted on fig . [ fig - r - vs - l5100 ] @xmath55 in light - days versus @xmath66 , using eq . ( [ eq:9 ] ) to convert the disc accretion rate into optical luminosity ( otherwise , accretion rates are unrealistically high ) , together with the data of the kaspi et al . sample . figure [ fig - roverrg - vs - l95100overledd ] displays @xmath47 , for the kaspi et al . sample , still assuming eq . ( [ eq:9 ] ) . we see clearly from these two figures that , in absolute , the blr size is correlated with the occurrence of the disc gravitational instability . so , if we identify the edge of the gravitationally unstable disc with the inner edge blr , that is @xmath67 , we conclude that _ active nuclei hosting low mass black holes are predicted to have broad lines narrower than others_. fig . [ fig - roverrg - vs - l95100overledd ] shows that , though the observed masses do not match exactly the theoretical expectations , there is a clear trend that objects with small masses ( 10@xmath68 m@xmath69 ) have a large @xmath70 ratio and that objects with large masses ( @xmath71 m@xmath69 ) have a small @xmath70 ratio , _ in agreement with our theoretical predictions_. so , at least to this `` zero order approximation '' , the gravitationally unstable region of the disc has kinematic and size properties compatible with the blr and could therefore be the ultimate source of the blr clouds . it is however difficult to draw more quantitative conclusions from this investigation . one can notice that @xmath55 depends mainly of the bh mass and little on the luminosity , while a correlation appears on fig . [ fig - r - vs - l5100 ] between @xmath42 and the @xmath72 . kaspi et al . ( 2000 ) represent this correlation as @xmath73 . a smaller power law index ( closer to @xmath74 ) was found in previous works ( e.g. wandel et al . anyway it is not clear how to translate such a relation into a relation between @xmath42 and @xmath7 , because of an important uncertainty arising from the optical - to - bolometric conversion . if the optical to bolometric luminosity ratio is constant , it results in @xmath75 . in a recent paper , nicastro ( 2000 ) proposed that the blr clouds are released by the accretion disc in the region where a vertically outflowing corona exists , according to a model proposed by witt , czerny & zicky ( 1997 ) . this is indeed an interesting model , since in this case the main parameter governing the size of the blr would be @xmath76 and not @xmath4 . however one would expect that the remote regions giving rise to the blr , which are strongly pressurized by the corona , are also gravitationally unstable . moreover there is also another important parameter governing the size of the blr , that is its ionization parameter @xmath77 where @xmath78 is the ionizing luminosity ( @xmath79 ) and @xmath80 is the number density in the clouds . actually , any model must reproduce not only the kinematics and dimension of the blr but also the ionization parameter ( linked to the ionization state ) consistent with the observed line ratios which are almost independent on the luminosity over more than four decades ( except for the baldwin effect which might indicate a decrease of the ionization parameter with increasing luminosity , but only for high ionization lines ) . typically , @xmath81 and detailed studies of the line ratios show that @xmath82 @xmath83 . if the density is about a constant , the constancy of @xmath84 translates into a relation @xmath85 , in close agreement with the observations . another way to express this relation is that the flux irradiating the clouds is constant . this relation has been used in the ionization method " aiming to determine the mass of the black holes , and it gives results compatible with the reverberation mapping method ( wandel , peterson & malkan 1999 ) , but more uncertain . thus a possible interpretation of the observed correlation is that among clouds released by the gravitationally unstable disc , only those located at the right distance ( i.e. corresponding to the right ionization parameter or ionizing flux ) are observed as blr clouds : the others could contribute to the warm absorber . this could explain why @xmath55 constitutes a lower envelope " to @xmath42 for a given bh mass . also since a constant ionizing flux corresponds to @xmath86 , we see that the objects displaying the largest @xmath47 ratios , hence the smaller line widths , are those which have the largest accretion rates in eddington unit and the smallest masses . such a situation is proposed to explain the properties of nls1s . note that in this picture , the more intense soft x - ray excess displayed by nls1s compared to bls1s can also play a role , since such a spectrum has a stronger ionizing power for the same ionization parameter ( e.g. wandel 1997 ) . we have discussed the relations between the optical luminosity , the bh mass , and the size of the blr , in the framework of the standard accretion disc model . we have shown first that the optical luminosity can not be accounted for , meaning that the standard accretion disc picture ( stationary , geometrically thin and optically thick ) does not hold , at least in the region emitting the optical band , i.e. at @xmath87 . either the major fraction of the optical luminosity is not due to disc emission , or the disc is not standard " : it is unstable , or the accretion rate depends on the radius , owing to strong outflows or to advection dominated accretion . in these last cases , the implied mass rate would have to be strongly super - critical . we would thus favor the first explanation . we have also shown that nls1s are extreme in this context : either they have a larger fraction of non disc emission in the optical range and are radiating close to their eddington luminosity , or they have strongly super - eddington luminosity , which seems implausible . so again in this case it seems that the best explanation would be that a large fraction of the optical emission ( larger even than for bls1s ) is not produced by the disc . in the second part , we have studied the relation between the disc and the blr , and we have shown that there is a good agreement between the size of the blr and the critical radius at which an @xmath0-disc becomes gravitationally unstable . this suggests that the blr is produced above the gravitationally unstable part of the disc . however the ionization parameter should also play a role in explaining the correlation observed between the size and the luminosity . if blr clouds are seen only for a small range of ionization parameter or of ionizing flux , the size of the blr expressed in @xmath2 should increase with the accretion rate expressed in eddington unit and decrease with the bh mass , according to the observed correlation . this could explain the small widths of nls1s . abramowicz , m. a. , czerny , b. , lasota , j. p. , szuszkiewicz , e. , 1988 , apj , 332 , 646 antonucci , r. r. j. , miller , j. s. , 1985 , apj , 297 , 621 boller , t. , brandt , w. n. , fink , h. , 1996 , a&a , 305 , 53 boller th . , brandt , w.n . , leighly k.m . , ward , m.j . , 2000 , proceedings of the workshop on observational and theoretical progress in the study of nls1 galaxies `` held in bad honnef , germany , dec . 8 - 11 1999 , new astronomy review 44 , 381 - 580 cannizzo , j. k. , 1993 , apj , 419 , 318 celotti , a. , fabian , a. c. , rees , m. j. , 1992 , mnras , 255 , 419 collin - souffrin , s. , joly m. , pequignot d. , dumont s. , 1986 , a&a , 166 , 27 collin - souffrin , s. , czerny , b. , dumont , a .- m . , zycki , p. 1996 , a&a , 314 , 393 collin , s. , hur , j. , 1999 , a&a , 341 , 385 collin , s. , zahn , j - p . , 1999 , a&a , 344 , 433 collin , s. , 2000 , to appear in ' ' the starburst - agn connection `` , advanced lectures held in tonantzintla , mexico , ed . world scientific dumont , a.m. , collin - souffrin s. , 1990 , a&a , 229 , 302 edwards , a.c . , 1980 , mnras , 190 , 757 goldreich p. , lynden - bell d. , 1965 , mnras 130 , 97 hubeny , i. , agol , e. , blaes , o. , krolik , j. h. , 2000 , apj , 533 , 710 hur , j - m . , collin - souffrin s. , le bourlot j. , pineau des forets g. , 1994 , a&a , 290 , 19 hur , j. 1998 , a&a , 337 , 625 hur , j - m . 2000 , a&a , 358 , 378 kaspi , s. , smith , p. s. , netzer , h. , maoz , d. , jannuzi , b. t. , giveon , u. , 2000 , apj , 533 , 631 koratkar a. , blaes o. 1999 , pasp , 111 , 1 krolik , j.h . , mckee , c. f. , tarter , c. b. 1981 , apj , 249 , 422 krolik , j. h. , begelman , m. c. , 1988 , apj , 329 , 702 kumar p. , 1999 , apj , 519 , 589 laor , a. , fiore , f. , elvis , m. , wilkes , b.j . , mcdowell , j.c . , 1997 , apj , 477 , 93 lynden - bell , d. , pringle , j. e. , 1974 , mnras , 168 , 603 malkan m.a . , sargent w.l.w . , 1982 , apj , 254 , 22 murray , n. , chiang , j. , 1995 , apjl , 454 , l105 murray , n. , chiang , j. , 1997 , apj , 474 , 91 narayan , r . , yi , i. , 1995 , apj , 452 , 71 nicastro , f. , 2000 , apjl , 530 , l60 paczynski b. , 1978 , aca , 28 , 91 penston , m.v . , 1988 , mnras , 233 , 601 peterson , b. m. 1993 , pasp , 105 , 247 peterson , b. m. , wandel , a. 1999 , apjl , 521 , l95 peterson , b. m. , wanders , i. , bertram , r. , hunley , j. f. , pogge , r. w. , wagner , r. m.1998 , apj , 501 , 82 peterson , b. m. , wandel , a. , 2000 , apjl , 540 , l13 peterson , b. m. et al . , 2000 , apj , 542 , 161 peterson , b.m . , 2000 , to appear in ' ' the starburst - agn connection " , advanced lectures held in tonantzintla , mexico , ed . world scientific pounds , k.a . , done , c. , osborne , j.p . , 1995 , mnras , 277 , l5 puchnarewicz , e.m . mason , k.o . , siemiginowska , a. , fruscione , a. , comastri , a. , fiore , a. , cagnoni , i. , 2000 , astro - ph/ 0011389 , apj , in press sanders , d. b. , phinney , e. s. , neugebauer , g. , soifer , b. t. , matthews , k. , 1989 , apj , 347 , 29 scoville , n.z . , norman c. , 1988 , apj , 332 , 163 shakura n.i . , sunyaev r.a . , 1973 , a&a , 24 , 337 shields , g.a . , 1978 , nature , 272 , 423 shlosman , i. , begelman , m. c. , 1989 , apj , 341 , 685 siemiginowska , a. , czerny , b. , kostyunin , v. 1996 , apj , 458 , 491 shore , s. n. , white , r. l. , 1982 , apj , 256 , 390 toomre a. , 1964 , apj 139 , 1217 wandel , a. , 1997 , apj , 490 , l131 wandel , a. , peterson , b. m. , malkan , m. a. , 1999 , apj , 526 , 579 witt , h.j . , czerny , b. , zicky , p.t . , 1997 , mnras , 286 , 848 | we address the question of the relations between the black hole s mass , the accretion rate , the bolometric luminosity , the optical luminosity and the size of the broad line region ( blr ) in active galactic nuclei , using recent observational data obtained from monitoring campaigns . we show that a standard accretion disc can not account for the observed optical luminosity , unless it radiates at super - eddington rates . this implies the existence of another , dominant emission mechanism in the optical range , or a non standard disc ( non stationary , adaf and/or strong outflows ) . narrow line seyfert 1 galaxies ( nls1s ) are most extreme in this context : they have larger bolometric to eddington luminosity ratios than broad line seyfert 1 ( bls1s ) , and most likely a larger non disc " component in the optical range . from realistic simulations of self - gravitating @xmath0-discs , we have systematically localized the gravitationally unstable disc and shown that , given uncertainties on both the model and observations , it coincides quite well with the size of the blr . we therefore suggest that the gravitationally unstable disc is the source which releases blr clouds in the medium . however the influence of the ionization parameter is also required to explain the correlation found between the size of the blr and the luminosity . in this picture the size of the blr in nls1s ( relative to the black hole size ) is larger ( and the emission line width smaller ) than in bls1s simply because their eddington ratio is larger . |
cond-mat0511152 | in 1962 , little and parks@xcite demonstrated that in multiply connected system , the superconducting transition temperature @xmath0 is a periodic function of the applied magnetic field @xmath1 in the axial direction of a superconducting thin loop . the oscillations of @xmath2 with a period of the flux quantum @xmath3 are a consequence of the fluxoid quantization constraint which was first predicted by f. london.@xcite the free energy of the superconducting state is periodic in the unit of flux quanta , while the free energy of normal state is almost independent of the flux . therefore the transition temperature should be a periodic function of the enclosed flux . recent advancements in micro - fabrication and technique of hall magnetometry @xcite make it possible to detect the properties of superconducting samples with sizes comparable to the coherence length @xmath4 and the london penetration depth @xmath5 at the temperature well below @xmath0 . the superconducting states in such a mesoscopic system reveal unique properties , which depend on the size and geometry of the sample . such confinement effects have been clearly demonstrated experimentally in nanosized superconducting square loops@xcite , disks@xcite and rings.@xcite in the last decade , the properties of mesoscopic superconductors have drawn growing attention , both experimentally and theoretically(see , e.g. , refs . 7 - 15 ) . in particular , as a doubly connected topological sample , superconducting ring like structures have also been studied extensively in the past years@xcite . in contrast to bulk superconductivity , the symmetry of the sample play an important role when the sample scales become comparable with @xmath6 ( or @xmath5 ) . the effective ginzburg - landau(gl ) parameter @xmath7 is significantly increased , and the magnetic response of a type i superconductor even presents a shape of a type ii superconductor . on the basis of gl theory , berger and rubinstein predicted that there is a surface in a nonuniform mesoscopic superconducting loop , where the order parameter vanishes due to the existence of the `` singly connected state '' . @xcite using the linearized gl equation , bruyndoncx _ et al . _ studied superconducting loops of finite width and found an dimensional crossover from different behaviors of the phase boundary as the geometry of the loop changes.@xcite taking the induced magnetic fields into account , baelus _ et al._@xcite investigated vortex states in a thin superconducting disk with a hole and noticed a transition from the giant vortex state to the multivortex state arises when the size of the disk becomes large enough . they also showed that the multi vortex state is stable when circular symmetry is broken . recently , pedersen _ et al . _ experimentally investigated the flux quantization of a mesoscopic loop with a @xmath8 hall magnetometer . the magnetic field intensity periodicity observed in the magnetization measurements indicates a gradual transition from large flux avalanches to single flux jumps as the external magnetic field intensity is increased . such a sub - flux quantum shift was interpreted as a consequence of a giant vortex state nucleating towards either the inner or the outer boundary of the loop.@xcite their observation leads to a new interest in the phase transition in superconducting loops@xcite . at low magnetic field , multiple flux jumps and irreversible behavior were also observed by vodolazov _ et , al._@xcite in thin al superconducting rings with sufficiently large radii . the also showed the possibility of the existence of flux avalanches by numerical calculations based on the time dependent gl model . the nucleation of superconductivity in rings has been studied both experimentally and theoretically by morelle _ et al._@xcite , a transition from a one - dimensional to a two - dimensional regime is seen when the magnetic field with small holes is increased . the phase transitions due to the superconducting vortices enter into the sample were also reported by bourgeois _ _ in mesoscopic square loops@xcite . the measurements of specific heat as a function of external magnetic field exhibit oscillations with changing periodicity , depending on both the temperature and applied flux . there are three kinds of vortex states in mesoscopic systems , the giant vortex state , the multi vortex state and the ring - like vortex state . in terms of thermodynamical stability , the multi - vortex states and giant vortex states can be stable , while ring - like vortices in superconductors seem to be unstable @xcite . in present work , we confined our study in the giant vortex states since the mesoscopic superconducting ring has more surfaces compared to the disk with same size . the confinement effects from the boundaries are dominating and it will impose a circular symmetry on superconducting order parameter . moreover , recent experimental observations also indicate giant vortex states nucleating in mesoscopic superconductors with cylindrical symmetry@xcite . for a giant vortex state , the free energy of a type i superconducting ring has been studied theoretically@xcite in terms of external magnetic field and the winding number l. the vorticity of the ground state changes from @xmath9 to @xmath10 at some values as the external magnetic field increases . however , their numerical results seem to show that the properties of giant vortex states are related to the winding number l. in the present work , we theoretically investigate the giant vortex states of a multiply connected superconductor in terms of the nonlinear gl theory . we show that the winding number l of a giant vortex state is a tuned function of the flux inside the hole of a ring , and that all the information of giant vortex states can be obtained with a defined winding number l. we also show that the vector potential - tuned giant vortex states have periodicity in the units of @xmath11 , as demonstrated in little - parks experiment . this paper is organized as follows : in section ii , we describe the model of the mesoscopic superconducting ring based on the two - dimensional gl equations . this approach is suitable in two cases : ( i ) for a ring made from a thin film and ( ii ) for a high cylinder considered in its cross - section far from the bases . we present a simple proof to show that the gibbs free energy of a giant vortex state is independent of the vorticity l. in section iii , we investigate the giant vortex states numerically and obtain the local magnetic field , the cooper pair density and the current density . we consider different cases with diamagnetic response , paramagnetic response and the combination of the above twos . we also show how the quantum phase tuned by the flux inside the hole . in section iv , we give further discussion and conclusions . in the present paper , we consider a two - dimensional superconducting ring , with internal radius @xmath12 and external radius @xmath13 . the applied magnetic field is along the axial direction and has a uniform value@xmath14 . when the size of the superconducting ring falls in a mesoscopic regime , where the surface effects are of the same order of magnitude as the bulk effects , the confinement effects from the boundaries are dominating and impose a circular symmetry on the superconducting order parameter and the local magnetic field . hence the order parameter is expected to be given by @xmath15 and the magnetic field has the form @xmath16 . we can always choose appropriate gauge so that the vector potential can be written as , @xmath17 in order to simplify the numerical calculation , we will make the formulas dimensionless by measuring the order parameter @xmath18 in units of @xmath19 , lengths in units of @xmath20 , the magnetic field in units of @xmath21 , the gibbs free energy in units of @xmath22 , and the vector potential in units of @xmath23 , where @xmath24 and @xmath25 . then the gibbs free energy @xmath26 is given by @xmath27 @xmath28 substituting the expressions of the order parameter and the vector potential into gl equations , we have @xmath29 @xmath30 the @xmath31 term in equation ( 7 ) has to be vanished , then we have @xmath32 . substituting this equation back into equation(5 ) , we find the phase of order parameter satisfies @xmath33 thus it is convenient to assume @xmath34 , where l is called as the winding number of the vortex . when the superconductor is described by such a circular symmetric order parameter , it is said to be in giant vortex state . gl equations turn into a set of second - order ordinary differential equations , @xmath35 @xmath36 the boundary conditions assure that no current passes through the surface , which is @xmath37 the gibbs free energy can be written as @xmath38 , which depends only on the value of the kernel @xmath39 in the expression @xmath40 notice that in equations(9),(10 ) and ( 12 ) , the winding number choice l can fix the gauge choice for the vector potential so that @xmath41 it is straightforward to find that both gibbs free energy and gl equations are gauge invariant as long as we choose the winding number l and the vector potential @xmath42 satisfying equation(13 ) . consequently , with different winding number l , gl equations have same solution for the local magnetic field @xmath43 , copper pair density @xmath44 and current density @xmath45 . it shall be noted that when the winding number changes with gauge transformation equation(13 ) , the vector potential will change respectively , so that although all the observable physical properties of the superconductor wo nt change with winding number , the flux around the superconductor do change . from the gauge transformation equation(13 ) , it can be predicted that the mesoscopic superconducting ring has the possibility to hold rather strong magnetic field inside its hole . actually , this gauge - invariant solution has similar interpretation as the well - known little - parks experiment . if the winding number and the flux change together through a gauge invariant transformation , the physical properties of the thin - walled superconductor does not change the non - linear gl equations ( 9 - 10 ) can be represented as four first - order ordinary differential equations , thus four boundary conditions are required . apparently the boundary conditions equation(11 ) is not sufficient . we set the value of the vector potential at the external boundary of the ring since the real magnetic field can not be obtained experimentally although the applied magnetic field is known . we apply the _ _ _ _ `` shooting method '' @xcite , in which trial integrations are `` launched '' _ _ _ _ that satisfy the boundary condition at one endpoint . the discrepancies from the desired boundary condition at the other endpoint are used to adjust the starting conditions , until the _ _ _ _ boundary conditions at both endpoints are ultimately satisfied . the relative _ _ _ _ accuracy is set to be @xmath46 for the numerical calculation . as it has been discussed in the previous section , the full gl equations can be obtained with a fixed winding number such as @xmath47 . three kinds of magnetic responses can be obtained numerically as we change the boundary condition of vector potential . in figure.1 and figure.2 , we show that in the case of the diamagnetic response , copper pair density decreases and magnetic field increases when the radius becomes larger . since the magnetic filed at the external boundary are much larger than that at the internal boundary , the super - current induces an negative magnetic field to keep the applied magnetic field out of the superconducting ring from the external boundary so that the part closer to the inner side of the ring always have larger cooper pair density . in the case of paramagnetic response , the situation will be opposite . the magnetic field at the internal boundary are much larger . the cooper pair density increases and the magnetic field decreases when the radius becomes larger . the super - current induces a positive magnetic filed in order to keep the applied field out of the internal boundary . in the case of combination of both effects , the magnetic field first decreases until it reaches a minimum and then it increases with the increase of the radius , the super - current keeps the magnetic field out of the ring from both boundaries . the total magnetic field reaches its minimum in the middle of the ring while the cooper pair density show different behaviors for type ii and type i. the type i ring has a positive surface energy , since the magnetic field has much larger value at the internal boundary , the positive surface energy keeps the cooper pairs away . in fig.3 . the calculated super - current as a function of radius is displayed . the current at the sample boundary is not equal to zero which implies that the flux is not quantized . diamagnetic response has a negative super - current while paramagnetic response has a positive one . moreover , the superconducting state can consist of a combination of the diamagnetic and paramagnetic meissner state , and the super - current density goes to zero at the circle where the magnetic field reaches a minimum . this also indicates a certain effective radius inside the ring through which circular area the flux is exactly quantized , which has been studied both experimentally@xcite and theoretically@xcite . it shall be noted that this `` combination '' of superconducting state can only have diamagnetic response in the outer part of ring and paramagnetic response in the inner part . there is no possibility of having the response vice versa because the super - current has to keep magnetic field from `` invading '' from both the internal and the external boundary . we have studied the case for different @xmath48 as 0.5 and 1.0 , which represents type i and type ii superconductor respectively . there is not much difference in the behaviors of a giant vortex state when only @xmath48 changes , except for the value of gibbs free energy . we have calculated the free energy for all the cases . the total flux through the area of the superconducting ring is directly obtained from local magnetic field . the flux inside the superconducting ring is found to be not necessarily quantized . for example , the calculated flux for the giant vortex states considered in fig.1.(a ) is around 8.7 , 9.8 and 18.0 respectively . the size of the ring is carefully chosen since it was found experimentally that the physical properties of a mesoscopic superconducting system depend on its size . the size of the ring we considered here is large enough to be superconducting when more than one flux enter . meanwhile it is also narrow enough to maintain the cylindrical symmetry of giant vortex states by the boundary condition . as it has been generalized@xcite , the flux inside the hole of the ring is not quantized . our numerical results also show non - quantized solutions for the flux inside the hole . however , the concept of winding number l in the present work is different from that reviewed in their work . the gibbs free energy of the giant vortex state will not change with l , while the flux inside the hole changes correspondingly . for example , the flux in the hole of the combination magnetic response in fig.1(b ) . is 0.8 when @xmath49 . when the winding number change to @xmath50 , the solution of gl equations is the same . the only change is that the flux in the hole there is 1.8 , which means one more flux enters inside the hole . a transition from a state with vorticity l to one with vorticity @xmath10 happens when a vortex , carrying unit vorticity , enters at the outer radius , crosses the ring , and then annihilates at the inner radius . the numerical results are consistent with the theoretical analysis obtained in section ii . it is well known that the phase shift of an electron wave function resulting in an alteration in the interference pattern of a double slit electron diffraction experiment in the presence of a potential magnetic field , even if the magnetic field is shielded so that diffracted electrons do not pass through it@xcite . what is going to happen if only the flux inside the hole of the superconducting ring is changed while the magnetic field is not . if the additional flux is quantized , according to the gauge invariant transformation equation(13 ) , all the parameters of the giant vortex state will not be influenced except that the winding number @xmath9 changes to @xmath10 . it s also interesting to study the case when additional flux is not quantized . experimentally , this additional flux could be obtained by setting a very small but long solenoid inside the hole . the solenoid will hold in the magnetic field inside its coils , but the uncurled vector potential will also appear outside the coil and it will affect the superconducting states . in fig.4 . we provide the numerical calculation of the gibbs free energy displayed as a function of the additional flux . it is clearly shown that the gibbs free energy is a periodic function of the `` field free '' flux with a period of the flux quantum @xmath3 . the periodicity of gibbs free energy with the additional flux quantum(or winding number l ) is reminiscent of aharonov - bohm effect , and such kind of quantum periodicity in the free energy of superconducting pairs has been directly observed via little - park experiment . if the additional flux is not quantized , the free energy of the vortex states will change . as a result , the magnetic field inside and outside the superconducting ring will also change , assuming that the additional flux will not change the magnetic field in the hole of the ring except for the area occupied by the solenoid . in such a way , the `` invisible '' vector potential @xmath51 becomes `` visible '' . if the applied magnetic field is fixed , the additional flux in the solenoid can even cause the free energy to become lower . based on our numerical results , it can be predicted that when the superconducting state is close enough to the phase boundary , little - parks like oscillations could be observed experimentally in a rather `` fat '' ring for both the critical temperature @xmath0 and critical applied field @xmath52 , as the additional flux changing continuously . in conclusion , we have theoretically studied the giant vortex states in terms of the non - linear gl equations for a superconducting ring . we provide a gauge invariant transformation and show that the solutions can be independent of the winding number l. we also calculate the numerical results for different magnetic responses of the superconductor , and discuss the concept of the winding number in details . for a superconducting ring , there are giant vortex states that hold more than one flux quantum inside both the superconductor and the hole . the flux is found to be not quantized , while he winding number l is still an integer , but not necessarily to be the number of vortices anymore . the gl equations can be fully solved without changing the value of the winding number l. we also indicate that the periodicity of gibbs free energy g with additional flux in mesoscopic superconducting ring is based on the same principle of aharonov - bohm effect , and can be shown with a little - parks - like oscillation . this work has been supported by the grant from the state education department of china and the grant from beijing normal university . hu zhao also wish to thank professor juelian shen , professor jia - cai nie and professor f. brosens for helpful discussions . a. k. geim , i. v. grigorieva , s. v. dubonos , j. g. s. lok , j. c. maan , a. e. filippov , and f. m. peeters , nature ( london ) * 390 * , 259(1997 ) ; a. k. geim , s. v. dubonos , j. g. s. lok , m. henini , and j. c. maan _ ibid.**396 * * , 144 ( 1998 ) . _ l. f. chibotaru , a. ceulemans , v. bruyndoncx , and v. v. moshchalkov , nature ( london ) * 408 * , 833 ( 2000 ) ; m. lange , m. j. van bael , y. bruynseraede , and v. v. moshchalkov , phys . lett . * 90 * , 197006 ( 2003 ) . | the giant vortex states of a multiply connected superconductor , with radius comparable to the penetration depth and the coherence length , are theoretically investigated based on the nonlinear ginzburg - landau theory , in which the induced magnetic field by the super - currents is accurately taken into account . the solutions of ginzburg - landau equations are found to be actually independent of the angular momentum l in a gauge invariant point of view , provided that the hole is in the center . different cases with the paramagnetic current , the diamagnetic current , and the coexistence of the above two , have been studied numerically . the interpretation of the l - independent solutions of ginzburg - landau equations is given based on the same principle of aharonov - bohm effect , and could be observed by little - parks like oscillations near the phase boundary . |
astro-ph0106546 | bals are present in about 10% of all optically selected quasars ( weymann et al . the absorption features result from mass outflows with velocity widths of order 2000 to 20 000 km s@xmath2 and maximum velocities to 0.1@xmath3 and possibly higher in a few cases . the chemical abundances in the bal regions are of interest as possible indicators of chemical enrichment in galactic nuclei ( e.g. korista et al . 1996 , hamann and ferland 1999 ) . the absorption features in bal quasars are not easy to interpret because the bal region may cover only a part of the background source(s ) ( hamann 1998 , arav 1997 ) . partial covering along the line of sight is common in narrower intrinsic absorbers ( e.g. barlow , hamann , and sargent 1997 ) , but more difficult to determine in bal quasars where the strong doublets of si iv and c iv are typically blended into wide features . in narrower intrinsic absorption systems , the partial covering is both ion and velocity dependent ( barlow and sargent 1997 ) . partial covering definitely influences some narrow bal components as determined from hires observations of cso 755 ( barlow and junkkarinen 1994 ) and q0226@xmath41024 . in this conference proceedings paper , we report on a program that uses keck hires spectra in the analysis of the bals . bal features in the uv ( observed frame ) are analyzed using lower resolution spectra obtained from the hst archive . the hires spectra contribute in a number of areas to the analysis . here we report on : 1 . ) bal smoothness , and 2 . ) absorption templates . as a by product of the template generation , the the hires spectra provide some information on partial covering . the observed smoothness of the bal features in hires spectra rules out a `` picket fence '' model for the bals . a `` picket fence '' model ( partial covering by turbulent components in velocity space ) was proposed by kwan ( 1990 ) in order to explain the relative weakness of the h i ly @xmath5 bal without resorting to non solar chemical abundances or partial covering along the line of sight . the smooth bal features also imply a large number of `` clouds '' in the bal region if the bal region is composed of clouds rather than a smooth outflow . in order to quantify the smoothness of the bal features , the c iv bal in q1246@xmath4047 has been divided by a piecewise polynomial . a small number of polynomials of low order were used to preserve residual fluctuations on scales less than @xmath1 200 km s@xmath2 . the result of that division is shown in figure 1 . the entire c iv bal feature spans absorption velocities from 10 000 km s@xmath2 to 27 000 km s@xmath2 . in the c iv bal , from 4700 to 4760 ( chosen because the optical depth is roughly constant ) , there are 375 8.8 km s@xmath2 bins . each bin is four pixels , about the fwhm resolution for this hires spectrum . if we ignore the fact that the bins are not completely independent and and also ignore the doublet nature of the c iv transition , an estimate of the number of independent `` clouds '' can be made from the noise in the divided c iv spectrum . the residual intensity is assumed to be given by @xmath6 = @xmath7 with @xmath8 = @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the number of clouds contributing to the absorption in each bin and @xmath11 is the optical depth per cloud . if the clouds obey a simple gaussian distribution with its @xmath12 rms variation in number , then the rms fluctuations in the divided spectrum , @xmath13 = @xmath14 , will be given by : @xmath15 = @xmath16 . here @xmath17 and @xmath18 is the smooth fit to the data . putting in the observed @xmath19 and @xmath20 in this wavelength range , gives n @xmath1 300 clouds and multiplying by 375 bins gives @xmath21 clouds . this is a very crude estimate , but it is clear that a large number of clouds are needed to make a smooth trough . the residuals observed are at a level slightly higher than expected from the noise estimate in the spectrum ( @xmath22 , while 1.0 is expected if purely from noise ) . given the process of piecing together the hires spectral orders , fitting a continuum , and then fitting the trough with a piecewise polynomial , it is possible that all of the observed variation is noise plus some fitting errors . this analysis is most sensitive to a large number of clouds at the resolution of the observation . above a few hundred km s@xmath2 , for the c iv trough in q1246 - 057 , some structure is removed by the polynomial fit used to model the smooth trough . the bin size can easily be varied and repeating this exercise shows that for `` cloud '' ( or component ) widths from 5 to 200 km s@xmath2 a large number ( @xmath23 ) of clouds is needed . the assignment of a typical velocity width for a typical cloud is uncertain because the physical mechanism behind bal cloud confinement is not known . photoionization at parsec distances or greater leads to a much larger number of very small individual clouds and small filling factors ( e.g. junkkarinen , burbidge , and smith 1987 ) . velocity widths @xmath1 8 km s@xmath2 ( fwhm ) are produced by thermal broadening for carbon at t @xmath1 15 000 k , near the temperature expected from photoionization equilibrium . the smoothness of the troughs in bal quasars like q1246@xmath4057 may instead indicate a smooth outflow . models that avoid the need for small clouds have been calculated by murray et al . ( 1995 ) . in these models the emission and absorption regions are both formed very close to the central engine ( starting point as near as @xmath10.003 pc ) , and the absorption is produced by a smooth outflow that crosses the line of sight at an angle . the conventional analysis of bal spectra involves the extraction of absorption templates from the data . doublets like c iv @xmath24 1548.2,1550.8 and si iv @xmath24 1393.8,1402.8 , can be iteratively corrected for the weaker line ( junkkarinen , burbidge , and smith 1983 ) to produce optical depth versus velocity . these templates are shifted to the wavelengths of other transitions and scaled in a @xmath25 fitting procedure to match the data and give approximate ( lower limit ) column densities ( e.g. korista et al . 1992 ) . because bal quasars like q0226@xmath41024 ( fig . 2 ) and q1246@xmath4057 have smooth troughs with no apparent features at scales around 30 km s@xmath2 , spectra obtained at the hires resolution ( typically 7 - 9 km s@xmath2 fwhm ) can be smoothed to produce high quality templates . figure 3 shows the c iv and si iv absorption templates extracted from our keck hires spectrum of q0226@xmath41024 . the spectra were smoothed to produce these templates and could be further smoothed without losing any of the apparent structure . at the hires resolution of 7 km s@xmath2 fwhm for q0226@xmath41024 and at a resolution of 9 km s@xmath2 fwhm for q1246@xmath4057 the troughs are completely resolved . the troughs are not without structure as is illustrated in the case of q0226@xmath41024 . the lowest velocity bal feature ( marked `` 1 '' in figs . 2 & 3 ) breaks up into three `` spikes '' of absorption repeated in both c iv and si iv . these features are not resolved with @xmath26 spectra . analyzing bal quasar spectra using multiple templates that cover only a part of the velocity space may be possible when the bals occur in clumps well separated in velocity . troughs 1 and 2 in q0226@xmath41024 are narrower than the si iv @xmath24 1393.8,1402.8 doublet . trough 2 shows partial covering in si iv with @xmath27 based on measurements of the doublet using : @xmath28 , where @xmath29 and @xmath30 are the residual intensities in the stronger and weaker lines in the doublet ( e.g. hamann et al . 1997 ) . the template extraction procedure assumes full covering and produces a false absorption feature around 7500 km s@xmath2 in the extracted template ( marked `` art.''fig . 3 ) . such weak , echo like features and regions where the template goes negative are indications that the assumption of complete coverage of the background source has broken down . artifacts can also be produced by a poor choice of continuum , so the templates must be evaluated allowing for some uncertainty in the continuum . for very wide features with smooth edges compared to the doublet separation , like trough 3 in c iv in q0226@xmath41024 , it is easy to construct partial covering models that mimic the data . the data are consistent with either 100% covering over those velocities or with high optical depths and a covering function that is chosen to produce the shape of the observed feature . the important issue of partial covering dominating the shape of the broad bal troughs is not one that is easily resolved . the bals in q1246@xmath4057 and q0226@xmath41024 are found to be smooth and completely resolved in the keck hires spectra at a resolution of 7 9 km s@xmath2 fwhm . the smoothness of the c iv trough in q1246@xmath4057 leads to an estimate of at least @xmath31 clouds ( or components ) of width 5 to 200 km s@xmath2 comprising the deepest part of the trough . keck hires spectra are a good source for generating absorption templates for analyzing lower resolution ground based and hst uv spectra of bal quasars . the spectrum of q0226@xmath41024 shows bal features with structure that is not resolved in low resolution spectra . the q0226@xmath41024 si iv template also shows artifacts produced by a breakdown of the assumption of complete covering of the background source . in broader bal features ( broad relative to the doublet separation ) , the effects of optical depth and partial covering are not easy to separate . spectropolarimetry ( e.g. cohen et al . 1997 ) or photoionization equilibrium analysis could yield estimates of the partial covering and the true column densities in the broad features . | in the analysis of broad absorption line ( bal ) quasar spectra , keck hires spectra are a useful complement to lower resolution hst and ground based spectra . the hires spectra provide accurate parameters for narrow , intervening type absorption systems including lyman limit systems and a direct measurement of the smoothness of bal features . the smoothness of the troughs is related to the number of `` clouds '' in the bal region if the bal region consists of clouds . the hires spectra , especially for @xmath0 @xmath1 2 bal quasars , are also a source of high quality absorption templates . all of the bal features are apparently resolved in the high resolution spectra ( r @xmath1 45 000 ) , while low resolution ( r @xmath1 1000 ) spectra do not always resolve features belonging to the outflow . # 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in |
cond-mat0210199 | due to their high coercivity , single - domain nanoparticles exhibit long - range stability of the magnetization and thereby that of the information stored in recording media . the storage density may be increased by using very small particles , but then surface effects become dominant and affect the magnetization relaxation . therefore , one of our aims is to include surface effects in the calculation of the relaxation time of the particle magnetization . however , this requires a microscopic approach to account for the local environment inside the particle , and thus include microscopic interactions such as spin - spin exchange , in addition to anisotropy and applied field . unfortunately , this leads to a rather difficult task owing to the large number of degrees of freedom which hinders any attempt to analyze the energyscape . for this reason , inter alia , calculations of the reversal time of the magnetization of fine single - domain ferromagnetic particles , initiated by nel @xcite , and set firmly in the context of the theory of stochastic processes by brown @xcite , have invariably ignored all kind of interactions and included only the internal anisotropy of the particle , the random field due to thermal fluctuations , and the zeeman term . in 1968 langer @xcite came up with a general approach to the calculation of the reaction rate of a system with @xmath6 degrees of freedom , which is a powerful method of attack on the problem of interaction . within this approach the problem of calculating the relaxation time for a multi - dimensional process is reduced to solving a steady - state fokker - planck equation ( ssfpe ) in the immediate neighborhood of the saddle point that the system crosses as it goes from a metastable state to another state of greater stability . the idea is that a steady - state situation can be set up by continuously replenishing the metastable state at a rate equal to the rate at which it is leaking across the activation energy barrier . a brief review of the main steps and application to the problem at hand are given after eq . ( [ gamma_tsp ] ) , see also @xcite for uniform and non - uniform magnetization , and @xcite for comparison with kramers theory . however , langer s approach is only valid in the limit of intermediate - to - high damping ( ihd ) because of the inherent assumption that the potential energy in the vicinity of the saddle point may be approximated by its second - order taylor expansion . the result for small damping fails because the region of deviation from the maxwell - boltzmann distribution set up in the well extends far beyond the narrow region at the top of the barrier . the problem associated with the generalization of brown s theory to include interactions is rather difficult and can in general be solved only numerically . but before attacking this problem , one needs to understand the effect of exchange interaction on the relaxation time of the minimal system , i.e. , for a pair of atomic spins coupled via exchange interaction , including of course the usual magneto - crystalline anisotropy and zeeman terms . besides , in the case of exchange interaction , this is the unique non - trivial step towards the above - mentioned generalization , where analytical expressions can be obtained for the relaxation time . it is the purpose of this work to solve this problem within langer s approach and to compare with the nel - brown result for the one - spin problem . as a byproduct , we will show that langer s quadratic approximation at the saddle point fails when the exchange coupling assumes a critical value " even in the ihd limit . in this case , finiteness of the relaxation rate requires a higher - order expansion of the energy near the saddle point . the generalization to a multi - spin particle will be briefly discussed at the end . we finally mention that the effect of dipolar interactions on the relaxation time has been considered by a few authors . in refs . @xcite approximate analytical expressions were obtained for the relaxation time in various situations of assemblies of magnetic moments . in ref . @xcite a pair of coupled dipoles was dealt with using the ( numerical ) langevin approach . we consider a system of two exchange - coupled spins with the hamiltonian @xmath7 -\vec{h}\cdot(\vec{s}_{1}+\vec{s}_{2 } ) , \nonumber \\ & & j\equiv j / k,\ , h\equiv h/2k \label{hts}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath8 is the exchange coupling , @xmath9 the anisotropy constant , @xmath1 the applied magnetic field , and @xmath10 the reduced field , i.e. , @xmath11 . @xmath12 are uniaxial anisotropy unit vectors . here we restrict ourselves to the case @xmath13 . owing to the symmetry of this system with respect to rotations around the easy axis , the number of variables reduces to three , @xmath14 . now we apply langer s approach to the energy ( [ hts ] ) and study the relaxation rate as a function of the exchange coupling @xmath15 . we first analyze the energyscape in fig . [ enscape ] . the absolute minimum of the energy ( [ hts ] ) corresponds to the ferromagnetic order along the easy axis , @xmath16 where henceforth @xmath17 denotes the energy of the state . one metastable state corresponds to a ferromagnetic order opposite to the field @xmath18 there is also the metastable state of anti - ferromagnetic order , @xmath19 as to saddle points , we find that their number and loci crucially depend on the exchange coupling constant @xmath15 . more precisely , for @xmath20 , there is a single saddle point given by @xmath21 whereas for @xmath22 there are two saddle points given by @xmath23 where @xmath24 and @xmath25 with energy , @xmath26 at @xmath27 the saddle point ( [ sp21 ] ) with @xmath28 merges with the saddle point ( [ sp0 ] ) , while that with @xmath29 merges with the metastable state ( [ afm ] ) , see fig . [ enscape ] central panel . starting with both spins aligned in the metastable state ( [ mfm ] ) with @xmath30 , if @xmath22 one of the two spins crosses the saddle point ( [ sp21])(@xmath28 ) into the state ( [ afm ] ) by reversing its direction . then the second spin follows through the second saddle point ( [ sp21])(@xmath29 ) , of lower energy due to the exchange coupling ( see fig . [ rate ] ( left ) ) , ending up in the stable state ( [ sfm ] ) . in fig . [ enscape ] ( left ) the path is indicated by a pair of curved arrows . there are actually two such paths corresponding to the two - fold symmetry of the problem owing to the full identity of the two spins . note that when the first spin starts to switch and arrives at @xmath31 , the second spin has @xmath32 ( hence the curved arrows in fig . [ enscape ] ) , which suggests that in the switching process of the first spin , the position of the second spin undergoes some fluctuations creating a small transverse field , and when @xmath33 the second spin goes back to the position @xmath34 before it proceeds to switch in turn . the successive switching of the two spins through the corresponding saddle points is a sequential two - step process , similarly , it was found in ref . @xcite that the reversal of the two dipoles considered is a two - stage process with an intermediary metastable antiparallel state . ] so the relaxation rates for @xmath22 add up inverse - wise . in the case @xmath35 the two spins cross the unique saddle point ( [ sp0 ] ) to go from the metastable state ( [ mfm ] ) into the stable one ( [ sfm ] ) in a single step , see fig . [ enscape ] ( right ) where the path is indicated by a single straight arrow . there is the symmetry @xmath36 , which leads to a factor of 2 in the relaxation rate . therefore , if we denote by @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 the respective relaxation rates , the relaxation rate of the two - spin system is given by @xmath40 in langer s approach the @xmath41s are obtained from the ssfpe linearized around each saddle point , using the fluctuating variables @xmath42 where @xmath43 , or more adequately the canonical " variables @xmath44 with @xmath45 , in which the energy hessian is diagonal . the deterministic dynamics of the system is governed by the landau - lifshitz equations , which upon linearization near the saddle point , read @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the quadratic approximation of the energy ( [ hts ] ) near the saddle point and @xmath48 is the damping parameter . in matrix form eqs . ( [ linlle ] ) become @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is the dynamic matrix containing the precessional and dissipative parts . rather than investigating the stochastic trajectories @xmath51 that arise by adding a noise term in eqs . ( [ linlle ] ) , langer concentrates on the distribution function @xmath52 as the probability that the system is found in the configuration @xmath53 at time @xmath54 . the time evolution of @xmath55 is governed by the fokker - planck equation ( fpe ) @xmath56 , which is a continuity equation with the probability current @xmath57 given , near the saddle point , by @xmath58 in order to calculate the nucleation rate , one must solve the fpe . a particular solution is obtained at equilibrium and is given by the maxwell - boltzmann distribution @xmath59 , which corresponds to zero current , @xmath60 . however , what is really needed is a finite probability current flowing across the saddle point . in fact , instead of solving the time - dependent fpe , langer solves the ssfpe @xmath61 near the saddle point . the steady - state situation may be realized by imposing the boundary conditions : @xmath62 near the metastable state and @xmath63 beyond the saddle point . then , the problem of calculating the escape rate reduces to the calculation of the total current by integrating the probability current @xmath64 over a surface through the saddle point . this led langer to his famous expression for the relaxation rate which is valid in the ihd limit . however , since the escape rate is simply given by the ratio of the total current through the saddle point to the number of particles in the metastable state , langer s result for the escape rate can in fact be achieved by only computing the energy - hessian eigenvalues near the saddle points and metastable states , from which one then infers the partition function @xmath65 of the system restricted to the region around the saddle point where the energy - hessian negative eigenvalue is ( formally ) taken with absolute value , and the partition function @xmath66 of the region around the metastable state . when computing these partition functions , one has to identify and take care of each goldstone mode , that is a massless mode or zero - energy fluctuation associated with a continuous unbroken global symmetry . finally , one computes the unique is unstable @xcite . ] negative eigenvalue @xmath67 of the ssfpe corresponding to the unstable mode at the saddle point as the negative eigenvalue of the dynamic matrix @xmath68 , where the @xmath69 s are the eigenvalues of the hessian at the saddle point and @xmath70 is the transformation matrix from @xmath71 to @xmath72 . consequently , langer s final expression for the escape rate is rewritten in the following somewhat more practical form @xmath73 where @xmath74 is the attempt frequency which contains the damping parameter @xmath48 . now , we give the different relaxation rates for @xmath75 , and @xmath76 . * relaxation rate for @xmath35 * : the quadratic expansion of the energy ( [ hts ] ) at the saddle point ( [ sp0 ] ) reads , @xmath77 with zero eigenvalue for the @xmath78 mode , that is the goldstone mode associated with the rotation around the easy axis . @xmath79 is given in eq . ( [ sp0 ] ) . the negative eigenvalue of the ssfpe , corresponding to the unstable mode , is @xmath80 . the partition function at the saddle point @xmath81 where @xmath82 is calculated by changing to the variables @xmath83 , setting @xmath84 ( see eq . ( [ sp0 ] ) ) in the integration measure , and finally computing the gaussian integrals . hence , @xmath85 where we have formally replaced the negative eigenvalue @xmath86 by its absolute value . the partition function @xmath66 at the metastable state ( [ mfm ] ) is computed by expanding the energy up to @xmath87 order , leading to @xmath88 using eq . ( [ gammapr ] ) and inserting the symmetry factor of @xmath89 , the relaxation rate for @xmath90 reads @xmath91 for @xmath92 ( [ gamma_tsp_j > jc ] ) tends to the nel - brown result , @xmath93 for the relaxation rate of one rigid pair of spins with a barrier height twice that of one spin . note , however , that this convergence is very slow so that @xmath94 remains above the nel - brown result and only merges with the latter for @xmath95 . * relaxation rate for @xmath22 * : here we are faced with a semi - analytical case since the attempt frequencies @xmath96 ( for @xmath24 ) can not be obtained in a closed form and are thus computed numerically . on the other hand , following the same procedure as for @xmath35 we obtain the relaxation rate for @xmath24 , @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the barrier height given by the energy ( [ enj < jc ] ) measured with respect to ( [ mfm ] ) or ( [ afm ] ) for @xmath99 respectively , and ( see eq . ( [ sp21 ] ) et seq . for notation ) @xmath100 the limit of the relaxation rate ( [ gamma_jleqjc ] ) when @xmath101 is just the nel - brown result for one spin . indeed , the product of the last two factors in the prefactor tend to @xmath102 , the attempt frequencies tend to @xmath103 , and the energy barriers @xmath104 . note that in the present regime of @xmath105 the large value of anisotropy has not changed the temperature dependence of the individual relaxation rates , i.e. , @xmath106 , with @xmath107 . this is due to the fact that @xmath108 appears in the prefactor each time there is a continuously degenerate class of saddle points @xcite , which is indeed the case for @xmath90 and @xmath105 with @xmath109 and @xmath110 . however , anisotropy do affect the temperature dependence of the relaxation rate of the two - spin system , since for @xmath22 there are two saddle points bringing each a factor @xmath108 , see the first line in eq . ( [ gamma_tsp ] ) . * the case of @xmath76 * : when @xmath15 approaches @xmath111 either from above or from below , more hessian eigenvalues ( in addition to @xmath112 ) vanish , rendering the saddle point rather flat and thus leading to a divergent relaxation rate . indeed , for @xmath76 the relaxation rate ( [ gamma_tsp_j > jc ] ) diverges , which clearly shows that langer s approach which uses a quadratic approximation for the energy at the saddle point , e.g. , eq . ( [ qej > j_c ] ) , fails in this case . the remedy is to push the energy expansion to the @xmath113order in the variable @xmath114 ( since @xmath115 as @xmath116 ) , i.e. , @xmath117 where @xmath118 . then , the contribution @xmath119 of the mode @xmath114 to the relaxation rate ( [ gamma_tsp_j > jc ] ) must be replaced by@xmath120 , upon which the divergence of @xmath121 is cut off ( see fig . [ rate ] ( right ) ) . similarly , when @xmath15 approaches @xmath111 from below , for @xmath29 the eigenvalue @xmath122 vanishes at @xmath27 , upon which the saddle point ( [ sp21 ] ) ( @xmath29 ) merges with the state ( [ afm ] ) and thereby the partition functions @xmath123 and @xmath66 tend to infinity . however , as @xmath124 increases much faster than @xmath123 , and @xmath125 , @xmath126 tends to zero as @xmath127 . on the other hand , for @xmath28 , both @xmath122 and @xmath128 vanish leading to a divergent relaxation rate , since now @xmath123 diverges but @xmath66 in eq . ( [ z_m ] ) remains finite for the metastable state ( [ mfm ] ) is well defined . indeed , as @xmath127 , the relaxation rate @xmath129 goes over to the result in eq . ( [ gamma_tsp_j > jc ] ) upon making the change @xmath130 , and taking account of the symmetry factor . in this case , the divergence at the point @xmath27 can not be cut off by expanding the energy beyond the @xmath87 order and @xmath131 is simply cut off at the point where it joins @xmath94 taking account of eq . ( [ e6 ] ) . in fig . [ rate ] ( right ) we plot ( @xmath132 of ) the relaxation rate of the two - spin system as defined in eq . ( [ gamma_tsp ] ) , under the condition of ihd , in which langer s approach is valid , that the reduced barrier height @xmath133 and @xmath134 @xcite . we also plot separately both relaxation rates for @xmath135 . we see that the relaxation rate of the two - spin system contains two unconnected branches corresponding to the two regimes , @xmath22 and @xmath35 , the bridging of which would require a more sophisticated approach . fig . [ rate ] ( right ) also shows that as @xmath15 increases , but @xmath136 , the relaxation rate @xmath37 decreases because the switching of the first spin is hindered by the ( ferromagnetic ) exchange coupling . while @xmath38 is an increasing function of @xmath15 with a faster rate , since now the exchange coupling works in favor of the switching of the second spin . this is also illustrated by the evolution of the energy barrier height in fig . [ rate ] ( left ) . as @xmath15 approaches @xmath111 from below , the relaxation rate @xmath137 tends to @xmath39 because the respective saddle points merge at @xmath27 . whereas @xmath38 goes to zero since the corresponding saddle point merges with the antiferromagnetic state that is no longer accessible to the system . for @xmath138 , as @xmath15 increases the minimum ( [ sfm ] ) , the metastable state ( [ mfm ] ) and the saddle point ( [ sp0 ] ) merge together , which means that the system is found in an `` energy groove '' along the direction @xmath139 because the eigenvalue @xmath140 corresponding to the mode @xmath141 becomes very large , and thus the escape rate decreases and eventually reaches the nel - brown value at large @xmath15 . the present study has helped us understand the effect of exchange coupling on the relaxation rate of the two - spin system , and will be very useful for the generalization to multiple - spin small particles at least for small deviations from collinearity , where it has been shown @xcite that the surface contribution to the macroscopic energy has a simple cubic anisotropy . however , this generalization can only be performed using numerical techniques . this is now attempted by the help of the ridge method @xcite for probing the energyscape and locating the saddle points , and by the ( onsager - machlup ) path integrals @xcite for determining the most probable paths connecting a metastable state to a more stable state . dormann j.l . , bessais l. , fiorani d. , j. phys . c : solid state phys . * 21 * ( 1988 ) 2015 ; morup s. and tronc e. , phys . lett * 72 * ( 1994 ) 3278 ; jonsson p.e . and garcia - palacios j.l . , * 55 * ( 2001 ) 418 . | we use langer s approach to calculate the reaction rate of a system of two ( classical ) spins interacting via the exchange coupling @xmath0 in a magnetic field @xmath1 , with uniaxial anisotropy of constant @xmath2 . we find a particular value of the exchange coupling , that is @xmath3 , where @xmath4 , which separates two regimes corresponding to a two - stage and one - stage switching . for @xmath5 the nel - brown result for the one - spin problem is recovered . |
astro-ph0608707 | ls i + 61 303 is a be x - ray binary with strong and variable radio emission . it has been suggested as the potential counterpart of the gamma - ray sources 2cg 135 + 01 and 3eg j0241 + 6103 ( gregory & talor 1978 , kniffen et al . massi et al . ( 2001 ) detected relativistic jets in the source , which was then included in the microquasar class . the existence of jets was confirmed by the observations presented by massi et al . ( 2004 ) . very recently , ls i + 61 303 was detected by magic , a very large atmospheric imaging cherenkov telescope located at la palma ( albert et al . this makes ls i + 61 303 the second high - energy microquasar detected by ground - based telescopes . moreover , magic found clear evidence for variability in the detected signal : the source was stronger at orbital phases 0.5 - 0.6 , whereas the periastron passage occurs at phase 0.23 . at x - rays the source has been detected by xmm - newton , beppo - sax and integral ( sidoli et al . 2006 , chernyakova et al . 2006 ) showing variability on short timescales and a harder spectrum when the source was brighter ( sidoli et al . 2006 ) . the orbital parameters of ls i + 61 303 have been determined by casares et al . the eccentricity of the system is [email protected] and the orbital inclination is @xmath3 deg . the nature of the compact object is not well - established . a low - mass black hole can not be ruled out ( massi 2004 ) . if a mass of @xmath4 2.5 m@xmath5 is assumed for the compact object , then the mass of the be star should be @xmath6 m@xmath5 , for @xmath7 deg . from a theoretical point of view , both accreting and non - accreting models have been proposed to explain the high - energy emission of ls i+61 303 . in the accreting scenario ( e.g. bosch - ramon et al . 2006a ) a relativistic jet is launched from the surroundings of the compact object . strong magnetic fields are supported by an underluminous accretion disk , which is advection - dominated . high - energy emission can be produced in the jet by leptonic ( e.g. bosch - ramon et al . 2006b , gupta & bttcher 2006 , bednarek 2006a ) or hadronic ( romero et al . 2003 , 2005 ) interactions . in non - accreting models ( dubus 2006b , chernyakova et al . 2006 ) particles are accelerated up to relativistic energies in the interacting region where a pulsar wind collides with the stellar wind . inverse compton ( ic ) cooling of electrons ( maraschi & treves 1981 , dubus 2006b ) or @xmath0 interactions ( chernyakova et al . 2006 ) could result in the production of high - energy photons . a colliding wind model has been proposed as the mechanism producing the high - energy emission in the @xmath1-ray binary psr b1259 - 63 , a system that contains a radio pulsar in an eccentric orbit around a be star ( aharonian et al . 2005 ) . in the case of ls i+61 303 , the existence of jets extending up to @xmath8 au from the core seems to support an accretion / jet model ( see the discussion in mirabel 2006 ) . albert et al . ( 2006 ) favor a microquasar model and suggest that the detection of the high - energy signal after the periastron passage would support a leptonic origin for the emission . however , @xmath1-ray propagation effects alone could be responsible for such a behavior ( bednarek 2006a ) . in this paper we revisit the hadronic model for high - energy emission in ls i+61 303 proposed by romero et al . ( 2005 ) before the magic detection . using an improved accretion model and more sophisticated calculations for the opacity effects inside the binary system we show that a hadronic origin for the emission detected by magic can not be ruled out . we consider gamma - ray production in hadronic interactions of relativistic protons from a jet launched close to the compact object and cold protons from the equatorial wind of the be star ( romero et al . 2003 , 2005 ) . the star has a slow equatorial wind that fits a density profile @xmath9 , with @xmath10 and @xmath11 g @xmath12 ( mart and paredes 1995 ) . the wind remains mainly near to the equatorial plane , confined in a disk with half - opening angle @xmath13 , and an initial outflowing radial velocity @xmath14 km s@xmath15 ( mart and paredes 1995 ) . the disk effective temperature close to the star is @xmath16 k. the values of the adopted parameters in our model are listed in table [ tab ] . lllll parameter : description [ units ] & values + @xmath17 : stellar mass [ @xmath18 & 12 + @xmath19 : stellar radius [ @xmath20 & 10 + @xmath21 : compact object mass [ @xmath18 & 2.5 + @xmath22 : eccentricity & 0.72 + @xmath23 : orbital plane inclination [ @xmath24 & 30 + @xmath25 : angle of periastron [ @xmath24 & 20 + @xmath26 : initial jet radius [ @xmath27 & 5 + @xmath28 : jet initial point in the compact object rf [ @xmath27 & 50 + @xmath29 : jet semi - opening angle tangent & 0.1 + @xmath30 : equipartition magnetic field at the base of the jet [ g ] & @xmath31 + @xmath32 : relativistic proton power - law index & 2.5 + @xmath33 : lowest lorentz factor of relativistic protons & 2 + @xmath34 : highest lorentz factor of relativistic protons & @xmath35 + @xmath36 : macroscopic jet lorentz factor & 1.25 + @xmath37 : stellar surface temperature [ k ] & @xmath38 + @xmath39 : circumstellar disk temperature [ k ] & 17000 + @xmath40 : circumstellar disk outer radius [ @xmath19 ] & 12 + @xmath42 : radius of the circumstellar disk brightest region [ @xmath19 ] & 3 + @xmath43 : circumstellar disk luminosity [ erg s@xmath15 ] & @xmath45 + @xmath46 : disk half - opening angle [ @xmath24 & 15 + @xmath47 : radial velocity of the wind at the base [ cm s@xmath15 ] & @xmath48 + @xmath49 : azimuthal velocity of the wind at the base [ cm s@xmath15 ] & @xmath50 + @xmath51 : density of wind at the base [ g @xmath12 ] & @xmath53 + the @xmath0 interactions can occur either because there is some mixing of the stellar wind with the jet matter or because some protons escape from the jet into the wind . the level of interaction is quantified through a mixing factor " , here assumed as @xmath54 . this phenomenological prescription accounts for a more efficient rejection of particles when a larger relative velocity is thought to enhance the boundary effects between the jet and the wind . at phase @xmath55 the mixing factor is maximum , reaching @xmath56 . the jet is assumed to be in a steady state . we are not dealing here with the details of the launching mechanism , which is supposed to be related to magneto - centrifugal effects ( blandford & payne 1982 ) . the hadronic jet power is a fraction of the accretion power : @xmath57 . the value of @xmath58 is taken as a free parameter . in order to reproduce the magic observations we have that @xmath59 . the mass accretion rate @xmath60 is strongly dependent on the relative velocity of the compact object with respect to the wind . to estimate the evolution of the accretion rate onto the black hole we have taken into account the azimuthal wind velocity @xmath61 cm s@xmath15 ( gregory & neish 2002 , casares et al . 2005 ) in addition to the radial velocity , @xmath62 cm s@xmath15 . the bondi - hoyle accretion regime was considered to obtain the values of @xmath60 shown in figure 1 . this is just a rough approximation used by several authors ( mart and paredes 1995 , gregory & neish 2002 ) . close to the compact object there should be a transition to disk accretion , but the absence of disk signatures in the x - ray spectrum suggests that the accretion disk in ls i+61 303 is small . we shall assume that changes in @xmath60 are propagated to the jet on timescales much shorter than the orbital period . g s@xmath15 . ] in figure [ c - luz ] we show the gamma - ray luminosity expected from @xmath63 and the subsequent neutral pion decays . the light curve is plotted for photon energies @xmath64 gev , which is the lower energy reported by magic for ls i + 61 303 . the differential @xmath1-ray emissivity is calculated applying the @xmath65-function approximation ( aharonian & atoyan 2000 ) . the jet is assumed to expand in a conical way ( see parameters in table [ tab ] ) . the magnetic field ( @xmath66 g at the base of the jet ) results from the equipartition condition ( see bosch ramon et al . 2006a ) and then decreases with the distance as @xmath67 . notice that the field will change with the accretion rate and hence , with the orbital phase . since hadronic energy losses are negligible , the maximum proton energy has been obtained at the jet formation point equating the shock acceleration rate to the proton synchrotron rate . this leads to @xmath68 at the base of the jet during the periastron passage . photohadron interactions in the stellar field ( the typical energy of the stellar photons is @xmath69 ev ) are well below the threshold even for the most energetic protons . these type of losses are possible with x - ray photons form the accretion disk , but the x - ray luminosity is low enough as to neglect them in a first approximation . the differential distribution of relativistic protons has an index @xmath70 in order to match the slope of the magic spectrum . we note that the usual particle acceleration through the fermi mechanism can lead to such a soft distribution for shocks with low mach number . actually , @xmath32 could be time dependent , affected at some extent by the strong variations in the accretion rate . there are two maxima in the light curve shown in figure [ c - luz ] , one at the periastron and the other around phase 0.5 , when the relative velocity is minimum . the solid line shows the luminosity corrected by @xmath71 absorption in the stellar and disk radiation fields . we have calculated the opacity of the anisotropic stellar field as in dubus ( 2006a ) , taking into account angular effects and the finite size of the star . the orientation of the orbit is given by casares et al . the circumstellar disk is modeled as a blackbody of @xmath16 k for the inner region ( up to an inner radius of 3 stellar radii ) and then with an emissivity that goes as @xmath72 ( waters 1986 , bosch - ramon et al . 2006b ) . the disk farther truncates at 12 @xmath73 . the inner region of the disk is normalized to emit @xmath74 erg s@xmath15 , which is a non negligible fraction of the total thermal emission of the system ( casares et al . the total @xmath71 cross - section has been considered for interactions with photons from the disk . the energy dependence of the optical depth from both disk and stellar contribution is shown in figure [ tau - e ] . figure [ tau-200 ] presents the variation of the total optical depth with the orbital phase for a photon of energy of 200 gev . the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) from @xmath0 interactions , estimated for different orbital phases , is shown in figure [ spectros ] . close to the periastron the absorption results to be significant , and mainly dominated by the circumstellar disk emission . on the other hand , at phase @xmath75 most of the radiation escapes from the source , making it detectable at this phase and not during the first accretion peak , when the ambient wind density is maximum . notice that the more realistic modeling of the wind and the absorption changes these results from those previously presented by romero et al . ( 2005 ) . we have computed the high - energy @xmath1-ray spectra resulting from cascades traversing the anisotropic stellar radiation field during the periastron passage . the star is characterized by a surface temperature @xmath76 k , and a stellar radius @xmath77 r@xmath78 . monte carlo simulations were performed after developing a computational code based on the scheme outlined by protheroe ( 1986 ) and protheroe et al . the @xmath1-ray spectra produced through ic interactions were approximated as in jones ( 1968 ) , modified in similar way to bednarek ( 1997 ) . we introduced the effects of the finite size of the star and the spatial variation of the ambient photon field density by considering the geometric configuration as in dubus ( 2006a ) . the magnetic field in the cascade region , originated in the star , was assumed to be lower than 0.1 g , assuring in this way a strongly compton dominated regime . we followed the cascades induced by the injected gamma - ray flux with mentioned photon index @xmath70 , during the periastron passage ( i.e. orbital separation of @xmath79 ) . in figure [ cascados ] we present the results of the simulations . the one - dimensional cascade development is calculated in the anisotropic stellar field along the line of sight , forming a 30 deg angle with the jet axis . at phase 0.5 the opacity is not enough to sustain a local cascade ( gamma - rays that escape in the direction of the star can produce cascades in the stellar photosphere , and some gamma - rays could , in principle , be redirected toward the observer , see bednarek 2006a and 2006b ) . we notice that at the periastron passage the effect of the cascades is to produce a softer @xmath1-ray spectrum with index @xmath80 in the magic energy range . such a feature should be detectable through larger exposures than those reported in albert et al . ( 2006 ) . -ray luminosity from hadronic interactions . the dashed line corresponds to the generated luminosity . in solid line , we show the luminosity corrected by absorption in the stellar and disk photon fields , according to the values of @xmath81 shown in figure [ tau-200 ] . ] -ray photons with energy @xmath82 gev . note that at @xmath75 ( solid line ) the expected signal should be stronger than at the periastron passage ( @xmath83 ) for the range of energies covered by magic . the actual cutoff for high - energy photons is around 1 pev . ] ( which mimics the original proton spectral index ) . these results were obtained through monte carlo simulations , properly taking into account the geometric configuration . the curves were normalized with @xmath84 and the actual cutoff is around 1 pev . ] the luminosity obtained at phase 0.5 implies that the constant coupling the jet kinetic power and the accretion luminosity should be @xmath59 in order to explain the @xmath85 erg s@xmath15 inferred from magic detections . powerful jets can be present in microquasars , as showed by gallo et al . ( 2005 ) for the case of cygnus x-1 . at energies below the break of the hadronic spectrum ( @xmath4 gev ) the emission of leptonic origin should change the shape of the sed yielding the egret spectrum . the hadronic interactions that produce neutral pions also generate relativistic electrons and positrons by the decay of charged @xmath86-mesons . we have not computed here the emission of such leptons , for we are concerned only with the very high energy range . some estimations of the synchrotron luminosity of secondaries were presented in romero et al . ( 2005 ) . both leptonic and hadronic microquasar models for the gamma - ray emission in ls i + 61 303 can reproduce the main features of the observed gamma - ray emission . the detection of the source at phase 0.5 is a consequence of the opacity effects and is independent of the dominant radiative process in the jet . even in hadronic models like the one presented here , near the periastron passage gamma - rays will initiate electromagnetic cascades with ic emission , hence the actual situation could be a mixture of radiative processes . more realistic simulations of the photospheric cascades should include the effects of circumstellar disk absorption . in a pure leptonic model the radiative losses equating the acceleration rate fix the maximum energies of the @xmath1-ray photons at @xmath69 tev ( bosch - ramon et al . detection of @xmath1-ray emission of ls i + 61 303 at higher energies than those observed by magic ( e.g. at @xmath87 tev ) could give support to a hadronic model , and to the presence of intense magnetic fields at the base of the jet . a clear distinction about the nature of most of the primary gamma - rays can be established through the detection of neutrinos , which are produced only in hadronic models . in the context of our model , we expect around 3 - 4 muon neutrinos per squared km per year at earth , so the source might be detectable by icecube ( christiansen et al . 2006 , see also the discussion in torres & halzen 2006 ) . as we mentioned in the introduction , an alternative model for the gamma - ray production in ls i + 61 303 involves an energetic pulsar which could generate a strong wind that would stop the accretion . particles might be accelerated at the colliding wind region , producing gamma - rays through ic and @xmath0 interactions ( dubus 2006b , chernyakova et al . however , it is not clear how the morphological and variability properties of the system might be explained in this scenario . what is clear is that the high accretion rates and the observed low x - ray luminosity seem to exclude a scenario based upon an accreting pulsar , since there is no trace of the emission from the heated surface . future observations with magic will help to detect the source close to the periastron and the spectral evolution along the orbit , providing in this way more constraints to the models . we thank valenti bosch - ramon , wlodek bednarek , e. derishev , and josep m. paredes for discussions and an anonymous referee for valuable comments . this work was supported by grants pict 03 - 13291 , bid 1728/oc - ar ( anpcyt ) and pip 5375 ( conicet ) . 3 aharonian , f. a. , et al . ( hess coll . ) , a&a , * 442 * , 1 ( 2005 ) aharonian , f. a. , & atoyan , a. m. , a&a * 362 * , 937 ( 2000 ) albert , j. et al . ( magic coll . ) , science , * 312 * , 1771 ( 2006 ) bednarek , w. , a&a , * 322 * , 523 ( 1997 ) bednarek , w. , mnras , * 368 * , 579 ( 2006a ) bednarek , w. , mnras , * 371 * , 1737 ( 2006b ) blandford , r.d . & payne , d.g . , mnras * 199 * , 883 ( 1982 ) bosch - ramon , v. , romero , g.e . , paredes , j.m . , a&a , * 447 * , 263 ( 2006a ) bosch - ramon , v. et al . , a&a , in press ( 2006b ) casares , j. , et al . , mnras , * 364 * , 899 ( 2005 ) chernyakova , m. , neronov , a. , walter , r. , mnras , in press , [ astro - ph/0606070 ] ( 2006 ) christiansen , h.r . , orellana , m. , romero , g.e . d. * 73 * , 063012 ( 2006 ) dubus , w. , a&a , * 451 * , 9 ( 2006a ) dubus , w. , a&a , * 456 * , 801,(2006b ) gallo , e. , et al . nature , * 436 * , 819 - 821 ( 2005 ) gregory , p.c , & taylor , a.r . , nature , * 272 * , 704 ( 1978 ) gregory , p.c . , & neish , c. , apj , * 580 * , 1133 ( 2002 ) gupta , s. & b@xmath88ttcher , m. , apj lett , in press [ astro - ph/0606590 ] ( 2006 ) jones , f. , physical review * 167 * , 1159 ( 1968 ) kniffen , d.a . , et al . , apj , * 486 * , 126 ( 1997 ) maraschi , l. & treves , a. , mnras * 194 * , 1 ( 1981 ) marti , j. , & paredes , j.m . , a&a , * 298 * , 151 ( 1995 ) massi , m. , et al . , a&a , * 376 * , 217 ( 2001 ) massi , m. , et al . , a&a , * 414 * , l1 ( 2004 ) massi , m. , a&a , * 422 * , 267 ( 2004 ) mirabel , i.f . , science * 312 * , 1759 ( 2006 ) romero , g.e . , et al . , a&a , * 410 * , l1 ( 2003 ) romero , g.e . , christiansen , h.r . , orellana , m. , apj * 632 * , 1093 ( 2005 ) sidoli , l. et al . , submitted to a&a , [ astro - ph/0606722 ] ( 2006 ) torres , d.f . , & halzen , f , [ astro - ph/0607368 ] ( 2006 ) waters , l.b.f.m . , a&a , * 162 * , 121 ( 1986 ) | ls i+61 303 has been detected by the cherenkov telescope magic at very high energies , presenting a variable flux along the orbital motion with a maximum clearly separated from the periastron passage . in the light of the new observational constraints , we revisit the discussion of the production of high - energy gamma rays from particle interactions in the inner jet of this system . the hadronic contribution could represent a major fraction of the tev emission detected from this source . the spectral energy distribution resulting from @xmath0 interactions is recalculated . opacity effects introduced by the photon fields of the primary star and the stellar decretion disk are shown to be essential in shaping the high - energy gamma - ray light curve at energies close to 200 gev . we also present results of monte carlo simulations of the electromagnetic cascades developed very close to the periastron passage . we conclude that a hadronic microquasar model for the gamma - ray emission in ls i + 61 303 can reproduce the main features of its observed high - energy @xmath1-ray flux . example.eps gsave newpath 20 20 moveto 20 220 lineto 220 220 lineto 220 20 lineto closepath 2 setlinewidth gsave .4 setgray fill grestore stroke grestore |
1608.06777 | fourier spectroscopies concept revolutionized many analytical techniques in the second half of the @xmath0 century : nuclear magnetic resonance ( nmr ) , infrared spectroscopy ( ir ) , raman spectroscopy , and mass spectrometry ( ms ) with fourier transform ion cyclotronic resonance ( fticr - ms)@xcite and more recently orbitrap@xcite . the use of fast fourier transform gives access to fellgett advantage@xcite and permits higher sensitivity and faster acquisitions . as these analytical techniques share the same processing procedures it is possible to devise common tools . however , generally each domain usually comes with specific methods for display as well as specific file formats , limiting the sharing of tools and leading to redundant developments . every experimental study is the result of a three steps procedure . data are first acquired , then processed and finally analyzed . depending on the domain , processing is a more or less neglected task . for example , in mass spectrometry , analysis is a very important part of the work for the exploitation of the data and many commercial and open - source softwares have been developed for this purpose during the last decades and are now available@xcite . but very few tools are proposed for processing the data before analysis . most of the time , this step is abandoned to manufacturers and considered as black boxes full of obscure procedures , whereas processing is a crucial step for providing a more precise and complete information for analysis . in contrast , processing is a dominant part of the nmr spectroscopist culture with a very large wealth of existing softwares @xcite . in addition new processing techniques are profundly modifying data processing and there is a need of incorporating them in the toolbox of the practitioners . recent computer capabilities have indeed given the possibility to store very large amount of data at each experimental run . the rising usage of high - throughput@xcite acquisition in mass spectrometry has rapidly taken advantage of those progresses . but in spite of hardware enhancements , the classical processing techniques at disposal ( such as denoising , deconvolution , etc .. ) are facing both the huge volume of data and the limited time available for computations . this phenomenon , known as the _ big data bottleneck _ , raises the need of newer algorithms , adapted to big data by being faster and with less memory footprint . as a first answer to these two major concerns : generic processing tools for ft spectroscopies and big data challenge , we propose here a framework able to handle general processing and which can currently be used for ft mass spectrometry ( fticr and orbitrap ) as well as for nmr processing . we called it spike ( spectrometry processing innovative kernel ) , as it is developed as a kernel , extensible to any ft spectroscopies beyond the ones already implemented . this approach should help for a _ cross - fertilization _ in the target spectroscopic domains , by a wider use of some sophisticated techniques which are currently confined to a specialized domain . spike was developed from the difficulties observed when using the npk package@xcite on large nmr and ft - icr data - sets ( and was even called npkv2 in the beginning of the project ) . it was conceived as a complete rewrite , with a totally new organization while retaining some of its modularity and data concepts . the choice of the computer language was considered with an emphasis on robustness , flexibility and evolvability , with some consideration on the inherent speed . scientific python@xcite was thus chosen as a development platform since it comes with all the benefits of a clear syntax , easy maintainability , simple and fast extensibility . processing speed is insured by the scientific modules numpy@xcite and scipy@xcite which have been developed on the top of performant standard libraries developed in low level languages . all the processing in spike relies on a chained syntax in which each element performs an elementary processing task . this gives the possibility to write code easily without any programming expertise . the language can be used for writing scripts or in an interactive programming context such as the ipython notebook@xcite web interface . spike comes also with a plugin mechanism which is practical for adding in a flexible manner new functionalities to the native library , without modifying the internal code . the elementary basic block routines in spike are apodisation , zero - filling and a full set of fourier transforms . 1d and 2d spectra are handled , and the processing of higher dimension spectra is in development . the handling of hypercomplex numbers originally incorporated for multidimensional nmr @xcite is available and used for the processing of 2d - nmr as well as 2d - fticr - ms data - sets . baseline correction can be done using classical savitzky - golay@xcite filter or with a specific algorithm using @xmath1 norm optimization . elementary peak - picking with centroid correction can be performed both on 1d and 2d spectra . several advanced processing methods are also proposed in the spike program . it contains specific algorithms such as the burg algorithm for linear prediction@xcite which can be useful in many situations such as missing points reconstruction or spectral analysis . denoising is a major concern in data processing . statistical methods such as cadzow@xcite or wavelet denoising@xcite are very efficient for coping with noise in different kind of signals and are provided here@xcite . spike also incorporates the recently proposed algorithm urqrd@xcite which relies on low rank matrix approximation performed with random projections . this algorithm provides a more robust noise filtering as well as a much faster speed than algorithms of the same kind . its much reduced memory footprint permits to handle very large data - sets . it is used for example on the 2d - fticr - ms data - set for removing the strong scintillation noise from the 2d - ms data - sets . whenever practical spike performs its data processing in memory . this is done with the numpy library which allows vectorized computations of large binary arrays . in the case of operations too large to fit into memory , the processing is performed _ onfile _ thanks to the hierarchical data format file format hdf5@xcite . data stored in this format are accessible transparently as numpy arrays thanks to the pytable@xcite python module . this feature allows to efficiently cope with the with ram bottleneck for memory greedy application such as 2d - fticr - ms processing and visualization . the hdf5 format was chosen as the default file format for storing spike data . its hierarchical structure allows an easy storage of complex data and structured metadata , and the internal compression capabilities insure an optimal file size . each manufacturer data - set comes with its own specific importer integrated via a plugin mechanism . the importers encapsulate the data and metadata in a unique corresponding python object which can then be easily manipulated through pipe commands . the metadata are interpreted from the parameter files provided by the instrument , and give information about characteristic acquisition parameters . importers are provided for thermofisher _ .dat _ files , bruker _ apex _ and _ solarix _ files , as well as _ mzxml _ generic format ; and for bruker _ fid _ , _ ser _ and processed nmr files . data can also be easily imported from and exported to the gifa and npk software@xcite file formats as well as csv text files . with the emphasis on big data processing approach relies on fast algorithms but also on parallel calculations . this is done transparently using either the multiprocessing python module for a simple parallelism on multicore machines , or the mpi tool@xcite which permits a deployment on a large scale clusters . a generic interface to mpi was developed inside spike , allowing a very efficient parallelism . figure [ fig : parallel ] presents the processing of a large 2d - fticr - ms experiment , parallelized on up to 64 processors on a large linux beowulf cluster . line , corresponding to a perfect speed - up . top ) processing of a 2k@xmath264k data - set , ( fft and rank 20 urqrd ) to produce a 4k@xmath2128k output spectrum , on a dual xeon machine with a total of 12 cores , using the python multiprocessing module ; bottom ) processing of a 4k@xmath2256k data - set , ( fft and rank 200 urqrd ) to produce a 8k@xmath2512k output spectrum , performed on the strasbourg university hpc using mpi ; the limiting burden here is the file access time.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] line , corresponding to a perfect speed - up . top ) processing of a 2k@xmath264k data - set , ( fft and rank 20 urqrd ) to produce a 4k@xmath2128k output spectrum , on a dual xeon machine with a total of 12 cores , using the python multiprocessing module ; bottom ) processing of a 4k@xmath2256k data - set , ( fft and rank 200 urqrd ) to produce a 8k@xmath2512k output spectrum , performed on the strasbourg university hpc using mpi ; the limiting burden here is the file access time.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] recently the equivalent of two - dimensional nmr applied to fticr - ms , namely 2d - fticr - ms@xcite was revived@xcite . this is a new exciting but challenging tool for the analysis of very complex mixtures . in comparison to tandem mass spectrometry , no chromatographic separation nor ion isolation are required , acquisition is greatly simplified and the technique is much more flexible . even though it was proposed in the mid eighties , it was not usable in practice until very recently principally because of the limitations on processing and of the huge memory consumption . indeed , the latest examples of 2d - fticr - ms applied to proteomics studies@xcite would not have been possible without the development of the project presented here . a special independent module is provided which performs the complete processing of 2d - fticr - ms experiment using spike s library . this module makes an optimal use of all capabilities of the program , in particular the parallel processing . the processing of this large data - sets is not interactive , so a batch processing mode was chosen and the user has to set - up a configuration file for the parameters for the processing . this configuration file , as well as the log of the process , is stored as metadata into the final hdf5 file . all data - sets can be displayed interactively using the python matplotlib library@xcite in a transparent manner , it comes with all the standard tools for manipulating the graph ( zoom , drag , saving etc ... ) . axes representation is handled according to data type and in their own natural unit ( _ second _ , _ hz _ , _ ppm _ , _ m / z _ , etc ... ) on multidimensional data the axes can be set independently . spike proposes also a specific graphic interface developed using the qt library@xcite dedicated to the display and analysis of the 2f - fticr - ms spectra ( cf figure [ visu2d ] ) . this module comprises tools for fluid navigation in the large spectral matrix . several resolution of the same 2d spectrum are stored in the hierarchical multiresolution hdf5 file structure . this allows rapid zooming and the extration of ms subspectra profiles with the highest possible precision without requiring excessive amount of memory despite the huge size of the data matrix . using spike it is easy to devise the analysis of a spectroscopic data - set , in few lines of python using the pipe syntax . as a first example , figure [ orbi_fid ] presents the standard processing of an orbitrap ft - ms data - set , and the few commands that were issued to produce the spectrum . in the nmr spectroscopy studies of protein ligand interactions , a common procedure consists in monitoring the displacement of spectral lines upon some variation of an experimental parameter . in such an example , it is important to process the spectra in the same condition , to monitor automatically parameters such peak position or width , and finally to report in a graphical manner the evolution of the system . figure [ fig : hsqc ] presents a set of @xmath3n - hsqc 2d spectra of the interaction between the third sh3 domain of vinexin@xmath4 and varying concentration of a polyproline peptide from the n - terminal domain of the rar@xmath5@xcite . the data - sets here are processed and peak - picked automatically . in the recent period , the 2d - fticr - ms method@xcite , has been shown to be a valuable analytical technique for proteomics studies@xcite . however , these analyses require the acquisition of very large data - sets , and set high constraint on the analysis software . spike has been design to handle this kind of large data - sets , and is capable of processing and analyzing 2d - fticr - ms spectra . in contrast with the previous examples , the processing is too large to be performed interactively , and specific modules have been developed for the processing and the display of these spectra . figure [ visu2d ] shows the user interface of the program which permits to interactively display 2d - fticr - msand extract 1d sub - spectra . the tool provides rapid zooming and panning , easy extraction of parents and fragments spectra , but also of diagonal spectra ( for instance for neutral loss analysis@xcite ) . we have presented spike , a python package meant for processing and visualizing data - sets for fourier spectroscopies with a capacity to easily process large data - sets . this software aims at giving an easy access to processing in the domain of ft techniques . the program is an ongoing development , and while only nmr and ft mass spectrometry are currently available , the code is meant to be extensible to any other ft techniques . the program spike is entirely written in python , and relies on the standard scientific python libraries . it is released in open - source under the cecill 2.1 license , and available for download at https://bitbucket.org/delsuc/spike . the authors thank c.khler and b.kieffer for the set of nmr hsqc data - sets and j.chamot-rooke for the orbitrap data - set ; the cnrs , for the dfi instrumention aux limites and the mastodons-2013 grant , the agence nationale pour la recherche ( grant ft - icr2d ( 2010 ) and grant one_shot_ft - icr_ms_2d ( 2014 ) ) for funding . the authors acknowledge the high performance computing center of the university of strasbourg for scientific support and access to computing resources . we also thank all the many colleagues , interns , students , and program users that helped in the development by using the program , and eventually correcting bugs or adding features . | we present spike ( spectrometry processing innovative kernel ) , an open - source python package dedicated to fourier spectroscopies . it provides basic functionalities such as apodisation , a complete set of fourier transforms , phasing ( for nmr ) , peak - picking , baseline correction and also tools such as linear prediction . beside its versatility , the most prominent novelty of this package is to incorporate new tools for big data processing . this is exemplified by its ability to handle the processing and visualization of very large data - sets , with multiprocessor capabilities and a low memory footprint . the software contains also all the tools necessary for the specific fast processing and visualization of 2d - fticr - ms data - sets . |
0707.4470 | the yee scheme ( also known as finite - difference time - domain , or fdtd ) was introduced in @xcite and remains one of the most successful numerical methods used in the field of computational electromagnetics , particularly in the area of microwave problems . although it is not a `` high - order '' method , it is still preferred for many applications because it preserves important structural features of maxwell s equations that other methods fail to capture . among these distinguishing attributes are that the gauss constraint @xmath1 is exactly conserved in a discrete sense , and electrostatic solutions of the form @xmath2 indeed remain stationary in time ( see * ? ? ? * ) . in this paper , we show that these desirable properties are direct consequences of the variational and discrete differential structure of the yee scheme , which mirrors the geometry of maxwell s equations . moreover , we will show how to construct other variational methods that , as a result , share these same numerical properties , while at the same time applying to more general domains . geometric numerical integrators have been used primarily for the simulation of classical mechanical systems , where features such as symplecticity , conservation of momentum , and conservation of energy are essential . ( for a survey of various methods and applications , see @xcite . ) among these , _ variational integrators _ are developed by discretizing the lagrangian variational principle of a system , and then requiring that numerical trajectories satisfy a discrete version of hamilton s stationary - action principle . these methods are automatically symplectic , and they exactly preserve discrete momenta associated to symmetries of the lagrangian : for instance , systems with translational invariance will conserve a discrete linear momentum , those with rotational invariance will conserve a discrete angular momentum , etc . in addition , variational integrators can be seen to display good long - time energy behavior , without artificial numerical damping ( see * ? ? ? * for a comprehensive overview of key results ) . this variational approach was extended to discretizing general multisymplectic field theories , with an application to nonlinear wave equations , in @xcite and @xcite , which developed the multisymplectic approach for continuum mechanics . building on this work , @xcite introduced _ asynchronous variational integrators _ ( avis ) , with which it becomes possible to choose a different time step size for each element of the spatial mesh , while still preserving the same variational and geometric structure as uniform - time - stepping schemes . these methods were implemented and shown to be not only practical , but in many cases superior to existing methods for problems such as nonlinear elastodynamics . some further developments are given in @xcite . while there have been attempts to apply the existing avi theory to computational electromagnetics , these efforts encountered a fundamental obstacle . the key symmetry of maxwell s equations is not rotational or translational symmetry , as in mechanics , but a _ differential gauge symmetry_. without taking additional care to preserve this gauge structure , even variational integrators can not be expected to capture the geometry of maxwell s equations . as will be explained , we overcome this obstacle by combining variational methods with discrete differential forms and operators . this differential / gauge structure also turns out to be important for the numerical performance of the method , and is one of the hallmarks of the yee scheme . as motivation , consider the basic relation @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the magnetic flux and @xmath5 is the magnetic vector potential . because of the vector calculus identities @xmath6 and @xmath7 , this equation has two immediate and important consequences . first , @xmath4 is automatically divergence - free . second , any transformation @xmath8 has no effect on @xmath4 ; this describes a gauge symmetry , for which the associated conserved momentum is @xmath9 ( which must be zero by gauss law ) . a similar argument also explains the invariance of electrostatic solutions , since @xmath10 is curl - free and invariant under constant shifts in the scalar potential @xmath11 . therefore , a proper variational integrator for electromagnetism should also preserve a discrete analog of these differential identities . this can be done by viewing the objects of electromagnetism not as vector fields , but as _ differential forms _ in @xmath0-dimensional spacetime , as is typically done in the literature on classical field theory . using a discrete exterior calculus ( called dec ) as the framework to discretize these differential forms , we find that the resulting variational integrators automatically respect discrete differential identities such as @xmath12 ( which encapsulates the previous div - curl - grad relations ) and stokes theorem . consequently , they also respect the gauge symmetry of maxwell s equations , and therefore preserve the associated discrete momentum . the yee scheme , as we will show , is a method of precisely this type , which gives a new explanation for many of its previously observed _ a posteriori _ numerical qualities . for instance , one of its notable features is that the electric field @xmath13 and magnetic field @xmath14 do not live at the same discrete space or time locations , but at separate nodes on a staggered lattice . the reason why this particular setup leads to improved numerics is not obvious : if we view @xmath13 and @xmath14 simply as vector fields in @xmath15-space the exact same type of mathematical object why should nt they live at the same points ? indeed , many finite element method ( fem ) approaches do exactly this , resulting in a `` nodal '' discretization . however , from the perspective of differential forms in spacetime , it becomes clear that the staggered - grid approach is more faithful to the structure of maxwell s equations : as we will see , @xmath13 and @xmath14 come from objects that are dual to one another ( the spacetime forms @xmath16 and @xmath17 ) , and hence they naturally live on two staggered , dual meshes . the argument for this approach is not merely a matter of theoretical interest : the geometry of maxwell s equations has important practical implications for numerical performance . for instance , the vector - field - based discretization , used in nodal fem , results in spurious @xmath15-d artifacts due to its failure to respect the underlying geometric structure . the yee scheme , on the other hand , produces resonance spectra in agreement with theory , without spurious modes ( see * ? ? ? * ) . furthermore , it has been shown in @xcite that staggered - grid methods can be used to develop fast numerical methods for electromagnetism , even for problems in heterogeneous media with highly discontinuous material parameters such as conductivity and permeability . by developing a structure - preserving , geometric discretization of maxwell s equations , not only can we better understand the yee scheme and its characteristic advantages , but we can also construct more general methods that share its desirable properties . this family of methods includes the `` yee - like '' scheme of @xcite , which presented the first extension of yee s scheme to unstructured grids ( e.g. , simplicial meshes rather than rectangular lattices ) . general methods like these are highly desirable : rectangular meshes are not always practical or appropriate to use in applications where domains with curved and oblique boundaries are needed ( see , for instance * ? ? ? * ) . by allowing general discretizations while still preserving geometry , one can combine the best attributes of the fem and yee schemes . using dec as a structure - preserving , geometric framework for general discrete meshes , we have obtained the following results : 1 . the yee scheme is actually a variational integrator : that is , it can be obtained by applying hamilton s principle of stationary action to a discrete lagrangian . 2 . consequently , the yee scheme is _ multisymplectic _ and _ preserves discrete momentum maps _ ( i.e. , conserved quantities analogous to the continuous case of electromagnetism ) . in particular , the gauss constraint is understood as a discrete momentum map of this integrator , while the preservation of electrostatic potential solutions corresponds to the identity @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the discrete exterior derivative operator . we also create a foundation for more general schemes , allowing _ arbitrary discretizations of spacetime _ , not just uniform time steps on a spatial mesh . one such scheme , introduced here , is a new asynchronous variational integrator ( avi ) for maxwell s equations , where each spatial element is assigned its own time step size and evolves `` asynchronously '' with its neighbors . this means that one can choose to take small steps where greater refinement is needed , while still using larger steps for other elements . since refining one part of the mesh does not restrict the time steps taken elsewhere , an avi can be computationally efficient and numerically stable with fewer total iterations . in addition to the avi scheme , we briefly sketch how completely covariant spacetime integrators for electromagnetism can be implemented , without even requiring a 3 + 1 split into space and time components . we will begin by reviewing maxwell s equations : first developing the differential forms expression from a lagrangian variational principle , and next showing how this is equivalent to the familiar vector calculus formulation . we will then motivate the use of dec for computational electromagnetics , explaining how electromagnetic quantities can be modeled using discrete differential forms and operators on a spacetime mesh . these dec tools will then be used to set up the discrete maxwell s equations , and to show that the resulting numerical algorithm yields the yee and bossavit kettunen schemes as special cases , as well as a new avi method . finally , we will demonstrate that the discrete maxwell s equations can also be derived from a discrete variational principle , and will explore its other discrete geometric properties , including multisymplecticity and momentum map preservation . this section quickly reviews the differential forms approach to electromagnetism , in preparation for the associated discrete formulation given in the next section . for more details , the reader can refer to @xcite and @xcite . maxwell s equations , without free sources of charge or current , are traditionally expressed in terms of four vector fields in @xmath15-space : the electric field @xmath13 , magnetic field @xmath14 , electric flux density @xmath20 , and magnetic flux density @xmath4 . to translate these into the language of differential forms , we begin by replacing the electric field with a @xmath21-form @xmath22 and the magnetic flux density by a @xmath23-form @xmath24 . these have the coordinate expressions @xmath25 where @xmath26 and @xmath27 . the motivation for choosing @xmath22 as a @xmath21-form and @xmath24 as a @xmath23-form comes from the integral formulation of faraday s law , @xmath28 where @xmath13 is integrated over curves and @xmath4 is integrated over surfaces . similarly , ampre s law , @xmath29 integrates @xmath14 over curves and @xmath20 over surfaces , so we can likewise introduce a @xmath21-form @xmath30 and a @xmath23-form @xmath31 . now , @xmath13 and @xmath4 are related to @xmath20 and @xmath14 through the usual constitutive relations @xmath32 as shown in @xcite , we can view @xmath33 and @xmath34 as corresponding to hodge operators @xmath35 and @xmath36 , which map the @xmath21-form `` fields '' to @xmath23-form `` fluxes '' in space . therefore , this is compatible with viewing @xmath22 and @xmath30 as @xmath21-forms , and @xmath31 and @xmath24 as @xmath23-forms . note that in a vacuum , with @xmath37 and @xmath38 constant , one can simply express the equations in terms of @xmath13 and @xmath4 , choosing appropriate geometrized units such that @xmath39 , and hence ignoring the distinction between @xmath13 and @xmath20 and between @xmath4 and @xmath14 . this is typically the most familiar form of maxwell s equations , and the one that most students of electromagnetism first encounter . in this presentation , we will restrict ourselves to the vacuum case with geometrized units ; for geometric clarity , however , we will always distinguish between the @xmath21-forms @xmath22 and @xmath30 and the @xmath23-forms @xmath31 and @xmath24 . finally , we can incorporate free sources of charge and current by introducing the _ charge density @xmath15-form _ @xmath40 , as well as the _ current density @xmath23-form _ @xmath41 . these are required to satisfy the continuity of charge condition @xmath42 , which can be understood as a conservation law ( in the finite volume sense ) . in lorentzian spacetime , we can now combine @xmath22 and @xmath24 into a single object , the faraday @xmath23-form @xmath43 there is a theoretical advantage to combining the electric field and magnetic flux into a single spacetime object : this way , electromagnetic phenomena can be described in a relativistically covariant way , without favoring a particular split of spacetime into space and time components . in fact , we can turn the previous construction around : take @xmath16 to be the fundamental object , with @xmath22 and @xmath24 only emerging when we choose a particular coordinate frame . taking the hodge star of @xmath16 , we also get a dual @xmath23-form @xmath44 called the maxwell @xmath23-form . the equation @xmath17 describes the dual relationship between @xmath22 and @xmath24 on one hand , and @xmath31 and @xmath30 on the other , that is expressed in the constitutive relations . likewise , the charge density @xmath45 and current density @xmath46 can be combined into a single spacetime object , the source @xmath15-form @xmath47 having defined @xmath48 in this way , the continuity of charge condition simply requires that @xmath48 be closed , i.e. , @xmath49 . let @xmath50 be the electromagnetic potential @xmath21-form , satisfying @xmath51 , over the spacetime manifold @xmath52 . then define the @xmath0-form lagrangian density @xmath53 and its associated action functional @xmath54 = \int _ x \mathcal{l}.\ ] ] now , take a variation @xmath55 of @xmath50 , where @xmath55 vanishes on the boundary @xmath56 . then the variation of the action functional along @xmath55 is @xmath57 \cdot \alpha & = \left . \frac{\mathrm{d } } { \mathrm{d } \epsilon } \right\rvert _ { \epsilon = 0 } s[a + \epsilon \alpha ] \\ & = \int _ x \left ( - \mathrm{d } \alpha \wedge * \mathrm{d } a + \alpha \wedge \mathcal{j } \right ) \\ & = \int _ x \alpha \wedge \left ( - \mathrm{d } { * \mathrm{d}a } + \mathcal{j } \right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where in this last equality we have integrated by parts , using the fact that @xmath55 vanishes on the boundary . hamilton s principle of stationary action requires this variation to be equal to zero for arbitrary @xmath55 , thus implying the electromagnetic euler lagrange equation , @xmath58 since @xmath59 , then clearly is equivalent to @xmath60 . furthermore , since @xmath61 , it follows that @xmath62 . hence , maxwell s equations with respect to the maxwell and faraday @xmath23-forms can be written as @xmath63 suppose now we choose the standard coordinate system @xmath64 on minkowski space @xmath65 , and define @xmath22 and @xmath24 through the relation @xmath66 . then a straightforward calculation shows that is equivalent to @xmath67 likewise , if @xmath68 , then is equivalent to @xmath69 hence this lagrangian , differential forms approach to maxwell s equations is _ strictly equivalent _ to the more classical vector calculus formulation in smooth spacetime . however , in discrete spacetime , we will see that the differential forms version is _ not _ equivalent to an arbitrary vector field discretization , but rather implies a particular choice of discrete objects . we can also derive maxwell s equations by using a mixed variational principle , similar to the hamilton pontryagin principle introduced by @xcite for classical lagrangian mechanics . to do this , we treat @xmath50 and @xmath16 as separate fields , while @xmath70 acts as a lagrange multiplier , weakly enforcing the constraint @xmath71 . define the extended action to be @xmath72 = \int _ x \left [ - \frac{1}{2 } f \wedge * f + a \wedge \mathcal{j } + \left ( f - \mathrm{d } a \right ) \wedge g \right ] .\ ] ] then , taking the variation of the action along some @xmath73 ( vanishing on @xmath56 ) , we have @xmath74 \cdot \left ( \alpha , \phi , \gamma \right ) & = \int _ x \left [ - \phi \wedge * f + \alpha \wedge \mathcal{j } + \left ( \phi - \mathrm{d } \alpha \right ) \wedge g + \left ( f - \mathrm{d } a \right ) \wedge \gamma \right ] \\ & = \int _ x \left [ \alpha \wedge \left ( \mathcal{j } - \mathrm{d } g \right ) + \phi \wedge \left ( g - * f \right ) + \left ( f - \mathrm{d } a \right ) \wedge \gamma \right ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , setting this equal to zero , we get the equations @xmath75 this is precisely equivalent to maxwell s equations , as derived above . however , this approach provides some additional insight into the geometric structure of electromagnetics : the gauge condition @xmath51 and constitutive relations @xmath17 are _ explicitly included in the equations of motion _ , as a direct result of the variational principle . when solving an initial value problem , it is not necessary to use all of maxwell s equations to evolve the system forward in time . in fact , the curl equations and automatically conserve the quantities @xmath76 and @xmath77 . therefore , the divergence equations and can be viewed simply as constraints on initial conditions , while the curl equations completely describe the time evolution of the system . there are a number of ways to see why we can justify eliminating the divergence equations . a straightforward way is to take the divergence of equations and . since @xmath78 , we are left with @xmath79 therefore , if the divergence constraints are satisfied at the initial time , then they are satisfied for all time , since the divergence terms are constant . another approach is to notice that maxwell s equations depend only on the exterior derivative @xmath80 of the electromagnetic potential , and not on the value of @xmath50 itself . therefore , the system has a _ gauge symmetry _ : any gauge transformation @xmath81 leaves @xmath80 , and hence maxwell s equations , unchanged . choosing a time coordinate , we can then partially fix the gauge so that the electric scalar potential @xmath82 ( the so - called weyl gauge or temporal gauge ) , and so @xmath50 has only spatial components . in fact , these three remaining components correspond to those of the usual vector potential @xmath5 . the reduced euler lagrange equations in this gauge consist only of , while the remaining gauge symmetry @xmath83 yields a momentum map that automatically preserves @xmath84 in time . equations and are automatically preserved by the identity @xmath85 ; they are not actually part of the euler lagrange equations . a more detailed exposition of these calculations will be given in . in this section , we give a quick review of the fundamental objects and operations of discrete exterior calculus ( dec ) , a structure - preserving calculus of discrete differential forms . by construction , dec automatically preserves a number of important geometric structures , and hence it provides a fully discrete analog of the tools used in the previous section to express the differential forms version of maxwell s equations . in subsequent sections , we will use this framework to formulate maxwell s equations discretely , emulating the continuous version . modern computational electromagnetism started in the 1960s , when the finite element method ( fem ) , based on _ nodal basis functions _ , was used successfully to discretize the differential equations governing @xmath23-d static problems formulated in terms of a scalar potential . unfortunately , the initial success of the fem approach appeared unable to carry over to @xmath15-d problems without spurious numerical artifacts . with the introduction of _ edge elements _ in @xcite came the realization that a better discretization of the geometric structure of maxwell s electromagnetic theory was key to overcoming this obstacle ( see @xcite for more historical details ) . mathematical tools developed by weyl and whitney in the 1950s , in the context of algebraic topology , turned out to provide the necessary foundations on which robust numerical techniques for electromagnetism can be built , as detailed in @xcite . in this section , we show how to define differential forms and operators on a discrete mesh , in preparation to use this framework for computational modeling of classical fields . by construction , the calculus of discrete differential forms automatically preserves a number of important geometric structures , including stokes theorem , integration by parts ( with a proper treatment of boundaries ) , the de rham complex , poincar duality , poincar s lemma , and hodge theory . therefore , this provides a suitable foundation for the coordinate - free discretization of geometric field theories . in subsequent chapters , we will also use these discrete differential forms as the space of fields on which we will define discrete lagrangian variational principles . the particular `` flavor '' of discrete differential forms and operators we will be using is known as _ discrete exterior calculus _ , or _ dec _ for short ; see @xcite . ( for related efforts in this direction , see also @xcite and @xcite . ) guided by cartan s exterior calculus of differential forms on smooth manifolds , dec is a discrete calculus developed , _ ab initio _ , on discrete manifolds , so as to maintain the covariant nature of the quantities involved . this computational tool is based on the notion of discrete chains and cochains , used as basic building blocks for compatible discretizations of important geometric structures such as the de rham complex @xcite . the chain and cochain representations are not only attractive from a computational perspective due to their conceptual simplicity and elegance ; as we will see , they also originate from a theoretical framework defined by @xcite , who introduced the whitney and de rham maps that establish an isomorphism between simplicial cochains and lipschitz differential forms . dec is concerned with problems in which the smooth @xmath86-dimensional manifold @xmath52 is replaced by a discrete mesh precisely , by a cell complex that is manifold , admits a metric , and is orientable . the simplest example of such a mesh is a finite simplicial complex , such as a triangulation of a @xmath23-dimensional surface . we will generally denote the complex by @xmath87 , and a cell in the complex by @xmath88 . given a mesh @xmath87 , one can construct a _ dual mesh _ @xmath89 , where each @xmath90-cell @xmath91 corresponds to a dual @xmath92-cell @xmath93 . ( @xmath89 is `` dual '' to @xmath94 in the sense of a graph dual . ) one way to do this is as follows : place a dual vertex at the circumcenter of each @xmath86-simplex , then connect two dual vertices by an edge wherever the corresponding @xmath86-simplices share an @xmath95-simplex , and so on . this is called the _ circumcentric dual _ , and it has the important property that primal and dual cells are automatically orthogonal to one another , which is advantageous when defining an inner product ( as we will see later in this section ) . for example , the circumcentric dual of a delaunay triangulation , with the euclidean metric , is its corresponding voronoi diagram ( see ) . for more on the dual relationship between delaunay triangulations and voronoi diagrams , a standard reference is @xcite . a similar construction of the circumcenter can be carried out for higher - dimensional euclidean simplicial complexes , as well as for simplicial meshes in minkowski space . note that , in both the euclidean and lorentzian cases , the circumcenter may actually lie _ outside _ the simplex if it has a very bad aspect ratio , underscoring the importance of mesh quality for good numerical results . there are alternative ways to define the dual mesh for example , placing dual vertices at the barycenter rather than the circumcenter but we will use the circumcentric dual unless otherwise noted . note that a refined definition of the dual mesh , where dual cells at the boundary are restricted to @xmath87 , will be discussed in to allow proper enforcement of boundary conditions in computational electromagnetics . -d simplicial mesh ( left ) , we can construct its circumcentric dual mesh , called the voronoi diagram of the primal mesh ( right ) . in bold , we show one particular primal edge @xmath96 ( left ) and its corresponding dual edge @xmath97 ( right ) ; the convex hull of these cells @xmath98 is shaded dark grey . ] the fundamental objects of dec are discrete differential forms . a discrete @xmath90-form @xmath99 assigns a real number to each oriented @xmath90-dimensional cell @xmath100 in the mesh @xmath87 . ( the superscripts @xmath90 are not actually required by the notation , but they are often useful as reminders of what order of form or cell we are dealing with . ) this value is denoted by @xmath101 , and can be thought of as the value of @xmath102 `` integrated over '' the element @xmath100 , i.e. , @xmath103 for example , @xmath104-forms assign values to vertices , @xmath21-forms assign values to edges , etc . we can extend this to integrate over discrete paths by linearity : simply add the form s values on each cell in the path , taking care to flip the sign if the path is oriented opposite the cell . formally , these `` paths '' of @xmath90-dimensional elements are called _ chains _ , and discrete differential forms are _ cochains _ , where @xmath105 is the pairing between cochains and chains . differential forms can be defined either on the mesh @xmath87 or on its dual @xmath89 . we will refer to these as _ primal forms _ and _ dual forms _ respectively . note that there is a natural correspondence between primal @xmath90-forms and dual @xmath92-forms , since each primal @xmath90-cell has a dual @xmath92-cell . this is an important property that will be used below to define the discrete hodge star operator . the discrete exterior derivative @xmath19 is constructed to satisfy stokes theorem , which in the continuous sense is written @xmath106 therefore , if @xmath55 is a discrete differential @xmath90-form , then the @xmath107-form @xmath108 is defined on any @xmath109-chain @xmath91 by @xmath110 where @xmath111 is the @xmath112-chain boundary of @xmath113 . for this reason , @xmath19 is often called the _ coboundary _ operator in cohomology theory . the discrete hodge star transforms @xmath90-forms on the primal mesh into @xmath92-forms on the dual mesh , and vice - versa . in our setup , we will use the so - called diagonal ( or mass - lumped ) approximation of the hodge star @xcite because of its simplicity , but note that higher - order accurate versions can be substituted . given a discrete form @xmath55 , its _ hodge star _ @xmath114 is defined by the relation @xmath115 where @xmath116 and @xmath117 are the volumes of these elements , and @xmath118 is the causality operator , which equals @xmath119 when @xmath113 is spacelike and @xmath120 otherwise . ( for more information on alternative discrete hodge operators , the reader may refer to , e.g. , @xcite . ) define the _ @xmath121 inner product _ @xmath122 between two primal @xmath90-forms to be @xmath123 where the sum is taken over all @xmath90-dimensional elements @xmath91 , and @xmath124 is the @xmath86-dimensional convex hull of @xmath125 ( see ) . the final equality holds as a result of using the circumcentric dual , since @xmath91 and @xmath126 are orthogonal to one another , and hence @xmath127 . ( indeed , this is one of the advantages of using the circumcentric dual , since one only needs to store volume information about the primal and dual cells themselves , and not about these primal - dual convex hulls . ) this inner product can be expressed in terms of @xmath128 , as in the continuous case , for a particular choice of the discrete primal - dual wedge product ; see @xcite . note that since we have already defined a discrete version of the operators @xmath129 and @xmath130 , we immediately have a discrete codifferential @xmath131 , with the same formal expression as given previously . see for a visual diagram of primal and dual discrete forms , along with the corresponding operators @xmath132 , for the case where @xmath87 is a @xmath15-d tetrahedral mesh . -d simplicial mesh . in the top row , we see how a discrete @xmath90-form lives on @xmath90-cells of the primal mesh , for @xmath133 ; the bottom row shows the location of the corresponding dual @xmath92-forms on the dual mesh . the differential operators @xmath129 and @xmath131 map `` horizontally '' between @xmath90 and @xmath134 forms , while the hodge star @xmath130 and its inverse @xmath135 map `` vertically '' between primal and dual forms . ] dec can be implemented simply and efficiently using linear algebra . a @xmath90-form @xmath55 can be stored as a vector , where its entries are the values of @xmath55 on each @xmath90-cell of the mesh . that is , given a list of @xmath90-cells @xmath136 , the entries of the vector are @xmath137 . the exterior derivative @xmath129 , taking @xmath90-forms to @xmath134-forms , is then represented as a matrix : in fact , it is precisely the _ incidence matrix _ between @xmath90-cells and @xmath134-cells in the mesh , with sparse entries @xmath138 . the hodge star taking primal @xmath90-forms to dual @xmath92-forms becomes a square matrix , and in the case of the diagonal hodge star , it is the diagonal matrix with entries @xmath139 . the discrete inner product is then simply the hodge star matrix taken as a quadratic form . because of this straightforward isomorphism between dec and linear algebra , problems posed in the language of dec can take advantage of existing numerical linear algebra codes . for more details on programming and implementation , refer to @xcite . particular care is required to properly enforce initial and boundary conditions on the discrete spacetime boundary @xmath140 . for example , in electromagnetism , we may wish to set initial conditions for @xmath22 and @xmath24 at time @xmath141 but while @xmath24 is defined on @xmath142 at @xmath141 , @xmath22 is not . in fact , as we will see , @xmath22 lives on edges that are extruded between the time slices @xmath143 and @xmath144 , so unless we modify our definitions , we can only initialize @xmath22 at the half - step @xmath145 . ( this half - step issue also arises with the standard yee scheme . ) there are some applications where it may be acceptable to initialize @xmath22 and @xmath24 at separate times ( for example , when the fields are initialized randomly and integrated for a long time to compute a resonance spectrum ) , but we wish to be able to handle the more general case . although our previous exposition of dec thus far applies anywhere away from a boundary , notions as simple as `` dual cell '' need to be defined carefully on or near @xmath140 . for a primal mesh @xmath87 , the dual mesh @xmath146 is defined as _ the voronoi dual of @xmath87 restricted to @xmath87_. this truncates the portion of the dual cells extending outside of @xmath147 ; compare with the earlier . this new definition results in the addition of a dual vertex at the circumcenter of each boundary @xmath95-simplex , in addition to the interior @xmath86-simplices as previously defined . to complete the dual mesh @xmath146 , we add a dual edge between adjacent dual vertices on the boundary , as well as between dual boundary vertices and their neighboring interior dual vertices , and proceed similarly with higher - dimensional dual cells . for intuition , one can imagine the @xmath95-dimensional boundary to be a vanishingly thin @xmath86-dimensional shell . that is , each boundary @xmath148-simplex can be thought of as a prismal @xmath90-cell that has been `` squashed flat '' along the boundary normal direction . this process is quite similar to the use of `` ghost cells '' at the boundary , as is commonly done for finite volume methods ( see * ? ? ? note that these additional dual cells provide the boundary @xmath149 with its own dual mesh @xmath150 . in fact , the boundary of the dual is now equal to the dual of the boundary , i.e. , @xmath151 . -d example , the dual mesh is properly defined near the boundary by adding dual vertices on the boundary edges . the restricted voronoi cells of the primal boundary vertices ( shaded at right ) thus have boundaries containing both dual edges ( dashed lines ) _ and _ primal boundary half - edges . ] returning to the example of initial conditions on @xmath22 and @xmath24 , we recall that @xmath22 is defined on extruded faces normal to the time slice @xmath143 . therefore , thanks to the proper restriction of the voronoi diagram to the domain , we can now define @xmath22 on _ edges _ in @xmath152 at time @xmath143 , where these edges can be understood as vanishingly thin faces ( i.e. , extruded between some @xmath153 and @xmath143 for @xmath154 ) . notice finally that with this construction of @xmath146 , there is a dual relationship between dirichlet conditions on the dual mesh and neumann conditions on the primal mesh , e.g. , between primal fields and dual fluxes , as expected . with the dual mesh properly defined , dual forms can now be defined on the boundary . therefore , the discrete duality between @xmath155 and @xmath156 can be generalized to include nonvanishing boundary terms . if @xmath55 is a primal @xmath148-form and @xmath157 is a primal @xmath90-form , then @xmath158 in the boundary integral , @xmath55 is still a primal @xmath148-form on @xmath159 , while @xmath160 is an @xmath92-form taken on the boundary dual @xmath161 . formula is readily proved using the familiar method of discrete `` summation by parts , '' and thus agrees with the integration by parts formula for smooth differential forms . in this section , we explain how to obtain numerical algorithms for solving maxwell s equations with dec . to do so , we will proceed in the following order . first , we will find a sensible way to define the discrete forms @xmath16 , @xmath70 , and @xmath48 on a spacetime mesh . next , we will use the dec version of the operators @xmath19 and @xmath162 to obtain the discrete maxwell s equations . while we havent yet shown that these equations are variational in the discrete sense , we will show later in that the lagrangian derivation of the smooth maxwell s equations also holds with the dec operators , in precisely the same way . finally , we will discuss how these equations can be used to define a numerical method for computational electromagnetics . in particular , for a rectangular grid , we will show that our setup results in the traditional yee scheme . for a general triangulation of space with equal time steps , the resulting scheme will be bossavit and kettunen s scheme . we will then develop an avi method , where each spatial element can be assigned a different time step , and the time integration of maxwell s equations can be performed on the elements asynchronously . finally , we will comment on the equations for fully generalized spacetime meshes , e.g. , an arbitrary meshing of @xmath163 by @xmath0-simplices . note that the idea of discretizing maxwell s equations using spacetime cochains was mentioned in , e.g. , @xcite , as well as in a paper by @xcite taking the more abstract perspective of higher - level `` @xmath164-form '' versions of electromagnetism and category theory . suppose that we have a rectangular grid in @xmath165 , oriented along the axes @xmath64 . to simplify this exposition ( although it is not necessary ) , let us also suppose that the grid has uniform space and time steps @xmath166 . note that the dec setup applies directly to a non - simplicial rectangular mesh , since an @xmath86-rectangle does in fact have a circumcenter . since @xmath16 is a @xmath23-form , its values should live on @xmath23-faces in this grid . following the continuous expression of @xmath16 @xmath167 and due to the tensor product nature of the regular grid , the exact assignment of each @xmath23-face becomes simple : _ the six components of @xmath16 correspond precisely to the six types of @xmath23-faces in a @xmath0-d rectangular grid_. simply assign the values @xmath168 to faces parallel to the @xmath169-plane , @xmath170 to faces parallel to the @xmath171-plane , and @xmath172 to faces parallel to the @xmath173-plane . likewise , assign @xmath174 to faces parallel to the @xmath175-plane , @xmath176 to faces parallel to the @xmath177-plane , and @xmath178 to faces parallel to the @xmath179-plane . this is pictured in . are stored on the primal @xmath23-faces of a @xmath0-d rectangular grid . shown here are the three mixed space / time @xmath15-cells , and the one purely spatial @xmath15-cell ( lower right ) . ] let us look at these values on the faces of a typical @xmath0-rectangle @xmath180 \times \left [ y _ l , y _ { l + 1 } \right ] \times \left [ z _ m , z _ { m + 1 } \right ] \times \left [ t _ n , t _ { n + 1 } \right ] $ ] . to simplify the notation , we can index each value of @xmath16 by the midpoint of the @xmath23-face on which it lives : for example , @xmath181 is stored on the face @xmath182 \times \left\{y _ l\right\ } \times \left\{z _ m\right\ } \times \left [ t _ n , t _ { n + 1 } \right ] $ ] , parallel to the @xmath183-plane . hence , the following values are assigned to the corresponding faces : @xmath184 @xmath185 we see that a `` staggered grid '' arises from the fact that @xmath22 and @xmath24 naturally live on @xmath23-faces , not at vertices or @xmath0-cells . the discrete equations of motion are , as in the continuous case , @xmath186 where now these equations are interpreted in the sense of dec . let us first look at the dec interpretation of @xmath187 . since @xmath188 is a discrete @xmath15-form , it takes values on the @xmath15-faces of each @xmath0-rectangle . its values are as follows : @xmath189 @xmath190 @xmath191 @xmath192 setting each of these equal to zero , we arrive at the following four equations : @xmath193 @xmath194 @xmath195 and @xmath196 these equations are the discrete version of the equations @xmath197 moreover , since @xmath22 and @xmath24 are differential forms , this can also be seen as a discretization of the _ integral version _ of maxwell s equations as well ! because dec satisfies a discrete stokes theorem , this automatically preserves the equivalence between the differential and integral formulations of electromagnetism . doing the same with the equation @xmath60 , evaluating on dual @xmath15-faces this time , we arrive at four more equations : @xmath198 @xmath199 @xmath200 and @xmath201 this results from storing @xmath202 on the dual grid , as shown in . this set of equations is the discrete version of @xmath203 are stored on dual @xmath23-faces in a rectangular grid . shown here are a mixed space / time dual @xmath15-cell ( left ) , corresponding to a spacelike primal edge ; and a purely spatial dual @xmath15-cell ( right ) , corresponding to a timelike primal edge . there are also two other mixed space / time cells , as in , that are not shown here . ] after eliminating the redundant divergence equations and ( see for details ) and making the substitutions @xmath204 , @xmath205 , the remaining equations are precisely the yee scheme , as formulated in @xcite . we now consider the case of an unstructured grid in space , but with uniform steps in time as advocated in , e.g. , @xcite . suppose that , instead of a rectangular grid for both space and time , we have an arbitrary space discretization on which we would like to take uniform time steps . ( for example , we may be given a tetrahedral mesh of the spatial domain . ) this mesh contains two distinct types of @xmath23-faces . first , there are triangular faces that live entirely in the space mesh at a single position in time . every edge of such a face is spacelike that is , it has positive length so the causality operator defined in takes the value @xmath206 . second , there are rectangular faces that live between time steps . these faces consist of a single spacelike edge extruded by one time step . because they have one timelike edge , these faces satisfy @xmath207 . again , the circumcentric - dual dec framework applies directly to this type of mesh , since the prismal extrusion of a @xmath15-simplex still has a circumcenter . again , we can characterize the discrete values of @xmath16 by looking at the continuous expression @xmath208 therefore , let us assign @xmath24 to the purely spacelike faces and @xmath209 to the mixed space / time faces . looking at @xmath17 shows that mixed dual faces should store @xmath210 and spacelike dual faces should store @xmath31 ; see . is stored on primal @xmath23-faces ( left ) , while @xmath17 is stored on dual @xmath23-faces ( right ) . shown here are the values on mixed space / time @xmath15-cells . ( the purely spatial @xmath15-cells , which correspond to the divergence equations and do not contribute to the equations of motion , are not shown . ) ] as in @xcite , we can store the values of each differential form over every spatial element in an array , using the method described in . this leads to the arrays @xmath211 and @xmath212 at whole time steps @xmath86 , and @xmath213 and @xmath214 at half time steps . let @xmath215 denote the edges - to - faces incidence matrix for the spatial domain . that is , @xmath216 is the matrix corresponding to the discrete exterior derivative , taken only in space , from primal @xmath21-forms to primal @xmath23-forms . similarly , the transpose @xmath217 corresponds to the exterior derivative from spatial dual @xmath21-forms to dual @xmath23-forms . then the equation @xmath218 , evaluated on all prismal @xmath15-faces becomes @xmath219 likewise , the equation @xmath60 , evaluated on all space / time @xmath15-faces in the dual mesh , becomes @xmath220 we can also evaluate @xmath218 and @xmath221 on spacelike @xmath15-faces , e.g , tetrahedra ; these simply yield the discrete versions of the divergence conditions for @xmath24 and @xmath31 , which can be eliminated . therefore , the dec scheme for such a mesh is equivalent to bossavit and kettunen s yee - like scheme ; additionally , when the spatial mesh is taken to be rectangular , this integrator reduces to the standard yee scheme . however , we now have solid foundations to extend this integrator to handle asynchronous updates for improved efficiency . instead of picking the same time step size for every element of the spatial mesh , as in the previous two sections , it is often more efficient to assign each element its own , optimized time step , as done in @xcite for problems in elastodynamics . in this case , rather than the entire mesh evolving forward in time simultaneously , individual elements advance one - by - one , asynchronously hence the name _ asynchronous variational integrator _ ( avi ) . as we will prove in , this asynchronous update process will maintain the variational nature of the integration scheme . here , we again allow the spatial mesh to be unstructured . after choosing a primal space mesh , assign each spatial @xmath23-face ( e.g. , triangle ) @xmath91 its own discrete time set @xmath222 for example , one might assign each face a fixed time step size @xmath223 , taking equal time steps _ within _ each element , but with @xmath224 varying _ across _ elements . we further require for simplicity of explanation that , except for the initial time , no two faces take the same time step : that is , @xmath225 for @xmath226 . in order to keep proper time at the edges @xmath227 where multiple faces with different time sets meet , we let @xmath228 therefore the mixed space - time @xmath23-faces , which correspond to the edge @xmath227 extruded over a time step , are assigned the set of intermediate times @xmath229 where @xmath230 . the values stored on a primal avi mesh are shown in . since @xmath231 when @xmath232 , each spatial edge @xmath227 takes more time steps than any one of its incident faces @xmath91 ; as a result , it is not possible in general to construct a circumcentric dual on the entire spacetime avi mesh , since the mesh is not prismal and hence the circumcenter may not exist . instead , we find the circumcentric dual to the _ spatial _ mesh , and assign same time steps to the primal and dual elements @xmath233 this results in well - defined primal and dual cells for each @xmath23-element in spacetime , and hence a hodge star for this order . ( a hodge star on forms of different order is not needed to formulate maxwell s equations . ) the equation @xmath218 , evaluated on a mixed space / time @xmath15-cell , becomes @xmath234 similarly , the equation @xmath60 becomes @xmath235 where @xmath236 equals @xmath21 when face @xmath91 has @xmath237 for some @xmath86 , and @xmath104 otherwise . ( that is , the indicator function `` picks out '' the incident face that lives at the same time step as this edge . ) solving an initial value problem can then be summarized by the following update loop : 1 . pick the minimum time @xmath238 where @xmath239 has not yet been computed . 2 . advance @xmath240 according to . update @xmath241 . 4 . advance @xmath242 on neighboring edges @xmath243 according to . update @xmath244 . as detailed in @xcite for elastodynamics , the explicit avi update scheme can be implemented by selecting mesh elements from a priority queue , sorted by time , and iterating forward . however , as written above , the scheme is not strictly iterative , since depends on past values of @xmath22 . this can be easily fixed by rewriting the avi scheme to advance in the variables @xmath50 and @xmath22 instead , where the potential @xmath50 effectively stores the cumulative contribution of @xmath245 to the value of @xmath246 on neighboring faces . compared to the avi for elasticity , @xmath50 plays the role of the positions @xmath247 , while @xmath22 plays the role of the ( negative ) velocities @xmath248 . the algorithm is given as pseudocode in . note that if all elements take uniform time steps , the avi reduces to the bossavit kettunen scheme . ' '' '' @xmath249 _ // store initial field values and times _ @xmath250 compute the next update time @xmath251 @xmath252.push@xmath253 _ // push element onto queue with its next update time _ @xmath254 @xmath252.pop ( ) _ // pop next element @xmath91 and time @xmath255 from queue _ @xmath256 _ // update neighboring values of @xmath50 at time @xmath255 _ @xmath257 @xmath258 @xmath259 @xmath260 @xmath261 @xmath262 _ // update element s time _ compute the next update time @xmath263 @xmath252.push@xmath264 _ // schedule @xmath91 for next update _ ' '' '' we first present a simple numerical example demonstrating the good energy behavior of our asynchronous integrator . the avi was used to integrate in time over a @xmath23-d rectangular cavity with perfectly electrically conducting ( pec ) boundaries , so that @xmath22 vanishes at the boundary of the domain . @xmath22 was given random values at the initial time , so as to excite all frequency modes , and integrated for 8 seconds . each spatial element was given a time step equal to 1/10 of the stability - limiting time step determined by the cfl condition . this simulation was done for two different spatial discretizations . the first is a uniform discretization so that each element has identical time step size , which coincides exactly with the yee scheme . the second discretization randomly partitioned the @xmath265- and @xmath266-axes , so that each element has completely unique spatial dimensions and time step size , and so the update rule is truly asynchronous . the energy plot for the uniform yee discretization is shown in , while the energy for the random discretization is shown in . even for a completely random , irregular mesh , our asynchronous integrator displays near - energy preservation qualities . such numerical behavior stems from the variational nature of our integrator , which will be detailed in . in addition , we tested the performance of the avi method with regard to computing the resonant frequencies of a @xmath15-d rectangular cavity , but using an _ unstructured _ tetrahedral spatial mesh . while the resonant frequencies are relatively simple to compute analytically , nodal finite element methods are well known to produce spurious modes for this type of simulation . by contrast , as shown in , the avi simulation produces a resonance spectrum in close agreement with theory . furthermore , by refining the mesh close to the spatial boundary , while using a coarser discretization in the interior , we were able to achieve these results with less computational effort than a uniformly fine mesh would require , since the time steps were selected to be proportional to the respective element sizes . finally , we look at the most general possible case : an arbitrary discretization of spacetime , such as a simplicial @xmath0-complex . such a mesh is completely relativistically covariant , so that @xmath16 can not be objectively separated into the components @xmath22 and @xmath24 without a coordinate frame . in most engineering applications , relativistic effects are insignificant , so a 3 + 1 mesh ( as in the previous subsections ) is almost always adequate , and avoids the additional complications of spacetime mesh construction . still , we expect that there are scientific applications where a covariant discretization of electromagnetism may be very useful . for example , many implementations of numerical general relativity ( using regge calculus for instance ) are formulated on simplicial @xmath0-complexes ; one might wish to simulate the interaction of gravity with the electromagnetic field , or charged matter , on such a mesh . first , a quick caution on mesh construction : since the lorentz metric is not positive definite , it is possible to create edges that have length @xmath104 , despite connecting two distinct points in @xmath267 ( so - called `` null '' or `` lightlike '' edges ) . meshes containing such edges are degenerate akin to a euclidean mesh containing a triangle with two identical points . in particular , the dec hodge star is undefined for @xmath104-volume elements ( due to division by zero ) . even without @xmath104-volume elements , it is still possible for a spacetime mesh to violate causality , so extra care should be taken . methods to construct causality - respecting spacetime meshes over a given spatial domain can be found in , e.g. , @xcite and @xcite . when the mesh contains no inherent choice of a time direction , there is no canonical way to split @xmath16 into @xmath22 and @xmath24 . therefore , one must set up the problem by assigning values of @xmath16 directly to @xmath23-cells ( or equivalently , assigning values of @xmath50 to @xmath21-cells ) . for initial boundary value problems , one might choose to have the initial and final time steps be prismal , so that @xmath22 and @xmath24 can be used for initial and final values , while the internal discretization is general . the equations @xmath218 and @xmath60 can be implemented directly in dec . since this mesh is generally unstructured , there is no simple algorithm as the ones we presented above . instead , the equations on @xmath16 results in a sparse linear system which , given proper boundary conditions , can be solved globally with direct or iterative solvers . however , it is clear that the previous three examples that the methods of yee , bossavit kettunen , and our avi integrator are special cases where the global solution is particularly simple to compute via synchronous or asynchronous time updates . it is known that , while variational integrators in mechanics do not preserve energy exactly , they have excellent energy behavior , in that it tends to oscillate close to the exact value . this is only true , however , when the integrator takes time steps of uniform size ; adaptive and other non - uniform stepping approaches can give poor results unless additional measures are taken to enforce good energy behavior . ( see ( * ? ? ? * chapter viii ) for a good discussion of this problem for mechanics applications . ) therefore , there is no reason to expect that _ arbitrary _ meshes of spacetime will yield energy results as good as the yee , bossavit kettunen , and avi schemes . however , if one is taking a truly covariant approach to spacetime , `` energy '' is not even defined without specifying a time coordinate . likewise , one would not necessarily expect good energy behavior from the other methods with respect to an arbitrary transformation of spatial coordinates . which sort of mesh to choose is thus highly application - dependent . in this section , we complete our exposition with a number of theoretical results about the discrete and continuous maxwell s equations . in particular , we show that the dec formulation of electromagnetism derives from a discrete lagrangian variational principle , and that this formulation is consequently multisymplectic . furthermore , we explore the gauge symmetry of maxwell s equations , and detail how a particular choice of gauge eliminates the equation for @xmath84 from the euler lagrange equations , while preserving it automatically as a momentum map . the discrete maxwell s equations are variational . the idea of this proof is to emulate the derivation of the continuous maxwell s equations from . interpreting this in the sense of dec , we will obtain the discrete maxwell s equations . given a discrete @xmath21-form @xmath50 and dual source @xmath15-form @xmath48 , define the discrete lagrangian @xmath0-form @xmath268 with the corresponding discrete action principle @xmath269 = \left\langle \mathcal{l } _ d , k \right\rangle . \nonumber\ ] ] then , taking a discrete @xmath21-form variation @xmath55 vanishing on the boundary , the corresponding variation of the action is @xmath270 \cdot \alpha = \left\langle - \mathrm{d } \alpha \wedge * \mathrm{d } a + \alpha \wedge \mathcal{j } , k \right\rangle = \left\langle \alpha \wedge \left ( - \mathrm{d } { * \mathrm{d } a } + \mathcal{j } \right ) , k \right\rangle . \nonumber\ ] ] ( here we use the bold @xmath271 to indicate that we are differentiating over the _ smooth space of discrete forms _ @xmath50 , as opposed to differentiating over discrete spacetime , for which we use @xmath19 . ) setting this equal to @xmath104 for all variations @xmath55 , the resulting discrete euler lagrange equations are therefore @xmath272 . defining the discrete @xmath23-forms @xmath71 and @xmath17 , this implies @xmath273 and @xmath274 , the discrete maxwell s equations . the concept of _ multisymplecticity _ for lagrangian field theories was developed in @xcite , where it was shown to arise from the boundary terms for general variations of the action , i.e. , those not restricted to vanish at the boundary . as originally presented , the cartan form @xmath275 is an @xmath276-form , where the @xmath86-dimensional boundary integral is then obtained by contracting @xmath275 with a variation . the multisymplectic @xmath277-form @xmath278 is then given by @xmath279 . contracting @xmath278 with two arbitrary variations gives an @xmath86-form that vanishes when integrated over the boundary , a result called the _ multisymplectic form formula _ , which results from the identity @xmath280 . in the special case of mechanics , where @xmath281 , the boundary consists of the initial and final time points ; hence , this implies the usual result that the symplectic @xmath23-form @xmath282 is preserved by the time flow . alternatively , as communicated to us by @xcite , one can view the cartan form @xmath283 as an @xmath86-form - valued @xmath21-form , and the multisymplectic form @xmath278 as an @xmath86-form - valued @xmath23-form . therefore , one simply evaluates these forms on tangent variations to obtain a boundary integral , rather than taking contractions . these two formulations are equivalent on smooth spaces . however , we will adopt patrick s latter definition , since it is more easily adapted to problems on discrete meshes : @xmath284 and @xmath278 remain smooth @xmath21- and @xmath23-forms , respectively , but their @xmath86-form values are now taken to be discrete . see for an illustration of the discrete multisymplectic form formula . the discrete maxwell s equations are multisymplectic . let @xmath285 be an arbitrary subcomplex , and consider the discrete action functional @xmath286 restricted to @xmath87 . suppose now that we take a discrete variation @xmath55 , _ without _ requiring it to vanish on the boundary @xmath142 . then variations of the action contain an additional boundary term @xmath270 \cdot \alpha = \left\langle \alpha \wedge \left ( - \mathrm{d } { * \mathrm{d } a } + \mathcal{j } \right ) , k \right\rangle + \left\langle \alpha \wedge * d a , \partial k \right\rangle . \nonumber\ ] ] restricting to the space of potentials @xmath50 that satisfy the discrete euler lagrange equations , the first term vanishes , leaving only @xmath287 then we can define the _ cartan form _ @xmath288 by @xmath289 since @xmath290 takes a tangent vector @xmath55 and produces a discrete @xmath15-form on the boundary of the subcomplex , it is a _ smooth 1-form taking discrete @xmath15-form values_. now , since the _ space of discrete forms _ is itself actually continuous , we can take the exterior derivative in the smooth sense on both sides of . evaluating along another first variation @xmath157 ( again restricted to the space of euler lagrange solutions ) , we then get @xmath291 \cdot \alpha \cdot \beta = \left\langle \mathbf{d } \theta \cdot \alpha \cdot \beta , \partial k \right\rangle . \nonumber\ ] ] finally , defining the multisymplectic form @xmath292 , and using the fact that @xmath293 , we get the relation @xmath294 for all variations @xmath295 ; is a discrete version of the multisymplectic form formula . since this holds for any subcomplex @xmath87 , it follows that these schemes are multisymplectic . -d asynchronous - time mesh @xmath296 , where the shaded region is an arbitrary subcomplex @xmath285 . given any two variations @xmath297 of the field , and the multisymplectic form @xmath298 , the formula states that @xmath299 vanishes when integrated over the boundary @xmath140 ( shown in bold ) . ] we now explore the symmetry of maxwell s equations under gauge transformations . this symmetry allows us to reduce the equations by eliminating the time component of @xmath50 ( for some chosen time coordinate ) , effectively fixing the electric scalar potential to zero . because this is an incomplete gauge , there is a remaining gauge symmetry , and hence a conserved momentum map . this conserved quantity turns out to be the charge density @xmath300 , which justifies its elimination from the euler lagrange equations . these calculations are done with differential forms and exterior calculus , hence they apply equally to the smooth and discrete cases of electromagnetism . because maxwell s equations only depend on @xmath80 , they are invariant under gauge transformations of the form @xmath81 , where @xmath301 is any scalar function on spacetime . if we fix a time coordinate , we can now choose the weyl gauge , so that the time component @xmath302 . therefore , we can assume that @xmath303 in fact , @xmath304 are precisely the components of the familiar vector potential @xmath5 , i.e. , @xmath305 . having fixed the gauge and chosen a time coordinate , we can now define two new `` partial exterior derivative '' operators , @xmath306 ( time ) and @xmath307 ( space ) , where @xmath308 . since @xmath50 contains no @xmath309 terms , @xmath310 is a @xmath23-form containing only the space terms of @xmath311 , while @xmath312 contains the terms involving both space and time . that is , @xmath313 restricted to this subspace of potentials , the lagrangian density then becomes @xmath314 next , varying the action along a restricted variation @xmath55 that vanishes on @xmath56 , @xmath315 \cdot \alpha & = \int _ x \left ( \mathrm{d } _ t \alpha \wedge { d } - \mathrm{d } _ s \alpha \wedge h \wedge \mathrm{d } t + \alpha \wedge j \wedge \mathrm{d } t \right ) \label{eqn : weylaction}\\ & = \int _ x \alpha \wedge \left ( \mathrm{d } _ t d - \mathrm{d } _ s h \wedge \mathrm{d } t + j \wedge \mathrm{d } t \right ) .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] setting this equal to zero by hamilton s principle , one immediately gets ampre s law as the sole euler lagrange equation . the divergence constraint @xmath316 , corresponding to gauss law , has been eliminated via the restriction to the weyl gauge . let us restrict @xmath50 to be an euler lagrange solution in the weyl gauge , but remove the previous requirement that variations @xmath55 be fixed at the initial time @xmath143 and final time @xmath317 . then , varying the action along this new @xmath55 , the euler lagrange term disappears , but we now pick up an additional boundary term due to integration by parts @xmath318 \cdot \alpha = \left . \int _ { \sigma } \alpha \wedge { d } \,\right\rvert _ { t _ 0 } ^ { t _ f } , \ ] ] where @xmath319 denotes a cauchy surface of @xmath52 , corresponding to the spatial domain . if we vary along a gauge transformation @xmath320 , then this becomes @xmath318 \cdot \mathrm{d } _ s f = \left . \sigma \mathrm{d } _ s f \wedge { d } \,\right\rvert _ { t _ 0 } ^ { t _ f } = - \left . \int _ \sigma f \wedge \mathrm{d } _ s { d } \,\right\rvert _ { t _ 0 } ^ { t _ f } \ ] ] alternatively , plugging @xmath321 into , we get @xmath318 \cdot \mathrm{d } _ s f = \int _ x \mathrm{d } _ s f \wedge j \wedge \mathrm{d } t = - \int _ x f \wedge \mathrm{d } _ s j \wedge \mathrm{d } t = - \int _ x f \wedge \mathrm{d } _ t \rho = - \left . \int _ \sigma f \wedge \rho \,\right\rvert _ { t _ 0 } ^ { t _ f } .\ ] ] since these two expressions are equal , and @xmath301 is an arbitrary function , it follows that @xmath322 this indicates that @xmath323 is a conserved quantity , a momentum map , so if gauss law holds at the initial time , then it holds for all subsequent times as well . it should be noted that the variational structure and symmetry of maxwell s equations may be affected by the boundary conditions that one chooses to impose . there are many boundary conditions that one can specify independent of the initial values , such as the pec condition used in the numerical example in . however , one can imagine more complicated boundary conditions where which the boundary interacts nontrivially with the interior of the domain such as dissipative or forced boundary conditions , where energy / momentum is removed from or added to the system . in these cases , one will obviously _ not _ conclude that the charge density @xmath324 is conserved , but more generally that the _ change _ in charge is related to the flux through the spatial boundary . this is because , in the momentum map derivation above , the values of @xmath301 on the initial time slice causally affects its values on the spatial boundary at intermediate times , not just on the final time slice . thus , the spatial part of @xmath56 can not be neglected for arbitrary boundary conditions . the continued success of the yee scheme for many applications of computational electromagnetism , for over four decades , illustrates the value of structure - preserving numerical integrators for maxwell s equations . recent advances by , among others , bossavit and kettunen , and gross and kotiuga , have demonstrated the important role of compatible spatial discretization using differential forms , allowing for yee - like schemes that apply on generalized spatial meshes . in this paper , we have extended this approach by considering discrete forms on _ spacetime _ , encapsulating both space and time discretization , and have derived a general family of geometric numerical integrators for maxwell s equations . furthermore , since we have derived these integrators from a discrete variational principle , the resulting methods are provably multisymplectic and momentum - map - preserving , and they experimentally show correct global energy behavior . besides proving the variational nature of well - known techniques such as the yee and bossavit kettunen schemes , we have also introduced a new asynchronous integrator , so that time step sizes can be taken non - uniformly over the spatial domain for increased efficiency , while still maintaining the desirable variational and energy behavior of the other methods . one promising avenue for future work involves increasing the order of accuracy of these methods by deriving higher - order discrete hodge star operators . while this would involve redefining the hodge star matrix to be non - diagonal , the discrete maxwell s equations would remain formally the same , and hence there would be no change in the variational or multisymplectic properties proven here . we are currently exploring the development of a spectrally accurate spatial hodge star , which might make these geometric schemes competitive for applications where non - variational spectral codes are currently favored . additionally , the recent work of @xcite has shown that avis can be implemented as parallel algorithms for solid mechanics simulations . this uses the fact that , due to the asynchronous update procedure , an element does not need information from every one of its neighbors at every time step , which lessens the need for communication among parallel nodes . the resulting parallel avis , or pavis , can therefore take advantage of parallel computing architecture for improved efficiency . it is reasonable to expect that the same might be done in the case of our electromagnetic avi . while we have experimentally observed the fact that variational integrators exhibit near - energy conservation , little is known about this behavior from a theoretical standpoint . in the case of odes in mechanics , backwards error analysis has shown that these methods exactly integrate a nearby smooth hamiltonian system , although not much known about how this relates to the discrete variational principle on the lagrangian side . some initial work has been done in @xcite to understand , also by a backward error analysis approach , why discrete multisymplectic methods also display good energy behavior . finally , variational methods using discrete spacetime forms may be developed for field theories other than electromagnetism . promising candidates include numerical general relativity and fluid dynamics , although the latter is complicated by the difficulty in finding a proper discretization of the infinite - dimensional diffeomorphism group . if discrete lagrangian densities are developed for these theories , it should be straightforward to combine them with the electromagnetic lagrangian , resulting in numerical methods to simulate , e.g. , gravity coupled with an electromagnetic field , or the dynamics of a charged or magnetic fluid . we would like to thank several people for their inspiration and suggestions . first of all , alain bossavit for suggesting many years ago that we take the present dec approach to computational electromagnetism , and for his excellent lectures at caltech on the subject . second , michael ortiz and eva kanso for their ongoing interactions on related topics and suggestions . we also thank doug arnold , uri ascher , robert kotiuga , melvin leok , adrian lew , and matt west for their feedback and encouragement . in addition , the @xmath15-d avi simulations shown in were programmed and implemented by patrick xia , as part of a summer undergraduate research fellowship at caltech . desbrun , m. , a. n. hirani , and j. e. marsden ( 2003 ) , discrete exterior calculus for variational problems in computer vision and graphics . in _ proceedings of the 42nd ieee conference on decision and control ( cdc ) _ , volume 5 , pages 49024907 . ieee press , washington , dc . desbrun , m. , e. kanso , and y. tong ( 2008 ) , discrete differential forms for computational modeling . in _ discrete differential geometry _ , volume 38 of _ oberwolfach semin . _ , pages 287324 . birkhuser , basel . elcott , s. , and p. schrder ( 2005 ) , building your own dec at home . in _ siggraph 05 : acm siggraph 2005 courses_. acm press , new york . http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/1198555.1198667[`doi:10.1145/1198555.1198667 ` ] . erickson , j. , d. guoy , j. sullivan , and a. ngr ( 2005 ) , building spacetime meshes over arbitrary spatial domains . _ engineering with computers _ , * 20 * ( 4 ) , 342353 . http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00366-005-0303-0[`doi:10.1007/s00366-005-0303-0 ` ] . gross , p. w. , and p. r. kotiuga ( 2004 ) , _ electromagnetic theory and computation : a topological approach _ , volume 48 of _ mathematical sciences research institute publications_. cambridge university press , cambridge . hairer , e. , c. lubich , and g. wanner ( 2006 ) , _ geometric numerical integration _ , volume 31 of _ springer series in computational mathematics_. springer - verlag , berlin , second edition . structure - preserving algorithms for ordinary differential equations . wang , k. , weiwei , y. tong , m. desbrun , and p. schrder ( 2006 ) , edge subdivision schemes and the construction of smooth vector fields . in _ siggraph 06 : acm siggraph 2006 papers _ , pages 10411048 . acm press , new york . http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/1179352.1141991[`doi:10.1145/1179352.1141991 ` ] . | in this paper , we develop a structure - preserving discretization of the lagrangian framework for electromagnetism , combining techniques from _ variational integrators _ and _ discrete differential forms_. this leads to a general family of variational , multisymplectic numerical methods for solving maxwell s equations that automatically preserve key symmetries and invariants . in doing so , we demonstrate several new results , which apply both to some well - established numerical methods and to new methods introduced here . first , we show that yee s finite - difference time - domain ( fdtd ) scheme , along with a number of related methods , are multisymplectic and derive from a discrete lagrangian variational principle . second , we generalize the yee scheme to unstructured meshes , not just in space but in @xmath0-dimensional spacetime . this relaxes the need to take uniform time steps , or even to have a preferred time coordinate at all . finally , as an example of the type of methods that can be developed within this general framework , we introduce a new _ asynchronous variational integrator _ ( avi ) for solving maxwell s equations . these results are illustrated with some prototype simulations that show excellent energy and conservation behavior and lack of spurious modes , even for an irregular mesh with asynchronous time stepping . |
1606.00140 | gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) are transient events that can be divided into two classes , short - duration ( @xmath1 2 s ) and long - duration ( @xmath2 2 s ) @xcite , or type i and ii grbs @xcite . the physical origins of the two classes are different : long grbs ( lgrbs ) are trigged by the collapse of low metallicity , massive star , and short grbs ( sgrbs ) are thought to be originated from mergers of compact binary systems , such as a black hole and a neutron star ( bh - ns ) , or two neutron stars ( ns - ns ) @xcite . the environments of the grb host galaxies provide important clues for understanding these energetic cosmic events , and have been under intensive study in the past two decades ( see , e.g. @xcite and @xcite for reviews ) . in general , long - duration bursts are associated with star - forming galaxies @xcite that can be either faint or bright @xcite . on the other hand , the short - duration bursts typically have long - lived progenitors , and their host galaxies show a mixed population of early and late - type galaxies , with a wide span of star formation rates @xcite . up until grb 150101b , neither long or short - duration grb hosts show activities of active galactic nuclei ( agns ) in the center . due to the link between the long - duration bursts and the core - collapse of massive stars , it was suspected that some grb hosts with bright sub - millimeter or infrared emission may be powered by agns ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . several attempts have been made to identify agns in the grb hosts but yield no results @xcite . yet , it remains extremely interesting to explore the connection between grbs and the star - formation and agn activities of the host galaxies , as it may provide important clues about the roles of agn feedback , as well as the grb host environment . in this letter , we present a multi - wavelength analysis of the host galaxy of grb 150101b . we confirm this host galaxy contains a central agn , which was first suggested by @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . to date , it is the first confirmed agn in known grb host population . we also suggest that the host galaxy can be classified as an x - ray bright , optically normal galaxy ( xbong , @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . observations and data analysis are presented in section 2 . in section 3 , we fit the host sed and discuss the nature of the host galaxy and central agn . section 4 is discussion and summary . throughout the paper , we adopt the standard @xmath3cdm cosmology with @xmath4=0.30 , @xmath5=0.70 , and h@xmath6=70 km s@xmath7 mpc@xmath7 . _ swift _ burst alert telescope ( bat ) was trigged by grb 150101b at 15:23 ut on 01 january 2015 . the light - curve shows a single peak with a duration ( t@xmath9 ) of 0.018 @xmath10 0.006 seconds @xcite . _ fermi _ was also triggered with a duration ( t@xmath9 ) of about 0.08 s ( 50 - 300 kev ) @xcite . at @xmath11 away , the very large telescope ( vlt ) clearly detected the optical emission from the bright galaxy , 2masx j12320498 - 1056010 , which was identified as the host galaxy of grb 150101b @xcite . the vlt spectra show several prominent absorption features , most notably mg b and na d , at a redshift of @xmath12 @xcite . the gran telescopio canarias ( gtc ) also detected a faint , single emission line which they tentatively identified as an [ ] emission line at @xmath13 @xcite . however , the gtc data suffered from poor weather condition , passing clouds , and bad seeing ( @xmath14 2.5@xmath15 ) @xcite . therefore , we adopt z=0.134 as the redshift of the host galaxy in this work . this is one of the lowest redshifts among sgrb hosts @xcite . the estimated grb isotropic energy between 15 and 150 kev is 9.7 @xmath16 10@xmath17 erg at z = 0.134 . two _ chandra _ follow - up observations were performed at 7.8 days @xcite and 39 days @xcite after the burst , respectively . in figure 1 , the images taken by the two _ chandra _ observations show a bright and a fading source . the position of the fading x - ray counterpart is consistent with the only fading optical source in the bat position , reported by @xcite . the x - ray data reduction was performed with the chandra interactive analysis of observations ( ciao ) software package ( version 4.6 ) . the spectra extracting region is shown in figure 1 in blue circles . for the x - ray fading counterpart , the net count rates of the first and second epoch are ( 9.6 @xmath10 0.8 ) and ( 1.4 @xmath10 0.3 ) @xmath16 10@xmath18 cts / s , respectively . therefore , the fading x - ray source is identified as the grb afterglow . the position of the bright source is located in the nucleus of the known galaxy 2masx j12320498 - 1056010 , which was reported by several surveys and follow - up observations ( see , table 1 for photometry ) . adopting the images from the two chandra observations , the bright source coordinate is @xmath19 , and the fading source coordinate is @xmath20 , with a 90% uncertainty of 0.6 . the offset between two sources is @xmath21 2.77@xmath15 , and the projected physical offset is 6.61 kpc at z = 0.134 . about 35% sgrbs are located at more than 7 kpc away from the center of the host galaxies ( see , figure 10 in @xcite ) . furthermore , the host light extends beyond the position of the grb optical afterglow @xcite . the possibility of such bright source coincidently appeared in the region of grb in a radius of 10 is less than 2.4 @xmath16 10@xmath22 @xcite . therefore , we conclude that the bright x - ray source is the nucleus of the host galaxy 2masx j12320498 - 1056010 . to increase the photon statistics we merged the two observations of the bright source and extract its x - ray spectrum for modeling ( green regions in figure 1 ) . we used the xspec package v12.8.2 and adopted a model of power law with two photoelectric absorptions . one photoelectric absorption was fixed at the galactic value of @xmath23 , and one was let free at the redshift of the host galaxy . this simple model provides adequate fit to the x - ray spectrum . the fitted @xmath24 at the redshift of the host galaxy is @xmath25 , and the power law index is @xmath26 . we have derived a flux of 2.86 @xmath16 10@xmath27 erg @xmath28 s@xmath7 in 0.5 - 8.0 kev , and a luminosity of 1.37 @xmath16 10@xmath29 erg s@xmath7 in 0.5 - 8.0 kev . as we will discuss later in this paper , the source x - ray luminosity indicates it is a low luminosity agn , and this agn showed no variation during the two epochs ( 32 days ) . our flux is somewhat lower than that of @xcite , which may be attributed to the size of the source extraction region . note that the _ xmm_-newton also have @xmath21 30 ks observation for this source after burst proposed by @xcite . but the grb and the central agn can not be spatial resolved . table 1 lists multi - wavelength observations of 2masx j12320498 - 1056010 , the host galaxy of grb 150101b . column 1 shows the observing bands from uv to radio . column 2 shows the effective wavelength of each band . column 3 shows the instruments with which observation was taken at each band . column 4 shows the host fluxes after galactic extinction correction ( except radio fluxes ) which a@xmath30=0.1096 @xcite . the galaxy evolution explorer ( _ galex _ ) have detected the host , namely galex j123205.0 - 105600 , at distance of 0.6 from the center of 2masx j12320498 - 1056010 . the optical / uv telescope ( om ) on board of _ xmm_-newton and wide - field infrared survey explorer ( _ wise _ ; @xcite ) have also detected the host at distance of 2.7 and 0.4 , respectively . the radio continuum at 9.8 ghz and 4.9 ghz are adopted from @xcite . the 1.4 ghz flux is taken from he nrao vla sky survey ( nvss ; @xcite ) . lcccccccccc fuv & 1528 @xmath31 & galex & 0.013 @xmath10 0.005 + nuv & 2271 @xmath31 & galex & 0.012 @xmath10 0.003 + uvm2 & 2310 @xmath31 & xmm om & @xmath1 0.013@xmath32 + uvw1 & 2910 @xmath31 & xmm om & @xmath1 0.022@xmath32 + u & 3440 @xmath31 & xmm om & @xmath1 0.046@xmath32 + v & 5430 @xmath31 & xmm om & @xmath1 0.636@xmath32 + j & 1.24 @xmath33 m & 2mass & 1.120 @xmath10 0.090 + h & 1.66 @xmath33 m & 2mass & 1.444 @xmath10 0.144 + ks & 2.16 @xmath33 m & 2mass & 1.603 @xmath10 0.130 + w1 & 3.4 @xmath33 m & wise & 1.306 @xmath10 0.032 + w2 & 4.6 @xmath33 m & wise & 0.917 @xmath10 0.025 + w3 & 12 @xmath33 m & wise & 0.323 @xmath10 0.145 + w4 & 22 @xmath33 m & wise & @xmath1 2.553@xmath34 + 9.8 ghz & 3 cm & vla & 3.15 @xmath10 0.02 + 4.9 ghz & 6 cm & wsrt & 7.21 @xmath10 0.07 + 1.4 ghz & 20 cm & vla & 10.2 @xmath10 1.0 lcccccc sed & 0.057 @xmath10 0.003 & + fuv & 0.86 @xmath35 & @xcite + nuv & 0.83 @xmath36 & @xcite + 12 @xmath37 & 0.49 @xmath38 & @xcite + 22 @xmath37 & @xmath1 3.23 & @xcite using all the available photometric data presented in table 1 , we have fitted the spectral energy distributions ( seds ) of the host galaxy with the code investigating galaxy emission ( cigale ; @xcite ) . we have also included an agn component @xcite . in figure 2 we present the data points and the model continuum . the fit is reasonably good with a @xmath39 of @xmath40 . in table 2 we list the star formation rates of the host galaxy , estimated using sed , uv and infrared data . both uv and ir data show star formation rates that are significantly higher than those estimated by the sed fitting , suggesting strong contamination by the central agn . fitting of the sed of the host galaxy suggests a stellar mass of log@xmath41(m@xmath42/m@xmath43 ) = 11.07 @xmath10 0.06 , and a galaxy age of 5.7 @xmath10 1.0 gyr . this makes the host galaxy of grb 150101b one of the oldest sgrb hosts detected so far @xcite . the host av derived from sed is 0.33 @xmath10 0.02 , consist with the very small @xmath24 observed in x - ray . the sed fitting suggests the host galaxy of grb 150101b is a massive elliptical galaxy . our _ wise _ color - color diagram also suggests the host is likely an elliptical galaxy . we have found [ w1 ] - [ w2 ] = 0.25 @xmath10 0.04 ( mag ) and [ w2 ] - [ w3 ] = 0.79 @xmath10 0.49 ( mag ) , falling into the region of elliptical galaxies suggested by the _ wise _ color - color diagram @xcite . is 0.9 with 11 degree of freedom.,scaledwidth=52.0% ] the most unique property is the detection of a central agn in the host galaxy of grb 150101b , first suggested by @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . our multi - waveband analysis has confirmed the existence of the agn , which makes it the first grb host with reported agn . beside the clear detection of an x - ray point source in the center of the host galaxy , we draw the conclusion based on the following findings . first , our sed fitting required an agn component ( green line in figure 2 ) . we have experimented the fit with a model without the agn component , and have found such fit officially unacceptable ( @xmath39 = 1.54 ) . the main problem with such model is that it can not fit the high flux presented in the uv band observed with _ galex_. secondly , the observed x - ray and mid - infrared luminosities are consistent with the intrinsic correlation among agns discovered by @xcite . the observed x - ray luminosity between 2 and 10 kev is @xmath44 , and the predicted mid - infrared flux at 12 @xmath37 is between 0.3 and 4 mjy . this is consistent with the _ wise _ w3 data of 0.323 @xmath10 0.145 mjy , and suggests that the galaxy emission in mid - ir is dominated by the central agn . finally , the sed modeling also shows a synchrotron emission with a spectral slope of -0.62 @xmath10 0.03 in the radio band , suggesting agn - related activities . our sed fitting also suggest this is a radio - loud agn . conventionally , the radio loudness @xcite is defined as : @xmath45 using a b - band flux of 0.099 mjy from our sed model , we have found a radio - loudness of @xmath46 . both the radio loudness and the spectral index in the radio band suggest this agn is not a type - i agn . this conclusion is also supported by the derived angle between equatorial axis and line of sight ( @xmath47 ) from the sed fitting . very interestingly , all the properties of the host galaxy of grb 150101b suggest it belongs to a special class of galaxies , namely the x - ray bright , optically normal galaxies , or xbongs ( see , e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . the observed x - ray luminosity of the host galaxy is consistent with those typical of xbongs in the range of @xmath48 . the observed x - ray to optical flux ratio of @xmath49 is also consistent those of xbongs ( @xmath50 ) . such flux ratio in general indicates some moderate level of agn activities . finally , the lack of optical emission features of those typical of agns is also consistent with the definition of xbongs . @xcite suggested three scenarios that may explain xbongs : agns with heavy obscuration , bl lac - like objects , or agns with radiatively inefficient accretion flow ( riaf , @xcite ) . in the host galaxy of grb 150101b , the observed low @xmath51 and moderate x - ray luminosity suggest the first two scenarios are unlikely . for the central agn we discussed here , the observed optical - to - x - ray spectral index is @xmath52 ( 2500@xmath31 - 2 kev ) . adopting the m@xmath53-m@xmath54 relation in @xcite , we estimate the m@xmath55 and an eddington ratio of @xmath56 . those values , as well as the radio - loudness , are consistent with the predictions of the riaf model @xcite . therefore , we conclude that the central agn of the host galaxy is dominated by riaf . in this paper we present multi - wavelength analysis of the host galaxy of grb 150101b . we have confirmed the host galaxy harbors an agn , based on : ( 1 ) the x - ray detection of a central point source with high x - ray luminosity ; ( 2 ) broadband sed modeling ; ( 3 ) the correlation between observed x - ray and mid - infrared luminosities ; and ( 4 ) the radio loudness and radio spectral index . we also found the host galaxy belongs to a special class of galaxies , the xbongs . the observed properties of this agn are consistent with being dominated by a radiatively inefficient accretion flow . grb 150101b is the first confirmed grb - agn system . up to date no agn was detected among lgrb hosts , and only one is reported among sgrb hosts ( this work ) . it is still unclear why the grb host galaxies show very little or no agn activities . agns are rare among galaxies , so one reason might simply be due to counting statistics . the fraction of high - ionization agn in local galaxies is about 2% ( the fraction of low - ionization agn is larger ) @xcite . this rate becomes higher at high redshift when agns activities peak between redshift 2 and 3 . up to date , redshift measurements have been reported for a total of @xmath57 grbs ; however , some of these measurements were performed on the grb afterglows and not on the host galaxies . adopting a conservative number of @xmath58 grb host galaxies from the ghosts sample , we would expect roughly 4 galaxies with agn activities if agn and grb are independent phenomena . so it probably is not entirely a surprise if we only observed one . future multi - wavelength study of the grb host galaxies should be able to resolve this issue . on the other hand , if agns do become less likely to be detected among the grb hosts , one possibility is that agn activities quench the star formation in the host galaxies , therefore reduce the likelihood of detecting lgrb events in such environment . however , since sgrb hosts typically show a wide span of stellar population ages , they clearly exhibit a link with the delayed star formation activities ( berger 2014 ) . therefore , it is likely to detect some level of agn activities among sgrb hosts . in particular , we have found the host galaxy of the grb 150101b belongs to xbongs , suggesting the direction of further study of the link between agn activities and grbs . we thank the anonymous referee for helpful suggestions . we thank dr . denis burgarella for answering our questions about cigale . we also thank drs . weimin gu , mouyuan sun , tinggui wang , feng yuan , and bing zhang for beneficial discussion . this work was supported by the national basic research program of china ( 973 program ) under grant 2014cb845800 , by the national natural science foundation of china under grants 11233006 , 11273021 , 11473021 , 11473022 , 11522323 , 11525312 and u1331101 , by the fundamental research funds for the central universities under grant 20720160023 , 20720160024 , and 2013121008 , and by the strategic priority research program the emergence of cosmological structures " of the chinese academy of sciences , grant no . xdb09000000 . this research has made use of data obtained from the chandra data archive and the chandra source catalog , and software provided by the chandra x - ray center ( cxc ) in the application packages ciao . this publication makes use of data products from the two micron all sky survey @xcite , which is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and the infrared processing and analysis center / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration and the national science foundation . based in part on public data from galex gr6/gr7 . the galaxy evolution explorer ( galex ) satellite is a nasa mission led by the california institute of technology . this publication makes use of data products from the wide - field infrared survey explorer @xcite , which is a joint project of the university of california , los angeles , and the jet propulsion laboratory / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration . this research has made use of the ghosts database ( www.grbhosts.org ) , which is partly funded by spitzer / nasa grant rsa agreement no . | we present a multi - wavelength analysis of the host galaxy of short - duration gamma - ray burst ( grb ) 150101b . follow - up optical and x - ray observations suggested that the host galaxy , 2masx j12320498 - 1056010 , likely harbors a low - luminosity active galactic nuclei ( agn ) . our modeling of the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) has confirmed the nature of the agn , making it the first reported grb host that contains an agn . we have also found the host galaxy is a massive elliptical galaxy with stellar population of @xmath0 , one of the oldest among the short - duration grb hosts . our analysis suggests that the host galaxy can be classified as an x - ray bright , optically normal galaxy ( xbong ) , and the central agn is likely dominated by a radiatively inefficient accretion flow ( riaf ) . our work explores interesting connection that may exist between grb and agn activities of the host galaxy , which can help understand the host environment of the grb events and the roles of agn feedback . |
1007.0801 | galactic black hole candidates ( bhcs ) are ideal objects in studying how accretion disks and coronae evolve due to changes in the accretion rate , thanks to their high photon statistics and frequent state transitions ( see , e.g. , @xcite for a review ) . they are characterized by transient behavior , such as a sudden x - ray brightening caused by instabilities originating in the outer accretion disk . during the outburst , which typically lasts a few months , they may go through several distinct spectral states , initial low / hard state ( lhs ) , intermediate or very high state ( ims / vhs ) , high / soft state ( hss ) , lhs , then go back to quiescence . these states are believed to reflect changes in the geometry of the accretion disk and corona ( @xcite ) , as well as jet ( @xcite , @xcite ) . bhcs sometimes show powerful radio jets in their outbursts in association with state transitions from the lhs to the hss . hence , study of the spectral transition and the disk - jet interaction is important in clarifying jet production mechanisms ( see , e.g. , @xcite for a review ) . the new x - ray transient xte j1752223 was first detected at the 30 mcrab flux level in the 210 kev range on october 23 , 2009 during the galactic bulge monitoring with the proportional counter array ( pca ) of the rossi x - ray timing explorer ( rxte ) @xcite . on october 24 , the source also triggered the swift burst alert telescope ( bat ) at a 100 mcrab flux in the 1550 kev range @xcite . the position was determined to ( ra , dec)=(17@xmath052@[email protected] , [email protected] ) with 5 arc - sec uncertainty by a follow - up swift x - ray telescope ( xrt ) localization @xcite . the energy spectrum is consistent with a power - law with photon index [email protected] and the power spectrum shows band - limited noise with a total rms of @xmath530 percent , suggesting that the source was in a typical lhs ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . the optical @xcite , near - infrared @xcite , and radio counterparts @xcite were also discovered within the x - ray error circle during the initial phase . possible double - sided jets were detected on february 11 , 2010 ( @xcite ; @xcite ) ; however , the bh mass , inclination angle , and distance have not been determined yet . since august 3 , 2009 , the highly sensitive all - sky monitor , monitor of all - sky x - ray image , maxi(@xcite ) , has been activated on the exposed facility of the japanese experimental module `` kibo '' of the international space station ( iss ) . soon after the discovery of xte j1752223 , when the maxi was still in the commissioning phase , the source was found at the 30 mcrab level in an x - ray image of the maxi gas slit camera ( gsc ) ( @xcite ) . maxi / gsc also observed a rapid spectral softening on 2010 january 22 due to a spectral transition from the lhs to the hss ( @xcite ) . the maxi initial results are described in @xcite and @xcite . in this paper , we report on maxi gsc observations of xte j1752223 during its outburst since october 2009 . in the observation and result section , we demonstrate maxi s spectral performance for such a bright source . finally , we discuss the origin of the rather unusual behavior of xte j1752223 in the light curve and spectral hardness . the maxi carries two scientific instruments : the gsc and the solid state camera ( ssc ) . the gsc consists of twelve one - dimensional position - sensitive proportional counters operated in the 220 kev range , while the ssc is composed of 32 x - ray ccd cameras with an energy range of 0.512 kev . the gsc observes two different directions ( horizontal and zenithal direction ) with an instantaneous field of view of 3@xmath6160@xmath3 each covered by six cameras . it covers 70 percent of the whole sky in every orbit 32 times per day at maximum . both instruments have been working properly in orbit , but four out of the twelve gsc cameras are turned off due to discharges in the proportional counters . see @xcite for more details of the maxi . in this paper , we use only the gsc data , which offer a larger sky coverage and effective area than those of the ssc . figure [ fig1 ] shows two 1-month integrated x - ray sky images with a radius of 10 degrees centered on xte j1752223 in the 220 kev band . these false - color images are produced by superposing red ( 24 kev ) , green ( 410 kev ) , and blue ( 1020 kev ) images . data from all the counters were combined , and two images were made for two separate periods ( from december 20 , 2009 to january 19 , 2010 , and january 20 , 2010 to february 28 , 2010 ) . xte j1752223 is clearly detected in both gsc images . because of its location near the galactic center ( l , b)=(6.42 , 2.11 ) , many bright x - ray sources such as gx 9 + 1 , gx 51 , and gx 3 + 1 are visible in this field . the point spread function ( psf ) of the maxi / gsc is estimated at about 2.0 degrees ( fwhm ) in this energy range . the position of xte j1752223 determined by the gsc was consistent with the swift / xrt localization . we calculated net source counts by subtracting the background from the on - source data . to avoid the source contamination from the nearby bright sources gx 9 + 1 ( 2.82@xmath3 away ) and sax j1748.92021 in the globular cluster ngc 6440 ( @xcite ; 2.13@xmath3 away ) , we carefully selected the source and background regions as circles of 1.17-degree and 2.48-degree radius , respectively ( see figure [ fig1 ] ) . the extracted source counts were normalized by dividing by a total exposure ( in unit of @xmath7s ) obtained with a time integral of the collimator effective area . the crab nebula was analyzed in the same way , and the count rates of xtej 1752223 were normallized by the crab unit ( 1.30 , 1.25 , and 0.32 counts @xmath8 s@xmath9 in the 24 , 410 , and 1020 kev range ) . the 1-day averaged light curve of xte j1752223 thus obtained is shown in figure [ fig2 ] . the gsc scans were performed approximately 10 times per day . a data gap from december 7th to 23th was due to solar avoidance limitation ( the current solar protection is set at above 4@xmath3 from the sun ) . the x - ray light curve shows the following notable features . there are two initial plateau phases that lasted for @xmath525 days and @xmath540 days , respectively , and the spectral hardness between them is slightly different : the second phase ( phase d in figure [ fig2 ] ) has a softer spectrum than the first one ( phase b ) . the source could not be observed during phase d by any other x - ray instruments except for rxte / asm and swift / bat due to the sun constraints . the time scales of the rising phases a and c were about 5 days and 15 days , respectively . another notable feature is the anti - correlated behavior around the peak : the 24 kev flux rapidly increased after january 20 , 2010 ( mjd : 55216 ) while fluxes in the other two bands and the swift / bat 1550 kev flux decreased ( phase e for @xmath5 9 days ) . the anti - correlation between the soft and hard bands indicates a spectral transition . this fact means that it took a very long time of @xmath5 90 days for the source to complete the transition after the onset of outburst . the 220 kev flux reached a peak on january 23 , 2010 ( mjd : 55219 ) at about the 430 mcrab level , then gradually decreased ( phase f ) . the emissions during phase f are dominated by the soft bands ( @xmath10 kev ) ( see also the lower panel of figure [ fig1 ] ) . around march 28 ( mjd : 55283 ) , hard x - rays and the hardness ratio again increase ( phase g and h ) . the outburst continues at the time of writing this paper ( the end of may 2010 ) , and the current duration for the outburst is about 210 days . figure [ fig3 ] shows a hardness - intensity diagram for the currently on - going outburst in xte j1752223 . because of the anti - correlated behavior between the soft and hard x - rays during phases e and g , the data points track the q - shaped curve , i.e. hysteresis behavior , as seen in other bhcs ( @xcite ) . the two plateau phases b and d correspond to the lhs , while the softer phase f corresponds with the hss . thus , the state transition from the lhs to the hss can be clearly identified with the maxi / gsc data alone . a color - color diagram is also shown in figure [ fig4 ] . a line is plotted for a power - law spectral model with a photon index ( @xmath11 ) ranging from 1.0 to 5.0 modified by the absorption ( equivalent hydrogen column density n@xmath12=0.72@xmath1310@xmath14@xmath8 ; @xcite ) . note that the current gsc energy response gives systematic uncertainties of about 0.5@xmath15 @xmath8 and 0.1 in @xmath16 and @xmath11 , respectively . as the outburst proceeds , the @xmath11 continuously varies from @xmath51.5 to @xmath55.0 . the spectral shape during phases b+d and f are is approximated by a power - law with photon indices of 1.52.0 and above 3.5 , respectively . these estimated photon indices are roughly consistent with typical values found from bhcs in the lhs ( phase b+d ) and the hss ( phase f ) . the power - law index in phase e shows an intermediate value ( 2.03.0 ) between these seen in the lhs and the hss . an rxte - pointed observation carried out on january 19 , 2010 ( mjd : 55215 ) during phase e shows that the source was at least in the ims ( @xcite ) . detailed spectral parameters and their evolution in this outburst will be reported in a forthcoming paper ( yamaoka et al . 2010 , in preparation ) . we have presented the first results on the black hole candidate xte j1752223 in the current outburst from the maxi / gsc on the iss . judging from the light curve and spectral hardness , we have found that the source was initially in the lhs with two long plateau phases ( b and d ) . after the long stay ( @xmath590 days ) in the lhs , it exhibited a spectral transition via the ims ( phase e ) into the hss around january 22 , 2010 ( phase f ) . the source came back to the lhs around april 3 , 2010 ( phase h ) , and the source flux is gradually declining toward the quiescent state . it should be noted that a relatively high level of radio emission was detected by the australia telescope compact array ( atca ) on january 21 , 2010 ( @xcite ) , just corresponding to the beginning of the spectral transition from the lhs to the hss . the gsc spectrum on this date is roughly represented by a power - law with a photon index of 2.53.0 ( see figure [ fig4 ] ) , suggesting that the source was probably in the ims . later , two separate radio sources were identified with high resolution imaging by the european vlbi network ( e - evn ) ( @xcite ) . if we interpret it as plasma ejection , it is consistent with the scenario that large - scale jets are produced in association with the spectral transition from the lhs to the hss . another important result is that the luminosities during the transition from the hss to the lhs , and from the lhs to the hss were not the same : the hard - to - soft transition happened at a 220 kev flux higher by a factor of about 7 than that at the soft - to - hard transition . such hysteresis behavior was first noticed for gs 112468 and gx 3394 ( @xcite , ) and has been well established for many bhcs . it means that the spectral transition is not controlled by the mass accretion rate alone , but depends on its history . most of the bhcs show a rapid flux rise within a few days that causes the near - instantaneous spectral transition ( @xcite ) , and then their fluxes decay with an e - folding time of several ten days into quiescence ( some bhcs show a secondary flare ) . it is known that the spectral state begins with the initial lhs , then evolves through the vhs / ims , hss , and lhs during an outburst . however , about 8 bhcs such as xte j1118 + 480 and gro j0422 + 32 remained in the lhs throughout their previous outbursts ( @xcite ) . the very long duration of the initial lhs in xte j1752223 and the two long plateau phases are rather uncommon for the bhc outbursts . meyer - hofmeister ( @xcite ) points out that systems with short orbital periods like xte j1118 + 480 ( 4.1 hours ) and gro j0422 + 32 ( 5.1 hours ) tend to have low peak luminosities in their outbursts ( and hence do not show state transition ) because smaller accretion disks have less accumulated matter . the long lhs observed in xte j1752223 might be related with a short orbital period . from our observations , however , xte j1752 - 223 also resembles gx 339 - 4 , which remained in the lhs for a long period before transition into the hss ( @xcite ) . gx 339 - 4 has a relatively long orbital period ( 1.7 days ) among bhcs categorized in low - mass x - ray binaries , indicating a larger accretion disk size . in this case , the unusually long duration of the lhs before the state transition would result from gradual change in the accretion rate . it is still unclear what causes the slow increase of the accretion rate in contrast with other x - ray novae . therefore , the determination of orbital period of xte j1752223 should be important to clarify the nature of the long lhs period . let us explain the overall picture of the light curve of the xte j1752 - 223 outburst . we assume the generally accepted disk truncation scenario in the lhs never though some other scenarios have been proposed for the lhs , e.g. @xcite , where the innermost radius of the disk ( @xmath17 ) is basically determined by the balance between the accretion rate and gas evaporation rate ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . in this scenario , the lhs is the state where the accretion disk is truncated at a larger radius than the innermost stable circular orbit ( isco =3 schwarzschild radii for a non - rotating bh ) , due to a low accretion rate . as the accretion rate increases ( thin begins in an outer part of the accretion disk ) , @xmath17 decreases . when the radius decreases , the corona around the disk cools down via efficient inverse compton scattering of the soft disk photons and exhibits softer x - ray spectra . thus , the two phases in the lhs ( b and d ) can be interpreted with a slightly higher accretion rate in phase d than that in phase b. furthermore , when the accretion rate eventually exceeds a critical rate required for the state transition , the gas evaporation will not be strong enough to truncate the disk . thus , @xmath17 reaches the isco , and the intense thermal radiation from the accretion disk , i.e. ultra - soft component , appears in soft x - rays ( phase f in the hss ) . the disk truncation scenario does not predict any time evolution of @xmath17 during the hss . as seen in the light curve with a very smooth decay during the hss , the local accretion rate smoothly decreases with time . when it falls below the critical rate again , the source comes back to the lhs ( phase h ) . the significant increase mainly in the 24 kev band suggests that the disk innermost temperature ( @xmath18 ) is relatively low . preliminary fits of the maxi gsc data with the disk blackbody model ( @xcite ) during phase f revealed that @xmath18 was 0.40.7 kev including a systematic uncertainty of 0.1 kev . the swift xrt observation taken on february 4 , 2010 also showed that the blackbody temperature is about 0.5 kev ( @xcite ) . this temperature is lower than those of other bhcs such as gro j165540 and xte j1550564 whose @xmath18 in the hss exceeds 1 kev ( @xcite ) . the vary of @xmath18 is determined by how much the accretion rate exceeds the critical rate , hence a low @xmath18 indicates that the accretion rate in the hss is above the critical rate . it is known that the spectral transition from the lhs to the hss will occur at around 1020% eddington luminosity , but with large uncertainties ( @xcite ) . the k@xmath19 for the schwarzschild bh can be estimated to be @xmath20 ( e.g. , @xcite ) , where @xmath21 is the spectral hardening factor ( @xcite ) , @xmath22 is the eddington ratio ( @xmath23 ) , and @xmath24 is the mass of the central object . assuming that the maximum @xmath18 is [email protected] kev and @xmath22 is [email protected] , the black hole mass can be roughly estimated at 8.632 m@xmath25 . the gsc flux in the 210 kev range at the outburst peak ( 2010 january 23 ) was 9.7@xmath1310@xmath26 erg @xmath8 s@xmath9 with a @xmath520% absolute flux uncertainty . assuming that 1 ) the 210 kev flux is 2128 % of the bolometric flux based on the disk blackbody model , and that 2 ) the eddington luminosity is 1.5@xmath1310@xmath27 erg s@xmath9 , the distance to the source can be estimated as 510 kpc . the authors are indebted to many other members of the maxi team and the iss / maxi operation team for their efforts during the data acquisition and the daily maxi operation . this research was partially supported by the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ( mext ) , grant - in - aid no.19047001 , 20041008 , 20540230 , 20244015 , 21340043 , 21740140 , 22740120 , and global - coe from mext `` the next generation of physics , spun from universality and emergence '' and `` nanoscience and quantum physics '' . one of the authors ( k. y. ) is grateful to dr . t. kawaguchi and dr . p. gandhi for valuable discussion . the authors also acknowledge the swift / bat team for making the hard x - ray transient monitor results publicly available . brocksopp , c. , jonker , p. g. , fender , r. p. , groot , p. j. , van der klis , m. , tingay , s. j. , 2001 , mnras , 323 , 517 brocksopp , c. , corbel , s. , zunis , t. , fender , r. , 2009 , atel , 2278 brocksopp , c. , corbel , tzioumis , t. , fender , r. , coriat , m. , 2010 , atel , 2400 brocksopp , c. , yang , j. , corbel , s. , zunis , t. , fender , r. , 2010 , atel , 2438 curran , p. a. , evans , p. a. , still , m. , brocksopp , c. , done , c. , 2010 , atel , 2424 done , c. , gierliani , m. , kubota , a. , 2007 , a&ar , 15 , 1 esin , a. a. , mcclintock , j. e. , & narayan , r. , 1997 , , 489 , 865 fender , r. , 2006 , in compact stellar x - ray sources , ed . w. h. g. merwin & m. van der ks ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press ) , 381 gierliski , m. , & newton , j. , 2006 , , 370 , 837 gierliski , m. , & done , c. , 2004 , , 347 , 885 homan , j. , & belloni , t. , 2005 , sap&ss , 300 . 107 liu , b. f. , mineshige , s. , meyer , f. , meyer - hofmeister , e. , wac , t. , 2002 , , 575 , 117 liu , b. f. , taam , r. e. , meyer - hofmeister , e. , meyer , f. , 2007 , , 671 , 695 makishima , k. , et al . , 2000 , , 535 , 632 markoff , s. , falcke , h. , & fender , r. , 2001 , a&a , 372 , l25 markwardt , c. b. , et al . , 2009 , atel , 2258 markwardt , c. b. , barthelmy , s. d. , evans , p. a. , swank , j. h. , 2009 , atel , 2261 matsuoka , m. , et al . , 2009 , , 61 , 999 matsuoka m. , et al . 2010 , proc . `` x - ray astronomy 2009 '' , bologna , italy , sep . 7 - 11 , 2009 , up , eds . a. comastri , m. cappi , and l. angelini in press . mcclintock , j. e. , & remillard , r.a . , 2006 , in compact stellar x - ray sources , ed . merwin & m. van der klis ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press ) , 157 meyer , f. , liu , b.f . , & meyer - hofmeister , e. , 2000 , a&a , 354 , l67 meyer - hofmeister , e. , 2004 , a&a , 423 , 321 mistier , k. , et al . , 1984 , , 36 , 741 miyamoto et al . , 1995 , , 442 , l13 munoz - darias , t. , motta , s. , parer , d. , belloni , t. m. , campana , s. , bhattacgarta , d. , 2010 , arxiv:1003.0477 nakahira , s. et al . , 2009 , atel , 2259 negoro , h. et al . , 2010 , atel , 2396 patna , a. et al . , 2010 , atel , 2407 shaposhnikov , n. , markwardt , c. b. , & swank , j. h. , 2009 , atel , 2269 shaposhnikov , n. , 2010 , atel , 2391 shimura , t. , & takahara , f. , 1995 , , 445 , 780 torres , m. a. p. , jonker , p. g. , steeghs , d. , yan , h. , huang , j. , soderberg , a. m. , 2009 , atel , 2263 torres , m. a. p. , steeghs , d. , jonker , p. g. , thompson , i. , soderberg , a. m. , 2009 , atel , 2268 ueno , s. , et al . , 2010 , in proceedings of `` the extreme sky : sampling the universe above 10 kev '' pos(extremesky2009)011 wu , x. y. , yu , w. , sun , l. , li , t. p. , 2010 , a&a , 512 , 32 yuan , f. , cui , w. , & narayan , r. , 2005 , , 620 , 905 | we present the first results on the black hole candidate xte j1752223 from the gas slit camera ( gsc ) on - board the monitor of all - sky x - ray image ( maxi ) on the international space station . including the onset of the outburst reported by the proportional counter array on - board the rossi x - ray timing explorer on 2009 october 23 , the maxi / gsc has been monitoring this source approximately 10 times per day with a high sensitivity in the 220 kev band . xte j1752223 was initially in the low / hard state during the first 3 months . an anti - correlated behavior between the 24 kev and 420 kev bands were observed around january 20 , 2010 , indicating that the source exhibited the spectral transition to the high / soft state . a transient radio jet may have been ejected when the source was in the intermediate state where the spectrum was roughly explained by a power - law with a photon index of 2.53.0 . the unusually long period in the initial low / hard state implies a slow variation in the mass accretion rate , and the dramatic soft x - ray increase may be explained by a sudden appearance of the accretion disk component with a relatively low innermost temperature ( 0.40.7 kev ) . such a low temperature might suggest that the maximum accretion rate was just above the critical gas evaporation rate required for the state transition . |
astro-ph0312562 | theories of the structure , origin , development and effects of spiral arms in galaxies have occupied researchers ever since such structure was discovered in 1845 . many galaxies are observed with tightly - wound , regular spiral arms covering a significant fraction of their disc . the commonest model of this phenomenon is based on the lin - shu hypothesis of spiral structure @xcite , which states that quasi - steady spiral patterns exist in the stellar disc , rotate at a pattern speed @xmath2 , and persist for many orbits . the orbits of the stars are organised into ` kinematic density waves ' , which increase the stellar density in a spiral pattern . the stars themselves drift through the pattern inside the corotation radius , as they orbit with an angular velocity @xmath3 . the spiral density wave picture is by no means the only theory of spiral structure , but provides a very successful description . the possible origins , driving mechanisms and long - term support of such density waves has been the subject of a great deal of literature , and this subject is beyond the scope of this paper ; see reviews by @xcite and @xcite . it is generally accepted that spiral waves , if they do not naturally arise through instabilities , may be driven by nearby companions or central bars , and that under the right conditions they may persist for many rotations , and it is from this starting point that we proceed in this paper . galaxies that are optically classified as spirals usually have a clear spiral structure with one dominating mode , and arms are usually logarithmic in shape ( e.g. they have a constant pitch angle ) @xcite . however , galaxies not classified as spirals are now known commonly to show spiral structure in their stellar discs . the old stellar population , which will trace the mass of the disc , can be observed in longer wavelengths such as the k or k@xmath4 bands . @xcite found ` broad spiral patterns ' in the discs of six spiral galaxies , concluding that smooth spiral structure exists in their mass distributions . @xcite examined several galaxies of different types , suggesting a class of galaxy which has flocculent structure at blue wavelengths and a spiral structure in k. more recently , @xcite showed that optical classification does not constrain the structure of stellar discs , finding smooth spiral structure in galactic discs independently of their optical structure . many galaxies optically classified as flocculent , when observed in k@xmath4 , show regular spiral structure @xcite . most of these have a central bar , and some also have a neighbour @xcite . the presence of regular spiral structure , but flocculent structure in bluer wavelengths , has also arisen in numerical simulations @xcite . we make the distinction between three separate arm components : the peaks of the underlying stellar mass distribution , approximately tracing the perturbations in the gravitational potential ( the p - arms ) , the shock fronts of the gas , which will generally be observed from dust ( the d - arms ) , and the ridges of enhanced star formation ( the sf - arms ) . many tightly - wound spiral galaxies are known . assuming that the model of a rotating spiral potential is accurate , the parameters of that potential are fundamental to the galaxies themselves . an understanding of the structure of spiral arms is important in considering the processes affecting the ism flowing through them . in this paper , we focus on the determination of the corotation radius . we discuss the formation of single - shock flows in the gaseous disc , and show how the angular offset between these shocks ( the d - arms ) and the minima of the gravitational potential ( the p - arms ) could be used to constrain corotation . in section [ model ] , we introduce the model spiral potential , to which the gas responds . section [ response ] investigates the resulting gas flow using a well known semi - analytical approach , and compares the results to those obtained by numerical methods . in section [ offset ] , different components of spiral arms are discussed , and the offset function @xmath5 is introduced . various ways to constrain corotation are summarised in section [ corotation ] , and the use of the offset function to provide an additional constraint is explained . finally , our findings are summarised in section [ conclusions ] . the rigidly rotating potential of a spiral galaxy can be decomposed into a static , axisymmetric part and a spiral perturbation . we define the gravitational potential @xmath6 ( in galactocentric polar coordinates @xmath7 ) as @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the axisymmetric potential and @xmath10 is the spiral perturbation . the axisymmetric part represents the unperturbed velocity curve . in this paper , the following velocity curve is used : @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the limit of the circular velocity at large radius , @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the inverse disc and bulge scale lengths ( respectively ) and @xmath15 is the bulge strength parameter @xcite . the potential @xmath9 that produces this velocity curve is @xmath16 where the exponential integral @xmath17 is defined as @xmath18 a spiral perturbation with one mode is given by the general form @xmath19 where the spiral phase @xmath20 is defined as @xmath21 and the pattern has @xmath22 arms . the pattern rotates rigidly at angular velocity @xmath2 . the radial shape of the arms is set by the function @xmath23 , and at constant radius , the potential is sinusoidal in @xmath24 with period @xmath25 . the overall amplitude is set by @xmath26 . the equipotentials of each mode are spirals , which have an inclination @xmath27 to circles . trailing logarithmic arms , with a constant inclination @xmath28 , correspond the choice @xmath29 it is convenient to define the perturbation strength @xmath30 as the ratio of the amplitude of the perturbation force to the axisymmetric force : @xmath31 where the circular velocity at radius @xmath32 is @xmath33 . the radial and time variation of the amplitude can be chosen arbitrarily . a suitable radial choice is to specify @xcite @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the inverse spiral scale length , and the overall amplitude at any time is set by @xmath36 . in this paper we are interested in steady solutions in which the potential has reached a stable state , so that @xmath37 is independent of time . @xmath36 can most conveniently be set by requiring that the maximum relative spiral strength takes a specified value @xmath38 at some radius @xmath39 . an example potential surface , with an exaggerated spiral perturbation , is shown in figure [ pot_surface ] . , @xmath40 kpc , @xmath41 kpc , @xmath42 , @xmath43 and @xmath44 at @xmath45 kpc . a very high value of @xmath46 is chosen to produce a spiral perturbation visible on this figure.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] a relatively small perturbation can have a significant effect on the flow of gas through it . large deviations from the circular flow can lead to the formation of shocks . in this section we examine the formation of single - shock solutions in the flow of isothermal gas through the spiral potential . since the intent is to examine the large - scale behaviour , and ignore small - scale processes , approximations of initial uniformity and isothermality are appropriate . here , the sound speed used is an ` effective ' sound speed equal to the velocity dispersion of the ism , a good approximation for the time and length scales involved @xcite . in this paper we repeat the procedure used in @xcite for finding non - linear solutions ( containing a shock ) to the asymptotic equations of gas flow under a spiral perturbation . the derivation of the equations and descriptions of the procedure are given in @xcite and @xcite and are only briefly described here . solutions are expressed in ` curvilinear ' coordinates @xmath47 that vary perpendicularly to and parallel to the equipotentials , respectively ( see figure [ diagram_coords ] ) . these are defined in a stationary frame of the spiral perturbation . they are defined by @xmath48 @xmath49 where @xmath50 where the last result is for the case of logarithmic arms . a circle at constant @xmath32 will therefore pass through @xmath22 periods of @xmath51 . specifically we define @xmath52 so that @xmath53 always corresponds to the potential minimum . the passage from one arm to the next corresponds to a period of @xmath54 in @xmath51 , regardless of the number of arms . the velocity of the gas is written in components @xmath55 in this coordinate system . these are then expressed as the sum of the ` base ' flow @xmath56 ( the equilibrium circular flow when the perturbation is not present , in the stationary frame of the perturbation ) and a perturbed velocity @xmath57 . in the specific case of logarithmic arms the coordinates can be defined as follows : @xmath58 @xmath59 the differential equations in @xmath60 and @xmath61 , and the technique for locating appropriate solutions , are given in appendix [ appendix ] . the boundary condition for any solution is that it be periodic in @xmath51 with period @xmath54 . solutions are found along streamlines under the approximation that they are at nearly constant radius , and the surface density @xmath62 is then found from the velocity . the solution at a given radius is controlled by seven parameters , under the approximation that they are constant along a streamline : @xmath22 ( the number of arms ) @xmath2 ( the pattern speed of the arms ) @xmath28 ( the local pitch angle ) @xmath46 ( the local relative arm strength ) @xmath33 ( the unperturbed circular velocity ) @xmath63 ( the local epicyclic frequency ) @xmath64 ( the effective sound speed of the gas ) base - supersonic flow is defined as any flow with @xmath65 , so that in the stationary frame of the arms , the unperturbed flow perpendicular to the equipotentials is supersonic . similary , base - subsonic flow has @xmath66 . in general , if the flow in a galaxy is mostly base - supersonic , there will be a region ( the base - subsonic region ) in which it is not . this , of course , occurs either side of the corotation radius in a band where the relative velocity @xmath67 is sufficiently small . in this region , the response of the gas , and the asymptotic flow solutions , will be qualitatively different . the base - subsonic region is bounded by the radii satisfying @xmath68 . if for the whole solution @xmath69 ( entirely subsonic ) or @xmath70 ( entirely supersonic ) , the solution will not contain a shock . this will occur under conditions where the sound speed @xmath64 is very high or low , or the strength @xmath46 of the perturbation is sufficiently small . in the limit of small @xmath46 , the solutions reach the first - order response , which is sinusoidal in @xmath71 and @xmath33 ( and hence @xmath62 ) , such that @xmath72 and @xmath73 . the maximum density ( and minimum of @xmath74 ) occur at the centre of the potential well , i.e. at @xmath53 . if the strength @xmath46 of the perturbation is gradually increased , starting from an entirely subsonic solution , then at some point the flow will be sufficiently perturbed that @xmath74 will pass the sound speed @xmath64 . any solution must now contain a sonic point , at which the gas accelerates to supersonic velocities , and a shock . such solutions are no longer symmetric . a consistent solution consists of a closed curve in the @xmath75 plane containing a single isothermal shock , with a periodicity in @xmath51 of @xmath76 . such a solution only exists for certain choices of parameters . figure [ vu_shock ] shows an example velocity curve in @xmath75 for a solution in a tightly wound spiral , and the corresponding density profile through the shock is shown in figure [ rho_shock ] . plane of the solution at @xmath77 kpc and @xmath78 . the cross marks the unperturbed velocity . the sonic point is marked by a circle . the shock is represented by the dashed line.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] corresponding to the solution shown in figure [ vu_shock ] . the sonic point is marked by a circle.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] it is not always possible to find solutions containing a shock for any choice of parameters . the equations are based on the approximation that the gravitational field is in the @xmath51 direction ( and hence that the shock is parallel to the equipotentials ) , which will hold for large @xmath79 or ( equivalently ) @xmath80 , so that the spiral arms are tightly wound and @xmath23 varies rapidly . in more open spirals the equations therefore break down . also , the parameters are approximated as constant along a streamline , which will be a good approximation only if @xmath46 is not much larger than @xmath81 . in our experience , solutions are difficult or impossible to find for @xmath82 and @xmath83 ( with all other parameters as indicated in table [ standardmodel ] ) . within parameters that satisfy these approximations , solutions still may not exist . in particular , solutions in the base - subsonic region are difficult to find , as discussed in appendix [ appendix ] . in many cases , although shock solutions can be found , no solution of the correct periodicity exists . many solutions show secondary peaks in the density . these occur especially near the ultraharmonic resonances , where higher harmonic terms in the solution become important . if a secondary peak crosses the sonic line , a second shock will occur . it will therefore become impossible to locate a single - shock solution , since a singularity will be present at the second sonic point . it is possible to extend the method described here to include a secondary shock @xcite , but this has not been attempted in this paper . a ` standard model ' is defined , with parameter values as given in table [ standardmodel ] . density profiles for the standard model are shown in figure [ profiles ] for a range of radii . no profiles are shown for radii between 11 and 12.5 kpc , as no solutions exist . the figure shows the smooth transition toward the base - subsonic density profiles , in which the broad density peak at @xmath53 appears and the shock is small . this figure also indicates that the shock location moves to smaller values of @xmath51 with increasing radius . at small radii , the shock occurs almost at the potential minimum , but as the radius increases and the shock becomes weaker , it moves upstream toward the potential maximum . .parameter values of the standard model . [ cols= " > , > , < " , ] [ m81table ] a commonly suggested method of locating corotation arises from examination of the separate arm components . if star formation occurs at some time offset after the passage of a spiral shock , then the relative location of the d - arm and the sf - arm should be reversed inside and outside corotation . the radius at which these arms cross should , therefore , correspond to corotation . this point is mentioned by @xcite , but they failed to observe such a crossing . @xcite proposed that observations in the b and v bands could allow the variation of stellar age across an arm to be determined , and that corotation should correspond to the radius at which this trend reverses angular direction . @xcite attempted to locate corotation in two galaxies by this method , performing a fourier analysis on observations in b and i bands . observational studies of the separations of arm components usually focus on the sf - arm and the p - arm , observing in ( for example ) b and k bands . @xcite observed in the b and i bands , finding an offset in one galaxy , but too flocculent a structure in another . @xcite measured radial variations in the location of sf - arms and p - arms , but conclude that uncertainties in the absolute phase offset between them prevent corotation from being located . @xcite also examined arms in the k and b bands , observing that the sf - arms appear on the convex side of the p - arms as expected , but that the p - arms are more tightly wound than the sf - arms , which is the opposite of the expected result . all of these investigations are based on observations of the sf - arms . this will always be inherently difficult , since the existence , location and shape of the sf - arm are neither expected , nor observed , to be very regular . as discussed in the introduction , galaxies with regular structure in p - arms will often be classified as flocculent in optical observations , meaning that they do not possess regular sf - arms . as pointed out by @xcite , one would expect the stimulation of star formation in shock fronts to be followed by a ` shuffling ' of material , including feedback from star formation , random structure from the condensation of dense clouds and so forth . the appearance of any sf - arm would therefore be much more irregular , and in the right circumstances will appear entirely flocculent . the observation of these arms is further hampered by the effects of dust obscuration , which can make it difficult to locate their full extent . furthermore , the unknown quantity of the ` onset time ' for star formation may in reality be a range of times , leading to star formation occurring at a range of offsets from the shock . the prediction of the large scale shock - induced star formation scenario would be , therefore , that regular p - arms should produce regular d - arms , and any subsequent sf - arms will be irregular and poorly localised . observations of the p - arms and d - arms , and the offset @xmath5 between them , avoid all such issues and would be expected , in galaxies with a regular spiral potential , to result in a much clearer result . in the next section , the way in which corotation might be constrained from such measurements is described . as has already been seen in figure [ cmoffsets_m2 ] , there is a general trend for @xmath5 to vary in two - armed spirals in a specific way . at small radii , @xmath5 approaches zero , but as the radius approaches corotation , @xmath5 moves toward @xmath84 . even with @xmath85 , although @xmath5 does not go to zero at small radii , it still moves toward @xmath84 with increasing @xmath32 . the extrapolation of the curve of @xmath5 , in all these cases , roughly indicates the location of corotation . the form of @xmath86 does , of course , depend on the parameters of the spiral potential . however , the extrapolation of @xmath5 to find corotation stays approximately unchanged under all such variations . figure [ offsets_1 ] shows the curve for the standard model compared to the alterations @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 km s@xmath90 , @xmath85 and @xmath91 km s@xmath90 kpc@xmath90 . corotation is located at 17 kpc in all of these models except the last , in which it is at @xmath92 kpc . the shapes of all the curves indicate corotation to be in the range 1520 kpc , except the curve at higher @xmath2 which correctly indicates a smaller radius of corotation . with various parameters . lines marked with crosses correspond to ( bottom to top ) @xmath88 , standard model , @xmath87 , @xmath89 km s@xmath90 , @xmath85 . line with circles corresponds to @xmath91 km s@xmath90 kpc@xmath90.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] variations in the velocity curve will also affect the shape of @xmath86 . in figure [ offsets_2 ] , the resulting plots are compared using a flat velocity curve , a rising velocity curve in which @xmath93 kpc ( rather than @xmath94 kpc ) , and the velocity curve used in @xcite , which is peaked at around 8 kpc , and shown in figure [ shuvel ] . the values corresponding to @xmath91 km s@xmath90 kpc@xmath90 are also shown . since each of these velocity curves places corotation at a different radius , the values are plotted against @xmath95 in this figure . again , in all cases the approximate position of corotation is indicated by the extrapolation of the curve . , plotted against radius relative to corotation , for various parameters . lines marked with crosses correspond to ( left to right ) @xmath93 kpc , standard model , velocity curve from figure [ shuvel ] . line marked with circles corresponds to @xmath91 km s@xmath90 kpc@xmath90.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] probably the most difficult parameter to constrain in a spiral galaxy is the relative strength @xmath46 of the spiral perturbations . in the standard model , this takes the value 5% at @xmath96 kpc , and varies as @xmath97 . in figure [ offsets_3 ] , the shock locations obtained using a constant strength @xmath30 , at values 3% , 5% and 10% , are shown . this figure indicates that the spiral strength introduces the greatest uncertainty into the location of corotation . generally , weaker spirals will form shocks further upstream at smaller radii than stronger spirals . if the strength of the spiral perturbation varied systematically across a galactic disc , for example increasing from 3% to 10% ( or vice versa ) , the extrapolation of @xmath5 could indicate an inaccurate value for corotation . for models using a constant @xmath46 of ( bottom to top ) @xmath98 , @xmath99 and @xmath100.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] to assess the approximate accuracy of the method , we consider in this section how the semi - analytical results in figures [ offsets_1 ] , [ offsets_2 ] and [ offsets_3 ] may be used , in conjunction with observational data , to constrain the location of corotation in spiral galaxies . we therefore begin with 10 sets of data @xmath86 for @xmath43 . the general idea is to extrapolate the downward - curving trend to the point @xmath101 , which forms the estimate for corotation . the radial range over which we have managed to obtain semi - analytic solutions depends on the model parameters ( e.g. arm strength , rotation curve ) , so that these parameters affect the range in @xmath86 for which we have solutions in each case . estimates will be more accurate where a larger @xmath102 is available . we wish to assess the approximate accuracy of this method as a function of @xmath102 . to this end , we analysed the results at values of @xmath102 in steps of @xmath103 up to the largest value covered by the data . for each value of @xmath102 , only those curves were included whose results cover at least that range , and only the points ( at small radii ) within that range were used . thus , at small @xmath102 , all the curves can be extrapolated , but only the first part of each will be used . at large @xmath102 , only a few of the curves have sufficient data to produce a result , but they will be more accurate . any set of data clearly needs to show a decrease in @xmath5 with @xmath32 as a minimum requirement for this method to be applied . the simplest extrapolation is to apply a least - squares quadratic fit to the points . in some cases , the data curve toward positive @xmath5 over some sections , in which case a quadratic fit does not extrapolate to @xmath101 . to avoid this problem , if the coefficient of @xmath104 in the quadratic fit is positive , we use a linear fit instead . once a fit has been chosen , the corotation radius is estimated as the intersection of the fit with @xmath101 . figure [ cs5fits ] illustrates some fits for the data with @xmath105 km s@xmath90 . km s@xmath90 at two values of @xmath102 . at @xmath106 , only the first five points constitute the data ( solid circles ) . the resulting quadratic fit has the wrong curvature , so a linear fit is used ( dashed line ) . at @xmath107 , all the data are included , and the quadratic fit estimates the corotation radius at @xmath108 kpc.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] the scatter in the resulting predicted values for corotation over the 10 sets of data gives an indication of the accuracy of this method . the results are plotted in figure [ corotationresults ] for all values of @xmath102 . at an optimal value of @xmath109 to @xmath110 , most of the data sets cover a sufficient range to be included , and the spread is some 25% . we estimate , therefore , that this method should be accurate to around 25% if a sufficiently large @xmath102 is available in the observed data , and that @xmath111 is a reasonable guide to this requirement . . solid lines with crosses correspond to ( bottom to top at left end ) @xmath88 , standard model , @xmath105 km s@xmath90 , @xmath87 . the solid line with circles corresponds to @xmath91 km s@xmath90 kpc@xmath90 . dashed lines are models with constant @xmath46 with values ( bottom to top at right end ) 3% , 5% , 10% . dotted lines are alternative velocity curves ( lower : @xmath112 kpc , upper : figure [ shuvel ] ) . solid circles indicate results where a linear ( rather than quadratic ) extrapolation was used . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] in this paper , we re - examine the response of an isothermal gas disc to a model spiral potential , leading to a large - scale flow containing a single shock . the established semi - analytical method was compared to results from numerical techniques , with good agreement within the limitations of each method . we found that : 1 . results from two - dimensional sph fail to resolve the shock sufficiently sharply to determine its location . more work on the details of the sph implementation may improve results . much better results were obtained with the ppmlr code cmhog2 . 3 . in parameter regimes where a semi - analytical solution can not be found , in general the numerical results failed to show a simple single - shock solution . we discuss the appearance of spiral arms in galaxies , and the existence of three separate arms , the p - arm ( in the stellar disc , approximately tracing the gravitational potential ) , the d - arm ( the shock as traced by dust ) and the sf - arm ( an arm traced by enhanced star formation ) . even in galaxies classified as optically flocculent , a regular structure in the p - arms and d - arms should be common . the angular offset @xmath86 between the d - arm and p - arm is proposed as an observable function , avoiding all the difficulties inherent in tracing the shape and location of the sf - arm . finally , we show how this function could be extrapolated to provide an estimate of the corotation radius , and assess the accuracy of the method as a function of the range @xmath102 available in the observations . we estimate that given @xmath111 , the method is accurate to around 25% . thanks are due to peter teuben for providing the cmhog2 code . advice and comments are acknowledged from jim pringle , ron allen , steve lubow , jerry sellwood , eve ostriker and jim stone . thanks are also due to jonathan gair for suggesting the change of variables to avoid the singularity in the semi - analytical equations . finally , we thank the referee for useful comments , and for suggesting the addition of a quantitative assessment of the accuracy of the method . in this appendix , the method for locating solutions in the semi - analytical approach is described for convenience . the method is almost the same as that described in @xcite and @xcite . it is convenient to transform these equations into dimensionless form with @xmath122 replaced by the dimensionless @xmath123 defined by @xmath124 @xmath125 by first defining the dimensionless parameters @xmath126 @xmath127 @xmath128 so that the final dimensionless equations to be solved are as follows : @xmath129 @xmath130 for low spiral strength @xmath46 or sufficently high or low sound speed @xmath64 , solutions will be entirely supersonic or entirely subsonic , and will not contain a shock . for parameters where @xmath131 crosses the value @xmath64 , a shock must exist . the method for locating such a solution containing a single shock ( if it exists ) is as follows . as can be immediately seen from equations [ floweq1 ] and [ floweq2 ] , singularities occur at three points : @xmath132 , @xmath133 and @xmath134 . these correspond , respectively , to @xmath135 , @xmath136 and @xmath137 . for a solution flowing through the shock , the first two conditions should never occur , since gas flow through a trailing spiral ( inside corotation ) should always be moving outward in @xmath51 . the third singularity corresponds to the sonic point , at which the gas undergoes the transition to supersonic flow after the shock ( the gas returns to subsonic flow in the shock itself ) . the value of @xmath51 at which this sonic point occurs is denoted @xmath138 . the singularity at this point is removed as long as @xmath139 . this requirement fixes the boundary conditions ; given any guessed value for @xmath138 , the starting values of @xmath71 and @xmath33 at this point must be @xmath134 and @xmath140 . solutions are therefore calculated starting at @xmath138 , and proceeding forward in @xmath51 ( the subsonic branch ) and backward in @xmath51 ( the supersonic branch ) . the determination of the shock location and the procedure for adjusting @xmath138 to find a solution are described below . the presence of the singularity at @xmath138 can create difficulties for numerical integration . @xcite used a series expansion in @xmath51 around @xmath138 to overcome this problem . an alternative is to rewrite the equations in new variables , which hide the singularity , as follows ( j. gair , private communication ) . start by defining @xmath141 @xmath142 and then define @xmath143 the differential equations now become @xmath144 @xmath145 where the positive root of @xmath146 is taken where @xmath147 ( i.e. along the supersonic branch ) and the negative root is taken where @xmath148 ( the subsonic branch ) . in this form , the equations can be integrated along each branch separately , starting at @xmath138 , and @xmath146 and @xmath149 transformed back to find @xmath71 and @xmath33 . the singularity is hidden and replaced by a forbidden region of phase space , namely the requirement that @xmath150 . this will be satisfied so long as the correct boundary condition is used ( @xmath151 ) . the procedure for locating the shock is as follows . the flow is integrated from @xmath138 along the supersonic and subsonic branches , to give @xmath152 and @xmath153 . generally , the supersonic branch will eventually return to the singularity at @xmath154 and can not be further integrated , while the subsonic branch either tends asymptotically to @xmath155 , or also reaches @xmath154 . if a consistent solution exists , then the shock will terminate both branches before they reach singularities . for every point along the supersonic branch @xmath156 , the isothermal jump conditions can be used to calculate the post - shock velocity @xmath157 that the flow would have if the shock were to occur at that particular value of @xmath51 . since the shock is perpendicular to the @xmath51 direction and the gas is isothermal , the jump condition is simply @xmath158 and so the post - shock branch is defined ( in terms of the dimensionless parameters ) by @xmath159 through the shock , @xmath33 should be continuous , but @xmath71 should drop from @xmath156 to @xmath157 . in a consistent solution , the shock joins the supersonic branch to the subsonic branch at the same value of @xmath33 . therefore , the only consistent location for the shock exists where the post - shock branch crosses the subsonic branch in the @xmath160 plane . this process is shown visually in figure [ shocklocation ] . the starting value of @xmath138 must be adjusted until a shock location appears , at a point on each branch before they reach a singularity . for some parameters , no value of @xmath138 will produce a shock . ) along the supersonic ( dotted ) and subsonic ( short dashed ) branches . the post - shock branch ( solid ) is calculated for each point along the supersonic branch using the jump conditions . it crosses the subsonic branch at the appropriate location for the shock ( circle ) . the shock , indicated by the long dashed line , closes the velocity curve . flow proceeds in an anticlockwise direction . the value of @xmath138 should now be adjusted until the period in @xmath51 of the solution reaches @xmath54 . the unperturbed flow corresponds to @xmath161 ( cross).,scaledwidth=45.0% ] the location of the crossing point is found numerically by minimising @xmath162 with respect to @xmath163 and @xmath164 , which are the values of @xmath51 on the subsonic and supersonic branch ( respectively ) at which the shock occurs . the period in @xmath51 of the solution will therefore be @xmath165 . in general , for a given value of the sonic point @xmath138 , this period will not be @xmath76 . the starting value of @xmath138 must therefore be adjusted , repeating the shock location procedure at each value , until a solution is found with a period of @xmath76 . if such a value can be found , it represents the only physical solution to the flow equations , containing one isothermal shock . the density @xmath166 can be calculated from the values of @xmath71 . solutions in the base - subsonic region are particularly hard to find . this is because the integrated branches depend very sensitively on the value of @xmath138 . in some cases , the range of values for which a solution containing a shock exists can have a width of less than @xmath167 , and so can be difficult to locate . outside this range , the calculated branches run into singularities too rapidly . | we present a new method for estimating the corotation radius in tightly wound spiral galaxies , through analysis of the radial variation of the offset between arms traced by the potential ( p - arms ) and those traced by dust ( d - arms ) . we have verified the predictions of semi - analytical theory through hydrodynamical simulations and have examined the uniqueness of the galactic parameters that can be deduced by this method . we find that if the range of angular offsets measured at different radii in a galaxy is greater than around @xmath0 , it is possible to locate the radius of corotation to within @xmath1% . we argue that the relative location of the p- and d - arms provides more robust constraints on the galactic parameters than can be inferred from regions of enhanced star formation ( sf - arms ) , since interpretation of the latter involves uncertainties due to reddening and the assumed star formation law . we thus stress the importance of k - band studies of spiral galaxies . hydrodynamics methods : numerical galaxies : ism galaxies : spiral galaxies : structure |
