Datasets:

kilian-group
/

arxiv-classifier

Dataset card Data Studio Files Files and versions Community

Subset (4)

default · ~99.6k rows (showing the first 120k)

Split (2)

train · ~72.4k rows (showing the first 93.1k)

paper_id stringlengths 9 16	version stringclasses 26 values	yymm stringclasses 311 values	created timestamp[s]	title stringlengths 6 335	secondary_subfield sequencelengths 1 8	abstract stringlengths 25 3.93k	primary_subfield stringclasses 124 values	field stringclasses 20 values	fulltext stringlengths 0 2.84M
1008.3478	3	1008	2011-08-30T13:31:10	Spatial clustering of interacting bugs: Levy flights versus Gaussian jumps	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.stat-mech" ]	A biological competition model where the individuals of the same species perform a two-dimensional Markovian continuous-time random walk and undergo reproduction and death is studied. The competition is introduced through the assumption that the reproduction rate depends on the crowding in the neighborhood. The spatial dynamics corresponds either to normal diffusion characterized by Gaussian jumps or to superdiffusion characterized by L\'evy flights. It is observed that in both cases periodic patterns occur for appropriate parameters of the model, indicating that the general macroscopic collective behavior of the system is more strongly influenced by the competition for the resources than by the type of spatial dynamics. However, some differences arise that are discussed.	physics.bio-ph	physics	epl draft 1 1 0 2 g u A 0 3 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 3 v 8 7 4 3 . 8 0 0 1 : v i X r a Spatial clustering of interacting bugs: L´evy flights versus Gaussian jumps E. Heinsalu1,2, E. Hern´andez-Garc´ıa1 and C. L´opez1 1 IFISC, Instituto de F´ısica Interdisciplinar y Sistemas Complejos (CSIC-UIB), E-07122 Palma de Mallorca, Spain 2 National Institute of Chemical Physics and Biophysics, Ravala 10, Tallinn 15042, Estonia PACS 02.50.Ey -- Stochastic processes PACS 05.40.-a -- Fluctuation phenomena, random processes, noise, and Brownian motion PACS 05.40.Fb -- Random walks and Levy flights Abstract. - A biological competition model where the individuals of the same species perform a two-dimensional Markovian continuous-time random walk and undergo reproduction and death is studied. The competition is introduced through the assumption that the reproduction rate de- pends on the crowding in the neighborhood. The spatial dynamics corresponds either to normal diffusion characterized by Gaussian jumps or to superdiffusion characterized by L´evy flights. It is observed that in both cases periodic patterns occur for appropriate parameters of the model, indicating that the general macroscopic collective behavior of the system is more strongly influ- enced by the competition for the resources than by the type of spatial dynamics. However, some differences arise that are discussed. Introduction. -- Interacting particle systems help to model and understand various problems in many diverse fields. In biological contexts they are particularly impor- tant to study aggregation phenomena of individuals. Fish schools, insect swarms, bacterial patterns, bird flocks and patchy plankton structures are just a few examples reveal- ing the ubiquity and fundamental importance of organism aggregates. An attempt to address a simple mechanism giving rise to the clustering of particles (with emphasis on plankton patchiness) was made within a Brownian bug model [1] (see also refs. [2, 3]). The model consists of an ensemble of particles (bugs), each one dying or reproducing with a given probability and undergoing Brownian motion. If the diffusivity of the particles is low enough, macroscopic spatial clustering occurs, since a newborn is located close to the parent but particles can die anywhere. If diffusivity is large, particles perform more extended walks and the region that was left empty due to the death of a particle, is occupied fast by some other particle. Similar results were obtained in refs. [4 -- 7] where lattice-models were studied. The basic Brownian bug model lacks any interaction between the particles. In a more realistic model (inter- acting Brownian bug model) the inter-particle interaction was taken into account assuming that the birth and death of individuals depend on the number of other bugs in the neighborhood [8 -- 13]. For appropriate parameters, a salient property of that model is the formation of spa- tially periodic clustering of bugs [8]. For large diffusion the clusters become blurred and the periodic pattern is replaced by a more uniform distribution of bugs. Impor- tantly, whereas the positive correlations leading to clus- tering in the non-interacting bug case arise from the re- productive correlations, i.e., from the fact that offspring is born at the same location of parent [5, 6], the periodic arrangement of clusters in the system of interacting bugs is a consequence of the competitive interaction and has a spatial scale determined by the interaction range R [8]. At the same time it has been observed that many liv- ing organisms move consistently with L´evy flight behav- ior [14 -- 18]. In particular, the motion of some bacteria is found to be described by L´evy statistics [19, 20], as well as the movement of spider monkeys in search of food [21]. The L´evy type of motion has been shown to be advanta- geous with respect to standard Brownian motion in some searching strategies involving foraging [18], or in order to enhance encounter rates at low densities [22]. The main reason for this resides in the occurrence of occasional long jumps. However, the impact of L´evy-type diffusion on the prop- erties of organism aggregates has not received much atten- tion thus far. In the present paper we investigate in the p-1 E. Heinsalu et al. context of a simple interacting bug model, continuous in space, how the occurrence of long jumps in the motion of the individuals influences the collective behavior (c.f. ref. [23]). Similarities and differences between the inter- acting Brownian and L´evy bug systems will be highlighted. Model and numerical algorithm. -- We consider a system consisting initially of N0 pointlike particles, placed randomly in a two-dimensional L× L square domain with periodic boundary conditions. After the random time τ , a particle i, chosen randomly among all the N (t) bugs in the system at the present time t, undergoes one of the two events: it either reproduces or disappears. For the birth and death rates of the i-th particle we assume [8], ri ri b = max(cid:0)0, rb0 − αN i d = max(cid:0)0, rd0 + βN i R(cid:1) , R(cid:1) . (1) (2) Here N i R is the number of particles which are at a distance smaller than R from particle i, the parameters rb0 and rd0 are the zero-density birth and death rates, and the pa- rameters α and β determine how ri d depend on the neighborhood; the function max() enforces the positivity of the rates. Such a choice for the reproduction and death rates introduces an interaction between the bugs. For the random times τ an exponential probability density with the complementary cumulative distribution b and ri p(τ ) = exp(−τ /τ ) (3) and a characteristic time hτi = τ = R−1 the time-scale parameter and tot is chosen; τ is N Rtot = (ri b + ri d) Xi=1 (4) is the total rate of all the N ≡ N (t) particles. In the case of reproduction, the new bug is located at the same position (xi, yi) as the parent particle i. After the de- mographic event, i.e., after each random time τ , all the particles perform a jump of random length ℓ in a random direction characterized by an angle uniformly distributed on (0, 2π) (ℓ and the direction of the jump are different for each particle). The new present time is t + τ and the process is repeated again, until the final simulation time is reached [13]. In order to simulate the system where the particles un- dergo normal diffusion, a Gaussian jump-length probabil- ity density function is used, ϕ(ℓ) = (cid:16)ℓ√2π(cid:17)−1 exph−ℓ2/(2ℓ2)i , (5) with variance hℓ2i = ℓ2; ℓ is the space-scale parameter. Since we draw the angle specifying the direction of the jump from the interval (0, 2π), we can neglect the sign of ℓ. Note that the random walk defined in this way is not exactly the same as the one in which the walker per- forms jumps extracted from a two-dimensional Gaussian distribution, but it also leads to normal diffusion and al- lows a more direct comparison with the L´evy case. The corresponding diffusion coefficient is κ = hℓ2i/(2hτi) , (6) which expressed through the space- and time-scale pa- rameters reads, κ = ℓ2/(2τ ). As we choose to fix the value of κ, then the space-scale parameter is determined by ℓ = √2κτ = p2κ/Rtot. Note that because the number of particles is changing in time also the quantity Rtot is changing in time. However, as in this paper we investigate asymptotic statistically steady states, the number of par- ticles weakly fluctuates around a well-defined mean value. Thus, the space-scale parameter ℓ is fluctuating in time, but this time dependence is not affecting qualitatively the dynamics of the system. In order to simulate the system where the particles un- dergo superdiffusion one can use a symmetric L´evy stable probability density function for the jump size, which be- haves asymptotically as [14, 17] ϕµ(ℓ) ≈ ℓµℓ−µ−1 , ℓ → ±∞ (ℓ ≫ ℓ) , (7) with the L´evy index 0 < µ < 2. For all L´evy stable probability density functions with µ < 2 the variance di- verges, hℓ2i = ∞, leading to the occurrence of extremely long jumps, and typical trajectories are self-similar, on all scales showing clusters of shorter jumps intersparsed by long excursions. For 0 < a < µ < 2 fractional moments converge, hℓai < ∞. Therefore, for the L´evy index in the range 1 < µ < 2 the value of hℓi is finite, whereas for 0 < µ ≤ 1 it diverges. The complementary cumulative distribution corresponding to (7) is Pµ(ℓ) ≈ µ−1(ℓ/ℓ)−µ , ℓ → ±∞ . (8) As a simple form of complementary cumulative distribu- tion function, which is normalizable and behaves asymp- totically as (8), we use Pµ(ℓ) = (1 + b1/µℓ/ℓ)−µ , (9) where b = [Γ(1 − µ/2)Γ(µ/2)]/Γ(µ). As before, we can neglect the sign of ℓ since the direction of the jump is assigned by drawing an angle on (0, 2π). Now the diffusion coefficient (6) is infinite, but one can define a generalized diffusion coefficient in terms of the scales ℓ and τ as [14,17] κµ = ℓµ/(2τ ) . (10) Therefore, in the case of the L´evy flights, when fixing the value of κµ, the space-scale parameter is, ℓ = (2κµ τ )1/µ = (2κµ/Rtot)1/µ. The model described can be interpreted in the follow- ing way: during a time interval τ each individual moves on average a distance ℓ in some direction but only one of them reproduces or dies. For positive values of α and β, the more neighbors a particle has within the radius p-2 Spatial clustering of interacting bugs: L´evy flights versus Gaussian jumps (a) y (b) y 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 x 0 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 x Interacting Brownian bugs (a) versus interacting L´evy Fig. 1: bugs (b): spatial configuration of particles in the statistically steady state. The parameters are: rb0 = 1, rd0 = 0.1, α = 0.02, β = 0, and R = 0.1 (see also text). In the case of Brownian bugs the diffusion coefficient is κ = 10−5. In the case of L´evy bugs the value of L´evy index is µ = 1 and the anomalous diffusion coefficient is κµ = 56 × 10−5. The average number of particles in the two systems is approximately the same, hN i = 2555 and hN i = 2565, respectively. R, the smaller is the probability of reproduction and the larger is the probability that the bug does not survive, e.g., due to competition for resources. The periodicity of the simulation domain represents the fact that particles can leave and enter the observation area. In the case of long jumps it represents the situation where there is one particle that leaves the domain and another one that ar- rives from somewhere, perhaps from far away, and its po- sition is basically random in the domain. In principle, one could also simulate the system so that after the inter-event time τ a randomly chosen particle undergoes one of the three events: reproduction, death, or jump. However, the results obtained are the same as following the procedure described above; one would just have one more parameter, the jump rate, and different numerical values for the other parameters. Results. -- In the following we set β = 0 in eq. (2) and α = 0.02 in eq. (1), i.e., the probability of death is constant and the same for all the particles while the prob- ability for the reproduction depends on how crowded the environment is. Also, we use the values rb0 = 1, rd0 = 0.1, L = 1, and R = 0.1 in all the figures presented in the current paper. For β = 0 the critical number of neigh- bors, N ∗ R, for which death and reproduction are equally probable for particle i, is determined by N ∗ R = ∆bd/α , (11) where ∆bd = rb0 − rd0. If N i R < N ∗ R it is more probable that particle i reproduces and if N i R > N ∗ R death is more likely. In the following we fix the value of the L´evy index to µ = 1. The detailed discussion of the influence of the birth and death rates as well as the L´evy index on the results is outside the scope of the current paper and will be presented elsewhere. In the case of interacting Brownian bugs, for small enough κ and large enough ∆bd, the occurrence of pe- riodic patterns has been observed previously [8, 10]. In the statistically steady state clusters form and arrange in a hexagonal lattice (see fig. 1-a). For large values of the diffusion coefficient the periodic pattern is replaced by an almost homogeneous distribution of particles (see also fig. 3-a). In the case of L´evy flights, since the dif- fusion coefficient (6) is infinite, one could expect that for the interacting L´evy bugs the spatial distribution will not reveal a periodic pattern. However, as can be seen from fig. 1-b, this is not the case. The reason for the diver- gence of the diffusion coefficient in the L´evy case is in the statistical weight of the large jumps. These large jumps have some influence in the characteristics of the patterns formed, but the large-scale structure is ruled mainly by the interactions between particles. For the interacting bug system with Gaussian jumps and moderate diffusion the appearance of periodic clustering is well captured by combining the effects of diffusion and interaction in a mean-field approach [8]. Following the steps in ref. [8] one obtains the following equation as a mean-field approximation to the dynamics of the density of particles ρ(x, t) in the interacting L´evy bug model (β = 0): ∂ρ(x, t) ∂t = ρ(x, t)(cid:18)∆bd − αZD dyρ(y, t)(cid:19) + κµ∇γρ(x, t) . (12) The integration domain D is the set of points within a dis- tance smaller than R from x: x − y < R. The operator ∇γ, with γ = µ1, is the fractional diffusion operator asso- ciated to the L´evy flights of exponent µ ∈ (0, 2) [14, 17]. It reduces to the standard diffusion operator for µ > 2. In this mean-field description the first term accounts for the net growth of the population, the second one takes into 1This expression was incorrect in the paper originally published in EPL 92, 40011 (2010); it was corrected to the present form in the Erratum in EPL 95, 69902 (2011). p-3 E. Heinsalu et al. 100 10 1 0.1 ) r ( g Gaussian Levy 0.01 0.1 r 0.5 Fig. 2: Comparison of the radial distribution functions for the systems with Gaussian jumps and with L´evy flights. The parameters are as in fig. 1. account the non-local contribution associated to the sat- uration due to the interactions within a distance R, and the third term describes the spatial diffusion of particles. Equation (12) differs from the mean-field approximation derived in ref. [8] only in the third term where the stan- dard diffusion operator is replaced by the fractional diffu- sion operator and the diffusion coefficient by the general- ized diffusion coefficient. Similar descriptions of reaction- diffusion systems with a fractional diffusion term can be consulted, e.g., in refs. [14, 15, 24, 25]. Equation (12) has always the uniform solution ρ(x, t) = ρ0 = ∆bd/(απR2) , (13) which turns out to become unstable for small κµ and/or large ∆bd (what is small or large depends also on the value of µ). This can be seen by introducing the ansatz ρ(x, t) = ρ0 + δρ(x, t) in eq. (12) and linearizing in δρ(x, t). The result is δρ(x, t) ∼ exp(ik · x + λ(k)t) , with λ(k) = −κµkγ − 2∆bdJ1(kR)/(kR) ; (14) (15) J1 is a Bessel function. An instability of the uniform solu- tion will occur if the sign of λ(k) changes from negative to positive at some value of k. This will occur first for the critical wavenumber kc for which λ(k) is maximum. The instability will develop in a periodic pattern which, at least close enough to the instability, will have a periodic- ity δ = 2π/kc. Introducing a dimensionless wavenumber q ≡ kR and growth rate Λ = Rγλ/κµ, eq. (15) reads, Λ(q) = −qγ − νJ1(q)/q . (16) The latter equation shows that, within this mean-field de- scription, the relevant parameters are γ (or µ) and the dimensionless quantity ν ≡ 2Rγ∆ab/κµ. Imposing the condition Λ(q) = 0, corresponding to the change of sign in (a) κ = 6⋅10-6 10-5 3⋅10-5 10-4 (b) κµ = 3⋅10-4 6⋅10-4 10-3 5⋅10-3 100 10 1 0.1 10 1 ) r ( g ) r ( g 0.01 0.1 r 0.5 Fig. 3: Radial distribution function for the system with (a) Gaussian jumps and (b) L´evy jumps for several values of the diffusion and generalized diffusion coefficient, respectively. The other parameters are as in fig. 1 (see also text). the growth rate, and Λ′(q) = 0, corresponding to the max- imum of the growth rate, one can find the critical value of ν, νc = −qγ+1 /J1(qc), and the equation for the critical wavenumber: c qcJ2(qc)/J1(qc) = −γ . (17) Numerical solution of the latter equation provides qc, and therefore δ, as a function of γ (or µ), and that δ is propor- tional to R. In order to make a comparison with the results from numerical simulations of the system, one should keep in mind that the periodic boundary conditions will change qc to the closest number of the form (2πR/L)√n2 + m2 with n and m integers. For µ = 1 the value of δ ob- tained from the mean-field approximation is 0.128036 and for µ = 2 (Gaussian case) it is 0.131306, i.e., the periodic- ity of the pattern is in both cases of the order of R = 0.1. To extract the periodicity of the pattern from the nu- merical simulations of the system, it is useful to study the radial distribution function g(r). It describes how the density varies with the distance from a given parti- cle respect to the one expected from a uniform distribu- tion, giving thus additional information about the distri- bution of bugs [26]. It is computed in the standard way, i.e., by counting all particles, dn, at a distance between p-4 Spatial clustering of interacting bugs: L´evy flights versus Gaussian jumps Gaussian Levy ρ 100 80 60 40 20 0 0 10 20 30 40 50 Nc Fig. 4: The distribution of cluster sizes for the interacting Brownian bug and L´evy bug models. All parameters have the same values as in figs. 1 and 2. r and r + dr from the target particle, using the formula dn = (N/L2)g(r)2πrdr, and averaging over all particles and different long times. In fig. 2 the comparison of the ra- dial distribution functions for the Brownian and L´evy bugs (for the same systems as in fig. 1) is depicted. Figure 3-a shows the behavior of g(r) in the case of Brownian bugs and in fig. 3-b in the case of L´evy bugs for various values of diffusion coefficient and generalized diffusion coefficient, respectively. The second maximum of g(r), indicating the periodicity of the pattern, appears in fig. 3-a (in the sys- tems of Brownian bugs), up to κ = 10−5, at 0.13125 and in fig. 3-b (in the L´evy case), up to κµ = 10−3, at 0.12875, be- ing in good agreement with the results obtained from the mean-fieled approximation, and becoming slightly larger only at larger values of κ and κµ. The anomalous expo- nent µ has only a very light influence on the periodicity of the pattern, which is of the order of R (see also fig. 2 where the slight shift can be can be noticed). Figure 3 shows also that as κ or κµ increases, the first peak of g(r) gets lower and wider: the total number of particles in the system decreases and the clusters become more spread. For large values of diffusivity (κ or κµ), the oscillations of g(r) smooth out, indicating that the periodic pattern becomes replaced by a more homogeneous distribution of bugs. As a difference compared to the case of interacting Brownian bugs, we observe that now, even at small val- ues of κµ, there are many solitary particles appearing for short time periods in the space between the periodically arranged clusters, due to the large jumps, c.f. figs. 1-a and 1-b. This is even better illustrated by fig. 4 where the probability distributions of the cluster sizes for the systems with Gaussian and L´evy jumps are depicted (for the same systems as in fig. 1, i.e., for the given param- eters the values of κ and κµ have been chosen such that the average number of the particles in the two systems is approximately equal). The clusters are defined using the nearest neighbor clustering method [27], with a threshold (a) Gaussian Levy 8⋅104 6⋅104 4⋅104 ρ 2⋅104 (b) 0 104 103 102 ρ 101 -0.06 -0.03 0.03 0.06 0 x Fig. 5: Cross-section of the two-dimensional particle density of the average cluster in (a) linear and (b) semi-log scale. Com- parison between the interacting Brownian and L´evy bug mod- els. The values of the parameters are the same as in figs. 1, 2, and 4. The continuous lines correspond to the fitting with Gaussian functions. value 0.025 to define neighbors. As one can see, for the system of interacting Brownian bugs the most probable size of large clusters forming the periodic pattern is 41 particles whereas for interacting L´evy bugs it is 36 (the critical number of neighbors is in both cases N ∗ R = 45). A noticeable difference occurs in the proportion of single- particle clusters: the peak of the distribution at the value characterizing isolated particles (Nc = 1) is much higher in the L´evy flight case. Returning to fig. 2, which refers to the same systems as in figs. 1 and 4, it is to be noticed that the minimum between the first and the second peak is much lower for the system of Brownian bugs. This result is consistent with fig. 4: in the system with L´evy flights, the occurrence of many single particles between the clus- ters forming the periodic pattern produces a higher inter- cluster density is observed. Finally, in fig. 5 the cross-section of the two-dimensional particle density of the average cluster is depicted for the in- teracting Brownian and L´evy bug systems (same systems as in fig. 1). The average cluster is obtained by setting the origin at the center of mass of each cluster forming the periodic pattern and averaging over all the clusters in the p-5 E. Heinsalu et al. simulation area and over time. In the case of Brownian as well as of L´evy bugs, the central part of the average clus- ter, where most of the particles are concentrated, is well fitted by a Gaussian function (continuous curve). How- ever, fig. 5-b reveals the difference in the way the particle density decreases in the two systems when moving away from the center of mass of the cluster. Though even in the case of the Brownian bugs the tail of the average clus- ter is not really well described by a Gaussian function, a Gaussian decay provides a good approximation. Instead, in the case of the L´evy bugs the tail of the average clus- ter decays slower. Since the average cluster is calculated from individual clusters which are separated by a distance of order R, one cannot properly estimate an asymptotic decay, but the decay in the L´evy case seems close to ex- ponential. In any case, it is distinctively faster than the power-law behavior which would be exhibited by clusters of non-interacting particles moving purely by L´evy flights. The existence of the interaction range R introduces a cut- off distance which makes the long-jumps characteristic of L´evy flights not so relevant to determine the large-scale properties of the spatial particle configurations. Conclusion. -- In the present paper we have studied a simple birth-death model with competition among the individuals of the same species. In particular, we have investigated how the superdiffusive motion of the individ- uals characterized by L´evy flights influences the collective behavior. We have observed that the appearance of peri- odic clustering known from previous studies of the inter- acting Brownian bug model takes place also in the inter- acting L´evy bug model for appropriate parameters. This is against the expectation that particles performing L´evy flights cannot give rise to space-periodic clustering since their diffusion coefficient is infinite, for which the interact- ing Brownian bug model is known to reveal no periodic pattern. However, as a difference we have observed that, in the interacting L´evy bug model, due to the long jumps, there are many single particles between the clusters, lead- ing also to the differences in the particle density profiles of the average cluster or in the short-distance behavior of the radial distribution function. From this one can con- clude that the large-scale collective behavior of the system is much more strongly influenced by the competitive in- teraction than by the type of spatial motion performed by the bugs. We have also verified that the mean-field ap- proximation (12) is proper to describe the periodicity in the interacting L´evy bug model. As a final remark, let us mention that though the model studied in the present article describes rather living organ- isms, such as animals or bacteria, non-local interactions and L´evy flights are important also in plant ecology for the development of vegetation patterns [28], due to the competition for the resources and because the seed dis- persal is often described better by L´evy flights than by Gaussian jumps [29]. ∗ ∗ ∗ This work has been supported by the targeted financ- ing project SF0690030s09, Estonian Science Foundation through grant no. 7466, by the Balearic Government (E.H.), and by Spanish MICINN and FEDER through project FISICOS (FIS2007-60327). REFERENCES [1] Young W. R., Roberts A. J. and Stuhne G., Nature , 412 (2001) 328. [2] Zhang Y.-C., Serva M. and Polikarpov M., J. Stat. Phys. , 58 (1990) 849. [3] Felsenstein J., Am. Nat. , 109 (1975) 359. [4] Houchmandzadeh B., Phys. Rev. E , 66 (2002) 052901. [5] Houchmandzadeh B., Phys. Rev. Lett. , 101 (2008) 078103. [6] Houchmandzadeh B., Phys. Rev. E , 80 (2009) 051920. [7] Paessens M. and Schutz G., J. Phys. A , 37 (2004) 4709. [8] Hern´andez-Garc´ıa E. and L´opez C., Phys. Rev. E , 70 (2004) 016216. [9] Hern´andez-Garcia E. and L´opez C., J. Phys.: Con- dens. Matter , 17 (2005) S4263. [10] L´opez C. and Hern´andez-Garcia E., Physica D , 199 (2004) 223. [11] Bolkel B. M. and Pacala S. W., Am. Nat. , 153 (1999) 575. [12] Martin A. P., J. Theor. Biol. , 230 (2004) 343. [13] Birch D. A. and Young W. R., Theor. Pop. Biol. , 70 (2006) 26. [14] Metzler R. and Klafter J., Phys. Rep. , 339 (2000) 1. [15] Metzler R. and Klafter J., J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. , 37 (2004) R161. [16] Dieterich P., Klages R., Preuss R. and Schwab A., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA , 105 (2008) 459. [17] Klages R., Radons G. and Sokolov I. M., Anomalous Transport: Foundations and Applications (Wiley-VCH) 2008. [18] Viswanathan G. M., Raposo E. P. and da Luz M. G. E., Phys. Life Rev. , 5 (2008) 133. [19] Levandowsky M., White B. S. and Schuster F. L., Acta Protozool. , 36 (1997) 237. [20] Nossal R., J. Stat. Phys. , 30 (1983) 391. [21] Ramos-Fern´andez G., Mateos J. L., Miramontes O., Cocho G., Larralde H. and Ayala-Orozco B., Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. , 55 (2004) 223. [22] Bartumeus F., Peters F., Pueyo S., Marras´e C. and Catal´an J., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA , 100 (2003) 12771. [23] Durang X. and Henkel M., J. Phys. A , 42 (2009) 395004. [24] Baeumer B., Kov´acs M. and Meerschaert M., Bull. Math. Biol. , 69 (2007) 2281. [25] del Castillo-Negrete D., Carreras B. A. and Lynch V. E., Phys. Rev. Lett. , 91 (2003) 018302. [26] Ramos F., L´opez C., Hern´andez-Garc´ıa E. and Munoz M. A., Phys. Rev. E , 77 (2008) 021102. p-6 Spatial clustering of interacting bugs: L´evy flights versus Gaussian jumps [27] Florek K., Lukaszewicz J., Steinhaus H. and Zubrzycki S., Colloquium Mathematicum , 2 (1951) 282. [28] Borgogno F., D'Odorico P., Laio F. and Ridolfi L., Rev. Geophys. , 47 (2009) RG1005. [29] Clark J. S., Silman M., Kern R., Macklin E. and HilleRisLambers J., Ecology , 80 (1999) 1475. p-7
1604.06366	1	1604	2016-04-21T16:02:03	Molecular dynamics study of accelerated ion-induced shock waves in biological media	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft" ]	We present a molecular dynamics study of the effects of carbon- and iron-ion induced shock waves in DNA duplexes in liquid water. We use the CHARMM force field implemented within the MBN Explorer simulation package to optimize and equilibrate DNA duplexes in liquid water boxes of different sizes and shapes. The translational and vibrational degrees of freedom of water molecules are excited according to the energy deposited by the ions and the subsequent shock waves in liquid water are simulated. The pressure waves generated are studied and compared with an analytical hydrodynamics model which serves as a benchmark for evaluating the suitability of the simulation boxes. The energy deposition in the DNA backbone bonds is also monitored as an estimation of biological damage, something which lies beyond the possibilities of the analytical model.	physics.bio-ph	physics	EPJ manuscript No. (will be inserted by the editor) 6 1 0 2 r p A 1 2 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 6 6 3 6 0 . 4 0 6 1 : v i X r a Molecular dynamics study of accelerated ion-induced shock waves in biological media Pablo de Vera1,2,3,a, Nigel J. Mason2, Fred J. Currell1, and Andrey V. Solov'yov3,b 1 School of Mathematics and Physics, Queen's University Belfast, BT7 1NN Belfast, Northern Ireland, United Kingdom 2 Department of Physical Sciences, The Open University, Walton Hall, MK7 6AA Milton Keynes, England, United Kingdom 3 MBN Research Center, Altenhoferallee 3, 60438 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Received: date / Revised version: date Abstract. We present a molecular dynamics study of the effects of carbon- and iron-ion induced shock waves in DNA duplexes in liquid water. We use the CHARMM force field implemented within the MBN Explorer simulation package to optimize and equilibrate DNA duplexes in liquid water boxes of different sizes and shapes. The translational and vibrational degrees of freedom of water molecules are excited according to the energy deposited by the ions and the subsequent shock waves in liquid water are simulated. The pressure waves generated are studied and compared with an analytical hydrodynamics model which serves as a benchmark for evaluating the suitability of the simulation boxes. The energy deposition in the DNA backbone bonds is also monitored as an estimation of biological damage, something which lies beyond the possibilities of the analytical model. 1 Introduction Collisional phenomena between fast ions and biomolecules is a topic of major interest since it is necessary to un- derstand the mechanisms of such processes if we are to develop ion beam cancer therapy (IBCT). In this ther- apy technique, energetic protons or heavier ions are used clinically to treat deeply seated tumors [1]. From a macro- scopic point of view one of the working principles of IBCT is the Bragg peak, a sharp maximum in the depth-dose curve at the end of the energetic ion trajectories (con- trary to photon or electron beams which have a quite broad energy deposition profile) that maximizes energy deposition in the tumor while sparing surrounding healthy tissues. However, it is well known that the effectiveness of IBCT relies on nanoscopic phenomena rather than on macroscopic characteristics [2,3], the former being directly related to atomic collisions with biomolecules. Indeed, a given dose deposited by ions presents a much larger cell killing probability than the same dose deposited by pho- tons. This increased relative biological effectiveness is due to the large energy deposited around ion tracks on the nanoscale, giving place to an increase in the clustering of damaging events in biomolecules, especially in nuclear DNA, which makes the repair processes less effective [4]. The fundamental aspects of the problem are also of great interest. The irradiation with ions involves new phys- ical phenomena which are not always considered properly a Corresponding author: [email protected] b On leave from A. F. Ioffe Physical Technical Institute, 194021 St. Petersburg, Russian Federation (or considered at all) in biophysical models. In fact, IBCT is a complex problem, involving many different space, en- ergy, and time scales, ranging from the transport of en- ergetic ions in macroscopic tissues, the production of sec- ondary electrons and radicals that can propagate on the nano- and microscale (molecular and cellular levels, re- spectively) and their interaction with biomolecules on the nanometer scale leading to the final biological outcomes, noticeable in larger space and time scales [3]. More sig- nificantly, all the physico-chemical processes occurring at the molecular level make it necessary to deviate from a simple energy deposition scheme. On these space scales not only energy deposition events are of importance, since the way in which this energy promotes different kind of processes can significantly affect the final effects. While many processes are fairly well known, such as the electron production and propagation or the generation of free rad- icals, new interactions are being discovered, such as the dissociative electron attachment, a mechanism by which very low energy electrons (with energies even below the ionization threshold) can fragment biomolecules [5]. In this context another damage mechanism has been theoretically predicted: ion-induced shock waves on the nanometer scale [6,7,8]. Ion beams can deposit large amounts of energy per unit path length (a carbon ion in the Bragg peak region deposits 900 eV/nm), and the major part of this energy is used to eject secondary elec- trons of very low energies, below 50 eV [3,9,10]. Most of such electrons transfer their energy to electronic excita- tions of the medium in less than a nanometer and the time scale in which this energy loss occurs is very short, 2 P. de Vera et al.: Molecular dynamics study of ion-induced shock waves in biological media of a few femtoseconds [11]. These times are very short in comparison with the mechanism capable of dissipating this energy, the electron-phonon coupling, which occurs in the sub-picosecond scale [11]. This situation results in a large heating of the medium in nanocylinders around the ion tracks, providing the conditions for a violent explo- sion of these "hot cylinders", a mechanism we refer to as ion-induced shock waves. This shock wave effect was first predicted in terms of a hydrodynamics model where it was shown that pressures up to tens of GPa can be produced around ion tracks [7]. However, this is not enough for predicting biomolecu- lar damage and subsequently molecular dynamics simula- tions were used to show how these conditions are sufficient to produce bond breaking in nucleosomes [6]. Moreover since the shock waves travel at high velocity they can propagate secondary species (i.e., free radicals, solvated electrons) much faster than the diffusion mechanism. All these dynamical and thermo-mechanical effects can dras- tically change the physico-chemical environment to which biomolecules are exposed under irradiation. A proper understanding of the characteristics of shock waves requires more systematic studies, especially by the use of molecular dynamics, a technique that can assess their properties and consequences in more detail. Such studies will enhance the understanding of the biological role of ion-induced shock waves, as well as help in the design of possible experiments to verify their existence. In the present paper we report molecular dynamics sim- ulations to study the main features of ion-induced shock waves and their effects on DNA by means of the MBN Explorer software [13]. We focus the work on shock waves produced around carbon (one of the most promising pro- jectiles used in IBCT) and iron ion tracks in the Bragg peak region. We study the dependence of several quanti- ties, namely pressure waves and energy deposition in DNA bonds, on the size and characteristics of the system, in order to establish the proper features of the simulation box for future more systematic studies. These results are compared with the analytical hydrodynamics model [7] as well as to previous simulation results [6] to benchmark the simulations. As a probe for biodamage we will use short DNA segments. This is because such short DNA duplexes can be simulated more straightforwardly than nucleosomes, so they are more convenient for systematic studies. Also, since the effects of shock waves are more noticeable in short distances, a short DNA strand should be enough for evaluating biomolecular damage, in a sim- ilar fashion to the effects of secondary electrons on DNA studied previously [3]. The methodology of the work is explained in section 2, where the hydrodynamics model (subsection 2.1) and the molecular dynamics procedure (subsection 2.2) are dis- cussed. The results of the simulations are presented in sec- tion 3, where the pressure generated by the shock waves and their effects in the DNA duplex are studied. The final conclusions and remarks are given in section 4. 2 Methods Ion-induced nanoscopic shock waves were first described in terms of an analytical hydrodynamics model that was used for the first evaluation of their characteristics [7]. Even though it allows calculation of the basic physical features, such as the pressure generated during the shock wave, it does not allow the evaluation of the characteristics related to biological effects, such as the damage of DNA molecules, for which an atomic level description is needed. This kind of analysis can be performed through molecular dynamics simulations [6]. However, the analytical hydro- dynamics model serves as a good benchmark for the molec- ular dynamics simulations. Some relevant features of the analytical hydrodynamics model are reviewed in subsec- tion 2.1. The molecular dynamics simulations technique is reviewed in subsection 2.2. The choice of the biomolecu- lar probe, as well as its setting up for the simulations, is explained in subsection 2.2.1, and the setting up of the ini- tial conditions for the simulation of the ion-induced shock wave is described in subsection 2.2.2. 2.1 Hydrodynamics model This model was adapted from a classical hydrodynam- ics treatment of the self-similar flow of liquid water and heat transfer [12] and applied to the specific situation of the energy delivered around an energetic ion track on the nanoscale where the resulting water flow is cylindrical [7]. Several predictions of this model are very convenient for benchmarking the simulations performed in the present work. In particular, the position of the wave front as a function of time is given by: R(t) = β√t(cid:20)dT /ds ρ (cid:21)1/4 , (1) and the pressure of the front as a function of the front radius is: Pfront(R) = 1 2 (γ + 1) β4 dT /ds R2 . (2) In both equations, ρ = 1 g/cm3 is the density of unper- turbed liquid water, γ = Cp/Cv = 1.222 for liquid water, dT /ds is the stopping power (i.e., mean energy loss dT per unit path length ds) of an ion in liquid water, and β is a parameter which value for liquid water is β = 0.86 [7]. 2.2 Molecular dynamics simulation In the molecular dynamics technique [14] all the atoms of the system are considered and their classical trajectories are followed by computing the interaction forces between all the atoms in the system. The evolution with time of the coordinates ri(t) of each atom i of mass mi is com- puted for discrete time steps dt, according to the Langevin P. de Vera et al.: Molecular dynamics study of ion-induced shock waves in biological media 3 equation: mi d2ri dt2 =Xj6=i F ij − 1 τd mivi + fi , (3) where Pj6=i F ij is the total force acting on atom i as a consequence of its interaction with all other atoms j in the system (i.e., Newton's second law). The second and third terms in the right hand side of Eq. (3) correspond to the thermostat, used to keep the temperature of the system nearly constant to T , when coupled to a thermal bath. In the present work the Langevin thermostat is used, which exerts a viscous force on each particle of velocity vi, as well as a random force fi which guarantees thermal equilibrium. τd is the damping time of the thermostat, while fi is a Gaussian random force with zero mean and variance σ2 i = 2mikBT /τd with kB being the Boltzmann's constant. For biomolecular systems, where the structure of the molecule is determined not only by interatomic distances but also by the geometric configuration of groups of atoms due to the molecular orbital hybridization, it is common to use special forcefields describing such interactions. In the CHARMM forcefield [15], one of the most common ones for describing biomolecules, the force acting on the atom i is obtained from the potential energy U (R) as Pj6=i F ij = dU (R)/dri which corresponds to a given set of atomic coordinates R and is expressed as a combina- tion of energies arising from the distances between pairs of bonded atoms, the angles formed between groups of three sequentially bonded atoms, the dihedral torsion an- gle formed by groups of sequentially four bonded atoms, the improper angles formed between groups of atoms that should form a plane, and the nonbonded interactions rep- resented by the pure Coulomb force and the van der Waals interaction between pairs of atoms: U (R) = Xbonds + Xdihedr. +Xi Xj6=i Kb(b − b0)2 + Xangles Kχ (1 + cos nχ − δ) + Ximprop. rij (cid:19)12 +"ǫij(cid:18) Rmin,ij qiqj ε rij Kθ(θ − θ0)2 + (4) Kϕ(ϕ − ϕ0)2 + rij (cid:19)6# . −(cid:18) Rmin,ij In this equation b is the bond distance between two bonded atoms, θ is the bond angle between every triplet of sequen- tially bonded atoms, χ is the dihedral torsion angle formed by every four atoms connected via covalent bonds and ϕ is the improper torsion angle, used to maintain planarity between groups of sequentially bonded atoms; b0, θ0 and ϕ0 correspond to the equilibrium quantities, while n and δ determine the periodicity of the dihedral interaction. Kb, Kθ, Kχ and Kϕ are the corresponding force constants. The Coulomb interaction is characterized by the atomic partial charges qi, the interatomic distances rij and the effective dielectric constant ε. The van der Waals interaction is de- fined by a 6 -- 12 Lennard-Jones potential with well depth Table 1. Summary of the different simulation boxes used for the shock wave simulations. The four systems have a length of 4.6 nm along the track direction y, where PBC are applied. System Shape Track-to-boundary PBC distance (nm) (x, z) I II III IV disc parallelepiped disc parallelepiped 10 10 17 17 No Yes No Yes ǫ and the minimum energy distance Rmin. All of these pa- rameters can be obtained for many biological molecules, including nucleic acids and proteins, from the CHARMM potential [15]. All simulations in this work have been per- formed using the CHARMM implementation within the MBN Explorer simulation package [13]. 2.2.1 Setting up the biological system The main constituent of living tissues is liquid water. Therefore when we refer to the ion-induced shock waves, they occur mainly in water. However, if we want to es- timate possible biological effects, we should consider as a target of the shock wave some biological molecules, for example DNA. Thus in order to set up a simulation box for the present study we need to define (i) the water box in which the shock wave is going to propagate and (ii) the biological molecule that we are going to use to assess biodamage. Point (i), even though it seems straightforward, has to be considered carefully. This is because the shock wave is a violent dynamical process and the pressure waves generated can propagate fast, reaching, under certain cir- cumstances, the boundaries of the simulation box. Such "boundary effects" can produce artifacts in the simula- tions. These artifacts could be simply avoided by setting a extremely large water box in order to guarantee that the shock wave will not arrive to the boundaries. However, the computational cost of molecular dynamics simulations in- creases with the number of atoms in the simulation box, so the size of the system has to be selected properly in order to perform the simulations in reasonable times. For this reason in the present study we have constructed four different simulation boxes. In particular we want to study the effect of the size of the system in the simulation results as well as the inclusion of periodic boundary conditions to simulate extended me- dia. These four systems are summarized in Table 1. The first box, which we will refer as system I, was designed as a liquid water disc of 10 nm radius around the track, located in the disc center. This system is quite convenient since it is quite small and then computationally efficient. A radius of 10 nm was chosen following results from the hydrodynamics model, which shows that the pressure of the shock wave is already very small after 10 nm [7]. This disc, 4.6 nm long in the track direction y, was simulated 4 P. de Vera et al.: Molecular dynamics study of ion-induced shock waves in biological media with periodic boundary conditions (PBC) only in this di- rection. In order to check the effect of the inclusion of PBC in the directions x and z, the parallelepiped system II was built. It has the same length of 4.6 nm in the track direc- tion y and the distance from the track to the boundary is also 10 nm but PBC are applied in the three coordinates. Finally, to check size effects, two similar systems but with a track-to-boundary distance of 17 nm where built, sys- tems III and IV. System IV will be in general used as a benchmark for the rest of them since it is the largest one and it has PBC in all directions. Regarding point (ii), in the present work we would like to chose a simple system that can be simulated straight- forwardly for performing more systematic studies of shock wave effects in biomolecules. As a first approximation we will use short DNA segments, as it was done in previous works evaluating the damaging effect of secondary elec- trons [3]. They are simpler to treat than nucleosomes and, since shock wave effects are quite local, they should be large enough for estimating DNA damage. In the present study we have chosen the B-DNA molecule from the Protein Data Bank [16] with PDB ID 309D [17]. This molecule, represented in Fig. 1, con- sists on a B-DNA duplex containing eight base-pairs and two free nucleotides at each 5'-end. These sticky ends are complementary, forming continuous 10-fold double helix molecules. This molecule is very convenient since it allows the building of DNA duplex models as long as desired, by the replication and displacement of the original molecule as many times as wanted. It opens, as well, the possibility of being used as building block for more complex DNA structures if desired. Currently we have used the 309D molecule to con- struct a linear DNA duplex, each strand being 30-base long, which we consider is enough for an initial assess- ment of the shock wave effects in DNA. After building this molecule from the original one from the Protein Data Bank it is solvated in liquid water and an atmosphere of 60 sodium counterions is placed around the DNA (since each base carries one negative charge) by means of the software VMD [18]. Then, using MBN Explorer [13], the system is optimized by a velocity quenching algorithm, and then equilibrated at T = 310 K (body temperature), using the Langevin thermostat with damping time τd = 0.2 ps, a simulation time step dt = 1 fs, periodic boundary con- ditions, the particle mesh Ewald algorithm for the long- range Coulomb interactions, and a van der Waals cut off distance of 13 A. The geometry of the resulting DNA du- plex, as well as the structure of the sodium ions envi- ronment, has been checked and compared with reference data [19,20,21]. The equilibrated DNA duplex has then been put in the different water boxes described above for the subsequent shock wave simulations. The DNA duplex, oriented in the z direction, is always placed with its center at 2 nm distance from the track, in a way in which the closest DNA atom is at ∼ 1 nm from the track. The initial configurations for systems I and II are shown in Figs. 2(a) and (d). Fig. 1. (Color online) Representation of the B-DNA molecule from the Protein Data Bank [16] with PDB ID 309D [17]. Thick lines represent the backbone bonds whose energy is monitored during the shock wave simulations (see section 3). 2.2.2 Setting up the initial conditions of the shock wave An energetic ion losses its energy mainly by electronic ex- citations and ionizations. As a result a large number of low energy electrons are produced (below 50 eV in the Bragg peak) [3,9,10,22] which will propagate on the nanometer scale, being stopped very quickly. The dynamics of such a process was studied in Ref. [11], where it was shown how the radial dose around the ion track is built up in ∼ 50 fs. Also, almost all the energy lost by the ion is deposited within 1 nm from the ion track. It is well known that the electron-phonon coupling, the mechanism by which the energy deposited by the secondary electrons can be dissipated, occurs in times much longer than fs, i.e., in the sub-ps scale. This means that a large amount of en- ergy will be locally deposited within ∼ 1 nm very quickly (∼ 50 fs) and that it will be released at once, putting the initial conditions for the formation of the shock wave. In terms of the molecular dynamics simulations we se- lect the water molecules initially present within 1 nm ra- dius from the ion track. These molecules are highlighted in Fig. 2, where their atoms are shown as spheres. All the energy lost by the ion (which is not considered explicitly in the simulations since it crosses the system in much shorter times) will be transferred to these molecules so the veloci- ties of their atoms (obtained from previous equilibration) are multiplied by a factor α, in a way in which their total kinetic energy after the ion crosses the system is: 1 2 N Xi mi(α · vi)2 = 3N kBT 2 · l . +(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) dT ds(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) (5) P. de Vera et al.: Molecular dynamics study of ion-induced shock waves in biological media 5 Fig. 2. (Color online) Snapshots of a shock wave induced by a carbon ion in the Bragg peak region in liquid water with the track (y direction) crossing systems I and II at 1 nm distance from the DNA duplex (oriented in the z direction). Panels (a), (b), and (c) correspond to the system I at 0, 5, and 10 ps after the ion traversal, while panels (d), (e), and (f) represent the same times for the system II. The water molecules initially excited by the ion track as well as the DNA duplex are highlighted, with their atoms shown as explicit atoms. The first term in the right hand side of the equation corre- sponds to the initial kinetic energy of the excited cylinder (with N atoms) at equilibrium (T = 310 K). The second term is the energy lost by the ion when crossing the sys- tem, which is its stopping power, dT /ds times the length of the simulation box, l. The simulation of the shock wave is done as indicated previously for the equlibration but without thermostat and with lower values of the time step dt, depending on the simulation, to ensure conservation of energy. 6 P. de Vera et al.: Molecular dynamics study of ion-induced shock waves in biological media 3 Results and discussion We will start our study of the effects of ion-induced shock waves in DNA duplexes with a carbon ion in the Bragg peak region (with kinetic energy of ∼300 keV/u), carbon being a common choice in modern ion beam therapy cen- ters. The stopping power of a carbon ion in the Bragg peak is 900 eV/nm. Figures 2(a), (b), and (c) show three snapshots of the evolution of the system after irradiation (0, 5, and 10 ps, respectively) when using system I, i.e., a 10 nm radius disc in vacuum (see Table 1). The same results are shown in Figs. 2(d), (e), and (f) for system II, i.e., a parallelepiped of 10 nm track-to-boundary distance with periodic boundary conditions (PBC). The explosion of the system is much more violent for system I than for system II with the structure of the DNA duplex being heavily distorted in Fig. 2(c). This is due to the high pressures produced by the shock wave that force the system to expand into vacuum in system I. However, this behavior does not occur in system II, apparently be- cause the periodic boundary conditions provide the pres- sure to damp the effects of the shock wave. The final struc- ture of the DNA duplex is distorted in system II (Fig. 2(f)) but not that much as in the case of system I. Therefore, periodic boundary conditions are needed to suppress the system explosion if a small system is used for the simula- tions. A better understanding of this situation can be achieved by calculating the pressure generated by the shock wave. These values can be compared to the results provided by the analytical model (subsection 2.1). To calculate the pressure, virtual walls have been placed at different ra- dial distances r from the track. At several times t during the simulation the number of atoms crossing this wall in each direction has been monitored and their momentum pi = mivi calculated. The pressure is calculated as: P = dp dt A = 2(cid:16)Pi pi −Pj pj(cid:17) dt A , (6) where dt is the time passed between frames in the sim- ulation, A is the surface of the cylindrical wall and the indexes i and j refer to the atoms crossing the wall in the outer and in the inner directions respectively. The factor 2 comes from the assumption that, if the wall was there to measure the pressure, the atoms would have an elas- tic collision coming back after the collision with the same momentum pi but in nearly opposite direction, so the mo- mentum transfer would be dpi ≃ 2pi. The results for the time evolution of the pressure wave produced by a carbon ion in the Bragg peak in system IV (where boundary effects are not expected) are shown in Fig. 3(a). The wave front can be clearly identified dur- ing the first picosecond, where the Gaussian shape is very visible, with a sharp maximum, that propagates rapidly (faster than ∼1600 m/s) in the radial direction. After the first few picoseconds the pressure wave widens and loses intensity quickly. This time evolution can be compared with the results of the hydrodynamics model (subsection 2.1). This comparison is shown for the position of the front 8 6 4 2 0 25 20 15 10 5 0 ) 2 / m n N n ( P (a) (b) 0.25 ps 0.5 ps 1 ps 2 ps 3 ps 6 ps 9 ps 0 2 4 6 10 12 14 16 8 r (nm) Fig. 3. (Color online) Time evolution of the pressure, as a function of the radius from the track r, generated by (a) a carbon ion and (b) an iron ion in the Bragg peak region in system IV, a parallelepiped with 17 nm track-to-boundary distance and periodic boundary conditions (see Table 1). and its pressure, respectively, in Figs. 4(a) and (b), where lines are the results from the analytical model and sym- bols represent the results from the simulations (which have been obtained by finding the maximum of the Gaussian fitting each curve in Fig. 3(a)). The first important observation is that simulation re- sults in system IV follow the results of the analytical model for carbon. However, artifacts appear in the re- sults of systems II and III due to their small size or the lack of PBC. In the case of system II, where the track-to- boundary distance is just 10 nm, the tail of the pressure wave reaches the boundary after ∼3 ps. This produces a reflection of the pressure wave in the boundary, which stops the front propagation. Even though the disc-like sys- tem III has a track-to-boundary distance of 17 nm, the lack of PBC seems to produce an unnatural propagation of the front at longer times. Neither of these effects are ob- served for carbon when system IV is used, what suggests that the system has to be large enough and PBC should be applied in order to properly contain the shock wave. P. de Vera et al.: Molecular dynamics study of ion-induced shock waves in biological media 7 t (ps) 4 6 8 10 2 0 (a) 10 8 6 4 2 0 25 20 15 10 (b) C (MD, System II) C (MD, System III) C (MD, System IV) C (Hydrodynamics) Fe (MD, System IV) Fe (Hydrodynamics) t n u o c e v i t l a e R (a) 100 10-1 10-2 10-3 10-4 10-5 100 (b) 10-1 10-2 10-3 10-4 0.6 0.4 0.2 ) V e ( d n o b U 0.0 0 2 4 6 t (ps) 8 10 C in system I C in systemII C in system III C in system IV Fe in system IV C ion in nucleosome [6] Fe in nucleosome [6] ) m n ( R ) 2 / m n N n ( t n o r f P 5 0 0 2 4 6 R (nm) 8 10 12 Fig. 4. (Color online) (a) Time evolution of the wave front position for carbon and iron ion induced shock waves in the Bragg peak region. (b) Pressure of the wave front as a function of its radial position, for carbon and iron induced shock waves in the Bragg peak region. Symbols represent molecular dynamics results, while lines are the predictions of the analytical hydrodynamics model. See the text for further details. 10-5 0 1 2 3 Ubond (eV) 4 5 Fig. 5. (Color online) Relative count of energy deposition events in the DNA backbone bonds located within 2.2 nm of the ion track. (a) Present results for a carbon ion in the Bragg peak region in systems I -- IV. (b) Present results for carbon and iron ions in system IV, compared with previous results in the nucleosome [6]. The inset shows the time evolution of the potential energy of some of the bonds analyzed for a carbon ion in system IV. Before discussing results for a heavier ion (iron), we will analyze the effects of the carbon-induced shock wave in the DNA duplex. We have monitored the energy stored in the covalent bonds of the DNA backbone closest to the track [6]. The inset in Fig. 5(a) shows the potential en- ergy of some of the covalent bonds (first term in the right hand side of Eq. (5)), initially located within 2.2 nm from the track, as a function of time. The energy stored in the bonds varies in time, with some sudden jumps due to the exposure of the bonds to the pressure of the shock wave. Each of those local maxima can be stored as an energy deposition event. The frequency count of such events for the shock wave produced by a carbon ion in the Bragg peak in all the systems I-IV is represented in Fig. 5(a). This frequency, which presents an exponential behavior, can be parameterized to estimate the probability for in- ducing single strand breaks, regarded as energy deposition larger than some given threshold, typically around 2.5 eV [6]. Clearly, system I presents a very different behavior while systems II-IV converge. This result arises from the artificial violent explosion of system I, due to the lack of pressure to damp the shock wave. The convergence be- tween systems II-IV emphasizes the importance of the first picoseconds of the shock wave in terms of DNA damage: even though the pressure wave differs in these systems af- ter ∼ 3 ps, their energy deposition profile is similar, high- lighting the fact that it is built up during the first picosec- onds after the explosion. The energy deposition profile is compared with previous simulations in the nucleosome [6] in Fig. 5(b), where we find a fairly good match, allowing for the different geometries. 8 P. de Vera et al.: Molecular dynamics study of ion-induced shock waves in biological media From these simulations it is clear that there is a rel- atively low probability of producing single strand breaks by the shock wave in the case of carbon ions (assuming a SSB threshold of 2.5 eV; however, such thresholds can be even lower [6]). In terms of a possible experimental verifi- cation of these results it would be convenient to study ions with larger stopping powers since these can produce larger numbers of strand breaks, so they are easier to detect. For this reason we have performed a simulation of the shock wave produced by an iron ion in the Bragg peak region, having a stopping power of 7195 eV/nm. System IV has been used for this simulation simulation since, from the results for carbon, the other systems would be too small. The evolution of the pressure wave for iron is shown in Fig. 3(b), the evolution of the front is depicted in Fig. 4, and the energy deposition profile in the DNA backbone bonds is shown in Fig. 5(b). The final geometry of the system after 10 ps, as compared with the carbon case, is shown in Fig. 6. Both the position of the front and its pressure, shown in Fig. 4, seem to follow the predictions of the analytical model but only up to 4 ps. After that, it can be clearly seen that the front actually goes backwards. This behaviour is caused by the reflection of the pressure wave at the boundaries of the system, as it happened for carbon with system II. As expected from Eqs. (1) and (2), the velocity of propagation of the iron shock wave is 1.682 faster than for carbon and the pressure of the front is 8 times larger. This results from the fact that the stopping power for iron in the Bragg peak region is 8 times larger than for carbon. Such large pressures lead to larger distortions of the DNA duplex being observed for iron in comparison with carbon in Fig. 6. This leads to a larger number of high en- ergy deposition events in DNA backbone bonds, as shown in Fig. 5(b), where the slope of the curve is much smaller than for carbon ion and many more events larger than 2.5 eV (a conservative estimation for the threshold for single strand break production) are produced. This would justify the use of heavier ions for a possible experimental verifica- tion of shock wave effects, where more single strand breaks would be detected. The results for iron are compared with previous simulations performed for nucleosome [6]. In this case, the present results are not that close to the previ- ously reported values. However, the order of magnitude seems to be similar. Such differences could be due to sev- eral reasons, the most probable being the different geom- etry. The larger slope of the previously reported data sug- gests that the histone protein has some protective role in DNA damage. In the present work the DNA duplex is free, allowing a larger stretching of the molecule which might be impeded in the nucleosome. Also the fact that system IV is not large enough for the iron-induced shock wave could have some contribution. However, as seen from the results for carbon, the first picoseconds of the simulation are the most relevant for the DNA damage and the molec- ular dynamics simulation follows properly the analytical results up to 4 ps. It is clear, in any case, that a larger system is needed for the simulation of an iron ion shock wave. This has not been done here in order not to increase Fig. 6. (Color online) Geometry of system IV, 10 ps af- ter passage of (a) a carbon ion and (b) an iron ion, in the Bragg peak region. Nanochannels are formed in liquid water, and the DNA structure is distorted, particularly heavily in the case of the iron ion. the computational expense of the calculations. However, precautions should be taken in future calculations to op- timize the box for each ion. In any case, the main conclu- sion that can be extracted from Fig. 4 is that molecular dynamics simulations can reproduce perfectly the results predicted by the analytical hydrodynamics model as long as the system used for the simulations is large enough for containing the wave and PBC are applied. Indeed the hy- drodynamics model can be used as a consistency check to analyze whether the system built for molecular dynamics simulation is appropriate or not. 4 Conclusions In this paper we have presented a molecular dynamics study of the effects of ion-induced shock waves in biologi- cal media. The study focuses on the pressure waves arising from the heating of liquid water after energetic carbon and P. de Vera et al.: Molecular dynamics study of ion-induced shock waves in biological media 9 iron ions traversal (in the Bragg peak region) and on the effects of such waves on short DNA duplexes. The first important conclusion of this paper is that molecular dynamics simulations of ion-induced shock waves can reproduce the results obtained by the analyti- cal hydrodynamics model previously reported, in terms of front velocity and pressure, as long as the simulation box is properly designed. This point is of great importance: ion-induced shock waves have not been detected yet ex- perimentally and their existence has been so far only pre- dicted theoretically. The fact that independent techniques, such as classical molecular dynamics and classical hydro- dynamics, coincide in the prediction of the properties of the shock waves adds arguments in favor of their existence and establishes the theoretical grounds over which possi- ble experiments can be designed and interpreted for their confirmation. Molecular dynamics simulations reproduce the analyt- ical results only if the system is well designed. This means that it has to be large enough to contain the pressure waves produced and that preferably periodic boundary conditions should be applied to avoid boundary effects in the simulation, such as the reflection of the pressure wave in the periodic boundaries or the expansion of the system into vacuum when PBC are not applied. In the present case, a track-to-boundary distance of 17 nm has been demonstrated to be large enough for carbon-induced shock waves in the Bragg peak region. For iron larger boxes should be used in future work. However, smaller boxes can be used for certain simulations as long as one is interested in short times and distances from the track where most of the damage occurs. The analytical hydro- dynamics model can be always used to check the consis- tency of the results, as shown in this paper. This is some- thing that has not been considered before and has not been checked in other works. The energy deposition profile in the DNA backbone bonds has been analyzed, both for carbon and iron ions, as an estimation of possible biological damage. The results obtained for carbon are very similar to those reported pre- viously for molecular dynamics simulations in the nucle- osome [6]. For the case of iron ions we have found some differences with the previous published data. However, the order of magnitude of the results is quite similar, confirm- ing the systematics of the stopping power of the ion on the expected damage of DNA. The observed differences are most likely due to the different geometry of the sys- tems used, where the presence of the histone protein in the nucleosome can have some protective effect. The present results establish a solid procedure for per- forming more systematic simulations of shock wave effects in DNA duplexes, where the analytical hydrodynamics model can be used as a benchmark. The properties of the shock waves for ions of different stopping powers can be predicted and their effects on DNA determined. This opens the door to new simulation improvements, such as the inclusion of reactive force fields for a better prediction of DNA damage [23,24] or the study of the shock wave effects in the propagation of secondary species generated around ion tracks. Such systematic studies will allow a better understanding of the biological relevance of ion- induced shock waves and will be useful for the future de- sign and interpretation of potential experiments for their detection. The authors acknowledge financial support from the European Unions FP7-People Program (Marie Curie Actions) within the Initial Training Network No. 608163 "ARGENT", Advanced Radiotherapy, Generated by Exploiting Nanoprocesses and Technologies. The molecular dynamics simulations were per- formed at the computer clusters IMACT, at The Open Univer- sity (UK), and KELVIN, at Queen's University Belfast (UK). References 1. J. S. Loeffler and M. Durante, Nature Rev. Clin. Oncol. 10, 411 (2013) 2. M. Scholz and T. Elsasser, Adv. Space Res. 40, 1381 (2007) 3. E. Surdutovich and A. V. Solov'yov, Eur. Phys. J. D 68, 353 (2014) 4. D. Schardt, T. Elsasser, and D. Schulz-Ertner, Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 383 (2010) 5. B. Boudaıffa, P. Cloutier, D. Hunting, M. A. Huels, and L. Sanche, Science 287, 1658 (2000) 6. E. Surdutovich, A. V. Yakubovich, and A. V. Solov'yov, Scientific Reports 3, 1289 (2013) 7. E. Surdutovich and A. V. Solov'yov, Phys. Rev. E 82, 051915 (2010) 8. A. V. Yakubovich, E. Surdutovich, and A. V. Solov'yov, Nucl. Instr. Meth. B 297, 135 (2012) 9. P. de Vera, R. Garcia-Molina, I. Abril, and A. V. Solov'yov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 148104 (2013) 10. P. de Vera, I. Abril, R. Garcia-Molina, and A. V. Solov'yov, J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. 438, 012015 (2013) 11. E. Surdutovich and A. V. Solov'yov, Europ. Phys. J. D 69, 193 (2015) 12. L. Landau and E. Lifshitz, Fluid Dynamics, 2nd ed. (Reed- Elsevier, Oxford, Boston, Johannesburg, 1987), Vol. 6. 13. I. A. Solov'yov, A. V. Yakubovich, P. V. Nikolaev, I. Volkovets, and A. V. Solov'yov, J. Comp. Chem. 33, 2412 (2012); www.mbnexplorer.com 14. M. P. Allen and D. J. Tildesley, Computer simulation of liquids (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1989). 15. A. D. MacKerell, Jr., D. Bashford, M. Bellott, R. L. Dun- brack, Jr., J. D. Evanseck, et al., J. Phys. Chem. B 102, 3586 (1998) 16. H. M. Berman, J. Westbrook, Z. Feng, G. Gilliland, T. N. Bhat, H. Weissig, I. N. Shindyalov, P. E. Bourne, Nucl. Acids Res. 28, 235 (2000) 17. H. Qiu, Biol. J. C. Dewan, N. C. 267, 881 Mol. http://www.rcsb.org/pdb/explore/explore.do?structureId=309D. (1997). Available Seeman, J. online: 18. W. Humphrey, A. Dalke, and K. Schulten, J. Molec. Graphics 14, 33 (1996) 19. U. Heinemann, C. Alings and M. Bansal, The EMBO Jour- nal 11, 1931 (1992) 20. F. Pan, C. Roland and C. Sagui, Nucl. Acids Res. 42, 13981 (2004) 21. T. J. Robbins and Y. Wang, J. Biomolec. Struct. Dynam. 31, 1311 (2013) 10 P. de Vera et al.: Molecular dynamics study of ion-induced shock waves in biological media 22. O.I. Obolensky, E. Surdutovich, I. Pshenichnov, I. Mishus- tin, A.V. Solov'yov, and W. Greiner, Nucl. Instr. Meth. B 266, 1623 (2008) 23. D. Bottlander, C. Muckschb, H. M. Urbassek, Nucl. Instr. Meth. B 365, 622 (2015) 24. G. B. Sushko, I. A. Solov'yov, A. V. Verkhovtsev, S. N. Volkov, and A. V. Solov'yov, Eur. Phys. J. D 70, 12 (2016).
1910.05413	1	1910	2019-10-11T21:06:12	Temporal precision of molecular events with regulation and feedback	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.MN" ]	Cellular behaviors such as migration, division, and differentiation rely on precise timing, and yet the molecular events that govern these behaviors are highly stochastic. We investigate regulatory strategies that decrease the timing noise of molecular events. Autoregulatory feedback increases noise. Yet, we find that in the presence of regulation by a second species, autoregulatory feedback decreases noise. To explain this finding, we develop a method to calculate the optimal regulation function that minimizes the timing noise. The method reveals that the combination of feedback and regulation minimizes noise by maximizing the number of molecular events that must happen in sequence before a threshold is crossed. We compute the optimal timing precision for all two-node networks with regulation and feedback, derive a generic lower bound on timing noise, and discuss our results in the context of neuroblast migration during Caenorhabditis elegans development.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Temporal precision of molecular events with regulation and feedback Shivam Gupta,1 Sean Fancher,1, 2 Hendrik C. Korswagen,3 and Andrew Mugler1, ∗ 1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA 2Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA 3Hubrecht Institute, Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences and University Medical Center Utrecht, 3584 CT Utrecht, Netherlands Cellular behaviors such as migration, division, and differentiation rely on precise timing, and yet the molecular events that govern these behaviors are highly stochastic. We investigate regulatory strategies that decrease the timing noise of molecular events. Autoregulatory feedback increases noise. Yet, we find that in the presence of regulation by a second species, autoregulatory feedback decreases noise. To explain this finding, we develop a method to calculate the optimal regulation function that minimizes the timing noise. The method reveals that the combination of feedback and regulation minimizes noise by maximizing the number of molecular events that must happen in sequence before a threshold is crossed. We compute the optimal timing precision for all two-node networks with regulation and feedback, derive a generic lower bound on timing noise, and discuss our results in the context of neuroblast migration during Caenorhabditis elegans development. Precise timing is crucial for many biological processes including cell division [1 -- 3], cell differentiation [4], cell migration [5], embryonic development [6, 7], and cell death [8]. Ultimately the timing of these processes is gov- erned by the timing of molecular events inside the cell. However, these events are inherently stochastic. Cells use regulatory networks to reduce this stochasticity, but the effects of particular regulatory features on timing pre- cision remain poorly understood. We recently demon- strated that the time at which an accumulating molecu- lar species crosses an abundance threshold is more precise if that species is regulated by a second species with its own stochastic dynamics [9]. In contrast, it was recently demonstrated that if the species is instead regulated by itself (feedback), then the crossing time is less precise [10]. Yet, feedback is common in many important tim- ing processes. In yeast, the cyclin proteins that cross an abundance threshold to initiate the cell cycle [3] are subject to positive feedback [1, 11, 12]. In Caenorhabdi- tis elegans, the mig-1 protein that crosses an abundance threshold to terminate migration in QR neuroblasts [5] has been found in experiments on the sister QL lineage to be subject to feedback via Wnt signaling [13]. This raises the question of why feedback is observed in key timing processes if it has been shown to decrease timing precision. Here we investigate the combined effect of regulation and feedback on timing precision. We develop a gradient- descent approach to find the globally optimal regulation function for a given network topology that minimizes the timing noise. We find that, despite the fact that feedback generically increases timing noise when it acts alone, feedback decreases timing noise when it acts in combination with regulation by an external species. We explain the mechanisms behind this counterintuitive re- sult, derive a generic lower bound on the timing noise, and discuss the relevance of our results to the timing of neuroblast migration in C. elegans. FIG. 1: Feedback increases timing precision in the presence but not absence of regulation. (A) A species Y crosses a molecule-number threshold y∗ at mean time t∗ with timing variance σ2 t . (B) Feedback increases the variance. However, in the presence of regulation by a second species X, feedback on either (C) Y or (D) X can decrease the variance. Parameters are Ky = 2.5 in B; α0t∗ = 10, Hx = −0.5, Hxy = −Hy, Kx = 15, Ky = 5, and Kxy = 6 in C; α0t∗ = 10, Hy = 4, Kx = 10, and Ky = 7.5 in D; and y∗ = 10 throughout. Consider a molecular species Y that is produced over time and first reaches a molecule-number threshold y∗ at a particular time t∗ on average (Fig. 1A). Stochastic- ity in the accumulation process leads to variability in the crossing time t. The timing noise is given by the variance σ2 t . For unregulated production of Y , the time between each production event is exponentially distributed with 9 1 0 2 t c O 1 1 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 3 1 4 5 0 . 0 1 9 1 : v i X r a 012051015-1010.511.50240.50.60.70.80.91-8-6-4-200.50.60.70.80.91ABCDYXHy<latexit sha1_base64="iurlgOJ3OkaVVILAwpRNzkWzs0c=">AAAB6nicbVBNS8NAEJ34WetX1aOXxSJ4KkkV9Fj00mNF+wFtKJvtpF262YTdjRBKf4IXD4p49Rd589+4bXPQ1gcDj/dmmJkXJIJr47rfztr6xubWdmGnuLu3f3BYOjpu6ThVDJssFrHqBFSj4BKbhhuBnUQhjQKB7WB8N/PbT6g0j+WjyRL0IzqUPOSMGis91PtZv1R2K+4cZJV4OSlDjka/9NUbxCyNUBomqNZdz02MP6HKcCZwWuylGhPKxnSIXUsljVD7k/mpU3JulQEJY2VLGjJXf09MaKR1FgW2M6JmpJe9mfif101NeONPuExSg5ItFoWpICYms7/JgCtkRmSWUKa4vZWwEVWUGZtO0YbgLb+8SlrVindZqd5flWu3eRwFOIUzuAAPrqEGdWhAExgM4Rle4c0Rzovz7nwsWtecfOYE/sD5/AEw/o28</latexit>XYHx<latexit sha1_base64="LpYWhs7E/rE/PxiN3jaT+6oN590=">AAAB6nicbVDLTgJBEOzFF+IL9ehlIjHxRHbRRI9ELxwxyiOBDZkdemHC7OxmZtZICJ/gxYPGePWLvPk3DrAHBSvppFLVne6uIBFcG9f9dnJr6xubW/ntws7u3v5B8fCoqeNUMWywWMSqHVCNgktsGG4EthOFNAoEtoLR7cxvPaLSPJYPZpygH9GB5CFn1FjpvtZ76hVLbtmdg6wSLyMlyFDvFb+6/ZilEUrDBNW647mJ8SdUGc4ETgvdVGNC2YgOsGOppBFqfzI/dUrOrNInYaxsSUPm6u+JCY20HkeB7YyoGeplbyb+53VSE177Ey6T1KBki0VhKoiJyexv0ucKmRFjSyhT3N5K2JAqyoxNp2BD8JZfXiXNStm7KFfuLkvVmyyOPJzAKZyDB1dQhRrUoQEMBvAMr/DmCOfFeXc+Fq05J5s5hj9wPn8AL3qNuw==</latexit>YHy<latexit sha1_base64="iurlgOJ3OkaVVILAwpRNzkWzs0c=">AAAB6nicbVBNS8NAEJ34WetX1aOXxSJ4KkkV9Fj00mNF+wFtKJvtpF262YTdjRBKf4IXD4p49Rd589+4bXPQ1gcDj/dmmJkXJIJr47rfztr6xubWdmGnuLu3f3BYOjpu6ThVDJssFrHqBFSj4BKbhhuBnUQhjQKB7WB8N/PbT6g0j+WjyRL0IzqUPOSMGis91PtZv1R2K+4cZJV4OSlDjka/9NUbxCyNUBomqNZdz02MP6HKcCZwWuylGhPKxnSIXUsljVD7k/mpU3JulQEJY2VLGjJXf09MaKR1FgW2M6JmpJe9mfif101NeONPuExSg5ItFoWpICYms7/JgCtkRmSWUKa4vZWwEVWUGZtO0YbgLb+8SlrVindZqd5flWu3eRwFOIUzuAAPrqEGdWhAExgM4Rle4c0Rzovz7nwsWtecfOYE/sD5/AEw/o28</latexit>mean t∗/y∗ and variance (t∗/y∗)2. Because the produc- tion events are independent, the variances add, giving a t = y∗(t∗/y∗)2 = t2∗/y∗. Therefore we total variance of σ2 t y∗/t2∗, whose value is 1 for focus on the scaled variance σ2 unregulated production. First we investigate the effect of feedback on timing precision using a simple example: we suppose that the production rate of Y is not a constant but rather is a sim- ple sigmoidal function of the current number of molecules y, β(y) = β0{1 + tanh[Hy(y/Ky − 1)]}, (1) where positive (negative) Hy corresponds to positive (negative) feedback, Hy is the maximum steepness, Ky is the molecule number at which β is half-maximal, and β0 is set to ensure that the average time at which y first reaches y∗ is t∗. We calculate the variance σ2 t from the master equation by matrix inversion [9]. In Fig. 1B we see that when there is no feedback (Hy = 0), the vari- t y∗/t2∗ = 1, and that either positive or ance satisfies σ2 negative feedback increases the variance. This result is consistent with previous findings for a species that does not degrade [10], and it has an intuitive explanation: a sequence of time-ordered stochastic events is most pre- cisely timed if the mean time for each event to occur is equal, but feedback makes these times unequal. Next we investigate the interplay of feedback and regu- lation by introducing a second species X that is produced at a constant rate α0. The Y production rate β(x, y) is now a function of both molecule numbers x and y. We find that if it is a simple sum β(x, y) = f1(x) + f2(y) or product β(x, y) = f1(x)f2(y) then feedback continues to generically increase the timing variance, but if we include a coupling term β(x, y) = f1(x)f2(y)f3(xy) the situation is different. Specifically, Fig. 1C shows the case where β(x, y) = β0{1 + tanh[Hx(x/Kx − 1)]} × {1 + tanh[Hy(y/Ky − 1)]} × {1 + tanh[Hxy(xy/K 2 xy − 1)]}. (2) We see that with no feedback (Hy = 0) we have t y∗/t2∗ < 1, which demonstrates that regulation by a σ2 second species increases the timing precision as found previously [9]. However, now we also see that with pos- itive feedback (Hy > 0), the variance can be even lower. Together with Fig. 1B, this result implies that although feedback increases timing noise in the absence of regu- lation, it can decrease timing noise in the presence of regulation. Similarly we investigate the case where the feedback occurs on X, not Y . We take the production rates of x and y to be α(x) = α0{1 + tanh[Hx(x/Kx − 1)]}, β(x) = β0{1 + tanh[Hy(x/Ky − 1)]}, (3) (4) 2 respectively. We see in Fig. 1D that with negative feed- back (Hx < 0) the variance is lower than with no feed- back (Hx = 0), again implying that feedback can reduce timing noise when coupled to regulation. To understand this effect, we develop a gradient- descent method to find the optimal regulation that min- imizes the timing variance. The regulation is specified by the X and Y production rates α(x, y) and β(x, y), respectively, which each depend on the molecule num- bers x and y in general, but whose dependencies will later be restricted to consider particular feedback topolo- gies. The probability of first reaching y = y∗ at time t is P (t) =(cid:80){(cid:126)s} P (t(cid:126)s)P ((cid:126)s), where S−1(cid:89) (cid:32)S−1(cid:89) i=0 ri ki , (cid:90) ∞ i=0 0 P ((cid:126)s) = P (t(cid:126)s) = (cid:33) δ t − S−1(cid:88) j=0  . tj (5) (6) −kiti dtikie In Eq. 5, P ((cid:126)s) is the probability of taking a path (cid:126)s from (x0, y0) = (0, 0) to (xS, yS) = (xS, y∗) for any non- negative xS, where S is the length of the path. Each step i takes the system out of state (xi, yi) with rate ki = α(xi, yi) + β(xi, yi) and into a new state with prob- ability ri/ki, where the new state is either (xi + 1, yi) with ri = α(xi, yi) or (xi, yi + 1) with ri = β(xi, yi). In Eq. 6, P (t(cid:126)s) is the probability that traversing the given path (cid:126)s takes a time t. The first term integrates over all values of each step's transition time ti, which is expo- nentially distributed with rate ki, and the second term ensures that the sum of these transition times is t. From P (t) we calculate the moments [14], of which the first two are (cid:88) (cid:88) {(cid:126)s} {(cid:126)s} , 1 ki S−1(cid:88) (cid:32)S−1(cid:88) i=0 i=0 P ((cid:126)s) P ((cid:126)s) (cid:104)t(cid:105) = (cid:104)t2(cid:105) = (cid:33) + S−1(cid:88) j=0 1 kj 2 . 1 k2 i (7) (8) The optimal regulation function minimizes (cid:104)t2(cid:105) at fixed (cid:104)t(cid:105) = t∗. Therefore, defining a vector (cid:126)γ whose compo- nents are all components of both the α(x, y) and β(x, y) matrices, we initialize (cid:126)γ to satisfy (cid:104)t(cid:105) = t∗ and update it as (cid:126)γ(n+1) = (cid:126)γ(n) − (cid:126)u. (9) Here (cid:28) 1, and (cid:126)u is such that (cid:126)u · ∇γ(cid:104)t2(cid:105) is maximized with respect to the constraints (cid:126)u·∇γ(cid:104)t(cid:105) = 0 and u2 = 1. First we apply this method to the case where X reg- ulates Y with no feedback. Thus, we fix α = α0 and optimize β(x). Figure 2A shows the result, and we see that the optimal β(x) is an increasing function of x (i.e., 3 in Fig. 1C. The first property ensures that Y is not pre- maturely activated at early times when x is small. The second property provides an additional acceleration of y at late times when x is large. Thus, X acts as a "timer" for Y , allowing Y to apply self-amplification only at late times. This has two advantages, as seen in Fig. 2D: (i) it increases the slope of ¯y at crossing, beyond that with- out feedback; and (ii) it allows the acceleration to begin at a ¯y value that is already close to y∗, thus reducing trajectory-to-trajectory variability caused by prolonged self-amplification [10]. Finally we consider the case where feedback acts on X instead of Y . Here, to provide a reasonable constraint on x(t), we introduce a bound x∗ and restrict α(x) such that ¯x(t) ≤ x∗ over the range 0 ≤ t ≤ t∗. The optimal regulation functions α(x) and β(x) are shown in Fig. 2E. We see that X represses itself and activates Y , and that both regulation functions have a sharp transition when x = x∗. We see in Fig. 2F that the resulting dynamics are sharply kinked. To understand the sharp nature of the optimal solution in Fig. 2E and F, we investigate our optimization scheme (Eqs. 5-9) analytically. The analytic version of Eq. 9 is 0 = γi∂γi ((cid:104)t2(cid:105) − λ(cid:104)t(cid:105)), where the Lagrange multiplier λ enforces (cid:104)t(cid:105) = t∗, and the factor of γi in front enforces γi > 0 [14]. By inserting Eqs. 7 and 8 into this condition, we show [14] that it is satisfied when (i) α and β are such that all possible paths (cid:126)s to reach y = y∗ have the same length S, and (ii) all transition rates along each of these paths are equal. Each such set of equal-length, constant-velocity paths is a local optimum, and the global optimum that minimizes the timing variance is the set for which (iii) the path length S is as large as possible. More generally, if only property (ii) is satisfied, we show [14] that the timing variance satisfies σ2 t t2∗ = σ2 S(cid:104)S(cid:105)2 + 1 (cid:104)S(cid:105) , (10) where (cid:104)S(cid:105) and σ2 S are the mean and variance of the path lengths, weighted by the path probabilities P ((cid:126)s). Clearly S = 0 and (cid:104)S(cid:105) is as large the variance is minimized when σ2 as possible, consistent with properties (i) and (iii) above, respectively. Now we can understand why the the optimal solution in Fig. 2E and F looks the way it does. The sharp nature of the regulation functions ensures that at early times only x changes, and at late times only y changes, con- fining the stochastic dynamics to only one possible path in (x, y) space [property (i)]. The values of α and β, when they are nonzero, are constant and equal to each other, ensuring that the velocity along this path is con- stant [property (ii)]. Finally, both x and y attain their maximal values x∗ and y∗, ensuring that the path is as long as possible [property (iii)]. Indeed, Fig. 3 shows the optimal solutions for all of the networks considered thus far in terms of these FIG. 2: Optimal regulation functions that minimize timing variance. (A) Without feedback, X activates Y , (B) allow- ing ¯y to accelerate before crossing y∗. (C) With feedback on Y , X acts as a "timer" for Y , allowing Y to self-repress at early times and self-activate at late times, and (D) providing further, late-phase acceleration of ¯y. (E) With feedback on X, it represses itself and activates Y sharply, (F) resulting in kinked dynamics where ¯x and ¯y growth are separated in time. Parameters are α0t∗ = 7 (A-D), x∗ = 7 (E, F), and y∗ = 10 throughout. X activates Y ). The reason, clear from the mean dynam- ics in 2B, is that as x increases over time, β(x) increases over time, which causes y to accelerate. The accelera- tion allows ¯y to cross y∗ with a large slope, reducing the uncertainty of the crossing time. We observed this ef- fect previously with Hill-function activation [9], but the optimal regulation function was unknown. Next we keep α = α0, but we allow feedback on Y and find the optimal β(x, y). Figure 2C shows the result, and we see that the optimal β(x, y) depends on y, confirming that feedback is beneficial in the presence of regulation. Specifically, we see that β(x, y) decreases with y (negative feedback) when x is small, and increases with y (positive feedback) when x is large. These two properties are also exhibited by Eq. 2 with Hx < 0, Hy > 0, and Hxy < 0 as ABDCEFXYYXXYYXXY4 (A) Ranking of timing variance for all one- and two- FIG. 4: node networks. Global minimum is σ2 t y∗/t2∗ = y∗/(x∗ + y∗). In red network, link 1, 2, or both is required. Parameters as in Fig. 2. (B) Mean dynamics and regulation function (inset) for case when X is degraded. Here α0t∗ = 3.5. ulated (cyan, orange), this corresponds to replacing its production propensity α0 (for x → x + 1) with a degra- dation propensity α0x (for x → x − 1). The resulting minimal values of the timing variance are shown by the open circles in Fig. 4A, and we see that they are lower than the corresponding values when X is produced over time (filled circles). The reason, illustrated for the case where X regulates Y in Fig. 4B, is that when X is pro- duced over time it increases linearly (Fig. 2B dashed), whereas when X is degraded over time it decreases expo- nentially (Fig. 4B dashed). The curvature of the expo- nential begins to approximate the kinked dynamics of the globally optimal solution (Fig. 2F dashed). Specifically, X is most dynamic at early times (Fig. 4B dashed), and Y is only produced once x drops below a particular value (Fig. 4B inset) allowing it to be most dynamic at late times (Fig. 4B solid). Thus, even without feedback, the nonlinear dynamics of a degraded regulator allow its tar- get to more closely approach the globally optimal timing precision. How can these results be tested in experimental sys- tems? Our findings suggest that a cellular process where timing precision is important should be governed by a molecular network with both multistep regulation and feedback, particularly one in which every species is sub- ject to regulation as in Fig. 4A (red). An experimen- tal example in which timing precision is particularly well studied is neuroblast migration in developing C. elegans larvae. Here, the QR neuroblast produces a protein called mig-1 that crosses an abundance threshold to ter- minate migration; overproduction causes undermigration and vice versa [5]. It was recently discovered in the sis- ter QL lineage that mig-1 is subject to both regulation and negative feedback via canonical Wnt signaling [13]. Specifically, mig-1 activates one or more Wnt signaling factors, which in turn repress mig-1. These interactions form a network of the red type in Fig. 4A (with link 2), where X is the Wnt factor and Y is mig-1, which is pre- cisely the class of networks that we predict achieve the FIG. 3: Properties that minimize timing variance: (A) large path length S, (B) constant velocity v(t) along path, and (C) small path length variance σ2 S. Parameters as in Fig. 2. three properties. Specifically, Fig. 3A shows the mean dynamics in (x, y) space; Fig. 3B shows the velocity v(t) = (cid:112)(d¯x/dt)2 + (d¯y/dt)2 along this path, normal- ized by its time average ¯v = t−1∗ (cid:82) t∗ 0 dt v(t); and Fig. 3C shows the variance σ2 S in the path length across all paths. With only Y and no X (blue), there is only one possible path (Fig. 3A), and therefore σ2 S = 0 (Fig. 3C). The op- timal solution has constant velocity along the path (Fig. 3B), which is achieved with no feedback. When X regu- lates Y (cyan, orange), the mean path extends into the (x, y) plane (Fig. 3A), which increases its length and thus lowers the timing variance. However, it also makes the velocity non-constant (Fig. 3B) and allows for many possible paths such that σ2 S > 0 (Fig. 3C). Only upon allowing X to also regulate itself (red) does the path become as long as possible (Fig. 3A), constant-velocity (Fig. 3B), and unique (Fig. 3C). The minimal values of the timing variance for the net- works are shown by the filled circles in Fig. 4A. We see t y∗/t2∗ = that the single species Y achieves the standard σ2 1 (blue), regulation by X lowers the variance (cyan), feed- back on Y lowers it further (orange), and regulation of X lowers it to the global minimum given by Eq. 10 with S = 0 and (cid:104)S(cid:105) = x∗+y∗, namely σ2 t y∗/t2∗ = y∗/(x∗+y∗). σ2 Because the results in Fig. 4A are minima, it does not matter in the last case whether the regulation of X is by X itself (red link 1), by Y (red link 2), or both; the optimal regulation functions will produce the red path in Fig. 3 regardless. Thus far we have only considered the scenario where X is produced over time. However, X could alternatively be degraded over time [9]. In the cases where X is unreg- 0123456780123456789101100.510.811.21.40246ABCYXYYXXYYXYYXXY00.51024681005010200.50.60.70.80.91YXYYXXY21ABXYglobally minimum timing noise. We anticipate that other biological processes where timing precision is paramount will be governed by interaction networks in this class. We have developed a gradient-descent approach that provides the optimal regulation functions for a given network topology that minimize the timing noise of a threshold-crossing event. The approach has revealed that feedback reduces timing noise in the presence but not ab- sence of regulation because the combination of the two increases the number of transitions that must happen sequentially in molecular state space. More generally, our work suggests a perspective where noise is not mini- mized by finding the right network topology, but rather by finding the right combination of regulation functions that produce a path through state space that is as long, steady, and unique as possible. Our approach is straight- forward to generalize to larger and more complex net- works, and we anticipate that this perspective applies broadly to biological processes where timing is crucial. This work was supported by Human Frontier Science Program grant RGP0030/2016 and Simons Foundation grant 376198. ∗ Electronic address: [email protected] 5 [1] J. M. Bean, E. D. Siggia, and F. R. Cross, Molecular cell 21, 3 (2006). [2] I. Nachman, A. Regev, and S. Ramanathan, Cell 131, 544 (2007). [3] B. L. Schneider, J. Zhang, J. Markwardt, G. Tokiwa, T. Volpe, S. Honey, and B. Futcher, Molecular and cel- lular biology 24, 10802 (2004). [4] K. Carniol, P. Eichenberger, and R. Losick, Journal of Biological Chemistry 279, 14860 (2004). [5] R. A. Mentink, T. C. Middelkoop, L. Rella, N. Ji, C. Y. Tang, M. C. Betist, A. van Oudenaarden, and H. C. Ko- rswagen, Developmental cell 31, 188 (2014). [6] H. Meinhardt, Models of biological pattern formation (Academic Press Inc, 1982). [7] D. E. Tufcea and P. Fran¸cois, Biophysical journal 109, 1724 (2015). [8] J. Roux, M. Hafner, S. Bandara, J. J. Sims, H. Hudson, D. Chai, and P. K. Sorger, Molecular systems biology 11, 803 (2015). [9] S. Gupta, J. Varennes, H. C. Korswagen, and A. Mugler, PLoS computational biology 14, e1006201 (2018). [10] K. R. Ghusinga, J. J. Dennehy, and A. Singh, Pro- ceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 114, 693 (2017). [11] L. Dirick and K. Nasmyth, Nature 351, 754 (1991). [12] F. R. Cross and A. H. Tinkelenberg, Cell 65, 875 (1991). [13] N. Ji, T. C. Middelkoop, R. A. Mentink, M. C. Betist, S. Tonegawa, D. Mooijman, H. C. Korswagen, and A. van Oudenaarden, Cell 155, 869 (2013). [14] See Supplementary Material. SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL Calculation of the moments of the first passage time Using Eqs. 5 and 6 of the main text, we write the first passage time distribution as {(cid:126)s} (cid:88) (cid:88) (cid:88) {(cid:126)s} P ((cid:126)s)P (t(cid:126)s) (cid:32)S−1(cid:89) (cid:32)S−1(cid:89) i=0 (cid:33)S−1(cid:89) (cid:90) ∞ ri ki j=0 dtirie (cid:90) ∞ 0 −kj tj  δ t − S−1(cid:88) tj (cid:33) t(cid:96) (cid:32) t − S−1(cid:88)  . (cid:96)=0 dtjkje (cid:33) −kiti δ j=0 {(cid:126)s} i=0 0 0 dt tnP (t) (cid:90) ∞ (cid:32)S−1(cid:89) (cid:90) ∞ dt tn(cid:88) (cid:32)S−1(cid:89) (cid:90) ∞ (cid:88) {(cid:126)s} i=0 0 {(cid:126)s} i=0 0 (cid:90) ∞ 0 −kiti dtirie (cid:33) n δ t − S−1(cid:88) j=0  tj . −kiti dtirie (cid:33)S−1(cid:88) j=0 tj The nth moment is P (t) = = = (cid:104)tn(cid:105) = = = (11) (12) Specifically, the first and second moments are (cid:33)S−1(cid:88) j=0  tj −kiti dtirie i=0 (cid:32)S−1(cid:89) (cid:90) ∞ (cid:33) S−1(cid:88) (cid:32)S−1(cid:89) S−1(cid:88) ri ki j=0 i=0 0 P ((cid:126)s) 1 kj j=0 {(cid:126)s} (cid:88) (cid:88) (cid:88) {(cid:126)s} {(cid:126)s} 1 kj (cid:104)t(cid:105) = = = and (cid:10)t2(cid:11) = = = = = {(cid:126)s} {(cid:126)s} (cid:88) (cid:88) (cid:88) (cid:88) (cid:88) {(cid:126)s} {(cid:126)s} {(cid:126)s} −kiti −kiti 0 0 i=0 i=0 dtirie dtirie (cid:32)S−1(cid:89) (cid:32)S−1(cid:89) (cid:32)S−1(cid:89) (cid:32)S−1(cid:89)  (cid:90) ∞ (cid:90) ∞ (cid:33) S−1(cid:88) S−1(cid:88) (cid:33) S−1(cid:88) S−1(cid:88)  + P ((cid:126)s) ri ki ri ki j=0 j=0 i=0 i=0 (cid:96)=j 1 k2 j 1 k2 j j=0 tj j=0 j=0 j=0 t2 j + (cid:33)S−1(cid:88) 2 (cid:33)S−1(cid:88) S−2(cid:88) S−1(cid:88) 2 ,  + S−1(cid:88) 2 , S−1(cid:88) 1 kj j=0 1 kj j=0 2 kjk(cid:96) (cid:96)=j+1 6 (13) (14)  2tjt(cid:96) as in Eqs. 7 and 8 of the main text, where the last line in each case recalls Eq. 5 from the main text. Analytic minimization of timing variance using Lagrange multipliers To find the minimum variance when the mean is fixed to be t∗, we utilize Lagrange multipliers. Because the variance is a function of only the first and second moments and is monotonically increasing with the second moment, finding the minimum of the variance with a fixed mean is equivalent to finding the minimum of the second moment with a fixed mean. Thus, the set of r(cid:96) values which produces the minimum variance is the set which solves (cid:0)(cid:10)t2(cid:11) − λ(cid:104)t(cid:105)(cid:1) 0 = ∂ ∂r(cid:96) (15) (16) However, Eq. 15 raises an issue. Assume that x∗ = y∗ = 1. for Lagrange multiplier λ. In this case, there are only three possible rates αxy and βxy, namely α00, β00, and β10. There are also only two possible paths: (cid:126)s1 = [{0, 0} ,{0, 1}] and (cid:126)s2 = [{0, 0} ,{1, 0} ,{1, 1}]. Putting these rates and paths into Eqs. 13 and 14 yields (cid:104)t(cid:105) = β00 α00 + β00 = 1 α00 + β00 1 (cid:18) α00 + β00 α00 β10 1 + α00 α00 + β00 β10 β10 + (cid:19) (cid:18) 1 α00 + β00 + 1 β10 (cid:19) and (cid:10)t2(cid:11) = = β00 α00 + β00 2 (α00 + β00)2 2 (cid:18) (α00 + β00)2 + 1 + α00 β10 + (cid:32) (cid:19) (α00 + β00)2 + 2 α00 α00 + β00 β10 β10 α00 (α00 + β00) . β2 10 (cid:33) 2 (α00 + β00) β10 + 2 β2 10 7 (17) By putting Eqs. 16 and 17 into Eq. 15 and solving the resulting system of equations, one obtains that some rates must be negative or even undefined depending on the order in which they are solved. Since negative rates are unphysical, we can enforce positivity by making the substitutions αxy = exp (axy) /t∗ and βxy = exp (bxy) /t∗ and finding the minimum variance in (axy, bxy) space rather than (αxy, βxy) space. This procedure can be done without ever leaving (αxy, βxy) space by noting that ∂/∂a = (∂α/∂a) ∂/∂α = α (∂/∂α) and similarly that ∂/∂b = β (∂/∂β). This allows Eq. 15 to be rewritten as (cid:0)(cid:10)t2(cid:11) − λ(cid:104)t(cid:105)(cid:1) . 0 = r(cid:96) ∂ ∂r(cid:96) (18) (19) Putting Eqs. 16 and 17 into Eq. 18 yields two possible solutions to the resulting equations: [β00, α00, β10] = [1/t∗, 0, β10] with σ2 = t2∗ for any value of β10 or [β00, α00, β10] = [0, 2/t∗, 2/t∗] with σ2 = t2∗/2. Of important note is the fact that when α00 = 0 only the (cid:126)s1 path is available, while when β00 = 0 only the (cid:126)s2 path is available. Thus, the variance is seen to be extremized when only one possible path is available and all rates along that path are equal. Additionally, the longer path yields a smaller variance. This can be seen to be a simple case of a larger trend. For any possible values of x∗ and y∗ it is possible to choose a set of reaction rates such that there is only one possible path through (x, y) space. When this is done, the product terms in Eqs. 13 and 14 becomes identically 1 since ri = ki must be true along the one possible path. All other paths will have ri = 0 for some i and will thus not contribute. This allows Eq. 18 to be easily calculated for any r(cid:96) that is in the single possible path, (cid:32)S−1(cid:88) i=0 (cid:32)S−1(cid:88) (cid:33) i=0 (cid:33) (cid:32)S−1(cid:88) 1 r2 i i=0 + 1 ri 0 = r(cid:96) ∂ ∂r(cid:96) = λ r(cid:96) − 2 r2 (cid:96) − 2 r(cid:96) (cid:33)2 − λ 1 ri (cid:33) (cid:32)S−1(cid:88) i=0 1 ri Eq. 19 is true for all r(cid:96) along the single path if and only if all r(cid:96) along that path have the same value, which, from the restriction that the mean first passage time must be t∗ and Eq. 13, means r(cid:96) = S/t∗. Putting these values back into Eq. 14 then allows the variance to be simply calculated to be σ2 = t∗2/S. Eq. 18 must hold for all off-path reactions as well. This can be seen to be true by noting that for all other paths at least one ri must be 0 in the product term. If (cid:96) (cid:54)= i this fact is not changed and that path will still have 0 contribution. If (cid:96) = i then the r(cid:96) in front of the derivative operator will still force that path to have 0 contribution since no ki can be 0. Similarly, if r(cid:96) is not a reaction that occurs at any state along the one possible path then the derivative will cause it to vanish since the contribution from the one possible path does not depend on rates that exist in other states, while if r(cid:96) is a 0 rate that exists at a state in the one possible path then the factor of r(cid:96) in front of the derivative will cause the whole expression to vanish. Thus, choosing a set of reaction rates such that there is a single possible path and all rates along that path are equal is a solution to Eq. 18 for all r(cid:96). Additionally, since σ2 = t∗2/S, the longer that path is the smaller the variance will be. We state this result more generally by establishing three rules which state that the variance in first passage time is minimized when: 1. Variability in the possible path taken is minimized 2. Rate at which the system moves through state space is as constant as possible 3. The path length through state space is maximized Derivation of the lower bound on timing variance If all rates are the same, ki = k, then Eqs. 13 and 14 become (cid:104)t(cid:105) = P ((cid:126)s) (cid:104)S(cid:105) k S k = and We then have σ2 t(cid:104)t(cid:105)2 = as in Eq. 10 of the main text. (cid:88) (cid:10)t2(cid:11) = (cid:10)t2(cid:11) − (cid:104)t(cid:105)2 {(cid:126)s} (cid:104)t(cid:105)2 P ((cid:126)s) k2 + = k2 (cid:104)S(cid:105)2 k2 + {(cid:126)s} (cid:88) (cid:18) S (cid:32)(cid:104)S(cid:105) (cid:19) = S2 k2 (cid:104)S(cid:105) k2 + (cid:10)S2(cid:11) k2 − (cid:104)S(cid:105)2 k2 (cid:10)S2(cid:11) (cid:33) k2 . = 1 (cid:104)S(cid:105) + 8 (20) (21) (22) σ2 S(cid:104)S(cid:105)2 ,
1810.05848	1	1810	2018-10-13T12:00:24	Traction force microscopy with optimized regularization and automated Bayesian parameter selection for comparing cells	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.CB", "q-bio.QM" ]	Adherent cells exert traction forces on to their environment, which allows them to migrate, to maintain tissue integrity, and to form complex multicellular structures. This traction can be measured in a perturbation-free manner with traction force microscopy (TFM). In TFM, traction is usually calculated via the solution of a linear system, which is complicated by undersampled input data, acquisition noise, and large condition numbers for some methods. Therefore, standard TFM algorithms either employ data filtering or regularization. However, these approaches require a manual selection of filter- or regularization parameters and consequently exhibit a substantial degree of subjectiveness. This shortcoming is particularly serious when cells in different conditions are to be compared because optimal noise suppression needs to be adapted for every situation, which invariably results in systematic errors. Here, we systematically test the performance of new methods from computer vision and Bayesian inference for solving the inverse problem in TFM. We compare two classical schemes, L1- and L2-regularization, with three previously untested schemes, namely Elastic Net regularization, Proximal Gradient Lasso, and Proximal Gradient Elastic Net. Overall, we find that Elastic Net regularization, which combines L1 and L2 regularization, outperforms all other methods with regard to accuracy of traction reconstruction. Next, we develop two methods, Bayesian L2 regularization and Advanced Bayesian L2 regularization, for automatic, optimal L2 regularization. Using artificial data and experimental data, we show that these methods enable robust reconstruction of traction without requiring a difficult selection of regularization parameters specifically for each data set. Thus, Bayesian methods can mitigate the considerable uncertainty inherent in comparing cellular traction forces.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Traction force microscopy with optimized regularization and automated Bayesian parameter selection for comparing cells Yunfei Huang1, Christoph Schell2, Tobias B. Huber4,5,6, Ahmet Nihat S¸ ims¸ek1, Nils Hersch3, Rudolf Merkel3, Gerhard Gompper1, and Benedikt Sabass1,* 1Theoretical Soft Matter and Biophysics, Institute of Complex Systems-2 and Institute for Advanced Simulation, Forschungszentrum Juelich, D-52425, Juelich, Germany 2Institut fur Klinische Pathologie, Universitatsklinikum Freiburg, D-79002, Freiburg, Germany 3Biomechanics, Institute of Complex Systems-7, Forschungszentrum Juelich, D-52425, Juelich, Germany 4Department of Medicine IV, Faculty of Medicine, Medical Center -- University of Freiburg, Germany 5BIOSS Center for Biological Signalling Studies, Albert-Ludwigs-University Freiburg, Germany 6III. Department of Medicine, University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany [email protected] ABSTRACT Adherent cells exert traction forces on to their environment, which allows them to migrate, to maintain tissue integrity, and to form complex multicellular structures during developmental morphogenesis. Traction force microscopy (TFM) enables the measurement of traction forces on an elastic substrate and thereby provides quantitative information on cellular mechanics in a perturbation-free fashion. In TFM, traction is usually calculated via the solution of a linear system, which is complicated by undersampled input data, acquisition noise, and large condition numbers for some methods. Therefore, standard TFM algorithms either employ data filtering or regularization. However, these approaches require a manual selection of filter- or regularization parameters and consequently exhibit a substantial degree of subjectiveness. This shortcoming is particularly serious when cells in different conditions are to be compared because optimal noise suppression needs to be adapted for every situation, which invariably results in systematic errors. Here, we systematically test the performance of new methods from computer vision and Bayesian inference for solving the inverse problem in TFM. We compare two classical schemes, L1- and L2-regularization, with three previously untested schemes, namely Elastic Net regularization, Proximal Gradient Lasso, and Proximal Gradient Elastic Net. Overall, we find that Elastic Net regularization, which combines L1 and L2 regularization, outperforms all other methods with regard to accuracy of traction reconstruction. Next, we develop two methods, Bayesian L2 regularization and Advanced Bayesian L2 regularization, for automatic, optimal L2 regularization. Using artificial data and experimental data, we show that these methods enable robust reconstruction of traction without requiring a difficult selection of regularization parameters specifically for each data set. Thus, Bayesian methods can mitigate the considerable uncertainty inherent in comparing cellular tractions in different conditions. Introduction Mechanical forces between cells and their embedding matrix are essential for a variety of biological processes, ranging from migration of cells -- including immune cells and cancer cells -- to tissue maintenance and organ development, see1 -- 7 for only a few of the many review articles on this topic. Many of the relevant processes occur on a micrometer, or sub-micrometer lengthscale, for instance in nascent cell adhesion sites, filopodia, and bacterial adhesion. To understand these processes' mechanics and its biological control, reliable and accurate methods for measurement of cellular forces are required. Traction force microscopy (TFM) is a versatile and perturbation-free method yielding a spatial image of substrate stress exerted by cells on relatively soft elastic gel substrates. This method has its origins in pioneering work by Harris et al.8, who employed flexible silicone substrates to investigate the mechanical forces that cells generate. Today, traction force microscopy has become a method that is routinely used in laboratories studying cell biology and soft matter physics around the world.9 -- 14 Traction force microscopy includes three distinct procedures, illustrated in Fig. 1(a): (1) Cells are plated on an elastic substrate containing fiducial markers allowing to quantify gel deformation visually, for instance fluorescent beads or quantum dots.15, 16 The deformations caused by adherent cells are recorded by taking images of the gel before and after removing the cell. (2) A discrete gel displacement field u is calculated by tracking the markers. The most common techniques for tracking are particle tracking velocimetry (PTV) and particle image velocimetry (PIV). (3) Finally, the traction force field f is calculated from the displacement field u by making use of a mechanical model of the elastic substrate. A variety of methods exist for this purpose, including finite element methods,17 -- 21 boundary element methods15, 22, 23 and methods operating in Fourier space11, 21, 23 -- 25. Usually, calculation of traction from displacement requires either filtering or regularization approaches to reduce the effect of noise. The TFM methodology is limited by two common serious issues that introduce systematic errors. First, the resolution of the measured traction is usually not high enough to resolve processes at micrometer-sized cellular structures. Secondly, the most commonly used TFM algorithms require the user to choose a filter or a regularization parameter, which introduces a considerable degree of subjectivity regarding smoothness and magnitude of the resulting traction. In this article, we suggest methods for improving the state-of-the art with respect to these issues. In the standard TFM approach it is assumed that the substrate is a homogeneous, isotropic, and linear elastic half-space. The mechanical model relating a continuous displacement field Ui(x) to the traction force field Fj(x(cid:48)) on a two-dimensional (x = (x1,x2)) surface of the gel is expressed as the integral equation26 (cid:90) Ui(x) = Gi j(x− x(cid:48))Fj(x(cid:48))d2x(cid:48), (1) 2 ∑ j=1 Ω where Ω denotes the whole surface of the substrate. The integrand contains a Green's function Gi j(x) = (1 + ν)/(πE)[(1− ν)δi j/r + νxix j/r3], and E and ν represent the Young modulus and Poisson ratio, respectively. We also write r = x and δi j is the Kronecker delta function. Calculation of the traction Fj requires inversion of Eq. (1). A very popular and practical approach is to solve Eq. (1) in Fourier space.23, 24, 27 With this approach, the inversion is often directly feasible if noise in the displacement data has been filtered prior to calculation of the traction. Optimal filtering, however, requires input of a prior-defined filter function that imposes a smoothness constraint on the calculated traction. Moreover, spatial clustering of traction into sparse regions is not conserved when switching from real space to Fourier space. To take advantage of the sparsity of traction patterns for better reconstruction, one can solve Eq. (1) in real space. Here, the integral in Eq. (1) can be converted into a matrix product by discretizing the traction field Fj and interpolating it as a piecewise linear, continuous function using pyramidal shape functions h(x).23, 28 We write the two-dimensional, discrete displacement field as a 2m× 1 vector u, where m is the number of discretization nodes. The discrete traction field f is a 2n× 1 vector, where n is the number of nodes at which traction is prescribed. Then, Eq. (1) becomes u = Mf + s, (2) where we also explicitly included the linear acquisition noise s that is present the experimental data. The matrix M represents the coefficients of a discretized integration. It can be calculated with different techniques. The required convolution of the Green's function with the shape functions h(x) can be done by numerical integration.23 However, the computational effort can be significantly reduced by using the convolution theorem in Fourier space on regular grids.28 In the supplementary S1, we show how this method for fast calculation of M can be extended to irregularly spaced measurements with the help of the shift theorem. Regardless of the way how M is calculated, the condition number of M is typically very large. This means that even the smallest noise s leads to very large errors if a direct inversion of Eq. (2) is attempted. A further characteristic of TFM is that the experimental data is always undersampled, which introduces a large degree of uncertainty. The challenge in traction force microscopy is to turn Eq. (2) into a well-posed problem, while providing a traction field f with correct magnitude at high spatial resolution. The standard approaches employed in TFM are L1 or L2 regularization that penalize norms of the solution to render traction calculation a well-defined numerical problem. However, linear problems involving large, ill-conditioned matrices occur commonly throughout engineering and physics. Consequently, a variety of solution methods exist that not yet been employed in the context of TFM. For example, the elastic net regularization. Literally, the elastic net regularization behaves like a stretchable fishing net that retains "all the big fish" while removing the small background signal.29 An alternative are proximal gradient methods, which usually operate in wavelet space and employ adaptive or non-adaptive thresholding of high spatial frequencies.30, 31 Proximal gradient methods are for instance used for reconstructing lost parts of an image,32 -- 34 for analysis of MRI data,35 and for analysis of genomic data.36, 37 All regularization methods have the weakness that they require selection of one or more constant regularization parameters to allow discrimination of noise and signal. Bayesian statistics provides one solution to this problem. From the Bayesian point of view, regularization parameters can be seen of as random variables that are picked for every experimental sample from a prior distribution. Thus, one infers the most probable value of the regularization parameters in a conceptually similar way as one infers the solution.38 Such methods do not require the choice of a regularization parameter and are therefore potentially less prone to subjectiveness than the classical regularization. The conceptual framework of employing hierarchical priors for data regularization has been exploited for a large number of different applications, for instance in astrophysics,39 -- 41, machine learning42, mechanical structure monitoring43, face recognition44, and radar imagery45. Therefore, it is to be expected that Bayesian analysis can be of great use for traction force reconstruction. 2/20 In this work, we systematically compare a range of different approaches for solving Eq. (2). Altogether, we study the performance of seven methods, illustrated as a schematic diagram in Fig. 1(b). First, we test various regularization methods. Among the regularization methods, we complement the classical TFM approaches, L1- and L2 regularization, with previously untested methods from computer vision, namely Elastic Net (EN) regularization, Proximal Gradient Lasso (PGL), and Proximal Gradient Elastic Net (PGEN). We find that the new EN regularization scheme has a substantially improved accuracy as compared to previous approaches but requires considerable extra computational cost. Secondly, we seek to establish Bayesian models that can automatically perform an optimal regularization of the data. Initial tests indicate that different freely available Bayesian hierarchical models are of little use for TFM, since the large number of hidden variables, even when used with sparsity priors, does not enforce sufficient data faithfulness. Instead, we find that the simplest-possible Bayesian models with global priors yields robust results that can be interpreted as optimal L2 regularization. We study two variants of this algorithm: Bayesian L2 regularization (BL2), where the magnitude of the noise in the displacement data must be measured separately, and Advanced Bayesian L2 regularization (ABL2), which requires no extra input. We test the Bayesian methods using artificial data and real experimental data. Our results suggest that BL2 is not only very robust, but also superior to classical L2 regularization when measurement noise is large. Most importantly, BL2 automatically determines the degree of regularization, which removes subjectiveness from the result. This advance is particularly relevant for in-detail comparison of cells in different conditions, where the varying signal-to-noise ratio previously made an unambiguous comparison challenging. Methods Regularization A common heuristic approach to solve Eq. (2) is regularization of the solution through additional constraints. Here, not only the residual of (u− Mf) is minimized in a least-squares sense, but also the magnitude of the solution is penalized through its p-norm denoted by (cid:107)f(cid:107)p. The trade-off between minimization of the residual and minimization of the solution norm is determined by fixed regularization parameters, λ1 and λ2, leading to a minimization problem of the type (3) (cid:2)(cid:107)Mf− u(cid:107)2 2 + λ1(cid:107)R1f(cid:107)1 + λ2(cid:107)R2f(cid:107)2 2 (cid:3). f = argmin f The two norms are explicitly written as x(cid:107)1 = ∑k xk and x(cid:107)2 as the unit matrix I. Of the large number of existing regularization strategies, we will focus on the following: k. R1 and R2 are functions that are to be defined, e.g., 2 = ∑k x2 • L2 regularization, employing an L2-norm with λ2 > 0 and λ1 = 0 to penalize traction magnitude through R2 = I is currently the most common technique used for TFM.23, 46, 47 L2 regularization is also known as ridge regression or Tikhonov regularization48 and this method efficiently produces a continuous and smooth reconstructed traction field. This approach conveys a high level of robustness for the inversion problem in real space and also in Fourier space. See supplementary information for our implementation in real space.49 • L1 regularization, also called Lasso,50 is realized through setting λ2 = 0, λ1 > 0, and R1 = I. With L1 regularization, small values of the reconstructed signal are efficiently set to zero. L1 regularization is therefore frequently used in the the field of compressive sensing (CS),51 where the underlying assumption is that the signal can be represented in a sparse form where all but a few components of the signal vanish. Recently, the technique has found use for TFM28, 52 -- 54 and it is appropriate for traction fields containing few, sparsely located traction hotspots. In this case, it has been found that L1 regularization improves the ability to distinguish different traction hotspots. • The elastic net regularization combines L1- and L2 regularization and both parameters through λ1 > 0, λ2 > 0, and R1 = R2 = I in Eq. (3). Note that the actual implementation also involves a rescaling of the variables as suggested in Ref.29. This regularization scheme is known to have a better accuracy compared to L1 and L2 regularization if the coefficient matrix has many, correlated entries.29 EN regularization is well established for a wide variety of applications, most notably the analysis of genetic data,36, 55 -- 57 but has to date not been used for TFM. For our implementation of the EN we employ the popular convex optimization solver CVX, see supplementary information.58, 59 • Proximal gradient methods are an alternative approach to the optimization problems arising from the non-differentiable target functions in L1 regularization (PGL) and the EN regularization (PGEN).30, 60 Here, the penalty terms are chosen to be wavelet-transforms written as R1f = 2∑l(cid:104)f,Ψl(cid:105) and R2f = ∑l(cid:104)f,Ψl(cid:105), where the Ψl constitute an orthonormal Wavelet basis.61, 62 The optimization problem is solved through iterative soft thresholding, where the regularization parameters control the threshold below which the wavelet-coefficients are set to zero. Proximal gradient methods are widely applied for image inpainting, which is the process of reconstructing lost or deteriorated parts of images.32, 34, 63 -- 65 Therefore, these methods may be useful for TFM where traction images are reconstructed from undersampled displacement data. Details regarding our implementation of is given in the supplementary information. 3/20 These schemes have in common that they require the choice of one or two regularization parameters. Selecting the optimal regularization parameters is often a non-trivial problem. For L2- and L1-regularization, one can use the so-called L-curve criterion49 to find regularization parameters that provide a tradeoff between minimization of residual from the inverse problem and the regularization penalty.21, 23, 28, 46, 47, 66 Usually, the regularization parameter is assumed to be located at the inflection point of a curve described by the norm of the residual versus the norm of the solution in double-logarithmic axes. However, the L-curve criterion is of limited use for real data, since the inflection point does not always exist. Alternatively, multiple inflection points can appear, and the points are hard to localize precisely on the employed logarithmic scales. Moreover, the L-curve criterion does not behave consistently in the asymptotic limit of large system sizes or when the data is strongly corrupted by noise.67, 68 Hence, in practice, regularization parameters are often chosen by visual inspection of the resulting traction field. This procedure lacks objectivity and significantly biases any conclusions drawn from later analysis of the traction forces. Note that this problem is not specific to regularization, but the issue of distinguishing between noise and "real" signal appears generally with any type of method if the data is processed in any way to reduce noise. Bayesian approaches for traction reconstruction The discrete inverse problem u = Mf + s is of two-fold statistical nature. First, the traction varies from cell to cell and from image to image. Thus, f is a sample drawn from a distribution of possible traction values, which we denote by p(fα) with an undetermined parameter α. The function p(fα) describes any prior knowledge about the distribution of traction. For reasons that will become clear below, we will assume that the prior distribution for the 2n× 1 vector f is a Gaussian p(fα) = exp[−αEf(f)] Zf , (4) where Zf = (2π/α)n and Ef = fTf/2. The second source of randomness is the acquisition noise s. Typically, s is assumed to be drawn from a zero-mean Gaussian with unknown variance 1/β .38, 39, 41, 69 In the language of Bayesian statistics, the probability distribution p(uf,β ) is called the likelihood function and determines the probability to to measure a particular vector u given a traction vector f. Since the noise is Gaussian, the likelihood function is p(uf,β ) = exp[−β Eu(uf)] Zu , (5) where Eu(uf) = (Mf− u)T(Mf− u)/2 and Zu = (2π/β )m. m is, as above, the number of two-dimensional displacements. The likelihood function p(uf,β ) describes a situation that is exactly the reverse of the experimental situation, where we are looking for the probability of having f given measurements u. This situation is described by the posterior distribution p(fu) and can be related to the likelihood via Bayes' rule P(fu,α,β ) = p(uf,β )p(fα) p(uα,β ) = exp[−β Eu(uf)] Zu p(fα) p(uα,β ) . (6) 2 + α(cid:107)f(cid:107)2 2 (cid:2)β(cid:107)Mf− u(cid:107)2 Here, the marginal likelihood p(uα,β ) is the overall probability of finding the displacements u when the traction distributions are integrated out. Thus, p(uα,β ) is also called evidence for the model with {α,β ,u}. Assuming that α and β are known constants, one can maximize the posterior probability P(fu,α,β ) with respect to f. (cid:3), which is exactly the formula employed for L2 The resulting solution then satisfies fMP = argminf regularization, Eq. (3), if the parameters α and β are related to the L2 regularization parameter as λ = α/β .70 Thus, our choice of a Gaussian prior is justified if we intend to perform an L2 regularization. Other popular choices for replacing Eq. (5) as prior are the Laplace distribution p(fθ ) = (θ /2)exp(−θ /2(cid:107)f(cid:107)1),71 and a product of a Gaussian and a Laplace distribution.72 Using these priors, we would have found the formulas corresponding to L1 regularization and EN regularization, respectively. Thus, regularization is equivalent to maximizing the posterior probability of a measurement assuming fixed, known parameters of the prior distributions. However, α and β can also be treated as variables whose values can be determined by maximizing their probability p(α,βu) = p(uα,β )p(α,β )/p(u) ∼ p(uα,β ), where we assume a uniform prior p(α,β ) and we can omit the marginal probability since it plays no role for the optimization. To calculate the evidence p(uα,β ), we need to integrate out f in the posterior given in Eq. (6). Due to the Gaussian probabilities, this integration can be done conveniently by expanding the integrand around the most probable value fMP. On defining K(f) ≡ αEf(f) + β Eu(f) and its Hessian, A ≡ ∇∇K(f), we expand as K(f) ≈ K(fMP) + (f− fMP)T A(f− fMP)/2. Thus, the evidence becomes (cid:90) p(uα,β ) = p(uf,β )p(fα)d2nf = 1 ZuZf f (cid:90) f exp[−K(f)]d2nf = (2π)n(detA)−1/2 ZuZf exp[−K(fMP)]. (7) 4/20 Taking the logarithm yields the final result log p(uα,β ) = −αEf(fMP)− β Eu(fMP)− 1 2 log(detA) + nlogα + mlogβ − mlog(2π). (8) The right hand side of this equation is a typical example for target functions employed in Bayesian analysis, for example in the context of data fitting.38 For TFM, numerical calculation of log(detA) requires some care. We employ here a Cholesky decomposition of the positive matrix A = LLT yielding log(detA) = log(det(LLT)) = 2logΠiLii = 2Σi log(Lii). The logarithmic evidence, Eq. (8), assumes a maximum at those parameters α and β that are most likely associated f = 2n − αTrA−1 and with the measurement u. The implicit equations resulting from maximizing Eq. (8) read38 2 αEMP 2 β Eu = 2m− 2n + αTrA−1. Since fMP and A depend on α and β , these equations need to be solved numerically. Once α and β are determined, the equivalent optimal L2 regularization parameter follows as λ = α/ β . We employ two approaches for determining the numerical values of α and β . In the first approach, called Bayesian L2 regularization (BL2), we estimate the inverse noise variance β directly from the data calculating the variance of the measured displacements in spatial regions that are very far away from any cell. Thus, in BL2 only α is determined through maximization of Eq. (8). In the second approach, termed advanced Bayesian L2 regularization (ABL2), we solve directly for α and β , which result in an increased computational cost. For both approaches, it is imperative to standardize the data to adjust its spread in different dimensions. For a displacement vector u of length 2m, we first subtract the mean u = u− 12m ¯u with ¯u = ∑2m i=1 Mi j i=1(Mi j − ¯Mj)2/(2m− 1))1/2. Thus, we can define a problem matrix where each column is normalized by its and ω j = (∑2m spread Mi j = (Mi j − ¯Mj)/ω j. The standardized problem therefore reads ui = Mi j f j, which yields fi = fi/ωi. i=1 ui/(2m). Next, we calculate the mean and standard deviation for all columns of the matrix M as ¯Mj = 1/(2m)∑2m Generation of artificial test data To quantitatively compare the performance of different reconstruction methods, we require artificial data with exactly known traction force and displacements. The process of generating this data is shown in Fig. 2(a,i)-(a,iv) and involves prescribing traction force magnitude and direction in distributed circular areas, analytical calculation of the resulting displacements,23 sampling displacements at discrete positions and addition of noise, and finally the reverse traction reconstruction. Supplementary S5 provides further details on the involved analytical calculations. Throughout the article, artificial test data is generated for gel substrates with a Young modulus of E = 10 kPa and a Poisson ratio of ν = 0.3. The size of the image plane is arbitrary, but fixed to 25 µm × 25 µ m and involves 9 or 15 circular traction spots. For these fixed geometries we vary the traction magnitude, density of displacements, and the noise level. Evaluation metrics for assessing the quality of traction reconstruction To evaluate the quality of the reconstructed traction, we introduce four different error measures comparing reconstructed traction and known original traction. For this purpose, traction at every grid node is written as a two-dimensional vector t = {tx,ty}. Real traction and reconstructed traction are discriminated by superscripts as treal and trecon. The error measures are calculated by discriminating traction inside and outside of Ni circular traction patches in a test sample. • The Deviation of Traction Magnitude at Adhesions (DTMA)23 is defined as mean j DTMA = 1 Ni ∑ i (cid:17) (cid:16)(cid:107)trecon (cid:16)(cid:107)treal (cid:17) j,i (cid:107)2 −(cid:107)treal j,i (cid:107)2 j,i (cid:107)2 mean j , (9) where Ni is the number of circular traction patches and the index i runs over all patches. The index j runs over all traction vectors in one patch. A DTMA of 0 represents a perfect average traction recovery and a negative or positive value implies underestimation or overestimation, respectively. • The Deviation of Traction Magnitude in the Background (DTMB) is the normalized difference between the reconstructed and real traction magnitude outside the circular patches DTMB = meank (cid:0)(cid:107)trecon k (cid:1) (cid:17) , k (cid:107)2 (cid:107)2 −(cid:107)treal j,i (cid:107)2 (cid:16)(cid:107)treal 1 Ni ∑i mean j (10) where the index k runs over all traction vectors outside the patches. A DTMB with a magnitude much smaller than unity implies low background noise in the reconstructed traction. 5/20 • The Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR) for TFM SNR = 1 Ni ∑i mean j((cid:107)trecon j,i (cid:107)2) ) stdk(trecon k . (11) measures the detectability of a real signal within a noisy background.73 As before, the index k runs over all traction vectors outside the patches while j is the index of each traction vector in the patch i. The value of the SNR runs from 0 to infinity where a SNR that is much larger than unity indicates a good separation between traction and noise. • The Deviation of the traction Maximum at Adhesions (DMA) measures how peak-values of the traction over- or (cid:105) underestimate the true value. The quantity is defined as j,i (cid:107)2) max j((cid:107)trecon (cid:104) j,i (cid:107)2)− max j((cid:107)treal max j((cid:107)treal j,i (cid:107)2) DMA = 1 NA ∑ i , (12) where the maxima of traction magnitude are calculated for each traction patch separately through index j. This error measure is particularly important since traction maxima are easy to extract from real experimental data. A DMA of 0 means that the local traction maxima in the reconstruction and in the original data are equal. Positive or negative values of the DMA indicate that the maximum of traction is overestimated or underestimated. Experimental procedures Primary murine podocytes were isolated and maintained by following previously published protocols.74 In brief, mGFP positive podocytes were isolated from mTom/mGFPNphs2Cre reporter mice and subsequent FACS based purification resulted in a primary podocyte culture of highest purity.75 Substratum matrices were prepared according to previously established protocols.70 Primary podocytes were seeded on polyacrylamide substrates with a Young's modulus of 16 kPA. Before, gels were functionalized via SULFO-SANPAH based crosslinking of fibronectin (UV light applied for 5 minutes). Cells were cultivated for 12− 16 hours before imaging. Cover slips were transferred into flow chambers and cell removal to image the stress-free gel was achieved with a cell micromanipulator (Eppendorf). Heart muscle cells from embryonic rats were freshly prepared as described previously76. Cover slides were coated with approximately 70 µm thick silicone elastomer layer produced from a commercial two-component formulation (Sylgard 184, Dow Corning; mixing ratio 50:1 base to crosslinker by weight; cured overnight at 60◦C). These substrates contained fluorescent beads in their uppermost layer (FluoSpheres Crimson carboxylate-modified beads; Invitrogen) and were coated with fibronectin before cell seeding. Details on preparation and cell culture are published elsewhere76, calibration of stiffness77 yielded a Young module of 15 kPa and a Poisson ratio of 0.5. Live cell microscopy on spontaneously beating cardiac myocytes was performed and positions of fluorescent beads were determined by cross-correlation as described in detail previously.76, 78 Results Manual selection of optimal regularization parameters is challenging The optimal regularization parameters λ1/2 in Eq. (3) are usually unknown. Classical methods for their choice are the L-curve criterion67, 79 or the generalized cross validation (GCV) for L2 regularization.49, 80 However, these two methods hardly ever produce the same parameter values and results can differ substantially in the presence of noise, see supporting Fig. S1. To illustrate the strong effect of regularization on traction reconstruction, we focus on artificial test data where the underlying traction pattern is known. Figure 2(a) illustrates the generation of artificial traction fields consisting of circular patches each exerting 100 Pa. Fig. 2c) demonstrates how variation of the regularization parameters affects the error of traction reconstruction with different methods. Note that the errors exhibit minima for intermediate values of the regularization parameters. For the methods shown in panels i,iv,v of Fig. 2(c) (L2 regularization, PGL, PGEN), minima occur in the positive error of the background traction DTMB. In contrast, L1 regularization shown in panel ii of Fig. 2(c) exhibits a maximum in the DTMA, indicating a parameter regime where the traction magnitude is not underestimated. The occurrence of clear minima in the error measures suggests that the corresponding regularization parameter values produce a faithful traction reconstruction. Indeed, employing the values corresponding to the error minima yields traction fields that visually compare well with the original data, see Figs. 2a) and 2d). Note that for L1 regularization, the reconstruction clearly overestimates the maximum traction locally. As shown in the supplementary Fig. S2(b), the overestimation of the maximum quantified by the DMA can only be reduced through ∼ 10 fold reduction of λ1, which however leads to strong background traction and suppression of real traction, see also Fig. S6. While the minima of the error measures in Fig. 2c) allow to determine a "best" regularization for test data, the resulting regularization parameter values deviate from those suggested by 6/20 the L-curve criterion, see green lines in Fig. 2c). Moreover, the L-curves for these samples are complex and exhibit multiple turning points, illustrating the difficulty in choosing the right regularization parameter in experiments, see supporting Fig. S5. The elastic net outperforms other regularization methods for traction reconstruction To facilitate quantitative comparison of different reconstruction methods, we employ artificial data consisting of 15 circular traction spots with traction magnitude between 0 Pa and 250 Pa, see Fig. 3(a). Gaussian noise with a standard deviation given in percent of the maximal absolute value of the of true displacements is added. The spots have a diameter of 2 µm and the mesh constant for traction reconstruction is 0.5 µm. Results from different regularization approaches are shown in Fig. 3(a). The figure illustrates that L2 regularization can yield realistic estimates for the absolute magnitude of traction on the spots but produces a strong traction background, which may render identification of traction sites difficult. The opposite deficiencies occur for results from L1 regularization. Here, the background is nicely suppressed, which can allow excellent resolution of very small traction spots. However, the peak tractions are significantly overestimated, which can not be mitigated by increasing the regularization parameter, see the supplementary Fig. S6. Note that the quality of L1 regularization can be improved by using an Iterative Reweighted Least Squares algorithm and the solution from the L2 regularization as an initial guess, see Supplemental Material. The best results are obtained with the EN regularization which combines the advantages of L1- and L2-regularization. Here, we obtain a clean background combined with acceptable accuracy in the absolute traction magnitude on the circular patches. The results from the proximal gradient methods PGL and PGEN qualitatively have a smooth appearance with a level of background traction that is between those of L2 and L1. Fig. 3(b) quantifies the described differences between the regularization methods through the error in traction magnitude on the traction spots (DTMA), the error in traction magnitude in the background (DTMB), signal to noise ratio (SNR), and error in maximum traction on the spots (DMA). The supplementary Fig. S9 contains additional plots of these quantities. We find that the reconstruction quality of traction and background improves with increasing number of displacement measurements m. Furthermore, EN regularization outperforms other regularization methods with regard to reconstruction accuracy of undersampled data (m/n < 1). However, the advantage of EN regularization comes at a significantly increased computation time and memory requirement as shown in Table 1. Reconstruction method Name Simulation time Requirement RAM Regularization L2 8 s L1 75 s EN 0.8 h PGL 126 s PGEN 127 s Bayesian models ABL2 BL2 0.1 h 0.5 h 350 MB 1.98 GB 3.87 GB 101 MB 107 MB 400 MB 400 MB Table 1. Overview of calculation time and RAM requirement for each method. The benchmark results were conducted with a data set consisting of 1000 displacement measurements and a traction field consisting of 2500 entries. Bayesian variants of the L2 regularization allow parameter-free traction reconstruction We next consider the performance of the two Bayesian methods, BL2 and ABL2, that allow automatic choice of the optimal L2 regularization parameter, as schematically shown in Fig. 4(a). Both methods select the optimal regularization parameter by maximizing the logarithmic evidence, Eq. (8). As illustrated in Fig. 4(a), the regularization parameter is here deduced from the parameters β and α, characterizing the distributions of measurement noise and traction respectively. We first employ the same test data as used for Fig. 3, containing 5% Gaussian noise in the displacements with β = 400 Pix−2. With BL2, the log evidence exhibits a clear maximum in a one-dimensional space as seen in Fig. 4(c). Figure 4(d) shows the reconstructed traction employing the optimal parameter λ2 = 76.75 Pa2/Pix2. Visual comparison of the color-coded traction magnitude in Figs. 4(d) and 4(b) clearly shows that the reconstructed traction has the correct range. For ABL2, the evidence is a function of β and α as seen in Fig. 4(e). Numerical localization of the maximum yields α = 3.06e4 Pa−2 and β = 394 Pix−2, which is very close to the known input value of β = 400 Pix−2. The optimal regularization parameter in this case is thus λ2 = α/ β = 77.66 Pa2/Pix2, which agrees well with the estimate from BL2 (76.75 Pa2/Pix2). The resulting traction map is is shown in Fig. 4(f) and is very similar to the traction map resulting from BL2 in Fig. 4(d). Thus, BL2 and ABL2 yield consistent parameter estimates that produce traction reconstruction of good accuracy. See supplementary Fig. S9 for a comparison of the Bayesian methods with non-Bayesian approaches. As with other regularization approaches, quality of reconstruction strongly depends on the present noise. When the magnitude of the noise is comparable to the magnitude of the displacements caused by the traction (σn/σ¯u ≈ 1), little information can be recovered. For instance, the small circular traction sites labeled 1 and 2 in Fig. 3(a) are almost impossible to detect in the presence of 5% noise, but can be reconstructed in the noise-free case, see the supplementary Fig. S7. To quantitatively assess the fidelity of reconstruction with small traction forces, we employ a constant 5% but scale the tractions to mean values of (12 Pa, 16 Pa, 60 Pa, and 120 Pa). The resulting relative strength of noise and displacements is quantified 7/20 through the ratio of standard deviations σn/σ¯u, which is plotted against our reconstruction quality measures in Fig. 4(g). For comparison, results from manual selection of the regularization parameter using the L-curve criterion are also given. The reconstruction qualities of BL2, ABL2 and L2 are similar when σn/σ¯u (cid:28) 1 (high traction). However, BL2 and ABL2 have an improved signal to ratio SNR compared with the L-Curve approach when σn/σ¯u approaches unity, see (iii). This is due to the difficulties with the L-curve criterion at high noise. The logarithmic evidence function exhibits in all cases a clear maximum, which enables robust and reliable choice of optimal parameters with BL2 and ABL2. In general, the results from BL2 are however more reliable since the optimization involves here only one parameter. Overall, the tests with artificial data show that these Bayesian methods containing few additional parameters to be determined from the data can resolve the ambiguity associated with manual choice of the regularization parameters over a wide range of signal strengths σn/σ¯u < 1. BL2 and ABL2 are based on the simplest structure of a Bayesian model with only one, global prior distribution. One may hypothesize that more complex hierarchies of priors yield an improved traction estimate. For instance, it is possible to prescribe a position-dependent prior for sparse traction patterns through hierarchical Bayesian networks. Such methods require more advanced techniques for sampling of the probability distributions and optimization, such as variational techniques or Markov-chain Monte Carlo methods. We have tested three such algorithms that were originally developed for purposes other than TFM.71, 81 -- 83 Results are shown in the supplementary information. However, the tested algorithms all produce highly overestimated, localized traction patterns that sensitively depend on noise. Such errors are likely due to the many free parameters of the models that, in spite of the sparsity constraints, do not favor a faithful data reconstruction. Thus, our tests suggests that these hierarchical network models are not suited for the inverse problem associated with TFM. Test of methods with experimental data To compare the performance of the different methods for real cells, we employ primary mouse podocytes studied with a standard TFM setup on polyacrylamide gels having a Young module of ∼ 16 kPa. The deformation field resulting from cellular traction is shown in Fig. 5 (a). Using this displacement data, we find that the variance of noise is ∼ 0.01pix2 = 103.4nm2 in regions that are far away from the cell. The maximum displacement is 0.52 µm. Figs. 5(b)-(h) show reconstruction results using all methods discussed above. As for artificial data, we find here that the EN regularization results in a very clear background. The traction magnitudes and outlines of adhesion sites are similar to those resulting from regularization with the L2 method. For L1 regularization, traction localizes in sparse regions and has a significantly higher value than for other methods. Proximal gradient methods produce smooth traction profiles as expected from the use of the soft wavelet thresholding. The magnitude of traction measured with PGL and PGEN is close to results of EN and L2. Next, we considered the performance of the Bayesian methods. The logarithmic evidence, Eq. (8), calculated with BL2 and ABL2 reveals pronounced maxima, allowing to robustly choose the optimal parameters for the experimental data. See also supplementary Fig. S11. The resulting values for λ2 are 30.4 Pa2/Pix2 and 24.4 Pa2/Pix2 for BL2 and ABL2, respectively, and thus agree reasonably well with each other. Figures 5(e),(h) show the traction fields calculated with BL2 and ABL2. These traction fields are visually very similar to the one obtained with standard L2 regularization. However, the L-curve criterion provides a much more uncertain estimate of a regularization parameter due to the difficulty of localizing it on a logarithmic scale, see supplementary Fig. S12. Note that the regularization parameters obtained from the L-curve criterion can not be directly compared to the parameters resulting from the Bayesian methods due to standardization employed for the latter. Overall, the suggested Bayesian models can eliminate ambiguity in TFM by automatically providing a consistent parameter choice. Bayesian regularization enables consistent analysis of traction time sequences TFM is frequently employed to study dynamical aspects of cell mechanics. Examples include cell migration, cell division, or cytoskeletal reorganization in response to extracellular stimuli. Such processes are usually accompanied with a change in the traction distribution. As a result, the optimal regularization parameter varies among different images in a time sequence of microscopy data. Additionally, the regularization parameter can also change if the degree of noise varies over time, which can be caused for example by stage drift or photo bleaching. In such cases, it is very challenging to perform a consistent, frame-by frame analysis to determine the degree of regularization with conventional methods. Thus, one fixed parameter is commonly employed for the whole time sequence and precision, but also accuracy of traction reconstruction is thereby sacrificed. To test whether our Bayesian methods can be useful in this situation, we employ TFM data with a spontaneously beating cardiac myocyte, see Fig. 6. Due to the large size of the cell, we focus on a region of interest shown in Fig. 6(a). The analyzed time sequence corresponds to one cell contraction. Snapshots from frames 1, 4, and 6 are shown for illustration. Figure 6(b) shows the overall norm of reconstructed traction where λ2 is either chosen according to the L-curve criterion, held at an intermediate, constant value, or automatically determined in BL2. The overall traction magnitudes are similar in frames 2-6 where traction is high. Differences occur, however, in the low-traction regime, where BL2 systematically yields lower values of traction. We expect that the results from BL2 are more trustworthy in this regime since the L-curve criterion yields highly ambiguous values for the regularization parameters, see supplementary Fig. S13. Figure 6(c) shows the overall norm of the gel displacement and the optimal regularization parameter estimated with BL2. The noise variance is small, ∼ 0.00003pix2, in 8/20 regions that are far away from the cell (pixel size 0.2 µm). As expected, λBL2 is inversely correlated with the displacement magnitude. Figs. 6e show snapshots of the resulting traction fields that illustrate again that BL2 produces slightly different results for low traction, most apparent in Figs. 6(e)i,I and Fig. 6(f),i. Note that the traction field resulting from classical L2 regularization in Figs. 6(e),i,I shows a noise background outside of the cell that is almost comparable to the real cellular traction. In contrast, BL2 suppresses this background at the price of an apparently reduced spatial resolution as seen in Fig. 6(f),i. However, this provides an objective distinction between real signal and noise, which is what is to be expected from a faithful data reconstruction. Discussion During the last decade, traction force microscopy has become one of the most popular techniques for studying mechanobiology on the cellular level. The technique has found broad use for studying sub-cellular structures,66, 84 -- 87 single cell dynamics,88 -- 91 and collective cellular behavior,92 -- 97, and there are far too many applications to be reviewed here appropriately. Many, if not all, TFM methods critically rely on some form of noise reduction. Usually, traction is calculated from substrate displacement through the solution of a linear problem involving elastic Green's functions. Here, the effects of noise are not a technical issue relating to the data precision, but connected directly to the structure of the linear problem where even the slightest numerical noise can be amplified to an extent that the true solution is entirely lost. The most immediate approach to deal with noise is to filter the displacement field prior to traction reconstruction. Filtering becomes possible if the solution is calculated in Fourier space because the convolution theorem simplifies the matrix inversion.24 However, filtering the input data generally reduces the spatial resolution and optimal resolution can only be gained if the filter is adapted for each sample. In certain cases, moreover, data filtering is not sufficient to guarantee stability of the solution, for example, if the three-dimensional position of displacements is included. A popular alternative strategy for enforcing well-behaved solutions is regularization. With regularization, Fourier-space inversion becomes more robust.21, 23 However, regularization is also used for real-space approaches and has been used in conjunction with finite element methods or boundary element methods. Solving the linear problem in real space is generally more demanding, but has the advantage that the spatial sparsity of traction patterns is conserved. For TFM, two regularization methods have to date been used, namely L2 regularization23, 70, 73 and L1 regularization28, 53, 54. These methods each have one regularization parameter that is chosen manually based on heuristics, which introduces a considerable degree of subjectivity in the resulting traction. In this work, we systematically compare the classical L1- and L2 regularization to three other methods that have, to our knowledge, not yet been employed for TFM. These three regularization methods are the Elastic Net (EN), Proximal Gradient Lasso (PGL) and Proximal Gradient Elastic Net (PGEN). Our tests with artificial data clearly demonstrate that EN regularization outperforms other regularization methods with regard to the reconstruction quality. Here, accurate traction reconstruction is due to a simultaneous suppression of background noise and penalizing of large traction magnitude. In contrast, the proximal gradient methods PGL and PGEN are effective at producing a smoothed traction field, due to the local removal of high-frequency spatial variations. These results obtained with artificial data agree qualitatively with results from tests with experimental data. Here too, L1 and L2 regularization yield overestimated or underestimated traction on adhesion sites. EN again yields a clear background without producing excessively sharp traction peaks at adhesions, see Fig. 5. PGL and PGEN yield smooth traction fields and rounded adhesion site contours. While our work presents a comprehensive overview of regularization variants in TFM, it does not cover all variants and solution procedures. For example, it has been suggested to use an L1 norm for both the residual and regularization term,54 and various other iterative regularization procedures can be tested for TFM in the future. Next, we ask if Bayesian methods can eliminate the necessity of a manual choice of regularization parameters. Here, the corresponding parameter values are inferred by maximizing their evidence given a fixed class of chosen probability distributions. Using the simplest approach, our prior assumption on the traction forces is that they are drawn from one global Gaussian distribution with an unknown variance 1/α. The posterior distribution determining the probability of a particular traction field given a measured displacement field is then determined by the parameter 1/α and a further parameter 1/β , quantifying the variance of the measurement noise. For fixed values of α and β , maximization of the posterior distribution corresponds exactly to L2 regularization with λ2 given by α/β . However, the values of α and β can also be determined through maximizing their probability conditioned on a given measurement and the chosen probability distributions. Here, this is equivalent to maximizing the evidence for u, given any two parameter values. We refer to the simultaneous determination of both parameters from the evidence as advanced Bayesian L2 regularization (ABL2). In an even simpler approach, we estimate the noise strength directly from the displacement data, leaving only one parameter α to be determined by maximization of the evidence; which we call Bayesian L2 regularization (BL2). These methods represent an automatic optimization of the L2 regularization. Thus the resulting traction field has all the qualitative features of L2 regularization, including the suppression of exceedingly high traction values and a visible background traction. For all our tests, we found that BL2 was a robust method yielding reasonable estimates for traction and regularization parameters. Due to the difficulty in choosing the correct regularization parameter 9/20 manually, BL2 has substantial advantages over the classical L2 procedure, in particular if the traction is so small that the resulting displacements are comparable to the noise σn/σ¯u ≈ 1. We mention that we have also tested more elaborate hierarchical Bayesian network algorithms that were originally designed for other purposes than for use with TFM. These include a variational approach termed "Bayesian compressive sensing using Laplace priors" (BCSL),71 and Markov chain Monte Carlo methods, for instance the "Bayesian Lasso".83 In our experience, however, none of these methods could compete with the much simpler Bayesian L2 regularization when applied to TFM problems, see Figs. S8-S10,S14 in the supplementary information. The advantage of employing Bayesian traction reconstruction is most apparent when cells in different conditions are to be compared. To perform a correct comparison of situations with different traction, different substrate rigidities, etc., it is technically necessary to adapt the regularization parameter for each case. However, the difficulty of finding the corresponding parameters usually makes this impossible, which introduces significant quantitative errors. Bayesian methods present a possible solution to this problem. We have shown here that BL2 produces regularization that varies smoothly and robustly with strong temporal changes in the traction exerted by a cell. Thus, we expect that this method can be of wide use for quantitative studies of cell physiology. Acknowledgements C.S. acknowledges support by the Berta-Ottenstein Programme, Faculty of Medicine, University of Freiburg, Germany. Author contributions statement Y.H. implemented the algorithms and analyzed the data; N.H. and R.M. performed the experiment on heart muscle cells; C.S. and T.H. performed the experiment on podocytes; G.G. discussed data and results; B.S. designed and supervised the project and wrote the main text. All authors participated in writing the manuscript. Additional information The authors declare no competing interests. 10/20 References 1. Geiger, B., Bershadsky, A., Pankov, R. & Yamada, K. Transmembrane extracellular matrix-cytoskeleton crosstalk. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 2, 793 -- 805 (2001). 2. Vogel, V. & Sheetz, M. Local force and geometry sensing regulate cell functions. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 7, 265 -- 275 (2006). 3. Hinz, B. Formation and function of the myofibroblast during tissue repair. J. Invest. Dermatol. 127, 526 -- 537 (2007). 4. Butcher, D. T., Alliston, T. & Weaver, V. M. A tense situation: forcing tumour progression. Nat. Rev. Cancer 9, 108 -- 122 (2009). 5. Califano, J. P. & Reinhart-King, C. A. Exogenous and endogenous force regulation of endothelial cell behavior. J. Biomech. 43, 79 -- 86 (2010). 6. Ringer, P. et al. Multiplexing molecular tension sensors reveals piconewton force gradient across talin-1. Nat. methods 14, 1090 (2017). 7. Lecuit, T., Lenne, P.-F. & Munro, E. Force generation, transmission, and integration during cell and tissue morphogenesis. Annu. Rev. Cell Dev. Biol. 27, 157 -- 184 (2011). 8. Harris, A. K., Wild, P., Stopak, D. et al. Silicone rubber substrata: a new wrinkle in the study of cell locomotion. Sci. 208, 177 -- 179 (1980). 9. Roy, P., Rajfur, Z., Pomorski, P. & Jacobson, K. Microscope-based techniques to study cell adhesion and migration. Nat. Cell Biol. 4 (2002). 10. Lange, J. R. & Fabry, B. Cell and tissue mechanics in cell migration. Exp. Cell Res. 319, 2418 -- 2423 (2013). 11. Style, R. W. et al. Traction force microscopy in physics and biology. Soft matter 10, 4047 -- 4055 (2014). 12. Schwarz, U. S. & Soiné, J. R. Traction force microscopy on soft elastic substrates: A guide to recent computational advances. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1853, 3095 -- 3104 (2015). 13. Polacheck, W. J. & Chen, C. S. Measuring cell-generated forces: a guide to the available tools. Nat. meth. 13, 415 (2016). 14. Roca-Cusachs, P., Conte, V. & Trepat, X. Quantifying forces in cell biology. Nat. Cell Biol. 19, 742 (2017). 15. Dembo, M. & Wang, Y.-L. Stresses at the cell-to-substrate interface during locomotion of fibroblasts. Biophys. J. 76, 2307 -- 2316 (1999). 16. Bergert, M. et al. Confocal reference free traction force microscopy. Nat. Commun. 7, 12814 (2016). 17. Yang, Z., Lin, J.-S., Chen, J. & Wang, J. H. Determining substrate displacement and cell traction fields -- a new approach. J. Theo. Biol. 242, 607 -- 616 (2006). 18. Hur, S. S., Zhao, Y., Li, Y.-S., Botvinick, E. & Chien, S. Live cells exert 3-dimensional traction forces on their substrata. Cell. Mol. Bioeng. 2, 425 -- 436 (2009). 19. Tang, X., Tofangchi, A., Anand, S. V. & Saif, T. A. A novel cell traction force microscopy to study multi-cellular system. PLoS Comput. Biol. 10, e1003631 (2014). 20. Soiné, J. R. et al. Measuring cellular traction forces on non-planar substrates. Interface focus 6, 20160024 (2016). 21. Kulkarni, A. H., Ghosh, P., Seetharaman, A., Kondaiah, P. & Gundiah, N. Traction cytometry: regularization in the fourier approach and comparisons with finite element method. Soft matter (2018). 22. Dembo, M., Oliver, T., Ishihara, A. & Jacobson, K. Imaging the traction stresses exerted by locomoting cells with the elastic substratum method. Biophys. J. 70, 2008 -- 2022 (1996). 23. Sabass, B., Gardel, M. L., Waterman, C. M. & Schwarz, U. S. High resolution traction force microscopy based on experimental and computational advances. Biophys. J. 94, 207 -- 220 (2008). 24. Butler, J. P., Toli´c-Nørrelykke, I. M., Fabry, B. & Fredberg, J. J. Traction fields, moments, and strain energy that cells exert on their surroundings. Am. J. Physiol., Cell Physiol. 282, C595 -- C605 (2002). 25. Franck, C., Maskarinec, S. A., Tirrell, D. A. & Ravichandran, G. Three-dimensional traction force microscopy: a new tool for quantifying cell-matrix interactions. PLoS One 6, e17833 (2011). 26. Landau, L. D. & Lifshitz, E. Theory of elasticity, vol. 7. Course Theor. Phys. 3, 109 (1986). 27. Tolic-Nørrelykke, I. M., Butler, J. P., Chen, J. & Wang, N. Spatial and temporal traction response in human airway smooth muscle cells. Am. J. Physiol.-Cell Physiol. 283, C1254 -- C1266 (2002). 11/20 28. Han, S. J., Oak, Y., Groisman, A. & Danuser, G. Traction microscopy to identify force modulation in subresolution adhesions. Nat. Methods 12, 653 -- 656 (2015). 29. Zou, H. & Hastie, T. Regularization and variable selection via the elastic net. J. R. Stat. Soc. Ser. B Stat. Methodol. 67, 301 -- 320 (2005). 30. Combettes, P. L. & Pesquet, J.-C. Proximal splitting methods in signal processing. In Fixed-point algorithms for inverse problems in science and engineering, 185 -- 212 (Springer, 2011). 31. Schmidt, M., Roux, N. L. & Bach, F. R. Convergence rates of inexact proximal-gradient methods for convex optimization. In Advances in neural information processing systems, 1458 -- 1466 (2011). 32. Mosci, S., Rosasco, L., Santoro, M., Verri, A. & Villa, S. Solving structured sparsity regularization with proximal methods. In Joint European Conference on Machine Learning and Knowledge Discovery in Databases, 418 -- 433 (Springer, 2010). 33. Peyré, G., Bougleux, S. & Cohen, L. Non-local regularization of inverse problems. Comput. Vision -- ECCV 2008 57 -- 68 (2008). 34. Fadili, J. M. & Peyré, G. Total variation projection with first order schemes. IEEE Trans. Image Process. 20, 657 -- 669 (2011). 35. Michel, V., Gramfort, A., Varoquaux, G., Eger, E. & Thirion, B. Total variation regularization for fmri-based prediction of behavior. IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging 30, 1328 -- 1340 (2011). 36. Hannum, G. et al. Genome-wide methylation profiles reveal quantitative views of human aging rates. Mol. cell 49, 359 -- 367 (2013). 37. Sokolov, A., Carlin, D. E., Paull, E. O., Baertsch, R. & Stuart, J. M. Pathway-based genomics prediction using generalized elastic net. PLoS Comput. Biol. 12, e1004790 (2016). 38. MacKay, D. J. Bayesian interpolation. Neural Comput. 4, 415 -- 447 (1992). 39. Suyu, S. H., Marshall, P., Hobson, M. & Blandford, R. A bayesian analysis of regularized source inversions in gravitational lensing. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 371, 983 -- 998 (2006). 40. Vegetti, S. & Koopmans, L. V. Bayesian strong gravitational-lens modelling on adaptive grids: objective detection of mass substructure in galaxies. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 392, 945 -- 963 (2009). 41. Ghosh, A., Koopmans, L. V., Chapman, E. & Jeli´c, V. A bayesian analysis of redshifted 21-cm h i signal and foregrounds: simulations for lofar. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 452, 1587 -- 1600 (2015). 42. Tipping, M. E. Sparse bayesian learning and the relevance vector machine. J. Mach. Learn. Res. 1, 211 -- 244 (2001). 43. Huang, Y., Beck, J. L., Wu, S. & Li, H. Robust bayesian compressive sensing for signals in structural health monitoring. Comput.-Aided Civ. Infrastruct. Eng. 29, 160 -- 179 (2014). 44. Qiao, L., Chen, S. & Tan, X. Sparsity preserving projections with applications to face recognition. Pattern Recognit. 43, 331 -- 341 (2010). 45. Zhao, L., Wang, L., Bi, G. & Yang, L. An autofocus technique for high-resolution inverse synthetic aperture radar imagery. IEEE Trans. Geosci. Remote. Sens. 52, 6392 -- 6403 (2014). 46. Schwarz, U. S. et al. Calculation of forces at focal adhesions from elastic substrate data: the effect of localized force and the need for regularization. Biophys. J. 83, 1380 -- 1394 (2002). 47. Colin-York, H. et al. Super-resolved traction force microscopy (stfm). Nano Lett. 16, 2633 -- 2638 (2016). 48. Tikhonov, A. N., Arsenin, V. I. & John, F. Solutions of ill-posed problems, vol. 14 (Winston Washington, DC, 1977). 49. Hansen, P. C. Regularization tools version 4.0 for matlab 7.3. Numer. algorithms 46, 189 -- 194 (2007). 50. Tibshirani, R. Regression shrinkage and selection via the lasso. J. Royal Stat. Soc. Ser. B (Methodological) 267 -- 288 (1996). 51. Candès, E. J., Romberg, J. & Tao, T. Robust uncertainty principles: Exact signal reconstruction from highly incomplete frequency information. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 52, 489 -- 509 (2006). 52. Brask, J. B., Singla-Buxarrais, G., Uroz, M., Vincent, R. & Trepat, X. Compressed sensing traction force microscopy. Acta Biomater. 26, 286 -- 294 (2015). 53. Suñé-Auñón, A., Jorge-Peñas, A., Van Oosterwyck, H. & Muñoz-Barrutia, A. L1-regularized reconstruction for traction force microscopy. In Biomedical Imaging (ISBI), 2016 IEEE 13th International Symposium on, 140 -- 144 (IEEE, 2016). 12/20 54. Suñé-Auñón, A. et al. Full l 1-regularized traction force microscopy over whole cells. BMC Bioinf. 18, 365 (2017). 55. Sunagawa, S. et al. Structure and function of the global ocean microbiome. Sci. 348, 1261359 (2015). 56. Horlbeck, M. A. et al. Compact and highly active next-generation libraries for crispr-mediated gene repression and activation. Elife 5, e19760 (2016). 57. Reddy, A. et al. Genetic and functional drivers of diffuse large b cell lymphoma. Cell 171, 481 -- 494 (2017). 58. Grant, M. & Boyd, S. CVX: Matlab software for disciplined convex programming, version 2.1. http://cvxr.com/cvx (2014). 59. Grant, M. & Boyd, S. Graph implementations for nonsmooth convex programs. In Blondel, V., Boyd, S. & Kimura, H. (eds.) Recent Advances in Learning and Control, Lecture Notes in Control and Information Sciences, 95 -- 110 (Springer-Verlag Limited, 2008). http://stanford.edu/~boyd/graph_dcp.html. 60. Parikh, N., Boyd, S. et al. Proximal algorithms. Foundations Trends Optim. 1, 127 -- 239 (2014). 61. Donoho, D. L. & Johnstone, J. M. Ideal spatial adaptation by wavelet shrinkage. Biom. 81, 425 -- 455 (1994). 62. Donoho, D. L., Johnstone, I. M., Kerkyacharian, G. & Picard, D. Wavelet shrinkage: asymptopia? J. Royal Stat. Soc. Ser. B (Methodological) 301 -- 369 (1995). 63. Figueiredo, M. A. & Nowak, R. D. An em algorithm for wavelet-based image restoration. IEEE Transactions on Image Process. 12, 906 -- 916 (2003). 64. Beck, A. & Teboulle, M. A fast iterative shrinkage-thresholding algorithm with application to wavelet-based image deblurring. In ICASSP 2009. IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing., 693 -- 696 (IEEE, 2009). 65. Peyré, G. The numerical tours of signal processing. Comput. Sci. Eng. 13, 94 -- 97 (2011). 66. Legant, W. R. et al. Multidimensional traction force microscopy reveals out-of-plane rotational moments about focal adhesions. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 110, 881 -- 886 (2013). 67. Hansen, P. C. The L-curve and its use in the numerical treatment of inverse problems (IMM, Department of Mathematical Modelling, Technical Universityof Denmark, 1999). 68. Hanke, M. Limitations of the l-curve method in ill-posed problems. BIT Numer. Math. 36, 287 -- 301 (1996). 69. Molina, R., Katsaggelos, A. K. & Mateos, J. Bayesian and regularization methods for hyperparameter estimation in image restoration. IEEE Trans. Image Process. 8, 231 -- 246 (1999). 70. Plotnikov, S. V., Sabass, B., Schwarz, U. S. & Waterman, C. M. High-resolution traction force microscopy. Methods cell biology 123, 367 (2014). 71. Babacan, S. D., Molina, R. & Katsaggelos, A. K. Bayesian compressive sensing using laplace priors. IEEE Trans. Image Process. 19, 53 -- 63 (2010). 72. Li, Q., Lin, N. et al. The bayesian elastic net. Bayesian Analysis 5, 151 -- 170 (2010). 73. Holenstein, C. N., Silvan, U. & Snedeker, J. G. High-resolution traction force microscopy on small focal adhesions- improved accuracy through optimal marker distribution and optical flow tracking. Sci. Rep. 7, 41633 (2017). 74. Schell, C. et al. N-wasp is required for stabilization of podocyte foot processes. J. Am. Soc. Nephrol. 24, 713 -- 721 (2013). 75. Schell, C. et al. The ferm protein epb41l5 regulates actomyosin contractility and focal adhesion formation to maintain the kidney filtration barrier. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 114, E4621 -- E4630 (2017). 76. Hersch, N. et al. The constant beat: cardiomyocytes adapt their forces by equal contraction upon environmental stiffening. Biol. Open 2, 351 -- U119 (2013). 77. Cesa, C. M. et al. Micropatterned silicone elastomer substrates for high resolution analysis of cellular force patterns. Rev. Sci. Instr. 78 (2007). 78. Merkel, R., Kirchgebner, N., Cesa, C. M. & Hoffmann, B. Cell force Microscopy on elastic layers of finite thickness. Biophys. J. 93, 3314 -- 3323 (2007). 79. Winters, D. W., Van Veen, B. D. & Hagness, S. C. A sparsity regularization approach to the electromagnetic inverse scattering problem. IEEE Trans. Antennas Propag. 58, 145 -- 154 (2010). 80. Golub, G. H., Heath, M. & Wahba, G. Generalized cross-validation as a method for choosing a good ridge parameter. Technometrics 21, 215 -- 223 (1979). 13/20 81. Hobert, J. P. & Casella, G. The effect of improper priors on gibbs sampling in hierarchical linear mixed models. J. Am. Stat. Assoc. 91, 1461 -- 1473 (1996). 82. Tipping, M. E., Faul, A. C. et al. Fast marginal likelihood maximisation for sparse bayesian models. In AISTATS (2003). 83. Korobilis, D. Hierarchical shrinkage priors for dynamic regressions with many predictors. Int. J. Forecast. 29, 43 -- 59 (2013). 84. Balaban, N. Q. et al. Force and focal adhesion assembly: a close relationship studied using elastic micropatterned substrates. Nat. Cell Biol. 3, 466 (2001). 85. Théry, M., Pépin, A., Dressaire, E., Chen, Y. & Bornens, M. Cell distribution of stress fibres in response to the geometry of the adhesive environment. Cell Motil. Cytosk. 63, 341 -- 355 (2006). 86. Gardel, M. L. et al. Traction stress in focal adhesions correlates biphasically with actin retrograde flow speed. J. Cell. Biol. 183, 999 -- 1005 (2008). 87. Ray, A. et al. Anisotropic forces from spatially constrained focal adhesions mediate contact guidance directed cell migration. Nat. Commun. 8 (2017). 88. Chaudhuri, O. et al. Substrate stress relaxation regulates cell spreading. Nat. Commun. 6, 6365 (2015). 89. Valon, L., Marín-Llauradó, A., Wyatt, T., Charras, G. & Trepat, X. Optogenetic control of cellular forces and mechan- otransduction. Nat. Commun. 8, 14396 (2017). 90. Oria, R. et al. Force loading explains spatial sensing of ligands by cells. Nat. 552, 219 (2017). 91. Sabass, B., Koch, M. D., Liu, G., Stone, H. A. & Shaevitz, J. W. Force generation by groups of migrating bacteria. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 114, 7266 -- 7271 (2017). 92. Trepat, X. et al. Physical forces during collective cell migration. Nat. Phys. 5, 426 (2009). 93. Mertz, A. F. et al. Cadherin-based intercellular adhesions organize epithelial cell -- matrix traction forces. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 110, 842 -- 847 (2013). 94. Ng, M. R., Besser, A., Brugge, J. S. & Danuser, G. Mapping the dynamics of force transduction at cell -- cell junctions of epithelial clusters. Elife 3, e03282 (2014). 95. Steinwachs, J. et al. Three-dimensional force microscopy of cells in biopolymer networks. Nat. Methods 13, 171 (2015). 96. Lembong, J., Sabass, B. & Stone, H. Calcium oscillations in wounded fibroblast monolayers are spatially regulated through substrate mechanics. Phys. Biol. (2017). 97. Saw, T. B. et al. Topological defects in epithelia govern cell death and extrusion. Nat. 544, 212+ (2017). 14/20 Figure 1. Schematic representation of a typical traction force microscopy (TFM) setup and different reconstruction methods for TFM. (a) Cells are plated on a planar gel substrate containing fiducial markers. Tracking the markers allows to infer the deformations u in the surrounding of the cell. These deformations are linearly related to the cellular traction forces f. The problem of calculating traction f from displacement u is associated with inverting an ill-conditioned matrix M. This problem can be solved with different reconstruction methods. (b) In this work, we test five regularization methods for traction reconstruction: L2 regularization (L2), L1 regularization (L1), EN regularization (EN), Proximal Gradient Lasso (PGL) and Proximal Gradient Elastic Net (PGEN). Furthermore, we develop two Bayesian approaches that do not have any free parameters, namely Bayesian L2 regularization (BL2) and Advanced Bayesian L2 regularization (ABL2). 15/20 ReconstructionTested reconstruction methodsaRegularization methods: parameter choice requiredBayesian models: no free parameter L2L1ENPGLPGENbBL2Measured substrate displacementsReconstructed tractionABL2Gelufu=MfFigure 2. Systematic tests illustrate substantial ambiguity in the choice of regularization parameters. (a) Schematic of the employed procedure to test the reconstruction methods. (a,i) Artificial traction pattern consisting of circular spots that uniformly exert a traction of 100 Pa. (a,ii) Analytical calculation of the gel displacements. (a,iii) The displacement field is sampled at random positions representing measurements of motion of fiducial markers. (a,iv) Reconstruction of the traction. (b) Central formula summarizing different regularization approaches. (c) Dependence of various error measures on the regularization parameters. (b,i)-(b,v) Error measures defined in Eqns. (9)-(12) exhibit various extrema and turning points, making the definition of an optimal parameter challenging. Note that the minima of the errors do not correspond to values of regularization parameters suggested by the L-curve criterion (Green dotted lines vs. black dotted lines). DTMA: Deviation of traction magnitude at adhesion, DTMB: deviation of traction magnitude in background. (b,I)-(b,V) Traction fields calculated with regularization parameters that correspond to the error minima at the black dotted lines. Space bar: 5 µm. 16/20 Reconstructed traction Traction reconstruction using dierent regularization methods Simulation of measurement Analytical displacementArticial tractioniiiiiIL2L1PGLPGEN 0200[Pa]0200[Pa]022[nm]argmin[Mf-u22+1f1+2f22[fError normsf=Reconstruction worseworseworseworseworseworseworseworse[Pix /Pa ]22[Pix /Pa]2[Pix /Pa ]22[Pix /Pa]2[Pix /Pa]2[Pix /Pa ]22[Pix /Pa]2worseworseIIIVVivivb0200[Pa]aL2:1=02>0,L1:1>02=0,EN:1>02>0,PGL:1>02=0,PGEN:1>02>0,Green dotted line: parameter suggestion from L-curve criterionBlack dotted line: regularization parameter estimated from Error norms in (i)-(v) Eect of regularization parameter for dierent regularization methodsciivENIIIiiiiiFigure 3. The elastic net (EN) outperforms other reconstruction methods in the presence of noise and when applied to undersampled data. (a) Artificial test data with uniform traction spots and 4% noise in the displacements. Traction maps in (ii-vi) result from different regularization methods: L2-, L1-, EN, PGL and PGEN, respectively. Space bar 5 µm, displacements are sampled on average every 0.5 µm (b) Comparison of errors resulting from undersampled data. Undersampling is realized by reducing the number of displacement vectors m. (c) L-curves with chosen regularization parameters (gray boxes) for a data set containing 2% noise and m/n = 0.4. (d) Comparison of errors for the regularization parameters shown in (c). EN regularization shows a favorable tradeoff between error and background signal. 17/20 L2L1ENPGLaPGEN0biiiiiiArticial tractionMean traction errorBackground error( )Signal to noise ratio( )12[Pix /Pa ]22ivMax. traction error( )( )ivcdiL2iiiiviii[Pix /Pa ]22[Pix /Pa ]22[Pix /Pa ]22ENvL1iiiiiPGL[Pix /Pa]2[Pix /Pa]2[Pix /Pa]2ivPGEN[Pa]2500iiiiiiivvviFigure 4. Bayesian L2 regularization (BL2) and Advanced Bayesian L2 regularization (ABL2) are robust methods for automatic, optimal regularization. (a) Schematic diagram of the procedure employed to infer λ2 in BL2 and ABL2. BL2 requires the variance of the displacement measurements 1/β , which can be obtained by analyzing displacement noise far away from any cell. ABL2 estimates this noise strength directly from the data. (b) Artificial test data. For the shown results, 5% Gaussian noise is added to the displacements. Space bars: 5 µm. (c) For BL2, the optimal regularization parameter is located at the maximum of a one-dimensional plot of the evidence Eq. (8). (d) Reconstruction of traction force using BL2. (e) For ABL2, the optimal regularization parameter is located at the maximum of a two-dimensional plot of the data evidence vs. α and β . (f) Reconstruction of traction force using ABL2. (g,i)-(g,iv) Comparison of reconstruction accuracy for L2, BL2 and AbL2. Different levels of traction forces were applied to change signal-to noise ratio where σn is the standard deviation of the noise and σ¯u is the standard deviation of the noise-free traction field. Note that BL2 outperforms the other methods for high noise levels. 18/20 Articial test traction0250[Pa]b0250[Pa]2, ()2ABL2BL2cegiiiiivReconstruction (BL2)Reconstruction (ABL2)argmin[Mf-u22+2f22[ff=max. evid.measure(from )u obtain2= BL2:ABL2:maximize evidence obtain2= and[Pa /Pix ]22[Pa /Pix ]42[1/Pix ]2iidfFigure 5. Test of all reconstruction methods using experimental data. (a) Image of an adherent podocyte with substrate displacements shown as green vectors. (b)-(h) Reconstructed traction forces using L2, L1, EN, BL2, PGL, PGEN and ABL2, respectively. Reconstruction with L2-type regularization exhibits a comparatively high background noise. L1-regulation shows very high, localized traction. Based on tests with artificial data, we expect that these peaks overestimate the traction. The EN method combines the advantages of L1 and L2 regularization, namely a clean background and localized traction of reasonable magnitude. PGL and PGEN have smooth traction forces at adhesion and background. (g-h) The Bayesian methods BL2 and ABL2 yield very similar results as the standard L2 regularization without requiring a search for the optimal regularization parameters. For better visibility, only every fourth traction vector is shown. Space bar: 25 µm. 19/20 L2PGLPGENL1Cell and gel displacementfcabdeENBL2g2ABL201600[Pa]hm(b, c) L1 regularization(d, e) EN regularization(f, g, h) L2 regularizationFigure 6. Bayesian L2 regularization robustly adapts to different traction levels allowing quantitative analysis of time series. (a) Image of a spontaneously beating heart muscle cell on a micropatterned substrate allowing to measure displacements. (b) Overall norm of traction magitude in successive image frames. The maximum corresponds to one contraction of the heart muscle cell. Traction is calculated with BL2 or, for comparison, via L2 regularization where λ2 is either selected manually for every frame using the L-curve criterion or held constant throughout the image sequence. (c) Optimal regularization parameter suggested by BL2 and the norm displacement field correlate. (d,i)-(d,iii) Cell images with displacement field at frames 1, 4, and 6. (e,i)-(e,iii) Snapshots of the traction fields resulting from L2 regularization with a manually chosen parameter λL-curve and a constant parameter λL-const. in an intermediate range. (f,i)-(f,iii) Snapshots of the traction fields resulting from BL2. Note the different scaling of displacement and tractions for the different frames. Frame 1 (I) illustrates that BL2 yields a smaller traction magnitude than L2 in the presence of large noise, where the L-curve criterion is hard to employ. As a result, BL2 allows to differentiate real traction from noise outside of the cell. For better visibility, only every fourth traction vector is shown. 20/20 Frame=1100 nmL2 regularization2000 nm1000 nmDisplacementsd06[Pa]0120[Pa]060[Pa]20mFrame=4Frame=6BL2efIIIIIIiiiiiibciiiiiiiiiiiia20mCellroi for (b)-(f)[Pa /Pix ]22
1606.02191	2	1606	2016-11-28T11:00:20	Run-and-pause dynamics of cytoskeletal motor proteins	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.SC" ]	Cytoskeletal motor proteins are involved in major intracellular transport processes which are vital for maintaining appropriate cellular function. The motor exhibits distinct states of motility: active motion along filaments, and effectively stationary phase in which it detaches from the filaments and performs passive diffusion in the vicinity of the detachment point due to cytoplasmic crowding. The transition rates between motion and pause phases are asymmetric in general, and considerably affected by changes in environmental conditions which influences the efficiency of cargo delivery to specific targets. By considering the motion of molecular motor on a single filament as well as a dynamic filamentous network, we present an analytical model for the dynamics of self-propelled particles which undergo frequent pause phases. The interplay between motor processivity, structural properties of filamentous network, and transition rates between the two states of motility drastically changes the dynamics: multiple transitions between different types of anomalous diffusive dynamics occur and the crossover time to the asymptotic diffusive or ballistic motion varies by several orders of magnitude. We map out the phase diagrams in the space of transition rates, and address the role of initial conditions of motion on the resulting dynamics.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Run-and-tumble dynamics of cytoskeletal motor proteins Anne E. Hafner1,∗, Ludger Santen1, Heiko Rieger1, M. Reza Shaebani1,∗,† 1 Department of Theoretical Physics, Saarland University, 66041 Saarbrücken, Germany ∗ These authors contributed equally to this work. † Corresponding author. [email protected] Cytoskeletal motor proteins are involved in major intracellular transport processes which are vi- tal for maintaining appropriate cellular function. The motor exhibits distinct states of motility: active motion along filaments, and effectively stationary phase in which it detaches from the fila- ments and performs passive diffusion in the vicinity of the detachment point due to cytoplasmic crowding. The transition rates between motion and pause phases are asymmetric in general, and considerably affected by changes in environmental conditions which influences the efficiency of cargo delivery to specific targets. By considering the motion of molecular motor on a single fila- ment as well as a dynamic filamentous network, we present an analytical model for the dynam- ics of self-propelled particles which undergo frequent pause phases. The interplay between motor processivity, structural properties of filamentous network, and transition rates between the two states of motility drastically changes the dynamics: multiple transitions between different types of anomalous diffusive dynamics occur and the crossover time to the asymptotic diffusive or ballis- tic motion varies by several orders of magnitude. We map out the phase diagrams in the space of transition rates, and address the role of initial conditions of motion on the resulting dynamics. The cellular cytoskeleton is a highly dynamic and complex network of cross-linked biopolymers, which carries out essential functions in cells such as serving as tracks for motor proteins and adjusting the shape and spatial organization of the cell. The cytoskeleton enables the cell to efficiently adapt to changes in the environment. Microtubules (MTs) and actin filaments constitute the dynamic tracks for intracellular transport driven by molecular motors1,2. The cytoskeletal filaments are polar due to their structural asymmetry, with different spatial organizations. While the orientations of actin filaments are rather randomly distributed, MTs are usually growing outwards from a microtubule organizing center with their plus ends facing the cell periphery. MTs often span long distances, of the order of the cell diameter, whereas the mesh size of the actin cortex is of the order of 100 nm3. Three different families of motor proteins are involved in the active intracellular transport of organelles and other cargoes: kinesins, dyneins, and myosins. Molecular motors of each family always move on a specific type of track in a particular direction4; while kinesins and dyneins usually move along MTs towards the plus and minus ends, respectively, different types of myosins move on actin filaments towards the plus or minus directions. Motors can attach to the filaments, perform a number of steps, and detach. Such binding/unbinding cycles are frequently repeated during the motion of motors along the cytoskeleton. The tendency of the motor to continue its motion along the filament, called motor processivity, varies with the type of filament and motor5,6, and is highly sensitive to the environmental conditions such as the presence of specific binding domains or proteins7–9. Active transport on filaments makes the long-distance cargo delivery to specific targets in cells feasible, whereas the detached phases are extremely inefficient since the cytoplasm is a highly crowded environment which slows down the transfer of materials10,11. The combination of active and passive motions has been however shown to be beneficial for optimizing the first-passage properties12. The motion of molecular motors involves a high degree of complexity due to the dynamics of cytoskeletal filaments, binding/unbinding cycles of motion, motor-motor interactions, variations of environmental conditions, etc. The dynamics of cargoes is even more complicated, as they can be transported by teams of motors moving in different directions13. The analytical studies of the dynamics of molecular motors are often made by adopting simplified schemes, e.g. by ignoring the chemomechanical cycles and other mechanistic details of stepping. Stochastic two-state models of motion, consisting of altering phases of active and passive dynamics, have been widely employed to describe the motion of cytoskeletal motor proteins14,15 and swimming bacteria16–19, and locomotive patterns in other biological systems10,11,20,21. The transition probabilities between the two states are generally asymmetric and influence the efficiency of cargo delivery18. Interestingly, bacteria are capable of adjusting the balance between their running and tumbling states in response to the changes in environmental conditions. For example, it has been recently observed that viscoelasticity of the medium suppresses the tumbling phase and enhances the swimming speed of E. coli22. Here, we adopt a coarse-grained approach to study the dynamics of molecular motors on cytoskeleton, which enables us to identify the impact of motor processivity, structural properties of the filamentous network, and switching frequencies between the two phases of motion on the transport properties of motors. To isolate the influence of switching frequencies, we first consider the motion along a single filament and present a random walk model with two states of motility: active motion along the filament and pausing periods. The latter state emerges due to unbinding from the filament, or due to waiting periods induced by the presence of obstacles or transport of other motors on the same filament. If unbound from the filament, the motor practically experiences a subdiffusive dynamics in the crowded cytoplasm and spreads extremely slowly, thus, it cannot reach far distances and its net displacement is negligible compared to the active motion phase23. The duration of stay in the pause phase however has a crucial influence on the overall transport dynamics. Hence, we consider the pauses as a waiting phase when the particle effectively remains stationary along the cytoskeleton until it continues its active motion again. We focus on the single particle dynamics in this study. Investigation of the motion of a group of motors is more complicated as, for example, persistent motion in the presence of volume-excluded interactions between the particles leads to jammed regions or even jamming transition with increasing the particle density19,24–26. The effects of transition probabilities and volume exclusion on the density and traffic of motors along the filament was recently studied14. We moreover assume that the transitions between the states of motion occur spontaneously and with asymmetric rates. Assuming constant transition probabilities in our model results in exponential distributions for the residence times in each state, which is in agreement with the experimental findings for the distribution of active lifetimes of micron-sized beads moving along cytoskeleton27. We derive exact analytical expressions for the temporal evolution of the moments of displacement and show that depending on the transition probabilities between the two states, the motor can experience crossovers between different anomalous diffusive dynamics on different time scales. In the second part of this work we study the motion of motor proteins on dynamic cytoskeletal filaments to disentangle the combined effects of binding/unbinding transition rates, processivity, and structural properties of the underlying network on transport dynamics. We introduce a coarse-grained perspective to the problem and consider the motion of motors at the level of traveling between network junctions rather than individual steps along filaments. Since the distribution of direc- tional change contains rich information about the particle dynamics23,28,29, we characterize the structure of the filamentous network by probability distributions R(φ) for the angle φ between intersecting filaments, and F (ℓ) for the segment length ℓ between neighboring intersections. The model consists of two states of motility: active motion and waiting at the junc- tions. Such waiting periods at junctions have been experimentally observed for transport along cytoskeletal networks6,30,31. For example, tracking the motion of lysosomes on MT networks has revealed that the particles experience even long pauses at the nodes of the network before that they can either pass through it or switch to the intersecting filament31. In the mo- tion state, the motor either moves processively along the previous filament or switches to a new one. The cytoskeleton is a dynamic network due to the underlying growth and shrinkage of filaments. The dynamics even varies depending on the cell type and region32. Thus, the transport takes place on a continuously changing structure, which justifies the relevance of our stochastic approach as the network structure is implicitly given via the probability distributions. Within the proposed analytical framework, we prove the existence of different regimes of anomalous motion and that the motor may experience several crossovers between these regimes, as observed in various experiments of motion on cytoskeletal filaments33–37. It is also shown that the crossover times between different regimes and the asymptotic diffusion coefficient can vary widely depending on the key parameters of the model: processivity, network structure, and transition rates. We address the role of initial conditions of motion on the resulting dynamics38, and validate the theoretical predictions by performing extensive Monte Carlo simulations. The proposed analytical approach and the results are also applicable to other run-and-tumble motions in biological as well as nonliving systems. Results Motion along a single filament We first consider the motion of a molecular motor on a single filament in a crowded environment. For spontaneously switching motors, the stochastic motion can be described by two states of motility: (i) ballistic motion along the filament, and (ii) waiting phase, where the motor remains stationary for a while or unbinds from the filament and performs passive diffusion until the next binding event happens. When the motor attaches again to the filament, it continues its unidirec- tional motion. The transition probabilities between the two states of motion are not necessarily symmetric in general, thus, we consider asymmetric constant transition probabilities κm and κw for the transition from waiting to motion state and vice versa, respectively [see Fig. 1(A)]. At each time step, the particle either waits or performs a step of length ℓ taken from a probability distribution F (ℓ). We introduce the probability densities P M n (x) to find the walker at position x at time step n in the motion and waiting states, respectively. The temporal evolution of the process can be described by the following set of coupled master equations n (x) and P W P M n+1(x) =Zdℓ F (ℓ)κm P W n (x−ℓ)+(1 − κw )P M n (x−ℓ), P W n+1(x) = κw P M n (x)+(1−κm)P W n (x). (1)    We develop a Fourier-z-transform approach39–41, which enables us to obtain exact analytical expressions for the arbitrary moments of displacement. The details of the theoretical approach can be found in the Suppl. Info., where as an example, the lengthy expression for the mean squared displacement (MSD) is obtained. It can be seen from Eq.(S17) that, in addition to the transition probabilities, the results also depend on the initial conditions of motion. In derivation of Eq.(S17), denoting the probability of initially starting in the motion state by P M 0 , the following initial conditions are imposed P M n=0(x) = P M 0 δ(x), n=0(x) = (1 − P M P W 0 ) δ(x), (2) 2 (B) 108 w m 1 0 0.9 0.1 0.9 0.9 0.1 0.01 0.001 0.001 allistic b f u s i v e f d i 1 10 102 103 104 105 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 4 10 3 10 c 2 10 10 (A) (C) 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 1 106 4 10 2 10 1 (D) ballistic diffusive w m 1 0 0.9 0.1 0.9 0.9 0.1 1 1 1 0.01 1 0.001 1 0.001 10 102 103 104 105 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 FIG. 1 Motion on a single filament. (A) A schematic of the transition probabilities between waiting and motion states of a motor protein on a single cytoskeletal filament, as described by the set of master equations (1). (B) MSD as a function of the step number n for λ=1, P M 0 =1, and several values of κm and κw. The solid lines are obtained from the analytic expression (S17) and the symbols represent Monte Carlo simulation results. (C) Temporal evolution of the anomalous exponent α via Eq. (5), for the same parameters as in panel (B). (D) The crossover time nc to the asymptotic ballistic motion for λ=1 and P M 0 =1 in the (κw, κm) phase space. n=0(x)+P W which results in Pn=0(x)=P M n=0(x)=δ(x). The analytical results for the time evolution of MSD are shown in Fig. 1(B) for different values of κm and κw parameters. Several crossovers on different time scales can be observed, even though the asymptotic behavior is ballistic in all cases as expected from the unidirectional motion of the motor along the filament. In order to determine the crossovers more quantitatively, we fit the time dependence of the MSD to a power-law 〈x 2〉∼t α, with α being the anomalous exponent. For instance, the following expression can be deduced for the initial anomalous exponent by fitting the first two steps of motion α⋆ = ln2 − 2(κw −1) λ − κw + κm − 1+ 1 0 (−1+κm+κw) ln[2], κm−P M (3) with λ=〈ℓ2〉/〈ℓ〉2 being the variance of the step-length distribution. Assuming a constant step length for simplicity (i.e. λ=1), if the walker remains in the motion phase forever (i.e. κw =0 and κm=1) one gets α⋆=2 as expected for a ballistic motion. When starting from the motion state, one has P W n=0(x)=δ(x), and the initial slope follows n=0(x)=0 and P M α⋆ = ln4 − 3κw − κm + κm 1 − κw ln[2]. (4) By applying the fit to successive time steps n and n+1, the anomalous exponent as a function of time can be obtained as α(n) = ln 〈r 2〉n+1 〈r 2〉n ln n + 1 n . (5) Figure 1(C) shows the time evolution of the exponent for a motor starting from the motion state. Depending on the choice of κm and κw rates, the motor may undergo transitions between different regimes of anomalous diffusive dynamics, e.g. from super- to subdiffusion and then to asymptotic ballistic motion. The crossovers happen on different time scales, controlled by the transition rates. With increasing κw , the chance of switching to the waiting state grows which, on average, reduces the initial exponent. On the other hand, smaller values of κm postpone the crossover to the long-term ballistic 3 regime. The combination of these effects may cause up to two crossovers for P M extrema of α(n) (i.e. if dα/dn=0), or when asymptotically approaching the ballistic regime ( dα dn 0 =1. We identify a crossover from the −−→ n→∞ 0). In the limit of n→∞ the terms proportional to n2 dominate and the motility becomes purely ballistic. The asymptotic MSD is given by 〈x 2〉n→∞ ≈ κ2 m(κm+1)2 (κm+κw )4 〈ℓ〉2 n2. (6) The prefactor depends on the switching rates. If the walker never switches to the waiting state, one recovers the relation 〈x 2〉=〈ℓ〉2n2 which is the fastest possible propagation. The crossover to the long-term ballistic regime is approached asymptotically. We use the distance from the exponent of ballistic motion, i.e. δα = α(n)−2, and estimate the crossover time as the time step nc at which δα drops below a threshold value ε. Here we report the results for ε=10−2, however, we checked that the choice of ε does not affect our conclusions. As it can be seen from Fig. 1(D), nc varies by several orders of magnitude in the (κw , κm) plane. It is expected that nc increases with decreasing κm, as the chance of switching to the motion state is reduced. The increase of nc at large values of both rates κm and κw is due to frequent state oscillations which postpone the transition to asymptotic ballistic regime to longer times. Motion on a dynamic filamentous network The theoretical framework can be generalized to describe active motion of particles on filamentous networks. We adopt a coarse-grained approach in which the motion of motor proteins is modeled as a persistent random walk on the intersections of cytoskeletal filaments. The structure of the network is characterized by the probability distributions R(φ) for the angle φ between intersecting filaments, and F (ℓ) for the segment length ℓ between neighboring intersections. Furthermore, a parameter p is introduced to take the processivity of molecular motors into account. The particle either waits at each time step (waiting state) or walks with a step length ℓ (motion state). In the latter state, the motor either continues along the previous filament with probability p or chooses a new filament with probability 1−p. Similar to motion on a single filament, the transition probabilities κm and κw between the two states are assumed to be asymmetric and constant. The parameter κm (κw ) denotes the switching probability from waiting to motion (motion to waiting) state. The probability density functions P M n (x, yθ ) denote the probability to find the walker at position (x, y) along the direction θ at time step n in the motion and waiting states, respectively. Here a 2D system is considered for simplicity. For extension of the approach to 3D see28. The evolution of the process is described by the following set of coupled master equations n (x, yθ ) and P W P M n+1(x, yθ ) = pZ dℓ F (ℓ)κm P W n x ′, y ′(cid:12)(cid:12)θ+(1−κw ) P M n x ′, y ′(cid:12)(cid:12)θ+(1−p)Z dℓ F (ℓ)Z π −π dγ R(φ)κm P W n x ′, y ′(cid:12)(cid:12)γ+(1−κw) P M n x ′, y ′(cid:12)(cid:12)γ,    P W n+1(x, yθ ) = κw P M n (x, yθ )+(1−κm)P W n (x, yθ ). Assuming isotropic initial conditions P M 0 (x, yθ ) = P W 0 (x, yθ ) = 1 2π 1 2π δ(x)δ( y) P M 0 , δ(x)δ( y) (1 − P M 0 ), (7) (8) 2π 0 (x, yθ ) = 1 0 (x, yθ ) + P W which leads to P0(x, yθ ) = P M δ(x)δ( y), one can follow the proposed Fourier-z-transform formalism and calculate arbitrary moments of displacement. The exact analytical expression for the MSD, which is the main quantity of interest, is given in Eq.(S45). The interplay between transition probabilities, motor processivity, initial conditions of motion, and structure of the underlying network lead to a variety of anomalous transport dynamics on different time scales. The structure of the network is characterized by the relative variance of F (ℓ) (i.e. λ=〈ℓ2〉/〈ℓ〉2) and the Fourier transform R of R(φ), which quantify the heterogeneity and anisotropy of the environment, respectively. R ranges from −1 to 1, with R=0 for a completely random structure, and positive (negative) values for an increased probability for motion in the near forward (backward) directions. The processivity p and anisotropy R parameters always appear combined as A = p + R − pR in the solution; thus, by varying A one can separately study the effects of p or R on the transport of motors. We first choose A=0 in Fig. 2, corresponding to a non-processive motion (p=0) on an isotropic structure such as actin filament networks (R=0), and then study positive values A=0.5 and A=0.99 in Fig. 3. These latter choices can e.g. correspond to either a non-processive motion (p=0) on aligned filaments (R>0) such as radially organized MT networks, or an active motion (p>0) on an isotropic actin network (R=0). As the phase space of the system is entangled, we restrict ourselves to initially starting from the motion state (P M 0 =1) in this section, and elaborate on the role of initial conditions in the discussion section. A wide range of different types of anomalous motion can be observed on varying the transition rates κw and κm. The possible crossovers at short and 4 (C) κm 1 κw 0 0.9 0.1 0.9 0.9 0.1 0.01 0.001 0.001 allistic b f u s i v e f d i 10 102 103 104 105 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 1 ballistic diffusive κm 1 κw 0 0.9 0.1 0.9 0.9 0.1 1 1 1 0.01 1 0.001 1 0.001 10 102 103 104 105 y/(y+x) 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 (F) 100 = 6 = 2 = 1 10 1 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 A (A) (D) 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 (B) 108 106 104 102 1 1 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 (E) 104 103 102 10 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 FIG. 2 Non-processive motion on random actin networks. (A) Schematic of the path on a cytoskeletal network during two consecutive steps of motion, as described by the coupled set of master equations (7). (B) MSD as a function of the step number n for λ=1, P M 0 =1, A=0, and several values of κm and κw. The solid lines correspond to the analytical expression (S45) and the symbols represent the simulation results. (C) Temporal evolution of the anomalous exponent α via Eq. (5), for the same parameters as in panel (B). (D,E) Phase diagrams of (D) the crossover time nc to the asymptotic diffusive regime, and (E) the long-term diffusion constant D∞, scaled by 1 vs A for several 4 values of λ. 0 =1 in the (κw, κm) plane. (F) The scale parameter Γ = A(λ−2)−λ v〈ℓ〉Γ , via Eq. (12) for A=0, λ=1, and P M A−1 (A) (B) (C) 108 106 104 2 10 1 1 (D) 108 6 10 4 10 2 10 1 1 w m 1 0 0.9 0.1 0.9 0.9 0.1 0.01 0.001 0.001 allistic b f u s i v e f d i 10 102 103 104 105 (E) allistic b f u s i v e f d i 10 102 10 3 104 105 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 1 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 1 ballistic diffusive w m 1 0 0.9 0.1 0.9 0.9 0.1 1 .1 1 0.01 1 0.001 1 0.001 10 102 103 104 105 (F) ballistic diffusive 10 10 2 103 104 105 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 4 10 3 10 102 10 5 10 4 10 FIG. 3 Motion on microtubule networks / Processive motion. In the upper (lower) panels, the results for A=0.5 (A=0.99) are shown, which correspond to non-processive motion on moderately (highly) aligned filaments or, alternatively, active motion with moderate (high) processivity on isotropic networks. (A,D) MSD in terms of the step number n for λ=1, P M 0 =1, and several values of κm and κw. The solid lines (symbols) correspond to analytical results via Eq.(S45) (simulation results). (B,E) Time evolution of the anomalous exponent α for the same parameter values as in panels (A,D). (C,F) Crossover time nc to the asymptotic diffusive dynamics in the case of λ=1 and P M 0 =1 in the (κw, κm) phase space. 5 intermediate time scales are even more diverse than those observed for the motion on a single filament. A similar approach as in the previous section is followed to obtain the time evolution of the anomalous exponent and identify the crossovers. The long term dynamics is diffusive in all cases as the directional memory is short ranged and the walker eventually gets randomized on the network. However, we note that the asymptotic diffusive motion might be observable only on time and length scales which are not accessible in experiments. By fitting to the power-law 〈x 2〉∼t α, the initial anomalous exponent is obtained as α⋆ = ln2 − 2(p+R−p R)(κw−1) λ − κw + κm − 1+ which in the case of κw =0 and κm=1 reduces to 1 0 (−1+κm+κw ) ln[2], κm−P M α⋆ = 1 + ln1 + p+R−p R λ ln[2]. (9) (10) For example, one gets α⋆=1 for non-processive motion on random actin networks in the absence of waiting phases, which is expected to be diffusive on all time scales. From Eq. (9) one can also see the impact of the initial conditions of motion and heterogeneity of the network on the exponent. In the long-time limit, the terms linear in n dominate, thus, the motility becomes purely diffusive. From Eq.(S45), the MSD in the limit of n→∞ is given by from which the asymptotic diffusion constant can be determined as 〈r 2〉n→∞ ≈ κm A(λ − 2) − λ κm + κw A − 1 〈ℓ〉2 n, D∞ = 1 4 v〈ℓ〉 κm A(λ − 2) − λ κm + κw A − 1 = 1 4 v〈ℓ〉Γ κm κm + κw , (11) (12) A−1 with Γ = A(λ−2)−λ and v being the average motor velocity. Figure 2(E) shows how D∞ varies in the space of transition probabilities. While decreasing κw or increasing κm enhances the diffusion coefficient, changing the rates in the opposite direction leads to a strong localization. Taking the dependence of Γ on the heterogeneity parameter λ into account [see Fig. 2(F)], it can be seen that D∞ varies by several orders of magnitude by varying the key parameters of the problem. Interestingly, the long-term diffusion constant does not depend on the initial conditions. To estimate the transition time nc to asymptotic diffusive regime, we follow the convergence of the anomalous exponent towards 1, and determine nc as the earliest time step at which the exponent difference drops below a threshold ε, i.e. α(n) − 1 < ε. (13) The results shown in Figs. 2(D), 3(C), and 3(F), reported for ε=10−2, reveal that nc varies over several orders of magnitude. On an actin filament network with an average mesh size 〈ℓ〉∼100nm and a typical motor velocity v∼1µm/s, nc ranges from 0.1 seconds to more than 100 seconds, which might be beyond the possible time window of experiments, thus, all different regimes of motion are not necessarily realized in practice. Discussion In the previous sections we showed that the transport dynamics of molecular motors depend on the initial conditions of motion. This can be more clearly seen in Figs. 4(A,D), where the MSD for the motion along a single filament is plotted for a given set of κw and κm parameters and for different probabilities P M 0 of initially starting in the motion state (see also Figs. 4(B,E) for the influence of initial conditions on the anomalous exponent α). Indeed, the probabilities of finding the walker in each of the two states of motility at time n, i.e. P M n , are controlled by the transition rates κw and κm at long times. Thus, the influence of initial conditions gradually weakens as P M n converge towards their stationary values. The sequence of motion and waiting states can be considered as a discrete time Markov chain with transition probabilities κm and κw . Denoting the initial probabilities by P M 0 , it can be verified that the time evolution of these probabilities follows n and P W n and P W n =1−P M 0 and P W 0 =1−P M P M n = P W n = κm κm + κw κw κm + κw κm + κw + 1 − κm − κwn − 1 − κm − κwn κm + κw κw P M κw P M 0 − κm(1 − P M 0 − κm(1 − P M 0 ) , 0 ) . (14) 6 (B) (A) 108 106 104 102 1 10-2 a lli s ti c b M P0 1 1 .1 0.5 1 0.1 1 0.01 1 0 ballistic diffusive (C) 1 0.8 M Pn 0.6 W Pn 0.4 0.2 0 P M PW M P0 1 1 .5 0.5 .1 0.1 0.01 1 0 0 10 102 103 104 105 1 10 102 103 104 105 3 2 .5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 1 1 10 2 10 3 10 4 10 5 10 (D) 108 106 4 10 102 1 10-2 a lli s ti c b (E) 3 2.5 ballistic 2 diffusive 1.5 1 0.5 (F) 1 0.8 M Pn 0.6 W Pn 0.4 0.2 0 PW P M 1 10 102 103 104 5 10 0 1 10 102 103 104 105 1 10 102 103 104 105 FIG. 4 Influence of initial conditions. The dynamics on a single filament in the absence of waiting (κw =0, upper panels) and for weak switching rates to waiting state (κw=0.1, lower panels) are compared. (A,D) MSD as a function of the step number n for κm=0.001, λ=1, and different probabilities P M 0 of initially starting in the motion state. (B,E) Temporal evolution of the anomalous exponent α(n) for the same set of parameters as in panels (A,D). (C,F) Evolution of the Markov chain probabilities P M n (red lines) and P W n (blue lines), via Eqs. (14). The stationary probabilities are given by Eqs. (15). The probabilities eventually converges to the stationary values P M ∞ = P W ∞ = κm (κm+κw ) κw (κm+κw ) , , (15) thus, if the process is initially started with these probabilities, the system is already equilibrated. Otherwise, the dynamics at short times is influenced by the choice of initial conditions of motion until the system relaxes towards stationary state, as shown in Figs. 4(C,F). By varying the probability P M 0 of initially starting in the motion state, we find regimes with an anomalous exponent greater than 2 in Figs. 4(B,E). To understand the origin of this peculiar behavior we note that the presented MSD is indeed an ensemble averaged quantity. When starting from the initial probability P M 0 which is smaller (larger) than the equilibrated value P M ∞ , an acceleration (deceleration) due to the injection of more (less) particles from the waiting to the motion state occurs. This is especially more obvious for the case of motion along a single filament with P M 0 =κw =0. In this case, 10 10 8 10 6 10 4 10 2 10 1 -2 10 -4 10 1 10 2 10 103 4 10 5 10 FIG. 5 MSD for the motion on a single fila- ment, starting from the initial condition P M 0 =0 and without any switching from the waiting to motion state, i.e. κw=0. The results are shown for λ=1 and several values of κm. 7 all particle are in the waiting state initially, and no transition to the waiting state happens during the process, thus, all particles switch to the motion state gradually according to the transition probability κm. By injection of more particles into the ballistic motion state, the exponents greater than 2 appear, as shown in Fig. 5 (see also the supplementary figure S1). The exponent converges to 2 as the system approaches the stationary state. Figure 5 shows that the initial slope of the ensemble averaged MSD is nearly 3 for this set of the parameter values, which can be explained as follows. Because of the constant transition probabilities, the residence time in the waiting state is exponentially distributed. The particles of the ensemble, which are all in the waiting phase initially, switch to motion at exponentially distributed times t0, i.e. p(t0)=κme−κm t0 . As soon as a particle switches the state, it performs a ballistic motion with velocity v, thus and we obtain the ensemble averaged MSD by integration over all possible transition times until time t r(t) =0, v(cid:12)(cid:12)t − t0(cid:12)(cid:12) , t < t0 t ¾ t0 (16) (17) 〈r 2(t)〉 =Z t 0 dt0 p(t0)v2(cid:12)(cid:12)t − t0(cid:12)(cid:12) m 1 3 2 = v2 κ2 m 2 − 2κm t + κ2 m t 2 − 2e−κm t . By Taylor expansion around t=0, one finds 〈r 2(t)〉 ≃ v2 κ2 is nearly 3. A similar procedure can be applied to obtain the initial exponents for other sets of parameter values, as those shown in Figs. 4(B,E). m t 3 + . . ., which verifies that the initial anomalous exponent κ3 In summary, we developed a general analytical framework to study the dynamics of molecular motors on cytoskeleton, which enabled us to identify the influence of filament network structure, binding/unbinding rates, and motor processivity on the transport properties of motors. The flexibility of our coarse-grained formalism allowed us to consider different filamentous structures, from a single filament to a complex network of biopolymers characterized by its structural het- erogeneity and anisotropy. We obtained exact analytical expressions for the arbitrary moments of displacement, and verified that the motors display a wide range of different types of motion due to the interplay between motor processivity, structural properties of filamentous network, and transition rates between the two states of motility. One observes that multiple crossovers occur between different types of anomalous transport at short and intermediate timescales, and that the crossover time to the asymptotic diffusive or ballistic motion varies by several orders of magnitude. We also addressed how the initial conditions of motion affect the resulting dynamics. In the analysis presented in this work, the transitions between the two states of motion were assumed to be spontaneous, thus, the motion of motors was described by a Markovian process. However, switching between the states might be not necessarily spontaneous, and the process can be non-Markovian in general, e.g. if the residence time in a state affects its switching probability to the other state. These generalizations can be handled within our proposed analytical framework enabling to deal with different types of environments. The analytical formalism is also applicable to study similar dynamics in other biological as well as nonliving systems, such as the run-and-tumble motion of bacteria in biological media. It is worthwhile to mention that the motility in the passive state may not be negligible in general. The dynamics in such a case can be described by altering states of motion with different velocities and run times. Methods We develop an analytical Fourier-z-transform formalism to describe the persistent motion of motor proteins along cy- toskeletal filaments with stochastic pausing periods. A random walk in discrete time and continuous space with two states of motility is introduced. The walker either performs a persistent motion on filaments or waits when faces obstacles or tumbles in the crowded cytoplasm. By introducing the probability density functions P M n (x, yθ ) for the probability to find the walker at position (x, y) along the direction θ at time step n in the motion or waiting states, the temporal evolution of the process can be described by a set of coupled master equations, where the transitions from motion to waiting state and vice versa (denoted by κw and κm, respectively) are assumed to be asymmetric and constant. Then, arbitrary moments of displacement can be calculated by applying Fourier and z transforms on the set of master equations. Finally, the quantities of interest can be obtained in the real space and time by means of inverse transforms. A detailed description of the analytical approach can be found in Suppl Info. n (x, yθ ) and P W References 1. Chowdhury, D. Stochastic mechano-chemical kinetics of molecular motors: A multidisciplinary enterprise from a physicist's perspective. Phys. Rep. 529, 1-197 (2013). 2. Appert-Rolland, C., Ebbinghaus, M. & Santen L. Intracellular transport driven by cytoskeletal motors: General mechanisms and defects. Phys. Rep. 593, 1-59 (2015). 3. Morone, N. et al. Three-dimensional reconstruction of the membrane skeleton at the plasma membrane interface by electron tomography. J. Cell Biol. 174, 851-862 (2016). 4. Schliwa, M. & Woehlke, G. Molecular motors. Nature 422, 759-765 (2003). 5. Shiroguchi, K. & Kinosita, K. Myosin V walks by lever action and Brownian motion. Science 316, 1208-1212 (2007). 6. Ali, M. Y. et al. Myosin Va maneuvers through actin intersections and diffuses along microtubules. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 104, 4332-4336 (2007). 8 7. Okada, Y., Higuchi, H. & Hirokawa, N. Processivity of the single-headed kinesin KIF1A through biased binding to tubulin. Nature 424, 574-577 (2003). 8. Culver-Hanlon, T. L., Lex, S. A., Stephens, A. D., Quintyne, N. J. & King, S. J. A microtubule-binding domain in dynactin increases dynein processivity by skating along microtubules. Nat. Cell Biol. 8, 264-270 (2006). 9. Vershinin, M., Carter, B. C., Razafsky, D. S., King, S. J. & Gross, S. P. Multiple-motor based transport and its regulation by Tau. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 104, 87-92 (2007). 10. Höfling, F. & Franosch, T. Anomalous transport in the crowded world of biological cells. Rep. Prog. Phys. 76, 046602 (2013). 11. Bressloff, P. C. & Newby, J. M. Stochastic models of intracellular transport. Rev. Mod. Phys. 85, 135-196 (2013). 12. Benichou, O., Loverdo, C., Moreau, M. & Voituriez, R. Intermittent search strategies. Rev. Mod. Phys. 83, 81-129 (2011). 13. Hancock, W. O. Bidirectional cargo transport: moving beyond tug of war. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 15, 615-628 (2014). 14. Pinkoviezky, I. & Gov, N. S. Transport dynamics of molecular motors that switch between an active and inactive state. Phys. Rev. E 88, 022714 (2013). 15. Thiel, F., Schimansky-Geier, L. & Sokolov, I. M. Anomalous diffusion in run-and-tumble motion. Phys. Rev.E 86, 021117 (2012). 16. Elgeti, J. & Gompper, G. Run-and-tumble dynamics of self-propelled particles in confinement. EPL 109, 58003 (2015). 17. Theves, M., Taktikos, J., Zaburdaev, V., Stark, H. & Beta, C. A bacterial swimmer with two alternating speeds of propagation. Biophys. J. 105, 1915-1924 (2013). 18. Taktikos, J., Stark, H. & Zaburdaev, V. How the motility pattern of bacteria affects their dispersal and chemotaxis. PLoS ONE 8, e81936 (2013). 19. Soto, R. & Golestanian R. Run-and-tumble exclusion process environment: persistent for swimmers. dynamics in a crowded Phys. Rev. E 89, 012706 (2014). 20. Shaebani, M. R., Hafner, A. E. & Santen, L. Geometrical considerations for anomalous transport in complex neuronal dendrites. submitted (2016). 21. Angelani, L. Averaged run-and-tumble walks. EPL 102, 20004 (2013). 22. Patteson, A. E., Gopinath, A., Goulian, M. & Arratia, P. E. Running and tumbling with E. coli in polymeric solutions. Sci. Rep. 5, 15761 (2015). 23. Shaebani, M. R., Sadjadi, Z., Sokolov, I. M., Rieger, H. & Santen L. Anomalous diffusion of self-propelled particles in directed random environments. Phys. Rev. E 90, 030701(R) (2014). 24. Fily, Y. & Marchetti, M. C. Athermal phase separation of self-propelled particles with no alignment. Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 235702 (2012). 25. Bialké, J., Löwen, H. & Speck T. Microscopic theory for the phase separation of self-propelled repulsive disks. EPL 103, 30008 (2013). 26. Peruani, F., Deutsch, A. & Bar, M. Nonequilibrium clustering of self-propelled rods. Phys. Rev. E 74, 030904 (2006). 27. Arcizet, D., Meier, B., Sackmann, E., Rädler, J.O. & Heinrich, D. Temporal analysis of active and passive transport in living cells. Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 248103 (2008). 28. Sadjadi, Z., Shaebani, M. R., Rieger, H. & Santen L. Persistent-random-walk approach to anomalous transport of self-propelled particles. Phys. Rev. E 91, 062715 (2015). 29. Burov, S. et al. Distribution of directional change as a signature of complex dynamics. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 110, 19689-19694 (2013). 30. Ross, J. L., Ali, M. Y. & Warshaw, D. M. Cargo transport: molecular motors navigate a complex cytoskeleton. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 20, 41-47 (2008). 31. Balint, S., Vilanova, I. V., Alvarez, A. S. & Lakadamyali, M. Correlative live-cell and superresolution microscopy reveals cargo transport dynamics at microtubule intersections. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 110, 3375-3380 (2013). 32. Shaebani, M. R., Pasula, A., Ott, A. & Santen, L. Tracking of plus-ends reveals microtubule functional diversity in different cell types. submitted (2016). 33. Kulic, I. M. et al. The role of microtubule movement in bidirectional organelle transport. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 105, 10011-10016 (2008). 34. Caspi, A., Granek, R. & Elbaum, M. Enhanced diffusion in active intracellular transport. Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 5655-5658 (2000). 35. Caspi, A., Granek, R. & Elbaum, M. Diffusion and directed motion in cellular transport. Phys. Rev. E 66, 011916 (2002). 36. Bruno, L., Levi, V., Brunstein, M. & Desposito, M. A. Transition to superdiffusive behavior in intracellular actin-based transport mediated by molecular motors. Phys. Rev. E 80, 011912 (2009). 37. Salman, H., Gil, Y., Granek, R. & Elbaum, M. Microtubules, motor proteins, and anomalous mean squared displacements. Chem. Phys. 284, 389-397 (2002). 38. Saxton, M. J. Anomalous diffusion due to binding: a Monte Carlo study. Biophys. J. 70, 1250-1262 (1996). 39. Sadjadi, Z., Miri, M. F., Shaebani, M. R. & Nakhaee, S. Diffusive transport of light in a two-dimensional disordered packing of disks: Analytical approach to transport mean free path. Phys. Rev. E 78, 031121 (2008). 40. Sadjadi, Z. & Miri, M. F. Diffusive transport of light in two-dimensional granular materials. Phys. Rev. E 84, 051305 (2011). 41. Miri, M. F. & Stark, H.Modelling light transport in dry foams by a coarse-grained persistent random walk. J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 38, 3743-3749 (2005). Acknowledgments This work was funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) through Collaborative Research Center SFB 1027 (Projects A3 and A7). 9
1011.3470	1	1011	2010-11-15T18:24:03	Optical tweezer for probing erythrocyte membrane deformability	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft" ]	We report that the average rotation speed of optically trapped crenated erythrocytes is direct signature of their membrane deformability. When placed in hypertonic buffer, discocytic erythrocytes are subjected to crenation. The deformation of cells brings in chirality and asymmetry in shape that make them rotate under the scattering force of a linearly polarized optical trap. A change in the deformability of the erythrocytes, due to any internal or environmental factor, affects the rotation speed of the trapped crenated cells. Here we show how the increment in erythrocyte membrane rigidity with adsorption of $Ca^{++}$ ions can be exhibited through this approach.	physics.bio-ph	physics	APS/123-QED Optical tweezer for probing erythrocyte membrane deformability Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore - 560012, India∗ Manas Khan, Harsh Soni and A.K. Sood1 (Dated: September 20, 2018) We report that the average rotation speed of optically trapped crenated erythrocytes is direct sig- nature of their membrane deformability. When placed in hypertonic buffer, discocytic erythrocytes are subjected to crenation. The deformation of cells brings in chirality and asymmetry in shape that make them rotate under the scattering force of a linearly polarized optical trap. A change in the deformability of the erythrocytes, due to any internal or environmental factor, affects the rotation speed of the trapped crenated cells. Here we show how the increment in erythrocyte membrane rigidity with adsorption of Ca++ ions can be exhibited through this approach. PACS numbers: In mammals, erythrocytes (red blood cells, (RBCs)) play a very critical role in transportation of oxygen and nutrition via microcirculation. In this process they are pumped through the capillaries of much smaller cross- sections. Thus any change in the deformability of the red blood cells affects the microcirculatory functions and may cause serious problems. The altered mechanical properties of the erythrocyte membranes often indicate the pathogenesis of many diseases [1]. Sickle cell disease causes the RBCs to be less deformable and more fragile [2]. Malaria infected red blood cells too show notable changes in the mechanical properties of the membranes [1, 3]. Hence, the estimation of the erythrocyte mem- brane deformability is of paramount importance. Many single-cell measurement techniques e.g. micropipette as- piration [4], forced or flow induced stretching of an RBC with the help of optical tweezers [5 -- 9], microrheology study using optical magnetic twisting cytometry [10] and high-frequency electrical deformation tests [11] etc. have been used for this purpose. Rheological measurements also have been done on red blood cells suspensions [12 -- 15]. Rotations of folded RBCs under circularly polarized optical trap have been observed too [16]. Here, we re- port a simpler method to probe the erythrocyte mem- brane deformability, connecting it to the rotation speed of crenated RBCs under the scattering force of an optical trap. Normal healthy bi-concave shaped (discocytic) ery- throcytes possess circular symmetry. While in an op- tical trap a discocytic erythrocyte stands up and aligns its diameter along the optic axis. Because of its sym- metry, the trapped RBC does not experience any torque under the radiation pressure of the trapping laser beam and therefore it does not show any rotation. However when the cells are treated with hypertonic buffer, due to rapid efflux of water they get deformed, losing the inher- ent symmetry in their shape (crenation) [17]. In most of the cases the asymmetric deformation brings in a finite chirality. A non-zero chirality about the optic axis con- ∗ 1 For correspondence : [email protected] verts the scattering force into a finite torque that makes the trapped body rotate about the axis [18 -- 20]. Thus most of the crenated erythrocytes show rotation in an optical trap [21, 22]. The average speed of rotation de- pends on the chirality which, in general, increases with the contortion of the cells. With the tonicity of the medium, the degree of de- formation of the RBCs changes and so does the average rotation speed [22]. On the other hand, if the intrinsic membrane deformability of the erythrocytes is changed by any internal or external condition, they would deform to a different degree albeit being in a similar hypertonic buffer. In this letter we report that the average rota- tion speed of crenated RBCs in an optical trap can be used as a measure of their membrane deformability. It is known that the presence of calcium ions (Ca++) en- hances the lipid ordering in erythrocyte membranes mak- ing them more rigid [23 -- 25]. We have probed the same phenomenon through the average rotation speed and ro- tation probability of optically trapped crenated RBCs in hypertonic buffer containing different concentrations of calcium ions. Fresh blood was obtained from healthy donors. The erythrocytes were separated by centrifugation and washed with phosphate buffer saline (PBS). Until the experiments, the cells were suspended in PBS (isotonic) and preserved at 4oC. Experiments were done within 36 hours after collecting the fresh blood samples. To treat the red blood cells with hypertonic buffer of osmo- larity 1200 mOsm, sodium chloride (N aCl) and calcium chloride (CaCl2) were mixed in different proportions and added to the original erythrocyte suspension in PBS (300 mOsm). In this method we obtained 5 different red cell suspensions in hypertonic buffer mediums of same osmo- larity 1200 mOsm but with varying calcium ion concen- trations in them. The relative proportions of N aCl and CaCl2 in the five different salt mixtures were determined in such a fashion that in the final suspensions the contri- bution of the Ca++ ions to the total osmolarity of 1200 mOsm varied from 0% to 25%, where the absolute value of Ca++ ion concentration changed from 0 to 300 mM . To rule out the time dependence of the calcium ion treat- ment on the erythrocytes, each suspension was prepared and kept for one hour before it was loaded in the sample cell. A linearly polarized 1064 nm N d : Y V O4 diode pumped solid state laser was used to trap the erythro- cytes. To built the optical trap, the laser beam was coupled to a modified Axiovert 200 microscope where a 63X special IR objective focused the beam tightly to the sample plane. A monochrome digital CCD camera, with 30f ps capture rate, attached at the binocular port of the microscope along with an image acquisition card was utilized to visualize and record the observations. All the erythrocyte suspensions in different media were ob- served under the microscope before switching on the trap. Then the cells in hypertonic buffer solutions having dif- ferent concentrations of Ca++ ions were trapped at vary- ing laser powers. To avoid the surface effect the trap was kept at 25-30 micron above the bottom plate. A total of 75 RBCs from each suspension were trapped at 5 differ- ent laser powers for better statistics. All the observations were recorded and stored in computer HDD for off-line analysis. For each of the suspensions, we counted the number of cells out of those 75 trapped RBCs that per- formed rotations under the trap. The rotation speeds were measured to get their average values as a function of trapping laser power for all the samples. (a) (b) 5 mm (c) (d) FIG. 1: The optical microscope images display erythrocytes in different conditions. (a) Normal healthy discocytic RBCs in phosphate buffer saline (300 mOsm). (b) Red blood cells in hypertonic buffer of osmolarity 1200 mOsm, without calcium ions. (c) RBCs in hypertonic buffer medium of same osmolar- ity (1200 mOsm) but containing 150 mM of Ca++ ions. (d) Erythrocytes in hypertonic buffer (1200 mOsm) consisting of 300 mM of Ca++ ions. In the isotonic phosphate buffer, before adding the salt mixtures to make it hypertonic, the cells were biconcave disk shaped (discocytic) - as expected (Fig. 1(a)). The erythrocytes in the hypertonic buffer of 1200 mOsm - without calcium ions, got deformed to a great extent. The crenated cells lost their disk like symmetric shape and became fairly contorted. With irregular morphol- ogy they almost attained the state of acanthocytes (Fig. 1(b)). The other hypertonic media (all were 1200 mOsm) with calcium ions did not cause that much of distortion to the symmetric shapes of the erythrocytes. As fluid came out of the RBCs, they shrank but retained their 2 symmetry to some degree. The smaller and thinner cells looked more like a disk. The contortions were lesser for the erythrocytes in media containing higher concentra- tions of Ca++ ions (Fig. 1(c),(d)). When trapped, most of the crenated cells started ro- tating. The RBCs with more deformation rotated faster. As each of the erythrocyte suspensions contained cells with a finite distribution in their sizes, ages etc, all the cells in the sample cell did not behave in the same fash- ion. Their degree of contortions and the speed of ro- tations showed a finite spread. Even some of them did not rotate at all though the others from the same sample performed rotation at moderate speeds under the trap. From the hypertonic buffer suspension of RBCs without any Ca++ ions, 70% of the trapped cells showed rota- tions. This percentage decreased as the concentration of the calcium ions in the suspension increased. Not a single erythrocyte rotated under the trap where the Ca++ ion concentration was the most, 300 mM . The number frac- tion of the total trapped crenated cells that performed rotation and their average rotation speeds are presented here (Fig. 2) as a measure of the erythrocyte membrane deformabilities at different calcium ion concentrations. 0 mM Ca++ 100 mM Ca++ 150 mM Ca++ 200 mM Ca++ 300 mM Ca++ ) m p r ( d e e p S n o i t a t o R e g a r e v A 100 80 60 40 20 0 120 160 200 240 280 320 Laser Power ( mW ) FIG. 2: (Color Online) The average rotation speeds of the trapped crenated erythrocytes have been plotted against the laser power for five different calcium ion concentrations. For each concentration, the data points are fitted to a straight line. The open symbols represent the experimental data points and the solid lines are the linear fit to them. Typical rotations of trapped RBCs corresponding to two data points are shown in the side panel (enhanced online). For each of the suspensions, the average rotation speed of the trapped rotors increased linearly with the laser power, as expected for the asymmetric chiral rotors [19, 20]. (Two representative rotation observations are shown in Fig. 2 side panel.) Thus we get five straight lines for the five hypertonic media containing different concentrations of calcium ions (Fig. 2). The slopes of the straight lines decreased monotonically with increas- ing Ca++ ion concentration, becoming zero for the high- est calcium ion concentration. The slope (S) that reflects the intrinsic membrane deformability of the RBCs, has been plotted against the calcium ion concentrations (Fig. 3(b)). The other parameter that too reflects the defor- mations of the erythrocytes is the percentage (R) of the total number of trapped cells which performed rotation. The percentage, R, decreased with the increasing con- centration of the calcium ion (Fig. 3(a)), following the same trend as that of the former. 0 1 0 2 0 3 0 (a) 1/K = 0.1 M A = 97.20 80 60 40 R 20 ( 1/K = 0.1 M B = 0.63 S 0 5 4 3 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 ! 0 Concentration of Ca++ 0 1 0 2 0 3 ( M ) FIG. 3: (Color Online) (a) The bar graph shows R, the per- centage of the total number of crenated erythrocytes that rotated under the trap, at varying Ca++ ion concentrations, C. (b) Slopes (S) of the straight line fits in Fig. 2 are plotted against C. The dashed curves represent the fit to the data sets R and S following eqn 1a and 1b respectively. As the change in deformability of the erythrocytes with calcium ion concentrations is an effect of the adsorption 3 of the ions to the cell membrane, the variation is expected to follow the Langmuir isotherm [25]. The isotherm re- lates the adsorption of molecules or ions (θ, fractional coverage of the surface) on a surface to the concentra- tion of the ions (C) as θ = K · C/(1 + K · C), where K is the Langmuir adsorption constant. In our experiments, the observables - reflecting the erythrocyte deformability, drop off with increasing adsorption of the calcium ions. Therefore, to fit to our experimental data, we use two complementary equations: R = Rmax − A · θ (1a) S = Smax − B · θ (1b) A and B being fitting parameters. Fig. 3 displays the data sets R and S at varying Ca++ ion concentration (C) and the corresponding fitting curves as solid lines. The parameters' values are given in the figure. To conclude, the fitting of our experimental data shows that the variation of the average rotation speed of the trapped crenated RBCs and the probability of their ro- tation under the trap are the direct signatures of the red blood cell membrane deformability. The membrane de- formability of the cells determine the degree of their con- tortions when subjected to hypertonic media of same os- molarity, and the contortions become visible through the rotation speed as well as the probability of rotation under an optical trap. Albeit being indirect, this method pro- vides an easier alternative way to investigate the change of erythrocyte membrane rigidity and stiffness due to any internal or external abnormalities. Therefore, it could be used as a generalized diagnostic tool for the diseases that cause to affect the normal red blood cell membrane de- formability. We thank Department of Science and Technology, In- dia and Council for Scientific and Industrial Research, India for financial support. [1] L. H. Miller, D. I. Baruch, K. Marsh and O. K. Doumbo, [11] H. Engelhardt and E. Sackmann, Biophys. J. 54, 495 Nature 415, 673 (2002). (1988). [2] D. E. Discher, N. Mohandas and E. A. Evans, Science [12] T. Suda, N. Maeda, D. Shimizu, E. Kamitsubo and T. 266, 1032 (1994). Shiga, Biorheology 19, 555 (1982). [3] F. K. Glenister, R. L. Copper, A. F. Cowman, N. Mo- [13] A. Seiyama, Y. Suzuki and N. Maeda, Colloid Polym Sci handas and B. M. Cooke, Blood 99, 1060 (2002). 271, 63 (1993). [4] S. Chien, KL. P. Sung, R. Skalak and S. Usami, Biophys. [14] BD Riquelme, J. Valverde and RJ Rasia, Biorheology 35, J. 24, 463 (1978). 325 (1998). [5] K. Svoboda, C. F. Schmidt, D. Branton and S. M. Block, [15] A. Drochon, European Physical Journal-Applied Physics Biophys. J. 63, 784 (1992). 22, 155 (2003). [6] M. Dao, C. T. Lim and S. Suresh, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 51, 2259 (2003). [7] YP. L. C. Li, KK. Liu and A. C. K. Lai, J. Boimed. Engg. 128, 830 (2006). [16] J. A. Dharmadhikari, S. Roy, A. K. Dharmadhikari, S. Sharma and D. Mathur, Appl. Phys. Lett. 85, 6048 (2004). [17] T. H. Ham, R. F. Dunn, R. W. Sayre and J. R. Murphy, [8] C. Li and K. K. Liu, J Mater Sci: Mater Med 19, 1529 Blood 32, 847 (1968). (2008). [18] P.Galajda and P. Ormos, Appl. Phys. Lett. 78, 249 [9] R. M. Hochmuth, E. A. Evans and D. F. Colvard, Mi- (2000). crovasc Res 11, 155 (1976). [19] M. Khan, A. K. Sood, F. L. Deepak and C. N. R. Rao, [10] M. PM Marinkovic, K. T. Turner, J. P. Butler, J. J. Fredberg and S. Suresh, Cell Physiol 293, C597 (2007). Nanotechnology 17, S287 (2006). [20] M. Khan, A. K. Sood, F. L. Deepak and C. N. R. Rao, J. Nanosci. Nanotechnol. 7, 1800 (2007). [24] E. E. Quist, Biochem. Biophys. Research Comm. 92, 631 [21] M. Khan, S. K. Mohanty and A. K. Sood, Pramana - J. (1979). Phys. 65, 777 (2005). [22] S. K. Mohanty, K. S. Mohanty and P. K. Gupta, Opt. Express 13, 4745 (2005). [23] D. R. Anderson, J. L. Davis and K. L. Carraway, J. Biol. Chem. 252, 6617 (1977). [25] R. S. Vest, L. J. Gonzales, S. A. Permann, E. Spencer, L. D. Hansen, A. M. Judd, and J. D. Bell, Biophysical J. 86, 2251 (2004). 4
1604.03532	1	1604	2016-04-12T19:19:09	A Computational Model of YAP/TAZ Mechanosensing	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.SC" ]	In cell proliferation, stem cell differentiation, chemoresistance and tissue organization, the ubiquitous role of YAP/TAZ continues to impact our fundamental understanding in numerous physiological and disease systems. YAP/TAZ is an important signaling nexus integrating diverse mechanical and biochemical signals, such as ECM stiffness, adhesion ligand density, or cell-cell contacts, and thus strongly influences cell fate. Recent studies show that YAP/TAZ mechanical sensing is dependent on RhoA-regulated stress fibers. However, current understanding of YAP/TAZ still remains limited due to the unknown interaction between the canonical Hippo pathway and cell tension. To identify the roles of key signaling molecules in mechanical signal sensing and transduction, we present a novel computational model of the YAP/TAZ signaling pathway. This model converts ECM mechanical properties to biochemical signals via adhesion, and integrates intracellular signaling cascades associated with cytoskeleton dynamics. Adhesion molecules, such as FAK, are predicted to rescue YAP/TAZ activity in soft environments via the RhoA pathway. We found that changes of molecule concentrations result in different pattern of YAP/TAZ stiffness response. We also investigate the sensitivity of YAP/TAZ activity to ECM stiffness. In addition, the model shows that the unresolved synergistic effect of YAP/TAZ activity between the mechanosensing and the Hippo pathways can be explained by the interaction of LIMK and LATS. Overall, our model provides a novel platform for studying YAP/TAZ activity in the context of integrating different signaling pathways. This platform can be used to gain new fundamental insights into roles of key molecular and mechanical regulators on development, tissue engineering or tumor progression.	physics.bio-ph	physics	A Computational Model of YAP/TAZ Mechanosensing Keywords: pathway model, Hippo pathway, synergy, adhesion, cytoskeleton dynamics Meng Sun1, Fabian Spill2,1,* and Muhammad H. Zaman1,3,* 1. Department of Biomedical Engineering, 44 Cummington Street, Boston MA 02215, USA 2. Department of Mechanical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA 3. Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Boston University, Boston, MA 02215, USA *Corresponding author E-mail: [email protected] (MHZ) and [email protected] (FS) 1 Abstract In cell proliferation, stem cell differentiation, chemoresistance and tissue organization, the ubiquitous role of YAP/TAZ continues to impact our fundamental understanding in numerous physiological and disease systems. YAP/TAZ is an important signaling nexus integrating diverse mechanical and biochemical signals, such as ECM stiffness, adhesion ligand density, or cell-cell contacts, and thus strongly influences cell fate. Recent studies show that YAP/TAZ mechanical sensing is dependent on RhoA-regulated stress fibers. However, current understanding of YAP/TAZ still remains limited due to the unknown interaction between the canonical Hippo pathway and cell tension. Furthermore, the multi-scale relationship connecting adhesion signaling to YAP/TAZ activity through cytoskeleton dynamics remains poorly understood. To identify the roles of key signaling molecules in mechanical signal sensing and transduction, we present a novel computational model of the YAP/TAZ signaling pathway. This model converts ECM mechanical properties to biochemical signals via adhesion, and integrates intracellular signaling cascades associated with cytoskeleton dynamics. We perform perturbations of molecular levels and sensitivity analyses to predict how various signaling molecules affect YAP/TAZ activity. Adhesion molecules, such as FAK, are predicted to rescue YAP/TAZ activity in soft environments via the RhoA pathway. We also found that changes of molecule concentrations result in different pattern of YAP/TAZ stiffness response. We also investigate the sensitivity of YAP/TAZ activity to ECM stiffness, and compare with that of SRF/MAL, which is another important regulator of differentiation. In addition, the model shows that the unresolved synergistic effect of YAP/TAZ activity between the mechanosensing and the Hippo pathways can be explained by the interaction of LIMK and LATS. Overall, our model provides a novel platform for studying YAP/TAZ activity in the context of integrating different signaling pathways. This platform can be used to gain new fundamental insights into roles of key molecular and mechanical regulators on development, tissue engineering or tumor progression. Introduction One of the fundamental questions of cell biology is how cells organize themselves into complex tissues and three-dimensional structures. Multiple signals transmitted from neighboring cells and extracellular matrix (ECM) environment are integrated into intracellular pathways and guide cellular behavior, such as proliferation, migration and differentiation. Recent years have seen enormous progress in uncovering the roles of the transcriptional regulator YAP/TAZ, which controls organ size by integrating both physical and biochemical cues (1–3). First discovered in Drosophila, deregulation of YAP or its paralog TAZ has been found to lead to massive organ overgrowth (4). YAP/TAZ has been shown to have significant roles in regulating remarkable biological properties in development, tissue homeostasis and cancer. The activation of the most studied upstream cascade of YAP/TAZ, the canonical Hippo pathway, is mainly dependent on cell density sensing, and results in the activation of the core Hippo kinase LATS which regulates YAP/TAZ localization (1). Despite these ubiquitous roles, the mechanism of YAP/TAZ localization regulation is still poorly understood (2). One of the models suggests that activated LATS in the Hippo core complex prevents YAP/TAZ from entering the nucleus via phosphorylation, involved with further cytosolic sequestration through binding with molecules such as 14-3-3, or degradation (2, 5). YAP/TAZ lacks of a nuclear localization signal (NLS), and the machinery for their nuclear import/export is unknown (2). Thus it is an important question to investigate which molecules are involved in this nuclear transport regulation, such as RanGTPases (6). After translocating into the nucleus, YAP/TAZ acts as a transcriptional co-activator with several transcription factors and thus targets various genes, including TEAD (2). More recently, attention has been focused on mechanical regulators of YAP/TAZ activity beyond the core Hippo pathway (7). For instance, increasing stiffness of the external environment (8), or exerting static stretch (7) has been found to promote YAP/TAZ nuclear translocation and its downstream transcription activity. Specifically, it was found that these effects are transmitted through RhoA pathways and resulting stress fiber formation (8). Therefore, YAP/TAZ can be considered as master-integrators of the cellular 2 microenvironment, integrating different cues of mechanical and biochemical nature. Sensing mechanical properties of ECM alone is a complex process and of fundamental importance in regulating cell behaviors (9, 10). Stiff or high adhesion environments have been shown to promote both migration and proliferation (11). For instance, cells have been shown to migrate towards a stiffer ECM environment (durotaxis) (12) or a surface-bound gradient of ECM adhesion (haptotaxis) (13). Furthermore, manipulation of ECM stiffness can direct mesenchymal stem cells to differentiate into neuron, myoblasts or osteoblasts in a myosin II-dependent manner (14). Up-regulating YAP activity on soft substrates is shown to direct mesenchymal stem cell differentiation towards osteogenesis, which otherwise is observed on stiff substrates (8, 15). Specifically, the sensing of the mechanical properties of the ECM relies on force-sensitive molecules located at cell-ECM adhesion complexes, converting the mechanical signals to biochemical signals inside the cell (16, 17). These adhesion complexes form around integrins, which are membrane-bound heterodimers, and bind to the ECM. Important downstream targets include FAK (18, 19), which is phosphorylated at tyrosine 397 (20) upon integrin binding, and Src further enhances FAK phosphorylation sites at other residues to maximize the kinase activity of FAK (19, 21). Other than adhesion sensing, phosphorylated FAK at tyrosine 397 is also sensitive to the stiffness of the surrounding matrix in both 2D and 3D environments (11, 22, 23). Importantly, in 3D, FAK diffuses throughout the cytoplasm but still modulates cell motility by affecting protrusion activity and matrix deformation (24). 2D substrates have demonstrated that cells increase their assembly of F-actin stress fibers and focal adhesions via RhoA contractility regulation when substrate rigidity is increased (9, 13, 25). Stiffness sensing in 3D is also shown to be associated with RhoA dependent cytoskeleton regulation (23, 26). Mechanical sensing of the microenvironment is a complex and multi-step process with profound implications for maintaining homeostasis and disease relevance (9, 10, 27, 28). Various quantitative aspects of signal transmission from the ECM stiffness or adhesion to intracellular biochemical signals remain largely elusive. While there are several mechanical models (29), and multiple studies of cytoskeleton dynamics, there is a lack of an integrated model of mechanosensing and YAP/TAZ which enables one to understand the interactions of various factors influencing YAP/TAZ activity in a quantitative way. Furthermore, such integrated model can be used to predict the effect of molecular inhibitors or changes in mechanical properties in silico. In this paper, we aim to bridge this gap through an integrated model that includes mechanical-to-biochemical signal conversion by adhesion molecules, intracellular signal transmission, cytoskeleton dynamics, and regulation of effectors relevant to directing transcriptional programs, such as YAP/TAZ (30). We introduce a response function for YAP/TAZ activity dependent on ECM stiffness, and study how disturbances of molecular activities can alter this stiffness response function. The model predicts that adhesion regulation has a significant role in regulating YAP/TAZ activity in mechanical sensing. Changes in FAK shift the stiffness response function horizontally, such that FAK overexpression rescues YAP/TAZ activity in soft environments, while mDia shifts the stiffness response function vertically. We also predict that YAP/TAZ is more sensitive than SRF/MAL in response to changes in ECM properties. Furthermore, our model is able to explain the observed synergistic effect of mechanical and canonical Hippo regulation on YAP/TAZ activity through incorporating interaction between LATS and LIMK. Methods To understand and predict YAP/TAZ activity, as measured by its amount in the nucleus, we consider a model of interactions among several key molecules involved in mechanical sensing mechanism (14, 31). Previous models focused on providing new insights into individual components of mechanical signaling, such as adhesion (32), Rho GTPase (33), and cytoskeleton dynamics (34–37) separately. However, an integrated understanding of how adhesion affects cytoskeleton dynamics and stiffness response effector such as YAP/TAZ is not well characterized. Our model includes key selective molecules from previous models, such as FAK and 3 RhoA, and is extended with the necessary components for YAP/TAZ regulation (8). We model the time evolution of the concentrations of the molecules per cell by ordinary differential equations. The model distinguishes between molecules in different cellular compartments, such as YAP/TAZ in the cytoplasm and nucleus, and F-actin in the cortex and the cytoplasm. It consists of the conversion of mechanical signals to biochemical signals via adhesion molecules, RhoA GTPase signal transmission, cytoskeleton dynamics, and the regulation of transcriptional activity (16, 30, 38). Signaling network The network of signaling molecules is shown in Figure 1. External ECM properties are felt through adhesion complexes via integrins. Higher stiffness of ECM correlates with larger protein aggregation at focal adhesions (39). Thus the clustering of integrins attracts more FAK to activate them (40). For this paper we focus on FAK, for which there is clear evidence of higher activity in stiffer 3D ECM environments (11, 41). Further downstream, we include the small GTPase RhoA, which can activate autoinhibited mDia (42, 43) and ROCK (44) by binding with them. mDia is an actin formin that nucleates actin filaments (45) and accelerates the rate of actin elongation 5- to 15- fold (46). ROCK enhances myosin activity by phosphorylating myosin light chain and inhibiting myosin phosphatase (47). It also phosphorylates and activates LIM-kinase, resulting in the inactivation of the F-actin severing protein cofilin (44). Thus ROCK promotes the assembly of stress fibers and actomyosin contractility. In turn, increased actin and myosin activity is associated with increased YAP/TAZ activity (7, 8). In our model these key molecules are sufficient to interpret the mechanism of mechano-sensing of YAP/TAZ, and the model is formulated in a way that other molecules, such as Rac, Cdc42, profilin, Aip1 (48), Src or capping proteins, can be easily added to the model. The inputs are the ECM mechanical properties and concentrations of intracellular signaling molecules, while the output is the nuclear translocation of the relevant transcriptional molecule, YAP/TAZ. The signaling process of another key regulator of differentiation, SRF/MAL (49), is used in comparison with YAP/TAZ mechanical sensing. The entry of MAL into the nucleus to interact with SRF transcription factor activity is regulated through monomeric G-actin. G-actin binds to MAL to prevents it from binding to SRF and thus its downstream transcription (50). Figure 1 YAP/TAZ mechano-sensing signaling pathway network This is the scheme of the computational signaling cascade model. The ECM mechanical properties are transmitted to intracellular signals via adhesion molecules, such as FAK. Adhesion molecules activation induces RhoA binding with GTP. The RhoA-GTP drives the formation of actomyosin via mDia and ROCK activation. mDia is a formin that polymerizes F-actin. ROCK can both activate myosin and induce F-actin assembly through LIMK and cofilin. Eventually, the resultant of F-actin and myosin activity, i.e., stress fibers in 2D systems, leads to the YAP/TAZ nuclear translocation. In comparison 4 with the YAP/TAZ mechanical sensing mechanism, SRF/MAL senses mechanical inputs by being inhibited by G-actin. In addition, the Hippo core component LATS is sensitive to cell-cell interaction. In our model, the synergistic effect between the mechanical sensing and the Hippo pathway is predicted due to the interaction of LATS and LIMK. Conversion from mechanical signals to biochemical signals ECM stiffness and ligand density are two key ECM properties initially sensed and transmitted to intracellular signals via adhesion molecules (16). Elucidating the mechanisms of conversion of mechanical signals to biochemical signals via adhesion molecules is a fundamental question of mechanobiology, and the precise mechanisms of mechanical sensing in regulating YAP/TAZ activity are poorly understood. Among the large number of adhesion molecules, we focus on the activity of FAK in our model, since FAK is a key molecule in adhesion components regulating the downstream signals, such as RhoA GTPase (51). Other components of adhesion molecules are implicitly incorporated into the model by the usage of a higher-order Hill function, which represents cooperativity among the groups of adhesion molecules. There is strong evidence showing that with higher rigidity of ECM, FAK phosphorylation is up-regulated both on 2D substrate and in 3D matrix (11, 22, 23, 41). Over-expression of FAK can rescue cells whose proliferation was inhibited by low adhesion or reduced cell spreading (52). In 2D, the cells constrained in spreading showed lower FAK phosphorylation than the spread cells, even when coated with high densities of fibronectin, and had impaired proliferative ability (52). Previous modeling approaches have focused on the dependence of the FAK phosphorylation rate on the ECM ligand density through a Michaelis-Menten function (32, 53). We extend this function by adding the mechanical properties of ECM, notably its Youngs modulus E mol . When fitting data regarding the dependence of FAK on ECM stiffness (11), we found that a second-order Hill function is able to capture the features of the data (Figure S1 in the Supporting Materials). This is consistent with previous studies showing that a Hill function is compatible with the high cooperativity of the adhesion molecules such as integrin, talin, etc (51). Hence, the time dependence of active phosphorylated FAK is given by dFAK P(t ) dt = ksf ( LD(t ) × E mol(t ))2 C 2 + ( LD(t ) × E mol(t ))2 ( FAK 0 − FAK P(t )) − kdf FAK P(t ) . (1) Here, ksf is the maximum activation rate due to the ECM, and the de-phosphorylation rate of FAK is kdf . C is the value of LD(t ) × E mol(t ) when the activation rate of FAK is ksf / 2 , that is, half of the maximum activation rate. We mainly focus on the ECM stiffness in this paper and regard ligand density as constant. Molecular switch RhoA GTPase Rho-family GTPases are molecular 'switches' within cells to control the formation and disassembly of actin cytoskeletal structures, such as stress fibers and filopodia. Adhesion molecules, such as FAK, sense the ECM and activate Rho-family GTPases. Among them, RhoA is a key GTPase which has been shown to be up-regulated with increasing rigidity of ECM in 3D environments (11, 41). In detail, phosphorylated FAK activates RhoA in both a direct (54) and indirect manner, such as via Fyn (55). Hence, we model the time-dependence of the concentration of RhoA as dRhoA GTP (t ) dt = k (γ(FAK fkρ P (t ))2 + 1)(RhoA 0 − RhoA GTP (t )) − k RhoA dρ GTP (t ). (2) Here, k fkρ is the baseline activation rate of RhoA due to the molecules other than phosphorylated FAK, k dρ 5 is the RhoA-GTP deactivation rate, which is relevant to the hydrolysis rate of RhoA bound GTP to GDP, and γ is the RhoA activation enhancement/amplification due to active FAK. We have modeled the dependence of the activation rate of RhoA on phosphorylated FAK as second order, so the steady state RhoA GTP = k (γ(FAK fkρ P(t ))2 + 1) k dρ + k (γ(FAK fkρ P(t ))2 + 1) is a quasi-second-order hill function. This can represent the cooperative process of activating RhoA through FAK as discussed earlier. Cytoskeleton regulation Downstream of RhoA, several cytoskeleton regulators are activated. We focus on ROCK and mDia to model their time-dependence by dROCK A(t ) = k dt RhoA GTP(t )(ROCK rρ − ROCK A(t )) − k drock ROCK A(t ), (3) 0 dmDia A(t ) = k dt RhoA GTP(t )(mDia 0 mρ − mDia A(t )) − k dmDia mDia A(t ) . (4) Here k rρ is the activation rate of ROCK due to RhoA-GTP, k drock is the deactivation rate of ROCK, k is mρ the activation rate of mDia due to RhoA-GTP, and k dmDia is the deactivation rate of mDia. Myosin is then up-regulated by ROCK, and evolves according to (t ) dMyo A dt = k mr(εT(ROCK A(t )) + 1)(Myo 0 − Myo (t )) − k Myo A dmy A (t ) . (5) Here k mr is the activation rate of myosin due to pathways other than ROCK, k is the deactivation rate of dmy myosin, and ε is the myosin activation enhancement/amplification due to active ROCK. Activated ROCK further activates LIM-kinase (LIMK) and LIMK phosphorylates cofilin to prevent its binding with actin and deactivates its severing and disassembly of F-actin. dLIMK A(t ) dt = k lr(τT(ROCK A(t )) + 1)(LIMK 0 − LIMK A(t )) − k dl LIMK A(t ) , (6) dCofilin NP (t ) dt = k turn−over (Cofilin 0 − Cofilin NP (t )) − k cr(1 − k LATS 0 ll )LIMK A NP 2(t )Cofilin (t ). (7) Here, k lr is the activation rate of LIMK due to pathways other than ROCK, such as PAK (56), k dl is the deactivation rate of LIMK, τ is LIMK activation enhancement/amplification due to active ROCK compared with the activation rate due to other molecules, k turn−over is the dephosphorylation rate of cofilin, k cr is phosphorylation rate of cofilin due to LIMK, k ll is the inhibition rate of LIMK-dependent cofilin phosphorylation due to the total concentration of LATS 0 in the cell, and the function T(ROCK A(t )) is a 6 smoothing function given by T(ROCK A(t )) = smoothing( 0, ROCK A(t ) ≤ ROCK B ROCK A(t ) − ROCK B, ROCK A(t ) > ROCK B ) . This T-function approximates the activation starting region of a Michaelis-Menten function. It mimics that active ROCK concentrations are required to exceed a threshold to activate LIMK. This approximates the flat region of the deactivating part of the Michaelis-Menten function. Once active ROCK is above the threshold concentration ROCK B , the LIMK activation rate is linearly dependent on ROCK A(t ), approximating the linear activation part of the Michaelis-Menten function. The smoothing function uses a smooth filter for connection, so the T-function and its first derivative are continuous. The saturation part of the Michaelis-Menten function is implicit in the T-function due to the saturation of concentrations of other molecules, such as FAK and RhoA. Here we also propose a distinction between cortical F-actin and F-actin mainly in the interior cytoplasm, named as cytoplasmic F-actin, which is a key component forming stress fibers. The cortical F-actin and cytoplasmic F-actin have distinct regulators and downstream effectors. In Drosophila, Tsr, which is a cofilin homolog and accumulates F-actin around the entire cell cortex, does not have an effect in Yki, the YAP homolog, while the inhibition of capt, another homolog of cofilin, which restricts actin filament accumulation near the apical surface, promotes Yki activities (57). Cortical actin associating with apical junctions is also latrunculin resistant (58). Thus, in our model, we distinguish the cortical F-actin and cytoplasmic F-actin. For simplicity, we assume that the ratio between G-actin and cortical F-actin is constant. The cytoplasmic F-actin is regulated by mDia and cofilin as follows: dFcyto(t ) dt = k ra(aT(mDia A(t )) + 1)Gactin(t ) − kdepFcyto(t ) − k fc1cofilinNP(t )Fcyto(t ) . (8) Here, k ra is the polymerization rate of cytoplasmic F-actin from G-actin, kdep is the depolymerization rate of cytoplasmic F-actin, α is the amplification/enhancement of the polymerization rate due to mDia, and k fc1 is the severing and disassembly rate of cytoplasmic F-actin due to active cofilin. Cofilin is an F-actin assembly regulator and its effect is dependent on its concentration in vitro: if the ratio of cofilin/actin subunits in a filament is low (<1/100), this results in persistent filament severing and acceleration of F-actin depolymerization, while if the ratio is above 1/10, cofilin stabilizes F-actin in a twisted conformation and can nucleate filaments (56). The severing effect of cofilin itself can be biphasic when interacting with other cytoskeleton regulators such as Arp2/3 (35). Therefore in our model, cofilin's effect is to reduce the cytoplasmic F-actin concentration in the range of given endogenous cofilin and actin amounts (36). For simplicity, we do not explicitly take cortical actin into account and assume it is proportional to G-actin with a ratio β . YAP/TAZ dynamics YAP/TAZ is regulated by both stress fiber/RhoA activity and cell-cell contacts/LATS activity (2). It translocates to the nucleus to bind with transcription factors such as TEAD and activate them. Phosphorylation by LATS or, potentially through some currently unknown kinase whose activity is regulated by cytoskeletal tension, leads to sequestration of YAP/TAZ. We thus model nuclear YAP/TAZ concentrations by 7 dYAP / TAZ N(t ) dt = (k CN + kCY Fcyton(t )myoA(t ))(YAP / TAZ0 − YAP / TAZ N(t )) (9) − kNCYAP / TAZ N(t ) − klyLATSP(t )YAP / TAZ N(t ). Here, k CN is the rate of YAP/TAZ trans-locating from the cytoplasm to the nucleus with no active cytoplasmic F-actin and myosin, k NC is the rate of YAP/TAZ translocating from nucleus to cytoplasm with no active LATS, and k CY is the YAP/TAZ nuclear translocation rate due to the stress fibers or the tensional cytoplasmic F-actin. n characterizes the weight of how YAP/TAZ activity is dependent on cytoplasmic F-actin. n = 1 is the default setting that indicates the myosin and cytoplasmic F-actin have a similar effect on regulating YAP/TAZ activity, and k ly is the cytoplasmic translocation rate of YAP/TAZ due to active LATS. The mechanism for YAP/TAZ nuclear import/export is unknown (2), thus we model the YAP/TAZ nuclear transport directly depending on the stress fibers and LATS as approximation. Importantly, YAP/TAZ nuclear translocation has been shown to dependent on stress fibers and RhoA in 2D (8). In 3D stress fibers in cells are not as distinct as those present in the 2D monolayer cultures (59, 60), but still with more F-actin in the cytoplasm in rigid environments in comparison to the softer ones (61). Thus for cells with no apparent stress fiber structure in 3D, we generally use the tensional cytoplasmic F-actin filaments, which are characterized by the product of the cytoplasmic F-actin concentration and active myosin concentration Fcyto(t )myoA(t ), to be an equivalent component of stress fibers in 3D. MAL dynamics MAL in the cytoplasm has been shown to bind with G-actin, which inhibits its ability to go to the nucleus and associate with SRF to form the activate SRF/MAL complex (50). (t ) = dMAL N dt !! cnm k Gactin(t )2 1 + k mg (MAL 0 − MAL N (t )) − k ncm MAL N (t ) . (10) Here, k cnm is the rate of MAL translocation from the cytoplasm to the nucleus, k mg is the decreasing effect due to cytoplasmic MAL binding with G-actin and retained in the cytoplasm (this inhibition effect is a second-order hill function), and ncm is the rate of MAL trans-locating from the nucleus to the cytoplasm. k ! Results We use our computational model to investigate how mechanical signal transmission and YAP/TAZ regulation depend on pathways of interacting signaling molecules. We study the effect of kinetic inhibition, and perform local sensitivity analysis to predict the role of crucial model parameters and external variables such as stiffness. The model not only reproduces the existing experimental results, but also makes a number of new predictions. First, we study the effect of disturbing adhesion complexes on YAP/TAZ activity represented by the stiffness response function. Then, we explore the distinction between SRF/MAL and YAP/TAZ sensitivity to ECM stiffness. More importantly, we investigated the unresolved synergistic effect between the mechanical sensing and the Hippo pathway of YAP/TAZ through the addition of interaction between LIMK and LATS. 8 Molecular intervention To demonstrate the fidelity of our model, we reproduced the results observed in experiments with molecular intervention, so that the model can be readily used to make novel predictions. The YAP/TAZ signaling cascade in response to mechanical stimuli is studied mostly by molecular interventions targeting the actin cytoskeleton, such as by adding blebbistatin or latrunculin A (8). We mimicked the inhibition or overexpression process in our model by upregulating or downregulating the corresponding kinetic parameters. The results are consistent with the experimental ones from Dupont et al (8) (Figure 2a). Furthermore, we examined the sensitivity of YAP/TAZ activity to local changes in kinetic parameters (62). It turns out that the parameters relevant to cell-ECM adhesion are the ones most robustly affecting YAP/TAZ activity (Figure 2b and S2 in the Supporting Materials), so we study their effect in depth in the following sections. Figure 2 Molecular intervention of YAP/TAZ activity in stiffness sensing (a) The results in the computational model regarding molecular interventions are consistent with the experimental results from previous mechanical regulation studies on YAP/TAZ (8). Here the molecular intervention process is mimicked by upregulating or downregulating the corresponding kinetic parameters (Supporting Methods in the Supporting Materials). The soft environment here is 0.5kPa hydrogel for 2D MEC cells, while stiff environment is 20kPa hydrogel(8). Blebbist.: myosin inhibitor. Y-27632: ROCK inhibitor. C3: RhoA inhibitor. Lat. A: F-actin inhibitor. mDia: over-expression of mDia (a 9 formin that induces F-actin assembly). (b) Local sensitivity analysis of the nondimentionalized model. The local perturbations of adhesion-relevant parameters ( C , k and k df sf ) are the most robust ones in affecting YAP/TAZ activity in the model. This is the local sensitivity analysis of YAP/TAZ activity in stiff environment by downregulating the kinetic parameters individually 10%. The upregulating effect is much weaker than this, since most of the molecular activities are saturated. The up-regulation in a soft environment also shows that the adhesion is the most robust component in affecting YAP/TAZ activity (Figure S2 in the Supporting Materials). (c) and (d) are the cell stiffness response function, which is a YAP/TAZ activity function regulating cellular behavior such as proliferation dependent on external ECM stiffness. (c) Different amounts of FAK determine the threshold stiffness for cell stiffness sensing by shifting the curves horizontally. FAK0~1 corresponds to the endogenous FAK amount of NMuMG cell in 3D collagen. Collagen with 25 kPa is a soft environment and 45 kPa is a stiff environment for 3D NMuMG cells. If FAK is over-expressed to about 3-fold, 20 kPa will appear as a stiff environment for these cells. (d) The 2D MEC and MSC stiffness sensing identifies 1kPa ECM environment as soft and 20kPa as stiff, while in 3D NMuMG cells senses 25kPa as soft and 45kPa as stiff. These stiffness response functions are very alike the ones of manipulating only the FAK total amount of cells in (c). The initiation of YAP/TAZ signaling converts the biomechanical signals into molecular signals. The first stage in the cascade, as described in the Methods section and Figure 1, is the phosphorylation level of FAK in response to ECM stiffness. Overexpressing or downregulating FAK amount has been demonstrated to be able to rescue or inhibit cell proliferation (52), respectively. Furthermore, overexpression of FAK has shown to rescue YAP/TAZ activity in serum-starved cells in a PI3K- and LATS-dependent way (63). However, with sufficient EGF in the environment, we predict that FAK overexpression can rescue YAP/TAZ activity in a soft ECM environment dependent on the RhoA cascade (Figure 2c). For example, with undisturbed FAK levels, the cells show high YAP/TAZ activity in ECM with a high stiffness of 45kPa, while they have low YAP/TAZ activity with 25kPa ECM stiffness. On the other hand, if FAK0 is overexpressed by severalfold, YAP/TAZ activity is rescued in ECM environment as soft as 20 kPa. More specifically, FAK-overexpression rescues YAP/TAZ by shifting the stiffness response function leftwards rather than upwards. The transition window in ECM stiffness between high and low YAP/TAZ activity is also shortened with FAK-overexpression. Thus, we further predict that in downregulated FAK cells, activating YAP/TAZ activity requires considerably higher stiffness than in cells with normal FAK levels. That is, the YAP/TAZ activity in downregulated FAK cells can be rescued by plating them in a much stiffer environment. Changing mDia concentration mainly shifts the YAP/TAZ stiffness response functions vertically (Figure S3 in the Supporting Materials), and so do many actin regulators. In addition, increasing FAK concentration results in a narrower range of rigidity sensing and response in 3D, which displays high sensitivity of YAP/TAZ activity to stiffness between 10 and 15 kPa but little sensitivity in the range of 25-40 kPa. In addition, comparing the cell stiffness response functions in 2D and 3D environments (Figure 2d), we found that their difference in YAP/TAZ activity is very similar to the difference of stiffness response functions with changing concentrations of FAK (Figure 2c). For example, for normal murine mammary gland cells (NMuMG) in 3D environments, 45 kPa appears as a stiff environment in terms of YAP/TAZ activity, whereas 25 kPa appears as soft. On the other hand, for human mammary epithelial cells (MEC), 20kPa appears as stiff whereas 1kPa appears soft. In agreement with the stiffness response function due to FAK concentration change, FAK has been shown to be more aggregated around the cell membrane in a 2D environment and thus has a higher total concentration than in a 3D environment, in which FAK is diffused throughout the cytoplasm (24) and has a lower average concentration. Thus, different localization of FAK in 2D and 3D environments may explain differences of stiffness sensing and cell behavior in such environments. Due to differences for varying cell types and dimensions, in the following we talk about the cell behavior and stiffness environment generally, rather than clarifying specific cell types, dimensions or ECM stiffness values. 10 Comparison between YAP/TAZ and SRF/MAL In a single-cell mechanical regulation of YAP/TAZ activity is thought to be transmitted mainly though stress fibers (8), which are a resultant of both F-actin assembly and myosin activity, while SRF/MAL nuclear translocalization is mainly regulated by the amount of G-actin in the cytoplasm (49, 50). One of the hypotheses presented in the literature is that due to the resultant interaction of F-actin and myosin, YAP/TAZ nuclear localization is more sensitive to the stiffness of the ECM than SRF/MAL, which is only affected by actin. To better study the effect of each molecular perturbation on the YAP/TAZ nuclear translocation in comparison with MAL nuclear translocation, we define the fold-change of nuclear YAP/TAZ fraction when comparing soft and stiff ECM environment, FoldChange = (YAP / TAZ N )stiff − (YAP / TAZ N )soft (YAP / TAZ N )soft . (11) This fold-change characterizes the sensitivity of YAP/TAZ activity with regard to stiffness, that is, soft versus stiff. SRF/MAL sensitivity to the ECM environment is also defined in the same way as Eq. 11. YAP/TAZ activity was found to be more sensitive to ECM stiffness than SRF/MAL signaling (Figure 3b and S4 in the Supporting Materials). SRF/MAL is clearly sensitive to F/G-actin, while there is no clear evidence of SRF/MAL being a genuine mechano-sensor. In addition, YAP/TAZ nuclear fold-change changes more dramatically by downregulating the activation rates of FAK and RhoA than by upregulating them. It also shows that changing FAK activation has a larger impact on YAP/TAZ fold change than changing RhoA activation. The reduction of YAP/TAZ stiffness sensitivity resulting from downregulated FAK (reducing FAK activation rate) can be rescued by upregulating RhoA (increasing the RhoA activation rate). However, the reduction of YAP/TAZ stiffness sensitivity by reducing either the mDia or ROCK activation rate cannot be rescued by increasing the other (Figure S4 in the Supporting Materials). This is due to the fact that mDia and ROCK affect actin and myosin separately. Hence, the model gives rise to a new approach to compare the sensitivities quantitatively. 11 Figure 3 YAP/TAZ activity sensitivity analysis and comparison with SRF/MAL (a) shows YAP/TAZ nuclear localization under different stiffness environment, in comparison with MAL nuclear translocation. Here MAL nuclear translocation is not as robust as YAP/TAZ in response to stiffness change, likely due to YAP/TAZ having a myosin-dependent amplification effect other than the common regulator G-actin/F-actin in SRF/MAL activity. (b) shows fold-change of YAP/TAZ and MAL activities depending on the kinetic parameters, such as the activation rate of FAK ( k / k sf 0 sf ) and RhoA ( k / k fkρ fkρ0 ), when switching matrix from a soft to a stiff one. In addition, YAP/TAZ keeps showing higher sensitivity than MAL translocation fold-change in response to different stiffnesses, and the shape of the activated region reveals that downregulating FAK and RhoA has a more robust effect in regulating the YAP/TAZ nuclear localization than upregulating it. The synergistic effect between the Hippo and mechano-sensing pathways Our previous analyses are carried out with a constant LATS condition. There is a puzzling fact arising from simultaneous changes in LATS activity and cell tension due to mechanical signals: Dupont et al (8) showed that LATS kinase activity is independent of cell tension, while Aragona et al (7) showed inhibiting LATS and capping proteins for F-actin together can promote YAP/TAZ activity to a greater degree than the total combined effects of adding only siCapZ and adding only siLATS. This is thus a synergy in inhibiting capping proteins and LATS. In the previous work, this phenomenon is characterized as LATS regulation dominated by cytoskeleton regulation (7), however, its mechanism is unknown. Our model predicts that this synergistic effect is from the direct interaction between LATS and LIMK-cofilin. In single-cell system within a soft environment, though most LATS is inactive, LATS can dramatically reduce the phosphorylation of cofilin and enhances actin polymerization in an LATS kinase activity-independent way (64). By adding this interaction (the red interaction 12 in Figure 1), our model is able to capture the synergistic effect between the Hippo and mechano-sensing pathways. Through this interaction, knockout of LATS enhances F-actin assembly. More importantly, it gives 12 rise to the synergistic effect of LATS and CapZ inhibition (Figure 4a). If YAP/TAZ is more dependent on cytoplasmic F-actin than myosin (n changes from 1 to 2 in Eq. 9), the synergistic effect is larger (Figure 4b). Figure 4 The synergistic effect between the mechano-sensing and the Hippo pathway. (a) Adding the interaction between LIMK and LATS, which induces more free active LIMK molecules by adding siLats, YAP/TAZ is activated synergistically compared with inducing F-actin assembly and adding siLats separately. Condition1: stiff environment. 2: Soft environment. 3: Soft environment with siLats. 4: Soft environment with siCapZ. 5: Soft environment with both siLats and siCapZ. CapZ is a capping protein that inhibits F-actin polymerization. Here the effect of siCapZ on soft environment can be quantified as its corresponding YAP/TAZ activity (H(siCapZ)) abstracting the activity of YAP/TAZ in soft environment (control: H(soft)). The synergistic effect is quantified as H(siCapZ) – H(soft) + H(siLats) – H(soft) > H(siCapZ+siLats) – H(soft), i.e., H(siCapZ) + H(siLats) > H(soft) + H(siCapZ+siLats). (b) With a higher dependence on F-actin than on myosin, the YAP/TAZ showed a more apparent synergistic effect. Discussion The key goal of our study is to understand YAP/TAZ activity as a function of mechanical ECM properties. Here we present a novel mechano-biochemical model that predicts YAP/TAZ activity by integrating adhesion, RhoA GTPases and actomyosin dynamics. The transduction of the mechanical ECM properties into intracellular signaling is quantitatively characterized, and we predict how regulating the signaling molecules can make cells feel different mechanical environments. This gives rise to a direct quantitative function of the mechanical and intracellular molecule signals, the stiffness response function. We have focused on a few core regulators of cytoskeleton dynamics, which are sufficient to predict the difference between cytoskeleton-dependent YAP/TAZ and SRF/MAL activities. Furthermore, the synergistic effect between the LATS and F-actin regulator LIMK can be fully captured by this model. The model indicates that F-actin may have a larger impact in modulating YAP activity than myosin. The bulk of the previous studies on cell-matrix interactions have relied on perturbing signaling molecules in different ECM environment, but mostly characterize only relative upregulating or downregulating effects. Our study thus provides us with methods to systematically study the sensitivity of signaling molecules and the environment with the stiffness response function and fold-change function of different effectors (YAP and SRF). Most importantly, this work provides a quantitative framework for studying YAP/TAZ activity in response to mechanical sensing and predicts consistent results with the synergistic effect of mechanical and canonical Hippo signaling. There are several interesting aspects and predictions of the model that merit further discussion. A key outcome is that the adhesion is a more robust regulator in affecting YAP/TAZ activities than other cytoskeleton regulators (Figure 2b). This may be due to two reasons: one is because it is the most upstream signaling molecule that initiates the signal transmission and others are not as sensitive to the input signals. The other, and perhaps a more important reason may be that for the RhoA actomyosin cascade, mDia and ROCK are acting 13 complementarily on actin polymerization. A molecule in either of the mDia or ROCK cascades is not as influential in affecting YAP/TAZ as upstream molecules such as FAK or RhoA. This observations is consistent with experimental studies focusing on overexpression of mDia (8) where YAP/TAZ activities in both stiff and soft environment are up-regulated but still have a distinction, due to the additional ROCK cascade. Furthermore, manipulating FAK will change the range of stiffness sensing where YAP/TAZ activity rises with increasing stiffness. However, manipulating mDia or other actin regulators will only raise the activity of YAP/TAZ at soft stiffness, but will not change the range of stiffness sensitivity (Figure S3 in the Supporting Materials). Our model also shows that the upregulation of mDia or deletion of cofilin upregulates YAP/TAZ through inducing contractile actin stress fiber, which is consistent with what has been observed previously (65). Secondly, the inhibition of LATS and CapZ analysis in our model indicates that YAP/TAZ may have a higher dependence on F-actin than myosin. It remains unclear whether this is due to stress fiber formation itself has a larger dependence on F-actin, or whether YAP/TAZ is more sensitive to F-actin than myosin. There have been proposed interactions between myosin and actin cytoskeleton, while whether myosin leads to F-actin assembly (66, 67) or disassembly (34) is not well studied. Our model in its current form does not include any direct interactions between myosin and F-actin. The third interesting prediction is that LATS regulates the F-actin formation via interaction with LIMK/Cofilin, which gives rise to the explanation for the synergistic effect of YAP/TAZ activity between the mechanosensing and the Hippo pathways. This is consistent with some recent findings in Drosophila. The overexpression of hpo reduces F-actin at apical sites independent of Yki/YAP, and partially suppresses the F-actin accumulation caused by knocking down the capping proteins (57). By inhibiting the binding of LIMK and LATS while preserving the integrity of their individual phosphorylation function, the synergistic effect of the Hippo and the mechanical transduction will be greatly reduced or diminished. Other actin regulators, such as ENA (68) and zyxin (69), were found to affect Yki/YAP activity synergistically (70), most likely through their actin bundles and stress fiber regulation as well. The experimental study of the YAP/TAZ regulation cascade is difficult, due to the existence of the co-existing alternative interactions and pathways mentioned above. With our computational model, we are able to investigate the proposed interactions or possible mechanisms for the YAP/TAZ regulation in a more comprehensive way. This method facilitates an understanding of the complicated interactions and pathways in an alternative and efficient manner. There are also some parts in need of further clarifications. Currently the model mostly studies the single cell stiffness-sensing mechanism in an EGF-sufficient environment, and is not focused on multicellular environments or cell-cell adhesion or stress. The changing of EGF or serum dose can also be rate-limiting factors for this stiffness sensing and YAP/TAZ signaling pathway and is not considered in the model. That said, as mentioned in the methods section, our model can be extended to include other molecules, such as the Hippo upstream regulators or PI3K, which are also known to affect YAP/TAZ activity. Secondly, it has been demonstrated that expressing kinase-dead FAK in FAK-/- cells prevented growth, which is consistent with our model. However, FAK-/- cells exhibit an excessive adhesion formation and uncontrolled proliferation (52). This suggests that the absence of FAK, rather than inactive FAK, triggers an alternative pathway activation (51, 52, 71). Nevertheless, the FAK-null cells have been shown to be unable to detect soft versus rigid substrata (72). Thus here our predictions and analysis of FAK activity are restricted to the regime of the downregulation of its total amount or the phosphorylation rate change, rather than the complete knockout of FAK. There have also been studies reported in literature showing the mechanical feedback of F-actin stiffening on ECM properties (73). However, the role of biochemical signaling transduction during this process is not well known and thus this feedback is not currently included in the model. Overall, our model provides a platform to study mechanical regulation and molecular crosstalk of YAP/TAZ upstream regulators. It will be interesting to combine our stiffness-sensing model with models such as the effect of growth factor stimulation to explore potential interactions between various stimuli. Likewise, it is also important to extend the model in a multicellular context to capture the in vivo complexity. To this purpose, 14 incorporating cell-cell adhesion and its effect on the dynamics of the canonical Hippo pathway into our model will provide useful insights. Considering that the mechanical effects can regulate YAP/TAZ independent of the canonical Hippo pathway, and the cell size control mechanism is very similar to the one of stiffness sensing (7), we believe that our current model can be useful and quantitatively predictive in a multicellular environment in elucidating key processes that are too costly to investigate or remain experimentally intractable. Author Contributions M.S., F.S. and M.H.Z developed the concepts and designed the models, M.S. implemented the simulations, M. S. and F. S. performed data analysis, and M.S, F.S. and M.H.Z wrote the article. Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge research support from the National Institutes of Health (U01-CA177799) and the National Science Foundation (DMR-1206635) for this work. We deeply appreciate the input from members of our lab during this research, and especially Robert J. Seager and Dan Reynolds for useful comments on our manuscript. Supporting Citations References (74–80) appear in the Supporting Material. Reference 1. Zhao, B., X. Wei, W. Li, R.S. Udan, Q. Yang, J. Kim, J. Xie, T. Ikenoue, J. Yu, L. Li, P. Zheng, K. Ye, A. Chinnaiyan, G. Halder, Z. Lai, and K. Guan. 2007. Inactivation of YAP oncoprotein by the Hippo pathway is involved in cell contact inhibition and tissue growth control. Genes Dev. : 2747–2761. 2. Piccolo, S., S. Dupont, and M. Cordenonsi. 2014. The biology of YAP/TAZ: hippo signaling and beyond. Physiol. Rev. 94: 1287–312. 3. Low, B.C., C.Q. Pan, G. V Shivashankar, A. Bershadsky, M. Sudol, and M. Sheetz. 2014. YAP/TAZ as mechanosensors and mechanotransducers in regulating organ size and tumor growth. FEBS Lett. 588: 2663–2670. 4. Goulev, Y., J.D. Fauny, B. Gonzalez-Marti, D. Flagiello, J. Silber, and A. Zider. 2008. SCALLOPED Interacts with YORKIE, the Nuclear Effector of the Hippo Tumor-Suppressor Pathway in Drosophila. Curr. Biol. 18: 435–441. 5. Ren, F., L. Zhang, and J. Jiang. 2010. Hippo signaling regulates Yorkie nuclear localization and activity through 14-3-3 dependent and independent mechanisms. Dev. Biol. 337: 303–312. 6. Moore, J.D. 2001. The Ran-GTPase and cell-cycle control. BioEssays. 23: 77–85. 7. Aragona, M., T. Panciera, A. Manfrin, S. Giulitti, F. Michielin, N. Elvassore, S. Dupont, and S. Piccolo. 2013. A mechanical checkpoint controls multicellular growth through YAP/TAZ regulation by actin-processing factors. Cell. 154: 1047–1059. 8. Dupont, S., L. Morsut, M. Aragona, E. Enzo, S. Giulitti, M. Cordenonsi, F. Zanconato, J. Le Digabel, M. Forcato, S. Bicciato, N. Elvassore, and S. Piccolo. 2011. Role of YAP/TAZ in mechanotransduction. Nature. 474: 179–183. 15 9. Discher, D.E., P. Janmey, and Y. Wang. 2005. Tissue Cells Feel and Respond to the Stiffness of Their Substrate. Sci. . 310 : 1139–1143. 10. Sun, M., A.B. Bloom, and M.H. Zaman. 2015. Rapid Quantification of 3D Collagen Fiber Alignment and Fiber Intersection Correlations with High Sensitivity. PLoS One. 10: e0131814. 11. Provenzano, P.P., D.R. Inman, K.W. Eliceiri, and P.J. Keely. 2009. Matrix density-induced mechanoregulation of breast cell phenotype, signaling and gene expression through a FAK-ERK linkage. Oncogene. 28: 4326–4343. 12. Lo, C.-M., H.-B. Wang, M. Dembo, and Y. Wang. 2000. Cell Movement Is Guided by the Rigidity of the Substrate. Biophys. J. 79: 144–152. 13. Wu, C., S.B. Asokan, M.E. Berginski, E.M. Haynes, N.E. Sharpless, J.D. Griffith, S.M. Gomez, and J.E. Bear. 2012. Arp2/3 is critical for lamellipodia and response to extracellular matrix cues but is dispensable for chemotaxis. Cell. 148: 973–987. 14. Engler, A.J., S. Sen, H.L. Sweeney, and D.E. Discher. 2006. Matrix Elasticity Directs Stem Cell Lineage Specification. Cell. 126: 677–689. 15. Tang, Y., R.G. Rowe, E.L. Botvinick, A. Kurup, A.J. Putnam, M. Seiki, V.M. Weaver, E.T. Keller, S. Goldstein, J. Dai, D. Begun, T. Saunders, and S.J. Weiss. 2013. MT1-MMP-Dependent Control of Skeletal Stem Cell Commitment via a β1-Integrin/YAP/TAZ Signaling Axis. Dev. Cell. 25: 402–416. 16. Berrier, A.L., and K.M. Yamada. 2007. Cell–matrix adhesion. J. Cell. Physiol. 213: 565–573. 17. Harunaga, J.S., and K.M. Yamada. 2011. Cell-matrix adhesions in 3D. Matrix Biol. 30: 363–368. 18. Hanks, S.K., and T.R. Polte. 1997. Signaling through focal adhesion kinase. Bioessays. 19: 137–145. 19. Mitra, S.K., and D.D. Schlaepfer. 2006. Integrin-regulated FAK–Src signaling in normal and cancer cells. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 18: 516–523. 20. Schaller, M.D., J.D. Hildebrand, J.D. Shannon, J.W. Fox, R.R. Vines, and J.T. Parsons. 1994. Autophosphorylation of the focal adhesion kinase, pp125FAK, directs SH2-dependent binding of pp60src. Mol. Cell. Biol. . 14 : 1680–1688. 21. Calalb, M.B., T.R. Polte, and S.K. Hanks. 1995. Tyrosine phosphorylation of focal adhesion kinase at sites in the catalytic domain regulates kinase activity: a role for Src family kinases. Mol. Cell. Biol. 15: 954–963. 22. Paszek, M.J., N. Zahir, K.R. Johnson, J.N. Lakins, G.I. Rozenberg, A. Gefen, C.A. Reinhart-King, S.S. Margulies, M. Dembo, D. Boettiger, D.A. Hammer, and V.M. Weaver. 2005. Tensional homeostasis and the malignant phenotype. Cancer Cell. 8: 241–254. 23. Levental, K.R., H. Yu, L. Kass, J.N. Lakins, M. Egeblad, J.T. Erler, S.F.T. Fong, K. Csiszar, A. Giaccia, W. Weninger, M. Yamauchi, D.L. Gasser, and V.M. Weaver. 2009. Matrix Crosslinking Forces Tumor Progression by Enhancing Integrin Signaling. Cell. 139: 891–906. 24. Fraley, S.I., Y. Feng, R. Krishnamurthy, D.-H. Kim, A. Celedon, G.D. Longmore, and D. Wirtz. 2010. A distinctive role for focal adhesion proteins in three-dimensional cell motility. Nat. Cell Biol. 12: 598– 604. 25. Khatiwala, C.B., S.R. Peyton, and A.J. Putnam. 2006. Intrinsic mechanical properties of the extracellular matrix affect the behavior of pre-osteoblastic MC3T3-E1 cells. Am. J. Physiol. - Cell Physiol. 290: C1640–C1650. 16 26. Zaman, M.H., L.M. Trapani, A.L. Sieminski, D. MacKellar, H. Gong, R.D. Kamm, A. Wells, D.A. Lauffenburger, and P. Matsudaira. 2006. Migration of tumor cells in 3D matrices is governed by matrix stiffness along with cell-matrix adhesion and proteolysis. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 103: 10889–10894. 27. Mak, M., F. Spill, R.D. Kamm, and M.H. Zaman. 2015. Single-Cell Migration in Complex Microenvironments: Mechanics and Signaling Dynamics. J. Biomech. Eng. . 28. Spill, F., D.S. Reynolds, R.D. Kamm, and M.H. Zaman. 2016. Impact of the physical microenvironment on tumor progression and metastasis. Curr. Opin. Biotechnol. 40: 41–48. 29. Walcott, S., and S.X. Sun. 2010. A mechanical model of actin stress fiber formation and substrate elasticity sensing in adherent cells. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. . 107 : 7757–7762. 30. Halder, G., S. Dupont, and S. Piccolo. 2012. Transduction of mechanical and cytoskeletal cues by YAP and TAZ. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 13: 591–600. 31. Harrison, S.M., T. Knifley, M. Chen, and K.L. O Connor. 2013. LPA, HGF, and EGF utilize distinct combinations of signaling pathways to promote migration and invasion of MDA-MB-231 breast carcinoma cells. BMC Cancer. 13: 501. 32. Asthagiri, a, C.M. Nelson, a F. Horwitz, and D. a Lauffenburger. 1999. Quantitative relationship among integrin ligand-binding, adhesion, and signaling via focal adhesion kinase and extracellular signal-regulated kinase 2. J. Biol. Chem. 274: 27119–27127. 33. Holmes, W.R., B. Lin, A. Levchenko, and L. Edelstein-Keshet. 2012. Modelling cell polarization driven by synthetic spatially graded Rac activation. PLoS Comput. Biol. 8. 34. Onsum, M., and C. V. Rao. 2007. A mathematical model for neutrophil gradient sensing and polarization. PLoS Comput. Biol. 3: 0436–0450. 35. Tania, N., J. Condeelis, and L. Edelstein-Keshet. 2013. Modeling the synergy of cofilin and Arp2/3 in lamellipodial protrusive activity. Biophys. J. 105: 1946–1955. 36. Tania, N., E. Prosk, J. Condeelis, and L. Edelstein-Keshet. 2011. A temporal model of cofilin regulation and the early peak of actin barbed ends in invasive tumor cells. Biophys. J. 100: 1883–1892. 37. Tao, J., and S.X. Sun. 2015. Active Biochemical Regulation of Cell Volume and a Simple Model of Cell Tension Response. Biophys. J. 109: 1541–1550. 38. Pollard, T.D., L. Blanchoin, and R.D. Mullins. 2000. Molecular Mechanisms Controlling Actin Filament Dynamics in Nonmuscle Cells. Annu. Rev. Biophys. Biomol. Struct. 29: 545–576. 39. Sarvestani, A.S. 2013. The effect of substrate rigidity on the assembly of specific bonds at biological interfaces. Soft Matter. : -. 40. Giannone, G., and M.P. Sheetz. 2006. Substrate rigidity and force define form through tyrosine phosphatase and kinase pathways. Trends Cell Biol. 16: 213–223. 41. Wozniak, M.A., R. Desai, P.A. Solski, C.J. Der, and P.J. Keely. 2003. ROCK-generated contractility regulates breast epithelial cell differentiation in response to the physical properties of a three-dimensional collagen matrix. J. Cell Biol. 163: 583–595. 42. Sakamoto, S., T. Ishizaki, K. Okawa, S. Watanabe, T. Arakawa, N. Watanabe, and S. Narumiya. 2012. Liprin-controls stress fiber formation by binding to mDia and regulating its membrane localization. J. Cell Sci. 125: 108–120. 43. Loria, P.M., A. Duke, J.B. Rand, and O. Hobert. 2003. The Mouse Formin mDia1 Is a Potent Actin 17 Nucleation Factor Regulated by Autoinhibition. Curr. Biol. 13: 1317–1323. 44. Narumiya, S., M. Tanji, and T. Ishizaki. 2009. Rho signaling, ROCK and mDia1, in transformation, metastasis and invasion. Cancer Metastasis Rev. 28: 65–76. 45. Higashida, C., T. Miyoshi, A. Fujita, F. Oceguera-Yanez, J. Monypenny, Y. Andou, S. Narumiya, and N. Watanabe. 2004. Actin Polymerization-Driven Molecular Movement of mDia1 in Living Cells. Sci. . 303 : 2007–2010. 46. Higashida, C., S. Suetsugu, T. Tsuji, J. Monypenny, S. Narumiya, and N. Watanabe. 2008. G-actin regulates rapid induction of actin nucleation by mDia1 to restore cellular actin polymers. J. Cell Sci. 121: 3403–3412. 47. Totsukawa, G., Y. Yamakita, S. Yamashiro, D.J. Hartshorne, Y. Sasaki, and F. Matsumura. 2000. Distinct roles of ROCK (Rho-kinase) and MLCK in spatial regulation of MLC phosphorylation for assembly of stress fibers and focal adhesions in 3T3 fibroblasts. J. Cell Biol. 150: 797–806. 48. Bamburg, J.R., and B.W. Bernstein. 2010. Roles of ADF/cofilin in actin polymerization and beyond. F1000 Biol. Rep. 2: 62. 49. Trappmann, B., J.E. Gautrot, J.T. Connelly, D.G.T. Strange, Y. Li, M.L. Oyen, M.A. Cohen Stuart, H. Boehm, B. Li, V. Vogel, J.P. Spatz, F.M. Watt, and W.T.S. Huck. 2012. Extracellular-matrix tethering regulates stem-cell fate. Nat. Mater. 11: 642–9. 50. Connelly, J.T., J.E. Gautrot, B. Trappmann, D.W.-M. Tan, G. Donati, W.T.S. Huck, and F.M. Watt. 2010. Actin and serum response factor transduce physical cues from the microenvironment to regulate epidermal stem cell fate decisions. Nat. Cell Biol. 12: 711–718. 51. Mitra, S.K., D.A. Hanson, and D.D. Schlaepfer. 2005. Focal adhesion kinase: in command and control of cell motility. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 6: 56–68. 52. Pirone, D.M., W.F. Liu, S.A. Ruiz, L. Gao, S. Raghavan, C.A. Lemmon, L.H. Romer, and C.S. Chen. 2006. An inhibitory role for FAK in regulating proliferation: a link between limited adhesion and RhoA-ROCK signaling. J. Cell Biol. . 174 : 277–288. 53. Kumar, S., A. Das, and S. Sen. 2014. Extracellular matrix density promotes EMT by weakening cell-cell adhesions. Mol. Biosyst. 10: 838–50. 54. Zhai, J., H. Lin, Z. Nie, J. Wu, R. Cañete-Soler, W.W. Schlaepfer, and D.D. Schlaepfer. 2003. Direct Interaction of Focal Adhesion Kinase with p190RhoGEF. J. Biol. Chem. . 278 : 24865–24873. 55. Guilluy, C., V. Swaminathan, R. Garcia-Mata, E.T. O'Brien, R. Superfine, and K. Burridge. 2011. The Rho GEFs LARG and GEF-H1 regulate the mechanical response to force on integrins. Nat. Cell Biol. 13: 722–727. 56. Bernstein, B.W., and J.R. Bamburg. 2010. ADF/Cofilin: a functional node in cell biology. Trends Cell Biol. 20: 187–195. 57. Fernández, B.G., P. Gaspar, C. Brás-Pereira, B. Jezowska, S.R. Rebelo, and F. Janody. 2011. Actin-Capping Protein and the Hippo pathway regulate F-actin and tissue growth in Drosophila. Development. 138: 2337–2346. 58. Kannan, N., and V.W. Tang. 2015. Synaptopodin couples epithelial contractility to α-actinin-4– dependent junction maturation. J. Cell Biol. . 211 : 407–434. 59. Toh, Y.-C., C. Zhang, J. Zhang, Y.M. Khong, S. Chang, V.D. Samper, D. van Noort, D.W. Hutmacher, and H. Yu. 2007. A novel 3D mammalian cell perfusion-culture system in microfluidic channels. Lab 18 Chip. 7: 302–9. 60. LI, S., J. LAO, B.P.C. CHEN, Y.-S. LI, Y. ZHAO, J. CHU, K.-D. CHEN, T.-C. TSOU, K. PECK, and S.H.U. CHIEN. 2003. Genomic analysis of smooth muscle cells in 3-dimensional collagen matrix. FASEB J. . 17 : 97–99. 61. Peyton, S.R., P.D. Kim, C.M. Ghajar, D. Seliktar, and A.J. Putnam. 2008. The effects of matrix stiffness and RhoA on the phenotypic plasticity of smooth muscle cells in a 3-D biosynthetic hydrogel system. Biomaterials. 29: 2597–2607. 62. Zi, Z. 2011. Sensitivity analysis approaches applied to systems biology models. IET Syst. Biol. 5: 336. 63. Kim, N.-G., and B.M. Gumbiner. 2015. Adhesion to fibronectin regulates Hippo signaling via the FAK– Src–PI3K pathway. J. Cell Biol. . 210 : 503–515. 64. Yang, X., K. Yu, Y. Hao, D. Li, R. Stewart, K.L. Insogna, and T. Xu. 2004. LATS1 tumour suppressor affects cytokinesis by inhibiting LIMK1. Nat. Cell Biol. 6: 609–617. 65. Kanellos, G., J. Zhou, H. Patel, R.A. Ridgway, D. Huels, C.B. Gurniak, E. Sandilands, N.O. Carragher, O.J. Sansom, W. Witke, V.G. Brunton, and M.C. Frame. 2015. ADF and Cofilin1 Control Actin Stress Fibers, Nuclear Integrity, and Cell Survival. Cell Rep. . 66. Lechler, T., A. Shevchenko, A. Shevchenko, and R. Li. 2000. Direct involvement of yeast type I myosins in Cdc42-dependent actin polymerization. J. Cell Biol. 148: 363–373. 67. Huckaba, T.M., T. Lipkin, and L. a. Pon. 2006. Roles of type II myosin and a tropomyosin isoform in retrograde actin flow in budding yeast. J. Cell Biol. 175: 957–969. 68. Krause, M., E.W. Dent, J.E. Bear, J.J. Loureiro, and F.B. Gertler. 2003. Ena/VASP proteins: regulators of the actin cytoskeleton and cell migration. Annu. Rev. Cell Dev. Biol. 19: 541–564. 69. Harborth, J., S.M. Elbashir, K. Bechert, T. Tuschl, and K. Weber. 2001. Identification of essential genes in cultured mammalian cells using small interfering RNAs. J. Cell Sci. 114: 4557–4565. 70. Gaspar, P., M. V. Holder, B.L. Aerne, F. Janody, and N. Tapon. 2015. Zyxin antagonizes the FERM protein expanded to couple f-actin and yorkie-dependent organ growth. Curr. Biol. 25: 679–689. 71. Playford, M.P., K. Vadali, X. Cai, K. Burridge, and M.D. Schaller. 2008. Focal Adhesion Kinase regulates cell–cell contact formation in epithelial cells via modulation of Rho. Exp. Cell Res. 314: 3187– 3197. 72. Wang, H.-B., M. Dembo, S.K. Hanks, and Y. Wang. 2001. Focal adhesion kinase is involved in mechanosensing during fibroblast migration. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. . 98 : 11295–11300. 73. Provenzano, P.P., K.W. Eliceiri, J.M. Campbell, D.R. Inman, J.G. White, and P.J. Keely. 2006. Collagen reorganization at the tumor-stromal interface facilitates local invasion. BMC Med. 4: 38. 74. Yarmola, E.G., T. Somasundaram, T. a. Boring, I. Spector, and M.R. Bubb. 2000. Actin-latrunculin a structure and function: Differential modulation of actin-binding protein function by latrunculin A. J. Biol. Chem. 275: 28120–28127. 75. Dawes, A.T., and L. Edelstein-Keshet. 2007. Phosphoinositides and Rho proteins spatially regulate actin polymerization to initiate and maintain directed movement in a one-dimensional model of a motile cell. Biophys. J. 92: 744–768. 76. Feng, J., M. Ito, Y. Kureishi, K. Ichikawa, M. Amano, N. Isaka, K. Okawa, A. Iwamatsu, K. Kaibuchi, D.J. Hartshorne, and T. Nakano. 1999. Rho-associated Kinase of Chicken Gizzard Smooth Muscle. J. 19 Biol. Chem. . 274 : 3744–3752. 77. Ji, H., H. Tang, H. Lin, J. Mao, L. Gao, J.I.A. Liu, and T. Wu. 2014. Rho / Rock cross ‑ talks with transforming growth factor ‑ β / Smad pathway participates in lung fibroblast ‑ myofibroblast differentiation. Biomed. Reports. : 787–792. 78. Cirit, M., M. Krajcovic, C.K. Choi, E.S. Welf, A.F. Horwitz, and J.M. Haugh. 2010. Stochastic model of integrin-mediated signaling and adhesion dynamics at the leading edges of migrating cells. PLoS Comput. Biol. 6. 79. Song, X., X. Chen, H. Yamaguchi, G. Mouneimne, J.S. Condeelis, and R.J. Eddy. 2006. Initiation of cofilin activity in response to EGF is uncoupled from cofilin phosphorylation and dephosphorylation in carcinoma cells. J. Cell Sci. . 119 : 2871–2881. 80. Pollard, T. 1986. Rate constants for the reactions of ATP-and ADP-actin with the ends of actin filaments. J. Cell Biol. 103: 2747. 20 Supporting Materials Supporting Methods Molecular intervention When latrunculin A is employed in vitro, the depolymerization of actin filaments results from sequestration of monomeric actin by latrunculin (1), and the effect in our model is mimicked by changing the polymerization rate of F-actin in the cytoplasm to 1/10 of the original. Overexpression of mDia is mimicked by changing mDia0 to 5- fold. Blebbistatin and Y-27632 inhibit myosin and ROCK, thus we mimic their effects by changing the deactivation rates of myosin kdmy and the one of ROCK to 10- fold. Local sensitivity analysis of YAP/TAZ activity on kinetic parameters Each kinetic parameter is locally up- or down-regulated by 10% individually, the YAP/TAZ activity, quantified by YAP/TAZ nuclear translocation fraction, is calculated ParameterSensitivity = !! YAP /TAZ (k + Δk) − YAP /TAZ N YAP /TAZ (k) N (k) N /( Δk k ) . Here Δk / k = 10% . If parameter sensitivity is 1, the dependence on the correspondent kinetic parameters is linear. If it is larger than 1, it shows the YAP/TAZ activity is highly dependent on the parameters in a way that is more dramatic than the linear dependence, while if it is smaller than 1, then it is the other way around (2). Supporting Figures Figure S1 The FAK activity model comparison. Our model adapts from the previous Michaelis-Menten model of FAK activation rate dependent on ECM ligand density (3, 4). After incorporating the ECM stiffness in the model, we found that the second-order hill function matches the experimental data from previous work (5), with the Michaelis-Menten model not able to capture the increase of FAK activity from soft to stiff environments. 1 Figure S2 Local sensitivity analysis of YAP/TAZ model in soft environment This shows the local sensitivity in YAP/TAZ model by up-regulating the kinetic parameters in a soft environment. In consistent with Figure 2b, the adhesion components in the model have the largest impact on the YAP/TAZ activity. Figure S3 stiffness response function with changing protein contents (a) and (b) are active RhoA fraction and stress fiber content changing along with the stiffness under different amount of FAK. The RhoA activity goes plateau as the stiffness increases. Both the sensitivity range and the plateau position of RhoA change with FAK intervention. (c) The YAP/TAZ stiffness response function shifts vertically by changing total amount of mDia for 3D NMuMG cells as an example. mDia0~1 corresponds the endogenous mDia amount of NMuMG cell in 3D collagen. (d) The stress fiber content stiffness response function changes along the total amount of mDia. The stress fiber content change with stiffness gives rise to the 2 YAP/TAZ stiffness response. As predicted in YAP/TAZ activity, the FAK shifts the stress fiber content stiffness response function horizontally, while other actin molecules such as mDia shifts the stress fiber content stiffness response function vertically. Figure S4 The kinetic parameter analysis of ROCK and mDia Using the same method as in Figure 3b, we analyze the activation rate of ROCK and mDia on YAP/TAZ sensitivity to ECM stiffness, and also compare with SRF/MAL sensitivity. Similar with regulating adhesion and RhoA components, down-regulating ROCK and mDia shows a dramatic effect in the YAP/TAZ sensitivity to stiffness. However, SRF/MAL shows a relative monotonic dependence on mDia activation, which regulates F-actin polymerization. This indicates that SRF/MAL increase rate dependence on F-actin is also monotonic and the increase rate of SRF/MAL in stiff environment is larger than the one in soft environment. The YAP/TAZ sensitivity to stiffness pattern shows that by down-regulating the ROCK and mDia, the YAP/TAZ decrease rate in soft environment is first lower than the one in stiff environment, and then rises the other way. Comparing with the dependence on FAK and RhoA sensitivity analysis, the region of high YAP/TAZ activity is smaller, indicating that there are other more robust regulators limiting the active regime of YAP/TAZ activity. Supporting nondimentionalized model The nondimentionalization has been carried out for the model. The refined parameters are in the Table S1. And we mainly focus on the ECM stiffness in our paper and thus treat ligand density constant. The model is applicable with changing ligand density, as it is adapted from the ligand density dependent adhesion model (3, 4). The variables of proteins are normalized per cell. Most of the proteins involved in YAP/TAZ stiffness sensing have been found to be constant under stiff and soft environment, for example, the total amount of FAK (2), RhoA (2), total actin (3), and YAP/TAZ (4). dfak(t ) dt = ksf E mol(t )2 2 C + E mol(t )2 (1 − fak(t )) − kdf fak(t ) (S1), 3 drhoA(t ) !! dt = k fkρ (γ( fak(t ))2 + 1)(1 − rhoA(t ))− k rhoA(t ) (S2), dρ drock(t ) = k dt drock(t ) = k dt rhoA(t )(1 − rock(t )) − k rρ rock(t ) (S3), drock rhoA(t )(1 − rock(t )) − k rρ rock(t ) (S4), drock dmyo(t ) !! dt = k mr (εT(rock(t )) + 1)(1 − myo(t )) − k dmy myo(t ) (S5), dlimk(t ) dt = k lr(τT(rock(t )) + 1)(1 − limk(t )) − k dl limk(t ) (S6), dcofilin(t ) dt = k turn−over (1 − cofilin(t )) − k (1 − k lats 0 ll cr )limk 2(t )cofilin(t ) (S7), dfcyto(t ) dt = k ra(αT(mdia(t )) + 1)(1 − factin(t )) − (kdep + k fc1cofilin(t )) fcyto(t ) (S8), = (k CN + kCY fcyton(t )myoA(t ))(1 − yaptaz(t )) − (k NC + klylats(t )) yaptaz(t ) dyaptaz(t ) dt (S9), dmal(t ) = dt k cnm (1 − factin(t ))2 (1 − mal(t )) − k mal(t ) (S10), ncm Table S1. The parameter values used in the nondimentionalized model. Parameter k ! k sf df C C fkρ k ! γ k k dρ rρ k drock k mρ Value 0.0175 s-1 0.035 s-1 45 kPa for 3D NMuMG cells 25 kPa for 2D MEC and MSC 0.018 s-1 500 0.625 s-1 2.2 s-1 0.8 s-1 1 s-1 Reference Kumar et al (4) Kumar et al (4) Estimated from Provenzano et al (5) Estimated from Dupont (6) Estimated from Provenzano et al (5) Estimated from Provenzano et al (5) Sako et al (7) Edelstein-Keshet et al (8, 9) Estimated from Feng et al (10) and Ji et al (11) Estimated 4 k dmDia k mr ε k dmy ! k lr τ k dl ! k turn−over ! k cr k ll k ra ! α k dep ! k fc1 k CN k CY k NC k ly k cnm 1 s-1 0.015 s-1 40 0.067s-1 0.07 s-1 200 2 s-1 0.04 s-1 0.7 s-1 0.8 s-1 0.4 s-1 40 3.5 s-1 8 0.1 s-1 20 s-1 3 s-1 6 s-1 0.2s-1 Estimated Estimated Estimated Cirit et al (12) Estimated from Tania et al and Song et al (13, 14) Estimated Estimated from Tania et al and Song et al (13, 14) Tania et al (13) Tania et al (13) Estimated from Yang et al (15) Estimated Estimated from Higashida et al (16) Bonder et al (17) Estimated from Tania et al and Song et al (13, 14) Estimated Estimated Estimated Estimated Estimated from Connelly et al (18) Table S2. Redefinition of the parameters in the nondimentionalized model Parameters in the nondiment- ionalized model C γ k rρ k mρ ε τ Parameters in the dimentionalized model C / LD !! γFAK 2 0 RhoA k !! rρ k !! mρ RhoA 0 0 εROCK !! τROCK !! 0 0 Parameters in the nondiment- ionalized model k ! cr k ll α k k fc1 CY k ly Parameters in the dimentionalized model LIMK k cr 2 0 LATS k !! ll 0 αmDia !! 0 fc1Cofilin0 nMyo0 actin0 k !! k !! CY k ly !! LATS0 5 k ra fak !rhoA rock FAK k ra(1 + β) P / FAK 0 GTP / RhoA RhoA 0 ROCK A / ROCK 0 k cnm !limk cofilin fcyto yaptaz k !! cnm /k mg (1 + β)2 LIMK A / LIMK 0 /Cofilin 0 Cofilin !! NP Fcyto /actin !! 0 0 0 mal mDia Myo !! A / Myo A / mDia (YAP /TAZ )N /(YAP /TAZ ) !! mdia !myo Supporting Reference 1. Yarmola, E.G., T. Somasundaram, T. a. Boring, I. Spector, and M.R. Bubb. 2000. Actin-latrunculin a structure and function: Differential modulation of actin-binding protein function by latrunculin A. J. Biol. Chem. 275: 28120– 28127. Zi, Z. 2011. Sensitivity analysis approaches applied to systems biology models. IET Syst. Biol. 5: 336. N / MAL MAL !! 2. 0 0 3. Asthagiri, a, C.M. Nelson, a F. Horwitz, and D. a Lauffenburger. 1999. Quantitative relationship among integrin ligand-binding, adhesion, and signaling via focal adhesion kinase and extracellular signal-regulated kinase 2. J. Biol. Chem. 274: 27119–27127. 4. Kumar, S., A. Das, and S. Sen. 2014. Extracellular matrix density promotes 5. EMT by weakening cell-cell adhesions. Mol. Biosyst. 10: 838–50. Provenzano, P.P., D.R. Inman, K.W. Eliceiri, and P.J. Keely. 2009. Matrix density-induced mechanoregulation of breast cell phenotype, signaling and gene expression through a FAK-ERK linkage. Oncogene. 28: 4326–4343. 6. Dupont, S. Role of YAP/TAZ in cell-matrix adhesion-mediated signalling and 7. mechanotransduction. Exp. Cell Res. . Sako, Y., K. Hibino, T. Miyauchi, Y. Miyamoto, M. Ueda, and T. Yanagida. 2000. Single-Molecule Imaging of Signaling Molecules in Living Cells. Single Mol. 1: 159–163. 8. Holmes, W.R., B. Lin, A. Levchenko, and L. Edelstein-Keshet. 2012. Modelling cell polarization driven by synthetic spatially graded Rac activation. PLoS Comput. Biol. 8. 9. Dawes, A.T., and L. Edelstein-Keshet. 2007. Phosphoinositides and Rho proteins spatially regulate actin polymerization to initiate and maintain directed movement in a one-dimensional model of a motile cell. Biophys. J. 92: 744– 768. 10. Feng, J., M. Ito, Y. Kureishi, K. Ichikawa, M. Amano, N. Isaka, K. Okawa, A. Iwamatsu, K. Kaibuchi, D.J. Hartshorne, and T. Nakano. 1999. Rho-associated Kinase of Chicken Gizzard Smooth Muscle. J. Biol. Chem. . 274 : 3744–3752. Ji, H., H. Tang, H. Lin, J. Mao, L. Gao, J.I.A. Liu, and T. Wu. 2014. Rho / Rock cross ‑ talks with transforming growth factor ‑ β / Smad pathway participates in lung fibroblast ‑ myofibroblast differentiation. Biomed. Reports. : 787–792. 11. 6 12. Cirit, M., M. Krajcovic, C.K. Choi, E.S. Welf, A.F. Horwitz, and J.M. Haugh. 2010. Stochastic model of integrin-mediated signaling and adhesion dynamics at the leading edges of migrating cells. PLoS Comput. Biol. 6. 13. Tania, N., E. Prosk, J. Condeelis, and L. Edelstein-Keshet. 2011. A temporal model of cofilin regulation and the early peak of actin barbed ends in invasive tumor cells. Biophys. J. 100: 1883–1892. 14. Song, X., X. Chen, H. Yamaguchi, G. Mouneimne, J.S. Condeelis, and R.J. Eddy. 2006. Initiation of cofilin activity in response to EGF is uncoupled from cofilin phosphorylation and dephosphorylation in carcinoma cells. J. Cell Sci. . 119 : 2871–2881. 15. Yang, X., K. Yu, Y. Hao, D. Li, R. Stewart, K.L. Insogna, and T. Xu. 2004. LATS1 tumour suppressor affects cytokinesis by inhibiting LIMK1. Nat. Cell Biol. 6: 609–617. 16. Higashida, C., S. Suetsugu, T. Tsuji, J. Monypenny, S. Narumiya, and N. Watanabe. 2008. G-actin regulates rapid induction of actin nucleation by mDia1 to restore cellular actin polymers. J. Cell Sci. 121: 3403–3412. 17. Pollard, T. 1986. Rate constants for the reactions of ATP-and ADP-actin with the ends of actin filaments. J. Cell Biol. 103: 2747. 18. Connelly, J.T., J.E. Gautrot, B. Trappmann, D.W.-M. Tan, G. Donati, W.T.S. Huck, and F.M. Watt. 2010. Actin and serum response factor transduce physical cues from the microenvironment to regulate epidermal stem cell fate decisions. Nat. Cell Biol. 12: 711–718. 7