1504.00501 | equilibrium statistical mechanics allows a successful description of the thermodynamic properties of matter . more importantly , it relates entropy , a phenomenological quantity in thermodynamics , to the volume of a certain region in phase space @xcite . the laws of thermodynamics are also equally applicable to quantum mechanical systems . a lot of progress has been made recently in studying the cold trap atoms that are largely isolated from surroundings @xcite . furthermore , the availability of feshbach resonances is shown to be useful to control the strength of interactions , to realize strongly correlated systems , and to drive these systems between different quantum phases in controlled manner @xcite . these experiments have raised the possibility of understanding the emergence of thermodynamics from principles of quantum mechanics . the fundamental questions that one hopes to answer from these investigations are : how the macroscopic laws of thermodynamics emerge from the reversible quantum dynamics ? how to understand the thermalization of a closed quantum systems ? what are the relations between information , thermodynamics and quantum mechanics @xcite ? while answer to these questions , for many body system is out of sight , some important progress has been made by considering simple lattice systems ( see , for instance , refs . @xcite ) . in this work , in an attempt to address some of the above questions , our focus is on another simple , yet , macroscopic system black - holes . it has long been conjectured that a black hole s thermodynamic entropy is given by its entropy of entanglement across the horizon @xcite . however , this has never been directly related to the hawking temperature @xcite . here we show that : a. hawking temperature is given by the rate of change of the entropy of entanglement across a black hole s horizon with regard to the system energy . b. the information lost across the horizon is related to black hole entropy and laws of black hole mechanics emerge from entanglement across the horizon . the model we consider is complementary to other models that investigate the emergence of thermodynamics @xcite : first , we evaluate the entanglement entropy for a relativistic free scalar fields propagating in the black - hole background while the simple lattice models that were considered are non - relativistic . second , quantum entanglement can be unambiguously quantified only for bipartite systems @xcite . while the bipartite system is an approximation for applications to many body systems , here , the event horizon provides a natural boundary . evaluation of the entanglement of a relativistic free scalar field , as always , is the simplest model . however , even for free fields it is difficult to obtain the entanglement entropy . the free fields are gaussian and these states are entirely characterized by the covariance matrix . it is generally difficult to handle covariance matrices in an infinite dimensional hilbert space @xcite . there are two ways to calculate entanglement entropy in the literature . one approach is to use the replica trick which rests on evaluating the partition function on an n - fold cover of the background geometry where a cut is introduced throughout the exterior of the entangling surface @xcite . second is a _ direct approach _ , where the hamiltonian of the field is discretized and the reduced density matrix is evaluated in the real space . we adopt this approach as entanglement entropy may have more symmetries than the lagrangian of the system @xcite . to remove the spurious effects due to the coordinate singularity at the horizon need to be bipartited @xcite . ] , we consider lematre coordinate which is explicitly time - dependent . one of the features that we exploit in our computation is that for a fixed lematre time coordinate , hamiltonian of the scalar field in schwarzschild space - time reduces to the scalar field hamiltonian in flat space - time @xcite . the procedure we adopt is the following : a. we perturbatively evolve the hamiltonian about the fixed lematre time . b. we obtain the entanglement entropy at different times . we show that at all times , the entanglement entropy satisfies the area law i. e. @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the entanglement entropy evaluated at a given lematre time @xmath2 , @xmath3 is the proportionality constant that depends on @xmath4 , and @xmath5 is the area of black hole horizon . in other words , the value of the entropy is different at different times . we calculate the change in entropy as function of @xmath4 , i. e. , @xmath6 . similarly we calculate change in energy @xmath7 , i.e. , @xmath8 . for several black - hole metrics , we explicitly show that ratio of the rate of change of energy and the rate of change of entropy is identical to the hawking temperature . the outline of the paper is as follows : in sec . ( [ sec.1 ] ) , we set up our model hamiltonian to obtain the entanglement entropy in ( @xmath9)-dimensional space time . also , we define _ entanglement temperature _ , which had the same structure from the statistical mechanics , that is , ratio of change in total energy to change in entanglement entropy . in sec . ( [ sec.2 ] ) , we numerically show that for different black hole space times , the divergent free _ entanglement temperature _ matches approximately with the hawking temperature obtained from general theory of relativity and its lovelock generalization . this provides a strong evidence towards the interpretation of entanglement entropy as the bekenstein - hawking entropy . finally in sec . ( [ sec.3 ] ) , we conclude with a discussion to connect our analysis with the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis for the closed quantum systems @xcite . throughout this work , the metric signature we adopt is @xmath10 and set @xmath11 . before we go on to evaluating entanglement entropy ( ee ) of a quantum scalar field propagating in black - hole background , we briefly discuss the motivation for the studying entanglement entropy of a scalar field . consider the einstein - hilbert action with a positive cosmological constant ( @xmath12 ) : [ eq : ehaction ] s__eh ( |g ) = m__pl^2 d^4x . perturbing the above action w.r.t . the metric @xmath13 , the action up to second order becomes @xcite : s__eh(g , h ) & = & - d^4x . the above action corresponds to massive ( @xmath14 ) spin-2 field ( @xmath15 ) propagating in the background metric @xmath16 . rewriting , @xmath17 [ where @xmath18 is the constant polarization tensor ] , the above action can be written as s__eh ( g , h ) = - 1 2 d^4x . which is the action for the massive scalar field propagating in the background metric @xmath16 . in this work , we consider massless ( @xmath19 corresponding to asymptotically flat space - time ) scalar field propagating in @xmath20dimensional spherically symmetric space - time . the canonical action for the massless , real scalar field @xmath21 propagating in @xmath20dimensional space - time is [ equ21 ] = d^d+2*x*g^_(*x*)_(*x * ) where @xmath22 is the spherically symmetric lematre line - element : [ equ22 ] ds^2= d^2-(1-f[r(,)])d^2-r^2(,)d^2_d where @xmath23 are the time and radial components in lematre coordinates , respectively , @xmath24 is the radial distance in schwarzschild coordinate and @xmath25 is the @xmath26dimensional angular line - element . in order for the line - element ( [ equ22 ] ) to describe a black hole , the space - time must contain a singularity ( say at @xmath27 ) and have horizons . we assume that the asymptotically flat space - time contains one non - degenerate event - horizon at @xmath28 . the specific form of @xmath29 corresponds to different space - time . lematre coordinate system has the following interesting properties : a. the coordinate @xmath30 is time - like all across @xmath31 , similarly @xmath32 is space - like all across @xmath31 . b. lematre coordinate system does not have coordinate singularity at the horizon . c. this coordinate system is time - dependent . the test particles at rest relative to the reference system are particles moving freely in the given field . d. scalar field propagating in this coordinate system is explicitly time - dependent . the spherical symmetry of the line - element ( [ equ22 ] ) allows us to decompose the normal modes of the scalar field as : [ equ23 ] ( * x*)=_l , m_i_lm_i ( , ) z__lm_i(,_i ) , where @xmath33 and @xmath34 s are the real hyper - spherical harmonics . we define the following dimensionless parameters : @xmath35 by the substitution of the orthogonal properties of @xmath34 , the canonical massless scalar field action becomes , [ equ26 ] & = & _ _ l , m_idd ^d [ ( _ _ lm_i)^2 - . + & & . ( _ _ lm_i)^2-_lm_i^2 ] the above action contains non - linear time - dependent terms through @xmath36 . hence , the hamiltonian obtained from the above action will have non - linear time - dependence . while the full non - linear time - dependence is necessary to understand the small size black - holes , for large size black - holes , it is sufficient to linearize the above action by fixing the time - slice and performing the following infinitesimal transformation about a particular lematre time @xmath37 @xcite . more specifically , =+ , = , + ( ,)=(+ , ) , + _ lm_i(,)_lm_i(,)=_lm_i ( , ) [ equ27 ] where @xmath38 is the infinitesimal lematre time . the functional expansion of @xmath36 about @xmath38 and the following relation between the lematre coordinates , - = , allow us to perform the perturbative expansion in the above action . after doing the legendre transformation , the hamiltonian up to second order in @xmath38 is [ hamilt_1 ] h ( ) h__0 + v__1+^2 v__2 where @xmath39 is the unperturbed scalar field hamiltonian in the flat space - time , @xmath40 are the perturbed parts of the hamiltonian ( for details , see appendix [ app1 ] ) . physically , the above infinitesimal transformations ( [ equ27 ] ) correspond to perturbatively expanding the scalar field about a particular lematre time . the hamiltonian in eq . ( [ hamilt_1 ] ) is key equation regarding which we would like to stress the following points : first , in the limit of @xmath41 , the hamiltonian reduces to that of a free scalar field propagating in flat space - time @xcite . in other words , the zeroth order hamiltonian is identical for all the space - times . higher order @xmath4 terms contain information about the global space - time structure and , more importantly , the horizon properties . second , the lematre coordinate is intrinsically time - dependent ; the @xmath4 expansion of the hamiltonian corresponds to the perturbation about the lematre time . here , we assume that the hamiltonian @xmath42 undergoes adiabatic evolution and the ground state @xmath43 is the instantaneous ground state at all lematre times . this assumption is valid for large black - holes as hawking evaporation is not significant . also , since the line - element is time - asymmetric , the vacuum state is unruh vacuum . evaluation of the entanglement entropy for different values of @xmath4 corresponds to different values of lematre time . as we will show explicitly in the next section , entanglement entropy at a given @xmath4 satisfies the area law [ @xmath44 and the proportionality constant depends on @xmath4 i. e. @xmath0 . third , it is not possible to obtain a closed form analytic expression for the density matrix ( tracing out the quantum degrees of freedom associated with the scalar field inside a spherical region of radius @xmath28 ) and hence , we need to resort to numerical methods . in order to do that we take a spatially uniform radial grid , @xmath45 , with @xmath46 . we discretize the hamiltonian @xmath42 in eq.([hamilt_1 ] ) . the procedure to obtain the entanglement entropy for different @xmath4 is similar to the one discussed in refs . @xcite . in this work , we assume that the quantum state corresponding to the discretized hamiltonian is the ground state with wave - function @xmath47 . the reduced density matrix @xmath48 is obtained by tracing over the first @xmath49 of the @xmath50 oscillators ( y , y ) = ( _ i = 1^n dx_i ) _ ,x_n;y ) ^*_gs(x_1, .. ,x_n;y ) fourth , in this work , we use von neumann entropy [ renyi ] s ( ) = - ( ) as the measure of entanglement . in analogy with microcanonical ensemble picture of equilibrium statistical mechanics , evaluation of the hamiltonian @xmath42 at different infinitesimal lematre time @xmath4 , corresponds to setting the system at different internal energies . in analogy we define _ entanglement temperature _ @xcite : [ temp_1 ] = = the above definition is consistent with the statistical mechanical definition of temperature . in statistical mechanics , temperature is obtained by evaluating change in the entropy and energy w.r.t . thermodynamic quantities . in our case , entanglement entropy and energy depend on the lematre time , we have evaluated the change in the entanglement entropy and energy w.r.t . @xmath4 . in other words , we calculate the change in the ground state energy ( entanglement entropy ) for different values of @xmath4 and find the ratio of the change in the ground state energy and change in the ee . as we will show in the next section , ee and energy goes linearly with @xmath4 and hence , the temperature does not depend on @xmath4 . while the ee and the energy diverge , their ratio is a non - divergent quantity . to understand this , let us do a dimensional analysis n^d+1()^d+1 , [ s ] + [ t_ee]n + = [ t_ee ] ( n / n)^d [ temper_1 ] where @xmath51 is the @xmath52 dimensional hyper- surface area . in the thermodynamic limit , by setting @xmath53 finite with @xmath54 and @xmath55 , @xmath56 in eq . ( [ temper_1 ] ) is finite and independent of @xmath38 . for large @xmath50 , we show that , in the natural units , the above calculated temperature is identical to hawking temperature for the corresponding black - hole @xcite : [ eq : hawkingtemp ] t_bh = . = | _ _ r= r_h fifth , it is important to note the above _ entanglement temperature _ is non - zero only for @xmath57 . in the case of flat space - time , our analysis shows that the _ entanglement temperature _ vanishes , and we obtain @xmath56 numerically for different black hole space - times . the hamiltonian @xmath42 in eq . ( [ hamilt_1 ] ) is mapped to a system of @xmath50 coupled time independent harmonic oscillators ( ho ) with non - periodic boundary conditions . the interaction matrix elements of the hamiltonian can be found in ref @xcite . the total internal energy ( e ) and the entanglement entropy ( @xmath58 ) for the ground state of the ho s is computed numerically as a function of @xmath38 by using central difference scheme ( see appendix [ app2 ] ) . all the computations are done using matlab r@xmath59a for the lattice size @xmath60 , @xmath61 with a minimum accuracy of @xmath62 and a maximum accuracy of @xmath63 . in the following subsections , we compute @xmath56 numerically for two different black - hole space - times , namely , 4 dimensional schwarzschild and reissner - nordstrm black holes and show that they match with hawking temperature @xmath64 . @xmath56 is calculated by taking the average of _ entanglement temperature _ for each @xmath49 s by fixing @xmath50 . the 4-dimensional schwarzschild black hole space - time ( put @xmath65 ) in dimensionless units @xmath66 is given by the line element in eq.([equ22 ] ) with @xmath36 is given by : f(r)=1- in fig.([fig1 ] ) , we have plotted total energy ( in dimensionless units ) and ee versus @xmath38 for 4-dimensional schwarzschild space - time . following points are important to note regarding the numerical results : first for every @xmath38 , von neumann entropy scales approximately as @xmath67 . second , ee and the total energy increases with @xmath38 . using relation ( [ temp_1 ] ) , we evaluate `` entanglement '' temperature numerically . in dimensionless units , we get @xmath68 which is close to the value of the hawking temperature @xmath69 . however , it is important to note that for different values of @xmath50 , we obtain approximately the same value of entropy . the results are tabulated , see table([table1 ] ) . see appendix [ app3 ] , for plots of energy and ee for @xmath70 and @xmath71 . for the 4d schwarzschild black hole . we set @xmath60 and @xmath72 . the cyan coloured dots are the numerical data and the red line is the best linear fit to the data . ] the 4-dimensional reissner - nordstrm black hole is given by the line element in eq.([equ22 ] ) , where @xmath73 is [ equ219 ] f(r)=1-+ @xmath74 is the charge of the black hole . note that we have rescaled the radius w.r.t the outer horizon ( @xmath75 ) . choosing @xmath76 , we get f(r ) = 1-+ and the black hole temperature in the unit of @xmath28 is @xmath77 . note that we have evaluated the _ entanglement temperature _ by fixing the charge @xmath78 . for a fixed charge @xmath78 , the first law of black hole mechanics is given by @xmath79 , where @xmath5 is the area of the black hole horizon . the energy and ee for different @xmath78 values have the same profile , which looks exactly like in the previous case and is shown in the middle row in fig . ( [ fig3 ] ) . see appendix [ app3 ] , for plots for other values of @xmath49 . as given in the table ( [ table1 ] ) , @xmath56 matches with hawking temperature . @xmath80 & @xmath81 + & & 0.07958 & 0.07927 + * & @xmath82 & 0.07878 & 0.07836 + & @xmath83 & 0.07639 & 0.07507 + & @xmath84 & 0.07242 & 0.07501 + & @xmath85 & 0.06685 & 0.06659 + in this work , we have given another proof that 4-dimensional black hole entropy can be associated to entropy of entanglement across the horizon by explicitly deriving entanglement temperature . entanglement temperature is given by the rate of change of the entropy of entanglement across a black hole s horizon with regard to the system energy . our new result sheds the light on the interpretation of temperature from entanglement as the hawking temperature , one more step to understand the black hole thermodynamics from the quantum information theory platform . some of the key features of our analysis are : first , while entanglement and energy diverge in the limit of @xmath55 , the _ entanglement temperature _ is a finite quantity . second , _ entanglement temperature _ vanishes for the flat space - time . while the evaluation of the entanglement entropy _ does not _ distinguish between the black - hole space - time and flat space - time , entanglement temperature distinguishes the two space - times . our analysis also shows that the entanglement entropy satisfies all the properties of the black - hole entropy . first , like the black hole entropy , the entanglement entropy increases and never decreases . second , the entanglement entropy and the temperature satisfies the first law of black - hole mechanics @xmath86 . we have shown this explicitly for schwarzschild black - hole and for reissner - norstrom black - hole . it is quite remarkable that in higher dimensional space time the rnyi entropy provides a convergent alternative to the measure of entanglement @xcite , however , entanglement temperature will depend on the rnyi parameter . while a physical understanding of the rnyi parameter has emerged @xcite , it is still not clear how to fix the rnyi parameter from first principles @xcite . our analysis throws some light on the emergent gravity paradigm @xcite where gravity is viewed not as a fundamental force . here we have shown that the information lost across the horizon is related to the black - hole entropy and the laws of black - hole mechanics emerge from the entanglement across the horizon . since general relativity reduces gravity to an effect of the curvature of the space - time , it is thought that the microscopic constituents would be the _ atoms of the space - time _ itself . our analysis shows that entanglement across horizons can be used as building blocks of space - time @xcite . one of the unsettling questions in theoretical physics is whether due to hawking temperature the black - hole has performed a non - unitary transformation on the state of the system aka information loss problem . our analysis here does not address this for two reasons : ( i ) here , we have fixed the radius of the horizon at all times and evaluated the change in the entropy while to address the information loss we need to look at changing horizon radius . ( ii ) here , we have used perturbative hamiltonian , and hence , this analysis fails as the black - hole size shrinks to half - its - size @xcite . we hope to report this in future . while the unitary quantum time - evolution is reversible and retains all information about the initial state , we have shown that the restriction of the degrees of freedom outside the event - horizon at all times leads to temperature analogous to hawking temperature . our analysis may have relevance to the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis @xcite , which we plan to explore . authors wish to thank a. p. balachandran , charles bennett , samuel braunstein , saurya das and jens eisert for discussions and comments . also , we would like to thank the anonymous referee for the useful comments . all numerical computations were done at the fast computing clusters at iiser - tvm . the work is supported by max planck - india partner group on gravity and cosmology . ssk acknowledges the financial support of the csir , govt . of india through senior research fellowship . ss is partially supported by ramanujan fellowship of dst , india . in this appendix section , we give details of the derivation of the hamiltonian ( h ) upto second order in @xmath38 . using the orthogonal properties of the real spherical harmonics @xmath34 , the scalar field action reduces to , [ equu26 ] s&=&__l , m_idd ^d [ ( _ _ lm_i)^2 - -_lm_i^2 ] where @xmath87 are dimensionless . performing the following infinitesimal transformation @xcite in the above resultant action : =+,= , + _ lm_i(,)_lm_i(,)=_lm_i ( , ) , + ( ,)=(+ , ) the action in eq . ( [ equu26 ] ) becomes , s & & _ _ l , m_idd (+h_1+^2 h_2/2)^d[(1-f - h_1-[h_2+h_1 ^ 2 ] ) ^1/2 ( _ _ lm_i)^2 . + & & .- (1-f - h_1-[h_2+h_1 ^ 2 ] ) ^-1/2 ( _ _ lm_i)^2 - . (1-f - h_1-[h_2+h_1 ^ 2 ] ) ^1/2_lm_i^2 ] [ equ28 ] where @xmath88 . using the relation between the lematre coordinates - = gives the following expression , [ equ214 ] h_1=- , h_2= , |_= the hamiltonian @xmath89 corresponding to the above lagrangian is [ equ212 ] h__l , m_id[_lm_i^2 + ( _ ) ^2+__lm_i^2 ] where [ equ210 ] g__1=+h_1+^2 h_2/2 , g__2= , _ _ lm_i= g__1^d/2_lm_i and @xmath90 is the canonical conjugate momenta corresponding to the field @xmath91 . upon quantization , @xmath90 and @xmath91 satisfy the usual canonical commutation relation : [ equ211 ] [_lm_i(,),_lm_i ( , ) ] = i _ ll_m_im_i(- ) using relations ( [ equ214 ] ) and expanding the hamiltonian up to second order in @xmath38 , we get , [ equ215 ] h&__l , m_i_^d[^2_lm_i+^d [_r ] ^2 . + & .+^2_lm_i ] the hamiltonian in eq . ( [ equ215])is of the form [ hamilt_11 ] hh__0 + v__1+^2 v__2 where @xmath39 is the unperturbed scalar field hamiltonian in the flat space - time , @xmath92 are the perturbed parts of the hamiltonian given by ; h__0&=&__l , m_i_^d[^2_lm_i+ r^d[_r ] ^2 + ^2_lm_i ] + v__1&=&__l , m_i_^d [ . + ^2_lm_i ] + v__2&=&__l , m_i_^d[(h^2_3+h_4)^2_lm_i+ ( --+d h_1 h_1-d h_3 h_1+d h_2+h_3 h_3 + h_4)_lm_i_lm_i . + & & .+(++-++ d^2 h_1^2- .. + & & ..-- d h_1 h_3+ h_3^2-)^2_lm_i ] where h__1= , h__2= , h__3= , h__4=()^2 + and the redefined field operators are _ lm_i= _ lm_i= such that they satisfy the following canonical commutation relation [ equ216 ] [_lm_i(r , ) , _ lm_i(r,)]=i _ ll_m_im_i(r- r ) the hamiltonian @xmath42 in eq . ( [ hamilt_11 ] ) is mapped to a system of @xmath50 coupled time independent harmonic oscillators ( ho ) with non - periodic boundary conditions . the interaction matrix elements of the hamiltonian can be found in the ref.@xcite . the total internal energy ( e ) and the entanglement entropy ( @xmath93 ) for the ground state of the ho s is computed numerically as a function of @xmath38 by using central difference scheme . this is one of the effective method for finding the approximate value for derivative of a function in the neighbourhood of any discrete point , @xmath94,with unit steps of @xmath95 . the taylor expansion of the function about the point @xmath96 in the forward and backward difference scheme is given respectively by , f(x+h)= f(x ) + + + ...... + f(x - h)=f(x ) - + - ....... which implies , f(x)&= & + o(h^2 ) + f(x)&=&+o(h^2 ) + f(x)&=&+o(h^2 ) in this section of appendix , we give plots of ee for different black hole space - times ; , gross c. , weller a. , giovanazzi s. , and oberthaler m. k. , `` squeezing and entanglement in a bose - einstein condensate , '' http://dx.doi.org/http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature07332[_nature_ * 455 * no . 7217 , ( oct , 2008 ) 12161219 ] . d. a. smith , m. gring , t. langen , m. kuhnert , b. rauer , r. geiger , t. kitagawa , i. mazets , e. demler , and j. schmiedmayer , `` prethermalization revealed by the relaxation dynamics of full distribution functions , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/15/7/075011[_new journal of physics _ * 15 * no . 7 , ( 2013 ) 075011 ] . j. von stecher , e. demler , m. d. lukin , and a. m. rey , `` probing interaction - induced ferromagnetism in optical superlattices , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/12/5/055009[_new journal of physics _ * 12 * no . 5 , ( 2010 ) 055009 ] . j. dinerman and l. f. santos , `` manipulation of the dynamics of many - body systems via quantum control methods , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/12/5/055025[_new journal of physics _ * 12 * no . 5 , ( 2010 ) 055025 ] . m. b. plenio and v. vedral , `` teleportation , entanglement and thermodynamics in the quantum world , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/001075198181766 [ _ contemporary physics _ * 39 * no . 6 , ( nov . , 1998 ) 431446 ] . , dunjko vanja , and olshanii maxim , `` thermalization and its mechanism for generic isolated quantum systems , '' http://dx.doi.org/http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature06838[_nature_ * 452 * no . 7189 , ( apr , 2008 ) 854?858 ] . r. nandkishore and d. a. huse , `` many - body localization and thermalization in quantum statistical mechanics , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev-conmatphys-031214-014726[_annual review of condensed matter physics _ * 6 * no . 1 , ( 2015 ) 1538 ] . p. calabrese and j. l. cardy , `` entanglement entropy and quantum field theory , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1742-5468/2004/06/p06002 [ _ journal of statistical mechanics : theory and experiment _ * 0406 * ( 2004 ) p06002 ] . k. mallayya , r. tibrewala , s. shankaranarayanan , and t. padmanabhan , `` zero modes and divergence of entanglement entropy , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.90.044058[_phys . d _ * 90 * ( aug , 2014 ) 044058 ] . click on the following ` dropbox ' link for more details on matlab codes that use for the numerical study reported in the paper , https://www.dropbox.com/sh/wxmq02qxg6m3pbm/aabee-k4mmow7fjj_jhgfrv_a?dl=0 . a. d. sakharov , `` vacuum quantum fluctuations in curved space and the theory of gravitation , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1023/a:1001947813563[_general relativity and gravitation _ * 32 * no . 2 , ( 2000 ) 365367 ] . a. almheiri , d. marolf , j. polchinski , and j. sully , `` black holes : complementarity or firewalls ? , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/jhep02(2013)062[_journal of high energy physics _ * 2013 * no . 2 , ( 2013 ) 120 ] . | the thermodynamic entropy of an isolated system is given by its von neumann entropy . over the last few years , there is an intense activity to understand thermodynamic entropy from the principles of quantum mechanics . more specifically , is there a relation between the ( von neumann ) entropy of entanglement between a system and some ( separate ) environment is related to the thermodynamic entropy ? it is difficult to obtain the relation for many body systems , hence , most of the work in the literature has focused on small number systems . in this work , we consider black - holes that are simple yet macroscopic systems and show that a direct connection could not be made between the entropy of entanglement and the hawking temperature . in this work , within the adiabatic approximation , we explicitly show that the hawking temperature is indeed given by the rate of change of the entropy of entanglement across a black hole s horizon with regard to the system energy . this is yet another numerical evidence to understand the key features of black hole thermodynamics from the viewpoint of quantum information theory . |
astro-ph0011180 | now that cosmic - microwave - background ( cmb ) experiments @xcite have verified the inflationary predictions of a flat universe and structure formation from primordial adiabatic perturbations , we are compelled to test further the predictions of the simplest single - scalar - field slow - roll inflation models and to look for possible deviations . measurements of the distribution of primordial density perturbation afford such tests . if the primordial perturbations are due entirely to quantum fluctuations in the scalar field responsible for inflation ( the `` inflaton '' ) , then their distribution should be _ very _ close to gaussian ( e.g. , ) . however , multiple - scalar - field models of inflation allow for the possibility that a small fraction of primordial perturbations are produced by quantum fluctuations in a second scalar field . if so , the distribution of these perturbations could be non - gaussian ( e.g. , ) . moreover , it is still possible that some component of primordial perturbations are due to topological defects or some other exotic causal mechanism @xcite , and if so , their distribution should be non - gaussian ( e.g. , ) . detection of any non - gaussianity would thus be invaluable for appreciating the nature of the ultra - high - energy physics that gave rise to primordial perturbations . ruling such exotic possibilities in or out will also be necessary to test the assumptions that underly the new era of precision cosmology . there are several observables that can be used to look for primordial non - gaussianity . cmb maps probe cosmological fluctuations when they were closest to their primordial form , and many authors have developed various mathematical tools to test the gaussian hypothesis . the statistics of present - day large scale structure ( lss ) in the universe can also be used ( e.g. , ) . the properties and abundances of the most massive and/or highest - redshift objects in the universe also contain precious information about the nature of the initial conditions ( e.g. , ; robinson , gawiser & silk 1999 ; robinson , gawiser & silk 2000 ; ( mvj ) ; ) . in verde et al . ( 2000a ; vwhk00 ) , the relative sensitivities of the cmb and lss to several broad classes of primordial non - gaussianity were compared , and it was found that forthcoming cmb maps can provide more sensitive probes of primordial non - gaussianity than galaxy surveys . here we extend the results of that paper to include comparisons to the abundances of high - redshift galaxies as well as the abundance and properties of clusters . one of our original aims was to determine whether any of these probes would be able to detect the miniscule deviations from gaussianity that arise from quantum fluctuations in the inflaton ; unfortunately , we have been unable to find any . nevertheless , some detectable deviations from gaussianity are conceivable with multiple - field models of inflation and/or some secondary contribution to primordial perturbations from topological defects . we will follow vwhk00 and parameterize the primordial non - gaussianity with a parameter that can be dialed from zero ( corresponding to the gaussian case ) for two different classes of non - gaussianity . we will then compare the smallest value for the parameter that can be detected with each of the different approaches . there are infinite types of possible deviations from gaussianity , and it is unthinkable to address them all . however , we can consider plausible physical mechanisms that produce small deviations from the gaussian behavior and thus analyze the following two models for the primordial non - gaussianity ( e.g. , coles & barrow 1987 , vwhk00 , mvj ) . in the first model , we suppose that the fractional density perturbation @xmath0 is a non - gaussian random field that can be written in terms of a gaussian random field @xmath1 through ( model a ) @xmath2 in the second model , we suppose that the primordial gravitational potential @xmath3 is a non - gaussian random field that can be written in terms of a gaussian random field @xmath1 through ( model b ) @xmath4 non - gaussianity in the density field is then obtained from that in the potential through the poisson equation . here , @xmath5 and @xmath6 refer to the _ primordial _ gravitational potential and density perturbation , before the action of the transfer function that takes place near matter - radiation equality . although not fully general , these models may be considered as the lowest - order terms in taylor expansions of more general fields , and are thus quite general for small deviations from gaussianity . the scale - dependence of the non - gaussianity in the two models differs . model a produces deviations from gaussianity that are roughly scale - independent on large scales , while model b produces deviations from non - gaussianity that become larger at larger distance scales . although we choose these models essentially in an _ ad hoc _ way , the non - gaussianity of model b is precisely that arising in standard slow - roll inflation and in non - standard ( e.g. , multifield ) inflation (; see also below ) . model a more closely resembles the non - gaussianity that would be expected from topological defects ( e.g. , vwhk00 ) . in either case , the lowest - order deviations from non - gaussianity ( and those expected generically to be the most easily observed ) are the three - point correlation function ( including the skewness , its zero - lag value ) or equivalently the bispectrum , its fourier - space counterpart . it is straightforward to calculate these quantities for both models a and b. temperature fluctuations in the cmb come from density perturbations at the surface of last scatter , so the distribution of temperature fluctuations reflects that in the primordial density field . it is thus straightforward to relate the density - field bispectra of models a and b to the bispectrum of the cmb . density perturbations in the universe today grew via gravitational infall from primordial perturbations in the early universe , and this process alters the mass distribution in a calculable way . cosmological perturbation theory allows the bispectrum for the mass distribution in the universe today to be related to that for the primordial distribution . vwhk00 calculated the smallest values of @xmath7 and @xmath8 that would be accessible with the cmb and with lss . for the cmb calculation , it was assumed that a temperature map could be measured to the cosmic - variance limit only for multipole moments @xmath9 ; it was assumed ( quite conservatively ) that no information would be obtained from larger multipole moments . the lss calculation were made under the very optimistic assumption that the distribution of mass could be determined precisely from the galaxy distribution ( i.e. , that there was no biasing ) in a survey of the size of sdss and/or 2df . vwhk00 found that the smallest values of @xmath10 that can be detected with the cmb under these assumptions is @xmath11 and @xmath12 ( including noise and foreground but neglecting dust contamination found that @xmath13 from the planck experiment ) , while the smallest values measurable with lss are @xmath14 and @xmath15 . more realistically , the galaxy distribution will be biased relative to the mass distribution , and this will degrade the sensitivities to nonzero @xmath7 and @xmath8 obtainable with lss . vwhk00 thus concluded that the cmb will provide a keener probe of primordial non - gaussianity for the class of models considered . according to the press - schechter theory , the abundance of high - redshift and/or massive objects is determined by the form of the high - density tail of the primordial density distribution function . a probability distribution function ( pdf ) that produces a larger number of @xmath16 peaks than a gaussian distribution will lead to a larger abundance of rare high - redshift and/or massive objects . since small deviations from gaussianity have deep impact on those statistics that probe the tail of the distribution ( e.g. , mvj ) , rare high - redshift and/or massive objects should be powerful probes of primordial non gaussianity . the number densities of high - redshift galaxies and/or of clusters ( at either low or high redshifts ) provides a very sensitive probe of the pdf . since the gaussian tail is decaying exponentially at higher densities , even a small deviation from gaussianity can lead to huge enhancements in the number densities . the non - gaussianity parameters @xmath17 are effectively `` tail enhancement '' parameters ( c.f . , mvj ) or @xmath8 , if the pdf is not too non - gaussian . it is easy to understand this statement if one thinks in terms of skewness . physical mechanisms that produce non - gaussianity generically produce non - zero skewness in the pdf for the simple reason that underdense region can not be more empty than voids while overdense regions can become arbitrarily overdense . skewness can be scale dependent , but for a given value of the skewness there is one - to - one correspondence to @xmath18 parameters ( see the appendix ) . ] in order to determine the minimum value of @xmath19 that can be detected using high - redshift objects , one needs to compute by how much the observed number density of objects changes with respect to the gaussian case when the primordial field is described by equations ( [ firstngmap ] ) and ( [ secondngmap ] ) . we calculate this enhancement using the results for the mass function for mildly non - gaussian initial conditions obtained analytically in mvj . conservatively , we make the assumption that objects form at the same redshift at which they are observed ( @xmath20 ) ; since for some objects the dark halo will have collapsed before we observe them , the assumption gives a _ lower limit _ to the amount of non - gaussianity . the directly observed quantity , however , is not the mass function , but is @xmath21 , the total number of objects in the survey area of mass @xmath22 that collapse at redshift @xmath23 . in fact it is extremely difficult to obtain an accurate estimate of the mass of high - redshift objects , what is a more robust quantity is the minimum mass that these objects must have in order to be detected at that redshift . this quantity is related to the mass function , @xmath24 , by n(m , z)=_m^n(m , z)dm . in calculating the enhancement of high - redshift objects due to primordial non - gaussianity , we restrict ourselves to consider , at any given redshift , only those masses , @xmath25 for which at least one object is expected in the whole sky for gaussian initial conditions ( @xmath26 in @xmath27 radians ) is motivated by the following considerations . of course it is not robust to detect a non - gaussianity that suppresses the number of objects with respect to the gaussian prediction , since one can always argue that one did not look hard enough , or that the objects are there but are somewhat `` invisible '' . so we set to detect a non - gaussianity that enhances the number of objects relative to the gaussian case . if within gaussian initial conditions we expect @xmath28 in the whole sky , and observations find @xmath29 in the survey area , we can say that we have detected non - gaussianity . however , the non - gaussianity ( or tail enhancement ) parameter is directly related to the ratio of observed @xmath30 to the gaussian predicted @xmath31 ( see eq . obviously this ratio is well defined for any @xmath32 and @xmath33 , but the observed @xmath34 can only be an integer @xmath35 . the tail enhancement parameter will then make @xmath36 ( and we consider only cases where @xmath37 ) . it is reasonable therefore to consider only those masses and redshift for which the theoretical prediction for the gaussian @xmath38 is @xmath35 . ] . this is illustrated in fig . 1 for a @xmath39cdm model ( hereafter we adopt the currently favored cosmological model with parameters : @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath43 and transfer function of with @xmath44 ) where the shaded region encloses predictions for @xmath45 from different mass functions ( e.g. , ) . given the rapidly dying tail of the gaussian pdf , small uncertainties in the mass determination of high - redshift objects could lead to overestimate the value of @xmath19 . an overabundance of galaxies of estimated mass @xmath46 , which in principle can be attributed to a non - zero value of @xmath18 , can also be explained under the hypothesis of gaussian initial conditions if the actual galaxy mass @xmath47 is @xmath48 . we thus include conservative values for the uncertainty @xmath49 in the mass determination of high - redshift objects and we then calculate the minimum change @xmath50 in the number density of objects over the gaussian case that can not be attributed to the uncertainty in the mass determination . for a given uncertainty in the mass , this can be computed by using the standard press - schechter ( ps ) theory @xcite . observationally it is difficult to measure the mass of high - redshift clusters with accuracy better than 30% , with either weak lensing or the x - ray temperature , and of high - redshift galaxies better than a factor 2 ( @xmath51 ; at least of their stellar mass ) . although the calculations in this section are obtained using the standard ps theory , our conclusions will be essentially unchanged if we had used modified ps theories ( e.g. , ; see below ) . with the mass uncertainties discussed above , we obtain that the minimum @xmath50 that can not be attributed to @xmath49 is a factor 10 for clusters and a factor 100 for galaxies ( see , e.g. , fig . 6 of mvj00 ) . we therefore estimate the minimum @xmath19 that can be measured from the abundance of high - redshift objects as the one that corresponds respectively to a factor 100 and 10 change in the observed number density of objects ( @xmath21 ) over the gaussian case . this condition can be written as n_ng(m , z)/n(m , z)r(m , z)r _ * , where @xmath38 is obtained using the gaussian mass function while @xmath52 is obtained using the non - gaussian mass function as in mvj , and @xmath53 is set to be 100 for galaxies and 10 for clusters . for small primordial non - gaussianity ( i.e. , for small values for @xmath54 ) , it is possible to derive an expression for @xmath55 using the analytical approximation for the mass function @xmath56 found in mvj . doing so we find @xmath57f(m , z_c,\eps_{\rm a , b})dm } { \int_m^{\infty}(\sigma_mm)^{-1}\exp[-\frac{\delta_c^2(z_c ) } { 2\sigma_m^2}]\left|\frac{d\sigma_m}{dm}\right|dm}\;. \label{ratio}\ ] ] here , f(m , z_c,_a , b ) & = & | . + | , and _ * ( z_c)=_c(z_c ) , _ c(z_c)=_c / d(z_c ) , where @xmath58 is the linear - theory growth factor , and @xmath59 is the linear extrapolation of the over - density for spherical collapse . in the formulas above , @xmath60 denotes the primordial skewness , s_3,m=_a , b^(1)_3,m/^2_m , where the expressions for @xmath61 and @xmath62 can be found in mvj section 3.2 equations ( 37 ) and ( 38 ) . ( 90,55 ) however , for @xmath63 , the mass function @xmath64 has to be evaluated numerically and equation ( [ ratio ] ) is not valid . for the cosmological model considered here and the redshifts of interest , the quantity @xmath59 takes a nearly constant value ( @xmath65 ) in the ps theory . a better fit to the mass function of halos in high - resolution n - body simulations is however obtained by lowering @xmath59 for rare objects and giving it an extra mass and redshift dependence (; ) , as motivated by ellipsoidal collapse ( e.g. , ) . it is possible to understand the effect of a lower @xmath59 by the following argument . for rare fluctuations such as high - redshift objects one is probing the mass function above the knee . since the mass function drops very rapidly as @xmath66 increases we can approximate @xmath67 . it is then possible to obtain an analytic expression for @xmath68 if the primordial non - gaussianity is small : r(m , z_c ) | + | . for a given mass @xmath66 , @xmath69 slowly decreases when lowering @xmath59 , slightly damping the effect of non - gaussianity . for example when lowering @xmath59 from the value we assume here 1.686 , to the value @xmath70appropriate to fit the numerical mass function of for the range of masses and redshifts considered here@xmath69 decreases by less than a factor 2 . however this effect is compensated by the fact that , by lowering @xmath59 , objects are created more easily also with gaussian initial conditions , and it is therefore possible to consider objects of higher @xmath66 and/or @xmath23 , where the effect of non - gaussianity is bigger . in summary , the conclusions obtained by assuming @xmath71 will not be substantially modified . it is important to note that for model a , the primordial skewness has the same sign as @xmath72 , while for model b the primordial skewness has the opposite sign of that of @xmath73 . in detecting non - zero @xmath19 from cmb maps , the sign of the skewness does not influence the accuracy of the detection of non - gaussianity , but , when using the abundance of high - redshift objects the sign of the skewness matters . only a positively skewed primordial distribution will generate more high - redshift objects than predicted in the gaussian case . although a negatively skewed probability distribution will generate fewer objects than the gaussian case , a decrement might be difficult to attribute exclusively to a negatively skewed distribution . therefore in the following we will consider only negative @xmath73 and positive @xmath72 . showed that the size - temperature ( st ) distribution of clusters is fairly sensitive to the degree of primordial non - gaussianity . if clusters are created from rare gaussian peaks , the spread in formation redshift should be small and so should the scatter in the st distribution . conversely , if the probability distribution function has long non - gaussian tails , then clusters of a given mass we observe today should have a broader formation redshift distribution and thus a broader st relation . in , the non - gaussianity considered is a log - normal distribution ; it is not strictly equivalent to models a or b considered here . however , for small deviations from gaussianity , the two models can be identified if , for a given scale , they produce the same skewness in the density fluctuation field . we thus find that in the @xmath39cdm model the minimum @xmath7 and @xmath8 detectable with the st distribution method are @xmath74 and @xmath75 respectively . these estimates assume that the cosmology and @xmath76 are well known , but use only the local cluster data set of . of course , with improved observational data , the st method could probably yield stronger constraints . we find that the non - gaussianity of model a has a bigger effect on high - redshift galaxies than on high - redshift clusters . this can be understood for the following reason . for model a the skewness @xmath60 is approximately scale independent ( @xmath77 ) . thus , as found in mvj , the mass function for non - gaussian initial conditions is obtained from the ps mass function for gaussian initial conditions replacing @xmath78 . the effect of a non - zero skewness is therefore to lower the effective threshold for collapse thus allowing more objects to be created . for a given @xmath79 , @xmath80 is a monotonically decreasing function of @xmath81 . since galaxies can be observed at @xmath81 much bigger than that of clusters , the effect is bigger . on the other hand , clusters are better probes than galaxies for model b. in fact , for model b the induced skewness in the density field is scale dependent and the effect of non - gaussianity is roughly the same for galaxies with @xmath82 and clusters with @xmath83 . however since mass determinations are more accurate for clusters than for galaxies , we have @xmath84 : clusters are therefore better probes . in fig . [ figure2 ] we show the ratio @xmath85 ( cf . ( 5 ) ) for galaxies at redshift @xmath86 and 10 for @xmath87 ( model a , left panel ) and clusters at redshift @xmath88 and 3 for @xmath89 ( model b , right panel ) , as a function of @xmath66 . lines are plotted only for masses where , for gaussian initial conditions , one would expect to observe at least one object in the whole sky with the most conservative estimate ( see fig . [ figure1 ] ) . note that those high - redshift objects represent 3- to 5-@xmath90 peaks . if we now require @xmath91 , we deduce that the minimum detectable deviation from gaussian initial conditions will be @xmath92 ( from high - redshift galaxies ) and @xmath93 ( from high - redshift clusters ) . we also estimate that an uncertainty of 10% on @xmath76 would propagate into an uncertainty of 25% in @xmath8 ( from clusters ) and of 70% in @xmath7 ( from galaxies ) . the minimum @xmath8 detectable from high - redshift cluster abundances is much larger than the value that can be measured from the cmb ( @xmath94 to @xmath95 for planck data ) , while for @xmath72 , high - redshift galaxies are much better probes than the cmb , which can only detect @xmath96 . we therefore conclude that _ if _ future ngst or 30- to 100-m ground - based telescope observations of high - redshift galaxies yield a significant number of galaxies at @xmath97 _ and _ are able to determine their masses within a factor 2 , these observations will perform better than cmb maps in constraining primordial non - gaussianity of the form of model a with positive @xmath72 . conversely , forthcoming cmb maps will constrain deviations from gaussianity in the initial conditions much better than observations of high - redshift objects for model b ( with positive _ and _ negative value for @xmath73 ) and for model a with negative @xmath72 . the type of non - gaussianity of model b is particularly interesting because initial conditions set from standard inflation show deviations from gaussianity of this kind . in fact , it is possible to relate the two slow roll parameters , @xmath98 , \label{slowrollparam}\ ] ] to the non - gaussianity parameter @xmath73 . in equation ( [ slowrollparam ] ) @xmath99 is the planck mass , @xmath100 denotes the inflaton potential and @xmath101 and @xmath102 the first and second derivatives with respect to the scalar field . the skewness @xmath79 for @xmath103 , @xmath104 , can be evaluated following a similar calculation of , obtaining s_3,=2_b3[1+(n ) ] , where @xmath105 and weakly depends on @xmath106 if @xmath107 , but diverges for @xmath108 . for a scale - invariant matter density power spectrum , @xmath109 , @xmath110 , and so @xmath111 . we can then compare this expression with the value for the skewness parameter for the gravitational potential arising from inflation to infer the magnitude of @xmath73 . gangui et al . ( 1994 ) calculate the cmb skewness for the sach - wolfe effect @xmath112 in several inflationary models ; @xmath112 is related to @xmath113 by @xmath114 where @xmath115 . from this it follows that @xmath116 . the condition for slow roll from gangui et al . 1994 is @xmath117 ; thus , @xmath118 , and the relation to the slow - roll parameters is ( cf . , ) @xmath119 since this combination of the slow - roll parameters is different from the combination that gives the spectral slope @xmath106 of the primordial power spectrum ( @xmath120 ) , in principle , if @xmath73 could be measured with an error @xmath121 , it would be possible to determine the shape of the inflaton potential through eq . ( [ slowrollparam ] ) . however , from the present analysis , an error of @xmath73 of about an order of magnitude larger seems to be realistically achievable . .minimum @xmath122 and @xmath123 detectable form different observables and their sign when positive skewness is required for detection . for model a the primordial skewness has the same sign as @xmath7 , while for model b the primordial skewness has the opposite sign as @xmath8 . in detecting non - zero @xmath19 from cmb maps , the sign of the skewness does not influence the accuracy of the detection of non - gaussianity , but , when using the abundance of high - redshift objects it is robust to detect non - gaussianity that produces an excess rather than a defect in the number density . only a positively skewed primordial distribution will generate more high - redshift objects than predicted in the gaussian case . [ cols="<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] we considered two models for small primordial non - gaussianity , one in which the primordial density perturbation contains a term that is the square of a gaussian field ( model a ) , and one in which the primordial gravitational potential perturbation contains a term proportional to the square of a gaussian ( model b ) . the non - gaussianity of model b is precisely that arising in standard slow - roll inflation and in non - standard inflation , while model a more closely resembles the non - gaussianity that would be expected from topological defects . we investigated the relative sensitivities of several observables for testing for deviations from gaussianity : cmb , lss and high - redshift and/or massive objects ( e.g. , galaxies and clusters ) . the analytic tools developed above allow us to address the question of whether the abundance of currently known high - redshift objects can be accommodated within the framework of inflationary models for a given cosmology . recently has studied in detail the mass determination of the cluster ms1054 - 03 concluding that its mass lies in the range @xmath124 @xmath125 for @xmath126 ( similar to the independent mass estimates by , e.g. , and ) . as already pointed out by , for @xmath127 the expected number of objects like ms1054 - 03 in the survey area is @xmath128 ; i.e. , it must be a 3-@xmath90 fluctuation or larger . using the formalism we have described here , a primordial non - gaussianity parameterized by @xmath129 would be required to account for ms1054 - 03 as a @xmath130 fluctuation in the @xmath39cdm model described above . this value is much too large to be consistent with slow - roll inflation . our calculation shows that if such a non - gaussianity exists , it would be easily detectable from forthcoming cmb maps . lv and rj thank the caltech theoretical astrophysics group for hospitality . mk was supported in part by nsf ast-0096023 , nasa nag5 - 8506 , and doe de - fg03 - 92-er40701 . buchalter & kamionkowski<1999 > albrecht a. , stebbins a. , 1992 , , 68 , 2121 allen t. j. , grinstein b. , wise m. b. , 1987 , , 197 , 66 balbi a. et al . , 2000 , apjl , in press , astro - ph/0005124 bardeen j. m. , steinhardt p. j. , turner m. s. , 1983 , , 28 , 679 bode p. , bahcall n. a. , ford e. d. , ostriker j. , 2000 , , submitted bouchet f. r. , peter p. , riazuelo a. , sakellariadou m. , 2000 , /005022 a. , kamionkowski m. , 1999 , , 521 , 1 chiu w. a. , ostriker j. , strauss m. a. , 1998 , , 494 , 479 chodorowski m. j. , bouchet f. r. , 1996 , , 279 , 563 coles p. , moscardini l. , lucchin f. , matarrese s. , messina a. , 1993 , , 264 , 740 , 2000 , , 404 , 955 durrer r. , juskiewicz r. , kunz m. , uzan j. , 2000,0005087 . falk t. , rangarajan r. , srednicki m. , 1993 , , 403 , 1l fan z. , bardeen j. m. , 1992 , , uw - pt-92 - 11 gangui a. , martin j. , 2000 , , 313 , 323 gangui a. , lucchin f. , matarrese s. , mollerach s. , 1994 , , 430 , 447 gangui a. , 1994 , , 50 , 3684 guth a. , pi s .- y . , 1982 , , 464 , l11 hill c. t. , schramm d. n. , fry j. n. , 1989 , , 19 , 25 jaffe a. h. et al . , 2000 , 0007333 jenkins a. , frenk c. s. , white s. d. m. , colberg j. m. , cole s. , evrard a. e. , yoshida n. , 2000 , 0005260 kofman l. , pogosyan d. y. , 1988 , , 214 , 508 komatsu e. , spergel d. , 2000 , , submitted lange a. e. et al . , 2000 , astro - ph/0005004 lee j. , shandarin s. f. , 1998 , , 500 , 14 linde a. d. , mukhanov v. , 1997 , , 56 , 535 lokas e. l. , juszkiewicz r. , weinberg d. h. , bouchet f. r. , 1995 , , 274 , 744 luo x. , schramm d. n. , 1993 , , 408 , 33 luo x. , 1994 , , 427 , l71 matarrese s. , verde l. , jimenez r. , 2000 , , 541 , 10 mohr j. j. , reese e. d. , ellingson e. , lewis a. d. , evrard a. e. , 2000 , newmann d. m. , arnaud m. , 2000 , , in press , astro - ph/0005350 peebles p. j. e. , 1999a , , 510 , 523 peebles p. j. e. , 1999b , , 510 , 531 press w. h. , schechter p. , 1974 , , 187 , 425 robinson j. , gawiser e. , silk j. , 1999 , astro - ph/9805181 robinson j. , gawiser e. , silk j. , 2000 , , 532 , 1 salopek d. , bond j. r. , bardeen j. m. , 1989 , , 40 , 1753 salopek d. , 1999 , aip conf . 478 , 180 sheth r. , tormen g. , 1999 , , 308 , 119 sheth r. , mo h. j. , tormen g. , 1999 , /9907024 starobinski a. a. , 1982 , , 117b , 175 stirling a. j. , peacock j. a. , 1996 , , 283 , 99 sugiyama n. , 1995 , , 100 , 281 tran k. h. et al . , 2000 , , 522 , 39 turok n. , 1989 , , 63 , 2625 vachaspati t. , 1986 , , 57 , 1655 verde l. , heavens a. , 2000 , verde l. , wang l. , heavens a. f. , kamionkowski , 2000 , , 313 , 141 verde l. , kamionkowski m. , mohr j. j. , benson a. j. , 2000 , , astro - ph/0007426 vilenkin a. , 1985 , , 121 , 263 wang l. , kamionkowski m. , 2000 , , 61 , 063504 willick j. a. , 2000 , , 530 , 80 in this appendix we quote the expressions for the primordial bispectrum and skewness for the two non - gaussian models considered in this paper . the large - scale structure ( lss ) bispectrum for model a is ( e.g. vwhk00 ) b(*k*_1,*k*_2,*k*_3)=2_a p(k_1)p_(k_2)+cyc . where @xmath131 denotes the power spectrum . the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) bispectrum for model a is ( e.g. vwhk00 ) b__1_2_3 ( ^_1_2_3_0 0 0 ) + where @xmath132 denotes the cosmic microwave background power spectrum , @xmath133 denotes the radiation transfer function and @xmath134 denotes the wigner 3j symbol . the lss bispectrum for model b is ( e.g. vwhk00 ) b(*k*_1,*k*_2,*k*_3)+cyc . where is defined by @xmath135 where @xmath5 denotes the gravitational potential field . ] @xmath136 and @xmath137 denotes the matter transfer function . the cmb bispectrum for model b is ( e.g. , vwhk00 , ) : b__1_2_3=(^_1_2_3_0 0 0 ) + ( c__1c__2+cyc . ) the corresponding primordial skewness @xmath138 where @xmath6 denotes @xmath139 for the large - scale structure case and @xmath140 for the cosmic microwave background is easily obtained from the consideration that @xmath141 is given by : for lss and cmb respectively . for example in the large scale structure case , model a , for a power law power spectrum and in the absence of spatial filtering in the general case can easily be derived following the calculations of by setting @xmath142 and @xmath143 . ] we have that @xmath144 | we investigate the relative sensitivities of several tests for deviations from gaussianity in the primordial distribution of density perturbations . we consider models for non - gaussianity that mimic that which comes from inflation as well as that which comes from topological defects . the tests we consider involve the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) , large - scale structure ( lss ) , high - redshift galaxies , and the abundances and properties of clusters . we find that the cmb is superior at finding non - gaussianity in the primordial gravitational potential ( as inflation would produce ) , while observations of high - redshift galaxies are much better suited to find non - gaussianity that resembles that expected from topological defects . we derive a simple expression that relates the abundance of high - redshift objects in non - gaussian models to the primordial skewness . # 1#1 # 1 # 1#23.6pt + + cosmology : theory - galaxies - clusters of galaxies - large scale structures - cosmic microwave background - methods : analytical |
0712.1747 | devices in which organic molecules form the active element are taking an increasingly important place in solid state physics . these are the building blocks of the field of molecular electronics , whose potential applications underpin a vast number of technological areas . novel components for high - performance computers @xcite , highly sensitive chemical sensors @xcite , and disposable and wearable devices are among the many proposed applications . in addition the same set - up can be used for medical purposes , for instance in the detection of viruses @xcite or in the construction of a rapid and reliable protocol for dna sequencing @xcite . most of the progress originates from the recently achieved ability to construct single molecule junctions and to measure their transport properties . the experimental strategies for fabricating such devices include mechanically controllable break junctions @xcite , scanning tunneling spectroscopy @xcite , lithographically fabricated nanoelectrodes @xcite and colloid solutions @xcite . unfortunately most of these techniques are actually `` blind '' in the sense that the geometrical configuration of the device at the atomic scale is not known . for this reason it should not be surprising that different experiments for the same molecule yield conductances differing by of up to three orders of magnitude @xcite . in view of all these uncertainties _ ab initio _ quantum transport schemes for calculating the electrical response of a molecular device become crucial . the most common computational scheme for evaluating the electronic transport of a molecular device combines scattering theory in the form of the non - equilibrium green s function ( negf ) formalism @xcite , with an electronic structure method , the most widely used being density - functional theory ( dft ) @xcite . alternatives are time - dependent dft @xcite or many - body methods @xcite , which at present however are more computationally involved and are at an earlier stage of development as routinely used schemes . unfortunately for several molecules negf combined with dft appears to disagree with the experimental results . in particular it seems to systematically overestimate the current flowing across a device , even if one bears in mind the uncertainty over the detailed geometry of the junction . in the prototypical case of benzenedithiol ( bdt ) sandwiched between two gold electrodes , the conductance for the most probable contact geometry calculated with negf and dft is higher than that of _ any _ of the experiments by at least one order of magnitude @xcite . in this work we demonstrate that most of the errors originate from using local or semi - local exchange and correlation potentials in dft . this shortfall however can be corrected by applying an atomic self - interaction correction ( asic)@xcite scheme to the local functionals , leading to a dramatic improvement of the agreement between the calculated results and those obtained from experiments . the reason for this improvement is rooted in the ability of asic to predict the correct ionization potential of molecules , and hence to correctly describe the band alignment between the molecular orbitals and the fermi level , @xmath2 , of the metallic electrodes . here we extend the results previously published for bdt attached to the gold hollow site of the ( 111 ) surface @xcite to new molecules such as benzenedimethanethiol ( bdmt ) and biphenyldithiol ( bpd ) . we also carry out a thorough investigation of the effects of changing the anchoring geometry between the molecule and the electrodes , demonstrating that , for the case of bdt attached to gold , the asic calculated @xmath0-@xmath1 curves are rather stable with respect to geometry changes . this explains the relatively narrow distribution of conductance histograms found in experiments @xcite . the problem we wish to solve is that of calculating the two - probe @xmath0-@xmath1 curve of a molecule sandwiched in between two metallic electrodes . the negf scheme partitions such system into three regions , respectively the two current / voltage electrodes ( leads ) and a middle region called the scattering region ( sr ) ( see figure [ fig1 ] ) . the sr includes the molecule and a portion of the leads , which is extended enough for the charge density calculated at the most external atomic layer to resemble that of the bulk electrodes . the leads , assumed to be a periodic crystal in the direction of the transport , are kept at different chemical potentials @xmath3 where @xmath1 is the applied potential bias and @xmath4 is the electron charge . the sr is described by a hamiltonian @xmath5 , which is used to construct the non - equilibrium green s function , @xmath6 @xmath7^{-1}\ : , \label{negfmx}\ ] ] where @xmath8 are the self - energies for the leads . @xmath6 enters in a self - consistent procedure to calculate the density matrix , @xmath9 , of the sr , and hence the two probe - current of the device @xcite . the non - equilibrium @xmath9 is calculated following the negf prescription as @xmath10 g^{\dag}(e ) de \ : , \label{chdens}\ ] ] where @xmath11 $ ] . in practice , this integral is performed by splitting it into two parts@xcite : an equilibrium part which can be integrated along a contour in the complex plane , and a non - equilibrium part which has to be integrated along the real energy axis but which only contributes around @xmath2 . the non - equilibrium charge density @xmath9 is then used to calculate a new hamiltonian for the scattering region @xmath12 $ ] ( where it is assumed that the hamiltonian has some functional dependence on @xmath9 ) . this procedure is repeated self - consistently until the density matrix converges . finally , the converged green s function can be used to calculate the current @xmath0 through the device : @xmath13 ( f(e , \mu_\mathrm{1 } ) - f(e , \mu_\mathrm{2 } ) ) de \ : . \label{curint}\ ] ] this is effectively the integral between @xmath14 and @xmath15 ( the bias window ) of the transmission coefficients @xmath16 $ ] . in brief the negf scheme calculates the non - equilibrium scattering potential of the device . thus the transmission coefficient @xmath17 is simply a superposition of resonances located at the molecular single - particle energy levels , including a possible shift and broadening due to the interaction with the leads . it follows that the molecular levels close to the electrode fermi level , i.e. the highest highest occupied molecular orbital ( homo ) and the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital ( lumo ) , provide the dominant contribution to the current . it is therefore crucial to employ an electronic structure theory capable of describing the position of these two levels accurately . the negf scheme is general and not related to a particular electronic structure theory . however , since the transmission occurs through single - particle states , the associated electronic structure theory should meet several requirements @xcite . first of all , the single - particle levels must closely resemble the physical removal energies of the system , i.e. the energy levels of the molecule should line up correctly with the @xmath2 of the metals forming the electrodes . secondly , the theory should work at both integer and fractional occupation , ensuring the correct response of the molecular orbitals to changes in occupation due to the applied potential bias . finally , the matrix elements describing the interaction between the leads and the molecule should be calculated accurately avoiding the use of phenomenological parameters or fitting procedures . the kohn - sham ( ks ) form @xcite of dft is certainly the most widely used _ ab initio _ electronic structure theory associated with the negf method . in the ks scheme the dft problem of finding the ground state charge density is mapped onto that of solving a system of non - interacting single - particle schr " odinger equations @xmath18 \psi^{\sigma}_n({\bf r } ) = \epsilon^{\sigma}_n \psi^{\sigma}_n({\bf r } ) \ : , \label{kseqn}\ ] ] where @xmath19 is the hartree ( classical coulomb ) potential and @xmath20 is the exchange - correlation ( xc ) potential . the exact form of @xmath20 is unknown , so it is typically approximated by local functionals such as the local density approximation @xcite ( lda ) or the generalized gradient approximation @xcite ( gga ) . therefore the ks scheme is only a convenient prescription for minimizing the energy functional , and as such the individual ks eigenvalues do not necessarily correspond to physical energy levels of the system . the dft observables such as the total energy and the charge density are in fact only integral quantities respectively of the ks eigenvalues and eigenvectors . however , in solid state theory it is common to associate the ks energies with the system band structure . this , although it is not justified at the fundamental level , is supported by the practical evidence that ks bands represent a good first approximation of the true energies of a system , particularly for metals . however , there is a remarkable exception to the non - physical nature of the ks eigenvalues . in fact , the ks energy of the homo level ( @xmath21 ) can be rigorously associated with the negative of the ionization potential @xmath0 @xcite . similarly the homo ks energy for the negatively charged system can be associated with the chemical affinity @xmath22 . this suggests that , at least for moderate bias where the transport is through the homo , ks theory can be used effectively for transport calculations @xcite . unfortunately , standard local and semi - local functionals completely misplace @xmath21 , which is often nowhere near @xmath23 . this is particularly problematic for organic molecules , for which the lda @xmath21 is typically off from the experimental value of @xmath0 by approximately 4 ev @xcite . most of the failures of lda and gga can be traced back to the self - interaction ( si ) problem , i.e. the spurious interaction of an electron with the hartree and exchange - correlation ( xc ) potentials generated by itself @xcite . in the case of hartree - fock theory the self - hartree energy @xmath24 $ ] cancels exactly the self - xc energy @xmath25 $ ] @xmath26 + u[\rho^{\sigma}_n ] = 0 \ : , \label{exxhar}\ ] ] where we introduce the orbital density @xmath27 . however , this cancellation is incomplete for both lda and gga . the resulting ks potential therefore appears too repulsive and the eigenstates of a molecule are pushed to higher energies . when this is transferred to the transport problem , the position of the peaks in the transmission coefficient results are in the wrong place . in particular it is likely that peaks will erroneously move close to the fermi level of the electrodes , generating a large conductivity at zero bias . since the position of the peaks is ultimately determined by the interplay between the hopping probabilities from the electrodes to the molecule with the charging energy of the molecule itself , this failure is somewhat reminiscent of the inability of local and semi - local functionals to describe mott - hubbard insulators . perdew and zunger suggested @xcite that the self - interaction correction ( sic ) @xmath28 for an occupied ks orbital @xmath29 can be calculated from the sum of the self - hartree and self - xc energies @xmath30 + u[\rho^{\sigma}_n ] \ : . \label{siclda}\ ] ] note that , although here we consider the case of sic - lda only , the same procedure can be readily applied to any approximated functionals . the sic - lda xc energy @xmath31 is thus obtained by subtraction @xmath32 = e^\mathrm{lda}_\mathrm{xc}[\rho^{\uparrow } , \rho^{\downarrow } ] - \sum^\mathrm{occ.}_{n \sigma } \delta^\mathrm{sic}_n \ : , \label{sicen}\ ] ] and the sic - lda xc potential @xmath33 , to be subtracted from @xmath34 , is simply given by @xmath35 ; { \bf r})+v_\mathrm{xc}^{\mathrm{lda},\sigma}([\rho_n^\uparrow,0 ] ; { \bf r } ) \ ; , \label{sicpot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath36 ; { \bf r})=\int\mathrm{d}^3{\bf r}^\prime\frac{\rho({\bf r}^\prime)}{|{\bf r}-{\bf r}^\prime|}\ ; , \\ v_\mathrm{xc}^{\mathrm{lda},\sigma}([\rho^\uparrow,\rho^\downarrow ] ; { \bf r})=\frac{\delta}{\delta \rho^\sigma({\bf r } ) } e_\mathrm{xc}^\mathrm{lda}[\rho^\uparrow,\rho^\downarrow]\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the problem of finding the energy minimum is complicated by the fact that @xmath31 is not invariant under unitary rotations of the occupied ks orbitals , which instead leave @xmath9 invariant . this creates problem to the standard ks scheme since the theory becomes size - inconsistent . in order to avoid such a complication modern sic theory introduces a second set of orbitals @xmath37 related to the canonical ks orbitals @xmath29 by a unitary transformation @xmath38 @xmath39 the functional can then be minimized by varying both the ks orbitals and the unitary transformation @xmath38 , leading to the system of ks - like equations : @xmath40 \psi^{\sigma}_n({\bf r } ) = \epsilon^{\sigma , \mathrm{sic}}_n \psi^{\sigma}_n({\bf r } ) \ : , \label{siceqn}\ ] ] where @xmath41 is the lda hamiltonian , and the sic potential , @xmath42 , is given by : @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the projector @xmath45 . the numerical implementation of the full perdew - zunger sic scheme in typical solid state codes is cumbersome since the theory is orbital dependent and the energy minimization can not follow the standard ks scheme @xcite . when this is applied to transport there is the additional complication that the ks orbitals are never individually available and moreover that one has to deal with an intrinsically non - local potential . a drastic simplification of the problem can be obtained by using a recently implemented atomic approximation to the sic scheme , which we call the asic @xcite . this is based on the pseudo - sic approximation , originally proposed by vogel and coworkers @xcite , and later extended to non - integer occupation by filippetti and spaldin @xcite . the main idea is that of replacing the @xmath46 orbitals with atomic like functions , which are not calculated self - consistently . thus the si correction becomes atomic - like and no information is needed other than the charge density and the asic projectors @xcite . asic has been demonstrated to produce single - particle energy levels which match the experimental molecular removal energies quite well @xcite . in particular , for several different molecules investigated , @xmath47 , and the @xmath21 for negatively charged molecules is close to the molecular affinity @xcite . as an example , asic places @xmath21 for 1,2-bdt at -8.47 ev to compare with the lda value of -4.89 ev and the experimental ionization potential @xmath488.5 ev @xcite . asic is the scheme that we adopt in this work . local and semi - local functionals are affected by another fundamental problem , i.e. the lack of the derivative discontinuity ( dd ) in the dft energy . this is the discontinuity at integer occupation in the derivative of the total energy of a system @xmath49 with respect to its occupation @xmath50 @xcite . from janak s theorem it follows that there should be also a discontinuity in @xmath51 when going from @xmath50 to ( @xmath52 ) with @xmath53 . in a previous work @xcite , we have investigated the consequences of the absence of the dd in local xc functionals on the electronic transport of organic molecules . we have demonstrated that the dd can strongly affect the @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristics of metal - molecule - metal junctions when the coupling between the molecule and the metal is relatively weak . this would be the case , for instance , where molecules bind to adatoms on the metal surface . however , we have also shown that in the case of strong coupling the dd had little effect on the transport . the self - interaction error is largely responsible for the disappearance of the dd in local and semi - local functionals . it follows that sic methods restore the dd at least in part . this last aspect is deeply rooted in the orbital minimization needed to extract the sic potential , which unfortunately is not captured by our asic approximation . therefore the main feature of our asic methodology is simply the correction of the ionization potentials of the molecules @xcite , thus yielding a quantitatively realistic energy level alignment . hence , the calculations described in this paper investigate a second important aspect of the sic beside that of the dd . this is the quantitative description of the band alignment between the metal fermi energy and the molecular levels . in particular , for most of the paper we investigate molecules attached to the gold fcc ( 111 ) hollow sites , for which the coupling is expected to be strong and the effects due to the dd small . we have numerically implemented the asic method @xcite in the localized atomic orbital code siesta @xcite , which is the dft platform for our transport code _ smeagol _ @xcite , and carried out calculations for the prototypical au / benzene / au molecular devices . the asic corrections are not applied to the gold atoms , as si errors for metals are small @xcite . unless otherwise specified , we use a double zeta polarized basis set @xcite for carbon and sulfur @xmath54 and @xmath55 orbitals , double zeta for the 1@xmath54 orbitals of hydrogen and 6@xmath54-only double zeta for gold . the mesh cut - off is 200 ry and we consider 500 real and 80 complex energy points for integrating the green s function . calculations were also performed using double zeta 6@xmath54 and single zeta 5@xmath56 and 6@xmath55 orbitals for the gold to investigate the effect of an enlarged basis on the transport . results for calculations using both basis sets are shown , with the 6@xmath54-only basis used unless otherwise indicated . for geometry optimizations and total energy calculations , the extended 5@xmath566@xmath546@xmath55 basis set is employed , as the 6@xmath54-only does not yield enough accuracy . in calculating the @xmath0-@xmath1 curves , the potential bias was incremented in steps of 0.1 volts . we compare the electronic transport properties for three different molecules calculated either by using lda or asic . these are 1,4-benzenedithiol ( 1,4-bdt ) , benzenedimethanethiol ( bdmt ) , and biphenyldithiol ( bpd ) . the electronic transport through these molecules have already been investigated at length both experimentally and computationally @xcite . thus these offer us a unique benchmark for our calculations . in all cases , the molecule is attached via the sulfur atoms to fcc ( 111 ) gold electrodes on each side . in the case of bdt , we look at several different anchoring geometries . it is worth pointing out that although the exact anchoring geometry encountered in breaking junction experiments is unknown , the resulting conductance histograms are relatively narrow suggesting an intrinsic stability in the measurements @xcite . this may be an indication that similar anchoring configuration are highly probable in the breaking process , or alternatively that several anchoring geometries yield the same @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristic . one of our goals is to distinguish between these two possibilities . the first device which we consider is 1,4-benzenedithiol ( 1,4-bdt ) attached to two fcc ( 111 ) gold surfaces . the anchoring geometries for the sulfur atoms investigated are the hollow site , the top site , the bridge site , ( see figure [ fig3 ] ) , as well as asymmetric configurations where the s ions are attached to an adatom on one side and to the hollow site on the other . we also examine the effect of altering the angle which the molecule makes with the metal surface , and of varying the distance between the sulfur atom and the surface ( i.e. varying the strength of the coupling between the molecule and the metal ) . finally , we investigate the effect of hydrogenating the thiol groups . as explained previously the actual experimental contact geometry is unknown . electronic structure calculations indicate that the lowest energy configuration for the molecule on the ( 111 ) surface occurs when the s atom attaches to the hollow site , although other calculations suggest that the bridge site configuration has a lower energy @xcite . recent x - ray standing wave measurements suggest that molecules in monolayers prefer to attach to adatoms on the metal surface @xcite . it is also worth noticing that in breaking junctions the actual geometry might be different from any equilibrium geometries , since the system is likely to be under strain . hence , a thorough analysis of this system should comprise many different configurations . we start by attaching bdt at the au ( 111 ) hollow site ( see figures [ fig3 ] and [ fig4 ] ) . the distance of the sulfur atom from the plane of the gold surface ( the `` sulfur - surface separation '' , @xmath57 , shown in figure [ fig3]a ) is optimized ( using the 5@xmath566@xmath546@xmath55 basis set for gold ) to a value of 1.9 . this corresponds to a distance of 2.53 between the sulfur atoms and the nearest gold atoms on the surface in good agreement with previous calculations @xcite . the @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristic , the orbital resolved density of states ( dos ) and the conductance as a function of energy , @xmath58 , are presented in figure [ fig5 ] . the conductance is plotted in units of @xmath59 , so that it is equivalent to the transmission coefficients @xmath60 . lda results are shown in the left panels , while the asic ones are on the right . from the dos it is clear that the effect of asic is that of shifting the occupied orbitals downwards in energy relatively to the @xmath2 of gold . the asic homo - lumo gap is considerably larger than that calculated with lda and most importantly in the case of asic there is little dos originating from the molecule at @xmath2 . this has profound effects on the electron transmission . the lda peaks of @xmath17 arising from occupied orbitals are shifted downwards in energy and away from @xmath2 . at variance from lda ( figure [ fig5]c ) , where @xmath61 is dominated by a resonance at @xmath62 , the asic transmission ( figure [ fig5]d ) is through the bdt gap and therefore it is tunneling - like . this results in a drastic reduction of the low - bias current when going from lda to asic ( figure [ fig5]e ) . the asic - calculated conductance at zero bias is now about 0.06@xmath63 ( @xmath64 ) , compared to 0.23@xmath63 for lda . a conductance of 0.06@xmath63 is much closer to the value of 0.011@xmath63 obtained by xiao et . @xcite and is actually lower than values 0.09 - 0.14@xmath63 obtained by tsutsui et . @xcite . without altering the anchoring geometry , the basis set on the gold atoms is then changed to include the 5@xmath56 and 6@xmath55 orbitals . the relative orbital resolved dos , transmission coefficients and @xmath0-@xmath1 curves are presented in figure [ fig6 ] for both lda and asic . clearly the enriched basis set does not have a large effect on the electronic transport , particularly at low bias . as can be seen from figure [ fig6]e , the @xmath0-@xmath1 curves calculated with the 6@xmath54-only basis set for gold are approximately the same as that calculated with the 5@xmath566@xmath546@xmath55 basis set up to about 1 volt for both the lda and asic . differences appear only at high bias ( @xmath65 volt ) and are due to the presence of au @xmath56 electrons in an energy range comprising the bias window . however the zero - bias conductances , from the transmission plots in panels ( c ) and ( d ) of figure [ fig6 ] , are very similar to those for the 6@xmath54-only basis set with a value of 0.21@xmath63 for lda and a value of 0.06@xmath63 for asic . this demonstrates that the 6@xmath54-only basis set should give reasonably reliable results for electronic transport at low bias . next , the transport properties of the system are calculated for the hollow site at different @xmath57 , as well as for the equilibrium distance @xmath66 but different angles of the molecule with respect to the direction of transport . the results are reported in figure [ fig7 ] . in general asic seems to be much less sensitive to changes in the anchoring geometry than lda , particularly for the case of bond stretching . for instance , the zero bias conductance values calculated with lda are 0.16 @xmath63 , 0.23 @xmath63 , 0.32 @xmath63 and 0.77 @xmath63 for @xmath57 values of 1.8 , 1.9 , 2.1 and 2.5 respectively . for the same @xmath57 asic returns 0.05 @xmath63 , 0.06 @xmath63 , 0.07 @xmath63 , and 0.14 @xmath63 . the stability of the asic @xmath0-@xmath1 curve with respect the details of the anchoring geometry of the hollow site is an interesting feature , since it is suggesting that in breaking junction experiments several different anchoring configurations may yield similar @xmath0-@xmath1 curves . this is consistent with the relatively narrow peaks measured in the typical conductance histograms @xcite . lda does not seem to have this property and in fact the zero - bias conductance increases quite drastically when @xmath57 is increased . while counterintuitive , this is consistent with previous results @xcite , and it is due to the realignment of the homo of the molecule to @xmath2 of gold . such a feature is investigated in more detail in figure [ fig8 ] where we report the zero - bias @xmath17 for different @xmath57 . when @xmath57 is increased , the transmission peaks corresponding to molecular orbitals become narrower , as expected , due to the weakened molecule - lead coupling . however , charge transfer between the molecule and the metal is also affected , so that the charge on the actual molecule slightly increases as @xmath57 gets larger . this extra charge produces an electrostatic shift of the homo level towards the au fermi energy . as a consequence the narrowing of the resonance peak at the homo level is compensated by the upwards shift of the same peak , resulting in an enhancement of the zero - bias conductance . when asic is used this feature is strongly suppressed . in fact , the asic calculated transmission peaks are narrower and further away from @xmath2 that their lda counterparts . thus , although also for asic the molecular homo realigns with respect to the au fermi level , this is is not enough to produce high transmission at reasonable @xmath57 . note that a similar realignment is expected for weaker binding anchoring geometries which we will investigate in the remainder of this section ( see figures [ fig9]b , [ fig11 ] , [ fig12 ] and [ fig14 ] ) the second contact geometry investigated is that where the s atom is connected to the bridge site on the fcc ( 111 ) au surface at both of the electrodes ( figure [ fig3]b ) . total energy dft calculations suggest that this configuration ( @xmath67 ) , has a lower energy than that of the hollow site @xcite . we calculate a lda zero bias conductance for the bridge site of 0.1 @xmath63 , which is lower than the value of 0.23 @xmath63 obtained for the hollow site . this can be seen from the @xmath0-@xmath1 curves presented in figure [ fig9]a . interestingly this lower conductance found for the bridge site with respect to the hollow site is a low - bias feature and the two @xmath0-@xmath1 curves matches closely for @xmath68 volt . the effect of asic on the transmission of the bridge site configuration is rather similar to that on the hollow site . also in this case the molecular homo - lumo gap opens and the current gets suppressed . the zero bias conductance for the bridge site is calculated to be 0.06 @xmath63 , the same value found for the hollow site . hence , whether the molecule is anchored to the hollow site or to the bridge site makes relatively little difference to the low - bias transport properties as obtained with asic . this further confirms that our asic calculations are certainly more compatible than their lda counterparts with the relative stability of the experimental conductance histograms . the top site of the au fcc ( 111 ) surface ( figure [ fig3]b ) is the next anchoring site to be investigated . the equilibrium distance @xmath57 is 2.39 and the calculated @xmath0-@xmath1 curves are presented in figure [ fig9]b . this time both lda and asic present @xmath0-@xmath1 characteristics with much higher conductance than that associated with the hollow site . this is particularly dramatic for lda for which the zero - bias conductance goes from 0.23 @xmath63 for the hollow to 0.65 @xmath63 for the top site . for asic the increase is only twofold with the zero bias conductance going from 0.06 @xmath63 to 0.12 @xmath63 . also for this case the general increase in current can be correlated with the larger au - s bond - length of the top site compared to the hollow site . this has the same effect found when analyzing the hollow site under strain and it is due to the realignment of the homo of bdt to @xmath2 of gold . it is important to point out that the top site is less energetically favorable than both the bridge and the hollow sites . although it can still play a role in breaking junctions , we believe that this may be only of secondary importance and therefore would not have a considerable influence on the typical conduction histograms . in actual breaking junctions , the electrodes are under strain and so the thiol groups are less likely to attach to a regular surface site . for instance in figure [ fig10 ] we present the case where one electrode connects to the molecule via the hollow site ( @xmath66 ) and the other via a gold adatom , with a distance of 2.39 between the sulfur and the adatom . recent x - ray standing wave experiments @xcite demonstrate that gold adatoms may be the most favorable sites for the thiol groups in self - assembled molecular monolayer . this therefore may be a likely configuration for the bottom electrode in a stm - break junction . the orbital resolved dos , transmission coefficients and @xmath0-@xmath1 curves for this system are presented in figure [ fig11 ] . this configuration shows the largest difference between the conductance calculated with lda and that calculated with asic . the lda conductance is 0.32 @xmath63 , whereas when asic is applied this drops by a order of magnitude to 0.03 @xmath63 . because of the weaker interaction between the @xmath69 orbitals of the molecule and the gold surface , the molecular orbitals in the dos ( figure [ fig11]a and figure [ fig11]b ) and hence the peaks in the transmission coefficients ( figure [ fig11]c and figure [ fig11]d ) are considerably narrower than for the case of the hollow site . these narrow levels are however closer to @xmath2 , resulting in the relatively high conductance at low bias . this originates from the same mechanism producing a change in conductance when @xmath57 is increased ( see figure [ fig8 ] ) . at variance with the case of stretched hollow bonding geometry , this time the asic does not shift the conductance peaks enough to bring them close to the fermi level of gold , and the conductance remains rather small . as the peaks in the transmission are rather narrow we checked our results against the choice of basis set . in figure [ fig12 ] we present the orbital resolved dos , transmission coefficients and @xmath0-@xmath1 curves for the enlarged 5@xmath566@xmath546@xmath55 basis , to be put in perspective with those calculated with 6@xmath54 only in figure [ fig11 ] . the most notable difference is the appearance of transmission away from @xmath2 , in particular at low energies . this is connected to the gold @xmath56 electrons , which are neglected in the small basis . importantly however the low - energy features around @xmath2 are only slightly affected with the zero - bias conductance assuming values of 0.47 @xmath63 and 0.05@xmath70 for lda and asic respectively . this confirms the feasibility of using a restricted basis set for the @xmath0-@xmath1 curve at low bias . finally , we investigate two more configurations . the first considers adatoms as the bonding site at both sides of the junction ( figure [ fig13 ] ) , while the second investigates hollow sites where the two hydrogens of the thiol groups are not dissociated in forming thiolate as in all the other cases studied ( figure [ fig15 ] ) . in the first case we expect a rather weak bond , which is confirmed by the sharp peaks in transmission shown in figure [ fig14 ] . the lda low - bias conductance , calculated with the 5@xmath566@xmath546@xmath55 basis for gold , is 0.43 @xmath63 , which drops to 0.19 @xmath63 when asic is applied . in this case the molecular homo is pinned at @xmath2 and the transmission remains large . interestingly this is a situation similar to the one we discussed in our previous work in the context of tight - binding hamiltonian @xcite . in this case the suppression of the conductance may further originate from the derivative discontinuity of the potential , which may move the peak in the conductance away from @xmath2 . since this is not described by the asic scheme , we believe that the current in this case may be erroneously large . the results for the case where bdt is attached to the hollow sites but hydrogen atoms remain attached to thiol anchoring groups are presented in figure [ fig16 ] . the total energy for this situation is 1.47 ev higher than that obtained when the end groups are thiolate and the remaining two h atoms form a h@xmath71 molecule . as can be seen from the dos in panels ( a ) and ( b ) and the transmission coefficients in panels ( c ) and ( d ) , the transport is now through the lumo of the system , the energy of which is lowered only slightly by asic . hence , the asic zero - bias conductance of 0.09 @xmath63 is higher than the value of 0.06 @xmath63 calculated with lda . however it is important to note that the small , but significant , downshift of the lumo state caused by asic is only an artifact of our atomic approximation to sic . as an empty state , the sic for the lumo is not defined and no corrections should be applied . the second device studied consists of a benzenedimethanethiol ( bdmt ) molecule attached to two gold fcc ( 111 ) surfaces . two different isomers of are investigated ; in the first the sulfur atoms of the thiol groups lie in the same plane of the benzene ring ( figure [ fig17]a ) , while in the second they are aligned out of plane ( figure [ fig17]b ) . in both cases they anchor the molecule to the hollow site of the gold fcc ( 111 ) surface . the orbital resolved dos , transmission coefficients and @xmath0-@xmath1 curves for the first isomer are presented in figure [ fig18 ] for both lda and asic . in this case , as one can see from the orbital resolved density of states ( figures [ fig18]a and [ fig18]b ) , the homo - lumo gap is much larger than that of bdt . the asic again has the effect of shifting the occupied orbitals downwards in energy , but this has little effect on the transport since the resonances in the transmission coefficients due the homo and lumo lie well outside the bias region investigated . therefore , asic increases the homo - lumo gap but the actual transmission coefficient around @xmath2 does not change much from its lda value . the asic conductance at zero bias is calculated to be 0.004@xmath63 , compared to 0.006@xmath63 obtained with lda only . both these values are one order of magnitude larger than the experimental value of 0.0006@xmath63 obtained by xiao et . it also follows that the @xmath0-@xmath1 curves ( figures [ fig18]e and [ fig18]f ) obtained with lda and asic respectively are quite similar . the @xmath0-@xmath1 curve calculated for the second isomer is presented in figure [ fig19 ] . also in this case the effects of asic are minimal due to the large homo - lumo gap . the conductance at zero bias is calculated to be 0.015@xmath63 with lda , compared to the value of 0.013@xmath63 for asic . interestingly this is about a factor 3 larger than that calculated for the first isomer . in general , in contrast to the case of bdt , for bdmt asic does not appear to improve the agreement between theory and experiments . the fact that the fermi level of au is pinned in the middle of the large homo - lumo gap of bdmt , which is already well described by lda , makes the asic corrections rather marginal to transport at moderate voltages . given the fact that the geometry of the anchoring is not known and that we have only investigated one case , we may conclude that the disagreement between theory and experiments may simply lie in the details of the anchoring geometry . the third and final system investigated is that of biphenyldithiol ( bpd ) attached to two gold surfaces as shown in figure [ fig20 ] . once again we consider only the gold fcc ( 111 ) hollow site as the anchoring site . the planes of the two benzene rings are usually tilted with respect to each other by an angle known as the torsion angle , that in this case is calculated to be 37@xmath72 . the orbital resolved dos , transmission coefficients and @xmath0-@xmath1 curves for this system are presented in figure [ fig21 ] for both lda and asic . once again , asic has the effect of lowering the energy of the occupied molecular orbitals , as can be seen from the dos ( panels ( a ) and ( b ) ) . this in turn results in opening up the conductance gap in the transmission as shown in panels ( c ) and ( d ) of figure [ fig21 ] . for this molecule , the homo is near @xmath2 as in the case of bdt , giving a lda conductance of 0.07@xmath63 at zero bias . when asic is applied , the homo is shifted downwards in energy and outside the bias window for voltages up to 2 volt . in this case the asic conductance drops to 0.018@xmath63 at @xmath2 and the whole low bias @xmath0-@xmath1 curve shows rather smaller current with respect to its lda counterpart . the optimum torsion angle is @xmath73@xcite . however , this may fluctuate due to temperature or when the molecule is under strain in a breaking junction . panel ( e ) of figure [ fig21 ] shows the @xmath0-@xmath1 curves calculated for the equilibrium torsion angle of @xmath73 , whereas panel ( f ) shows the result for the case when the benzene rings are in the same plane ( i.e. when the torsion angle is @xmath74 ) . reducing the torsion angle causes an increase in the transmission since the overlap between the @xmath69 orbitals is increased . the conductance at zero bias for a torsion angle of @xmath74 is 0.09@xmath63 with lda only , and 0.024@xmath63 when asic is applied . these results show that asic has an effect on bpd similar to the one it has on bdt , i.e. it shifts the homo downwards in energy and reduces the zero - bias conductance . in this case however even our asic results differ from the experimental data of dadosh et . @xcite by several orders of magnitude . since we are essentially in a tunneling situation , the magnitude of the current is severely dependent on the tunneling matrix elements , which in turn are rather sensitive to the details of the anchoring geometry . although the hollow site is believed to be the preferential site , such a large discrepancy between theory and experiments could be attributed to the contact geometry . in view of the many contradictory results for the transport properties of molecular junctions , first principles computational tools are becoming increasingly important . these , however , also suffer from some uncertainty in the results , rooted in the approximations used for computing the junction electronic structure . in this work , we have addressed the problem of the self - interaction error in dft and we demonstrate how a simple self - interaction correction scheme can be used to improve the agreement between theory and experiments . in particular , we have considered the problem of correctly reproducing the molecular ionization potential as the negative of the single particle kohn - sham homo energy . our asic scheme is capable of achieving such a description , and for most of the molecules investigated this has the effect of moving conductance resonances away from the fermi level of the electrodes . thus , molecular junctions with zero bias resonant transport through the homo become insulating when calculated with asic . we then investigated transport through bdt attached to the gold ( 111 ) surfaces in several different anchoring geometries . in general , we have found a systematic reduction of the low bias current when asic is applied . most importantly , we have demonstrated that a number of anchoring geometries all yield similar low bias conductivities , which in most cases are rather insensitive to bond stretching or bond angle changes . this suggests that several anchoring geometries might contribute to the peaks in the typical experimental conductance histograms , thus providing a natural explanation for their stability . nevertheless , even with asic , some problems still remain . in general , if the first molecular orbital to enter the bias window as the bias increases is the lumo , then our method potentially fails . in fact , asic only partially restores the dft derivative discontinuity , and erroneously @xmath75 . since the size of the derivative discontinuity is unknown , it is difficult at this time to evaluate the impact of such an error . a second problem is connected to the accuracy of the calculation of the wave - functions . when no molecular levels appear at the fermi level , the transport is essentially tunneling like , and therefore becomes crucially dependent on the accuracy of the calculated hopping integrals between the molecule and the electrodes . asic does not drastically improve the quality of the lda wave - function and thus one might expect some errors in the tunneling transmission coefficients . additionally , we do not correct the surface atoms of the electrodes for si , so it is expected that our asic results in general produce overextended orbitals and hence a systematically overestimated current . finally , it is worth noting that asic still overestimates the polarizability of molecules @xcite , with a quantitatively incorrect prediction of the response exchange and correlation field . the use of xc potentials constructed from exact charge densities @xcite which correct both the molecule and the metallic surfaces may offer a solution to these problems . however , for some of the molecules investigated the disagreement between theory and experiments is still of several orders of magnitude . this is difficult to associate with any systematic error in the theory , and might be connected to the specific contact geometry . in conclusion , negf combined with the asic electronic structure method offers a description of transport through molecules which is considerably improved with respect to standard negf lda / gga . since this is also a computationally undemanding scheme , it can be employed for large systems , and therefore can become an important tool for systematically predicting the performance of molecular junctions . we thank alex reily rocha , chaitanya pemmaraju , kieron burke and alessio filippetti for useful discussions . this work is funded by science foundation of ireland ( grant sfi02/in1/i175 ) . computational resources have been provided by the hea iitac project managed by the trinity center for high performance computing and by ichec . + j. lagerqvist , m. zwolak and m. di ventra , nano letters * 6 * , 779 ( 2006 ) ; m. zwolak and m. di ventra , nano letters * 5 * , 421 ( 2005 ) ; r. zikic , p.s . krstic , x .- zhang , m. fuentes - cabrera , j. wells and x. zhao , phys . e * 74 * , 011919 ( 2006 ) . hettler , w. wenzel , m.r . wegewijs and h. schoeller , phys . lett . * 90 * , 076805 ( 2003 ) ; p. delaney and j.c . greer phys . * 93 * , 036805 ( 2004 ) ; b. muralidharan , a.w . ghosh , and s. datta , phys . b , * 73 * , 155410 ( 2006 ) ; s .- h . ke , h.u . baranger , and w. yang , j. chem . phys . * 126 * , 201102 ( 2007 ) ; k.s . thygesen and a. rubio , j. chem . * 126 * , 091101 ( 2007 ) . a rigorous demonstration that ks orbitals can be used as single particle states for electronic transport is still not available . for an extensive discussion see m. koentopp , k. burke and f. evers , phys . b rapid comm . * 73 * , 121403 ( 2006 ) ; g. stefanucci , s. kurth , e.k.u . gross , and a. rubio , cond - mat/0607333 ; g. stefanucci , phys . rev . b * 75 * , 195115 ( 2007 ) . | in transport calculations for molecular junctions based on density functional theory the choice of exchange and correlation functional may dramatically affect the results . in particular local and semi - local functionals tend to over - delocalize the molecular levels thus artificially increasing their broadening . in addition the same molecular levels are usually misplaced with respect to the fermi level of the electrodes . these shortfalls are reminiscent of the inability of local functionals to describe mott - hubbard insulators , but they can be corrected with a simple and computationally undemanding self - interaction correction scheme . we apply such a scheme , as implemented in our transport code _ smeagol _ , to a variety of phenyl - based molecular junctions attached to gold electrodes . in general the corrections reduce the current , since the resonant kohn - sham states of the molecule are shifted away from the contact fermi level . in contrast , when the junction is already described as insulating by local exchange and correlation potentials , the corrections are minimal and the @xmath0-@xmath1 is only weakly modified . |
1512.04118 | articulated pose estimation from a static image remains a challenge in computer vision . the difficulty lies in the wide variations in the appearance of object due to articulated deformations . therefore , an effective method generally relies on strong appearance models and expressive spatial models to capture the variations . more importantly , these models should be incorporated into a sensible framework where correct poses do enjoy relatively high likelihood . there has been great progress in developing appearance and spatial models . histogram of gradient ( hog ) @xcite was widely used as the part descriptor . however , hog is rather weak and introduces visual ambiguities @xcite . recently , deep convolutional neural networks ( dcnns ) have demonstrated excellent performance in building appearance models for object detection @xcite and human pose estimation @xcite . compared with a shallow classifier with hand - crafted features , dcnns have the capacity of learning more discriminative features . as for the spatial models , tree - structured model wins popularity by enjoying a simplified representation of object shape . in this model , parts are connected with tree edges modeled as elastic springs . on top of such model , various formulations have been proposed . @xcite designed pictorial structure to combine appearance and spatial terms in a generative way . discriminatively trained method is more powerful , and easily adapts to extended deformable part models ( dpms ) with mixture of parts @xcite and hierarchical representations @xcite . there are efforts to go beyond the tree structure : @xcite proposes a loopy model that contains composite parts implemented by poselets @xcite ; @xcite treat all the other parts as the neighbors of a target part ; grammar model has also been proposed to generalize the tree structure @xcite . as nonparametric spatial models , exemplars are also effective in part localization problems @xcite , as an ensemble of labeled samples ( i.e. , exemplars ) literally capture plausible part configurations without assuming the distribution of part relations . however , the exemplar - based models have not shown much efficacy in human pose estimation due to degraded expressiveness of limited training samples @xcite . in our work , we improve the expressiveness of exemplar - based models by leveraging hierarchy and composite parts : each composite part is treated as an object , with exemplars dictating the configuration of its child parts . by doing so , we obtain exemplar - based models covering a spectrum of granularity . in addition , we propose a novel formulation that captures the interactions between object parts in two aspects : spatial relations between parts at the same granularity level are inferred by dcnns ( inspired by @xcite ) , and constrained by exemplar - based models at that level ; spatial relations between parts at different levels follow the parent - child relations in the hierarchy , which are well maintained in the bottom - up inference through exemplars . these efforts together allow us to only model the part relations in each layer via dcnns without impairing the strength of the method . in some sense , our formulation is tailored for exemplar - based inference , which differs from other hierarchical models such as multi - layer dpms . also note that we use grouped parts to optimize the individual parts jointly , which differs from @xcite . our method features a hierarchical representation of object . we will first describe the relevant notations and introduce hierarchical exemplars . then we will explain our formulation of pose estimation . in the end , a comparison with relevant techniques will be addressed . a hierarchical object ( exemplar ) contains two types of parts : _ atomic part _ and _ composite part_. an atomic part @xmath0 is at the finest level of granularity , and can be annotated as a keypoint with pixel location @xmath1 ( e.g. , elbow ) . a composite part @xmath2 is the composite of its child parts ( e.g. , arm = \{sholder , elbow , wrist } ) , and is denoted as a tight bounding box @xmath3 containing all the child parts inside . in our work , a _ part configuration _ @xmath4 is denoted as the locations of atomic parts @xmath5 $ ] where @xmath6 is the total number of atomic parts . now , we define the _ spatial relation _ between parts of the same type . for atomic parts @xmath0 and @xmath7 , their offset @xmath8 characterizes the relation @xmath9 ( e.g. , shoulder is @xmath10 pixels above the elbow ) . for composite parts @xmath2 and @xmath11 , we first assign anchor points @xmath12 and @xmath13 to them . anchor points are manually determined such that they are relatively rigid w.r.t the articulated deformation . then we represent the relation @xmath14 as @xmath15 $ ] , where @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the top - left and bottom - right corners of part bounding box ( please see fig . [ fig : instant](a ) ) . the hierarchical representation follows a tree structure , as shown in fig . [ fig : instant](a ) . each leaf node denotes an atomic part . a node @xmath2 at level @xmath18 corresponds to a composite part @xmath19 the union of its children at level @xmath20 which are denoted as @xmath21 . the degree of the tree is not bounded , and the structure of the tree depends on the particular object category . a general rule is : geometrically neighboring parts ( at the same level ) can form a part at an upper level if their spatial relations can be captured by the training data . [ fig : instant](b ) shows the instantiation of hierarchical representation for human and bird . as the bird body is relatively more rigid than the human body , the degrees of bird s internal nodes can be larger , resulting in fewer levels . the exemplars in previous works @xcite correspond to a depth-2 hierarchy , where all the atomic parts are the children of the unique composite part ( i.e. , root part ) . as a result , each exemplar models the relations between all the atomic parts , making the ensemble of training exemplars not capable of capturing unseen poses . our hierarchical exemplars , however , adapt to a hierarchy with larger depth which gives us multiple composite parts . by treating each composite part as a standalone object , we have exemplars only modeling the spatial relations between its child parts ( which are referred to as part pose ) . we use @xmath22 to denote the set of exemplar - based models for all the composite parts , where @xmath2 is the index , and @xmath23 denotes the level . by design , the hierarchical exemplars cover a spectrum of granularity with proper decomposition of the object , which dramatically improves the expressiveness of exemplars . note that the depth had better not go too large , as we still want to make use of the strength of exemplars in constraining the configurations of more than two parts . we define an energy function to score a configuration @xmath4 given an image @xmath24 and the spatial models @xmath25 : @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the appearance term , @xmath28 is the spatial term , and @xmath29 is the bias parameter . our goal is to find the best configuration @xmath30 . , @xmath14 ) between sibling parts . the black dots on level @xmath31 denote the anchor points . ( b ) the instantiations of part hierarchy on human and bird . the part levels increase from the left to the right . each figure shows the parts at the same level with the same color ( except for the atomic parts ) . immediate children are also plotted for level @xmath31 and above . the stars mark the anchor points for the composite parts . ] * appearance terms : * @xmath32 is a weighted combination of the detection scores for each atomic part : @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the weight parameter , @xmath35 scores the presence of part @xmath0 at the location @xmath1 based on the local image patch ( eq . [ eq : app_level1 ] ) , and @xmath36 denotes the level-@xmath37 scaling factor based on @xmath4 s size . as we use sliding - window paradigm for detection , the local image patch is expected to fit the object size and the part s level . * spatial terms : * we design multi - level spatial terms to evaluate the part relations . assuming there are @xmath38 levels in the object hierarchy , and there are @xmath39 parts at the @xmath23-th level , then @xmath40 is defined as @xmath41 where @xmath42 denotes the bounding box of part @xmath19 , @xmath43 denotes the pose of @xmath19 , @xmath44 denotes the corresponding spatial models , and @xmath45 scores @xmath43 based on both appearance and spatial models . note that @xmath43 is defined as the spatial relations between the children of @xmath19 . we now elaborate the derivation of @xmath45 . using exemplar - based models , we can assume @xmath44 contains @xmath46 exemplars @xmath47 , each of which dictates a particular pose @xmath48 ( e.g. , an example of raised arm ) . here , we drop the subscript @xmath2 and superscript @xmath23 for clarity . with these in hand , we evaluate @xmath45 as the combination of two terms : @xmath49 where @xmath50 and @xmath51 are the weight parameters , @xmath52 ( corresponding to exemplar @xmath53 ) is the pose that best fits @xmath43 . @xmath54 evaluates the likelihood of pose @xmath52 being present in the image region at @xmath42 ( eq . [ eq : app_level2 ] , [ eq : app_level2plus ] ) . the relevant image patches also need to be resized as eq . [ eq : app_score ] . @xmath55 measures the similarity between @xmath43 and @xmath52 as @xmath56 where @xmath57 denotes the operation of similarity transformation ( the rotation angle is constrained ) , @xmath58 denotes the vectorized locations of parts @xmath21 in @xmath4 , and @xmath59 denotes the vectorized @xmath53 . as multi - scale image cues and multi - level spatial models are both involved , @xmath45 covers part relations at different levels of granularity . for instance , at a fine scale ( small @xmath23 ) , it evaluates whether the arm is folded ; at a coarse scale ( large @xmath23 ) , it evaluates whether the person is seated . we make independence assumption on the spatial models in eq . [ eq : geo_score ] , which can benefit articulated pose estimation . the reason lies in that it gives us a collection of spatial models that can better handle rare poses . for instance , our models allow a person to exhibit arbitrarily plausible poses at either arm as long as the spatial relations between the two arms are plausible . with such assumption , our formulation still captures the part relations thoroughly and precisely : the relations between sibling parts are encoded explicitly in eq . [ eq : geo_term ] ; the relations between parent and child parts are implicitly enforced ( the same @xmath4 is referred to across the levels ) . below , we address the differences between our method and relevant techniques , such as image dependent spatial relations @xcite and hierarchical models @xcite : * unlike @xcite , our method infers from the image the spatial relations between atomic parts ( e.g. , elbow and shoulder ) , as well as the relations between composite parts ( e.g .. upper body and lower body ) . * unlike @xcite , we do not conduct the selection of spatial models upfront as errors in this step are hard to correct afterwards . instead , our selection of spatial models is based on the configuration under evaluation ( the second term in eq . [ eq : geo_term ] ) , which avoids pruning the model space too aggressively . * unlike @xcite , our method directly optimizes on the atomic part locations , avoiding the interference from localizing the composite parts . also , we turn to exemplars to constrain the part relations , rather than using piece - wisely stitched `` spring models '' . the optimization of eq . [ eq : overall_opt ] does not conform to general message passing framework due to the dependency of @xmath52 on @xmath4 ( eq . [ eq : geo_term ] ) and the interactions between variables @xmath60 across multiple levels ( eq . [ eq : geo_score ] ) . therefore , we propose an algorithm ( algorithm [ alg : opt ] ) which simplifies the evaluation of eq . [ eq : geo_score ] . although being approximate , the algorithm is efficient and yields good results . in the following sections , we explain the two major components of the algorithm . the first component is _ hypothesize and test _ , which leverages a ransac - like procedure of exemplar matching . for this , we rewrite eq . [ eq : geo_score ] in a recursive form which scores the subtree rooted at @xmath42 ( @xmath61 ) : @xmath62 note that @xmath63 for any @xmath2 . by comparing eq . [ eq : recur_score ] with eq . [ eq : geo_score ] , we can see that @xmath64 . _ hypothesize and test _ is conducted in a bottom - up manner : ( 1 ) given the hypothesized locations of all the parts at level @xmath20 ( each part has multiple hypotheses ) , transform the exemplars at level @xmath23 to the test image with similarity transformation such that each exemplar s child parts aligns with two randomly selected hypotheses of atomic parts ( if @xmath65 ) , or up to two hypotheses of composite parts ( if @xmath66 ) . ( 2 ) the geometrically well - aligned exemplars generate hypotheses for the parts at level @xmath23 . each hypothesis carries from exemplar the object size , the corresponding subtree , as well as the pose @xmath52 for each node in the subtree . ( 3 ) augment the hypotheses of @xmath19 ( if @xmath66 ) by swapping their subtrees with geometrically compatible hypotheses at level @xmath20 . ( 4 ) evaluate all the hypotheses at level @xmath23 using eq . [ eq : recur_score ] and keep the top - scoring ones . ( 5 ) increment @xmath23 and go to step ( 1 ) . [ fig : algo ] shows examples of the first three steps . and the second row corresponds to @xmath67 . ( a ) two training exemplars . ( b ) the test image overlaid with hypotheses at level @xmath20 . ( c ) part hypotheses at level @xmath23 which are inherited from the exemplars . ( d ) augmented hypothesis after swapping hypotheses of child part . ] @xmath68 top @xmath69 local maximas from @xmath70 , @xmath71 refine and re - score @xmath72 through _ backtrack _ @xmath73 highest - scoring @xmath74 . the architecture of dcnn - based models for composite parts . it consists of five convolutional layers , three max - pooling layers and three fully - connected layers . the last two layers branch out , with each branch targeting the possible spatial relations of one composite part to its predefined reference part . ] the second component of the algorithm is _ backtrack_. assuming we have a hypothesis of the root part @xmath75 , we can trace down the hierarchy , which gives us @xmath52 in eq . [ eq : geo_term ] for each composite part , as well as the hypothesized locations for the atomic parts @xmath76 $ ] . the next step is to re - score @xmath77 by obtaining its refined configuration @xmath74 . for this purpose , we define @xmath78 to approximate @xmath79 in eq . [ eq : overall_opt ] : @xmath80 where @xmath81 . such approximation assumes @xmath82 , @xmath52 and @xmath42 for @xmath66 change little during the refinement . after plugging eq . [ eq : app_score ] and eq . [ eq : psi_def ] into eq . [ eq : appro_s ] , we can solve each atomic part independently as @xmath83 where part @xmath84 is the parent of part @xmath0 , @xmath85 denotes the search region of part @xmath0 . we define the search region as a circle with radius equal to @xmath86% of the average side length of @xmath75 . we evaluate eq . 8 for all the pixel locations inside the circle , which gives us the highest - scoring location . in the end , we obtain the refined configuration @xmath87 $ ] with updated score @xmath88 . in this section , we describe how we learn the appearance models in eq . [ eq : overall_opt ] ( i.e. , @xmath35 and @xmath54 ) , as well as how we learn the weight parameters @xmath89 ( i.e. , @xmath34 , @xmath50 , and @xmath51 ) . we follow the method of @xcite to infer the spatial relations between atomic parts . specifically , we design a dcnn - based multi - class classifier using caffe @xcite . the architecture is shown in the first row of fig . [ fig : dnn_architecture_2 ] . each value in the output corresponds to @xmath90 , which is the likelihood of seeing an atomic part @xmath0 with a certain spatial relation ( type @xmath91 ) to its predefined neighbor @xmath7 , at location @xmath92 . if @xmath93 , then @xmath94 , indicating the background ; if @xmath95 , then @xmath96 . by marginalization , we can derive @xmath35 and @xmath54 as @xmath97 note that superscript @xmath98 and @xmath4 are dropped for clarity , @xmath0 and @xmath7 are siblings . to define type @xmath91 , during training , we discretize the orientations of @xmath9 into @xmath99 ( e.g. , @xmath100 ) uniform bins , and @xmath91 indicates a particular bin . the training samples are then labeled as @xmath101 . we build another dcnn - based model to infer the spatial relations between composite parts , as shown in the second row of fig . [ fig : dnn_architecture_2 ] , the architecture differs from that for atomic parts in multiple aspects . first , as the model targets composite parts which have coarser levels of granularity , the network has a larger receptive field . second , as there are relatively fewer composite parts than atomic parts , we let all the composite parts share the features in the first several layers ( the input patches of different composite parts have different receptive fields ) . third , as the composite parts have different granularity with possibly significant overlap with each other , the dcnn branches out to handle them separately . assuming the @xmath0-th branch corresponds to part @xmath0 at level @xmath20 ( note that @xmath66 ) , then the branch has @xmath102-dim output with each value being @xmath103 based on the image patch centered at the anchor point @xmath104 . assuming the parent of part @xmath0 is part @xmath19 , then @xmath54 is evaluated as @xmath105 note that superscript @xmath106 and @xmath4 are dropped for clarity . to train this model , we cluster the relation vector @xmath9 into @xmath99 ( e.g. , @xmath107 ) clusters ( types ) for part @xmath0 , and the training samples are labeled accordingly . [ eq : overall_opt ] can be written as a dot product @xmath108 . given a training sample @xmath109 , we compute @xmath110 as its feature . each training sample also has a binary label , indicating if the configuration @xmath4 is correct . therefore , we build a binary max - margin classifier @xcite to estimate @xmath111 , with non - negativity constraints imposed . to avoid over - fitting , the training is conducted on a held - out validation set that was not used to train the dcnns . before training , we augment the positive samples by randomly perturbing their part locations as long as they are reasonably close to the ground - truth locations . to generate the negative samples , we randomly place the configurations of positive samples at the incorrect regions of the training images , with gaussian noise added to the part locations . we evaluate our method extensively on multiple benchmarks , and conduct diagnostic experiments to show the effect of different components in our method . the leeds sports pose ( lsp ) dataset @xcite includes @xmath112 images for training and @xmath112 images for testing , where each image is annotated with @xmath113 joint locations . we augment the training data by left - right flipping , and rotating through @xmath114 . we use observer - centric ( oc ) annotations to have fair comparisons with the majority of existing methods . to measure the performance , we use percentage of correct parts ( pcp ) . in pcp measure , a `` part '' is defined as a line segment connecting two neighboring joints . if both of the segment endpoints ( joints ) lie within @xmath115% of the length of the ground - truth annotated endpoints , then the part is correct . in this experiment , we build a hierarchy of four levels for human body . the first level contains the atomic body joints ; the second level has five composite parts ( head , right arm , left arm , right leg , and left leg ) ; the third level has two composite parts ( head&arms and legs ) ; and the fourth level corresponds to the whole body . to gain an understanding of the effect of the components of our inference algorithm , we evaluate our full method ( which will be referred to as `` ours - full '' ) , and variants of our method ( which will be referred to as `` ours - partial '' , and `` ours - no - hier '' ) . ours - full corresponds to the whole inference algorithm ; ours - partial only conducts the first part of the inference algorithm , traces down the best root hypothesis based on eq . [ eq : recur_score ] , and outputs the locations of its atomic parts ; ours - no - hier only uses full - body exemplars ( after augmentation ) as the spatial models . the quantitative results of our method as well as its counterparts are listed in tab . [ tbl : lsp ] . ours - full generally outperforms the state - of - the - art methods on all the parts . the improvement over idpr @xcite demonstrates the effect of reasoning multi - level spatial relations . we expect to see even larger improvement if we augment the annotations with midway points between joints . we also experiment with person - centric ( pc ) annotations on the same dataset , where the accuracy drops slightly . ours - full achieves improvement over ours - partial and ours - no - hier by a large margin , which demonstrates the benefits of _ backtrack _ ( higher precision ) and hierarchical exemplars ( more expressive models ) . note that ours - partial already outperforms strong - ps @xcite and posemachine @xcite . [ fig : final_results ] shows some testing examples , which are selected with high diversity in poses . we can see that our method achieves accurate localization for most of the body joints , even in the case of large articulated deformation . .comparison of pose estimation results ( pcp ) on lsp dataset . our method achieves the best performance . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] we use percentage of detected joints ( pdj ) to evaluate the performance , which provides an informative view of the localization precision . in this experiment , we evaluate the baseline of our method ( referred to as `` ours - base '' ) by only using the first term in eq . [ eq : overall_opt ] . it is equivalent to localizing the parts independently . in fig . [ fig : model_performance ] , we plot the detection rate vs. normalized error curves for different methods . from the curves , we can see that ours - base already achieves better accuracy than @xcite except for knee . it demonstrates that a detector that scores the part appearance is more effective than a regressor that predicts the part offset . ours - full achieves significant improvement over ours - base by incorporating the multi - level spatial models . our method is also comparable to @xcite which enjoys the benefit of jointly learning appearance models and spatial context . @xcite has higher accuracy on the lower arms , while we have better results on the lower legs . also note that @xcite requires delicate implementation of a sophisticated network architecture , while our method allows the use of off - the - shelf dcnn models . we also evaluate our method on the cub-200 - 2011 bird dataset , which contains @xmath116 images for training and @xmath117 images for testing . each image is annotated with image locations for @xmath86 parts . we also augment the training data through flipping and rotation . as birds are less articulated than humans , we design a three - level hierarchy for birds . the first level contains the atomic parts ; the second level has three composite parts ( head , belly&legs , and back&tail ) ; and the third level corresponds to the whole bird . although we did not prove that the manually - designed hierarchy is optimal , we empirically find that it facilitates the prediction of part relations . we use pcp to measure performance . in the bird dataset , a correct part detection should be within @xmath118 standard deviation of an mturk worker s click from the ground - truth location . for a semi - rigid object such as bird with sufficient training samples , directly applying exemplar - based models can produce very good results . therefore , we replace the part detectors in @xcite with dcnn - based detectors ( only targeting the atomic parts ) , which will be referred to as `` dcnn - coe '' . we compare the results of different methods in tab . [ table : global_loc ] , including coe @xcite and part - pair @xcite . first , dcnn - coe outperforms coe significantly , demonstrating that dcnn is much more powerful than the conventional classification model ( e.g. , svm ) . dcnn - coe also outperforms part - pair with much less overhead , thanks to the efficiency of multi - class detector . using our new method , the localization accuracy is further improved . ours - partial improves slightly over dcnn - coe , which is reasonable as ours - partial is essentially multi - level dcnns plus multi - level exemplars , and the flexibility from our multi - level exemplars has limited effect for semi - rigid objects . also note that ours - partial uses an incomplete scoring function . by considering the full scoring function , ours - full achieves the best results on all the parts . some qualitative results are shown in fig . [ fig : final_results_bird ] . from the examples , we can see that our method is capable of capturing a wide range of poses , shapes and viewpoints . in addition , our method localizes the bird parts with very high precision . in this paper , we propose a novel approach for articulated pose estimation . the approach exploits the part relations at different levels of granularity through multi - scale dcnn - based models and hierarchical exemplar - based models . by incorporating dcnn - based appearance models in the spatial terms , our method couples spatial models with them , thus better adapting to the particular test image than otherwise . by introducing hierarchy in the exemplar - based models , we enjoy much more expressive spatial models even if the training data are limited . in addition , we propose an efficient algorithm to infer `` good - enough '' part configurations from a less simplified formulation . these efforts together enable us to achieve state - of - the - art results on different datasets , which demonstrates the effectiveness and generalization ability of our method . this work was supported by nsf awards 0968546 and 1116631 , onr award n00014 - 08 - 1 - 0638 , and gordon and betty moore foundation grant 2987 . | exemplar - based models have achieved great success on localizing the parts of semi - rigid objects . however , their efficacy on highly articulated objects such as humans is yet to be explored . inspired by hierarchical object representation and recent application of deep convolutional neural networks ( dcnns ) on human pose estimation , we propose a novel formulation that incorporates both hierarchical exemplar - based models and dcnns in the spatial terms . specifically , we obtain more expressive spatial models by assuming independence between exemplars at different levels in the hierarchy ; we also obtain stronger spatial constraints by inferring the spatial relations between parts at the same level . as our method strikes a good balance between expressiveness and strength of spatial models , it is both effective and generalizable , achieving state - of - the - art results on different benchmarks : leeds sports dataset and cub-200 - 2011 . = 1 |
astro-ph0011021 | the standard theory of the origin of the large - scale structure of the universe involves the assumption that the structure we see today grew by gravitational instability from initial small fluctuations in the density field . in most popular variants of this model , particularly those involving cosmic inflation , the initial fluctuations are of a particularly simple form known as a gaussian random field . gaussian random fields are useful because many properties of gaussian random density fields can be calculated analytically ( e.g. bardeen et al . some direct motivation for such an assumption emerges from inflationary models , wherein the fluctuations are generated by quantum oscillations of the scalar field driving inflation ( the `` inflation '' ) . even if inflation turns out to be incorrect , however , the central limit theorem tends to produce gaussian fluctuations in any linear process , so that they are the most generic form for small initial conditions and a natural default assumption . one particularly interesting property of gaussian random fields is that the requirement for the density contrast @xmath0/\rho_{0}$ ] to be a gaussian random field is equivalent to that the real and imaginary parts of its fourier components @xmath1 , where @xmath2 are independently distributed . in other words , the fourier modes @xmath3 , @xmath4 possess phases @xmath5 which are independently distributed and uniformly random on the interval @xmath6 $ ] . as the density field is simply a sum over a large number of fourier modes and if the phases of each of fourier modes are random , the central limit theorem guarantees that the resulting superposition of the one - point probability distribution @xmath7 is close to gaussian and that all of the field s joint probability distributions are multivariate gaussians . the statistical properties of an isotropic gaussian random field are then completely specified by its second - order statistical quantity : the covariance function , or alternatively , its power spectrum @xmath8 . in the framework of gravitational instability , the growth of fluctuations can be understood analytically when the density fluctuation amplitude is small compared to the mean density ; the linear perturbation theory tells us that each fourier mode grows with the same rate independent of wavenumber and the statistical distribution of @xmath9 remains constant except its variance . the linear theory breaks down when @xmath10 is comparable with unity or beyond , and different fourier modes start coupling . one way to look at the mode coupling is that @xmath9 is always constrained to value @xmath11 . when the perturbation is small , the tail of @xmath7 in the part of @xmath12 assigned by gaussian distribution is negligible , because probability of @xmath13 is small . when the density field evolves beyond the linear regime , i.e. , @xmath14 , a long tail at high @xmath9 is generated while lower bound is confined at @xmath15 . gaussian condition is therefore invalid , in that mode coupling effect causes the initial condition to skew . terms in the evolution equations for the fourier modes that represent coupling between different modes are of second ( or higher ) order in @xmath9 and these are neglected when first - order perturbation theory is considered . phases of fourier modes therefore are therefore coupled together in a way which is yet to be fully elucidated but which has been recently investigated by chiang & coles ( 2000 ) and coles & chiang ( 2000 ) . one of the reasons for studying fourier phases in depth is the question of possible primordial non - gaussianity of the initial density distribution of the universe . for example , there have been claims of non - gaussianity from analysis results in the cobe dmr sky maps of cosmic microwave background using a number of different diagnostics : bispectrum analysis ( ferreira et al . 1998 ) ; the wavelet transform ( hobson et al . 1999 ) ; and minkowski functionals ( schmalzing & gorski 1998 ) . the most direct practical approach , however , is through the distribution of fourier phases . this diagnostic can also avoid the subtlety of more standard methods that depend on the distribution function @xmath7(scherrer et al . 1991 ) , in that a density field with gaussian single - point density distribution @xmath7 is not necessarily a gaussian field . phase information is also important as a statistical diagnostic of non - linearity when the evolution of clustering in the non - linear regime which is generally intractable analytically . indeed , , as we shall show , it is also closely related to the morphology of gravitational clustering and through this to the dynamical origin of structure . the layout of this paper is as follows . in section 2 we present a visual demonstration of the link between fourier phases and clustering morphology . section 3 contains a brief discussion of some of the properties of phases and some pitfalls that must be avoided when using them as part of a clustering descriptor . in section 4 we introduce a cross - correlation parameter @xmath16 and a rank - correlation @xmath17 as quantitative measures of the agreement between two distributions . in section 5 we display the results of the correlation tests between sample distributions and phase - based reconstructions , and between simulations evolving from different initial power spectra but the same initial phase set . a brief discussion of the results follows in section 6 . to give a qualitative , visual description of the key ideas in this paper consider fig . [ demo ] , in which we isolate the role of phases in determining clustering morphology . plates ( a ) and ( b ) are two example realisations from two 2d n - body experiments , evolving from different initial power - law power spectra and different initial phase sets . plate ( a ) is evolved from power spectral index @xmath18 , and ( b ) from @xmath19 . we perform a fourier transform on both realisations , e.g. , @xmath20 , where @xmath21 . plate ( c ) is obtained by taking the inverse fourier transform from the combination of the phases of fourier modes from ( a ) , and the amplitudes from ( b ) , i.e. , @xmath22 $ ] . plate ( d ) is from the phases from ( b ) but amplitudes from ( a ) . therefore , plate ( a ) and ( c ) share the same phase configuration , so do ( b ) and ( d ) . it is easy to see resemblance between ( a ) and ( c ) , and between ( b ) and ( d ) . note that plate ( a ) and ( d ) have the same power spectrum , or equivalently , two - point correlation function , as do plate ( b ) and ( c ) . plate ( e ) is the inverse fourier transform from only the phases from ( a ) : @xmath23 $ ] ; it therefore retains only the phase information from ( a ) . in plate ( f ) , each mode keeps the same amplitude so its power spectrum is unchanged ( i.e. the same as plate ( a ) and ( d ) ) but the phases are redistributed randomly among the modes before inverse fourier transform . again , plate ( e ) , the phase - only reconstruction ( hereafter phase - only reconstruction ) , resembles the original distribution plate ( a ) , and plate ( c ) , the same - phase amplitude - swapped reconstruction ( hereafter amplitude - swapped reconstruction ) , but ( f ) which has the same power spectrum as ( a ) but random phases ( hereafter random - phase reconstruction ) , is featureless . this experiment suffices to show very clearly how phases determine morphology . another interesting property of fourier phases in clustering morphology is that two realisations evolving from the same initial random phase set , though different power - law power spectra , will have their extrema at the same locations . the fact that plate ( a ) and ( b ) are evolved from different initial phase sets is for demonstration purpose . fourier phases reflect the locations of spatial ` events ' more than fourier amplitudes do . for a single hypothetical spike , represented by the dirac @xmath9-function @xmath24 , the amplitudes are constant and phases are @xmath25 . this has a white - noise spectrum , but very strong phase correlation . the phase configuration of a spike is very similar to that of a single density peak evolved from 1d zeldovich approximation ; see chiang & coles ( 2000 ) for details . a translation @xmath26 of the dirac @xmath9-function density field , @xmath27 , has no effect on the fourier amplitudes , but the phases now become @xmath28 , which suffers a shift by a linear term proportional to wave number @xmath29 . this dependency of phases on the choice of origin means that some care must be taken when trying to extract meaningful information . some previous studies focused on the evolution of individual phases away from their initial values ( ryden & gramann 1991 ; soda & suto 1992 ; jain & bertschinger 1998 ) . the mean deviation from the initial phase can be defined as @xmath30 where the averages are performed over the different modes within a shell in k - space whose wave numbers lie in the range @xmath31 . as long as there are enough modes , the maximal value of @xmath32 is @xmath33 ( jain & bertschinger 1998 ) , which can be understood as a variable obtained from the change from a random field to a hypothetical spike , i.e. , from random phases to a very ordered state , @xmath34 ( mod @xmath35 ) , where @xmath36 is the location of the spike and takes on any values except zero . this statistic will change following the translation of ` events ' , e.g. , @xmath37 if the hypothetical spike is shifted to the origin . although the examples displayed in section 2 serve to demonstrate the importance of phases , it is necessary to measure objectively how well the phase - based reconstructions compare not only with the original distribution , but also with reconstruction from , say , random phases . the tool we use here is the cross - correlation statistic introduced by coles , melott & shandarin ( 1993 ) . a correlation coefficient is defined as @xmath38 where @xmath39 and @xmath40 represent two density distribution and @xmath41 and @xmath42 are their mean densities , respectively . the indices @xmath43 and @xmath44 label the pixel positions in the two - dimensional simulations we use here for illustration . the parameter @xmath16 compares the density value of each grid point at @xmath45 in the original distribution @xmath9 with the corresponding grid point of the reconstruction @xmath46 ; averages are taken over all grid points . @xmath47 denotes ` completely positive correlation ' , a perfect agreement between @xmath9 and @xmath46 , and a value of zero indicates the two distributions are uncorrelated . what is useful about this test is that it compares the morphology between two distributions , point by point , but does not take into account their variances this is because @xmath47 when @xmath48 , @xmath49 being a constant . if the structures of two distributions are different , @xmath50 is less than unity . cross - correlation tests the spatial correspondence of the locations of ` events ' , such as clusters of points or edges , between two distributions . even the comparison by a small displacement between two identical periodic distributions will result in low value of @xmath16 . it should be pointed out , therefore , that this grid - by - grid test is severe . as we have explained , phases are related to preservation of locations of ` events ' . relative magnitudes of the ` events ' , however , are not preserved when the information of fourier amplitudes is partially or totally lost . to relax the test , comparisons are made not only between raw density distributions @xmath9 and @xmath46 , but also between smoothed distributions @xmath51 and @xmath52 . for this purpose , a gaussian window function is chosen to smooth the field , @xmath53 as well as the linear cross - correlation @xmath16 , we also use a non - parametric rank - correlation , kendall s @xmath17 parameter(kendall and gibbons 1990 ) . this parameter uses the relative ordering of ranks to measure the degree of agreement between two compared distributions . for any two grid points @xmath45 and @xmath54 , the given value is @xmath55 if the relative ordering of the density values of @xmath56 and @xmath57 is the same as @xmath58 and @xmath59 , i.e. , either both decreasing or both increasing from @xmath45 to @xmath54 ; @xmath60 when one pair is increasing and the other is decreasing . the @xmath17 parameter compares @xmath61 pairs from total @xmath62 grid points and is normalized to @xmath63 $ ] . rank correlation measures such as this do not look specifically for linear association between the image and reconstruction , but for one - to - one ordering of the values in one relative to those in the other . if there is strong non - linear association , then @xmath17 can be close to unity even though @xmath16 may be small . @xmath17 parameter is used here as an auxiliary test , which is again `` softened '' with a gaussian window function as in eq . ( [ eq : window ] ) . fig . [ corr ] shows cross - correlation coefficient @xmath16 and rank - correlation coefficient @xmath17 drawn against smoothing scale @xmath64 in computer grid units . each panel includes correlations between the sample distribution and phase - only , amplitude - swapped reconstructions . correlations of random - phase reconstructions are calculated only in @xmath16 . on the top - left panel of fig . [ corr ] , the sample distribution evolved from spectral index @xmath18(fig.1a ) is compared with phase - only reconstruction(fig.1e ) , and with amplitude - swapped reconstruction ( fig.1c ) . the random - phase reconstruction ( fig.1f ) is also compared for reference . the sample distribution of lower - left panel is evolved from @xmath19(fig.1b ) . even before smoothing , the higher degree of cross - correlation from phase - only and amplitude - swapped reconstructions than from random - phase reconstruction shows the ability of phases to retain the morphology of the sample distributions . non - resemblance of random - phase reconstructions is shown through low value of @xmath50 . that smoothing of the reconstructions increases ( for amplitude - swapped it even decreases ) certain level of @xmath16 indicates the limitation of phases on reconstruction with the loss of amplitude information . the rank - correlations , on the other hand , show that phase - only reconstructions have higher agreement than amplitude - swapped ones on relative density magnitudes , which is due to the ` twist ' on the latter s power spectra . surely , the loss of the fourier amplitude information destroys part of the signal , as shown in the rank - correlation of the right panels . on the morphology of gravitational clustering , however , phases play a much more important role than amplitudes . it emphasizes this point still further to test the correspondence between simulations evolving from different initial power spectra but the same initial phases . in fig . ( [ xcorr1 ] ) we compare the morphology for some relevant examples in terms of cross - correlation coefficient @xmath16 deployed above . in particular , we show realisations obtained by evolving @xmath65-body experiments from different 2d initial power - law power spectra @xmath18 , @xmath66 @xmath67 and @xmath68 . the left panel is the comparison of stage @xmath69 in which the scale of non - linearity is @xmath70 , and the right panel is that of later stage @xmath71 with @xmath72(chiang & coles 2000 , beacom et al . we use the fundamental mode @xmath73 as length unit , where @xmath74 is the length of the side of the simulation square . before smoothing , there is little or no correspondence between any of the realisations . this is due to the severe point - by - point test of the cross - correlation . after smoothing , however , there is a dramatic improvement between in the correspondence between @xmath75 , @xmath76 , and between @xmath77 . we can examine the morphology evolving from the same phase set by the characteristic scale @xmath78 . for example , @xmath78 for stage @xmath69 corresponds to 8 computer grid units , thus the smoothing on scales beyond 8 grid units erases non - linearities , while the larger scale structure remains in the linear regime . the linear growth of the density fluctuations set up by the same initial phases depends only on time . the comparison therefore indicates the intrinsic difference in clustering morphology arising from different initial power spectra . what we see on the scales beyond @xmath78 is that the correspondence is low between @xmath18 and @xmath77 . the correspondence deteriorates when the difference between the spectral indices increases , i.e. , the difference in intrinsic morphology is significant , or when the evolution goes into highly non - linear regime , where particles move away from their initial lagrangian position and interact with each other non - linearly . simulations evolving from the same initial phase configuration tend to develop nonlinear structures at or near the same spatial locations , but these structures appear with different contrast when the initial spectra are different . for example , filaments appear in the nonlinear regime in all cases , but for spectra with large @xmath79 these tend to be less well defined and broken up into clumps . our statistic @xmath16 takes into account both the position and amplitude of structures that form so it indicates a deteriorating agreement for very different spectra . nevertheless , it is clear that there is strong imprint upon the morphology of the initial phases resulting from the process of gravitational clustering . this can also be seen visually in the pictures shown by beacom et al . ( 1991 ) . the cross - correlation coefficient being a single number , so one can not infer from it precisely how the phase - based reconstructions perform relative to the morphology of the original distribution . one intriguing question is how the density regions from reconstructions can be compared to those from the original distributions . is it @xmath80 that produces high value of @xmath16 ? from rank - correlation coefficient @xmath17 , this is is not the case . in order to get more information between the two distributions , we also made a grid - by - grid comparison between them . a scatter diagram can be drawn in logarithmic scales for the comparison between each cell density from phase - based reconstructions against the corresponding one from the original distribution . if @xmath80 , the points scatter along a straight line of slope equal to unity , and the relative magnitude of ` events ' is preserved by a linear scale factor . [ scatter ] shows the scatter diagram between original distribution and phase - only , amplitude - swapped reconstructions for @xmath19 and @xmath18 . not all the points scatter along the straight line , as is suggested . instead , most points scatter horizontally , particularly for phase - only cases . also notice also that , in both reconstruction cases , the density values span only roughly one order of magnitude and the points that do not align well correspond to very small fluctuations . high values of @xmath16 result from phase configuration preserving the locations of high - density ` events ' with large magnitudes in the original structure . the relatively flat phase - only reconstructed density distribution is caused by the flat power spectrum , in which the fourier amplitude for each mode is squashed into unity . the lower two panels are scatter diagrams of the amplitude - swapped reconstructions against the originals , i.e. , in fig . [ demo ] between ( c ) and ( a ) and between ( d ) and ( b ) . the difference is amplitude - swapped reconstructions have the power spectra from the alternative sample distributions . the @xmath18 amplitude - swapped reconstruction has the power spectrum from the original distribution of @xmath19 , which gives more power on small scales in the reconstruction , the @xmath19 reconstruction , on the other hand , has more power on large scales . this adverse effect causes the points of the low fluctuations to spread on the scatter diagram , which , however , does nt decrease much the cross - correlation coefficient @xmath16 between phase - only and amplitude - swapped reconstructions . this is in accord with with our visual impression that our eyes pick up the maxima between the distributions for comparison . in fig . [ scatter1 ] the scatter diagrams for the realisations evolving from the same phase set are also produced . here only two cases are chosen , i.e. , between @xmath18 and @xmath66 , and between @xmath18 and @xmath68 . the left two panels are comparison between @xmath18 and @xmath81 , and the scattering is expected , which nonetheless follows the straight line . for the right panels , at early stage @xmath69 , the deviation from the straight line is more isotropic , hence the correspondence is low . at late stage @xmath71 , there is even more deviation , which comes from the mapping from the low - density regions of stage @xmath71 , @xmath82 . the reason is as follows . for the realisation of @xmath82 to reach the same level of non - linearity , the variance is higher than that of @xmath18 , and there are a substantial number of voids . after smoothing to create continuous distribution , the void regions are smoothed as low - density regions , which is seen in the bottom - right panel . we have shown the importance of fourier phases on morphology of gravitational clustering via qualitative and quantitative demonstrations . it is interesting to remark upon the similarity of the results we have obtained here and those presented in coles et al . the latter authors were interested in the ability of simple analytic methods to reproduce the clustering displayed by full n - body computations . they showed in particular that the zeldovich approximation ( zeldovich 1970 ) could reproduce the full numerical results quite well , with cross - correlations similar to those we have found here . the zeldovich approximation works as well as it does in this respect because it places the caustic surfaces forming sheets and filaments near to the correct location in the n - body experiment . in other words , the zeldovich approximation has a high phase fidelity . it is less good at getting the amplitudes right . as we have shown , however , phases dominate the morphology . with a new colour representation technique ( coles & chiang 2000 ) , phase information can be used to distinguish between non - gaussianity induced by gravitational clustering and that by other mechanisms . for example , in the web page .... http://www.nottingham.ac.uk/~ppzpc/phases/cmb.html .... the phase configuration of the non - gaussian temperature fluctuations on the cmb sky induced by cosmic strings can be seen to be intrinsically different from that of hierarchical clustering developed in n - body simulations . a new algorithm based on the analysis of the phase distribution of fourier components is recently devised to extract noise from point sources from the cmb signal(naselsky et al . 2000 ) , which is another example practice of the close link between fourier phases and morphology . future large - scale galaxy redshift surveys and microwave sky maps will reveal much morphological information about large - scale structure in the universe . existing statistical technology , however , is still dominated by second - order methods that are blind to phase information . our success in extracting this information will therefore depend on the development of statistical methods sufficiently sensitive to the key ingredient : the distribution of fourier phases . i thank peter coles for useful suggestions . this work was partly supported by danmarks grundforskningsfond through its support for tac . bardeen j.m . , bond j.r . , kaiser n. , szalay a.s . , 1986 , apj , 304 , 15 beacom j.f . , dominik k.g . , melott a.l . , perkins s.p . , shandarin s.f . , 1991 , apj , 372 , 351 chiang l .- y . , coles p. , 2000 , mnras , 311 , 809 coles p. , chiang l .- y . , 2000 , nature , 406 , 376 coles p. , melott a.l , shandarin s.f . , 1993 , mnras , 260 , 765 ferreira p.g . , magueijo j. , gorski k.m . , 1998 , apj , 503 , l1 hobson m.p . , jones a.w . , lasenby a.n . , 1999 mnras , 309 , 125 jain b. , bertschinger e. , 1996 , apj , 456 , 43 jain b. , bertschinger e. , 1998 , apj , 509 , 517 kendall m. , gibbons j.d . , 1990 , rank correlation methods , oxford university press , new york naselsky p. , novikov d. , silk j. , astro - ph/0007133 ryden b.s . , gramann m. , 1991 , apj , 383 , l33 scherrer r.j . , melott a.l . , shandarin s.f . , 1991 , apj , 377 , 29 schmalzing j. , gorski k.m . , 1998 , mnras , 297 , 355 soda j. , suto y. , 1992 , apj , 396 , 379 zeldovich y.b . , 1970 , a&a , 5 , 84 | the phases of the fourier modes appearing in a plane - wave expansion of cosmological density fields play a vital role in determining the morphology of gravitationally - developed clustering . we demonstrate this qualitatively and quantitatively using simulations . in particular , we use cross - correlation and rank - correlation techniques to quantify the agreement between a simulated distribution and phase - only reconstructions . the phase - only reconstructions exhibit a high degree of correlation with the original distributions , showing how meaningful spatial reconstruction of cosmological density fields depends more on phase accuracy than on amplitudes . cosmology : theory large - scale structure of the universe methods : statistical |
quant-ph0002002 | a key distinguishing feature of quantum physics from classical physics is the prediction of a new kind of correlation between physical quantities , called entanglement . quantum entanglement has been often been referred to as the inseparability of composite quantum systems . such an entangled composite system is said to be inseparable because it can not be prepared by manipulating each subsystem separately , using only measurements and operations local to one subsystem at a time . if a composite quantum mechanical state is specified by some density matrix , how can we tell if the system is entangled ? much work has been done studying the particular case of two subsystems , with each in a two dimensional hilbert space ( qubits ) . there is a good understanding of the entanglement for such systems and in fact a criterion , the partial transposition condition of peres@xcite , indicates whether the subsystems are entangled . this , however , is a necessary and sufficient condition only when there are two subsystems , one with hilbert space dimension @xmath0 , and the other of dimension @xmath0 or @xmath1 , as was shown by the horodeckis@xcite . for more complex systems , it only determines whether the state contains distillable entanglement , however there are also some states with bound entanglement , which are lumped together with the separable states by this criterion . lewenstein _ et . al._@xcite have used the peres condition to consider two subsystems , but with each subsystem now in a @xmath2 dimensional hilbert space . yczkowski _ et . al._@xcite have , among other results , shown that all the mixed states in a sufficiently small neighbourhood of the maximally mixed state are separable . they also gave a bound on the size of this neighbourhood for small composite systems . vidal and tarrach@xcite gave a lower bound on the size of this neighbourhood for arbitrary composite states , of any number of subsystems . schack and caves@xcite gave bounds for composite systems composed of many qubits ( @xmath3 ) . it has been pointed out by braunstein _ et . al._@xcite that maximally - entangled states of the ghz type , with noise added , are connected to recent proposals for nmr quantum computing . they are also relevant to fundamental tests of quantum mechanics using bell inequalities . the separability of such noisy generalised singlet states has been considered by various authors recently , mostly for the case of qubits ( subsystems with hilbert space dimension two ) . schack and caves@xcite , using the approach of braunstein _ et . al . _ have obtained an exact boundary condition for the werner states@xcite ( two qubits ) , while caves and milburn@xcite extended the approach to two q - trits ( hilbert space dimension three ) . the horodeckis@xcite gave exact bounds for the case of two subsystems . in this paper we extend the approach of peres@xcite to consider such noisy generalised singlet states in the general case of @xmath4 subsystems with each subsystem in a @xmath5 dimensional hilbert space . a parameter @xmath6 specifies the amount of the pure ghz - type maximally - entangled states present compared with the maximally - mixed noise state.we then ask and answer the following question : what is the maximum value of @xmath6 for this state to be entangled ? another fundamental question is also considered . to create as entangled a state as possible , is it simply better to increase the dimension of the subsystems or is it better to increase the number of subsystems ? the states considered here , consist of a mixture of the maximally - mixed noise states , and the ghz - type entangled states , where the number @xmath4 of subsystems over which entanglement occurs , and the hilbert space dimension @xmath5 of each subsystem ( equal for all @xmath4 subsystems ) can take on any values @xmath7 , @xmath8 . the relative proportion of ghz - type states is controlled by the parameter @xmath9 , where @xmath10 corresponds to a pure ghz - type state , while @xmath11 corresponds to the maximally mixed state . explicitly , the state is given by the density operator [ p= ] @xmath12 where @xmath13 here @xmath14 represents one of @xmath5 complete orthogonal basis states for the @xmath15 subsystem , while @xmath16 is the density operator for the maximally mixed state , and @xmath17 for the ghz - like state . the werner state@xcite , consisting of a singlet state and some noise , is the simplest @xmath18 case , hence we call these generalised werner states . the state @xmath19 can be viewed as a generalised singlet state @xmath17 after it has emerged from a depolarising channel . the separability of particular cases of the state ( [ p= ] ) , and of more general states , has been considered previously by a number of authors @xcite . firstly , it was shown @xcite that for the two - qubit ( @xmath20 ) case , ( the werner state ) @xmath19 is separable for , and entangled otherwise , whereas for three qubits ( @xmath21 ) , schack and caves@xcite found the state to be separable for . soon after , horodecki and horodecki@xcite found the exact result for arbitrary numbers of qubits : @xmath22 schack and caves also found bounds on the size of the separable neighbourhood around the maximally mixed state for totally general states of many qubits ( @xmath3 ) . for and these are and respectively , and for higher @xmath4 are given by @xmath23 what about the more general case when @xmath5 and @xmath4 are arbitrary ? for what values of @xmath9 is the state given by ( [ p= ] ) separable ? vidal and tarrach@xcite gave a maximum bound for the random robustness @xmath24 of arbitrary multi - component states . for the states considered here , the critical value of @xmath9 at which the states change from being entangled to separable is ( in the notation of ref.@xcite ) . so according to that bound , @xmath25 we will prove in the next section ( section [ proof ] ) that the states given by ( [ p= ] ) , are always entangled if @xmath26 that this bound is strong for qubits ( ) is shown in appendix ( [ strong ] ) , and an explicit decomposition into product states is given for the case of separable @xmath19 . peres@xcite has shown that a necessary condition for a state consisting of two subsystems to be separable is that the partial transpose of the density matrix over one of the subsystems , and the partial transpose over the other subsystem , have positive eigenvalues . however , this is a necessary and sufficient condition only when one of the subsystems has hilbert space dimension @xmath0 or @xmath1 , and the other dimension @xmath0 , as was shown by the horodeckis@xcite . that paper went on to give a necessary and sufficient condition for a state to be separable . nevertheless the peres condition is just what is needed for an upper bound on @xmath9 for separable states . i.e. any states which break the condition are entangled , although some which satisfy it may also be , but do not have to be , entangled . it is worth noting that any states which satisfy the peres condition but are entangled are said to contain only `` bound '' entanglement , as it can not be used for teleportation , nor distilled by the process of entanglement distillation . firstly , note that the peres condition is easily extended to more than two entangled subsystems . if there are @xmath4 subsystems , one simply chooses some group of original subsystems to be called half - system number @xmath27 , and the remaining subsystems to be called half - system number @xmath0 . if for any such group of subsystems , an eigenvalue of the partial transpose of @xmath19 over half - system number @xmath27 ( say ) is negative , then @xmath19 is entangled . thus to use the peres condition to full advantage , one must consider all such groups of subsystems . the state ( [ p= ] ) is convenient in this respect , because it is unchanged under relabeling of the subsystems ( evident by inspection ) . thus the eigenvalues of @xmath28 , the partial transpose of @xmath19 over the set @xmath29 of subsystems , need only be looked at for @xmath30 ( rounded down ) sets of subsystems to extract the maximum benefit from the peres condition . in particular , a choice of sets of subsystems can be @xmath31 where @xmath32 , and @xmath33 contains the labels of the subsystems to be considered as members of the @xmath34th half - system . firstly let s consider @xmath35 , i.e. the first subsystem s entanglement with the remaining @xmath36 of them . the partially transposed density matrix is [ pt1= ] @xmath37 since all of the elements of @xmath19 , ( hence @xmath38 ) are finite , the eigenvalues of @xmath38 must also be finite . now , exploiting the general continuity property of eigenvalues of @xmath39 , we conclude that at the value of above which the peres condition indicates the state is entangled , one or more eigenvalues of @xmath38 must be zero , since they are all positive for , and at least one is negative for . i.e. for some nonzero eigenvector @xmath40 we must have @xmath41 . expanded , this gives @xmath42 equation ( [ ptpsi ] ) can explicitly be written out as @xmath43 equations @xmath44 where @xmath45 if @xmath46 , @xmath47 otherwise . now if one or more of the @xmath48 does not equal @xmath49 , then that equation is satisfied only if @xmath10 or @xmath50 . the first case is not of interest here , as @xmath10 corresponds to our maximally entangled ghz like states , so we choose @xmath51 . the rest of the equations where @xmath52 , separate into @xmath53 coupled sets of two equations of the identical form @xmath54 these have solutions if @xmath55 , but this would imply @xmath56 , which was specifically excluded in ( [ eigenvector ] ) . otherwise , these coupled two equations are only satisfied if @xmath57 so for @xmath58 , at least one such coupled set of two equations leads to the expression ( [ eo ] ) . this is the only candidate for the point where the peres condition becomes satisfied . now it can be easily seen that in the total - noise case @xmath59 , @xmath60 and all the eigenvalues of @xmath38 are @xmath61 . in the no - noise case ( @xmath10 ) , proceeding in similar fashion to before , the eigenvalues @xmath62 of @xmath38 must satisfy @xmath63 this gives @xmath64 if for some @xmath65 , @xmath66 , and leads to sets of two coupled equations of the form @xmath67 these have the solutions @xmath55 or @xmath68 as before , for nonzero eigenvectors , the first can not be true . so , finally , for the no - noise state , at least one eigenvalue of @xmath38 must be negative , and equal to @xmath69 thus , finally , since @xmath70 is the only value of @xmath9 where an eigenvalue of @xmath38 is zero , all eigenvalues are positive for @xmath59 , and an eigenvalue is negative for @xmath10 , there must be at least one negative eigenvalue for @xmath71 given by ( [ eo ] ) . when one proceeds in the same fashion when @xmath72 , one always gets coupled sets of two equations identical in form to ( [ eigeqn ] ) , as can be seen by inspection , so nothing new is found . thus the result of section ( [ state ] ) is indicated . for the qubit case ( @xmath3 ) , as seen in figure ( [ n=2 ] ) , equation ( [ eo= ] ) gives an exact bound on the values of @xmath9 that divide separable from entangled states of the form ( [ p= ] ) . one sees that the upper bound ( [ vtbound ] ) derived from the work of vidal and tarrach comes very close to the exact value for the qubit case . this exact bound is also greater than those lower bounds previously found by schack and caves@xcite , as expected . for the two - subsystem ( @xmath73 ) case , the bound ( [ eo= ] ) agrees with the exact one found by the horodeckis@xcite . for other values of @xmath4 and @xmath5 , the results on random robustness by vidal and tarrach , lead to an upper bound which is considerably weaker than the upper bound ( [ eo= ] ) given by the partial transposition condition . the upper bound found here , actually gives a stronger bound on the random robustness of entanglement of states given by ( [ p= ] ) . @xmath74 it is interesting to note that in the border cases when @xmath3 or @xmath73 , the bound ( [ eo= ] ) is in fact an exact bound . this is despite the fact that the peres condition does not necessarily give a strong bound for such states . this leads one to the tentative conjecture that for noisy ghz - type states of the form ( [ p= ] ) , the peres condition may in general give a strong upper bound . looking at figure ( [ vard ] ) , one sees that as the hilbert space dimension of the subsystems increases , the upper bound on @xmath9 rapidly decreases , indicating that the entanglement becomes stronger . as the bound ( [ eo= ] ) is completely general in @xmath5 and @xmath4 , it does provide some answers to the question of what raises entanglement more : creating more entangled subsystems , or increasing their dimension ? since the bound on @xmath9 decreases exponentially with @xmath4 , but only polynomially with @xmath5 , one concludes that increasing the number of subsystems is a more effective way of increasing the entanglement . the results presented here based on the peres condition provide a lower bound on the parameters @xmath9 in ( [ p= ] ) above which the generalised werner states are always entangled . furthermore , it gives an exact bound on this parameter for the case of many qubits . an explicit simple expression is derived that depends on @xmath4 , the number of subsystems over which entanglement occurs , and @xmath5 the hilbert space dimension of each subsystem . apart from the few cases ( @xmath73;@xmath3 and @xmath75 ) where this bound was known exactly previously , the new bounds are stronger than previously known ones . this work also sheds light on the question of whether to increase quantum entanglement in a system , is it better to create more entangled subsystems , or to increase the dimension of the existing subsystem . as the bound on @xmath9 decreases exponentially with @xmath5 , but only polynomially with @xmath4 , increasing the number of subsystems is a much more effective way of increasing entanglement . to conclude , the peres partial transposition condition has provided a good upper bound for determining the separability of a generalised @xmath5 , @xmath4 werner state . however for other systems it is known that this transposition condition fails to give strong results , thus when this condition is useful , and when not , remains an interesting question . we wish to show that the bound ( [ eo= ] ) is exact for qubits ( @xmath3 ) , and to find the product states which combine to give the state when it is separable . by analogy with the results of schack and caves @xcite , it has been guessed that an expansion of @xmath83 in terms of the density matrices @xmath84 is given by the following : @xmath85 here the sum is over all permutations of @xmath4 indices @xmath86 satisfying the following conditions : 1 . 2 . the number of @xmath88 is even ( or zero ) . if the number of @xmath89 is a multiple of four ( or is zero ) , then the number of is even ( or zero ) . if the number of @xmath89 is not a multiple of four , then the number of is odd . the proof of this proceeds by starting with the above guess , and showing that it is a correct one . as it turns out , the hard work is in actually writing down the guess mathematically , so let us begin with this . to begin with , note that @xmath90 where the sum is over _ all _ permutations of @xmath4 indices @xmath91 . also note that @xmath92 will give a sum over all these permutations , except that all terms which have an odd number of indices in @xmath93 will be subtracted rather than added like in @xmath94 . thus one can see that now consider some more similar expressions . @xmath98 @xmath99 will give a sum over all index permutations , except that all terms which have an odd number of indices in @xmath100 will be subtracted rather than added like for @xmath94 . @xmath101 @xmath102 will give a similar sum over all permutations , but terms in which the number of indices in @xmath103 is a multiple of four ( or is zero ) will be added , terms in which this number is even , but not a multiple of four , will be subtracted , terms in which this number is one more than a multiple of four will be added and multiplied by @xmath104 , and terms for which this number is one less than a multiple of four will be subtracted and multiplied by @xmath104 . @xmath105 @xmath106 is the complex conjugate of @xmath102 . it can be seen ( after a little thought ) that @xmath107 $ ] will give a sum over only those terms in which the number of indices in @xmath100 is a multiple of four ( or is zero ) . similarly , @xmath108 $ ] will give a sum over only those terms in which the number of indices in @xmath100 is even , but not a multiple of four . and one can define expressions for @xmath110 and @xmath111 for @xmath112 analogously to equations ( [ r ] ) . so following the same reasoning as previously , the sum of all terms in which the number of indices in @xmath100 is a multiple of four , and the number of indices in @xmath93 is even is given by @xmath113.\ ] ] and thus finally , the sum in the second term of the guess @xmath114 ( equation ( [ expguess ] ) ) can be written @xmath115 + \frac{1}{4 } [ { \cal r}_0^o + { \cal r}_1^o -{\cal r}_2^o -{\cal r}_3^o]\nonumber \\ = \frac{1}{4 } [ { \cal t}_0 + { \cal t}_1 + { \cal s}_2 + { \cal s}_3 ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] so the guess that has been made ( i.e. equation ( [ expguess ] ) ) can be rewritten @xmath116,\ ] ] which is explicitly ( via the expressions ( [ t0 ] ) , ( [ s0 ] ) , ( [ t1 ] ) , ( [ si ] ) ) a positive sum of direct tensor products of density matrices , and thus is separable . the only question that remains is whether @xmath117 ? so @xmath119 which only seemingly differs from equation ( [ rho ] ) by the first term , but using the expression for @xmath120 ( [ ec ] ) , one finds that these first terms are equal also . @xmath121 so @xmath122 , the guess was correct , and thus the bound @xmath120 is strong . a. peres , phys . lett . * 77 * , 1413 ( 1996 ) . m. horodecki , p. horodecki , and r. horodecki , phys . a * 223 * , 1 ( 1996 ) ; ( quant - ph/9605038 ) . m. lewenstein , j. i. cirac , and s. karnas , quant - ph/9903012 ( 1999 ) . k. yczkowski , p. horodecki , a. sanpera , and m. lewenstein , phys . a * 58 * , 883 ( 1998 ) . g. vidal and r. tarrach , phys . rev . a * 59 * , 141 ( 1999 ) . r. schack and c. m. caves ( quant - ph/9904109 ) ( 1999 ) . s. l. braunstein , c. m. caves , r. jozsa , n. linden , s. popescu , and r. schack , phys . * 83 * , 1054 ( 1999 ) . r. f. werner , phys . a * 40 * , 4277 ( 1989 ) . c. m. caves and g. j. milburn , to be published ( 1999 ) . m. horodecki and p. horodecki , phys . a * 59 * , 4206 ( 1999 ) . m. murao , m. b. plenio , s. popescu , v. vedral , and p. l. knight , phys . a * 57 * , r4075 ( 1998 ) . r. horodecki and m. horodecki , phys . a * 54 * , 1838 ( 1996 ) . | a lower bound on the amount of noise that must be added to a ghz - like entangled state to make it separable ( also called the random robustness ) is found using the transposition condition . the bound is applicable to arbitrary numbers of subsystems , and dimensions of hilbert space , and is shown to be exact for qubits . the new bound is compared to previous such bounds on this quantity , and found to be stronger in all cases . it implies that increasing the number of subsystems , rather than increasing their hilbert space dimension is a more effective way of increasing entanglement . an explicit decomposition into an ensemble of separable states , when the state is not entangled , is given for the case of qubits . 2 |
1602.09099 | recently , the atlas @xcite and cms @xcite collaborations have both reported an excess in the diphoton channel near @xmath0 gev . with an integrated luminosity of 3.2 @xmath2 , the atlas collaboration has observed a local @xmath3 excess at a diphoton invariant mass of around 747 gev , assuming a narrow width resonance . for a wider width resonance , the signal significance increases to @xmath4 with a preferred width of about 45 gev . with an integrated luminosity of 2.6 @xmath2 , the cms collaboration has also observed a diphoton excess with a local significance of @xmath5 at invariant mass of around 760 gev . assuming a decay width of around 45 gev , the significance reduces to @xmath6 in this case . the corresponding excesses in the cross section can be roughly estimated as @xmath7 @xcite . while this is well below the threshold to claim a discovery , this excess could be the first signal of physics beyond the standard model . as such , it is worthwhile to consider possible models of new physics which may explain the excess . indeed , many groups have proposed such possible explanations @xcite perhaps the simplest explanation for the excess is the addition of a sm singlet scalar with a mass near @xmath0 gev along with additional vector - like multiplets of colored particles . with this set - up , the singlet may be produced via gluon fusion with the vector - like particles appearing in loops . similarly , the singlet may decay to diphotons . however , in order to preserve gauge coupling unification as in supersymmetric versions of the sm , these vector - like states should come in complete multiplets of @xmath1 . moreover , to preserve unification and avoid landau poles , the types and numbers of @xmath1 multiplets is restricted @xcite . such light vector - like multiplets are often found in models constructed within the framework of string theory@xcite . indeed , vector - like states are generically present in intersecting / magnetized d - brane models on orientifold backgrounds @xcite . one such model satisfying all global consistency conditions has been constructed from intersecting / magnetized d - branes within the context of type ii orientifold compactifications @xcite on a @xmath8 background . this model corresponds to the mssm with three generations of quarks and leptons as well as a single pair of higgs fields . the model contains a minimal amount of exotic matter , which may be decoupled from the low - energy sector . in addition , the tree - level gauge couplings are automatically unified at the string scale @xcite . finally , the yukawa couplings are allowed by global @xmath9 symmetries , and it is possible to obtain correct masses and mixings for quarks and charged leptons . thus , this is a phenomenologically interesting model worthy of detailed study . in the following , we briefly summarize the intersecting d - brane model under study , which is a variation of the model discussed above . it is shown that vector - like quarks are present in the model , and that these states may appear in complete multiplets of @xmath1 so that gauge coupling unification may be maintained . furthermore , it is shown that there are sm singlets in the model which have yukawa couplings to the vector - like quarks and leptons . it should be emphasized that this is a non - trivial result as these fields carry global @xmath9 charges , under which the yukawa coupling must be neutral . finally , we show that the diphoton excesses can be accomodated in the model . a phenomenologically interesting intersecting d - brane model has been studied in refs . @xcite . a variation of this model with a different hidden sector was also studied in refs . type iia orientifold string compactifications with intersecting d - branes ( and their type iib duals with magnetized d - branes ) have provided exciting geometric tools with which the mssm may be engineered . while this approach may not allow a first - principles understanding of why the sm gauge groups and associated matter content arises , it may allow a deeper insight into how the finer phenomenological details of the sm may emerge . in short , d6-branes in type iia fill ( 3 + 1)-dimensional minkowski spacetime and wrap 3-cycles in the compactified manifold , such that a stack of @xmath10 branes generates a gauge group u(@xmath10 ) [ or u(@xmath11 ) in the case of @xmath12 in its world volume . in general , the 3-cycles wrapped by the stacks of d6-branes intersect multiple times in the internal space , resulting in a chiral fermion in the bifundamental representation localized at the intersection between different stacks @xmath13 and @xmath14 . the multiplicity of such fermions is then given by the number of times the 3-cycles intersect . each stack of d6-branes @xmath13 may intersect the orientifold images of other stacks @xmath15 , also resulting in fermions in bifundamental representations . each stack may also intersect its own image @xmath16 , resulting in chiral fermions in the symmetric and antisymmetric representations . non - chiral matter may also be present between stacks of d - branes which do not intersect on one two - torus . a zero intersection number between two stacks of branes implies that the branes are parallel on at least one torus . at such kind of intersection additional non - chiral ( vector - like ) multiplet pairs from @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 can arise . global consistency of the model requires certain constraints to be satisfied , namely , ramond - ramond ( r - r ) tadpole cancellation and the preservation of @xmath20 supersymmetry . in particular , the conditions for preserving @xmath20 supersymmetry fixes the complex structure parameters . .d6-brane configurations and intersection numbers for a three - family pati - salam model on a type - iia @xmath21 orientifold , with a tilted third two - torus . the complete gauge symmetry is @xmath22_{\rm observable } \times [ { \rm u}(2 ) \times { \rm usp}(2)^2]_{\rm hidden}$ ] and @xmath20 supersymmetry is preserved for @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] vector - like matter appears in intersecting / magnetized d - brane models on toroidal orientifolds between stacks of d - branes which do not intersect . the mass of such vector - like states depends upon the separation between the stacks of d - branes in the internal space . as such , it is generically massive . only stacks of d - branes which are directly on top of one another have massless vector - like states between them . in the model studied in section ii , the toroidal orientifold consist of a six - torus which is factorizable , @xmath26 . if two stacks of d - branes are parallel on one two - torus , then vector - like matter appears in the bifundamental representation of the gauge groups within the world - volume of each stack . if the two stacks are not separated on the two torus on which they are parallel , the vector - like multiplets are massless however , these states become massive if the stacks are separated . the most straightforward way to obtain the diphoton excesses is with a sm singlet scalar with a mass @xmath27 gev coupled to vector - like quarks . the coupling to vector - like quarks is necessary in order to produce the scalar via gluon fusion and to allow the decay of the scalar into diphotons . the requisite vector - like quarks are indeed present in the model . in particular , the vector - like quarks and leptons in the @xmath28 and @xmath29 sector fill @xmath30 and @xmath31 spinorial representations of so(10 ) , or equivalently @xmath32 of su(5 ) . for example , @xmath33 it is well - known that gauge coupling unification may be preserved at the 1-loop level if the extra matter comes in complete representations of @xmath1 . however , at the 2 or 3-loop level , a landau pole may appear . this restricts the number of @xmath1 multiplets which may remain light to either one @xmath34 or three copies of @xmath35 . in addition , any number of sm singlets may be present in the light spectrum . generically , there are many more vector - like states in the spectrum , as can be seen from tables [ vector - likespectrummssm1],[vector - likespectrummssm2 ] , and [ vector - likespectrummssm3 ] . thus , in order to preserve gauge coupling unification , many of these states must obtain string - scale masses , while simultaneously maintaining light masses for either of the two cases stated above . recalling that vector - like matter appears between stacks of d - branes which are parallel on one two - torus , the masses of these vector - like states depend on the separation between the stacks on the two - torus on which they are parallel . so , it is possible to give string - scale masses to some of the vector - like states by separating the two stacks of d - branes on the two - torus on which they are parallel and where these vector - like states are localized . is it possible to choose the position of the stacks of d - branes so that only the @xmath36 or @xmath37 fields remain light ? the answer to this question is yes . as an example , let us consider just the fields in the @xmath28 and @xmath29 sectors , where it should be noted that these stacks of d - branes are parallel on the third two - torus . thus , for example the fields @xmath38 may become massive by separating stacks @xmath39 and @xmath15 on the third torus . similarly , the fields @xmath40 may become massive by separating stacks @xmath39 and @xmath41 , while @xmath42 become massive if stacks @xmath43 and @xmath44 are separated on the third two - torus . the fields @xmath45 may remain massless if stacks @xmath39 and @xmath44 overlap on the third two - torus , and the same is true for @xmath46 if stacks @xmath43 and @xmath15 overlap on the third two - torus . thus with this configuration , only the fields in the @xmath47 and @xmath48 ( with @xmath49 ) representations of eq . [ abvector ] remain light . in addition , there are additional vector - like quarks and leptons in the spectrum in the @xmath50 and @xmath51 sectors , as shown in tables [ vector - likespectrummssm2 ] and [ vector - likespectrummssm3 ] . these fields may also become massive by separating the relevant stacks of d - branes on the two - torus where they are parallel . for example , stacks @xmath39 and @xmath43 are parallel with stacks @xmath52 and @xmath53 on the third two - torus , and so the vector - like matter in these sectors may be eliminated if these stacks are separated on the third two - torus . similarly , stacks @xmath39 and @xmath43 are parallel with stacks @xmath54 and @xmath55 on the second two - torus , and the vector - like matter in this sector may be eliminated by displacing these stacks on the second two - torus . on the other hand , it must also be kept in mind that splitting the stacks in this fashion may affect the higgs sectors , which are also vector - like . for example the higgs fields @xmath56 and @xmath57 arise from vector - like matter in the @xmath58 and @xmath59 sectors respectively . stackss @xmath39 and @xmath44 must overlap to keep @xmath60 light while stacks @xmath39 and @xmath15 must be separated to give masses to the fields @xmath61 ) such that the light vector - like fields may be placed in @xmath36 representations . however , this implies that stacks @xmath14 and @xmath62 must be separated and thus that the higgs field @xmath57 is not present in the light spectrum . clealy , then it is not possible to eliminate the fields in the @xmath63 while keeping the fields in the @xmath64 without also eliminating some of the higgs field . note that this constraint only applies to those fields in the @xmath28 and @xmath29 sectors . in the next section , we shall also consider the vector - like matter in the @xmath50 and @xmath51 sectors . we shall find that it is possible to have just vector - like matter in the @xmath64 representation without eliminating some of the higgs fields as a by - product . we have seen in the previous section that the model contains vector - like quarks and leptons in the @xmath28 and @xmath29 sectors which may be grouped into complete representations of @xmath1 . furthermore , by displacing the stacks of d - branes , it is possible to eliminate some of these fields from the spectrum so that only three copies of @xmath65 remain light . in this way , gauge coupling unification may be maintained while also avoiding the landau pole problem . however , upon inspection , none of these vector - like quarks and leptons appear to have yukawa couplings with any of the singlet fields present in the model . therefore , they may not be involved in producing the diphoton excesses . however , this is not the case if we examine the vector - like quarks and leptons present in the @xmath50 and @xmath51 sectors . let us turn our attention to the sm singlet fields @xmath66 and @xmath67 shown in table [ hiddenspectrum ] . these fields have yukawa couplings with the vector - like quarks in the @xmath50 and @xmath51 sectors : @xmath68 where @xmath69 and @xmath70 are near the string scale @xmath71 as discussed in section i. in addition , there are yuakwa couplings between these singlets and some of the vector - like doublets : @xmath72 finally , there are additional yukawa couplings between @xmath66 and @xmath67 and the singlet fields in the @xmath73 and @xmath74 sectors : @xmath75 thus , the required couplings of the sm singlet fields to vector - like quarks are present so that the singlet fields may be produced by gluon fusion and decay to diphotons . in addition , the singlet fields have additional couplings to other doublet and singlet fields . note that the vector - like quarks involved in these couplings combined with additional vector - like matter may be placed in complete representations of @xmath1 by replacing the right - handed vector - like quarks , leptons , and singlets in eq . [ abvector ] with some of the quarks , leptons and singlets of tables [ vector - likespectrummssm2 ] and [ vector - likespectrummssm3 ] . for example , making the interchanges @xmath76 we have @xmath77 where @xmath78 , and making the interchanges @xmath79 we have @xmath80 in order to have just three @xmath65 multiplets + additional singlets in the light spectrum , the fields grouped into the @xmath81 multiplets must become massive , as well as any additional vector - like states . to eliminate the vectorlike fields in the @xmath28 and @xmath29 sectors from the light spectrum , we must require that stacks @xmath39 and @xmath43 are separated from stacks @xmath15 , @xmath41 , and @xmath44 on the third two - torus . futhermore , to eliminate the fields in the above @xmath37 , we require that stack @xmath39 be separated from stack @xmath52 on the third two - torus and from @xmath54 on the second two - torus . let us also require that stack @xmath43 be separated from both stacks @xmath52 , @xmath54 , @xmath53 and @xmath55 . to keep the fields in the above @xmath65 representations light , we require that stack @xmath39 overlap with stack @xmath53 on the third two - torus and with stack @xmath55 on the second two torus . in addition , we require that stack @xmath14 overlap stacks @xmath82 , @xmath41 , @xmath62 , and @xmath44 as well as stacks @xmath54 . this configuration assures that the higgs fields @xmath83 and @xmath84 are present in the spectrum . in addition , stack @xmath14 may not overlap stack @xmath54 since stack @xmath39 overlaps stack @xmath52 . since stack @xmath39 and @xmath15 are separated , this implies that stacks @xmath14 and @xmath54 are also separated . then , the fields in the light spectrum consist of the following fields with quantum numbers under the @xmath85 gauge symmetry shown : @xmath86 plus additional singlets . as shown in eq . [ vectorquarksingletyukawa ] , the vector - like quarks @xmath87 and @xmath88 have yukawa couplings with the singlet field @xmath89 . thus , this singlet field may be produced via loops involving these vector - like quarks as well as decay to diphotons via gluon fusion . in addition , the singlet field s has couplings to the doublets @xmath90 to which it may also decay . using the notation of eq . [ lightreps ] , the superpotential for the extra vector - like states and the singlet @xmath91 is @xmath92 the corresponding supersymmetry breaking soft terms are @xmath93 @xmath94&@xmath95&@xmath96&@xmath97&@xmath98&@xmath99&@xmath100&@xmath101&@xmath102&@xmath103&@xmath104&@xmath105&@xmath106&@xmath107&@xmath108&@xmath109&@xmath110&@xmath111&@xmath112 + @xmath113&@xmath114&@xmath115&@xmath116&@xmath117&@xmath118&@xmath119&@xmath120&@xmath121&@xmath122&@xmath123&@xmath124&@xmath125&@xmath126&@xmath127&@xmath128&@xmath129&@xmath130&@xmath131 + @xmath132&@xmath133&@xmath134&@xmath135&@xmath136&@xmath137&@xmath138&@xmath120&@xmath139&@xmath140&@xmath141&@xmath142&@xmath143&@xmath144&@xmath145&@xmath146&@xmath147&@xmath148&@xmath149 + @xmath113&@xmath150&@xmath151&@xmath152&@xmath153&@xmath154&@xmath148&@xmath120&@xmath121&@xmath155&@xmath156&@xmath157&@xmath158&@xmath159&@xmath160&@xmath161&@xmath162&@xmath163&@xmath164 + @xmath165&@xmath166&@xmath134&@xmath135&@xmath167&@xmath168&@xmath169&@xmath120&@xmath170&@xmath171&@xmath172&@xmath173&@xmath174&@xmath175&@xmath176&@xmath177&@xmath178&@xmath179&@xmath180 + @xmath181&@xmath133&@xmath151&@xmath182&@xmath183&@xmath184&@xmath169&@xmath120&@xmath185&@xmath140&@xmath186&@xmath187&@xmath143&@xmath188&@xmath189&@xmath146&@xmath190&@xmath191&@xmath192 + @xmath193&@xmath194&@xmath195&@xmath135&@xmath167&@xmath196&@xmath119&@xmath120&@xmath197&@xmath198&@xmath199&@xmath200&@xmath201&@xmath144&@xmath202&@xmath203&@xmath204&@xmath205&@xmath206 + @xmath193&@xmath114&@xmath207&@xmath135&@xmath208&@xmath209&@xmath119&@xmath120&@xmath197&@xmath122&@xmath210&@xmath211&@xmath125&@xmath212&@xmath213&@xmath128&@xmath214&@xmath215&@xmath216 + [ tab:5gev ] @xmath94&@xmath95&@xmath96&@xmath97&@xmath98&@xmath99&@xmath100&@xmath101&@xmath102&@xmath103&@xmath104&@xmath105&@xmath106&@xmath107&@xmath108&@xmath109&@xmath110&@xmath111&@xmath112 + @xmath113&@xmath114&@xmath134&@xmath217&@xmath218&@xmath133&@xmath169&@xmath120&@xmath121&@xmath122&@xmath219&@xmath220&@xmath125&@xmath221&@xmath222&@xmath223&@xmath224&@xmath225&@xmath119 + @xmath226&@xmath114&@xmath227&@xmath182&@xmath228&@xmath229&@xmath119&@xmath120&@xmath230&@xmath122&@xmath231&@xmath232&@xmath125&@xmath233&@xmath234&@xmath223&@xmath235&@xmath236&@xmath237 + @xmath238&@xmath114&@xmath195&@xmath239&@xmath240&@xmath241&@xmath169&@xmath120&@xmath242&@xmath122&@xmath243&@xmath244&@xmath125&@xmath245&@xmath199&@xmath223&@xmath246&@xmath236&@xmath247 + @xmath193&@xmath150&@xmath140&@xmath135&@xmath248&@xmath249&@xmath169&@xmath120&@xmath197&@xmath155&@xmath250&@xmath251&@xmath158&@xmath221&@xmath252&@xmath253&@xmath224&@xmath254&@xmath255 + @xmath256&@xmath150&@xmath257&@xmath217&@xmath258&@xmath259&@xmath119&@xmath120&@xmath260&@xmath155&@xmath261&@xmath262&@xmath158&@xmath245&@xmath263&@xmath253&@xmath224&@xmath264&@xmath191 + @xmath226&@xmath150&@xmath227&@xmath239&@xmath228&@xmath265&@xmath169&@xmath120&@xmath230&@xmath155&@xmath266&@xmath267&@xmath158&@xmath245&@xmath268&@xmath253&@xmath269&@xmath270&@xmath271 + @xmath272&@xmath150&@xmath273&@xmath274&@xmath275&@xmath276&@xmath169&@xmath120&@xmath277&@xmath155&@xmath278&@xmath279&@xmath158&@xmath280&@xmath281&@xmath253&@xmath282&@xmath283&@xmath284 + [ tab:45gev ] the 750 gev diphoton production cross - sections observed by the cms collaboration are @xmath285 at @xmath286 tev @xciteand @xmath287 at @xmath288 tev @xcite , while the atlas collaboration observed @xmath289 at @xmath286 tev @xcite and @xmath290 at @xmath288 tev @xcite . replicating the strategy of ref . @xcite , we constrain the total decay width to @xmath291 gev . to reproduce the observed production cross - sections , we constrain the model using @xmath292 . the effective loop - level couplings amongst the standard model gauge bosons and scalar @xmath91 are given by @xmath293 \label{lagrangian}\ ] ] where @xmath294 and @xmath295 are the photon and gluon field strength tensors , respectively , with @xmath296 . the effective operators are represented by @xmath297 and @xmath298 , which are written as @xmath299 \label{kem}\ ] ] @xmath300 \label{k3}\ ] ] where @xmath301 , @xmath302 , and @xmath303 , and the functions @xmath304 and @xmath305 are expressed as @xmath306 \\ & & f_{\widetilde{f } } = \chi \left [ -1 + \chi f(\chi ) \right ] \ \label{feq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the function @xmath307 denoted by @xmath308 the triangle loop functions @xmath309 are defined here as @xmath310 & \mbox{if } \chi \geq 1 \\ -\frac{1}{4 } \left [ \ln \frac{1 + \sqrt{1 - \chi}}{1 - \sqrt{1 - \chi } } - i \pi \right]^2 & \mbox{if } \chi < 1 . \end{cases } \label{loop_function}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the diphoton and digluon decay widths in @xmath311-@xmath1 are computed from @xmath312 @xmath313 the diphoton production cross - section is calculated from @xmath314 where k is the qcd k - factor , @xmath315 is the total decay width , @xmath316 is the proton - proton center of mass energy , and @xmath317 is the dimensionless partonic integral computed for an @xmath318 gev resonance , yielding @xmath319 at @xmath286 tev and @xmath320 at @xmath288 tev @xcite . we use the gluon fusion k - factor of 1.98 . we construct our intersecting d - brane model with the ( @xmath321,@xmath322 ) and ( @xmath323,@xmath324 ) vector - like particles , implementing three copies of the ( @xmath325,@xmath326 ) . for the calculations , we decompose the @xmath327 multiplet into its @xmath328 and @xmath329 components . given the null @xmath330 electric charge @xmath331 , no constraints can be placed on @xmath332 , @xmath333 , or @xmath334 in the model via the production cross - section calculations , so for simplicity we set @xmath335 and @xmath336 when computing the decay of the scalar @xmath91 directly to the @xmath330 multiplet . the multiplets @xmath337 and @xmath328 participate in the @xmath338 loop diagrams and only @xmath337 in the @xmath339 loops , hence there are 8 free parameters in the effective operators @xmath297 and @xmath298 consisting of the yukawa couplings @xmath340 , trilinear a term couplings @xmath341 , fermionic component masses @xmath342 , and scalar component masses @xmath343 . in total , there are 10 parameters to compute : @xmath344 though the supersymmetry breaking soft terms @xmath345 and @xmath346 can be trivially computed from the fermionic and scalar components using the following relations @xmath347 the freedom on the 8 free - parameters engenders a large d - brane model parameter space . we treat the fermionic component of the vector - like particle and its soft supersymmetry breaking term independently , such that @xmath348 . recent constraints at the lhc on vector - like @xmath349 quarks @xcite provide lower limits of around 735 gev for the @xmath321 multiplet , allowing a light @xmath350 multiplet , which contributes to invisible branching fractions when @xmath351 gev . for the large yukawa couplings @xmath352 and @xmath101 at the unification scale , there exist the quasi focus points with @xmath353 and @xmath354 at low energy , respectively @xcite . constraints are placed on the @xmath355 terms of @xmath356 and @xmath357 to preclude premature breaking of the @xmath358 gauge symmetry . we provide some sample benchmark points in table [ tab:5gev ] and table [ tab:45gev ] to illustrate that the model can accommodate the observed diphoton cross - section . note that the cross - sections @xmath111 and @xmath112 in tables [ tab:5gev ] - [ tab:45gev ] display a gain of 4.65 from 8 tev to 13 tev . we use values of the coupling constants at the @xmath359 scale in our calculations of @xmath360 and @xmath361 . the diphoton and digluon decay modes are only a small portion of the total decay width , as shown in tables [ tab:5gev ] - [ tab:45gev ] . these practical constraints on the diphoton and digluon decay widths allocate the majority of the total width to the other decay channels , for instance , to dark matter invisibly and/or @xmath362 and @xmath363 , kinematically allowed for both @xmath95 and @xmath332 less than 375 gev , which is reflected in the @xmath106 decay width and @xmath364 branching ratio in tables [ tab:5gev ] - [ tab:45gev ] . specifically , the decay width for the decay into pairs of fermions @xmath365 is given by @xmath366 where we take @xmath367 and @xmath368 in the calculations . we have studied the diphoton excesses near @xmath0 gev recently reported by the atlas and cms collaborations within the context of a phenomenologically interesting intersecting / magnetized d - brane model on a toroidal orientifold . we have shown that the model contains a sm singlet scalar as well as vector - like quarks and leptons . in addition , we have shown that the singlet scalar has yukawa couplings with vector - like quarks and leptons such that it may be produced in proton - proton collisions via gluon fusion as well as decay to diphotons through loops involving the vector - like quarks . moreover , the required vector - like quarks and leptons may appear in complete @xmath1 multiplets so that gauge coupling unification may be maintained . in particuar , we showed that we may have three copies of @xmath65 representations of @xmath1 in the light spectrum which are present in the model . finally , we showed that the diphoton excesses observed by the atlas and cms collaborations may be accommodated . it should be emphasized that we have obtained these results within the context of a complete , globally consistent string model . this particular model has many interesting phenomenological features such as automatic gauge coupling unification , realistic yukawa mass matrices for quarks and leptons , and mimimal exotic matter . it is of note that the singlet fields required to explain the diphoton signal arise from this extra matter . in addition , the required vector - like quarks are naturally present in the spectrum . finally , the yukawa couplings between the singlet fields and the vector - like quarks are allowed by the global symmetries arising from @xmath9 factors whose gauge bosons become heavy at the string scale via the green - schwarz mechanism , a result which is completely non - trivial . an interesting question is whether or not is it possible to obtain supersymmetry partner spectra from the model which take into account the light vector - like matter . as mentioned earlier , the vector - like quarks and leptons have yukawa couplings with the higgs fields in the model , and thus may raise the higgs mass by up to a few gev . this may alleviate the problem with electroweak fine - tuning . in addition , the vector - like matter affects the rge running of the soft masses . finally , the soft supersymmetry breaking masses may be calculated at the string scale in the model . thus , it would be very interesting to study the possible supersymmetry partner spectra obtainable in the model including the extra vector - like matter . we plan to study this in future work . k. harigaya and y. nomura , arxiv:1512.04850 [ hep - ph ] ; y. mambrini , g. arcadi and a. djouadi , arxiv:1512.04913 [ hep - ph ] ; m. backovic , a. mariotti and d. redigolo , arxiv:1512.04917 [ hep - ph ] ; a. angelescu , a. djouadi and g. moreau , arxiv:1512.04921 [ hep - ph ] ; y. nakai , r. sato and k. tobioka , arxiv:1512.04924 [ hep - ph ] ; s. knapen , t. melia , m. papucci and k. zurek , arxiv:1512.04928 [ hep - ph ] ; d. buttazzo , a. greljo and d. marzocca , arxiv:1512.04929 [ hep - ph ] ; a. pilaftsis , arxiv:1512.04931 [ hep - ph ] ; r. franceschini _ et al . _ , arxiv:1512.04933 [ hep - ph ] ; s. di chiara , l. marzola and m. raidal , arxiv:1512.04939 [ hep - ph ] . s. d. mcdermott , p. meade and h. ramani , arxiv:1512.05326 [ hep - ph ] ; r. benbrik , c. h. chen and t. nomura , arxiv:1512.06028 [ hep - ph ] ; j. ellis , s. a. r. ellis , j. quevillon , v. sanz and t. you , arxiv:1512.05327 [ hep - ph ] ; m. low , a. tesi and l. t. wang , arxiv:1512.05328 [ hep - ph ] ; b. bellazzini , r. franceschini , f. sala and j. serra , arxiv:1512.05330 [ hep - ph ] ; r. s. gupta , s. jger , y. kats , g. perez and e. stamou , arxiv:1512.05332 [ hep - ph ] ; c. petersson and r. torre , arxiv:1512.05333 [ hep - ph ] ; e. molinaro , f. sannino and n. vignaroli , arxiv:1512.05334 [ hep - ph ] ; q. h. cao , y. liu , k. p. xie , b. yan and d. m. zhang , arxiv:1512.05542 [ hep - ph ] ; s. matsuzaki and k. yamawaki , arxiv:1512.05564 [ hep - ph ] ; a. kobakhidze , f. wang , l. wu , j. m. yang and m. zhang , arxiv:1512.05585 [ hep - ph ] ; r. martinez , f. ochoa and c. f. sierra , arxiv:1512.05617 [ hep - ph ] ; p. cox , a. d. medina , t. s. ray and a. spray , arxiv:1512.05618 [ hep - ph ] ; d. becirevic , e. bertuzzo , o. sumensari and r. z. funchal , arxiv:1512.05623 [ hep - ph ] ; j. m. no , v. sanz and j. setford , arxiv:1512.05700 [ hep - ph ] ; s. v. demidov and d. s. gorbunov , arxiv:1512.05723 [ hep - ph ] ; w. chao , r. huo and j. h. yu , arxiv:1512.05738 [ hep - ph ] ; s. fichet , g. von gersdorff and c. royon , arxiv:1512.05751 [ hep - ph ] ; d. curtin and c. b. verhaaren , arxiv:1512.05753 [ hep - ph ] ; l. bian , n. chen , d. liu and j. shu , arxiv:1512.05759 [ hep - ph ] ; j. chakrabortty , a. choudhury , p. ghosh , s. mondal and t. srivastava , arxiv:1512.05767 [ hep - ph ] ; a. ahmed , b. m. dillon , b. grzadkowski , j. f. gunion and y. jiang , arxiv:1512.05771 [ hep - ph ] ; c. csaki , j. hubisz and j. terning , arxiv:1512.05776 [ hep - ph ] ; d. aloni , k. blum , a. dery , a. efrati and y. nir , arxiv:1512.05778 [ hep - ph ] ; y. bai , j. berger and r. lu , arxiv:1512.05779 [ hep - ph ] ; e. gabrielli , k. kannike , b. mele , m. raidal , c. spethmann and h. veerme , arxiv:1512.05961 [ hep - ph ] ; j. s. kim , j. reuter , k. rolbiecki and r. r. de austri , arxiv:1512.06083 [ hep - ph ] ; a. alves , a. g. dias and k. sinha , arxiv:1512.06091 [ hep - ph ] ; e. megias , o. pujolas and m. quiros , arxiv:1512.06106 [ hep - ph ] ; l. m. carpenter , r. colburn and j. goodman , arxiv:1512.06107 [ hep - ph ] ; j. bernon and c. smith , arxiv:1512.06113 [ hep - ph ] ; w. chao , arxiv:1512.06297 [ hep - ph ] ; m. t. arun and p. saha , arxiv:1512.06335 [ hep - ph ] ; c. han , h. m. lee , m. park and v. sanz , arxiv:1512.06376 [ hep - ph ] ; s. chang , arxiv:1512.06426 [ hep - ph ] ; i. chakraborty and a. kundu , arxiv:1512.06508 [ hep - ph ] ; h. han , s. wang and s. zheng , arxiv:1512.06562 [ hep - ph ] ; x. f. han and l. wang , arxiv:1512.06587 [ hep - ph ] ; f. wang , l. wu , j. m. yang and m. zhang , arxiv:1512.06715 [ hep - ph ] ; j. cao , c. han , l. shang , w. su , j. m. yang and y. zhang , arxiv:1512.06728 [ hep - ph ] ; f. p. huang , c. s. li , z. l. liu and y. wang , arxiv:1512.06732 [ hep - ph ] ; j. j. heckman , arxiv:1512.06773 [ hep - ph ] ; x. j. bi , q. f. xiang , p. f. yin and z. h. yu , arxiv:1512.06787 [ hep - ph ] ; j. s. kim , k. rolbiecki and r. r. de austri , arxiv:1512.06797 [ hep - ph ] ; j. m. cline and z. liu , arxiv:1512.06827 [ hep - ph ] ; m. chala , m. duerr , f. kahlhoefer and k. schmidt - hoberg , arxiv:1512.06833 [ hep - ph ] ; s. m. boucenna , s. morisi and a. vicente , arxiv:1512.06878 [ hep - ph ] ; p. s. b. dev and d. teresi , arxiv:1512.07243 [ hep - ph ] ; j. de blas , j. santiago and r. vega - morales , arxiv:1512.07229 [ hep - ph ] ; c. w. murphy , arxiv:1512.06976 [ hep - ph ] ; u. k. dey , s. mohanty and g. tomar , arxiv:1512.07212 [ hep - ph ] ; g. m. pelaggi , a. strumia and e. vigiani , arxiv:1512.07225 [ hep - ph ] ; w. c. huang , y. l. s. tsai and t. c. yuan , arxiv:1512.07268 [ hep - ph ] ; q. h. cao , s. l. chen and p. h. gu , arxiv:1512.07541 [ hep - ph ] ; s. chakraborty , a. chakraborty and s. raychaudhuri , arxiv:1512.07527 [ hep - ph ] ; w. altmannshofer , j. galloway , s. gori , a. l. kagan , a. martin and j. zupan , arxiv:1512.07616 [ hep - ph ] ; m. cveti , j. halverson and p. langacker , arxiv:1512.07622 [ hep - ph ] ; k. das and s. k. rai , arxiv:1512.07789 [ hep - ph ] ; k. cheung , p. ko , j. s. lee , j. park and p. y. tseng , arxiv:1512.07853 [ hep - ph ] ; j. liu , x. p. wang and w. xue , arxiv:1512.07885 [ hep - ph ] ; j. zhang and s. zhou , arxiv:1512.07889 [ hep - ph ] ; g. li , y. n. mao , y. l. tang , c. zhang , y. zhou and s. h. zhu , arxiv:1512.08255 [ hep - ph ] ; m. son and a. urbano , arxiv:1512.08307 [ hep - ph ] ; h. an , c. cheung and y. zhang , arxiv:1512.08378 [ hep - ph ] ; f. wang , w. wang , l. wu , j. m. yang and m. zhang , arxiv:1512.08434 [ hep - ph ] ; q. h. cao , y. liu , k. p. xie , b. yan and d. m. zhang , arxiv:1512.08441 [ hep - ph ] ; j. gao , h. zhang and h. x. zhu , arxiv:1512.08478 [ hep - ph ] ; x. j. bi _ et al . _ , arxiv:1512.08497 [ hep - ph ] . f. goertz , j. f. kamenik , a. katz and m. nardecchia , arxiv:1512.08500 [ hep - ph ] ; p. s. b. dev , r. n. mohapatra and y. zhang , arxiv:1512.08507 [ hep - ph ] ; l. a. anchordoqui , i. antoniadis , h. goldberg , x. huang , d. lust and t. r. taylor , phys . b * 755 * , 312 ( 2016 ) doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2016.02.024 [ arxiv:1512.08502 [ hep - ph ] ] . y. l. tang and s. h. zhu , arxiv:1512.08323 [ hep - ph ] ; j. cao , f. wang and y. zhang , arxiv:1512.08392 [ hep - ph ] ; c. cai , z. h. yu and h. h. zhang , arxiv:1512.08440 [ hep - ph ] ; w. chao , arxiv:1512.08484 [ hep - ph ] ; n. bizot , s. davidson , m. frigerio and j .- l . kneur , arxiv:1512.08508 [ hep - ph ] ; l. e. ibanez and v. martin - lozano , arxiv:1512.08777 [ hep - ph ] ; y. hamada , t. noumi , s. sun and g. shiu , arxiv:1512.08984 [ hep - ph ] ; s. k. kang and j. song , arxiv:1512.08963 [ hep - ph ] ; s. kanemura , k. nishiwaki , h. okada , y. orikasa , s. c. park and r. watanabe , arxiv:1512.09048 [ hep - ph ] ; y. jiang , y. y. li and t. liu , arxiv:1512.09127 [ hep - ph ] ; k. kaneta , s. kang and h. s. lee , arxiv:1512.09129 [ hep - ph ] ; l. marzola , a. racioppi , m. raidal , f. r. urban and h. veerme , arxiv:1512.09136 [ hep - ph ] . a. dasgupta , m. mitra and d. borah , arxiv:1512.09202 [ hep - ph ] . w. chao , arxiv:1601.00633 [ hep - ph ] . w. chao , arxiv:1601.04678 [ hep - ph ] . k. ghorbani and h. ghorbani , arxiv:1601.00602 [ hep - ph ] . u. danielsson , r. enberg , g. ingelman and t. mandal , arxiv:1601.00624 [ hep - ph ] . l. j. hall , k. harigaya and y. nomura , arxiv:1512.07904 [ hep - ph ] ; k. m. patel and p. sharma , arxiv:1512.07468 [ hep - ph ] . r. ding , l. huang , t. li and b. zhu , arxiv:1512.06560 [ hep - ph ] . b. c. allanach , p. s. b. dev , s. a. renner and k. sakurai , arxiv:1512.07645 [ hep - ph ] . u. aydemir and t. mandal , scalars in @xmath370 grand unification , arxiv:1601.06761 [ hep - ph ] . m. berkooz , m. r. douglas and r. g. leigh , nucl . b * 480 * , 265 ( 1996 ) . l. e. ibanez , f. marchesano and r. rabadan , jhep * 0111 * , 002 ( 2001 ) . r. blumenhagen , b. kors , d. lust and t. ott , nucl . b * 616 * , 3 ( 2001 ) . m. cveti , g. shiu and a. m. uranga , phys . rev . lett . * 87 * , 201801 ( 2001 ) ; m. cveti , g. shiu and a. m. uranga , nucl . b * 615 * , 3 ( 2001 ) . c. m. chen , t. li and d. v. nanopoulos , nucl . b * 740 * , 79 ( 2006 ) [ hep - th/0601064 ] . c. m. chen , t. li and d. v. nanopoulos , nucl . b * 751 * , 260 ( 2006 ) [ hep - th/0604107 ] . c. m. chen , t. li , v. e. mayes and d. v. nanopoulos , phys . b * 665 * , 267 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0703280 ] . c. m. chen , t. li , v. e. mayes and d. v. nanopoulos , phys . d * 77 * , 125023 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0711.0396 [ hep - ph ] ] . j. a. maxin , v. e. mayes and d. v. nanopoulos , phys . d * 84 * , 106009 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1108.0887 [ hep - ph ] ] . e. cremmer , s. ferrara , c. kounnas and d. v. nanopoulos , phys . b * 133 * , 61 ( 1983 ) . m. dine , n. seiberg , and e. witten , nucl . b * 289 * ( 1987 ) 589 ; j. attick , l. dixon , and a. sen , nucl . b * 292 * ( 1987 ) 109 ; m. dine , i. ichinose , and n. seiberg , nucl . b * 293 * ( 1987 ) 253 . v. khachatryan _ et al . _ [ cms collaboration ] , phys . b * 750 * , 494 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1506.02301 [ hep - ex ] ] . g. aad _ et al . _ [ atlas collaboration ] , phys . lett . * 113 * , no . 17 , 171801 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1407.6583 [ hep - ex ] ] . | we study the diphoton excesses near @xmath0 gev recently reported by the atlas and cms collaborations within the context of a phenomenologically interesting intersecting / magnetized d - brane model on a toroidal orientifold . it is shown that the model contains a sm singlet scalar as well as vector - like quarks and leptons . in addition , it is shown that the singlet scalar has yukawa couplings with vector - like quarks and leptons such that it may be produced in proton - proton collisions via gluon fusion as well as decay to diphotons through loops involving the vector - like quarks . moreover , the required vector - like quarks and leptons may appear in complete @xmath1 multiplets so that gauge coupling unification may be maintained . finally , it is shown that the diphoton signal may be accommodated within the model . |
cond-mat9811404 | synthetic colloids are never perfectly monodisperse . often , this polydispersity is a drawback for instance , polydispersity is a problem in the preparation of high - quality colloidal crystals , that are needed in photonic bandgap materials . however , occasionally , polydispersity is desirable , because it allows us to achieve material properties that can not be realized with monodisperse colloids . for instance , monodisperse colloidal systems can fill at most 74.05 % of space in the crystalline phase ( regular close packing ) and some 63% in the liquid / glassy state ( random close packing ) . in contrast , colloids with a properly chosen particle - size distribution can be made essentially space filling , both in the crystalline solid ( appolonian packing ) and in the liquid . in practice , perfect space filling structures are never achieved because this requires an infinite number of ( predominantly small ) particles per unit volume . here , we consider a somewhat simpler problem , namely the filling of a given volume @xmath2 by a fixed number of particles @xmath0 , that occupy a prescribed total volume fraction @xmath3 . we assume that the particles are free to exchange volume . as we have fixed both the number and the total volume of the particles , the average volume per particle is fixed it defines the natural length - scale in the model . clearly , the helmholtz free energy of the system will depend on the non - fixed particle - size distribution . the distribution , however , is restricted by the two constraints of fixed number of particles and fixed total volume . we define the optimal size distribution to be the one that minimizes the helmholtz free energy under both constraints . in the monte carlo simulations ( performed in the isothermal - isobaric ensemble ) that we report in this paper , we study the density dependence of the particle - size distribution . we compare the simulation results for the size distribution with an analytical estimate that is obtained by solving the percus - yevick ( py ) equation for an @xmath0-component hard - sphere mixture@xcite . not surprisingly , the py equation works very well at low densities . however , the theory breaks down at a surprisingly low density ( @xmath40.26 ) . of course , the fact that an approximate theory fails at a given density , does not imply that there is anything special going on in the system at that density . yet , our simulations indicate that there is the size distribution that was initially uni - modal , becomes bi - modal . we present a theoretical argument supporting this scenario . the remainder of this paper is organized as follows : in section [ simu ] we describe the constant - pressure monte carlo simulations . the percus - yevick expression for the free energy of a system of polydisperse hard spheres with variable size distribution is discussed in section [ idealentr ] and [ theory ] . section [ sec : analytical ] is devoted to the derivation of analytical results turning useful when interpreting the simulation data . the mechanism behind the transition from uni - modal to bi - modal size distribution is also discussed . monte carlo simulations were performed in the isothermal - isobaric ( constant @xmath5 ) ensemble @xcite . this means that the number of particles @xmath0 , the pressure @xmath6 and the temperature @xmath7 are fixed . we attempt three distinct types of trial moves . we change the positions of the particles and allow the volume of simulation box to fluctuate , in order to equilibrate with respect to the applied pressure . since we do not expect any crystalline order at low pressures , a cubic box shape is maintained . the third type of move is the one related to sampling the polydispersity of the system . to this end , we select two particles at random , between which we exchange an amount of volume drawn uniformly from the interval @xmath8 $ ] ( fig . [ poly_move ] ) . the maximum volume change @xmath9 was chosen such that the acceptance of a volume exchange move is between 35 and 50 % . the relative frequency of the three moves is given by @xmath10 . the initial configurations are made by @xmath0 monodisperse spheres on a simple cubic lattice . simulations were performed for system sizes of @xmath0=512 or 1000 , and several different reduced pressures @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the diameter of particles , and @xmath13 denotes an average over particle - size distribution . as @xmath14 is fixed , we choose @xmath15 to define the unit of length that we will use in the remainder of this paper . we use @xmath16 as our unit of energy . all other units that we need , follow from these definitions . the equation of state [ @xmath17 as a function of @xmath18 and the particle size distribution function were determined in the simulations . the results for the equation of state are shown in fig . [ eq_of_state ] . the simulation data have been collected in table [ table - fequ1 ] . at low pressures the particle - size distribution function is a single - peaked function with its maximum at @xmath19 ( figs . [ fig : uni - bi ] , [ prob_dist_pres_0.50 ] and [ snap - low ] ) . at higher pressures ( typically , @xmath20 ) , the particle - size distribution develops a second peak . actually , this second peak is quite small ( _ i.e. _ only a small fraction of all particles becomes `` large '' ) . however , these particles contribute appreciably to the total volume fraction ( fig . [ snap - high ] ) . depending on the pressure this contribution can get as large as 75% . the formation of big particles in these mc simulations is a rather slow `` dynamical '' process . in order to speed up calculations , we did additional simulations , in which we started with a bi - disperse distribution , with one or several big particles containing 99% of the total volume occupied by the spheres , surrounded by a sea of small particles containing the remaining volume . in the 512 particle system , only one or two big particles remain for the lower pressures ( @xmath21 and @xmath22 ) . for higher pressures the number of big particles can stabilize at higher values as well . for the 1000 particle system the maximum number of big particles observed at the lower pressures is three . in addition , the size of these big particles is not the same . it is not clear whether this suggests a further possible fractionation or that it is a consequence of the slow equilibration and that one or more of the big particles are still shrinking . below , we discuss these simulation results in the context of the relevant theoretical predictions , but first let us stop to make certain considerations on the ideal entropy associated with this system . strictly speaking , the ideal entropy of a polydisperse system is infinite @xcite . in a multicomponent system such an entropy is exactly given by @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the molar fraction of species @xmath25 and @xmath26 its thermal wavelength . the usual path towards the entropy of a polydisperse system @xcite ( or for that matter , towards the entropy of continuous signals in information theory @xcite ) is to classify the species into `` boxes '' according to a certain property which distinguishes them ( diameter , volume , molecular weight , etc ) . if @xmath27 denotes such a property species @xmath25 will denote the box having particles with @xmath27 between @xmath28 and @xmath29 , for a given @xmath30 which defines the boxes . if @xmath31 denotes the probability density of a particle having the value @xmath27 for that property , then @xmath32 where @xmath33 is a typical value of the @xmath25th box . ( [ ideal1 ] ) adopts the form @xmath34 the entropy of the polydisperse system is obtained from eq . ( [ ideal2 ] ) taking the limit @xmath35 , and we can clearly see that , besides obtaining the usual expression @xcite @xmath36 \ , , \label{idealpoly}\ ] ] there is also a divergent @xmath37 , which is simply taken as a `` constant '' ignorable term . but expression ( [ idealpoly ] ) is not well defined . suppose we simply change coordinates to label the species from @xmath27 to @xmath38 ( say , from the diameter to the volume ) . then the probability density in the new variable will be @xmath39 . it is straightforward to show that in the new labeling the entropy becomes @xmath40+nk_b \int dy\ , \widetilde w(y)\ln\left|\frac{dy}{dx}\right| \ , , \label{newideal}\ ] ] which is different of what we would have obtained had we began with the labeling @xmath38 . this is a well known fact in information theory @xcite . in the study of fluid equilibria of _ quenched _ polydisperse systems this fact turns out to be irrelevant because the new term simply adds the same constant to both sides of the equilibrium equations @xcite . however when studying _ annealed _ polydispersity this results tells us that the labeling is crucial and has to be dictated by the physical process underlying the polydispersity . in our case the monte carlo movements described in section [ simu ] are a large scale description of a hypothetical microscopic system of tiny particles of exactly the same size distributed among @xmath0 aggregates of a variable number of particles . the constant volume constraint would correspond to the conservation of the number of tiny particles , and the natural labeling of the aggregates would be the number of tiny particles which form it . as this number is proportional to the volume of the aggregate , in the continuum description is the volume , instead of the diameter , what turns out to be the natural labeling . notice that we could have described another model in which the tiny particles aggregated into spherical surfaces . in that case it would be the total surface what would be preserved and the natural labeling of aggregates would be their respective surfaces . as we will discuss in the conclusions , the physics of this model would be completely different . the percus - yevick equation for an @xmath41-component hard - sphere mixture can be solved analytically , to yield the following equation of state @xcite : @xmath42 the @xmath43-th moment of the particle - size distribution @xmath44 is defined as @xmath45 where @xmath46 , the index @xmath25 is used to denote the different particle species , and @xmath47 is the volume of the @xmath25-th species . equation ( [ py - eos ] ) is also valid for a continuous size distribution , in which case the sum in eq . ( [ xi - j ] ) is replaced by an integral . the corresponding expression for the chemical potential of a species with radius @xmath48 is@xcite @xmath49- \ln ( 1-\xi _ { 3})+\frac{6\xi _ { 2}r } { ( 1-\xi _ { 3})}+\frac{12\xi _ { 1}r^{2}}{(1-\xi _ { 3})}+\frac{18\xi _ { 2}^{2}r^{2}}{(1-\xi _ { 3})^{2}}+\frac{4\pi } { 3}p^ * r^{3 } \label{py - mu}\ ] ] where @xmath50 is the de - broglie thermal wavelength , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 is the probability density to find a particle with a volume around @xmath53 . the pressure @xmath54 is given by eq . ( [ py - eos ] ) . in an ( npt ) description , the gibbs free energy of the system fulfilling the constraints , must be at a minimum . the conservation of the number of particles and of the solid volume fraction , imply that @xmath52 must be of the form : @xmath55 where @xmath56 the coefficients @xmath57 and @xmath58 are determined by the constraints that the number of particles and the solid volume fraction are fixed . note that all @xmath59 @xmath60 are positive . moreover , @xmath61 is equal to the volume fraction @xmath3 , and is therefore necessarily less than one . hence , @xmath62 and @xmath63 are always negative . the last coefficient , @xmath58 , should be negative or zero , because otherwise the particle - size distribution can not be normalized . since @xmath64 , @xmath63 and @xmath58 are always negative the percus - yevick equation predicts that @xmath52 is a monotonically decreasing function of @xmath65 . this implies that the size - distribution given by eq . ( [ g(nu)-2 ] ) can never be bi - modal . note that these conclusions also hold for the more accurate equation of state of mansoori _ et al . _ this equation adds an extra term to the pressure given in eq . ( [ py - eos ] ) depending on @xmath66 . ( [ py - mu ] ) is the same with the new expression for @xmath6which turns out to be irrelevant because the @xmath67 term is controlled by the lagrange multiplier associated with the constraint on the total solid particle volume . in other respect , the analysis for the mansoori equation - of - state is identical to that for py . in practice , we solve eq . ( [ g(nu)-2 ] ) numerically . to this end , we represent @xmath52 as a histogram . initially , the value of @xmath52 in the different bins is assigned an arbitrary non - negative value , compatible with the constraint that @xmath52 is normalized and that @xmath68 is fixed . we fix the density at the desired value . we determine the optimal @xmath69 using the following scheme : we select a bin ( say @xmath25 ) at random and change the value of @xmath70 by a random amount @xmath71 , distributed uniformly in the interval @xmath72 $ ] . we first check if the new value @xmath70 is non - negative . if it is , we satisfy the constraints by scaling the width of all bins and the height of the function by two appropriately chosen factors . we then compute all moments @xmath44 , the pressure and the free energy , and we check if the helmholtz free energy is smaller than the previous one . if it is , we accept the new value for @xmath73 , otherwise we reject it . we repeat the procedure until the free energy no longer decreases . we have verified that @xmath52 is indeed of the form given by eqs . ( [ g(nu)-2 ] ) through ( [ alpha-2 ] ) . figure [ prob_dist_pres_0.50 ] shows a comparison of the py estimate for @xmath52 , determined in this way , with the results of the full monte carlo simulations . we find that @xmath58 is a monotonically increasing function of density . a comparison between simulation and py theory for the equation of state is shown in fig . [ eq_of_state ] . note that , in this figure , the py solution terminates at pressure @xmath74 ( the cross in fig . [ eq_of_state ] ) . this is the point where @xmath58 becomes zero . beyond this point we can no longer find a solution for @xmath52 that is of the form given by eq . ( [ g(nu)-2 ] ) . in appendix [ app : py ] , we consider the breakdown of the py theory in more detail and obtain the packing fraction beyond which the py approximation breaks down : @xmath75 , the corresponding pressure being @xmath76 . this breakdown of the py equation at a relatively low density is surprising , as the py equation works well up to quite high densities for _ fixed _ particle size distributions @xcite . that it breaks down regardless the accuracy of the equation of state can be inferred from the fact that mansoori _ s equation of state undergoes exactly the same breakdown , though for slightly different values of @xmath3 and @xmath6 . besides , from the analysis that we have carried out , it can be seen that a similar breakdown will appear for any other theory yielding an equation of state depending only on @xmath59 , @xmath77 . in this section , we derive a theoretical bound for the pressure of the polydisperse system , providing the equation of state at the packing fraction where the size distribution becomes bi - modal . to this end , we work in the ( @xmath78 ) ensemble and take advantage of the extremality of the helmholtz free energy under the constraints of constant @xmath0 and @xmath79 : the `` grand potential '' @xmath80 where @xmath81 and @xmath82 are lagrange multipliers , has to be minimum for the optimal size distribution . in the above relation , the free energy functional @xmath83 can be cast into the usual ideal and excess contributions @xmath84 + { \cal f}_{\hbox{\scriptsize excess}}\{w\}.\ ] ] we attempt the following change in the system : the volume of a given particle @xmath85 is increased by an amount @xmath86 , before a rescaling of all volumes by a factor @xmath87 ( _ e.g. _ @xmath88 ) such that the overall volume change vanishes . this imposes : @xmath89 ^ 2\right).\ ] ] the effect of the expansion of particle @xmath85 on the size - distribution can be written : @xmath90,\ ] ] where @xmath91 denotes the dirac distribution . the scaling procedure affects @xmath92 according to @xmath93}{dv } \,+\ , { \cal o}\left([\delta v_0]^2\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the corresponding variation of the ideal contribution to @xmath83 reads @xmath94 with the functional derivative @xmath95.\ ] ] we then get the entropic term @xmath96 \left [ \delta \left ( v - v_0-\delta v_0\right)-\delta\left(v - v_0\right ) + \frac{\delta v_0}{\langle v\rangle}\ , \frac{d [ v w]}{dv } \right ] \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! \\ & = & k_b t \left\ { \frac{w'(v_0)}{w(v_0 ) } + \frac{1}{\langle v\rangle}\right\ } \delta v_0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath97 is the derivative of @xmath92 . the variation of the excess free energy reduces to the reversible work needed to perform the transformation , and is derived in appendix [ app : work ] : @xmath98 where @xmath99 denotes the radial distribution function evaluated at contact between species of diameters @xmath100 ( having volume @xmath85 ) and @xmath12 ( having volume @xmath65 ) . when @xmath101 , we can replace the density at the surface of particle @xmath85 by that at a planar wall , and eq . ( [ eq : wrevtout ] ) becomes @xmath102 \delta v_0.\ ] ] in this limit @xmath103 @xmath104 for the optimal size distribution , @xmath105 vanishes so that @xmath106 = 0 . \label{eq : equilw}\ ] ] assuming @xmath52 to be a normalizable distribution , @xmath107 has to be negative for large arguments , which sets the upper bound : @xmath108 for the rescaled pressure . for low packing fractions ( @xmath109 ) where the py solution is available , the above inequality is fulfilled ( fig . [ eq_of_state ] ) . at the threshold @xmath110 where the second polydispersity peak appears , @xmath97 changes sign which means @xmath111 the above relation is remarkably well obeyed within the py approximation ( see the data of section [ theory ] or figure [ eq_of_state ] : the py expression crosses the line given by eq . ( [ eq : pbound ] ) exactly at @xmath112 ) . for @xmath113 , the upper bound is violated by the simulation results reported in table [ table - fequ1 ] and figure [ eq_of_state ] . however , the data suggest non negligible finite - size effects : increasing @xmath0 shifts the pressure closer to the theoretical bound . besides , starting from bi - disperse initial conditions ( cf the procedure described in section [ simu ] ) , supposed to be closer to the expected polydispersity , has the same effect . according to expressions ( [ eq : rouge ] ) and ( [ eq : equilw ] ) , the violation of eq . ( [ eq : pbound ] ) means that @xmath114 for @xmath115 , so that the biggest particle tends to expand . its growth is however necessarily limited by the length @xmath116 of the simulation box . this is supported by the observation that , even for the largest system investigated ( @xmath117 particles ) , the size of the biggest particle obtained is determined by @xmath116 ( @xmath118 , irrespective of the packing fraction , see for example figure [ snap - high ] ) . this suggests that system sizes that would presumably allow the system to reach thermodynamic equilibrium ( and fulfill inequality ( [ eq : pbound ] ) ) are numerically out of reach . consequently , the question of the extensivity / intensivity of the number of large particles can not be addressed by simulations ; a theoretical investigation seems to require the detailed knowledge of the interfacial free energy between `` large '' and `` small '' species . at this stage , we can not tell whether a true phase transition is associated with the occurrence of the second peak in the particle - size distribution . the available data certainly do not rule out this possibility . finally , the integration of eq . ( [ eq : equilw ] ) yields the tail of the optimal size - distribution : @xmath119 equation ( [ g(nu)-2 ] ) obeys this relation , which can not be tested against simulation results because of the lack of statistics for very large particles ( not more than 5 in a typical run ) . at this stage , we can only speculate what will happen at larger @xmath0 and/or larger densities . conceivably , once the volume - fraction of the large particles exceeds a certain threshold , proliferation of still larger particles can occur , and so on , until eventually an packing of the liquid is achieved . the theoretical analysis of this scenario is non - trivial , as the small particles now induce attractive depletion forces between the large particles . unfortunately , the systems that we can conveniently study by simulation are too small to allow us to investigate this regime . we stress that the specific model we have chosen to study is somewhat arbitrary . for instance , rather than fixing the number of particles , one might have chosen to fix the total surface area of the particles . the latter constraint would be logical if one aims to model the size distribution of droplets covered with a fixed amount of surfactant . in addition , we assume that the surface free energy of the spheres is negligible . again , this constraint can be removed . we hope that the rather surprising results of the present study will stimulate research into these related models . we thank bela mulder for critical discussions . the work of the fom institute is part of the research program of fom and is made possible by financial support from the netherlands organization for scientific research ( nwo ) . junfang zhang acknowledges financial support from chinese government . jos cuesta participated in this work during a stay at amolf financed by the project no . pr95 - 558 from the direccin general de enseanza superior ( dges ) . his work is also part of the dges project no . he also wants to thank the hospitality found at amolf , specially from daan frenkel s and bela mulder s groups . let us consider the range of densities where a solution of the percus - yevick equation is possible . as stated in section [ theory ] , it is essential that @xmath58 be non - positive . hence , the pressure at which @xmath120 defines the end point of the theory . to locate this point , consider the form of the solution at the point where @xmath120 . then the distribution function reduces to @xmath121 where @xmath48 hereafter denotes a reduced radius measured in units of @xmath122 . using the two constraints for normalization and for the average volume of the particles , we can express the coefficients @xmath57 and @xmath123 in terms of @xmath62 . if we combine eqs . ( [ alpha-1 ] ) and ( [ alpha-2 ] ) to eliminate @xmath66 , we obtain @xmath124 where the ratio of the moments @xmath125/@xmath126 does not depend explicitly on the density @xmath127 or on @xmath57 , but it only depends on @xmath62 itself . in the second line we have used the definition @xmath128 but we have another relation between the moments of the particle - size distribution : partial integration of @xmath129 yields @xmath130 _ { 0}^{\infty } = \int_{0}^{\infty } \left ( 2\alpha _ { 2}r^{n+2}+\alpha _ { 1}r^{n+1}+(n+1)r^{n}\right ) w(v)dr=0\ ] ] for @xmath131 . this leads to the identities @xmath132 this allows us to write @xmath133 and @xmath134 as a function of @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath135 and @xmath136 ; i.e. @xmath137 but @xmath138 and @xmath139 ; hence @xmath140 substituting this expression in eq . ( [ a1-a2 ] ) , we can eliminate @xmath141 to obtain @xmath142 for what follows , it is convenient to introduce two new variables @xmath143 and @xmath144 @xmath145 then @xmath146 we can use this relation to express @xmath143 as function of @xmath144 . we use the fact that the average volume per particle is fixed , to rewrite @xmath147 where the second line defines the function @xmath148 hence @xmath149 as @xmath150 can be expressed explicitly in terms of error functions , we now know @xmath143 as a function of @xmath144 . equation ( [ a1fca2ff ] ) allows us to express both @xmath62 and @xmath63 as explicit functions of @xmath144 . we can then use eq . ( [ self - consist1 ] ) to determine @xmath144 numerically . we find that this equation has a unique solution . once the value of @xmath144 has been determined , we know @xmath151 and @xmath57 ( from the normalization condition ) . ( [ alpha-1 ] ) finally yields the packing fraction beyond which the py approximation breaks down : @xmath152 . the corresponding pressure is @xmath153 . we first note that the reversible work done by an operator rescaling both particle volumes ( @xmath154 ) and container volume ( @xmath155 ) , is @xmath156 in the transformation , the total volume @xmath157 of the particles changes according to @xmath158 keeping the particle volumes fixed and going back to the original container volume ( @xmath159 ) requires the reversible work @xmath160 it is then straightforward to obtain the work associated with a rescaling of particle volumes at constant accessible volume @xmath2 : @xmath161 valid for all polydispersities @xmath52 . in the remainder , the shall derive the work needed to grow a particle @xmath85 by an amount @xmath86 ( @xmath162 ) . we assume the normalization @xmath163 to hold . consider species having volumes between @xmath65 and @xmath164 ( diameters between @xmath12 and @xmath165 ) . they exert a pressure @xmath166 on particle @xmath85 , involving the radial distribution function at contact between species @xmath100 and @xmath12 . for the above pair @xmath167 , the excluded volume sphere has diameter @xmath168 , and sweeps a volume @xmath169 during the growth of particle @xmath85 . summing over all species @xmath65 , the work performed by the operator takes the form @xmath170 for the size modification considered in section [ sec : analytical ] , the global volume change of the particles vanishes , such that @xmath171 . summing the contributions arising from eqs . ( [ eq : abw1 ] ) and ( [ eq : abw2 ] ) , the results of eq . ( [ eq : wrevtout ] ) is recovered : @xmath172 note that a similar argument can be invoked to compute the reversible work needed to rescale all particle diameters , at constant @xmath2 . after integration of eq . ( [ eq : abw2 ] ) over all @xmath173 , we obtain : @xmath174 inserting this result into eq . ( [ eq : abw1 ] ) provides the equation of state for a polydisperse fluid of hard spheres @xmath175 for a monodisperse fluid , @xmath176 and we recover the well known relation @xmath177 .equation of state of polydisperse hard spheres , obtained from mc simulations with 1000 particles . the estimated error in the last digit of the packing fraction @xmath3 is indicated in parentheses . [ table - fequ1 ] [ cols="<,<",options="header " , ] 1 . schematic drawing of the monte carlo trial used to sample the polydispersity . of two randomly chosen particles the volume of one is increased , while the other is decreased in volume by the same amount . 2 . the equation of state of the polydisperse system . the solid line is the py prediction , which can not be extended beyond the cross . the circles correspond to a system initially prepared monodisperse , while the squares are final values in which we initially started with one big particle . the solid squares and the open symbols are from a 512 and 1000 particle system respectively . the dashed line is the upper bound ( [ eq : upperbound ] ) for the pressure . 3 . the monte carlo results for the distribution of particle volumes , @xmath52 , as a function of @xmath65 , for several reduced pressures for a 1000 particle system . for @xmath20 the distribution develops a second peak ( with statistical noise ) at much larger volumes ( note the change in scale on the right - hand side of the figure ) . although there are only one or several of these big particles , they can contribute over 30% of the total volume of all particles . the diameters can get larger than a third of the length of the simulation box . comparison of the numerical results ( dashed line ) for the particle - size distribution @xmath52 , with the corresponding prediction of the py theory ( solid line ) . these results were obtained at a relatively low pressure ( @xmath178 ) , which corresponds to a volume fraction @xmath179 . note that at this density , simulation and theory are in quite good agreement . snapshot of a typical configuration at reduced pressure @xmath180 and volume fraction @xmath181 . 6 . snapshot of a typical configuration at reduced pressure @xmath22 and volume fraction @xmath182 . in this case there are two big particles . | we consider the effect of intermolecular interactions on the optimal size - distribution of @xmath0 hard spheres that occupy a fixed total volume . when we minimize the free - energy of this system , within the percus - yevick approximation , we find that no solution exists beyond a quite low threshold ( @xmath1 ) . monte carlo simulations reveal that beyond this density , the size - distribution becomes bi - modal . such distributions can not be reproduced within the percus - yevick approximation . we present a theoretical argument that supports the occurrence of a non - monotonic size - distribution and emphasizing the importance of finite size effects . |
nucl-th0104018 | elliptic flow , @xmath5 , the differential second moment of the azimuthal momentum distribution , has been the subject of increasing interest @xcite , especially since the discovery@xcite at rhic that @xmath6 gev ) @xmath7 . this sizable high-@xmath4 collective effect depends strongly on the dynamics in a heavy ion collision and provides important information about the density and effective energy loss of partons . the simplest theoretical framework to study elliptic flow is ideal hydrodynamics@xcite . for rhic energies , ideal hydrodynamics agrees remarkably well with the measured elliptic flow data@xcite up to transverse momenta @xmath8 gev@xmath9 . however , it fails to saturate at high @xmath10 gev as does the data reported by star at quark matter 2001 . a theoretical problem with ideal hydrodynamics is that it assumes local equilibrium throughout the whole evolution . this idealization is marginal for conditions encountered in heavy ion collisions@xcite . a theoretical framework is required that allows for nonequilibrium dynamics . covariant boltzmann transport theory provides a convenient framework that depends on the local mean free path @xmath11 . parton cascade simulations@xcite show on the other hand , that the initial parton density based on hijing@xcite is too low to produce the observed elliptic flow unless the pqcd cross sections are artificially enhanced by a factor @xmath12 . however , gluon saturation models@xcite predict up to five times higher initial densities , and these may be dense enough to generate the observed collective flow even with pqcd elastic cross sections . in this study , we explore the dependence of elliptic flow on the initial density and the elastic @xmath13 cross section . calculations based on inelastic parton energy loss@xcite also predict saturation or decreasing @xmath14 at high @xmath4 . these calculations are only valid for high @xmath4 , where collective transverse flow from lower-@xmath4 partons can be neglected . the collective component from low @xmath4 is , on the other hand , automatically incorporated in parton cascades . though parton cascades lack at present covariant inelastic energy loss , elastic energy loss alone may account for the observed high-@xmath4 azimuthal flow pattern as long as the number of elastic collisions is large enough @xcite . forerunners of this study @xcite computed elliptic flow for partonic systems starting from initial conditions expected at rhic . here , we extend these in three aspects . we compute the @xmath4-differential elliptic flow @xmath15 , model hadronization , which enables us to compute the final observable hadron flow , and consider realistic nuclear geometry . we consider here , as in @xcite , the simplest form of lorentz - covariant boltzmann transport theory in which the on - shell phase space density @xmath16 , evolves with an elastic @xmath17 rate . we solve the transport equation using the cascade method , which inherently violates lorentz covariance . to ensure lorentz covariance , we apply the parton subdivision technique@xcite . see @xcite for details . the elastic gluon scattering matrix elements in dense parton systems are modeled by a debye - screened form @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the screening mass , @xmath20 is the total cross section , which we chose to be independent of energy . the initial condition was a longitudinally boost invariant bjorken tube in local thermal equilibrium at @xmath21 mev at proper time @xmath22 fm/@xmath23 as by fitting the gluon mini - jet transverse momentum spectrum predicted by hijing@xcite ( without shadowing and jet quenching ) . the pseudo - rapidity distribution was taken as uniform between @xmath24 , while the transverse density distribution was assumed to be proportional to the binary collision distribution for two woods - saxon distributions . for collisions at impact parameter @xmath25 , the transverse binary collision profile is @xmath26 , where @xmath27 , in terms of the diffuse nuclear density @xmath28 . from hijing , the pqcd jet cross section normalization at @xmath29 , @xmath30 is fixed such that @xmath31 . the evolution was performed numerically with 40 and 100 mb isotropic cross sections , and with 3 , 40 and 100 mb gluonic cross sections ( @xmath32 ) . we used particle subdivision @xmath33 for impact parameters 0 , 2 , and 4 fm , while @xmath34 , 450 , 1100 , and 5000 , for @xmath35 , 8 , 10 , and 12 fm . two different hadronization schemes were applied . one is based on local parton - hadron duality , where as @xcite , we assumed that each gluon gets converted to a pion with equal probability for the three isospin states . hence , @xmath36 the other hadronization prescription was independent fragmentation . we considered only the @xmath37 channel with the nlo fragmentation function from @xcite . for the scale factor @xmath38 we take @xmath39 because the initial hijing gluon distribution is already quenched due to initial and final state radiation . since we do not consider soft physics , we limit our study to hadrons with @xmath40 gev . [ figure : v2 ] shows elliptic flow as a function of @xmath4 and impact parameter . with increasing @xmath4 , the minimum - bias elliptic flow increases until @xmath44 gev , where it saturates . with increasing impact parameter , elliptic flow first monotonically increases , then monotonically decreases , showing a maximum at @xmath45 fm . the minimum - bias flow was computed via @xmath46 where we chose @xmath47 fm . this differs from the definition by star , which weights @xmath48 with @xmath49 and hence results in a smaller @xmath15 than our estimate . the @xmath50 mb isotropic curve is almost the same as the @xmath51 mb gluonic curve , showing that not the _ total _ , rather the _ transport _ cross section is the relevant parameter . thus , we expect that the flow in the @xmath51 mb isotropic case can also reproduced with @xmath52 mb and a gluonic cross section . with the pqcd @xmath13 cross section of 3 mb , this corresponds to an 80 times larger initial density than from hijing . [ figure : pt ] shows the quenching of the @xmath4 spectra due to elastic energy loss . in the dilute @xmath53 mb case quenching is negligible , however , for @xmath54 mb it is an order of magnitude at @xmath55 gev for semicentral collisions . naturally , for a fixed @xmath56 , quenching decreases as the collision becomes more peripheral because the parton density decreases . hadronization via independent fragmentation results in an additional quenching . d. molnar and m. gyulassy , phys . * c 62 * , 054907 ( 2000 ) [ nucl - th/0005051 ] . parton cascade code mpc 1.0.6 used in the present study can be downloaded from the oscar homepage at http://www-cunuke.phys.columbia.edu/oscar | differential elliptic flow out to @xmath0 gev / c and particle spectra are calculated using the mpc elastic parton cascade model for au+au at @xmath1 @xmath2 gev . the evolution is computed from parton transport theory , followed by hadronization either via independent fragmentation or by imposing parton - hadron duality . with pqcd elastic cross sections , very large initial gluon densities @xmath3 are required to reproduce the data measured by the star collaboration . in addition , elliptic flow and the @xmath4 spectra are shown to be very sensitive to particle subdivision . |
quant-ph0402161 | recently , much attention has been paid to the topic of quantum games @xcite , which is forming a new area of study within quantum information and applications of quantum theory . in additional to their own intrinsic interest , quantum games open a new window for exploring the fascinating world of quantum information and quantum mechanics . actually , various problems in quantum information and computation , such as quantum cryptography , quantum cloning , quantum algorithms , can be regarded as quantum games @xcite . the quantum prisoner s dilemma @xcite is a famous two player quantum game which is quantization of the so - called prisoner s dilemma . eisert and coworkers @xcite showed that with proper quantum strategies , the paradox in the classical two - player prisoner s dilemma can be solved under the maximal entangled states , and discussed the generalized quantum game of the quantum prisoner s dilemma where the players share a nonmaximally entangled states . then du and coworkers @xcite experimentally realized the quantum game on a nuclear magnetic resonance quantum computer . quantum games with multi - players @xcite have also been studied to some extent . it has been found that through properly choosing quantum strategies , the players may gain more payoffs in the quantum case than in classical case , and quantum games can exhibit certain forms of nonclassical equilibria since quantum entanglement is introduced . as well known , optical realization is one of the most effective methods for quantum information processing . the important experimental implementation of quantum cryptography @xcite , quantum teleportation @xcite , quantum dense coding @xcite and quantum computation @xcite , is completed in quantum optical systems which generally consist of beam splitters , phase shifters , mirrors , kerr medium , and so on . in this paper we add quantum games to the list . the purpose of the present paper is to present an optical realization of the quantum prisoner s dilemma which involves nonmaximally entangled states . this paper is organized as follows . in sec . ii , we briefly review the quantum game of the quantum prisoner s dilemma with nonmaximally entangled states . in sec . iii and iv , we present optical preparation of the initial state and optical realization of the strategic operations in the quantum game . finally , we summarize our results in sec . vi . before going into the optical realization , let us briefly review the quantum game of the two - player quantum prisoner s dilemma with nonmaximally entangled states @xcite . there are two players , and the players have two possible strategies : cooperate ( @xmath0 ) and defect ( @xmath1 ) . the payoff table for the players is shown in table i. classically the dominant strategy for both players is to defect ( the nash equilibrium ) since no player can improve his / her payoff by unilaterally changing his / her own strategy , even though the pareto optimal is for both players to cooperate . this is the dilemma . in the quantum version involving nonmaximally entangled states , ( see fig . 1 ) , the game is modelled by two qubits , one for each player , with the basis states denoted by @xmath2 and @xmath3 . the physical model of the quantum game consists of three ingredients : a entangling source of two qubits , a set of physical instruments that enables the players to manipulate his or her own qubits in a strategic manner , and a physical measurement device which determines the players pay of from the outstate of the two qubits . starting with the product state @xmath4 of the two players one acts on the state with the entangling gate @xmath5 to obtain an entangled state given by @xmath6 measures the entanglement of the initial state , it changes from @xmath7 ( no entanglement ) to @xmath8 ( maximal entanglement ) . the two players now act with local unitary operators @xmath9 and @xmath10 on their qubits . finally , the disentangling gate @xmath11 is carried out and the system is measured in the computational basis , giving rise to one of the four outcomes @xmath4 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 . if one allows quantum strategies of the form @xmath15 where @xmath16 and @xmath17 , the two classical strategies @xmath18 and @xmath19 is correspond to @xmath20 and @xmath21 given by @xmath22 it is worthwhile to mention that eq . ( [ 2 ] ) is a restriction of the possible unitary strategies . it is a subset of the possible strategies . this subset is being chosen because of the ease of physical implementation . .payoff matrix for the prisoner s dilemma . the first entry in the parenthesis denotes the payoff of alice and the second number is bob s payoff [ cols="<,^,^",options="header " , ] du and coworkers @xcite showed that the game exhibits an intriguing structure as a function of the amount of entanglement with two thresholds @xmath23 and @xmath24 which separate a classical region , an intermediate region , and a fully quantum region when @xmath25 changes from @xmath7 ( no entanglement ) to @xmath8 ( maximal entanglement ) . @xmath26 is the classical region in which the quantum game behaves classically , i.e. , the only nash equilibrium is @xmath27 and the payoffs for both players are one , which is the same as in the classical game . the intermediate region is given by @xmath28 . in this region the quantum game can not resolve the dilemma . the region of @xmath29 is the fully quantum region in which a unique and new nash equilibrium is only a nash equilibriumin the space of strategies given by eq . ( [ 2 ] ) , which has the property of being pareto optimal . in the next two sections , we will give rise to optical realization of the players strategic operations and the @xmath5-gate operation , respectively . in this section we propose a method to realize the player s strategy of the quantum prisoner s dilemma with nonmaximally entangled state only by 50:50 lossless beam splitters , phase shifters and mirrors , which are easy to operate for players . a typical two - mode mixer that preserves the total number of photons in the mode pair , is a lossless beam splitter with transparency @xmath30 . denoting the input annihilation operators as @xmath31 and @xmath32 , and the output s as @xmath33 and @xmath34 . the beam splitter transform the input @xmath31 and @xmath32 into the output @xmath33 and @xmath34 as following @xmath35 where the transparency @xmath36 . this is one ways to relate the input state to the output state . a beam splitter also can be described by a unitary operator with the form @xmath37}.\ ] ] [ htbp ] , and two outputs @xmath38.,title="fig:",width=226 ] if impinging on a beam splitter with one photon in one mode and zero photon in the other , the output lights are entangled through the following expressions @xmath39 in the above single - photon representation of quantum bits , let @xmath40 , @xmath41 , under the beam - splitter transformation we have @xmath42 where if we set @xmath43 , it is a 50:50 beam splitter with transparency @xmath44 . the second device we should introduce is a phase shifter in mode @xmath45 , which can be described by the unitary operate @xmath46}.\ ] ] putting a phase shifter in mode @xmath45 and mode @xmath47 , respectively , with the phase shifter in mode @xmath47 conjugate to the one in mode @xmath45 , for convenience , we denote @xmath48 @xmath49 which correspond to the rotation around the @xmath50 axes by @xmath51 . the rotations around the @xmath52 and @xmath53 axes by @xmath54 and @xmath55 , respectively , can be realized by the following form @xmath56 where the rotations around the @xmath52 and @xmath53 axes are defined by @xcite @xmath57 , \\ \hat{u}_{y}(\beta)&=&\exp\left[-\frac{\beta}{2}(\hat{a}^{\dagger}\hat{b } - \hat{b}^{\dagger}\hat{a})\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ htbp ] . it consists of two 50:50 beam splitters , two mirrors , and four phase shifters . among these phase shifters , ps2 acts conjugate to ps3 and ps1 acts conjugate to ps4 . the two beam splitters and two mirrors along with ps2 and ps3 realize the @xmath58.,title="fig:",width=264 ] then the unitary operator of the player s strategy shown in eq.([1 ] ) , can be realized using the following identity : @xmath59 and the experiment setup is the combination of the beam splitters , phase shifters and mirrors shown in fig.[cong : strategy ] . the @xmath5 gate is the most important operation in the quantum game since it introduces quantum entanglement . in this section we show that the @xmath5 gate can be realized in terms of a sequence of beam splitters , cross kerr medium , and phase shifters . unitary transformations corresponding to beam splitters and phase shifters are given by eqs . ( [ 3 ] ) and ( [ 6 ] ) , respectively , while a unitary transformation which characterizes a cross - kerr medium is given by @xmath60},\ ] ] where the nonlinear kerr coefficient @xmath61 is proportional to the third order susceptibility @xmath62 of the medium and the interaction time within the medium . here we assume the self - modulation terms @xmath63 and @xmath64 can be ignored by an appropriate choice of resonance @xcite . our scheme to realize the @xmath5-gate is indicated in fig.[cong : jgate ] , which consists of four 50:50 beam splitters , four phase shifters , one cross - kerr medium and some mirrors . all of the bss are 50:50 beam splitters . the cross - kerr medium couples the lights in mode @xmath45 and @xmath65 . the lights of four modes first pass through bs1 and bs2 , and two of them go through the cross - kerr medium , then they change their phases by four phase shifters , whose value is connected with the nonlinear kerr coefficient , at last they propagate through beam splitters , bs3 and bs4 . [ htbp ] -gate . the cross - kerr medium couples mode @xmath45 and @xmath65 . all the beam splitters here are 50:50 lossless beam splitters , phase shifter ps1 is conjugate to ps2 with parameter @xmath66 , and ps3 is conjugate to ps4 with parameter @xmath67 , whose values is connected with the nonlinear kerr coefficient.,title="fig:",width=226 ] then the unitary transformation to realize the @xmath5-gate can be expressed as the product of a sequence of beam - splitter transformations , the cross - kerr transformation and phase - shifter transformations , which is given by @xmath68 which can be further reduced to the following simple form @xmath69}.\ ] ] if we assume that the input state of the setup indicated in fig.[cong : jgate ] is @xmath4 , then its out state is given by @xmath70}|c c\rangle,\ ] ] which can be explicitly written as @xmath71 given by ( [ 1 ] ) . it is easy to verify the following commutators @xmath72&=0 , \hspace{0.5 cm } [ \hat{j } , \hat{d}\otimes\hat{d}]=0,\nonumber \\ & [ \hat{j } , \hat{c}\otimes\hat{d}]&=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which are the subsidiary conditions which the entangling operation @xmath5 must be satisfied in order to guarantee that the ordinary prisoner s dilemma is faithfully represented . hence , the unitary transformation ( [ 14 ] ) faithfully realize the @xmath5-gate operation to generate the initial entangled state ( [ 1 ] ) . in this paper we have presented a optical scheme to realize the quantum prisoner s dilemma by using beam splitters , phase shifters , cross - kerr medium and mirrors with single - photon sources . it should also be possible to use this method to realize multi - player quantum game . we believe that the practical realization of such quantum games should provide further insight into the studies of quantum networks . this work was supported in part the national fundamental research program ( 2001cb309310 ) , the national natural science foundation of china under grant nos . 90203018 and 10075018 , the state education ministry of china and the educational committee of hunan province . j. eisert , m. wilkens , and m. lewenstein , phys . * 83 * ( 1999 ) 3077 . j. du , h. li , x. xu , m. shi , j.wu , x. zhou , and r. han , phys . . lett . * 88 * ( 2002 ) 137902 . j. du , h. li , x. xu , x. zhou , and r. han , phys . lett . a * 302 * ( 2002 ) 229 . meyer , phys . * 82 * ( 1999 ) 1052 . a. p. flitney _ et al . , _ fluctuation and noise lett . * 4 * ( 2002 ) r175 . benjamin , p.m. hayden , phys . a * 64 * ( 2001 ) 030301(r ) . y.m . ma , g.l . long , f.g . deng , f. li , s.x . zhang , phys . a * 301 * ( 2002 ) 117 . a. iqbal , a.h . toor , phys . lett . a * 293 * ( 2002 ) 103 . t. jennewein , c. simon , g. weihs , j. weinfurter and a zeilinger , phys . lett * 84 * ( 2000 ) 4729 . pan , s. gasparoni , m. aspelmeyer , t. jennewein and a. zeilinger , nature * 421 * ( 2003 ) 721 . k. mattle , h. weinfurter , p.g . kwiat , and a. zeilinger , phys . * 76 * ( 1997 ) 4656 . x. li , q. pan , j. jing , j. zhang , c. xie , and k. peng , phys . 88 ( 2002 ) 047904 . e. knill , r. laflamme , and g.j . milburn , nature * 409 * ( 2001 ) 46 . campos , b.e.a . saleh , m.c.teich , phys . a * 40 * ( 1989 ) 1371 . gerry and r.a . campos , phys . a * 64 * ( 2001 ) 063814 . n. imoto , h. a. haus , and y. yamamoto , phys . a * 32 * ( 1985 ) 3387 . gerry , phys . a * 61 * ( 2000 ) 043811 . | we present a proposal for optically implementing the quantum game of the two - player quantum prisoner s dilemma involving nonmaximally entangled states by using beam splitters , phase shifters , cross - kerr medium , photon detector and the single - photon representation of quantum bits . pacs number(s ) : 03.67.-a , 03.67.lx , 42.50.dv |
1206.5394 | it has been almost five decades , since the pioneer work of hnon and heiles [ 1 ] , who studied the regular and chaotic character of motion in a system of two coupled harmonic oscillators . during these years several methods have been presented in order to distinguish order from chaos . among them , it is worth mentioning , the method based on the fourier spectra of trajectories ( see [ 2,18 ] ) , the lyapunov characteristic exponents ( l.c.es)(see [ 19 ] ) and the ks entropy ( see [ 3 ] ) . apart from the above methods , in systems of two degrees of freedom , one can apply the classical method of the poincar phase plane , in order to distinguish regular from chaotic motion . on the contrary , in a 3d system the above method can not be applied . on this basis , it is of particular interest to locate the regions of initial conditions in 3d potentials generating regular or chaotic motion . the aim of the present article is to investigate the nature of motion in the 3d potential @xmath3 , \ \ \\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath4 is the common frequency of oscillation along @xmath5 and @xmath6 axis , while @xmath7 is the perturbation strength . potential ( 1 ) represents three coupled harmonic oscillators in the 1:1:1 resonance . potentials of this type are also known as perturbed elliptic oscillators ( see [ 5,6 ] ) . the basic reason for the choice of potential ( 1 ) is that perturbed elliptic oscillators appear very often in galactic dynamics and atomic - particle physics ( see [ 5 ] and references therein ) . a second reason is that it displays exact periodic orbits , interesting sticky orbits together with large chaotic regions . therefore , it gives a good chance in order to check the reliability of the @xmath1 spectrum ( see [ 7,10 ] ) , which is used as an indicator to track the sticky orbits and to distinguish between regular and chaotic motion . the outcomes of this research are mainly based on the numerical integration of the equations of motion @xmath8 where the dot indicates derivatives with respect to the time . the hamiltonian to the potential ( 1 ) reads @xmath9 where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the momenta per unit mass conjugate to @xmath5 and @xmath6 , while @xmath12 is the numerical value of the hamiltonian . the paper is organized as follows : in section 2 we present the analysis of the structure of the @xmath13 poincar phase plane of the 2d system for a set of values of energy @xmath12 . in the same section , we give some examples for the reader to understand the usefulness of the @xmath1 spectrum , since it has the ability to describe islandic and sticky motion . in section 3 we study the character of orbits in the 3d system . special interest is given to the evolution of the exact periodic orbits . particularly , we are interested to find the value of energy , where orbits starting near the exact periodic orbits change their character from regular to chaotic . we close our investigation with section 4 , where a discussion and the conclusions of this research are presented . in the following we shall study the character of motion in the corresponding 2d potential @xmath14 it is well known , that in this potential the two axes @xmath15 and @xmath16 and the straight lines @xmath17 are exact periodic orbits ( see [ 8 ] ) . the hamiltonian to potential ( 4 ) writes @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the numerical value of the hamiltonian . it is interesting to note , that potential ( 4 ) has not a finite energy of escape , so the corresponding zero velocity curves ( zvcs ) are always closed . in all numerical calculations , we adopt the values : @xmath20 , while the energy is treated as a parameter . figure 1a shows the @xmath13 , @xmath21 phase plane , when @xmath22 . one can see , that a large part of the phase plane is covered by chaotic orbits . the regular regions are occupied by invariant curves around the points @xmath23 and @xmath24 . the above points give the positions of two exact periodic orbits , the first is the @xmath16 axis while the second describes the @xmath17 straight line orbits on the @xmath13 phase plane . furthermore , one observes a large number of smaller islands of invariant curves produced by secondary resonances and some sticky regions as well . figure 1b is similar to fig . 1a but when @xmath25 . here we see that the majority of the phase plane is covered by a chaotic sea . the regular regions are confined only around the straight line periodic orbits , while the @xmath16 axis has now become unstable . some smaller islands of invariant curves are also present . the most interesting feature observed in this case , is the sticky regions around the chain of islands of invariant curves on the @xmath15 as well as on the @xmath26 axis . we shall come to this point later in this section . if we increase the value of energy to @xmath27 , we obtain the phase plane shown in figure 1c . in this case , the @xmath16 axis has returned to stability , while the straight line periodic orbits are unstable . almost all the phase plane is chaotic , except of a small region around the center and some small islands of invariant curves which are products of secondary resonances . a sticky region around the chain of the small islands of invariant curves near the center is also observed . figure 1d is similar to fig . 1a but when @xmath28 . this value of the energy is the value of the energy of escape of the 3d potential ( see next section ) . here almost all the phase plane is covered by chaotic orbits . there is a tiny regular region near the center . a careful observation also shows some very small regular islands of invariant curves embedded in the chaotic sea . 0.02 cm one can see , that the fraction of the phase plane covered by chaotic orbits increases as the energy @xmath19 increases . figure 2a shows a plot of the percentage of the phase plane @xmath29 covered by chaotic orbits vs @xmath19 . we observe that @xmath29 increases rapidly , as @xmath12 increases . dots indicate values of @xmath29 found numerically , while the solid line is a fourth degree polynomial fitting curve . we would like to make clear , that @xmath29 is estimated on a completely empirical basis , by measuring the area on the @xmath13 phase plane occupied by chaotic orbits ( see [ 11 ] ) . in order to have an estimation of the degree of chaos from another point of view , we have plotted the maximum l.c.e vs @xmath19 . the results are shown in figure 2b . note that the l.c.e increases linearly with @xmath19 . here , we must point out that it is well known that the l.c.e has different values in each chaotic component ( see [ 20 ] ) . since we have regular regions in all cases and a large chaotic area with small sticky regions embedded in each chaotic sea , we calculate the average value of the l.c.e in each case by taking fifty orbits with different initial conditions @xmath30 , in each chaotic domain . in all cases , the obtained values of the l.c.es were different in the fourth decimal point , in the same chaotic area . 0.02 cm 0.02 cm 0.02 cm 0.02 cm interesting information not only for the chaotic or regular character of orbits but also for islandic and sticky motion can be obtained using the dynamical parameter of the @xmath1 spectrum . the parameter @xmath31 is defined as @xmath32 where @xmath33 are the successive values of the @xmath34 orbital elements on the poincar @xmath13 phase plane . the dynamical spectrum of the parameter @xmath31 is its distribution function @xmath35 where @xmath36 are the number of the parameters @xmath31 in the interval @xmath37 , after @xmath38 iterations . this dynamical spectrum has been proved a very reliable tool in several cases ( see [ 7,10 ] for details ) . the nature of a 2d orbit can be identified by the shape of the @xmath1 spectrum . if the structure of the spectrum is a well formed @xmath39-type shape , then the corresponding orbit is regular . on the other hand , if the shape of the spectrum is complicated , asymmetric , with a lot of of small and large abrupt peaks , then this indicates that the orbit is chaotic . moreover , the @xmath1 spectrum can help us identify resonant orbits or orbits of higher multiplicity , as it produces as much @xmath39-type spectra as the total number of the islands of invariant curves in the @xmath13 phase plane . one additional advantage of this spectrum , is that it can be used in order to calculate the sticky period of a 2d sticky orbit and also to help us follow its time evolution towards the chaotic sea . at this point , we should emphasize that there are some spectra , such as the @xmath40 spectrum , ( see [ 23 ] ) , which have no ability to identify islandic or sticky motion . furthermore , the @xmath40 spectrum needs the computation of two neighboring orbits and a large number of iterations ( about @xmath41 ) in order to provide reliable results regarding the character of a 2d orbit . using the @xmath1 spectrum we have managed to overcome these drawbacks . recently , in [ 24 ] we introduced the @xmath42 spectrum which proved to be a very sensitive and reliable spectrum . this new spectrum definition allow us to study more accurately the islandic motion of resonant orbits of higher multiplicity , as it produces as much spectra as the total number of the islands of invariant curves in the @xmath13 phase plane . the main advantage of the @xmath42 is that it has the ability to detect complicated resonant orbits especially in 2d hamiltonian systems , no matter how small are the corresponding islands of invariant curves . furthermore , for the study of orbits in 3d hamiltonian systems , we constructed and used in [ 25 ] the @xmath43 dynamical spectrum . this spectrum is an advanced form of the @xmath1 spectrum and it was especially designed for the study of 3d orbits , as it produces as much spectra as the total number of the 3d invariant tori in the @xmath44 phase subspace . in what follows we present some examples in order to visualize the usefulness of the @xmath1 spectrum . figure 3a - b shows the @xmath1 spectrum and the corresponding l.c.e vs time of an orbit with initial conditions : @xmath45 and @xmath22 , while in all cases the initial value of @xmath46 is always found from the energy integral . we see a @xmath39 type spectrum indicating regular motion while the corresponding l.c.e tends asymptotically to zero . figure 4a - b is similar to fig . 3a - b for an orbit with initial conditions : @xmath47 and @xmath25 . here we see a spectrum with a lot of asymmetric small and large peaks indicating chaotic motion . the plot of the l.c.e vs time in fig . 4b verifies the results of the spectrum . the @xmath1 spectrum is useful in order to detect islandic and sticky motion . the results are shown in figure 5a - d . figure 5a shows an orbit with initial conditions : @xmath48 and @xmath25 . this orbit produces the two sets of five islands shown near the @xmath15-axis in fig . 1b . note that the corresponding spectrum produces ten individual regular spectra each one corresponding to an island . as the orbit produces two different sets of five islands on the positive and negative side of the @xmath15-axis , we observe two sets of five spectra almost symmetric to the origin . figure 5b shows the spectrum of a nearby orbit . the initial conditions are : @xmath49 and @xmath19=2 . this orbit produces the two sticky regions around each set of the five islands near the @xmath15-axis shown in fig . 1b . as there are two areas of sticky motion we see two separate sticky spectra with asymmetric large and small peaks . here the time is @xmath50 time units . figure 5c is similar to 5b but when @xmath51 time units . we see two different asymmetric spectra . this indicates that the test particle is still in the sticky region . figure 5d shows the spectrum when @xmath52 time units . in this case , we see that the two spectra have joined to produce a unified chaotic spectrum . this indicates that the test particle has left the sticky region and has gone into the chaotic sea . the l.c.e vs time of the orbit described above is shown in figure 6 . all l.c.es were computed for a time period of @xmath53 time units . the above results strongly suggest that the @xmath1 spectrum is a powerful dynamical parameter providing useful and reliable results for distinguishing between order and chaos . furthermore , the @xmath1 spectrum describes very satisfactorily islandic and sticky motion . in this section we shall investigate the regular or chaotic behavior of the orbits in the 3d potential ( 1 ) . working in a similar way as in caranicolas and varvoglis [ 9 ] , we find that this potential has an energy of escape given by @xmath54 for values of @xmath55 the zero velocity surface is open and the test particle is free to escape to infinity . in this paper we investigate only bounded motion that is we consider always @xmath56 . for the adopted values of the parameters @xmath20 we find that @xmath57 . figure 7 shows the surface @xmath58 . note that in the potential ( 1 ) the straight lines @xmath59 are exact periodic orbits . using the origin @xmath60 as a starting point we find from hamiltonian ( 3 ) that the starting value of the corresponding velocities are @xmath61 , while the value of @xmath46 is obtained from the energy integral . 0.02 cm 0.02 cm 0.02 cm 0.02 cm in order to find the regular or chaotic nature of the 3d orbits we choose initial conditions @xmath62 , where @xmath63 is a point on the phase plane of the 2d system . this point lies inside the limiting curve @xmath64 which is the curve containing all the invariant curves of the 2d system . we use @xmath65 and the value of @xmath46 , for all orbits , is obtained from the energy integral ( 3 ) . the numerical calculations suggest , that orbits with initial conditions @xmath62 , such as @xmath63 is a point in the chaotic regions of fig . 1 a - d and for all permissible values of @xmath66 , produce chaotic orbits . on the other hand , it would be also interesting to investigate the character of orbits with initial conditions @xmath62 , such as @xmath63 is a point in the regular regions of fig . 1 a - d . we shall use the @xmath1 spectrum and in order to verify the effectiveness of the @xmath1 spectrum in 3d dynamical systems , we shall compare the results with two other indicators , the classical method of the l.c.e and the spectral method @xmath2 , used by karanis and vozikis [ 18 ] . this method , uses the fast fourier transform ( fft ) of a series of time intervals , each one representing the time that elapsed between two successive points on the poincar @xmath13 phase plane , for 2d systems , while for 3d systems they take two successive points on the plane @xmath67 . note that the coupling of the third component , @xmath6 , carrying all the information about the 3d orbits , is hidden in the definition of the @xmath1 spectrum , but in any case it affects the values of @xmath68 and @xmath69 entering eq . thus , the @xmath1 spectrum provides implicit results for the 3d orbits . on the other hand , using the new @xmath43 spectrum the outcomes are explicit , since the coupling of the third component @xmath6 is located directly in its definition . figure 8 a - d shows ( a ) the 3d orbit , ( b ) the corresponding l.c.e . ( c ) the @xmath1 spectrum and ( d ) the @xmath2 indicator , of an orbit with initial conditions : @xmath70 . the value of energy is @xmath71 , while in all cases the value of @xmath46 is found from the energy integral . all dynamical indicators coincide that this orbit is regular . figure 9a - d is similar to fig . 8a - d but for a chaotic 3d orbit . initial conditions are : @xmath72 , @xmath71 . here one observes an asymmetric @xmath1 spectrum with a lot of small and large peaks indicating chaotic motion . the l.c.e in figure 9b and the @xmath2 indicator in figure 9d , coincide with the results of the spectrum . finally , we shall study the character of orbits starting near the 3d exact periodic orbits . figure 10 a - d is similar to fig . 8 a - d but for an orbit starting near the 3d exact periodic orbit . initial conditions are : @xmath73 , @xmath71 . the l.c.e , the @xmath1 spectrum and the @xmath2 indicator suggest for regular motion . figure 11 a - d is similar to fig . 9 a - d but when @xmath74 . here the dynamical indicators reveal the chaotic nature of this orbit . the numerical calculations indicate that orbits starting near the exact periodic orbits become chaotic when @xmath75 . figure 12 shows a plot of the l.c.e vs @xmath12 for the chaotic orbits in the 3d system . we see that the l.c.e increases linearly as @xmath12 increases . note that the values of the l.c.es of the 3d system are smaller than the corresponding values of the l.c.es of the 2d system . potentials composed of harmonic oscillators have been frequently used during the last years by several researchers [ 4 , 12 - 16 ] . in this article we have studied the regular or chaotic character of orbits in a 3d potential made up of perturbed elliptic oscillators . this potential displays exact periodic orbits , that are straight lines going through the origin , together with extended chaotic regions . our investigation begins from the 2d potential . in order to keep things simple we tried to study the regular or chaotic character of orbits for fixed values of the two other parameters and different values of the energy . our numerical calculations have shown that the extend of chaotic regions increases rapidly as the value of the energy increases . on the other hand , we have found that the degree of chaos also increases as the energy of increases . the numerical experiments show that the l.c.e increases linearly with @xmath19 . furthermore , the application of the @xmath1 spectrum shows that this dynamical parameter is a fast and reliable indicator in order to distinguish order from chaos . note that in order to obtain the @xmath1 spectrum we need only one orbit and 3000 - 10000 time units , while in order to obtain the l.c.e we use two orbits and much longer time periods . moreover , the @xmath1 spectrum describes in a very satisfactorily way islandic and sticky motion . on the other hand , the time needed in order to obtain the @xmath2 indicator , is of order of 5000 time units . using the results of the 2d potential we proceeded to study the 3d model . first we tried to find the character of the 3d orbits with @xmath65 and initial conditions @xmath62 , such as @xmath63 is a point in ( i ) in the chaotic regions or ( ii ) in the regular regions of fig . the numerical results indicate that all orbits of type ( i ) are chaotic . the orbits of type ( ii ) display a different behavior . the numerical outcomes suggest that for small values of @xmath6 @xmath76 the orbits remain regular , while for larger values of @xmath6 @xmath77 the motion becomes chaotic . the regular or chaotic nature of the 3d orbits can be found using the @xmath1 spectrum . comparison with the l.c.e and the @xmath2 spectral method , shows that the @xmath1 spectrum is a good and fast indicator in order to distinguish regular from chaotic motion , in 3d dynamical systems . in the present research , we have choose to use dynamical parameters , such as the @xmath1 spectrum and the @xmath2 indicator , in order to characterize the nature of orbits , because the main advantage of these new methods is that they can provide reliable and conclusive results in short integration time periods , that is @xmath78 time units . here , we must point out that there are also other new dynamical indicators , such as the fli [ 17 ] , sali [ 21 ] and gali [ 22 ] . these indicators need at most 500 to 1000 time units of integration time , in order to reveal the true nature of an orbit in hamiltonian systems . the main disadvantage of the above methods is that we can not use them to identify resonant orbits of higher multiplicity which correspond to multiple islands of invariant curves in the phase plane . moreover , fli and gali are not very sensitive in the case of sticky motion . on the contrary , the sali method can provide reliable information about sticky orbits , using shorter integration time than the s(c ) spectrum . note that an interesting characteristic of this investigations is that both , the 2d and 3d potentials display exact periodic orbits and large chaotic regions . the numerical results , in the 2d and the 3d model , show that , for small values of the energy , orbits starting near the exact periodic orbits remain regular , while for larger values of the energy become chaotic . the authors would like to thank the two anonymous referees for their very useful and also constructively suggestions and comments , which improved the quality of the present work . ferrer , s. , lara , m. , palacin , j. , juan , j.s . , viartola , a. , yanguas , p. : the hnon heiles problem in three dimensions . ii . relative equilibria and bifurcations in the reduced problem . j. bifurc . chaos * 8 * , 1215 ( 1998 ) | we study the nature of motion in a 3d potential composed of perturbed elliptic oscillators . our technique is to use the results obtained from the 2d potential in order to find the initial conditions generating regular or chaotic orbits in the 3d potential . both 2d and 3d potentials display exact periodic orbits together with extended chaotic regions . numerical experiments suggest , that the degree of chaos increases rapidly , as the energy of the test particle increases . about @xmath0 of the phase plane of the 2d system is covered by chaotic orbits for large energies . the regular or chaotic character of the 2d orbits is checked using the @xmath1 dynamical spectrum , while for the 3d potential we use the @xmath1 spectrum , along with the @xmath2 spectral method . comparison with other dynamical indicators shows that the @xmath1 spectrum gives fast and reliable information about the character of motion . = 1 |
1512.04167 | collisionless shocks driven by supernova explosions have been expected to accelerate cosmic rays ( crs ) . the acceleration mechanism is though to be diffusive shock acceleration ( dsa ) @xcite . in fact , recent gamma - ray observations show that supernova remnants ( snrs ) accelerate crs @xcite . magnetic fields play a crucial role in the particle acceleration , but our understanding of magnetic fields around snr shocks is still incomplete . several observations suggest that magnetic fields are amplified over @xmath1 around snr shocks @xcite . in addition , many theoretical studies also suggest that magnetic fields are amplified by several mechanisms around snr shocks . however , what is the dominant mechanism remains an open question . the interstellar medium and ejecta of snrs are often a partially ionized plasma . plasma instabilities are often thought to be stabilized in the partially ionized plasma because of a collision with neutral particles . however , it was recently proposed that many plasma instabilities are excited by ionization around a collisionless shock in the partially ionized plasma @xcite . @xcite performed the first hybrid simulation of a collisionless shock wave propagating into a partially ionized plasma and showed that ionization of neutral particles excite plasma instabilities both in the upstream and downstream regions . in addition , the simulation showed that some downstream hydrogen atoms leak into the upstream region . in the upstream region ( neutral precursor region ) , density fluctuations are excited by ionization of leaking neutral particles from the downstream region @xcite . according to early studies , upstream density fluctuations amplify magnetic fields in the downstream region if the alfvn mach number and amplitude of the density fluctuations are sufficiently large @xcite . for the first hybrid simulation of @xcite , the upstream flow velocity is @xmath2 in the downstream rest frame , where @xmath3 is the alfvn velocity . the amplitude of the upstream density fluctuation is about @xmath4 , so that the expected velocity dispersion of the downstream turbulence is not more than about @xmath5 , that is , the kinetic energy of turbulence in the downstream region is not more than @xmath6 of the total shock kinetic energy . if all the kinetic energy of turbulence was converted to the magnetic field energy , the expected magnetic field would be at most @xmath7 , which is smaller than the shock - compressed magnetic field , @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the upstream magnetic field strength . therefore , upstream density fluctuations can not stretch compressed magnetic field lines in the downstream region for @xcite . more leakage of neutral particles from the downstream region and larger density fluctuations can be expected for a slower shock velocity than that of @xcite because the charge exchange rate becomes larger than the collisional ionization rate @xcite . in this paper , we perform two - dimensional hybrid simulations of collisionless shocks propagating into the partially ionized plasmas for @xmath10 , that are higher alfvn mach number and slower shock velocity than that of the first simulation . we then show that the shock strongly amplify magnetic fields . in order to study collisionless shocks propagating into partially ionized plasmas , we use a two - dimensional hybrid code that computes the motion of protons and hydrogen atoms , maxwell s equations in the low - frequency limit , and ionization of hydrogen atoms @xcite . the code solves charge exchange and collisional ionization as ionization of hydrogen atoms . their cross sections are obtained from @xcite and @xcite . the ionization timescale is at least @xmath11 times longer than the gyro period for typical young snrs . to solve this large timescale gap exactly is challenging even for current supercomputers . therefore , we adopt cross sections boosted by a factor of @xmath12 , but ionization timescale is still much longer than the gyro period . because hybrid codes do not solve the electron dynamics , the evolution of the electron temperature must be assumed . although we have not understood how electrons are heated in collisionless shocks , the electron temperature is expected to be @xmath13 in the downstream region of snrs @xcite , where @xmath14 is the downstream proton temperature for the strong shock limit and @xmath15 is the upstream flow velocity in the downstream rest frame . therefore , when we calculate collisional ionization by electrons , we assume that the relative velocity between a hydrogen atom and electrons is given by @xcite @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the velocity of the hydrogen atom and the mean velocity of electrons is assumed to be the mean velocity of protons , @xmath18 , and the electron temperature is assumed to be @xmath19 and @xmath20 in the upstream and downstream regions , respectively . we perform two - dimensional hybrid simulations in the @xmath21 plane . we inject simulation particles with a positive drift velocity at the left boundary , @xmath22 , and the simulation particles are specularly reflected at the right boundary . then , a collisionless shock is produced and propagates to the left boundary as time goes on , that is , the simulation frame corresponds to the downstream rest frame . we impose the periodic boundary condition in the @xmath23 direction . the simulation box size is @xmath24 , where @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the speed of light and plasma frequency of protons , respectively . the cell size and time step are @xmath27 and @xmath28 , respectively . initially , we put 64 protons and 64 hydrogen atoms in each cell and the magnetic field is taken to be spatially homogenous , pointing in the @xmath23 direction , @xmath29 . therefore , a perpendicular shock is formed in this simulation , where the shock normal direction is perpendicular to upstream mean magnetic field lines . for parameters of the upstream plasma , we set @xmath30 , and @xmath31 , where @xmath32 , and @xmath15 are the upstream ionization fraction , ratio of the proton pressure to the magnetic pressure , ratio of the hydrogen pressure to the magnetic pressure , and drift velocity of the @xmath33 direction , respectively . @xmath34 is the alfvn velocity defined by the proton mass density in the far upstream region , @xmath35 . direction at @xmath36 . the red , blue , and black lines show the fluid velocity normalized by the far upstream value , @xmath37 , the proton density normalized by 10 times the far upstream value , @xmath38 , and the ionization fraction , @xmath39 , respectively . [ fig:2 ] ] . the color shows the phase space density in logarithmic scale . [ fig:3 ] ] , @xmath36 . [ fig:4 ] ] in figure [ fig:1 ] , we show shock structures of the proton density , @xmath40 , magnetic field @xmath41 , and fluid velocity in the downstream rest frame , @xmath42 , at time @xmath43 , where @xmath44 and @xmath45 are x and y components of the mean proton velocity , respectively . the shock front is located at about @xmath46 and the left side of the shock front is the upstream region . the shock velocity is @xmath47 in the upstream rest frame . if we use another alfvn velocity , @xmath48 , defined by the total mass density , the shock velocity is expressed as @xmath49 in the upstream rest frame , where @xmath50 is the upstream hydrogen mass density . large amplitude density fluctuations are observed both in the upstream and downstream regions . in our previous simulation for @xmath51 , the proton density is correlated with the magnetic field strength in the upstream region and the wave vector is highly oblique to the magnetic field direction , that is , the fast magnetosonic mode are excited @xcite . in this simulation for @xmath52 , the correlation is observed in many upstream regions , but unticorrelation between the proton density and the magnetic field strength is observed in high density filaments of the upstream region and the wave vector is almost parallel to the initial magnetic field direction . the velocity field in figure [ fig:1 ] ( @xmath45 ) show that the upstream filamentary structures are produced by compression in the @xmath23 direction . the compression motion is driven by the magnetic pressure of large amplitude alfvn waves propagating to the initial magnetic field direction ( see @xmath53 and @xmath54 in figure [ fig:1 ] ) . the upstream alfvn waves are excited by the pressure anisotropy produced by ionization of leaking neutral particles @xcite . the amplitude of the filamentary structures in the upstream region is about @xmath55 . such large density fluctuations produce rippled shock structures and turbulence in the downstream region ( see velocity structures @xmath44 and @xmath45 in figure [ fig:1 ] ) . as the result , downstream magnetic fields are amplified by the turbulence , which was suggested by @xcite . in this paper , we first demonstrated via hybrid simulations that even though shocks propagate partially ionized plasmas , magnetic fields are amplified up to near the equipartition level by the downstream turbulence . figure [ fig:1 ] shows that downstream magnetic fields are locally amplified over @xmath56 and the spatially averaged value is about @xmath57 at @xmath58 , that is , significant fraction of the upstream kinetic energy is converted to the magnetic field energy . after the magnetic field strength reaches a saturation level , it gradually decays as the turbulence decays . the decay length scale is about @xmath59 which is much smaller than the observable length scale . however , once particles are accelerated by dsa , density fluctuations with larger length scale would be generated by the accelerated particles @xcite . if so , the decay length scale of magnetic fields would be larger . although simulations in this paper are two - dimensional system , it has been demonstrated by the three - dimensional magnet hydrodynamic simulation that the turbulence do amplify magnetic fields up to near the equipartition level @xcite . therefore , actual higher alfvn mach number shocks can be expected to amplify magnetic fields more strongly . the amplitude of the magnetic field fluctuations is @xmath60 in the upstream region . the coherent length scale of magnetic field structures is of the order of the gyroradius of upstream pickup ions . the pickup ions are preferentially accelerated by charge exchange and pickup processes @xcite . therefore , the observed magnetic turbulence is important for injection into dsa . simulations in this paper are performed in the two - dimensional system , so that particle diffusion perpendicular to the magnetic field line is artificially surpassed @xcite . therefore , we can expect dsa in perpendicular shocks propagating into partially ionized plasmas for a real three dimensional system , which will be addressed in future works . there are no clear mirror mode structures in the downstream region although we observed that in the previous simulation for @xmath51 . the mirror mode is excited by the pressure anisotropy of pickup ions produced in the downstream region @xcite . however , magnetic field lines are not ordered in the downstream region of this simulation , so that pickup ions produced in the downstream regions do not have pressure anisotropy and the mirror mode is not excited . in figure [ fig:2 ] , we show one - dimensional shock structures averaged over the @xmath23 direction at time @xmath36 . the red , blue , and black lines indicate the mean proton velocity of the @xmath33 direction , @xmath61 , the proton density , @xmath38 , and ionization fraction , @xmath39 , respectively . as with our previous simulation , the plasma flow is gradually decelerated within the ionization length scale but the shock modification is larger than that of the previous simulation for @xmath62 . this is because more hydrogen atoms leak into the upstream region for @xmath63 than that for @xmath62 . the number of leaking neutral particles increases with the ratio of the charge exchange rate to the collisional ionization rate . the ratio decreases with the shock velocity , so that many hydrogen atoms leak into the upstream region in this simulation compared with our previous simulation . the ratio of the fluid velocity just front of the shock to that just behind the shock is about 3.2 and the total compression ratio is about 4 in this simulation . if particles are accelerated by dsa in this velocity structure , the momentum spectrum , @xmath64 , becomes steeper than @xmath65 @xcite . figure [ fig:3 ] shows the phase space at time @xmath43 . as one can see , there are many leaking hydrogen atoms in the upstream region . downstream hot hydrogen atoms produced by charge exchange can leak into the upstream region because they do not interact with electromagnetic fields and some of them have a velocity faster than the shock velocity . because the ionization rate dominates over the charge exchange rate for @xmath66 , the maximum velocity of leaking neutral particles is about @xmath67 that is @xmath68 in this simulation . the leaking hydrogen atoms are ionized by upstream particles and picked up by the upstream flow and become pickup ions . all the upstream protons are mainly thermalized at the collisionless shock at @xmath46 . in the left panel of figure [ fig:4 ] , we show the z component of the velocity distribution of hydrogen atoms in the downstream region , @xmath69 , at time @xmath43 . for the standard model of h@xmath70 emission from snrs @xcite , the velocity distribution has two components ( narrow and broad ) . the dashed line in the left panel of figure [ fig:4 ] shows a gaussian distribution with dispersion @xmath71 , that corresponds to the broad component of the standard model . as one can see , the velocity distribution has three components ( narrow , intermediate and broad ) in this simulation . the intermediate component originates from protons thermalized by the collisionless shock . because upstream cold protons are significantly decelerated before they interact with the collisionless shock ( see figure [ fig:2 ] ) , the downstream temperature of these protons becomes lower than that of the standard model . the lost kinetic energy of upstream cold protons mainly converts to the kinetic energy of pickup ions . as a result , the width of intermediate component becomes smaller than expected from the standard model . the broadest component is produced by protons ionized in the downstream region . upstream neutral particles penetrate the collisionless shock front without energy exchange with pickup ions , so that protons ionized in the downstream region have the kinetic energy of @xmath72 . therefore , the width of the broadest component is the same as that of the standard model . as with the standard model , the narrowest component originates from upstream hydrogen atoms ( before charge exchange ) . we do not see any heating of upstream hydrogen atoms in this simulation , so that the velocity dispersion of the narrowest component in this simulation corresponds to the temperature of the far upstream region . @xcite proposed the three - component structure of h@xmath70 emission , but the formation mechanism is different from our results . their intermediate component originates from the neutral precursor region , and the velocity dispersion is of the order of @xmath73 , which is much smaller than that in this simulation . interestingly , the three - component structure is observed in the snr tycho @xcite . if the broadest component can not be identified as h@xmath70 emission , we would mistakenly identify the intermediate component as the broad competent of the standard model of h@xmath70 emission from snrs and mistakenly estimate the downstream temperature . therefore , estimating the downstream temperature from h@xmath70 emission requires careful attention . the right panel of figure [ fig:4 ] shows energy spectra of protons and hydrogen atoms in the downstream region , @xmath69 , at time @xmath43 . some protons are accelerated to over @xmath74 times the initial kinetic energy , @xmath75 . as with previous simulation , particles are accelerated by charge change and pickup processes @xcite . the typical energy becomes @xmath76 after the first cycle of the acceleration @xcite . almost all accelerated particles experience only the first cycle of the acceleration and the energy spectrum has a cutoff at @xmath77 in the previous simulation for @xmath78 . on the other hand , the energy spectrum has a cutoff at @xmath79 in this simulation for @xmath63 because some accelerated particle can experience the second cycle of the acceleration . the maximum velocity of leaking neutral particles is about @xmath67 in the downstream rest frame . after ionization in the upstream region , they are picked up by the upstream flow and their velocity becomes about @xmath80 in the upstream rest frame . the picked up particles interact with the shock and are heated to @xmath81 , that is , the kinetic energy becomes @xmath82 that is comparable to the cutoff energy in this simulation . the total kinetic energy of non thermal particles is about @xmath83 of the total kinetic energy of all particles in this simulation , where the nonthermal particles are defined by @xmath84 . as mentioned above , particle diffusion perpendicular to the magnetic field line is artificially surpassed in our two - dimensional simulations , so that we can not follow further acceleration by dsa . however , several early studies have already show that once crs are injected , magnetic field fluctuations are excited by crs even though there are neutral hydrogen atoms @xcite . therefore , we can expect the further acceleration by dsa in a real three dimensional system . we briefly mention simulation results for other shock velocities in order to discuss dependence on the upstream velocity ( shock velocity ) and alfvn mach number . the upstream velocities of our previous simulation and this simulation are @xmath2 and @xmath31 , respectively . in addition to that , we perform two other simulations for @xmath85 and @xmath86 . for @xmath85 , phase space plot , one - dimensional shock structures , velocity distribution and energy spectra are similar to that of this simulation for @xmath31 , but the large magnetic field amplification is not observed . for @xmath86 , phase space plot , one - dimensional shock structures , velocity distribution and energy spectra are similar to that of our previous simulation for @xmath2 , and magnetic fields are slightly amplified . therefore , only magnetic fields strongly depend on the alfvn mach number of shocks and other strongly depend on the shock velocity . all results should be depend on other parameters ( ionization fraction , electron temperature , and magnetic field orientation ) . systematic studies will be address in future works . in this paper , we use artificially large cross sections of charge exchange and collisional ionization in order to reduce the ionization length scale and time scale . for actual snr shocks , the length scale of neutral precursor region becomes larger than that of our simulations . then , the size of turbulent regions would be lager than that of this simulation , and the second order acceleration would become important @xcite . the growth rates of instabilities in this simulation might be artificially increased by a factor of @xmath12 . in actual snr shocks , amplitudes of excited waves would be smaller than that in this simulation because of several damping mechanisms . on the other hand , the alfvn mach number of actual young snrs is larger than that in this simulation , that is , the free energy of leaking particles of realistic young snrs is larger than that in this simulation . therefore , amplitudes of density and magnetic field fluctuations would be smaller or larger than that in this simulation . in order to understand more precisely , we need to perform a more realistic simulation . in this paper , we have performed two - dimensional hybrid simulations in order to investigate collisionless shocks generated by snrs in partially ionized plasmas . we have found that large magnetic field and density fluctuations are excited both in the upstream and downstream regions for high alfvn mach number shocks . in addition , we have found that the velocity distribution of downstream hydrogen atoms has three components for @xmath87 . as with our previous simulation , we have observed leaking neutral particles , the modified shock structure , and particle acceleration by charge exchange and pickup processes in this simulations . these results suggest that collisionless perpendicular shocks propagating into partially ionized plasma can produce cosmic rays . we thank t. inoue and r. yamazaki for useful comments . we are also grateful to issi ( bern ) for support of the team `` physics of the injection of particle acceleration at astrophysical , heliospheric , and laboratory collisionless shocks '' . numerical computations were carried out on the xc30 system at the center for computational astrophysics ( cfca ) of the national astronomical observatory of japan . axford , w. i. , leer , e. , & skadron , g. , 1977 , proc . cosmic ray conf . , plovdiv , 11 , 132 berezhko , e. g. , ksenofontov , l. t. , & vlk , h. j. , , 412 , l11 blandford , r. d. , & ostriker , j. p. , 1978 , , 221 , l29 bamba , a. , yamazaki r. , yoshida t. , terasawa t. , and koyama , k. , 2005 , , 621 , 793 barnett , c. f. , hunter , h. t. , kirkpatrick , m.i . , alvarez , i. , cisneros , c. , & phaneuf , r. a. , 1990 , atomic data for fusion , vol . 1 , ornl-6086/v1 bell , a. r. , 1978 , , 182 , 147 blasi , p. , morlino , g. , bandiera , r. , amato , e. , caprioli , d. , 2012 , , 755 , 121 bykov , a. m. , & toptygin , i. n. , 2005 , astronomy letters , 31 , 748 caprioli , d. , & spitkovsky , a. , 2013 , , 765 , l20 chevalier , r. a. & raymond , j. c. , 1978 , , 225 , l27 drury , l. oc , duffy , p. , & kirk , j. g. , 1996 , , 309 , 1002 ghavamian , j. , laming , j. m. , & rakowski , c. e. , 2007 , , 654 , l69 giacalone , j. , & jokipii , j. r. , 1994 , , 430 , l137 giacalone , j. , & jokipii , j. r. , 2007 , , 663 , l41 inoue , t. , yamazaki , r. & inutsuka , s. , 2009 , , 695 , 825 inoue , t. , yamazaki , r. & inutsuka , s. , 2010 , , 723 , l108 janev , r. k. , & smith , j. j. , 1993 , cross sections for collision processes of hydrogen atoms with electrons , protons and multiply charged ions ( vienna : int . at . energy agency ) jokipii , j. r. , kta , j. , & giacalone , j. , 1993 , geophys . 20 , 1759 koyama , k. , petre , r. , gotthelf , e. v. , hwang , u. , matsuura , m. , ozaki , m. , & holt , s. s. 1995 , , 378 , 225 krymsky , g. f. , 1977 , dokl nauk sssr , 234 , 1306 laming , j. m. , hwang , u. , ghavamian , p. , & rakowski , c. , 2014 , , 799 , 11 morlino , g. , bandiera , r. , blasi , p. , & amato , e. , 2012 , , 760 , 137 ohira , y. , & takahara , f. , 2007 , , 661 , l171 ohira , y. , & takahara , f. , 2008 , , 668 , 320 ohira , y. , terasawa , t. , & takahara , f. , 2009 , , 703 , l59 ohira , y. , & takahara , f. , 2010 , , 721 , l43 ohira , y. , murase , k. & yamazaki , r. , 2011 , , 410 , 1577 ohira , y. , 2012 , , 758 , 97 ohira , y. , 2014 , , 440 , 514 pauls , h. l. , zank , g. p. , & williams , l. l. 1995 , j. geophys . res . , 100 , 21 rakowski , c. e. , laming , j. m. , and ghavamian , p. , 2008 , , 684 , 348 raymond , j. c. , isenberg . p. a. , & laming , j. m. , 2008 , , 682 , 408 raymond , j. c. , winkler . p. f. , blair , w. p. , lee , j - j . , & park , s. , 2010 , , 712 , 901 reville , b. , kirk . j. g. , duffy , p. , & osullivan , s. , 2007 , , 475 , 435 uchiyama , y. , aharonian , f a. , tanaka , t. , takahashi , t. , & maeda , y. , 2007 , , 449 , 576 van adelsberg , m. , heng , k. , mccray , r. , & raymond , j. c. , 2008 , , 689 , 1089 vink , j. , & laming , j. m. , 2003 , , 584 , 758 vink , j. , broersen , s. , bykov , a. , & gabici , s. , 2015 , , 579 , a13 | in this paper , we study shock structures of collisionless shocks in partially ionized plasmas by means of two - dimensional hybrid simulations , where the shock is a perpendicular shock with shock velocity @xmath0 and the upstream ionization fraction is 0.5 . we find that large density fluctuations and large magnetic fields fluctuations are generated both in the upstream and downstream regions . in addition , we find that the velocity distribution of downstream hydrogen atoms has three components . observed shock structures suggest that diffusive shock acceleration can operate at perpendicular shocks propagating into partially ionized plasmas in real three - dimensional systems . |
astro-ph0505500 | young neutron stars ( nss ) probe some of the most extreme physical environments in the universe . their rapid rotations and large magnetic fields combine to accelerate particles to extremely high energies , producing energetic winds that result in the slow spin - down of the stars and generate nebulae of synchrotron - emitting particles spiraling in a wound - up magnetic field . the structure of these nebulae is determined by the energy input from the central pulsars as well as the structure and content of the medium into which they expand . in the centermost regions , relativistic outflows in the form of rings and jets are formed ; the geometry of these emission regions reveals the orientation of the pulsar spin axes and can provide information on the formation of kicks imparted in the moments following their formation . their large - scale structures reveal details of the magnetic field and signatures of interaction with the ejecta from the explosions that gave them birth . the stellar interiors are characterized by conditions and physical processes otherwise observed only within the nuclei of atoms . they are born hot , but cool rapidly due to neutrino production in their interiors . however , details of the interior structure of such stars remain poorly understood owing to our incomplete understanding of the strong interaction at ultrahigh densities and , since the neutrino production rate is critically dependent on the structure of the interior , the cooling rate is highly uncertain . in the standard cooling scenario , neutrino production proceeds primarily via the modified urca process . residual heat diffuses from the core to the surface , manifesting itself as blackbody - like emission modified by effects of any residual atmosphere which peaks in the soft x - ray band . the rate at which the surface temperature declines depends critically upon the neutrino emission rate ; thus , its measurement provides constraints on hadronic physics at high densities . perhaps the most stunning thing about nss is the fact that we can actually make measurements that , directly or indirectly , probe the above properties . particularly with the advent of sensitive high - resolution x - ray observations , we can now image jets and outflows from the wind termination shocks , identify magnetic filaments in the nebular interiors , detect the thermal emission from shock - heated ejecta , and measure directly the pulsations from the rotating stars and the emission from their ultra - hot surfaces . here i describe the basic properties of young nss and their nebulae , and summarize recent observational work that has begun a revolution in our understanding of how these stars work . brevity precludes a thorough review , and the reader is referred to recent articles by @xcite and @xcite for additional information and references . our basic understanding of pwne stems from the picture presented by @xcite , and expanded upon by @xcite , in which an energetic axisymmetric wind is injected from a pulsar into its surroundings . as illustrated schematically in figure 1 , the structure of a pwn is regulated by the input power from the pulsar and the density of the medium into which the nebula expands ; the pulsar wind and wound - up toroidal magnetic field inflates a bubble which is confined in the outer regions by the expanding shell of ejecta or interstellar material swept up by the snr blast wave . the boundary condition established by the expansion at the nebula radius @xmath0 results in the formation of a wind termination shock at which the highly relativistic pulsar wind is decelerated to merge with the particle flow in the nebula . the shock forms at the radius @xmath1 at which the ram pressure of the wind is balanced by the internal pressure of the pwn : @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the rate at which the pulsar injects energy into the wind , @xmath4 is the fraction of a spherical surface covered by the wind , and @xmath5 is the total pressure outside the shock . ultimately , the pressure in the nebula is believed to reach the equipartition value ; a reasonable pressure estimate can be obtained by integrating the radio spectrum of the nebula , using standard synchrotron emission expressions , and assuming equipartition between particles and the magnetic field . typical values yield termination shock radii of order 0.1 pc , which yields an angular size of several arcsec at distances of a few kpc . as the relativistic fluid comprising the pwn encounters the freely - expanding ejecta , rayleigh - taylor instabilities result in the formation of a network of dense , optical line - emitting filaments ( @xcite ) . the density and magnetic field strength becomes enhanced in regions where the pwn encounters these filaments , producing enhanced synchrotron emission observed as radio filaments . due to the pinching effect of the global toroidal magnetic field , the overall morphology of a young pwn is often elongated along the pulsar spin axis ( begelman & li , 1992 ; van der swaluw et al . , 2004 ) . along the rotation axis the flow becomes collimated , producing jets . pinch instabilities may disrupt the toroidal structure , however , changing the structure of the magnetic field in the outer nebula regions and relaxing the collimation of the jets far from the pulsar ( @xcite ) . the overall geometry of the pwn , as well as that of the emission from jets or ring - like structures near the termination shock , thus provides a direct indication of the pulsar geometry . the details of the jet morphology and the emission structure in the postshock region provide the strongest constraints available on wind composition and particle acceleration in pwne . for cases in which the pulsar proper motion is also known , constraints on the kick velocity mechanism can be derived based on the degree of alignment between the velocity vector and the pulsar spin axis . in later stages the pwn interacts with the reverse shock formed in the snr in which the ns was born . this interaction causes the disruption of the pwn , often leading to composite snrs with complicated pwn structures in their interiors . in the inner portions of the crab nebula , optical wisps mark the position of the wind termination shock , at a distance of @xmath6 pc from the pulsar . the brightness and position of these wisps varies in time , with inferred outflow speeds up to @xmath7 ( @xcite ) . as shown in figure 2 ( left ) , high resolution x - ray images reveal a ring of emission at the position of the wisps ( @xcite ) , providing a direct connection between the unshocked pulsar wind and the bulk properties of the nebula . material from the inner ring forms a series of toroidal x - ray wisps that are variable with time ( @xcite ) . the geometry of these x - ray features imply a tilted torus , and a jet of material flows perpendicular to the plane of the toroid , extending some 0.25 pc from the pulsar . a faint counterjet is also observed , along with significantly enhanced x - ray emission from the leading portion of the toroid , presumably the result of doppler beaming . one troubling aspect of this suggestion is that the brightness distribution around the inner ring does not match that of the outer toroid ; indeed , the brightness is rather uniform except for some small clump - like structures that vary in position and brightness with time . a handful of other pwne display x - ray features that suggest the presence of extended ring - like structures and narrow collimated components . the size of the ring - like features places the emission region near the pulsar wind termination shock . the spectral and temporal properties of the collimated structures argue that they are focused jets of high speed material , as observed in the crab . such observations have already begun to inspire new axisymmetric mhd models that predict similar features ( e.g. , komissarov & lyubarsky 2004 ) , and ongoing observational studies promise to further constrain and refine such models . in particular , the confining mechanism for jets is not well - understood ; many jets display some amount of curvature , with the vela pulsar jet being an extreme example in which the morphology is observed to change on timescales of months ( @xcite ) . this may be the result of pinch instabilities disrupting the toroidal structure of the confining magnetic field ( begelman 1998 ) , or could be indicative of an interaction of the jet material with the ambient medium . there also appears to be a wide variation in the fraction of spin - down energy channeled into the jets , ranging from roughly @xmath8 for psr j0205 + 6449 in 3c 58 to nearly @xmath9 for psr b1509@xmath1058 . and , while doppler beaming is invoked to explain the large brightness variations in jets and the associated counterjets , as well as around the observed toroidal structures , it is not clear that this alone is sufficient to explain the observations . _ chandra _ observations of g54.1 + 0.3 ( @xcite ) reveal a central 136 ms pulsar ( @xcite ) embedded in a diffuse @xmath11 nebula ( figure 2 , center ) . the pulsar is surrounded by an x - ray ring for which the x - ray emission is brightest along the eastern limb . when interpreted as the result of doppler boosting , this implies a post - shock velocity of @xmath12 ( lu et al . 2002 ; romani & ng 2003 ) . faint bipolar elongations running roughly east - west , perpendicular to the long axis of the ring , are also observed . these apparent outflows , which presumably lie along the pulsar rotation axis , are more diffuse than the jets in the crab nebula , yet appear to carry away a considerably larger fraction of the energy ; they comprise roughly the same luminosity as the central ring , which is in stark contrast to the crab where the torus outshines the jets by a large factor . _ chandra _ observations of psr b1509@xmath13 ( @xcite ) demonstrate that this young and energetic pulsar associated with g320.41.2 powers an extended and extremely complicated pwn , with structures on scales from @xmath14 down to the spatial resolution limit ( figure 2 , right ) . the elongated pwn has a clear axis of symmetry centered on the pulsar , presumably representing the projected orientation of the pulsar spin axis . to the southeast of the pulsar , the nebula is dominated by a narrow jet - like feature approximately 6 pc in length . the lack of a similar feature to the north can be explained by doppler boosting if the pulsar s spin axis is inclined to the line - of - sight by @xmath15 ( gaensler et al . , 2002 ) . in the central regions of the pwn , a pair of semi - circular arcs lie @xmath16 and @xmath17 pc to the north of the pulsar . gaensler et al . ( 2002 ) note that if the inner region of these arcs represents the position of the pulsar wind termination shock , then the flow time to the arcs is much shorter than the synchrotron lifetime of the emitting particles based on equipartition estimates of the magnetic field . thus , unlike for the crab torus , where these timescales are similar , the emission from the arcs is not the result of large synchrotron cooling at this position . instead , the arcs appear to resemble the series of concentric wisps seen for the crab which are interpreted as sites of electron compression in an ion - dominated flow ( @xcite , gaensler et al . , 2002 ) . the innermost region of 3c 58 ( see figure 3 ) consists of a bright , elongated compact structure centered on the pulsar j0205 + 6449 . this inner nebulosity is bounded along the western edge by a radio wisp ( @xcite ) , and is suggestive of a toroidal structure that is tilted about a north - south axis , with the pulsar at its center . the eastern side of the toroid is slightly brighter than the western side , suggesting that the eastern side is beamed toward us . if interpreted as a circular termination shock zone , the inferred inclination angle in the plane of the sky is roughly 70 degrees ( @xcite ) . the elongated structure extending westward from the position of the pulsar has the appearance of a jet ( figure 3 , right ) . its orientation is consistent , in projection , with the pulsar rotation axis inferred from the wind termination shock region discussed above , and also the east - west elongation of the entire pwn ( figure 3 , left ) . the structure shows considerable curvature , similar to that seen in the crab pulsar jet . a faint structure that may be a counterjet is observed to the east of the pulsar . the observed luminosity is nearly a factor of 10 smaller than that for the torus . for the crab nebula , the torus is nearly 20 times more luminous than the jet in x - rays , while for psr b150958 the jet is brighter than the extended inner emission ( gaensler et al . 2002 ) . the jet / torus morphology observed in these pwne provides the geometry of the pulsar system , yielding both the projected direction of the spin axis and the inclination angle . modeling of such emission in other pwne holds promise for understanding the kicks that give pulsars their large space velocities ( @xcite ) . the jets observed in the crab and vela pulsars , for example , are aligned with their proper motion vectors ( aschenbach & brinkman 1975 ; helfand et al . 2001 ) . if the kick that gave these pulsars their proper motion was generated in the supernova explosion by some asymmetric mass ejection , then this alignment requires an initial pulsar spin period that is short relative to the kick timescale , so that the impulse of the kick is averaged over many rotations of the star ( @xcite ) . @xcite reach similar conclusions for psr j0538 + 2817 in the supernova remnant ( snr ) s147 . by modeling the faint extended pwn emission as a jet and torus , they derive a spin axis direction that is aligned with the vector from the snr center to the current pulsar position . for some pulsars [ e.g. j0205 + 6449 in 3c 58 ( @xcite ) and j18111925 in g11.20.3 ( @xcite ) ] , we believe that the initial spin period was much longer than typical pulsar kick timescales . this would suggest that their proper motions should not necessarily be aligned with the jet direction . future radio timing observations of these pulsars will ultimately lead to such proper motion measurements . extensive filamentary structure is observed in h@xmath18 , [ oiii ] , and other optical line images of the crab nebula . based on their observed velocities , these filaments form an expanding shell of ejecta that surrounds the nonthermal optical emission from the nebula . high resolution images with hst reveal detailed morphology and ionization structure suggesting that the filaments form from rayleigh - taylor instabilities as the expanding relativistic bubble encounters slower moving ejecta ( @xcite ) , a picture supported by mhd simulations that show that 60 - 75% of the swept - up mass ends up concentrated in such filaments ( jun 1998 , bucciantini et al . radio observations reveal filaments that coincide with these optical filaments , presumably corresponding to synchrotron emission from regions of enhanced density and magnetic field in the form of magnetic sheaths that form as the pulsar - injected energy encounters the thermal filaments ( @xcite ) . such filamentary structure is not observed in x - rays , however , suggesting that the electrons with sufficient energy to radiate x - rays do not reach the shell of filaments . this is consistent with the observed smaller extent of the x - ray emission in the crab nebula relative to its radio size , and indicates a larger magnetic field than is observed in 3c 58 and psr b1509@xmath1058 . recent _ chandra _ observations of 3c 58 reveal a complex of loop - like filaments most prominent near the central regions of the pwn ( figure 3 , left ) , but evident throughout the nebula ( @xcite ) . these structures , whose x - ray spectra are nonthermal , are very well correlated with features observed in the radio band ( @xcite ) . optical observations reveal faint thermal filaments as well ( @xcite ) , which presumably have an origin similar to that of the crab filaments . the velocities of these optical filaments in 3c 58 are @xmath19 ( @xcite ) , sufficiently high to indicate that the pwn is young , but too small to account for the current size of 3c 58 if the historical age is assumed one of several standing problems with regard to its evolution ( @xcite ) . a detailed comparison of the x - ray and optical images shows that most of the x - ray filaments do not have corresponding optical structures , however . while comparisons with deeper optical images are clearly needed , the fact that many of the x - ray features without optical counterparts are brighter than average in x - rays suggests that these may actually arise from a different mechanism . slane et al . ( 2004 ) propose that the bulk of the discrete structures seen in the x - ray and radio images of 3c 58 are magnetic loops torn from the toroidal field by kink instabilities . in the inner nebula , the loop sizes are similar to the size of the termination shock radius , as suggested by begelman ( 1998 ) . as the structures expand , they enlarge slightly as a consequence of the decreasing pressure in the nebula . some of the observed x - ray structure in the outermost regions may be the result of thermal filaments produced by rayleigh - taylor instabilities , similar to the filaments in the crab nebula . a shell of thermal x - ray emission demonstrates the presence of ejecta in these outer regions ( @xcite , @xcite . it is worth noting that considerable loop - like filamentary structure is evident in _ chandra _ observations of the crab nebula as well ( @xcite ) . these features are primarily observed encircling the bright crab torus , perpendicular to the toroidal plane , and may result from currents within the torus itself . it is at least conceivable that such currents are signatures of the kink instabilities suggested above . the large - scale elongated shape of 3c 58 is similar to that found ( particularly in the radio band ) for a number of other pwne including the crab nebula and g54.1 + 0.3 . magnetohydrodynamical calculations by begelman & li , 1992 , and van der swaluw , 2004 , show that such an elongation can result from the pinching effect of a toroidal magnetic field for which the projected axis lies along the long axis of the pwn . the pinching effect results in a low pressure at the edge of the bubble along the major axis with respect to the ( higher ) pressure at the edge of the minor axis , which yields the elongated structure . the elongation thus marks the projection of the spin axis of the pulsar producing the wound - up field . in 3c 58 this is consistent with the inference of an east - west direction for the projected spin axis based on the interpretation of the extended structure in the inner nebula as being associated with a tilted ring - shaped wind termination shock zone ( @xcite ) . the structure of a pwn can be altered significantly through interaction with the reverse shock from the snr in which it resides . in its early evolution the pwn is basically freely - expanding , encountering only small amounts of slow - moving ejecta in the snr interior . as the snr blast wave sweeps up sufficient amounts of circumstellar / interstellar material , a reverse shock is driven back through the ejecta . as this reverse shock propagates , heating the ejecta , it will eventually reach the pwn . _ chandra _ studies of the oxygen - rich remnant g292.0 + 1.8 reveal an snr in the intermediate stages of this process . the 0.5 - 10 kev x - ray image is presented in figure 4 ( left ) , and shows the complex structure associated with the shock - heated ejecta and csm ( @xcite ) . the inset shows the central image at energies above 4 kev , and reveals a compact pulsar surrounded by a wind nebula ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . x - ray spectra of the snr show metal - rich ejecta with strong lines of oxygen and neon , but a distinct shortage of iron emission ( @xcite ) , indicating that the reverse shock has not yet propagated sufficiently far toward the center to heat the iron - rich material that was formed closest to the core of the progenitor ( figure 4 , right ) . the morphology of the pwne in [email protected] presents a rather different picture . the radio image ( figure 5 , left ) reveals a well - defined snr shell with a bright pwn in its interior , distinctly offset from the geometric center . a finger of emission extends to the northwest of the radio pwn , and _ chandra _ observations reveal a compact x - ray source at this location ( figure 5 , right ) . the source is slightly extended ( see inset ) suggesting that we are seeing material near the wind termination shock . the compact source resides at the tip of a trail of emission that leads back to the bulk of the radio nebula , rather than at the center of the pwn ( as in g292.0 + 1.8 , for example ) , suggesting that the pwn morphology results from a combination of the pulsar motion and the passage of the reverse shock which has apparently disrupted the western side of the nebula ( slane et al . , in preparation ) . the cooling rate of isolated nss has been a subject of considerable theoretical work predating even the discovery of the first pulsars ( e.g. , bahcall & wolf 1965 ) . the poorly understood properties of the strong nuclear potential at the densities found in ns interiors make these calculations difficult , and lead to a wide range of predictions based on different assumptions for the equation of state , composition , and details of superconductivity ( see , e.g. , reviews by tsuruta , 1998 , and yakovlev & pethick , 2004 ) . while there is a clear consensus that the early cooling proceeds via neutrino emission from the ns core , the timescale over which this dominates depends critically on the neutrino production rate which , in turn , can vary by orders of magnitude depending upon the state of matter in the interior . broadly speaking , models can be divided into `` standard '' and `` non - standard '' cooling scenarios based on the rate of neutrino production in the ns interior . at the high densities and low proton fractions expected in ns interiors , the direct urca reactions ( @xmath20 and @xmath21 ) can not conserve both energy and momentum . instead , a bystander baryon is required for each interaction to absorb momentum . the neutrino rate for this so - called modified urca ( murca ) process is considerably lower than in the direct ( durca ) process because of the extra interaction required , and is the basis for standard cooling models . neutrino bremsstrahlung , and plasmon neutrino processes ) . in figure 6 ( left ) , we plot cooling curves for different models of the ns interior and its properties using representative neutrino rates ( see @xcite and references therein ) . the solid curve corresponds to `` standard '' cooling using an equation of state of moderate stiffness . non - standard cooling models incorporate neutrino emissivities associated with other processes that may operate in ns interiors , such as those arising from the presence of pion condensates which may form at sufficiently high densities . the resulting pion - induced beta decay leads to very a high neutrino emissivity and a correspondingly shorter cooling time for the ns interior . similar processes involving kaon condensates or quark matter may operate as well . alternatively , equations of state that allow a high proton fraction in the interior may allow the durca process to proceed ; this also leads to extremely high neutrino production rates ( e.g. , @xcite ) . these nonstandard cooling mechanisms modify the ns cooling curves substantially . the dashed curves in figure 6 represent approximations for several nonstandard cooling models and illustrate the associated rapid cooling ( page 1998 ) . the effects of superfluidity can substantially moderate such rapid cooling because the significantly reduced heat capacity of the superfluid particles reduces the neutrino rate considerably . thus , slow cooling can occur from a combination of slow neutrino rates and a high degree of superfluidity , while rapid cooling places strong constraints on both , and thus on the structure and physics of the ns interior , as well as on the microphysics of superfluidity . in particular , as the temperature approaches the critical temperature for the superfluid state , the formation and breaking of cooper pairs opens another channel for neutrino emission that can lead to more rapid cooling . page et al . , 2004 have calculated a `` minimal cooling '' scenario which extends the standard murca cooling scenario to include the contributions from this cooper pair process . as discussed below , for some superfluidity models they find sufficiently rapid cooling to explain most observations of young nss . @xcite , on the other hand , have considered both standard and enhanced cooling models . using the ns mass as a free parameter , they find models for which the durca process becomes active for sufficiently high masses , thus leading to a picture in which the young , cool nss correspond to those with higher mass ( see below ) . treating the emission from the ns surface as a blackbody , x - ray spectral fitting provides a measure of the gravitationally redshifted temperature and luminosity ( assuming the distance is known ) : @xmath22 t_s ; l^\infty = \left[1 - \sqrt{\frac{2gm}{rc^2}}\right]^2 l\ ] ] where the quantities on the left are observed at infinity , and those on the right are at the ns surface ; @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the mass and radius of the ns . from this we calculate the effective radius , which can be compared directly with predications for different equations of state : @xmath25 $ ] ( where @xmath26 is the stefan - boltzmann constant ) . alternatively , if only an upper limit on the source luminosity is determined , a temperature upper limit can be derived by assuming a value for the ns radius . as with all stars , the emission from the surface of a ns is not a blackbody ; rather , it is modified by the presence of whatever atmosphere might exist . one expects the surface of the ns to be covered with fe , but an atmosphere consisting of h , he , and/or intermediate - mass elements acquired either from ejecta fallback following the neutron star s formation , or from material accreted from the ism , is also a possibility . from models of nonmagnetic atmospheres , the primary effect of h or he atmospheres is a considerable deviation of the high energy end of the spectrum relative to the wien tail of a pure blackbody . the result is that attempts to fit the observed emission with a blackbody model will overestimate the effective temperature typically by as much as a factor of two . the inferred size of the ns would , in turn , be underestimated in order to yield the same flux . for atmospheres dominated by heavier elements the effect is considerably reduced , and the blackbody fit gives a good approximation to the temperature . in figure 6 ( right ) we plot the measured temperatures , or upper limits , for the pulsars and compact objects in snrs for which these values are best determined . values for known pulsars are plotted with closed circles . for comparison , curves are shown for standard cooling as well as the `` minimal '' cooling model of @xcite ( dashed curve ) . the latter model assumes no enhanced cooling mechanisms in the interior . the primary mechanism which results in faster cooling is neutrino emission from the cooper pair breaking and formation process , which is heavily dependent upon the assumed superfluidity model ( here we have plotted their model `` a '' for the neutron @xmath27p@xmath28 gap ) ; the predicted cooling rate is sufficiently rapid to explain the measurements for most pulsars , although the temperatures for the vela pulsar and j0205 + 6449 in 3c 58 fall appear to require more rapid cooling . the inferred temperature for rx j0007.0 + 7302 ( plotted as an open box in figure 6 ) , a compact x - ray source in the snr cta 1 , also falls below this minimal cooling scenario ( slane et al . , 2004 ) . while pulsations have yet to be detected from this source , _ chandra _ observations by @xcite reveal a slightly extended source with a distinct jet - like tail that is the signature of the pulsar outflows described in section 1.2 . for comparison , cooling curves illustrating the effects of increasing mass are plotted as solid curves , using the model 1p for proton superfluidity from yakovlev and pethick , 2004 . also plotted in the figure , as dashed arrows , are upper limits based on a neutron star search in nearby snrs ( @xcite ) . in this study , deep x - ray observations were used to identify , sources within the field of the snrs , and follow - up optical and ir observations were used to screen for non - ns counterparts . while the lack of detection of a ns in these remnants ( g127.1 + 0.5 , g84.2 - 0.8 , g93.3 + 6.9 , and g315.4 - 2.3 in increasing order of temperature upper limit ) may indicate that these snrs originated in type ia events , or all formed black holes , this is statistically unlikely . future measurements from this study will solidify this picture , and perhaps provide further evidence for rapid cooling in young neutron stars . due in large part to the availability of high resolution x - ray measurements , the study of young nss and their pwne have yielded dramatic new information on the nature of the stellar interiors and the structure of their winds . it is now clear that the axisymmetric wind from a pulsar goes through a termination shock as it joins the slower flow of its extended nebula , and that jets and toroidal structures characterizing the inner structure can be used to infer the orientation of the pulsar spin axis . the brightness variations in the inner nebula and jets , as well as the spectral and spatial structure of these regions , yield information on the outflow geometry as well as the fraction of spin - down energy being channeled into these regions . with broad application to particle acceleration and jet formation in astrophysical settings , these observations are providing constraints on theoretical models of considerable importance for a wide range of problems . similarly , new observations are providing unprecedented capabilities for detecting young neutron stars in snrs , and for characterizing their emission . these have forced a revised look at models for the structure of ns interiors and provide the best opportunity for addressing the possibility that exotic states of matter reside in ns cores . through additional and more sensitive observations of these systems , we anticipate significant refinements , and undoubtedly new surprises , in broad picture of their structure that is currently unfolding . the author wish to thank bryan gaensler , david helfand , jack hughes , and fred seward for their particular contributions to this work . informative discussions on ns cooling with dima yakovlev and dany page are also gratefully acknowledged . this work was supported in part by nasa contract nas8 - 39073 and grants go0 - 1117a , nag5 - 9281 , and go1 - 2054x . bocchino , f. , warwick , r. s. , marty , p. , lumb , d. , becker , w. , and pigot , c. ( 2001 ) . the x - ray nebula of the filled center supernova remnant 3c 58 and its interaction with the environment . , 369:10781087 . camilo , f. , lorimer , d. r. , bhat , n. d. r. , gotthelf , e. v. , halpern , j. p. , wang , q. d. , lu , f. j. , and mirabal , n. ( 2002a ) . discovery of a 136 millisecond radio and x - ray pulsar in supernova remnant g54.1 + 0.3 . , 574:l71l74 . , j. j. , stone , j. m. , scowen , p. a. , jun , b. , gallagher , j. s. , norman , m. l. , ballester , g. e. , burrows , c. j. , casertano , s. , clarke , j. t. , crisp , d. , griffiths , r. e. , hoessel , j. g. , holtzman , j. a. , krist , j. , mould , j. r. , sankrit , r. , stapelfeldt , k. r. , trauger , j. t. , watson , a. , and westphal , j. a. ( 1996 ) . . , 456:225233 . hughes , j. p. , slane , p. o. , burrows , d. n. , garmire , g. , nousek , j. a. , olbert , c. m. , and keohane , j. w. ( 2001 ) . a pulsar wind nebula in the oxygen - rich supernova remnant g292.0 + 1.8 . , 559:l153l156 . kaspi , v. m. , roberts , m. s. e. , and harding , a. k. ( 2004 ) . isolated neutron stars . in lewin , w. h. g. and van der klis , m. , editors , _ compact stellar x - ray sources _ , cambridge . cup . in press ( astro - ph/0402136 ) . , d. ( 1998 ) . thermal evolution of isolated neutron stars . in _ the many faces of neutron stars . edited by r. buccheri , j. van paradijs , and m. a. alpar . dordrecht ; boston : kluwer academic publishers , 1998 . , p.539 _ , pages 539 . park , s. , roming , p. w. a. , hughes , j. p. , slane , p. o. , burrows , d. n. , garmire , g. p. , and nousek , j. a. ( 2002 ) . the structure of the oxygen - rich supernova remnant g292.0 + 1.8 from chandra x - ray images : shocked ejecta and circumstellar medium . , 564:l39l44 . , m. c. , hester , j. j. , tennant , a. f. , elsner , r. f. , schulz , n. s. , marshall , h. l. , karovska , m. , nichols , j. s. , swartz , d. a. , kolodziejczak , j. j. , and odell , s. l. ( 2000 ) . discovery of spatial and spectral structure in the x - ray emission from the crab nebula . , 536:l81l84 . | with teragauss magnetic fields , surface gravity sufficiently strong to significantly modify light paths , central densities higher than that of a standard nucleus , and rotation periods of only hundredths of a second , young neutron stars are sites of some of the most extreme physical conditions known in the universe . they generate magnetic winds with particles that are accelerated to energies in excess of a tev . these winds form synchrotron - emitting bubbles as the particle stream is eventually decelerated to match the general expansion caused by the explosion that formed the neutron stars . the structure of these pulsar wind nebulae allow us to infer properties of the winds and the pulsating neutron stars themselves . the surfaces of the the stars radiate energy from the rapidly cooling interiors where the physical structure is basically unknown because of our imprecise knowledge of the strong interaction at ultrahigh densities . here i present a summary of recent measurements that allow us to infer the birth properties of neutron stars and to probe the nature of their winds , the physics of their atmospheres , and the structure of their interiors . neutron star , pulsar wind , cooling , jets , filaments |
cond-mat0008390 | the lowest energy vibrational excitations of molecules adsorbed on metal surfaces generally correspond to motion of the molecule as a whole about the adsorption bond , i.e. , frustrated translations and rotations . these modes play an important role in thermally activated processes at surfaces , such as catalysis and surface diffusion.@xcite it would , therefore , be highly desirable to be able to control the dynamical behavior of these vibrations . we propose a way to dramatically alter the lifetime of low - frequency adsorbate modes by suitably modifying the composition of the substrate . we recently developed a theory for the relaxation dynamics of adsorbate vibrational modes whose frequency lies within the long - wavelength acoustic part of the substrate phonon spectrum.@xcite this frequency range is relevant , for example , for in - plane frustrated translations ( ft ) of molecules on metal surfaces . we have shown that the relaxation of these modes is governed by resonant coupling to bulk substrate phonons ; _ i.e. , _ the vibrating overlayer radiates its energy into resonant acoustic waves.@xcite all other relaxation channels , such as substrate electron - hole pair excitation , are typically sub - dominant . this result suggests that the lifetime of ft and other low - lying adsorbate modes can be significantly altered by changing the substrate phonon spectrum at the resonant frequency . in this paper we explore the use of superlattices to achieve this goal . for the last two decades , superlattices have received considerable attention by materials researchers because of their unusual and highly tunable properties . superlattices consist of a periodic alternation of layers of two or more different materials . for simplicity , this paper focuses on superlattices of two materials , @xmath0 and @xmath1 . the resulting periodic mass modulation causes frequency gaps to open in the phonon spectrum for modes propagating parallel to the stacking direction , @xmath2 . the size and placement of the band gaps are determined by compositional parameters of the superlattice , such as the mass ratio of materials @xmath0 and @xmath1 and the modulation period . the modes expelled from band - gap regions gather near van hove singularities at the gap edges . thus , the superlattice mass modulation enhances the bulk phonon spectrum at some frequencies while depleting it at others . we consider an ordered adsorbate overlayer on the surface of such a superlattice , with the surface normal aligned along @xmath2 . a @xmath3 ft excitation of the overlayer will only couple to bulk modes propagating parallel to @xmath2 . thus , depending on the superlattice compositional parameters , the ft frequency may fall in a region of either depleted or enhanced phonon density of states ( dos ) , compared to the pure substrate . in the former case , resonant phonon emission is eliminated as a ft decay channel , because there are no phonon states at the resonant frequency . in the latter case , one might expect enhanced coupling because of the increased phase space . however , before reaching that conclusion , it is necessary to consider the coupling strength to modes in the van hove singularities . in this work , we examine all of these issues using a model system corresponding to an ordered adsorbate overlayer on a face - centered cubic ( fcc ) superlattice . acoustic waves in superlattice substrates have been investigated previously . @xcite in particular , camley _ et al . _ derived vibrational dispersion relations for both infinite and semi - infinite superlattices in the elastic - continuum limit ( _ i.e. , _ both the solid as a whole and the @xmath0 and @xmath1 layers individually are treated as continuous media).@xcite they focused on superlattices with a modulation wavelength of 1000 or more . in this paper , we opt for an atomistic approach instead of an elastic - continuum model , because we are interested in superlattices of small enough modulation wavelength that variations by even a single atomic layer cause noticeable changes in the bulk phonon spectrum . nevertheless , the basic physical picture presented in ref . still applies . figure 6 of ref . is a plot of @xmath4 vs. @xmath5 for an infinite superlattice . this plot shows that the mass modulation creates frequency gaps in the bulk vibrational spectrum not only at @xmath6 , but also at finite @xmath5 . indeed , for any frequency , there will be regions of the @xmath5-plane for which there are no propagating acoustic modes and other regions for which propagating acoustic modes exist . points on the boundary between these two types of regions are van hove singularities . this picture is very encouraging , since @xmath5-resolved experimental surface techniques , such as inelastic helium - atom scattering,@xcite could then be used to exhibit the whole range of behaviors predicted here for adsorbate vibrations coupled to a superlattice . et al . , _ also present @xmath4 vs. @xmath5 for a semi - infinite superlattice ( fig . 8 of ref . ) . they show that a band of surface waves appears in each bulk band - gap region . we use lattice dynamics to study the vibrational coupling between the adsorbate overlayer and the superlattice substrate . in this approach , the atoms are treated as point masses , and each atomic degree of freedom of the system is coupled harmonically to all others . the normal modes of vibration are obtained by solving the generalized eigenvalue problem , @xmath7 , where the eigenvector @xmath8 resides in the 3@xmath9-dimensional configuration space of the @xmath9 atoms , with origin at the equilibrium configuration , the eigenvalue @xmath10 is the square of the normal - mode frequency , * m * is the diagonal 3@xmath9@xmath113@xmath9 matrix of atomic masses , and * k * is the symmetric 3@xmath9@xmath113@xmath9 matrix of harmonic force constants . for metals and non - polar semiconductors and insulators , a cutoff can be defined so that only coupling constants above a given magnitude are included . this makes the * k * matrix sparse . our model substrate is an fcc superlattice with the stacking axis and the surface normal both parallel to the [ 001 ] crystallographic axis . integers @xmath12 and @xmath13 represent the number of atomic ( 001 ) planes of materials @xmath0 and @xmath1 , respectively , in each superlattice period ( @xmath14 ) . the overall thickness of the substrate in our calculations is 250@xmath15 . our model overlayer consists of an ordered array of diatomic molecules forming a @xmath16(2@xmath112 ) pattern ( _ i.e. , _ checkerboard pattern ) . in - plane periodic boundary conditions are used , making the model system of infinite extent parallel to the surfaces and superlattice interfaces , but restricting our analysis to @xmath6 modes . for simplicity in this exploratory research , we make the approximation that the force constants coupling the substrate atoms are insensitive to the chemical species . therefore , varying the superlattice composition is achieved simply by altering the mass matrix * m*. for real systems , the mass modulation accounts for the majority of the effect , with compositionally varying force constants contributing essentially no new physics . the major conclusions of this research are insensitive to the specific details of the model system . however , we study this particular structural model for two important reasons . first , this structure is often experimentally realized for diatomic adsorbates on fcc - metal ( 001 ) substrates . second , this choice of model allows us to use the force constants we obtained from earlier density - functional theory calculations for the prototypical system of co on cu ( 001).@xcite the vibrational frequencies computed in that study are in excellent quantitative agreement with experiment . see ref . for numerical values of the force constants , as well as details of how they were computed and comparisons to experiment . for definiteness and ease of comparison to our earlier work , we also choose the masses of co and cu for the adsorbate and @xmath0-atom masses , respectively . given the model described above , there remain three parameters for specifying the system : the mass ratio @xmath17 of the two superlattice materials and the layer thicknesses , @xmath12 and @xmath13 . experience shows that the mass ratio needs to be fairly large in order to create sizable phonon band gaps . we have chosen a mass ratio of 3:1 ( _ e.g. , _ au and cu have this mass ratio ) . the modulation period @xmath15 should be chosen so that the ft frequency is near or within a phonon band gap . if the frequency of resonant phonons in the pure material corresponds to a wavelength spanning about @xmath18 atomic layers , then bragg theory suggests that a modulation period of @xmath19 layers will open a band gap at or near the resonant frequency . for the model parameters corresponding to @xmath16(2@xmath112)-co on cu ( 001 ) , our base system , this condition gives a modulation wavelength of about @xmath20 layers . this value is to be contrasted with the elastic - continuum work of ref . , which considered a superlattice with 1500 modulation wavelength , corresponding to @xmath21 layers . the resulting lowest band gap was 0.05 @xmath22 wide , centered at a frequency of 0.24 @xmath22 . these values are two orders of magnitude too small for our purposes , and we thus need to consider a superlattice modulation that is two orders of magnitude narrower . the distribution of the @xmath23 layers between materials @xmath0 and @xmath1 is left as a variable parameter . figure [ dos](a)-(d ) shows the low - frequency portion of the vibrational dos of the coupled adsorbate / substrate system for @xmath20 superlattices . the dashed curve in each panel is the dos projected onto the idealized ft coordinate . each panel corresponds to a different partitioning of the 8 layers of the superlattice period into @xmath0 and @xmath1 layers . the symbol ( @xmath12,@xmath13 ) in the figure panels specifies the partitioning . the ( 8,0 ) panel ( fig . [ dos](a ) ) corresponds to a pure substrate of material @xmath0 . for the present choice of masses and force constants , this system is identical to our vibrational spectrum in refs . and online@xcite . the broad peak centered at 27 @xmath22 is the ft resonance , whose natural line width corresponds to a lifetime of 3.0 ps . = 4.50 in as soon as mass modulation is introduced into the substrate , band gaps open in the dos near the ft frequency , as predicted . in addition there are band gaps at higher frequencies corresponding to higher order bragg reflections . the band gaps are accompanied by the large spectral enhancement on either side of the gap characteristic of van hove singularities . notice that isolated peaks often appear in the band gaps . these peaks are mixtures of the surface states described by camley _ _ in ref . with the adsorbate frustrated translation they are truly @xmath24-functions ; the width that appears in the figure results from gaussian smoothing of the spectra . for the ( 6,2 ) superlattice , the van hove singularity below the band gap coincides in frequency with the ft mode ( see fig . [ dos](b ) ) . despite the large density of bulk phonon states at that frequency , the ft mode does not form a broad resonance . rather , it remains a narrow , @xmath24-function - like peak . this suggests that the coupling strength of the ft to bulk modes in this peak is very weak . we explore this issue further in the discussion below . as the content of the more massive material ( @xmath1 ) in the superlattice increases , the band gap narrows and shifts to lower frequency . these changes reflect the overall contraction of much of the phonon spectrum due to the @xmath25-like dependence of vibrational frequencies . for the ( 4,4 ) superlattice , this effect causes the lower edge of the band gap to come below the ft frequency , leaving the adsorbate mode in the gap with no phonons to couple to ( see fig . [ dos](c ) ) . this feature is now an infinitely narrow @xmath24-function . resonant coupling to substrate phonons , therefore , contributes nothing to ft relaxation , leaving previously marginal processes , such as electron - phonon , multi - phonon , and anharmonic coupling , as the dominant decay channels . for the ( 2,6 ) superlattice , the narrowing and lowering of the gap has caused the upper edge of the gap to come below the ft frequency , leaving the ft mode once again well within the bulk phonon continuum . the coupling to these bulk modes is strong enough to produce a broad ft resonance peak , as in the case of the pure ( 8,0 ) substrate . to gain a deeper understanding of the effect of varying superlattice composition on the ft dynamics , we examine , in fig . [ eigvec ] , the atomic displacement patterns of ft - related normal modes for the ( 4,4 ) , ( 6,2 ) , and ( 8,0 ) systems . for the ( 6,2 ) and ( 8,0 ) systems , we display the modes at the center of the ft resonance peak . in each panel , the vertical axis denotes the position of a layer of atoms relative to the surface , and the horizontal axis denotes the relative displacement of each layer away from equilibrium for the given normal mode . for clarity only @xmath2680 atomic layers of the 2,000-layer substrate are shown . = 4.50 in figure [ eigvec ] highlights the characteristic delocalization that occurs when an isolated mode comes into resonance with a continuum of states . the isolated ft mode for the ( 4,4 ) system , shown in fig . [ eigvec](a ) , is exponentially localized at the surface . the side - to - side `` wagging '' of the co molecules dominates the displacement pattern , with the amplitude on substrate layers rapidly decaying as a function of penetration distance . in contrast , the resonance modes pictured in figs . [ eigvec](b ) and ( c ) for the ( 6,2 ) and ( 8,0 ) systems , respectively , are clearly combinations of adsorbate ft motion and substrate phonon motion . these modes exhibit the large amplitude c - o wagging behavior characteristic of frustrated translations . however , an appreciable amplitude of long - wavelength bulk - phonon motion persists throughout the substrate , so that the resonance states are not localized . comparing panels ( b ) and ( c ) of fig . [ eigvec ] shows that the substrate - phonon component of the mode has noticeably smaller amplitude for the ( 6,2 ) system than for the ( 8,0 ) system , indicating a smaller coupling strength between the adsorbate ft motion and the substrate phonons . we were able to infer the same result in the previous section by comparing both the dos s and the ft - projected dos s of the ( 6,2 ) and ( 8,0 ) systems . to understand the source of this weaker coupling , we investigate the nature of the bulk modes in the enhanced spectral region below the band gap . figure [ beat ] illustrates the atomic displacement pattern for the first two modes below the band gap for a 2,000-layer , bare ( 6,2 ) superlattice substrate . the vertical axis again denotes the position of a layer of atoms relative to the surface , but in this figure , unlike fig . [ eigvec ] , all substrate layers are shown . these modes have a beat - like pattern , with the comparatively short - wavelength oscillations spanning about 16 ( _ i.e. , _ @xmath27 ) atomic layers per cycle and the long - wavelength oscillations exhibiting fixed - end standing - wave character . = 4.50 in the existence of these beat - like modes is tied to the formation of the band gap . for wavelengths around @xmath27 atomic layers in a period-@xmath15 superlattice , it becomes possible to form linear combinations of homogeneous - substrate modes that have maximal atomic displacement solely in either material-@xmath0 or material-@xmath1 regions of the superlattice . these linear combinations are stabilized by the coherence with the superlattice modulation , and they give rise to a band gap because of the inverse - square - root dependence of the frequency on the mass . the beat patterns form because the linear combinations superpose modes with similar spatial frequencies ( _ i.e. , _ wavelengths ) . there are many different ways to form linear combinations that are commensurate with the superlattice modulation , each one distinguished by the number of nodes in the resulting envelope waveform . this is the source of the spectral enhancement below and above the band gap . for the ( 6,2 ) system , the adsorbate ft motion is in resonance with these beat - like modes . however , since these modes have very small amplitude at the surface of the superlattice , the coupling between them and the ft mode is very weak . therefore , despite the large density of bulk modes available for coupling , the resulting resonance peak remains very narrow , and the ft - mode remains long - lived . to elucidate more fully the effect of the envelope function of the beat - like modes on ft vibrational relaxation , we examine how the width of the ft resonance varies with ft frequency , for a given superlattice substrate . we are able to accomplish this by varying the value of the force constant , @xmath28 , coupling the adsorbates to the substrate,@xcite since the ft frequency is a smooth , monotonically increasing function of @xmath28 . figure [ freqwid ] displays the computed dependence of the resonance width on the ft frequency for the ( 6,2 ) superlattice.@xcite as expected , the resonance width is zero for ft frequencies in the superlattice - induced bulk band gap . the weak coupling of the ft to the beat - like modes near the gap edges is seen as a rapid decrease in the resonance width when approaching the band - gap region from either side . away from the bulk band gap and its adjacent spectrally enhanced regions , the resonance width is a monotonic , more gently increasing function of the ft frequency . = 3.00 in one concern regarding the analysis in this paper is that superlattices with very short modulation periods are required . as a result , the interfaces between the @xmath0 and @xmath1 layers must be sharp on the scale of one or two atomic layers . this sharpness may be difficult to achieve for metallic superlattices due to interfacial diffusion or miscibility . a potential solution to this concern would be to use a semiconductor superlattice for the substrate . these materials can be grown with very sharp interfaces , and therefore may accommodate the short modulation periods that are required for the application described in this paper . in order to restore the chemical environment of the adsorbate - metal interface , one could first deposit several layers of metal ( _ e.g. , _ copper ) on the surface of the superlattice , and then form the molecular overlayer on the supported metal film . one of the most important goals in surface science is to be able to control dynamical processes taking place at a surface . we have proposed substrate patterning as a means to control the relaxation dynamics of low - frequency frustrated - translational vibrations of an adsorbate overlayer . this proposal emerges from our recent work demonstrating that the dominant relaxation mechanism for these modes is resonant emission of phonons into the substrate . specifically , we have considered short - period superlattices as candidate substrates , because the mass modulation of a superlattice causes gaps to open in the phonon density of states . varying the superlattice composition allows one to control the size and placement of these band gaps , thereby controllably modifying the coupling between the adsorbate overlayer and the substrate . we view the successful experimental demonstration of the behavior predicted here as a stringent test of our theory of resonant adsorbate - substrate coupling . moreover it would establish substrate patterning as an important tool in surface dynamical research . financial support for this research was provided by the national science foundation under grant no . dmr 97 - 02514 , the air force office of scientific research , air force materiel command , usaf , under grant no . f49620 - 00 - 1 - 0170 , and the university of georgia research foundation . spl acknowledges support of the donors of the petroleum research fund , administered by the american chemical society . amr acknowledges support of the alfred p. sloan foundation . adsorbate vibrational relaxation via phonon emission was first considered theoretically by b. n. j. persson and r. ryberg , phys . b * 32 * , 3586 ( 1985 ) , and by b. hall , d. l. mills , and j. e. black , phys . b * 32 * , 4932 ( 1985 ) . the variation of this force constant has to be done in a manner that preserves the acoustic sum rule ( _ i.e. , _ acoustic modes go to zero frequency as wavelength becomes infinite ) . thus , if @xmath29 is the force constant in question , then incrementing @xmath29 by an amount @xmath30 requires decrementing @xmath31 and @xmath32 by the same amount . figure [ freqwid ] corresponds to the case where the superlattice substrate terminates on the more massive material , @xmath1 . this choice has the effect of suppressing the intra - gap surface state . the alternate choice of terminating on an @xmath0-type layer leads to a more complicated picture involving an avoided crossing of the ft and surface states as a function of @xmath28 . | we propose using short - period superlattices as substrates to control the vibrational relaxation dynamics of adsorbate overlayers . the mass modulation of superlattices creates both band gaps and large spectral enhancements in the phonon density of states . these modifications can dramatically alter the coupling between vibrational modes of the adsorbate overlayer and the substrate lattice , thereby significantly affecting the lifetime of adsorbate modes . |
1701.08888 | users confront with the `` information overload '' dilemma and it is increasingly difficult for them to choose the preferred items over others because of the growing large item set , e.g. , hundreds of millions products at amazon.com and tens of thousands videos at netflix.com @xcite . recommender systems ( rss ) assist users in tackling this problem and help them make choices by ranking the items based on their past behavior history . item recommendation predicts a personalized ranking over a set of items for individual user and hence alleviates the dilemma . the rating - based ( or point - wise ) methods predict ratings that a user will give to items and then rank the items according to their predicted ratings . many methods are proposed and matrix factorization based models are most popular due to their scalability , simplicity , and flexibility @xcite . this paradigm concentrates on explicit feedback and it faces the difficulties in collecting them . meanwhile , the ranking - based ( pair - wise ) methods are presented with seen items and then rank the seen above the unseen . bayesian personalized ranking ( bpr - mf ) and collaborative item selection are typical representatives @xcite . this paradigm takes advantage of widely available implicit feedback but it usually ignores a kind of important information : item reviews . * related works . * item reviews justify the preferences of users and help alleviate the cold - start problem ; they are a diverse and complementary data source for recommendation beyond the user - item co - rating information . the cmf method @xcite can be adapted to factorize the user / item - word matrix constructed from the item reviews . the ctr @xcite and hft @xcite models integrate explicit ratings with item content / reviews to build better rating predictors ; they employ topic modeling to learn hidden topic factors which explain the variations of users preferences . the ctrank model @xcite also adopts topic modeling to exploit item meta - data like article title and abstract via bag - of - words representation for one - class collaborative filtering @xcite , while the cdr @xcite and cke @xcite models adopt stacked denoising autoencoders . nevertheless , integrating item reviews into the ranking - based methods presents both opportunities and challenges for traditional bayesian personalized ranking . there are few works on leveraging item reviews to improve personalized ranking . in this paper we propose two novel and simple models to incorporate item reviews into bpr - mf . like hft , they integrate item reviews and unlike hft they generate a ranked list of items for individual ranking . like ctrank , they focus on personalized ranking and unlike ctrank they are based on matrix factorization and using word embeddings to extract features . like bpr - mf , they rank preferred items over others and unlike bpr - mf they leverage the information from item reviews . in each of the two models , we make use of text features extracted from item reviews using word embeddings . and on top of text features we uncover the review dimensions that explain the variation in users feedback . these review factors represent a prior preference of a user . one model treats the review factor space independent of the latent factor space ; another connects implicit feedback and item reviews through the shared item space . the contributions of this work are summarized as follows . we propose two novel models to integrate item reviews into matrix factorization based bayesian personalized ranking ( section [ paper : different ] and [ paper : shared ] ) . they generate a ranked list of items for individual user by leveraging the information from item reviews . \2 . for exploiting item reviews , we build the proposed models on the top of text features extracted from them . we demonstrate a simple and effective way of extracting features from item reviews by averagely composing word embeddings ( section [ paper : features ] ) . we empirically evaluate the proposed models on multiple real - world datasets which contains over millions of feedback in total . the experimental results show the benefit of leveraging item reviews on personalized ranking prediction . we also conduct analyses to understand the proposed models including the training efficiency and the impact of the number of latent factors . before proposing our models , we briefly review the personalized ranking task and then describe the problem statement . to this end , we first introduce the notations used throughout the paper . suppose there are @xmath0 users @xmath1 and @xmath2 items @xmath3 . we reserve @xmath4 for indexing users and @xmath5 for indexing items . let @xmath6 denote the user - item binary implicit feedback matrix , where @xmath7 is the preference of user @xmath8 on item @xmath9 , and we mark a zero if it is unknown . define @xmath10 as the set of items on which user @xmath8 has an action : @xmath11 . rating - based methods @xcite and ranking - based methods @xcite are mainly to learn the latent user factors @xmath12 \in \mathbb{r}^{f \times m}$ ] and latent item factors @xmath13 \in \mathbb{r}^{f \times n}$ ] from partially observed feedback @xmath14 . item @xmath9 may have text information , e.g. , review @xmath15 commented by user @xmath8 . we aggregate all reviews of a particular item as a ` doc ' @xmath16 . approaches like ctr and hft @xcite integrate item content / reviews with explicit ratings for rating prediction using topic modeling . another approach is to learn word embeddings and then compose them into document level as the item text features ; we adopt this way of extracting text features @xmath17 from @xmath18 ( see section [ paper : features ] ) . our work focuses on the item recommendation or personalized ranking task where a ranked list of items is generated for each individual user . the goal is to accurately rank the unobserved items which contain both truly negative items ( e.g. , the user dislikes the netflix movies or is not interesting in buying amazon products ) and missing ones ( e.g. , the user wants to see a movie or buy a product in the future when she knows it ) . instead of accurately predicting unseen ratings by learning a model from training samples @xmath19 where @xmath20 , personalized ranking optimizes for correctly ranking item pairs by learning a model from training tuples @xmath21 . the meaning of item pairs of a user @xmath22 is that she prefers the former than the latter , i.e. , the model tries to reconstruct parts of a total order @xmath23 for each user @xmath8 . from the history feedback @xmath14 we can infer that the observed items @xmath9 are ranked higher than the unobserved ones @xmath24 ; and for both observed items @xmath25 or both unobserved items @xmath26 we can infer nothing . random ( negative ) sampling is adopted since the number of such pairs is huge . see the original bpr paper @xcite for more details . * problem 1 . * personalized ranking with item reviews . * input : * 1 ) a binary implicit feedback matrix @xmath14 , 2 ) an item reviews corpus @xmath27 , and 3 ) a user @xmath8 in the user set @xmath28 . * output : * a ranked list @xmath23 over the unobserved items @xmath29 . in problem 1 , to generate the ranked list , we have item reviews to exploit besides implicit feedback . in this section , we propose two models as a solution to problem 1 which leverage item reviews into bayesian personalized ranking . one model treats the review factor space independent of the latent factor space ( section [ paper : different ] ) . another model connects implicit feedback and item reviews through the shared item space ( section [ paper : shared ] ) . in each of the two proposed models , we make use of text features extracted from item reviews via word embeddings ( section [ paper : features ] ) . on top of text features we uncover the review dimensions that explain the variation in users feedback and these review factors represent a prior preference of a user . both models are based on basic matrix factorization ( section [ paper : basicmf ] ) and learned under the bayesian personalized ranking framework ( section [ paper : learning ] ) . the basic matrix factorization ( basic mf ) is mainly to find the latent user - specific feature matrix @xmath30^m_1 $ ] and item - specific feature matrix @xmath31^n_1 $ ] to approximate the partially observed feedback matrix @xmath14 in the regularized least - squares ( or ridge regression ) sense by solving the following problem . @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the regularization parameter to avoid over - fitting . the predicted scores @xmath34 can be modeled by various forms which embody the flexibility of matrix factorization . a basic form is @xmath35 , where @xmath36 , @xmath37 and @xmath38 are biases @xcite . in this section , we propose our first model _ tbpr - diff _ to integrate item reviews with implicit feedback . analogical to the basic mf which factorizes the ratings into user- and item- _ latent _ factors , we can factorize the reviews into user- and item- _ text _ factors ( see the illustration in figure [ fig : predictors]up ) . the tbpr - diff model sharpens this idea and teases apart the rating dimensions into latent factors and text factors : @xmath39 where the term @xmath40 is newly introduced to capture the text interaction between user @xmath8 and item @xmath9 . to exploit item reviews , text features @xmath17 are firstly extracted from item reviews via word embeddings ( hence they are known and fixed ) . the shared embedding kernel @xmath41 linearly transforms original text features @xmath42 from high - dimensional space ( e.g. , 200 ) into a lower text rating space ( e.g. , 15 ) , and then it @xmath43 interacts with text factors of user @xmath44 . a text bias vector @xmath45 is also introduced to model users overall preferences towards the item reviews . the details of text features extracted from item reviews using word embeddings are described later ( see section [ paper : features ] ) . since the text factors of user @xmath46 and of item @xmath43 are _ independent _ of latent factors @xmath47 and @xmath48 , there is no deep interactions between the information sources of observed feedback and item reviews , and hence they can not benefit from each other . also additional parameters increase the model complexity . based on these observations , we propose another model to alleviate the above challenges . in this section , we propose our second model _ tbpr - shared _ to integrate item reviews with implicit feedback more compactly . for an item @xmath9 , its latent factors @xmath48 learned from feedback can be considered as characteristics that it processes ; meanwhile , these characteristics are probably discussed in its reviews and hence exhibit in its text factors @xmath49 ( see the illustration in figure [ fig : predictors]down ) . for user @xmath8 , if we let @xmath48 and @xmath50 be in the same space then it leads to deep interactions between text factors of user @xmath8 and the latent factor of item @xmath9 . the tbpr - shared model sharpens this idea and enables the deep interactions between text factors and latent factors as well as reduces complexity of the model : @xmath51 on the right hand , the last four terms are the same with the tbpr - diff model . different from the tbpr - diff model , the shared item factors @xmath48 now have two - fold meanings : one is item latent factors that represent items characteristics ; another is to interact with item text factors that capture items semantics from item reviews . also different from the tbpr - diff model , the preferences of a user now have a prior term which shows the ` text influence of her rated items ' captured by the text factors of corresponding items . in summary , on top of text features the tbpr - shared model uncovers the review dimensions that explain the variation in users feedback and these factors represent a prior preference of user . * remarks * * i. * the vbpr model @xcite proposed an analogical formulation with eq ( [ eq : diff ] ) . it exploits visual features extracted from item images and we leverage item features extracted from item reviews . the svd++ and nsvd @xcite models proposed similar formulas with eq ( [ eq : shared ] ) . they learn an implicit feature matrix to capture implicit feedback and we learn a text correlation matrix to capture text factors ; note that they did nt exploit item reviews and hence they had no the text bias term . * ii . * there can be an adjustable weight on the term of text ( i.e. , @xmath40 in eq ( [ eq : diff ] ) and @xmath52 in eq ( [ eq : shared ] ) ) to balance the influence from feedback and from reveiws , but here we just let feedback and reviews be equally important . before we delve into the learning algorithm , the preference predictors of tbpr - diff and of tbpr - shared models are shown in figure [ fig : predictors ] . revisit problem 1 , we need to generate a ranked list of items for individual user . bayesian personalized ranking @xcite is a generic pair - wise optimization framework that learns from the training item pairs using gradient descent . denote the model parameters as @xmath53 and let @xmath54 ( for simplicity we omit model parameters , and the notation @xmath55 is the same with @xmath7 ) represent an arbitrary real - valued mapping under the model parameters . then the optimization criterion for personalized ranking bpr - opt is [ eq : bpr - opt ] ( ) _ ( u , i , j ) d_s - ^2 , where @xmath56 , and the sigmoid function is defined as @xmath57 . the meaning behind bpr - opt requires ranking items accurately as well as using a simple model . under the generic bpr - opt framework , we derive the learning process for our proposed models tbpr - diff and tbpr - shared by embodying @xmath58 with @xmath59 and @xmath60 , respectively . the bpr - opt defined in eq ( [ eq : bpr - opt ] ) is differentiable and hence gradient ascent methods can be used to maximize it . for stochastic gradient ascent , a triple @xmath22 is randomly sampled from training sets @xmath61 and then update the model parameters by : [ eq : update - sgd ] + ( ( -x_uij ) - ) . the same gradients for user latent factors and bias terms of both models are : @xmath62 parameter gradients of the model tbpr - diff are : @xmath63 parameter gradients of the model tbpr - shared are : @xmath64 @xmath65 * complexity of models and learning . * the complexity of model tbpr - diff is @xmath66 while the complexity of model tbpr - shared is @xmath67 . we can see that the latter model reduces the complexity by @xmath68 , i.e. , the parameters @xmath69^m_1 $ ] . for updating each training sample @xmath70 , the complexity of learning tbpr - diff is linear in the number of dimensions ( @xmath71 ) while the complexity of learning tbpr - shared is also linear provided that the scale of rated items of users is amortizing constant , i.e. , @xmath72 , which holds in real - world datasets because of sparsity ( see table [ table : datasets ] ) . recall that when generating the ranked list of items for individual user , we have item reviews to exploit besides implicit feedback . to exploit item reviews , we extract text features from them , i.e. , there is a feature vector for each item . our proposed two models are both built on the top of text features ( @xmath73_{i=1}^{n}$ ] ) and hence they are important for improving personalized ranking . in this section , we give one simple way to extract text features from reviews of item word embedding . the sgns model @xcite is an architecture for learning continuous representations of words from large corpus ; these representations , or word embeddings , can capture the syntactic and semantic relationships of words . we first run the google word2vec code on amazon reviews corpus ( see table [ table : datasets ] ) using the default setting ( particularly , dimensionality @xmath74 ) to learn a vector @xmath75 for each word @xmath76 . and then we directly sum up all of the embeddings in an item s reviews ( excluding stop words ) and get a composition vector as the text feature for this item : @xmath77 to get @xmath42 , we can also use complex methods ( e.g. , tensor networks to compose word embeddings or learning the doc representation directly ) ; they are left for future work . lrrrrrr|c datasets & # users & # items & # feedback & # words & # colduser & # colditem & density ( % ) + girls & 778 & 3,963 & 5,474 & 302 m & 572 & 3,946 & 0.177 + boys & 981 & 4,114 & 6,388 & 302 m & 787 & 4,080 & 0.158 + baby & 1,238 & 4,592 & 8,401 & 302 m & 959 & 4,482 & 0.147 + men & 21,793 & 55,647 & 157,329 & 302 m & 15,821 & 52,031 & 0.013 + women & 62,928 & 157,656 & 504,847 & 302 m & 41,409 & 143,444 & 0.005 + phones&58,741 & 77,979 & 420,847 & 210 m & 43,429 & 67,706 & 0.009 + we evaluate our two models on multiple amazon.com datasets in terms of ranking performance ( section [ paper : data - metric ] ) . they integrate item reviews into bayesian personalized ranking optimization criterion and we want to know the benefit from them . so we compare with bpr - mf @xcite which ignores them and also with the most popular ( pop ) baseline that does nt show personalized ranking ( section [ paper : compare ] ) . we report the results in different settings ( section [ paper : results ] ) and analyse the proposed methods ( section [ paper : analysis ] ) . * datasets . * we evaluate our models on six amazon datasets @xcite http://jmcauley.ucsd.edu / data / amazon/. they consist of five from clothing and shoes category , and one from cell phones and accessories . we use the review history as implicit feedback and aggregate all users reviews to an item as a doc for this item . we draw the samples from original datasets such that every user has rated at least five items ( i.e. , @xmath78 ) and the statistics of final evaluation datasets are show in table [ table : datasets ] . from the table we can see that : 1 ) the observed feedback is very sparse , typically less than 0.01% ; 2 ) the average feedback events for users are typical about ten , i.e. , @xmath79 holds ; 3 ) more than half of the users and of the items are cold and have feedback less than seven . note that the cold - users/-items are those that have less than seven feedback events , and the feedback density = @xmath80 . we split each of the whole datasets into three parts : training , validation , and test . in detail , for each user @xmath81 , we randomly sample two items from her history feedback for test set @xmath82 , two for validation set @xmath83 , and the rest for training set @xmath84 ; and hence @xmath85 . this is the reason that we discard users who rated items less than five to ensure that there is at least one training sample for her . * evaluation protocol . * for item recommendation or personalized ranking , we need to generate a ranked list over the unobserved items . therefore for the hold - out test item @xmath86 of individual user @xmath8 , the evaluation calculates how accurately the model rank @xmath9 over other unobserved items @xmath87 . the widely used measure area under the roc curve ( auc ) sharpens the ranking correctness intuition : @xmath88 where @xmath89 and the @xmath90 is an indicator function . a higher auc score indicates a better recommendation performance . the validation set @xmath91 is used to tune hyperparameters and we report the corresponding results on the test set @xmath92 . we compare our proposed models tbpr - diff ( see eq ( [ eq : diff ] ) ) and tbpr - shared ( see eq ( [ eq : shared ] ) ) with the most popular * ( pop ) * and * bpr - mf * @xcite baselines . the difference of models lies in their preference predictors . * reproducibility*. we use the released code in @xcite to implement the comparing methods and our proposed models . the hyperparameters are tuned on the validation set . referring to the default setting , for the brp - mf model , the norm - penalty @xmath93 , and learning rate @xmath94 . as with our proposed models tbpr - diff and tbpr - shared , the norm - penalty @xmath95 for latent factors and @xmath96 for text factors , and learning rate @xmath97 . for simplicity , the number of latent factors equals to the number of text factors ; the default values for them are both fifteen ( i.e. , @xmath98 ) . since the raw datasets , comparing code , and parameter setting are given publicly , we confidently believe our experiments are easily reproduced . cccccc|cc datasets&setting & pop & bpr - mf & tbpr - diff&tbpr - shared & improv1 & improv2 + girls & all & 0.1699 & 0.5658 & 0.5919 & * 0.5939 * & 4.966 & 7.097 + boys & all & 0.2499 & 0.5493 & 0.5808 & * 0.5852 * & 6.535 & 11.99 + baby & all & 0.3451 & 0.5663 & 0.5932 & * 0.6021 * & 6.321 & 16.18 + & all & 0.5486 & 0.6536 & 0.6639 & * 0.6731 * & 2.983 & 18.57 + men & cold & 0.4725 & 0.5983 & 0.6114 & * 0.6225 * & 4.044 & 19.23 + & all & 0.5894 & 0.6735 & 0.6797 & * 0.6842 * & 1.588 & 12.72 + women & cold & 0.4904 & 0.6026 & 0.6110 & * 0.6152 * & 2.090 & 11.22 + & all & 0.7310 & 0.7779 & 0.7799 & * 0.7809 * & 0.386 & 6.396 + phones & cold & 0.5539 & 0.6415 & 0.6464 & * 0.6467 * & 0.811 & 5.936 + the auc performance results on eight amazon.com datasets are shown in table [ table : results ] where the last but one column is @xmath99 , and the last column is @xmath100 . for each dataset there are three evaluation settings : the _ all items or all _ setting evaluates the models on the full test set @xmath101 ; the _ cold start or cold _ setting evaluates the models on a subset @xmath102 such that the number of training samples for each item within @xmath103 is no greater than three ( i.e. , @xmath104 or @xmath105 ) ; the _ warm _ setting evaluates the models on the difference set of all and cold . revisit the table [ table : datasets ] we can see that : 1 ) almost all of the items are cold - item for datasets girls , boys , and baby ; and hence the results of cold setting are almost the same with all and the results of warm setting is not available to get a statistical reliable results ; and 2 ) for other three datasets , the percent of cold - items is also more than 86% which requires the model to address the inherent cold start nature of the recommendation problem . there are several observations from the evaluation results . _ under the all setting _ , tbpr - shared is the top performer , tbpr - diff is the second , with bpr - mf coming in third and pop the weakest . these results firstly show that leveraging item reviews besides the feedback can improve the personalized ranking ; and also show that the personalization methods are distinctly better than the user - independent pop method . for example , tbpr - shared averagely obtains relative 4.83% performance improvement compared with bpr - mf on the first three smaller datasets in terms of auc metric , and 2.74% in total six datasets . this two figures show , to some extent , that transferring the knowledge from auxiliary data source ( here item reviews ) helps most when the target data source ( here rating feedback ) is not so rich . _ under the cold setting _ , tbpr - shared is the top performer , tbpr - diff is the second , with bpr - mf coming in third and pop is also the weakest . these results firstly show that leveraging item reviews besides the feedback can improve the personalized ranking even in the cold start setting ; and also show that the personalization methods are distinctly better than the user - independent pop method since the cold items are not popular . in detail , tbpr - shared averagely obtains relative 2.31% performance improvement compared with bpr - mf in terms of auc metric . furthermore , tbpr - shared compared with bpr - mf , the relative improvement in the _ cold start setting _ is about 1.6 times than that in the _ all setting _ which implies that integrating item reviews more benefits when observed feedback is sparser . as with the results on the phones dataset , revisiting table [ table : datasets ] we can see that the ratio of cold items over all item is 86.8% which is far less than those on other two datasets ( @xmath106 ) . and in this case adding auxiliary information does nt help much . we also evaluate on _ the warm setting _ ( not shown in table [ table : results ] ) , and all of the personalized , complex methods are worse than the user - independent , simple method pop . warm items are more likely to be popular and show less personalized characteristics . it reminds us the commonplace that recommendation plays an important role in long - tailed items . after demonstrating the benefits of leveraging item reviews , we analyse the proposed models from two points ; one is the impact of number of latent factors , and one is the training efficiency and convergence analysis . more depth investigation like the impact of embedding dimensionality and of corpus source to train the embeddings , is left to future work . * impact of the number of latent factors . * the two proposed models tbpr - shared and tbpr - diff have two important hyperparameters ; one is the number of latent factors @xmath107 and one is the number of text factors @xmath108 . for simplicity , we let the two values equal . we vary the number of latent factors @xmath109 to observe the performance results of different methods . the test auc scores are shown in figure [ fig : factors ] . on the girls and boys datasets , both of the personalized models are to perform better as the number of factors increases ; on the other datasets , the performance improves as the number of factors increases to around fifteen ; then it does nt go up and may even downgrade . we set the default value as 15 . also the plots visually show the benefits of integrating item reviews ( tbpr - shared vs. bpr - mf ) and of generating a personalized ranking item list for individual user ( tbpr - shared and bpr - mf vs. pop ) . * training efficiency and convergence analysis . * the complexity of learning is approximately linear in the number of parameters of our proposed models . figure [ fig : iterations ] shows the auc scores of the tbpr - shared model on validation sets with increasing training iterations . in summary , our models take 3 - 4 times more iterations to converge than bpr - mf . on three smaller datasets ( girls , boys , and baby ) , the first five iterations are enough to get a better score than pop ; and on the other larger datasets ( men , women , and phones ) , it takes longer . as a reference , the bpr - mf model usually converges in 50 iterations . as another reference , all of our experiments are completed in about one week using one server that has 65gib memory and 12 cores with frequency 3599mhz . we proposed two models to integrate item reviews into bayesian personalized ranking based on matrix factorization for cold start recommendation . in each of the two models , we make use of text features extracted from item reviews via word embeddings . on top of text features we uncover the review dimensions that explain the variation in users feedback . these review factors represent a prior preference of a user and show the ` text influence of her rated items ' . empirical results on multiple real - world datasets demonstrated the improved ranking performance under the all and cold start setting . and the shared space model is slightly better than the different space one which shows the benefits of considering the interactions between latent factors and text factors . training efficiency is analyzed . since we investigate the benefits of leveraging item reviews , we only compare our models with bpr - mf ( and pop ) ; and to know the effectiveness , comparing with more baselines is needed . the construction strategy of positive / negative samples is also worth further investigating because it deeply affects the modeling design , the learning results , and the evaluation performance . | item recommendation task predicts a personalized ranking over a set of items for individual user . one paradigm is the rating - based methods that concentrate on explicit feedbacks and hence face the difficulties in collecting them . meanwhile , the ranking - based methods are presented with rated items and then rank the rated above the unrated . this paradigm uses widely available implicit feedback but it usually ignores some important information : item reviews . item reviews not only justify the preferences of users , but also help alleviate the cold - start problem that fails the collaborative filtering . in this paper , we propose two novel and simple models to integrate item reviews into matrix factorization based bayesian personalized ranking ( bpr - mf ) . in each model , we make use of text features extracted from item reviews via word embeddings . on top of text features we uncover the review dimensions that explain the variation in users feedback and these review factors represent a prior preference of a user . experiments on real - world data sets show the benefits of leveraging item reviews on ranking prediction . we also conduct analyses to understand the proposed models . |
astro-ph0111282 | it is well established that the diffuse x - ray emission from clusters of galaxies implies the existence of a hot ( 10@xmath1 k ) , thermally radiating intracluster medium ( icm ) . in the dense centers of many clusters this gas is expected to cool radiatively in less than a hubble time . as pressure support decreases the gas will gravitate towards the bottom of the cluster potential well , a phenomenon that has come to be known as a `` cooling flow '' ( cf . fabian 1994 ) . such cooling flows can be detected by direct x - ray imaging , where they are seen as a surface brightness enhancement in the x - ray emission from a region typically @xmath0 100 - 200 kpc in radius , and by spectroscopic observations which reveal gas at cooler temperatures than the surrounding icm . the excess x - ray luminosity in the cooling flow region is typically 10@xmath2 ergs s@xmath3 , corresponding to roughly 10 - 50 % of the total cluster x - ray emission ( peres et al . the mass deposition rate is @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the gas temperature at r@xmath6 , the cooling radius . estimated cooling flow rates in the centers of rich clusters vary from 30 - 300 m@xmath7 yr@xmath3 ( white , jones , & forman 1997 ) and in some cases reach mass deposition rates of 1000 m@xmath7 yr@xmath3 or more ( allen 2000 ) . a long - standing problem with the cooling flow scenario has been the fact that the large quantities of cool gas expected to accumulate from the flow have rarely been detected . searches for cool gas in atomic or molecular form have generally proven unsuccessful ( e.g. , heckman et al . 1989 ; jaffe 1990 ; mcnamara , bregman , & oconnell 1990 ; odea et al . 1994 ; voit & donahue 1995 ; jaffe & bremer 1997 ; donahue et al . 2000 ) , with reported upper limits two orders of magnitude smaller than the masses implied by x - ray mass deposition rates ( although see edge 2001 ) . while some support for the cooling flow picture is provided by low energy x - ray spectra of clusters which appear to require larger absorption than can be accounted for by foreground gas alone ( white et al . 1991 ; allen et al . 1993 ; irwin & sarazin 1995 ) , it now appears that the fraction of clusters that actually possess such excess absorption may be much less than previously thought ( arabadjis & bregman 2000 , hereafter ab2000 ; bhringer et al . furthermore , recent high - resolution x - ray spectra obtained with the xmm - newton and chandra satellites have failed to show expected emission lines from cooled gas at temperatures below a few kev ( fabian et al . 2001 ; peterson et al . 2001 ; tamura et al . 2001 ) and it has also been found that local isothermality matches the spectral data of `` cooling flow '' regions better than the continually declining temperature profile predicted by the standard cooling flow model ( e.g. molendi & pizzolato 2001 ; bhringer et al . a variety of mechanisms have been proposed to account for the lack of detectable cool gas in cooling flows ; these include reheating the gas , mixing , differential absorption , efficient conversion of cooling flow gas into low mass stars , inhomogeneous metallicity distributions , or disruption of cooling flows by recent subcluster mergers ( see recent discussions in fabian et al . 2001 and peterson et al . 2001 ) . as of yet , it is unclear whether any of these mechanisms are capable of resolving the aforementioned problems with the cooling flow model . one characteristic that is common to the mechanisms mentioned above is that they have mainly been introduced in an `` after the fact '' manner . that is , they assume the observed mass deposition rates are basically correct but that something is happening to the gas after ( or while ) it cools , be it reheating or conversion into low mass stars or some other process . perhaps a simpler way of addressing the problems of the cooling flow model are to look for ways to reduce the mass deposition rates from the beginning . one way to achieve this is to reduce the excess emission ( @xmath8 ) associated with cooling flows by attributing some ( or all ) of it to x - ray sources other than thermal bremsstrahlung or line emission from the icm . but are there sources luminous enough to reproduce @xmath8 , can they be found within galaxy clusters , and , most importantly , can they mimic hot cluster gas ? soon after x - ray emission was first detected from galaxy clusters , katz ( 1976 ) proposed that much of this emission might come from individual compact sources such as those known to exist in our own galaxy . however , the subsequent discovery of iron emission lines in x - ray spectra ( forman & jones 1982 , and references therein ) clearly demonstrated that thermal bremsstrahlung from a diffuse intracluster gas is the dominant source of x - ray emission in clusters , and interest in compact sources quickly waned . nevertheless , compact sources must surely contribute some fraction of the total x - ray emission from galaxy clusters . a growing body of evidence indicates that a substantial intergalactic population of stars , star clusters and stellar remnants is present in the cores of rich clusters , and some of these objects will be x - ray sources . for example , ferguson , tanvir , & von hippel ( 1998 ) showed the existence of intergalactic stars in the virgo cluster , and planetary nebulae associated with this population have also been detected ( e.g. , arnaboldi et al . 1996 ; ciardullo et al . 1998 ) . similarly , west et al . ( 1995 ) hypothesized the existence of a large population of intergalactic globular clusters in the cores of galaxy clusters based on observed galaxy - to - galaxy variations in globular cluster populations . furthermore , there is mounting evidence that many cluster galaxies have been destroyed over a hubble time , victims of collisions with other galaxies or disruption by the mean tidal field of the cluster potential in which they reside ( e.g. , thompson & gregory 1993 ; lopez - cruz et al . 1997 ; gregg & west 1998 ; moore et al . 1999 ; calcaneo - rodin et al . 2000 ) . as galaxies are disrupted they will spill their contents throughout intracluster space , including x - ray sources such as x - ray binaries , globular clusters , and black holes . such disruption is likely to be most frequent in the dense cluster core , and hence would be expected to produce a substantial pool of intracluster material , including compact x - ray sources , at the cluster center . any significant contribution by these compact sources to the x - ray flux will have to be taken into account when estimating the properties of icm , including temperatures , densities , and cooling flow mass deposition rates . an intracluster population of compact objects would have a different spectral signature than thermal emission from intracluster gas . for instance , the spectra of large spiral and elliptical galaxies reveal the presence of hard x - ray emission which is thought to be produced by either high mass x - ray binaries or accretion onto massive black holes and is adequately represented by power - laws having @xmath9 @xmath0 0.6 - 3.0 ( where @xmath10 ; colbert & mushotzky 1999 ; allen , di matteo , & fabian 2000 ) . luminous agn , on the other hand , are often fit by power - laws with @xmath9 @xmath0 1.6 - 2.0 ( nandra et al . indeed , the spectral signatures of such objects have already been identified in several x - ray clusters by allen et al . ( 2001 ) . using asca data , these authors found very luminous sources with power - law spectral indices characteristic of compact sources . the recent discovery of luminous _ extended _ non - thermal x - ray emission in several weak ( or non- ) cooling flow clusters ( rephaeli , gruber , & blanco 1999 ; fusco - femiano et al . 1999 ; 2000 ; 2001 ) suggests that one should also look for such emission in massive cooling flow clusters . at present , the origin of the diffuse non - thermal emission is still a matter of some debate . suggested mechanisms include inverse - compton scattering of cmb photons up to x - ray energies via a population of highly relativistic electrons , and non - thermal bremsstrahlung , likewise , by a population of relativistic electrons ( sarazin 2001 ; rephaeli 2001 ) . those highly relativistic electrons may have been accelerated by recent subcluster merger events which shocked the icm or may have been ejected from a central massive black hole . the discovery of x - ray holes at the positions of radio lobes of a central compact object in several massive cooling flow clusters ( e.g. bhringer et al . 1993 , mcnamara et al . 2000 ; fabian et al . 2000 ) certainly lends credence to the second hypothesis . recently , harris et al . ( 2000 ) ( chandra data ) and bhringer et al . ( 2001b ) ( xmm - newton data ) have even identified extended non - thermal emission directly associated with radio jets / lobes in 3c295 and m87 , respectively . the spectral signature of extended non - thermal emission is also different from that of thermal emission . to date , the extended non - thermal components of x - ray spectra of clusters have adequately been modeled by power - laws having @xmath11 ( fusco - femiano et al . 1999 ; 2000 ; 2001 ) . as with luminous compact sources , a proper deduction of cluster properties should explicitly include the effects of extended non - thermal emission in the analysis . in the present work we assess the case for a power - law component to the x - ray spectra of cluster centers , in particular those with cooling flows . we show that simultaneous fits of rosat pspcb and asca gis / sis spectra , which have been used to infer the presence of cooling flows in many clusters to date , are in fact consistent with a significant contribution from compact sources and/or extended non - thermal emission . using rosat hri data , we have placed limits on the contribution of any bright point sources within the central regions of these clusters and conclude that the power - law components are most likely produced by either a collection of many low - luminosity compact sources ( with @xmath12 ergs s@xmath3 ) or by diffuse non - thermal emission or by some combination of the two . we shall assume @xmath13 = 50 km s@xmath3 mpc@xmath3 and @xmath14 throughout . ten well - studied x - ray luminous galaxy clusters ( table 1 ) were chosen to span a wide range of cooling flow mass deposition rates . five of these have essentially no cooling flow ( ncf ) , while the other five cooling flow ( cf ) clusters have calculated mass deposition rates ranging from 189 to 645 solar masses per year . observations by the rosat position sensitive proportional counter ( pspcb ) and high resolution imager ( hri ) and the asca gas imaging spectrometer ( gis ) and solid - state imaging spectrometer ( sis ) were obtained from the heasarc public archives and reduced using ftools v5.01 . the combination of rosat and asca data provides good sensitivity to both soft and hard x - ray emission , spanning the total energy range 0.14 - 10.0 kev , and should provide a strong test of power - law components in the x - ray spectra of clusters . the rosat pspcb data were corrected for spatial and temporal gain fluctuations in the detector . x - ray spectra , spanning the energy range 0.14 - 2.04 kev , of all ten clusters were extracted from circular regions centered on the peak of the emission with a constant extraction radius ( r ) of 3 arcminutes . background spectra were selected from source - free circular regions of radius r. all spectra were corrected for the effects of cosmic rays in the detector ( snowden et al . 1992 ) , vignetting , spatial variations in detector efficiency , and deadtime . the background - subtracted spectra were then grouped to ensure a minimum of 20 counts per radial bin so that reliable @xmath15 statistics could be computed . the rosat hri data was reduced in a manner similar to the pspcb data . the hri data was used to place limits on the contribution of any point sources within the central regions of these clusters . unfortunately , the hri lacks spectral resolution and was not used in the main spectral analysis . a description of the analysis of hri data is given in section 5 . no hri data were available for a2063 or a3532 . the screened events from `` revision 2 '' processing of asca gis / sis data were used . additional cleaning procedures ( discussed in the asca abc guide ) were implemented , including gain and deadtime corrections . for the gis detectors ( gis2 and gis3 ) , x - ray spectra spanning the energy range 0.7 - 10.0 kev were extracted from the same region of sky as that of the rosat pspcb source spectra . for the sis detectors ( sis0 and sis1 ) , x - ray spectra spanning the range 2.0 - 10.0 kev were extracted , thus avoiding complications with the degrading efficiency of the sis detectors at low energies . background spectra for both the sis and gis detectors were extracted from the `` blank sky '' observations made during the performance testing stage of the mission . spectra were extracted from the same regions of the detectors as that of the source spectra ( thus minimizing position - dependent effects associated with background subtraction ) . the background - subtracted spectra were also grouped ( or binned ) to ensure @xmath15 statistics could be used . for the clusters a2142 and a3667 sis1 data were ignored because of an excess of hot and flickering pixels . reduced rosat pspcb and asca gis / sis spectra were fit simultaneously using models within the software package xspec v11 ( arnaud 1996 ) . each cluster was fit with a variety of models based on mekal thermal plasma routine ( mewe & gronenschild 1985 ; kaastra 1992 ; liedahl et al . 1995 ) , and/or redshifted power - laws . in addition , we used the popular cooling flow model comprising a thermal plasma ( mekal ) and cooling flow component implemented by the mkcflow routine within xspec ( mushotzky & szymkowiak 1988 ) . fits were obtained by varying the temperature ( @xmath16 ) and metallicity ( @xmath17 ) of thermal plasma component(s ) and by varying the photon index ( @xmath9 ) of any power - law components . photoelectric absorption ( balucinska - church & mccammon 1992 ) was applied to the spectral models through two separate methods : i ) by applying only one absorption component to the entire spectral model and fixing the hi column density ( @xmath18 ) at the known galactic value ( see table 1 ) and then letting it vary to see if the fit could be improved ; ii ) by applying one absorption component to the entire spectral model ( with @xmath18 fixed at the galactic value ) and a separate redshifted variable absorption component ( @xmath19 ) to any power - law components via the zphabs model in xspec . the second method allows for _ intrinsic _ absorption to be associated with any power - law components . spectra of nearby high mass x - ray binaries and accreting massive black holes provide strong evidence for heavy intrinsic absorption , with @xmath20 @xmath21 above the galactic column ( colbert & mushotzky 1999 ; iwasawa et al . 2000 ; akylas et al . 2001 ) . we therefore regard the addition of a free intrinsic absorption parameter as an important feature of our spectral analysis . henceforth we will use tp , pl , and cf to refer , respectively , to thermal plasma ( mekal ) , power - law , and mkcflow components . for example , in this notation tppl identifies a model having thermal plasma and power - law components . goodness of fit was judged by the reduced chi - square ( @xmath22 ) and by visual inspection of residual plots . when additional components were added to a spectral model , for example adding a power - law component to a thermal plasma component to make tppl , the corresponding f - statistic was calculated in order to judge whether the addition was reasonable . unless stated otherwise , the derived relative contributions of each of the components to the total flux refer to the energy range 0.14 - 10.0 kev stated , whereas the luminosities presented refer to the asca gis band only ( 0.7 - 10.0 kev ) , since the spectra were fit simultaneously and not combined . all luminosities presented were corrected for galactic absorption only . to check our data reduction procedures , spectra from each of the detectors were also fit individually and no significant deviations were found . we have also attempted to duplicate published results by arabadjis & bregman ( 2000 ) for three clusters derived using the same data ( rosat pspcb ) and the same software . the results , which refer to the inner 3 arcminute radius , are presented in table 2 . here , the hotter tp component is fixed at the white , jones , & forman ( 1997 ) value , @xmath23 , @xmath18 is fixed at the stark et al . ( 1992 ) value , and the energy range is 0.14 - 2.4 kev and 0.14 - 2.04 kev for ab2000 and our study , respectively . the comparison shows excellent agreement , with derived temperatures and mass deposition rates having the same values to within one standard deviation . we find that single - temperature tp models provide acceptable fits to the spectra of a119 , a2063 , a3266 , a3532 , and a3667 ( 1.00 @xmath24 @xmath22 @xmath24 1.17 ) with temperatures in very good agreement with previous studies ( white , jones , & forman 1997 ; markevitch et al . significant improvement is not usually obtained by varying the hydrogen column density from the known galactic value reported by dickey & lockman ( 1990 ) or stark et al . the derived metallicities range from @xmath25 which is typical of the intracluster medium ( allen & fabian 1997 ) . in general , both pure pl models with or without variable intrinsic absorption do not provide acceptable fits to the ncf cluster spectra with @xmath26 @xmath27 1.4 . this result is not unexpected since it leaves no room for thermal emission from the icm . with intrinsic absorption included , an acceptable fit is obtained for a3532 with @xmath28 , however . this cluster is located at the center of the shapley concentration and is thought to be undergoing a merger with a3528 . the diffuse non - thermal emission generated from such a merger might possibly account for the ability of the simple pl model to fit the spectrum of a3532 . unfortunately , no hri data exists for this cluster so we can not place limits on the contribution of any point sources within the central 3 arcminutes . 0.1 in 0.1 in in the best fitting tppl models , the pl component typically contributes 1 - 14% ( mean of 7 % ) when absorbed by the galactic column only or 10 - 25 % ( mean of 20 % ) when intrinsic absorption is included ( excluding a3532 which has an anomalously large pl component ) . we note that in virtually every case the inclusion of intrinsic absorption noticeably improves the quality of the fit , making it superior to even the simple tp models ( see table 3 ) . a mean f - statistic of @xmath29 ( @xmath27 95 % confidence ) was found when the pl component with intrinsic absorption was included in the fit indicating that its addition is , indeed , reasonable . the corresponding luminosities of intrinsically absorbed pl components range from @xmath30 erg s@xmath3 with a mean value of @xmath31 erg s@xmath3 ( corrected for galactic absorption only ) . photon indices for these components are typical of compact accretion - driven x - ray sources and extended non - thermal emission . interestingly enough , the amount intrinsic absorption ranges from @xmath32 @xmath21 which is typical of optically thick compact sources . we also note that the temperature of the icm tends to decrease significantly when a power - law component is included . this trend was previously reported by allen et al . ( 2001 ) when including a power - law component in their spectral models . figure 1 presents the best fit tppl model to the spectrum of a3667 . for clarity , only the rosat pspcb data are plotted . as expected , standard cooling flow ( tpcf ) models of our non - cooling flow sample yield best fits with @xmath33 = 0 m@xmath7 yr@xmath3 to within one sigma . the mass deposition rate for the modest cooling flow cluster a2063 , however , is 25 @xmath34 12 m@xmath7 yr@xmath3 . the cooler component in our tptp models typically contributes zero flux to within one sigma ( @xmath0 10 % for a2063 & a3667 ) . neither of these models provided fits significantly better than those of the standard tp models . in summary , we confirm earlier investigations which find that tp models provide satisfactory fits to rosat and asca spectra of the centers of non - cooling flow clusters . however , tppl models which include intrinsic absorption generally provide fits of superior quality , and predict that the power - law component contributes 20 percent of the total flux . the photon indices of this component are typical of accreting x - ray sources and/or diffuse non - thermal x - ray emission which usually range from @xmath35 . we have fit the spectra of the cf clusters with the same variety of models used in the previous section , but also with an additional model ; tptppl . this model represents the emission from the observed region as the sum of the hot icm , a diminished cooling flow ( second tp component ) , and intermixed compact sources and/or extended non - thermal emission characterized by the pl component . simple tp models generally provide fairly reasonable fits to the spectra with 1.1 @xmath36 @xmath22 @xmath36 1.25 . derived temperatures and metallicities are in good agreement with previous studies ( white , jones , & forman 1997 , allen & fabian 1997 ; sarazin & mcnamara 1997 ; markevitch et al . 1998 ; allen 2000 ; ab2000 , allen et al . 2001 ) . none of the fits were significantly improved by letting the value of @xmath18 vary . hence , we find no evidence for excess absorption in these clusters , which is also consistent with several other investigations ( sarazin 1996 ; allen & fabian 1997 ; sarazin & mcnamara 1997 ; allen 2000 ; ab2000 ) . as anticipated , pure pl models ( with or without intrinsic absorption ) do not provide acceptable fits to the x - ray spectra of any of the cf clusters . typically , @xmath26 @xmath27 1.5 for this model . our tppl models fit the spectra of all 5 cf clusters very well , with 1.0 @xmath36 @xmath22 @xmath36 1.2 ( see table 4 ) . with the exception of a2029 , which is best fit by simple tp models , the pl component typically contributes 5 - 30 % ( mean of 20 % ) of the total flux when absorbed only by the galactic column . the inclusion of intrinsic absorption significantly improves the quality of the fit and raises the contribution of the pl component to 9 - 47 % ( mean of 27 % ) . the mean f - statistic value for the addition of this power - law component is @xmath37 which suggests it is significant ( @xmath38 99 % confidence ) . the luminosity ( 0.7 - 10.0 kev ) of pl components in these four clusters span @xmath39 ergs s@xmath3 , with a mean value of @xmath40 ergs s@xmath3 . the photon indices of pl components are reasonably well constrained and range from 1.0 @xmath41 2.4 ( mean of 1.8 ) ( see table 4 ) . the implied intrinsic column densities acting on the pl component are rather high for three of the cf clusters ( a644 , a1689 , & a2597 ) and are consistent with high - mass compact sources . as with the ncf clusters , a lower temperature is found for the thermal component than is found from the simple tp models . tptp models were also implemented . the quality of the fits provided by these models is generally comparable to that of tppl models . calculation of the f - statistic suggests that the addition of the extra tp component is significant . thus , we confirm previous reports that multi - phase thermal plasmas fit the spectra of cf clusters much better than that of isothermal models . the temperatures and metallicites of the two thermal components are consistent with the results of previous studies ( white , jones , & forman 1997 , markevitch et al . 1998 ; allen 2000 ; ab2000 ; allen et al . 2001 ) . for the cooler component in particular , we find @xmath42 and a mean contribution of roughly 22 % of the total flux , which is typical of cooling flow clusters ( peres et al . 1998 ) . the standard cooling flow model ( tpcf ) provides adequate fits to the spectra of the cf clusters , as expected . derived mass deposition rates , temperatures , and metallicities are generally consistent with previous studies ( white , jones , & forman 1997 ; peres et al . 1998 ; allen et al . 1999 ; allen 2000 ; ab2000 ) . the best fitting tpcf model to the spectrum of a644 is presented in figure 2 . only the asca sis0 and gis2 data are plotted . a comparison of the tpcf and tppl models is presented in table 4 . it is clear that the tppl models fit the spectra of the 5 cf clusters just as well as standard tpcf models and without any additional complexity . 0.1 in 0.1 in finally , the tptppl model also fits the x - ray spectra of these clusters well , with 1.0 @xmath36 @xmath22 @xmath36 1.2 . when absorbed by the galactic column only , the pl component typically contributes 2 - 5 % of the total flux inside 3 arcminutes . the addition of intrinsic absorption on the pl component , again , improves the fit and the mean contribution of the pl component is raised to @xmath43 32 % . when compared to the tppl model , the mean f - statistic value is about 5 ( @xmath43 68 % confidence ) which suggests the addition of a second tp component only improves the fit marginally . the luminosity ( 0.7 - 10.0 kev ) of the pl component ranges from @xmath44 ergs s@xmath3 with a mean value of @xmath45 ergs s@xmath3 . the power - law components have photon indices of 1.8 @xmath41 3.3 with a mean of 2.3 . with the exception of a2029 ( which has virtually no contribution from the pl component ) , the intrinsic column densities on the pl component are @xmath46 @xmath21 . the temperature of the cooler tp component did not change significantly from the value derived from tptp models . however , it s contribution to the flux was generally lower than that of tptp models ( mean @xmath0 10 % ) . in summary , we find that in all cases the tppl and tptppl models fit the rosat and asca spectra of the five cf clusters just as well as the standard cooling flow model ( tpcf ) or the two - temperature thermal plasma ( tptp ) . the pl components of these models are quite luminous ( contributing between 27 - 32 % of the total flux ) and characterized by photon indices typical of compact accreting x - ray sources and/or extended non - thermal emission . this , then , is the main conclusion of our work : _ rosat and asca spectra can be satisfactorily modeled by attributing a significant part of the luminosity within the central regions of cf clusters to sources other than cooling gas . _ our analysis shows that luminous ( l@xmath47 @xmath0 10@xmath48 ergs s@xmath3 ) power - law components with @xmath49 might be present in the centers of rich clusters . including intrinsic absorption dramatically improves the quality of the fit ; in these circumstances , there is an apparent dichotomy in the importance of the pl components between ncf and cf clusters . not only is the typical pl component in the cf cluster more luminous by about a factor of 10 than that of its ncf counterpart , but it also contributes a larger fraction of the total x - ray flux within the central 3 arcminutes of its cluster ( between 27 - 32 % for cf clusters as opposed to 20 % for ncf clusters ) . this may be consistent with the fact that the _ cores _ of cf clusters are more often observed to be active ( i.e. radio loud ) , perhaps implying the presence of a central massive black hole(s ) and a surrounding diffuse plasma of relativistic electrons , than the cores of ncf clusters ( burns 1990 ) . it is also worth noting that the improvement of the fit to the spectra of cf clusters far exceeds the improvement of the fit to the spectra of ncf clusters when a power - law component is included in the spectral model . the most attractive feature of the tppl models is that one does not expect large quantities of atomic or molecular gas to be present in the centers of clusters , nor does one expect to see emission lines below a few kev , because cooling is not significant . this is consistent with current observations . on the other hand , evidence which apparently supports the existence of cooling flows ( e.g. excess absorption , detection of co line emission in extreme cf clusters ) may contradict this model . however , the success of the single - temperature plasma + power - law model in fitting the spectra of the central regions of rich clusters , regardless of cooling flow status , has also been reported by a number of authors using a variety of x - ray instruments , including markevitch & vikhlinin ( 1997 ) ( asca and rosat data ) , markevitch et al . ( 1998 ) ( asca data ) , rephaeli , gruber & blanco ( 1999 ) ( rxte data ) , guainazzi & molendi ( 1999 ) ( beppo - sax data ) , fusco - femiano et al . ( 1999 ; 2000 ; 2001 ) ( beppo - sax data ) , and recently by sambruna et al . ( 2000 ) who used chandra to uncover a previously _ hidden _ agn in hydra a with @xmath50 ergs s@xmath3 and @xmath51 . however , our study is the first that systematically addresses the problems of the standard cooling flow model by implementing the single - temperature plasma + power - law model . the tptppl models , which might represent a compromise between the standard cooling flow model and our favoured tppl models , also provide good fits to the spectra of the cf clusters . however , the addition of the second , cooler tp component only marginally improves the fit and at the expense of adding much more complexity ( and uncertainty ) to the model . furthermore , the predicted temperatures and relative contributions of the cooler tp component in the tptppl models suggest that emission lines below a few kev should be present , however they have failed to turn up in chandra and xmm spectra . finally , because the mean contribution of the cooler component is @xmath0 10 % , as compared with 20 % in the tptp models , this implies that mass deposition rates are only roughly reduced by a factor of two . using models similar to our tptppl models , allen et al . ( 2001 ) reached the same conclusion for a number of clusters in their sample . these reduced deposition rates are still far too large to be consistent with the small amounts of atomic and molecular gas found in cooling flow clusters . we expect that chandra and xmm - newton will place much tighter constraints on the parameters of the complex tptppl models and it will be interesting to see if the models can be reconciled with problems of the standard cooling flow model . assuming that a power - law component is , indeed , present in the spectra of these clusters , some of the possible candidates are : * seyfert - like agn could contribute most , if not all , of the pl component luminosity found in our study . these objects can be quite luminous and are often observed to have @xmath52 @xmath53 ergs s@xmath3 with power - law indices of 1.6 - 2.0 ( nandra et al . 1997 ) . in fact , allen et al . 2001 have suggested that agn are the likely candidate for the observed pl component in their sample . likewise , the luminosities and steepness of the pl components in our sample are generally consistent with emission from a central agn(s ) . * diffuse non - thermal emission , which has possibly been seen in the central regions of coma , a2256 , and a2199 . searches of those clusters using beppo - sax and rxte have yielded very luminous ( @xmath43 10@xmath48 ergs s@xmath3 ) sources which are described by power - laws with @xmath54 and may possibly be linked to power - law components observed in the asca band ( rephaeli , gruber , & blanco 1999 ; fusco - femiano et al . 1999 ; 2000 ; 2001 ) . unfortunately , x - ray spectra usually have to be extracted from regions _ much _ larger than that of the central galaxy and , thus , it is difficult to draw conclusions about the source of the power - law component . a vla survey of more than 200 nearby clusters found that only 29 had extended radio emission on mpc scales ( giovannini , tordi , & feretti 1999 ) perhaps implying that extended non - thermal emission is not that common in galaxy clusters . it should be noted , however , that the detection of true intracluster radio emission is exceptionally difficult , as one must remove bright radio galaxies from the analysis ( rephaeli 2001 ) . furthermore , the non - thermal emission may be associated with the radio galaxies themselves ( e.g. in the radio lobes ) . * massive black holes associated with elliptical and lenticular galaxies . the regions sampled in our study generally include a single giant elliptical or cd galaxy plus a number of large galaxies , probably e or s0 galaxies . colbert & mushotzky ( 1999 ) and allen , di matteo , & fabian ( 2000 ) have recently discovered hard power - law components in several nearby ge galaxies with @xmath55 ergs s@xmath3 with photon indices of 0.5 - 3.0 . such sources are typically less luminous than seyfert nuclei , perhaps as a result of low radiative efficiency from an advection - dominated accretion flow ( adaf ; narayan & yi ) . while several of these sources could , in principle , account for the pl component in the ncf clusters they would have to be scaled up by a factor of 100 to account for the emission in the cf clusters . faint galaxies , on the other hand , are much more numerous and many of them might harbor less massive central black holes . the local group elliptical m32 , whose central object has @xmath56 erg s@xmath3 ( loewenstein et al . 1998 ) offers a possible guide to the x - ray luminosity of faint cluster members . hence @xmath57 such galaxies , each with a supermassive black hole , would be required to account for the power - law component of the clusters studied here . on this basis , faint galaxies seem incapable of producing significant power - law emission inside the regions we have observed . we note , however , that if massive black holes originally belonging to bright or faint galaxies are now scattered throughout intracluster space ( i.e. no longer associated with optically visible galaxies ) as the result of past mergers or stripping both of these limits may be relaxed . * galactic x - ray binaries , having @xmath58 ( white et al . 1988 , verbunt et al . 1995 ) , and which in our galaxy are most commonly associated with globular clusters . intergalactic globular clusters , if similar to globular clusters in the milky way , would have to be present in large numbers to collectively account for @xmath59 erg s@xmath3 attributable to the pl component in our models . assuming a typical intergalactic globular contains a binary x - ray source with @xmath60 @xmath61 ergs s@xmath3 ( hertz & wood 1985 ) and the specific frequency of globulars in the central ge galaxy is @xmath62 ( harris 1991 ) then even a very bright central galaxy with m@xmath63 = -24 would have a total x - ray luminosity of @xmath64 ergs s@xmath3 , too low by a factor of @xmath65 . even the most optimistic models of intracluster globular clusters of west et al . ( 1995 ) predict @xmath66 such clusters , significantly less than is required to account for the entire pl component . hence , it appears that there are probably two or three sources capable of producing the luminosity of the pl components of our models : massive black holes associated ( or once associated ) with large elliptical galaxies , diffuse non - thermal emission , and agn . does existing data favor one type of source over the others ? to determine the luminosity of any point sources within the central 3 arcminutes we used rosat hri data . two different procedures were implemented : i ) spectra of clearly visible point sources were extracted from a 5 region centered on the source and grouped into one large energy bin ( 0.5 - 2.0 kev ) . the spectra were then fit within the xspec package using a simple power - law model with @xmath67 and absorbed by the galactic column only . the 0.5 - 2.0 kev flux was then converted into a 0.7 - 10.0 kev unabsorbed flux using the program w3pimms . if more than one point source was present the individual fluxes were summed . as an example , figure 3 is the hri observation of a3667 , smoothed with a 5 gaussian beam . there are at least two bright compact sources within the central 3 arcminutes of this cluster . ; ii ) to place limits on the contribution of point sources which are hidden in the bright diffuse background ( what we refer to as `` barely visible '' point sources ) we calculated the mean standard deviation of counts per pixel ( within 3 ) and then scaled this to a standard deviation per circular region of diameter = 5 ( comparable to the hri psf ) . the latter value was expressed as unabsorbed flux ( 0.7 - 10.0 kev ) using the program w3pimms and assuming a simple power - law spectral model with @xmath67 absorbed only by the galactic column listed in table 1 . we regard the result as a 1-sigma limit to the contribution of any point sources . 0.1 in 0.1 in the results of hri data analysis are presented in table 5 . one or more point sources are easily visible within the central 3 arcminutes of all three ncf clusters having hri observations . it is clear from a comparison with the luminosities of the observed pl component from the best fitting tppl models ( with intrinsic absorption ) , however , that the bright point sources can not be solely responsible for the power - law emission , as they contribute only @xmath43 5 % of the pl component luminosity . significant contributions are required from low - luminosity point sources and/or diffuse non - thermal emission . the third column in table 5 ( method ii ) presents the 3-sigma limit of `` barely visible '' point sources , suggesting that at least @xmath68 of them are needed ( in addition to the visible point sources ) to account for the entire power - law component . there are no visible point sources within the central 3 of the 5 cf clusters studied . this is almost certainly the result of the cf clusters being much more centrally peaked than the ncf clusters . at least @xmath68 `` barely visible '' point sources are required to account for the observed pl component in these clusters . perhaps another way to differentiate between compact sources and diffuse non - thermal emission is through the presence or absence of flux variability , since most luminous accreting x - ray sources are known to vary significantly on short time scales ( e.g. nandra et al . 1997 ) . however , because the pl component typically contributes only @xmath69 % this might make detection of variability difficult in clusters ( especially in the cf clusters ) . furthermore , if the pl component is produced by @xmath68 point sources , and the variations in each are random , it will make the variation in the collective luminosity quite small , perhaps rendering this method unusable . if compact or diffuse non - thermal sources provide significant emission from the centers of rich clusters , it will be necessary to revise a number of conclusions derived from x - ray data . fully exploring the consequences is beyond the scope of the present paper ; however , we will mention a few important issues . allen ( 2000 ) reports that a deprojection analysis of rosat hri data yields cooling flow mass deposition rates that agree reasonably well with those derived from asca spectra . a consistent re - analysis would require first subtracting the power - law contribution from the x - ray images , but of course the spatial distribution of the power - law emission must first be understood . the presence of emission lines from heavy ions originally led astronomers to accept thermal emission as the dominant mechanism in rich cluster icms . accretion - driven x - ray sources do exhibit line emission ( kallman , vrtilek , & kahn 1989 ; narayan & raymond 1999 ) , but the lines are produced under quite different physical conditions than those within the canonical hot icm . the implications for icm abundance estimates and enrichment scenarios will require careful study . likewise , previously derived temperatures of the icm will also be affected ( as demonstrated in table 3 ) . might emission from compact sources account for the excess hard x - radiation recently discovered ( xu et al . 1998 ; ikebe et al . 1997 ) in the centers of several clusters ? the next generation of x - ray detectors and satellites ( i.e. xmm and chandra ) will be needed to map the x - ray emission with adequate spatial resolution to address this and other questions raised by the present work . we have shown that rosat pspcb and asca gis2/gis3 spectra of ten x - ray luminous clusters permit a significant contribution from compact sources and/or diffuse non - thermal emission . although this conclusion holds irrespective of the presence of a cooling flow , we find that power - law components are especially luminous in clusters with massive cooling flows . our study indicates that inferred cooling flow mass deposition rates may be lowered substantially , thus ameliorating , or possibly resolving , the long - standing problem of the missing cool gas . existing x - ray observations of large elliptical galaxies , agn , and extended non - thermal emission suggest that any of these sources could account for the observed luminosity of the power - law component . however , the absence of extremely bright point sources in the rosat hri observations rules out the possibility that the power - law emission comes from a few extremely bright compact sources . more likely is that most of the power - law emission is produced by some combination of diffuse and low - luminosity compact sources , such as massive black holes . the deep imaging capabilities and superior spectral resolution of chandra and xmm should be able to place much tighter constraints on the relative contributions of power - law sources and thermal bremsstrahlung to cluster x - ray emission and , perhaps , even determine the source of the power - law emission . we thank the rosat and asca help teams , in particular jane turner , for advice with data reduction techniques . we also thank paul nandra , peter thomas , arif babul , ann gower , pat henry , and alastair edge for useful comments and suggestions . igm acknowledges support from nserc of canada ( usra & pgsa ) . gaw and mjw were supported by nserc research grants . mjw also acknowledges support from nsf grant ast-0071149 . akylas , a. , georgantopoulos , i. , & comastri , a. , 2001 , mnras , 324 , 521 allen , s.w . , 2000 , mnras , 315 , 269 allen , s.w . , di matteo , t. , & fabian , a.c . 2000 , mnras , 311 , 493 allen , s.w . , et al . , 1993 , mnras , 262 , 901 allen , s.w . , et al . , 2001 , mnras , 322 , 589 allen , s.w . , & fabian , a.c . , 1997 , mnras , 286 , 583 arabadjis , j.s . , & bregman , j.n . , 2000 , apj , 536 , 144 ( ab2000 ) arnaboldi , m. , et al . , 1996 , apj , 472 , 145 arnaud , k.a . , 1996 , in asp conf . ser . 101 , astronomical data analysis software and systems v , ed . jacoby , g. , & barnes , j. , ( san francisco : asp ) , 17 balucinska - church , m. , & mccammon , d. , 1992 , apj , 400 , 699 bardelli , s. , zucca , e. , & baldi , a. , 2001 , mnras , 320 , 387 bauer , f. , & sarazin , c.l . , 2000 , apj , 530 , 222 bazzano , a. , et al . , 1984 , apj , 279 , 515 bhringer , h. , et al . , 1993 , mnras , 264 , l25 bhringer , h. , et al . , 2001a , a&a , in press ( astro - ph/0111112 ) bhringer , h. , et al . , 2001b , a&a , 365 , l181 burns , j.0 . , 1990 , aj , 99 , 14 calcneo roldn , c. , et al . , 2000 , mnras , 314 , 324 ciardullo , r. , et al . , 1998 , aj , 118 , 488 colbert , e.j.m . , & mushotzky , r.f . , 1999 , apj , 519 , 89 dickey , j.m & lockman , f.j . 1990 , ara&a , 28 , 215 donahue , et al . , 2000 , apj , 545 , 670 edge , a.c . , 2001 , mnras , in press ( astro - ph/0106225 ) fabian , a.c . , 1994 , ara&a , 32 , 277 fabian , a.c . , et al mnras , 318 , 65 fabian , a.c . , mushotzky , r.f . , nulsen , p.e.j . , & peterson , j.r . , 2001 , mnras , 321 , l33 feretti , l. , et al . , 1999 , a&a , 344 , 472 ferguson , h.c . , tanvir , n.r . , & von hippel , t. , 1998 , nature , 391 , 461 flores , r.a . , quintana , h. , & way , m.j . , 2000 , apj , 532 , 206 forman , w. , & jones , c. , 1982 , ara&a , 20 , 547 fusco - femiano , r. , et al . , 1999 , apj , 513 , l21 fusco - femiano , r. , et al . , 2000 , apj , 534 , l7 fusco - femiano , r. , et al . , 2001 , apj , 552 , l97 gregg , m.d . , & west , m.j . , 1998 , nature , 396 , 549 giovannini g. , tordi , m. , & feretti , l. , 1999 , new ast . , 4 , 141 guainazzi , m. , & molendi , s. , 1999 , a&a , 351 , l19 harris , w. e. , 1991 , ara&a , 29 , 543 harris , d.e . et al . , 2000 , apj , 530 , l81 heckman , t.m . , baum , s.a . , van breugel , w.j.m . , & mccarthy , p.j . , 1989 , apj , 338 , 48 hertz , p. , & wood , k.s . , 1985 , apj , 290 , 171 ikebe , y. , et al . , 1997 , apj , 481 , 660 irwin , j.a . , & sarazin , c.l . , 1995 , apj , 455 , 497 iwasawa , k. , et al . , 2000 , mnras , 318 , 879 jaffe , w. , 1990 , a&a , 240 , 254 jaffe , w. , & bremer , m.n . , 1997 , mnras , 284 , l1 kaastra , j.s . , 1992 , an x - ray spectral code for optically thin plasmas ( internal sron - leiden report , updated version 2.0 ) kallman , t.r . , vrtilek , s.d . , & kahn , s.m . , 1989 , apj , 345 , 498 katz , j.i . , 1976 , apj , 207 , 25 liedahl , d.a . , osterheld , a.l . , & goldstein , w.h . , 1995 , apjl , 438 , 115 loewenstein , m. , hayashida , k. , toneri , t. , & davis , d.s . , 1998 , apj , 497 , 681 lopez - cruz , o. , et al . , 1997 , apj , 475 , l97 markevitch , m. , forman , w.r . , sarazin , c.l . , & vikhlinin , a. , 1998 , apj , 503 , 77 markevitch , m. , et al . , 2000 , apj , 541 , 542 markevitch , m. & vikhlinin , a. , 1997 , apj , 491 , 467 mcnamara , b.r . , bregman , j.n . , & oconnell , r.w . , 1990 , apj , 360 , 20 mcnamara , b.r . , et al . , 2000 , apj , 534 , l135 mewe , r. , gronenschild , e.h.b.m . , & van den oord , g.h.j . , 1985 , a&as , 62 , 197 molendi , s. , & de grandi , s. 1999 , a&a , 351 , l41 molendi , s. , & pizzolato , f. , 2001 , apj , in press ( astro - ph/0106552 ) moore , b. , lake , g. , quinn , t. , & stadel , j. , 1999 , mnras , 304 , 465 mushotzky , r.f . , & szymkowiak , a.e . , 1988 , in cooling flows in clusters and galaxies , ed . fabian , ( dordrecht : kluwer ) , 53 nandra , k. , et al . , apj , 477 , 602 narayan , r. , & raymond , j. , 1999 , apj , 515 , l69 narayan , r. , & yi , i. , 1995 , apj , 452 , 710 odea , c.p . , et al . , 1994 , apj , 422 , 467 oegerle , w.r . , & hill , j.m . , 1994 , aj , 107 , 857 peres , c.b . , et al . , 1998 , mnras , 298 , 416 peterson , j.r . , et al . , 2001 , a&a , 365 , l104 rephaeli , y. 2001 , astro - ph/0101363 rephaeli , y. , gruber , d.e . , & blanco , p. , 1999 , 511 , l21 sarazin , c.l . , 1996 , in galactic and cluster cooling flows , ed . n. soker , ( san francisco : publ . pacific ) , 115 , 172 sarazin , c.l . , 2001 , in merging processes in clusters of galaxies , ed . l. feretti , m. gioia , and g. giovannini ( dordrecht : kluwer ) , in press ( astro - ph/0105418 ) sambruna , r.m . , et al . , 2000 , apj , 532 , 91 . sarazin , c. l. , burns , j.o . , roettiger , k. , & mcnamara , b.r . , 1995 , apj , 447 , 559 . sarazin , c.l . , & mcnamara , b.r . , 1997 , apj , 480 , 203 snowden , s.l . , et al . , 1992 , apj , 393 , 819 stark , a.a . , et al . , 1992 , apjs , 79 , 77 tamura , t. , et al . , 2001 , a&a , 365 , l86 thompson , l.a . , & gregory , s.a . , 1993 , aj , 106 2197 verbunt , f. , bunk , w. , hasinger , g. , johnston , h.m . , 1995 , a&a , 300 , 732 voit , g.m . & donahue , m. , 1995 , apj , 452 , 164 west , m. , ct , p. , jones , c. , forman , w. , & marzke , r. , 1995 , apj , 453 , l77 white , d.a . , et al . , 1991 , mnras , 252 , 72 white , d.a . , jones , c. , & forman , w. , 1997 , mnras , 292 , 419 white , n.e . , stella , l. , & parmar , a.n . , 1988 , apj , 324 , 363 xu , h. , et al . , 1998 , apj , 500 , 738 ccccccll a119 & 0.0442 & 3.17 & ncf & 0 & 5.3 & 3 bright radio galaxies near center@xmath70 + a644 & 0.0704 & 8.00@xmath71 & cf & 189 & 6.5 & minor merger event@xmath72 + a1689 & 0.1832 & 1.81 & cf & 645 & 8.7 & + a2029 & 0.0773 & 3.14 & cf & 556 & 7.4 & non - thermal emission not detected@xmath73 + a2063 & 0.0353 & 2.90@xmath71 & ncf & 37 & 4.1 & subcluster merger?@xmath74 + a2142 & 0.0909 & 4.16 & cf & 350 & 11.4 & merger@xmath75 & hard x - ray emission detected@xmath76 + a2597 & 0.0852 & 2.49 & cf & 271 & 9.1 & powerful cd radio galaxy@xmath77 + a3266 & 0.0589 & 3.00@xmath71 & ncf & 0 & 6.2 & major merger@xmath78 + a3532 & 0.0554 & 5.98 & ncf & 0 & 4.7 & merger@xmath79 + a3667 & 0.0556 & 4.00@xmath71 & ncf & 0 & 7.1 & hard x - ray emission found@xmath80 + a119 & tp & - & - & 0.987 & & - & - & 1.011 + & tpcf & 0.08 @xmath34 @xmath81 & 0 @xmath34 3 & 0.994 & & 0.01 @xmath34 151 & 0.6 @xmath34 5 & 1.026 + a2029 & tptp & 1.29 @xmath34 0.15 & - & 1.592 & & 1.19 @xmath34 0.31 & - & 1.499 + & tpcf & 0.08 @xmath34 6.97 & 132 @xmath34 31 & 1.911 & & 0.03 @xmath34 4.82 & 170 @xmath34 43 & 1.772 + a2142 & tpcf & 0.08 @xmath34 7.41 & 188 @xmath34 43 & 1.190 & & 0.10 @xmath34 9.16 & 230 @xmath34 73 & 1.130 + a119 & tp & @xmath82 & & & & 467.4/446 + & tppl & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & 25 % & @xmath85 & 454.0/443 + a2063 & tp & @xmath86 & & & & 945.6/807 + & tppl & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & 8.5 % & @xmath89 & 933.3/804 + a3266 & tp & @xmath90 & & & & 1160.5/1117 + & tppl & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & 23 % & @xmath93 & 1158.0/1114 + a3532 & tp & @xmath94 & & & & 776.4/746 + & tppl & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & 87.5 % & @xmath97 & 756.0/743 + a3667 & tp & @xmath98 & & & & 809.0/791 + & tppl & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & 22 % & @xmath101 & 797.6/788 + a644 & tppl & & @xmath102 & 35 % & @xmath103 & 1855.7/1613 + & tpcf & @xmath104 & & & & 1841.2/1613 + a1689 & tppl & & @xmath105 & 9 % & @xmath106 & 1643.6/1409 + & tpcf & @xmath107 & & & & 1653.9/1409 + a2029 & tppl & & @xmath108 & 5 % & @xmath109 & 1460.3/1149 + & tpcf & @xmath110 & & & & 1462.1/1149 + a2142 & tppl & & @xmath111 & 47 % & @xmath112 & 1010.4/868 + & tpcf & @xmath113 & & & & 1013.2/868 + a2597 & tppl & & @xmath114 & 17 % & @xmath115 & 1305.1/1281 + & tpcf & @xmath116 & & & & 1302.3/1281 + a119 & @xmath117 & @xmath118 & @xmath119 + a644 & & @xmath120 & @xmath121 + a1689 & & @xmath122 & @xmath123 + a2029 & & @xmath124 & @xmath125 + a2142 & & @xmath126 & @xmath127 + a2597 & & @xmath128 & @xmath129 + a3266 & @xmath130 & @xmath131 & @xmath132 + a3667 & @xmath133 & @xmath134 & @xmath135 + | we report the results of experiments aimed at reducing the major problem with cooling flow models of rich cluster x - ray sources : the fact that most of the cooled gas or its products have not been found . here we show that much of the x - ray emission usually attributed to cooling flows can , in fact , be modeled by a power - law component which is indicative of a source(s ) other than thermal bremsstrahlung from the intracluster medium . we find that adequate simultaneous fits to rosat pspcb and asca gis / sis spectra of the central regions of ten clusters are obtained for two - component models that includes a thermal plasma component that is attributable to hot intracluster gas and a power - law component that is likely generated by compact sources and/or extended non - thermal emission . for five of the clusters that purportedly have massive cooling flows , the best - fit models have power - law components that contribute @xmath0 30 % of the total flux ( 0.14 - 10.0 kev ) within the central 3 arcminutes . because cooling flow mass deposition rates are inferred from x - ray fluxes , our finding opens the possibility of significantly reducing cooling rates . |
1509.04407 | photospheric and corona magnetic field evolution is essential to the energy build - up and release process of solar eruptions . the field evolution is closely related to changes of sunspot structures . it is thus of vital importance to establish the physical connection between the photospheric magnetic field , the sunspot evolution , and the coronal dynamics . many previous studies have been focusing on flare - induced changes of the photospheric magnetic field and sunspot structures ( e.g. , severny 1964 ; wang et al . , 1994 ; spirock et al . , 2002 ; yurchyshyn et al . , 2004 ; wang & liu 2010 ; wang et al . , 2012 ; liu et al . , 2014 ) . over the past five decades with growing observational capabilities , it was established that the sunspot structure and corresponding photospheric magnetic field may change suddenly and irreversibly after flares . the flare - induced changes are manifested in the rapid change of the transverse photospheric magnetic field ( @xmath0 ) , and darkening as well as decay or even disappearance of sunspot structures . in a recent study , liu et al . ( 2014 ) presented a comprehensive comparison of two major events released from the same noaa active region ( ar 11283 ) . both events are characterized by x - class flares ( an x2.1 one on 2011 september 6 and an x1.8 one on september 7 ) , with fast filament eruptions and coronal mass ejections ( cmes ) . the authors found that both flares result in rapid increases of @xmath0 around the flaring polarity inversion line ( pil ) and decreases in the surrounding peripheral penumbral region , corresponding to the darkening or decay in white - light ( wl ) intensities respectively . this is interpreted as the result of the inward collapse of the central magnetic field ( also see hudson , 2000 ) and the radial outward stretching of the peripheral magnetic field during the flare - cme eruption . from the space weather forecasting perspective , it is more important to figure out whether there exist some general trends in the pre - flare photospheric magnetic field and wl evolutions of involved sunspots . in ruan et al . ( 2014 ) , a study focusing on the 6-hour long pre - flare sunspot activities and photospheric magnetic field evolution of the x2.1 event from ar 11283 was presented . it was concluded that the persistent sunspot rotation plays an important role in twisting , energizing , and destabilizing the coronal filament - flux rope system . during the period of apparent sunspot rotation , it was found that both horizontal field strength ( @xmath0 ) and the inclination angle ( @xmath1 the angle between the vector magnetic field and the local radial direction ) decline gradually . they found that the variation of the surface field and the inclination angle is associated with the overall ascending motion of the corona filament - flux rope structure . ruan et al . ( 2014 ) proposed that the long - term pre - flare evolution of the photospheric @xmath0 can be taken as a possible precursor of an eruption . in addition , the photospheric field evolution carries information about the energy storage and triggering process of the event , and can be used to discern different eruption mechanism . it was suggested that a gradual decrease of @xmath0 may be a precursor for an eruption in terms of the flux rope instability ( see , e.g. , lin et al . , 2003 ) , while a persistent increase of this quantity may be a precursor of the tether - cutting reconnection scenario ( moore 2001 ) . in this study , we investigate the x1.8 flare on 2011 september 7 , occurred in the same ar as studied by ruan et al . as mentioned , this event was associated with a fast cme - filament eruption , very similar to the preceding x2.1 event according to the solar dynamics observatory ( sdo ; pesnell et al . , 2012 ) data . our focus is the long - term pre - flare evolution of the photospheric magnetic field and the sunspot structure , and their correlation with the pre - eruption dynamics in the upper layers of the solar atmosphere . for this study , we mainly analyzed the multi - wavelength imaging data provided by the atmospheric imaging assembly ( aia ; lemen et al . 2012 ) and the vector magnetic field and continuum intensity data by the helioseismic and magnetic imager ( hmi ; schou et al . 2012 ) on board the solar dynamic observatory ( sdo ) . the aia data at passbands of 304 ( heii , [email protected] mk ) , 171 ( feix , @xmath20.6 mk ) and the 94 ( fexviii , [email protected] mk ) are examined in order to reveal the filament and coronal dynamics at different temperatures . the processed disambiguated hmi vector magnetic field data are of 12-minute cadence at a 0.5@xmath3@xmath3 pixel resolution , provided by the hmi team ( see ftp://pail.stanford.edu/pub/hmivector2/movie/ar1283.mov for the movie ) . we also used the hmi continuum intensity observation at the 6173 to investigate the evolution of the sunspot structure . these intensity data have been normalized and removed of limb darkening effect with a cadence of 12 minutes and a 0.5@xmath3@xmath3 pixel resolution . we also examined the tio image ( a proxy for continuum at 7057 ) taken by the new solar telescope ( nst ; goode et al . 2010 ; cao et al . 2010 ) at big bear solar observatory ( bbso ) with a high spatial resolution of about 0.04@xmath3@xmath3/pixel . the ar 11283 was located n14w30 at 19:55 ut on september 7 , close to the disk center . as mentioned , it released two x - class flares on september 6 and 7 , respectively . the eruption processes of both events have been well - studied by many authors ( feng et al . , 2013 ; jiang et al . , 2013 ; wang et al . , 2012 ; zharkov et al . , 2013 ; ruan et al . , 2014 ; liu et al . 2014 ; shen et al . so details of the overall evolution of this ar will not be repeated here . in figure 1 , we show the goes sxr ( 1 - 8 ) light curve from 20:00 ut sept . 6 to 24:00 ut sept . 7 . the x1.8 flare started at 22:32 ut , peaked at 22:38 ut , and ended at 22:44 ut according to the goes data . a c3 flare took place from 19:55 ut to 20:19 ut with a peaking time at 20:06 ut , which is also of interest to this study . the peaking times of these three flares have been labeled with blue vertical dotted lines . according to the cdaw ( coordinated data analysis workshops ) catalog of the lasco data ( brueckner et al . 1995 ) , the x1.8 flare was accompanied by a cme travelling at a linear speed of 792 km s@xmath4 . in figure 2 , we present overall structure of this active region at several observing wavelengths . panel ( a ) is the bbso high - resolution image taken at 18:15 ut to show details of the sunspot structure . the image has been rotated by -22.6@xmath5 to facilitate comparison with the sdo data . panel ( b ) is for the hmi 6173 intensity data in a similar field of view ( fov ) as that of panel ( a ) . panel ( c ) is taken from the hmi vector magnetic field data of this ar with the color map representing the vertical field component ( @xmath6 ) and arrows for the @xmath0 component . panels ( d ) to ( f ) present the 304 , 171 , and 94 images recorded by sdo around the same time . the contours are given by @xmath7300 g of the hmi vertical field component ( @xmath6 ) on the solar surface . this figure shows some pre - eruption condition of the ar . the large - scale magnetic field is quadrupolar , with the two spots on the west giving a @xmath8 configuration , in which the negative one being the leading and the positive one being the following spot . both x - class flares occurred in similar areas in this ar ( liu et al . , 2014 ) . the yellow line in panel ( c ) delineates an `` l''-shaped pil . the hmi movie given above provides the long - term evolution of the sunspot and the magnetic field , from which we observe that the following @xmath8 spot continues to move eastward after the x2.1 flare ( peaking at 22:20 ut , september 6 ) . the magnetic field around the pil is almost parallel to the pil indicating a severely - sheared state of the magnetic field . this is consistent with the transverse alignment of the surrounding filamentary penumbral structures as seen in panel ( a ) of figure 2 . liu et al . ( 2014 ) measured the shearing speed of the two opposite - polarity spots in this @xmath8 configuration , and detected a weaker converging motion along the north - south direction . in addition , after a careful inspection of the hmi data , we find some signatures of rotation of the positive @xmath8 spot , although no clear features like a well - developed magnetic tongue can be used to undoubtedly trace the rotation ( see , e.g. , ruan et al . , 2014 ) . no apparent flux emergence is observed during the period between the x2.1 and the x1.8 flare . generally speaking , the above existing sunspot motions continuously transport energy to the corona through their magnetic connection , and play a fundamental role in pushing the corona state to the eruptive point . the 304 - 171 - 94 images presented in panels ( d)-(f ) and the accompanying animation show the pre - eruption structures and dynamics of the filament and the corona . we can see the filament is above the pil with the northern foot rooted in the positive spot umbra . it has a sigmoidal shape , corresponding to the hot sigmoidal structure observed with 94 . the filament - sigmoid structure has often been taken as the signature of a twisted flux rope structure ( e.g. , rust & kumar 1994 ; titov & demoulin 1999 ; mckenzie & canfield 2008 ) , which shall carry a major part of the free magnetic energy to be released . now let us inspect the dynamic evolution of the relevant filament - corona structure . initially , the filament is buried underneath the overlying coronal arcades ( 171 ) . as the region evolves , the coronal arcades expand gradually and continuously , especially those arcades atop the filament . these arcades seem to be consistently removed from the filament top . this allows a larger part of the filament to be exposed . before the eruption , the filament becomes thicker , darker and more bulging than before , as seen from both the 304 and 171 images . brightening of loops atop the filament can be seen for several times from the 171 and 94 passbands , indicating reconnections on - going there . the post - flare loops of the c3 flare are representative of these loops . later , we will discuss the possible role of this c3 flare and following reconnections in triggering the subsequent major eruption . in figure 3 we present the long - term temporal evolution of 6173 intensity map ( upper panels ) and the photospheric transverse field ( @xmath0 , lower panels ) of the ar derived from the hmi data . @xmath0 is illustrated using a color map with red color representing stronger and blue representing weaker magnetic field strength . this figure and the accompanying animation exhibit a very striking feature , that is the close correlation between the gradual changes of @xmath0 and the wl intensity ( @xmath9 ) . this feature is the focus of our study . note that for completeness the data pre- and during the previous x2.1 flare have been included in the animation . here we only focus on the data since 00:00 ut of september 7 . initially , we see that the region with enhanced @xmath0 is allocated with the pil . then , the red color of this region gradually evolves into a region of yellow , green and blue colors . this indicates that @xmath0 there becomes weaker with time . after the peaking of the x1.8 flare , the @xmath0 gets enhanced suddenly . on the other hand , the sunspot penumbrae around the pil get brightened persistently in almost the same period ( @xmath1010 hours before the x1.8 flare ) , and become darkened suddenly during the flare . the changes of @xmath0 and the penumbral structures during the flare are consistent with previous studies mentioned in our introduction . of particular interest here is their long - term pre - flare evolution and correlation of the two quantities . in the earlier papers reported the flare - induced penumbra intensity changes ( wang et al . 2004 ; deng et al . , 2005 ) , the authors adopted the wording `` penumbral decay '' to describe the process . here we follow them on the terminology , although the wording `` penumbral fade '' might be a better choice since during the process only the penumbral intensity changes considerably while the area remains largely unchanged . to further examine their evolution and correlation , we select a trapezoid to include the main area of the pre - flare enhanced @xmath0 region , which is around the pil across the @xmath8 spot . we then calculate the averages of the magnetic field components ( @xmath0 and @xmath6 ) , inclination angle ( @xmath1 ) , total magnetic flux ( @xmath11 ) , and the wl intensity ( @xmath9 ) within the trapezoid . the obtained profiles are plotted in the two panels of figure 4 . in the upper panel , we see that after @xmath27:00 ut , @xmath0 starts to decline gradually till the x1.8 flare , from an initial magnitude of @xmath21226 g to a final value of @xmath2679 g. the overall declining percentage is @xmath245@xmath12 . during the x1.8 flare , @xmath0 jumps to @xmath21053 g. similarly , @xmath1 decreases from @xmath268@xmath5 ( 10:00 ut ) to @xmath255@xmath5 before the flare , and jumps back to 64@xmath5 after the flare ( 24:00 ut ) . on the other hand , the average intensity starts to increase also from @xmath210:00 ut , from a normalized value of @xmath20.70 to @xmath20.89 before the flare and drops to 0.78 after the flare ( 24:00 ut ) . the intimate anti - correlation between @xmath9 and @xmath0 ( or @xmath1 ) is self - evident . in the lower panel of figure 4 , we plot the profiles of the average positive and negative components of @xmath6 as well as the total flux ( @xmath13 ) . we see that during the whole pre - flare stage , all the three quantities do not show any considerable systematic changes . the value of the positive ( negative ) @xmath6 lies in a narrow range of [ 251 , 280 ] g ( [ -174 , -215 ] g ) , and @xmath13 lies in a range of [ 0.58x@xmath14 , 0.65x@xmath14 ] maxwell , from 05:00 ut to 21:00 ut . this indicates that the pil region is dominated by the transverse component of the photospheric field , and there is no significant flux emergence or cancellation in the period of study . a straightforward explanation of the results shown in figures 3 and 4 is that the magnetic field lines on the photosphere becomes more vertical with time during the pre - flare phase . to find further observational support of this explanation , we examine the aia data taken in the 304 and 171 passbands . following ruan et al . ( 2014 ) , we plot the height - time map along a slice of the filament . the slice location and the map are shown in the upper panels of figure 5 , with an accompanying animation available online . a dashed white line is plotted for visual guide . we see that , along the slice , at about 08:00 ut the filament becomes thick enough to be observable from the map . after that , it shows a gradual ascending motion , very similar to the filament motion leading to the previous x2.1 flare ( ruan et al . , 2014 ) . the 171 data present the filament and its overlying arcades . as described in the previous section , initially the filament seems to be buried underneath these arcades . along with the continuous apparent expansion of the arcades , a larger part of the filament comes into view . to show this continuous expansion , we make an angular time map along a circular slice centered around one foot of the arcades . the northward direction is taken to be 0 degree and the angle increases clockwise . the slice and the map are shown in the lower panels of figure 5 , where the expansion is manifested as a gradual rotating motion , which is obvious from 05:00 ut on . the apparent expansion is initially very fast , then gets slower with time . the outer edge of the loops move from @xmath250@xmath5 at 05:00 ut to @xmath2100@xmath5 at 12:00 ut and reaches @xmath2120@xmath5 from 12:00 ut to 22:00 ut , along the circular slice . note that thermal effects , which can make the coronal arcades visible or invisible , can result in some pseudo expansion . nevertheless , with a careful inspection of the animation , we believe that the genuine physical expansion of the arcades is important here . assuming the pre - eruption corona field evolves slowly enough so that it can be represented by a series of magnetic equilibria , liu et al . ( 2014 ) deduced this slow evolution with a nonlinear force - free field ( nlfff ) extrapolation technique ( wieglemann , 2004 ; wieglemann et al . , 2006 ) . in their figure 4 and the accompanying animation , they showed the long - term evolution of the extrapolated electric current density distribution and magnetic field lines across the central part of the filament . it is clear from their study that there exists a flux rope aligning with the filament and the flux rope arises gradually during the period from after the x2.1 to before the x1.8 flare . this result is consistent with the observation that a significant part of the well - developed filament exists after the x2.1 flare ( see also liu et al . 2014 ) , and supports our argument deduced above . in summary , we found a persistent well - correlated pre - flare long term evolution of the penumbral structure and the photospheric transverse field around the pil . the observed penumbral decay and @xmath0 decline are likely caused by the ascending motion of the filament - flux rope system . this picture is supported by the simultaneous imaging data with the 304 for the filament and the 171 for the overlying arcades . nevertheless , it can not be ruled out of the possibility that the pre - flare sunspot decay and the @xmath0 decline are simply the result of the overall sunspot evolution and not the direct response to the filament - corona dynamics . another interesting problem to discuss here is the possible role played by the c3 flare in triggering the following x1.8 eruption . to show this , in figure 6 we present the four aia 171 images from 20:39 ut to 22:27 ut . the first panel presents the post loops of the c3 flare , stretching over the filament . a nearby bright loop on the northern side is also shown . in the second panel both loops get darkened and expanded . in the third panel ( 21:54 ut ) a new loop connecting the southern foot of the post - flare loops and the eastern foot of the nearby loop appears . this is very likely a result of the reconnection between the two loop systems , as will be explained in the following paragraph . at 22:27 ut , in the fourth panel , the post - reconnection loops get brightened considerably and the post - c3 loops almost disappear . this evolution of coronal loops can also be clearly seen from the accompanying aia 171 animation . to support this reconnection scenario , we show the contours of the vertical magnetic field component of hmi in figure 6 ( b ) . it is seen that the magnetic field polarities are in the order of positive , negative , positive , and negative for the four foots of the two sets of pre - reconnection loops , thus favoring the reconnection process described above . the post - reconnection bright loops ( see figure 6d ) are still likely on top of the filament and more high - lying in the corona in comparison to those pre - reconnection overlying loops . shortly after the reconnection , the filament starts to rise rapidly and the x1.8 flare takes place . to illustrate the reconnection process more clearly , we show schematics in the left two panels at the bottom of figure 6 , where yellow lines are for pre - reconnection loops and red lines are for post - reconnection loops . it can be seen that the expansion of the coronal arcades overlying the filament ( in cyan ) drives their reconnection with longer magnetic loops rooted in a nearby pair of opposite polarities . this reconnection can remove some of the arcades overlying the filament and reduce the confining force ( or the strapping effect , see recent paper of wang et al . , 2015 ) acting on the filament . this will at least speed up the evolution process leading to the following major eruption , and possibly play as a trigger of the filament - flux rope instability . * possible configuration during the impulsive stage of the x1.8 flare is also shown in the last panel of figure 6 , for completeness , from which we see that the filament erupts with a flux rope and part of its overlying arcades . * the picture involves a quadrupolar topology and a triggering reconnection in the corona , both are essential features of the breakout model ( antiochos et al . , 1999 ) for solar eruption . we therefore suggest that the breakout process may be important to the trigger of the x1.8 flare and the associated cme . some recent studies on the magnetic field evolution have been focusing on rapid changes of the photospheric transverse field and sunspot structures induced by solar flares . in this study we investigate the correlation between the long - term ( @xmath210 - 20 hours ) pre - flare evolution of the sunspot penumbrae and the photospheric transverse field component around the pil , as well as their relation with filament - corona dynamics . it is found that the penumbrae decayed gradually and the strength of the transverse field ( and the inclination angle of the magnetic field ) on the solar surface declined correspondingly , indicating that the pre - flare magnetic structure from the photosphere to the corona is getting more vertical with time . this indication is corroborated with the sdo imaging observation of the filament arising and the apparent expansion of its overlying arcades , and consistent with the nlfff extrapolation results of the pre - eruption state of the local corona . intensity changes of the sunspot penumbra induced by solar flares have been reported in several studies ( e.g. , wang et al . , 2004 ; deng et al . , 2005 ; liu et al . , 2014 ) . here we report the long - term pre - flare evolution of the penumbra intensity change as well as its correlation with the photospheric magnetic field evolution and relevant coronal dynamics . in deng et al . ( 2005 ) , the flare - induced penumbra decay was explained with the change of the inclination angle of the magnetic field in the corresponding penumbral region . according to leka & skumanich ( 1998 ) , the magnetic field inclination angle in the peripheral penumbrae , when turning from more inclined to more vertical and toward the umbra , can directly suppress the penumbral evershed flow resulting in an increase of the continuum intensity . here we propose a very similar scenario to interpret the observational result , although the trend of long term change is opposite to that of the flare - induced rapid changes . we suggest that the observed persistent pre - flare penumbral decay ( or fade ) is a result of the gradual change of the direction of the magnetic field in the penumbral region from more horizontal to more vertical , which is likely caused by the gradual rising of the filament - flux rope system in the upper solar atmosphere . the long - term pre - flare behavior of the photospheric magnetic field , sunspot , filament and the corona arcades are of vital importance to space weather studies . these behaviors could provide clues about how the solar magnetic field evolves from a pre - eruption state to the eruption , including the energy transport , storage , and release processes . the result of our study is based on eruptions from only one ar . more events should be investigated to decide what signatures or processes could be used as possible eruption precursor or trigger . we thank sdo / hmi and sdo / aia science teams for the free access to the data . we are grateful to the referee for valuable comments and dr . guohui du , bing wang , and di zhao for their help in preparing the figures . this work was supported by the 973 program nsbrsf 2012cb825601 , u1331104 and nnsfc grants 41331068 , 41274175 to sduwh , and by nsf grants ags-1348513 and ags-1408703 to njit . antiochos , s. k. , devore , c. r. , klimchuk , j. a. , 1999 , apj , 510 , 485 brueckner , g. e. , howard , r. a. , koomen , m. j. , et al . 1995 , soph , 162 , 357 cao , w. , gorceix , n. , coulter , r. , ahn , k. , rimmele , t. r. , & goode , p. r. 2010 , astronomische nachrichten , 331 , 636 deng , n. , liu , c. , yang , g. et al . , 2005 , apj , 623 , 1195 evershed j. , 1909 , mon . not . feng , l. , wiegelmann , t. , su , y. , et al . 2013 , apj , 765 , 37 goode , p. r. , yurchyshyn , v. , cao , w. , abramenko , v. , andic , a. , ahn , k. , & chae , j. 2010 , apj , 714 , l31 hudson , h. s. , 2000 , apj , 531 , l75 jiang , c. w. , & feng , x. s. 2013 , apj , 769 , 144 lemen , j. r. , title , a. m. , akin , d. j. , boerner , p. f. , & et al . 2012 , solar phys . , 275 , 17 leka , k. d. , & skumanich , a. 1998 , apj , 507 , 454 lin , j. , soon , w. , & baliunas , s. l. 2003 , new astron . , 47 , 53 liu , c. , deng , n. , lee , j. et al . , 2014 , apj , 795 , 128 mckenzie , d.e . and hudson , h.s . : 1999 , astrophys . j. 519 , l93 moore , r. l. , sterling , a. c. , hudson , h. s. , & lemen , j. r. 2001 , apj , 552 , 833 pesnell , w. dean , thompson , b. j. , chamberlin , p. c. , 2012 , solar phys . , 275 , 3 ruan , g.p . , chen , y. , wang , s. , zhang , h.q . , li , g. , jing , j. , su , j.t . , li , x. , xu , h.q . , du , g.h . , & wang , h.m . , 2014 , apj , 784 , 165 . rust , d. m. , & kumar , a. 1994 , sol . phys . , 155 , 69 schou , j. , scherrer , p. h. , bush , r. i. , wachter , r. , et al . 2012 , solar phys . , 275 , 229 severny , a. b. , 1964 , ara&a , 2 , 363 shen , y.d . , ichimoto , k. , ishii , t. t. , tian , z.j . , zhao , r.j . , shibata , k. , 2014 , apj , 786 , 151 spirock , t. j. , yurchyshyn , v. , wang , h. , 2002 , apj , 572 , 1072 titov , v.s . and demoulin , p. : 1999 , astron . and astrophys . 351 , 707 wang , h. , ewell , m. w. , zirin , h. , ai g. , 1994 , apj , 424 , 436 wang , h. , liu , c. , qiu , j. , deng , n. , goode , p. r. , & denker , c. 2004 , apj , 601 , l195 wang , h. m. , liu , c. 2010 , apjl , 716 , l195 wang , h. m. , cao , w. d. , liu , c. , xu , y. , liu , r. , zeng , z. c. , chae , j. c. , ji , h. s. , 2015 , nature communications , doi : 10.1038/ncomms8008 wang , s. , liu , c. , liu , r. , deng , n. , liu , y. , & wang , h. m. , 2012 , apj , 745 , l17 wiegelmann , t. 2004 , sol . phys . , 219 , 87 wiegelmann , t. , inhester , b. , & sakurai , t. 2006 , sol . phys . , 233 , 215 yurchyshyn , v. , wang , h. , abramenko , v. et al . , 2004 , apj , 605 , 546 zharkov , s. , green , l. m. , matthews , s. a. , & zharkova , v. v. 2013 , jphcs , 440 , 012046 | in this paper , we present a study on persistent and gradual penumbral decay and correlated decline of the photospheric transverse field component during 10 - 20 hours before a major flare ( x1.8 ) eruption on 2011 september 7 . this long - term pre - eruption behavior is corroborated with the well - imaged pre - flare filament rising , the consistent expansion of coronal arcades overlying the filament , as well as the nlfff modelling results in the literature . we suggest that both the long - term pre - flare penumbral decay and the transverse field decline are the photospheric manifestation of the gradual rise of the coronal filament - flux rope system . we also suggest that a c3 flare and subsequent reconnection process preceding the x1.8 flare play an important role in triggering the later major eruption . |