1302.3196	1	1302	2013-02-13T19:28:03	Biophysics of filament length regulation by molecular motors	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.SC" ]	Regulating physical size is an essential problem that biological organisms must solve from the subcellular to the organismal scales, but it is not well understood what physical principles and mechanisms organisms use to sense and regulate their size. Any biophysical size-regulation scheme operates in a noisy environment and must be robust to other cellular dynamics and fluctuations. This work develops theory of filament length regulation inspired by recent experiments on kinesin-8 motor proteins, which move with directional bias on microtubule filaments and alter microtubule dynamics. Purified kinesin-8 motors can depolymerize chemically-stabilized microtubules. In the length-dependent depolymerization model, the rate of depolymerization tends to increase with filament length, because long filaments accumulate more motors at their tips and therefore shorten more quickly. When balanced with a constant filament growth rate, this mechanism can lead to a fixed polymer length. However, the mechanism by which kinesin-8 motors affect the length of dynamic microtubules in cells is less clear. We study the more biologically realistic problem of microtubule dynamic instability modulated by a motor-dependent increase in the filament catastrophe frequency. This leads to a significant decrease in the mean filament length and a narrowing of the filament length distribution. The results improve our understanding of the biophysics of length regulation in cells.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Biophysics of filament length regulation by molecular motors Hui-Shun Kuan Program in Chemical Physics and Biofrontiers Institute, University of Colorado at Boulder M. D. Betterton Department of Physics and Biofrontiers Institute, University of Colorado at Boulder∗ (Dated: September 16, 2018) Regulating physical size is an essential problem that biological organisms must solve from the subcellular to the organismal scales, but it is not well understood what physical prin- ciples and mechanisms organisms use to sense and regulate their size. Any biophysical size-regulation scheme operates in a noisy environment2 and must be robust to other cel- lular dynamics and fluctuations. This work develops theory of filament length regulation inspired by recent experiments on kinesin-8 motor proteins, which move with directional bias on microtubule filaments and alter microtubule dynamics. Purified kinesin-8 motors can depolymerize chemically-stabilized microtubules. In the length-dependent depolymer- ization model, the rate of depolymerization tends to increase with filament length, because long filaments accumulate more motors at their tips and therefore shorten more quickly. When balanced with a constant filament growth rate, this mechanism can lead to a fixed polymer length. However, the mechanism by which kinesin-8 motors affect the length of dynamic microtubules in cells is less clear. We study the more biologically realistic problem of microtubule dynamic instability modulated by a motor-dependent increase in the filament catastrophe frequency. This leads to a significant decrease in the mean filament length and a narrowing of the filament length distribution. The results improve our understanding of the biophysics of length regulation in cells. I. INTRODUCTION A fundamental question in biology is how organisms control the size of subcellular structures, cells, organs, and whole organisms. The physical principles underlying the sensing and control of size in biology are not well understood; indeed, whether there are general principles or mechanisms in size control is unclear [1 -- 3]. In particular, the regulation of polymer length is important for the organization of the cellular cytoskeleton. Regulation of cytoskeletal filaments affects both the size of subcellular organelles such as the mitotic spindle [4, 5] and the structure of cells themselves [6, 7]. Microtubules are an important cytoskeletal filament that contribute to cell structure, affect the distribution of other cytoskeletal filaments, move chromosomes during cell division, and serve as tracks for transport within the cell. This paper focuses on the regulation of microtubule length. Microtubules undergo complex, nonequilibrium polymerization dynamics, known as dynamic instability, characterized by stochastic switching between distinct growing and shrinking states. When dynamic microtubules polymerize in vitro from purified tubulin protein, dynamic instability leads to a broad distribution of polymer lengths [8]. However, in cells other proteins are also present which modify microtubule dynamics, particularly at the plus ends of microtubules [9]. This allows cells to control tubulin polymerization dynamics to give microtubules of regulated length. A relatively well-studied example of length regulation of microtubule-based structures is the control of flagellar length in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, where the assembly and disassembly ∗ [email protected] 2 of the flagellum is controlled to give a fixed flagellar length [10]. However, in general it is not well understood how cells control the length of their microtubules. Recently an example of physically-based microtubule length detection and control was proposed, based on motor proteins that walk with directional bias on a microtubule and shorten a stabilized (non-polymerizing) microtubule from its plus end [11 -- 13]. If the motors are processive (unbinding slowly from the microtubule), then a long filament can accumulate large numbers of motors at its end, and the shortening rate is high; for a short filament fewer motors reach the end, and shortening slows. This length-dependent depolymerization has been demonstrated for the kinesin-8 protein Kip3p moving on stabilized microtubules. The physical interactions of motors moving on the filament allow a physical process (the rate of depolymerization) to vary with the filament length, thereby allowing sensing of the length [12 -- 14]. By coupling this length-sensitive depolymerization with other processes (for example, a constant filament growth rate) a specific filament length or narrow filament-length distribution could in principle be achieved [12]. To understand the biological relevance of length-dependent depolymerization, it is important to make a connection between the biophysically measured effects of purified proteins on stabilized microtubules and the more complex situation in cells. Stabilized microtubules have little or no intrinsic length dynamics, while in cells microtubules undergo dynamic instability. Other proteins can also modify microtubule dynamics. Therefore, the kinesin-8 length-dependent depolymeriza- tion process will be affected by microtubule length fluctuations and the presence of other proteins at microtubule tips. In general, any biophysical mechanism of length regulation must be robust to noise in the cellular environment. Recent work suggests that direct length-dependent depolymerization may not be occurring in cells; instead, kinesin-8 proteins may act to promote catastrophe (the transition from growing to shrinking). Extensive experiments have demonstrated that deletions or knockdowns of kinesin- 8 proteins in cells result in longer microtubules and mitotic spindles as well as an increase in chromosome loss in mitosis [11, 15 -- 21]. Other work has shown that kinesin-8 activity is associated with destabilization of microtubules and other alterations in microtubule dynamics [11 -- 13, 15, 20, 22 -- 35]. While the molecular mechanisms of kinesin-8 protein function are not clear, it appears that not all kinesin-8 proteins are able to depolymerize stabilized microtubules [26, 35, 36]. Both experimental evidence [11, 25, 29, 35] and modeling work [37] suggest that in cells kinesin-8 proteins may act to promote catastrophe of dynamic microtubules. Therefore, it is necessary to understand the consequences of length-dependent changes in microtubule dynamic instability to predict the effects of these motors in cells. This will improve our general question of how length-sensing mechanisms are altered by fluctuations and dynamics in biological systems. Previous theory and modeling work has addressed aspects of kinesin 8 behavior and length regulation. Several papers have focused on modeling the physical effects important to describe the length-dependent depolymerization of otherwise static filaments [13, 14, 38] or filaments with simplified polymerization kinetics [39 -- 41]. To our knowledge, previous work has not examined the effect of catastrophe-promoting motors on the length distribution of microtubules undergoing dynamic instability. Tischer et al. used a similar formalism to that in this paper in a model for how length-dependent microtubule catastrophe and rescue rates affect the density of cargo-carrying motors along microtubules, an effect that could be used to target cargo delivery to specific cellular locations [42]. In this paper, we develop a simplified physical theory to compare two scenarios for length regula- tion: for length regulation by depolymerization we calculate the steady-state length that is reached by a constantly growing filament balanced by depolymerizing motors, while for length regulation by altering catastrophe we consider filaments undergoing dynamic instability with alterations in the dynamics due to motors. We consider two possible mechanisms of motor action at the microtubule tip, both the minimal model in which motor effects (depolymerization or catastrophe) increase 3 FIG. 1. Schematic of the model. (A) Model of length regulation by depolymerization. Filament growth at the plus end is balanced by motor-induced depolymerization. Motors bind to and unbind from the filament, move toward the filament plus end, and catalyze removal of filament subunits from the plus end. This leads to a length-dependent depolymerization rate, so a single filament length is favored, depending on the model parameters. (B) Model of length regulation by altering catastrophe. The filament undergoes dynamic instability at its plus end, characterized by stochastic transitions between growing (blue) and shrinking (green) states. Motors bind to and unbind from the filament, move toward the filament plus end, and catalyze catastrophe (transition from the growing to the shrinking state) at the filament plus end. Motor effects make the catastrophe frequency length dependent, which leads to a broad distribution of filament lengths determined by the properties of the motors. in proportion to the motor density [14, 38, 41] and the cooperative model in which motor effects (depolymerization or catastrophe) increase in proportion to the flux of motors to the filament end [13]. These two models show important differences in their effects on length regulation, suggesting that cellular length regulation could be sensitive to the precise mechanism. We find consistent qualitative agreement between mean-field theory and stochastic simulation; in some parameter regimes the two approaches agree quantitatively. II. MOTOR DYNAMICS ALONG FILAMENT The mean-field density of the motors along the filament, ρ(x, t), in units of motors per unit length is described by [43] ∂ρ ∂t = −v ∂ ∂x (cid:18) (cid:20) ρ (cid:19)(cid:21) (cid:18) (cid:19) 1 − ρ ρmax + konc 1 − ρ ρmax − koff ρ. (1) On the right hand side, the first term describes biased motion of the motors with speed v, where crowding effects reduce the motor flux [43] and ρmax is the maximum possible motor density. The second term describes binding of motors to unoccupied sites at rate per unit length konc. The third term describes unbinding of motors from occupied sites at rate koff . This formulation assumes a continuum limit in which the lattice spacing a → 0 so that the motor density can be treated as continuous in x. The bulk motor concentration c is assumed constant, i.e., the binding of motors to the filament is assumed not to deplete the pool of motors in the bulk. Note that we do not consider protofilament interactions within a microtubule, so we are effectively considering a single-protofilament microtubule (figure 1). For relatively low motor density, we neglect crowding effects in the drift term, which makes the density equation linear. In addition, we work with the motor fractional occupancy p(x, t) = (A) Length regulation by depolymerization(B) Length regulation by altering catastropheGrowing filamentShrinking filamentMotor-inducedcatastropheGrowing filamentMotor-induceddepolymerizationρ(x, t)/ρmax, so the density equation can be written ∂p ∂t = −v ∂p ∂x + konc ρmax (1 − p) − koff p. 4 (2) With the initial condition p(x, t) = 0 at time t = 0 and the boundary condition p(x = 0, t) = 0, the solution to this equation is (cid:40) p(x, t) = p0(1 − e−t/τ ), x ≥ vt (short time) p0(1 − e−x/λ), x < vt (long time) (3) The steady-state occupancy away from the filament ends is p0 = konc/(koff ρmax + konc), the time scale τ = 1/(koff + konc/ρmax), and the length scale λ = v/(koff + konc/ρmax) = vτ . At long time, the density approaches the steady state profile which is constant away from the filament end but has a boundary layer for small x where transport effects and boundary conditions change the motor density away from p0 [39, 43, 44]. III. LENGTH REGULATION BY DEPOLYMERIZATION Here we study the regulation of filament length assuming the motors directly depolymerize the filament from its plus end, an effect which is balanced by a constant rate of filament growth (figure 1A). This approach neglects fluctuations due to microtubule dynamic instability, and so the resulting length is deterministically reached. We suppose that a filament grows with constant speed u. We consider two simple models for the dynamics of the plus end end. (We assume that the filament minus end is not dynamic.) For density-controlled depolymerization, the motor- induced depolymerization rate is proportional to the motor occupancy at the end [14, 38, 41]. For flux-controlled depolymerization, the motor-induced depolymerization rate is proportional to the motor flux to the end [13, 38]. We assume that the motors move faster than the growth (v > u), so the motors track the end as observed experimentally. We therefore assume that the motor occupancy away from the filament end reaches the steady-state value p(x) = p0(1 − e−x/λ). Dimensional analysis suggests that the filament length reached should be related the boundary layer length scale λ = v/(koff + konc/ρmax) = vτ , the obvious length scale that can be constructed from the rates in the problem. However, the steady-state filament length is quite different from λ and is controlled by the dynamics at the end of the filament. This model is related to recent work that also considered the balance between depolymerizing motors and filament kinetics described by constant growth [39, 41] or treadmilling [40]. The model here is simplified compared to the previous work, to allow the derivation of analytic expressions for the length achieved and to allow comparison to the results for filaments undergoing dynamic instability. A. Density-controlled depolymerization In the density-controlled model, we assume that the depolymerization rate is proportional to the motor density at the terminal site of the microtubule [14]. We assume that only the motor occupancy at the last site of the filament is important for depolymerization, i.e., we neglect possible cooperative effects. Define pe(t) to be the average motor occupancy at the last site on the filament, 5 FIG. 2. Filament dynamics and steady-state filament length for length regulation by depolymerization. Blue (top), density-controlled depolymerization; red (bottom), flux-controlled depolymerization. Left, example trace of filament length versus time in the stochastic simulation for c = 10 nM. Middle, normalized filament length distribution in the stochastic simulation for c = 10 nM, averaged from 10 stochastic simulations after removal of the initial transient. Right, steady-state filament length predictions of mean-field theory and the stochastic simulation (error bars are standard deviations of steady-state length distributions). The steady- state length varies rapidly with the bulk motor concentration. The two models give similar predictions, and the approximate expressions (eqns 7 and 10) for the steady-state length are within a factor of two of the exact expressions (eqns 6 and 9) except for very low bulk motor concentrations. The mean-field theory uses the parameters v = 3 µm min−1, kon = 2 nM−1µm−1 min−1, koff = 0.25 min−1, kend off = 1.45 min−1, w = 1.025 µm min−1, a = 8 nm, δ = 8 nm, and ρmax = 125 µm−1; for the density-controlled model u = 1.0 µm min−1 while for the flux-controlled model u = 0.5 µm min−1. The stochastic simulation uses the same parameters except w = 1.5 µm min−1 and kend off = 1 min−1 for the density-controlled model. and the filament length is L(t). The mean-field density-dependent depolymerization model is: (cid:32) v − L (cid:33) pe = L = u − wpe. a p(L − a, t)(1 − pe) − kend off pe, (4) (5) The first term on the right side of equation (4) represents the stepping of motors from the site adjacent to the end to the terminal site on the filament, at rate (v − L)/a. The density at the penultimate site on the filament is p(L− a, t), where a is the lattice spacing, assumed small. If the motor dynamics at the end are faster than the typical time scale of density changes in the bulk of the filament, we can treat the motor density away from the end quasi-statically assuming it is unaffected by the end dynamics. Thus, we write p(L − a, t) ≈ p(L, t), where p(x, t) is the motor occupancy for a region far from the filament end. Because the kinetics of motor removal may be different at the end of the filament, we include crowding effects at the last site even though they are neglected elsewhere along the microtubule. The second term on the right side of equation (4) describes unbinding of the motor at the end. In equation (5), the filament lengthens at constant speed u and shortens at a rate proportional to the motor density at the end, with a maximum speed w. Note that in this model the unbinding of the motor from end of the filament (controlled by the off pe in equation (4)) is decoupled from the depolymerization rate (controlled by term with rate kend the term with rate wpe in equation (5)). This means that we allow processive depolymerization, with a single motor able to remove an average of w/kend off monomers from the filament. The steady-state length in the density-controlled model Lden is reached when L = 0 and pe = 0, 6 which implies pe = u/w and (cid:20) (cid:18) ρmaxakend 1 − uakend p0v(w − u) off (cid:19) off w − u (cid:21) (6) (7) Lden = −λ ln ≈ u konc The approximate solution in equation (7) applies when the second term inside the logarithm of equation (6) is small. Note that there is no steady-state solution if either w < u (in this case the off /(p0v(w − motors can never remove dimers quickly enough to keep up with the growth) or uakend off /(v(w− u)) ≥ 1. Therefore the motor occupancy must be larger than the critical value p0c = uakend u)) for a steady-state length to occur, implying a minimum bulk motor concentration of cc = koff ρmaxakend off ]). In practice given measured motor parameters, reasonable values of the steady-state length require w quite similar to u; the requirement for such fine-tuning of the depolymerization rate suggests that this length-regulation mechanism is not highly robust (figure 2). off /(kon[w(w/u− 1)− akend We show the dependence of the steady-state length on the bulk motor concentration in figure 2. We use parameters similar to those found in experiments [11, 13]. The results of stochastic simulation of density-controlled depolymerization agree qualitatively with the predictions of the mean-field theory (figure 2, details of the simulations are described in section V). The best agree- ment occurs when the stochastic simulation uses a slightly larger motor-induced depolymerization speed w and a slightly lower motor unbinding rate from the filament end kend off than the mean-field theory. In this case the mean filament lengths reached in the two models are similar, but the stochastic simulation shows large fluctuations about the mean length. This is intuitively reason- able since in this model depolymerization is controlled by the motor occupancy at the terminal site of the filament, which undergoes significant fluctuations. B. Flux-controlled depolymerization Varga et al. found that their experimental data for depolymerization of stabilized microtubules by Kip3p are consistent with filament depolymerization being determined by the flux of motors to the end [13]. In this model, a motor would in principle remain bound to the filament end forever, unless displaced from the tip by the arrival of another motor. When unbinding, each motor is assumed to shorten the microtubule by a length δ (where δ could equal the lattice spacing a if each motor removes exactly one tubulin dimers, but could differ from a depending on the motor depolymerization processivity). Therefore the depolymerization speed is w = δJ(L), where J(L) = p(L)ρmax(v− L) is the flux of motors to the end of the filament. Note that steric interactions between motors that decrease the flux are neglected here. The length of the microtubule changes in time according to L = u − w = u − δρmaxp(L) v − L (8) (cid:16) (cid:17) At steady state, δρmaxvp(Lss), and the steady-state length in the flux-controlled model is L = 0 and the motor occupancy is the steady-state value. Therefore u = Lflux = −λ ln ≈ u konc 1 − (cid:19) u p0vδρmax . (cid:21) (cid:20) (cid:18) 1 δ 7 (9) (10) As above, the approximate solution applies when the second term inside the logarithm is small. Note that there is no steady-state solution if u/(vδp0ρm) ≥ 1. This implies that the motor density must be larger than the critical value p0c = u/(vδρmax) for a steady-state length to occur; this corresponds to a critical bulk motor density cc = koff ρmaxu/(kon(vδρmax − u)). This requires vδρmax > u; in practice, for parameters for the budding-yeast motor Kip3 vδρmax must be a few times u to get steady-state lengths of a few microns. We show the dependence of the steady-state length on the bulk motor concentration in figure 2. The results of stochastic simulation of flux-controlled depolymerization agree quantitatively with the predictions of the mean-field theory for identical parameters (figure 2, details of the simulations are described in section V). Compared to the density-controlled depolymerization model, the flux- controlled depolymerization model shows decreased fluctuations and a relatively narrow length distribution. This may occur because in this model depolymerization is controlled by the motor flux to end of the filament, which is a collective property of multiple motors. The structures of the steady-state solutions are similar in the two models, having the approxi- mate form (equations (7) and (10)) L ∼ u/konc times a factor with units of inverse length related to how motors are removed from the end. These approximations to L make clear the strong depen- dence of the steady-state length on the bulk motor concentration, implying that length regulation by this mechanism requires tight regulation of the motor concentration c. In the density-controlled model the motor unbinding rate from the end of the filament and the difference w − u between the maximum speed of depolymerization and the filament growth rate are important in controlling the length reached. In the flux-controlled model the steady-state length takes a simple form, depending primarily on u, konc, and δ. In both cases, there is a minimum motor occupancy required to reach a steady-state length, as expected, because a minimum number of motors is required for depolymerization to balance polymerization. The steady-state filament length is quite different from the dimensional length scale λ which characterizes the motor density profile. IV. LENGTH REGULATION BY ALTERING CATASTROPHE In cells, microtubule filaments typically don't grow constantly as in the simple model above, but instead undergo dynamic instability, characterized by long-lived growing and shrinking regimes with transitions between these two states. Studies of Kip3p in cells [11] and in vitro [29] and of other kinesin-8 motors [25, 35], as well as modeling work [37] suggest that in cells these proteins may act to promote catastrophe (the transition from growing to shrinking) of dynamic microtubules. Therefore, it is necessary to understand the consequences of length-dependent changes in filament dynamics (rather than merely shortening) to predict the effects of these motors in cells. Here we develop a theory of motors that promote filament catastrophe in a length-dependent manner. The number probability density n(L) = nG(L) + nS(L) for filaments of length L is made up of two populations, growing (G) and shrinking (S) filaments. The total number of filaments is N =(cid:82) n(L) dL. In this model, we neglect pauses (neither growth nor shrinkage) exhibited by dynamic microtubules in cells. The distributions evolve according to ∂nG ∂t ∂nS ∂t = −u = w ∂nG ∂L ∂nS ∂L − fcnG + frnS + fcnG − frnS 8 (11) (12) The terms in the first equation represent filament growth with speed u, catastrophe with frequency fc, and rescue with frequency fr. The terms in the second equation represent filament shortening with speed w, catastrophe, and rescue. At steady state, u ∂nG ∂L . The solution to this equation (consistent with the boundary condition that the number of filaments drops to zero as L → ∞) is nS = (u/w)nG. Then the steady-state equation for the total number of filaments n = nG + nS simplifies to ∂L = w ∂nS (cid:18) fc u = − ∂n ∂L − fr w (cid:19) n (13) If the catastrophe and rescue rates are spatially constant, the microtubule length distribution is exponential, n(L) = n0 exp(−(fc/u − fr/w)L), so the distribution is a bounded exponential if fc/u > fr/w and has characteristic length uw/(fcw − fru). In the case of length-dependent rates, we have the formal solution (cid:90) ln n = − dL (cid:19) − fr w (cid:18) fc u (cid:90) (cid:18) − 1 u (cid:19) Here, we assume that only the catastrophe rate fc(L) varies with length (as observed for the kinesin-8 motors Klp5/6 in fission yeast cells [25]), and other rates are all constant. Then n = n0efrL/w exp dL fc(L) (15) (14) A. Density-controlled catastrophe As above, we assume that the motors move faster than the filament growth, so the motors track the end and the motor density is at steady state. In the density-controlled catastrophe model, we assume that the catastrophe frequency increases linearly with the motor occupancy at the end of the filament: The motor occupancy at the end is determined by equation (4). At steady state, the occupancy at the end of the growing filament is f = fc + αpe. (16) pe = b(1 − e−L/λ) off + b(1 − e−L/λ) kend , with b = (v − u)p0/a. Using the integral (cid:90) L 0 dL(cid:48) (1 − e−L(cid:48)/λ) off + b(1 − e−L(cid:48)/λ) kend = L kend off + b − λkend off b(kend off + b) (17) (cid:18) ln 1 + b kend off (cid:19) (1 − e−L/λ) , (18) 9 FIG. 3. Dynamics of length regulation by altering catastrophe. Top, density-controlled model. Bottom, flux- controlled model. Left, example trace of filament length versus time in the stochastic simulation. Middle, catastrophe frequency as a function of filament length, comparing mean-field theory (line) and stochastic simulation (points). Right, length distribution of dynamic filaments for the model with and without motors, comparing mean-field theory and stochastic simulation. The presence of the motors leads to a significant decrease in the mean filament length. This figure uses the parameters v = 3 µm min−1, u = 1 µm min−1, w = 7 µm min−1, minimum catastrophe frequency fc = 0.2 min−1, rescue frequency fr = 0.05 min−1, a = 8 nm, and ρmax = 125 µm−1. For the density-controlled model the parameters are kon = 1 nM−1µm−1 min−1, koff = 0.25 min−1, kend off = 1.5 min−1, bulk motor concentration c = 2 nM, and α = 0.35 min−1. off = 1 min−1and α = 0.38 The simulation of the density-controlled model has the same parameters except kend min−1. For the flux-controlled model the parameters are kon = 3 nM−1µm−1 min−1, koff = 0.25 min−1, bulk motor concentration c = 4 nM, and α = 7 × 10−3. The simulation of the flux-controlled model has the same parameters as the corresponding mean-field theory except kon = 1.5 nM−1µm−1 min−1 and α = 2 × 10−3. the length distribution is n(L) = n0e−((fc+∆f )/u−fr/w)L (cid:18) 1 + (v − u)p0 akend off (cid:19) (1 − e−L/λ) αλkend off +(v−u)p0/a) u(kend off , (19) off + (v − u)p0) is the maximum possible increase in the catastrophe where ∆fden = α(v − u)p0/(akend frequency in the density-controlled model. We see two effects due to motors: first, there is an effective increase in the catastrophe rate of ∆fden. Second, there is an additional multiplicative factor in the length distribution. This factor approaches one in the limit of short filaments (L (cid:28) λ) and for typical experimental parameters varies slowly with L. Note that in this model the unbinding of the motor from end of the filament is controlled by the rate constant kend off . This means that a motor can processively track the end of a depolymerizing filament, and this processivity tends to increase motor concentration at the end of the filament and therefore enhance the filament-shortening effects of motors. B. Flux-controlled catastrophe In the flux-controlled catastrophe model, we assume that the catastrophe frequency increases linearly with the flux of motors to the end: 10 (cid:18) α(v − u)ρmaxp0λ (cid:19) (20) The flux to the end of the microtubule is J = p(L)ρmax(v − u). Note that in this model α is dimensionless and that steric interactions between motors that decrease the flux are neglected. The length distribution is then f = fc + αJ. n = n0e−(fc/u+∆f /u−fr/w)L exp (21) where ∆fflux = α(v − u)ρmaxp0 is the maximum possible increase in the catastrophe frequency in the flux-controlled model. Again, we see two effects from the length-dependent catastrophe: there is an effective increase in the catastrophe rate of ∆fflux, and there is an additional multiplicative factor in the length distribution which is an exponential of an exponential of the length. This factor approaches 1 in the limit of short microtubules (L (cid:28) λ) and approaches the constant factor exp as L → ∞; for typical experimental parameters this factor is of order 1. (cid:16) α(v−u)ρmaxp0λ (cid:17) u (1 − e−L/λ) , u We show simulations of filament length as a function of time, calculations of the variation of catastrophe frequency with filament length and filament length distributions in figure 3. We chose parameters from experiments on the increase in catastrophe frequency associated with the kinesin-8 motor Klp5/6 in fission yeast[25], which found a catastrophe frequency fc = 0.2 min−1 in cells lacking kinesin-8 motors and a length-dependent increase in the catastrophe frequency up to a maximum of 0.5 min−1 for filaments 8 µm long in cells containing motors. With the correct choice of parameters, the length-dependent increase in catastrophe frequency due to motors is qualitatively similar to that measured by Tischer et al. [25]. The results of stochastic simulation are shown for comparison with mean-field theory. For density-controlled catastrophe, there is excellent agreement between stochastic simulation results and mean-field theory if the parameters kend off and α are slightly modified. The flux-controlled catas- trophe model predictions of the dependence of catastrophe frequency on filament length show only rough qualitative agreement with mean-field theory; the shapes of the curves are quite different. Even this level of agreement requires modification of the parameters kon and α. C. Mean filament length The length-dependent catastrophe induced by motors changes the microtubule length distri- bution in two ways: the effective catastrophe frequency increases, and the length distribution is multiplied by an additional function. When the additional change in the functional form due to this multiplication can be neglected, including only the effective increase in the catastrophe frequency gives a simple result for the change in mean filament length. The approximate length distribution is (22) We define ¯L0 = uw/(fcw − fru), the mean filament length in the absence of motors, and the mean length including motor effects is ¯L = ¯L0 − ∆L. The mean length is n(L) = n0e−[(fc+∆f )/u−fr/w]L. (cid:18) fc − u fc − u w fr w fr + ∆f (cid:19) ¯L = ¯L0 (23) 11 FIG. 4. Mean filament length and changes in filament length as a function of motor parameters. Left, variation as a function of bulk motor concentration. Center, variation as a function of motor speed. Right, variation as a function of kend off in the density-controlled model. This figure uses the same parameters as figure 3 except where noted in varying the bulk motor concentration and motor speed: v = 3 µm min−1, u = 1 µm min−1, w = 7 µm min−1, minimum catastrophe frequency fc = 0.2 min−1, rescue frequency fr = 0.05 min−1, a = 8 nm, and ρmax = 125 µm−1. For the density-controlled model the parameters are kon = 1 nM−1µm−1 min−1, koff = 0.25 min−1, kend off = 1.5 min−1, bulk motor concentration c = 2 nM, and α = 0.35 min−1. The simulation of the density-controlled model has the same parameters except kend off = 1 min−1 and α = 0.38 min−1. For the flux-controlled mean-field model the parameters are the same as for the density-controlled mean-field model except kon = 3 nM−1µm−1 min−1 and α = 7× 10−3. The simulation of the flux-controlled model has the same parameters as the corresponding mean-field theory except kon = 1.5 nM−1µm−1 min−1 and α = 2 × 10−3. The fractional change in the mean length is ∆L ¯L0 = fc − u ∆f w fr + ∆f (24) This expression is an approximation that typically overestimates the change in filament length due to motors, but has the advantage that it has a simple analytical form that can be used to understand which parameters control the mean length. The mean filament length is related to the maximum increase in catastrophe frequency that can be achieved by the motors. In the density-controlled model ∆fden = α(v − u)p0/(akend off + (v − u)p0), and in the flux-controlled model ∆fflux = α(v − u)ρmaxp0. The change in the mean filament length varies with the bulk motor concentration (through the occupancy p0), the difference between the filament growth speed and the motor walking speed, and the motor unbinding rate from the filament end in the density-controlled model (figure 4). This suggests that in cells length regulation could be tuned by altering motor concentration, mo- tor/filament velocity, or motor off rate at the end of the filament in the density-controlled model. For typical experimental parameters, the fractional change in mean filament length varies from 0.1 to 0.9 with changes in these parameters. While changes in bulk motor concentration can alter the mean filament length, relatively large changes in the concentration (over two orders of magnitude) lead to only modest changes in mean filament length. We find that in comparison to stochastic simulation the approximate expressions calculated above tend to overstate the changes in mean 12 filament length achievable through bulk motor density changes. Particularly for the flux-controlled model, mean filament length is more sensitive to alterations in motor speed. Varying motor speed over a factor of 4 allows approximately factor of 10 change in the mean filament length. Compar- ison to stochastic simulations shows that mean filament length changes due to variation in motor speed are accurately captured by the approximate model. In the density-controlled model, the rate constant kend off controls the residence time of a motor at the end of a filament. In the limit that this rate becomes large compared to other rates in the problem, the motors rapidly unbind upon reaching the filament end and the changes in filament length due to motors become smaller. The increase in catastrophe due to motors can shift the filament length distribution from the unbounded growth regime to the bounded growth regime. If fr/w > fc/u, the filament dynamics are in the unbounded growth regime, with no defined mean filament length. If the increase in catastrophe due to motors ∆f is large enough, the presence of motors can shift the distribution back to the bounded growth regime characterized by an exponential length distribution and a well-defined mean filament length. This requires that ∆f > fru/w − fc. This relationship implies a minimum motor concentration to shift from unbounded to bounded growth. V. STOCHASTIC SIMULATION We developed a kinetic Monte Carlo simulation of the model as shown in figure 1. The model considers a single filament (equivalent to representing a microtubule by a single protofilament) made up of a varying number of monomers. Each motor occupies a single filament monomer. Typical time scales of motor and filament processes are of order seconds to minutes, so we chose a simulation time step of 0.01 s. At each time step a number of monomers equal to the total number of monomers currently in the the filament is randomly sampled and one step of the polymerization dynamics at the end of the filament is performed. Each site on the filament except the last site has the same rules: a motor can bind to an empty site, if the next site forward is empty a motor can step forward, and a motor can unbind to create an empty site. The behavior of the last site (the end of the filament) varies depending on the model considered. In the model of length regulation by depolymerization (figure 1A), the filament can grow by addition of a monomer. Growth is independent of motor occupancy at the last site. The filament can shrink by one monomer depending on the motor occupancy at the end of the filament. In the density-controlled depolymerization model, removal of the terminal monomer can occur if the terminal site is occupied by a motor. In this model the motor can processively track the depolymerizing filament: if the penultimate site is empty, the motor at the last site steps backward when the terminal monomer is removed. If the second-to-last site is occupied, the motor on the terminal site is removed when the terminal monomer is removed. The motor at the terminal site can also directly unbind from the filament without removal of a monomer. In the flux-controlled depolymerization model, removal of the terminal monomer occurs when the last and penultimate sites are both occupied by motors and the motor at the penultimate site attempts a forward step. In this case the terminal motor and monomer are both removed. In the model of length regulation by catastrophe (figure 1B), the filament stochastically switches between growing and shrinking states. Speeds of growth and shrinkage as well as the rescue frequency are independent of motor occupancy at the last site. The catastrophe frequency is increased depending on the motor occupancy at the end of the filament. In the density-controlled catastrophe model, the catastrophe frequency is increased by α if the terminal site is occupied by a motor. In this model the motor can processively track the depolymerizing filament: if the filament is shortening and the penultimate site is empty, the motor at the last site steps backward when the 13 terminal monomer is removed. If the second-to-last site is occupied, the motor on the terminal site is removed when the terminal monomer is removed. The motor at the terminal site can also directly unbind from the filament without removal of a monomer. In the flux-controlled catastrophe model, the increase in the catastrophe frequency by α occurs when the last and penultimate sites are both occupied by motors and the motor at the penultimate site attempts a forward step. In this case the terminal motor is removed independent of whether or not a catastrophe occurs. In all versions of the model, if the filament fully depolymerizes (0 sites remain) a new filament is nucleated containing 1 site. For each parameter set we performed 5-10 simulations of 106 − 108 time steps. VI. CONCLUSION We have considered an example of biophysical length regulation by motors that walk along a filament and promote filament shortening, inspired by experiments on the effects of kinesin-8 motor proteins on microtubule dynamics. The motors bind to microtubules and move toward their plus ends, and the presence of motors at the filament end alters microtubule polymerization dynamics. The first mechanism we considered is a simplified model of length regulation, in which the motors directly catalyze depolymerization of the filament from its plus end. When the action of the motors is balanced by a constant filament polymerization rate, a steady-state filament length can be reached. This mechanism neglects any fluctuating filament dynamics: only a single steady- state length is reached. In the stochastic simulation, fluctuations due to stochastic motor/filament dynamics lead to a spread about the mean length but the distribution of filament lengths remains strongly peaked. There is a minimum bulk motor concentration on the filament to reach a steady- state length, because if there are too few motors, motor-induced depolymerization can never be fast enough to balance the intrinsic polymerization. In addition, inequalities involving the motor motion constrain the parameter regime where steady-state solutions are possible. The steady- state filament length differs from the length scale λ which characterizes the motor density profile. The steady-state filament length depends sensitively on the bulk motor concentration, implying that this mechanism of length regulation requires tight control of total motor number to operate successfully. Other recent theory work has addressed length regulation due to depolymerizing motors and filament kinetics described by constant growth [39, 41] or treadmilling [40]. Govindan et al. con- sidered a similar model for motor motion, but used an absorbing boundary condition for motors at the filament plus end, an approximation that doesn't apply to filaments with biologically realistic growth and shrinkage rates. Their work found an exponential filament length distribution for typi- cal parameter values corresponding to Kip3 [39]. Melbinger et al. improved the model of Govindan et al. by studying in detail how effects of motor crowding near the microtubule end control the depolymerization dynamics. They discovered a parameter regime in which filament length is well regulated, and how the length depends on motor kinetics [41]. Johann et al. considered the related problem of how length regulation can be achieved by depolymerizing motors on filaments that undergo treadmilling dynamics (addition of subunits at one end and removal at the other) [40]. In the model of length regulation by depolymerization we have discussed, constant growth is bal- anced by length-dependent depolymerization. In the balance-point model of flagellar length regula- tion in Chlamydomonas, a constant rate of flagellar disassembly is balanced by a length-dependent rate of flagellar assembly, leading to a fixed flagellar length [10, 45]. While the underlying micro- scopic mechanisms of flagellar length regulation differ from those discussed here, the conceptual similarity is striking. Perhaps this basic idea of regulating length by making assembly or disas- sembly length-dependent while the other process (disassembly or assembly) is length independent 14 could be a general paradigm for length regulation, at least of microtubule-based structures. A more biologically relevant model for the length regulation of dynamic microtubules is length regulation by altering catastrophe, in which the filament undergoes dynamic instability character- ized by long-lived growing and shrinking states with transitions between growth and shrinkage. The effect of the motors at the end is then not to directly depolymerize the filament but to increase the catastrophe frequency. We calculate how the filament length distribution is altered by the motor-dependent increase in catastrophe frequency, and derive a simple approximate expression that relates the mean filament length to the maximum increase in catastrophe frequency that can be achieved by the motors. The mean filament length varies modestly with bulk motor concentra- tion but is sensitive to the difference between the filament growth speed and the motor walking speed. The increase in catastrophe frequency associated with the kinesin-8 motor Klp5/6 in fission yeast cells was measured by Tischer et al. [25], who found a catastrophe frequency fc = 0.2 min−1 in cells lacking Klp5/6 and a length-dependent increase in the catastrophe frequency up to a maximum of 0.5 min−1 for filaments 8 µm long in cells containing motors. With the correct choice of parameters, our model displays a length-dependent increase in catastrophe frequency due to motors which is qualitatively similar to that measured by Tischer et al. Using these parameters in our model, changes in the mean length of a factor of 2 can be achieved by this mechanism. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank Robert Blackwell, Matt Glaser, Loren Hough and Dick McIntosh for useful discussions. This work was supported by NSF CAREER Award DMR-0847685, NSF MRSEC Grant DMR-0820579, and NIH training grant T32 GM-065103. REFERENCES [1] S. J. Day and P. A. Lawrence. Measuring dimensions: the regulation of size and shape. Development, 127(14):2977 -- 2987, 2000. [2] E. Hafen and H. Stocker. How are the sizes of cells, organs, and bodies controlled? PLoS Biology, 1(3):e86, 2003. [3] Mike Cook and Mike Tyers. Size control goes global. Current Opinion in Biotechnology, 18(4):341 -- 350, August 2007. [4] G. Goshima, R. Wollman, N. Stuurman, J. M. Scholey, and R. D. Vale. Length control of the metaphase spindle. Current Biology, 15(22):1979 -- 1988, 2005. [5] Claire E. Walczak, Timothy J. Mitchison, and Arshad Desai. XKCM1: a xenopus kinesin-related protein that regulates microtubule dynamics during mitotic spindle assembly. Cell, 84(1):37 -- 47, January 1996. [6] F. Rivero, B. Koppel, B. Peracino, S. Bozzaro, F. Siegert, C. J. Weijer, M. Schleicher, R. Albrecht, and A. A. Noegel. The role of the cortical cytoskeleton: F-actin crosslinking proteins protect against osmotic stress, ensure cell size, cell shape and motility, and contribute to phagocytosis and development. Journal of Cell Science, 109(11):2679 -- 2691, November 1996. [7] C. Revenu, R. Athman, S. Robine, and D. Louvard. The co-workers of actin filaments: from cell structures to signals. Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology, 5(8):635 -- 646, 2004. [8] Marileen Dogterom and Stanislas Leibler. Physical aspects of the growth and regulation of microtubule structures. Physical Review Letters, 70(9):1347 -- 1350, March 1993. [9] Anna Akhmanova and Casper C Hoogenraad. Microtubule plus-end-tracking proteins: mechanisms and functions. Current Opinion in Cell Biology, 17(1):47 -- 54, February 2005. 15 [10] Wallace F. Marshall, Hongmin Qin, M´onica Rodrigo Brenni, and Joel L. Rosenbaum. Flagellar length control system: Testing a simple model based on intraflagellar transport and turnover. Molecular Biology of the Cell, 16(1):270 -- 278, January 2005. [11] M. L. Gupta, P. Carvalho, D. M. Roof, and D. Pellman. Plus end-specific depolymerase activity of Kip3, a kinesin-8 protein, explains its role in positioning the yeast mitotic spindle. Nature Cell Biology, 8(9):913 -- 923, 2006. [12] V. Varga, J. Helenius, K. Tanaka, A. A. Hyman, T. U. Tanaka, and J. Howard. Yeast kinesin-8 depolymerizes microtubules in a length-dependent manner. Nature Cell Biology, 8(9):957 -- 962, 2006. [13] Vladimir Varga, Cecile Leduc, Volker Bormuth, Stefan Diez, and Jonathon Howard. Kinesin-8 Motors Act Cooperatively to Mediate Length-Dependent Microtubule Depolymerization. Cell, 138(6):1174, 2009. [14] L. E. Hough, A. Schwabe, M. A. Glaser, J. R. McIntosh, and M. D. Betterton. Microtubule depolymer- ization by the kinesin-8 motor kip3p: a mathematical model. Biophysical Journal, 96(8):3050 -- 3064, 2009. [15] Robert R West, Terra Malmstrom, Cynthia L Troxell, and J R McIntosh. Two related kinesins, klp5+ and klp6+, foster microtubule disassembly and are required for meiosis in fission yeast. Molecular Biology of the Cell, 12(12):3919 -- 32, 2001. [16] Robert R West, Terra Malmstrom, and J Richard McIntosh. Kinesins klp5(+) and klp6(+) are required for normal chromosome movement in mitosis. Journal of Cell Science, 115:931 -- 40, 2002. [17] Miguel Angel Garcia, Nirada Koonrugsa, and Takashi Toda. Two kinesin-like Kin I family proteins in fission yeast regulate the establishment of metaphase and the onset of anaphase A. Current biology, 12(8):610 -- 21, 2002. [18] M. A. Garcia, N. Koonrugsa, and T. Toda. Spindle-kinetochore attachment requires the combined action of Kin I-like Klp5/6 and Alp14/Dis1-MAPs in fission yeast. EMBO Journal, 21(22):6015 -- 6024, 2002. [19] M. S. Savoian, M. K. Gatt, M. G. Riparbelli, G. Callaini, and D. M. Glover. Drosophila Klp67A is required for proper chromosome congression and segregation during meiosis i. Journal of Cell Science, 117(16):3669 -- 3677, 2004. [20] M. I. Mayr, S. Hummer, J. Bormann, T. Gruner, S. Adio, G. Woehlke, and T. U. Mayer. The human kinesin Kif18A is a motile microtubule depolymerase essential for chromosome congression. Current Biology, 17(6):488 -- 498, 2007. [21] K. Jaqaman, E. M. King, A. C. Amaro, J. R. Winter, J. F. Dorn, H. L. Elliott, N. Mchedlishvili, S. E. McClelland, I. M. Porter, M. Posch, et al. Kinetochore alignment within the metaphase plate is regulated by centromere stiffness and microtubule depolymerases. The Journal of Cell Biology, 188(5):665 -- 679, 2010. [22] R. Gandhi, S. Bonaccorsi, D. Wentworth, S. Doxsey, M. Gatti, and A. Pereira. The drosophila kinesin- like protein KLP67A is essential for mitotic and male meiotic spindle assembly. Molecular Biology of the Cell, 15(1):121 -- 131, 2004. [23] M. K. Gatt, M. S. Savoian, M. G. Riparbelli, C. Massarelli, G. Callaini, and D. M. Glover. Klp67A destabilises pre-anaphase microtubules but subsequently is required to stabilise the central spindle. Journal of Cell Science, 118(12):2671 -- 2682, 2005. [24] Amy Unsworth, Hirohisa Masuda, Susheela Dhut, and Takashi Toda. Fission yeast kinesin-8 Klp5 and Klp6 are interdependent for mitotic nuclear retention and required for proper microtubule dynamics. Molecular Biology of the Cell, 19(12):5104, 2008. [25] Christian Tischer, Damian Brunner, and Marileen Dogterom. Force- and kinesin-8-dependent effects in the spatial regulation of fission yeast microtubule dynamics. Molecular Systems Biology, 5, March 2009. Current Biology, 20(4):374 -- 380, 2010. [26] Y. Du, C. A. English, and R. Ohi. The kinesin-8 Kif18A dampens microtubule plus-end dynamics. [27] Carsten Peters, Katju[scaron]a Brejc, Lisa Belmont, Andrew J. Bodey, Yan Lee, Ming Yu, Jun Guo, Roman Sakowicz, James Hartman, and Carolyn A. Moores. Insight into the molecular mechanism of the multitasking kinesin-8 motor. The EMBO Journal, 29(20):3437 -- 3447, September 2010. [28] H. Wang, I. Brust-Mascher, D. Cheerambathur, and J.M. Scholey. Coupling between microtubule sliding, plus-end growth and spindle length revealed by kinesin-8 depletion. Cytoskeleton, 67(11):715 -- 728, 2010. 16 [29] Melissa K. Gardner, Marija Zanic, Christopher Gell, Volker Bormuth, and Jonathon Howard. Depoly- merizing kinesins Kip3 and MCAK shape cellular microtubule architecture by differential control of catastrophe. Cell, 147(5):1092 -- 1103, November 2011. [30] Natsuko Masuda, Tetsuhiro Shimodaira, Shu-Jen Shiu, Noriko Tokai-Nishizumi, Tadashi Yamamoto, and Miho Ohsugi. Microtubule stabilization triggers the plus-end accumulation of Kif18A/kinesin-8. Cell Structure and Function, 36(2):261 -- 7, January 2011. [31] Monika I. Mayr, Marko Storch, Jonathon Howard, and Thomas U. Mayer. A non-motor microtubule binding site is essential for the high processivity and mitotic function of kinesin-8 Kif18A. PLoS One, 6(11):e27471, November 2011. [32] Jason Stumpff, Yaqing Du, Chauca A. English, Zoltan Maliga, Michael Wagenbach, Charles L Asbury, Linda Wordeman, and Ryoma Ohi. A tethering mechanism controls the processivity and kinetochore- microtubule plus-end enrichment of the kinesin-8 Kif18A. Molecular cell, 43(5):764 -- 75, September 2011. [33] X. Su, W. Qiu, M.L. Gupta Jr, J.B. Pereira-Leal, S.L. Reck-Peterson, and D. Pellman. Mecha- nisms underlying the dual-mode regulation of microtubule dynamics by Kip3/kinesin-8. Molecular cell, 43(5):751, 2011. [34] L.N. Weaver, S.C. Ems-McClung, J.R. Stout, C. LeBlanc, S.L. Shaw, M.K. Gardner, and C.E. Walczak. Kif18A uses a microtubule binding site in the tail for plus-end localization and spindle length regulation. Current Biology, 2011. [35] M. Erent, D. R. Drummond, and R. A. Cross. S. pombe kinesins-8 promote both nucleation and catastrophe of microtubules. PloS One, 7(2):e30738, 2012. [36] P. M. Grissom, T. Fiedler, E. L. Grishchuk, D. Nicastro, R. R. West, and J. R. McIntosh. Kinesin-8 from fission yeast: A heterodimeric, plus-end -- directed motor that can couple microtubule depolymerization to cargo movement. Molecular Biology of the Cell, 20(3):963 -- 972, 2009. [37] Ludovic Brun, Beat Rupp, Jonathan J. Ward, and Fran¸cois N´ed´elec. A theory of microtubule catas- trophes and their regulation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 106(50):21173 -- 21178, December 2009. [38] Louis Reese, Anna Melbinger, and Erwin Frey. Crowding of molecular motors determines microtubule depolymerization. Biophysical Journal, 101(9):2190 -- 2200, November 2011. [39] B. S. Govindan, M. Gopalakrishnan, and D. Chowdhury. Length control of microtubules by depoly- merizing motor proteins. Europhysics Letters, 83(4):40006, August 2008. [40] Denis Johann, Christoph Erlenkamper, and Karsten Kruse. Length regulation of active biopolymers by molecular motors. Physical Review Letters, 108(25):258103, June 2012. [41] Anna Melbinger, Louis Reese, and Erwin Frey. Microtubule length regulation by molecular motors. Physical Review Letters, 108(25):258104, June 2012. [42] Christian Tischer, Pieter Rein ten Wolde, and Marileen Dogterom. Providing positional information with active transport on dynamic microtubules. Biophysical Journal, 99(3):726 -- 735, August 2010. [43] A. Parmeggiani, T. Franosch, and E. Frey. Totally asymmetric simple exclusion process with Langmuir kinetics. Physical Review E, 70(4), October 2004. [44] Sarah A. Nowak, Pak-Wing Fok, and Tom Chou. Dynamic boundaries in asymmetric exclusion pro- cesses. Physical Review E, 76(3):031135 -- 11, 2007. [45] Benjamin D. Engel, William B. Ludington, and Wallace F. Marshall. Intraflagellar transport particle size scales inversely with flagellar length: revisiting the balance-point length control model. The Journal of Cell Biology, 187(1):81 -- 89, October 2009.
1104.0876	1	1104	2011-04-05T16:06:29	Direct measurement of the correlated dynamics of the protein-backbone and proximal waters of hydration in mechanically strained elastin	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.SC" ]	We report on the direct measurement of the correlation times of the protein backbone carbons and proximal waters of hydration in mechanically strained elastin by nuclear magnetic resonance methods. The experimental data indicate a decrease in the correlation times of the carbonyl carbons as the strain on the biopolymer is increased. These observations are in good agreement with short 4ns molecular dynamics simulations of (VPGVG)3, a well studied mimetic peptide of elastin. The experimental results also indicate a reduction in the correlation time of proximal waters of hydration with increasing strain applied to the elastomer. A simple model is suggested that correlates the increase in the motion of proximal waters of hydration to the increase in frequency of libration of the protein backbone that develops with increasing strain. Together, the reduction in the protein entropy accompanied with the increase in entropy of the proximal waters of hydration with increasing strain, support the notion that the source of elasticity is driven by an entropic mechanism arising from the change in entropy of the protein backbone.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Direct measurement of the correlated dynamics of the protein-backbone and proximal waters of hydration in mechanically strained elastin Cheng Sun, Odingo Mitchell, Jiaxin Huang and Gregory S. Boutis∗ (Dated: June 6, 2021) We report on the direct measurement of the correlation times of the protein backbone carbons and proximal waters of hydration in mechanically strained elastin by nuclear magnetic resonance methods. The experimental data indicate a decrease in the correlation times of the carbonyl carbons as the strain on the biopolymer is increased. These observations are in good agreement with short 4ns molecular dynamics simulations of (VPGVG)3, a well studied mimetic peptide of elastin. The experimental results also indicate a reduction in the correlation time of proximal waters of hydration with increasing strain applied to the elastomer. A simple model is suggested that correlates the increase in the motion of proximal waters of hydration to the increase in frequency of libration of the protein backbone that develops with increasing strain. Together, the reduction in the protein entropy accompanied with the increase in entropy of the proximal waters of hydration with increasing strain, support the notion that the source of elasticity is driven by an entropic mechanism arising from the change in entropy of the protein backbone. PACS numbers: 87.64.kj, 87.80.Lg Elastin, the principal protein component of the elas- tic fiber, is a remarkable biopolymer that gives rise to the resilience of many vertebrate tissues [1 -- 3]. The structure-function relationship of this system has been of interest since Partridge's original work in isolating elastin from other tissue constituents and a model in- volving cross-links of hydrophobic and hydrophilic do- mains [4]. Central to the elasticity of elastin is the de- gree of protein solvation as well as the polarity of the solvent as made evident by experimental studies of the Young's modulus -- elastin only exhibits elasticity when hydrated [5]. A 'liquid drop elastomer' model was sug- gested wherein both the surface interaction between hy- drophobic and hydrophilic phases and the change in con- figurational entropy contribute to elasticity [6]. The no- tion that the elasticity of elastin is entropic in origin was established early on and a model was proposed that in- corporated a network of random chains [7]. However, experimental work gave evidence of ordered structures in elastin, specifically, the presence of both α-helices and β-turns [1, 8]. The short model peptide (VPGVG)n, an abundant motif of elastin, has been extensively studied as it exhibits the inverse temperature transition that is characteristic of the hydrated protein [1, 9]. In studies of the (VPGVG)n peptide, a model was proposed that incorporates a hydrogen bond formed between Val1 and Val4 residues, resulting in suspended segments between β-turns [10]. In this model, termed the Librational En- tropy Mechanism (LEM), the suspended segments are free to undergo large-amplitude low-frequency torsional oscillations; the amplitude might be damped during ex- tension, giving rise to a decrease in entropy of the seg- ment with increasing strain, providing the driving mecha- nism for elasticity [10]. In addition, type II β-turns have ∗ Email:[email protected], Phone: (718)951-5000x2873, Fax: (718)951-4407, Physics Department, Brooklyn College of The City University of New York, Brooklyn NY 11210 also been proposed for the (GXGGX) sequence, a sec- ond repeating motif of elastin, wherein hydrogen bonds are formed either between Gly1 and Gly4 residues or be- tween the second and fifth X residues; the interchange between the two conformations results in a dynamical β- turn sliding giving rise to elasticity [2]. In both model sequences, according to the LEM model, the elastic force is borne by the protein backbone by virtue of a decrease in entropy upon extension. In all elastin models, wa- ters of hydration are tacitly assumed and yet the contri- bution of proximal waters of hydration to the entropic mechanism of elasticity has eluded experimentalists. Re- cent short time Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of (VPGVG)18 have suggested that the orientational en- tropy of waters hydrating hydrophobic groups decreases, whereas the elastin backbone is more dynamic and has a greater entropy upon extension than in a relaxed state in disagreement with the LEM model [9]. In this work we report on the first direct measurement of the motional correlation times of proximal waters of hydration and the protein backbone of mechanically strained elastin. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) experiments were performed on purified bovine nuchal ligament elastin purchased from Elastin Products Company, LLC. The elastin was purified by the neutral extraction method of Partridge [4], and was suspended in a mixture of D2O and H2O with a volume ratio of 50:50 with 0.0003g/mL of sodium azide added as a biocide. The elastin samples were mechanically strained in 1.5cm long, 5mm diameter NMR tubes with both ends held by polytetrafluoroethy- lene tape and sealed using ethylene-vinyl acetate. Four samples were prepared; the strain (∆L/L) on the samples was 0, 17, 35 and 43 percent, and are denoted I, II, III, and IV respectively in the remainder of this work. Addi- tionally, after the experiments were performed on sample IV, the sample was released and measured after 72 hours and is denoted sample V. The loss of water in any of the samples was less than 1 percent over the entire course of 1 1 0 2 r p A 5 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 6 7 8 0 . 4 0 1 1 : v i X r a experiments. All the experiments were carried out on a 200MHz Tecmag Apollo NMR spectrometer using a Doty solids NMR probe. The 90o pulse time was 9µs in the 13C measurements and 19µs in the 2H measurements. In the 13C measurements, a radio frequency field strength of ωe=27.7kHz was applied with 1H SPINAL-64 decou- pling during signal acquisition [11]. All the experiments were conducted at approximately 25oC. We employed the 2D T1-T2 NMR technique [12], and measured the 2H T1 and T2 relaxation times of water in hydrated elastin. By applying a 2D Inverse Laplace Transform (ILT) of the experimental data, the T1 and T2 relaxation times are correlated and are manifested into a peak in the 2D map. The 2D ILT map of sample I is shown in Fig. 1 as an example. Four peaks are observed in the figure, corresponding to four reservoirs of water with distinguishable dynamical properties; the 2D ILT maps for all samples studied showed four components. For a spin I=1 nucleus, such as 2H, the relaxation is governed by the quadrupolar interaction and the T1 and T2 are given by 1 T1 = 3 40 (1 + η2 3 )Cq{J(ωD) + 4J(2ωD)} (1) 1 T2 = 1 80 (1 + η2 3 )Cq{9J(0) + 15J(ωD) + 6J(2ωD)} (2) τc where ωD is the Larmor frequency for 2H, Cq = ( eQ ∂2V ∂z2 )2 and η is the asymmetry parameter of the potential V and assumed to 0 in our case. The spectral density is given by J(ω) = 1+(ωτc)2 with τc defined as the correlation time of the fluctuating quadrupolar field of the 2H nu- cleus [13]. Using Eq. 1 and 2 and our measured values of T1 and T2, the τc was determined for the four components shown. Component α1 is free water, by virtue of the fact that T1 ≈ T2, α2 is water that resides between the elastin fibers and β is a mobile component that resides within the elastin fiber as verified by a T2-T2 exchange experi- ment [14]. The water corresponding to the peak with the shortest T1 and T2 relaxation times, labeled γ in Fig. 1, has been determined to be in closest proximity to elastin, also by the T2-T2 exchange experiment and by consider- ing the correlation times of the slowest two components in the 2D ILT map (τ β c =111.7ns). In this work, we therefore study the changes in the correlation time of component γ as a function of mechanical strain. For samples I, II, III and IV, the correlation times are plotted in Fig. 2a as a function of ∆L/L. It is evident from the figure that the correlation time of proximal wa- ters of hydration decreases with increasing strain on the biopolymer. Not shown in the figure is the correlation time of the water from sample V, which was measured to be the same, within our experimental uncertainty, as that measured in sample I. This observation indicates that the dynamics of the water in close proximity to the protein c =48.8ns and τ γ 2 FIG. 1. 2H 2D ILT map of the T1-T2 NMR relaxation times of water in sample I, defined in the text. Four components are discernable and are labeled α1, α2, β and γ. The dashed lines are used to guide the eye for the region of the 2D map where T1 is approximately equal to T2. The signal intensity, indicated by the colorbar, is shown on a logarithmic scale. FIG. 2. Correlation times measured in samples I, II, III and IV as defined in the text. (a) Correlation time of the fluctuat- ing quadrupolar field of D2O in close proximity to elastin, as determined from Eq. 1 and 2 and the measured 2H T1 and T2. (b) Correlation times characterizing the fluctuating dipolar field experienced by the carbonyl (open circles) and aliphatic carbons (closed circles) of elastin, as determined from Eq. 3 and 4 and the measured 13C T1 and T1ρ. The dashed lines are used to guide the eye. returned to what was observed in an unstrained sample when the applied strain was removed. Natural abundance 13C Direct Polarization (DP) and 1H → 13C Cross Polarization (CP) NMR experiments were performed [15], and exemplary spectra are shown in Fig. 3 from sample I. A phase cycling scheme was implemented in the CP experiment, such that the result- ing signal observed on the 13C spectra results only from cross-polarized magnetization. Two features are evident in the spectra. First, it is clear from the DP spectrum, shown in Fig. 3a, that the signal for the carbonyl car- bons (centered at 173ppm) is clearly distinguishable from that of the aliphatic carbons (16ppm-60ppm) even with- out any magic angle spinning [16]; this allows us to dis- tinguish these two signals and measure the respective re- laxation times unambiguously. Second, the overall signal in the CP spectrum (Fig. 3b) is smaller than that of the DP spectrum (Fig. 3a), indicating a high degree of mo- γβα2α10510152025303540456080100120∆L / L [%]τc [ns] 051015202530354045400600800∆L / L [%]τc [ns] ab3 that the correlation times for both carbonyl and the over- all aliphatic carbons decrease with increasing strain. The physics of this result dictates an increase in the fluctua- tion of the dipolar field surrounding both carbonyl and aliphatic regions with increasing strain. The measured correlation times of the carbonyl and overall aliphatic carbons of sample V, not shown, were within the experi- mental uncertainty of that observed in sample I. To help visualize possible dynamical properties of strained elastin measured in our experimental work, we have studied the elastin mimetic sequence (VPGVG)3 by MD simulation. The MD simulations were performed at 25oC using the OPLS-AA/L force field model [18] and a Berendsen ther- mostat [19] in GROMACS [20]. The peptide was termi- nated by (-NH-CH3) and (-CO -- CH3) groups at its C- and N-terminus, respectively. The model system was placed in a cubic box solvated with water using the SPC216 wa- ter model [21] and was run for 4ns. Two scenarios were studied: (a) without an applied pull force and (b) with the Gly14 atoms being fixed and a pull force being ap- plied on the atoms of Val4 with a constant force equal to 50000 kJ/mol nm. The resulting increase in the radius of gyration, as determined by the position of the Cα, is highlighted in Table 1 as well as the increase in the num- ber of water molecules in 0.6nm of the peptide resulting from the applied strain. Further details of the mechan- ical properties of this elastin mimetic peptide, and oth- ers, will appear in a forthcoming manuscript. For each scenario the eigenvalues, λii, of the mass weighted co- variance matrix of the MD trajectory were computed. A quasi-harmonic approximation was applied whereby the frequencies, ωi of uncorrelated simple harmonic oscilla- tors are given by ωi = [22]. The entropy of a harmonic oscillator with frequency ωi at a temperature T is given by (cid:113) kB T λii Si = kB[ ωi/kBT eωi/kB T − 1 − ln(1 − e−ωi/kB T )] (5) The histogram of the frequencies derived from the simu- lations are plotted in Fig. 4 for both scenarios studied. The resulting total entropy of the peptide was determined by summing the entropy contribution of each frequency and is tabulated in Table 1. Fig. 4 shows a shift in pop- ulation to higher frequency when the peptide is strained. According to Eq. 5 high frequencies contribute less to en- tropy, thus Fig. 4 implies a decrease in the total peptide entropy when strained; this is observed in our results tab- ulated in Table 1. In the LEM model [10], the peptide is treated as a series of quasi-harmonic oscillators un- dergoing low-frequency, large torsional oscillations when relaxed; the amplitude of the motion is reduced upon ex- tension. Our experimental data, highlighted in Fig. 2b, indicate that there is a decrease in the correlation times of both carbonyl and aliphatic carbons, implying that the motion of the fluctuating dipolar field of both regions in- creases with increasing strain. We attribute the decrease in the measured correlation times to an increase in fre- quency of the protein backbone motion as observed in our FIG. 3. Natural abundance 13C NMR spectra of sample I defined in the text. (a) Direct Polarization (DP) and (b) 1H → 13C Cross Polarization (CP). The contact time for 1H → 13C CP was 1.4ms. The data shown were accumulated with 14512 scans, with a recycle delay of 5s. All spectra are referenced to adamantane. bility for this system (a factor of 3.977 in gain is expected for cross polarization for the case of a rigid solid [15]). Similar spectral resolution was achieved on all samples studied. Using the DP technique, we obtained the T1 and T1ρ times for the carbonyl and aliphatic carbons of mechani- cally strained elastin. Given the low spectral resolution of the static sample, one cannot distinguish different signals in the aliphatic region and the dynamics of individual constituents may vary. However, the 13C T1 and 1H T1ρ values measured on hydrated elastin using magic angle spinning methods at a similar temperature showed sim- ilar values for the different components of the aliphatic region [16]. It is therefore reasonable to study the region by employing an effective T1 and T1ρ relaxation time. In hydrated elastin, it has been demonstrated that the car- bonyl chemical shift anisotropy is averaged to a great extent due to the high mobility of the system [16]. The 13C relaxation times are thus mediated largely by carbon- proton dipolar interactions and the 13C T1 and T1ρ are given by 1 T1 = 1 10 CD{J(ωH − ωC) + 3J(ωC) + 6J(ωH + ωC)} (3) 1 T1ρ CD{4J(ωe) + J(ωH − ωC) + 3J(ωC) = 1 20 2γC γH r3 C−H +6J(ωH ) + 6J(ωH + ωC)} (4) where ωH and ωC are the Larmor frequencies for 1H and 13C respectively, and CD = ( )2 [17]. In the spec- tral density J(ω) in Eq. 3 and 4, τc is the correlation time of the fluctuating dipolar field experienced by the 13C spins, which is reflective of the overall motions of the 13C and nearby 1H nuclei. Using Eq. 3 and 4, and the measured relaxation times the τc is determined for the carbonyl carbons and aliphatic carbons in all the sam- ples. The results are presented in Fig. 2b as a function of the strain on the sample. It is clear from the figure −50050100150200−202468ppmIntensity [a.u.]−50050100150200−202468ppmIntensity [a.u.]ab4 sulting from the strain, as quantified by the Root Mean Square Fluctuation (RMSF) of the Cα shown in Table 1, is also consistent with the expected change according to the LEM model. Referring to Fig. 2a, the measured decrease in corre- lation time indicates an increase in motion and hence an increase in entropy of the proximal waters of hydration with increasing strain. This observation appears to be correlated with the observation that the lifetime of hydro- gen bonds formed between the model peptide (VPGVG)3 and water decreases upon extension, as noted in Table 1. Given that the deformation is applied to the protein backbone, it is clear that the changes to the dynamics of the proximal waters of hydration are driven by the in- crease in the frequency of libration of the backbone. The increase in the entropy of the proximal waters of hydra- tion and reduction in entropy of the backbone upon me- chanical strain therefore suggests that the driving mech- anism of elasticity is a change in the backbone entropy. While the experimental data suggest that the proximal waters of hydration in elastin increase mobility upon in- creasing strain, the presence of water is a required, albeit complex element for the elasticity of elastin. Ultimately the solvent gives rise to backbone mobility whose increase in librational frequency with increasing strain reduces the backbone entropy and drives the system back to a relaxed state. The authors thank Yi-Qiao Song for use of the 2D ILT algorithm and Raymond Tung, Alexej Jerschow, Rana- jeet Ghose and Nicolas Giovambattista for useful discus- sions. G. S. Boutis acknowledges support from NIH grant number 7SC1GM086268-03. The content is solely the re- sponsibility of the authors and does not necessarily repre- sent the official views of the National Institute of General Medical Sciences or the National Institutes of Health. FIG. 4. Histogram of frequencies derived from the quasi- harmonic approach in the MD simulations of the elastin mimetic peptide (VPGVG)3 under relaxed (blue line) and strained (red line) states. Relaxed Strained Peptide entropy [kJ/mol·K] 1.63 1.46 1132±248 5451±177 No. of H2O within 0.6nm of peptide 0.19±0.05 0.14±0.06 Average RMSF of Cα [nm] 0.78±0.07 0.83±0.03 Radius of gyration of Cα [nm] Lifetime of petpide-water H-bond [ps] 0.87±0.05 0.53±0.02 TABLE I. Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulation results for an elastin mimetic peptide (VPGVG)3 under relaxed and strained states, as described in the text. Peptide-water H- bonds were counted when the donor-acceptor cutoff distance of 0.35nm and the hydrogen-donor-acceptor angle of 30o was satisfied. 4ns MD simulations. The observed increase in backbone motion is also consistent with resulting MD simulations of strained (VPGVG)18 [9]. In addition, the observed reduction of the amplitude of the backbone motion re- [1] D.W. Urry, J. Protein Chem. 7, 1 (1988). [2] L. Debelle and A.M. Tamburro, Int. J. Biochem. Cell Biol. 31, 261 (1999). [3] L.D. Muiznieks, A.S. Weiss and F.W. Keeley, Biochem. Cell Biol. 88, 239 (2010). 261 (2002). [13] A. Abragam, P rinciples of N uclear M agnentism (Ox- ford University Press, 1961). [14] C. Sun and G.S. Boutis, New J. Phys. 13 025026 (2011). Introduction to Solid − State N M R [15] M.J. Duer, [4] S.M. Partridge, H.F. Davies and G.S. Adair, Biochem. J. Spectroscopy (Blackwell Publishing Ltd., 2004). 61, 11 (1955). [5] M.A. Lillie and J.M. Gosline, J. Biorheol. 30, 229 (1993). [6] T. Weis-Fogh and S.O. Anderson, Nature 227, 718 [16] A Perry, M.P. Stypa, B.K. Tenn and K.K. Kumashiro, Biophys. J. 82, 1086 (2002). [17] J.W. Peng, V. Thanabal and G. Wagner, J. Magn. Reson. (1970). [7] C.A.J. Hoeve and P.J. Flory, Biopolymers 13, 677 (1974). [8] M. Mammi, L. Gotte and G. Pezzin, Nature 225, 371 (1968). 94, 82 (1991). [18] W.L. Jorgensen and J. Tirado-Rives, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 110, 1657 (1988). [19] H.J.C. Berendsen, J.P.M. Postma, A. DiNola and J.R. [9] B. Li, D.O.V. Alonso, B.J. Bennion and V. Daggett. Haak, J. Chem. Phys. 81, 3684 (1984). 2001. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 123, 11991 (2001). [20] B. Hess, C. Kutnzer, D.V.D. Spoel and E. Lindahl, J. [10] D.W. Urry and T.M. Parker, J. Muscle Res. Cell Motil. Chem. Theory Comput. 4, 435 (2008). 23, 543 (2002). [21] O. Teleman, B. Jonsson and S. Engstrom, Mol. Phys. 60, [11] B. M. Fung, A.K. Khitrin and K. Ermolaev, J. Magn. 193 (1987). Reson. 142, 97 (2000). [22] I. Andricioaei and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys. 115, 6289 [12] Y.-Q. Song, L. Venkataramanan, M.D. Hurlimann, M. Flaum, P. Frulla and C. Straley, J. Magn. Reson. 154, (2001). 5101520253035404550010203040506070Frequency [MHz]Population
1204.1418	1	1204	2012-04-06T06:40:26	Multiple barriers in forced rupture of protein complexes	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.BM" ]	Curvatures in the most probable rupture force ($f^$) versus log-loading rate ($\log{r_f}$) observed in dynamic force spectroscopy (DFS) on biomolecular complexes are interpreted using a one-dimensional free energy profile with multiple barriers or a single barrier with force-dependent transition state. Here, we provide a criterion to select one scenario over another. If the rupture dynamics occurs by crossing a single barrier in a physical free energy profile describing unbinding, the exponent $\nu$, from $(1- f^/f_c)^{1/\nu}\sim(\log r_f)$ with $f_c$ being a critical force in the absence of force, is restricted to $0.5 \leq \nu \leq 1$. For biotin-ligand complexes and leukocyte-associated antigen-1 bound to intercellular adhesion molecules, which display large curvature in the DFS data, fits to experimental data yield $\nu<0.5$, suggesting that ligand unbinding is associated with multiple-barrier crossing.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Multiple barriers in forced rupture of protein complexes Changbong Hyeon1 and D. Thirumalai2 1Korea Institute for Advanced Study, Seoul 130-722, Republic of Korea 2Biophysics Program, Institute for Physical Science and Technology, University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, USA Curvatures in the most probable rupture force (f∗) versus log-loading rate (log rf ) observed in dy- namic force spectroscopy (DFS) on biomolecular complexes are interpreted using a one-dimensional free energy profile with multiple barriers or a single barrier with force-dependent transition state. Here, we provide a criterion to select one scenario over another. If the rupture dynamics occurs by crossing a single barrier in a physical free energy profile describing unbinding, the exponent ν, from (1 − f∗/fc)1/ν ∼ (log rf ) with fc being a critical force in the absence of force, is restricted to 0.5 ≤ ν ≤ 1. For biotin-ligand complexes and leukocyte-associated antigen-1 bound to intercellular adhesion molecules, which display large curvature in the DFS data, fits to experimental data yield ν < 0.5, suggesting that ligand unbinding is associated with multiple-barrier crossing. PACS numbers: 87.10.-e,87.15.Cc,87.80.Nj,87.64.Dz INTRODUCTION Single molecule pulling experiments have generated a wealth of data, which can be used to probe aspects of folding that were not previously possible [1 -- 3]. In ad- dition, DFS has been used to decipher the energy land- scape of molecular complexes by measuring the rupture force (f ) by linearly increasing load at a rate rf (= df /dt). Because of the stochastic nature of the unbind- ing events, f varies from one complex (or realization) to another, giving rise to an rf -dependent rupture force distribution (P (f )). For a molecular complex obeying Bell's formula, k(f ) = kof f exp (f x‡/kBT ), Evans and Ritchie showed that the most probable force is f∗ = (kBT /x‡) log(rf x‡/kof f kBT ) [4], where x‡(= xts − xb) is the location of the transition state (xts) from the bound state (xb) projected along the pulling coordinate and kof f is the unbinding rate in the absence of force. However, Bell's formula is applicable only if the molecular com- plexes are mechanically brittle or if the applied tension is sufficiently small that x‡ does not shift upon applica- tion of force [5]. More generally, f∗ follows a (log rf )ν dependence where ν depends on the details of the as- sumed one dimensional (1D) model potential [6 -- 13]. The basic assumption in all these works is that a single free energy barrier along the pulling coordinate is sufficient to describe force-driven rupture of the bound complex. Sometime ago Merkel et al. used DFS to probe load de- pendent strength of biotin bound to ligands, streptavidin and avidin [14], showing that over six orders of variation in rf (from about 10−2 to rf in excess of 104 pN/s) the plot of f∗ versus log rf ([f∗, log rf ] plot) varies nonlin- early for both ligands. We note parenthetically that it is also common to observe curvature in unfolding rates of proteins when the rf is varied [15]. By careful data analysis combined with molecular dynamics simulations they proposed an energy landscape for the complex, with multiple energy barriers [14]. A similar picture emerges in the rupture of intercellular adhesion molecules (ICAM- 1 and ICAM-2) bound to leukocyte function-associated antigen-1 (LFA-1) upon application of force [16]. In principle, however, nonlinearity in [f∗, log rf ] plot could also arise from load dependent variation in x‡ [17] in a 1D energy landscape with a single barrier [5 -- 10, 12, 13, 17]. A theoretical model describing force- induced escape from a bound state with a single barrier in a cubic potential (ν = 2/3) has been used to ratio- nalize the biotin-ligand data by identifying various linear regimes demarcated by rf [9]. However, in the absence of easily discernible changes in the slopes in [f∗, log rf ] plot it is difficult to justify such an analysis. Here, we show by analyzing experimental data that the observed non- linearity in the DFS data of several protein complexes can be better accounted for with an energy landscape con- taining multiple sequential barriers, as originally demon- strated [14, 16]. To illustrate how steep curvatures in DFS data can arise naturally from a 1D free energy profile we cal- culated P (f ) and [f∗, log rf ] of forced-escape kinetics of a quasiparticle from a potential with two barriers, U (x) = Ax(x − 1)[(x − 2)(x − 3)(x − 4)(x − 5) + 1] with A > 0 (Fig.1). The distributions P (f ) are typical of what is observed in experiments (Fig.1b). For all val- ues of A, [f∗, log rf ] plots are curved although one could discern a modest change in slope (Fig.1c). The load- ing rate dependent x‡(rf ), calculated from the slope of the data kBT /x‡(rf ) at each rf in Fig.1c, changes from ∼ 3 nm to < 1 nm. The precipitous change in x‡ at rf ≈ (e−3 − e0) pN/s reflects the transition of the confin- ing barrier from outer to inner barrier with an increasing force (see Fig.1a). In contrast, gradual change of x‡ in the range 0 < log rf < 10 is most likely due to the move- 2 FIG. 2. The n-dependent shape of G(x) (Eq.1). The poten- tial with increasing n is associated with more brittle molecular complexes. The yellow circle (x = xc) denotes an inflection point and a cusp in each even and odd n potential, respec- tively. tial with a single barrier. Consider a Kramers' problem of barrier crossing in a free energy profile G(x) in which a single barrier separates the bound and unbound states of a quasi-particle as in ligand bound in a pocket of a receptor: G(x) = G(xc) + fc(x− xc) + (−1)n+1M (n + 1)! (x− xc)n+1 (1) with M > 0. In G(x), a 1D free energy profile with a sin- gle barrier, the shape of barrier and energy well is approx- imated using n-th order polynomial with n = 1, 2, 3,··· . For odd n, we assume that G(x) = −∞ for x > xc, so that the transition state of G(x) is cusped. In the ab- sence of tension, the barrier height, G‡, and the location of transition state, x‡, are G‡ = χ n n+1 fc(n!fc/M )1/n and x‡ = χ(n!fc/M )1/n, respectively, where χ = 1 (for odd n G‡/x‡. The form n), 2 (for even n). Thus fc = n+1 of G(x), an extension of the microscopic theories using harmonic-cusp or linear-cubic potential, accounts for the degree of plasticity (or ductility) or brittleness of the energy landscape [4] by changing n (Fig.2) [5]. Under tension, Gef f (x) = G(x) − f · x; fc should be replaced with fc(1 − f /fc) = fcε. Therefore, G‡(f ) = G‡ε1+1/n and x‡(f ) = x‡ε1/n. Although Eq.1 looks similar to the one Lin et al. used to discuss rupture dynamics for ε (cid:28) 1 where the barrier height is almost negligi- ble [12], we did not impose any specific force condition on G(x). Instead of attributing the movement of tran- sition state to a large external tension [7 -- 10, 12, 13], we mapped the non-linearity in DFS data onto G(x) that has the n-dependent shape of transition barrier and bound state. In G(x), increasing brittleness makes x‡(f ) insensitive to applied tension, which is dictated by n; x‡(f )/x‡ = ε1/n → 1. For a generic free energy pro- file F (x) with high curvatures at both x = xts and xb, x‡(f )/x‡ = 1 − f /x‡ × (F (cid:48)(cid:48)(xts)−1 + F (cid:48)(cid:48)(xb)−1) → 1 [5]. When free energy profile is associated with a brittle barrier, Bell's formula can be used to extract the feature (MFPT), k−1(f ) = D−1(cid:82) b (cid:105) (cid:104)−(cid:82) f a dyeβ(U (y)−f·y)(cid:82) y FIG. 1. Rupture characteristics obtained numerically using a potential with two barriers at constant loading rates. (a) U (x) (magenta) and U (x) − f · x (cyan) with A = 5 pN · nm and f = 50 pN. Reflecting and absorbing boundary condi- tions are set at x = a and x = b, respectively. (b) Rupture force distributions, P (f ) = k(f )/rf · exp 0 df(cid:48)k(f(cid:48))/rf , at varying rf were computed by using mean first passage time a dze−β(U (z)−f·z), starting from the first bound state at a(=0 nm) to reach an absorbing boundary at b(=5 nm). MFPT expression is valid in the force regime where stationary flux approximation holds [4]. The length was scaled by nm, and D = 1.0 × 107 nm2/s was used for the diffusion constant. (c) [f∗, log rf ] plots at three A values. Fits of [f∗, log rf ] to Eq.5 yield ν (cid:28) 0.5 for all A values (ν = 0.064, 0.075, 0.046 for A = 4, 5, 6 pN · nm, respectively). In this case, the data should be divided into two regions and analyzed by the two linear fits as depicted using green lines on the curve with A = 6pN · nm. (d) load- ing rate dependent x‡(rf )(= xts − xb), extracted from the slope of plot at each rf in (c) with A = 5 pN · nm, shows a sharp decrease from ∼3 nm to < 1 nm around rf ≈ (e−3− e0) pN/s. ment of the inner transition state (see Fig.5C in Ref.(5)). Although it is straightforward to interpret that the two discrete slopes in Fig.1c (or the precipitous transition of x‡ in Fig.1d) are due to crossing two barriers since the underlying potential is given in Fig.1a, it is nontrivial to solve the inverse problem of unambiguously determining from [f∗, log rf ] plots and decide whether the underly- ing free energy profile has a single barrier with a moving transition state as rf increases or multiple barriers. To establish a criterion for ascertaining whether the energy landscapes for forced-ligand rupture from biotin and LFA-1 have multiple barriers, we study the range of applicability of DFS formalism based on a model poten- -f!xx=ax=b(a)x2++~1.3nmx1++(outer)~3.3nmx2++x1++(inner)~0.9nm0306090120f [pN]00.10.2P(f)10-2 pN/s10-1pN/s1 pN/s10 pN/s102pN/s103pN/s-20-1001020log rf (pN/s)050100150f* (pN)A=4pN/nm5A=5pN/nm5A=6pN/nm5Eq.(5) fit-10-50510log rf (pN/s)012345x (nm)++0306090120f [pN]00.10.2P(f)10-2 pN/s10-1pN/s1 pN/s10 pN/s102pN/s103pN/s-20-1001020log rf (pN/s)050100150f* (pN)A=4pN/nm5A=5pN/nm5A=6pN/nm5Eq.(5) fit-10-50510log rf (pN/s)012345x (nm)++(b)(c)(d)0306090120f [pN]00.10.2P(f)10-2 pN/s10-1pN/s1 pN/s10 pN/s102pN/s103pN/s-20-1001020log rf (pN/s)050100150f* (pN)A=4pN.nmA=5pN.nmA=6pN.nmEq.(5) fit-10-50510log rf (pN/s)012345x (nm)++n=2n=6n=20plastic, ductile (soft)brittle (hard)............G(x)n=1n=5n=19............3 of the underlying 1D profile from DFS data [5]. For general n, the Kramers rate equation based on the Eq.1 under tension can be derived as: k(ε) = κεα(n) exp (−βG‡ε(n+1)/n) (2) where κ is the prefactor in Kramers theory and α(n) = χ(1−1/n) with χ = 1, 2 for odd and even n, respectively. For a given k(f ), the most probable unbinding force is determined by dP (f )/dff =f∗ = 0, resulting in a general equation for f∗: k(cid:48)(f∗) = [k(f∗)]2 (3) 1 rf which leads to n+1 n = ε −1 βG‡ log (cid:20) rf x‡ κkBT ε1/n−α(n) (cid:18) 1 − 1 βG‡ (cid:19)(cid:21) . nα(n) n + 1 ε− n+1 n (4) Under the typical condition that rupture occurs by ther- mal activation, i.e., f (cid:28) fc(ε ≈ 1) and βG‡ (cid:29) 1, the most probable unbinding force is approximated as: f∗ ≈ fc 1 − − kBT G‡ log rf x‡ κkBT (5) (cid:20) (cid:18) (cid:19)ν(cid:21) where ν = n n+1 . In deriving Eq.5 using G(x), the large force ε(= 1 − f /fc) (cid:28) 1 or fast loading condition, an assumption made in obtaining the mean unbinding force expression similar to Eq.5 [6, 12, 13], is not needed. Only the shape of the energy potential matters in deriving Eq.5 from Eq.1. The DFS data will have a larger curvature for smaller n, namely when the energy landscape associated with a protein complex is more ductile (Fig. 2). Because n = 1 (harmonic cusp), 2 (linear cubic), . . ., ∞ (Bell), ν must satisfy the bound, 1/2 ≤ ν ≤ 1 (6) for an arbitrary 1D profile that suffices to describe rup- ture kinetics. For forced-rupture of biotin-ligand complex, fits to the entire range of the data using Eq.5 give ν in the disal- lowed range; ν = 0.40 (biotin-streptavidin) and ν = 0.070 (biotin-avidin) (see Fig.3a). Even in biotin-streptavidin case, the parameters extracted from the fits with ν = 0.40 and ν = 0.5 (fixed) are comparable; however, the fit with ν = 0.40 is superior yielding both smaller relative error and reduced chi-square value, χ2 red, than with ν = 0.5, the lower bound of Eq. 6, that gives the maximal curva- ture in the single-barrier picture (see Fig.3(a) and Fig.S2 in the SI). For both biotin-ligand complexes, our crite- rion consistently suggests that the unbinding landscapes for the complexes involve more than one barrier, as was FIG. 3. Analysis of DFS data with large curvatures. (a) The data obtained using biomembrane force probe (BFP) with force constant in the range 0.1-3 pN/nm [14] were fitted to Eq.5 (solid lines) with ν=0.40 for biotin-streptavidin (circle) and ν=0.070 for biotin-avidin (triangle). The x‡(rf ) at each rf is calculated on the right using the slope of four succes- sive data points of [f∗, log rf ] plot. Analyses of data using restricted ν values (ν = 0.5 fit is in dashed line in Fig.3a) are in the SI (b) Analysis of DFS data of LFA-1 and its ligands, ICAM-1 and ICAM-2 in Ref. [16]. The fits in log-log scale are shown on the right. In all cases, ν < 1/2 suggests that for these complexes as well the underlying free energy profiles must contain at least two barriers; thus multi-state fits are required by dividing the DFS data into multiple regions as was already surmised in [16]. [14]. Next, we analyzed emphasized by Merkel et al. the extensive data on LFA-1 expressed in Jurkat T cells whose binding affinity to ICAM-1 and ICAM-2 can be enhanced by treating the cells with phorbol myristate ac- etate (PMA) and the divalent counterion, Mg2+. Under all conditions the exponents that best fit the DFS data are ν < 0.5 (Fig.3b). As originally argued by entirely different method [16] rupture of ICAM-1 and ICAM-2 from LFA-1 is best described using a free energy profile with at least two barriers. Taken together we arrive at a consistent conclusion that ν < 0.5 implies that the under- lying free energy landscape in protein-ligand complexes has multiple barriers. -5051015log rf [pN/s]050100150200f* [pN](cid:105)=0.40 ((cid:114)red2=0.120)(cid:105)=0.50 ((cid:114)red2=0.784)(cid:105)=0.070 ((cid:114)red2=8.48)-2024681012log rf [pN/s]012345x [nm]biotin-streptavidinbiotin-avidin++246810120100200300400f* (pN)resting ((cid:105)=0.076)PMA ((cid:105)=0.063)Mg2+ ((cid:105)=0.046)24681012log rf050100150200f* (pN)resting ((cid:105)=0.031)PMA ((cid:105)=0.029)Mg2+ ((cid:105)=0.14)-5-4-3-2-10-0.5-0.4-0.3-0.2-0.100.1log1!ffc"#$%&'log!kBTGlogrfx"kBT#$%&'(log1−f/fc()log−kBTG‡logrfx‡κkBT⎛⎝⎜⎞⎠⎟246810120100200300400f* (pN)resting ((cid:105)=0.076)PMA ((cid:105)=0.063)Mg2+ ((cid:105)=0.046)LFA-1:ICAM124681012log rf050100150200f* (pN)resting ((cid:105)=0.031)PMA ((cid:105)=0.029)Mg2+ ((cid:105)=0.14)LFA-1:ICAM2246810120100200300400f* (pN)resting ((cid:105)=0.076)PMA ((cid:105)=0.063)Mg2+ ((cid:105)=0.046)LFA-1:ICAM124681012log rf050100150200f* (pN)resting ((cid:105)=0.031)PMA ((cid:105)=0.029)Mg2+ ((cid:105)=0.14)LFA-1:ICAM2(a)(b)Mathematically the inequality (Eq.6) is not strict be- cause it is possible to construct 1D profiles with ν < 0.5 for which [f∗, log rf ] plots exhibit curvature like those ob- served in experiments. However, such free energy profiles are physically pathological with non-existing first deriva- tives in the vicinity of the bound complex and fits to the data give manifestly unrealistic parameters (see Support- ing Information for detailed calculations and analysis). For the physical free energy profiles Eq.6 is rigorously satisfied. In addition, there is no compelling reason to choose a special n value even if 1D profile is deemed ad- equate, and thus ν ought to be treated as a parameter. Although Ref. [11] used ν as a free parameter, the va- lidity range for ν was not discussed. If a global fit of [f∗, log rf ] data using Eq.5 yields ν < 0.5 and the effect of probe stiffness [18] is absent in the DFS data (see be- low), we can conclude that a single barrier description of the energy landscape is inadequate. 1 ef f = k−1 In principle curvature in the DFS data could also arise due to probe stiffness. Simple procedure of tiling free en- ergy profile by the amount −f · x under tension is widely used in analyzing single molecule force experiment. How- ever, more rigorous formulation for the effective free en- ergy profile under load using a transducer with stiffness 2 kef f (x − Xtr)2 k should read Gtot(x, Xtr) = G(x) + 1 where x is the position of the end of molecule, Xtr is the position of transducer, and kef f is the effective stiffness of molecular construct combining the trans- ducer and the complex (k−1 In fact, 2 kef f (x − Xtr)2 = −f · x + 1 tr with f = kef f Xtr. Therefore, the effective free energy for the complex under tension should be written in general as Gef f (x) = G(x) − [f − 1 2 kef f x] · x [19]. As long as f (cid:29) 1 2 kef f x (or Xtr (cid:29) x/2) especially when kef f is small as in optical tweezers or BFP, one can approx- imate Gef f (x) ≈ G(x) − f · x. Otherwise, rebinding from transient capture well created by a large probe stiff- ness at near-equilibrium loading condition could give rise to the nonlinearity in the DFS data [18]. Therefore, the rupture force being measured should be replaced by f∗ → f∗ − 1 most probable force measured by using a transducer with high stiffness such as AFM could be approximated as, 2 kef f x‡ε1/n, and at low forces (f (cid:28) fc) the tr + k−1 m ). 2 kef f X 2 2 kef f x2 + 1 f∗ ≈ 1 2 (cid:124) kef f x‡ (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) + fc (cid:124) =fpl rf x‡ κkBT − kBT G‡ log (cid:123)(cid:122) =fDFS (cid:18) (cid:20) 1 − (cid:19)ν(cid:21) (cid:125) . (7) The effect of probe stiffness manifests itself as a non- vanishing plateau force, which could be as large as fpl ≈ (10 − 100) pN when kef f ≈ 100 pN/nm and x‡ = 0.1 − 1 nm, even when rf is small enough that fDFS = 0 [18]. The biotin-ligand complexes data preclude this possi- bility because the probe stiffness of BFP kef f = 0.01−0.3 4 pN/nm [14], which is 1-2 orders of magnitude smaller than the kef f value discussed in the literature [20, 21]. The value of kef f is 0.5 − 2.0 pN/nm in the experiments involving LFA-1 [16]. Even the largest estimated x‡ value for the outmost barrier (x‡ ≈ 3 nm) only yields fpl < 1 pN. Furthermore, if the nonlinear curvature of DFS data is suspected to be due to the stiffness effect, this ought to be discerned from the curvature due to multiple barri- ers by producing DFS data at a reduced probe stiffness. The curvature due to multiple barrier should persist in the DFS data even with a small kef f . Thus, the cur- vature in the data in [14] can only be attributed to the presence of multiple barriers. The condition (Eq.6) for single-barrier based 1D theo- ries for DFS [7 -- 13] provides a guideline to judge whether the curvature in DFS data is due to multiple barriers or single barrier with a ductile transition state. Our work, which does not consider complications due to various multidimensional landscape scenarios [22, 23], shows that the extracted parameters from the data for the protein complexes with ligands using 1D profile with multiple barriers are physically reasonable [14, 16]. Additional justification for the use of such energy landscapes can only be made by studying the structures of the protein complexes in detail. Acknowledgements: This work was funded by Na- tional Research Foundation of Korea (2010-0000602) (C.H.) and National Institutes of Health (GM089685) (D.T.). We thank Korea Institute for Advanced Study for providing computing resources. [1] D. Thirumalai, E. P. O'Brien, G. Morrison, and C. Hyeon, Annu. Rev. Biophys. 39, 159 (2010). [2] A. Borgia, P. Williams, and J. Clarke, Annu. Rev. Biochem. 77, 101 (2008), ISSN 0066-4154. [3] S. Garcia-Manyesa, L. Dougana, C. L. Badillaa, J. Brujic, and J. M. Fernandez, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 106, 10534?10539 (2009). [4] E. Evans and K. Ritchie, Biophys. J. 72, 1541 (1997). [5] C. Hyeon and D. Thirumalai, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 19, 113101 (2007). [6] A. Garg, Phys. Rev. B. 51, 592 (1995). [7] G. Hummer and A. Szabo, Biophys. J. 85, 5 (2003). [8] O. K. Dudko, A. E. Filippov, J. Klafter, and M. Urbakh, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 100, 11378 (2003). [9] Y. Sheng, S. Jiang, and H. Tsao, J. Chem. Phys. 123, 091102 (2005). [10] O. K. Dudko, G. Hummer, and A. Szabo, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 108101 (2006). [11] O. K. Dudko, J. Math´e, A. Szabo, A. Meller, and G. Hummer, Biophys. J. 92, 4188 (2007). [12] H. J. Lin, H. Y. Chen, Y. J. Sheng, and H. K. Tsao, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 088304 (2007). [13] R. W. Friddle, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 138302 (2008). 5 [14] R. Merkel, P. Nassoy, A. Leung, K. Ritchie, and E. Evans, Nature 397, 50 (1999). [15] M. Schlierf and M. Rief, Biophys. J. 90, L33 (2006). [16] E. P. Wojcikiewicz, M. H. Abdulreda, X. Zhang, and V. T. Moy, Biomacromolecules 7, 3188 (2006). [17] C. Hyeon and D. Thirumalai, Biophys. J. 90, 3410 (2006). [18] E. Evans, Annu. Rev. Biophys. Biomol. Struct. 30, 105 (2001). [19] E. B. Walton, S. Lee, and K. J. Van Vliet, Biophys. J. 94, 2621 (2008). [20] R. Friddle, P. Podsiadlo, A. Artyukhin, and A. Noy, J. Phys. Chem. C 112, 4986 (2008). [21] Z. Tshiprut, J. Klafter, and M. Urbakh, Biophys. J. 95, L42 (2008). [22] B. T. Marshall, M. Long, J. W. Piper, T. Yago, R. P. McEver, and C. Zhu, Nature 423, 190 (2003). [23] V. Barsegov and D. Thirumalai, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 102, 1835 (2005). SUPPORTING INFORMATION DFS theory for a free energy profile with non- integer n. It could be argued that the inequality 1/2 ≤ ν ≤ 1 (valid rigorously for integer n) that accounts for the curvature of DFS data is not mathematically re- quired. Here we show that it is possible to construct 1D free energy profiles for which ν is clearly less than 0.5. Indeed, these free energy profiles can even have nearly vanishing ν. However, such profiles are unphysical be- cause near the bound state they have incorrect curva- tures compared to the physical profiles discussed in the text and in the references cited therein. More impor- tantly, the first derivatives of these free energy profiles, which yield ν < 0.5 do not exist near the bound state i.e, they have a singularity. For these and other reasons (see below) we reject these free energy profiles as plausi- ble models for explaining the curvatures in the observed [f∗, log rf ] plots in a number of protein complexes dis- cussed in the main text, which have all been explained using a two barrier model. A free energy profile with 0 < n < 1 (see Eq.1) can n+1 . To explore this lead to 0 < ν < 1/2 since ν = n possibility, we consider a free energy profile, G(x) = σax1/σ − bx (S1) with σ > 1. Here we may regard n = 1/σ, and hence n < 1. The term −bx is required for the potential to have a barrier at a finite value of x‡, the location of the transition state (TS). The TS location and the associated barrier height are (cid:16) a (cid:17) σ σ−1 x‡ = G‡ = (σ − 1)a b (cid:16) a (cid:17) 1 σ−1 b . (S2) Under tension f the potential becomes Gef f = G(x) − f x = σax1/σ − (b + f )x. The f -dependent TS location and the barrier height are σ−1 (cid:19) σ (cid:19) 1 σ−1 (cid:18) b (cid:18) b b + f b + f  G‡/x‡  G‡/x‡ σ−1 G‡/x‡ σ−1 + f σ−1 G‡/x‡ σ−1 + f σ−1  σ  1 σ−1 = = x‡(f ) x‡ = G‡(f ) G‡ = σ 1−σ = η = η 1 1−σ . (S3) where η ≡ (1 + f /f1/σ) with f1/σ ≡ 1 G‡ x‡ . Therefore, σ−1 one can rewrite Eq.S1 (G(x)) and an effective free energy (Gef f (x)) under tension as G(x) = Gef f (x) = σG‡ σ − 1 σG‡ σ − 1 (cid:16) x (cid:16) x x‡ x‡ (cid:17)1/σ − G‡ (cid:17)1/σ − ( σ − 1 G‡ σ − 1 (cid:16) x (cid:17) , x‡ + f x‡) 6 (cid:17) (cid:16) x x‡ . (S4) Given Gef f (x), it is possible to obtain the mean first passage time expression corresponding to the lifetime of the complex that can be measured in single molecule ex- periments. It is given by, (cid:90) x (cid:90) ∞ ef f (0)y(cid:17)−1(cid:113) G(cid:48)(cid:48) dxeβGef f (x) 0 0 approximation, ef f (x‡(f )) 2πkB T k(f )−1 = 1 D (cid:16)(cid:82) The saddle-point bound dye−βG(cid:48) D Eq.A3, yields Kramers' equation for the escape rate: k(f ) ≈ e−βG‡(f ) with dye−βGef f (y). (S5) (cid:104)−βG‡η (cid:105) 1 1−σ k(f ) = κηα(σ) exp (S6) (cid:16)(cid:82) ef f (0)y(cid:17)−1 with α(σ) ≡ 2σ−1 2(σ−1) . Here, note that the κ, de- fined as the prefactor, contains the singular integral bound dye−βG(cid:48) . By using the relationship k(cid:48)(f∗) = [k(f∗)]2/rf to derive the most probable force, we get (cid:20) (σ − 1)α(σ) (cid:21) ηα(σ)+1βG‡ + η σ 1−σ . (S7) η 1 1−σ = − 1 βG‡ log rf x‡ κkBT By assuming βG‡ (cid:29) 1 and f (cid:28) f1/σ, we can simplify the above equation into η 1 1−σ ≈ − 1 βG‡ log rf x‡ κkBT . (S8) Therefore, the most probable force (f∗) for the fractional potential (Eq.S1) is (cid:34)(cid:18) (cid:34)(cid:18) f∗ ≈ f1/σ = f1/σ − 1 βG‡ log − 1 βG‡ log rf x‡ κkBT rf x‡ κkBT (cid:35) (cid:19)1−σ − 1 (cid:19)2−1/ν − 1 (cid:35) , (S9) where σ = 1−ν ν was employed in the last line. There are a few important comments about Eq.S9 that need to be made. (i) Note that the form of Eq.S9 is very different from Eq.5. The difference is related to the afore- mentioned difficulties associated with Gef f (x). Never- theless, it is possible mathematically to construct model free energy profiles, without regard to physical consid- erations, for which [f∗, log rf ] plot has curvature that is reminiscent of what is observed in experiments. (ii) Al- though Eq.S9 can be used to obtain excellent fits to DFS 7 FIG. S1. (a) The blue curve is the bare (f = 0) free energy profile of the form given in Eq. (S1) and the green curve is the tilted form of G(x) in the presence of force. By fitting the numerically computed (black circles) f∗ as a function of rf to Eq.5 (red curve) we obtain the parameters shown below. Although the features of original potential G(x) = 100x1/3 − 10x are reasonably recovered (σ is larger than the value in G(x)) by using Eq.5, the extracted value of κ is unrealistically large. (b) Eq.5 was used to fit the DFS data of biotin-strepavidin (circles) and biotin-avidin (triangles). Although the quality of fit is excellent, the unrealistically large value of κ, due to the singularity of the hypothesized fractional potential at x = 0, suggests that the potential with a fractional power should not be used for the analysis. In fact the κ values are comparable to or much greater than the TST estimate kBT /h (≈ 6.2 × 1012 s−1), which of course makes no sense. Hence, we can rule out the free energy profiles of the form given in Eq.S1 to analyze DFS data on protein complexes. data on protein complexes, it turns out that the extracted value of κ is extremely large and are clearly unphysical (see Fig.S1). The unphysical values are a consequence of the singularity of G(x) (or Gef f (x)) at x = 0. We con- clude that the free energy profiles with a fractional power of n, which mathematically creates singularity at bound state, is not suitable to be used to analyze experimental data. Thus, the bound 1/2 < ν < 1 in Eq.6 must hold for physical 1D free energy profiles with a single barrier. -20-1001020log rf020406080100f05101520x (nm)050100150200G(x) (pN.nm)G(x)=100x1/3-10xGeff(x)=G(x)-10xf=8.54−149.2(logrf−36.3)⎛⎝⎜⎞⎠⎟1−4.17−1⎡⎣⎢⎢⎤⎦⎥⎥G‡=49.2kBT, x‡=7.51 nm, κ=3.0×1015s-1, σ=4.17-5051015log rf [pN/s]050100150200f* [pN] f=422.1((-(log rf-112.6)/19.1)1-1.13-1) G=19.1kT, x=1.42nm, (cid:103)=2.68×1048s f=11.15((-(log rf-27.5)/31.1)1-5.29-1) G=31.1kT, x=2.70nm, (cid:103)=5.59×1011f=422.1−119.1(logrf−112.6)⎛⎝⎜⎞⎠⎟1−1.13−1⎡⎣⎢⎢⎤⎦⎥⎥G‡=19.1kBT, x‡=1.42 nm, κ=2.68×1048s-1, σ=1.13f=11.15−131.1(logrf−27.5)⎛⎝⎜⎞⎠⎟1−5.29−1⎡⎣⎢⎢⎤⎦⎥⎥G‡=31.1kBT, x‡=2.70 nm, κ=5.59×1011s-1, σ=5.29(a)(b)8 exp/f∗ f it − f∗ FIG. S2. Analysis of DFS data using Eq.5 for (a) biotin-streptavidin and (b) biotin-avidin. For each ν, the fits, residuals (f∗ exp × 100), and extracted parameters were summarized in the table on the right. We can draw some general conclusions from the fits. For the biotin-streptavidin complex, fit with ν = 0.397 produces the smallest errors although at high loading rates the relative errors for ν = 0.397 and ν = 0.5 are comparable. There are variations in other parameters (x‡, G‡, and κ) for all ν. For the biotin-avidin complex the situation is far worse. In particular, the relative errors in the fits are large even when ν is varied. Similarly, the parameters extracted from the fits are not totally consistent. Taken together, the fits using a 1D free energy profile with a single barrier is not appropriate to describe the rupture kinetics of these two complexes. (a)ν x‡ (nm)G‡ (kT) κ (s-1)0.3970.90015.661.91×1040.1201/20.71914.641.22×1040.7842/30.54713.569.24×1035.743 x‡ (nm)κ exp(-G‡/kT) (s-1)κ exp(-G‡/kT) (s-1)10.3960.0160.01615.32Double barrier fit with ν=1Dynamics over inner barrierDynamics over outer barrier 0.1340.5720.2490500.249050χred2050100150200f* [pN](cid:105)=0.4(cid:105)=1/2(cid:105)=2/3(cid:105)=12 barrier fit-5051015log rf [pN/s]051015202530rel. error (%)(b)ν x‡(nm)G‡ (kT)κ (s-1)0.070.90613.32.70×1048.481/20.58711.951.03×10421.282/30.48811.748.54×10333.67 x‡(nm)κ exp(-G‡/kT) (s-1)κ exp(-G‡/kT) (s-1)10.3260.0460.04670.48Triple barrier fit with ν=1Dynamics over inner barrierDynamics over middle barrierDynamics over outer barrier 0.1120.3213.890.0220.0658700.0220.065870χred2050100150200f* [pN](cid:105)=0.070(cid:105)=1/2(cid:105)=2/3(cid:105)=13 barrier fit-5051015log rf [pN/s]050100150200rel. error (%)
1006.4431	1	1006	2010-06-23T07:10:24	On the feasibility of nanocrystal imaging using intense and ultrashort 1.5 {\AA} X-ray pulses	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.comp-ph" ]	Structural studies of biological macromolecules are severely limited by radiation damage. Traditional crystallography curbs the effects of damage by spreading damage over many copies of the molecule of interest. X-ray lasers, such as the recently built LINAC Coherent Light Source (LCLS), offer an additional opportunity for limiting damage by out-running damage processes with ultrashort and very intense X-ray pulses. Such pulses may allow the imaging of single molecules, clusters or nanoparticles, but coherent flash imaging will also open up new avenues for structural studies on nano- and micro-crystalline substances. This paper addresses the theoretical potentials and limitations of nanocrystallography with extremely intense coherent X-ray pulses. We use urea nanocrystals as a model for generic biological substances and simulate primary and secondary ionization dynamics in the crystalline sample. Our results establish conditions for ultrafast nanocrystallography diffraction experiments as a function of fluence and pulse duration.	physics.bio-ph	physics	On the feasibility of nanocrystal imaging using intense and ultrashort 1.5 A X-ray pulses C. Caleman1,2, G. Huldt3, F. R. N. C. Maia3, C. Ortiz4, F. G. Parak1, J. Hajdu3, D. van der Spoel3, H. N. Chapman2,5 and N. Timneanu3∗ 1Physik Department E17, Technische Universitat Munchen, James-Franck-Strasse, DE-85748 Garching, Germany 2Center for Free-Electron Laser Science, DESY, Notkestrasse 85, DE-22607 Hamburg, Germany 3Department of Cell and Molecular Biology, Biomedical Centre, Box 596, Uppsala University, SE-75 124 Uppsala, Sweden 4Institut fur Theoretische Physik, Goethe-Universitat Frankfurt, Max-von-Laue-Strasse 1, DE-60438 Frankfurt am Main, Germany 5 University of Hamburg, Luruper Chaussee 149, DE-22761 Hamburg, Germany Structural studies of biological macromolecules are severely limited by radiation damage. Tradi- tional crystallography curbs the effects of dam- age by spreading damage over many copies of the molecule of interest. X-ray lasers, such as the recently built LINAC Coherent Light Source (LCLS) [1], offer an additional opportunity for limiting damage by out-running damage pro- cesses with ultrashort and very intense X-ray pulses. Such pulses may allow the imaging of sin- gle molecules, clusters or nanoparticles, but co- herent flash imaging will also open up new av- enues for structural studies on nano- and micro- crystalline substances. This paper addresses the theoretical potentials and limitations of nanocrys- tallography with extremely intense coherent X- ray pulses. We use urea nanocrystals as a model for generic biological substances and simulate pri- mary and secondary ionization dynamics in the crystalline sample. Our results establish condi- tions for ultrafast nanocrystallography diffraction experiments as a function of fluence and pulse du- ration. Any sample exposed to an intense X-ray pulse will be ionized and extensive ionization destroys the sample. The time scale on which this process occurs is critical for obtaining an interpretable diffraction pattern that conveys an atomic structure of the sample. In princi- ple, the X-ray pulse must be short enough for the en- tire pulse to pass through the sample before major disar- rangement of atomic and electronic configurations takes place. The ionizations due to direct photoabsorption and subsequent secondary processes affect the ability to get useful structural information from the diffraction pat- tern in three ways: (i) Ionization decreases the elastic X-ray scattering power of atoms and induces consid- erable changes in diffracted intensities due to ionization stochasticity. (ii) Removal of electrons from atoms leaves behind positively charged ions that repel each other due ∗E-mail: [email protected] FIG. 1: Comparison of crystal size and the modeled size of secondary electron cascades. (a) The unit cell of a urea crystal contains light elements abundant in proteins: carbon (depicted as green), nitrogen (blue), oxygen (red) and hydrogen (white). (b) A urea nanocrystal of 200 nm would contain about 50 million unit cells. A protein nanocrystal of similar size would contain about 20,000 unit cells (using lysozyme as an example). (c) The overall dimensions of sim- ulated electron clouds produced during the thermalization of a single 0.4 keV Auger electron ejected from a nitrogen atom (top) and a single 8 keV photoelectron (bottom) inside a large urea crystal after 50 femtoseconds. Similar cascade sizes are produced in protein crystals, during an X-ray diffraction ex- periment. The total number of ionizations was 18 in the Auger cascade, and 390 in the photoelectron cascade at 50 fs after the emission of primary electrons. At this point, the radius of gyration of the photoelectron cloud reached 300 nm, and that of the Auger electron cloud 8 nm. The photoelectron cascade is bigger than a typical nanocrystal under consideration here. to Coulomb forces, leading to the destruction of the struc- ture. (iii) Free electrons either leave the sample, if their energy is high enough, or remain in the sample as a back- ground electron gas, in which case they will be a source of noise in the diffraction image. 2 FIG. 2: Evolution of secondary ionization cascades in a urea crystal over time. (a) Number of secondary ionizations produced by a photoelectron of 8 keV and by Auger electrons (impact energies: 250 eV for carbon, 400 eV for nitrogen, 500 eV for oxygen). (a) Spatial evolution of the electron cloud from a single photoelectron of 8 keV energy in an infinitely large urea crystal depicted through the radial electron density as a function of time and radial distance from the point of incidence. The cascade includes the primary electron and its secondary electrons. At any given time, the 4π integration over the radius in the 3D volume gives the total number of electrons, assuming spherical symmetry when the cascades are added stochastically. (c) Secondary electron cloud from a single Auger electron (nitrogen). The cascade includes the primary electron and its secondary electrons. The thermalization of electrons from oxygen and carbon has similar features. Black lines in (b) and (c) show the radii of gyration (Equation 1) of the electron clouds. In the first femtosecond the electron clouds are highly anisotropic. After 20 fs no more secondary ionizations will occur in the photoelectron cascade (5 fs for Auger cascades). Figures show averaging over 1000 simulations on an infinitely large urea crystal. Thermalization of trapped electrons leads to additional ionizations through cascade processes. The probability of trapping, and the size of the resulting secondary elec- tron cascades, depends on sample size and X-ray energy (among others). Photoelectrons released by X-rays of 1.5 A wavelength are fast (53 nm/fs) and can escape from small samples such as "nanosized" crystals [2, 3] early in an exposure (Figure 1). In contrast, Auger electrons from carbon atoms are slow (9.5 nm/fs) and cause sec- ondary ionization even in a single protein molecule [4, 5]. For small samples (diameter<10 nm), the explosion is dominated by the repulsion of positive ions left behind by electrons leaving the sample [4, 6]. In big samples (diameter>500 nm), most electrons will be trapped sim- ply because they lose energy before reaching the surface. Trapped electrons increase the temperature of the sample through collisional processes, while slowing the explosion by partially screening the positive charges and creating a net neutral core. Predictions point to a transition from Coulomb explosion to a hydrodynamic expansion with in- creasing sample size. A positively charged surface layer is formed, destroying the sample from outside towards the center. The expansion is driven by thermal processes as the electron pressure grows [7]. Hence, crystalline diffrac- tion and useful structural information might still be ob- tained from the center of the crystal. Descriptions of electron impact ionization and sec- ondary ionization cascades exist for different materi- als [5, 8, 9]. Dynamics of photoelectrons in protein crys- tals have been investigated earlier [2, 3], without consid- eration to Auger emission or secondary ionization cas- cades. These predictions suggest that radiation damage can be limited by reducing the crystal size. The present work steps beyond these studies and gives an integrated description of photo-emission, Auger emission and cas- cade processes during exposure of a biological nanocrys- tal to an ultrashort and intense X-ray pulse, to determine the feasibility of nanocrystal imaging and improvement in resolution achievable with shorter pulses. Our find- ings are summarized in Figures 1-4 and the methodology is described in Methods and Supplementary. For light elements, a single photo-ionization releases electrons at two distinctly different energies (Figure 1). The photoelectron energy corresponds to the difference between the photon energy and the K-shell binding en- ergy, while Auger electrons carry kinetic energy depen- dent on atom type (250 eV for carbon). The average time for the first collisional ionization scales with the primary electron energy (Figure 2a). The electron cloud initiated by a photoelectron thermalizes slower than elec- trons in Auger cascades, since energetic electrons travel further between scattering events in the crystal due to their lower interaction cross section (Figures 2b,c). At the same time, the cloud generated by a photoelectron is around four orders of magnitude larger in volume than the Auger electron induced cloud. After thermalization, the electron clouds keep expanding through diffusion, fol- lowing a random walk pattern. Figures 2b,c show that the radius of gyration (Equation 1) at these impact en- ergies describes well the spatial extent of the electron clouds. In a sample that is small compared to the size of the X-ray beam or the photon absorption length, photoion- ization events will occur with equal probability through- out the entire sample. At 8.3 keV photon energy, a sin- gle photoelectron will liberate about 400 electrons before reaching thermal equilibrium (Figure 2a). The electron gas will have high temperature due to the high photon en- 3 FIG. 3: Degradation of the detected signal as a result of radiation damage. (a) Decay of Bragg peaks during exposure to an X-ray pulse in a urea crystal. Pulse length: 10 fs (FWHM) centered at t=0, at 1.5 A wavelength. The pulse intensity (1.5×1011 photons in a focal spot of 1 µm diameter FWHM) is such that atoms are ionized once in average when 99.5% of the intensity of the pulse passes through the sample. Peak intensities at different resolutions are represented by the (hkl) reflections and are normalized to one, based on intensities from undamaged crystals. The (330) reflection corresponds to 1.2 A resolution and has a pulse-integrated degradation of 50% due to ionization and atomic displacement. The dashed black line shows the average root mean square deviations (RMSD) in atomic positions during illumination. (b,c) Contour plots for the average ionization per atom (¯z) and the R-value as a function of the X-ray pulse length and intensity (photons/focal spot of 1 µm diameter FWHM). The R-value (Equation 3) is calculated from all the Bragg peaks up to a resolution of 1.5 A. The red thick line corresponds to an R-value of 0.15, lower values are considered acceptable for a good reconstructable signal. The blue thick dashed line represents the damage of 1 ionization per atom. The plot in (b) shows behavior of nanocrystals smaller than 200 nm, from which the photoelectrons escape early in an exposure, while (c) shows the behavior of crystals larger than 500 nm, when photoelectrons are completely trapped during exposure. ergy, and the electrons will be distributed approximately uniform throughout the sample. The free electrons will scatter predominantly in the forward direction and con- tribute incoherently to the background in the diffraction pattern. At 1.5 A wavelength, the ratio between elastically scat- tered photons and photoionization is 1:32 for oxygen, 1:26 for nitrogen and 1:20 for carbon. Incoming photons will primarily ionize sample and only a few will contribute to coherent scattering. The loss of an electron will de- crease the scattering power by 17% for a carbon atom, 14% for nitrogen and 12% for oxygen. One ionization per atom also leads to atomic displacement and further degradation of the scattered signal (Figure 3a). Since a focused X-ray pulse will destroy the sample, three-dimensional (3D) structure determination relies on the experiment being repeatable. Rather than build- ing up a complete X-ray diffraction data set by rotat- ing the crystal and collecting a sequence of diffraction images it will be necessary to scale together individual diffraction images from many different nanocrystals, in order to assemble a complete 3D data set [10]. A crys- tal with 5×5×5 unit cells will produce a discrete diffrac- tion pattern [11], and conventional X-ray analysis tech- niques may be used for indexing, merging and recon- struction [10]. Furthermore, oversampling techniques for direct phase retrieval may also be employed for a 3D structural determination [12]. We express damage-induced errors in terms of degra- dation of Bragg peaks, and for the entire diffraction pattern we calculate an R-value from simulated crys- tals exposed to X-ray pulses (Figure 3). The R-value is a measure of the overall agreement between the crys- tallographic model and the experimental X-ray diffrac- tion data (Equation 3). Small molecules (such as urea) form more ordered crystals and an R-value below 0.05 is considered a good threshold (Cambridge Structural Database). For macromolecules, values up to 0.20 are acceptable (Protein Data Bank) and we use the conven- tion R< 0.15 from [11] (Figure 3). Figure 3a shows how Bragg peaks may degrade during exposure to an X-ray pulse, and how this influences the dependence of the R- value with pulse parameters. The R-value is also de- pendent on crystal size, and Figures 3b,c compare two regimes: crystals where Auger cascades dominate versus crystals where damage is driven by photoelectron cas- cades. Trapping of photoelectrons in crystals larger than 500 nm leads to a steeper degradation of the signal and constrains what pulse lengths and intensities could be used for successful imaging. When deciding which parameters of the X-ray laser pulse and sample characteristics one should use (Fig- ure 4), there is an interplay between two effects driven mainly by photoelectrons; i) If photoelectrons escape the sample, the total number of ionizations will be signifi- cantly lowered. To reduce radiation damage early in the exposure, the sample has to be smaller than the size of the photoelectron cascade. The diffraction signal from the crystal scales with the size of the crystal as a power law (Equation 5). Thus reducing sample size will con- versely require an increase in pulse intensity in order to retain the signal at the same level (Figure 4). ii) If the 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1-15-10-5 0 5 10 15 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1Relative intensity of Bragg peakRMSD atomic positions (nm)Time (fs)aPulseRMSD urea(110)(220)(330)101010111012 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100Pulse intensity (photons/pulse)Pulse length (FWHM, fs)R=0.050.150.25z-=1z-=2z-=0.2bcrystal size < 200 nm R value = 0.151 ionization/atom10910101011 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100Pulse intensity (photons/pulse)Pulse length (FWHM, fs)R=0.050.150.25z-=1z-=2z-=0.2z-=3z-=0.5ccrystal size > 500 nm R value = 0.151 ionization/atom4 than 10 fs for crystals larger than 500 nm, where as for small crystals (< 200 nm) pulse lenghts can be as long as 30 fs. Ultrafast single-shot nanocrystallography fills the gap between single molecule imaging and crystallography. It offers the opportunity to investigate biological molecules which are too small to provide a good signal on their own in an X-ray laser diffraction experiment, however they could form nanocrystals which would be too small to investigate with conventional synchrotron radiation. Methods 1. Electron impact ionization. Simulations of the ionization cascade dynamics in crystalline urea (CO(NH2)2) were performed using the spatial electron dynamics program, ehole, that is a part of the gro- macs [15] Molecular Dynamics software package. Urea was chosen as model for a biological sample for three rea- sons: it has a well known crystalline structure, it has an atomic composition of biological character, and its unit cell is small. In earlier work [5], the inelastic electron cross sections for urea have been derived from first princi- ples calculations. Based on these we have calculated the number of secondary electrons generated by an impact electron in a urea crystal. The inelastic cross section for electron scattering in urea is comparable in magnitude with that for water [5]. Thus, urea crystals are a good model for protein nanocrystals, known to contain 30%- 60% water. We refer to [5, 9, 16] and the supplementary material for further details of these calculations and how the model compares with experiments on diamond [17]. Considering mi to be the mass of electron i and ri the position of electron i with respect to the center of mass of all free electrons, the radius of gyration, used in Figure 2, is defined as (cid:18)(cid:80) (cid:80) i ri(t)2mi i mi (cid:19)1/2 Rg(t) = . (1) 2. Electron thermalization during the pulse. We assume that the X-ray pulse can be described by a Gaus- sian centered at time t0 = 0 and will consider the incom- ing X-ray photons to be unpolarized and have a wave- length of 1.5 A. Following this pulse, several primary ionizations are treated -- the photoelectric effect result- ing in an ejection of a high energy electron (≈ 8 keV), accompanied by an Auger effect which provides an elec- tron of a lower energy, depending on atomic species. The emission for these electrons is described by normalized probability distributions: (i) the photoelectric effect is in- stantaneous so the emission probability follows the same Gaussian profile as the X-ray pulse, with the width w; (ii) the probability for an Auger process to be emitted is a convolution of a Gaussian with the exponential decay characteristic for each individual atomic species. The ex- ponential decays are taken with corresponding life times FIG. 4: Photon signal as a function of unit cell and crystal size for a perfect crystal. The integrated Bragg peak intensity (Equation 5) is shown for the lowest resolution where a full reflection can be recorded (Equation 4). Fully integrated Bragg peaks can be used for indexing and averag- ing the signal from different nanocrystal orientations in the beam, and 10 detected photons are considered to give a good signal-to-noise ratio. The X-ray pulse has an intensity of 1011 photons focused in a focal spot of 1 µm diameter (FWHM), wavelength 1.5 A, beam divergence is 0.1 mrad and spectral bandwidth is ∆λ/λ = 0.1%. The solid lines correspond to a scattered signal of 1, 10 and 100 photons in the first fully integrated Bragg peak, when peak degradation is not taken into account. The signal scales with the X-ray fluence, thus the "1" line will correspond to 10 scattered photons for the case of 1012 incident photons, and the "100" line will corre- spond to 10 scattered photons for the case of 1010 incident photons. If larger bandwidth or divergence is expected, full Bragg peaks can be recorded at lower resolutions and conse- quently the detected signal will be higher (Equation 5). The inset shows details for crystals with small unit cells. pulse is very short, the photoelectric cascade will not have time to develop to reach a large number of ionizations. At the same time, short pulses considerably reduce the signal degradation due to atomic displacements and ion- ization (low R-value in Figure 3). In this case the sample size is less important, and one can investigate any crystal size at photon fluences that will provide enough signal. The size could however be constrained by coherence re- quirements due to the pulse length [13]. At extremely short pulses, one would also need to consider the broad- ening of Bragg peaks [14], i.e. a bandwidth effect. The above considerations stress the importance of hav- ing very short pulses as means for radiation damage control, to reduce both the ionization cascades and the A photon flux of 1012 photons per atomic disorder. pulse and unit area (µm2) will offer the opportunity to investigate a wider range of crystal sizes and unit cells sizes. For lower available intensities (1010 pho- tons/pulse), longer pulse lengths can be accommodated and imaging nanocrystals of small proteins with a small unit cell, such as lysozyme, could be feasible. Our cal- culations show that to achieve an R-value of 0.15 at a fluence of 1011 photons/µm2 pulses have to be shorter τ of 11.3 fs for carbon, 8.3 fs for nitrogen and 6.6 fs for oxygen. The probability for photoionization in urea is determined by the cross section of the atoms, which are well known For the three atomic species that can un- dergo an Auger process, the contribution from the atoms C, N, and O, is weighted according to the photoioniza- tion cross section on the respective atoms, σC, σN, σO, and normalized to the total photoelectric cross section for the urea molecule. The single electron ionization cas- cades develop mainly along the direction of the incident photon, however we consider spherical symmetry when these are stochastically produced. Thus, the entire ion- ization cascade following an X-ray pulse impinging on a crystal is given by (cid:88) (cid:26)(cid:90) (cid:90) C(t) = + niσi i=C,N,O − (t(cid:48)−t0)2 2w2 N e 1 τ N e − (t(cid:48)−t0)2 2w2 Cphoto(t, t(cid:48))dt(cid:48)+ τ CAuger(t, t(cid:48))dt(cid:48)(cid:27) , e− (t−t(cid:48) ) (2) where Cphoto(t, t(cid:48)) and CAuger(t, t(cid:48)) represent the cascade development with time for a single electron starting from time t(cid:48). These are obtained from MD simulations and are represented by the ionization rate as a function of time (Figure 2a for t(cid:48) = 0), or radii of gyration, Figures 2b,c. 3. X-ray interactions and damage quantification. The degradation of Bragg peaks in Figure 3 has been cal- culated from MD simulations on an urea crystal, using gromacs with a stochastic interaction of X-ray photons with atoms, assuming unpolarized X-rays and homoge- neous spatial distribution of the free electrons. The sim- ulation box was 10x10x10 unit cells of urea, with peri- odic boundary conditions, and includes thermal motion of atoms. The model is described in reference [11], and in the supplementary material. The intensity of Bragg peaks at each time step is defined by integrating around each peak over a rectangular area centered on the Bragg peak and with sides of length equal to 1/10 of the sepa- ration between adjacent peaks [18]. The spectral width ∆λ/λ, beam divergence or any broadening of the Ewald sphere are not taken into account here. The degradation of the Bragg peak is expected to be smaller when inte- grating through an Ewald sphere of finite thickness. To estimate the damage induced error we make use of the R-value (used in Figure 3), calculated up to a resolution q from (cid:80) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:112)(cid:104)Ihkl(cid:105)t −(cid:112)I 0 (cid:112)(cid:104)Ihkl(cid:105)t hkl<q (cid:80) hkl (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) R(q) = hkl<q , (3) where the summation is performed over all Bragg peaks (hkl) corresponding to scattering vectors less than q. The intensities of the Bragg peaks I 0 hkl for the undamaged crystal are used as reference when compared with the time averaged intensities (cid:104)Ihkl(cid:105)t of the damaged crystal exposed to a Gaussian-shaped X-ray pulse. The latter 5 intensities take into account the ionization dynamics and atomic displacement as a function of time during the X- ray pulse. 4. Minimum required signal. In ultra-fast single- shot experiments at X-ray lasers the crystals will be ex- posed in random orientations, X-rays beams are expected to have small divergence (< 1 mrad) and are highly monochromatic (spectral bandwidth ∆λ/λ < 0.1%). Thus, single shot diffraction patterns will contain many partially reflected Bragg peaks. Full Bragg peaks may be recorded on the detector at higher resolution, and could be used for retrieving the original orientation of the nanocrystals and for averaging the signal from simi- lar orientation [10] (partial Bragg peaks could in princi- ple also be used for indexing). In our estimates for the minimum required signal for successful indexing, we con- sider only the signal from fully integrated Bragg peaks at the lowest resolution where these can be recorded. For given parameters that control the thickness of the Ewald sphere (beam divergence ∆φ, spectral bandwidth ∆λ/λ), the lowest resolution where a full Bragg peak can be recorded (qmin) is found by comparing the thickness of the Ewald sphere to the size of the Bragg peak (modeled as inversely proportional to the crystal width A) (cid:114) 1 A ∼ ∆λ λ λ 2 q2 min + ∆φ qmin 1 − λ2 4 q2 min . (4) The average number of photons scattered elastically by a protein crystal within a Bragg peak for a given resolu- tion qmin can be approximated by the expression for the integrated reflected intensity [19] IBragg(qmin) ≈ I0(λ) λ2 1 + cos2 θ0 (cid:88) 2 sin2(θ0/2) ×λ2 A3 a6 r2 e atoms 2 × (5) f 2 atom(θ0) , where both small beam divergence and polychromatic- ity are accounted for. I0(λ) is the spectral intensity of the incoming X-ray beam (number of incoming photons per unit wavelength and unit area), integrated over the angular density of the incident beam. The Lorentz fac- tor λ2/(2 sin2(θ0/2)) takes into account the integration over the thickness of the Ewald sphere encompassing the Bragg peak, in a similar way as [19] for the stationary case (no rotation) with divergent polychromatic radia- tion. The polarization factor is given by (1 + cos2 θ0)/2. Furthermore, re is the classical electron radius, λ the wavelength, A the crystal side (cubic crystal), a the unit cell side (cubic unit cell), fatom the atomic scattering fac- tor, and θ0 the polar angle between the incident pulse and the center of the Bragg peak. It is assumed that the unit cell structure factor is con- stant within the Bragg peak, and that adjacent Bragg peaks do not overlap; both these approximations improve with the ratio A/a. The squared structure factor of the unit cell is represented by its average value at high scat- tering angles [20]. For numerical evaluation, the unit cell was assumed to have a density of 1/30 A−3 carbon- equivalent atoms (corresponding to a unit cell consist- ing of 50% non-structural water and protein with density approximately 1.35 g/cm3), and the scattering factor of carbon was calculated from the Cromer-Mann parame- ters [21]. The calculation of the number of photons per Bragg peak (Equation 5) presented in Figure 4 with the assumption of perfect crystals with no mosaicity. It has been shown that micron sized crystals could consist of only a few highly ordered domains [22], thus nanocrys- tals are unlikely to be organized with a mosaic spread. The above approximations will break down when the crystal size approaches the unit cell size, as the diffracted image turns from a discrete into a continuous pattern. 6 Acknowledgments The Swedish Research Council is acknowledged for fi- nancial support as well as the DFG Cluster of Excellence: Munich-Center for Advanced Photonics. The authors would like to thank Magnus Bergh, Gerard Kleywegt, In- ger Andersson, Erik G. Marklund, Richard Neutze, Mar- tin Svenda, Rosmarie Friemann, Jochen Hub and Karin Valegard for their valuable input. [1] L. F. DiMauro, J. Arthur, N. Berrah, J. Bozek, J. N. Galayda, and J. Hastings. Progress report on the LCLS XFEL at SLAC. J. Phys.: Conf. Ser., 88:012058, 2007. [2] Coline Nave and Mark A. Hill. Will reduced radiation damage occur with very small crystals? J. Sync. Rad., 12:299 -- 303, 2005. [3] John A. Cowan and Colin Nave. The optimum conditions to collect x-ray data from very small samples. J. Sync. Rad., 15:458 -- 462, 2008. [4] M. Bergh, N. Tımneanu, and D. van der Spoel. A model for the dynamics of a water cluster in a X-ray FEL beam. Phys. Rev. E, 70:051904, 2004. [5] C. Caleman, C. Ortiz, E. Marklund, F. Bultmark, M. Gabrysch, F. G. Parak, J. Hajdu, M. Klintenberg, and N. Tımneanu. Radiation damage in biological mate- rial: electronic properties and electron impact ionization in urea. Europhys. Lett., 85:18005, and erratum 88:29901, 2009. [6] Z. Jurek, G. Faigel, and M. Tegze. Dynamics in a cluster under the influence of intense femtosecond hard X-ray pulses. Eur. Phys. J. D, 29:217 -- 229, 2004. [7] Stefan P. Hau-Riege, Richard A. London, and Abraham Szoke. Dynamics of biological molecules irradiated by short x-ray pulses. Phys. Rev. E, 69:051906, 2004. [8] Beata Ziaja, Richard A. London, and Janos Hajdu. Uni- fied model of secondary electron cascades in diamond. J. Appl. Phys., 97:064905, 2005. [9] Carlos Ortiz and Carl Caleman. Secondary electron cascade dynamics in KI and CsI. J. Phys. Chem. C., 111:17442 -- 17447, 2007. [10] Richard A. Kirian, Xiaoyu Wang, Uwe Weierstall, Kevin E. Schmidt, John C. H. Spence, Mark Hunter, Petra Fromme, Thomas White, Henry N. Chapman, and James Holton. Femtosecond protein nanocrystallogra- phydata analysis methods. Opt. Express, 18:5713 -- 5723, 2010. [11] R. Neutze, R. Wouts, D. van der Spoel, E. Weckert, and J. Hajdu. Potential for biomolecular imaging with fem- tosecond X-ray pulses. Nature, 406:752 -- 757, 2000. [12] J. Miao, K. O. Hodgson, and D. Sayre. An approach to three-dimensional structures of biomolecules by using single-molecule diffraction images. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 98:6641 -- 6645, 2001. [13] Stefan P. Hau-Riege. Effect of the coherence properties of self-amplified-spontaneous-emission x-ray free electron lasers on single-particle diffractive imaging. Opt. Express, 16(4):2840 -- 2844, 2008. [14] IV Tomov, P Chen, and PM Rentzepis. Pulse broad- ening in femtosecond x-ray diffraction. J. Appl. Phys., 83(10):5546 -- 5548, MAY 15 1998. [15] David van der Spoel, Erik Lindahl, Berk Hess, Gerrit Groenhof, Alan E. Mark, and Herman J. C. Berendsen. GROMACS: Fast, Flexible and Free. J. Comp. Chem., 26:1701 -- 1718, 2005. [16] N. Tımneanu, C. Caleman, J. Hajdu, and D. van der Spoel. Auger electron cascades in water and ice. Chem. Phys., 299:277 -- 283, 2004. [17] M. Gabrysch, E. Marklund, J. Hajdu, D. J. Twitchen, J. Rudati, A. M. Lindenberg, C. Caleman, R. W. Fal- cone, T. Tschentscher, K. Moffat, P. H. Bucksbaum, J. Als-Nielsen, A. J. Nelson, D. P. Siddons, P. J. Emma, P. Krejcik, H. Schlarb, J. Arthur, S. Brennan, J. Hast- ings, and J. Isberg. Formation of secondary electron cascades in single-crystalline plasma-deposited diamond upon exposure to femtosecond x-ray pulses. J. Appl. Phys., 103:064909, 2008. [18] David van der Spoel, Filipe R. N. C. Maia, and Carl Caleman. Structural studies of melting on the picosec- ond time scale. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 10:6344 -- 6349, 2008. [19] ZH Kalman. On the derivation of integrated reflected energy formulae. Acta Cryst. A, 35:634 -- 641, JUL 1979. [20] A. J. C. Wilson. The probability distribution of X-ray intensities. Act. Cryst., 2:318 -- 321, 1949. [21] Don T. Cromer and Joseph B. Mann. X-ray scatter- ing factors computed from numerical Hartree-Fock wave functions. Acta Cryst. A, 24:321 -- 326, 1968. [22] R Fourme, A Ducruix, M Rieskautt, and B Capelle. The perfection of protein crystals probed by direct record- ing of bragg reflection profiles with a quasi-planar x-ray wave. J. Sync. Rad., 2(Part 3):136 -- 142, MAY 1 1995.