1603.09607 | quantum interference effects involving various atomic transition amplitudes were intensively investigated recently @xcite . it originate from indistinguishability of the corresponding transition pathways . as a consequence , quenching of spontaneous emission occurs due to quantum interference effects between decaying pathways which are dependent on mutual orientation of corresponding transition dipoles @xcite . laser- or phase - control of spontaneous emission processes were demonstrated there . also , quantum interference effects lead to very narrow spectral lines in the spontaneous emission spectrum of pumped molecular , semiconductor or highly charged ion systems @xcite . furthermore , such spontaneously generated coherences in a large ensemble of nuclei operating in the x - ray regime and resonantly coupled to a common cavity environment were experimentally demonstrated in @xcite . previously it was shown that multi - level atoms interacting with the vacuum of a preselected cavity mode , in the bad - cavity limit , exhibit cavity induced quantum interference which is similar to the spontaneously generated coherences due to parallel transition dipoles @xcite . quantum interference effects in an ensemble of @xmath0 nuclei interacting with coherent light were demonstrated too , in ref . @xcite . destructive or constructive interference effects were observed even in a strongly pumped few - level quantum- dot sample @xcite . protection of bipartite entanglement @xcite or continuous variable entanglement @xcite via quantum interferences were shown to occur as well . finally , electromagnetic induced transparency is an another phenomenon of quantum destructive interference which makes a resonant opaque medium highly transparent and dispersive within a narrow spectral band @xcite . based on this background , here , we study the quantum dynamics of a three - level ladder - type atomic system possessing orthogonal transition dipoles and embedded in an optical leaking resonator . the atomic sample is pumped coherently and resonantly with external electromagnetic field sources . despite of photon scattering into surrounding electromagnetic modes including the cavity one and resonant laser - atom driving , we identify regimes when the cavity mode is empty in the good - cavity limit . we demonstrate that this occurs due to destructive quantum interference effects among the involved transition pathways . the effect is maximal when the cavity mode frequency is in resonance with particular resonance fluorescence sidebands . this is distinct from interference phenomena observed in @xcite where the experiment was performed in the bad - cavity limit and different parameter regimes . furthermore , most upper bare - state population inversion is achieved as well in our system although it is identified with coherent population trapping effects rather than quantum interference phenomena which lead to zero cavity mean - photon numbers . the inversion can facilitate the generation of correlated or entangled photon - pairs when one photon lies in an optical range while another one is in a higher frequency domain , i.e. , euv or x ray etc . the article is organized as follows . in section ii we describe the hamiltonian , the adopted approximations and the master equation describing our system . in section iii we discuss and analyze the obtained results . the summary is given in section iv . we consider a laser driven three - level @xmath1 atom placed in a cavity of frequency @xmath2 and leaking rate @xmath3 . we denote via @xmath4 the transition frequency from the most excited level @xmath5 to the intermediate level @xmath6 whereas @xmath7 is the frequency of the transition from the state @xmath6 to the ground state @xmath8 . the atom s decay rates via spontaneous emissions corresponding to each transition are defined as @xmath9 and @xmath10 , respectively . the atomic system is coherently pumped , perpendicularly to the cavity axis , by two different laser fields of frequencies @xmath11 and @xmath12 with @xmath13 and @xmath14 being the corresponding rabi frequencies on transitions @xmath15 and @xmath16 ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) . correspondingly , the cavity - atom interaction constants are given by @xmath17 and @xmath18 . the hamiltonian describing the whole system is : @xmath19 here @xmath20 , @xmath21 , are the atom operators , while @xmath22 are the cavity field creation and annihilation operators and obey the commutation relations @xmath23 = \delta_{\beta , \beta'}s_{\alpha,\alpha ' } -\delta_{\alpha',\alpha}s_{\beta',\beta}$ ] and @xmath24 = 1 $ ] , respectively . the first two terms in eq . ( [ htot ] ) describe the single mode free cavity field and the atom free hamiltonians . the external laser fields and the cavity field interact with both transitions of the atom and every interaction is defined via separate terms corresponding to each transition . thus , the next two terms of the hamiltonian represent the interaction of the quantized cavity with the atom whereas the last two terms describe the laser - atom semi - classical interaction . the system s quantum dynamics is given by the master equation for the density operator @xmath25 as : @xmath26 + \frac{\kappa}{2 } \mathcal{l } ( a ) + \frac{\gamma_{32}}{2 } \mathcal{l } ( s_{23})+ \frac{\gamma_{21}}{2 } \mathcal{l } ( s_{12 } ) , \nonumber \\ \label{meq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , on the right - hand side of the equation , the first term represents the coherent evolution based on the system hamiltonian @xmath27 , while the other terms describe the damping phenomena , i.e. , the cavity field damping and the spontaneous emissions processes , respectively . the damping effects are expressed by the liouville superoperator @xmath28 , which acts on a given operator @xmath29 as : @xmath30 . in the usual interaction picture with @xmath31 it is more convenient to apply the semi - classical dressed - state transformation defined as : @xmath32 with @xmath33 and @xmath34 . then , in the dressed - state picture , the system s dynamics is described by the following dressed - state master equation : @xmath26 + \frac{\kappa}{2 } \mathcal{l } ( a ) + \frac{\gamma_{32 } \cos^{2}{\theta}}{4 } ( \mathcal{l } ( r_{-0 } ) + \mathcal{l } ( r_{+0 } ) ) \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{\gamma_{32 } \sin^{2}{\theta } + \gamma_{21}\cos^{2}{\theta}}{8 } ( \mathcal{l } ( r_{z } ) + \mathcal{l } ( r_{+-})\nonumber \\ & + & \mathcal{l } ( r_{-+ } ) ) + \frac{\gamma_{21 } \sin^{2}{\theta}}{4 } ( \mathcal{l } ( r_{0- } ) + \mathcal{l } ( r_{0 + } ) ) . \label{meqdb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , the secular approximation was performed in the spontaneous emission terms by neglecting the time - dependent rapidly oscillating terms - an approximation valid as long as @xmath35 . the dressed - state atomic operators @xmath36 , @xmath37 , and @xmath38 , obey the same commutation relations as the old ones . the system hamiltonian in the dressed - state picture is expressed as : @xmath39 with @xmath40 . as a next step , we perform a unitary transformation : @xmath41 where @xmath42 to arrive at the following transformed hamiltonian : @xmath43 analyzing the hamiltonian one can conclude that the atom s resonance fluorescence spectra on each transition is formed of sidebands centered at @xmath44 and @xmath45 as well as a central peak around @xmath46 . the dressed - state hamiltonian significantly simplifies if one tunes the laser - cavity detuning @xmath47 in resonance with one of the sidebands frequency . in what follows , we shall consider such a situation when @xmath48 , i.e. @xmath49 ( notice that similar results would be obtained for a cavity tuned to the lowest energy sideband , i.e. , when @xmath50 ) . in this case , the dressed - state hamiltonian is @xmath51 with @xmath52 . this hamiltonian accurately describes the quantum dynamics within the adopted approximations as long as @xmath53 . furthermore , the obtained hamiltonian has a similar form to the hamiltonian of a two - level atom interacting with a cavity with an effective coupling @xmath54 . this effective coupling originates from the quantum interference of the two dressed - state transition amplitudes , see fig . ( [ fig1 ] ) , contributing to the atom pumping of the cavity mode . as it will be shown later , it is possible to configure the two rabi frequencies in order to effectively decouple the atom from the cavity , i.e. , the effective coupling vanishes when @xmath55 . correspondingly , the cavity mode is empty , although the pumped atom spontaneously scatters photons . notice that when @xmath56 there are no destructive quantum interference effects . the master equation ( [ meqdb ] ) , with the hamiltonian ( [ hfinal ] ) , is solved by projecting into the system s states basis @xcite . the first projection in the atom s dressed - state basis leads to a set of five linearly coupled differential equations defined by the variables : @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 , where @xmath62 , @xmath63 , namely , @xmath64 here @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 . the next projection in the field s basis leads to a set of infinite equations corresponding to the infinite fock states @xmath68 , that is , @xmath69 where @xmath70 . interestingly , @xmath71 are the diagonal elements of the field s reduced density matrix , i.e. , it contains the trace over the atom s dressed - states : @xmath72 \vert n \rangle$ ] . hence , it is possible to deduce the cavity field s mean photon number @xmath73 by tracing over the the field s states : @xmath74 respectively , the second order photon - photon correlation function @xmath75 is given by : @xmath76 after some mathematical manipulations one finds : @xmath77 with the condition @xmath78 . using also transformation ( [ db ] ) , the population of the upper bare state is given by : @xmath79 finally , in order to solve the infinite system of eqs . ( [ sysfin ] ) , we truncate it at a certain maximum value @xmath80 of considered fock states . the photon distribution of the field converges to zero for larger @xmath81 , and thus , @xmath82 is selected such that a further increase of its value does not modify the obtained results . the mean cavity photon number as well as their quantum statistics are shown in fig . ( [ fig2 ] ) . a dip in the photon number is clearly visible when @xmath83 . it is due to quantum interference effects with a destructive nature on the cavity field photons . the interference occurs because both dressed - state transitions of the atom are coupled to the cavity mode leading to indistinguishable photon emission ( see also fig . [ fig1 ] ) . a destructive quantum interference phenomenon is observed when the cavity is tuned to one of the external sidebands , i.e. , @xmath84 . respectively , the atom decouples from the cavity field in this particular case . thus , the zero cavity photon detection in this scheme is directly related to quantum interference phenomena . quantum switching devises are feasible applications here , because , the mean - photon number abruptly changes from zero to a particular value which depends on the atom - cavity coupling . the photon statistics shows super - poissonian behaviors . particularly , @xmath85 and @xmath86 when @xmath87 . here , the involved parameters or their ratios can be determined when the cavity mean- photon number vanishes . additional applications may be related to quantum networks where tools to control the involved processes are highly required @xcite . [ fig3 ] shows the bare - state population of the upper state @xmath88 as well as the cavity mean - photon number when @xmath89 while @xmath90 and @xmath91 with @xmath92 . the cavity mode resonantly couples with the upper atomic transition @xmath93 only , i.e. @xmath94 . this situation is described as well by the analytical formalism developed here via setting @xmath94 in eqs . ( [ sysfin ] ) . reasonable population inversion is achieved . we have found that the inversion is a signature of the coherent population trapping phenomenon @xcite , i.e. , the atom is trapped in the dressed - state @xmath95 . then with a suitable chose of the ratio @xmath96 one can transfer the populations among the state @xmath97 . furthermore , the cavity field does not affect the bare - state population dynamics in the adopted approximations . as a concrete atomic system , for this particular configuration , one may consider he atoms , @xmath98 @xcite . the spontaneous decay rates ratio is approximately @xmath99 . the corresponding transition wavelengths are @xmath100 and @xmath101 . instead of a continuous wave laser on the high - frequency transition one may consider a long pulse laser wave . potential applications here may be related to entangled photon pair emissions @xcite in optical and euv ( or even higher ) frequency ranges . summarizing , we have investigated the quantum dynamics of a three - level atom embedded in an optical cavity and resonantly interacting with external coherent electromagnetic waves . we have found parameter regimes where the atom completely decouples from the interaction with the cavity field . as a consequence , the cavity mean photon number goes to zero . photon vanishing is due to quantum interference effects involving two possible dressed - state atomic transitions . their indestinguishability leads to destructive quantum interference phenomena . upper bare - state population inversion occurs as well . we appreciate the helpful discussions with professor christoph h. keitel and are grateful for the hospitality of the theory division of the max planck institute for nuclear physics from heidelberg , germany . furthermore , we acknowledge the financial support by the german federal ministry of education and research , grant no . 01dk13015 , and academy of sciences of moldova , grants no . 13.820.05.07/gf and 15.817.02.09f . zhu and m. o. scully , spectral line elimination and spontaneous emission cancellation via quantum interference , phys . lett . * 76 * , 388 ( 1996 ) ; m. a. g. martinez , p. r. herczfeld , c. samuels , l.m . narducci , and c. h. keitel , quantum interference effects in spontaneous atomic emission : dependence of the resonance fluorescence spectrum on the phase of the driving field , phys . a * 55 * , 4483 ( 1997 ) ; e. paspalakis and p. l. knight , phase control of spontaneous emission , phys . rev . lett . * 81 * , 293 ( 1998 ) . c. h. keitel , narrowing spontaneous emission without intensity reduction , phys . rev . lett . * 83 * , 1307 ( 1999 ) ; o. postavaru , z. harman , and c. h. keitel , high - precision metrology of highly charged ions via relativistic resonance fluorescence , phys . lett . * 106 * , 033001 ( 2011 ) . k. p. heeg , h .- c . wille , k. schlage , t. guryeva , d. schumacher , i. uschmann , k. s. schulze , b. marx , t. kmpfer , g. g. paulus , r. rhlsberger , and j. evers , vacuum - assisted generation and control of atomic coherences at x - ray energies , phys . lett . * 111 * , 073601 ( 2013 ) . b. m. garraway , and p. l. knight , cavity modified quantum beats , phys . a * 54 * , 3592 ( 1996 ) ; a. patnaik , and g. s. agarwal , cavity - induced coherence effects in spontaneous emissions from preselection of polarization , phys . a * 59 * , 3015 ( 1999 ) . b. d. gerardot , d. brunner , p. a. dalgarno , k. karrai , a. badolato , p. m. petroff , and r. j. warburton , dressed excitonic states and quantum interference in a three - level quantum dot ladder system , new journal of physics * 11 * , 013028 ( 2009 ) . s. e. harris , electromagnetically induced transparency , phys . today * 50 * , 36 ( 1997 ) ; m. fleischhauer , a. imamoglu , and j. p. marangos , electromagnetically induced transparency : optics in coherent media , rev . * 77 * , 633 ( 2005 ) ; y. sun , y. yang , h. chen , sh . zhu , dephasing - induced control of interference nature in three - level electromagnetically induced transparency system , sci . rep . * 5 * , 16370 ( 2015 ) . | we discuss quantum interference phenomena in a system consisting from a laser driven three - level ladder - type emitter possessing orthogonal transition dipoles and embedded in a leaking optical resonator . the cavity mean - photon number vanishes due to the destructive nature of the interference phenomena . the effect occurs for some particular parameter regimes which were identified . furthermore , upper bare - state population inversion occurs as well . |
0902.4613 | cosmic ray interactions at ultra - high energies offer unique insights into particle collisions at center - of - mass energies exceeding 100 tev . due to their very small flux at these energies , cosmic rays can only be detected indirectly via the extensive air showers ( eas ) they induce in the atmosphere . hence , in order to infer the mass and energy of the primary cosmic rays as well as to gain insight into the physics of the high - energy collisions , one has to rely on detailed simulations of air showers . for this purpose , hadronic multiparticle production has to be simulated at energies exceeding by far those accessible at man - made accelerators and in phase space regions not covered in collider experiments . the secondary muons produced in these collisions which can be detected directly on ground , are a tracer of high - energy hadronic interactions . for this reason , the number of muons produced in simulated air showers depends strongly on the adopted hadronic interaction models @xcite . in addition , muons are a sensitive indicator of the primary composition , as , for example , iron showers produce about 40% more muons than protons . in this work we will employ _ air shower universality _ in order to determine the number of muons in air showers detected with auger , using several independent methods . air shower universality @xcite states that the average properties of air showers can be completely characterized by the primary energy , stage of shower evolution , and overall muon normalization , when viewing the shower around or after shower maximum . in particular , the electromagnetic particle content of the shower is already determined by its energy and stage of evolution . physically , this is due to the fact that the electromagnetic cascade involves dozens of particle generations and of order @xmath0 particles , which washes out the details of high - energy hadronic interactions . in order to infer the muon density of showers at a given energy , one has to rely on an energy scale of the surface detector . using the universality of the electromagnetic contribution to the signal measured by the auger surface detectors , @xmath1 , we are able to determine an energy scale independent of the fluorescence energy measurement . the muon density at ground which we infer using the surface detector and , independently , using hybrid events , does not rely on assumptions on the primary cosmic ray composition . this allows for a direct test of the predictions of hadronic interaction models . universality features of the longitudinal profile of showers have been studied by several authors . here we exploit shower universality features to predict the surface detector signal expected for auger cherenkov tanks from the electromagnetic and muonic shower components at 1000 m from the shower core . in the following , we give a brief outline of the parameterization . for a detailed description , see @xcite . a library of proton and iron showers covering the energy range from @xmath2 to @xmath3ev and zenith angles between @xmath4 and @xmath5 was generated with corsika 6.5 @xcite and the hadronic interaction models qgsjet ii.03 @xcite and fluka @xcite . for comparison , a smaller set of showers was simulated with the combinations qgsjet ii.03/gheisha @xcite and sibyll 2.1/fluka @xcite . seasonal models of the malarge molecular atmosphere were used @xcite . the detector response is calculated using look - up tables derived from a detailed geant4 simulation of the auger surface detectors , which has been shown to match the data well @xcite . note that since the auger detectors are calibrated against the cosmic ray muon background , we only rely on the correct simulation of the signal generated by electromagnetic particles relative to that of the muons . air shower universality states that the electromagnetic component of the predicted surface detector signal @xmath1 at the lateral distance of 1000 m depends only on primary energy and the stage of shower evolution , and not on the primary particle and hadronic model assumed . we define the electromagnetic component of the signal as that of electrons , positrons , and gamma rays excluding muon decay products , and measure shower evolution in terms of the distance between the shower maximum and the ground @xmath6 , measured along the shower axis . in fact , universality is slightly violated , and the electromagnetic contribution to @xmath1 of proton and iron showers differ by about 12% @xcite , see fig . [ fig : sparam ] . the dependence on the hadronic model is much smaller , about 5% . + the muon contribution to @xmath1 , which includes muon decay products in our definition , depends strongly on the primary particle ( 40% difference between proton and iron ) and the hadronic model ( fig . [ fig : sparam ] ) . however , the functional dependence on @xmath7 is universal . after accounting for geometrical effects such as the projected tank surface area , the electromagnetic shower signal ( averaged over proton and iron ) is parameterized as function of the energy @xmath8 , distance to shower maximum @xmath7 , and zenith angle @xmath9 . the difference between proton and iron shower profiles is included in the calculation of the systematic uncertainties later on . similarly , the universal shape of the muon signal profile is parameterized simultaneously using a gaisser - hillas function for all models and primaries ( fig . [ fig : sparam ] ) , leaving only normalization factors free . the expected detector signal at 1000 m can then be written as @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the parametrized muon signal adopting the normalization for proton - qgsjet ii at 10eev , so that @xmath12 is the number of muons relative to that of qgsjet - ii proton showers at 10eev . within the current statistics , the arrival directions of high - energy cosmic rays around 10 eev are found to be isotropic , allowing us to apply the _ constant intensity _ method to determine the muon signal contribution . dividing the surface detector data into equal exposure bins , the number of showers with @xmath1 greater than a given threshold @xmath13 , should be the same for each bin . @xmath14 using the independently measured mean depth of shower maximum @xmath15 @xcite , the only remaining free parameter in eq . ( [ eq : cic - muons ] ) is the relative number of muons @xmath12 . for a given energy @xmath8 , @xmath12 is adjusted to obtain a flat distribution of events in @xmath16 . more precisely , scanning through a range of @xmath12 values , we calculate the @xmath17/dof of the event histogram relative to a flat distribution in @xmath16 . we then fit a two - branch parabola around the minimum of @xmath18 , which results in a best - fit @xmath19 and its asymmetric error , @xmath20 . the sensitivity of this method to the muon number parameter in eq . ( [ eq : s1000 ] ) is illustrated in fig . [ fig : cic - results ] . clearly , @xmath21 ( top histogram in the lower panel of fig . [ fig : cic - results ] ) is ruled out by the data . the best description of the data above 10eev requires @xmath22 . however , we have to take into account shower - to - shower fluctuations and the finite resolution of @xmath1 which lead to a slightly biased @xmath12 measurement in this method . in order to estimate this bias , we have simulated a large number of monte carlo realizations of sd data sets of the same size as the auger data set , distributed according to the observed cosmic ray spectrum and assuming different primary compositions ( pure proton , iron , or mixed composition ) , and different `` true '' @xmath12 . for each shower , @xmath23 is obtained from distributions which closely match the observed @xmath23 distributions in the fluorescence data . the electromagnetic and muon signals are fluctuated according to the model predictions @xcite . note that the magnitude of fluctuations in @xmath23 and @xmath12 are robust predictions which only depend on the primary particle . ( [ eq : s1000 ] ) is then used to calculate the signal at 1000 m from the shower core , @xmath1 , which is smeared with an experimental reconstruction accuracy @xcite . a realistic trigger probability is also applied . for each simulated data set , we then apply exactly the same analysis as used on the real data . we found that @xmath12 is systematically _ overestimated _ by 3@xmath246% . this bias is due to a combined action of shower - to - shower fluctuations and detector resolution which depends on the signal size . we have found that the bias in @xmath12 is independent of the `` true '' value of @xmath12 adopted , and primarily depends on the size of reconstruction uncertainties on @xmath1 and the primary composition . [ fig : bias ] shows the relative bias on @xmath12 as a function of primary energy , for different assumed compositions and increased / decreased detector resolution . clearly , the bias is quite robust to rather extreme changes in those assumptions . we then subtract the bias expected for a mixed composition ( black dots in fig . [ fig : bias ] ) from the measured @xmath19 , obtaining a corrected @xmath12 of : @xmath25 three main sources of systematics enter in the determination of @xmath12 using the constant intensity method : the uncertainty on the electromagnetic signal due to universality violation ( sec . [ sec : univ ] ) ; the uncertainty on @xmath26 at this energy ; and the uncertainty on the bias of @xmath12 determined from the monte carlo simulations . in order to quantify the first two systematics , we measure @xmath12 using an electromagnetic signal rescaled by @xmath276% , bracketing the observed universality violation , and measuring @xmath12 with varying @xmath26 , adopting the systematic and statistical uncertainty reported by auger @xcite . for the uncertainty on the bias , we adopt @xmath28% . summing the different contributions in quadrature , we obtain the total systematic error on @xmath12 quoted in eq . ( [ eq : nmucic ] ) . once @xmath12 at 10 eev is measured , and using the measured mean depth of shower maximum , the signal size at @xmath29 can be calculated : @xmath30 within the uncertainties , this value of @xmath31 is consistent with the energy scale from fluorescence detector measurements , whose systematic uncertainty ( 22% @xcite ) is dominated by the uncertainty on the fluorescence yield . ( [ eq : energy - scale ] ) corresponds to assigning showers a @xmath32% higher energy than done in the fluorescence detector - based auger shower reconstruction ( @xmath33 ) . the pierre auger observatory has the unique capability of measuring hybrid events which have been simultaneously detected by the surface detector array and fluorescence telescopes . for each of these events , a calorimetric measurement of the energy @xmath8 and depth of shower maximum @xmath23 are available , in addition to the signal @xmath1 from the surface array . hence , we can use our parameterization of the universal electromagnetic signal @xmath34 to determine the electromagnetic contribution to @xmath1 . the remainder of the signal is attributed to muons , and we can determine a muon normalization for each event : @xmath35 where @xmath36 is again the reference muon signal ( proton - qgsjetii at 10 eev ) . we select high - quality hybrid events for which the shower maximum is in the field of view of a telescope , @xmath37 , and the mie scattering length is measured . furthermore , the cherenkov light fraction is limited to less than 50% , and we apply all cuts used in the measurement of the elongation rate @xcite which have been carefully chosen in order to ensure an unbiased @xmath23 distribution of the air showers . the surface detector event has to satisfy the t5 selection cuts which are also applied in @xcite . the average muon normalization in hybrid events at 10eev is found to be @xmath38 in excellent agreement with the constant intensity method results , when compared at the same energy scale . a similar study has been performed for inclined hybrid events ( @xmath39 ) . while the statistics are limited , no subtraction of @xmath40 is necessary for these events , as the electromagnetic part has been attenuated in the large depth of atmosphere traversed . thus , inclined hybrid events yield a clean measurement of @xmath12 , and good agreement between muon numbers of the inclined and the vertical data sets is found . [ fig : hybrid - muons ] shows the muon signal derived from the hybrid events as a function of shower evolution ( @xmath7 ) . while the muon signal is clearly higher than that predicted in the simulations , the behavior as a function of @xmath7 follows the prediction very well , which serves as a consistency test of our method . in fig . [ fig : comparison ] we compare the results of the different methods applied for inferring the muon density at 1000 m from the shower core . the relative number of muons is shown as function of the adopted energy scale with respect to the auger fluorescence detector energy reconstruction . only the constant intensity method yields an independent measurement of the energy scale . good agreement between the presented methods is found , when compared at @xmath41 . assuming air shower universality , which was tested with simulations of various primaries and hadronic interaction models , we have determined the muon density at 10 eev and the energy scale with which the data of the pierre auger observatory can be described self - consistently . the number of muons measured in data is about 1.5 ( 1.7 ) times larger than that predicted by qgsjet ii ( sibyll ) for proton showers , with statistical and systematic errors of the order of 0.1 . this value of @xmath12 is even slightly larger than that predicted for iron showers , by a factor of 1.1 and 1.2 for qgsjetii and sibyll , respectively . a similar excess has been found at energies from 3 eev to 50 eev . consistent results were obtained with several analysis methods on independent data sets : the constant intensity method ( sec . [ sec : cic ] ) uses only the surface detector data and is independent of the fluorescence energy scale . vertical hybrid events ( sec . [ sec : hybrid ] ) allow for a direct and unbiased measurement of @xmath12 for each event , albeit depending on the flourescence energy . the signal in inclined hybrid events ( @xmath42 ) is purely muonic , and the resulting @xmath12 independent of the subtraction of the electromagnetic signal . the fact that all three methods agree within errors for an energy scale of @xmath43 indicates that increasing the number of muons by 50% ( relative to proton - qgsjetii ) yields a consistent description of the auger data . if interpreted in terms of cosmic ray composition , the derived muon density would correspond to nuclei heavier than iron , which is clearly at variance with the measured @xmath44 values at this energy . the discrepancy between air shower data and simulations reported here is qualitatively similar to the inconsistencies found in composition analyses of previous detectors @xcite . this points towards a deficiency of hadronic models in predicting the number of muons produced in air showers at large distances from the shower core . however , it is important to note that the method presented here relies on a correct description of the electromagnetic shower component in the simulations . p. billoir , lecture given at corsika school , http://www-ik.fzk.de/corsika/corsika-school , 2005 ; m. giller _ et al . _ , j. phys . g31 ( 2005 ) 947958 ; f. nerling _ et al . _ , 24 ( 2006 ) 421437 ; d. gora _ et al . _ , 24 ( 2006 ) 484494 ; a. s. chou [ auger collab . ] , proc . 29th icrc ( pune , india ) , p. 319 | the pierre auger observatory , recently completed , has been operational since 2004 . as a hybrid experiment , it allows for a wide range of measurements of uhecr - induced extensive air showers ( eas ) , including measurements of the eas particle content on ground which is sensitive to high - energy hadronic interactions . we present the results of several independent measurements of the eas muon content on ground in auger data at a primary energy of 10 eev . we discuss implications on high - energy hadronic interaction models and cosmic ray composition . |
1309.4492 | the possibilities of studying the propertes of neutrinos and extracting conditions inside a supernova ( sn ) progenitor star before and during its explosion , through observation of the neutrinos emitted from the sn , have been extensively investigated in the past two decades following the observation of neutrinos from sn1987a @xcite . most of these investigations focused on neutrino detection using charged current ( cc ) processes on water and other detector materials @xcite , though process of inelastic neutral current scattering on , for example , oxygen @xcite , deuterium @xcite , and carbon @xcite were also studied . in the last ten years or so , processes like neutrino - proton @xcite and neutrino - nucleus @xcite elastic scattering have also been looked at in detail . in particular , as pointed out long ago @xcite , there can be the process of coherent elastic neutrino - nucleus scattering ( cenns ) , for which there is a significant enhancement in the predicted number of events , increasing approximately as the square of the number of neutrons constituting the nuclei of the detector material . however , the typical kinetic energies of the recoil nucleus in the elastic neutrino - nucleus scattering are expected to be rather small , requiring detectors with low energy thresholds in the range of few kev to few tens of kev . no conventional neutrino detectors have such low thresholds . however , the detectors used in dark matter ( dm ) direct detection ( dd ) experiments designed to look for the weakly interacting massive particle ( wimp ) candidates of dm through nuclear recoil signals associated with wimp - nucleus scattering may have sufficiently low thresholds so as to be sensitive enough to detect the low energy nuclear recoil events associated with sn neutrinos @xcite . however , the presently operating dm detectors are not large enough to detect such neutrino events . only in context of planned future large ton scale detectors such possibilities would be viable . in the previous studies @xcite investigating the possibility of observing the cenns using various astrophysical neutrino sources and geoneutrinos predict interesting prospects . indeed , it is now well recognized that these cenns events due to astrophysical and terrestrial neutrinos can be a major source of background in dm search experiments @xcite . the detectors for dm dd , which are currently in operation or are under consideration , use a variety of different target materials . in order to optimize the possibility of detecting sn neutrinos using such detectors , it is important to study the process of coherent elastic scattering of @xmath0 mev energy neutrinos on various different target nuclei . for supernova neutrino detection the dm detectors may be particularly useful as the coherent elastic scattering is caused by all neutrino / antineutrino flavors as opposed to only the electron flavor neutrinos in cc processes @xcite . such coherent scatterings will give rise to a few events per @xmath1 of detector material for a galactic ( 10 kpc ) sn event compared to some hundreds of @xmath2 events per @xmath3 in cc based detectors . so with an order of magnitude increase in the number of events spread over only about 10 seconds , this needs serious consideration particularly for the future ton / multi - ton detectors . an important consideration for using dm detectors for sn neutrino detection is the excellent time resolutions of the dm detectors which can be in the region of @xmath0 10 ms . this offers the interesting possibility of studying the temporal structure of the neutrino emission from the sn . indeed , measuring the sn neutrino light curve will allow one to probe the standard sn model , which predicts three main phases of neutrino emission , namely , the neutronization burst phase , the accretion phase and the cooling phase . clear demarcation of these phases is extremely important as the flux and average energy of the emitted neutrinos are very different in these different phases . since the cenns process is flavor blind , the dm detectors can measure the total sn neutrino light curve , and thus will be complementary to the light curves of oscillated @xmath4 , @xmath5 flavors detected by other detectors through cc interactions . in order to derive realistic estimates of the expected number of sn @xmath6 events in a typical dm detector , it is important to use a reliable sn model that incorporates as much realistic physics of sn explosion and associated neutrino emission as possible . in this paper , we use the results from the basel / darmstadt simulations @xcite to study the detectability of sn neutrinos in dm detectors employing various different detector materials , and also study the possibility of demarcating the different phases of the neutrino emission from the sn using these detectors . it may be mentioned here that the average energies of the emitted neutrinos given by the basel / darmstadt simulations are typically lower than those given by earlier simulations ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . consequently , we find somewhat lower ( by about a factor of 2 ) number of events compared to earlier estimates @xcite . this paper is organized as follows : in section [ sec : neu - nuc - coherent ] , we briefly review the cenns process . there , for the purpose of illustration , we also calculate the expected event rates in dm detectors with different target materials , for the case of a guaranteed source of astrophysical neutrinos , namely , the @xmath7 solar neutrinos . section [ sec : snevents ] contains the main new results of this paper , where we estimate the expected number of events from a future galactic sn in dm detectors with different target materials and discuss the possibility of detecting the different phases of the neutrino emission . we further discuss the possibility of extracting the temperature of the non electron neutrinos in the sn neutrino flux . finally , section [ sec : summary ] summarizes the main results of this paper . the differential cross section for the process of coherent elastic neutrino - nucleus scattering is given by @xcite @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the neutrino energy , @xmath10 is the recoil nucleus kinetic energy , @xmath11 is the weak nuclear charge for a nucleus with @xmath12 neutrons and @xmath13 protons , @xmath14 is the mass of the nucleus with mass number @xmath15 and @xmath16 is the average nucleon mass . the form factor , @xmath17 ( with normalization @xmath18 , @xmath19 being the 4-momentum transfer to the nucleus ) , represents the loss of coherence at high recoil energies when @xmath20 , @xmath21 being the magnitude of the 3-momentum transfer , and @xmath22 the radius of the nucleus . the maximum kinetic energy of the recoil nucleus is @xmath23 for @xmath24 . in the limit of complete coherence ( @xmath25 ) , the cross section ( [ eq : coherent_xsec ] ) varies approximately as the square of the number of neutrons in the nucleus . in the following analysis , for @xmath17 we use the helm form factor with the parametrization given in @xcite . the differential nuclear recoil event rate is given by @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the differential neutrino flux incident on the detector and @xmath28 is the minimum neutrino energy required to give a recoil kinetic energy of @xmath10 to the nucleus . the cenns process has not yet been observed . to illustrate the kind of event rates one may expect in typical dm detectors , with astrophysical sources of neutrinos , we display in figure [ fig : solar_nu ] the expected event rates as a function of the recoil energy ( i.e. , the recoil energy spectrum ) for the case of a guaranteed source of astrophysical neutrinos , namely , the solar @xmath29 neutrinos , and for three different target nuclei constituting the detector material , namely , @xmath30 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 . the event rates shown in figure [ fig : solar_nu ] do not take into account the energy resolution of the detector . to illustrate the dependence on the threshold recoil energy of the detector , the right panel of figure [ fig : solar_nu ] shows the integral recoil energy spectra above a threshold recoil energy as a function of the recoil energy . it is clear that future ton - scale dm detectors have good prospects for detecting a neutrino source such as the @xmath33b solar neutrinos through neutrino - nucleus elastic scattering in a few years of running . detection of neutrinos from sn 1987a @xcite established beyond doubt that some supernova explosions are associated with emission of large number of neutrinos . according to the present understanding of core collapse supernovae , as the core of a large star starts to collapse after the nuclear fuel gets exhausted , the density in the inner core region at some point goes beyond the nuclear matter density . in the earlier stages of the collapse , the neutronization of matter produces @xmath34 s , but later at very large densities both neutrinos and antineutrinos of all three flavors ( i.e. @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath36 , @xmath37 , @xmath38 and @xmath39 ) get produced in much larger numbers . almost all the enormous energy released in the gravitational contraction , roughly a few times @xmath40 ergs , comes out through the emission of these neutrinos over a timescale of @xmath0 10 seconds . as already mentioned , the cenns process being flavor blind will be sensitive to @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 , @xmath44 ( hereafter collectively referred to as @xmath45 ) in addition to @xmath34 and @xmath46 . this will allow a direct estimation of the total energy emitted in neutrinos in the sn process . combined with information about @xmath34 and/or @xmath46 event rates for the same sn event in other ( conventional cc ) detectors , this would then allow one to estimate the average @xmath45 energies emitted in the sn event . while exploring these possibilities one has to be careful , however , as the sn neutrino properties like average energy , luminosity and energy distribution change with the post - bounce time . there are three important stages of neutrino emission in sn : the neutronization burst phase , the accretion phase and the cooling phase . in figure [ fig : lum_av_energy_time_profile ] the luminosities and average energies of different neutrino flavors for the different phases are shown for the basel / darmstadt simulation . progenitor sn . ] the neutronization burst phase , which is associated with the deleptonization of the outer core layers during shock breakout , lasts for about 50 ms post - bounce and is characterized by a sharp peak in the electron neutrino luminosity with little contribution from other flavors . this is followed by the accretion phase which is powered by infalling matter , and lasts for about 0.5 second . during this phase the electron neutrino contribution to luminosity gets reduced and the contributions from other species start building up . finally , we have the cooling phase , which lasts for about 10 seconds , when all the six species diffuse out of the core . more than 80 percent of the total energy emitted in the sn event comes out during this cooling phase . the luminosities of all the neutrino species in the cooling phase show an approximately exponential decrease with time whereas their average energies show a slow linear decrease . from the above it is clear that the expected number of events in the different emission phases will be different due to different luminosities of the emitted neutrinos during these phases . therefore , measuring the temporal structure of the detected events will be crucial for extracting the energy spectra of the emitted neutrinos . note also that the flavor oscillation properties during the different phases will also be different because of different physical conditions during the phases . [ [ sn - neutrino - emission - spectra ] ] sn neutrino emission spectra : for the initial neutrino distribution in energy and time , we use the outputs from the simulation mentioned above @xcite . we factorize the time and energy dependence as @xmath47 for each flavor ( @xmath48 ) . here @xmath49 represents the neutrino emission rate ( number of @xmath6 s per unit time ) with mean neutrino energy @xmath50 . the time variations of the luminosity and the average energy are taken from the simulations . we use the following parametrization of the instantaneous normalized ( @xmath51 ) energy spectrum @xmath52 from ref . @xcite : @xmath53\ , . \label{eq : varphi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath54 is the energy - shape parameter @xcite and is also extracted from the simulations . note that all parameter values used in the present work correspond to the luminosities and average energies of the various neutrino species corresponding to the basel / darmstadt simulations for a standard 18@xmath55 progenitor , as shown in figure [ fig : lum_av_energy_time_profile ] . having specified the energy and time dependence of the emitted neutrino spectra , we now study the possibility of detecting the neutrinos from the early emission phases in a typical dm detector . for our calculations below we conservatively take the time resolution of the detector to be @xmath0 10 ms . typical future dm detectors are expected to have even better time resolution . so our results presented here should be considered as conservative . [ [ neutronization - burst ] ] neutronization burst : the sn shock while moving outward through the iron core of the sn dissociates the iron nuclei , thereby producing free protons and neutrons . the subsequent electron capture by nuclei and free protons gives rise to a large @xmath4 flux , which is emitted in a ` burst ' when the shock breaks out of the neutrinosphere . this deleptonization `` neutronizes '' the sn environment . the burst peak shown in figure [ fig : lum_av_energy_time_profile ] is fairly independent of the details of the sn models such as electron capture rates , nuclear equation of state and the progenitor mass . in fact , the neutronization burst phase is considered as the standard neutrino candle " for the core - collapse supernovae scenario , and thus serves as one of the most sensitive probes of the physics of neutrino oscillation @xcite and nonstandard physics @xcite . since the @xmath4 burst phase ends within the first 50 ms , with the time resolution of about 10 ms the future dm detectors may have a fair possibility of detecting the neutronization burst phase neutrinos . for illustration , the left panel of figure [ fig : nue - burst - accretion ] shows the expected number of events in 10 ms time bins in xe detectors of different total target mass for a basel / darmstadt sn model ( see figure [ fig : lum_av_energy_time_profile ] ) at a distance of 10 kpc from the earth . xe is chosen for this illustration as it offers a relatively large @xmath56 enhancement of the cenns cross section . it is clear from figure [ fig : nue - burst - accretion ] that identification of the neutronization burst phase neutrinos will require greater than 10 ton mass xe detectors . for example , a 100-ton xe detector should be able to detect the signature of the neutronization burst phase through neutrinos . the estimated numbers of events shown in figure [ fig : nue - burst - accretion ] assume a zero background and a small ( 0.1 kev ) threshold recoil energy of the detector . the backgrounds in typical direct dm detectors generally have negligible time variation , and the sn events will arrive in a relatively small time window ( @xmath0 10 seconds ) , like a pile on the near constant background . moreover , the background from other neutrino sources like the solar and atmospheric neutrinos in this small time window would be negligible @xcite compared to the galactic sn neutrino flux . so , the background may not be an issue . however the threshold recoil energy of the detector will be important for determining the minimum required target mass of the detector for detection of the sn neutrinos . note also that the estimated number of events are for a sn at a distance of 10 kpc ; the numbers will scale as the inverse square of the distance to the sn . [ [ accretion - phase ] ] accretion phase : the sn shock loses energy as it moves outward through the iron core , finally to stall at around few 100 km from the center of the star . at that point , matter starts accreting on to the core , giving increased neutrino emission . this process results in the typical accretion hump in the neutrino luminosity seen in all sn simulations . the infalling material as it accretes onto the core is heated to high temperatures thereby allowing electron - positron annihilation resulting in production of neutrinos of all flavors . due to high degeneracy of @xmath4 and electron during deleptonization , the production of @xmath5 is initially suppressed compared to @xmath45 . however , the @xmath5 flux starts growing after the initial deleptonization phase ceases as the cc processes ( electron and positron captures on free nucleons ) start becoming more efficient . interestingly , the @xmath45 , which can be produced only via neutral current processes , can not catch up with the @xmath5 and @xmath4 . moreover , being less strongly coupled with the environment compared to the electron flavors , the @xmath45s diffuse out much more swiftly from the sn core than do @xmath4 and @xmath5 . hence , @xmath45 luminosities remain lower than those of @xmath5 and @xmath4 . this large flux hierarchy between the initial @xmath4 , @xmath5 and @xmath45 flux provides excellent opportunity for studying oscillation physics @xcite with cc based detectors . however , again , the cenns being flavor blind the detectors will measure the total neutrino flux and should be able to observe the accretion hump independent of the oscillation scenario . like in the case of the neutronization burst @xmath4s , in combination with results from cc based detectors , the detection of the accretion hump neutrinos in a dm detector will offer an important probe of any new physics and also of the standard sn scenario . the right panel of figure [ fig : nue - burst - accretion ] shows the expected number of events due to accretion phase neutrinos in 50 ms time bins in xe detectors of different total target mass , again for a sn at a distance of 10 kpc from the earth . as in the case of neutronization burst phase neutrinos , we have assumed zero background and a threshold recoil energy of 0.1 kev for the detector . evidently , while a 1-ton xe detector will not be good enough , a 10-ton xe detector , for example , should be able to pick out the temporal profile of the signal . obviously , a closer sn offers a better detection possibility . clearly , more detailed analysis , including proper optimization of the time bin size , threshold recoil energy as well as energy resolution of the detector will be required to have accurate estimation of the required detector mass . [ [ different - materials ] ] different materials : our discussions so far were concerned with xe as the detector target material . however , dm detectors use a variety of other materials . to study the suitability of relatively lower mass number nuclei for sn @xmath6 detection , below we consider the cases of fluorine and silicon , which are also used in dm dd experiments . here , again , we use the same basel / darmstadt sn neutrino fluxes as described above for a sn at a distance of 10 kpc . we optimize the required detector mass so that the neutronization burst phases events are are detectable . the condition used is that the detector mass should be large enough so that the lower limits of the predicted number of events including the statistical fluctuations are above zero for the first five 10-ms time bins during the neutronization burst . we find that , with this criterion for f and si , one would require at least 60 and 50 ton mass detectors , respectively , for detecting the neutronization burst phase neutrinos . as expected the required minimum detector masses are larger compared to that for xe ( see figure [ fig : nue - burst - accretion ] ) . a somewhat better prospect for detection is offered by the accretion phase neutrinos , which is shown in figure [ fig : sn - f - si ] assuming , again , zero background and a recoil energy threshold of 0.1 kev . notice that the accretion hump is visible in both cases . [ [ recoil - energy - spectra ] ] recoil energy spectra : although demarcation of the temporal profiles ( the light curve ) of the different neutrino emission phases would , as discussed above , require at least a 10 ton xe detector , a smaller , 1 ton detector would be good enough to detect a galactic sn event . figure [ fig : sn - xe ] shows the expected recoil energy spectra ( event rate as a function of the recoil energy ) in a 1 ton xe detector for a sn at a distance of 10 kpc . for comparison , in addition to the basel / darmstadt sn model considered throughout this paper ( see figure [ fig : lum_av_energy_time_profile ] ) , we also show in figure [ fig : sn - xe ] the event rate expected for a neutrino flux parametrization with average energies of 10 , 12 and 18 mev for @xmath4 , @xmath5 and @xmath45 , respectively , for the entire duration of the sn neutrino emission as used in previous studies ( see , e.g. , ref . @xcite ) . evidently , the larger @xmath45 average energy used in earlier studies yielded more expected number of events compared to those for the recent basel / darmstadt simulations . the relatively larger average energies quoted in many previous studies represent the early accretion phase of the sn . the average energies in the accretion phase are expected to be larger than those in the cooling phase . thus , using the larger average energies for the entire sn duration would give larger number of events . we find , for the basel / darmstadt sn model , the total number of events are reduced by about a factor of two compared to earlier estimates @xcite . note , the recent results @xcite from the same basel / darmstadt group shows a larger flux difference of different flavors compare to the their old simulation results @xcite . however , even the new differences are way too smaller compare to the very large average energy simulations of @xcite and thus the overall results remain robust under the new simulations @xcite as well . as clear from the above figures , the main contribution to the event rates comes from recoil energies below 1 kev . hence only detectors with relatively low recoil energy threshold @xmath57 will have a reasonable chance of detecting the sn neutrinos . on the optimistic side , however , since the event rates scale as the inverse square of the distance to the sn , some of the potential sn candidates , such as betelgeuse , mira ceti and antares , which are relatively close by stars ( at @xmath58 kpc ) , offer interesting possibilities for the next generation dm detectors . [ [ extracting - the - nu_x - properties ] ] extracting the @xmath45 properties : finally , we mention an important by - product of measuring the sn neutrino recoil energy spectrum . for the four non - electron flavor neutrinos / antineutrinos , @xmath59 , there are two physical quantities of great interest , namely , their time - averaged temperature and the total energy they carry . whereas the neutral current reactions in conventional neutrino detectors can give information on their total number , measurement of the recoil spectrum for the cenns events in dm detectors can in principle give information about the energy spectra of the neutrinos . beacom , farr and vogel @xcite pointed out in connection with neutrino - proton elastic scattering of sn neutrinos in scintillation detectors like kamland that one can get estimates of the total neutrino energy as well as the temperature from the observed proton energy spectra . though these two observables are strongly correlated , a monte carlo simulation procedure as suggested in ref . @xcite may allow one to extract estimates of these two quantities from the observed nuclear recoil spectra in the case of cenns in dm detectors . of course , this is possible when the distance of the sn is known independently . otherwise , like in @xcite , one can obtain an estimate of the neutrino temperature by marginalizing over the unknown total energy . since currently there is no observational handle available on the temperature " of the @xmath45 emitted from sne , the possibility of measuring the sn @xmath45 temperature in dm detectors through the cenns process is certainly worth exploring . in figure [ fig : sn - xe - nux ] we plot the flavor composition of the expected recoil energy spectra for the accretion phase neutrinos of a basel / darmstadt sn at 10 kpc from earth in a 10 ton xe detector . the main contribution to the event rate comes from @xmath60 as they have larger average energies and also because it is a sum of contributions from four species of neutrinos . the curves shown in figure [ fig : sn - xe - nux ] include flavor oscillation which is primarily due to msw effect since the collective effects are considered matter suppressed @xcite during the accretion phase . in the cooling phase more complex scenarios of oscillations may arise which are not very well understood @xcite and the flux expressions would be complicated @xcite . hence we focus on the accretion phase where the oscillation scenario seems settled . the flux differences due to different neutrino mass hierarchies are , however , not resolvable even in the multi ton detectors . these curves shown in figure [ fig : sn - xe - nux ] are for the case of inverted hierarchy . as already shown in figure [ fig : nue - burst - accretion ] , a 10-ton xe detector should be able to distinguish the accretion phase by measuring the temporal profile of the neutrinos . thus the measurement of the recoil energy spectrum together with the temporal profile of the events in a 10-ton xe detector , for example , may indeed allow a measurement of the temperature " of the bulk of the neutrinos emitted during the main accretion phase of a sn event . in this paper we have studied the possibility of observing supernova neutrinos through the process of coherent elastic neutrino - nucleus scattering in next generation detectors for direct detection of dark matter . in doing this we have used the predicted neutrino flux from the recent basel / darmstadt simulations , which incorporate more realistic supernova physics than those used in earlier simulation models . we find that our estimated total event rates are typically a factor of 2 lower than those estimated in earlier studies using older simulation models . we have also studied the possibility of distinguishing the various phases of neutrino emission from the supernova through measurement of the temporal profile of the detected events . there we find that , with optimistic assumptions on the detector s time resolution ( @xmath0 10 ms ) and energy threshold ( @xmath0 0.1 kev ) , the neutrinos associated with the accretion phase of the sn at 10 kpc from earth can in principle be demarcated out with , for example , a 10-ton xe detector , although distinguishing the neutrinos associated with the neutronization burst phase of the explosion would typically require several tens of ton detectors . we also noted that the dm detectors being flavor blind are sensitive to all the neutrino flavors including the non - electron flavor neutrinos , and thus have the potential to constrain possible non - standard physics of neutrino flavor oscillation . finally , we have explored the possibility of measuring the temperature of the non - electron flavor neutrinos which are inaccessible through other charge current based detectors . we are grateful to tobias fisher and collaborators for providing the supernova data . we thank rupak mahapatra for discussions on the time resolution of the direct dark matter experiments . one of us ( pb ) wishes to thank ramanath cowsik for hospitality and support under the clark way harrison visiting professorship program at the mcdonnell center for the space sciences at washington university in st . kk thanks abhijit chakrabarti for help . sc acknowledges support by a marie - curie - fellowship of the european community . sc also thank the cosmology and astroparticle division of saha institute of nuclear physics for kind hospitality and support during the initial phase of the project . k. scholberg , ann . nucl . part . sci . * 62 * , 81 ( 2012 ) . t. fischer , s. c. whitehouse , a. mezzacappa , f. -k . thielemann and m. liebendorfer , astron . astrophys . * 517 * , a80 ( 2010 ) . t. totani , k. sato , h. e. dalhed and j. r. wilson , astrophys . j. * 496 * , 216 ( 1998 ) . | the possibility of observing supernova ( sn ) neutrinos through the process of coherent elastic neutrino - nucleus scattering ( cenns ) in future ton scale detectors designed primarily for direct detection of dark matter is investigated . in particular , we focus on the possibility of distinguishing the various phases of the sn neutrino emission . the neutrino emission rates from the recent long term basel / darmstadt simulations are used to calculate the expected event rates . the recent state - of - the - art sn simulations predict closer fluxes among different neutrino flavors and lower average energies compared to the earlier simulation models . we find that our estimated total event rates are typically a factor of two lower than those predicted using older simulation models . we further find that , with optimistic assumptions on the detector s time resolution ( @xmath0 10 ms ) and energy threshold ( @xmath0 0.1 kev ) , the neutrinos associated with the accretion phase of the sn can in principle be demarcated out with , for example , a 10-ton xe detector , although distinguishing the neutrinos associated with the neutronization burst phase of the explosion would typically require several tens of ton detectors . we also comment on the possibility of studying the properties of non - electron flavor neutrinos from the cenns of sn neutrinos . |
1609.07095 | in his 1939 paper @xcite , wigner considered the subgroups of the lorentz group whose transformations leave the four - momentum of a given particle invariant . these subgroups are called wigner s little groups and dictate the internal space - time symmetries in the lorentz - covariant world . he observed first that a massive particle at rest has three rotational degree of freedom leading to the concept of spin . thus the little group for the massive particle is like o(3 ) . wigner observed also that a massless particle can not be brought to its rest frame , but he showed that the little group for the massless particle also has three degrees of freedom , and that this little is locally isomorphic to the group e(2 ) or the two - dimensional euclidean group . this means that the generators of this little group share the same set of closed commutation relations with that for two - dimensional euclidean group with one rotational and two translational degrees of freedom . it is not difficult to associate the rotational degree of freedom of e(2 ) to the helicity of the massless particle however , what is the physics of the those two translational degrees of freedom ? wigner did not provide the answer to this question in his 1939 paper @xcite . indeed , this question has a stormy history and the issue was not completely settled until 1990 @xcite , fifty one years after 1939 . in this report , it is noted first that the lorentz group has six generators . among them , three of them generate the rotation subgroup . it is also possible to construct three generators which constitute a closed set of commutations relations identical to that for the e(2 ) group . however , it is also possible to construct the cylindrical group with one rotational degree of freedom and two degrees freedom both leading to up - down translational degrees freedom . these two translational degrees freedom correspond to one gauge degree of freedom for the massless particle @xcite . while the o(3)-like and e(2)-like little groups are different , it is possible to derive the latter as a lorentz - boosted o(3)-like little group in the infinite - momentum limit . it is shown then that the two rotational degrees of freedom perpendicular momentum become one gauge degree of freedom @xcite . it is noted that the e(2)-like symmetry for the massless spin-1 particle leads to its helicity and gauge degree of freedom . likewise , there is a gauge degree of freedom for the massless spin-1/2 particle . however , the requirement of gauge invariance leads to the polarization of massless neutrinos @xcite . in sec . [ little ] , we introduce wigner s little groups for massive and massless particles . in sec . [ o3e2 ] , it is shown that the e(2)-like little group for massless particles can be obtained as the infinite - momentum limit of the o(3)-like little group . in sec . [ spinhalf ] , the same logic is developed for spin - half particles . it is shown that the polarization of massless neutrinos is a consequence of gauge invariance . if we use the four - vector convention @xmath0 , the generators of rotations around and boosts along the @xmath1 axis take the form @xmath2 respectively . we can also write the four - by - four matrices for @xmath3 and @xmath4 for the rotations around the @xmath5 and @xmath6 directions , as well as @xmath7 and @xmath8 for lorentz boosts along the @xmath5 and @xmath6 directions respectively @xcite . these six generators satisfy the following set of commutation relations . @xmath9 = i\epsilon_{ijk } j_{k } , \qquad \left[j_{i } , k_{j}\right ] = i\epsilon_{ijk } k_{k } , \qquad \left[k_{i } , k_{j}\right ] = -i\epsilon_{ijk } j_{k}.\ ] ] this closed set of commutation relations is called the lie algebra of the lorentz group . the three @xmath10 operators constitute a closed subset of this lie algebra . thus , the rotation group is a subgroup of the lorentz group . in addition , wigner in 1939 @xcite considered a group generated by @xmath11 these generators satisfy the closed set of commutation relations @xmath12 = 0 , \qquad \left[j_{3 } , n_{1}\right ] = in_{2 } , \qquad \left[j_{3 } , n_{2}\right ] = -in_{1}.\ ] ] group and the cylindrical group . they share the same lie algebra , but only the cylindrical group leads to a geometrical interpretation of the gauge transformation . ] as wigner observed in 1939 @xcite , this set of commutation relations is just like that for the generators of the two - dimensional euclidean group with one rotation and two translation generators , as illustrated in fig . [ cylin ] . however , the question is what aspect of the massless particle can be explained in terms of this two - dimensional geometry . indeed , this question has a stormy history , and was not answered until 1987 . in their paper of 1987 @xcite , kim and wigner considered the surface of a circular cylinder as shown in fig . [ cylin ] . for this cylinder , rotations are possible around the @xmath1 axis . it is also possible to make translations along the @xmath1 axis as shown in fig . [ cylin ] . we can write these generators as @xmath13 applicable to the three - dimensional space of @xmath14 they then satisfy the closed set of commutation relations @xmath15 = 0 , \qquad \left[l_{3 } , q_{1}\right ] = iq_{2 } , \qquad \left[l_{3 } , q_{2}\right ] = -iq_{1}.\ ] ] which becomes that of eq.([eq200 ] ) when @xmath16 and @xmath17 are replaced by @xmath18 and @xmath19 of eq.([eq005 ] ) respectively . indeed , this cylindrical group is locally isomorphic to wigner s little group for massless particles . let us go back to the generators of eq.([eq005 ] ) . the role of @xmath19 is well known . it is generates rotations around the momentum and corresponds to the helicity of the massless particle . the @xmath20 and @xmath21 matrices take the form @xcite @xmath22 the transformation matrix is @xmath23 & { } & \hspace{20 mm } = \pmatrix{1 & 0 & -u & u \cr 0 & 1 & -v & v \cr u & v & 1 - ( u^{2}+ v^{2})/2 & ( u^{2 } + v^{2})/2 \cr u & v & -(u^{2 } + v^{2})/2 & 1 + ( u^{2 } + v^{2})/2 } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] if this matrix is applied to the electromagnetic wave propagating along the @xmath1 direction , @xmath24 which satisfies the lorentz condition @xmath25 , the @xmath26 matrix can be reduced to @xcite @xmath27 if @xmath25 , the four - vector @xmath28 can be written as @xmath29 with @xmath30 . the four - vector @xmath31 represents the four - momentum . if the @xmath32 matrix of eq.([eq109 ] ) is applied to the above four vector , the result is @xmath33 with @xmath34 . thus the @xmath32 matrix performs a gauge transformation when applied to the electromagnetic wave propagating along the @xmath1 direction @xcite . from the generators of the lorentz group , it is possible to construct the four - by - four matrices for rotations around the @xmath6 axis and lorentz boosts along the @xmath1 axis as @xcite @xmath35 respectively . the lorentz - boosted rotation matrix is @xmath36 which can be written as @xmath37 while @xmath38 , this boosted rotation matrix becomes a transformation matrix for a massless particle when @xmath39 becomes infinite . on the other hand , it the matrix is to be finite in this limit , the angle @xmath40 has to become small . let us set @xmath41 then this four - by - four matrix becomes @xmath42 this is the lorentz - boosted rotation matrix around the @xmath6 axis . however , we can rotate this @xmath6 axis around the @xmath1 axis by @xmath43 . then the matrix becomes @xmath44 this matrix becomes @xmath26 of eq.([eq101 ] ) , if we let @xmath45 let us go back to the lie algebra of the lorentz group given in eq.([eq002 ] ) . it was noted that there are six four - by - four matrices satisfying nine commutation relations . it is possible to construct the same lie algebra with six two - by - two matrices @xcite . they are @xmath46 where @xmath47 are the pauli spin matrices . while @xmath10 are hermitian , @xmath48 are not . they are anti - hermitian . since the lie algebra of eq.([eq002 ] ) is hermitian invariant , we can construct the same lie algebra with @xmath49 this is the reason why the four - by - four dirac matrices can explain both the spin-1/2 particle and the anti - particle . here again the @xmath10 matrices generate the rotation - like @xmath50 subgroup . here also we can consider the @xmath51-like subgroup generated by @xmath52 the @xmath20 and @xmath21 matrices take the form @xmath53 on the other hand , in the `` dotted '' representation , @xmath54 there are therefore two different @xmath32 matrices : @xmath55 and @xmath56 these are the gauge transformation matrices applicable to massless spin-1/2 particles @xcite . the spinors @xmath59 and @xmath60 are gauge - invariant since @xmath61 as for @xmath62 and @xmath63 , @xmath64 & { } & \dot{d}(u , v ) \dot{\chi}_{+ } = \dot{\chi}_{+ } + ( u + iv)\dot{\chi}_{- } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] they are not gauge invariant . thus , we can conclude that the polarization of massless neutrinos is a consequence of gauge invariance . if @xmath39 becomes very large , and this matrix is to remain finite , @xmath40 has to become very small , and this expression becomes @xmath68 with @xmath69 as given in eq.([gamma ] ) . this expression becomes @xmath70 in this two - by - two representation , the rotation around the @xmath1 axis is @xmath71 respectively . thus @xmath72 which becomes @xmath73 with @xmath74 and @xmath75 given in eq.([eq602 ] ) . we have studied how the massive neutrino with its o(3)-like symmetry to become the massless neutrino in the massless limit . the boost parameter @xmath39 can be derived from the mass and momentum of the massive neutrino from @xmath76 where @xmath77 and @xmath78 are the mass and the momentum of the neutrino respectively . for small values of @xmath79 , @xmath80 which becomes large when @xmath77 becomes very small . the question is then the reverse process @xcite . start from the massless neutrino with its gauge degree of freedom . what happens when the particle gains its mass ? in that case , the particle can be brought to its rest frame ? the matrix of eq.([eq607 ] ) is one way to bring it the rest frame , and @xmath81 becomes @xmath82 . however , what happens when @xmath81 is larger than one ? this is a challenging future question . | wigner s little groups are subgroups of the lorentz group dictating the internal space - time symmetries of massive and massless particles . these little groups are like o(3 ) and e(2 ) for massive and massless particles respectively . while the geometry of the o(3 ) symmetry is familiar to us , the geometry of the flat plane can not explain the e(2)-like symmetry for massless particles . however , the geometry of a circular cylinder can explain the symmetry with the helicity and gauge degrees of freedom . it is shown further that the symmetry of the massless particle can be obtained as a zero - mass limit of o(3)-like symmetry for massive particles . it is shown further that the polarization of massless neutrinos is a consequence of gauge invariance , while the symmetry of massive neutrinos is still like o(3 ) . * symmetries of massive and massless neutrinos * y. s. kim + center for fundamental physics , university of maryland , + college park , maryland 20742 , u.s.a . + e - mail : [email protected] + presented at the international conference on hadron structure and qcd : from low to high energies ( gatchina , russia , 2016 ) |
cond-mat0204086 | the behaviour of dilute bose - einstein condensates in multi - well potentials is remarkably rich . the tunnelling of a condensate through an optical lattice potential @xcite provides an atomic physics analogue of a josephson junction array . in principle , the analogue of a single josephson junction can be realised experimentally by a condensate in a double - well potential @xcite , and this system has attracted considerable theoretical interest @xcite . however , the experimental observation of the transition between the dc and ac josephson effects is challenging because the small energy splitting associated with josephson oscillations means that thermal or quantum fluctuations will tend to destroy the effect even at the lowest achievable temperatures @xcite . while the energy splitting can be increased by lowering the barrier height , it then becomes comparable with that of higher - lying states , and the accuracy of a two - mode approximation to describe the system @xcite becomes questionable . in this paper , we investigate the josephson dynamics of a dilute bose - einstein condensate in a double - well potential , by considering transitions between energy eigenstates . we show that in the regime of most interest for experiments where the energy splittings are large , the influence of higher - lying states can not be ignored . the paper is organised as follows . first , we calculate the eigenenergies of the double - well potential as a function of the barrier position . we show that in the vicinity of a level crossing the non - linearity leads to triangular structures in the eigenenergy curves . similar structures have been shown to occur in a non - linear landau - zener model @xcite , and near the zone boundary in optical lattices @xcite . next we review the two - state model @xcite , and show that as long as the influence of higher - lying states is small , the level structure can be reproduced using three parameters determined by numerical solution of the time - independent gross - pitaevskii equation . finally in section [ sec : dynamics ] we consider the time - dependent evolution as the barrier is moved , and analyse the transition between dc and ac tunnelling in terms of transitions between eigenstates . the eigenenergies of the double - well potential , @xmath0 , are found by numerical solution of the one - dimensional ( 1d ) gross - pitaevskii ( gp ) equation @xmath1 here @xmath2 is the self interaction parameter , @xmath3 is the @xmath4-wave scattering length , and @xmath5 is the number of atoms per unit area in the @xmath6 plane . distance , time and energy are measured in terms of the standard harmonic oscillator units ( h.o.u . ) , @xmath7 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 , respectively . in particular , we have concentrated on a system confined by the potential @xmath10~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] describing a harmonic trap with a gaussian potential barrier with height @xmath11 and unit width . we have also carried out three - dimensional simulations , and verified that the essential physics is described by a 1d model . this model facilitates an exploration of a wide range of values of the self - interaction , @xmath12 , barrier height , @xmath11 , and barrier velocity . time - independent states of the form , @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the chemical potential , are found by numerical solution of the discretized system of equations , @xmath15 where @xmath16 is a real function , and @xmath17 is the grid spacing . note that in general , one must solve for both the real and imaginary parts of @xmath18 @xcite . since @xmath14 is also a variable we have @xmath5 equations and @xmath19 unknowns . an additional equation is provided by fixing the normalisation of the wave function , @xmath20 a solution is found iteratively by linearising equations ( [ eq : dgp ] ) and ( [ eq : norm ] ) ( with @xmath21 ) @xmath22^{(p ) } \approx 0~ , \label{eq : lin}\ ] ] where @xmath23 is determined from the approximation @xmath24 by solving ( [ eq : lin ] ) using the bi - conjugate gradient method @xcite . the iterative solution depends on the symmetry of the initial trial wave function @xmath25 . for example , to find the lowest energy excited state we begin with a ground state solution at @xmath26 and change the parity . higher lying excited states can be found by beginning with an excited state solution of the harmonic trap and moving the barrier in from the side . in fig . [ fig : eh12 ] we show the eigenenergies of the ground level @xmath12 and the first and second excited levels , @xmath27 and @xmath28 , as a function of the barrier position @xmath29 with @xmath30 and @xmath31 . a triangular structure appears in the upper level at each level crossing . for states @xmath12 and @xmath27 this structure is essentially the same as that discussed by wu and niu in the context of a non - linear two - state model @xcite . the three states in the triangular region correspond to an anti - symmetric state with the population balanced between the two wells , and two higher energy states with most of the population in either the lower or the upper well . the higher energy states are referred to as self - trapping states @xcite . any dissipative mechanism that damps the system towards the ground state will tend to destroy self - trapping , as pointed out in refs . @xcite . for small @xmath29 the energy of the ground state is almost independent of the barrier position . this is because the transfer of atoms through the barrier exactly compensates for the change in potential energy . however , this can not continue when all the atoms reach one side and the energy becomes strongly position dependent again at the critical displacement , @xmath32 ( @xmath33 for the parameters in fig . 1 ) . at @xmath34 there is a second level crossing where it becomes energetically favourable for the first excited state @xmath27 to move from the upper to the lower well . the energy level structure is similar to that at @xmath26 , where it is the ground state population that moves from the upper to the lower well . in both cases , following the eigenenergy curve produces a large change or ` step ' in the well populations . when considering a moving barrier these steps give rise to a resonance in the tunnelling current . in section [ sec : dynamics ] , we suggest the optimal scheme for observing such tunnelling resonances . the energy splitting between the ground and lowest excited state is extremely small for @xmath31 , see fig . [ fig : eh12](inset ) . from an experimental viewpoint , lower barriers resulting in larger energy splittings are more interesting . in fig . [ fig : e1hdep ] we illustrate how the triangular structures evolve as a function of barrier height with @xmath30 . the appearance of the loop structure , which coincides with the threshold for self - trapping , occurs at critical height @xmath35 ( see section [ sec : eigen ] ) . the structure becomes more triangular as @xmath11 increases . in fig . [ fig : eh4cp5 ] we show the eigenenergies for @xmath30 and @xmath36 . in this case , the loop structure appears for the first but not the second excited state . the appearance of a loop structure results in the breakdown of adiabatic following of an eigenenergy curve @xcite . in section [ sec : dynamics ] , we will see that this breakdown is associated with a discontinuity in the population difference between the two wells . finally in fig . [ fig : eh4c5 ] , we illustrate the effect of increasing the self - interaction parameter to @xmath37 . in this case the energy splittings are a significant fraction of the harmonic oscillator energy level spacing and the critical displacement coincides with the position of the crossings between states @xmath27 and @xmath28 . in this regime , the influence of state @xmath28 can not be neglected , and a two - state approximation can not be used to describe the system . we stress that by solving the gross - pitaevskii equation in three dimensions we have obtained eigenenergy curves qualitatively similar to those shown in figs . [ fig : eh12 ] to [ fig : eh4c5 ] . in this section we review the two - state model @xcite , and apply it to the specific case of a bose - einstein condensate in an asymmetric double - well . the wave function , @xmath38 , is written as @xmath39 where the zeroth - order ( real ) mode functions @xmath40 , @xmath41 , are eigenfunctions of the time - independent gp equations @xmath42 the mode potentials @xmath43 and @xmath44 are single - well potentials displaced to the left and the right of @xmath45 , respectively , and satisfy @xmath46 so that @xmath47 . the time - dependent coefficients @xmath48 can , in turn , be expressed as @xmath49 where @xmath50 and @xmath51 are the population and phase of state @xmath52 , with @xmath53 . recalling that the two mode functions satisfy @xmath54 and redefining the zero of energy , we obtain the following non - linear equations of motion for @xmath55 : @xmath56 the non - linear hamiltonian matrix , @xmath57 , is given by @xmath58 \label{eqn : nlham}\ ] ] where @xmath59 is the population difference between the left and right sides of the well , and @xmath60 and @xmath61 are the coupling or josephson energy and the self - interaction energy , respectively . the self - interaction energy of each mode is @xmath62 and we define the shift in energy of the mode states due to the displacement of the potential barrier to be @xmath63 if states @xmath64 and @xmath65 correspond to the population on the left and right of the barrier , respectively , then linearising yields @xmath66 where @xmath67 is the rate of change of the energy with displacement . as will be discussed below , this linear approximation works well when the influence of higher - lying states is negligible . finally , the coupling energy of the two - modes is @xmath68 where use has been made of the fact that @xmath69 the hamiltonian , equation ( [ eqn : nlham ] ) , is similar to that considered by wu and niu in their study of non - linear landau - zener tunnelling @xcite . in the next section we discuss the eigenstates of @xmath70 in relation to the numerical solutions discussed in section [ sec : newton ] . within the two - state model , one may find the eigenenergies of the system by substituting @xmath71 . the eigenenergies are given by the roots of the quartic equation @xcite @xmath72 the population difference between the left and right wells is obtained from the eigenenergies via @xmath73 an important feature of equation ( [ eqn : roots ] ) is that there are four real roots when the coefficient of the quadratic term @xmath74 is positive and only two when it is negative . for a symmetric double - well ( @xmath75 ) , the additional roots appear at the critical point where the self - interaction energy satisfies @xmath76 . for @xmath77 , the eigenenergies of the stationary states are @xmath78 and @xmath79 , with the latter being doubly degenerate . the additional roots disappear if the displacement of the barrier is such that @xmath80 . to test the applicability of the two - state model , we have compared the eigenenergies with those determined from the numerical solution of the gp equation . the energy curves are parametrised by three numbers : the splitting between the two lower levels , which is equal to @xmath60 ; the energy of the self - trapping states , @xmath79 ; and an energy gradient , @xmath81 . in a two - state model , @xmath81 is both the energy gradient of the self - trapping state , and that of the ground state for @xmath82 . for small @xmath12 and high barriers , such that @xmath83 , @xmath84 . [ fig : model_e ] shows a comparison between the exact eigenenergies and the model curves for @xmath36 , @xmath30 . the values of @xmath61 , @xmath60 , and @xmath81 are taken from the exact solutions . the energy gradient is matched to that of the self - trapping states at @xmath26 ( @xmath85 ) . this value gives the best agreement when comparing population dynamics ( see section [ sec : dynamics ] ) . however , due to the slight curvature of the eigenenergy curves a smaller value ( @xmath86 ) gives a better fit to the triangular structure . the agreement between the two - state model and the exact eigenenergies becomes less good as the influence of higher - lying states increases . for example , the model does not predict the almost flat position dependence of the upper levels in @xmath27 for @xmath36 , @xmath37 , see fig . [ fig : eh4c5 ] . to apply the two - state model one needs to known the value of @xmath60 , @xmath61 and @xmath81 for any particular barrier height or non - linearity . in fig . [ fig : edep ] we show how the energy splittings vary with the non - linearity and the barrier height . the critical point , @xmath76 , appears as either a critical non - linearity or a critical height depending on which parameter is varied . note that for large non - linearity , the existence of the second excited state , @xmath28 , effectively puts an upper limit on the value of @xmath61 . in fig . [ fig : ndep ] , we show the left - right population difference of the self - trapping state . a population asymmetry appears at the critical point , @xmath76 , corresponding to the critical barrier height , @xmath35 for @xmath30 . the asymmetry increases with increasing barrier height . as a function of the non - linearity , the self - trapping population first increases , then saturates , and finally decreases at large @xmath12 due to the influence of @xmath28 . we now apply the eigenstate picture to analyse the population dynamics when the barrier is moved uniformly through the condensate at velocity @xmath87 . the time - dependent gp equation is integrated using a crank - nicholson algorithm and the time evolution analysed in terms of transitions between eigenstates . a similar approach was used previously to study vortex nucleation @xcite . in fig . [ fig : nh12 ] we show both the eigenstate population differences and the calculated evolution of the population difference as the barrier is moved from the canter towards the right at a speed @xmath88 ( bold line ) . this example is similar to the case studied in @xcite . the eigenstate population differences appear as straight diagonal lines . for low velocities , the evolution is adiabatic , and the time - dependent solution follows the ground state population difference curve resulting in a dc tunnelling current . above a critical velocity , there is a transition to a superposition of ground and excited states such that the population difference remains constant , apart from a decaying oscillatory component ( see inset ) . subsequently , the excited state component encounters a level crossing with higher - lying states which leads to further ` steps ' in the population difference or resonances in the tunnelling current . for the example of @xmath88 shown in fig . [ fig : nh12 ] , the speed is just below the critical velocity for the transition from @xmath28 to @xmath89 leading to a large tunnelling current as the object moves past @xmath90 . by defining @xmath91 , and rearranging equations ( [ eqn : coeff][eqn : nlham ] ) , one obtains the coupled equations @xmath92 @xmath93 differentiating again and substituting for @xmath94 and @xmath95 gives @xmath96 if @xmath97 is roughly constant , this equation may be re - written as @xmath98 , where @xmath99 describes a ` tilted - washboard ' potential . the critical velocity is determined by setting the minimum gradient of @xmath99 equal to zero . for @xmath100 at @xmath101 and using @xmath102 , one finds @xmath103 for @xmath83 , one can use the linear approximation , @xmath104 , where @xmath32 is the critical displacement , which yields @xmath105 . taking the values from fig . [ fig : eh12 ] , @xmath106 and @xmath33 , gives @xmath107 . according to equations ( [ eq : ndot ] ) and ( [ eq : thetadot ] ) the maximum population difference occurs at approximately @xmath108 , which is in excellent agreement with the value determined by numerical integration of the gp equation . as stated above , the small critical velocity for high barriers ( typically less than a micron per second ) makes experimental verification challenging . although higher critical velocities are obtained for lower barriers , the transition between the dc and ac regime becomes less sharp . this problem can be partially circumvented by noting that one can induce larger population changes by starting with an asymmetric well and moving the barrier back through the origin . this is illustrated in fig . [ fig : nh4cp5 ] with a lower barrier height , @xmath36 . again for low barrier speeds the population follows the ground state distribution , whereas for faster speeds a transition to an oscillatory current is observed . the critical velocity is a factor of 200 times larger than for @xmath31 . for @xmath109 the population difference follows that of the excited state , @xmath27 , therefore to observe a large population difference , it is important to stop the motion before the barrier reaches @xmath110 . this restricts the evolution to short times or low velocities . in fig . [ fig : nv ] we show the population difference as a function of the barrier speed for both a symmetric and asymmetric starting condition . [ fig : nv](a ) shows that the two - state model can no longer predict the correct result if the second level crossing is reached , which for @xmath111 occurs when @xmath112 . comparison between fig . [ fig : nv](a ) and ( b ) illustrates that a larger population difference and a better demarcation of the critical velocity is obtained by moving the barrier from the edge of the condensate inwards ( asymmetric initial condition ) . the numerical results indicate that the critical velocity for this case is similar to that for the symmetric initial state . however , it is not straightforward to predict the critical velocity for the asymmetric initial condition because the relative importance of the coefficients in equation ( [ eq : thetaddot ] ) depends on the instantaneous value of @xmath113 . for @xmath31 , @xmath30 , the critical velocity is a factor of three smaller than for the symmetric initial state . finally , we consider the interesting case where the influence of higher - lying states severely limits the applicability of the two - state model . in fig . [ fig : nh4c5 ] we show the population change as a barrier with height @xmath36 is moved through the centre of a condensate with @xmath37 . for these parameters the critical velocity is sufficiently high that the level crossing to a higher - lying state is reached before the transition to the ac regime is completed . however , a large population difference for different barrier velocities can still be observed if the motion is halted when the barrier reaches @xmath114 . the large critical velocity , @xmath115 , offers the best potential for the experimental observation of josephson - like tunnelling resonances . for example , taking a typical sodium condensate with a trap frequency of @xmath116 hz , the black and grey curves in fig . [ fig : nh4c5 ] correspond to a barrier formed by a blue detuned laser sheet with waist 3 microns , moved by 5 microns in 1.5 s and 1 s , respectively . for these parameters , a model involving higher - lying excited states is essential to give a clear picture of the josephson population dynamics . to restate the richness of the double - well system , it is worth noting that as one increases the non - linearity further , the transition from the ground to first excited state corresponds to the formation of a soliton . consequently by varying only two parameters , the barrier height and the interaction strength , for example using a feshbach resonance @xcite , one can explore the complete parameter space between josephson tunnelling and soliton formation . in summary , we have studied the eigenstates of a dilute bose - einstein condensates in an asymmetric double - well potential . we have shown that in the regime of interest for experiments , i.e. , with a large non - linearity and a low barrier , a two - state description is insufficient to describe the tunnelling dynamics . by determining the influence of higher - lying states we have demonstrated that large population differences can be observed if the barrier motion is halted before the upper tunnelling resonance is reached . we thank andrew macdonald whose preliminary study stimulated our interest in this problem . we would also like to thank the university of durham and the engineering and physical sciences research council ( epsrc ) for financial support . | the dynamics of a bose - einstein condensate in a double - well potential are analysed in terms of transitions between energy eigenstates . by solving the time - dependent and time - independent gross - pitaevskii equation in one dimension , we identify tunnelling resonances associated with level crossings , and determine the critical velocity that characterises the resonance . we test the validity of a non - linear two - state model , and show that for the experimentally interesting case , where the critical velocity is large , the influence of higher - lying states is important . |
1405.1212 | directive 2009/138/ec of the european parliament and of the council of 25 november 2009 on the taking - up and pursuit of the business of insurance and reinsurance ( solvency ii ) introduces new capital regimes on insurance companies . according to section 4 , article 101 , p. 3 : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the solvency capital requirement shall be calibrated so as to ensure that all quantifiable risks to which an insurance or reinsurance undertaking is exposed are taken into account . it shall cover existing business , as well as the new business expected to be written over the following 12 months . with respect to existing business , it shall cover only unexpected losses . it shall correspond to the value - at - risk of the basic own funds of an insurance or reinsurance undertaking subject to a confidence level of 99,5 % over a one - year period . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ further according to p. 4 : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the solvency capital requirement shall cover at least the following risks : \(a ) non - life underwriting risk ; \(b ) life underwriting risk ; \(c ) health underwriting risk ; \(d ) market risk ; \(e ) credit risk ; \(f ) operational risk . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the question imposed by this regulation is how much money is enough to hedge the risk with the probability 0.995 . what is important here from mathematical point of view , is that the risk here involves market and non - market factors , which means that it can not be dealt using just real expectations probability measure . this is usually neglected by insurance companies although this neglectance oposses widely accepted black - scholes approach . mathematically speaking we ask for minimal @xmath0 ensuring the probability of satysfying all the claims @xmath1\geq 0.995 $ ] , where @xmath3 denotes the contingent claim and @xmath4 denotes the value of hedging portfolio at time t. equivalently we can fix the capital look for strategy wieth maximal probability of successful hedging this problem was solved in literature only for complete markets ( besides sekine @xcite and klusik & palmowski @xcite ) , i.e for financial positions which do nt allow for typical insurance risk . foellmer & leukert @xcite investigate the general semimartingale setting . authors point out the optimal strategy for a complete market with maximal @xmath5 $ ] . the proofs are based on various versions of neymann - pearson lemma . spivak & cvitanic @xcite study a complete market framework of assets modelled with ito processes . they also constructed a strategy with maximal @xmath5 $ ] but using different proof methods . they also implement this technique for market with partial observations . finally they consider the case where the drift of the wealth process is a nonlinear ( concave ) function of the investment strategy of the agent . klusik , palmowski , zwierz @xcite solve the problem of the quantile hedging from the point of view of a better informed agent acting on the market . the additional knowledge of the agent is modelled by a filtration initially enlarged by some random variable . sekine @xcite considers a defaultable securities in very simple incomplete market , where security - holder can default at some random time and receives a payoff modelled by martingale process . author shows strategy maximizing the probability of successful hedge . the more complex incomplete market was considered by klusik & palmowski @xcite . they consider the equity - linked product where the insurance event can take a finite numer of states and is independent on financial asset modelled with geometric brownian motion . they construct optimal strategy for both : maximal probability and maximal expected success ratio . in their framework the knowledge about the insurance event is not revealed before the maturity . in this paper we state a general problem of optimizing probability of non - insolvency @xmath5 $ ] in a incomplete market , as in klusik & palmowski @xcite , but we allow very general flow of information outside the market and very general space of possible non - market events . as it was said at the beginning the solution of this problem gives a solution to solvency ii problem . in fact the solution could be used not only for solvency ii , but also for pricing instruments in incomplete markets . this would include equity - linked or options on illiquid assets or traded only over - the - counter . the replicating strategy can not be built in such case . it may suggest to price the option as an expectation in subjective probability measure or as the cost of superhedging ( very costly ! ) . from practical point of view very often it may be more apprioprate to hedge the claim with some dependent ( for example correlated ) liquid asset and smartly allow some risk , what actually to our knowledge is done by many ( also of worldwide recognition ) financial institutions without quantitive tools . this paper is organized as follows . the section [ sec : mathematical_model ] introduces a model of financial market and the optimality problem . we also state and give a price of hedging and construct hedging strategy . in section [ sec : example ] we provide the aplication of our result to hedging a european put option on nontradable asset . we calculate the cost of hedging strategy with the other asset with price process partially dependent on the underlying . in numerical calculation we assume that both price processes are driven by correlated geometric brownian motion . consider a discounted price process @xmath6}$ ] which is a semimartingale on a probability space @xmath7 with filtration @xmath8}$ ] , @xmath9 . note that @xmath10 may be substantially greater than filtration generated by @xmath11 . the interpretation is following : the knowledge modelled by @xmath10 could be augmented by information outside the market . the augmentation of filtration here could be interpreted as the information signal about non - market variables important to the value of contract . an example here could be the `` life '' part of information about the equity - linked contract . we will assume that @xmath12 . denote the set of all equivalent martingale measures by @xmath13 and assume that the market does not allow for arbitrage , i.e @xmath14 . a self - financing admissible trading strategy is a pair @xmath15 where @xmath0 is constant and @xmath16 is a @xmath10-predictable process on @xmath17 $ ] for which the value process @xmath18 , @xmath19,$ ] is well defined and @xmath20 @xmath21-almost surely for all @xmath22 $ ] . fix an initial capital @xmath23 and denote by @xmath24 the set of all admissible strategies @xmath15 such that @xmath25 . for nonnegative real @xmath26 define a _ success factor _ @xmath27 assuming values in @xmath28 $ ] such that @xmath27 is nondecreasing function of @xmath29 for all @xmath30 . the following functions can serve as examples of success factor : @xmath31 and @xmath32 . for a contingent claim @xmath3 being a @xmath33-measurable nonnegative random variable we formulate the following problem : [ p1 ] find @xmath34 maximizing _ expected success factor _ @xmath35 $ ] . [ rys_pi ] and @xmath36.,title="fig:",width=377 ] for any increasing function @xmath37\rightarrow { \mathbb{r}}$ ] and positive constant @xmath38 define @xmath39 where @xmath40\rightarrow { \mathbb{r}}$ ] denotes the highest line touching @xmath41 from above with the slope @xmath38 ( see the figure ) . fix a measue @xmath42 and define @xmath43.\ ] ] assume that there is a positive constant @xmath38 that @xmath44 exists and is replicable with strategy @xmath45 where @xmath46 , i.e. @xmath47 note that the assumption above is always fulfilled if all measures from @xmath13 coincide on @xmath48 . this is true because @xmath44 is @xmath48-measurable . in particular this is the case for a complete market extended with contingent claims dependent on some randomness from outside the market ( also in a situation when the information outside the market in revealed continously till the moment of maturity ) . in the next section we give a numerical procedure to find @xmath38 by monte carlo estimation . from now on we write @xmath49 as a shortcut to @xmath50 . [ th_p1 ] @xmath51 is a solution of problem [ p1 ] with the expected success factor equal @xmath52 $ ] . for any @xmath34 holds @xmath53 \leq v_0- \widetilde{v}_0 \leq 0 $ ] . for every @xmath54 and a. a. @xmath55 the inequality holds @xmath56 where @xmath57 . \geq{\mathbb{e}}^{\mathbb{q}}\left [ g_{\mathbb{q}}(v_t)\right]$ ] , i.e. @xmath59= { \mathbb{e}}^{\mathbb{p}}\left[\phi^{\pi}_d\right]\geq{\mathbb{e}}^{\mathbb{p}}\left[\phi^{\pi}_d\right]+m{\mathbb{e}}^{\mathbb{q}}\left[v_t-\pi\right]\geq{\mathbb{e}}^{\mathbb{p}}\left[\phi^{v_t}_d\right].\nonumber\ ] ] note that @xmath60 because @xmath61 , so left side of inequality is attainable . we consider a situation where we sell a put option on nontradable asset @xmath62 with the payoff @xmath63 . we are going to hedge it using tradable asset @xmath64 with the strategy maximizing @xmath65 . assume that the dynamics of two price processes is given with following equations @xmath66 where we assume a correlation @xmath67 between two brownian motions @xmath68 and @xmath69 , i.e. @xmath70 where @xmath71 is some brownian motion independent on @xmath69 . we assume that the interest rate is equal zero . for @xmath72 we have @xmath73= \frac{d{\mathbb{p}}}{d{\mathbb{q}}}{\mathbb{e}}^{{\mathbb{q}}}\left[1_{\{(k - y_t)^+\leq x\}}\big{|}{\mathbb{x}}\right]\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{d{\mathbb{p}}}{d{\mathbb{q}}}{\mathbb{q}}\left[k - x\leq y_0 \exp{\left\ { \mu_yt+\sigma_y(\rho w_t^x+\sqrt{1-\rho^2}w_t)-\frac{1}{2}\sigma_y^2t\right\}}\big{|}{\mathbb{x}}\right]\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{d{\mathbb{p}}}{d{\mathbb{q}}}{\mathbb{q}}\left[\ln\left(\frac{k - x}{y_o}\right)\leq \mu_y t+\sigma_y(\rho w_t^x+\sqrt{1-\rho^2}w_t)-\frac{1}{2}\sigma_y^2t\big{|}{\mathbb{x}}\right]\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{d{\mathbb{p}}}{d{\mathbb{q}}}{\mathbb{q}}\left[\frac{\ln\left(\frac{k - x}{y_o}\right)- \mu_y t-\sigma_y\rho w_t^x+\frac{1}{2}\sigma_y^2t}{\sigma_y\sqrt{1-\rho^2}}\geq w_t\big{|}{\mathbb{x}}\right]\nonumber\\ & = & \exp{\left\{\frac{\mu_x}{\sigma_x}w_t^x+\frac{1}{2}\frac{\mu^2_x}{\sigma^2_x}t\right\}}\left(1-\phi \left(\frac{\ln\left(\frac{k - x}{y_o}\right)- \mu_y t-\sigma_y\rho w_t^x+\frac{1}{2}\sigma_y^2t}{\sigma_y\sqrt{t(1-\rho^2)}}\right)\right)\nonumber,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath74 denotes the cdf of standard normal distribution . [ symulacja ] we describe the sketch of numerical algorithm basing on a monte carlo approach : 1 . fix a real number @xmath75 and integers @xmath76 . 2 . draw a sample @xmath77 from normal distribution with mean 0 and variance @xmath78 . 3 . for @xmath79 find such @xmath54 from set @xmath80 maximizing expression @xmath81 and denote it by @xmath82 . the solution is following : for an initial capital equal to @xmath83 maximal expected success factor is equal @xmath84 different @xmath38 would give a different initial capital and expected success factor . the figure shows the results of simulations for put option maturing at time @xmath85 with the strike @xmath86 . the price dynamics follows [ dynamics ] with parameters @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 . the diagram illustrates the dependence for different levels of @xmath67 . one could verify that as expected if @xmath64 almost mimicks @xmath62 ( i.e. @xmath67 is almost 1 ) , the hedging strategy with @xmath64 should be very close to the hedging strategy with @xmath62 if @xmath62 was tradable . the cost of the last is equal @xmath90 as the result of standard black - scholes formula . usually during capital modelling insurance companies ignore the basic difference between market risks and insurance ( and other nonmarket risks ) : the fact that market risks can be hedged away using underlying asset in our framework . in our seeting this would mean taking @xmath91 , @xmath31 and @xmath3 that represent all liabilities of insurance company at time @xmath92 . it is worth to stress that our solution give gives a strategy to get minimal probability of insolvency . equivalently for given probability ( here 0.995 ) we get capital needed . this solution does nt assume static or almost static posioni , what is usually done in practic , but point out the best strategy(possibly dynamic ) . this author s research was supported by the ministry of science and higher education grant ncn 2011/01/b / hs4/00982 . | in the paper we develop mathematical tools of quantile hedging in incomplete market . those could be used for two significant applications : 1 . calculating the * optimal capital requirement imposed by solvency ii * ( directive 2009/138/ec of the european parliament and of the council ) when the market and non - market risk is present in insurance company . + we show hot to find the minimal capital @xmath0 to provide with the one - year hedging strategy for insurance company satisfying @xmath1=0.995 $ ] , where @xmath2 denotes the value of insurance company in one year time and @xmath3 is the payoff of the contract . 2 . finding a hedging strategy for derivative not using underlying but an asset with dynamics correlated or in some other way dependent ( no deterministically ) on underlying . + the work is a genaralisation of the work of klusik and palmowski @xcite . _ keywords : _ quantile hedging , solvency ii , capital modelling , hedging options on nontradable asset . _ jel subject classification : _ primary g10 ; secondary g12 |
0801.2312 | screening in semiconductor nanocrystals is a fundamental issue , the importance of which is mostly due to the large amount of technological applications inherent in the world of nanostructures . while screening in bulk semiconductors is a well known and widely investigated subject , @xcite the phenomenon of screening in nanostructures is still not fully understood . the presence of many papers recently published on this subject shows that there is a strong interest in this field . @xcite in particular , it has been shown that the response of a nanostructure to an external field is bulklike well inside the structure . @xcite this is an interesting feature due to the local nature of bonding in semiconductors . on the other hand , such a behavior is quite different from the trend shown , in both experimental results and theoretical calculations , by the nanocrystal macroscopic dielectric constant,@xcite that is shown to increase quite slowly with the size upon going from small nanocrystals to the bulk . the connection between the microscopic local , bulk - like response and the macroscopic dielectric properties can be understood only through the study of the surface polarization contribution , which strongly influences the nanocrystal properties . preliminary results on this subject have been presented in ref . . in the present paper , we investigate the nature of the screening in semiconductor nanocrystals by performing a detailed microscopic analysis . in the first part of the paper , a first - principles study of shallow impurity screening in nanocrystals is described . the charge density induced by donors and acceptors in si and ge nanocrystals is discussed , pointing to the connections to both the point - charge case and the bulk limit . it is shown that , just like in bulk semiconductors,@xcite the response to isocoric impurities in nanocrystals is similar to that of a point - charge . a description of the local field effects on the induced charge is given showing that the present real - space analysis gives a way to distinguish between surface and bond polarization contributions . in particular , a very interesting comparison with the work of ref . allows us to give a physical interpretation of the various contributions to the screening . in the second part of the paper , a model for the screening is proposed . the well known electrostatic model , based on the image charge method,@xcite is not valid in the neighborhood of the impurity , in that wrong boundary conditions are given for the induced potential . we propose a generalization to semiconductor nanocrystals of the thomas - fermi model as originally proposed in ref . for bulk semiconductors . in order to better appreciate the merits and the shortcomings of the thomas - fermi theory , an alternative derivation of the model from the hohenberg and kohn theorem @xcite is described . in the present model , both the correct limit in the neighborhood of the impurity and the surface polarization contributions are taken into account from the beginning as boundary conditions of the poisson equation . our results fit well the screening diagonal contribution @xcite for bulk silicon , and excellent agreement with a recent first - principles calculation of the screening function @xcite is obtained . moreover , the model gives a fair prediction of the impurity binding energies . we have performed _ ab initio _ calculations using different kinds of impurities in si and ge nanocrystals . the study has been based on a plane - wave density - functional theory ( dft ) framework . the calculations have been done with the quantum - espresso package,@xcite using the general gradient approximation with ultrasoft pseudopotentials.@xcite a vacuum space of at least @xmath0 has been left within the supercell , in order to avoid spurious interactions between a nanocrystal and its replicas . the convergence with respect to the plane - wave basis - set cutoff has been treated with care , and makov - payne corrections @xcite have been added for the computation of the charged nanocrystal total energies . the nanocrystals have a nearly spherical shape , they are centered on a si ( ge ) atom , and the surface dangling bonds are saturated with hydrogen atoms . the undoped structures have been relaxed , and the optimized geometries used for the doped structures . in this way we study the screening due to the electronic response to an external perturbation , where fixed ionic positions are considered . the resulting screening does not take into account the contribution due to the ionic displacement . this latter is negligible when covalent semiconductors are considered . the electron density induced by a donor species @xmath1 in the nanocrystal si@xmath2h@xmath3 is given by @xmath4 -n\left [ \mathrm{si}_{l}\mathrm{h}_{m}\right ] , \label{eq : indchorig}\ ] ] where @xmath5 is the impurity net charge ( atomic units are used throughout this work ) . a similar expression holds for acceptors and for ge nanocrystals . we have focused our study on the spherical average of @xmath6 , and on its integrated density defined as @xmath7 where @xmath8 . ( color online ) spherically averaged density @xmath9 [ panel ( a ) ] and integrated density @xmath10 [ panel ( b ) ] induced in si@xmath11h@xmath12 by different doping species : s@xmath13 ( dashed , pink line ) and p@xmath14 ( solid , black line ) donor doping , al@xmath15 ( circles , red ) and mg@xmath16 ( stars , blue ) acceptor doping.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] in fig . [ fig : fig1 ] , the results for donor and acceptor isocoric dopants in si@xmath11h@xmath12 are reported . the spherically averaged induced densities @xmath9 [ fig . [ fig : fig1](a ) ] and the integrated densities @xmath10 [ fig . [ fig : fig1](b ) ] are shown for the donors p@xmath14 , s@xmath13 and acceptors al@xmath15 , mg@xmath16 . it is worth noticing that the densities induced by p@xmath14 and s@xmath13 ( solid and dashed line , respectively ) are almost indistinguishable . this suggests that , at least for donor isocoric impurities , the screening is within a linear - response regime . this was already argued some years ago for the bulk , @xcite and our analysis shows that this is valid for nanocrystals too . from fig . [ fig : fig1 ] it is seen that , in the case of the acceptors al@xmath15 and mg@xmath16 ( circles and stars ) , apart from a narrow region of space near the impurity ( inside the pseudopotential core , the acceptor curves show a nonlinear peak that is absent in the donor case ) , the overall structure is similar to the donor case . however , while in the region of space after the second main peak from the impurity the curve is very similar to the donor case , the first main peak is lower and pushed away from the impurity site @xmath17 . this discrepancy between donor and acceptor doping is in agreement with some results recently published , @xcite and is related to nonlinearity effects . the problem of nonlinear screening in bulk semiconductors has been studied with care in the past within a thomas - fermi formalism . in refs . , it was shown that there is an asymmetry in the response when positive or negative charged impurities are considered . while for donor screening ( @xmath18 ) nonlinear effects are negligible , in the case of acceptor screening the response is quite far from linearity . as we shall see in the next section , the screening in semiconductors is mostly confined within a screening sphere around the impurity . the deviation of the radius of such a sphere ( screening radius ) from the linear case furnishes a realistic check of the linearity of the response . from the thomas - fermi theory , an increase of the screening radius of about @xmath19 and @xmath20 a.u . ( with respect to the linear case ) was observed for @xmath21 and @xmath22 , against a decrease of only @xmath23 and @xmath24 a.u . found for @xmath25 and @xmath26 , respectively . @xcite these results show the same trend as in fig . [ fig : fig1 ] , confirming our first hypothesis of a good linearity of the response in the donor case . ( color online ) spherically averaged density @xmath9 [ panel ( a ) ] and integrated density @xmath10 [ panel ( b ) ] , induced ge@xmath11h@xmath12 and ge@xmath27h@xmath28 nanocrystals . the results shown are for p@xmath14 ( dashed , blue line ) and as@xmath14 ( solid , black line ) in ge@xmath11h@xmath12 , as@xmath14 ( circles , green ) in ge@xmath27h@xmath28 . in panel ( b ) we also report the linear response to a point - charge impurity in bulk ge from ref . ( stars , red ) . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] in order to show that the features discussed above for both the induced and integrated density are not peculiar to silicon , we have also studied the case of ge nanocrystals . in fig . [ fig : fig2 ] , our results for the induced [ panel ( a ) ] and integrated [ panel ( b ) ] electron densities are shown for p@xmath14 and as@xmath14 in ge@xmath11h@xmath12 ( dashed and solid line , respectively ) and as@xmath14 in ge@xmath27h@xmath28 ( circles ) . for comparison , in fig . [ fig : fig2](b ) we also report ( stars ) a previous _ ab initio _ result obtained using a truly point - charge impurity for computing the linear - response screening in bulk ge.@xcite it is evident that the screening near the impurity is much more pronounced for the nonisocoric p@xmath14 impurity than for the isocoric as@xmath14 . the different core of the dopant atom with respect to the host atom gives rise , in the first case , to the so called central cell corrections , which give a nonlinear contribution . on the other hand , the response to ( isocoric ) as@xmath14 impurity does not induce central cell corrections it should be pointed out that these corrections have a finite range , being especially pronounced in the region of space before the second main peak in the @xmath10 curve . instead , the electron charge localized on the surface is quite independent of the chemical shift . based on fig . [ fig : fig2 ] , an interesting analysis of the size dependence of the screening can be deduced as well . indeed , from a comparison between our results for ge@xmath11h@xmath12 and ge@xmath27h@xmath28 , we argue that , upon increasing the nanocrystal size , the induced charge close to the impurity rapidly converges to its bulk value . this can be better inferred from panel ( b ) , showing results at small @xmath29 very close to those calculated in ref . for bulk ge . from the results illustrated so far , we can reasonably conclude that ( i ) the isocoric doping is well approximated by a point - charge screening , ( ii ) the screening is in the range of the linear response regime , ( iii ) the induced density rapidly converges to the bulk in the region of space close to the impurity . further considerations can be driven from panel ( b ) of fig . [ fig : fig2 ] . in ref . , it was shown for bulk ge that the induced charge density [ stars in fig [ fig : fig2](b ) ] receives contributions from both diagonal and off - diagonal terms of the dielectric matrix in reciprocal space . the diagonal contribution to the integrated density consists in a monotonic increase of @xmath10 , followed by constant value . instead , the off - diagonal contribution , related to the so called local field effects , gives a wavy structure to the integrated induced density . this undulating behavior has been discussed by several authors for bulk systems , and arises from the polarization of the bonds.@xcite both the diagonal and off - diagonal contributions are retrieved for the nanocrystals , as is clearly seen in fig . [ fig : fig2 ] , but an additional effect due to the polarization of the surface emerges . it consists of an electron density accumulation around the nanocrystal surface due to the dielectric nature of the structure , as is well known from classical electrostatics . the surface polarization is retrieved from the present _ ab initio _ formulation and can be seen as a very special kind of local field effect causing the annihilation of @xmath10 in correspondence with the nanocrystal boundary [ figs . [ fig : fig1](a ) and [ fig : fig2](a ) ] . we conclude that in a nanocrystal , local field effects ( i.e. , not diagonal contributions ) show up as both the bond and the surface polarization . nonetheless , while the bond polarization , which is a bulk effect , gives a negligible contribution to the screening and the optical properties , the surface polarization is extremely important . indeed , it is closely related to the depolarization effects that have been shown to strongly modify the optical properties of low - dimensional structures.@xcite ( color online ) spherical averaged induced density @xmath30 [ panel ( a ) ] and integrated induced density @xmath31 [ panel ( b ) ] , calculated for p@xmath14 impurities in si nanocrystals with increasing size : si@xmath11h@xmath12 ( solid - black line ) , si@xmath32h@xmath33 ( dashed - red line ) , si@xmath34h@xmath35 ( circles - blue ) and si@xmath27h@xmath28 ( stars - green ) . the full arrows point to the nanocrystal radius ( see text for definition ) . , scaledwidth=50.0% ] the size dependence of the screening can be inferred from fig . [ fig : fig3 ] , where the spherical average of the induced density [ panel a ] and the integrated density [ panel b ] are shown for a set of p@xmath14-doped silicon nanocrystals with increasing radii . it comes out that up to a distance of a few a.u . from the impurity , both the induced and the integrated densities are almost independent of the nanocrystal size . in order to be more quantitative , it is necessary to define the nanocrystal radius . we do not follow the standard route , that is , the radius of sphere whose volume equals the product of the volume per atom in the bulk times the number of , say , silicon atoms . indeed , the shortcoming of this definition is that the hydrogens passivating the surface are left out . moreover , in a screening problem the fundamental objects are the electrons , including those participating in the bonds near the surface . on the basis of these arguments , we define the nanocrystal radius through the equation @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is the bulk valence electron density and @xmath38 is the total number of valence electrons in si@xmath2h@xmath3 . the nanocrystal radii calculated in this way are shown in fig . [ fig : fig3 ] as arrows . they have slightly higher values than the conventional radii . for instance , in the case of si@xmath11h@xmath12 , we retrieve @xmath39 a.u . against the conventional value of @xmath40 a.u .. but , as it is seen from fig . [ fig : fig3](a ) , with the present definition all the radii lie almost exactly in the middle of the surface charge density . as a final observation , we stress that despite the undulation in both the induced and integrated densities , the total induced charge around the impurity is almost independent of the nanocrystal radius . although , at this level , this concept may not appear to be well - defined , we shall see in the next section how it allows the construction of a thomas - fermi model for the screening . as we have seen in the previous section , the density induced by a point - charge impurity in semiconductor nanocrystals consists of several contributions . the first contribution is due to the reciprocal - space diagonal part of the dielectric matrix , the second contribution comes from the si - si bond polarization , and the third is from the nanocrystal surface polarization . in this section , we illustrate a thomas - fermi model , which reproduces with great accuracy both the diagonal and surface polarization contributions . as a starting step , we briefly describe a simple electrostatic model that can be used as a first approximation in studying point - charge screening in semiconductor nanocrystals . the basic assumption is that , as a response to a point - charge potential @xmath41 , an electron polarization charge @xmath42 is induced around the impurity . on the other hand , since the total induced charge must integrate to zero , a compensating charge @xmath43 , assumed as uniformly distributed on the nanocrystal surface , must be introduced . the resulting potential energy is therefore due to a total charge @xmath44 localized around the impurity , and to a charge @xmath43 distributed on the surface . from electrostatics , the potential energy for an electron is @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the nanocrystal radius , as defined in the previous section . this electrostatic model is supported by the dft results described in the previous section . indeed , fig.[fig : fig3 ] ( a ) shows that the induced electron density has two main contributions concentrated around the impurity and across the surface . a basic hypothesis for the model is that the total charge @xmath43 is independent of the nanocrystal size . this is supported by the fact that , as shown in fig . [ fig : fig3 ] , the induced density near the impurity rapidly converges to the bulk value . as is shown below , the use of the bulk value for @xmath43 is a good approximation for nanocrystals . however , this simple model is not accurate in the description of the screened potential close to the impurity site . indeed , one can easily see that unphysical potential values are predicted in the limit @xmath47 . in order to correct the model , we follow ref . , in which a thomas - fermi description for bulk semiconductors is given . the basic point is the concept of incomplete screening occurring in a semiconductor . this means that the charge is induced only inside a screening sphere of radius @xmath48 . outside the screening sphere , the system behaves as a classical dielectric medium having a static dielectric constant @xmath49 . in a semiconductor , the total induced charge @xmath43 is a finite fraction of the whole external charge @xmath5 introduced with the impurity . it is well known that the ratio @xmath50 closely depends on the static dielectric constant through the relation @xcite @xmath51 the larger the static dielectric constant is , the closer to unit is the ratio @xmath50 . the induced potential and the spatial dielectric function are obtained solving the thomas - fermi equations with appropriate boundary conditions , where the screening radius is derived self - consistently . @xcite the thomas - fermi theory establishes the linear relation between the induced electron density @xmath6 and the screened potential @xmath52 inside the screening sphere , @xmath53,\ ] ] where @xmath54 ( the chemical potential ) is a constant to be determined with the boundary conditions and @xmath55 is a multiplicative constant related to the nanocrystal average valence electron density.@xcite outside the screening sphere , the induced charge is zero and the screened potential matches the classical expression @xmath56 given in eq . ( [ eq : vc ] ) . the continuity of the induced density , which inside the screening sphere is given by eq . ( [ eq : tfcondition ] ) , at @xmath57 implies [ @xmath58 if @xmath59 that @xmath60 before going to the application of the thomas - fermi theory to a nanocrystal , it is of some interest to rederive eq . ( [ eq : tfcondition ] ) within the dft framework . from the hohenberg and kohn theorem , it is known that the total energy of an electron system , written as a functional of the electron density , can be decomposed into several contributions , @xmath61 = t _ s \left [ n \right ] + j \left [ n \right ] + e_{\mathrm{xc } } \left [ n \right ] + v \left [ n \right],\ ] ] where @xmath62 is the noninteracting kinetic energy , @xmath63 is the total one - particle potential energy @xmath64 = \int d\mathbf{r}\ , n(\mathbf{r})v(\mathbf{r}),\ ] ] @xmath65 is the classical coulomb energy @xmath66 = \frac{1}{2}\int d\mathbf{r}\,d\mathbf{r'}\frac{n(\mathbf{r } ) n(\mathbf{r'})}{\left|\mathbf{r - r'}\right|},\ ] ] and @xmath67 is the exchange - correlation energy density functional.@xcite from the variational principle , with the constraint that the integrated density gives the total number of electrons @xmath68 , we have the stationary condition for the ground - state density @xmath69 , @xmath70 the variable @xmath71 has been shown to be the system chemical potential.@xcite in order to study the screening , we write down the hohenberg and kohn equations , for both the unperturbed ( labeled with 0 ) and the perturbed ( labeled with 1 ) systems @xmath72}{\delta n ( \mathbf{r } ) } \right| _ { n_0}+ v_0 ( \mathbf{r } ) + v_h [ n_0 ( \mathbf{r } ) ] + v_{\mathrm{xc } } [ n_0(\mathbf{r})]&= & \mu_0,\\ \label{eq : hkpert } \left . \frac{\delta t _ s [ n]}{\delta n ( \mathbf{r } ) } \right| _ { n_1}+ v_1 ( \mathbf{r } ) + v_h [ n_1 ( \mathbf{r } ) ] + v_{\mathrm{xc } } [ n_1(\mathbf{r } ) ] & = & \mu_1 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath73 is the one - electron potential , @xmath74 is the hartree potential @xmath75 = \int d\mathbf{r ' } \frac{n(\mathbf{r'})}{\left|\mathbf{r'-r}\right|},\ ] ] and @xmath76 is the exchange - correlation potential . by subtracting eq . ( [ eq : hkimpert ] ) from eq . ( [ eq : hkpert ] ) , and assuming linear response , we obtain an expression relating the induced density @xmath77 with the screened impurity potential @xmath78 . this potential is defined as the sum of the external perturbation @xmath79 , the induced electrostatic potential @xmath80 $ ] , and the induced exchange - correlation potential @xmath81 the final result is @xmath82}{\delta n ( \mathbf{r } ) \delta n(\mathbf{r ' } ) } \right| _ { n_0 } n _ { \mathrm{ind}}(\mathbf{r ' } ) \right\rbrace+ v_{\mathrm{scr } } ( \mathbf{r } ) = \delta \mu.\ ] ] before showing how and under what conditions eq . ( [ eq : tfcondition ] ) can be derived from eq . ( [ eq : tfexact ] ) , it is worth mentioning that this derivation is equivalent to the standard linear response theory , in which the perturbation theory is applied to the self - consistent kohn - sham equations . @xcite equation ( [ eq : tfexact ] ) is an integral equation in which the exact form of the kernel is unknown . the thomas - fermi approximation consists in approximating the kinetic functional to the free - electron gas case . therefore , we have @xcite @xmath83}{\delta n ( \mathbf{r } ) \delta n(\mathbf{r ' } ) } \right| _ { n_0 } & = & \alpha \frac{10}{9 } n_{0}(\mathbf{r})^{-1/3 } \delta ( \mathbf{r - r'}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] so that the integral condition eq . ( [ eq : tfexact ] ) reduces to the following algebraic expression : @xmath84,\ ] ] where @xmath85^{1/2}\ ] ] and @xmath86 . in the standard thomas - fermi model @xmath87 is approximated as the constant spatial averaged valence electron density , which is the number of valence electrons in a unit cell divided by the unit cell volume . however , anticipating the results for si and ge to be discussed below , we have found that this approximation is not so important . what turns out to be crucial is the choice in eq . ( [ eq : tfexact ] ) for the second functional derivative of the kinetic energy . indeed , writing it as a function of only the difference @xmath88 corresponds to neglecting the local field effects , in that the response is independent of the coordinates in which an external point - charge impurity is located . this is equivalent , in a bulk system , to only considering the diagonal component of the reciprocal space dielectric matrix . this argument is about the kinetic functional , and does not regard the surface polarization effects , which are taken into account in the model through the use of suitable boundary conditions for the poisson equation . we know that local field effects enter the theory through the kinetic functional derivative , as well as through the boundary conditions of the poisson equation . the thomas - fermi theory neglects the first , but retains the second of such effects . in the bulk , only the first effect occurs , due to the polarization of bonds , and a link with the diagonal screening of the analysis of ref . can be traced . the thomas - fermi theory gives results in fair agreement with the linear - response results , when the off - diagonal elements of the dielectric matrix are neglected . in order to give a first indication on the validity of the thomas - fermi approximation in nanostructures , we compare the chemical potential @xmath54 calculated from dft with the thomas - fermi prediction . within dft , the chemical potential of a given structure is calculated as @xmath89 where @xmath90 and @xmath91 are , respectively , the structure ionization potential and the electron affinity ( @xmath92 is the total energy).@xcite we have calculated the chemical potential variation @xmath54 for si@xmath11h@xmath12 , for the isocoric p@xmath14 impurity , obtaining @xmath93 ev from eq . ( [ eqmu ] ) and @xmath94 ev from the thomas - fermi eq . ( [ mudef ] ) ( for the determination of the parameters , see below ) . considering all the approximations involved , the agreement of less than @xmath95 ev can be considered very good . the poisson equation , together with eq . ( [ eq : tfcondition ] ) , gives the thomas - fermi equation for an external point - charge @xmath5 located at the nanocrystal center , @xmath96.\ ] ] it can be written as @xmath97\ ] ] with the condition @xmath98 = -z.\ ] ] the leading boundary condition is given by the continuity of the potential on the screening sphere , @xmath99 solving the poisson equation , we find that the thomas - fermi expression for the effective spatial dielectric function , defined as the ratio between external and screened potential , is @xmath100+rq\right\ } + \frac{r}{r } \frac{q}{z}\right\rbrace ^{-1 } , & 0<r\leq r_s \\ \left\lbrace 1-\frac{q}{z } + \frac{r}{r}\frac{q}{z } \right\rbrace ^{-1 } , & r_s \leq r \leq r. % \\ % 1 & r \geq r \end{array } \right . \text { \ } \label{eq : eps}\ ] ] moreover , from the continuity of the electric field on the screening sphere , a relationship between the product @xmath101 and @xmath43 can be obtained , @xmath102 in the following , we shall use eq . ( [ eq : resta ] ) for determining the variable @xmath55 for each nanocrystal , once the total density @xmath43 and the screening radius @xmath48 are known . the determination of the thomas - fermi parameters @xmath43 and @xmath48 is not obvious . we propose to use the bulk @xmath43 , and calculate the screening radius from the _ ab initio _ nanocrystal - induced density . as we shall see below , the @xmath48 dependence on the nanocrystal size is very weak , and , _ a posteriori _ , we can say that the use of a constant value for the screening radius does not significantly change the results . for determining @xmath43 in the bulk , it is necessary to consider eq . ( [ eq : eps ] ) in the limit @xmath103 . it is easy to see that @xmath104+rq\right\ } \right\rbrace ^{-1 } , & 0<r\leq r_s \\ \left\lbrace 1-\frac{q}{z } \right\rbrace ^{-1 } , & r \geq r_s . \end{array } \right . \text { \ } \label{eq : epsbulk}\ ] ] this is the equation first derived in ref . . since the material behaves like a dielectric medium beyond the screening radius , we get @xmath105 from the above equation , in agreement with eq . ( [ eq : qvseps0 ] ) . from this equation we have @xmath106 and @xmath107 for si and ge , respectively , corresponding to the bulk static dielectric constants @xmath108 and @xmath109 . the choice for @xmath43 in the case of ge is motivated by the fact that it is the diagonal contribution to the integrated density , in the limit @xmath110 . @xcite also , the corresponding @xmath49 is very close to the walter and cohen pseudopotential calculations of dielectric function ( they used @xmath111 for bulk ge ) . @xcite this allows us to show that the present model fits well to a standard rpa calculation . finally , we want to point out here that the experimental value @xmath112 is not far from the value we use . we have checked that small differences in the static dielectric constant do not significantly change our results . it remains now to fix the screening radius @xmath48 . this can be done starting from the dft - induced charge illustrated in the previous section . one can define @xmath48 as the radius corresponding to an integrated induced charge equal to @xmath43 . namely , the screening radius is given by the solution of the equation @xmath113 however , because of the wavy behavior shown by the induced charge , there can be several solutions to eq . ( [ eq : rsdef ] ) . among the possible solutions , a choice can be done starting from physical motivations ; in particular , we expect that the screening radius would take a value close to ( actually slightly greater than ) the impurity host bond length . indeed , the whole displaced charge has to be included in the model , and it is likely that , after giving off the wavy contribution , the induced charge extends to the nearest - neighbor distance . @xcite .thomas - fermi parameters calculated for several si and ge nanocrystals and for bulk si . the nanocrystal radius @xmath46 , the screening radius @xmath48 , and the parameter @xmath55 , as computed from eq . ( [ eq : resta ] ) , are reported . all the quantities are in atomic units . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] screening in covalent semiconductor nanocrystals has been studied using both advanced _ ab initio _ methods and a thomas - fermi model . our dft calculations have shown that isocoric donor dopants essentially behave as a point - charge giving an induced charge that agrees well with the linear - response approximation . comparing the induced integrated densities with those obtained in ref . , we have been able to conceptually isolate the features directly related to local field effects . it is , at least in principle , not easy to distinguish the several contributions to the screening due to local fields . however , in the specific cases we have analyzed , there is an indication of the fact that surface polarization is the dominant local field effect in semiconductor nanocrystals . this was proved combining the thomas - fermi theory including electrostatics of surface polarization with the result that the screening function agrees very well with state - of - the - art _ ab initio _ calculations . it is worth mentioning that local field effects related to surface polarizations may have dramatic consequences also in the optical response , particularly for anisotropic structure such as wires and ellipsoidal dots . indeed , it has been shown for both silicon @xcite and germanium @xcite wires that the optical frequency - dependent absorption function is strongly suppressed for light polarized perpendicularly to the wire axis . this suppression does not come out when local fields are neglected . from a classical point of view , these local fields are again dominated by surface polarization , as originally recognized in interpreting the polarization anisotropy of porous silicon.@xcite although the present model can not be generalized to the case of the response to an external field , it is of interest to note that in both cases , that is , point - charge screening and external field , surface polarization plays a fundamental role at the nanoscale . the first - principles calculations presented in this work have shown that the concept of bulklike response to an external perturbation introduced in ref . is valid also in a screening problem . although the induced electron density contains some oscillations , we have shown that it is possible to define a screening radius that is practically independent of the nanocrystal dimension . the progressive reduction of the screening action is due to the surface polarization . in this paper we have shown how this contribution may be described with simple electrostatics . the important point is that now we have an analytical expression for the effective screening function whose validity for both the nanoscale and bulk has been proved . a final note should be devoted to a possible generalization of the model to the case of off - center impurities . this could be done , at least in principle , by considering the matching of the thomas - fermi solution to the full image potential of an off - center point - charge . however , beyond the technical difficulties in doing that , one should consider that the method fails , particularly for very small nanocrystals , when the impurity is at a distance from the nanocrystal surface that is less than or comparable to the screening radius . we are grateful to professor serdar t for a critical reading of the manuscript . financial support by cofin - prin 2005 is acknowledged . calculations have been performed at cineca-``progetti supercalcolo 2006 '' and `` campus computational grid''-universit di napoli `` federico ii '' advanced computing facilities . | a first - principles calculation of the impurity screening in si and ge nanocrystals is presented . we show that isocoric screening gives results in agreement with both the linear response and the point - charge approximations . based on the present _ ab initio _ results , and by comparison with previous calculations , we propose a physical real - space interpretation of the several contributions to the screening . combining the thomas - fermi theory and simple electrostatics , we show that it is possible to construct a model screening function that has the merit of being of simple physical interpretation . the main point upon which the model is based is that , up to distances of the order of a bond length from the perturbation , the charge response does not depend on the nanocrystal size . we show in a very clear way that the link between the screening at the nanoscale and in the bulk is given by the surface polarization . a detailed discussion is devoted to the importance of local field effects in the screening . our first - principles calculations and the thomas - fermi theory clearly show that in si and ge nanocrystals , local field effects are dominated by surface polarization , which causes a reduction of the screening in going from the bulk down to the nanoscale . finally , the model screening function is compared with recent state - of - the - art _ ab initio _ calculations and tested with impurity activation energies . |
quant-ph0703049 | motivated by the fact that all realistic quantum systems are coupled to their surrounding environments , many researchers have paid their attention on the study of geometric phase in open systems since 1980s@xcite . from the perspective of application , the use of geometric phase in the implementation of fault - tolerant quantum gates @xcite also requires the study of geometric phase in open systems , because the system which needs to be manipulated may decoher from a quantum superposition into statistical mixtures due to coupling to its environment . despite of extensive studies that have been performed in this direction , investigation into the effect of correlation among the environmental systems on the induced geometric phase in open systems is lacking . geometric phases have been shown to associate with a variety of condensed matter phenomena @xcite . nevertheless , their connection to quantum phase transitions has only been given recently in @xcite , where it has been shown that the berry s phase can be used to signal the critical points of the spin chain@xcite , the critical exponents were evaluated from the scaling behavior of geometric phases@xcite , and the geometric phase can be considered as a topological test to reveal quantum phase transitions@xcite . in these works , the geometric phase analyzed is acquired by the ground state ( or the low lying excited states ) of the many - body system . this gives rise to the following question , whether the geometric phase induced in an auxiliary system by the many - body system has connection to the critical points of the many - body system . in this paper , we shall try to answer this question by examining the geometric phase induced in a qubit by the many - body system . this makes our study different from that in @xcite . two kinds of coupling between the auxiliary qubit and the many - body system are considered . the first kind of coupling commutes with the free hamiltonian of the auxiliary qubit , leading to dephasing in the qubit . whereas the second one commutes with the free hamiltonian of the many - body system , which causes energy loss ( dissipation ) of the qubit . this paper is organized as follows . in sec.ii we present a general formulism to calculate and analyze the reduced density matrix of the auxiliary qubit , and establish a connection of the reduced density matrix to the critical points . as an example , we calculate the geometric phase induced in the auxiliary qubit taking the xy spin chain as the many - body system in sec.iii . and finally we conclude our results in sec.iv . in this section , we will give a general formalism to analyze the reduced density matrix of a qubit coupled to a quantum many - body system , and establish a connection between the reduced density matrix of the qubit and the criticality in the quantum system . we restrict ourself to consider the following qubit to many - body system couplings . first we consider the case where the coupling conserves the energy of the qubit . then we analyze the case where the energy of the qubit does not conserve , but the energy of the quantum many - body system conserves . the first case corresponds to dephasing in the qubit , while the second kind of coupling results in dissipation in the qubit . consider a qubit coupled to a quantum many - body system . the hamiltonian that governs the evolution of the whole system may have the form @xmath0 where @xmath1 describes the free hamiltonian of the qubit , @xmath2 stands for the free hamiltonian of the quantum many - body system , and @xmath3 represents the coupling between them . @xmath4 is an arbitrary operator of the many - body system . it is clear that @xmath5=0 $ ] , therefore the energy of the qubit conserves . the quantum system described by @xmath2 undergoes a quantum phase transition for parameter @xmath6 . it is easy to show that the time evolution operator for the whole system may be written as @xmath7 with @xmath8 and @xmath9 satisfying @xmath10 where @xmath11 @xmath12 and @xmath13 are eigenstates of @xmath14 for the qubit . having these expressions , we now show that the off - diagonal elements of the reduced density matrix of the qubit change drastically in the vicinity of critical points . to this end , we assume that the qubit and the quantum many - body system are initially independent , such that we take the following product state as the initial state of the whole system @xmath15 where @xmath16 represent the ground state of @xmath17 and @xmath18 . by a standard calculation , one obtains the reduced density matrix of the qubit @xmath19 here , @xmath20 is defined by @xmath21 this is the survival probability of the ground state of the quantum system under the action of the hamiltonian @xmath22 . the leading term @xmath23 of this equation represents the overlap function between two ground states @xmath24 and @xmath25 , where @xmath25 denotes the ground state of @xmath22 . this overlapping function was shown @xcite to take extremal values in the vicinity of critical points . in fact , @xmath20 represents the loschmidt echo which goes exponentially to zero as the many - body system approaches the regions of criticality@xcite . this give us the behavior of @xmath20 in the vicinity of critical points @xmath26 as @xmath27 , leading to a dramatic change in the induced geometric phase near this point @xmath26 . we would like to notice that the above discussions hold for a general coupling between the spin and the quantum system , provided the coupling is weak . next we turn to study the case when the energy of the qubit does not conserve , but the energy of the many - body system conserves instead . this implies that @xmath28\neq 0,$ ] but @xmath29=0.$ ] without loss of generality , we consider the following hamiltonian @xmath30 @xmath31 are pauli operators of the qubit . the interaction hamiltonian @xmath32 can be rewritten as @xmath33 with @xmath34 , and @xmath35 the fact that the interaction hamiltonian @xmath32 commutes with @xmath17 enables us to write the time evolution operator of the whole system as @xmath36 where @xmath37 are eigenstates of @xmath17 with corresponding eigenenergies @xmath38 , and we assume that they are nondegenerate . it is easy to show that @xmath39 \ } .\label{ha3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath40 and @xmath41 quantum phase transition theory tells us that the ground state energy @xmath42 behaves drastically in the vicinity of the critical point @xmath26 , this would reflect in @xmath43 that is a function of @xmath42 . having established this linkage , we claim that the final state of the qubit @xmath44 and the geometric phase acquired by this state can signal quantum critical points in the many - body system , provided the initial state of the many - body system is a superposition of @xmath45 , i.e. , @xmath46 ( @xmath47 ) , and at least two @xmath48 including @xmath49 are not zero . we would like to emphasize that the geometric phase in this case can not signal the critical points , if the many - body system is initially in the ground state with probability 1 . this is because the qubit - system interaction could not excite the many - body system in this situation . in other words , if the couplings between the qubit and the many - body system commute with the free hamiltonian of the many - body system , the many - body system would remain in its initial state if the initial state is one of the eigenvalues of the free hamiltonian @xmath17 . thus , the many - body system would make no effect on the qubit during the dynamics , and consequently the geometric phase acquired by the qubit could not signal the critical points of the many - body system . in this section , we will present an example to illustrate the claim . taken a spin - chain described by the one - dimensional xy model as the quantum many - body system , the hamiltonian for the whole system ( spin+chain ) may be given by @xmath50 where @xmath51 here @xmath52 denotes spin operator of the qubit which couples to the chain spins @xmath53 @xmath54 located at the lattice site @xmath55 . the spins in the chain are coupled to the qubit through a constant @xmath56 . the time evolution operator @xmath57 for the whole system may be written as @xmath58 it is easy to show that @xmath59 satisfy @xmath60 with @xmath61 where @xmath62 . if the auxiliary qubits are initially in state @xmath63 , the dynamics and statistical properties of the spin chain would be govern by @xmath64 , it takes the same form as @xmath17 but with modified field strengths @xmath65 . the hamiltonian @xmath64 can be diagonalized by a standard procedure@xcite to be @xmath66 where @xmath67 are the annihilation ( creation ) operators of the fermionic modes with frequency @xmath68 @xmath69 @xmath70 the fermionic operator @xmath71 was defined by the bogoliubov transformation as , @xmath72 where @xmath73 and the mixing angle @xmath74 was defined by @xmath75 fermionic operators @xmath76 were connected with the spin operators by the jordan - wigner transformation via @xmath77 . the operators @xmath71 parameterized by @xmath78 clearly do not commute with each other , this will leads to nonzero geometric phase in the auxiliary qubits as shown later on . before going on to calculate the reduced density matrix , we present a discussion on the diagonalization of @xmath64 . for a chain with periodic boundary condition , i.e. , @xmath79 boundary terms @xmath80[exp(i\pi m)+1]$ ] have to be taken into acount@xcite . in this paper , we would work with @xmath81 ignored , because we are interested in finding a link between the criticality of the chain and the entanglement in the auxiliary qubits . in fact , the boundary effect can be ignored provided @xmath82 , this is exactly the situation we consider in this paper . having given an initial product(separable ) state of the total system , @xmath83 @xmath84 @xmath85 we can obtain the reduced density matrix for the auxiliary qubits as @xmath86 @xmath87,$ ] it may be formally written in the form @xmath88 a straightforward but somewhat tedious calculation shows that @xmath89 with @xmath90\ } , \label{stateab}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath91 to derive this result , the spin chain was assumed to be initially in the ground state of @xmath17 . with these expressions , we now turn to study the geometric phase of the open system . for an open system , the state in general is not pure and the evolution of the system is not unitary . for non - unitary evolution as shown in eq.([stateab ] ) , the geometric phase can be calculated as follows . first , solve the eigenvalue problem for the reduced density matrix @xmath92 and obtain its eigenvalues @xmath93 as well as the corresponding eigenvectors @xmath94 secondly , substitute @xmath93 and @xmath95 into @xmath96 here , @xmath97 is the geometric phase for the system undergoing non - unitary evolution @xcite , @xmath98 is the total evolution time . the geometric phase eq . ( [ gp5 ] ) is gauge invariant and can be reduced to the well - known results in the unitary evolution . it is experimentally testable . the geometric phase factor defined by eq.([gp5 ] ) may be understood as a weighted sum over the phase factors pertaining to the eigenstates of the reduced density matrix , thus the detail of analytical expression for the geometric phase would depend on the digitalization of the reduced density matrix eq.([stateab ] ) . the eigenvalues of the reduced density matrix are readily calculated @xmath99 in order to calculate the geometric phase , we only need the eigenvalue @xmath100 and its corresponding eigenvector @xmath101 since @xmath102 here @xmath103 and @xmath104 i.e. , the ratio of the imaginary part to the real part of @xmath105 having these results , we obtain the geometric phase , @xmath106 we would like to notice that the geometric phase vanishes with @xmath107 because @xmath108 at this point . @xmath108 results in @xmath109 in eq.([gp6 ] ) , this together with that @xmath110 is real yield zero geometric phase at this critical point . now we turn to study the criticality in the transverse ising model(@xmath111 in the xy model ) . the ground state structure of this model change drastically as the parameter @xmath112 is varied . we first summarize the ground states of this model in the limits of @xmath113 , @xmath114 and @xmath115 . the ground state of the spin - chain approaches a product of spins pointing the positive / negative @xmath116 direction in the @xmath113 limit , whereas the ground state in the limit @xmath115 is doubly degenerate under the global spin flip by @xmath117 . at @xmath114 , a fundamental transition in the ground state occurs , the symmetry under the global spin flip breaks at this point and the chain develops a nonzero magnetization @xmath118 which increases with @xmath119 growing . the above mentioned properties of the ground state are reflected in the geometric phase as shown in figure [ fig1]-(d ) . in the limit @xmath120 , @xmath121 , this results in @xmath122 . in fact when @xmath123 , @xmath124 approaches zero very well . around @xmath125 , the geometric phase changes drastically , this can be interpreted as the sensitivity of the spin - chain ground state to perturbations from the qubit - chain coupling at these points . the difference between @xmath107 and @xmath111 is that @xmath108 for @xmath107 , but it does not hold for @xmath111 . this is the reason why the geometric phase takes different values at these critical points , as figure [ fig1 ] shows . the ground state of the xy model is really complicated with many different regime of behavior@xcite , these are reflected in sharp changes in the geometric phase across the line @xmath114 regardless of @xmath112 ( as shown in figure 1-(a),(b ) and ( c ) ) , indicating the change in the ground state of the spin - chain from paramagnetic phase to the others . instead of discussing the scaling behavior of the induced geometric phase , we consider the scaling property of @xmath126 given in eq.([stateab ] ) in the vicinity of the critical points . noticing that @xmath126 is a function of @xmath127 @xmath128 , the scaling behavior of @xmath126 may be characterized by @xmath129 , and @xmath130@xcite . it was shown that @xmath131 and @xmath132 in the vicinity of criticality for the one - dimensional xy model . in conclusion , by discussing the geometric phase in the auxiliary qubit coupled to the many - body systems , the relation between the geometric phase induced in the qubit and the critical points of the many - body system was established . the induced geometric phase in the qubit change drastically at the critical points , this is due to the sensitivity of the many - body systum to parameter changes near its critical points . the relation not only provides an efficient theoretical tool to study quantum phase transitions , but also proposes a method to measure the critical points in experiments@xcite . the limitation of this discussion is that the coupling between the qubit and the quantum system is assumed weak , and as we have shown , the geometric phase could not reflect the critical points of the quantum system that is initially in its ground state with qubit - system coupling satisfying @xmath133=0 $ ] . the experiment to observe the prediction in this paper can be envisioned as follows . first let the qubit ( a two - level system ) transmit through a 50/50 beam splitter , the qubit is split and follows two different paths then . on one of the paths , the many - body system is placed and interact with the qubit . an interference patten can be observed when the two paths meet , this is similar to the mach - zehnder interferometer . | the geometric phase induced in an auxiliary qubit by a many - body system is calculated and discussed . two kinds of coupling between the auxiliary qubit and the many - body system are considered , which lead to dephasing and dissipation in the qubit , respectively . as an example , we consider the xy spin - chain dephasingly couple to a qubit , the geometric phase induced in the qubit is presented and discussed . the results show that the geometric phase might be used to signal the critical points of the many - body system , and it tends to zero with the parameters of the many - body system going away from the critical points . |
1602.06352 | cognitive research deals with how people learn and solve problems @xcite . at a coarse - grained level , there are three components of cognitive research : how do people acquire knowledge , how do they organize and retain the knowledge in memory ( brain ) and how do they retrieve this knowledge from memory in appropriate situations including to solve problems . these three components are strongly coupled , e.g. , how knowledge was organized and retained in memory during acquisition will determine how effectively it can be retrieved in different situations to solve problems . we can define problem solving as any purposeful activity where one must devise and perform a sequence of steps to achieve a set goal when presented with a novel situation . a problem can be quantitative or conceptual in nature . using the findings of cognitive research , human memory can be broadly divided into two components : the working memory or the short term memory ( stm ) and the long term memory ( ltm ) . the long term memory is where the prior knowledge is stored . appropriate connections between prior knowledge in ltm and new knowledge that is being acquired at a given time can help an individual organize his / her knowledge hierarchically . such hierarchical organization can provide indexing of knowledge where more fundamental concepts are at the top of the hierarchy and the ancillary concepts are below them . similar to an index in a book , such indexing of knowledge in memory can be useful for accessing relevant knowledge while solving problems in diverse situations . it can also be useful for inferential recall when specific details may not be remembered . the working memory or stm is where information presented to an individual is processed . it is the conscious system that receives input from memory buffers associated with various sensory systems and can also receive input from the ltm . conscious human thought and problem solving involves rearranging and synthesizing ideas in stm using input from the sensory systems and ltm . one of the major initial findings of the cognitive revolution is related to miller s magic numbers 7@xmath02 ( 5 to 9 ) , i.e. , how much information can stm hold at one time . @xcite miller s research found that stm can only hold 5 to 9 pieces of information regardless of the iq of an individual . here is an easy way to illustrate this . if an individual is asked to memorize the following sequence of 25 numbers and letters in that order after staring at it for 30 seconds , it is a difficult task : 6829 - 1835 - 47dr - lpcf - ogb - twc - pvn . an individual typically only remembers between 5 to 9 things in this case . however , later research shows that people can extend the limits of their working memory by organizing disparate bits of information into chunks or patterns . @xcite using chunks , stm can evoke from ltm , highly complex information . an easy way to illustrate it is by asking an individual to memorize the following sequence of 25 numbers and letters : 1492 - 1776 - 1865 - 1945-aol - ibm - usa . this task is much easier if one recognizes that each of the four digit number is an important year in history and each of the three letters grouped together is a familiar acronym . thus , an individual only has to remember 7 separate chunks rather than 25 disparate bits . this chunking mechanism is supported by research in knowledge rich fields such as chess and physics where experts in a field have well organized knowledge . @xcite for example , research shows that if experts in chess are shown a very good chess board that corresponds to the game of a world - class chess player , they are able to assemble the board after it is disassembled because they are able to chunk the information on the board and remember the position of one piece with respect to another . if chess novices are shown the same board , they are only able to retrieve 5 - 9 pieces after it is jumbled up because they are not able to chunk large pieces of information present on the chess board . on the other hand , both chess experts and novices are poor at assembling a board on which the chess pieces are randomly placed before it was jumbled up . in this latter case , chess experts are unable to chunk the random information due to lack of pattern . a crucial difference between expert and novice problem solving is the manner in which knowledge is represented in their memory and the way it is retrieved to solve problems . experts in a field have well organized knowledge . they have large chunks of compiled " knowledge in ltm and several pieces of knowledge can be accessed together as a chunk @xcite . for example , for an expert in physics , vector addition , vector subtraction , displacement , velocity , speed , acceleration , force etc . can be accessed as one chunk while solving problems while they can be seven separate pieces of information for beginning students . if a problem involves all of these concepts , it may cause a cognitive overload if students stm can only hold 5 or 6 pieces of information . experts are comfortable going between different knowledge representations , e.g. , verbal , diagrammatic / pictorial , tabular etc . and employ representations that make problem solving easier . @xcite experts categorize problems based upon deep features unlike novices who can get distracted by context dependent features . for example , when physics professors and introductory physics students are asked to group together problems based upon similarity of solution , professors group them based upon physics concepts while students can choose categories that are dependent on contexts such as ramp problems , pulley problems , spring problems etc @xcite . of course , an important goal of most physics courses is to help students develop expertise in problem solving and improve their reasoning skills . in order to help students , instructors must realize that the cognitive load , which is the amount of mental resources needed to solve a problem , is subjective @xcite . the complexity of a problem not only depends on its inherent complexity but also on the expertise , experience and intuition of an individual @xcite . it has been said that problems are either impossible " or trivial " . a ballistic pendulum problem that may be trivial for a physics professor may be very difficult for a beginning student @xcite . cognitive load is higher when the context is abstract as opposed to concrete . the following wason tasks @xcite are examples of abstract and concrete problems which are conceptually similar , but the abstract problem turns out to be cognitively more demanding . * you will lose your job unless you enforce the following rule : if a person is rated k , then his / her document must be marked with a 3 " . + each card on the table for a person has a letter on one side and a number on the other side . indicate only the card(s ) shown in figure 1 that you definitely need to turn over to see if the document of any of these people violates this rule . + * you are serving behind the bar of a city centre pub and will lose your job unless you enforce the following rule : if a person is drinking beer , then he / she must be over 18 years old " . + each person has a card on the table which has his / her age on one side and the name of his / her drink on the other side . indicate only the card(s ) shown in figure 2 that you definitely need to turn over to see if any of these people are breaking this rule . the correct answer for the abstract case is that you must turn the cards with k and 7 ( to make sure that there is no k on the other side ) . please note that the logic presented in the task is one sided in that it is ok for a document with a 3 to have anything on the other side . the correct answer for the concrete case is beer " and 16 years old " , and it is much easier to identify these correct answers than the correct answers for the abstract case . a major reason for why the cognitive load is high during problem solving in physics is because the laws of physics are abstract . it is important to realize that it is not easy to internalize them unless concrete contexts are provided to the students . another difficulty is that , once the instructor has built an intuition about a problem , it may not appear difficult to him / her even if it is abstract . in such situations the instructor may overlook the cognitive complexity of the problem for a beginning student unless the instructor puts himself / herself in the students shoes . an important lesson from cognitive research is that new knowledge that an individual acquires builds on prior knowledge . this idea is commensurate with piaget s notion of optimal mismatch " @xcite or vygotsky s idea of zone of proximal development " ( zpd ) @xcite . zpd is the zone defined by what a student can do on his / her own vs. with the help of a guide who is familiar with the student s initial knowledge and targets instruction somewhat above it continuously for effective learning . this is analogous to the impedance matching of a transformer in which the power transfer can be maximized if the input and output impedances are matched . another analogy is with light passing through two polarizers placed perpendicular to each other vs. having several polarizers stacked one after another where the transmission axes of adjacent polarizers are slightly different from each other . in the first case of crossed polarizer , no light passes through whereas in the second case most of the light passes through if the angle @xmath1 between the transmission axes of the adjacent polarizers is small enough . similarly , if the instruction is targeted significantly above students prior knowledge , learning wo nt be meaningful and even if the students make an effort to store some hap - hazardous information in their brain till the final exam , it will get shampooed out " soon after that . on the other hand , if the instructional design takes into account students initial knowledge and builds on it , learning will be meaningful . another important lesson from cognitive research is that students must construct their own understanding . this implies that we should give students an opportunity to reconstruct , extend , and organize their knowledge . such opportunities will come from ensuring that the students are actively engaged in the learning process and take advantage of their own knowledge resources and also benefit from interactions with their peers . we now describe computer - based interactive problem solving tutorials that we have been developing that build on introductory physics students prior knowledge and keep them actively engaged in the learning process . the tutorials combine quantitative and conceptual problem solving . they focus on helping students develop a functional understanding of physics while learning useful skills @xcite . it is worthwhile thinking about why quantitative problem solving alone often fails to help most students extend and organize their physics knowledge . without guidance , most students do not exploit the problem solving opportunity to reflect upon what they have actually learned and build a more robust knowledge structure . if only quantitative problems are asked , students often view them as plug - and - chug " exercises , while conceptual problems alone are often viewed as guessing tasks with little connection to physics content . the interactive tutorials we have been developing combine quantitative and conceptual problem solving and provide guidance and support for knowledge and skill acquisition . they provide a structured approach to problem solving and promote active engagement while helping students develop self reliance . other computer - based tutorials are also being developed @xcite . our tutorials are unique in that they focus on helping students learn effective problem solving strategies and the conceptual questions are developed based upon the common difficulties found via research on students difficulties in learning a particular topic in physics . a major goal of an introductory physics course for science and engineering majors is to enable students to develop complex reasoning and problem solving skills to explain and predict diverse phenomena in everyday experience . however , numerous studies show that students do not acquire these skills from a _ traditional _ course @xcite . the problem can partly be attributed to the fact that the kind of reasoning that is usually learned and employed in everyday life is not systematic or rigorous . although such hap - hazardous reasoning may have little measurable negative consequences in an individual s personal life , it is insufficient to deal with the complex chain of reasoning that is required in rigorous scientific field such as physics @xcite . educational research suggests that many introductory physics students solve problems using superficial clues and cues , applying concepts at random without thinking whether they are applicable or not @xcite . also , most traditional courses do not _ explicitly _ teach students effective problem solving strategies . rather , they may reward inferior problem solving strategies in which many students engage . instructors often implicitly assume that students know that the analysis , planning , evaluation , and reflection phases of problem solving are as important as the implementation phase . consequently , they may not discuss these strategies explicitly while solving problems during the lecture . there is no mechanism in place to ensure that students make a conscious effort to interpret the concepts , make qualitative inferences from the quantitative problem solving tasks , or relate the new concepts to their prior knowledge . in order to develop scientific reasoning by solving quantitative problems , students must learn to exploit problem solving as an opportunity for knowledge and skill acquisition . thus , students should not treat quantitative problem solving merely as a mathematical exercise but as a learning opportunity and they should engage in effective problem solving strategies . effective problem solving begins with a conceptual analysis of the problem , followed by planning of the problem solution , implementation and evaluation of the plan , and last but not least reflection upon the problem solving process . as the complexity of a physics problem increases , it becomes increasingly important to employ a systematic approach . in the qualitative or conceptual analysis stage , a student should draw a picture or a diagram and get a visual understanding of the problem . at this stage , a student should convert the problem to a representation that makes further analysis easier . after getting some sense of the situation , labeling all known and unknown numerical quantities is helpful in making reasonable physical assumptions . making predictions about the solution is useful at this level of analysis and it can help to structure the decision making at the next stage . the prediction made at this stage can be compared with the problem solution in the reflection phase and can help repair , extend and organize the student s knowledge structure . planning or decision making about the applicable physics principles is the next problem solving heuristic . this is the stage where the student brings everything together to come up with a reasonable solution . if the student performed good qualitative analysis and planning , the implementation of the plan becomes easy if the student possesses the necessary algebraic manipulation and mathematical skills . after implementation of the plan , a student must evaluate his / her solution , e.g. , by checking the dimension or the order of magnitude , or by checking whether the initial prediction made during the initial analysis stage matches the actual solution . one can also ask whether the solution is sensible and , possibly , consistent with experience . the reflection phase of problem solving is critical for learning and developing expertise . research indicates that this is one of the most neglected phase of problem solving @xcite . without guidance , once a student has an answer , he / she typically moves on to the next problem . at the reflection stage , the problem solver must try to distill what he or she has learned from solving the problem . this stage of problem solving should be used as an opportunity for reflecting upon why a particular principle of physics is applicable to the problem at hand and how one can determine in the future that the same principle should be applicable even if the problem has a new context . the development of the computer - based tutorials to help students learn effective problem solving strategies is guided by a learning paradigm which involves three essential components : modeling , coaching , and weaning @xcite . in this approach , modeling " means that the instructor demonstrates and exemplifies the skills that students should learn ( e.g. , how to solve physics problems systematically ) . coaching " means providing students opportunity , guidance and practice so that they are actively engaged in learning the skills necessary for good performance . weaning " means reducing the support and feedback gradually so as to help students develop self - reliance . each of the tutorials starts with an overarching problem which is quantitative in nature . before using a tutorial , students use a pre - tutorial worksheet which divides each quantitative problem given to them into different stages involved in problem solving . for example , in the conceptual analysis stage of problem solving , the worksheet explicitly asks students to draw a diagram , write down the given physical quantities , determine the target quantity , and predict some features of the solution . after attempting the problem on the worksheet to the best of their ability , students access the tutorial on the computer ( or use a paper version for evaluation purposes as discussed in the evaluation section below ) . the tutorial divides an overarching problem into several sub - problems , which are research - guided conceptual multiple - choice questions related to each stage of problem solving . the alternative choices in these multiple - choice questions elicit common difficulties students have with relevant concepts as determined by research in physics education . incorrect responses direct students to appropriate help sessions where students have the choice of video , audio or only written help with suitable explanations , diagrams , and equations . correct responses to the multiple - choice questions give students a choice of either advancing to the next sub - problem or directs them to the help session with the reasoning and explanation as to why the alternative choices are incorrect . while some reasonings are problem - specific , others focus on more general ideas . after students work on the implementation and assessment phase sub - problems posed in the multiple - choice format , they answer reflection sub - problems . these sub - problems focus on helping students reflect upon what they have learned and apply the concepts learned in different contexts . if students have difficulty answering these sub - problems , the tutorial provides further help and feedback . thus , the tutorials not only model or exemplify a systematic approach to problem solving , they also engage students actively in the learning process and provide feedback and guidance based upon their need . each tutorial problem is matched with other problems ( which we call paired problems ) that use similar physics principles but which are somewhat different in context . students can be given these paired problems as quizzes so that they learn to de - contextualize the problem solving approach and concepts learned from the tutorial . the paired problems play an important role in the weaning part of the learning model and ensure that students develop self - reliance and are able to solve problems based upon the same principle without help . these paired problems can also be assigned as homework problems and instructors can inform students that they can use the tutorials as a self - paced study tool if they have difficulty in solving the paired problems assigned as homework related to a particular topic . we have developed computer - based tutorials related to introductory mechanics , electricity , and magnetism . topics in mechanics include linear and rotational kinematics , newton s laws , work and energy , and momentum . topics in electricity and magnetism include coulomb s law , gauss s law , potential and potential energy , motion of charged particles in an electric field , motion of charged particles in a magnetic field , faraday s law , and lenz s law . figures 3 - 6 show screen captures from a computer - based tutorial which starts with a quantitative problem in which two blocks with masses @xmath2 and @xmath3 are in contact on a frictionless horizontal surface and a horizontal force @xmath4 is applied to the block with mass @xmath2 . students are asked to find the magnitude of force exerted by the block with mass @xmath3 on @xmath2 . we have found that this problem is sufficiently challenging for students in both algebra and calculus - based introductory physics courses that most students are unable to solve it without help . in the tutorial , the quantitative problem is broken down into several conceptual problems in the multiple - choice format that students have to answer . for example , one of the conceptual questions related to the initial analysis of the problem is shown in figure 3 along with a screen capture of a help session that a student is directed to if he / she chooses an incorrect response . figure 4 is a multiple - choice question about the free body diagram and figure 5 is a screen capture of a help screen in which an instructor explains relevant concepts to the students related to difficulty with the question asked in figure 4 . figure 6 is a help screen related to a reflection question in which students are asked about the force exerted by the block of mass @xmath2 on @xmath3 if the force of the hand @xmath4 was applied to the block of mass @xmath3 in the opposite direction ( instead of being applied to the block of mass @xmath2 as in the tutorial ) . below , we describe a case - study to evaluate the tutorials . in one case study , we compared three different groups who were given different aid tools : * group ( 1 ) consists of students who used the tutorials as aid tool . * group ( 2 ) consists of students who were given the solved solutions for the tutorial problems which were similar to the solutions in the textbook s solutions manual . however , the solutions were not broken down into the multiple - choice questions with alternative choices targeting common misconceptions as was done in the tutorials . * group ( 3 ) consists of students who were given the textbook sections that dealt with the relevant concepts as the aid tool and were asked to brush up on the material for a quiz on a related topic . fifteen students were recruited and divided into two pools based upon their prior knowledge . then , the students from each of these pools were randomly assigned to one of the three groups discussed above . during the interview session , students in each group initially answered a pre - questionnaire to determine their level of preparation , their views about problem solving in physics , and their perception of physics instruction . it was interesting to note that a majority of the students ( regardless of the group to which they belonged ) disagreed with the statement when confronted with a physics problem , i first spend a reasonable amount of time planning how to solve the problem before actually solving it " . half of the students also agreed with the statement physics problem solving is all about matching given quantities in the problem to the formula in the book " . half of the students thought that the pace of their introductory physics courses was very fast . after this pre - questionnaire , all students were given the following problem on a worksheet and were asked to solve it to the best of their ability before using their aid tools : * _ an insulating sphere of radius @xmath5 has a spherical cavity of radius @xmath6 located within its volume and centered a distance @xmath7 from the center of the sphere . a cross section of the sphere is shown in figure 7 . the solid part of the insulating sphere has a uniform volume charge density @xmath8 . find the electric field @xmath9 at a point inside the cavity . _ all students identified the correct principle to use ( gauss s law ) when asked to solve the problem to the best of their ability on the worksheet . the above problem is challenging enough that none of the interviewed students could solve it without help . most students initially thought that the problem was relatively easy . except for one student who came up with a different incorrect answer , the rest of the students came up with the same incorrect answer : the electric field is zero everywhere inside the cavity . all of them invoked gauss s law , which states that the total electric flux through a closed surface is equal to the net charge inside the surface divided by @xmath10 . their reasoning for zero electric field in the cavity was based on the incorrect interpretation that whenever the electric flux through a closed surface is zero , the electric field at every point inside the surface must be zero too regardless of whether there was a symmetric charge distribution to justify such claims . thus , students drew a gaussian sphere inside the hole and concluded that the electric field must be zero everywhere inside since the enclosed charge is zero . students ignored the asymmetric charge distribution surrounding the cavity , which is a common difficulty . @xcite among many of the difficulties the interviewed students faced , one difficulty was not recognizing that the charge distribution was not symmetric enough and therefore the net electric field at a point inside the cavity can not be zero . when asked to show why the electric field should be zero everywhere inside , most students drew a spherical gaussian surface inside the hole , wrote down gauss s law in the integral form and pulled out the electric field from inside the integral . interviews show that many students believed that the electric field can always be pulled out from the surface integral regardless of the symmetry of the charge distribution . when pressed harder about why the electric field should be equal everywhere on the gaussian surface and why it can be pulled out of the integral , some students noted that one should not worry about this issue at least in this case since the zero charge enclosed implies zero electric field everywhere inside anyway . their convoluted reasoning showed that many students have difficulty in organizing different knowledge resources and applying them at the same time . after the students tried to solve the problem on the worksheet on their own to the best of their ability , students in group 1 were given the corresponding tutorial to work on , those in group 2 were given a textbook - style solution for the problem ( similar to the solutions in a textbook solution manual ) , and those in group 3 were given the section in the textbook , university physics by young and freedman , which deals with this topic . each student used his / her respective aid tool for the same amount of time ( 20 minutes ) . all students were told that they would have to solve a paired problem involving similar concepts after help from the tools they were provided ( tutorial , textbook - style solution , relevant chapter from textbook ) . all students were informed that aid tool was only for learning the material and could not be used while working on the paired problem they will be given later . the paired problem that followed tested whether students could transfer relevant knowledge acquired from the aid tools to the paired problem . @xcite for example , for the gauss s law problem discussed above , the paired problem was similar to the tutorial problem but was for an infinite solid insulating cylinder with a uniform volume charge and an asymmetric cylindrical cavity inside it . we used a rubric to grade students . the average performance of the tutorial group was approximately @xmath11 . all of them made the correct assumption that the electric field is not zero inside the cavity due to the asymmetry of the charge distribution and explained how gauss s law can not be used in such cases to conclude that the electric field is zero in the cavity . during the interviews , these students were able to explain verbally their thought processes and how they solved the problem to find the electric field . by analyzing the students thought processes during the interviews , it appears that the pattern of reasoning employed by these students was significantly better on an average than the reasoning of students from the other two groups . the other two groups did nt show as much improvement as the tutorial group when graded on a rubric after using the aids . between groups 2 and 3 , the students who used the textbook - style solution as a guide did better on the paired problem than those who used the relevant textbook section . the average performance of group 2 was approximately @xmath12 and group 3 was less than @xmath13 . students who used the textbook - style solution still had difficulties in solving the paired problem and four of them did not solve the entire problem correctly . the solution of the problem involves breaking the problem into subproblems each of which has a spherical symmetry and can be solved by known methods using gauss s law . most of the students in the second group ( those who were given a solution of the type given in solutions manual ) realized that they had to combine or superpose two electric fields . however , their most common difficulty was in using vectors in order to relate the final solution to the solutions to the two subproblems which have a spherical symmetry . the textbook - type solution showed them that calculating the electric field at a point in the cavity involved subtracting from the electric field due to the full insulating sphere as though there was no cavity , the electric field due to an insulating sphere of the size of the cavity . from the surveys given after the paired problem , some students mentioned that the textbook - style solutions did nt explain in words the steps used thoroughly . since the misconceptions students had at the beginning were not explicitly targeted by asking explicit questions in the textbook - type solution ( as was done explicitly in the multiple - choice questions which were part of the tutorials ) , students did not transfer relevant knowledge from the solved example to the paired problem as well as the tutorial group did . all of the students who made use of the textbook as an aid for learning ( rather than the tutorial or the solved example ) did poorly on the paired problem . this finding is consistent with another study that shows that unless introductory physics students have seen solved examples . @xcite students in this group realized that the problem solution could not be that the magnitude of the electric field inside the cavity is @xmath14 because otherwise they would not be given 20 minutes to browse over the section of the textbook trying to formulate a solution . but the responses they provided after browsing over the book were often difficult to understand and dimensionally incorrect . when asked to explain what they had done , students noted that they were not very sure about how to solve the problem . they added that the relevant section of the textbook did not help because it did not have a solved example exactly like the problem that was asked . people do not automatically acquire usable knowledge by spending lots of time on task . limited capacity of stm can make cognitive load high for beginning students . for learning to be meaningful , students should be actively engaged in the learning process . moreover , it is important to consider the difficulty of a problem from students perspective and build on their prior knowledge . we are developing computer - based interactive tutorials for introductory mechanics and electricity and magnetism that are suited for a wide variety of students . the self - paced tutorials combine quantitative and conceptual problem solving . they engage students actively in the learning process and provide feedback based upon their needs . they focus on helping students learn problem solving and reasoning skills while helping them build a more coherent knowledge structure related to physics . they can be used as a self - study tool by students . the paired problems can be incorporated into regular quizzes or assigned as homework problems . we thank daniel haileselassie and josh bilak for help in the development and evaluation of the tutorials and thank f. reif , j. levy , and r. devaty for helpful discussions . we are grateful to the nsf for award due-0442087 . national reserach council , _ how people learn : bridging research and practice _ , committee on learning research and educational practices , eds . m. donovan , j. bransford , and j. pellegrino , national academy press , washington , dc , 1999 ; national reserach council , _ how people learn : brain , mind , experience and school _ , committee on developments in science on learning , eds . j. bransford , a. brown and r. cocking , national academy press , washington , dc , 1999 ; h. a. simon , and c. a. kaplan , _ foundations of cognitive science _ , ( m. i. posner editor , mit press , 1989 ) ; j. r. anderson , _ the adaptive character of thought _ , hillsdale , nj : lawrence erlbaum , 1990 ; j. anderson and c. lebiere , _ atomic components of thoughts _ , mahwah nj : lawrence erlbaum , 1998 ; a. newell , _ unified theories of cognition _ , cambridge , ma : harvard university press , 1990 ; a. newell and h. simon , _ human problem solving _ , englewood cliffs nj : prentice hall , 1972 ; e. thorndike , _ human learning _ , new york : century , 1931 ; r. d. tennyson and r. l. elmore , _ learning theory foundations for instructional design _ in instructional design : international perspectives , ( vol . 1 : theory , research , models ) , r. d. tennyson , f. schott , n. seel , and s. dijkstra , mhawah , nj : lawr . erlb . , 1997 ; r. g. glaser , _ education and thinking : the role of knowledge _ , am . psychologist , * 39 * , 93 - 104 , ( 1984 ) . f. reif , _ scientific approaches to science education _ , phys . today * 39 * , 48 , 1986 ; f. reif , _ interpretation of scientific or mathematical concepts : cognitive issues and instructional implications _ * 11 * , 395 , 1987 ; f. reif and s. allen , _ cognition of interpreting scientific concepts : a study of acceleration _ , cognition and instruction * 9(1 ) * , 1 - 44 , ( 1992 ) ; j. mestre and j. touger , _ cognitive research - what s in it for physics teachers ? _ , phys . teach . * 27 * , 447 ( 1989 ) ; e. f. redish , _ implications of cognitive studies for teaching physics _ , am . j. phys . * 62 * , 796 , 1994 ; e. redish , _ teaching physics with the physics suite _ , wiley , 2003 . h. simon , _ how big is a chunk ? _ , science , * 183 * ( 4124 ) , 482 - 488 , 1974 ; p. kyllonen and r. christal , _ reasoning ability is ( little more than ) working memory capacity ? ! _ , intelligence , * 14 * , 389 - 433 , 1990 ; a. baddeley , _ working memory _ , oxford : clarendon press / oxford university press , 1986 ; m. miyake , m. just and p. carpenter , _ working memory contraints on the resolution of lexical ambiguity : maintaining multiple interpretationsin neutral contexts _ , j. memory and language , * 33(2 ) * , 175 - 202 , 1994 ; a. fry , s. hale , _ processing speed , working memory and fluid intelligence : evidence for a developmental cascade _ , psychological science , * 7(4 ) * , 237 - 241 , 1996 ; r. kail and t. salthouse , _ processing speed as a mental capacity _ , acta psychologica , * 86 * , 199 - 225 , 1994 . w. chase and h. simon , _ the mind s eye in chess _ , in visual information processing , ed . w. chase , new york : academic press , 1973 w. chase and h. simon , _ perception in chess _ , cognitive psychology , * 4 * , 55 - 81 , 1973 ; f. gobert and h. simon , _ recall of random and distorted chess positions : implication of the theory of expertise _ , memory and cognition , * 24(4 ) * , 493 - 503 , 1996 ; p. rosenbloom and a. newell , _ learning by chunking : a production system model of practice _ , in production system models of learning and development , eds . d. klahr and p. langley , cambridge , ma : mit press , pp . 221 - 286 , 1987 ; d. broadbent , _ the magic number severn after fifteen years _ , in eds . a. kennedy and a. wilkes , studies in long term memory , ny : wilet , 1975 . j. larkin , and h. simon , _ why a diagram is ( sometimes ) worth ten thousand words _ , in h. a. simon , models of thought ( yale univ . press , new haven ) , vol . ii , pp . 413 - 437 ( 1989 ) ; j. larkin , _ understanding , problem representations , and skill in physics _ in s. f. chipman , j. w. segal and r. glaser ( eds . ) , thinking and learning skills ( lawrence erl . , hillsdale , nj ) , * 2 * , pp . 141 - 159 ( 1985 ) ; j. kaput , _ representation and problem solving : methodological issues related to modeling _ , e. a. silver ( ed . ) , in teaching and learning mathematical problem solving : multiple research perspectives , lawrence erl . , hillsale , nj , pp . 381 - 398 , 1985 ; d. norman , _ things that make us smart _ , addison - wesley , p. 49 , 1993 ; j. zhang , _ the nature of external representations in problem solving _ , cog . 21 , 179 - 217 ( 1997 ) ; j. zhang , and d. norman , " representations in distributed cognitive tasks , cog . , 18 , 87 - 122 ( 1994 ) ; k. reusser , _ tutoring systems and pedagogical theory : representational tools for understanding , planning , and reflection in problem solving _ , in s. lajoie and s. derry ( eds . ) , computer as cognitive tools , lawrence erl . , hillsdale , nj , 1993 ; t. de jong and m. ferguson - hessler , _ cognitive structure of good and poor problem solvers in physics _ psych . * 78 * , 279 - 288 ( 1986 ) ; h. simon , _ on the forms of mental representation _ , in c. savage ( ed . ) , minnesota studies in the philosophy of science ( univ . minnesota press , minneapolis ) , vol . ix , _ perception and cognition : issues in the foundations of psychology _ ( 1978 ) ; h. simon and d. simon , _ individual differences in solving physics problems _ , in models of thought , vol . ii , yale univ . press , ( 1989 ) . m. t. h. chi , p. j. feltovich , and r. glaser , _ categorization and representation of physics knowledge by experts and novices _ , cog . sci . * 5 * , 121 - 152 ( 1981 ) ; p. w. cheng and k. j. holyoak , _ pragmatic reasoning schema _ , cognitive psychology , * 17 * , 391 - 416 , 1985 ; k. johnson and c. mervis , _ effects of varying the levels of expertise on the basic level of categorization _ , 1997 ; p. johnson - laird , _ psychology of reasoning , structure and content _ , cambridge , ma , 1972 ; s. marshall , _ schemas in problem solving _ , new york , ny : cambridge university press , 1995 ; d. bobrow and d. norman , _ some principles of memory schemata _ , in representation and understanding : studies in cognitive science , eds . d. bobrow and a. collins , new york : academic press , pp 131 - 149 , 1975 . b. eylon , and f. reif , effect of knowledge organization on task performance " , cognition and instruction * 1 * , 5 ( 1984 ) ; j. i. heller , and f. reif , _ prescribing effective human problem solving processes : problem description in physics _ , cognition and instruction , * 1 * , 177 , ( 1984 ) . m. chi , r. glaser , and e. rees , _ expertise in problem solving _ , in advances in the psychology of human intelligence , vol . 7 - 75 , r. j. sternberg ( editor ) , hillsdale , nj : lawrence erlbaum ( 1982 ) ; r. e. mayer , _ thinking , probelm solving , cognition _ , second edition , new york : freeman , 1992 ; j. larkin , j. mcdermott , d. simon , and h. simon , _ expert and novice performance in solving physics problems _ , science * 208 * , 1335 - 1362 ( 1980 ) ; j. larkin , _ the role of problem representation in physics _ , in d. gentner and a. l. stevens ( eds . ) , mental models ( lawrence erlbaum , hillsdale , nj ) , pp . 75 - 98 ( 1983 ) ; j. larkin , _ cognition of learning physics _ * 49(6 ) * , 534 - 541 , ( 1981 ) ; j. larkin , _ skilled problem solving in physics : a hierarchical planning approach _ , j. of structured learn . * 6 * , 121 - 130 ( 1980 ) ; a. h. schoenfeld , _ mathematical problem solving _ , new york : academic press , 1985 ; a. h. schoenfeld , _ teaching mathematical thinking and problem solving _ , pp . 83 - 103 , in toward the thinking curriculum : current cognitive research ( l. b. resnick and b. l. klopfer eds . ) , washington , dc : ascd , 1989 ; a. schoenfeld and d. j. herrmann , _ problem perception and knowledge structure in expert novice mathematical problem solvers _ , j. exp . psych . , learning , memory , and cognition * 8 * , 484 - 494 ( 1982 ) ; y. anzai and t. yokoyama , _ internal models in physics problem solving _ , cognition and instruction * 1(4 ) * , 397 - 450 , ( 1984 ) ; c. schunn and j. anderson , _ acquiring expertise in science : explorations of what , when and how _ , in designing for science , implications from everyday , classroom and professional settings , eds . k. crowley , c. d. schuun and t. okada , lawrence erlbaum , 2001 . j. sweller , _ cognitive load during problem solving : effects on learning _ , cognitive science * 12 * , 257 , 1988 ; j. sweller , r. mawer , and m. ward , _ development of expertise in mathematical problem solving _ , j. exptal . psychology : general * 112 * , 639 , 1983 . p. wason , _ reasoning about a rule _ , quarterly journal of experimental psychology , * 20 * , 273 - 281 , 1968 ; p. wason and p. johnson - laird , _ psychology of reasoning : structure and content _ , cambridge , ma : harvard university press , 1972 . h. ginsberg , and s. opper , _ piaget s theory of intellectual development _ , englewood cliffs , prentice hall , n.j . , 1969 ; r. gorman , _ discovering piaget : a guide for teachers _ , merrill , columbus , 1972 ; j. piaget , _ the language and thought of a child _ , ny : meridian , ( 1974 ) ; j. piaget , _ success and understanding _ , cambridge , ma : harvard university press , 1978 ; a. lawson , _ a review of research on formal reasoning and science teaching _ , j. research in science teaching , * 22(7 ) * , 569 - 617 , 1985 . l. vygotsky , _ mind in society : the development of higher psychological processes _ , harvard university press , 1978 ; j. wertsch , _ mind in action _ , ny : oxford university press , ( 1998 ) ; j. valsiner , and r. van der veer , _ the encoding of distance : the concept of the zone of proximal development and its interpretations_. in ( r. r. cocking and k. a. renninger eds . ) the development and meaning of psychological distance ( pp 35 - 62 ) , hillsdale , nj : lawrence erlbaum associates . c. singh , interactive video tutorials for enhancing problem solving , reasoning , and meta - cognitive skills of introductory physics students " , proceedings of the 2003 physics education research conference , edited by j. marx , s. franklin and k. cummings , aip conf . proc . , volume 720 , melville , new york , 177 - 180 , 2004 . for example , see http://www.andes.pitt.edu/ , http://www.webassign.net , http://www.masteringphysics.com a. collins , j. brown , and s. newman , _ cognitive apprenticeship : teaching the crafts of reading , writing and mathematics _ , in l. b. resnick ( ed . ) , knowing , learning , and instruction : essays in honor of robert glaser " , hillsdale , nj : lawrence erlbaum . , 453 - 494 , ( 1989 ) . m. gick and k. holyoak , _ the cognitive basis of knowledge transfer _ , in transfer of learning : contemporary research and applications , cornier @xmath15 hagman ( eds . ) , new york , academic press ( 1987 ) ; m. gick and k. holyoak , _ schema induction and analogical transfer _ , cognitive psychology , * 15 * , 1 - 38 , 1983 ; k. holyoak , _ the pragmatics of analogical transfer _ , in the psychology of learning and motivation , ed . g. bower , ( vol . 19 ) , new york : academic press , 1985 ; k. holyoak and p. thagard , _ mental leaps : analogy in creative thought _ , cambridge , ma : mit press , 1995 ; r. dufresne , j. mestre , t. thaden - koch , w. gerace and w. leonard , _ knowledge representation and coordination in the transfer process _ 155 - 215 , in transfer of learning from a modern multidisciplinary perspective , j. p. mestre ( ed . ) , 393 pages , greenwich , ct : information age publishing , ( 2005 ) ; j. lobato , _ how design experiments can inform a rethinking of transfer and vice versa _ , educational researcher , 32(1 ) , 17 - 20 , ( 2003 ) ; j. lobato , _ alternative perspectives on the transfer of learning : history , issues and challenges for future research _ , j. learning sciences , * 15(4 ) * , 431 - 439 , ( 2006 ) ; d. j. ozimek , p. v. engelhardt , a. g. bennett , n. s. rebello , _ retention and transfer from trigonometry to physics _ , proceedings of the physics education research conference , eds . j. marx , p. heron , s. franklin , 173 - 176 , ( 2004 ) ; j. d. bransford and d. schwartz , _ rethinking transfer : a simple proposal with multiple implications _ , review of research in education , * 24 * , 61 - 100 , ( 1999 ) ; l. novick , _ analogical transfer , problem similarity and expertise _ , j. experimental psychology : learning , memory and cognition , * 14(3 ) * , 510 - 520 , ( 1988 ) . c. singh , assessing student expertise in introductory physics with isomorphic problems , part ii : examining the effect of some potential factors on problem solving and transfer " , phys . . res . * 4 * , 010105 , ( 2008 ) . | one finding of cognitive research is that people do not automatically acquire usable knowledge by spending lots of time on task . because students knowledge hierarchy is more fragmented , `` knowledge chunks '' are smaller than those of experts . the limited capacity of short term memory makes the cognitive load high during problem solving tasks , leaving few cognitive resources available for meta - cognition . the abstract nature of the laws of physics and the chain of reasoning required to draw meaningful inferences makes these issues critical . in order to help students , it is crucial to consider the difficulty of a problem from the perspective of students . we are developing and evaluating interactive problem - solving tutorials to help students in the introductory physics courses learn effective problem - solving strategies while solidifying physics concepts . the self - paced tutorials can provide guidance and support for a variety of problem solving techniques , and opportunity for knowledge and skill acquisition . address = department of physics and astronomy , university of pittsburgh , pittsburgh , pennsylvania , 15260 |
hep-ph0412279 | measurements of lepton pair production in hadron - hadron interactions is of a big interest from the point of view of study of the quark - parton structure of hadrons @xcite and @xcite . the best example is the discovery of j ( also called as j / psi ) charmed meson confirmed later by e+e- experiment tool to get out the information about the parton distribution functions ( pdf ) in hadrons as it was already shown in a number of high energy experiments @xcite and theoretical papers , devoted to the data analysis in the framework of qcd . in this connection it is worth to mention that up to now there is no good theoretical understanding of the physics of this process . the best example of this situation is the wide use of such a `` theoretical method '' of elimination of quite a noticeable discrepancy among the lepton pair production data and the theory predictions ( quark - parton model and its qcd extensions ) as a simple multiplication of the theory predictions by the so called phenomenological `` k - factors '' which values vary in the interval from 1.5 to 2 . intermediate energy experiments may play an important role as they allow to study the range where the perturbative methods of qcd ( pqcd ) come into the interplay with a rich physics of bound states . the physics of hadron resonances formation and decays is strongly connected with the confinement problem , i.e. with the qcd dynamics at large distances . its high precision and detail experimental study would allow to make a serious discrimination between a large variety of non - perturbative approaches and models that are already proposed as well as among those which are under development . therefore to define a boundary among perturbative and non - perturbative approaches it may be instructive to make some estimations on kinematical distributions , connected with the @xmath1- or @xmath2- pairs production in the range of future panda experiment energies basing upon the well known pythia @xcite event generator , which is widely and successfully used in high energy experiments . such an experience may allow to set the low energy limits for pqcd application as well as it may be also useful for comparison with the predictions of the present ( and future ) non - perturbative approaches and finding out their difference . it is worth to mention also that in any case the dominant mechanism of the lepton - anti - lepton pair production would be the same in the most approaches because in this special process @xmath3 the dominant contribution in any model would come from the same quark pair annihilation amplitude @xmath4 . pythia includes this amplitude as well as proper account of relativistic kinematics to this reason , in present note we shall simulate in framework of pythia6 the scattering of the anti - protons with the energy of @xmath5 on the proton target , taken as to be at the rest frame thus the present simulation would not include the effects connected with the real detector conditions which would be the subject of the following papers . thus , the present simulation has the importance as its own because it gives in some sense the `` unbiased distributions '' of particles as well as the corresponding quark - parton distributions and allows , in principle , to estimate the size of the corrections needed to reconstruct the original input parton distributions . let us mention that in what follows we choose mrst4 @xcite parameterization of structure functions , which is one from the list of proton parton - distributions set of pythia6 . it should be noted also that the main part of this note ( sections 1 . and 2 . ) can be easily applied to a case of electron - positron pair production . the main difference of @xmath2 case with that one of muon pair production is that for @xmath2 case there would not a big need of discussion of appearance of fake electrons in the same `` signal '' annihilation event due to negligibly small contribution of fake electrons from pions decays as comparing with their muon decay channel . here we present some distributions of muon physical variables obtained by use of pythia event generator . its parameters were set to those values that allow fast simulation for the antiproton beam with the energy @xmath7=14 gev , which corresponds to the center of mass frame energy of @xmath8 collision @xmath9 . the muons produced in the corresponding hard qcd @xmath10 subprocess @xmath11 would be called in what follows as the `` signal '' ones , while those which will appear in event due to meson decays would be called as `` decay '' muons . the simulation was done for a case when both initial state radiation ( isr ) and final one ( fsr ) were switched on ( i.e. with the following values of pythia parameters mstp(61)= mstp(71)=1 ) . the number of generated events was taken to be 100 000 . the distributions of the signal muons energy @xmath12 values as well as of the modulus of the transverse momentum @xmath13 and of the polar angle @xmath14 ( measured from the beam direction ) versus the number of generated events are shown ( from top to bottom , respectively ) in figure 1 of section 6 , which contains all the figures . the left column in figure 1 is for @xmath15 distributions and the right one for @xmath16 ) . there is no difference seen between @xmath16 and the analogous e @xmath15 distributions in a case when the influence of magnetic field is not considered ) . one can see from the top raw of figure 1 that the energy of muons may vary in the interval @xmath17 with a mean value @xmath18 gev and a peak at a rather small value @xmath19 = 0.5 gev . the @xmath20 spectrum , see middle raw of figure 1 , has an analogous peak @xmath21 gev / c . after this point both @xmath22 and @xmath20 spectra falls rather steeply but the spectrum of @xmath20 is confined in a more narrow interval @xmath23 gev / c . the spectrum of events number ( nevent ) versus the polar angle @xmath24 ( see bottom raw ) has a peak at @xmath25 and the mean value @xmath26 . from these plots we see that while the most of signal muons are scattered into the forward direction @xmath27 still there is a small number of them that fly in the backward hemisphere ( @xmath28 ) . we shall discuss this point in more details in what follows . from the view point of the background ( the main source for it are the muons from charged pions and other hadrons decays ) estimation it is usefull to have the set of plots analogouse to the previouse one , but done separatley for the signal muons having the largest energy ( `` fast '' muons ) in the muon pair produced in an event , and , correspondently , for those having the smaller energy ( `` slow '' muon ) . this set of plots for the signal muons are given in figure 2 of the appendix , where the left column is for the `` slow '' muon distributions and the right one is for `` fast '' muons . we see from figure 2 that the energy spectrum ( top raw ) of the fast signal muons grows steeply from the point @xmath29 ( practically @xmath30 of fast muons have @xmath31 ) to the peak at the point @xmath32 = @xmath33 and then vanishes at @xmath34 = @xmath35 . in contrast to this picture the spectrum of less energetic signal munons ( left raw ) has a peak at the point @xmath36=0.5 gev ( where the spectrum of fast muons only starts ) and it practicaly vanishes at the point , which corresponds to the mean value of the most energetic signal muons , i.e. to @xmath37 = 3.9 gev . thus , one may say that the spectrum of slow muons in a pair is very different from that of the fast ones . the difference between the @xmath20 spectra ( see middle raw of figure 2 ) of the fast and slow muons seams not to be so large and it results only in about 340 mev shift to the left of the peak position as well in the corresponding shift of the end point of slow muons spectrum . both of these spectra demonstrait that the most of slow as well as of fast muons have @xmath38 gev . this similarity of @xmath20 spectra of fast and slow muons results ( due to a large difference of their energy spectra , i.e. of @xmath39 compronent ) in a large difference of their polar angle @xmath24 distributions ( see bottom raw in figure 2 ) : @xmath40 spectrum is shifted to the right as comparinring to that one for @xmath41 and their mean value @xmath42 = @xmath43 is a more than two times higher than the analogouse mean value for the fast one : @xmath44 . another and the most important difference that is seen from these angular distributions is that all fast muons fly in forward direction @xmath45 and their spectrum practically finishes at @xmath46 , while about @xmath47 of slow muons have @xmath48 and about of @xmath49 of them may scatter into the back hemisphere . up to now we disscussed the results obtained without any other kinematical cuts than those implemented onto internal pythia varaibles and needed to run this generator at as low as possible values of beam energy . in our generation we have restricted the value of the invariant mass of @xmath1 signal pair , produced in event . namely we have taken the last parameter @xmath50 to be restricted by the inequality @xmath51 gev . the distributions of bjorken x - variables are shown in figure 3 for up- and antiup- quarks ( top raw ) and for down- and antidown- quarks ( bottom raw ) correspondingly . in what follows we shall refer to these distributions as to the `` unbiased '' ones as the influence of different cuts onto muons energy @xmath52 as well as the angle cuts , connected with possible different geometry size of muon muon system would be studied latter . as it can be easialy seen from this plots the obtained distributions do not start from the point x=0 , what take place for the used parton distribution parametrizations used in pythia . such a differnce at low values of x appears due to the mention above cut on the value of muon pair invariant mass . the number of entries at these plots reflects the valence quark flavour structure of the proton ( the analoguse distributions and the number of entries for the antiquarks show the absolute similarity of quark and antiquarks distributions ) . all what was said above may be to a good approximation applied also to a case of electron - positron pair production in the final state . the most difference of @xmath2 case with that one of @xmath53 pair production appears , as it was allready mentioned in the introduction , when one turns to the problem of background or fake leptons in the same signal lepton pair production process . really , the events with a pair of signal muons should contain also some hadrons in the final state . the pions , produced directly or in the decays cascades of other hadrons , may decay in the detector volume and thus serve as a source of background muons that may fake the signal ones produced in the annihilation subprocess . figure 4 includes in the left column ( as in the figures 1 and 2 ) the distributions ( from top to bottom ) of the number of events versus the energy @xmath54= @xmath55 , the transverse momentum @xmath56 = @xmath57 and versus the polar angle @xmath58= @xmath59 of produced pions . the right hand column contains only one plot with the distribution of the total number npi of charged @xmath60-mesons in the signal events . one may see that there is a big number of events ( about@xmath61 ) which do not contain charged pions at all in the final state ( they mostly have nucleon pairs in the final state ) . this result is very important . despite the fact that pythia provides a good ( at least one of the bests if not the best one ) but still a model approximation to the real hadronization effects , it indicates ( in the absence of a complete physical and theoretical understanding of parton to hadrons fragmentation processes ) that it may happen so that about of one third of events with signal muon pairs may appear practically without additional fake ( or internal background ) decay muons content . that means that muon channel may be quite competitive to the @xmath2 one . in what follows we shall add more arguments in a favor of this suggestion . from the same right hand plot we also see that about of @xmath62 of events have only one charged pion in the final state ( appearing mostly in @xmath63 resonance decays ) , and a bit less than @xmath62 of events have two charged pions . it demonstrates also that about of @xmath49 of events have 3 charged pions and there is only about of @xmath64 of events with 4 final state charged pions . figure 5 includes in the left column , respectively from top to bottom , the energy @xmath65 , @xmath66 and polar angle @xmath67 distributions for muons appearing from the discussed above charged @xmath60 -meson decays . these distributions follow the analogue spectra of parent pions , presented in figure 4 . by comparing these plots with those from signal muon pairs shown in figure 1 , one may conclude that the energy mean value of the signal muons @xmath68 = 2.6 gev does corresponds to the point in the energy distribution of fake decay muons where the contribution of the decay muons is already low . the same may be said about the pt- distribution of decay muons . the mean value of the pt- distribution of signal muons @xmath69 gev ( see figure 1 ) does corresponds to the point where the spectrum of @xmath70 practically vanishes . the e- and pt- spectra of decay muons are a bit softer than those of `` slow '' signal ones . they are shifted by 300 mev ( i.e. by @xmath71 to the left ( see their mean values ) as comparing with those of signal slow muons . analogously the fake decay muons polar angle spectrum is shifted also to the left by @xmath61 , i.e. by @xmath72 . still , due to a big similarity of decay and `` slow''signal muons the former may appear as a serious background . therefore a reasonable cut upon the muons energy @xmath73 ( as well as on the @xmath74 ) may lead to an essential reduction of the decay mesons contribution and allow to keep the main part of signal events . thus a cut @xmath75 gev may allow to get rid of a half of decay mesons at the coast of lost of @xmath76 of signal events . the analogous strict cut @xmath77gev leaves more than @xmath78 of signal muons and less than @xmath79 of decay mesons . another way to discriminate the signal `` slow '' muons from the decay ones is to use the information about the position of the muon production vertex . the right hand side raw in figure 5 contains ( from top to bottom ) the x- , y- and z-(i.e . along the beam direction ) components of muon production vertex position , as given by pythia simulation , i.e. in a space free of experimental setup around the interaction point . the distances at these distribution plots are given in millimeters . thus one may see that the tails of the z - distribution may expand up to 100 meters , while those along x- and y- axis reach 40 meters distance . from this right hand plots it is clearly seen that in a case of mentioned above @xmath80 of signal events that include the decay muons ( i.e. addition to the signal muon pair , produced in annihilation subprocess ) the size of the detector ( i.e. , the `` decay volume '' ) may strongly reduce the number of charged @xmath60-mesons which potentially may produce muons in the decays because the most of parent pions would interact with the detector components . therefore one may expect that in the real experimental conditions the situation with the contribution of the additional decay muons may become much easy . the detailed geant simulation , which is in our nearest plans , should allow to get more definite predictions about the decay mesons contribution to the background . the energy , transverse momenta and polar angle ( with respect to the beam axis ) distributions of muons that may be produced in pairs in @xmath3 process , i.e. the distributions of signal muons , are presented for a case of the proton target rest frame . these distributions were obtained by use of pythia generator which parameters were adjusted to perform effective generation of physical events in a case of @xmath81 beam energy equal to 14 gev . it is shown that those of muons that are the most energetic in a moun pair , i.e. fast muons , predominantly fly in forward direction ( with the mean value @xmath44 ) , while those which are less energetic in a pair , i.e. slow muons , fly at larger angles ( their mean value is @xmath42 = @xmath43 ) . it is found that some of slow signal muons may fly in backward hemisphere also . thus , a good angle coverage by muon system would be very usefull . the analogous distributions for muons that appear from hadrons decays ( mostly from pions ) , i.e. for decay muons , have shown that decay muons may fake the signal slow muons in the same events and thus , in principle , may be considered to appear as a serious bakground . nevertheless , the distributions of the number of generated events versus the number of charged pions in lepton pair production event has shown that , fortunatly , more than @xmath61 of signal events do not have charged pions in the final state . on a top of this it seams to be clear from the obtained distribution of the space position of fake decay muon production vertex that a large amount of these muons may be potentialy rejected with the account of the real detector decay volume . we plan as our next step to perform such type of complete geant detector simulation with the analysed here events , generated by use of pyhtia . the auhtors are very gratefull to g.d.alexeev for suggestion of this topic for study , the interest to this work and multiple stimulating discussions of the questions concerned . 50 v.a . matveev , r.m . muradian , a.n . tavkhelidze , jinr p2 - 4543 , jinr , dubna , 1969 ; slac - trans-0098 , jinr r2 - 4543 , jun 1969 ; 27p . drell , t.m . yan , slac - pub-0755 , jun 1970 , 12p . ; phys.rev.lett . * 25*(1970)316 - 320 , 1970 . cern ua1 collaboration , c. albajar et al . lett . , * b209 * ( 1988 ) 397 ; fnal e772 collaboration , p.l . gaughey at al . phys . rev . * d50 * ( 1994 ) 3038 ; t.sjostrand , computer phys . commun.*39 * ( 1986 ) 347 , t.sjostrand and m.bengtsson , computer phys . commun.*43 * ( 1987 ) 367 . martin _ et al . j. * c4 * ( 1998 ) 463 . r. brun and f. rademakers , root - an object oriented data analysis framework , proceedings aihenp96 workshop , lausanne , sep . 1996 , nucl . inst . & meth . * a389 * ( 1997 ) 81 . see also http://root.cern.ch/. -5 mm ( top raw ) , the modulus of the transverse momentum @xmath13 ( middle raw ) and the polar angle @xmath14 ( bottom raw ) distributions . left column is for @xmath15 and right one for @xmath16.,title="fig:",width=680,height=755 ] -5 mm ( left column ) and the smaller energy ( `` slow '' muons ) @xmath36 ( right column ) . top raw includes their energies , in middle raw are pt and in bottom raw are @xmath82.,title="fig:",width=680,height=755 ] -5 mm = @xmath55 , the transverse momentum @xmath83= @xmath84 and versus the polar angle @xmath58= @xmath85 of produced pions . the right hand plot shows the distribution of the total number ( npi ) of charged @xmath60-mesons in the signal events.,title="fig:",width=680,height=755 ] -5 mm = @xmath55 , the transverse momentum @xmath83= @xmath84 and versus the polar angle @xmath58= @xmath85 of produced pions . the right column ( from top to bottom ) shows the distributions of x- , y- and z- components of decay muon vertex position.,title="fig:",width=680,height=755 ] | we use pythia event generator to simulate the process of muon pair production in antiproton scattering upon the proton target at the energy of the antiproton equal to @xmath0 , which may be one of the energies for the future panda ( gsi , darmstadt ) experiment operation . |
astro-ph0008155 | dynamical studies of the two largest members of the local group the milky way and the andromeda ( m31 ) galaxies are of particular interest . the mass of m31 is well constrained on the scales of a few tens of kiloparsecs from the optical and hi rotation curves ( braun 1991 ) and from the kinematics of the planetary nebulae and globular cluster populations ( e.g. , evans & wilkinson 2000 ) . to probe much larger radii and estimate the total mass of the m31 halo , it is to the satellite galaxy population that we must turn . here , there have been dramatic developments in the last few years . the advent of wide - field imaging surveys ( armandroff , davies , & jacoby 1998 ; karachentsev & karachentseva 1999 ; armandroff , jacoby , & davies 1999 ) has led to the discovery of three new dwarf spheroidals ( dsphs ) andv , andvi ( pegdsph ) and casdsph . in all , the entourage of galaxies accompanying m31 now numbers as many as fifteen , although the status of two of these ( pegasus and ic 1613 ) is perhaps unclear as opinions differ as to whether they are close enough to be bound ( mateo 1998 ; grebel 1999 ; courteau & van den bergh 1999 ) . for the milky way , the data set of the eleven companion galaxies , as well as the distant globular clusters , has often been exploited to estimate the total mass of the milky way halo . the older techniques of virial estimators have nowadays been superseded by more sophisticated bayesian likelihood estimators ( little & tremaine 1987 ) . the most recent analysis by wilkinson & evans ( 1999 ) found a total mass for the milky way halo of @xmath3 , with the large error bars reflecting the small sample size and the uncertainties in the proper motions . hitherto , the satellites of m31 have received scant attention . evans & wilkinson ( 2000 ) looked at all the available published data on ten of the satellite galaxies and found a rather low mass of @xmath4 . this raises the possibility that the milky way galaxy may be the largest member of the local group . here , we exploit recent stellar velocity measurements with the spectrographs on the _ keck telescopes_. the new observations are reported in detail by guhathakurta et al . ( 2000a , b ) . the results enhance the dataset on the radial velocities of the companion galaxies of m31 by fifty per cent and are used to provide the most reliable estimate of the mass of the extended halo of m31 to date . the radial velocities of eight of the companions to m31 have been known for some time based on one or more of the following techniques : hi 21 cm measurements , optical absorption line spectra of the integrated light of galaxy cores / nuclei , bulges , or globular clusters , or optical emission line spectra of hii regions . the data are recorded in the upper panel of table [ tab : satdata ] . these techniques are not easily applicable to galaxies of low surface brightness and/or low gas content . consequently , until very recently , the radial velocities of the six dsph companions ( andi , andii , andiii , andv , andvi , cas dsph ) remained unmeasured . they require 810 meter class telescopes and efficient spectrographs for spectroscopy of individual red giant stars . ct et al . ( 1999 ) have recently provided the first kinematic study of andii . they used the _ high - resolution echelle spectrometer _ ( hires ; vogt et al . 1994 ) on the 10-meter _ keck i telescope _ to measure the radial velocities of a few red giants in each dwarf galaxy . guhathakurta et al . ( 2000a , b ) provide the data on the outstanding five dsphs . using the _ low - resolution imaging spectrometer _ ( lris ; oke et al . 1995 ) on the _ keck ii telescope _ , they obtained velocity measurements for nearly a hundred red giants in andi , andiii , andv , and andvi . guhathakurta et al . ( 2000a , b ) have also carried out hires multislit echelle observations of 21 red giant branch stars in casdsph . the radial velocities of the dsphs are recorded in the lower panel of table [ tab : satdata ] . in general , distance estimates for the m31 companions are derived from variable stars such as cepheids and rr lyrae , from the tip of the red giant branch ( trgb ) method ( lee , freedman , & madore 1993 ) , or from the brightness of horizontal branch ( hb ) stars ( lee , demarque , & zinn 1994 ) . one has to rely on trgb- or hb - based distances for the dsphs , since they lack the young stellar populations with which cepheid variables are associated . deep @xmath5 and @xmath6 exposures with _ hubble space telescope_/wfpc2 have been used to clearly detect the hb in andi and andii ( da costa et al . 1996 , 2000 ) . the distance estimates for these galaxies are the most accurate of all the m31 dsphs . the hb method provides greater distance accuracy than the trgb method , but hb stars are faint and difficult to photometer accurately , especially in crowded fields , and this makes the method impractical for most ground - based telescopes . moreover , the metallicity dependence of the hb absolute magnitude , @xmath7 , has been the subject of some debate ( cf . ajhar et al . distances based on the trgb method are available for the rest of the m31 dsph satellites . photometry of bright red giants has been carried out with the kpno 4-meter telescope , 3.5-meter wiyn telescope , 6-meter bta telescope at the special astrophysical observatory , and with lris on _ keck ii _ for the following dsphs : andiii ( armandroff et al . 1993 ) , andv ( armandroff , davies , & jacoby 1998 ; grebel & guhathakurta 1998 ) , andvi ( grebel & guhathakurta 1999 ; tikhonov & karachentsev 1999 ; armandroff , davies , & jacoby 1999 ) , and casdsph ( grebel & guhathakurta 1999 ; tikhonov & karachentsev 1999 ) . there are several limitations to the trgb method : it takes a large sample size to define the trgb break accurately ; since the method involves the location of a step in the stellar luminosity function , biases in the distance estimate are caused by blends and photometric errors ; errors in statistical field subtraction can be a problem ; super trgb populations such as intermediate - age agb stars can cause systematic errors . for all the dsphs , there is substantial error on the distances ( see table [ tab : satdata ] ) . additional uncertainty is introduced through the poorly known distance of m31 itself , for which a variety of estimates is available using different methods ; we adopt a distance of 770 kpc . let us assume that the halo of m31 is spherically symmetric with the potential @xmath8 and density @xmath9 given by @xmath10 the satellite galaxies are assumed to follow the same density law @xmath11 but with the scalelength @xmath12 ( cf . , evans & wilkinson 2000 ) . the velocity normalisation @xmath13 is chosen to reproduce the circular speed at @xmath14 of @xmath15 ( braun 1991 ) . we adopt two possibilities for the distribution of velocities . these must depend on the integrals of motion , namely the binding energy @xmath16 and angular momentum @xmath17 per unit mass . the first is a distribution function of form @xmath18 so that the orbital anisotropy @xmath19 is constant . this distribution ranges from radial anisotropy ( @xmath20 ) to tangential anisotropy ( @xmath21 ) . the second is a distribution of osipkov - merritt form ( see binney & tremaine 1987 ) @xmath22 where @xmath23 is an anisotropy radius . this distribution is isotropic in the inner parts ( @xmath24 ) and radially anisotropic in the outer parts ( @xmath25 ) . the functions @xmath26 and @xmath27 are written out elsewhere ( wilkinson & evans 1999 ; evans & wilkinson 2000 ) . mass estimation using bayesian likelihood methods was introduced by little & tremaine ( 1987 ) . bayes theorem states that the probability of any set of model parameters given the data @xmath28 is @xmath29 here , @xmath30 describes our prior beliefs as to the likelihood of the model parameters , while @xmath31 is the probability of the data given the model . for the 15 satellite galaxies , the data consist of three - dimensional positions @xmath32 with respect to the center of andromeda , together with their heliocentric line of sight velocities @xmath33 . these are corrected for the motion of the sun around the galactic center and the infall of the milky way towards andromeda . we assume a circular speed of @xmath34 at the galactocentric radius of the sun ( @xmath35 = 8.0 kpc ) and a solar peculiar velocity in @xmath36 of ( @xmath37 ) = ( @xmath38 ) . the line of sight velocity of m31 , corrected for the motion of the sun , is @xmath39 ( courteau & van den bergh 1999 ) . this gives the velocities @xmath40 in the rest frame of the center of m31 . along any line of sight , let ( @xmath41 ) be polar coordinates in the plane of the sky . then the required probability is given by @xmath42 the prior probabilities contain the _ a priori _ information about the model parameters . for the total mass @xmath43 , we use @xmath44 , while for the velocity anisotropy , we use @xmath45 or @xmath46 ( see wilkinson & evans ( 1999 ) for a discussion ) . the distances to the satellite galaxies are the main uncertainty . our error convolution aims to take account of two factors . first , there is the quoted error estimate @xmath47 associated with each distance given in table [ tab : satdata ] . second , there is a small , but distinct , probability @xmath48 that some of the published distance estimates are seriously in error due to systematic uncertainties ; we assume that the probability of a rogue distance @xmath48 is @xmath49 . therefore , we choose our convolution function @xmath50 to have the form @xmath51 here , @xmath6 is the hat - box function @xmath52 while @xmath53 is the published distance estimate of the @xmath54th satellite with error @xmath47 and @xmath55 and @xmath56 are the maximum and minimum of the distance estimates listed in table [ tab : satdata ] . figure [ fig : figl2b ] shows the results for the constant anisotropy distributions . the most likely mass is @xmath57 and the most likely value of @xmath58 is @xmath590.95 corresponding to tangential anisotropy . an earlier analysis found that there is a tendency to underestimate the mass for small datasets ( evans & wilkinson 2000 ) . this typically leads to an underestimate of the order of a factor of two for a dataset of ten to twenty objects , and is combined with a spread that is of the order of fifty per cent . this gives a final result of @xmath60 . the anisotropy is poorly constrained as the likelihood contours are distended horizontally . however , radial anisotropy is not favored as the @xmath61 contour is concentrated in the tangentially anisotropic portion of the figure . figure [ fig : figom ] shows the results for the osipkov - merritt distribution function . the most likely mass is @xmath62 and the most likely value of @xmath23 is @xmath63 , suggesting the velocity distribution is roughly isotropic . table [ tab : othercases ] shows the effects of varying some of our modelling assumptions on the results for the mass . these include ( i ) the omission of pegasus and ic 1613 , which may not be bound to m31 ( courteau & van den bergh 1999 ) , ( ii ) the alteration of the satellite distances to those compiled by mateo ( 1998 ) , ( iii ) the increase of the error bars on the distances to @xmath64 , ( iv ) the alteration of the scalelength of the satellite galaxy number density distribution and ( v ) the change of the velocity normalisation of the halo @xmath13 . the main change is the removal of pegasus and ic 1613 from the dataset , which cause a roughly 30% drop in the mass estimate . as can be seen from table [ tab : othercases ] , the other alterations do not have a significant effect on the answer . we have presented the first detailed study of the mass of the halo of the andromeda galaxy that uses the radial velocity and distance measurements for all six dsph satellites ( andi , andii , andiii , andv , andvi and casdsph ) . this takes to fifteen the number of tracers at large radii and provides a reasonable sample with which to estimate the total mass . such calculations have not been possible before , because of the unavailability of radial velocity data for the low surface brightness companions of andromeda . spectroscopy of individual red giant stars in these systems has only recently become feasible thanks to 810 meter class telescopes such as _ keck _ and state - of - the - art spectrographs ( ct et al . 1999 ; guhathakurta et al . 2000a , b ) . we reckon that the mass of the andromeda halo is @xmath65 . this comes from analysing all the companion galaxies with a family of velocity distributions of constant orbital anisotropy . the error bars include the statistical effects of the small dataset , as well as the uncertainties in the distance estimators . there is some additional uncertainty from changes in the modelling assumptions but this is at the 30% level at most . for example , altering the velocity distribution gives us a slightly higher estimate of @xmath66 . the most recent estimate of the mass of the milky way is @xmath67 ( wilkinson & evans 1999 ) . all the mass estimates inevitably come with substantial uncertainty , as they are inferred from the small datasets of satellite galaxies that are the only known probes of the distant halo . bearing in mind such caveats , a fair conclusion is that _ the andromeda halo is very roughly as massive as that of the milky way_. there seems little evidence from the satellite galaxy motions for the widely held belief that the andromeda halo is more massive than that of the milky way ( e.g. , peebles 1996 ) . indeed , such evidence as there is points in the opposite direction , namely that the andromeda halo may actually be slightly less massive . rrrr@lr@lrrc name & & & & & & & type + + m31 & 121.2 & @xmath70 & 770 & @xmath71 & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath59 & @xmath59 & sbi - ii + + m32 & 121.1 & @xmath74 & 770 & @xmath71 & @xmath75 & @xmath76 & 5 & @xmath77 & e2 + ngc 205 & 120.7 & @xmath78 & 830 & @xmath79 & @xmath80 & @xmath76 & 61 & @xmath81 & dsph + ngc 147 & 119.8 & @xmath82 & 755 & @xmath79 & @xmath83 & @xmath76 & 100 & @xmath84 & dsph / de5 + ngc 185 & 120.8 & @xmath85 & 620 & @xmath86 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & 173 & @xmath89 & dsph / de3 + m33 & 133.6 & @xmath90 & 850 & @xmath71 & @xmath91 & @xmath73 & 225 & @xmath92 & scii - iii + ic 10 & 119.0 & @xmath93 & 660 & @xmath94 & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & 253 & @xmath97 & dirr + lgs3 & 126.8 & @xmath98 & 810 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & 276 & @xmath102 & dirr / dsph + pegasus & 94.8 & @xmath103 & 760 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & @xmath106 & 409 & @xmath107 & dirr / dsph + ic 1613 & 129.7 & @xmath108 & 715 & @xmath79 & @xmath109 & @xmath96 & 504 & @xmath110 & irrv + + + andi & 121.7 & @xmath111 & 790 & @xmath112 & @xmath113 & @xmath106 & 49 & @xmath114 & dsph + andii & 128.9 & @xmath115 & 680 & @xmath86 & @xmath116 & @xmath76 & 158 & @xmath117 & dsph + andiii & 119.3 & @xmath118 & 760 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 & @xmath121 & 67 & @xmath110 & dsph + andv & 126.2 & @xmath122 & 810 & @xmath123 & @xmath124 & @xmath101 & 118 & @xmath125 & dsph + andvi & 106.0 & @xmath126 & 775 & @xmath79 & @xmath127 & @xmath76 & 265 & @xmath128 & dsph + casdsph & 128.5 & @xmath129 & 760 & @xmath119 & @xmath130 & @xmath106 & 244 & @xmath131 & dsph + + ccccccccc comment & most likely & most likely & & most likely & most likely + & @xmath58 & @xmath43 & & @xmath23 & @xmath43 + + canonical & @xmath132 & 7.0 & & 680 & 9.4 + pegasus & ic 1613 & @xmath133 & 4.8 & & 224 & 6.8 + omitted & & & & & + sat . distances & @xmath134 & 8.7 & & 659 & 11.2 + altered & & & & & + @xmath135 & @xmath132 & 8.1 & & 610 & 10.8 @xmath136 kpc & @xmath133 & 7.6 & & 627 & 11.1 + @xmath137 & @xmath133 & 7.0 & & 697 & 9.3 @xmath138 & @xmath133 & 7.6 & & 648 & 10.2 + + | the last few months have seen the measurements of the radial velocities of all of the dwarf spheroidal companions to the andromeda galaxy ( m31 ) using the spectrographs ( hires and lris ) on the _ keck telescope_. this paper summarises the data on the radial velocities and distances for all the companion galaxies and presents new dynamical modelling to estimate the mass of extended halo of m31 . the best fit values for the total mass of m31 are @xmath0 , depending on the details of the modelling . the mass estimate is accompanied by considerable uncertainty caused by the smallness of the dataset ; for example , the upper bound on the total mass is @xmath1 , while the lower bound is @xmath2 . these values are less than the most recent estimates of the most likely mass of the milky way halo . bearing in mind all the uncertainties , a fair conclusion is that the m31 halo is roughly as massive as that of the milky way halo . there is no dynamical evidence for the widely held belief that m31 is more massive it may even be less massive . = cmcsc10 # 1#2 # 1to 0pt#1 |
1701.04026 | in this article we revisit the notion of _ state _ : when it is preceded by the adjective _ pure _ it is commonly understood within _ quantum _ formalism as a unit ray in an hilbert space . we revisit the way a state is transformed through the action of an operator named _ quantum observable _ , and the way it evolves with the introduction in the formalism of an evolution parameter , i.e. a _ time_. hilbert spaces in quantum physics are usually vector spaces on complex numbers , and are infinite - dimensional for many of them . here , our approach is utterly minimalist , not only for pedagogical purposes , but also to show that quantum formalism applies as well to unexpected situations , far beyond our modelling of the microscopical world . it is minimalist in the sense that our departure point is the two - dimensional hilbert space on the real numbers , i.e. the euclidean plane , denoted @xmath5 , so familiar to us since , say , the kindergarden - grade 12 . think about the following quote extracted from common core state standards initiative @xcite _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ although there are many types of geometry , school mathematics is devoted primarily to plane euclidean geometry , studied both synthetically ( without coordinates ) and analytically ( with coordinates ) . euclidean geometry is characterized most importantly by the parallel postulate , that through a point not on a given line there is exactly one parallel line . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ besides parallel lines , _ vector _ is also a central concept of euclidean geometry , and the terminology associated to it can be a source of confusions , as exemplified by the following question asked on march 23 2013 at 22:15 on the site _ math.stackexchange.com_ , _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ i m trying to understand the difference between the sense , orientation , and direction of a vector . according to this , sense is specified by two points on a line parallel to a vector . orientation is specified by the relationship between the vector and given reference lines ( which i m interpreting to be some basis ) . _ _ however , these two definitions seem to be synonymous with direction . how do these 3 terms differ ? _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the most clear , detailed , correct in our sense , answer was given on january 1 2014 , at 9:44 , as _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ here is how i think of it , let s construct a vector from scratch using just two points in space @xmath6 , @xmath7 . draw a line segment between the two points @xmath6 , @xmath7 . the magnitude of the line segment is the `` length '' of the vector . the `` orientation '' of the line segment we can define as the angle that the line segment makes with the horizontal axis . to be clear this angle is measured counterclockwise from the positive @xmath8 axis and is an angle between @xmath9 and @xmath10 . ok so far we just have a line segment that is situated on the plane somewhere and we know how it is oriented , but there is no arrowhead yet . now the last thing you need is the `` sense '' , that basically tells you where to put the arrowhead and implies an order . we can define this vector as @xmath11 with an arrow over it , where you read it as the vector starting from @xmath6 and ending at @xmath7 . _ _ more generally you can define a vector by defining its magnitude ( length ) , its orientation , and then its sense . but keeping in mind , technically a vector is an equivalence class . so there are an infinite number of vectors which are parallel to each other ( have the same orientation ) and have the same sense or same choice of where to put the arrowhead ( there are only two possible senses , since the arrowhead can be placed on @xmath6 or on @xmath7 ) . but i do nt want to confuse you . usually we discuss vectors that are situated at the origin so we do nt concern ourselves over other equivalent vectors . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hence , a unit ray in the euclidean plane is an orientation associated to an angle @xmath12 , equivalently to a point of the upper unit semi - circle deleted of its left boundary point . it is the unit circle @xmath13 where diametrically opposed points are made identical , i.e. @xmath14 as a physical realization of this set , we immediately think of the compass without considering the sense , i.e , by identifying north with south , east with west , .... , or even better , to the familiar protractor shown in figure [ protractor ] . is clearly apparent on the picture , with @xmath15 , @xmath16 , etc , sign minus being attributed to the internal graduation.,width=480 ] the true compass orientations @xmath17 senses are described by the unit circle itself . in order to avoid notational complications , we consider in this paper states as elements of the latter , keeping in mind the possibility to view as equivalent two diametrically opposed points . now , multiplying a unit vector or a ray by a real number has a deep signification both in euclidean geometry as in quantum formalism , since it lies at the heart of the superposition principle , which states that any linear combination of two vectors is a vector , and that a new unit vector or ray is built from this vector , if it is not zero , by dividing it by its length . an appreciable part of the material presented here is borrowed from references @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . the article is organized as follows . in section [ r2dirac ] we briefly recall the definition of hilbert space before rewriting the language of euclidean geometry by using _ bra _ and _ ket _ dirac notations . we then describe _ pure _ or _ mixed _ states , and symmetric @xmath18 matrices as observables in these real hilbert spaces . in section [ intquant ] we proceed with the integral quantization of the circle , after a rapid survey of the method . this method allows us to give in a straightforward way the quantum counterparts of classical models such as functions ( and even distributions ) defined on the circle . some probabilistic aspects of the obtained quantum objects and of their _ semi - classical _ portraits are examined in great details . section [ evolution ] is devoted to the description of a quantum dynamics adapted to our model . indeed , an adaptation is necessary since we are supposed to use real numbers , vectors and matrices in our quantum formalism , and the latter can not be derived from the quantization of some phase space . such a classical object does not exist in our formalism , and so our quantum dynamics can not be derived from an hamiltonian system . if we want to use quantum dynamics _ la _ dirac , we are forced to introduce at a certain stage pure imaginary numbers . hence , the most general hamiltonian compatible with the equation ruling the quantum evolution of symmetric @xmath18 real matrices must be a symmetric complex matrix . on the other hand , we can deal with a formalism using real numbers only and leading to a kind of majorana evolution equation . then unitary evolution operators are just @xmath18 rotation matrices , as expected in two - dimensional euclidean geometry . in section [ entanglement ] , we address the question of entanglement of two systems with states in the euclidean plane . states of such objects are elements of the tensor product @xmath19 . now , because of the elementary identity @xmath20 , this tensor product is isomorphic to @xmath21 ( and also to @xmath22 ) . since the plane @xmath5 can be also viewed as the complex plane @xmath23 , we get the possibility of understanding initial entangled objects either as elements of the more elementary complex hilbert spaces @xmath2 , e.g. , the space of quantum one - half spins , or as elements of the quaternion field @xmath3 . this set of possibilities sheds an interesting light on entangled objects viewed as cat states in @xmath2 . the purpose of section [ magnint ] is to give a physical exemple of the quantum hamiltonian appearing in euclidean plane quantum dynamics . this is done by considering for instance a charged spin one half particle , e.g. , an electron , interacting with a magnetic field with constant direction in the plane . the demonstration rests upon an integral quantization of the 2-sphere @xmath24 viewed as the phase space with canonical coordinates @xmath25 , where @xmath26 has the meaning of an angular momentum and @xmath27 is the azimutal angle . in section [ conclu ] we present some interesting perpectives of generalisations of the content of our work , centred on the continuation of the game @xmath28 ( as vector spaces ) with @xmath29 ( as vector spaces ) , the latter cartesian product being given an octonionic structure . in appendix [ pararho ] we describe different parametrizations of real @xmath30 density matrices together with interesting properties . quaternions in different languages and their basic properties are described in appendix [ allsu2 ] , by insisting on their @xmath31 representation . in appendix [ unitsphere ] we present the integral quantization of the @xmath0-sphere which is needed to establish our result in section [ magnint ] . we first recall that a finite - dimensional hilbert space is a finite - dimensional real or complex vector space @xmath32 equipped with a scalar ( or dot or inner ) product @xmath33 or @xmath23 , between any pair of vectors @xmath34 , @xmath35 , with the following properties @xmath36 where @xmath37 , @xmath38 , in are arbitrary complex or real numbers , and encodes the _ semi - definiteness _ of the scalar product . in the case of real vector space , the scalar product is fully symmetric and bilinear . hence , it is clear that the two - dimensional real vector space equipped with the usual dot product , i.e. the euclidean plane @xmath5 , is the simplest non - trivial hilbert space . we now adopt the dirac notations for vectors in @xmath5 after restoring the familiar arrow or hat superscripts and boldface symbols . given the orthonormal basis of @xmath5 defined by the two familiar unit vectors @xmath39 and @xmath40 , as is shown in figure [ r2fig ] , any vector @xmath41 in the plane decomposes as @xmath42 we also use in the sequel the column vector notation to designate @xmath41 with implicit mention of orthonormal basis , @xmath43 in such a way that the dirac _ ket _ and _ bra _ notations become transparent , @xmath44 hence , elementary matrix calculus allows to formulate scalar product and ( orthogonal ) projector in _ bra ket _ ( respectively in _ ket bra _ ) notations : @xmath45 since we view the euclidean plane as a space of quantum states , pure states are identified with unit vectors , discarding , as announced in the introduction , the imposed equivalence between opposed senses along the orientation support . hence , the unit circle @xmath13 in the plane is the natural set of parameters which distinguish these states . to each @xmath46 , polar angle of the unit vector @xmath47 , corresponds the pure state @xmath48 . in particular , with these notations and associated quantum terminology , the horizontal orientation " or _ spin up _ state is @xmath49 , @xmath50 is the vertical orientation " or _ spin down _ state . their quality to form an orthonormal basis is encoded in the relations @xmath51 together with the fact that the sum of their corresponding orthogonal projectors _ resolves the unity _ @xmath52 ( 60,60 ) ( 10,20)(1,0)30 ( 10,20)(0,1)30 ( 43 , 24)(0,0)@xmath53 ( 29 , 52)(0,0)@xmath54 ( 45 , 41)(0,0)(quantum ) state in `` spin representation '' ( 10 , 16.5)(0,0)@xmath55 ( 30 , 10)(0,0)@xmath56 ( 30 , 1)(0,0)@xmath57 ( 8 , 52)(0,0)@xmath58 ( 16 , 38)(0,0)@xmath59 ( 20 , 26)(0,0)@xmath27 ( 14,20)(10,15)[tr ] ( 10,20)(1,2)14 pursuing with our quantum terminology , the spin representation of a pure state lies in the form of the expansion or decomposition @xmath60 there exists another representation which could be abusively named `` phase space '' , as will become clearer in the next section . it is the `` unit circle '' representation given by the trigonometric function @xmath61 however , we should be aware that in our model there is no quantum observable underlying localisation on the whole unit circle , at the difference of ordinary quantum mechanics for which there exists a position operator , @xmath62 , underlying configuration representation , or a momentum operator , @xmath63 , underlying momentum representation . on the other hand , we know that in ordinary quantum mechanics there is no sharp localisation in the corresponding phase space @xmath64 due to the non commutativity of these two operators ( heisenberg ! ) . a similar situation is encountered here with the fuzzy localisation exemplified by the probability distribution families on the unit circle derived from , @xmath65 to the pure state @xmath66 corresponds the orthogonal projector @xmath67 given by : @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the matrix of rotation in the plane by the angle @xmath27 , @xmath70 in quantum formalism , the projector @xmath71 is also called pure state . this designation is consistent with the fact that the projector ignores orientation , @xmath72 . then , _ mixed states _ or _ density matrices _ are unit trace and non - negative matrices of the form @xmath73 with @xmath74 the conditions express the non - negativeness of @xmath75 , i.e. @xmath76 for all @xmath77 . pure states are rank - one such matrices corresponding to @xmath78 , i.e. @xmath79 . more details are given in subsection [ ssecqcirc ] and in appendix [ pararho ] . a more enlightening parametrisation is given in terms of the highest eigenvalue @xmath80 , @xmath81 given in and polar angle @xmath27 , @xmath82 of the corresponding pure eigenstate @xmath77 pointing toward the upper half - plane . introducing the parameter @xmath83 , @xmath84 , the most general form of a real density matrix can be given , as a @xmath85-periodic matrix , in terms of the polar coordinates @xmath86 of a point in the upper half unit disk : @xmath87 this expression epitomizes the map from the closed unit disk to the set of density matrices . more precisely , each @xmath88 is univocally ( but not biunivocally ) determined by a point in the unit disk @xmath89 , with polar coordinates @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath92 . we check that for @xmath93 the density matrix is just the orthogonal projector on the unit vector @xmath77 with polar angle @xmath27 , i.e. @xmath94 . the parameter @xmath95 can be viewed as a measure of the distance of @xmath75 to the pure state @xmath67 while @xmath96 measures the degree of mixing " . a statistical interpretation is made possible through the von neumann entropy@xcite defined as @xmath97 as a function of @xmath98 $ ] @xmath99 is nonnegative , concave and symmetric with respect to its maximum value @xmath100 at @xmath101 , which corresponds to @xmath102 . the graph of @xmath99 as a function of @xmath95 is presented in figure [ srho1 ] . in fact , this function is the basic boltzmann - gibbs or shannon entropy in the case of two possibilities with probabilities @xmath80 and @xmath103 . as a function of parameter @xmath104$].,width=288 ] according to the canons of quantum formalism , a quantum observable is a self - adjoint operator in the hilbert space of quantum states , because self - adjointness is essential in the copenhagen - dirac - von neumann interpretation of quantum physics @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite . indeed , the spectral theorem for bounded or unbounded self - adjoint operators is the key for ( sharp ) quantum measurement , as it was mentioned above . in our case , a self - adjoint operator @xmath6 is represented by a @xmath30 real symmetric matrix and its spectral decomposition reads in terms of the two orthogonal projectors corresponding to its real eigenvalues : @xmath105 an immediate example is provided by the spin representation , which is also understood through the superposition of the two basic projectors @xmath106 in terms of quantum measurement , this decomposition means that the observable `` orientation '' assumes two values only : @xmath107 , associated to the projector on the horizontal or spin up state @xmath108 and the other one , @xmath109 , associated to the projector on the vertical or spin down @xmath110 . those measurements of orientation with only two issues are sharp in the sense that the corresponding projectors are orthogonal . at this point , we understand why no angular sharp localisation can be established on the unit circle . by sharp localisation we mean the existence of an angle operator @xmath6 acting as a multiplication operator in `` angle '' representation @xmath111 . such an operator does not existe because no @xmath30 real symmetric matrix @xmath6 can satisfy the equation @xmath112 , for all @xmath113 . three basic matrices generate the jordan algebra @xcite of all real symmetric @xmath18 matrices . they are the identity matrix and the two real pauli matrices , @xmath114 any element @xmath6 of the algebra decomposes as : @xmath115 the product in this algebra is defined by @xmath116 which entails on the level of components @xmath117 , the relations : @xmath118 in this context , a pure state @xmath77 in the plane can be viewed as the eigenstate of a system , e.g. a spin @xmath119 , for the eigenvalue @xmath120 of the following operator @xmath121 whereas it is eigenstate of @xmath122 for the eigenvalue @xmath123 . it is interesting to notice that the density operator can be expressed in terms of @xmath124 as @xmath125 any quantization of functions defined on a set @xmath126 ( e.g. a phase space or something else ) should reasonably meet four basic requirements @xcite : it is a linear map @xmath127 : @xmath128 where * @xmath129 is a vector space of complex or real - valued functions @xmath130 on a set @xmath126 , i.e. a `` classical '' mathematical model , * @xmath131 is a vector space of linear operators in some real or complex hilbert space @xmath132 , i.e , a `` quantum '' mathematical model . the map is such that the function @xmath133 is mapped to the identity operator @xmath134 on @xmath132 , a real @xmath135 is mapped to a self - adjoint operator @xmath136 in @xmath132 or , at least , a symmetric operator ( in the infinite dimensional case ) if @xmath126 is acted on by a symmetry group @xmath137 , i.e. for @xmath138 , @xmath139 , then there exists a unitary representation @xmath140 of the group such that @xmath141 , with @xmath142 . in our case , @xmath132 is finite - dimensional and the operators @xmath143 can be viewed as matrices . of course , further requirements are necessarily added , depending on the mathematical structures equipping @xmath126 and @xmath129 and their respective physical relevance . an easy way to achieve the above minimal programme is to use resources offered by some adapted integral calculus . suppose that the set @xmath126 is equipped with a measure @xmath144 allowing to deal with integrals like @xmath145 , in which the functions @xmath146 are matrix valued , the integral being performed on each matrix element . now , suppose that there exists an @xmath126-labeled family of matrices @xmath147 resolving the identity @xmath134 in the following sense : @xmath148 the case we are specially interested in occurs when the @xmath149 s are unit trace and non - negative , i.e. are density matrices , @xmath150 because of their possible probabilistic content ( see below ) . with this material at hand , the integral quantization of functions @xmath130 on @xmath126 is the linear map @xmath151 which fulfills at least our quantization requirements ( i ) and ( ii ) and it takes the classical function @xmath130 to the operator @xmath143 . if the matrices @xmath149 are real symmetric , then ( iii ) is also satisfied . to get ( iv ) , i.e. covariance , we need to add more structure on the measure space @xmath152 . such structures will appear in a natural way in the examples we consider in this paper , namely the circle , @xmath153 , and the sphere , @xmath154 . any quantization map should be complemented by a dequantization " map , associating to @xmath143 a function @xmath155 , more or less similar to the original @xmath130 , and giving a semi - classical portrait " of @xmath143 . in quantum mechanics , examples are provided by the husimi function or the wigner function@xcite , more generally by lower ( lieb ) @xcite or contravariant ( berezin ) @xcite symbols . the terminology _ lower _ , which will appear below together with _ upper _ , is justified by the two berezin - lieb inequalities which follow from the symbol formalism . as a matter of fact , some properties of the operator @xmath136 , may be derived or at least well grasped from functional properties of its lower symbol , which is defined in the present context by : @xmath156 when @xmath157 ( density matrix ) for all @xmath8 , this new function is the local average of the original @xmath135 with respect to the probability distribution @xmath158 with respect the measure @xmath159 : @xmath160 in many cases , this generalisation of convolution has a regularising effect on the original @xmath135 . for instance , if @xmath161 is a dirac peaked at @xmath162 , @xmath163 for any test function @xmath164 , then @xmath165 , a function which is expected to be more regular around @xmath166 . here , the measure space @xmath167 is the unit circle equipped with its uniform ( lebesgue ) measure : @xmath168 the hilbert space is the euclidean plane @xmath169 . note that @xmath13 is also a group , isomorphic to the abelian group so@xmath4 of rotations in the plane . thus , we can expect that rotational covariance mentioned in point ( iv ) plays a central role here . it is indeed the case since the covariance property described in appendix [ pararho ] allows one to define the family of density operators obtained from rotational transport of the initial density operator introduced in , @xmath170 where the rotation matrix @xmath171 is defined by . it is straightforward to prove that this family resolves the identity @xmath172 the proof can be made by hand , integrating each matrix element . actually it is the direct consequence of a famous result in group representation theory , named schur s lemma @xcite . it follows the @xmath13-labelled family of probability distributions on @xmath173 @xmath174 such an expression reminds us of the cardioid distribution ( see @xcite , page 51 ) . at @xmath175 we get the uniform probability on the circle whereas at @xmath93 we get the simplified resolution of the identity @xmath176 and the pure state probability distribution @xmath177 previously introduced in . at given @xmath95 and @xmath178 a distance @xmath179 on the circle is defined as @xmath180 where the subscript @xmath181 refers to the hilbertian norm @xmath182 defined on matrices @xmath6 @xcite . the quantization of a function ( or distribution ) @xmath183 on the circle based on leads to the 2@xmath1842 matrix operator @xmath185 where @xmath186 is the average of @xmath135 on the unit circle and @xmath187 . the symbols @xmath188 and @xmath189 are for the cosine and sine doubled angle fourier coefficients of @xmath135 , @xmath190 the simplest function to be quantized is the angle function @xmath191 , i.e. the @xmath192-periodic extension of @xmath193 for @xmath46 , @xmath194 its eigenvalues are @xmath195 with corresponding eigenvectors @xmath196 . its lower symbol is given by the smooth function @xmath197 the existence of the set @xmath198 as the particular case @xmath93 and @xmath199 of the density matrices permits to proceed with the simplified coherent state " integral quantization @xmath200 the quantized version of the angle function @xmath201 introduced above becomes : @xmath202 with eigenvalues @xmath203 . thus , a localisation measurement on the circle would yield those two values only , along the spectral decomposition @xmath204 with @xmath205 the family of pure states @xmath206 allows one to carry out the symbol calculus _ la _ berezin - lieb mentioned above . to any _ self - adjoint _ operator @xmath6 one associates the two types of _ symbol _ , functions @xmath207 et @xmath208 respectively defined on the unit circle by @xmath209 and @xmath210 where @xmath208 is named upper or contravariant symbol of @xmath6 , besides the fact that it is also the classical counterpart of @xmath6 in the context of integral quantization . the simplest upper symbols and the lower symbols of non - trivial basic elements are respectively given by : @xmath211 for the symmetric matrix ( [ msym13 ] ) there follows the two symbols : @xmath212 for instance , the lower symbol of the quantum angle ( [ qangle13 ] ) is equal to @xmath213 a @xmath85-periodic function that smoothly varies between the two eigenvalues of @xmath214 , as is shown in figure [ quantangle13 ] . -periodic function @xmath215 that varies between the two eigenvalues of @xmath214.,width=384 ] one should notice that all the symbols defined above belong to the subspace @xmath216 of real fourier series that is the linear span of the three functions @xmath59 , @xmath217 , @xmath218 . hence @xmath208 is highly non unique since it is defined up to the addition of any function @xmath219 lying in the orthogonal complement of @xmath216 , i.e. such that @xmath220 . let us make explicit the berezin - lieb inequalities in the present context . let @xmath221 be a convex function . denoting by @xmath222 the eigenvalues of the symmetric matrix @xmath6 , we have @xmath223 this double inequality is not trivial . independently of the euclidean context it reads as : @xmath224 where @xmath225 and @xmath226 denotes the mean value on a period . if one applies ( [ berlieb13 ] ) to the exponential function @xmath227 , we get an intertwining of inequalities involving bessel functions of the second kind and the hyperbolic cosine : @xmath228 behind the resolution of the identity lies an interesting interpretation in terms of geometrical probability . let us consider a borel@xcite subset @xmath229 of the interval @xmath230 and the restriction to @xmath229 of the integral : @xmath231 one easily verifies the following properties : @xmath232 the application @xmath233 defines a normalized measure on the @xmath234-algebra @xcite of the borel sets in the interval @xmath230 , assuming its values in the set of positive or null @xmath30 matrices ( povm ) . let us now put into evidence the probabilistic nature of the measure @xmath235 . let @xmath236 be a unit vector . the application @xmath237 is clearly a probability measure , since it involves precisely the distribution @xmath238 introduced in . for instance , for @xmath239 $ ] and @xmath240 , we have @xmath241\right)= \frac{\theta_2-\theta_1}{2\pi } - \frac{1}{\pi}\sin\left(\theta_2-\theta_1\right ) \sin\left(\theta_2+\theta_1\right)\ , .\ ] ] now , the quantity @xmath242 means that direction @xmath243 is examined from the point of view of the family of vectors @xmath244 . as a matter of fact , it has a _ geometrical probability _ interpretation in the plane @xcite . with no loss of generality let us choose @xmath240 . recall here the canonical equation describing a straight line @xmath245 in the plane : @xmath246 where @xmath247 is the direction normal to @xmath245 and the parameter @xmath248 is equal to the distance of @xmath245 to the origin . there follows that @xmath249 is the ( non - normalized ) probability measure element on the set @xmath250 of the lines randomly chosen in the plane . picking a certain @xmath27 , consider the set @xmath251 of the lines normal to @xmath252 that intersect the segment with origin @xmath55 and length @xmath253 equal to the projection of @xmath252 onto @xmath254 as shown in figure [ probge13 ] ( 8,6 ) ( 5.1,4.9)(0,-1)3.9 ( 2.8,.6)o ( 7.5,1.3)@xmath254 ( 5.2,5)@xmath255 ( 3.1,1)(1,2)2 ( 3.1,1)(1,0)4.67 ( 2.1,1.5)(.1,.2)5(2,-1)2.7 ( 3.1,.1)@xmath256 0.5 cm the measure of this set is equal to : @xmath257 integrating ( [ measline13 ] ) over all directions @xmath252 gives the area of the unit circle . hence we can construct @xmath258 as the probability for a straight line in the plane to belong to the set of secants of segments that are projections @xmath259 of the unit vectors @xmath252 , @xmath260 , onto the unit vector @xmath243 . one could think in terms of _ polarizer _ @xmath261 and _ analyzer _ `` sandwiching '' the directional signal @xmath236 . as was asserted in the introduction , from a strictly quantum point of view , we should have made equivalent any vector @xmath263 of the euclidean plane with its symmetric @xmath264 , which amounts to deal with the half - plane viewed as the coset @xmath265 . following the same procedure as above , we start from the hilbert space @xmath266 and we choose the subset @xmath267 that is orthonormal . note that @xmath268 and @xmath269 are now exactly wigner semicircle distributions @xcite . we then consider the continuous family of pure states or coherent states @xmath270 . they are normalized and they solve the identity ( just change the factor @xmath271 into @xmath272 ) . the previous material can be repeated _ in extenso _ but with the restriction that @xmath12 . we now deal with the question of the existence of a quantum dynamics compatible with the simplicity of our model . let us introduce into the game a time ( or evolution ) parameter @xmath273 . can we associate with it a self - adjoint hamiltonian or energy operator @xmath274 , i.e. a @xmath18 real symmetric matrix @xmath274 ? a first problem concerns the construction of @xmath274 without the existence of a classical phase space as a guidance . let us circumvent this difficulty by simply postulating its existence . then , another issue makes our effort totally pointless . indeed , if we rely on the copenhagen - dirac - von neumann canons @xcite , the evolution of a time - dependent quantum observable or state is ruled by the equation @xmath275 + \ii \hbar\frac{\partial a}{\partial t}\ , .\ ] ] the presence of the imaginary unit @xmath276 in is unavoidable since the latter has to be a relation between symmetric operators acting in complex hilbert spaces . on the other hand , we want to keep the reality of our euclidean plane and of the matrices acting on it . thus , this number @xmath276 should be canceled because of its appearance somewhere on the right - hand side of . the only place where it can stand lies in the expression of @xmath274 as a @xmath18 complex symmetric matrix , and we easily check that the most general allowed matrix form of @xmath274 is @xmath277 actually the diagonal hamiltonian parameter @xmath278 does not play any role . moreover @xmath279 can be time - dependent . hence , no real symmetric matrix , except the trivial multiple of the identity , can represent an hamiltonian in the context of our approach . if we wish to keep real our matrices , we have to abandon the requirement of being symmetric . instead , let us introduce the real `` pseudo - hamiltonian '' @xmath280 then , by dividing by @xmath276 the evolution equation , one obtains an equation involving only real quantities , our _ baby majorana equation _ @xcite , @xmath281 + \hbar\frac{\partial a}{\partial t } \ , .\ ] ] the price to pay with our manipulation is that the eigenvalues @xmath282 of @xmath283 are real only in the trivial case @xmath284 : no physical energy comes out from our formalism . on the other hand , if @xmath279 is constant , the pseudo - hamiltonian @xmath283 may generate unitary time evolution . more precisely , in the case of time explicit independence of @xmath6 , the integration of is straightforward : @xmath285 i.e. the appearance of the @xmath30 proper rotation matrix in the plane as the solely possible continuous unitary operator in the plane is unescapable . in the case of the time evolution of a pure state @xmath286 , this solution corresponds to a uniform rotation , with frequency @xmath287 , of the unit vector @xmath288 . on the algebraic side , we note that our real quantum dynamics involves the antisymmetric matrix @xmath289 . together with @xmath290 and @xmath291 these 3 matrices generate the lie algebra @xmath292 of the group sl@xmath293 @xmath294= 2\sigma_3\ , , \quad [ \tau_2,\sigma_3]= 2\sigma_1\ , , \quad [ \sigma_3,\sigma_1]= -2\tau_2= 2\tau_2\,.\ ] ] if we had sticked to the complex formalism imposed by , we would have to introduce the third pauli matrix @xmath295 , which was missing in . then the self - adjointness of @xmath274 is preserved , and quantum evolution restores the full real lie algebra of su@xmath4 generated by the @xmath296 s , @xmath297 . actually , we will use in section [ magnint ] the equation for presenting a physical example of . the possible entanglement property of quantum states appears with the construction of tensor products @xcite of hilbert spaces for describing quantum states of composite systems . in the present case , we are in presence of a remarkable sequence of vector space isomorphisms due to the fact that @xmath298 : @xmath299 where @xmath3 is the field of quaternions ( see appendix [ allsu2 ] for definition and properties of these objects ) . let us first write the ( canonical ) orthonormal basis of the tensor product @xmath300 , the first factor being for system `` @xmath6 '' and the other for system `` @xmath7 '' , as latexmath:[\[\label{tensbas } these factors @xmath108 , @xmath302 pertaining to @xmath6 or to @xmath7 , are termed `` @xmath303-bit '' or qubit " in standard language of quantum information . they can be associated to a pointer measuring the horizontal ( resp . vertical ) direction or polarisation described by the state @xmath108 ( resp . @xmath302 ) . we now introduce the celebrated bell pure states @xcite in @xmath300 as special linear superpositions of the above basis elements @xmath304 or in matrix form , @xmath305 they form an orthonormal basis of @xmath300 . they are four specific _ maximally entangled _ quantum states of two qubits . `` maximally '' refers to the degree to which a state in a quantum system consisting of two entities is entangled . this degree is measured by the von neumann entropy @xcite of either of the two reduced density operators of the state , i.e. , obtained by tracing out one of the partners in the composite systems . they exhibit perfect correlation . consider for instance the state @xmath306 . if the pointer associated to @xmath6 measures its qubit in the standard basis the outcome would be perfectly random , either possibility having probability 1/2 . but if the pointer associated to @xmath7 then measures its qubit , the outcome , although random for it alone , is the same as the one @xmath6 gets . there is quantum correlation . let us now turn our attention to the complex two - dimensional hilbert space @xmath2 , one of the most familiar mathematical objects in our initiation to quantum formalism , after having been so nicely popularised by feynman @xcite with examples like two - level atom or spin one - half objects . now , as a complex vector space , @xmath2 , with canonical basis @xmath307 , @xmath308 , has a real structure . the latter is isomorphic to the real vector space @xmath309 , itself isomorphic to @xmath19 , from the above . a standard real structure is obtained by considering the vector expansion @xmath310 i.e. , by writing @xmath311 , @xmath312 , and considering the set of vectors @xmath313 as forming a basis of @xmath309 . now , we need to define a map from this @xmath309 to @xmath19 , forgetting about the superfluous subscripts @xmath6 and @xmath7 . for this , we use the map euclidean plane @xmath5 @xmath314 complex `` plane '' @xmath23 determined by @xmath315 or , in matrix form , @xmath316 interpreting @xmath2 as the space of quantum states of a two - level system , e.g. spin one - half with notations @xmath317 the correspondances and might be interpreted as giving a real composite nature to `` up '' and down " complex objects . note that the @xmath318-matrix on the right of is its own inverse . finally , we get the matrix map from the bell basis and the basis @xmath319 in terms of components of vectors in their respective spaces , @xmath320 equivalently , in complex notations , with @xmath321 , @xmath322 where we have introduced the conjugation operator @xmath323 , i.e. the mirror symmetry with respect to the real axis , @xmath324 being the mirror symmetry with respect to the imaginary axis . note that the operator @xmath325 can be expressed in the quaternionic language for su@xmath4 , as introduced in , by @xmath326 therefore , with the above choice of isomorphisms , bell entanglement in @xmath327 is represented by a linear superposition in @xmath2 . it involves also the two mirror symmetries @xmath328 . interpreting @xmath2 as in , we see that the operator @xmath329 is a kind of `` flip '' whereas `` cat '' operator @xmath325 builds from the _ up _ and _ down _ basic states the two elementary schrdinger cats @xmath330 we can now understand better the real bell state nature of these elementary cat superpositions if we remember the identification between composite real states and complex _ up _ and _ down _ basic states . interesting too is the appearance of the flip @xmath329 in the construction of the spin one - half coherent state defined in terms of spherical coordinates @xmath331 by @xmath332 indeed , they result from the action on the up state by the operator @xmath333 given in . this operator represents the element @xmath334 in su@xmath4 , quaternionic conjugate or inverse of @xmath335 . the latter corresponds through the homomorphism so@xmath336 @xmath314 su@xmath4 to the specific rotation @xmath337 that maps the unit vector pointing to the north pole , @xmath338 , to @xmath339 , as is shown in figure [ rotkton ] and explained at length in appendix [ allsu2 ] : @xmath340 now we notice that the second column of @xmath333 is precisely the flip of the first one , @xmath341 actually , this feature is the key for grasping the isomorphisms @xmath342 . with the notations of appendix [ allsu2 ] and using quaternionic algebra , e.g. , @xmath343 @xmath17 even permutations , @xmath344 after identifying @xmath345 , as both are roots of @xmath123 . then the flip appears naturally in the final identification @xmath346 as @xmath347 the fact that the sole acceptable form the hamiltonian may assume in our model is might suggest a kind of magnetic field interacting with some one - half spin magnetic moment . how can we integrate this physics in our toy model ? the ( potential ) energy of a magnetic moment @xmath348 ( whatever the origin of the latter ) submitted to a magnetic field @xmath349 is given by @xmath350 in the case of a moving charge , the magnetic moment is proportional to the angular momentum of the latter . here we consider a magnetic moment as a physical system on its own , without any consideration of space location or something else , and proportional to an angular momentum or classical spin denoted by @xmath351 : @xmath352 the factor @xmath353 is usually named gyromagnetic factor . now , the energy of a magnetic moment submitted to a constant magnetic field alone is conserved . choosing the direction of the unit vector @xmath354 , part of the orthonormal basis in space @xmath355 , as the same as @xmath349 , we have for the hamiltonian @xmath356 and so the polar angle @xmath357 is conserved : the magnetic moment experiences a precession about the @xmath354-axis at constant azimuthal velocity @xmath358 in such a way that @xmath359 is also conserved . actually , this precession motion which takes place on the surface of a sphere @xmath360 of radius @xmath361 has to be viewed as a phase trajectory in @xmath360 , the latter being as the classical phase space for the magnetic moment . the canonical conjugate coordinates are in the present case action - angle variables , the angle variable being the azimuthal angle @xmath27 whereas the action variable @xmath362 is precisely @xmath363 . indeed , from the expression @xmath364 of the rotational invariant measure on @xmath360 , one infers that @xmath363 is canonically conjugate to @xmath27 , and the action variable defined as @xmath365 is identical to @xmath363 in the case of a constant external magnetic field . note that the pair @xmath366 are a part of the cylindrical coordinates of the sphere @xmath360 with radius @xmath361 . let us turn our attention to the quantum model of a magnetic moment interacting with a constant magnetic field . following the integral quantization procedure of the two - sphere @xmath24 and of functions ( or distributions on it , as is explained in details in appendix [ unitsphere ] , and yielding the expression ) , the quantum version of the classical hamiltonian with @xmath367 reads as @xmath368 where the parameter @xmath369 plays the same rle as in . now , contrarily to our previous choice , we take the direction of the magnetic field along the unit vector @xmath370 , , @xmath371 . this new choice gives a quantum hamiltonian of the form , @xmath372 this formula leaves to us the freedom to choose @xmath95 and @xmath361 in order to comply with observations , for instance for the electron . we just remind that , in its quantum description , the electron _ total _ spin magnetic moment is given by the formula @xcite : @xmath373 where @xmath374 is the charge of the electron , @xmath221 is the land @xmath221-factor , and by the quantization equation along the direction determined by @xmath339 : @xmath375 where @xmath376 is the bohr magneton . basic aspects of quantum formalism have been presented in this paper , taking the euclidean plane as the simplest mathematical model to be considered in a pedagogical approach . the corresponding quantum dynamics has been given a physical flavour at the price of increasing the dimension from 2 to three in order to implement what we call integral quantization , and a simple illustration is presented in terms of magnetic moment . we have shown that entanglement , a central notion of modern developments in quantum physics , allows to follow an interesting path from the euclidean plane to the quantum one - half spin formalism and to the quaternionic language as well . now , this path can be extended in order to include entanglement of two @xmath119 spins and to give an interesting description of the latter in an octonionic language . indeed , like @xmath28 ( as vector spaces ) , we can continue with @xmath29 ( as vector spaces ) , the cartesian product of two quaternion field being given an octonionic structure _ la _ cayley dickson . this is the content of a work in progress . there are various expressions for a density matrix acting on the euclidean plane , i.e. a @xmath18 real positive matrix with trace equal to @xmath59 . the most immediate one is the following with parameters @xmath377 and @xmath378 : @xmath379 the above inequalities imply the following ones @xmath380 let @xmath381 be the highest eigenvalue of @xmath75 ( the lowest one is @xmath382 ) . the spectral decomposition of @xmath75 reads as @xmath383 where @xmath384 is the corresponding unit eigenvector , chosen as pointing toward the right half - plane . we could have as well chosen the opposite @xmath385 pointing in the left half - plane since @xmath386 . our choice corresponds to the most immediate one in terms of orthonormal basis of the plane issued from the canonical one @xmath387 through the rotation by @xmath27 . let us make explicit the decomposition , @xmath388 we derive from this expression the polar parametrization of the @xmath389 parameters of @xmath75 : @xmath390 in return , we have the angle @xmath391 $ ] in function of @xmath377 and @xmath378 @xmath392 in this way , each @xmath75 is univocally ( but not biunivocally ) determined by a point in the unit disk , with polar coordinates @xmath393 , @xmath91 , @xmath394 . also note the alternative expression issued from : @xmath395 where @xmath396 is the rotation matrix in the plane @xmath397 and @xmath291 is the diagonal pauli matrix @xmath398 in order to get the second equality in we used the important property @xmath399 therefore the expression of a matrix density to which we refer mostly often through the paper reads @xmath400 from and we derive the interesting multiplication formula @xmath401 and the resulting ( non - closed ! ) `` algebra '' of real density matrices , @xmath402= -irr'\sin(\phi -\phi^{\prime } ) \sigma_2\ , , \quad \{\rho,\rho'\ } = \rho + \rho ' + ( \cos(\phi - \phi^{\prime})- 1/2)i\ , .\ ] ] the expression is convenient to examine the way a density matrix transforms under a rotation @xmath403 in the plane . we have , @xmath404 the computation of the three following integrals is straightforward : @xmath405 @xmath406 @xmath407 @xmath408 where @xmath89 is the unit disk and @xmath409 . a convenient representation of rotations in space is possible thanks to quaternion calculus . we recall that the quaternion field as a multiplicative group is @xmath411su@xmath4 . the correspondence between the canonical basis of @xmath412 , @xmath413 , and the pauli matrices is @xmath414 , with @xmath415 . hence , the @xmath18 matrix representation of these basis elements is the following : @xmath416 any quaternion decomposes as @xmath417 ( resp . @xmath418 ) in scalar - vector notation ( resp . in euclidean metric notation ) . we also recall that the multiplication law explicitly reads in scalar - vector notation : @xmath419 . the ( quaternionic ) conjugate of @xmath420 is @xmath421 , the squared norm is @xmath422 , and the inverse of a nonzero quaternion is @xmath423 . unit quaternions , i.e. , quaternions with norm @xmath59 , which form the multiplicative subgroup isomorphic to su@xmath4 , constitute the three - sphere @xmath424 . on the other hand , any proper rotation in space is determined by a unit vector @xmath339 defining the rotation axis and a rotation angle @xmath425 about the axis , as illustrated in figure [ rotation ] . ( 40,40 ) ( 20,10)(2,1)30 ( 18,6)@xmath55 ( 35,12)@xmath426 ( 20,10)(-4,1)30 ( 16,20)@xmath427 ( 18,18)@xmath428 ( 17,26)@xmath339 ( 20,10)(-1,4)5 ( 0,10)@xmath429 the action of such a rotation , @xmath430 , on a vector @xmath429 is given by : @xmath431 the latter is expressed in scalar - vector quaternionic form as @xmath432 where @xmath433 or , in matrix form resulting from the identification , @xmath434 in which case quaternionic conjugation corresponds to the transposed conjugate of the corresponding matrix , @xmath435 in particular , for a given unit vector @xmath436 one considers the specific rotation @xmath437 that maps the unit vector pointing to the north pole , @xmath338 , to @xmath339 , as is shown in figure [ rotkton ] , @xmath438 with , in quaternionic matrix notations , @xmath439 @xmath440 ( 50,30 ) ( 20,10)(4,3)20 ( 20,10)(4,1)15 ( 18,6)@xmath55 ( 40,21)@xmath339 ( 33,9)@xmath441 ( 20,12.5)@xmath442 ( 27,11.5)@xmath442 ( 22,16)@xmath357 ( 17,28)@xmath354 ( 20,10)(0,4)23 the unitary irreducible representations @xmath443 of su@xmath4 are labelled by half - integers @xmath444 . for a given @xmath444 , the corresponding complex hilbert space is finite - dimensional , with dimension @xmath445 . the matrix elements of the linear operator @xmath446 in the basis @xmath447 are given by @xmath448 in agreement with talman @xcite . in the lowest non trivial dimensional case we are concerned with in this paper , @xmath449 , these matrix elements are given by @xmath450 hence , we have to be careful when we work with matrix representations of quaternions , due to the choice of basis . consequently , besides the `` canonical '' one , we use preferably ( and safely ! ) the notation @xmath451 for the @xmath30 matrix given by in the `` up '' and `` down '' spin basis , @xmath452 precisely , we have @xmath453 and for the particular case @xmath454 , essential in the construction of spin @xmath119 coherent states , @xmath455 we consider the unit sphere equipped with its rotationally invariant measure : @xmath456\ , , \quad \phi\in [ 0,2\pi)\ , .\ ] ] the hilbert space is @xmath457 . the unit ball @xmath458 in @xmath410 parametrizes the set of @xmath18 complex density matrices @xmath75 . indeed , given a 3-vector @xmath459 , viewed as a pure quaternion @xmath460 , and such that @xmath461 , a general density matrix @xmath75 can be written as @xmath462 where @xmath463 ( resp . @xmath464 ) are the cartesian ( resp . spherical ) coordinates of vector @xmath429 . we have used the representation @xmath465 defined by in order to avoid any ambiguity about the basis in which is expressed the density matrix @xmath75 . if @xmath93 , with spherical coordinates @xmath466 , then @xmath75 is the pure state @xmath467 where the column vector @xmath468 is the spin @xmath449 coherent state introduced in . let us now transport the density matrix @xmath75 by using the two - dimensional complex representation of rotations in space , namely the matrix su@xmath4 representation . for @xmath469 , one defines the family of density matrices labelled by @xmath470 : @xmath471 in order to get a one - to - one correspondence with the points of the 2-sphere , we restrict the elements of su@xmath4 to those corresponding to the rotation @xmath472 bringing the unit vector @xmath354 pointing to the north pole to the vector @xmath473 with spherical coordinates @xmath474 , as described in and but with an opposed sign for @xmath27 in order to get for @xmath93 . @xmath475 the value of the integral @xmath476 shows that the resolution of the unity is achieved with @xmath477 only . then , it is clear that @xmath478 it is with this strong restriction and the simplified notation @xmath479 that we go forward to the next calculations with the resolution of the unity @xmath480 note that the resolution of the identity with the su@xmath4 transport of a generic density operator is possible only if we integrate on the whole group , as it was done in @xcite . the @xmath24-labelled family of probability distributions on @xmath481 @xmath482 at @xmath175 we get the uniform probability on the sphere whereas at @xmath93 we get the probability distribution corresponding to the spin 1/2 cs , @xmath483 the quantization of a function ( or distribution ) @xmath484 on the sphere based on leads to the 2@xmath1842 matrix operator @xmath485 where @xmath486 is the average of @xmath135 on the unit sphere and @xmath487 and @xmath488 are fourier coefficients of @xmath135 on the sphere defined as @xmath489 since the sphere is a phase space with canonical coordinates @xmath490 , @xmath491 , and @xmath492 , the latter may be thought as the simplest functions to be quantized . we find for the quantization of @xmath303 @xmath493 its eigenvalues are @xmath494 with corresponding eigenvectors @xmath495 . its lower symbol is given by the smooth function @xmath496 the quantization of @xmath248 yields the diagonal matrix @xmath497 with immediate eigenvalues @xmath498 and lower symbol @xmath499 we note the commutation rule @xmath500 now , applying the quantization formula of the three components of the generic unit vector provides , as expected , the three pauli matrices , up to a common factor in agreement with general results given in @xcite , @xmath501 j.p . gazeau thanks cbpf and cnpq for financial support and cbpf for hospitality . curado acknowledges cnpq and faperj for financial support . the authors are grateful to pierre martin - dussaud ( ens lyon ) for helpful comments . for a quantum - mechanical system described by a density matrix @xmath503 , the von neumann entropy is @xmath504 , the last expression being actually its shannon form . it is zero if and only if @xmath75 is a pure state , i.e. , a projector . j. von neumann , mathematische grundlagen der quantenmechanik , springer , berlin ( 1932 ) . english translation by r. t. beyer , mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics , princeton university press ( 1955 ) . a borel set is any set in a topological space that can be formed from open sets ( or , equivalently , from closed sets ) through the operations of countable union , countable intersection , and relative complement . a very pedagogical explanation of the semi - circle law is given in the junior research seminar on probability , y. sinai , s. miller , l. silberman , @xmath505-functions , random matrix theory and ramanujan graphs , online at https://web.williams.edu/mathematics/sjmiller/public_html/mathlab/public_html/jr02spring/plfrmt.pdf ( 2003 ) . see the answer to the question _ what is the difference between cartesian and tensor product of two vector spaces ? _ at http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/710481/what-is-the-difference-between-cartesian-and-tensor-product-of-two-vector-spaces | the euclidean plane is certainly the simplest example of real hilbert space . viewed as a space of quantum states , it can be used as a nice introductive example in teaching quantum formalism . the pure states form the unit circle ( actually one half of it ) , the mixed states form the unit disk ( actually one half of it ) , and rotations in the plane rule time evolution through a majorana - like equation involving only real quantities . the set of pure states or the set of mixed states at fixed `` temperature '' solve the identity and they are used for the integral quantization of functions on the unit circle and to give a semi - classical portrait of quantum observables . interesting probabilistic aspects are developed . since the tensor product of two planes , their direct sum , their cartesian product , are isomorphic ( @xmath0 is the unique solution to @xmath1 ) , and they are also isomorphic to @xmath2 , and to the quaternion field @xmath3 ( as a vector space ) , we describe an interesting relation between entanglement of real states , one - half spin cat states , and unit - norm quaternions which form the group su@xmath4 . finally , we explain the most general form of the hamiltonian in the real plane by considering the integral quantization of a magnetic - like interaction potential viewed as a classical observable on the unit 2-sphere . |
hep-th9607050 | string duality is a recently discovered symmetry of string theory . string theory itself is over twenty - five years old , and has been under intensive development since 1984 as the leading candidate for a unified theory of particle physics and gravity . the reason that some of its symmetry has been overlooked until now is simple , and important : string duality is not manifest in the weak - coupling perturbation expansion by which the theory is usually studied , but it is a property of the exact theory . as a result , string duality gives information about the behavior of string theory at strong coupling . in a period of a little over a year , we have gone from near - complete ignorance of the behavior of strongly - coupled strings to a rather detailed understanding of the intricate dynamics which occurs , at least in vacua having enough supersymmetry , and the subject continues to develop at a rapid pace . the central idea of string duality is that the strongly coupled limit of any string theory is equivalent to the weakly coupled limit of some other theory . all string theories are connected in this way , as well as something new and surprising : an eleven - dimensional theory known provisionally as ` m - theory . ' besides the ordinary vibrating strings which are the basic quanta of string theory , the multiplets of string duality include smooth classical objects ( solitons ) , singular classical objects ( black holes ) , and a new type of topological defect which is unique to string theory ( d - branes ) . with the improved understanding of string dynamics it has become possible to address one of the long - standing problems of quantum gravity to count the number of states of certain black holes in a controlled way , giving for the first time a statistical mechanical interpretation to the bekenstein - hawking entropy . beyond these specific results , string duality has greatly changed the way string theorists think about the fundamental principles of the theory . many ideas which once seemed to be central are now seen as technicalities , while other ideas which were neglected are now central . in this colloquium i would like to try to explain these developments and to put them in the context of the search for the unified theory of particle physics and gravity . i will use units in which @xmath0 . the gravitational coupling @xmath1 is then a length - squared , @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the planck length , @xmath4 cm . this is the natural length scale for the effects of quantum gravity to become important and so for the unification of gravity with the other interactions . it is far shorter than the length scales which can be probed directly ; the corresponding energy scale is @xmath5 far beyond the reach of accelerators . thus , to construct a unified theory one must rely heavily on theoretical reasoning such as the internal consistency of the theory , and any experimental tests will be indirect . fortunately , consistency is a very restrictive guide . general relativity is a nonrenormalizable field theory , meaning that its quantum mechanical perturbation theory has uncontrollable divergences . to see the significance of this , let us recall the four - fermi theory of the weak interaction . the weak interaction was originally described as an interaction of four fermionic fields at a spacetime point as depicted in figure 1a . the weak coupling constant @xmath6 also has units of length - squared , or inverse energy - squared . in a process with a characteristic energy @xmath7 the effective dimensionless coupling is then @xmath8 . it follows that at sufficiently high energy the coupling becomes arbitrarily strong , and this also implies divergences in the perturbation theory . a second order weak amplitude is dimensionally of the form @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the energy of the virtual state in the second order process , and this diverges at large energy . in position space the divergence comes when the two weak interactions occur at the same spacetime point ( high energy = short distance ) . the divergences become worse at each higher order of perturbation theory and so can not be controlled even with renormalization . the natural interpretation of such divergences is that the theory one is working with is only valid up to some energy scale , beyond which new physics appears . the new physics should have the effect of smearing out the interaction in spacetime and so soften the high energy behavior . one might imagine that this could be done in many ways , but in fact the combined constraints of lorentz invariance and causality are very restrictive . this is because lorentz invariance requires that if the interaction is spread out in space it is also spread out in time . in fact , for the weak interaction there is only one known way to solve the short - distance problem . this is depicted in figure 1b , where the four - fermi interaction is resolved into the exchange of a vector boson . moreover , this vector boson must be of a very specific kind , coming from a spontaneously broken gauge invariance . this is the only known solution , and in fact it is the one that nature chooses . for gravity the discussion is much the same . the gravitational interaction is depicted in figure 2a . as we have noted already , the gravitational coupling @xmath1 has units of length - squared and so the dimensionless coupling is @xmath11 . this grows large at high energy and signifies a nonrenormalizable perturbation theory . again the natural suspicion is that short - distance physics smears out the interaction , and again there is only one known way to do this , shown in figure 2b . it involves a bigger step than in the case of the weak interaction : it requires that at the planck length the graviton and other particles turn out to be not points but one - dimensional objects , loops of ` string . ' it is certainly not obvious that this should be the right thing to do , but if one tries to make a consistent lorentz - invariant quantum theory of one - dimensional objects , one finds that it is possible but that the theory is highly constrained . in particular , one of the states of the string is massless and has spin two . consistency requires that such a particle be a graviton , that its long - wavelength interactions be described by general relativity , and indeed this is what is found from the sum - over - histories depicted in figure 2b ( yoneya , 1974 ; scherk and schwarz , 1974 , 1975 ) . in a sense string theory predicts gravity , in that every consistent string theory includes general relativity , even though the theory initially seems to be formulated in flat space . further , calculation of the quantum corrections to amplitudes shows that they are finite . it is also not obvious why _ only _ this idea should work . many others have been tried without success . one natural question is , why one - dimensional objects and not two - dimensional or higher ? for this at least there is a simple answer . extended objects have an infinite number of internal degrees of freedom ( the fourier modes describing their shape ) . spreading out point particles into extended objects softens the spacetime divergences but introduces potential new divergences from the internal degrees of freedom . the latter grow worse as the dimension of the object increases , and the one - dimensional case is the only one for which both the spacetime and internal behavior is under control . it could be that we suffer from a failure of imagination , and that there are other solutions . however , we see from the example of the weak interaction that if we can find even one solution to a short - distance problem we should take it very seriously and see where it leads . the result here is quite striking . besides the graviton , other states of the string with different internal oscillators excited behave as gauge bosons ( neveu and scherk , 1972 ) , and yet others are fermions ( ramond , 1971 ) . in fact , string theory automatically incorporates ( and in some ways generalizes ) three earlier ideas for explaining the patterns in the standard model , namely grand unification , supersymmetry ( gliozzi , scherk and olive , 1977 ) , and kaluza - klein theory . some of the simplest string theories , the calabi - yau models , closely resemble unified versions of the supersymmetric standard model . as a particle physicist i usually emphasize these particle physics motivations for string theory , but many of those educated in general relativity and in mathematics find string theory compelling for reasons that are not entirely the same . from newton s gravity to einstein s , from quantum mechanics to non - abelian gauge theory , new physical theories have often required new mathematics , or least mathematics that had not previously been used in physics . if one searches for higher symmetries or other more mathematical structures that might be useful in physics , one finds many connections to string theory . one reason i emphasize this now is that in the recent work on string duality , all of these different points of view have had a role to play . it is worthwhile to note that these three kinds of motivation solving the divergence problem , the connection with geometry , and explaining the broad patterns in the standard model , were also present in the weak interaction . weinberg ( 1980 ) emphasized the divergence problem as i have done . salam ( 1980 ) was more guided by the idea that non - abelian gauge theory was a beautiful structure that should be incorporated in physics . experiment gave no direct indication that the weak interaction was anything but the pointlike interaction of figure 1a , and no direct clue as to the new physics that smears it out , just as today it gives no direct indication of what lies beyond the standard model . but it did show certain broad patterns universality and the @xmath12 structure , which were telltale signs of a gauge interaction . it appears that nature is kind to us , in providing many trails to a correct theory . the key question is , how do we go from explaining broad patterns to making precise predictions ? to understand the situation , it is useful to look again to history , to the state of quantum field theory in the early 60 s . at that time there was a good technical control of the weak - coupling perturbation theory , the feynman graph expansion , but little else . important dynamical ideas were missing , such as the higgs mechanism , dynamical symmetry breaking , and confinement . these have largely to do with the fact that the vacuum , the ground state of quantum field theory , is generally a more interesting and less symmetric object than one might naively expect from the hamiltonian . without understanding these ideas one can not make sense of the standard model : it would seem to predict fractionally charged particles and a long - ranged force coupled to isospin . beyond these dynamical ideas , it remained to discover the defining principle of the theory that one should organize the physics not _ graph by graph _ but rather _ length scale by length scale _ with the shortest distances first . this realization not only made it possible to define the theory beyond perturbation theory , but also provided a framework for understanding the dynamics , both analytically and numerically . the situation is similar in string theory . there has been a good technical control of the perturbation theory , but little else , at least up until the recent developments . the need to understand the dynamics is even more acute than in the case of the standard model for two reasons . the first is that because the planck energy is so large , there is no hope to explore a ` partonic ' regime where the stringy behavior is directly visible rather , we see only the extreme low energy limit of string theory , filtered through all the dynamics at intervening scales . the second reason has to do with one of the very attractive features of string theory , that it has no free dimensionless parameters at all . instead it has , in perturbation theory , many degenerate ground states parameterized by the values of various scalar fields ( moduli ) . the parameters of the standard model come ultimately from the values of these scalars , so it is necessary to understand the dynamics which selects one of the many ground states . string theory contains quantum field theory as its low energy limit , so all of the familiar dynamics of the latter is still present , but because string theory has many more degrees of freedom it is likely to have interesting new dynamics of its own . beyond this , the central defining principle of string theory is not known . we are trying to answer the question ` what is string theory ? ' , just as wilson and others addressed the question ` what is field theory ? ' . the various properties that make string theory an attractive unifying idea also imply that the theory exists as something more than an asymptotic weak - coupling expansion . so there is good reason to expect that we will find a central principle as powerful as that in field theory , which will again enable us to better understand the dynamics . with this background i can summarize what has been learned from string duality . we have learned a number of new dynamical ideas though certainly not yet all we need . we have not yet found the central principle but we have many new clues , some of which are surprising and have taken us in unexpected directions . string duality involves an interplay of many different ideas from quantum field theory and string theory . in this part i would like to explain some of the central principles . here are two ways to think about the meaning of the coupling constant @xmath13 of a quantum field theory . the first is in terms of the weak - coupling perturbation expansion . the amplitude @xmath14 for any process can be expanded @xmath15 where @xmath13 is the amplitude for a single interaction to occur . , or only odd , contribute to a given amplitude . ] the coefficient @xmath16 is given by the sum over feynman graphs with @xmath17 interaction vertices . interpreted with sufficient care this is an asymptotic series , meaning that it gives an approximation of any desired accuracy by taking @xmath13 to be sufficiently small . thus it is also a good qualitative guide to the small-@xmath13 physics . but for @xmath13 of order @xmath18 or larger it is of limited usefulness and can miss important aspects of the physics . another way to think about the meaning of @xmath13 is in terms of the quantum fluctuation of the fields . for the purpose of this discussion it is useful to keep explicit factors of @xmath19 ; we will return to @xmath20 units after section 3.2 . when @xmath13 is small the fluctuations are small and their equations of motion can be approximated by linear equations in other words , small @xmath13 is approximately free field theory . for larger @xmath13 the fluctuations of the fields , and the nonlinearities , become larger . and the size of the quantum fluctuations is in terms of the path integral , the sum over field histories weighted by @xmath21 with @xmath22 the classical action . the fields can be rescaled in such a way that @xmath13 appears in the action only as an overall factor @xmath23 , so @xmath13 and @xmath19 appear only in the combination @xmath24 . it is then clear that small @xmath13 and small @xmath19 are equivalent with this scaling of the fields . to relate this to the familiar example of qed , one must note that the electric charges of individual quanta are related to the charge in the classical field action by @xmath25 , so the familiar expansion parameter @xmath26 is indeed @xmath27 . ] in qcd , for example , the coupling is very strong at long distance , and correspondingly the color magnetic fields undergo large fluctuations in the vacuum this is the source of confinement . weak / strong duality ( in field theory or string theory ) means that as the string coupling @xmath13 becomes large , one can find new ` dual ' fields whose fluctuations become _ small_they are characterized by a new coupling @xmath28 which is something like @xmath29 . this is similar to a fourier transform , where a function which becomes spread out in position space can become very narrow in momentum space . here though , the fourier transform is in a complicated nonlinear field space . string theory includes gravity , and so one of the fields is the spacetime metric . one might therefore have expected strongly coupled string theory to have new and very exotic physics , including large fluctuations of the spacetime geometry and all other fields . this might correspond to some sort of confined phase of gravity . one of the surprises of string duality is that this is not so . as @xmath30 , @xmath31 and so the metric of the dual theory behaves more and more classically . it is quite likely that in nature the string coupling is close to 1 rather than to 0 or @xmath32 , so that string duality does not allow one to relate the theory directly to a weakly coupled theory in which one can calculate accurately . but having an understanding of both limits , large and small coupling , constrains the kinds of qualitative physics that can occur at intermediate coupling . even more important , duality gives a great deal of information about the exact theory and its symmetries , information that is not contained in the perturbation expansion , and so new clues to the answer to ` what is string theory ? ' . another perspective on the meaning of duality starts with maxwell s equations , @xmath33 the symmetry between @xmath34 and @xmath35 in these equations is striking . if one ignores the sources , or adds magnetic sources , the equations are invariant under @xmath36 , @xmath37 . this curious fact was made more interesting by dirac s study ( 1931 ) of the quantum mechanics of a charge moving in a magnetic monopole field . he found that the wavefunction could be consistently defined only if the electric charge @xmath38 and magnetic charge @xmath39 satisfy a quantization condition @xmath40 note that if a monopole of some charge @xmath39 exists , then all electric charges must be multiples of the unit @xmath41 . this would ` explain ' why the magnitudes of the electron and proton charges should be _ exactly _ equal , a fact known to hold to one part in @xmath42 . the subject took another step forward when t hooft ( 1974 ) and polyakov ( 1974 ) showed that in any grand unified theory , magnetic monopoles actually do exist . they are classical solutions , with a nonsingular core whose size is set by the scale of spontaneous symmetry breaking . at weak coupling , the electrically and magnetically charged objects look very different . the electrically charged objects are weakly coupled and have pointlike interactions . the magnetically charged objects are strongly coupled by the dirac condition ( [ dirac ] ) , the magnetic fine structure constant @xmath43 is roughly the reciprocal of the usual one and as noted above they have cores of finite size . montonen and olive ( 1977 ) were led by various evidence to conjecture that at strong coupling the situation would be reversed : the electrically charged objects would be strongly coupled and have nonsingular cores , while the magnetically charged objects would become weakly coupled and pointlike . the strongly coupled theory would be equivalent to weakly coupled theory in which the basic quanta carried magnetic rather than electric charges . in subsequent work this conjecture was refined ( witten and olive , 1978 ; osborn , 1979 ) . it was argued to hold specifically in supersymmetric gauge theories , in particular @xmath44 theories ( @xmath45 is the number of conserved supersymmetries ) . relating this discussion to the previous section , the weakly coupled dual fields described there would be the fields corresponding to the magnetic quanta . these conjectures were greeted with wide skepticism because the evidence for them was rather circumstantial , while attempts to construct the dual fields directly in terms of the original ones did not succeed . this skepticism is now largely gone , not because the dual fields have been found ( they have not ) , but because of a substantial strengthening of the circumstantial evidence . this evidence , based on supersymmetry , will be described in the next section . the reader should notice that this whole section has been concerned with duality in field theory , not string theory . the extension to string theory will be discussed in section 3.5 . to test the duality conjectures we need to be able to say something about the physics of the strongly coupled theories . the methods available for this are very limited , but in supersymmetric theories it is possible . supersymmetry is of interest for a number of reasons . it is likely that it is associated with the breaking of the electroweak symmetry . if so , it should be discovered by the lhc if not before , and it is the one piece of new physics associated with string theory that might be accessible at accelerators . beyond this , it is an appealing mathematical structure that extends general coordinate invariance and unifies fermions and bosons . any consistent string theory must have supersymmetry , at least at the planck scale . finally , supersymmetric field theories , and string theories with unbroken supersymmetry below the planck scale , have various nice properties that make them easier to study . it is difficult to give an intuitive picture of supersymmetry . one way to think about it is that in addition to the usual spacetime dimensions , whose coordinates are real numbers @xmath46 ( and so their multiplication commutes ) , there are additional ` fermionic ' coordinates @xmath47 which anticommute , @xmath48 . these extra dimensions have no size ; the anticommuting property means that they are essentially infinitesimal . one can make sensible field theories on this space . in fact , they can be thought of as quantum field theories on ordinary spacetime but with fields that have both fermionic and bosonic components , with a symmetry relating the masses and charges of the particles with different statistics . to see why supersymmetry is valuable in studying strong coupling we need the algebra of the quantum mechanical generators of the symmetry . for an ordinary internal symmetry , such as baryon number , the generator @xmath49 commutes with the hamiltonian @xmath50 , @xmath51 = 0.\ ] ] this is the definition of a symmetry . for supersymmetry , with generator @xmath52 , there is an additional relation ( see , for example , haag , lopuszansky , and sohnius , 1975 ) @xmath53 = 0 \qquad \{q , q\ } = h + g. \label{susy}\ ] ] in the second , anticommutation , relation , both the hamiltonian and various internal generators appear on the right - hand side . for clarity we have omitted the indices which would distinguish the various supersymmetry and internal symmetry generators and various associated constants , so this anticommutation relation is schematic . the anticommutation relation has the hamiltonian on the right - hand side , and as a result supersymmetry gives much more information about the dynamics than ordinary internal symmetries . to see one example of this ( witten and olive , 1978 ) , consider a one - particle state @xmath54 which has the special property that is invariant under part of the supersymmetry algebra ; in other words , @xmath55 for some of the @xmath52 s . this is known as a _ bogomolnyi - prasad - sommerfeld ( bps ) state_. take the expectation value of the anticommutator in eq . ( [ susy ] ) , @xmath56 for those @xmath52 s which annihilate @xmath57 , the left hand side is zero . the two terms on the right are just the mass of the particle and its @xmath49-charge . thus , the mass of any bps particle is determined entirely by its charge . this is a consequence of symmetry and does not depend on dynamics at all ; in particular it remains true even if the coupling is large . further analysis puts strong constraints on the interactions and on the phase diagram . for example , any bps state with zero charge has zero energy . the anticommutation relations imply that no other state can have lower energy , so any such state will be the ground state . a typical supersymmetric theory has many such states , which are characterized by the expectation values of some scalar fields . all these states must be degenerate . this is similar to spontaneous symmetry breaking , but with spontaneous symmetry breaking the degenerate vacua all have the same physics while here they are physically inequivalent they are not related to one another directly by any symmetry , rather the degeneracy follows indirectly from the bps argument . the scalar fields which label these vacua , known as moduli , must be massless for the same reason that goldstone bosons are massless . the low energy physics , the phase structure , is determined by the physics of the moduli , which is strongly constrained by supersymmetry . applying these methods to test the @xmath44 duality conjecture , one first finds that the bps mass formula is duality symmetric . that is , electrically charged bps states at coupling @xmath13 have the same masses as magnetically charged states at coupling @xmath29 . secondly , one can compare the degeneracies of bps states with different charges and spins . the degeneracy of magnetic monopoles can be determined by semiclassical methods when @xmath13 is small . in @xmath44 theories there can not be a phase transition as the coupling is varied and the supersymmetry algebra prevents the number of bps states from changing , so this also determines the degeneracy at strong coupling . for @xmath44 theories it is the same as that of the electrically charged states in the dual theory . as another test , the effective low energy physics of the moduli is duality invariant . this evidence was widely regarded as unconvincing , an accidental consequence of supersymmetry , until seiberg ( 1994 ) and others began to apply these methods systematically to determine the phase structures of theories with less supersymmetry , @xmath58 and @xmath59 . the arguments in these cases are more intricate , the physics is richer , and there are more consistency checks . many more examples of duality were found ( reviewed in seiberg , 1995 , and intriligator and seiberg , 1995 ) , as well as convincing evidence for various associated phenomena such as composite gauge bosons . , the duality holds at all energies . in many others it is holds only in the low energy theory . ] duality in supersymmetric gauge theory is now well - established . it is important to note , though , that the dual fields still have not been constructed . it is believed that to make duality manifest one may need a new formulation of these quantum field theories , something more intrinsically quantum - mechanical than the path integral over classical histories . it is also suspected that an understanding of the dualities in field theory will ultimately come from string theory . we will need one more idea in order to fully understand string duality . this is that spacetime may have more than four dimensions . the three spatial dimensions we see are expanding , and once were highly curved . it is a logical possibility that there are other dimensions which did not expand but remain small and highly curved . moreover , this is an attractive idea for a number of reasons . a good model for physics in such a spacetime is a waveguide , a cavity which has some finite cross section in the @xmath60-@xmath61 plane and is very long in the @xmath62 dimension . seen from far away , or with low resolution , this looks one - dimensional . an infinite number of different fields ( functions of @xmath62 and @xmath63 ) with different dispersion relations ( masses ) move along the waveguide . seen up close , the three - dimensional structure is evident and one sees that there is only one field , the electromagnetic field , and that the different dispersion relations come from modes with different @xmath60 , @xmath61 dependence . physics is much the same in a spacetime with three large spatial dimensions and additional ones which are small and compact . in nature , the additional dimensions would be quite small , close to the planck scale , so we would have seen only the very lowest modes . one reason this is attractive is that it unifies gravitational and gauge interactions . depending on whether its polarization is aligned along the long or compact directions , a higher - dimensional graviton can look like a graviton , photon , or scalar from the lower - dimensional point of view . this is the kaluza - klein mechanism . in addition , the dirac equation on such a space typically gives rise to multiple copies of the same set of quantum numbers ( that is , generations ) in the lower - dimensional spectrum . consistent weakly - coupled string theories necessarily live in ten spacetime dimensions . the origin of this condition is difficult to explain in simple terms , but it can be understood in various ways . calculation of quantum effects shows that they spoil essential symmetries unless the dimension is ten . also , the properties of fermions depend in an essential way on the number of dimensions and ten is special here for a number of reasons related to supersymmetry . for example , ten is the highest dimension in which the number of states of a massless vector ( eight : the spacetime dimension minus the timelike and longitudinal polarizations ) can be equal to the number of states of a massless fermion in higher dimensions the spinor representations are too large . the field equations of ten - dimensional string theory are consistent with four - dimensional physics that looks very much like what we have . some of the simplest solutions give rise to the same gauge groups and matter representations found in grand unification ( candelas , horowitz , strominger , and witten , 1985 ) . it is notable that the four - dimensional gauge couplings can be chiral , meaning that the right- and left - handed fermions have different gauge interactions . this was impossible for a number of previously considered unifying ideas including standard kaluza - klein theory ( witten , 1981 ) . for future reference it is useful to look at a simple example . this is a massless scalar field in five spacetime dimensions , with one dimension periodic with period @xmath64 . let @xmath46 with @xmath65 be the coordinates for the large dimensions , and @xmath66 be the periodic coordinate ; the index @xmath67 runs over all five values . the wave equation is @xmath68 as in the waveguide , separate variables and expand the @xmath66 dependence in a complete set of modes , @xmath69 then the @xmath17th mode satisfies @xmath70 which is the klein - gordon equation for a scalar field of mass @xmath71 . at low energies only the @xmath72 mode is detectable , but at energies above @xmath73 one sees a characteristic infinite tower of states . for this simple geometry the states are spaced evenly in mass . more complicated compact spaces would of course give a more complicated spectrum , but the average density of states depends only on the number of additional dimensions . from another point of view , consider how the spectrum behaves as @xmath74 : the infinite tower comes down in mass and forms the continuum characteristic of a noncompact dimension . string theory includes gauge theory . weak / strong duality in gauge theory is thus necessary if the same is to be true in string theory , but it is not sufficient . after the work of seiberg , it was still possible that duality was a property only of the low energy limit of string theory , not of the full massive spectrum . there were a number of early duality conjectures in string theory . a partial list includes the self - duality of @xmath58 heterotic string theories in four dimensions ( font , ibanez , lust , and quevedo , 1990 ) , self - duality of @xmath44 heterotic strings in four dimensions ( font , ibanez , lust , and quevedo , 1990 ; sen , 1994 ) , self - duality of the heterotic string in six dimensions ( duff,1995 ) , duality of certain string theories with theories of five - dimensional objects ( five - branes ) in ten dimensions ( duff , 1988 ; strominger , 1990 ) , and a relation not specifically duality of other string theories in ten dimensions to theories of membranes ( two - branes ) in eleven dimensions ( duff , howe , inami , and stelle , 1987 ) . these conjectures did not attract broad attention , due to their rather scattered nature and the limited evidence for any of them . the subject took a major step forward with the papers of hull and townsend ( 1995 ) , townsend ( 1995 ) , and witten ( 1995a ) . these authors proposed a nearly complete set of duals for all known string theories with at least @xmath44 supersymmetry . these new proposals elevated duality from a set of isolated conjectures to a general principle applying to any string theory in any dimension . the structure is quite rigid for each string theory the spectrum and symmetries determine a unique candidate for its dual , and the entire pattern fits together in an intricate way as dimensions are compactified and decompactified . some of the earlier conjectures , such as the @xmath44 conjecture , were incorporated whole , while others were incorporated in a modified or limited form ; we will return to the membrane idea in section 4.2 . these systematic conjectures made possible many new tests , and evidence for weak / strong duality in string theory accumulated rapidly . this led also to the discovery of various new dynamical ideas , some of which will be described in part 4 . there is now an integrated picture of the strongly coupled dynamics , at least for string theories with enough supersymmetry , and the methods are being extended to theories with less supersymmetry . figure 3 is a schematic picture of the space of string vacua . the parameters are the string coupling and the sizes and shapes of the compact dimensions ; in string theory these are not fixed but are determined by the expectation values of the moduli . over most of the space , the string coupling @xmath13 is of order 1 . in various limits , there is an effective description in terms of one or another weakly coupled string theory . the different string theories are characterized by the number and kind of supersymmetries and by the world - sheet topologies allowed ( oriented vs. unoriented and closed vs. open ) . in some limits new theories are encountered ; the most interesting of these , m - theory , will be described in section 4.1 . figure 3 is actually an oversimplification , in that the different limits are characterized not only by different string theories but by different topologies for the compact dimensions . it has been known for some time that even in weakly coupled string theory spacetime topology is not invariant ( aspinwall , greene , and morrison , 1993 ) , and string duality has provided many more examples ( greene , morrison , and strominger , 1995 ) . also , a more accurate picture would have many pieces resembling figure 3 , touching one another at points or along curves . in field theory the duality multiplets included the elementary quanta plus smooth classical configurations ( magnetic monopoles ) . the string duality multiplets include these ( though the elementary quanta are now loops rather than points ) , plus singular classical configurations ( black holes ) and also a new type of object unique to string theory , the d - brane . d - branes are topological defects on which the ends of a string can be trapped , as shown in figure 4 . they can be pointlike , one - dimensional , two - dimensional , and so on . these were discovered in the study of perturbative dualities of string theories , dualities that relate different weakly coupled theories ( dai , leigh , and polchinski , 1989 ; polchinski , chaudhuri , and johnson , 1996 ) . their relevance to weak / strong duality was noticed more recently ( polchinski , 1995 ) . let me illustrate one of the methods by which the strongly coupled limits are determined . in addition to the fundamental strings , various string theories have in their spectra one - dimensional objects which are either smooth solitons or d - branes . at weak coupling these are much heavier than the fundamental strings , but at strong coupling they are much lighter ( again this is guaranteed by the bps formula ) . in this limit it is natural to reinterpret the theory with the soliton or d - brane being the fundamental string . which string theory one gets depends on the degrees of freedom of the object , which can be determined by a weak - coupling calculation . this has been applied to determine , or confirm , the strongly coupled limits of various string theories ( sen , 1995a ; harvey and strominger , 1995 ; dabholkar , 1995 ; hull , 1995 ; schwarz , 1995 ; witten , 1996a ; polchinski and witten , 1996 ) . i have described the principal methods and general results of string duality . in this final part i would like to focus on some specific highlights , some of the discoveries that have most greatly changed our understanding . as described in section 3.4 , weakly coupled string theory requires specifically ten dimensions . one of the striking consequences of string duality is the existence of an eleventh dimension , not visible in weakly coupled string theory . how does one discover a new dimension ? the experimental signature was discussed in section 3.4 , a tower of new states above the energy @xmath73 . the theoretical signature is the same . a certain string theory , the iia theory in ten dimensions , has zero - dimensional d - branes , d - particles . these are heavy , with a mass @xmath75 at weak coupling ( @xmath76 is the string mass scale ) . for a pair of d - particles , the supersymmetric bound state problem can be solved and there is a single bound state with mass @xmath77 ( witten , 1996a ; sen , 1995b ) . similarly , @xmath17 d - particles have a single bound state of mass @xmath78 . this bound state spectrum was actually inferred from lower - dimensional duality symmetries before the explicit construction of the bound states . at strong coupling all of these become light , and in the @xmath79 limit form a continuum . we have seen just such a spectrum before , in section 3.4 . it is the signature of a new , eleventh , dimension with @xmath80 ( townsend , 1995 , witten , 1995a ) . this makes it clear why this dimension is invisible in string perturbation theory : the latter is an expansion in @xmath81 , so an expansion around the zero - radius limit . eleven dimensions is an interesting number . this is the maximum in which supersymmetry is possible beyond eleven the massless multiplets would contain spins higher than two , something which seems to be impossible in a consistent theory . eleven - dimensional supergravity is therefore the most symmetric theory based on supersymmetry ( cremmer , julia , and scherk , 1978 ) , and was considered as a possible unifying idea before string theory . the principal problems were that it is nonrenormalizable and that it is not possible to obtain a chiral spectrum . string theorists generally regarded eleven - dimensional supergravity as an irrelevant curiosity because of its difficulties and because strings seemed to live in ten , though some supergravity experts retained an interest in the theory because of its high degree of symmetry . now it develops that strings have an eleven - dimensional limit whose low energy physics is determined by symmetry considerations to be eleven - dimensional supergravity and whose short distance physics is not understood . this has been given the provisional name ` m - theory . ' the following exercise gives an interesting insight into m - theory . consider a long iia string in ten dimensions , shown in figure 5a . follow this state as the coupling is increased . we now know that a new orthogonal dimension will appear , but there are two possibilities for the form of the resulting state : in eleven dimensions it could look like a string as in figure 5b , or it could turn out to be a membrane wrapped around the eleventh dimension as shown in figure 5c . the answer can be determined in various ways from the conserved charges carries by the various objects , from the scaling of the string tension with coupling , from symmetry and it is figure 5c , the wrapped membrane . this is a puzzle . it seems to say that string theory is really the quantum mechanics of membranes , but in section 2.1 we have said that theories of fundamental membranes do not seem to exist . it is possible that the problems of quantizing membranes will be overcome and string theory will become membrane theory this was one of the origins of the name m - theory . it is likely , though , that the resolution lies in a different direction , that strings and membranes will turn out to be composites of something else . this has long been suspected in the case of string theory . some of the reasons for this are reviewed in polchinski ( 1994 ) . they include the general lack of success of string field theory and the fact that string perturbation theory diverges more rapidly than in field theory ( shenker , 1991 ) . string duality seems to give further support for this . in figure 3 , asymptotic _ behaviors in various limits are generated by different string theories , but there is no sign that the string descriptions do more than this . sums over string or membrane world - sheets are directly analogous to the feynman graph expansion and so are intrinsically perturbative . as for duality in field theory , we need a more quantum - mechanical description , one in which @xmath19 is not a free parameter ( witten , 1996c ) . incidentally , the membrane can also be oriented perpendicular to the eleventh dimension , so that in ten dimensions it still looks like a membrane . in string theory it appears as a d - brane . from the eleven - dimensional point of view one sees a symmetry in which a @xmath82 rotation takes the eleventh dimension into one of the others . from the string theory point of view this is a nonperturbative symmetry , mixing radii and couplings and relating strings to d - branes . in this section i would like to explain how all this business of extra dimensions might enter into an important piece of physics , the unification of the couplings . figure 6a shows the three gauge couplings and the dimensionless gravitational coupling @xmath83 as a function of energy . the logarithmic running of the gauge couplings is familiar ( amaldi , de boer , and furstenau , 1991 ) , as is the fact that they meet within experimental errors in the minimal supersymmetric model . it is also striking that the gravitational coupling nearly meets the other three , missing by a little over one order of magnitude out of fourteen.s and other factors reduces this to a factor of 20 ( kaplunovsky , 1988 ) . ] this is a near miss , less than ten percent in scale , but it is larger than the experimental error and so must be understood . there are many ways that the four couplings might turn out to unify . additional particles at an intermediate scale would change the running of the gauge couplings and can cause them to meet at a higher energy . enough extra states near the unification scale can have the same effect . or , the three gauge couplings may actually unify at the lower energy and a grand unified field theory with a single gauge coupling describe the physics from there until the string scale . all of these ideas modify the behavior of the gauge couplings . since the gauge couplings already meet , it would seem more economical to find instead a mechanism to change the running of the gravitational coupling . but this seems impossible because the running of the gauge coupling is just dimensional , as @xmath84 ; gravity is still classical at these scales . it is interesting to consider the effect of a new dimension below the unification scale . this changes the dimensional analysis . both the gauge and gravitational couplings grow more rapidly as shown in figure 6b , but they do not meet any sooner . in the @xmath85 heterotic string , the strong coupling limit leads to a new dimension which is slightly different from that considered before . instead of being periodic , a circle , it is a segment ( horava and witten , 1996 ) . the gauge fields and matter live at the endpoints only , while gravity propagates in the bulk . suppose that a fifth dimension of this type exists below the unification scale . that is , spacetime is a narrow five - dimensional layer bounded by four - dimensional walls . since the gauge fields and matter live in the walls , the evolution of the gauge couplings is the same as in four dimensions , but since gravity propagates in the full five dimensions the gravitational coupling behaves as in figure 6b . the result is shown in figure 6c : for a fifth dimension of appropriate size , the kink in the gravitational coupling makes it meet the others at the unification scale ( witten , 1996b ) . this is no more predictive than the idea of a unified theory : it adds one new parameter , the size of the fifth dimension . nevertheless it is an economical solution to the problem of the unification of all couplings , as likely to be true as any other . with only the data of the four couplings , there is not enough to distinguish among the possibilities . if supersymmetry is found and the masses of the superpartners measured with precision , many new renormalization group analyses become possible and it may be possible to determine the physics at the unification scale . local symmetries gauge invariance and coordinate invariance are a key ingredient in physics , appearing in the strong , weak , electromagnetic , and gravitational interactions . yet as has often been noted , these are not really symmetries in the usual sense . rather , they are _ redundancies _ : different vector potentials or coordinate systems describe the same physical state . why redundancy should be so important is puzzling , but it seems to be , and most attempts to unify are based on embedding the local symmetries at low energy into larger groups such as @xmath86 . in weakly coupled four dimensional theories , the size of the gauge group can only get larger at higher energies . there have been various arguments made that at strong coupling the reverse could be true , but convincing examples have only come with the understanding of strongly coupled dynamics in supersymmetric gauge and string theories . there are now many examples of composite gauge fields in the low energy theory , gauge fields not among the original short - distance fields ( intriligator and seiberg , 1995 ) . the interpretation of gauge symmetry is reversed : gauge symmetry is ubiquitous not because it is present in the underlying ultraviolet theory , but because it is infrared stable . that is , it is one of the few kinds of interesting long - distance dynamics which is _ natural _ , which does nt disappear when small changes are made in the short - distance parameters . in the early 1970 s it was found that classical black holes obey laws directly analogous to the laws of thermodynamics . this analogy was made sharper by hawking s discovery ( 1975 ) that black holes radiate as black bodies at the corresponding temperature . under this analogy , the entropy of a black hole ( the bekenstein - hawking entropy ) is the area of its horizon divided by @xmath87 . it has long been a goal to find a statistical mechanical theory associated with this thermodynamics , and in particular to associate the entropy with the density of states of the black hole . many arguments ( too many to review here ) have been put forward in this direction . while it may develop that some of the principles behind these are correct , until recently there was no example where the states of a black hole could be counted in a controlled way . the idea is to count supersymmetric ( bps ) black hole states . such black holes always carry gauge charges and have the maximum allowed charge to mass ratio they are extremal . as discussed in section 2.2 , the number of bps states can not change as we vary the string coupling constant . as the coupling is reduced and so the gravitational interaction weakened , certain black holes will at sufficiently weak coupling no longer look like black holes . rather , they look like a collection of d - particles as depicted in figure 7 ; this has the same charge - to - mass ratio as the black hole . the d - particles are a weakly coupled quantum system whose spectrum is explicitly known from d - brane methods . the density of bps states is just that given by the bekenstein - hawking entropy ( strominger and vafa , 1996 , and much subsequent work ; for a review see horowitz , 1996 ) . closely associated with all this is the black hole information paradox . a black hole of given mass and charge can be formed in a very large number of ways . it will then evaporate , and the final state is black body radiation that does not depend on how the black hole formed . thus , many initial states evolve to a single final state . this violates the usual laws of quantum mechanics . there are various schools of thought here ( reviewed in page , 1993 ) . the proposal of hawking ( 1976 ) is that this is just the way things are : the laws of quantum mechanics need to be changed . there is also strong opposition to this view . the problem is not that theorists believe that the laws of quantum mechanics are in their final form they may be , though most of us would like to see a less mysterious structure . rather , it is that the specific modification required here , the replacement of wavefunctions with density matrices , seems ugly and very possibly inconsistent . the principal alternative , that the initial state is encoded in subtle correlations in the hawking radiation , sounds plausible but in fact is even more radical . the problem is that hawking radiation emerges from the region of the horizon , where the geometry is smooth and so ordinary low energy field theory should be valid . one can follow the hawking radiation and see correlations develop between the fields inside and outside the black hole ; the superposition principle then forbids the necessary correlations to exist strictly among the fields outside . to evade this requires that the locality principle in quantum field theory break down in some long - ranged but subtle way . there is a proposal for how this might occur in string theory ( susskind , 1993 , 1995 ; lowe , polchinski , susskind , thorlacius , and uglum , 1995 ) , but it is controversial . the recent progress in string duality suggests that black holes do obey the ordinary rules of quantum mechanics . the multiplets include black holes along with various nonsingular states , and in figure 7 we have continuously deformed a black hole into a system which obeys ordinary quantum mechanics , at least to high accuracy . this is certainly not decisive , however . the problem is that dynamical properties are not like the counting of bps states ; they are not invariant under changes in parameters . it could be that as the coupling constant is increased , a critical coupling is reached where the d - particles collapse into a black hole . at this coupling there could be a discontinuous change ( or a smooth crossover ) from ordinary quantum behavior to information loss . it is an open question whether d - branes will give insight into the dynamical behavior of black holes ; there are hints that it may be so . so when will string theory make sharp predictions ? probably not until the vacuum is understood , as we discussed in section 2.3 . an important problem remains in our understanding of the vacuum , when we try to calculate the vacuum energy density , the cosmological constant . the vacuum is a complicated place , and there are many different contributions to the energy density the zero point energies of the quantum fields , the potential energy of the higgs field , the energy of the strongly fluctuating qcd fields . the total of the separate densities is at least @xmath88 gev@xmath89 , and there is no reason known that they should cancel to any degree of accuracy . yet the experimental bound on the cosmological constant is 55 orders of magnitude smaller than this ( see weinberg , 1989 , for a review ) . this is just as much problem in quantum field theory as in string theory but field theory can still make precise predictions because it is less ambitious . one can ignore gravity , or add a free parameter and adjust it to cancel the other contributions to the cosmological constant . in string theory , neither of these is possible . does string duality help here ? possibly . it is an interesting fact that in supersymmetric theories the energy density can cancel naturally . for example the zero point energies of bosons and their fermionic partners are equal and opposite . one can see this in the discussion of bps states : a supersymmetric vacuum has zero energy ( though the inclusion of supergravity makes things a bit more subtle ) . in nature , though , supersymmetry must be spontaneously broken there is no charged boson degenerate with the electron and spontaneous breaking spoils the cancellation of the cosmological constant . we need some new phase of supersymmetric theories , in which the boson / fermion degeneracy is removed while the vacuum energy remains zero . witten ( 1995b ) has suggested how such a phase might appear in strongly coupled string theory . from another point of view , the cosmological constant and black hole information problems both seem to require subtle nonlocalities in spacetime . for the information problem we have discussed this ; for the cosmological constant , the point is that the low energy value of this constant must somehow feed back into the short - distance physics that determines it . for example , it was argued that spacetime wormholes could accomplish this ( coleman , 1988 ) . this proposal was the subject of intense and skeptical scrutiny , but the subject ground to a halt because a nonperturbative formulation of quantum gravity was lacking . it may then be that it will return , possibly in some transmuted form , when we know what string theory is . in closing , let me say that there is a sense among those working in string theory that we are dealing with a unique and remarkable structure , one which has many points of contact with the physics we know and with earlier attempts to unify it quantum mechanics , gravity , gauge symmetry , chirality , grand unification , supersymmetry , and kaluza - klein theory . there is also a sense that we are discovering this structure , not inventing it . the distinction is illustrated , for example , by the question of the nature of spacetime . there have been many previous attempts to modify spacetime in a way that would look the same at long distance but would solve the problems of quantum gravity . this approach has often been sterile it is not a problem that seems to yield to direct effort . string theory , on the other hand , starts with a flat spacetime . one discovers first that the spacetime is dynamical , that the theory contains gravity . later one finds , as mentioned in section 3.5 , that spacetime topology is not a physical invariant but can change in specific and controlled ways . there is still more to be learned . in perturbation theory it seems that the shortest sensible distance is the string length scale , the typical radius of zero point vibrations of the string ( gross and mende , 1987 ; amati , ciafaloni , and veneziano , 1989 ; reviewed in witten , 1996c ) . this works out to be the planck length divided by a power of the string coupling . there is evidence for a somewhat shorter scale in the exact theory ( shenker , 1995 ) , and that d - branes may probe it ( bachas , 1995 ; danielsson , ferretti and sundborg , 1995 ; kabat and pouliot , 1995 ) . moreover , there is a sense in which the spacetime coordinates for d - branes are elevated from numbers to matrices ( witten , 1996a ) ; only at low energy the matrices are diagonal and an ordinary spacetime picture holds . it may turn that this is a curiosity , or it may signal a new uncertainty principle relating to a minimum distance . exploring the connection between d - branes and black holes is a likely way to learn which . in effect , string theory is smarter than we are . it knows what spacetime is , and we do nt , and we have to figure out how to ask it . we are very fortunate that this remarkable structure exists and that it seems to be within our power to understand it . i would like to thank gary horowitz , clifford johnson , and andy strominger for their suggestions on the manuscript . this work is supported by nsf grants phy91 - 16964 and phy94 - 07194 . u. amaldi , w. de boer , and h. furstenau , 1991 , `` comparison of grand unified theories with electroweak and strong coupling constants measured at lep , '' phys . lett . * b260 , * 447 . + d. amati , m. ciafaloni , and g. veneziano , 1989 , `` can spacetime be probed below the string scale ? '' phys . lett . * b216 , * 41 . + p. s. aspinwall , b. r. greene , and d. r. morrison , 1993 , `` multiple mirror manifolds and topology change in string theory , '' phys . lett . * b303 , * 249 , e - print hep - th/9301043 . + c. bachas , 1996 , `` d - brane dynamics , '' phys . * b374 , * 37 , e - print hep - th/9511043 . + e. bergshoeff , e. sezgin , and p.k . townsend , 1987 , `` supermembranes and eleven dimensional supergravity , '' phys . lett . * b189 , * 75 . + p. candelas , g. horowitz , a. strominger , and e. witten , 1985 , `` vacuum configurations for superstrings , '' nucl . phys . * b258 , * 46 . + b. carter , 1979 , `` the general theory of the mechanical , electromagnetic , and thermodynamic properties of black holes , '' in _ general relativity . an einstein centennial survey , _ ed . s. w. hawking and w. israel ( cambridge , cambridge ) . + s. coleman , 1988 , `` why there is nothing rather than something : a theory of the cosmological constant , '' nucl . phys . * b310 , * 643 . + e. d. commins and p. h. bucksbaum , 1983 , _ weak interactions of leptons and quarks _ ( cambridge , new york ) . + e. cremmer , b. julia , and j. scherk , 1978 , `` supergravity theory in eleven dimensions , '' phys . lett . * 76b , * 409 . + a. dabholkar , 1995 , `` ten - dimensional heterotic string as a soliton , '' phys . * b357 , * 307 , e - print hep - th/9506160 . + j. dai , r. g. leigh , and j. polchinski , 1989 , `` new connections between string theories , '' mod . . lett . * a4 , * 2073 . + u. h. danielsson , g. ferretti , and b. sundborg , 1996 , `` d - particle dynamics and bound states , '' preprint usitp-96 - 03 , e - print hep - th/9603081 . + p. a. m. dirac , 1931 , `` quantized singularities in the electromagnetic field , '' proc . * a133 , * 60 . + m. j. duff , p.s . howe , t. inami , and k.s . stelle , 1987 , `` superstrings in @xmath90 from supermembranes in @xmath91 , '' phys * 191b , * 70 . + m. j. duff , 1988 , `` supermembranes : the first fifteen weeks , '' class . * 5 , * 189 . + m. j. duff , 1995 , `` strong / weak duality from the dual string , '' nucl . * b442 , * 47 , e - print hep - th/9506057 . + a. font , l. ibanez , d. lust , and f. quevedo , 1990 , `` strong - weak coupling duality and nonperturbative effects in string theory , '' phys . * b249 , * 35 . + f. gliozzi , j. scherk , and d. olive , 1977 , `` supersymmetry , supergravity theories , and the dual spinor model , '' nucl . phys . * b122 , * 253 ; reprinted in schwarz , 1985 , vol . 1 , 300 . + m. b. green and j. h. schwarz , 1984 , `` anomaly cancellations in supersymmetric @xmath90 gauge theory and superstring theory , '' phys . lett . * 136b , * 367 ; reprinted in schwarz , 1985 , vol . 2 , 1007 . + m. b. green , j. h. schwarz , and e. witten , 1987 , _ superstring theory , vols . 1 and 2 _ ( cambridge , cambridge ) . + b. r. greene , d. r. morrison , and a. strominger , 1995 , `` black hole condensation and the unification of string vacua , '' nucl . * b451 , * 109 , e - print hep - th/9504145 . + d. j. gross , j. a. harvey , e. martinec , and r. rohm , 1985 , `` heterotic string , '' phys . * 54 , * 502 . + r. haag , j. t. lopuszanski , and m sohnius , 1975 , `` all possible generators of supersymmetries of the s matrix , '' nucl . phys . * b88 , * 257 . + j. a. harvey and a. strominger , 1995 , `` the heterotic string is a soliton , '' nucl . * b449 , * 535 , ( e ) * b458 , * 456 , e - print hep - th/9504047 . + j. a. harvey , 1996 , `` magnetic monopoles , duality , and supersymmetry , '' chicago preprint efi-96 - 06 , e - print hep - th/9603086 . + s. w. hawking , 1975 , `` particle creation by black holes , '' comm . * 43 , * 199 . + s. w. hawking , 1976 , `` breakdown of predictability in gravitational collapse , '' phys . rev . * d14 , * 2460 . + p. horava and e. witten , 1996 , `` heterotic and type i string dynamics from eleven dimensions , '' nucl . * b460 , * 506 , e - print hep - th/9510209 . + g. t. horowitz , 1996 , `` the origin of black hole entropy in string theory , '' ucsb preprint ucsbth-96 - 07 , e - print gr - qc/9604051 . + c. m. hull and p. k. townsend , 1995 , `` unity of superstring dualities , '' nucl . * b438 , * 109 , e - print hep - th/9410167 . + c. m. hull , 1995 , `` string - string duality in ten - dimensions , '' phys . * b357 , * 545 , e - print hep - th/9506194 . + k. intriligator and n. seiberg , 1995 , `` lectures on supersymmetric gauge theories and electric - magnetic duality , '' presented at tasi 95 , boulder , colo . , trieste summer school , trieste , italy , and cargese summer school , cargese , france , rutgers preprint ru-95 - 48 , e - print hep - th/9509066 . + d. kabat and p. pouliot , `` a comment on zero - brane quantum mechanics , '' rutgers preprint ru-96 - 17 , e - print hep - th/9603127 . + v. s. kaplunovsky , 1988 , `` one loop effects in string unification , '' nucl . phys . * b307 , * 145 , ( e ) * b382 , * 436 ( 1992 ) , e - print hep - th/9205070 . + d. a. lowe , j. polchinski , l. susskind , l. thorlacius , and j. uglum , 1995 , `` black hole complementarity versus locality , '' phys . rev . * d52 , * 6997 , e - print hep - th/9506138 . + c. montonen and d. olive , 1977 , `` magnetic monopoles as gauge particles ? '' phys . * 72b , * 117 . + a. neveu and j. scherk , 1972 , `` connection between yang - mills fields and dual models , '' nucl . phys . * b36 , * 155 . + h. osborn , 1979 , `` topological charges for @xmath44 supersymmetric gauge theories and monopoles of spin 1 , '' phys . * 83b , * 321 . + d. n. page , 1993 , `` black hole information , '' canadian gen . rel . * 1993 , * 1 , e - print hep - th/9305040 . + j. polchinski , 1994 , `` what is string theory ? '' les houches summer school , session 62 : fluctuating geometries in statistical mechanics and field theory , 1994 , e - print hep - th/9411028 + j. polchinski , 1995 , `` dirichlet - branes and ramond - ramond charges , '' phys . * 75 , * 4724 , e - print hep - th/9510017 . + j. polchinski and e. witten , 1996 , `` evidence for heterotic - type i string duality , '' nucl . phys . * b460 , * 525 , e - print hep - th/9510169 . + j. polchinski , s. chaudhuri , and c. v. johnson , 1996 , `` notes on d - branes , '' itp preprint nsf - itp-96 - 003 , e - print hep - th/9602052 . + p. ramond , 1971 , `` dual theory for free fermions , '' phys . * d3 , * 2415 ; reprinted in schwarz , 1985 , vol . 1 , 53 . + a. salam , 1980 , `` grand unification of fundamental forces , '' rev . * 52 , * 525 . + j. scherk and j. h. schwarz , 1974 , `` dual models for non - hadrons , '' nucl . * b81 , * 118 ; reprinted in schwarz , 1985 , vol . 1 , 191 . + j. scherk and j. h. schwarz , 1975 , `` dual model approach to a renormalizable theory of gravitation , '' caltech preprint calt-58 - 488 ; reprinted in schwarz , 1985 , vol . 1 , 218 . + j. h. schwarz , 1985 , _ superstrings . the first 15 years of superstring theory , vols . 1 and 2 _ ( world scientific , singapore ) . + j. h. schwarz , 1995 , `` an @xmath92 multiplet of type iib superstrings , '' phys . * b360 , * 13 , ( e ) * b364 , * 252 , e - print hep - th/9508143 . + n. seiberg , 1994 , `` exact results on the space of vacua of four - dimensional susy gauge theories , '' phys * d49 , * 6857 , e - print hep - th/9402044 . + n. seiberg , 1995 , `` the power of duality : exact results in 4-d susy field theory , '' rutgers preprint ru-95 - 37 , e - print hep - th/9506077 . + a. sen , 1994 , `` strong - weak coupling duality in four - dimensional string theory , '' int . * a9 , * 3707 , e - print hep - th/9402002 . + a. sen , 1995a , `` string string duality conjecture in six - dimensions and charged solitonic strings , '' nucl . * b450 , * 103 , e - print hep - th/9504027 . + a. sen , 1995b , `` a note on marginally stable bound states in type ii string theory , '' mehta preprint mri - phy-23 - 95 , e - print hep - th/9510229 . + s. h. shenker , 1991 , `` the strength of nonperturbative effects in string theory , '' in _ random surfaces and quantum gravity _ , eds . o. alvarez , e. marinari , and p. windey ( plenum , 1991 ) . + s. h. shenker , 1995 , `` another length scale in string theory ? '' rutgers preprint ru-95 - 53 , e - print hep - th/9509132 . + a. strominger , 1990 , `` heterotic solitons , '' nucl . * b343 , * 167 , ( e ) * b353 , * 565 . + a. strominger and c. vafa , 1996 , `` microscopic origin of the bekenstein - hawking entropy , '' preprint hutp-96-a002 , e - print hep - th/9601029 . + l. susskind , 1993 , `` string theory and the principles of black hole complementarity , '' phys . * 71 , * 2367 , e - print hep - th/9307168 + l. susskind , 1995 , `` the world as a hologram , '' j. math . phys . * 36 , * 6377 , e - print hep - th/9409089 . + p. k. townsend , 1995 , `` the eleven - dimensional supermembrane revisited , '' phys . * b350 , * 184 , e - print hep - th/9501068 . + s. weinberg , 1980 , `` conceptual foundations of the unified theory of weak and electromagnetic interactions , '' rev . * 52 , * 515 . + s. weinberg , 1989 , `` the cosmological constant problem , '' rev . * 61 , * 1 . + k. wilson , 1983 , `` the renormalization group and critical phenomena , '' rev . mod . * 55 , * 515 . + e. witten and d. olive , 1978 , `` supersymmetry algebras that include topological charges , '' phys . lett . * 78b , * 97 . + e. witten , 1981 , `` search for a realistic kaluza - klein theory , '' nucl . * b186 , * 412 . + e. witten , 1995a , `` string theory dynamics in various dimensions , '' nucl . * b443 , * 85 , e - print hep - th/9503124 . + e. witten , 1995b , `` strong coupling and the cosmological constant , '' mod . * a10 , * 2153 , e - print hep - th/9506101 . + e. witten , 1996a , `` bound states of strings and @xmath93-branes , '' nucl . * b460 , * 335 , e - print hep - th/9510135 . + e. witten , 1996b , `` strong - coupling expansion of calabi - yau compactification , '' ias preprint iassns - hep-96 - 08 , e - print hep - th/9602070 . + e. witten , 1996c , `` reflections on the fate of spacetime , '' phys . today * 49 , * 4 , 5 . | the strong coupling limit of a quantum system is in general quite complicated , but in some cases a great simplification occurs : the strongly coupled limit is equivalent to the weakly coupled limit of some other system . in string theory conjectures of this type go back several years , but only in the past year and a half has it been understood to be a general principle applying to all string theories . this has improved our understanding of string dynamics , including quantum gravity , in many new and sometimes surprising ways . i describe these developments and put them in the context of the search for the unified theory of particle physics and gravity . epsf.tex 3.7 in * string duality * * a colloquium * * joseph polchinski * institute for theoretical physics university of california santa barbara , ca 93106 - 4030 e - mail : [email protected] |
0809.3313 | the radio emission of core - dominated , radio - loud active galactic nuclei ( agn ) is synchrotron radiation generated in the relativistic jets that emerge from the nucleus of the galaxy , presumably along the rotational axis of a central supermassive black hole . one important source of information about the physical conditions in the radio - emitting regions is the distribution of the spectral index @xmath0 over the source ( @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the source flux at frequency @xmath3 ) . the core region is typically observed to be at least partially optically thick , with a nearly flat or inverted spectrum , while the jets are optically thin , with negative spectral indices . the spectrum may also flatten in regions of the jet in which there is re - acceleration of electrons or low - frequency absorption ( e.g. gabuzda , pushkarev & garnich 2000 ; gabuzda , gmez & agudo 2001 ) . synchrotron radiation can be highly linearly polarised , to @xmath4 in the case of a uniform magnetic field ( pacholczyk 1970 ) , and linear polarisation observations can yield unique information about the orientation and degree of order of the magnetic field in the synchrotron source , as well as the distribution of thermal electrons and the magnetic - field geometry in the immediate vicinity of the agn ( e.g. , via faraday rotation of the plane of polarisation ) . the compact radio emission of such agn can be probed with high resolution using very long baseline interferometry ( vlbi ) . the radio telescopes in the interferometric array can be separated by hundreds or thousands of kilometres , making it infeasible to physically link ( synchronise ) them electronically , and high - accuracy timing signals must be recorded together with the data , so that the signals obtained at different antennas can be accurately synchronised during correlation . in practice , the amplitudes and , especially , phases of the measured complex visibility data unavoidably contain unknown errors , which can conveniently be expressed via antenna - based complex gain factors : @xmath5 where @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the observed and true visibility functions on the baseline between antennas @xmath8 and @xmath9 , and @xmath10 , @xmath11 are the complex gain factors for antennas @xmath8 and @xmath9 . the complex gains @xmath12 must be determined and removed from the data in order to achieve the highest - quality images possible for the radio - telescope array used . this is normally done iteratively , via alternate application of self - calibration ( fort and yee 1976 , cotton 1979 , readhead & wilkinson 1978 , readhead et al . 1980 , cornwell & wilkinson 1981 ) and a deconvolution method , such as clean ( hgbom 1974 ) . since agn are variable , it goes without saying that multi - frequency data to be compared must correspond to epochs separated by time intervals appreciably less than the timescales for variability of the source . when preparing data for techniques involving comparison of multi - frequency data , various instrumental differences between the datasets must also be taken into account . vlbi datasets at different frequencies will have different angular resolutions and sensitivities to structures on various scales due to the different baseline coverages of the observations . one approach to reducing these differences when comparing multi - frequency images is to match the baseline coverages at different frequencies by giving relatively low weights to the longest baselines at higher frequencies and to the shortest baselines at lower frequencies , e.g. , via tapering of the visibility data . alternatively , the images can be obtained without such weighting , but then all be convolved with the same clean beam before comparison . the size of the clean beam to be used in this case is ordinarily roughly equal to the central lobe of the dirty beam for the lowest frequency . the accuracy to which the positions of the clean components are known is limited by the resolution of the observing system , and convolving with a beam that was much smaller than the central lobe of the dirty beam would result in a `` superresolved '' image that may not be reliable . iterative imaging via self - calibration and a deconvolution algorithm such as clean is generally quite effective , but the absolute information about the coordinates of the source on the sky is lost during phase self - calibration , which essentially places the centre of gravity of the radio brightness distribution at the phase centre , which has coordinates @xmath13 . because most radio - loud agn are highly core - dominated , directly comparing multi - frequency self - calibrated vlbi images of agn essentially amounts to aligning these images on the observed vlbi core , which usually coincides very closely with the peak of the radio brightness distribution . however , the standard theory of extragalactic radio sources ( e.g. blandford & knigl 1979 ) predicts a frequency - dependent shift in the location of the vlbi core due to opacity effects in the core region . reabsorption of synchrotron radiation takes place in the ultra - compact region near the central engine of an agn , a mechanism which is more efficient at low frequencies . consequently , the peak brightness appears further along the jet axis in lower frequency observations . thus the alignment of multi - frequency images on their vlbi core results in a misalignment between images of different observing frequencies . this prediction is supported by observation : the frequency - dependent shift in core position has been measured for several quasars and micro - quasars ( see lobanov 1998 and references therein ) , and the effect is discussed in terms of its impact on high precision astrometry by fey ( 2000 ) , charlot ( 2002 ) , ros ( 2005 ) and boboltz ( 2006 ) . lobanov ( 1998 ) explains in detail how the frequency - dependence of the shift depends on physical conditions near the central engine . it is thus necessary to correctly align images prior to applying multi - frequency data - analysis techniques . this can be achieved in one of two ways . the first is by phase - referenced observations , first employed by marcaide & shapiro ( 1984 ) , in which a nearby source ( or sources ) is observed along with the target source . the reference source would ideally be a point source , to eliminate structure effects including those discussed above , but this is rarely possible since most sources show extended structure on the milliarcsecond scales available with vlbi . the position of the target source relative to the reference source can then be determined . the second method involves aligning images according to the positions of optically thin jet components ( i.e. components optically thin to synchrotron radiation , so that their positions are not affected by absorption effects such as those occuring in the core ) that are present in both images to be compared . this can be non - trivial , particularly if the source has a complicated structure , but has been employed effectively by several authors , such as paragi et al . ( 2000 ) , who used this method to determine the radio core shift in 1823 + 568 . this difficulty in aligning complex images without distinct optically thin components detected at all frequencies to be compared was the main motivation for us to consider alternative methods of image alignment . the method we have developed to align multi - frequency images is based on the cross - correlation technique widely used in many fields , including biomedical signal processing and imaging ( panescu 1993 , frank & mcewan 1992 ) and remote sensing ( hartl 1976 ) . cross - correlation provides a measure of how closely correlated ( i.e. how alike ) two functions are . the use of this measure in image alignment gives an objective , quantitative assessment of how well two images are aligned , and does not depend on the presence of very compact features . by applying different shifts between images and calculating the cross - correlation coefficient for each shift , it is possible to determine which shift results in the best alignment . the normalised cross - correlation coefficient we used ( see , e.g. , dunn & clark 1974 ) is defined in two - dimensions as : @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the number of pixels in each direction in the two - dimensional images to be compared , @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the intensities for the maps at frequencies @xmath18 and @xmath19 at pixel @xmath20 , and @xmath21 and @xmath22 are the mean values of these two intensities over the region analyzed . although the source emission at a given location varies with frequency , all the radiation observed at radio frequencies is believed to be synchrotron radiation from the same population of relativistic electrons . therefore the optically thin total - intensity ( @xmath23 ) structures should be well - correlated despite local changes in the spectrum of the synchrotron emission due to variations in the local magnetic field , interaction with the surrounding medium and other effects . using this ( reasonable ) assumption , it is possible to determine the shift to be applied between maps by comparing the structures of optically thin regions of the source at different frequencies . the highest correlation between dual - frequency images should therefore be obtained when the areas being compared correspond to the same physical region of the sky . this method has the advantage that it takes account of the optically thin emission from the _ entire _ source , not just isolated compact components . the most widely used software for the calibration , imaging and analysis of radio interferometric data is the national radio astronomy observatory aips ( astronomical image processing system ) package . we have written a c program to implement the cross - correlation technique , which is external to but compatible with the nrao aips package . the input to the program are two images in the format produced by the aips task imtxt , and the program outputs files which can be imported back into aips using the task fetch . imtxt allows the user to export an aips image as a text file containing an array of floats representing the map values at each pixel location . conversely , fetch imports a text file in the format exported by imtxt as a map file which can be displayed by any aips tasks that work with images ( e.g. kntr , tvlod ) . ( 360,360 ) ( 288,288)[bl ] ( 0,0)(0,288)2(0,0)(18,0)16(1,0)12 ( 0,0)(288,0)2(0,0)(0,18)16(0,1)12 ( 0,0)(12,12)7 ( 36,36)(0,288)2(1,0)288 ( 36,36)(288,0)2(0,1)288 ( 72,72)(0,216)2(1,0)216 ( 72,72)(216,0)2(0,1)216 ( 234,126 ) ( 72,285)(3,3)2(1,-1)147 ( 246,111)(3,3)2(1,-1)39 ( 72,279)(9,9)2(1,-1)146 ( 241,110)(9,9)2(1,-1)38 ( 72,273)(15,15)2(1,-1)144 ( 237,108)(15,15)2(1,-1)36 ( 72,267)(21,21)2(1,-1)144 ( 231,108)(21,21)2(1,-1)36 ( 72,261)(27,27)2(1,-1)189 ( 72,255)(33,33)2(1,-1)183 ( 72,249)(39,39)2(1,-1)177 ( 72,243)(45,45)2(1,-1)171 ( 72,237)(51,51)2(1,-1)165 ( 72,231)(57,57)2(1,-1)159 ( 72,225)(63,63)2(1,-1)153 ( 72,219)(69,69)2(1,-1)147 ( 72,213)(75,75)2(1,-1)141 ( 72,207)(81,81)2(1,-1)135 ( 72,201)(87,87)2(1,-1)129 ( 72,195)(93,93)2(1,-1)123 ( 72,189)(99,99)2(1,-1)117 ( 72,183)(105,105)2(1,-1)111 ( 72,177)(111,111)2(1,-1)105 ( 72,171)(117,117)2(1,-1)99 ( 72,165)(123,123)2(1,-1)93 ( 72,159)(129,129)2(1,-1)87 ( 72,153)(135,135)2(1,-1)81 ( 72,147)(141,141)2(1,-1)75 ( 72,141)(147,147)2(1,-1)69 ( 72,135)(153,153)2(1,-1)63 ( 72,129)(159,159)2(1,-1)57 ( 72,123)(165,165)2(1,-1)51 ( 72,117)(171,171)2(1,-1)45 ( 72,111)(177,177)2(1,-1)39 ( 72,105)(183,183)2(1,-1)33 ( 72,99)(189,189)2(1,-1)27 ( 72,93)(195,195)2(1,-1)21 ( 72,87)(201,201)2(1,-1)15 ( 72,81)(207,207)2(1,-1)10 ( 298,184)(-1,0)10 ( 298,182)@xmath24 ( 314,184)(1,0)10 ( 184,298)(0,-1)10 ( 180,302)@xmath24 ( 184,314)(0,1)10 ( 218,123)@xmath25 the input images to the program must have the same pixel size and numbers of pixels ( i.e. so that both the size of a pixel and the overall size of the images correspond to the same area on the sky ) , convolved with the same beam , and exported from aips using the task imtxt . the user specifies the maximum trial shift to be applied between the images . the procedure used to calculate the shift that best aligns the input images is as follows . 1 . strips of width @xmath26 , where @xmath26 is the maximum shift to be applied to the maps , are subtracted from each edge of the first map ( map 1 ) . an area of the same shape as the restoring beam , but whose size is specified by the user , is removed from the area in map 1 surrounding the ( at least partially ) optically thick core , whose position will be frequency - dependent and which usually corresponds to the peak of the map . in comparatively unusual cases , the brightest feature may not correspond to the core ; to enable the program to produce reliable results for this situation , we have included the option of the user specifying the position of the core . the remaining area is used in the comparison ( see fig . the second map ( map 2 ) is shifted so that different regions overlay this area each time . since the area of map 1 is not changed , the normalised cross - correlation coefficients can be compared directly to determine which part of map 2 is best correlated with the selected region . 3 . map 2 is first shifted so that its bottom left hand corner corresponds to the bottom left hand corner of the selected sub - area of map 1 . this corresponds to the maximum negative shift ( @xmath27 ) applied . map 2 is then shifted in right ascension , one pixel at a time , and the cross - correlation coefficient computed each time , until the maximum positive shift @xmath26 is reached . the image is then shifted by one pixel in declination , and the correlation coefficients for the next row computed in the same way . this is repeated until the maximum shift in both directions ( @xmath28 ) is reached , which occurs when the top right hand corner of map 2 corresponds to the top right hand corner of the selected subarea of map 1 . the program outputs to the screen the maximum correlation @xmath29 and the shift ( @xmath30,@xmath31 ) at which it occurs . 5 . having found the best initial alignment between the two images , the program now applies the corresponding shift to map 2 , constructs a spectral - index map and blanks any optically thick points in this map , taken to be points with spectral indices @xmath32 . the theoretical limiting optically thick spectral index @xmath33 is rarely reached , but it is generally accepted that a positive spectral index implies some optically thick contribution in that region . the optically thick regions are blanked _ after _ first calculating the shift with only the core region blanked , since the shift between the maps can result in a significant change in the spectral - index distribution , and thus in those regions which have @xmath32 . the cross - correlation procedure is then repeated , taking into account only the optically thin ( i.e. unblanked ) regions of the source , since the position of these regions is not affected by absorption effects . the program again outputs to the screen the maximum correlation @xmath29 and the shift ( @xmath30,@xmath31 ) at which it occurs . positive shifts correspond to moving the second image downward ( to the south ) and to the left ( east ) relative to the first image . in other words , a feature whose pixel location is ( @xmath34,@xmath35 ) in the first map is located at ( @xmath36,@xmath37 ) in the second map . three files are output . one is simply a text file containing the array of cross - correlation values computed , while the other two are text files of the format recognised by the aips task fetch . one of these likewise contains the cross - correlation coefficients ; importing this image into aips and plotting it ( e.g with kntr ) shows the shape of the cross - correlation function . the other image text file displays the subarea of map 1 that was compared ; displaying this image can be useful in verifying the area to be blanked around the optically thick core . ideally this area should be large enough to cover virtually all of the core region , but not features in the inner jet ; it should cover at least one beam size , and usually more , since the shape of the beam and the very high flux emanating from the core will dominate the vlbi @xmath23 structure here . in all cases we have tested , we found the cross - correlation function to fall off monotonically from its peak . this lends credence to the hypothesis that the optically thin jet structures in the maps should be well correlated when aligned properly ( if small - scale variations were important the function could show secondary peaks where individual features align well rather than falling off uniformly , but we have never found this to be the case ) . obviously , the accuracy of the estimated shift between a pair of images will depend to some extent on the pixel size in the images being compared . in practice , it may be expedient , within reason , to use images with slightly smaller pixel sizes in order to derive more refined shift estimates . the results should not depend on whether the higher - frequency or lower - frequency images is used as map 1 : in either case , it is the relative shift that is being determined , and the shifts obtained with the higher - frequency map as map 1 will be the negative of those obtained with the lower - frequency map as map 1 . in practice , it may be expedient to compare results obtained blanking out core areas of several different sizes ( e.g. 2.0 times the beam area , 2.5 times the beam area etc . ) , to ensure that the optically thick core region is fully blanked , while as much of the optically thin inner jet is included in the correlation analysis as possible . we present two examples of applying the program in practice to align total - intensity images of agn obtained with the nrao very long baseline array at 7.9 ghz and 5.1 ghz : ( i ) for 2007 + 777 , which displays a fairly distinct optically thin jet feature that could be used to align the two maps in the `` traditional '' way , and ( ii ) for 2200 + 420 , which displays only fairly amorphous optically thin jet emission . the maps compared have matched cell sizes , map sizes and beam parameters . the vlba observations were made over 24 hours in july 2006 in a snapshot mode , so that the baseline coverage obtained was spread out over the time the sources were visible with all or nearly all of the vlba antennas . the data was obtained simultaneously at the different frequencies . the preliminary calibration and imaging of these data were carried out in aips using standard techniques ; some initial results are presented by osullivan & gabuzda ( 2008 ) , and a more complete analysis is in preparation . for each of these two sources , we show a superposition of the 7.9 ghz and 5.1 ghz @xmath23 maps before and after applying the derived alignment shift ( figs . 2 and 4 ) , and the spectral - index maps obtained before and after applying the derived alignment shift ( figs . 3 and 5 ) . in both cases , we used a cell size of 0.1 mas during the initial total - intensity mapping , but used final maps made with a cell size of 0.05 mas as input to the program , to improve slightly the accuracy of the relative shifts obtained . in the case of 2007 + 777 , the derived shift of the 5.1 ghz relative to the 7.9 ghz image was 4 pixels ( 0.20 mas ) to the west and 0 pixels to the south , in the direction of the vlbi jet , as expected . the correctness of this shift is immediately obvious via a visual inspection of the superposed @xmath23 images ( fig . 2 ) and the spectral - index maps before and after applying this shift ( fig . 3 ) ; the algorithm has obviously aligned a distinct optically thin jet component located @xmath38 mas to the west of the map peak . in the case of 2200 + 420 , the calculated shift of the 5.1 ghz relative to the 7.9 ghz image was 4 pixels ( 0.20 mas ) to the south and 0 pixels to the east , again in the direction of the vlbi jet , as expected . it is less straightforward to estimate the correctness of this shift directly from the superposed @xmath23 maps in fig . 4 , but the spectral - index map after applying this shift shows appreciably more regular behaviour , with a smooth gradient in the spectral index from north of the core region to the jet extending nearly directly to the south ; in particular , a spurious region of optically thin emission to the north of the peak has disappeared . we also show the results of applying the cross - correlation technique to 4.8 and 1.6-ghz images of the agn 1803 + 784 ( gabuzda & chernetskii 2003 ) , as an example of the operation of the program when applied to two images at more widely separated frequencies . a superposition of the 4.8 ghz and 1.6 ghz @xmath23 maps before and after applying the derived alignment shift is shown in fig . 6 , and the spectral - index maps obtained before and after applying the derived alignment shift in fig . 7 . a cell size of 0.50 mas was used during the initial total - intensity mapping , but final maps with a cell size of 0.25 mas were used as input to the shift program . the derived shift of the 1.6 ghz relative to the 4.8 ghz image was 5 pixels ( 1.25 mas ! ) to the west and 1 pixel to the north , in the direction of the vlbi jet . although examination of the superposed @xmath23 images ( fig . 6 ) does not enable an unambiguous estimate of the needed shift `` by eye , '' the correctness of the shift derived by our program is immediately obvious via a visual inspection of the spectral - index maps before and after applying this shift ( fig . 7 ) . at first glance , the `` slanting '' boundary between the regions of optically thick and thin emission near the core seems suspicious , but in fact , the 4.8-ghz vsop space - vlbi image for this epoch shows that the vlbi jet initially emerges to the northwest ( gabuzda 1999 ) , and this feature likely real ( the implied spectral - index gradient is roughly perpendicular to the direction of the small - scale jet ) . finally , we show the two - dimensional plots of the cross - correlation functions output by the program for 2007 + 777 , 2200 + 420 and 1803 + 784 ( fig . the cross - correlation plots contain a single peak , with a monotonic fall - off in the correlation coefficient with distance from the derived optimal alignment shift . we have developed a c program to determine the shift between two vlbi images based on a cross - correlation analysis of the images . in the past , it has been necessary to determine such shifts for images of agn by aligning compact optically thin jet components , which can be a somewhat subjective and not entirely unambiguous procedure . in addition , this method is difficult to apply to complex and/or extended agn jets without compact optically thin features suitable for such an analysis . the great advantage of our new approach is that it provides a straightforward , objective means to determine the shift between two images that makes use of all optically thin regions in the source structure , not just individual chosen features . our tests have shown that the program produces reliable shifts for images both with and without distinct optically thin features . the code can be compiled using a standard c compiler , and has been designed to take input files written by the aips task imtxt , and to output files that can be read by the aips task fetch , making it straightforward for radio astronomers familiar with aips to implement the code . the code can be obtained by contacting d. c. gabuzda ( [email protected] ) . we thank shane p. osullivan for allowing us to use unpublished images of 2007 + 777 and 2200 + 420 as examples of our alignment program , and for help in making the spectral index maps for 1803 + 784 . sc thanks ger croke for helpful discussions on the cross - correlation technique . we are also grateful to the referee , bob campbell , for helpful comments that led to improvement of this paper . blandford r. d. & knigl a. 1979 , apj , 232 , 34 boboltz d. a. 2006 , in _ international celestial reference system and frame ( iers technical note 34 ) _ , eds . j. souchay & m. feissel vernier , p. 41 charlot p. 2002 , in _ international vlbi service for geodesy and astrometry 2000 , general meeting proceedings _ , ed . n. r. vandenburg & k. d. baver , nasa / cp-2002 - 210002 , p. 233 cornwell t. j. & wilkinson p. n. 1981 , mnras , 196 , 1067 cotton w. d. 1979 , aj , 84 , 1122 dunn o. h. & clark v. a. 1974 , _ applied statistics : analysis of variance and regression _ ( wiley ) fey a. 2000 , in _ iau colloq . 180 : towards models and constants for sub - microarcsecond astrometry _ , ed . k. j. johnston , d. d. mccarthy , b. j. luzum & g. h. kaplan ( washington , dc : us naval observatory ) , 20 fort d. n. & yee h. k. g. 1976 , a&a , 50 , 19 frank j. & mcewen b. f. 1992 , in _ electron tomography : three dimensional imaging with the transmission electron microscope _ , ed . j. frank ( plenum press ) , 205 gabuzda d. c. 1999 , new . , 43 , 691 gabuzda d. c. & chernetskii v. a. 2003 , mnras , 229 , 669 gabuzda d. c. , gmez j .- , agudo i , 2001 , mnras , 328 , 719 gabuzda d. c. , pushkarev a. b. & garnich n. n. , 2001 , mnras , 327 , 1 hartl p. 1976 , in _ remote sensing for environment sciences _ , ed . e. schanda ( springer - verlag ) , 304 hgbom j. a. 1974 , a&as , 15 , 417 lobanov a. p. 1998 , a&a , 330 , 79 marcaide j. m. & shapiro i. i. 1984 , apj , 276 , 56 osullivan s. p. & gabuzda d. c. 2008 , in _ extragalactic jets : theory and observation from radio to gamma ray _ , ed . t. a. rector & d. s. deyoung ( astronomy society of the pacific ) , in press . pacholczyk a. g. 1970 , radio astrophysics ( san francisco : freeman and co. ) panescu d. 1993 , in _ biomedical digital signal processing _ , ed . w. tompkins ( prentice hall ) , 216 paragi z. , fejes i. & frey s. 2000 , in _ international vlbi service for geodesy and astrometry 2000 , general meeting proceedings _ , ed . n. r. vandenburg & k. d. baver , nasa / cp-2000 - 209893 , p. 342 readhead a. c. s. , walker r. c. , pearson t. j. & cohen m. h. 1980 , nature , 285 , 137 readhead a. c. s. & wilkinson p. n. 1978 , apj , 223 , 137 ros e. 2005 , in _ future directions in high resolution astronomy : the 10th anniversary of the vlba _ j. romney & m. reid , asp conf . proc . , 340 , 482 . | many important techniques for investigating the properties of extragalactic radio sources , such as spectral - index and rotation - measure mapping , involve the comparison of images at two or more frequencies . in the case of radio interferometric data , this can be done by comparing the clean maps obtained at the different frequencies . however , intrinsic differences in images due to the frequency dependence of the radio emission can be distorted by additional differences that arise due to source variability ( if the data to be compared is obtained at different times ) , image misalignment , and the frequency dependence of the sensitivity to weak emission and the angular resolution provided by the observations ( the resolution of an interferometer depends on the lengths of its baselines in units of the observing wavelength ) . these effects must be corrected for as best as possible before multi - frequency data comparison techniques can be applied . we consider the origins for the afore - mentioned factors , outline the standard techniques used to overcome these difficulties , and describe in detail a technique developed by us , based on the cross - correlation technique widely used in other fields , to correct for misalignments between maps at different frequencies . [ firstpage ] |
gr-qc0201069 | theoretical physics faces nowadays a great challenge . there is four dimensional standard model on one side ( and the additional dimensions are not required to explain experimental data ) together with inflationary cosmology based on additional scalar fields @xcite . on the other side there is the completely supersymmetrical string / m - theory . building links between those approaches @xcite is a very motivating goal of modern physics which could be achieved by the study of microscopic black holes . as general relativity is not renormalizable , its direct standard quantization is impossible . to build a semiclassical gravitational theory , the usual lagrangian should be generalized , which is possible in different ways . one of them is to study the action expansion in scalar curvature , _ i.e. _ higher order curvature corrections . at the level of second order , according to the perturbational approach of string theory , the most natural choice is the 4d curvature invariant gauss - bonnet term @xmath0 @xcite . with 4d action , it is not possible to consider only @xmath1 because , being full derivative , it does not contribute to the field equations . it must be connected it with a scalar field @xmath2 to make its contribution dynamical . the following 4d effective action with second order curvature corrections can be built : @xmath3,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath4 is the string coupling constant . as in cosmology , the most simple generalization of the theory ( a single additional scalar field ) is not possible because while dealing with spherically symmetric solutions , the `` no - hair '' theorem restriction must be taken into account . treating @xmath2 as a dilatonic field , the coupling function @xmath5 is fixed from the first string principles and should be written @xmath6 @xcite , which leads to : @xmath7.\end{aligned}\ ] ] such type of actions can be considered as one of the possible middle steps between general relativity and quantum gravity . in this paper , we show that this effective string gravity model and its solutions can be applied for a description of the last stages of primordial black holes ( pbh ) evaporation @xcite and suggests possible dark matter candidates @xcite . this should be understood in the general framework of gauss - bonnet black hole ( bh ) theory @xcite . the paper is organized as follows : in section ii we briefly recall previously obtained results and point out some new features important for this study , section iii is devoted to the establishment of the new hawking evaporation law ( especially for the detailed description of last stages of gauss - bonnet bh evaporation ) , in section iv we show that the direct experimental registration of such pbhs is impossible , section v is devoted to pbh relics as dark matter candidates and section vi contains discussions and conclusions . for the sake of completeness , main results from ref . @xcite are briefly repeated . starting from the action ( [ a11 ] ) , a static , spherically symmetric , asymptotically flat black hole solution is considered . one of the most convenient choice of metric in this model is @xmath8 where @xmath9 , @xmath10 . asymptotic expansion of the solution has the usual quasi - schwarzschild form , @xmath11 where @xmath12 and @xmath13 are adm ( arnowit - dieser - misner ) mass and dilatonic charge respectively . using a dedicated code , a bh type solution was obtained . this solution provides a regular horizon of quasi - schwarzschild type and the asymptotic behaviour near this horizon @xmath14 is : @xmath15 where @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath14 are free independent parameters . after solving the equations to the first perturbation order , the following limit on the minimal bh size can be obtained : @xmath19 where @xmath4 is a combination of the string coupling constants ( _ fundamental value _ ) and @xmath20 is dilatonic value at @xmath14 , depending upon dilatonic value at infinity which can not be determined only in the framework of this model . according to this formula and taking into account the numerical values , the minimal bh mass has the order of planck one ( more precisely @xmath21 planck masses @xcite ) . it is necessary to point out that the stability of the solution under time perturbations at the event horizon was described in @xcite and was studied at the singularity @xmath22 in @xcite . contribution of higher order curvature corrections was studied in @xcite to show that , in the bosonic case with heterotic string models ( the question is still open in susy ii ) , all the new topological configurations are located inside the determinant singularity and , therefore , do not produce any new _ physical _ consequences . our conclusions remain valid when the next higher order curvature corrections are made of pure products of riemannian tensors . this topic is under additional investigation now . gathering these results , it can be concluded that the solution is stable in all the particular points , and , therefore , at all the values of initial data set . generalizing the model by taking into account the effective contribution of additional compact dimensions in the most simple form scalar field the action must be given as @xmath23.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this model was studied into the details in @xcite . for current investigations it should be emphasized that when the contribution of moduli field value is considered , a naked singularity can appear if the size of additional dimensions is greater than the bh size . the minimal bh mass must therefore be increased to 10 planck masses ( to avoid being in naked singularity region ) . it is a key feature because it allows to move away from the planck region and to use _ semiclassical approach_. if these additional dimensions were non - compact @xcite the bh minimal mass would be much greater . according to the analysis given in ref . @xcite , the transition from prelast to last stage of bh evaporation is forbidden and evaporating pbhs will never reach the minimal mass state . the shape of the bh mass loss rate law changes and becomes the one presented in fig.2 , analogously to the simplified `` toy model '' presented in @xcite . different types of similar models for bh evaporation were studied in lovelock gravity @xcite , string inspired curvature expansions @xcite and in many other theories . the numerical values of gauss - bonnet bh ( important for experimental search analysis ) will be presented in section d. in the wkb approximation of the hawking evaporation process , everything happens in the neighbourhood of the event horizon . as our metric functions @xmath24 and @xmath25 depend upon radial coordinate @xmath26 and black hole mass @xmath12 , i.e. @xmath27 and @xmath28 ( other variables are not important ) , we can use expansions ( [ a12 ] ) , taking into account only the first terms ( partially neglecting the dependence upon radial coordinate @xmath26 ) . using [ a12 ] , the metric can be written as : @xmath29 using the numerically calculated data , fits were performed for @xmath30 and @xmath31 . as we are interested mostly in the last stages of pbhs evaporation , where the difference from the standard bekenstein - hawking picture is considerable , taylor expansions around @xmath32 can be used . this also helps in obtaining good fits of the metric functions ( see fig.3 and fig.4 ) which can be considered as polynom expansions ( of @xmath12 or @xmath33 ) that are valid between @xmath34 and @xmath35 with good accuracy . @xmath36 where ( for @xmath37 ) the corresponding coefficients are @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 . using this technique , the pbh evaporation spectra and mass loss rate were derived in an analytical form ( valid only near the @xmath32 point ) . in some approaches , black holes are treated as immersed in a thermal bath and the evaporation can be described as a wkb approximation of semiclassical tunnelling in a dynamical geometry . in our investigation , we follow the techniques described in @xcite and @xcite . the same method was also applied in @xcite . some other descriptions of bh evaporation can be found in @xcite . the key idea of the method from ref.@xcite and @xcite is that the energy of a particle changes its sign when crossing the bh horizon . so , a pair created just inside or just outside the horizon can become real with zero total energy after one member of the pair has tunnelled to the opposite side . the energy conservation plays a fundamental role : transitions between states with the same total energy are the only possible ones . using quantum mechanical rules , it is possible to write the imaginary part of the action for an outgoing positive energy particle which crosses the horizon outwards from @xmath46 to @xmath47 as : @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the energy of the particle , @xmath50 is total hamiltonian ( and total energy ) and the metric is written so as to avoid the horizon coordinate singularity . following @xcite , painleve s coordinates are used . the transformation to this metric from the schwarzschild one can be obtained by changing the time variable : @xmath51 substituting @xmath52 into ( [ e21 ] ) one obtains @xmath53 in wkb approximation , the imaginary part of the semiclassical action @xmath54 , describing the probability of tunnelling through the horizon is @xmath55 where @xmath56 is canonical momentum . for gauss - bonnet bh the radial geodesics are described by the equation @xcite @xmath57 after substituting expression ( [ e41 ] ) to the equation ( [ e40 ] ) one obtains : @xmath58 substituting the expression ( [ a31 ] ) extended in ( [ e33 ] ) to the equation ( [ e44 ] ) , the imaginary part of the action can be written as : @xmath59 changing variables with @xmath60 @xmath54 takes the form @xmath61 as a result the imaginary part of the action is : @xmath62 where @xmath63 is a huge expression that can not be written here . it can be found at http://isnwww.in2p3.fr/ams/ims.ps . using the numerical values for a realistic order of @xmath32 around 10 planck masses , the corresponding @xmath64 and @xmath65 , it is possible to find from ( [ a31 ] ) the approximate expression for @xmath54 . as we are interested mostly in the last stages of bh evaporation where the influence of higher order curvature corrections is important , the limit @xmath66 can be taken in the computations , leading to a very different spectrum than the standard bekenstein - hawking picture ( where @xmath67 ) . taking into account energy conservation , @xmath49 can be bounded : @xmath68 . the approximate expression of @xmath69 for a given @xmath32 can then be used in the form @xmath70 where constant @xmath71 in planck unit values with a satisfying accuracy ( the plot of @xmath54 and its approximation are shown on fig.5 ) . following ref.@xcite , the emission spectrum per degree of freedom can simply be written as : @xmath72 @xmath73 being the absorption probability for a particle of spin @xmath74 and the heavyside function being implemented to take into account energy conservation with a minimal mass @xmath32 . in this section and in the following ones , standard units are used instead of planck ones as numerical results should be obtained for experimental fluxes . at this point , two questions have to be addressed : which kind of fields are emitted ( and which correlative @xmath75 have to be used ) and which mass range is physically interesting . to answer those questions , the mass loss rate is needed : @xmath76 where the integration is carried out up to @xmath77 so as to ensure that the transition below @xmath32 is forbidden . the absorption probabilities can clearly be taken is the limit @xmath78 as we are considering the endpoint emission when the cutoff imposed by @xmath32 prevents the black hole from emitting particle with energies of the order of @xmath79 . using analytical formulae @xcite and expanding @xmath80 to the first order with the approximation according to ( [ e49 ] ) , it is easy to show that the emission of spin-1 particles , given by ( per degree of freedom ) @xmath81 dominates over s=1/2 and s=2 emission whatever the considered energy in the previously quoted limit . it is interesting to point out that the fermion emission around @xmath32 is not strongly modified by the edgb model as , in the lowest order , @xmath82 . furthermore , if energy conservation was implemented as a simple cutoff in the hawking spectrum , the opposite result would be obtained : s=1/2 particles would dominate the mass loss rate as the power of @xmath83 in the absorption probability is the smallest one . if we restrict ourselves to massless particles , _ i.e. _ the only ones emitted when @xmath12 is very close to @xmath32 , the metric modification changes the endpoint emission nature from neutrinos to photons . the real mass loss rate is just twice the one given here to account for the electromagnetic helicity states . with this expression @xmath84 , it is possible to compute the mass @xmath12 at any given time @xmath85 after formation at mass @xmath86 as : @xmath87 where only the dominant term in the limit @xmath88 is taken from the analytical primitive of the function . as expected , the result does not depend on @xmath86 which is due to the fact that the time needed to go from @xmath86 to a few times @xmath32 is much less than the time taken to go from a few times @xmath32 to @xmath12 as long as @xmath89 for @xmath90 . at time @xmath85 after formation , the mass is given by : @xmath91 this mass can be implemented in the emission spectrum formula : @xmath92 leading to a frequency f given by @xmath93 if we want to investigate the possible relic emission produced now from pbhs formed in the early universe with small masses , this leads to a frequency around @xmath94 with a typical energy of the order of @xmath95 ev . this emission rate is very small as it corresponds to the evaporation into photons with wavelength much bigger that the radius of the black hole . it should , nevertheless , be emphasized that the spectrum is a monophonically increasing function of energy , up to the cutoff , with a @xmath96 behaviour . furthermore , it shows that , although very small in intensity , the evaporation never stops and leads to a mass evolution in @xmath97 . we investigate in this section the possibility to measure the previously given relic emission . let @xmath98 be the distance from the observer , @xmath99 the redshift corresponding to the distance @xmath98 , @xmath100 the opening angle of the detector ( chosen so that the corresponding solid angle is @xmath101 ) , @xmath102 the individual differential spectrum of a black hole relic ( bhr ) at time @xmath85 , @xmath103 the numerical bhr density taking into account the cosmic scale factor variations , @xmath104 the horizon in the considered energy range , @xmath105 the age of the universe and @xmath50 the hubble parameter . the `` experimental '' spectrum @xmath106 ( j@xmath107s@xmath108sr@xmath109 ) can be written as : @xmath110 which leads to : @xmath111 this integral can be analytically computed and takes into account both the facts that bhrs far away from earth must be taken at an earlier stage of their evolution and that energies must be redshifted . even assuming the highest possible density of bhrs ( @xmath112 ) and @xmath104 around the universe radius , the resulting flux is extremely small : @xmath113 around @xmath114 ev , nearly 20 orders of magnitude below the background . this closes the question about possible direct detection of bhrs emission . another way to investigate differences between edgb black holes particle emission and a pure hawking spectrum is to study the mass region where @xmath115 is maximal . taking into account that the mass loss rate becomes much higher in the edgb case than in the usual hawking picture , it could have been expected that the extremely high energy flux was strongly enhanced . in particular , it could revive the interest in pbhs as candidates to solve the enigma of measured cosmic rays above the gzk cutoff . nevertheless , the spectrum modification becomes important only when the mass is quite near to @xmath32 . depending on the real numerical value of @xmath32 , it can vary substantially ( increasing with increasing @xmath32 ) but remains a few planck masses above @xmath32 . this is far too small to account for a sizeable increase of the flux . the number of particles emitted above @xmath116ev in a pure hawking model is of the order of @xmath117 @xcite . this value should be taken with care as it relies on the use of leading log qcd computations of fragmentation functions far beyond the energies reached by colliders but the order of magnitude is correct . on the other hand , even if all the energy available when edgb modifications becomes important were released in @xmath116 ev particles ( which is not realistic ) it would generate only a few times @xmath118 particles and modify by less than 0.01% the pure hawking flux . it would not allow to generate , as expected , a spectrum harder than @xmath119 . the idea of pbh relics as a serious candidate for cold dark matter was first mentioned in @xcite . it was shown that in a friedman universe without inflation , planck - mass remnants of evaporating primordial black holes could be expected to have close to the critical density . nevertheless , the study was based on the undemonstrated assumption that either a stable object forms with a mass around @xmath120 or a naked space - time singularity is left . our study provides new arguments favouring massive relic objects , probably one order of magnitude above planck mass and could revive the interest in such non - baryonic dark matter candidates . an important problem is still to be addressed in standard inflationary cosmology : the rather large size of the horizon at the end of inflation . the standard formation mechanism of pbhs requires the mass of the black holes to be of the order of the horizon mass at the formation time and only those created after inflation should be taken into account as the huge increase of the scale factor would extremely dilute all the ones possibly formed before . it is easy to show that under such assumptions the density of planck relics is very small : @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the density of pbhs not yet evaporated , @xmath63 is the spectral index of the initial mass spectrum ( = 5/2 in the standard model for a radiation dominated universe ) , @xmath123 is the initial mass of a pbh which evaporating time is the age of the universe ( @xmath124 g ) and @xmath125 is the horizon mass at the end of inflation . this latter can be expressed as @xmath126 where @xmath127 is the formation time and @xmath128 is the reheating temperature . even with the highest possible value for @xmath128 , around @xmath129 gev ( according to ref . @xcite if the reheating temperature is more than @xmath130 gev , bhr remnants should be present nowadays ) and the upper limit on @xmath122 coming from gamma - rays , around @xmath131 the resulting density is extremely small : @xmath132 . there are , nevertheless , at least two different ways to revive the interest in pbh dark matter . the first one is related to relics that would be produced from an initial mass spectrum decreasing fast enough , so as to overcome the gamma - rays limit . the second one would be to have a large amount of big pbhs , between @xmath117 g and @xmath133 g , where experiments are completely blind : such black holes are too heavy to undergo hawking evaporation and too light to be seen by microlensing experiments ( mostly because of the finite size effect @xcite ) . the most natural way to produce spectra with such features is inflationary models with a scale , either corresponding to a change in the spectral index of the fluctuations power spectrum @xcite either corresponding to a step @xcite . in this paper , the bh type solution of 4d effective string gravity action with higher order curvature corrections was applied to the description of bhrs . a corrected version of the evaporation law near the minimal bh mass was established . it was shown that the standard bekenstein - hawking evaporation forluma must be modified in the neighbourhood of the last stages . our main conclusion is to show that contrarily to what is usually thought the evaporation does not end up by the emission of a few quanta with energy around planck values but goes asymptotically to zero with an infinite characteristic time scale . the direct experimental registration of the products of evaporation of bhrs is impossible . this gives an opportunity to consider these bhrs as one of the main candidates for cold dark matter in our universe . s.a . would like to thank the ams group in the institut des sciences nucleaires ( cnrs / ujf ) de grenoble for kind hospitality . & g.b are very grateful to the sternberg astronomical institute for inviting them . this work was supported in part by `` universities of russia : fundamental investigations '' via grant no . ur.02.01.026 and by russian federation state contract no . the authors are grateful to a. starobinsky and m. pomazanov for the very useful discussions on the subject of this paper . a.tseytlin , `` string solutions with nonconstant scalar fields '' _ published in the proceedings of international symposium on particle theory , wendisch - rietz , germany , 7 - 11 sep 1993 ( ahrenshoop symp.1993:0001 - 13 ) , _ hep - th/9402082 b.zwiebach , phys.lett . * b156 * , 315 ( 1985 ) ; e.poisson , class.quant.grav . * 8 * , 639 ( 1991 ) ; d.witt , phys.rev . * d38 * , 3000 ( 1988 ) ; j.t.wheeler , nucl.phys . * b268 * , 737 ( 1986 ) , nucl.phys . * b273 * , 732 ( 1986 ) ; g.w.gibbons and k.maeda , nucl.phys . * b298 * , 741 ( 1988 ) ; d.garfincle , g.horowitz and a.strominger , phys.rev . * d43 * , 3140 ( 1991 ) , phys.rev . * d45 * , 3888 ( 1992 ) . s. mignemi and n.r . stewart , phys . rev . * d47 * , 5259 ( 1993 ) ; p. kanti , n.e . mavromatos , j. rizos , k. tamvakis and e. winstanley , phys . rev . * d54 * , 5049 ( 1996 ) ; t. torii , h. yajima , and k. maeda , phys . rev . * d55 * , 739 ( 1997 ) . alexeyev and m.v . pomazanov , phys . * d55 * , 2110 ( 1997 ) ; s.o . alexeyev and m.v . sazhin , gen . relativ . and grav . * 8 * , 1187 ( 1998 ) ; s.o . alexeyev , m.v . sazhin and m.v.pomazanov , int . d10 * , 225 ( 2001 ) . a.g.polnarev , m.yu.khlopov , astronomicheskii zhurnal ( astronomical journal ) * 58 * , 706 ( 1981 ) , in russian ; m.yu.khlopov , b.a.malomed , ya.b.zeldovich , mnras * 215 * , 575 ( 1985 ) ; j.h.macgibbon , nature * 329 * , 308 ( 1987 ) ; j.h.macgibbon , b.carr , ap.j . * 371 * , 447 ( 1991 ) ; v.i.manko , m.a.markov , phys.lett . * a172 * , 331 ( 1993 ) . j.m.blatt , v.f.weisskopf , theoretical nuclear physics ( wiley , new york , 1952 ) , p. 520 ; a.a.starobinsky , s.m.churilov , zh . . fiz . * 65 * , 3 ( 1973 ) ; j.h.macgibbon , b.r.webber , phys . rev . * d41 * , 3052 ( 1990 ) . | the endpoint of black hole evaporation is a very intriguing problem of modern physics . based on einstein - dilaton - gauss - bonnet four dimensional string gravity model we show that black holes do not disappear and should become relics at the end of the evaporation process . the possibility of experimental detection of such remnant black holes is investigated . if they really exist , these objects could be a considerable part of the non baryonic dark matter in our universe . |
astro-ph9905208 | studies of the dynamics of clusters of galaxies play an important role in the analysis of large scale structure formation . cluster velocity dispersion measurements @xmath1 provide cluster mass estimates and a direct normalization of the primordial mass power spectrum ( see for instance eke et al . samples of abell clusters have been extensively used in these analyses . however , studies of selection effects in the abell catalog ( sutherland 1988 , dalton 1992 ) have shown the presence of serious projection effects and plate calibration systematics . on the other hand , numerical simulations @xcite provide evidence that cluster surveys in two dimensions are subject to strong projection biases if the cluster search radius is as large as abell s radius r@xmath2=1.5 h@xmath0 mpc . thus , clusters selected with this criteria are subject to a frequent superposition of groups that may produce artificial large velocity dispersions . nevertheless , these authors find that clusters obtained from two dimensional analysis but with a significantly smaller search radius , r=0.5 h@xmath0 mpc , have similar distributions of velocity dispersions than those clusters selected in three dimensions . several studies based on different observational samples frenk et al . ( 1990 ) , girardi et al . ( 1993 ) , zabludoff et al . ( 1993 ) , collins et al . ( 1995 ) , mazure et al . ( 1996 ) , fadda et al . ( 1996 ) have provided insights on the kinematics of galaxies in clusters . these works have been based on abell clusters where spurious high velocity dispersions may be expected due to projection effects . the edinburgh durham cluster catalog ( lumsden et al . 1992 ) although free from subjective visual systematics , would also be biased toward artificial large velocity dispersions due to superpositions given that the same search radius than in abell s catalog is used in the cluster identifications . other automated survey , the apm cluster catalog ( dalton et al . 1994 , 1997 ) has an intermediate search radius 0.75 h@xmath0 mpc although galaxies in the outer ring 0.500.75 h@xmath0 mpc have a smaller weight in the calculation of cluster richness . thus , it might be expected that the distribution of apm cluster velocity dispersions would be more representative of the true distribution . there are 31 apm identifications ( mazure et al . 1996 ) in the eso nearby abell cluster survey ( enacs ) . in a quantitative analysis of these data the authors conclude that the large spread between velocity dispersion and richness , both apm and abell , is probably or at least partially intrinsic to the clusters . in order to improve the sample of apm clusters with velocity dispersion estimates we have undergone an observational program to obtain radial velocities of galaxies in the field of apm clusters . we present in this paper new measurements of radial velocities of galaxies in the fields of 18 apm clusters . our data combined with radial velocities from the literature allow us to determine cluster velocity dispersions for 17 apm clusters ( 13 of these without previous estimates ) . in section 2 we present the galaxy data set and a statistical analysis of the new velocity dispersion estimates and those from the literature providing correlations between @xmath1 and richness counts @xmath3 . a brief discussion of the results is given in section 3 . we aim to estimate velocity dispersions of apm clusters for a wide range of richness . therefore , we have selected a sample of apm clusters ( dalton et al . 1994 , 1997 , hereafter apm iv and apm v respectively ) with redshifts between 0.06 and 0.13 and uniformly distributed in richness . to avoid confusion , cluster names are as in nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) . our sample comprises 23 apm clusters for which we have selected galaxies with @xmath4 19.5 from the edinburgh durham southern galaxy catalogue ( heydon - dumbleton et al . 1989 , hereafter cosmos ) within 0.75 mpc @xmath5 in projection from the cluster centers ( dalton et al . 1994 ) . we have chosen the apm clusters in our sample to have abell identifications ( abell 1958 , abell et al . 1989 ) in order to perform a comparative analysis between the cluster dynamics and richness . in table 1 we show basic information of our original sample . we list in column 1 and 2 , the cluster identifications ( apm and abell respectively ) ; columns 3 and 4 , coordinates of cluster centers ; columns 5 and 6 , mean cluster redshift and the number of objects used in these calculations from ebeling & maddox ( 1995 ) ; and columns 7 and 8 , the richness parameter from abell and apm v. as it can be seen from the table , most of the mean cluster redshifts are based on measurements of two members and it is very important to improve these cluster redshifts . the spectroscopic observations were carried out during 1996 and 1997 using a reosc spectrograph in the 2.15 m telescope at casleo observatory , argentina . we have used a 600 line mm@xmath0 grating with a resolution of 3.3@xmath6 . we observed the galaxies twice with typical exposure times of about 20 minutes to avoid collecting many cosmic rays . the spectral range was 4000@xmath6 to 7500@xmath6 and the spectra were calibrated using comparison lines from a he ne ar lamps with an accuracy of 15 km s@xmath0 . we also observed galaxies with known radial velocities to be used as templates . the data reductions were performed using the standard procedure to remove bias images , correct by flat - field and make illumination corrections using iraf routines . radial velocities were obtained following the cross correlation method of tonry & davies . table 2 shows radial velocities obtained with galaxies in common with other authors , listing the identification , coordinates , @xmath7 magnitude , our heliocentric radial velocities and the measurements from other authors , respectively . our measurements are in good agreement with those from literature , with a mean difference of 52@xmath860 km s@xmath0 , lesser than quoted errors . we provide in table 3 our new radial velocity measurements of galaxies in the fields of our selected apm clusters . for each cluster , column 1 lists galaxy identification , using names taken from the guide star catalog @xcite , apm ( maddox et al . 1990a , maddox et al . 1990b ) , apmbgc @xcite or the catalogue of principal galaxies ( paturel 1989 , pgc ) whenever available ; columns 2 and 3 , the equatorial coordinates ; column 4 , @xmath7 magnitude when available ; column 5 , the observed heliocentric radial velocity , v@xmath9 and the associated standard deviation . those galaxies marked with an asterisk in column 2 are not in cosmos survey . quoted coordinates are from our own identification . we have also searched for available redshifts in the area of apm clusters using the nasa / ipac extragalactic database in order to improve our @xmath1 estimates . we have identified 52 galaxies from the las campanas redshift survey @xcite within 0.75h@xmath0 mpc in projection in the fields of the clusters apmcc 160 , apmcc 173 , apmcc 352 , apmcc 746 , apmcc 042 and apm 221539.0 - 390817 . based on the rostat routine ( see beers et al . 1990 ) we have used robust mean and scale estimators . we have applied relativistic corrections and we have taken into account velocity errors . considering the typical number of redshift confirmed cluster members ( usually @xmath10 20 ) we have considered the _ trimean _ estimator for the mean velocity and the _ gapper _ for the velocity dispersion . errors are based on the statistical _ jacknife_. when possible , we have analyzed the velocity and the projected distributions in order to detect subclustering . in the cluster apmcc 746 we find a substructure separated from the main cluster in both radial velocity and projected coordinates . this structure was previously identify as the group of galaxies am 2159 - 224 ( arp and madore , 1987 ) . we obtained a mean radial velocity for this group @xmath11 km / s , with a difference of 476 km / s with respect to the main cluster . thus , mean radial velocity and @xmath1 of cluster apmcc 746 were computed after removing this structure . we have not computed velocity dispersions for several clusters in our sample . apmcc 107 has several substructures and more redshifts are needed to derive an accurate velocity dispersion . the clusters : apm 032010.5 - 454456 , apmcc 604 and apmcc 864 have few redshift measurement to estimates the velocity dispersion . finally , we have computed new velocity dispersion estimates for 13 clusters . in 11 clusters , the estimates rely on our new radial velocity measurements , and in 2 of them on the las campanas redshift survey ( schectman et al . 1996 ) . in table 4 we list cluster identification ; our new estimates of mean cluster redshift and velocity dispersions ; and the number of objects used in these measurements . the mean redshifts , given in this table , provide a more confident source of apm cluster redshifts given a larger number of members . there is a general good agreement between the cluster mean redshifts and the estimates quoted in ebeling & maddox ( 1995 ) . redshift uncertainties are smaller than 0.001 and are not quoted in the table . we also present velocity dispersions for four apm clusters in common with fadda et al . , the largest survey for determination of cluster velocity dispersions . table 5 shows our results for these clusters listing cluster identifications , our new estimate for the cluster redshift , our velocity dispersion estimates and those from fadda et al . the mean difference between our results and fadda et al . is -63@xmath850 showing a good agreement in spite of the small number of member galaxies in our analysis . we have added to our new velocity dispersion determinations , estimates taken from the literature ( mazure et al . 1996 , fadda et al . 1996 , struble and rood 1991 , zabludoff et al . 1993 , and muriel et al . 1999 ) . we consider apm richness counts as defined in apm v and we analyze a sample of 48 apm clusters with reliable velocity dispersions . in order to compare the correlations of apm and abell richness counts with velocity dispersions we have added to the previous compilation of apm / abell clusters , those abell clusters within the same area and redshifts of the apm cluster survey that were not identified by the apm selection criteria . figure 1 shows the correlation between @xmath1 and @xmath3 . figure 1a corresponds to apm richness counts @xmath12 , with solid circles representing our new velocity dispersions and open circles those obtained from the literature . figure 1b and 1c correspond to abell richness count @xmath13 , where only richnnes class @xmath14 are considered in 1c . in figures 1b and 1c are also shown as crosses abell clusters in the same survey area and redshift range than the apm survey that did not fulfill the apm v cluster selection criteria . in these figures there is a clear tendency of these clusters to have systematically lower values of velocity dispersion compared to those clusters in the apm survey , suggesting that `` non - apm '' clusters have artificially larger abell richness counts . in figure 1a , b and c are also shown the corresponding least - squares power - law fits . the values of the best fitting parameters of the form @xmath15 for the correlations shown in this figure are : apm [email protected] , [email protected] ; abell [email protected] , [email protected] and abell ( @xmath16 ) [email protected] , b=2.471 @xmath80.180 . the corresponding rms scatter around these fits are 0.016 , 0.018 and 0.017 respectively . it can be appreciated a poor correlation between @xmath1 and richness counts irrespective of the different procedures indicating that this scatter is partially intrinsic to the clusters . this should be taken into account when deriving mass estimates and abundances from cluster richness ( bahcall and cen 1993 ) , which could introduce spurious biasing effects against low @xmath1 objects as discussed by mazure et al . the measurements of galaxy redshifts in the field of apm clusters contribute to our understanding of the dynamics of these systems and provide a deeper insight in the problem of cluster identification from projected data . the estimated velocity dispersions obtained from our analysis with typical number of galaxies @xmath17 are in good agreement with estimates derived from the literature as seen in table 5 . the new observations presented in this paper together with previous published data allows for a comparative analysis of the correlation between cluster velocity dispersion and richness defined by different selection algorithms . the correlation between abell cluster richness and velocity dispersions is very poor . automated cluster catalogs such as apm are free from subjective effects which may blur significantly the correlation between richness and @xmath1 . however , apm richness counts do not provide a significantly better correlation with @xmath1 , suggesting the presence of an intrinsic spread related to galaxy formation or evolution in clusters . therefore , the observed spread in the richness - @xmath1 correlations raise serious concerns on the use of richness in cluster mass determinations irrespectively of cluster selection criteria and richness definition . we observe a systematic trend to lower values of @xmath1 in the sample of abell clusters that did not satisfy apm cluster selection criteria . this effect may be related to the fact that these objects are subject to larger contamination by projection effects as has been previously determined ( sutherland 1988 , dalton 1992 , van haarlem et al . the authors are specially grateful to c. caretta who obtained some spectra for this project in 1996 and c. n. a. willmer for his help in reducing the data . the authors acknowledge use of the ccd and data acquisition system supported under u.s . national science foundation grant ast-90 - 15827 , to r. m. rich . this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration . this research was supported by grants from conicet , conicor , agencia nacional de promocin cientfica y tecnolgica , secretara de ciencia y tcnica de la universidad nacional de crdoba and fundacin antorchas , argentina . abell , g. o. 1958 , apjs , 3 , 211 abell , g. o. , corwin , h. g. , jr . & olowin , r. p. 1989 , apjs , 70 , 1 arp , h.c . and madore , b.f . a cataloge of southern peculiar galaxies and associations . cambridge university press . bahcall , n. a. ; cen , r. 1993 . beers , t. c. , flynn , k. & gebhardt , k. 1990 , aj , 100 , 32 collins , c. a. , guzzo , l. , nichol , r. c. & lumsden , s. l. 1995 , mnras , 274 , 1071 dalton g. 1992 . d.phil thesis . oxford university . dalton , g. b. , efstathiou , g. , maddox , s. j. & sutherland , w. j. 1994 , mnras , 269 , 151 di nella , h. , couch , w. j. , paturel , g. & parker , q. a. 1996 , mnras , 283 , 367 ebeling , h. & maddox , s. j. 1995 , mnras , 275 , 1155 eke v.r , cole s. , frenk c. 1996 . mnras , 282 , 263 . fadda , d. , girardi , m. , giuricin , g. , mardirossian , f. & mezzetti , m. 1996 , apj , 473 , 670 girardi , m. ; biviano , a. ; giuricin , g. ; mardirossian , f. ; mezzetti , m. 1993 . apj 404 , 38 heydon - dumbleton , n. h. , collins , c. a. & macgillivray , h. t. 1989 , mnras , 238 , 379 katgert p. , mazure a. , den hartog r. , adami c. , biviano a. , perea j. 1998 . astronomy & astrophysics supp . 129 , 399 . lasker , b. m. , sturch , c. r. , mclean , b. m. , russel , j. l. , jenker , h. & shara , m. 1990 , aj , 99 , 2019 loveday , j. 1996 , mnras , 278 , 1025 loveday , j. , peterson , b. a. , maddox , s. j. & efstathiou , g. 1996 , apjs , 107 , 201 lumsden , s. l. , nichol , r. c. , collins , c. a. & guzzo , l. 1992 , mnras 258 , 1 maddox , s. j. , sutherland , w. j. , efstathiou , g. & loveday , j. 1990a , mnras , 243 , 692 maddox , s. j. , efstathiou , g. & sutherland , w. j. 1990b , mnras , 246 , 433 mazure a. , katgert p. , den hartog r. , biviano a. , dubath p. , escalera e. , focardi p. , gerbal d. , giuricin g. , jones b. , le fevre o. , moles m. , perea j. , rhee g. 1996 . a & a , 310 , 31 . muriel h. et al . 1999 . in preparation . paturel , g. 1989 . catalog of principal galaxies ( pgc ) . lyon : base de donnees extragalactiques , observatoire de lyon , lc1980 . paturel , g. , vauglin , i. , andernach , h. , garnier , r. , marthinet , m. , petit , c. , di nella , h. , bottinelli , l. , gouguenheim , l. & durand , n. 1995 . information & on - line data in astronomy , eds . d. egret & m. a. albrecht , kluwer acad . publ . , p. 115 - 126 , astrophysics and space science library 203 . shectman , s. a. , landy , s. d. , oemler , a. , tucker , d. l. , lin , h. , kirshner , r. p. & schechter , p. l. 1996 , apj , 470 , 172 sutherlanid w. 1988 . mnras . 234 , 159 . tonry , j. l. & davis , m. 1979 , aj , 84 , 1511 van haarlem , m. p. , frenk , c. s. & white , d. m. 1997 , mnras , 287 , 817 zabludoff a. i. , geller m. j. , huchra j. p. , ramella m. 1993 . aj 106 , 1301 . | we present 83 new galaxy radial velocities in the field of 18 apm clusters with redshifts between 0.06 and 0.13 . the clusters have abell identifications and the galaxies were selected within 0.75 h@xmath0mpc in projection from their centers . we derive new cluster velocity dispersions for 13 clusters using our data and published radial velocities . we analyze correlations between cluster velocity dispersions and cluster richness counts as defined in abell and apm catalogs . the correlations show a statistically significant trend although with a large scatter suggesting that richness is a poor estimator of cluster mass irrespectively of cluster selection criteria and richness definition . we find systematically lower velocity dispersions in the sample of abell clusters that do not fulfill apm cluster selection criteria suggesting artificially higher abell richness counts due to contamination by projection effects in this subsample . galaxies : clustering galaxies : dynamics cosmology : observations cosmology : theory . |
astro-ph0703596 | feedback is an essential component of our understanding and modeling of the intergalactic medium and galaxy formation . this feedback falls broadly into two categories : radiative feedback and mechanical feedback . they both act to deposit energy into the intergalactic medium ( igm ) which in turn suppresses star formation . radiative feedback is dominated by ionizing photons and their capacity to reionize the universe , keeping it ionized until the present epoch . this ionization photoheats the igm and suppresses a crucial source of cooling : atomic line cooling . radiative feedback acts to suppress the formation of low - mass galaxies ( e.g. @xcite , hereafter dhrw ) since the gas is unable to cool and collapse into the dark matter halos to form stars . mechanical feedback results from a variety of sources , but up to @xmath0 the main source of this feedback is thought to be galactic outflows caused by many coeval type ii supernovae exploding during the starburst phase . population iii stars may also contribute significantly but early result indicate they will be sub - dominant @xcite . these outflows do not simply deposit energy into the igm but also deposit metals . these metals increase the gas cooling efficiency and also provide a convenient observational tracer of this feedback . @xcite find that most mechanical feedback is caused by low - mass galaxies , however , this is without the inclusion of radiative feedback . in this work we seek to investigate the degree to which radiative feedback can suppress the formation of low - mass galaxies that form in dark matter halos with virial temperatures @xmath1 ( below which atomic cooling is inefficient ) . hence we do not consider the contribution to our outflows of minihalos and stars which form with a @xmath2 cooling mechanism . we do not make specific predictions for the degree of suppression and so the extent of metal enrichment , rather we constrain the potential impact of this effect . we use analytic models for the expansion of galactic outflows described in @xcite ( hereafter pmg07 ) , which self - consistently include the impact of ram - pressure stripping of halos and metal enrichment . we make a simple parametrisation of the degree of photoionization suppression by choosing a step - like reionization and using a suppression criterion taken from dhrw . this paper is set out as follows . in [ criterion ] we describe our criterion for photoionization suppression . in [ model ] we summarize the model of galactic outflows used . the results from our simulations are set out in [ results ] . we discuss the implications of our results and conclude in [ discconc ] . our criterion for photoionization suppression can be expressed as follows : halos ionized before turnaround , with a mass below a certain threshold , fail to cool a ` sufficient ' quantity of gas in order to form a galaxy . this mass threshold corresponds to a particular halo circular velocity @xmath3 and a particular virial temperature @xmath4 . we specify this quantity of gas in two ways : 1 ) @xmath5 , where half the halo baryons or more cool , and 2 ) @xmath6 , where galaxy formation is only suppressed in halos where no gas cools . the former is an acceptable approximation for our monte carlo simulations and is used in our fiducial model . the latter is also considered in the interest of placing a lower limit on the suppression . . the squares are for an evolving uv background and the dashed line is a least - squares fit to these points . the crosses show the case were the uv background amplitude has a fixed value of @xmath7 and the dotted line is their fit . the dot - dashed line is the fit to the case where @xmath8 and the uv background evolves , given by the triangles . ] in figure [ vcirc ] we use the results from dhrw s figure 3 to derive a fit to the evolution of the critical circular velocity for a given collapse redshift , @xmath9 . we show their results for three cases : @xmath10 for an evolving uv background amplitude ( @xmath11 ) taken from @xcite , @xmath10 for a fixed amplitude @xmath7 , and @xmath12 for an evolving amplitude . all three have been fitted with the straight lines shown using the least - squares method . where an evolving uv background is used we find circular velocities , @xmath13 { \rm km\,s^{-1 } } , \label{eqv1/2}\ ] ] which corresponds to our fiducial model . we also consider modifications to this model using @xmath14 { \rm km\,s^{-1 } } \label{eqv0}\ ] ] and for a uv background with a fixed amplitude , @xmath15{\rm km\,s^{-1}}. \label{eqnoevol}\ ] ] these dependences are used in the following work to provide a criterion for photoionization suppression . these circular velocities can be related monotonically in a straightforward manner to a virial temperature , making the criterion simple to incorporate into our cooling time calculation ( note that for @xmath16 , @xmath17 ) . we require that the virial temperature is below the value derived for suppression to occur . dhrw argue that the choice of evolving @xmath18 constitutes an upper limit on the expected @xmath3 , but it is notable that the effect on mechanical feedback of switching from equation ( [ eqv1/2 ] ) to equation ( [ eqnoevol ] ) are almost indistinguishable in the results that follow . dhrw perform their simulations using a one - dimensional spherically symmetric hydrodynamics code based on that used by @xcite . they consider a halo which is crossed by an ionization front during collapse ; this occurs at @xmath19 in their simulations . we prefer to choose the crucial reionization redshift , which we call @xmath20 . we do this in our fiducial model by assuming that , so long as the halo itself is ionized before its turnaround redshift , @xmath21 , the precise redshift of reionization is unimportant . this is a reasonable approximation but will underestimate the degree of suppression at high redshift since equations ( [ eqv1/2])([eqnoevol ] ) are derived from dhrw and for their @xmath22 , @xmath23 and at these redshifts @xmath24 . as result we also show the other extreme case , allowing suppression when the @xmath25 . it should be noted that our choice of @xmath20 is not intended to be characteristic of reionization as a whole , but rather a good representation of when low - mass halos are ionized . we do not select one value for @xmath20 but rather use upper and lower values of @xmath26 and @xmath27 . the higher redshift value is chosen to correspond to the redshift of reionization derived from the 3-yr wmap data release in a step - like reionization scenario @xcite . @xmath27 constitutes a conservative lower limit on the significance of photoionization suppression based on the end of the reionization epoch which may have been detected in quasar absorption spectra ( e.g. @xcite ) . for a complete description of the model used see pmg07 . we will describe some of the main features of the code and those particularly significant for this work . the approach is a monte carlo simulation of a @xmath28 box , which constitutes a cosmological volume down to the end point of our simulations : @xmath29 . a @xmath30cdm cosmology consistent with @xcite is used and a gaussian random realization of structure is formed on a @xmath31 grid . the dark matter halos , their mass , @xmath32 , and their collapse redshifts , @xmath9 , are found . mergers are included although only in a non - dynamical manner . upon collapse the gas inside these halos virializes and begins to cool . we use mappings iiiralph / map.html ] @xcite to calculate the cooling time . when cooling is complete galaxies are formed with a star formation efficiency @xmath33 . type ii supernovae then inject energy into the igm , preferentially taking a path of least resistance out of large - scale structures with an opening angle , @xmath34 . in our fiducial model we use isotropic outflows but also consider an anisotropic case . the expansion of these outflows out of the gravitational potential well of the host halos is calculated using the thin shell approximation . we assume that the igm is ionized throughout the expansion of the outflows . this is an acceptable approximation since the epoch of outflow expansion is later than most ( if not all ) of reionization and so ( pre - turnaround ) halo suppression . we now have the modifications required to perform our simulations of mechanical feedback with a simple description of photoionization suppression of low - mass galaxy formation . we run our simulations to their end point of @xmath29 and compare the regions which have experienced galactic outflows with the underlying gas density field . as in pmg07 we describe this igm density field , @xmath35 , by producing a realization of gas structure using jeans filtering . we map the resultant gas density field to a lognormal probability distribution function to reproduce a degree of non - linear behavior @xcite . every point in the @xmath36 grid is compared with the outflow locations to determine if it is within the volume of an outflow , the gas density of that point is also noted . in figure [ enrichstats ] we see the results of this statistic . each panel shows the cumulative statistic ( @xmath37 ) of the number of grid points enriched at a given density @xmath38 , which gives the volume filling factor of enriched systems below this density . this is shown for the case were no suppression of gas infall is included and the cases where it begins at @xmath26 and @xmath39 . the second and third panels show hard upper and lower limits ( respectively ) on our suppression criterion and its impact . the first panel shows the fiducial case with a suppression criterion using equation ( [ eqv1/2 ] ) , @xmath40 and isotropic galactic outflows . this shows that photoionization feedback has a pronounced effect at all densities and may result in a @xmath41 reduction in the volume of the universe affected by galactic outflows . even in the conservative case of @xmath27 , a @xmath42 smaller volume is enriched . this result uses the condition that a galaxy can only be suppressed when its host halo has turned around after it has experienced reionization . if we require instead that suppression may occur even after turnaround and up until collapse , we obtain the results shown in the second panel . this certainly results in excessive suppression . the third panel shows the case where we use equation ( [ eqv0 ] ) to provide the circular velocity for which suppression occurs . this is rather conservative as suppression only occurs where no gas falls into the halo ; all other halos are unaffected . the case where @xmath27 is almost unaffected by this adjustment , while the degree of suppression in the @xmath26 case is reduced from @xmath41 to @xmath43 . we show an example of the impact of this suppression for anisotropic outflows in the last panel of figure [ enrichstats ] . this includes a run with an opening angle , @xmath44 for no suppression , @xmath27 and @xmath26 . also shown is the case of isotropic outflows and no suppression for comparison . this illustrates the difference in the nature of the two effects : anisotropic outflows have a strong impact on the degree of enrichment in low density regions ( see pmg07 ) while this suppression affects all densities equally . figure [ vffmass ] shows the breakdown of volume filling factor enriched by different halo masses for all the models shown in figure [ enrichstats ] . note that the sum of these histograms is not the total volume filling factor as some regions have been enriched more than once by galaxies of different mass . in all cases the dominant sources of mechanical feedback are galaxies in halos of mass @xmath45 . it is clear that low mass halos dominate the volume filling factor of metals , even when photoionization suppression is included . in all but two of the cases considered , the volume enriched peaks around @xmath46 and decreases monotonically with increasing mass . in the first of these two cases , @xmath6 and @xmath26 are used and the volume enriched rises for halos of mass @xmath47 . this is mainly because the lower circular velocity threshold allows such halos to escape photoionization suppression . in the second case , anisotropic outflows are used with no suppression resulting in a peak at around @xmath48 . this results from a combination of factors related to clustering but mainly : a ) a reduction in stripping since outflows take a path of least resistance away from other halos , and b ) a lower volume per outflow combined with less overlap in outflows . it is striking that suppression of gas infall in the @xmath27 case makes little change to the impact of halos of mass @xmath49 in all but the strongest suppression ( shown in the second panel ) . this is because , in a @xmath30cdm model , most halos in this mass range turn around early , before @xmath20 . this also explains why the third panel of figure [ enrichstats ] shows only a small change in the @xmath27 case compared to the first panel : the significant lowest mass halos are unaffected and so the results are insensitive to the @xmath50 threshold used . the @xmath26 case shows a significant suppression of galaxies in halos of mass @xmath49 , however , the impact of suppression on these halos is still small compared to the impact on higher mass halos and they continue to dominate the overall volume filling factor . our analysis of the influence of photoionization suppression of galaxy formation is based on a simple prescription taken from the findings of dhrw . we use an analytic description of galactic outflows in a monte carlo cosmological simulation ( pmg07 ) . in our fiducial model we have chosen to suppress the formation of galaxies in halos which allow the infall of half their baryons or less . this occurs only when the halo has experienced reionization before its turnaround redshift . these choices , as well as the use of a step - like reionization , are justified simplifications , but in each case we have also bounded the simplification with the lower - limiting case . in all our result we find that this form of radiative feedback significantly reduces the physical extent of enrichment . the largest unknown in our prescription for suppression is the reionization redshift . work must be done to determine what redshift satisfactorily characterizes when halos which dominate the enrichment of the igm are reionized . this is further complicated interdependence of reionization history and photoionization suppression ( e.g. @xcite ) . also the values taken for @xmath3 represent upper limits since self - shielding is not included ( see dhrw ) . it may be necessary produce models which describe both radiative transfer and galactic outflows in order to address this issue with any precision . we have shown that this suppression has a pronounced impact on the extent of galactic outflows , but one should note that changes in the star formation efficiency result in a similarly pronounced effect @xcite . we chose a value of @xmath51 which is widely accepted ( e.g. @xcite ) , but we find that doubling ( halving ) @xmath52 leads to @xmath53 larger ( @xmath54 smaller ) volume filling factor in all our simulations . this change in @xmath33 would of course modify the reionization history ( which would counter the impact of changes in @xmath33 ) but we have not considered this here . it should be noted that the non - dynamical nature of our models and the way they treat mergers means that we will tend to have more low - mass halos than one would expect . as figure [ vffmass ] shows , one may not simply argue that fewer low - mass halos would result in a weaker suppression signal . the least massive halos which have a significant impact on the igm by @xmath29 are less affected by this suppression as they are more likely to turn around before reionization . observationally the volume filling factor of the enriched igm is rather poorly constrained but it appears that the universe is @xmath55 enriched @xcite . if we assume that the star formation efficiency is not significantly higher than our chosen value , our results seem to rule out the strongest photoionization suppression in our models . metals have been observed in the igm at @xmath56 @xcite and our results are further indication that metal enrichment and reionization are no - longer two distinct fields but part of a growing field of _ reionization chemodynamics_. using our fiducial model , we find that photoionization suppression may result in a @xmath41 reduction of the fraction of the universe enriched at all densities in the igm . furthermore , we find that even using a variety of conservative modifications to the suppression , we still find a @xmath42 reduction in the enrichment of the igm . we also find that the least massive halos ( @xmath49 ) are almost unaffected by late reionization and even with our best reionization redshift we find that these halos are suppressed to a relatively low degree . despite this suppression , low - mass galaxies continue to dominate the metal enrichment of the universe by volume . further work is required to determine the precise degree of suppression and the largest unknown in our models is the local reionization history experienced by halos . also a focused study constraining the amount of star formation in halos of various masses which are irradiated at varying stages of collapse would significantly improve our analytic prescription of this effect . observationally , 30 m class telescopes are required to significantly improve constraints on the volume filling factor of metals . in the meantime , more studies must be performed investigating the nature and environment of enriched systems , while extending qso absorption studies to higher redshift in order to study the evolution of metallicity at the end of the reionization epoch . the authors would like to thank mark dijkstra for providing data from dhrw and for his comments on the manuscript . we are also grateful to ilian iliev for valuable discussions and daisuke kawata for the use of his mappings iii cooling rate table . all calculations were performed at the _ laboratoire dastrophysique numrique _ , universit laval . we thank the canada research chair program and nserc for support . | we show that radiative feedback due to reionization has a pronounced effect on the extent of mechanical feedback due to galactic outflows . the photoionization of the intergalactic medium ( igm ) suppresses low - mass galaxy formation by photoheating the gas and limiting atomic line cooling . the number of low - mass galaxies is central for the enrichment of the igm as these objects have the capacity to enrich a significant fraction ( by volume ) of the universe . we use a modified version of our galactic outflow model , combined with a simple criterion for suppression , to investigate the potential impact upon the igm . we find that this suppression strongly reduces the enrichment of the igm and is sensitive to the reionization history . we also investigate the contribution of halos of different masses with varying degrees of suppression . |
hep-ex0304033 | the experiment at the electron - proton collider hera at desy in hamburg , germany , is a fixed - target spectrometer with large angular acceptance . has been designed to study neutral @xmath0 mesons produced in proton - nucleus interactions . s current physics program aims at the measurement of the production of @xmath2 and @xmath3 bound states in different target materials . the target consists of eight wires in the halo of the hera proton beam . the wires can be independently moved transverse to the beam to adjust the average number of proton - nucleus interactions per bunch crossing . the detector is shown in fig . [ fig : detector ] . it consists of tracking devices and devices used for particle identification . the tracking devices comprise a vertex detector of double - sided silicon micro - strip detectors , and an inner and outer tracking system using micro - strip gaseous chambers with gas electron multiplier foils ( gem - msgcs ) in the inner acceptance region ( @xmath4 from the proton beam direction ) and honey - comb drift chambers in the outer acceptance region ( @xmath5 ) . particle identification is performed in the electromagnetic calorimeter ( ecal ) , the ring - imaging erenkov counter ( rich ) @xcite and the muon detector built of multi - wire proportional chambers . to achieve the large suppression of background events needed for @xmath2 and @xmath3 production measurements , a highly selective multi - level trigger system is used . the first level trigger ( flt ) , built from custom - made electronics , performs a track search in the tracking detectors behind the spectrometer magnet . it has to sustain interaction rates of up to @xmath6 . track candidates for the flt are provided by pretriggers in the muon detector and the ecal , based on hit coincidences in adjacent detector layers and hit clusters in the ecal . the detector and trigger are described in greater detail in @xcite and references therein . large hit multiplicities are mainly caused by a superposition of multiple interactions in a single bunch crossing of the hera proton beam . the number of simultaneous interactions follows a poisson distribution . the flt is based on a track search algorithm implemented in custom - made hardware which requires hits in four superlayers of the tracking system . large hit multiplicities lead to an increase of the number of possible hit combinations to form a track in the flt . as a result , the flt is sensitive to events with large hit multiplicities , see fig . [ fig : fltrate ] . since the flt is a modular message - driven system , the message load in its network increases with the hit multiplicity which may introduce dead - time in the system . therefore a mechanism to protect the flt from processing multi - interaction events is needed . at the same time , this mechanism should preserve a large efficiency for interesting physics signals , e.g. the decay @xmath7 . a suitable measure of the hit multiplicity in the detector is the number of photons generated by charged particles in the rich . a sketch of the rich detector can be found in fig . [ fig : veto_area](a ) . as shown in fig . [ fig : correlation](a ) , the number of rich photons is highly correlated with the number of hits in the tracking chambers used in the flt . even in the case when only a small part of the rich detector is covered , the number of rich photons in this part is highly correlated with the number of hits in the whole rich , see fig . [ fig : correlation](b ) . hence the veto functionality can already be established with partial coverage of the rich . photons emitted in parallel cones around the flight direction of a particle are reflected to the upper or lower focal plane by spherical and planar mirrors , where they form a ring . ( b ) focal planes of the rich detector : the photons are detected by multi - anode photomultipliers of two sizes . the dark areas are currently covered by the rich multiplicity veto system.__,scaledwidth=75.0% ] the rich detector is suited to host a multiplicity veto not only from the physics but also from the technological point of view . it has proven to be a very reliable , low - noise system . in addition , its interface to the data acquisition system ( daq ) , the front - end driver ( fed ) , is easily accessible to install the necessary additional electronics . the strategy of a multiplicity veto using the rich detector is to provide a fast sum of the number of photons in part of the rich and to generate a veto signal based on the comparison of this number of photons with an adjustable threshold . in order to stop the trigger chain even before the message - driven processing in the flt , the veto signal has to be distributed to the pretriggers . the photon signals detected by the photomultipliers of the rich detector are provided as digitized data at the feds . therefore the summation of hits is performed by digital electronics . the logic of the veto system is implemented in large complex programmable logic devices ( cpld ) @xcite to allow for rapid development of the logic and to keep the design flexible . the cplds used in the design are well - suited for cascaded summation . since the rich feds are distributed in 14 fed crates close to the detector , the veto system has to be a distributed modular system . the current implementation of the rich multiplicity veto covers two fed crates , see fig . [ fig : veto_area](b ) . the maximum allowed latency @xmath8 of the system is given by the conditional requirement that the pretrigger systems have to be stopped before transfering data to the flt . latency measurements show that the maximum allowed latency is given by the muon pretrigger . the veto signal has to arrive at the muon pretrigger within @xmath9 after the interaction at the target . the rich multiplicity veto is a new hardware component to be integrated into an existing detector . therefore care is taken not to introduce additional electronic noise into the detector front - end . the electronics boards that receive the data from the feds are plugged directly on the fed boards in order to keep signal paths short . in addition , the signal lines on all electronics boards are routed carefully . the data inside the multiplicity veto has to be transmitted over approximately @xmath10 from the detector front - end to the electronics trailer which is situated outside the experimental area . differential pecl logic is used for all flat cable connections to improve the noise immunity . various specialized test boards and internal test facilities are needed to allow for fast and controlled commissioning of the veto system . an overview of the rich multiplicity veto system is shown in fig . [ fig : vetosystem ] . the rich fed is distributed over 14 fed crates with up to eight fed daughter cards processing data from 256 photomultiplier channels each . the data of eight fed daughter cards are transmitted to eight base sum cards ( bsc ) , where they are summed . the sums of the eight bscs are transmitted to the fed sum card ( fsc ) , which calculates the subtotal of the hits in a single rich fed crate . this sum is transmitted via twisted - pair flat cables or an optical link to the veto board ( vb ) , which is situated in the electronics trailer . a modified i@xmath11c bus system is used for communication among the modules of the rich multiplicity veto system . the veto decision calculated from the sum of up to 14 fsc subtotals is distributed to the pretrigger via the veto distributor ( vdis ) @xcite . a veto signal from the ecal energy inhibit ( eei ) board can be combined with the signal from the rich multiplicity veto system . the eei is a veto system complementary to the rich multiplicity veto . it is based on the analog energy sum in the inner part of the ecal . in addition , the veto signal generated from a single fsc can be fed into the fast control system ( fcs ) mother card , which distributes triggers in the experiment . in this `` fast veto '' mode , the veto system can be used as a low - bias interaction trigger . for the data - taking period 2002/2003 , 15 bscs , 2 fscs , and the vb have been installed in the detector . a bus system for the rich multiplicity veto has to address up to @xmath12 boards and to transmit signals over distances of more than @xmath10 . the fast control system @xcite , the central bus system of the experiment , can not be extended to fulfill these requirements . the i@xmath11c bus standard provides an easy and widely used protocol to implement the internal communication of the rich multiplicity veto system . the original protocol is based on two bi - directional lines , one for data transmission and one for the transmission of clock signals . however , to use the i@xmath11c bus in the rich multiplicity veto system , some modifications have been made to the protocol . the i@xmath11c bus controller used in the rich multiplicity veto @xcite is operated in a special long - distance mode with four uni - directional lines . this mode allows to use long - distance drivers ( rs485 ) for the i@xmath11c lines . in order to ensure the correct position of the acknowledge signal after data transmission in the long - distance mode , a feedback loop has to be introduced to the data and clock lines , as shown in fig . [ fig : i2c_mod ] . c bus controller , as indicated by the arrows : the i@xmath11c bus controller needs a feedback of the data lines ( sda_in , sda_out ) and the clock lines ( scl_in , scl_out ) to ensure the correct position of the acknowledge signal after data transmission . the clock signals are only generated by the master controller , hence scl_in and scl_out can be connected on the slave controller side . the feedback on the signal lines is implemented as and gates @xcite.__,scaledwidth=75.0% ] the i@xmath11c master controller is situated on the vb . it is controlled via vme commands , while the controllers on the bscs and the fscs are operated as i@xmath11c slaves . finite state machines implemented in dedicated cplds on these boards are used to operate the i@xmath11c slave controllers . the bscs and the fscs are entirely controlled via the i@xmath11c bus . the bus system is used to access the command , status , and reference registers of the cplds on the bscs and fscs boards in order to initialize and monitor these boards . the bsc is a six - layer electronics board which is plugged directly on an fed daughter card . almost the complete logic of the board is implemented in two cplds . each of the cplds processes signals from 128 of the 256 detector channels provided by the fed daughter card . the summation logic of the cpld is shown in fig . [ fig : summation ] . the 128 channels are further divided into four 32-bit blocks . for every 32-bit block , a `` block - lut adder '' unit is implemented , see fig . [ fig : blocklut ] . eight look - up tables are used to count the number of hits in four bits and transform them into a three - bit number . each 32-bit block can be masked individually to account for problematic channels in the detector readout . the subtotals of the four 32-bit blocks are summed by an additional adder unit , and the subtotal of the second cpld is added , before the sum is transmitted to the fsc . in order to assign the veto signal generated by the rich multiplicity veto to a given event , the bunch crossing number ( bx ) of the current event is transmitted to the fsc together with the subtotal of the bsc . the bx is provided by the fcs system and transmitted to the bsc via the backplane of the fed crate . while for the internal logic of the bsc ttl is used , the logic level is transformed to differential pecl for data transmission . due to a limitation of number of lines on the flat cable , the least significant bit ( lsb ) of the sum is discarded before the data transmission occurs . the fsc , situated in an fed crate together with up to eight bscs , receives data from the bscs via flat cables . the summation logic is depicted in fig . [ fig : fsc ] . the subtotals of the bscs are added . to check the synchronization of the bscs , the bxs which are transmitted together with the subtotals are compared . in case of inconsistencies , an error code is generated . the result of the summation and the error code are transmitted to the vb . the subtotal of the fsc is compared with an adjustable threshold , and a `` fast veto '' signal is generated if the subtotal is equal to or larger than the threshold . the fast veto signal can be fed into the fcs mother card via a lemo cable to be used as an interaction trigger , sensitive to minimal activity in part of the rich detector . since the data transmission from the fsc to the vb takes place in a harsh hadronic environment , the fsc foresees data transmission via optical links in addition to conventional twisted - pair flat cables . in - situ tests show that using flat cables for the data transmission in the experimental area is feasible . moreover , in flat cable data transmission , no additional time is needed to serialize the data for the optical transmission , thus the latency of the system is smaller compared to optical transmission . therefore , transmission via flat cables has been chosen for the installation of the rich multiplicity veto system . the vb is a 6u electronics board designed in vme standard . it is situated in the electronics trailer . the subtotals of up to 14 fscs arrive at the input connectors of the vb via flat cables . the vb is designed to consist of a main board and a mezzanine board , each processing the data from seven fscs . in the current installation in , only the main board is used . the veto logic of the vb is shown in fig . [ fig : vetoflex ] . the sums of seven fscs and the final sum of the mezzanine board are written to input registers before they are transmitted to the veto unit . the veto unit calculates the final sum , and the veto signal is generated based on a comparison with two adjustable thresholds . hence , four different veto modi can be chosen , as depicted in fig . [ fig : vetomodi ] . the veto signal from the eei can combined with the internal veto signal by a logical or . the veto can also be generated from a different source : the logical or of the fast veto signals for the fscs , also combined with the eei veto , can be used instead of the final sum . the vme interface of the vb is used to control the entire rich multiplicity veto system , including the i@xmath11c bus master controller and all registers of the cplds of the vb and via the i@xmath11c bus of the cplds of the bscs and the fscs . the vb monitors the error codes generated by the fscs due to bx synchronization errors of the bscs . in addition , the bx synchronization of the fscs themselves and the number of vetos generated in the last 256 bx , both on the vb and on the eei , are monitored . this information is available in the status registers of a specialized monitoring cpld which can be read out via vme . to transmit the veto decision and the veto rate to the data stream , the vb provides an interface to the second level buffer ( slb ) , s event buffer made of a network of specialized digital signal processors . on the vb , a modified fed buffer is implemented . it contains the veto decision and the current veto mode , tagged with the flt bx number , which is provided by the fcs via the fcs backplane . if the fcs issues a trigger , the content of the fed buffer is transmitted to the slb and saved in the data stream . due to this feature , the efficiency of the rich multiplicity veto system can be determined easily , cf . section [ sec : efficiency ] . since the internal monitoring provides the number of vetos only for the last 256 bx , i.e. on a statistical basis , a better monitoring mechanism is needed to control the number of events rejected by the rich multiplicity veto system . thus the veto signal is transmitted to a vme scaler which counts the number of vetos in an adjustable time interval . the scaler is read out via vme , and the measured veto rate is written to the data stream . the commissioning of the rich multiplicity veto system comprises detailed tests of the hardware functionality in the laboratory and measurements of the latency of part of the system and the whole system . furthermore , the efficiency of the system is determined , and the influence on the trigger chain and daq and on physics signals is studied . the laboratory tests are based on a complex test setup using specialized test boards to generate the input and analyze the output of the individual boards so that the bit error level can be determined . the bsc is tested with a specialized board that emulates the timing and data of the fed and the fcs , the pretrigger fed simulator ( pfeds ) . this board allows to generate defined test input for the bsc . the test input is designed such that every channel is tested individually , i.e. without bits being set in neighboring channels , hence hardware defects can be located on the bsc . the output of the bsc is written to a fifo on the base sum test card ( bstc ) where it can be read out via vme and compared with the input . in the next step , the veto chain is extended by the fsc . with a special adapter , the bstc can also be used to test the output of the fsc . as for the bsc , every input channel is tested individually . by adding more bscs , the bx comparison and the summation on the fsc are tested . the fast veto signal is tested by programming a threshold on the fsc via the i@xmath11c bus and monitoring if the signal is generated correctly and assigned to the correct bx . for tests of the vb , the veto board test card ( vbtc ) has been designed . the vbtc uses pfeds data as an input and emulates the output of two fscs , including the fsc subtotals , the fast veto signals , the bxs and the fsc error codes . the timing of these signals can be shifted to emulate errors in the chain of the veto system . an eei emulator generates signals to test the insertion of the eei veto in the veto decision of the vb . for all four veto modi , a test of the correct generation of veto signals has been performed . the data transmission to the slbs is tested with an slb module , and the signal that triggers the data transmission to the slb is generated by the fcs system . in fig . [ fig : systemtest ] , a test setup for the entire chain of the rich multiplicity veto system is shown . the results of the laboratory tests are summarized in table [ tab : biterror ] . during the tests , no bit errors could be detected , therefore the error limits quoted in the table are given only by the test statistics . .__bit error measurements @xcite _ _ [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] using data taken during the commissioning phase from august to october 2002 , the influence of the rich multiplicity veto on physics signals in the detector is studied . the data sample includes approximately 3,500 candidates for the decay @xmath13 . the rich multiplicity veto system has been inactive during the data - taking , and cuts on the veto threshold are applied in the offline analysis . at a `` generic '' upper threshold of 300 hits in the area covered by the rich multiplicity veto system corresponding to approximately 2,500 hits in the entire rich the survival of mesons and a possible bias on the kinematics are studied . fitting the di - muon invariant mass spectrum for events with less than a given number of hits and for all events , the survival fraction of mesons is determined as a function of the rich veto threshold , see fig . [ fig : njpsi ] . for an upper threshold of 300 hits , the survival fraction is in the range of 97100% . the kinematics can be described by two independent parameters . in this analysis , the rapidity @xmath14 and the transverse momentum @xmath15 are chosen . the di - muon invariant mass spectrum is fitted in bins of @xmath14 and @xmath15 , and the result using only events with less than 300 hits is compared with the result using all events . the distributions are not corrected for detector acceptance and efficiency . [ fig : kinematics ] shows the resulting rapidity and transverse momentum distributions . within errors , no significant bias on the kinematics is observed . the influence of the rich multiplicity veto on the centrality of the proton - nucleus collision in accepted events is studied using a monte carlo simulation of 50,000 events each for carbon and tungsten targets . the simulation includes the process @xmath13 mixed with poisson - distributed inelastic background with a mean value of one interaction . in fig . [ fig : centrality ] , the number of expected hits in the area of the rich covered by the rich multiplicity veto is shown as a function of the impact parameter of the proton - nucleus collision . only a small fraction of the events is rejected ( carbon : @xmath16% , tungsten : @xmath17% ) , and the simulation shows no significant centrality bias . , mixed with inelastic interactions according to a poisson distribution with a mean value of 1 . the vertical bars indicate the cut of 300 hits.__,scaledwidth=75.0% ] within only 1.5 years , a programmable modular veto system for the rich has been designed , built and successfully commissioned . the system provides a fast sum of the number of photons seen in the rich which is used to reject events with large multiplicities . the system shows very low bit error rates and an efficiency close to 100% . while the trigger and daq timing is improved using the rich multiplicity veto system , more than 97% of the events survive the veto decision , and no significant bias on the kinematics is observed . | we present the design and commissioning of a new multiplicity veto for the detector , a fixed - target spectrometer originally designed to study the physics of @xmath0 mesons in proton - nucleus interactions . the trigger is a message - driven multi - level track trigger . the first level trigger ( flt ) consists of custom - made electronics , and the higher trigger levels are implemented as pc farms . the multiplicity veto has been designed to reject high - multiplicity events before they enter the trigger chain . a veto signal is generated based on the comparison of the number of photons in part of the ring - imaging erenkov counter ( rich ) with a programmable threshold . the rich multiplicity veto is a modular system . first the hits in 256 detector channels are summed by base sum cards ( bsc ) , then fed sum cards ( fsc ) sum the subtotals of up to eight bscs . finally the veto board ( vb ) takes the veto decision based on the sum of up to 14 fscs . the rich multiplicity veto has been successfully installed and commissioned in . the measured veto efficiency is @xmath1 , and the system is used in the routine data - taking of the experiment . * si-2003 - 1 * poster presented at the ieee nuclear science symposium 2002 , + norfolk , virginia , november 1214 , 2002 this work was supported by the german bundesministerium fr bildung und forschung ( bmbf ) under the contract number 5hb1pea/7 . |
cond-mat0406706 | divalent hexaborides have been at the focus of attention for the last couple of years because of their anomalous electronic and magnetic properties . divalent rare earth hexaborides , eub@xmath0 and ybb@xmath0 behave quite differently due to the half and full filled @xmath1 orbital of eu and yb respectively . ybb@xmath0 is nonmagnetic whereas eub@xmath0 orders ferromagnetically@xcite at 15.1 k accompanied by a large negative magneto resistance and a significant blue shift@xcite of the reflectivity plasma edge.@xcite a second phase transition occurs at 12.7 k with a broad peak in the specific heat or an anomaly in the resistivity.@xcite neutron diffraction experiment indicates that magnetization increases very sluggishly with decreasing temperature in the absence of magnetic field.@xcite the spectacular discovery of ferromagnetism in alkaline earth hexaborides , la - doped cab@xmath0 , cab@xmath0 , srb@xmath0 and ba - doped cab@xmath0 have aroused deep interest in these compounds.@xcite curie temperature of alkaline hexaborides is above 600 k , much higher than eub@xmath0 . the introduction of chemical pressure by substituting ca for eu in eub@xmath0 lowers ferromagnetic transition temperature to 5.5 k. the intriguing magnetic and transport properties of hexaborides arise from the complex electronic properties . spectroscopic measurements@xcite indicate that eub@xmath0 may be a narrow gap semiconductor , in unanimity with early@xcite band structure calculation . however the resistivity measurements revealed metallic behavior below 300 k. [ ] shubnikov - de haas , de haas - van alphen@xcite and reflectivity@xcite measurements suggest that eub@xmath0 is a semimetal with a very low carrier concentration whereas lab@xmath0 is a semimetal with a higher carrier concentration . model hamiltonian calculations@xcite claim that electronic properties of eub@xmath0 may be explained by considering the fact that it is a semimetal . the anomaly in electrical resistivity suggests that it is close to metal - insulator transition . however the recent optical experiments observe that there is a sizable increase in charge - carrier concentration and/or a reduction of the effective mass of the itinerant charge carriers as it is cooled through the ferromagnetic transition temperature . hall effect measurements indicate that with the increase in magnetic order , the effective carrier concentration increases significantly.@xcite angle - resolved photoemission and resonant inelastic x - ray scattering experiments reveal that eub@xmath0 is a semiconductor with a gap of 0.8 ev . [ ] magneto - optical kerr measurements suggest a lorentz - drude model in order to account for a large resonance in its kerr rotation spectrum.@xcite there is stress upon the importance of the interplay between the charge carriers and the localized - electron interband transitions . all these experiments imply that eub@xmath0 has a metallic or a semimetallic ground state . hence the ground state of eub@xmath0 is not only controversial but an open problem . first principle band structure calculations based on local density approximation ( lda ) yield semimetal with small overlap between the valence and conduction band at the x point of brillouin zone.@xcite again these results are within the limitations of density functional theory ( dft ) . the failure of lda in describing electronic structure of semiconductors is well known . lda is also proving to be inadequate for some @xmath4 and @xmath5 systems and grossly wrong for the strongly correlated systems like the transition metal and rare earth ( re ) compounds . thus corrections to lda such as self - interaction@xcite and inclusion of on - site coulomb interaction ( orbital dependent potential ) are required to obtain the exact electronic structure of correlated systems . the band structure calculation performed within weighted density and gw approximations@xcite has successfully produced a gap in cab@xmath0 . strong on - site coulomb interactions among the 4@xmath1 electrons in rare earth systems describe their optical properties satisfactorily.@xcite very recently lda + @xmath6 calculations@xcite have been performed on eub@xmath0 which concludes that its ground state is half metallic semimetal . al . discussed the origin of magnetism in terms of exchange interaction between conduction electrons and local 4@xmath1 magnetic moments . there have been as many advocates of the semiconducting nature of eu@xmath7b@xmath0 as of its semimetallic ground state . flapw calculations have been reported for eub@xmath0 without considering the strong correlations and optical properties of eub@xmath0 are not calculated.@xcite magneto - optical spectra provide useful information about interplay between electronic structure and the magnetization of systems . the optical and magneto - optical properties of hexaborides have not yet been studied from the band structure calculation . we have investigated systematically optical and magneto - optical properties of reb@xmath0 ( re = la , eu and yb ) . the main purpose of our present work is to observe the effects of @xmath8 occupation of re , where n=0 , 7 , 14 , on optical and magneto - optical spectra and to compare with the experimental results.@xcite linearized band structure calculations are fairly accurate within the limitations of various approximations used in bypassing the many - body problem . full potential ( fp ) self - consistent spin - polarized band structure calculations have been performed on rare earth hexaborides reb@xmath0 by the linear muffin - tin orbital method ( lmto)@xcite using the fp - lmto code developed by s. y. savrasov et . .. @xcite since la has empty 4@xmath1 shell , the calculations are performed within simple lsda ( local spin density approximation ) . the dft is modified in order to include the strong correlations among the @xmath1 electrons in eub@xmath0 and ybb@xmath0 . in the lda + @xmath6 method@xcite , the lda energy functional is modified by removing the lda @xmath9 interactions and adding the strong on - site coulomb interactions among the @xmath1 electrons . the main idea of the lda + @xmath6 method used in this calculation is that the lda gives a good approximation for the average coulomb energy of @xmath9 interactions e@xmath10 as a function of the total number of @xmath1 electrons . subtracting this average energy from the lda total - energy functional and adding orbital- and spin - dependent contributions yield the exact total energy within the mean field approximation . the detailed description of the method is given in ref . .[tab : table1]table contains @xmath11 , the lattice parameter , muffin - tin radius of re ion , @xmath12 , structural parameter @xmath13 , coulomb parameter @xmath6 and density of states at fermi level , @xmath14 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] the value of the parameter @xmath15 used in the present calculation is 9 ev for both the divalent hexaborides in order to place the occupied @xmath1 states at about 2 ev below fermi level , @xmath16 . [ ] the other slater integrals @xmath17 and @xmath18 for @xmath1 electrons have been used from the experimental paper by thole et . al.@xcite to calculate the matrices @xmath19 and @xmath20 . the skeletal structure of these cubic hexaborides may be viewed as a cscl type lattice with re ion occupying the cs sites and cl replaced by @xmath21 octahedral cages . octahedral cages of boron ions are linked together along the three cartesian directions . the structure is formally known as cab@xmath0 type crystal structure and has a space group @xmath22 . an internal parameter @xmath13 determines the ratio between inter and intra octahedron b - b distances . structural parameters @xmath13 and lattice parameter @xmath11 are given in table i. table i also provides the parameter @xmath6 and density of states at @xmath23 . in srb@xmath0 , a linear relationship between @xmath13 and energy gap is found . for @xmath24 , band gap assumes a positive value.@xcite . however we use @xmath13 = 0.202 , as reported@xcite for eub@xmath0 . the exchange - correlation potential in the lda was calculated with vosko - wilk - nussair parametrization . the basis consists of @xmath25 states of cation and boron : @xmath26 and @xmath27 , where @xmath28 refers to the principal quantum number . charge density , density of states and the momentum matrix elements were calculated on a grid of @xmath29 @xmath30 points in irreducible brillouin zone and the @xmath30 space integration was performed using the tetrahedron method . we have treated orbital momentum quantum number , @xmath31 as a parameter . eu ion is considered to be in its divalent state and calculations were performed with the @xmath32 configuration . the self - consistent full potential spin - polarized band structure of eub@xmath0 is shown in fig . 1 . . ] typical small overlap between the 5@xmath2 conduction band and the boron @xmath5 valence bands is seen at the x(100)-point . the lower hubbard 4@xmath1 band is situated in between 2 and 3 ev below the fermi level , @xmath23 . the upper hubbard band lies about 5.5 ev above @xmath23 . the bonding 2@xmath5 orbitals of boron mainly constitute the valence band near @xmath23 . the bottom of the conduction band also has some boron 2@xmath5 character . hence the bottom of the conduction band and the top of the valence band is formed from the hybridized eu 5@xmath2 and boron 2@xmath5 states . this picture is fairly consistent with the xps and bis results@xcite and previous flapw calculation@xcite . it was suggested by knes et . al . that a ferromagnetic gw calculation may result in a gap opening up in spin - up channel only however this picture is contrary to most experimental results . on comparison with band structure of lab@xmath0 , as given in fig . 2 , one finds that the boron 2@xmath5 bands lie much below @xmath23 . the fermi level has eu @xmath33 hybridized bands located on it . apparently , this proves that lab@xmath0 has much more free carriers than eub@xmath0 . the unoccupied 5@xmath2 band is at about 4 ev above @xmath23 , which is about 1 ev lower than that in eub@xmath0 . the 4@xmath1 band lies 2 ev above @xmath23 in lab@xmath0 . the band structure of ybb@xmath0 reveals a zero gap , with zero overlap at x - point . the 5@xmath2 states move further up in energy in the conduction band . all the 14 electrons in the 4@xmath1 state are occupied and the occupied 4@xmath1 band has a width of 2 ev . the position of the occupied 4@xmath1 band is 1 ev deeper than that obtained from experiments.@xcite the blue shift@xcite of the 5@xmath2 band is evident from the movement of the 5@xmath2 conduction band towards higher energy from lab@xmath0 to ybb@xmath0 . . ] . ] the basic difference between the divalent hexaborides and lab@xmath0 is that the overlap at the x - point is larger in lab@xmath0 and the overlap is between la @xmath34 hybridized and boron 2@xmath5 states . here it is to be kept in mind that the calculation for lab@xmath0 is performed within lsda . the lsda band structure is in agreement with previous @xcite band structure calculation . in the divalent hexaborides , there is small or no overlap between the eu ( or yb ) 5@xmath2 and boron 2@xmath5 states . band structure calculation in eub@xmath0 [ ] reveal that the electronic structure is sensitive to the dimensions of the boron octahedra . choosing a larger ( @xmath35 0.206 ) value of the internal parameter @xmath13 opens up a small band gap . it is apparent that even this large value is insufficient in producing the gap of about 0.8 ev . [ ] there is no available band structure calculation on ybb@xmath0 as far as we know . figure 4 depicts the angular - momentum decomposed density of states ( dos ) . the region near @xmath23 comprises of boron @xmath5 and eu @xmath2 states in eub@xmath0 . the fundamental electronic structure of ybb@xmath0 is very similar to that of eub@xmath0 since both the cations are divalent . the occupied @xmath1 state split into the 4@xmath36 and 4@xmath37 states in ybb@xmath0 . the former lies at about 3.5 ev and the latter at about 2 ev below @xmath23 . the boron @xmath5 states lie deeper in lab@xmath0 than in the divalent hexaborides . -projected density of states of reb@xmath0 ( re = la , eu , yb ) . ] the fermi level is predominantly occupied by the la 5@xmath2 and 4@xmath1 electrons . it has no partially filled @xmath1 orbital . however 5@xmath2 states are partially occupied , as is evident from fig . that the carrier concentration is very small in the divalent hexaborides is also evident from table i. the decreasing value of dos at @xmath23 from lab@xmath0 to ybb@xmath0 bears testimony to it . however one can not compare the two divalent hexaborides directly from this data . the position of the 4@xmath1 band is fairly consistent with the xps and bis results in the divalent hexaborides . as mentioned earlier , lab@xmath0 and ybb@xmath0 are nonmagnetic . the spin - polarized calculations yield zero total moment for both of them . eub@xmath0 has a total magnetic moment of 6.98 @xmath38 . orbital polarization is negligible for both the ions . major contribution to the total moment is from the spin polarization of the 4@xmath1 electrons . eu@xmath7 has @xmath39 configuration . it has completely filled 4@xmath1 spin - up states and completely empty spin - down states . hence the spin moment should approach 7 @xmath38 . orbital moment should be quenched for an @xmath39 configuration . our calculational results are consistent with the atomic analog for eu . the value of @xmath40 from neutron diffraction experiments@xcite is 7.3 @xmath41 0.5 @xmath38 . the large error bar comes mainly from uncertainty in the absorption . but the total moment from the present calculation is within that error bar . optical conductivity tensor has been calculated from the standard relations given by reim et . al .. @xcite for accuracy calculations have been performed upto 30 ev . the imaginary component of diagonal optical conductivity ( @xmath42 ) and the real component of off - diagonal conductivity ( @xmath43 ) have been calculated using the kramers - kronig transformation . a description of the formalism is given in ref . optical and magneto - optical spectra have been calculated using the lmto band structure and further , a lorentzian broadening of about 0.0068 ev has been used in order to obtain the best agreement with the experimental results in the divalent re hexaborides . and their corresponding experimental(ref . ) reflectivity spectra . ] reflectivity spectra for these compounds are shown in figure 5 . the inclusion of drude correction reproduces the experimental reflectivity spectrum@xcite of lab@xmath0 . an absorption at low energy occurs due to eu 5@xmath2 to eu 4@xmath1 transition . due to this transition , a small disagreement occurs at low energy . this can be removed if the 4@xmath1 states are pushed up by 1 ev . addition of a constant potential to the hamiltonian@xcite which acts only on the 4@xmath1 states of la has been successful in reproducing the reflectivity spectrum in la monochalcogenides . a large dip in reflectivity or the plasma edge is successfully reproduced near 2 ev . however for the divalent hexaborides , a very small value of plasma frequency in the drude correction is required to reach an agreement . the small drude correction required , howsoever small it may be , strengthens the claim that the divalent re hexaborides are semimetals with low carrier concentration . due to smaller number of free carriers , plasma edge effect occurs around 0.3 ev and 0.2 ev in eu and yb hexaborides respectively . and their corresponding experimental ( ref . ) counterpart . ] the calculated and experimental optical conductivity spectra are depicted in figure 6 . drude correction brings in greater agreement with experiment as far as the plasma minimum is concerned . it occurs at about 2 ev in lab@xmath0 . but the minima is hardly distinguishable for divalent hexaborides . the broadness of the minimum emphasizes their low carrier density . the first structure in eub@xmath0 at 2 ev is due to 4@xmath1 to 5@xmath2 transition . this small absorption is missing in the spectrum for lab@xmath0 and hence the claim in the last line is justified . this structure shifts very slightly to higher energy in ybb@xmath0 since the unoccupied 5@xmath2 states shift to higher energy in the conduction band . the numerous structures till 6 ev are due to transition from boron 2@xmath5 state to eu 5@xmath2 state . from fig . 4 , it is obvious that the largest peak in eub@xmath0 will occur at 7 ev and it will be due to transition from the boron 2@xmath5 main peak in valence band to the eu 5@xmath2 main peak . this peak shifts to lower energy in lab@xmath0 and to higher energy in ybb@xmath0 due to similar blue shift of the 5@xmath2 state in the conduction band . around 8 ev , 5@xmath2 to 4@xmath1 transition and 2@xmath5 to 5@xmath2 transition structures overlap . beyond 9 ev , the structures arise solely due to transitions from the boron 2@xmath5 states to the 5@xmath2 peaks of eu . . ] the electron energy loss spectrum , as given in figure 7 , supports the fact given above . the first peak at 0.2 ev for ybb@xmath0 and that at 0.3 ev for eub@xmath0 , are surely due to the plasmon of the conduction electrons . the first peak is found at 1.8 ev in lab@xmath0 . this reduction in the energy position is due to the fall in the carrier concentration in divalent hexaborides . magneto - optical kerr effect is a very complex phenomenon . here a very subtle interplay between spin - orbit coupling and spin polarization leads to mo signals . however , in most cases , as in semimetallic magnetic rare - earth compounds , giant signals are obtained due to the plasmon resonance . the most important prescription for obtaining large mo response is a large plasmon resonance followed by a strong interband transition . inspite of large so interaction and a fair plasma resonance , we fail to see any kind of mo response in ybb@xmath0 shown in the left panel of figure 8 , as expected for non - magnetic materials . this is also in agreement with experiment.@xcite the same happens for lab@xmath0 . this proves that magnetism plays a very crucial role in moke . eub@xmath0 , with a total moment of 7 @xmath38 , is totally spin polarized . the calculated spectrum , as given in figure 8 , shows a jump from @xmath44 to @xmath45 at 0.3 ev and followed by a small signal of about @xmath46 at 1.5 ev . the former is due to large plasma resonance and the latter is due to 4@xmath1 to so split 5@xmath2 band transition . on comparison with the experimental spectrum , the first signal finds agreement . the second one is slightly suppressed and occurs at 0.5 ev higher in energy . this degree of agreement implies that the drude correction plays a very important role . obviously this strengthens the fact that eub@xmath0 is semimetallic . moreover , magnetism plays a crucial role along with so coupling . magneto - optical@xcite response in undoped eu hexaboride has been found to be giant at high fields and low temperature . it has been pointed out by broderick et . that drude component is essential in reproducing the overall features of the experimental kerr rotation spectrum . the resonance at 0.3 ev is caused by the response of the itinerant charge carriers to magnetism while the kerr response at 1 ev is associated with the magneto - optical response of the 4@xmath1 - 5@xmath2 interband transitions . on doping eub@xmath0 with isoelectronic ca , the sharp onset of plasma edge is broadened and the related kerr resonance is wiped out . this can be due to the large damping of the itinerant charge carriers , which is in turn is due to disorder in the cation sublattice.@xcite the intensity of the structure at 1 ev also diminishes with ca doping since the contribution of the 4@xmath1 electrons of eu decreases . these experimental observations are , hence , consistent with the electronic structure calculation of eub@xmath0 , presented here . self - consistent spin - polarized band structure calculations are presented for lab@xmath0 , eub@xmath0 and ybb@xmath0 . they reveal the metallic nature of the first and the low carrier density nature of the divalent ones . small overlap at the x - point implies semimetallic nature of eub@xmath0 and ybb@xmath0 . this is in disagreement with the recent arpes measurements in eub@xmath0 . present calculations lead to reasonable agreement with optical conductivity , reflectivity and magneto - optical kerr spectrum . the successful reproduction of the moke spectrum in eub@xmath0 implies that magnetism , spin - orbit coupling and large plasma resonance are responsible for the large magneto - optical response in this system . the mo response at about 1.5 ev is due to 4@xmath1 to 5@xmath2 transition . the inclusion of strong on - site coulomb repulsion is absolutely essential for its reproduction . most importantly , drude - like nature at low energy is a very strong evidence for the semi - metallic nature of eub@xmath0 and this is strongly supported by the present calculations . | full potential spin - polarized self - consistent electronic structure calculations have been performed on lab@xmath0 , eub@xmath0 and ybb@xmath0 using linear muffin - tin orbital method . the electronic structure of eub@xmath0 shows a small overlap near the fermi level . this is in disagreement with the recent arpes study . the reflectivity spectrum shows a plasma resonance at about 0.3 ev in eub@xmath0 . absorption starts at about 1.5 ev and it is due to 4@xmath1 to 5@xmath2 transition . both these features are reflected in the magneto - optical kerr spectrum . at 0.3 ev , there is a rotation of + 8@xmath3 to -10@xmath3 and at 1.5 ev , a rotation of about 0.5@xmath3 occurs . the reasonable agreement with moke experiment implies that the inclusion of drude correction is absolutely essential for the treatment of eub@xmath0 . |