1312.3450	1	1312	2013-12-12T11:27:35	Scarcity may promote cooperation in populations of simple agents	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.soc-ph", "q-bio.PE" ]	In the study of the evolution of cooperation, resource limitations are usually assumed just to provide a finite population size. Recently, however, it has been pointed out that resource limitation may also generate dynamical payoffs able to modify the original structure of the games. Here we study analytically a phase transition from a homogeneous population of defectors when resources are abundant to the survival of unconditional cooperators when resources reduce below a threshold. To this end, we introduce a model of simple agents, with no memory or ability of recognition, interacting in well-mixed populations. The result might shed light on the role played by resource constraints on the origin of multicellularity.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Scarcity may promote cooperation in populations of simple agents 1Departament de Física, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Campus UAB, E-08193 Bellaterra, Spain.∗ (Dated: January 20, 2020) R. J. Requejo1 and J. Camacho1 In the study of the evolution of cooperation, resource limitations are usually assumed just to provide a finite population size. Recently, however, it has been pointed out that resource limitation may also generate dynamical payoffs able to modify the original structure of the games. Here we study analytically a phase transition from a homogeneous population of defectors when resources are abundant, to the survival of unconditional cooperators when resources reduce below a threshold. To this end, we introduce a model of simple agents, with no memory or the ability of recognition, interacting in well-mixed populations. The result might shed light on the role played by resource constraints on the origin of multicellularity. PACS numbers: 02.50.-r,87.10.-e,87.23.-n,89.75.Fb Cooperation is common in nature in all levels of biolog- ical organization [1], and it is considered to have played a key role in the evolutionary appearance of higher selective units, such as eukaryotic cells or multicellular life, from simpler components [2]. However, its widespread abun- dance is intriguing because cooperators are vulnerable to exploitation by defectors [3], as detected early on [4, 5]. Since then, several mechanisms have been found allowing cooperative behaviors to survive such as network struc- ture, group selection, direct and indirect reciprocity or tag-based donation [6, 7]. Behavioral mechanisms -- the latter three are examples of such mechanisms -- require players to have some ability to avoid the exploitation from defectors, such as memory or the capacity to recog- nise the co-player [6, 7]. As a result, simple agents with- out these abilities, such as unconditional cooperators, are not expected to survive in well-mixed populations. Aside from a few examples [8 -- 11], the role played by the limitation of resources in most evolutionary game the- oretical studies on the origin and persistence of coopera- tion has been just to impose a constant population size [6, 7, 12 -- 17]. Recently, however, we have put forward a new viewpoint where the interacting players are set into a nonequilibrium context [18 -- 20]. The environment is considered explicitly by introducing a resource flux into the system that drives it away from equilibrium. This standpoint leads to unexpected outcomes, such as that resource limitation allows for stable coexistence between unconditional cooperators and defectors, and even dom- inance of cooperation, in well-mixed populations playing an a priori Prisoner's Dilemma (PD) game. This hap- pens due to a self-organizing process involving the envi- ronment which generates dynamical payoffs transforming the original PD structure into a neutral game. One of the main results of the analysis performed in ref.[19, 20] is that a well-mixed population of uncon- ditional cooperators extinguishes for infinite resources (where the system plays a PD game) but may survive for some parameter values when resources are finite (where the game is not a PD anymore). This suggests the possi- bility of a transition from a population of only defectors when resources are abundant to a population containing cooperators for more stringent environments. The exis- tence of this transition should have great interest, since it would provide a resource-based mechanism preventing the spread of defectors and thus may shed light on the conditions under which cooperators could survive during the evolutionary process. Indeed, the survival of cooper- ative strains has been recently observed experimentally in yeast (S.Cerevisiae) [21 -- 23] and bacterial (E.Coli) [24, 25] cultures, and has also been found in a model for the survival of aerobic cells inside anaerobic cultures [26, 27]. The models depicted in refs.[19, 20], however, do not yield such a transition: in these models we considered that the population was ruled by a resource limiting re- production, and that deaths occurred at a constant rate, so that the limiting resource influx determined the pop- ulation size; as it was thoroughly discussed, a reduction in the resource flux just decreased the size of the popu- lation in the same proportion, but it did not modify its composition. Our aim here is to devise a scenario where the selection pressure drived by resource limitation combined with the nonlinearities induced by this resource limitation in the interactions among players may lead to a transition of the type discussed above. In this scenario, we assume a limiting resource that constraints reproduction in a pop- ulation of constant size due, for instance to space con- straints. The plaussibility of the latter assumption is dis- cussed at the end of the paper. The model developed here is a stylized one inspired in the model of ref. [20], which consists of an evolving population of self-replicating indi- viduals that receive resources from the environment and exchange resources during interactions. In order to avoid the effect of spatial structure and focus on the effect of re- source constraints, we consider a well-mixed population. No memory, learning abilities or any other sensory in- puts are assumed. Each individual i is represented by its amount of resources, Ei, which in this simplified model is either 0 or 1, and its strategy, namely cooperate (C) or defect (D). Its amount of resources may be interpreted as the amount that belongs to it independently of how (it may be in its surroundings, for instance). Each defector attacks at a rate α per unit time to individuals chosen at random and steals its internal resources. To do so, the defector must have internal resources greater than 0 (i.e. Ei = 1), otherwise it does not attack. In every interaction, the defector loses its unit of resources with probability q, which can thus be seen as the average cost paid by a defector in an interaction. If the interaction partner has no resources, no reward is obtained. Coop- erators do nothing, they just eventually suffer from de- fectors' attacks. We assume that behaviors are inherited without mutation and represent physiologic or morpho- logic characteristics intrinsic to individuals which cannot be modified by choice. Each individual receives from the environment γ units of resources per unit time independently of its strat- egy, thus not modifying the interaction payoff structure. When an individual with internal resources Ei = 1 re- ceives an extra unit of resources it splits into two identical copies, each one with Ei = 1. Along with reproduction, we assume that players die with a probability f , indepen- dently of its strategy, in such a way that the number of individuals in the population remains constant. There- fore, resource allocation, reproduction and death rules are equal for both cooperators and defectors, being the strategy the only difference. Let us note that, in this model, an increase in the envi- ronmental resource supply is represented by an increase in γ, the amount of per capita resources obtained by in- dividuals. This contrasts with the model in refs. [19, 20], where an increase of resources leads to a proportional in- crease in the population size while keeping the same per capita value. We consider simultaneous interactions and large pop- ulations so that we can make a continuum approach. We denote by c0 and c1 the fraction of cooperators with in- ternal resources 0 and 1, and d1 and d0 = 1 − c0 − c1 − d1 the fraction of defectors with internal resources 1 and 0, respectively. The equations governing the evolution of cooperators are the following dc0 dt dc1 dt = αc1d1 − γc0 − f c0 = −αc1d1 + γ(c0 + c1) − f c1 (1) (2) The αc1d1 term shows the fraction of cooperators C1 that lose their internal resource unit after the attack of defec- tors (the latter pertaining to the population d1); these individuals move from population c1 to c0. The term in γc0 quantifies the fraction of individuals C0 that change to population c1 after getting a unit of resources from the environment. In addition, individuals in population c1 that receive resources from the environment replicate, thus increasing the c1 population. The terms f ci describe 2 the fraction of individuals dying in each population per unit time. To describe the evolution of defectors is enough to write the equation for population d1 because d0 is just the remaining fraction of the whole population. The dy- namic equation for d1 is dd1 dt = −αqd1 + αc1d1 + γ(d0 + d1) − f d1. (3) The terms related to deaths and resource allocation from the environment are analogous as for cooperators. The interaction term is as follows. On the one hand, with probability q individuals D1 lose its resource unit when interacting with individuals C0, D0 and D1; this leads to a decrease in the population of d1 in an amount αqd1(c0 + d0 + d1). On the other hand, when interacting with individuals C1, individuals D1 sequester their re- source unit; therefore, either the population of D1 does not change, with probability q, or it increases due to re- production at a rate αc1d1(1 − q). To complete the equations of the model, we need an expression for the death rate f . In order to have a con- stant population size, the frequency of deaths must equal the frequency of reproductions. This leads to f = γ(c1 + d1) + α(1 − q)(c1 + d1)d1. (4) The first term denotes reproductions due to resource al- location and the second one to reproduction of D1 in- dividuals when attacking individuals with Ei = 1 and not paying the cost. Eqs. (1) -- (4) are the equations of our model. They can be further simplified by noticing that one can divide all the equations by parameter γ and absorb it into the time parameter; therefore, there are just two dimensionless parameters in the model, q and β = α/γ. A large β value indicates either large de- fector attack rates or small resource influxes from the environment; conversely, large resource influxes or small attacking rates yield small β values. The dimensionless equations are the same Eqs (1) -- (4) replacing α by β, and γ by 1. The numerical resolution of the model shows that the system is attracted to a globally stable fixed point in- dependent of initial conditions. Depending on the pa- rameter values, the final fate is either a population of defectors (an expected solution) or, interestingly, a sta- ble mixture of cooperators and defectors. Remarkably enough, for fixed q, small β values, i.e. large resource in- fluxes, provide a population of just defectors, but when β exceeds a critical value βc a mixed state appears, thus providing a smooth phase transition from defective states to mixed states as resources become scarce (see Fig. 1a). The existence of stable mixed states in the model may be explained in terms of the overexploitation mechanism discussed in ref. [19]: an excess of defectors may reduce cooperators' resource contents and, as a result, the av- erage reward obtained by defectors; eventually, rewards (a) l s a u d v d n i i i f o n o i t c a r f (b) r ' E , t i f e n e b ' s r o t c e f e d c n o i t c e f e d l l u F Coexistence 0 10 20 30 40 50 attack probability to resource income ratio, 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 defectors' cost, q 0.8 1.0 FIG. 1: (a) Phase transition for q=0.5. The fraction of coop- erators c0, c1 and defectors d1 (see text) above the threshold are denoted with solid, dashed and dotted lines, respectively. Below the critical value βc = 7.58 cooperators die out. (b) Defectors' benefit versus costs in coexistence states. It equals the frequency rate function f (q) (see text). The dashed line E ′ r = q is a guide to the eye. decrease below costs and cooperators recover. Interest- ingly, we can obtain simple analytical expressions for the composition of the mixed state as a function of parameter β above the threshold: ci = ai(1 − βc β ), d1 = a2 β , (5) with ai and βc functions of parameter q. Remarkably, the dynamics in coexistence states selfor- ganizes defectors' rewards to be (almost) equal to costs thus turning the payoff matrix to neutral. According to the model, the payoff matrix for an average interaction is C 0 D −E ′ C D E ′ (cid:18) r − Ec −Ec (cid:19) r (6) with E ′ r the average reward obtained when a defector at- tacks a cooperator, and Ec = q the average cost paid when a defector attacks. Then, the average reward re- ceived by defectors when interacting with cooperators is 3 r = c1/(c0 + c1). Eq. (5) shows that E ′ E ′ r = a1/(a0 + a1) and then it is a function dependent only on q, and not on β. Fig. 1b displays the reward E ′ r as obtained nu- merically versus the cost q showing that E ′ r ≃ q. They are not exactly equal because, as explained in Eq. (4) of ref. [19], they may differ when death frequencies f are not small compared with resource intake. In this model, f cannot be arbitrarily chosen because of the constant population condition. Indeed, Eqs. 1 -- 2 readily show that f = c1/(c0 +c1) = E ′ r and then Fig. 1b also displays f (q). One observes that f is generally of order 1 (this is the cause of the small deviations found in Fig. 1b). At small q, however, f is also small and E ′ r and q match perfectly. One can further study the transition by drawing a phase diagram β − q with the regions where each be- havior dominates. It is possible to obtain an analytical expression for the critical curve βc(q) by performing a stability analysis. To do so, let us recall that for a fixed point to be stable in three dimensions the trace and de- terminant of the Jacobian matrix must be negative. Our model system (1) -- (4) has at least two fixed points, cor- responding to pure populations of cooperators and de- fectors: (A) c1 = 1 (the remaining variables equal to 0), and (B) c0 = c1 = 0 and d1 6= 0 obeying, according to Eq. 3, d1(f + βq) = 1. (7) As we know, it may also have a mixed fixed point, given by Eq. 5, but it need not be considered for our present purpose. Linear stability of fixed point A leads to the jacobian matrix −2 0 β 1 −1 −1 − 2β + βq −1 −1 β(1 − q) − 1   ,   (8) with determinant D = 4β(1 − q) > 0. The positive sign shows that at least one of its three eigenvalues is positive. Then point A is always unstable for q < 1 and coopera- tors never occupy the whole population. Fixed point B provides the following jacobian matrix −1 − f∗ βd∗ 1 1 1 − βd∗ 1 − f ∗   0 0 ,   df dd1 −1 −1 − d∗ 1 + βd∗ 1 −βq − f∗ − d∗ 1 df dc1 (9) where d∗ 1 and f∗ are the values of these quantities in fixed point B. To be compact, let us call J33 = −(βq + f∗ + d∗ 1)) < 0. The trace is T = J33 − 2f∗ − βd∗ 1 < 0, and the determinant can be written as 1(1 + 2β(1 − q)d∗ D = J33(−1 + βd∗ 1f∗ + f 2 ∗ ). (10) e c r u o s e r o t y t i l i b a b o r p k c a t t a , o i t a r e m o c n i 50 40 30 20 10 0 0.0 Coexistence Defection 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 defectors' cost, q FIG. 2: Phase diagram. The solid line indicates the numerical solution, the dashed line the analytical approximation βc = q−3. Cooperation is favoured at large β, i.e. small resource fluxes or large attacking rates (see text). Then, for point B to be stable the term inside parenthe- sis has to be positive. Although this is not a sufficient condition to prove that point B is stable, the numerical resolution of Eqs. (1) -- (4) shows that this is the case; this is the region where defectors are dominant. When the parenthesis in Eq. (10) is negative point B becomes un- stable, wich means that a small fraction of cooperators will grow and survive (notice that point B is the only fixed point with only defectors). Then, since point A is also unstable, in this situation there must exist a third (mixed) fixed point in the dynamics. Eq. (5) supplies the solution for this mixed fixed point and numerical so- lutions show it is a stable attractor, the one describing the stationary coexistence of cooperators and defectors found at large β values. In order to obtain the cuve βc(q) separating the regions of dominance of defectors from the mixture of cooperators and defectors we should find d∗ from Eqs. (4) and (7) and solve the equation 1 − 1 + βcd∗ 1f∗ + f 2 ∗ = 0. (11) The exact analytical solution of this transition curve is very cumbersome, so that we try two alternative routes. One is to obtain a numerical solution (see Fig.2), the other one is to find an approximate analytical solution. In this sense, let us note that, if β 2q3 ≫ 1 Eqs. (4) and 1 ≃ (βq)−1, because βq ≫ f∗ ≃ (βq2)−1. (7) show that d∗ In this limit, the instability condition (11) just gives βc = q−3, (12) which provides an excellent approximation not only for c q3 ≃ q−3 ≫ 1 (say q < β 2 ∼ 0.5 ) but over the whole range 0 ≤ q ≤ 1 as shown when compared with the exact nu- merical solution (Fig. 2). Fig. 2 shows that cooperation is favored at large costs q and large β, whereas defectors dominate in the opposite 4 limit. The origin of the dependence on the average cost q is rather direct: the larger the cost, the less favorable for defectors to reproduce. The dependence on param- eter β is, however, counterintuitive since (at first sight) one would expect that large attack rates (large β) should benefit defectors. The explanation is not easy due to the nonlinearities involved in the model. One might think that the origin of the observed behavior relies on the ex- ploitation mechanism that explains the existence itself of coexistence states, and accordingly reason that large attacking rates would cause a great damage on coopera- tors, which would reduce rewards over costs, ultimately harming defectors. However, this is not what happens, since we have seen above that the average reward E ′ r is a function of q only, and then it does not change when increasing β at fixed q. One explanation of why large β favor cooperators is that it leads to a small fraction of defectors in the active state (D1), thus reducing the damage on cooperators. In effect, if resources are abundant individuals receive them frequently and there will be large populations of D1 indi- viduals; if resources are scarce, only a few individuals will be in state Ei = 1. The same occurs if attacking rates are large. Since attacks are indiscriminate, defectors are also victim of the attacks, which decrease the number of D1 individuals; conversely for small attacking rates. This ex- planation is consistent with the behavior of d1 displayed in Fig. 1a. Indeed d1 decreases yet from β = 0, i.e. below the transition, as it can be seen from our approximate so- 1 ≃ (βq)−1. Below some critical population value lution d∗ depending on q (around q2) the reduced population of de- fectors in the active state is not capable of extinguishing cooperators. In this point is worthwhile to point out that parasites continuously receive resources from the environ- ment and interact, and then, they change from active to inactive states continuosly. In the stationary state, the fraction of defectors in the population is d0 + d1. These defectors spend a fraction of time d0/(d0 + d1) in inactive states and d1/(d0 + d1) in active states. In summary, we have developed a simple model de- scribing a phase transition from defective parasitic pop- ulations (which dissipate some amount of resources in order to gain a higher reproduction rate) when resources are abundant to the survival of cooperators when re- sources are scarce. This is the result of a self-organizing process involving subtle nonlinearities in the interactions induced by resource constraints. In contrast to previous models, where the same limiting resource ruled repro- duction and population size [19, 20] and do not display this transition, the model studied here assumes that the factor limiting reproduction is different from the one lim- iting the population size, so that populazion size remains approximately constant. This may be accomplished in chemostat or retentostat experiments [28 -- 31], which may allow for laboratory testing of the predictions of the model. Indeed, recent experiments with S.Cerevisiae [21] and E.Coli [24] at low concentration of glucose agree with the results presented here of the survival of cooperative traits instead of their expected extinction in unstructured populations. In natural environments, the constant population as- sumption may apply in situations where space constraints the size of the population more restrictively than re- source scarcity. Of course, a complete description of spa- tially distributed populations goes beyond the mean-field model presented here, and should consider that interac- tions occur only among neighbors. Note however, that space alone is well-known to favor cooperation because it permits the formation of clusters of cooperators. Since we have seen here that resource limitation alone already allows for the survival of cooperation, the combined ef- fects of both space and resource limitations are expected to enhance the conditions under which cooperators can prevent their extinction. Other extensions of the model, beside the inclusion of space, may be the introduction of continuous behaviors (and not just two, namely coop- erate or defect), what could shed light on the observed phenotypic radiation of behaviors in E.Coli [25], which represents an exception to the competitive exclusion prin- ciple [33]. In a broader scope, the results presented here might have played a role in the route towards the emergence of multicellularity by cooperative aggregation triggered by resource constraints. It has been argued [22, 26, 27] that such transition happened whenever cooperative indi- viduals formed clusters, which subsequently evolved nu- trient exchange between the components of the cluster, and later evolved a joint replication mechanism, stage at which a higher-order organism can be considered to exist. However, such studies do not explain why coop- erative bacteria survived in a first stage before forming clusters. The mechanism presented here provides some insights for the maintainance of such cooperative indivi- dals before clusters of cooperators could form, being a first step towards the formation of multicellular organ- isms. This work has been supported by the Spanish gov- ernment (FIS2009-13370-C02-01) and the Generalitat de Catalunya (2009SGR0164). R.J.R. acknowledges the financial support of the Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona and the Spanish government (FPU grant). ∗ Electronic address: [email protected] [1] P. Hammerstein, ed., Genetic and Cultural Evolution of Cooperation (Dahlem Workshop Report 90) (Cambridge, 5 Massachusetts: MIT Press., 2003). [2] J. Maynard Smith and E. Szathmary, The Major Tran- sitions in Evolution (Freeman, Oxford, 1995). [3] C. Darwin, On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection (John Murray, London, 1859), 1st ed. [4] W. D. Hamilton, J. Theor. Biol. 7, 1 (1964). [5] W. D. Hamilton, J. Theor. Biol. 7, 17 (1964). [6] R. L. Riolo, M. D. Cohen, and R. Axelrod, Nature 414, 441 (2001). [7] M. A. Nowak, Science 314, 1560 (2006). [8] J. Y. Wakano, J. Theor. Biol. 247, 616 (2007). [9] U. Dobramysl and U. C. Tauber, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 258102 (2008). [10] C. Hauert, M. Holmes, and M. Doebeli, Proc. Roy. Soc. London B 273, 2565 (2006). [11] A. Melbinger, J. Cremer, and E. Frey, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 178101 (2010). [12] R. L. Trivers, Q. Rev. Biol. 46, 35 (1971). [13] R. Axelrod and W. D. Hamilton, Science 211, 1390 (1981). [14] M. A. Nowak and K. Sigmund, Nature 393, 573 (1998). [15] A. Traulsen and H. Schuster, Phys. Rev. E 68 (2003). [16] J. Gomez-Gardenes, M. Campillo, L. M. Floria, and Y. Moreno, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 (2007). [17] C. P. Roca, J. A. Cuesta, and A. Sanchez, Phys. Rev. E 80 (2009). [18] R. J. Requejo and J. Camacho, J. Theor. Biol. 272, 35 (2011). [19] R. J. Requejo and J. Camacho, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 038701 (2012). [20] R. J. Requejo and J. Camacho, Phys. Rev. E 85, 066112 (2012). [21] M.L.A. Jansen, J.A. Diderich, M. Mashego, A. Hassane, J.H. de Winde, P. Daran-Lapugadel and J.T. Pronkl, Mi- crobiol. 151, 1657-1669 (2005) [22] J. H. Koschwanez, K. R. Foster, and A. W. Murray, Plos Biology 9, e1001122 (2011). [23] J.W. Wenger, J. Piotrowski, S. Nagarajan, K. Chiotti, G. Sherlock, and F. Rosenzweib, Plos Genet. 7, e1002202 (2011). [24] L. Notely-McRobb and T. Ferenci, Environm. Microbiol., 45-52 (1999) [25] R. Maharjan, S. Sheeto, L. Notely-McRobb and T. Fer- enci, Science., 514-517 (2006) [26] T. Pfeiffer, S. Schuster, and S. Bonhoeffer, Science 292, 504 (2001), ISSN 0036-8075. [27] T. Pfeiffer and S. Bonhoeffer, Proc. Nat. Ac. Sci. USA 100, 1095 (2003), ISSN 0027-8424. [28] A. Novik and L. Szilard, Science 112, 715-716 (1950) [29] J. Monod, Annales De L Institut Pasteur 79, 390-410 (1950) [30] H.W. Jannasch, Limnol. Oceanogr. 19, 716-720 (1974) [31] A. Groisman, C. Lobo, H.J. Cho, J.K. Campbell, Y.S. Dufour, A.M. Stevens and A. Levchenko Nature Methods 2, 685-689 (2005) [32] J. Alonso, A. Fernandez, and H. Fort, J. Stat. Mech., P06013 (2006) [33] G. Hardin, Science, 1292 (1960)
0911.2722	2	0911	2011-05-20T21:49:58	A Stochastic Compartmental Model for Fast Axonal Transport	[ "physics.bio-ph", "math.PR", "q-bio.NC" ]	In this paper we develop a probabilistic micro-scale compartmental model and use it to study macro-scale properties of axonal transport, the process by which intracellular cargo is moved in the axons of neurons. By directly modeling the smallest scale interactions, we can use recent microscopic experimental observations to infer all the parameters of the model. Then, using techniques from probability theory, we compute asymptotic limits of the stochastic behavior of individual motor-cargo complexes, while also characterizing both equilibrium and non-equilibrium ensemble behavior. We use these results in order to investigate three important biological questions: (1) How homogeneous are axons at stochastic equilibrium? (2) How quickly can axons return to stochastic equilibrium after large local perturbations? (3) How is our understanding of delivery time to a depleted target region changed by taking the whole cell point-of-view?	physics.bio-ph	physics	A Stochastic Compartmental Model for Fast Axonal Transport Scott A. McKinley∗ Lea Popovic† Michael C. Reed‡ October 29, 2018 Abstract In this paper we develop a probabilistic micro-scale model and use it to study macro-scale properties of axonal transport, the processes by which materials are moved in the axons of neurons. By directly mod- eling the smallest scale interactions, we can use recent microscopic ex- perimental observations to infer all the parameters of the model. Then using techniques from queueing theory, we can predict macroscopic behavior in order to investigate three important biological questions: (1) How homogeneous are axons at stochastic equilibrium? (2) How quickly can axons return to stochastic equilibrium after large local perturbations? (3) How inhomogeneous does deposition and turnover make the axon? 1 Introduction In all cells, one finds that proteins, membrane-bound organelles, and other structures (e.g. chromosomes) are transported from place to place at speeds much higher than diffusion. Though these transport processes are funda- mental to cell function, many of the underlying mechanisms, organizational principles, and regulatory features remain unknown. Axonal transport is one of the best studied systems because the transport is basically one- dimensional since axons are long and narrow. There are two speeds of axonal transport. Fast transport goes at speeds of roughly 0.2 to 0.5 meters/day ∗Department of Mathematics, Duke University, Box 90320, Durham, NC 27701 ([email protected]) †Department of Mathematics and Statistics, Concordia University, Montreal QC H3G 1M8 ‡Department of Mathematics, Duke University, Box 90320, Durham, NC 27701 1 2 [20][24], while slow transport goes at approximately 1 millimeter/day, the rate of axon growth and regeneration [5][20]. The biology and principles of slow transport are not yet clear [5], but the basic mechanisms of fast ax- onal transport were discovered in the 1980s [2][3][22][34]. The model in this paper refers to fast axonal transport, which we will henceforth call axonal transport. The axonal transport apparatus consists of vesicles which form reversible chemical bonds with motor proteins that bind reversibly to microtubules which run parallel to the long dimension of the axon [1]. When the vesicle- motor protein complex is assembled on the microtubule, the complex steps stochastically with step size approximately 8 nanometers for kinesin and dynein and 10 nanometers for myosin [6][10][16][31]. The vesicles enter from the cell body on microtubules and then detach and reattach to the transport mechanism at random times. In this paper we propose a spatial Markov-chain compartmental model based on these dynamics. We will assume independence of the interactions, and exponential wait times between events. While we address the validity of these assumptions in the Discussion section, we consider this a useful "first- order" approximation that permits study of the dynamics from both the perspective of individual vesicles as well as that of the full spatial system. Such a model unifies some earlier modeling efforts and can accommodate both qualitative and quantitative experimental data observed on multiple scales. In much experimental work in the 1970s and 1980s, radio-labeled amino acids were put into the cell bodies continuously or for a few hours. The amino acids were incorporated into proteins that were packaged into vesicles and put on the transport system so that at later times radioactivity could be seen moving progressively down the axons. In the continuous infusion case, one would see a wave of radioactivity with a sharp but slowly spreading wavefront propagating at constant velocity down the axon. In the case of infusion for a few hours one would see at long times a slowly spreading pulse of radioactivity that looked normally distributed. It was to understand this behavior that Reed and Blum constructed PDE models for axonal transport [3][25][26]. These models did not have traveling wave solutions, but the data certainly looked like approximate traveling waves. In [27] it was shown by a perturbation theory argument that, in the asymptotic limit where the unbinding and binding rates k1 and k2 get large, the solution approaches a slowly spreading traveling wave or a normal pulse. Recently, in a series of papers, Friedman and co-workers have introduced new PDE models and proved these results rigorously[12][13][14][15]. 3 Probabilistic models for axonal transport were introduced and used for simulations already in the 1980s [30][32]. However, rigorous work began with Lawler [21] in 1995 and was continued by Brooks [4] who used a continuous time stochastic model to show that the distribution of an individual particle is a spreading Gaussian at large times. Brooks also proved tail estimates for the central limit theorem and used them to estimate the error from normal. 1.1 Summary of Results In this paper we revise the existing probabilistic models in order to ob- serve randomness in the system as a whole rather than exclusively from the particle's point of view. Our goal is to exploit experimental observations at multiple scales in order to make predictions about the perceived homo- geneity of material along the length of the axon. To this end, we propose in Section 2 a continuous-time Markov chain queueing model for the axonal transport system and estimate the order of magnitude of the various param- eters. The precise values of the parameters will vary for different molecular motors, for various types of cargo and for various animal species. In Section 3 we take the individual vesicle point-of-view to recover pre- vious results [4] [26] and show that this model does unify and extend the existing probabilistic and PDE models. Using standard results from re- newal theory we calculate the mean velocity and the near-Gaussian wave- front spreading of the law of the vesicle's location. Since we assume indepen- dence of the particle interactions, the law of an individual is equivalent to the distribution of an ensemble of particles released at the same time. Therefore the PDE governing a spatial-continuum limit of the law of a single particle is the same as the PDE studied in [26] (see Section 3.3). Subsequently in Section 4 we adopt the full spatial system perspective to quantify stochasticity along the length of the axon. We begin by calculating in Proposition 4.1 the stationary distribution of a flow-through system that has sustained input from the nucleus, while particles are removed upon reaching the distal end. The stationary distribution has a product Poisson structure which allows for seamless transition between spatial scales. Via the coefficient of variation we give a precise characterization in Section 4.2 of the experimenter's qualitative perception of homogeneity at the millimeter scale. The final two sections deal with model predictions. In Section 5 we study the non-equilibrium dynamics of recovery. Due to the product struc- ture of the law of the transient dynamics, behavior is determined by the 2N - dimensional ODE governing the means. From this we estimate the timescale 4 of return to equilibrium as a function of the lengthscale of interest. In Sec- tion 6 we consider the effect of deposition of material in the cell membrane. We find that there should be an exponential loss of material along the length of the cell, and conclude that a new biological mechanism must be discov- ered to account for the homogeneity that is a hallmark of axonal transport experimental observations. 2 The model and its parameters Let L be the length of the axon, divided evenly into N lateral sections each of length δ, equal to the step size of the motor protein. Within each section, we disregard any further spatial geometry and take the particles to be in one of two states: • an on-transport state with mean lateral velocity v, or • an off-transport state with lateral velocity 0. We use a 2N -dimensional continuous time Markov chain to model the particle dynamics: • Qi(t) is the number of particles in the on-transport state in section i, • Pi(t) is the number of particles in the off-transport state in section i. Each Qi and Pi has the natural numbers N = {0, 1, 2, . . .} as its state space. In the simplest model, we consider the following transitions and rates, • Lateral transport: (Qi, Qi+1) → (Qi − 1, Qi+1 + 1) at rate rQi(t), where r = v/δ; • Switch from on-transport to off-transport: (Qi, Pi) → (Qi − 1, Pi + 1) at rate k1Qi(t); • Switch from off-transport to on-transport: (Pi, Qi) → (Pi − 1, Qi + 1) at rate k2Pi(t); • Production of new particles: (Q1) → (Q1 + 1) at rate q0r; • Removal of particles at distal end: (QN ) → (QN − 1) at rate rQN (t). Q1 = 3 P1 = 3 ∗ • ∗ ∗ ∗ • x = L 3 Q2 = 1 P2 = 2 ∗ • • N u c l e u s x = 0 5 Q3 = 3 P3 = 2 • ∗ ∗ • • x = 2L 3 x = L Q1 ✲q0r Q2 ✲r Q3 ✲r ✲r ❑ k2 k1 ❯ P1 ❑ k2 k1 ❯ P2 ❑ k2 k1 ❯ P3 Figure 1: Double Chain The lateral transport rate, r, is inversely proportional to the length scale so that the mean number of particles per unit length is invariant with respect to rescaling δ. The rate of production, q0r, ensures that this mean number per unit scales with q0. A graph of the model is depicted in Figure 1. In order to ensure the Markov property, we use exponential random variables for the waiting times between transition events. Specifically, we mean that after a given event we assign a new independent random variable to each of the 3N + 2 possible next events, exponentially distributed with the appropriate rate parameter. The system of values updates according to the transition associated with the minimum of these waiting times. Then we create a new set of exponential random variables and the process proceeds as before. 6 This is an exactly solvable model. The advantage of computing explicit formulas for quantities that can be observed in experiments is that the ex- perimental data can then be used to determine the parameter values in the model. For the characterization of the approximate wavefront speed and spreading in Section 3 and the homogeneity calculations in Section 4 we need order-of-magnitude estimates for the parameters. Actual parameter values will certainly differ depending on the particular neural tissue and the particular particles being transported. However, we can get order-of- magnitude estimates from existing data. First we recall that fast transport has been observed to travel at speeds of 0.2 to 0.5 m per day. We can assume that the average velocity of particles while physically bound to microtubules is roughly 1 m per day, or 10−6 m/s. We have already stated the assumption that the length scale of the individual steps satisfies δ ∼ 10−8m. This implies that the rate parameter should be r = v/δ = 102s−1. We now turn our attention to the on-off rates rates k1 and k2. These can be determined from experimentally observed run lengths on the transport system. Indeed, Dixit et al. [9] show that a typical run along microtubules for dinein and kinesin is on the order of 10−6m. We can compare this with the theoretical run length of the model to determine off-rate k1. Within the model, at each step on the transport mechanism the particle has a binary decision to jump laterally along the transport with probability r/(k1 + r), or to jump off with probability k1/(r + k1). The number of jumps along the transport system before jumping off is therefore geometrically distributed . It follows that average on the set {0, 1, . . .} with success probability number of steps in the run is r and therefore the average run length is k1 r k1 × 10−8 m. Setting this equal to the average experimental run length of 10−6 from [9], we see that r k1 ∼ 102, implying that k1 ∼ 1s−1. As we will see in the computation of the stationary distribution in Section 4.1, the ratio of the expected number of particles on the track to those off the track is k1 . k2 Dixit [9] found that approximately 75% of the particles were motile so this ratio is approximately equal to 3. Since k1 ∼ 1s−1 we see that k2 ∼ 1 3 . It remains to estimate q0. We will see in Proposition 4.1 that the mean number of particles per unit length is (1 + k1 )q0 = 4q0. Of course, axons k2 have a large variety of diameters and larger axons will have more vesicles per unit length so one expects a range of values for q0. However, examination of a large number of electron micrographs of axonal cross-sections (see for example [17], Fig. 3; [18]; [23]), which are typically 100 nm thick enables one to estimate the number of vesicles per 100 nm segment. This number r+k1 r 7 is typically in the range of 10 to 100 which implies that there are 1 to 10 vesicles per "box" in our model. Therefore q0 is in the range 0.25 to 2.5, for various axons. We remark that we are ignoring some aspects of the physics and the biology of axonal transport. We are not including diffusion of the vesicles off the track. We are treating the microtubule track as though it were a single continuous entity from one end of the axon to the other, when it fact it consists of numerous, separated, microtubule fragments. And, we are ignoring retrograde transport and the details of the motor proteins. Nevertheless, this simple model will enable us to investigate the homogeneity questions that are the main goal of this paper. 3 Dynamics from the Particle Perspective In this section we calculate properties of the stochastic dynamics by using standard theorems from queuing theory. In the δ → 0 limit, the law of the location of a single particle converges to the Green's function of a linear partial differential equation. This enables us to obtain, as a special case, the asymptotic behavior of the PDE models for axonal transport in various asymptotic limits. 3.1 The active transport mode We first consider the simple case where the particle starts at X0 = 0 and stays exclusively in active transport mode. Let Xt ∈ {0, δ, 2δ, . . . , L} be the lateral position of a particle at time t and let nt be the number of jumps made by the particle as of time t. Observe, Xt = δnt. Proposition 3.1. Let k1 = k2 = 0, and r = v/δ > 0, then Xt ∼ P ois(vt). In particular, the mean velocity of the particle is given by 1 E[Xt] = v. For t any given t ≥ 0, in the limit as δ → 0 the position of the particle satisfies Xt t a.s.−→ v and 1 √δ(cid:16)Xt − vt(cid:17)t≥0 where B is a standard Brownian motion. d=⇒√v(cid:0)Bt(cid:1)t≥0 Proof. Since Xt = δnt where (cid:0)nt(cid:1)t≥0 is a Poisson process with rate r = v/δ the set out results follow from the law of large numbers (LLN) and the central limit theorem (CLT) for a Poisson process. 8 3.2 The on/off dynamics We now consider a particle which undergoes transitions from on-transport to off-transport state and back. Denote again by Xt ∈ {0, δ, 2δ, . . . , L} the lateral position of a particle at time t and let nt be the number of lateral transition jumps made by the particle as of time t. Observe that the particle will spend only a fraction of its time in active transport and hence the lateral speed of the particle should be slower than before. Proposition 3.2. Let k1, k2 > 0, and let r = v/δ > 0, then the mean velocity of the particle satisfies 1 t k1+k2 v. k2 E[Xt] −→t→∞ Proof. Consider the time τ for a particle to make one step of lateral trans- port. Before doing so a particle performs m switches from on-transport k1+r ) to off-transport and back, where m is distributed as a Geometric( variable. The amounts of time a particle takes for each switch τ Q→P from on-transport to off-transport are iid variables with Exponential(k1+r) distri- bution. Likewise, the amounts of time a particle takes for each switch τ P→Q from off-transport back to on-transport are iid variables with Exponential(k2) distribution, and are independent of the other switching times. Then r i i m τ = i Xi=1(cid:0)τ Q→P + τ P→Q i m+1 (cid:1) + τ Q→Q with E[τ ] = (k1 + k2)/(k2r). Let nt be the number of times a particle makes a step of lateral transport until time t. By the Renewal Theorem 1 . t E[τ ] , and the result follows from Xt = δnt and δ k2r = k2v k1+k2 k1+k2 1 E[nt] →t→∞ Proposition 3.3. Let k1, k2 > 0, and r = v/δ > 0. In the limit as δ → 0 the position of a particle satisfies Xt t a.s −→t→∞ k2 k1 + k2 v, and √t(cid:16) Xt t − k2 k1 + k2 =⇒t→∞s 2k1k2 v(cid:17) d (k1 + k2)3 vB1 where B1 ∼ Normal(0, 1). Proof. The number of lateral transport steps (nt)t≥0 is a renewal chain with E[τ ] = (k1 + k2)/k2r and Var[τ ] = ((k1 + k2)2 + 2k1r)/r2k2 2. By the LLN and CLT for Renewal chains nt t a.s−→t→∞ 1 E[τ ] , and √t(cid:16) nt t − 1 E[τ ](cid:17) d=⇒t→∞s Var[τ ] (E[τ ])3 B1 and now the result follows from Xt = δnt, δ 1 E[τ ] = δ k2r k1+k2 9 = k2 k1+k2 v, and δ2 Var[τ ] (E[τ ])3 = δk2v k1 + k2 + 2k1k2v2 (k1 + k2)3 ≈ 2k1k2 (k1 + k2)3 v2 for δ ≈ 0. The fact that an individual particle starting at x = 0 will have the distri- bution given by Proposition 3.3 at long times was also obtained by Brooks [4] who proved tail estimates on the CLT and found that the remainder is O( 1√t ). In our approach, one can obtain the same error estimate using the asymptotic analysis of renewal chains, see, for example, [7]. 3.3 Connection to Partial Differential Equations Models. In order to demonstrate the connection between our model and the PDEs seen in [27][26][14], we make a formal calculation regarding convergence of the law of the location of a single particle in the full system. Let δN = 1 N and let XN (t) denote the lateral position of a particle in a system with N boxes. Define qN (x, t) := P{XN (t) = x, and the particle is on track} pN (x, t) := P{XN (t) = x, and the particle is off track.} We suppress N in the notation. By definition of the Poisson process, for small values of h we have q(x, t + h) = q(x, t)(1 − (k1 + r)h) + q(x − δ, t)rh + p(x, t)k2h + o(h) p(x, t + h) = p(x, t)(1 − k2h) + q(x, t)k1h + o(h). which we may reorganize as 1 (q(x, t + h) − q(x, t)) = r[q(x − δ, t) − q(x, t)] − k1q(x, t) + p(x, t)k2 + h 1 (p(x, t + h) − p(x, t)) = −k2p(x, t) + k1q(x, t) + h Formally, we take the Taylor expansion of q in space: q(x − δ, t) = q(x, t) − δ∂xq(x, t) + o(δ2). Taking limits as h → 0 and δ → 0 yields the system of PDEs o(h) h o(h) . h ∂tq(x, t) + v∂xq(x, t) = −k1q(x, t) + k2p(x, t) ∂tp(x, t) = k1q(x, t) − k2p(x, t). (1) (2) 10 When k1 = 0 = k2, the limiting PDE is simple linear transport: (∂t + v∂x)q(x, t) = 0. The initial condition q(x, 0) = δ0(x) corresponds to the density of a single particle at the origin at t = 0. The time evolution via simple linear transport is translation of the delta function, while the time evolution via the equations (1) and (2) will have a spreading profile. This is seen in Propositions 3.1 and 3.3 since the variance of the fluctuations goes to 0 in Proposition 3.1 but not in Proposition 3.3 as δ → 0. In the experiments described in the introduction one sees "approximate" traveling waves of radioactivity in the axons in the sense that there is a slowly spreading wave front moving at constant velocity away from the cell body. The equations (3) and (4) are linear and do not have solutions that are bounded traveling waves. However, it was shown by a perturbation theory argument in [27][26] that as ε → 0 the solutions of ε(∂t + v∂x)qε(x, t) = −k1qε(x, t) + k2pε(x, t), ε∂tpε(x, t) = k1qε(x, t) − k2pε(x, t). qε(0, t) = q0 (3) (4) are to leading order qε(x, t) = H( x − at ε1/2 , t), pε(x, t) = cH( x − at ε1/2 , t), where H satisfies the heat equation ∂sH(y, s) = κ2 2 ∂yyH(y, s), H(y, 0) = χ(−∞,0), and a = k1v k1 + k2 , κ2 = 2k1k2v2 (k1 + k2)3 . (5) This asymptotic form is valid for small ε, that is for large k1 and k2. How- ever, if we set q(x, t) = qε( x ε ), then q and p satisfy (3) and (4), so the solutions of (3) and (4) behave like approximate travel- ing waves for large t and large x whether or not k1 and k2 are large. The results suggested by these perturbation theory arguments have been proven rigorously by Friedman and coworkers [12][13][14][15]. ε ) and p(x, t) = pε( x ε , t ε , t In the case that radiolabeled particles enter the axon only for a short time, 0 ≤ t ≤ T , the same perturbation analysis shows that for large times the solution of (3) and (4), where q(0, t) = 0 for t > T is to leading order a spreading Gaussian with mean and variance as given in Proposition 3.3. This 11 corresponds to what is seen experimentally and arises asymptotically in the solutions of (3) and (4) by convolving the asymptotic solution corresponding to the initial condition q(x, 0) = δ0(x) with the indicator function χ[0,T ](x). 4 Dynamics from the spatial system perspective 4.1 The spatial system in equilibrium We are now ready to characterize the steady state dynamics induced by continually adding particles from the nucleus and removing them when they reach the distal end of the cell. Proposition 4.1. If the incoming rate of particles at Q0 is q0r, then the system has the following stationary distribution Qi ∼ P ois(q0), k2 (cid:19) Pi ∼ P ois(cid:18) k1q0 where the {Qi} and {Pi} are mutually independent. Proof. Given the value of the input rate Q0 = q∗ the generator of the process (Q1, P1) in the first section is Aq∗f (q, p) = [f (q + 1, p) − f (q, p)]rq∗ + [f (q − 1, p) − f (q, p)]rq + [f (q − 1, p + 1) − f (q, p)]k1q + [f (q + 1, p − 1) − f (q, p)]k2p If we first use f (q, p) = Q1(t) then use f (q, p) = P1(t) and take expectations we get a system of ODE's governing the change in E[Q1], E[P1] over time dE[Q1](t) dt dE[P1](t) dt = rE[Q0] − rE[Q1(t)] − k1E[Q1(t)] + k2E[P1(t)] = k1E[Q1(t)] − k2E[P1(t)] indicating that in equilibrium E[Q1] = E[Q0], E[P1] = E[Q1] k1 . For pur- k2 poses that will soon be clear we first assume that Q0 has a constant Pois(λ∗) distribution over time rather than just being equal to λ∗. Let π(q∗, q, p) = πλ∗(q∗) ⊗ πλQ(q) ⊗ πλP (p) where πλ are Pois(λ) distributions with rates λ∗, λQ = λ∗, and λP = λ∗ respectively. To show that π(q∗, q, p) is a stationary distribution for the process (Q1, P1) we need to check that k1 k2 ∞ Xq∗=0 ∞ Xq=0 ∞ Xp=0 Aq∗f (q, p)π(q∗, q, p) = 0 12 q∗ q∗ ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ λp P λp P p! λq Q q! λq Q q! Xp=0 λ∗ q∗! for any choice of function f ∈ D(Aq∗). Aq∗f (q, p)e−(λ∗+λQ+λP ) λ∗ Xq∗=0 Xq=0 q∗! = e−(λ∗+λQ+λP ) ∞ Xq∗=0 Xp=0 p! (cid:0)[f (q + 1, p) − f (q, p)]rq∗ + [f (q − 1, p) − f (q, p)]rq + [f (q − 1, p + 1) − f (q, p)]k1q + [f (q + 1, p − 1) − f (q, p)]k2p(cid:1)(cid:17) In the inner two sums, for a fixed value of q∗, the factor multiplying f (q, p) for any q, p ∈ N2 comes only from terms involving {q − 1, q, q + 1} and {p − 1, p, p + 1} and equals e−(λ∗+λQ+λP ) times λp P p! λq+1 Q (q + 1)! Xq=0 rq∗ − λq Q q! λp P p! λp P p! (cid:16) rq λq−1 Q (q − 1)! r(q + 1) − λq Q q! λq Q q! λp P p! λp P p! k1q k2p k1(q + 1) − k2(p + 1) − λQ q + 1 p λP k1(q + 1) λp P p! rq∗ + λp−1 P (p − 1)! λp+1 P (p + 1)! λq Q q! λq+1 Q (q + 1)! λq−1 Q (q − 1)! rq∗ − rq∗ + λP p + 1 q λQ λQ q + 1 + + λq Q q! = λp P p! (cid:16) q λQ r(q + 1) − rq + k2(p + 1) − k2p(cid:17) = λp P λq Q q! − k1q + rq∗ − rq∗ + λ∗r − rq(cid:17) p! (cid:16) q since λQ = λ∗ and λP Summing over q∗ the factor multiplying f (q, p) becomes = k1 k2 λ∗ λQ . e−(λQ+λP ) λq Q q! λp P p! = e−(λQ+λP ) λq Q q! ∞ q∗ rq∗ − rq∗ + λ∗r − rq(cid:17) λ∗ e−λ∗ λ∗ q∗! (cid:16) q Xq∗=0 p! (cid:16)qr − rλ∗ + λ∗r − rq(cid:17) = 0 λp P 13 We've just shown that if the distribution of input particles Q0 in equi- librium is Pois(λ∗) then the stationary distribution of Q1, P1 is independent of the distribution of Q0 and is πλQ ⊗ πλP where λQ = E[Q0], and λP = E[Q0]k1/k2. It is easy to see in the above calculation that if the input Q0 was indeed constant q0 then the stationary distribution of (P1, Q1) would again be πλQ ⊗ πλP with rates λQ = q0 and λP = q0k1/k2 respectively. Now, since the stationary distribution of Q1 is the input into (Q2, P2) process, the more general calculation shows that in equilibrium the stationary distribution of (Q2, P2) is independent of the stationary distribution for Q1 and is πλQ⊗πλP It with rates λQ = E[Q1] = q0 and λP = E[Q1]k1/k2 = q0k1/k2 again. follows by induction that the stationary distributions for {(Qi, Pi)} are in- dependent and identically distributed as πλQ ⊗ πλP , λQ = q0, λP = q0k1/k2. This is also an example of a clustering process satisfying the detailed balance conditions with linear rates discussed in Sec. 8.2 of [19]. 4.2 Homogeneity of the axons at equilibrium Recall that δ = 10nm, roughly the step size of motor proteins, and that axons can be up to one meter in length. Thus we are interested in phenomena on all the length scales 10ν δ, where ν = 1, 2, . . . 8. Let ∆ = 10ν δ; we want to determine how similar different segments of the axon of size ∆ are. Let Q∆ and P∆ denote the numbers of on-track and off-track particles in a segment of length ∆. In equilibrium, Q∆ and P∆ are both sums of 10ν independent Poisson random variables with parameters λQ = q0 and λP = k1 q0, respectively. k2 Therefore the distributions of Q∆ and P∆ are Poisson with parameters 10ν λQ and 10ν λP , respectively. The mean and the variance of the num- ber of particles in the segment of length ∆ is 10ν (λQ + λP ). To see how homogeneous different slices of length ∆ are, we consider the coefficient of variation, c∆, which is the standard deviation divided by the mean. c∆ = 1 = p(λQ + λP )10ν p(1 + k1/k2)q0∆108 1 . As indicated in Section 2, q0 is in the range 0.25 to 2.5 in different axons. For illustrative purposes here, we will assume q0 = 1. Since k1/k2 = 3, we see that the scale-dependent coefficient of variation c∆ = 1/(2√108∆). Therefore at the ten nanometer scale the coefficient of variation is simply 1/2. At the micron scale c∆ = 1/20 and at the millimeter scale c∆ = 0.5 × 10−5/2. The cutoff between "high variance" and "low variance" distributions 14 is usually considered to be when the coefficient of variation is near 1, so by this standard the axon is extremely homogeneous in its length at large scales. 5 Approaching Equilibrium We have seen above that the axon is very homogeneous at stochastic equilib- rium on a space scale down to micrometers. One of the beautiful properties of the system of transport with reversible binding is that if it is locally out of equilibrium, the dynamics will automatically take it back to equilibrium. This is of fundamental importance to the biological function of the system because it means that the axon will automatically "repair" itself without central control of the repair process. How good is this mechanism? If a segment of the axon is far away from equilibrium, how long does it take to get back close to equilibrium? We study this question first for a single location and then use the estimates derived to scale the results to segments of any length. Proposition 5.1. Let (Q, P )(0) = (0, 0) and let the constants a > 0 and p ∈ (0, 1) satisfy the relationship a2pλ∞ > 1 where λ∞ is the equilibrium vector of (Q, P )(t). Then there exists a t∗ such that t ≥ t∗, In fact, the choice is sufficient, where α := P{(Q, P )(t) − λ∞ ≥ aλ∞} ≤ p. t∗ = α−1 ln(cid:16) ppλ∞ appλ∞ − 1(cid:17) 1 2(cid:16)k1 + k2 + r −p(k1 + k2 + r)2 − 4k2r(cid:17) Proof. We begin by noting that for any given β ∈ (0, 1), we may choose t∗ > 0 such that for all t ≥ t∗, the vector of means λ(t) := E[(Q, P )(t)] satisfies λ(t) − λ∞ ≤ aβλ∞. Then P{(Q, P )(t) − λ∞ ≥ aλ∞} ≤ P{(Q, P )(t) − λ(t) + λ(t) − λ∞ ≥ aλ∞} ≤ P{(Q, P )(t) − λ(t) ≥ a(1 − β)λ∞} Applying Chebyshev's Inequality, and observing that the variance of a Pois- son random variable is equal to its mean, we conclude that P{(Q, P )(t) − λ∞ ≥ aλ∞} ≤ Var[(Q, P )(t)] a2(1 − β)2λ∞2 = λ(t) a2(1 − β)2λ∞2 15 Since the initial condition for both P and Q are less than their respec- tive equilibrium values, each are monotonically increasing functions and the above reduces to P{(Q, P )(t) − λ∞ ≥ aλ∞} ≤ 1 a2(1 − β)2λ∞ for all t > t∗. In order to satisfy the requirement that the right hand side must be less than p, we solve for β and find 1 appλ∞ β = 1 − provided that appλ∞ > 1. It remains to study the convergence of the mean and the appropriate choice of t∗. The dynamics of the mean vector λ(t) are given by the ODE (6) λ(t) = −A1λ(t) + q0re1 where e1 is the unit vector (1, 0) and A1 =(cid:18) k1 + r −k2 k2 (cid:19) . −k1 The solution to (6) is λ(t) = λ∞ + e−A1t(λ(0) − λ∞) where λ∞ = q0rA−1 1 e1 = q0(1, rk1 k2 ). This yields the estimate where α is the smaller of the eigenvalues of A1, namely λ(t) − λ∞ ≤(cid:12)(cid:12)e−A1tλ∞(cid:12)(cid:12) ≤ e−αtλ∞ (k1 + k2 + r −p(k1 + k2 + r)2 − 4k2r). Noting that α > 0, t∗ may be chosen so that e−αt∗ ≤ aβ, i.e. α = 1 2 t∗ = α−1 ln(1/(aβ)) 16 We now suppose that the whole axon is in statistical equilibrium except for a segment of length δ × 10ν m in which we will assume that there are no particles either on or off the track. We want to know how long will it take for this segment to get back close to equilibrium. Of course, Proposition 5.1 covered the case ν = 0. We are interested in ν = 1, . . . , 8. We imagine that the axon is broken up into 108−ν segments of length δ × 10ν m. In this rescaled system, the unbinding and binding rates per particle, k1 and k2 remain the same, as well as the mean on-transport velocity v. In order to retain this mean velocity, the rate of lateral stepping must be decreased to r = r × 10−ν . The ODE for the mean vector of the rescaled system is given by d dt λ(t) = − A1 λ(t) + q0re1 (7) with A1 =(cid:18) k1 + r −k2 k2 (cid:19) . −k1 We note that the last term in (7) contains an r rather than an r. This is because the input rate is unchanged while the exit rate is diminished. The resulting equilibrium value is therefore rescaled as well, λ∞ = q0r A−1 1 e1 = q0 r r(cid:18) 1 k1/k2(cid:19). Both components of this vector are of order 10ν , as expected. We will use the parameters discussed in Section 2: k1 = 1, k2 = 1 3 , v = 10−6m/s, r = 102s−1. This implies r = 102−ν s−1. As in our analysis in Proposition 5.1, the time to equilibrium, t∗, is proportional to α−1 where α satisfies: 1 α = = 2(cid:16)k1 + k2 + r −p(k1 + k2 + r)2 − 4k2r(cid:17) k1 + k2 + r +p(k1 + k2 + r)2 − 4k2r 2k2r . We are most interested in the cases ν ≥ 3 (the segment has length ≥ 10 mi- crons). Then k2r is small compared to k1. Ignoring constants and restricting our attention to the leading order terms gives α ∼ k2r k1 + k2 + r ∼ 102−ν s−1 17 Thus, t∗ ∼ 10ν−2s. Thus, for a 10 micron segment (ν = 3) the time to equilibrium is about 10 seconds and for a 1 millimeter segment (ν = 5) the time to equilibrium is 1000 seconds or 15 minutes. Of course, the time to get close to equilibrium depends on the parameter p that represents what we mean by "close." 6 Transport with Deposition One major feature of the biology we have ignored is that some particles in the off-transport state are actually deposed permanently in the membrane or are used for some other purpose. Such a phenomenon is easy to add to the model proposed above, but we must address a new qualitative feature of the results. Namely there is an exponential loss of material as we move toward the distal end. Q1 ✲q0r Q2 ✲r Q3 ✲r ✲r ❑ k2 k1 ❯ P1 ❑ k2 k1 ❯ P2 ❑ k2 k1 ❯ P3 k3 ❄ k3 ❄ k3 ❄ D1 ❄1/τ D2 ❄1/τ D3 ❄1/τ Figure 2: Fast Axonal Transport with Deposition 18 In addition to deposition, we recognize that particles are only useful in the membrane for a random amount of time with a given half-life, after which they decompose and get transported back to the cell body. Neglecting this retrograde transport, we augment the previous model as follows: at each δ- length lateral section let Di(t) be the number of particles deposed in section i, with N = {0, 1, 2, . . .} as the state space for Di. In addition to the previous dynamics we also define the following transition rates • (Pi, Di) → (Pi − 1, Di + 1) (deposition) at rate k3Pi(t) • Di → Di − 1 (decay) at rate 1/τ where τ > 0 The constant τ in the decay rate is the average lifetime of a deposed particle. 6.1 Dynamics from the particle perspective As before, we can use the renewal theorem to determine the average speed of particles that are not deposed, as well as the spreading of the wavefront. E[Xt] −→t→∞ Proposition 6.1. Let k1, k2, k3 > 0, τ < ∞ and let r = v/δ > 0, then the mean velocity of the particle that is not deposed into the membrane by time t satisfies 1 t Moreover, in the limit as δ → 0 the position of a particle satisfies Xt t k2 + k3 =⇒t→∞s 2k1(k2 + k3) v(cid:17) d (k1 + k2 + k3)3 vB1 k1 + k2 + k3 v, √t(cid:16) Xt t − k1 + k2 + k3 a.s −→t→∞ k2+k3 k1+k2+k3 v. k2 + k3 where B1 ∼ Normal(0, 1). Remark 1. Notice the mean velocity of particles is higher than when there is no deposition k2 + k3 (k1 + k2 + k3) v ≥ k2 (k1 + k2) v, with equality iff k3 = 0 A simple explanation for this is that particles that are still in lateral trans- port had returned to on-transport back from off-transport before managing to be deposed into the membrane, meaning that their time off-transport was shorter than it would have been if they did not have to beat the exponential clock for deposition. Proof. When there is deposition then by time t each particle has either already deposed, or is still performing lateral transport. A particle that is deposed into the membrane has velocity zero from the time of its deposition on. A particle that can still be laterally transported must have avoided deposition until time t. 19 If we proceed along the lines of the proof without deposition, then the only difference now is that the amount of time a particle takes for each switch from off-transport back to on-transport are i.i.d. exponential variables with parameter k2+k3 rather than k2. Hence the amount of time τ for a particle to make a step from one section to another has E[τ ] = (k1+k2+k3)/((k2+k3)r), and by the Renewal Theorem the number of steps a particle that can still be laterally transported satisfies 1 t (k1+k2+k3) r. (k2+k3) E[nt] →t→∞ Also Var[τ ] = ((k1 + k2 + k3)(k1 + k2 + k3 + 2k1r))/r2(k2 + k3)2, so the result now follows by the Renewal LLN and CLT for nt and the fact that δ 1 E[τ ] = δ (k2 + k3)r k1 + k2 + k3 = k2 + k3 k1 + k2 + k3 v, and δ2 Var[τ ] (E[τ ])3 = δ(k2 + k3)v k1 + k2 + k3 + 2k1(k2 + k3)v2 (k1 + k2 + k3)3 ≈ 2k1(k2 + k3) (k1 + k2 + k3)3 v2 for δ ≈ 0 6.2 Dynamics from the spatial system perspective Once again we compute the stationary distribution of the flow-through sys- tem, this time with deposition. Proposition 6.2. Suppose the incoming rate of particles at Q0 is q0r. Then the stationary distribution of the system is q0ρi(cid:19) Qi ∼ P ois(q0 ρi), Pi ∼ P ois(cid:18) k1 where ρ = r(k2 + k3)/((r + k1)(k2 + k3) − k1k2) and {Qi}, {Pi}, and {Di} are mutually independent. q0ρi(cid:19) , Di ∼ P ois(cid:18) k1k3τ k2 + k3 k2 + k3 Proof. Since (Qi, Pi) do not depend on Di the proof for the stationary dis- tribution of (Qi, Pi) follows along the same lines as in the case when there is no deposition. We first check the stationary distribution for the process (Q1, P1) in the first section. For given value of Q0 = q∗ the generator of the 20 process (Q1, P1) is given by Aq∗f (Q1, P1) = [f (Q1 + 1, P1) − f (Q1, P1)]rq∗ + [f (Q1 − 1, P1) − f (Q1, P1)]rQ1 + [f (Q1 − 1, P1 + 1) − f (Q1, P1)]k1Q1 + [f (Q1 + 1, P1 − 1) − f (Q1, P1)]k2P1 + [f (Q1, P1 − 1) − f (Q1, P1)]k3P1 The system of ODE's governing the change in E[Q1], E[P1] is now ∂tE[Q1] ∂t ∂tE[P1] ∂t = E[Q0]r − E[Q1]r − E[Q1]k1 + E[P1]k2 = E[Q1]k1 − E[P1]k2 − E[P1]k3 Hence, in equilibrium and E[Q1] = E[Q0] k2 + k3 (r + k1)(k2 + k3) − k1k2 = q0ρ E[P1] = E[Q1] k1 k2 + k3 = k1q0 k2 + k3 ρ. If we let λQ = E[Q1], λP = E[P1], and define the distribution π(Q0, Q1, P1) = πq0δ(Q0) ⊗ πλQ(Q1) ⊗ πλP (P1), then P∞q∗,q,p=0 Aq∗f (q, p)π(q∗, q, p) = 0 can be verified exactly as before. Since now the mean of Q1 differs from the mean of Q0 by a multiplicative factor ρ < 1, and this is the mean of the input into Q2, it follows by induction that the sequence of rates for {Qi, Pi} Poisson random variables decays geometrically in i by a factor ρi. This immediately implies that in equilibrium the magnitude of the variances also decays geometrically along the line of progression of lateral transport. To find the stationary distribution for Di note that if the number of particles at Pi = p∗ the generator for Di is Ap∗f (d) = [f (d + 1) − f (d)]k3p∗ + [f (d − 1) − f (d)](1/τ )d It is easily checked that if Pi ∼ πλPi for Di which is independent of the distribution for Pi with λDi = k3τ λPi. is the stationary distribution then πλDi Corollary 6.3. When in equilibrium the mean and the variance of the num- ber of particles along the axon decay exponentially, with a loss ratio E[Qi+1] E[Qi] = Var[Qi+1] Var[Qi] ≈ exp(cid:18)− δk1 k2 + k3 k3 v (cid:19) (8) and the same loss ratio holds for the off-transport and the deposed particles. 21 Remark 2. Notice that the rate of loss is depends on the ratio of reaction rates k1/k2, which we earlier estimated to be approximately 3, as well as the ratio k3/v, and that if k1, k2 ≫ k3 then the loss rate is e− Proof. Recalling ρ = r(k2 + k3)/(r(k2 + k3) + k1k3) and r = v/δ, we rewrite 3k3 v . ρ =(cid:16)1 + δ k1k3 v(k2 + k3)(cid:17)−1 Observing that for any small δ, the approximation (1 + δx)−1 = 1 − δx + (δx)2 − . . . ≈ e−δx, we have Equation (8). The same ratio holds for the other two states as well E[Pi]/E[P0] = Var[Pi]/Var[P0] = E[Di]/E[D0] = Var[Di]/Var[D0] = ρi 6.3 Homogeneity despite deposition It remains to estimate the rates k3 and τ from experimental data and then make a formal calculation to address the volume of material loss due to deposition and turnover as a function of length scale. To be precise, suppose we want to know the percentage loss over a length ∆ = 10ν δ. Then from the Corollary 6.3 the fraction of material loss is approximately E[Q10ν ] E[Q1] ≈ 10ν Yi=1 exp(cid:16) − δ k1 k2 + k3 k3 v (cid:17) = exp(cid:16) − 10ν−8 k1 k2 + k3 k3 v (cid:17) (9) So, for example, at the meter scale, ν = 8, and so the loss ratio is exp(−k1k3/v(k2+ k3)). We now consider the parameters of a specific example, sodium pumps being deposed in the cell membrane. We assume that the half life of a single pump is approximately a week, which means τ = 6 × 105s. It remains to estimate k3. According to [36], there are roughly 1000 sodium pumps per micron2 of membrane surface area. If we take the diameter of the neuron to be 5 microns, then the membrane surface area for one 10 nm slice is about 0.15 µm2. So there are roughly 150 sodium pumps per slice. It is important to note that each vesicle carries roughly 100 sodium pumps and so the stationary distribution for the quantity Di is on average 1/100th of the number of sodium channels which are deposed into the mem- brane at the location i. Taking this into account and recalling our earlier parameter estimations, k1 = 1, k2 = 1/3, v = 10−6 and q0 = 1 we estimate the average number of sodium pumps in the membrane of the first 10 nm slice to satisfy 150 = 100 q0k1k3τ /(k2 + k3) which implies k3 = 1 × 10−6. From the above we see that the loss ratio at the meter scale is 22 exp(cid:16) − k1 k2 + k3 k3 v (cid:17) = e−3 ≈ 0.04 (10) which is to say that over the length of an entire meter long axon, we expect the concentration of sodium pumps in the membrane near the distal end to be roughly a 1/25 of that found near the nucleus. It is striking to note that over a length 0.1 m, however, the loss ratio is e−.3 = .74. This implies that material loss due to deposition and turnover becomes an issue exactly over the range of lengths of typical axons: 0.1 m to 1 m. At the lower end of this range, the axon is very homogeneous. At the higher end, one predicts significant inhomogeniety. 7 Discussion In this paper, we used a spatial Markov chain model to unify several pre- vious approaches to modeling fast axonal transport. After inferring the orders of magnitude of the parameters of the model, we have used standard techniques from renewal theory and linear Markov chain theory to give a precise description of the most striking qualitative feature of axonal trans- port: homogeneity along the length of the axon. Furthermore we predict the timescale of recovery to this homogeneous state after removing the vesicles from a segment as a function of the length scale of the segment. In creating the model, we have become aware of two features of the biology which have not been adequately studied: 1) Deposition and decay of proteins; and 2) characterization of the process by which unbound vesicles reattach to the transport mechanism. Regarding deposition and decay, we mentioned in Section 6 that the model unequivocally predicts a loss of material down the length of the axon. Furthermore, it seems that certain biological features that we have chosen to ignore -- such as retrograde transport and a location-dependent unbinding rate [9] -- would only serve to increase the non-homogeneity. In the case of sodium pumps, it is not immediately clear if there is a contradiction between deposition loss and homogeneity, but we do see a sensitive dependence on the length of the axon. Furthermore, it stands to reason that for other types of cargo the loss may significant. We believe that this raises an interesting biological issue, and mention a few possible mechanisms for overcoming the 23 material loss: first, it is possible that proteins can be synthesized in axons [33]; second, there may be some signal that prevents material from deposing in a region that is already "full;" and third, it may be that for some materials "deposition" is a reversible process. Regarding reattachment, we note that we have modeled all event wait times as exponential random variables, but this is certainly a simplification. As an example, the stepping process of kinesin is a well-studied though still not completely understood phenomenon. Much work has focused on as- sessing the dependence of the mean rate of translocation on both the load and the local concentration of ATP [35] [29]. Implicit in this analysis is the assumption of exponential wait times with state dependent rate param- eters. However, when fitting to data and matching dispersion information the authors in [11] found it necessary to generalize the wait time distribu- tion. This was followed by more detailed models for which it was shown that load carrying could in fact regularize the stepping times of kinesin motors [28] [8]. Generalizing the wait times does not significantly affect the particle per- spective results of Sections 3.2 and 6.1. This is because renewal theory, which depends on independence of the wait times, is robust with respect to such changes. However, the spatial system results may be affected in that the full process is no longer Markov. While one may still expect a some- thing like a stationary distribution for the flow-through system (where new particles enter from the nucleus and particles are removed from the system at the distal end), the analysis of the approach to equilibrium may change. In the absence of direct observation of the phenomenon, we refrain from this more detailed analysis. In light of this known need for generalized wait times in the stepping process, it seems likely that detailed observation of the rebinding process will call for new models as well. Recall that when a vesicle unbinds from a microtubule it is unclear whether it typically rebinds to the same micro- tubule or if it explores the region significantly via diffusion before finding a different microtubule to bind to. In the latter case, a more appropriate model for rebinding time would be to solve some kind of first passage time problem and use that distribution for the rebinding wait. Acknowledgments The authors are grateful to Professors H. Frederik Nijhout and Vann Ben- nett of Duke University and Professor Anthony Brown of The Ohio State 24 University for helpful discussions. This work was supported by NSF Grant DMS-061670. References [1] Alberts B, Johnson A, Lewis J, Raff M, Roberts K, Walter P (2008) The Molecular Biology of the Cell, Garland Science, Taylor & Francis Group, New York. [2] Allen RD, Weiss DG, Hayden JH, Brown DT, Fijiwaki H, Simpson M (1985). Gliding movement and bidirectional transport along single native microtubules from squid axoplasm: evidence for an active role for microtubules in cytoplasmic transport. J. Cell Biol 100, 1736-1752. [3] Blum JJ, Reed MC (1985) A Model for Fast Axonal Transport. Cell Motility 5, 507-527. [4] Brooks, E. A. (1999) Probabilistic methods for a linear reaction- hyperbolic system with constant coefficients. Ann. Appl. Prob., 9(3), 719-731. [5] Brown A (2000) Slow axonal transport: stop and go traffic in the axon. Nat Rev Cell Mol Biol 1, 153-156. [6] Carter NJ, Cross RA (2005) Mechanics of the kinesin step. Nature 435, 308-312. [7] Cox DR (1962) Renewal Theory. Methuen & C0. Ltd., London, Section 4.5. [8] DeVille RL and Vanden-Eijnden E (2008) Regular Gaits and Optimal Velocities for Motor Proteins Biophysics Journal 95 6: 2681-2691. [9] Dixit R, Ross JL, Goldman YE, Holzbaur ELF (2008) Differential regulation of dynein and kinesin otor proteins by tau. Science 319, 1086-1089. [10] Finer JT, Simmons RM, Spudich JA (1994) Single myosin molecule mechanics: piconewton forces and nanometre steps. Nature 368, 113- 119. [11] Fisher ME and Kolomeisky (2001) Simple mechanochemistry describes the dynamics of kinesin molecules. PNAS 98 14: 7748-7753. 25 [12] Friedman A, Craciun G (2005) A model of intracellular transport of particles in an axon. SIAM J Appl Math 38, 741-758. [13] Friedman A, Craciun G (2006) Approximate traveling waves in linear reaction-hyperbolic equations. SIAM J Appl Math 38, 741-758. [14] Friedman A, Hu B (2007) Uniform convergence for approximate trav- eling waves in reaction-hyperbolic systems. Indiana Math J 56, 2133- 2158. [15] Friedman A, Hu B (2007) Uniform convergence for approximate trav- eling waves in reaction-diffusion-hyperbolic systems. Arch Rat Mech Anal 186, 251-274. [16] Gennerich A, Carter AP, Reck-Peterson, Vale RD (2007) Force-induced bidirectional stepping of cytoplasmic dynein. Cell 131, 952-965. [17] Gross, G.W, Weiss, D.G. (1982) "Theorestical considerations on rapid transport in low viscosity axonal regions." Axoplasmic Transport (Ed. D.G. Weiss), Springer-Verlag, Berlin. [18] Jastrow, H. Electron Microscopic Atlas of Cells, Tissues and Organs on the Internet. Schwann cells section. http://www.uni-mainz.de/FB/Medizin/Anatomie/workshop/EM/EMSchwannE.html [19] Kelly, F. R. Reversibility and stochastic networks. John Wiley & Sons Ltd., Chichester, 1979. Wiley Series in Probability and Mathematical Statistics. [20] Lasek RJ, Brady ST (1982). The structural hypothesis of axonal trans- port: two classes of moving elements. Axoplasmic Transport (ed. G. Weiss), Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1982, pp. 397-405. [21] Lawler G (1995) Introduction to Stochastic Processes Chapman and Hall, New York. [22] Miller R, Lasek RJ (1985) Crossbridges mediate anterograde and ret- rograde vesicle transport along microtubules in squid axoplasm. J Cell Biol 101, 2181-2193. [23] Moran, D., Rowley J.C. III Visual Histology.com, Chapter 8, Nerves. http://www.visualhistology.com/products/atlas/VHA Chpt8 Nerves.html [24] Ochs S (1972) Rate of fast axoplasmic transport in mammalian nerve fibers. J Physiol 227, 627-245. 26 [25] Reed, M. C. and Blum, J. J. (1986) Theoretical analysis of radioactivity proles during fast axonal transport: effects of deposition and turnover. Cell Motility and the Cytoskeleton, 6, 620627. [26] Reed M, Blum J (1994) Mathematical Questions in Axonal Transport. In Lectures in mathematics in the Life Sciences,24, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence. [27] Reed, M. C., Venakides, S. and Blum, J. J. (1990) Approximate travel- ing waves in linear reaction-hyperbolic equations. SIAM J. Appl. Math., 50, 167180. [28] Schilstra MJ and Martin SR (2006) An elastically tethered viscous load imposes a regular gait on the motion of myosin-V. Simulation of the effect of transient force relaxation on a stochastic process. J.R. Soc. In- terface 3 153-165. [29] Schnitzer MJ, Visscher K and Block SM (2000) Force production by single kinesin motors. Nat. Cell. Biol. 2 718-722. [30] Stewart GH, Horwitz B, Gross GW. A chromatographic model of ax- oplasmic transport. In Axoplasmic Transport (ed. G. Weiss), Springer- Verlag, Berlin, 1982, 414-422. [31] Svoboda K, Schmidt C, Schnapp B (1985) Direct observation of kinesin stepping by optical trapping interferometry. Nature 365, 721-727. [32] Takenaka T, Gotoh H (1984). Simulation of axoplasmic transport. J Theor Biol 107, 579-601. [33] Twiss JL, Fainzilber M (2009) Ribosomes in axons - scrounging from the neighbors. Trends in cell biology. 19, 236-243 [34] Vale RD, Reese TS, Sheetz MP (1985). Identification of a novel force- generating protein, kinesin, involved in microtubule-based motility. Cell 42, 39-50. [35] Visscher K, Schnitzer MJ, Block SM (1999) Single kinesin molecules studied with a molecular force clamp Nature 400, 184-189. [36] Willis, WD, Grossman, RG (1981) Medical Neurobiology: Neu- roanatomical and Neurophysiological Principles Basic to Clinical Neu- roscience. Mosby, Inc. 1 1 0 2 y a M 0 2 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 2 v 2 2 7 2 . 1 1 9 0 : v i X r a A STOCHASTIC COMPARTMENTAL MODEL FOR FAST AXONAL TRANSPORT LEA POPOVIC∗, SCOTT A. MCKINLEY†, AND MICHAEL C. REED‡ Abstract. In this paper we develop a probabilistic micro-scale compartmental model and use it to study macro-scale properties of axonal transport, the process by which intracellular cargo is moved in the axons of neurons. By directly modeling the smallest scale interactions, we can use recent microscopic experimental observations to infer all the parameters of the model. Then, using techniques from probability theory, we compute asymptotic limits of the stochastic behavior of individual motor-cargo complexes, while also characterizing both equilibrium and non-equilibrium ensemble behavior. We use these results in order to investigate three important biological questions: (1) How homogeneous are axons at stochastic equilibrium? (2) How quickly can axons return to stochastic equilibrium after large local perturbations? (3) How is our understanding of delivery time to a depleted target region changed by taking the whole cell point-of-view? 1. Introduction. In all cells, one finds that proteins, membrane-bound or- ganelles, and other structures (e.g. chromosomes) are transported from place to place at speeds much higher than diffusion. Though these transport processes are funda- mental to cell function, many of the underlying mechanisms, organizational principles, and regulatory features remain unknown. Axonal transport is one of the best studied systems because the transport is basically one-dimensional since axons are long and narrow. There are two speeds of axonal transport. Fast transport goes at speeds of roughly 0.2 to 0.5 meters/day [27][33], while slow transport goes at approximately 1 millimeter/day, the rate of axon growth and regeneration [6][27]. The biology and principles of slow transport are not yet clear [6], but the basic mechanisms of fast axonal transport were discovered in the 1980s [2][3][29][43]. The model in this paper refers to fast axonal transport, which we will henceforth call axonal transport. The axonal transport apparatus consists of vesicles which form reversible chemical bonds with motor proteins that bind reversibly to microtubules which run parallel to the long dimension of the axon [1]. When the vesicle-motor protein complex is assem- bled on the microtubule, the complex steps stochastically with step size approximately 8 nanometers for kinesin and dynein and 10 nanometers for myosin [7][12][18][40]. The vesicles enter from the cell body on microtubules and then detach and reattach to the transport mechanism at random times. In this paper we propose a spatial Markov-chain compartmental model based on these dynamics. We will assume independence of the interactions, and exponential wait times between events. While we address the validity of these assumptions in the Discussion section, we consider this a useful "first-order" approximation that permits study of the dynamics from both the perspective of individual vesicles as well as that of the full spatial system. Such a model unifies all earlier deterministic and stochastic modeling efforts and can accommodate both qualitative and quantitative experimental data observed on multiple scales. In much experimental work in the 1970s and 1980s, radio-labeled amino acids were put into the cell bodies continuously or for a few hours. The amino acids were incorporated into proteins that were packaged into vesicles and put on the transport system so that at later times radioactivity could be seen moving progressively down ∗Department of Mathematics and Statistics, Concordia University, Montreal QC H3G 1M8 †Department of Mathematics, University of Florida, 358 Little Hall Box 118105, Gainesville, FL 32605 ([email protected]) ‡Department of Mathematics, Duke University, Box 90320, Durham, NC 27701 1 2 the axons. In the continuous infusion case, one would see a wave of radioactivity with a sharp but slowly spreading wavefront propagating at constant velocity down the axon. In the case of infusion for a few hours one would see at long times a slowly spreading pulse of radioactivity that looked normally distributed. It was to understand this behavior that Reed and Blum constructed PDE models for axonal transport [3][34][35]. These models did not have traveling wave solutions, but the data certainly looked like approximate traveling waves. In [36] it was shown by a perturbation theory argument that, in the asymptotic limit where the unbinding and binding rates k2 and k1 get large, the solution approaches a slowly spreading traveling wave or a normal pulse. Recently, in a series of papers, Friedman and co-workers have introduced new PDE models and proved these results rigorously[14][15][16][17]. Probabilistic models for axonal transport were introduced and used for simula- tions already in the 1980s [39][41]. However, rigorous work began with Lawler [28] in 1995 and was continued by Brooks [5] who used a continuous time stochastic model to show that the distribution of an individual particle is a spreading Gaussian at large times. Brooks also proved tail estimates for the central limit theorem and used them to estimate the error from normal. Independently, Bressloff [4] developed a discrete stepping model and performed an analysis under the assumption that the rate of un- binding and binding to transport is fast relative to lateral velocity over the length scale of interest. The author derived a characterization of the spreading wavefront of a particle entering at the nucleus and traveling to the distal end. This model served as the basis for later investigations by Newby and Bressloff [31, 32] wherein the authors characterize the axonal transport system as an intermittent search for hidden targets. In this paper we revise the existing probabilistic models in order to study ran- domness in the system as a whole rather than exclusively from the point of view of an individual particle. Our goal is not only to recover and generalize previous results, but also to investigate three specific, biologically important, properties of the whole stochastic system. 1.1. Summary of Results. In Section 2, we create a continuous-time Markov chain queueing model for the axonal transport system. We show how to use experi- mental data to determine (or estimate) all the parameters of the model. In Section 3, we take the individual vesicle point-of-view. We prove the asymp- totic forms in [36] with rigorous error estimates. We show that in the limit as the compartment size becomes small our model becomes the probabilistic model of [5]. We also show that in the limit as the length of the axon and time become large (with the scale of axon length on the order of the squared scale of time) our model becomes the PDE model of [35]. Since we assume that particles are independent, the time evo- lution of the law of an individual will reflect the behavior of an ensemble of particles released at the same time. In Section 4 we adopt the full spatial system perspective to quantify stochasticity along the length of the axon. We begin by calculating in Proposition 4.1 the stationary distribution of a flow-through system that has sustained input from the nucleus, while particles are removed upon reaching the distal end. The stationary distribution has a product Poisson structure which allows for seamless transition between spatial scales. With this mathematical model, we are able to make precise statements about three biologically important system properties. In the stationary distribution, the number of vesicles in each slice of the axon is independent and identically distributed (Proposition 4.1), however this in and of itself is not sufficient to account for the sense that samples taken for different parts of the cell "look the same." We compute in 3 Section 4.2 the coefficient of variation for the number of vesicles in sections of different length and show that the coefficient of variation is low for all but the smallest length scales. In Section 4.3, we study the intermittent search problem posed by Newby and Bressloff [31] from the system point of view. Efficient transport to locations that need material must balance the speed of transport of material from the nucleus to the distal end of the cell with the rates of dissociation from the transport apparatus. We calculate the expected hitting time for a hidden target by all vesicles in the system. In so doing we encounter the counterintuitive result that while increasing the velocity of the motors while on transport increases the chance of any particular vesicle missing the target, the expected hitting time by the system actually decreases. This hitting time approach is natural for needed material that is sparsely dis- tributed throughout the axon, but when the needed cargo in question is more com- mon, the time to replenishment is better addressed through the ODE approach that we develop in Section 4.4. Due to the product structure of the law of the transient dynamics, this non-equilibrium behavior is determined by the 2N -dimensional ODE governing the means. From this we estimate the timescale of return to equilibrium as a function of the length scale of interest. 2. The model and its parameters. Let L be the length of the axon, divided evenly into N = L/δ lateral sections each of length δ, equal to the step size of the motor protein. Within each section, we disregard any further spatial geometry and take the particles to be in one of two states: · an on-transport state that steps laterally at a rate r = v/δ per section, or · an off-transport state that does not step laterally. We use a 2N -dimensional continuous time Markov chain {(Qi(t), Pi(t)), i = 1, . . . , N} to model the particle dynamics, where · Qi(t) is the number of particles at time t in on-transport state in section i, · Pi(t) is the number of particles at time t in off-transport state in section i. be a continuous time Markov chain on the state space NN×NN with the following tran- sitions and time dependent rates: Definition 2.1. (Stochastic compartmental model) Let ({(Qi(t), Pi(t)), i = 1, . . . , N})t≥0 · (Lateral transport) (Qi, Qi+1) → (Qi − 1, Qi+1 + 1) at rate rQi(t); · (Switch from on-transport to off-transport) (Qi, Pi) → (Qi − 1, Pi + 1) at rate k2Qi(t); · (Switch from off-transport to on-transport) (Pi, Qi) → (Pi − 1, Qi + 1) at rate k1Pi(t); · (Production of new particles) (Q1) → (Q1 + 1) at rate rq0; · (Removal of particles at distal end) (QN ) → (QN − 1) at rate rQN (t). The lateral transport rate, r = v/δ, is inversely proportional to the length scale so that the mean number of particles per unit length is invariant with respect to rescaling δ. We will assume that the rate of production q0 = δρ0, for some constant ρ0 > 0, in order for the mean number of particles in each compartment to scale with the size δ of each compartment. This will imply that the mean number of particles per unit length scales as ρ0. A graph of the model is depicted in Figure 1. In order to insure the Markov property, we use exponential random variables for the waiting times between transition events. Specifically, we mean that after a given 4 Q1 = 3 P1 = 3 ∗ • ∗ ∗ ∗ • x = L 3 Q2 = 1 P2 = 2 ∗ • • N u c l e u s x = 0 Q3 = 3 P3 = 2 • ∗ ∗ • • x = 2L 3 x = L Q1 ✲q0r Q2 ✲r Q3 ✲r ✲r ❑ k1 k2 ❯ P1 ❑ k1 k2 ❯ P2 ❑ k1 k2 ❯ P3 Fig. 2.1. On-and-off Transport Chain event we assign a new independent random variable to each of the 3N +2 possible next events, exponentially distributed with the appropriate rate parameter. The system of values updates according to the transition associated with the minimum of these waiting times. Then we create a new set of exponential random variables and the process proceeds as before. The advantage of computing explicit formulas for quantities that can be observed in experiments is that the experimental data can then be used to determine the parameter values in the model. For the characterization of the approximate wavefront speed and spreading in Section 3 and the homogeneity calculations in Section 4 we need order-of-magnitude estimates for the parameters. Actual parameter values will certainly differ depending on the particular neural tissue and the particular particles being transported. However, we can get order-of-magnitude estimates from existing data. First we recall that fast transport has been observed to travel at speeds of 0.2 to 0.5 m per day. We can assume that the average velocity of particles while physically bound to microtubules is roughly 1 m per day, or v = 10−6 m/s. We assume that the compartment size scales as the length scale of the individual steps of the motor protein, so δ ∼ 10−8m. This implies that the rate parameter should be r = v/δ = 100s−1. We now turn our attention to the on-off rates rates k2 and k1. These can be de- termined from experimentally observed run lengths on the transport system. Indeed, 5 r r+k2 and therefore the average run length is r Dixit et al. [10] show that a typical run along microtubules for dinein and kinesin is on the order of 10−6m. We can compare this with the theoretical run length of the model to determine off-rate k2. Within the model, at each step on the transport mechanism the particle has a binary decision to jump laterally along the transport with probability r/(k2 + r), or to jump off with probability k2/(r + k2). The number of jumps along the transport system before jumping off is therefore geometrically dis- tributed on the set {0, 1, . . .} with success probability . It follows that average number of steps in the run is r k2 × 10−8 m. k2 Setting this equal to the average experimental run length of 10−6 from [10], we see that r k2 ∼ 100, implying that k2 ∼ 1s−1. As we will see in the computation of the stationary distribution in Section 4.1, the ratio of the expected number of particles on the track to those off the track is k2 . Dixit [10] found that approximately 75% of k1 the particles were motile so this ratio is approximately equal to 3. Since k2 ∼ 1s−1 we see that k1 ∼ 1 3 . It remains to estimate q0. We will see in Proposition 4.1 that the mean number of particles per compartment is (1 + k2 )q0 = 4q0. Of course, axons have a large k1 variety of diameters and larger axons will have more vesicles per unit length so one expects a range of values for q0. However, examination of a large number of electron micrographs of axonal cross-sections (see for example [20], Fig. 3; [21]; [30]), which are typically 100 nm thick enables one to estimate the number of vesicles per 100 nm segment. This number is typically in the range of 10 to 100 which implies that there are 1 to 10 vesicles per compartment in our model. Therefore q0 is in the range 0.25 to 2.5, for various axons. We remark that we are ignoring some aspects of the physics and the biology of axonal transport. We are not including diffusion of the vesicles off the track. We are treating the microtubule track as though it were a single continuous entity from one end of the axon to the other, when it fact it consists of numerous, separated, microtubule fragments. And, we are ignoring retrograde transport and the details of the motor proteins. Nevertheless, this simple model will enable us to investigate the homogeneity questions that are the main goal of this paper. 3. Dynamics from the Particle Perspective. In this section we calculate properties of the stochastic dynamics by using stochastic convergence theorems and stochastic averaging theorems from probability theory. We first see that, in the δ → 0 limit, the law of the location of a single particle corresponds to that of a particle with a piecewise linear Markov motion. We then show this law can be approximated by the Green's function of a linear partial differential equation. This enables us to obtain, as a special case, the asymptotic behavior of the PDE models for axonal transport in an either rate limiting or perturbed setting. 3.1. The active transport mode. We first consider the simple case where 0 = 0 and stays exclusively in active transport mode. Let t be the the particle starts at X δ X δ t ∈ {0, δ, 2δ, . . . , L} be the lateral position of a particle at time t and let nδ number of jumps made by the particle as of time t. Observe, X δ = δnδ. Lemma 3.1. Let k2 = k1 = 0, and r = v/δ > 0, then the position of the particle satisfies, for any time t < ∞ sup s≤t(cid:12)(cid:12)X δ s − vs(cid:12)(cid:12) −→δ→0 0 a.s. 6 and, for B a standard Brownian motion 1 √δ(cid:16)X δ t − vt(cid:17)t≥0 =⇒δ→0 √v(cid:0)Bt(cid:1)t≥0 in distribution on the Skorokhod space of cadlag (right continuous left limited) func- tions. Proof. Since nδ is a Poisson process with rate r = v/δ, defining Nt := nδ δt we get a Poisson process N with rate v, and we have X δ · = δN·/δ. Our results then follow directly from the functional law of large numbers (FLLN) and the functional central limit theorem (FCLT) for the Poisson process N . 3.2. The on/off dynamics. We now consider a particle which undergoes tran- sitions from on-transport to off-transport state and back. Denote again by X δ t ∈ {0, δ, 2δ, . . . , L} the lateral position of a particle at time t and let nδ t be the number of lateral transition jumps made by the particle as of time t. Observe that the particle will spend only a fraction of its time in active transport and hence the lateral speed of the particle should be slower than before. A non-compartmental stochastic model for axonal transport, introduced by Brooks in [5], is as follows. A particle can be in one of two states: We use a 2-dimensional Markov process to model the particle dynamics, where · an on-transport state with deterministic lateral velocity v, or · an off-transport state with lateral velocity 0. · Xt be the lateral position of this particle at time t, · ξt be the indicator for whether it is on (1) or off (0) transport at time t. Definition 3.2. (Stochastic non-compartmental model) Let (Xt, ξt)t≥0 be a piecewise-linear Markov process with values in (R+,{0, 1}) started at (X0, ξ0) = (0, 1) with the following dynamics: · (Switch from on-transport to off-transport) (Xt, 1) → (Xt, 0) at rate k1 · (Switch from off-transport to on-transport) (Xt, 0) → (Xt, 1) rate k2 · (Lateral travel) Xt =R t 0 vξsds The path of (Xt)t≥0 consists of alternating sequence of Exponential(k2) stretches of time where the lateral position increases linearly with speed v, and Exponential(k1) stretches of time where it remains constant. Proposition 3.3. Let k2, k1 > 0, and r = v/δ > 0, then the position of the particle converges (X δ t )t≥0 =⇒δ→0 (Xt)t≥0 in distribution on the Skorokhod space of cadlag functions. Proof. If we let ξδ be the indicator of whether the particle in the compartmental model is on (ξδ = 1) or off (ξδ = 0) transport, then (X δ t )t≥0 is a strong Markov process. We will see that ξδ is a continuous-time Markov chain on {0, 1} (independent of δ), and conditionally on ξδ the transition law of X is easily expressed. Likewise, for the non-compartmental model above, (Xt, ξt)t≥0 is a strong Markov process, with ξ the same continuous-time Markov chain on {0, 1} as ξδ, and conditionally on ξ the change in X is easily given in terms of its linear speed and ξ. t ) converges to (Xt, ξt) in distribution as δ → 0. We then show that the finite dimensional distributions of We will start by showing that for any t > 0, (X δ t , ξδ t , ξδ (X δ, ξδ) converge to those of (X, ξ). A tightness argument finally implies (Lemma 16.2 and Theorem 16.3 [22]) that (X δ, ξδ) converges to (X, ξ) in distribution on the Skorokhod space of cadlag processes. 7 0 , ξδ Suppose that initially the particle is on transport at x0, so (X δ 0) = (x0, 1). The first time τ1 = inf{t > 0 : ξδ t = 0} at which the particle steps off transport has Exponential(k2) distribution, irrespective of δ. The first subsequent increment in time σ1 = inf{t > 0 : ξδ τ1+t = 0} after which the particle steps back on transport has Exponential(k1) distribution, irrespective of δ as well. This is repeated, and ξδ is a simple continuous-time Markov chain on {0, 1} with transition rates k2 and k1, from 1 → 0 and 0 → 1, respectively. Until time τ1 the particle behaves as if it were in active transport (k2 = k1 = 0) and conditionally on the value of τ1, for any 0 ≤ s ≤ τ1 the lateral change in position over time s, X δ s is a Poisson(rs) random variable. Moreover, by results of Proposition 3.1, conditionally on the value of τ1, we have s where nδ s − X δ 0 , is δnδ 0 a.s. sup 0≤s≤τ1(cid:12)(cid:12)(X δ s − X δ 0 ) − vs(cid:12)(cid:12) −→δ→0 τ1 − X δ To get the unconditioned law of X δ 0 , we observe that the number of boxes the particle traverses before it steps off nδ τ1 has a Geometric(k2/(k2 + r)) distribution (note that a Poisson rate r process sampled at an Exponential(k2) time independent of the process has this distribution). Since k2/δ(k2 + r) → k2/v, as δ → 0, X δ 0 = δnδ τ1 converges in distribution to Exponential(k2/v) variable. τ1 −X δ Consider now the particle in the non-compartmental model. It is immediate from the definition of the model that ξ has the same law of a continuous-time Markov chain on {0, 1} with transition rates k2 and k1, from 1 → 0 and 0 → 1, as ξδ. Since we prove our convergence in law results by first conditioning on the values of ξδ and ξ, we can without loss of generality henceforth assume ξδ = ξ a.s., and drop its superscript. Suppose that initially the particle in the non-compartmental model is on transport at x0, so (X0, ξ0) = (x0, 1). Conditionally on τ1, for all 0 ≤ s ≤ τ1, Xs − X0 = vs and Xτ1 − X0 = vτ1, hence unconditionally, Xτ1 − X0 is an Exponential(k2/v) random variable. We now have both sup0≤s≤τ1(cid:12)(cid:12)(X δ τ1 − X δ X δ ally on values of τ1, σ1, and of X δ τ1+σ1−X δ and X δ tial values (X δ respectively. 0 ) − (Xs − X0)(cid:12)(cid:12) → 0 a.s. and τ1)− (Xs − Xτ1)(cid:12)(cid:12) ≡ 0, 0 ⇒ Xτ1+σ1−X0. At time τ1+σ1, the same process starts over from ini- τ1, 1) and (Xτ1 , 1) in the compartmental and non-compartmental model, τ1, Xτ1, supτ1≤s≤τ1+σ1(cid:12)(cid:12)(X δ Between times τ1 and σ1 the particle in both models stays in place, so condition- 0 ⇒ Xτ1 − X0. s − X δ s − X δ Let τ1, σ1, τ2, . . . , be the sequence of time increments between the consecutive times when the particle in both models gets off and gets back on transport, let σ0 = 0 and for i ≥ 1 τi = inf{t > 0 : ξσi−1 +t = 0}, σi = inf{t > 0 : ξτi+t = 1} Then (τi)i≥1 and (σi)i≥1 are independent sequences of i.i.d. Exponential(k2) and Exponential(k1) variables, respectively. For any t > 0, let ηt be the number of times the particle in either model gets back on transport until time t, and η′ t the number of times it gets off, ηt = inf{k ≥ 0 : k Xi=1 (τi + σi) ≤ t}, t = inf{k′ ≥ 0 : η′ τi + k′ Xi=1 k′−1 Xi=1 σi ≤ t} 8 t = ηt iff ξt = 1, and η′ Note that, η′ t = ηt + 1 iff ξt = 0. Let τt be the last time before time t that the particle changed whether it was on or off transport, that is, τt = sup{0 ≤ s ≤ t : ξs− 6= ξs}. Then, we have τt =( ηt η′ t Pi=1 Pi=1 ηt Pi=1 (τi + σi) if η′ t = ηt, τi + σi if η′ t = ηt + 1. If η′ t = ηt, then from time τt to t the particle is in active transport, and the same convergence argument as before implies that conditionally on the values of τt and X δ τt, τt≤s≤t(X δ sup s − X δ τt) − v(s − τt) → 0 a.s. If η′ 0 = δnδ τt − X δ τt − X δ τt where nδ Also X δ τt is the number of boxes the particle traverses by time t. Conditionally on the value of ηt, nδ τt is a sum of ηt i.i.d. Geometric(k2/(k2 + r)) random variables, hence X δ 0 converges in distribution to a sum of ηt i.i.d. Exponential(k2/v) random variables. In the non-compartmental model, if η′ t = ηt, then conditionally on the values of ηt and τt, for τt ≤ s ≤ t, Xs − Xτt = v(s− τt) and conditionally only on the value of ηt, X δ τt − X0 is a sum of ηt i.i.d. Exponential(k2/v) variables. Hence, conditionally on ηt and τt, supτt≤s≤t(cid:12)(cid:12)(X δ τt − X δ so conditionally on ηt and τt, supτt≤s≤t(cid:12)(cid:12)(X δ 0 ⇒ Xτt − X0. s − X δ τt is a sum of η′ τt)− (Xs − Xτt)(cid:12)(cid:12) → 0 τt)− (Xs − Xτt)(cid:12)(cid:12) = 0 a.s.. Also, con- t = ηt + 1, then from time τt to t the particle is in both models stays in place, ditionally only on the value of η′ ables, hence X δ variables. In the non-compartmental model, if η′ value of η′ only on η′ t i.i.d. Geometric(k2/(k2 + r)) vari- t i.i.d. Exponential(k2/v) t = ηt + 1, conditionally only on the t i.i.d. Exponential(k2/v) variables. Hence, conditionally 0 converges in distribution to a sum of η′ a.s., and conditionally only on ηt, X δ τt −X δ τt is a sum of η′ τt − X δ Now, integrating over the possible values of ηt,η′ t and τt, we get that for any t ≥ 0, (X δ t , ξδ t ) ⇒ (Xt, ξt). Convergence of finite dimensional distributions follows from an iterative use of the Markov property of (X δ, ξδ) and (X, ξ), and the fact that the increments of both (X δ, ξδ) and (X, ξ) are stationary. 0 ⇒ Xτt − X0. t, X δ t, X δ s − X δ t, nδ In order to verify tightness, Theorem 16.11 [22], of the sequence of Markov pro- cesses {(X δ, ξδ)}δ>0, because (X δ, ξδ) has stationary increments and is strong Markov, it will suffice to check that for any ǫ > 0 lim h→0 lim sup δ→0 h, ξδ h) − (X δ 0 , ξδ P(cid:8)(X δ 0) > ǫ(cid:9) = 0 where (x1, ξ1)−(x2, ξ2) = x1−x2+ξ1−ξ2 is a distance metric on R+×{0, 1}. For any δ > 0, the first change in the continuous-time Markov chain ξδ happens after an Exponential(k) time (where k = k2 or k = k1 depending on whether ξδ 0 = 0), 0 = 1 or ξδ 0(cid:9) ≤ 1 − e−kh. Moreover, h 6= ξδ and is independent of δ. Hence, at time h later, P(cid:8)ξδ h− X δ irrespective of the value of ξδ, at time h later the value of X δ 0 ≤ δnδ 0 > ǫ(cid:9) ≤ δE(cid:2)nδ h − X δ a Poisson process with rate r = v/δ. Hence, P(cid:8)X δ h(cid:3)/ǫ = vh/ǫ. Combining the two gives 0) > ǫ(cid:9) ≤ 1 − e−kh + vh/ǫ for any δ > 0, h) − (X δ and the desired limit follows. P(cid:8)(X δ h where nδ is h, ξδ 0 , ξδ 9 t ) ∈ δZ+ × {0, 1} is a Markov process The process (X δ, ξδ) : t ∈ [0,∞) 7→ (X δ t , ξδ with cadlag paths whose generator is given by Aδf (x, ξ) = rξ(cid:2)f (x + δ, ξ) − f (x, ξ)(cid:3) + k2ξ(cid:2)f (x, ξ − 1) − f (x, ξ)(cid:3) + k1(1 − ξ)(cid:2)f (x, ξ + 1) − f (x, ξ)(cid:3) for all f ∈ D(Aδ) = C0(δZ+ × {0, 1}). The piecewise linear process (X, ξ) : t ∈ [0,∞) 7→ (Xt, ξt) ∈ R+ × {0, 1} is a Markov process with continuous paths whose generator is the closure of the operator Af (x, ξ) = vξ∂xf (x, ξ) + k2ξ(cid:2)f (x, ξ − 1) − f (x, ξ)(cid:3) + k1(1 − ξ)(cid:2)f (x, ξ + 1) − f (x, ξ)(cid:3) for all f ∈ D(Aδ) = C1,0(R+ × {0, 1}). Letting ιδ : δZ+ × {0, 1} 7→ R+ × {0, 1} be an embedding, and f δ = f ◦ ιδ, then Aδf δ → Af as δ → 0 for all f ∈ C1,0(R+ × {0, 1}) imply that the finite dimensional distributions of (X δ, ξδ) converge to those of (X, ξ). Verification of additional con- ditions, see Theorem 19.25 of [22], would also imply convergence of processes with generators {(cid:0)Aδ,D(Aδ)(cid:1)}δ>0 to the process with generator (cid:0)A,D(Aδ)(cid:1), however, we thought this way of showing convergence in law was not as instructive. The fact that an individual particle will have the distribution given by Propo- sition 3.3 as the size of the boxes decreases means that our model is a microscopic version of the stochastic model used by Brooks [5], and that the hydrodynamic limit of our model as δ → 0 is equal to the macroscopic stochastic model from [5]. An approximation of the particle's position Xt is obtained in [5] to be Xt ≈ µt + √tσZ as t → ∞, where µ = k1v/(k2 + k1), σ = 2k2k1v2/(k2 + k1)3 and Z is a standard Normal variable. That approximation is valid only for large fixed values of t, while we next extend this result to give an approximation for the whole time trajectory of the particle's path. This is accomplished by the following functional central limit theorem for the position of the particle undergoing stochastic transport. Proposition 3.4. Let X be the position of a particle following the piecewise linear Markov process from Proposition 3.3 started at X0 = 0 on transport, then and, if B denotes a standard Brownian motion Xns n − k1 k2 + k1 sup s≤t(cid:12)(cid:12) √n(cid:16) Xnt n − 0 a.s. ∀t > 0 vs(cid:12)(cid:12) −→n→∞ =⇒n→∞ s 2k2k1v2 k1v k2 + k1 t(cid:17)t≥0 (k2 + k1)3(cid:0)Bt(cid:1)t≥0 in distribution on the space of continuous functions. Proof. For these results we use the notion of stochastic averaging [23][24][26]. Note that the indicator process ξ for being on- or off- transport is independent of the position X of the particle. Hence, the position of the particle X is a linear random evolution process, Ch 12 of [11], [19], driven by the independent indicator process ξ. The generator of (X, ξ) is the closure of the operator Af (x, ξ) = σ(ξ)∂xf (x, ξ) + λ(ξ)(cid:2)f (x, s(ξ)) − f (x, ξ)(cid:3) 10 for all f ∈ D(A) = C1,0 functions in x continuous in ξ and vanishing at infinity), where 0 (R+ × {0, 1}) (the space of all continuously differentiable σ(ξ) = vξ, λ(ξ) = k2ξ + k1(1 − ξ), and s(ξ) = 1 − ξ (when ξ = 1: σ = v, λ = k2, s = 0 and when ξ = 0: σ = 0, λ = k1, s = 1). In other words, if (X0, ξ0) = (0, 1) we have Xt =Z t 0 vξsds, ξt = 1 2(cid:0)1 + (−1)Y (R t 0 λ(ξs)ds)(cid:1) 0 λ(ξs)ds) is a counting process of the where Y is a rate 1 Poisson process, and Y (R t number of switches of ξ until time t. Rescaling time and position of the process by 1/n, we get that ( Xn· n , ξn·) satisfies Xnt n =Z t 0 vξnsds, ξnt = and its generator is 1 2(cid:0)1 + (−1)Y (n R t 0 λ(ξns)ds)(cid:1) Anf (x, ξ) = vξ∂xf (x, ξ) + n(k2ξ + (k1(1 − ξ)))(cid:2)f (x, s(ξ)) − f (x, ξ)(cid:3) for all f ∈ D(An) = C1,0 0 (R+ × {0, 1}). Note that ξn· switches at rate propor- tional to n, forming an ergodic Markov chain with stationary distribution π(1) = k1/(k2 + k1), π(0) = k2/(k2 + k1), andR σ(ξ)π(ξ) = vR ξπ(ξ) = vk1/(k2 + k1). Hence, the strong ergodic theorem implies that Xn n = 1 nZ n 0 vξsds −→n→∞ vk1 k2 + k1 a.s. We can extend this to a functional statement on any finite time interval [0, t]. Fix t > 0 and take any ∆ > 0, then there exists n∆ < ∞ a.s. such that Xn n − (cid:12)(cid:12) vk1 k2 + k1(cid:12)(cid:12) < ∆ t , for ∀n > n∆ Now, let M = supn≤n∆ Xn − k1/(k2 + k1)vn, which is finite a.s. since n∆ < ∞ a.s. Let n > M/∆. Then, for any 0 ≤ s ≤ t we have that either ns > n∆ in which case vk1 ∆ t vk1 k2 + k1 (cid:12)(cid:12) (cid:12)(cid:12) ns − s ≤ ∆ Xns n − or, ns ≤ n∆ in which case s(cid:12)(cid:12) =(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:16) Xns s(cid:12)(cid:12) = n(cid:12)(cid:12)Xns − n Xns − vk1/(k2 + k1)s(cid:12)(cid:12) < ∆ whenever n > M/∆. implying that we have sup0≤s≤t(cid:12)(cid:12) Once we rescale the position for the particle by 1/√n and time by 1/n, ξ still changes at a much faster rate than the position of the particle X. The generator of the rescaled centered process (X n, ξn) defined as k2 + k1(cid:17)s(cid:12)(cid:12) < ns(cid:12)(cid:12) < Xns n − k2 + k1 k2 + k1 M n < ∆ vk1 1 vk1 1 X n t := √n(cid:0) Xnt n − k1v k2 + k1 t(cid:1), ξn t := ξnt is the closure of the operator 11 ¯Anf (x, ξ) =(cid:0)√nσ(ξ) − k1v k2 + k1(cid:1)∂xf (x, ξ) + nλ(ξ)(cid:0)f (x, s(ξ)) − f (x, ξ)(cid:1) on f ∈ D(An) = C1,0 0 (R × {0, 1}). We will use the stochastic averaging theorem (Theorem 2.1 of [26]) to show that the paths of the centered rescaled process converge in distribution to paths of a Brownian motion with a diffusion coefficient equal to 2k2k1/(k2 + k3)3v2. Let h(ξ) be the function h(ξ) = v k2k1 1 (k2 + k1)3 λ(ξ) = v k2k1 1 (k2 + k1)3 k2ξ + k1(1 − ξ) Then h(1) = vk1/(k2 + k1)2, h(0) = −vk2/(k2 + k1)2 imply that h(s(1)) − h(1) = −v/(k2 + k1), h(s(0)) − h(0) = v/(k2 + k1), which in turn imply that λ(1)(cid:0)h(s(1)) − h(1)(cid:1) = −vk2/(k2 + k1), λ(0)(cid:0)h(s(0)) − h(0)(cid:1) = vk1/(k2 + k1), so that for ξ ∈ {0, 1} k1 λ(ξ)(cid:0)h(s(ξ)) − h(ξ)(cid:1) = −(cid:0)vξ − v k2 + k1(cid:1) 0 (R) define a sequence of functions f n ∈ C1,0 0 (R × {0, 1}) by Now, for any f ∈ C2 f n(x, ξ) = f (x) + 1 √n h(ξ)∂xf (x) Then f n → f as n → ∞ and ¯Anf n(x, ξ) = √n(cid:0)vξ − v k2 + k1(cid:1)∂xf (x) +(cid:0)vξ − v + √nλ(ξ)(cid:0)h(s(ξ)) − h(ξ)(cid:1)∂xf (x) k2 + k1(cid:1)h(ξ)∂2 =(cid:0)vξ − v xf (x) = ¯Af (x) k1 k1 where ¯A is defined on D( ¯A) = C2 0(R) by k1 k2 + k1(cid:1)h(ξ)∂2 xf (x) ¯Af (x) = k2k1v2 (k2 + k1)3 ∂2 xf (x) Define a sequence of processes εf,n t = 1 √n h(ξn t )∂xf (X n t ) = f n(X n t , ξn t ) − f (X n t ) Then our earlier calculation implies that for any f ∈ D( ¯A) t ) −Z t t ∈ {0, 1} it is clear that is a sequence of martingales. Since f ∈ C2 t ) −Z t 0 (R), ξn s )ds + εf,n t = f n(X n Anf (X n ¯Af (X n f (X n t , ξn 0 0 s , ξn s )ds sup n E(cid:20)Z t 0 (cid:12)(cid:12) ¯Af (X n 2 ds(cid:21) < ∞ and E(cid:20)sup s s≤t(cid:12)(cid:12)εf,n 0 (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:21) −→n→∞ s )(cid:12)(cid:12) 12 In order to apply Theorem 2.1 of [26] on stochastic averaging it is only left to show the process X n satisfies the compact containment condition, that is for any t > 0 and ∆ > 0 there exists a compact set K ⊂ R such that P{X n This follows from the fact that X n f (x) = x) with mean inf n s ∈ K ∀s ≤ t} ≥ 1 − ∆ t + h(ξn t )/√n is a sequence of martingales (let E(cid:20)X n t + h(ξn t ) √n (cid:21) = X n 0 + h(ξn 0 ) √n = k2k1 (k2 + k1)3 v2 √n and second moment (let f (x) = x2) h(ξn t ) √n (cid:17)2(cid:21) = k2k1 (k2 + k1)3 v22t + E[h(ξn t )] n So, by Doob's inequality t + E(cid:20)(cid:16)X n √n (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) ≥ C(cid:27) ≤ h(ξn t ) E[h(ξn t )] (cid:17) 4 h(ξn t ) t + k2k1 X n s + 4 C2 C2(cid:16) E(cid:20)(cid:16)X n (k2 + k1)3 v22t+ √n (cid:17)2(cid:21) = P(cid:26)sup s≤t(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) Noting that hmin := v min(k2, k1)/(k2 + k1)2 ≤ h ≤ hmax := v max(k2, k1)/(k2 + k1)2, and choosing C (given on t and ∆) so that the right hand side of the inequality with n = 1 is less than ∆, shows that with K = [−C − hmax, C − hmin] the compact containment condition holds for (X n)n≥1. Now Theorem 2.1 of [26] implies that X n ⇒ W in distribution on the Skorkhod space of continuous functions, where W is a process with generator ¯A, and conse- quently has the same distribution as p2k2k1v2/(k2 + k1)3B where B is a standard Brownian motion. n 3.3. Connection to Partial Differential Equations Models. In order to demonstrate the connection between our model and the PDEs seen in [36][35][16], consider the process (X, ξ) of the particle following the piecewise linear Markov pro- cess, and for any x ≥ 0, t ≥ 0 let q(x, t) = P{Xt ∈ dx, ξt = 1}/dx, p(x, t) = P{Xt ∈ dx, ξt = 0}/dx denote the probability densities of the particle's location x on and off transport, respectively, over time. Kolmogorov forward equations for (X, ξ) imply that q and p satisfy the system of PDEs ∂tq(x, t) + v∂xq(x, t) = −k2q(x, t) + k1p(x, t) ∂tp(x, t) = k2q(x, t) − k1p(x, t). (3.1) (3.2) When k2 = 0 = k1, the limiting PDE is simple linear transport: (∂t+v∂x)q(x, t) = 0. The initial condition q(x, 0) = δ0(x) corresponds to the density of a single particle at the origin at t = 0. The time evolution via simple linear transport is translation of the delta function, while the time evolution via the equations (3.1) and (3.2) will have a spreading profile. This is clear from the macroscopic limits of (X δ, ξδ) as δ → 0. When k2 = k1 = 0 the particle never switches off from traveling on transport at speed v and is deterministic, as seen in Proposition 3.1. When k2, k1 > 0 the particle follows 13 a truely stochastic process (X, ξ) with a non-zero variance, as seen in Proposition 3.3 and Proposition 3.4. In the experiments described in the introduction one sees "approximate" traveling waves of radioactivity in the axons in the sense that there is a slowly spreading wave front moving at constant velocity away from the cell body. Equations (3.1) and (3.2) are linear and do not have solutions that are bounded traveling waves. It was shown by a perturbation theory argument in [36][35] that as ε → 0 the solutions of ε(∂t + v∂x)qε(x, t) = −k2qε(x, t) + k1pε(x, t), ε∂tpε(x, t) = k2qε(x, t) − k1pε(x, t). (3.3) (3.4) subject to qε(0, t) = q0, are to leading order qε(x, t) = c1H( x − µt ε1/2 , t), pε(x, t) = c2H( x − µt ε1/2 , t), where H satisfies the heat equation ∂sH(y, s) = σ2 2 ∂yyH(y, s), H(y, 0) = χ(−∞,0) (3.5) µ = k2v k2 + k1 , σ2 = 2k2k1v2 (k2 + k1)3 c1 = k1 k2 + k1 , c2 = k2 k2 + k1 . This asymptotic form is valid for small ε, that is for large k2 and k1. However, if we set q(x, t) = qε( x ε ), then q and p satisfy (3.3) and (3.4), so the solutions of (3.1) and (3.2) behave like approximate traveling waves for large t and large x whether or not k2 and k1 are large. These results have been proven rigorously by Friedman and coworkers [14][15][16][17]. ε ) and p(x, t) = pε( x ε , t ε , t To see that our Proposition 3.4 provides another rigorous proof of these properties, n Xn·, ξn·) albeit using stochastic methods, consider the process (εX·/ε, ξ·/ε) (that is ( 1 with n = 1/ε), and let qε(x, t) = P(cid:8)εXt/ε ∈ dx, ξt/ε = 1(cid:9)/dx, pε(x, t) = P(cid:8)εXt/ε ∈ dx, ξt/ε = 0(cid:9)/dx be the probability densities for this process. The generator of this process is An (n = 1/ε), so the Kolmogorov forward equations imply that qε and pε satisfy the system of PDEs (3.3) and (3.4). Our result from Proposition 3.4 states that P(cid:8)εXt/ε ∈ dx(cid:9)/dx ≈ H( x − µt ε1/2 , t) for small ε > 0, where H satisfies (3.5). Hence, qε+pε ≈ H( x−µt ε1/2 , t), and P(cid:8)ξt/ε = 1(cid:9) ≈ k1/(k2 + k1), P(cid:8)ξt/ε = 0(cid:9) ≈ k2/(k2 + k1), gives the result that qε(x, t) and pε(x, t) are well approximated by ε1/2 , t) and H( x−µt H( x−µt ε1/2 , t). k1 k2+k1 k2 k2+k1 4. Dynamics from the spatial system perspective. 4.1. The spatial system in equilibrium. We are now ready to characterize the steady state dynamics induced by continually adding particles from the nucleus and removing them when they reach the distal end of the cell. Proposition 4.1. Let ({(Qi(t), Pi(t)), i = 1, . . . , N})t≥0 be the number of parti- cles in the axonal transport system with compartments of size δ, on and off transport, 14 respectively. Suppose the rate of production of particles from the source is rq0 = vρ0. Then this Markov chain has the product-form stationary distribution k1 (cid:19) (Qi, Pi) ∼ P ois(q0) ⊗ P ois(cid:18) k2q0 where all {(Qi, Pi), i = 1, . . . , N} are mutually independent. Proof. Since the production rate is rq0, the generator of the process (Q1, P1) is Aq0 f (q, p) = [f (q + 1, p) − f (q, p)]rq0 + [f (q − 1, p) − f (q, p)]rq + [f (q − 1, p + 1) − f (q, p)]k2q + [f (q + 1, p − 1) − f (q, p)]k1p If we use f (q, p) = Q1(t) and f (q, p) = P1(t), and take expectations, we get a system of ODEs governing the change in E[Q1], E[P1] over time dE[Q1](t) dt dE[P1](t) dt = rq0 − rE[Q1(t)] − k2E[Q1(t)] + k1E[P1(t)] = k2E[Q1(t)] − k1E[P1(t)] indicating that in equilibrium in the first section the mean numbers of on-transport particles and off-transport particles are E[Q1] = q0, and E[P1] = E[Q1] k2 = q0k2/k1, k1 respectively. Let πq0 (q, p) = πλQ (q)⊗ πλP (p) be a product of two independent Poisson distributions with rates λQ = q0, and λP = q0k2/k1 respectively. To show that πq0 (q, p) is a stationary distribution for the process (Q1, P1) we need to check that ∞ ∞ Xq=0 Xp=0 Aq0 f (q, p)πq0 (q, p) = 0 for any choice of function f ∈ D(Aq0 ). Aq0 f (q, p)e−(λQ+λP ) λq Q q! λp P p! ∞ ∞ Xq=0 Xp=0 = e−(λQ+λP ) + [f (q − 1, p + 1) − f (q, p)]k2q + [f (q + 1, p − 1) − f (q, p)]k1p(cid:17) λp P λq Q q! ∞ ∞ Xq=0 Xp=0 p! (cid:16)[f (q + 1, p) − f (q, p)]rq0 + [f (q − 1, p) − f (q, p)]rq λq+1 Q (q + 1)! λp P p! λq Q q! λp P p! rq r(q + 1) − λq Q q! λq Q q! λp P p! λp P p! k2q k1p k2(q + 1) − k1(p + 1) − λQ q + 1 p λP k2(q + 1) λq−1 Q (q − 1)! λp P p! rq0 − rq0 + λp P p! λp−1 P (p − 1)! λp+1 P (p + 1)! λq Q q! λq+1 Q (q + 1)! λq−1 Q (q − 1)! rq0 − rq0 + λP p + 1 q λQ + + λp P p! (cid:16) q λQ = λq Q q! = λq Q q! λQ q + 1 r(q + 1) − rq + k1(p + 1) − k1p(cid:17) − k2q + rq0 − rq0 + q0r − rq(cid:17) = 0 λp P p! (cid:16) q q0 In the two sums the factor multiplying f (q, p) for any (q, p) ∈ N × N comes only from terms involving {q − 1, q, q + 1} and {p − 1, p, p + 1} and equals e−(λQ+λP ) times 15 since λQ = q0 and λP /λQ = k2/k1. Thus, in equilibrium the input rate for (Q2, P2), which is rQ1, has a Poisson distribution with mean rq0, and is independent of P1. Let πq0 (q1)⊗ πλQ (q2)⊗ πλP (p2) be a product of three Poisson distributions with rates q0, λQ = q0, and λP = q0k2/k1 respectively. To show that this is a stationary distribution for the process (Q1, Q2, P2) we need to check that ∞ ∞ ∞ Xq1=0 Xq2=0 Xp2=0 Aq1 f (q2, p2)πq0 (q1)πq1 (q2, p2) = 0 for any choice of function f ∈ D(Aq1 ). For each fixed value q1, according to our previous calculation the inner two sums give 0, so the whole sum is 0. Thus, in equilibrium, (Q2, P2) have the distribution πλQ (q) ⊗ πλP (p) with λQ = It follows by induc- q0, λP = q0k2/k1 as well, and are independent from (Q1, P1). tion that the stationary distributions for {(Qi, Pi)} are independent and identically distributed as πλQ (q) ⊗ πλP (p), with λQ = q0, λP = q0k2/k1. This is also an exam- ple of a clustering process satisfying the detailed balance conditions with linear rates discussed in Sec. 8.2 of [25]. )q0 = (1 + k2 k1 We point out that the mean number of particles both on and off transport is (1 + k2 )ρ0δ, scaling with the size of a compartment. To obtain the mean k1 number of particles per unit length we add particles in ≈ 1/δ compartments, and the mean number of particles per unit length is (1 + k2 )ρ0 independent of the choice of k1 compartment size. One immediate consequence is the analogous result for the number of particles in the stochastic non-compartmental model at any location along the axon. Namely, suppose the particles move according to the piecewise-linear Markov process (X, ξ) with a Poisson rate ρ0 influx of new particles at location 0. Then, at any location 0 < x < L along the axon, the numbers of particles (Q(x,x+dx), P(x,x+dx)) on and off transport, respectively, have the stationary distribution Pois(ρ0dx)⊗ Pois( k2 ρ0dx) where for any x1, . . . xk ∈ (0, L), {Qxi}1≤i≤k and {Pxi}1≤i≤k are mutually indepen- dent. We note that this result would not have been obvious to notice without going through the compartmental model first, yet its consequences for prediction and anal- ysis of the long term stochastic behavior of the system are quite powerful. k1 16 4.2. Homogeneity of the axons at equilibrium. Recall that δ = 10nm, roughly the step size of motor proteins, and that axons can be up to one meter in length. Thus we are interested in phenomena on all the length scales 10νδ, where ν = 0, 1, 2, . . . 8. Let ∆ = 10νδ; we want to determine how similar different segments of the axon of size ∆ are. Let Q∆ and P∆ denote the numbers of on-track and off-track particles in a segment of length ∆. In equilibrium, Q∆ and P∆ are both sums of 10ν independent Poisson random variables with parameters λQ = q0 and λP = k2 q0, respectively. Therefore the distri- k1 butions of Q∆ and P∆ are Poisson with parameters 10νλQ and 10νλP , respectively. The mean and the variance of the number of particles in the segment of length ∆ is 10ν(λQ + λP ). To see how homogeneous different slices of length ∆ are, we consider the coefficient of variation, c∆, which is the standard deviation divided by the mean. c∆ = 1 = p(λQ + λP )10ν p(1 + k2/k1)q010ν 1 . As indicated in Section 2, q0 is in the range 0.25 to 2.5 in different axons. For illus- trative purposes here, we will assume q0 = 1. Since k2/k1 = 3, we see that the scale- dependent coefficient of variation c∆ = 1/(2√108∆). Therefore at the ten nanometer scale the coefficient of variation is simply 1/2. At the micron scale c∆ = 1/20 and at the millimeter scale c∆ = 0.5 × 10−5/2. The cutoff between "high variance" and "low variance" distributions is usually considered to be when the coefficient of variation is near 1, so by this standard the axon is extremely homogeneous in its length at large scales. 4.3. Balance between efficient transport and targeted delivery. The pre- ceding characterization of the transport apparatus enables us to address questions concerning whole cell function. One core issue is that intracellular transport must simultaneously accommodate two functional demands: some material, such as the enzymes used to construct neurotransmitters, must be transported from the soma to the axon terminal in a timely manner; whereas other cargo, such as sodium channels, need to be delivered to unspecified locations as needs arise throughout the length of the cell. The tradeoff between these two goals is clear. If a typical vesicle spends the vast majority of its time in transport mode, the mean velocity will be close to the mean on-transport velocity, but any needs that arise in the central part of the cell will be neglected. On the other hand, if a typical vesicle spends too much time off transport, presumably available for use if needed locally, then it will take substantially longer to traverse the entire cell. Recently Bressloff and Newby [31, 32] modeled particles that are created near the nucleus that then undergo intermittent search (being in search mode while off transport and not in search mode when on transport) for a target hidden somewhere along the axon. Their model is a non-compartmental individual particle model with the additional feature that vesicles can move backwards as well as forwards. They compute the probability that the particle is successful and conditioning on success, the mean first hitting time. With our system-wide model we can accommodate the observation the if a given vesicle misses the target, another vesicle with similar cargo will pass by before too long. We will assess this hitting time under two assumptions about the density of relevant material. Our standing assumption q0 ∼ 1 is appropriate for types of cargo that are found densely throughout the cell. In this setting, the wait time is essentially just the time it takes for one of several nearby vesicles to unbind 17 from transport in the target region. A more interesting case is a setting where the needed cargo is sparsely distributed, say q0 ∼ 10−3. In this setting, if the first cargo to reach the target region fails to unbind, there will be significant time before the next arrival. As we will see, we can still assess the trade-off intrinsic between risking a target miss and diminishing the time of the next arrival. To make the discussion concrete we define a target region Rn = {i∗ +1, . . . , i∗ +n} where i∗ ∈ 1, . . . , N − n. At time zero, we take the system {Qi(0), Pi(0)} to be drawn from the stationary distribution described by Proposition 4.1 conditioned on the event that for all i ∈ Rn, Qi(0) = Pi(0) = 0. We introduce the hitting time Hn := inf{t > 0 : Pi∈Rn Pi(t) > 0}, which marks the first time a particle is off transport while in Rn. Since computing the mean of Hn is analytically intractable, we introduce another hitting time H ′ n, stochastically dominating Hn, that nevertheless reflects the essential tradeoff between maximizing mean velocity and making detachment from transport likely in the target region. Let I∗ := {i ∈ {1, . . . , i∗} Qi(0) + Pi(0) > 0} be the set of all non-empty sections of the cell at time 0. Among the particle in these sections some will be "successful" in that they will detach from transport in the target region, while others will be unsuccessful. Labeling each particle in these terms, we decompose I0 into locations with successful particles I s ∗ . We are interested in the time H ′ n at which the rightmost successful particle, that is, a particle starting from position im = max{I s ∗}, detaches while in Rn. If S = 0 then we define im = max{∅} := 0. For the position of this particle we use the notation (X δ t )t≥0 from Section 3, where X δ 0 = δim, X δ t ∈ {δim, . . . , δN}, together with the indicator (ξδ t ∈ {0, 1} of whether the particle is on or off transport, respectively. Let ∗ and unsuccessful particles I u t )t≥0, ξδ H ′ n := inf{t > 0 : (X δ t , ξδ t ) = (δ(i∗ + 1), 1)}. ∗ , H i n = inf{t > 0 : X δ ∗ where for each i ∈ I s n : i ∈ I s Note that H ′ t ∈ δRn}, since particles cannot skip sections, and always enter a section on transport. If we were to analogously define a sequence of times {H i n}i∈I s 0 = δi and ξδ 0 ∈ {0, 1}, then the exact first hitting time of the target region will satisfy Hn = min{H i Since the exact distribution of H i n is complicated, E[Hn] is analytically intractable, and instead we focus on finding a simple expression for E[H ′ n]. Our point is that, in the sparse material limit (q0 small), the rightmost particle becomes increasingly likely to be the first successful particle to detach in the target region, and Hn approaches H ′ n. ∗}. Hence, clearly Hn ≤ H im n = inf{t > 0 : X δ t ∈ δRn} with X δ n ≡ H ′ n. The computation of E[H ′ n] requires computing the time it takes a particle to travel a certain axonal distance, given by the following. Lemma 4.2. Let the initial position of the particle be (X δ 0) = (0, 1) and let L∗ ∈ {1, . . . , L} be given where L is the total length of the axon. Then, the time TL∗ = inf{t > 0 : X δ t = L∗}, satisfies 0 , ξδ E[TL∗] = L∗(k2 + k1) vk1 . Proof. Since (X δ t , ξδ t )t≥0 is a Markov process with generator Aδf (x, ξ) = rξ(cid:2)f (x + δ, ξ) − f (x, ξ)(cid:3) + k2ξ(cid:2)f (x, ξ − 1) − f (x, ξ)(cid:3) + k1(1 − ξ)(cid:2)f (x, ξ + 1) − f (x, ξ)(cid:3) 18 it follows that M 1 s )ds are both martingales. Since both M 1 and M 2 have bounded increments and E[TL∗] < ∞, the optional stopping theorem implies that 0 k1(1 − ξδ t := X δ t := ξδ 0 ξδ s ds and M 2 t − rδR t TL∗i = L∗ − vEhZ TL∗ 0 0 k2ξδ s ds −R t t +R t s dsi ⇒ EhZ TL∗ ξδ 0 ξδ 0 = E(cid:2)M 1 0(cid:3) = EhM 1 and s dsi = L∗/v 1 = E(cid:2)M 2 0(cid:3) = EhM 2 TL∗i = 1 − k1E[TL∗] + (k2 + k1)EhZ TL∗ 0 ξδ s dsi which implies E[TL∗] = k2 + k1 k1 EhZ TL∗ 0 ξδ s dsi. and our claim follows. We also note that the same computation holds for the mean time a particle in the stochastic non-compartmental model (Xt, ξt)t≥0 takes to reach a distance L∗, as the two martingales used in the proof depend only on v and not on δ. We next compute the hitting time H ′ n of a particle started at location im ∈ I∗. Lemma 4.3. Let the system {(Qi(0), Pi(0)), i = 1, . . . , N} have the stationary distribution given by Proposition 4.1 conditional on Qi(0) = Pi(0) = 0, for all i ∈ Rn. Then k2 + r(cid:19)(cid:21) n] = (1 − e−λn)(cid:20) k2 + r(cid:19)n(cid:18)1 + k2pn (cid:20)1 −(cid:18) r k1(k2 + k1)(cid:21) + rq0pn E[H ′ nk2 k2 + 1 1 r k2+r )n and λn = k2+k1 where pn = 1 − ( Proof. The proof of Proposition 4.1 shows that conditioning on the values of Pi(0), i ∈ Rn does not affect the law of {(Qi(t), Pi(t)), i ≤ i∗}, hence for any t ≥ 0, they form two mutually independent sequences of Pois(q0) and Pois( k2q0 ) random k1 variables. q0i∗pn. k1 k1 probability it first detaches at location i∗ +i. Since p(i) = ( detaching there. This probability can be written pn := Pn a particle gets off transport in the i-th compartment, pn =Pn Let S denote the number of successful particles between sites 0 and i∗ at time zero. The total of number of particles at time 0 at these sites that are either on or off transport is distributed as a Pois( k2+k1 q0i∗) variable. We next compute the probability pn that any particle once it reached the target region is "successful" in i=1 p(i) where p(i) is the k2+r )i−1 k2 r k2+r is the chance k2+r )n. The probability that a particle is successful does not depend on which location it was at time 0, and whether it was on or off transport at that time. Hence, S is is distributed as a Pois( k2+k1 q0i∗pn) variable, and conditioned on the value S, the set of locations of the particles at time 0 is distributed as a set of S draws from the uniform distribution on {1, . . . , i∗}. Since im is the maximum of S samples from a Uniform{1, . . . , i∗} distribution we have E[imS] = i∗ − 1 x=1 xS ≈ i∗ e,n is the time it takes a successful particle initially at location im to enter the region Rn, and Ho,n is the time it takes any successful particle after it enters the region to get off transport. Thus, E[H ′ o,n, where we let H ′ ∗ Pi∗−1 We now decompose H ′ i=1 p(i) = 1 − ( e,n + H ′ n = H ′ S S+1 . k1 iS r n] = E(cid:2)H ′ e,n(cid:3) + E(cid:2)H ′ o,n(cid:3). If a successful particle starts at location X δ ξδ 0 = 1, then the time it takes to enter the region Rn is by Lemma 4.2 0 = im ∈ {0, . . . , i∗} on transport 19 e,n(X δ 0 , ξδ E(cid:2)H ′ 0) = (im, 1)(cid:3) = (i∗ − im)δ(k2 + k1) vk1 If it starts at location X δ 0 = 1 then it takes an additional Exponential time with mean 1/k1 for it to get back on transport at the , and 0 = im ∈ {1, . . . , i∗} off transport ξδ 0 , ξδ since we assume new particles always enter the system on transport 0 , ξδ e,n(X δ same location, so E(cid:2)H ′ E(cid:2)H ′ S+1 , P{im > 0} = P{S > 0}, we get that 0) = (im, 0)(cid:3) = E(cid:2)H ′ (i∗ − im)δ(k2 + k1) e,nim(cid:3) = e,n(X δ 1 k1 vk1 + S 1im>0. 0) = (im, 1)(cid:3) + 1 k1 Since E[imS] = i∗ E(cid:2)H ′ e,n(cid:3) = E(cid:20) with S ∼ Pois(λn), λn = k2+k1 we get k1 1 S + 1(cid:21) i∗(k2 + k1) rk1 + k2 k1(k2 + k1) P{S > 0} q0i∗pn. Since E[S] = 1−e−λn λn , P{S > 0} = 1 − e−λn , + k2 rq0pn k1(k2 + k1)(cid:19) e,n(cid:3) = (1 − e−λn )(cid:18) 1 E(cid:2)H ′ To calculate E(cid:2)H ′ o,n(cid:3) note that if a particle first gets off transport in the i-th compartment then the time of its travel until this point is a sum of i independent and identically distributed exponential random variables with parameter k2 + r. The probability a successful particle first gets off transport in the i-th compartment is p(i) . Hence, the time a successful particle takes to get off transport once it enters the pn region R has the mean E(cid:2)H ′ o,n(cid:3) = p(i) pn n Xi=1 i k2 + r = and our claim follows. 1 k2pn (cid:20)1 −(cid:18) r k2 + r(cid:19)n(cid:18)1 + nk2 k2 + r(cid:19)(cid:21) . To complete our analysis, we wish to characterize this result in terms of length along the axon and independent of the stepping size δ. To this end, we fix a length ℓ and for a given compartment size ℓ, we let n = ⌈ℓ/δ⌉, and for the start of the region we let i∗ = ⌈ℓ∗/δ⌉. As such, as δ → 0 the limiting region becomes Rℓ = (ℓ∗, ℓ∗ + ℓ). Then, under the assumption that q0/δ → ρ0 we have pn → pℓ = 1 − e−ℓk2/v, λn → λℓ = k2 + k1 ρ0ℓ∗pℓ k1 and E[H ′ n] → E[H ′] where E[H ′] =(cid:0)1 − e−λℓ(cid:1)(cid:20) 1 vρ0pℓ + k2 k1(k2 + k1)(cid:21) + 1 k2pℓ (cid:20)1 − e− ℓk2 v (1 + ℓk2 v )(cid:21) . (4.1) It remains to interpret this result with respect to the parameter choices we have made. First, we must set a value for the size ℓ of the target region. For this purpose 20 we note that the typical size of a Node of Ranvier -- a gap in the myelin sheath of a myelinated axon where sodium channels are concentrated in the cell membrane -- is approximately one micron.1 As seen in the preceding proof there are three contributions to E[H ′], and we next analyze them in terms of their dominance for the overall value. We begin with the contribution from the last term, which is the time it takes for a successful particle to detach once it has reached the target region. By our choice of ℓ, the recurring ratio ℓ/v is one. Along with the earlier assumption that k2 = 1, the entire term simplifies to (e− 2)/(e− 1) = 0.4 s. The multiplicative factor 1− e−λℓ preceding the first term of (4.1) results from a boundary effect: when ℓ∗ is very close to zero, it is very unlikely there are any particles already in the system between the soma and the target region. When the target region is in the middle of the axon, this contribution from particles in that section of the axon at time 0 is significant. When q0 ∼ 1 as assumed earlier, then ρ0 = q0/δ ∼ 108. Then if ℓ∗ > 10−8, which corresponds to the target region being just one motor step down the length of the axon, we have ρ0ℓ∗ ∼ 1 and λℓ > 2.3 so 1 − e−λℓ > 0.9. Looking at the first term inside the parenthesis, we note that vρ0 ∼ 102, while pℓ = 1 − exp(−ℓk2/v) ≈ 0.6 is the probability that any given vesicle will be successful in detaching from transport in the target region, so 1/(vρ0pℓ) ∼ 10−2. Meanwhile, the term k2/(k1(k2 + k1)), which is the expected time to bind to transport if a successful particle happens to be off transport at time 0, is 1/4 for the assumed values of k2 and k1. Therefore under the q0 ∼ 1 assumption, both this and the final term contribute significantly to the hitting time. However, in the sparse material regime, say q0 ∼ 10−3, we have then ρ0 ∼ 105, and the factor 1 − e−λℓ > 0.9 when ℓ∗ > 10−5. That is, if the target region is at least 1/100, or at least 1000 segments, down the length of a 10−3m axon. However, now the rate limiting factor is the wait time for the first successful vesicle to arrive in the target region, which is captured by the term 1/vρ0p. The product vρ0 ≈ 0.1 measures the average rate at which new particles should arrive and together with the probability of success pℓ ≈ 0.6, we now have 1/vρ0pℓ ≈ 16s. So, in the sparse material regime the first summand in E[H ′] giving the mean time for arrival of the particles to the target region dominates. It is interesting to consider what happens to the arrival rate term under per- turbations of the various parameters. In particular, we draw the reader's attention to changes in v. When viewing intermittent search in terms of a single particle, the probability of finding the target is strictly decreasing in v. Higher velocity seems to be the enemy of finding the target. Indeed, from a system point of view, this implies that the system will require more trials before a successful particle arrives in the target region. What the equation (4.1) gives us is the ability assess how much more quickly the trials will happen. In fact, the function v(1 − exp(−ℓk2/v)) is increasing in v. Therefore the entire expected wait time E[H ′] is actually decreasing in v. That is to say, while the particles are less likely to succeed, they will be arriving more rapidly enough to counterbalance the lost time. We believe that this kind of quantitative analysis will prove fruitful in future study when coupled with more details of the 1We do not wish to claim this is a complete model for deposition of sodium channels in Nodes of Ranvier, as the particulars of the biology -- which may include factors like local signals that encourage motors to detach from microtubules near the Nodes -- are not fully understood. We merely wish to use the size of the Nodes to fix our intuition about the size of a target to other important length scales such as that of microtubules which are also a micron in length. 21 biology of deposition of materials in the cell membrane. 4.4. Approaching Equilibrium. We have seen above that the axon is very homogeneous at stochastic equilibrium on a space scale down to micrometers. One of the beautiful properties of transport with reversible binding is that if it is locally out of equilibrium, the on-off dynamics can return the system to equilibrium on a much faster time scale than waiting for new material to arrive from the nucleus. Furthermore, as is discussed in [45], one of the key goals of biophysics investigation is the discovery of behaviors for which biochemical regulation is not necessary. This is of fundamental importance to the biological function of the system because it means that the axon will automatically "repair" itself without central control of the repair process. How good is this mechanism? If a segment of the axon is far away from equilib- rium, how long does it take to get back close to equilibrium? To investigate this ques- tion, we imagine that the axon is at stochastic equilibrium except for some segment R, where the total number of particles on and off transport, Qi(0)+ Pi(0) = 0,∀i ∈ R, is zero at time 0. Let a and ε be given small numbers and suppose that λ∞ is the mean vector for (Qi, Pi) at stochasttic equilibrium. We want to compute (an upper bound for) the time t∗ so that P{(Qi(t∗), Pi(t∗)) − λ∞ ≥ aλ∞,∀i ∈ R} ≤ ε, that is, the probability that (Qi, Pi),∀i ∈ R is significantly different from λ∞ is very small. In the applications below we will choose a = 0.1 and ε = 0.05, and we will see that a 10 micron segment can recover in about 10 seconds, while a 1 millimeter segment will take about 1000 seconds or 15 minutes to recover. We study this question first for a single location R = {i}, and then use the estimates derived to scale the results to segments of any length. Proposition 4.4. Let (Qi(0), Pi(0)) = (0, 0) and let the constants a > 0 and ) is the equilibrium ε ∈ (0, 1) satisfy the relationship a2ελ∞ > 1 where λ∞ = q0(1, k2 vector of (Qi, Pi). Then there exists t∗ > 0 such that ∀t ≥ t∗, P{(Qi(t), Pi(t)) − λ∞ ≥ aλ∞} ≤ ε. √pλ∞ a√ελ∞−1(cid:17) is sufficient, where 2(cid:16)k2 + k1 + r −p(k2 + k1 + r)2 − 4k1r(cid:17) . In fact, the choice t∗ = α−1 ln(cid:16) α := k1 1 guarantees that there are "enough" particles. We note that given a particular choice of a and ε, the condition a2ελ∞ > 1 Proof. Note that for any given β ∈ (0, 1), we may choose t∗ > 0 such that for all t ≥ t∗, the vector of means λ(t) := E[(Qi(t), Pi(t))] satisfies λ(t) − λ∞ ≤ aβλ∞. Then P{(Qi(t), Pi(t)) − λ∞ ≥ aλ∞} ≤ P{(Qi(t), Pi(t)) − λ(t) + λ(t) − λ∞ ≥ aλ∞} ≤ P{(Qi(t), Pi(t)) − λ(t) ≥ a(1 − β)λ∞} Applying Chebyshev's Inequality, and observing that the variance of a Poisson random variable is equal to its mean, we conclude that P{(Qi(t), Pi(t)) − λ∞ ≥ aλ∞} ≤ Var[(Qi(t), Pi(t))] a2(1 − β)2λ∞2 = λ(t) a2(1 − β)2λ∞2 22 Since the initial condition for both Pi and Qi are less than their respective equilibrium values, each are monotonically increasing functions and the above reduces to P{(Qi(t), Pi(t)) − λ∞ ≥ aλ∞} ≤ 1 a2(1 − β)2λ∞ for all t > t∗. In order to satisfy the requirement that the right hand side must be less than ε, we solve for β and find β = 1 − (apελ∞)−1 provided that apελ∞ > 1. It remains to study the convergence of the mean and the appropriate choice of t∗. The dynamics of the mean vector λ(t) are given by the ODE (4.2) λ(t) = −A1λ(t) + q0re1 where e1 is the unit vector (1, 0) and A1 =(cid:18) k2 + r −k1 −k2 k1 (cid:19) . d dt The solution to (4.2) is λ(t) = λ∞ + e−A1t(λ(0) − λ∞) where λ∞ = q0rA−1 1 e1 = ). This yields the estimate q0(1, k2 k1 λ(t) − λ∞ ≤(cid:12)(cid:12)e−A1tλ∞(cid:12)(cid:12) ≤ e−αtλ∞ where α is the smaller of the eigenvalues of A1. Noting that α > 0, t∗ may be chosen so that e−αt∗ ≤ aβ, i.e. t∗ = α−1 ln(1/(aβ)) is an upper bound for the time to be close to equilibrium with high probability. In order to calculate return to equilibrium at various scales, we now suppose that the whole axon is in statistical equilibrium except for a segment R of length ∆ = δ10ν in which we will assume that there are no particles either on or off the track. Proposition 4.4 covered the case ν = 0. We are interested in ν = 1, . . . , 8. We imagine that the axon is broken up into 108−ν segments of length ∆. In this rescaled system, the unbinding and binding rates per particle, k2 and k1 remain the same, as well as the mean on-transport velocity v. In order to retain this mean velocity, the rate of lateral stepping must be decreased to r = r10−ν. The ODE for the mean vector of the rescaled system is given by d dt λ(t) = − A1 λ(t) + q0re1 (4.3) with A1 =(cid:18) k2 + r −k1 k1 (cid:19) . −k2 We note that the last term in (4.3) contains an r rather than an r. This is because the input rate is unchanged while the exit rate is diminished. The resulting equilibrium value is therefore rescaled as well, λ∞ = q0r A−1 1 e1 = q0 components of this vector are of order 10ν, as expected. k2/k1(cid:1) = q010ν(cid:0) 1 r(cid:0) 1 Using the parameters discussed in Section 2: k2 = 1, k1 = 1 3 , v = 10−6m/s, r = 102s−1. This implies r = 102−νs−1. We choose the thresholds to be a = 0.1 and ε = 0.05, so the constraint that a2ελ∞ > 1 requires that λ∞ > 2 × 103. Since 0.25 ≤ q0 ≤ 2.5, this is indeed the case if ν > 3, i.e. if the segment has length greater than 10 microns. It follows from Proposition 4.4 that the time to equilibrium, t∗, is proportional k2/k1(cid:1). Both r to α−1 where α satisfies: 1 α = = 2(cid:16)k2 + k1 + r −p(k2 + k1 + r)2 − 4k1r(cid:17) k2 + k1 + r +p(k2 + k1 + r)2 − 4k1r 2k1r . 23 For the given parameter values (with λ∞ > 5 × 103 in particular), the constant of proportionality ln(cid:16)pελ∞/(apελ∞ − 1)(cid:17) is contained in the interval (2.3, 2.5) and does not have a impact on how the relaxation time scales with ν. In terms of analyzing α, we note that k1r is small compared to k2. To leading order, α ∼ (k1r)/(k2 + k1 + r) ∼ 102−νs−1. It follows that t∗ ∼ 10ν−2s. Thus, for a 10 micron segment (ν = 3) the time to recover is about 10 seconds and for a 1 millimeter seg- ment (ν = 5) the time to recover is 1000 seconds or 15 minutes. The time to recover depends, of course, on the parameter ε that represents what we mean by "close." We also note that one can compute various measures of time to recover using the PDE models discussed in Section 3. 5. Discussion. In this paper, we created a spatial Markov chain model for study- ing various aspects of fast axonal transport. Previous models that use PDEs treat the velocity of transport as constant when particles are attached to the fast transport system. Since it is known that transport along the microtubules is itself stochastic, it is important to have a fully stochastic model. Our model allows us to unify and extend previous work. In Section 3.2 we show that from the particle perspective as the compartment size δ tends to zero, our model converges in distribution on the Skorokhod space of c`adl`ag functions to the piecewise-deterministic model analyzed by Brooks [5]. Namely, we show that the paths of particles in our model converge to those of particles in a stochastic non-compartmental model. The argument proceeds by an explicit computation of the finite-dimensional distributions and a tightness ar- gument. In Proposition 3.4 we give a rigorous probabilistic proof of why the paths of particles follow "approximate traveling waves" described by other authors [36, 5, 14]. This proof is based on stochastic averaging arguments which show that a functional central limit theorem holds on the space of continuous functions for the paths of particles as the compartment size decreases. The diffusion of particles around their mean position can consequently be approximately described jointly for all time by a Brownian motion with the appropriate diffusion coefficient. In Section 2, we show how to use existing experimental data to indentify (ranges for) all the parameters of our model. In light of this, we can use the model to investigate several important biological questions. These are based on describing the spatial distribution of multiple particles in our model. In Section 4.1 we derive the stationary distribution for the number of particles in different compartments on and off transport along the axon. This gives an explicit description of the stochasticity of the system that is present even after a long time. In Section 4.2 we derive estimates for how homogeneous the axon is on different spatial scales. In Section 4.3 we study a question introduced by Bressloff, by providing a stochastic quantity which describes the balance the system needs to achieve between rapid transport that brings new material quickly and efficient local search that improves time of delivery to a target. Finally, in Section 4.4, we use the model to calculate the length of time that it would take for axonal segments of different lengths to recover to near stochastic equilibrium after they have been depleted of vesicles. In our stochastic compartmental model all event wait times are assumed to be exponential random variables, but this is certainly a simplification. As an example, the stepping process of kinesin is a well-studied though still not completely understood phenomenon. Much work has focused on assessing the dependence of the mean rate of translocation on both the load and the local concentration of ATP [44] [38]. Implicit in this analysis is the assumption of exponential wait times with state dependent rate 24 parameters. However, when fitting to data and matching dispersion information the authors in [13] found it necessary to generalize the wait time distribution. This was followed by more detailed models for which it was shown that load carrying could in fact regularize the stepping times of kinesin motors [37] [9]. Generalizing waiting times would significantly affect our results. Since the particle position process is no longer Markov, we no longer have the direct connection to the previous results stated in Section 3.1.-3.3., nor can we use the stationary distribution employed in Section 4.1 and used for addressing the biologicals questions in Sections 4.2.-4.4. In light of the known need for generalized wait times in the stepping process, it seems likely that detailed observation of the rebinding process will call for new mathematical models as well. Recall that when a vesicle unbinds from a microtubule it is unclear whether it typically rebinds to the same microtubule or if it explores the region significantly via diffusion before finding a different microtubule to bind to. In the latter case, a more appropriate model for rebinding time would be to solve some kind of first passage time problem and use that distribution for the rebinding wait. An important aspect of the biology of axonal transport is not included in the model presented here, namely the local deposition and eventual degradation of trans- ported materials. For example, sodium channels and sodium pumps are synthesized at the soma, transported down the axon and deposited in the axonal membrane, ether uniformly as in an unmyelinated axon or at the nodes of Ranvier in a myelinated axon. Channels and pumps are proteins with half-lives on the order of days to weeks. The present model can be extended to include a deposition compartment at each location, and, clearly, the processes of deposition and subsequent degradation will cause the mean number of particles both on and off transport to be monotone decreasing as one moves down the axon. How inhomogeneous this makes the axon will depend on the details of deposition and degradation rates. Our preliminary calculations indi- cate that long axons, such as the meter-long axons in human sciatic nerve, would be quite inhomogeneous. This is an important biological issue because it is controversial whether the machinery for protein synthesis (i.e. ribosomes) exist in axons [42]. We have also not included retrograde transport or the fact that some axons may have location-dependent unbinding rates [10]. All of these issues will be the subject of future work. Acknowledgments. The authors are grateful to Professors H. Frederik Nijhout and Vann Bennett of Duke University and Professor Anthony Brown of The Ohio State University for helpful discussions. This work was supported by NSF grants DMS-061670 and EF-1038593, and an NSERC Discovery Grant. REFERENCES [1] Alberts B, Johnson A, Lewis J, Raff M, Roberts K, Walter P (2008) The Molecular Biology of the Cell, Garland Science, Taylor & Francis Group, New York. [2] Allen RD, Weiss DG, Hayden JH, Brown DT, Fijiwaki H, Simpson M (1985). Gliding movement and bidirectional transport along single native microtubules from squid axoplasm: evidence for an active role for microtubules in cytoplasmic transport. J. Cell Biol 100, 1736-1752. [3] Blum JJ, Reed MC (1985) A Model for Fast Axonal Transport. Cell Motility 5, 507-527. [4] Bressloff PC, (2006) Stochastic model of protein receptor trafficking prior to synaptogenesis Physical Review E 74 031910. [5] Brooks EA (1999) Probabilistic methods for a linear reaction-hyperbolic system with constant coefficients. Ann. Appl. Prob., 9(3), 719-731. [6] Brown A (2000) Slow axonal transport: stop and go traffic in the axon. Nat Rev Cell Mol Biol 1, 153-156. 25 [7] Carter NJ, Cross RA (2005) Mechanics of the kinesin step. Nature 435, 308-312. [8] Cox DR (1962) Renewal Theory. Methuen & C0. Ltd., London, Section 4.5. [9] DeVille RL and Vanden-Eijnden E (2008) Regular Gaits and Optimal Velocities for Motor Proteins Biophysics Journal 95 6: 2681-2691. [10] Dixit R, Ross JL, Goldman YE, Holzbaur ELF (2008) Differential regulation of dynein and kinesin otor proteins by tau. Science 319, 1086-1089. [11] Ethier S, Kurtz TG (1986) Markov Processes: Characterization and Convergence. John Wiley & Sons Inc., New Jersey [12] Finer JT, Simmons RM, Spudich JA (1994) Single myosin molecule mechanics: piconewton forces and nanometre steps. Nature 368, 113-119. [13] Fisher ME, Kolomeisky (2001) Simple mechanochemistry describes the dynamics of kinesin molecules. PNAS 98 14: 7748-7753. [14] Friedman A, Craciun G (2005) A model of intracellular transport of particles in an axon. SIAM J Appl Math 38, 741-758. [15] Friedman A, Craciun G (2006) Approximate traveling waves in linear reaction-hyperbolic equations. SIAM J Appl Math 38, 741-758. [16] Friedman A, Hu B (2007) Uniform convergence for approximate traveling waves in reaction- hyperbolic systems. Indiana Math J 56, 2133-2158. [17] Friedman A, Hu B (2007) Uniform convergence for approximate traveling waves in reaction- diffusion-hyperbolic systems. Arch Rat Mech Anal 186, 251-274. [18] Gennerich A, Carter AP, Reck-Peterson, Vale RD (2007) Force-induced bidirectional stepping of cytoplasmic dynein. Cell 131, 952-965. [19] Griego RJ, Hersh R (1969) "Random evolutions, Markov chains, and systems of partial differ- ential equations." Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 62, 305-308. [20] Gross GW, Weiss, DG (1982) "Theoretical considerations on rapid transport in low viscosity axonal regions." Axoplasmic Transport (Ed. D.G. Weiss), Springer-Verlag, Berlin. [21] Jastrow H Electron Microscopic Atlas of Cells, Tissues and Organs on the Internet. Schwann cells section. http://www.uni-mainz.de/FB/Medizin/Anatomie/workshop/EM/EMSchwannE.html [22] Kallenberg O (2002) "Foundations of modern probability", 2nd ed. Springer-Verlag, New York. [23] Khas'minskii, RZ (1966) "On stochastic processes defined by differential equations with a small parameter." Theory Probab. Appl. , 11, 211-228. [24] Khas'minskii RZ (1966) "A limit theorem for the solutions of differential equations with random right-hand sides." Theory Probab. Appl. , 11, 390-406. [25] Kelly FR Reversibility and stochastic networks. John Wiley & Sons Ltd., Chichester, 1979. Wiley Series in Probability and Mathematical Statistics. [26] Kurtz TG (1992) Averaging for martingale problems and stochastic approximation. Lecture Notes in Control and Inform. Sci. , 177, 186-209. [27] Lasek RJ, Brady ST (1982). The structural hypothesis of axonal transport: two classes of moving elements. Axoplasmic Transport (ed. G. Weiss), Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1982, pp. 397-405. [28] Lawler G (1995) Introduction to Stochastic Processes Chapman and Hall, New York. [29] Miller R, Lasek RJ (1985) Crossbridges mediate anterograde and retrograde vesicle transport along microtubules in squid axoplasm. J Cell Biol 101, 2181-2193. [30] Moran D, Rowley JC III Visual Histology.com, Chapter 8, Nerves. http://www.visualhistology.com/products/atlas/VHA Chpt8 Nerves.html [31] Newby JM, Bressloff PC Directed Intermittent Search for Hidden Targets New Journal of Physics 11 023033. [32] Newby JM, Bressloff PC Quasi-steady State Reduction of Molecular Motor-Based Models of Directed Intermittant Search Bullentin of Mathematical Biology 72 1840-1866. [33] Ochs S (1972) Rate of fast axoplasmic transport in mammalian nerve fibers. J Physiol 227, 627-245. [34] Reed MC, Blum JJ (1986) Theoretical analysis of radioactivity proles during fast axonal transport: effects of deposition and turnover. Cell Motility and the Cytoskeleton, 6, 620627. [35] Reed MC, Blum J (1994) Mathematical Questions in Axonal Transport. In Lectures in math- ematics in the Life Sciences,24, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence. [36] Reed MC, Venakides S, Blum JJ (1990) Approximate traveling waves in linear reaction- hyperbolic equations. SIAM J. Appl. Math., 50, 167180. [37] Schilstra MJ, Martin SR (2006) An elastically tethered viscous load imposes a regular gait on the motion of myosin-V. Simulation of the effect of transient force relaxation on a stochastic process. J.R. Soc. Interface 3 153-165. [38] Schnitzer MJ, Visscher K, Block SM (2000) Force production by single kinesin motors. Nat. 26 Cell. Biol. 2 718-722. [39] Stewart GH, Horwitz B, Gross GW (1982) A chromatographic model of axoplasmic transport. In Axoplasmic Transport (ed. G. Weiss), Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1982, 414-422. [40] Svoboda K, Schmidt C, Schnapp B (1985) Direct observation of kinesin stepping by optical trapping interferometry. Nature 365, 721-727. [41] Takenaka T, Gotoh H (1984) Simulation of axoplasmic transport. J Theor Biol 107, 579-601. [42] Twiss JL, Fainzilber M (2009) Ribosomes in axons - scrounging from the neighbors. Trends in cell biology. 19, 236-243 [43] Vale RD, Reese TS, Sheetz MP (1985). Identification of a novel force-generating protein, kinesin, involved in microtubule-based motility. Cell 42, 39-50. [44] Visscher K, Schnitzer MJ, Block SM (1999) Single kinesin molecules studied with a molecular force clamp Nature 400, 184-189. [45] Welte MA, Gross SP (2008) Molecular motors: a traffic cop within? HFSP Journal 2 4: 178-182. [46] Willis WD, Grossman RG (1981) Medical Neurobiology: Neuroanatomical and Neurophysio- logical Principles Basic to Clinical Neuroscience. Mosby, Inc.