cond-mat0701175 | recently the successful preparation of monolayer graphene films @xcite has generated a lot of activity in the physics of two - dimensional ( 2d ) dirac fermions . the massless energy spectrum and the specific density of states of electrons and holes described by the dirac hamiltonian enabled to study experimentally the chiral tunnelling and klein paradox in graphene @xcite , and led to the discovery of the unconventional `` half - integer quantum hall effect '' @xcite . the presence of holes in graphene with 2d dirac - like spectrum was confirmed by measurements of de haas - van alphen and shubnikov - de haas ( sdh ) oscillations . @xcite these magnetic oscillations appear due to the interplay of the quantum landau levels with the fermi energy in the metal , and serve as a powerful technique to investigate the fermi surface and the spectrum of electron excitations . another technique which was successfully used to obtain information on the electron spectrum of 2d systems is based on the interaction of electrons with artificially created periodic potentials with periods in the submicrometer range . such electrical modulation of the 2d system was created by two interfering laser beams @xcite , or by depositing an array of parallel metallic strips on the layer surface @xcite , and led to the discovery of weiss oscillations in the magneto - resistance . these oscillations are a consequence of the commensurability of the electron cyclotron orbit radius at the fermi energy and the period of the above electrical modulation . they were found to be periodic in the inverse magnetic field like the sdh oscillations , but have a different period versus electron density dependence . the period for weiss oscillations varies with electron density ( @xmath0 ) as @xmath1 , whereas that of the sdh ones as @xmath0 . theoretical calculations of these oscillations were presented in refs . @xcite , and it was shown that weiss oscillations in the magneto - resistance for motion perpendicular to the oscillating potential can be understood as being a semiclassical effect.@xcite the klein paradox in graphene where dirac electrons can penetrate through potential barriers with a rather high probability shows that electric control of dirac electrons can not be realized . therefore , it is interesting to investigate the sensitivity of dirac electrons on the electrical modulation of the layer . thus , we subjected the system to a periodic potential that introduces a new length scale and a new energy scale into the problem . we found that such a periodic potential also leads to weiss oscillations in graphene which are even more pronounced than in typically 2d electron gases with a parabolic electron spectrum . the paper is organized as follows . in the next sec . all necessary expressions for the magneto - conductivity calculation are given , and in sec . iii the obtained results for graphene layer are compared with results for the standard 2d electron system . in sec . iv the asymptotic expression valid in the quasi - classical region is obtained . in sec . v some simple classical explanation of obtained results are presented , and in the last sec . the short conclusions are given . we consider the graphene layer within the single electron approximation where the low energy excitations are described by the two - dimensional ( 2d ) dirac - like hamiltonian @xcite @xmath2 here @xmath3 are the pauli matrices , and the vector potential @xmath4 describing the magnetic field @xmath5 perpendicular to the graphene layer is chosen in the landau gauge . the parameter @xmath6 characterizes the electron velocity which is usually about @xmath7 times smaller than the velocity of light . the total hamiltonian consists of two parts @xmath8 where the additional potential @xmath9 describes the static electrical modulation of our 2d system in the @xmath10 direction . the conductivity tensor @xmath11 within the one - electron approximation was evaluated in ref . we shall restrict ourselves to the diffusion contribution ( i. e. which is the dominant contribution ) which stems from the diagonal part of the density operator . following ref . @xcite it can be written as @xmath12 symbols @xmath13 characterize the dimensions of the layer , and @xmath14 is the inverse temperature . this diagonal part is caused by the influence of the electrical modulation on the electron drift in crossed electric and magnetic fields and is in order of magnitude larger than the other diagonal component @xmath15 which appears due to scattering on imperfections . symbol @xmath16 denotes the quantum numbers of the electron eigenstates , and the velocities @xmath17 can be calculated as derivatives of the energy eigenvalue over the corresponding electron momenta . the resistivity tensor is given in terms of the inverse conductivity tensor , namely , @xmath18 what in our case of small conductivity reduces to @xmath19 , and its @xmath20 component is actually proportional to the conductivity in the considered perpendicular direction . the energy eigenvalues are defined through the solution of the stationary schrdinger equation @xmath21 with total hamiltonian ( [ hamtot ] ) . we will follow ref . @xcite and assume that the electrical modulation is small enough and restrict to a lowest perturbation expansion in @xmath22 . for this purpose we have to solve the zero order schrdinger equation with the hamiltonian @xmath23 . due to the system homogeneity along @xmath24 axis we substitute the eigenfunction as @xmath25 and transform the zero order eigenvalue problem into the following two ordinary differential equation set for the wave function components : [ srsetmg ] @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the magnetic length . solution of these equations can be easily obtained making use of the analogy with the harmonic oscillator eigenvalue problem . it reads [ dwf ] @xmath28/l ) \\ \phi_n([x+x_0]/l ) \end{pmatrix},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath29 is expressed in the normalized hermitian polynomials , and @xmath30 indicates the localization of the electron in the @xmath10 direction . for the first order correction one has to add to the energy eigenvalue the diagonal matrix element of potential ( [ potmod ] ) calculated with the above eigenfunctions : @xmath31 where @xmath32 , @xmath33 , and @xmath34 is a laguerre polynomial . this energy correction makes the degenerate landau levels @xmath35-dependent , expands them into bands , what finally leads to non zero velocities : @xmath36\sin(kx_0 ) . \end{split}\ ] ] now substituting the velocities in eq . ( [ cond0 ] ) and specifying the summation over quantum numbers as @xmath37 we obtain the final expression for the diffusion contribution for the dc conductivity under the consideration @xmath38 where @xmath39 and the function @xmath40 ^ 2 } \left[l_n(u ) + l_{n-1}(u)\right]^2\ ] ] will be considered as a dimensionless conductivity . in order to simplify this expression we introduced the following exponential function @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the fermi energy . it is interesting to compare the obtained expression for dc conductivity with the same conductivity calculated in ref . @xcite for the case of a 2d electron system localized at the interface between two semiconductors and having a parabolic energy dependence on its momentum . comparing velocity expression ( [ veloc ] ) with the equivalent one in ref . @xcite ( see eq . ( 4 ) ) we notice that the diffusive conductivity for the system of dirac electrons differs from the one for the standard interface case by replacement of the laguerre polynomial @xmath34 by the average of two successive polynomials @xmath43/2 $ ] . and of course , two different expressions for the landau level energies ( eq . ( [ dwf1 ] ) for dirac electrons and @xmath44 for the parabolic electron spectrum case ) has to be used . these differences in the expressions , however , lead to essentially different results for the dimensionless conductivity as shown in fig . the results are shown as function of the inverse magnetic field for the temperature @xmath45k , electron density @xmath46@xmath47 , and the period of electric modulation @xmath48 nm . the dimensionless magnetic field @xmath49 is introduced using the characteristic magnetic field @xmath50 corresponding to the magnetic length equal to the modulation period @xmath51 , which in the above case is equal to @xmath52 t . we see that in graphene ( curve _ 1 _ ) the weiss oscillations are more pronounced as compared with the system of electrons with the standard parabolic energy spectrum ( curve _ 2 _ ) . furthermore , the weiss oscillations in graphene are much more robust with respect to temperature damping in the quasi - classical region of small magnetic fields . the physical reasons for these differences lay in different fermi velocities of dirac and standard electrons . in order to confirm the above statement we shall consider the asymptotic behavior of weiss oscillations in the quasi - classical region which according to refs . @xcite describes the main features of the above oscillations and which also allow for explicit analytical expressions . the asymptotic expression for the conductivity ( [ dcfphi ] ) is obtained following the approach of ref . @xcite for case of standard electrons . that approach is applicable when many landau levels are filled , and it is based on the following asymptotic expression for the laguerre polynomials : @xmath53 taking the continuum limit @xmath54 and having in mind that @xmath55 , we transform eq . ( [ dcfphi ] ) into the following integral : @xmath56 ^ 2\sqrt{n } } \\ & \times \cos^2\left(\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{\frac{u}{n}}\right ) \cos^2\left(2\sqrt{nu } - \frac{\pi}{4}\right ) \\ = & \frac{2a_0}{v_f\hbar b } \int_0^{\infty}\frac{f(e)de}{[f(e)+1]^2 } \cos^2\left(\frac{\pi v_f\hbar}{ea_0}\right ) \\ & \times \cos^2\left(\frac{2\pi a_0e}{v_fb\hbar } - \frac{\pi}{4}\right ) . \end{split}\ ] ] now assuming that the temperature is low ( @xmath57 ) and replacing @xmath58 we rewrite the above integral as @xmath59 where symbol @xmath60 stands for the dimensionless fermi momentum of the electron . note in eq . ( [ quasicl1 ] ) we replaced all energies @xmath61 by the fermi energy @xmath42 except that one which is included in the last cosine function , where the small energy correction can influence the damping of the weiss oscillations . the obtained expression for the dimensionless conductivity can be calculated using the standard integral @xmath62 and the result can be presented as @xmath63 \\ & + 2a\left(\frac{t}{t_d}\right ) \cos^2\left[2\pi\left(\frac{p}{b } - \frac{1}{8}\right)\right]\bigg\ } , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath64 and the symbol @xmath65 defined as @xmath66 ( @xmath67 is the boltzman constant ) gives the temperature scale for damping of the weiss oscillations . the validity of the asymptotic expression is seen in fig . [ fig2 ] where the weiss oscillations for the dirac electrons ( curve _ 1 _ ) are shown together with their asymptotic expression ( curve _ 2 _ ) for the same parameter values as in fig . [ fig1 ] in the region of strong magnetic fields where deviations of the asymptotic expression to the exact expression are largest . ) , _ 2 _ asymptotic expression ( [ result ] ) . ] we see that the coincidence of the exact result and its asymptotic expression is rather good everywhere except the region of very strong magnetic field where sdh oscillations become superimposed on top of the weiss oscillations . we compare now the obtained result for the conductivity for the dirac electron system with the similar asymptotic result for the system of electrons with the standard parabolic energy spectrum taken from ref . @xcite which can be presented as follows : @xmath68 \\ & + 2a\left(\frac{t}{t_p}\right ) \cos^2\left[2\pi\left(\frac{p}{b } - \frac{1}{8}\right)\right]\bigg\ } , \end{split}\ ] ] where the critical temperature reads @xmath69 having in mind that @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the velocity of the standard electron on the fermi surface , the critical temperature can be presented as @xmath72 for parameters used in fig . [ fig1 ] plot @xmath73 , @xmath74 , and @xmath75 . thus the asymptotic behavior of the dimensionless conductivity for dirac electrons ( [ result ] ) and standard electrons with parabolic energy spectrum ( [ dcndf ] ) differ mostly due to the very different critical temperatures . comparing eqs . ( [ crtemp ] ) and ( [ tp0 ] ) we see that @xmath76 or the ratio of critical temperatures for the standard and dirac electrons is equal to the ratio of the corresponding velocities on the fermi surface . it can be estimated as @xmath77 and for typical cases is less than unity . for instance , in the case of the parameters used in fig . [ fig1 ] it is @xmath78 what explains the different slope and damping of the weiss oscillations . the obtained results can be understood from a simple physical picture . in order to estimate the oscillation period we write down the momentum of the electrons on the fermi surface : @xmath79 which is identical in both cases . then it follows that the radius of electron orbit in the magnetic field is @xmath80 the physical reason for the appearance of the weiss oscillations is the commensurability of the electron orbit radius with the period of the electrical modulation , consequently , the argument of the cosine function has to be proportional to @xmath81 which we can see in both expressions ( [ result ] ) and ( [ ftr ] ) . the damping factor of the oscillations can be estimated as follows . due to the finite temperature there are electron orbits with various radia . the effective damping can be estimated as the ratio of the above broadening of the orbit to the period of the modulation : @xmath82 in the case of standard electrons ( when @xmath83 ) it reads @xmath84 in agreement with the definition of the critical temperature for standard electron ( [ tp ] ) . in the case of dirac electrons ( when @xmath85 ) the above damping parameter can be estimated as @xmath86 what coincides with the obtained earlier result for the critical temperature up to the same constant @xmath87 . now dividing eq . ( [ broadstd ] ) by eq . ( [ broaddir ] ) we obtain the same critical temperature ratio dependence on the ratio of the fermi velocities ( [ tratio ] ) what confirms the quasi - classical nature of weiss oscillations . in conclusion , we studied the weiss oscillations in electrically modulated single layer of graphene . it was shown that the static conductivity oscillations are periodic in @xmath88 with period varying with electron density as @xmath1 like in the 2d electron system with standard parabolic energy spectrum . due to the larger fermi velocity the conductivity oscillations of the dirac electron system are more pronounced and less damped as compared with the 2d system of electrons with parabolic energy spectrum in case of analogous parameters . the found dirac electron sensitivity to the electric perturbation does not contradicts the klein paradox , because in contrary to electron tunneling through barriers where both the electron and the hole nature of the excitation plays a role , only the electrons at the fermi energy are responsible for the conductivity and for the studied weiss oscillations . thus , their behavior in the electric field is not overshadowed by the admixture of the hole states . 99 k. s. novoselov , a. k. geim , s. v. morozov , d. jiang , y. zhang , s. v. dubonos , i. v. grigorieva , a. a. firsov , science , * 306 * , 666 ( 2004 ) . y. zhang , y. w. tan , h. stormer , and p. kim , nature , * 438 * , 201 ( 2005 ) . c. berger , z. song , x. li , x. wu , n. brown , c. naud , d. mayou , t. li , j. hass , a. n. marchenkov , e. h. conrad , p. n. first , w. a. de heer , science * 312 * , 1191 ( 2006 ) . m. i. katsnelson , k. s. novoselov and a. k. geim , nature phys . * 2 * , 620 ( 2006 ) . k. s. novoselov , a. k. geim , s. v. morozov , d. jiang , m. i. katsnelson , i. v. grigorieva , s. v. dubonos , and a. a. firsov , nature * 438 * , 197 ( 2005 ) . v. p. gusynin and s. g. sharapov , phys . rev . lett . * 95 * , 146801 - 1 ( 2005 ) . s. g. sharapov , v. p. gusynin , and h. beck , phys . rev . b * 69 * , 075104 ( 2004 ) . d. weiss , k. von klitzing , k. ploog , and g. weinmann , europhys . * 8 * , 179 ( 1989 ) , and in _ high magnetic fields in semiconductor physics ii _ , edited by g. landwehr ( springer - verlag , wurtzburg 1989 ) , p. 357 . r. w. winkler , j. p. kotthaus , and k. ploog , phys . lett . * 62 * , 1177 ( 1989 ) , r. r. gerhardts , d. weiss , and k. von klitzing , phys . 62 * , 1173 ( 1989 ) , p. vasilopoulos and f. m. peeters , phys . rev . lett . * 63 * , 2120 ( 1989 ) . c. w. j. beenakker , phys . lett . * 62 * , 2020 ( 1989 ) . f. m. peeters and p. vasilopoulos , phys . b * 46 * , 4667 ( 1992 ) . r. abe , _ statistical mechanics _ ( university of tokyo press , tokyo , 1975 ) , p. 28 . m. charbonneau and k , m. van vliet , j. math . * 23 * , 318 ( 1982 ) . | the magneto - conductivity of a single graphene layer where the electrons are described by the dirac hamiltonian weakly modulated by a periodic potential is calculated . it is shown that weiss oscillations periodic in the inverse magnetic field appear , that are more pronounced and less damped with the increment of temperature as compared with the same oscillations in a typical two - dimensional electron system with a standard parabolic energy spectrum . |
cond-mat0005180 | the discovery of persistence has recently generated considerable interest in understanding the statistics of first passage problems in spatially extended nonequilibrium systems , both theoretically and experimentally . the definition of persistence is as follows . let @xmath11 be a stochastic variable fluctuating in space and time according to some dynamics . the persistence probability is simply the probability @xmath12 that at a fixed point in space , the quantity @xmath13 $ ] does not change up to time @xmath7 . in many systems of physical interest a power law decay , @xmath14 , is observed , where @xmath15 is the persistence exponent and is , in general , nontrivial . the nontriviality of @xmath15 emerges as a consequence of the coupling of the field @xmath11 to its neighbours , since such coupling implies that the stochastic process at a fixed point in space and time is non - markovian . persistence phenomena have been widely studied in recent years @xcite . theoretical and computational studies include spin systems in one @xcite and higher @xcite dimensions , diffusion fields @xcite , fluctuating interfaces @xcite , phase - ordering dynamics @xcite , and reaction - diffusion systems @xcite . experimental studies include the coarsening dynamics of breath figures @xcite , soap froths @xcite , and twisted nematic liquid crystals @xcite . persistence in nonequilibrium critical phenomena has also been studied in the context of the global order parameter , @xmath16 , ( e.g. the total magnetization of a ferromagnet ) , regarded as a stochastic process @xcite . in the present work we consider spatially extended systems with a nonequilibrium field @xmath11 , which takes discrete values , at each lattice site @xmath17 . the field then evolves in time @xmath7 through interactions with its neighbours . the persistence probability at time @xmath7 is defined as the fraction of sites in which the stochastic field @xmath11 did not change its value in the time interval @xmath18 $ ] . the physical interpretation of @xmath11 could be for , for example , the coarsening spin field in the ising model after being quenched to low temperature from an initial high temperature , the sign of a diffusion field starting from a random initial configuration or the sign of the height , relative to the mean height , of a fluctuating interface . as the stochastic field evolves in time , such systems develop regions of persistent and nonpersistent sites . since the number of persistent sites decays with time according to @xmath6 , the persistent clusters shrink in size and number with a corresponding growth in the size of the nonpersistent regions . recently , manoj and ray ( mr ) @xcite have studied such spatially extended systems in one dimension ( 1d ) within the context of the @xmath19 reaction diffusion model , which is equivalent to the 1d ising model . they found that the length scale which characterises the interval sizes between persistent clusters _ apparently _ has a different time - dependence from the length scale characterising the walker separations ( or spin correlations , in the ising representation ) , and futhermore seems to depend on the initial walker density . if true , this result would be surprising . naively , one would expect the initial walker density to be irrelevant to the asymptotic dynamics , and the coarsening length scale , set by the mean distance between walkers , to be the relevant length scale for all spatial correlations . we shall show that the former expectation is correct , but the latter , in general , is not . in this paper we generalise , and reinterpret , this study in the context of the @xmath2-state potts model , which has @xmath2 distinct but equivalent ordered phases . the @xmath19 model corresponds to the @xmath20 potts model , i.e. the ising model , with the walkers identified as the domain walls between up and down ising spins . in the @xmath2-state potts model the random walkers represent domain walls between potts states . at each time step , every walker hops randomly left or right . persistent potts sites are those at which the potts state has never changed , i.e. sites which have never been crossed by a walker . if two walkers occupy the same site they either _ coalesce _ , with probability @xmath21 , or _ , with probability @xmath22 , these numbers being the probabilities that the states on the farther sides of the walkers are the same ( annihilation ) or different ( coalescence ) . the persistence probability ( the fraction of sites that have never been jumped over by a walker ) decays as a power of time , with a @xmath2-dependent exponent , @xmath23 . among the questions which emerge naturally in such a study are ( i ) what is the dominant length scale in the problem , as far as the persistent structures are concerned ? ( ii ) what is the nature of the spatial distribution of the persistent sites ? ( iii ) what is the average size of a persistent cluster ? an important point to make at the outset concerns the different length scales associated with the walkers and with the persistent sites . the walker density decays as @xmath24 for any @xmath2 , so the mean distance between walkers grows as @xmath25 . the density of persistent sites decays as @xmath26 , so the mean distance between these sites grows as @xmath27 . this simple observation immediately suggests that the spatial structure of the persistent sites for @xmath8 , where @xmath28 is the larger length scale , will be very different from when @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the larger length . this is precisely what we find : the characteristic length scale , @xmath31 , controlling the distribution of the _ intervals _ between clusters of persistent sites , is given by @xmath32 . for the ising case studied earlier @xcite , one has @xcite @xmath33 , which is ` close ' to @xmath34 . we believe the proximity of these two exponents is responsible for the apparently non - universal behavior in the ising system reported in mr . derrida et al . @xcite have obtained an exact expression for @xmath15 for 1d potts models with arbitrary @xmath2 : @xmath35 ^ 2\ . \label{theta(q)}\ ] ] the value of @xmath2 corresponding to @xmath36 is @xmath37 = 2.70528\ldots$ ] , so @xmath38 for all integer @xmath39 . note that the probabilistic algorithm for implementing the potts model through the annihilation or coalescence of random walkers ( domain walls ) allows @xmath2 to be a real number , @xmath40 , while an equivalent ising spin representation ( see section iv ) of the potts persistence problem even allows @xmath41 ! by this means means we can explore a range of @xmath15 above and below 1/2 . our main result is that the scale length controlling the distribution of interval sizes between persistent clusters is given by @xmath10 when @xmath29 , but by @xmath9 when @xmath8 . we find no evidence for any dependence of the asymptotic scaling distribution on the initial walker density ( other than through nonuniversal amplitudes ) . this paper is organised in the following manner . in section ii we outline a scaling phenomenology within which the above questions can be addressed . in section iii we give exact results for the @xmath42 potts model . finally , in section iv , we present extensive numerical simulations for the @xmath2-state potts model which confirm our predictions based on general scaling arguments and the exact large-@xmath2 results . section v concludes with a discussion and summary of the results . the basic scaling phenomenology was introduced by manoj and ray , although we will adopt a slightly different notation . we are interested in the distribution of the sizes of the _ intervals _ between persistent sites . we define an interval size , @xmath1 , as the number of _ non - persistent _ sites between two consecutive persistent sites . if the interval size is zero , the sites belong to the same _ cluster _ of persistent sites , and we henceforth consider only intervals of non - zero size . we define @xmath0 to be the number of intervals ( per site ) of size @xmath1 at time @xmath7 a natural dynamical scaling assumption is @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the ` characteristic ' length scale at time @xmath7 . ( a dynamical exponent @xmath45 is conventionally defined via @xmath46 , rather than @xmath47 . here we are following the notation of mr ) . the rationale for the scaling form ( [ scaling ] ) is as follows . the number of non - persistent sites ( per site ) is given by @xmath48 but since the number of persistent sites ( per site ) , @xmath12 , decays to zero as @xmath6 , and @xmath49 , it follows that @xmath50 for @xmath51 . converting the sum ( [ np ] ) to an integral , with lower limit zero ( valid as @xmath52 provided the integral converges ) , we see that the prefactor @xmath53 in ( [ scaling ] ) is precisely what is needed to satisfy the required condition @xmath54 for @xmath51 . consider next the number , @xmath55 , of persistent clusters per site . since the number of clusters is equal to the number of intervals , @xmath56 is given by @xmath57 converting the sum to an integral ( with lower limit zero ) , using ( [ scaling ] ) and assuming the integral converges , gives @xmath58 . thus the mean distance between persistent clusters , i.e. the mean interval size , increases as @xmath47 . is this reasonable ? let us recall that there are two length scales in the system , @xmath59 , the mean distance between walkers , and @xmath60 , the mean distance between persistent sites . to make further progress we make the following two assumptions , both of which are confirmed by our numerical studies , by exact results for @xmath61 , and by heuristic arguments to be expounded below : ( i ) the mean cluster size tends to a constant for @xmath51 , and ( ii ) the length scale @xmath62 that controls the interval size distribution is the _ larger _ of @xmath30 and @xmath28 , i.e. @xmath63 . from assumption ( i ) we deduce that @xmath64 , i.e. @xmath65 , which is consistent with assumption ( ii ) provided @xmath8 . what if @xmath29 ? then we still require @xmath64 , but now @xmath66 , so the result @xmath58 , derived from ( [ cl ] ) breaks down . going back to ( [ cl ] ) , we infer that this breakdown requires that the conversion of the sum to an integral be invalid the sum must have its dominant contribution from @xmath1 of order unity , rather than @xmath1 of order @xmath47 . this in turn requires that the scaling function @xmath67 in ( [ scaling ] ) have a singular small-@xmath17 limit of the form @xcite @xmath68 with @xmath69 . using this form in ( [ scaling ] ) , with @xmath66 , and inserting the result into ( [ cl ] ) , gives @xmath70 . comparing this with @xmath64 fixes the value of @xmath71 : @xmath72 we first present a heuristic argument for the result @xmath73 . consider first the case @xmath8 . in this regime , the distance between clusters is much greater that the distance between walkers , i.e. there are , on average , many ( @xmath74 ) random walkers between each consecutive pair of persistent clusters , as illustrated in figure [ fig0 ] . however , walkers separated by distances large compared to @xmath10 are essentially uncorrelated , because any correlations are mediated by the random walkers , and correlations between walkers decay on the length scale @xmath10 . therefore one expects the intervals between clusters , measured on the scale @xmath9 , to be independent random variables , and the interval size distribution to scale with this length . this argument also suggests that the locations of the clusters as a function of position on the lattice are described by a poisson process , i.e. the interval size distribution is an exponential , @xmath75 , with @xmath76 , for @xmath8 . these expectations are borne out by our numerical studies . for @xmath29 , the opposite is true : there are many clusters between each pair of walkers ( see the @xmath77 snapshot in figure [ fig0 ] ) . the largest length scale is set by the walker spacing , @xmath59 , and the interval size distribution will scale with this length . on smaller scales , there will be residual structure in the cluster distribution left from an earlier epoch when the number of walkers was larger . indeed , on these smaller scales the persistent sites form a fractal set @xcite . consider two sites separated by a distance @xmath78 . the probability , @xmath79 , that _ both _ are persistent has the scaling form , @xmath80 where @xmath81 for @xmath82 , since for @xmath83 the sites are uncorrelated . the residual structure remaining on scales @xmath84 , however , means that if the first site is persistent , which occurs with probability of order @xmath26 , the probability that the second one is also persistent depends only on @xmath78 . this implies @xmath85 for @xmath86 . the number of persistent sites within a distance @xmath87 of a given persistent site can therefore be estimated as @xmath88 , where @xmath89 is the fractal dimension of the persistent set . clearly this result only makes sense for @xmath29 , since @xmath90 can not be negative . this suggests @xmath91 for @xmath92 , corresponding to point - like objects , i.e. isolated finite clusters . for @xmath61 , for example , where @xmath93 , we find that there is typically one cluster of persistent sites , with a fixed mean size , per scale length @xmath94 . we now present a heuristic argument in support of our claim that the mean cluster size , @xmath95 , approaches a constant as @xmath51 for all values of @xmath15 . the initial steps of the argument follow the approach of mr . the total number of clusters per site can be written as @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the fraction of walker sites which have never been visited by a walker , i.e. the persistence probability for walker sites . such sites form ` spacers ' between each pair of persistent potts states in a cluster , there being exactly one more persistent potts site than persistent walker site in each cluster . the mean cluster size is @xmath98^{-1}\ . \label{lav}\ ] ] we expect , on universality grounds , that the exponents describing the decay of @xmath12 and @xmath97 should be the same ( i.e. @xmath15 ) , but the ( nonuniversal ) amplitudes will be different , i.e. @xmath99 , while @xmath100 , with @xmath101 . inserting these forms in ( [ lav ] ) gives the limiting value of the mean cluster size as @xmath102 . this number is nonuniversal and is determined by the initial distribution of cluster sizes . many of the general features of the dynamics for @xmath104 are exemplified by the @xmath105 limit , for which the walker dynamics reduces to @xmath106 , i.e. the walkers always aggregate on contact . at @xmath107 all sites are persistent . the random walkers initially present divide the sites into clusters of persistent sites . clearly no cluster can increase in size . consider a cluster of initial size @xmath108 . we first calculate the probability density , @xmath109 , that the cluster survives to time @xmath7 and has size @xmath110 . the key point is that , for @xmath106 dynamics , we need only consider the two walkers on either side of the initial cluster , since subsequent coalescence processes do not affect the random walk dynamics of these two walkers . the cluster and the two walkers can therefore be treated in isolation . for simplicity we begin by treating the continuum limit in which the walkers are regarded as continuous - time random walkers on a continuous space . this should be correct in the limit @xmath111 , an assertion we can subsequently test . let the ends of the initial cluster ( and the two walkers ) be located at @xmath112 and @xmath113 . each walker obeys an equation of the form @xmath114 , where @xmath115 is a gaussian white noise with mean zero and correlator @xmath116 . we first write down the probability distribution @xmath117 of the rightmost excursion , @xmath118 , up to time @xmath7 , of the left walker . an elementary calculation gives @xmath119 for the cluster to survive , we require @xmath120 , so in the limit @xmath121 the exponential factor in ( [ p_r ] ) can be dropped . the probability distribution , @xmath122 , of the leftmost excursion of the right walker ( from its initial position ) is given by a similar expression . clearly @xmath123 is the residual size of the cluster at time @xmath7 , where @xmath124 means the cluster has disappeared . the probability density @xmath109 that the cluster has survived and has size @xmath110 is therefore given , for @xmath121 , by @xmath125 the probability , @xmath126 , that the cluster survives till time @xmath7 is given by @xmath127 immediately we see that the mean interval between surviving clusters grows as @xmath7 ( @xmath128 , since @xmath129 ) , which is much larger than the mean interval between walkers , which grows as @xmath10 . the mean length of surviving clusters , of given initial size @xmath108 , in the @xmath51 limit is @xmath130 if the initial clusters have a distribution of sizes , a straightforward calculation gives @xmath131 , where @xmath132 indicates an average over this distribution , while the fraction of clusters which survive is @xmath133 . the above calculations demonstrate that the mean cluster size approaches a constant at late times , and that the scale length for the sizes of the intervals between clusters grows as @xmath7 , and not as the naive scaling length @xmath10 associated with the underlying domain wall coarsening . in fact we can calculate the interval size distribution , @xmath0 , explicitly for this model . first recall that the surviving clusters are separated , at late times , by many ( @xmath134 ) walkers . the fate of a given cluster depends only on the nearest walker on either side . the motion of these walkers is uncorrelated with that of the walkers bordering other clusters , because the correlation length for walkers grows only as @xmath10 . therefore we can assume , in the scaling limit @xmath135 , @xmath51 , with @xmath136 fixed , that clusters survive _ independently _ with probability @xmath137 ( where we have specialized to initial clusters of fixed size @xmath108 ) . the probability distribution of the interval size @xmath1 between neighboring clusters is therefore exponential , with mean @xmath138 , while @xmath139 , which has the scaling form ( [ scaling ] ) with @xmath140 . this exponential form is in excellent agreement with simulation data presented in section iv . since the initial clusters used in the @xmath61 simulations are quite small ( 2 or 4 ) , the continuum limit is not expected to be quantitatively correct . to conclude this section , therefore , we quote the asymptotic mean cluster size for clusters of arbitrary initial size @xmath108 . the details are given in the appendix : the result is @xmath141 , which generalizes the continuum result @xmath142 . let us recall the zero - temperature coarsening dynamics of the 1d @xmath2-state potts model , starting from a random initial configuration . to maximize the speed of the program , we adopt two - sublattice parallel updating . the zero - temperature dynamics proceeds as follows : in each time step every spin on one of the sublattices changes its colour to that of one of its two neighbours with equal probability , the two sublattices being updated alternately . the dynamics of such systems can equivalently be formulated in terms of the motions of the domain walls as a reaction - diffusion model . the domain walls can be considered as random walkers performing independent random walks . whenever two walkers meet , they annihilate ( @xmath19 ) with probability @xmath22 or aggregate ( @xmath143 ) , to become a single walker , with probability @xmath21 . the persistence is the probability that a fixed point in space has not been traversed by any random walker . for @xmath20 , the particles only annihilate and hence this is equivalent to the glauber model , whereas in the @xmath61 limit the walkers only aggregate . this algorithm is , however , restricted to modelling @xmath2-state potts models with @xmath40 , since @xmath144 generates negative probabilities , while the general result ( [ theta(q ) ] ) allows any real @xmath145 . in order to simulate values of @xmath2 in the interval @xmath146 we can map the potts model ( as far as persistence properties are concerned ) on to an ising representation with a fraction @xmath147 of the sites initially pointing up , and initially persistent , while the down spins are nonpersistent . studying the persistence of the minority ( majority ) spins then corresponds to the case @xmath148 ( @xmath144 ) @xcite . the domain walls between the up and down spins behave as random walkers , annihilating each other on contact with probability one . as far as the persistence is concerned , the dynamics of the potts and ising models are completely equivalent @xcite . for @xmath148 , results obtained from both types of simulation are entirely consistent . the numerical simulations are performed on a 1d lattice of size @xmath149 with periodic boundary conditions . the ising spins , or potts variables , occupy the odd sites of the lattice , while the random walkers are restricted to even - numbered sites . therefore the effective size of the lattice , in terms of ising / potts spins , is @xmath150 . each walker jumps to an adjacent even - numbered site with equal probability , turning any persistent site it hops over into a nonpersistent site . the positions of all walkers are updated simultaneously at each monte - carlo step . the initial configurations are chosen to eliminate the possibility of any ` crossover ' of random walkers when they jump . this can be done by placing them only on sites whose positions on the lattice are of the form @xmath151 , where @xmath1 is an integer . the walkers then occupy subsets of the sites @xmath151 and @xmath152 alternately . for the potts simulations ( @xmath148 ) , the lattice is initially completely persistent . the random walkers are periodically laid down , in clusters of uniform initial size @xmath108 . the walkers then execute random walks , aggregating or annihilating according to the prescribed probabilities , @xmath21 and @xmath22 respectively . the simulations are performed for initial cluster sizes of 2 and 4 . the values of @xmath2 chosen are @xmath153 and 4 , for which the corresponding values of @xmath15 are @xmath154 , @xmath155 , and @xmath156 . for @xmath157 the ising representation is employed , in which persistent sites ( up spins ) are periodically laid down on the lattice , with a fraction @xmath147 of all sites persistent , and the domain walls execute random walks annihilating according to @xmath19 . the value @xmath77 was chosen , for which @xmath158 . the simulations were performed for initial cluster sizes 4 and 8 . the ising simulations were also run for @xmath159 and @xmath160 . the results for scaling functions are consistent with the potts data , but the statistics are poorer due to the smaller number of clusters generated . for this reason , the data presented in figs . 3 - 9 were generated from the potts runs . all the simulations ( potts and ising ) were run for @xmath161 monte - carlo steps , and the results averaged over 30 independent runs . the simulations investigate the limiting values of the average sizes of the persistent clusters , and the distribution , @xmath0 , of intervals between persistent clusters with emphasis on its dynamic scaling form . while the first of these lends itself readily to direct measurement , the dynamic scaling form for @xmath0 manifests itself most clearly in the data through a study of the ( complement of the ) cumulative distribution . we define @xmath162 inserting the scaling form ( [ scaling ] ) and converting the sum to an integral in the scaling limit @xmath135 , @xmath51 with @xmath163 fixed but arbitrary , gives @xmath164 we now discuss the numerical results for the @xmath61 model . in figure [ fig1 ] we plot the mean cluster size against time for initial cluster sizes of 2 and 4 . the numerical results are summarized in table 1 . the numerics clearly support the exact results given in section iii [ and derived in the appendix as equation([l_av ] ) ] , namely @xmath165 where @xmath108 is the initial cluster size . in order to investigate the dynamic scaling form ( [ newscaling ] ) for @xmath61 , we plot , in figure [ fig2 ] , @xmath166 against @xmath136 for @xmath167 500 , 1000 , 2000 , 4000 , 8000 , for initial cluster size 2 , where we have used @xmath168 for @xmath61 . excellent data collapse occurs in agreement with the dynamic scaling form ( [ newscaling ] ) . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] . average cluster size at late times , @xmath169 , for various values of @xmath2 and various initial cluster sizes @xmath108 , where p or i indicate whether potts or ising representations were employed . in all cases the data were averaged over times between 1000 and 9000 monte carlo steps . in section iii we argued that the scaling function @xmath67 in ( [ scaling ] ) should be a simple exponential , which implies that @xmath170 in ( [ newscaling ] ) is also a simple exponential . to test this prediction , we plot @xmath171 against @xmath136 in figure [ fig3 ] . the data lie on the expected straight line except at the latest times , where the deviations from the line are scatter due to statistical noise . very similar results are obtained for initial cluster size 4 , confirming that the scaling function @xmath67 is independent of the initial walker density . in figure [ fig4 ] the mean cluster size is plotted against time for various finite values of @xmath2 and initial cluster size @xmath108 . the numerical results indicate that the average cluster size tends to a constant ( see table i ) in all cases , as expected on the basis of the heuristic argument in section ii . for @xmath172 , @xmath173 and the dominant length scale is still determined by the mean distance between persistent clusters . we therefore anticipate a scaling form of the kind given by ( [ newscaling ] ) with @xmath174 . the scaling plot presented in figure [ fig5 ] shows good data collapse with this value of @xmath45 , while figure [ fig6 ] indicates that @xmath170 , and therefore @xmath67 , is again a simple exponential . the data collapse is not as good as for @xmath61 , which we attribute to a poorer separation of the length scales @xmath28 and @xmath30 at the time scales available . this problem becomes more acute for @xmath175 ( see the discussion below ) . for @xmath175 , @xmath176 , so we plot ( figure [ fig7 ] ) @xmath177 against @xmath163 with @xmath178 . this time the scaling collapse is definitely not as good as for @xmath61 and @xmath172 , reflecting an apparent deviation from the dynamic scaling form ( [ newscaling ] ) . we believe that this deviation reflects the proximity of the length scales @xmath179 and @xmath59 , which are not sufficiently well separated on the timescales achievable in the simulation , and would disappear for asymptotically large times . for example , @xmath180 at @xmath181 , while the corresponding ratio is about 14 for @xmath172 and 90 for @xmath61 . a similar effect may explain the apparent deviations from universality ( e.g. an apparent dependence of @xmath45 on the initial walker density ) in the @xmath20 simulations of mr . in this case @xmath33 , and @xmath182 at @xmath183 , the largest time reached by the mr simulations . so in this case also there is not a strong separation of length scales at the times achieved in the simulations ( a point recently emphasized by manoj and ray @xcite ) . figure [ fig8 ] gives the log - linear plot for @xmath175 . again , the data are consistent with an exponential scaling function , except at small scaling variable where there is a perceptible deviation from a straight line . in this region , however , the data also do not scale at all well either ( see inset in figure [ fig8 ] ) , which may be another manifestation of the poor separation of length scales : the scaling limit requires @xmath135 , @xmath51 with @xmath163 fixed . in particular the condition @xmath184 , which should be satisfied for good scaling , is violated at the small values of @xmath163 where the upturn in the data occurs . we will return to this point in the discussion . to investigate the spatial distribution of the sites in the regime @xmath29 we study @xmath77 , for which @xmath185 . in figure [ fig4 ] we show that the mean cluster size is a constant for initial cluster sizes of 4 and 8 . in the regime @xmath29 the density of the persistent sites decays more rapidly than that of the walkers . the dominant length scale is therefore no longer given by the persistence length , @xmath60 , but is given instead by the mean separation , @xmath59 , of the the walkers . hence we expect asymptotic dynamic scaling of the form ( [ scaling ] ) and ( [ newscaling ] ) with @xmath66 . in figure [ fig9 ] we plot @xmath186 against @xmath187 for an initial cluster size @xmath188 . the numerical results give excellent data collapse , supporting the proposed dynamic scaling form . apart from a change of scale , very similar results are obtained for @xmath189 , supporting the universality of the scaling function , i.e. the independence of @xmath170 from the initial walker density . we choose @xmath77 rather than @xmath20 in order that the length scales @xmath28 and @xmath30 be reasonably well separated at late times : @xmath190 at @xmath181 . figure [ fig9 ] reveals a pronounced upturn at small @xmath1 , which can be seen more clearly in the log - linear plot of figure [ fig10 ] and its inset , suggesting a divergence for @xmath191 . this is , in fact , expected from the analysis of section ii , which predicts , for @xmath29 , @xmath192 for @xmath86 , with @xmath193 , i.e. @xmath71 is in the range @xmath69 . the scaling function @xmath170 is given by @xmath194 for @xmath86 , i.e. @xmath195 , where @xmath196 is the fractal dimension of the persistent set on scales smaller than @xmath30 [ equation ( [ df ] ) ] . according to this prediction , the product @xmath197 should approach a constant at small @xmath17 . this product is shown in figure [ fig11 ] . the small-@xmath1 divergence has clearly been removed , the function approaching a constant at small @xmath17 as predicted ( the erratic behaviour at very small @xmath17 is due to statistical noise ) . for @xmath77 all of the numerical simulations have been performed using the ising representation , with periodic initial conditions in which clusters of @xmath108 ` up spins ' are placed at uniform intervals in a ` down spin ' background , and occupy a fraction @xmath147 of the sites . for @xmath148 , the potts representation has mainly been used , but we expect all universal properties , such as exponents and scaling functions , to be the same for the two representations . this expectation is confirmed by the results for @xmath5 and the scaling function @xmath170 . in order to obtain a _ precise _ correspondence between the ising and the potts representations , however , it is necessary to run the ising simulations with random initial conditions , rather than periodic initial conditions which we have mostly employed , and to scale the axes appropriately with @xmath2 to account for the different interval sizes in the two cases . this is because the reaction - diffusion representation of the potts model , in which walkers annihilate or coalesce with probabilities which depend on @xmath2 , is only an exact representation if the potts states occur in a completely random sequence . this is not true for the periodic initial conditions employed in the ising representation , whose correlations spoil the exact correspondence between ising and potts simulations . our expectation , then , is that the ising representation with random and periodic initial conditions should give the same _ scaling functions _ as the reaction - diffusion implementation of the potts model , but non - universal amplitudes will be different for the periodic initial conditions . in order to test the exact equivalence between random ising and potts simulations we plot , in figure [ fig12 ] , the results for the @xmath172 model using the potts ( reaction - diffusion ) method . the lattice is initially all persistent and the initial cluster size is @xmath198 . this corresponds to a sequence of pairs of potts states in which the members of a pair are in same state , but there are no correlations between pairs ( except that neighboring pairs must be in different states ) . the random initial conditions for the ising simulation are generated from the potts initial state by setting all pairs in potts state ` 1 ' ( say ) to be up spins and all other pairs to be down spins . in the potts simulations we keep track of all persistent sites , while in the ising simulation we track the persistence of the spins initially ` up ' . the interval sizes ( between persistent clusters ) are then naturally larger by a factor @xmath2 in the ising simulations relative to the potts simulations . figure [ fig12 ] shows both scaling functions in log - linear form , for @xmath199 , with this factor of @xmath2 scaled out ( i.e. @xmath200 is plotted against @xmath201 for these data ) . the data overlap almost perfectly . the ising data for a periodic initial condition are consistent with the same scaling function ( exponential ) , but with a different amplitude . in this paper we have investigated the nature of persistent structures in the coarsening dynamics of 1d potts models . a central concept has been the existence of two characteristic length scales , the mean separation , @xmath59 , of domain walls ( or ` walkers ' ) and the ` persistence length ' , @xmath60 , which measures the mean separation of persistent sites or clusters . the focus of our attention has been the distribution function , @xmath0 , for the number of intervals ( between clusters of persistent sites ) of length @xmath1 . this distribution has the scaling form ( [ scaling ] ) , with characteristic length scale , @xmath47 , which is the _ larger _ of @xmath30 and @xmath28 , i.e. @xmath4 . within the 1d potts model both regimes , @xmath29 and @xmath8 , can be accessed by varying the number of potts states , @xmath2 . from the general result , ( [ theta(q ) ] ) , we see that @xmath5 is a monotonically increasing function with , @xmath202 marking the boundary between the two regimes . the regime @xmath8 is conceptually simpler . the @xmath61 limit can been solved exactly ( section iii ) , and results for the long - time limit of the mean cluster size obtained . the fact that the locations of the surviving clusters are statistically independent in the scaling regime leads to the result that the scaling function @xmath67 in ( [ scaling ] ) is a simple exponential . we have argued that the same result should hold for all @xmath8 , since in this regime there are , on average , many walkers between each pair of persistent clusters . the _ relevant _ walkers for this argument ( those which are turning persistent sites in neighboring clusters nonpersistent ) are uncorrelated since their separations , of order @xmath28 , are much larger than the typical separation , @xmath30 , of neighboring walkers . on this basis we expect the asymptotic scaling function @xmath67 to be exponential for all @xmath8 ( i.e. @xmath203 ) . the data for @xmath172 ( figure [ fig6 ] ) and @xmath175 ( figure [ fig8 ] ) are consistent with an exponential form for @xmath204 , although the scaling is not perfect and there is a small upturn in the scaling function at small scaling variable for @xmath175 . we attribute these features to an imperfect separation of length scales on the time scales achieved in the simulations , and conjecture that the true scaling function is exponential for all @xmath104 . the case @xmath29 is more tricky . in this case the persistent clusters outnumber the walkers . the scaling function @xmath67 is clearly _ not _ a simple exponential , though it seems ( figure [ fig10 ] ) to have an exponential tail . there is a small - argument singularity of the form @xmath192 , with @xmath193 . this is related to the fractal dimension , @xmath196 , of the persistent sites : @xmath205 . note that the borderline , @xmath206 , between the two regimes occurs at @xmath207 . the existence of a small-@xmath17 singularity for @xmath29 raises the possibility of an alternative scenario for @xmath104 , in which the @xmath208 singularity , with @xmath209 , persists for @xmath8 , where it becomes an integrable singularity . the small-@xmath17 singularity in @xmath170 would then take the form of a cusp : @xmath210 . we have not been able to rule out this scenario from the data , but think it unlikely for the reasons given elsewhere in this paper . further insight could be obtained if it were possible to perform an expansion around the soluble @xmath61 limit to first order in @xmath147 , but we leave this as a challenge for the future . we conclude by discussing briefly the possibility of the existence of these two qualitatively different regimes in spatial dimension @xmath211 . first we generalize the result ( [ df ] ) , relating @xmath90 and @xmath15 , to any dimension . starting from ( [ both ] ) , the result @xmath212 follows generally , and the number of persistent sites within a distance @xmath87 of a given site is estimated as @xmath213 , where @xmath214 . generalizing still further , if the coarsening exponent is @xmath215 , rather than @xmath34 , the result is @xmath216 ( the @xmath217 version of this result is given in @xcite , based on the same reasoning ) . clearly this result requires @xmath218 , since @xmath90 can not be negative . if this inequality is violated , as in the 1d potts model with @xmath104 , the persistent sites no longer have a fractal structure but become point - like objects , with mean density @xmath219 , where @xmath220 is the coarsening length scale . cases where @xmath221 are easy to find , e.g. in the coarsening of the 2d ising model @xcite , the 2d diffusion equation @xcite , or the time - dependent ginzburg - landau equation in 2d . these all exhibit fractal persistent structures with the expected fractal dimension @xcite . it would be interesting to look for examples , in addition to the 1d potts model , where one can have @xmath222 . this work was supported by epsrc ( uk ) . for a recent review see s. n. majumdar , curr . india * 77 * , 370 ( 1999 ) . b. derrida , a. j. bray , and c. godrche , j. phys . a * 27 * , l357 ( 1994 ) . b. derrida , v. hakim , and v. pasquier , phys . lett . * 75 * , 751 ( 1995 ) ; j. stat . 85 , 763 ( 1996 ) . d. stauffer , j. phys . a * 27 * , 5029 ( 1994 ) . s. n. majumdar , c. sire , a. j. bray , and s. j. cornell , phys . lett . * 77 * , 2867 ( 1996 ) ; b. derrida , v. hakim , and r. zeitak , ibid . * 77 * , 2871 ( 1996 ) . j. krug , h. kallabis , s. n. majumdar , s. j. cornell , a. j. bray , and c. sire , phys . e * 56 * , 2702 ( 1997 ) . a. j. bray , b. derrida , and c. godrche , europhys . * 27 * , 175 ( 1994 ) ; p. l. krapivsky , e. ben - naim , and s. redner , phys . e * 50 * , 2474 ( 1994 ) ; s. n. majumdar and c. sire , phys . * 77 * , 1420 ( 1996 ) . j. cardy , j. phys . a * 28 * , l19 ( 1995 ) ; e. ben - naim , phys . e * 53 * , 1566 ( 1996 ) ; m. howard , j. phys . a * 29 * , 3437 ( 1996 ) ; s. j. cornell and a. j. bray , phys . e * 54 * , 1153 ( 1996 ) . m. marcos - martin , d. beysens , j - p . bouchaud , c. godrche , and i. yekutieli , physica ( amsterdam ) 214d , 396 ( 1995 ) . w. y. tam , r. zeitak , k. y. szeto , and j. stavans , phys . lett . * 78 * , 1588 ( 1997 ) . b. yurke , a. n. pargellis , s. n. majumdar , and c. sire , phys . rev . e * 56 * , r40 ( 1997 ) . s. n. majumdar , a. j. bray , s. j. cornell , and c. sire , phys . lett . * 77 * , 3704 ( 1996 ) ; k. oerding , s. j. cornell , and a. j. bray , phys . e * 56 * , r25 ( 1997 ) . g. manoj and p. ray , preprint , cond - mat/9901130 ( 1999 ) ; preprint , cond - mat/0003203 ( 2000 ) . d. h. zanette , phys . e * 55 * , 2462 ( 1997 ) . g. manoj and p. ray , j. phys . a * 33 * , l109 ( 2000 ) . s. jain and h. flynn , preprint , cond - mat/0004148 ( 2000 ) . e. ben - naim , l. frachebourg , and p. l. krapivsky , phys . e * 53 * , 3078 ( 1996 ) . s. j. cornell and a. j. bray , unpublished . see http://theory.ph.man.ac.uk/@xmath223bray/pictures.html for some illustrations of the persistent structures which arise . in this appendix we compute the probability that a cluster of initial size @xmath108 survives to time @xmath7 , and the mean size of surviving clusters , for the process @xmath106 . first note that initially there is a random walker at each end of the domain . at each time step the walkers move independently left or right with probability @xmath34 , so we can treat each walker independently . consider , therefore , a single walker moving at discrete time steps on a discrete 1d lattice , starting , at time @xmath107 , at position @xmath78 . let the ` origin ' be the point @xmath224 , and let @xmath225 be the probability that the walker has not yet reached the origin at time @xmath7 . clearly , @xmath226,\ \ \ r \ge 2\ . \label{recurrence}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we are interested only in the limit @xmath51 . in this limit , we know from standard random walk theory that every @xmath225 decays like @xmath24 , with an @xmath78-dependent amplitude . to leading order in @xmath24 , therefore , the @xmath7-dependence drops out of equations ( [ recurrence ] ) , which then become equations for the amplitudes . by inspection , the solution in this regime is @xmath227 now consider a walker starting immediately to the right of a cluster of @xmath108 persistent sites . the probability that after @xmath7 steps the walker has jumped over exactly @xmath78 of these ( making them nonpersistent ) is @xmath228 , where the final result follows from ( [ leading ] ) , to leading order for large @xmath7 . the same result holds for a walker starting immediately to the left of the cluster . the probability that @xmath110 sites remain persistent after time @xmath7 is @xmath229 times the number of ways of partitioning the cluster of length @xmath108 into 3 sections , with the central section of length @xmath110 ( and zero lengths are allowed for the outer sections ) . this number is @xmath230 . so the probability of the cluster surviving and having length @xmath110 is @xmath231 a generalization of ( [ pl0 ] ) to the discrete system . | the distribution , @xmath0 , of the interval sizes , @xmath1 , between clusters of persistent sites in the dynamical evolution of the one - dimensional @xmath2-state potts model is studied using a combination of numerical simulations , scaling arguments , and exact analysis . it is shown to have the scaling form @xmath3 , with @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the persistence exponent which describes the fraction , @xmath6 , of sites which have not changed their state up to time @xmath7 . when @xmath8 , the scaling length @xmath9 for the interval - size distribution is larger than the coarsening length scale @xmath10 that characterizes spatial correlations of the potts variables . 2 |
1206.6177 | differential - algebraic equations ( dae ) systems arise naturally when modelling many dynamic systems . dynamic process models and their properties form the background of any process control activity including model analysis , model parameter and structure estimation , diagnosis , regulation or optimal control . in particular , the structural analysis of dynamic lumped process models forms an important step in the model building procedure @xcite , and it is used for the determination of the solvability properties of the model . furthermore , the dynamic lumped process models often require the consistent initial conditions and solution of high - index differential - algebraic systems . the index is a notion used in the theory of daes for measuring the distance from a dae to its related ode . high - index dae systems need prolongation ( differentiation ) to reveal all the system s constraints , and to determine consistent initial conditions . the key steps include identifying all hidden constraints on formal power series solutions in the neighborhood of a given point , and are required to prepare the system for numerical integration . so for such differential systems , prolongation is unavoidable . in the present work , pryce developed a taylor series method based on his structural analysis method @xcite and on pantelides work in @xcite . pantelides method gives a systematic way to reduce high - index systems of differential - algebraic equations to lower index , by selectively adding differentiated forms of the equations already present in the system . it is implemented in several significant equation - based simulation programs such as gproms @xcite , modelica @xcite and emso @xcite . however , the algorithm can fail in some instances . pryce s structural analysis is based on solving an assignment problem , which can be formulated as an integer linear programming problem . it finds all the constraints for a large class of ode using only prolongation , which can be considered as fast prolongation method . corless et al . show pryce s method can be extended to give a polynomial cost method for numerical solution of differential algebraic equations @xcite . give a differential algebraic interpretation of pryce s method for ode , which generalizes to a certain class of pde for finding missing constraints @xcite . mani shows how pre - symbolic simplification can usefully extend the applicability of the pryce method on models produced by maplesim @xcite . in @xcite , leitold propose the structural analysis of process models using their representation graphs for the determination of the most important solvability property of lumped dynamic models : the differential index . their graph - theoretical method depends on the change in the relative position of underspecified and overspecified subgraphs and has an effect to the value of the differential index for complex models . if these subgraphs move further from their original positions the value of differential index increases . in this paper , we consider other approaches for the structural analysis of dynamic lumped process models for high - index dae systems . in particular , we consider pryce s method and the symbolic differential elimination package rifsimp . pryce s method is a robust and reliable method for remedying the drawback of the approach @xcite and doing so automatically . this is a powerful way to determine the index of the system , its number of degrees of freedom , and exactly which components should be given initial values . the key idea is taken from pryce s signature - method . the nice feature of the work is a simple and straightforward method for analysing the structure of a differential algebraic system . the rest of this paper is organized as follows . section 2 describes pryce s method and introduces the symbolic differential elimination package rifsimp in maple . section 3 gives the structural analysis of simple process models using these approaches . section 4 gives some experimental results . the final section concludes this paper . in this section , we give a brief review of pryce s method and some remarks , and present the symbolic differential elimination with maple s rifsimp package . we review below the main steps of pryce s structural analysis and the corresponding algorithm following @xcite . we consider an input system of @xmath0 equations @xmath1 , where @xmath2 in @xmath0 dependent variables @xmath3 . form the @xmath4 signature matrix @xmath5 of the dae , where @xmath6 step 2 . solve an assignment problem to find a hvt @xmath7 , which is a subset of indices @xmath8 describing just one element in each row and each column , such that @xmath9 is maximized and finite . determine the offsets of the problem , which are the vectors @xmath10 , the smallest such that @xmath11 , for all @xmath12 with equality on the hvt . this problem can be formulated as an integer linear programming problem ( lpp ) in the variables @xmath13 ) and @xmath14 : @xmath15 the structural index is then defined as @xmath16 the structural index is no less that the differential index on first order dae . form the @xmath17 system jacobian matrix @xmath18 where @xmath19 step 5 . choose a consistent point . if @xmath18 is non - singular at that point , then the solution can be computed with taylor series or numerical homotopy continuation techniques in a neighborhood of that point . [ [ remark-1 . ] ] remark 1 . + + + + + + + + + the computation of @xmath20 and @xmath21 only involves the information on differential order and is consequently very fast in step 3 of pryce s method . this problem is dual to the assignment problem . the time complexity of the assignment problem can be done at polynomial cost by using the hungarian method @xcite . generally , such problems can be solved very efficiently in practice . [ [ remark-2 . ] ] remark 2 . + + + + + + + + + after we obtain the number of prolongation steps @xmath22 for each equation from step 3 of pryce s method , we can enlarge the system of equations using @xmath20 . we assume @xmath23 , and let @xmath24 , which is closely related to the index of daes . consider the equations obtained by taking the @xmath25-derivative of @xmath26 up to the @xmath22th derivative , @xmath27 , that is the collection @xmath28 where @xmath29 denotes @xmath30 . is defined by the same way for the rest of this paper . ] by the definition of @xmath31 and inequalities ( 1b ) , the derivatives of the @xmath32 that occur in equations ( 2 ) all lie in this set : @xmath33 represent ( 3 ) as a vector x , then ( 2 ) can be written as a system @xmath34 where @xmath35 , and assume @xmath36 . in particular , for @xmath37 , @xmath38 has fewer variables than @xmath39 . the block structure form @xmath40 in the case @xmath41 is given in table 1 . .the triangular block structure of @xmath42 for the case @xmath43 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ table : nonlin ] [ [ remark-3 . ] ] remark 3 . + + + + + + + + + fast prolongation produces a simplified system to which a standard numeric solver can be efficiently applied . maple s rifsimp package can be used to simplify small- and middle - scale daes , and overdetermined systems of polynomially nonlinear pdes or odes and inequations to a more useful form @xcite . for the daes and odes the only independent variable is time . it processes systems of polynomially nonlinear pdes with dependent variables @xmath44 , which can be functions of several independent variables . the key idea of algorithm is substitution and differential elimination , which requires a ranking to be defined on the dependent variables and their derivatives . a basic step of differential elimination algorithms linearly appearing is to write the system in solved form with respect to each highest ranked derivative . it is treated by methods involving a combination of gr@xmath45ber bases and triangular decompositions . another key step in such algorithms is the taking of integrability conditions between equations . the rifsimp algorithm is essentially an extension of the gaussian elimination to daes and systems of nonlinear pdes . it differentiates the leading nonlinear equations and then reduce them with respect to the leading linear equations . if zero is obtained , it means that the equation is a consequence of the leading linear equations . if not , it means that this equation is a new constraint to the system . this is repeated until no new constraints are found . see section 3.3 for a simple example . in this section , we apply the above techniques to structure analysis of dynamic lumped process models dae systems . the model is taken from dynamic process simulation and multi - domain modeling and simulation of complex systems . here , the cascade of perfectly stirred tank reactors yields the basic examples of the paper , see fig.1 . -th tank @xmath46 and @xmath47 ) are the inlet and outlet flow rate , @xmath48 is the concentration and @xmath49 is the fixed volume of the @xmath50-th tank.,height=158 ] suppose a system consists of @xmath51 perfectly stirred tank reactor . a feed of concentration @xmath52 is fed into the first tank . the concentrations in the tanks are described by the following equation : @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the concentration in the tank @xmath50 , @xmath55 is the flow rates from tank to tank and @xmath56 is the fixed volume of the tank @xmath50 . thus the flow rates between the tanks @xmath57 are all the same that @xmath58 , where @xmath59 is a specified function of @xmath25 . in general , there are two different specifications that can be added to these equations according to the modelling goal : + a ) in dynamic simulation studies the feed concentration @xmath52 is given by @xmath60 ; + b ) in dynamic design the product concentration @xmath61 is given by @xmath62 . when applied to process system a ) and b ) , the main steps of our approach are : step 1 . construct the original system as follows based on the equation ( [ eq : orig ] ) : @xmath63 , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath51 is the number of tanks . obtain the original condition and add it into @xmath42 . there are two cases : + a ) in dynamic simulation the tank feed concentration @xmath52 is given as a function of time then get @xmath64 equations in @xmath64 unknowns : @xmath65 , this is essentially index 1 no matter what @xmath51 is , and is a trivial system . symbolic differential elimination can be used for case a ) ; + b ) in dynamic design the product concentration @xmath61 is given as a function : @xmath66 . it is a nontrivial system , which is high - index as @xmath51 increased . call the pryce s algorithm of section 2 to solve the vector @xmath20 and @xmath67 , and enlarge the initial system by fast prolongation . alternatively symbolic differential elimination can be used for case b ) . check the jacobian matrix @xmath18 with the coefficients of highest derivatives equations and compute the consistent point . [ [ remark-4 . ] ] remark 4 . + + + + + + + + + based on the structure analysis of pryce s method , it is practical and efficient for dynamic lumped process models dae systems . in general , the goal of structural analysis of daes is to differentiate the equations in such a way that the coefficient ( jacobian ) matrix of the highest derivatives is non - singular . it means that some equations need prolongations on independent variable to balance the coefficients matrix . so it can computing jacobian matrix of the lower derivatives equations by an iterative procedure for finding all consistent points . [ [ remark-5 . ] ] remark 5 . + + + + + + + + + compared with the structural analysis of process models using their representation graphs method , the advantages of our algorithm are : + @xmath68 we efficiently apply the fast numerical and symbolic computations to a wide variety of physical models generated by the equation - based technique . + @xmath68 for the large models , we can keep the structural index of system remaining unchanged . moreover , the prolongation system has a favorable block triangular structure to compute the missing initial conditions more efficiently . for the general dynamic lumped process models dae systems , we can obtain the offsets of vector @xmath69 and @xmath70 by pryce s method . therefore , we have the following ranking of dependent variables . @xmath71 based on the above ranking , we can obtain the sequence of solving initial value problem for the dynamic lumped process models dae systems . it is equivalently the block - triangular system that has full row rank for each @xmath51 . from ( [ eq : orisys ] ) , @xmath42 and the original condition @xmath62 have @xmath72 components . the number of variables is @xmath73 considered as @xmath74 algebraic equations in @xmath75 variables , it has a solution @xmath76 , where @xmath77 and that @xmath18 is non - singular . therefore , @xmath76 is a consistent point . in a neighborhood of the point @xmath76 , the solution manifold has @xmath78 degrees of freedom @xcite . at a point @xmath76 in @xmath79 where @xmath18 is non - singular , @xmath79 is locally a manifold of dimension @xmath80 parameterized . the solution manifold has @xmath78 degrees of freedom , where @xmath81 the above shows that if we find a solution @xmath76 , this is a consistent point , and if the number of degrees of freedom @xmath82 there are other consistent points nearby for the same @xmath25 . the general dynamic lumped process models dae systems have degrees of freedom @xmath83 , where k is the number of tanks . the structural index is @xmath84 . from lemma 1 , we have degrees of freedom @xmath85 because the @xmath86 , the structural index is @xmath87 . here , we give the degrees of freedom and structural index of the general dynamic lumped process models dae systems that is a function of the number of tanks @xmath51 . we propose a simple example to set the number of tanks @xmath88 case a ) to illustrate the rifsimp algorithm . step : construct the original system as follows : @xmath89;\end{aligned}\ ] ] obtain the original condition @xmath65 , and add it to @xmath90 ; call rifsimp algorithm to reduce the system as follows : @xmath91.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ [ remark-6 . ] ] remark 6 . + + + + + + + + + in this paper , we consider the modelling goal for case a ) by the rifsimp algorithm . the main reason is the specific structure of models , which is the quasi - triangular system and has @xmath65 specified . therefore , it is only simple check . but it becomes rapidly more complicated as the number @xmath51 increased for case b ) . we propose a simple example to set the number of tanks @xmath92 case b ) and illustrate our algorithms . step : construct the original system as follows : @xmath93;\end{aligned}\ ] ] obtain the original condition @xmath94 , and add @xmath95 to @xmath90 ; obtain the variables list @xmath96 $ ] ; call the pryce s method and solving this integer lpp by lpsolve in the optimization package of maple , we obtain the fast prolongation times for the @xmath50-th equation from @xmath20 , and the highest order of derivative variables from @xmath21 as follows : + @xmath97 . + therefore , according to the @xmath22 values it can be prolonged for the corresponding equations automatically . enlarged sets of variables : + @xmath98 + equations : + @xmath99 the system jacobian @xmath18 is : @xmath100 0\ , \ , \ - { \displaystyle \frac { \mathrm{q}(t)}{{v_{2}}(t ) } } \ , \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \,{\displaystyle \frac { \mathrm{q}(t ) \,({c_{1}}(t ) - { c_{2}}(t))}{{v_{2}}(t)^{2 } } } \ , \ \ \ 0\ , \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \,0 \\ [ 2ex ] 0\ , \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ , - { \displaystyle \frac { \mathrm{q}(t)}{{v_{3}}(t ) } } \ , \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \,{\displaystyle \frac { \mathrm{q}(t)\,({c_{2}}(t ) - { c_{3}}(t))}{{v_{3}}(t)^{2}}}\ , \ \ \ \ \ , 0\ , \ \ \ \ \,0 \\ [ 2ex ] 0\ , \ \,0\ , \ \ , - { \displaystyle \frac { \mathrm{q}(t)}{{v _ { 4}}(t ) } } \ , \,1\ , \ \,0\ , \ \,0\ , \ \,0\ , \ \,{\displaystyle \frac { \mathrm{q}(t)\,({c_{3}}(t ) - { c_{4}}(t))}{{v_{4}}(t)^{2 } } } \ , \ , - { \displaystyle \frac { { c_{3}}(t ) - { c_{4}}(t)}{{v_{4}}(t ) } } \\ [ 2ex ] 0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,1\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0 \\ 0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,1\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0 \\ 0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,1\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0 \\ 0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,1\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0 \\ 0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,1 \\ 0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,1\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0\ , \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \,0 \end{array } } \right]\ ] ] computing the jacobian matrix @xmath101 , which is non - singular . and then we can compute the consistent point by numerical methods , such as taylor series methods , homotopy methods . [ [ remark-7 . ] ] remark 7 . + + + + + + + + + in particular , we can obtain the coefficient ( jacobian ) matrix that is sparse dramatically . for the highest derivatives , the determinant of jacobian matrix is @xmath102 where @xmath51 is the number of tanks . an efficient practical implementation of pryce s method is in _ maple_. the following examples run in the platform of maple and inter(r ) core(tm ) i3 2.40ghz , 2.00 g ram . we give some experimental results using symbolic differential elimination and fast prolongation for structural analysis of dynamic lumped process models dae systems . in fig . @xmath103 , we present the time for symbolic differential elimination by rifsimp of maple package and fast prolongation as the number of tank reactors @xmath51 increased . in fig . @xmath104 , we present the memory usage for symbolic differential elimination by rifsimp of maple package and fast prolongation as the number of tank reactors @xmath51 increased . the system jacobian is very sparse for case b ) . its determinants are evaluated symbolically to be @xmath102 where @xmath51 is the number of tanks , and is non zero . in other examples the alternative is to usually find an approximate point satisfying the constraints by numerical method ( eg . homotopy method ) and evaluate the condition number of the jacobian to carry out he validation . from figures @xmath103 and @xmath104 : + @xmath68 the time of structural analysis of dynamic lumped process models dae systems for fast prolongation is small and ultimately grows slowly in the range of degrees of freedom considered . the time for symbolic differential elimination method grows much faster . the main reason is that fast prolongation only needs to solve an integer linear programming problem , but the symbolic differential elimination needs a large number of eliminations and differentiates . therefore , the symbolic differential elimination is more difficult for the general high - index dae systems . + @xmath68 the memory shows steady growth as the number @xmath51 increases . the memory usage of symbolic differential elimination grows very quickly . the above analysis and experimental results , motivates consideration of hybrid techniques involving a combination of symbolic differential elimination and fast prolongation for large dae models . however , symbolic computations have the disadvantage of intermediate expression swell . in the future , we would like to consider a combination of partial symbolic differential elimination and fast prolongation to model and simulate realistic physical models . we hope to give the specific structural analysis algorithms that exploit the form of systems appearing in applications . in this paper , we have investigated the high - index structural analysis problem for the class of dynamic lumped process models dae systems by pryce s method and symbolic differential elimination . we designed the algorithm to automatically analysis the structural of simple process models , and showed that the rifsimp algorithm of maple package reduces the original system to standard form . we also gave the degrees of freedom and structural index of the dynamic lumped process models dae systems that is a function of the number of tanks @xmath51 . moreover , those approached can be generalized to a wide variety of physical models and analyzed the structural of square and non - square nonlinear dae and pdae systems . this work was partially supported by the national basic research program of china ( 2011cb302402 ) , the west light foundation of the chinese academy of sciences , the national natural science foundation of china ( grant no . 91118001 , 11171053 ) , and the chinese academy of sciences visiting professorship for senior international scientists(grant no.2010t2g31 ) . fritzson , p. : principles of object - oriented modeling and simulation with modelica 2.1 , wiley - ieee press ( 2004 ) soares , r.p . and secchi , a.r . : emso : a new environment for modeling , simulation and optimization . escape 13 , lappeenranta , finlandia , 947952 ( 2003 ) | this paper deals with the structural analysis problem of dynamic lumped process high - index dae models . we consider two methods for index reduction of such models by differentiation : pryce s method and the symbolic differential elimination algorithm rifsimp . discussion and comparison of these methods are given via a class of fundamental process simulation examples . in particular , the efficiency of the pryce method is illustrated as a function of the number of tanks in process design . algebraic equations , structural analysis , symbolic differential elimination , fast prolongation , linear programming problem |
cond-mat9805403 | phases of matter with broken continuous symmetries exhibit topological defects , which can be thermally excited or induced via external stresses . the surface interactions of a foreign inclusion within an ordered medium can induce nontrivial distortions in the bulk medium and lead to the nucleation of defect structures @xcite . even in cases where no defects are present , the distortions that arise can often be described by virtual defects within the foreign inclusion itself in much the same way that electric fields outside a conductor can be described by image charges within the conductor . two such experimental systems which have recently been studied are langmuir monolayers @xcite and nematic emulsions @xcite . at sufficiently high density , a langmuir monolayer forms an orientationally ordered liquid - condensed phase in which the order is characterized by a @xmath0 unit - vector order parameter , which we call the @xmath1-director @xcite . under appropriate conditions a liquid - condensed region can contain isolated domains of the rotationally isotropic liquid - expanded phase , that is , regions wherein the orientational order is absent . along the boundary separating the two phases , there is typically a preferred orientation of @xmath1 relative to the tangent vector to the boundary . the inclusions ( liquid - expanded regions ) can thus lead to a distortion of the order - parameter field of the ordered medium ( liquid - condensed region ) surrounding them . nematic emulsions are dispersions of droplets of nematic liquid crystal in an isotropic host @xcite . inverse nematic emulsions consist of surfactant coated spherical water droplets dispersed in a nematic host @xcite . the surfactant can be prepared such that the nematic director prefers to align either parallel or perpendicular to a surfactant coated surface . thus the droplets distort the local nematic field and , in the case of normal boundary conditions , the droplets themselves carry a topological hedgehog charge which must be compensated for by creating additional defect structures within the ordered medium . experimental observations @xcite in both langmuir monolayers and inverse nematic emulsions have been explained theoretically with some success @xcite . neither , however , is the simplest system one could imagine for the study of the effects of foreign inclusions in an ordered medium . in langmuir films the line tension of the interface between the two phases is so low that orientational order in the surrounding medium and the shape of the inclusion are strongly coupled , greatly complicating the theoretical treatment . in nematic emulsions , the elastic theory describing director distortions is highly non - linear , and as a result , it is very difficult to find exact solutions for the director around a droplet - defect pair . in this paper , we report observations of freely suspended inclusions in another ordered system , smectic - c films , and we develop a theory for their energetics . there are several types of circular inclusions with fixed boundary conditions that can be inserted into a freely suspended smectic - c film . the type we are concerned with here are islands , places where the film contains an integral number of additional smectic layers ( fig [ setup ] ) . islands can be introduced to a freely suspended film by ( 1 ) rapidly reducing the film area , ( 2 ) blowing across the film to pull material from the meniscus region or ( 3 ) heating the film near the smectic - to - isotropic or smectic - to - nematic phase transition , at which point isotropic or nematic droplets form in the film and remain as islands after cooling . typical islands have radii from 50 to several hundred microns . the boundaries of these inclusions are smectic dislocations , and the @xmath1 director has a preferred orientation relative to the tangent line to such dislocations @xcite thus providing our fixed boundary condition . this fixed boundary condition allows us to consider the interior and exterior regions of an island as separate systems , analogous to the way a conducting surface allows one to independently consider the electrostatic configurations interior and exterior to the conducting surface . while island - defect pairs are relatively easy to create and image ( fig . [ setup ] ) , they have the disadvantage that often the islands shrink , and it is difficult to control their size . this makes the creation of several islands of uniform size very difficult . a second type of inclusion in smectic - c films are isotropic or nematic droplets , found in materials that have a direct phase transition from the smectic - c to the isotropic phase . droplets have the disadvantage compared to islands that as one nears the isotropic transition , the birefringence of the film diminishes , and it becomes difficult to image the @xmath1-director . a third type of inclusion consists of the direct insertion of small ( 10 micron ) glass spheres into the film . while this in principle is the best technique , since size can be accurately controlled and the birefringence is unaffected , in practice it is difficult to maintain glass spheres larger than 5 microns in the film . larger spheres either rupture the film or simply pass through . regardless of its type , a circular inclusion with rigid boundary conditions along its perimeter carries a topological charge of @xmath2 . experimentally it is observed that each island nucleates a companion @xmath3 defect out of the bulk , which maintains a preferred separation from the inclusion while undergoing visible radial and azimuthal orientational fluctuations with respect to the center of the inclusion . in this paper , we present a theoretical study of these circular inclusions in smectic - c films . we also report briefly on preliminary experimental observations that are in qualitative agreement with our theoretical analysis . the theoretical treatment of circular inclusions with rigid boundary conditions in smectic - c films is simpler than the treatment of similar defects in langmuir films and nematic emulsions since shape changes in the boundary present in langmuir films do not occur and within the one coupling constant model of smectic - c elasticity we avoid the nonlinearities inherent in the treatment of @xmath4 nematics . in fact , the equation describing the order is simply laplace s equation , @xmath5 , where @xmath6 . because we impose rigid boundary conditions , our @xmath0 results are very similar to those obtained in @xmath4 nematic emulsions with similar boundary conditions . fluctuations , however , are more pronounced in @xmath0 than in @xmath4 . if the angle @xmath7 is constrained to make a constant angle @xmath8 with respect to the tangent to the boundary of an inclusion , then an inclusion necessarily creates ( or `` is '' ) a topological defect - a vortex , or equivalently , a disclination with positive topological charge . if the boundary conditions at infinity enforce alignment along a specific direction the total topological charge must be zero , and , as a consequence , a companion defect with negative charge must be created for every inclusion . the inclusion and its companion defect form a topological dipole that interacts with other distant inclusion - defect pairs via a @xmath0 dipole - dipole interaction . in @xmath4 nematic emulsions , fluctuations in both the distance @xmath9 between a droplet and its companion defect and the angle @xmath10 between the droplet - defect dipole and the direction of the far - field alignment are negligible , with @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the temperature , @xmath13 is a frank elastic constant and @xmath14 is the droplet radius ( @xmath15 m ) . since @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is approximately a molecular length ( @xmath18 nm ) we find that @xmath19 in our @xmath0 analog , the frank elastic constant @xmath20 has units of energy and is typically of order @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the film thickness . taking @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is the number of layers in the film , we then find @xmath25 . our calculation actually leads to the numerically smaller result @xmath26 . in addition , logarithmic singularities in two - dimensions lead to a logarithmic dependence on the system size , @xmath27 , in @xmath28 . laplace s equation in two dimensions admits two fundamental types of point defects : a topological defect with @xmath29 and a logarithmic defect with @xmath30 . in what follows , we will refer to the charge of the topological defect as the topological charge or magnetic charge and that of the logarithmic defect as the electric charge since the angle field of the latter is equivalent to the potential produced by a point electric charge ( see appendix ) . to describe arbitrary orientations of the topological dipole with respect to the @xmath1-director at infinity , both kinds of defects are needed . the `` charges '' of the topological defects are fixed to be integers whereas those of the logarithmic defects are proportional to the angular deviation of the dipole from its favored direction . as in @xmath4 nematic emulsions @xcite , widely separated inclusion - induced topological dipoles interact via a dipole - dipole potential arising from the arrangement of the magnetic charges associated with each inclusion . when the dipoles are not properly aligned with respect to the @xmath1-director at infinity , the inclusions will also carry a certain amount of electric charge , leading to an additional interaction . in three dimensions , the analogous interaction is unimportant because of the prohibitive cost of deviations from the direction of preferred alignment . in two dimensions , deviations can be large : this interaction is important , and it can be calculated . it predicts that correlated rotations of dipoles in which the total electric charge is zero are energetically less costly than those with non - zero electric charge . it should be possible to test this prediction experimentally . our preliminary experimental observations are in qualitative agreement with these predictions . associated with each island is a companion negative defect ( fig . [ vfs_no_q ] ) . the position of this defect fluctuates visibly with angular fluctuations apparently greater than the radial fluctuations . furthermore , defect fluctuations appear to be correlated when more than one island is present . further study will be needed to provide unambiguous confirmation of these observations . our free standing smectic - c film is closely approximated by a @xmath0 @xmath31-model @xcite . a typical film has a small number of layers , @xmath32 , ( roughly 4 - 10 ) which can be determined exactly with laser reflectivity measurements . the projection of the nematic director into the plane of the film provides us with our unit - vector order parameter @xmath1 ( the tilt is relatively constant over the area of the film ) . the effective free energy of these films contains two elastic constants - one for splay distortions ( @xmath33 ) and another for bend ( @xmath34 ) : @xmath35 d^2x.\ ] ] however , when the difference between @xmath34 and @xmath33 is small , the @xmath0 @xmath31-model provides an accurate approximation , @xmath36 d^2x \\ & = & \frac{k}{2 } \int_{\omega } ( \nabla \phi)^2 d^2x , \label{freeenergy}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where it is understood that the integral is taken over the region @xmath37 where the order parameter @xmath1 exists and is nonzero . let us now examine an ideal case of a circular inclusion immersed in an ordered medium described by an @xmath31 order parameter @xmath38 . we take eq . ( [ freeenergy ] ) to be our free energy , where @xmath13 is the frank elastic constant and the integral is to be taken over the region that the ordered medium occupies ( external to the inclusion and internal to some boundary farther away ) , namely @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is a disc of radius @xmath41 centered about the origin , @xmath14 is the radius of the inclusion and @xmath27 is the system size . we do not include any surface energies since we will assume the properties of the surface will remain fixed ( i.e. , strong pinning boundary conditions keeping @xmath1 fixed and a very large line tension keeping the shape fixed ) . we will assume that the far field is uniform at the outer boundary taking @xmath42 . next we take the boundary condition at the surface to be of the form @xmath43 , where @xmath44 is the azimuthal angle relative to the center of the disc and @xmath8 is the angle that the director @xmath1 makes with the tangent vector to the boundary . this condition gives the inclusion a topological charge ( winding number ) of @xmath2 . the far - field boundary condition requires that the total charge be 0 , thus requiring the existence of an additional topological defect with charge @xmath3 . we will find that this defect will sit fairly close to the inclusion and that the pair will constitute a dipole , which can in turn interact with other such pairs via a dipole - dipole interaction . we will note that the value of @xmath8 will only be relevant if one knows the actual direction of the far field , and then it will determine the relative angle between the far - field direction and the direction of the dipole . taking the radius of the defect to be @xmath45 and assigning a core energy to the defect @xmath46 @xcite , we simply need to find solutions for @xmath7 that depend on the position of the defect and to extract an effective free energy , @xmath47 $ ] , as a function of the defect position @xmath48 . minimization of eq . ( [ freeenergy ] ) leads to laplace s equation , @xmath49 throughout @xmath37 except at points occupied by defects . the angle field of a single charge @xmath2 defect located at @xmath50 is simply @xmath51 where @xmath52 . we note that @xmath53 satisfies laplace s equation everywhere except at @xmath54 . the angle field of a charge-@xmath55 defect at @xmath54 is @xmath56 . in particular , a charge @xmath3 defect has a field @xmath57 . there is an image solution to our problem of a disc with strong pinning boundary conditions and a uniform director field at infinity @xcite : @xmath58 and @xmath59 is an integer , which may vary depending upon the point on the circle @xmath60 at which we are evaluating the function . the function @xmath61 where @xmath62 has the following properties : @xmath63 and @xmath64 as @xmath65 . thus we can satisfy boundary conditions at @xmath60 and at @xmath66 by creating a real @xmath3 defect at @xmath67 in the medium outside the circular inclusion and a @xmath68 defect at @xmath69 and a @xmath3 defect at @xmath70 inside the disc . since in the absence of boundary conditions at @xmath27 , there would be a single @xmath2 defect at @xmath69 , we may regard one @xmath2 defect at @xmath69 and the interior @xmath3 defect as images . even though this solution does not strictly satisfy our boundary condition at @xmath27 , we claim that it is good enough for @xmath27 significantly larger than @xmath14 . to satisfy both boundary conditions would require an infinite number of images inside @xmath14 and outside @xmath27 , but the additional images would have little effect on the energy as the interested reader may easily confirm . the collection of three charges can be viewed as a topological dipole with moment @xmath71 pointing from the induced defect in the medium to the center of the disc : @xmath72 the dipole makes an angle of @xmath73 with the direction of @xmath1 in the far field . sample configurations are shown in fig ( [ vfs_no_q ] ) . if @xmath1 is parallel to the @xmath74-axis at infinity , then the induced defect lies above the disc , and hence @xmath71 points in the @xmath75 direction when @xmath76 ( tangential boundary conditions ) ; and the induced defect lies to the left of the disc , and hence @xmath71 points in the @xmath77 direction when @xmath78 ( normal boundary conditions ) . an intermediate configuration with @xmath79 is also shown in fig . ( [ vfs_no_q ] ) . the solution we have constructed is valid for any @xmath9 , and we now calculate the free energy of a single dipole , @xmath80 $ ] , as a function of @xmath9 at the fixed orientation @xmath73 @xmath81 = -\pi k \log ( a r_d ) + 2\pi k\log r_d \\ \nonumber & & \quad -\pi k \log\xi -\pi k \log\left(r_d-\frac{a^2}{r_d}\right ) + 2 \pi k \log r_d + \epsilon_{\rm core } \\ \nonumber & & = -\pi k \log \left ( \frac{a^2}{r_d^2 } -\frac{a^4}{r_d^4 } \right ) + \pi k \log \frac{a}{\xi } + \epsilon_{\rm core}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we see that the preferred position for the defect is @xmath82 . expanding about this minimum with @xmath83 we find , @xmath84 \approx { \rm const } + 4 \pi k \left(\frac{\delta r_d}{r_d^0}\right)^2 + \cdots.\ ] ] thermal fluctuations in @xmath9 then satisfy , @xmath85 in qualitative agreement with our estimate from section ( i ) . noting that this @xmath13 is the two - dimensional constant @xmath20 from section ( i ) , we recall the estimate @xmath86 where @xmath24 is the number of layers in the film ( typically 4 - 10 ) . this would suggest that the radial fluctuations should be of order @xmath87 for a @xmath88 layer film . our experimental observations are slightly larger than this . we would now like to relax our assumption about the azimuthal location of the defect and calculate @xmath89 $ ] where @xmath90 and @xmath91 . equivalently , we now let the angle of the dipole ( @xmath92 ) vary as well as its magnitude ( fig . [ vfs_q ] ) . in doing so , we will in fact see that @xmath93 is the equilibrium azimuthal location of the defect . to find a solution , we have only to add to @xmath7 in eq . ( [ phi_r ] ) a solution to @xmath94 that is zero at @xmath95 and equal to @xmath96 at @xmath60 . such a solution can be constructed from the electric - charge field @xmath97 , which is constant for constant @xmath41 . we find @xmath98 where @xmath99 is the electric charge . the energy associated with this field is @xmath100 = f_1[(a , r_d,\phi_d^0 ) ] + \frac{\pi k}{\log \frac{r}{a } } ( \delta \phi_d)^2 . \label{f_delphi}\ ] ] from this we can calculate the magnitude of the orientational fluctuations : @xmath101 thus , in an infinite sample @xmath102 is infinite , and there is no well - defined direction of @xmath71 relative to the direction of @xmath1 at infinity . in laboratory samples one typically finds @xmath103 giving @xmath104 and hence fluctuations in the angle are reasonably enhanced by this logarithmic factor . finally again using our estimate of @xmath105 with @xmath106 we find that for @xmath107 we have @xmath108 . this corresponds to angular fluctuations of approximately 30 degrees , which should be far more noticeable than the radial fluctuations @xmath109 . observed angular fluctuations indeed appear to be of this order . a single inclusion distorts the @xmath1-director field as we have just shown . if there are two or more inclusions , the distortions they induce will give rise to effective interactions among the inclusions . if the separation between inclusions is large compared to their radii , each inclusion behaves like a dipole , and there will be a pair - wise dipole - dipole interaction between them . in addition , if the dipoles are not properly oriented with respect to the far - field @xmath1-director they spawn `` electric '' charges within the inclusion , and these give rise to a @xmath0 coulomb interaction between the inclusions . more importantly , since the values of these electric charges are not fixed , the usually constant `` self - energy '' contribution will not be constant and will greatly favor total charge neutrality within the system . this in turn will imply that fluctuations of the dipoles adhering to electrostatic charge neutrality will be enhanced over those that do not . before proceeding we wish to clarify our notation for a single inclusion - defect pair . for simplicity and without loss of generality , we will continue to assume that the far - field @xmath1-director points in the @xmath110 direction . from the previous section we conclude that a single inclusion - defect pair can be fully described by @xmath111 $ ] , where @xmath112 is the position of the center of the inclusion ( no longer required to be at the origin ) , @xmath14 is the radius of the inclusion , @xmath8 tells us what the boundary condition is at the inclusion boundary , and @xmath113 we then found it convenient to code @xmath96 via @xmath114 . now we would like to calculate the free energy for a system of such inclusion - defect pairs , @xmath115})$ ] , where we assume that this description of multiple inclusions is valid when @xmath116 for all pairs @xmath117 . as we are now aware , each isolated inclusion - defect pair can be thought of purely in terms of the external topological defect and an arrangement of topological and logarithmic defects inside the inclusion . of course , when there is more than one inclusion , additional images must be introduced in the interior of each inclusion to satisfy boundary conditions . the full calculation of the energy is then reduced to calculating the energy from all of the topological charges and electric charges . as long as the inclusion - defect pairs are reasonably separated , however , one can obtain a good estimate of the energy by ignoring the contributions made by the additional image charges . the energy decomposes in a natural way into three pieces : the first is the contribution each individual inclusion - defect pair makes when its electric charge @xmath118 , the second is the contribution from the dipole - dipole interaction among the topological defects , and finally , the third is the total electrostatic energy arising from the electric charges : @xmath119\ } ) \approx \sum_i f_1(a_i , r_{di},\phi_{ai } ) \nonumber \\ & & + \sum_{i < j } 2 \pi k \left ( \frac{\pv_i \cdot \pv_j}{r_{ij}^2 } - \frac{2 ( \pv_i \cdot \rv_{ij } ) ( \pv_j \cdot \rv_{ij})}{r_{ij}^4 } \right ) \nonumber \\ & & + \pi k \left(\sum_i q_i\right ) \left(\sum_i q_i \log\left(\frac{r}{a_i}\right ) \right ) \nonumber \\ & & - \sum_{i < j } \pi k q_i q_j \log \left(\frac{r_{ij}^2}{a_i a_j}\right ) , \label{f_multi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath120 is defined by eq . ( [ f_r ] ) and @xmath121 . the second term is the dipole - dipole energy and the third and fourth are the electrostatic energy . again we emphasize that this is only an approximate form for the energy valid when the pairs are sufficiently for apart . to see the importance of the first electrostatic term in the energy we now turn to a more specific example . for simplicity we will assume that our system consists of only two inclusion - defect pairs : @xmath122 , [ r_s \ev_x , \pv_2 , a , -\pi/2]$ ] . we have taken the inclusions to have the same radii and to have the same normal boundary conditions . in addition we have placed one inclusion at the origin and the second at @xmath123 , where @xmath123 is parallel to the preferred orientation of the inclusion - defect dipoles ( fig . ( [ fluctuations ] ) ) . assuming that the magnitudes of the dipoles are fixed at the value for a single inclusion , @xmath124 , we can write @xmath125 where @xmath126 and @xmath127 ( note that @xmath128 so that @xmath129 ) . this implies each inclusion - defect pair carries an electric charge @xmath130 using eq . ( [ f_multi ] ) we can calculate @xmath131 & = & 2 f_1[(a , r_d,\frac{\pi}{2 } - \phi_a ) ] \\ \nonumber & + & 2 \pi k \left ( \frac{\pv_1 \cdot \pv_2}{r_s^2 } - \frac{2 ( \pv_1 \cdot \rv_s ) ( \pv_2 \cdot \rv_s)}{r_s^4 } \right ) , \\ \nonumber & + & \pi k ( q_1+q_2)^2 \log\left(\frac{r}{a}\right ) - 2 \pi k q_1 q_2 \log \left(\frac{r_s}{a}\right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where again the first term is simply twice the energy from eq.([f_r ] ) for a single inclusion with @xmath132 . taking @xmath133 and @xmath134 , we can simplify now to find @xmath135 & = & 2 f_1[(a , r_d,\frac{\pi}{2 } - \phi_a ) ] \\ \nonumber & + & - 2 \pi k \frac{p^2}{r_s^2 } \cos\left(2 q_{+ } \log\left(\frac{r}{a}\right ) \right ) \\ \nonumber & + & 2 \pi k q_{+}^2 \left ( \log \left(\frac{r}{a } \right ) + \log \left(\frac{r}{r_s } \right ) \right ) \\ \nonumber & + & 2 \pi k q_{-}^2 \log \left(\frac{r_s}{a } \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] we see immediately that @xmath136 is the minimum , which corresponds to @xmath137 where the dipoles are aligned with the @xmath77-axis . more interestingly we see that @xmath138 and @xmath139 are decoupled . the equipartition theorem then implies @xmath140 for the @xmath141 s we have , @xmath142 in the limit @xmath143 , fluctuations in @xmath138 tend to zero . the ratio of @xmath144 to @xmath145 , however , diverges so that in this limit , @xmath146 is finite and @xmath147 diverges . note that fluctuations in @xmath148 in the two inclusion system are much larger than fluctuations in @xmath96 for a single inclusion . of course , the ratio @xmath149 in a real system is such that @xmath150 is not much greater than @xmath151 . let us compare @xmath152 and @xmath153 to @xmath154 from equation ( [ del_phi ] ) for realistic values @xmath107 and @xmath155 . we find that @xmath156 and that @xmath157 . for @xmath106 this would correspond to angular fluctuations of a single dipole of approximately 40 degrees versus angular fluctuations of only 30 degrees for an isolated domain . furthermore we see that the fluctuations are highly correlated . thus we see that the presence of multiple domains can enhance the magnitude of the fluctuations a noticeable degree . had we not taken the separation vector to be in the direction of the far - field director we would have first been obliged to find the new equilibrium values for @xmath138 and @xmath139 . not surprisingly we would have found that the @xmath138 equilibrium value would no longer be zero , however the term in the energy for @xmath139 would remain the same . since the fluctuations in @xmath139 dominate the fluctuations in @xmath138 we would still expect the above observations concerning the magnitude of the fluctuations to be fairly accurate . furthermore , in the presence of many domains , the correlations between them may be quite complicated but we will still expect some enhancement in the angular fluctuations arising from those fluctuations which preserve electric charge neutrality . smectic - c films are adequately described by the @xmath0-@xmath31 model . circular inclusions in the film with appropriate boundary conditions carry a topological charge . global boundary conditions require the inclusions to nucleate companion topological defects out of the surrounding ordered medium , providing a good method for studying the properties of a small collection of defects . herein we have described how director configurations can be described systematically by externally nucleated topological defects and associated image defects lying within the inclusions , provided we allow for logarithmic as well as topological defects . the electric charge required is determined by the orientation of the topological dipole created by the inclusion and its companion and by the direction of the far - field director . the value of the electric charge fluctuates producing visible fluctuations of the position of the companion defect about its host inclusion . when multiple inclusions are present they interact through their topological and electric charge distributions . the topological dipole distributions associated with each inclusion - defect pair lead to a dipole - dipole interaction between them an to an alignment of the dipoles . however , thermal fluctuations of the dipole direction are large ( the fluctuations the companion about the host ) and carry electric charges with them . orientational fluctuations of the dipoles are coupled via the interaction of these electric charges . by far the strongest correlations arise from the overriding desire for global electric charge neutrality in the system ( the energy of an electric charge in @xmath0 diverges with the system size ) . we have presented detailed calculations describing this effect for the case of two inclusions , and have presented how to approach the problem for additional inclusions . we have considered here only the case of zero total topological charge brought about by parallel boundary conditions at infinity . if the @xmath1-director has some fixed angle relative to the outer boundaries of the sample , then the total topological charge is @xmath2 . in this case , a single inclusion will not force the nucleation of a companion defect . each additional inclusion will however , and there will be @xmath158 defects in a sample with @xmath24 inclusions . this is entirely analogous to the situation in multiple nematic emulsions where water droplets are captured inside spherical nematic drops t.c . lubensky and darren link thank noel clark for helpful discussions . the authors were supported primarily by the materials research science and engineering center program of nsf under award number dmr96 - 32598 . darren link acknowledges further support from nasa under nag3 - 1846 as well as support from the nsf under dmr96 - 14061 . we take the most general @xmath7 to be of the form @xmath159 it can be shown that @xmath160 and thus if we define @xmath161 then we have @xmath162 and we see that the two families of singularities do not interact . now recall that the potential for a line charge parallel to the @xmath163axis is @xmath164 where @xmath165 are the @xmath166 coordinates where the line pierces the @xmath167plane . thus , we can identify @xmath168 with a collection of line charges or equivalently @xmath0 electrostatic charges . next , noting that for any function @xmath169 we have @xmath170 we can define @xmath171 and note that @xmath172 interestingly , the vector potential for a line of magnetic charges parallel to the @xmath163axis piercing the @xmath167plane at @xmath165 is simply @xmath173 which corresponds precisely to the singularities in @xmath174 . equivalently we can view this as a magnetic charge in @xmath0 , just as we viewed the electrostatic line charge as a charge in @xmath0 electrostatics . now , making the final identification , @xmath175 we can write @xmath176 which looks just like the energy density for electromagnetism . furthermore , we can define electric and magnetic charge densities @xmath177 and then complete the electromagnetic analogy by writing @xmath178 this is why we have chosen to call the logarithmic singularities `` electric charges '' and the @xmath179 singularities `` magnetic charges '' . of course , in this analogy we have no reason to expect the lines of magnetic charge to be quantized , whereas in the original problem there is a clear explanation as to why the @xmath179 singularities are quantized ( the requirement that the physical field @xmath7 be single - valued ) . alternatively we could have exploited the fact that @xmath180 treated the @xmath179 singularities as a separate species of logarithmic singularities and viewed our free energy as being the sum of two distinct non - interacting electrostatic energies . caption fig.1 + + ( a ) a schematic overhead view of a generic circular inclusion , showing the relative positions of the physical and virtual defects , as well as the relationships between the far - field director , the director at the boundary of the inclusion and the direction of the topological dipole moment . the director @xmath1 is shown at the boundary and its angle with respect to the tangent vector @xmath181 measured in a counterclockwise fashion is @xmath8 . the direction of the dipole moment @xmath71 is given by the usual convention ( i.e. from negative to positive charges ) . we see from this and figure ( 2 ) that @xmath71 makes an angle of @xmath182 with respect to the far - field director . ( b ) an oblique view of a schematic representation of a film containing an inclusion consisting of one additional layer . the rods represent the actual nematogens in the film which are tilted with respect to the normal to the smectic planes . on the top plane the projection of the nematogens into the smectic plane is represented using the conventional nails with heads representation , where the head of the nail distinguishes which end of the projection into the plane corresponds to the end touching the plane . the companion defect is centered at the dark circle . the figure to the right indicates the two dimensional interpretation , consisting of the boundary of the circular inclusion , the direction of the far - field director as well as the orientation of the director at the boundary of the inclusion , the positions of the physical and virtual defects and the resulting topological dipole moment . ( c ) photograph of a four layer freely suspended smectic - c liquid crystal film with a circular five layer island of radius 75 microns . the companion @xmath3 defect is seen sitting outside the island . the collection of image charges is shown in the inset . the presence of only a single @xmath2 point defect in the center of the island in the photograph reminds us that the charges that the companion @xmath3 defect interacts with are image charges imposed by the boundary conditions and not real physical charges inside the island . as mentioned in the paper , the rigid boundary conditions along the dislocation separating the bulk from the interior of the island allows us to consider the regions independently . the visible @xmath3 defect has been observed undergoing large fluctuations in its radial position as well as its azimuthal orientation . + + caption fig.2 + + three examples of the director field @xmath1 around an inclusion for three different values of @xmath8 . the direction of @xmath71 is indicated . in each case we have placed the external defect at its preferred position , in particular @xmath183 and hence @xmath184 . the values of @xmath185 , the azimuthal position of the companion defect , are indicated . [ vfs_q ] shows examples of fields where @xmath96 is nonzero . also note that in each picture the far - field director is taken to be in the @xmath77 direction . + + caption fig.3 + + director configurations with nonzero values of @xmath96 . the far - field director is assumed to be in the positive @xmath74 direction , and @xmath76 . thus the equilibrium position of the companion defect is above the inclusion ( @xmath186 ) and the equilibrium direction of @xmath71 is down . in ( a ) @xmath187 and in ( b ) @xmath188 . compared to the equilibrium configuration of fig . 2(a ) , note the increasing distortion of the @xmath1-director as @xmath96 increases . the energy of ( b ) with @xmath71 pointing up is clearly higher than that with @xmath71 down . unlike @xmath4 nematics , there is a preferred direction rather than a preferred axis of orientation for @xmath71 . this is not surprising since a nematic is invariant under @xmath189 whereas a smectic - c is not invariant under @xmath190 . + + caption fig.4 + + above we have two interacting inclusions . the equilibrium configuration for the dipoles is represented by the solid arrows . the dashed arrows represent possible orientations of the dipoles due to thermal fluctuations . note the correlations in the directions of the dipole moments , when @xmath191 is tilted downward we expect to find @xmath192 tilted upward . | in thin films of smectic - c liquid crystals , localized regions containing additional smectic layers form circular inclusions that carry a topological charge . such inclusions nucleate a companion topological defect . these inclusion - defect pairs are modeled as topological dipoles within the context of a one - coupling constant approximation to the @xmath0 frank free energy . deviations of the dipole direction from a preferred orientation cause the dipoles to acquire a logarithmic charge . thermal fluctuations of the dipole direction are calculated and found to be large , scaling as the logarithm of the system size . in addition to dipole - dipole interactions arising from the topological charges , we also find that the thermal fluctuations of the dipole directions are coupled through a preference for global charge neutrality of the logarithmic charges . psfig corresponding author : david pettey + department of physics and astronomy + university of pennsylvania + philadelphia , pa 19104 |
1507.07519 | collagen is the single most abundant protein in the animal kingdom ; most of it occurs in the form of fibrous collagen such as collagen - i . a major component of tissue is disordered networks of fibrous collagen , i.e. collagen polymer gels . these networks are one of many important biological examples of athermal " biopolymer gels athermal means that the coiling of the stiff fibrils due to thermal fluctuations is negligible . these materials have remarkable mechanical properties : even though the constituents are in the linear elastic regime ( up to the yield point of the network ) , the network itself is nonlinear and strain - stiffening . for example , in dilute collagen - i gels the shear modulus increases by orders of magnitude as the strain increases @xcite . such nonlinear effects are important in biology , for example in the stiffening and alignment of tissue near a growing tumor @xcite . the unusual mechanical properties of collagen are believed to be intimately connected to two facts . first , the fibrils have a large stretching modulus , @xmath0 , and a small bending modulus , @xmath1 . more precisely , we define @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the mesh size of the network ; typically @xmath4 . for example , for collagen - i we can think of the fibrils as elastic rods . in the dilute case ( densities of order 2mg / ml ) @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the diameter of the fibrils and @xmath7 is the mesh size . second , the disordered structure of collagen can accommodate small deformations through bending the fibrils , but at large deformation , the bending modes are exhausted and the fibrils have to be stretched . owing to the huge difference between the bending and stretching stiffness of the fibrils , such a bending - to - stretching crossover lead to a dramatic increase of the elastic moduli@xcite . the existence of such a bending - to - stretching crossover is controlled by the physics of the central - force isostatic point ( cfip ) . the concept of cfip traces back to j. c. maxwell @xcite . he pointed out that the onset of mechanical instability for a system of particles with central force interactions occurs when the mean coordination number of bonds is twice the spatial dimension , @xmath8 . at this point the number of degrees of freedom , @xmath9 , and the number of constraints , @xmath10 , of each particle are the same @xcite . for @xmath11 there are soft floppy modes ; for @xmath12 there are redundant bonds and states of self - stress . thus the cfip is a critical point of a mechanical phase transition . biopolymer gels with @xmath13 can be thought of as a nearly central - force system if we identify the crosslinking points as the particles and the polymer fibrils between them as bonds . the coordination number @xmath14 depends on the type of gel . each crosslinking point can have a maximum coordination number @xmath15 , depending on the type of bonding . the most common situation , two polymers meeting at a crosslinking point , corresponds to @xmath16 ( collagen i belongs to this class ) . the average coordination number @xmath17 because of dangling ends . therefore , pure collagen i and similar biopolymer gels have mean coordination @xmath18 and are always below the cfip . in contrast , if a gel has crosslinking points with @xmath19 the gel can go above the cfip when the filaments are long . this may be the case for multi - component complex gels seen in extracellular matrix material . since the cfip is a critical point , it is natural to suspect that mechanical properties such as the shear modulus would exhibit scaling properties in its vicinity , and , indeed , for linear elasticity such scaling has been demonstrated @xcite . in this paper we extend scaling relations near the cfip to the nonlinear regime . as simplified models of real biopolymers we use simulations on two different disordered lattice models , the diluted triangular and kagome lattices ( see fig . [ fig : lattices ] ( a , b))@xcite . these two lattices have maximum coordination @xmath20 and @xmath16 ; they represent two classes of gels with @xmath19 and @xmath21 . we use these lattices to verify our scaling laws and to extract exponents . we discuss the application of the scaling regimes to more realistic biopolymer networks in sec . [ sec : concdisc ] . . the scaling form that has been proposed @xcite previously for the linear shear modulus , @xmath22 is : @xmath23 here @xmath24 is the extra coordination above the cfip and @xmath25 is a scaling function . the exponent @xmath26 captures the emergence of rigidity as coordination increases in the central - force system , and the crossover exponent @xmath27 captures the effect of @xmath28 as a relevant perturbation near isostaticity . this scaling law for the linear elasticity includes the observed effect that the elastic modulus of the gel can change dramatically when the connectivity is changed near the cfip . below the cfip the elasticity of the gel is bending dominant , @xmath29 , because it is floppy in the central - force limit . above the cfip the gel becomes stretching dominant @xmath30 . if @xmath19 there is a special regime where bending and stretching modes are strongly coupled , @xmath31 . this law has been shown to be valid using two and three dimensional disordered lattice models @xcite . we now turn to the nonlinear elasticity . a generalized scaling law should describe the very large strain - stiffening that is characteristic of these materials . as we discussed above , the physical origin of this effect is that gels in biological systems are often below the cfip ( @xmath32 ) . in the linear elasticity regime the shear modulus is proportional to the bending stiffness , @xmath1 , and is very small because the shear is accommodated in the floppy bending modes . as the deformation progress , the soft modes are stretched out and central - force paths form to bear the stress , increasing @xmath22@xcite . based on these ideas , we propose a two - parameter scaling law for the differential shear modulus : @xmath33 here @xmath34 is the shear strain , and the @xmath35 subscript labels the branches of the scaling function for @xmath36 and @xmath37 , respectively . this scaling law captures the stiffening effect of both the bending rigidity , @xmath1 , and of the strain , @xmath34 . a one - parameter version of this scaling relation for the nonlinear case has been previously proposed by wyart et al @xcite . these authors considered varying @xmath34 with fixed @xmath1 . they give numerical evidence that @xmath38 for jammed packings , and demonstrated the scaling of the crossover from linear to nonlinear behavior . our goal is to advance such scaling relations to include both the connectivity @xmath14 and the dimensionless bending stiffness @xmath28 as variables . we will collapse the whole elastic modulus curve with varying @xmath14 and @xmath28 , and analyze different elastic regimes . our results are summarized in figs . [ fig : final ] and [ fig : pd ] . the model lattices are the diluted triangular @xcite and kagome lattices @xcite , as shown in figure [ fig : lattices]ab . in both lattices each bond is present with probability @xmath39 . the undiluted triangular and kagome lattices have coordination numbers @xmath20 and @xmath16 respectively . it is straightforward to use maxwell s rule to find that the cfip is at @xmath40 , @xmath41 , respectively , at the mean - field level . in the triangular lattice there is a second - order rigidity percolation transition and the critical point is slightly lower than @xmath42 due to critical fluctuations @xcite . in the kagome case rigidity percolation is a first - order transition@xcite at @xmath43 . for these lattices @xmath44 . these models are representative members of two different classes of disordered networks as they approach the cfip . as above , we make contact with the mechanics of physical biopolymer gels by identifying the lattice sites as crosslinking points and bonds as fibrils between crosslinks . we write the elastic hamiltonian for our models as @xcite : @xmath45 the sum @xmath46 runs over all bonds and @xmath47 runs over pairs of bonds that are co - linear and share lattice site @xmath48 . we assign harmonic springs of spring constant @xmath0 for the bonds and bending stiffness @xmath1 to the bond pairs . in our simulations we minimize @xmath49 using conjugate gradient methods to get the elastic energy , @xmath50 . then we numerically measured the differential shear modulus , @xmath51 at various values of @xmath39 and @xmath1 . here @xmath52 is the total lattice area . to shear the networks , the horizontal boundaries to which the bonds are attached are translated with strain @xmath34 . we use periodic boundary conditions on the vertical boundaries and fixed boundary conditions on the horizontal boundaries . our network size is @xmath53 . examples of shear modulus data measured from our simulations before any scaling are shown in fig . [ fig : lattices]cd . it is clear from these curves that strain - stiffening is prominent when the network is diluted ( smaller @xmath39 ) . in order to test the scaling relation in eq . , we need to first determine the location of the cfip and the exponents @xmath26 and @xmath27 . for the triangular lattice , we follow the method of broedersz _ et al_@xcite to determine the location of the rigidity percolation point for our system size , @xmath54 . this involves looking for a peak of the nonaffinity parameter : @xmath55 in the central - force lattice ( @xmath56 ) . here @xmath57 labels the sites , @xmath58 is the displacement vector of the site , and @xmath59 is the displacement vector if the deformation would have been affine . we find that @xmath60 for the triangular lattice . next we determine the scaling exponents @xmath26 and @xmath27 . these can be extracted from the small @xmath34 ( linear elasticity ) limit . as shown in figure [ fig : linear ] ( a ) we find that @xmath61 for the triangular lattice , consistent with previous literature on the linear elasticity of this lattice @xcite . the cfip for the kagome lattice is at @xmath43 , and we can only observe @xmath62 . also , for this case , it is known @xcite that the transition is first order with @xmath41 ; thus we expect , and indeed find @xmath63 . our simulations show that @xmath64 , as shown in fig . [ fig : linear]b and consistent with previous literature on the linear elasticity of this lattice @xcite . to test the scaling law of eq . we can plot @xmath22 using scaled parameters : @xmath65 the scaling law predicts that @xmath66 collapses into a _ single surface _ as a function of @xmath67 for the correct critical exponents @xmath68 . however , to verify such three - dimensional scaling collapse in general is computationally expensive . instead , we make two types of plots using our simulation data . the first type of plot is at fixed @xmath28 , given in figure [ fig : fixedkappa ] . we obtain the expected complete collapse in the nonlinear ( stretching ) regime where the curves are predicted to be independent of @xmath69 . the second type of plot is to observe _ a slice _ of the scaling collapse in the three - dimensional space of @xmath70 . to do this , we take a given finite value of @xmath71 . in practice , this correspond to taking the value of @xmath72 which changes as @xmath39 changes so that @xmath69 is fixed in the simulation . recall that @xmath27 has already been determined from the linear regime . as a result the shear modulus data completely collapses for both lattices according to our two - parameter scaling , as shown in figure [ fig : final ] . in particular , for the triangular lattice @xmath73 lies on two branches , corresponding to @xmath74 and @xmath62 . from these plots we find that @xmath75 for the triangular lattice and @xmath76 for the kagome lattice . . we should take note of a detail in the fitting procedure that we and others have used @xcite . we are , in fact , never extremely close to the critical point , because sufficiently near to @xmath77 there is a non - scaling feature in the shear modulus , a dip . we found this for both our lattice models , and it has been observed by others@xcite . it occurs in models which have explicit buckling@xcite for fibrils under compression ; of course , real biopolymers buckle as well . the reason is easy to see . euler buckling is a pitchfork bifurcation as the compressive strain on an elastic beam varies . thus we expect that the elastic energy near the buckling threshold , @xmath78 will have the classic form @xmath79 . the second derivative of the energy is the shear modulus , so we expect @xmath80 as we pass through the threshold . the background modulus increases , so we should see a dip in @xmath81 . the common way @xcite to introduce buckling in model fiber networks is to introduce an extra node in the middle of each link which can bend with a small bending modulus . there is a pitchfork bifurcation at a threshold just as in the case of a continuous elastic beam . in our models , although we do not have such buckling at the bond level , the crosslinking points represent internal degrees of freedom of the filaments and also exhibit a buckling instability . nevertheless , why these show up as a sharp dip near @xmath77 remains a puzzle to us . with these results in hand , we can speculate about their applicability to other lattice models and to physical systems . based on our results , we can discern at least two different classes of scaling behavior with different exponents , though both obey eq . ( [ eq : gfull ] ) . we show the schematic phase diagrams for these two classes in fig . [ fig : pd ] . in the first case , exemplified by the diluted triangular lattice , we have a network that can vary through the cfip as a parameter is changed . biopolymer gels with @xmath19 belong to this class . some dense forms of collagen , such as tendons and cartilage may also belong to this class . in this case @xmath19 so that we can tune through @xmath82 . then we have various regimes implied by eq . ( [ eq : gfull ] ) : * a linear bending regime when @xmath83 . this regime is described by linear elasticity so @xmath84 is independent of @xmath85 . this regime is bending dominated : @xmath86 * a linear coupled regime when @xmath87 while @xmath88 . this regime is also described by linear elasticity ; @xmath84 is independent of @xmath85 . also , it is in a critical regime ( @xmath89 ) so @xmath22 should be independent of @xmath90 . thus : @xmath91 * a nonlinear regime when @xmath92 while keeping @xmath93 . this regime characterizes nonlinear elasticity as the strain goes beyond a `` turning point '' @xmath94 . the turning point approaches @xmath95 as to @xmath96 meaning that near the cfip the linear elasticity regime vanishes . it is reasonable to hypothesize that in this regime @xmath22 is independent of @xmath90 and @xmath69 so that : @xmath97 our simulation data verifies this hypothesis . * the stretching regime . this includes a small - strain stretching - dominated regime when @xmath36 and @xmath98 , and a large - strain stretching - dominant regime when @xmath99 and the bending modes are all stretched out . here the elasticity is controlled by the stretching stiffness @xmath0 : @xmath100 the other category , for which the diluted kagome lattice is an example , has @xmath101 and a first - order central - force rigidity transition at @xmath41 and @xmath63 . in this case we have two regimes : * a linear bending regime when @xmath102 ( in this case we always have @xmath37 ) so that : @xmath103 * the stretching regime , including small - strain part @xmath89 and large - strain part @xmath104 . in this regime deformations are dominated by stretching of fibers and @xmath105 the linear coupled regime and the nonlinear regime are missing because they are consequences of a continuous transition at @xmath82 . as a result the crossover to stretching as strain increases is more abrupt in these lattices . many three - dimensional fiber - networks including dilute collagen i , have @xmath106 . for this case , the central - force network is not rigid even at @xmath43 . as in the kagome case , scaling law predicts a linear bending regime crossing over to stretching at either large @xmath1 or large @xmath34 . this is consistent with numerical results on three - dimensional models @xcite . we can relate experimental results to our models by focusing on three dimensionless numbers . the first one is the maximum coordination of the crosslinkers @xmath15 which determines which type of the phase diagrams applies . the second one is @xmath28 which can be deduced , for example , from the young s modulus and the shape of individual fibers . the simplest case of this estimate has been given above . the third one is @xmath39 . for a network made up of fibers of mean length @xmath107 it is easy to see that the relation between mesh size @xmath3 and fiber length @xmath107 is : @xmath108 . this allows us to estimate the effective bond dilution from data . with these three numbers one can sketch the phase diagram and determine which regime the experimental system belongs to . in addition , it is also interesting to compare our theory to other types of gels with less stiff filaments and thus stronger thermal fluctuations . a different mechanism of strain - stiffening has been proposed in the literature attributing strain stiffening to stretching out thermal undulations of polymers @xcite . this is relevant for gels composed of filaments such as actin or elastin which have persistence length comparable or smaller than the mesh size , so considerable thermal undulations present , thus providing a regime of entropic elasticity at small strain . although for these gels stretching out thermal undulations contribute to the strain - stiffening , if the gel is below the cfip ( which is true for most bio - polymer gels ) , the bending modes still need to be stretched out in addition to the thermal undulations before the gel enters true stretching - dominant elasticity regime . during the preparation of our manuscript , we learned about two recent preprints @xcite which use a combination of experimental and simulation tools to investigate nonlinear elasticity . both of these preprints mainly focus on the nonlinear shear modulus as bending stiffness @xmath1 varies while keeping the connectivity @xmath109 fixed . in contrast , our study obtained full collapse of shear modulus in the more general case of varying both @xmath1 and @xmath109 . moreover , we also identify various regimes of nonlinear elasticity in a three - dimensional phase diagram of connectivity , bending stiffness , and strain . we acknowledge informative discussions with f. c. mackintosh , c. p. broedersz . j - c feng is supported by the national science foundation center for theoretical biological physics ( grant phy-1427654 ) . the work of hl was supported in part by the cancer prevention and research institute of texas ( cprit ) scholar program of the state of texas at rice university . | disordered biopolymer gels have striking mechanical properties including strong nonlinearities . in the case of athermal gels ( such as collagen - i ) the nonlinearity has long been associated with a crossover from a bending dominated to a stretching dominated regime of elasticity . the physics of this crossover is related to the existence of a central - force isostatic point and to the fact that for most gels the bending modulus is small . this crossover induces scaling behavior for the elastic moduli . in particular , for linear elasticity such a scaling law has been demonstrated [ broedersz _ et al . nature physics _ , 2011 * 7 * , 983 ] . in this work we generalize the scaling to the nonlinear regime with a two - parameter scaling law involving three critical exponents . we test the scaling law numerically for two disordered lattice models , and find a good scaling collapse for the shear modulus in both the linear and nonlinear regimes . we compute all the critical exponents for the two lattice models and discuss the applicability of our results to real systems . |
1412.6005 | the subject here are the standard maxwell s equations and their inability to handle a lot of situations that in the common practice are instead considered trivial . the main criticism is that the system is overdetermined , i.e. , solutions must satisfy too many constraints without enjoying the necessary degrees of freedom . the discovery of these inconsistencies was made about ten years ago , when i started a review process of the theory of electromagnetism . the underlying motivation was based on some unsatisfactory marginal aspects . nevertheless , in the development of the analysis , these aspects became much more relevant . the result was a renewed model ( see @xcite , @xcite ) that strictly includes the solutions to maxwell s equations , thus providing the description of a wider range of events . in particular , non - dissipating compact - support electromagnetic waves , travelling straightly at the speed of light , are very easily modelled by the new set of equations . the importance of this fact is high if we realize that one of the reasons for the split of physics into the classical and the quantum versions is actually the impossibility to represent photons via maxwell s equations in vacuum . indeed , an initially localized wave - packet , whose fields are successively modelled by maxwell s equations , is soon destroyed , diffusing all around . it is not my intention to further self - celebrate here the potentiality of my extension and the possible implications in the study of the quantum world by a classical approach . for further insight the reader is referred to @xcite . criticizing maxwell s equations is dangerous . one is immediately relegated as heretic . on the other hand , the power of mathematical reasoning can not be ignored . after publishing my first report ( @xcite ) , i was contacted by dr . w. engelhardt ( see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . he was puzzled by the excessive number of constraints that a maxwellian solution has to satisfy . by trying to impose all of them one inevitably comes to contradictions . usually , engineers follow a certain computational path in order to come out with solutions mimicking as much as possible reality . when a reasonable output is obtained they do not feel it is necessary to check if further restrictions apply . it is like storing all of @xmath1 objects inside @xmath2 boxes ( one object per box ) . there are several paths one can follow , but none is going to be resolutive . a dirty trick is to hide the last object ( whatever it is ) and show to the public one of the allowed combinations . due to its linearity , it is easy to prove that the maxwell s system must have , under very mild assumptions , at most one solution ( uniqueness ) . the work of engelhardt shows that there may be different solutions to the same given problem . how can this happen ? in reality , the problem imposes @xmath1 constraints and turns out to be impossible ; however , by applying @xmath2 steps of the solution process one can actually get something meaningful . that `` something '' depends on the constraint that has been discarded . engelhardt writes the electromagnetic unknowns in terms of the potentials @xmath3 and @xmath4 and notes that different conclusions are reached according to the choice of the _ gauge _ , notwithstanding that the gauge has no influence on the expression of maxwell s equations . the conclusion that there are different solutions contradicts uniqueness . this nonsense can only be justified by deducing that none of the solutions proposed is correct , not because of a mistake in the computation , but because they result from an incomplete procedure and that a full resolution does not exists . this observation casts dark clouds on the maxwellian theory . in this short note i would like to study in the easiest possible way a very simple problem : the charge of a capacitor . solving the wave equation for the electric field i get a solution incompatible with ampre s law . a similar question was examined in @xcite via retarded potentials . there the author points out inconsistencies between the wave equation and the faraday s law . hence , the analysis of the distribution of an electromagnetic field inside a capacitor depends on the way the problem is presented . in the quasi - stationary regime ( current flow is relatively slow ) the magnetic contribution is usually neglected . if higher modes are invoked , the full system of maxwell s equations must be involved . in this fashion , according to the nature of the phenomenon , one picks up the right tool to operate , consisting of @xmath2 relations chosen on purpose . very often the outcome is convincing . if little troubles emerge they are attributed to some unavoidable inaccuracy dictated by the limits of the model . however , the question is deeper : the model itself is not mathematically correct when taken with all its constraints . one could find rigorous mathematical outcomes by getting rid of one constraint at the time , but at this point there is no a unique theory of electromagnetism . in @xcite , the limit of the maxwellian theory is attributed to the presence of nonhomogeneous terms . in my opinion , as rigorously analyzed in @xcite , even homogeneous maxwell s equations in vacuum are not trouble free , displaying an extremely reduced space of solutions . the equations in this case are affected by an almost total lack of initial displacements satisfying both the conditions @xmath5 and @xmath6 ( see my viewpoint in @xcite , chapter 1 ) . it must be honestly pointed out however that the solution s space of maxwell s equations is far from being empty . there are in fact remarkable situations where the model has mathematical meaning and matches reality . solutions seem however to belong to a kind of _ meagre set_. this set looks closed , connected and with zero measure ( with respect to standard topologies in functional spaces ) , though i have no rigorous proof of these statements . common applications , as the one studied here , belong to the _ complementary set _ and can not be approximated by maxwellian solutions . my conclusion is that , despite of the extraordinary achievements of the technological world , maxwell s equations are inefficacious in most practical cases , unless they are accompanied by rough and non well justified mathematical adaptations . in order to make the problem as simplest as possible let us suppose we are in vacuum , though this restriction is not necessary . maxwell s equations include the ampre s law : @xmath7 where we set the current source term equal to zero . moreover , we have the faraday s law of induction : @xmath8 and the two following conditions on the divergence of the fields : @xmath9 @xmath10 putting all together , there are six unknowns and eight equations . relations ( [ fde1 ] ) and ( [ fdb1 ] ) are often taken as an optional . for example , if one assumes that @xmath5 holds at initial time @xmath11 , it follows from ( [ fem1 ] ) that the divergence of the electric field must be zero at all times . it is enough to compute the divergence of both terms in equality ( [ fem1 ] ) to obtain : @xmath12 the above passage is mathematically correct . however , it is source of big mistakes . from expression ( [ dfem1 ] ) we presume that it is not necessary to check whether equation @xmath5 is maintained during time evolution . nevertheless , it would be wise not to be much confident on this fact . we shall demonstrate through a simple example that @xmath13 can instead spontaneously assume values different from zero , mining the foundations of the ampre s law in vacuum . we assume that our functions are regular , so that they can be differentiated as many times as needed . it is easy to recover the following equation regarding the time variation of the electromagnetic energy : @xmath14 here @xmath15 is the poynting vector . to get ( [ poyn ] ) one scalarly multiplies ( [ fem1 ] ) by @xmath16 , ( [ fbm1 ] ) by @xmath17 , and uses notions of standard calculus . the electric field satisfies the wave equation : @xmath18 which is obtained by observing that : @xmath19 therefore , relation ( [ fde1 ] ) is necessary in order to get ( [ wave ] ) . the wave equation also holds for the magnetic field @xmath17 . in addition , there are initial conditions and boundary constraints . the discussion of these is a crucial issue . there are several ways to impose boundary conditions . commonly , a list of possible choices is presented ( see , e.g. , @xcite , section i.5 , or @xcite , section 11.6.1 ) . one can then pick up the ones that better fit the phenomenon to be studied . as in the case of the wave equation ( [ wave ] ) , there is the tendency to transform the first - order system ( [ fem1 ] ) , ( [ fbm1 ] ) into a second - order one . playing with second - order derivatives in the space variables is much easier and the _ well - posedness _ of the problem generally follows from properties of the laplace operator . in this circumstance , boundary conditions are naturally derived from a solid theory . it is to be noticed however that the choice of the constraints for an elliptic operator is not equivalent to that of a system of hyperbolic equations , where a preliminary study of the _ characteristic lines _ should be done in order to detect which part of the boundary is actually involved . this analysis looks quite difficult in the context of maxwell s equations , where the notions of characteristic curves and wave - fronts are in most cases not very clear . for practical applications , the nature of the boundary constraints comes from physical considerations , sometimes without worrying about the mathematics . it is not rare to see cases where boundary conditions are under - determined , and others in which boundary conditions are over - determined . nevertheless , this does not seem to cause any sort of ethical problem . as far as the results are in agreement with reality there is no reason to suspect the possibility of spurious solutions or that the entire formulation is inconsistent . by examining a specific case , let us review what possibilities are offered regarding equation ( [ wave ] ) . for a given smooth bi - dimensional domain @xmath20 , we consider a capacitor where the two plates , shaped as @xmath20 , are parallel and placed at a distance @xmath21 . the vertical direction is the @xmath22-axis and the plates are situated at the positions @xmath23 and @xmath24 . we assume to work with an _ ideal capacitor_. this means that the electric field stays perpendicular to each plate surface and that the charge can be uniformly modified on the plates . as initial condition we impose ( capacitor completely uncharged ) : @xmath25 since @xmath26 , one has @xmath27 for @xmath11 . thanks to ( [ fem1 ] ) , one must have : @xmath28 we are going to show that the wave equation for the electric field has unique solution ( which is not however a proof for existence ) . if there were two distinct solutions , their difference would satisfy the wave equation with homogeneous data . consequently , we impose the initial conditions in ( [ initd ] ) , dirichlet homogeneous conditions on the upper and the lower plates , and conditions in ( [ rote ] ) on the lateral surface . it is possible to show ( see below ) that , with these constrictions , the only admissible case is @xmath16 identically zero everywhere at every time . therefore , the difference of two solutions has to vanish identically , and this is against the hypothesis that they are distinct . the uniqueness of the vector wave equation follows from the conservation of a suitable energy . by extending the proof given in @xcite , p. 83 , to the vector case , one scalarly multiplies both members of ( [ wave ] ) by @xmath45 and integrates on the whole domain : @xmath46 } \frac{\partial { \bf e}}{\partial t } \cdot\frac{\partial^2 { \bf e}}{\partial t^2}= -c^2\int_{\omega\times [ 0,d ] } \frac{\partial { \bf e}}{\partial t } \cdot { \rm curl}{\rm curl}{\bf e}+ c^2\int_{\omega\times [ 0,d ] } \frac{\partial { \bf e}}{\partial t}\cdot\nabla { \rm div}{\bf e}\ ] ] where we recalled ( [ curldel ] ) . note that @xmath47 on the boundaries @xmath48 and @xmath49 ( lower and upper plates ) . by assuming that @xmath29 is the outer normal , green s formulas yield : @xmath50 } \left ( \frac{\partial { \bf e } } { \partial t}\right)^{\hspace{-.1cm}2 } ~+~c^2 \int_{\omega\times [ 0,d ] } ( { \rm curl}{\bf e})^2 ~+~c^2\int_{\omega\times [ 0,d ] } ( { \rm div}{\bf e})^2\right]\ ] ] @xmath51 @xmath52 } \frac{\partial { \bf e } } { \partial t } \cdot ( { \rm curl}{\bf e}\times { \bf n})~+~ c^2\int_{\partial\omega\times [ 0,d ] } \frac{\partial}{\partial t}\left ( { \bf e}\cdot { \bf n}\right ) { \rm div}{\bf e}\ ] ] all the terms on the right - hand side are zero by virtue of the homogeneous boundary conditions ( note in particular that @xmath53 on the lower and upper sides ) . on the left - hand side we have the time derivative of a non negative quantity . due to the initial conditions , such a quantity is zero at the beginning . hence , it will remain zero forever . one easily finds out that the only compatible solution is @xmath54 identically . for this last check , boundary conditions must be used one more time . note that the role of the one - dimensional boundaries @xmath55 and @xmath56 is negligible ( in presence of regular solutions , at least ) . the above reasoning is quite standard , especially in the framework of finite element approximations , where the theory is constructed on a weak formulation having the associated energy similar to the one considered here . let us suppose for example that @xmath16 is forced to be zero on the lower and upper plates ( homogeneous dirichlet conditions ) . one gets , after integrating ( [ poyn ] ) in the entire domain : @xmath67 } ( \vert { \bf e}\vert^2 + c^2\vert { \bf b}\vert^2 ) ~=~- c^2 \int_{\omega\times [ 0,d]}{\rm div}({\bf e}\times { \bf b})\ ] ] @xmath68}({\bf e}\times { \bf b})\cdot { \bf n}~=~0\ ] ] where we used the divergence theorem with @xmath29 directed outward . the last term is zero because of ( [ rotem ] ) . according to ( [ poyni ] ) , the electromagnetic energy , initially zero , will stay zero during time evolution . this says that the maxwell s system admits unique solution . by assuming @xmath5 , we multiply equation ( [ wave ] ) by @xmath45 and integrate , obtaining through the usual passages : @xmath50 } \left ( \frac{\partial { \bf e } } { \partial t}\right)^{\hspace{-.1cm}2 } ~+~c^2 \int_{\omega\times [ 0,d ] } ( \vert \nabla e_x\vert^2 + \vert \nabla e_y\vert^2 + \vert \nabla e_z\vert^2 ) \right]\ ] ] @xmath70 } \left ( \frac{\partial e_x}{\partial t}\frac{\partial e_x}{\partial { \bf n } } + \frac{\partial e_y}{\partial t}\frac{\partial e_y}{\partial { \bf n } } + \frac{\partial e_z}{\partial t}\frac{\partial e_z}{\partial { \bf n } } \right ) ~=~0\ ] ] where we imposed ( [ neum ] ) and homogeneous dirichlet conditions on the plates . again , we deduce an uniqueness result . we apply to a concrete case the situation examined in the previous section . the two plates , initially short - circuited , are successively subjected to a difference of potential . as far as the initial and boundary condition are concerned , we assume ( [ initd ] ) and ( [ rote ] ) . moreover , for any @xmath71 : @xmath72 where @xmath73 is a given function with @xmath74 and @xmath75 . thus , the charge starts flowing smoothly on the plates , based on a difference of potential equal to @xmath76 . for symmetry reasons , we can set the ground at level @xmath77 . with respect to the lines of force of the electric field , for @xmath73 positive the lower surface is an _ inflow boundary _ , while the upper surface is an _ outflow boundary_. the total flux through the boundaries is zero , so that the integral of @xmath13 on the whole domain is also zero . we omit to specify the boundary conditions for @xmath17 , since there is no need for them , as it will emerge from the analysis . in the context of smooth functions , the solutions to the maxwell s system belong to a subset of those satisfying the wave equation ( [ wave ] ) . we can construct an explicit solution by setting @xmath78 , where @xmath79 does not depend on @xmath80 and @xmath81 . in this fashion , we have : @xmath82 with ( see the last relation in ( [ rotec ] ) ) : @xmath83 @xmath84 @xmath85 the explicit expression of ( [ wavez ] ) is not elementary but it is recoverable through fourier series expansion . a theory in the framework of sobolev spaces can be found for instance in @xcite , section 7.2 , or in @xcite , p. 345 . such a solutions turns out to be smooth in the domain including the boundary . due to the uniqueness theorem cited in the previous section , there are no other possible choices for @xmath16 . hence , we also found the solution to the maxwell s problem . at this point we notice that the function @xmath79 is not certainly constant with respect to @xmath22 . in fact , the setting @xmath86 , @xmath87 $ ] , is in general incompatible with equation ( [ wavez ] ) , because @xmath88 . therefore , the partial derivative @xmath89 is different from zero almost everywhere . in the end , we have : @xmath90 we just discovered that the solutions to our vector wave equation can not be divergenceless . as a consequence , independently on how we define the magnetic field , there are no chances to solve the entire set of maxwell s equations . this is true for any set @xmath20 , for any @xmath21 and for any function @xmath73 ( with zero derivative at the origin ) ; too many degrees of freedom to argue that this is just incidental . the problem we proposed has very smooth solutions , hence the idea that things may improve by converting it into variational form is hopeless . in truth , using a general _ test function _ in ( [ wave2 ] ) , a variational formulation is soon obtained , which can be automatically extended to functions belonging to suitable sobolev spaces . by the above procedure , the magnetic field turns out to be totally unspecified . as already noticed , the electric field remains parallel to the @xmath22-axis and does not depend on @xmath80 and @xmath81 . the only reasonable choice compatible with such a behavior of the electric field is @xmath26 everywhere at all times . this is again in contradiction with ( [ fem1 ] ) since we know that @xmath91 . the case @xmath92 is more difficult to handle , but this preliminary analysis induces us to guess that conclusions can not be too much different . time periodic conditions applied at the plates are not compatible with ( [ initd ] ) . however , even starting from @xmath92 , after a transient , the function @xmath73 may assume a given oscillating behavior , resulting asymptotically in a periodic evolution of the internal fields ( see figure 1 ) . at this point , one may argue that the wave equation approach requires too strong boundary conditions . perhaps , by weakening the insulation condition at the lateral sides one can enlarge the solution space and obtain situations that are compatible with @xmath93 . so , we just enforce @xmath94 , forgetting the other constraints and losing the uniqueness result for the wave equation . unfortunately , this weaker hypothesis is again inconsistent with maxwell s equations . to prove such a negative claim we follow very classical arguments . we work in the neighborhood of the lower plate @xmath95 . due to ( [ conv ] ) , we have : @xmath96 @xmath97 thanks to ( [ derze ] ) , the third component of the wave equation satisfies ( [ wavez ] ) for all @xmath98 , when restricted to @xmath99 . moreover , the @xmath93 condition implies : @xmath100 in conclusion , one obtains : @xmath101 therefore , near the surface , one gets the taylor expansion : @xmath102 for instance , let us assume that @xmath73 has a quadratic growth ( though similar considerations will hold for a more general choice ) : @xmath103 . the expression of @xmath79 for @xmath22 sufficiently small becomes @xmath104 . we now take @xmath1050,d]$ ] and consider the domain @xmath106 $ ] . the divergence of @xmath16 is zero inside there . the lateral boundary is insulated , i.e. @xmath107 , hence the incoming flux in @xmath108 must equate the outgoing flux in @xmath109 . if @xmath110 is suitably small this is impossible since @xmath111 uniformly in @xmath20 for @xmath23 , which is less than @xmath112 for @xmath113 . again we arrive at a contradiction . it is worthwhile to notice that , in the proof given above , the zero divergence condition has been recalled both locally ( via ( [ cv1 ] ) ) and globally ( gauss s law applied to the box @xmath106 $ ] ) . this paradox tells us that there are troubles at the constitutive level . relation ( [ dfem1 ] ) states that condition @xmath114 must be preserved at all times , while we discovered that this can not be true . where is the mistake ? the wrong assumption is in the writing of the ampre s law in vacuum , where the generic vector @xmath45 is supposed to be the _ curl _ of another vector . this is not necessarily true . by dropping this hypothesis one discovers that , even in absence of currents due to independent charges , there might be a sort of flow - field with the property @xmath115 . one may try a correction by rewriting equation ( [ fem1 ] ) as : @xmath116 where the added forcing term substitutes the boundary conditions , that now become of homogeneous type . this consideration does not help , since the new term is also the _ curl _ of a vector ( take for instance @xmath117 ) . to justify that relation @xmath115 is physically admissible one can rely on the finiteness of the speed of light @xmath118 , which rules the transfer velocity of the information between the two plates . as one modifies the difference of potential , the electric field inside the capacitor has to be redistributed ( recall that , in the path we followed , the magnetic field remains equal to zero ) . this happens at speed @xmath118 , in contrast with coulomb s law ( represented by the gauss s law ) that requires the information to travel at infinite speed . the only way for a field of the form @xmath119 to establish a communication between the plates is to create compression and rarefaction waves by varying its divergence . note however that the integral of @xmath13 on the entire domain remains always zero , so that sources and wells are in perfect equilibrium . these observations , based on elementary arguments , tell us that a rethinking of the equations ruling electrodynamics is unavoidable . at this point , some readers may argue that the insulating condition @xmath107 is too `` artificial '' and made on purpose to guide the internal field along vertical lines of force . in order to answer this possible question , first of all , we remark that , in the framework of 3d geometries , imposing @xmath107 does not necessarily mean that @xmath16 must be vertical ( this is a consequence of the resolution of the wave equation ) . secondly , we propose to remove the boundary conditions in ( [ rote ] ) and replace them by ( [ neum ] ) . a uniqueness theorem for the wave equation is still guaranteed ( see the end of section 2 ) . in the new setting , @xmath16 could in principle assume configurations that are more similar to those of a charged capacitor in a stationary regime , i.e. , with curved lines of force that are more pronounced at the rim of the plates . by the way , such an improvement is only illusory . indeed , let us consider again @xmath78 ( with @xmath79 not depending on @xmath80 and @xmath81 ) satisfying the one - dimensional equation ( [ wavez ] ) . such a solution also satisfies ( [ neum ] ) , therefore it is the unique solution to the vector wave equation ( [ wave ] ) equipped with the new set of boundary constraints . we know that @xmath16 is not of maxwellian type since its divergence is not zero . we also know that @xmath17 remains equal to zero when time passes . thus , starting from @xmath54 and @xmath120 at time @xmath11 , there is no development of horizontal component of @xmath16 during the charging process . such a conclusion seems counterintuitive . every physicist would bet that there is a mistake in the reasoning . on the other hand , this is just a correct mathematical results which is a consequence of having approached the problem from a nonstandard perspective . here the study of a dynamical situation provides results apparently not in agreement with the stationary case . as claimed in the introduction , there are many different paths one may follow and they depend on what information one would like to extrapolate . although some partial results could be reasonably in agreement with the physical phenomenon under study , others may not . in any case the final answer is often contradictory . one may finally wonder about the possibility to replace ( [ neum ] ) by weaker hypotheses , as done for the case of the insulated wall . the aim is to allow the creation of a nontrivial field @xmath17 with the consequent generation of curved lines of force for the electric field . at the same time , the hope is to restore the zero divergence condition . the risk is to invalid the uniqueness theorem for maxwellian solutions . certainly , one may think that there are infinite ways the magnetic field can grew up in the capacitor s charging procedure , as there are infinite ways the electric field may be deformed . distinguishing among these solutions may require unusual physical considerations that are not comprised in the standard theory of electrodynamics . nevertheless , such a risk does not occur , since , even with a total lack of information on the lateral boundary , we are able to end up with a nonexistence result . the proof is simple . let us recall relation ( [ cv3 ] ) and for simplicity take @xmath121 . near the surface @xmath99 , the electric field is of the form : @xmath122 , neglecting second - order infinitesimals . this is true for any @xmath98 . at level @xmath113 ( for @xmath123 fixed and sufficiently small ) , by computing the divergence one gets : @xmath124 where the approximation holds up to first - order infinitesimals . the crucial step is now to observe that , since the capacitor is initially uncharged , for @xmath98 small enough the sum of @xmath125 and @xmath126 can not be equal to the fixed number @xmath127 . thus , we arrived at another absurdity . this check shows that there is conflict between boundary constraints , the wave equation and the divergence - free condition , pointing out once again the inconsistency of the model . note that hypotheses here are really very mild . in particular , it is sufficient to have the boundary condition @xmath128 only in a 2d region ( of any size ) included in @xmath99 . we do not deny that there are interesting solutions of the full set of equations , but they look dotted islands in the ocean of electromagnetic phenomena ( see the introduction ) . one can try to `` hide '' the above evidences and argue as follows ( the @xmath2-steps - instead - of-@xmath129 technique mentioned in the introduction ) . faraday s and ampre s laws can be advanced in time . they have good physical justification , so the solution will naturally find its path , reproducing within a certain accuracy the phenomenon . thanks to ( [ dfem1 ] ) , there is no necessity to check what happens to the divergence of the electric field . one hopes that nobody will discover that , in some small remote region of the plates , @xmath16 will grow up in such a way that @xmath130 is not of curl - type , disregarding ampre s law . a nonzero divergence starts developing and at this point the link with maxwell s equations is definitely lost . if somebody asks to explain the reason of a non vanishing divergence , an evasive answer is that such a divergence is negligible in practical cases . that is why is hard to convince the public of the unreliability of the maxwell s model . we propose the following experiment . the difference of potential between the plates is increased quadratically for a given interval of time , after which is kept constant . the information propagates from the boundary to the interior and the third component @xmath79 follows the wave equation ( [ wavez ] ) . as we stop the increasing of potential , the field continues to develop and assumes an oscillating behavior . the plots of figure 1 , obtained from a simple numerical test , show that after a transient where the distribution monotonically grows ( solid lines ) , a periodic regime follows ( dashed lines ) . we do not specify all the parameters of the test , since the purpose here is to comment the qualitative behavior . in particular , the intensity of the field inside the capacitor assumes values that are greater than the ones attained at the boundary . by denoting with @xmath131 the area of @xmath20 , the capacitance is given by @xmath132 , while the stored energy is given by : @xmath133 where @xmath134 is the difference of potential and @xmath135 is the measure of the volume of the capacitor . in ( [ enec ] ) it is assumed that , at stationary regime , the electric field inside the capacitor is uniformly equal to @xmath136 . we also know that the quantity @xmath137 denotes the energy density of the electromagnetic field . in the case we are examining , this energy integrated over the volume of the capacitor is : @xmath138 . as we notice before , this last quantity can be bigger than the one predicted by ( [ enec ] ) . of course , perfect capacitors as the one we are studying here do not exist in reality and this strangeness is not noticed in practice . nevertheless , such a suspicious theoretical result provides us with another indication that the ruling equation have flaws or , at least , that the definition of the energy stored by a capacitor is lacunary . behavior with respect to time of the function @xmath79 . boundary conditions are increased quadratically and suddenly stopped . as the wave equation predicts , non dissipating oscillations are developed . in the _ two - capacitors paradox _ ( see , e.g. , @xcite , vol . 2 , p. 684 ) , the charge present at the plates of a capacitor of capacitance @xmath139 is redistributed by adding another capacitor in parallel of capacitance @xmath139 ( the new total capacity is then @xmath140 ) . this implies that the initial voltage @xmath141 is halved . the initial stored energy is @xmath142 while the final one is @xmath143 . thus , half of the energy mysteriously disappears . explanations of this fact have been proposed copiously . the principal track for the investigation is the analysis of losses in the charge transfer procedure . this includes : heating of the connecting wire , self inductance of the circuit ( see @xcite ) , electromagnetic emission , etc . what emerges from this paper is rather the urgent need of restating basic formulas . the stored energy in ( [ enec ] ) is only part of the total energy that also contains the kinetic of the fields inside the capacitors . such a dynamics in inevitably produced by the redistribution of the charges . by assuming energy conservation , internal oscillations do not dump and must contribute to the total energy . a correction of ( [ enec ] ) should include this option . a similarity can be made with a perfect elastic ball , that initially is at rest at distance @xmath144 from the ground ( pure gravitational potential energy ) . the ball successively drops and bounces back . a barrier is posed at level @xmath145 before the ball can reach again level @xmath144 . oscillations develop between the ground and level @xmath145 , where the potential energy is half of the initial one . however , there is no energy loss , since one has to take into account the nonzero kinetic energy when the ball hits the upper obstacle . formula ( [ enec ] ) is only valid in the pure stationary case , so its application in the dynamical description of the charge transfer between two capacitors is incorrect . in practical applications , the oscillations decay in a finite time due to some internal energy dissipation . this loss of energy must be added to the one arising from the external circuitry . after an appropriate interval of time , the total amount of lost energy is , as correctly predicted , equal to half of the initial energy . this result is not as suspicious as before : if from one hand , we have the right to suppose that the dissipation due to the outer circuit is negligible , on the other hand we must handle the dissipation of the internal oscillations in some appropriate way . i am sure that following the above discussion many experts will start providing their explanations . an ideal capacitor does not exist . charges are fluctuating on the plates making it impossible a uniform distribution and resulting in the creation of `` magnetic currents '' . the lateral boundaries of the capacitors can not be perfectly insulated . the wave equation theoretically implies that the divergence of the electric field can be different from zero , but in a quasi - stationary regime the amount is negligible . for fast - varying fields the approach to the problem should be different . at high frequencies , the coupling of electric and magnetic fields produces electromagnetic emissions . in other words , nature is very complicated and a simple linear model , such as the maxwellian , can not take into account all the possible manifestations , unless one accepts to introduce some approximation . by the way , there are no excuses ! what has been studied here is a mathematical setting trying to explain a very simple phenomenon . moreover , it is not a simple phenomenon with very rare specific parameters , since the shape of the capacitor and the applied potential are arbitrary . the results are wrong because the underlying physics is wrong : too many constraints compared to the degrees of freedom . the evolution equations rely on the finiteness of the speed of light , while the gauss s law ( ruling the stationary cases ) finds its roots on the `` action at the distance '' . depending on circumstances , one has to choose what equations are `` more meaningful '' . what is the borderline between the physics of slow - varying or fast - varying potentials ? nobody can predict it ; because in reality such a difference does not exist . why do we think there should be a difference ? because the maxwell s model is controversial . it has to be specialized based on the target , and misses the analysis of the intermediate situations . in fact , very little is known for instance about the so called _ near - field _ of an antenna , where , under suitable resonance conditions , oscillating fields transform into radiation waves ( see my paper @xcite to this regard ) . it is not admissible that the structure of a model changes depending on the problem to be solved . i have a solution to propose ( see the references to my papers ) . in my alternative model equations the divergence of the electric field can be different from zero even in vacuum ( let me skip any explanation ) . what happens inside a capacitor ? everything one may suspect : magnetic fields are generated , information propagates at the speed of light , some electromagnetic pressure ( included in the model equations ) acts on the plates , and several other known ( or less known ) effects . it depends on the assumptions on the device and the external solicitation . the general solution can be a nightmare . the difficulty of the math reflects however the complexity of the phenomena observed in the real world , without any barrier among the different regimes . starting from a unique formulation , negligible quantities can be simplified later , if the nature of the phenomenon allows for it . in the modified model , the wave equation does not hold and it is substituted by a suitable nonlinear hyperbolic system of equations where @xmath13 can be actually different from zero . a meaningful solution ( from the mathematical viewpoint ) can be finally recovered . this is the way a correct model should work . a more precise explanation will be given in a future paper . i still do not know if my proposal is the optimal tool to study electromagnetism . it is certain that maxwell s model is mathematically incorrect and , consequently , requires revision . it fails on simple questions and not just in the simulation of exotic problems . | the charge of an ideal parallel capacitor leads to the resolution of the wave equation for the electric field with prescribed initial conditions and boundary constraints . independently of the capacitor s shape and the applied voltage , none of the corresponding solutions is compatible with the full set of maxwell s equations . the paradoxical situation persists even by weakening boundary conditions , resulting in the impossibility to describe a trivial phenomenon such as the capacitor s charging process , by means of the standard maxwellian theory . @xmath0dipartimento di fisica , informatica e matematica universit di modena e reggio emilia , via campi 213/b , 41125 modena ( italy ) keywords : maxwell equations , wave equation , capacitor , paradox . pacs : 02.30.jr , 41.20.jb |
1211.4913 | sap flow in deciduous trees is driven during the growing season by the process of transpiration , in which evaporation of water in the leaves draws groundwater from the roots to the crown @xcite . as much as 90% of water taken up by the tree is transpired into the atmosphere to generate the large pressure differential needed to overcome gravity ; only 10%of the water is actually consumed in photosynthesis reactions in the leaves to produce the sugars needed for growth and other life processes . these sugars are transported by the sap in dissolved form back to the trunk and roots where they are either consumed immediately or else stored as starch for later use . transpiration halts in late fall when the leaves drop and the tree enters its winter dormant phase , which lasts until the spring thaw . at that time , the stored starch reserves are released and provide the energy needed to initiate budding and leaf growth before photosynthesis and transpiration can begin again . in the sugar maple ( _ acer saccharum _ ) , a process known as _ sap exudation _ occurs in the time period between the dormant leafless phase and the active transpiration phase , when certain processes are triggered that build up positive sap pressure and convert stored starches into sugars . the stem pressure is large enough that when the tree is tapped , sap exudes naturally from the tap - hole . the mechanism that generates this internal pressure is unique to the sugar maple and a few other related species ( black and red maple , birch , walnut , and butternut ) whose sap sugar content is also significant although not typically as high as sugar maple . raw maple sap typically contains 2 to 3% sugar by weight ( primarily sucrose ) and can be processed by repeated boiling to produce sweet syrup and other edible maple products . the scientific study of sap exudation has a long history that has seen several competing hypotheses proposed for the mechanism that drives sap flow in spring . these hypotheses can be roughly divided into two classes : `` vitalistic '' models that require some intervention by living cells ; and `` physical '' models that rely on passive , physical effects . early in the 20th century , wiegand s experiments @xcite showed that even though up to one - quarter of the total volume of sapwood or _ xylem _ is filled with gas , the expansion and contraction of this gas in response to temperature changes alone could still not account for the observed pressure changes . he concluded that some active process initiated by living cells must be responsible , a claim that was supported by the experiments of johnson @xcite . later studies questioned this vitalistic hypothesis , for example stevens and eggert @xcite who attributed the pressure generation in leafless maple trees to volume changes arising from freezing and thawing of sap . this hypothesis was further explored in subsequent years @xcite , culminating in the ground - breaking paper of milburn and omalley @xcite who proposed that gas trapped in the xylem is compressed by growth of ice crystals and subsequent uptake of water when the tree freezes in fall ; during the spring thaw , they argued that this compressed gas generates the pressures that drive exudation . this freeze / thaw hypothesis was later supported by experimental evidence @xcite showing that gas expansion due to thawing sap is the primary cause of exudation pressure ; they also found no evidence to suggest that living cells play a significant role . however , the milburn omalley model was unable to account for all observations , and so some authors @xcite cast doubt on the ability of gas expansion alone to explain exudation , arguing that heightened pressures in the xylem will dissolve any gas bubbles within a few hours . several studies @xcite suggested that osmotic pressure , generated by differences in sugar concentration across semi - permeable structures that separate various cells in the xylem , could play a significant supporting role in sap exudation . most notably , tyree proposed @xcite that a combination of the freeze / thaw mechanism and osmosis is the key to maintaining stable gas bubbles in the xylem over observed exudation time scales . this issue remains controversial and the current situation is perhaps best summed up by amglio et al . who concluded that `` no existing single model explains all of the xylem winter pressure data , '' so that both vitalistic and physical effects must play a role @xcite . the lack of a clear consensus in the tree physiology literature regarding the precise mechanisms driving sap exudation is compounded by the fact that no detailed mathematical model has yet been developed for the freeze / thaw mechanism , not to mention the other effects of osmosis and gas dissolution . the aim of this paper is therefore to develop a mathematical model that captures the essential processes driving sap exudation . we begin in section [ sec : tree - physiology ] by providing details of tree physiology , sap flow , and the milburn omalley and tyree hypotheses for pressure generation , at the core of which is the special role played by two types of non - living xylem cells called vessels and fibers . in section [ sec : model ] we derive a system of differential equations governing the multiphase gas / liquid / ice system that incorporates the effects of thawing sap in the fibers , dissolving gas bubbles in the vessels , and the osmotic pressure pressure gradient between the two . numerical simulations in section [ sec : numerics ] are used to validate the model and conclusions are drawn regarding the various mechanism for sap generation in section [ sec : conclusion ] . we first provide some background information on tree structure and the hydraulics of sap flow that can be found in texts such as @xcite . we also describe the freeze / thaw model proposed by milburn and omalley , and indicate how other mechanisms such as gas dissolution and osmotic pressure enter the picture . the milburn omalley model is a purely physical one that operates at the cellular level and depends fundamentally on the structure of the non - living cells making up the xylem . as pictured in figure [ fig : fibers - vessels](a ) , the xylem consists of long , hollow , roughly cylindrical cells of two types : _ fibers _ , that are the main structural members in the wood ; and _ vessels _ , that have a larger radius and form the primary conduit for transmitting sap . an individual vessel can extend for up to tens of centimeters vertically through the xylem , and is subdivided into _ elements _ that are connected end - to - end via perforated plates to form a continuous hydraulic connection . vessels are connected to each other via numerous _ pits _ or cavities that perforate the vessel walls . the fibers are in turn subdivided into two sub - classes : _ libriform fibers _ and _ tracheids_. according to cirelli et al . @xcite , the tracheid walls also contain pits through which they exchange sap with the vessels and hence integrating the tracheids into the water transport system of the tree . we will therefore ignore the tracheids , treating them as a part of the vessel network , and focus instead on the fibers . in comparison with tracheids , the libriform fibers ( or simply `` fibers '' ) lack the pits that provide a direct hydraulic connection to the vessels and so they are often considered to play a primarily structural role . however , the recent experiments of cirelli et al . @xcite suggest that the fiber secondary wall has a measurable permeability to water . other experiments show that under normal conditions , maple trees ( and other species that exude sap in spring ) are characterized by gas - filled fibers and water - filled vessels @xcite . this is in direct contrast with most other tree species whose fibers are completely filled with water . hence , it is reasonable to suppose that the presence of gas in xylem fibers may be connected with the ability of maple trees to generate exudation pressure in the leafless state . the mechanism proposed by milburn and omalley @xcite , and discussed in complete detail in @xcite , can be summarized as follows : * during late fall or early winter when the tree freezes , ice crystals form on the inner wall of the fibers and the growing ice layer compresses the gas trapped inside . * in early spring when temperatures rise above freezing , ice crystals in the fiber melt and the pressure of the trapped gas drives the melted sap through the fiber walls into the vessel , hence leading to the elevated pressures observed during sap exudation . tyree @xcite estimates that this effect is responsible for a pressure increase of roughly 3060 . * exudation pressure is enhanced by the gravitational potential of sap that was drawn into the crown during the previous fall , and once thawed is then free to fall toward the roots . as mentioned before , this model can account for the initiation of exudation pressure but it can not explain how pressures are sustained over periods longer than about 12 hours because gas bubbles will dissolve when pressurized . tyree @xcite explains how surface tension effects require that any gas bubble is at higher pressure than the surrounding fluid . as a result , henry s law necessitates that the concentration of dissolved gas in the region adjacent to the bubble is proportional to interfacial pressure . since the gas concentration is highest there , dissolved gas diffuses away from the bubble and eventually causes the bubble to disappear . one clue to identifying a mechanism that can sustain gas bubbles over longer time periods is provided by experiments that show maple trees exude sap only when sugar is present @xcite . with this in mind , tyree @xcite proposed a modification of the milburn omalley mechanism in which osmotic pressures arising from differences in sucrose concentration could permit gas bubbles to remain stable . in particular , he suggested that the fiber secondary walls are selectively permeable , permitting water to pass through but not larger molecules like sucrose . therefore , the ice layer that forms on the inner surface of the fibers in fall / winter is composed of pure water , which leads to an osmotic potential difference between the fibers and the vessels . _ m0.4cm0.5 & & + ( a ) 3d view of the xylem , showing vessel elements surrounded by fibers and illustrating the difference in the cell diameters . the pits forming the hydraulic connections between the cells are also shown . source : @xcite . & & ( b ) 2d cross - section highlighting the vessel elements ( ve ) , libriform fibers ( l - f ) , and fiber tracheids ( f - t ) . source : cirelli et al . 6b ) ( reproduced with permission , oxford univ . we now derive a compartment model describing the dynamics of gas , water and ice in a single vessel that is in contact with the surrounding fibers . to begin with , we restrict ourselves to the time period before the ice in the fiber melts completely . the geometry is depicted in figure [ fig : fibves ] which is an idealized view of figure [ fig : fibers - vessels](b ) . before deriving the governing equations , we make the following simplifying assumptions : 1 . we [ assume : thaw ] consider only the thawing phase , assuming that all water within the fibers is initially frozen . gravitational potential differences due to height [ assume : gravity ] can be neglected since we focus only locally on a small section of the xylem . we [ assume : element ] consider a single vessel element and ignore interactions between adjacent elements . this is a reasonable assumption if all elements experience similar conditions , and any gas contained within an element is isolated by the perforated plates from that of its neighbors . the [ assume : nfiber ] vessel is surrounded by @xmath0 identical fibers . although our model considers only a single fiber explicitly , the fluxes and other fiber quantities are scaled by a factor @xmath0 to determine the total influence of all @xmath0 fibers on the vessel . the [ assume : cylinder ] fiber and vessel are hollow and cylindrical in shape , with interior radii @xmath1 and @xmath2 , and heights @xmath3 and @xmath4 respectively . both have large aspect ratio so that @xmath5 . 6 . we assume the problem is one - dimensional , with the domain extending horizontally from the center of the fiber to the rightmost outer edge of the vessel ( pictured at the top of figure [ fig : fibves ] ) . the [ assume : coord ] coordinate system is chosen so that the horizontal ( @xmath6 ) axis is directed along the line joining the centers of the fiber and vessel and with origin @xmath7 at the center of the fiber . referring to figure [ fig : fibves ] , the fiber / vessel interface is located at @xmath8 and the center of the vessel at @xmath9 . gas is present in both [ assume : vesselgas ] fiber and vessel . although the existence of gas in the fiber is a fundamental assumption of the milburn omalley model , the gas in the vessel is a novel feature introduced in our model . because water is incompressible and the xylem is a closed system when the tree is frozen , pressure can not be transferred between the fiber and vessel compartments unless gas is also present in the vessel . further justification for this assumption is provided in the papers @xcite , which indicate that maple trees experience winter embolism ( bubble formation ) when gas in the vessels is forced out of solution upon freezing . gas [ assume : bubble ] in both fiber and vessel takes the form of a cylindrical bubble located at the center of the corresponding cell . this seems reasonable in the vessel where the surface tension is of the order of @xmath10 , which is several orders of magnitude smaller than the typical gas and liquid pressures . in the fiber , the smaller radius gives rise to a much larger surface tension ( @xmath11 ) which though still small relative to gas and liquid pressures could still potentially initiate a break - up into smaller bubbles owing to the plateau - rayleigh instability @xcite . however , regardless of the precise configuration of the gas in the fiber , we assume that the net effect on gas pressure is equivalent to that of a single large bubble . heat [ assume : ice ] from outside the tree enters from the right in figure [ fig : fibves ] . consequently , the sap in the vessel is taken to be initially in liquid form and the ice in the fiber begins melting on the inner surface of the fiber wall . 10 . gas and ice temperatures in the fiber can be taken as constant and equal to the freezing point . this is justified by the fiber length scale [ assume : tfiber ] being so much smaller than that of the vessel ( @xmath12 ) . time [ assume : tvessel ] scales for heat and gas diffusion are much shorter than those corresponding to ice melting and subsequent phase interface motion ( which our simulations show are on the order of minutes to hours ) . this is justified by considering the various diffusion coefficients ( @xmath13 ) and a typical length scale ( @xmath14 ) , and in each case calculating the corresponding diffusion time scale @xmath15 : * _ diffusion in gas bubbles : _ using the air self - diffusion coefficient @xmath16 , the time scale is @xmath17 ; * _ diffusion of dissolved gas : _ diffusivity @xmath18 of air in water gives @xmath19 ; * _ diffusion of heat : _ thermal diffusivities @xmath20 ( for air ) and @xmath21 ( for water ) yield @xmath22 and @xmath23 respectively . + therefore , heat transport is essentially quasi - steady and the temperature equilibrates rapidly to any change in local conditions . also , gas concentration and density ( in both gaseous and dissolved forms ) can be taken as constants in space . a significant osmotic [ assume : osmosis ] pressure arises owing to differences in sugar content between liquid in the vessel and fiber . this is motivated by recent experiments which show that the fiber cell wall is permeable to water but not to larger molecules such as sucrose @xcite , suggesting that ice contained in the fiber is composed of pure water . a simple order of magnitude estimate based on a sap sugar concentration of 2% then implies that the osmotic pressure @xmath24 , which is of the same order as typical gas and liquid pressures . [ assume : post - dissolve ] is no need to consider modelling the system beyond the time when either fiber or vessel bubble is completely dissolved , since then no further exchange of pressure is possible . at the center of the fiber.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=70.0% ] model equations are derived for the fiber and vessel compartments in the next two sections . for easy reference , all parameters and variables are listed in table [ tab : params ] along with physical values where appropriate . there are some similarities that can be found with other models developed for related problems such as ice lensing in porous soils @xcite and freeze / thaw processes in the food industry @xcite ; however , neither problem contains all of the physical mechanisms encountered during sap exudation . + @xmath25 & area of vessel wall that is permeable & & @xmath26 & ( [ eq : wall - area ] ) + @xmath27 & sucrose concentration in vessel sap & & 58.4 & + @xmath28 & gravitational acceleration & & 9.81 & @xcite + @xmath29 & heat transfer coefficient & & 10.0 & @xcite + @xmath30 & henry s constant & & 0.0274 & @xcite + @xmath31 & thermal conductivity of air & & 0.0243 & @xcite + @xmath32 & thermal conductivity of water & & 0.580 & @xcite + @xmath33 & cell wall hydraulic conductivity & & @xmath34 & @xcite + @xmath3 & length of fiber & & @xmath35 & @xcite + @xmath4 & length of vessel element & & @xmath36 & @xcite + @xmath37 & molar mass of air & & 0.0290 & @xcite + @xmath38 & molar mass of sucrose & & 0.3423 & @xcite + @xmath0 & number of fibers per vessel & & 16 & ( [ eq : nfiber ] ) + @xmath39 & pressure scale & & @xmath40 & ( [ eq : rho - p - bar ] ) + @xmath1 & interior radius of fiber & & @xmath41 & @xcite + @xmath2 & interior radius of vessel & & @xmath42 & @xcite + @xmath43 & universal gas constant & & 8.314 & @xcite + @xmath44 & time scale & & 46.1 & ( [ eq : tbar ] ) + @xmath45 & freezing temperature of ice & & 273.15 & + @xmath46 & ambient temperature of gas & & @xmath47 & + @xmath48 & volume of fiber & & @xmath49 & ( [ eq : vbarf ] ) + @xmath50 & volume of vessel & & @xmath51 & ( [ eq : vbarv ] ) + @xmath52 & thickness of fiber + vessel wall & & @xmath53 & @xcite + @xmath54 & latent heat of fusion & & @xmath55 & @xcite + @xmath56 & ice density & & 917 & @xcite + @xmath57 & water density & & 1000 & @xcite + @xmath58 & density scale & & 1.29 & @xcite + @xmath59 & air - water surface tension & & 0.0756 & @xcite + + @xmath60 & dissolved gas concentration & + @xmath61 & mass & + @xmath62 & pressure & + @xmath63 & radius of gas bubble in vessel & + @xmath64 & fiber interface location & + @xmath65 & time & + @xmath66 & temperature & + @xmath67 & volume of melted ice & + @xmath68 & volume & + @xmath6 & spatial location & + @xmath69 & density & + + @xmath28 & + @xmath70 & + @xmath71 & + + @xmath72 & + @xmath73 & + we now develop a set of governing equations for the fiber that is restricted to the time period when ice is present , so that an ice layer separates the gas from the water adjacent to the wall . the modifications that are required to the model once the ice layer has disappeared and the fiber bubble is in direct contact with the sap are described in section [ sec : ice - melted ] . the inner fiber wall is initially coated by an ice layer of uniform thickness , inside of which is a cylindrical volume of compressed gas with radius @xmath74 . as the ice layer melts , an ice / water interface @xmath75 appears at the inner edge of the fiber wall ( @xmath76 ) and propagates inward . the speed of the interface depends not only on the volume difference between ice and water but also on the seepage of liquid through the porous fiber wall . the gas pressure that drives water through the wall into the vessel is transmitted through the ice layer to the adjacent water . if we denote by @xmath77 , @xmath78 and @xmath79 the volumes of gas , water and ice within the fiber , then owing to the cylindrical symmetry @xmath80 which also satisfy @xmath81 recalling assumption [ assume : tfiber ] , which takes the gas temperature @xmath82 to be constant and equal to the freezing point @xmath83 , the gas density varies only due to changes in volume so that @xmath84 the corresponding gas pressure is given by the ideal gas law @xmath85 where @xmath37 is the molar mass of air . this can be combined with ( [ eq : volfg ] ) and ( [ eq : rhofg ] ) to obtain @xmath86 as ice thaws , some volume of melt - water ( denoted @xmath87 ) is forced through the fiber wall into the vessel , while the remainder stays in the fiber sandwiched between the ice layer and the wall . let the ( constant ) mass of gas in the fiber be @xmath88 and the mass of water and ice be @xmath89 where @xmath57 and @xmath56 are the densities of water and ice respectively . conservation of mass in the fiber implies that @xmath90 where initially @xmath91 and @xmath92 . differentiating ( [ eq : mf0 ] ) yields @xmath93 where the `` dot '' denotes a time derivative . substituting ( [ eq : vbarf ] ) and ( [ eq : massfi])([eq : massfw ] ) into the last expression yields @xmath94 and the volume terms can be replaced using ( [ eq : volfg ] ) and ( [ eq : volfw ] ) to obtain @xmath95 recall that the temperature in both gas and ice is assumed constant and equal to the freezing point @xmath45 . the water layer , on the other hand , is heated from the vessel side so that the water temperature @xmath96 is not constant but instead obeys the steady - state heat equation and boundary condition [ eq : heat - tfw ] @xmath97 the speed @xmath98 of the ice / water interface is determined by the stefan condition @xmath99 where @xmath54 is the latent heat of fusion and @xmath32 is the thermal conductivity of water . in summary , ( [ eq : pfg2 ] ) , ( [ eq : sgi - siw ] ) , ( [ eq : heat - tfw - pde ] ) and ( [ eq : stefan ] ) represent a coupled system of equations for the fiber unknowns @xmath100 , @xmath74 , @xmath101 , and @xmath96 . in the next section , we will derive an equation for @xmath102 and also determine the missing boundary condition for @xmath103 as a matching condition with the vessel temperature at the fiber / vessel wall @xmath8 . let @xmath104 and @xmath105 denote the volume of the water and gas compartments . the time derivative of the total volume ( gas + water ) must be zero so that @xmath106 or simply @xmath107 this equation embodies the assumption that there is no flow between vessel elements so that the portion of the volume consisting of water equals the initial value @xmath108 plus whatever water enters from the @xmath0 surrounding fibers . using the fact that the bubble radius and volume are connected by @xmath109 equation ( [ eq : vvg0 ] ) can then be rewritten as @xmath110 assuming that fibers are packed tightly around the vessel and that both vessel and fiber have wall thickness @xmath52 , a simple geometric argument provides an estimate for the constant @xmath111 : @xmath112 we next focus on porous transport through the fiber wall which is governed by darcy s law @xmath113 where @xmath114 is the vessel water pressure , @xmath33 is the hydraulic conductivity , @xmath52 is the wall thickness , and @xmath25 is the area of the wall that is permeable to water . in the absence of experimental measurements for hydraulic conductivity in maple , we use the value @xmath115 obtained for birch trees @xcite . finally , @xmath25 is taken equal to the internal surface area of the cylindrical vessel @xmath116 we next describe the temperature evolution within the various vessel compartments , recalling that the diffusive time scale is short in relation to either melting or gas dissolution . we therefore employ a quasi - steady approximation in which temperatures obey a steady - state heat equation . denote by @xmath117 the temperature within the gas bubble , and @xmath118 and @xmath119 the water temperatures to the left and right of the bubble respectively . then , in the water region on the left ( adjacent to the vessel wall ) @xmath118 obeys [ eq : heat - tvw1 ] @xmath120 the gas temperature @xmath117 inside the bubble obeys [ eq : heat - tvg ] @xmath121 finally , the water temperature @xmath119 to the right of the gas obeys [ eq : heat - tvw2 ] @xmath122 where @xmath29 is a convective heat transfer coefficient . the ambient temperature @xmath46 refers to the temperature in the neighboring layer of xylem cells ; using a temperature difference of @xmath123 through the sapwood over a tap depth of 0.05 , we obtain a rough estimate of @xmath124 for the temperature difference on the cell scale . the final component of the model is a description of the process whereby elevated pressures in the gas bubble cause the gas to dissolve at the gas / water interface . because of the small bubble size , it is essential to take into account the effect of surface tension . gas and liquid pressures in the vessel are connected by the young laplace equation , where the proportionality constant is the interfacial surface tension @xmath59 . for a cylindrical gas bubble with radius @xmath63 , the principal radii of curvature are @xmath125 and @xmath126 . ] , @xmath127 where @xmath59 is the air - water surface tension and @xmath128 is the bubble radius . in this formula , the gas pressure can be written using the ideal gas law @xmath129 where @xmath130 is the gas density which we have taken uniform in space according to assumption [ assume : tvessel ] . the concentration @xmath131 of dissolved gas in the sap is then related to the gas density by henry s law @xmath132 where @xmath30 is a dimensionless constant . the gas density in the preceding equations decreases over time owing to dissolution and can be written @xmath133 where @xmath105 is given by ( [ eq : vvg ] ) and the integral in the first expression is taken over @xmath134 , the annular portion of the vessel filled with liquid . in summary , equations ( [ eq : rg ] ) , ( [ eq : volmelt ] ) and ( [ eq : heat - tvw1])([eq : rhovg ] ) represent a nonlinear system of differential - algebraic equations for the nine unknown functions @xmath128 , @xmath114 , @xmath135 , @xmath118 , @xmath119 , @xmath117 , @xmath130 , @xmath131 and @xmath87 . the vessel and fiber solutions are coupled via matching conditions ( [ eq : volmelt ] ) , ( [ eq : heat - tvw1-bc1 ] ) and ( [ eq : heat - tvw1-bc2 ] ) . tyree and co - workers have argued that a pressurized gas bubble in the xylem will dissolve entirely over a period of 12 hours or less , so that some other pressure - generating mechanism must operate to sustain the bubbles actually observed in xylem sap @xcite . recent experiments by cirelli et al . @xcite suggest that the fiber secondary wall is selectively - permeable , allowing water to pass through but preventing the passage of larger molecules such as sucrose and thereby generating a significant osmotic potential difference between fibers and vessels . this leads naturally to the hypothesis that osmotic pressure might provide the extra mechanism needed to enhance flow of sap from fiber to vessel and hence prevent bubbles in the fiber from totally dissolving once the ice layer has completely melted . osmosis can be described mathematically by means of the morse equation that relates osmotic pressure @xmath136 within a solution to the dissolved solute concentration @xmath27 via @xmath137 . following the approach in @xcite , we apply this equation to the sap solutions in fiber and vessel and hence obtain a modified version of the melt volume equation ( [ eq : volmelt ] ) @xmath138,\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath139 and @xmath140 are the sucrose concentrations in the fiber and vessel respectively . according to tyree and zimmermann @xcite , sucrose is present only in the vessels , so that @xmath141 and @xmath142 . \label{eq : volmelt - osmotic}\end{gathered}\ ] ] this equation replaces ( [ eq : volmelt ] ) , but otherwise the governing equations remain unchanged . for the sake of simplicity , we assume that the vessel sucrose concentration @xmath140 is a constant which for a 2% sucrose solution corresponds to taking @xmath143 , where the molar mass of sucrose is @xmath144 . this assumption can be justified by arguing that ray parenchyma cells ( which provide the bulk of the sucrose to the tree vascular system ) are so numerous in maples that they should be capable of maintaining the sucrose concentration at a relatively constant level . to simplify the governing equations , we reduce the number of parameters in the problem by introducing the following change of variables : @xmath145 t = { \hat{t } } \ , { \bar{t } } , & { u}= { v}^v { \bar{{u } } } , & p = { \hat{p } } \ , { \bar{p } } , \\[0.2 cm ] \rho = { \hat{\rho } } \ , { \bar{\rho } } , & c = \frac{{\hat{\rho}}}{{m}_g } \ , { \bar{c } } , & t = t_c + ( t_a - t_c ) { \bar{t } } , \end{array } \label{eq : change - vars } \end{gathered}\ ] ] where an overbar denotes a dimensionless quantity . the melt volume is non - dimensionalized using @xmath146 density and pressure scales are chosen based on initial values as @xmath147 and the time scale @xmath44 will be specified shortly . the above expressions are then substituted into the dimensional equations from section [ sec : model ] , after which we immediately simplify notation by dropping asterisks . the differential equations and boundary conditions ( [ eq : heat - tfw ] ) and ( [ eq : heat - tvw1])([eq : heat - tvw2 ] ) governing the temperatures @xmath148 , @xmath149 , @xmath150 and @xmath151 become : [ eq : adim - tfw1 ] @xmath152 [ eq : adim - tvw1 ] @xmath153 [ eq : adim - tvg ] @xmath154 [ eq : adim - tvw2 ] @xmath155 the dimensionless parameter @xmath156 is the biot number . next are five algebraic equations for @xmath157 , @xmath158 , @xmath159 , @xmath160 and @xmath161 : @xmath162 the non - dimensionalized stefan condition ( [ eq : stefan ] ) becomes @xmath163 where we have chosen the time scale @xmath164 so as to eliminate the coefficient in the stefan condition . this is clearly an appropriate time scale for our problem because the melting process governs the dynamics of the ice layer and hence also the water transport from fiber to vessel . using parameter values from table [ tab : params ] , we find that a typical value of the time scale is @xmath165 . finally , the remaining differential equations ( [ eq : sgi - siw ] ) , ( [ eq : rg ] ) and ( [ eq : volmelt ] ) for the quantities @xmath166 , @xmath167 and @xmath168 become @xmath169 . \label{eq : n - udot - nondim}\end{gathered}\ ] ] .a list of dimensionless parameters and their numerical values . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] the aim of this work was to develop a detailed mathematical model that captures the physical effects heat and mass transport , gas dissolution , surface tension , osmosis and phase change that are believed to play a significant role in sap exudation in maple trees . in particular , we were interested in investigating two competing hypotheses for sap exudation based on a model of milburn omalley ( without osmosis ) @xcite and another of tyree ( with osmosis ) @xcite . the model focuses on the cellular scale and the transfer of pressure between two main xylem components : fibers and vessels . we derived a coupled system of nonlinear , time - dependent , differential - algebraic equations , which we solved using matlab . extensive numerical simulations were performed that uncovered the following : * it is necessary to include the effect of gas bubbles in the vessel sap in order to allow a transfer of stored pressure in the fibers to the vessel sap . this gas in the vessels was not explicitly mentioned by either milburn omalley or tyree . * taking parameter values consistent with data in the literature , our model captures positive vessel pressures provided that the gas in the fiber is sufficiently compressed during the previous year s freezing phase . the observed increase in vessel sap pressure lies in the range of 3060 that is consistent with experimental values reported in the literature for maple sap exudation . * for a wide range of parameters , and provided the vessel gas content is low enough , the fibers are able to completely dissolve the gas bubbles within the vessel sap . this is consistent with the phenomenon of embolism repair that is known to occur in maple as well as other hardwood species . * reasonable exudation pressures are obtained both with and without osmosis . one impact of including osmotic effects is to increase slightly the threshold vessel bubble size below which gas in the vessel gas dissolves entirely ; in this respect , our model suggests that osmosis may enhance embolism repair . the second main impact of osmosis is to lessen the likelihood that the fiber gas bubble collapses , which enhances the ability to exude sap . this paper can only be considered as a preliminary study of sap exudation because the comparisons and conclusions we have drawn so far are mainly qualitative . more detailed comparisons with experimental data in the literature are currently underway to further validate the model , and will form the basis of a future publication . there are a number of other specific areas that we believe would provide fruitful avenues for future research : * the long - time behavior pictured in figures [ fig : case5a ] and [ fig : case5d ] suggests that this problem is ripe for a multi - layer asymptotic analysis in which the solution is divided into two pieces : a linear solution , matched to initial conditions via a boundary layer on the left ; and a constant equilibrium state that is matched across an interior layer to the linear solution . * the predictive power of this model would be strengthened with better estimates of two parameters : the gas content in the vessel , and the initial pressure in the fiber . we will perform a more extensive search of the literature and focus in particular on data from studies of embolism . in conjunction with this effort , we believe that our model ( with only minor modifications ) could also be applied to study the phenomenon of embolism repair coinciding with the spring thaw @xcite . * the conditions under which the maple tree freezes at the end of the previous season are known to have a significant impact on sap exudation during the following spring . to study this process , we could run our model `` in reverse '' to study the cooling sequence in the milburn omalley model ( steps 14 in figure [ fig : milburn - omalley ] ) . * we are currently developing a macroscopic tree - level model , based on the 1d model of chuang et al . @xcite that uses richards equation to capture sap flow in the porous xylem . in order to apply this work to the study of exudation , we require solution - dependent transport coefficients that will be derived from the microscopic cell - level model derived in the current paper using an up - scaling procedure . t. amglio , f. w. ewers , h. cochard , m. martignac , m. vandame , c. bodet , and p. cruiziat . winter stem xylem pressure in walnut trees : effects of carbohydrates , cooling and freezing . , 21:387394 , 2001 . chuang , r. oren , a. l. bertozzi , n. phillips , and g. g. katul . the porous media model for the hydraulic system of a conifer tree : linking sap flux data to transpiration rate . , 191:447468 , 2006 . j. b. keller . growth and decay of gas bubbles in liquids . in r. davies , editor , _ cavitation in real liquids : proceedings of the symposium on cavitation in real liquids _ , pages 1929 . general motors research laboratories , warren , michigan , elsevier , 1964 . a. radu , j. vrouwenvelder , m. van loosdrecht , and c. picioreanu . modeling the effect of biofilm formation on reverse osmosis performance : flux , feed channel pressure drop and solute passage . , 365(1 - 2):115 , 2010 . r. sander . compilation of henry s law constants for inorganic and organic species of potential importance in environmental chemistry . max planck institute of chemistry , mainz , germany , downloaded from http://www.rolf-sander.net/henry , april 8 , 1999 . m. t. tyree . the mechanism of maple sap exudation . in m. terazawa , c. a. mcleod , and y. tamai , editors , _ tree sap : proceedings of the 1st international symposium on sap utilization _ , pages 3745 , bifuka , japan , april 1012 , 1995 . hokkaido university press . | we develop a mathematical model for sap exudation in a maple tree that is based on a purely physical mechanism for internal pressure generation in trees in the leafless state . there has been a long - standing controversy in the tree physiology literature over precisely what mechanism drives sap exudation , and we aim to cast light on this issue . our model is based on the work of milburn and omalley [ _ can . j. bot . _ , ( 10):21012106 , 1984 ] who hypothesized that elevated sap pressures derive from compressed gas that is trapped within certain wood cells and subsequently released when frozen sap thaws in the spring . we also incorporate the extension of tyree [ in _ tree sap _ , pp . 3745 , eds . m. terazawa et al . , hokkaido univ . press , 1995 ] who argued that gas bubbles are prevented from dissolving because of osmotic pressure that derives from differences in sap sugar concentrations and the selective permeability of cell walls . we derive a system of differential - algebraic equations based on conservation principles that is used to test the validity of the milburn omalley hypothesis and also to determine the extent to which osmosis is required . this work represents the first attempt to derive a detailed mathematical model of sap exudation at the micro - scale . sap transport , multiphase flow , phase change , stefan problem , gas dissolution , osmosis . 35r37 , 76m12 , 76t30 , 80a22 , 92c80 . |
astro-ph9912476 | there is a general lack of information about the nature of uv sources fainter than the completeness limit of the td-1 photometric catalog ( thompson 1978 ) . this is , primarily , the result of a lack of surveys of the uv sky . only partial surveys , in limited regions of the sky , have been conducted since the td-1 mission . one of the more extended , in terms of general sky coverage , was by the faust experiment . faust is a @xmath1 instantaneous field - of - view ( fov ) telescope , covering the spectral range between 1400 and 1800 with an angular resolution of 3.5 arcminutes . it has a 20 cm entrance aperture and it utilizes a microchannel plate detector with wedge and strip anode , which records the position of each detected photon . faust operated on board the space shuttle ( sts ) atlantis in march 1992 as part of the atlas1 mission . a description of faust and its operation aboard atlas1 was given by lampton ( 1993 ) . during this flight 19 pointed exposures were obtained , of which three were short exposures for pointing checks . the other fixed - pointing images were exposed for 12 to 18 minutes . in addition , two @xmath030@xmath2 long scans of the sky were obtained by rolling the sts during the exposure . details of the image reconstruction from the time - tagged photon stream and subsequent reductions are given in bowyer ( 1993 ) . a catalog of 4660 faust sources , originating from the fixed - pointings as well as from the sky scans , was produced by bowyer ( 1995 ; fsc ) . this used a uniform thresholding algorithm for source detection , and the identifications were obtained from correlations against catalogs ( mainly from the simbad data base ) . the faust images are being studied systematically at tel aviv in order to identify sources and perform , as much as possible , ground - based follow - up studies . in this context , we already presented results from five images at high galactic latitude sky regions visible from the northern hemisphere : the north galactic pole ( brosch 1995 ) , the virgo cluster region ( brosch 1997 ) , and in the direction of the coma cluster ( brosch 1998 ) . this paper presents our analysis of four faust fields in the southern sky . it uses , for the first time , data from an objective - prism survey ( the hamburg - eso survey = hes , wisotzki 1996 ; reimers 1997 ) to provide additional ground - based spectroscopic information about the possible optical counterparts . the uv sources in this part of the milky way ( mw ) may help the understanding of the morphology of the disk and halo of the mw . this is because stellar uv sources represent special stellar populations ; the majority are rather massive main - sequence objects with spectral types a & f , as our previous studies have shown . their study allows us to test the mw structure in four spatial windows . in this region there are indications of bends , corrugations , valleys , and other morphological peculiarities of the galactic disk ( alfaro & efremov 1996 ) . the paper is arranged as follows . we first describe the faust observations and the source detection on the uv images . we then describe the process of source identification based on correlations with published data , mainly from electronic data banks . we describe our use of the he s objective - prism plates to confirm or modify our proposed identification . the discussion concentrates on ( a ) a comparison of the fields which have he s data with those fields lacking this information , and ( b ) the general properties of the uv sources we detected , in the context of the fourth galactic quadrant in which they are located . one field is located at the border between the third and the fourth quadrant ; it is analyzed here as though it is one of the 4th quadrant fields . the regions observed by faust , and in which the source identification process has been performed , are listed in table 1 . the faust images are shown in figures 1 to 4 , for the dorado , centaurus , m83 , and telescopium ( hereafter dor , cen , m83 , and tel ) regions . all four regions are located in , or very close to , the fourth galactic quadrant , the part of the mw galaxy which ( as seen from the solar neighbourhood ) lies between the galactic center ( gc ) and l@xmath3270@xmath2 . they are all located at intermediate galactic latitudes , two north of the mw plane and two south of it . the lines of sight sample , therefore , the disk and halo of the mw at similar `` elevation '' angles from the galactic equator and at approximately the same aspect angles with respect to the galactic bulge . therefore , apart from the general interest in source detection and identification , the present observations allow , in principle , an inter - comparison of regions which sample approximately the same mw environments . each faust image has location - specific exposure levels within the image . the reason is that the space shuttle attitude control system permits some platform motion , and the information was collected as a time - tagged photon stream . the images were reconstructed on the ground by tracking relatively bright stars . this implies that during a pointed exposure a larger area of the sky was imaged than the instantaneous fov of faust . table 1 lists , for each region , the actual sky area covered by each image and the lowest and highest exposure levels , generally collected near the edge and in the central part of the image , respectively . the sky area covered by each image was calculated from the total number of non - zero exposure pixels , and by assuming that each pixel is a square of 1.1 arcmin sides . this is an approximation , because electrostatic distortions of the image caused by the detector causes pixels to have slightly different areas . an impartial source detector algorithm , described in brosch ( 1995 ) , operated on the faust images and produced lists of uv source candidates with their faust uv fluxes and equatorial coordinates . because of the physical nature of the faust frames , the exposure times , and therefore the image depths , differ for different regions in each image . variations range from a few hundred seconds in the central regions to a few tens of seconds at the frame periphery . this results in regions with reasonably high signal , whereas other regions ( with low exposure ) have low signal levels . the detector used in faust has as only sources of noise the poisson statistics of photon arrival and detection , and the sky background . as a result , the detection method must be signal - to - noise limited rather than flux - limited . the source detector algorithm used here required an acceptance threshold ( at ) level of 5.5 times the standard deviation of the local background ( @xmath4 ) to decide that a source was probably real . this was determined by examining the behavior of the number of source candidates with threshold level ; the number of possible sources increased exponentially with at for thresholds lower than 5 , but only linearly for thresholds higher than this value . we infer that , if the at is too low , large numbers of `` false '' sources are introduced by the detection method . by adopting a high threshold level one is in danger of losing valuable information . we selected the specific 5.5@xmath5 level used here at the inflexion point in the plot of the number of detected sources ( n@xmath6 ) _ vs. _ at , where the linear regime and the exponential regime cross over . the total number of sources detected by this method in each field is also listed in table 1 . the astrometry of the sources positions is based on a best - fit to the @xmath040 brightest uv sources in each field . these were identified in predicted uv images , which were created with data from the sao catalog and the hipparcos input catalog ( hic ) , together with the algorithm for predicting the uv magnitude using the visual magnitude and spectral type of stars ( brosch 1991 , and further modifications ) . the fits were usually good to @xmath030 " and were checked using the derived coordinates of the remaining @xmath020 visually identified sources . the photon flux from each detected source was measured by integrating all count rates within a simulated round aperture centered on the location of the object , and subtracting the local background . a round aperture of diameter 12 pixels , equivalent to 13.2 arcmin , was used for the majority of sources except for the very strong sources where a diameter of 24 pixels ( 26.4 arcmin ) was used . this aperture is much larger than the resolution of faust and it allows the collections of virtually all the uv photons from a source . the photometric error is composed of the aperture photometry error , that originating from the background estimation , and a systematic error in flux resulting from the laboratory calibration of faust and the intrinsic errors of the iue photometric scale ( 15.8% of the observed flux ) . monochromatic faust magnitudes ( [ uv]=2.5 log(flux)21.175 ) are used here to represent the detected brightness , where the flux is in erg/@xmath7/sec / and was derived from the count rate of faust , as explained in brosch ( 1995 ) . the photometric error translates to a minimum error of 0.16 mag in the uv magnitude used here . the lists of uv sources , separate for each faust field , are presented in table 2 . each source is identified by a running number and two leading letters , the second that identifies the faust field in which this source was identified . for instance , source fd1 is the first detected uv source in the dorado ( dor ) field , and fm83 in the 83rd source in the m83 field . we give the j2000 coordinates of the sources in columns 2 and 3 , the faust magnitude and error in column 4 , and the corresponding uv source number from the faust source catalog ( fsc : bowyer 1995 ) , for the cases where the fsc lists a source in column 5 . it is important to emphasize that the source detection algorithm used here is different from the one used in creating the fsc ( bowyer 1995 ) . because of this , a comparison of the number of detected sources listed here and in the fsc is in order . we searched the fsc for all entries within 3 of each of the sources detected here . the corresponding fsc number is listed in table 2 for all entries where a match was found . in a few cases more than one match was found . this was usually due to the proximity of another source and the `` ownership '' was resolved by visually inspecting the uv image . for three sources , all in the m83 field , bowyer ( 1995 ) detected two components , while we detected only one . the vast majority of the fsc detections have matches in our lists . in the three other fields ( dor , cen , and tel ) most fsc sources undetected by us are all very faint and remained unidentified in the fsc . they could be artefacts , but there is one exception : fsc4623 = sao193381 in the tel field , apparently a bright uv source , whose presence we could not confirm with our detection technique . a comparison for the m83 field is problematic due to the overlap of one of the faust scans with the pointed m83 exposure . nevertheless , the number of fsc entries for the m83 region not detected here is small ; ten such entries were found within [email protected] of the m83 image center . this number does not include the three cases where the fsc showed two adjacent entries for only one source detected here . in these cases we included both fsc numbers in the lists , but caution that this may be due to a single object having slightly different fsc astrometric solutions , from the scan and from the fixed pointing . since almost all of the ten other `` undetected here '' m83 fsc entries have either nearby detected sources or are very close the edge of the image , we conclude that they originate from the faust scan , not from the pointed observation . we estimate the number of fsc sources we did not detect and which originate from the m83 fixed exposure to be at most five . table 3 summarizes this comparison of results and emphasizes the significant addition of uv sources to those in the fsc by using the present detection algorithm . on average , fsc sources make up only 2/3 of the uv sources detected by us . therefore , with our detection scheme we increased by @xmath050% the number of faust uv sources in comparison with the fsc . figure 5 shows histograms of the uv magnitude distribution in each of the four fields . in general , all fields show a steady increase in the number of detected sources with increasing apparent magnitude , but there are some subtle differences . the cen field , which is at the lowest galactic latitude , has many more sources than the other fields . on the other hand , the source distribution with uv magnitude in the cen field starts to become incomplete already at m@xmath811 , approximately 1 - 2 magnitudes brighter than in the three other fields . one important feature is noticeable by even a cursory inspection of table 1 , which gives the total number of detections along with the location of each image and its depth . the m83 image has almost the same number of detections as has the tel field , yet the two images differ by a factor of @xmath9 in exposure depth , with the tel field being shallower . the discrepancy can not be due to a higher stellar concentration in tel , because there are no ( listed ) star clusters in this direction and the galactic latitudes of the two fields are almost identical . this will be discussed further , below . the primary identification used on - line data bases , such as the sao catalog ( sao 1966 ) , the hipparcos input catalogue ( turon 1993 ) , the tycho catalog ( esa 1997 ) , and the ned . the identification criterion was the angular distance : the nearer an object is to the calculated uv source position , the more likely it is to be the actual counterpart . additional constraints were imposed on a physical basis . the bluer an optical candidate , the more likely it is to be the real counterpart . the spectral type of the object , if it was listed in the catalog source , was an important input to the determination of the accepted counterpart . sources for which no physical properties could be found were correlated with guide star catalog ( lasker , jenkner , & russell 1988 ) objects , if such could be found in the neighbourhood of a source . the remaining identifications were extracted mainly from the first edition of the us naval observatory two - colour catalog ( usno - a1.0 , hereafter usno : monet 1996 ) . this catalog is based on scans of the palomar and eso / serc sky survey blue and red schmidt telescope plates . the absolute scale of the blue and red magnitudes is not accurate , but a `` local '' comparison of colours between a number of candidates for the same uv source is useful for identifying the bluest and brightest object , which is most likely to be the counterpart of the uv source . the second version of this catalog ( usno - a2.0 : monet 1998 ) has improved astrometric positions and photometric calibration and was used to check a few problematic sources . the photometric improvement is based on the b and v magnitudes of the tycho catalog for the brighter objects and on ccd observations of standard stars for some sky regions . however , the final reported photometric accuracy ( 0.15 mag internal error and up to 0.5 mag due to systematic effects ) is not much better that that of the a1.0 version of the catalog . the usno catalog , whose candidates are designated by a `` usno '' prefix in the lists , contains both stellar and non - stellar sources . on completing the identification process and analyzing the results , a few ( @xmath1010 for all four fields combined ) fairly strong sources , all very near the edge of the images , remained unidentified . as these are relatively strong uv sources they are very probably not artefacts , and a special effort was exerted to identify them . an additional search in the tycho catalog , using a search radius of 5 arcmin , produced good identifications for most sources with optical counterparts located within 3 - 4 arcmin of the uv source . analysis of other identified sources in the same vicinity showed that a systematic positional error appears sometimes at the edge of the images . this is presumably due to the electrostatic distortions being the greatest at the edges of the detector , and not having enough pre - identified stars in these locations as input for the astrometric solution used to compute the celestial coordinates . these additional identifications have been included in the lists shown in tables 2 and 4 . the entries of table 4 , which reports the identifications , repeat the source identifier used here in table 2 column 1 , give a leading catalog identifier for the proposed counterpart ( column 2 ) , its v - band magnitude ( or b - band , in some cases ) in column 3 , a note on its spectral type if it is a star or on its morphological classification if it is a galaxy ( column 4 ) , its listed b - v colour ( or b - r , in some cases ) in column 5 , and the candidate s celestial position in columns 6 and 7 . all positions reported here are for j2000 . the he s ( wisotzki 1996 ) is an objective - prism survey aimed at detecting bright qsos . it was performed with the eso schmidt telescope using iiia - j plates and a 4@xmath2 objective prism . the plates have a resolution of 15 at h@xmath11 ( seeing - dependent ) and cover the range 3200 to 5400 . the celestial area covered by the he s is mainly in the extragalactic sky , roughly above @xmath12b@xmath12=30@xmath2 . because of this sky coverage limitation , two of the faust regions analysed here could not be compared with the he s data sets . in particular , we limit the discussion of the objective - prism spectra to the fields of m83 and of dorado , as the other two regions have a galactic latitude too low to be included in the he s . the he s plates were scanned on the hamburg pds with a 30@xmath1330@xmath14m@xmath15 aperture , and spectra were automatically extracted using object detection on the digitized sky survey . each spectrally observed candidate has , therefore , an astrometric solution good to @xmath02 arcsec and a linearized spectrum ( using the plate sensitometric relation ) covering the range of the he s objective - prism plates , which is @xmath0300 pixels long . on average , @xmath075% of the spectra do not show overlap with other neighbouring spectra and can be used to verify or revise the classification and assignation of an optical candidate to a faust uv source . the search for optical counterparts on the he s data set was done by lw in early - november 1998 . a search in a region 3 arcmin wide around each faust source was performed and the candidates were extracted and examined by nb . in a number of instances , the candidate optical object was so bright as to cause partial or even full saturation of the objective - prism plate . for several cases , the spectral information allowing a rough classification could be recovered using additional scan lines from the two - dimensional scan data . we could thus use the balmer absorption lines and the 4000 ca ii break as classifier criteria in objects as bright as [email protected] . an optical candidate was accepted as the probable counterpart of a uv source if it : 1 . was the brightest source , 2 . was the nearest source , 3 . showed strong balmer absorption lines , 4 . showed a significantly strong blue - uv `` tail '' of the spectrum not all these conditions had to be fulfilled simultaneously for a source to be accepted as a counterpart . we are aware that these may seem to be subjective criteria , but adopt them here in absence of a systematic spectral classification of all he s spectra . an example of the output produced from the he s plates for this search of optical counterparts , one page of the many produced for the various candidates and inspected by us , is shown in figure 6 . three objects are displayed in this figure ; the bottom one is source fm 31 identified as a new sub - dwarf star . the various entries for each candidate include the number of the eso - schmidt plate on which the object appears , various classification parameters , the image of the field from the digitized sky survey with the candidate object centered , and two representations of the objective - prism spectrum , one at full resolution ( centered ) and another binned to low resolution ( to the right ) . the strong blue tail , indicative of a very hot object , is evident for candidate he1342 - 2728=fm 31 . the he s plates yield also blue ( b@xmath17 ) magnitudes , from the blue part of the spectrum and a calibration against standard stars ( vanelle 1996 ) . the calibration is good to @xmath00.2 mag provided that the spectrum is not overexposed ( [email protected] ) . in principle , it is also possible to determine the u b and b v colour indices of the candidates from the spectra , using a calibration of spectral slope against colour indices ; however , here one has to guard even more carefully against chance partial spectrum overlap . we emphasize that the assignation of optical counterparts in the dor and m83 fields was done in a completely independent way from the assignments based on catalog correlations . in most cases , the he s spectra confirmed the original catalog selection of a counterpart . the counterparts selected from the he s spectra are listed in table 4 if they were `` better '' than those originally selected using catalog correlations , or if they offered the choice of a single counterpart , when the catalog searches yielded a number of optical sources in the same error ellipse . the he s sources can be recognized by the he prefix identifier and by the approximate spectral type , derived from the visual inspection of the spectrum tracing . note that in many cases the location of the uv source on the he s contains no object with a spectrum which could be associated with the faust source . in the dor field 37 uv sources had no such he s counterpart . in a number of cases , we could not solve the question of the proper counterpart , even using the he s data . in such cases we reverted to the usno catalog ( version a2.0 ) and selected the best counterpart to be the nearest and bluest listed object , and this is the entry adopted for table 4 . in this section we summarize results from the detection and identification process , including the confirmatory or enhancing results with the he s spectra using the data from table 4 . the summary , which splits the source identification into three broad classes ( extragalactic , stars , and unknown ) is given in table 5 . one item stands out immediately , that is the low number of `` unknown '' sources in the dorado and m83 fields . in these two faust fields the percentage of such sources is 19% and 5% , respectively , while it is @xmath030% in the other two fields . the only difference between the first pair of fields and the second is that for dor and m83 we used the additional information from the he s survey . this indicates that using the he s resource we could classify ( in broad spectral types ) an additional @xmath015% of the faust uv source , some of which belong to the interesting `` hot , evolved '' stellar variety . in this context , an important statistic is the number of such sources ( sub - dwarfs and white dwarfs ) counted in each field . whereas the images without he s data have extremely few such sources ( one in cen and none in tel ) , the other two fields contain significantly more sources ( nine in dor and five in m83 ) . this emphasizes the importance of additional spectral information in untangling the nature of the ( optically faint ) hot uv sources . a comparison of the detected and identified stars with the predicted number of stars , using the updated model of the uv galaxy of brosch ( 1991 ) . the original model uses the bahcall & soneira ( 1980 ) predictor routines , where the milky way is approximated as an exponential disk and a bulge , each with its own luminosity function . the extinction by dust is treated by assuming a slab - like distribution of dust along the galactic equator with an exponential scale height above the disk . the bahcall & soneira model yields predictions for optical bands , and it has also been extended to the near - ir . the uv application of this model uses an optical - to - uv transformation for stars based on their colours . this was derived from iue observations and was extended to late - type stars using kurucz ( 1991 ) model atmospheres . in addition , the uv predictor model includes the gould belt , and a thick disk of white dwarfs with the scale height determined by boyle ( 1989 ) . the comparison of the observations with the model predictions is shown in figures 7 and 8 . we show there the distribution of the differential star counts ( number of stars per uv magnitude ) vs. the model predictions in the left panels , where the actual star counts are represented by squares with error bars derived from poisson statistics . the right - hand plot for each region corresponds to the distribution of colours . to produce this , we deleted from the star list those objects classified as `` hot evolved stars '' , such as hot wds and sd s , based on the catalog information or on data extracted from the he s spectra , because they are not predicted well by our model . we also deleted all the extragalactic objects , which are not included in the predictor model . our model predicts the star numbers and magnitude distributions per square degree , and the predicted colour distribution depends on the faint magnitude cutoff . the fainter this cutoff , the redder is the peak and the median colour of the stellar distribution . allowing fainter stars in the calculation of the colour distribution brings in more red objects than blue ones , driving the total distribution to the red . the actual cutoff in a specific faust exposure is location - dependent . this is because the exposure depth is shallower the closer an object is to the edge of the faust image , the part of the area with the low exposure time . for this reason , we adopted the following strategy when scaling the predictions to the `` effective area '' surveyed : 1 . we selected a magnitude cutoff for the colour prediction at 70% of the peak in the magnitude distribution . that is , we set the cutoff to a fainter magnitude than the peak of the magnitude distribution of the specific field , at the ( interpolated ) magnitude level where the stellar magnitude distribution reached 70% of the peak value . we decided on a scaling constant from the `` per square degree '' prediction of the model and the real star counts in * both * the magnitude and colour distributions using the total number of stars detected to be brighter than or equal to m@xmath19=11 [ n(m@xmath20 ) ] and the similar number of stars , brighter than 11 mag , predicted by the model [ n(m@xmath21 ) ] . the ratio of these values was used to scale both the magnitude distribution prediction and the colour distribution prediction . the actual detected distributions , and those predicted by the model and scaled as explained above , are shown in figures 7 and 8 . in deriving the uv - v colour of an object we used the magitude of the counterpart as listed in table 4 . in many cases , this is the usno catalog `` blue '' magnitude , which may be substantially different from the actual v magnitude of the objects . however , we estimate that this is a random error , which will only increase the scatter of the results but will not introduce a systematic bias , as most of the stars that have spectral types tend to be a and f , which have small b v values . the results , shown in figures 7 and 8 for the four fields , indicate that the procedure is valid and that the predicted stellar populations , as well as the general colour distributions , correspond to those actually observed . we emphasize that , while the choice of the scaling factor seems arbitrary by using the total number of stars to 11 mag . , the use of the same constant for scaling the colour distribution is a constraint , and the subsequent reasonable fit represents an independent confirmation of this procedure . the possible sources of discrepancy between the model predictions and the actual measurements are presumably stars that are too blue in the uv than the model is able to predict . such stars are , for example , hot evolved objects that are not included in the model . the discrepancy is emphasized by the trend of the plots in the right panels of figs . 7 and 8 to under - predict the observed colour distribution at the blue end . this indicates that probably there are more hot evolved stars among those observed by faust than revealed by the spectroscopic classification . the assumption is supported by the size of the under - prediction : the discrepancy is higher for the two fields where we do not have he s spectroscopic data than in the two fields with such data . this finding indicates that collections of uv observations have the potential of enlarging the samples of such objects , with obvious influences on our understanding of the structure and evolution of the milky way . in this section we discuss those stellar sources classified as either hot evolved stars ( sd s , wds , etc . ) , or as red stars ( k0 and later ) , which represent the hot and the cold extremes of the stellar distribution . it is noticeable that of 24 such objects in the four faust fields treated here , only two are in a image for which we have no he s information . this demonstrates , again , the value of ancilliary spectral information from which we extract the special - interest objects . we identified 15 stars as hot evolved objects , mostly in the dor and m83 fields . these are relatively faint uv sources , with a median magnitude of 11.44 , and with very blue colours ( median uv - v , or uv - b=3.65 ) that imply rather faint optical magnitudes . the optical faintness explains the lack of spectral information ; only wide - field surveys using multi - band colours or an objective prism could have picked these objects out . most are sdo , sdb , or sda , but one ( fc 89 ) is classified sdf2 and is indeed very red , with uv - v=3.94 . this is a high proper motion star , as expected of a subdwarf . the source with the most negative colour index is fd 46 , with uv - v=5.03 . we searched the lists of objects for those with extremely blue uv - v colours ( @xmath224 ) and found very few of these . specifically , we detected three such stars in the dor field , three in cen , seven in m83 , and two in tel . six of these are classified in simbad or by us as sub - dwarfs , one is an emission - line galaxy , and for the rest we do not have information beyond the identification with a star - like object and a rough optical magnitude . it is possible that most are also hot sub - dwarfs or binary systems containing hot , evolved stars , and spectroscopic follow - ups are necessary to clarify this point . there are 10 objects classified k0 or later in the four faust fields . as expected of red stars , their uv - v colours are in general large and positive . the colour indices are , though , much bluer than could be expected from the effective temperature which corresponds to their spectral type . the variations of the colour index within the same allocated spectral type are considerable ; among four k2 stars the spread of uv - v is more than 5.5 mag ! normally , k stars are expected to have uv - [email protected] - 7.4 , but some stars in this class are more uv - bright than this , presumably because of some form of coronal activity ( see jordan 1987 ) , or because of the presence of a hot secondary . one object , fm 81 , is classified as a m0 star with an expected uv - [email protected] colour , yet it shows an almost nil colour index . checking with simbad , we find this star to be rw hya , a well - known symbiotic system consisting of an m2 giant and a @xmath080,000k wd ( kenyon & mikolajewska 1995 ) . this demonstrates the advantage of a wide wavelength base , from the uv to the optical , with which to identify potentially peculiar objects . another one , fc 168 , is an m3iii star with uv - v=+5.4 , while we expect for such an object uv - v=+9.67 . although there are no indications in simbad of any peculiarity concerning this star , it is likely that this is yet another binary system , with a hot component responsible for the uv excess . we remarked in earlier papers that metallic - line a stars ( am ) appear fainter in the uv than their regular counterparts . the present study is particularly useful to check this behavior because it yielded a relatively large stellar sample . table 4 lists six am stars ( earlier than a5 ) and one late - bm star . these are plotted as filled squares in the colour - colour diagram shown in figure 9 . the comparison is done with regular a stars from the same faust images . the a0 stars are plotted as circles and the late - a stars ( a7 , a8 , and a9 ) are plotted as filled triangles . we added the reddening vector assuming the standard savage & mathis ( 1979 ) relation as a vector for e(b - v)=0.2 to demonstrate that the discrepancy could not be due to reddening by a standard milky way extinction law . it is clear that the am stars are uv - deficient in comparison to most of the a - type regular stars , including the latest a stars ( a9 ) . this deficiency has been noted before ( by van dijk 1978 ) and is presumably due to line blanketing of their spectral energy distributions . note though that the study of van dijk , and others dealing with the issue of uv deficiency of a stars , concentrated mostly on ap objects rather than on am stars . in principle , this points a way to use the property of these a stars to be less uv - bright than expected from their rough optical spectral classification , to identify possible candidate am ( or ap ) stars from among those objects in our four fields for which we found spectral classifications . the requirement is for good uv and optical photometry of the candidate objects , which should have been previously classified as a stars . fifty - four objects in table 4 have been identified as extragalactic objects . in two instances two optical counterparts could correspond to specific uv sources ; the extragalactic ones are listed in table 6 . as seen in previous cases , faust detected more uv flux than iue in the few instances where such observations are available . in the case of ngc 5253 , the iue spectra yield monochromatic uv magnitudes of [ 1482]=11.03 and [ 1913]=11.39 , whereas faust measured [email protected] mag . the iue measurements refer to `` standard '' bands in the sw spectral range , centered at the listed wavelengths . this discrepancy between faust and iue is undoubtedly the result of measuring a large object with a small aperture . for ngc 5236=fm 83 the faust magnitude is [email protected] whereas iue measured [ 1482]=10.48 and [ 1913]=10.82 . ngc 5135 has [ faust][email protected] and [ 1482]=13.94 and [ 1913]=13.87 , presumably the result of most of the uv emission being produced in the `` composite '' seyfert 2+starburst compact nucleus ( phillips 1983 ) . the amount of uv flux external to the iue aperture may be quite significant in some cases . among the more interesting extragalactic objects detected by faust in these four fields we note m83 ( source fm 70 ) , a starburst galaxy in which no less than six supernovae were discovered in a period of 60 years . a similar case is tol 34 ( source fm 181 ) , which contains a starburst and a sy 2 nucleus . some interacting galaxies appear as uv sources : the compact group of ngc 6845 with four peculiar spirals is such an example . unfortunately , the angular resolution of faust is not sufficient to show which of the objects is the uv source . this group would make an interesting target for a future uv imaging observation . we detected nine uv - emitting galactic nuclei , of which six were identified from the he s spectroscopic data . one of the more interesting such sources is the optically - violent - variable bl lac object euve j2009 - 48.8 ( source ft 34 ) . ours is the first listed uv measurement of this object , which has been detected in @xmath11-rays and xrays , as well as in the euv range . note that the uv - v colour index we measure is based on the optical magnitude listed in the ned . because of the intrinsic variability of a bl lac object , the real colour index may be different from the `` instantaneous '' one . note also the detection of the cd galaxy eso 444-g046 , the largest in the cluster abell 3558 , as a faust uv source . this object has a neutral colour index , uv - v@xmath16 + 0.06 . one other object detected by faust could belong to the same cluster : this is source fm 185 , a star - like object listed only with its gsc number but which showed emission lines in he s spectra and appears almost star - like on the blue plates of the he s . the object was classified by us as an `` emission - line galaxy '' ( elg ) . the colour index exhibited by this galaxy is one magnitude bluer than that of the cd galaxy . the elg is apparently part of a chain of larger galaxies in the cluster , extending from north - west to south - east . lacking a redshift , the assumption that this galaxy is a member of the a3558 cluster remains to be proven . we remarked above on the puzzling discrepancy in the source count between the m83 and the tel areas . briefly , the discrepancy is that these two sky regions , at almost identical @xmath24b@xmath24 , have approximately the same number of uv sources but one ( m83 ) has three times more exposure than the other . the puzzle only deepens when we consider the normalized source count , that is , the projected source density . we first define a representative projected source density for a field @xmath25 as @xmath26 , where @xmath27 is the number of sources brighter than m@xmath19=11 detected in the specific field , and @xmath28 is the angular coverage obtained by faust and listed in table 1 . this magnitude cutoff makes it likely that we are not missing sources that bright even in the image with the shortest exposure time ( 280 sec for the central region of the tel image ) , as indeed the source detection histograms in fig . 5 show . comparing the four values of @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the exposure time for the image of area @xmath25 , we find that the tel regions has a @xmath31 higher than the three other regions , which have almost identical @xmath32 values . the tel region appears to have many more uv sources that it is `` entitled '' to have , given its projected sky area and depth of exposure . the discrepancy can * not * be explained by the galactic model . the modified bahcall - soneira predictions appear to fit reasonably well both the colour and the magnitude distributions of uv sources . one possibility is that the tel region contains even more of the hot , evolved stellar types than do the other three regions . this could , in a way , be understood when considering the pointing direction : the line - of - sight to the tel region grazes the bulge of the galaxy whereas the three other images have wider separations from the galactic center . if the excess of uv sources in the direction of telescopium would be due to hot , horizontal - branch stars in the bulge , these would appear as the sources near the faint completeness limit of the faust exposure . we estimate this from the colours and magnitudes of zero - age horizontal - branch models listed in table 2 of mould ( 1996 ) and from a galactocentric distance of 8 kpc . another possibility could be for the m83 region to have , for some reason , more extinction than the tel area . we checked this using the stars identified as a0 in table 4 . there are 15 such stars in the m83 frame and 11 in the tel image . the mean b v values are [email protected] and [email protected] , respectively . the mean uv v values , on the other hand , are [email protected] and 0.16@xmath2377 , respectively . the difference between the mean b v values of the two regions could imply an expected difference in the mean uv v values of @xmath00.15 , assuming the wavelength dependence of the extinction as in the `` typical '' galactic law ( savage & mathis 1979 ) , whereas we measure @xmath33(uv v)@xmath160.84 . this could be the case if the slope of the extinction law would be steeper in the faust - observed regions than the savage & mathis relation , and is supported also by the slope of the uv v _ vs. _ b v relation for all the a0 stars in table 4 . the 43 objects have a regression slope of [email protected] , whereas the savage & mathis relation indicates a slope of 4.9 . a steeper dependence of the uv extinction may be an indicator for the presence of smaller dust grains than encountered on average in the milky way . we note this as a possibility , but do not explore it further in this paper . we presented faust uv observations in four sky area , mostly in the fourth galactic quadrant . our detection algorithm identified 777 uv sources in these regions . we identified the sources with optical counterparts mainly through correlations with catalogued object , and succeeded in increasing the number and quality of identifications by including objective - prism spectra . the stellar objects detected and identified in this program fit reasonably well our model of the uv galaxy . we discussed the more interesting stellar and extragalactic sources , and pointed out that the tel area may contain horizontal branch stars on the outskirts of the galactic bulge . this paper made use of the simbad data bank , established and maintained by the centre du donnes stellaire in strasbourg . the paper is dedicated to the memory of dr . barry lasker , one of the `` founding fathers '' of the guide star catalog and of other catalogs derived from scanning of photographic plates . uv research at tel aviv university is supported by grants from the ministry of science and arts through the israel space agency , from the austrian friends of tel aviv university , and from a center of excellence award from the israel science foundation . nb acknowledges support from a us - israel binational award to study uv sources measured by the faust experiment . we are grateful to mr . benny bilenko for updating the model of uv stellar distributions in the milky way . constuctive remarks by an anonymous referee are gratefully acknowledged . alfaro , e. & efremov , yu . n. 1996 , rev.mex.a.a . , 4 , 1 bahcall , j.n . & soneira , r.m . 1980 astrophys . j. suppl 44 , 73 . boyle , b.j . 1989 mon . not . 240 , 533 . bowyer , s. , sasseen , t.p . , lampton , m. & wu , x. 1993 , apj , 415 , 875 bowyer , s. , sasseen , p.t . , xiauyi , w. & lampton , m. 1995 , apjs , 96 , 461 ( fsc ) brosch , n. 1991 , mnras , 250 , 780 brosch , n. , almoznino , e. , leibowitz , e.m . , netzer , h. , sasseen , t. , bowyer , s. , lampton , m. & wu , x. 1995 , apj , 450 , 137 brosch , n. , formiggini , l. , almoznino , e. , sasseen , t. , lampton , m. & bowyer , s. 1997 , apjs , 111 , 143 brosch , n. , ofek , e. , almoznino , e. , sasseen , t. , lampton , m. , & bowyer , s. 1998 , mnras , 295 , 959 esa `` the hipparcos and tycho catalogues '' 1997 , esa sp-1200 hagen , h .- j . , groote , d. , engels , d. & reimers , d. 1995 , a&as , 111 , 195 jordan , c. , ayres , t.r . , brown , a. , linsky , j.l . & simon , t. 1987 , mnras , 225 , 903 kenyon , s.j . & mikolajewska , j. 1995 , aj , 110 , 391 kurucz , r.l . 1991 nato asi ser . c. , math . , 341 , 441 . lampton , m. , sasseen , t.p . , wu , x. & bowyer , s. 1993 , geophys . res . lett . * 20 * , 539 lasker , b. , jenkner , h. & russell , j.l . 1988 in `` mapping the sky : past heritage and future directions '' ( s. debarat , ed . ) , dordrecht : kluwer , p. 229 . monet , d. 1996 , `` usno - a1.0 catralog '' , washigton : u.s . naval observatory monet , d. 1998 , `` usno - a2.0 catalog '' , washigton : u.s . naval observatory mould , j.r . , watson , a.m. , gallagher , j.s . iii , ballester , g.e . , burrows , c.j . , casertano , s. , clarke , j.t . , crisp , d. , griffiths , r.e . , hester , j.j . , hoessel , j.g . , holtzman , j.a . , scowen , p.a . , stapelfeldt , k.r . , trauger , j.t . & westphal , j.a . 1996 , apj , 461 , 762 paturel , g. , vauglin , i. , garnier , r. , marthinet , m.c . , petit , c. , di nella , h. , bottinelli , l. , gouguenheim , l. & durand , n. 1992 _ leda : the lyon - meudon extragalactic database _ , cd - rom observatorie de lyon phillips , m.m . , charles , p.a . & baldwin , j.a . 1983 , apj , 266 , 485 reimers , d. & wisotzki , l. 1997 , the messenger , 88 , 14 sao 1966 , `` smithsonian astrophysical observatory star catalog '' , washington : smithsonian institution , publication no . 4652 savage , b.d . & mathis , j.s . 1979 , araa , 17 , 73 thompson , g.i . , nandy , k. , jamar , c. , monfils , a. , houziaux , l. , carnochan , d.j . & wilson , r. 1978 , _ catalogue of stellar ultraviolet fluxes _ , the science research council ( td-1 ) turon , c. 1993 bull . cds 43 . van dijk , w. , kerssiers , a. , hammerschlag - hensberg , g. & wesselius , p.r . 1978 , a&a , 66 , 187 vanelle , c. 1996 , msc thesis , hamburger sternwarte wisotzki , l. , kohler , t. , groote , d. & reimers , d. 1996 , a&as , 115 , 227 cccccccccc dor & 04 15 36 & -56 04 12 & 266.0 & -43.7 & 200 - 610 & 60.5 & 142 & 58 & 12.7 cen & 12 47 24 & -40 46 12 & 302.1 & 22.1 & 300 - 1100 & 62.0 & 249 & 129 & 12.5 m83 & 13 34 48 & -28 45 00 & 314.3 & 33.2 & 250 - 850 & 60.1 & 197 & 81 & 13.0 tel & 20 11 38 & -47 06 00 & 352.5 & -32.8 & 100 - 280 & 52.6 & 189 & 105 & 12.35 fc 1 & 12 47 36 & -37 23 22 & 11.85 & 0.40 & 3466 fc 2 & 12 55 45 & -37 17 35 & 11.26 & 0.32 & 3574 fc 3 & 12 40 22 & -37 51 52 & 7.99 & 0.17 & 3350 fc 4 & 12 56 32 & -37 39 28 & 11.75 & 0.29 & 3580 fc 5 & 12 41 54 & -37 53 32 & 10.07 & 0.21 & 3378 fc 6 & 12 42 37 & -37 54 09 & 11.30 & 0.23 & 3392 fc 7 & 13 03 21 & -37 44 39 & 10.73 & 0.29 & 3654 fc 8 & 12 56 50 & -37 57 31 & 12.19 & 0.36 & 3584 fc 9 & 12 52 21 & -38 02 20 & 13.23 & 0.76 & 3538 fc 10 & 12 53 32 & -38 03 43 & 12.56 & 0.45 & 3548 fc 11 & 12 38 03 & -38 15 09 & 11.50 & 0.33 & 3304 fc 12 & 12 49 58 & -38 18 24 & 12.36 & 0.39 & 3510 fc 13 & 12 43 48 & -38 20 52 & 11.85 & 0.34 & 3410 fc 14 & 12 48 21 & -38 22 30 & 11.40 & 0.25 & 3481 fc 15 & 12 39 42 & -38 24 46 & 11.98 & 0.37 & 3333 fc 16 & 13 04 38 & -38 23 54 & 9.39 & 0.19 & 3665 fc 17 & 12 39 09 & -38 44 46 & 10.08 & 0.20 & 3317 fc 18 & 12 34 51 & -38 49 43 & 10.39 & 0.23 & 3253 fc 19 & 12 59 41 & -38 42 32 & 8.81 & 0.17 & 3614 fc 20 & 12 47 45 & -38 51 16 & 10.49 & 0.20 & 3467 fc 21 & 12 45 27 & -38 51 25 & 11.19 & 0.24 & 3434 fc 22 & 13 00 35 & -38 44 38 & 12.24 & 0.28 & 3631 fc 23 & 12 58 01 & -38 55 04 & 7.48 & 0.16 & 3599 fc 24 & 12 40 19 & -39 02 42 & 13.07 & 0.83 & 3346 fc 25 & 12 51 54 & -38 58 24 & 13.58 & 0.92 & 3526 fc 26 & 12 31 48 & -39 13 14 & 10.70 & 0.30 & 3208 fc 27 & 12 52 43 & -39 03 40 & 12.16 & 0.40 & 3542 fc 28 & 12 58 53 & -39 06 28 & 6.73 & 0.16 & 3608 fc 29 & 13 03 37 & -38 58 24 & 10.58 & 0.20 & 3657 fc 30 & 12 57 11 & -39 06 51 & 10.80 & 0.22 & 3587 fc 31 & 13 01 04 & -39 03 05 & 11.79 & 0.30 & 3633 fc 32 & 12 36 10 & -39 22 40 & 12.51 & 0.58 & 3276 fc 33 & 12 58 01 & -39 16 06 & 9.85 & 0.18 & 3600 fc 34 & 12 50 26 & -39 26 33 & 10.94 & 0.25 & ? fc 35 & 13 00 40 & -39 17 38 & 11.67 & 0.27 & 3629 fc 36 & 12 58 12 & -39 22 23 & 11.24 & 0.20 & 3601 fc 37 & 12 53 46 & -39 29 10 & 10.85 & 0.22 & 3553 fc 38 & 12 39 18 & -39 39 35 & 9.89 & 0.22 & 3320 fc 39 & 12 52 01 & -39 41 41 & 5.23 & 0.16 & 3529 fc 40 & 12 49 09 & -39 43 25 & 5.82 & 0.16 & 3498 fc 41 & 12 35 58 & -39 52 00 & 5.22 & 0.16 & 3271 fc 42 & 12 44 12 & -39 46 12 & 9.60 & 0.18 & 3420 fc 43 & 12 39 53 & -39 58 08 & 5.42 & 0.16 & 3338 fc 44 & 12 42 08 & -40 04 42 & 10.66 & 0.26 & 3386 fc 45 & 12 43 26 & -40 10 42 & 8.47 & 0.17 & 3407 fc 46 & 12 53 25 & -40 11 10 & 6.04 & 0.16 & 3545 fc 47 & 12 31 29 & -40 16 34 & 10.63 & 0.24 & 3198 fc 48 & 12 49 41 & -40 13 26 & 12.30 & 0.46 & 3507 fc 49 & 13 03 33 & -40 14 59 & 12.64 & 0.40 & 3655 fc 50 & 12 40 21 & -40 37 31 & 10.91 & 0.24 & 3348 fc 51 & 12 49 12 & -40 37 58 & 10.12 & 0.19 & 3501 fc 52 & 12 34 13 & -40 49 54 & 11.17 & 0.24 & 3245 fc 53 & 12 48 40 & -40 42 36 & 12.77 & 0.32 & 3486 fc 54 & 12 59 07 & -40 37 53 & 11.85 & 0.33 & 3610 fc 55 & 12 51 35 & -40 44 18 & 13.81 & 1.04 & 3524 fc 56 & 12 35 46 & -41 01 15 & 6.94 & 0.16 & 3270 fc 57 & 12 46 54 & -40 53 27 & 11.60 & 0.27 & 3458 fc 58 & 13 04 47 & -40 42 34 & 11.85 & 0.30 & 3666 fc 59 & 12 52 31 & -40 56 22 & 10.71 & 0.21 & 3539 fc 60 & 12 59 55 & -40 52 40 & 9.57 & 0.18 & 3619 fc 61 & 12 45 15 & -41 02 35 & 13.06 & 0.57 & 3431 fc 62 & 13 07 39 & -40 45 59 & 12.50 & 0.49 & 3680 fc 63 & 12 38 19 & -41 12 22 & 9.76 & 0.19 & 3308 fc 64 & 12 44 40 & -41 13 17 & 12.85 & 0.52 & 3429 fc 65 & 12 51 01 & -41 15 06 & 10.22 & 0.18 & 3519 fc 66 & 12 33 35 & -41 25 24 & 8.87 & 0.17 & 3232 fc 67 & 12 52 16 & -41 19 40 & 8.01 & 0.16 & 3536 fc 68 & 13 10 37 & -40 56 50 & 11.09 & 0.28 & 3702 fc 69 & 12 31 32 & -41 31 47 & 10.15 & 0.21 & 3199 fc 70 & 13 02 40 & -41 13 42 & 11.58 & 0.26 & 3648 fc 71 & 12 47 50 & -41 28 01 & 12.58 & 0.43 & 3470 fc 72 & 12 59 55 & -41 23 11 & 11.04 & 0.22 & 3620 fc 73 & 12 43 14 & -41 36 15 & 11.97 & 0.35 & 3403 fc 74 & 13 08 15 & -41 23 05 & 9.00 & 0.17 & 3684 fc 75 & 13 04 01 & -41 24 09 & 12.65 & 0.44 & 3662 fc 76 & 12 50 25 & -41 42 59 & 11.24 & 0.26 & 3516 fc 77 & 12 59 14 & -41 36 27 & 8.94 & 0.17 & 3611 fc 78 & 12 39 26 & -41 50 48 & 9.57 & 0.18 & 3328 fc 79 & 13 05 00 & -41 30 41 & 14.48 & 2.02 & 3667 fc 80 & 12 33 50 & -41 57 49 & 11.24 & 0.28 & 3239 fc 81 & 12 30 29 & -41 57 11 & 11.05 & 0.27 & 3185 fc 82 & 12 50 25 & -41 54 09 & 10.20 & 0.20 & 3515 fc 83 & 12 37 24 & -42 01 19 & 12.22 & 0.36 & 3292 fc 84 & 13 03 01 & -41 46 57 & 10.48 & 0.20 & 3651 fc 85 & 12 56 46 & -41 55 04 & 12.09 & 0.38 & 3582 fc 86 & 12 44 19 & -42 05 35 & 12.70 & 0.50 & 3422 fc 87 & 13 01 06 & -41 58 55 & 11.48 & 0.26 & 3634 fc 88 & 12 56 09 & -42 09 10 & 7.87 & 0.17 & 3576 fc 89 & 12 36 14 & -42 18 47 & 11.92 & 0.35 & 3275 fc 90 & 12 58 23 & -42 05 43 & 13.31 & 0.80 & 3603 fc 91 & 13 07 33 & -42 01 59 & 9.37 & 0.18 & 3678 fc 92 & 12 55 10 & -42 18 26 & 4.98 & 0.16 & 3569 fc 93 & 12 39 45 & -42 21 41 & 12.09 & 0.39 & 3335 fc 94 & 13 10 06 & -42 12 23 & 9.21 & 0.18 & 3697 fc 95 & 12 37 30 & -42 35 45 & 11.20 & 0.25 & 3293 fc 96 & 13 11 08 & -42 12 60 & 11.43 & 0.25 & 3703 fc 97 & 13 00 16 & -42 29 48 & 11.74 & 0.29 & 3624 fc 98 & 13 01 28 & -42 29 59 & 12.20 & 0.34 & 3636 fc 99 & 13 02 12 & -42 28 60 & 13.25 & 0.40 & 3646 fc 100 & 12 39 33 & -42 58 09 & 11.60 & 0.33 & 3329 fc 101 & 12 52 05 & -42 55 28 & 10.53 & 0.21 & 3530 fc 102 & 12 38 01 & -43 01 17 & 12.49 & 0.33 & 3305 fc 103 & 12 45 59 & -43 05 06 & 7.91 & 0.16 & 3444 fc 104 & 12 38 03 & -43 03 35 & 12.51 & 0.33 & ? fc 105 & 12 53 29 & -43 04 17 & 9.41 & 0.18 & 3546 fc 106 & 12 51 40 & -43 10 34 & 11.46 & 0.30 & 3525 fc 107 & 12 49 28 & -43 12 44 & 14.67 & 2.49 & 3503 fc 108 & 12 48 22 & -43 19 37 & 11.89 & 0.35 & 3482 fc 109 & 12 41 31 & -43 37 55 & 9.46 & 0.18 & 3372 fc 110 & 13 01 30 & -43 22 37 & 10.42 & 0.20 & 3639 fc 111 & 13 02 39 & -43 20 59 & 10.36 & 0.21 & 3647 fc 112 & 12 48 45 & -43 42 36 & 7.55 & 0.16 & 3489 fc 113 & 13 08 57 & -43 27 50 & 8.38 & 0.17 & 3689 fc 114 & 12 35 49 & -43 49 27 & 11.35 & 0.31 & 3269 fc 115 & 12 42 02 & -43 53 10 & 11.96 & 0.35 & 3379 fc 116 & 12 56 14 & -43 46 40 & 11.70 & 0.32 & 3577 fc 117 & 12 49 02 & -43 56 26 & 9.51 & 0.18 & 3494 fc 118 & 13 00 55 & -43 47 50 & 10.83 & 0.24 & 3632 fc 119 & 12 43 22 & -44 00 13 & 12.09 & 0.28 & 3404 fc 120 & 12 42 49 & -44 05 49 & 11.72 & 0.26 & 3395 fc 121 & 12 59 20 & -43 59 42 & 11.01 & 0.24 & 3613 fc 122 & 13 04 58 & -43 54 50 & 10.49 & 0.23 & 3668 fc 123 & 12 55 10 & -44 10 27 & 12.27 & 0.35 & 3567 fc 124 & 12 41 25 & -44 17 34 & 13.25 & 1.03 & 3368 fc 125 & 13 06 11 & -44 06 08 & 11.80 & 0.45 & 3674 fc 126 & 12 54 15 & -44 23 15 & 12.16 & 0.35 & 3559 fc 127 & 12 43 06 & -44 34 02 & 10.56 & 0.23 & 3401 fc 128 & 12 48 18 & -44 43 22 & 5.92 & 0.16 & 3479 fc 129 & 12 41 14 & -44 41 51 & 11.06 & 0.30 & 3363 fc 130 & 13 06 15 & -44 24 36 & 9.92 & 0.22 & 3673 fc 131 & 12 45 30 & -44 43 49 & 11.01 & 0.25 & 3437 fc 132 & 13 03 25 & -44 34 04 & 8.75 & 0.18 & 3653 fc 133 & 13 01 20 & -44 45 55 & 5.69 & 0.16 & 3635 fc 134 & 12 56 24 & -44 51 50 & 11.93 & 0.40 & 3578 fc 135 & 13 04 04 & -44 55 37 & 10.34 & 0.27 & 3663 fc 136 & 12 53 52 & -45 05 47 & 11.64 & 0.36 & 3555 fc 137 & 13 01 29 & -45 11 02 & 9.40 & 0.21 & 3637 fc 138 & 12 48 39 & -45 25 42 & 10.85 & 0.27 & 3488 fc 139 & 12 46 05 & -45 29 59 & 9.98 & 0.23 & 3448 fc 140 & 12 52 24 & -45 30 01 & 11.16 & 0.37 & 3537 fc 141 & 12 44 33 & -37 18 20 & 11.95 & 0.46 & ? fc 142 & 12 53 14 & -37 34 32 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fc 143 & 12 45 01 & -37 43 04 & 12.41 & 0.51 & ? fc 144 & 12 50 55 & -37 50 52 & 12.81 & 0.64 & ? fc 145 & 13 00 32 & -37 49 28 & 12.16 & 0.44 & ? fc 146 & 12 32 32 & -38 31 40 & 11.72 & 0.37 & ? fc 147 & 12 32 38 & -38 34 39 & 11.77 & 0.37 & ? fc 148 & 12 50 20 & -38 29 37 & 13.22 & 0.80 & 3514 fc 149 & 12 36 00 & -38 38 02 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fc 150 & 12 56 00 & -38 39 57 & 15.18 & 3.90 & ? fc 151 & 12 53 32 & -38 47 20 & 13.23 & 0.76 & 3544 fc 152 & 12 44 09 & -38 58 16 & 13.96 & 1.38 & ? fc 153 & 12 49 39 & -39 01 08 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fc 154 & 12 44 42 & -39 06 17 & 13.55 & 0.86 & ? fc 155 & 12 40 10 & -39 22 23 & 11.77 & 0.33 & 3344 fc 156 & 12 41 23 & -39 25 15 & 12.36 & 0.45 & ? fc 157 & 13 00 02 & -39 14 40 & 12.64 & 0.28 & 3621 fc 158 & 12 54 19 & -39 19 14 & 12.19 & 0.36 & 3560 fc 159 & 12 43 12 & -39 31 42 & 12.25 & 0.40 & 3402 fc 160 & 12 47 27 & -39 30 35 & 13.94 & 0.68 & ? fc 161 & 12 47 27 & -39 32 58 & 13.32 & 0.45 & ? fc 162 & 12 30 26 & -39 40 36 & 12.49 & 0.71 & ? fc 163 & 12 45 13 & -39 37 46 & 14.01 & 1.42 & ? fc 164 & 12 33 23 & -39 48 36 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fc 165 & 12 47 33 & -39 47 24 & 11.51 & 0.27 & 3465 fc 166 & 12 49 37 & -39 54 43 & 12.85 & 0.48 & ? fc 167 & 12 34 38 & -40 01 57 & 11.21 & 0.32 & ? fc 168 & 12 47 21 & -40 06 59 & 13.81 & 1.32 & ? fc 169 & 13 09 18 & -39 51 04 & 16.14 & 0.16 & ? fc 170 & 12 30 34 & -40 16 59 & 12.41 & 0.37 & ? fc 171 & 12 45 27 & -40 18 07 & 13.81 & 1.09 & ? fc 172 & 12 47 53 & -40 22 24 & 11.62 & 0.73 & ? fc 173 & 12 38 12 & -40 29 26 & 11.30 & 0.30 & ? fc 174 & 12 56 36 & -40 21 02 & 12.97 & 0.58 & ? fc 175 & 12 59 20 & -40 25 47 & 10.04 & 0.19 & 3612 fc 176 & 12 58 18 & -40 36 17 & 14.97 & 1.65 & ? fc 177 & 12 36 57 & -40 50 55 & 13.29 & 0.82 & ? fc 178 & 13 01 46 & -40 36 22 & 12.02 & 0.32 & 3642 fc 179 & 13 04 42 & -40 32 08 & 13.64 & 0.54 & ? fc 180 & 13 07 47 & -40 30 09 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fc 181 & 13 11 23 & -40 28 46 & 12.16 & 0.55 & ? fc 182 & 12 38 51 & -41 01 41 & 13.65 & 1.08 & ? fc 183 & 12 33 56 & -41 02 06 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fc 184 & 12 32 04 & -41 04 27 & 15.87 & 9.24 & 3213 fc 185 & 12 50 00 & -41 05 35 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fc 186 & 12 59 17 & -40 59 13 & 13.68 & 0.61 & ? fc 187 & 12 49 05 & -41 11 57 & 12.92 & 0.57 & ? fc 188 & 13 05 57 & -40 56 55 & 13.97 & 1.38 & ? fc 189 & 12 41 45 & -41 17 18 & 12.78 & 0.59 & ? fc 190 & 12 38 17 & -41 22 22 & 14.59 & 1.11 & ? fc 191 & 12 30 06 & -41 24 33 & 12.02 & 0.44 & ? fc 192 & 12 58 50 & -41 10 32 & 13.02 & 0.59 & ? fc 193 & 12 53 41 & -41 18 59 & 15.09 & 3.51 & 3550 fc 194 & 12 33 02 & -41 38 48 & 17.55 & 0.16 & ? fc 195 & 13 10 44 & -41 19 13 & 12.03 & 0.38 & ? fc 196 & 12 45 48 & -41 49 08 & 14.74 & 2.19 & ? fc 197 & 12 52 02 & -41 52 05 & 13.06 & 0.39 & ? fc 198 & 12 52 36 & -41 56 33 & 12.85 & 0.38 & ? fc 199 & 12 52 46 & -41 58 17 & 13.02 & 0.42 & ? fc 200 & 12 53 18 & -42 00 55 & 12.61 & 0.32 & ? fc 201 & 12 42 43 & -42 10 01 & 13.14 & 0.70 & ? fc 202 & 13 08 17 & -41 57 20 & 13.00 & 0.49 & ? fc 203 & 12 42 01 & -42 17 44 & 14.13 & 1.69 & 3383 fc 204 & 13 01 25 & -42 07 19 & 13.80 & 0.62 & ? fc 205 & 13 04 28 & -42 06 35 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fc 206 & 12 49 14 & -42 27 49 & 16.28 & 9.22 & ? fc 207 & 12 46 01 & -42 31 38 & 15.17 & 3.01 & ? fc 208 & 12 39 02 & -42 34 49 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fc 209 & 12 52 11 & -42 31 26 & 12.81 & 0.64 & ? fc 210 & 12 35 17 & -42 38 58 & 12.48 & 0.53 & 3264 fc 211 & 12 49 07 & -42 38 11 & 13.50 & 0.83 & 3495 fc 212 & 12 51 22 & -42 43 03 & 12.66 & 0.48 & ? fc 213 & 12 59 42 & -42 35 02 & 13.16 & 0.44 & ? fc 214 & 12 44 16 & -42 46 34 & 13.98 & 1.30 & 3418 fc 215 & 13 08 51 & -42 27 57 & 13.66 & 1.17 & 3688 fc 216 & 12 47 52 & -42 48 46 & 14.45 & 2.25 & ? fc 217 & 12 44 22 & -43 02 09 & 12.64 & 0.50 & ? fc 218 & 13 10 02 & -42 41 48 & 12.14 & 0.46 & ? fc 219 & 12 41 21 & -43 15 57 & 13.56 & 1.15 & ? fc 220 & 13 04 17 & -43 02 40 & 14.07 & 0.91 & ? fc 221 & 13 01 51 & -43 05 11 & 14.34 & 1.69 & ? fc 222 & 12 39 00 & -43 25 44 & 12.54 & 0.49 & 3312 fc 223 & 13 04 29 & -43 08 36 & 13.27 & 0.54 & ? fc 224 & 12 44 43 & -43 25 14 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fc 225 & 12 57 47 & -43 17 47 & 12.78 & 0.35 & 3591 fc 226 & 12 57 04 & -43 19 39 & 12.98 & 0.43 & ? fc 227 & 12 58 53 & -43 27 14 & 11.62 & 1.01 & ? fc 228 & 13 00 32 & -43 25 24 & 13.44 & 0.49 & ? fc 229 & 13 10 05 & -43 16 00 & 11.92 & 0.46 & ? fc 230 & 13 04 32 & -43 23 45 & 12.77 & 0.59 & ? fc 231 & 13 02 55 & -43 31 37 & 13.48 & 0.63 & ? fc 232 & 13 07 20 & -43 35 40 & 13.25 & 1.03 & ? fc 233 & 13 02 19 & -43 40 23 & 14.42 & 2.37 & ? fc 234 & 13 08 22 & -43 40 12 & 14.24 & 3.01 & ? fc 235 & 12 59 06 & -43 51 13 & 12.74 & 0.34 & 3609 fc 236 & 12 51 07 & -44 12 28 & 13.62 & 1.21 & ? fc 237 & 12 58 52 & -44 18 45 & 15.73 & 7.63 & ? fc 238 & 13 00 44 & -44 15 45 & 12.58 & 0.61 & ? fc 239 & 12 48 57 & -44 28 34 & 12.98 & 0.46 & ? fc 240 & 13 03 53 & -44 20 17 & 12.57 & 0.42 & ? fc 241 & 13 03 58 & -44 22 34 & 12.86 & 0.52 & ? fc 242 & 12 59 55 & -44 27 30 & 11.71 & 0.40 & ? fc 243 & 12 51 09 & -44 51 50 & 11.84 & 0.38 & ? fc 244 & 12 57 28 & -45 07 36 & 12.00 & 0.48 & ? fc 245 & 12 57 23 & -45 26 17 & 12.69 & 1.26 & ? fc 246 & 12 58 50 & -40 27 18 & 11.23 & 0.21 & ? fc 247 & 12 51 41 & -41 18 49 & 9.52 & 0.17 & 3522 fc 248 & 12 52 43 & -41 11 23 & 12.18 & 0.27 & 3541 fc 249 & 12 52 10 & -43 02 07 & 12.10 & 0.27 & 3531 fd 1 & 3 48 31 & -54 16 44 & 9.22 & 0.20 & 497 fd 2 & 3 52 58 & -54 05 47 & 9.36 & 0.19 & 499 fd 3 & 3 53 27 & -54 50 39 & 6.13 & 0.16 & 500 fd 4 & 4 03 38 & -52 55 38 & 10.87 & 0.24 & 516 fd 5 & 3 48 06 & -56 41 44 & 12.74 & 0.93 & 496 fd 6 & 3 59 59 & -54 10 23 & 12.25 & 0.43 & 509 fd 7 & 3 57 09 & -55 05 33 & 12.32 & 0.49 & 505 fd 8 & 4 00 59 & -54 23 16 & 8.82 & 0.17 & 510 fd 9 & 3 51 37 & -56 39 25 & 9.56 & 0.19 & 498 fd 10 & 4 03 16 & -54 39 51 & 11.66 & 0.30 & 514 fd 11 & 3 56 30 & -56 19 37 & 11.72 & 0.33 & 504 fd 12 & 3 57 42 & -56 15 16 & 11.17 & 0.26 & 506 fd 13 & 4 03 49 & -55 24 23 & 9.14 & 0.18 & 518 fd 14 & 4 15 23 & -52 09 32 & 9.33 & 0.19 & 534 fd 15 & 3 59 35 & -56 28 21 & 9.46 & 0.18 & 508 fd 16 & 4 10 25 & -53 34 56 & 12.27 & 0.36 & 525 fd 17 & 4 01 12 & -56 19 48 & 8.91 & 0.17 & 512 fd 18 & 3 58 37 & -57 06 20 & 10.56 & 0.22 & 507 fd 19 & 4 11 07 & -54 03 12 & 12.73 & 0.56 & 528 fd 20 & 4 11 43 & -53 51 17 & 12.93 & 0.68 & ? fd 21 & 4 13 41 & -53 26 35 & 11.26 & 0.25 & 531 fd 22 & 3 55 52 & -58 19 19 & 11.99 & 0.46 & 503 fd 23 & 4 18 36 & -52 52 09 & 11.27 & 0.26 & 542 fd 24 & 4 09 24 & -55 44 52 & 12.53 & 0.53 & 524 fd 25 & 4 02 39 & -57 27 48 & 11.38 & 0.30 & 513 fd 26 & 4 06 34 & -56 34 50 & 10.94 & 0.25 & 522 fd 27 & 4 16 05 & -54 01 25 & 11.93 & 0.36 & 537 fd 28 & 4 04 25 & -57 09 57 & 11.89 & 0.33 & 519 fd 29 & 4 15 26 & -54 22 43 & 10.60 & 0.21 & 536 fd 30 & 4 19 22 & -53 19 25 & 12.26 & 0.39 & 545 fd 31 & 4 00 53 & -58 39 30 & 7.76 & 0.17 & 511 fd 32 & 4 18 46 & -54 08 43 & 7.49 & 0.16 & 543 fd 33 & 4 19 05 & -53 51 01 & 12.45 & 0.45 & 544 fd 34 & 4 19 59 & -54 04 45 & 10.53 & 0.21 & 548 fd 35 & 4 17 09 & -54 58 14 & 11.30 & 0.24 & 539 fd 36 & 4 04 58 & -58 09 44 & 12.59 & 0.55 & 520 fd 37 & 4 22 54 & -53 32 18 & 12.57 & 0.43 & 552 fd 38 & 4 05 35 & -58 28 31 & 9.36 & 0.18 & 521 fd 39 & 4 14 07 & -56 11 16 & 12.14 & 0.42 & 533 fd 40 & 4 25 31 & -53 06 01 & 10.40 & 0.23 & 555 fd 41 & 4 19 57 & -54 56 46 & 9.68 & 0.19 & 547 fd 42 & 4 22 34 & -54 09 18 & 10.09 & 0.19 & 551 fd 43 & 4 08 49 & -58 29 04 & 9.56 & 0.18 & 523 fd 44 & 4 23 32 & -54 17 51 & 13.01 & 0.70 & 553 fd 45 & 4 27 24 & -53 23 44 & 11.06 & 0.28 & 562 fd 46 & 4 28 30 & -53 27 15 & 10.10 & 0.20 & 565 fd 47 & 4 17 30 & -56 44 23 & 12.74 & 0.52 & 540 fd 48 & 4 13 40 & -58 01 10 & 9.14 & 0.18 & 532 fd 49 & 4 29 39 & -53 13 03 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fd 50 & 4 11 39 & -58 41 36 & 12.30 & 0.44 & 529 fd 51 & 4 25 48 & -55 07 15 & 11.90 & 0.35 & 556 fd 52 & 4 31 12 & -53 35 18 & 11.14 & 0.31 & 567 fd 53 & 4 27 55 & -55 04 09 & 12.29 & 0.48 & 564 fd 54 & 4 22 06 & -56 59 34 & 11.42 & 0.27 & 550 fd 55 & 4 21 19 & -57 32 32 & 12.69 & 0.59 & 549 fd 56 & 4 27 03 & -56 05 19 & 10.12 & 0.20 & 561 fd 57 & 4 24 06 & -57 15 42 & 7.71 & 0.16 & 554 fd 58 & 4 16 39 & -59 17 34 & 9.74 & 0.19 & 538 fd 59 & 4 26 35 & -56 27 53 & 12.15 & 0.37 & 559 fd 60 & 4 19 13 & -58 44 49 & 8.75 & 0.17 & 546 fd 61 & 4 36 18 & -53 42 58 & 8.15 & 0.17 & 572 fd 62 & 4 25 56 & -57 12 13 & 12.03 & 0.36 & 557 fd 63 & 4 34 20 & -55 00 41 & 5.03 & 0.16 & 570 fd 64 & 4 31 08 & -55 55 31 & 11.35 & 0.32 & 566 fd 65 & 4 32 43 & -55 35 23 & 10.28 & 0.21 & 569 fd 66 & 4 36 33 & -54 37 25 & 9.92 & 0.24 & 576 fd 67 & 4 26 33 & -59 06 07 & 10.51 & 0.23 & 560 fd 68 & 4 34 48 & -56 36 07 & 11.51 & 0.29 & 571 fd 69 & 4 36 06 & -56 17 32 & 12.22 & 0.49 & 573 fd 70 & 4 40 50 & -56 02 32 & 10.58 & 0.24 & 584 fd 71 & 4 40 20 & -56 11 39 & 12.29 & 0.32 & 583 fd 72 & 4 37 03 & -57 28 29 & 12.27 & 0.50 & 578 fd 73 & 4 39 21 & -57 19 34 & 11.03 & 0.25 & 582 fd 74 & 4 36 10 & -58 36 40 & 12.21 & 0.56 & 575 fd 75 & 4 42 39 & -56 41 59 & 11.77 & 0.33 & 587 fd 76 & 4 38 51 & -58 58 05 & 8.83 & 0.18 & 580 fd 77 & 4 40 14 & -58 44 35 & 11.64 & 0.39 & ? fd 78 & 4 03 33 & -52 28 53 & 11.07 & 0.29 & 515 fd 79 & 3 55 31 & -53 29 43 & 13.68 & 1.56 & ? fd 80 & 3 57 34 & -54 20 33 & 13.39 & 0.94 & ? fd 81 & 3 48 33 & -56 32 11 & 14.59 & 3.76 & ? fd 82 & 4 06 00 & -52 39 49 & 12.62 & 0.57 & ? fd 83 & 3 58 19 & -54 51 39 & 12.38 & 0.39 & ? fd 84 & 3 51 34 & -56 23 23 & 12.24 & 0.56 & ? fd 85 & 4 09 29 & -52 28 06 & 12.69 & 0.63 & ? fd 86 & 4 04 01 & -54 04 22 & 12.90 & 0.67 & ? fd 87 & 4 13 30 & -52 24 19 & 13.56 & 1.12 & ? fd 88 & 4 00 14 & -56 05 14 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fd 89 & 4 06 09 & -54 35 51 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fd 90 & 4 13 23 & -52 53 27 & 13.71 & 1.18 & 530 fd 91 & 3 55 11 & -57 45 16 & 13.22 & 1.01 & ? fd 92 & 4 03 47 & -56 01 00 & 13.17 & 0.89 & ? fd 93 & 4 06 59 & -55 19 29 & 12.89 & 0.68 & ? fd 94 & 4 12 55 & -54 01 46 & 13.64 & 0.97 & ? fd 95 & 4 08 50 & -55 37 09 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fd 96 & 4 03 03 & -57 41 48 & 13.50 & 0.98 & ? fd 97 & 4 10 56 & -56 28 58 & 12.92 & 0.58 & 527 fd 98 & 4 00 56 & -58 55 36 & 11.44 & 0.32 & ? fd 99 & 4 03 41 & -58 57 02 & 12.94 & 0.83 & ? fd 100 & 4 26 31 & -53 09 01 & 11.73 & 0.37 & 558 fd 101 & 4 10 21 & -57 47 14 & 12.89 & 0.69 & 526 fd 102 & 4 14 18 & -57 02 59 & 14.31 & 1.89 & ? fd 103 & 4 29 47 & -52 58 52 & 13.13 & 0.95 & ? fd 104 & 4 17 12 & -57 01 21 & 12.93 & 0.64 & ? fd 105 & 4 26 43 & -54 16 53 & 13.17 & 0.81 & ? fd 106 & 4 23 34 & -55 53 51 & 13.36 & 0.90 & ? fd 107 & 4 11 47 & -59 08 38 & 12.61 & 0.52 & ? fd 108 & 4 31 54 & -53 29 58 & 13.93 & 1.01 & ? fd 109 & 4 17 15 & -58 11 30 & 12.45 & 0.52 & 541 fd 110 & 4 33 51 & -53 09 36 & 14.89 & 4.19 & ? fd 111 & 4 32 00 & -53 46 44 & 14.16 & 2.76 & ? fd 112 & 4 26 03 & -56 20 39 & 13.21 & 0.41 & ? fd 113 & 4 29 38 & -57 10 21 & 13.23 & 0.81 & ? fd 114 & 4 28 51 & -57 36 39 & 13.02 & 0.70 & ? fd 115 & 4 40 48 & -54 04 44 & 13.03 & 1.01 & ? fd 116 & 4 37 31 & -55 41 40 & 11.28 & 0.34 & ? fd 117 & 4 30 36 & -58 10 39 & 12.07 & 0.42 & ? fd 118 & 4 37 41 & -55 56 25 & 12.19 & 0.60 & ? fd 119 & 4 39 14 & -55 38 19 & 14.35 & 3.66 & ? fd 120 & 4 33 05 & -57 32 35 & 13.22 & 0.70 & ? fd 121 & 4 37 34 & -56 20 24 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fd 122 & 4 36 53 & -56 38 57 & 11.84 & 0.39 & 577 fd 123 & 4 40 20 & -55 34 29 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fd 124 & 4 43 14 & -54 41 49 & 12.18 & 0.58 & ? fd 125 & 4 30 60 & -58 52 52 & 13.05 & 1.05 & ? fd 126 & 4 43 58 & -54 47 09 & 12.73 & 0.86 & ? fd 127 & 4 36 11 & -57 52 50 & 15.23 & 5.16 & ? fd 128 & 4 43 22 & -55 46 25 & 13.01 & 0.75 & ? fd 129 & 4 33 51 & -58 51 57 & 14.51 & 3.81 & ? fd 130 & 4 42 19 & -56 07 32 & 12.83 & 0.73 & 586 fd 131 & 4 45 20 & -55 06 26 & 13.33 & 1.40 & ? fd 132 & 4 35 31 & -58 28 25 & 14.37 & 2.75 & ? fd 133 & 4 40 38 & -56 54 25 & 14.25 & 1.51 & ? fd 134 & 4 43 47 & -56 46 10 & 12.69 & 0.59 & ? fd 135 & 4 44 51 & -56 42 02 & 12.23 & 0.45 & ? fd 136 & 4 40 46 & -58 29 47 & 12.19 & 0.53 & ? fd 137 & 4 46 02 & -56 54 28 & 14.87 & 4.03 & ? fd 138 & 4 03 41 & -52 11 25 & 9.11 & 0.18 & 517 fd 139 & 3 56 01 & -52 51 56 & 11.07 & 0.35 & 502 fd 140 & 3 47 06 & -58 06 32 & 7.79 & 0.17 & 495 fd 141 & 4 31 20 & -59 45 28 & 8.92 & 0.19 & 568 fd 142 & 3 55 17 & -54 52 36 & 11.55 & 0.25 & 501 fm 1 & 13 55 36 & -28 59 15 & 12.40 & 0.50 & 3942/3 fm 2 & 13 53 60 & -28 09 49 & 7.70 & 0.17 & 3938 fm 3 & 13 53 60 & -27 56 29 & 10.24 & 0.21 & 3937 fm 4 & 13 53 42 & -27 07 16 & 11.35 & 0.33 & 3935 fm 5 & 13 53 14 & -27 20 60 & 11.67 & 0.35 & 3934 fm 6 & 13 52 56 & -27 41 09 & 10.87 & 0.24 & 3930 fm 7 & 13 53 54 & -30 01 20 & 9.29 & 0.18 & 3936 fm 8 & 13 52 37 & -27 31 43 & 9.37 & 0.18 & 3929 fm 9 & 13 52 18 & -26 48 08 & 11.35 & 0.30 & 3928 fm 10 & 13 52 17 & -30 47 45 & 9.17 & 0.18 & 3927 fm 11 & 13 51 23 & -29 07 27 & 11.35 & 0.25 & 3923 fm 12 & 13 51 52 & -30 48 28 & 9.16 & 0.18 & 3924 fm 13 & 13 50 03 & -29 05 48 & 5.92 & 0.16 & 3915 fm 14 & 13 51 22 & -30 48 10 & 12.36 & 0.34 & ? fm 15 & 13 49 53 & -28 11 48 & 10.30 & 0.20 & 3914 fm 16 & 13 49 11 & -26 55 26 & 11.13 & 0.25 & 3911 fm 17 & 13 50 39 & -30 15 24 & 12.21 & 0.38 & 3917 fm 18 & 13 49 46 & -28 38 55 & 11.77 & 0.31 & 3913 fm 19 & 13 49 12 & -27 25 49 & 11.61 & 0.29 & 3912 fm 20 & 13 50 40 & -31 12 27 & 9.02 & 0.18 & 3918 fm 21 & 13 50 21 & -31 03 57 & 9.58 & 0.18 & 3916 fm 22 & 13 49 11 & -28 35 27 & 12.67 & 0.32 & 3910 fm 23 & 13 48 27 & -27 56 22 & 13.13 & 0.70 & 3907 fm 24 & 13 48 06 & -29 19 50 & 12.59 & 0.46 & 3905 fm 25 & 13 45 38 & -26 06 26 & 5.51 & 0.16 & 3895 fm 26 & 13 47 51 & -31 32 40 & 11.40 & 0.30 & 3903 fm 27 & 13 46 27 & -28 02 03 & 12.25 & 0.35 & 3898 fm 28 & 13 47 23 & -30 27 02 & 12.57 & 0.47 & 3902 fm 29 & 13 46 57 & -29 41 34 & 13.35 & 0.70 & 3900 fm 30 & 13 45 33 & -27 51 33 & 12.17 & 0.32 & 3894 fm 31 & 13 45 11 & -27 43 07 & 11.44 & 0.25 & 3892 fm 32 & 13 46 27 & -30 26 01 & 13.52 & 0.85 & ? fm 33 & 13 46 06 & -30 12 11 & 11.89 & 0.30 & 3896 fm 34 & 13 44 38 & -26 46 33 & 10.63 & 0.20 & 3891 fm 35 & 13 46 24 & -31 45 34 & 12.60 & 0.54 & 3897 fm 36 & 13 45 16 & -29 01 15 & 12.80 & 0.52 & 3893 fm 37 & 13 43 52 & -26 47 37 & 12.22 & 0.37 & 3880 fm 38 & 13 44 10 & -28 16 50 & 12.86 & 0.53 & 3886 fm 39 & 13 43 53 & -27 46 10 & 11.85 & 0.29 & 3882 fm 40 & 13 43 54 & -28 42 03 & 12.75 & 0.46 & 3881/3 fm 41 & 13 44 25 & -30 07 07 & 10.94 & 0.21 & 3888 fm 42 & 13 44 10 & -31 49 07 & 11.81 & 0.32 & 3885 fm 43 & 13 43 00 & -30 10 02 & 9.71 & 0.18 & 3877 fm 44 & 13 43 28 & -31 26 27 & 12.11 & 0.35 & 3879 fm 45 & 13 41 31 & -27 16 16 & 9.93 & 0.19 & 3871 fm 46 & 13 42 15 & -29 45 20 & 10.74 & 0.21 & 3874 fm 47 & 13 41 42 & -28 45 09 & 12.31 & 0.26 & 3872 fm 48 & 13 42 32 & -31 02 37 & 12.32 & 0.35 & 3875 fm 49 & 13 41 42 & -29 53 43 & 11.14 & 0.23 & 3873 fm 50 & 13 40 47 & -28 14 29 & 12.01 & 0.34 & 3866 fm 51 & 13 40 53 & -28 57 18 & 12.40 & 0.42 & 3867 fm 52 & 13 39 54 & -27 08 47 & 10.00 & 0.19 & 3863 fm 53 & 13 41 13 & -31 34 28 & 12.43 & 0.27 & 3868 fm 54 & 13 39 42 & -28 08 13 & 10.71 & 0.21 & 3860 fm 55 & 13 40 14 & -29 33 34 & 12.02 & 0.32 & 3865 fm 56 & 13 38 44 & -27 15 36 & 9.64 & 0.18 & 3853 fm 57 & 13 38 31 & -26 54 19 & 9.63 & 0.18 & 3850 fm 58 & 13 39 57 & -31 38 05 & 9.89 & 0.19 & 3862 fm 59 & 13 39 10 & -30 14 09 & 12.44 & 0.37 & 3856 fm 60 & 13 38 42 & -29 32 48 & 9.95 & 0.18 & 3851 fm 61 & 13 39 05 & -30 44 04 & 12.34 & 0.34 & 3855 fm 62 & 13 39 44 & -32 29 31 & 12.38 & 0.46 & 3861 fm 63 & 13 37 35 & -27 03 44 & 10.86 & 0.22 & 3848 fm 64 & 13 38 23 & -29 49 40 & 11.02 & 0.23 & 3849 fm 65 & 13 36 48 & -26 30 13 & 7.37 & 0.16 & 3838 fm 66 & 13 37 14 & -26 42 39 & 12.18 & 0.35 & 3845 fm 67 & 13 38 46 & -31 50 34 & 11.74 & 0.31 & 3852 fm 68 & 13 37 04 & -27 39 32 & 12.87 & 0.57 & 3843 fm 69 & 13 37 03 & -27 54 14 & 12.59 & 0.46 & 3842 fm 70 & 13 37 00 & -29 50 41 & 7.92 & 0.17 & 3840 fm 71 & 13 35 53 & -25 56 39 & 12.21 & 0.38 & 3833 fm 72 & 13 37 36 & -32 08 53 & 11.28 & 0.24 & 3847 fm 73 & 13 36 29 & -29 07 03 & 12.25 & 0.35 & 3835 fm 74 & 13 36 06 & -28 41 47 & 11.86 & 0.29 & 3834 fm 75 & 13 36 41 & -30 17 51 & 13.03 & 0.56 & 3836 fm 76 & 13 36 59 & -32 18 02 & 12.28 & 0.28 & 3839 fm 77 & 13 36 49 & -32 24 45 & 10.66 & 0.22 & 3837 fm 78 & 13 35 01 & -26 07 13 & 12.67 & 0.51 & 3824 fm 79 & 13 35 31 & -29 08 32 & 8.42 & 0.17 & 3827 fm 80 & 13 35 42 & -29 21 49 & 11.48 & 0.25 & 3830 fm 81 & 13 34 12 & -25 25 52 & 8.86 & 0.17 & 3818 fm 82 & 13 35 39 & -31 25 04 & 12.52 & 0.26 & 3828 fm 83 & 13 35 40 & -32 01 15 & 10.73 & 0.21 & 3829 fm 84 & 13 34 13 & -27 55 12 & 11.99 & 0.34 & 3819 fm 85 & 13 35 15 & -32 13 16 & 9.82 & 0.19 & 3826 fm 86 & 13 34 47 & -31 11 39 & 12.80 & 0.48 & 3821 fm 87 & 13 32 54 & -26 36 00 & 9.77 & 0.18 & 3811 fm 88 & 13 33 10 & -29 17 04 & 10.54 & 0.18 & 3815 fm 89 & 13 32 34 & -28 41 37 & 5.47 & 0.16 & 3806 fm 90 & 13 33 21 & -31 39 08 & 10.08 & 0.18 & 3816 fm 91 & 13 32 36 & -29 17 04 & 9.91 & 0.17 & 3805 fm 92 & 13 31 49 & -26 09 20 & 12.10 & 0.37 & 3803 fm 93 & 13 32 37 & -29 33 07 & 11.41 & 0.25 & 3808 fm 94 & 13 33 09 & -31 47 29 & 10.83 & 0.21 & 3812 fm 95 & 13 31 33 & -28 06 44 & 6.69 & 0.16 & 3801 fm 96 & 13 31 01 & -25 42 36 & 9.06 & 0.18 & 3796 fm 97 & 13 31 22 & -27 32 14 & 11.69 & 0.29 & 3798 fm 98 & 13 32 45 & -32 46 54 & 12.04 & 0.39 & 3810 fm 99 & 13 31 48 & -29 42 25 & 12.26 & 0.39 & 3802 fm 100 & 13 32 12 & -32 06 22 & 12.16 & 0.25 & 3804 fm 101 & 13 31 36 & -32 08 57 & 10.86 & 0.22 & 3799 fm 102 & 13 30 02 & -27 02 52 & 10.71 & 0.22 & 3792 fm 103 & 13 29 48 & -26 35 11 & 8.56 & 0.17 & 3790 fm 104 & 13 30 57 & -31 44 42 & 11.77 & 0.29 & 3794 fm 105 & 13 29 33 & -27 23 39 & 10.23 & 0.19 & 3789 fm 106 & 13 29 54 & -28 56 11 & 10.00 & 0.18 & 3791 fm 107 & 13 29 34 & -29 04 58 & 11.08 & 0.19 & 3788 fm 108 & 13 28 17 & -26 34 47 & 11.17 & 0.24 & 3780 fm 109 & 13 28 42 & -31 59 43 & 11.69 & 0.31 & 3783 fm 110 & 13 28 01 & -29 46 48 & 12.83 & 0.49 & 3779 fm 111 & 13 27 12 & -29 03 28 & 11.15 & 0.22 & 3777 fm 112 & 13 26 51 & -29 51 53 & 12.87 & 0.50 & 3775 fm 113 & 13 26 03 & -27 28 15 & 11.62 & 0.27 & 3771 fm 114 & 13 25 60 & -30 23 11 & 11.71 & 0.20 & 3769 fm 115 & 13 25 14 & -30 22 12 & 8.68 & 0.17 & 3765 fm 116 & 13 24 58 & -31 20 15 & 11.17 & 0.25 & 3764 fm 117 & 13 23 51 & -26 53 60 & 11.05 & 0.24 & 3761 fm 118 & 13 22 43 & -28 47 03 & 11.08 & 0.23 & 3758 fm 119 & 13 22 45 & -30 11 08 & 11.43 & 0.24 & 3757 fm 120 & 13 21 58 & -28 26 52 & 12.02 & 0.34 & 3754 fm 121 & 13 20 46 & -29 29 29 & 11.11 & 0.24 & 3745 fm 122 & 13 19 39 & -30 20 40 & 6.21 & 0.16 & 3737 fm 123 & 13 18 02 & -27 36 19 & 11.28 & 0.33 & 3730 fm 124 & 13 55 02 & -29 07 28 & 12.83 & 0.69 & ? fm 125 & 13 51 24 & -27 24 05 & 14.75 & 2.96 & 3922 fm 126 & 13 51 18 & -28 06 27 & 12.22 & 0.43 & 3921/0 fm 127 & 13 51 10 & -29 20 03 & 11.67 & 0.28 & 3919 fm 128 & 13 49 02 & -28 17 46 & 11.73 & 0.29 & 3909 fm 129 & 13 49 35 & -30 02 06 & 14.11 & 1.11 & ? fm 130 & 13 48 05 & -27 16 56 & 12.45 & 0.46 & 3904 fm 131 & 13 48 25 & -29 06 48 & 12.98 & 0.55 & ? fm 132 & 13 48 49 & -30 12 30 & 13.62 & 0.85 & ? fm 133 & 13 47 38 & -28 55 02 & 14.30 & 1.64 & ? fm 134 & 13 47 11 & -30 46 12 & 12.87 & 0.53 & 3901 fm 135 & 13 45 53 & -28 34 06 & 14.57 & 1.65 & ? fm 136 & 13 44 34 & -26 18 22 & 11.46 & 0.29 & 3889 fm 137 & 13 43 39 & -26 29 55 & 13.11 & 0.71 & ? fm 138 & 13 44 40 & -29 39 34 & 13.69 & 0.88 & ? fm 139 & 13 44 14 & -28 48 53 & 13.39 & 0.42 & 3887 fm 140 & 13 45 17 & -31 22 33 & 13.48 & 0.83 & ? fm 141 & 13 43 21 & -28 55 36 & 13.50 & 0.46 & 3878 fm 142 & 13 43 18 & -29 00 16 & 14.07 & 0.71 & ? fm 143 & 13 42 59 & -29 07 15 & 13.80 & 0.56 & ? fm 144 & 13 42 11 & -28 28 59 & 16.06 & 3.81 & ? fm 145 & 13 41 13 & -27 29 26 & 14.53 & 1.73 & 3869 fm 146 & 13 41 56 & -29 28 49 & 14.33 & 0.80 & ? fm 147 & 13 41 25 & -29 06 22 & 14.45 & 0.89 & ? fm 148 & 13 40 27 & -27 43 12 & 13.69 & 1.00 & ? fm 149 & 13 41 59 & -32 09 29 & 12.59 & 0.51 & ? fm 150 & 13 41 23 & -30 52 59 & 12.78 & 0.44 & ? fm 151 & 13 41 43 & -31 37 13 & 13.47 & 0.45 & ? fm 152 & 13 39 30 & -26 40 11 & 13.04 & 0.60 & 3859 fm 153 & 13 40 59 & -31 14 31 & 13.44 & 0.76 & ? fm 154 & 13 40 15 & -29 53 12 & 14.01 & 1.10 & 3864 fm 155 & 13 40 34 & -32 17 11 & 13.79 & 1.22 & ? fm 156 & 13 39 13 & -29 05 45 & 14.07 & 1.18 & ? fm 157 & 13 39 28 & -29 54 45 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? fm 158 & 13 36 57 & -25 54 28 & 12.26 & 0.38 & 3841 fm 159 & 13 38 00 & -31 06 14 & 13.22 & 0.43 & ? fm 160 & 13 38 01 & -31 10 40 & 13.15 & 0.36 & ? fm 161 & 13 37 40 & -32 21 50 & 12.50 & 0.47 & 3846 fm 162 & 13 37 11 & -31 29 23 & 13.78 & 0.87 & ? fm 163 & 13 35 50 & -30 51 28 & 13.74 & 0.58 & 3831 fm 164 & 13 33 21 & -27 42 04 & 13.02 & 0.51 & 3817 fm 165 & 13 32 10 & -30 44 25 & 13.86 & 0.84 & ? fm 166 & 13 30 34 & -25 29 15 & 14.32 & 1.11 & ? fm 167 & 13 30 56 & -30 18 29 & 13.11 & 0.50 & 3795 fm 168 & 13 30 41 & -30 47 08 & 12.93 & 0.53 & ? fm 169 & 13 29 00 & -25 36 03 & 12.49 & 0.65 & 3785 fm 170 & 13 29 20 & -28 27 46 & 12.74 & 0.50 & 3787 fm 171 & 13 29 40 & -29 36 24 & 16.34 & 7.80 & ? fm 172 & 13 29 06 & -31 02 01 & 13.73 & 0.90 & ? fm 173 & 13 28 46 & -29 16 29 & 13.41 & 0.73 & 3784 fm 174 & 13 27 48 & -30 46 28 & 13.40 & 0.66 & 3778 fm 175 & 13 27 41 & -31 31 45 & 13.91 & 0.56 & ? fm 176 & 13 27 07 & -30 04 33 & 13.63 & 0.79 & 3776 fm 177 & 13 26 20 & -26 51 42 & 13.01 & 0.56 & ? fm 178 & 13 27 06 & -31 30 15 & 14.23 & 0.77 & ? fm 179 & 13 26 48 & -32 28 51 & 13.27 & 0.59 & ? fm 180 & 13 25 36 & -27 39 21 & 13.28 & 0.66 & ? fm 181 & 13 25 47 & -29 49 49 & 13.84 & 1.01 & 3767 fm 182 & 13 24 57 & -28 15 51 & 14.52 & 1.88 & ? fm 183 & 13 24 02 & -28 24 56 & 13.94 & 1.19 & 3762 fm 184 & 13 23 17 & -27 05 24 & 12.12 & 0.38 & ? fm 185 & 13 20 29 & -29 52 49 & 13.64 & 1.23 & ? fm 186 & 13 19 53 & -27 48 56 & 13.03 & 0.81 & 3738 fm 187 & 13 17 42 & -28 48 03 & 12.37 & 0.54 & 3728 fm 188 & 13 31 21 & -29 33 53 & 13.31 & 0.40 & ? fm 189 & 13 31 36 & -29 30 21 & 12.77 & 0.29 & 3800 fm 190 & 13 26 07 & -32 33 26 & 10.36 & 0.23 & 3770 fm 191 & 13 48 09 & -32 13 29 & 11.17 & 0.32 & 3906 fm 192 & 13 32 05 & -32 11 40 & 12.50 & 0.30 & ? fm 193 & 13 34 47 & -25 18 49 & 11.91 & 0.28 & 3822 fm 194 & 13 41 19 & -28 45 37 & 12.89 & 0.35 & ? fm 195 & 13 35 20 & -31 24 27 & 13.07 & 0.32 & ? fm 196 & 13 40 10 & -31 31 06 & 13.06 & 0.36 & ? fm 197 & 13 36 21 & -29 41 57 & 13.86 & 0.64 & ? ft 1 & 19 55 30 & -49 27 45 & 10.27 & 0.24 & 4536 ft 2 & 19 53 16 & -48 27 36 & 11.25 & 0.37 & 4532 ft 3 & 20 00 09 & -50 09 49 & 10.09 & 0.24 & 4544 ft 4 & 19 54 51 & -48 31 15 & 11.27 & 0.34 & 4534 ft 5 & 19 55 18 & -48 16 52 & 10.60 & 0.27 & 4535 ft 6 & 20 01 44 & -49 58 38 & 10.16 & 0.23 & 4551 ft 7 & 20 04 50 & -49 56 01 & 11.11 & 0.30 & 4560 ft 8 & 20 00 10 & -48 43 38 & 12.18 & 0.54 & 4546 ft 9 & 19 56 08 & -47 23 08 & 9.34 & 0.19 & 4538 ft 10 & 20 04 46 & -49 44 03 & 11.19 & 0.30 & 4559 ft 11 & 20 03 31 & -49 22 26 & 11.28 & 0.30 & 4555 ft 12 & 19 53 15 & -46 22 23 & 9.35 & 0.20 & 4533 ft 13 & 20 00 01 & -48 11 02 & 11.80 & 0.39 & 4545 ft 14 & 20 05 07 & -49 29 09 & 10.78 & 0.27 & 4562 ft 15 & 20 09 35 & -50 25 49 & 10.43 & 0.25 & 4584 ft 16 & 20 05 59 & -49 30 24 & 11.84 & 0.29 & 4567 ft 17 & 20 07 50 & -49 58 27 & 12.45 & 0.58 & 4572 ft 18 & 19 59 41 & -47 33 41 & 12.26 & 0.54 & ? ft 19 & 20 03 54 & -48 37 00 & 13.09 & 0.91 & ? ft 20 & 19 57 02 & -46 35 36 & 10.35 & 0.22 & 4540 ft 21 & 20 06 16 & -48 59 27 & 9.60 & 0.20 & 4568 ft 22 & 20 04 59 & -48 36 25 & 11.36 & 0.32 & 4561 ft 23 & 20 02 55 & -47 58 16 & 12.14 & 0.44 & 4554 ft 24 & 20 01 26 & -47 23 38 & 10.15 & 0.18 & 4550 ft 25 & 20 12 44 & -50 18 27 & 10.99 & 0.28 & 4597 ft 26 & 20 02 07 & -47 18 50 & 8.69 & 0.17 & 4552 ft 27 & 20 13 54 & -50 19 21 & 8.65 & 0.18 & 4602 ft 28 & 20 05 56 & -48 16 17 & 8.92 & 0.18 & 4566 ft 29 & 20 08 57 & -49 3 54 & 12.30 & 0.53 & 4581 ft 30 & 20 12 53 & -49 58 40 & 11.18 & 0.29 & 4599 ft 31 & 20 07 39 & -48 39 25 & 12.06 & 0.46 & 4570 ft 32 & 20 05 35 & -47 56 03 & 10.08 & 0.20 & 4564 ft 33 & 19 58 60 & -46 06 29 & 11.91 & 0.38 & 4542 ft 34 & 20 09 26 & -48 49 48 & 11.56 & 0.34 & 4583 ft 35 & 20 05 13 & -47 29 42 & 9.47 & 0.19 & 4563 ft 36 & 19 58 41 & -45 36 50 & 9.24 & 0.18 & 4541 ft 37 & 20 18 21 & -50 39 31 & 10.59 & 0.25 & 4609 ft 38 & 20 00 53 & -45 42 34 & 8.04 & 0.17 & 4548 ft 39 & 20 11 25 & -48 22 45 & 10.75 & 0.23 & 4593 ft 40 & 20 08 32 & -47 33 54 & 10.96 & 0.25 & 4578 ft 41 & 20 19 11 & -50 09 55 & 12.04 & 0.50 & 4615 ft 42 & 20 08 09 & -47 11 30 & 9.28 & 0.18 & 4575 ft 43 & 20 00 46 & -45 06 44 & 8.33 & 0.17 & 4547 ft 44 & 20 15 37 & -48 58 12 & 11.91 & 0.38 & 4606 ft 45 & 20 07 35 & -46 51 45 & 12.59 & 0.59 & 4571 ft 46 & 20 21 01 & -50 00 27 & 7.51 & 0.17 & 4619 ft 47 & 20 15 11 & -48 44 17 & 12.28 & 0.48 & ? ft 48 & 20 06 25 & -46 05 07 & 9.26 & 0.18 & 4569 ft 49 & 20 18 09 & -48 57 25 & 12.53 & 0.61 & 4608 ft 50 & 20 02 04 & -44 26 49 & 7.11 & 0.16 & 4553 ft 51 & 20 08 37 & -46 19 58 & 11.59 & 0.31 & 4579 ft 52 & 20 05 43 & -45 34 38 & 11.78 & 0.37 & 4565 ft 53 & 20 22 22 & -49 29 13 & 9.17 & 0.18 & 4625 ft 54 & 20 04 29 & -44 57 08 & 10.44 & 0.22 & 4558 ft 55 & 20 23 35 & -49 46 36 & 12.57 & 0.76 & 4631 ft 56 & 20 03 25 & -44 35 11 & 9.59 & 0.19 & 4556 ft 57 & 20 18 34 & -48 32 33 & 11.51 & 0.33 & 4613 ft 58 & 20 10 30 & -46 25 39 & 12.32 & 0.42 & 4590 ft 59 & 20 23 01 & -49 19 55 & 11.28 & 0.24 & 4628 ft 60 & 20 20 06 & -48 28 29 & 9.02 & 0.18 & 4617 ft 61 & 20 03 46 & -43 49 14 & 9.01 & 0.18 & 4557 ft 62 & 20 13 56 & -46 33 51 & 11.56 & 0.30 & 4603 ft 63 & 20 12 25 & -46 10 46 & 10.62 & 0.21 & 4598 ft 64 & 20 07 47 & -44 55 47 & 12.58 & 0.62 & 4574 ft 65 & 20 16 42 & -47 05 24 & 12.12 & 0.40 & ? ft 66 & 20 19 18 & -47 35 05 & 11.32 & 0.31 & 4616 ft 67 & 20 12 23 & -45 51 35 & 11.14 & 0.26 & 4596 ft 68 & 20 09 40 & -44 46 27 & 12.70 & 0.70 & 4586 ft 69 & 20 08 55 & -44 31 16 & 11.83 & 0.43 & 4582 ft 70 & 20 13 37 & -45 36 15 & 8.02 & 0.17 & 4601 ft 71 & 20 21 57 & -47 43 25 & 10.33 & 0.21 & 4622 ft 72 & 20 23 58 & -48 13 09 & 11.38 & 0.31 & 4632 ft 73 & 20 30 13 & -49 21 49 & 8.83 & 0.18 & 4650 ft 74 & 20 09 38 & -44 19 20 & 12.87 & 0.82 & 4587 ft 75 & 20 18 19 & -46 33 12 & 12.04 & 0.38 & 4611 ft 76 & 20 27 12 & -48 34 42 & 11.38 & 0.34 & 4641 ft 77 & 20 10 27 & -44 08 21 & 11.39 & 0.34 & 4589 ft 78 & 20 26 36 & -47 56 53 & 10.29 & 0.23 & 4639 ft 79 & 20 12 03 & -44 16 19 & 9.84 & 0.20 & 4595 ft 80 & 20 10 46 & -43 36 02 & 10.34 & 0.20 & 4591 ft 81 & 20 26 22 & -47 30 36 & 11.94 & 0.43 & 4638 ft 82 & 20 10 60 & -43 28 51 & 9.81 & 0.19 & 4592 ft 83 & 20 22 29 & -46 27 09 & 12.16 & 0.45 & 4626 ft 84 & 20 12 40 & -43 50 20 & 10.53 & 0.23 & 4600 ft 85 & 20 14 11 & -44 10 37 & 12.69 & 0.74 & 4604 ft 86 & 20 27 00 & -47 15 39 & 10.41 & 0.22 & 4640 ft 87 & 20 29 33 & -47 47 07 & 9.56 & 0.19 & 4645 ft 88 & 20 15 34 & -44 28 42 & 11.57 & 0.33 & ? ft 89 & 20 11 59 & -43 24 30 & 11.60 & 0.43 & 4594 ft 90 & 20 20 45 & -45 41 25 & 11.80 & 0.32 & 4620 ft 91 & 20 26 06 & -46 39 46 & 9.10 & 0.18 & 4636 ft 92 & 20 22 00 & -45 39 05 & 8.86 & 0.17 & 4624 ft 93 & 20 14 58 & -43 39 54 & 9.85 & 0.21 & 4605 ft 94 & 20 28 24 & -46 56 53 & 10.68 & 0.24 & 4643 ft 95 & 20 33 45 & -47 56 28 & 11.65 & 0.39 & 4653 ft 96 & 20 26 05 & -46 10 09 & 11.74 & 0.40 & 4637 ft 97 & 20 29 39 & -46 09 44 & 7.00 & 0.16 & 4647 ft 98 & 20 22 40 & -44 35 38 & 11.14 & 0.31 & 4627 ft 99 & 20 33 58 & -46 49 56 & 10.07 & 0.21 & 4654 ft 100 & 20 29 51 & -45 55 25 & 11.55 & 0.40 & 4649 ft 101 & 20 29 33 & -45 23 16 & 10.17 & 0.21 & 4646 ft 102 & 20 27 16 & -44 45 25 & 11.20 & 0.29 & 4642 ft 103 & 20 23 00 & -43 39 26 & 10.14 & 0.20 & 4630 ft 104 & 20 22 46 & -43 29 04 & 9.18 & 0.20 & 4629 ft 105 & 20 35 48 & -46 37 18 & 10.91 & 0.32 & 4655 ft 106 & 20 23 53 & -43 36 56 & 11.09 & 0.27 & 4633 ft 107 & 20 29 25 & -44 57 48 & 12.42 & 0.42 & ? ft 108 & 20 24 20 & -43 40 09 & 11.75 & 0.33 & ? ft 109 & 20 36 52 & -46 26 44 & 9.32 & 0.20 & 4657 ft 110 & 20 32 19 & -45 21 27 & 10.72 & 0.28 & 4652 ft 111 & 20 36 33 & -45 32 42 & 9.22 & 0.20 & 4656 ft 112 & 20 30 33 & -43 58 04 & 10.59 & 0.34 & 4651 ft 113 & 20 01 32 & -50 15 50 & 11.88 & 0.53 & ? ft 114 & 20 02 55 & -50 17 38 & 12.32 & 0.72 & ? ft 115 & 19 56 53 & -48 19 13 & 12.58 & 0.42 & ? ft 116 & 20 01 22 & -49 33 41 & 12.20 & 0.56 & ? ft 117 & 19 54 21 & -47 36 48 & 12.62 & 0.83 & ? ft 118 & 19 55 12 & -47 47 48 & 12.39 & 0.73 & ? ft 119 & 19 57 16 & -48 20 54 & 12.59 & 0.46 & ? ft 120 & 20 03 60 & -49 47 48 & 12.68 & 0.46 & ? ft 121 & 19 56 56 & -47 25 48 & 10.75 & 0.21 & 4539 ft 122 & 19 57 07 & -47 02 54 & 12.84 & 0.90 & ? ft 123 & 19 55 18 & -46 48 39 & 12.23 & 0.61 & ? ft 124 & 20 01 20 & -48 27 16 & 12.70 & 0.76 & ? ft 125 & 19 54 34 & -46 27 26 & 12.33 & 0.58 & ? ft 126 & 20 00 13 & -47 55 55 & 12.78 & 0.81 & ? ft 127 & 19 54 45 & -46 13 16 & 12.49 & 0.69 & ? ft 128 & 20 07 01 & -49 31 30 & 12.57 & 0.44 & ? ft 129 & 20 12 03 & -50 39 49 & 12.48 & 0.81 & ? ft 130 & 19 59 28 & -47 05 44 & 12.37 & 0.55 & 4543 ft 131 & 20 01 07 & -47 04 17 & 12.50 & 0.54 & 4549 ft 132 & 19 58 28 & -46 08 04 & 13.46 & 0.73 & ? ft 133 & 19 57 45 & -45 50 31 & 12.82 & 0.71 & ? ft 134 & 20 13 13 & -49 38 29 & 12.71 & 0.71 & ? ft 135 & 20 09 55 & -48 35 38 & 12.79 & 0.66 & ? ft 136 & 19 58 27 & -45 06 34 & 12.77 & 0.88 & ? ft 137 & 20 02 44 & -45 59 33 & 12.46 & 0.57 & ? ft 138 & 20 16 08 & -48 49 27 & 12.86 & 0.43 & 4607 ft 139 & 20 08 01 & -46 44 14 & 12.99 & 0.48 & ? ft 140 & 20 20 44 & -49 48 58 & 12.47 & 0.43 & ? ft 141 & 20 18 32 & -49 15 10 & 12.36 & 0.50 & ? ft 142 & 20 14 38 & -48 12 26 & 12.78 & 0.68 & ? ft 143 & 20 19 56 & -49 21 59 & 12.71 & 0.72 & ? ft 144 & 20 24 37 & -50 23 17 & 11.27 & 0.34 & ? ft 145 & 20 06 18 & -45 51 36 & 12.34 & 0.50 & ? ft 146 & 20 20 30 & -49 06 44 & 12.77 & 0.66 & 4618 ft 147 & 20 09 01 & -46 07 16 & 14.47 & 1.20 & ? ft 148 & 20 09 38 & -46 09 04 & 12.33 & 0.45 & 4585 ft 149 & 20 09 50 & -46 02 37 & 13.59 & 0.63 & ? ft 150 & 20 05 11 & -44 40 02 & 12.81 & 0.78 & ? ft 151 & 20 04 53 & -44 30 40 & 12.48 & 0.59 & ? ft 152 & 20 10 57 & -45 54 08 & 13.54 & 1.11 & ? ft 153 & 20 10 01 & -45 40 43 & 13.70 & 1.22 & 4588 ft 154 & 20 08 36 & -45 06 48 & 12.34 & 0.53 & ? ft 155 & 20 23 31 & -48 49 47 & 13.26 & 0.90 & ? ft 156 & 20 07 49 & -44 37 54 & 14.62 & 3.42 & ? ft 157 & 20 06 22 & -44 02 51 & 12.27 & 0.56 & ? ft 158 & 20 15 33 & -46 21 51 & 14.23 & 1.98 & ? ft 159 & 20 10 12 & -44 53 29 & 12.29 & 0.53 & ? ft 160 & 20 07 59 & -44 12 04 & 14.41 & 2.52 & 4577 ft 161 & 20 16 55 & -46 31 54 & 13.05 & 0.74 & ? ft 162 & 20 15 15 & -46 04 49 & 12.87 & 0.68 & ? ft 163 & 20 07 59 & -43 33 44 & 12.10 & 0.61 & 4576 ft 164 & 20 27 07 & -48 21 14 & 13.07 & 0.92 & ? ft 165 & 20 25 28 & -47 50 18 & 12.34 & 0.57 & 4635 ft 166 & 20 14 04 & -44 50 33 & 11.69 & 0.34 & ? ft 167 & 20 34 15 & -49 00 19 & 11.84 & 0.49 & ? ft 168 & 20 18 43 & -45 20 15 & 12.63 & 0.56 & 4614 ft 169 & 20 16 43 & -44 42 22 & 12.44 & 0.52 & ? ft 170 & 20 26 44 & -46 27 28 & 13.36 & 1.21 & ? ft 171 & 20 35 41 & -48 22 03 & 11.26 & 0.35 & ? ft 172 & 20 24 51 & -45 43 39 & 12.90 & 0.70 & ? ft 173 & 20 29 19 & -46 28 36 & 12.04 & 0.45 & ? ft 174 & 20 30 17 & -46 28 32 & 11.80 & 0.44 & ? ft 175 & 20 27 48 & -45 41 12 & 11.62 & 0.16 & ? ft 176 & 20 19 11 & -43 32 24 & 12.46 & 0.72 & ? ft 177 & 20 24 44 & -44 38 13 & 14.14 & 2.42 & ? ft 178 & 20 21 37 & -43 47 53 & 12.43 & 0.62 & 4621 ft 179 & 20 35 22 & -46 56 34 & 12.40 & 0.61 & ? ft 180 & 20 25 13 & -44 26 49 & 11.91 & 0.45 & ? ft 181 & 20 27 59 & -44 59 28 & 12.93 & 0.77 & ? ft 182 & 20 29 19 & -45 06 47 & 11.92 & 0.29 & 4644 ft 183 & 20 31 20 & -44 47 35 & 11.89 & 0.53 & ? ft 184 & 20 29 26 & -49 43 37 & 8.74 & 0.17 & ? ft 185 & 20 29 52 & -49 47 23 & 8.52 & 0.17 & 4648 ft 186 & 19 52 07 & -46 50 40 & 10.33 & 0.25 & 4531 ft 187 & 20 15 08 & -43 34 26 & 10.15 & 0.22 & ? ft 188 & 20 05 12 & -47 20 23 & 11.50 & 0.29 & ? ft 189 & 20 24 09 & -43 40 39 & 11.98 & 0.40 & ? fc 1 & usno0525 - 12907188 & b11.1 & u & ? & ? & 12 47 28.6 & -37 22 34 fc 2 & usno0525 - 13025279 & b12.6 & u & ? & ? & 12 55 26.4 & -37 19 18 fc 3 & sao203688 & 7.7 & s & a1v & 0.09 & 12 40 16.0 & -37 51 25 fc 4 & tyc7772 - 851 - 1 & 10.93 & s & ? & 0.39 & 12 56 30.5 & -37 40 10 fc 5 & sao203718 & 9.3 & s & a0 & 0.17 & 12 41 47.0 & -37 53 12 fc 6 & sao203731 & 8.1 & s & f0v & 0.38 & 12 42 32.2 & -37 54 10 fc 7 & tyc777 - 835 - 1 & 9.93 & s & ? & 0.47 & 13 03 39.7 & -37 46 52 fc 8 & usno0450 - 15027418 & b13.7 & u & ? & ? & 12 56 43.5 & -37 58 06 c 9 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14831165 & b14.7 & u & ? & * -0.7 & 12 52 18.2 & -38 02 35 fc 10 & sao203908 & 9.7 & s & a & 0.31 & 12 53 25.7 & -38 03 32 c 11 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14517802 & b12.0 & u & ? & * 0.4 & 12 38 01.9 & -38 15 11 fc 12 & usno0450 - 14861545 & b11.2 & u & ? & * 0.5 & 12 49 54.7 & -38 18 16 fc 13 & usno0450 - 14722885 & b14.0 & u & ? & ? & 12 43 53.0 & -38 21 25 fc 14 & sao203822 & 9.2 & s & a3 & 0.23 & 12 48 18.4 & -38 22 04 fc 15 & tyc7758 - 812 - 1 & 9.68 & s & ? & 0.32 & 12 39 35.9 & -38 24 39 fc 16 & sao204099 & 9.0 & s & a0 & 0.06 & 13 04 38.5 & -38 23 40 fc 17 & usno0450 - 14623199 & b11.9 & u & ? & * 0.0 & 12 39 09.8 & -38 44 51 fc 18 & sao203609 & 9.0 & s & a3ii & 0.23 & 12 34 55.5 & -38 49 55 fc 19 & usno0450 - 15096908 & b12.9 & u & ? & * -1.0 & 12 59 39.5 & -38 42 35 fc 20 & sao203816 & 8.9 & s & a3 & 0.24 & 12 47 48.3 & -38 51 45 fc 21 & usno0450 - 14756756 & b12.6 & u & ? & * -0.1 & 12 45 27.0 & -38 51 15 fc 22 & tyc7773 - 1670 - 1 & 10.09 & s & ? & 0.29 & 13 00 33.8 & -38 44 58 fc 23 & sao203979 & 6.8 & s & a3v & 0.13 & 12 58 01.0 & -38 55 02 fc 24 & sao203690 & 9.8 & s & f2 & 0.39 & 12 40 21.9 & -39 02 10 fc 25 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14821964 & b11.8 & u & ? & * 0.2 & 12 51 54.7 & -38 58 10 fc 26 & sao203562 & 9.6 & s & a0 & 0.17 & 12 31 52.82 & -39 13 57 fc 27 & eso323-g025 & 13.39 & ig & sa(rs)b & ? & 12 52 38.7 & -39 01 42 fc 28 & sao204001 & 6.94 & s & a0v & 0.03 & 12 58 52.8 & -39 06 20 fc 29 & sao204080 & 7.88 & s & f0v & 0.36 & 13 03 36.7 & -38 58 07 fc 30 & usno0450 - 15038765 & b13.7 & u & ? & * -0.3 & 12 57 12.7 & -39 06 54 fc 31 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 15040174 & b14.9 & u & ? & * -0.8 & 13 01 04.0 & -39 03 19 fc 32 & ngc4553 & 13.5 & gp & sa0 & 0.93 & 12 36 08.0 & -39 26 19 fc 33 & sao203981 & 7.53 & s & a9iv & 0.34 & 12 58 03.1 & -39 16 02 fc 34 & usno0450 - 14874256 & b11.9 & u & ? & * 1.1 & 12 50 24.5 & -39 25 37 fc 35 & sao204034 & 8.2 & s & f2 & 0.41 & 13 00 44.4 & -39 17 43 fc 36 & sao20398 & 10.0 & s & a0 & 0.26 & 12 58 15.4 & -39 22 59 fc 37 & tyc7776 - 1116 - 1 & 10.95 & s & ? & 0.32 & 12 53 53.2 & -39 28 38 fc 38 & usno0450 - 14627245 & b13.6 & u & ? & * 0.5 & 12 39 21.4 & -39 41 04 fc 39 & sao203881 & 5.97 & s & b8v & -0.1 & 12 51 57.0 & -39 40 50 fc 40 & sao203835 & 8.1 & s & b5iv & -0.09 & 12 49 10.1 & -39 43 02 fc 41 & sao203621 & 5.78 & s & a0v & 0.00 & 12 36 01.1 & -39 52 11 fc 42 & tyc7775 - 798 - 1 & 10.73 & s & ? & 0.03 & 12 44 13.6 & -39 46 17 fc 43 & sao203681 & 4.63 & s & b8ii & -0.08 & 12 39 52.6 & -39 59 15 fc 44 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14607200 & 9.9 & g & sabcd & * -1.3 & 12 42 16.2 & -40 06 25 fc 45 & sao203746 & 6.44 & s & a7iii & 0.24 & 12 43 26.3 & -40 10 41 fc 46 & sao203907 & 4.28 & s & a4iv & 0.22 & 12 53 26.2 & -40 10 44 fc 47 & sao203554 & 8.6 & s & a6iii & 0.29 & 12 31 29.1 & -40 16 28 fc 48 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14768318 & b14.8 & u & ? & * -0.1 & 12 49 36.4 & -40 13 56 fc 49 & tyc7777 - 1416 - 1 & 10.37 & s & ? & 0.35 & 13 03 36.3 & -40 15 14 fc 50 & sao223587 & 8.9 & s & a5 & 0.31 & 12 40 22.0 & -40 37 52 fc 51 & sao223687 & 9.8 & s & a2 & 0.07 & 12 49 15.1 & -40 37 59 fc 52 & sao223519 & 8.0 & s & a5 & 0.17 & 12 34 13.8 & -40 49 44 fc 53 & usno0450 - 14828057 & b12.2 & u & ? & ? & 12 48 35.9 & -40 44 36 fc 54 & tyc7776 - 1480 - 1 & 10.09 & s & ? & 0.25 & 12 59 13.0 & -40 38 03 fc 55 & usno0450 - 14907321 & b13.6 & u & ? & * -0.4 & 12 51 42.7 & -40 44 09 fc 56 & sao223542 & 5.12 & s & a7iii & 0.22 & 12 35 45.5 & -41 01 19 fc 57 & tyc7775 - 757 - 1 & 10.34 & s & ? & 0.15 & 12 46 55.7 & -40 53 24 fc 58 & sao223879 & 7.93 & s & f6v & 0.45 & 13 04 45.2 & -40 40 58 fc 59 & sao223727 & 8.3 & s & a9iv & 0.28 & 12 52 34.3 & -40 56 28 fc 60 & sao223824 & 8.0 & s & a0 & 0.19 & 13 00 01.1 & -40 53 01 fc 61 & pgc042966 & 15.17 & ig & e & ? & 12 45 03.8 & -41 00 47 fc 62 & sao223916 & 10.26 & s & a3 & 0.28 & 13 07 38.1 & -40 46 30 fc 63 & tyc7762 - 215 - 1 & 11.11 & s & ? & 0.21 & 12 38 19.8 & -41 12 41 fc 64 & tyc7775 - 1763 - 1 & 10.63 & s & ? & 0.16 & 12 44 45.2 & -41 13 38 fc 65 & sao223706 & 8.47 & s & a2 & 0.21 & 12 51 03.9 & -41 15 05 fc 66 & sao223511 & 6.7 & s & a7v & 0.24 & 12 33 28.8 & -41 24 51 fc 67 & tyc7780 - 107 - 1 & 9.95 & s & ? & -0.07 & 12 52 19.4 & -41 19 38 fc 68 & tyc7778 - 1705 - 1 & 10.98 & s & ? & 0.18 & 13 10 27.0 & -40 57 24 fc 69 & sao223484 & 7.7 & s & a5iv & 0.32 & 12 31 18.8 & -41 30 17 fc 70 & sao223859 & 9.0 & s & a3 & 0.29 & 13 02 43.2 & -41 14 01 fc 71 & ngc4683 & 13.8 & ig & sb(s)0 & 0.93 & 12 47 42.6 & -41 31 44 fc 72 & sao223823 & 7.4 & s & f2 & 0.37 & 12 59 59.0 & -41 23 27 fc 73 & usno0450 - 14710416 & b14.1 & u & ? & * 0.5 & 12 43 18.5 & -41 37 04 fc 74 & sao223924 & 8.1 & s & a3v & 0.09 & 13 08 12.4 & -41 23 41 fc 75 & ngc4930 & 12.0 & g & sb(rs ) & 0.76 & 13 04 04.7 & -41 24 44 fc 76 & sao223701 & 8.8 & s & f3v & 0.43 & 12 50 31.7 & -41 41 47 fc 77 & sao223808 & 9.5 & s & a0 & 0.01 & 12 59 16.9 & -41 36 34 fc 78 & sao223577 & 9.11 & s & b9 & 0.11 & 12 39 25.2 & -41 51 03 fc 79 & tyc7781 - 616 - 1 & 10.04 & s & ? & 0.27 & 13 04 59.3 & -41 31 54 fc 80 & sao223513 & 7.95 & s & f2 & 0.37 & 12 33 40.8 & -41 57 04 fc 81 & sao223475 & 8.53 & s & ? & 0.29 & 12 30 11.6 & -41 55 28 fc 82 & sao223700 & 8.93 & s & a3 & 0.22 & 12 50 30.4 & -41 54 24 fc 83 & sao223558 & 8.72 & s & a5 & 0.38 & 12 37 21.7 & -42 01 42 fc 84 & sao223864 & 9.2 & s & a2 & 0.19 & 13 03 03.1 & -41 47 21 fc 85 & sao223778 & 8.2 & s & f3v & 0.44 & 12 56 50.2 & -41 54 50 fc 86 & sao223635 & 8.04 & s & f5v & 0.49 & 12 44 20.1 & -42 04 48 fc 87 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 15041646 & b11.3 & u & ? & * -0.1 & 13 01 07.7 & -41 58 55 fc 88 & tyc7780 - 1433 - 1 & 10.38 & s & ? & -0.03 & 12 56 14.2 & -42 09 11 fc 89 & sao223545 & 7.98 & s & sdf2 & 0.45 & 12 36 05.3 & -42 18 35 fc 90 & usno0450 - 15063833 & b11.6 & u & ? & * 0.7 & 12 58 16.0 & -42 03 15 fc 91 & tyc7781 - 83 - 1 & 9.85 & s & ? & 0.10 & 13 07 30.9 & -42 02 40 fc 92 & sao223756 & 6.82 & s & b5vn & -0.13 & 12 55 07.0 & -42 17 28 fc 93 & sao223580 & 9.51 & s & a3 m & 0.32 & 12 39 40.6 & -42 22 29 fc 94 & sao223946 & 8.95 & s & a0 & 0.10 & 13 10 03.7 & -42 13 16 fc 95 & tyc7766 - 1334 - 1 & 10.03 & s & ? & 0.14 & 12 37 25.3 & -42 36 07 fc 96 & sao223960 & 5.79 & s & f7iv & 0.51 & 13 11 08.9 & -42 13 59 fc 97 & sao223828 & 7.83 & s & f3iv & 0.43 & 13 00 17.8 & -42 30 04 fc 98 & tyc7781 - 907 - 1 & 10.52 & s & ? & 0.37 & 13 01 29.9 & -42 29 58 fc 99 & tyc7781 - 802 - 1 & 10.71 & s & ? & 0.35 & 13 02 11.6 & -42 29 13 fc 100 & sao223578 & 9.0 & s & f0v & 0.4 & 12 39 31.9 & -42 59 04 fc 101 & tyc7780 - 609 - 1 & 10.42 & s & ? & 0.15 & 12 52 08.7 & -42 55 26 fc 102 & sao223561 & 9.19 & s & f2 & 0.41 & 12 38 00.2 & -43 02 02 fc 103 & tyc7779 - 1941 - 1 & 10.56 & s & ? & -0.13 & 12 45 59.1 & -43 05 22 fc 104 & tyc7766 - 345 - 1 & 10.75 & s & ? & 0.57 & 12 37 52.3 & -43 05 24 fc 105 & sao223737 & 7.29 & s & a5v & 0.25 & 12 53 33.5 & -43 04 30 fc 106 & usno0450 - 14908873 & b12.8 & u & ? & * -1.2 & 12 51 46.9 & -43 10 44 fc 107 & sao223691 & 9.27 & s & f2 & 0.40 & 12 49 31.4 & -43 12 44 fc 108 & sao223678 & 8.2 & s & f0iii & 0.37 & 12 48 22.4 & -43 19 59 fc 109 & sao223605 & 9.38 & s & a2 & 0.08 & 12 41 30.5 & -43 38 43 fc 110 & tyc7785 - 239 - 1 & 10.89 & s & ? & 0.05 & 13 01 30.2 & -43 22 53 fc 111 & sao223857 & 7.9 & s & a7v & 0.26 & 13 02 38.0 & -43 21 18 fc 112 & sao223681 & 8.82 & s & b9iii & -0.03 & 12 48 47.2 & -43 42 56 fc 113 & tyc7785 - 2089 - 1 & 10.5 & s & ? & -0.10 & 13 08 46.2 & -43 27 52 fc 114 & usno0450 - 14550141 & b13.0 & u & ? & * -0.3 & 12 35 42.8 & -43 49 17 fc 115 & sao223609 & 10.01 & s & a2 & 0.32 & 12 41 58.9 & -43 53 52 fc 116 & tyc7784 - 810 - 1 & 10.93 & s & ? & 0.29 & 12 56 15.1 & -43 46 45 fc 117 & sao223683 & 7.8 & s & a3iii & 0.17 & 12 49 04.0 & -43 56 58 fc 118 & sao223836 & 9.67 & s & a0 & 0.16 & 13 00 53.3 & -43 47 45 fc 119 & usno0450 - 14711408 & b12.4 & u & ? & * 0.3 & 12 43 21.2 & -43 58 34 fc 120 & usno0450 - 14699795 & b12.0 & u & ? & * 0.2 & 12 42 47.8 & -44 06 09 fc 121 & sao223809 & 9.61 & s & a0 & 0.23 & 12 59 19.5 & -43 59 32 fc 122 & sao223880 & 8.79 & s & a2 & 0.25 & 13 04 48.3 & -43 55 29 fc 123 & sao223753 & 5.88 & s & g2iv & 0.63 & 12 54 58.6 & -44 09 07 fc 124 & tyc7783 - 1498 - 1 & 10.49 & s & ? & 0.40 & 12 41 17.9 & -44 18 10 fc 125 & sao223896 & 9.6 & s & a2 & 0.07 & 13 05 58.2 & -44 05 44 fc 126 & sao223742 & 9.1 & s & f0v & 0.38 & 12 54 15.6 & -44 24 06 fc 127 & tyc7783 - 1223 - 1 & 11.36 & s & ? & -0.07 & 12 43 02.4 & -44 34 25 fc 128 & sao223677 & 6.88 & s & b9v & -0.02 & 12 48 16.5 & -44 43 08 fc 129 & sao223598 & 10.28 & s & a2 & 0.21 & 12 41 11.8 & -44 42 26 fc 130 & sao223899 & 9.38 & s & a2iv & 0.18 & 13 06 08.8 & -44 25 14 fc 131 & sao223646 & 9.42 & s & a2 & 0.26 & 12 45 26.3 & -44 44 06 fc 132 & sao223866 & 7.8 & s & a2iv & 0.13 & 13 03 17.9 & -44 33 46 fc 133 & sao223842 & 7.66 & s & b6v & -0.08 & 13 01 15.2 & -44 45 07 fc 134 & sao223769 & 9.44 & s & a0 & 0.31 & 12 56 24.0 & -44 52 07 fc 135 & tyc7785 - 1568 - 1 & 10.88 & s & ? & 0.02 & 13 04 20.5 & -44 59 37 fc 136 & sao223740 & 9.0 & s & a9v & 0.34 & 12 53 54.3 & -45 06 33 fc 137 & sao223846 & 9.74 & s & b9 & 0.11 & 13 01 30.1 & -45 11 23 fc 138 & sao223679 & 8.4 & s & f0 & 0.33 & 12 48 33.8 & -45 25 11 fc 139 & sao223655 & 8.31 & s & f0 & 0.27 & 12 46 03.3 & -45 30 05 fc 140 & sao223722 & 9.33 & s & a2 & 0.03 & 12 52 18.7 & -45 29 29 fc 141 & tyc7259 - 115 - 1 & 9.94 & s & ? & 0.311 & 12 44 52.9 & -37 18 48 fc 142 & usno0450 - 14941695 & b12.3 & u & ? & * 0.4 & 12 53 07.4 & -37 31 45 fc 143 & usno0450 - 14747828 & b12.3 & u & ? & * 1.4 & 12 45 02.2 & -37 43 30 fc 144 & usno0450 - 14885379 & b11.3 & u & ? & * 0.7 & 12 50 49.6 & -37 49 39 fc 145 & usno0450 - 15121279 & b12.4 & u & ? & * 0.3 & 13 00 40.9 & -37 49 05 fc 146 & usno0450 - 14481710 & b13.7 & u & ? & * 0.4 & 12 32 26.5 & -38 32 45 fc 147 & usno0450 - 14485189 & b10.7 & u & ? & * -0.1 & 12 32 36.5 & -38 39 11 fc 148 & usno0450 - 14870154 & b13.2 & u & ? & * 0.0 & 12 50 14.8 & -38 29 34 fc 149 & usno0450 - 14551298 & b12.6 & u & ? & * 1.0 & 12 35 46.2 & -38 39 54 fc 150 & usno0450 - 15008287 & b12.8 & u & ? & * -0.5 & 12 55 55.5 & -38 39 59 fc 151 & usno0450 - 14951320 & b11.6 & u & ? & * 0.9 & 12 53 31.5 & -38 47 16 fc 152 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14652712 & b15.9 & u & ? & * -0.2 & 12 44 24.5 & -38 56 15 fc 153 & usno0450 - 14854637 & b15.7 & u & ? & * -0.1 & 12 49 38.7 & -39 02 20 fc 154 & tyc7771 - 925 - 1 & 10.43 & s & ? & 0.42 & 12 44 37.7 & -39 05 51 fc 155 & usno0450 - 14643933 & b11.6 & u & ? & * 1.4 & 12 40 08.3 & -39 23 40 fc 156 & tyc7775 - 674 - 1 & 9.99 & s & ? & 0.46 & 12 41 33.8 & -39 27 38 fc 157 & usno0450 - 15104855 & b12.6 & u & ? & * 0.5 & 12 59 59.8 & -39 14 56 fc 158 & tyc7772 - 1576 - 1 & 9.81 & s & ? & 0.36 & 12 54 20.1 & -39 19 32 fc 159 & usno0450 - 14709560 & b11.5 & u & ? & * 1.0 & 12 43 16.0 & -39 32 22 fc 160 & sao203807 & 8.81 & s & g3v & 0.63 & 12 47 23.2 & -39 28 54 fc 161 & ngc4679 & 13.15 & g & sa(s)bc & ? & 12 47 30.2 & -39 34 21 fc 162 & tyc7762 - 1018 - 1 & 11.20 & s & ? & 0.30 & 12 30 31.9 & -39 39 53 fc 163 & tyc7775 - 54 - 1 & 10.99 & s & ? & 0.53 & 12 45 11.9 & -39 38 34 fc 164 & tyc7762 - 206 - 1 & 10.03 & s & ? & 1.03 & 12 33 31.5 & -39 49 01 fc 165 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14720843 & b16.9 & u & ? & * 1.7 & 12 47 33.0 & -39 46 46 fc 166 & usno0450 - 14850792 & b13.1 & u & ? & * 0.4 & 12 49 30.1 & -39 53 31 fc 167 & usno0450 - 14528258 & b12.2 & u & ? & * 1.6 & 12 34 40.1 & -40 03 17 fc 168 & sao203806 & 8.4 & s & m3iii & 1.58 & 12 47 19.4 & -40 07 377 fc 169 & sao204171 & 8.06 & s & f5v & 0.48 & 13 09 10.5 & -39 52 24 fc 170 & sao203541 & 8.8 & s & a2 & 0.41 & 12 30 27.9 & -40 16 06 fc 171 & sao223652 & 9.1 & s & f8 & 0.56 & 12 45 42.5 & -40 16 41 fc 172 & tyc7775 - 1831 - 1 & 10.14 & s & ? & 0.44 & 12 47 49.7 & -40 22 53 fc 173 & tyc7762 - 1543 - 1 & 10.56 & s & ? & 0.35 & 12 38 21.2 & -40 30 58 fc 174 & usno0450 - 15031167 & b14.0 & u & ? & * 0.0 & 12 56 53.2 & -40 21 00 fc 175 & tyc7776 - 987 - 1 & 10.96 & s & ? & 0.14 & 12 59 25.0 & -40 25 53 fc 176 & usno0450 - 15063491 & b13.3 & u & ? & * 0.4 & 12 58 15.1 & -40 36 25 fc 177 & usno0450 - 14575914 & b13.7 & u & ? & * 0.5 & 12 36 55.9 & -40 52 01 fc 178 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 15059539 & b12.2 & u & ? & * 0.0 & 13 01 52.8 & -40 37 45 fc 179 & usno0450 - 15215568 & b13.5 & u & ? & * -0.7 & 13 04 37.6 & -40 32 15 fc 180 & tyc7777 - 392 - 1 & 10.5 & s & ? & 0.81 & 13 07 40.9 & -40 30 02 fc 181 & tyc7778 - 1639 - 1 & 9.36 & s & ? & 0.33 & 13 11 12.2 & -40 28 26 fc 182 & tyc7762 - 1945 - 1 & 10.18 & s & ? & 0.56 & 12 38 52.6 & -41 00 55 fc 183 & tyc7762 - 1926 - 1 & 10.57 & s & ? & 0.24 & 12 33 49.9 & -40 59 52 fc 184 & sao223494 & 7.3 & s & k2iii & 1.24 & 12 31 59.2 & -41 03 19 fc 185 & usno0450 - 14860017 & b11.4 & u & ? & * 0.8 & 12 49 50.9 & -41 04 23 fc 186 & eso323-g054 & 14.86 & ig & s & ? & 12 59 18.2 & -40 57 41 fc 187 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14757081 & b12.4 & u & ? & * 0.0 & 12 49 08.7 & -41 12 26 fc 188 & usno0450 - 15248516 & b13.2 & u & ? & * -0.4 & 13 05 59.3 & -40 57 58 fc 189 & usno0450 - 14676419 & b14.7 & u & ? & * 1.4 & 12 41 41.4 & -41 16 59 fc 190 & tyc7766 - 717 - 1 & 10.64 & s & ? & 0.37 & 12 38 18.1 & -41 24 34 fc 191 & sao223465 & 8.03 & s & f3iv & 0.39 & 12 29 48.4 & -41 24 09 fc 192 & tyc7776 - 1098 - 1 & 10.55 & s & ? & 0.39 & 12 58 49.4 & -41 09 07 fc 193 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14865062 & 16.4 & u & ? & * -0.4 & 12 53 42.8 & -41 18 29 fc 194 & sao223501 & 9.38 & s & f0 & 0.26 & 12 32 49.5 & -41 37 58 fc 195 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 15278266 & b11.8 & u & ? & * -0.2 & 13 10 52.4 & -41 18 04 fc 196 & tyc7779 - 1219 - 1 & 11.05 & s & ? & 0.43 & 12 45 45.7 & -41 49 32 fc 197 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14825935 & b14.5 & u & ? & * 1.0 & 12 52 04.9 & -41 52 03 fc 198 & usno0450 - 14926401 & b14.6 & u & ? & * 0.7 & 12 52 30.3 & -41 55 28 fc 199 & usno0450 - 14931221 & b14.7 & u & ? & * 0.4 & 12 52 41.9 & -41 57 41 fc 200 & usno0450 - 14945366 & b15.0 & u & ? & * 1.0 & 12 53 16.5 & -42 00 40 fc 201 & tyc7779 - 733 - 1 & 10.93 & s & ? & 0.32 & 12 42 37.3 & -42 10 13 fc 202 & tyc7781 - 114 - 1 & 11.19 & s & ? & 0.08 & 13 08 12.6 & -41 57 12 fc 203 & usno0450 - 14682772 & b14.3 & u & ? & ? & 12 41 59.7 & -42 18 16 fc 204 & usno0450 - 15142256 & b14.3 & u & ? & * 0.5 & 13 01 34.0 & -42 07 48 fc 205 & usno0450 - 15213947 & b12.1 & u & ? & ? & 13 04 33.6 & -42 08 21 fc 206 & usno0450 - 14842856 & b13.2 & u & ? & * 0.6 & 12 49 11.6 & -42 26 10 fc 207 & tyc7779 - 1570 - 1 & 10.28 & s & ? & 0.52 & 12 45 58.5 & -42 31 52 fc 208 & tyc7766 - 1132 - 1 & 10.51 & s & ? & 0.37 & 12 38 58.0 & -42 34 53 fc 209 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14919623 & b13.1 & u & ? & * 0.5 & 12 52 13.9 & -42 31 01 fc 210 & sao223535 & 8.95 & s & f2 & 0.36 & 12 35 13.1 & -42 40 21 fc 211 & sao223684 & 7.85 & s & f5iv & 0.54 & 12 49 07.0 & -42 38 03 fc 212 & tyc7780 - 747 - 1 & 10.7 & s & ? & 0.45 & 12 51 24.6 & -42 44 48 fc 213 & sao223819 & 8.8 & s & g5v & 0.71 & 12 59 52.0 & -42 33 41 fc 214 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 14647502 & 9.5 & u & ? & * 0.4 & 12 44 18.5 & -42 47 25 fc 215 & usno0450 - 15318910 & b11.7 & u & ? & ? & 13 08 52.4 & -42 27 49 fc 216 & tyc7779 - 2014 - 1 & 9.82 & s & ? & 0.37 & 12 47 55.1 & -42 50 35 fc 217 & tyc7779 - 2027 - 1 & 9.89 & s & ? & 0.31 & 12 44 10.1 & -43 04 30 fc 218 & sao223942 & 9.56 & s & ? & 0.37 & 13 09 44.9 & -42 43 14 fc 219 & sao223596 & 9.32 & s & f5 & 0.43 & 12 41 10.5 & -43 16 59 fc 220 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 15116369 & b14.5 & u & ? & * 1.5 & 13 04 15.1 & -43 02 04 fc 221 & usno0450 - 15150211 & b12.4 & u & ? & * 0.1 & 13 01 54.1 & -43 03 39 fc 222 & sao223571 & 9.35 & s & a0 m & 0.37 & 12 39 01.6 & -43 25 26 fc 223 & usno0450 - 15209781 & b11.6 & u & ? & ? & 13 04 23.1 & -43 08 30 fc 224 & tyc7783 - 60 - 1 & 9.81 & s & ? & 0.73 & 12 44 25.1 & -43 22 45 fc 225 & tyc7784 - 1348 - 1 & 10.77 & s & ? & 0.24 & 12 57 53.9 & -43 18 20 fc 226 & usno0450 - 15036393 & b12.2 & u & ? & * 0.4 & 12 57 06.7 & -43 20 59 fc 227 & usno0450 - 15075910 & b11.6 & u & ? & * 0.8 & 12 58 46.7 & -43 27 41 fc 228 & tyc7785 - 188 - 1 & 10.26 & s & ? & 0.27 & 13 00 36.8 & -43 27 17 fc 229 & eso269-ig056 & 14.01 & ig & sb(s)mp & ? & 13 10 01.2 & -43 12 46 fc 230 & sao223878 & 9.89 & s & a0 & 0.33 & 13 04 28.6 & -43 23 56 fc 231 & usno0450 - 15171172 & b12.6 & u & ? & * 1.3 & 13 02 46.7 & -43 32 10 fc 232 & usno0450 - 15282695 & b12.6 & u & ? & * 0.5 & 13 07 23.3 & -43 36 50 fc 233 & usno0450 - 15158550 & b12.9 & u & ? & * -1.2 & 13 02 14.6 & -43 39 19 fc 234 & tyc7785 - 367 - 1 & 10.54 & s & ? & 0.40 & 13 08 18.1 & -43 35 18 fc 235 & eso269-ig022/3 & 14.7 & ip & s0 & * -1.3 & 12 58 50.6 & -43 52 35 fc 236 & tyc7784 - 485 - 1 & 9.71 & s & ? & 0.54 & 12 51 01.0 & -44 11 32 fc 237 & usno0450 - 15075030 & b14.7 & u & ? & * 0.1 & 12 58 44.4 & -44 19 32 fc 238 & pgc044774 & 16.0 & gp & sab(s)p & ? & 13 00 31.1 & -44 14 39 fc 239 & usno0450 - 14840957 & b12.0 & u & ? & * 1.4 & 12 48 46.7 & -44 27 22 fc 240 & usno0450 - 15201324 & b13.5 & u & ? & * 0.1 & 13 04 01.7 & -44 19 42 fc 241 & usno0450 - 15199021 & b13.3 & u & ? & * -0.3 & 13 03 56.1 & -44 22 31 fc 242 & usno0450 - 15100880 & b12.7 & u & ? & * 1.1 & 12 59 49.7 & -44 27 49 fc 243 & sao223704 & 9.61 & s & f2 & 0.36 & 12 51 02.6 & -44 53 04 fc 244 & usno0375 - 17118731 & b12.9 & u & ? & * 0.8 & 12 57 28.5 & -45 05 36 fc 245 & tyc8246 - 51 - 1 & 10.82 & s & ? & 0.34 & 12 57 29.5 & -45 25 06 fc 246 & tyc7776 - 1164 - 1 & 9.57 & s & ? & 0.28 & 12 58 58.9 & -40 27 40 fc 247 & sao223716 & 9.52 & s & a0v & 0.11 & 12 51 45.8 & -41 18 27 fc 248 & sao223728 & 8.5 & s & f3v & 0.43 & 12 52 44.7 & -41 11 04 fc 249 & sao223721 & 9.45 & s & a5 & 0.32 & 12 52 16.0 & -43 02 14 fd 1 & sao233280 & 6.92 & s & a4v & 0.59 & 3 48 24.9 & -54 17 37 fd 2 & sao233313 & 8.69 & s & a0 & 0.08 & 3 53 01.3 & -54 06 231 fd 3 & sao233314 & 7.75 & s & b6v&-0.13 & 3 53 22.8 & -54 51 08 fd 4 & sao233384 & 7.52 & s & f0iv & 0.34 & 4 03 40.6 & -52 55 44 fd 5 & tyc8503 - 860 - 1 & 11.15 & s & a & 0.17 & 3 48 14.0 & -56 41 13 fd 6 & sao233351 & 7.81 & s & f5v & 0.42 & 3 59 54.3 & -54 09 41 fd 7 & tyc8504 - 1517 - 1 & 10.42 & s & ? & 0.11 & 3 57 13.7 & -55 05 25 fd 8 & sao233363 & 7.68 & s & a3v & 0.14 & 4 00 59.1 & -54 23 31 fd 9 & sao233306 & 9.25 & s & a0 & 0.07 & 3 51 44.2 & -56 39 06 fd 10 & usno0300 - 01218129 & 13.19 & s & b a & 0.45 & 4 03 21.8 & -54 39 54 fd 11 & sao233334 & 8.66 & s & f0iii & 0.33 & 3 56 34.5 & -56 19 30 fd 12 & sao233341 & 8.36 & s & a9iii & 0.28 & 3 57 45.5 & -56 15 01 fd 13 & hic18969 & 7.66 & s & a3v & 0.17 & 4 03 53.0 & -55 24 00 fd 14 & sao233451 & 9.51 & s & b9&-0.03 & 4 15 18.3 & -52 09 48 fd 15 & hic18656 & 6.84 & s & a2 m & 0.24 & 3 59 37.5 & -56 28 22 fd 16 & sao233423 & 9.49 & s & f8 & 0.53 & 4 10 31.0 & -53 35 06 fd 17 & sao233368 & 9.20 & s & a0 & 0.06 & 4 01 15.4 & -56 19 34 fd 18 & hic18592 & 6.05 & s & f2iv & 0.45 & 3 58 42.9 & -57 06 09 fd 19 & hic19543 & 8.55 & s & f3v & 0.42 & 4 11 08.9 & -54 02 22 fd 20 & gsc0850201085 & 14.78 & s & f & ? & 4 11 31.6 & -53 49 57 fd 21 & usno0300 - 01267605 & b13.7 & s & a & * 0.6 & 4 13 44.9 & -53 26 19 fd 22 & he0365 - 5827 & b13.54 ? & s & sdo & * 1.8 & 3 55 53.6 & -58 18 23 fd 23 & hic20109 & 6.09 & s & a8v & 0.48 & 4 18 40.0 & -52 51 36 fd 24 & usno0300 - 01253020 & 11.87 & s & a & * 0.9 & 4 09 25.4 & -55 44 27 fd 25 & hic18878 & 8.45 & s & f0iv & 0.28 & 4 02 49.7 & -57 27 34 fd 26 & sao233400 & 8.78 & s & a5 & 0.31 & 4 06 37.0 & -56 34 32 fd 27 & sao233460 & 9.63 & s & f2 & 0.28 & 4 16 10.1 & -54 00 53 fd 28 & sao233392 & 9.64 & s & a2 & 0.29 & 4 04 32.8 & -57 09 35 fd 29 & gsc0850200572 & 14.80 & s & sdob & ? & 4 15 30.3 & -54 21 58 fd 30 & he0418 - 5326 & 15.76 & s&wfd a & ? & 4 19 24.8 & -53 19 18 fd 31 & hic18731 & 7.04 & s & a2v & 0.11 & 4 00 44.9 & -58 39 42 fd 32 & hic20117 & 7.17 & s & a1v & 0.11 & 4 18 48.2 & -54 08 08 fd 33 & iue - bpfm 1 7731 & 15.54 & s & wfd a & * -1.2 & 4 19 10.1 & -53 50 43 fd 34 & usno0300 - 01307552 & 14.28 & s & sdo+cool & * 0.3 & 4 20 02.7&-54 04 14 fd 35 & iue - wd0416 - 55 & 15.49 & s & wd & * -1.4 & 4 17 11.4 & -54 57 47 fd 36 & tyc8507 - 189 - 1 + 2 & 9.40 & s & f5iv & 0.47 & 4 04 50.3 & -58 10 40 fd 37 & sao233500 & 9.85 & s & a2 & 0.24 & 4 22 59.4 & -53 32 06 fd 38 & hic19086 & 7.97 & s & a4v & 0.16 & 4 05 31.3 & -58 28 42 fd 39 & hic19759 & 7.55 & s & f5v & 0.45 & 4 14 11.3 & -56 10 36 fd 40 & hic20650 & 6.95 & s & f0v & 0.35 & 4 25 29.8 & -53 06 43 fd 41 & ngc1566 & 10.33 & g & sab(rs ) & 0.56 & 4 20 00.6 & -54 56 17 fd 42 & usno0300 - 01320497 & 13.87 & s & sdo & * -0.8 & 4 22 37.3 & -54 08 49 fd 43 & hic19353 & 9.40 & s & a1v & 0.07 & 4 08 45.9 & -58 29 14 fd 44 & usno0300 - 01325652 & 15.06 & s & a & * -0.4 & 4 23 36.7 & -54 17 17 fd 45 & hic20799 & 8.06 & s & b ? & 0.36 & 4 27 24.2 & -53 24 16 fd 46 & usno0300 - 01351412 & 15.13 & s & sdb & * -0.9 & 4 28 31.0 & -53 27 53 fd 47 & usno0300 - 01295274 & 12.51 & s & a & * -0.4 & 4 17 35.3 & -56 43 36 fd 48 & hic19726 & 7.32 & s & a5iv & 0.22 & 4 13 39.9 & -58 01 19 fd 49 & usno0300 - 01357213 & 13.04 & s & a & * 0.0 & 4 29 35.4 & -53 13 13 fd 50 & usno0300 - 01265933 & b15.7 & u & ? & * -0.8 & 4 11 45.7 & -58 41 06 fd 51 & tyc8505 - 1427 - 1 & 10.62 & s & b - a & 0.19 & 4 25 53.9 & -55 06 11 fd 52 & usno0300 - 01365856 & b12.8 & s & b(l)-a & * -0.5 & 4 31 11.0 & -53 35 27 fd 54 & sao233498 & 9.71 & s & a2 & 0.25 & 4 22 06.0 & -56 58 59 fd 55 & sao233493 & 9.40 & s & f2 & 0.37 & 4 21 23.9 & -57 32 30 fd 56 & sao233526 & 9.80 & s & a0 & 0.01 & 4 27 04.8 & -56 04 24 fd 57 & hic20543 & 7.53 & s & a2v & 0.01 & 4 24 06.9 & -57 15 11 fd 58 & hic19921 & 4.44 & s & k2iv & 1.08 & 4 16 28.9 & -59 18 07 fd 59 & sao233524 & 9.10 & s & f0 & 0.31 & 4 26 33.0 & -56 26 41 fd 63 & hic21281 & 3.30 & s & a0v & -0.08 & 4 33 59.8 & -55 02 42 fd 64 & sao233547 & 9.70 & s & a0 & 0.01 & 4 31 10.2 & -55 54 43 fd 65 & hic21200 & 8.17 & s & f2v & 0.38 & 4 32 43.2 & -55 35 49 fd 66 & hic21460 & 8.50 & s & ap & 0.28 & 4 36 30.8 & -54 37 16 fd 67 & usno0300 - 01340927 & b13.6 & u & ? & * -0.4 & 4 26 29.3 & -59 06 10 fd 68 & tyc8512 - 2014 - 1 & 9.55 & s & f & 0.29 & 4 34 48.1 & -56 35 30 fd 69 & usno0300 - 01391935 & b14.4 & u & ? & * 0.4 & 4 35 59.8 & -56 16 50 fd 70 & hic21787 & 7.75 & s & a8iv & 0.34 & 4 40 48.9 & -56 01 52 fd 71 & sao233619 & 9.35 & s & a & 0.28 & 4 40 18.5 & -56 11 34 fd 75 & tyc8512 - 2052 - 1 & 10.17 & s & ? & 0.16 & 4 42 36.9 & -56 41 35 fd 76 & hic21645 & 7.20 & s & a4v & 0.19 & 4 38 54.1 & -58 58 50 fd 77 & eso118-g34 & 13.52 & g & s0 pec & * 0.4 & 4 40 17.4&-58 44 43 fd 78 & hic18929 & 8.39 & s & f0iii & 0.34 & 4 03 28.1 & -52 30 21 fd 127 & usno - a2 - 0300 - 01385078 & b14.7 & u & ? & * 1.3 & 4 36 17.0 & -57 53 32 fd 128 & tyc8512 - 1176 - 1 & 11.33 & s & ? & 0.84 & 4 43 34.8 & -55 49 34 fd 129 & usno - a2 - 0300 - 01371953 & b12.2 & u & ? & * 0.9 & 4 33 53.7 & -58 50 21 fd 130 & hic21874 & 8.04 & s & f5v & 0.46 & 4 42 10.5 & -56 07 08 fm 2 & hfd 121081 & 8.9 & s & b9v & 0.08&13 53 58.4 & -28 8 34 fm 3 & usno0600 - 09386883 & 14.01 & s & b ? & * -1.1&13 54 00.2 & -27 55 16 fm 4 & sao182054 & 9.34 & s & a2 & 0.28&13 53 44.8 & -27 06 02 fm 5 & hfd 120970 & 10.3 & s & a2 & 0.22&13 53 15.0 & -27 18 37 fm 6 & tyc6724 - 799 - 1 & 11.68 & s & a - f ? & 0.42&13 52 54.8 & -27 40 08 fm 7 & sao182056 & 8.1 & s & a6iv & 0.24&13 53 53.1 & -30 00 39 fm 8 & hfd 120867 & 10.2 & s & a0 & 0.09&13 52 36.0 & -27 30 00 fm 9 & sao182034 & 10.24 & s & a0 & 0.11&13 52 18.7 & -26 47 16 fm 10 & sao204927 & 7.9 & s & a3 & 0.10&13 52 17.6 & -30 47 06 fm 11 & hfd 120657 & 10.5 & s & a2 & 0.24&13 51 23.1 & -29 08 44 fm 12 & hfd 120733 & 9.69 & s & a0 & 0.10 & 13 51 48.7 & -30 48 12 fm 13 & sao181999 & 6.19 & s & a0v & -0.03&13 50 06.4 & -29 04 51 fm 14 & tyc7279 - 1224 - 1 & 12.99 & s & ? & -0.04 & 13 51 28.9 & -30 48 27 fm 15 & sao181996 & 7.70 & s & a6 & 0.45&13 49 54.2 & -28 11 11 fm 16 & usno0600 - 09347896 & 15.37 & u & ? & * -0.1&13 49 10.2 & -26 55 30 fm 17 & sao204899 & 8.6 & s & f6v & 0.41&13 50 38.2 & -30 15 41 fm 18 & sao181993 & 8.7 & s & a2 & 0.36&13 49 47.3 & -28 38 24 fm 19 & usno0600 - 09348084 & b15.2 & s & f ? & * 0.4&13 49 11.6&-27 25 30 fm 20 & sao204900 & 7.1 & s & a5 & 0.17&13 50 39.6 & -31 12 20 fm 21 & sao204892 & 7.2 & s & f0 & 0.29 & 13 50 20.9 & -31 04 03 fm 22 & tyc6728 - 518 - 1 & 11.16 & s & a ? & 0.27&13 49 10.9 & -28 34 31 fm 23 & usno0600 - 09343173 & 13.52 & s & a ? & * -0.2&13 48 35.8 & -27 56 33 fm 24 & tyc6727 - 804 - 1 & 11.41 & s & b - a ? & 0.19&13 48 05.8 & -29 20 22 fm 25 & sao181931 & 5.8 & s & a0v & 0.02&13 45 36.3 & -26 06 57 fm 26 & tyc7266 - 692 - 1 & 10.69 & s & a0 & 0.10 & 13 47 50.9 & -31 32 49 fm 27 & usno0600 - 09325326 & 11.83 & u & ? & * 0.5&13 46 27.3 & -28 02 45 fm 28 & n5291/b & 14.00 & g & s pec & ? & 13 47 24.1 & -30 24 27 fm 29 & sao181949 & 8.6 & s & f8 & 0.51&13 46 57.5 & -29 40 18 fm 30 & hfd 119753 & 8.2 & s & f3v & 0.60&13 45 35.0 & -27 51 15 fm 32 & sao204825 & 8.3 & s & g0 & 0.59&13 46 17.0 & -30 28 28 fm 33 & tyc7266 - 1276 - 1 & 11.17 & s & a - f ? & 0.13 & 13 46 07.6 & -30 12 29 fm 34 & sao181919 & 8.6 & s & a3 & 0.30 & 13 44 36.7 & -26 46 48 fm 35 & tyc7266 - 1014 - 1 & 11.47 & s & a - f ? & 0.17 & 13 46 25.2 & -31 45 48 fm 36 & sao181928 & 8.8 & s & f0 & 0.31&13 45 17.8 & -29 01 00 fm 37 & hfd 119463 & 10.5 & s & a3 & 0.24 & 13 43 52.4 & -26 47 38 fm 38 & usno0600 - 09305363 & 15.35 & s & a - f(e ) ? & * -0.2&13 44 10.0 & -28 17 21 fm 39 & sao181910 & 8.8 & s & a2 & 0.26 & 13 43 53.9 & -27 45 59 fm 41 & sao181914 & 9.3 & s & a2 & 0.07&13 44 25.4 & -30 07 50 fm 42 & sao204787 & 8.5 & s & f0 & 0.37&13 44 09.9 & -31 48 59 fm 43 & sao181891 & 7.0 & s & a2v & 0.90&13 43 00.9 & -30 10 58 fm 44 & sao204771 & 9.0 & s & f0iv & 0.38&13 43 27.1 & -31 26 39 fm 45 & sao181862 & 8.7 & s & a2v & 0.19&13 41 31.2 & -27 16 21 fm 46 & sao181876 & 8.5 & s & f0 & 0.31&13 42 15.5 & -29 46 12 fm 47 & sao181868 & 8.0 & s & f2 & 0.37&13 41 43.6 & -28 45 44 fm 48 & usno0525 - 13768846 & 12.17 & s & a ? & * -0.1&13 42 29.8 & -31 3 21 fm 49 & n5264 & 12.6 & g & ib(s)m & 0.55&13 41 31.9 & -29 55 08 fm 50 & hic66742 & 8.01 & s & f3 & 0.44 & 13 40 47.0 & -28 14 32 fm 51 & usno - a2 - 0600 - 15938674 & b13.7 & u & ? & * -2.0 & 13 40 46.1 & -28 56 54 fm 52 & sao181838 & 8.4 & s & a3 & 0.10&13 39 52.9 & -27 09 05 fm 53 & usno0525 - 13747141 & b13.8 & s & a ? & * 0.1&13 41 13.3 & -31 34 54 fm 54 & gsc06726001897 & 14.58 & s & ? & ? & 13 39 42.5 & -28 8 37 fm 56 & sao181827 & 8.1 & s & a3iv & 0.16&13 38 44.5 & -27 15 35 fm 57 & sao181823 & 8.4 & s & a1v & 0.09&13 38 31.2 & -26 54 21 fm 58 & ngc5253 & 10.87 & g&im pec & 0.38&13 39 56.8 & -31 38 11 fm 59 & sao204696 & 9.59 & s & a3 & 0.35&13 39 07.3 & -30 15 30 fm 60 & sao181825 & 5.8 & s & f3v & 0.42 & 13 38 42.1 & -29 33 39 fm 61 & sao204695 & 9.37 & s & f5 & 0.38&13 39 03.6 & -30 44 53 fm 62 & sao204711 & 9.8 & s & a0 & 0.18 & 13 39 41.8 & -32 29 21 fm 63 & sao181807 & 8.6 & s & a5 & 0.17&13 37 34.8 & -27 03 31 fm 64 & sao181821 & 7.0 & s & f2iii & 0.40&13 38 23.3 & -29 50 20 fm 69 & he1334 - 2739 & 16.41 & ag & qso cand . & & 13 37 04.7 & -27 54 20 fm 70 & n5236 & 8.2 & g & sab(s)c & 0.61&13 36 58.8 & -29 51 52 fm 71 & i4293 & 13.50 & g & sa0 & * 1.5&13 36 01.7 & -25 52 53 fm 72 & sao204668 & 9.08 & s & a3 & 0.35&13 37 33.4 & -32 08 24 fm 73 & he1333 - 2853 & 15.92 & s & sda or qso cand . & & 13 36 29.5 & -29 08 53 fm 74 & hfd 118250 & 10.7 & s & a2 & 0.25&13 36 06.8 & -28 42 20 fm 75 & usno0525 - 13671585 & b13.4 & s & a ? & * 0.5&13 36 40.5 & -30 18 36 fm 76 & hfd 118350 & 9.8 & s & a0 & 0.31 & 13 36 58.8 & -32 17 38 fm 77 & sao204651 & 7.6 & s & a9v & 0.42&13 36 46.7 & -32 24 13 fm 78 & usno0600 - 09235666 & 13.7 & us & ? & * 1.1&13 35 00.6 & -26 05 32 fm 79 & sao181775 & 8.4 & s & a0 & 0.01&13 35 30.8 & -29 09 18 fm 80 & sao181779 & 8.1 & s & f2v & 0.41&13 35 41.1 & -29 22 40 fm 81 & sao181760 & 8.9 & s & m0 & 1.27&13 34 18.0 & -25 22 49 fm 82 & hfd 118147 & 10.03 & s & a3 & 0.27 & 13 35 34.3 & -31 25 26 fm 83 & hfd 118162 & 9.7 & s & a0 & 0.17 & 13 35 37.8 & -32 01 04 fm 85 & sao204623 & 6.8 & s & f0 & 0.37&13 35 12.2 & -32 12 45 fm 86 & sao204613 & 9.7 & s & f2 & 0.37&13 34 42.4 & -31 12 13 fm 87 & sao181742 & 6.9 & s & a9iv & 0.33&13 32 54.0 & -26 35 15 fm 88 & sao181749 & 8.7 & s & a2 & 0.07&13 33 09.2 & -29 17 58 fm 89 & sao181737 & 5.7 & s & a1v & 0.04&13 32 35.9 & -28 41 34 fm 90 & sao204584 & 10.2 & s & a0 & 0.01&13 33 19.7 & -31 39 13 fm 91 & sao181736 & 8.2 & s & a4v & 0.18&13 32 35.1 & -29 17 45 fm 93 & sao181735 & 6.4 & s & f5iv & 0.44&13 32 34.5&-29 33 55 fm 94 & ppm291518 & 10.49 & s & a ? & 0.20 & 13 33 06.6 & -31 47 36 fm 95 & sao181723 & 6.4 & s & a1v & 0.09&13 31 33.2 & -28 06 46 fm 96 & sao181716 & 7.5 & s & a4iv & 0.18&13 31 07.4 & -25 39 25 fm 97 & hfd 117531 & 9.70 & s & a2 & 0.27&13 31 20.8 & -27 31 46 fm 98 & tyc7269 - 1285 - 1 & 11.21 & s & ? & 0.04 & 13 32 42.5 & -32 47 00 fm 105 & sao181690 & 7.6 & s & a5 & 0.17&13 29 30.4 & -27 23 22 fm 106 & sao181698 & 9.2 & s & a3v & 0.16&13 29 53.0 & -28 56 41 fm 107 & sao181691 & 9.3 & s & a0 & 0.01&13 29 32.5 & -29 05 28 fm 108 & gsc06721 - 01689 & 13.4 & s & hot star ? & * -0.8&13 28 18.2 & -26 33 51 fm 119 & sao181601 & 8.8 & s & a2 & 0.07&13 22 42.7 & -30 11 51 fm 120 & gsc06712 - 01800 & 13.4 & s & a ? & * -0.3&13 21 56.2 & -28 26 31 fm 121 & usno - a2 - 0600 - 15616353 & b12.1 & s & a ? & * 0.3 & 13 20 45.5 & -29 29 33 fm 122 & sao204359 & 8.48 & s & b5iii & -0.11&13 19 43.0 & -30 19 56 fm 136 & sao181916 & 9.2 & s & k0 & 0.86&13 44 26.8 & -26 19 27 fm 137 & usno0600 - 09301026 & b14.6 & u & ? & * 1.3&13 43 36.1 & -26 29 45 fm 138 & gsc06727 - 01025 & 13.0 & s & f ? & * 1.2&13 44 43.6 & -29 37 49 fm 139 & hfd 119523 & 10.54 & s & f5 & 0.31 & 13 44 14.6 & -28 48 56 fm 174 & sao204493 & 8.3 & s & f3v & 0.48&13 27 45.0 & -30 47 03 fm 175 & eso444 - 46 & 15 & g & e & ? & 13 27 56.8 & -31 29 43 fm 176 & eso444 - 37 & 14.82 & g & sb(s)dm & * 0.6&13 26 59.8 & -30 04 27 fm 177 & ppm261656 & 9.7 & s & f8 & 0.38&13 26 21.8 & -26 50 54 fm 190 & sao204469 & 6.84 & s & f0v & 0.40&13 26 08.1 & -32 32 51 fm 191 & sao204853 & 9.1 & s & a2 & 0.07&13 48 10.1 & -32 14 18 fm 192 & sao204562 & 9.1 & s & f0 & 0.31&13 32 03.0 & -32 12 44 fm 193 & sao181770 & 9.00 & s & f8 & 0.54&13 35 05.1 & -25 18 15 fm 194 & hfd 119027 & 10.5 & s & a3 & 0.48&13 41 19.8 & -28 47 00 fm 195 & sao20462 & 8.0 & s & f3 & 0.46&13 35 15.9 & -31 24 31 fm 196 & gsc07266 - 00123 & 12.97 & s & ? & * 1.8&13 40 06.6 & -31 31 11 fm 197 & sao181785 & 9.6 & s & g5 & 0.64 & 13 36 13.4 & -29 39 40 ft 1 & ppm325630 & 10.57 & s & ? & 0.03 & 19 55 29.2 & -49 31 21 ft 2 & sao229911 & 8.97 & s & ? & 0.36 & 19 53 14.7 & -48 28 10 ft 3 & hic98444 & 6.67 & s & f2iv & 0.40 & 20 00 08.4 & -50 13 00 ft 4 & usno0375 - 38494969 & b12.8 & u & ? & * -0.5 & 19 54 53.6 & -48 32 33 ft 5 & hic98040 & 8.14 & s & f0v & 0.31 & 19 55 20.4 & -48 16 56 ft 6 & tyc8399 - 146 - 1 & 9.05 & s & ? & 0.49 & 20 02 07.3 & -49 58 54 ft 7 & usno0375 - 38670988 & b13.3 & u & ? & * -0.3 & 20 04 52.6 & -49 57 14 ft 8 & hic98449 & 7.67 & s & f6v & 0.47 & 20 00 11.8 & -48 44 54 ft 9 & sao229930 & 9.87 & s & a0 & 0.07 & 19 56 10.6 & -47 23 15 ft 10 & hic98880 & 8.55 & s & f0v & 0.37 & 20 04 47.8 & -49 45 18 ft 11 & usno0375 - 38647724 & b14.1 & u & ? & * 0.3 & 20 03 31.2 & -49 21 06 ft 12 & sao229910 & 8.19 & s & a2 & 0.14 & 19 53 09.0 & -46 22 12 ft 13 & sao229967 & 8.92 & s & a5 & 0.29 & 19 59 57.9 & -48 11 25 ft 14 & sao230028 & 9.6 & s & a2 & 0.03 & 20 05 07.1 & -49 30 17 ft 15 & sao246465 & 9.2 & s & a3 & 0.28 & 20 09 33.0 & -50 26 25 ft 16 & tyc8400 - 1697 - 1 & 9.56 & s & ? & 0.22 & 20 05 59.3 & -49 31 10 ft 17 & tyc8400 - 1353 - 1 & 11.1 & s & ? & 0.68 & 20 07 46.2 & -49 56 35 ft 18 & tyc8395 - 622 - 1 & 9.08 & s & f2 & 0.36 & 19 59 45.4 & -47 32 59 ft 19 & tyc8396 - 100 - 1 & 10.18 & s & ? & 0.36 & 20 03 51.2 & -48 37 04 ft 20 & sao229945 & 9.23 & s & a2 & 0.17 & 19 57 03.4 & -46 35 26 ft 21 & sao230036 & 10.42 & s & a0 & -0.05 & 20 06 17.2 & -48 59 39 ft 22 & tyc8396 - 580 - 1 & 9.66 & s & ? & 0.30 & 20 04 59.6 & -48 36 49 ft 23 & sao230006 & 10.12 & s & a3 & 0.16 & 20 02 52.5 & -47 58 52 ft 24 & hic98577 & 6.99 & s & f2iv & 0.35 & 20 01 25.3 & -47 23 51 ft 25 & hic99595 & 7.92 & s & f3v & 0.39 & 20 12 43.2 & -50 18 41 ft 26 & tyc8395 - 1024 - 1 & 10.5 & s & ? & 0.16 & 20 02 06.0 & -47 18 51 ft 27 & hic99703 & 8.42 & s & a2v & 0.12 & 20 13 54.9 & -50 19 16 ft 28 & usno0375 - 38688655 & b13.3 & u & ? & * -0.5 & 20 05 55.8 & -48 16 10 ft 29 & hic99260 & 8.83 & s & f2v & 0.38 & 20 08 58 & -49 04 42 ft 30 & usno0375 - 38800440 & b12.3 & u & ? & * -0.7 & 20 12 52.0 & -49 58 28 ft 31 & sao230049 & 7.95 & s & f2 & 0.43 & 20 07 39.5 & -48 39 08 ft 32 & ngc6851a / b & 14.81 & gp & sb & 0.84 & 20 05 39.7 & -47 58 40 ft 33 & hic98355 & 7.49 & s & f6v & 0.47 & 19 58 58.6 & -46 05 17 ft 34 & euvej2009 - 48.8 & 15.3 & qs & bl lac & * 0.6 & 20 09 25.4 & -48 49 54 ft 35 & sao230030 & 9.06 & s & a0 & 0.10 & 20 05 10.8 & -47 29 17 ft 36 & usno0375 - 38564499 & b11.6 & u & ? & * 1.0 & 19 58 43.0 & -45 36 31 ft 37 & tyc8417 - 667 - 1 & 10.02 & s & ? & 1.10 & 20 18 17.8 & -50 39 33 ft 38 & sao229984 & 8.78 & s & a0 & 0.00 & 20 00 53.4 & -45 41 58 ft 39 & sao230088 & 9.02 & s & a3 & 0.24 & 20 11 23.6 & -48 22 46 ft 40 & sao230060 & 8.09 & s & f0 & 0.29 & 20 08 30.1 & -47 33 34 ft 41 & tyc8413 - 1194 - 1 & 10.96 & s & ? & 0.58 & 20 19 24.6 & -50 12 41 ft 42 & sao230054 & 8.77 & s & a2 & 0.02 & 20 08 07.1 & -47 10 56 ft 43 & hic98512 & 5.8 & s & a8iii & 0.00 & 20 00 48.3 & -45 06 47 ft 44 & sao230121 & 9.75 & s & ? & 0.22 & 20 15 36.5 & -48 58 21 ft 45 & hic99130 & 8.72 & s & f0v & 0.39 & 20 07 31.0 & -46 50 50 ft 46 & hic100349 & 7.31 & s & a3v & 0.13 & 20 21 02.2 & -50 01 02 ft 47 & tyc8409 - 5 - 1 & 10.71 & s & ? & 1.2 & 20 15 15.6 & -48 43 43 ft 48 & tyc8392 - 1957 - 1 & 11.21 & s & ? & -0.05 & 20 06 24.1 & -46 04 05 ft 49 & usno0375 - 38880708 & b14.1 & u & ? & * -2.2 & 20 18 07.4 & -48 57 32 ft 50 & sao230000 & 7.91 & s & a0 & -0.03 & 20 02 10.2 & -44 27 58 ft 51 & sao230062 & 8.28 & s & f5v & 0.43 & 20 08 37.9 & -46 18 05 ft 52 & usno0375 - 38684700 & b15.7 & u & ? & * -0.3 & 20 05 41.5 & -45 33 25 ft 53 & tyc8413 - 818 - 1 & 8.03 & s & ? & 1.08 & 20 22 17.1 & -49 26 51 ft 54 & hic98859 & 7.83 & s & a9iv & 0.30 & 20 04 29.8 & -44 56 49 ft 55 & sao230181 & 9.54 & s & f5 & 0.35 & 20 23 36.6 & -49 47 44 ft 56 & sao230012 & 8.34 & s & a2 & 0.17 & 20 03 29.4 & -44 35 36 ft 57 & tyc08409 - 887 - 1 & b11.9 & u & ? & 0.58 & 20 18 29.1 & -48 32 11 ft 58 & usno0375 - 38762110 & b11.2 & u & ? & * 1.2 & 20 10 25.9 & -46 25 34 ft 59 & tyc8413 - 1203 - 1 & 10.68 & s & ? & 0.90 & 20 23 18.8 & -49 20 47 ft 60 & tyc8409 - 365 - 1 & 9.09 & s & ? & 0.05 & 20 20 07.0 & -48 28 41 ft 61 & sao230017 & 9.25 & s & a0 & 0.06 & 20 03 51.4 & -43 50 01 ft 62 & sao230111 & 9.68 & s & ? & 0.21 & 20 13 54.5 & -46 33 23 ft 63 & sao230099 & 9.07 & s & a0 & 0.19 & 20 12 22.3 & -46 10 00 ft 64 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 38582716 & b15.8 & u & ? & * 1.5 & 20 07 43.4 & -44 56 45 ft 65 & usno0375 - 38856050 & b12.8 & u & ? & * 1.1 & 20 16 32.2 & -47 06 59 ft 66 & hic100184 & 6.13 & s & f5v & 0.48 & 20 19 17.7 & -47 34 47 ft 67 & tyc8392 - 1398 - 1 & 10.42 & s & ? & 0.46 & 20 12 25.6 & -45 49 29 ft 68 & tyc7959 - 412 - 1 & 10.74 & s & ? & 0.28 & 20 09 38.3 & -44 44 52 ft 69 & tyc7959 - 1706 - 1 & 11 & s & ? & 0.19 & 20 08 59.3 & -44 30 19 ft 70 & hic99671 & 7.79 & s & ap & 0.00 & 20 13 34.8 & -45 35 26 ft 71 & tyc8409 - 1802 - 1 & 9.78 & s & ? & 0.05 & 20 21 56.8 & -47 43 25 ft 72 & sao230183 & 8.92 & s & f0 & 0.30 & 20 24 00.7 & -48 13 43 ft 73 & tyc8414 - 154 - 1 & 8.93 & s & ? & 0.15 & 20 30 20.6 & -49 26 29 ft 74 & tyc7959 - 1973 - 1 & 10.57 & s & ? & 0.34 & 20 09 39.5 & -44 18 56 ft 75 & tyc8405 - 1915 - 1 & 10.85 & s & ? & 0.10 & 20 18 15.0 & -46 31 36 ft 76 & hic100872 & 7.84 & s & f3iv & 0.43 & 20 27 11.1 & -48 35 35 ft 77 & sao230082 & 9.58 & s & a5 & 0.18 & 20 10 30.7 & -44 08 04 ft 78 & tyc8410 - 1739 - 1 & 8.41 & s & a7iv & 0.26 & 20 26 38.3 & -47 57 42 ft 79 & sao230096 & 9.26 & s & a0 & 0.10 & 20 12 03.3 & -44 15 42 ft 80 & hic99426 & 7.84 & s & a3 m & 0.25 & 20 10 50.2 & -43 36 11 ft 81 & usno - a2 - 0375 - 38789037 & b13.6 & u & ? & * -3.0 & 20 26 22.0 & -47 30 44 ft 82 & hic99448 & 7.71 & s & a4v & 0.22 & 20 11 04.7 & -43 28 28 ft 83 & hic100467 & 9.39 & s & f0v & 0.32 & 20 22 26.3 & -46 26 58 ft 84 & usno0450 - 38842338 & b14.4 & u & ? & * -0.4 & 20 12 41.5 & -43 50 53 ft 85 & hic99722 & 8.42 & s & f8iv & 0.44 & 20 14 06.4 & -44 10 24 ft 86 & sao230212 & 7.65 & s & f0 & 0.33 & 20 27 00.9 & -47 15 34 ft 87 & usno0375 - 39045904 & b13.3 & u & ? & * -0.8 & 20 29 34.1 & -47 47 26 ft 88 & usno0450 - 38892109 & b12.5 & u & ? & * 0.7 & 20 15 38.7 & -44 29 59 ft 89 & tyc7960 - 215 - 1 & 9.7 & s & a3 & 0.17 & 20 12 04.3 & -43 23 53 ft 90 & tyc8405 - 1234 - 1 & 9.78 & s & ? & 0.33 & 20 20 44.3 & -45 39 49 ft 91 & hic100787 & 6.73 & s & a9iii & 0.29 & 20 26 04.8 & -46 39 36 ft 92 & sao230170 & 8.65 & s & a0 & 0.09 & 20 21 57.2 & -45 38 20 ft 93 & hic99806 & 8.19 & s & a7v & 0.21 & 20 14 59.8 & -43 40 42 ft 94 & sao230230 & 9.36 & s & a2 & 0.20 & 20 28 23.9 & -46 57 21 ft 95 & tyc8410 - 743 - 1 & 11.44 & s & ? & 0.22 & 20 33 45.99 & -47 56 38 ft 96 & sao230200 & 8.95 & s & ? & 0.33 & 20 26 04.0 & -46 09 29 ft 97 & sao230238 & 7.42 & s & a0 & 0.05 & 20 29 38.6 & -46 09 05 ft 98 & hic100487 & 7.94 & s & a5 m & 0.34 & 20 22 38.1 & -44 35 14 ft 99 & tyc8406 - 29 - 1 & 10.71 & s & ? & 1.06 & 20 34 00.4 & -46 51 16 ft 100 & tyc8406 - 795 - 1 & 9.57 & s & ? & 0.33 & 20 29 53.0 & -45 54 48 ft 101 & sao230237 & 8.35 & s & ? & 0.23 & 20 29 30.5 & -45 22 58 ft 102 & sao230215 & 8.16 & s & f0 & 0.33 & 20 27 13.6 & -44 45 31 ft 103 & hic100528 & 8.39 & s & a6iv & 0.23 & 20 23 02.1 & -43 40 14 ft 104 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 38843012 & b13.6 & u & ? & * 1.1 & 20 22 45.4 & -43 29 43 ft 106 & tyc7961 - 435 - 1 & 9.89 & s & ? & 0.14 & 20 23 54.1 & -43 39 11 ft 107 & tyc7961 - 1763 - 1 & 10.5 & s & ? & 0.17 & 20 29 19.0 & -44 57 18 ft 108 & ngc6902 & 11.64 & ig & sa(r)b & 0.62 & 20 24 27.7 & -43 39 09 ft 109 & sao230295 & 10.23 & s & a0 & 0.03 & 20 36 54.6 & -46 27 22 ft 110 & tyc8406 - 1679 - 1 & 8.00 & s & f0 & 0.3 & 20 32 09.7 & -45 21 14 ft 111 & tyc8406 - 457 - 1/2 & 7.52 & s & a7iii & 0.28 & 20 36 30.5 & -45 33 28 ft 112 & usno0450 - 39114689 & b12.2 & u & ? & * 1.0 & 20 30 14.1 & -44 00 30 ft 113 & tyc8399 - 463 - 1 & 10.52 & s & ? & 0.17 & 20 01 32.4 & -50 17 46 ft 114 & usno0375 - 38638499 & b11.9 & u & ? & * 0.7 & 20 02 59.4 & -50 17 45 ft 115 & usno0375 - 38534372 & b13.7 & u & ? & * 1.4 & 19 57 01.8 & -48 18 58 ft 116 & usno - a2 - 0375 - 38402237 & b12.3 & u & ? & * 0.7 & 20 01 19.7 & -49 33 04 ft 117 & usno0375 - 38485210 & b13.9 & u & ? & ? & 19 54 22.9 & -47 37 44 ft 118 & usno0375 - 38502981 & b11.9 & u & ? & ? & 19 55 19.0 & -47 48 48 ft 119 & tyc8395 - 953 - 1 & 11.49 & s & ? & 0.04 & 19 57 16.1 & -48 21 29 ft 120 & tyc8400 - 336 - 1 & 10.97 & s & ? & 0.34 & 20 03 56.4 & -49 48 25 ft 121 & sao22994 & 9.61 & s & ? & 0.21 & 19 56 57.0 & -47 25 22 ft 122 & usno - a2 - 0375 - 38326701 & b12.4 & u & ? & * 1.0 & 19 57 01.1 & -47 03 45 ft 123 & tyc8391 - 843 - 1 & 10.47 & s & ? & 0.24 & 19 55 20.5 & -46 47 57 ft 124 & usno0375 - 38606749 & b13.8 & u & ? & * 0.5 & 20 01 08.3 & -48 28 31 ft 125 & tyc8391 - 2312 - 1 & 10.04 & s & ? & 0.40 & 19 54 35.9 & -46 30 37 ft 126 & usno0375 - 38593648 & b15.4 & u & ? & ? & 20 00 22.2 & -47 55 22 ft 127 & tyc8391 - 1762 - 1 & 10.69 & s & ? & 0.28 & 19 54 37.7 & -46 13 35 ft 128 & usno0375 - 38709646 & b12.3 & u & ? & * -0.4 & 20 07 11.4 & -49 30 04 ft 129 & tyc8404 - 1258 - 1 & 8.53 & s & ? & 0.56 & 20 12 02.9 & -50 43 23 ft 130 & tyc8395 - 1998 - 1 & 10.5 & s & ? & 0.83 & 19 59 33.0 & -47 04 30 ft 131 & ngc6845/a / b / c / fd & 14.28 & ig & sbb?pec & ? & 20 01 05.8 & -47 03 34 ft 132 & pgc063901 & 14.27 & gp & sab & * 0.2 & 19 58 17.6 & -46 06 46 ft 133 & sao98233 & 8.64 & s & f5iv & 0.01 & 19 57 45.2 & -45 49 39 ft 134 & usno0375 - 38806618 & b15.3 & u & ? & * 0.1 & 20 13 16.6 & -49 36 20 ft 135 & tyc8396 - 154 - 1 & 10.66 & s & ? & 0.24 & 20 09 52.3 & -48 34 30 ft 136 & tyc8391 - 677 - 1 & 10.85 & s & ? & 0.59 & 19 58 53.2 & -45 05 24 ft 137 & usno - a2 - 0375 - 38425789 & b11.1 & u & ? & * 0.5 & 20 02 43.4 & -45 57 22 ft 138 & usno - a2 - 0375 - 38637967 & b13.6 & u & ? & * 0.2 & 20 15 59.7 & -48 51 28 ft 139 & tyc8392 - 28 - 1 & 10.59 & s & ? & 0.15 & 20 07 57.6 & -46 43 45 ft 140 & tyc8413 - 614 - 1 & 9.98 & s & ? & 0.35 & 20 20 38.8 & -49 49 00 ft 141 & usno0375 - 38888302 & b12.7 & u & ? & * -0.8 & 20 18 36.2 & -49 13 07 ft 142 & tyc8396 - 418 - 1 & 10.63 & s & ? & 0.91 & 20 14 43.0 & -48 12 50 ft 143 & usno0375 - 38910011 & b13.4 & u & ? & * 0.8 & 20 20 01.1 & -49 19 57 ft 144 & tyc8413 - 1738 - 1 & 10 & s & ? & 0.34 & 20 24 36.6 & -50 25 20 ft 145 & tyc8392 - 1262 - 1 & 10.06 & s & ? & 0.65 & 20 06 16.8 & -45 54 16 ft 146 & eso234-g004 & 15.27 & gp & sbpec & ? & 20 20 43.4 & -49 07 29 ft 147 & usno - a2 - 0375 - 38528298 & b15.8 & u & ? & * -0.2 & 20 08 55.8 & -46 05 47 ft 148 & usno0375 - 38748771 & b11.3 & u & ? & * 0.3 & 20 09 35.9 & -46 07 28 ft 149 & usno0375 - 38753431 & b12.6 & u & ? & * 1.0 & 20 09 53.4 & -46 03 28 ft 150 & tyc7959 - 742 - 1 & 11.12 & s & ? & 0.15 & 20 05 11.9 & -44 39 32 ft 151 & usno0450 - 38690235 & b13.5 & u & ? & * 1.2 & 20 04 58.4 & -44 29 13 ft 152 & usno - a2 - 0375 - 38561392 & b15.7 & u & ? & * 0.0 & 20 10 59.6 & -45 53 50 ft 153 & usno0375 - 38758273 & 13.3 & u & ? & * 0.8 & 20 10 11.8 & -45 41 40 ft 154 & usno0375 - 38732664 & b15.9 & u & ? & * -0.5 & 20 08 36.3 & -45 05 16 ft 155 & usno0375 - 38963244 & b12.7 & u & ? & * 1.4 & 20 23 35.0 & -48 49 06 ft 156 & usno - a2 - 0450 - 38583089 & b17.7 & u & ? & * 0.1 & 20 07 44.6 & -44 37 38 ft 157 & usno0450 - 38718073 & b14.7 & u & ? & * -0.2 & 20 06 21.4 & -44 03 01 ft 158 & tyc8405 - 885 - 1 & 10.36 & s & ? & 0.37 & 20 15 24.7 & -46 19 50 ft 159 & usno0450 - 38794373 & b14.1 & u & ? & * 1.0 & 20 10 16.8 & -44 52 15 ft 160 & sao230055 & 8.49 & s & f5 & 0.441 & 20 08 01.3 & -44 11 33 ft 161 & eso284-ig045 & 14 & ig & sabbc & ? & 20 16 48.6 & -46 31 55 ft 162 & sao230119 & 9.75 & s & f5 & 0.38 & 20 15 12.5 & -46 03 12 ft 163 & tyc7959 - 962 - 1 & 10.18 & s & ? & 0.44 & 20 07 49.5 & -43 37 54 ft 164 & usno0375 - 39013302 & b14.4 & u & ? & * 0.9 & 20 27 11.4 & -48 19 47 ft 165 & usno - a2 - 0375 - 38776135 & b12.0 & u & ? & * 0.0 & 20 25 27.5 & -47 51 23 ft 166 & tyc7960 - 1677 - 1 & 9.77 & s & ? & 0.31 & 20 14 09.1 & -44 51 02 ft 167 & tyc8414 - 685 - 1 & 10.21 & s & ? & 0.36 & 20 34 24.2 & -49 05 05 ft 168 & usno0375 - 38887188 & b15.1 & u & ? & ? & 20 18 32.0 & -45 20 59 ft 169 & pgc064404 & 14.31 & pm & sabbcp & 0.95 & 20 16 45.5 & -44 41 43 ft 169 & pgc064399 & 14.51 & pm & sbdm & 1.17 & 20 16 31.0 & -44 42 32 ft 170 & sao230206 & 9.23 & s & f2 & 0.37 & 20 26 48.6 & -46 26 34 ft 171 & tyc8410 - 1555 - 1 & 11.42 & s & ? & 0.37 & 20 35 23.8 & -48 19 20 ft 172 & usno0375 - 38983401 & b15.2 & u & ? & * 1.1 & 20 25 03.5 & -45 42 55 ft 173 & tyc8406 - 1146 - 1 & 11.11 & s & ? & 0.07 & 20 29 17.2 & -46 27 58 ft 174 & hic101168 & 9.17 & s & f5v & 0.41 & 20 30 22.4 & -46 27 20 ft 175 & usno0375 - 39019592 & b14.2 & u & ? & * 1.3 & 20 27 39.3 & -45 40 49 ft 176 & usno0450 - 38948511 & b12.6 & u & ? & * 0.5 & 20 19 12.5 & -43 34 02 ft 177 & usno0450 - 39036632 & b13.6 & u & ? & * 1.4 & 20 24 53.5 & -44 37 31 ft 178 & sao230167 & 9.75 & s & f0 & 0.47 & 20 21 34.2 & -43 49 17 ft 179 & usno0375 - 39120597 & b12.8 & u & ? & * 0.8 & 20 35 14.8 & -46 58 10 ft 180 & usno0450 - 39039977 & b15.9 & u & ? & * 0.8 & 20 25 06.8 & -44 27 39 ft 181 & usno - a2 - 0375 - 38811091 & b13.9 & u & ? & * 1.2 & 20 27 58.9 & -45 00 52 ft 182 & tyc8406 - 452 - 1 & 10.59 & s & ? & 0.36 & 20 29 12.5 & -45 07 14 ft 183 & tyc7962 - 710 - 1 & 9.85 & s & ? & 0.52 & 20 31 12.8 & -44 45 57 ft 184 & tyc8414 - 669 - 1 & 8.46 & s & a2vn & 0.10 & 20 29 26.78 & -49 46 59 ft 185 & tyc8414 - 387 - 1 & 10.66 & s & ? & -0.12 & 20 29 48.9 & -49 52 24 ft 186 & hic97756 & 8.31 & s & a7iiim & 0.28 & 19 51 58.9 & -46 51 42 ft 187 & tyc7960 - 817 - 1 & 9.72 & s & ? & 0.38 & 20 15 08.2 & -43 34 14 ft 188 & sao230029 & 9.67 & s & f0 & 0.43 & 20 05 08.9 & -47 21 42 ft 189 & usno0450 - 39025207 & b13.2 & u & ? & * 2.0 & 20 24 07.9 & -43 41 10 lllccccc fc 27 & eso 323-g025 & sa(rs)b & [email protected] & 13.39 & 1.17 & fc 32 & ngc 4553 & sa(r)0 & [email protected] & 12.17 & 1.02 & fc 44 & usno & sab(r)cd & [email protected] & 9.9 & * -1.3 & fc 61 & pgc 042966 & e ? & [email protected] & 12.72 & 1.08 & fc 71 & ngc 4683 & sb(s)0 & [email protected] & 13.8 & 0.93 & fc 75 & ngc 4930 & sb(rs)bc & [email protected] & 12.0 & 0.76 & fc 161 & ngc 4679 & sa(s)bc & [email protected] & 11.94 & 1.38 & fc 186 & eso 323-g054 & s & [email protected] & 14.86 & & fc 229 & eso 269-ig056 & sb(s)m pec & [email protected] & 14.01 & & fc 235 & eso 269-ig022/3 & s0+e & [email protected] & 14.75 + 16.17 & & int.pair fc 238 & pgc044774 & sab(s ) pec & [email protected] & 16.0 & & fd 41 & ngc 1566 & sab(rs)bc sy1 & [email protected] & 10.33 & 0.56 & xrays fd 53 & ngc 1602 & ib(s)m pec & [email protected] & 12.98 & 0.35 & fd 62 & euvej0425 - 57.1 & sy1 & [email protected] & 14.1 & * -0.6 & xrays fd 77 & eso 118-g034 & s0 pec & [email protected] & 13.04 & 0.44 & hii gal . fd 82 & ngc 1522 & s0 pec & [email protected] & 13.56 & 0.27 & fd 86 & ngc 1515 & sab(s)bc & [email protected] & 11.20 & 0.85 & fd 93 & ic 2032 & iab(s)m pec & [email protected] & 14.73 & * -3.6 & fd 97 & ngc 1536 & sb(s)c pec & [email protected] & 12.52 & 0.63 & fd 100 & ic 2073 & sb(s)cd ? pec & [email protected] & 13.78 & 0.77 & fd 111 & pgc 015445 & e & [email protected] & 15.0 & * 0.7 & fd 118 & eso 157-g044 & ib(s)m & [email protected] & 14.87 & & fd 134 & he0442 - 5652 & qso z=0.34 & [email protected] & 16.3 & * 0.2 & fd 142b & usno & qso z=0.29 & [email protected] & 15.6 & * -0.2 & iras fsc 25 + 60 fm 28 & ngc 5291/b & s pec & [email protected] & 14.0 & & int.pair fm 49 & ngc 5264 & ib(s)m & [email protected] & 12.00 & 0.60 & ddo 242 fm 55 & he1337 - 2919 & qso & [email protected] & 16.06 & & candidate fm 58 & ngc 5253 & i m pec & [email protected] & 10.87 & 0.38 & * burst , iue fm 69 & he1334 - 2739 & qso & [email protected] & 16.41 & & candidate fm 70 & ngc 5236=m83 & sab(s)c & [email protected] & 7.54 & 0.66 & * burst ; xray ; iue fm 71 & ic 4293 & sa0 & [email protected] & 13.50 & * 1.5 & fm 104 & gsc07265 - 02231 & em.ln.gal . & [email protected] & 12.7 & * 0.0 & abell 3558 [email protected] ? fm 112 & ic 4248 & s ? & [email protected] & 13.85 & * 0.7 & fm 124 & eso 445-g076 & s & [email protected] & 14.66 & * 0.6 & fm 126 & he1348 - 2751 & qso & [email protected] & 16.62 & & candidate & fm 130 & he1348 - 2751 & qso & [email protected] & 16.62 & & candidate & fm 132 & ic 4327 & sb(s)c ? & [email protected] & 13.89 & 0.61 & fm 141 & ic 4318 & s ? & [email protected] & 14.54 & & fm 142 & eso - lv4450171 & s & [email protected] & 17.03 & & fm 152b & he1336 - 2624 & qso & [email protected] & 16.53 & & candidate fm 163 & eso 444-g075 & i ? & [email protected] & 14.27 & * 0.7 & fm 175 & eso 444-g046 & cd & [email protected] & 13.85 & & abell 3558 [email protected] ? fm 176 & eso 444-g037 & sb(s)dm : & [email protected] & 14.82 & * 0.6 & lsb ; ugca 358 fm 181 & ngc 5135 & sb(l)ab & [email protected] & 12.11 & 0.77 & tol 34 ; * burst+sy2 ; iue fm 185 & he1317 - 2937 & em.ln.gal . & [email protected] & 17.79 & & ft 32 & ngc 6851 a+b & sb ( rs)d+sb(s)m & [email protected] & 14.81 + 16.67 & 0.84 & ft 34 & euvej2009 - 48.8 & qso & [email protected] & 15.3 & * 0.6 & bl lac z=0.071 ; xray ft 108 & ngc 6920 & sa0 & [email protected] & 12.35 & 1.22 & ft 131 & ngc 6845 abcd & group & [email protected] & 14.28 & & interacting ft 132 & pgc 063901 & sab(rs)bc & [email protected] & 14.27 & * 0.2 & ft 146 & eso 234-g004 & sb(s)dm pec & [email protected] & 15.27 & & ft 161 & eso 284-ig045 & sab(rs)bc : & [email protected] & 13.32 & 0.68 & ft 169a & pgc 064404 & sab(s)bc pec & [email protected] & 14.31 & 0.95 & nelg ft 169b & pgc 064399 & sb(s)dm & [email protected] & 14.51 & 1.17 & | we analyze uv observations with faust of four sky fields in the general direction of the fourth galactic quadrant , in which we detect 777 uv sources . this is @xmath050% more than detected originally by bowyer ( 1995 ) . we discuss the source detection process and the identification of uv sources with optical counterparts . for the first time in this project we use ground - based objective - prism information for two of the fields , to select the best - matching optical objects with which to identify the uv sources . using this , and correlations with existing catalogs , we present reliable identifications for @xmath075% of the sources . most of the remaining sources have assigned optical counterparts , but lacking additional information we offer only plausible identification . we discuss the types of objects found , and compare the observed population with predictions of our uv galaxy model . # 1#2#3#4#5#6#7 to#2 ' '' '' |
0810.1347 | ultracold atomic gases offer various opportunities for the study of interacting many - body quantum systems in a well - controlled environment @xcite . for instance , the bose - hubbard model a simplified description for bosons in a periodic potential can be studied with bose - einstein condensates confined in optical lattices @xcite . quantum gases have also gained much attention lately regarding the emergence of an effective space - time @xcite : their low - energy phase fluctuations obey the same covariant field equations as a scalar quantum field in a certain curved space - time . hence , the study of phonons in this laboratory system might shed some light on aspects of cosmic quantum effects , e.g. , hawking radiation @xcite or the freezing and amplification of quantum fluctuations in expanding spacetimes @xcite . although the fluctuations in bose - einstein condensates are usually small , it has recently become possible in experiments to go beyond the classical order parameter and resolve signatures of the fluctuations @xcite . theoretically , the fluctuations in a bose - einstein condensate are usually treated as small perturbations of the mean field . the solution of the coupled field equations is rather demanding and often requires further approximations , especially for time - dependent condensates . the hartree - fock - bogoliubov method , see , e.g. , @xcite , permits in principle the self - consistent propagation of the mean field and the quantum correlations for arbitrary time - dependences of the trap potential or interaction strength . but the scaling of the numerics with system size often limits the actual calculations to a low number of dimensions , certain symmetries , or a short time interval . thermal condensates might be studied using the projected gross - pitaevskii equation @xcite , where the low - energy part of the fluctuations is expanded into an arbitrary basis and , in view of the large thermal occupation , treated classically ; higher excitations as well as the vacuum effect are omitted . on the other hand , studies in the context of expanding spacetimes , e.g. , @xcite , indeed focus on the quantum fluctuations but often assume a homogeneous background or start with the hydrodynamic action , which is only valid on scales longer than the healing length . in this article , i will discuss the evolution of the quantum fluctuations in trapped time - dependent bose - einstein condensates . the linear field operators will be expanded into their eigenmodes thus permitting the diagonalization of the ( initial ) evolution equations . although basis expansions of the field operator are frequently used ( e.g. , in @xcite ) , these references usually consider the harmonic oscillator eigenfunctions , a large number of which must be used in order to describe the excitations properly . by adopting the eigenmodes , a much smaller part of the basis needs to be considered and many more situations will become numerically feasible . ( note , however , that in order to obtain the fluctuation eigenmodes , a relatively large number of oscillator functions must be employed but they need not be propagated . ) this article is organized as follows . section [ secfieldequations ] reviews the field equations and their linearization . the bogoliubov - de gennes equation for the linear quantum fluctuations can be diagonalized by an eigenmode expansion , which will be performed in sec . [ seceigenmode ] . however , as soon as trap frequency or interaction strength are varied , off - diagonal terms appear . this coupling of different modes is negligible for excitations with energies much smaller than the chemical potential even in time - dependent condensates , as will be shown in sec . [ sectf ] , where the order parameter is treated in the thomas - fermi approximation . it is then also possible to establish the analogy between phase fluctuations and a massless scalar field in a certain curved spacetime . if the excitation energies are of the same order as the chemical potential , the coupling of different modes might lead to a population transfer , which will be illustrated in an example in sec . [ sec1d ] . in dimensionless units , the field operator @xmath0 of a trapped ( quasi)-@xmath1-dimensional bose - einstein condensate obeys the non - linear schrdinger field equation @xcite @xmath2 \hat \psi \ , , \label{fieldequation } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath1-dimensional coupling strength @xmath3 . by changing the @xmath4-wave scattering length @xmath5 through feshbach resonances @xcite or by varying the trap frequency @xmath6 , an external time - dependence can be prescribed on the condensate . the gas cloud will adapt to these changes and it will either expand or contract and with it the quasi - particle excitations residing upon it . a part of this background motion can be accounted for by transforming to new coordinates @xmath7 with scale factor @xmath8 . the field operator then reads @xcite @xmath9 the phase @xmath10 is chosen such as to generate an isotropic velocity field @xmath11 which ( at least partially ) describes the expansion / contraction of the condensate . if the scale factor @xmath8 obeys @xmath12 with @xmath13 being the initial value of the coupling strength , a scaled field equation follows @xmath14 \hat \psi \ , , \label{scaledheisenberg } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where trapping and interaction terms have acquired the same time - dependent pre - factor @xmath15 and all other coefficients are time - independent . ( the scale factor @xmath8 on the left hand side might be included into a redefined time @xmath16 , see sec . [ secspacetime ] . ) for large particle numbers @xmath17 , one might formally expand the field operator into inverse powers of @xmath18 @xcite @xmath19 here , @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the atomic operators . they commute with the linear @xmath22 and higher - order quantum excitations @xmath23 and thus yield the exact conservation of particle number . the order parameter @xmath24 in the center of the trap but diminishes towards the edge of the condensate . insertion of the expansion into the scaled heisenberg equation yields the gross - pitaevskii equation for the classical background @xmath25 @xcite @xmath26 \psi_0 \ , . \label{gp } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the linear quantum fluctuations @xmath27 obey the bogoliubov - de gennes equation @xcite @xmath28 \hat \chi + f^2 g_0 \psi_0 ^ 2 \hat\chi^\dagger \ , , \label{bdg } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and the residual terms comprise the equation of motion for @xmath23 @xmath29 \hat \zeta + g_0 \psi_0 ^ 2 \hat \zeta^\dagger \nonumber\\ & \quad + g_0 \left ( 2 \psi_0 \hat \chi^\dagger \hat \chi + \psi_0^ * \hat \chi^2 + \hat \chi^\dagger \hat \chi^2 \right ) + { { \cal o } } ( g_0 \hat \zeta ) \ , . \label{zeta } \end{aligned}\ ] ] these higher orders @xmath23 must remain small in order for the mean - field expansion to be valid , i.e. , for the linearized equation to be applicable . this means that the terms involving products of @xmath27 must remain small because they act as source terms for higher orders @xmath23 . from the gross - pitaevskii equation , i can infer when the evolution of the order parameter @xmath25 is solely described by the scale factor @xmath8 : apart from the trivial case @xmath30 , this occurs only when the spatial derivatives can be neglected with respect to the interaction and trapping terms , @xmath31 , i.e. , in the thomas - fermi approximation . density and phase of the order parameter @xmath32 then assume the form @xmath33 where the heaviside step function @xmath34 is @xmath35 for @xmath36 and @xmath37 elsewhere . in this approximation , the motion of the classical background becomes stationary and the scaled coordinates @xmath38 are co - moving with the condensate . the bogoliubov - de gennes equation can be tackled by introducing self - adjoint operators @xmath39 with @xmath40 being the phase of the order parameter . these operators resemble ( relative ) density and phase fluctuations @xmath41 and @xmath42 up to the prefactor @xmath43 . since this prefactor eventually becomes large near ( and beyond ) the surface of the condensate , the smallness of @xmath44 and @xmath45 can not be ensured . therefore , i will stick to @xmath46 in the following , but still refer to them as density and phase fluctuations . they obey @xmath47 \hat \chi_- \ , = \ , - \mathcal k_+ \hat \chi_+ \ , , \nonumber\\ & \frac{1}{2 } \left [ b^2 \frac{\partial}{\partial t } + \bm v_0 \bm \nabla_x + \frac{1}{2 } ( \bm \nabla_x \bm v_0 ) \right ] \hat \chi_+ \ , = \ , \mathcal k_- \hat \chi_- \ , , \label{eomchipm } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the velocity field @xmath48 results from the residual background phase beyond the thomas - fermi approximation . however , @xmath49 is small for @xmath50 and if @xmath51 does not change too swiftly , because an almost homogeneous phase will develop with only small deviations near the boundary of the condensate . whereas attractive @xmath52 invalidate the thomas - fermi approximation and generally @xmath53 even in the center of the trap . the differential operators on the right - hand sides @xmath54 generally do not commute for inhomogeneous condensates @xmath55 @xmath56 \ , & = \ , f g_0 \left\ { ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\nabla$}}_x^2 \varrho_0 ) + 2 ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\nabla$}}_x\varrho_0 ) { \mbox{\boldmath$\nabla$}}_x \right\ } \ , . \label{commkpm } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to define the initial state unambiguously , i will assume that the condensate is at rest before @xmath57 . then @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 such that the left hand sides of eqs . reduce to partial time derivatives and the initial eigenmode equations for @xmath62 follow @xmath63 because @xmath64 for inhomogeneous condensates , cf . eq . , density and phase fluctuations of each mode must have different space dependences . this leads to the expansions @xcite ( i will adopt the sum convention throughout this article for brevity ; any indices appearing only on one side of the equation are to be summed ) @xmath65 of @xmath62 into different eigenmode bases @xmath66 and @xmath67 , see appendix [ appeigenmodes ] for more details on how to obtain @xmath68 . usually , these two bases are neither orthogonal nor normalized , , but instead can be chosen to be dual to each other @xmath69 note that this condition does not fix the norm of @xmath68 but still permits the multiplication by an arbitrary factor , @xmath70 and @xmath71 . observables must be unaffected by this ambiguity , see app.[secobservables ] . insertion of the eigenmode expansion into the linear field equations yields a set of coupled first - order differential equations @xmath72 with time - dependent coefficients . the symmetric matrices @xmath73 are initially diagonal @xmath74 and @xmath75 . at later times , they acquire off - diagonal elements because of the different - time commutators @xmath76 \neq 0 $ ] and @xmath77 \neq 0 $ ] when @xmath78 . the velocity coupling matrix @xmath79 h_m^- \label{velo } \end{aligned}\ ] ] is not symmetric , but vanishes for homogeneous phases @xmath80 of the order parameter , e.g. , initially or in the thomas - fermi approximation . for repulsive @xmath50 and slow variations of interaction strength @xmath81 and trap frequency @xmath6 , the order parameter phase is homogeneous except for small ripples near the boundary of the condensate such that the matrix @xmath82 is usually negligible . from the evolution equations with the initially diagonal coupling matrices , the introduction of bosonic operators @xmath83 and @xmath84 creating or annihilating an initial quasi - particle is straightforward @xmath85 here , a bar shall denote complex conjugation , e.g. , @xmath86 . the coefficients obey the initial values @xmath87 where the phase has been appropriately chosen and the frequencies @xmath88 . the upper index of the coefficients @xmath89 and @xmath90 labels the mode , while the lower index denotes the components of this particular mode when expanded in a certain basis , e.g. , the initial eigenfunctions @xmath91 . since the coupling matrices become non - diagonal even for slow ( adiabatically ) variation of the trap frequency @xmath6 or coupling strength @xmath81 , the initial bases @xmath91 can not represent the eigenmodes at later times . although @xmath68 might be employed in order to calculate the spatial correlation functions , see appendix [ secobservables ] , the use of these functions might be misleading regarding the correlations between different modes . furthermore , when probing the excitations using , e.g. , the scheme proposed in @xcite , the proper particles defined at the time of measurement will be detected and not the initial ones . the particle definition in time - dependent background is a non - trivial task , see , e.g. , @xcite . nonetheless , it is always possible to expand @xmath62 @xmath92 into bases @xmath93 , which are defined such that the coupling matrices and , cf . , become diagonal at any particular instant @xmath94 @xmath95 of course , the velocity term @xmath96 is then generally non - diagonal and the evolution equations of the different modes will not exactly decouple at this particular instant @xmath94 . but one should bear in mind that measurement occurs usually in an adiabatic region , where the external parameters are only slowly - varying functions of time . then , the background phase is approximately homogeneous and the velocity @xmath97 . hence , quasi - particle creators and annihilators might be introduced analogous to eq . @xmath98 where @xmath99 . in the previous sections , i made no approximations except for the linearization and the assumption of an isotropic trap . the formalism is , in principle , applicable for arbitrary variations of trap frequency @xmath6 and interactions @xmath81 . to this end , it would be necessary to solve the gross - pitaevskii equation and the linear evolution equations simultaneously . the numerical solution is complicated by the fact that the coupling matrices and need to be calculated at each time step . some of the numerical difficulties can be circumvent by adopting the thomas - fermi profile , where density and phase of the background become time - independent ( in the coordinates @xmath38 ) and thus require the calculation of the coupling matrices only once . despite some shortcomings regarding the dynamics of the order parameter , this approximation is usually applicable for repulsive interactions and in the center of the trap , but becomes inaccurate towards the surface of the condensate , where the quantum pressure @xmath100 is relevant . within the thomas - fermi approximation , the coordinate transformation @xmath101 associated with the scaling transformation renders the background density time - independent @xmath102 , while the phase becomes homogeneous @xmath103 and thus @xmath104 . the integrals of the coupling matrices simplify considerably and the evolution equations can be cast into the form @xmath105 i.e. , @xmath106 and @xmath107 can be split into time - independent diagonal parts , cf . @xmath108 and constant , symmetric , non - diagonal coupling matrices @xmath109 with time - dependent prefactors @xmath110 . the external variation of trap frequency @xmath6 and coupling strength @xmath81 is solely encoded in the scale factor @xmath8 and the scalar function @xmath111 . note also that the coefficients and thus also the evolution equations for the fluctuations are independent of the initial coupling strength @xmath13 . the addend @xmath112 appearing in the parentheses of eqs . and can be expressed through the chemical potential @xmath113 , where @xmath114 , cf . the thomas - fermi equation . the mode functions @xmath68 of excitations with low energies , @xmath115 , are localized inside the condensate . hence , changing the bounds of the integrals and from infinity to the thomas - fermi radius @xmath116 will not alter these matrix elements significantly . bearing further in mind that for @xmath117 , it follows @xmath118 and . also because of the restriction to low energies , , and one gets @xmath119 . hence , the evolution equations of different eigenmodes approximately decouple and i obtain second - order equations of motion for phase @xcite @xmath120 \delta\hat \phi_n \ , = \ , 0 \ , , \label{effkfgmode } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and density fluctuations @xmath121 \delta\hat\varrho_n \ , = \ , 0 \ , , \label{effkfgdensitymode } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where i also introduced proper time @xmath16 . equation is the evolution equation of a mode of a minimally - coupled massless scalar field in a friedman - lematre - robertson - walker spacetime @xcite , provided the scale factor @xmath122 of the space - time is identified with @xmath123 , cf . @xcite @xmath124 [ note that the prefactor of the damping term is @xmath125 in eq . , while it is @xmath1 in a @xmath126-dimensional friedman - lematre - robertson - walker spacetime . ] the analogy is not restricted to the evolution equations in mode expansion but applies in the low - energy limit of the field equations as well : within the thomas - fermi approximation , @xmath127 for @xmath117 and @xmath61 , and for low excitations , @xmath128 , the phase fluctuations obey a second - order field equation @xcite @xmath129 \delta\hat\phi \ , = \ , 0 \ , , \label{effkfg } \end{aligned}\ ] ] which is similar to that of a minimally coupled scalar field in a friedman - lematre - robertson - walker spacetime . having established this kinematical analogy , cf . , some of the concepts of general relativity can be applied to time - dependent bose - einstein condensates . sonic analogs of horizons @xcite are of particular interest for the study of non - equilibrium effects , because they give a rough estimate whether and when adiabaticity will be violated and the ( quantum ) fluctuations freeze and get amplified , i.e. , ( quasi-)particle production occurs . an effective particle horizon occurs , if a phonon emitted at a time @xmath130 can only travel a finite ( co - moving ) distance , i.e. , if the integral @xmath131 converges to a finite value @xmath132 for @xmath133 . wavepackets emitted at time @xmath130 at the origin @xmath134 can reach only points within the horizon , @xmath135 , in a finite time . all other points are concealed by the horizon . [ for simplicity , i assumed in eq . an homogeneous sound velocity @xmath136 . ] in order to point out the analogy of phase fluctuations to cosmic quantum fields , i formulated the evolution equations and using proper time @xmath137 . on the other hand , experiments are usually performed in the laboratory and thus the variations of trap frequency @xmath138 and coupling strength @xmath139 are prescribed in laboratory time @xmath140 . since @xmath137 is a complicated function of @xmath140 , it is not quite obvious whether or not the quantum fluctuations will experience non - adiabatic evolution for a given modulation of @xmath6 or @xmath81 . in laboratory time @xmath140 , eq . reads @xmath141 \delta\hat\varrho_n \ , = \ , 0 \ , , \label{effkfgdensitymodet } \end{aligned}\ ] ] which is the evolution equation of a damped harmonic oscillator with time - dependent coefficients @xmath142 and @xmath143 initially , when @xmath59 , the field modes perform free oscillations . upon the gradual increase of the damping term @xmath144 with respect to the oscillation frequencies @xmath145 , the non - adiabatic evolution of the quantum fluctuations slowly sets in , until they finally freeze and get amplified when both terms , @xmath142 and @xmath145 are of the same order @xcite . let me discuss the two extremal ways a time - dependent scale factor @xmath8 can be achieved : firstly , only the trap frequency might be varied , while the interaction strength @xmath146 . with instantaneous frequencies @xmath147 , adiabaticity can be violated for any finite change @xmath148 if @xmath149 becomes sufficiently large . the quantum fluctuations can not adapt to the changing background any more , they freeze and get amplified . and , secondly , for static traps , @xmath150 , where @xmath81 is time - dependent . then , the situations is not so clear because @xmath151 , cf . hence , only the rapid acceleration of the scale factor @xmath152 will lead to notable changes of the excitation frequencies . on the other hand , adiabaticity could be violated by increasing the magnitude of the damping term , @xmath142 . then , however , a continuous acceleration of @xmath149 is required , because otherwise , if @xmath153 was constant , the system would equilibriate . as an example for the absence of particle production inside a static trap , @xmath150 , i will consider an exponential sweep of the coupling coefficient @xmath154 with @xmath155 . in this case , eq . for the scale factor permits an analytic solution @xmath156^{\frac1{2+d } } \exp\left\{\frac{\gamma t}{2+d}\right\ } \ , . \label{bexpsweepg } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the coefficients of eq . become time - independent @xmath157 and the density eigenmodes are just damped harmonic oscillators with solutions @xmath158 where @xmath159 is some residual oscillating function with frequency @xmath145 . hence , the density - density fluctuations diminish @xmath160 , and , consequently , the phase - phase fluctuations increase . but this is just the adiabatic evolution , because @xmath161 and thus @xmath162 , cf . [ secobservables ] . this means that no quasi - particle production occurs for the dynamics in the hydrodynamic regime , i.e. , for low - energy excitations with order parameter treated in the thomas - fermi approximation . these findings can also be inferred from the ( absence of an ) effective particle horizon . for the particular shape of the scale factor @xmath149 follows @xmath163 because @xmath164 . note that the presented solution assumes @xmath165 at all times , especially also for @xmath166 . hence @xmath167 at some time @xmath168 when @xmath169 , cf . eqs . and . on the other hand , @xmath170 and @xmath171 for a condensate at rest , see eq . . since both solutions ( static initial state and exponential sweep ) can not be matched at @xmath172 such that @xmath139 and @xmath149 are both continuous , the switching on of the exponential sweep would excite breathing oscillations . these oscillations , however , generally affect particle production , e.g. , through parametric resonance . the simplest application of the presented formalism consists in a quasi - one - dimensional condensate . in highly anisotropic traps , where the perpendicular trap frequency @xmath173 is much larger than the chemical potential , the motion in the perpendicular directions is restricted to the ground state and might be integrated out . an effectively one - dimensional field equation follows , where the interaction strength @xmath174 can be varied through feshbach resonance or by changing @xmath173 . however , one should bear in mind that the transversal extent of the condensate @xmath175 has to be much larger than the @xmath4-wave scattering length @xmath5 such that the interaction of different atoms can still be described through three - dimensional scattering theory . for simplicity , i will adopt in this section the thomas - fermi approximation for the order parameter but will permit arbitrary energies for the excitations . calculated using 100 harmonic oscillator basis functions . the frequencies equal the chemical potential at the intersection with the black line . the lowest odd mode converges for @xmath176 to the classical thomas - fermi breathing frequency @xmath177 ( green ) , which follows from eq . . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] in figure [ spectrum1d ] , the excitation frequencies @xmath178 of the lowest modes are plotted versus the chemical potential @xmath179 . for @xmath180 , one has the equidistant spectrum of the harmonic oscillator @xmath181 . whereas for high @xmath182 , the frequencies become almost independent of the chemical potential . in particular , the frequency @xmath183 of the lowest excitation with odd parity tends for @xmath176 towards the thomas - fermi breathing frequency @xmath184 obtained from eq . . the discrepancy between these two frequencies @xmath183 and @xmath185 for finite values of the chemical potential @xmath179 hints at shortcomings of the thomas - fermi approximation . in particular , eq . does not describe the breathing motion of the background properly and care must be taken when employing eqs . for the order parameter . nonetheless , eq . still predicts the correct order of magnitude of the characteristic response time of the background , @xmath186 , to variations of trap frequency or interaction strength . hence , it is still possible to discuss several cases , where the difference of @xmath187 and @xmath188 is either small or does not matter : firstly , if the shape of the condensate varies only slowly , i.e. , if @xmath189 and the condensate can adapt to changes of @xmath138 and/or @xmath139 immediately . secondly , if no breathing oscillations are excited , e.g. , because the condensate expands or contracts , see also eqs . and . and , thirdly , for very large chemical potentials , @xmath176 , the thomas - fermi approximation becomes exact . the quantum fluctuations are in the hydrodynamic regime and their effective evolution equations decouple . in order to address cases where breathing of the background occurs , it would be necessary to abandon the thomas - fermi approximation and to solve the gross - pitaevskii equation , which could , e.g. , be done by expanding the order parameter @xmath25 into oscillator functions @xcite . a stationary condensate , i.e. , @xmath58 , can be accomplished through simultaneous variation of trap frequency @xmath138 and interaction strength @xmath139 , cf . @xmath190 though , one should be aware that this only holds within the thomas - fermi approximation : the instantaneous chemical potential must at all times be much larger than the trap frequency @xmath191 if both were of the same order , the kinetic term , @xmath192 , in the gross - pitaevskii equation becomes important ; no stationary background could be realized even for simultaneous variation of @xmath138 and @xmath139 . for an exponential sweep @xmath193 the effective second - order equation for the phase fluctuations in the hydrodynamic limit @xmath194 \delta\hat\phi \ , = \ , 0 \ , . \label{effkfgexp } \end{aligned}\ ] ] is that of a massless scalar field in a de sitter spacetime with exponentially growing scale factor @xmath195 , cf . eq . which is believed to describe the universe during the epoch of cosmic inflation @xcite for the time - dependence , the integral is finite and an effective sonic horizon occurs ; the quantum fluctuations freeze and get amplified . instead of solving eq . for @xmath196 , i will consider the evolution equation of the density fluctuations @xmath197 @xmath198 \hat x_n^+ \ , = \ , 0 \ , , \label{densitysweepeom } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath199 . obviously , all modes undergo the same evolution just at different times . eq . can be solved analytically in terms of bessel functions @xcite @xmath200 where @xmath201 . the hankel functions @xmath202 have the proper asymptotics for early times @xmath203 such that the operators @xmath84 annihilate the initial vacuum state . the phase fluctuations read @xmath204 from these expressions and , i can infer the correlations of each mode . at late times follows @xmath205 comparison with the adiabatic values @xmath206 , cf.eq . , yields the quasi - particle number at late times @xmath207 the occupation number of all modes grows exponentially though at different times @xmath208 , where the shift @xmath209 is determined by the excitation frequencies @xmath210 . however , one should bear in mind that eq . is only valid for a limited time before leaving the hydrodynamic regime . in order to go beyond the effective space - time description and thus the analytical findings - , i will now consider the full evolution equations . the sweep rate @xmath211 shall be chosen such that all modes evolve adiabatically at first , i.e. , @xmath212 for all @xmath213 . when subsequently reducing trap potential and coupling strength , the excitation frequencies @xmath214 decrease and non - adiabatic evolution sets in at different times for each mode . the fluctuations freeze and get amplified . figure [ sweep50 ] shows the instantaneous particle numbers of the lowest three modes for initial chemical potential @xmath215 and @xmath211 . the lowest excitation , @xmath216 , which becomes non - adiabatic first , acquires the largest particle number . the next two modes , @xmath217 , experience less squeezing , though , remarkably , @xmath218 an unexpected result , which can be explained by the coupling of different modes : the second even mode , @xmath219 , gets populated from the principle excitation , @xmath216 , whereas the coupling matrix elements between @xmath216 and @xmath220 are zero because of different parity . and the sweep rate @xmath211 . at @xmath221 , the chemical potential equals the trap frequency . for the calculation of the eigenmodes @xmath68 and the coupling matrices , i used the harmonic oscillator functions @xmath222 up to @xmath223 , cf . appendix [ seceigenmode ] . the lowest 20 modes @xmath224 were then propagated . the numerical accuracy was set to @xmath225 . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] the main objective of this article was the investigation of quantum fluctuations in time - dependent harmonically - trapped bose - einstein condensates with repulsive interactions . to this end , the linear fluctuations were expanded into their initial eigenmodes and the field equations were diagonalized . this diagonal form , however , persists only as long as the condensate is at rest ; as soon as trap frequency or interaction strength are varied , the coupling of different modes sets in . ( only part of which can be accounted for by transforming to the instantaneous eigenmodes , though the definition of instantaneous eigenmodes is a non - trivial task . ) two regimes were identified : firstly , for energies much smaller than the chemical potential , the coupling of different modes is negligible and an effective space - time metric might be introduced for the phase fluctuations . this , however , necessitates a redefinition of the time coordinate such that the required change of trap frequency and/or interaction strength for a certain dynamics of this effective space - time is not obvious . it turned out that the sole variation of the interaction coefficient @xmath81 in a smooth monotonic way is hardly sufficient to render the evolution of the quantum fluctuations non - adiabatic , since the expansion / contraction of the background might compensate for changes of @xmath139 such that the sound velocity ( in comoving coordinates ) remains constant . breathing oscillations of the background , excited , e.g. , by the sudden change of the interaction coefficient @xmath139 , might still yield a notable amount of quasi - particles . and secondly , if the excitation energy is of the same order as the chemical potential , different quasi - particle modes couple . the amplification and freezing of the fluctuations and also the coupling of different modes was illustrated in an example , where the trap frequency and interaction strength were exponentially ramped down such that the shape of the condensate remains constant . for the considered parameters , a quasi - particle number of 0.5 was obtained in the lowest mode , though higher occupation numbers could be achieved by faster sweep rates or starting with a higher chemical potential . the inversion of the occupation number in the next two modes could be attributed to the inter - mode coupling : although the third excitation , @xmath219 , experiences a much briefer period of non - adiabatic evolution than the second mode , @xmath220 , only the former couples to the lowest mode , @xmath216 , and gets populated from it . i would like to thank craig m. savage and uwe r. fischer for helpful discussions . this research was supported by the australian research council . the aim of this appendix is the derivation of the initial eigenfunctions @xmath68 of density and phase fluctuations . to this end , let me expand the field operator into any orthonormal basis @xmath226 of the underlying hilbert space @xmath227 with some operator - valued coefficients @xmath228 @xmath229 lower - case greek indices ( @xmath230 , @xmath231 , ... ) shall denote the components in this arbitrary basis , while lower - case latin indices ( @xmath232 , @xmath213 , ... ) label the initial eigenmodes . if the condensate is initially at rest , the scale factor and the phase of the order parameter is homogenous @xmath233 such that @xmath61 and thus @xmath234 , cf .. the evolution equations simplify considerably and can be expanded into the basis @xmath235 . it follows , cf . @xmath236 where @xmath237 are defined in eq . . the matrices @xmath238 and @xmath239 are real and symmetric but do not commute due to @xmath240 \neq 0 $ ] , cf . . from eqs . , i obtain second - order evolution equations for phase and density fluctuations @xmath241 which can be diagonalized by a transformation to the eigenvectors . because the matrix @xmath242 is not symmetric , phase and density fluctuations obey different eigenvalue equations @xmath243 where @xmath213 denotes the vectors and @xmath230 merely counts the components in the particular basis representation . for brevity , i will only discuss the eigenvectors of @xmath244 in the following , though the same applies for those of @xmath245 as well . the eigenvectors are generally not orthogonal @xmath246 but @xmath247 usually still forms a basis . ( note , however , that the eigenvectors of a non - symmetric matrix not always span the entire vector space . but if the @xmath248 were no basis , the evolution equation could not be diagonalized . this would mean that there existed some fluctuations , which have constant losses to some eigenmodes rather unphysical in view of the stationary initial state considered here . therefore , i will not discuss this case any further . ) with the @xmath249 forming a basis of @xmath227 , there must exist a dual basis @xmath250 in the space of linear functionals ( the dual ) on @xmath227 , which obeys @xmath251 [ roughly speaking , the elements of @xmath227 become column vectors in the basis expansion , whereas row vectors correspond to the functionals on @xmath227 , i.e. , the elements of the dual . since the eigenvectors @xmath248 form a basis , the matrix with the @xmath248 as columns must be invertible . the rows of the ( left ) inverse matrix then comprise the elements of the dual basis @xmath250 in the particular basis expansion . ] after the multiplication of the first of eqs . with @xmath252 from the left and summation over @xmath230 follows @xmath253 which , because @xmath254 is a basis , implies that the @xmath255 are the left eigenvectors of @xmath256 with the same eigenvalues @xmath257 @xmath258 transposition yields @xmath259 i.e. , the eigenvalue equation of @xmath245 , cf . . hence , @xmath260 and @xmath261 and @xmath262 ( i.e. , density and phase fluctuations ) must have the same spectrum @xmath263 . for simplicity , @xmath264 , which can be achieved by renormalization of @xmath265 , in the following . note that the spectrum of a real non - symmetric matrix might contain pairs of complex conjugate eigenvalues @xmath257 , @xmath266 , which can be seen when taking the complex conjugate of . complex eigenvalues @xmath267 are associated with exponentially growing solutions , i.e. , unstable modes . since i am interested in the quantization of the stationary initial state , i will not discuss this case but instead assume @xmath268 @xmath269 . ( as can be easily verified , the components of the eigenvectors @xmath270 and @xmath271 must be real - valued as well . ) nonetheless , complex eigenvalues might still occur in dynamical situations , e.g. , during the signature change event proposed in @xcite or during ( quantum ) phase transitions @xcite ( see also ref . @xcite for an illustrative example ) . the initial evolution equations can be diagonalized by multiplication with the left eigenvectors @xmath272 which leads to the definition of the density and phase fluctuation eigenmodes @xmath224 through @xmath273 where the spatial mode functions @xmath274 follow from comparison of eqs . with and the duality of the @xmath270 and @xmath271 implies eq . for the @xmath68 . in view of , the initial evolution equations can be transformed to the new basis , cf.eq . @xmath275 where the transformed matrices @xmath276 have become diagonal . note that the transformation is not orthogonal because the matrices comprising of the eigenvectors @xmath270 and @xmath271 are not orthogonal . hence , the commutators are _ not _ preserved , in particular @xmath277 where the latter can be inferred from eq . @xmath278 since @xmath106 and @xmath107 also commute with their product @xmath279 , which is diagonal , they must be diagonal , too . the duality condition does not fix the norm of the eigenvectors but still permits the multiplication with an arbitrary factor @xmath280 @xmath281 this renormalization then leads to a stretching / shrinking of the operator - valued coefficients , cf . @xmath282 since this is merely a basis transformation , the time - evolution of the quantum fluctuations @xmath224 must be unaffected . to see this , recall the definitions and of the coupling matrices : they are the matrix elements of the operators @xmath237 and of @xmath283 with respect to the basis functions @xmath68 and thus acquire additional factors as well . as expected , all of these factors cancel such that the time - evolution remains unchanged . in particular , the eigenfrequencies are invariant @xmath284 . furthermore the observables should not depend on the particular normalization of the basis functions . the relative density - density correlations at time @xmath140 read @xmath285 where i used the instantaneous eigenmode basis @xmath286 , see eq .. obviously , the factors @xmath280 and @xmath287 contributed by @xmath286 and @xmath288 cancel each other and the spatial correlations are independent of the normalization @xmath280 . similarly , the expression for the spatial phase - phase correlations @xmath289 yields the same result regardless of the employed basis . hence , the factors @xmath280 can be chosen at will . there exist , however , several convenient choices for @xmath280 : firstly , the density modes might be normalized to unity , @xmath290 . this is advantageous if left and right eigenvectors are the same , i.e. , if @xmath244 is symmetric . the drawback is that if @xmath244 is not symmetric and therefore @xmath291 , only one of the mode functions , @xmath292 , can be normalized to unity , whereas the norm of the @xmath293 follows from eq . . and , secondly , these factors @xmath280 can be fixed by demanding @xmath294 . in this case , the prefactors of initially obey @xmath295 and @xmath296 and both quadratures @xmath297 . however , one should note that neither of the eigenfunctions @xmath68 is generally normalized to unity , @xmath298 . of course , the coefficients @xmath299 and @xmath300 do depend on the particular choice of the basis functions @xmath301 and thus also on the factors @xmath280 . for instance , the adiabatic density - density and phase - phase correlations of a particular mode read @xmath302 the dependence on the factor @xmath280 becomes important regarding the low excitations in the thomas - fermi approximation , cf . [ sectf ] : the modes decouple and it is not necessary to introduce a new spatial basis @xmath68 at the time of measurement . one has instead @xmath303 and @xmath304 such that @xmath305 while @xmath306 , i.e. , the phase and density fluctuations apparently increase or decrease even for adiabatic evolution . in view of this @xmath280 ambiguity , the ( absolute ) density - density or phase - phase correlations provide no adequate measure for the squeezing ( i.e. , non - adiabaticity ) of a single mode . the fourier transforms of eqs . and on the other hand are independent of @xmath280 but do not represent the excitation eigenmodes . as will be shown in the following , the ( instantaneous ) quasi - particle number measures the relative deviation of density and phase fluctuations from their adiabatic values . in view of the different expansions and of density and phase fluctuations into their initial and adiabatic eigenfunctions , the corresponding creation and annihilation operators @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath307 , @xmath308 , respectively , can be transformed by virtue of a bogoliubov transformation . for the annihilators @xmath308 follows in particular @xmath309 with the bogoliubov coefficients @xmath310 and @xmath311 . the first line follows from inversion of eq . and the second line can be inferred after transforming to the new basis @xmath301 . since @xmath312 for non - adiabatic evolution , the quasi - particle number operator @xmath313 will have a non - zero expectation value as well @xmath314 \right\rangle \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the commutator @xmath315 = -i$ ] . noting that the prefactors @xmath316 and @xmath317 are just the adiabatic density - density and phase - phase correlations , see eq . , the particle number can be rewritten @xmath318 i.e. , the instantaneous particle number gives just the relative deviation of the density and phase correlations from their adiabatic values . note that expression does not contain the correlations between different modes . to this end , it would be necessary to evaluate @xmath319 , which is fourth order in the @xmath308 . this observable can be reduced to expectation values quadratic in in the @xmath308 by virtue of wick s theorem , see , e.g. , @xcite . another interesting aspect regards the scaling of the correlation functions and with the interaction strength : within the thomas - fermi approximation , see sec . [ sectf ] , the evolution equations are independent of @xmath13 . all properties of the linear excitations are determined by the chemical potential @xmath179 and the variations @xmath320 and @xmath321 , in particular the expectation values @xmath322 . only the normalization factor @xmath323[\mu_0 - v(\bm x')]}$ ] in eqs . and depends on @xmath13 . hence , the relative density - density and phase - phase correlations in the thomas - fermi approximation are both proportional to @xmath13 for fixed @xmath179 . a. fisher , p. b. weichman , g. grinstein , and d. s. fisher , phys . b * 40 * , 546 ( 1989 ) ; d. jaksch _ et al . _ , phys . lett . * 81 * , 3108 ( 1998 ) ; d. jaksch and p. zoller , ann . ( n.y . ) * 315 * , 52 ( 2005 ) ; r. schtzhold , m. uhlmann , y. xu , and u. r. fischer , phys . rev . lett . * 97 * , 200601 ( 2006 ) ; c. kollath , a. m. luchli , and e. altman , phys . rev . * 98 * , 180601 ( 2007 ) . c. barcel , s. liberati , and m. visser , phys . a * 68 * , 053613 ( 2003 ) ; c. barcel , s. liberati , and m. visser , int . j. mod . d * 12 * , 1641 ( 2003 ) ; c. barcel , s. liberati , and m. visser , class . quant . grav . * 18 * , 1137 ( 2001 ) ; _ ibid . _ * 18 * , 3595 ( 2001 ) . dimensionless units can be introduced through the initial trap frequency @xmath324 and the atom mass @xmath232 . all energies are then measured in units of @xmath324 , the dimensionless time is defined through @xmath325 , and the characteristic length @xmath326 , where @xmath327 . e. tiesinga , b. j. verhaar , and h. t. c. stoof phys . rev . a * 47 * , 4114 ( 1993 ) ; s. inouye _ et al . _ , nature * 392 * , 151 ( 1998 ) ; ph . courteille , r. s. freeland , and d. j. heinzen , phys . lett . * 81 * , 69 ( 1998 ) . as similar expansion of the linear fluctuations is also considered in @xcite . there , the authors expand the linear field operator @xmath27 of a static / stationary condensate into eigenmodes and not the phase and density fluctuations @xmath62 . this leads to complex mode functions @xmath328 and @xmath329 , while @xmath68 are real . the eigenfunctions of density and phase fluctuations @xmath330 and @xmath45 are defined slightly differently than those of @xmath62 @xmath331 noting that @xmath332 the center of the trap , the eigenfunctions @xmath292 and @xmath333 ( and similarly @xmath293 and @xmath334 ) must be approximately proportional for low excitations . hence , the @xmath335 for @xmath336 indeed represent the proper density and phase eigenmodes @xmath337 and @xmath338 up to a constant prefactor @xmath339 . l. e. sadler _ et al . _ , nature * 443 * , 312 ( 2006 ) ; h. saito and m. ueda , phys . a * 72 * , 023610 ( 2005 ) ; h. saito , y. kawaguchi , and m. ueda , phys . lett . * 96 * , 065302 ( 2006 ) ; a. lamacraft phys . lett . * 98 * , 160404 ( 2007 ) ; m. uhlmann , r. schtzhold , and u. r. fischer , phys . * 99 * , 120407 ( 2007 ) . | quantum fluctuations in time - dependent , harmonically - trapped bose - einstein condensates are studied within bogoliubov theory . an eigenmode expansion of the linear field operators permits the diagonalization of the bogoliubov - de gennes equation for a stationary condensate . when trap frequency or interaction strength are varied , the inhomogeneity of the background gives rise to off - diagonal coupling terms between different modes . this coupling is negligible for low energies , i.e. , in the hydrodynamic regime , and an effective space - time metric can be introduced . the influence of the inter - mode coupling will be demonstrated in an example , where i calculate the quasi - particle number for a quasi - one - dimensional bose - einstein condensate subject to an exponential sweep of interaction strength and trap frequency . |
1306.5823 | the optical nanofibre ( onf ) , or optical microfibre depending on the waist diameter , is an ultrathin light guide usually fabricated from commercially - available fibre using a heat - and - pull technique @xcite . the enhancement of the spontaneous emission from atoms surrounding an onf into its guided modes is well known @xcite , making it an ideal high - sensitivity tool for channeling atomic fluorescence to a detector . in recent years , onfs have been used as probes for cold atoms @xcite and hot atomic vapors @xcite . a number of proposals for trapping neutral atoms around onfs have been made @xcite and two - colour trapping of caesium has been achieved @xcite . some of the advantages of onfs are that , in addition to trapping applications , the nanofibre provides an interface that can be exploited for quantum communication using ensembles of laser - cooled atoms or for studying atom - surface interactions @xcite . a review on recent advances in this field is contained in morrissey _ _ @xcite . in the work reported here , atom cloud density enhancement techniques for a sample of laser - cooled @xmath0rb atoms are studied in order to increase the fluorescence and/or absorption signals obtainable with onfs . the density of atoms in a standard magneto - optical trap ( mot ) is limited to @xmath6 atoms/@xmath7 for two reasons . first , a transfer of kinetic energy occurs when a ground state atom collides with an excited state atom leading to a trap loss rate that is proportional to the number of atoms trapped . the second limitation is due to laser - cooled atoms in the mot reabsorbing scattered photons , a phenomenon known as radiation pressure . the outward radiation pressure of the fluorescent light balances the confining forces of the trapping laser beams at a particular density and , at this point , if the number of atoms is increased , the atom cloud simply grows in size rather than in density . for the onf , this is a major consideration ; if one wishes to do absorption experiments using optical nanofibres , as many atoms as possible are required to fill the evanescent region around the fibre in order to optimize the signal quality . in 1993 ketterle _ et al . _ @xcite demonstrated a mot configuration , known as the dark mot ( dmot ) , which confined sodium atoms in the lower ( or dark ) hyperfine ground level , where they are unperturbed by the cooling beams and , thus , the dmot is free from the density limitations of a standard bright mot ( bmot ) . by reducing the intensity of the repump beams used in the standard bmot configuration almost all the atoms are transferred from the bright hyperfine level , @xmath4 , to the dark hyperfine level , @xmath8 , of the @xmath9 ground state of na . although a small excitation rate is optimal for confining large numbers of atoms at a high density , the maximum possible excitation rate is required to efficiently capture atoms from a vapor and load them into a mot . by using bright and dark regions in the repump beam simultaneously , both of these requirements can be fulfilled ; a doughnut - shaped ( or hollow ) repump beam can be used for this as it consists of a bright outer ring of light and a dark inner circle . an atom which encounters the dark region ( i.e. the region with negligible repump intensity ) will only spend a very short time in the cooling cycle before being shelved into the dark hyperfine level . alternative methods of creating a dmot have been demonstrated . for example , muniz _ et al . _ @xcite tuned the frequency of the repump laser to create a dmot from an intense flux of slowed na atoms . in the last decade , a more complete understanding of the dmot has been formed @xcite and recently extended to studies with ultracold atoms and molecules @xcite . one way of working with a bmot and dmot is by generating them sequentially in time using triggered , mechanical shutters and aoms . however , an alternative approach is to simultaneously generate the bmot and dmot in different spatial regions of the trap , as achieved using the aforementioned doughnut - shaped repump beam . the spatially - generated dmot has advantages since atoms can be continuously loaded into the dark region from the outer bright mot where the usual processes occur . in fact , although the inner , dark region is not really a magneto - optical trap , the outer bright region still captures background atoms and feeds the dark section . in other words , experimental parameters for the atoms at the trap center can be monitored and adjusted , while simultaneously maintaining the high loading rate achievable with the bright mot . this is possible because the trapped atom cloud is localized near the minimum of the magnetic field , whereas the capture of atoms occurs throughout the whole intersection volume of the cooling laser beams . note that only the spatial dmot is considered in the work that follows . this arrangement is very appealing for optical nanofibre - based work . for example , the possibility of continuous absorption measurements via an onf probe becomes available . @xcite report that , even with moderate beam powers of the order of 6 mw , the dark mot can capture a large number of atoms and achieve optical densities as high as 9 . thus , by using low cooling laser intensities ( for confining large numbers of atoms at a high density ) in a dmot scheme , high signal - to - noise ratios for the fluorescence coupling should be achievable for minimal beam powers . this leads to the potential demonstration of non - linear optical effects in the atom cloud without requiring high laser powers . earlier , townsend _ et al . _ @xcite demonstrated atom densities of nearly @xmath10 @xmath11 in a dark mot for caesium . prior to this , no report of similar density enhancements in mots for elements other than sodium had been reported . excited state hyperfine splitting is large for heavier alkali - metal atoms which makes it difficult to get the atoms in the dark state , while still maintaining enough atoms in the trap , by transient reduction of repump beam intensity as done in case of na atoms . hence , townsend _ et al . _ used a technique of partially blocking the repump beam to create a low repump intensity region at the centre surrounded by a higher repump intensity , and directed a depump beam to the dark region to increase the rate of decay to the dark ground state . we follow the same scheme for creating a dmot for @xmath0rb . the depump beam is tuned to the @xmath12 transition of @xmath0rb . rb atoms ( see ) undergo many cooling cycles ( @xmath13 ) before falling to the dark ground state ( @xmath4 ) due to spontaneous raman processes if no depump beam is used . the use of depump beam accelerates ground state pumping of atoms . energy levels used in the dark mot for @xmath0rb . ` c ' represents the cooling laser , ` r ' represents the repump beam , and ` d ' represents the depump beam.,width=377 ] in the work reported here , a retro - reflected three beam mot configuration is used for laser - cooling and trapping @xmath0rb atoms . the doughnut - shaped repump beam is generated in the following manner . first , the laser beam is expanded in a telescope setup to a diameter of 25 mm ( see ) . a separate , unit magnification telescope is used to place a shadow in the beam and project it on to the atom cloud . a glass slide with an opaque circle as the shadow is placed near the focal point of the telescope and aligned to create the doughnut - shaped repump beam at the mot . the opaque circle has a transmission of @xmath14 as determined experimentally . if the circle were placed in the beam without being incorporated into a telescope system , fresnel diffraction effects would occur at the trap centre . this would diminish the efficiency of the dark mot in shelving atoms into @xmath4 . to facilitate switching from a dmot to a bmot , the slide with the shadow in the optical path of the repump beam can be easily removed from its holder , turning the doughnut beam into a standard gaussian repump beam . rather than directing the doughnut repump beam along a path which copropagates with a cooling beam , a separate path is used . the reason for this is due to the retro - reflecting mirrors in the cooling beam path for the mot design . if the repump beam were aligned such that it passed centrally through the cloud , but reflected back off a retro - reflecting mirror , the back - reflected dark spot may not align perfectly with the forward propagating one and could destroy the dmot . left : experimental setup used to create the doughnut repump beam using a unity magnifier with an opaque circle positioned near the centre of two lenses . this imaging setup reduces fresnel diffraction in the beam at the position of the mot . right : repump beam profile obtained using a ccd camera.,width=529 ] to quantify the ` darkness ' of the trap , ketterle _ et al . _ @xcite introduced a quality parameter , @xmath5 , that denotes the fraction of atoms in the bright , ground hyperfine level compared to the total number of atoms in the ground state , where @xmath15 for @xmath0rb , @xmath16 is the number of atoms in the bright @xmath3 level and @xmath17 is the number of atoms in the dark @xmath4 level of the ground state . the quality of the dmot is determined from @xmath5 , where @xmath18 represents a 100% bright mot and @xmath19 is a 100% dark mot . for the measurements of @xmath5 reported here an onf with diameter @xmath11 @xmath2 m is passed through the centre of the atom cloud . fluorescence emitted from the laser - cooled atoms couples into the guided modes of the onf and is subsequently measured at one fibre pigtail end using a single photon counting module ( spcm ) . the recorded count rate is proportional to the number of atoms in whichever hyperfine ground level is probed , thereby enabling a measurement of @xmath5 to be performed . alternatively , @xmath5 can be estimated from the magnitude of observed absorption dips if free - space spectroscopy is performed . the experimental setup is shown in . initially , a free - space probe beam is passed through the atom cloud for absorption spectroscopy measurements , as illustrated in ( a ) . the free - space probe beam is aligned with the centre of the cloud so that it passes through the dmot . the probe beam is obtained from a 780 nm extended cavity diode laser ( ecdl ) operating in scanning mode and frequency tuned via saturated absorption spectroscopy . the beam , after passing through the cloud , is directed on an avalanche photodiode ( apd ) ( hamamatsu model : c5460 - 01 ) , connected to a computer . schematic of the experimental setup : ( a ) free - space spectroscopy on the dmot incorporating a frequency - scanned probe beam , apd : avalanche photodiode , uhv : ultrahigh vacuum . ( b ) probing the dmot with an optical fibre , onf : optical nanofibre , spcm : single photon counting module.,width=566 ] ( upper plot ) shows the absorption spectrum obtained using the free - space method to obtain a bright mot . the lower plot in shows the spectrum for the dmot ( with the doughnut repump beam and the depump beam ) . it is evident that the magnitude of the @xmath20 dips has doubled for the dmot compared to the bmot , while the magnitude of the @xmath21 dips has approximately halved , indicating a clear enhancement of the atom population in the @xmath4 hyperfine level for the dmot compared to the bmot . upper trace : free - space absorption spectroscopy on a bmot . lower trace : free - space absorption spectroscopy on an optimized dmot . the dmot here is created using a doughnut repump mot beam and a depump beam . there is a higher population in the @xmath4 lower hyperfine level for the dmot compared to the bmot.,width=566 ] by using beam stops to block and unblock the depump beam and/or the probe beam , different populations of atoms can be studied using an onf . to fabricate the onf , a heat - and - pull - technique is used @xcite . commercially - available sm780 ( fibercore ) optical fibre is heated using an oxygen - butane flame and pulled using a pair of motorised translational stages . for these experiments , the final transmission of the onf was @xmath160% from end to end and the waist diameter was @xmath1 1 @xmath2 m . after fabrication , the onf is fixed in a vertical orientation to an aluminium u - shaped mount with uv - curable glue . the nanofibre is aligned centrally in the mot and the fibre pigtails are coupled into and out of the uhv chamber using a teflon feedthrough @xcite . a single photon counting module ( spcm ) is connected to one pigtail of the onf so that fluorescence from the atom cloud can be recorded . the setup is shown in ( b ) . in the previous section , a probe beam generated by an ecdl was used ( ( a ) ) . now , the probe beam is derived from the repump beam of the mot and aligned , in free - space , with the center of the atom cloud ( ( b ) ) . the frequency of this probe beam is fixed with an aom and tuned to the repump transition of @xmath0rb . shows two loading curves : the upper ( red ) plot is for a bmot and the lower ( black ) plot is for a dmot . the dmot in this instance has no depump shining on it and , thus , it is not extremely dark ( i.e. @xmath5 is not very low ) . this explains why the resulting coupling from the dmot ( @xmath1750 counts/5 ms ) is not negligible when compared to the coupling from the bmot ( @xmath12000 counts/5 ms ) . the steady state count rate for both curves is proportional to the number of atoms in @xmath3 although the distribution of atoms between both hyperfine ground states , @xmath4 and @xmath3 , is different in each case . however , these two sets of data are not sufficient to determine the population of each ground state or the darkness of the dmot . to determine the value of @xmath5 with the spcm and onf two sets of data must be recorded and analyzed , as described in the following section . loading curves for a bmot ( red , upper ) and a dmot ( black , lower ) . this plot shows the residual fluorescence coupling that can be obtained using a dmot of modest @xmath5 value . in this case , the dmot has been created with the doughnut repump beam only ( no depump light has been used).,width=453 ] \(a ) shows the fluorescence count rate through the fibre for a dmot created with a doughnut repump beam ( and no depumping beam ) . the black , vertical line at @xmath17.5 s indicates the point at which the magnetic field is switched on to allow the dmot to load . the fluorescence level increases from 125 counts/2 ms ( indicated by the red line that shows the background light coupling into the fibre ) to @xmath1275 counts/2 ms due to the residual bright atoms in the dmot . in other words , the @xmath3 atoms contribute @xmath1150 counts/2 ms to the signal . this is the numerator of @xmath5 as given in . in ( b ) , the fluorescence signal is recorded for a dmot created with the doughnut repump beam and the depumper . this yields a baseline count rate of 175 counts/2 ms ( blue line , ( b ) ) and the numerator of @xmath5 in this case is 50 counts/2 ms . furthermore , in this plot , the probe beam is added to the optical configuration . this probe beam is tuned to the repumping transition of @xmath0rb ( @xmath22 ) and aligned with the dark region of the cloud . thus , it `` fills in '' the dark central region of the doughnut - shaped repump beam , thereby recreating a standard bmot configuration . the probe switches on for 100 ms at 1 hz repetition rate , while the depump switches off at the same time and with the same rate . the observed spikes in the fluorescence count rate ( @xmath11150 counts/2 ms ) coupled into the onf are from atoms in both the ground state hyperfine levels , @xmath4 and 3 . this is the denominator of @xmath5 . by taking the ratio of the baseline ( 125 counts/2 ms ) in ( a ) to the peak counts in ( b ) , and correcting for the background level , the value for @xmath5 is determined as @xmath10.10 in the dmot without the depumper . however , with the inclusion of the depumper the dark mot is improved and a value of @xmath23 is obtained . florescence count rate coupled into the onf for : ( a ) a dmot created with a doughnut repump beam and no depump light , ( b ) a dmot created with a doughnut repump beam and the depump beam . the depumper is switched off for 100 ms at 1 hz repetition rate . additionally , there is also a probe beam that switches on when the depump is off . for both plots , the doughnut - shaped repump beam is on at all times . by taking the ratio of the baseline counts in plot a to the peaks in plot b the value for @xmath5 is determined to be @xmath10.10 . however , by including the depumper , @xmath5 is determined using the baseline of plot b(blue line ) to be @xmath24.,width=566 ] background - corrected loading curves for the bmot and dmot are shown in ( a ) with theoretical fits to determine the loading rates : @xmath25 counts / s , @xmath26 counts / s . in this case , @xmath27 for the dmot . ( b ) as the dmot becomes darker ( i.e. as @xmath5 reduces ) the loading rate @xmath28 decreases.,width=566 ] loading curves were analyzed for the dmot and bmot via the onf with a methodology similar to that described in @xcite . ( a ) shows a loading curve for a bmot ( red plot ) and a loading curve for a dmot ( black plot ) . both curves have been background - corrected . the bmot curve yields a loading rate , @xmath29 , of @xmath30 counts / s by fitting it with @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the collisional loss rate in the mot . the plot in the lower panel represents the loading for a dmot which has been created with a doughnut repump beam and a depumper . the spikes in fluorescence occurring at 1 hz ( for 100 ms duration ) are due to simultaneously switching off the depumper and switching on the probe beam for detection purposes . as discussed previously , these conditions ( depumper off and probe on ) recreate the conditions for a bmot and provide a measurement of the denominator of @xmath5 . these peaks in the dmot plot reach values of @xmath33 counts / s , matching the steady state count rate of the bmot loading curve . the baseline curve of the dmot plot represents the loading of the fraction of @xmath3 atoms present in the dmot . the dmot does not contribute to the loading process so the loading rate can not be larger in the dmot than in the bmot . in ( a ) one can see that the loading rate of the dmot , @xmath28 , is @xmath34 . for this dmot , @xmath5=0.22 . the red ( black ) data points show the trend in loading rates for the bmot ( dmot ) while varying the cooling laser intensity per mot beam , @xmath35 . as the doughnut repump beam and the depumper do not help the loading process , the loading rates for the dmot are lower than those of the bmot . linear fits have been applied to each series as a guide to the eye . the error bars are calculated from the loading curve fits.,width=453 ] the change in @xmath28 can be examined as a function of @xmath5 . in ( b ) , @xmath5 is varied ( using different depumper intensities ) over the range 0.08 to 0.50 . the loading rate of the dmot decreases for lower @xmath5 values as expected @xcite . loading rates for the bmot and dmot can be explored by varying the cooling laser intensity ( per mot beam , @xmath35 ) and recording the same data as shown in ( a ) for each @xmath35 . this study is shown in . the dmot loading rate , @xmath28 , is consistently lower than the bmot loading rate @xmath29 . this work examined the implementation of a dmot in order to circumvent the density - limitations of a bmot . for `` atom - nanofibre '' experiments , this is a major consideration . if one wishes to do absorption experiments using an onf , for example , signal quality will be improved dramatically by forcing as many atoms as possible to fill the evanescent region around the fibre . although there will still be collisional losses in a dmot ( unless @xmath19 ) , the reabsorption of scattered photons is no longer a major problem . by packing more atoms closer to the fibre surface , absorption of the light passing through the nanofiber can be enhanced as number of atoms in the evanescent field region is increased . a density improvement is critical to achieve high optical densities , thereby allowing demonstrations of nonlinear effects such as electromagnetically induced transparency and slow light @xcite . the variation in dmot loading rate , @xmath28 , for changing @xmath5 was measured via the onf , with the lowest values of @xmath28 obtained for the darkest dmots as expected . this alternative technique for measurement of dmot parameters using an onf has the advantage that it can be used to probe different local regions of a dmot . for example , the loss of dark state cold atoms due to collisions around the central region and near the interface between bright and dark regions of a dmot can be studied using an onf . this would be extremely difficult to achieve using other commonly employed methods of fluorescence detection , i.e. , using photodetectors . this work was supported by science foundation ireland under grant no . 08/era / i1761 through the nanosci- e+ transnational programme , nois , and oist graduate university . lr acknowledges support from ircset through the embark initiative . 25 ward j m , oshea d g , shortt b j , morrissey m j , deasy k d and nic chormaic s 2006 heat - and - pull rig for fiber taper fabrication 083105 le kien f , dutta gupta s , balykin v i and hakuta k 2005 spontaneous emission of a cesium atom near a nanofiber : efficient coupling of light to guided modes a * 72 * 032509 nayak k p , melentiev p n , morinaga m , le kien f , balykin v i and hakuta k 2007 optical nanofiber as an efficient tool for manipulating and probing atomic fluorescence _ opt . exp . _ * 15 * 5431 morrissey m j , deasy k , wu y , chakrabarti s and nic chormaic s 2009 tapered optical fibers as tools for probing magneto - optical trap characteristics 053102 russell l , deasy k , daly m j , morrissey m j and nic chormaic s 2012 sub - doppler temperature measurements of laser - cooled atoms using optical nanofibres 015201 russell l , kumar r , tiwari v b and nic chormaic s 2013 measurements on release - recapture of cold @xmath0rb atoms using an optical nanofiber in a magneto - optical trap _ opt . commun . _ * 309 * 313 spillane s m , pati g s , salit k , hall m , kumar p , beausoleil r g and shahriar m s 2008 observation of nonlinear optical interactions of ultralow levels of light in a tapered optical nanofiber embedded in a hot rubidium vapor 233602 hendrickson s m , lai m m , pittman t b and franson j d 2010 observation of two - photon absorption at low power levels ssing tapered optical fibers in rubidium vapor 173602 watkins a , tiwari v b , ward j m and nic chormaic s 2013 observation of zeeman shift in the rubidium d2 line using an optical nanofiber in vapor _ arxiv:1208.4708v3 _ balykin v i , hakuta k , le kien f , liang j q and morinaga m 2004 atom trapping and guiding with a subwavelength - diameter optical fiber a * 70 * 011401 le kien f , balykin v i and hakuta k 2004 atom trap and waveguide using a two - color evanescent light field around a subwavelength - diameter optical fiber a * 70 * 063403 sagu g , baade a and rauschenbeutel a 2008 blue - detuned evanescent field surface traps for neutral atoms based on monde interference in ultrathin optical fibres _ new j. phys . * 113008 reitz d and rauschenbeutel a 2012 nanofiber - based double - helix trap for cold atoms _ opt . commun . _ * 285 * 4705 phelan c f , hennessy t and busch t 2013 shaping the evanescent field of optical nanofibers for cold atom trapping _ arxiv:1308.0905v1 _ vetsch e , reitz d , sagu g , schmidt r , dawkins s t and rauschenbeutel a 2010 optical interface created by laser - cooled atoms trapped in the evanescent field surrounding an optical nanofiber 203603 goban a , choi k s , alton d j , ding d , lacrote c , pototschnig m , thiele t , stern n p and kimble h j 2012 demonstration of a state - insensitive , compensated nanofiber trap 033603 russell l , gleeson d a , minogin v g and nic chormaic s 2009 spectral distribution of atomic fluorescence coupled into an optical nanofibre _ j. phys . b : at . mol . opt . phys._*42 * 185006 minogin v g and nic chormaic s 2010 manifestation of the van der waals surface interaction in the spontaneous emission of atoms into an optical nanofiber _ las . phys . _ * 20 * 32 morrissey m , deasy k , frawley m , kumar r , prel e , russell l , truong v g and nic chormaic s 2013 spectroscopy , manipulation and trapping of neutral atoms , molecules , and other particles using optical nanofibers : a review _ sensors _ * 13 * 10449 ketterle w , davis k b , joffe m a , martin a and pritchard d e 1993 high densities of cold atoms in a dark spontaneous - force optical trap 2253 muniz s r , magalhes k m f , henn e a l , marcassa l g and bagnato v s 2004 creating a self - induced dark spontaneous - force optical trap for neutral atoms _ opt . commun . _ * 235 * 333 chapovsky p l 2006 spectral characteristics of cold rubidium atoms in a dark magneto - optical trap _ j. exp . phys . _ * 103 * 711 chapovsky p l 2007 observation of nonlinear optical recoil - induced resonances in a dark magneto - optical trap _ j. exp . _ * 86 * 78 singh s , tiwari v b and rawat h s 2010 efficient loading of a rb dark magneto - optical trap by controlling current through a getter source _ j. exp . phys . _ * 111 * 371 li - rong w , zhong - hua j , jin - peng y , yan y , yan - ting z , jie m , lian - tuan x and suo - tang j 2012 investigation of ultracold atoms and molecules in a dark magneto - optical trap _ chin . b _ * 21 * 113402 permyakova o i , yakovlev a v and chapovskii p l 2008 measurement of the lifetime of rubidium atoms in a dark magneto - optical trap _ quant . _ * 38 * 884 townsend c g , edwards n h , zetie k p , cooper c j , rink j and foot c j 1996 high - density trapping of cesium atoms in a dark magneto - optical trap a * 53 * 1702 kenny r p , birks t a and oakley k p 1991 control of optical fibre taper shape _ electron . lett . _ * 27 * 1654 brambilla g , finazzi v and richardson d 2004 ultra - low - loss optical fiber nanotapers _ opt . express _ * 12 * 2258 abraham e r i and cornell e a 1998 teflon feedthrough for coupling optical fibers into ultrahigh vacuum systems _ appl . _ * 37 * 1762 cowpe j and pilkington r 2008 swagelok ultra - torr based feed - through design for coupling optical fibre bundles into vacuum systems _ vacuum _ * 82 * 1341 anderson m h , petrich w , ensher j r and cornell e a 1994 reduction of light - assisted collisional loss rate from a low - pressure vapor - cell trap a * 50 * r3597 kim j y and cho d 2001 dark - spot magneto - optical trap of cesium atoms _ j. kor . phys . soc . _ * 39 * 864 braje d , bali v , yin g and harris s 2003 low - light - level nonlinear optics with slow light a * 68 * 041801(r ) hakuta k 2008 single atoms on an optical nanofiber : a novel work system for slow light _ proc . | we report here measurements on a dark magneto - optical trap ( dmot ) of @xmath0rb atoms using an optical nanofibre ( onf ) with a waist of @xmath1 1 @xmath2 m . the dmot is created using a doughnut - shaped repump beam along with a depump beam for efficient transfer of cold atoms from the bright hyperfine ground state ( @xmath3 ) into the dark hyperfine ground state ( @xmath4 ) . the fluorescence from the cold @xmath0rb atoms of the dmot is detected by coupling it into the fibre - guided modes of the onf . the measured fractional population of cold atoms in the bright hyperfine ground state ( @xmath5 ) is as low as @xmath10.04 . the dependence of loading rate of dmot on cooling laser intensity is investigated and also compared with the loading rate of a bright - mot ( bmot ) . this work lays the foundation for the use of an onf for probing of a small number of atoms in an optically - dense cold atomic cloud . _ keywords _ : laser - cooling , dark mot , rubidium , tapered optical fibre , optical nanofibre , atom cloud density |
astro-ph0103479 | the classical picture of the dependence of the luminosity function ( lf ) on environment is that richer environments have steeper faint - end slopes . the range of measured slopes , using @xmath1 of the schechter ( 1976 ) formalism , was considered to vary from @xmath2 in rich clusters to @xmath3 for the low - density field . galaxy groups have long been included with the field in these models , taking the local group ( lg ) slope of @xmath4 ( pritchet & van den bergh 1999 ) as the prototype . as the lfs are superpositions of the lfs of individual morphological types , this suggests that dwarf galaxies contribute a larger fraction by luminosity in denser environments . yet , there have a been a number of observational constraints on determining the lf to dwarf luminosities of @xmath5 , where this steepening occurs . many photometric surveys do not reach much fainter than this potential turn - up at @xmath6 , as dwarfs are notoriously difficult to detect at any significant distance . this has often led to a trade - off in group and cluster studies between the distance of a galaxy sample ( and thus the limiting magnitude ) and angular sky coverage , as the nearer groups and clusters cover substantial and almost unwieldy fractions of the sky . this leads to further difficulties in membership classification , as the more distant groups and clusters require statistical membership determination using control fields for the faintest galaxies which can prove problematic ( _ c.f . _ valotto , moore , & lambas 2001 ) . finally , as we probe fainter dwarf galaxies , we also probe fainter surface brightnesses which introduce significant surface - brightness selection effects . with our @xmath7-band survey of the leo i group , we probe a nearby poor group to observational limits approaching those of the lg . leo i is a poor group at a distance of 10 mpc and contains ngc 3379 as a member . the best work on the lf of the group to date is the photographic work of ferguson & sandage ( 1991 ) . these data reached a limiting magnitude of @xmath8 ( adjusted for @xmath9 ) , which for a @xmath10 corresponds to @xmath11 . our program is designed to extend these limits . the strategy of our survey has three main features which mitigate some of the more insidious observational difficulties . first , our imaging survey uses the kpno 0.9m+mosaic , which has a 59@xmath12@xmath1359@xmath12 field of view with eight mosaiced ccds . thus , we have @xmath7-band imaging of over seven square degrees in leo i with the advantage of the linear response of ccds . second , the proximity of leo i at 10 mpc allows for galaxy membership classification on a galaxy - by - galaxy basis , using morphology , photometric parameters , radial profiles , colors , and in many cases , directly measured distances . finally , we have developed a detection technique that optimizes detection of very low - surface - brightness ( lsb ) dwarfs , extending our survey to both faint luminosities and faint surface brightnesses which approach the limits measured in the local group . our detection method is two - fold . first we use the traditional method of standard sextractor detection to find high - surface - brightness ( hsb ) objects . we then complement this with our optimized method , which is based on the work of dalcanton ( 1995 ) for finding large lsb galaxies in the field . we mask our image of high - surface - brightness features , and then convolve it with a filter of the shape and size we expect for dwarf galaxies at 10 mpc . in figure 1a , we show an example of a dwarf in our sample that is not detected by our traditional method . in the central panel , we show the masked image , and in the right panel , the same image convolved with a 5@xmath14 exponential kernel . the aperture size shown is the detection aperture from the optimized method , where the dwarf is now a significant detection . our method is described more fully in flint et al . ( 2001 ) . exponential kernel , now showing up as a significant detection.,width=384 ] an advantage of our detection procedure is that it is completely automated ; thus , we can run extensive montecarlo simulations to tune our detection parameters , quantify our completeness , and calculate our errors in measuring photometric parameters . we generate artificial galaxies , input them to our data images , and apply both our detection methods to recover them . we then calculate a recovery fraction as a function of both input central surface brightness ( @xmath15 ) and input total magnitude ( @xmath16 ) . our simulations for one field are shown in figure 2 , where the greyscale indicates recovery fractions of 90% ( darkest ) , 70% , 50% , 30% , and 10% ( lightest ) . lg galaxies , if seen at a distance of 10 mpc , are plotted for comparison . while we do nt detect dwarfs like draco and ursa minor , we find that without our optimized method , we would only detect objects with @xmath17 and so would miss dwarfs like and ii and fainter . furthermore , these data were taken with the mosaic s engineering grade chips which are difficult to flat field . we estimate that with flatter data , we could extend our method one magnitude in total magnitude and two magnitudes in central surface brightness . yet , even with these limitations , we find that at the 90% completeness level we can find dwarfs similar to antlia and sculptor , and at the 50% completeness level , dwarfs similar to tucana and leo ii ( flint et al . first results from leo i are shown in figure 3 . here we plot our detections in the same way as figure 2 , where the filled dots are lg galaxies again for comparison . here the crosses are objects detected via our traditional method . the stars are objects which would not have been detected without using the optimized method . these detections have had a preliminary membership classification , using their position in this figure , profile type , and morphology . using our sample of follow - up observations , we find that objects falling in the upper right area of the figure typically are small , higher - redshift background objects . we find some degree of contamination from background spirals around the freeman s law value of @xmath18 , where the open circle indicates a background spiral removed from the sample . ironically , however , we find the most robust membership classification so far for the lowest - surface - brightness objects , where the circled stars are examples of dwarfs we have identified as members via spectroscopic redshifts and surface - brightness fluctuations ( sbf ) . our follow - up program is on - going and includes velocity measurements from both hi and optical spectroscopy , sbf , and colors for all candidates . in this way , we also hope to guard against contamination from field lsb galaxies , cosmologically dimmed high-@xmath19 galaxies , and possibly diffuse light from @xmath20 galaxy clusters . an interesting feature of our sample is that we find a few galaxies which deviate from the typical @xmath21 relation followed by the lg galaxies in figure 3 . these galaxies , if members , are large , lsb dwarfs not seen in the lg . similar galaxies have previously been discovered in other environments such as virgo ( impey , bothun , & malin 1988 ) and m81 ( caldwell et al . with the data in figure 3 , we can begin to construct the group lf . in figure 4 , in the shaded histogram , we show the raw galaxy counts for the 80% of the data analyzed to date . we then weight these raw counts for incompleteness as quantified through the montecarlo simulations , as a function of both @xmath15 and @xmath16 . the scaled lf is shown as the open histogram in figure 4 . a preliminary measurement of the faint - end slope yields @xmath22 , which is consistent with @xmath4 measured in the local group ( pritchet & van den bergh 1999 ) . . filled histogram : raw galaxy counts . open histogram : galaxy counts scaled for completeness as a function of ( @xmath23 ) using results from the simulations.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] we present a new program for robustly detecting low - luminosity dwarfs at a distance of 10 mpc in the leo i group . using an optimized , filter - detection technique for finding low - surface - brightness dwarfs , we probe the group luminosity function to @xmath24 at the 50% completeness level . we use follow - up observations and morphological membership classification to construct a preliminary luminosity function which appears to be consistent with that of the local group . we also find several large , lsb dwarfs which , if they are members , deviate from the @xmath25 relation and have no counterpart in the local group . | we present first results of a survey of the leo i group at 10 mpc for @xmath0 dwarf galaxies . this is part of a larger program to measure the faint end of the galaxy luminosity function in nearby poor groups . our method is optimized to find local - group - like dwarfs down to dwarf spheroidal surface brighnesses , but we also find very large lsb dwarfs in leo i with no local group counterpart . a preliminary measurement of the luminosity function yields a slope consistent with that measured in the local group . ps . @plainmkbothoddheadoddfoot``dwarf galaxies and their environment '' ; international conference in bad honnef , germany , 23 - 27 january 2001evenheadevenfootoddfoot |
1009.4790 | solar @xmath3-modes are believed to be stochastically excited in the near surface layers of the sun by turbulent convection . the process can be described as acoustic radiation by turbulent multipole sources @xcite . further theoretical descriptions of the excitation of solar oscillations follow the work on stochastic driving by turbulent convection presented by @xcite and @xcite . these models were successful in explaining the acoustic power distribution over a wide range in frequencies as is manifested in the ensemble of solar @xmath3-modes . numerical simulations of convection , as described e.g. by @xcite or @xcite , predict supersonic downdrafts which could play a role in the excitation of the solar oscillations . actually , the turbulent velocity field from the numerical simulations by @xcite were used by @xcite to determine the energy supply rate of convection into the solar oscillations . for the seismology of the sun and sunlike stars , knowledge of the stochastic properties of the source function that drives @xmath3-modes would be a valuable input . in local helioseismology , e.g. , the sensitivity functions which connect the acoustic properties of the @xmath3-modes with physical quantities in the sun depend on the source function whose properties are not known and must be estimated @xcite . in addition , the sun could serve as a paradigm for stellar seismology since the interaction of pulsations and convection and the energy gain and loss of @xmath3-modes from radiation and convection is a general problem of stellar physics @xcite . when searching for the possible locations of the wave sources on the sun , the turbulent downdrafts in the dark intergranular lanes are primary targets . so - called `` acoustic events '' , which are individual sunquakes with epicenters near the solar surface and located in the intergranular lanes , are assumed to feed continuously energy into the resonant @xmath3-modes of the sun . studies of such acoustic events were carried out by @xcite and @xcite with the result that such events have typical durations of 5 minutes and are caused by collapsing intergranular lanes . in this contribution our basis for further studies of the driving of the solar oscillations are dopplergrams of the velocity above the solar surface . time series recorded with the imax instrument @xcite aboard the balloon - borne observatory sunrise @xcite provide the spatial and temporal resolution needed to measure the propagation of acoustic oscillations in the granules and the intergranular lanes . we assume that acoustic events could be observed as they eventually cause waves to propagate away from the location of the source . the unprecedented spatial resolution of the data makes it worthwhile to study the excitation and propagation of acoustic waves visible in the solar photosphere . as a new result we find that the acoustic power is not only enhanced in the intergranular lanes and along the borders of the granules but also above large granules , where splitting processes are about to occur . surprisingly , the excitation of waves of high wave number seem to be a diagnostic of pending granule splitting . for our study we use a time series of solar granulation with a field of view of [email protected] by [email protected] located close to disk center . the data were obtained with the imaging magnetograph experiment imax @xcite onboard the sunrise balloon - borne solar observatory @xcite between 00:35:49 ut and 00:59:57 ut ( 1st series ) and 01:30:41 ut and 02:02:48 ut on june 9 , 2009 ( 2nd series ) . the imax instrument and the reduction process which was applied to the data is described in detail in @xcite and shall be briefly summarized in the following . the imax filtergraph was operated in the v5 - 6 observing mode , recording all stokes parameters at @xmath5 $ ] m with respect to the line center of 5250.2 ( @xmath6 , @xmath7 ev ) . the exposure time for a picture at a single wavelength position was 6 s , while the entire line was scanned in 33 s. in the data reduction process , the dark current was removed , and a flat field procedure damped residual impurities , i.e. dust particles or scratches . in addition , the interference fringes caused by the polarizing beam splitter were removed from the images by attenuating their contribution in fourier space . furthermore , a spatially dependent blue - shift over the fov was calibrated and removed . phase diversity ( pd ) measurements that were recorded close in time to the actual data , were used to reconstruct all pictures . the corrected images of the two cameras were merged to increase the s / n ratio which is of the order of @xmath8 related to the continuum intensity ( @xmath9)in the reconstructed data . in a last step , crosstalk induced by residual motion was removed . thus , we obtained time series with lengths of 24 and 32 minutes , resp . , and a cadence of 33 s. a spatial resolution between @xmath10 - @xmath11 was achieved by combining the on - board image stabilization system @xcite . besides doppler velocity ( @xmath12 ) and continuum intensity ( @xmath9 ) , which we will use for further investigation , other quantities like line center intensity ( @xmath13 ) , linear and circular polarization , and line width ( fwhm ) were computed . the quantities @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and fwhm are inferred from a gaussian fit to the four points in the line after they have been normalized using the continuum intensity at @xmath14227 m . the velocity scale has been calibrated assuming a convective blue shift of 0.2 kms@xmath15 at disk center , and the absolute error in @xmath12 was estimated to be of the order of @xmath16 kms@xmath15 . the two time series of the doppler velocity measured by imax reveal a `` flying shadow '' pattern with a characteristic time scale of five minutes and a characteristic spatial length scale between 5@xmath4 and 10@xmath4 . such a movie will be part of the electronic supplemenatary material of the introductory letter by @xcite . this pattern is due to the solar @xmath0- and @xmath3-modes present on the sun . the `` flying shadows '' originate from the stochastic superposition of a multitude of solar acoustic eigenmodes of various spatial wavelength , temporal frequency , and amplitude , which cause these `` five - minute oscillations '' . for a quantitative analysis we investigate the power distribution in the diagnostic diagram , where the spectral power density is displayed as a function of wave number @xmath17 and temporal frequency @xmath18 , cf . [ fig : power ] . the frequency resolution in the fourier domain is 0.52mhz . we find a significant enhancement of oscillatory power between 2 and 7mhz in the @xmath0- and @xmath3-mode area . ridges of solar acoustic oscillations are at best visible only in outlines at high wave numbers . the @xmath0-mode ridge seems to extend until a wave number of @xmath19mm@xmath15 , where the ridge is cut by the acoustic cut - off frequency at @xmath20 5.3mhz ( see fig . [ fig : power ] ) . the velocity of the superposition of @xmath0-modes has an rms - amplitude of 147 m/s with a maximum velocity of 902 m/s . from the location of enhanced power in this diagram we conclude that besides the superposition of large - scale standing acoustic waves with low wave numbers also the small - scale waves with high wave numbers are excited . these small - scale waves are expected to have a shorter lifetime than the large - scale waves . in the following we will focus on the study of these small - scale oscillations . before doing so , we would like to note that besides the sonic power we find also subsonic power below the @xmath0-mode . these subsonic velocities correspond to the convective granular motions we observe . we study the excitation and propagation of solar @xmath3-modes by first filtering the data . in order to remove trends in the time series a `` first - difference '' filter is applied . further filtering for the @xmath0- and @xmath1-modes is carried out in the fourier domain . a fast fourier transformation is applied to the time series . the result of this is multiplied by a filter that acts as a band - pass including the @xmath0-mode and the @xmath1-mode ridges . figure [ fig : power ] outlines ( gray lines ) this three - dimensional filter as projection onto the @xmath21 diagram . the filter is based on hanning windows with increasing widths as a function of the absolute magnitude of the wavenumber @xmath17 . further filter properties are that the filter allows only those modes with wave numbers @xmath22mm@xmath23mm@xmath15 to pass , i.e. the filter removes the contributions of large - scale waves and subsonic granular motions . after filtering , the data is transformed back into the time domain . the resulting time series contains only the small - scale oscillatory motions . the filtered data allows the excitation and propagation of small - scale acoustic waves to be seen . for a quick investigation , acoustic power maps are determined by averaging the square of the filtered velocity time series over time and at each pixel . figure [ fig : acmap ] displays this temporally averaged acoustic power of the oscillatory velocity field after filtering . + in this map the granular network is visible , since the intergranular lanes and the borders of the granules exhibit strong acoustic power . however , there is also significant power present above the granules . this is visible in detail in the enlarged view shown in the bottom panel of fig . [ fig : acmap ] . inspecting the complete series of doppler maps , the origin of this acoustic power enhancements on top of the granules are oscillations which are either excited in the integranular lanes propagating through the granules or waves which are excited inside splitting or exploding granules . a time sequence of such an exploding granule is shown in figs . [ fig : seq ] and [ fig : seq2 ] . during the observation the displayed granule continues to grow within the first half of the sequence before it fragments in the second half . already at the beginning of the recording ( t=199s ) parallel wave fronts are rippling on top of the granule . surprisingly , these wave fronts are aligned with an intergranular lane that is forming during the sequence but finally splits the granule 265 s later ( t=464s ) . further splittings of the granule occur at later times which seem to excite additional wave fronts on a smaller scale . such events happen in multitude in the recorded time series and not only at this particular location . based on a wavelet analysis @xcite study the distribution of acoustic power in space and time . they find also increased power above small fast - evolving granules , splitting granules , dark dots and forming lanes . another finding , which can be observed in all granules of fig . [ fig : seq ] and fig . [ fig : seq2 ] , is that the wave amplitude itself is attenuated in the granules . the centers of stable granules show only weak small - scale oscillatory motions . after approximately four wavelengths the high - degree oscillations are damped away . therefore , waves excited in the intergranular lanes or in the splitting process of granules seem to lose energy while probing a granule . this might explain the comparatively high acoustic power along the borders of the granules . we have investigated the properties of small - scale solar @xmath3-modes as recorded by the imax instrument during the flight of the balloon - borne sunrise observatory in june 2009 . we analyzed the doppler velocity and continuum intensity observations to study the potential of such data sets for investigations of the excitation and propagation of high - degree acoustic waves on the sun . based on two sequences of data , we find that there is a strong relation between increased acoustic @xmath3-mode power with high wave number above granules and the onset of the splitting process that fragments granules . the splitting of granules triggers the excitation of waves several minutes before the actual splitting becomes visible in continuum radiation . a possible explanation for the excitation of such waves could be related to the formation of new intergranular lanes and connected turbulent motions which set off acoustic waves . therefore , we conclude that not only the vigorous motions in the established integranular downdrafts are sources for acoustic waves , but also the processes related to the formation of new intergranular lanes . in future studies , e.g. based on either data from a second sunrise flight or from other instruments in space or on ground , we plan to investigate the excitation process of solar @xmath3-modes on the basis of spatially highly resolved data in greater detail . for a more quantitative analysis we aim to obtain new contiguous observations that cover a longer time period , which shall allow to resolve the ridges of the @xmath3-modes in the diagnostic diagram . such longer time series are needed to measure e.g. the green s function which is the respose to an `` acoustic event '' on the sun . this would help determining the statistical properties of the solar oscillation s source function , which is needed as an input to sensitivity kernels as they are calculated , e.g. , for local helioseismology . furthermore , it remains an open task to study the damping , transmission , and refraction of solar @xmath3-modes in granules . observations of such quality could be useful for such investigations and might allow obtaining an acoustic image of the formation and the structure of granules . the german contribution to @xmath24 is funded by the bundesministerium fr wirtschaft und technologie through deutsches zentrum fr luft- und raumfahrt e.v . ( dlr ) , grant no . 50 ou 0401 , and by the innovationsfond of the president of the max planck society ( mpg ) . the spanish contribution has been funded by the spanish micinn under projects esp2006 - 13030-c06 and aya2009 - 14105-c06 ( including european feder funds ) . the hao contribution was partly funded through nasa grant number nnx08ah38 g . m. roth acknowledges support from the european helio- and asteroseismology network ( helas ) which was funded as coordination action under the european commisssion s framework programme 6 . this work has been partially supported by the wcu grant no . r31 - 10016 funded by the korean ministry of education , science and technology . | solar oscillations are expected to be excited by turbulent flows in the intergranular lanes near the solar surface . time series recorded by the imax instrument aboard the sunrise observatory reveal solar oscillations at high resolution , which allow studying the properties of oscillations with short wavelengths . we analyze two times series with synchronous recordings of doppler velocity and continuum intensity images with durations of 32min and 23min , resp . , recorded close to the disk center of the sun to study the propagation and excitation of solar acoustic oscillations . in the doppler velocity data , both the standing acoustic waves and the short - lived , high - degree running waves are visible . the standing waves are visible as temporary enhancements of the amplitudes of the large - scale velocity field due to the stochastic superposition of the acoustic waves . we focus on the high - degree small - scale waves by suitable filtering in the fourier domain . investigating the propagation and excitation of @xmath0- and @xmath1-modes with wave numbers @xmath21/mm we find that also exploding granules contribute to the excitation of solar @xmath3-modes in addition to the contribution of intergranular lanes . |
cond-mat9605135 | in recent years , the annihilation - diffusion problem has generated significant interest , both theoretical and experimental . the annihilation - diffusion problem usually corresponds to that of the kinetics of particle density decay in the annihilation reaction @xmath1 ( one - species annihilation ) and @xmath2 ( two - species annihilation ) . in the latter case , in most physical systems that one is interested in , in addition to the thermal diffusion and kinetic annihilation , the particles a and b are charged and interact via a power - law long - range interaction ( lri ) , usually of coulomb type , although here we will consider a more general lri . such physically important interaction can clearly strongly influence the annihilation dynamics by introducing an additional time scale in the annihilation process , and can lead to a new mechanism for slow dynamics . the two - species annihilation reaction with lri can be studied in a variety of experiments . a thermal quench of a freely - suspended liquid crystal film from smectic - a to smectic - c phase @xcite is one experimental system where this annihilation process has been studied in great detail . in such experiments , immediately after quench , the singularities of the smectic director ( 2d vector ) field appear as positive and negative vortices interacting ( due to elastic forces ) via a logarithmic potential . as time elapses , vortices of opposite sign slowly annihilate , exhibiting complex dynamics that is clearly and strongly influenced by temperature , initial particle distribution , and lri that leads to an attraction between annihilating partners . similar annihilation problems also appear in turbulent flow , superconductivity , spinodal decomposition , and many other condensed matter systems . the annihilation process is also relevant to coarsening of topological defects produced by symmetry breaking field in particle physics models , after an early temperature quench due to the fast initial universe expansion , a process that is thought in part to determine the large scale structure of today s universe.@xcite it is well known that in classical chemical kinetics , density decay for both one - species and two - species annihilation is described by the kinetic rate - equation ( see , e.g. , @xcite ): @xmath3 with the large-@xmath4 asymptotics given by : @xmath5 where @xmath6 is a reaction constant . equation ( [ eq : kinrate ] ) completely neglects all spatial fluctuations and correlations of the particle density . although the dynamics described by equations ( [ eq : kinrate ] ) - ( [ eq : mfsoln ] ) is correct above an upper critical space dimension @xmath7 , for @xmath8 , both diffusion and fluctuations play an important role , substantially slowing down the density decay . it was indeed shown @xcite , that for the one - species annihilation without lri , the @xmath9 . that is , for systems of dimensionality less than @xmath10 , the density decay is given by : @xmath11 where @xmath12 is diffusion constant and @xmath13 is the initial particle density . equation ( [ eq : difsolnaa ] ) can be understood either by invoking a single length scaling arguments @xcite or by using a more elaborate smoluchowski approach @xcite . for the two - species case , it was shown ( refs.@xcite , @xcite ) that the upper critical dimension @xmath14 , and that for @xmath15 , the large-@xmath4 asymptotics is : @xmath16 the decay law ( [ eq : difsolnab ] ) was confirmed in several numerical simulations of one- , two- , and three - dimensional systems @xcite . it is important to emphasize that in order to observe such power - law decay , it is necessary initially to have an equal number of positive and negative charges , distributed at random . if initial numbers of positive and negative charges are different , one should observe an exponential density decay to the non - vacuum equilibrium ( see , e.g. , sokolov et al . if the system is well - stirred , i.e. , long - wavelength fluctuations of charge density are suppressed , the decay law would also be different . we will not consider such cases in this paper . to better study the role of correlations in reactions without lri , description in terms of secondary quantization operators of creation and annihilation was proposed . @xcite further developing this approach , peliti @xcite proposed an `` exact '' ( valid to all orders in perturbation expansion ) renormalization - group theory for the one - species annihilation , and lee and cardy @xcite suggested a similar approach to the two - species annihilation , both based on the rigorous master equation converted into a field - theoretic formulation . in the latter case , it was shown that the decay law ( [ eq : difsolnab ] ) is an asymptotic one for large @xmath4 and small @xmath13 . it was also rigorously proven that the assumptions used in the derivation of equation ( [ eq : difsolnab ] ) are correct only for @xmath17 , while for @xmath18 , a more elaborate renormalization group procedure which includes an effective noise with nontrivial correlations should be carried out . the addition of the lri further complicates the picture . equations of motion become strongly coupled via the nonlocal interaction , and only approximate solutions of these equations can be found . up to date , only coulombic @xcite systems in two dimensions ( @xmath19 , the case corresponding to particles interacting via a logarithmic potential on a two - dimensional substrate or film ) were studied numerically @xcite , and results appear to be inconclusive . in these simulations , particle density exhibited a power - law decay @xmath20 with the exponent @xmath21 varying from @xmath22 @xcite to @xmath23 @xcite . the authors proposed a scaling theory @xcite suggesting that for a coulombic ( @xmath24 ) two - dimensional diffusion - annihilation system , annihilation exponent is equal to @xmath25 - close to but less than the mean - field exponent @xmath26 . oshanin et al . @xcite suggested that the exponent should be exactly 1 ; ispolatov and krapivsky @xcite came to the same conclusion using an `` inpenetrable domain '' scaling theory . in their theoretical and computational study of the defect annihilation in two - dimensional xy - model , yurke et al . @xcite argued that annihilation exponent is 1 , with logarithmic correction due to the logarithmic dependence of the mobility on the defect size . thus , the problem of annihilation behavior for coulombic system in two dimensions has not been completely resolved , although it seems rather plausible that the final asymptotics is governed by a classical exponent 1 , with possible logarithmic correction . it seems to be certain , however , that annihilation in three - dimensional coulombic system has a mean - field type final asymptotics with exponent 1 . finally , we should point out that until recently , there has been no discussion of lri other than coulombic . recently . several scaling theories have been suggested to analyze arbitrary power - law interaction ( more short - ranged than coulombic ) @xcite.such problems may arise , e.g. , in describing interactions between vacancies and interstitials in a two- or three - dimensional crystal . in this paper , we propose a self - consistent theory based on coarse - grained hydrodynamic equations of motion for particle number density and charge density fields . this theory allows us to systematically calculate the dependence of the density decay law on initial conditions and to investigate the role of lri . it can be shown@xcite that the self - consistent approximation that we employ here is equivalent to a resummation of an infinite class of feynman graphs which take into account the conserved charge density fluctuations but ignore the less important nonconserved number density fluctuations . this approximation can be further systematically improved by the use of perturbation theory and the renormalization group analysis that will be a subject of future publication.@xcite in the limit of weak long - range interactions , this approach agrees well with the known theoretical results ( see refs . @xcite ) for the two - species annihilation @xmath27 , thereby further clarifying the underlying assumptions that led to these results . the paper is organized as follows : in section [ sec : eqns ] we define all variables and present the equations of motion on which our analysis and results will be based . in section [ sec : solns ] the self - consistent approximation is described and the asymptotic solutions are obtained and analyzed . finally , in section [ sec : concl ] we analyze the resulting phase diagram and discuss it in the context of the previously obtained results for various diffusion - annihilation systems , which are selected points on our phase diagram . let us consider a system consisting of two kinds of particles , a and b , with a having a positive charge @xmath28 and b having a negative charge @xmath29 . we label their , time- and position - dependent concentrations as @xmath30 and @xmath31 , respectively , and impose the condition that @xmath32 . the equation of motion for the densities is based on the generalized law of mass conservation , violated by the annihilation process , @xmath33 where the mass current is given by @xmath34 and @xmath35 is the electrostatic long - range potential at a point * r * at time @xmath4 due to local charge fluctuations away from neutrality ; @xmath36 is the power exponent of the long - range force , @xmath37 is particle mobility taken to be a constant , and @xmath38 is particle charge . equations ( [ eq : evol ] ) - ( [ eq : poten ] ) should be solved in conjunction with initial conditions for @xmath39 and @xmath40 . since here we are interested in statistical averages , rather than in a dynamic solution for a given system with specific initial conditions , we will focus on the density correlation functions , with averages over random @xmath41 initial conditions . equations ( [ eq : evol ] ) - ( [ eq : poten ] ) represent the coarse - grained continuum limit for the `` real '' equations of motion ; all variables in these equations are averaged over `` elementary volume '' @xmath42 . thus , only long - wavelength modes are actually described by these equations , and , therefore , only intermediate - time and large - time regimes can be analyzed . it is more natural and convenient to describe the system in terms of the particle number and charge densities . we denote the former one as @xmath43 , and the latter one as @xmath44 and relate them to densities @xmath45 and @xmath46 as follows : @xmath47 @xmath48 rewriting equations ( [ eq : evol ] ) - ( [ eq : poten ] ) using densities @xmath49 and @xmath50 , we obtain : @xmath51 where @xmath52 . in the absence of lri , equations ( [ eq : rhoevol ] ) - ( [ eq : fevol ] ) are those analyzed in ref . however , the presence of the additional long - range interactions , makes the analysis of their asymptotic solutions rather nontrivial and , as we will show below , leads to new dynamic regimes . it is important to note that equations ( [ eq : rhoevol ] ) - ( [ eq : fevol ] ) do not contain noise terms in their right - hand sides . it has been rigorously shown that such noise terms represent important correlations and in some cases may even become predominant in determining the asymptotic decay rate . in equations of motion describing a near - equilibrium dynamics , powerful fluctuation - dissipation theorem determines the form of noise correlations . in contrast , in systems far from equilibrium , such as a system of annihilating particles , it can be shown@xcite that the effective hydrodynamic equations of motion derived from the fundametal master equations contain noise terms with very nontrivial correlations , of the form which could not be easily guessed a priori . lee and cardy @xcite proved that in a two - species reaction without lri , such noise leads only to the renormalization of the reaction rate @xmath6 , but not to the change of the scaling exponents , provided that space dimensionality @xmath53 . we have shown , in a similar fashion @xcite , that for systems with lri , the noise has no effect on the asymptotic dynamics for @xmath53 , if the renormalization of both @xmath6 and @xmath54 is implied . in addition , since equations ( [ eq : rhoevol ] ) - ( [ eq : fevol ] ) provide a coarse - grained description on the length scale larger than the interparticle spacing @xmath55 , the kinetic coefficients , e.g. @xmath6 , are effective coefficients that incorporate finite renormalization due to the correlations on short length scales . in order to simplify further analysis , we divide each of the equations ( [ eq : rhoevol ] ) -([eq : fevol ] ) by @xmath13 and transform everything to dimensionless variables as follows : / _ 0 , f f / _ 0 , d d ( _ 0)^2/d , + @xmath56 it is important to notice that equation ( [ eq : fevol ] ) is linear with respect to @xmath49 , while equation ( [ eq : rhoevol ] ) is quadratic with respect to @xmath49 ( this points to the system s invariance with respect to the simultaneous charge sign reversal for all particles ) . in the next section , we will describe the self - consistent approximation and its solutions . we now make an important approximation in order to further simplify the analytical treatment of equations ( [ eq : rhoevol])-([eq : fevol ] ) , namely , we choose to ignore the fluctuations of the particle density @xmath50 and concentrate on the fluctuations of the conserved charge density @xmath49 . this assumption is somewhat similar in spirit to the approach of glotzer and coniglio @xcite for the problem of spinodal decomposition , and to the spherical approximation for the ising model in the limit of @xmath57 . unlike the `` classical '' mean - field approach , however , the proposed approximation does take into account exactly the charge density fluctuations , and is expected , therefore , to describe at least some of the features of the fluctuation - dominated kinetics . the justification of the proposed assumption lies in a simple observation that , while average particle density at any time is nonzero , so that @xmath58 is finite and likely to be small , average charge density is always zero , and therefore in comparison the charge fluctuations @xmath59 are large . thus , we expect the former fluctuations to be less important that the latter , and that we can approximate the particle number density by its average ( time - dependent ) value in the equations of motion without losing their important features . in a sense , our approximation is a generalization of an argument used by toussaint and wilczek @xcite , in which they based their scaling decay law on a suggestion that @xmath60 . it seems clear that the approximation of ignoring the number density fluctuations must breakdown at least below some upper - critical dimension @xmath7 , since asymptotically @xmath50 vanishes . in this case our approximation will be valid for @xmath61 for all times and in systems below @xmath7 it will be a good approximation up to a crossover time beyond which the asymptotics will be modified by the number density fluctuations . systematically taking into account these additional fluctuations will be a subject of future work.@xcite taking into account the above approximation , we rewrite the equation ( [ eq : fevol ] ) in fourier representation , taking @xmath62 as a spatially - independent but time - dependent function : @xmath63 where @xmath64 . the equation ( [ eq : rhoevol ] ) in this self - consistent approximation is rewritten as : @xmath65 where @xmath66 denotes averaging over initial conditions . these equations of motion have to be supplemented with initial conditions . it is well known that the initial density distribution plays an important role in determining the scaling decay law . although the self - consistent approximation employed here is well suited for a comprehensive study of the influence of initial conditions on the dynamics , here we limit our study to a single type of an initial condition . throughout this paper we will focus on the dynamics initiated with a random gaussian particle distribution , completely characterized by @xmath67 which constraints the system to charge neutrality at all times and for simplicity we take the variance @xmath68 ( @xmath69 in physical units ) . for most charged experimental systems a more relevant initial conditions incorporate the suppression of long - wavelength fluctuations in charge density , which can be modeled ( within e.g. the debye - hckel approximation ) by @xmath70 in equation ( [ eq : fkinit ] ) . the diffusion - only ( do ) case ( @xmath71 ) and coulombic case ( @xmath72 ) are the simplest systems with a relatively clear , yet interesting asymptotic behavior . all the intermediate interactions ( arbitrary @xmath36 and @xmath73 ) lead to a more complicated scaling behavior , with several regimes and crossovers . we will devote a subsection to each of these three cases . there are two ways of approaching the limit of `` no long - range interactions '' : by decreasing the force constant @xmath54 to 0 or by increasing the power exponent @xmath36 to infinity ( interaction with an effectively vanishing range ) . obviously , these limits should give the same answer . for simplicity , we will set @xmath74 and show that our self - consistent approximation yields the well - known results.@xcite-@xcite @xmath75 for @xmath71 , the kinetic equation for @xmath49 reduces to a simple diffusion equation , with the solution @xmath76 substituting this solution ( [ eq : twfk ] ) for @xmath77 into equation ( [ eq : rhonewevol ] ) , and taking into account the initial condition ( [ eq : f1kinit ] ) - ( [ eq : fkinit ] ) , we obtain : @xmath78 an the exact solution expressible in terms of confluent hypergeometric functions is possible.@xcite it can also be easily shown that equation ( [ eq : twsoln ] ) describes the asymptotic solution of equation ( [ eq : twequation ] ) . this is expected , since , as we argued above , the approximations made by toussaint and wilczek @xcite are very similar to our self - consistent model . the case of @xmath79 will be analyzed in subsection [ intermediate systems ] , where it will be shown that for all @xmath80 , the decay law is asymptotically the same as for do systems . in coulombic systems , the long - range interaction is the strongest possible that one can achieve without making the system thermodynamically unstable ( systems with interactions stronger than coulombic have infinite pressure and chemical potential even if their total charge is zero ) . because of this , one would expect the particle density decay for coulombic systems to be very close or equal to the mean - field law @xmath81 . @xcite as we describe below , the self - consistent approximation predicts the decay exponent @xmath26 consistent with this expectation and with some simulations reported in the literature.@xcite however , it can be shown@xcite that correction to this mean - field like decay law can arise from the number density fluctuations and noise for @xmath82 , both of which have been neglected in the self - consistent theory presented here . equation for the evolution of charge density @xmath49 for the coulombic systems in the self - consistent approximation can be exactly solved to yield : @xmath83\;. \label{eq : coulfksoln}\ ] ] using this solution ( [ eq : coulfksoln ] ) and the initial condition ( [ eq : f1kinit ] ) - ( [ eq : fkinit ] ) , @xmath62 can be easily shown to satisfy the following differential equation : @xmath84 in order to find the asymptotic solutions , we introduce a new variable : @xmath85 equation ( [ eq : coulrhoevol ] ) then transforms to : @xmath86 let us find the `` critical '' dimension @xmath7 , above which the mean - field behavior is manifested . the mean - field solution for @xmath87 is given by @xmath88 where @xmath89 corresponds to subdominant constant terms and terms decreasing with time . by counting powers of @xmath4 in the right - hand side and the left - hand side of equation ( [ eq : thetaevol ] ) , we obtain : power(lhs ) = @xmath90 ; power(rhs ) = @xmath91 . + obviously , for the mean - field solution to be valid asymptotically , the power(lhs ) should be larger than the power(rhs ) , which happens for systems with dimensionality larger than the critical dimension , @xmath92 if @xmath93 , the asymptotic kinetics is determined by the slower process , which is the annihilation , with possibly interaction renormalized @xmath94 ( implicitely assumed here ) , and the coulomb interaction and diffusion are asymptotically irrelevant . for @xmath95 , the coulomb interaction has an interesting effect of continuously lowering the upper - critical dimension from @xmath96 ( for @xmath97 , in which case for @xmath15 the diffusion dominates giving @xmath98 ) down to @xmath7 given above . in order to analyze the kinetics when space dimensionality @xmath73 is below @xmath7 , we employ the `` steady - state '' approximation , which suggests that at long times the time derivative in the lhs of equation ( [ eq : coulrhoevol ] ) is the smallest of the three terms . in this case , the equation of motion can be written as : @xmath99 an exact solution of this equation is : @xmath100\ ; , \label{eq : theta2soln}\ ] ] and @xmath101 it can be easily shown that for large @xmath4 , the asymptotic solution for the particle density decay ( @xmath102 ) is : @xmath103 predicting the asymptotic decay exponent @xmath26 for coulomb systems , as in the mean - field regime , although with @xmath54- rather than @xmath104-determined amplitude . this large-@xmath4 limit is achieved when : @xmath105^{{4}/(4-d)}\ ; , \label{eq : coullarget}\ ] ] and it can be easily seen that in the limit of @xmath106 ( vanishing interactions ) the transition time @xmath107 to this region becomes infinite , i.e. this time is never reached . if diffusion is faster than the deterministic coulomb interaction - driven relaxation , i.e. , @xmath108 , then for times less than @xmath109 , the annihilation is governed by the intermediate asymptotics : @xmath110 so the particle density is described by the toussaint - wilczek solution up to the crossover time @xmath107 : @xmath111 this intermediate asymptotics , which exists only for @xmath112 , reflects early times diffusion - dominated decay , with the slower deterministic coulomb interaction driven classical @xmath113 decay appearing only at times later than @xmath107 . in contrast , for @xmath114 or if @xmath115 , there is no extended intermediate regime and one should see a quick transition to a classical decay law . although within the self - consistent approximation the asymptotic @xmath116 decay is not affected by the choice of reasonable initial conditions , the intermediate diffusion - dominated decay is certainly affected by our choice of random gaussian uncorrelated initial conditions given in equation ( [ eq : fkinit ] ) . for instance if the screened debye - hckel initial conditions are used with @xmath117 , then this @xmath118 will appear as a multiplicative kernel under the @xmath119 integral in equation ( [ eq : coulrhoevol ] ) . it will then modify the intermediate decay exponent from @xmath120 to @xmath121 ( and , for @xmath53 , eliminating this intermediate region altogether ) , without modifying the asymptotic decay of equation ( [ eq : coulrholarget ] ) . to sum up , we find that within the self - consistent approximation , coulombic systems @xmath122 asymptotically exhibit the @xmath113 density decay , consistent with several scaling arguments and simulations.@xcite let us now consider the general case of long - range interactions with a power - law @xmath123 that is of shorter range ( weaker ) than the coulomb interaction considered in the previous section . equations ( [ eq : fkevol ] ) - ( [ eq : rhonewevol ] ) can be solved to yield : @xmath124\;,\label{eq : intfksoln}\\ \frac{d \rho}{d t } + { \cal k}\rho^{2 } & = & { \cal k}\int \frac{d^{d } k}{(2 \pi)^{d } } \exp [ -2dk^{2}t - 2qk^{2-\sigma } \int_{0}^{t } \rho(\tau ) d \tau]\ ; , \label{eq : intrhoevol}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath125 . equation ( [ eq : intrhoevol ] ) is significantly more complicated than its analogs for either coulombic or non - interacting cases . nevertheless , it is possible to find its power - law asymptotic solutions . using an asymptotic analysis analogous to that described in the previous subsection , we find several kinetic regimes depending on the values of @xmath73 and @xmath36 . these regimes depend crucially on the charge density relaxation mechanism , i.e. , whether the lri or diffusion determines the relaxation rate of @xmath126 at late times . in order to analyze the asymptotic behavior of the system , we again introduce the integrated density @xmath127 as defined in equation ( [ eq : theta ] ) . we also assume a power - law for the density and , for @xmath112 , neglect the term @xmath128 . in this case , the equations of motion are : @xmath129}\;,\label{eq : ims1}\\ \rho ( t ) & = & \frac{d \theta}{d t}\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] depending on @xmath130 and @xmath73 , either the first or second term in the exponential in equation ( [ eq : ims1 ] ) dominates for large @xmath4 , corresponding to either diffusive or superdiffusive relaxation . we first assume that diffusive relaxation is prevalent and determine the conditions when it is true . in the case of diffusive relaxation mechanism and at large @xmath4 , equation ( [ eq : ims1 ] ) can be simplified to yield : @xmath131}\ ; , \label{eq : ims2}\ ] ] where @xmath132 is a dimensionless constant absorbing integration over angular variables , and the integral becomes time - independent for large @xmath4 if the second term in the exponential vanishes with time . if we assume the power - law dependence for @xmath50 and @xmath87 : @xmath133 then it follows from equation ( [ eq : ims2 ] ) that for the predominantly diffusive system @xmath134 , as expected . thus , in order for this solution to be self - consistent , we must require that : @xmath135 and , from the definition of @xmath130 , we determine the region where the relaxation and density decay are diffusion - limited : @xmath136 this region is marked fd ( fluctuation - dominated ) in figure 1 . in it , the lri are irrelevant at large @xmath4 , although they may influence the density decay kinetics for intermediate @xmath4 . the asymptotic decay law in the fd region is given by : @xmath137 in the region referred to as the ir ( intermediate region ) and which lies below fd in figure 1 ( @xmath138 ) the lri are strong and dominate the diffusion at large @xmath4 . to investigate the asymptotics of the decay in this region , we rewrite equation ( [ eq : ims1 ] ) in the following way : @xmath139}. \label{eq : ims4}\ ] ] using @xmath140 . by solving equation ( [ eq : ims4 ] ) approximately we find two asymptotics in this region : @xmath141 valid at intermediate times , and @xmath142 where @xmath143 for asymptotically large times . the crossover time @xmath144 from the diffusion - dominated decay to the lri - dominated decay is : @xmath145 thus , in this region ( marked ir - intermediate region - in figure 1 ) the lri accelerates the relaxation of the initial density fluctuations and thereby speed up the annihilation . if @xmath146 , the diffusive relaxation and the ( @xmath120)-law may be observed for the intermediate @xmath4 before transition to the superdiffusive relaxation and faster decay takes place for @xmath147 . if @xmath115 ( region mf - mean - field - in figure 1 ) , spatial fluctuations become irrelevant and the classical kinetic - rate equation becomes asymptotically correct , so the decay law in this region is given by : @xmath148 as previously discussed . in the presented work we derive approximate kinetic equations for the annihilation - diffusion process with long - range forces . to analyze the asymptotic decay law for systems with @xmath53 , we proposed a new self - consistent method of calculating the average particle density as function of time . since the total particle density is a nonconserved order parameter with positive average at all times , we argued that its fluctuations are less important in determining dynamics of annihilation than that of a conserved order parameter - the charge density . this approximation self - consistently decouples two kinetic equations and make it possible to find the asymptotic solutions . for coulombic systems in more than two dimensions , our model yields the mean - field exponent @xmath26 , yet the role of segregation ( i.e. , charge density fluctuations ) is important and can not be simply left out . ispolatov and krapivsky @xcite proposed the `` unpenetrable domain '' scaling concept , which in coulombic case results in decay exponent @xmath150 independently of space dimensionality . both their model and our self - consistent approximation neglect possible fluctuation modes due to the spatial variation of particle density , as well as noise , which can lead to some slowing down of the reaction kinetics , as indicated by simulations . elucidation of such modes and their role should require detailed account of noise and possibly use of renormalization group analysis when @xmath151 , since it is the critical dimension for the annihilation - diffusion problem . since neglecting of noise in this problem appears to be justified for long - time asymptotics for systems with @xmath53,@xcite it is possible that the exponent @xmath26 for @xmath152 coulombic systems is exact , even though there is no experimental evidence to support this conclusion . the analysis of the self - consistent equations of motion ( [ eq : fkevol ] ) - ( [ eq : rhonewevol ] ) suggests that there is a new region in the ( n , d ) phase diagram ( the region labeled ir in figure 1 ) , in which the large - t asymptotics of the density decay is determined by long - range forces . the annihilation initally depletes positively charged region of negative particles and vice versa , and then the decay rate is determined by the speed of particle drift from such regions . again , our large - t asymptotics here agrees with the `` unpenetrable domain '' theory of ispolatov and krapivsky , although their model predicts different boundaries of the ir region in the ( n , d ) phase space ( @xmath153 is the upper boundary of the ir region in the self - consistent model , and @xmath154 is the upper boundary of the ir region in the `` unpenetrable domain model '' ; the lower boundary in both theories is the coulombic line @xmath24 ) . the self - consistent theory also predicts a crossover from diffusion - dominated decay to the lri - dominated decay at large times for the systems in this region . because the self - consistent model is a semi - mean - field approximation ( it completely neglects particle density fluctuations and only takes into account the concerved charge density fluctuations ) , it should be considered only as a first step . a systematic perturbative analysis of equations ( [ eq : rhoevol ] ) - ( [ eq : fevol ] ) around our self - consistent solution is needed to assess the role of left out number density fluctuations and noise.@xcite the proposed self - consistent model , its somewhat uncontrolled approximations notwithstanding , represents an important tool in qualitative analysis of dynamic processes in two - component systems with one conserved and one non - conserved variable . it predicts new annihilation behavior ( ir regime ) and new crossovers between diffusion - driven and lri - driven decay regions , reproduces all known results for the annihilation problem in special limits , and can be used to systematically study the role of initial conditions in such processes . by coulombic , we mean such a lri that its potential obeys poisson s equation in d - dimensional system . this transforms to a relationship between system dimensionality d and lr force power exponent n : @xmath24 . k. lindenberg , p. argyrakis and r. kopelman , the hierarchies of nonclassical regimes for diffusion - limited binary reactions . in : fluctuations and order : the new sysnthesis , springer - verlag , 1996 , and references therein . phase diagram of the annihilation - diffusion reaction with long - range forces . fr - forbidden region ( below coulombic line ) . ir - intermediate region - large-@xmath4 asymptotics is determined by lri . fd - fluctuation - dominated region - large-@xmath4 asymptotics is determined by diffusion and initial fluctuations . mf - mean - field region - large-@xmath4 asymptotics is determined by the kinetic - rate equation . | we introduce coarse - grained hydrodynamic equations of motion for diffusion - annihilation system with a power - law long - range interaction . by taking into account fluctuations of the conserved order parameter - charge density - we derive an analytically solvable approximation for the nonconserved order parameter - total particle density . asymptotic solutions are obtained for the case of random gaussian initial conditions and for system dimensionality @xmath0 . large - t , intermediate - t and small - t asymptotics were calculated and compared with existing scaling theories , exact results and simulation data . |