1310.0218	1	1310	2013-10-01T10:02:24	Synaptic metaplasticity underlies tetanic potentiation in Lymnaea: a novel paradigm	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.dis-nn", "q-bio.NC" ]	We present a mathematical model which explains and interprets a novel form of short-term potentiation, which was found to be use-, but not time-dependent, in experiments done on Lymnaea neurons. The high degree of potentiation is explained using a model of synaptic metaplasticity, while the use-dependence (which is critically reliant on the presence of kinase in the experiment) is explained using a model of a stochastic and bistable biological switch.	physics.bio-ph	physics	1 Synaptic metaplasticity underlies tetanic potentiation in Lymnaea: a novel paradigm Anita Mehta1,∗, Jean-Marc Luck2, Collin C. Luk3, Naweed I. Syed3 1 S. N. Bose National Centre for Basic Sciences, Calcutta, India 2 Institut de Physique Th´eorique, CEA Saclay and CNRS URA 2306, Gif-sur-Yvette, France 3 Hotchkiss Brain Institute, Faculty of Medicine, University of Calgary, Alberta, Canada ∗ E-mail: [email protected] Abstract We present a mathematical model which explains and interprets a novel form of short-term potentiation, which was found to be use-, but not time-dependent, in experiments done on Lymnaea neurons. The high degree of potentiation is explained using a model of synaptic metaplasticity, while the use-dependence (which is critically reliant on the presence of kinase in the experiment) is explained using a model of a stochastic and bistable biological switch. Introduction All brain functions, ranging from simple reflexes to complex motor patterns, learning and memory, rely upon synaptic transmission between neurons through specialized structures termed synapses. These synaptic connections are, however, not static in nature; in fact, they exhibit a high degree of synaptic plasticity, enabling a network to generate behaviorally relevant and functionally meaningful outputs. These changes in synaptic strength can either be short- or long-term, and may form the basis for both short- and long-term memory, respectively. Synaptic plasticity is neither restricted to any select group of neurons nor to a particular species -- rather it is a universal trademark of all neurons that have been investigated to date. When a nervous system is unable to exhibit modulatory changes associated with short- and long-term synaptic plasticity, it is rendered dysfunctional. Therefore, defining the mechanisms underlying synaptic plasticity is not only pivotal for our understanding of how the brain functions but also for managing the behavioral, learning, memory and cognitive defects that are met in clinical practice. However, despite recent advances in our understanding of various modes of neuronal communication, the cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying synaptic plasticity remain poorly defined. Moreover, the data generated from experimental studies has often been inadequate to garner mathematical modeling predictions that may aid future research in this area, or to provide insights into the mechanisms of synaptic plasticity. This field could however benefit from a paradigm shift where modeling approaches could be used to predict elements of synaptic plasticity and to facilitate future research in the area of metaplasticity. In a recent study [1], two of the authors of this paper observed a form of short-term potentiation induced by tetanic stimulation, whose time-frame exceeded conventional forms of short-term potentiation. While the induction of potentiation was similar to previous forms of short-term potentiation, the time frame of the potentiated response was characteristic of long-term potentiation (∼ 5 hrs). More specifically, using well-defined, excitatory cholinergic synapses between Lymnaea pre- and post- synaptic neurons, specifically visceral dorsal 4 (VD4) and left pedal dorsal 1 (LPeD1-Excitatory), they provided evidence for a novel form of short-term potentiation, which was use-, but not time-dependent. They found that following a tetanic stimulation (∼ 10 Hz) in the presynaptic neuron with a minimum of seven action potentials, the synapse became potentiated, whereby a subsequent action potential trig- gered in the presynaptic neuron resulted in an enhanced postsynaptic potential (see Figure 1). Further, if an inducing tetanic stimulation was activated but a subsequent action potential was not triggered, the 2 synapse was shown to remain potentiated for as long as 5 hours. However, once this action potential was triggered, the authors found that the synaptic strength rapidly returned to baseline levels. It was also shown that this form of synaptic plasticity relied on the presynaptic neuron, and required pre- but not postsynaptic Ca2+/calmodulin dependent kinase II (CaMKII) activity. Hence, this form of potentiation shares induction and de-potentiation characteristics similar to other forms of short-term potentiation, but exhibits a time-frame analogous to that of long-term potentiation. The model of metaplastic synapses [2] reviewed below allows us to reproduce these long timescales, and forms the basis of our explanation of the experimental results reported in [1]. In the model of metaplastic synapses, incoming signals are stored as memories at progressively deeper levels of a synapse, leading to a clear temporal separation between long- and short-term memory. The upper levels are more vulnerable to 'noise', i.e., the regular influx of (usually irrelevant) information which is responsible for the phenomenon of forgetting; only short-term memories can be stored here. (For a review of noise in neural systems, see [3]). Deeper synaptic levels are more protected from this noise, and thus able to retain the memory of applied signals for a much longer time. Drawing on these structural ideas first proposed by Fusi et al. [4], the model of [2] provides a theoretical framework for the dynamics of signal propagation within the metaplastic synapse. It suggests that random signals are typically stored in the upper levels of the synapse for relatively short times, and then lost to noise: non-random signals, on the other hand, are stored as long-term memories in the deepest synaptic levels and forgotten much more slowly. The link between this theory and the experiment reported in [1] relies on the fact that the output signal in the latter was amplified after a process of tetanic stimulation. This suggested the following scenario: the initial action potentials, interpreted as a non-random signal, cumulatively built up a long- term memory of the signal in the deepest synaptic levels. The synapse dynamics were then frozen so that further discharge was prevented. When a further action potential was applied, the synaptic dynamics restarted ('use'-dependence): the release of the accumulated memory from the deepest levels of the synapse constituted the observed enhancement of the output signal described in [1]. While this enhancement is plausibly accounted for by the model of metaplastic synapses [2], the explanation of the freezing of the synaptic dynamics and its subsequent use-dependence needs the introduction of a biological switch. The stochastic and bistable switch presented in this paper meets this need, and models the role of kinase (CaMKII) in the actual experiment [1]. In the following, we first review the basics of the model of a metaplastic synapse [2]. We then provide a full theoretical framework for the explanation of the experimental results, with an emphasis on the dynamics of the biological switch. We close by discussing our results. Results A model of a metaplastic synapse If synapses are highly plastic, signals are quickly stored: however, high plasticity also means that more and more signals are stored, generating enough 'noise' so that 'memories' of earlier signals soon become irretrievable. Clearly, this is at variance with the fact that long-term memories are ubiquitous in human experience; it was to resolve this paradox that models of metaplastic synapses were formulated [4]. The idea behind such models was that the introduction of 'hidden states' for a synapse would enable the delinking of memory lifetimes from instantaneous signal response: while maintaining quick learning, this mechanism would also be able to allow slow forgetting. This was implemented by the storage of memories at different 'levels': the relaxation times for the memories increased as a function of depth. This hierarchy of time scales models the phenomenon of metaplasticity [5, 6]. In [2] these ideas were put into a new framework, with the dynamics of signal processing playing a central role. Also, two different internal synaptic structures were investigated: the first (Model I) was 3 very similar to Fusi's original model [4], while the second (Model II) had a different architecture. In the following, we focus on the second model. We start by reviewing its essential features. The dynamics of the model are defined in Figure 2. At every discrete time step t, the synapse is subjected either to a potentiating pulse (PP) (encoded as ε(t) = +1) or to a depressing pulse (DP) (encoded as ε(t) = −1), where ε(t) = ±1 is the instantaneous value of the input signal at time t. There are three outcomes of the application of a PP signal: • If the synapse is in its − state at depth n, it may climb one level (n → n − 1) with probability αn. • If it is in its − state at depth n, it may alternatively cross over to the + state at the same level with probability βn. • If it is already in its + state at depth n, it may fall one level (n → n + 1) with probability γn. The level-resolved output signal of level n at time t: and the total output signal at time t: Dn(t) = Qn(t) − Pn(t) D(t) = Xn≥0 Dn(t) (1) (2) can be expressed in terms of the probabilities Pn(t) (resp. Qn(t)) for the synapse to be in the − state (resp. in the + state) at level n = 0, 1, . . . at time t = 0, 1, . . . The dynamical equations obeyed by the latter probabilities are reviewed in the Methods section, along with other details for the mathematically inclined reader. Before any meaningful signal is applied, the synapse is assumed to be in its default state. The latter state is defined as the stationary state reached by the synapse if subjected to a long random input signal. It is described in detail in the Methods section (see equations (16) to (21)). When a single potentiating pulse signal is applied at time t = 1 (that is, ε(1) = +1) to the synapse in its default state, the synapse will get polarized in response, and thus 'learn' the signal. Later on, under the influence of a random input signal for times t ≥ 2, it will 'forget' the PP signal, and return to its default state. Figure 3 shows plots of the reduced output signal D(t)/D(1) against time t for several values of the control parameter β. All subsequent figures refer to the parameter values β = 0.2, γ = 0.5, and ξs = ξd = 5 (see Methods section). From here on, we will refer to times where the synapse is subjected to a significant signal (ε(t) = ±1) as learning phases, and to times where the synapse is subjected to random input (ε(t) = 0) as forgetting phases. The late stages of the forgetting process are characterized by a universal power-law decay of the output signal: D(t) ∼ t−θ. This is known as power-law forgetting [7 -- 9]. The forgetting exponent θ = 1 + ξd ξs (3) (4) is always larger than unity and depends on the ratio of the dynamical and static lengths ξd and ξs. If the synapse were finite rather than infinite, and consisted of N levels, the power-law decay (3) would be exponentially cut off at a time τN ∼ exp(N/ξd) (5) which grows exponentially fast with the ratio of the number N of levels to the dynamical length ξd. We now describe the effect of a sustained input of potentiating pulses lasting for T consecutive time steps (ε(t) = +1 for 1 ≤ t ≤ T ) on the model synapse: in the following, this will be referred to as a long-term potentiating (LTP) signal. The synapse is again assumed to be initially in its default state. The learning and forgetting processes are qualitatively similar to the PP case described above, while novel 4 qualitative features emerge when the duration of the signal is long enough (βT ≫ 1). In this regime, the synapse gets almost totally polarized under the persistent action of the input signal. This saturation phenomenon is illustrated in Figure 4, which shows the output signal D(t) for several durations T of the LTP signal. The synapse slowly builds up a long-term memory in the presence of a long enough LTP signal, as the memorized signal moves to deeper and deeper levels. At the end of the learning phase (t = T ), the polarisation profile will have the form of a sharply peaked traveling wave, around a typical depth which grows according to the logarithmic law n(T ) ≈ ξd ln γT. (6) The total output signal then decays according to the universal power law (3), irrespective of the duration of the learning phase, driving home the universality of power-law forgetting. The above model provides a mechanism for the long-term memory storage due to use dependence in the Lymnaea synapse examined in [1]. With the tetanic stimulation acting as an LTP signal, this model shows that the synapse becomes fully polarized, the memory of the stimulating pulses being 'stored' in a deep level. However, another concept is needed to model the subsequent freezing of the synaptic dynamics: a major clue is provided by the fact that it is suggested in [1] that the activation of CaMKII in the presynaptic cell acts like a 'molecular switch'. Accordingly, we present a theoretical model of a stochastic and bistable switch in the following section. The effect of use-dependent synaptic potentiation: coupling to a stochastic and bistable switch In this section, we present a model of a biological switch to describe the role of CaMKII in the experiment reported in [1]. The switch can exist in two states, 'on' or 'off', which we label by the binary variable σ(t) = 1 or 0. Since natural processes are usually stochastic rather than deterministic, we incorporate this by postulating that the switch is on with probability Π(t), and off with the complementary probability 1 − Π(t). Thus: σ(t) = (cid:26)1 with probability Π(t), 0 with probability 1 − Π(t). (7) The main effect of this switch is to freeze the synaptic dynamics after adequate potentiation: we accordingly refer to the probability Π(t) as the freezing probability. Thus: • If the switch is off (σ(t) = 0), the synapse evolves as usual. This occurs with probability 1 − Π(t). • If the switch is on (σ(t) = 1), the forgetting process ('discharge') is frozen. This occurs with probability Π(t). More precisely, the synapse learns via (12)-(13) and forgets via (18) when the switch is off. When the switch is on, the synapse still learns via (12)-(13), but it does not forget at all. In the experiment, a minimum of seven action potentials is needed to activate the switch and freeze the dynamics: this suggests that the switch somehow responds to the saturation of the synaptic capacity, so that freezing never sets in for less than this number of action potentials. Also, a further tetanic pulse after a period of quietude is needed to restart the synaptic dynamics. We design the evolution of the freezing probability Π(t) accordingly: • If the synapse is within a learning phase (ε(t) = ±1 and ε(t − 1) = ±1), the freezing probability evolves according to the quadratic rule Π(t) = 1 − c(1 − Π(t − 1))2. (8) This rule ensures that the freezing probability increases with the number of action potentials applied, saturating quickly to Π = 1 and freezing the synaptic dynamics after a threshold number of these is reached. It is desirable that the fixed point of Π = 1 is superstable (see below), and the quadratic law (8) is the simplest non-linear law which ensures this. 5 • If the synapse is in a forgetting phase (ε(t) = 0), the freezing probability is itself frozen to its value inherited from the past: Π(t) = Π(t − 1). (9) This rule ensures that once frozen, the dynamics stay frozen and that the synapse stays potentiated, until a further action potential is applied. • If the synapse is at the first step of a learning phase (ε(t) = ±1 but ε(t − 1) = 0), the freezing probability is instantly reset to Π(t) = 0. (10) This ensures that the synaptic dynamics restart, as soon as an action potential is applied for the first time following a period of forgetting. Note that there is a 'soft' threshold in the experiment for the switch to kick in, in that a minimum of seven action potentials is required; as reported in [1], this phenomenon was usually seen to occur across a range of 7 to 14 action potentials. The freezing probability which models the switch dynamics needs to incorporate this soft threshold, for which superstability of the fixed point Π = 1 is desirable. This ensures that at the end of a sustained LTP signal of duration T , Π(T ) converges very rapidly to unity (more rapidly than exponentially), as soon as T exceeds a characteristic time T0, defined operationally by Π(T0) = 1 2 . The value of the characteristic time fixes the parameter c. We have then Π(T ) = 1 − exp(cid:18)− 2T −1 − 1 2T0−1 − 1 ln 2(cid:19) . (11) Figure 5 shows a plot of the freezing probability Π(T ) at the end of an LTP signal of duration T for several values of the characteristic time T0 in the realistic range of 5 ≤ T0 ≤ 9. In practice, as soon as Π(T ) is appreciably large, the switch kicks in stochastically -- and this can occur, as shown in Figure 5, over a range of signal durations. We now commence a global interpretation of the experiment. The synapse is assumed to be initially in its default state, with Π(0) = 0. It is then subjected to a sustained LTP signal of duration T1 (i.e., the application of T1 action potentials), and to a single action potential at a much later time (T2 ≫ T1). The synapse is subjected to a random input at all the other instants of time (ε(t) = +1 for 1 ≤ t ≤ T1 and for t = T2, else ε(t) = 0). In the regime where the number of action potentials T1 of the initial signal is larger than the charac- teristic time T0 of the switch, the freezing probability Π(T1) at the end of the LTP period is very high, i.e., very close to unity (see Figure 5). During this learning phase, the output signal D(t) grows progres- sively from D(0) = 0 to a large value D(T1). The high value of Π(T1) at the end of this phase typically freezes the synaptic dynamics, ensuring that this enhanced output signal is not discharged. When the next action potential is applied at time T2, the switch is turned off, and the synapse then relaxes via the full discharge of the stored, enhanced output signal. We now compare theory with experiment. Figure 6 shows a comparison between our theoretical predictions (upper panel) with sharp-electrode electrophysiology recordings of a VD4/LPeD1 synaptic pair (two lower panels). The theoretical prediction is meant to describe the average over many ensembles, while the experimental data are assumed to be typical. Since the experimental averages are well-behaved rather than subject to large fluctuations [1], a typical experimental output is representative of its average. On the theoretical side, the time unit for the discrete updates is consistently chosen to be the time interval between two successive applied APs, i.e., 100 ms. The black theoretical curve corresponds to 3 APs triggered during tetanic stimulation, which are insufficient to result in potentiation of a subsequent excitatory postsynaptic potential (EPSP) in the LPeD1 neuron (T1 = 3 ≪ T0, and so the switch remains off). The red theoretical curve corresponds to 11 APs, resulting in a potentiated response (T1 = 11 ≫ T0, so the switch is turned on and the synapse is frozen). The predicted pattern of peak heights (symbols) is rather robust, i.e., insensitive to model parameters, and provides a good overall description of the experimental recordings. 6 The last part of this section reflects the 'bistability' of the switch, i.e., its stability in one of two If the duration T1 of the initial LTP signal is comparable to the characteristic time T0, the states. synapse may exhibit two types of temporal behavior. It may behave as above for T1 = 11, i.e., stay frozen until the subsequent action potential unfreezes it at time T2. This occurs with probability Π(T1) (see Figure 5). The synapse may also remain unfrozen, so that the output signal decays almost entirely before the subsequent action potential sets in. This occurs with the complementary probability 1 −Π(T1). This bistable behavior is illustrated in Figure 7. We see from this figure that the difference between T1 and T0 provides a tunable parameter which determines how frequently the phenomenon described in the experiment in [1] is observed: in the upper panel the parameters are such that it is almost always observed, whereas in the lower panel it makes a much more random appearance. This parametrisation is useful, since it can form the basis of future experiments. If we assume that the characteristic time T0 is, say, inversely proportional to the concentration of kinase, this suggests that a threshold concentration can be identified for which a given number of action potentials will cause the short-term potentiation of the synapse. Discussion Our theoretical model of a biological switch coupled to a metaplastic synapse is able to provide an interesting framework for the interpretation of the experimental results of [1]. This novel form of synaptic potentiation exhibits characteristics of short-term potentiation, but also exhibits characteristics of long- term potentiation based on its time frame. While the enhanced output signal observed in the latter is attributable to long-term potentiation of the synapse via tetanic stimulation, the use-dependence of the synapse is explainable by the biological switch. We start with the depotentiated state of the synapse, where, experimentally, single action potentials triggered in VD4 elicit EPSP in LPeD1 of a non-potentiated amplitude. The application of repeated action potentials in the pre-synaptic cell however builds up long-term memory in the synapse, i.e., a potentiated EPSP in LPeD1. Meanwhile, during the tetanic stimulation, the freezing probability of the molecular switch (CaMKII) evolves according to (8) in response to the growing saturation of the synapse. If the number of action potentials is large enough, the switch is activated and synaptic dynamics are fully frozen. Synaptic dynamics are only restarted when the switch is turned off: this happens when the synapse is next 'used', and leads to the observed rapid decay back to a non-potentiated amplitude in LPeD1. Thus, the critical dependence of the onset of the decay on synapse use, rather than the time elapsed after priming, is explained by the model presented in this paper. It is useful to discuss some of the key assumptions made here before concluding. The level of descrip- tion of our model is sufficiently abstract that it does not claim to replicate intricate biological detail; its description is limited to probing the unusually long times of use-dependent synaptic potentiation in the Lymnaea synapse. From this point of view, the use of a model of long-term memory in metaplastic synapses is perfectly appropriate. This model embodies the idea that forgetting takes place via the expo- sure of the multi-level synapse to noise, from which the lowest synaptic levels are protected. This noise could refer to fluctuations in neural/synaptic activity or to background signals; what is clear is that it is ubiquitous and unavoidable. The model of a biological switch which we introduce depends both on the presynaptic cell and on the state of the synapse: it is turned on when the synapse is saturated in response to a series of action potentials, leading to the freezing of synaptic dynamics. It is turned off when the synapse is next 'used', i.e an activation potential is applied after an inert period. An enhanced output signal results, because of the discharge of accumulated memory at the synapse. The turning on and off of the switch is stochastic, rather than deterministic, given the nature of most natural processes: and it is bistable, since it can lead to two kinds of temporal behaviour at the synapse (with different probabilities, of course). Finally, since the experimental recordings do not show strong fluctuations [1], the output of a typical experiment can be meaningfully compared with the average output signal given by theory. 7 While the intact brain is composed of a significantly greater number of synapses with far more intricate connectivity patterns, the current model has taken a reductionist approach to understanding synaptic plasticity at the level of a single synapse. While previous forms of synaptic potentiation have been modeled, this novel form of use-dependent synaptic potentiation has not. Therefore, this study may not only be an important step in developing more complex models composed of multiple synapses, but also be important in guiding further research in understanding neuronal network function in intact Lymnaea brain. Methods The basic quantities used to describe the state of the synapse are the probabilities Pn(t) (resp. Qn(t)) for the synapse to be in the − state (resp. in the + state) at level n = 0, 1, . . . at time t = 0, 1, . . . These probabilities obey the following coupled linear equations, whose form is characteristic of Markov chains [10]: • ε(t + 1) = +1 (see Figure 2, left): Pn(t + 1) = (1 − αn − βn)Pn(t) + αn+1Pn+1(t), Qn(t + 1) = (1 − γn)Qn(t) + γn−1Qn−1(t) + βnPn(t). • ε(t + 1) = −1 (see Figure 2, right): Pn(t + 1) = (1 − γn)Pn(t) + γn−1Pn−1(t) + βnQn(t), Qn(t + 1) = (1 − αn − βn)Qn(t) + αn+1Qn+1(t). (12) (13) The transition probabilities of the model are assumed to decay exponentially with level depth n: αn = αe−(n−1)µd , βn = βe−nµd , γn = γe−nµd , where the dynamical length ξd = 1 µd (14) (15) measures the number of fast levels at the top of the synapse. The default state of the synapse is defined as its stationary state in the presence of a random input signal, defined by choosing at each time step ε(t) = (cid:26)+1 with probability 1 2 , −1 with probability 1 2 . (16) The dynamics of the synapse subjected to such a random input, referred to as a 'white-noise' random input in [2], is defined by averaging the linear dynamical equations (12)-(13) over both instances of ε(t) at each time step. The resulting average dynamics is formally labeled as ε(t) = 0. It has a simpler expression in terms of the sums and differences namely Sn(t) = Pn(t) + Qn(t), Dn(t) = Pn(t) − Qn(t), Sn(t + 1) = Sn(t) + 1 Dn(t + 1) = Dn(t) + 1 2(cid:0)γn−1Sn−1(t) − (αn + γn)Sn(t) + αn+1Sn+1(t)(cid:1), 2(cid:0)γn−1Dn−1(t) − (αn + 2βn + γn)Dn(t) + αn+1Dn+1(t)(cid:1). The default state of the synapse, defined as the stationary state of the above average dynamics, is characterized by the probabilities P st n = Qst n = 1 2 (1 − e−µs)e−nµs , (19) (17) (18) with µs = ln α γ . 8 (20) The default state is appropriately featureless and unpolarized, as it should be for a symmetric synapse. The corresponding static length ξs = 1 µs (21) gives a measure of the effective number of occupied levels in the default state. Acknowledgments A. M. thanks the Institut de Physique Th´eorique, where much of this work was carried out, for its customary gracious hospitality during her visits. References 1. Luk CC, Naruo H, Prince D, Hassan A, Doran SA, et al. (2011) A novel form of presynaptic CaMKII-dependent short-term potentiation between Lymnaea neurons. Eur J Neurosci 34: 569- 577. 2. Mehta A, Luck JM (2011) Power-law forgetting in synapses with metaplasticity. J Stat Mech P09025. 3. Faisal AA, Selen LPJ, Wolper DM (2008) Noise in the nervous system. Nature Reviews Neurosci 9: 292-303. 4. Fusi S, Drew PJ, Abbott LF (2005) Cascade models of synaptically stored memories. Neuron 45: 599-611. 5. Abraham WC, Bear MF (1996) Metaplasticity: The plasticity of synaptic plasticity. Trends in Neurosciences 19: 126-130. 6. Fischer TM, Blazis DEJ, Priver NA, Carew TJ (1997) Metaplasticity at identified inhibitory synapses in aplysia. Nature 389: 860-865. 7. Wixted JT, Ebbesen EB (1991) On the form of forgetting. Psychol Science 2: 409-415. 8. Wixted JT, Ebbesen EB (1997) Genuine power curves in forgetting: a quantitative analysis of individual subject forgetting functions. Mem Cognit 25: 731-739. 9. Brown MW, Xiang JZ (1998) Recognition memory: neuronal substrates on the judgement of prior occurrence. Prog Neurobiol 55: 149-189. 10. van Kampen NG (1992) Stochastic Processes in Physics and Chemistry. Amsterdam: North- Holland. Figure Legends 9 Figure 1. A representative electrophysiology trace showing the potentiation of the VD4/LPeD1 synapse following tetanic stimulation and its subsequent depotentiation. A tetanic stimulation of presynaptic neuron VD4 (at thin arrow) results in a compound excitatory postsynaptic potential (EPSP) in postsynaptic neuron LPeD1. A subsequently triggered action potential in VD4 (asterisk) results in an EPSP of greater amplitude than pre-tetanic stimulation (thick arrow). β 0 β 1 β 2 α 1 α 2 β 0 β 1 β 2 α 1 α 2 γ 0 γ 1 γ 0 γ 1 ε = +1 (LTP) ε = −1 (LTD) Figure 2. Schematic representation of the model of the internal synaptic structure. Arrows denote possible transitions in the presence of a potentiating pulse (PP, ε = +1, left panel) and of a depressing pulse (DP, ε = −1, right panel). Corresponding transition probabilities are indicated. In each panel, the left (resp. right) column corresponds to the − (resp. +) state. The model studied in this work is actually infinitely deep. After [2]. 1.2 ) 1 ( D / ) t ( D 0.8 0.4 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0 0 20 40 t 60 80 Figure 3. Plot of the reduced output signal D(t)/D(1) after a single PP input signal, against time t, for several β. After [2]. 10 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 ) t ( D 1 3 10 30 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 t Figure 4. Plot of the output signal D(t) against time t, for several durations T of the LTP signal. After [2]. T0=5 T0=7 T0=9 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 ) T ( Π 0 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 T Figure 5. Plot of the freezing probability Π(T ) at the end of an LTP signal, against its duration T , for three values of the characteristic time T0. The threshold for freezing is least for the black curve (T0 = 5), and most for the blue (T0 = 9): while, say, 8 action potentials will definitely cause the onset of freezing for the black curve (Π(8) = 0.997), it will only rarely do so for the blue one (Π(8) = 0.292). 11 ) t ( D 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0 3 APs 11 APs 20 40 60 t 80 100 120 140 Figure 6. An integrative figure showing the good qualitative agreement of theory and experiment. The two lower panels show sharp-electrode electrophysiology recordings of a VD4/LPeD1 synaptic pair. During the induction phase, three action potentials were triggered at ∼ 10 Hz. The synapse was allowed to remain quiescent for ∼ 5 s and when a subsequent action potential was triggered, the amplitude of the postsynaptic potential was similar to pre-tetanic stimulation. However, when eleven action potentials were triggered at ∼ 10 Hz, a potentiated response was observed after the same quiescent period of ∼ 5 s after stimulation. The upper panel shows the predictions of the theoretical model, also for three and eleven action potentials. 12 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 ) t ( D T1=7 > T0=5 unfrozen frozen 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 ) t ( D T1=T0=5 unfrozen frozen 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 t 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 t Figure 7. Plot of the two possible kinds of output signals D(t) generated by the protocol described in the text, against time t (T0 = 5, T2 = 50). Symbol sizes are proportional to the probabilities of each kind of behavior, i.e., Π(T1) for the frozen one and 1 − Π(T1) for the unfrozen one. Left: T1 = 7 is larger than T0 = 5, so that Π(T1) = 0.946 is very high. Right: T1 = T0 = 5, so that Π(T1) = 1 2 .
1707.01373	2	1707	2017-12-15T12:59:47	Looping and Clustering model for the organization of protein-DNA complexes on the bacterial genome	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.SC" ]	The bacterial genome is organized in a structure called the nucleoid by a variety of associated proteins. These proteins can form complexes on DNA that play a central role in various biological processes, including chromosome segregation. A prominent example is the large ParB-DNA complex, which forms an essential component of the segregation machinery in many bacteria. ChIP-Seq experiments show that ParB proteins localize around centromere-like parS sites on the DNA to which ParB binds specifically, and spreads from there over large sections of the chromosome. Recent theoretical and experimental studies suggest that DNA-bound ParB proteins can interact with each other to condense into a coherent 3D complex on the DNA. However, the structural organization of this protein-DNA complex remains unclear, and a predictive quantitative theory for the distribution of ParB proteins on DNA is lacking. Here, we propose the Looping and Clustering (LC) model, which employs a statistical physics approach to describe protein-DNA complexes. The LC model accounts for the extrusion of DNA loops from a cluster of interacting DNA-bound proteins. Conceptually, the structure of the protein-DNA complex is determined by a competition between attractive protein interactions and the configurational and loop entropy of this protein-DNA cluster. Indeed, we show that the protein interaction strength determines the "tightness" of the loopy protein-DNA complex. With this approach we consider the genomic organization of such a protein-DNA cluster around a single high-affinity binding site. Thus, our model provides a theoretical framework to quantitatively compute the binding profiles of ParB-like proteins around a cognate (parS) binding site.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Looping and Clustering model for the organization of protein-DNA complexes on the bacterial genome Jean-Charles Walter, Nils-Ole Walliser, Gabriel David, J´erome Dorignac, Fr´ed´eric Geniet, and John Palmeri Laboratoire Charles Coulomb, UMR5221 CNRS-UM, Universit´e de Montpellier, Place Eug`ene Bataillon, 34095 Montpellier Cedex 5, France Andrea Parmeggiani DIMNP, UMR5235 CNRS-UM, Universit´e de Montpellier, Place Eug`ene Bataillon, 34095 Montpellier Cedex 5, France Department of Molecular Biology and Lewis-Sigler Institute for Integrative Genomics, Princeton University, Princeton NJ 08544, USA Ned S. Wingreen Chase P. Broedersz∗ Arnold-Sommerfeld-Center for Theoretical Physics and Center for NanoScience, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universitat Munchen, D-80333 Munchen, Germany. (Dated: December 18, 2017) The bacterial genome is organized by a variety of associated proteins inside a structure called the nucleoid. These proteins can form complexes on DNA that play a central role in various bio- logical processes, including chromosome segregation. A prominent example is the large ParB-DNA complex, which forms an essential component of the segregation machinery in many bacteria. ChIP- Seq experiments show that ParB proteins localize around centromere-like parS sites on the DNA to which ParB binds specifically, and spreads from there over large sections of the chromosome. Recent theoretical and experimental studies suggest that DNA-bound ParB proteins can interact with each other to condense into a coherent 3D complex on the DNA. However, the structural organization of this protein-DNA complex remains unclear, and a predictive quantitative theory for the distribution of ParB proteins on DNA is lacking. Here, we propose the Looping and Clustering (LC) model, which employs a statistical physics approach to describe protein-DNA complexes. The LC model accounts for the extrusion of DNA loops from a cluster of interacting DNA-bound proteins that is organized around a single high-affinity binding site. Conceptually, the structure of the protein-DNA complex is determined by a competition between attractive protein interactions and the configura- tional and loop entropy of this protein-DNA cluster. Indeed, we show that the protein interaction strength determines the "tightness" of the loopy protein-DNA complex. Thus, our model provides a theoretical framework to quantitatively compute the binding profiles of ParB-like proteins around a cognate (parS) binding site. I. INTRODUCTION Understanding the biophysical principles that govern chromosome structure in both eukaryotic and prokary- otic cells remains an outstanding challenge [1–7]. Many bacteria have a single chromosome with a length three orders of magnitude longer than the cell itself, posing a daunting organizational problem. Owing to recent tech- nological advances in live-cell imaging and chromosome conformation capture based approaches, it is becoming increasingly clear that the DNA is not coiled like a sim- ple amorphous polymer inside the cell [8–10], but rather exhibits a high degree of organization over a broad range of lengthscales [11]. It remains unclear, however, how this spatial and dynamic organization of the chromosome is established and maintained inside living bacteria [12]. A ∗Electronic address: [email protected] host of Nucleoid-Associated Proteins (NAPs) have been shown to play a central role in the spatial organization of the bacterial chromosome [12–14]. Such NAPs bind to the DNA in large numbers, and by interacting with each other and with DNA in both sequence-dependent and sequence-independent manners they can collectively structure the DNA polymer and control chromosome or- ganization. In many bacterial species, the broadly conserved ParABS system is responsible for chromosome and plas- mid segregation [12, 15]. A central component of this system is the partitioning module, which is formed by a large protein-DNA complex of ParB proteins that as- sembles around centromere-like parS sites, frequently lo- cated near the origin of replication. The ParBS com- plexes can subsequently interact with ParA ATPases, leading to the segregation of replicated origins [16–23]. How is this ParBS partitioning module physically orga- nized on the DNA? ParB is known to bind specifically to parS, triggering the formation of a large protein-DNA cluster, which is visible as a tight focus in microscopy 2 model with short range interactions. On general statis- tical physical grounds, such a 1D model cannot be ex- pected to account for the formation of a large coherent protein-DNA complex, given physiological protein inter- action strengths [29]. Furthermore, the number of ParB proteins available in the cell is not sufficient to allow enrichment by simple 1D polymerization of ParB along DNA at genomic distances from parS as large as observed experimentally [25]. To resolve the puzzle of how ParB proteins organize around a parS site, we recently intro- duced a novel theoretical framework to study the collec- tive behavior of interacting proteins that can bind to a DNA polymer [29]. This model suggested that ParB as- sembles into a three-dimensional complex on the DNA, as illustrated in Figure 1a,b. Single molecule experiments provided direct evidence for the presence of 3D bridging interactions between two ParB proteins on DNA [30, 31]. We showed that a combination of such a 3D bridging bond and 1D spreading bonds between ParB proteins constitutes a minimal model for the condensation of ParB proteins on DNA into a coherent complex [29], consistent with the observation that ParB-GFP fusion proteins form a tight fluorescent focus on the DNA [15, 19, 24, 25]. The statistical properties of the 3D structure of ParB- DNA complexes determines the binding profile of ParB on DNA, which can be accurately measured in ChIP-Seq experiments. However, it is computationally demanding to simulate these binding profiles with the Spreading & Bridging model. The protein binding profiles can be eas- ily calculated analytically in the limit of strong protein- protein interactions, where the cluster of ParB on the DNA becomes compact with a corresponding triangu- lar distribution of ParB along DNA. The protein binding profiles can also be estimated in the limit of weak protein- protein interactions with the so-called Stochastic Binding model, where a sphere of high ParB concentration is as- sumed to exist within which a DNA polymer freely fluc- tuates [25] (see Figure 1c). The description of the average protein binding profile is thus similar to the return statis- tics of the polymer into the ParB sphere [32], suggesting a long range (power-law) distribution of ParB proteins along DNA. Importantly, however, neither of these two existing approaches provide a simple way of computing ParB binding profiles around parS sites over the full rele- vant range of system parameters. In addition, it remains unclear how the Spreading & Bridging model and the Stochastic Binding model relate to each other. Here, we propose a theoretical approach to describe the distribution of ParB proteins around parS sites on the DNA in terms of molecular interaction parameters and protein expression levels. To this end, we develop a simple model for protein-DNA clusters that explicitly accounts for the competition between the positional en- tropy associated with placing the loops on the cluster, which favours a looser cluster configuration, and both protein-protein interactions and loop closure entropy, which tend to favour a compact cluster. This Looping and Clustering model represents a reduced, approximate FIG. 1: Schematic illustration of two recent models pro- posed to describe the ParB partition complex (left) accom- panied with a typical distribution of ParB on extended DNA (middle), and the average distribution profile (right). The Spreading & Bridging model [29] is shown with (a) strong coupling JS → ∞, where thermal fluctuations cannot break the bonds between proteins such that all bridging and spread- ing interactions are satisfied, and (b) intermediate coupling where the energetic cost of breaking a spreading bond com- petes with the configurational and loop entropy. With the Looping and Clustering approach presented here, we propose a simple analytic description for this regime. (c) The Stochas- tic Binding model assumes a spherical region of high concen- tration of ParB around parS [25]. This model can be seen as taking the limit of the spreading bond strength to zero (JS → 0), and thus the formation of loops is not hampered by protein-protein bonds. In this limit, the binding profile can be described as the return of the polymer to an origin of finite size, such that the profile is given by P (s) ∝ (s + C)−dν , where d is the dimension, ν is the Flory exponent, and C is a constant. images of fluorescently labeled ParB [15, 19, 24, 25]. The propensity of ParB to form foci around parS has been exploited in recent studies, which used exogenous ex- pression of fluorescently labeled ParB along with parS insertion to label DNA loci for live-cell imaging [26, 27]. In the F-plasmid of Escherichia coli cells, each ParB fo- cus contains roughly 300 proteins, together representing 90% of all ParB present in the cell [25]. High-precision ChIP-Seq experiments on this system provide quantita- tive ParB binding profiles along the DNA, which are strongly peaked around parS with a broad decay over a distance of up to 13 kilobasepairs (kb), consistent with earlier observations [24, 28]. Various models have been introduced to explain the distribution of ParB along DNA around parS sites. An early study of the distribution of ParB proposed that ParB proteins spread from the parS sequence by nearest- neighbor interactions, forming a continuous filament-like structure along the DNA [28]. This model was termed the Spreading model. However, this is effectively a 1D (a)(b)(c): parS: DNA outside the cluster: DNA inside the cluster: ParB proteinP(s)sP(s)sP(s)~[s+C]-1.5J =J = 0SS0011parSparSP(s)s?Intermediate JS0parS: ParB bound to parSJS=1JS=0JS(a)(b)(c): parS: DNA outsidethecluster: DNA insidethecluster: ParB proteinP(s)sP(s)sP(s)~[s+C]-1.5J =J =0SS0011parSparSP(s)s?IntermediateJS0parS: ParB boundtoparS(a)(b)(c): parS: DNA outsidethecluster: DNA insidethecluster: ParB proteinP(s)sP(s)sP(s)~[s+C]-1.5J =J =0SS0011parSparSP(s)s?IntermediateJS0parS: ParB boundtoparSp(s)⇠(s+C)d⌫version of the full Spreading & Bridging model that incor- porates the key physical ingredients needed to provide a clearer understanding and at the same time greatly facil- itates calculations of the distribution profile of ParB (or other proteins that form protein-DNA clusters). Thus, our approach can be used to estimate molecular interac- tions between proteins from experimentally determined protein binding profiles. II. THE LOOPING AND CLUSTERING MODEL To theoretically describe the protein binding profiles of ParB on DNA, we first consider a DNA polymer of length L that can move in space on a 3D cubic lattice and with a finite number of proteins m. Since the number of ParB proteins in the protein-DNA cluster has been observed to include the vast majority of proteins in the cell [25], we employ a canonical ensemble with a fixed number of ParB proteins m in the ParB complex. These proteins are able to diffuse along the DNA. Importantly, in this model the DNA itself is also dynamic and fluctuates be- tween different three-dimensional configurations, which are affected by the presence of interacting DNA bound proteins. When proteins are bound to the DNA, they are assumed to be able to interact attractively with each other by contact interactions in two distinct ways: (i) 1D spreading interactions with coupling strength JS, defined as an interaction between proteins on nearest-neighbor sites along the polymer, and (ii) a 3D bridging interaction with strength JB between two proteins bound to sites on non-nearest neighbor-sites on the DNA, but which are positioned at nearest neighbor-sites in 3D space (see Fig- ure 1a,b). Thus, these bridging interactions couple to the 3D configuration of the DNA, while the 1D spreading in- teractions do not. Single-molecule experiments provide evidence for bridging bonds [30], with the bridging va- lency of a ParB protein limited to one [33, 34]. Even in this case where each protein can form two spreading bonds and a single bridging bond, the system has been shown to exhibit a condensation transition where the ma- jority of the proteins form a single large cluster that can be localized by a single parS site on the DNA [29]. While it is possible to perform Monte Carlo simulations of the Spreading & Bridging model for a lattice poly- mer, such simulations are computationally demanding. In this paper, we aim to provide a simple analytical de- scription for the average binding profile of proteins along the DNA (see right panels in Figure 1). With this aim in mind, we can simplify our description by realizing that the configurations of ParB proteins along the DNA are more sensitive to JS than to JB, for sufficiently large JB. While both spreading and bridging bonds are necessary for the condensation of all proteins into a single cluster, loop extrusion from the cluster is controlled by JS, and such loop extrusion strongly impacts the binding profile of proteins on the DNA. Indeed, a loop can be extruded from the protein-DNA cluster by breaking a spreading 3 bond, but without effecting the internal configuration of the bridging bonds. Therefore, we will assume that JB is sufficiently large to maintain a coherent 3D protein-DNA cluster, leaving JS as the main adjustable parameter in the model. A contiguous 3D cluster of proteins on DNA with loops can effectively be represented graphically by a discon- nected 1D cluster along the DNA, where connections in 3D between the 1D subclusters are implied, and domains of protein-free DNA within the disconnected 1D cluster represent loops that emanate from the 3D cluster (see Figure 1b,c). We can describe this system by a reduced model for the effective 1D cluster in which we account for the entropy of the loops that originate from the protein- DNA cluster. In this model, the spreading bond energy set by the parameter JS combined with the cost in loop closure entropy, competes with the positional entropy for placing loops on the cluster and will therefore play a cru- cial role in determining the binding profile of ParB on DNA around a parS site. To capture these effects, we propose the reduced Loop- ing and Clustering (LC) model, which offers a simplified description of 3D protein-DNA clusters with spreading and bridging bonds. In this model a loop is formed when- ever there is a gap between 1D clusters. We can make the connection between the gaps in the 1D cluster and the number of loops extending from the 3D cluster explicit by writing down the partition function for this model. The effective 1D cluster corresponding to a 3D cluster with m proteins and n loops has a multiplicity: Ωcluster = (m − 1)! (m − n − 1)!n! , (1) which counts the number of ways in which one can parti- tion m proteins into n + 1 subclusters in 1D. This multi- plicity leads to a positional entropy of mixing, Scluster = ln Ωcluster, for placing n loops at m − 1 possible posi- tions (in units of kB). Note, we do not explicitly include the number of ways in which the bridging bonds can be formed, since loop formation is not expected to substan- tially affect the possible configurations of bridging bonds. However, creating n loops will require breaking n spread- ing bonds, and the probability at equilibrium for this to occur will include a Boltzmann factor ∼ exp (−nJS), where the interaction energy is expressed in units of kBT . Within our simple description, we do not consider how the formation of a loop affects the full internal entropy of the protein-DNA cluster, but this can be expected to be a fixed number per loop that can be absorbed into JS. Furthermore, the loops that are formed are assumed to be independent, and thus contribute to the loop closure entropy (in units of kB) as [32]: n(cid:88) i=1 Sloop = −dν ln((cid:96)i) , (2) where d is the spatial dimension, ν is the Flory exponent, and the loop length is measured in units of the lattice spacing of the polymer a, which we take to be equal to the footprint of a ParB protein, e.g. 16 bp for the exogenous ParABS system of E. coli [25]. This entropy is obtained by considering both the loops formed within the protein cluster and the protein-free segment of DNA outside the cluster. Indeed, the number of configurations associated with loop i for a Gaussian polymer is given by z(cid:96)i(cid:96)−dν [32, 35], where z is the lat- tice coordination number. Therefore, there is also an ex- tensive contribution to the entropy given by kB(cid:96)i log(z). i However, when a loop of length (cid:96)i forms, the same length of polymer is removed from the DNA outside of the clus- ter, which also results in a reduction of the entropy by kB(cid:96)i log(z). Thus, there is a precise cancelation between the extensive contribution to the entropy associated with the loop inside the cluster and the extensive contribution due to effectively shortening the DNA outside the clus- ter [39]. It is now straightforward to write down the partition function of the Looping and Clustering model: 4 m−1(cid:88) (m − 1)! n=0 (m − n − 1)!n! [1 + exp(−J(cid:48)S)]m−1 (cid:90) (cid:96)max (cid:96)0 (cid:90) (cid:96)max (cid:96)0 d(cid:96)n(cid:96)−dν n d(cid:96)1(cid:96)−dν 1 ... exp(−nJS) . (3) ZLC = −→(cid:96)max→∞ where J(cid:48)S = JS + ln(cid:2)(cid:96)dν−1 0 (dν − 1)(cid:3) > JS is a renor- where Lj =(cid:80)j−1 malized loop activation energy that includes the cost in loop closure entropy). All lengths are measured in units of the protein's footprint a, (cid:96)0 is the lower cutoff of loop sizes and approximately represents the persistence length of DNA, and the bond interactions are in units of kBT . In the partition function, we conveniently set the upper boundary of integration, (cid:96)max, to infinity. Strictly speak- ing, the upper boundary for (cid:96)j should be L − (m + Lj), i=1 represents the total accumulated loop length before loop j. In practice, however, for chromo- somes, but arguably also for plasmids, L (cid:29) m and the probability to have a large loop is very small. For in- stance, if we consider the F-plasmid of E. coli with a length of 60 kbp, we have L = 3750 in units of the ParB footprint of 16 bp [25, 36]. For this system, Monte Carlo (MC) simulations (see Appendix A) of the LC model, with m = 100 reveal that the average cumulated loop size is ≈ 500 for small couplings (JS = 1) down to ≈ 25 for large couplings (JS = 4), which in both cases is much less than the DNA length. Thus, for biologically relevant cases it is reasonable to assume that the length of the DNA polymer is much larger than the footprint of the whole protein complex on the DNA. The LC model constitutes a simple statistical mechan- ics approach to describe how proteins assemble into a protein-DNA cluster with multiple loops. Next, we will include a parS site on the DNA, to which ParB proteins bind with a higher affinity than the other non-specific binding sites on the DNA. Our central aim is to compute the binding profile of ParB around this parS site. III. PROFILE OF PAR B FOR FIXED NUMBER AND SIZES OF LOOPS With our approach, we aim to quantitatively describe average ParB binding profiles, which are directly mea- surable by ChIP-Seq experiments. By fitting our model to such ChIP-Seq data, it would be possible to extract microscopic parameters such as the number of proteins in the ParB clusters and the protein-protein interaction parameters such as JS. In this section, we will describe how to compute the ParB binding profile around this parS site given a fixed number of loops with specified loop lengths. Then we will use the statistical mechanics framework provided above, to perform a weighted aver- age over all possible loop numbers and sizes to arrive at a simple predictive theory for the ParB binding profile. A. 1-loop binding profile It is instructive to start our analysis of ParB binding profiles by first calculating the probability of ParB occu- pancy as a function of distance from the parS site for the case of a protein-DNA cluster with only one DNA loop (n = 1) with fixed loop length (cid:96). We will assume a fixed number m of ParB proteins in this 1-loop protein-DNA cluster, and that one of these proteins is bound to the parS site at any time, as illustrated in Figure 2. Thus, to calculate the 1-loop ParB binding probability, P1(s, (cid:96)), at a distance s from parS, we need to consider all possi- ble configurations of proteins in the protein-DNA cluster subject to these constraints. First, we note that P1(s, (cid:96)) = 0 for s > m + (cid:96), be- cause the 1D cluster can maximally extend to a distance m + (cid:96), which occurs when the 1D cluster adopts a con- figuration that lies entirely on one side of the parS site. For a binding site at a distance s < m + (cid:96), the ParB 5 extruding from the cluster, i.e. an unoccupied site on the DNA within the protein cluster, as depicted in Fig- ure 2. The overbar here represents the complementary condition, and the expression above simplifies because P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s)) = 0 by construction. We can proceed to calculate the conditional probabil- ity, P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s)), by decomposing this contributions as a sum of probabilities of mutually exclusive configu- rations, which are conditioned by the location s(cid:48) of the right edge of the 1D ParB cluster denoted as "end(s(cid:48))" (see Figure 2). Then, we will take a continuous limit for the binding profile assuming m (cid:29) 1, and express the binding profile P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s)) in terms of probabilities, pend(s(cid:48)), for the condition describing the position of the right edge of the cluster. Thus, we first write the con- ditional probability P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s)) for s ≥ 0 (the case s < 0 is obtained by symmetry) as: m+(cid:96)(cid:88) (cid:90) m+(cid:96) P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s), end(s(cid:48)))pend(s(cid:48)), s(cid:48)=0 (5) P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s)) = ≈ ds(cid:48)Θ(s(cid:48) − s)pend(s(cid:48)). 0 Clearly, P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s), end(s(cid:48))) = 1 when s < s(cid:48) and zero otherwise, and thus we have replaced this term by the Heaviside step function Θ(s(cid:48) − s) and approximated the sum by an integral in the second line above. To calculate pend(s(cid:48)), it is convenient to introduce two subclusters, 1 and 2, with m1 and m − m1 proteins re- spectively (0 < m1 < m), such that cluster 1 with m1 proteins is overlapping with parS, as shown in Figure 2. Given two such subclusters, two equally likely situations can occur: (i) the leftmost cluster overlaps with parS, i.e. m − m1 + (cid:96) ≤ s(cid:48) < m + (cid:96) or (ii) the rightmost cluster overlaps with parS, i.e. 0 ≤ s(cid:48) < m1. This directly al- lows us to construct the conditional probability to find the right edge of the whole system, such that one of the m1 proteins in the cluster overlaps with parS: pend(s(cid:48)m1) = 1 2m1 [Θ(s(cid:48) − (m − m1 + (cid:96)))Θ(m + (cid:96) − s(cid:48)) (6) + Θ(m1 − s(cid:48))] , where the prefactor 1/2 comes from the equal probabili- ties to find the system in one of the two cases (i) and (ii). The conditions (i) and (ii) are encoded with a product of two unit step functions for (i) and a single step function for (ii). Each single realization can be obtained by shift- ing the position of the site in cluster 1 overlapping with parS and is equally likely, giving rise to an overall prefac- tor 1/m1. From this, we can obtain the full probability pend(s(cid:48)) by integrating over m1: FIG. 2: Schematic of the system with m proteins and a single loop of size (cid:96). The whole cluster is split in two parts: m1 is the number of proteins in the cluster that overlaps with parS and m − m1 is the number of proteins in the other cluster. The origin of the genomic coordinates is parS, the right edge of the system (RE) is located at the coordinate s(cid:48). We can divide the configurations into two equally likely cases: (i) the leftmost cluster overlaps with parS or (ii) the rightmost cluster overlaps with parS. FIG. 3: Protein occupation probability, P1(s, (cid:96)), for a site a genomic distance s from the parS site for different loop lengths (cid:96) and a fixed cluster size of m = 200 proteins. Solid curves represent analytic calculations from Eqs. (4), (8), and (??), and dashed curves represent data obtained from exact numer- ical enumeration for comparison to our analytical approxima- tions. We note that for (cid:96) = 0, we recover the triangular profile of the S&B model in the strong coupling limit JS → ∞ [29]. binding probability is reduced, either by configurations where this site is located on the DNA loop within the 1D cluster, or by states where the 1D cluster adopts a configuration around the parS site that does not extend to the binding site at s, placing this site outside the 1D cluster. To capture these effects, it is helpful to express P1(s, (cid:96)) in terms of conditional probabilities: P1(s, (cid:96)) = P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s))ploop(s) + P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s))ploop(s) (4) = P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s))ploop(s), where "loop(s)" represents a condition with probabil- ity ploop(s) corresponding to site s being part of a loop sparS0s'mm-msparS0s'mm-mREREcase (i)case (ii)ll1111``050100150200250300s00.20.40.60.81P1(s,l)l = 0l = 25l = 50l = 75l = 100050100150200250300s00.20.40.60.81P1(s,l)l=0l=25l=50l=75l=100`050100150200250300s00.20.40.60.81P1(s,l)l=0l=25l=50l=75l=100`````050100150200250300s00.20.40.60.81P1(s,l)l=0l=25l=50l=75l=100050100150200250300s00.20.40.60.81P1(s,l)l=0l=25l=50l=75l=100(cid:90) m−1 1 pend(s(cid:48)) ≈ dm1 pend(s(cid:48)m1)p(m1) Θ(m + (cid:96) − s(cid:48)) m(m − 2) = + Θ(1 − s(cid:48))(m − 2) + Θ(s(cid:48) − 1)Θ(m − 1 − s(cid:48))(m − 1 − s)] [Θ(1 − (m + (cid:96) − s(cid:48)))(m − 2) + Θ(m + (cid:96) − s(cid:48) − 1)Θ(s(cid:48) − (cid:96) − 1)(s(cid:48) − (cid:96) − 1) 6 (7) where we used p(m1) = 2m1/(m(m − 2)), since the number of configurations to place cluster 1 is ∝ m1 and m1 ∈ [1, m− 1]. Using this expression for the normalized probability distribution for the right edge of the 1D clus- ter to be positioned at s(cid:48), we can compute the conditional probability in Eq. (5): P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s)) ≈ Θ((cid:96) + m − s) (m − 2)m Θ((cid:96) − s + 1) + (m − 2)Θ((cid:96) + m − s − 1) (cid:20) (m − 2)2 (cid:18) (m − 2)2 2 + (m − 2)(m + (cid:96) − s)Θ(s − m − (cid:96) + 1) + (m + (cid:96) − s − 1)m − (cid:96) + s − 3)Θ(s − (cid:96) − 1) + Θ(1 − s) Θ(m − s − 1) + (m − 2)(1 − s) (s − m + 1)2 Θ(s − 1)Θ(m − s − 1) + 2 2 (cid:19) (cid:21) (8) To obtain the full 1-loop protein distribution (Eq. (4)), we first need to compute the probability for a site to not be part of loop, ploop(s) = 1 − ploop(s). (9) loop(s) = (cid:96)ρuni(m, (cid:96)) = (cid:96) If the loop density, ρ, were uniform, we would simply have puni m+(cid:96) , since the 1D cluster has a total length of m + (cid:96) with a single loop of length (cid:96). This uniform condition would only apply if we randomly choose (cid:96) sites to be part of the loop and ignore the re- quirement that all these loop sites need to be neighbor- ing. In a real cluster, however, we expect the loop density ρloop(s) to be higher in the bulk of the 1D cluster than close to the parS site or the edges, because fewer loops can be formed near the parS site or near the boundaries of the 1D cluster, at which a protein must be bound by construction. In particular, we expect the loop density, ρ(s, m, (cid:96)) ∝ min(s, (cid:96), m+(cid:96)−s), which measures the num- ber of ways a site at s can be part of a loop. This results in the normalized probability: ploop(s) = (cid:96)ρ(s, m, (cid:96)) Θ(m − (cid:96)) [(cid:96)2 + (cid:96)(m − (cid:96))] + Θ((cid:96) − m)(cid:0) m+(cid:96) (cid:96) min(s, (cid:96), m + (cid:96) − s) 2 (cid:1)2 (10) = In the normalization of this expression we distinguish the cases where the loop is either smaller or larger than the number of proteins in the cluster. With Eqs. (8) and (10), we have all the elements to calculate the 1-loop protein binding profile P1(s, (cid:96)) from Eq. (4). We investigated the binding profiles P1(s, (cid:96)) predicted by this model for a selected set of parameters, as shown in Figure 3. We only show s > 0 because of the sym- metry of the binding profile. It is instructive to contrast these profiles with the triangular profile (black curve) for a cluster with no loops. As expected, the addition of loops widens the profile, allowing the tail of the distribu- tion to extend out to a distance m + (cid:96). The widening of the binding profile is accompanied by a faster decay of the profile in the vicinity of parS, which crosses over to a flatter profile at distances s > (cid:96) due to additional contri- butions from configurations where the loop lies between the parS site and site s. Interestingly, for large loop size the profile can even become non-monotonic with a slight increase near the far edges of the domain. These features of the profile reflect the reduced loop density near parS and near the far edges of the cluster. Note that the integral under this curve remains constant for varying (cid:96) to conserve the number of particles in the cluster. To verify the validity of the analytical approximations leading to P1(s, (cid:96)), we used exact enumeration as a benchmark. Overall, the nu- merics (dashed lines) and the analytics (solid lines) are in good agreement for the 1-loop case, as shown in Figure 3. In the next section, we employ the approximate analyt- ical expressions obtained above, to efficiently calculate the full binding profile averaged over all configurations. 7 IV. PROTEIN BINDING PROFILES AND STATISTICS OF THE LOOPING AND CLUSTERING MODEL Above we defined the Looping and Clustering model and calculated the binding profile of proteins around a parS site for a cluster with 1 loop with fixed length. Real protein-DNA clusters, however, are expected to fluctuate with new loops forming and disappearing continuously. To capture such fluctuations, we will use the expressions for the binding profile of a static cluster with fixed loop length together with a statistical mechanics description of the LC model to obtain average binding profiles for dy- namic clusters, including an ensemble average over both the number of loops and the loop lengths. To obtain a full binding profile averaged over all real- izations, it is useful to investigate the statistics of loops that extend from the protein-DNA cluster and how these statistics are determined by the underlying microscopic parameters of the model. We start by considering the number of loops that extend from the cluster. Using the partition function in Eq. (3), it is possible to calculate the basic features of the LC model. For instance, the moments of the distribution of the number of loops are given by: (cid:104)nα(cid:105) = 1 ZLC nα (m − 1)! (m − n − 1)!n! e−nJS (11) From this, we find the the average loop number is given by: m−1(cid:88) n=0 (cid:35)n . (cid:34) (cid:96)1−dν 0 dν − 1 (cid:104)n(cid:105) = (m − 1) 1 1 + eJ(cid:48) S me−JS , (12) ∼m,J(cid:48) S(cid:29)1 (a) Average number of loops, (cid:104)n(cid:105), as a function of FIG. 4: spreading coupling strength JS obtained from Eq. (12). The different curves correspond to protein number m = 50 (black) m = 100 (red), m = 200 (green), and m = 400 (blue), with loop-size cutoff (cid:96)0 = 10. We observe an exponential decrease (cid:104)n(cid:105) ∝ e−JS in accordance with Eq.(12). Inset: Same data replotted with expected dependence of average loop number on m scaled out. (b) Average number of loops (cid:104)n(cid:105) as a func- tion of m for JS = 1, 2, 3, and 4. The behaviour is linear as expected from Eq.(12). The prefactor that determines the vertical shift between the different curves scales with e−JS , as demonstrated in the inset of panel (b). (c) Average loop prob- ability as a function of the genomic coordinate with m = 200 and L = 4000 for protein-DNA clusters with fluctuating loop number and loop lengths. Different curves correspond to dif- ferent spreading couplings JS = 1, 2, 3, and 4. The analytic approximation using Eq.(15) for the loop density, averaged over different loop configurations with the appropriate Boltz- mann factor as in Eq. (14) is compared to MC simulations (dashed curves) of the LC model (see Appendix A). where J(cid:48)S is the renormalized loop activation energy in- troduced in Eq. (3). The average loop number (cid:104)n(cid:105) is depicted in Figure 4a, demonstrating the exponential de- pendence on the spreading energy JS. In Figure 4b, we plot (cid:104)n(cid:105) as a function of the total number of proteins m in the protein-DNA cluster. Indeed, we observe the ex- pected linear dependence of the average loop number (cid:104)n(cid:105) on m over a broad range of parameters. These results illustrate how the average number of loops is determined by the competition between the effective renormalized loop activation energy, J(cid:48)S (including the cost in loop closure entropy), and the gain in the positional entropy of mixing (see Appendix B). The linear dependence on m in Eq. (12) reflects that loops are assumed to be able to form anywhere in the cluster in the Looping and Clustering model. However, one would naively expect that loops can only form at the surface of a 3D cluster, resulting in a dependence (cid:104)n(cid:105) ∼ m2/3 for a compact, spherical cluster. However, Monte Carlo simulations of the full S&B model have revealed that the protein-DNA clusters are not com- pact [29], but rather have a surface that scales almost linearly in m, close to the behavior of the simplified LC 012345JS10-1100101102103<n>m=50m=100m=200m=400012345JS10-310-210-1<n>/m(a)~exp(-JS)102m100101102103104105<n>JS=1JS=2JS=3JS=4102103m101102<n> eJS(b)~m0100200300400500s00.20.40.60.8ploop(s)JS=1JS=2JS=3JS=4(c)8 model presented here. The non-compact nature of the protein-DNA cluster is perhaps not surprising because each protein can form only one bridging bond. A closely related statistic is the average accumulated loop length (cid:104)(cid:96)(cid:105). From the LC partition function, we no- tice that the loop length is completely decoupled from the coupling constant JS and depends only on the up- per cutoff (cid:96)max. Therefore, the cumulated average loop length becomes: (cid:104)(cid:96)(cid:105) = (cid:96)max(cid:29)(cid:96)0 dν − 1 2 − dν (cid:96)2−dν max (cid:96)1−dν 0 (cid:104)n(cid:105), (13) where the factor in front of (cid:104)n(cid:105) represents the average length per loop. This prefactor induces a small algebraic dependence on (cid:96)max, in contrast to (cid:104)n(cid:105) which depends only on the lower cutoff (cid:96)0. The loop statistics of protein-DNA clusters are not eas- ily accessible in experiments. Instead, the most relevant results for which this model can provide insight come from ChIP-Seq experiments. These experiments yield data for the enrichment of bound ParB as a function of genomic position on the DNA, providing a measure of the average protein binding profile of ParB on DNA [24, 25]. In the LC model, the ParB density profile along DNA can be calculated from: exp(−nJS) (14) d(cid:96)n(cid:96)−dν n Pn (s,{(cid:96)i}) (cid:96)0 m−1(cid:88) n=0 PLC(s) = 1 ZLC (cid:90) ∞ (cid:96)0 (m − n − 1)!n! (m − 1)! (cid:90) ∞ d(cid:96)1(cid:96)−dν 1 ... FIG. 5: Binding profiles of ParB from Eq. (14) plotted ver- sus the genomic distance s to parS for (a) m = 100, (b) 200, and (c) 400. In Eq. (14), the loop size integrals were calcu- lated with a lower cutoff (cid:96)0 = 10 and an upper cutoff of 10(cid:96)0; summations were truncated at n = 15. The dark grey circles in panel (c) show experimental ChIP-Seq ParB enrichment data from the F-plasmid of E. coli extracted from [25]. The inset in panel (a) shows the binding profile of ParB versus ge- nomic distance s to parS for JS = 1, ν = 0.588 (self-avoiding polymer). The results in this inset were obtained by Monte Carlo simulations of the LC model (see SI for details). The data are plotted in log-log scale, we observe the power law decay PLC ∼ s−dν as expected in the limit of low JS, where the LC model becomes conceptually similar to the Stochastic Binding model. (cid:80) (cid:80)n where ZLC is given in Eq. (3). Here, Pn (s,{(cid:96)i}) repre- sents the multiloop ParB binding profile with n loops of length {(cid:96)i} = {(cid:96)1, ..., (cid:96)n}. For simplicity, we approximate this multiloop profile by the analytical 1-loop conditional probability, P1(s, (cid:96)loop(s)), with the loop length equal to the accumulated loop length, i.e. (cid:96) → i (cid:96)i, weighted by the loop probability ploop(s,{(cid:96)i}) ≈ i=1 (cid:96)iρ(s, m, (cid:96)i, (cid:96)). In the expression for the loop probability, ρ(s, m, (cid:96)i, (cid:96)) is defined as the contribution to the loop density of a loop of length (cid:96)i in a cluster of m proteins with a total ac- cumulated loop length (cid:96), and we neglected correlations between contributions from different loops. Furthermore, we approximate ρ(s, m, (cid:96)i, (cid:96)) by using a generalization of the 1-loop expression in Eq. (10), ρ(s, m, (cid:96)i, (cid:96)) ≈ i + (cid:96)i(m + (cid:96) − 2(cid:96)i)] + Θ(2(cid:96)i − ((cid:96) + m))(cid:0) m+(cid:96) min(s, (cid:96)i, m + (cid:96) − s) 2 Θ(m + (cid:96) − 2(cid:96)i) [(cid:96)2 (cid:1)2 . (15) In the analysis above, we aimed to capture the effects of multiple loops in a simple way by assuming statisti- 0100200300s00.20.40.60.81PLC(s)100101102103s10-510-410-310-210-1100PLC(s)(a)PLC ~ s-dν0100200300400500600s00.20.40.60.81PLC(s)JS = 1JS = 2JS = 3JS = 4(b)cal independence of the loops, and by using the analyti- cal 1-loop expressions to approximate the impact of loop formation on the loop density and the ParB binding pro- file of the protein-DNA complex. To test the validity of these approximations, we performed MC simulations of the complete LC model. We find that the numerically obtained average loop probability is in reasonable agree- ment with our approximate expression for the multiloop density, as shown in Figure 4c. Thus, despite the simplic- ity of our approach, the analytical model provided here captures the essential features of looping in protein-DNA clusters. The protein binding profile PLC(s) around a parS site is calculated by averaging the static binding profile for different total loop numbers and loop lengths using the Boltzmann factor (see Eq. (3)) from the Looping and Clustering model as the appropriate weighting factor. The resulting expression in Eq. (14) for the protein bind- ing profile of a protein-DNA cluster is the central result of this paper. We use this expression to compute bind- ing profiles for the full Looping and Clustering model, which are shown in Figure 5 as a function of the dis- tance s to parS for m = 100, 200, and 400. By con- struction, the site s = 0 corresponding to parS is always occupied, and thus P (s = 0) = 1 for all values of the spreading energy JS. This feature of the LC model cap- tures the assumed strong affinity of ParB for a parS bind- ing site. For JS = 4, the binding profile converges to a triangular profile, implying a very tight cluster of pro- teins on the DNA with almost no loops. The triangular profile in this case results from all the distinct config- urations in which this tight cluster can bind to DNA such that one of the proteins in the cluster is bound to parS, and therefore the probability drops linearly to 0 at s ≈ m. The same triangular binding profile was ob- served for the S&B model in the strong coupling limit JS → ∞ [29]. Interestingly, as JS becomes weaker, we observe a faster decrease of the binding profile near parS together with a broadening of the tail of the distribution for distances far from parS. This behavior results from the increase of the number of loops that extrude from the ParB-DNA cluster with decreasing spreading bond strength JS. The insertion of loops in the cluster allows binding of ParB to occur at larger distances from parS. Thus, the genomic range of the ParB binding profiles is set by smax ≈ m + (cid:104)(cid:96)(cid:105), where the average cumulated loop length (cid:104)(cid:96)(cid:105) is controlled by JS (see Eq. (13)) and m. These results illustrate how the full average binding pro- file is controlled by the spreading bond strength JS: the weaker JS, the looser the protein-DNA cluster becomes, which results in a much wider binding profile of proteins around parS. In the limit JS → 0, the LC model quanti- tatively reduces to the statistics of non-interacting loops, as shown in the inset of Figure 5. In this case, the bind- ing profiles exhibit asymptotic behaviour PLC(s) ∝ s−dν for large s, as in the Stochastic Binding model [25]. In- terestingly, we observe a weaker scaling PLC(s) with s at intermediate genomic distances, which we attribute to 9 FIG. 6: Scaling function of the ParB binding profile for dif- ferent total protein numbers m (same data as Figure 5). The data for different total protein numbers m are plotted ver- sus the dimensionless genomic distance s/m from parS (main graph: JS = 3, inset: JS = 2). the reduced loop density near parS (see Figure 4c). To investigate how the functional shape of the binding profile is determined by the total number of proteins in the cluster, we plot the binding probability versus the scaled variable s/m for m = 100, 200, and 400, as shown in Figure 6. For fixed JS, the data approximately collapse onto a single curve as a function of the scaled distance s/m. This implies that the functional shape of the ParB binding profile is largely determined by the spreading bond strength JS, while the number of proteins in the cluster determines the width of the profile. V. DISCUSSION The Looping and Clustering model introduced here allows us to access the average binding profile of pro- teins making up a large 3D protein-DNA complex. In our model, the formation of a coherent cluster of ParB proteins is ensured by a combination of spreading and bridging bonds between DNA bound proteins, which to- gether can drive a condensation transition in which all ParB proteins form a large protein-DNA complex local- ized around a parS site [29]. We do not assume, however, that this protein-DNA cluster is compact. Indeed, loops of protein-free DNA may extend from the cluster, which strongly influences the average spatial configuration of proteins along the DNA. In the LC model, the forma- tion of loops in the protein-DNA cluster is controlled by the strength of spreading bonds, i.e. the bond between proteins bound to nearest neighbor sites on the DNA. Specifically, for every protein-free loop of DNA that ex- tends from the cluster, a single spreading bond between two proteins within the cluster must be broken. Thus, if the spreading interaction energy, JS, is sufficiently small, thermal fluctuations will enable the transient formation and breaking of spreading bonds, thereby allowing mul- tiple loops of DNA to emanate from the protein cluster (See Figure 1). Conceptually, the spreading bond interaction deter- 012s/m00.20.40.60.81PLC(s)00.511.5s/m00.20.40.60.81PLC(s)m = 100m = 200m = 400JS = 2JS = 3mines how "loose" the protein-DNA cluster is, which directly impacts the ParB binding profiles. When JS is large, loop formation is unlikely, resulting in a com- pact protein-DNA cluster with a corresponding triangu- lar protein binding profile centered around parS [29]. At intermediate JS, the protein-DNA cluster becomes looser with the formation of loops, resulting in a binding pro- files that are more strongly peaked around parS but with far-reaching tails. Importantly, the LC model enables us to establish a link between the Spreading & Bridging model and the Stochastic Binding model [25]. The first used a microscopic approach based on the types of in- teractions between proteins on the DNA polymer, while the second employed a more macroscopic approach based on the polymer configurations around a dense sphere of proteins. In the limit JS → 0, the LC model is consistent with the Stochastic Binding model with a profile of the form [25] given by P (s) ∝ s−dν(inset Figure 5a). Thus, the LC model offers a description for a broad parameter regime, connecting two limits investigated in preceding studies [25, 29]. The Looping and Clustering model, which we intro- duce to calculate the binding profile of ParB-like proteins on the DNA, is a simple theoretical framework similar to the Poland-Scheraga model for DNA melting [37, 38]. An important difference in the LC model with respect to the homogeneous Poland-Scheraga model, is that trans- lational symmetry is broken due to the presence of a parS site at which a protein is bound with a high affinity. Thus, the protein-DNA cluster can adopt a wide range of configurations as long as one of the proteins is bound to the parS site. As a result, loops are effectively excluded in the vicinity of parS. The central new result of this work is a simple way of computing the protein binding profiles around such a parS site in terms of molecular interactions parameters. We show that the binding profiles predicted 10 by this model are sensitive to both the expression level of proteins and the spreading interaction strength, which directly controls the formation of loops in the protein- DNA cluster. The LC model predicts a profile in good quantitative agreement with binding profiles measured with ChIP-Seq on the F-plasmid of E. coli, as shown in Fig. 5c. Importantly, from this analysis we extract the spreading interaction strength JS ≈ 1kBT and the num- ber of proteins in the cluster m ≈ 400. Our results also have implications for experiments that employ fluorescent labelling of DNA loci by exogenous ParBs [26, 27]. Indeed, our model can be used to inves- tigate how the protein interaction strengths determine the 3D structure and mobility of the ParB-DNA cluster, as well as the tendency of multiple ParB foci to adhere to each other. This model thus provides an insightful quantitative tool that could be employed to analyze and interpret ChIP-Seq and fluorescence data of ParB-like proteins on chromosomes and plasmids. Acknowledgments This project was supported by the German Excellence Initiative via the program NanoSystems Initiative Mu- nich (NIM) (C.P.B.), the Deutsche Forschungsgemein- schaft (DFG) Grant TRR174 (C.P.B), and the National Science Foundation Grant PHY-1305525 (N.S.W.). We also thank J.-Y. Bouet for helpful comments on the manuscript. The authors acknowledge financial support from the Agence Nationale de la Recherche (IBM project ANR-14-CE09-0025-01) and from the CNRS D´efi In- phyniti (Projet Structurant 2015-2016). This work is also part of the program "Investissements d'Avenir" ANR- 10-LABX-0020 and Labex NUMEV (AAP 2013-2-005, 2015-2-055, 2016-1-024). [1] Dekker, J., Marti-Renom, M. A., & Mirny, L. A. (2013). Exploring the three-dimensional organization of genomes: interpreting chromatin interaction data. Na- ture Reviews Genetics, 14(6), 390-403. [2] Scolari, V. F., & Lagomarsino, M. C. (2015). Combined collapse by bridging and self-adhesion in a prototypical polymer model inspired by the bacterial nucleoid. Soft matter, 11(9), 1677-1687. [3] Dame, R. T., Tark-Dame, M., & Schiessel, H. (2011). A physical approach to segregation and folding of the Caulobacter crescentus genome. Molecular microbiology, 82(6), 1311-1315. [4] Jun, S., & Mulder, B. (2006). Entropy-driven spatial organization of highly confined polymers: lessons for the bacterial chromosome. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 103(33), 12388-12393. [5] Emanuel, M., Radja, N. H., Henriksson, A., & Schies- sel, H. (2009). The physics behind the larger scale or- ganization of DNA in eukaryotes. Physical biology, 6(2), 025008. [6] Marenduzzo, D., Micheletti, C., & Cook, P. R. (2006). Entropy-driven genome organization. Biophysical jour- nal, 90(10), 3712-3721. [7] Mirny, L. A. (2011). The fractal globule as a model of chromatin architecture in the cell. Chromosome research, 19(1), 37-51. [8] Umbarger, M. A., Toro, E., Wright, M. A., Porreca, G. J., Bau, D., Hong, S. H., & Shapiro, L. (2011). The three- dimensional architecture of a bacterial genome and its alteration by genetic perturbation. Molecular cell, 44(2), 252-264. [9] Le, T. B., Imakaev, M. V., Mirny, L. A., & Laub, M. T. (2013). High-resolution mapping of the spatial orga- nization of a bacterial chromosome. Science, 342(6159), 731-734. [10] Viollier, P. H., Thanbichler, M., McGrath, P. T., West, L., Meewan, M., McAdams, H. H., & Shapiro, L. (2004). Rapid and sequential movement of individual chromoso- mal loci to specific subcellular locations during bacterial DNA replication. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 101(25), 9257-9262. [11] Lagomarsino, M. C., Esp´eli, O., & Junier, I. (2015). From structure to function of bacterial chromosomes: Evo- lutionary perspectives and ideas for new experiments. FEBS letters, 589(20PartA), 2996-3004. [12] Wang, X., Llopis, P. M., & Rudner, D. Z. (2013). Organi- zation and segregation of bacterial chromosomes. Nature Reviews Genetics, 14(3), 191-203. [13] Dillon, S. C., & Dorman, C. J. (2010). Bacterial nucleoid- associated proteins, nucleoid structure and gene expres- sion. Nature Reviews Microbiology, 8(3), 185-195. [14] Dame, R. T. (2005). The role of nucleoid?associated pro- teins in the organization and compaction of bacterial chromatin. Molecular microbiology, 56(4), 858-870. [15] Mohl, D. A., & Gober, J. W. (1997). Cell cycle-dependent polar localization of chromosome partitioning proteins in Caulobacter crescentus. Cell, 88(5), 675-684. [16] Lim, H. C., Surovtsev, I. V., Beltran, B. G., Huang, F., Bewersdorf, J., & Jacobs-Wagner, C. (2014). Evidence for a DNA-relay mechanism in ParABS-mediated chro- mosome segregation. Elife, 3, e02758. [17] Banigan, E. J., Gelbart, M. A., Gitai, Z., Wingreen, N. S., & Liu, A. J. (2011). Filament depolymerization can explain chromosome pulling during bacterial mito- sis. PLoS Comput Biol, 7(9), e1002145. [18] Ptacin, J. L., Lee, S. F., Garner, E. C., Toro, E., Eckart, M., Comolli, L. R., & Shapiro, L. (2010). A spindle-like apparatus guides bacterial chromosome segregation. Na- ture cell biology, 12(8), 791-798. [19] Le Gall, A., Cattoni, D. I., Guilhas, B., Mathieu- Demazi`ere, C., Oudjedi, L., Fiche, J. B., & Nollmann, M. (2016). Bacterial partition complexes segregate within the volume of the nucleoid. Nature Communications, 7. [20] Walter, J. C., Dorignac, J., Lorman, V., Rech, J., Bouet, J. Y., Nollmann, M., Palmeri, J., Parmeggiani A. & Ge- niet, F. (2017). Surfing on protein waves: proteophoresis as a mechanism for bacterial genome partitioning. Phys- ical Review Letters 119(2), 028101. [21] Vecchiarelli, A. G., Neuman, K. C., & Mizuuchi, K. (2014). A propagating ATPase gradient drives transport of surface-confined cellular cargo. Proceedings of the Na- tional Academy of Sciences, 111(13), 4880-4885. [22] Jindal, L., & Emberly, E. (2015). Operational principles for the dynamics of the in vitro ParA-ParB system. PLOS Comput Biol, 11(12), e1004651. [23] Surovtsev, I. V., Campos, M., & Jacobs-Wagner, C. (2016). DNA-relay mechanism is sufficient to explain ParA-dependent intracellular transport and patterning of single and multiple cargos. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 113(46), E7268-E7276. [24] Breier, A. M., & Grossman, A. D. (2007). Whole?genome analysis of the chromosome partitioning and sporulation protein Spo0J (ParB) reveals spreading and origin?distal sites on the Bacillus subtilis chromosome. Molecular mi- crobiology, 64(3), 703-718. [25] Sanchez, A., Cattoni, D. I., Walter, J. C., Rech, J., Parmeggiani, A., Nollmann, M., & Bouet, J. Y. (2015). Stochastic self-assembly of ParB proteins builds the bac- terial DNA segregation apparatus. Cell systems, 1(2), 163-173. [26] Chen, B., Guan, J., & Huang, B. (2016). Imaging specific genomic DNA in living cells. Annual review of biophysics, 45, 1-23. 11 [27] Saad, H., Gallardo, F., Dalvai, M., Tanguy-le-Gac, N., Lane, D.,& Bystricky, K. (2014). DNA dynamics during early double-strand break processing revealed by non- intrusive imaging of living cells. PLoS Genet, 10(3), e1004187. [28] Rodionov, O., Lobocka, M., & Yarmolinsky, M. (1999). Silencing of genes flanking the P1 plasmid centromere. Science, 283(5401), 546-549. [29] Broedersz, C. P., Wang, X., Meir, Y., Loparo, J. J., Rud- ner, D. Z., & Wingreen, N. S. (2014). Condensation and localization of the partitioning protein ParB on the bac- terial chromosome. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(24), 8809-8814. [30] Graham, T. G., Wang, X., Song, D., Etson, C. M., van Oijen, A. M., Rudner, D. Z., & Loparo, J. J. (2014). ParB spreading requires DNA bridging. Genes & development, 28(11), 1228-1238. [31] Taylor, J. A., Pastrana, C. L., Butterer, A., Pernstich, C., Gwynn, E. J., Sobott, F., ... & Dillingham, M. S. (2015). Specific and non-specific interactions of ParB with DNA: implications for chromosome segregation. Nu- cleic acids research, 43(2), 719-731. [32] Gennes, P. G. D. (1979). Scaling concepts in polymer physics. [33] Leonard, T. A., Butler, P. J., & Lowe, J. (2005). Bacterial chromosome segregation: structure and DNA binding of the Soj dimer?a conserved biological switch. The EMBO journal, 24(2), 270-282. [34] Fisher, G. L., Pastrana, C. L., Higman, V. A., Koh, A., Taylor, J. A., Butterer, A., & Moreno-Herrero, F. (2017). The C-Terminal Domain Of ParB Is Critical For Dy- namic DNA Binding And Bridging Interactions Which Condense The Bacterial Centromere. bioRxiv, 122986. [35] Hanke, A., & Metzler, R. (2003). Entropy loss in long- distance DNA looping. Biophysical journal, 85(1), 167- 173. [36] Bouet, J. Y., & Lane, D. (2009). Molecular basis of the supercoil deficit induced by the mini-F plasmid partition complex. Journal of Biological Chemistry, 284(1), 165- 173. [37] Poland, D., & Scheraga, H. A. (1970). Theory of helix- coil transitions in biopolymers. [38] Everaers, R., Kumar, S., & Simm, C. (2007). Unified description of poly- and oligonucleotide DNA melting: Nearest-neighbor, Poland-Sheraga, and lattice models. Physical Review E, 75(4), 041918. [39] Although this reasoning is not strictly true for self- avoiding polymers, it does hold if we adopt the usual ap- proximation used in the Poland-Scheraga model for DNA melting that self-avoidance acts only within individual loops Appendix A: Monte Carlo simulations and numerical integration procedures 1. Monte Carlo procedure Using the partition function, we can formulate an effec- tive 1D Hamiltonian for the LC model, which explicitly accounts for the balance between spreading bonds and loop entropy: 12 2. Numerical integration To evaluate the binding profile PLC(s), we proceeded as follows. We carried out the evaluation of the simplified expression in Eq. (14) using numerical summation and integration. We truncated the summation at n = 15, instead of going up to m− 1, based on the corresponding average number of loops of Fig. 5. Finally, we introduced an upper cutoff for the loop-length, (cid:96)max = 100, instead of going up to infinity. We confirmed that shape of the binding profiles does not change significantly for higher values of (cid:96)max = 100. The numerical evaluation of the multidimensional in- tegrals in Eq. (14) have been performed with an accuracy and precision of respectively 2 and 3 effective digits in the final results. We have carried out convergence tests of the curve shapes in order to assess our parameters choice and rule out numerical instabilities. All computations have been performed by routines written in the Wolfram Lan- guage and executed by the Mathematica software suite (version 10 and 11). Appendix B: Formal connection between the LC model and a Lattice Gas with renormalized coupling For m and n (cid:29) 1 (thermodynamic limit), we can for- mulate a saddle point approximation to evaluate the par- tition function and (cid:104)n(cid:105), by approximating the entropic (factorial) term in Z (Eq.(11)) using the standard en- tropy of mixing for placing n loops on m−1 possible sites. This approach gives physical insight into how the loop entropy contributes to a renormalized protein-protein in- teraction and how the competition between this renor- malized interaction and the entropy of mixing controls (cid:104)n(cid:105). Taking the thermodynamic limit leads to a parti- tion function: (cid:90) ∞ 0 Z(cid:48) = dρ(cid:96) exp [−(m − 1)Feff (ρ(cid:96))] , (B1) where ρ(cid:96) = n/(m − 1) is the concentration of loops (0 ≤ ρ(cid:96) ≤ 1) and Feff (ρ(cid:96)) = ρ(cid:96)J(cid:48)S + {[1 − ρ(cid:96)] ln[1 − ρ(cid:96)] + ρ(cid:96) ln[ρ(cid:96)]} (B2) an effective free energy where J(cid:48)S = JS +ln α0 is a loop ac- tivation energy renormalized by the cost in loop entropy with α0 = (cid:96)dν−1 (dν − 1). In the limit m → ∞, the ap- proximate partition function Z(cid:48) becomes exact and can be evaluated exactly in the saddle point approximation by minimizing Feff . The solution, ρSP, to the saddle point equation, dFeff (ρ(cid:96))/dρ(cid:96) = 0, is 0 ρSP = 1 1 + eJ(cid:48) S . (B3) The entropic contribution to Feff (second term) vanishes at ρ(cid:96) = 0 and 1, and reaches a minimum at ρ(cid:96) = 1/2, FIG. 7: The binding profile obtained with the analytic ap- proach (symbols) are compared to MC simulations (dashed lines) for m = 100, (cid:96)0 = 10, and JS = 1, 2, 3 and 4. L−1(cid:88) i=1 HLC = −JS n(cid:88) i=1 φiφi+1 + dν ln((cid:96)i + (cid:96)0) . (A1) This effective Hamiltonian is useful to perform Monte Carlo simulations of the model as a benchmark for the approximations performed in the analytical approach (see Fig.7). The proteins are modelled as particles that bind/unbind onto sites of a one-dimensional lattice with free boundary conditions. The lattice size L = 4000 is chosen to prevent finite size effect for the range of pro- teins considered. Note that, in these MC simulations, the total size of the loops is limited to L − m. Metropolis rules: The simulations are performed with the standard 1. Propose a move of a particle randomly chosen to a random empty site of the lattice (conserved or- der parameter). A MC iteration step consists of m attempts of move. 2. Calculate the difference of energy ∆H = Hf − Hi between final and initial configurations. 3. If ∆H < 0, the move is accepted with proba- bility 1, otherwise it is accepted with probability exp(−β∆H). The system is set initially with all particles in a single cluster (JS = ∞), and then thermalized to the actual JS of the simulations ranging from 1 to 4 (see Fig. 7). The sampling starts after thermalization of the system (40000 MC iterations). A sampling of the systems configuration is performed every 100 MC iterations. All MC averages have been performed over 107 configurations, ν = 0.588, L = 4000 and (cid:96)0 = 10. The numerical results of this Monte Carlo simulation are in good agreement with our approximate analytic results, as shown in Fig. 7. 0100200300s00.20.40.60.81PLC(s)JS=1JS=2JS=3JS=4(a)m = 100which is the exact result for ρSP at vanishing renormal- ized loop activation energy J(cid:48)S because the entropy of mixing is then maximized. For J(cid:48)S > 0, ρSP decreases (cid:48) from 1/2 to vanish in the limit J(cid:48)S → ∞ as ρSP → e−J S . In this limit only the no and one loop states contribute and the asymptotic behavior can be simply obtained by a series expansion of the partition sum and the correspond- ing expression for (cid:104)n(cid:105). The saddle point result leads to nSP = m − 1 1 + eJ(cid:48) S , (B4) 13 which turns out to be the exact result, thanks to compen- sating errors, for (cid:104)n(cid:105) for finite m (which can be obtained by differentiating the exact Z with respect to JS, see Eq.(12)). For example, for (cid:96)0 = 10, d = 3, and ν = 0.588, α0 = 4.437 and ln(α0) = 1.49, which is not negligible if JS = O(1).
1506.08168	2	1506	2015-11-24T18:57:28	Shaping the Growth Behaviour of Biofilms Initiated from Bacterial Aggregates	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.CB" ]	Bacterial biofilms are usually assumed to originate from individual cells deposited on a surface. However, many biofilm-forming bacteria tend to aggregate in the planktonic phase so that it is possible that many natural and infectious biofilms originate wholly or partially from pre-formed cell aggregates. Here, we use agent-based computer simulations to investigate the role of pre-formed aggregates in biofilm development. Focusing on the initial shape the aggregate forms on the surface, we find that the degree of spreading of an aggregate on a surface can play an important role in determining its eventual fate during biofilm development. Specifically, initially spread aggregates perform better when competition with surrounding unaggregated bacterial cells is low, while initially rounded aggregates perform better when competition with surrounding unaggregated cells is high. These contrasting outcomes are governed by a trade-off between aggregate surface area and height. Our results provide new insight into biofilm formation and development, and reveal new factors that may be at play in the social evolution of biofilm communities.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Shaping the Growth Behaviour of Biofilms Initiated from Bacterial Aggregates Gavin Melaugh,1 Jaime Hutchison,2 Kasper Nørskov Kragh,3 Yasuhiko Irie,4, 5 Aled Roberts,4 Thomas Bjarnsholt,3, 6 Stephen P. Diggle,4 Vernita D. Gordon,2 and Rosalind J. Allen1 1School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, James Clerk Maxwell Building, Peter Guthrie Tait Road, Edinburgh, EH9 3FD 2Center for Nonlinear Dynamics and Department of Physics, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas 78712-1199 3Department of International Health, Immunology and Microbiology, Faculty Of Health Sciences, University of Copenhagen, DK-2200 Copenhagen 4School of Life Sciences, Centre for Biomolecular Sciences, University of Nottingham, University Park, Nottingham NG7 2RD 5Department of Biology & Biochemistry, University of Bath, Claverton Down, Bath BA2 7AY 6Department for Clinical Microbiology, University of Copenhagen, DK-2100 Copenhagen Bacterial biofilms are usually assumed to originate from individual cells deposited on a surface. However, many biofilm-forming bacteria tend to aggregate in the planktonic phase so that it is possible that many natural and infectious biofilms originate wholly or partially from pre-formed cell aggregates. Here, we use agent-based computer simulations to investigate the role of pre-formed aggregates in biofilm development. Focusing on the initial shape the aggregate forms on the surface, we find that the degree of spreading of an aggregate on a surface can play an important role in determining its eventual fate during biofilm development. Specifically, initially spread aggregates perform better when competition with surrounding unaggregated bacterial cells is low, while initially rounded aggregates perform better when competition with surrounding unaggregated cells is high. These contrasting outcomes are governed by a trade-off between aggregate surface area and height. Our results provide new insight into biofilm formation and development, and reveal new factors that may be at play in the social evolution of biofilm communities. INTRODUCTION Surface-attached communities known as biofilms are believed to be the predominant mode of existence for bac- teria in many environmental settings [1]. Understanding how biofilms establish and grow is also clinically impor- tant given their ubiquity in medical implant infections [2], chronic wounds [3], and in the respiratory tracts of cystic fibrosis patients [4]. In the clinical context, biofilm com- munities often show enhanced virulence [5], resistance to antibiotics [6], and resistance to the host immune system [7]. These features may be associated with the spatial structure of the biofilm, which not only affects material transport, e.g., penetration of nutrients/antibiotics, but is also associated with differences in metabolism and gene expression among cells within the community [8, 9]. In the canonical picture of biofilm development, indi- vidual cells land on a surface, attach and proliferate to form first micro-colonies and later 3-dimensional struc- tures [10]. However, bacteria are also known to form dense aggregated clumps when they are grown in liquid (planktonic phase) [11 -- 13]. Moreover, cells often disperse from existing biofilms as clumps of aggregated cells. Thus it is very likely that when a biofilm forms, some cells may arrive on the surface already in an aggregated state. In support of this view, evidence exists for the seeding of in- fections by pathogenic bacteria already in an aggregated state [14, 15], and bacterial aggregates are abundant in cystic fibrosis [4, 5] and tuberculosis [16] infections. Having arrived on the surface, e.g., a plant leaf [17], a surgical implant [2] or an industrial component [18], it is to be expected that cells within a bacterial aggregate will have to compete during biofilm development, both with other aggregates and with initially non-aggregated cells, to which they may or may not be genetically related. We take a first step towards understanding the role of pre-formed aggregates in biofilm development by investi- gating this competitive process, using agent-based simu- lations. Such simulations, in which the spatial structure of a biofilm emerges from local interactions between in- dividual cells, have become a staple tool for investigating biofilm structure and dynamics [19 -- 21], as well as so- cial evolutionary aspects of biofilm development [22, 23]. Using this approach, we determine how a pre-existing aggregate of bacteria impacts the spatial structure of a biofilm, both in the presence and absence of competing unaggregated bacterial cells. Our main focus here is on the role of the initial shape of the aggregate. It is well known that bacterial inter- actions with a surface depend on features such as extra- cellular polymeric substances (EPS), presence of cell sur- face appendages (such as pili), and cell surface charge, which are species- and strain-dependent [24]. Moreover, soft-matter science has established that the nature of material-surface interactions can drastically affect the shape of fluid or semi-fluid droplets on surfaces [25]. It is therefore reasonable to suppose that in some circum- stances, bacterial aggregates will spread out in contact with a surface, while in other scenarios, aggregates will adopt a more compact configuration. Here we investi- gate the biological consequences of aggregate shape in the seeding of biofilm growth. arXiv:1506.08168v2 [physics.bio-ph] 24 Nov 2015 2 gated cells has been suggested to be a stepping stone in the evolution of multicellularity [26, 27] Our study highlights the effects of nutrient gradients and bacterial aggregate shape on long-term biofilm devel- opment. Our work reveals that these factors alone can produce a trade-off between nutrient access and compe- tition, with the balance between these factors depending sensitively on aggregate shape. While the link between biofilm spatial structure and nutrient access has been highlighted in many other studies [8, 23, 28 -- 30], our work is the first to focus on the role of preformed aggregates in this context. Our study should help to decipher the role of pre-formed aggregates in biofilm infections. More generally, our findings emphasise the need to consider pre-formed aggregates in our current understanding of biofilm development. METHODS In this study, we use agent-based computer simula- tions to model the growth of a biofilm on a surface, start- ing from initial configurations of bacterial cells like those shown in Figure 1(a). In our simulations, an initial ag- gregate of cells (shown in green in Figure 1(a)), adopting a particular shape, seeds an inert surface, and may com- pete with surrounding unaggregated cells (red in Figure 1(a)). Note that the red and green bacterial cells differ only in the manner in which they are initially arranged on the surface. At the start of our simulations, the "red" bacteria are distributed at random across those parts of the surface not occupied by the aggregate (see Sections S1 to S5). To vary the extent of competition between the aggregated and unaggregated cells, we varied the initial cell density (number of cells per unit length of surface) of the unaggregated "red" cells (see Sections S1 to S5). As a control, we also ran simulations in which the aggregate grew in the absence of the unaggregated cells. The focus of this work is on the shape of the initial cell aggregate. Figure 1(a) illustrates three different sce- narios, in which the cell aggregate adopts a compact rounded shape (top), spreads out on the surface (bot- tom), or adopts an intermediate shape (middle). In each scenario, the dimensions of the aggregate are adjusted so that the number of cells within the aggregate remains the same (see Sections S1 and S2). Aggregate Shape Characteristation To characterise quantitatively the aggregate shapes in the different scenarios shown in Figure 1(a), we define the "aggregate-surface angle" θ, which is the angle that the initial aggregate makes with the flat surface. A small value of θ (θ → 0◦) describes an initial aggregate config- uration that is spread on the surface, whereas a large value of θ (θ → 180◦) describes an aggregate that is rounded. Given that the total number of cells in the FIG. 1. Our simulation set-up. (a) Schematic representation of bacterial aggregates (green) which are initially spread on a surface to varying extents. The schematic also shows sur- rounding, competing, unaggregated cells (red). Top- Rounded aggregate, θ = 180o; Middle- Semi-spread aggregate, θ = 90◦; Bottom- Spread aggregate with θ → 0◦. Note that the size of the aggregates (in terms of number of bacteria) is approxi- mately equal. (b) Growth of the spread (θ = 5o), semi-spread (θ = 90◦), and rounded aggregate (θ = 180◦) populations over the course of our simulations in the absence (ρ = 0 cell µm−1) and presence of competition (ρ = 0.5 cell µm−1). For clarity the error bars, representing the standard deviations, are only shown for the final data points. The standard deviations at these points are maximal. Simulating the development of biofilms initiated from initially spread or rounded aggregates, we find that the initial configuration of a bacterial aggregate on a sur- face is crucial in determining its eventual fate within the biofilm. In the absence of competitor cells on the surface, aggregates that maximise the extent to which they initially spread on the surface perform better than rounded ones because their initial access to nutrients (in the surrounding media) is greater. However when faced with strong competition from neighbouring unaggregated cells, initially rounded aggregates perform better at long times, despite the fact that the rounded aggregate shape has a smaller surface area and hence a reduced expo- sure to nutrients. Importantly, we show that in an ini- tially rounded aggregate, cells at the top of the aggregate proliferate at the expense of cells in the aggregate cen- tre. This has interesting possible consequences for social evolution given that cooperation within clumps of aggre- Spread, no competition Spread, high competition Semi-spread, no competition Semi-spread, high competition Rounded, no competition Rounded, no competition 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 time [h] 16000 14000 12000 10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 0 population of aggregate cells, N initial aggregate is fixed, θ also encapsulates an interplay between the initial surface coverage of the aggregate and its initial height; with increasing θ, the surface coverage decreases whereas height increases. In soft matter sci- ence, an analogous parameter is often used to describe wetting interactions between liquid droplets and surfaces [25]. A similar approach has recently been applied to the surface-spreading behaviour of eukaryotic cell aggregates [31]. From a phenotypic perspective, θ is related to the nature of the interactions between cells in the aggregate and between cells and the surface, and thus could be tun- able by biological regulatory processes, or by evolution. We performed simulations for a range of θ values between 5◦ and 180◦ (Figure 1(a)). The aggregate configurations that we used to initiate our simulations were generated by "transplantation" of circular segments from simulation snapshots of pre-grown biofilms (see Sections S1 and S2). This procedure proved preferable to other initialisation methods as it ensures no overlap between individual bacteria and enables the gen- eration of different aggregate shapes of the same number density (∼100 cells per unit area). By varying the radius of the circular segment we are able to ensure that each aggregate contained ∼100 cells that were initially spread on the surface to different extents. To ensure statistical accuracy, four different configurations were generated for each aggregate shape, defined by its value of θ, and for each of these configurations, five simulations were per- formed using different random number seeds. Changing the random number seed affects the order in which in- dividual bacteria grow and divide, and also changes the locations of the unaggregated cells on the surface sur- rounding the aggregate. A total of twenty simulations were therefore performed for each value of θ, enabling us to sample both variation in the configuration and the or- dering of cell updates (Section S5). Increasing the num- ber of repeated simulations did not affect our results. In common with many other biofilm simulation studies [19, 22, 23, 32], our simulations were performed in two dimensions for the purposes of computational efficiency. We have verified, however, that our key findings are re- produced when we use 3D simulations (see Sections S3 and S10). Simulation Implementation We use the agent-based microbial simulation package iDynoMiCs [33] to model biofilm growth, starting from configurations such as those shown in Figure 2. In these simulations, individual bacterial cells are represented as spherical agents, which grow and proliferate conditional on the local nutrient concentration, and "shove" each other apart to relieve local stresses within the biofilm. The order in which cells are selected to grow and divide is random during each global time-step of the simulation, as is the direction of cell division. In our simulations, the initial distribution of surrounding competitor cells on the 3 surface is also random. The simulations use a spatial grid to track the local nutrient concentration field. Nutrient is assumed to diffuse towards the biofilm from above, with the concentration being fixed to a bulk value in a layer far from the biofilm. Within the biofilm itself, nutrient diffusion is hindered relative to the region outside the biofilm. Nutrient consumption by the bacterial cells leads to local gradients, which can have a strong impact on the structural features of the growing biofilm [8, 23, 28 -- 30]. Periodic boundary conditions are imposed on both the nutrient concentration field and the particle coordinates in the horizontal direction. From a mathematical perspective, nutrient is repre- sented as a concentration field, the dynamics of which are governed by the the reaction-diffusion equation ∂S(x) ∂t = ∇ · (DS(x) · ∇S(x)) + rS(x), (1) where S(x) is the space (x)-dependent nutrient concen- tration, DS(x) is the diffusion coefficient of the nutrient, and rS(x) is the consumption rate of the nutrient by the bacteria. The rate of nutrient consumption, rS(x), is related to the growth rate of the bacteria, dX/dt, via rS(x) = dS dt = − 1 Yx/s dX dt , (2) where X(x) is the local biomass density, and Yx/s is a yield coefficient that describes the amount of nutrient required to produce one unit of biomass X. The growth rate of each cell is governed by the well- known Monod function dX dt = µmax S kS + S X, (3) where µmax is the maximum specific growth rate of the bacteria, and kS is the concentration of nutrient, S, at which the growth rate is half maximal. The growth pa- rameters used in our simulations were taken from em- pirical and simulation studies on Pseudomonas aerugi- nosa, assuming glucose to be the rate-limiting nutrient (see Table I). However our results are not sensitive to the detailed parameter choice, or to the choice of rate- limiting nutrient. Note that the growth rate parameters YX/N , µmax, and kS are the same for both the aggregate cells and the competitor cells (see Table I). From a practical point of view, in idynoMiCs the nu- trient concentration fields are assumed to be in pseudo steady-state with respect to biomass growth and there- fore the time dependence is removed from Equation 1 0 = ∇ · (DS(x) · ∇S(x)) + rS(x). (4) This equation is solved numerically for every global up- date of the bacterial population. In our simulations, we used a bulk nutrient concentration of 5.4 × 10−3 gL−1 (see Section S6) comparable with previous work [32 -- 34]. Each of our simulations was run for a total time of 480 h, Yield coefficient for Monod equation (Equation 3) 0.44 Symbol Description [S]bulk Bulk concentration of limiting nutrient YX/N µmax Maximum specific growth rate KN γ DG Lx Ly Ldbl Half saturation concentration of nutrient Density of biomass Diffusivity of glucose in water Dimension of system in horizontal direction Dimension of system in vertical direction Thickness of diffusion boundary layer 4 Notes/ref Value 5.4 × 10−3 gL−1 Within range of values from [32 -- 34] 0.35 h−1 3 × 10−3 200 gL−1 5.8−5 m2day−1 1032 µm 1032 µm 80 µm Within range of values from [32, 35, 36] Within range of values from [35, 37 -- 39] Within range of values from [20, 21, 33, 35 -- 38, 40] [20, 32, 35] [41] Ensures aggregates do not interact periodically Corresponds to the horizontal length Within range of values from [20, 21, 42] TABLE I. Input parameters for biofilm simulations. in order to explore the long-term growth dynamics (see results and Section S7). Our complete parameter set is listed in Table I. Using the parameters in Table I, our simulations produce spa- tially structured biofilms 200-300 µm in height after a simulation time of 480 h (see Figure 5, and Section S6). For an aggregate in the presence of competing non- aggregating cells, Figure 1(b) points to two strategies for maximising progeny. For long-lived biofilms, progeny can be maximised by the aggregate adopting a rounded configuration, whereas if the biofilm is short-lived then it may instead be optimal for the aggregate to spread on the surface. RESULTS Initial Aggregate Shape Determines Growth Dynamics To assess the growth dynamics of pre-formed aggre- gates in a biofilm, we tracked the number of progeny cells, N , produced by aggregates of different shape (Figure 1(b)). We investigated three different aggregate shapes, characterised by the angle θ (See Methods). The three angles, θ = 5◦, 90◦, 180◦, describe pre-formed aggregates that are initially arranged on the surface in either a spread, intermediately spread, or rounded manner. To investigate the effect of the surrounding unaggregated competitor cells (red cells in Figure 1(a)), we varied the density, ρ, of these cells between two extremes regimes of competition reported in this study: ρ = 0 cell µm−1, no competition; and ρ = 0.5 cell µm−1, high competition. Not surprisingly, aggregates grow better in the absence of surrounding cells on the surface regardless of their initial shape, i.e., for ρ = 0 cell µm−1. In this "non- competitive regime", the initially spread aggregate pro- duces more progeny than the more rounded aggregate. This is evident in Figure 2, which shows representative initial aggregate configurations and the structures of the biofilms which they form after 480 hours. Competition from unaggregated competitor cells on the surfaces leads to more complex behaviour. Figure 1(b) shows that, in the presence of strong competition, the spread aggregate produces more progeny over short times than the rounded aggregate. However, over longer times, the size of the population arising from the rounded aggregate is larger. Initial Aggregate Shape Affects Long-Term Biofilm Structure In our simulations the initial shape of the aggregate influences the long-term structure of the biofilm. Fig- ure 2 shows typical biofilm structures formed after 480 h of growth, starting from aggregates that were initially spread on the surface (θ = 5◦, left), rounded (θ = 180◦, right) or partially spread (θ = 90◦, centre), in the absence of competition from surrounding cells. It is clear that the spread aggregate covers much more of the surface during growth than its more rounded counterparts. In the presence of competition (Figure 3), we observe a marked difference in the structure of the biofilms that originate from spread aggregates (left panels) and from rounded aggregates (right panels). For the spread aggre- gate (a and c), the green section of biofilm that originates from the aggregate is structurally indistinguishable to that of the surrounding red biofilm that originated from the competing, unaggregated cells. In contrast, for the rounded aggregate (b and d), cells originating from the aggregate form a distinct "clump", which is taller than the surrounding biofilm. When the density of competing (red) cells is high (Figure 3(d)), there is a cell-free gap around the growing clump that appears to be a result of nutrient depletion. It is clear from the biofilm structures shown in Figures 2 and 3 that, even at very long times, the spatial structure of a biofilm can be affected by the initial spatial configu- ration of its founder cells (see also Section S6). While it might seem remarkable that apparently small changes in initial configuration can have dramatic effects on biofilm structure even after many cell generations, this effect is 5 FIG. 2. Initial aggregate arrangement affects biofilm morphology. Simulation snapshots of three bacterial aggregates initially arranged on the surface and the biofilms they form after 480 h: (a) Spread, 0 h. A zoomed in image is also shown to make the shape of the aggregate easier to resolve; (b) Semi-spread, 0 h; (c) Rounded, 0 h; (d) Spread, 480 h; (e) Semi-spread, 480 h; (f) Rounded, 480 h. are effectively created by the presence of the initial ag- gregates. The introduction of the rounded aggregate amongst the lawn of unaggregated cells on the surface at high competition leads to an instability in the biofilm structure that propagates as the biofilm develops. Nutrient gradients are important determinants of aggregate fate FIG. 3. Aggregate shape and neighbouring strain density affect biofilm morphology. Simulation snapshots of biofilms seeded from spread and rounded aggregates after 480 h growth in the presence of a low and high density inoculum of the competing strain: (a) θ = 5◦, ρ = 0.01 cell µm−1; (b) θ = 180◦, ρ = 0.01 cell µm−1; (c) θ = 5◦, ρ = 0.5 cell µm−1; (d) θ = 180◦, ρ = 0.5 cell µm−1. in fact well-known in a different context. For initially flat biofilms, Dockery and Klapper showed theoretically that small inhomogeneities in initial configuration may be magnified into large "fingers" over the course of biofilm development [30]. This phenomenon is shown as a finger- ing instability and arises from the fact that an emerging protrusion (or finger) is elevated above, and thus depletes nutrients from the surrounding biofilm. This leads to positive feedback, in which the enhanced growth of the cells at the top of the instability is to the detriment of the surrounding cells below [43]. While Dockery and Klapper assumed that struc- tural inhomogeneities would arise spontaneously during biofilm growth, in our simulations such inhomogeneities FIG. 4. Cells on the outside of the aggregates grow faster because they have greater access to nutrients. (a) Cell growth rate (µ) distribution of the biofilm formed from the semi- spread aggregate in the absence of competition after 4h. (b) Corresponding nutrient concentration field, [S]. 6 FIG. 5. Gradients in individual cell growth rates emerge in our simulated biofilms during growth. Cell growth rate distributions for the spread and rounded aggregates at after 480 h of growth: (a) θ = 5◦, ρ = 0.0 cell µm−1; (b) θ = 5◦, ρ = 0.01 cell µm−1; (c) θ = 5◦, ρ = 0.5 cell µm−1; (d) θ = 180◦, ρ = 0.0 cell µm−1; (e) θ = 180◦, ρ = 0.01 cell µm−1; (f) θ = 180◦, ρ = 0.5 cell µm−1. These distribution correspond to the configurations in Figures 2 and 3. Note that the gradient in cell growth rate is so large that a log scale is used for visualisation purposes. The green dashed lines represents an approximate boundary between the aggregate cells and the surrounding competing strain. It is well known that growth rate heterogeneities, re- sulting from nutrient concentration gradients, emerge during biofilm growth [44]. With this in mind, we tracked the growth rates of individual cells as a function of their position within the growing biofilm. Even in the very early stages of biofilm growth, we see heterogeneity in growth rates which emerge from (and influence) spatial gradients in nutrient concentration. Figure 4 illustrates this for a semi-spread aggregate (θ = 90o), after 4 h of growth, in the absence of competition. As expected, the cell growth rate is highly heterogeneous across the biofilm, Figure 4(a), with cells on the outside growing faster than those on the inside because they have better access to nutrients (Figure 4(b)). The growth rate heterogeneities shown in Figure 4(a) are amplified in the later stages of biofilm growth. Figure 5 shows the spatial distribution of cell growth rates for biofilms arising from spread and rounded aggregates after 480 h, in the presence and absence of competitor cells, for the same simulations as shown in Figures 2 and 3. In all cases we observe, as in previous work [45], two distinct regions of growth activity within the develop- ing biofilms: an outer layer of metabolically active cells and an interior region of inactive cells. These distinct regions arise because consumption by cells in the outer layer deprives cells in the inner layer of nutrients [45]. We also observe a large gradient in individual cell growth rate within the growing layer itself (note the logarithmic scale in Figure 5). The dynamics of the metabolically active layer determine the overall growth behaviour and structure of the biofilm. In Section S9 we show that the active layer of the rounded aggregate, unlike the spread aggregate, continues to expand in the presence of compe- tition; explaining why its total population becomes larger than that of the spread at longer times in Figure 1(b), and why it's structures tend to fan outwards at the top (Figure 5(f)). Although it is well documented that nutrient gradi- ents arising during biofilm growth play an essential role in biofilm formation [8, 23, 29], so far few studies have investigated the effect of pre-formed bacterial clumps in this process; in particular how the initial arrangement of cells within a clump affects biofilm structure and develop- ment. Figures 4 and 5 show that the initial arrangement of cells on the surface can determine the shape and struc- ture of a growing biofilm because small initial differences in nutrient gradients become amplified as the biofilm de- velops. Competition for Nutrient Favours Rounded Aggregates Next we investigated how the fate of an aggregate, as measured by the average number of progeny of one of its cells, varies with aggregate shape. To this end, we computed the number of progeny cells, N , arising from the aggregate after a period of biofilm growth, relative to the initial number of cells in the aggregate, N0, for a range of aggregate shapes, determined by θ, at varying 7 FIG. 6. Average number of progeny, N/N0, of aggregates defined by their surface-aggregate angle θ, the functional from of which changes with increasing density of competitor cells: (a) ρ = 0 µm cell−1; (b) aggregate-medium interface length, s, as a function of θ; (c) ρ = 0.145 µm cell−1; ρ = 0.5 µm cell−1. Vertical bars in represent the standard deviation from 20 data points. levels of competition. For this analysis, we carried out long simulations (480 h of biofilm development), so that the ratio N/N0 reflects the long-time fate of the progeny of cells within the aggregate (see Section S7). Figure 6(a) shows N/N0 plotted as a function of the aggregate-surface angle, θ, in the absence of competition from surrounding unaggregated cells. It is clear that the spread aggregate produces more progeny on average than the rounded one. In the previous section we saw that cells on the out- side of the aggregate have more access to nutrients even in the very early stages of biofilm growth. Thus, we might hypothesise that the growth advantage of the spread ag- gregate, in the absence of competition, is related to its larger surface area. Indeed, Figure 6(b) shows that N/N0 correlates closely with the interfacial area (or arc length) of the initial aggregate, s(θ). We therefore conclude that the spread aggregate produces more progeny than the rounded one because the former has a greater surface area with the surrounding medium, providing greater ex- posure to nutrient in the initial stages of growth. The difference in initial structure between the spread and rounded aggregates therefore translates into significant differences in cell fate, even after many generations of biofilm growth. As the density of competition of unaggregated cells on the surface increases, however, a very different scenario emerges. Figures 6(c) and (d) show that cells in the rounded aggregate (large θ) produce more progeny, on average, than those in the spread aggregate. This is more evident in Figure 7, which shows N/N0 for the spread and rounded aggregates as a function of the density of competitor cells. This effect is also observed at higher nutrient concentration (see Section S8). FIG. 7. Relative fitness as measured by N/N0 of rounded aggregates increases with competition. Rounded aggregates become favourable relative to spread aggregates with increas- ing density of competitor cells. Why does competition from surrounding unaggregated cells favour rounded over spread aggregates? Close in- spection of Figure 6 shows that, while the number of progeny produced by the spread aggregate decreases with increasing competition from surrounding cells (panels (c), and (d)), the number of progeny produced by the rounded aggregate remains rather constant. This finding can be understood by investigating how the fate of an individual cell within an aggregate depends on its initial spatial location. To this end, we tracked the number of progeny of each individual founder bacterium, as a function of its initial position within an aggregate. This constitutes a local, spatially-resolved version of the "fitness measure" N/N0. Averaging our results over 20 repeated simulations allowed us to generate a map show- ing the average number of progeny produced by indi- vidual cells within an aggregate, for initially spread and rounded aggregates, Figure 8. Figure 8 shows that the initial position within an ag- gregate indeed has a strong effect on cell fate. In the absence of competition from surrounding unaggregated cells, the most successful cells in the spread aggregate are those at the horizontal extreme edges; in the interior region of the aggregate, cell fate is more uniform (Figure 8(a)). It seems likely that in this case, cells at the hori- zontal edges have an advantage because their progeny can expand in the horizontal direction, whereas the progeny of cells in the interior of the aggregate must compete with their neighbours within the aggregate for nutrients and space. The proliferation of the cells at the edges of the aggregate drives the lateral expansion of the growing biofilm which we observe in Figures 2(a) and (d). In con- trast, for the rounded aggregate (Figure 8(b)), cell fate is overall more heterogeneous within the aggregate, with the most successful cells being located around the out- 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 θ [ o ] θ [ o ] (a) (d) 300 250 200 150 s [µm] 100 50 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 0 N / N (b) (c) 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 0 N / N 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 0 N / N * P = 0,0008 * P = 0,0031 P < 0,0001 * P < 0,0001 Spread Rounded 80 60 40 20 0 N/N0 0.01 Density of Competitor Cells [cell um-1] 0.145 0.291 0.5 side surface of the aggregate. For the rounded aggregate, it appears that height is a relevant factor as well as the proximity to the aggregate surface. Figure 8(c) shows that, in the presence of competition, cells at the horizontal edges of the spread aggregate actu- ally do less well than those in the centre. The decreased fitness of these cells explains the inhibited lateral expan- sion observed in Figures 3(a) and (c). For the rounded aggregate, the most successful cells in the absence of com- petition are those at the top of the aggregate. In the presence of competition (Figure 8(d)), these cells, which are now highly localised at the top, are elevated above the level of the competitor cells and therefore are little affected by the increased competition for nutrients. The "fitness" cost associated with its smaller surface inter- face is compensated in the presence of competition by its height, since its top cells remain unchallenged by com- petitors with respect to nutrient access. DISCUSSION Given the tendency of many bacteria to aggregate, and the frequent observation of aggregates in diverse environ- mental situations [5, 46, 47], it seems likely that natural biofilms are often initiated from pre-formed aggregates. Despite this, the role of pre-formed aggregates in biofilm development has, to our knowledge, not yet been ad- dressed. In this paper, we have investigated the fate of pre-aggregated cells during biofilm formation, using individual-based simulations. Our study shows that an initial aggregate can have a significant and long-lasting effect on biofilm spatial structure, even after many gen- erations of cell growth. Focusing on the role of aggre- gate shape, we find that, in the absence of competition for nutrients from surrounding cells, an aggregate that is initially spread on the surface is favoured over one that is initially rounded even over long periods of biofilm devel- opment. This is likely to be because the spread aggregate has initially a larger surface over which it can absorb nu- trients, giving it an initial growth advantage that is then maintained as the biofilm grows. Strikingly though, our results change qualitatively in the presence of competition from surrounding, unaggre- gated cells. When this competition is strong, although the spread aggregates still grow faster in the early stages of biofilm development, rounded aggregates become more successful (produce more progeny) as the biofilm devel- ops over longer times. This effect appears to arise from a trade-off between height (as nutrients diffuse from above) and exposed surface area. In the absence of competi- tion, surface area is more important than height, and the spread aggregate is favoured. However, in the presence of competition, height becomes more important, since cells at the top of the aggregate can avoid competing for nutrients with the surrounding competitors. Since the rounded aggregate is taller than the spread aggregate, it gains a "fitness" advantage under conditions of strong 8 competition that is only realised after long times. Bacterial biofilm formation is a complex phenomenon which involves a plethora of biological mechanisms in- cluding cell motility [48], EPS production [49, 50], metabolic and other phenotypic differentiation [9, 47, 51], and cell-cell interactions such as quorum sensing [52 -- 54]. In our simulations, almost all of this biological complex- ity has been neglected; our model takes account only of nutrient gradients established by cell consumption, nutrient-dependent growth, and competition among cells for space. Nevertheless this simplistic approach produces biologically interesting, and potentially testable, predic- tions. In particular our simulations predict that being initially spread on a surface is a better strategy for a bacterial aggregate in the absence, but not in the pres- ence, of competition. Understanding how further bio- logical complexity might affect this picture would be a very interesting topic for further work. Another avenue worth investigating would be the effects of biofilm erosion and the subsequent detachment of cells. Here, our simu- lations have not included the effects of fluid flow, which among other effects, may flatten the biofilm by detaching protruding cells. How might aggregates of different shape arise in na- ture? It is well known that bacterial interactions with surfaces can vary greatly depending both on the physi- cal and chemical properties of the surface [55 -- 57], and on bacterial phenotypes such as EPS production and the presence of surface appendages. It is therefore very likely that aggregates formed from bacteria of different taxa or strains, landing on different surfaces, might adopt dif- ferent configurations. For example, certain bacteria pro- duce surfactant which can alter the morphology of a de- veloping biofilm and allow them to expand over surfaces more efficiently [58, 59]. Our work has been inspired by the observation that bacterial aggregates often form in the planktonic phase [11 -- 13]. Aggregates are known also to form via the detachment of bacterial clumps from a mother biofilm [15, 60, 61]; should such aggregates land on a pristine surface, similar phenomena to those discussed here would be expected to arise. Moreover, our results could also be relevant to aggregates that form on the surface itself. In the classical picture of P. aeruginosa biofilm devel- opment, individual cells land on a surface, upon which they migrate and proliferate to form small aggregates (i.e. microcolonies). Surface-induced motility mecha- nisms [62, 63] such as twitching [64], crawling [65] and walking [66] have been implicated in this process. Once formed, such small aggregates would compete with sur- rounding cells for nutrients in much the same way as the pre-formed aggregates that we investigate in this paper. This study has focused on a single pre-formed aggre- gate seeding the surface and competing with initially un- aggregated cells during biofilm formation. To further un- derstand biofilms in nature, this work should be extended to investigate competition between multiple aggregates arranged on the surface, and competition between ag- 9 FIG. 8. Distribution of fittest cells varies with aggregate shape. 2D histograms representing the number of progeny, N , produced (480 h) by individual bacteria as a function of their initial location in the spread and rounded aggregates in the absence and presence of competition: (a) θ = 5◦, ρ = 0.0 cell µm−1; (b) θ = 180◦, ρ = 0.0 cell µm−1; (c) θ = 5◦, ρ = 0.5 cell µm−1; (d) θ = 180◦, ρ = 0.5 cell µm−1. Note that these distributions were averaged over 20 trajectories for each aggregate. Note that the gradient in the number of progeny is so large that a log scale is used for visualisation purposes. gregates and mixed strains of bacteria, i.e., strains with different growth rates. Recently cooperation within clumps of aggregated cells has been suggested to be a major stepping stone in the evolution of multicellularity [26, 27]. Our study thus also hints that interesting social interactions might arise be- tween cells within an aggregate. For all aggregate shapes, we observe heterogeneity in fitness among cells within the aggregate. This is particularly pronounced for the rounded aggregate, where cells at the top are strongly favoured while those in the centre of the aggregate hardly proliferate. Based on arguments recently put forward by West and Biernaskie [26, 27], one might predict that rounded aggregates would be favourable under condi- tions where cells within the aggregate are closely related, whereas spread aggregates, in which fitness differences between cells are less pronounced, might form where cells are less closely related. This leads to interesting fur- ther questions, e.g., when a rounded aggregate initiates biofilm growth, does the majority of cells in the aggre- gate "sacrifice" their future progeny in favour of their kin at the top? This idea supports previous suggestions that height plays a crucial role in competition within biofilms [32]. While previous work pointed to EPS production as a means to push progeny cells above the surrounding competitors [32, 67], our work shows that aggregate for- mation also provides a means to this end. Such a picture raises new questions about the evolutionary implications of bacterial aggregation. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS GM would like to thank Diarmuid Lloyd and Bartek Waclaw for helpful discussions, and Jan Ulrich Kreft, Robert Clegg, and Kieran Alden for technical advice throughout the duration of this study. All authors wish to thank The Human Frontiers Science Program for fi- nancial support under Grant Number RGY 0081/2012. In addition GM and RA would also like to thank the EP- SRC EP/J007404. Also, KK and TB were supported by the Lundbeck Foundation. KK was supported by Oticon Fonden and Knud Højgaards Fond. RJA was supported by a Royal Society University Research Fellowship. AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS GM designed and performed the simulation work, and drafted the manuscript. RA designed and coordinated the study and helped draft the manuscript. The idea of investigating the growth of pre-formed aggregates on sur- faces was conceived by TB, VG, RA, and SG. KK, JH, YI, and AR all aided in the design of the study and the biological interpretation of the results. All authors pro- vided critical evaluation of the study, assisted in editing the manuscript, and provided approval for submission. COMPETING INTERESTS The authors declare no competing interests. [1] Costerton, J. W., Lewandowski, Z., Caldwell, D. E., Ko- rber, D. R. & Lappin-Scott, H. M. Microbial biofilms. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 49, 711 -- 45 (1995). URL http: //www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8561477. [2] Costerton, J. W., Montanaro, L. & Arciola, C. R. Biofilm in implant infections: Its production and regulation. Int. J. Artif. Organs 28, 1062 -- 1068 (2005). [3] Fazli, M. et al. Nonrandom distribution of Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus in chronic wounds. J .Clin. Microbiol. 47, 4084 -- 4089 (2009). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender. fcgi?artid=2786634&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype= abstract. [4] Bjarnsholt, T. et al. Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilms in the respiratory tract of cystic fibrosis patients. Pediatr Pulmonol 44, 547 -- 558 (2009). [5] Burmølle, M. et al. Biofilms in chronic infections - a matter of opportunity - monospecies biofilms in mul- tispecies infections. FEMS Immunol. Med. Mic. 59, 324 -- 36 (2010). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ pubmed/20602635. [6] Høiby, N., Bjarnsholt, T., Givskov, M., Molin, S. r. & Ciofu, O. Antibiotic resistance of bacterial biofilms. Int. J. Antimicrob. Ag. 35, 322 -- 32 (2010). URL http://www. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20149602. [7] Kharazmi, A. Mechanisms involved in the evasion of the host defence by Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Immunol. Lett. 30, 201 -- 206 (1991). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm. nih.gov/pubmed/1757106. [8] Stewart, P. S. & Franklin, M. J. Physiological heterogene- ity in biofilms. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 6, 199 -- 210 (2008). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18264116. [9] Sauer, K., Camper, A. K., Ehrlich, G. D., Costerton, J. W. & Davies, D. G. Pseudomonas aeruginosa Displays Multiple Phenotypes during Development as a Biofilm. J. Bacteriol 184, 1140 -- 1154 (2002). The develop- [10] Monds, R. D. & O'Toole, G. A. mental model of microbial biofilms: ten years of a paradigm up for review. Trends Microbiol. 17, 73 -- 87 (2009). URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/ article/pii/S0966842X09000055. [11] Bossier, P. & Verstraete, W. Triggers for microbial ag- gregation in activated sludge? Appl. Microbiol. Biot. 45, 1 -- 6 (1996). URL http://link.springer.com/10.1007/ s002530050640. aeruginosa [12] Alhede, M. et al. Phenotypes of non-attached Pseu- domonas surface attached biofilm. PloS one 6, e27943 (2011). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender. fcgi?artid=3221681&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype= abstract. aggregates resemble [13] Haaber, J., Cohn, M. T., Frees, D., Andersen, T. r. J. & Ingmer, H. Planktonic aggregates of Staphylococcus 10 aureus protect against common antibiotics. PloS one 7, e41075 (2012). URL http://www.pubmedcentral. nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=3399816&tool= pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract. [14] Faruque, S. M. et al. Transmissibility of cholera: in vivo-formed biofilms and their relationship to infectivity and persistence in the environment. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 103, 6350 -- 5 (2006). URL http://www. pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid= 1458881&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract. [15] Hall-Stoodley, L. & Stoodley, P. Biofilm formation and dispersal and the transmission of human pathogens. Trends. Microbiol. 13, 7 -- 10 (2005). URL http://www. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15639625. [16] Anton, V., Roug´e, P. & Daff´e, M. Identification of the sugars involved in mycobacterial cell aggregation. FEMS Microbiology Letters 144, 167 -- 170 (1996). [17] Monier, J. & Lindow, S. E. Frequency , Size , and Lo- calization of Bacterial Aggregates on Bean Leaf Surfaces. Appl. Environ. Microb. 70, 346 -- 355 (2004). [18] Lens, P., Moran, A. P., Mahony, T., Stoodley, P. & O'Flaherty, V. Biofilms in medicine, industry and en- vironmental biotechnology: characteristics, analysis and control, vol. 1 (IWA Publishing, London, 2003). [19] Kreft, J.-U., Picioreanu, C., Wimpenny, J. W. T. & van Loosdrecht, M. C. M. Individual-based modelling of biofilms. Microbiology 147, 2897 -- 912 (2001). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11700341. [20] Xavier, J. B., Picioreanu, C. & van Loosdrecht, M. C. M. A framework for multidimensional modelling of activity and structure of multispecies biofilms. Environ. Micro- biol. 7, 1085 -- 1103 (2005). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm. nih.gov/pubmed/16011747. [21] Alpkvist, E., Picioreanu, C., Loosdrecht, M. C. M. V. & Heyden, A. Three-Dimensional Biofilm Model With Individual Cells and Continuum EPS Matrix. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 94, 961 -- 979 (2006). [22] Kreft, J.-U. Biofilms promote altruism. Microbiology 150, 2751 -- 2760 (2004). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm. nih.gov/pubmed/15289571. [23] Nadell, C. D., Foster, K. R. & Xavier, J. a. B. Emergence of spatial structure in cell groups and the evolution of cooperation. Plos. Comp. Biol. 6, e1000716 (2010). URL http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender. fcgi?artid=2841614&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype= abstract. [24] Tuson, H. H. & Weibel, D. B. Soft matter 9, Bacteria-surface 4368 -- 4380 (2013). http://www.sciencemag.org/content/256/ interactions. URL 5056/495.shorthttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ pubmed/23930134http://www.pubmedcentral.nih. gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=3733390&tool= pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract. [25] Israelachvili, face Forces http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/ pii/B9780123751829100119. J. N. (Elsevier, Intermolecular third edn. 2011), and Sur- URL [26] Biernaskie, J. M. & West, S. A. Cooperation, clumping and the evolution of multicellularity. Proc. R. Soc. B (2015). [27] West, S. A., in individuality. Fisher, R. M., Gardner, A. transi- Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (2015). URL http: & Kiers, E. T. tions USA 112, //www.pnas.org/content/112/33/10112.abstract. http://www.pnas.org/content/112/33/10112.full.pdf. 10112 -- 10119 evolutionary Major [28] Hermanowicz, S. W. A Simple 2D Biofilm Model Yields a Variety of Morphological Features. Math. Biosci. 169, 1 -- 14 (2001). [29] Stewart, P. S. Diffusion in Biofilms. J. Bacteriol 185, 1485 -- 1491 (2003). [30] Dockery, J. & Klapper, Finger Formation in Biofilm Layers. SIAM J. Appl. Math. 62, 853 -- 869 (2001). URL http://epubs.siam.org/doi/abs/10. 1137/S0036139900371709. I. [31] Douezan, S. et al. Spreading Dynamics and Wetting Transition of Cellular Aggregates. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108, 7315 -- 7320 (2011). URL http://www. pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid= 3088609&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract. [32] Xavier, J. B. & Foster, K. R. Cooperation and conflict in microbial biofilms. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 104, 876 -- 881 (2007). URL http://www.pubmedcentral. nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=1783407&tool= pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract. [33] Lardon, L. A. et al. iDynoMiCS: Next-Generation Individual-Based Modelling of Biofilms. Environ. Micro- biol. 13, 2416 -- 34 (2011). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm. nih.gov/pubmed/21410622. [34] Xavier, J. B., Picioreanu, C., Rani, S. A., van Loosdrecht, M. C. M. & Stewart, P. S. Biofilm-control strategies based on enzymic disruption of the extracellular poly- meric substance matrix -- a modelling study. Microbiol- ogy (Reading, England) 151, 3817 -- 3832 (2005). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16339929. [35] Characklis, W. G. & Marshall, K. C. Biofilms (Wiley Interscience, New York, 1990). 11 [41] Shedlovsky, T. Electrochemistry in Biology and Medicine (John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1955). [42] Picioreanu, C., Van Loosdrecht, M. C. M. & Heijnen, J. J. Mathematical modeling of biofilm structure with a hybrid differential- discrete cellular automaton approach. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 58, 101 -- 116 (1998). [43] Van Loosdrecht, M. C. M., Heijnen, J. J., Eberl, H., Kreft, J. & Picioreanu, C. Mathematical modelling of biofilm structures. Anton. Leeuw. Int. J. G. 81, 245 -- 256 (2002). [44] Wentland, E. J., Stewart, P. S., Huang, C.-T. & McFeters, G. A. Spatial variations in growth rate within klebsiellapneumoniae colonies and biofilm. Biotechnol. Prog. 12, 316 -- 321 (1996). URL http://dx.doi.org/10. 1021/bp9600243. [45] . [46] Monier, J. M. & Lindow, S. E. Differential survival of solitary and aggregated bacterial cells promotes aggregate formation on leaf surfaces. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 100, 15977 -- 15982 (2003). URL http: //www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi? artid=307678&tool=pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract. [47] Stoodley, P., Sauer, K., Davies, D. G. & Costerton, J. W. Biofilms as complex differentiated communities. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 56, 187 -- 209 (2002). URL http://www. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12142477. [48] Klausen, M. et al. Biofilm formation by Pseudomonas aeruginosa wild type, flagella and type IV pili mutants. Mol. Microbiol. 48, 1511 -- 1524 (2003). URL http://www. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12791135. [49] Flemming, H.-C., Neu, T. R. & Wozniak, D. J. The EPS matrix: the "house of biofilm cells". J. Bacteriol 189, 7945 -- 7947 (2007). URL http://www.pubmedcentral. nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=2168682&tool= pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract. [50] Flemming, H.-C. & Wingender, J. The biofilm matrix. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 8, 623 -- 633 (2010). [51] Watnick, P. & Kolter, R. Biofilm , City of Microbes. J. Bacteriol 182, 2675 -- 2679 (2000). [52] Davies, D. G. The Involvement of Cell-to-Cell Signals Science in the Development of a Bacterial Biofilm. 280, 295 -- 298 (1998). URL http://www.sciencemag. org/cgi/doi/10.1126/science.280.5361.295. [53] Miller, M. B. & Bassler, B. L. Quorum sensing in bacte- [36] Bailey, J. E. & Ollis, D. F. Biochemical Engineering ria. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 55, 165 -- 199 (2001). Fundamentals (McGraw-Hill, New York, 1986). [37] Bakke, R., Trulear, M. G., Robinson, J. A. & Characklis, W. G. Activity of Pseudomonas aeruginosa in Biofilms: Steady State. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 26, 1418 -- 1424 (1984). [38] Robinson, J. A., Trulear, M. G. & Characklis, W. G. Cellular Reproduction and Extracellular Polymer Forma- tion by Pseudomonas aeruginosa in Continuous Culture. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 26, 1409 -- 1417 (1984). [39] Beyenal, H., Chen, S. N. & Lewandowski, Z. The dou- ble substrate growth kinetics of Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Enzyme. Microb. Tech. 32, 92 -- 98 (2003). in biofilms with new numerical [40] Horn, H., Neu, T. R. & Wulkow, M. Modelling the structure and function of extracellular polymeric substances tech- niques. Water Sci. Technol. 43, 121 -- 127 (2001). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11381957$\ delimiter"026E30F$nhttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&dopt= Citation&list_uids=11381957. [54] Diggle, S. P., Griffin, A. S., Campbell, G. S. & West, S. A. Cooperation and conflict in quorum-sensing bacte- rial populations. Nature 450, 411 -- 414 (2007). [55] Dorobantu, L. S., Bhattacharjee, S., Foght, J. M. & Gray, M. R. Analysis of force interactions between AFM tips and hydrophobic bacteria using DLVO theory. Langmuir 25, 6968 -- 6976 (2009). [56] Harimawan, A., Rajasekar, A. & Ting, Y. P. Bacteria attachment to surfaces - AFM force spectroscopy and physicochemical analyses. Journal of Colloid and Inter- face Science 364, 213 -- 218 (2011). [57] Wright, C. J., Shah, M. K., Powell, L. C. & Armstrong, I. Application of AFM from Microbial Cell to Biofilm. Scanning 32, 134 -- 149 (2010). [58] Davey, M. E., Caiazza, N. C. & O'Toole, G. A. Rham- nolipid surfactant production affects biofilm architecture in Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1. J. bacteriol. 185, 1027 -- 36 (2003). URL http://www.pubmedcentral. nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=142794{&}tool= pmcentrez{&}rendertype=abstract. [63] Henrichsen, J. Bacterial surface translocation: 12 [59] Angelini, T. E., Roper, M., Kolter, R., Weitz, D. A. & Brenner, M. P. Bacillus subtilis spreads by surf- Proc. Natl. Acad. ing on waves of Sci. USA 106, 18109 -- 18113 (2009). URL http: //www.pnas.org/content/106/43/18109.abstract. http://www.pnas.org/content/106/43/18109.full.pdf. surfactant. [60] Wilson, S., Hamilton, M. a., Hamilton, G. C., Schumann, M. R. & Stoodley, P. Statistical quantification of de- tachment rates and size distributions of cell clumps from wild-type (PAO1) and cell signaling mutant (JP1) Pseu- domonas aeruginosa biofilms. Appl. Environ. Microb. 70, 5847 -- 5852 (2004). [61] Stoodley, P., Hall-Stoodley, L. & Lappin-Scott, H. M. Detachment, surface migration, and other dynamic be- havior in bacterial biofilms revealed by digital time-lapse imaging. Method Enzymol. 337, 306 -- 19 (2001). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11398439. [62] Harshey, R. M. Bacterial Motility on a Surface: Many Ways to a Common Goal. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 57, 249 -- 73 (2003). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ pubmed/14527279. a Bacteriol. Rev. 36, URL http://www.pubmedcentral. survey and a classification. 478 -- 503 (1972). nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=408329&tool= pmcentrez&rendertype=abstract. [64] Burrows, L. L. Pseudomonas aeruginosa Twitching Motility: Type IV Pili in Action. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 66, 493 -- 520 (2012). [65] Conrad, J. C. et al. Flagella and Pili-Mediated Near-Surface Single-Cell Motility Mechanisms in P. aeruginosa. Biophys. J. 100, 1608 -- 1616 (2011). URL http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/ pii/S0006349511002372. [66] Gibiansky, M. L. et al. Bacteria use type IV pili to walk upright and detach from surfaces. Science (New York, N.Y.) 330, 197 (2010). [67] Kim, W., Racimo, F., Schluter, J., Levy, S. B. & Foster, K. R. Importance of positioning for microbial evolution. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 111, E1639 -- E1647 (2014). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24715732. Supplementary Material Shaping the Growth Behaviour of Biofilms Initiated from Bacterial Aggregates S1 Generating 2D bacterial aggregates To generate bacterial aggregates of the appropriate shape, circular segments were extracted from simulation configurations of pre-grown biofilms as illus- trated in Figures S1 and S2. Figure S1(a) shows a circle (red) with radius R and segmental region defined by the white area between the black horizontal line and the perimeter of the circle. The "surface-aggregate angle", θ, defines the angle between the black horizontal line (surface) and the tangent line of the circle at the point of contact with the surface. The area, A, of a circular segment of radius R and with surface-aggregate angle of θ, is given by [1] (S1) (2θ − sin2θ)R2. 1 2 A = The corresponding arc length, s, of an aggregate defines the initial interface between the bacterial aggregate and the surrounding nutrient medium, and is computed according to (S2) To ensure our aggregates contained the same number of cells (∼100), the area in Equation S1 was fixed at 1257 µm2. The procedure for generating the starting aggregate configurations was s = 2Rθ. performed as follows: 1 arXiv:1506.08168v2 [physics.bio-ph] 24 Nov 2015 1. An in silico biofilm was grown for a simulation time of 7 days. This simulation was initiated with 200 cells randomly distributed on the surface and a nutrient concentration of 5.4×10−2 g L−1 was used. A typical biofilm resulting from such a simulation was approximately 800 µm in height with some finger-like projections such as those in Figure S2. 2. A point, P , was defined in the middle of the biofilm (Figure S1 and S2). The point P is the reference point from which the origin, O, of a circle is computed. The point P was selected such that the density of cells within any segmental area was relatively uniform. Bacterial aggregates of shapes θ = 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, ....., 180o with fixed area of 1257 µm2 were then generated as in Figure S2. 3. For each θ, the radius of the corresponding circle was computed by solving Equation S1 for R. Using the radius, R, of this new circle, we computed the distance, X, to move the origin of this new circle above or below the point P according to where X = R sinα, α = 90 − θ. (S3) (S4) 4. With the new origin and radius defined, we then extracted all bacteria within the radial distance from O. Note those bacteria located below the horizontal line (blue region) were excluded. The corresponding segment gave rise to a bacterial aggregate with a shape determined by the value of θ. 5. The vertical component of the point P was then subtracted from all bacterial coordinates so that the base of the aggregate was located on the surface as shown in Figure 1(a) of the main manuscript. S2 Generating configurations of competing "sin- gle cells" in 2D The width of the surface available to the surrounding competitor cells de- pends on the surface coverage of the aggregate. As surface coverage of the aggregate increases, θ → 0, the amount of available surface either side of the aggregate decreases. Surrounding cells were inserted at random positions 2 Supplementary Figure S1: Schematic representation of the geometry of ag- gregates in (a) 2D and (b) 3D. The light blue region represents the area not included when computing cells within a distance R from the origin, O. The angle θ is the contact angle of the aggregate with the surface. Supplementary Figure S2: Generating aggregates with different geometries but containing the same number of cells. Using pre-grown 2D biofilm con- figurations, green, aggregates of the desired shape can be generated using the geometric relationships from Figure S1(a). (a) Schematic showing how a spread aggregate is generated. (b) Schematic showing how a more rounded aggregate is generated. 3 on the surface excluding the region occupied by the aggregate. To ensure a constant density of cells surrounding the aggregate, the number of cells in these regions were varied according to the width of surface available. S3 Generating 3D aggregates To generate aggregates in our 3D simulations, we performed an analogous process to that used for the 2D case. Configurations of spherical caps were transplanted from pre-grown biofilms using the geometrical relationships il- lustrated in Figure S1(b). The volume of a spherical cap is [2] (S5) (S6) (S7) πR3(2 − 3sinα + sin3α), 1 3 Vcap = and the corresponding surface area of the cap is given by where the height, h, is given by S = 2πRh, h = R − X A spherical cap volume, Vcap, of 5575 µm3 was used for all values of θ, giving approximately 118 bacteria in each aggregate. S4 Generating configurations of competing "sin- gle cells" in 3D To surround the 3D aggregates with neighbours, we seeded the surface sur- rounding the aggregate with single cells. The number of these competing cells per square µm gave the density of cells on the surface. Cells that lay in the region defined by the radius of the spherical cap, a, were removed from this configuration. The aggregate configuration and the surrounding cell configuration were then combined to produce the initial state of the system. S5 Multiple simulation runs in 2D and 3D For our 2D simulations, four different aggregate configurations were gener- ated for each value of θ, and for each of these configurations, 5 simulations of 480 hours were performed using a different initial distribution of surrounding cells. This gave rise to a total of 20 simulations for each value of θ. 4 In 3D, only the spread aggregate, θ = 5o, and the rounded aggregate, θ = 180o, were simulated. Three different initial configurations were generated for each value of θ, and for each of these configurations 3 simulations of 72 hours were performed, each using different initial distributions of surrounding single cells. This gave rise to a total of 9 simulations for each value of θ. Note that, in both the 2D and 3D simulations, the competitor cells on the surface and the aggregated cells are identical in their growth parameters (Table 1, main manuscript). S6 Exploration of Biofilm Structure at Low and High Nutrient Concentration With- out Aggregates To investigate the effect of nutrient concentration in general in our simu- lations, we simulated 2D biofilms in the absence of initial aggregates, at several different nutrient concentrations and various densities of cells, which were initially located at random across the surface. Figures S3 (a) and (b) show the resulting biofilms formed after 120 h at a nutrient concentration of 5.4 × 10−2g L−1 for seeder cell densities of 0.01 cell µm−1 and 0.5 cell µm−1. Clearly, the biofilms formed at this nutrient concentration are significantly thicker than those formed at lower nutrient concentration (Figures S3(c) to (f)). Comparing (a) and (b), we see that a low density of seeder cells leads to a less uniform biofilm morphology with finger-like projections. After 120 h, at low nutrient concentrations (5.4×10−3g L−1), the biofilms remain very thin (Figures S3(c) and (d)). At this low concentration, the initial number of seeder cells has a marked effect on the final structure of the biofilm. A high density of seeder cells yields a biofilm with a uniform morphology whereas a low density of seeder cells yields a biofilm with a spatial structure that is clearly dependent on the initial configuration of the seeder cells. Figures S3(e) and (f) show that this effect persists at long times. From Figures S3(a) and (e), it is clear that both longer times and/or higher nutrient concentration lead to larger biofilms. Selecting a bulk nutrient concentration and timescale to investigate the shape dependent fitness of aggregated clusters of bacteria is therefore non-trivial. In our simulations, we used the lower nutrient concentration of 5.4 × 10−3g L−1 (see Table 1 in the main manuscript), comparable with previous biofilm simulations [3, 4, 5]. We also chose to run the simulations for 480 h in order to explore the long term growth dynamics, and to generate populations that were large enough to obtain good statistics. Timescales of 480 h have also been used in previous 5 Supplementary Figure S3: Nutrient concentration and initial density of seeder cells affect biofilm morphology in the absence of initial aggregates: (a) Nutrient concentration = 5.4 × 10−2g L−1, Density of seeder cells = 0.01 cell µm−1. (b) Nutrient concentration = 5.4 × 10−2g L−1, Density of seeder cells = 0.5 cell µm−1. (c) Nutrient concentration = 5.4× 10−3g L−1, Density of seeder cells = 0.01 cell µm−1. (d) Nutrient concentration = 5.4 × 10−3g L−1, Density of seeder cells = 0.5 cell µm−1. (e) Nutrient concentration = 5.4× 10−3g L−1, Density of seeder cells = 0.01 cell µm−1, 480 h. (f) Nutri- ent concentration = 5.4× 10−3g L−1, Density of seeder cells = 0.5 cell µm−1, 480h. simulation studies [3, 4]. After 480 h growth using a bulk concentration of 5.4 × 10−3g L−1, our simulations produce biofilms that are approximately 200-300 µm in height (Figures S3(e) and (f)). 6 Supplementary Figure S4: Without competing cells on the surface, the func- tional form of the N/N0 curves remains relatively constant over time. Note, however that the scale does change because more cells are produced as time increases: (a) 56 h. (b) 120 h. (c) 240 h. (d) 480 h. Error bars represent the standard deviation from 20 simulations. S7 Exploration of Aggregate Fate at Differ- ent Times In the main manuscript, we computed N/N0, as a function of the aggregate surface angle, θ, after 480 h. Here, we show that qualitatively similar results are obtained regardless of the time at which fitness is measured. Figures S4 shows N/N0 as function of θ in the absence of competing cells (no red cells in Figure 1(a) of the main manuscript) at 4 different times. Evidently, the functional form of the curves does not change significantly with time. In the highly competitive regime where we include competitor cells (red cells in Figure 1 of main manuscript) at a density of 0.5 cells µm−1, the situation is more complex. Here, the functional form of the curves changes during the course of the simulation (Figure S5). For early times, the curves are similar to the case without competition, suggesting that shape-dependent nutrient access is the still dominant factor in the early stages. As time 7 (b) 120 h (d) 480 h 22 20 18 16 0 N / N 14 12 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 0 N / N (a) 56 h (c) 240 h 10 9 8 7 6 5 55 50 45 40 35 0 N / N 0 N / N 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 θ [ o ] θ [ o ] Supplementary Figure S5: With competing cells on the surface at a density of 0.5 cell µm−1, the functional form of the N/N0 curve changes over time: (a) 56 h. (b) 120 h. (c) 240 h. (d) 480 h. Error bars represent the standard deviation from 20 simulations. increases, the rounded aggregates become increasingly "fitter" relative to the spread aggregates, until at 480 h, all aggregates with a surface aggregate angle greater than 75o are fitter than the spread aggregate. From this we can conclude that the initial height advantage of the rounded aggregate only becomes important at longer times. S8 Difference in Fate Between Spread and Rounded Aggregates at Higher Nutrient Concentration Here, we investigate the fate of the spread and round aggregate at a higher nutrient concentration, 1 × 10−2 gL−1. Figure S6 shows that our conclusions remain valid at this nutrient concentration: at low density of seeder cells there is no difference in fate between the spread and rounded aggregates, whereas at higher density of initial neighbours, the rounded aggregate is favoured 8 (b) 120 h (d) 480 h 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 50 48 46 44 42 40 38 36 34 32 30 28 0 N / N 0 N / N (a) 56 h (c) 240 h 6.5 6 5.5 5 4.5 4 3.5 3 0 N / N 22 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 0 N / N 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 θ [ o ] θ [ o ] Supplementary Figure S6: At higher nutrient concentration, 1 × 10−2gL−1, rounded aggregates are more favourable for growth. At low density of seeder cells (0.01 cell µm−1) there is no significant difference in N/N0 between the spread and rounded aggregates. At high density (0.5 cell µm−1), the rounded aggregate is again produces more progeny per initial cells relative to that of the spread. Note that these data were generated from simulations represent- ing 480 h of biofilm growth. over its initially more spread counterpart. Note that these simulations were again run for 480 h. S9 The Effect of Aggregate Shape on the Growth of the Active Layer In the main manuscript we discussed cell growth rate heterogeneity within the biofilm and the presence of a well-defined active layer in the growing aggregate. The depth of the active later has been shown to be very important in determining biofilm structure and the degree of segregation amongst cell groups within the community [6]. It has also been discussed in extensive mathematical detail by Dockery and Klapper [7]. Here we look at the growth 9 P = 0,5342 * P < 0,0001 Spread Rounded 0.0 1 0.5 Density of Competitor Cells [cell um-1] 200 150 100 50 0 N/N0 Supplementary Figure S7: Dynamics of the growing layer determine aggre- gate growth behaviour. The number of growing cells in the spread and rounded aggregates at various competitive regimes. For clarity the error bars, representing the standard deviations, are only shown for the final data points. The standard deviations at these points are maximal. of the active layer. In the analysis that follows, we simply define the active layer as the region of the growing aggregate in which all cells grow with a growth rate greater than 1 fg h−1 (see Figure 5 of main manuscript), and we assess the number of cells in this layer. This choice is arbitrary; what is important is the qualitative difference in behaviour between the aggregate shapes. Figure S7(a) shows the number of active cells within the spread (θ = 5o) and rounded (θ = 180o) aggregates at varying degrees of competition; dictated by the density of surrounding unaggregated cells on the surface. In the absence of competition, the number of active cells within the spread and rounded aggregates increases with time. Initially the number of active cells in the spread aggregate grows faster than that for its rounder counterpart, however for t > 100 h, the number of active cells in both aggregates increases with similar rates (slope of red curves). This linear increase determines the super-linear increase in the corresponding aggregate populations in Figure 1(b) of the main manuscript: a linear increase in the number of active cells translates to a super-linear increase in the total aggregate population. In all competitive regimes, the number of cells in the growing layer of the spread aggregates becomes constant after ∼100 h. A constant population of 10 0 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 time [h] Spread, no competition Rounded, no competition Spread, low competition Rounded, low competition Spread, high competition Rounded, high competition 5000 4500 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 number of cells in active layer, N active cells in the growing layer translates to linear growth behaviour of the total aggregate population (compare solid blue curve with the dashed red curve in Figure 1(b) of the main manuscript). For the rounded aggregates, this transition to the constant regime does not occur within the timescales of our simulations, and the layer continues to grow monotonically. Comparing the spread and rounded aggregates (solid curves with dashed curves), with competition, we see that growth of the active layer always in- creases faster for the spread aggregate before levelling off after 100 h. How- ever, later in the simulation, the number of active cells in the rounded ag- gregates becomes greater. The time at which this crossover occurs increases with increasing levels of competition. The increasing growth of the active layer in the rounded aggregate at high competition, ρ = 0.5 cell µm−1, ex- plains why its number of progeny becomes larger than that of the spread aggregate in Figure 1(b), and why its structures tend to fan outwards at the top (Figure 4(d)). S10 Aggregate Simulations in 3D The results presented in the main manuscript are for 2D simulations, for reasons of computational feasibility. To validate our results further, we also ran some simulations in 3D. Figure S8 shows simulation snapshots after 72 h for the spread and rounded aggregates in the presence of low and high densities of competitor cells. As in our 2D simulations (Figures 3(b) and (d) of the main manuscript), the rounded aggregate persists as a dominant structural feature at both low and high densities of competitor cells. The spread aggregate on the other hand becomes swamped by the surrounding competitors and after 72 h is structurally indistinguishable from the rest of the biofilm (as in our 2D simulations, Figures 3(b) and (d) of the main manuscript). N/N0 for the spread and rounded aggregates are plotted in Figure S9 and is analogous to the data shown in Figures 8 of the main manuscript for the 2D simulations. As in the 2D case, the number of progeny per initial cell of the aggregates decreases with increasing density of surrounding cells. In the absence of competition, the spread aggregate again produces significantly more progeny than the rounded aggregate, however as the competition on the surface is increased, the number of progeny produced by cells in the rounded aggregate increases relative to that of the spread. 11 Supplementary Figure S8: 3D simulation snapshots showing initial and final configurations of the spread and rounded aggregates at low and high density of surrounding cells. (a) Spread aggregate, Density of seeder cells = 0.002 cell µm−2. (b) Spread aggregate, Density of seeder cells = 0.03 cell µm−2. (c) Rounded aggregate, Density of seeder cells = 0.002 cell µm−2. (d) Rounded aggregate, Density of seeder cells = 0.03 cell µm−2. 12 Supplementary Figure S9: N/N0 of the rounded aggregate with respect to the spread aggregate increases with the density of neighbouring cells on the surface. In 3D, the trend is similar to that observed in 2D. The spread aggregate is significantly favoured when there is no competition on the surface however with increasing density the rounded aggregate is more favourable for growth. 13 P = 0,0081 Spread Rounded P = 0,122 * P < 0,0001 * P < 0,0001 0 0.0 0 2 0.0 0 4 0.0 3 Density of Competitor Cells [cell um-1] 500 400 300 200 100 0 N/N0 References [1] Weisstein, MathWorld -- A http://mathworld.wolfram.com/CircularSegment.html Resource. Web W. E. Wolfram "Circular Segment". Available From at: [2] Weisstein E. W. "Spherical Cap". From MathWorld -- A Wolfram Web Re- source. Available at: http://mathworld.wolfram.com/SphericalCap.html [3] Xavier, J. B., Picioreanu, C., Rani, S. A., van Loosdrecht, M. C. M. , Stewart, P. S., Biofilm-control strategies based on enzymic disruption of the extracellular polymeric substance matrix -- a modelling study, Microbiol. 151, 3817-3832 (2005). [4] Xavier, J. B., Foster, K. R., Cooperation and conflict in microbial biofilms. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 104, 876-881 (2007). [5] Lardon, L. A., Merkey, B. V., Martins, S., Dtsch, A., Picioreanu. C., iDynoMiCS: Next-Generation Individual- Kreft, J.-U., & Smets, B.F., Based Modelling of Biofilms. Environ. Microbiol. 13, 2416-2434 (2011) [6] Nadell, C. D., Foster, K. R., & Xavier, J.B., Emergence of spatial struc- ture in cell groups and the evolution of cooperation. PLoS Comput. Biol. 6, e1000716 (2010) [7] Dockery, J., & Klapper, I., Finger formation in biofilm layers. SIAM J. Appl. Math 62, 853-869 (2001). 14
1910.03941	1	1910	2019-10-07T14:01:58	High Sensitivity and Specificity Biomechanical Imaging by Stimulated Brillouin Scattering Microscopy	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.optics" ]	Noncontact label-free biomechanical imaging is a crucial tool for unraveling the mechanical properties of biological systems, which play critical roles in the fields of engineering, physics, biology and medicine; yet, it represents a significant challenge in microscopy. Spontaneous Brillouin microscopy meets this challenge, but often requires long acquisition times or lacks high specificity for detecting biomechanical constituents with highly overlapping Brillouin bands. We developed stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) microscopy that provides intrinsic noncontact biomechanical contrast and generates mechanical cross-sectional images inside large specimens, with high mechanical specificity and pixel dwell times that are >10-fold improved over those of spontaneous Brillouin microscopy. We used SBS microscopy in different biological applications, including the quantification of the high-frequency complex longitudinal modulus of the pharyngeal region of live wild-type Caenorhabditis elegans nematodes, imaging of the variations in the high-frequency viscoelastic response to osmotic stress in the head of living worms, and in vivo mechanical contrast mesoscopy of developing nematodes	physics.bio-ph	physics	High Sensitivity and Specificity Biomechanical Imaging by Stimulated Brillouin Scattering Microscopy Itay Remer1,2, Netta Shemsesh3, Anat Ben-Zvi3 & Alberto Bilenca1,4* 1Biomedical Engineering Department, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, 1 Ben Gurion Blvd, Be'er-Sheva 84105, Israel 2Agilent Research Laboratories, 94 Shlomo Shmeltzer Road, Petach Tikva 4970602, Israel 3Department of Life Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, 1 Ben Gurion Blvd, Be'er Sheva 84105, Israel 4Ilse Katz Institute for Nanoscale Science and Technology, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, 1 Ben Gurion Blvd, Be'er-Sheva 84105, Israel e-mail: [email protected] Abstract Noncontact label-free biomechanical imaging is a crucial tool for unraveling the mechanical properties of biological systems, which play critical roles in the fields of engineering, physics, biology and medicine; yet, it represents a significant challenge in microscopy. Spontaneous Brillouin microscopy meets this challenge, but often requires long acquisition times or lacks high specificity for detecting biomechanical constituents with highly overlapping Brillouin bands. We developed stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) microscopy that provides intrinsic noncontact biomechanical contrast and generates mechanical cross-sectional images inside large specimens, with high mechanical specificity and pixel dwell times that are >10-fold improved over those of spontaneous Brillouin microscopy. We used SBS microscopy in different biological applications, including the quantification of the high-frequency complex longitudinal modulus of the pharyngeal region of live wild-type Caenorhabditis elegans nematodes, imaging of the variations in the high- frequency viscoelastic response to osmotic stress in the head of living worms, and in vivo mechanical contrast mesoscopy of developing nematodes. Main Text Label-free biomechanical imaging has long used a variety of techniques, including atomic-force microscopy, multiphoton microscopy, and optical coherence elastography1 -- 6, that obtain mechanical images with high spatial resolution, but require contact or external mechanical stimulation of the sample. Spontaneous Brillouin microscopy7 -- 20 circumvents these requirements by measuring the so-called Brillouin shifts B and linewidths , which are the frequency shifts and linewidths of light backscattered inelastically from gigahertz-frequency longitudinal acoustic phonons characteristic to the different viscoelastic constituents of the material. However, spontaneous Brillouin microscopy often demands long acquisition times due to the low efficiency of spontaneous Brillouin scattering in biological matter, or suffers from limited mechanical specificity because of the relatively low spectrometer resolution of spontaneous Brillouin microscopes, making it difficult to specifically detect biomechanical constituents with highly overlapping Brillouin bands. 1 Here we introduce stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) as a process to significantly enhance the acquisition rate and mechanical specificity of Brillouin microscopy. SBS is a photon-phonon scattering process analogous to stimulated Raman scattering but which involves lower-frequency acoustic phonons. SBS was first observed in 196421 and has widely been used in spectroscopic research22 -- 29. While in spontaneous Brillouin scattering a single laser beam at a frequency 1 illuminates the sample to produce the entire Brillouin spectrum around the Stokes and anti-Stokes frequencies ω1  B, in SBS counter narrowband laser pump and probe beams at 1 and 2 overlap inside the sample to efficiently interact with a particular longitudinal acoustic phonon of vibrational frequency B (Fig. 1a). When the frequency of the probe beam at 2 is scanned around S experiences a stimulated Brillouin gain (SBG) via the Stokes frequency ω1 -- B, its intensity I2 wave resonance, whereas I1 the intensity of the pump beam at 1 shows a stimulated Brillouin loss (SBL), as depicted in Fig. 1b. The opposite occurs when 2 is scanned around the anti-Stokes frequency ω1 + B. No gain or loss arise at 2 otherwise. Consequently, unlike spontaneous Brillouin scattering, SBG or SBL enables Brillouin spectrum measurements that are free of elastic background interference and that do not trade spectrometer resolution for acquisition time, or vice versa25 -- 28. The SBG or SBL spectrum is given by G() =   g()  l  I1, where  is the crossing efficiency of the pump and probe beams in the sample, g() is the SBS gain or loss factor well represented by a lorentzian line shape, l is the interaction length of the two counter laser beams in the sampled 23. As for the spontaneous Brillouin scattering volume, and I1 is the intensity of the pump beam at 1 spectrum7, 10, the close relationship between the SBG or SBL spectrum and the complex longitudinal modulus of the probed volume allows to locally extract the high-frequency viscoelastic response of the medium. This relationship is described by M =   (1/2n)2  B 2  (1 + iB), where M* is the complex longitudinal modulus, 1 is the wavelength of the beam at 1, and n and  are the refractive index and the mass density of the medium, respectively7, 30. Similar to other nonlinear optical techniques31, SBS inherently provides optical sectioning in three dimensions owing to the nonlinearity of SBS in the total irradiance intensity. SBS has recently been demonstrated for Brillouin microscopy of liquids using tunable single- frequency lasers in a frequency-scanning SBS scheme24 or picosecond lasers in an impulsive SBS arrangement29. Although these systems provide high spectrometer resolution, their low sensitivity hinders biomechanical imaging. To enable biomechanical SBS imaging, we constructed a SBS microscope (Fig. 1c; see Methods Section 1 and Supplementary Fig. 1) based on our previous frequency-scanning SBS spectrometer design26 -- 28, but with an improved spatial resolution of ~0.8  0.8  16 m3 and an enhanced shot- noise sensitivity that yields a spectral acquisition time as low as 2 ms in water with Brillouin shift and linewidth measurement precision of 11.5 MHz and 35 MHz, respectively (see Methods Section 2 and Supplementary Fig. 2). This acquisition time represents a 50-fold improvement over the typical spectral measurement times of hundreds of milliseconds used in Brillouin measurements of water11-13,16 -- 19. The obtainable Brillouin shift and linewidth measurement precision allow to determine the real and imaginary parts of the gigahertz-frequency longitudinal modulus of water to a fractional precision of 0.0046 and 0.11, respectively (see Methods Section 2). The light sources were 780-nm tunable distributed-feedback semiconductor lasers that delivered a total excitation power of ~265 mW at the sample. The linewidth of the lasers was 1-4 MHz, enabling highly 2 specific measurements of a SBG or SBL spectrum with megahertz spectrometer resolution, which is at least 12-fold higher than the >100-MHz spectrometer resolution of Brillouin biomicroscopes9 -- 20. Fig. 1. Principle and method of SBS microscopy. (a) Acousto-optic interaction between focused, counter-propagating pump (ω1) and probe (ω2 < ω1) light with longitudinal acoustic phonon (B). The interference of the pump and probe fields (stripe pattern with intensity profile in white) drives the acoustic wave (gray wavefronts). (b) Intensity transfer S) light by virtue of SBS along an interaction length l, with an intensity increase between the pump (I1) and the probe (I2 in the probe beam (SBG) and an intensity decrease in the pump beam (SBL). Left and right illustrations are in the frequency and spatial domains, respectively. (c) Schematic of the SBS microscope. The pump beam is modulated by an acousto-optic modulator (AOM) and is left circularly polarized by a quarter wave plate (/4). The probe beam is right circularly polarized by a second quarter wave plate (/4). The pump and the probe beams are focused to the same point in the sample (S) by identical lenses (L). The frequency of the probe beam is scanned around the Stokes frequency ω1 -- B to produce the backscattering SBG spectrum of the focus point on the probe intensity. The probe beam is directed to an atomic notch filter (AF) by a polarizing beam splitter (PBS). The filter passes the probe light to a custom transimpedance receiver (TIR) and suppresses the unwanted pump back-reflections into the receiver. The ac signal at the receiver is input to a lock-in amplifier (LIA) to measure the SBG spectrum, whereas the dc signal is processed by a personal computer (PC) to measure the total attenuation across the sample. By raster-scanning the sample through the mutual focus of the pump and probe beams, three-dimensional images are obtained. (d) SBG 3 spectrum from volumes inside the pharynx (upper spectrum; purple cross in the coregistered brightfield image, scale bar = 20 m) and the surrounding region (bottom spectrum; cyan cross in the coregistered brightfield image) of a live wild-type C. elegans nematode. The spectra measured (T, dots) in 20 ms show a multipeak feature that was fitted well by a double lorentzian line shape (T, black line), with contributions from a particular mechanical constituent of the nematode (N, green line) and the buffer component (B, red line). (e) Three-dimensional sections of the Brillouin shift B, Brillouin linewidth B, and peak SBG GB, through the head of a live C. elegans nematode. A pixel dwell time of 20 ms was used to acquire a SBG spectrum over the range of 3-7 GHz in each pixel. Images contain 100  200 pixels, resulting in a total image recording time of 400 s. We show in Fig. 1d the SBG spectrum from volumes inside the pharynx and the surrounding region of a live wild-type C. elegans nematode (see Methods Sections 1 and 3, and Supplementary Fig. 3), which is an important model organism for biomedical research32. No substantial photodamage was observed (see Methods Section 4 and Supplementary Fig. 4). A multipeak feature is apparent in these two spectra, which can be well reproduced by a double lorentzian line shape. Whereas the green lorentzian represents the SBG spectral contribution of a particular mechanical constituent of the nematode, and the red lorentzian corresponds to the SBG spectral contribution of the buffer component, which always exists in the sampled volume. Thus, SBS enables highly specific identification of the Brillouin shift B, linewidth , and peak gain GB that completely parametrize the SBG spectrum of a specific biomechanical component of the specimen. By raster scanning the sample through the focus of the microscope, cross-sectional images of B, , and GB of the nematode were obtained across the entire 50 m thickness of the worm's head, as shown in Fig. 1e. As the first application of SBS microscopy, we imaged and quantified the gigahertz-frequency complex longitudinal modulus in live wild-type C. elegans at the second larval stage (L2) (Fig. 2). Figure 2a displays the Brillouin shift B image and the coregistered brightfield image of a live C. elegans larva along with images of the Brillouin linewidth  (Fig. 2b) and peak gain GB (Fig. 2c) across the entire middle plane of the worm at a depth of 10 m. The pharynx, analogous to the vertebrate esophagus, is an important organ of the nematode that pumps and grinds food into the worm's intestine33. The pharynx is seen to exhibit high values of Brillouin shift and linewidth but low values of peak gain compared to the surrounding region. From the SBG spectral parameters (B, , GB) measured in the worm, and using the relation between mass density and SBG23 and the reported refractive index distribution of the worm34, the spatial distributions of the gigahertz-frequency complex longitudinal moduli in the nematode were evaluated, as shown in Fig. 2d,e (see Methods Sections 5 and 6, and Supplementary Fig. 5). These distributions indicate that at high frequencies the larva pharynx is stiffer -- with higher Brillouin shifts (Fig. 2a) -- and more viscous -- with larger Brillouin linewidths (Fig. 2b) -- than its surroundings, attributable to the muscular nature of the pharynx33. Such direct correlations between the Brillouin shift and stiffness and the Brillouin linewidth and viscosity were consistently observed in other highly hydrated biological systems10, 17. We further confirmed these findings by statistically comparing the Brillouin shift and linewidth as well as the complex longitudinal modulus of the pharynx (purple in Fig. 2a) and the surrounding region (cyan in Fig. 2a) averaged across the corresponding volumes in several worms (Fig 2f-i). Therefore, we can use SBS microscopy to map the gigahertz- frequency complex longitudinal modulus of live organisms, opening possibilities to study biomechanics at high frequencies. 4 Fig. 2. Characterization of the high-frequency complex longitudinal modulus in live wild-type C. elegans L2 larvae with SBS microscopy. (a) Brillouin shift B image (and the coregistered brightfield image) of a live L2 larva at a depth of 10 m inside the worm. In the brightfield image, the pharynx (P) and the surrounding region (S) are filled in purple and cyan, respectively. The pixel dwell time and the frequency acquisition range were as in Fig. 1e. Images contain 100  400 pixels, resulting in a total image recording time of 800 s. Scale bar, 20 m. (b) Brillouin linewidth B image of the larva. (c) Peak SBG GB image of the larva. (d) Gigahertz-frequency longitudinal storage modulus M' of the larva (relative to that of double-distilled water M'W = 2.056 GPa). Mean refractive index values from the literature were used (34) for the pharynx (n = 1.38) and the surrounding region (n = 1.36). For the other regions of the worm, a mean refractive index value of 1.37 was used34. (e) Gigahertz-frequency longitudinal loss modulus M'' of the larva (relative to that of double-distilled water M''W = 0.1249 GPa). (f) Average Brillouin shift of the pharynx (P, purple bar) and the surroundings (S, cyan bar) of live L2 larvae (N = 10, p-value < 0.05 as computed by paired student's t- test, 10-m depth). Error bars represent standard deviation from the mean. (g) Relative average gigahertz-frequency longitudinal storage modulus M' of the larva pharynx and the surrounding region (same statistics as in f). (h) Average Brillouin linewidth of the larva pharynx and surroundings (same statistics as in f). (i) Relative average gigahertz- frequency longitudinal loss modulus M'' of the larva pharynx and surroundings (same statistics as in f). These results indicate that at gigahertz frequencies the larva pharynx is stiffer and more viscous than its surroundings. We also present the use of SBS microscopy to visualize variations in the high-frequency viscoelastic response to hyperosmotic stress within the pharyngeal region of live wild-type C. elegans young adults. Common instruments for biomechanics, such as cantilevers and micropipettes, are limited to measurements at the surface of the worm and cannot image biomechanical properties in vivo with depth sectioning2, 35 -- 38. Figure 3A-C shows the brightfield images and the Brillouin shift B and linewidth B sections of the head region of three individual C. elegans young adults from a depth of 25 m, under isotonic (Fig. 3a) and hypertonic (Fig. 3b,c) salt conditions. At 125 mM of salt (250 Osm), the images show a notable increase in the Brillouin shift and linewidth throughout the worm's head compared to a control worm under isotonic conditions. At 250 mM of salt (500 Osm), the Brillouin shift and linewidth further increased. These results suggest that hyperosmotic shock increases the high-frequency stiffness and viscosity of the worm's pharyngeal region; consistent with previous findings that exposure of C. elegans to a high-salt environment induces an increase in the low-frequency stiffness of the animal's body-wall37. Similar results were reported in biological cells using spontaneous Brillouin microscopy and atomic-force microscopy10. At both isotonic and hypertonic salt concentrations, the Brillouin shift and linewidth of the worm's pharynx are found to remain higher than those of the surrounding area, indicating that the pharynx is stiffer and more viscous 5 than its surroundings regardless of the osmotic conditions. All these findings were further verified statistically in several nematodes by means of the average Brillouin shift and linewidth of the pharynx and the surrounding region (Fig. 3d,e). These results show that SBS microscopy offers a new approach for investigating biomechanics in vivo. Fig. 3. SBS imaging of the variations in the high-frequency viscoelastic response to hyperosmotic stress within the pharyngeal region of live wild-type C. elegans young adults. (a-c) Brillouin shift B and Brillouin linewidth B images (and the coregistered brightfield image) of the head of live nematodes under isotonic salt conditions (see a), hypertonic salt conditions (250 Osm, b), and hypertonic salt conditions (500 Osm, c). All the data was acquired from a depth of 25 m inside the worms' head. The arrow lengths in the worm schematic illustrate the rate of water entrance to and exit from the nematode. The pixel dwell time and the frequency acquisition range were as in Fig. 1e. Images contain 100  200 pixels, resulting in a total image recording time of 400 s. Scale bar, 20 m. (d) Average Brillouin shift of the pharynx (P, purple bar) and the surroundings (S, cyan bar) of live young adults (N = 10, p-value between levels of osmolarity < 0.05 as computed by one-way ANOVA following post-hoc analysis Tukey's tests, p-value within levels of osmolarity < 0.05, as computed by paired student's t-test, 25-m depth) before and after hyperosmotic shock of 125 mM NaCl (250 Osm) and 250 mM NaCl (500 Osm). Error bars represent standard deviation from the mean. (e) Average Brillouin linewidth of the nematodes' pharynx and surroundings before and after the hyperosmotic shock (same statistics as in d). These findings suggest that the gigahertz-frequency stiffness and viscosity of the worm's pharyngeal region increases under hyperosmotic stress, whereas the pharynx is stiffer and more viscous than its surroundings regardless of the osmotic conditions. Another application of SBS microscopy is biomechanical mesoscopy. Although spontaneous Brillouin microscopy has been used to acquire mesoscopic images of the Brillouin shift of tissue11, mouse embryo15, and zebrafish18, the recording periods are often excessively long due to prolong pixel dwell times (hundreds of milliseconds). While shorter times (50 ms) are possible for imaging thin biological cells with spontaneous Brillouin microscopes based on virtually imaged phase arrays20, their sub gigahertz spectrometer resolution considerably limits the ability to detect biomechanical constituents with highly overlapping Brillouin bands17. We map here in vivo the mesoscopic distributions of the Brillouin shift and the Brillouin linewidth across the middle plane of C. elegans nematodes at three larval stages (L2, L3, L4) and two adult stages (young adult and adult), as shown in Fig. 4a,b. These distribution maps allow us to identify organs and structures, such as the pharynx, vulva, gonad, and eggs, within the worms during development based on their viscoelastic contrast. Focusing on the nematode's head, a noticeable feature in these maps is the larger Brillouin shifts and linewidths of the pharynx than those of its surroundings, at all 6 developmental stages. This was further validated statistically in several nematodes by means of the average Brillouin shift and linewidth of the pharynx (inset of Fig. 4a) and the surrounding region (inset of Fig. 4b). These findings imply that, regardless of the particular developmental stage of the nematode, the pharynx is stiffer and more viscous than the surrounding area at high frequencies. Interestingly, the mean Brillouin shift and linewidth of the pharynx and surroundings remained relatively unchanged during development. This suggests that the mechanical properties of the pharynx and the surrounding area are determined early in development, perhaps because of the prominent function of the pharynx in feeding33. Fig. 4. Biomechanical SBS mesoscopy of developing C. elegans nematodes. (a) Brillouin shift B images of live nematodes at three larval stages (L2, L3, L4) and two adult stages, young adult (YA) and adult (A). The inset shows the average Brillouin shift of the pharynx (P, purple bar) and the surroundings (S, cyan bar) of the live worms at the different stages (N = 10 per stage, p-value within stages < 0.05 as computed by paired student's t-test, p-value for the pharynx between the L4 stage and the other stages < 0.05, all other p-values between stages were > 0.05 as computed by one-way ANOVA following post-hoc analysis Tukey's tests). Error bars represent standard deviation from the mean. Images were acquired from the middle plane of the nematodes at depths of 10-35 m inside the worms. The pixel dwell time and the frequency acquisition range were as in Fig. 1e. Images contain 100  400 -- 120  1200 pixels, resulting in a total image recording time of 800 -- 2880 s. Scale bar, 50 m. (b) Brillouin linewidth B images of the live nematodes at the different developmental stages. The average Brillouin linewidth of the worms' pharynx and surroundings is displayed in the inset for the various stages (same statistics as in a). SBS microscopy enables in vivo mechanical contrast visualization across large areas inside live organisms. With its high sensitivity and spectrometer resolution, SBS microscopy enables mechanical imaging of large and living samples in practical times and the ability to highly specify mechanical constituents inside the samples based on resolvable Brillouin information. Together, these 7 capabilities may open up new possibilities for studying various mechanical aspects of cancer and muscle disorders in model organisms. Methods 1. SBS microscope A detailed schematic of the SBS microscope is shown in Supplementary Fig. 1a. An amplified continuous-wave (CW) distributed feedback (DFB) laser (SYST TA-pro-DFB, Toptica) and a CW DFB laser (SYST DL-100-DFB, Toptica), both s-polarized, thermally stabilized and coupled into a polarization-maintaining single-mode fiber, serve as a pump beam at a frequency 1 and a probe beam at a frequency 2, respectively. The frequency 1 corresponds to the wavelength of 780.24 nm, and the frequency 2 is scanned around the Stokes frequency ω1 -- B, with B representing the characteristic longitudinal Brillouin shift of the material. Although SBG and SBL spectra provide equivalent information, we acquired SBG spectra because the passband of the detection filter used is flatter for the Stokes than for the anti-Stokes frequency band26. The lasers exhibit mode-hop-free tuning ranges larger than 50 GHz and laser linewidths of 1-4 MHz, providing wide spectral range and high spectrometer resolution for the acquisition of SBG spectra. The frequency of the probe laser is scanned by modulating its current with a sawtooth wave from a function generator (AFG2021, Tektronix). The frequency difference between the pump and probe lasers  = 2 -- 1 is determined from a lookup table produced by measuring the beat frequency of the two lasers as a function of the probe laser current with a fast photodetector (1434, Newport) and a frequency counter (EIP 578B, Phase Matrix). The pump beam is optically filtered by a narrowband Bragg filter (SPC-780, OptiGrate) to suppress the amplified spontaneous emission of the pump laser. The filtered beam is modulated with an acousto-optic modulator (15210, Gooch and Housego) driven by a 1.1 MHz sinusoidal wave from the function generator. The same sinusoidal wave is used as a reference for the lock-in amplifier. Following modulation, the pump beam is p- polarized by a half wave plate and is transmitted toward the sample through a polarizing beam splitter. The pump and probe beams are circularly polarized orthogonally to each other with quarter wave plates, and are tightly focused at a joint point in the sample by aspheric lenses with a numerical aperture (NA) of 0.25 (Asphericon). This polarization scheme allows an efficient modulation of the pump beam and also SBS in a backscattering geometry, which maximizes the obtainable SBS signal. As a nonlinear process, SBS yielded with this NA an estimated lateral resolution of  / (4  NA) = 0.78 m and an estimated axial resolution of   n / NA2 = 16.6 m in water. The sample is mounted on a close-loop XYZ motorized stage (LS-50, Applied Scientific Instrumentation) to enable raster scanning of the sample through the joint focus of the aspheric lens pair. The backscattered SBG signal at the probe frequency 2 is collected with the same aspheric lens that focuses pump light into the sample, is then s-polarized by the quarter wave plate of the pump beam, and is finally reflected toward the detection module through the polarizing beam splitter. The detection unit comprises an atomic vapor notch filter at the pump frequency 1, an amplified photodetector, and a lock-in amplifier. The atomic filter is based on the narrowband absorption of a rubidium-85 cell (SC-RB85-25x150-Q-AR, Photonics Technologies), heated to 90C, at the Fg=3 line frequency to which the pump laser is tuned for suppressing unwanted pump stray reflections in the lock-in detection bandwidth. The amplified photodetector uses a large-area photodiode (FDS1010, Thorlabs) reverse-biased at 24V and a novel transimpedance amplifier with gain and equivalent input noise of 5104 V/A and 2.5 pA/Hz at the lock-in modulation frequency 8 of 1.1 MHz, respectively, to generate an ac-coupled output voltage proportional to the SBG. In addition, the amplified photodetector has a dc-coupled voltage output to monitor the probe intensity attenuated by transmission through the sample. A high‐frequency lock‐in amplifier (SR844, Stanford Research) is used to demodulate the probe intensity. A data acquisition unit (NI USB-6212 BNC, National Instruments) connected to a personal computer is fed with the analog x-output of the lock-in amplifier, the dc-coupled voltage output of the amplified photodetector, the sawtooth wave output of the function generator, and the analog readout channel of the frequency counter. To acquire a SBG spectrum, the lock-in detection bandwidth is set in the lock-in amplifier and the sawtooth wave is programmed in the function generator, with the height of the waveform defining the scanning frequency range of the probe laser around the Stokes frequency ω1 -- B and the time period of the waveform determining the acquisition time of the entire spectrum. The microscope is focused into a point in the sample and a custom program (LabVIEW version 2014, National Instruments) tunes the frequency of the probe laser and records the dc and ac intensity of the transmitted probe beam for each . Correction of the SBG signal for sample attenuation is performed by estimating the attenuation coefficient of the sample and the pump intensity at the focusing point from the measured dc probe intensity and the predetermined imaging depth in the sample. Spectral analysis was performed in MATLAB (The MathWorks Inc.) to fit a measured SBG spectrum to a double lorentzian line (Fig. 1d). For biomechanical SBS imaging, the sample is raster-scanned through the microscope focus with a XYZ motorized stage controlled by a multi-axis controller (MS-2000, Applied Scientific Instrumentation). The beginning of a line scan is initiated by the controller, which also triggers, via a transistor-transistor logic (TTL) signal, the function generator that drives the current of the probe laser for frequency scanning (Supplementary Fig. 1b). The period of the driving current defines the pixel dwell time over which a SBG spectrum is acquired with predetermined measurement bandwidth and pixel size (Supplementary Fig. 1b). The pixel size (or the scanning step size) should be at least two times smaller than the optical resolution for Nyquist sampling. We set the pixel size to closely match the optical resolution (1 m), which represents a compromise between the acquisition speed and the spatial resolution of the image. At each pixel, a SBG spectrum is acquired by the lock‐in amplifier, as described above (Supplementary Fig. 1b). When the motorized stage completes the line scan the TTL signal falls, which leads to termination of frequency scanning and movement of the stage to the subsequent line scan, as shown in Supplementary Fig. 1b. For brightfield imaging, a halogen light source (HL-2000, Ocean Optics) was introduced into the SBS microscope by placing a dichroic mirror in the path of the probe beam, and a complementary metal -- oxide -- semiconductor camera (Lt225, Lumenera) was imaging the sample through a dichroic mirror located immediately before the detection unit of the microscope, as shown in Supplementary Fig. 1a. 2. Detection limit of the SBS microscope We previously have demonstrated an SBS spectrometer for high-speed analysis of materials26 -- 28. Here, we use a novel low-noise high-frequency transimpedance photoreceiver to yield shot-noise limited sensitivity of the spectrometer. The electrical noise of our lock-in amplifier is 1.8 nV/Hz, 9 therefore dominating over the shot noise at detected optical powers of 0.1-10 mW. This noise performance is insufficient for SBS bioimaging with high sensitivity. An efficient technique to improve the sensitivity is to increase the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) using a low-noise transimpedance photoreceiver. To this end, a large-area photodiode (FDS1010, Thorlabs) was integrated with a custom transimpedance amplifier with gain and equivalent input noise of 5104 V/A and 2.5 pA/Hz at the lock-in modulation frequency of 1.1 MHz, respectively. Using this low-noise high-frequency transimpedance photoreceiver, the SBS microscope was brought close to the shot-noise limit over the entire range of optical powers of 0.1-10 mW (Supplementary Fig. 2a). Further, we doubled the SBG signal detected by improving the crossing efficiency of the pump and probe beams in the sample to 55% while minimizing the amount of pump stray reflections detected. This was accomplished using measurement chambers that are much thicker than the confocal parameter of the focusing lenses. Consequently, we were able to measure SBG spectra of water in acquisition times as low as 2 ms with SNRs > 25 dB, resulting in Brillouin shift and linewidth measurement precision of B/2  11.5 MHz and B/2  35 MHz, respectively (Supplementary Fig. 2b-d). This result represents a fivefold improvement in the spectral acquisition time compared with the previous SBS spectrometer, without compromising precision of the measurements. For the mean Brillouin shift and linewidth retrieved from the SBG spectra of water measured in 2 ms (B/2 = 5.05 GHz, B/2 = 323 MHz), the SBS microscope obtained fractional precision of at least 2  B/B = 0.0046 and [(B/B)2 + (B/B)2]½ = 0.11 in the estimate of the real and imaginary parts of the gigahertz-frequency longitudinal modulus M* of water, respectively. 3. Preparation of the C. elegans samples Wild type (N2) C. elegans worms were grown on nematode growth media (NGM) plates seeded with the Escherichia coli OP50 or OP50-1 strains at 15°C. 30-60 embryos, laid at 15°C, were picked, transferred to new plates and grown at 25°C for the duration of the experiment. Nematodes at a well-defined developmental stage were determined using a light microscope during the developmental time window of interest. During the reproductive period, animals were transferred to fresh plates every 1-2 days to circumvent progeny contamination. For imaging, we first prepared two 0.5-mm-thick 5% agar pads mixed with 10 mM sodium azide solution (NaN3) to anesthetize the worms. Then, the agar pads were mounted on two 0.17-mm- thick round glass coverslips (18 mm and 25 mm in diameter), and 10-15 nematodes at a specific developmental stage were sandwiched between the agar-padded coverslips (Supplementary Fig. 3a). 10 l of M9 contact buffer was added between the agar pads and served as a control environment for the worms. To fix the entire sample and to avoid dehydration, a few drops of UV glue were applied at the edge of the smaller coverslip and a thin layer of Vaseline sealed the gap between the two coverslips, as illustrated in Supplementary Fig. 3b. Following SBS imaging, worms were washed from the agar pads to NGM plates for recovery. 4. Measurements of photodamage in SBS imaging of live C. elegans nematodes In live-organism SBS imaging, high irradiation intensities are used. To assess photodamage, we monitored the Brillouin shift at multiple locations in the head of live C. elegans nematodes and across the agar pads surrounding the worm over 120 s at room temperature (20C) (Supplementary Fig. 4). These measurements showed no consistent elevation in the Brillouin shift with time. 10 Because the Brillouin shift increases with rising temperature39, these results suggest that no substantial sample heating occurred in 120 s − a time period significantly longer than the pixel dwell time of 20 ms used in SBS imaging of live C. elegans worms. In addition, the maximum standard deviation of these Brillouin shift measurements is 0.021 MHz, corresponding to a maximum temperature change of less than 1.8C in water40. This result is consistent with our calculation of the heating in water (below 1 K) due to water absorption at 780 nm using the same conditions as in the experiments (total excitation power of 265 mW, NA of 0.25, and measurement time of 120 s). In addition, examination of several worms following SBS imaging showed recovery from anesthesia and a typical crawling motion. 5. Estimate of the mass density and the complex longitudinal modulus of materials by SBS In SBS, the mean density of a material  is related to the Brillouin shift B and linewidth B, and the normalized line-center gain factor of the SBG spectrum of the medium by the expression , (1) where γe is the electrostrictive constant, ω2 is the frequency of the probe beam, n is the refractive index of the medium, c is the speed of light in vacuum, and qB is the acoustic wavenumber. is calculated from the SBG spectrum G() as , (2) with GB being the peak gain G(),  the crossing efficiency of the pump and probe beams in the sample, I1 the intensity of the pump beam at the sample entrance, and Leq the equivalent SBS interaction length in the medium calculated using the assumed spatial distribution of the pump intensity in the sample28. For backward SBS, qB = 2  ω2  n / c and Eq. (1) reduces to23 . (3) By estimating γe through use of the Lorentz -- Lorenz law, it is obtained that γe = (n2 -- 1)  (n2 + 2) / 3 (Ref. 23). Thus, the mean density of a material  can be evaluated from the measured values of B, B, and GB of the SBG spectrum of the material and from knowledge about the material refractive index n. Subsequently, the complex longitudinal modulus of the material M* is calculated using the spectral parameters B and B of the measured SBG spectrum, the  estimated by Eq. (3), and the literature refractive index value of the material n as , (4) 11 NBg222B22BB2eNBqncg=NBgNBBeq1GgLI=2324NBBB2ecg=221BB2B14Min=+with 1 denoting the wavelength of the beam at 1 (Refs. 7 and 30). We validated Eq. (3) and computed M (Eq. (4)) in various materials using the SBS microscope with 0.033 NA focusing lenses (Supplementary Fig. 5). The use of these low NA lenses minimized the effects of broadening and blue shift of the SBG spectrum and enabled to work in a near backward SBS geometry with a crossing efficiency close to 100%. Reported refractive index values at a wavelength of 780.24 nm and at 20C were used in Eqs. (3) and (4) for the materials measured41,42. The estimated mass density of all materials agreed well, to within 1-10%, with values from the literature (Ref. 43; Supplementary Table I). 6. Estimate of the mass density and the complex longitudinal modulus in C. elegans by the SBS microscope In backward SBS, the SBG spectrum of the ith voxel of volume centered at in a scattering medium is25 , (5) where  the crossing efficiency of the pump and probe beams in the sample, g() is the SBS gain factor which, to good approximation, is described by a lorentzian with a spectral shift ΩB, linewidth B, and peak gain GB. is the effective SBS interaction length in the medium , (6) with being the mean total attenuation coefficient of the medium at . is a function that describes the dependence of the SBS interaction length on the spatial distribution of the pump intensity in the sample28. is the pump intensity at the voxel entrance , (7) where I10 is the pump intensity at the entrance plane of the medium. To estimate the mass density of the C. elegans nematode at the ith voxel, we used Eq. (3) with the reported refractive index n value of the region to which the voxel belongs in the worm (34), the Brillouin shift B and linewidth B retrieved from the SBG spectrum G(Ω) measured at the voxel, and the normalized Brillouin line-center gain factor evaluated as . (8) Here, the mean total attenuation coefficient , appearing in (Eq. (6)) and (Eq. (7)), was recovered by measuring the attenuation of the probe beam through the worm at using 12 xyz(),,iiixyz()()()1iieqeffGgfLI=ieffL()()(),1,1tiixyziefftiiLxye−−=−(),tiixy(),iixy()eqf1iI()(),2110tiiixyzziIIe−−=N,Big()()BN,B1iiieqeffGgfLI=(),tiixyieffL1iI(),iixythe dc output signal of the photoreceiver, together with estimating the thickness of the nematode at the same point from the worm's brightfield images (assuming cylindrical symmetry of the in Eqs. (6) and (7) was approximated as the extent of the worm's body). The voxel's axial size resolution cell along the axial dimension, and the voxel's axial position in Eq. (7) was obtained from the position readings of the motorized sample stage. To compute the complex longitudinal modulus of the material M* at the ith voxel of the C. elegance nematode, Eq. (4) is used with the spectral parameters B and B of the SBG spectrum measured at the ith voxel, the mass of density  estimated at the voxel, and the literature refractive index n value of the region to which the voxel belongs in the worm. We point out that Eq. (5) assumes low NA values (< ~0.1). For the NA of 0.25 used in SBS imaging of the C. elegance worms, the Brillouin shift is expected to show a <1% decrease compared with the Brillouin shift at NA = 0.1, the Brillouin linewidth a <5% increase, and the normalized Brillouin line-center gain factor a <4% decrease, resulting in a <2% (<4%) decrease (increase) in the calculation of the real (imaginary) part of the complex longitudinal modulus. References 1. Thomas, G., Burnham, N. A., Camesano, T. A. & Wen, Q. Measuring the mechanical properties of living cells using atomic force microscopy. J. Vis. Exp. 76, 50497 (2013). 2. Essmann, C. L. et al. In-vivo high resolution AFM topographic imaging of Caenorhabditis elegans reveals previously unreported surface structures of cuticle mutants. Nanomedicine 13, 183-189 (2017). 3. Goulam Houssen, Y., Gusachenko, I., Schanne-Klein, M. C. & Allain, J. M. Monitoring micrometer-scale collagen organization in rat-tail tendon upon mechanical strain using second harmonic microscopy. J. Biomech. 44, 2047 -- 2052 (2011). 4. Wang, S. & Larin, K. V. Shear wave imaging optical coherence tomography (SWI-OCT) for ocular tissue biomechanics. Opt. Lett. 39, 41-44 (2014). 5. Kennedy, K. M. et al. Quantitative micro-elastography: imaging of tissue elasticity using compression optical coherence elastography. Sci. Rep. 5, 15538 (2015). 6. Kennedy, B. F., Wijesinghe, P. & Sampson, D. D. The emergence of optical elastography in biomedicine. Nat. Photonics 11, 215 -- 221 (2017). 7. Vaughan, J. M. & Randall, J. T. Brillouin scattering, density and elastic properties of the lens and cornea of the eye. Nature 284, 489-491 (1980). 8. Koski, K. J., Akhenblit, P., McKiernan, K. & Yarger, J. L. Non-invasive determination of the complete elastic moduli of spider silks. Nat. Mater. 12, 262-267 (2013). 9. Palombo, F. et al. Biomechanics of fibrous proteins of the extracellular matrix studied by Brillouin scattering, J. R. Soc. Interface 11, 20140739 (2014). 10. Scarcelli, G. et al. Noncontact three-dimensional mapping of intracellular hydromechanical properties by Brillouin microscopy. Nat. Methods 12, 1132-1134 (2015). 11. Antonacci, G. et al. Quantification of plaque stiffness by Brillouin microscopy in experimental thin cap fibroatheroma. J. R. Soc. Interface 12, 20150483 (2015). 12. Lepert, G., Gouveia, R. M., Connonb, C. J. & Paterson, C. Assessing corneal biomechanics with Brillouin spectro- microscopy. Faraday Discuss. 187, 415-428 (2016). 13. Elsayad, K. et al. Mapping the subcellular mechanical properties of live cells in tissues with fluorescence emission-Brillouin imaging. Sci. Signal. 9, rs5 (2016). 14. Meng, Z., Traverso, A. J., Ballmann, C. W., Troyanova-Wood, M. A. & Yakovlev, V. V. Seeing cells in a new light: a renaissance of Brillouin spectroscopy. Adv. Opt. Photonics 8, 300-327 (2016). 15. Raghunathan, R. et al. Evaluating biomechanical properties of murine embryos using Brillouin microscopy and optical coherence tomography. J. Biomed. Opt. 22, 086013 (2017). 13 ziz16. Karampatzakis, A. et al. Probing the internal micromechanical properties of Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilms by Brillouin imaging. NPJ Biofilms Micro. 3, 20 (2017). 17. Mattana, S. et al. Non-contact mechanical and chemical analysis of single living cells by microspectroscopic techniques. Light Sci. Appl. 7, 17139 (2018). 18. Schlussler, R. et al. Mechanical mapping of spinal cord growth and repair in living zebrafish larvae by Brillouin imaging. Biophys. J. 115, 911-923 (2018). 19. Bevilacqua, C., Sánchez-Iranzo, H., Richter, D., Diz-Muñoz, A. & Prevedel, R. Imaging mechanical properties of sub-micron ECM in live zebrafish using Brillouin microscopy. Biomed. Opt. Express 10, 1420-1431 (2019). 20. Nikolić, M. & Scarcelli, G., Long-term Brillouin imaging of live cells with reduced absorption-mediated damage at 660nm wavelength. Biomed. Opt. Express 10, 1567-1580 (2019). 21. Chiao, R. Y., Townes, C. H. & Stoicheff, B. P. Stimulated Brillouin scattering and coherent generation of intense hypersonic waves. Phys. Rev. Lett. 12, 592-595 (1964). 22. Damzen, M. j. Stimulated Brillouin Scattering: Fundamentals and Applications (IOP Publishing, Bristol, 2003). 23. Boyd, R. W. Nonlinear Optics (Academic Press, New York, ed. 3, 2008). 24. Ballmann, C. W. et al. Stimulated Brillouin scattering microscopic imaging. Sci. Rep. 5, 18139 (2015). 25. Remer, I. & Bilenca, A. Background-free Brillouin spectroscopy in scattering media at 780 nm via stimulated Brillouin scattering. Opt. Lett. 41, 926-929 (2016) 26. Remer, I. & Bilenca, A. High-speed stimulated Brillouin scattering spectroscopy at 780 nm. APL Photonics 1, 061301 (2016). 27. Remer, I., Cohen, L. & Bilenca, A. High-speed continuous-wave stimulated Brillouin scattering spectrometer for material analysis. J. Vis. Exp. 127, e55527 (2017). 28. Remer, I. Stimulated Brillouin Scattering Microscopy. (Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, 2017). 29. Ballmann, C. W., Meng, Z., Traverso, A. J., Scully, M. O. & Yakovlev, V. V., Impulsive Brillouin microscopy. Optica. 4, 124-128 (2017). 30. Litovitz, T. A. & Davis, C. M. Physical Acoustics, (Academic, New York, 1965, Vol. 2A) 31. Freudiger, C. W. et al. Label-free biomedical imaging with high sensitivity by stimulated Raman scattering microscopy. Science 322, 1857-1861 (2008). 32. Kaletta, T. & Hengartner, M. O. Finding function in novel targets: C. elegans as a model organism. Nat. Rev. Drug Discov. 5, 387-399 (2006). 33. Mango, S. E. The C. elegans pharynx: a model for organogenesis. WormBook, 1-26 (2007). 10.1895/wormbook.1.129.1. 34. Choi, W. et al. Tomographic phase microscopy. Nat. Methods 4, 717 -- 719 (2007). 35. Park, S. J., Goodman, M. B. & Pruitt, B. L. Analysis of nematode mechanics by piezoresistive displacement clam. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U S A. 104, 17376-17381 (2007). 36. Sznitman, J., Purohit, P. K., Krajacic, P., Lamitina, T. & Arratia, P. E. Material properties of Caenorhabditis elegans swimming at low Reynolds number. Biophys. J. 98, 617-26 (2010). 37. Backholm, M., Ryu, W. S. & Dalnoki-Veress, K. Viscoelastic properties of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, a self-similar, shear-thinning worm. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci U S A. 110, 4528- 4533 (2013). 38. Gilpin, W., Uppaluri, S. & Brangwynne, C. P. Worms under pressure: bulk mechanical properties of C. elegans are Independent of the cuticle. Biophys J. 108, 1887-1898 (2015). 39. Fry, E. S., Emery, Y., Quan, X. & Katz, J. W. Accuracy limitations on Brillouin lidar measurements of temperature and sound speed in the ocean, Appl. Opt. 36, 6887-6894 (1997). 40. Schonle, A. & Hell, S. W. Heating by absorption in the focus of an objective lens. Opt. Lett. 23, 325-327 (1998). 41. Podeǎ, J., Procházka, O. & Medin, A. Studies on agaroses; 1. Specific refractive index increments in dimethyl sulfoxide and in water at various wavelengths and temperatures. Polymer 36, 4967-4970 (1995). 42. Polyanskiy, M. N. Refractive index database. Available at: http://www.refractiveindex.info (2008-2019). 43. Weast, R. C. Handbook of Chemistry and Physics (CRC Press, 1987). 14 Supplementary Information High Sensitivity and Specificity Biomechanical Imaging by Stimulated Brillouin Scattering Microscopy Itay Remer1,2, Netta Shemsesh3, Anat Ben-Zvi3 & Alberto Bilenca1,4* 1Biomedical Engineering Department, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, 1 Ben Gurion Blvd, Be'er-Sheva 84105, Israel 2Agilent Research Laboratories, 94 Shlomo Shmeltzer Road, Petach Tikva 4970602, Israel 3Department of Life Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, 1 Ben Gurion Blvd, Be'er Sheva 84105, Israel 4Ilse Katz Institute for Nanoscale Science and Technology, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, 1 Ben Gurion Blvd, Be'er-Sheva 84105, Israel e-mail: *[email protected] 15 Supplementary Fig. 1. Detailed schematic of the SBS microscope. (a) Near infrared (NIR) fiber-coupled pump and probe distributed feedback (DFB) lasers are collimated with collimators of 1 mm (C). The collimated, s-polarized probe laser beam (light red) is expanded by lenses L1 and L2, and is then right circularly polarized by a quarter wave plate (/4) and focused into the sample (S) by a 0.25 NA aspheric lens L3. The collimated, s-polarized pump laser beam (deep red) is filtered with a Bragg filter (BF) and is then expanded by lenses L4 and L5 and sinusoidally modulated by an acousto-optic modulator (AOM) at 1.1 MHz. Next, the beam is p-polarized by a half wave plate (/2) and transmitted through a polarizing beam splitter (PBS). The beam is subsequently left circularly polarized by a 16 quarter wave plate (/4) and focused by an aspheric lens L6 (same as lens L3) to the focal point of lens L3 in the sample. The backscattered SBG signal that modulates the intensity of the probe beam is collected with lens L6 and is then s- polarized by a quarter wave plate (/4) and reflected by the PBS. Next, the signal passes a rubidium notch filter (85Rb) at the pump frequency, and is detected by a transimpedance receiver (TIR), which comprises a large area photodiode (PD), a bias tee, and a transimpedance amplifier (TIA). The SBG signal in the ac output voltage of the TIR is measured by a lock-in amplifier (LIA). Two fiber splitters (FS) extract auxiliary beams from the pump and probe lasers, and a fast photodetector (FPD) and a frequency counter (FC) measure the beat frequency (or the difference frequency) between these beams. The SBG signal, the average probe power (measured by the dc output voltage of the TIR), the difference frequency measurement, and the probe laser current Iprobe are all sampled by a data acquisition card (DAQ) connected to a personal computer (PC) for further analysis and visualization. A wide halogen illumination and a CMOS camera co-register brightfield images in the microscope. The halogen beam is directed from a collimated fiber- coupled source to the sample through lenses L7 and L3 and a dichroic mirror (DM) that combines white and NIR light. The sample is imaged onto the camera via lenses L6 and L8, where a DM positioned after the PBS splits the NIR and white light for SBG and brightfield imaging, respectively. The camera is connected to a PC for further analysis and presentation. All folding mirrors (M) fit the microscope on a 18''×24'' breadboard that is vertically mounted on an optical table. (b) SBS imaging acquisition scheme. The sample stage controller initiates the beginning of a line scan and TTL-triggers the probe current Iprobe to start the frequency scans. The motorized stage raster scans the sample through the joint focus of lenses L3 and L6, while the probe laser scans the pump-probe frequency difference around the Brillouin shift of the sample and the LIA retrieves the SBG spectrum at a pixel. The TTL signal falls when the stage completes the line scan and this terminates the frequency scans and moves the stage to the next line scan. 17 Supplementary Fig. 2. Performance of the SBS microscope. (a) Noise density against detected power. Measurements (open circles) were made in double-distilled water at room temperature (20C) with only probe light excitation. To measure the noise density, the probe frequency ω2 was scanned around the Stokes frequency ω1 -- B (~ −5.05 GHz from the pump frequency ω1) over a 2-GHz bandwidth in 100 ms and the ac signal at the receiver was lock-in detected at a 1.1-MHz reference frequency. The noise density was calculated as the ratio of the standard deviation of the ac voltage to the square-root of the lock-in bandwidth (B = 138 Hz). The optical probe power was measured from the dc voltage at the receiver. The fit of the noise density measurements to the sum of three noise contributions is shown in a solid line. These noise contributions are the electrical noise density (125 nV/Hz), the shot noise density (2q  R  P where q is the electron's charge, R = 0.53 A/W is the photodetector responsivity, and P is the optical power of the probe beam) and the relative intensity noise of the laser (RIN  R2  P2 with RIN = 3.16  10-17 Hz-1). (b) SBG spectrum of double-distilled water at room temperature (20C). The spectrum (close circles) was acquired over a 2- GHz bandwidth in 2 ms. A total excitation power of 265 mW was used. The lorentzian fit to the measurements is shown in a red solid line. (c) Signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) against the acquisition time of the SBG spectrum of water. The SNR was evaluated as the ratio of the SBG peak power to the standard deviation of the noise skirt in the SBG spectrum over a 1-GHz bandwidth. Open circles and error bars represent mean value and standard deviation from the mean, respectively, as calculated from one hundred SBG spectra measured sequentially. A slope of ~10 dB/dec was obtained from the linear regression line, as expected from the direct dependence of the SNR on the acquisition time (25). (d) Precision of the Brillouin shift and linewidth measurements (B and B) against the acquisition time of the SBG spectrum of water. The precision was calculated as the standard deviation of the Brillouin shift and linewidth recovered from the lorentzian fits of one hundred SBG spectra measured sequentially. Dashed lines are drawn to guide the eye. 18 Supplementary Fig. 3. Sample mount for SBS imaging of live C. elegans nematodes. (a) Three-dimensional schematic and side view of the sample mount. Nematodes are sandwiched between 0.5-mm-thick agar pads each is mounted on a 0.17-mm-thick round glass coverslip of a different diameter (18 mm and 25 mm). (b) Top view of the sample mount. A few drops of UV glue are applied at the edge of the smaller coverslip and a thin layer of Vaseline seals the gap between the two coverslips, thereby fixing the entire sample and avoiding dehydration. 19 Supplementary Fig. 4. Photodamage in SBS imaging of live C. elegans nematodes. Brillouin shift B versus time for a live C. elegans worm. The Brillouin shift B was recovered from a double lorentzian fit of the SBG spectra measured over a 4-GHz bandwidth in 200 ms. For these measurements, a total excitation power of 265 mW was used, which is the same power level employed all through this work. Curve colors represent different spatial positions across the middle plane of the sample at which the measurements were taken (~25 m in depth). These positions are marked in the coregistered brightfield image with crosses of corresponding colors (scale bar, 20 m). Curve pale and dark shades indicate raw and ten-sample moving average data, respectively. 20 Supplementary Fig. 5. Estimation of the mass density and the complex longitudinal modulus of materials by SBS. (a) Brillouin shift B of methanol, dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), double-distilled water, and 1%, 5% and 10% agar/water gels at room temperature (20C). (b) Brillouin linewidth B of the different materials. (c) Normalized Brillouin line-center gain factor of the different materials. The spectral parameters (B, , ) were retrieved from the lorentzian fits of two hundred SBG spectra measured sequentially. Each spectrum was recorded over a bandwidth of 4 GHz in 200 ms by the SBS microscope with 0.033 NA focusing lenses and a total excitation power of 285 mW. (d) Mass density estimate for the different materials using Eq. (3) of Methods Section 5 with refractive index values of 1.315, 1.47, 1.329, 1.331, 1.337, and 1.345 for methanol, DMSO, double-distilled water, 1%, 5% and 10% agar/water gels, respectively. (e) Real part of the gigahertz-frequency longitudinal modulus M' for the different materials. (f) Imaginary part of the gigahertz-frequency longitudinal modulus M'' for the different materials. M' and M'' were calculated using Eq. (4) of Methods Section 5 with the Brillouin shift B and linewidth B values described in a and b, and the mass density estimates and refractive indices presented in d. 21 NBgNBgSupplementary Table I. Mean and standard deviation values for the Brillouin shift B, the Brillouin linewidth B, the normalized Brillouin line-center gain factor , the mass density estimate , and the real and imaginary parts of the gigahertz-frequency longitudinal modulus M' and M'' of methanol, DMSO, double-distilled water, and 1%, 5% and 10% agar/water gels at room temperature (20C). Literature values for the mass density are also presented43. 22 NBg
1701.09173	1	1701	2017-01-31T18:39:18	Asymmetry of short-term control of spatio-temporal gait parameters during treadmill walking	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	Optimization of energy cost determines average values of spatio-temporal gait parameters such as step duration, step length or step speed. However, during walking, humans need to adapt these parameters at every step to respond to exogenous and/or endogenic perturbations. While some neurological mechanisms that trigger these responses are known, our understanding of the fundamental principles governing step-by-step adaptation remains elusive. We determined the gait parameters of 20 healthy subjects with right-foot preference during treadmill walking at speeds of 1.1, 1.4 and 1.7 m/s. We found that when the value of the gait parameter was conspicuously greater (smaller) than the mean value, it was either followed immediately by a smaller (greater) value of the contralateral leg (interleg control), or the deviation from the mean value decreased during the next movement of ipsilateral leg (intraleg control). The selection of step duration and the selection of step length during such transient control events were performed in unique ways. We quantified the symmetry of short-term control of gait parameters and observed the significant dominance of the right leg in short-term control of all three parameters at higher speeds (1.4 and 1.7 m/s).	physics.bio-ph	physics	Asymmetry of short-term control of spatio-temporal gait parameters during treadmill walking Klaudia Kozlowska1,+, Miroslaw Latka1,+, and Bruce J. West2,+ 1Wroclaw University of Science and Technology, Faculty of Fundamental Problems of Technology, Department of Biomedical Engineering, Wroclaw, 50-370, Poland 2Army Research Office, Information Sciences Directorate, Research Triangle Park, 27709, USA [email protected] +each author contributed equally to this work ABSTRACT Optimization of energy cost determines average values of spatio-temporal gait parameters such as step duration, step length or step speed. However, during walking, humans need to adapt these parameters at every step to respond to exogenous and/or endogenic perturbations. While some neurological mechanisms that trigger these responses are known, our under- standing of the fundamental principles governing step-by-step adaptation remains elusive. We determined the gait parameters of 20 healthy subjects with right-foot preference during treadmill walking at speeds of 1.1, 1.4 and 1.7 m/s. We found that when the value of the gait parameter was conspicuously greater (smaller) than the mean value, it was either followed imme- diately by a smaller (greater) value of the contralateral leg (interleg control), or the deviation from the mean value decreased during the next movement of ipsilateral leg (intraleg control). The selection of step duration and the selection of step length during such transient control events were performed in unique ways. We quantified the symmetry of short-term control of gait parameters and observed the significant dominance of the right leg in short-term control of all three parameters at higher speeds (1.4 and 1.7 m/s). Introduction It has been known for over a century that the stride interval of human gait is remarkably stable. Small fluctuations of approxi- mately 3 -- 4% were attributed to the complexity of the locomotor system and treated as an uncorrelated random process.1 From this viewpoint, the discovery of long-time, fractal correlations in stride-interval time series was unexpected.2, 3 Those early papers not only spurred interest in the emerging concept of fractal physiology,4 but also shifted the focus of quantitative gait analysis from average values of typical parameters (e.g. stride intervals) to their temporal variability. That profound change of perspective brought new insights into locomotor manifestations of Huntington's and Parkinson's diseases, aging, and the connection between gait dynamics and fall risk, see5 and references therein. From a plethora of physiologically accessible gait patterns, humans employ only walking and running. Walking feels easiest at low speeds, and running feels easiest when moving faster. Optimization of energy cost underlies not only the choice of gait,6 -- 8 but also determines average values of gait parameters, such as step length and duration.10 During walking, humans need to adapt their spatio-temporal gait parameters at every step to be able to respond to exogenous (e.g. irregularities of walking surface) and/or endogenic (neuromuscular noise) perturbations.11 While some neurological mechanisms that trigger these responses are known,12 -- 15 the fundamental principles governing step-by-step adaptation remain elusive.16 Treadmill walking, especially at high speeds, presents challenges that can be met only through effective short-term control of spatio-temporal gait parameters. In order to stay on a treadmill, the subject's step duration and length must yield a step speed which can fluctuate over a narrow range centered on the treadmill belt's speed. The results of previous experiments with walking on a split-belt treadmill underscore the intricacies of such aggregation. In particular, spatial and temporal controls of locomotion are accessible through distinct neural circuits17 and neural control of intra- versus interlimb parameters (calculated using values from both legs, e.g., step length, double support) during walking is to a large extent independent.18 Herein, we investigate the dynamics of time series of gait parameters (step duration, length and speed) following a sudden, large deviation from the mean value. In particular, we test the hypothesis that whenever the value of a gait parameter is markedly greater (smaller) than the mean value, it is either immediately followed by a smaller (greater) value of the contralateral leg (interleg control), or the deviation from the mean value decreases during the next movement of ipsilateral leg (intraleg control). Said differently, during treadmill walking errors are not gradually attenuated via long-term corrections, but are corrected immediately by the same or opposite leg. Taking into account differences in the relative contribution of lower limbs Table 1. The statistics of the occurrence of intraleg (columns L-L and R-R) and interleg (columns R-L and L-R) control mechanisms that are evoked in response to errors in step duration, length and velocity. Statistics are presented for three values of treadmill speed v. The number of errors, defined as abrupt deviations from the moving average value, is presented in the Total column. The column labeled NC gives the number of errors that persisted for more than two successive steps. The Left and Right columns show the number of control events performed by each leg. Probabilities of occurrence of intra- and interleg control mechanisms are listed in the last four columns. v [m/s] Total NC L-L R-L R-R L-R Left [%] Right [%] pLL pRL pRR pLR 1.1 1.4 1.7 1.1 1.4 1.7 1.1 1.4 1.7 180 121 103 380 257 186 393 275 189 4 11 5 14 12 18 5 14 8 42 29 22 125 73 42 51 21 18 71 30 17 83 63 34 115 61 45 32 18 26 122 93 87 84 61 66 step duration 51 42 32 53 45 41 step length 54 48 42 49 22 35 step speed 51 48 44 106 76 36 47 55 59 46 58 65 49 52 56 0.23 0.24 0.21 0.28 0.17 0.17 0.18 0.15 0.25 0.28 0.35 0.31 0.33 0.28 0.23 0.19 0.12 0.09 0.32 0.36 0.47 0.13 0.19 0.12 0.21 0.23 0.18 0.29 0.22 0.24 0.21 0.22 0.35 0.27 0.28 0.19 to control and propulsion -- the effect known as functional gait asymmetry,19 we further hypothesize that in subjects with right foot preference the short-term control of gait spatio-temporal parameters is stronger for the right leg. Results In Table 1 we recorded data which are crucial for testing the main hypothesis of the paper: that errors in gait parameters are e corrected immediately by the same or opposite leg. Let us focus on the first row of this table which concerns step duration control at a treadmill speed of 1.1 m/s. There were 180 "errors" defined as abrupt changes in step duration (equations 2-4). For the left leg, in 42 cases (column L-L), the deviation of step duration from the mean value did not trigger a compensating change in the step duration of the right leg. The value of the control parameter DLR, defined by equation 5, greater than 1 indicates the absence of such adjustment. However, the deviation decreased during the next left step as indicated by the value of intraleg control parameter DLL, defined by equation 7, smaller than 1 (the statistics of both inter- and intraleg control parameters are presented in Table 2). In other words, for the left leg, we observed intraleg control of step duration in 42 cases. In 51 cases (column R-L), the change in the step duration of the left leg compensated the deviation of step duration of the previous right step (interleg control). By adding columns L-L and R-L, we obtain 93 control events performed by the left leg. This number expressed as the percentage of all 180 control events is given in the column of Table 1 labeled as Left. Please note that only in 4 (column NC) out of 180 cases (2.2%), the appearance of a step duration error did not evoke either of the control mechanisms. For all three gait parameters, the number of errors decreases with speed. For example, there were 180 errors in step duration at v = 1.1 m/s but only 103 at v = 1.7 m/s (a 43% reduction). A comparable drop in the number of errors was observed for step length (51%) and velocity (52%). Less than half of these changes can be explained by the 22% reduction of the number of steps taken by all the subjects at v = 1.7 m/s in comparison with v = 1.1 m/s. Please note that the number of steps decreases with treadmill speed since at each speed, the subjects were asked to cover the same distance of 400 m. It is worth emphasizing that there were approximately twice as many errors in step length and speed than in step duration. For all three parameters: step duration, length, and speed, in at least 90% of cases, the deviations from the mean value decreased during the subsequent two steps via either intra- or interleg control. Regardless of treadmill belt speed, the control of step length is predominately intraleg (Table 1). For example, for the left leg at the lowest speed, the probability of evoking intraleg control pLL = 0.33 is 42% greater than that of interleg control pRL = 0.19). In the same condition, for the right leg such difference is equal to 59% ( pRR = 0.32 vs pLR = 0.13). There is no such pattern for the other two gait parameters. 2/11 Table 2. The values of intra- and interleg control parameters for treadmill walking. Data are presented as mean (standard deviation). v [m/s] DLL DRL DRR DLR DBEL DBER D DBE [%] step duration 0.34 (0.22) 0.45 (0.26) 0.31 (0.25) 0.55 (0.26) 0.55 (0.25) 0.63 (0.20) 0.43 (0.25) 0.31 (0.22) 0.36 (0.28) 0.58 (0.21) 0.54 (0.24) 0.49 (0.26) step length 0.46 (0.26) 0.46 (0.27) 0.44 (0.26) 0.72 (0.23) 0.79 (0.16) 0.79 (0.15) 0.48 (0.25) 0.45 (0.26) 0.44 (0.27) 0.62 (0.30) 0.61 (0.30) 0.68 (0.23) step speed 0.44 (0.26) 0.39 (0.25) 0.51 (0.26) 0.65 (0.26) 0.68 (0.24) 0.73 (0.20) 0.40 (0.27) 0.33 (0.23) 0.41 (0.24) 0.56 (0.28) 0.56 (0.29) 0.58 (0.27) 1.20 0.85 0.97 0.98 0.76 0.63 0.92 0.91 0.68 0.91 1.12 1.34 0.88 1.12 1.24 1.01 1.15 1.19 1.1 1.4 1.7 1.1 1.4 1.7 1.1 1.4 1.7 28 -28 -32 11 -38 -65 -9 -23 -55 For step duration, length, and speed, the control parameter D was independent of speed (Table 2). For all three gait parameters, both for the right and left leg, the mean value of D for interleg control was greater than that of intraleg control. For example, for step duration at v = 1.1m/s DRL = 0.55 and DLL = 0.34. The difference between the values of intra- and interleg control parameters for a given leg was statistically significant for all three treadmill speeds for step length: • at 1.1 m/s: ple f t < 1 × 10−4, pright = 6 × 10−3; • at 1.4 m/s: ple f t < 1 × 10−4, pright = 3 × 10−2; • at 1.7 m/s: ple f t = 1 × 10−4, pright = 2 × 10−3; as well as the step speed: • at 1.1 m/s: ple f t < 1 × 10−4, pright = 6 × 10−4; • at 1.4 m/s: ple f t < 1 × 10−4, pright < 1 × 10−4; • at 1.7 m/s: ple f t = 2 × 10−3, pright = 9 × 10−3. For step duration such differences were not so strongly pronounced: • at 1.1 m/s: ple f t = 5 × 10−4, pright = 5 × 10−2; • at 1.7 m/s: ple f t = 2 × 10−3. With the exception of step duration and step length at the lowest speed (v = 1.1 m/s), the asymmetry parameter D DBE was smaller than zero indicating a dominant role of the right leg in short-term control of gait parameters during treadmill walking. Table 3 shows the probability of compensatory response to errors in gait spatio-temporal parameters for intra- (L-L, R- R) and interleg (L-R, R-L) control. Such response corresponds to negative values of variables Sinter (equation 6) and Sintra (equation 8). For all speeds and parameters, the probability of interleg compensation is close to 1, roughly two times higher than that of intraleg response. 3/11 Table 3. Probability of compensation of errors in gait spatio-temporal parameters for intra- (L-L, R-R) and interleg (L-R, R-L) control. Statistics are presented for three values of treadmill speed v. v [m/s] L-L R-R L-R R-L L-L R-R L-R R-L L-L R-R L-R R-L step duration 0.98 0.42 0.95 0.39 0.54 0.97 0.50 0.28 0.50 0.94 0.95 0.94 0.40 0.42 0.40 step length 0.83 0.38 0.82 0.34 0.43 0.95 1.1 1.4 1.7 0.83 0.80 0.76 0.52 0.52 0.32 step speed 0.92 0.55 0.93 0.46 0.44 0.95 0.92 0.92 0.89 Discussion In overground walking with self-selected speed, fluctuations of stride interval, length, and speed exhibit persistent fractal scaling characterized by a Hurst exponent a > 0.5.2, 3, 20 Auditory metronomic cueing changes fractal statistics of stride intervals from persistent to antipersistent (a < 0.5).21 The super central pattern generator model, introduced by West and Scafeta,22 elucidates the dynamic origin of such transitions. In particular, the transitions result from the driving of a fractal clock, which retains its properties under perturbation. In treadmill walking, fluctuations of interstride interval and stride length are also persistent. However, the time series of stride speed is antipersistent, which is a manifestion of increased central control of this gait parameter.16, 23 Terrier has recently demonstrated that visual cueing (alignment of step lengths with marks on the floor) also induced anti-correlated pattern in gait parameters.30 To a large extent, fluctuations of spatio-temporal gait parameters result from the intrinsic fractal properties of pattern gen- erators. Hidden in these fluctuations are sporadic control events, triggered to accomplish a locomotor task such as remaining on a moving treadmill belt. This is why we study the dynamics of time series of gait parameters that follow a sudden large deviation from a mean value. For lack of a better word, we dubbed such events errors, but emphasize that they may originate either from the failure of the motor control system, or from the necessary adjustment of the subject's position on a treadmill. While the definition of such events is arbitrary (equations 2-4), it satisfies the research objective. We found that when the value of the gait parameter (step duration, length or speed) was conspicuously greater (smaller) than the mean value, it was either followed immediately by a smaller (greater) value of the contralateral leg (interleg control), or the deviation from the mean value decreased during the next movement of ipsilateral leg (intraleg control). The existence of distinct short-term control of step frequency (the inverse of step duration) was demonstrated by Snaterse et al.24 The time evolution of step frequency triggered by sudden stepwise increments in treadmill speed was modeled by the sum of two exponentially decaying terms. The time constant of the first term was 1.44 ± 1.14 s and its amplitude was two times larger than that of the second term, whose time constant was 27.56 ± 16.18s. For those values of time constants, step frequency adjustments were two-thirds complete in less than two seconds. Snaterse et al. argued that the first term represents a rapid pre- programmed response, while the slower one models fine-tuning of step frequency driven by energy expenditure optimization. Herein we extended this line of reasoning by demonstrating that short-term control of gait parameters may be realized using intra- and interleg adjustments. The better understanding of short-term control mechanisms does not bring us any closer to understanding how, during treadmill walking, persistent stochastic variables: step duration and step length are combined to yield antipersistent step speed. We believe that a different mechanism operating at a longer time scale underlies this effect. There are fundamental differences between the control of step duration and step length. The probability of evoking intraleg control of step length at the highest treadmill speed ( v = 1.7m/s) is approximately three times greater than that of evoking interleg control. There is no such distinct pattern for step duration. Moreover, the number of errors in step duration is half that of step length, regardless of treadmill belt speed. This is a strong indication that spatial and temporal controls of locomotion are accessible through distinct neural circuits. This interpretation is corroborated by the earlier study of Malone and Bastian, who investigated adaptation of spatial and temporal aspects of walking to a sustained perturbation, generated by a split-belt treadmill.18 They demonstrated that conscious correction facilitates adaptation, whereas distraction slows it. The unexpected finding of their study was that those manipulations affected the adaptation rate of the spatial elements of walking, but not of the temporal ones. In the follow-up study Malone et al25 demonstrated that temporal and spatial controls of symmetric gait can be adapted independently. Please note that continuous, conscious assessment of distance to surrounding objects lies at the heart of the control problem of remaining stationary on a moving treadmill belt. Thus, the large number of errors in step length as compared to step duration may reflect both the dominant role of spatial control and its susceptibility to distraction. It is worth mentioning that in casual walking, the coefficient of variation of stride time is much smaller than that of stride length and of walking speed.10 Step speed may be interpreted as the output of the intricate neuromuscular control system, which integrates different 4/11 sensory-motor processes. The ratio of average values of step length and frequency, or walk ratio, is constant over a broad range of walking speeds. In other words, there is a linear relation between these gait parameters (the stride length -- cadence relationship), a pre-programmed pattern which presumably simplifies gait control in steady state walking.26 Let us analyze the interplay of step duration and step length during transient changes following the occurrence of errors. We previously pointed out that these two parameters are controlled in distinct ways. In particular, the probability of evoking the interleg control of step length is at least two times smaller than that of evoking the intraleg control (Table 1). In sharp contrast, the probability of either inter- or intraleg control of step speeds is comparable. Thus, we may hypothesize that negative-feedback adjustment of step duration of the contralateral leg underlies the interleg control of step speed. It is worth emphasizing that the intraleg control of step speed is stronger than the interleg control. The recent work of Dingwell et al.16 provides insight into the maintenance of speed during treadmill walking. A subject can in principle choose any combination of stride length and time that yields step speed equal to that of a treadmill belt. These pairs of values form in phase-space a diagonal line called a goal equivalent manifold (GEM).27 Dingwell et al. decomposed deviation from this manifold into tangent and transverse components. Only the latter component was tightly controlled. Moreover, the time series of transverse deviations exhibited statistical antipersistence characteristic of stride speed. This study underscores the significance of interleg control of gait parameters. We believe that the GEM decomposition should be applied to time series of step velocities to quantify the interleg control in a more sophisticated way. In able-bodied gait, asymmetry in spatio-temporal and kinematic parameters (such as speed profiles, step and stride length, foot placement angle, maximum knee flexion) for the left and right leg has been frequently reported.28 To the best of our knowledge, the present study is the first observation of asymmetry in dynamics of human gait parameters. With the exception of step duration control at the lowest speed, for all three gait parameters D DBE < 0, indicating dominance of the right leg in short-term control. The origin of this asymmetry can be traced back to differences in the relative contribution of lower limbs to control and propulsion -- the effect known as functional gait asymmetry.19 More specifically, the leg with greater muscle power generation dominates propulsion, while the support and control functions are more conspicuous for the leg with greater power absorption. Humans are typically right-footed for mobilization and left-footed for postural stabilization. Special consideration should be given to step duration and step length control at the lowest speed v = 1.1m/s. Only in this case, the asymmetry parameter D DBE was greater than zero, indicating the dominance of left lower limb. Note that the lowest asymmetry, D DBE, was observed for all three parameters at v = 1.1m/s. Differences in low-speed gait have been reported before. Terrier and Schutz29 demonstrated that during overground walking, at low speeds the majority of subjects adopted a higher walk ratio and had a higher variability of stride time. However, in this study the lowest treadmill speed coincides with the preferred walking speed (PWS) of young subjects.23 There are two possible explanations for the positive value of D DBE. It is likely that in the vicinity of PWS priority is given to balance maintenance and consequently stride duration control is shifted to the left leg, which is used for postural stabilization. Please note that our cohort included only subjects with clearly pronounced right foot preference. Alternatively, reversed asymmetry for step duration and low values of D DBE for step length and step speed may indicate that there exists a different strategy for control of gait parameters in overground walking (treadmill walking at v = 1.1m/s may not be challenging for young subjects and may resemble unconstrained overground walking). This argument is plausible because in motor coordination tasks, humans correct only those deviations that interfere with task goals and allow variability in redundant (task-irrelevant) dimensions.31 Following the logic of this minimum inter- vention principle, in treadmill walking, step speed must be tightly regulated. However, in overground walking, higher priority may be given, for example, to balance control, which would affect the value of the asymmetry parameter D DBE. These two qualitatively different strategies may also reflect other fundamental differences between overground and treadmill walking. The rate at which the environment flows past the eyes seems to be an important mechanism for regulating walking speed.32, 33 More specifically, vision is used correctively to maintain walking speed at a value that is perceived to be optimal. For treadmill walking, a discrepancy between observed and expected visual flow leads to a significant reduction (about 20%) of PWS,34 as well as the speeds of walk-run and run-walk transitions.32 It is worth pointing out that as far as kinetic and kinematic parameters are concerned, treadmill and outdoor gaits are similar.35 The discovery of dependence of functional asymmetry in short-term control of gait spatio-temporal parameters on treadmill speed was an unexpected outcome of this research. The elucidation of the transition from left-leg to right-leg dominance in short-term control entails determination of the PWS for each subject. Further research is also needed to understand why the probability of compensatory response for interleg control is close to 1 and is almost two times greater than that of intraleg control (Table 3). Undoubtedly, such a strong difference indicates different roles these two mechanism play in control of gait during treadmill walking. One may hypothesize that the primary goal of interleg control is maintenance of balance via negative feedback from either leg while achieving specific goals such as matching the speed of the treadmill belt requires intraleg adjustments. During human locomotion, the legs act as two coupled oscillators.36 However, most studies disregard bilateral coordination and synchronization dynamics37 -- 39 and focus on single-leg variability (stride time, length, speed). Herein we demonstrated 5/11 asymmetric short-term intra- and interleg control of spatio-temporal gait parameters. We believe that a better understanding of these effects will not only pave the way for more realistic models of gait variability and control, but also help to refine procedures used in rehabilitation of gait impairments. Methods We recruited 20 healthy students (10M/10F, mean(SD): age 22 yr (2), height 1.73 m (0.1), weight 71 (15) kg, BMI 23 (4)) of the Wroclaw University of Science and Technology, who all signed an informed consent. The study was performed according to the Declaration of Helsinki and the protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee of Wroclaw Medical University. The subjects were screened to exclude those with a history of orthopedic problems, recent lower extremity injuries, any visible gait anomalies, or who were taking medications that might have influenced their gait. We only enrolled subjects who used the right leg to: kick a tennis ball, manipulate a tennis ball around a circle, make a first step, make a step after being pushed from behind. These purely bilateral tasks are frequently incorporated into foot-preference inventories.40, 41 The protocol began with a 5 min familiarization period of walking on a level motor-driven treadmill. Then each subject was asked to walk 400 m three times at 1.1 m/s, 1.4 m/s i 1.7 m/s (4 km/h, 5 km/h and 6 km/h). The objective was to investigate control of gait parameters at treadmill speeds equal to or greater than the PWS of young subjects. Therefore, the lowest speed was equal to the preferred walking speed reported by Terrier and Deriaz23 and slightly smaller than the values determined by Dal et al.34 (1.19 m/s) and Dingwell11 (1.22 m/s). The gait parameters were extracted from the trajectories of the 30 mm optical markers attached to both shoes below the ankle. The movements of those markers were recorded using an in-house motion capture system with a frame rate of 240 Hz and 720p resolution. The optical tracking was implemented in C++ (Visual Studio 2013) using OpenCV library. A heel strike was defined as the point where the marker of the forward foot was at its most forward point during each gait cycle. A step length was the distance between the ipsilateral and contralateral heel strikes. A step duration was equal to the elapsed time between the ipsilateral and contralateral heel strikes. A step speed was calculated as the quotient of step length and step duration. The group averaged number of steps taken per trial was equal to 593 (23) at 1.1 m/s, 508 (59) at 1.4m/s, and 456 (56) at 1.7 m/s. In Fig. 1 we present a time series of step duration for treadmill walking at 1.1 m/s. The circle in this figure indicates step duration that was longer than the mean value (represented in this figure by horizontal, thick, dotted line) by more than 3/2 of standard deviation (the upper, horizontal, thin dotted gridline represents this threshold). It is apparent that the duration of the step, which immediately follows the "error", suddenly decreases (this shorter interval is marked by the filled rectangle). This example hints at the existence of an interleg control mechanism that stabilizes the stride interval. 0.56 0.54 0.52 0.5 0.48 ] s [ n o i t a r u d p e t s compensation 0.46 60 error left right 65 70 75 80 85 90 time [s] Figure 1. Time series of step durations for treadmill walking at 4 km/h. The circle indicates the step duration of left leg which was longer than the mean value (represented in this figure by horizontal, thick, dotted line) by more than 3 ⁄ 2 of standard deviation (the upper, horizontal, thin dotted gridline represents this threshold). It is apparent that the duration of the step which immediately follows the "error" suddenly decreases. Let N be the number of steps taken by each leg. Let us introduce a notation that facilitates the analysis of interleg control. n=1 in the following We write the time series of length 2N of one of the gait parameters (step duration, length or speed) {Sn}2N form: {Sn} = {I1,C1,I2,C2...IN,CN} , (1) 6/11 s I and s C are where subseries(cid:8)I j(cid:9)N standard deviations of these series. The simple moving averages (the unweighted mean of the previous m data) of (cid:8)I j(cid:9) and (cid:8)Cj(cid:9) are denoted by ¯I(m) and ¯C(m), respectively. j=1 correspond to the ipsilateral and the contralateral leg, respectively. j=1 and (cid:8)Cj(cid:9)N We define as errors these values Ii which satisfy all of the following criteria: Ii − ¯I(m) > 1.5s I Ii − Ii−1 (cid:12) > 3% (cid:12) (cid:12)(cid:12) (cid:12) < 0.5s C Ci−1 − ¯C(m)(cid:12) (cid:12) (cid:12) 100%(cid:12) (cid:12) (cid:12)(cid:12) Ii−1 (2) (3) (4) These undoubtedly heuristic criteria are used to detect abrupt changes (equation (3)) which lead to conspicuous deviations from the moving average value (equation (2)) and which are not brought about by a deviation in the preceding step of the contralateral leg (equation (4)). As previously mentioned, we dub such events errors, but bear in mind that they may originate either from the motor control system failure, or from the necessary adjustment of the subject's position on a treadmill. The rationale for using the moving average in the above definition of an error stems from non-stationarity of gait time series. This modification ensures that during transient linear trends the large deviation from the global mean value does not invoke the detection algorithm. Please note that equation (3) by itself is another safeguard for false error detection caused by the transient drift of local mean value. Herein, we report the values for m = 10. to denote a deviation of a given gait parameter from its moving average value, e.g. D Ii = Ii − ¯I(m). In interleg control the gait parameter of contralateral leg Ci changes in such a way as to decrease deviation of Ii + Ci. To quantify such stabilization, we introduce the following metric: Let us use D Dinter i = D Ii + D Ci D Ii + D Ci−1 . (5) The stabilization occurs when Dinter two cases. In the first case the D Ci has the opposite sign to D Ii: i < 1. The numerator in the above equation may become smaller than the denominator in i = D IiD Ci < 0, Sinter (6) in other words, the contralateral leg compensates for errors, as shown in Fig. 2a. The perfect compensation corresponds to Dinter = 0. In the alternative scenario, only the magnitude of the deviation of the contralateral leg from the mean value decreases ( Sinter i > 0) as illustrated by Fig. 2b. i Figure 2. In interleg control the gait parameter of contralateral leg Ci changes in such a way as to decrease deviation of Ii +Ci from the mean value. a) The error of ipsilateral leg Ii is immediately compensated for by the contralateral leg. b) In the alternative scenario, only the magnitude of the deviation of the contralateral leg from the mean value decreases. It is possible that an error does not bring about a sudden change of gait parameter of contralateral leg. In this case, >= 1. However, stabilization may occur during the next step of ipsilateral leg. The change of Ii+1 may reduce the Dinter deviation D Ii+1 + D Ci. We refer to such a scenario as an intraleg control and define a corresponding metric: i Dintra i = D Ii+1 + D Ci D Ii + D Ci . (7) 7/11 To be able to directly compare the properties of both types of control (inter- and intraleg) we distinguish whether the intraleg control was achieved via compensation: i = D IiD Ii+1 < 0, Sintra (8) as shown in Fig. 3a, or by the reduction of the magnitude of the displacement of gait parameter of the ispislateral leg from the moving average value (Fig. 3b). Figure 3. The error in a gait spatio-temporal parameter may not evoke a sudden change of the parameter of contralateral leg. However, the deviation of the next ipsilateral gait parameter Ii+1 from the mean value ¯I may decrease as a result of: a) compensation or b) the reduction of the magnitude of the displacement of parameter of the ispislateral leg from the mean value. The flowchart in Fig. 4 elucidates the analysis of the dynamics of gait parameter time series which follows the occurrence of errors. Using Dinter and Dintra, we detect the activation of inter- and intraleg control mechanism, respectively. Figure 4. Flowchart of analysis of dynamics of gait parameter which follows an error -- gait-parameter's value which satisfy the criteria described by equations (2-4). In our analysis of the experimental data, we use a more specific notation for the interleg parameter Dinter. For example, to indicate that an error in a given gait parameter of the left leg was followed by an adjustment of this parameter by the right 8/11 leg, we write DLR. In the same vein, we use DLL , DRR to denote intraleg leg control parameter for the left and right leg, respectively. In most cases D values, for a given gait parameter, speed, and control type, were not normally distributed (the Shapiro- Wilk test). For a given speed and gait parameter, the Levene's test showed equality of variances among the control types (with the exception of step duration at 1.1 m/s and step length at all speeds). For a given gait parameter and control type (L-L, R-R, L-R, R-L), we investigated the dependence of D on treadmill speed. In this case, the Levene's test showed homogeneity of variance. Consequently, the Kruskal-Wallis test with Tukey's post hoc comparisons was used to detect differences across speed and control type. The significance threshold was set to 0.05. To quantify functional asymmetry in control of gait spatio-temporal parameters we need to take into account the stochastic aspect of motor control system. Let us employ an analogy of detailed balance equation of statistical physics42 and call it gait detailed balance equation (DBE). In its original formulation, detailed balancing relates the relative population of two states by the probability of a transition between them. The principle applies equally well to physical systems, mathematical probability densities, or statistical processes in a variety of forms. The smaller D the better stabilization of stride gait parameters. Consequently, the influence of a control mechanism (inter or intra) on gait parameters is proportional to its probability of occurrence and the inverse of the corresponding mean value of control parameter ¯D. For example, for the right lower limb, we may write: DBER = pRR ¯DRR + pLR ¯DLR , in the same vein, for the left lower limb: DBEL = pLL ¯DLL + pRL ¯DRL . The perfect symmetry corresponds to the following equality: DBEL = DBER. We quantify the asymmetry in control of gait spatio-temporal parameters with the relative difference expression: D DBE = 2 DBEL − DBER DBEL + DBER . (9) (10) (11) (12) References 1. West, B. J. & Griffin, L. A. Biodynamics: Why the Wirewalker Doesn't Fall (Wiley, 2004). 2. Hausdorff, J. M., Peng, C. K., Ladin, Z., Wei, J. Y. & Goldberger, A. L. Is walking a random walk? Evidence for long- range correlations in stride interval of human gait. Journal of applied physiology (Bethesda, Md. : 1985) 78, 349 -- 58 (1995). 3. Hausdorff, J. M. et al. Fractal dynamics of human gait: stability of long-range correlations in stride interval fluctuations. Journal of applied physiology (Bethesda, Md. : 1985) 80, 1448 -- 57 (1996). 4. Bassingthwaighte, J. B., West, B. J. & Liebovitch, L. S. Fractal Physiology (Oxford University Press, 1994). 5. Hausdorff, J. M. Gait dynamics, fractals and falls: finding meaning in the stride-to-stride fluctuations of human walking. Human movement science 26, 555 -- 89 (2007). 6. Zarrugh, M. Y., Todd, F. N. & Ralston, H. J. Optimization of energy expenditure during level walking. European journal of applied physiology and occupational physiology 33, 293 -- 306 (1974). 7. Srinivasan, M. & Ruina, A. Computer optimization of a minimal biped model discovers walking and running. Nature 439, 72 -- 75 (2006). 8. Srinivasan, M. & Ruina, A. Idealized walking and running gaits minimize work. Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 463, 2429 -- 2446 (2007). 9. Diedrich, F. J. & Warren, W. H. Why change gaits? Dynamics of the walk-run transition. Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance 21, 183 -- 202 (1995). 10. Kito, T. & Yoneda, T. Dominance of gait cycle duration in casual walking. Human movement science 25, 383 -- 92 (2006). 9/11 11. Dingwell, J. B. & Marin, L. C. Kinematic variability and local dynamic stability of upper body motions when walking at different speeds. Journal of biomechanics 39, 444 -- 52 (2006). 12. Zehr, E. P. & Stein, R. B. What functions do reflexes serve during human locomotion? Progress in neurobiology 58, 185 -- 205 (1999). 13. Warren, W. H., Kay, B. A., Zosh, W. D., Duchon, A. P. & Sahuc, S. Optic flow is used to control human walking. Nature neuroscience 4, 213 -- 6 (2001). 14. Bent, L. R. et al. When is vestibular information important during walking? Journal of neurophysiology 92, 1269 -- 1275 (2004). 15. Rossignol, S., Dubuc, R., Gossard, J.-P. & Dubuc, J. Dynamic Sensorimotor Interactions in Locomotion. Physiological Reviews 86, 89 -- 154 (2006). 16. Dingwell, J. B., John, J. & Cusumano, J. P. Do humans optimally exploit redundancy to control step variability in walking? PLoS computational biology 6, e1000856 (2010). 17. Reisman, D. S., Block, H. J. & Bastian, A. J. Interlimb coordination during locomotion: what can be adapted and stored? Journal of neurophysiology 94, 2403 -- 2415 (2005). 18. Malone, L. a. & Bastian, A. J. Thinking about walking: effects of conscious correction versus distraction on locomotor adaptation. Journal of neurophysiology 103, 1954 -- 1962 (2010). 19. Sadeghi, H., Allard, P. & Duhaime, M. Functional gait asymmetry in able-bodied subjects. Human Movement Science 16, 243 -- 258 (1997). 20. Terrier, P., Turner, V. & Schutz, Y. GPS analysis of human locomotion: further evidence for long-range correlations in stride-to-stride fluctuations of gait parameters. Human movement science 24, 97 -- 115 (2005). 21. Deligni`eres, D. & Torre, K. Fractal dynamics of human gait: a reassessment of the 1996 data of Hausdorff et al. Journal of applied physiology (Bethesda, Md. : 1985) 106, 1272 -- 1279 (2009). 22. West, B. J. & Scafetta, N. Nonlinear dynamical model of human gait. Phys. Rev. E 67, 051917 (2003). 23. Terrier, P. & D´eriaz, O. Persistent and anti-persistent pattern in stride-to-stride variability of treadmill walking: influence of rhythmic auditory cueing. Human movement science 31, 1585 -- 97 (2012). 24. Snaterse, M., Ton, R., Kuo, A. D. & Donelan, J. M. Distinct fast and slow processes contribute to the selection of preferred step frequency during human walking. Journal of applied physiology (Bethesda, Md. : 1985) 110, 1682 -- 1690 (2011). 25. Malone, L. A., Bastian, A. J. & Torres-Oviedo, G. How does the motor system correct for errors in time and space during locomotor adaptation? Journal of Neurophysiology 108, 672 -- 683 (2012). 26. Egerton, T., Danoudis, M., Huxham, F. & Iansek, R. Central gait control mechanisms and the stride length - cadence relationship. Gait and Posture 34, 178 -- 182 (2011). 27. Cusumano, J. P. & Cesari, P. Body-goal variability mapping in an aiming task. Biological Cybernetics 94, 367 -- 379 (2006). 28. Sadeghi, H., Allard, P., Prince, F. & Labelle, H. Symmetry and limb dominance in able-bodied gait: a review. Gait & posture 12, 34 -- 45 (2000). 29. Terrier, P. & Schutz, Y. Variability of gait patterns during unconstrained walking assessed by satellite positioning (GPS). European Journal of Applied Physiology 90, 554 -- 561 (2003). 30. Terrier, P. Fractal Fluctuations in Human Walking: Comparison Between Auditory and Visually Guided Stepping. Annals of biomedical engineering 44, 2785 -- 2793 (2016). 31. Todorov, E. & Jordan, M. Optimal feedback control as a theory of motor coordination. Nature neuroscience 5, 1226 -- 1235 (2002). 32. Mohler, B. J., Thompson, W. B., Creem-Regehr, S. H., Pick, H. L. & Warren, W. H. Visual flow influences gait transition speed and preferred walking speed. Experimental Brain Research 181, 221 -- 228 (2007). 33. O'Connor, S. M. & Donelan, J. M. Fast visual prediction and slow optimization of preferred walking speed. Journal of Neurophysiology 107, 2549 -- 2559 (2012). 34. Dal, U., Erdogan, T., Resitoglu, B. & Beydagi, H. Determination of preferred walking speed on treadmill may lead to high oxygen cost on treadmill walking. Gait & posture 31, 366 -- 9 (2010). 10/11 35. Riley, P. O. et al. A kinematics and kinetic comparison of overground and treadmill running. Medicine and science in sports and exercise 40, 1093 -- 100 (2008). 36. Beek, P. J., Peper, C. E. & Stegeman, D. F. Dynamical models of movement coordination. Human Movement Science 14, 573 -- 608 (1995). 37. Bartsch, R. et al. Fluctuation and synchronization of gait intervals and gait force profiles distinguish stages of Parkinson's disease. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications 383, 455 -- 465 (2007). 38. Krasovsky, T. et al. Stability of gait and interlimb coordination in older adults. Journal of Neurophysiology 107, 2560 -- 2569 (2012). 39. Wuehr, M., Pradhan, C., Brandt, T., Jahn, K. & Schniepp, R. Patterns of optimization in single- and inter-leg gait dynamics. Gait & posture 39, 733 -- 8 (2014). 40. Chapman, J. P., Chapman, L. J. & Allen, J. J. The measurement of foot preference. Neuropsychologia 25, 579 -- 584 (1987). 41. Gabbard, C. & Hart, S. A question of foot dominance. The Journal of general psychology 123, 289 -- 296 (1996). 42. Kampen, N. V. Stochastic Processes in Physics and Chemistry, Third Edition (North Holland, 2007), 3 edition edn. Author contributions statement M.L and B.J.W conceived the experiment, K.K. conducted the experiment, all authors analyzed the results and contributed to the manuscript. Additional information Competing financial interests There were no conflicts of interest. 11/11