1509.02379 | in student laboratories there is a constant demand for simple and cost - effective laboratory equipment to illustrate modern physics phenomena . in the area of nuclear or particle physics , radiation detectors can be quite expensive . commercial detectors also do not offer as extensive learning factors as the `` do it yourself '' equipment does . in this article we discuss how a gaseous proportional counter can be built and used to acquire @xmath0- and @xmath1-ray spectra from radioactive sources . a gaseous proportional counter @xcite operates with the same principle as an ionization chamber @xcite with the additional feature of gas amplification . a schematic drawing of a simple proportional counter is shown in fig.[fig01 ] . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] the radial electric field between the cathode and the anode is generated by applying positive high voltage ( hv ) to the anode . a photon or a charged particle that enters the chamber , ionizes the gas and the electrons ( ions ) move towards to the anode ( cathode ) and induce an electric current . the electric field strength in a cylindrical detector can be approximated by @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the applied potential , @xmath4 is the inner radius of the cathode tube , and @xmath5 is the outer radius of the anode wire . if the applied voltage is high enough , a sufficiently strong electric field of around @xmath6 kv / cm will be generated close to the anode wire and secondary ionization and townsend avalanches will occur in this region.@xcite this process is commonly referred to as gas amplification . figure [ fig02 ] illustrates this process . it shows the result of a simulation of our detector using garfield@xmath7,@xcite a toolkit for simulation of gas and semi - conductor based particle detectors . the path of the drifting electron that results from the ionizing process is shown in white . close to the anode ( @xmath8 ) the townsend avalanche ignites . the positive ions that drift towards the cathode are shown in orange . the term `` proportional '' indicates that the total number of electron - ion pairs is proportional to the number of primary electron - ion pairs created by the incident radiation . the energy of the incident radiation can only be measured if exactly one avalanche occurs per primary electron - ion pair . a special gas mixture , mainly consisting of a noble gas , is used for optimal performance . noble gasses can be excited and emit photons that can release electrons from the detector material through the photoelectric effect . these electrons cause additional avalanches that distort the primary signal . to suppress such spurious pulses , some molecular anti - quenching gas , such as co@xmath9 or methane , is added . the avalanche electrons drift to the anode rather quickly ( @xmath10 ns ) compared to the much slower positive ions ( @xmath11 @xmath12s ) . this leads to a fast rise of the signal caused by the electrons and a much slower rise caused by the ions . the amount of the induced charge by the electrons is very small compared to the amount induced by the ions.@xcite if a very high voltage is applied to the proportional counter it operates as a geiger - mller counter . in this regime , each primary electron - ion pair will not only create an avalanche but also high - energetic photons that are emitted by excited atoms . this causes a full electric discharge that can be easily processed with simple electronics . however , the proportional character of the detector signal is lost . for a more detailed introduction into gaseous proportional counters we refer the reader to the literature@xcite and references therein . this article is organized as follows . section [ sec : assembly ] describes the assembly of the proportional counter . in section [ sec : setup ] , the experimental setup and the preparations and testing procedures are discussed . section [ sec : electrocalib ] describes the calibration procedure . in section [ sec : spectra ] , the spectra obtained with two radioactive sources are presented . finally , the operation region of the proportional counter is probed and discussed in section [ sec : hvscan ] . our conclusions are presented in section [ sec : conclusions ] . this article has two educational components . the first component is the mechanical construction and setup of the detector and the electronics , described in sections [ sec : assembly]-[sec : electrocalib ] . the second component is the analysis of spectral data recorded with this detector , covered in sections [ sec : spectra ] and [ sec : hvscan ] . with this publication , we specifically concentrate on the detector itself . operational equipment , such as the hv - supply , the oscilloscope , and the amplifier , are assumed to be available to the reader . these devices can be of the `` do it yourself '' type as well , but a detailed description of these would go beyond the scope of this publication . the interested reader is referred to publications@xcite or websites specialized on these topics . the motivation for a radiation detector made of an aluminium beverage can is to build a properly working device at minimal costs . similar approaches have been proposed in the past@xcite but have become partially impracticable due to the availability of suggested parts and the crude data quality these devices offer . our approach follows the design of moljk and drever,@xcite but uses materials that are available in today s society . in addition , our design significantly improves the performance of the device . a good option for a cheap conducting cathode tube is a conventional aluminium beverage can.@xcite the wall thickness is thin enough for low energetic @xmath1- and @xmath0-rays to enter the gas volume and no additional _ entrance - window _ , as used by moljk and drever,@xcite is needed for operation . this is illustrated in fig.[fig03 ] which shows the ratio of the transmitted photon intensity @xmath13 after passing through detector materials and the incident photon intensity @xmath14 as function of photon energy . the black curve shows the results of absorption in the thin aluminium can wall and the red curve the absorption in 6 cm of argon gas . multiplying these two curves gives an rough estimate of the detector efficiency . the photon energies of interest are between 5 and 60 kev . these energies are high enough to enter the detector through the can wall and low enough for some of the photons to be absorbed in the gas . the parts used for our assembly are listed in table [ tab01 ] . our detector was designed and built from scratch without the use of prefabricated components . the beverage can was carefully opened from the top side with a hole saw . a small area on the outside of the can was roughened with sandpaper to expose the bare aluminium . it is recommended to remove the polymer coating inside the can for better detector performance . however , in our case the coating was not removed . acrylglass covers were used as end - caps of the can . holes for the anode wire and the gas supply were drilled in the bottom side of the can and in the acrylglass covers . the diameter of the holes were chosen to be of the size of the nylon screws , m5 for the anode holes and m8 for the gas supply holes . another hole was drilled into the can wall close to the opening to attach a firm ground connection for the cathode cable . the central cores of the the nylon screws were removed to hold the brass tubes that support the anode wire and the gas supply lines . the diameters of the holes drilled into the m5 and m8 screws were 1.2 mm and 3 mm , respectively . all components were cleaned using ethanol in an ultrasonic bath for about 3 minutes . lc amount & part ' '' '' ' '' '' + 1 & aluminium beverage can ' '' '' + & ( empty , length 168 mm , 67 mm , + & wall thickness 0.19 mm ) + 1 & low voltage cable + & strand ( @xmath15 mm ) + 1 & high voltage ( hv- ) connector + 1 & low voltage cable ( @xmath16 mm ) + & to connect cathode to the ground + & of the hv - connector + 2 & nylon screws and nuts ( m5 size ) + 2 & pieces of acrylglass ( @xmath17 bottom of can ) + 1 set & two part epoxy adhesives + 2 & nylon screws and nuts ( m8 size ) + 4 & metal rods ( threaded , @xmath18 length of can ) + 12 & nuts ( fitting the metal rods ) + 1 & mini banana plug and socket + & with screw hole + 1 & piece of rubber sheet ( of can ) + 1 & strip of copper tape + 2 @xmath19 4cm&brass tube ( inner @xmath20 mm ) to hold the anode ' '' '' + the components were assembled as shown in figs . [ fig01 ] and [ fig04 ] . the nylon screws used to hold the gas supply lines were put in place first . another nylon screw to hold the anode wire was fixed to the bottom of the can . this provides electrical insulation for the brass tube that supports the anode wire and keeps the anode wire centered inside the can . our experience has shown that it is best to first put the anode wire carefully through the brass tube and then solder the brass tube to the hv - connector . the thin anode wire was obtained by taking a single strand from a conventional head - phone cable . the drawback of this approach is a larger wire diameter and uneven fabrication compared to e.g. professional beryllium - copper wires with a diameter of 50 @xmath12 m or less . the effect of the thicker wire can be compensated with higher operational voltages . the can was closed and tightened after pulling the wire carefully through the brass tube at the opposite end . rubber was used between the can and the acrylic end - caps . since the rubber might not be sufficiently gas - tight , two part epoxy adhesives was applied to the end - caps to ensure gas - tightness . the detector was gas tight 24 h after the application of the epoxy . the anode wire was soldered to the brass tube on the bottom of the can after straightening it carefully and the screw - on socket for the cathode cable was installed . the gas supply tubes were connected and all possible areas of gas leakage were sealed with epoxy adhesive . to connect the cathode , a low voltage cable , @xmath16 mm , was soldered to the metal casing of the hv - connector . a mini banana plug was attached to the other end of the cable to connect it to the socket attached to the can wall . these cables are visible in the pictures in fig . [ fig04 ] . in the left picture the red high voltage connection is visible on the right - hand side . on the left - hand side of the right picture , the black cable providing the ground connection to the cathode is visible . discharge can occur if a non - hv rated cable is used for the anode connection since most non - hv rated cables are only rated up to 500 v and a discharge between hv and ground can occur above that limit . in our original setup this happened immediately after reaching 600 v. we decided to remove the anode cable and solder the hv - connector directly onto the anode wire outlet , as can be seen in the picture on the right hand side of fig . [ fig04 ] . this also reduces the noise level and increases the simplicity of the detector . the quality of the cathode cable does not impact to the operation of the detector . the detector was flushed over - night with a p10 gas mixture ( ar 90 % / methane 10 % ) to remove oxygen , which is highly electronegative and captures some of the primary electrons from the ionization process . even though some electrons will reach the avalanche region close to the anode , the loss of primary electrons would result in a loss of the proportional character of the counter . the gas flow during the night was set to @xmath21 ml / min . the gas outlet of the detector is either vented into the atmosphere or connected to a gas - recycling circuit , if available . additional beverage can detectors can be connecting in series , but the flushing - time will increase with each added device . if the gas is vented into the atmosphere , the gas outlet tube should be at least a couple of centimeters long to prevent back - flow diffusion . for the measurement an analog oscilloscope ( hp cos 6100 , 100 mhz ) , a pre - amplifier ( ortec pre amp 142 ih ) , a linear spectrum amplifier ( ortec 855 dual spec amp ) , a pulse generator ( bnc pulse generator model bl-2 ) , a high voltage supply ( @xmath22 silena milano ) , and a multi - channel - analyzer ( pocket mca , amptek ) were used . the experimental setup is shown schematically in fig.[fig05 ] . the ortec pre - amplifier uses capacitive decoupling to separate the signal from the hv . if the pre - amplifier does not have an integrated capacitive decoupling of hv and signal it is easy to build a separate decoupling box using the circuit shown in fig.[fig06 ] . the linear amplifier provided gains between 5 and 1200 . the pulse generator was used to calibrate the electronics . the hv supply can provide up to @xmath23 kv with a current limit of 1 ma . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] , scaledwidth=35.0% ] the signal from the linear amplifier was read out in parallel by the analog oscilloscope and the multi - channel - analyzer which was interfaced with a computer . an essential part of the operational preparations is noise reduction . standard aluminium kitchen foil proved to be highly effective for shielding . for the noise study , the hv was slowly ramped up to values well above 1 kv , while the gas flow through the detector was kept constant at @xmath24 ml / min of p10 . the noise was observed with the oscilloscope and aluminium foil was wrapped around the end - caps of the detector . a firm contact to the cathode ( ground ) was obtained with self - adhesive conducting copper - tape . this reduced the noise to amplitudes below 100 mv for a gain of 120 . we used @xmath25fe and @xmath26am isotopes to test the detector . the latter can be obtained from commercial ionizing smoke detectors.@xcite for our measurements , the sources were put on top of the detector . a simple lead collimator can be used to reduce signal pileup@xcite if the source activity is too high . an example of a typical detector signal is shown in fig.[fig07 ] . fe source was put in front of the detector . the horizontal and vertical scales are 50 @xmath12s / division and 100 mv / division , respectively . the shaping time and gain of the amplifier used in this measurement was 3 @xmath12s and 120 , respectively . [ fig07],scaledwidth=32.0% ] the analysis of the measured data can be done manually , with spreadsheet programs , or with scientific software such as root , a freely available object - oriented data analysis framework@xcite that was used in our case . to calibrate the electronics a negative test signal from the pulse generator was sent to the pre - amplifier and the oscilloscope . the test signal was a tail pulse with a steep falling edge and a slow rise . a negative pulse was used since the signal from the anode wire of the proportional counter is negative . the amplitude of the test pulse was measured with the oscilloscope . the response of the electronic chain was recorded with the mca . a gain factor of 120 was used during the calibration process . during the electronics calibrations , the detector was connected to the pre - amplifier and the bias voltage was set to zero . for accurate calibrations , all devices that are used for the measurements should be connected and turned on . the response of the electronics to test pulses with amplitudes in the order of 100 mv was measured and the results are shown in fig.[fig08 ] . fig.[fig08 ] ( bottom ) shows the mca channel histograms for the different test pulses . the test capacitance of 1 pf was taken into account to calculate the injected charge @xmath27 , shown by the data points in fig.[fig08 ] ( top ) . a linear function was used to fit the data and obtain the following relation between the charge @xmath28 and the mca channel number : , scaledwidth=45.0% ] @xmath29 where @xmath30 pc / channel and @xmath31 pc . the uncertainty in the calibration constants is dominated by the uncertainty in the measurement of amplitude of the test pulse , estimated by eye to be 5 mv . this calibration will be used to probe the detectors operational region . the bias voltage was ramped up until a clear signal was seen on the oscilloscope when the @xmath26am source was placed on top of the detector . the hv and the amplifier gain were adjusted to observe the whole spectrum of @xmath26am over the full range of the mca . at a voltage of @xmath32 kv and a gain of @xmath33 , the spectra of both isotopes were recorded . in addition , a background spectrum was acquired to be able to do a background subtraction.@xcite the energy spectra obtained with @xmath25fe and @xmath26am are shown in figs . [ fig09 ] and [ fig10 ] , respectively . for each spectrum , the most prominent peaks were used to calibrate the energy scale of the measurement . from common isotope tables@xcite and the table of nuclides@xcite it is well known that the decay of @xmath25fe is accompanied by prominent @xmath0-ray emissions originating from the relaxation process of the @xmath25mn daughter . these @xmath0-ray emissions , with an energy of @xmath34 kev ( 16.2 % , @xmath35 ) , @xmath36 kev ( 8.1 % , @xmath37 ) and @xmath38 kev ( 2.9 % , @xmath39 ) , are the dominating spectrum of @xmath25fe . the energy resolution @xcite of the detector is not good enough to separate these emissions@xcite due to the large gas volume of the can and the in - homogeneity of the anode wire that influences the local electric field . an attempt was made to fit a double gaussian distribution function to the visible peak , as shown in fig.[fig09 ] . the two almost not distinguishable @xmath40 emissions are represented by fit number 2 and the @xmath41 emissions by fit number 3 . the intensity ratio of the sum of @xmath39 and @xmath42 is approximately 12% . this ratio and a similar width of the two gaussian distributions were used to constrain the fit . the resulting double gaussian fit converged with a @xmath43 value of 1.29 . [ fig09],scaledwidth=45.0% ] the most prominent escape peak of argon ( lowered by @xmath44 kev ; peak 1 in fig.[fig09 ] ) was also fitted with a gaussian function . escape peaks are due to secondary @xmath0-ray emissions , originating from the detector gas , that escape from the detector . in the energy spectrum obtained with @xmath26am , shown in fig.[fig10 ] , the most prominent emission line is the @xmath45 kev line due to a transition in @xmath46np ( peak 8 in fig.[fig10 ] . ) the peak was fitted with a single gaussian function . am . [ fig10],scaledwidth=45.0% ] using those known peaks of @xmath25fe and @xmath26am an energy calibration was performed with the result shown in fig.[fig11 ] . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] four other visible peaks of the @xmath26am spectrum , between channel 50 and 220 in fig.[fig10 ] , were fit with gaussian distributions and an exponential background . the details of the peaks used for the energy calibration as well as details of the four other `` unknown '' peaks in the @xmath26am spectrum are listed in table [ tab02 ] . .details of the peaks observed in the spectra obtained with @xmath25fe and @xmath26am . peaks are numbered with increasing energy . the systematic and statistical uncertainties are added in quadrature.[tab02 ] [ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ] using the calibration function shown in fig.[fig11 ] , the energies and widths of the `` unknown '' peaks were determined . apart from the statistical uncertainties , systematic uncertainties were also taken into account and standard textbook error propagation techniques were used.@xcite systematic errors are associated with the hv power supply , the amplification chain , and the mca . the instability of the silena milano power supply was estimated to be 1 v. the corresponding uncertainty in terms of mca channels is estimated by using the result of the operation region test ( see fig . [ fig12 ] ) . the uncertainties of the pre - amplifier and the spectrum amplifier were taken from the specification sheet , each contributing a integral nonlinearity of @xmath47 . the mca has a differential nonlinearity of 0.6 % and an integrated nonlinearity of 0.02 % . errors resulting from pressure and temperature changes of the environment during the measurement as well as uncertainties due to charge - up and ion build - up were not studied . the total systematic uncertainty was added to the statistical uncertainty by quadrature and shown in table [ tab02 ] . peaks 1 , 2 , 3 and 8 , listed in table [ tab02 ] , were used to obtain the energy calibration . peak number 1 with an energy resolution of 50 % is not well pronounced due to the large gas volume and the non - ideal background subtraction . the characteristic @xmath25fe peak was fit with a double gaussian distribution ( peaks 2 and 3 ) . the energy resolution is @xmath48 27 % for the 5.9 kev emission and @xmath48 36 % for the 6.49 kev emission . peak 8 is the characteristic @xmath26am peak at 59.54 kev which has an energy resolution of about 9 % . this peak shows a non - gaussian tail on the left side , mostly caused by photo - electrons escaping the gas volume before losing all their energy in ionizing collisions . peaks 5 and 7 are well - pronounced peaks with similar energy resolutions of about 16 % and about 12 % , respectively . peak 7 appears to correspond to the @xmath49 kev transition in @xmath46np with an intensity of 2.4 % . the origin of peak number 5 is less clear . the closest emission found in radiation tables of the @xmath26am @xcite is the @xmath50 kev @xmath0-ray emission from the @xmath51 shell in @xmath46np with an intensity of 5.7 % . other @xmath0-ray emissions from the @xmath52 shells also contribute . a weighted average of those suggests a peak centroid of 17.48 which is well below one standard deviation off our measured peak . for peak number 6 no direct candidate was found . peak 6 might be the result of overlapping @xmath0-ray emissions from the @xmath53 shells . the weighted centroid of the @xmath53 shells @xmath0-ray emissions suggests a peak at 21.04 kev that is compatible with our measured peak . another @xmath0-ray emission from @xmath54 at 13.94 kev with an intensity of 9.6 % is expected . our recorded spectrum reveals a possible peak around 10 kev ( peak 4 ) , but no clear evidence is found without applying a thorough background subtraction . it should be mentioned that the detection efficiencies for the transitions in the energy spectra are energy dependent . as shown in fig.[fig03 ] , low - energy photons have a higher attenuation in the aluminium can wall than high - energy photons . the effect of attenuation can be corrected using the efficiency distribution shown in fig.[fig03 ] . to reveal the full potential of the detector , the operational hv region was scanned in order to understand its proportionality behavior and measure the gas gain . the idea was to measure the prominent characteristic peaks of the two isotopes over the full operational voltage range available.@xcite the location of the peaks observed with the mca were converted into induced charge on the anode wire , using the electronics calibration function shown in fig.[fig08 ] . the measurement was started with @xmath25fe and the maximum gain of the amplification system ( factor 1200 ) . the bias voltage was set to the minimum level of @xmath55 kv at which a clear signal could still be seen with the oscilloscope and recorded at the lower end of the mca scale . a recording time of @xmath48 200 s was sufficient to acquire just enough statistics to resolve the characteristic peaks and short enough to finish the measurement in reasonable time . we recorded data for voltage steps of 50 to 100 v until we reached the minimum gain of the amplification chain and the upper limit of the mca range . next , @xmath26am was used with its characteristic @xmath1-ray emission at a ten times higher energy than the characteristic @xmath25fe @xmath0-ray emission . this allowed us not only to extend the scan of the operational range but also to show the proportional character of the detector . the observed charge curve obtained with @xmath26am should be shifted upwards and be parallel to the curve obtained with @xmath25fe . again , spectra were recorded in steps of 50 or 100 v over the whole amplification range . the measurement started with the maximum gain and a bias voltage of @xmath56 kv , at which one still was able to identify the peak signal on the oscilloscope . for all the recorded spectra the characteristic peaks and their details were extracted . the centroids of the peaks were converted into total charge or the number readout electrons using the measured electronics calibration function . these results are shown in fig.[fig12 ] . exponential fits were carried out for both data sets with the following function . fe and @xmath26am . error bars include statistical and systematic uncertainties.[fig12],scaledwidth=44.0% ] @xmath57 the measured slope was @xmath58 v@xmath59 and the offset was for the @xmath25fe ( @xmath26am ) data . in addition to the uncertainties already discussed , the errors include the effect of a 5 v uncertainty of the manual setup of the hv power supply . the proportional character of the detector is consistent with the data shown in fig.[fig12 ] . plotted on a logarithmic scale , the proportional operational region is the linear part of the curves . the curves shown in fig.[fig12 ] . are almost parallel and shifted by a factor close to 10 , which is expected as the characteristic isotope peaks are a factor of 10 apart in terms of energy . with about 26 ev needed to create an electron - ion pair in argon gas , we can estimate the gas multiplication factor knowing the energy of the incident @xmath0- or @xmath1-rays . we assumed that all the energy was absorbed by the gas , which is not totally true for the 59.54 kev @xmath1-ray from @xmath26am . the gas multiplication factor @xmath60 was calculated by using the formula , @xmath61 where @xmath28 is the collected charge , @xmath62 is the energy of the incident radiation , and @xmath63 is the energy required to create an electron - ion pair . the 5.9 kev @xmath0-ray of @xmath25fe produces 227 electron - ion pairs and the 59.54 kev @xmath1-ray of @xmath26am produces 2,290 electron - ion pairs . the gas multiplication factors are shown in fig.[fig13 ] and are in satisfactory agreement with theoretical predictions . versus bias voltage . the solid line shows the theoretical prediction obtained using the diethorn formula.@xcite[fig13],scaledwidth=44.0% ] the predictions were obtained using the diethorn formula,@xcite @xmath64,\ ] ] where @xmath65 is the bias voltage , @xmath5 and @xmath4 are the anode and cathode radii , and @xmath66 the gas pressure . the parameters @xmath67 and @xmath68 depend on the properties of the gas mixture.@xcite the geiger - mller region is unfortunately not accessible due to the argon - methane gas mixture that was used . even though the data recording was stopped at 3 kv , the hv was ramped up to 4.7 kv out of curiosity . constant discharge was observed , including a glow around the anode wire , and sparks within the gas volume were observed through the acrylglass end - cap window . afterwards , the detector was not able to measure any radiation even at voltages around 1.4 kv . after flushing the detector over night it returned to a state , able to detect radiation at the nominal level . recombination of positive ions at the cathode might have been slowed down by the polymer coating that was not removed . plasma discharge , which , produces free radicals that attach to the anode - wire , result in detector aging . we demonstrated that it is relatively easy and inexpensive to build a fully functioning gaseous proportional counter for measuring radioactive @xmath0- and @xmath1-ray emissions . building such a device offers great educational benefits for students at all levels . not only do the students learn how to build an inexpensive proportional counter from scratch , they also are introduced to high voltage systems and electronic readout devices used in actual research . in addition to the experimental techniques , students may also gain knowledge in analyzing the recorded data and discussing experimental uncertainties . we thank the staff of the detector laboratory of helsinki institute of physics and university of helsinki for their valuable help and discussions , i.e. eija tuominen , jouni heino , rauno lauhakangas and raimo turpeinen . we also thank ismo koponen and michael albrow for reading our manuscript . j.h . hubbell and s.m . seltzer , `` tables of x - ray mass attenuation coefficients and mass energy - absorption coefficients ( version 1.4 ) , '' http://physics.nist.gov/xaamdi ( 2014 , september 11 ) , national institute of standards and technology , gaithersburg , md . | the gaseous proportional counter is a device that can be used to detect ionizing radiation . these devices can be as simple as a cylindrical cathode and a very thin anode wire centered along its axis . by applying a high voltage , a strong electric field is generated close to the anode wire . ion - pairs , generated by passing ionizing radiation , create avalanches once they drift into the strong electric field region near the anode . the electrical charges created by the avalanche generate an observable signal which is proportional to the energy loss of the incoming radiation . we discuss the construction of such a device . our detector was built from an ordinary aluminium beverage can and uses a common electric wire strand as the anode . the construction of this detector offers students at universities or technically oriented high schools a detailed understanding of the design and operation of gaseous radiation detectors . the equipment required to complete the project should be available at most institutions . |
1004.4110 | quantum information processes in a noisy environment are conveniently described in terms of _ quantum channels _ , that is , linear , trace preserving , completely positive maps on the set of quantum states @xcite . the problem of discriminating quantum channels is of great interest . for instance , knowing the correct noise model might provide useful information to devise efficient error - correcting strategies , both in the fields of quantum communication and quantum computation . it is therefore natural to consider _ distances _ between quantum channels , that is to say , we would like to quantify how similarly two channels @xmath0 and @xmath1 act on quantum states , or in other words to determine if there are input states @xmath2 on which the two channels produce output states @xmath3 and @xmath4 that are distinguishable . the trace norm of @xmath5 represents how well @xmath6 and @xmath7 can be distinguished by a measurement @xcite : the more orthogonal two quantum states are , the easier it is to discriminate them . the trace distance of two quantum channels is then obtained after maximizing the trace norm of @xmath5 over the input state @xmath2 . however , the trace norm is not a good measure of the distance between quantum channels . indeed , in general the presence in the input state of entanglement with an ancillary system can help discriminating quantum channels @xcite . this fact is captured by the _ diamond norm _ @xcite : the trace distance between the overall output states ( including the ancillary system ) is optimized over all possible input states , including those entangled . the computation of the diamond norm is not known to be straightforward and only a limited number of algorithms have been proposed @xcite , based on complicated semidefinite programming or convex optimization . on the other hand , analytical solutions are limited to special classes of channels @xcite . in this paper , we propose a simple and easily parallelizable monte - carlo algorithm based on the fano representation of quantum states and quantum operations . we show that our algorithm provides reliable results for the case , most significant for present - day implementations of quantum information processing , of single - qubit quantum channels . furthermore , in the fano representation quantum operations are described by affine maps whose matrix elements have precise physical meaning : they are directly related to the evolution of the expectation values of the system s polarization measurements @xcite . the paper is organized as follows . after reviewing in sec . [ sec : dnorm ] basic definitions of the distance between quantum channels , we discuss in sec . [ sec : methods ] two numerical monte - carlo strategies for computing the diamond norm . the first one is based on the kitaev s characterization of the diamond norm . the second one is based on the fano representation of quantum states and quantum operations . the two methods are compared in sec . [ sec:1qchannels ] for a few physically significant single - qubit quantum channels . finally , our conclusions are drawn in sec . [ sec : conclusions ] . we consider the following problem : given two quantum channels @xmath0 and @xmath1 , and a single channel use , chosen uniformly at random from @xmath8 , we wish to maximize the probability of correctly identifying the quantum channel . it seems natural to reformulate the optimization problem into the problem of finding an input state ( density matrix ) @xmath2 in the hilbert space @xmath9 such that the error probability in the discrimination of the output states @xmath10 and @xmath11 is minimal . in this case , the minimal error probability reads @xmath12 where @xmath13 denotes the trace norm . the superoperator trace distance @xmath14 is , however , not a good definition of the distance between two quantum operations . the point is that in general it is possible to exploit quantum entanglement to increase the distinguishability of two quantum channels . in this case , an ancillary hilbert space @xmath15 is introduced , the input state @xmath16 is a density matrix in @xmath17 , and the quantum operations are trivially extended to @xmath15 . that is to say , the output states to discriminate are @xmath18 and @xmath19 , where @xmath20 is the identity map acting on @xmath15 . the minimal error probability reads @xmath21 where @xmath22 denotes the diamond norm of @xmath23 . it is clear from definition ( [ eq : diamondnorm ] ) that @xmath24 and therefore @xmath25 , so that it can be convenient to use an ancillary system to better discriminate two quantum operations after a single channel use . the two quantum channels @xmath0 and @xmath1 become perfectly distinguishable ( @xmath26 ) when their diamond distance @xmath27 . it turns out that the diamond norm does not depend on @xmath15 , provided @xmath28 @xcite . due to the convexity of the trace norm , it can be shown that the maximum in both eqs . ( [ eq : tracenorm ] ) and ( [ eq : diamondnorm ] ) is achieved for pure input states @xcite . kitaev provided a different equivalent characterization of the diamond norm , see , e.g. , @xcite . any superoperator ( not necessarily completely positive ) @xmath29 , with @xmath30 space of linear operators mapping @xmath9 to itself , can be expressed as @xmath31 where @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 linear operators from @xmath9 to @xmath35 , with @xmath36 auxiliary hilbert space and @xmath37 $ ] . it is then possible to define completely positive superoperators @xmath38 : @xmath39 note that the space @xmath40 is traced out in the definition of @xmath41 , @xmath42 , rather than the space @xmath43 . finally , it turns out that @xcite @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the maximum output fidelity of @xmath41 and @xmath42 , defined as @xmath46 , \label{eq : dnormkitaev}\ ] ] where @xmath47 are density matrices in @xmath9 , and the fidelity @xmath48 is defined as @xmath49 note that @xmath41 , @xmath42 are not density matrices : the conditions @xmath50 , @xmath51 are not satisfied . we numerically compute the distance ( induced by the diamond norm ) between two quantum channels @xmath0 and @xmath1 using two monte - carlo algorithms . the first one is based on the direct computation of @xmath52 , with the output states @xmath53 and @xmath54 in eq . ( [ eq : diamondnorm ] ) computed from @xmath16 taking advantage of the fano representation of quantum states and quantum operations . the second monte - carlo algorithm uses the kitaev s representation of the diamond norm to compute the maximum output fidelity @xmath55 of eq . ( [ eq : dnormkitaev ] ) . in the following , we will refer to the two above monte - carlo algorithms as f - algorithm and k - algorithm , respectively . for the sake of simplicity we will confine ourselves to one - qubit quantum channels , even though the two algorithms can be easily formulated for two- or many - qubit channels . in this section we describe the f - algorithm , which we will use to directly compute the diamond norm ( [ eq : diamondnorm ] ) , with the maximum taken over a large number of randomly chosen input states @xmath16 . a convexity argument shows that it is sufficient to optimize over pure input states @xmath56 @xcite . for one - qubit channels , it is enough to add a single ancillary qubit when computing the diamond norm @xcite . therefore , we can write @xmath57 with @xmath58 where the angles @xmath59 $ ] and the phase @xmath60 $ ] . hence , the maximization in the diamond norm is over the 6 real parameters @xmath61 , and @xmath62 . of course , the number of parameters can be reduced for specific channels when there are symmetries . let @xmath0 and @xmath1 denote the two single - qubit superoperators we would like to distinguish . the output states @xmath63 and @xmath64 can be conveniently computed using the fano representation . any two - qubit state can be written in the fano form as follows @xcite : @xmath65 where @xmath66 , @xmath67 , and @xmath68 are the pauli matrices , @xmath69 , and @xmath70 . \label{eq : ralphabeta}\ ] ] note that the normalization condition @xmath71 implies @xmath72 . moreover , the coefficients @xmath73 are real due to the hermicity of @xmath16 . ( [ eq : fanoform ] ) and ( [ eq : ralphabeta ] ) allow us to go from the standard representation for the density matrix ( in the latexmath:[$\{|0\rangle\equiv |00\rangle , vice versa . it is convenient to write the coefficients @xmath73 as a column vector , @xmath75^t . \end{array}\ ] ] then the quantum operations @xmath76 and @xmath77 map , in the fano representation , @xmath78 into @xmath79 and @xmath80 , respectively , where @xmath81 and @xmath82 are affine transformation matrices . such matrices have a simple block structure : @xmath83 with @xmath84 and @xmath85 @xmath86 affine transformation matrices corresponding to the quantum operations @xmath87 and @xmath88 ( of course , @xmath84 is the identity matrix ) . matrices @xmath85 directly determines the transformation , induced by @xmath88 , of the single - qubit bloch - sphere coordinates @xmath89 . given the fano representation for a single qubit , @xmath90 , then @xmath91^t$ ] and @xmath92 . we point out that , while one could compute @xmath93 from the kraus representation of the superoperator @xmath94 , the advantage of the fano representation is that the matrix elements of @xmath95 are directly related to the transformation of the expectation values of the system s polarization measurements @xcite . finally , we compute the trace distance between @xmath96 and @xmath97 as @xmath98 where @xmath99 are the eigenvalues of @xmath100 . we consider a special and unnormalized state in the extended hilbert space @xmath17 : @xmath101 where @xmath102 and @xmath103 , @xmath104 are orthonormal bases for @xmath15 , @xmath9 . the state @xmath105 is , up to a normalization factor , a maximally entangled state in @xmath106 . we define an operator @xmath107 on @xmath106 : @xmath108 where @xmath109 is the difference of two quantum operations but is not a quantum operation itself . that is , @xmath23 is linear but not trace preserving and completely positive . using the singular value decomposition of @xmath107 , we can write @xmath110 where @xmath111 is the rank of @xmath107 and @xmath112 , @xmath113 are vectors in @xmath106 . the operator @xmath107 completely specifies @xmath23 and can be exploited to express @xmath23 as @xmath114 the operators @xmath115 and @xmath116 can be derived by generalizing the construction of the operator - sum representation for quantum operations ( see , for instance , sec . 8.2.4 in ref . @xcite ) . given a generic state @xmath117 in @xmath9 , we define a corresponding state in @xmath15 : @xmath118 . next , we define @xmath119 for instance , in the single - qubit case @xmath120^t$ ] and we obtain @xmath121.\ ] ] similarly , we define @xmath122 finally , it can be checked that with the above defined operators @xmath115 , @xmath116 we can express @xmath23 by means of eq . ( [ eq : aibisum ] ) . we can now give explicit expressions for @xmath41 and @xmath42 in eq . ( [ eq : psiapsib ] ) : @xmath123_{ij}=\sum_{\alpha , m , n } a^{(i)}_{\alpha m } x_{mn } a^{(j)\star}_{\alpha n},\ ] ] @xmath124_{ij}=\sum_{\alpha , m , n } b^{(i)}_{\alpha m } x_{mn } b^{(j)\star}_{\alpha n},\ ] ] with @xmath125 . therefore , @xmath41 and @xmath42 are @xmath126 matrices . in the single - qubit case , @xmath127 and to compute the diamond norm through eq . ( [ eq : dnormkitaev ] ) we need to calculate eigenvalues and eigenvectors of matrices of size @xmath111 . a simpler but less efficient decomposition of @xmath23 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 is provided in appendix [ app : kraus2 ] . for single - qubit channels the optimization ( [ eq : dnormkitaev ] ) is over 6 real parameters , 3 for @xmath128 and 3 for @xmath129 ( for instance , the bloch - sphere coordinates of @xmath128 and @xmath129 ) . as discussed in sec . [ subsec : kmethod ] , the same number of parameters are needed in the f - method . however , the f - method has computational advantages in that only the eigenvalues of the @xmath86 matrix @xmath130 are required , while in the k - method we need to evaluate both eigenvalues and eigenvectors of matrices in general of the same size ( @xmath131 ) . moreover , the singular - values decomposition of matrix @xmath107 is needed . besides computational advantages , the f - method is physically more transparent , as it is based on affine maps , whose matrix elements have physical meaning , being directly related to the transformation of the expectation values of the system s polarization measurements @xcite . in this section , we illustrate the working of the f- and k - methods for the case , most significant for present - day implementations , of single - qubit quantum channels . we start by considering the case of pauli channels , @xmath132 for which the diamond norm can be evaluated analytically @xcite : @xmath133 this value of the diamond norm being achieved for maximally entangled input states . the pauli - channel case will serve as a testing ground for the f- and k - algorithms and help us develop a physical and geometrical intuition . let us focus on a couple of significant examples . we first consider the bit - flip and the phase - flip channels : @xmath134 with @xmath135 . we then readily obtain from eq . ( [ eq : dpauli ] ) that @xmath136 for this example , the diamond norm coincides with the trace norm , @xmath137 , and therefore has a simple geometrical interpretation : for a single qubit the trace distance between two single - qubit states is equal to the euclidean distance between them on the bloch ball @xcite . superoperators @xmath0 and @xmath1 map the bloch sphere into an ellipsoid with @xmath138 ( for the bit - flip channel ) and @xmath139 ( for the phase - flip channel ) as symmetry axis . if we call @xmath140 , @xmath141 , and @xmath142 , the initial bloch - sphere coordinates and the new coordinates after application of quantum operations @xmath0 and @xmath1 , respectively , we obtain @xmath143 the geometrical meaning of the trace norm for the present example is clear from fig . [ fig : bitphaseflip ] : the length of the line segment @xmath144 is the trace ( and the diamond ) distance @xmath145 ) . , width=264 ] as a further example , we discuss a special instance of the channels considered in ref . @xcite : @xmath146 in this case , @xmath147 the trace norm @xmath148 , as shown in fig . [ fig : sacchi ] , where @xmath149 is given by the length of the segment @xmath150 . on the other hand , the two channels @xmath0 and @xmath1 are perfectly distinguishable , as we readily obtain from eq . ( [ eq : dpauli ] ) that @xmath151 , this value being achieved by means of maximally entangled input states . therefore , in this example @xmath152 , that is , entangled input states improve the distinguishability of the two channels . ) . [ fig : sacchi],width=264 ] channels ( [ eq : sacchi ] ) are very convenient to illustrate the convergence properties of the f- and k - algorithms . let us first consider the f - algorithm . if the maximum of @xmath153 , with @xmath154 ( @xmath155 ) is taken over @xmath156 random initial conditions , then the obtained value differs from the diamond norm @xmath22 by an amount @xmath157 which must converge to zero when @xmath158 . to get convergence to @xmath22 for channels ( [ eq : sacchi ] ) it is enough to optimize over real initial conditions . numerical results , shown in fig . [ fig : test ] for a few runs , are consistent with @xmath159 . a rough argument can be used to explain the @xmath160 dependence . assuming a smooth quadratic dependence of the distance @xmath161 on the parameters for optimization [ the angles @xmath162 in ( [ eq : thetaphi ] ) , with @xmath163 $ ] , @xmath164 for @xmath16 around the value @xmath165 optimizing @xmath166 , then @xmath167 when the distance between @xmath16 and @xmath165 is of the order of @xmath168 . the number @xmath156 of randomly distributed initial conditions typically requested to get a point satisfying @xmath169 is of the order of @xmath170 , where @xmath171 is the number of parameters for optimization . therefore , @xmath172 . in the example of fig . [ fig : test ] , @xmath173 leading to @xmath174 . on the other hand , numerical data exhibit a @xmath160 dependence . this fact has a simple explanation : the maximum is achieved for bell states , which are invariant under rotations . hence , the maximum distance is obtained not on a single point but on a curve and the number @xmath156 of initial conditions requested to get a point within a trace distance smaller than @xmath168 from this curve is of the order of @xmath175 , thus leading to @xmath176 . in evaluating the diamond distance between channels ( [ eq : sacchi ] ) by means of the f - algorithm after @xmath156 randomly chosen initial conditions . three different runs are shown , together with the @xmath160 ( full line ) and @xmath177 ( dashed line ) dependences . [ fig : test],width=302 ] with regard to the k - algorithm , we have observed in the example of eq . ( [ eq : sacchi ] ) the same @xmath160 convergence to the expected asymptotic value @xmath151 . however , the cost per initial condition in the k - algorithm is much larger than in the f - algorithm , in agreement with the general discussion of sec . [ subsec : kmethod ] . furthermore , the physical meaning of the f - method is much more transparent . for instance , for the pauli channels ( [ eq : pauli ] ) the affine transformation matrix @xmath85 such that @xmath178 has a simple diagonal structure : @xmath179,\ ] ] where @xmath180 , \\ \\ ( c_y)_i=1 - 2[(q_z)_i+(q_x)_i ] , \\ \\ ( c_z)_i=1 - 2[(q_x)_i+(q_y)_i ] . \end{array}\ ] ] matrix @xmath85 simply accounts for the transformation , induced by @xmath88 , of the polarization measurements for the system qubit : @xmath181 , with @xmath182 bloch - sphere coordinates . we have checked the computational advantages of the f - method also for all the other examples discussed in this paper . for this reason in what follows we shall focus on this method only . in this section , we consider nonunital channels , that is , channels that do not preserve the identity . therefore , in contrast to the pauli channels considered in sec . [ sec : pauli ] , single - qubit nonunital channels displace the center of the bloch sphere . such channel are physically relevant in the description , for instance , of energy dissipation in open quantum systems , the simplest case being the amplitude damping channel @xcite . as a first illustrative example , we compute the distance between two channels @xmath0 and @xmath1 corresponding to displacements of the bloch sphere along the @xmath183- and @xmath184-direction @xcite . in the fano representation the affine transformation matrices @xmath85 corresponding to maps @xmath88 have a simple structure : @xmath185,\ ] ] @xmath186,\ ] ] where we have used the shorthand notation @xmath187 and @xmath188 . the two channels depend parametrically on @xmath189 $ ] . the limiting cases @xmath190 and @xmath191 correspond to @xmath192 and @xmath193 , respectively . moreover , for @xmath194 quantum operation @xmath0 maps the bloch ball onto the single point @xmath195 ; for @xmath196 the mapping operated by @xmath1 is onto the north pole of the bloch sphere , @xmath197 . the numerically computed trace distance @xmath14 is shown in fig . [ fig : dispxz ] , as a function of the parameters @xmath198 and @xmath199 . we gathered numerical evidence that for such channels the diamond distance equals the trace distance . , where @xmath0 and @xmath1 are displacement channels along the @xmath183- and @xmath184-axis of the bloch sphere . [ fig : dispxz],width=302 ] it is interesting to examine the analytical solutions for two limiting cases : ( i ) @xmath190 ( the case @xmath191 is analogous ) and ( ii ) @xmath200 . in the first case , @xmath0 maps the bloch sphere into an ellipsoid with @xmath139 as symmetry axis @xcite , while @xmath193 . the trace norm is given by the length of the line segment @xmath201 shown in fig . [ fig : blochdispxz ] ( left ) , @xmath202 in the limiting cases @xmath190 ( left ) and @xmath200 ( right ) . [ fig : blochdispxz],width=302 ] it is interesting to remark that , in contrast to the pauli channels , the optimal input state is not a maximally entangled input state . in the limiting case ( i ) the channels are strictly better discriminated by means of an appropriate separable input state , i.e. , the south pole of the bloch sphere ( see the left plot of fig . [ fig : blochdispxz ] ) ) rather than by bell states . indeed , given the maximally entangled input state @xmath203.\ ] ] the trace distance between @xmath96 and @xmath97 is then computed by means of eq . ( [ eq : tracenormxi ] ) : @xmath204 as shown in fig . [ fig : checknorm ] , @xmath205 for any @xmath206 . ( upper curve ) and @xmath153 ( lower curve ) for @xmath194 . [ fig : checknorm],width=302 ] in case ( ii ) , for any initial state @xmath2 , the bloch coordinates of @xmath6 and @xmath7 are given by @xmath207 and @xmath208 . the trace norm is given by the distance between these two points , @xmath209 [ see fig . [ fig : blochdispxz ] ( right ) ] . in this case , given an input bell state or any other two - qubit input state @xmath16 , the trace distance @xmath210 . thus , there is no advantage in using an ancillary system . as a further example , we compute the distance between the depolarizing channel @xmath0 and the nonunital channel @xmath1 corresponding to the displacement along the @xmath184-axis of the bloch sphere . the depolarizing channel belongs to the class of pauli channels ( [ eq : pauli ] ) , with @xmath211 and @xmath212 . this channel contracts the bloch sphere by a factor @xmath213 , with @xmath214 . [ fig : dispdep ] shows the numerically computed @xmath149 and @xmath22 as well as their difference @xmath215 , @xmath196 we obtain from eqs . ( [ eq : tnormdispz ] ) and ( [ eq : dnormdispz ] ) @xmath216 . a clear advantage is instead seen in another limiting case , @xmath217 , @xmath191 . the fully depolarizing channel maps each point of the bloch ball onto its center , so that the trace distance is given by the radius of the bloch sphere , @xmath218 . on the other hand , by means of eq . ( [ eq : dpauli ] ) we obtain @xmath219 . , diamond norm @xmath22 , and their difference @xmath220 ; @xmath0 is the depolarizing channel , @xmath1 the displacement along the @xmath184-axis of the bloch sphere . [ fig : dispdep],width=302 ] we have shown that the distance between two quantum channels can be conveniently computed by means of a monte - carlo algorithm based on the fano representation . the effectiveness of this algorithm is illustrated in the case , most relevant for present - day implementations of quantum information processing , of single - qubit quantum channels . a main computational advantage of this algorithms is that it is easily parallelizable . furthermore , being based on the fano representation , is enlights the physical meaning of the involved quantum channels : the matrix elements of the affine map representing a quantum channel directly account for the evolution of the expectation values of the system s polarization measurements . more generally , we believe that the fano representation provides a computationally convenient and physically trasparent representation of quantum noise . given a superoperator @xmath109 , with @xmath0 , @xmath1 quantum operations , we start from the kraus representation @xcite of @xmath0 and @xmath1 : @xmath221 and define new operators : @xmath222 where @xmath223 . note that , if @xmath224 , we set @xmath225 for @xmath226 ; vice - versa , if @xmath227 , @xmath228 for @xmath229 . it is easy to see that @xmath230 in contrast to ( [ eq : aibisum ] ) , the present decomposition of @xmath231 is simpler , in that no singular value decomposition is required , but less efficient . indeed , the maximum number of terms in ( [ eq : tildeab ] ) is twice that of decomposition ( [ eq : aibisum ] ) . this implies that , if @xmath41 , @xmath42 are expressed in terms of operators @xmath232 , @xmath233 rather than @xmath115 , @xmath116 , to evaluate @xmath234 we need to compute eigenvalues and eigenvectors of matrices of size @xmath235 . in the single - qubit case , typically @xmath236 . g. benenti , g. casati , and g. strini , _ principles of quantum computation and information _ , vol . i : basic concepts ( world scientific , singapore , 2004 ) ; vol . ii : basic tools and special topics ( world scientific , singapore , 2007 ) . | the diamond norm measures the distance between two quantum channels . from an operational vewpoint , this norm measures how well we can distinguish between two channels by applying them to input states of arbitrarily large dimensions . in this paper , we show that the diamond norm can be conveniently and in a physically transparent way computed by means of a monte - carlo algorithm based on the fano representation of quantum states and quantum operations . the effectiveness of this algorithm is illustrated for several single - qubit quantum channels . |
1002.0687 | the ultimate goal of nanotechnology is control over molecular - scale mechanical and electronic components . an oft - proposed route to this goal is the construction of components from controllable single molecules . an important class of such molecules with obvious applications is formed by those that have properties that are reversibly and bi - stably modifiable by external stimuli so - called _ molecular switches_. one example is the azobenzene molecule ( h@xmath2c@xmath3-n@xmath4n - c@xmath3h@xmath2 ) , which can be bi - stably photo - isomerized between its planar , @xmath5 symmetric _ trans _ and torsioned - twisted , @xmath6 _ cis _ conformers in both solution and gas - phase . the high yield and stability of this reaction have rendered azobenzene an archetype of molecular switch research with proposed technical applications including e.g. light - driven actuators@xcite and information storage media@xcite . perspective views of _ trans _ and _ cis _ azobenzene and tba , together with an illustration of the diazo - bridge bond length @xmath7 and the dihedral cnnc angle @xmath8 . the latter is defined as the smallest angle between two planes spanned by the @xmath1 bridge and @xmath9c@xmath9n@xmath9 and @xmath9n@xmath9c@xmath9 bonds to the first and second phenyl - ring , respectively . the c atoms of the phenyl - rings have been darkened to allow easier distinction of azobenzene backbone and functional butyl groups in tba . ] for many such applications , switching of molecules at solid interfaces adsorbed at metal surfaces , for example is of particular interest . unfortunately however , the switching properties of azobenzene have proven highly sensitive to the adsorbate - substrate interaction : even at nearly chemically inert close - packed noble metal surfaces , switching of surface - adsorbed azobenzene by light has never been achieved , and switching by excitation with a scanning tunneling microscope ( stm ) tip has been successful only at au(111)@xcite . a natural route to restoring the adsorbate switching ability is to further decouple the frontier @xmath10 and @xmath11 orbitals responsible@xcite for the gas- or liquid phase photo - isomerization from the substrate electronic structure . with these frontier orbitals largely located at the central diazo ( @xmath9n = n@xmath9 ) bridge an intuitive idea to achieve such a decoupling is to functionalize the molecule with bulky spacer groups that prevent a closer encounter of the photochemically active unit with the substrate . this is precisely the notion behind the arguably to date most studied such adsorbate , @xmath0-tetra-_tert_-butyl - azobenzene ( tba ) @xcite . tba consists of azobenzene functionalized with four _ tert_-butyl ( -c-(ch@xmath12)@xmath12 ) groups in the phenyl - ring meta positions as illustrated in fig . these table legs were indeed found to enhance the switching efficiency of the adsorbed species , as e.g. indicated by the successful tba switching by light at au(111 ) @xcite . however , attempts at stm - tip induced switching at ostensibly comparable substrates such as ag(111)@xcite and au(100)@xcite have been unsuccessful , indicating that tba is not significantly more robust to specifics of the substrate interaction than pure azobenzene . these circumstances beg the question , how and to what degree the tba butyl groups really decouple the photochromic moiety from the substrate . for a corresponding atomic - scale understanding the detailed characterization of the adsorbate geometry and binding constitutes a prerequisite and is the main objective of the present contribution . in contemporary surface science , corresponding analyses are increasingly performed by quantitative first - principles electronic structure calculations . particularly density - functional theory ( dft ) with present - day local or semi - local exchange - correlation ( xc ) functionals has developed into an unparalleled workhorse for this task , with often surprising accuracy particularly with respect to structural properties of the surface adsorption system . for tba at au(111 ) corresponding calculations are already challenged by the extension of the functionalized molecule and the simultaneous necessity to describe the metal band structure within a periodic supercell approach . on a more fundamental level , the real limitation comes nevertheless from sizable dispersive van der waals ( vdw ) contributions to the surface chemical bond as characteristic for organic molecules containing highly polarizable aromatic ring systems @xcite . with local and semi - local xc functionals inherently unable to account for such contributions @xcite skewed , if not qualitatively wrong results must therefore be suspected . we have recently quantified this for azobenzene at the close - packed coinage metal surfaces @xcite . comparison to detailed structural and energetic reference data from normal - incidence x - ray standing wave ( ni - xsw ) and temperature programmed desorption ( tpd ) measurements for azobenzene at ag(111 ) demonstrates that the prevalent semi - local dft xc treatment leads indeed to a significant underbinding with key structural parameters deviating by more than 0.5 @xcite . for system sizes as those implied by the adsorption of azobenzene or tba an appealing and computationally tractable possibility to improve on this situation is a semi - empirical account of dispersive interactions within the framework of so - called dft - d schemes @xcite . in this approach the vdw interactions not described by present - day xc functionals are approximately considered by adding a pairwise interatomic @xmath13 term to the dft energy . at distances below a cut - off , motivated by the vdw radii of the atom pair , this long - range dispersion contribution is heuristically reduced to zero by multiplication with a short - range damping function . while the applicability of this approach to adsorption at metal surfaces is uncertain ( _ vide infra _ ) , our recent benchmark study for azobenzene at ag(111 ) revealed that in particular the most recent dft - d scheme due to tkatchenko and scheffler ( ts ) @xcite yields excellent structural properties , albeit at a notable overbinding @xcite . in this contribution we further explore the generality of this finding by analyzing the adsorption geometry , vibrations and energetics of tba at au(111 ) . comparison against our recent near edge x - ray absorption fine structure ( nexafs ) @xcite and high - resolution electron energy loss spectroscopy ( hreels ) @xcite measurements , as well as a complete analysis of new tpd data confirms the accurate structural and vibrational predictions reached by the dft - d ts scheme . the again obtained significant overbinding furthermore supports the interpretation @xcite that the neglect of metallic screening is the main limitation in the application of this scheme to the adsorption of organic molecules at metal surfaces . comparing the tba data to those for pure azobenzene at au(111 ) we find a qualitatively different adsorption geometry for the functional backbone in the case of the _ cis _ isomer . for the _ trans _ isomer , on the other hand , we determine an intriguing structural and vibrational insensitivity of the photochemically active central diazo - bridge to the presence of the bulky spacer groups . the role of the latter for the switching efficiency is therefore more subtle than simple geometric decoupling and will be the topic of continuing work in our groups . the dft - d methodology followed in this work corresponds exactly to that employed in our preceding work for the adsorption of azobenzene . we therefore restrict ourselves here to a brief account and refer to our previous publications @xcite for an in - depth description of the underlying concepts and technical details . the dft calculations were performed using a plane - wave basis set and library ultrasoft pseudopotentials@xcite as implemented in and distributed with the castep@xcite code . the generalized gradient approximation ( gga ) to the xc - functional with the parametrization suggested by perdew , burke and ernzerhof@xcite ( pbe ) was used throughout . in the spirit of the dft - d approach , the lack of vdw interactions in this semi - local functional is approximately corrected with an additional analytical , two - body inter - atomic potential . at long range , this potential equals the leading @xmath14-term of the london series , where @xmath15 is the inter - atomic distance , and @xmath16 a so - called dispersion coefficient . at short range , this long range potential is matched to the dft inter - atomic potential by a damping function @xmath17 , typically modulated by the vdw radii @xmath18 of the atom pair . in this work we use the material - specific @xmath16 and @xmath18 parameters , as well as the damping function form suggested by tkatchenko and scheffler @xcite ( henceforth denominating corresponding results as pbe+ts ) . this scheme accounts to some degree for the bonding environment through a hirshfeld - analysis based adjustment of the @xmath19 parameters , which in our previous work on azobenzene at coinage metal surface gave a superior performance compared to other dft - d schemes @xcite . the analytical form of the dispersion correction potential brings the advantage that dispersion - corrected total energies of geometries that are fully relaxed with respect to the dispersion - corrected forces can be obtained ( employing an in - house extension to the castep code ) at essentially the same computational cost as a regular gga calculation . on the other hand the assumption of a simple two - body form for the dispersion potential inherently neglects the effect of electronic screening of the vdw interactions@xcite , which particularly for the here studied adsorption at metal surfaces is expected to lead to an overestimation of the binding energy @xcite . a second limitation of the semi - empirical dft - d approach might arise for adsorbate molecules which also interact covalently with the substrate . this typically leads to molecule - substrate bond distances that are so short that the uncertainties in the heuristic damping function of the dispersion term may mingle in an uncontrolled way with deficiencies of the employed semi - local dft xc functional . the surface calculations were performed within supercells , using ( 111)-oriented metal slabs with @xmath20 surface unit - cells and at least 18 vacuum . we verified that lateral interactions between adsorbed tba and its periodic images are negligble at the gga - pbe level . in the dispersion correction potential corresponding interactions were also switched off , so that our calculations should give a fair account of tba adsorption in the low - coverage limit . as in our preceding work we neglected the subtle effects of the long - range au(111 ) surface reconstruction . full geometry optimizations ( to within residual forces below 30 mev / ) of all molecular degrees of freedom were correspondingly performed with tba adsorbed on one side of a four layer bulk - truncated slab . test calculations with appropriately saturated _ tert_-butyl groups indicated only a weakly expressed site specificity of these tba functional groups at au(111 ) . this suggests that the photochemically active diazo - bridge plays a prominent role in anchoring the molecule at the metal substrate . the geometry optimizations were correspondingly initiated with the tba diazo - bridge laterally placed as in the previously determined optimal adsorption geometry of azobenzene , corresponding to a 1:1 n - metal atom coordination @xcite . harmonic vibrational spectra of the adsorbed species in these relaxed geometries ( and in the gas - phase ) were subsequently obtained from numerical hessians calculated by finite differences and neglecting any degrees of freedom of substrate atoms . to efficiently parallelize over the 432 displacements required for each spectrum , we have interfaced with the atomistic simulation environment including the phonopy extension to it @xcite . not aiming to reproduce the hreels intensities @xcite , simple lorentzian broadening with a width of 1 mev was applied to the spectra for better visualization . for the energetic and electronic structure calculations the thus determined relaxed adsorbate geometries were inverted in the bottom layer , forming inversion - symmetric seven layer slabs with adsorbates at both sides . this zeroes the internal dipole moment of the slab and results in a substantially improved substrate electronic structure . the two central energetic quantities obtained with the resulting structures are the adsorption energy @xmath21-e_{{\rm azo(gas ) } } \quad , \label{eq : e_ads}\ ] ] and the relative stability of adsorbed _ cis _ ( c ) and _ trans _ ( t ) conformer @xmath22 \quad . \label{eq : delta_e}\ ] ] here @xmath23 is the total energy of the relaxed , double - sided azobenzene - surface system , @xmath24 the total energy of the clean slab , and @xmath25 the total energy of the correspondingly relaxed gas - phase isomer ( computed within @xmath26-point sampled @xmath27 supercells ) . where applicable , ts dft - d corrections calculated in optimized four layer slab and gas - phase geometries are added to @xmath28 and @xmath25 , respectively . both quantities were also consistently zero - point energy corrected with the previously obtained vibrational frequencies . in the convention of eq . ( [ eq : e_ads ] ) the adsorption energy of either _ cis _ or _ trans _ isomer at the surface is thus measured relative to its stability in the gas - phase at both pure pbe and dispersion corrected pbe+ts levels of theory , and a negative sign indicates that adsorption is exothermic . consistently , a negative sign of @xmath29 indicates a higher stability of the _ cis _ isomer . convergence tests show that at the employed plane wave cutoff of 450ev and @xmath30 monkhorst - pack ( mp ) grid@xcite both energetic quantities are numerically converged to within @xmath31mev . the tpd measurements were carried out under ultrahigh vacuum conditions . the au(111 ) crystal was mounted on a liquid nitrogen cooled cryostat , which in conjunction with resistive heating enables temperature control from 90k to 750k . the crystal was cleaned by a standard procedure of ar@xmath32 sputtering and annealing . the tba was dosed by means of a home - built effusion cell held at 380k at a crystal temperature of 260k . in the tpd experiments , the substrate was resistively heated with a linear heating rate of 1 k / s and desorbing tba was detected with a quadrupole mass spectrometer at the tba - fragment mass of 190 amu ( 3,5-di-_tert_-butyl - phenyl ion ) . this procedure was repeated for different dosing times corresponding to different initial tba - coverages . as further discussed below , three desorption features ( @xmath33@xmath34 ) are observed in the tpd . they are assigned to desorption from the multilayer ( @xmath33 ) and the first monolayer ( ml ) ( @xmath35 + @xmath34 ) , where @xmath35 represents the desorption of @xmath36 10% of the monolayer coverage ( for details see fig . [ fig5 ] and ref . ) . the nexafs and hreels measurements of refs . discussed in section iii were performed at a coverage of 1.0 and 0.9ml , respectively , which were prepared by heating the multilayer - covered surface to 340k or to 420k . side view of adsorbed _ cis _ tba at au(111 ) , illustrating key structural parameters defining the adsorption geometry ( see text ) : the vertical height @xmath37 of the two diazo - bridge n atoms , as well as the out - of - horizontal phenyl plane bend angles @xmath38 . ] our previous work on azobenzene at coinage metal surfaces points to an understanding of the surface chemical bond in terms of a balance of four major contributions : a covalent bond between the diazo - bridge and the metal , the vdw attraction between the metal and the phenyl - rings , the pauli repulsion between the phenyl - rings and the metal , and the energetic penalty due to the distortion of the gas - phase molecular geometry @xcite . this understanding should largely carry over to tba at au(111 ) , with the bulky tert - butyl groups particularly adding to the vdw attraction and the molecular deformation upon adsorption . key structural parameters to characterize the adsorption geometry for both _ trans _ and _ cis _ isomer are therefore the location and orientation of the central diazo - bridge , as well as the orientation of the planes of the two phenyl - rings with respect to the surface . as further illustrated in figs . [ fig1 ] and [ fig2 ] we concentrate on the @xmath9n = n@xmath9 bond length @xmath39 and the vertical n atom@xmath9surface plane distances @xmath40 for the prior . here , the indices @xmath41 and @xmath42 represent the value for the n atom connected to the phenyl - ring closer to and further away from the surface , respectively . obviously , @xmath43 reflects an diazo - bridge that is oriented parallel to the surface , as we obtain for the more symmetric _ trans _ isomer throughout . to specify the position of the phenyl - rings we focus on the cnnc dihedral angle @xmath8 and the out - of - horizontal bend angles @xmath44 of the two ohenyl planes , with the same convention for the index @xmath45 to distinguish the closer and more distant phenyl - ring in the asymmetric adsorption geometry of . [ fig2 ] . adapting to the convention employed in refs . and , a dihedral angle of @xmath46 indicates a planar tba molecule , while @xmath47 denotes a phenyl - ring that lies parallel to the surface plane . .[table1 ] structural parameters as defined in figs . [ fig1 ] and [ fig2 ] . values for adsorbed tba at pbe+ts level of theory are compared to corresponding data obtained at pbe level of theory , as well as for adsorbed pure azobenzene @xcite . additionally shown are the out - of - horizontal phenyl plane bend angles @xmath44 as determined recently by nexafs measurements @xcite . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] in the low - coverage regime @xmath48 0.2 ml this analysis determines an essentially constant desorption energy of @xmath490.1ev . assuming no additional activation barrier for adsorption , this then provides the aspired benchmark number against which the calculated @xmath50 for _ trans _ tba may be referenced . as apparent from table [ table2 ] the values obtained at the pbe and pbe+ts level are very consistent with the findings of the previous studies of benzene and pure azobenzene at coinage metal surfaces @xcite : the lack of vdw interactions in the semi - local pbe functional leads to an overall negligible binding of both tba isomers , with the actual values for @xmath50 in fact essentially identical to those computed for pure azobenzene at au(111 ) before @xcite . adding dispersive attraction within the dft - d approach these binding energies are dramatically increased , such that in the end the intended dispersion correction amounts to more than 90% of the total binding energy . compared to the experimental reference the pbe+ts approach overbinds the _ trans _ isomer by about as much as pbe underbinds . in absolute numbers this is a disconcerting deviation of more than 1ev . in our previous work we had assigned the corresponding overbinding determined for pure azobenzene to the neglect of metallic screening in the dft - d approach@xcite . this argument was largely based on the intriguing accuracy of the pbe+ts adsorption geometry compared to the bond distances derived from ni - xsw measurements . as discussed above , such a conclusion on the determined tba adsorption geometry is presently not possible , as all hitherto measured structural parameters are not very sensitive to the additional vdw attraction provided by the pbe+ts scheme . on the other hand , the additional butyl groups lead to a significantly increased overall binding energy of tba compared to azobenzene , and in both cases pbe+ts overbinds by roughly 40% ( azo : 1.71ev vs. 1.08ev @xcite ; tba : 3.00ev vs. 1.70ev ) . such a rather geometry - unspecific deviation between theoretical and experimental data quite well fits the anticipated effect of an overestimated uniform background potential . the latter is attributed to the neglect of screening of vdw contributions from more distant substrate atoms . for gas - phase tba pbe+ts yields a somewhat smaller _ cis_-_trans _ energy difference @xmath51 than for pure azobenzene , 0.29ev compared to 0.49ev@xcite , respectively . this arises predominantly from the additional vdw attractions due to the butyl groups in the bend _ conformer , cf . [ fig1 ] , and is not found at the pbe level of theory , where @xmath52ev for both tba and azobenzene . compared to the gas - phase reference , the stability difference of the two tba conformers is with 0.99ev substantially increased at au(111 ) at pbe+ts level of theory . this is primarily due to the larger vdw attraction possible in the planar _ trans _ adsorption mode and was equivalently obtained for pure azobenzene adsorption @xcite . this interpretation in terms of vdw is corroborated by the essentially unchanged @xmath29 of gas - phase and adsorbed tba at pbe level of theory , where these bonding contributions are absent , cf . table [ table2 ] . not withstanding , in light of the suspected overestimation of the vdw attraction within pbe+ts we also expect that this increase of @xmath29 upon adsorption is overestimated . extrapolating the roughly 40% overshoot seen in the _ trans _ tba binding energy , we would therefore cautiously conclude on only a moderate @xmath53ev increase of the _ cis_-_trans _ energy difference upon adsorption of tba at au(111 ) . while the therewith implied higher stability of adsorbed _ trans _ tba is consistent with the existing experimental data , there are to date unfortunately no dedicated measurements of @xmath29 against which this estimate could be compared . the picture arising from the geometric and energetic characterization of tba at au(111 ) points to a surface chemical bond that is predominantly due to unspecific dispersive interactions . particularly for the _ trans _ conformer , the structural similarity of the azobenzene and tba adsorption complex with respect to the photochemically active diazo - bridge moiety ( together with the in both cases negligible @xmath9n = n@xmath9 bond activation ) questions the oft - quoted function of the tert - butyl spacers in terms of a geometric decoupling from the surface . complementary information confirming this view can come from an analysis of the surface vibrational modes . figure [ fig6 ] compares corresponding results computed for _ trans _ tba at au(111 ) at pbe+ts level of theory with experimental data from hreels @xcite . at first glance , we find overall agreement with all major features nicely reproduced by the calculations . as had already been noticed in the experimental work , the vibrational spectrum exhibits only minor changes between adsorbed _ cis _ and _ trans _ tba and even tba in the condensed phase @xcite . this is similarly obtained in the calculations , as illustrated by the spectrum for _ cis _ tba at au(111 ) also shown in fig . [ fig6 ] . the detailed inspection of the c - h vibrational modes in the energy range of 350 to 400 mev reveals nevertheless the subtle influence of the au(111 ) substrate on the vibrational spectra of the adsorbed species . based on the calculations the three frequency bands centered at 368 , 378 , and 390mev are assigned to the symmetric and asymmetric c - h vibrations of the tert - butyl groups , as well as the c - h bending modes at the phenyl - rings , respectively . there is a clear change of the former two vibrational bands when going from the pbe to the pbe+ts description , cf . the inset of fig . the overall reduced distance of the tba molecule to the gold substrate upon inclusion of the attractive vdw forces leads to a clear splitting of the c - h vibrations of the _ tert_-butyl moieties . in the adsorbed species the frequencies of the c - h bonds pointing towards the substrate are red shifted by 5 - 10mev and the corresponding vibrations develop low - energy sidebands . these subtle but important changes are confirmed by the experimental hreels spectra . due to the mainly in - plane character of the c - h phenyl - ring bending modes we observe only a small shoulder at 390mev . in contrast the symmetric and asymmetric c - h stretch vibrations of the _ tert_-butyl legs at 368 and 380mev result in pronounced dipole - active bands . upon _ trans _ to _ cis _ isomerization the number of c - h bonds pointing towards and noticeably contacting the substrate is roughly halved , cf . this leads in both experiment and theory to a reduction of the low - energy side bands best seen for the symmetric c - h stretch vibrations which constitute the lowest band at 368mev . as the splitting of the c - h stretch vibrations happens only at a reduced distance to the substrate ( pbe vs. pbe+ts adsorption structure ) it confirms the importance of vdw interaction in the bonding of tba . unfortunately this is not a quantitative benchmark for the accuracy of our semi - empirical pbe+ts approach . more insight into the specific bonding of the diazo - bridge moiety can specifically come from a detailed analysis of the @xmath9n = n@xmath9 stretch mode . however , identically obtained with pbe and pbe+ts , the computed value of 184mev in adsorbed _ trans _ and _ cis _ tba again reflects a negligible activation of the nn bond at the surface . compared to the respective gas - phase values , the mode red - shifts only by about 3mev for both isomers . correspondingly , the obtained shift between this stretch mode in _ trans _ and _ cis _ tba at au(111 ) is very similar to the one computed for free tba , 6 vs. 5 mev , respectively . this in turn compares very well to the 8mev measured for tba in the condensed phase with ir and raman spectroscopy @xcite . such a negligible change of the _ cis_-_trans _ stretch frequency difference upon adsorption is not found for pure azobenzene at au(111 ) . here , the closer encounter of the diazo - bridge in the _ cis _ adsorption geometry softens the stretch mode by more than 6 mev . with the mode unaffected in adsorbed azobenzene , this leads to a concomitant increase of the _ cis_-_trans _ stretch frequency shift compared to the gas - phase . in _ tba at au(111 ) a corresponding softening does not occur as the diazo - bridge does not come as close to the surface in the skewed adsorption mode . in this respect , one can really attest some geometric decoupling effect to the butyl groups , yet only for the _ cis _ isomer . for the _ trans _ isomer though , an equivalent analysis of the diazo - bridge against surface stretch or other torsional azo modes shows always the same similarity between tba and azobenzene at au(111 ) as for the just discussed @xmath9n = n@xmath9 stretch mode . also the characterization of the surface vibrational properties supports therefore the understanding that the effect of the bulky _ tert_-butyl groups for the switching properties of _ trans _ tba at au(111 ) must be more subtle than a mere geometric decoupling of the central photochemically active molecular moiety . a methodological motivation of this work was to further explore the capabilities of the semi - empirical dispersion correction approach to semi - local dft in describing the adsorption of complex organic molecules at metal surfaces . for this we have presented a detailed characterization of the geometric , energetic and vibrational properties of the _ trans _ and _ cis _ isomers of the azobenzene derivate tba at au(111 ) . the findings are in all respects in line with the experience from preceding studies on benzene and pure azobenzene at coinage metal surfaces @xcite : the additional account of attractive vdw interaction introduced by the pbe+ts scheme leads to a significant modification of the adsorption geometry , primarily in terms of bringing the molecule closer to the surface . the concomitantly dramatically increased binding energy is notably overestimated compared to the reference value from tpd measurements . for azobenzene at ag(111 ) a corresponding overbinding in fact in relative terms very much comparable to the one found here for tba at au(111 ) was attributed to the neglect of metallic screening of dispersive interactions in the semi - empirical dft - d approach @xcite . this argument was largely based on the very accurate pbe+ts adsorption geometry as compared to detailed structural data from ni - xsw measurements . such a conclusion is , unfortunately , not yet possible in full for the here studied tba at au(111 ) . the qualitative features of the determined _ trans _ and _ cis _ adsorption geometries and even detailed tilt and inclination angles agree all very well with existing data from stm @xcite , hreels @xcite and nexafs @xcite experiments . the energetic lowering of the c - h stretch vibrations of the _ tert_-butyl groups pointing towards the substrate is only observed in the pbe+ts approach . this points towards the importance of the vdw component introduced by the dft - d approach . however , no experimental reference data exist to date for the vertical height of the adsorbed molecule , that would allow to directly confirm the present working hypothesis , namely that the pbe+ts approach is a very useful and computationally tractable tool to provide accurate structural information for adsorbed complex organic molecules . if this working hypothesis proves correct and the determined pbe+ts adsorption geometries are indeed accurate , the prevailing preconception of the role of the bulky functional groups for the experimentally observed improved isomerization ability of adsorbed tba needs revision . motivated by the gas - phase structure , this view discusses the butyl groups as spacers that help to decouple the molecular switch from the metal substrate . for the tba _ cis _ isomer we indeed compute a skewed adsorption mode , in which one phenyl - moiety is much more tilted , up to the point of standing essentially perpendicular to the surface plane . this is quite different to the more symmetric adsorption mode of _ cis _ azobenzene at au(111 ) , such that here one can attest some geometric decoupling from the surface due to the butyl table legs. quite distinctly , the almost planar adsorption mode of _ trans _ tba is very much comparable to the adsorption geometry of pure azobenzene . particularly for the photochemically active diazo - bridge moiety this similarity goes even down to essentially unchanged structural and vibrational properties . in this respect , a core message arising from the present study is that especially for the photo - switching of _ trans _ tba the effect of the bulky spacer groups must be more subtle than the anticipated mere geometric decoupling of the functional backbone from the metal surface . funding by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft through sfb 658 - elementary processes in molecular switches at surfaces - is gratefully acknowledged . ample computing time has been provided at the hlrb - ii architecture of the leibniz supercomputing centre in garching . the central cnnc atoms of the azobenzene backbone are only precisely located within one plane for a dihedral angle @xmath54 . for the small , but finite angles @xmath8 determined in the calculations , we therefore use a simple arithmetic average to determine the inclination of the cnnc plane in the comparison to the nexafs data . | we present large - scale density - functional theory ( dft ) calculations and temperature programmed desorption measurements to characterize the structural , energetic and vibrational properties of the functionalized molecular switch @xmath0-tetra-_tert_-butyl - azobenzene ( tba ) adsorbed at au(111 ) . particular emphasis is placed on exploring the accuracy of the semi - empirical dispersion correction approach to semi - local dft ( dft - d ) in accounting for the substantial van der waals component in the surface chemical bond . in line with previous findings for benzene and pure azobenzene at coinage metal surfaces , dft - d significantly overbinds the molecule , but seems to yield an accurate adsorption geometry as far as can be judged from the experimental data . comparing the _ trans _ adsorption geometry of tba and azobenzene at au(111 ) reveals a remarkable insensitivity of the structural and vibrational properties of the @xmath1 moiety . this questions the established view of the role of the bulky tert - butyl - spacer groups for the switching of tba in terms of a mere geometric decoupling of the photochemically active diazo - bridge from the gold substrate . |
1008.0100 | research on the topological defects have expanded tremendously during the last decade and still remains one of the most active fields in modern cosmology . topological defects are inevitably formed during phase transitions in the early universe , and their subsequent evolution and observational signatures must therefore be understood . also , apart from their possible astrophysical roles , topological defects are fascinating objects in their own right . their properties , which are very different from those of more familiar system , can give rise to a rich variety of unusual mathematical and physical phenomena . the string model of structure formation may help to resolve one of cosmological mystery , the origin of cosmic magnetic fields @xcite . there is strong evidence from all numerical simulations for the scaling behavior of the long string network during the radiation - dominated era . despite the original lack of consensus on the actual long string density , all simulations demonstrated that high or low initial string densities were driven towards a stable fixed point @xcite . metrics describing the causal birth of a cosmic string have been studied by mageuijo @xcite . in a specific toy model for straight string formation , the metric takes account of a compensating radiation under density and also an outgoing gravitational shock wave where the deficit angle switches off . solutions of einstein s equations with conical singularities describing straight strings can easily be constructed @xcite . one needs only a spacetime with a symmetry axis . if one then cuts out a wedge then a space with a string lying along the axis is obtained . a non axisymmetric solution of the combined einstein and maxwell equations with a string has been found by linet @xcite . this solution describes a maximally charged black hole with an infinite string . today , nonlinear electromagnetic fields in higher dimensions are subjects of interest in recent years . for example , there has been a renewed interest in born - infeld gravity ever since new solutions have been found in the low energy limit of string theory . static and rotating solutions of born - infeld gravity have been considered in refs . @xcite . in this paper we want to introduce magnetic solutions of the einstein gravity in the presence of a nonlinear electromagnetic field and find the effects of the nonlinearity on the properties of the solutions . the basic motivation of considering this spacetime is that near the origin , @xmath2-dimensional section of this metric may be interpret as a topological string ( in analogy with cosmic string ) . also , the presented solutions is a generalization of usual linear electromagnetic field and the nonlinearity effects on the electromagnetic field , solutions , charge , deficit angle and so on . in the other word the presented solutions are completely differ from the usual linear electromagnetic field . as we see , our solutions do not have the same asymptotic behavior with respect to linear case . it is interesting to note that , in general case , the expression of the electric field depends on the dimension , @xmath0 , and the power of nonlinearity , @xmath3 , simultaneously and its value coincides with the higher dimensional reissner - nordstrm solutions for linear limit . these solutions are very flexible and there is not any restriction on the nonlinear parameter @xmath3 and one can fix it for consistency to other theoretical and experimental evidences . solutions with longitudinal and angular magnetic field were considered in refs . similar static solutions in the context of cosmic string theory were found in ref . all of these solutions dehhorizonless1,dehhorizonless2,db07,vilbanbansen96,levicivita19marder58 are horizonless and have a conical geometry ; they are everywhere flat except at the location of the line source . the extension to include the electromagnetic field has also been done @xcite . the generalization of these solutions in einstein gravity in the presence of a dilaton and born - infeld electromagnetic fields has been done in ref . hendijmp08dsh08 . another example of the nonlinear electromagnetic field is conformally invariant maxwell field . in many papers , straightforward generalization of the maxwell field to higher dimensions one essential property of the electromagnetic field is lost , namely , conformal invariance . indeed , in the reissner - nordstrm solution , the source is given by the maxwell action which enjoys the conformal invariance in four dimensions . massless spin-@xmath4 fields have vanishing classical stress tensor trace in any dimension , while scalars can be improved to achieve @xmath5 , thereby guaranteeing invariance under the special conformal ( or full weyl ) group , in accord with their scale - independence dessch . maxwell theory can be studied in a gauge which is invariant under conformal rescalings of the metric , and at first , have been proposed by eastwood and singer @xcite . also , poplawski @xcite have been showed the equivalence between the ferraris kijowski and maxwell lagrangian results from the invariance of the latter under conformal transformations of the metric tensor . quantized maxwell theory in a conformally invariant gauge have been investigated by esposito @xcite . in recent years , gravity in the presence of nonlinear and conformally invariant maxwell source have been studied in many papers @xcite . the outline of our paper is as follows . we give a brief review of the field equations of einstein gravity in the presence of cosmological constant and nonlinear electromagnetic field in sec . [ fiel ] . in sec . [ long ] we present static horizonless solutions which produce longitudinal magnetic field , compare it with the solutions of the standard electromagnetic field and then investigate the properties of the solutions and the effects of nonlinearity of the electromagnetic field on the deficit angle of the spacetime . section [ rot ] will be devoted to the generalization of these solutions to the case of rotating solutions and use of the counterterm method to compute the conserved quantities of them . we finish our paper with some concluding remarks . we consider the @xmath0-dimensional action in which gravity is coupled to nonlinear electrodynamics field in the presence of negative cosmological constant with an action @xmath6 , \label{ig}\ ] ] where @xmath7 is the scalar curvature , @xmath8 is the negative cosmological constant for asymptotically ads solutions , @xmath9 is the maxwell invariant which is equal to@xmath10(where @xmath11 is the electromagnetic tensor field and @xmath12 is the vector potential ) , @xmath13 and @xmath3 is a coupling and positive arbitrary constant respectively . varying the action ( [ ig ] ) with respect to the metric tensor @xmath14 and the electromagnetic field @xmath12 , the equations of gravitational and electromagnetic fields may be obtained as @xmath15 @xmath16 in the presence of nonlinear electrodynamics field , the energy - momentum tensor of eq . ( [ graveq ] ) is @xmath17 . \label{tt}\ ] ] it is easy to show that when @xmath3 goes to @xmath18 , the eqs . ( [ ig])([tt ] ) , reduce to the equations of magnetic brane in einstein - standard maxwell gravity @xcite . here we want to obtain the @xmath0-dimensional solutions of eqs . ( [ graveq ] ) , ( [ maxeq ] ) which produce longitudinal magnetic fields in the euclidean submanifold spans by @xmath19 coordinates ( @xmath20 ) . we will work with the following ansatz for the metric @xcite : @xmath21where @xmath22 is the euclidean metric on the @xmath23-dimensional submanifold . the angular coordinates @xmath24 is dimensionless as usual and ranges in @xmath25 $ ] , while @xmath19 s range in @xmath26 . also , one can obtain this metric with transformations @xmath27 and @xmath28 in the horizon flat schwarzschild like metric , @xmath29 . the motivation for this metric gauge @xmath30 and @xmath31 $ ] instead of the usual schwarzschild gauge @xmath32 and @xmath33 $ ] comes from the fact that we are looking for a horizonless magnetic solutions . taking the trace of the gravitational field equation ( [ graveq ] ) , the scalar curvature is expressed in terms of the maxwell invariant @xmath9 and cosmological constant @xmath34 as @xmath35before studying in details the field equations , we first specify the sign of the coupling constant @xmath36 in term of the exponent @xmath3 in order to ensure a physical interpretation of our future solutions . in fact , the sign of the coupling constant @xmath36 in the action ( [ ig ] ) can be chosen such that the energy density , i.e. the @xmath37 component of the energy - momentum tensor in the orthonormal frame , is positive @xmath38as a direct consequence , one can show that the maxwell invariant @xmath39 is positive and hence , the sign of the coupling constant @xmath36 should be positive , which can be set to @xmath18 without loss of generality . the gauge potential is given by @xmath40the nonlinear electromagnetic field equations ( [ maxeq ] ) reduce to @xmath41for @xmath42 , with the solution @xmath43where @xmath44 is an integration constant and is related to the electromagnetic charge . it is easy to show that the only nonzero electromagnetic field tensor is @xmath45to find the function @xmath46 , one may use any components of eq . ( graveq ) . the simplest equation is the @xmath47 component of these equations which can be written as @xmath48for @xmath42 , where the prime denotes a derivative with respect to the @xmath49 coordinate . the solution of eq . ( [ rrcom ] ) , which also satisfies all the other components of the gravitational field equations ( graveq ) , can be written as @xmath50where mass parameter , @xmath51 is related to integration constant . after some manipulations , we find that for @xmath53 and @xmath54 , the gauge potential @xmath12 and the charge term in the metric function differ from previous section . it is notable that for @xmath53 , all components of the electromagnetic field , @xmath55 , vanish and the solutions reduce to uncharged solutions . while for @xmath56 , there is a logarithmic function related to the charge term of the solutions obtained as followed@xmath57 here , with an appropriate combination of nonlinear electromagnetic field and @xmath2-dimensional einstein gravity , we constructed a class of four dimensional magnetic string solutions which produces a longitudinal magnetic field . in @xmath58-dimensional case the metric reduce to magnetic string coupled to nonlinear electromagnetic field@xmath59 the coordinate @xmath60 has the dimension of length and ranges @xmath61 and the electromagnetic field and metric function reduce to@xmath62 in this subsection , we want to investigate the effects of the nonlinearity of the magnetic field on the metric ( function ) . it is clear that the nonlinearity effects on the second term of @xmath46 , eq . ( [ f(r ) ] ) , directly . but for the study of the spacetime structure , it is better to investigate the behavior of the metric function for small and large value of @xmath49 . the metric function of the _ einstein - standard maxwell _ is @xmath63one can show that for small and large value of @xmath49 ( @xmath64 and @xmath65 ) , the dominant terms of the metric function ( [ fmax ] ) are second and first term , respectively . it means that @xmath66it is easy to find that these solutions ( einstein - standard maxwell solutions ) are asymptotically ads . but for _ nonlinear maxwell field coupled to einstein gravity _ ( our case ) , we have @xmath67it is worthwhile to mention that if @xmath68 , the solutions of the einstein - nonlinear maxwell field equations are not asymptotically ads and for @xmath69 , the asymptotic behavior of einstein - nonlinear maxwell field solutions are the same as linear case . it is interesting that the nonlinear maxwell field effects on all values of @xmath70 . there is not any restriction on the nonlinear parameter @xmath3 and one can fix it for consistency to other models . in order to study the general structure of the solutions given in eqs . ( met1a ) and ( [ f(r ) ] ) , we first look for curvature singularities . one can find that the kretschmann scalar , @xmath71 , is @xmath72it is easy to show that the kretschmann scalar @xmath73 diverge at @xmath74 and therefore one might think that there is a curvature singularity located at @xmath74 . however , as we will see , the spacetime will never achieve @xmath74 . the function @xmath75 is negative for @xmath76 and positive for @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the largest root of @xmath79 . the function @xmath80 can not be negative ( which occurs for @xmath76 ) , because of the change of signature of the metric . thus , one can not extend the spacetime to @xmath81 . to get rid of this incorrect extension , we can introduce the new radial coordinate @xmath70 as @xmath82with this new coordinate , the metric ( [ met1a ] ) is @xmath83where the coordinate @xmath70 and @xmath24 assume the value @xmath84 @xmath85 and @xmath86 . the function @xmath87 is now given as @xmath88for @xmath89 , when @xmath90 it is sufficient to let @xmath91 in eq . ( [ f2 ] ) and for @xmath56 , we should substitute second term of eq . ( [ f2 ] ) with @xmath92 . the electromagnetic field equation in the new coordinate is @xmath93 } } & , % \text{else}% \end{array}% \right . . \label{f33}\]]the function @xmath87 given in eq . ( [ f(r ) ] ) is positive in the whole spacetime and is zero at @xmath94 . one can show that all curvature invariants ( such as kretschmann scalar , ricci scalar , ricci square , weyl square and so on ) are functions of @xmath95 , @xmath96 and @xmath97 . since these terms do not diverge in the range @xmath98 , one finds that all curvature invariants are finite . therefore this spacetime has no curvature singularities and no horizons . it is worthwhile to mention that the magnetic solutions obtained here have distinct properties relative to the electric solutions obtained in @xcite . indeed , the electric solutions have black holes , while the magnetic do not . however , the metric ( [ met1a ] ) has a conic geometry and has a conical singularity at @xmath94 . for e.g. , when @xmath89 and using a taylor expansion in the vicinity of @xmath94 , we can write @xmath99as a result , we can rewrite eq . ( [ met1b ] ) @xmath100then @xmath101which clearly shows that the spacetime has a conical singularity at @xmath94 since , when the radius @xmath70 tends to zero , the limit of the ratio _ circumference / radius _ is not @xmath102 . the conical singularity can be removed if one identifies the coordinate @xmath24 with the period @xmath103where @xmath104 .\]]one concludes that near the origin , @xmath94 , metric ( [ met0 ] ) describes a spacetime which is locally flat but has a conical singularity at @xmath94 with a deficit angle @xmath105 . in four dimensional solutions , @xmath106 interpreted as the mass per unit length of the magnetic string . therefore , in higher dimensions , we may interpret @xmath107 as the mass per unit volume of the magnetic brane . also , in order to investigate the effects of the nonlinearity of the magnetic field on @xmath107 , we plot the deficit angle @xmath108 versus the charge parameter @xmath44 . this is shown in fig . [ fig1 ] , which shows that the nonlinear parameter effects on the deficit angle unless for @xmath109 and @xmath110 . of course , one may ask for the completeness of the spacetime with @xmath111 ( or @xmath112 ) . it is easy to see that the spacetime described by eq . ( [ met1b ] ) is both null and timelike geodesically complete as in the case of four - dimensional standard maxwell solutions @xcite . in fact , one can show that every null or timelike geodesic starting from an arbitrary point can either extend to infinite values of the affine parameter along the geodesic or end on a singularity @xcite . now , we want to endow our spacetime solutions ( [ met1a ] ) with a global rotation . at first , we consider the solutions with one rotation parameter . in order to add angular momentum to the spacetime , we perform the following rotation boost in the @xmath113-@xmath24 plane @xmath114where @xmath115 is the rotation parameter and @xmath116 . substituting eq . ( [ tphi ] ) into eq . ( [ met1a ] ) we obtain @xmath117where @xmath87 is the same as @xmath87 given in eq . ( [ f2 ] ) . the non vanishing electromagnetic field components become @xmath118 } } & , \text{else}% \end{array}% \right.\]]because of the periodic nature of @xmath24 , the transformation ( [ tphi ] ) is not a proper coordinate transformation on the entire manifold . therefore , the metrics ( [ met1b ] ) and ( [ metrot ] ) can be locally mapped into each other but not globally , and so they are distinct @xcite . again , this spacetime has no horizon and curvature singularity , however , it has a conical singularity at @xmath94 . second , we study the rotating solutions with more rotation parameters . the rotation group in @xmath0 dimensions is @xmath119 and therefore the number of independent rotation parameters is @xmath120 $ ] , where @xmath121 $ ] is the integer part of @xmath122 . we now generalize the above solution given in eq . ( [ met1b ] ) with @xmath123 $ ] rotation parameters . this generalized solution can be written as @xmath124where @xmath125 , @xmath126 is the euclidean metric on the @xmath127-dimensional submanifold with volume @xmath128 and @xmath129 is the same as @xmath87 given in eq . ( [ f(r ) ] ) . the non - vanishing components of electromagnetic field tensor are @xmath130 } } & , \text{else}% \end{array}% \right . .\]]one can see that rotation does not change the metric function @xmath87 , and therefore the metric in the transformed coordinate systemin the remaining part of this section , we compute the conserved quantities of the solutions . in general , the conserved quantities are divergent when evaluated on the solutions . a systematic method of dealing with this divergence for asymptotically ads solutions of einstein gravity is through the use of the counterterms method inspired by the anti - de sitter conformal field theory ( ads / cft ) correspondence @xcite . one can use the brown - york definition of the stress - energy tensor @xcite to construct a divergence - free stress - energy tensor @xmath131 , \label{stres}\]]where @xmath132 is the extrinsic curvature of the boundary , @xmath133 is its trace and @xmath134 is the induced metric of the boundary . to compute the conserved charges of the spacetime , we choose a spacelike surface @xmath135 in @xmath136 with metric @xmath137 , and write the boundary metric in arnowitt - deser - misner form : @xmath138where the coordinates @xmath139 are the angular variables parameterizing the hypersurface of constant @xmath70 around the origin , and @xmath140 and @xmath141 are the lapse and shift functions respectively . when there is a killing vector field @xmath142 on the boundary , then the quasilocal conserved quantities associated with the stress tensors of eq . ( [ stres ] ) can be written as @xmath143where @xmath144 is the determinant of the metric @xmath137 , and @xmath145 is the timelike unit normal vector to the boundary @xmath135**. * * in the context of counterterm method , the limit in which the boundary @xmath146 becomes infinite ( @xmath147 ) is taken , and the counterterm prescription ensures that the action and conserved charges are finite . for our case , horizonless rotating spacetimes , the first killing vector is @xmath148 and therefore its associated conserved charge of the brane is the mass per unit volume @xmath128 calculated as @xmath149 m. \label{mas}\]]the second class of conserved quantities are the angular momentum per unit volume @xmath128 associated with the rotational killing vectors @xmath150 which may be calculated as @xmath151 one can find that the mass and angular momentum , eqs . ( [ mas ] ) and ( ang ) , do not depend on the nonlinear parameter @xmath3 . it is a matter of calculation to show that the mass and angular momentum per unit volume of the solutions for @xmath152 is the same as asymptotic ads case . next , we calculate the electric charge of the solutions . to determine the electric field we should consider the projections of the electromagnetic field tensor on special hypersurfaces.the electric charge per unit volume @xmath153 can be found by calculating the flux of the electromagnetic field at infinity , yielding @xmath154note that the electric charge is proportional to the rotation parameter , and is zero for the case of static solutions . in many papers , straightforward generalization of the maxwell field to higher dimensions one essential property of the electromagnetic field is lost , namely , conformal invariance . as one can see the clue of the conformal invariance lies in the fact that we have considered power of the maxwell invariant , @xmath155 . here we want to justify @xmath3 , such that the electromagnetic field equation be invariant under conformal transformation ( @xmath156 and @xmath157 ) . the idea is to take advantage of the conformal symmetry to construct the analogues of the four dimensional reissner - nordstrm solutions in higher dimensions . consider the lagrangian of the form @xmath158 , where @xmath159 . it is easy to show that for this form of lagrangian in @xmath0-dimensions , @xmath160 $ ] ; so @xmath161 implies @xmath162 . for our case @xmath163 , and subsequently , @xmath164 . it is worthwhile to mention that since @xmath165 and therefore @xmath166 , one can show that the conformally invariant maxwell source solutions are asymptotically ads in arbitrary dimensions @xmath167 . in this paper , we investigated the effects of the nonlinearity of the electromagnetic fields on the properties of the spacetime by finding a new class of magnetic solutions in einstein gravity in the presence of nonlinear electromagnetic field . this class of solutions yields an @xmath0-dimensional spacetime with a longitudinal nonlinear magnetic field [ the only nonzero component of the vector potential is @xmath168 generated by a static magnetic brane . also , we compared the asymptotic behavior of metric functions for linear and nonlinear cases and showed that the nonlinear case is not asymptotic ads for special range of nonlinear parameter , ( @xmath169 ) . we found that these solutions have no curvature singularity and no horizons , but have conic singularity at @xmath94 with a deficit angle @xmath170 . we found that this deficit angle is different from the deficit angle of spacetimes of einstein gravity in the presence of maxwell field for large value of charge parameter . next , we endow the spacetime with rotation . for the spinning brane , when the rotation parameters are nonzero , the brane has a net electric charge density which is proportional to the magnitude of the rotation parameters given by @xmath171 . we also applied the counterterm method in order to calculate the conserved quantities of the spacetime , and found that the mass and angular momentum per unit volume of the spacetime do not depend on the nonlinear parameter . finally , we considered the conformally invariant maxwell source of the solutions and found that the nonlinear parameter restricted to @xmath164 , and spacetime is asymptotic ads for arbitrary dimensions @xmath167 . | considering the nonlinear electromagnetic field coupled to einstein gravity in the presence of cosmological constant , we obtain a new class of @xmath0-dimensional magnetic brane solutions . this class of solutions yields a spacetime with a longitudinal nonlinear magnetic field generated by a static source . these solutions have no curvature singularity and no horizons but have a conic geometry with a deficit angle @xmath1 . we investigate the effects of nonlinearity on the metric function and deficit angle and also find that for the special range of the nonlinear parameter , the solutions are not asymptotic ads . we generalize this class of solutions to the case of spinning magnetic solutions , and find that when one or more rotation parameters are nonzero , the brane has a net electric charge which is proportional to the magnitude of the rotation parameters . then , we use the counterterm method and compute the conserved quantities of these spacetimes . finally , we obtain a constrain on the nonlinear parameter , such that the nonlinear electromagnetic field is conformally invariant . |
0905.3648 | the atlas experiment @xcite at the large hadron collider ( lhc ) @xcite must be synchronized to the collisions to ensure the quality of the event data recorded by its sub - detectors . in order to facilitate this , the lhc provides beam related timing signals to the experiments via optical fibers that are several kilometers long @xcite . the phase of these clock signals can drift , e.g. due to temperature fluctuations , causing front - end electronics to sample at non - optimal working point . on both sides of atlas , 175 m upstream from the interaction point , beam pick - up detectors are installed along the lhc beam pipe . this paper describes how these detectors are used * to monitor the phase between the collisions and the lhc clock signals that drive the atlas electronics * to monitor the structure and uniformity of the lhc beams * as input to the trigger system [ fig : bptxstation ] the bptx stations are beam position monitors provided by the lhc machine , but operated by experiments for timing purposes . they are comprised of four electrostatic button pick - up detectors , arranged symmetrically in the transverse plane around the lhc beam pipe . since the signal from a passing charge distribution is linearly proportional to distance to first order , the signals from all four pick - ups are summed to cancel out potential beam position deviations . the resulting signal is then transmitted to the underground counting room _ usa15 _ via a 220 m low - loss cable . figure [ fig : bptxstation ] shows the installed bptx station for beam 2 on the c - side of atlas . at the bottom of the photograph , the cables from the four button pick - ups are visible the bptx signals are used for two separate purposes within atlas , by the trigger system and by a monitoring system for the lhc beams and timing signals . figure [ fig : bptxcontextdiagram ] shows the bptx system and how it interacts with the related systems @xcite . the optical timing signals from the lhc arrive in the underground counting room to a receiver module , the ` rf2ttc ` . this module converts the optical signals to _ _ ttc _ _ signals and can also manipulate their phase , duration etc . if needed . the electrical signals are then transmitted to the atlas sub - detectors via the _ central trigger processor _ ( ctp ) of the level-1 trigger system and to the bptx monitoring system . the atlas trigger system is designed in three levels , each level sequentially refining the selection of events to be saved for further offine analysis . the level-1 trigger is implemented in custom electronics and performs a first selection of events within 2.5 @xmath0s , based primarily on reduced - granularity data from the calorimeters and the muon spectrometer . the selected events are processed further by the _ high level trigger _ system which is implemented in software . the signals from the bptx stations are discriminated with a constant - fraction discriminator to provide atlas with an accurate and reliable timing reference in the form of a standard nim pulse . this pulse is fed into the level-1 _ central trigger processor _ where it serves as a trigger condition indicating a bunch passing through atlas . furthermore , the bptx detectors are used by a stand - alone monitoring system for the lhc bunches and timing signals . the bptx and lhc timing signals are digitized by a deep - memory , high sampling rate ( 5ghz ) oscilloscope and transferred to a computer running linux for analysis . the features of the scope enables capturing a full lhc turn in one acquisition while retaining enough detail to get about 5 measurement points on the sharp falling edge of each bptx pulse ( see e.g. figure [ fig : firstbunch ] ) . since most of the high - frequency content of the bptx signals is attenuated by the long transmission line , the frequency spectrum of the signals arriving in atlas peaks around 400 mhz , making an analog bandwidth of 600 mhz sufficient for the oscilloscope used for digitization . by making fits to the identified bunch pulses and clock edges , the bptx monitoring system measures the phase between each bunch and the clock signal with high accuracy . monitoring these quantites is crucial to guarantee a stable phase relationship for optimal signal sampling in the subdetector front - end electronics . in addition to monitoring this phase , the intensity and longitudinal length of the individual bunches are measured and the structure of the beams is determined . using the bptx monitoring applications , the shifter in the control room can verify that the timing signals are synchronized to the collisions , and also look for so - called _ satellite bunches _ , out - of - time bunches that would cause off - center collisions in atlas . the monitoring system is running independently from the atlas online data acquisition infrastructure , enabling monitoring of the lhc machine in the control room even when atlas is not taking data . summary data from the bptx monitoring system , e.g. mean bunch intensity and phase , is published to the atlas _ _ detector control system__@xcite and ultimately saved to the conditions database . on september 10 , 2008 , the first lhc proton bunch reached atlas . figure [ fig : firstbunch ] shows the pulse recorded by the bptx monitoring system . a few hours later , a bunch was successfully circulated 8 turns around the accelerator and seen by atlas as depicted in figure [ fig:8turns ] . the pulses are separated by 89@xmath0s , corresponding to the time it takes for an lhc bunch to circulate around the 27 km long ring . the pulse amplitude , which is proportional to the bunch intensity , is degrading from turn to turn , which is consistent with the beam loss and debunching expected for a beam not yet captured by the lhc rf system . around 1 am on september 12 , 2008 , a single bunch was circulated around the lhc for about 20 minutes after being captured by the rf system . the bptx monitoring system measured the intensity during this period , and the resulting plot is shown in figure [ fig : longfill ] . it should be noted that this is a relative but not yet normalized intensity measurement . the scattering of the data points suggests that the precision is around 10% . figure [ fig : persistency ] shows an oscilloscope picture recorded in persistency mode during the same time period . the falling edge of the analog bptx signal for beam 2 ( the scope channel with bipolar pulses to the left ) is used as scope trigger and can be seen together with the discriminated bptx signal used as level-1 trigger input ( with longer nim pulse to the right ) . the clock related to beam 2 ( bottom ) is stable within an rms of 40 picoseconds with respect to the beam , indicating rf capture . the reference clock signal ( top ) , corresponding to the bunch frequency at a higher energy , has a different frequency . in the first period of beam in the lhc , the bptx system was used extensively as a trigger to time in the read - out windows of the sub - detectors of the atlas experiment . the bptx monitoring system was able to record the very first lhc bunch approaching atlas , and provided detailed information about the beams during these first days of data taking . the authors would like to thank the atlas collaboration and its level-1 central trigger group in which most of this work was carried out . we would also like to express our deepest gratitude to the lhc community , both for the support and for providing the bptx detectors . 00 the atlas collaboration 2008 `` the atlas experiment at the cern large hadron collider '' ( 2008 ) s08003 . l. evans and p. bryant ( editors ) 2008 `` lhc machine '' ( 2008 ) s08001 . s. baron 2005 `` ttc challenges and upgrade for the lhc '' pp 125 - 129 . t. pauly et al . 2005 `` atlas level-1 trigger timing - in strategies '' pp 274 - 278 . c. ohm 2007 m.sc . thesis , linkping university , sweden , lith - ifm - ex07/1808se . a. barriuso poy , h. boterenbrood , h. j. burckhart , j. cook , v. filimonov , s. franz , o. gutzwiller , b. hallgren , v. khomutnikov , s. schlenker and f. varela 2008 `` the detector control system of the atlas experiment '' . ( 2008 ) p05006 . | the atlas bptx stations are comprised of electrostatic button pick - up detectors , located 175 m away along the beam pipe on both sides of atlas . the pick - ups are installed as a part of the lhc beam instrumentation and used by atlas for timing purposes . the usage of the bptx signals in atlas is twofold : they are used both in the trigger system and for lhc beam monitoring . the bptx signals are discriminated with a constant - fraction discriminator to provide a level-1 trigger when a bunch passes through atlas . furthermore , the bptx detectors are used by a stand - alone monitoring system for the lhc bunches and timing signals . the bptx monitoring system measures the phase between collisions and clock with a precision better than 100 ps in order to guarantee a stable phase relationship for optimal signal sampling in the subdetector front - end electronics . in addition to monitoring this phase , the properties of the individual bunches are measured and the structure of the beams is determined . on september 10 , 2008 , the first lhc beams reached the atlas experiment . during this period with beam , the atlas bptx system was used extensively to time in the read - out of the sub - detectors . in this paper , we present the performance of the bptx system and its measurements of the first lhc beams . atlas , beam monitoring , level-1 trigger , bptx , lhc , lhc timing signals |
math-ph0610087 | the phenomena of the atmosphere and ocean are extremely rich in its organization and complexity , and a lot of them can not be produced by experiments . these phenomena involve a broad range of temporal and spatial scales . as we know , both the atmospheric and oceanic flows are flows under the rotation of the earth . in fact , fast rotation and small aspect ratio are two main characteristics of the large scale atmospheric and oceanic flows . the small aspect ratio characteristic leads to the primitive equations , and the fast rotation leads to the quasi - geostrophic equations . these are fundamental equations in the study of atmospheric and oceanic flows ; see ghil and childress @xcite , lions , temam and wang @xcite , and pedlosky @xcite . furthermore , convection occurs in many regimes of the atmospheric and oceanic flows . a key problem in the study of climate dynamics and in geophysical fluid dynamics is to understand and predict the periodic , quasi - periodic , aperiodic , and fully turbulent characteristics of large - scale atmospheric and oceanic flows . stability / bifurcation theory enables one to determine how different flow regimes appear and disappear as control parameters , such as the reynolds number , vary . it , therefore , provides one with a powerful tool to explore the theoretical capability in the predictability problem . most studies so far have only considered systems of ordinary differential equations ( odes ) that are obtained by projecting the pdes onto a finite - dimensional solution space , either by finite differencing or by truncating a fourier expansion ( see ghil and childress @xcite and further references there ) . these were pioneered by lorenz @xcite , stommel @xcite , and veronis @xcite among others , who explored the bifurcation structure of low - order models of atmospheric and oceanic flows . more recently , pseudo - arclength continuation methods have been applied to atmospheric ( legras and ghil @xcite ) and oceanic ( speich et al . @xcite and dijkstra @xcite ) models with increasing horizontal resolution . these numerical bifurcation studies have produced so far fairly reliable results for two classes of geophysical flows : ( i ) atmospheric flows in a periodic mid - latitude channel , in the presence of bottom topography and a forcing jet ; and ( ii ) oceanic flows in a rectangular mid - latitude basin , subject to wind stress on its upper surface ; see among others charney and devore @xcite , pedlosky @xcite , legras and ghil @xcite and jin and ghil @xcite for saddle - node and hopf bifurcations in the the atmospheric channel , and @xcite for saddle - node , pitchfork or hopf in the oceanic basin . the main objective of this article is to conduct bifurcation and stability analysis for the original partial differential equations ( pdes ) that govern geophysical flows . this approach should allow us to overcome some of the inherent limitations of the numerical bifurcation results that dominate the climate dynamics literature up to this point , and to capture the essential dynamics of the governing pde systems . the present article addresses the stability and transitions of basic flows for the stratified rotating boussinesq equations . these equations are fundamental equations in the geophysical fluid dynamics ; see among others pedlosky @xcite . we obtain two main results in this article . the first is to conduct a rigorous and complete bifurcation and stability analysis near the first eigenvalue of the linearized problem . the second is the onset of the hopf bifurcation , leading to the existence of periodic solutions of the model . the detailed analysis is carried out in two steps . the first is a detailed study of the eigenvalue problem for the linearized problem around the basic state . in comparison to the classical bnard convection problem , the linearized problem here is non - selfadjoint , leading to much more complicated spectrum , and more complicated dynamics . we derive in particular two critical rayleigh numbers @xmath0 and @xmath1 . here @xmath0 is the first critical rayleigh number for the case where the prandtl number is greater than one , and @xmath1 is the first critical rayleigh number for the case where the prandtl number is less than one . moreover , @xmath0 leads to the onset of the steady state bifurcation while @xmath1 leads to the onset of the hopf bifurcation . both parameters are explicitly given in terms of the physical parameters . the crucial issues here include 1 ) a complete understanding of the spectrum , 2 ) identification of the critical rayleigh numbers , and most importantly 3 ) the verification of the principle of exchange of stabilities near these critical rayleigh numbers . the second step is to conduct a rigorous nonlinear analysis to derive the bifurcations at both the critical rayleigh numbers based on the classical hopf bifurcation theory and a newly developed dynamic bifurcation theory by two of the authors . this new dynamic bifurcation theory is centered at a new notion of bifurcation , called attractor bifurcation for dynamical systems , both finite dimensional and infinite dimensional , together with new strategies for the lyapunov - schmidt reduction and the center manifold reduction procedures . the bifurcation theory has been applied to various problems from science and engineering , including , in particular , the kuramoto - sivashinshy equation , the cahn - hillard equation , the ginzburg - landau equation , reaction - diffusion equations in biology and chemistry , and the bnard convection problem , the taylor problem ; see @xcite and the references therein . we remark that the non - selfadjointness of the linearized problem gives rises the onset of the hopf bifurcation . we prove that the hopf bifurcation appears at the rayleigh number @xmath1 . as mentioned earlier , the understanding and prediction of of the the periodic , quasi - periodic , aperiodic , and fully turbulent characteristics of large - scale atmospheric and oceanic flows are key issues in the study of climate dynamics and in geophysical fluid dynamics . it is hoped that the study carried out in this article will provide some insights in these important issues . also , we would like to mention that rigorous proof of the existence of periodic solutions for a fluid system is a normally a very difficult task from the mathematical point of view . for instance , with a highly involved analysis , chen et al . @xcite proved the existence of a hopf bifurcation in an idealized fourier space . the paper is organized as follows . section 2 gives the basic setting of the problem . section 3 states the main results . the proofs of the main results occupies the remaining part of the paper : section 4 recapitulates the essentials of the attractor bifurcation theory , section 5 is on the eigenanalysis , and section 6 is on the central manifold reduction and the completion of the proofs . the stratified rotating boussinesq equations are basic equations in the geophysical fluid dynamics , and their non - dimensional form is given by [ b1 ] \ { & =( u - p ) + r t e - e u-(u ) u , + & = t + w-(u ) t , + & u = 0 , . for @xmath2 in the non - dimensional domain @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the velocity fields , @xmath5 is the unit vector in the @xmath6-direction , @xmath7 is the prandtl number , @xmath8 is the thermal rayleigh number , @xmath9 is the rossby number , @xmath10 is the temperature function and @xmath11 is the pressure function . we refer the interested readers to pedlosky @xcite , lions , temam and wang @xcite for the derivation of this model and the related parameters . in particular , the term @xmath12 represents the coriolis force , the @xmath13 term in the temperature equation is derived using the stratification , and the definition of the rayleigh number @xmath8 as follows : @xmath14 we consider the periodic boundary condition in the @xmath15 and @xmath16 directions @xmath17 for any @xmath18 . at the top and bottom boundaries , we impose the free - free boundary conditions : [ b3 ] ( t , w)=0 , = 0 , = 0 , z=0,1 . it is natural to put the constraint [ b4 ] _ udxdydz= _ vdxdydz = 0 . the initial value conditions are given by [ b5 ] ( u , t)= ( , ) t=0 . let @xmath19 let @xmath20 ( resp . , @xmath21 @xmath22 @xmath23 ) and @xmath24 @xmath22 @xmath25 ( resp . , @xmath21 @xmath22 @xmath23 ) be defined by @xmath26 , -\delta t ) , \\ & b_{r } \psi = ( -p [ \sigma r t e],-w ) , \\ & g ( \psi ) = g(\psi , \psi),\end{aligned}\ ] ] for any @xmath27 ( resp . , @xmath21 ) , where @xmath28 , -(u_1 \cdot \nabla)t_2),\end{aligned}\ ] ] for any @xmath29 , @xmath30 . here @xmath31 is the leray projection to @xmath32 fields , and for a detailed account of the function spaces ; see among many others @xcite . [ rmb1 ] note that @xmath21 and @xmath23 are invariant under the bilinear operator @xmath33 in the sense that @xmath34 hence , @xmath21 and @xmath23 are invariant under the operator @xmath35 . then the boussinesq equations ( [ b1])-([b4 ] ) can be written in the following operator form @xmath36 to state the main theorems of this article , we proceed with the definition of attractor bifurcation , first introduced by t. ma and s. wang in @xcite . let @xmath25 and @xmath37 be two hilbert spaces , and @xmath38 be a dense and compact inclusion . we consider the following nonlinear evolution equations [ c1 ] \ { & = l_u + g(u , ) , + & u(0 ) = u_0 , . where @xmath39 is the unknown function , @xmath40 is the system parameter , and @xmath41 are parameterized linear completely continuous fields depending continuously on @xmath42 , which satisfy @xmath43 it is easy to see @xcite that @xmath44 generates an analytic semi - group @xmath45 . then we can define fractional power operators @xmath46 for any @xmath47 with domain @xmath48 such that @xmath49 if @xmath50 , and @xmath51 . furthermore , we assume that the nonlinear terms @xmath52 for some @xmath53 are a family of parameterized @xmath54 bounded operators ( @xmath55 ) continuously depending on the parameter @xmath42 , such that @xmath56 in this paper , we are interested in the sectorial operator @xmath57 such that there exist an eigenvalue sequence @xmath58 and an eigenvector sequence @xmath59 of @xmath60 : @xmath61 for some @xmath62 , such that @xmath63 is a basis of @xmath25 . also we assume that there is a constant @xmath64 such that @xmath65 under conditions ( [ c4 ] ) and ( [ c5 ] ) , the operator @xmath66 is a sectorial operator . let @xmath67 be an operator semi - group generated by the equation ( [ c1 ] ) . then the solution of ( [ c1 ] ) can be expressed as @xmath68 for any @xmath69 [ dfc1 ] a set @xmath70 is called an invariant set of ( [ c1 ] ) if @xmath71 for any @xmath72 . an invariant set @xmath70 of ( [ c1 ] ) is called an attractor if @xmath73 is compact , and there exists a neighborhood @xmath74 of @xmath73 such that for any @xmath75 we have @xmath76 [ dfc2 ] 1 . we say that the solution of ( [ c1 ] ) bifurcates from @xmath77 to an invariant set @xmath78 , if there exists a sequence of invariant sets @xmath79 of ( [ c1 ] ) such that @xmath80 , @xmath81 , and @xmath82 2 . if the invariant sets @xmath78 are attractors of ( [ c1 ] ) , then the bifurcation is called attractor bifurcation . in this article , we consider two cases : @xmath83 for some @xmath84 , @xmath85 , where @xmath0 and @xmath1 are defined in ( [ e18 ] ) and ( [ e22 ] ) respectively . in the above cases , @xmath0 and @xmath1 are given by the following formulas : @xmath86 1 . condition ( [ c6 ] ) guarantees that for @xmath87 , the first eigenvalue of @xmath88 ( resp . , @xmath89 ) is real and of multiplicity two ( resp . , one ) ; see remark [ rme3 ] . 2 . condition ( [ c7 ] ) guarantees that , for @xmath90 , there exists only one simple pair of conjugate complex eigenvalues of @xmath89 crossing the imaginary axis ; see lemma [ le6 ] . 3 . condition ( [ c6 ] ) or ( [ c7 ] ) can be satisfied easily ; see lemmas [ le4 ] and [ le5 ] . [ thc4 ] assume ( [ c6 ] ) . then the following assertions for problem ( [ b1])-([b4 ] ) defined in @xmath25 hold true . 1 . if @xmath91 , the steady state @xmath92 is locally asymptotically stable . 2 . for @xmath93 , the problem bifurcates from @xmath94 to an attractor @xmath95 , consisting of only steady state solutions . to an attractor @xmath96 for @xmath93 . ] [ thc5 ] assume ( [ c7 ] ) and @xmath97 the following statements are true . 1 . for problem ( [ b1])-([b4 ] ) defined in @xmath25 , the steady state @xmath92 is locally asymptotically stable if @xmath98 . 2 . for problem ( [ b1])-([b4 ] ) defined in @xmath23 , a hopf bifurcation occurs generically when @xmath8 crosses @xmath1 . consider ( [ c1 ] ) satisfying ( [ c2 ] ) and ( [ c3 ] ) . we start with the principle of exchange of stabilities ( pes ) . let the eigenvalues ( counting the multiplicity ) of @xmath44 be given by @xmath99 , @xmath100 , @xmath101 . suppose that @xmath102 @xmath103 let the eigenspace of @xmath44 at @xmath104 be @xmath105 it is known that @xmath106 . [ thd1 ] assume that the conditions ( [ c2])-([c5 ] ) and ( [ d1])-([d2 ] ) hold true , and @xmath107 is locally asymptotically stable for ( [ c1 ] ) at @xmath108 . then the following assertions hold true . 1 . for @xmath109 , ( [ c1 ] ) bifurcates from @xmath110 to attractors @xmath111 , having the same homology as @xmath112 , with @xmath113 , which is connected if @xmath114 ; 2 . for any @xmath115 , @xmath116 can be expressed as @xmath117 3 . there is an open set @xmath118 with @xmath119 such that the attractor @xmath111 bifurcated from @xmath120 attracts @xmath121 in @xmath122 , where @xmath123 is the stable manifold of @xmath107 with co - dimension m. a crucial ingredient for the proof of the main theorems using the above attractor bifurcation theorem is an approximation formula for center manifold functions ; see @xcite . let @xmath37 and @xmath25 be decomposed into @xmath124 for @xmath125 near @xmath126 , where @xmath127 , @xmath128 are invariant subspaces of @xmath44 , such that @xmath129 , @xmath130 , @xmath131 closure of @xmath128 in @xmath25 . in addition , @xmath44 can be decomposed into @xmath132 such that for any @xmath133 near @xmath104 , @xmath134 where all eigenvalues of @xmath135 possess negative real parts , and the eigenvalues of @xmath136 possess nonnegative real parts at @xmath108 . furthermore , with @xmath137 given by ( [ c3 ] ) , let @xmath138 by the classical center manifold theorem ( see among others @xcite ) , there exists a neighborhood of @xmath104 given by @xmath139 for some @xmath140 , a neighborhood @xmath141 of @xmath142 , and a @xmath143 center manifold function @xmath144 , called the center manifold function , depending continuously on @xmath133 . then to investigate the dynamic bifurcation of ( [ c1 ] ) it suffices to consider the finite dimensional system as follows @xmath145 hence , an approximation formula for the center manifold function @xmath146 is crucial for the bifurcation and stability study . let the nonlinear operator @xmath33 be in the following form @xmath147 for some integer @xmath148 . here @xmath149 is a @xmath150-multilinear operator , and @xmath151 @xcite [ thd2 ] under the conditions ( [ d3 ] ) , ( [ d4 ] ) and ( [ d6 ] ) , the center manifold function @xmath152 can be expressed as @xmath153 where @xmath135 is as in ( [ d4 ] ) , @xmath154 the canonical projection , @xmath155 , and @xmath156 the eigenvectors of @xmath136 . the eigenvalue problem of the linearized problem of ( [ b1])-([b3 ] ) is given by [ e1 ] \ { & ( u - p ) + r t e - e u = u , + & t + w = t , + & u = 0 , . supplemented with ( [ b2 ] ) and ( [ b3 ] ) . for @xmath157 satisfying ( [ b2 ] ) and ( [ b3 ] ) , we expand the field @xmath158 in fourier series [ e2 ] ( x , y , z)=_j , k=-^_jk(z)e^i(j_1 x + k _ 2 y ) . plugging ( [ e2 ] ) into ( [ e1 ] ) , we obtain the following system of ordinary differential equations [ e3 ] \ { & ( d_jk u_jk - ij_1 p_jk)+v_jk = u_jk , + & ( d_jk v_jk - ik_2 p_jk)-u_jk = v_jk , + & d_jk w_jk - p_jk+r t_jk = ^-1w_jk , + & d_jk t_jk + w_jk = t_jk , + & ij_1 u_jk+ik_2 v_jk + w_jk=0 , + & u_jk _ z=0,1 = v_jk _ z=0,1= w_jk_z=0,1= t_jk_z=0,1=0 , . for @xmath159 , where @xmath160 , @xmath161 and @xmath162 . if @xmath163 , ( [ e3 ] ) can be reduced to a single equation for @xmath164 : @xmath165 for @xmath166 . thanks to ( [ e5 ] ) , @xmath167 can be expanded in a fourier sine series [ e6 ] w_jk(z)=_l=1^w_jkllz , for @xmath168 . substituting ( [ e6 ] ) into ( [ e4 ] ) , we see that the eigenvalues @xmath169 of the problem ( [ e1 ] ) satisfy the cubic equations @xmath170\beta \\ & \,\,\ , + \sigma^2 \gamma_{jkl}^6 -\sigma^2 r \alpha_{jk}^2 + \frac{l^2 \pi^2}{ro^2}=0 , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath18 and @xmath171 , where @xmath172 . in the following discussions , we let @xmath173,\\ & h_{jkl}(\beta)= \sigma r \alpha_{jk}^2 \gamma_{jkl}^{-2 } ( \beta + \sigma \gamma_{jkl}^2 ) , \\ & f_{jkl}(\beta)=g_{jkl}(\beta ) - h_{jkl}(\beta ) , \\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath174 , @xmath175 and @xmath176 be the zeros of @xmath177 with @xmath178 in the following discussions , we consider the following index sets : @xmath179 \1 . for @xmath180 , we define @xmath181 where @xmath182 it is not hard to see that @xmath183 and @xmath184 . \2 . for @xmath185 , we define @xmath186 where @xmath187 , @xmath188 and @xmath189 . it is easy to check that @xmath190 \3 . for @xmath191 , we define @xmath192 it is easy to check that @xmath193 and @xmath194 are invariant subspaces of the linear operator @xmath195 respectively , i.e. , @xmath196 and @xmath197 . the characteristic polynomial of @xmath198 ( resp . , @xmath199 ) is given by @xmath177 as defined in ( [ e8 ] ) . since @xmath193 ( resp.,@xmath194 ) is of dimension three , the ( generalized ) eigenvectors of @xmath200 , @xmath201 ( @xmath202 ) , form a basis of @xmath193 ( resp . , @xmath194 ) , i.e. , span@xmath203 ( resp . , span@xmath204 ) . if @xmath205 is a real zero of @xmath177 , the eigenvector corresponding to @xmath205 in @xmath193 ( resp . , @xmath194 ) is given by @xmath206 where [ e10 ] a_1()= , a_2()=. if @xmath207 ( imaginary numbers ) are zeros of @xmath177 , the ( generalized ) eigenvectors corresponding to @xmath208 and @xmath209 in @xmath193 ( resp . , @xmath194 ) are given by @xmath210 @xmath211 where @xmath212 the dual vector corresponding to @xmath213 ( resp . , @xmath214 ) is given by @xmath215 where [ e14 ] c_1()= , c_2()=. the dual vector @xmath216 ( resp . , @xmath217 ) satisfies @xmath218 for @xmath219 . we note that @xmath220 is orthogonal to @xmath221 for @xmath222 and @xmath193 is orthogonal to @xmath194 for @xmath191 . hence the dual vector @xmath216 ( resp . , @xmath217 ) satisfies @xmath223 in view of the fourier expansion , we see that @xmath224 is a basis of @xmath37 and @xmath225 is a basis of @xmath21 . hence , by the discussion above , we have the following conclusions . \a ) the set @xmath226 consists of all eigenvalues of @xmath227 , and the ( generalized ) eigenvectors of @xmath227 form a basis of @xmath37 . \b ) the set @xmath228 consists of all eigenvalues of @xmath229 , and the ( generalized ) eigenvectors of @xmath229 form a basis of @xmath21 . \c ) @xmath230 for each @xmath231 . [ le1 ] if @xmath8 is small , then @xmath232 for each @xmath233 . plugging @xmath234 into @xmath177 , we get @xmath235 , where @xmath236 hence , we only need to show that the real part of each zero of @xmath237 is strictly negative when @xmath8 is small . we observe that @xmath238 for all @xmath239 provided @xmath240 . therefore , if all zeros of @xmath237 are real numbers , we are done . for the case where only one of the zeros of @xmath237 is real , this real zero , @xmath241 , is a perturbation of @xmath242 . there exists an @xmath243 ( depending on @xmath7 only ) such that @xmath244 provided @xmath245 . this makes the real part of the other two zeros of @xmath237 strictly negative and the proof is complete . based on the above discussion , we know that only the eigenvalues in @xmath246 depend on the rayleigh number @xmath8 . hence , to study the principle of exchange of stabilities for problem ( [ e1 ] ) , it suffices to focus the problem on the set @xmath246 . we proceed with the following two cases . @xmath247 is a zero of @xmath177 if and only if the constant term of the polynomial @xmath177 is @xmath248 . in this case , we have @xmath249 hence the critical rayleigh number @xmath0 is given by [ e18 ] r_c_1= _ ( j , k , l)_1 \ { + } = + , for some @xmath250 . a careful analysis on ( [ e7 ] ) shows that @xmath251 ( @xmath252 ) , a purely imaginary number , is a zero of @xmath177 if and only if the following two equations hold true : @xmath253 \\ & \quad = \sigma^2 \gamma_{jkl}^6 -\sigma^2 r \alpha_{jk}^2 + \frac{l^2 \pi^2}{ro^2}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] in this case , we have @xmath254 plugging ( [ e20 ] ) into ( [ e19 ] ) , we derive an upper bound for @xmath255 , [ e21 ] ro^2 < , which could only hold true when @xmath256 . as in case 1 , the minimum of the right hand side of ( [ e19 ] ) is always obtain at @xmath257 . hence the critical rayleigh number @xmath1 is given by @xmath258 for some @xmath259 . in the case of @xmath256 , ( [ e21 ] ) with @xmath257 implies @xmath1 is smaller than @xmath0 . hence , for problem ( [ b1])-([b4 ] ) , @xmath0 is the first critical rayleigh number if @xmath260 and @xmath1 is the first critical rayleigh number if @xmath256 . therefore , the principle of exchange of stabilities is given by lemma [ le2 ] and lemma [ le6 ] . [ le2 ] for fixed @xmath261 and @xmath262 , suppose that @xmath263 minimizes the right hand side of ( [ e17 ] ) , then [ e23 ] _ j_1 k_1 11(r ) < 0 r < r_c_1 + = 0 r = r_c_1 + > 0 r > r_c_1 , [ e24 ] re _ jklq(r ) < 0 ( _ jk^2 , l ) ( _ j_1k_1 ^ 2 , 1 ) , q=1,2,3 , r r_c_1 . by the above discussion , we only need to show that the first eigenvalue crosses the imaginary axis . we note that @xmath264 is equivalent to @xmath265 , i.e. , @xmath266= \sigma r \alpha_{j_1 k_1}^2 \gamma_{j_1 k_1 1}^{-2 } ( \beta + \sigma \gamma_{j_1 k_1 1}^2).\ ] ] we see that both @xmath267 and @xmath268 are strictly increasing for @xmath269 ( since @xmath261 ) . let @xmath270 be the graph of @xmath271 and @xmath272 be the graph of @xmath273 as shown in figure [ fig2 ] . when @xmath274 , point @xmath275 , the intersecting point of @xmath270 and @xmath272 corresponding to @xmath276 ( i.e. , the @xmath169 coordinate of @xmath275 is @xmath276 ) , is on the @xmath277 axis . when @xmath8 increases ( resp . , decreases ) , @xmath275 becomes @xmath278 ( resp . , @xmath279 ) . this proves ( [ e23 ] ) and the proof is complete . [ rme3 ] 1 . in the proof of lemma [ le2 ] , as shown by ( [ e25 ] ) and figure [ fig2 ] , we see that , for @xmath280 , the first eigenvalue @xmath281 is a simple zero of @xmath282 . we have seen in section 5.1 that there are eigenvectors @xmath283 and @xmath284 corresponding to @xmath285 . therefore , the multiplicity of the first eigenvalue of @xmath286 ( resp . , @xmath287 ) is @xmath288 ( resp . , @xmath289 ) , where @xmath290 is the number of @xmath291 s ( @xmath292 ) satisfying @xmath293 hence , condition ( [ c6 ] ) guarantees that , for @xmath87 , the first eigenvalue of @xmath88 ( resp . , @xmath89 ) is real and of multiplicity two ( resp . , one ) . 2 . for the classical bnard problem without rotation , the second term on the right hand side of ( [ e17 ] ) , hence the second term on the right hand side of ( [ e18 ] ) , is not presented . therefore , the first critical rayleigh number of the classical bnard problem depends only on the aspect of ratio ; while the first critical rayleigh number of the rotating problem depends on the aspect of ratio , the prandtl number and the rossby number . and it is clear that the first critical rayleigh number of fast rotating flows is remarkably larger than the first critical rayleigh number of the classical bnard problem . this indicates that the rotating flows are much more stable than the non - rotating flows . @xmath0 is the first critical rayleigh number if the prandtl number is greater than one . for the case where the prandtl number is smaller than one , @xmath1 is the first critical rayleigh number and , in general , there are a few critical values between @xmath1 and @xmath0 . for @xmath294 , @xmath295 , we define @xmath296 let @xmath297 , then the right hand side of ( [ e18 ] ) could be expressed as @xmath298 , where @xmath299 ; and the second line of ( [ e22 ] ) could be expressed as @xmath300 , where @xmath301 . consider @xmath302 as shown in figure [ fig3 ] , it is easy to see that 1 . for @xmath303 , @xmath304 has only one critical number @xmath305 , 2 . @xmath306 if @xmath307 , 3 . @xmath308 if @xmath309 , 4 . @xmath310 is the global minimum of @xmath304 , and 5 . @xmath305 is strictly increasing in @xmath311 , hence , @xmath312 . in lemmas 5.4 and 5.5 , we consider the following different conditions @xmath313 [ le4 ] 1 . condition ( [ c6 ] ) holds true under the assumption ( [ e28 ] ) . 2 . generically , condition ( [ c6 ] ) holds true under the assumption ( [ e29 ] ) . 1 . under the assumption ( [ e28 ] ) , by c ) , we conclude that @xmath0 is only obtained at @xmath314 , i.e. @xmath315 . 2 . under the assumption ( [ e29 ] ) , there exists @xmath316 such that @xmath317 . we note that @xmath318 hence , by b ) and c ) , we conclude that @xmath319 i.e. , @xmath320 or @xmath321 . note that , by b ) and c ) , generically @xmath322 . the proof is complete . [ le5 ] 1 . condition ( [ c7 ] ) holds true under the assumption ( [ e30 ] ) . 2 . generically , condition ( [ c7 ] ) holds true under the assumption ( [ e31 ] ) . consider @xmath323 the rest part of the proof is the same as the proof of lemma [ le4 ] . [ le6 ] assume ( [ c7 ] ) , @xmath324 and @xmath255 satisfies ( [ e21 ] ) for @xmath325 , i.e. , @xmath326 , then @xmath327 ( @xmath328 ) is the only simple pair of complex eigenvalues of the problem ( [ e1 ] ) in space @xmath21 satisfying @xmath329 @xmath330 we only need to prove ( [ e32 ] ) . under the assumptions of the lemma together with ( [ e11 ] ) , ( [ e19 ] ) and ( [ e20 ] ) , by the discussion in case ( 2 ) at the beginning of this subsection , we know that @xmath331 is the only simple pair of complex eigenvalues of @xmath332 with @xmath333 . since @xmath334 ( real ) , @xmath335 and @xmath336 are zeros of @xmath337 , we know that @xmath338 hence ( [ e32 ] ) is equivalent to @xmath339 which is true as shown in figure [ fig4 ] . this completes the proof . [ le8 ] for fixed @xmath340 , @xmath341 and @xmath261 , @xmath342 as @xmath343 . more precisely , @xmath344 . since @xmath299 , by ( [ e27 ] ) , @xmath345 as @xmath343 hence , @xmath346 we are now in a position to reduce equations of ( [ b1])-([b4 ] ) to the center manifold . for any @xmath347 , we have @xmath348 under the assumption ( [ c6 ] ) , the first critical rayleigh number is given by [ f1 ] r_c_1 = + . in this case , the multiplicity of the first eigenvalue is two and the reduced equations of ( [ b1])-([b4 ] ) are given by @xmath349 . where [ f12 ] = - ( + ) / ( ( 1+a_1 c_1 ) + 1 + a_2 c_2 ) < 0 . a standard energy estimate on ( [ f11 ] ) together with the center manifold theory show that , for @xmath91 , @xmath92 is locally asymptotically stable for the problem ( [ b1])-([b4 ] ) . hence by theorem [ thd1 ] , the solutions to ( [ b1])-([b4 ] ) bifurcate from @xmath373 to an attractor @xmath96 . moreover , by ( [ f11])-([f12 ] ) together with theorem 5.10 in @xcite , we conclude that @xmath96 is homeomorphic to @xmath374 in @xmath25 . in this subsection , we prove that @xmath96 consists of steady state solutions . it is clear that the first eigenvalue of @xmath375 is simple for @xmath87 . by the kransnoselski bifurcation theorem ( see among others chow and hale @xcite and nirenberg @xcite ) , when @xmath8 crosses @xmath0 , the equations bifurcate from the basic solution to a steady state solution in @xmath23 . therefore the attractor @xmath376 contains at least one steady state solution . secondly , it s easy to check that the equations ( [ b1])-([b4 ] ) defined in @xmath25 are translation invariant in the @xmath15-direction . hence if @xmath377 is a steady state solution , then @xmath378 are steady state solutions as well . by the periodic condition in the @xmath15-direction , the set @xmath379 is a cycle homeomorphic to @xmath380 in @xmath25 . therefore the steady state of ( [ b1])-([b4 ] ) generates a cycle of steady state solutions . hence the bifurcated attractor @xmath376 consists of steady state solutions . the proof of theorem [ thc4 ] is complete . height 2pt depth -1.6pt width 23pt , _ geometric theory of incompressible flows with applications to fluid dynamics _ , vol . 119 of mathematical surveys and monographs , american mathematical society , providence , ri , 2005 . , _ topics in nonlinear functional analysis _ , courant institute of mathematical sciences new york university , new york , 1974 . with a chapter by e. zehnder , notes by r. a. artino , lecture notes , 19731974 . | the main objective of this article is to study the dynamics of the stratified rotating boussinesq equations , which are a basic model in geophysical fluid dynamics . first , for the case where the prandtl number is greater than one , a complete stability and bifurcation analysis near the first critical rayleigh number is carried out . second , for the case where the prandtl number is smaller than one , the onset of the hopf bifurcation near the first critical rayleigh number is established , leading to the existence of nontrivial periodic solutions . the analysis is based on a newly developed bifurcation and stability theory for nonlinear dynamical systems ( both finite and infinite dimensional ) by two of the authors @xcite . |
1302.5213 | the random phase approximation ( rpa ) for electron correlation was originally developed in the context of the many - body perturbation treatment of the uniform electron gas @xcite and later reformulated in the framework of density functional theory ( dft ) via the adiabatic - connection fluctuation - dissipation theorem @xcite . in the last years , rpa correlation witnessed an increasing interest in quantum chemistry @xcite , due to its ability to describe with good accuracy a rather large variety of reaction and interaction energies . in this context rpa is generally employed as a post kohn - sham ( ks ) approach where the exact exchange ( exx ) and the correlation energies are evaluated using the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions from a ks calculation with conventional exchange - correlation ( xc ) functionals . exx ks orbitals @xcite have been also employed via the optimized effective potential ( oep ) method , while for a fully variational approach self - consistent exx - rpa orbitals are required @xcite . in all cases practical applications of the method are often hindered by the the very slow convergence of the rpa - correlation energy with the basis set dimension @xcite , which is related to the electron cusp problem @xcite , in analogy with wavefunction methods . the cusp problem is strongly reduced for range - separated rpa @xcite , whereas for full - range rpa approaches extrapolation to the complete basis set ( cbs ) must be employed . basis set extrapolation to the cbs limit has been longley studied for post hartree - fock correlated methods , with the aim of reducing as much as possible the basis set truncation error without resorting to the brute force employment of extremely large basis sets . numerical work @xcite on various correlation treatments of the helium atom has shown that the basis set incompleteness error is approximately proportional to the inverse third power of the maximum angular momentum , provided that all angular momenta are radially saturated . however , the ideal conditions of fully saturated angular momenta in an atomic system are rather distant from those encountered in real applications on molecules with finite basis sets . nevertheless , the correlation energy has been empirically observed to converge regularly enough to allow the development of various accurate extrapolation schemes which have been assessed in several studies in literature @xcite . on the other hand , no such study has been performed for rpa correlation energies . in this paper we aim at filling this gap and shed light on the usefulness and limits of different extrapolation schemes for rpa correlation energies . in this respect the goal of the present work is to : ( 1 ) create a set of benchmark cbs rpa absolute correlation energies to be used as reference for future assessments ; ( 2 ) validate some extrapolation schemes , usually applied in the context of coupled cluster theory , for the calculation of cbs rpa absolute energies , including semiempirical techniques to approach the extrapolation from relatively small basis sets ; ( 3 ) test the convergence behavior of different basis sets and the reliability of the extrapolations schemes for atomization energies , which exploit a significant error cancellation effect . absolute correlation energies will be considered , as in many corresponding studies of correlated methods , because these converge regularly with the basis set and provide an ideal quantity for the study of extrapolation schemes . in this paper we focus on light elements because they provide a simpler convergence of the correlation energy and can be more easily investigated with large basis sets . rpa calculations were performed using the eigenvalues and the orbitals from dft calculations based on the perdew - burke - ernzerhof ( pbe ) exchange - correlation functional @xcite . in all calculations dunning s correlation - consistent basis sets @xcite ( cc - pv@xmath0z , @xmath1 ) augmented with core and core - valence basis functions @xcite were employed . these are hereafter denoted as v@xmath0zcv with @xmath0=4 , 5 , 6 , and 7 . augmented diffuse basis functions were not considered in the present work since they were shown to slow down rpa basis set convergence without bringing substantial benefits in most cases @xcite . also , no basis set superposition error correction was considered for atomization energies . for molecules experimental geometries were considered @xcite . all calculations were performed with the turbomole program package @xcite using the implementation described in ref . @xcite . [ cols="<,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] the inspection of tab . [ tab4 ] reveals that several approaches are capable to yield very good results , with mean absolute errors close to 1 mha and mean relative errors smaller than 1% . in particular , all the calculations using raw basis - set results ( except v4zcv ) perform remarkably well , showing a significantly better performance with respect to the case of absolute energies , thanks to the cancellation of systematic errors in the present case . interestingly little or no benefit comes instead from the use of extrapolation techniques . in fact , 67-extrapolation results are in line with v7zcv results , while 56-extrapolation atomization energies are even worst that v5zcv ones and of similar quality as the v4zcv results . this result shall be rationalized in terms of an inevitable small but random computational noise that affects the extrapolation data ( especially if small basis sets are used as a base for the extrapolation ) . the small inaccuracies of extrapolated data can be in fact almost irrelevant for absolute energies ( below 1 mha ) , but can easily sum to several mha in the case of atomization energies ( especially for many atoms molecules ) . finally , we remark the good performance of the semiempirical extrapolation method , which yields atomization energies in good agreement with the reference ones , with a mean absolute relative error of only 0.75% and very small maximum absolute deviation and standard deviation . the results of tab . [ tab4 ] show that the quality of each extrapolation procedure to yield accurate atomization energies can not be directly inferred from the results obtained for absolute energies , because atomization energies are energy differences and thus a complex error propagation can occur . as we showed this effect is more important for low - level approaches and is somehow amplified for extrapolated results , because of the presence of unsystematic errors due to the numerical procedure . it is thus finally important to note that this issue applies also for our reference atomization energies , that were obtained from the best estimated rpa absolute energies of tab . [ tab1 ] , although in this case we may expect the effect to be rather limited due to the high quality of the extrapolation . nevertheless , we have to remark that possibly errors of few mha are plausible for some systems , so that in general the set can not be fully considered as an accurate benchmark set of atomization energies , although it could be safely considered as reference for a qualitative discussion of the trends obtained from different extrapolation methods . the slow basis set convergence of the rpa correlation energy is a major problem for the development and the application of the method in quantum chemistry and solid - state physics . in fact , a careful assessment of the rpa methodology and related methods ( e.g. , rpa+ @xcite , rpa+se @xcite ) , requires the existence of a set of benchmark absolute and relative rpa - correlation energies as well as the availability of accurate extrapolation techniques . practical applications , on the other hand , would greatly benefit from efficient extrapolation schemes with well calibrated levels of confidence . surprisingly however only little effort has been dedicated in literature to study the cbs limit of rpa correlation energies and assess the effectiveness of different extrapolation procedures in this context . in this paper we aimed at pushing this work one step further and considered the problem in a more systematic way , constructing a benchmark set of reference rpa - correlation energies and studying the behavior of different extrapolation schemes in the rpa framework . our work can be summarized in the following conclusions : * the extremely slow convergence of the rpa correlation energy with the basis set dimension prevents the computation of highly accurate reference energies . already at the v7zcv level in fact the energies can be incorrect up to 10 mha . nevertheless , we showed that a careful extrapolation procedure allows to construct an accurate benchmark set with a well defined estimation of the uncertainty . in the present work we estimate our reference data to have an accuracy close to 1 mha for most of the systems . * we analyzed several two - point extrapolation formulas against our benchmark set of absolute rpa correlation energies . it turns out that good results can only be achieved if global parameters are optimized in eqs . ( [ e5 ] ) , ( [ e6 ] ) , and ( [ e7 ] ) , as to effectively reproduce high - order terms in the theoretical asymptotic energy expansion ( @xmath2 ) . when this procedure is followed all the considered formulas provide equivalent results . moreover , with a careful optimization of the global parameters very good results can also be achieved from 56-extrapolation procedures . * rpa correlation energies evaluated at the v4zcv level appear to be of too low quality to serve as a basis in an extrapolation procedure with globally optimized parameters . this fact indicates that in the case of 45-extrapolations high - order terms beyond the @xmath3 one , play a crucial role and are thus dominant in the asymptotic expansion . therefore , rpa energies obtained at the quadruple - zeta level of theory can not be considered well converged with respect to the one - particle expansion in basis set and shall not be used in applications . nevertheless , the introduction of atomic - based parameters within a semiempirical extrapolation scheme can strongly reduce the problem and provide extrapolated rpa absolute energies of good quality ( within 2 mha from the reference ) . the semiempirical extrapolation method can thus be considered as a good tool for the cbs extrapolation in rpa applications on large systems . * when energy differences are considered , an unpredictable error propagation occurs and accurate cbs results are even more hard to achieve than the absolute correlation energies . however , because an error cancellation occurs for the systematic errors ( e.g. systematic underestimation of the energy by incomplete basis sets ) we finally found that most approaches yield results that agree within 2 mha . because no highly accurate reference data exist to assess such small differences , no clear preference can be expressed for any of the considered approaches and 2 mha ( @xmath4 kcal / mol , @xmath5 mev ) must be considered the level of confidence of state - of - the - art rpa calculations on atomization energies . therefore , caution must be always employed when small energy difference are considered . we mention finally that , following the encouraging results of the present study , further investigations will be needed to assess in detail the basis set - dependence of rpa energies and the accuracy of extrapolation schemes for energy differences ( e.g. atomization energies ) , which are a main quantity in many practical computational studies . in fact , when energy differences are considered , an unpredictable error propagation may occur and accurate cbs results are harder to achieve than the absolute correlation energies , despite the former can be directly derived as an algebraic sum of the latter . from our calculations it can be easily seen indeed that all the approaches considered in this work yield very similar atomization energies for the molecules of the test set , with differences mostly below 2 - 3 mha . however , no clear trend can be identified between the different approaches , so that no highly accurate reference data can be established to assess such small differences . this traces back to the fact that systematic errors ( e.g. systematic underestimation of the energy by incomplete basis sets ) may be expected to cancel out in this case , but extrapolation procedures may introduce in general unsystematic errors which worsen the results with respect to the raw data obtained from the corresponding basis sets . we thank turbomole gmbh for providing us with the turbomole program package , and m. margarito for technical support . this work was funded by the erc starting grant fp7 project dedom , grant agreement no . 207441 . 99 bohm d , pines d ( 1953 ) phys rev 92:609 gell - mann m , brueckner ka ( 1957 ) phys rev 106:364 langreth dc , perdew jp ( 1977 ) phys rev b 15:2884 furche f ( 2001 ) phys rev b 64:195120 fuchs m , gonze x ( 2002 ) phys rev b 65:235109 furche f , van voorhis t ( 2005 ) j chem phys 122:164106 dobson jf , wang j , dinte bp , mclennan k , le hm ( 2005 ) int j quantum chem 101:579 scuseria ge , henderson tm , sorensen dc ( 2008 ) j chem phys 129:231101 grneis a , marsman m , harl j , schimka l , kresse g ( 2009 ) j chem phys 131:154115 janesko bg , scuseria ge ( 2009 ) j chem phys 131:154106 janesko bg , henderson tm , scuseria ge ( 2009 ) j chem phys 130:081105 toulouse j , gerber ic , jansen g , savin a , ngyn jg ( 2009 ) phys rev lett 102:096404 toulouse j , zhu w , ngyn jg , savin a ( 2010 ) phys rev a 82:032502 ruzsinszky a , perdew jp , csonka gi ( 2010 ) j chem theor comput 6:127 . nguyen hv , galli g ( 2010 ) j chem phys 132:044109 paier j , janesko bg , henderson tm , scuseria ge , grneis a , kresse g ( 2010 ) j chem phys 132:094103 eshuis h , yarkony j , furche f ( 2010 ) j chem phys 132:234114 jansen g , liu rf , ngyn jg ( 2010 ) j chem phys 133:154106 ren x , tkatchenko a , rinke p , scheffler m ( 2011 ) phys rev lett 106:153003 eshuis h , furche f ( 2011 ) j phys chem lett 2:983 ruzsinszky a , perdew jp , csonka gi ( 2011 ) j chem phys 134:114110 ngyn jg , liu rf , toulouse j , jansen g ( 2011 ) j chem theory comput 7:3116 heelmann a ( 2011 ) j chem phys 134:204107 eshuis h , bates je , furche f ( 2012 ) theor chem acc 131:1084 paier j , ren x , rinke p , scuseria ge , grneis a , kresse g , scheffler m ( 2012 ) new j phys 14:043002 ren x , rinke p , blum v , wieferink j , tkatchenko a , sanfilippo a , reuter k , scheffler m ( 2012 ) new j phys 14:053020 ren x , rinke p , joas c , scheffler m ( 2012 ) j mater sci , doi : 10.1007/s10853 - 012 - 6570 - 4 heelmann a , grling a ( 2010 ) mol phys 108:359 heelmann a , grling a ( 2011 ) phys rev lett 106:093001 heelmann a , grling a ( 2011 ) mol phys 109:2473 godby rw , schlter m , sham lj ( 1986 ) phys rev lett 56:2415 kotani t ( 1998 ) j phys cond matt 10:9241 niquet yn , fuchs m , gonze x ( 2003 ) phys rev a 68:032507 grning m , marini a , rubio a ( 2006 ) j chem phys 124:154108 hellgren m , von barth u ( 2007 ) phys rev b 76:075107 hellgren m , von barth u ( 2010 ) j chem phys 132:044101 hellgren m , rohr dr , gross eku ( 2012 ) j chem phys 136:034106 verma p , bartlett rj ( 2012 ) j chem phys 136:044105 harl j , kresse g ( 2008 ) phys rev b 77:045136 eshuis h , furche f ( 2012 ) j chem phys 136:084105 janesko bg , henderson tm , scuseria ge ( 2009 ) j chem phys 131:034110 zhu w , toulouse j , savin a , ngyn jg ( 2010 ) j chem phys 132:244108 schwartz c ( 1962 ) phys rev 126:1015 schwartz c ( 1963 ) methods comput phys 2:241 carroll dp , silverstone hj , metzger rm ( 1979 ) j chem phys 71:4142 schmidt hm , von hirschhausen h ( 1983 ) phys rev a 28:3179 hill rn ( 1985 ) j chem phys 83:1173 kutzelnigg w , morgan iii jd ( 1992 ) j chem phys 96:4484 schmidt hm , linderberg j ( 1994 ) phys rev a 49:4404 mller t , basis set accuracy and calibration in quantum chemistry , in computational nanoscience : do it yourself ! , grotendorst j , blugel s , marx d ( eds . ) , john von neumann institute for computing , julich , nic series , vol . 31 , isbn 3 - 00 - 017350 - 1 , pp . 19 - 43 , 2006 . feller d , peterson ka , grant hill j ( 2011 ) j chem phys 135:044102 barkowies d ( 2007 ) j chem phys 127:084105 barkowies d ( 2007 ) j chem phys 127:164109 varandas ajc ( 2007 ) j chem phys 126:244105 perdew jp , burke k , ernzerhof m ( 1996 ) phys rev lett 77:3865 dunning jr th ( 1989 ) j chem phys 90:1007 woon de , dunning jr . th ( 1994 ) j chem phys 100:2975 feller d , peterson ka ( 1999 ) j chem phys 110:8384 feller d , sordo ja ( 2000 ) j chem phys 113:485 woon de , dunning jr . th ( 1995 ) j chem phys 103:4572 peterson ka , dunning jr . th ( 2002 ) j chem phys 117:10548 grant hill j , mazumder s , peterson ka ( 2010 ) j chem phys 132:054108 boyd drj ( 1955 ) j chem phys 23:922 venkateswarlu p , gordy w ( 1955 ) j chem phys 23:1200 redington rl , olson wb , cross pc ( 1962 ) j chem phys 36:1311 herzberg g , electronic spectra and electronic structure of polyatomic molecules , van nostrand , new york , 1966 . sverdlov lm , kovner ma , krainov ep , `` vibrational spectra of polyatomic molecules '' wiley , new york , 1974 . tsuboi m , overend j ( 1975 ) j mol spec 52:256 hirota e ( 1979 ) j mol spect 77:213 hoy ar , bunker pr ( 1979 ) j mol spect 74:1 huber kp , herzberg g , molecular spectra and molecular structure . constants of diatomic molecules , van nostrand reinhold co. , 1979 . herbst e , messer jk , delucia fc ( 1984 ) j mol spect 108:42 junttila ml , lafferty wj , burkholder jb ( 1994 ) j mol spect 164:583 gurvich lv , veyts iv , alcock cb , thermodynamic properties of individual substances , fouth edition , hemisphere pub . co. , new york , 1989 . kuchitsu k ( editor ) `` structure of free polyatomic molecules - basic data '' springer , berlin , 1998 . nist diatomic spectral database ( www.physics.nist.gov/physrefdata/molspec/diatomic/index.html ) turbomole v6.2 2010 , a development of university of karlsruhe and forschungszentrum karlsruhe gmbh , 1989 - 2007 , turbomole gmbh , since 2007 ; available from http://www.turbomole.com . kutzelnigg w ( 1985 ) theor chem acta 68:445 helgaker t , klopper w , koch h , noga j ( 1997 ) j chem phys 106:9639 halkier a , helgaker t , jrgensen p , klopper w , koch h , olsen j , wilson ak ( 1998 ) chem phys lett 286:243 martin jml ( 1996 ) chem phys lett 259:669 truhlar dg ( 1998 ) chem phys lett 294:45 fast pl , sanchez ml , truhlar dg ( 1999 ) j chem phys 111:2921 pitok m , riley ke , neogrdy p , hobza p ( 2008 ) chemphyschem 9:1636 | we construct a reference benchmark set for atomic and molecular random - phase - approximation ( rpa ) correlation energies in a density functional theory ( dft ) framework at the complete basis set limit . this set is used to evaluate the accuracy of some popular extrapolation schemes for rpa all - electron molecular calculations . the results indicate that for absolute energies accurate results , clearly outperforming raw data , are achievable with two - point extrapolation schemes based on quintuple- and sextuple - zeta basis sets . moreover , we show that results in good agreement with the benchmark can also be also obtained by using a semiempirical extrapolation procedure based on quadruple- and quintuple - zeta basis sets . finally , we analyze the performance of different extrapolation schemes for atomization energies . |
astro-ph0405199 | the x - ray source ms1603.6 + 2600 was discovered in the einstein extended medium sensitivity survey @xcite and associated with a faint ( @xmath0 ) optical counterpart designated uw crb @xcite . its nature has remained a puzzle . @xcite found the counterpart to be an eclipsing binary with an orbital period of 111.04min and considered the source to be either a cataclysmic variable or low - mass x - ray binary ( lmxb ) hosting a neutron star . the emission line spectrum and optical to x - ray flux ratio favored the lmxb interpretation , with an accretion disk corona ( adc ) source most likely . the implied distance was large , 3080kpc , making this high latitude source a halo object . @xcite reconsidered these possibilities and proposed another alternative a quiescent low - mass x - ray binary , likely a black hole system , which is much closer to us . an important clue was subsequently provided by @xcite who identified a strong x - ray flare in _ asca _ data . while this appeared to resemble a type - i x - ray burst , the authors did not consider this identification conclusive . if the event was a type - i burst then it was faint , indicating either a very distant object in the halo , or an adc source . based on the x - ray lightcurve , @xcite favored the former of these interpretations , arguing that the source is a dipper rather than an adc source . finally , @xcite reported new _ chandra _ observations of the source , and favored the adc interpretation , although they allowed that a quiescent system was still possible if the earlier x - ray flare was not a type - i burst . they rejected the distant dipper scenario , arguing that the optical luminosity would then be too high for a compact 2hr binary . from a more theoretical standpoint , @xcite considered several evolutionary scenarios for the lmxb case , including degenerate and non - degenerate hydrogen rich mass donors and evolved helium stars . again , bursts could be a crucial diagnostic . the presence , recurrence time , and duration of bursts can discriminate between systems with different mass transfer rates ( e.g. , the degenerate and non - degenerate cases discussed by @xcite ) , and the burst properties will be sensitive to the chemical composition of the accreted material . to date , the only published x - ray burst from this source was that reported by @xcite , and this only yielded 60counts . it is possible to also search for bursts in the optical , as the optical counterpart , while faint , is accessible to rapid photometry . type - i x - ray bursts are expected to be manifested in the optical via reprocessed x - ray emission . this behavior has been widely seen in many other lmxbs for several decades ( e.g. , @xcite and many subsequent works ) . optical bursts are dramatic , involving a brightening of a factor @xmath1 . ultraviolet bursts are also present and are even more dramatic @xcite . we report here rapid optical photometry of uw crb . the primary goal of the program was to resolve the flickering contamination of the orbital variability , and this study will be presented separately . however , several optical bursts were serendipitously discovered , and we discuss those here . uw crb was observed over several nights from 2004 april 1626 using the argos fast ccd camera @xcite on the mcdonald observatory 2.1 m telescope . a total of 25hrs of good data were obtained ; details are provided in table [ logtable ] . observations were obtained with a broadband @xmath2 filter ( rolyn optics no.66.2475 , bandpass @xmath3 ) to maximize count rates and hence allow exposure times of 5 or 10s . the data were taken as a continuous sequence of images with negligible intervening dead - time . conditions were mostly near - photometric with 12arcsec seeing and no moon . the nights of april 18 , 20 , and 26 experienced poorer transparency and/or seeing . lcccc date & ut range & good & exposure & bursts + ( 2004 ) & & time ( ks ) & time ( s ) & + april 16 & 08:04:2111:43:11 & 11.4 & 10 & 1 + april 18 & 10:14:5311:29:03 & 4.1 & 10 & 0 + april 20 & 06:28:4011:25:55 & 5.8 & 10 & 0 + april 21 & 08:01:0511:37:65 & 13.0 & 10 & 1 + april 22 & 07:39:1311:26:33 & 13.6 & 5 & 1 + april 23 & 05:43:0911:31:19 & 20.9 & 5 & 1 + april 25 & 09:20:3411:40:34 & 8.0 & 5 & 0 + april 26 & 05:35:1106:58:11 & 4.8 & 5 & 0 + & 06:58:2610:45:36 & 9.0 & 10 & 0 + data reduction employed a combination of iraf routines to generate calibration files and then a custom idl pipeline to apply calibrations and extract photometry . bias structure and dark current were subtracted using many dark exposures of the same duration as the object frames . residual time - dependent bias variations were removed using two partial bad columns which are not light sensitive . sensitivity variations were removed using flat - field exposures of the inside of the dome ; we verified that this flattened the average sky background and hence that no illumination correction was necessary . photometry was extracted using standard aperture photometry techniques . for each lightcurve , the aperture was chosen to minimize the scatter between stars c and v of @xcite , and differential photometry of uw crb was then performed relative to star c. adopted apertures were typically 1.01.5arcsec in radius . we show the lightcurves containing bursts in fig . [ orbitfig ] . these exhibit a typical range of morphologies for this source @xcite , with eclipses sometimes being very deep , and sometimes barely detectable . superposed on the orbital modulations and low - level flickering are several very sharp , large amplitude burst - like events , involving a flux increase of a factor of 23 . we will discuss their origin in section [ discussionsection ] , but here we will anticipate the conclusion by characterizing them in the same terms commonly used for type - i x - ray bursts . the events appear to be real , being resolved in time and exhibiting no anomalies in the point spread function ( psf ) . event 2 is of lower brightness than the others , but also appears resolved in time and has a normal psf . to characterize the bursts we fit a simple model consisting of an instantaneous rise and exponential decay . as the burst peak is unresolved in the data , we rebin this model to match the data in fitting . free parameters are the burst amplitude , start - time , and e - folding decay time . expanded views of each burst are shown in fig . [ burstfig ] together with the best fitting models . results are summarized in table [ burstfittable ] , based on fitting data from @xmath4s to @xmath5s . we quote the relative fluence , expressed as individual burst fluence values divided by the mean fluence of bursts 1 , 3 , 4 , and 5 , and the burst durations @xmath6 , defined by @xcite as the burst fluence divided by the peak flux . the latter is obviously crudely constrained as the peaks are not actually resolved . for both quantities we quote both values from the model fit and those derived directly from the data . the relative fluences derived are similar with both methods . the durations differ significantly , however . durations derived from the data probably overestimate the burst duration , as the burst peak is unresolved and hence the peak flux will be underestimated . in contrast , the model assumes a sharper peak than is seen in type - i bursts , so will underestimate the duration compared to such bursts . hence the two values obtained for each burst should bracket its true duration . given that we do not resolve the peak , this is probably the best estimate that can be made . , fluxes are relative to the source mean brightness and so can be directly compared . the persistent level has been subtracted off using fluxes immediately before and after each burst . ] lccccc burst & & & + & model & observed & & model & observed + 1 & 0.91 & 0.93 & & 7.8 & 15.2 + 2 & 0.43 & 0.45 & & 13.6 & 28.9 + 3 & 1.11 & 1.09 & & 15.0 & 25.3 + 4 & 0.90 & 0.92 & & 10.7 & 18.2 + 5 & 1.08 & 1.06 & & 12.1 & 17.2 + the bursts are , with the exception of the weak event 2 , very uniform in properties . the burst fluence is constant to within 10% , and burst durations ( including event 2 ) are all consistent with a value of 515s if measured from the model ( probably an underestimate ) , or 1530s from the unresolved data ( an overestimate ) . `` true '' values of the burst duration ( in the sense of @xcite ) are likely to be in the 1020s range for these bursts ( for example , events 4 and 5 which are better resolved ) . burst recurrence times can be crudely estimated from the data , although are subject to small number statistics and sampling problems . we observed four full bursts in 90.6ks ( 25.2hrs ) of good data , or an average of 1 per 6.3hrs . if the bursts occur randomly ( i.e. , as poisson distributed events ) then recurrence times of between 3.8 and 11hrs have a 10% or greater chance of producing 4 events in this period ( i.e. , longer or shorter recurrence times would be excluded at 90% confidence ) . of course , if the events are type - i x - ray bursts then they are not distributed as poisson events but occur quasi - regularly . in that case , the statistics could be biased by our once - per - day sampling . more robust constraints are that the longest period continuously observed without a burst being seen is 3.5hrs , and the shortest period between _ observed _ bursts is 21.1hrs . both arguments suggest that an average recurrence time of much less than 4hrs is very unlikely . recurrence times of up to @xmath7hrs are possible , or around 24hrs if they were synchronized with our observations , and irregular enough to allow intervals as short as 21.1hrs . it has already been suggested by @xcite that a type - i x - ray burst was seen by _ asca_. the optical events that we see also exhibit characteristics typical of type - i bursts . the implied duration of @xmath8s , the fast rise and slow decay , and optical brightening of a factor @xmath9 are all similar to reprocessed optical bursts seen in other objects ( e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; and other works ) . the burst frequency , one per @xmath10hrs , is also normal . event 2 breaks the pattern of otherwise uniform burst fluences , but has a similar duration to the other events . it is also the only burst seen in the same lightcurve as another , suggesting that it could be a mini - burst produced when the first burst ( event 1 ) leaves unspent fuel on the neutron star surface . such behavior is seen in other lmxbs ( e.g. , @xcite ) . the uniformity of fluences also presents suggestive , if not conclusive , evidence for the location of reprocessing of the bursts . since uw crb is a high inclination system , if the burst reprocessing were dominated by the inner face of the companion star , we would expect large changes in the brightness of optical bursts dependent on orbital phase . in particular , event 3 occurs near phase 0.5 when the inner face of the companion is viewed nearly face - on , hence should be stronger than the other bursts which all appear to occur in eclipse ingress or egress . this is not seen , indicating that the burst reprocessing is probably dominated by the disk . @xcite suggested that uw crb might be a quiescent lmxb , possibly harboring a black hole . in this case an alternative flaring mechanism is needed . quiescent lmxbs containing both black holes and neutron stars do undergo relatively rapid optical flaring ( e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ) , and this behavior was already considered by @xcite as a possible explanation for the x - ray flare of @xcite . indeed , the black hole candidate xte j1650500 has exhibited _ non - thermal _ x - ray flares otherwise very similar to type - i bursts in a low state @xcite . in the case of a062000 at least , the optical events can be relatively rapid , occurring on timescales comparable to those seen here @xcite . while the observed amplitudes are much smaller , that is probably a consequence of dilution of the accretion light by the companion star , and the undiluted disk light could undergo variations of a factor of two or more . in spite of these similarities , the lightcurves shown in fig . [ orbitfig ] appear completely different to those of quiescent lmxbs . the burst - like events we see are single discrete events , and do not appear to belong to the general range of flickering behavior . the similarity of burst fluences is also rather unlike the kind of stochastic events seen in quiescent lmxbs to date . we therefore consider this explanation of the bursts to be very unlikely , and that the type - i burst interpretation is far more plausible . now that we have seen both an x - ray burst - like event @xcite , and multiple optical events , it is hard to escape the conclusion that uw crb is an x - ray burster . this immediately rules out white dwarf and black hole models for the system ; the compact object is a neutron star . the burst properties and recurrence time further constrain the accretion rate . the short burst recurrence time rules out a quiescent system . such systems can exhibit type - i bursts , but the recurrence time is estimated to be 1060yrs , or even more @xcite , a direct consequence of the very low accretion rate onto the neutron star . the probable 412hr recurrence time and 1020s burst duration are both typical of intermediate luminosity bursting lmxbs ( @xcite ; @xcite ) and suggest that uw crb is not accreting at an unusually low rate ; hence its low x - ray brightness must indicate either extreme distance or an adc source as discussed in section [ introsection ] . in contrast , for example , aql x-1 was observed to exhibit optical bursts lasting over a minute and recurring once per hour @xcite . both short recurrence times and long bursts are believed to be often associated with low accretion rates @xcite , yet are not seen in uw crb . it is also of value to compare our observations with those of gs 182624 @xcite . both gs 182624 and uw crb are neutron star lmxbs having orbital periods @xmath11hr ; thus the sizes of the two systems should be very similar . if we assume that the intrinsic optical burst luminosity is simply a function of the x - ray burst strength and reprocessing disk area ( and hence orbital period ) , then we might expect similar luminosity reprocessed bursts in the two systems , assuming that x - ray bursts have comparable peak luminosities , and similar disk geometries . gs 182624 is a low - inclination system , however , whereas uw crb is eclipsing and hence high inclination . in a high inclination system we see less projected disk area , so if reprocessing is dominated by the disk ( as suggested by the lack of phase dependence in the optical burst fluences ) , then we would expect to observe weaker optical bursts at a given distance . this is not the case , however ; both uw crb and gs 182624 are of comparable optical brightness and exhibit optical bursts rising to a peak @xmath12 the persistent optical level , indicating that the observed optical burst flux is actually comparable in the two systems . this would imply , subject to the assumptions made , that uw crb is somewhat closer than gs 182624 , or at least not much further away . the distance to gs 182624 is estimated at less than @xmath13kpc by @xcite , so unless bursts in uw crb are substantially more luminous than in gs 182624 , or reprocessing into optical emission is much more efficient , we would expect a comparably nearby distance for uw crb . this contradicts the extreme distances inferred for the dipper scenario ( e.g. , 75kpc @xcite ) and instead favors the adc model . note that this argument is essentially similar to that made by @xcite , but complements it as we have used the optical burst brightness rather than the persistent level . the argument is approximate and model dependent , but is sufficient to indicate that uw crb should not be @xmath14 further away than gs 182624 as has been previously suggested . we have reported the discovery of several resolved optical bursts from uw crb . these are almost certainly reprocessed type - i x - ray bursts , clarifying several characteristics of the source . i ) for type - i bursts , the compact object must be a neutron star rather than a black hole or white dwarf . ii ) the burst rate is relatively high , indicating an active rather than quiescent system , and thus a distance greater than a few kpc . iii ) the optical burst flux is comparable to the similar source gs 182624 , suggesting a comparable distance ( @xmath15kpc ) . it is thus most likely that uw crb is an adc source ( as also argued by @xcite ) rather than a distant dipper . given its high galactic latitude and intermediate distance , however , it must still be situated in the galactic halo . rih is supported by nasa through hubble fellowship grant # hf-01150.01-a awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc . , for nasa , under contract nas 5 - 26555 . we are indebted to ed nather and anjum mukadam for making argos available to the mcdonald community and providing considerable assistance in its use , and also grateful to brad schaefer for discussions and constructive skepticism on the first of the bursts . this work has made use of the nasa ads abstract service . | we report the discovery of several optical burst - like events from the low - mass x - ray binary ms 1603.6 + 2600 ( uw crb ) . the events last for a few tens of seconds , exhibit a very fast rise and slow decay , and involve optical brightening of a factor of 23 . the flares appear distinct from the lower level flickering and instead strongly resemble reprocessed type - i x - ray bursts as seen in a number of other neutron star low - mass x - ray binaries . in conjunction with the previously reported candidate x - ray burst , these confirm that the compact object in uw crb is a neutron star . we examine the optical burst brightness and recurrence times and discuss how the nature of the system can be constrained . we conclude that the source is most likely an accretion disk corona source at an intermediate distance , rather than a nearby quiescent system or very distant dipper . |
1609.04524 | detecting a very weak signal which is almost inaccessible within the classical ( i.e. , non - quantum ) regime is one of the most important subjects in quantum information science . a strong motivation to devise such an ultra - precise sensor stems from the field of gravitational wave detection @xcite . in fact , a variety of linear sensors composed of opto - mechanical oscillators have been proposed @xcite , and several experimental implementations of those systems in various scales have been reported @xcite . it is well known that in general a linear sensor is subjected to two types of fundamental noises , i.e. , the _ back - action noise _ and the _ shot noise_. as a consequence , the measurement noise is lower bounded by the _ standard quantum limit ( sql ) _ @xcite , which is mainly due to the presence of back - action noise . hence , high - precision detection of a weak signal requires us to devise a sensor that evades the back - action noise and eventually beats the sql ; i.e. , we need to have a sensor achieving _ back - action evasion ( bae)_. in fact , many bae methods have been developed especially in the field of gravitational wave detection , e.g. , the variational measurement technique @xcite or the quantum locking scheme @xcite . moreover , towards more accurate detection , recently we find some high - level approaches to design a bae sensor , based on those specific bae methods . for instance , ref . @xcite provides a systematic comparison of several bae methods and gives an optimal solution . also systems and control theoretical methods have been developed to synthesize a bae sensor for a specific opto - mechanical system @xcite ; in particular , the synthesis is conducted by connecting an auxiliary system to a given plant system by _ direct - interaction _ @xcite or _ coherent feedback _ @xcite . along this research direction , therefore , in this paper we set the goal to develop a general systems and control theory for engineering a sensor achieving bae , for both the coherent feedback and the direct - interaction configurations . the key tool used here is the _ geometric control theory _ @xcite , which had been developed a long time ago . this is indeed a beautiful theory providing a variety of controller design methods for various purposes such as the non - interacting control and the disturbance decoupling problem , but , to our best knowledge , it has not been applied to problems in quantum physics . actually in this paper we first demonstrate that the general synthesis problem of a bae sensor can be formulated and solved within the framework of geometric control theory , particularly the above - mentioned disturbance decoupling problem . + this paper is organized as follows . section [ sec:2 ] is devoted to some preliminaries including a review of the geometric control theory , the general model of linear quantum systems , and the idea of bae . then , in section [ sec:3 ] , we provide the general theory for designing a coherent feedback controller achieving bae , and demonstrate an example for an opto - mechanical system . in section [ sec:4 ] , we discuss the case of direct interaction scheme , also based on the geometric control theory . finally , in section [ sec:5 ] , for a realistic opto - mechanical system subjected to a thermal environment ( the perfect bae is impossible in this case ) , we provide a convenient method to find an approximated bae controller and show how much the designed controller can suppress the noise . + for a matrix @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 represent the transpose , hermitian conjugate , and element - wise complex conjugate of @xmath4 , respectively ; i.e. , @xmath5 , @xmath6 , and @xmath7 . @xmath8 and @xmath9 denote the real and imaginary parts of a complex number @xmath10 . @xmath11 and @xmath12 denote the zero matrix and the @xmath13 identity matrix . @xmath14 and @xmath15 denote the kernel and the image of a matrix @xmath4 , i.e. , @xmath16 and @xmath17 . let us consider the following _ classical _ linear time - invariant system : @xmath18 where @xmath19 is a vector of system variables , @xmath20 and @xmath21 are vectors of input and output , respectively . @xmath22 , and @xmath23 are real matrices . in the laplace domain , the input - output relation is represented by @xmath24 where @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the laplace transforms of @xmath27 and @xmath28 , respectively . @xmath29 is called the _ transfer function_. in this subsection , we assume @xmath30 . now we describe the geometric control theory , for the disturbance decoupling problem @xcite . the following _ invariant subspaces _ play a key role in the theory . * definition 1 : * let @xmath31 be a linear map . then , a subspace @xmath32 is said to be @xmath4-_invariant _ , if @xmath33 . * definition 2 : * given a linear map @xmath31 and a subspace im@xmath34 @xmath35 , a subspace @xmath32 is said to be @xmath36-_invariant _ , if @xmath37 . * definition 3 : * given a linear map @xmath31 and a subspace ker@xmath38 @xmath35 , a subspace @xmath39 is said to be @xmath40-_invariant _ , if @xmath41 . * definition 4 : * assume that @xmath42 is @xmath40-invariant , @xmath43 is @xmath36-invariant , and @xmath44 . then , @xmath45 is said to be a @xmath46-pair . from definitions 2 and 3 , we have the following two lemmas . * lemma 1 : * @xmath32 is @xmath36-invariant if and only if there exists a matrix @xmath47 such that @xmath48 * lemma 2 : * @xmath32 is @xmath40-invariant if and only if there exists a matrix @xmath49 such that @xmath50 the disturbance decoupling problem is described as follows . the system of interest is represented , in an extended form of eq . , as @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the disturbance and @xmath53 is the output to be regulated . @xmath54 and @xmath55 are real matrices . the other output @xmath28 may be used for constructing a feedback controller ; see fig . [ fig_feedbackframework ] . the disturbance @xmath52 can degrade the control performance evaluated on @xmath53 . thus it is desirable if we can modify the system structure by some means so that eventually @xmath52 dose not affect at all on @xmath53 . to @xmath56 is zero for all @xmath57 , for the modified system . or equivalently , the controllable subspace with respect to @xmath52 is contained in the unobservable subspace with respect to @xmath53 . ] this control goal is called the disturbance decoupling . here we describe a specific feedback control method to achieve this goal ; note that , as shown later , the direct - interaction method for linear quantum systems can also be described within this framework . the controller configuration is illustrated in fig . [ fig_feedbackframework ] ; that is , the system modification is carried out by combining an auxiliary system ( controller ) with the original system ( plant ) , so that the whole closed - loop system satisfies the disturbance decoupling condition . the controller with variable @xmath58 is assumed to take the following form : @xmath59 where @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 , and @xmath63 are real matrices . then , the closed - loop system defined in the augmented space @xmath64 is given by @xmath65 & = \left[\begin{array}{cc } a+bd_{\scriptscriptstyle k}c & bc_{\scriptscriptstyle k}\\ b_{\scriptscriptstyle k}c & a_{\scriptscriptstyle k}\\ \end{array}\right ] \left[\begin{array}{c } x\\ x_{{\scriptscriptstyle k}}\\ \end{array}\right ] + \left[\begin{array}{c } e\\ o\\ \end{array}\right ] d , ~ \nonumber \\ z&=\left[\begin{array}{cc } h & o\\ \end{array}\right ] \left[\begin{array}{c } x\\ x_{{\scriptscriptstyle k}}\\ \end{array}\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the control goal is to design @xmath66 so that , in eq . , the disturbance signal @xmath52 dose not appear in the output @xmath53 : see the below footnote . here , let us define @xmath67 , \label{eq_extended_matrixae}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , and @xmath71 . then , the following theorem gives the solvability condition for the disturbance decoupling problem . * theorem 1 : * for the closed - loop system , the disturbance decoupling problem via the dynamical feedback controller has a solution if and only if there exists a @xmath46-pair @xmath72 satisfying @xmath73 note that this condition does not depend on the controller matrices to be designed . the following corollary can be used to check if the solvability condition is satisfied . * corollary 1 : * for the closed - loop system , the disturbance decoupling problem via the dynamical feedback controller has a solution if and only if @xmath74 where @xmath75 is the maximum element of @xmath36-invariant subspaces contained in @xmath76 , and @xmath77 is the minimum element of @xmath40-invariant subspaces containing @xmath78 . these subspaces can be computed by the algorithms given in appendix a. once the solvability condition described above is satisfied , then we can explicitly construct the controller matrices @xmath79 . the following intersection and projection subspaces play a key role for this purpose ; that is , for a subspace @xmath80 , let us define @xmath81 \in \mathcal{v}_{{\scriptscriptstyle e } } \right\ } , ~ \\ \mathcal{v}_{{\scriptscriptstyle p}}:&= \left\{x \in \mathcal{x}~\bigg| \left[\begin{array}{c } x\\ x_{{\scriptscriptstyle k}}\\ \end{array}\right ] \in \mathcal{v}_{{\scriptscriptstyle e}},~ \exists { x}_{{\scriptscriptstyle k } } \in \mathcal{x}_{{\scriptscriptstyle k } } \right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , the following theorem is obtained : * theorem 2 : * suppose that @xmath82 is a @xmath83-pair . then , there exist @xmath84 , @xmath85 , and @xmath63 such that @xmath86 and @xmath87 hold , where @xmath88 . moreover , there exists @xmath89 with @xmath90 , and @xmath91 has an invariant subspace @xmath92 such that @xmath93 and @xmath94 . also , @xmath95 satisfies @xmath96 where @xmath97 is a linear map satisfying @xmath98 . in fact , under the condition given in theorem 2 , let us define the following augmented subspace @xmath99 : @xmath100 \bigg|~ x \in \mathcal{v}_{2 } \right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , @xmath93 and @xmath94 hold , and we have @xmath101 & = \left[\begin{array}{cc } a+bd_{\scriptscriptstyle k}c & bc_{\scriptscriptstyle k}\\ b_{\scriptscriptstyle k}c & a_{\scriptscriptstyle k}\\ \end{array}\right ] \left[\begin{array}{c } x\\ nx\\ \end{array}\right ] \nonumber\\ & = \left[\begin{array}{c } ( a+bf)x\\ n(a+bf)x\\ \end{array}\right ] \in \mathcal{v}_{{\scriptscriptstyle e}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] implying that @xmath102 is actually @xmath91-invariant . now suppose that theorem 1 holds , and let us take the @xmath46-pair @xmath82 satisfying eq . . then , together with the above result ( @xmath103 ) , we have @xmath104^{\top } \subseteq \mathcal{v}_{{\scriptscriptstyle e } } \subseteq { { \rm ker}\hspace{0.07cm}}[h~o]$ ] . this implies that @xmath52 must be contained in the unobservable subspace with respect to @xmath53 , and thus the disturbance decoupling is realized . here we describe a general linear quantum system composed of @xmath105 bosonic subsystems . the @xmath106-th mode can be modeled as a harmonic oscillator with the canonical conjugate pairs ( or quadratures ) @xmath107 and @xmath108 satisfying the canonical commutation relation ( ccr ) @xmath109 . let us define the vector of quadratures as @xmath110^{\top}$ ] . then , the ccrs are summarized as @xmath111 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath112 is a @xmath113 block diagonal matrix . the linear quantum system is an open system coupled to @xmath114 environment fields via the interaction hamiltonian @xmath115 , where @xmath116 is the field annihilation operator satisfying @xmath117 . also @xmath118 is given by @xmath119 with @xmath120 . in addition , the system is driven by the hamiltonian @xmath121 with @xmath122 . then , the heisenberg equation of @xmath123 is given by @xmath124 where @xmath125 is defined by @xmath126 = \left[\begin{array}{cc } ( \hat{a}_j+\hat{a}_j^*)/\sqrt{2 } \\ ( \hat{a}_j-\hat{a}_j^*)/\sqrt{2 } i \\ \end{array}\right].\ ] ] the matrices are given by @xmath127 and @xmath128 with @xmath129^\top \in \mathbb{r}^{2 \times 2n}$ ] . also , the instantaneous change of the field operator @xmath125 via the system - field coupling is given by @xmath130 summarizing , the linear quantum system is characterized by the dynamics and the output , which are exactly of the same form as those in eq . ( @xmath131 in this case ) . however note that the system matrices have to satisfy the above - described special structure , which is equivalently converted to the following _ physical realizability condition _ @xcite : @xmath132 the opto - mechanical oscillator illustrated in fig . [ fig_opticalsensor ] is a linear quantum system , which serves as a sensor for a very weak signal . let @xmath133 and @xmath134 be the oscillator s position and momentum operators , and @xmath135 represents the annihilation operator of the cavity mode . the system hamiltonian is given by @xmath136 ; that is , the oscillator s free evolution with resonant frequency @xmath137 plus the linearized radiation pressure interaction between the oscillator and the cavity field with coupling strength @xmath138 . the system couples to an external probe field ( thus @xmath139 ) via the coupling operator @xmath140 , with @xmath141 the coupling constant between the cavity and probe fields . the corresponding matrix @xmath142 and vector @xmath143 are then given by @xmath144,~~ c_{1}=\sqrt{\frac{\kappa}{2 } } \left[\begin{array}{c } 0 \\ 0 \\ 1 \\ i \\ \end{array}\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the oscillator is driven by an unknown force @xmath145 with coupling constant @xmath146 ; then the vector of system variables @xmath147^\top$ ] satisfies @xmath148 where @xmath149 , \ , b=\sqrt{\gamma}\left[\begin{array}{c } 0 \\ 1 \\ 0 \\ 0 \\ \end{array}\right ] , \nonumber \\ c_1&=-b_1^{\top } = \left[\begin{array}{cccc } 0 & 0 & \sqrt{\kappa } & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & \sqrt{\kappa}\\ \end{array}\right ] , \nonumber \\ \hat{w}_{1 } & = [ \hat{q}_{1 } , \hat{p}_{1}]^{\top } , ~~ \hat{w}_{1}^{\rm out } = [ \hat{q}_{1}^{\rm out } , \hat{p}_{1}^{\rm out}]^{\top}. \label{eq_matrix_originalplant}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that we are in the rotating frame at the frequency of the probe field . these equations indicate that the information about @xmath150 can be extracted by measuring @xmath151 by a homodyne detector . actually the measurement output in the laplace domain is given by @xmath152 where @xmath153 , @xmath154 , and @xmath155 are transfer functions given by @xmath156 thus , @xmath151 certainly contains @xmath150 . note however that it is subjected to two noises . the first one , @xmath157 , is the back - action noise , which is due to the interaction between the oscillator and the cavity . the second one , @xmath158 , is the shot noise , which inevitably appears . now , the normalized output is given by @xmath159 and the normalized noise power spectral density of @xmath160 in the fourier domain @xmath161 is calculated as follows : @xmath162 the lower bound is called the sql . note that the last inequality is due to the heisenberg uncertainty relation of the normalized noise power , i.e. , @xmath163 . hence , the essential reason why sql appears is that @xmath164 contains both the back - action noise @xmath165 and the shot noise @xmath166 . therefore , toward the high - precision detection of @xmath150 , we need bae ; that is , the system structure should be modified by some means so that the back - action noise is completely evaded in the output signal ( note that the shot noise can never be evaded ) . the condition for bae can be expressed in terms of the transfer function as follows @xcite ; i.e. , for the modified ( controlled ) sensor , the transfer function from the back - action noise to the measurement output must satisfy @xmath167 equivalently , @xmath164 contains only the shot noise @xmath158 ; hence , in this case the signal to noise ratio can be further improved by injecting a @xmath158-squeezed ( meaning @xmath168 ) probe field into the system . there are two schemes for controlling a quantum system via feedback . the first one is the _ measurement - based feedback _ @xcite illustrated in fig . [ fig_mfvscf ] ( a ) . in this scheme , we measure the output fields and feed the measurement results back to control the plant system . on the other hand , in the _ coherent feedback _ scheme @xcite shown in fig . [ fig_mfvscf ] ( b ) , the feedback loop dose not contain any measurement component and the plant system is controlled by another quantum system . recently we find several works comparing the performance of these two schemes @xcite . in particular , it was shown in @xcite that there are some control tasks that can not be achieved by any measurement - based feedback but can be done by a coherent one . more specifically , those tasks are realizing bae measurement , generating a quantum non - demolished variable , and generating a decoherence - free subsystem ; in our case , of course , the first one is crucial . hence , here we aim to develop a theory for designing a coherent feedback controller such that the whole controlled system accomplishes bae . as discussed in section [ sec:2 - 1 ] , the geometric control theory for disturbance decoupling problem is formulated for the controlled system with special structure ; in particular , the coefficient matrix of the disturbance @xmath52 is of the form @xmath169^\top$ ] and that of the state vector in the output @xmath53 is @xmath170 $ ] . here we consider a class of coherent feedback configuration such that the whole closed - loop system dynamics has this structure , in order for the geometric control theory to be directly applicable . first , for the plant system given by eqs . and , we assume that the system couples to all the probe fields in the same way ; i.e. , @xmath171 this immediately leads to @xmath172 . next , as the controller , we take the following special linear quantum system with @xmath173 input - output fields : @xmath174 where the matrices @xmath175 satisfy the physical realizability condition . note that , corresponding to the plant structure , we assumed that the controller couples to all the fields in the same way , specified by @xmath176 . here we emphasize that the number of channels , @xmath114 , should be as small as possible from a viewpoint of implementation ; hence in this paper let us consider the case @xmath177 . now , we consider the coherent feedback connection illustrated in fig . [ fig_3i3o_general ] , i.e. , @xmath178 where @xmath179 and @xmath180 are @xmath181 unitary matrices representing the scattering process of the fields ; recall that the scattering process @xmath182 with @xmath183 the phase shift can be represented in the quadrature form as @xmath184 = s(\theta ) \left[\begin{array}{cc } \hat{q } \\ \hat{p } \\ \end{array}\right ] = \left[\begin{array}{cc } \cos \theta & -\sin \theta \\ \sin \theta & \cos \theta \\ \end{array}\right ] \left[\begin{array}{cc } \hat{q } \\ \hat{p } \\ \end{array}\right ] . \label{eq_phaseshifter}\ ] ] here we apply the coherent feedback scheme elaborated in section [ sec:3 - 2 ] to the opto - mechanical system studied in section [ sec:2 - 3 ] . the goal is , as mentioned before , to determine the controller matrices @xmath95 such that the closed - loop system achieves bae . here , we provide a step - by - step procedure to solve this problem ; the relationships of the class of controllers determined in each step is depicted in fig . [ fig_controllerconstraint ] . -phase shifter corresponding to eq . . , width=264 ] * ( ii ) * in the next step we apply theorem 1 to check if there exists a feedback controller such that the above closed - loop system achieves bae ; recall that the necessary and sufficient condition is eq . , i.e. , @xmath206 , where now @xmath207 \right\ } , \\ \mathcal{h}&={{\rm ker}\hspace{0.07cm}}h={\rm span } \left\ { \left[\begin{array}{c } 1\\ 0\\ 0\\ 0\\ \end{array}\right ] , \left[\begin{array}{c } 0\\ 1\\ 0\\ 0\\ \end{array}\right ] , \left[\begin{array}{c } 0\\ 0\\ 1\\ 0\\ \end{array}\right ] \right\}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] to check if this solvability condition is satisfied , we use corollary 1 ; from @xmath208 and @xmath209 , the algorithms given in appendix a yield @xmath210 implying that the condition in corollary 1 , i.e. , @xmath211 , is satisfied . thus , we now see that the bae problem is solvable , as long as there is no constraint on the controller parameters . next we aim to determine the controller matrices @xmath95 , using theorem 2 . first we set @xmath212 and @xmath213 ; note that @xmath82 is a @xmath83-pair . then , from theorem 2 , there exists a feedback controller with dimension @xmath214 . moreover , noting again that @xmath196 , there exist matrices @xmath84 , @xmath85 , and @xmath215 such that @xmath216 these conditions lead to @xmath217 , ~~ g=\left[\begin{array}{cc } 0&g_{\scriptscriptstyle 12}\\ -\frac{g}{\sqrt{\kappa}}&g_{\scriptscriptstyle 22}\\ g_{\scriptscriptstyle 31}&g_{\scriptscriptstyle 32}\\ 0&\sqrt{\kappa}\\ \end{array}\right ] , \\ n&=\left[\begin{array}{cccc } n_{\scriptscriptstyle 11 } & n_{\scriptscriptstyle 12 } & 0 & n_{\scriptscriptstyle 14 } \\ n_{\scriptscriptstyle 21 } & n_{\scriptscriptstyle 22 } & 0 & n_{\scriptscriptstyle 24}\\ \end{array}\right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath218 , and @xmath219 are free parameters . then the controller matrices @xmath95 can be identified by eq . with the above matrices @xmath220 ; specifically , by substituting @xmath221 , @xmath222 , and @xmath223 in eq . , we have @xmath224 which yield @xmath225 where @xmath226 is the right inverse to @xmath215 , i.e. , @xmath227 . * ( iii ) * note again that the controller has to satisfy the physical realizability condition , which is now @xmath228 and @xmath229 . these constraints are represented in terms of the parameters as follows : @xmath230 where @xmath231 and @xmath232 . this is one of our main results ; the linear controller achieving bae for the opto - mechanical oscillator can be fully parametrized by eq . satisfying the condition . we emphasize that this full parametrization of the controller can be obtained thanks to the general problem formulation based on the geometric control theory . * ( iv ) * in practice , of course , we need to determine a concrete set of parameters to construct the controller . especially here let us consider a _ passive system _ ; this is a static quantum system such as an empty optical cavity . the main reason for choosing a passive system rather than a non - passive ( or _ active _ ) one such as an optical parametric oscillator is that , due to the external pumping energy , the latter could become fragile and also its physical implementation must be more involved compared to a passive system @xcite . now the condition for the system @xmath233 to be passive is given by @xmath234 and @xmath235 ; the general result of this fact is given in theorem 3 in appendix b. from these conditions , the system parameters are imposed to satisfy , in addition to eq . , the following equalities : @xmath236 there is still some freedom in determining @xmath237 , which however corresponds to simply the phase shift at the input - output ports of the controller , as indicated from eq . . thus , the passive controller achieving bae in this example is unique up to the phase shift . here particularly we chose @xmath238 and @xmath239 . then the controller matrices satisfying eqs . and are determined as @xmath240,~~ c_{\scriptscriptstyle k}=-b_{\scriptscriptstyle k}^{\top } = \left[\begin{array}{cc } \frac{g}{\sqrt{\kappa } } & 0 \\ 0 & \frac{g}{\sqrt{\kappa } } \\ \end{array}\right ] . \ ] ] as illustrated in fig . [ fig_3i3obae ] , the controller specified by these matrices can be realized as a single - mode , 2-inputs and 2-outputs optical cavity with decay rate @xmath241 and detuning @xmath242 . in other words , if we take the cavity with the following hamiltonian and the coupling operator ( @xmath243 is the cavity mode ) @xmath244 then to satisfy the bae condition the controller parameters @xmath245 must satisfy @xmath246 summarizing , the above - designed sensing system composed of the opto - mechanical oscillator ( plant ) and the optical cavity ( controller ) , which are combined via coherent feedback , satisfies the bae condition . hence , it can work as a high - precision detector of the force @xmath150 below the sql , particularly when the @xmath247-squeezed probe input field is used ; this fact will be demonstrated in section [ sec:5 ] . in this section , we study another control scheme for achieving bae . as illustrated in fig . [ fig_mankei_scheme ] ( a ) , the controller in this case is directly connected to the plant , not through a coherent feedback ; hence this scheme is called the _ direct interaction_. the controller is characterized by the following two hamiltonians : @xmath248 where @xmath249^{\top}$ ] is the vector of controller variables with @xmath250 the number of modes of the controller . @xmath251 is the controller s self hamiltonian with @xmath252 . also @xmath253 with @xmath254 , @xmath255 represents the coupling between the plant and the controller . note that , for the hamiltonians @xmath251 and @xmath253 to be hermitian , the matrices must satisfy @xmath256 and @xmath257 ; these are the physical realizability conditions in the scenario of direct interaction . in particular , here we consider a plant system interacting with a single probe field @xmath197 , with coupling matrices @xmath258 and @xmath259 . then , the whole dynamics of the augmented system with variable @xmath260^{\top}$ ] is given by @xmath261 where @xmath262 , ~~ b_{{\scriptscriptstyle e}}=\left[\begin{array}{c } b\\ o \\ \end{array}\right ] , \nonumber \\ c_{{\scriptscriptstyle e}}&=\left[\begin{array}{cc } c & o \\ \end{array}\right ] , ~~ b_{{\scriptscriptstyle e}}=\left[\begin{array}{cc } b^{\top } & o\\ \end{array}\right ] ^{\top}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath263 , @xmath264 , and @xmath265 are the same matrices as those in eq . . also , comparing the matrices and , we have that @xmath266 , which thus leads to @xmath267 and @xmath268 in theorem 2 . now , again for the opto - mechanical system illustrated in fig . [ fig_opticalsensor ] , let us aim to design the direct interaction controller , so that the whole system achieves bae ; that is , the problem is to determine the matrices @xmath269 so that the back - action noise @xmath270 does not appear in the measurement output @xmath271 . for this purpose , we go through the same procedure as that taken in section [ sec:3 - 3 ] . * ( i ) * because of the structure of the matrices @xmath263 and @xmath264 , the system is already of the form , where the geometric control theory is directly applicable . * ( ii ) * because we now focus on the same plant system as that in section [ sec:3 - 3 ] , the same conclusion is obtained ; that is , the bae problem is solvable as long as there is no constraint on the controller matrices @xmath269 . the controller matrices can be determined in a similar way to section [ sec:3 - 3 ] as follows . first , because the @xmath46-pair @xmath82 is the same as before , it follows that @xmath272 , i.e. , @xmath273 . then , from theorem 2 with the fact that @xmath267 and @xmath268 , we find that the direct interaction controller can be parameterized as follows : @xmath274 the matrices @xmath47 , @xmath49 , and @xmath215 satisfy @xmath275 , and @xmath98 , which lead to @xmath276 , ~~ g=\left[\begin{array}{cc } 0&g_{\scriptscriptstyle 12}\\ -\frac{g}{\sqrt{\kappa}}&g_{\scriptscriptstyle 22}\\ g_{\scriptscriptstyle 31}&g_{\scriptscriptstyle 32}\\ 0&0\\ \end{array}\right ] , \nonumber \\ n&=\left[\begin{array}{cccc } n_{\scriptscriptstyle 11}&n_{\scriptscriptstyle 12 } & 0&n_{\scriptscriptstyle 14}\\ n_{\scriptscriptstyle 21}&n_{\scriptscriptstyle 22 } & 0&n_{\scriptscriptstyle 24}\\ \end{array}\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath218 , and @xmath219 are free parameters . * ( iii ) * the controller matrices have to satisfy the physical realizability conditions @xmath256 and @xmath257 ; these constraints impose the parameters to satisfy @xmath277 where @xmath231 and @xmath232 . + equations , , and provide the full parametrization of the direct interaction controller . * ( iv ) * to specify a set of parameters , as in the case of section [ sec:3 - 3 ] , let us aim to design a passive controller . from theorem 4 in appendix b , @xmath278 and @xmath279 satisfy the condition @xmath280 and @xmath281 , which lead to the same equalities given in eq . . then , setting the parameters to be @xmath238 and @xmath239 , we can determine the matrices @xmath278 and @xmath282 as follows : @xmath283 , ~~ r_2=r_1^\top = \left[\begin{array}{cccc } 0&0&g&0 \\ 0&0&0&g \\ \end{array}\right ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the controller specified by these matrices can be physically implemented as illustrated in fig . [ fig_mankei_scheme ] ( b ) ; that is , it is a single - mode detuned cavity with hamiltonian @xmath284 , which couples to the plant through a beam - splitter ( bs ) represented by @xmath285 . * remark : * we can employ an active controller , as proposed in @xcite . in this case the interaction hamiltonian is given by @xmath286 , while the system s self - hamiltonian is the same as above ; @xmath284 . that is , the controller couples to the plant through a non - degenerate optical parametric amplification process in addition to the bs interaction . to satisfy the bae condition , the parameters must satisfy @xmath287 . note that this direct interaction controller can be specified , in the full - parameterization , , and , by @xmath288 we have demonstrated in sections [ sec:3 - 3 ] and [ sec:4 ] that the bae condition can be achieved by engineering an appropriate auxiliary system and connecting it to the plant . however , in a practical situation , it can not be expected to realize such perfect bae due to several experimental imperfections . hence , in a realistic setup , we should modify our strategy for engineering a sensor so that it would accomplish _ approximate bae_. then , looking back into section [ sec:2 - 3 ] where the bae condition , @xmath289 , was obtained , we are naturally led to consider the following optimization problem to design an auxiliary system achieving the approximate bae : @xmath290 where @xmath291 denotes a valid norm of a complex function . in particular , in the field of robust control theory , the following @xmath292 norm and the @xmath293 norm are often used @xcite : @xmath294 that is , the @xmath292 or @xmath293 control theory provides a general procedure for synthesizing a feedback controller that minimizes the above norm . in this paper , we take the @xmath292 norm , mainly owing to the broadband noise - reduction nature of the @xmath292 controller . then , rather than pursuing an optimal quantum @xmath292 controller based on the quantum @xmath292 control theory @xcite , here we take the following geometric - control - theoretical approach to solve the problem . that is , first we apply the method developed in section [ sec:3 ] or [ sec:4 ] to the idealized system and obtain the controller achieving bae ; then , in the practical setup containing some unwanted noise , we make a local modification of the controller parameters obtained in the first step , to minimize the cost @xmath295 . as a demonstration , here we consider the coherent feedback control for the opto - mechanical system studied in section [ sec:2 - 3 ] , which is now subjected to the thermal noise @xmath296 . following the above - described policy , we employ the coherent feedback controller constructed for the idealized system that ignores @xmath296 , leading to the controller given by eqs . and , illustrated in fig . [ fig_3i3obae ] . the closed - loop system with variable @xmath297^{\top}$ ] , which now takes into account the realistic imperfections , then obeys the following dynamics : @xmath298 where @xmath299 . \ ] ] @xmath263 , @xmath264 , and @xmath265 are the same matrices given in eq . . @xmath296 is the thermal noise satisfying @xmath300 , where @xmath301 is the mean phonon number at thermal equilibrium @xcite . note that the damping effect appears in the @xmath302 component of @xmath303 due to the stochastic nature of @xmath296 . also , again , @xmath304 and @xmath305 are the decay rate and the detuning of the controller cavity , respectively . in the idealized setting where @xmath296 is negligible , the perfect bae is achieved by choosing the parameters satisfying eq . . the measurement output of this closed - loop system is , in the laplace domain , represented by @xmath306 the normalized noise power spectral density of @xmath307 is calculated as @xmath308 the coefficient of the back - action noise is given by @xmath309 our goal is to find the optimal parameters @xmath310 that minimize the @xmath292 norm of the transfer function , @xmath311 . norm @xmath312 versus the coupling constant @xmath304 and the detuning @xmath305.,width=264 ] the system parameters are taken as follows @xcite : @xmath313 mhz , @xmath314 mhz , @xmath315 khz , @xmath316 mhz , @xmath317 , and the effective mass is @xmath318 kg . we then have fig . [ fig_h2norm ] , showing @xmath319 as a function of @xmath304 and @xmath305 . this figure shows that there exists a unique pair of @xmath320 that minimizes the norm , and they are given by @xmath321 mhz and @xmath322 mhz , which are actually close to the ideal values . [ fig_noisepower ] shows the value of eq . with these optimal parameters @xmath320 , where the noise floor @xmath323 is subtracted . the solid black line represents the sql , which is now given by @xmath324 then the dot - dashed blue and dotted green lines indicate that , in the low frequency range , the coherent feedback controller can suppress the noise below the sql , while , by definition , the noise power of the autonomous ( i.e. , uncontrolled ) plant system is above the sql . moreover , this effect can be enhanced by injecting a @xmath158-squeezed probe field ( meaning @xmath325 and @xmath326 ) into the system . in fact the dashed red line in the figure illustrates the case @xmath327 ( about 9 db squeezing ) , showing the significant reduction of the noise power . the main contribution of this paper is in that it first provides the general theory for constructing a back - action evading sensor for linear quantum systems , based on the well - developed classical geometric control theory . the power of the theory has been demonstrated by showing that , for the typical opto - mechanical oscillator , a full parametrization of the auxiliary coherent - feedback and direct interaction controller achieving bae was derived , which contains the result of @xcite . note that , although we have studied a simple example for the purpose of demonstration , the real advantage of the theory developed in this paper will appear when dealing with more complicated multi - mode systems such as an opto - mechanical system containing a membrane @xcite . another contribution of this paper is to provide a general procedure for designing an approximate bae sensor under realistic imperfections ; that is , an optimal approximate bae system can be obtained by solving the minimization problem of the transfer function from the back - action noise to the measurement output . while in section [ sec:5 ] we have provided a simple approach based on the geometric control theory for solving this problem , the @xmath292 or @xmath293 control theory could be employed for systematic design of an approximate bae controller even for the above - mentioned complicated system . this is also an important future research direction of this work . the set of @xmath36-invariant subspaces has a unique maximum element contained in a given subspace @xmath330 . this space , denoted by @xmath331 , can be computed by the following algorithm : @xmath332 similarly , the set of @xmath40-invariant subspaces has a unique minimum element containing a given subspace @xmath333 , and this space , denoted by @xmath334 , can be computed by the following algorithm : @xmath335 note that a passive system is constituted only with annihilation operator variables ; a typical optical realization of the passive system is an empty optical cavity . moreover , @xmath345 is already satisfied and @xmath344 leads to @xmath346 . this is the reason why it is sufficient to consider the constraints only on @xmath347 and @xmath348 . then the goal here is to represent the conditions @xmath349 in terms of the coefficient matrices of eq . . for this purpose , let us introduce the permutation matrix @xmath350 as follows ; for a column vector @xmath351^{\top}$ ] , @xmath350 is defined through @xmath352^{\top}$ ] . note that @xmath350 satisfies @xmath353 . then , the coefficient matrices of the above two system representations are connected by @xmath354 where @xmath355.\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath356 , @xmath357 , and @xmath358 have the same forms as above . then , we have the following theorem , providing the passivity condition in the quadrature form : * theorem 3 : * the system is passive if and only if , in addition to the physical realizability condition , the following equalities hold : @xmath359 _ proof : _ let us first define @xmath360 $ ] , which leads to @xmath361 . then , we can prove @xmath362 the condition in the right hand side is equivalent to @xmath363 and @xmath364 , which thus leads to @xmath343 . also , from a similar calculation we obtain @xmath365 let us next consider the passivity condition of the direct interaction controller discussed in section [ sec:4 ] . the setup is that , for a given linear quantum system , we add an auxiliary component with variable @xmath366 , which is characterized by the hamiltonians . the point is that these hamiltonians have the following equivalent representations in terms of the vector of annihilation operators @xmath367 and @xmath368 : @xmath369 \mathscr{r}_{\scriptscriptstyle k } \left[\begin{array}{c } \hat{a}_{\scriptscriptstyle k } \\ \hat{a}_{\scriptscriptstyle k}^{\sharp } \\ \end{array}\right ] , \nonumber \\ \hat{h}_{\rm int}&=\frac{1}{2}\left ( \left[\begin{array}{cc } \hat{a}^{\dag } & \hat{a}^{\top } \\ \end{array}\right ] \mathscr{r}_1 \left[\begin{array}{c } \hat{a}_{\scriptscriptstyle k } \\ \hat{a}_{\scriptscriptstyle k}^{\sharp } \\ \end{array}\right ] + \left[\begin{array}{cc } \hat{a}_{\scriptscriptstyle k}^{\dag } & \hat{a}_{\scriptscriptstyle k}^{\top } \\ \end{array}\right ] \mathscr{r}_2 \left[\begin{array}{c } \hat{a } \\ \hat{a}^{\sharp } \\ \end{array}\right ] \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the matrices @xmath370 , and @xmath371 are of the same forms as those in eq . . note that they have to satisfy the physical realizability conditions @xmath372 and @xmath373 . now we can define the passivity property of the direct interaction controller ; that is , if the hamiltonians does not contain any quadratic term such as @xmath374 and @xmath375 , then the direct interaction controller is passive . the formal definition is given as follows : * definition 6 : * the direct interaction controller constructed by hamiltonians is said to be passive if , in addition to the physical realizability conditions @xmath372 and @xmath373 , the matrices satisfy @xmath376 and @xmath377 . * theorem 4 : * the direct interaction controller constructed by hamiltonians is passive if and only if , in addition to the physical realizability conditions @xmath256 and @xmath257 , the following equalities hold : @xmath378 c. m. caves , k. s. thorne , r. w. p. drever , v. d. sandberg , and m. zimmermann , on the measurement of a weak classical force coupled to a quantum - mechanical oscillator . i. issues of principle , rev . * 52 * , 341 ( 1980 ) c. l. latune , b. m. escher , r. l. de matos filho , and l. davidovich , quantum limit for the measurement of a classical force coupled to a noisy quantum - mechanical oscillator , phys . a * 88 * , 042112 ( 2013 ) . t. corbitt , y. chen , e. innerhofer , h. m@xmath379ller - ebhardt , d. ottaway , h. rehbein , d. sigg , s. whitcomb , c. wipf , and n. mavalvala , an all - optical trap for a gram - scale mirror , phys . lett . * 98 * , 150802 ( 2007 ) . m. underwood , d. mason , d. lee , h. xu , l. jiang , a. b. shkarin , k. brkje , s. m. girvin , and j. g. e. harris , measurement of the motional sidebands of a nanogram - scale oscillator in the quantum regime , phys . a * 92 * , 061801 ( 2015 ) . h. j. kimble , y. levin , a. b. matsko , k. s. thorne , and s. p. vyatchanin , conversion of conventional gravitational - wave interferometers into quantum nondemolition interferometers by modifying their input and/or output optics , phys . d * 65 * , 022002 ( 2001 ) . y. liu , s. shankar , n. ofek , m. hatridge , a. narla , k. m. sliwa , l. frunzio , r. j. schoelkopf , and m. h. devoret , comparing and combining measurement - based and driven - dissipative entanglement stabilization , phys . x * 6 * , 011022 ( 2016 ) . | engineering a sensor system for detecting an extremely tiny signal such as the gravitational - wave force is a very important subject in quantum physics . a major obstacle to this goal is that , in a simple detection setup , the measurement noise is lower bounded by the so - called standard quantum limit ( sql ) , which is originated from the intrinsic mechanical back - action noise . hence , the sensor system has to be carefully engineered so that it evades the back - action noise and eventually beats the sql . in this paper , based on the well - developed geometric control theory for classical disturbance decoupling problem , we provide a general method for designing an auxiliary ( coherent feedback or direct interaction ) controller for the sensor system to achieve the above - mentioned goal . this general theory is applied to a typical opto - mechanical sensor system . also , we demonstrate a controller design for a practical situation where several experimental imperfections are present . |
0903.5536 | scalar field - theoretic models play an important role in contemporary theoretical physics . they have a wide range of applications from condensed matter physics @xcite to cosmology @xcite . an interesting new class of scalar field models has been proposed in @xcite . such models are called models with v - shaped potentials due to their common property of a non - vanishing first derivative of the potential at the minimum . this feature introduces a qualitatively new behaviour of fields close to the vacuum . it turns out that for models with v - shaped potentials the field approaches its vacuum value in a polynomial ( quadratic ) way . as a consequence , topological defects ( _ e.g. _ kinks ) have compact support ( so - called _ compactons _ ) , see @xcite . a recently found non - topological object which has the form of an oscillon is also compact , @xcite . the other group of compact solutions which seem to be very interesting from a physical point of view are q - balls , see @xcite , @xcite . the possibility of applying q - balls to boson stars and black holes looks especially attractive @xcite . also models with standard ( smooth ) field potential can support compact objects if they have non - standard kinetic ( _ e.g. _ quartic ) terms @xcite-@xcite . these models , known also as k - field models , are studied in the context of the global expansion of the universe ( k - essence ) . in fact , historically , the first non - topological compact solution was found by roseanau and hyman in a modified kdv system @xcite . the simplest v - shaped scalar field model is the signum - gordon model @xcite , @xcite . it has been shown that , apart from self - simiar solutions , it supports also so - called shock waves , _ i.e. _ a class of solutions with a field discontinuity that propagates with velocity @xmath0 . the violation of the scaling symmetry of the signum - gordon model has been studied for both self - similar solutions @xcite and shock waves @xcite . in the following paper we concentrate on the case of shock waves . the genesis of this paper comes from the observation that a specific class of solutions in @xcite has not been considered . the new solutions are quite interesting because they merge properties of shock waves ( discontinuity of the field at one end ) and compactons ( quadratic approach to a vacuum value at the other end ) . such a solution is compact in an arbitrary stage of evolution so we call it _ a shock impulse _ instead of _ a shock wave_. our paper is organized as follows . in section 2 we briefly recall the signum - klein - gordon model . section 3 is devoted to the presentation of a new class of solutions . in the last section we summarize our paper . the lagrangian of a ( 1 + 1 ) dimensional signum - klein - gordon model reads @xmath1 where @xmath2 is a scalar field with an interaction given by the potential @xmath3 in @xcite we have proposed a mechanical system which in the limit of an infinite number of degrees of freedom is described by the lagrangian ( [ lagrangian ] ) . the quadratic interaction term has been chosen for simplicity . it is one of the simplest terms that can be used to violatate an exact scaling symetry . for details see @xcite and @xcite . the euler - lagrange equation reads @xmath4 where we assume ( for physical reasons ) that sign@xmath5 . it is clear that @xmath6 is a solution of ( [ el ] ) . this solution is necessary in the construction of compactons . the ansatz @xmath7 gives discontinuous solutions , where `` @xmath8 '' refers to solutions outside the light cone , `` @xmath9 '' refers to solutions inside the light cone and @xmath10 . it has been already discussed in @xcite that the velocity @xmath0 is distinguished by the model and it is the unique admissible velocity for the propagation of field discontinuities . we are interested in the case @xmath11 . for solutions outside the light cone our ansatz takes the form @xmath12 in the new variable @xmath13 , related to @xmath14 by the formula @xmath15 , the equation ( [ el ] ) takes the form @xmath16 where @xmath17 . it could be helpful to consider equation ( [ eqg ] ) as an equation of motion of a fictious particle in the potential @xmath18 . as we mentioned already in @xcite , equation ( [ eqg ] ) has partial solutions @xmath19 where @xmath20 for @xmath21 and @xmath22 otherwise . @xmath23 and @xmath24 are bessel functions . the partial solution not considered in @xcite is a constant zero solution . because of sign@xmath5 , @xmath25 is a solution of ( [ eqg ] ) . such a solution corresponds to the solution @xmath26 in a physical system , so it is well motivated from a physical point of view . the solution @xmath27 can be parametrized by only one parameter because at @xmath28 the bessel function @xmath24 has a singularity , so for physical reasons we set @xmath29 . the second coefficient @xmath30 can be expressed by the value of @xmath31 , which results in @xmath32 as was explained in a previous paper , depending on the values @xmath31 , the solution @xmath27 can be positive or can be matched with a negative partial solution @xmath33 . the intermediate case allows for matching the solution @xmath27 with the trivial solution @xmath25 . in this case @xmath27 reaches its zero value quadratically . this happens for @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the first zero of @xmath36 . we name this value @xmath37 . approximately @xmath38 . in this case the full compact impulse reads @xmath39 at moments @xmath40 for @xmath41.,scaledwidth=65.0% ] the matching point @xmath42 moves with subluminal velocity @xmath43 , where @xmath44 . for @xmath45 it is reached by the discontinuity @xmath46 . it comes from the fact that the length of the compact shock impulse @xmath47 for @xmath45 has a leading term @xmath48 . as was discussed in @xcite , for @xmath49 , negative partial solutions are present . if @xmath31 is not too big a full compact impulse @xmath50 is composed of two pieces @xmath27 and @xmath33 . again , for a certain value of @xmath31 a partial solution @xmath33 reaches its zero @xmath51 quadratically , therefore it could be matched with a constant zero partial solution . at the point @xmath52 @xmath33 is matched with @xmath27 . we have used a special notation @xmath53 for those zeros for which the field reaches its zero value in a quadratic way , whereas all other zeros we label by @xmath54 . a general higher - rank multi - zero solution consists of partial solutions @xmath55 and @xmath56 and has a matching points @xmath57 and @xmath53 . as an example let us study in details a solution for @xmath58 . there are three partial solutions @xmath27 , @xmath33 and a constant solution @xmath25 , and two matching points @xmath52 and @xmath51 . the partial solutions obey the following matching conditions @xmath59 the first condition , @xmath60 , and conditions ( [ zszycie2 ] ) give us @xmath61\label{g_0},\\ g_1(y)&=&-\frac{1}{\rho^2}\left[1-\frac{y_1(\rho\overline{c}_1)j_0(\rho y)-j_1(\rho\overline{c}_1)y_0(\rho y)}{y_1(\rho\overline{c}_1)j_0(\rho \overline{c}_1)-j_1(\rho\overline{c}_1)y_0(\rho \overline{c}_1)}\right]\label{g_1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the parameter @xmath31 is expressed in terms of @xmath52 . the other conditions in ( [ zszycie1 ] ) give algebraic equations for @xmath52 and @xmath51 . these equations can be rewritten in the following form @xmath62 equations ( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eq2 ] ) can be solved numerically . we will not present formulas for bigger @xmath63 because they are too complicated . in figs.[multi3 ] -[multi4 ] we present two examples of multi - zero solutions @xmath50 with three and four segments , respectively . for higher - range solutions , @xmath64 , instead of solutions we present only plots of numerical values of @xmath31 and @xmath53 as functions of @xmath63 , see figs [ initial_kwadrat]-[zeros ] . the numerical results suggest , surprisingly , that , at least for not too large @xmath63 , both the sequence of @xmath65 and the sequence of zeros @xmath53 behave linearly ( arithmetic sequences ) . linear fits give us : * @xmath66 @xmath67 * @xmath68 @xmath69 * @xmath70 @xmath71 ) multi - zero solution @xmath50 for @xmath41.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] ) multi - zero solution @xmath50 for @xmath41.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] for consecutive multi - zero compact solutions @xmath50 . straight lines represent linear fits to numerical data . the upper line has been obtained for @xmath66 , the middle line for @xmath68 and the bottom line corresponds to @xmath70.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] and their linear fits . the upper line has been obtained for @xmath66 , the middle line for @xmath68 and the bottom line corresponds to @xmath70.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] this means that the size of a compact impulse ( as a function of @xmath13 ) or the size of an initial compacton configuration ( as a function of @xmath72 ) changes linearly with a number @xmath63 . the size of the compacton for a fixed @xmath63 shrinks when @xmath73 increases . we want to emphasize that linear dependence @xmath53 and @xmath31 is completely unexpected . the expressions for solutions for higher @xmath63 and relations between coefficients are very complicated and one can not expect such a simple relationship . we have presented a new class of solutions in the ( 1 + 1 ) dimensional signum - klein - gordon model which was not been considered in @xcite . the solutions which appear in models with v - shaped potentials are usually either shock or compacton type . our solutions merge both of these properties . the compact shock impulses , presented above , have on one end a wave front where a scalar field is discontinuous and on the other end they approach their vacuum value quadratically . we would like to thank h. arodz , c. adam , j. sanchez - guillen and j. shock for discussion and valuable comments . this paper is supported by mcyt ( spain ) and feder ( fpa2005 - 01963 ) , and xunta de galicia ( grant pgidit06pxib296182pr and conselleria de educacion ) | a new class of solutions in the signum - klein - gordon model is presented . our solutions merge properties of shock waves and compactons that appear in scalar field models with v - shaped potentials . pacs : 03.50.kk , 05.45.-a , 11.10.lm + |
Subsets and Splits