1104.4201	1	1104	2011-04-21T08:31:48	Self-organised criticality in base-pair breathing in DNA with a defect	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "math.DS", "nlin.AO", "q-bio.BM" ]	We analyse base-pair breathing in a DNA sequence of 12 base-pairs with a defective base at its centre. We use both all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and a system of stochastic differential equations (SDE). In both cases, Fourier analysis of the trajectories reveals self-organised critical behaviour in the breathing of base-pairs. The Fourier Transforms (FT) of the interbase distances show power-law behaviour with gradients close to -1. The scale-invariant behaviour we have found provides evidence for the view that base-pair breathing corresponds to the nucleation stage of large-scale DNA opening (or 'melting') and that this process is a (second-order) phase transition. Although the random forces in our SDE system were introduced as white noise, FTs of the displacements exhibit pink noise, as do the displacements in the AMBER/MD simulations.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Self-organised criticality in base-pair breathing in DNA with a defect Ciprian-Ionut¸ DUDUIAL A, Jonathan A.D. WATTIS School of Mathematical Sciences, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom, NG7 2RD, UK Charles A. LAUGHTON, School of Pharmacy, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom, NG7 2RD, UK November 4, 2018 Abstract We analyse base-pair breathing in a DNA sequence of 12 base-pairs with a defective base at its centre. We use both all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and a system of stochastic differential equations (SDE). In both cases, Fourier analysis of the trajectories reveals self-organised critical behaviour in the breathing of base-pairs. The Fourier Transforms (FT) of the interbase distances show power-law behaviour with gradients close to −1. The scale-invariant behaviour we have found provides evidence for the view that base-pair breathing corresponds to the nucleation stage of large-scale DNA opening (or 'melting') and that this process is a (second-order) phase transition. Although the random forces in our SDE system were introduced as white noise, FTs of the displacements exhibit pink noise, as do the displacements in the AMBER/MD simulations. Keywords: DNA, breathers, self-organised criticality, stochastic differential equations, 1/f noise. PACS 05.10.Gg - Stochastic models in statistical physics and nonlinear dynamics PACS 89.75.Fb - Self-organization in complex systems, PACS 05.65.+b - Self-organised criticality PACS 87.14.gk - DNA MSC 60G18 Probability theory and stochastic processes: self-similar processes MSC 37K40 Dynamical systems: Soliton theory, asymptotic behavior of solutions MSC 92C45 Biology and other natural sciences: Kinetics in biochemical problems 1 Introduction Much has been written about the process by which double-stranded DNA becomes two sepa- rated single strands, see, for example, (1; 2). Several authors refer to the melting of DNA as 1 having the form of a phase transition, in which the opening of one or a few base-pairs is akin to nucleation, and the subsequent growth of open 'bubbles' is similar to the growth of crystal nucleii. This two-stage process is relatively well understood in the contexts of crystal growth, and aerosol formation, but less so in kinetics of DNA replication. The aim of this paper is to show that the nucleation event -- that is the initial opening of bases -- exhibits self-similar, or scale-free, critical behaviour, as one would expect at a phase transition. Whilst other studies have analysed bubble growth and the statistics of bubble length, we choose to focus on the temporal statistics. Our model is more detailed, only focusing on 12 base-pairs and the open- ing of the first base; our model is thus significantly smaller than the bubble growth models of (1; 2); however, our models are more accurate in that the AMBER simulations (3) (Assisted Model Building with Energy Refinement) include the effect of every atom in the DNA and the water molecules in the environment, and our SDE models include an accurate fitting of the nonlinear inter-base potential energy as described in our earlier work (4). According to Watson & Crick (7), the structure of a DNA duplex consists of two chains of bases. These bases are of four types: the purines Adenine (A) and Guanine (G) and the pyrimidines Cytosine (C) and Thymine (T). Along the chains, the bases are linked by covalent bonds, while the opposite bases from the two chains pair together by two or three hydrogen bonds forming base-pairs. Only A-T or C-G pairs are possible. Given this information, we use a lattice representation for our DNA sequence, as illustrated in Figure 1. Breathing -- the localised separation of complementary bases -- takes place on the microsecond timescale in normal DNA, which is beyond the range of all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) packages. The insertion of a defect, that is, replacing a thymine (T) with a difluorotoluene (F) base at the lattice site n = 0, increases the frequency of breathing due to the weakening of the inter-chain potential. This makes breathing occur on the nanosecond timescale and hence it becomes accessible to MD simulation techniques. Biologically the reason for considering the inclusion of a defect is to study fidelity, and the effects of errors, in DNA replication. The defect F has been considered previously, for example, by Cubero et al. (8), who considered such a system without any externally imposed twist. It is possible that proteins may locally alter the twist of a DNA helix in order to ease the process of localised melting. Hence, here, we impose a twist on the DNA structure in order to investigate its effect on base-pair breathing. s s s s s s u−2(t) u−1(t) ✇ ❣ ✇ γ k ✟✟✟✟ u−3(t) γ ✟✟✟✟ k v−3(t) ❣ ✇ ❣ k γ ✇ ❅ k ❅ ❣ v−2(t) ❅ ✇ ❅ ❣ ❅ ❅ u0(t) ✡ ❣ ✡ ❅✡ ✇ E0 bk bk bk bk ❣ ❣ ❅❍❍❍❍ ✇ v−1(t) v0(t) v1(t) ✇ ✇ ✇ ✡✡❅ ✡ u1(t) ❅ ❣ k γ k ❣ ❅ u2(t) ❅ ❣ ✇ γ ❣ ✇ v2(t) s s s s s s Figure 1: IIllustration of the mesoscopic model of DNA. In this paper, we analyse base-pair breathing at a defect in double-stranded DNA parame- terised using the molecular dynamics (MD) simulation tool AMBER. We consider a range of helicoidal twist angles from 30◦ to 40◦ per base-pair at rest, including the typical twist of 36◦. In (4) we derived a coarse-grained model based on stochastic differential equations with one variable for the displacement of each base from its equilibrium position. This model 2 includes explicit random forcing terms, which model the interactions of water molecules with the bases, and the whole model has been parameterised to the all-atom MD simulations de- rived using AMBER. Developed from the models of (5; 6), the incorporation of noise and damping terms enables us to investigate the temporal dynamics of breathing. The model is fitted to AMBER data using a sophisticated maximum likelihood estimation procedure which is described in (4) and summarised in Section 2.2 here. The associated fluctuation-dissipation relation, the dependence of parameters on angle of twist and form of the inter-base potential are also discussed in (4). The DNA sequence under study consists of 12 base-pairs and we have taken that the DNA sequence is surrounded by a water box. The analysis of the simulations of a DNA molecule obtained using AMBER and our SDE system presented in (4) revealed that the amplitude of fluctuations is slightly reduced in the SDE model, but the breathing length and frequency are similar. In addition, the derivation of the SDE model requires us to modify the fluctuation- dissipation relation in the reduced, or coarse-grained, mesoscopic models. We also make a distinction between the potential of mean force (the free energy) and the various potential energies in our system. This is supported by an analysis of the importance of the damping term in preserving the system energy (which, in combination with the forcing noise terms gives rise to the entropic component of the free energy) and the way in which the along- chain interactions influence the length of a breathing event. We have also shown in (4) that breathing events are due not only to inhomogeneities in the inter-strand interactions, but also to a significant change in along-chain interactions and the helical twist of the DNA, which potentially influences the interactions between the DNA molecule and the surrounding solvent. A more detailed analysis of our simulations presented below reveals an interesting result: rather than a well-defined breathing frequency that depends on the twist angle via the energy barrier between open and closed states of the central basepair, we find that at all angles of twist the DNA exhibits breathing across a wide range of frequencies and the amplitude-frequency relationship exhibits scale-free behaviour. Most previous results in the literature show that the energy is transferred between nonlinear localized modes with particular frequencies and between such modes and phonons, as discussed by Peyrard et al. (9; 10; 11) or as shown by the results of Gaeta et al. (12; 13; 14), for example. In the rest of this section we review some of the relevant theory and applications involv- ing self-organised systems. In Section 2 we outline the models we use and the simulation techniques. Section 3 contains the results of both approaches, showing the consistency of outcomes. Section 4 concludes the paper with a summary and discussion. 1.1 Self-organisation and criticality Many dynamical systems evolve to a steady state (or an equilibrium) solution or to a limit cycle. More complicated large-time behaviour includes spatio-temporal chaos which is often characterised by strange attractors in phase space (15). Through the study of cellular au- tomata, Wolfram (16) characterised large time behaviour into four classes. He empirically identified the following qualitative classes: spatially homogeneous systems (akin to steady- states), periodic structures (limit cycles), systems with chaotic aperiodic behaviour (chaos) 3 and, most notably, a fourth, that of complicated localised and possibly propagating structures. We claim that this last category is the most appropriate classification for the behaviour which we observe later in this paper, and, more precisely, this behaviour corresponds to self-organised criticality (SOC). In physics, a critical point specifies the conditions, such as temperature, pressure or composi- tion, at which a phase boundary is not valid anymore. Here, by 'phase' we understand a state of a system for which the physical properties of a component are uniform. As one approaches the critical point, the properties of the different phases approach each other. In other words, a critical point refers to a system configuration to which the system evolves without ever approaching a fixed equilibrium state. Mathematically, one can define characteristic sizes of behaviour (lengths or timescales of events) which describe the system. When these sizes become infinite the system is classed as critical, that is, fluctuations occur at all length scales. Systems having the SOC property present a spatially or temporally scale-invariant behaviour without the need to tune any parameter to a specific value. This ubiquity of scale-free behaviour (18) in such models shows that complex behaviour can be stable. This contrasts with systems where one would generically expect some stable steady behaviour for a wide range of parameter values, and as a parameter changes, one might observe either a smooth change in the system's behaviour or a bifurcation to a qualitatively different steady-state or limit cycle, for example. In the special case when the parameter takes on the threshold value between two states, more complex phenomena may be observed. This is a typical form of behaviour around a phase transition. In general, the total number of states is finite and the transitions can be characterised using a cellular automaton structure (19). When analysing a large system, we aim to reduce its complexity to a few degrees of freedom, for which the coupling can be defined in a general manner and hence we obtain some averaged, or coarse-grained, behaviour over ignored quantities and includes corresponding averaged interactions within the system and the surrounding environment. For dynamical systems, such a dimensional reduction can be achieved by the "slaving principle" (17) which leads to the the study of low-dimensional attractors. This is often a straightforward method. For example, "fast modes" at equilibrium can be slaved to a few slowly-evolving modes. However, sometimes a system responds on both fast and slow timescales, even at large times, and we require an alternative theory, such as the idea of self-organised systems, whose behaviour cannot be explained using the slaving principle or other reductions. Some attracting critical points of dynamical systems can be characterised using the concept of self-organized criticality (SOC), which was first introduced by Bak et al. (22; 23). Using simple automata, they demonstrated power-law relationships and 1/f noise (also known as "flicker noise") in spatially extended systems, this behaviour illustrates critical phenomena, and underpins more general scale-invariant behaviour and fractals. They studied the dynamics of damped pendula and the slope of sandpiles, determining critical points of the systems. One aspect of self-organised criticality is the separation of timescales: in the most familiar application of sandpiles, grains are continually added on a faster timescale. The gradient of the pile slowly steepens and there are avalanches (large-scale reorganisation of the pile) which take place rapidly but are separated by large time intervals (relative to the timescale at which grains are added to the pile). Bak et al also noted that changing the values of system parameters did not affect the emergence of critical behaviour. Avalanches in a one- dimensional sandpile are also analysed by Chapman et al. (see, for example, (24)) who showed 4 that the distribution of energy discharges due to internal reorganizations have a power-law form and so demonstrate that the system is self-organized. In general, for a noisy system the power spectrum has the form S(f ) = cf −β, where c is a constant. The noise present in the system can be classified in three important categories as follows: • white noise, for β = 0; • pink noise, for β = 1; • red noise (also known as Brownian noise), for β = 2. However, the term "1/f noise" is widely used to refer to any noise with a power spectral density S(f ) ∝ f −β, with 0 < β < 2. For 1/f noise that occurs in nature, β is usually close to 1. Although there is no single well-defined class of systems having the SOC property, it is typ- ically observed in complex systems with slowly-driven nonequilibrium behaviour, for which the causes of an event taking place in a system cannot be explained simply through some parameter values. Several studies of SOC show that scale-invariant phenomena can be deter- mined at critical points, but not necessarily at any critical point. There are two important categories of such phenomena: fractals (20) and power laws (21). Whilst the first category involves geometric shapes, which can be split into parts that are reduced-size copies of the initial shape, the second deals with frequency-dependent quantities and, hence, is relevant in the analysis of some Hamiltonian systems. We note that self-organised systems are always at criticality, but not all critical systems are self-organised. The range of systems exhibiting critical properties varies from earthquakes (25; 26) and forest- fires (27; 28) to biological systems, such as proteins (29; 30), the brain (31) and even DNA. Selvam (32), for example, studies the distribution of bases in a human DNA sequence and shows that the C-G base-pair frequency distribution exhibits a universal inverse power-law form. Also, Harris et al. (33) analyse the configurational entropy of a DNA molecule based on the entropy estimation for a Gaussian configuration given by Schlitter (34), which helps investigate whether a steady state has been reached during a simulation. They show that the estimate of the entropy Sn depends on the number of data points n and this relation is a power law (with exponent between zero and minus one). 2 Modelling DNA In our system, we also have a separation of timescales: there are rapidly oscillating forcing terms applied to the DNA chain illustrated in Figure 1 (these model the interactions with water molecules and are akin to grains being added to the sandpile) and the occasional larger- scale restructuring of the chain as the base-pairs open or close at the start and end of breathing events (which are akin to avalanches in sandpiles). We now discuss in detail the modelling approaches we adopt. 5 2.1 All-atom MD modelling using AMBER As already mentioned, we obtain data from an all atom simulation of DNA using the package AMBER (3). The DNA sequence analysed contains 12 base-pairs as follows: C T T T T G F A T C T T G A A A A C A T A G A A This sequence is analysed at a constant temperature of T = 293K, in the presence of a surrounding water box. The solvent has to be taken into account because it influences the displacement of atoms and through other bonds, affects the hydrogen bonds linking the bases on the DNA strands (36). Even if the breathing events occur on the nanosecond time-scale and the DNA sequence contains only 12 base-pairs, which together with the sugars and phosphate groups represent 763 atoms, the number of degrees of freedom in our system is actually very large (16682) due to the water box. This means most of the time is spent computing information about the solvent, even though this information is not used for our analysis, since we focus only on the DNA bases and their dynamics. Note that AMBER considers that the normal twist by default is about 32.5◦. In order to avoid this inconvenience, we have constructed the DNA sequence by considering the degree of twist at rest. The degree of twist is preserved by imposing a harmonic restraint on the atoms at the end bases. More precisely, we have considered a constant energy (of 1 kcal mol−1 A−2) and hence a constant force acting on the end bases, in order to keep the DNA atoms close to their initial positions. Applying this restraint to the end bases allows the A-F pair to breathe and so explore a larger volume of phase space than the other base-pairs. The force field used during the AMBER simulations is also important. For a DNA molecule, the predefined FF99SB all-atom force field was used. Moreover, AMBER provides several water models for residues with name WAT -- the default is TIP3P, which was used in our simulations. After creating the topology and coordinates files using the AMBER packages LEaP and nucgen, we have used SANDER for energy minimization. This process involves a structural relaxation, which is necessary because the coordinates file contains some initial values that do not guarantee a minimum energy configuration, this reduces the possibility of having conflicts or overlapping atoms. In addition to energy minimization, we have also performed a few equilibration and MD simulations in which temperature changes. Finally, our system is simulated using SANDER. Next, ptraj is used to measure the distance between the A-F base-pair as well as the separations of the other base-pairs and the corre- sponding velocities. This data is output every 1 ps or 2 fs depending on which simulation study is being performed. 2.2 Stochastic mesoscopic model In DNA, the rapid external fluctuation events correspond to random collisions of the bases with the water molecules surrounding the biopolymer. These events correspond to pertur- bations to the variables yn(t), fluctuations in these displacements may propagate along the 6 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 y g r e n e l a i t n e t o p PMF(y0) U(y0) E0(y0) 0 −1 0 1 2 4 5 6 7 3 y0 Figure 2: The interchain interaction potential E0(y0), the total potential energy U(y0) = 0, and the potential of mean force P MF (y0) = U(y0) + √kBT η0y0 used in (4), E0(y0) + 1 for a 36◦ twisted DNA sequence. 2bky2 chain, perturbing neighbouring bases, eventually causing the central base y0(t) to cross a barrier in the potential E0(y0), see Figure 2. A second source of data is the reduced model introduced in (4) which is based on a system of stochastic ordinary differential equations (SDEs). We start from the deterministic system H = X n + 1 2 v2 n + 1 2γ(un − vn)2 + 1 (cid:8) 1 2 u2 n 2(bk − k)(cid:2)(u1 − u0)2 + (u0 − u−1)2 + (v1 − v0)2 + (v0 − v−1)2(cid:3) + 1 +E0(y0) − 1 2k(un+1 − un)2 + 1 2γ(u0 − v0)2, 2 k(vn+1 − vn)2(cid:9) (1) which is illustrated in Figure 1. Here, un(t) represent the deviations from equilibrium of the bases on one chain of the DNA, and vn(t) the displacements of the bases on the second chain, with the index n determining the position down each chain (−6 ≤ n ≤ 5). Since we are interested in investigating in more detail a system similar to that of Guckian et al. (37) we place a defect at the centre of the chain, that is, the u0 and v0 bases correspond to the A-F base-pair. The parameter k describes the stiffness of the backbone down each side of the double-helix structure, whist the parameter γ indicates the strength of interaction between a base on one strand and its complement. These forces are assumed to be uniform along the DNA double helix, except at the defect where they are replaced by the parameter bk and the nonlinear force E ′ 0(y0) respectively. To these we add noise and damping terms with coefficients ǫ∗ and η∗ respectively. The dependence of all these parameters on the twist angle θ has been determined in an earlier paper (4). We make the transformation yn = un − vn so as to obtain 7 equations of motion for the distances between base-pairs dyn dt + ǫξn, d2yn dt2 = k(yn+1−2yn+yn−1) − γyn − η d2y−1 dt2 = bk(y0−y−1) − k(y−1−y−2) − γy−1 − η d2y0 dt2 = bk(y1−2y0+y−1) − (y0) − η0 d2y1 dt2 = k(y2−y1) − bk(y1−y0) − γy1 − η dy0 dt dy1 dt dE0 dy dy−1 dt + ǫ0ξ0, + ǫξ1. (n > 1), + ǫξ−1, (2) (3) (4) (5) The functions ξn(t) are white noise forcing terms. The quantities γ, k, bk, ǫ, ǫ0, η, η0 are all fitted using a maximum likelihood estimation procedure, as is the interaction potential E0(y0), a full description of this is given in (4; 35). A typical example of the multiwelled interaction potential, E0(y0) is given in Figure 2. Note that the total potential energy of the central defective base-pair is U(y0) = E0(y0) + 1 0, and the potential of mean force (free energy) is given by P MF (y0) = U(y0) + √kBT η0y0, can easily be obtained from simulations by plotting a histogram of binned displacement data. 2bky2 3 Results We measure the distance between the two bases (A, F) at the defect over many nanoseconds, that is, we sample y0(t) at specific intervals. Using data from both AMBER and the SDE system we analyse the (discrete) Fourier transforms of y0(t) for a range of twist angles from 30◦ to 40◦ per base-pair. The discrete Fourier transform is taken of the data, in the figures displayed later, we use the notation DF T (ω) for by0(ω), and the hypothesis we are testing is that over a wide range of ω, (6) logby0(ω) = −β log ω + log C. The highest frequency attainable is ωmax = 2π/2∆t, whilst the lowest frequency is given by 2π/T where T is the length of the simulation and ∆t is the sampling interval. Our initial results are simulations of length approximately T = 10 ns sampled every ∆t = 1 ps (giving ∼ 104 data points). We then perform simulations of T = 2 ns sampled on a much finer scale of ∆t = 2 fs (giving ∼ 106 data points). These are performed using both AMBER and our SDE system. The SDE system is then subjected to a longer-time simulation of T = 100 ns, sampled every ∆t = 1 ps (∼ 105 data points). This enables a wide range of frequencies to be sampled: for the initial simulations 0.00063 < ω < 3.14 ps−1 (−7.4 < log ω < 1.14), for the more frequently sampled simulations 0.0032 < ω < 1600 (−5.7 < log ω < 7.4), and for the long simulations 2π × 10−5 < ω < 3.14 (−9.7 < log ω < 1.14). Other frequencies which might be of relevance in interpreting the results are the upper and lower limits of the phonon band (which we refer to as ωopt and ωac respectively), and the frequency of the defect mode. Assuming that the defect mode can be approximated by 0 (0) = 14 and ωdef = 3.7, hence log ωdef = 1.3. Since 120 < γ < 165 y0 = −E ′′ and 160 < γ + 4k < 210, we have ωac = 11 and ωopt = 14.5, implying log ωac = 2.4 and log ωopt = 2.7. These all lie well above the range of frequencies that we shall be interested in below. 0 (0)y0 we find E ′′ 8 3.1 Initial results ) ) ω ( T F D ( g o l (a) 10 5 0 −8 −6 0 2 −4 −2 log(ω) (b) 10 5 ) ) ω ( T F D ( g o l 0 −8 −6 −4 −2 log(ω) 0 2 Figure 3: Discrete Fourier transforms (power spectra) of y0(t) plotted against ω on a log-log scale. Data sampled every 1 ps for 10 ns from a simulation of a 38◦ twisted DNA sequence from (a) AMBER, and (b) the SDE system (2) -- (5). In Figure 3, we present the log-log plot of the discrete Fourier transform (DFT) against the frequency ω, for 213 data points, that is, y0(t) sampled every 1 ps for 8 ns, for a 38◦ overtwisted DNA sequence. This Figure shows a straight line fit over several orders of magnitude of ω (−7 < loge ω < −1), with gradients of 0.7 -- 0.9 which are close to −1. Similar results are obtained for a 34◦ twisted DNA sequence, for example, as can be seen in Figure 4. These results suggests that there are breathing events of, and separated by, arbitrarily large times. Thus, if a DNA strand was successively observed for increasingly long intervals of time, there would always be breathing events of duration comparable to the total observation time. The gradients of the logeDFT(ω) against loge ω lines for the full range of twist angles tested are summarised in Table 1 and suggest the presence of generalised 1/f noise in our data (that is, 1/f β with 0 < β < 2). Initially our aim was to identify the dominant frequencies of breathers at the defect through the interchain distances. The asymptotic results of (6) initially appear to suggest that breathers are time-periodic modes with well-defined frequencies; however, that theory actually predicts a one-parameter family of "in-phase" breather modes with frequencies occupying the 9 ) ) ω ( T F D ( g o l ) ) ω ( T F D ( g o l (a) −6 −4 −2 log(ω) (b) 0 2 10 5 0 −8 10 5 0 −8 −6 −4 −2 log(ω) 0 2 Figure 4: Discrete Fourier transforms (power spectra) of y0(t) plotted against ω on a log-log scale. Data sampled every 1 ps for 10 ns from a simulation of a 34◦ twisted DNA sequence from (a) AMBER, and (b) the SDE system (2) -- (5). Angle βAM BER 30◦ 32◦ 33◦ 34◦ 35◦ 36◦ 38◦ 40◦ 0.725 0.700 0.725 0.750 0.750 0.775 0.700 0.700 βSDE 0.750 0.725 0.775 0.825 0.775 0.825 0.875 0.700 Table 1: The gradient β of the log-log representation of DF T (y0) against ω, from ∼ 10 ns of data, sampled every 1 ps obtained from the AMBER and SDE models. full range of values from the bottom of the phonon band down to arbitrarily small frequencies (as well as a one-parameter family of "out of phase" breathers with frequencies above the top of the phonon band). Since the part of the frequency range that we are interested in here is the small-ω limit, it is the former, in-phase, family that concerns us here. We assume 10 that a combination of the stochastic forcing noise and nonlinear interactions of phonons with the breathers which changes their frequency over time and may even sporadically create and destroy the breather modes. 3.2 More refined results By decreasing the sampling interval (∆t), we expect to obtain more accurate results; the cost being the increase in data storage requirements. Analysing data sampled every 2 fs for 2.1 ns (more precisely, 220 or 106 data points), we obtain qualitatively similar results, as can be seen in the results presented in Figure 5, which shows the Fourier power spectra for a DNA helix twisted to 34◦. (a) ) ) ω ( T F D ( g o l ) ) ω ( T F D ( g o l 15 10 5 0 −5 −6 15 10 5 0 −5 −6 4 6 8 −4 −2 0 2 log(ω) (b) −4 −2 0 2 log(ω) 4 6 8 Figure 5: Log-log plots of the discrete Fourier transforms (power spectrum) from more refined samplings of y0(t), specifically, data was sampled every 2 fs for 2.1 ns. Results for a 34◦ undertwisted DNA sequence from (a) AMBER and (b) the SDE system (2) -- (5). As with the results shown in Section 3.1, the full range of twist angles from 30◦ to 40◦ have been simulated and analysed the results are summarised in Table 2. These results, with the reduced sampling interval, suggest that the average value of β for such AMBER simulations increases to 0.93, which is much closer to unity than the values obtained when the sampling interval is ∆t = 1ps (Table 1). Analysing a similar data set from the SDE model with more frequent 11 sampling shows a similar increase in β, from an average of 0.79 when ∆t = 1ps (Table 1) to ∆t = 0.91 (Table 2). These results again confirm that our reduced mesoscopic model accurately reproduces the self-organised DNA behaviour observed in the all-atom AMBER simulation. This observed increase in β suggests that we might reasonably expect β → 1 as ∆t → 0 in both the AMBER and the SDE simulations. Angle βAM BER 30◦ 32◦ 33◦ 34◦ 35◦ 36◦ 38◦ 40◦ 0.920 0.920 0.900 0.940 0.930 0.930 0.940 0.950 βSDE 0.900 0.895 0.910 0.920 0.900 0.910 0.940 0.905 Table 2: The β exponents derived from more refined sampling of y0(t), specifically every 2 fs for 2.1 ns. The β-exponent is the gradient of the log-log representation of DF T (y0) against ω, from AMBER and SDE simulations (compare with Table 1). At higher values of ω, both AMBER and SDE simulations show changes in behaviour. Firstly, in both cases, the line broadens as more points are plotted at higher values of log ω and these display a greater variation; see the ranges −1 < log ω < 2 in Figures 3 and 4 and −1 < log ω < 6 in Figure 5. Note that the same ranges apply to both AMBER simulations and SDE simulations. Secondly, at larger ω, there is a more significant reduction in the discrete Fourier transform, for the AMBER simulation this occurs from ω = 2 upwards, following by a more abrupt decrease around ω = 6.5 in Figure 5(a); whereas, in the SDE simulation, Figure 5(b), the spectrum has a simpler form with a more rapid linear decrease with a larger gradient beyond ω = 2.5. 3.3 Long-time results We have analysed a longer simulation of 100 ns, sampling y0(t) every ∆t = 1 ps using just the SDE system; such a long simulation is beyond the scope of AMBER on currently avail- able computing facilities. This length of simulation allows lower breathing frequencies to be sampled, as shown in Figures 6 and 7. Here we observe the same self-organised behaviour as in earlier graphs, although with some deviation from the straight line at particularly small frequencies, namely those in the range −9 < log ω < −7. For example, from the 216(∼ 105) data points in the simulation of a 30◦ undertwisted DNA sequence illustrated in Figure 6, we find β = 0.725. This value is similar to that found in the shorter simulation of 10 ns sampled every 1 ps, where we found β = 0.750; the value of 0.725 is identical to the value obtained from the shorter AMBER simulation; both these values are reported in Table 1. For the 38◦ overtwisted DNA molecule the long-time SDE simulation gives β = 0.775, which lies between the value of β = 0.875 from the shorter SDE simulation and β = 0.700 from the 12 shorter AMBER simulation. Thus for both twist angles, the long-time SDE simulation gives exponents closer to the AMBER results than the shorter SDE simulations. 12 10 8 6 4 2 ) ) ω ( T F D ( g o l 0 −10 −8 −6 −4 log(ω) −2 0 2 Figure 6: Log-log plot of the discrete Fourier transform (power spectrum) of y0(t) from a long-time (100 ns) SDE simulation for a 30◦ twisted DNA sequence, y0(t) data sampled every 1 ps. 3.4 Bases away from the defect Finally we have analysed the motion of the base-pairs adjacent and further away from the defect in the AMBER and SDE systems, in both cases using the example of a 38◦ overtwisted DNA helix. For example, Figure 8 illustrates the power spectrum of the second-neighbour base-pair y2t, sampled every 1 ps over a simulation of length 10ns. Although the decay with increasing frequency (ω) is not as clear as in Figures 3, 4, 5, 6, or 7, it is still possible to fit a straight line through the points. For the AMBER and SDE simulations respectively, the gradients of these lines are 0.225 and 0.210 respectively. This procedure has been repeated for the first neighbour base-pair, y1(t), and more distant base-pairs, y3(t), y4(t), and the corresponding gradients of the best fit lines of the log-log plots have been calculated. Assuming that the FTs have power-law forms, these gradients, which correspond to the exponents, β, are given in Table 3. From the data in this Table we observe that β decreases as one moves away from the defect site. This behaviour is due to the reduced influence of the breathing pair on the neighbouring base-pairs. We observe a drop from β ≈ 1 at the defect (n = 0) to just under one quarter at the nearest neighbour (n = 1) in both SDE and AMBER. The analysis of y0(t) showed that the exponent β increased from 0.7 − 0.8 to 0.90 − 0.95 when the sampling frequency was decreased from 1ps to 2 fs, suggesting convergence to β = 1 13 12 10 8 6 4 2 ) ) ω ( T F D ( g o l 0 −10 −8 −6 −4 log(ω) −2 0 2 Figure 7: Log-log plot of the discrete Fourier transform (power spectrum) of y0(t) from a long-time (100 ns) SDE simulation for a 38◦ twisted DNA sequence, y0(t) data sampled every 1 ps. Base-pair βAM BER y1(t) y2(t) y3(t) y4(t) 0.225 0.180 0.180 0.180 βSDE 0.210 0.135 0.130 0.130 Table 3: The gradient β of the log-DFT function, from AMBER and SDE data sampled every 1 ps for 10 ns. Base-pair βAM BER y1(t) y2(t) y3(t) y4(t) 0.450 0.425 0.410 0.390 βSDE 0.445 0.205 0.180 0.155 Table 4: The gradient β of the log-DFT function, from AMBER and SDE data sampled every 2 fs for 2 ns. in the limit of small sampling frequency. Hence, we attempt to find more accurate values for the β-exponent for the neighbouring bases by decreasing the sampling timestep from 1 ps to 2 fs (as we reduce the simulation length from 10ns to 2ns). We obtain the gradients given in Table 4. Summarising, we find values just under one half at the nearest neighbour (n = 1) in both SDE and AMBER. For y2, in AMBER, there is then a further slow decay of 14 ) ) ω ( T F D ( g o l 4 2 0 −2 −8 (a) −6 −4 −2 log(ω) (b) 0 2 ) ) ω ( T F D ( g o l 4 2 0 −2 −8 −6 −4 −2 log(ω) 0 2 Figure 8: Discrete Fourier transforms (power spectra) of y2(t) plotted against ω on a log-log scale. Data sampled every 1 ps for 10 ns from a simulation of a 38◦ twisted DNA sequence from (a) AMBER, and (b) the SDE system (2) -- (5). O(0.01) per base-pair; whereas in SDE there is a more significant drop to 0.2 for y2 and then a slow decrease of O(0.01) per base-pair. We observe once again that these later results with a decreased sampling timestep of ∆t = 2 fs increases the measured values of β. Hence, we recommend that the even with spatially coarse-grained models of DNA, kinetic characteristics should be analysed using as small a timestep as possible, even as small as 2 fs (as used in AMBER) in order to obtain correct results and conclusions. This extra decrease in the SDE system may be due to the reduced number of degrees of freedom (only one per base-pair in the SDE), whereas in AMBER there are O(102) degrees of freedom per base-pair (the bases having 15 atoms moving in 3D space, in addition to the phosphate backbone). Whilst all base-pairs receive energy in the form of white noise forcing (in the SDE system) and in the form of random collisions with water molecules (AMBER), this energy is used and dissipated differently in the defective base from its neighbours. At the defect, there is a change in temporal behaviour, since white input noise (ξ0) is converted to pink output (y0) giving β ≈ 1, whereas in the neighbouring bases, the output noise (yn) remains significantly closer to white, that is β is significantly smaller. 15 4 Conclusions In summary, we have simulated a sequence of 12 base-pairs of DNA using two different models for a variety of times up to 100ns. We have analysed the displacement between the defective base-pair near the centre of the chain. Fourier transforms of the distance trajectory taken from both the AMBER and the mesoscopic stochastic differential equation simulations exhibit scale-free, or critical, behaviour for all twist angles in the range 30◦-40◦ per base-pair. From (6), we have by0(ω) = Cω−β across a considerable range of frequencies, ω. Furthermore, we find that β = 1 for all twist angles. Although we have imposed white noise forcing in the system (2) -- (5), the noise observed in the output y0(t) is pink (β ≈ 1, Figure 3). This shows that our SDE system preserves the SOC properties of DNA observed in the fully deterministic all-atom AMBER simulations. It is suspected that proteins which interact with DNA overtwisting or undertwisting the structure in order to ease the release of bases out from the structure. The fact that β = 1 for all twist angles appears to suggest that such a strategy will not change the base-pair breathing. However, the constant C in the formula by0(ω) = Cω−β will depend on twist angle, and mean that the fraction of time spent in the breathing state is less for the more stable angles 35◦ − 36◦ and more for the overtwisted or undertwisted DNA structures (i.e those in the ranges 38◦ − 40◦ and 30◦ − 34◦ respectively). What is surprising about our results is that the critical behaviour is not specific to any one twist angle but occurs at all angles. One might expect that, at normal twist angles of 35◦ -- 36◦, stable behaviour would be observed, with breathing events having some short characteristic timescale; at smaller and larger twist angles, a critical point would be found, where the DNA exhibited scale-invariant breathing, and that at even more extreme twist angles, the open state would be stable. However, this is not the case at all, instead, we find 1/f behaviour at all twist angles. Since the emergence of this critical behaviour is not affected by the variation of the twist angle of the system parameters values, or by the careful tuning of other parameters, we describe this as self-organised criticality. The scale-free nature of the kinetics of breathing events at all twist angles described herein is strongly reminiscent of the behaviour of fluctuations in systems at criticality. Thus, it appears that without any tuning of the interaction parameters of the DNA strand, it is at a critical point where open bubbles spontaneously nucleate, hence we apply the term 'self-organized criticality'. Figures 3 and 7 suggest that there is an upper frequency (around loge ω = −1), above which the amplitude of base-pair separation modes is small but ceases to decay any further, due to the effect of noise in the system. This cutoff is not due to the start of the phonon band (which occupies the range √γ < ω < √γ + 4k), and which corresponds to a relatively narrow range of velocities around 11 < ω < 14 (precise values depend on the twist angle). We observe some artifacts of the phonon band in the region of log ω being between two and three and the defect mode near log ω = 1, in that there is a shoulder in the power spectrum in Figure 5 where the trace is slightly larger than expected; however, no behaviour should be expected to persist over all scales, and the figures show good agreement with scale-free kinetic behaviour (straight-line) over the considerably large range of −6 < log ω < 1. One might think that the defect site is the cause of the SOC breathing behaviour. However, 16 replacing the thymine (T) base with a difluorotoluene (F) base lowers the barrier between the closed and open states. The replacement does not affect the DNA structure or other behaviour, as discussed in several papers, for example, (37). Lowering the energy barrier allows breathing to occur at lower energies, and so occur with a higher frequency, on a timescale accessible to MD simulations (on the nanosecond timescale as opposed to the microsecond scale for a normal DNA sequence). There is no reason to suppose that a change in the frequency of events should cause a more significant change in qualitative behaviour. Hence, we speculate that in pure DNA, with no defect, but with multiwelled potentials between all corresponding base-pairs, curves such as that seen in Figure 3, will be repeated but that the crossover frequency (from ω-independent noise to breathing with amplitude proportional to 1/ω) will be shifted to much lower frequencies, namely the microsecond scale, which is beyond current MD simulations. Here we only have a double-well potential at the defect, the other inter-base interactions are all governed by harmonic potentials, in reality, all inter-base interactions are double-welled, this will allow an open base-pair to be the nucleus for a bubble of several consecutive open base-pairs to form, as the along-chain interactions would then ease the opening of neighbouring base-pairs. Acknowledgments CID was funded by the EU as part of MMBNOTT -- an Early Training Research Programme in Mathematical Medicine and Biology. References [1] D. Hennig - Formation and propagation of oscillating bubbles in DNA initiated by structural distortions, Eur. Phys. J. B 37, 391 -- 397, (2004). [2] T. Ambjornsson, S.K. Banik, M.A. Lomholt & R. Metzler - Master equation approach to DNA breathing in heteropolymer DNA, Phys Rev E 75, 021908, (2007). [3] D.A. Case, T.A. Darden, T.E. Cheatham, III, C.L. Simmerling, J. Wang, R.E. Duke, R. Luo, K.M. Merz, D.A. Pearlman, M. Crowley, R.C. Walker, W. Zhang, B. Wang, S. Hayik, A. Roitberg, G. Seabra, K.F. Wong, F. Paesani, X. Wu, S. Brozell, V. Tsui, H. Gohlke, L. Yang, C. Tan, J. Mongan, V. Hornak, G. Cui, P. Beroza, D.H. Mathews, C. Schafmeister, W.S. Ross, & P.A. Kollman, AMBER 9, University of California, San Francisco (2006). [4] C.I. Duduiala, J.A.D. Wattis, I.L. Dryden & C.A. Laughton - Nonlinear breathing modes at a defect site in DNA, Phys Rev E, 80, 061906, (2009). [5] J.A.D. Wattis, S.A. Harris, C.R. Grindon & C.A. Laughton - Dynamic model of base pair breathing in a DNA chain with a defect, Phys Rev E, 63, 061903, (2001). [6] J.A.D. Wattis - Nonlinear breathing modes due to a defect in a DNA chain, Phil Trans Roy Soc Lond A, 362, 1461 -- 1477, (2004). [7] J.D. Watson & F.H.C. Crick - Molecular structure of nucleic acids, Nature 171, 737 (1953). [8] E. Cubero, E.C. Sherer, F.J. Luque, M. Orozco & C.A. Laughton - Observation of spontaneous base pair breathing events in the molecular dynamics simulation of a difluorotoluene-containing DNA oligonu- cleotide, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121, 8653 -- 8654, (1999). [9] M. Peyrard & A.R. Bishop - Statistical mechanics of a nonlinear model for DNA denaturation, Phys Rev, 62, 2755-2758 (1989). [10] M. Peyrard & J. Farago - Nonlinear localization in thermalized lattices: Application to DNA, Physica A 288, 199-217 (2000). [11] M. Peyrard, S.C. L´opez & G. James - Modelling DNA at the mesoscale: a challenge for nonlinear science?, Nonlinearity 21, T91-T100 (2008). 17 [12] G. Gaeta & L. Venier - Solitary waves in twist-opening models of DNA dynamics, Phys Rev E 78, 011901 (2008). [13] G. Caldarelli, R. Frondoni, A. Gabrielli1, M. Montuori1, R. Retzlaff & C. Ricotta - Percolation in real wildfires, Europhys Lett 56, 510-516 (2001). [14] M. Cadoni, R. De Leo & G. Gaeta - A composite model for DNA torsion dynamics, Phys Rev E 75 021919 (2007). [15] D. Ruelle - Small random perturbations of dynamical systems and the definition of attractors, Commun Math Phys 82, 137-151 (1981). [16] S. Wolfram - Cellular automata as model of complexity, Nature 311, 419 (1984). [17] H. Haken - Cooperative phenomena in systems far from thermal equilibrium and in nonphysical systems, Rev Mod Phys 47, 67-121 (1975). [18] J. Zinn-Justin - Quantum Field Theory and Critical Phenomena, Oxford University Press (2002). [19] B. Chopard & M. Droz - Cellular Automata Modeling of Physical Systems, Cambridge University Press (1998). [20] G. Peng & D. Tian - The fractal nature of a fracture surface, J Phys A: Math Gen 23, 3257-3261 (1990). [21] M.E.J. Newman - Power laws, Pareto distributions and Zipf 's law, Contemporary Physics 46(5), 323-351 (2005). [22] P. Bak, C. Tang & K. Wiesenfeld - Self-organized criticality: An explanation of the 1/f noise, Phys Rev Lett 59, 381 -- 384, (1987). [23] P. Bak, C. Tang & K. Wiesenfeld - Self-organized criticality, Phys Rev A 38, 364 -- 374, (1988). [24] S.C. Chapman - Inverse cascade avalanche model with limit cycle exhibiting period doubling, intermit- tency, and self-similarity, Phys Rev E 62, 1905 -- 1911, (2000). [25] Z. Olami, H.J.S. Feder & K. Christensen- Self-organised criticality in a continuous, nonconservative cellular automaton modelling earthquakes, Phys Rev Lett 68, 1244 -- 1247, (1992). [26] P. Bak, K. Christensen, L. Danon & T. Scanlon - Unified scaling law for earthquakes, Phys Rev Lett 88, 178501, (2002). [27] P. Bak, K. Chen & C. Tang - A forest-fire model and some thoughts on turbulence, Phys Lett A 147, 297 -- 300, (1990). [28] B. Drossel & F. Schwabl - Self-organized critical forest-fire model, Phys Rev Lett 69, 1629 -- 1632, (1992). [29] J.C. Phillips - Scaling and self-organized criticality in proteins I, Proc Natl Acad Sci 106(9), 3107 -- 3112, (2009). [30] J.C. Phillips - Scaling and self-organized criticality in proteins II, Proc Natl Acad Sci 106(9), 3113 -- 3118, (2009). [31] G. Werner - Metastability, criticality and phase transitions in brain and its models, Biosystems 90, 496 -- 508, (2007). [32] A.M. Selvam - Universal spectrum for DNA base C-G frequency distribution in Human chromosomes 1 to 24, arXiv:physics/0701079 (2007). [33] S.A. Harris, E. Gavathiotis, M.S. Searle, M. Orozco & C.A. Laughton - Cooperativity in drug-DNA recognition: a molecular dynamics study, J Am Chem Soc 123, 12658 -- 12663, (2001). [34] J. Schlitter - Estimation of absolute and relative entropies of macromolecules using the covariance matrix, Chem. Phys. Lett. 215, 617 -- 621, (1993). [35] C.I. Duduiala - Stochastic Nonlinear Models of DNA Breathing at a Defect, http://etheses.nottingham.ac.uk/, PhD Thesis, University of Nottingham, (2009). [36] M. Peyrard, S. C. L´opez, D. Angelov - Fluctuations in the DNA double helix, Eur Phys J Special Topics 147, 173-189 (2007). [37] K.M. Guckian, T.R. Krugh & E.T. Kool - Solution structure of a DNA duplex containing a replicable difluorotoluene-adenine pair, Nature Structural Biology 5, 954 -- 959, (1998). 18
1806.10490	1	1806	2018-06-27T13:58:02	Statistical mechanics of an elastically pinned membrane: Equilibrium dynamics and power spectrum	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft" ]	In biological settings membranes typically interact locally with other membranes or the extracellular matrix in the exterior, as well as with internal cellular structures such as the cytoskeleton. Characterization of the dynamic properties of such interactions presents a difficult task. Significant progress has been achieved through simulations and experiments, yet analytical progress in modelling pinned membranes has been impeded by the complexity of governing equations. Here we circumvent these difficulties by calculating analytically the time-dependent Green's function of the operator governing the dynamics of an elastically pinned membrane in a hydrodynamic surrounding and subject to external forces. This enables us to calculate the equilibrium power spectral density for an overdamped membrane pinned by an elastic, permanently-attached spring subject to thermal excitations. By considering the effects of the finite experimental resolution on the measured spectra, we show that the elasticity of the pinning can be extracted from the experimentally measured spectrum. Membrane fluctuations can thus be used as a tool to probe mechanical properties of the underlying structures. Such a tool may be particularly relevant in the context of cell mechanics, where the elasticity of the membrane's attachment to the cytoskeleton could be measured.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Statistical mechanics of an elastically pinned membrane: Equilibrium dynamics and power spectrum Josip A. Janes,1, 2 Daniel Schmidt,1, 3 Udo Seifert,3 and Ana-Suncana Smith1, 2, ∗ 1Institut fur Theoretische Physik and Cluster of Excellence: Engineering of Advanced Materials, Friedrich Alexander Universitat Erlangen-Nurnberg, 91052 Erlangen, Germany 3II. Institut fur Theoretische Physik, Universitat Stuttgart, 70569 Stuttgart, Germany 2Institut Ruder Boskovi´c, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia In biological settings membranes typically interact locally with other membranes or the extra- cellular matrix in the exterior, as well as with internal cellular structures such as the cytoskeleton. Characterization of the dynamic properties of such interactions presents a difficult task. Signifi- cant progress has been achieved through simulations and experiments, yet analytical progress in modelling pinned membranes has been impeded by the complexity of governing equations. Here we circumvent these difficulties by calculating analytically the time-dependent Green's function of the operator governing the dynamics of an elastically pinned membrane in a hydrodynamic surrounding and subject to external forces. This enables us to calculate the equilibrium power spectral density for an overdamped membrane pinned by an elastic, permanently-attached spring subject to thermal excitations. By considering the effects of the finite experimental resolution on the measured spec- tra, we show that the elasticity of the pinning can be extracted from the experimentally measured spectrum. Membrane fluctuations can thus be used as a tool to probe mechanical properties of the underlying structures. Such a tool may be particularly relevant in the context of cell mechanics, where the elasticity of the membrane's attachment to the cytoskeleton could be measured. I. INTRODUCTION A phospholipid membrane can be easily deformed and exhibits appreciable fluctuations due to its small elas- tic constant [1–6]. While occurring on time scales be- tween 10−9 and 10−5 s [7–10], the fluctuations are over- damped by the surrounding fluid [11–14]. Nonethe- less, mean fluctuation amplitudes of up to 100 nm have been observed experimentally [15]. In a vicinity of a substrate, these fluctuations are known to contribute to an effective potential which prevents the membrane from non-specifically adhering to the underlying scaffold [1, 3, 10, 16–21]. The scaffold in turn affects the hydro- dynamic damping of the membrane reflected in changes of the time dependent correlation function and the asso- ciated power spectrum, the so-called power spectral den- sity (PSD) [15, 22–24]. Moreover, in the cellular environ- ment, active processes couple with the membrane fluctua- tions [23–33], resulting in the violation of the fluctuation- dissipation theorem in the activated state of the cell [34– 36]. Over the last two decades, models for the fluctuations of free membranes, based on the Helfrich energetics and Stokes fluid dynamics, were experimentally confirmed, either by measuring the PSD or its Fourier transform, the time dependent correlation function (for reviews see [7, 15] and references therein). This body of work con- firmed the appropriateness of the models based on the Helfrich Hamiltonian [1] to capture the equilibrium dy- namics of free membranes. However, the presence of the ∗ author to whom correspondence should be addressed: [email protected] pinning introduces a challenge, which is often circum- vented by homogenising the effects of interactions with the scaffold [36, 37]. Alternative approaches, where the local pinnings remain explicit, commonly involved sim- ulations [38–41], while the theoretical modelling focused on the static properties of the membrane shape and fluc- tuations [37, 42, 43]. On the other hand, analytic treat- ments of the membrane-dynamics, even in the context of equilibrium, remained an open problem up to now. First quasi-analytical predictions were obtained for infinitely strong pinnings [44], while the more realistic case, where the membrane is attached by proteins which themselves maintain a certain flexibility has not been considered so far. In this paper we address this open issue by analyti- cally solving the integro-differential equation governing the motion of a pre-tensed membrane pinned by a sin- gle flexible construct. We describe in detail the effect of the pinning on the membrane's equilibrium dynam- ics. At last, we provide an exact analytical method for calculating the pinning stiffness from the experimentally measured PSD, accounting for the finite resolution of the setup. While constructed in the context of biolog- ical membranes, the obtained result can be applied more generally, in the context of bending fluctuations of thin sheets. II. EQUATION OF MOTION The system consists of one flexible attachment (har- monic spring of an elastic constant λ and rest length l0) that pins a tensed membrane (bending rigidity κ, tension σ). The later fluctuates in a harmonic non-specific po- tential (strength γ) positioned at the distance h0 above 8 1 0 2 n u J 7 2 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 0 9 4 0 1 . 6 0 8 1 : v i X r a 2 Figure 1. Snapshot from the Langevin simulation of locally pinned membrane fluctuating in a non-specific potential (Left). Sketch of the system (Right). Membrane is residing in a harmonic potential of strength γ at h0 separation from a flat substrate and pinned by an elastic spring of stiffness λ and rest length l0 positioned at r = 0. the substrate (Fig. 1). Placing the origin of the coor- dinate system at the pinning site and into the minimum of the non-specific potential sets the form of the energy functional [43, 45] as (cid:90) (cid:34) H = dr κ 2 (cid:0)∇2u(r, t)(cid:1)2 (∇u(r, t))2 + + σ 2 γ 2 (u(r, t))2 (cid:35) A λ (u(r, t) − (l0 − h0))2 δ(r) + 1 2 . (1) Here and throughout the paper, the energy scale kBT is set to unity, with Boltzmann constant denoted as kB and absolute temperature T . Dynamics of an overdamped membrane in a hydrody- namic surrounding is captured by the Langevin equation [20, 39, 41, 46–50] ∂u(r, t) ∂t = (cid:90) (cid:18) dr(cid:48)Λ(r − r(cid:48)) − δH (cid:18) δu(r, t) ≡ Λ(r) ∗ (cid:19) − δH δu(r(cid:48), t) + f (r(cid:48), t) (cid:19) + f (r, t) , (2) which states that the velocity of the membrane profile u(r, t) is given by a convolution of the hydrodynamic ker- nel Λ(r), the Oseen tensor, with the forces acting on the membrane. External forces on the system are denoted by f (r, t), while the internal forces acting to minimize the Hamiltonian (eq. (1)) are given by the first variation [43] =(cid:0)κ∇4 − σ∇2 + γ + λδ(r)(cid:1) u(r, t) δH δu(r, t) −λ(l0 − h0)δ(r). (3) Together with eq. (2), this leads to the equation for the dynamics of an overdamped pinned membrane D [u(r, t)] = Λ(r) ∗ [f (r, t) + λ(l0 − h0)δ(r)] , (4) with the operator D set as + Λ(r) ∗(cid:0)κ∇4 − σ∇2 + γ + λδ(r)(cid:1) . D = ∂ ∂t where Λk is the spatial Fourier transform of Λ(r) and (5) Ek = κk4 + σk2 + γ. (11) III. TIME-DEPENDENT GREEN'S FUNCTION The solution of eq. (4) provides the evolution of the membrane profile u(r, t). It is obtained by the integration of forces acting on the membrane, the latter accounted for by the dynamic Green's function g(r, tr(cid:48), t(cid:48)) (cid:90) dr(cid:48)(cid:90) u(r, t) = (cid:48) dt g(r, tr(cid:48), t(cid:48))× R R2 × (f (r(cid:48), t(cid:48)) + λ(l0 − h0)δ(r(cid:48))) . (6) (7) Here the Green's function is defined by D [g(r, tr(cid:48), t(cid:48))] =Λ(r) ∗ [δ(r − r(cid:48))δ(t − t(cid:48))] . Besides imposing causality, this equation is subject to ho- mogeneous spatial boundary conditions forcing the mem- brane in the minimum of the non-specific potential far from the pinning. A. Free membrane (λ = 0) Recognizing spatio-temporal translational invariance of the free membrane system, the corresponding Green's function gf (r, tr(cid:48), t(cid:48)) can be written in terms of variables t = t − t(cid:48) and r = r − r(cid:48) as gf (r, tr(cid:48), t(cid:48)) = gf (r − r(cid:48), t − t(cid:48)) ≡ gf (r, t). (8) Consequently, for the free membrane eq. (7) becomes (cid:20) ∂ + Λ(r) ∗(cid:0)κ∇4 = Λ(r) ∗(cid:2)δ(r)δ(t)(cid:3) . ∂t r + γ(cid:1)(cid:21) r − σ∇2 gf (r, t) (9) Fourier transforming eq. (9) (r → k and t → ω) upon rearranging yields gf (k, ω) = 1 iω/Λk + Ek , (10) u(r)h0γu2(r)l0ru(r,t)r=0λFinally, transforming back to the spatio-temporal domain (k → r and ω → t) provides the spatio-temporal Green's function for the free membrane (cid:90) (cid:90) dω 2π gf (r, t) = dk eikreiωt R2 (2π)2 R iω/Λk + Ek . (12) Integrating over the frequencies gives (cid:90) (cid:90) ∞ (2π)2 Λkeikre−ΛkEk tΘ(t) dk gf (r, t) = = dk 2π 0 ΛkkJ0(kr)e−ΛkEk tΘ(t), (13) where Θ is the Heaviside step function appearing as a consequence of causality. Moreover, gf (r, t) depends only on the absolute value of r, as expected. For ω = 0, the Green's function gf (r, ω) reduces to the static correlation function [43]. Consequently, (cid:32)(cid:114)(cid:16) λ0 (cid:114)(cid:16) λ0 (cid:33) (cid:17)2 − 1 (cid:17)2 − 1 m 4σ m 4σ arctan 2πσ 3 For r = 0 in eq. (19) we find g(r, ωr(cid:48)) = gf (r(cid:48), ω) 1 + λgf (r = 0, ω) , (20) which upon inserting into (19) yields the Green's function for the pinned membrane in the spatio-frequency domain g(r, ωr(cid:48)) = gf (r − r(cid:48), ω) − λ gf (r, ω)gf (r(cid:48), ω) 1 + λgf (r = 0, ω) . (21) Fourier transforming eq. (21) (r → k and r(cid:48) → k(cid:48)) results in g(k, ωk(cid:48)) = (2π)2δ(k + k(cid:48))gf (k, ω) − λ gf (k, ω)gf (k(cid:48), ω) 1 + λgf (r = 0, ω) (22) , which is the representation of the Green's function in the Fourier space. gf (r = 0, ω = 0) ≡ 1 λm = (14) IV. DYNAMICS OF THERMAL FLUCTUATIONS represents the fluctuation amplitude, which in the ten- sionless case reduces to A. Oseen tensor gf (r = 0, ω = 0; σ = 0) ≡ 1 λ0 m = 1 √ κγ 8 . (15) In thermal equilibrium f (r, t) is associated with the stochastic thermal noise characterized by a vanishing mean B. Pinned membrane Permanent pinning breaks the spatial, but keeps the temporal translational invariance. Therefore, the Green's function of the pinned membrane must be described by two spatial variables r and r(cid:48) and one temporal variable t = t − t(cid:48) g(r, tr(cid:48), t(cid:48)) = g(r, t − t(cid:48)r(cid:48)) ≡ g(r, tr(cid:48)). (16) (cid:20) ∂ In this notation, eq. (7) for the pinned membrane Green's function becomes + Λ(r) ∗(cid:0)κ∇4 − σ∇2 + γ + λδ(r)(cid:1)(cid:21) = Λ(r) ∗(cid:2)δ(r − r(cid:48))δ(t)(cid:3) . (17) g(r, tr(cid:48)) ∂t Fourier transforming (r → k and t → ω) and rearranging eq. (17) gives g(k, ωr(cid:48)) = e−ikr(cid:48) iω/Λk + Ek − λg(r = 0, ωr(cid:48)) 1 iω/Λk + Ek . (18) Transforming back to the spatial domain (k → r) gives g(r, ωr(cid:48)) =gf (r − r(cid:48), ω) − λg(r = 0, ωr(cid:48))gf (r, ω). (19) (cid:104)f (r, t)(cid:105) = 0 (23) and spatio-temporal correlations obeying the fluctuation- dissipation theorem (cid:104)f (r, t)f (r(cid:48), t(cid:48))(cid:105) = 2Λ−1(r − r(cid:48))δ(t − t(cid:48)). (24) Here Λ−1(r) is defined by Λ(r) ∗ Λ−1(r) = δ(r). (25) To model damping of the membrane due to hydrody- namic interactions with the surrounding fluid close to a wall [46, 48], we will use the Fourier transform of the Oseen tensor Λk Λk = (4ηk)−1, (26) where η is the viscosity of the surrounding fluid. Eq. (26) is appropriate when the wall is permeable to the fluid. In the presence of an impermeable wall, damping coefficients are modified [51, 52], which in the case of protein mediated adhesion, typically has an effect only on the amplitude of the first few membrane modes [49]. Furthermore, if the membrane is surrounded by two dif- ferent fluids with viscosities η1 and η2, the viscosity η in the damping coefficients is replaced by the arithmetic mean η = (η1 + η2)/2 [15]. B. Simulation methods Eq. (4) for the membrane dynamics, subject to ther- mal noise defined with eqs. (23)-(26), is the foundation of our Langevin dynamics simulations of the membrane, described previously in full detail [41]. In the current case, one pinning site is placed in a middle of the sim- ulation box (periodic boundary conditions) of a size of 640 × 640 nm for a tensionless membrane, and a size of 5120 × 5120 nm at finite tensions. The simulations are performed with a temporal and lateral resolution of 10−9 s and 10 nm, respectively. The membrane height profile is recorded as a function of time and analyzed to extract the membrane shape and correlation functions. C. Power Spectral Density We complement the simulations of thermally fluctu- ating membrane with the analytic calculations based on the Green's function approach (eq. (6)). We start with rewriting eq. (6) as u(r, t) = (cid:104)u(r)(cid:105) + v(r, t), where v(r, t) = (cid:48) dt g(r, t − t(cid:48)r(cid:48))f (r(cid:48), t(cid:48)) (28) are the fluctuations around the ensemble averaged static profile [43] (cid:104)u(r)(cid:105) = (cid:48) dt g(r, t − t(cid:48)r(cid:48))λ(l0 − h0)δ(r(cid:48)). (29) Transforming (t → ω) eq. (28) gives (cid:90) R2 R dr(cid:48)(cid:90) dr(cid:48)(cid:90) R (cid:90) R2 v(r, ω) = dr(cid:48) g(r, ωr(cid:48))f (r(cid:48), ω) (30) = (cid:90) R2 (2π)2 × 1 (cid:90) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)1 − ∞(cid:90) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)1 − 0 dk from which the PSD (cid:104)v(r, ω)2(cid:105) can be calculated as (see Supplementary Information) (cid:104)v(r, ω)2(cid:105) = 2Λ−1 k × dk R2 (ω/Λk)2 + E2 k λgf (r, ω) e−ikr 1 + λgf (r = 0, ω) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)2 . (31) With the hydrodynamic coefficients specified as in eq. (26), eq. (31) becomes (cid:104)v(r, ω)2(cid:105) = 4η π × (4ηkω)2 + (κk4 + σk2 + γ)2× k2 λgf (r, ω) e−ikr . (32) 1 + λgf (r = 0, ω) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)2 4 In the absence of the pinning (λ = 0), eq. (32) becomes homogeneous in space and reduces to the well-known re- sult(cid:10)vf (ω)2(cid:11) = 4η π ∞(cid:90) dk k2 (4ηkω)2 + (κk4 + σk2 + γ)2 , 0 (33)  which for small and large ω has the limiting behaviour [9, 11, 23, 53] (cid:104)vf (ω)2(cid:105) = η√ √ γ(λ0 m/4+σ)3 , ω (cid:28) ω0 ω−5/3, ω (cid:29) ω0. (34) Here, ω0 ≡ 4(cid:112)κγ3/η is a cross-over frequency, defined as 1 2η2κ 6 3 the intersection of the lines fitting the low- and high- frequency limits of the spectrum. The low-frequency limit decays with σ−3/2 for tensions σ (cid:29) λ0 m (Fig. 2b). It is clear from Eq. (32) that the PSD at the pinning site r = 0 can be recast into (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)2 (cid:104)vf (ω)2(cid:105). (35) (27) (cid:104)v(r = 0, ω)2(cid:105) = 1 1 + λgf (r = 0, ω) In agreement with simulations based on eqs. (4), (23) and (24) [41], eq. (35) shows that only the pinning stiff- ness, and not its length, has an effect on the PSD and that the pinning affects only the low-frequency regime (Fig. 2a). The low-frequency behaviour can be obtained upon combining eq. (35) for ω = 0 with eq. (34) to yield (cid:18) (cid:19)2 (cid:112)γ(λ0 η m/4 + σ)3 4σ/λ0 4σ/λ0 m (cid:28) 1 m (cid:29) 1. (36) (cid:16) (cid:16)  (cid:104)v(r = 0, ω = 0)2(cid:105) = 1 1 + λ/λm (cid:17)2 1 1+λ/λ0 m 1 1+λ ln(σ)/(2πσ) η√ γ(λ0 (cid:17)2 , m/4)3 η√ , γσ3 Eq. (36) shows that the low-frequency spectrum is in- m (cid:28) 1 and it dependent of membrane tension for 4σ/λ0 decays with σ−3/2 for membrane tensions large enough to diminish the effect of the pinning (λ ln(σ)/(2πσ) (cid:28) 1) 2b). For stiff pinnings (λ/λm (cid:29) 1) the low- (Fig. frequency limit falls off as λ−2 (Fig. 2c). On the other hand, for λ/λm (cid:28) 1, pinning effects vanish even in the low-frequency limit. Interestingly, the cross-over fre- quency ω0 for the pinned membrane (cid:104) 6 3(cid:112) 2η2κ (cid:104)v(r = 0, ω = 0)2(cid:105)(cid:105)−3/5 , (37) ω0 = defined analogously to the one for the free membrane, becomes sensitive to the elastic properties of the pinning as ω0 ∼ λ6/5 and as such increases with the pinning stiff- ness. 5 Figure 2. Dynamical properties of a membrane at the pinning site. Comparison of modelling (lines) and simulations (symbols) shows excellent agreement across the entire parameter range. a) Power spectral density of a free membrane (eq. (33)) (red) and a pinned tensionless membrane eq. (35) (blue dashed curves for λ/λ0 m = 1, 3, 10, increasing in the direction of the arrows). The high-frequency regime of the PSD is unaffected by the pinning and the free-membrane behaviour (ω−5/3) is recovered. b) Low frequency limit of the PSD (eq. (36)) as a function of the membrane tension σ for different pinning strengths (λ/λ0 m = 1, 3, 10). For large tensions, a σ−3/2 dependence is recovered irrespective of λ. c) Low frequency limit as a function of the pinning m = 1, 3, 10). For large bond stiffness, a λ−2 dependence is displayed. All strength for different membrane tensions (8σ/λ0 curves are plotted for κ = 20kBT , γ = 3 × 10−7kBT /nm4 and η = 1 mPas. V. EFFECT OF THE FINITE EXPERIMENTAL section I. A.1.) RESOLUTION ON THE FLUCTUATION SPECTRUM In order to compare with experiments, it is necessary to account for the finite temporal and spatial resolutions of the set-up [15, 54]. Averaging the true membrane profile u(r, t) over a spatial domain A and a time interval τ , gives rise the so-called apparent membrane profile uA τ (r, t) τ (cid:104)vR2π dk ∞(cid:90) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) J1(kR) k 0 × × (r = 0, ω)2(cid:105) = kΛ−1 k (ω/Λk)2 + E2 k 4 R2 − λ 1 + λgf (0, ω) (cid:18) sin(ωτ /2) (cid:19)2 1 ωτ /2 π × ∞(cid:90) 0 1 2π dk(cid:48) J1(k(cid:48)R) iω/Λk(cid:48) + Ek(cid:48) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)2 . (40) τ(cid:90) 0 (cid:90) A dt(cid:48) τ dr(cid:48) A uA τ (r, t) = u(r + r(cid:48), t + t(cid:48)), (38) Eq. (40) reduces to eq. (35) in the limit τ, R → 0. from which it is straightforward to derive the apparent PSD (Supplementary Information, section I. A) (cid:104)vA (cid:18) sin(ωτ /2) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) τ (r, ω)2(cid:105) = (cid:90) (cid:18) (ω/Λk)2 + E2 k 1 − λgf (r + r(cid:48), ω) Λ−1 ωτ /2 dk R2 k 1 + λgf (0, ω) × × (cid:19)2 (cid:90) A 2 (2π)2× dr(cid:48) A (cid:19)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)2 eik(r+r(cid:48)) × e−ik(r+r(cid:48)) . (39) The PSD measured around the pinning placed centrally in a circle of radius R is (Supplementary Information, The high frequency regime of the averaged PSD re- covers the averaging behaviour of the free membrane - spatial averaging changes the decay from ω−5/3 to ω−2 as previously reported [9], while finite temporal resolu- tion induces an additional attenuation of ω−2. Hence, the PSD which is subject to both temporal and spatial averaging decays as ω−4. In the low frequency regime, temporal averaging plays no role for ω < 1/τ , while the finite spatial resolution has a more complex effect. Due to the interplay with the effects of the pinning, the low frequency amplitude is not a monotone function of the averaging area (Fig. 3). In- creasing the averaging area up to some critical size (which is approximately the area affected by the pinning) ampli- fies the low-frequency components, but further increase of the averaging area starts to attenuate them. This can be understood as a competition of two effects; averaging has the effect of attenuating the low frequency compo- nents, as can be seen for the free membrane, but at the same time, averaging reduces the effect of the pinning on ●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●10210410610-810-610-4ω[s-1]〈v(r=0,ω)2〉[nm2s]freepinnedfreeh0=l0h0≠l0λ/λm0~ω-5/301310a)●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●●10-210010210-610-510-410-38σ/λm0〈v(r=0,ω=0)2〉[nm2s]freepinnedfreepinnedλ/λm0~σ-3/201310b)●●●●●●●●●10-210010-810-710-610-5λ/λm0〈v(r=0,ω=0)2〉[nm2s]~λ-28σ/λm001310c)6 Figure 3. Effect of the finite resolution (averaging over a circle of radius R and a time interval τ ) on the PSD at the pinning (eq. (40)). a) Averaging decreases the difference between the free and pinned PSD's, therefore reducing the effect of the pinning on the PSD. Pinning has no effect on the high-frequency part of the spectrum, for both the averaged and the unaveraged spectrum. b) The low-frequency part of the PSD is a non-monotone function of the spatial averaging area. On the other hand, increasing the averaging area always attenuates the high-frequency components, which in this case fall as ∼ ω−2 instead of ∼ ω−5/3. c) Time averaging introduces oscillatory behaviour of the PSD for which only the envelope of the PSD is shown. The combined effect of the spatial and temporal averaging gives a ∼ ω−4 behaviour of the high-frequency regime . Parameters κ = 20kBT , σ = 10−20kBT /nm2 and γ = 3 × 10−7kBT /nm4, λ/λ0 m=10 and η = 1 mPas. the PSD, which amplifies the low-frequency components. Obviously, the later effect is stronger up to the critical averaging area size, after which the first effect dominates. Specifically, for ω = 0 we obtain (Supplementary Infor- mation, section I.A.1) (cid:104)vR2π τ = 4η π ∞(cid:90) 0 dk k2 E2 k (r = 0, 0)2(cid:105) = (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) J1(kR) kR/2 (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)2 s(R) − λ 1 + λ/λm , (41) where for brevity purposes we introduce a reduced coef- ficient s(R) s(R) = × with a± × √ R2π 1 σ − 4κγ (cid:18) 1 − a−RK1(a−R) − 1 − a+RK1(a+R) 1 ± (cid:115) (cid:18) λ0 (cid:19)21/2  σ a± = 1 − a2− a2 + . (cid:19) , (42) (43) m 4σ 2κ In order to calculate the pinning stiffness λ from the PSD, eq. (41) can be inverted, which upon introduction of coefficients L, a, b and c, yields λ = with (cid:18) 1 L , (cid:19)−1 (cid:19)2 − c a − 1 λm (cid:115)(cid:18) b 2a L = − b 2a , m/4 + σ)3 dk kJ1(kR) E2 k  , πs2(R) 4(cid:112)γ(λ0  ∞(cid:90) (cid:18) 2 (cid:19)2 ∞(cid:90) 4s(R) R 0 and a = b = c = R 0 dk J 2 1 (kR) E2 k − π 4η (cid:104)vR2π τ (r = 0, 0)2(cid:105). (46) The averaged spectrum is contained in the coefficient c. When implemented numerically, eqs. (44-46) represent a fast and exact method for obtaining information about the pinning stiffness from the experimentally measured PSD. Here we note that the deconvolution of the noise associated with the experimental setting should be per- formed prior to the extraction of the pinning stiffness. VI. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION Our calculation of the Green's function (eq. (21)) fully resolves the dynamics of an overdamped, permanently pinned membrane in a hydrodynamic surrounding (eq. (2)). The solution is general in a sense that it works for any forces acting on the membrane and enables one to study the membrane dynamics in the presence of both non-thermal and thermal perturbations. The later case is resolved in this paper by the calculation of the thermal equilibrium power spectral density (eq. (31)). For the specific case of hydrodynamic damping close to a perme- able wall, our analytical calculation (eq. (32)) is verified with Langevin simulations in a broad range of param- eters, such as the pinning stiffness, membrane tension, (44) (45) 10210410610-810-610-4ω[s-1]〈vτ=0A=R2π(r=0,ω=0)2〉[nm2s]freefreepinnedR=0nmpinnedR=20nmω-5/3ω-2a)10210410610-810-610-4ω[s-1]〈vτ=0A=R2π(r=0,ω=0)2〉[nm2s]freeR=0nmpinnedR=0nm50nm200nm500nmω-5/3ω-2b)10410610-1010-810-610-4ω[s-1]〈vτA=R2π(r=0,ω=0)2〉[nm2s]Rτ0nm0s0nm10-5s200nm0s200nm10-5sω-5/3ω-2ω-11/3ω-4c)7 and strength of the non-specific potential, which were al- lowed to independently vary for several orders of magni- tude (Fig. 2). It is shown that the pinning decreases the low-frequency amplitudes of the spectrum and pushes the cross-over frequency (eq. (37)) to higher values, while the high-frequency amplitudes remain unaffected (Fig. 2). Interestingly, the pinned-membrane PSD at the pin- ning site is given by a product of a free-membrane PSD and a λ-dependent prefactor (eq. (35)). Assuming knowledge of the pinning stiffness λ, this enables infer- ence of the pinned-membrane PSD at the pinning site di- rectly from the free-membrane PSD. This approach has a clear advantage over a direct measurement of the pinned- PSD, as it replaces the pinned-membrane measurement, with a well-established free membrane measurement. On the other hand, if λ is not known, it can be easily de- termined by comparing the pinned- and free-membranes PSDs. The low-frequency limit of the PSD at the pinning site (eq. (36)) is particularly useful for getting a better understanding of the interplay of the system parameters and shows a λ−2 decay. These relationships, however, may not be observed ex- perimentally due to the finite resolution of the measure- ments. Specifically, while the effects of the temporal aver- aging are simple, significant spatial averaging introduces nontrivial modulations of the spectrum and breaks the re- lation between the free- and the pinned-membrane PSD given by eq. (35). In this regime the pinning stiffness can be inferred from the measured PSD with the use of the spatially averaged spectrum (eqs. (44-46)). A deep understanding of the mechanics of the pinned membrane is crucial for elucidating the role of more com- plex pinnings, which under typical biological conditions stochastically bind and unbind from the membrane. The stochasticity of this attachment will have additional ef- fects on fluctuations of the membrane which could not be resolved prior to this investigation, and will be sub- ject to a future study. The results presented in this pa- per will thus help establishing the connection between functioning of the protein assembly and the properties of the elastic fluctuating membrane, which is important for understanding of the formation of adhesions. Namely, there is a growing body of evidence that the membrane affects the affinity [55] and the kinetic rates for protein binding [41, 56], which in turn affect the fluctuations and the early stage signalling in developing junctions between cells [57]. The model presented here can be used to measure the elasticity of the bond from membrane fluctuations. Hith- erto, it was not possible to interpret these measurements accurately, a task that is enabled now by our current work. Such measurements could then be compared to AFM measurements, which are commonly used to study elastic properties of the linkers. Acknowledgments: A.-S.S and J.A.J. thank ERCStg MembranesAct for support as well as the Croatian Sci- ence Foundation research project CompSoLs MolFlex 8238. A.-S.S and D.S. were supported by the Re- search Training Group 1962 at the Friedrich-Alexander- Universitat Erlangen-Nurnberg. [1] W. Helfrich, "Elastic properties of lipid bilayers: Theory and possible experiments," Z. Naturforsch., C: J. Biosci. 28, 693–703 (1973). [2] W. Helfrich, "Steric interaction of fluid membranes in multilayer systems," Z. Naturforsch., A: Phys. Sci. 33, 305 (1978). [3] R. Lipowsky and E. Sackmann, eds., Structure and dy- namics of membranes (Elsevier, 1995). [4] A.-S. Smith, B.G. Lorz, S. Goennenwein, and E. Sack- mann, "Force-controlled equilibria of specific vesicle- substrate adhesion," Biophys. J. 90, L52–L54 (2006). [5] C. Monzel, S. F. Fenz, M. Giesen, R. Merkel, and K. Sen- gupta, "Mapping fluctuations in biomembranes adhered to micropatterns," Soft Matter 8, 6128–6138 (2012). [6] S. Marx, J. Schilling, E. Sackmann, and R. Bruinsma, "Helfrich repulsion and dynamical phase separation of multicomponent lipid bilayers," Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 138102 (2002). [7] C. Monzel and K. Sengupta, "Measuring shape fluctua- tions in biological membranes," J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 49, 243002 (2016). [8] S. F. Fenz and K. Sengupta, "Giant vesicles as cell mod- els," Integr. Biol. 4, 982–995 (2012). [9] T. Betz and C. Sykes, "Time resolved membrane fluctu- ation spectroscopy," Soft Matter 8, 5317–5326 (2012). [10] D. Schmidt, C. Monzel, T. Bihr, R. Merkel, U. Seifert, K. Sengupta, and A.-S. Smith, "Signature of a nonhar- monic potential as revealed from a consistent shape and fluctuation analysis of an adherent membrane," Phys. Rev. X 4, 021023 (2014). [11] F. Brochard and J. F. Lennon, "Frequency spectrum of the flicker phenomenon in erythrocytes," J. Phys. France 36, 11 (1975). [12] L. Kramer, "Theory of light scattering from fluctua- tions of membranes and monolayers," J. Chem. Phys. 55, 2097–2105 (1971). [13] U. Seifert and S.A. Langer, "Viscous modes of fluid bi- layer membranes," Europhys. Lett. 23, 71 (1993). [14] P. J. Atzberger, "Stochastic eulerian lagrangian meth- ods for fluid–structure interactions with thermal fluctu- ations," Journal of Computational Physics 230, 2821 – 2837 (2011). [15] C. Monzel, D. Schmidt, U. Seifert, A.-S. Smith, R. Merkel, and K. Sengupta, "Nanometric thermal fluc- tuations of weakly confined biomembranes measured with microsecond time-resolution," Soft Matter 12, 4755–4768 (2016). [16] W. Helfrich and R.-M. Servuss, "Undulations, steric in- teraction and cohesion of fluid membranes," Nuovo Ci- mento D 3, 137–151 (1984). [17] E. A. Evans and V. A. Parsegian, "Thermal-mechanical fluctuations enhance repulsion between bimolecular lay- ers," Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 83, 7132 (1986). [18] J. N. Israelachvili and H. Wennerstroem, "Entropic forces between amphiphilic surfaces in liquids," J. Phys. Chem. 96, 520–531 (1992). [19] J. O. Radler, T. J. Feder, H. H. Strey, and E. Sack- mann, "Fluctuation analysis of tension-controlled undu- lation forces between giant vesicles and solid substrates," Phys. Rev. E 51, 4526–4536 (1995). [20] U. Seifert, "Configurations of fluid membranes and vesi- cles," Adv. Phys. 46, 13–137 (1997). [21] B. G. Lorz, A.-S. Smith, C. Gege, and E. Sackmann, "Adhesion of giant vesicles mediated by weak binding of sialyl-lewisx to e-selectin in the presence of repelling poly(ethylene glycol) molecules," Langmuir 23, 12293– 12300 (2007). [22] S. A. Safran, N. Gov, A. Nicolas, U. S. Schwarz, and T. Tlusty, "Physics of cell elasticity, shape and adhesion," Physica A 352, 171 (2005). [23] T. Betz, M. Lenz, J.-F. Joanny, and C. Sykes, "Atp- dependent mechanics of red blood cells," Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 106, 15320–15325 (2009). [24] C. Monzel, D. Schmidt, C. Kleusch, D. Kirchenbuchler, U. Seifert, A.-S. Smith, K. Sengupta, and R. Merkel, "Measuring of bio- membranes with dynamic optical displacement spec- troscopy," Nat. Commun. 6, 8162 (2015). stochastic displacements fast [25] J. Prost, J.-B. Manneville, and R. Bruinsma, "Fluctuation-magnification of non-equilibrium mem- branes near a wall," Eur. Phys. J. B 1, 465–480 (1998). [26] S. Ramaswamy, J. Toner, and J.s Prost, "Nonequilib- rium fluctuations, traveling waves, and instabilities in active membranes," Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 3494 (2000). [27] J.-B. Manneville, P. Bassereau, S. Ramaswamy, and J. Prost, "Active membrane fluctuations studied by mi- cropipet aspiration," Phys. Rev. E 64, 021908 (2001). [28] P. Girard, J. Prost, and P. Bassereau, "Passive or active fluctuations in membranes containing proteins," Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 088102 (2005). [29] N. S. Gov and S. A. Safran, "Red blood cell mem- brane fluctuations and shape controlled by atp-induced cytoskeletal defects," Biophys. J. 88, 1859–1874 (2005). [30] L. C.-L. Lin, N. Gov, and F. L. H. Brown, "Nonequilib- rium membrane fluctuations driven by active proteins," J. Chem. Phys. 124, 074903 (2006). [31] B. Loubet, U. Seifert, and M. A. Lomholt, "Effective ten- sion and fluctuations in active membranes," Phys. Rev. E 85, 031913 (2012). [32] Y. Hanlumyuang, L. P. Liu, and P. Sharma, "Revisiting the entropic force between fluctuating biological mem- branes," J. Mech. Phys. Solids 63, 179–186 (2014). [33] R. Alert, J. Casademunt, J. Brugu´es, and P. Sens, "Model for probing membrane-cortex adhesion by mi- cropipette aspiration and fluctuation spectroscopy," Bio- phys. J. 108, 1878–1886 (2015). [34] D. Mizuno, C. Tardin, C. F. Schmidt, and F. C. MacK- intosh, "Nonequilibrium mechanics of active cytoskeletal networks," Science 315, 370–373 (2007). [35] E. Ben-Isaac, Y. Park, G. Popescu, F. L. H. Brown, N. S. Gov, and Y. Shokef, "Effective temperature of red-blood-cell membrane fluctuations," Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 238103 (2011). [36] H. Turlier, D. A. Fedosov, B. Audoly, T. Auth, N. S. Gov, C. Sykes, J.-F. Joanny, G. Gompper, and T. Betz, "Equilibrium physics breakdown reveals the active na- ture of red blood cell flickering," Nat. Phys. (2016), 10.1038/nphys3621. 8 [37] N. Gov and S. Safran, "Pinning of fluid membranes by periodic harmonic potentials," Phys. Rev. E 69, 011101 (2004). [38] L. C.-L. Lin and F. L. H. Brown, "Dynamic simulations of membranes with cytoskeletal interactions," Phys. Rev. E 72, 011910 (2005). [39] E. Reister, T. Bihr, U. Seifert, and A.-S. Smith, "Two intertwined facets of adherent membranes: membrane roughness and correlations between ligand–receptors bonds," New J. Phys. 13, 025003:1–15 (2011). [40] J. Hu, R. Lipowsky, and T. R. Weikl, "Binding constants of membrane-anchored receptors and ligands depend strongly on the nanoscale roughness of membranes," Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 110, 15283–15288 (2013). [41] T. Bihr, U. Seifert, and A.-S. Smith, "Multiscale ap- proaches to protein-mediated interactions between mem- branes-relating microscopic and macroscopic dynamics in radially growing adhesions," New J. Phys. 17, 083016 (2015). [43] J. A. Janes, H. Stumpf, Schmidt D., Seifert U., [42] R. Bruinsma, M. Goulian, and P. Pincus, "Self-assambly of membrane junctions," Biophys. J. 67, 746–750 (1994). and Smith A.-S., "Statistical mechanics of an elastically Static profile and correlations," pinned membrane: ArXiv e-prints (2018), arXiv:1806.05109 [physics.bio- ph]. [44] L. C.-L. Lin and F. L. H. Brown, "Dynamics of pinned membranes with application to protein diffusion on the surface of red blood cells," Biophys. J. 86, 764–780 (2004). [45] D. Schmidt, T. Bihr, U. Seifert, and A.-S. Smith, "Co- existence of dilute and densely packed domains of ligand- receptor bonds in membrane adhesion," Europhys. Lett. 99, 38003 (2012). [46] M. Doi and S.F. Edwards, The Theory of Polymer Dy- namics, Vol. 73 (Oxford University Press, 1988). [47] R. Granek, "From semi-flexible polymers to membranes: Anomalous diffusion and reptation," Journal de Physique II 12, 1761 (1997). [48] L. C.-L. Lin and F. L. H. Brown, "Simulating mem- brane dynamics in nonhomogeneous hydrodynamic envi- ronments," J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2, 472–483 (2006). [49] E. Reister-Gottfried, K. Sengupta, B. Lorz, E. Sack- mann, U. Seifert, and A.-S. Smith, "Dynamics of specific vesicle-substrate adhesion: From local events to global dynamics," Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 208103:1–4 (2008). [50] J. K. Sigurdsson, F. L. H. Brown, and P. J. Atzberger, "Hybrid continuum-particle method for fluctuating lipid bilayer membranes with diffusing protein inclusions," Journal of Computational Physics 252, 65 – 85 (2013). [51] U. Seifert, "Dynamics of a bound membrane," Phys. Rev. E 49, 3124–3127 (1994). [52] N. Gov, A. G. Zilman, and S. Safran, "Cytoskeleton confinement and tension of red blood cell membranes," Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 228101 (2003). [53] L. Bourdieu J. Robert F. C. MacKintosh D. Chatenay E. Helfer, S. Harlepp, "Microrheology of biopolymer- membrane complexes." Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 457 (2000). [54] J. P´ecr´eaux, H.-G. Dobereiner, J. Prost, J.-F. Joanny, and P. Bassereau, "Refined contour analysis of giant unil- amellar vesicles," Eur. Phys. J. E 13, 277–290 (2004). [55] J. B. Huppa, M. Axmann, M. A. Mortelmaier, B. F. Lille- meier, E. W. Newell, M. Brameshuber, L. O. Klein, G. J. Schutz, and M. M. Davis, "TCR–peptide–MHC inter- actions in situ show accelerated kinetics and increased affinity," Nature 463, 963 (2010). [56] S. Fenz, T. Bihr, D. Schmidt, R. Merkel, U. Seifert, K. Sengupta, and A.-S. Smith, "Membrane fluctuations mediate lateral interactions between cadherin bonds," Nature Physics 13, 906–913 (2017). [57] Tomas D. Perez, Masako Tamada, Michael P. Sheetz, and W. James Nelson, "Immediate-early signaling in- duced by e-cadherin engagement and adhesion," Journal of Biological Chemistry 283, 5014–5022 (2008). 9
1505.07408	1	1505	2015-05-27T17:26:22	Enhanced Stability of the Model Mini-protein in Amino Acid Ionic Liquids and Their Aqueous Solutions	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.chem-ph", "q-bio.BM" ]	Using molecular dynamics simulations, the structure of model mini-protein was thoroughly characterized in the imidazolium-based amino acid ionic liquids and their aqueous solutions. We report that the mini-protein is more stable when AAIL is added as a cosolvent. Complete substitution of water by organic cations and anions further results in hindered conformational flexibility of the mini-protein. This observation suggests that AAILs are able to defend proteins from thermally induced denaturation. We show by means of radial distributions that the mini-protein is efficiently solvated by both solvents due to agood mutual miscibility. However, amino acid based anions prevail in the first coordination sphere of the mini-protein.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Enhanced Stability of the Model Mini-protein in Amino Acid Ionic Liquids and Their Aqueous Solutions Guillaume Chevrot,1 Eudes Eterno Fileti,2 and Vitaly V. Chaban2 1)MEMPHYS - Center for Biomembrane Physics, Department of Physics, Chemistry and Pharmacy, University of Southern Denmark, Campusvej 55, 5230 Odense, Denmark. 2) Instituto de Ciência e Tecnologia, Universidade Federal de São Paulo, 12231-280, São José dos Campos, SP, Brazil Abstract. Using molecular dynamics simulations, the structure of model mini-protein was thoroughly characterized in the imidazolium-based amino acid ionic liquids and their aqueous solutions. We report that the mini-protein is more stable when AAIL is added as a cosolvent. Complete substitution of water by organic cations and anions further results in hindered conformational flexibility of the mini-protein. This observation suggests that AAILs are able to defend proteins from thermally induced denaturation. We show by means of radial distributions that the mini-protein is efficiently solvated by both solvents due to agood mutual miscibility. However, amino acid based anions prevail in the first coordination sphere of the mini-protein. Key words: solvation; protein; ionic liquid; amino acid; molecular dynamics simulation. TOC Graphic Introduction Efficient extraction and preservation of proteins constitute important goals of modern biotechnology.1-6 The extracted and preserved proteins must retain their structure and function, since many kinds of analysis are available in vitro only. This often appears impossible due to a high sensitivity of protein configurations to local intermolecular interactions. The three-dimensional structure of protein is maintained by means of hydrogen bonds and multiple hydrophobic interactions of slightly varying strength.3,6 Electrostatic interactions involving polar amino acid residues and monovalent inorganic ions (chloride, sodium, potassium, etc) are also of high importance to stabilize proteins and provide acceptable level of hydration of the binding sites. Even tiny change in the environment may alter the fine balance of these interactions causing denaturation of protein.7 Denaturation ultimately leads to unfolding and inactivation, but can also result in specific unnatural arrangements, whose function is either absent or far from the expected one. Many chronic diseases are linked to incorrect protein folding. The effect of such changes is close to mutations and may be fatal for the living organism. An extensive evidence exists that solvation plays a critical role in stability and function of most proteins.6-11 Accurate spatial information about proteins is obtained from routine diffraction experiments. Consistent interpretation of the diffraction density maps requires computer simulations with atomistic precision and adequate sampling of the phase space in the vicinity of the protein. In turn, the presence of macromolecular solute induces significant and permanent effects on microscopic structure and transport properties of the surrounded solvent and dissolved ions. Specific regions inside many proteins exist, where water cannot penetrate easily. The density of solvent in these regions is, consequently, different from the bulk density at given temperature and pressure. This feature is important to maintain the required configuration of an entire protein, as was found via atomistic molecular dynamics simulations. Small fluctuations of local temperature and pressure can result in protein denaturation, since they perturb an accurate free energy balance. These same factors apply when a protein is extracted from the living organism and handled in vitro. Chemical modification, immobilization, additional stabilizing agents and genetic modification are major techniques to allow protein storage outside their natural environment.3 The required temperature regime must be thoroughly maintained to prevent thermally induced structure alterations, most of which are strictly irreversible due to energy barriers. Room-temperature ionic liquids (RTILs) comprise an organic cation and organic or inorganic anion.12-15 In quite a few cases, these ionic combinations result in low melting points (below 373 K), which nevertheless comes at a price of a significantly high shear viscosity (ca. 100 cP). RTILs exhibit unique physical and chemical properties including negligible vapor pressure, non-flammability, high thermal and chemical stability, high ionic conductivity and interesting solvation behavior. RTILs are currently probed in versatile fields of chemical engineering, such as chemical sensors, electrochemical power sources, solution chemistry, gas capture, separation applications and catalysis.16-20 Certain ionic liquids are environmentally friendly, without any clearly determined toxicity in relation to living cells. There exists experimental evidence that grafting of ether groups to RTILs decreases toxic effects. Successful applications of RTILs in biotechnology are known involving biological catalysis and protein conservation. It was argued that RTILs can serve as highly efficient participants in versatile biochemical processes, in addition to providing a well tunable reaction media. Water cannot be completely removed from the reaction environment, therefore researchers have to deal with biphasic systems: RTIL + water. According to recent reports, aqueous solutions of RTILs foster protein activity and protein stability. Some RTILs prevent or inhibit protein aggregation and improve refolding. An ability of ionic liquids to exclude aggregating of proteins (for instance, during folding) is an extremely important feature. Such a behavior implies strong specific interactions between proteins and RTILs, which may be sometimes more favorable than those between proteins and water. Interactions, observed in the protein solvated in RTIL and water, are not perfectly understood currently, whereas mostly speculative interpretations are available. Molecular dynamics simulations are able to provide significant assistance along these lines. Following the conclusions of Herrman and coworkers,21 solvent properties of solutions change from typical electrolyte solution-like behavior to molten salt-like behavior as a function of RTIL concentration. Phase transition can be hypothesized in this case. Bhattacharyya and coworkers22 used femtosecond up-conversion to study solvation dynamics of a probe covalently attached via the lone cysteine group to a protein, in the presence of methylimidazolium RTIL. The average solvation time decreased from 650 ps to 260 ps, as 1.5 RTIL was supplied. The authors ascribed this observation to protein unfolding, which made the probe more exposed. Rama Devi and coworkers23 concluded that stability of proteins and their functional groups can be drastically modulated by the addition of cosolvents. The reported transfer free energies for a model protein from water to alkyl ammonium-based RTILs suggested that all those RTILs act as stabilizers. Yoshimura and coworkers24 described structural change in chicken egg white lysozyme in the highly concentrated aqueous 1-butyl- 3-methylimidazolium nitrate solutions (0-24M) by optical spectroscopy and small-angle X- ray scattering methods. The protein adopted a partially globular state (tertiary structure was disrupted), whereas the protein aggregation was inhibited. The partially globular state was explained by dehydration of the important protein binding sites at high contents of RTIL. Figueiredo and coworkers25 investigated protein destabilization incurred by 1-butyl-3- methylimidazolium and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride and dicyanamide employing molecular dynamics simulations, NMR spectroscopy and differential scanning calorimetry. According to these authors, stabilization or destabilization of proteins depends on the hydrophilicity of the RTIL anions. Binding of weakly hydrated anions to positively charged or polar residues leads to partial dehydration of the backbone groups and is critical to control protein stability. Thus, dicyanamide is more denaturating than chloride, which should not depend on the cation and, to a reasonable extent, on the concentration. Amino acid-based ionic liquids (AAILs) represent an interesting and recent implementation of RTILs.26-31 In AAILs, the anion is obtained from a molecular amino acid via deprotonation, whereas the cation can be picked up in view of prospective usage. Being in tight evolutional connection to alpha amino acids, AAILs are not toxic. They exhibit relatively low ionic conductivities and high shear viscosities, which can be tuned via the addition of water. Miscibility of water and AAILs is excellent over a wide range of contents.28 Dagade and coworkers29 reported thermodynamics of ionic hydration and discussed solvent- solute interactions of AAILs in water at room conditions. Woo and coworkers31 simulated certain equilibrium and transport properties of AAILs. We developed a simple and efficient force field for a significant set of amino acid anions and 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium cation.27 This work reports a model mini-protein solvation in the three pure AAILs (1-ethyl-3- methylimidazolium alanine, [EMIM][ALA]; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium methionine, [EMIM][MET]; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium tryptophane, [EMIM][TRP]) and their aqueous solutions. Classical empirical-potential molecular dynamics simulation offering an atomistic precision of the results was employed as a primary research technique. The force field of AAILs was developed recently by two of us.27 We describe structure of the mixed solvent in the vicinity of mini-protein and characterize preferential solvation. We conclude that solvation by AAILs is definitely favorable for the investigated mini-protein, since it better preserves its genuine structure than water. Methodology Constant-temperature constant pressure molecular dynamics simulations of seven principal systems (Table 1) were conducted at 310 K and 1 bar. Dynamics of the mini-protein and surrounding solvent was recorded during 100 ns. The immediate coordinates of all species were saved every 10 ps, whereas the immediate velocities and forces were not saved. The equations-of-motion were propagated with a time-step of 0.002 ps. The time-step of 0.002 ps requires that the lengths of all intra-molecular (covalent) bonds involving hydrogen atoms were fixed during dynamics. We applied the LINCS algorithm32 to achieve this. The CHARMM36 force field33 was used to represent the mini-protein and the recently developed force field was used to represent AAILs.27 Both force fields are fully compatible. One chloride anion was added to the system to neutralize the mini-protein. Prior to productive runs, the simulated systems were thoroughly equilibrated as described below. Table 1. List of the simulated systems and their compositions # system AAIL x (AAIL), mol% # ion pairs # water molecules 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 [EMIM][ALA] [EMIM][ALA] [EMIM][MET] [EMIM][MET] [EMIM][TRP] [EMIM][TRP] water 100 5 100 5 100 5 0 600 300 500 200 350 200 0 0 5700 0 0 3800 3800 5065 Equilibration of the macromolecule containing systems deserves an extensive attention, since these systems possess lots of local free energy minima. These minima must be avoided ultimately driving the system over a variety of possible states. With the above precautions in mind, we performed the equilibration in the three stages. First, initial geometries were prepared using PACKMOL.34 We used entry 1L2Y from the Protein Data Bank (PDB) for the TRP-cage mini-protein (Figure 1). Molecular dynamics simulations of 100 ps with no pressure coupling were performed on these geometries using GROMACS 5.0.2 with three- dimensional periodic conditions. The geometry of the mini-protein was restrained at this stage to defend it from any artificially induced conformational changes. Second, the barostat was turned on and the simulations of 10 ns each were conducted at 400 K. The temperature of simulation was temporarily increased to foster equilibration of the AAIL phase. Third, the mini-protein atoms were relieved, and the entire system was simulated for 10 ns at 310 K and 1 bar. Figure 1. The stick-and-ribbon superimposed representation of the TRP-cage protein (sequence NLYIQ WLKDG GPSSG RPPPS). The electrostatic interactions in all systems were simulated using direct Coulomb law up to 1.2 nm and using the computationally efficient implementation of the Ewald method (Particle-Mesh-Ewald) beyond 1.2 nm.35 The Lennard-Jones interactions were smoothly brought down to zero from 1.0 to 1.2 nm using the switched potential approach. The constant temperature was maintained using the Bussi-Donadio-Parinello velocity rescaling thermostat36 with a relaxation time of 0.1 ps. The constant pressure was maintained using the Parrinello-Rahman barostat37 with a relaxation time of 1 ps and the compressibility constant of 4.5×10-5 bar-1. The molecular trajectories were analyzed by means of conventional GROMACS utilities and the MDTraj software package38 using standard definitions of the physical properties of interest. The images have been produced using VMD (Visual Molecular Dynamics) software, version 1.9.39 Results and Discussion The molecular configurations of the investigated three-component systems corresponding to free energy minimum at 310 K and 1 bar are depicted in Figure 2. Water and [EMIM][ALA] appear perfectly miscible. Our recent study indicates that AAILs exist as mainly small ionic clusters in water, while water greatly decreases shear viscosity of AAILs.28 Good mutual miscibility of the simulated cosolvents likely means that both of them are present in the first solvation shell of the mini-protein. Figure 2. Final molecular configurations of the two selected simulated systems: (left) the mini-protein in system 2 [x([EMIM][ALA]) = 5 mol%]; (right) the mini-protein in system 1 (pure [EMIM][ALA]). The 1-methyl-3-ethylimidazolium cations are blue, the alanine anions are yellow, the water molecules are red. The mini-protein is in cyan and pink. Figure 3 summarizes radial distribution functions (RDFs) computed between oxygen atoms belonging to water and oxygen atoms belonging to the carboxyl group of the serine residue. The serine residue was chosen because it is polar and, therefore, its strong interaction with polar solvent is expected. Remember that both our cosolvents are polar. Indeed, the first peak is located at 0.28 nm and also the second peak is distinguishable (although small by height) at 0.48 nm. The height of the first peak is smaller in the case of pure water (system 7) than in AAILs (systems 1-6). This trend constitutes a common observation in aqueous solutions. Pure water possesses a very well structured network of hydrogen bonds, which is responsible for high water-water RDF peaks. Interactions with the solute may be strong themselves, but they are always weaker than water-water interactions. That is why local density increase (RDF peak) in the vicinity of protein in pure water is modest. When a significant concentration of another cosolvent is added, it perturbs hydrogen bonds of water, especially upon creation of new hydrogen bonds with water. The resulting water structure in the mixed solvent is weaker than that in pure water. Its binding to the protein produces a higher peak even though the strength of the water-protein interaction remains intact. The heights of the first peaks in the 5 mol% AAIL solutions are as follows: [EMIM][TRP]>[EMIM][MET]>[EMIM][ALA]. This trend can be correlated to mobility of cosolvents. [EMIM][TRP] is the least mobile AAIL due the anion size, [EMIM][MET] is more mobile, and [EMIM][ALA] is most mobile due to the very small amino acid radical. Coordination number of water in the first coordination sphere of serine amounts to 3.9 (system 7). Coordination numbers of the mini-protein with respect to the anions, n–=3.7 in all AAILs (systems 2, 4, 6). One can conclude that AAIL substitutes most water molecules in the vicinity of the mini-protein in the 5 mol% AAIL solutions. Figure 3. Radial distribution functions (RDF) featuring spatial correlation between carboxyl oxygen atoms of the serine residue (mini-protein) and oxygen atoms (water) in systems 2, 4, and 6. We selected an intrinsically acidic hydrogen atom of the imidazole ring to represent binding behavior of the 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium cation. This site of the cation was selected, because it is most electron deficient among atoms of [EMIM]+. Particularly this atom participates in hydrogen bonding with other chemical entities including anions in the condensed phase of ionic liquid. Figure 4 depicts RDFs between serine residue (carboxyl oxygen atom) and imidazole hydrogen atom computed in the six simulated AAIL containing systems. The amino acid anion of AAIL impacts significantly and provides different RDFs in each AAIL. Figure 4. Radial distribution functions (RDF) featuring spatial correlation between carboxyl oxygen atoms of serine residue (mini-protein) and intrinsically acidic hydrogen (imidazole ring) in systems 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6. The first peaks in all AAIL containing systems is located at 0.18 nm, which corresponds to a strong hydrogen bond between the imidazolium-based cation and the mini-protein. The first minima are poorly defined ranging from 0.3 to 0.4 nm. As composition of the first coordination sphere directly depends on the definition of it, the corresponding coordination numbers with respect to 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium cation, n+, must be treated with caution. In the 5% AAIL solutions, n+=0.11 in [EMIM][ALA], n+=0.11 in [EMIM][MET] and n+=0.07 in [EMIM][TRP]. Compare with n– reported above. The mutual affinity between the mini-protein and amino acid anions are hereby proven. In the pure AAIL systems (1, 3, 5), n+ obviously increases: n+ ([EMIM[ALA])=0.92, n+ ([EMIM[ALA])=0.77, n+ ([EMIM[ALA])=0.23. This is in concordance with RDFs for the mini-protein and the anions suggesting that affinity of the anions decreases in the following row: [EMIM][TRP]>[EMIM][MET]>[EMIM][ALA]. The root-mean-square deviation (RMSD) of the macromolecule structure is a central measure of its stability, in the broad sense, vs. time. Rupture of the initial mini-protein structure would result in high values of RMSD. In turn, smaller RMSD values would suggest a better conservation of the protein. RMSD is not only the function of solvent transport properties, but also – and to a larger extent – on specific chemical interactions between the mini-protein and solvents. According to Figure 5, the mini-protein has the largest conformational flexibility in water. Water is a natural environment for proteins. Although the investigated mini-protein retains stability at 310 K, temperature elevation will likely violate an initial structure drastically. It is widely known that many proteins in the multicellular organisms start denaturing at 40-50 °C. Such a denaturation is a primary reason that very little higher animal are able to survive even short temperature elevations. Bacteria and virus are much more advanced in this aspect, because their proteins are different. Thermal denaturation is considered the most frequent denaturation pathway, which takes place during storage of macromolecules in vitro. The conventional techniques, such as chemical modification, immobilization, stabilizing agents, cannot defend from thermal denaturation. However, this can be realistically achieved through the usage of different solvent, because RMSD in pure AAILs is significantly smaller than in water and in 5 mol% aqueous mixtures of AAILs. The difference between the cases of pure [EMIM][ALA], [EMIM][MET], and [EMIM][TRP] is not drastic. All three AAILs efficiently solvate the mini-protein similarly to water. They do not induce any observable structural alterations. Moreover, thermal fluctuations of the mini-protein structure in AAILs are smaller suggesting a better thermal stability of the mini-protein. Figure 5. Evolution of the root-mean-square deviation (RMSD) of the mini-protein structure upon the 100 ns long equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations. The first equilibrated geometry was taken as a reference point. See legends for system designation. Radius of gyration (Rg, Figure 6) confirms conclusions about a higher stability of the mini-protein in AAILs and 5 mol% AAIL solutions in water. Little changes of Rg were observed during 100 ns of equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations. Rg of the mini- protein in [EMIM][ALA] equals to 0.74±0.01 nm; 0.76±0.01 nm in [EMIM][MET]; 0.74±0.01 nm in [EMIM][TRP]; 0.74±0.01 nm in pure water. The standard deviation of Rg in water is slightly larger than in other systems, which is consistent with larger RMSD (Figure 5). All corresponding values of Rg and their components are summarized in Table S1. Figure 6. Radius of gyration of the mini-protein as a function of time during equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations. See legends for system designation. The average values of radius of gyration are summarized in Table S1. One of the most interesting questions that must be attended in this investigation is which solvent and which chemical entity in particular prevail in the first coordination sphere of the model mini-protein and are, therefore, responsible for its efficient solvation and conservation. The posed question can be answered in terms of distribution functions and coordination numbers, which are the integrals of those functions. Figures 7-8 investigate spatial correlations between terminal hydrogen atoms (position w) and methyl group hydrogen atoms of the mini-protein with oxygen atoms of water and three AAILs during the 100 ns long equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations of the seven systems. The two most representative plots are shown here. An interested reader is referred to Supplementary Information, Figures S1-S4, for all summarized RDFs. The w-H atoms are strongly correlated with carboxyl groups of the anions by creating multiple hydrogen bonds with the length of ca. 0.18 nm. In turn, both imidazolium cations and water molecules are pushed to the second coordination sphere, where they exhibit quite smashed RDF peaks. Unlike [EMIM]+, certain amount of water molecules is still present in the first shell, but the corresponding RDF maximum is much smaller as compared to that of the anions. 5% [EMIM][TRP] AAIL/water mixture (right). Snapshots highlight mini-protein solvation. Figure 7. Radial distribution functions (RDFs) featuring spatial correlation between hydrogen atoms (position w) of the mini-protein and oxygen atoms of solvents in pure AAIL (left) and Binding of all solvents to the methyl group is sufficiently different. Despite the first peak corresponding to [EMIM]+ at 0.42 nm, no strong structure correlations were observed. Even this peak vanishes in the 5 mol% [EMIM][MET] aqueous solution. The RDFs in other AAILs (Figures S1-S2) completely support this conclusion. All applicable coordination numbers range between 0.2 and 0.3. That is the methyl group appears insufficiently solvated by both solvents. Based on the RDF in the pure [EMIM][TRP] system, one can identify that 310 K is lower than a glassy transition temperature for the system containing the model mini- protein and this AAIL (system 5). Figure 8. Radial distribution functions (RDFs) featuring spatial correlation between hydrogen atoms (methyl groups) of the mini-protein and oxygen atoms of solvents in pure AAIL (left) and 5% [EMIM][MET] AAIL/water mixture (right). Snapshots highlight mini-protein solvation. Conclusions Classical molecular dynamics simulations using the recently developed force field for amino acid-based ionic liquids were carried out to observe their solvation behavior in relation to model mini-protein. In addition to pure AAILs, 5 mol% aqueous solutions of these AAILs were considered, since water is always abundant in real biological systems. We found that AAILs efficiently coordinate the mini-protein. This happens primarily thanks to amino acid based anions, which interact strongly with (the ‘like dissolves like’ rule holds). AAILs push some water molecules outside the first coordination sphere. This observation is in concordance with previous reports.7,10 Being coordinated by the ions, the mini-protein exhibits hindered mobility, as indicated by the RMSD analysis in all six AAIL containing systems. The conformation flexibility is even smaller when water is completely excluded. This observation favors applications of amino acid-based ionic liquids for conservation of proteins and their subsequent usage in vitro. Importantly, solvation by AAILs does not perturb an initial shape and configuration of the mini-protein, as suggested by constant radius of gyration and its components. According to our computational analysis, AAILs emerge as an interesting candidate solvent or cosolvent for a robust protein solvation, conservation and storage. We anticipate that our paper will inspire more experimental efforts in this direction. Acknowledgments The research was supported by CAPES, FAPESP and CNPq. Supporting Information Table S1 summarizes radii of gyration and their components. Figures S1-S4 show radial distribution functions for the mini-protein and selected AAILs. Author Information E-mails for correspondence: [email protected] (G.C.); [email protected] (E.E.F.); [email protected] (V.V.C.) Zhang, T.; Wang, L. J.; Chen, H. Protein Extraction of the Long-Term Room (1) Temperature Storage Wheat Straw. Material Design, Processing and Applications, Parts 1- 4 2013, 690-693, 1252-1255. REFERENCES (2) Fabian, C.; Ju, Y. H. A Review on Rice Bran Protein: Its Properties and Extraction Methods. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition 2011, 51, 816-827. Patel, R.; Kumari, M.; Khan, A. B. Recent Advances in the Applications of Ionic (3) Liquids in Protein Stability and Activity: A Review. Applied Biochemistry and Biotechnology 2014, 172, 3701-3720. Chen, X. W.; Mao, Q. X.; Wang, J. H. Ionic Liquids in Extraction/Separation of (4) Proteins. Progress in Chemistry 2013, 25, 661-668. (5) Asenjo, J. A.; Andrews, B. A. Aqueous Two-Phase Systems for Protein Separation: A Perspective. Journal of Chromatography A 2011, 1218, 8826-8835. Takekiyo, T.; Yamazaki, K.; Yamaguchi, E.; Abe, H.; Yoshimura, Y. High Ionic Liquid (6) Concentration-Induced Structural Change of Protein in Aqueous Solution: A Case Study of Lysozyme. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2012, 116, 11092-11097. Vasantha, T.; Attri, P.; Venkatesu, P.; Devi, R. S. R. Structural Basis for the (7) Enhanced Stability of Protein Model Compounds and Peptide Backbone Unit in Ammonium Ionic Liquids. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2012, 116, 11968-11978. Sun, Y.; Dominy, B. N.; Latour, R. A. Comparison of Solvation-Effect Methods for (8) the Simulation of Peptide Interactions with a Hydrophobic Surface. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2007, 28, 1883-1892. (9) Sun, Y.; Latour, R. A. Comparison of Implicit Solvent Models for the Simulation of Protein-Surface Interactions. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2006, 27, 1908-1922. (10) Chowdhury, R.; Sen Mojumdar, S.; Chattoraj, S.; Bhattacharyya, K. Effect of Ionic Liquid on the Native and Denatured State of a Protein Covalently Attached to a Probe: Solvation Dynamics Study. Journal of Chemical Physics 2012, 137. (11) Das, D. K.; Das, A. K.; Mandal, A. K.; Mondal, T.; Bhattacharyya, K. Effect of an Ionic Liquid on the Unfolding of Human Serum Albumin: A Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy Study. Chemphyschem 2012, 13, 1949-1955. (12) Eilmes, A.; Kubisiak, P. Stability of Ion Triplets in Ionic Liquid/Lithium Salt Solutions: Insights from Implicit and Explicit Solvent Models and Molecular Dynamics Simulations. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2015, 36, 751-762. (13) Bessac, F.; Maseras, F. Dft Modeling of Reactivity in an Ionic Liquid: How Many Ion Pairs? Journal of Computational Chemistry 2008, 29, 892-899. (14) Carlin, C.; Gordon, M. S. Ab Initio Calculation of Anion Proton Affinity and Ionization Potential for Energetic Ionic Liquids. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2015, 36, 597-600. (15) Addicoat, M. A.; Fukuoka, S.; Page, A. J.; Irle, S. Stochastic Structure Determination for Conformationally Flexible Heterogenous Molecular Clusters: Application to Ionic Liquids. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2013, 34, 2591-2600. (16) Corvo, M. C.; Sardinha, J.; Menezes, S. C.; Einloft, S.; Seferin, M.; Dupont, J.; Casimiro, T.; Cabrita, E. J. Solvation of Carbon Dioxide in [C(4)Mim][Bf4] and [C(4)Mim][Pf6] Ionic Liquids Revealed by High-Pressure Nmr Spectroscopy. Angewandte Chemie-International Edition 2013, 52, 13024-13027. (17) Chaban, V. Hydrogen Fluoride Capture by Imidazolium Acetate Ionic Liquid. Chemical Physics Letters 2015, 625, 110-115. (18) Ohba, T.; Chaban, V. V. A Highly Viscous Imidazolium Ionic Liquid inside Carbon Nanotubes. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2014, 118, 6234-6240. (19) Hantal, G.; Voroshylova, I.; Cordeiro, M. N. D. S.; Jorge, M. A Systematic Molecular Simulation Study of Ionic Liquid Surfaces Using Intrinsic Analysis Methods. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2012, 14, 5200-5213. (20) Chaban, V. V.; Prezhdo, O. V. Water Phase Diagram Is Significantly Altered by Imidazolium Ionic Liquid. Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 2014, 5, 1623-1627. (21) Weingartner, H.; Cabrele, C.; Herrmann, C. How Ionic Liquids Can Help to Stabilize Native Proteins. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2012, 14, 415-426. (22) Chowdhury, R.; Sen Mojumdar, S.; Chattoraj, S.; Bhattacharyya, K. Effect of Ionic Liquid on the Native and Denatured State of a Protein Covalently Attached to a Probe: Solvation Dynamics Study. J Chem Phys 2012, 137, 055104. (23) Vasantha, T.; Attri, P.; Venkatesu, P.; Devi, R. S. Structural Basis for the Enhanced Stability of Protein Model Compounds and Peptide Backbone Unit in Ammonium Ionic Liquids. J Phys Chem B 2012, 116, 11968-11978. (24) Takekiyo, T.; Yamazaki, K.; Yamaguchi, E.; Abe, H.; Yoshimura, Y. High Ionic Liquid Concentration-Induced Structural Change of Protein in Aqueous Solution: A Case Study of Lysozyme. J Phys Chem B 2012, 116, 11092-11097. (25) Figueiredo, A. M.; Sardinha, J.; Moore, G. R.; Cabrita, E. J. Protein Destabilisation in Ionic Liquids: The Role of Preferential Interactions in Denaturation. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2013, 15, 19632-19643. (26) Ohno, H.; Fukumoto, K. Amino Acid Ionic Liquids. Accounts of Chemical Research 2007, 40, 1122-1129. (27) Fileti, E. E.; Chaban, V. V. The Scaled-Charge Additive Force Field for Amino Acid Based Ionic Liquids. Chemical Physics Letters 2014, 616, 205-211. (28) Chaban, V. V.; Fileti, E. E. Ionic Clusters Vs Shear Viscosity in Aqueous Amino Acid Ionic Liquids. J Phys Chem B 2015, 119, 3824-3828. (29) Dagade, D. H.; Madkar, K. B.; Shinde, S. P.; Barge, S. S. Thermodynamic Studies of Ionic Hydration and Interactions for Amino Acid Ionic Liquids in Aqueous Solutions at 298.15 K (Vol 117, Pg 1031, 2013). Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2013, 117, 9584- 9584. (30) Zhu, J. F.; He, L.; Zhang, L.; Huang, M.; Tao, G. H. Experimental and Theoretical Enthalpies of Formation of Glycine-Based Sulfate/Bisulfate Amino Acid Ionic Liquids. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2012, 116, 113-119. (31) Sirjoosingh, A.; Alavi, S.; Woo, T. K. Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Equilibrium and Transport Properties of Amino Acid-Based Room Temperature Ionic Liquids. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2009, 113, 8103-8113. (32) Hess, B.; Bekker, H.; Berendsen, H. J. C.; Fraaije, J. G. E. M. Lincs: A Linear Constraint Solver for Molecular Simulations. J. Comp. Chem. 1997, 18, 1463. (33) Best, R. B.; Zhu, X.; Shim, J.; Lopes, P. E.; Mittal, J.; Feig, M.; Mackerell, A. D., Jr. Optimization of the Additive Charmm All-Atom Protein Force Field Targeting Improved Sampling of the Backbone Phi, Psi and Side-Chain Chi(1) and Chi(2) Dihedral Angles. J Chem Theory Comput 2012, 8, 3257-3273. (34) Martinez, L.; Andrade, R.; Birgin, E. G.; Martinez, J. M. Packmol: A Package for Building Initial Configurations for Molecular Dynamics Simulations. J Comput Chem 2009, 30, 2157-2164. (35) Darden, T.; York, D.; Pedersen, L. Particle Mesh Ewald: An N·Log(N) Method for Ewald Sums in Large Systems. J. Chem. Phys. 1993, 98, 10089-10099. (36) Bussi, G.; Donadio, D.; Parrinello, M. Canonical Sampling through Velocity Rescaling. J. Chem. Phys. 126 2007, 126, 014101-014108. (37) Parrinello, M.; Rahman, A. Polymorphic Transitions in Single Crystals: A New Molecular Dynamics Method. J. Appl. Phys. 1981, 52, 7182-7192. (38) McGibbon, R. T.; Beauchamp, K. A.; Schwantes, C. R.; Wang, L. P.; Hernandez, C. X.; Harrigan, M. P.; Lane, T. J.; Swails, J. M.; Pande, V. S. Mdtraj: A Modern, Open Library for the Analysis of Molecular Dynamics Trajectories. BioRxiv 2014. (39) Humphrey, W.; Dalke, A.; Schulten, K. Vmd: Visual Molecular Dynamics. Journal of Molecular Graphics 1996, 14, 33-38.
1905.03575	1	1905	2019-05-09T12:39:03	A TDDFT-based Study on the Proton-DNA Collision	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.chem-ph" ]	The interaction of heavy charged particles with DNA is of interest for several areas, from hadrontherapy to aero-space industry. In this paper, a TD-DFT study on the interaction of a 4 keV proton with an isolated DNA base pair was carried out. Ehrenfest dynamics was used to study the evolution of the system during and after the proton impact up to about 193 fs. This time was long enough to observe the dissociation of the target, which occurs between 80-100 fs. The effect of base pair linking to the DNA double helix was emulated by fixing the four O3' atoms responsible for the attachment. The base pair tends to dissociate into its main components, namely the phosphate groups, sugars and nitrogenous bases. A central impact with energy transfer of 17.9 eV only produces base damage while keeping the backbone intact. An impact on a phosphate group with energy transfer of about 60 eV leads to backbone break at that site together with base damage, while the opposite backbone site integrity is kept is this situation. As the whole system is perturbed during such a collision, no atom remains passive. These results suggest that base damage accompanies all backbone breaks since hydrogen bonds that keep bases together are much weaker that those between the other components of the DNA.	physics.bio-ph	physics	A TDDFT-based Study on the Proton-DNA Collision Rodrigo Seraide,† Mario A. Bernal,∗,† Gustavo Brunetto,† Umberto de Giovannini,‡,¶ and Angel Rubio‡,§ †Instituto de F´ısica Gleb Wataghin. Universidade Estadual de Campinas. SP. Brazil. ‡Max Planck Institute for the Structure and Dynamics of Matter and Center for Free-Electron Laser Science & Department of Physics. Luruper Chaussee 149. 22761 ¶Dipartimento di Fisica e Chimica. Universit`a degli Studi di Palermo. Via Archirafi 36. Hamburg. Germany. §Nano-Bio Spectroscopy Group and ETSF, Dpto. F´ısica de Materiales, Universidad del I-90123. Palermo. Italy. Pa´ıs Vasco UPV/EHU, 20018 San Sebasti´an, Spain. E-mail: [email protected] 9 1 0 2 y a M 9 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 5 7 5 3 0 . 5 0 9 1 : v i X r a 1 Abstract The interaction of heavy charged particles with DNA is of interest for several areas, from hadrontherapy to aero-space industry. In this paper, a TD-DFT study on the interaction of a 4 keV proton with an isolated DNA base pair was carried out. Ehrenfest dynamics was used to study the evolution of the system during and after the proton impact up to about 193 fs. This time was long enough to observe the dissociation of the target, which occurs between 80-100 fs. The effect of base pair linking to the DNA double helix was emulated by fixing the four O3' atoms responsible for the attachment. The base pair tends to dissociate into its main components, namely the phosphate groups, sugars and nitrogenous bases. A central impact with energy transfer of 17.9 eV only produces base damage while keeping the backbone intact. An impact on a phosphate group with energy transfer of about 60 eV leads to backbone break at that site together with base damage, while the opposite backbone site integrity is kept is this situation. As the whole system is perturbed during such a collision, no atom remains passive. These results suggest that base damage accompanies all backbone breaks since hydrogen bonds that keep bases together are much weaker that those between the other components of the DNA. Introduction The interaction of ionizing particles with DNA is a very complex process which depends both on the particle track structure (radiation quality) and the genetic material geometrical conformation. The early physicochemical damage that ionizing radiation induces in DNA may lead to biological effects. These effects are of supreme importance for medical radiation applications, both for diagnostic and therapeutic procedures. In addition, aerospace industry is interested on this problem as astronauts are exposed to charged particle radiation during their missions, and this includes heavy particles with mass even larger than a proton. The radiobiological problem consists in studying biological effects induced by ionizing particles in 2 living beings. Several approaches have been used to deal with this problem during the past seven decades. In vitro assays, in which cellular cultures are irradiated and later analyzed, is the main source of information for understanding this problem. This is the case of the pioneer works of Karl Sax and coworkers, 1 which were used by Lea and Catchside 2 as an empirical base to formulate a successful biophysical model for the early DNA damage. Later, Kellerer and Rossi proposed the long-standing Dual Radiation Action Theory, 3 which states that lethal lesions induced by ionizing radiation in cells are produced by the interaction of two sub-lesions (probably double strand breaks, DSB). With the rapid increase of computing power along the last few decades, numerical ap- proaches came out. For instance, Monte Carlo simulation of particle transport can be com- bined with a DNA geometrical models and biophysical model in such a way that DNA damage probability can be estimated. 4 -- 7 The latter approach counts a DNA damage, typical a single strand break (SSB), when an energy deposition above a certain threshold value oc- curs inside the target in question. Commonly, this target is the sugar-phosphate group. This method implicitly assumes that the collision of the ionizing particle with DNA is a one-body problem. That is, the rest of the DNA molecule remains frozen when the incoming particle interact with the atom in question. This is not the case in reality, mainly when dealing with relatively slow ions which produce a strong perturbation of the target system. Time Dependent Density Functional Theory (TD-DFT) emerges as a powerful tool to study the full dynamics of collisions involving complex systems since it is capable to ac- count for the many body problem in a consistent way. First of all, the ground state of the target system is determined using the Density Functional Theory (DFT). According to the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem, the ground-state density is enough to determine the ground state of an electronic system. 8 Kohn and Sham 9 found a way to uncouple the Schrodinger equation system of the electronic system, making the problem easier to solve. That is, the Kohn-Sham formalism is able to exactly map the interacting system into a non-interacting and easier to solve problem. 3 In principle, TD-DFT can be used to study the collision between a charged particle and DNA or some of its constituents. Bacchus et al. 10 studied the collision of carbon ions on nitrogenous bases thymine, uracil and 5-halouracil. Targets were bombarded at various in- cidence direction and impact parameters. Calculations were carried out with the MOLPRO package. 11 They determined charge transfer cross sections for different carbon ions charge states by following an impact parameter approximation. The authors speculate about dis- sociation cross sections but they did not study this process directly. Sadr-Arani et al. 12 -- 15 have carried out several works using experimental and theoretical methods for studying the fragmentation of DNA/RNA bases such as uracil, cytosine, adenine, and guanine. Their cal- culations were based on the DFT formalism by they did not explicitly simulate any collision process. Instead, they stretched bonds up to break and determined the involved dissocia- tion energies and possible fragments. Lopez-Tarifa et al. 16 have recently used the TD-DFT approach to study the fragmentation of doubly ionized uracil in gas phase. They did not account for the explicit incidence of any projectile. They simply removed electrons from inner-shells ad hoc and let the excited molecule evolve in time. Classical molecular dynamics has been also used to study the collision of charged particles with DNA. Albofath et al. 17 used the reactive force field ReaxFF 18 to study the role of hydroxyl free radicals on DNA damage. They randomly distributed free hydroxyl radicals in small pockets around a DNA fragment and followed the evolution of the system. They found that OH radicals produce holes in the sugar-moiety rings and that they evolve to larger holes that comprise several bases. Then this damage propagates to the bases and lead to single and double strand breaks. One year later, Abolfath et al. 19 continued studying the same process using the GEANT4-DNA Monte Carlo package 20 to obtain the initial position of hydroxyl radicals. Then, the interaction of those radicals with DNA was described by the REAXFF- based molecular dynamics approach. Primary 1 MeV electrons and protons were studied in this work. They reported that protons produce four times more DNA double strand breaks that electrons with the same energy. Bottlander et al. 21 used the REAX force field provided 4 by Abolfath et al. 19 to study the interaction of protons with DNA in a NaCl aqueous solution. They simulated the direct interaction of a proton with a DNA fiber fragment by uniformly distributing the energy transferred by the projectile to the target atoms within a cylinder with 2 A radius. This energy was determined from the particle stopping power. The authors reported the number of SSB and DSB produced by different energy transferred to the medium when the projectile travels along the three main cartesian axes. The effect of a violent sock wave created by ions with a very high stopping power (or linear energy transfer) has been also studied using classical molecular dynamics. 22,23 They used the CHARMM potential model to simulate the evolution of DNA atoms after the passage of the ion so explicit bond breakage was not accounted for. Instead, they estimated energy changes in DNA bonds due the influence of the ion-induced shock wave and speculated on the possible creation of single strand breaks. Recently, Bacchus-Montabonel and Calvo 24,25 studied the effect of the hydration shell around biomolecular targets (uracil and aminooxazole) on the proton-induced charge transfer process. This effect was done by adding only two water molecules at different molecular sites. They determined charge transfer cross sections during the impact of 10 eV to 10 keV protons using a software package based on the impact parameter approximation, rather than using TD-DFT calculations. This work aims at the study of the proton-DNA collision problem using the TD-DFT to see how a base-pair evolves during and after the impact of an energetic proton. This approach should allow the observation of many-body effects during this collision. In addition, in-vacuum dissociation times and the energy required for this dissociation can be estimated under different conditions, including different impact parameters and bounding with neighbor base-pairs. It should be remarked that the detailed study of the DNA dissociation is out of the scope of this work. We simply want to have a qualitative picture of this process as a support for the introduction of a new approach to study the early DNA damage induced by ionizing radiation. This new method would be an alternative to current biophysical models (discussed above). That is, those approaches based on the assumption that only the atom 5 targeted by the incoming particle is affected while the others remain frozen and that double strand breaks can be induced after the production of two close enough single strand breaks. Up to our knowledge, this is the first time the TD-DFT approach is used to explicitly study the collision between a heavy charged particle and a DNA base pair. Atomic units are used throughout this work, unless otherwise stated. Methods Theoretical background of the TD-DFT. The electronic Schrodinger equation of the interacting system with N electrons with positions at (r1, r2, ..., rN), respectively, is (cid:110) − 1 2 N(cid:88) i=1 ∇2 i + 1 2 2(cid:88) i,j=1 N(cid:88) i=1 vext(ri) 1 ri − rj + (cid:111) Ψ(r1, r2, ..., rN) = EΨ(r1, r2, ..., rN), (1) where the first term is the kinetic energy of electrons and the second one is the so-called Hartree term. The external potential in absence of electromagnetic fields is vext(ri) = − M(cid:88) k=1 Zk ri − RK (2) and comes from the interaction of electrons with point-like nuclei. After solving equation (1), the electronic density n(r) can be determined as (cid:90) n(r) = N d3r2 ··· d3rN Ψ(r, r2, ..., rN)Ψ∗(r, r2, ..., rN). (3) Equation (1) is very hard to solve but Kohn and Sham found a simpler and exact way to solve it by introducing the exchange-correlation potential vxc(r). According to their approach, the equation system (1) can be decomposed in equations for the orbitals φi(r) 6 forming a single Slater determinant of a fictitious non-interacting system with the same density of the interacting one as following ∇2 + vHartree[n](r) + vext(r) + vxc[n](r) φKS i (r) = EφKS i (r), (4) (cid:110) − 1 2 where (cid:90) d3r(cid:48) n(r(cid:48)) r − r(cid:48) vHartree[n](r) = (5) and vxc[n](r) is the exchange-correlation potential which accounts for the many-body effects of the problem. Notice that the Hartree and exchange-correlation potentials are (cid:111) (cid:111) functional of the density defined as N(cid:88) i=1 n(r) = φKS i (r)2. For the time-dependent case, Kohn-Sham equations are (cid:110) − 1 2 ∇2 + vHartree[n](r, t) + vext(r, t) + vxc[n](r, t) φKS i (6) (r, t) = i ∂ ∂t φKS i (r, t), (7) Now both the density n(r, t) and nuclei positions RK(r, t) are functions of time. Similar to the ground state calculation, equation system (7) is solved in a self-consistent way for each time step. Here, we used the Adiabatic Local Density Approximation for describing the time- dependent exchange-correlation functional vxc[n](r, t). 26 The time-evolution of nuclei was described through the Ehrenfest dynamics. In this formalism, nuclei are treated classically and allowed to move under the influence of the mean field generated by electrons. That is, their equation of motion is mK ∂2RK ∂t2 = −∇KV ( ¯R), (8) where mK and Rk are the nucleus mass and position, respectively. V ( ¯R) accounts for 7 the electron-nucleus attraction and nucleus-nucleus repulsion and is a function of the nuclei positions ¯R = (R1, R2, ..., RM ). In this approximation the solution to the time dependent Schrodinger equation is obtained propagating the classical equation of motion for the ions (8) together with the quantum mechanical TDDFT equations for the electrons (7) until a given time. Collision setup A proton with about 4 keV energy impacts on an isolated Guanine-Cytosine B-DNA base- pair (bp) at rest. Atoms positions correspond to canonical B-DNA as that found in Protein Data Bank ID 309D. 27 This bp contains the whole phosphate group on one side, ending in O3', and the O3' atom belonging to the phosphate adjacent group. In other words, this bp's backbone ends in two O3' atoms. These terminal oxygen atoms were fixed in some calculations to simulate the effect of bounding to the adjacent base pairs (see details below). In order to stabilize the molecule, we completed the dangling bonds with hydrogens. This means that hydrogen atoms were added to both O3' terminals and another one was attached to the O2P atom, which is responsible for some DNA-protein binding. Two impact parameters were included in this study. First, the proton impinges the DNA bp with 0 impact parameter with respect to the molecule's geometrical center, near the hydrogen-bridge bonds that link nitrogenous bases. Second, the proton impacts the bp with 0 impact parameter with respect to the upper phosphorus atom, which belongs a the sugar-phosphate group. The proton initially travels along the Z axis, which normally crosses the plane containing the nitrogenous bases atoms. Fig (1) shows the localization of the DNA atoms and the incoming proton. It should be remarked that this proton is treated as any other ion of the target system, as described in eq. 8. 8 Figure 1: Proton-DNA collision setups. Ground state calculation The Octopus code version 4.1.2 28 -- 30 was used to carry out TDDFT calculations. A ground state calculation for the DNA bp was done in a first stage. The Local Density Approximation (LDA) and the modified Perdew& Zunger LDA 31 were used for the exchange and correlation functionals, respectively. The system in question was placed inside a 46x20x20 a.u.3 box and the calculation grid was obtained using a 0.4 a.u. spacing along the three Cartesian axes. This spacing was found after an optimization process during which the system total energy converged. Troullier-Martins pseudopotentials were used for all the atoms that conform the bp 32 in such a way that their K-shell electrons were not treated explicitly. Using these pseudopotentials, the number of orbitals for the whole bp was 119. 9 a)b)Guanine(GUA)Cytosine(CYT)sugar-phosphatebackbonesugar-phosphatebackboneH+H+CNOPHAtom TypesxzyTime-dependent calculations After having obtained the ground state of the DNA bp, the proton was placed ad hoc according to the impact parameter in question. For the proton with zero impact parameter with respect to the geometrical center of the bp, the initial position was (0,0,-15) a.u. For the proton with zero impact parameter w.r.t. the upper phosphorus atom (Cytosine side), the initial point was (16.721,-4.396,-15) a.u. The initial proton velocity was (0,0,0.4) a.u. in both cases so the proton impinges normal to the plane defined by the nitrogenous bases. A first calculation was done for the central impact case in which all atoms were free to move. In a second stage, the four O3' terminal atoms were fixed. This emulates the case in which the bp is bound to a double helix DNA chain. Time step was set to 0.05 a.u. and the total calculation time was 8000 a.u. (∼193 fs). This time was chosen in such a way that the initial dissociation process can be observed. Calculations were carried out in a 120-core cluster and a single 193 fs calculation took about 6 weeks of wall-clock time. Absorbing boundary conditions were employed to prevent artificial reflections of electrons at the boundary of the simulation box. 33 The complex potential method was used. According to preliminary calculations, a temperature of 300 K shows negligible effects on the evolution of the bond lengths in question. Time-evolution rendering was done with the VMD software. 34 Results Figure 2 shows snapshots at characteristic times during the evolution of the DNA bp after the proton impact at zero impact parameter where all atoms are free to move. Blue shaded area represents the 0.001 % electronic density isosurface to show the evolution during the collision. Snapshot a) captures the proton just passing through the bp. Snapshot b) displays the proton charge capture. In the following lines, an energetic analysis will be carried out as a consistency test of our calculations. Yet, it does not aim at a rigorous explanation of the DNA dissociation. The energy transferred by the proton to the bp was 17.9 eV in 10 this collision. This energy is mainly transferred to the electrons during the collision and about 33 % (6.02 eV) of it is subsequently transferred to the ions until just before the dissociation process start. At first glance, it seems that the bp tends to dissociate into its main components, namely the phosphate groups, sugars, and bases. However, Fig. 3a shows that both O5' atoms dissociate from the corresponding phosphate groups. In fact, they remain attached to the corresponding sugar through the C5' atom (ester bond), which means that the integrity of the deoxyribose sugar prevails over that of the phosphate group. P-O5' (P-O(C)) and P-O2 (P=O) bonds require about 3.67 eV and 6.03 eV for breaking, respectively. 35 Thus it is more energetically advantageous to break the P-O5' bond instead of the P-O2 one. It was also obtained that the P-O5' bond length is ∼1.593 A, which remains stable until the dissociation process takes place. This value agrees with results reported in the literature (1.591-1.603 A). 35 Then, about 7.34 eV would be used to break both P- O5' bonds. The hydrogen-bonds that keep bases together are relatively weak. The binding energy of the N-H-N and N-H-O bonds are ∼0.135 eV and ∼0.301 eV, respectively. 36 In the CG bp, there are one N-H-N and two N-H-O bonds so the total binding energy for these hydrogen-bonds is around 0.737 eV. Thus, an energy of about 8.077 eV is used to dissociate the three hydrogen bonds and two sugar-phosphate bonds so still remain additional 9.823 eV from the transferred energy, which include the kinetic energy transferred to the ions (6.02 eV). Figure 3a shows that the sugar-cytosine bond is broken unlike that between the sugar and the guanine base, which remains stable during the calculation time. C-N bond energy is about 3.158 eV 37 so it is estimated from these results that about 11.235 eV are used to dissociate the DNA bp. The remaining transferred energy should be converted into kinetic energy of the dissociation fragments. Fig. 3a shows that the DNA bp actually dissociates into five products. Bond breaking occurs so that the main constituents of the DNA separate from each others. That is, the molecule tends to produce fragments such as phosphite groups, nitrogenous bases and de- oxyriboses. This fragmentation pathway seems to be plausible since the fragments produced 11 are relatively stable radicals and the linkage between them should be the weakest bonds of the molecule. However, unlike the sugar-cytosine bond, the sugar-guanine bond is stable until 193 fs. Sugar-cytosine and cytosine-guanine bonds begin to dissociate almost simul- taneously (from ∼50 fs on), while sugar-phosphate bonds take a bit longer (from ∼80 fs). These dissociation times are consistent with those reported for large molecules (∼0.1 ps). 38 The time elapsed between the proton impact and the beginning of dissociation was estimated as ∼49 fs. These results shows that passage of the proton perturbs the whole system. That is, this is a many-body collision in which no component of the system remains frozen. Figure 2: System snapshots for some important stages during the proton-free DNA central collision: a) the proton just passing through the bp, b) the proton leaves the bp taking a fraction of the system charge (electron capture process), c) beginning of the dissociation process, and d) the bp dissociates with into five fragments. Animation with the whole process can be found in supplementary information. 12 a)b)c)d)xzyGUAGUAGUAGUACYTCYTCYTCYT1.21 fs2.42 fs44.7 fs193 fsFigure 4 shows the same results as in Fig. 2, but with the O3' terminal atoms held fixed in order to emulate the binding of the bp to their neighbors. The energy transfer is 17.9 eV again which means that the binding of the bp to their neighbors does not influence this quantity, at least for central impact. This energy transfer occurs in a very short time so it is possible that the effect of bp linking through oxygen atoms relatively far from the impact region is very weak. As in the free DNA case, about 6.01 eV of this energy is later transferred to the ions after the collision. The dissociation process can be better observed in Fig. 3b. The dissociation of the hydrogen bonds begins almost at the same time as in the free bp case but now the process seems to be slower. At the maximum calculation time, hydrogen bonds lengths are larger for the bound bp than for the free one. Sugar-cytosine bond seems to be in dissociation route but at a slower velocity, beginning at ∼100 fs and thus delayed compared with the free configuration. Unlike the free bp situation, phosphate-sugar bonds do not dissociate. This means that only the so-called base damage occurs while the DNA backbone is not broken. The cytosine base is ejected while guanine remains attached to the corresponding sugar. That is, only three fragments are produced in this case. This behavior would be expected as the bp is now linked to their neighbors and the impact was on the hydrogen bonds that keep bases together. Finally, Fig. 5 shows snapshots of the proton DNA collision when the projectile impinges the phosphorus atom located on the cytosine side. This is a head-on collision where the proton transfers 61.8 eV to the bp. Unlike the two previous configurations, this is violent impact against the phosphorus atom so that 30.74 eV are immediately transferred to this ion, almost 50 % of the total energy transfer. This is an energy transfer high enough to even break the P-O and P=O bonds, which requires about 3.67 eV and 6.03 eV for breaking, respectively. At ∼2 fs and ∼10 fs, O1P and O2P atoms are ejected from the impacted phosphate group. At ∼100 fs, even the phosphorus atom is emitted, together with another oxygen atom and a proton. According to Fig. 3c, hydrogen bonds are dissociated, despite that the impact is relatively far from this region. Only the O5' atom remains linked to the 13 sugar in this sugar-phosphate group. In addition, the sugar is dissociated from the cytosine base, yet the process is slower than hydrogen-bonds dissociation. Again, the sugar-guanine bond survive to the proton impact. C5'-C4' and C5-O5' in both sugars oscillates but do not break so the deoxyribose integrity seems to be preserved. (a) (b) (c) Figure 3: Length of some important DNA bonds as a function of time during and after a collision with a 4 keV proton for cases in which a) all atoms are free and the proton impacts on the bp center, b) all atoms are free except four oxygen atoms that would link the bp to their neighbors and the proton impacts on the bp center, and all atoms are free except four oxygen atoms that would link the bp to their neighbors and c) the proton impacts on one of the phosphorus atoms. Discussion According to this TD-DFT picture, DNA is initially ionized by the proton, both by electron capture and direct ionization. Simultaneously, the proton perturbs the whole system (see 14 024681012140.0010.010.11101001000Phosphate-sugarBondlength(a.u.)time(fs)P-O5`,CytosineP-O5`,Guanine024681012Sugar-CytosineBondlength(a.u.)C1`-N10510152025Cytosine-GuanineBondlength(a.u.)N4-O6N3-N1O2-N2024681012Sugar-GuanineFreeDNAbase-pair.Centralimpact.Bondlength(a.u.)N9-C1`024681012140.0010.010.11101001000Phosphate-sugarBondlength(a.u.)time(fs)C5`-C4`,CytosineC5`-O5`,CytosineC5`-O5`,GuanineC5`-C4`,Guanine024681012Sugar-CytosineBondlength(a.u.)C1`-N10510152025Cytosine-GuanineBondlength(a.u.)N4-O6N3-N1O2-N2024681012Sugar-GuanineBoundDNAbase-pair.Centralimpact.Bondlength(a.u.)N9-C1` 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 1000Phosphate-sugar time (fs)C5`-C4`, CytosineC5`-O5`, CytosineP-O2P, CytosineP-O1P, CytosineC5`-O5`, GuanineC5`-C4`, Guanine 0 2 4 6 8 10 12Sugar-Cytosine (a.u.)C1`-N1 0 5 10 15 20 25Cytosine-Guanine (a.u.)N4-O6N3-N1O2-N2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12Sugar-GuanineBound DNA base-pair. Impact on upper P atom.Bond (a.u.)N9-C1`Figure 4: System snapshots for some important stages during the proton-bound DNA central collision: a) the proton just passing through the bp, b) the proton leaves the bp taking a fraction of the system charge (electron capture process), c) beginning of the dissociation process, and d) the bp dissociates with into three fragments. Animation with the whole process can be found in supplementary information. supplementary information with animations) and this perturbation together with the system ionization lead to the target molecule dissociation. The linking of the DNA bp to their neighbor tends to keep the integrity of the DNA backbone when the proton impacts on the bp center so only bases are damaged. Base damage was present in all the situation studied in this work since the hydrogen bonds that keep bases together have a low binding energy. The energetic analysis of these results show that 17.9 eV transferred during a central impact would only produce base damage while keeping the DNA backbone intact. Current Monte Carlo-based approaches to study the early DNA damage induced by ionizing radiation 15 a)b)c)d)xzyGUACYTGUAGUAGUACYTCYTCYTH+H+ leftcarrying charge1.21 fs2.42 fs100 fs193 fsFigure 5: System snapshots for some important stages during the proton-bound DNA upper collision: a) the proton just passing through the bp, b) the proton leaves the bp taking a fraction of the system charge (electron capture process), c) beginning of the dissociation process, and d) the bp dissociates with into five fragments. Animation with the whole process can be found in supplementary information. 16 xzya)b)c)d)CYTCYTCYTCYTGUAGUAGUAGUA1.21 fs58.1 fs100 fs193 fssuppose that an energy transfer to the phosphate-sugar group above a given threshold is enough to induce a single strand break. This threshold is commonly set to about 10 eV. Those approaches also consider that only the DNA component directly impacted by the projectile is affected. Those components are commonly divided into the sugar-phosphate groups and the nitrogeneous bases. This work shows that an impact on the phosphate group with an energy transfer of about 60 eV would be enough to break the DNA back bone on the impacted side and to damage the bases as well while keeping intact the opposite sugar-phosphate group. Furthermore, it is observed, as expected, that the proton-DNA collision is a many-body problem during which all atoms feel the proton impact and receive a fraction of the transferred energy. Thus, there is no passive DNA base pair component during the collision, unlike it is supposed on the vast majority of biophysical models based on Monte Carlo simulations mentioned just above. A complete TD-DFT study of this problem could provide enough information in order to change the actual paradigm of such biophysical models. That is, DNA damage probabilities could be determined as a function of the projectile impact parameter and several sites can be damage in a single impact, as the backbone and bases. This study also provides insights on the time evolution of the DNA base pair after the proton impact. Dissociation times are consistent with those reported in the literature for large molecules. The linking of the base pair to its neighbors tends to delay the dissociation process, which is about 100 fs according to our results. Conclusions TD-DFT can be a useful tool to study early DNA damage induced by the impact of heavy charged particle. However, due to the enormous computing resources and time demanded even for a single DNA base pair, a systematic study of this process is difficult to accomplish. A complete study should include the combination of many impact parameters, energies, 17 and incidence directions of the projectile. Yet, some interesting features can be obtained even with a limited number of calculations. For instance, energy transfers required for DNA damage can be inferred. In addition, some light can be shed on the effect of base-pair linking to its neigbors and the importance of the impact site on the way DNA is damaged by the ionizing particle. A relatively high energy transferred during the impact of a proton on the phosphate-sugar group can induce a single strand break together with bases damage. It seems that every backbone break is accompanied by base damage. This is an important point since current Monte Carlo-based approaches in computational radiobiology suppose that base damage is independent of backbone break. A central impact with energy transfer of less than 20 eV would not be enough to produce backbone breaks. Current biophysical models used to study the early DNA damage induced by charged particles can be improved with studies like this one. Acknowledgements M.B. thanks the Conselho Nacional para o Desenvolvimento Cient´ıfico e Tecnol´ogico (CNPq), Brazil, for financing his research activities through the project 306775/2015-8. A.R. and U.D.G. acknowledge financial support from the European Research Council(ERC-2015-AdG- 694097), Grupos Consolidados (IT578-13), H2020-NMP-2014 project MOSTOPHOS (GA no. 646259), European Union's H2020 programme under GA no.676580 (NOMAD) and COST Action MP1306 (EUSpec). The images of this work were made with VMD soft- ware support. VMD is developed with NIH support by the Theoretical and Computational Biophysics group at the Beckman Institute, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. References (1) Sax, K. Chromosome aberrations induced by X-rays. Genetics 1938, 23, 494 -- 516. 18 (2) Lea, D. E.; Catcheside, D. G. The mechanism of the induction by radiation of chromo- some aberrations inTradescantia. Journal of Genetics 1942, 44, 216 -- 245. (3) Kellerer, A. M.; Rossi, H. H. The action of dual radiation action. Current Topics in Radiation Rsearch Quarterly 1972, 8, 85 -- 158. (4) Pomplun, E. A new DNA target model for track structure calculations and its first application to I-125 Auger electrons. Int. J. Radiat. Biol. 1991, 59, 625 -- 642. (5) Nikjoo, H.; O'Neil, P.; Terrissol, M.; Goodhead, D. T. Quantitative modelling of DNA damage using Monte Carlo track structure method. Radiat. Environ. Biophys. 1999, 38, 31 -- 38. (6) Friedland, W.; Jacob, P.; Kundr´at, P. Mechanistic simulation of radiation damage to DNA and its repair: on the track towards systems radiation biology modelling. Radiation Protection Dosimetry 2011, 143, 542 -- 548. (7) Bernal, M. A.; deAlmeida, C. E.; David, M.; Pires, E. Estimation of the RBE of mammography-quality beams using a combination of a Monte Carlo code with a B- DNA geometrical model. Physics in Medicine and Biology 2011, 56, 7393 -- 7403. (8) Hohenberg, P.; Kohn, W. Inhomogeneous Electron Gas. Physical Review 1964, 136, B864 -- B871. (9) Kohn, W.; Sham, L. J. Self-Consistent Equations Including Exchange and Correlation Effects. Physical Review 1965, 140, A1133 -- A1138. (10) Bacchus-Montabonel, M.-C.; Tergiman, Y. S. Radiation damage on biomolecular sys- tems: Dynamics of ion induced collision processes. Computational and Theoretical Chemistry 2012, 990, 177 -- 184. (11) Werner, H. J.; Knowles, P. J. MOLPRO package of ab initio programs (version 1010.1). 19 (12) Sadr-Arani, L.; Mignon, P.; Abdoul-Carime, H.; Farizon, B.; Farizon, M.; Chermette, H. DFT study of the fragmentation mechanism of uracil RNA base. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2012, 14, 9855 -- 9870. (13) Sadr-Arani, L.; Mignon, P.; Abdoul-Carime, H.; Farizon, B.; Farizon, M.; Chermette, H. Hydrogen release from charged fragments of the uracil cation followed by their frag- mentation: A DFT study. Chemical Physics Letters 2013, 583, 165 -- 169. (14) Sadr-Arani, L.; Mignon, P.; Chermette, H.; Douki, T. Theoretical and experimental study of the fragmentation of protonated uracil. Chemical Physics Letters 2014, 605, 108 -- 114. (15) Sadr-Arani, L.; Mignon, P.; Chermette, H.; Abdoul-Carime, H.; Farizon, B.; Farizon, M. Fragmentation mechanisms of cytosine, adenine and guanine ionized bases. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2015, 17, 11813 -- 11826. (16) L´opez-Tarifa, P.; Herv´edu Penhoat, M.-A.; Vuilleumier, R.; Gaigeot, M.-P.; Rothlis- berger, U.; Tavernelli, I.; Le Padellec, A.; Champeaux, J.-P.; Alcam´ı, M.; Moretto- Capelle, P. et al. Time-dependent density functional theory molecular dynamics sim- ulation of doubly charged uracil in gas phase. Central European Journal of Physics 2014, 12, 97 -- 102. (17) Abolfath, R. M.; van Duin, A. C. T.; Brabec, T. Reactive Molecular Dynamics Study on the First Steps of DNA Damage by Free Hydroxyl Radicals. The Journal of Physical Chemistry A 2011, 115, 11045 -- 11049. (18) van Duin, A. C. T.; Dasgupta, S.; Lorant, F.; III, W. A. G. ReaxFF: A Reactive Force Field for Hydrocarbons. The Journal of Physical Chemistry A 2001, 105, 9396 -- 9409. (19) Abolfath, R. M.; Carlson, D. J.; Chen, Z. J.; Nath, R. A molecular dynamics simulation of DNA damage induction by ionizing radiation. Physics in Medicine and Biology 2013, 58, 7143. 20 (20) Bernal, M. A. et al. Track structure modeling in liquid water: A review of the Geant4- DNA very low energy extension of the Geant4 Monte Carlo simulation toolkit. Physica Medica: European Journal of Medical Physics 2015, 31, 861 -- 874. (21) Bottlander, D.; Mucksch, C.; Urbassek, H. M. Effect of swift-ion irradiation on DNA molecules: A molecular dynamics study using the REAX force field. Nuclear Instru- ments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 2015, 365, Part B, 622 -- 625. (22) Surdutovich, E.; Yakubovich, A. V.; Solov'yov, A. V. Biodamage via shock waves ini- tiated by irradiation with ions. Scientific Reports 2013, 3, 1289 EP -- . (23) de Vera, P.; Mason, N. J.; Currell, F. J.; Solov'yov, A. V. Molecular dynamics study of accelerated ion-induced shock waves in biological media. The European Physical Journal D 2016, 70, 183. (24) Bacchus-Montabonel, M.-C.; Calvo, F. Nanohydration of uracil: emergence of three- dimensional structures and proton-induced charge transfer. Physical Chemistry Chem- ical Physics 2015, 17, 9629 -- 9633. (25) Bacchus-Montabonel, M. C.; Calvo, F. Influence of microhydration on the structures and proton-induced charge transfer in RNA intermediates. Journal of Molecular Mod- eling 2016, 22, 262. (26) Miguel A.L. Marques, N. T. M., Nogueira, F. M., Gross, E., Rubio, A., Eds. Fundamen- tals of Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory; Lecture Notes in Physics; Springer, 2012; Vol. 837. (27) Protein Data Base. 2013; http://www.pdb.org/pdb/home/home.do. (28) Castro, A.; Appel, H.; Oliveira, M.; Rozzi, C. A.; Andrade, X.; Lorenzen, F.; Mar- ques, M. A. L.; Gross, E. K. U.; Rubio, A. octopus: a tool for the application of 21 time-dependent density functional theory. physica status solidi (b) 2006, 243, 2465 -- 2488. (29) Andrade, X.; Alberdi-Rodriguez, J.; Strubbe, D. A.; Oliveira, M. J. T.; Nogueira, F.; Castro, A.; Muguerza, J.; Arruabarrena, A.; Louie, S. G.; Aspuru-Guzik, A. et al. Time- dependent density-functional theory in massively parallel computer architectures: the octopus project. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 2012, 24, 233202. (30) Andrade, X. et al. Real-space grids and the Octopus code as tools for the development of new simulation approaches for electronic systems. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2015, 17, 31371 -- 31396. (31) Perdew, J. P.; Zunger, A. Self-interaction correction to density-functional approxima- tions for many-electron systems. Physical Review B 1981, 23, 5048 -- 5079. (32) Troullier, N.; Martins, J. L. Efficient pseudopotentials for plane-wave calculations. Phys- ical Review B 1991, 43, 1993 -- 2006. (33) De Giovannini, U.; Larsen, A. H.; Rubio, A. Modeling electron dynamics coupled to continuum states in finite volumes with absorbing boundaries. The European Physical Journal B 2015, 88, 56. (34) Humphrey, W.; Dalke, A.; Schulten, K. VMD: visual molecular dynamics. J Mol. Graph 1996, 14, 33 -- 8, 27 -- 8. (35) Range, K.; McGrath, M. J.; Lopez, X.; York, D. M. The Structure and Stability of Biological Metaphosphate, Phosphate, and Phosphorane Compounds in the Gas Phase and in Solution. Journal of the American Chemical Society 2004, 126, 1654 -- 1665. (36) Legon, A. C.; Millen, D. J. Angular geometries and other properties of hydrogen-bonded dimers: a simple electrostatic interpretation of the success of the electron-pair model. Chemical Society Reviews 1987, 16, 467 -- 498. 22 (37) Huheey, J.; Keiter, E. A.; Keiter, R. L. Inorganic Chemistry; Harper Collins, 1993. (38) Gross, J. H. Mass spectrometry; Springer, 2011. 23
1210.1172	1	1210	2012-10-03T17:01:58	Modeling self-organized systems interacting with few individuals: from microscopic to macroscopic dynamics	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cs.SI", "physics.soc-ph", "q-bio.QM" ]	In nature self-organized systems as flock of birds, school of fishes or herd of sheeps have to deal with the presence of external agents such as predators or leaders which modify their internal dynamic. Such situations take into account a large number of individuals with their own social behavior which interact with a few number of other individuals acting as external point source forces. Starting from the microscopic description we derive the kinetic model through a mean-field limit and finally the macroscopic system through a suitable hydrodynamic limit.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Modeling self-organized systems interacting with few individuals: from microscopic to macroscopic dynamics aUniversity of Ferrara, Department of Mathematics, Via Machiavelli 35, I-44121 Ferrara, Italy. G. Albia, L. Pareschia Abstract In nature self-organized systems as flock of birds, school of fishes or herd of sheeps have to deal with the presence of external agents such as predators or leaders which modify their internal dynamic. Such situations take into account a large number of individuals with their own social behavior which interact with a few number of other individuals acting as external point source forces. Starting from the microscopic description we derive the kinetic model through a mean-field limit and finally the macroscopic system through a suitable hydrodynamic limit. Keywords: Kinetic models, mean field models, flocking, swarming, collective behavior 1. Introduction The aim of this paper is to present different level of descriptions for the dynamic of a large group of agents influenced by a small number of external agent. In a biological context this corresponds to the behavior of a flock or a school of fishes attacked by one or more predators, or the movement of a heard of sheep guided by a sheepdog. Recently such dynamics have been studied also in robotic research, where engineers tried to control the action of a school of fishes introducing a fishbot recognized as leader, see [4]. From the modeling viewpoint this turns out in considering a microscopic dynamic described by classical flocking models like Cuker-Smale and D'Orsogna-Bertozzi et al. (see [10, 12]) interacting with a set of few individuals characterized in an analogous way as in [9]. Moreover, motivated by the works of [5], we endowed the classical dynamic of interaction both with a metric as well as a topological interaction rule. Following the approach in [8] we start from the microscopic dynamic, given by a ODEs system, and we derive two other different level of description: the mesoscopic (or kinetic) level through a mean-field limit and the macroscopic level through a suitable hydrodynamic limit. At difference to the first order macroscopic models proposed in [9] here we obtain second order models for the corresponding continuum dynamic. Finally we report some numerical examples for the solution of the mean field model in a series of test cases. The simulations have been performed using the fast algorithm recently presented in [1]. Rigorous mathematical results concerning the asymptotic limits just described can be found in [2]. Preprint submitted to Elsevier August 10, 2018 2. Microscopic model We are interested in the study of a dynamical system composed of N individuals and N p external agents with the following general structure xi = vi i = 1, . . . , N vi = 1 N ∗ Xj∈Σ∗ N (xi) F (xi, vi, xj, vj) + 1 Np Np Xk=1 F p(xi, vi, pk) (1) ph = ϕh(t, p, AρN (ph)) h = 1, . . . , Np   where (x, v)i = (xi, vi) lives in R2d, d ≥ 1, i = 1, . . . , N and (p)h = ph ∈ Rnd, with n = 1, 2, h = 1, . . . , Np, and Np ≪ N . Function F describes the interactions inside the swarm, and F p depicts the interaction with each external agent ph. According to the three zone model [3], F can be decomposed in F (xi, vi, xj, vj) = H(xi, xj)(vj − vi) + A(xi, xj) + R(xi, xj) + S(vi)vi. (2) H characterize the alignment term, A the attraction, R the repulsion and S represent a self propulsion-friction term. The same decomposition holds for F p if ph = (xp h), i.e. n = 2. In a first order model, n = 1, similar interaction can be considered, bu for the first term we should speak of consensus dynamic rather then alignment. h, vp Moreover we endow the model with a topological rule of interaction. Each agent will interact only with a fix number of agents of their specie, Σ∗ N (xi) = {the N ∗ closest neighbors respect to i} . A topological interaction is motivated by some recent studies, see [5, 11], suggesting that in a flock each individual modifies its position according to few individuals directly surrounding it, no matter how close or how far away those agents are. If N ∗ = N each agent interacts with all the others and the topological interaction coincides with the global metric interaction [1, 7]. Functions ϕh : [0, +∞) × (Rnd)Np × R −→ R, describe the evolution in time of each external individual and they depend on the discrete density ρN defined as empirical measure ρN (x, t) = 1 N N Xi=1 δ(x − xi(t)). According to [9] we define A as a convolutional operator AρN (t) = ρN (t) ∗ η, where η is a smooth kernel with compact support. 2.1. Classical swarming models The classical swarming models take in account a global interaction between the agents, that corresponds in our case to choose N ∗ = N neighbors. 2 Cucker-Smale model. Describes an alignment dynamic, see [10] and [7], H(xi, xj)(vj − vi) = H(xi − xj )(vj − vi), (3) where H(xi − xj) is a function that measures the strength of the interaction between individuals i and j , and depends on the mutual distance, under the assumption that closer individuals have more influence than the far distance ones, as depicted by H(r) = 1 (1 + r2)γ , where γ ≥ 0 discriminates the behavior of the solution, see [10, 7] and [8]. D'Orsogna, Bertozzi et al.. , considers a self-propelling, attraction and repulsion dynamic, see [12] A(xi, xj ) + R(xi, xj) + S(vi)vi = −∇xiW (xj − xi) + (α − βvi2)vi (4) where W : Rd −→ R is a given potential modeling the short-range repulsion and long-range attraction and α, β are positive parameters. A possible description is given by the following power law W (r) = − ra a rb b , where a > b > 0 are positive parameters. Both the models take in account symmetric interaction between agents, which correspond to the conservation of the first momentum. This assumption isn't really realistic if we want to model group of animals, to improve the models other features have been introduced as a perception cone [1, 7] or the concept of relative distance [14]. In these cases we lose the interaction symmetry and consequently the conservation of the first momentum, note that also the topological interaction breaks the symmetry. 3. Kinetic model In order to retrieve a mesoscopic description of the system (1) we proceed through a mean-field limit, as already done in [2, 7, 8]. Since the limit is done only for the first set of equations, which describe the evolution of the swarm, we obtain an hybrid model made by one kinetic equation and the ODEs system governing the external agents. The basic idea of the mean-field limit is to derive, through a weak argument, a single evolu- tionary equation for f N , the empirical measures defined as f N (x, v, t) = 1 N N Xi=1 δ(x − xi(t))δ(v − vi(t)). A second step is to show that the limit f N −→ f for N −→ ∞ holds true, then rigorous derivation of the limiting kinetic equation can be proved. A well-posedness theory for this derivation has been developed in [7] for a general set of swarming models. 3 We remark that in the mean-field limit the analogous of the topological set, Σ∗ N (x), of interaction is described by a characteristic function on the ball B(x, R∗), with center x and radius R∗ such that The model at mesoscopic level reads R > 0, ρ∗ =ZRdZB(x,R) f (x, v)dxdv) . R∗ = min(R(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)   ∂tf + v · ∇xf = −∇v · (E ∗(x, v)f ) − ∇v · (E p(x, v)f ). ph = ϕh(t, p, Aρ(ph)) h = 1, . . . , Np (5) where ρ(x, t) =RRd f (x, v, t)dv. Remark 1. If we consider the decompositions (2) in the case of Cucker-Smale and D'Orsogna- Bertozzi et al. models and ph = (xp h), we have a more particular formulation for E ∗ and E p, in this way h, vp E ∗(x, v) = and 1 ρ∗ ZRdZB(x,R∗) ρ∗ ZB(x,R∗) − 1 H(x − y)(w − v)f (y, w)dydw+ ∇xW (x − y)ρ(y)dy + S(v)v E p(x, v) = 1 Np Np Xk=1 4. Hydrodynamic model H p(x − xp k)(vp k − v) − 1 Np Np Xk=1 ∇xW p(x − xp k) (6) (7) We are interested also in the macroscopic description of the system, from a numerical point of view this corresponds to reduce the dimensionality of the problem in such a way that simulations become affordable. As done in [2, 8, 13] we define ρ := ρ(x, t) =Z f dv, ρu := ρu(x, t) =Z vf dv, T := T (x, t) =Z v − u2f dv, in order to obtain a system of equations which describe the evolution of these quantities, we integrate the kinetic equation in (5) against dv and vdv. According to [8] we impose the closure the momentum assuming that the fluctuations are negligible, i.e., that the temperature T (x, t) = 0, and the velocity distribution is monokinetic: f (x, v, t) = ρ(x, t)δ(v − u(x, t)). The previous assumptions lead to the following hydrodynamic system   ∂tρ + divx(ρu) = 0, ∂t(ρu) + ∇x · (ρu ⊗ u) = F ∗(x, u)ρ(x, t) + F p(x, u)ρ(x, t), (8) ph = ϕh(t, p, Aρ(ph)) h = 1, . . . , Np 4 4 3 2 1 Y 0 −1 −2 −3 −4 −4 t=0.1 −3 −2 −1 0 X 1 2 3 4 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 4 3 2 1 0.25 Y 0 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0 −1 −2 −3 −4 −4 t=0.8 −3 −2 −1 0 X 1 2 3 4 4 3 2 1 Y 0 −1 −2 −3 −4 −4 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0 t=4.4 −3 −2 −1 0 X 1 2 3 4 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 Figure 1: Shepherd dogs. With parameters a = 2.5, b = 0.1, γ = 0.45 for models (3) and (4). In the particular case of Cucker-Smale and D'Orsogna Bertozzi et al. model and ph = (xp second term reads h, vp h) the F ∗(x, u) = 1 1 − ρ∗ ZB(x,R∗) ρ∗ ZB(x,R∗) Xk=1 Np F p(x, u) = 1 Np 5. Numerical examples H(x − y)(u(y, t) − u(x, t))ρ(y, t)dy+ ∇xW (x − y)ρ(y, t)dy + S(u)u (9) H p(x − xp k)(vp k − u(x, t)) − 1 Np Np Xk=1 ∇xW p(x − xp k) (10) We show here two numerical examples taken from [9] for two different biological dynamics. In order to solve the kinetic part of the model, the simulations are performed using the Asymptotic Binary Interaction algorithms proposed in [1]. We recall that the algorithm is based on a stochastic routine which use Ns sample particles. The overall cost is O(Ns). The dynamics considered for the swarm in both the cases are F (xi, vi, xj, vj) = H(xi − xj)(vj − vi) + ∇xiW (xi − xj), and only a repulsion dynamic respect to ph in F p, given by the W p(r) = −rc/c with c > 0, and where r = xi − ph. Shepherd dogs. The simulation represents the evolution of a swarm controlled by two leaders p1, p2 ∈ R2n, n = 1, interacting with the swarm in the following way ϕh(t, p, sh) = Vp ; Vp = 300, rp = 5, h = 1, 2. η(x) = 3 πr6 p (max{0, r2 p − x2})2, sh := Aρ(xp h) = (ρ ∗x ∇η)(xp h). s⊥ h p1 + sh2 5 Y 5 4 3 2 1 0 −1 −2 −5 t=0.3 −4 −3 −2 −1 0 X 1 2 3 4 5 Y 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 −1 −2 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0 t=0.4 t=0.5 Y 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 −1 −2 0.12 0.1 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0 −6 −4 −2 0 X 2 4 6 −6 −4 −2 0 X 2 4 6 0.11 0.1 0.09 0.08 0.07 0.06 0.05 0.04 0.03 0.02 0.01 Figure 2: Swarm attacked by a predator. With parameters a = 4, b = 2, γ = 0.45 for models (3) and (4). Swarm attacked by predator. We consider the evolution of a swarm which undergoes the action of a predator. The predator is modeled by the evolution of p = (xp, vp) ∈ R2n, n = 2 and its evolution is lead by the following potential ϕ(t, p, s) = (vp, Vps); Vp = 1500, rp = 5. η(x) = 3 πr6 p (max{0, r2 p − x2})2, s := Aρ = ρ ∗ ∇η. References [1] G. Albi and L. Pareschi. Binary interaction algorithms for the simulations of flocking and swarming dynamics. SIAM, Multiscale Modeling and Simualtion, to appear, 2012. [2] G. Albi and L. Pareschi. Kinetic and hydrodynamic models for self-organized systems interacting with few individuals. preprint, 2012. [3] I. Aoki. A simulation study on the schooling mechanism in fish. Bulletin Of The Japanese Society Of Scientific Fisheries, 48(8):1081 -- 1088, 1982. [4] M. Aureli, F. Fiorilli, M. Porfiri. Portraits of self-organization in fish schools interacting with robots. Physica D, Vol. 241, Issue 9, pages 908 -- 920, May 2012. [5] M. Ballerini, N. Cabibbo, R. Candelier, A. Cavagna, E. Cisbani, I. Giardina, V. Lecomte, A. Orlandi, G. Parisi, A. Procaccini, et al. Interaction ruling animal collective behavior depends on topological rather than metric distance: Evidence from a field study. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 105(4):1232, 2008. [6] J. A. Canizo , J. A. Carrillo, J. Rosado. A well-posedness theory in measures for some kinetic models of collective motion. Mathematical Models and Methods in Applied Sciences, Vol. 21, No. 3, pp. 515-539, March 2011. [7] J. A. Carrillo, M. Fornasier, J. Rosado, and G. Toscani. Asymptotic flocking dynamics for the kinetic Cucker-Smale model. SIAM J. Math. Anal., 42(1):218 -- 236, 2010. 6 [8] J.A. Carrillo, M. Fornasier, G. Toscani, and F. Vecil. Particle, kinetic, and hydrodynamic models of swarming. pages 297 -- 336, 2010. [9] R. Colombo and M. L´ecureux-Mercier, An Analytical Framework to Describe the Interactions Between Individuals and a Continuum. Journal of Nonlinear Science, 22, pages 39 -- 61, 2012. [10] F. Cucker and S. Smale. Emergent behavior in flocks. IEEE Trans. Automat. Control, 52(5):852 -- 862, 2007. [11] E. Cristiani, B. Piccoli, and A. Tosin. Modeling self-organization in pedestrians and animal groups from macroscopic and microscopic viewpoints. In Mathematical modeling of collective behavior in socio-economic and life sciences, Model. Simul. Sci. Eng. Technol., pages 337 -- 364. Birkhauser Boston Inc., Boston, MA, 2010. [12] M.R. D'Orsogna, Y.L. Chuang, A.L. Bertozzi, and L.S. Chayes. Self-propelled particles with soft-core interactions: patterns, stability, and collapse. Physical review letters, 96(10):104 -- 302, 2006. [13] S. Ha and E. Tadmor. From particle to kinetic and hydrodynamic descriptions of flocking. Kinet. Relat. Models, 1(3):415 -- 435, 2008. [14] S. Motsch and E. Tadmor. A new model for self-organized dynamics and its flocking behavior. Journal of Statistical Physics, Springer, 144(5):923-947, 2011. 7
1306.4942	1	1306	2013-06-18T10:43:16	Disentangling electronic and vibronic coherences in two-dimensional echo spectra	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.chem-ph" ]	The prevalence of long-lasting oscillatory signals in the 2d echo-spectroscopy of light-harvesting complexes has led to a search for possible mechanisms. We investigate how two causes of oscillatory signals are intertwined: (i) electronic coherences supporting delocalized wave-like motion, and (ii) narrow bands in the vibronic spectral density. To disentangle the vibronic and electronic contributions we introduce a time-windowed Fourier transform of the signal amplitude. We find that 2d spectra can be dominated by excitations of pathways which are absent in excitonic energy transport. This leads to an underestimation of the life-time of electronic coherences by 2d spectra.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Disentangling electronic and vibronic coherences in two-dimensional echo spectra Christoph Kreisbeck,1 Tobias Kramer,2, 3 and Al´an Aspuru-Guzik1 1Department of Chemistry and Chemical Biology, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, USA 2Institut fur Physik, Humboldt Universitat zu Berlin, 12489 Berlin, Germany 3Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, USA (Dated: August 13, 2018) The prevalence of long-lasting oscillatory signals in the 2d echo-spectroscopy of light-harvesting complexes has led to a search for possible mechanisms. We investigate how two causes of oscillatory signals are intertwined: (i) electronic coherences supporting delocalized wave-like motion, and (ii) narrow bands in the vibronic spectral density. To disentangle the vibronic and electronic contri- butions we introduce a time-windowed Fourier transform of the signal amplitude. We find that 2d spectra can be dominated by excitations of pathways which are absent in excitonic energy transport. This leads to an underestimation of the life-time of electronic coherences by 2d spectra. I. INTRODUCTION The observation of long-lasting oscillations in peak amplitudes of two-dimensional (2d) echo spectroscopy as function of increasing delay time between pump and probe pulses1 -- 6 has lead to an intensive search for quantum mechanical effects in photosynthetic systems at physiological temperatures. The general theoretical model of excitonic energy transfer from the antenna to the reaction center is well established.7 -- 9 For the Fenna- Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex an efficient transfer re- lies on a dissipative coupling of electronic and vibronic degrees of freedom,10 -- 16 which puts the excited system in an energy funnel towards the reaction center. The oscillations recorded in 2d echo spectra were not antici- pated within a simplified rate equation formalism based on Markovian approximations for the dissipative coupling of vibronic and electronic degrees of freedom.17,18 The physical origin of the experimental observations has lead to various theoretical proposals, which are roughly divided into two mechanisms. As shown from calculations in model Hamiltonians19 -- 21 the presence of δ-spiked peaks in the vibronic mode distribution does imprint a long-lasting oscillatory signal on coherences. The spectral density determined from fluorescence line- narrowing experiments (JWendling in Fig. 1) reveals a se- ries of peaks. However a calculation of 2d spectra and coherences22 using a close approximation to the density (denoted by J3peaks and J11peaks in Fig. 1) puts the vi- bronic contributions on a much smaller scale compared to electronic coherences, which lead to oscillation periods determined by the differences in excitonic eigenenergies. The second proposed mechanism22 identifies two prereq- uisites for long-lasting electronic coherences and oscilla- tions of cross-peaks of 2d-spectra in the continuous part of the vibronic mode distribution: (i) a small initial slope of the vibronic density towards zero frequency, and (ii) a larger coupling between a continuum of vibrations whose frequencies are in the range of the typical excitonic en- ergy gaps. Both conditions are fullfilled by the florescence line-narrowing spectral density JWendling. ☛❲❡☞✌✍✎☞✏ ☛✠✠✑❡✒✓✔ ☛✕✑❡✒✓✔ ✷✺✵ ✷✵✵ ✶✺✵ ✶✵✵ ✺✵ ✵ ✶✵✵ ✷✵✵ ✸✵✵ ✖❤☎ ✆✝✞✟✠✡ ✹✵✵ ✺✵✵ FIG. 1. Spectral density of the FMO complex. Circles: mea- sured spectral density,23 parametrization.24 Fits J{3,11}peaks are used for the GPU-HEOM calculation. The marks on the frequency axis indicate differences of exciton eigenenergies. It remains an open question to what extend 2d spectra are probing vibrational or electronic properties of light- harvesting complexes. Moreover, for the design of artifi- cial nanostructure it is of interest to identify the physi- cal mechanism for efficient transport and conditions for the accompanying vibronic density. Here, we disentan- gle the interplay of electronic and vibronic effects on the transport by introducing a reliable method to dissect the 2d-echo signal. We show that a time-windowed short- time Fourier transform (STFT) is a suitable tool to track and assign specific vibronic and electronic contributions at all delay times. We find that two-dimensional echo- spectra can significantly underestimate the duration of electronic coherences due to the destructive superposi- tion of several pathways related to additional excitations and ground-state bleaching. Such pathways are not im- portant for excitonic energy transfer, which for the same system displays longer electronic coherences than the 2d spectra. The connection between 2d spectra and efficient ❏ ✭ ✦ ✮ ✭ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✮ ✁✄ ✁✵ ✁✂ ✲✁✂ t✓ t✔ ❘✌✍✚❊✶❊✺ ❪ ✎✏✑✒ ❋✇ ✖❤✦ ❬✄☎✆✶❪ ✖❤✦✶ 2 ✖❤✡❦ ✁☎ ✂ ✂✁☎ t ❬✡☛☞ FIG. 3. STFT analysis (tw = 0.4 ps, β = 7) of the coher- ence ρE1E5 of Fig. 2. The left arrow marks the frequency of the electronic energy difference E1 − E5 and the right arrows indicate the centers of vibrational peaks of J11peaks, Fig. 1. ✝✞ ❬✟✠❪ FIG. 2. Time evolution of the coherence ρE1E5 (t) for the spectral density J11peaks at T = 150 K. The dashed line shows a typical window function (tc = 0.6 ps, tw = 0.4 ps, β = 7). transport and the role of coherences requires a careful evaluation. II. TRANSITION FROM ELECTRONIC TO VIBRATIONAL INDUCED COHERENCE IN THE FMO COMPLEX Multiple frequencies are a common pattern in the cross-peak oscillations observed in 2d echo spectra of var- ious LHCs such as the FMO complex25,26 or light harvest- ing proteins PE545 and PC645 from marine cryptophyte algae.3,6 To unravel which physical processes are present as the delay-time progresses and to uncover the tran- sition from electronic to vibrational induced coherences we introduce a windowed short-time Fourier transform (STFT) of the signal Fw(ω, tc) ρEiEk (t) = Z ∞ −∞ dt Fw(tc, t)ρEiEk (t)eiωt (1) where tc denotes the center and tw the width of the win- dow function Fw(tc, t) = Xs=±1 s 1 + eβ(t−tc−stw/2)/tw . (2) Later, we normalize Fw(tc)ρEiEk to its maximal value. A typical window function along with the coherence be- tween exciton eigenstates E1i and E5i of the FMO com- plex calculated in Ref.22 is shown in Fig. 2 together with the corresponding STFT analysis in Fig. 3. Sweeping the centre of the window function tc yields information about the changes in the frequency distribution with ad- vancing time in the exciton dynamics. In Fig. 3, the initially dominant electronic coherent frequency ¯hω15 is indicated by the arrow on the left side. At later times dephasing reduces the influence of the electronic coher- ence while the interaction with the strongly coupled vi- brational modes increases. Around tc = 0.7 ps a "gap" can be seen, where the electronic frequency is absent but shortly afterwards re-emerges. From 1 − 3.5 ps a wob- bling motion of the dominant contribution is seen, which is caused by the vibronic frequencies marked by arrows on the right hand side. During the time evolution, en- ergy is shared among different vibrational modes close in resonance with the exction frequency ¯hω15. Which vibra- tions are activated changes with time. For example, the vibration at ¯hΩ = 380 cm−1 is present around 2.2 ps but absent around 3 ps. The features revealed in the STFT reflect two different mechanisms in the energy transfer. Electronic coherence signifies delocalized wavelike energy transfer which helps to overcome energy barriers and fa- cilitates fast energy transfer to specific target states. On the other hand the signatures of strongly coupled vibra- tional modes mark reversible energy exchange between the exciton system and the protein environment.27 III. COHERENCES IN 2D SPECTRA The decay of peak amplitude oscillations in two- dimensional spectra has been used to extract coherence lifetimes.5 In the following, we identify two processes which reduce the signature of electronic coherence in two-dimensional spectra compared to transport calcula- tions. To elucidate and quantify the interplay between electronic and vibronic degrees of freedom we discuss the physical processes mapped by 2d-echo spectra within a model trimer consisting of sites 1 − 3 of the FMO complex24 Hex =   410 −87.7 5.5 30.8 210 530 30.8 −87.7 5.5   cm−1. (3) ❝ ✆ ✝ ✞ ✟ ✞ ✠ ❝ ✞ ◆ ✭ t ❝ ✮ ✁ ✂ ❋ ✇ ✸✵✵ ✷✵✵ ✶✵✵ ✵ ✵ ✶✵✵ ✷✵✵ ✸✵✵ ✖❤☎ ✆✝✞✟✠✡ ✹✵✵ ✺✵✵ FIG. 4. Five peak model spectral density J5peaks with a suppressed slope at zero frequency and three strongly cou- pled underdamped vibrational modes. The vibrational fre- quencies (dashed line) are close in resonance with the dif- ference of the exciton energies Ei − Ej (solid line) of the exciton system Eq. (3). Parameters for Eq. (4): λk ∈ {11, 9, 12, 7, 4} cm−1, ν −1 k ∈ {230, 50, 750, 700, 750} fs, ¯hΩk ∈ {80, 260, 135, 260, 430} cm−1. As for the FMO complex22 we describe the energy trans- fer within a Frenkel exciton model,28 linearly coupled to independent baths at each site. The spectral density is parametrized by a superposition of shifted Drude-Lorentz peaks J(ω) = M Xk=1 (cid:20) νkλkω k + (ω + Ωk)2 + ν2 νkλkω k + (ω − Ωk)2(cid:21) . ν2 (4) The spectral density J5peaks (Fig. 4) for the model trimer fulfils the criteria for long-lived electronic coherences due to its small initial slope and later on larger coupling. To study the role of specific vibrational modes J5peaks adds three vibrational modes centered at frequencies ¯hΩ1 = 135 cm−1, ¯hΩ2 = 260 cm−1, ¯hΩ3 = 430 cm−1, which puts them close to resonance with the differences in exciton eigenenergies. The total 2d-echo rephasing signal is composed of three Liouville pathways29,30 re- flecting stimulated emission (SE), ground-state bleach- ing (GB) and excited state absorption (ESA), where the laser pulses create two excitons in the system. Formally, we calculate the Fourier transform of the third order re- sponse function SRP (t3, Tdelay, t1)29,30 in the impulsive limit dt1dt3eiω3t3−iω1t1 0 RP (t3, Td, t1) + SESA (5) IRP (ω1, Td, ω3) = Z ∞ 0 Z ∞ RP (t3, Td, t1) + SSE ×[SGB RP (t3, Td, t1)] We proceed along the steps in Ref.31 and include the ro- tational average over random orientations by sampling 20 distinct laser polarization vectors aligned along the vertices of a dodecahedron. We assume equal dipole strength of the three pigments and dipole orientations 3 along the nitrogen atoms NB − ND.32 The propagation is performed with the GPU-HEOM method.16,33 In an experimental setup all three pathways are tied together and cannot be analysed separately, while the theoreti- cal calculations allows us to study the individual contri- butions. Typically, the SE and ESA pathways interfere destructively and lead to a diminished amplitude of the coherent signal in the total spectrum. The cancellation of coherent amplitudes in 2d spectra enhances the influence of strongly coupled vibrations on the cross-peak oscilla- tions. In particular the ground-state vibrations moni- tored by the GB get amplified in weight in the 2d-echo spectra. Our finding, that ground-state vibrations af- fect the cross-peak dynamics is in agreement with Tiwari et al.34 who investigate the effect of a single vibrational mode in resonance with a model dimer. Different condi- tions govern transport and 2d-echo spectra, where sev- eral pulses hit the sample. For instance the ground-state bleaching and excited state absorption induced by the 2d-echo setup are not relevant for the energy transfer process. Thus the apparent diminishing of coherences in 2d spectra does not imply unimportance of coherence in the excitonic transfer. The cancellation effects are prominently visible in Fig. 5, which displays the oscillatory component of the lower- diagonal cross-peak dynamics of CP(12), CP(13) and CP(23) of the rephasing signal as function of delay time Tdelay. The amplitude of CP(ik) is determined by in- tegrating the real part of the rephasing 2d-spectra (all three rephasing pathways) over a small rectangle (∆E = 36 cm−1) in the 2d-energy grid. The center of the rect- angular area is located at ωi = Ei + λ/4.5 and ωk = Ek + λ/4.5, where Ei, Ek denote the exciton eigenener- gies of Eq. (3). The shift λ/4.5 takes into account the stokes shift and ensures that the amplitude is averaged around the maximum of the peaks. The non-oscillatory background is fitted by f (t) = a + b e−ct + d t + d2 t2 and is subtracted from the total signal. The three cross peaks show different behaviours. In the upper panel CP(12) os- cillates dominantly with a single frequency that matches the vibrational mode ¯hΩ1. The 2d-spectra thus appar- ently shows that there is almost no contribution of elec- tronic coherence between exciton states E1i and E2i left. This finding is in contradiction to simulations of the coherence ρE1E2(t) that predict long lasting elec- tronic coherence up to 1 ps. Studying the dynamics of the SE and ESA pathways of CP(12) separately re- covers the long lasting electronic coherence. But in the case of CP(12) the amplitudes of the coherent oscilla- tions of the SE and ESA pathway are nearly identical and the destructive interference of these pathways can- cels the contribution of electronic coherence in the total signal. The remaining oscillatory component of the to- tal signal reflects the ground state vibrations of the GB pathway shown as dashed line in Fig. 5(a) and the signal of electronic coherence is masked by the vibrational mode ¯hΩ1. The cross-peaks CP(13) and CP(23) (Fig. 5(b) and Fig. 5(c)) show a more complex dynamics, which is best ❏ ✭ ✦ ✮ ❬ ✁ ✂ ✄ ❪ 4 ✖❤✡ ✖❤✡✷ ✖❤✡✶ ✏✓✒ ✖❤✡ ✖❤✡✷ ✖❤✡✶ ✏✔✒ ✖❤✡ ✖❤✡✷ ✖❤✡✶ (a) (b) (c) 1 0 -1 1 0 -1 1 0 ] . u . a [ P C ] . u . a [ P C ] . u . a [ P C Re{CP(12)} only GB Re{CP(12)} ✖❤✦ ❬✝✞✟✶❪ ❙☞✌☞❙✍ ✏✑✒ SE+GB+ESA Re{CP(13)} SE+GB+ESA Re{CP(23)} ✖❤✦✷ ✖❤✦ ❬✝✞✟✶❪ ●✎ ✖❤✦✷ t❝ ❬✠☛❪ SE+GB+ESA t❝ ❬✠☛❪ ✖❤✦ ❬✝✞✟✶❪ -1 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 ❙☞✌●✎✌☞❙✍ Tdelay [ps] ✖❤✦✷ FIG. 5. Oscillatory component of the real part of the cross- peak dynamics of the total rephasing 2d-echo signal for Eq. (3) and J5peaks as function of delay time Tdelay. The temperature is set to T = 150 K. analysed using the STFT methodology for the case of CP(23) in Fig. 6. Multiple frequencies originating from electronic coherence and vibronic modes superpose each other and form rich structures in the beating pattern. The STFT frequency analysis for the sum of ESA and SE pathways is depicted in Fig. 6(a). In agreement with the coherences (not shown) we observe a transition around Tdelay = 0.7 ps from initially electronic coherence with frequency ¯hω23 = 212 cm−1 to vibrational frequencies ¯hΩk at later times. The strongest coupling to the exciton dynamics stems from the vibrational modes ¯hΩ1 and ¯hΩ2 that are close in resonance with the electronic frequency ¯hω23. For the GB pathway (Fig. 6(b)) the exciton system remains in the electronic ground state during Tdelay and no electronic frequencies show up in the cross peak dy- namics. In the total signal Fig. 6(c) the GB vibrational modes leave their trace and diminish the relative weight of the electronic coherences. t❝ ❬✠☛❪ FIG. 6. STFT analysis (tw = 0.7 ps, β = 7) of the cross-peak dynamics CP(23) of the rephasing 2d-echo signal. Shown are results for (a) the sum of the SE and ESA pathway, (b) the contribution of the GB pathway and (c) the total signal in- cluding all three pathways. The width of the window func- tion is tw = 1.0 ps and T = 150 K. The left arrow marks the frequency of electronic coherence ¯hω23 and the right ar- rows mark the frequencies of the strongly coupled vibrational modes ¯hΩk. IV. CONCLUSION The STFT provides a tool to determine the physical mechanisms behind oscillatory signals for progressing de- lay time. We find that the determination of electronic co- herence life-times from the experimentally observed total signal in the 2d-echo spectra is difficult and can underes- timate the lifetime of electronic coherences. For varying delay times the STFT shows multiple frequencies and a mix of vibronic and electronic contributions. Similar ob- ◆ ✭ ❚ ❞ ✁ ✂ ✄ ② ✮ ☎ ✆ ❋ ✇ ◆ ✭ ❚ ❞ ✁ ✂ ✄ ② ✮ ☎ ✆ ❋ ✇ ◆ ✭ ❚ ❞ ✁ ✂ ✄ ② ✮ ☎ ✆ ❋ ✇ servations are reported for experimentally recorded 2d spectra.3,6,25,26 We further found examples of a reemer- gent amplitude in the oscillatory component at later time in CP(23), where a larger amplitude at Tdelay = 0.35 ps is seen compared to Tdelay = 0.2 ps. Interestingly, such reemerging amplitudes are also observed for the FMO complex.25,26 The pollution of the 2d-signal by ground-state vibra- tions and two-exciton states is not directly relevant for as- sessing the role of coherences in excitonic energy transfer, where these two pathways are absent. This has also im- plications for identifying vibronic spectral-densities sup- porting efficient transport. We find a good correspon- dence between coherence lifetimes of the stimulated emis- sion pathway (SE) of cross peak CP(i, j) and the corre- sponding coherence ρEiEj . For certain cross-peaks the 5 ground state vibrations dominate, and the 2d-echo spec- tra are not able to determine the electronic coherence lifetime. like the proposed witness of electronic coherence35 or quantum process tomography36,37 is required to reveal the hidden information. In this case an additional analysis, ACKNOWLEDGMENTS A.A.-G. and C.K. are supported by the DARPA grants N66001-10-1-4063, N66001-10-1-4059, and T.K. by a Heisenberg fellowship of the DFG (KR 2889/5). A.A.-G. thanks the Corning foundation for their generous sup- port. 1 Engel, G. S.; Calhoun, T. R.; Read, E. L.; Ahn, T.- K.; Mancal, T.; Cheng, Y.-C.; Blankenship, R. E.; Flem- ing, G. R. Evidence for wavelike energy transfer through quantum coherence in photosynthetic systems. Nature 2007, 446, 782. 2 Lee, H.; Cheng, Y.-C.; Fleming, G. R. Coherence Dynam- ics in Photosynthesis: Protein Protection of Excitonic Co- herence. Science 2007, 316, 1462. 3 Collini, E.; Wong, C. Y.; Wilk, K. E.; Curmi, P. M. G.; Brumer, P.; Scholes, G. D. Coherently wired light- harvesting in photosynthetic marine algae at ambient tem- perature. Nature 2010, 463, 644. 4 Calhoun, T. R.; Ginsberg, N. S.; Schlau-Cohen, G. S.; Cheng, Y.-C.; Ballottari, M.; Bassi, R.; Fleming, G. R. Quantum Coherence Enabled Determination of the En- ergy Landscape in Light-Harvesting Complex II. J. Phys. Chem. B 2009, 113, 16291. 5 Panitchayangkoon, G.; Hayes, D.; Fransted, K. A.; Caram, J. R.; Harel, E.; Wen, J.; Blankenship, R. E.; En- gel, G. S. Long-lived quantum coherence in photosynthetic complexes at physiological temperature. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 2010, 107, 12766. 6 Turner, D. B.; Dinshaw, R.; Lee, K.-K.; Belsley, M. S.; Wilk, K. E.; Curmi, P. M. G.; Scholes, G. D. Quan- titative investigations of quantum coherence for a light- harvesting protein at conditions simulating photosynthe- sis. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2012, 14, 4857. 7 Amerongen, H. V.; Valkunas, L.; van Grondelle, R. Pho- tosynthetic excitons; World Scientific: Singapore, 2000. 8 Blankenship, R. E. Molecular mechanisms of photosynthe- sis; Blackwell Science: London, 2002. 9 Frigaard, N.-U.; Bryant, D. A. Seeing green bacteria in a new light: Genomics-enabled studies of the photosynthetic apparatus in green sulfur bacteria and filamentous anoxy- genic phototrophic bacteria. Arch. Microbiol. 2004, 182, 265. 10 Mohseni, M.; Rebentrost, P.; Lloyd, S.; Aspuru-Guzik, A. Environment-assisted quantum walks in photosynthetic energy transfer. J. Chem. Phys. 2008, 129, 174106. 11 Rebentrost, P.; Mohseni, M.; Kassal, I.; Lloyd, S.; Aspuru- Guzik, A. Environment-assisted quantum transport. New J. Phys. 2009, 11, 033003. 12 Plenio, M. B.; Huelga, S. F. Dephasing-assisted transport: Quantum networks and biomolecules. New. J. Phys. 2008, 10, 113019. 13 Caruso, F.; Chin, A. W.; Datta, A.; Huelga, S. F.; Ple- nio, M. B. Highly efficient energy excitation transfer in light-harvesting complexes: The fundamental role of noise- assisted transport. J. Chem. Phys. 2009, 131, 105106. 14 Wu, J.; Liu, F.; Shen, Y.; Cao, J.; Silbey, R. J. Efficient en- ergy transfer in light-harvesting systems, I: Optimal tem- peratrue, reorganization energy, and spatial-temporal cor- relations. New J. Phys. 2010, 12, 105012. 15 Mohseni, M.; Shabani, A.; Lloyd, S.; Rabitz, H. Optimal and robust energy transport in light-harvesting complexes: (II) A quantum interplay of multichromophoric geometries and environmental interactions. arXiv:1104.4812v1 2011, 16 Kreisbeck, C.; Kramer, T.; Rodr´ıguez, M.; Hein, B. High- Performance Solution of Hierarchical Equations of Motion for Studying Energy Transfer in Light-Harvesting Com- plexes. J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2011, 7, 2166. 17 Cho, M.; Vaswani, H. M.; Brixner, T.; Stenger, J.; Flem- ing, G. R. Exciton Analysis in 2D Electronic Spectroscopy. J. Phys. Chem. B 2005, 109, 10542. 18 Brixner, T.; Stenger, J.; Vaswani, H. M.; Cho, M.; Blankenship, R. E.; Fleming, G. R. Two-dimensional spec- troscopy of electronic couplings in photosynthesis. Nature 2005, 434, 625. 19 Christensson, N.; Kauffmann, H. F.; Pullerits, T.; Man- cal, T. Origin of Long Lived Coherences in Light- Harvesting Complexes. J. Phys. Chem. B 2012, 116, 7449. 20 Chin, A.; Prior, J.; Rosenbach, R.; Caycedo-Soler, F.; Huelga, S.; Plenio, M. The role of non-equilibrium vibra- tional structures in electronic coherence and recoherence in pigment-protein complexes. Nature Physics 2013, 9, 113 -- 118. 21 Kolli, A.; O'Reilly, E. J.; Scholes, G. D.; Olaya-Castro, A. The fundamental role of quantized vibrations in coher- ent light harvesting by cryptophyte algae. The Journal of Chemical Physics 2012, 137, 174109. 22 Kreisbeck, C.; Kramer, T. Long-Lived Electronic Coher- ence in Dissipative Exciton Dynamics of Light-Harvesting Complexes. J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2012, 3, 2828. 23 Wendling, M.; Pullerits, T.; Przyjalgowski, M. A.; Vulto, S. I. E.; Aartsma, T. J.; van Grondelle, R.; van Amerongen, H. Electron-Vibrational Coupling in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson Complex of Prosthecochloris aes- tuarii Determined by Temperature-Dependent Absorption and Fluorescence Line-Narrowing Measurements. J. Phys. Chem. B 2000, 104, 5825. 24 Adolphs, J.; Renger, T. How Proteins Trigger Excitation Energy Transfer in the FMO Complex of Green Sulfur Bac- teria. Biophys. J. 2006, 91, 2778. 25 Hayes, D.; Wen, J.; Panitchayangkoon, G.; Blanken- ship, R. E.; Engel, G. S. Robustness of electronic coher- ence in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex to vibronic and structural modifications. Faraday Discuss. 2011, 150, 459. 26 Panitchayangkoon, G.; Voronine, D. V.; Abramavicius, D.; Caram, J. R.; Lewis, N. H. C.; Mukamel, S.; Engel, G. S. Direct evidence of quantum transport in photosynthetic light-harvesting complexes. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 2011, 108, 20908. 27 Rebentrost, P.; Aspuru-Guzik, A. Communication: Exciton-phonon information flow in the energy trans- fer process of photosynthetic complexes. J. Chem. Phys. 2011, 134, 101103. 28 May, V.; Kuhn, O. Charge and energy transfer dynamics in molecular systems; Wiley-VCH: Weinheim, 2004. 29 Mukamel, S. Principles of nonlinear optical spectroscopy; Oxford University Press: New York, 1999. 30 Cho, M. Two-dimensional optical spectroscopy; CRC Press: Boca Raton, 2009. 6 31 Hein, B.; Kreisbeck, C.; Kramer, T.; Rodr´ıguez, M. Mod- elling of Oscillations in Two-Dimensional Echo-Spectra of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson Complex. New J. Phys. 2012, 14, 023018. 32 Adolphs, J.; Muh, F.; Madjet, M. E.-A.; Renger, T. Calcu- lation of pigment transition energies in the FMO protein. Photosynth. Res. 2008, 95, 197. C.; 33 Kreisbeck, ics Lab HEOM). http://nanohub.org/resources/16106. for 2013; Kramer, T. Light-Harvesting Complexes doi:10.4231/D3RB6W248 Exciton Dynam- (GPU- at online 34 Tiwari, V.; Peters, W. K.; Jonas, D. M. Electronic reso- nance with anticorrelated pigment vibrations drives photo- synthetic energy transfer outside the adiabatic framework. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 2012, doi:10.1073/pnas.1211157110. 35 Yuen-Zhou, J.; Krich, J. J.; Aspuru-Guzik, A. A witness for coherent electronic vs vibronic-only oscillations in ultrafast spectroscopy. J. Chem. Phys. 2012, 136, 234501. 36 Yuen-Zhou, J.; Aspuru-Guzik, A. Quantum process tomog- raphy of excitonic dimers from two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy. I. General theory and application to homod- imers. J. Chem. Phys. 2011, 134, 134505. 37 Yuen-Zhou, J.; Krich, J. J.; Mohseni, M.; Aspuru- Guzik, A. Quantum state and process tomography of en- ergy transfer systems via ultrafast spectroscopy. Proceed- ings of the National Academy of Sciences 2011, 108, 17615 -- 17620.
1802.01067	1	1802	2018-02-04T03:34:47	Computation of a Theoretical Membrane Phase Diagram, and the Role of Phase in Lipid Raft-Mediated Protein Organization	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.SC" ]	Lipid phase heterogeneity in the plasma membrane is thought to be crucial for many aspects of cell signaling, but the physical basis of participating membrane domains such as "lipid rafts" remains controversial. Here we consider a lattice model yielding a phase diagram that includes several states proposed to be relevant for the cell membrane, including microemulsion - which can be related to membrane curvature - and Ising critical behavior. Using a neural network-based machine learning approach, we compute the full phase diagram of this lattice model. We analyze selected regions of this phase diagram in the context of a signaling initiation event in mast cells: recruitment of the membrane-anchored tyrosine kinase Lyn to a cluster of transmembrane of IgE-Fc{\epsilon}RI receptors. We find that model membrane systems in microemulsion and Ising critical states can mediate roughly equal levels of kinase recruitment (binding energy ~ -0.6 kBT), whereas a membrane near a tricritical point can mediate much stronger kinase recruitment (-1.7 kBT). By comparing several models for lipid heterogeneity within a single theoretical framework, this work points to testable differences between existing models. We also suggest the tricritical point as a new possibility for the basis of membrane domains that facilitate preferential partitioning of signaling components.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Computation of a Theoretical Membrane Phase Diagram, and the Role of Phase in Lipid Raft-Mediated Protein Organization Eshan D. Mitra†1, Samuel C. Whitehead‡, David Holowka†, Barbara Baird†, James P. Sethna‡ †Department of Chemistry and Chemical Biology, Cornell University, 122 Baker Laboratory, Ithaca, NY, 14853 ‡Department of Physics, Cornell University, 109 Clark Hall, Ithaca, NY, 14853 1Current address: Los Alamos National Laboratory, P.O. Box 1663, Los Alamos, NM 87545 *Corresponding authors: B. Baird, [email protected] J. P. Sethna, [email protected] Abstract Lipid phase heterogeneity in the plasma membrane is thought to be crucial for many aspects of cell signaling, but the physical basis of participating membrane domains such as "lipid rafts" remains controversial. Here we consider a lattice model yielding a phase diagram that includes several states proposed to be relevant for the cell membrane, including microemulsion – which can be related to membrane curvature – and Ising critical behavior. Using a neural network-based machine learning approach, we compute the full phase diagram of this lattice model. We analyze selected regions of this phase diagram in the context of a signaling initiation event in mast cells: recruitment of the membrane-anchored tyrosine kinase Lyn to a cluster of transmembrane of IgE-FcεRI receptors. We find that model membrane systems in microemulsion and Ising critical states can mediate roughly equal levels of kinase recruitment (binding energy ~ -0.6 kBT), whereas a membrane near a tricritical point can mediate much stronger kinase recruitment (-1.7 kBT). By comparing several models for lipid heterogeneity within a single theoretical framework, this work points to testable differences between existing models. We also suggest the tricritical point as a new possibility for the basis of membrane domains that facilitate preferential partitioning of signaling components. 1 Introduction The lateral organization of cell plasma membranes, which contributes crucially to their functions, is regulated by membrane proteins and lipids as well as by attachment to the cytoskeleton and by communication with membrane trafficking and other cellular processes. A primary component of membrane organization appears to be the collective properties of the lipid populations, and this has been examined experimentally and theoretically, as described in numerous recent reviews (see 1,2 and reviews cited therein and elsewhere in this paper). Whereas the diameter of a constituent lipid is about 1 nm, the bulk of experimental evidence suggests that mammalian plasma membranes contain phase-based domains on the order of 10-200 nm in length.3–6 This heterogeneity has been related to studies of simpler model membranes composed of a high melting point (Tm) lipid, a low Tm lipid and cholesterol, considered to serve to as an approximation of plasma membrane lipids.7 Varying relative amounts of these three types of lipids has yielded phase diagrams showing regions of separation between phases characterized as liquid ordered (Lo, more high-Tm lipid and more cholesterol) and liquid disordered (Ld, more low-Tm lipid).8–10 Studies on giant plasma membrane vesicles (GPMVs), which are isolated from cells, exhibit micrometer-scale regions of Lo-like and Ld-like phase character.11 Similar fluorescence microscopy studies on intact cells under physiological conditions do not detect Lo/Ld separation above the diffraction limit, possibly due in part to their dispersal by cytoskeletal attachment in cells.12 However, electron spin resonance (ESR) studies on intact cells provide evidence for coexisting Lo and Ld domains.13 In cell plasma membranes these nanometer-scale phase-like domains are thought to be coalesced or stabilized as a result of an external stimulus (e.g. antigen cross-linking of immune receptors), and to play an essential role in stimulated cell signaling, by facilitating colocalization of membrane proteins that partition into the same Lo-like domain, and separating them from those that partition into Ld- like domains.6,14 We are particularly interested in cases where induced interactions between multiple Lo-preferring components stabilize these domains, thereby recruiting other Lo- preferring components. Such lipid-mediated segregation has been implicated in many mechanisms of membrane protein signaling, including immune receptors,15,16 G-protein coupled receptors,17 the oncogenic GTPase Ras,18 and others. A generic term that has emerged for plasma membrane domains of Lo-like character is "lipid rafts," and, although the size, dynamics, and other features of these structures in functional cells surely vary compared to those in model membranes, the lipid phase properties are expected to be 2 similar. Theories of raft formation Despite the centrality of lipid-based membranes to cell biology, there remains no consensus on the physical basis of lipid domains. As described above, formation of lipid rafts has been tied to the observation of phase separation in model plasma membranes, including giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs)8–10,19,20 and GPMVs11,21. In addition to the simplest forms of two-phase coexistence, these systems exhibit a rich variety of phase behavior, including, microemulsionsa,19,22 lamellar phases (also called modulated phases),23 and critical phenomena.21 Moreover, despite recent advances in experimental techniques (for recent reviews, see 16,24), lipid rafts in cell plasma membranes remain a difficult system to investigate – the dynamics and complexity of real cell systems notwithstanding, the 10-200 nm dimension of rafts4 prevents direct observation via conventional light microscopy. Thus, the goal for a theoretical consideration of lipid raft physics should provide comparisons and hypotheses that are amenable to testing with the currently available tools. Towards this end, various theoretical models have been proposed to describe raft-like phenomena. However, due to the lack of direct experimental data on lipid rafts, the set of theories that are consistent with observation is relatively unconstrained – models that disagree on the fundamental physics of raft formation can give qualitatively similar results that agree with extant experimental work.1 One theoretical viewpoint is that lipid rafts are mediated by membrane curvature,25–27 which makes the interface between immiscible membrane domains more energetically stable. It has also been proposed that a surfactant species could provide a similar interface between domains.28 Both of these viewpoints suggest that rafts exist as part of a microemulsion phase, in which nanoscopic domains of a characteristic size are stabilized due to the curvature or surfactant. An alternate hypothesis a Some groups describe the presence of "nanodomains,"19 a state of two-phase coexistence consisting of nanoscopic domains of a characteristic size, rather than a microemulsion, which is defined as a one-phase state with domains of a characteristic size. The difference in terminology arises from a difference in the definition of the location of the phase boundary. Theoretical physicists commonly define a phase based on the average of some order parameter, which is calculated over a long length scale. If this length scale is larger than the characteristic domain size, then the domains are averaged out in this calculation, leading to the conclusion that the system consists of a single phase, and the designation of "microemulsion". However, some experimental groups define a system to be in two-phase coexistence whenever an experimental technique (e.g. FRET, which has a detection length scale of ~2-8 nm) detects the presence of two components. 22 Analysis of the same "microemulsion" system with small characteristic domains would indeed give detection of two distinct components, leading to the conclusion of two-phase coexistence, and the label of "nanodomains." In this study, we use the term "microemulsion," but note that the same area of the phase diagram could be deemed "nanodomains" if one adopted an empirical definition of two-phase coexistence such as is used in 22. 3 suggests that rafts are formed from critical fluctuations in membrane composition, a result of proximity of the membrane to a 2D Ising critical point.21,29 Experimental studies have provided support for both an Ising critical point21 and interactions consistent with a microemulsion.22,23 We define lipid rafts as nanoscale domains concentrated with Lo-preferring components, and as described above, these domains can serve to colocalize membrane proteins that partition similarly. To analyze the functional consequence of Figure 1. Signal initiation by IgE-FcεRI. IgE-FcεRI are cross-linked by an external antigen. The resulting cluster of receptors stabilizes a lipid raft that enables the recruitment of Lyn. Lyn performs the initial phosphorylation steps that transmit the signal to more downstream signaling partners. rafts in depth, we focus on the tractable example of transmembrane signaling mediated by the IgE- FcεRI receptor in mast cells. Physiologically, this stimulated transmembrane coupling activates cellular signaling pathways involved in allergic immune responses (reviewed in 30–32). The mast cell is stimulated when specific multivalent ligands (antigen) physically cross-links several IgE-FcεRI receptors together in a cluster. This clustering causes recruitment of the kinase Lyn, which is anchored to the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane and when recruited, phosphorylates the receptor, thereby activating downstream signaling events (Figure 1). This kinase recruitment is thought to be raft-mediated: both the cross-linked receptors and the kinase preferentially partition into Lo-like membrane domains, facilitating their coupling on the plasma membrane.15,33,34 The mast cell system serves as an example of a more general paradigm in cell biology, in which the orchestrated co-clustering of membrane proteins due to an external stimulus leads to initiation of transmembrane signaling.18 Model In this work, we address some of the ambiguities in the physics of lipid raft formation by a comparative approach. We employ a lattice model originally described by Gompper and Schick,35,36 which can be used for simultaneous evaluation of both microemulsions and critical phenomena. In addition, this model captures features such as a lamellar (modulated) phase and two-phase coexistence observed in other membrane studies. Moreover, the model exhibits a tricritical point – defined as the termination of a three-phase coexistence regime in 4 a phase diagram – which we suggest has interesting implications for stimulated cell signaling. The model consists of a two-dimensional square lattice with the Hamiltonian (Eq. 1 with variables defined below) H=∑ (Hσ i+Δσi 2)+∑ i i,j (−Jσ i σ j−Kσ i 2 σ j 2)+∑ L σi(1−σ j 2)σk (1) i,j,k Each site on the 2D lattice can take a spin value σ of -1 (black pixel), 0 (gray pixel), or 1 (white pixel). Black and white pixels represent membrane components favoring Ld and Lo domains, respectively. Gray pixels represent a surfactant when surfacant strength L is greater than 0, or simply a molecule with neutral domain preference when L = 0. The summation over i is over all sites in the lattice; i,j is over all nearest neighbors; i,j,k is over all groups of three adjacent pixels in a straight horizontal or vertical line. We equate one lattice unit to a length of 1 nm, the approximate diameter occupied by one membrane lipid molecule. Each of the five parameters of this model – H, Δ, J, K, and L – has units of energy. We consider only non-negative values for J, K, and L, while H and Δ can take any value. The external fields H and Δ control the composition of the lattice. H controls the relative abundance of σ=-1 (black pixels) and σ=1 (white pixels), while larger Δ increases the concentration of σ=0 (gray pixels). We consider this model in the grand canonical ensemble: our simulation box represents one section of the membrane, so it makes sense that the number of each type of molecule can fluctuate, analogous to molecules diffusing in and out of the box. The coupling J between adjacent pixels represents the usual Ising model coupling, which, for a membrane model, is the preference for molecules that prefer Lo domains to be adjacent to other molecules that prefer Lo domains (and similarly for Ld-preferring molecules). J can also be thought of as equal to the line tension between black and white pixels times a distance of 1 lattice unit (1 nm). K is a two-pixel interaction that gives a favorable energy to adjacent non-gray pixels. For a particular concentration of gray pixels, a higher value of K makes it more favorable to have those gray pixels adjacent to each other. L controls the strength of gray pixels as a surfactant; this term contributes a nonzero value only when a gray pixel (σ =0) sits between two non-gray pixels (σ =±1), and is favorable when the two non-gray pixels have different signs. Thus, increasing L > 0 makes it more favorable for gray to sit between black and white. In our implementation, rather than choosing a value for J, we choose a value for temperature T in units of J/kB, and J is set accordingly. The other parameters H, Δ, K and L are chosen in units of J. Boltzmann's constant kB is set to unity. 5 Note that when L=0 Eq. 1 reduces to the Blume-Emery-Griffiths model.37 With K also set to 0, Eq. 1 becomes the Blume-Capel model.38,39 With Δ = -∞, corresponding to no gray pixels present, Eq. 1 reduces to the Ising model. Phases in the Lattice Model When the lattice model of Gompper and Schick was initially described, it was possible to extract some key features of the phase diagram, most notably the location of the critical line, by finite size scaling.35 With the great increase in the power of computational resources since that time, it has become possible for us to address the model more globally by simulation. We further take advantage of neural networks, which have become a powerful machine learning technique, leading to the development of computational tools to address challenging problems such as image recognition.40 In image recognition, a neural network is trained to read the pixel values of an image, and output a label corresponding to what the image shows, such as distinguishing between a cat and a dog. Similarly, neural networks have been trained on simulated snapshots of phase models in physics, to output a label corresponding to which phase the snapshot represents. When this phase classification is performed for snapshots at a large number of model parameter sets, one obtains the phase diagram of the model.41,42 With this methodology, we label a region of parameter space as a distinct "phase" if the neural network is able to distinguish simulation snapshots in that region from snapshots representing other phases. This definition is not always equivalent to a thermodynamic definition of a phase (i.e. based on the value of order parameters), but rather puts a greater emphasis on visually identifiable, qualitative differences in system properties. Based on our neural network analysis, we describe eight phases (distinguishable qualitative behaviors specified below) that the model (Eq. 1) produces. We name these as follows: Within the fluid phase, all three components are well-mixed, with only short-range interactions between them. The black phase and white phase consist of nearly all black pixels and white pixels, respectively. When H=0, the Hamiltonian (Eq. 1) is symmetric with respect to exchanging black and white, and so these phases are seen in a state of two-phase coexistence. The gray phase consists of nearly all gray pixels. The microemulsion "phase" consists of black and white domains stabilized by a boundary of surfactant. The critical "phase" consists of fluctuating black and white domains, resulting from close proximity above a critical phase transition. Note that the microemulsion and critical "phases" are not 6 thermodynamically distinct from one another or from the fluid phase.b 7,43 However, because we are interested in the qualitative nature of domains that could be relevant for membranes, we choose to consider them separately. The lamellar phase, is similar to a microemulsion "phase" in that the surfactant separates the black and white domains, but instead of enclosed, roughly round domains, the two domains exist as long stripes. Finally, the crystal phase includes the behavior in which rectangular domains of black and white exist, separated by a meshwork of surfactant. Applying the model to cell signaling Here, we apply the methodology of neural networks to the Gompper and Schick lattice model, with the ultimate goal of understanding how different qualitative phase behaviors in membranes compare in their capacities to mediate cell signaling through membrane receptors (Figures 1 and 2c). The neural-network-derived phase diagram labels regions of parameter space according to their distinctive behaviors, as described in the previous section. We use this diagram to focus on sections of parameter space that are proposed to be relevant for plasma membrane heterogeneity, in particular the microemulsion and critical "phases". At these interesting points, we perform Monte Carlo simulations to calculate the energy associated with recruitment of an inner-membrane-anchored kinase (Lo-preferring) into a transmembrane receptor cluster (also Lo-preferring), as in the mast cell signaling system. Note that these recruitment energies-in contrast to binding energies associated with chemical bonds-are associated with long range forces: Proteins are recruited into an energetically favorable region, without orienting and binding directly to specific sites on proteins that stabilized the energetically favorable region. Also the energies we calculate are non-specific – Lo and Ld preferring proteins will share the same interactions as a group, and their structure details would only determine the degree of preference. Thus these long range forces allow nonspecific interactions that are restricted only in terms of the components' phase preference, as for co-localization in lipid rafts. Monte Carlo methods allow us to explore the protein energetics semi-quantitatively throughout the phase diagram. Moreover, the recruitment energies that we calculate agree with exact conformal field theory results near the Ising critical point,44 and hence should quantitatively describe experimental systems near critical points. And while our simulations focus on a simplified model of clustered receptors, near critical points our results are b Those who define microemulsion-like states as two-phase nanodomains (see footnote a), would instead say that the microemulsion and critical "phases" are part of the two-phase coexistence between the black and white phases. 7 universal, and are thus generalizable to a broad range of phenomena associated with membrane heterogeneity. In total, this method of recruitment energy calculation allows us to evaluate how the qualitative behavior of the plasma membrane relates to its capacity to form lipid rafts that can be stabilized (e.g., by clustered receptors) to mediate biologically relevant signaling. The neural network approach is uniquely suited for this goal, offering a number of advantages over more traditional analysis approaches. First, it is capable of exploring large areas of parameter space at low computational cost. Second, it is able to detect qualitative changes in model behavior, such as microemulsions, even if those changes do not correspond to a true thermodynamic phase transition. These qualitative differences have important consequences for cell signaling that is facilitated by membrane organization. Methods Monte Carlo Simulations Snapshots of the lattice model35 were generated by the Metropolis algorithm. The length of the simulation was counted in sweeps, where, in each sweep, each lattice site has on average 100 opportunities to be flipped (total of 90000 individual proposed moves for a 30x30 lattice,c Figure 2a). Each proposed move consisted of randomly choosing a lattice site and a target value (one of {-1, 0, 1} that was not the current value at the site). The move was performed with probability min(1, e-ΔU/T) where ΔU is the change in the Hamiltonian energy (Eq. 1) resulting from the move. To generate a single independent snapshot, the lattice was randomized, then 100 sweeps were run to equilibrate, and the final result was saved. To generate correlated snapshots, additional sweeps were run after equilibration, and a sample was saved after each sweep. Such snapshots are correlated because a single sweep is not enough to fully reequilibrate the lattice. Neural Network Training We chose the cross-section H/J=0, K/J=2, L/J=3 (see Hamiltonian, Eq. 1) for training c The lattices we use for mapping phase diagrams are small; the size was chosen to capture the correlations on length scales of interest to protein aggregation, and for convenient training of the network. Phases without structure on long length scales should be well described by our small simulations; we would expect shifts in boundaries of microemulsion phases, for example, only when the modulation approaches 30 pixels. Near critical points all length scales are important for the physics, but we show that the phase boundaries converge fairly rapidly. The shift in the effective critical temperature in a system of size L goes as L1/ν, so for the Ising critical point with ν=1 we expect 3% shifts in phase boundaries for a 30x30 system (beyond the precision of our methods), and near the tricritical point with ν=5/9 we find even smaller shifts. 8 because this is close to the cross-section described by Gompper and Schick35 as containing examples of all major phases of the model. Generation of the neural network training data was an iterative and somewhat heuristic process. We started by sparsely sampling a large region of (Δ,T) space in the H/J=0, K/J=2, L/J=3 plane and labeling phases manually, to get a general sense of the layout of the phase diagram. This allowed us to find regions where we were highly confident about the correct classification, and we used these regions for training data. In the case of the microemulsion phase, this included checking that the correlation function had a local minimum.d After the first round of training and testing, we examined snapshots from different points in the phase diagram to visualize where errors occurred, and we added further training data at appropriate points to reduce these errors. For example, we initially did not include the crystal phase consisting of black and white rectangles, as this phase was not described in previous work. We identified this as a separate phase after it was labeled as fluid phase in earlier tests. The final training data set is shown in Figure S1a, overlaid on the final phase diagram. At each chosen set of training parameters (156 sets in total), 100 independent samples were acquired for training, for a total of 15600 samples in the training set. Note that, despite the heuristic approach to generating the training data, it is not the case that we could generate an arbitrary different phase diagram simply by changing the training data. Rather, the phase diagram reflects real, qualitative differences in the behavior of the system. In our experience, training with a bad training set (e.g., containing different phases labeled as the same phase) leads to an obviously bad phase diagram, in which some regions contain different adjacent pixels classified as different phases with low confidence (quantified as described below). Two types of training data were acquired for use in training two separate networks. In one data set (the snapshot approach, phase diagram shown in Figure S1c), simply 100 independent snapshots per parameter set were saved. In a second data set (the averaged approach, phase diagram shown in Figure S1b), 100 independent groups of 10 correlated snapshots each (as described in Monte Carlo Simulations, above) were acquired. The 10 snapshots were averaged to give one average image for the data set. Broadly speaking, this averaging has the effect of smoothing out random fluctuations, allowing the network training to focus on more constant aspects of each phase. d The appearance of this oscillation in the correlation function is one (admittedly somewhat arbitrary) definition of a microemulsion suggested by Gommper and Schick.32 9 Figure 2. Schematic of the methodology used in this study. (a) Schematic of the neural network (NN) used for phase prediction. The pixel values from a Monte Carlo simulation on a 30x30 lattice serve as inputs. (Black, white, and gray pixels are rescaled to non-negative values for these simulations as described in Methods). The network is trained using 2 hidden layers of 100 nodes each. The network contains 6 outputs, corresponding to its confidence that the input represents each of the 6 possible phases. Each pixel in the simulation box has dimensions of 1 nm x 1 nm. (b) At each point in parameter space (square pixels), the neural network was run on Monte Carlo simulation results to label the phase (c) Schematic of simulations used to calculate kinase binding energy by Bennett's method. The simulated system consists of two separate boxes, one representing the membrane near the receptor cluster (left), and another representing a section of the membrane at infinite distance (right). The teal and magenta proteins' σ values are fixed white, while the rest of the lattices are Monte Carlo sampled. We use Bennett's method to calculate the free energy difference between State 1 (kinase at infinity) and State 2 (kinase inside cluster). The dimension of each pixel in the simulation boxes is 1 nm x 1 nm. The solid lines linking panel a to panel b and panel b to panel c show one example of how a phase is determined and used in Bennett's calculation. The neural network code used is the implementation of 45, also available online at https://github.com/mnielsen/neural-networks- and-deep-learning . Each training sample was converted into an input vector of length 900 containing the values at each site of the 30x30 lattice, and a target output vector of length 6, consisting of 1 at the index of the correct phase, and 0 for all other values. The values of the input vector were rescaled such that black = 0, gray = 0.5, white = 1, in order to provide all non- 10 negative inputs to the network (Figure 2a). The feed-forward neural network contained two hidden layers of size 100 each, made up of sigmoid neurons. We performed 25 epochs of training. In each epoch, the training data were randomly divided into mini batches of size 10. With each mini batch, stochastic gradient descent was performed by a backpropagation algorithm with a learning rate η = 0.06. We use a cross-entropy cost function, with an L2 regularization parameter of λ = 0.04 to avoid overfitting. To avoid stopping the stochastic training at a bad point, if the final classification accuracy was worse than 0.85, extra epochs were run, one at a time, until 0.85 was reached. For the snapshot approach, we instead used a threshold of 0.9. This method resulted in at most 5 (typically 0-2) extra epochs added. 10 instances of the neural network were trained independently on the same training data set. When working with the test data, we took the average output of the 10 instances. Neural Network Phase Diagram Generation Test data were generated by the same Metropolis method as the training data. At each point in parameter space (H, K, L, Δ, T; Eq. 1) where we sought to determine the phase, 5 snapshots or correlated averages were generated. These were fed as input into the neural networks, yielding output vectors with 6 elements in the range [0,1]. In these output vectors, a higher value at a particular index indicates that the point more likely belongs to the corresponding phase. Output vectors were averaged over the 5 samples and 10 network instances to arrive at a single final output vector (Figure 2a). The point was classified as the phase corresponding to the maximum value in the output vector (Figure 2b). The classification confidence was calculated as the maximum value in the output vector, divided by the sum of the output vector. When rendering the phase diagrams, the phase classification determined the color – red, green, blue, orange, pink, or yellow. The RGB value of the base color was multiplied by the classification confidence, such that a brightere color represents more confident classification. For example, a point classified as lamellar (red, RGB = (0.8, 0.4, 0.0)) with confidence 0.8 would be rendered as RGB = (0.64, 0.32, 0.0). The averaged approach was more effective than the snapshot approach. With the snapshot approach, we could only distinguish 4 phases: Fluid, Black/White, Gray, and a single region covering Lamellar, Microemulsion, and Critical (Figure S1c). With the averaged approach, we could distinguish six phases (Figure S1b), but we had low confidence in the distinction between the Fluid and Gray phases (Figure S1d). To combine these, on testing e Note that we use the term brightness here in the sense of the HSB (Hue, Saturation, Brightness) representation of colors. HSB and HSV (Hue, Saturation, Value) are equivalent representations, so scaling the brightness is synonymous with scaling the value. 11 data, we used the Gray output from the snapshot approach, and the other 5 outputs from the averaged approach. This gave the final phase diagram that we believe most completely describes our understanding of it after our work with both these approaches. Binding Energy Computation We consider the binding energy to be the difference in free energy between a single white pixel (spin +1) with a set cluster of three other white pixels, compared to that single white pixel being at an infinite distance from that set cluster (Figure 2c). We call the set cluster "receptors" and the designated single pixel, "kinase." To compute this binding energy by Bennett's method,46 simulations were performed on the four separate lattices shown in Figure 2c: State 1 consists of a 50x50 lattice containing the set cluster of receptors, and a separate 30x30 lattice containing the kinase. State 2 consists of a 50x50 lattice containing the kinase within the cluster of receptors, and a 30x30 lattice empty of the kinase. Note, for the 30x30 boxes (Figure 2c, right), the smaller lattice size was permissible because these boxes only ever contain one designated white pixel, which affects the lattice on a shorter length scale than the full receptor cluster. Samples were generated by the Metropolis algorithm in the same way as the neural network training data, but the predefined receptor and kinase proteins were required to remain white. Any proposed move that attempted to flip one of these spins was automatically rejected. The free energy ΔF, corresponding to the binding energy, is computed according to the following formula. e−(ΔF−C )/(k BT )= ⟨f (( ΔU 1→2−C)/(kB T))⟩1 ⟨f ((ΔU 2 →1+C)/(k BT ))⟩2 (2) Here, C can be any constant, with the fastest convergence achieved when C ≈ ΔF. We choose C = -0.5 kBT, and choose f as the Fermi-Dirac function, f ( x)=1/(1+ex) as suggested in 46. The numerator is calculated as an ensemble average from simulations of state 1 (Figure 2c, top). ΔU1→2 for each sample is the energy change associated with exchanging the kinase and a pixel at the center of the cluster (corresponding to the kinase position in state 2). Likewise, the denominator is calculated from simulations of state 2, and ΔU2→1 is the energy change associated with exchanging the kinase located within the cluster and the pixel corresponding to its position in state 1. Note that the two separate boxes that make up each state in Figure 2c can be generated independently, and we use this to our advantage. We initially generated the same 12 number of samples of the 50x50 box and the 30x30 box. Then each 50x50 box was paired with 10 different 30x30 boxes, increasing the number of samples of the state by a factor of 10. These samples are not independent, but they still follow the correct Monte Carlo statistics. For calculating binding energy at each parameter set to be tested, simulations were performed for 5000 sweeps, a sample was saved every sweep, and the lattice was reshuffled every 10 sweeps. After data expansion, this gave 50000 non-independent samples of each state, to be used in the Bennett calculation. Results Neural Network Phase Identification We trained neural networks to classify the output of a Monte Carlo simulation of the Gompper and Schick lattice model,35 according to the phase that the simulation represents. A schematic of the network and an example of a resulting phase diagram are shown in Figure 2a, b. The σ values from a 30 by 30-pixel Monte Carlo snapshot (generated by the standard Metropolis method)47 were used as 900 inputs to the network. Training data consisted of 15600 such snapshots, which represented typical examples of each phase of interest (Figure S1). The network was trained with 2 hidden layers of 100 nodes each, and an output layer of 6 nodes, corresponding to the six phases of interest in the phase diagram. Alternatively, instead of single Monte Carlo snapshots, we used input consisting of the average of 10 correlated snapshots from consecutive simulation steps. This method tended to be more accurate in most cases, and our final reported phase diagrams make use of some output from both types of networks. Our procedures, including training of the neural networks, are further described in Methods. We initially evaluated the lattice model with H/J = 0, K/J = 2, L/J = 3, ranging over T/J and Δ/J values of order 1. In the original description of the model,35 this cross-section was found to contain examples of all phases present in the model. Our neural network was able to confidently label six distinct regions of the phase diagram (Figure 3), corresponding to the eight phases described in the Introduction: fluid, lamellar, gray, crystal, black / white, and microemulsion / critical. The network was not able to determine a distinct boundary between microemulsion and critical fluctuations, so the single microemulsion / critical label was applied to both. At larger values of Δ, the region is a microemulsion, while, at smaller values of Δ, the system shows fluctuating domains consistent with close proximity to an Ising critical point. Instead of a clear boundary between 13 Figure 3. Phase diagram of the lattice model. The color of each pixel with specified (Δ/J, T/J) coordinates indicates the phase at that point, as determined by the neural network. Pixels with a higher brightness indicate a higher level of confidence in the classification. Snapshots show typical examples of each of the phases, corresponding to the black points on the phase diagram. 14 the critical fluctuation and microemulsion behaviors, the regions blend into one another smoothly. Because two models often used to explain lipid rafts – microemulsion and critical phenomena1 – are included within this phase, it is highly relevant for membrane-related questions. The network applied the same black / white label to both the black phase and white phase. Because the training data contained examples of two-phase coexistence, including snapshots of both black phase and white phase with the same classification, the neural network was trained to apply the same label to both. With H=0, the black / white classification represents two-phase coexistence between the black and white phase, while with H>0, the white phase does not exist, and the label represents only the black phase (conversely for H<0). Finally, we note that the network applied the crystal label to the limit of the lamellar phase in which the components alternate with period of one lattice unit. Exploring the Phase Diagram We used our neural network to compute other cross-sections of the phase diagram and thereby gain a more complete perspective on the entire parameter space. Remarkably, it was not necessary to retrain the network to work with these other cross-sections. We found that the original network trained at H/J=0, K/J=2, L/J=3 accurately identifies the phases elsewhere in the phase diagram, for all H, K, and L values considered in this study. Varying the surfactant strength L changes the topology of the phase diagram (Figure 4). At zero or low L (L/J = 1.5), the lamellar phase does not exist, and the black/white phase directly borders the gray phase. At zero L, a tricritical point exists at the intersection of the fluid, black/white and gray phases. At higher L (L/J = 3), we reach the case shown in Figure 3, in which the lamellar and crystal phases exist between the black/white and gray phases. At even higher L (L/J = 6), the system becomes a crystal for nearly all values of Δ and T tested, maximizing the number of surfactant interactions. With K=0 and L=0, the model reduces to the more widely studied Blume-Capel model (Figure 5), in which gray pixels are neutral in their interactions with white and black pixels. In our diagram, the region between black/white coexistence and the fluid phase can be identified as a critical transition by virtue of the yellow critical region appearing between the blue and orange regions. Note that microemulsions are not possible with L=0, and therefore the entire yellow region in this cross-section represents Ising critical behavior. The critical line occurs at the boundary between the blue and yellow regions in Figure 5a. With H/J = 0.1, the critical "phase" disappears, correctly showing that at L=0, H>0, there is no longer a critical 15 Figure 4. Cross-sections of the phase diagram at varying values of the surfactant strength. Surfactant strength L/J is varied 0 to 6, with constant H/J = 0, K/J = 2. Colors have the same meaning as in Figure 3. phase transition (Figure 5b). When L is increased with K=0 (Figure S2), the phase diagram has topology similar to as the case with K/J = 2, although the phase boundaries occur at lower Δ. Finally, we considered some additional cross-sections at positive H (Figure S3). We note that with H/J=0.1, K/J=2, L/J=3, some yellow region remains at high Δ. Presumably this indicates microemulsion behavior, because a critical line is not expected to exist at nonzero H. At higher H (H/J=0.5), the black/white classification (here representing only the black phase) grows to encompass most of the parameter space examined in this range of Δ and T. Quantifying Protein Recruitment in Terms of Preferential Partitioning Having calculated the phase diagram for the lattice model, we turned to our questions related to biological function. In particular, we compare the effectiveness of lipid raft-mediated protein reorganization at various points on the phase diagram. As a specific test, we consider the case of three receptors (such as IgE-FcεRI) cross-linked to form a cluster; these are activated to initiate transmembrane signaling only after recruiting a membrane-anchored kinase (such as Lyn; see Figure 1). We assume both the receptors and the kinase prefer Lo-rich domains (i.e., lipid rafts), and 16 correspondingly, we represent them with white pixels, which we place at selected, fixed positions in the lattice. Lyn, is represented by one white pixel, whereas each of the three receptors is represented by 12 white pixels, corresponding to their relatively larger size (Figure 2c). We calculate the binding energy as the free energy associated with moving the kinase into the middle of the three-receptor cluster. A larger magnitude negative value indicates a stronger contribution of lipid rafts to protein colocalization at a particular point in the phase diagram. Similar to what we and others have done Figure 5. Cross-sections of the phase diagram for the Blume-Capel model (K=0, L=0), with H/J = 0 or 0.1. Colors have the same meaning as in Figure 3. previously,44 we use Bennett's method46 (Eq. 2) to calculate the free energy change. We do so here in a more computationally efficient method than in previous studies. In previous work, we calculated the energy change stepwise, moving the kinase out of the cluster, one lattice unit at a time, and generating a profile of energy versus position in the process.44 Here, we instead calculate the entire energy in one step. Our simulated system (Figure 2c) consists of two separate boxes, one containing the receptor cluster (left), and the other representing membrane at infinite distance from the cluster (right). By Bennett's method, we compute the free energy to move the kinase from the box at infinite distance (state 1) to the center of the cluster (state 2). We used the phase diagram to assist in choosing points for Bennett simulations – we ran a simulation at each point marked with a diamond in Figure 6. We focused our simulations primarily on the microemulsion/critical region of the phase diagram, and, for comparison, we performed simulations at a smaller number of points elsewhere in the phase diagram. We additionally performed simulations in which a single white pixel was set (instead of the receptor cluster) and calculated binding energies for a second white pixel to come into proximity. We found these binding energies to be qualitatively similar but weaker compared to the case with the cluster (Figure S4). 17 Our results for a kinase associating with a receptor cluster (Figure 2c) are shown by the colors of the diamonds in Figure 6. In the Blume-Capel (H = K = L = 0) phase diagram (Figure 6a), no microemulsion exists and we find roughly the same binding energy of ~ -0.6 kBT at all points along the Ising critical line at the boundary between the blue and yellow regions. This corresponds to a modest increase in kinase concentration, by a factor of e0.6≈1.8 . Along this critical line, the binding energy does not show a dramatic difference above, versus below, the transition temperature (columns of diamonds along blue-yellow boundary). Strikingly, as the tricritical point is approached (the box in Fig. 6a), we find a dramatic, nearly threefold increase in the magnitude of the binding energy. The minimum free energy of -1.7 kBT, is achieved at the tricritical Δ (1.9655 J) and 1.04 times the tricritical temperature (0.634 J/kB). The corresponding increase in kinase concentration by a factor of e1.7≈5.5 is much more significant than the 1.8 factor at an ordinary critical point. We suspect that the distance of the optimum above the tricritical temperature, 1.04x, is a finite size effect, as this value increases if the simulation box is made smaller. The true optimum might occur at exactly the tricritical temperature (0.610 J/kB). To validate our new application of Bennett's method (Eq. 2, Figure 2c), we also calculated the energy profile at the tricritical point stepwise by Jarsynski's method,48 identical to the method used in 44 (Figure S5). Due to the larger simulation box used in this method, finite size effects are less of a concern. We found a binding energy of ~ -1.5 kBT with Jarzynski's method, comparable to our result at 1.02x the tricritical temperature with Bennett's method (Figure 6b). However, at the tricritical temperature, our application of Bennett's method gives a binding energy of only -1.0 kBT, presumably due to finite size effects at this temperature. We compare these results to the first-order phase transition that occurs at H > 0 (Figure 6c), which yields a higher concentration of black (Ld-preferring) pixels than white (Lo- preferring) pixels in the lattice. We found a similar binding energy of ~ -0.6 kBT above the transition temperature in the fluid phase. However, we see a substantially stronger binding energy as low as ~ -1.4 kBT upon entering the phase-separated state. In the context of membranes, this would correspond to a situation in which most lipids on the membrane favor the Ld phase, but our receptor/kinase proteins of interest favor Lo. Finally, in Figure 6d, we consider the binding energy around the microemulsion/critical region using the parameters of Figure 3 (H/J=0.0, K/J=2.0, L/J=3.0). To aid in the distinction between microemulsion and critical "phase" in this cross-section, at selected points (marked 18 Figure 6. Kinase binding energy at selected points in the phase diagram. Each colored diamond indicates the free energy change associated with moving a kinase into a cluster of receptors (as in Figure 2c) at that point (Δ/J, T/J) in the phase diagram. The phase diagram colors are rendered paler than in other figures to make the diamonds more clearly visible. (a) Binding energy in the Blume-Capel model (K=0, L=0) for the cross-section H=0. (b) Inset of (a) in the region around the tricritical point (black box in (a) ). The indicated point (black arrow) with the minimum free energy of -1.7 kBT occurs at the tricritical Δ and 1.04 times the tricritical temperature. (c) Binding energy in the Blume-Capel model for the cross-section in which the external field H/J = 0.1 favors black pixels, opposite to the kinase and receptor preference for white pixels. (d) Binding energy in a cross-section that includes microemulsions and lamellar phases (K/J = 2, L/J = 3). Within the microemulsion/critical phase, marked points (magenta boxes) were analyzed with correlation functions and visual inspection of simulation snapshots (Figure S6). Point A is part of the critical "phase," point B is a microemulsion with length scale ~ 10, and point C is a microemulsion with length scale ~ 4. At certain points in this cross-section (blue color scale), including point C, the positive binding energy indicates that it is energetically unfavorable to bring the kinase into the cluster. 19 A, B, and C in Figure 6d), we performed correlation function analysis (Figure S6). We confirmed that point A is in the Ising critical region, and B and C are in the microemulsion region. In the Ising critical region (i.e. the yellow region at low values of Δ, including point A), we again find a binding energy of ~ -0.6 kBT, the same as the case with no surfactant strength L (Figure 6a). As we move to higher Δ, corresponding to a microemulsion region, we find a striking change. At a subset of the points in the microemulsion region (including point C), the binding energy at becomes much weaker, even turning positive (unfavorable). Intuitively, this happens when the characteristic length scale of the microemulsion is smaller than the size of the set receptor cluster. Considering microemulsions with a longer length scale (near blue- yellow boundary at Δ/J between 4 and 5, including point B), we find a binding energy of -0.6 kBT, comparable to that at an Ising critical point at lower values of Δ. Thus, the results indicate that the binding energy associated with microemulsion behavior depends on how the characteristic length scale of the microemulsion compares to the spacing of the clustered receptors. It is also possible that a microemulsion exists at a length scale larger than our 30x30 nm snapshot used to generate the phase diagram. This would likely appear as phase- separated in our diagram, and indeed would look equivalent to phase-separated from the perspective of a cluster of size less than 30 nm. Based on our simulated results at points in the phase-separated region, this case would also likely yield a value of around -0.6 kBT (Figure 6d). The Figure 6d cross-section contains no point comparable in binding energy to the tricritical point in Figure 6a. The minimum binding energy achieved in this cross-section (except perhaps at biologically irrelevant points at very low temperature) is ~ -0.6 kBT, which occurs along the entire boundary between the black/white and microemulsion/critical regions. This remains true if we more densely sample the entire length of the phase boundaries (data not shown). Among all of the phase states tested, the tricritical point at H = K = L = 0 (Figure 6a) leads to the strongest possible binding energy for kinase and clustered receptors. Discussion Comparison to Published Results We have generated the phase diagram for the Gompper and Schick lattice model using relatively new neural network methodologies. It is important to consider how this method compares to other more established methods for phase diagram determination. We examine certain special cases of the model that allow for direct comparison of our phase 20 diagram to published phase diagrams obtained by other methods. By taking Δ to -∞ (no gray pixels), and H=0, we have the Ising model, with the well- known critical transition temperature of 2 / log(1 + sqrt(2)) ≈ 2.269 J/kB. Applying our existing network to this case, we see the phase transition at close to the correct temperature (Figure S7a). The network's confidence level for the Ising model is worse than optimal because this network was trained to perform a more complicated classification on 6 phases, instead of the 2 phases (fluid and black/white coexistence) relevant to the Ising model. A different approach is to train a network, solely on Ising model examples, to classify between only the fluid phase and black/white coexistence. With this model, we distinguish the phases with high confidence, and we nearly perfectly identify the transition temperature (Figure S7b). This level of accuracy is comparable to previous neural network work on the Ising critical transition.41 The result for the Blume-Capel model (K=0, L=0; Figure 5) with H=0 is comparable to results with this model from other methods. We find good quantitative agreement on the location of phase boundaries with Beale's phase diagram from finite size scaling49 (Figure S8). We also show the mean field theory solution37 for comparison. The tricritical point has an upper critical dimension of three, meaning that mean field theory is expected to be inaccurate near the tricritical point in this two-dimensional model.50 However, our calculated result is much closer to the more accurate finite size scaling solution. Our diagrams can also be compared to those obtained in Gompper and Schick's original description of the model35 (Figure S9). Note that, to make this comparison it was necessary to add the parameter K2, the equivalent of K between second nearest neighbors in a straight line. This had no effect on the overall shape of the phase diagram, but shifted the phase boundaries slightly. We find very good agreement on the location of the critical line in all cross-sections with Gompper and Schick's transfer matrix approach. The original phase diagram included a Lifshitz line, which the authors defined as the separation between Ising and microemulsion regions. This helps us better interpret the combined microemulsion/critical region in our phase diagram, which is in fact a microemulsion to the right of the Lifshitz line. In other aspects of the phase diagram, the neural network approach provided new information, and it revealed shortcomings of the original phase diagram. We note our new placement of the lamellar phase (red) is qualitatively different from the Gompper and Schick diagram, including a lobe that sits below the phase-separated state on the temperature axis. We give a new boundary between the gray phase (pink) and the fluid phase (orange). Our identification of the rectangular crystal phase (green) is entirely new, not addressed in the 21 original study (the diagonal crystal that our network labeled as part of this phase arguably belongs in the lamellar phase, but the rectangular features are clearly a distinct phase). Some of these novel features are relevant to the biological system of interest, while others are not (such as the rectangular crystal phase, which likely exists only due to the use of a square lattice), but all point to the strengths of global computational approaches in phase diagram prediction, which allow direct comparisons. Theoretical techniques like finite size scaling frequently focus on specific interesting areas of the phase diagram, such as the critical line. In our neural network approach, we instead indiscriminately analyzed entire slices of the phase diagram, extracting features in both critical and non-critical regions. This is especially valuable for a problem such as biological lipid-based membranes, for which different groups have proposed that the most relevant states are either near a critical point21,29 or away from a critical point.7,26,28 Finally, to further validate the application of this model to the study of lipid membranes, we compare our neural-network-derived phase diagrams with the numerical and mean-field phase diagrams produced in previous studies on the formation of lipid rafts (nanoscale domains concentrated with Lo-preferring components, as defined in the Introduction). We consider first microemulsion-based models, which propose that either surfactant-like lipid species28 or membrane curvature7,26,27 stabilize the interface between different phase domains. Importantly, the generality of our neural network approach means that we could in principle explicitly reproduce the results of the different membrane models described above. It should even be possible to train a neural network with multiple models simultaneously, a potential avenue for future work. Here, however, we are interested in comparing the results of our single-Hamiltonian neural network approach with results in the membrane modeling literature. How much agreement should we expect between the neural network trained on our Hamiltonian (Eq. 1) and models with different Hamiltonian forms and explicitly different energetic terms (e.g. composition-curvature interactions)? Due to the presence of gray pixels as surfactants, our model most closely resembles models that make use of hybrid lipids,28,51 so we can ask how our model compares to curvature-based models, which are seemingly the most different. As discussed above (Results), our Hamiltonian captures much of the physics of other membrane models, including 2D Ising critical and tricritical behavior. In these critical regimes, our Hamiltonian is equivalent to all others due to the universality of critical behavior.50 22 Outside these critical regimes, in the biologically-relevant microemulsion phase, we also expect qualitative agreement between our model and curvature-based models. Intuitively, in a microemulsion regime, the gray pixels in our model will act analogously to regions of curvature mismatch: in a system with droplets of one phase suspended in a backdrop of another phase, the boundaries of the droplets will be regions of concentrated surfactant-like interaction. In our model, this looks like a domain of either black or white pixels encircled by a strip of gray pixels; in the curvature model, the picture is the same, except that the gray pixels are replaced by a region of curvature change (this can be pictured as the droplet "popping out" of the membrane). Importantly, in this regime we have a defined length scale in both models: in ours, it arises from the concentration of gray pixels, while in the curvature model it arises from the mechanical properties of the membrane. Ultimately, however, the comparison of predicted phase behavior serves as the best indicator of model similarity, and we find good agreement between the phase diagrams in the literature (both curvature- and hybrid-lipid-based) and those generated by our neural network approach (Figure 7). Our phase diagrams reproduce all the features found in these other model frameworks, including Ising critical transitions, lamellar phases, two-phase coexistence and tricritical phenomena. Moreover, the general topology of the phase diagrams is consistent regardless of model choice-for instance, all models considered here predict a lamellar phase separated from a microemulsion phase by an Ising critical line, with the microemulsion phase, in turn, separated from an ordinary fluid phase by a boundary that is not a true thermodynamic phase transition. This consistency with previously calculated phase diagrams7,51 speaks to the generality of our approach, which allows us to describe and compare a wide variety of membrane phenomenologies using a single model framework. Application to Lipid Rafts We set out with this model to analyze competing hypotheses on the physical basis for formation of lipid rafts: does stabilization of nanoscale Lo-like domains arise from proximity to a critical phase transition, or from nanodomains of a characteristic size, as in a microemulsion? We found that in some ways, the two hypotheses are much alike. As described in the Introduction, considerable evidence supports the view that lipid rafts serve to recruit proteins to the correct place on the cell membrane, such as our example of Lyn kinase recruitment into a set IgE-FcεRI cluster, where both components are Lo-preferring. Our phase diagram shows that critical and microemulsion phase states can be equally beneficial thermodynamically for this membrane purpose. As we showed, both can give about the same 23 Figure 7. Schematic comparison of our phase diagram with those from the microemulsion literature. (a) Mean-field phase diagram from a model with hybrid lipid species acting as a surfactant. Adapted from 51 (b) Mean-field phase diagram from a model with curvature coupled to membrane composition to produce a surfactant-like interaction. Adapted from 7. (c) Phase diagram generated by our neural network approach. X coordinate gives strength of surfactant- like interaction in (b), or concentration of surfactant species in (a) and (c). Y coordinate represents temperature. Note that this is a schematic representation, so the actual axes from the source papers differ in scale and representation. For the sake of comparison to the other models, we use yellow here to represent only microemulsions, not Ising critical behavior. The yellow-orange gradient in (c) is used to schematize the ambiguity between microemulsion and ordinary fluid phase, and represents our best interpretation of the location of the microemulsion state, taking into account the neural network output (Figure 3), snapshots within the phase diagram (Figure 3, yellow-bordered panels), and the location of the Lifshitz line from 35 shown in Figure S9. optimal binding energy of -0.6 kBT. We also showed it is possible to sit in a region between microemulsion and critical point with a classification that is subjective. Gompper and Schick chose the Lifshitz line as an arbitrary distinction for what qualifies as a microemulsion, while our neural network was unable to draw a sharp line between the two behaviors. Our energy calculations make a clear prediction for a difference between clearly critical and clearly microemulsion states (at lower and higher values of Δ, respectively). Microemulsions carry the requirement of a particular characteristic size, and can only effectively stabilize lipid domains smaller than that size. If the set cluster of Lo components is larger than the microemulsion length scale, then there is actually exclusion of other Lo components from the cluster (Figure 6d). In contrast, if the membrane sits near an Ising critical point, the consequent lipid rafts are 24 stabilized at all length scales, never excluding other Lo components. If the membrane indeed exists as a microemulsion, then in principle it should be possible to experimentally exceed the correct length scale, and cause a reversal of the lipid mediated signaling. To our knowledge, this exact experiment has not been carried out, and may remain challenging to implement. However, in mast cells, a structurally defined ligand with spacing 13 nm has been studied,52 and the resulting large receptor spacing lowers, but does not eliminate, the signaling response. This suggests that, if the mast cell signaling response relies on a microemulsion-mediated kinase recruitment, that microemulsion length scale must be larger than 13 nm. One argument sometimes used in favor of microemulsions is that they are easier to achieve, requiring less cell-directed tuning of the membrane. However, our phase diagram points to an additional complication: the cell not only has to tune the membrane composition to a microemulsion, but also must tune the length scale to the characteristic size necessary for the correct biological function, which may be highly variable, depending on the signaling pathway and components involved. What about the actin cytoskeleton? It is widely thought that cortical actin couples to the membrane, forming "corrals" that add further complexity to the heterogeneity of the membrane. However, in many ways this does not affect our conclusions, as typical size estimates for actin corrals53 are above our simulation size of 50x50 nm (Figure 2c). A small cluster of Lo-preferring components set within one corral sees a particular membrane composition, regardless of the corrals boundaries at longer length scales. However, actin involvement motivates two other considerations. First, we should not ignore the phase- separated region of the phase diagram (blue, Figures 3-5, S2-S3), as the membrane may have a phase-separating composition, driven below the diffraction limit only by actin- mediated partitioning.12,54 We see that a phase-separating membrane would yield a kinase binding energy similar to the minimum in the microemulsion/critical phase. (Figure 6a,d). Second, we note that, due to cortical actin, the membrane composition encountered by receptors might not be the global composition of the membrane. This actin meshwork has been proposed to preferentially sequester either Lo or Ld lipids,12,34 which would deplete these from a cluster set in the middle of a corral. The most striking new discovery from our phase diagram and energy calculations is the power of a membrane at a tricritical point. Our computations show that near the tricritical point, the potential binding energy due to lipid rafts increases by a factor of 3 compared to 25 any of the other proposed models: critical point, microemulsion, or phase-separated two- phase coexistence. This increase in energetic favorability could confer significant advantage for lateral recruitment in the membrane. Moreover, the interactions near a tricritical point are long-range in nature, which could also have important implications for signaling in the natural cell environment. Previous conformal field theory results have shown that, near an Ising critical point, proteins can interact via long-range critical Casimir forces.44 Because our method of calculating binding energies agrees with the results from 44, our system should also exhibit such long-range interactions near the tricritical point, but with a different power law governing their spatial decay. The large effect at the tricritical point likely comes from the different critical exponents of this universality class. In particular, the potential that gives rise to critical Casimir forces scales with the correlation function g(r), which itself scales as g(r) ~ r -d+2-η near a critical point, where d is the dimension of our system and η is a universal critical exponent.50 Plugging in the relevant critical exponents, we see that g(r) scales as r -0.15 at the Ising critical point, but as r -0.25 at the tricritical point.50,55–58 Thus, at the tricritical point, the critical exponent (η=0.15) allows attraction between Lo-preferring components to remain stronger at a longer distance, especially compared to direct chemical bonds or electrostatic interactions (which are expected to be screened over ~1 nm in the cell), and also longer range than the r-2 attractive forces mediated by membrane curvature.44 To our knowledge, a tricritical point has not previously been considered as a serious proposition for the physical basis of lipid rafts, and perhaps for a good reason: achieving proximity to a tricritical point requires tuning of three relevant parameters, whereas proximity to an Ising critical point requires only two. In the three-dimensional phase space of the Blume-Capel model, only a single point is a tricritical point. However, we note that in a many- component cell membrane with many more than 3 degrees of freedom, there would be more possibilities for tuning to a tricritical composition. The detailed nature of "lipid rafts" is probably quite variable even within a single functional cell membrane, and localized tuning may be possible for a particular signaling purpose. Furthermore, we argue that if effective lipid rafts provide a strong enough evolutionary advantage for the cell to respond appropriately to environmental stimuli, it might be to the cell's advantage to maintain a tricritical composition (at least locally), and gain the massive improvement in lipid raft energetics that results. Conversely, the optimal lipid raft strength for signaling to be appropriately regulated in the cell might be weaker than what is generated by the tricritical point, in which case we would expect 26 the membrane to exist in one of the other phase states explored in this study. It is also reasonable to ask whether lipid rafts could facilitate interactions between Lo- preferring components that lead to the formation of the cluster itself. This was not the case we considered for mast cells, in which clustering was due to physical cross-linking of the IgE- FcεRI by antigen. In T cell receptor signaling, for example, clusters form in the absence of cross-linking by a mechanism that remains unclear.59 The Ising critical point or microemulsion binding energy of -0.6 kBT would not be sufficient to cause clustering of individual receptors; this requires considerably stronger interactions. We previously performed calculations and simulations based on the formulas for Casimir forces given in 44 and concluded that these forces, at an Ising critical point, are not large enough to mediate receptor clustering (Milka Doktorova and Eshan Mitra, unpublished observations). However, we now note that the stronger binding energies found near the tricritical point may be sufficient to mediate receptor co-clustering, independently of external agent. We further note that the concept of a membrane at a tricritical point is not inconsistent with observations of GPMVs showing ordinary Ising critical exponents.21 We argue that a membrane might exhibit tricritical behavior at short length scales and Ising critical behavior at the longer length scale accessible with current experimental techniques. This hypothesis can be formalized using renormalization group (RG) theory, a tool for describing how the observed behavior of a system changes due to coarse-graining. Here, coarse-graining corresponds to the loss in resolution when a membrane is observed with a diffraction-limited microscope. Certain points in parameter space are RG fixed points, which are unaffected by coarse-graining (i.e. look the same at different length scales). Other points, under RG coarse- graining "flow" towards or away from the fixed points (Figure S10). The 2D tricritical fixed point and Ising critical fixed point are two examples of such RG fixed points, with systems tending to flow from tricritical to Ising behavior under coarse-graining. As seen in Figure S10, physical systems that flow near to the tricritical point will show tricritical behavior on length scales relevant for protein organization, but could then flow away to Ising behavior on the longer length scales observed in GPMV studies.f While our work with this lattice model has been useful in addressing many hypotheses on lipid organization (and proposing a new, tricritical possibility), it has some limitations. In f Indeed, the phase diagram of a physical system near a critical point echoes the flow diagram near the corresponding renormalization-group fixed point (the irrelevant contracting directions only making analytic changes in the phase boundaries), leading to a common conflation of the two (adding 'flow' arrows to the boundaries in experimental phase diagrams). 27 particular, this is a thermodynamic model, operating under the assumption of a steady state. Kinetic hypotheses about lipid organization, such as active actin remodeling,60 would require a different theoretical framework in order to compare to the cases that we have explored. However, our neural network-based methods should allow similar morphological classification. Moreover, while it is possible for active processes to be described by Ising critical behavior,61 studies on GPMVs isolated from cells21 show that these membranes remain close to an Ising critical point even after any active processes have likely been disrupted in sample preparation. Another future direction for this theoretical approach is to convert the phase diagrams using external fields H and Δ into diagrams based on the concentration of each component. We chose to use a model with fixed external fields and variable composition to enable efficient simulations on small system sizes, and to easily compare with existing theory literature. These external fields could be converted to the corresponding compositions of each component, transforming the phase diagram to one of fixed compositions. This would allow more direct comparison to experimental phase diagrams of model membranes such as in 19. Acknowledgements EM, DH, and BB were supported by National Institutes of Health grants R01-AI018306 followed by R01-GM117552, and their contributions further benefited from participation in the HHMI/MBL Summer Institute supported by an HCIA award. SW was supported by the Department of Defense through the National Defense Science Engineering Graduate Fellowship (NDSEG) Program. JPS was supported by the National Science Foundation grants DMR-1312160 and DMR-1719490. EM was additionally supported by the National Institutes of Health under the Ruth L. Kirschstein National Research Service Award (2T32GM008267) from the National Institute of General Medical Sciences. We are grateful to Frank Zhang for discussions on the use of neural networks for phase diagram prediction, to Archishman Raju, Colin Clement, and Benjamin Machta for discussions on critical phenomena and scaling analysis, and to Gerald Feigenson for discussions on lipid membranes. 28 References (1) Schmid, F. Physical Mechanisms of Micro- and Nanodomain Formation in Multicomponent Lipid Membranes. Biochim. Biophys. Acta - Biomembr. 2017, 1859 (4), 509–528. (2) Léonard, C.; Alsteens, D.; Dumitru, A. C.; Mingeot-Leclercq, M.-P.; Tyteca, D. Lipid Domains and Membrane (Re)Shaping: From Biophysics to Biology. In The Biophysics of Cell Membranes: Biological Consequences; Epand, R. M., Ruysschaert, J.-M., Eds.; Springer Singapore: Singapore, 2017; pp 121–175. (3) Munro, S. Lipid Rafts. Cell 2003, 115 (4), 377–388. (4) Pike, L. J. Rafts Defined: A Report on the Keystone Symposium on Lipid Rafts and Cell Function. J. Lipid Res. 2006, 47 (7), 1597–1598. (5) Sengupta, P.; Holowka, D.; Baird, B. Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer between Lipid Probes Detects Nanoscopic Heterogeneity in the Plasma Membrane of Live Cells. Biophys. J. 2007, 92 (10), 3564–3574. (6) Lingwood, D.; Simons, K. Lipid Rafts as a Membrane-Organizing Principle. Science 2010, 327 (5961), 46–50. (7) Schick, M. Theories of Equilibrium Inhomogeneous Fluids http://faculty.washington.edu/schick/Abstracts/sens-book.pdf (accessed Jun 6, 2017). (8) Dietrich, C.; Bagatolli, L. a.; Volovyk, Z. N.; Thompson, N. L.; Levi, M.; Jacobson, K.; Gratton, E. Lipid Rafts Reconstituted in Model Membranes. Biophys. J. 2001, 80 (3), 1417–1428. (9) Veatch, S. L.; Keller, S. L. Seeing Spots: Complex Phase Behavior in Simple Membranes. Biochim. Biophys. Acta - Mol. Cell Res. 2005, 1746 (3), 172–185. (10) Veatch, S. L.; Keller, S. L. Separation of Liquid Phases in Giant Vesicles of Ternary Mixtures of Phospholipids and Cholesterol. Biophys. J. 2003, 85 (5), 3074–3083. (11) Baumgart, T.; Hammond, A. T.; Sengupta, P.; Hess, S. T.; Holowka, D. A.; Baird, B. A.; Webb, W. W. Large-Scale Fluid/fluid Phase Separation of Proteins and Lipids in Giant Plasma Membrane Vesicles. PNAS 2007, 104 (9), 3165–3170. (12) Machta, B. B.; Papanikolaou, S.; Sethna, J. P.; Veatch, S. L. Minimal Model of Plasma Membrane Heterogeneity Requires Coupling Cortical Actin to Criticality. Biophys. J. 2011, 100 (7), 1668–1677. (13) Swamy, M. J.; Ciani, L.; Ge, M.; Smith, A. K.; Holowka, D.; Baird, B.; Freed, J. H. Coexisting Domains in the Plasma Membranes of Live Cells Characterized by Spin- Label ESR Spectroscopy. Biophys. J. 2006, 90 (12), 4452–4465. (14) Simons, K.; Gerl, M. J. Revitalizing Membrane Rafts: New Tools and Insights. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 2010, 11 (10), 688–699. 29 (15) Holowka, D.; Gosse, J. A.; Hammond, A. T.; Han, X.; Sengupta, P.; Smith, N. L.; Wagenknecht-Wiesner, A.; Wu, M.; Young, R. M.; Baird, B. Lipid Segregation and IgE Receptor Signaling: A Decade of Progress. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 2005, 1746 (3), 252–259. (16) Sezgin, E.; Levental, I.; Mayor, S.; Eggeling, C. The Mystery of Membrane Organization: Composition, Regulation and Roles of Lipid Rafts. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 2017, 18 (6), 361–374. (17) Chini, B.; Parenti, M. G-Protein Coupled Receptors in Lipid Rafts and Caveolae: How, When and Why Do They Go There? J. Mol. Endocrinol. 2004, 32 (2), 325–338. (18) Nussinov, R.; Jang, H.; Tsai, C. J. Oligomerization and Nanocluster Organization Render Specificity. Biol. Rev. 2015, 90 (2), 587–598. (19) Feigenson, G. W. Phase Diagrams and Lipid Domains in Multicomponent Lipid Bilayer Mixtures. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 2009, 1788 (1), 47–52. (20) Konyakhina, T. M.; Feigenson, G. W. Phase Diagram of a Polyunsaturated Lipid Mixture: Brain sphingomyelin/1-Stearoyl-2-Docosahexaenoyl-Sn-Glycero-3- Phosphocholine/cholesterol. Biochim. Biophys. Acta - Biomembr. 2016, 1858 (1), 153– 161. (21) Veatch, S. L.; Cicuta, P.; Sengupta, P.; Honerkamp-Smith, A.; Holowka, D.; Baird, B. Critical Fluctuations in Plasma Membrane Vesicles. ACS Chem. Biol. 2008, 3 (5), 287– 293. (22) Stanich, C. A.; Honerkamp-Smith, A. R.; Putzel, G. G.; Warth, C. S.; Lamprecht, A. K.; Mandal, P.; Mann, E.; Hua, T.-A. D.; Keller, S. L. Coarsening Dynamics of Domains in Lipid Membranes. Biophys. J. 2013, 105 (2), 444–454. (23) Konyakhina, T. M.; Goh, S. L.; Amazon, J.; Heberle, F. A.; Wu, J.; Feigenson, G. W. Control of a Nanoscopic-to-Macroscopic Transition: Modulated Phases in Four- Component DSPC/DOPC/POPC/Chol Giant Unilamellar Vesicles. Biophys. J. 2011, 101 (2), L8–L10. (24) Levental, I.; Veatch, S. L. The Continuing Mystery of Lipid Rafts. J. Mol. Biol. 2016, 428 (24), 4749–4764. (25) Schick, M. Membrane Heterogeneity: Manifestation of a Curvature-Induced Microemulsion. Phys. Rev. E 2012, 85 (3), 031902. (26) Sadeghi, S.; Müller, M.; Vink, R. L. C. Raft Formation in Lipid Bilayers Coupled to Curvature. Biophys. J. 2014, 107 (7), 1591–1600. (27) Amazon, J. J.; Goh, S. L.; Feigenson, G. W. Competition between Line Tension and Curvature Stabilizes Modulated Phase Patterns on the Surface of Giant Unilamellar 30 Vesicles: A Simulation Study. Phys. Rev. E 2013, 87 (2), 22708. (28) Palmieri, B.; Safran, S. A. Hybrid Lipids Increase the Probability of Fluctuating Nanodomains in Mixed Membranes. Langmuir 2013, 29 (17), 5246–5261. (29) Honerkamp-Smith, A. R.; Veatch, S. L.; Keller, S. L. An Introduction to Critical Points for Biophysicists; Observations of Compositional Heterogeneity in Lipid Membranes. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 2009, 1788 (1), 53–63. (30) Blank, U.; Rivera, J. The Ins and Outs of IgE-Dependent Mast-Cell Exocytosis. Trends Immunol. 2004, 25 (5), 266–273. (31) Gilfillan, A. M.; Rivera, J. The Tyrosine Kinase Network Regulating Mast Cell Activation. Immunol. Rev. 2009, 228 (1), 149–169. (32) Rivera, J.; Gilfillan, A. M. Molecular Regulation of Mast Cell Activation. J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 2006, 117 (6), 1214–1225. (33) Holowka, D.; Baird, B. Roles for Lipid Heterogeneity in Immunoreceptor Signaling. Biochim. Biophys. Acta - Mol. Cell Biol. Lipids 2016, 1861 (8, Part B), 830–836. (34) Shelby, S. A.; Veatch, S. L.; Holowka, D. A.; Baird, B. A. Functional Nanoscale Coupling of Lyn Kinase with IgE-FcεRI Is Restricted by the Actin Cytoskeleton in Early Antigen- Stimulated Signaling. Mol. Biol. Cell 2016, 27 (22), 3645–3658. (35) Gompper, G.; Schick, M. Lattice Model of Microemulsions: The Effect of Fluctuations in One and Two Dimensions. Phys. Rev. A 1990, 42 (4), 2137–2149. (36) Gompper, G.; Schick, M. Lattice Model of Microemulsions. Phys. Rev. B 1990, 41 (13), 9148–9162. (37) Blume, M.; Emery, V. J.; Griffiths, R. B. Ising Model for the Λ Transition and Phase Separation in He3-He4 Mixtures. Phys. Rev. A 1971, 4 (3), 1071–1077. (38) Blume, M. Theory of the First-Order Magnetic Phase Change in UO2. Phys. Rev. 1966, 141 (2), 517–524. (39) Capel, H. W. On the Possibility of First-Order Transitions in Ising Systems of Triplet Ions with Zero-Field Splitting. Physica 1966, 32 (5), 966–988. (40) Krizhevsky, A.; Sutskever, I.; Hinton, G. E. ImageNet Classification with Deep Convolutional Neural Networks; Pereira, F., Burges, C. J. C., Bottou, L., Weinberger, K. Q., Eds.; Curran Associates, Inc., 2012. (41) Carrasquilla, J.; Melko, R. G. Machine Learning Phases of Matter. Nat. Phys. 2017, 13 (5), 431–434. (42) Wang, L. Discovering Phase Transitions with Unsupervised Learning. Phys. Rev. B - Condens. Matter Mater. Phys. 2016, 94 (19), 195105. 31 (43) Gompper, G.; Schick, M. Lattice Model of Microemultions. Phys. Rev. B 1990, 41 (13), 9148–9162. (44) Machta, B. B.; Veatch, S. L.; Sethna, J. P. Critical Casimir Forces in Cellular Membranes. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2012, 109 (13), 1–5. (45) Nielsen, M. A. Neural Networks and Deep Learning neuralnetworksanddeeplearning.com (accessed Jan 1, 2017). (46) Bennett, C. H. Efficient Estimation of Free Energy Differences from Monte Carlo Data. J. Comput. Phys. 1976, 22, 245–268. (47) Metropolis, N.; Rosenbluth, A. W.; Rosenbluth, M. N.; Teller, A. H.; Teller, E. Equation of State Calculations by Fast Computing Machines. J. Chem. Phys. 1953, 21 (6), 1087– 1092. (48) Jarzynski, C. Nonequilibrium Equality for Free Energy Differences. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1997, 78 (14), 2690–2693. (49) Beale, P. D. Finite-Size Scaling Study of the Two-Dimensional Blume-Capel Model. Phys. Rev. B 1986, 33 (3), 1717–1720. (50) Cardy, J. Scaling and Renormalization in Statistical Physics; Cambridge University Press: New York, New York, USA, 1996. (51) Palmieri, B.; Grant, M.; Safran, S. A. Prediction of the Dependence of the Line Tension on the Composition of Linactants and the Temperature in Phase Separated Membranes. Langmuir 2014, 30 (39), 11734–11745. (52) Sil, D.; Lee, J. B.; Luo, D.; Holowka, D.; Baird, B. Trivalent Ligands with Rigid DNA Spacers Reveal Structural Requirements for IgE Receptor Signaling in RBL Mast Cells. ACS Chem. Biol. 2007, 2 (10), 674–684. (53) Kusumi, A.; Fujiwara, T. K.; Morone, N.; Yoshida, K. J.; Chadda, R.; Xie, M.; Kasai, R. S.; Suzuki, K. G. N. Membrane Mechanisms for Signal Transduction: The Coupling of the Meso-Scale Raft Domains to Membrane-Skeleton-Induced Compartments and Dynamic Protein Complexes. Semin. Cell Dev. Biol. 2012, 23 (2), 126–144. (54) Honigmann, A.; Sadeghi, S.; Keller, J.; Hell, S. W.; Eggeling, C.; Vink, R. A Lipid Bound Actin Meshwork Organizes Liquid Phase Separation in Model Membranes. eLife 2014, 3, e01671. (55) Nienhuis, B.; Berker, A. N.; Riedel, E. K.; Schick, M. First- and Second-Order Phase Transitions in Potts Models: Renormalization-Group Solution. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1979, 43 (11), 737–740. (56) Pearson, R. B. Conjecture for the Extended Potts Model Magnetic Eigenvalue. Phys. Rev. B 1980, 22 (5), 2579–2580. 32 (57) Nienhuis, B.; Warnaar, S. O.; Blote, H. W. J. Exact Multicritical Behaviour of the Potts Model. J. Phys. A. Math. Gen. 1993, 26 (3), 477. (58) Kwak, W.; Jeong, J.; Lee, J.; Kim, D.-H. First-Order Phase Transition and Tricritical Scaling Behavior of the Blume-Capel Model: A Wang-Landau Sampling Approach. Phys. Rev. E. Stat. Nonlin. Soft Matter Phys. 2015, 92 (2-1), 22134. (59) Sherman, E.; Barr, V.; Samelson, L. E. Super-Resolution Characterization of TCR- Dependent Signaling Clusters. Immunol. Rev. 2013, 251 (1), 21–35. (60) Rao, M.; Mayor, S. Active Organization of Membrane Constituents in Living Cells. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 2014, 29, 126–132. (61) Noble, A. E.; Machta, J.; Hastings, A. Emergent Long-Range Synchronization of Oscillating Ecological Populations without External Forcing Described by Ising Universality. Nat. Commun. 2015, 6, 6664. 33 Supporting Information Figure S1: Training the neural network. (a) Each circle at specified (Δ/J, T/J) coordinates represents a parameter set at which training data were acquired. The color indicates the human-generated classification of the phase at that point. These points are overlaid on the final phase diagram computed by the neural network. (b-c) Phase diagrams generated by two types of neural network. (b) is trained on averages of correlated Monte Carlo snapshots to identify all six phases, while (c) is trained on individual Monte Carlo snapshots to identify four S1 phases. Our final phase diagram is based mostly on (b), but we take the classification of the gray phase from (c) due to its high confidence in that phase. (d) Example simulation images taken near the Fluid / Gray boundary (Fluid at T/J = 1.49 , Δ/J = 6.2 ; Gray at T/J = 1.49 , Δ/J = 6.8), demonstrating the one case in which working with snapshots (phase diagram (c)) is advantageous compared to working with averages (phase diagram (d)). Note that the snapshots shown are easily distinguishable as two different phases, but the averages shown look more similar to each other. S2 Figure S2: Cross-sections of the phase diagram in which H/J=0, K/J=0, and L/J = 1 or 2. Colors have the same meaning as in Figure 3 and Figure S1. S3 Figure S3: Additional cross-sections of the phase diagram at positive H. Colors have the same meaning as in Figure 3 and Figure S1. S4 Figure S4: Free energy change (binding energy) due to moving two white pixels to a spacing of 3 lattice units apart. Simulations were run on a system similar to that shown in Figure 5, but with the box on the left containing, instead of the set cluster of 3 IgE receptors (each represented by 12 pixels), a single fixed white pixel. Each diamond indicates the free energy calculated by Bennett's method at that point in the phase diagram. (a) Binding energy in the Blume-Capel model (H=0, K=0, L=0) cross-section. (b) Inset of (a) in the area of the tricritical point (black box in (a)). Similar to the more complicated case of clustered receptors (Figure 6a-b), the binding energy is considerably higher close to the tricritical point. (c) Binding energy S5 in a cross-section that includes microemulsions (K/J = 2, L/J = 3). Similar to the more complicated case (Figure 6d), certain microemulsions give a positive binding energy. We provide data for this case, which is simpler than that shown in the main text, in the hopes that it will prove useful for future theoretical work related to this model. In particular, we note that it may be possible develop a universal scaling theory to describe the increase in binding energy magnitude as the tricritical point is approached. S6 Figure S5: Alternate method for calculating kinase binding energy. We use the method described in 1. (a-b) Example simulation at the tricritical point, in which the kinase sits at a position 95 nm from the cluster. As in Figure 5, receptors (red) and kinase (green) were held fixed as white, and the rest of the lattice was Monte Carlo sampled. (a) shows one simulation snapshot, and (b) shows the average of all snapshots acquired. The simulation was repeated S7 at every possible kinase position from 0 to 95, stepwise, in order to generate (c), the profile showing the free energy of the kinase in every position. The position axis in (c) corresponds to the axis shown in (a). The free energy at position 3 nm of ~ -1.4 kBT is in good agreement with the computationally cheaper method used in the rest of the study (Figure 6, Figure S4). S8 Figure S6: Detailed analysis of three selected points in the H/J=0, K/J=2, L/J=3 cross- section. (a) Correlation functions between white pixels at the selected points. The 2D correlation functions G are calculated according to the formula G= 1 ρ2 FFT −1(FFT ( A)2) FFT −1(FFT (M )2) where A is a 2D array with value 1 if the σ value at the corresponding pixel of the snapshot is 1 (white pixel), or 0 otherwise, M is an array of all 1's of the same size as A, ρ is the density of S9 white pixels (calculated as the sum of A divided by the sum of M), and FFT represents the fast Fourier transform. A correlation function value greater than 1 indicates positive correlation, 1 indicates no correlation, and less than 1 indicates anticorrelation. The function plotted here is the average transect of G along the horizontal (1,0) and vertical (0,1) directions (used instead of a radial average because G is not always radially symmetric). Correlation functions are averaged over 2000 snapshots of size 200x200 per point. One criterion to define a microemulsion is that this correlation function must have a local minimum, rather than decrease monotonically. By this criterion, T=2.01, Δ=2.0 is not a microemulsion, as the correlation function decreases monotonically. T=1.35, Δ=4.85 is a microemulsion with length scale ~ 10 because the first local minimum occurs at lattice distance 10, and T=1.25, Δ=5.7 is a microemulsion with length scale ~ 4 because the (considerably stronger) first local minimum occurs at lattice distance 4. (b) The analysis using correlation functions gives results consistent with a visual inspection of snapshots at the same three points, which appear as critical fluctuations (left), a long length-scale microemulsion (center), and a short length-scale microemulsion (right). S10 Figure S7: Neural network computation of the Ising model phase diagram. Graphs show the outputs of the neural network corresponding to each phase, indicating the network's level of confidence that the system represents that phase. At each temperature value, the network's prediction is the phase for which the network output is the highest. The true Ising transition temperature is indicated by the dashed line; an accurate network should give "Separated" as the highest output below this temperature, and "Critical" or "Fluid" as the highest output above this temperature. (a) Output of the neural network used in the rest of this study. The predicted transition temperature is close to, but slightly above, the true transition temperature. (b) Output of a neural network specialized for the Ising model only. This network was trained on examples from the Ising model, and only distinguishes between the fluid and phase- separated states. This network's predicted transition temperature almost exactly matches the true transition temperature. S11 Figure S8: Comparison to other methods for calculation of the Blume-Capel phase diagram. The neural network's phase diagram follows the same key as in Figure 2. Overlaid in gray is the phase boundary as determined by finite size scaling in 2. The dashed line represents a critical phase transition, solid represents a first-order transition, and the transition from dashed to solid is the tricritical point. Dotted line in blue is the critical line as determined by mean field theory in 3. S12 Figure S9: Comparing phase diagram results from our study to the original study. Gray overlays are reproduced from the original study.4 Solid lines indicate first order phase transitions, dashed lines indicate critical phase transitions, and dotted lines are Lifshitz lines. S13 Figure S10: Schematic of renormalization group flows and crossover behavior. The operation of coarse-graining leads to flows through the space of possible models (i.e. a space whose different directions correspond to different model parameters), a process formalized by the renormalization group (RG). Fixed points in this model space are models that look the same at all length scales, and correspond to different classes of critical phenomena. (a) gives an example of RG flows in the familiar Ising model. SIsing is the Ising critical fixed point; under coarse-graining, models flow towards it along black lines and away along gray lines. For the Ising model, temperature (vertical, dotted red arrow) is crucial in determining model behavior. Above the critical temperature, Tc, as we coarse-grain our model (RG Flow 1), it flows to a mixed (uniform) fluid state. Below Tc (RG Flow 2), the model flows toward a phase-separated state. Importantly, when the models in either RG Flow 1 or 2 pass near SIsing, they exhibit Ising-like properties, and coarse-graining to length scales of 20 nm is typically sufficient to produce critical behavior. (b) In the presence of more than one critical fixed point, a model's trajectory through RG flows can pass near-and thus be influenced by-the multiple different fixed points. In this schematic, we imagine the trajectory of a membrane model in such a space (gray dashed arrow), where STri and SIsing are the 2D tricritical and 2D Ising critical fixed S14 points (respectively). At T=Tc, where Tc is the Ising critical temperature, the model flows directly to the Ising fixed point. The transition from tricritical-like to Ising-like behavior is referred to as crossover. (c) In the same space as (b), above Tc, our model can flow along a complicated trajectory (red dashed arrow line). Note that here we have included a 3rd dimension-temperature, which acts as in (a). At short length scales (~20 nm), our model is near the tricritical fixed point, and will thus obey tricritical behavior. As we coarse-grain further, our model flows away toward the Ising critical point, so that the behavior of the model at intermediate length scales (~200 nm) is Ising-like. As we coarse-grain even further, the model flows away to some non-critical fixed point. S15 Supporting References (1) Machta, B. B.; Veatch, S. L.; Sethna, J. P. Critical Casimir Forces in Cellular Membranes. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2012, 109 (13), 138101. (2) Beale, P. D. Finite-Size Scaling Study of the Two-Dimensional Blume-Capel Model. Phys. Rev. B 1986, 33 (3), 1717–1720. (3) Blume, M.; Emery, V. J.; Griffiths, R. B. Ising Model for the λ Transition and Phase Separation in He3-He4 Mixtures. Phys. Rev. A 1971, 4 (3), 1071–1077. (4) Gompper, G.; Schick, M. Lattice Model of Microemulsions: The Effect of Fluctuations in One and Two Dimensions. Phys. Rev. A 1990, 42 (4), 2137–2149. S16
1805.12516	5	1805	2019-02-13T16:34:50	Available energy fluxes drive a transition in the diversity, stability, and functional structure of microbial communities	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.stat-mech", "q-bio.PE" ]	A fundamental goal of microbial ecology is to understand what determines the diversity, stability, and structure of microbial ecosystems. The microbial context poses special conceptual challenges because of the strong mutual influences between the microbes and their chemical environment through the consumption and production of metabolites. By analyzing a generalized consumer resource model that explicitly includes cross-feeding, stochastic colonization, and thermodynamics, we show that complex microbial communities generically exhibit a transition as a function of available energy fluxes from a "resource-limited" regime where community structure and stability is shaped by energetic and metabolic considerations to a diverse regime where the dominant force shaping microbial communities is the overlap between species' consumption preferences. These two regimes have distinct species abundance patterns, different functional profiles, and respond differently to environmental perturbations. Our model reproduces large-scale ecological patterns observed across multiple experimental settings such as nestedness and differential beta diversity patterns along energy gradients. We discuss the experimental implications of our results and possible connections with disorder-induced phase transitions in statistical physics.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Available energy fluxes drive a transition in the diversity, stability, and functional structure of microbial communities Robert Marsland III,∗ Wenping Cui,† Joshua Goldford,‡ Alvaro Sanchez,§ Kirill Korolev, and Pankaj Mehta Department of Physics, Boston University, Boston, MA (Dated: February 14, 2019) A fundamental goal of microbial ecology is to understand what determines the diversity, sta- bility, and structure of microbial ecosystems. The microbial context poses special conceptual chal- lenges because of the strong mutual influences between the microbes and their chemical environment through the consumption and production of metabolites. By analyzing a generalized consumer re- source model that explicitly includes cross-feeding, stochastic colonization, and thermodynamics, we show that complex microbial communities generically exhibit a transition as a function of available energy fluxes from a "resource-limited" regime where community structure and stability is shaped by energetic and metabolic considerations to a diverse regime where the dominant force shaping microbial communities is the overlap between species' consumption preferences. These two regimes have distinct species abundance patterns, different functional profiles, and respond differently to environmental perturbations. Our model reproduces large-scale ecological patterns observed across multiple experimental settings such as nestedness and differential beta diversity patterns along en- ergy gradients. We discuss the experimental implications of our results and possible connections with disorder-induced phase transitions in statistical physics. INTRODUCTION Microbial communities inhabit every corner of our planet, from our own nutrient-rich guts to the remote depths of the ocean floor. Different environments har- bor very different levels of microbial diversity: in some samples of non-saline water at mild temperature and pH, nearly 3,000 coexisting types of bacteria can be detected, whereas at ambient temperatures warmer than 40◦ C, most cataloged samples contain fewer than 100 distinct variants [49]. The functional structure of these commu- nities is also highly variable, with functional traits often reflecting the environment in which the communities are found [27, 49]. A central goal of microbial community ecology is to understand how these variations in diver- sity, stability and functional structure [55] arise from an interplay of environmental factors such as energy and re- source availability [15, 34] and ecological processes such as competition [10, 21, 32, 35] and stochastic colonization [9, 28, 30, 53]. This endeavor is complicated by the fact that microbes dramatically modify their abiotic environments through consumption and secretion of organic and inorganic com- pounds. This happens on a global scale, as in the Great Oxidation Event two billion years ago [5, 45], and also on smaller scales relevant to agriculture, industry and medicine. In this sense, every microbe is an "ecosys- tem engineer" [29]. Metabolic modeling and experiments suggests that metabolically-mediated syntrophic interac- tions should be a generic feature of microbial ecology ∗ [email protected] † Department of Physics, Boston College, Chestnut Hill, MA ‡ Bioinformatics Program, Boston University, Boston, MA § Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Yale Univer- sity, New Haven, CT [23, 26, 58] and that complex microbial communities can self-organize even in constant environments with no spa- tial structure or predation [19, 23]. For these reasons, there has been significant interest in developing new mod- els for community assembly suited to the microbial set- ting [8, 24, 25, 48, 51]. Here, we present a statistical physics-inspired con- sumer resource model for microbial community assembly that builds upon the simple model introduced in [23] and explicitly includes energetic fluxes, stochastic coloniza- tion, syntrophy, and resource competition. We focus on modeling complex communities with many species and metabolites. By necessity, any mathematical model of such a large, diverse ecosystem will contain thousands of parameters that are hard to measure. To circumvent this problem, we take a statistical physics approach where all consumer preferences and metabolic parameters are drawn from random distributions. This approach to modeling complex systems has its root in the pioneering work of Wigner on the spectrum of heavy nuclei [56] and was adapted by May to ecological settings [37]. Recently, there has been a renewed inter- est in using these ideas to understand complex systems in both many-body physics (reviewed in [11]) and com- munity assembly [1, 4, 6, 7, 13, 18, 22, 23, 30, 51]. The key insight underlying this approach is that generic and reproducible large-scale patterns observed across multi- ple settings likely reflect typical properties, rather than fine tuned features of any particular realization or com- munity. Consistent with this idea, it was recently shown that a generalized consumer resource model with random parameters can reproduce many of the patterns observed in experiments where natural communities were grown in synthetic minimal environments [23]. In this paper, we ask how varying the energy flux into an ecosystem and the amount of cross-feeding af- fects microbial community assembly. We find that the 9 1 0 2 b e F 3 1 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 5 v 6 1 5 2 1 . 5 0 8 1 : v i X r a 2 FIG. 1. Microbial communities engineer complex chemical environments using a single energy source. (A) Schematic of microbe-mediated energy fluxes in the Thermodynamic Microbial Consumer Resource Model. Each cell of species i (= 1, 2, . . . S) supplies itself with energy through import of resources, generating an incoming energy flux J in iα for each resource type α (= 1, 2, . . . M ). A fraction lα of this energy leaks back into the environment in the form of metabolic byproducts, with each byproduct type carrying an outgoing energy flux J out , is used to replicate the cell. (B) Each species is defined by a vector of consumer preferences that encode its capacity for harvesting energy from each resource type. These vectors comprise a consumer matrix ciα. (C) A regional pool of species is randomly generated, and communities are initialized with random subsets of these species to simulate stochastic colonization. (D) Each community is supplied with a constant flux κ0 of a single resource type (α = 0), and all resources are continuously diluted at a fixed rate −1 τ R . (E) Consumer populations Ni and resource concentrations Rα as a function of time for two realizations of this model, with low (l = 0.001) and high (l = 0.8) levels of uniform metabolic leakage (see Appendix B for parameters). iα. The remaining energy, J grow iβ =(cid:80) α lαDβαJ in i resulting communities generically fall into two distinct regimes, characterized by qualitative differences in their community-level metabolic networks, functional struc- tures, responses to environmental perturbations, and large-scale biodiversity patterns. We show our model pre- dictions are consistent with data from the Tara Oceans database [47] and the Earth Microbiome Project [49], and propose feasible experimental tests using synthetic com- munities. METHODS The starting point for our analysis is a new model that adapts MacArthur's Consumer Resource Model [35] to the microbial context by including energetics, stochas- tic colonization, and the exchange and consumption of metabolites. We consider the population dynamics of S species of consumers (e.g., microbes) competing for M types of substitutable resources. We are interested in large, diverse ecosystems where S, M (cid:29) 1. A schematic summarizing our model is shown in Figure 1. A natural setting for considering substitutable re- sources is when all essential biomass components are sup- plied in excess, and the limiting factor for growth is the supply of usable energy. In this context, one only needs to keep track of resources from which energy can be har- vested. All other nutrients are included implicitly, under the assumption that some of the energy budget is used to import whatever materials are required for growth and reproduction. Terminal waste products from which no more energy can be extracted are likewise treated implic- itly, and are not included among the M resource types. In our model, the rate at which an individual of species i harvests energy from resource α depends on the resource concentration Rα as well as on the consumer's vector of resource preferences ciα through the expression: J in iα = wασ(ciαRα), (1) where σ(x) encodes the functional response and has units of mass/time, while wα is the energy density of resource α with units of energy/mass. In the microbial context the consumer preferences ciα can be interpreted as expression levels of transporters for each of the resources. In the main text, we focus on Type-I responses where σ(x) = x, and we set wα = 1 for all α, but most of our results still hold when σ(x) is a Monod function or the wα are randomly sampled, as shown in the SI Appendix. We model leakage and secretion by letting a fraction lα of this imported energy return to the environment, so that the power available to the cell for sustaining growth is equal to (cid:88) α J grow i = (1 − lα)J in iα. (2) This parameterization guarantees that the community does not spontaneously generate usable energy in viola- tion of the Second Law of Thermodynamics. We assume that a fixed quantity mi of power per cell is required for maintenance of a steady population of species i, and that the per-capita growth rate is proportional to the re- maining energy flux, with proportionality constant gi. In (B)(C)(A)Low LeakageHigh LeakageJgrowiJini↵JoutiRegional Pool{Ni},{R↵}⌧1R(D)(E)D↵Local Communities(l=0.001)(l=0.8)Resource Conc. R𝛼Consumer Pop. Nitypical experimental conditions, cell death is negligible, and mi is the energy harvest required for the replication rate to keep up with the dilution rate. Under these as- sumptions, the time-evolution of the population size Ni of species i can be modeled using the equation (3) dNi dt = giNi [J grow i i = (cid:80) − mi] . α lαJ in The leaked energy flux J out iα from each cell of species i is partitioned among the M possible resource types via the biochemical pathways operating within the cell. We assume that all species share a similar core metabolism, encoded in a matrix Dβα. Each element of Dβα specifies the fraction of leaked energy from re- source α that is released in the form of resource β (note β Dβα = 1). Thus, in our model the resources that are excreted into the environment are intimately coupled to the resources a cell is consuming. The outgoing energy flux contained in metabolite β is given by that by definition, (cid:80) J out iβ = wβνout iβ = DβαlαJ in iα. (4) (cid:88) α (cid:88) j The dynamics of the resource concentrations depend on the incoming and outgoing mass fluxes νin iα = σ(ciαRα) and νout iα , which are related to the energy fluxes via the energy densities wα. In terms of these quantities, we have dRα dt = hα + Nj(νout jα − νin jα), (5) with hα encoding the dynamics of externally supplied resources. In this manuscript, we focus on the case where the microbial communities are grown in a chemostat with a single externally supplied resource α = 0 (Figure 1). In this case, the resource dynamics can be described by choosing hα = κα − τ−1 R Rα, with all the κα set to zero except for κ0. These equations for Ni and Rα, along with the expressions for J in iα and J out iα , completely specify the ecological dynamics of the model. This model has been implemented in a freely available open-source Python package "Community Simula- tor." The package can be downloaded from https: //github.com/Emergent-Behaviors-in-Biology/ community-simulator. RESULTS To assess the typical community structure and resource pool stability for ecosystems obeying Equations (1)-(5), we randomly generated an M×M metabolic matrix Dαβ, and a binary S× M consumer preference matrix ciα with S = 200 species and M = 100 resources. Realizations of the randomly drawn metabolic and consumer preference matrices are shown in Figure 3 (top) and Figure 5 (left), respectively. 3 We chose ciα so that each species had 10 preferred re- source types on average, with ciα = 1, while the rest of the resources were consumed at a baseline level of ciα = 0.01. The metabolic matrix Dαβ was sampled from a Dirichlet distribution, which guarantees that all the columns sum to 1 as required by the definition of this parameter. In Appendix C, we show that the qualitative patterns we observe are unchanged if ciα is drawn from a Gaussian or Gamma distribution, or if the Dαβ matrix is made less sparse. The full sampling procedure is detailed in Appendix A. We chose our units of energy flux such that the mean maintenance cost mi over all species in the regional pool is equal to 1. To break ties between species with simi- lar consumption profiles, we added a Gaussian random offset to the mi of each species with standard deviation 0.1. In Figure 19 of the Appendices, we show that these intrinsic fitness differences do not dominate the ecologi- cal dynamics, and that many species with relatively high maintenance costs are able to reach large population sizes in the steady-state communities. Finally, we set all the wα equal to 1, and made all the leakage fractions identical, with lα = l for all α. To assess the amount of variability in the results, we initialized 10 different communities by seeding each one with a random subset of 100 species from the full 200- species pool. This simulates the stochastic colonization frequently observed in microbial ecosystems, where the community composition can randomly vary depending on the set of microbes this particular local environment happened to be exposed to [41]. Figure 1 shows typical dynamical trajectories in the presence of high (l = 0.8) and extremely low leakage (l = 0.001). Available energy fluxes drive a transition between a "resource-limited" and "diverse" regime Our numerical simulations display a transition between two qualitatively different community structures as we vary the externally supplied energy flux w0κ0 and the leakage/syntrophy l. In the "thermodynamic limit" of M, S → ∞, the communities exhibit signatures of a phase transition analogous to those found in disordered systems in physics (see Discussion and Appendix D). Fig- ure 2 shows the effect of this transition on community diversity at our chosen finite values of S and M . At low levels of energy flux or syntrophy, the diversity is severely limited by resource availability. In the limit of high sup- plied energy flux and high leakage, a maximally diverse regime is obtained, where the number of surviving species is limited only by the similarity between consumption profiles within the regional species pool, in accordance with classical niche-packing theory [35] as we will discuss below. 4 The resource-limited regime produces a unidirectional flow of energy, which is converted from the externally supplied resource type into an orderly succession of se- creted resources. For the sparse metabolic matrix shown in the top row of Figure 3, most resource types also have extremely small incoming flux vectors in this regime, with magnitudes less than 1% the size of the largest flux in the network. The diverse regime displays a qualitatively dif- ferent structure, where all resources have significant in- coming fluxes (regardless of the choice of Dαβ), and the large number of loops in the network makes it impossible to put the resource types into any definite order. In Ap- pendix Figure 17, we plot the fraction of samples from Figure 2 whose (pruned) flux networks are free of cycles, and confirm that this observation is generic. The dra- matic contrast between the community-level metabolism of the two regimes affects many other global features of the ecosystem, which we will explore in the following sec- tions. The two regimes have distinct functional structures To better understand the behavior of consumers in the two regimes, we examined the functional traits of mem- bers of typical communities in each one. In the resource- limited regime, many surviving species derive most of their energy directly from the externally supplied re- source (Figure 4A). In the diverse regime, by contrast, only a minority of the steady-state community mem- bers can consume this resource at all, and even these species receive most of their energy from a diverse ar- ray of metabolic byproducts (Figure 4B). We quantified this observation using the Simpson Diversity M eff of the incoming resource flux vectors J in iα, which measures the effective number of resources consumed by each species, and is closely related to the inverse participation ratio in statistical physics. The Simpson Diversity is defined by i (cid:19)2(cid:35)−1 (cid:34)(cid:88) α (cid:18) J in iα J in i M eff i = , (7) i =(cid:80) i α J in where J in iα is the total incoming energy flux for each cell of this species. M eff approaches 1 for species that obtain the bulk of their energy from a single re- source type and approaches M when all resource types are consumed equally. In the resource-limited regime, the distribution of these values is sharply peaked around 2. In the diverse regime, the peak is located around 10, which is the average number of resources with high trans- porter expression in our binary sampling scheme for ciα. This shows that most community members in the diverse regime utilize multiple energy sources, with the incom- ing flux spread evenly over all resource types they are capable of consuming. FIG. 2. Steady-state richness as a function of metabolic leakage l and externally supplied energy flux w0κ0. We generated 200 species, initialized 10 com- munities of 100 species each from this pool, and ran the dy- namics to steady state under different combinations of w0κ0 and l (see main text and Appendix B for parameters). (A) Heat map summarizing all simulations, colored by the av- erage number of surviving species per steady-state commu- nity ("Richness"). Slices through the heat map are plotted in Figure 10 following the Appendices. (B) Community com- positions are displayed as rank-abundance curves for three illustrative w0κ0, l combinations (colored by community rich- ness): (1) "syntrophy-limited" (w0κ0 = 1000, l = 0.1), (2) "energy-limited" (w0κ0 = 28, l = 0.6) and (3) "similarity- limited" (w0κ0 = 1000, l = 0.9). The lines are assigned differ- ent shades for clarity. The first two examples are parts of the same resource-limited regime, manifesting similar statistical properties. The plots are truncated at a relative abundance of 0.5%; see Figure 11 following the Appendices for full data. The resource-limited and diverse regimes produce different patterns of energy flux The difference between the two regimes is most appar- ent from the perspective of the energy flux networks. Be- cause our model explicitly accounts for the flow of energy from one resource type into another, we can compute all the steady-state fluxes and represent them graphically, as shown in Figure 3 for some representative examples. Each node in this network is a resource type, and each directed edge represents the steady-state flux Jβα of en- ergy conversion from resource α to resource β, mediated by one or more syntrophic consumers: (cid:88) (cid:88) Jβα = NiJ out iβα = Dβαlα NiwαciαRα. (6) i i Resource-Limited RegimeDiverse Regime(B)123(A)5 FIG. 3. Energy flux networks differ in the two regimes. Community-scale energy flux networks are plotted for a characteristic example from the diverse and resource limited regimes and two different choices of metabolic matrix Dαβ. The color of each pixel in the heat maps indicates the logarithm (base 10) of the corresponding matrix entry. In the networks, each node represents one of the M = 100 resource types. Edges represent steady-state energy flux from one resource type into another, mediated by consumer metabolism and leakage/secretion. The thickness of each edge is proportional to the flux magnitude, and edges with magnitudes less than 1% of the maximum flux are not displayed. The single node at the top of each graph is the externally supplied resource, and the rows of nodes at the bottom are resources that are not connected to the external supply by any flux above the 1% threshold. A topological analysis of the flux networks of all the simulated communities can be found in Figure 17 of the Appendices. Responses to resource perturbations differ in the two regimes Another important property of microbial ecosystems is how they respond to environmental perturbations. Pre- vious theoretical studies have shown that sufficiently di- verse communities can "pin" the resource concentrations in their local environment to fixed values, which are in- dependent of the magnitude of externally supplied fluxes [44, 48, 50]. In these studies, resource pinning occurs only when the community saturates the diversity bound imposed by the principal of competitive exclusion, i.e. when the number of coexisting species is at least as large as the number of resource types. Such maximally diverse communities typically require fine-tuning of the resource utilization profiles or imposition of universal efficiency tradeoffs in cellular metabolism. In our stochastically assembled communities, the di- versity is always much lower than the number of re- source types, so we hypothesized that the resource con- centrations should not be pinned. To test this idea, we measured the response of the steady-state concentrations ¯Rα to changes in external supply rates κα, in terms of the "resource susceptibilities" ∂ ¯Rα/∂κα plotted in Fig- ure 4D [1]. Our hypothesis was valid in the resource- limited regime, where many resource susceptibilities are comparable to the susceptibility in the empty chemostat ∂ ¯Rα/∂κα = τR = 1. But in the diverse regime, we were surprised to find that the susceptibilities are 100 times smaller than this maximum value. This suggests that re- 6 FIG. 5. Richness of diverse regime depends on gen- eralized niche-overlap. We took the values of supplied energy flux w0κ0 and leakage fraction l from the three ex- amples highlighted in Figure 2, and varied the average niche overlap (cid:104)ρij(cid:105) between members of the metacommunity. For each w0κ0, l combination and each value of (cid:104)ρij(cid:105), we gener- ated 10 pools of 200 species, initialized 10 communities of 100 species each from this pool, and ran the dynamics to steady state. The steady-state richness of each community is plotted against the niche overlap. Points are colored by their regime (diverse or resource-limited), and solid lines are linear regres- sions. Inset: ciα matrices that define the regional pool for two different levels of overlap, with dark squares representing high consumption coefficients. regional pool is given by: (cid:104)ρij(cid:105) ≡ (cid:42) (cid:80) (cid:113)(cid:80) (cid:80) α ciαcjα α c2 iα (cid:43) (cid:113) = (cid:104)ciα(cid:105)2 (cid:104)c2 iα(cid:105)(cid:104)c2 jα(cid:105) . (8) α c2 jα Figure 5 shows how the richness varies as a function of (cid:104)ρij(cid:105). In the diverse regime the mean richness decreases approximately linearly with increasing overlap. The rich- ness of the resource-limited regime, on the other hand, has only a very weak dependence on the niche overlap. These results suggest that the distribution of consump- tion preferences in the regional pool is the primary driver of community assembly in the diverse regime. Impor- tantly, non-zero niche overlap limits the number of co- existing species well below the upper bound imposed by the competitive exclusion principle. FIG. 4. Structure and stability of resource dynam- ics depend on ecological regime. (A) Consumed energy fluxes (1 − l)J in iα for each of the ten surviving species in a resource-limited community (example 2 from Figure 2). The black portion of the bar is the flux (1 − l)J in i0 due to the ex- ternally supplied resource, and the colored bars represent the contributions of the other resources. Since these communities have reached the steady state, Equation (3) implies that the total height of each bar equals the maintenance cost mi of the corresponding consumer species. (B) Same as previous panel, but for a community from the diverse regime (example 3 from Figure 2). (C) Simpson diversity M eff i of steady-state flux vec- tor J in iα for each species from examples 2 (resource-limited) and 3 (diverse) in Figure 2. Vertical lines indicate the values of this metric when all the flux is concentrated on a single resource ("Specialist"), and where it is evenly spread over ten resource types ("Generalist"). (D) Logarithm of susceptibil- ity log10 ∂ ¯Rα/∂κα of community-supplied resources (α (cid:54)= 0) to addition of an externally supplied flux κα in these two ex- amples. source pinning may be a generic phenomenon, observable in real ecosystems when the energy supply is sufficiently large. Niche overlap limits richness in diverse regime In the diverse regime, the number of coexisting species ("richness") is not limited by energy availability or by access to secreted metabolites, but is still much less than the maximal value of M = 100 set by the competitive ex- clusion principle [32], even though almost all M resource types are present at non-negligible levels (as shown in Appendix Figure 18). We hypothesized that the diver- sity in this regime is limited by the degree of similarity between consumption preferences of members of the re- gional species pool. This can be quantified in terms of the niche overlap [10, 36], whose average value in a large Nestedness and other large-scale beta-diversity patterns Our aim in developing this model is to identify and un- derstand generic patterns in community structure, that are independent of particular biological details. In large- scale surveys of natural communities, subject to many sources of noise and environmental heterogeneity, one expects that only sufficiently generic patterns will be de- tectable. The simplest observable to examine in such survey data is the list of species that are present or ab- sent in each sample. We obtained these presence/absence (A)(B)(C)(D).7 only allow a few species from the regional pool to rise to dominance, and that these dominant species induce clus- tering of communities. Such "enterotype"-like behavior is a common feature observed in many microbial settings [3]. In contrast, the diverse regime exhibited neither well- defined clusters nor dominant, highly abundant species. Comparison to microbial datasets The preceding results suggest that the resource-limited and diverse regimes can be distinguished using beta- diversity patterns. Rigorous testing of this prediction is beyond the scope of the present work. But as an il- lustration of the kind of data we hope to explain, we examined the natural gradient of solar energy supply in the Tara Oceans survey, which collected microbial com- munity samples from a range of depths across the world's oceans [47]. Explicitly including light as an energy source would require some modification to the structure of the model equations, but we expect that the large-scale fea- tures of sufficiently diverse ecosystems should not be sen- sitive to changes involving just one resource. We ana- lyzed the 16S OTU composition of tropical ocean com- munities for all 30 sea-surface samples, where solar en- ergy is plentiful, and all 13 samples from the deep-sea Mesopelagic Zone where energy fluxes are limited. We projected these composition vectors onto their first two principal components as in Figure 6 above, and plot the results in Figure 7. The sea surface data superficially resembles our diverse regime, with a relatively uniform distribution of possible community compositions. In con- trast, the Mesopelagic Zone is similar to our resource- limited regime: the dominance of the most abundant species is much more pronounced, and the compositions appear to cluster into four discrete types. While these results are consistent with our model predictions, the number of samples at each depth is still too small to draw any definitive conclusions about clustering. As mentioned above, our model also gives a natural explana- tion for the nestedness in the Earth Microbiome Project community composition data [49], suggesting that it may be a natural byproduct of complex microbial communi- ties shaped by competition, environmental heterogeneity, and stochastic colonization. To test how generic this fea- ture is, we plotted presence/absence community compo- sitions of all samples from the Tara Oceans dataset, sort- ing samples by richness and OTU's ("species") by preva- lence. Each sample contains thousands of low-abundance OTU's, which can obscure ecological patterns through their susceptibility to sequencing noise and transient im- migration. We therefore imposed a 0.5% relative abun- dance threshold for an OTU to count as "present." The resulting pattern in Figure 7 is qualitatively similar to our simulations (Fig. 6D), and to the phylum-level data of the Earth Microbiome Project [49], with the region below the diagonal significantly less populated than the region above the diagonal. In Appendix C 5 and the ac- FIG. 6. Resource-limited regime features community- level environmental filtering. (A) Presence (black) or ab- sence (white) of all species in all 1,000 communities from the original simulations of Figure 2. (B, C, D) We initialized 200 new communities for each of the three examples highlighted in Figure 2A, by randomly choosing sets of 100 species from the regional pool. Each panel shows the projection of final community compositions {Ni} onto the first two principal components of the set of compositions. vectors from the simulations of Figure 2, and found that when we sorted species by prevalence (rows in Fig. 6A) and samples by richness (columns in Fig. 6A), the com- munity composition generically exhibited a nested struc- ture -- less diverse communities had a subset of the species prevalent in the more diverse communities [33, 42]. We quantified this result using an established nestedness metric, as described below in Appendix C 5, and found that the actual nestedness exceeds the mean value for a randomized null model by more than 100 standard devi- ations. This suggests that nested structures may gener- ically emerge in community assembly through the inter- play of stochastic colonization, competition, and environ- mental filtering. Next, we asked if we large-scale beta-diversity pat- terns could be used to distinguish the resource-limited and diverse regimes. We initialized 200 new communi- ties with 100 randomly chosen members from the full regional species pool and simulated these communities to steady state in both the resource-limited and diverse regimes (see Appendix B for details). This sub-sampling of the full regional species pools mimics the effect of stochastic colonization, where a different random sub- set of species seeds each community. To better under- stand beta-diversity signatures in the two regimes, we performed a Principal Component Analysis (PCA) on community composition and projected the data onto the first two principal components, as shown in Figure 6B- D. In the resource-limited regime, the communities form distinct clusters that are distinguished by different highly abundant species. This suggests that harsh environments (A)(B)(C)(D)8 strongly constrained by species- and community-level en- vironmental filtering. Each community is dominated by a handful of species, making the community properties sen- sitive to the idiosyncratic characteristics of these species and susceptible to environmental fluctuations. In the di- verse phase, communities exhibit more universal features because they substantially engineer their environments. In particular, the concentrations of resources at steady state are more narrowly distributed and insensitive to perturbations in the external supply rates. Moreover, each species draws its energy roughly equally from all re- sources, rather than subsisting on the externally supplied resource as in the resource-limited phase. The emergence of environmental engineering from this community-scale model makes it a valuable tool for test- ing and refining existing conceptual frameworks em- ployed by empirical biologists [46]. A major limitation of the dominant paradigms for evolution and ecology from the last century is the implicit assumption of a con- stant environment [14]. The generalized Lotka-Volterra model, for example, remains a standard lens for reason- ing about ecological dynamics, both quantitatively and qualitatively [17, 20, 54]. It assumes that the dynam- ics emerge from the sum of pairwise interactions among species, and that the sign and strength of these interac- tions are intrinsic properties of the species. This can be a good assumption in some circumstances [20, 54], but fails to accurately describe the behavior of simple models that explicitly account for the state of the environment [39]. Our work provides a starting point for determining the conditions under which pairwise models will generi- cally succeed or fail in describing the behavior of large ecosystems. Our model complements other recent efforts at under- standing microbial community ecology. Taillefumier et al. proposed a similar model of metabolite exchange, and focused on the case where the number of resource types M is equal to 3 [48]. In this case, repeated inva- sion attempts from a large regional species pool produced optimal combinations of metabolic strategies. Goyal et al. examined the opposite limit, with M = 5, 000, but allowed each species to consume only one type of re- source [25]. This generated communities with a tree-like metabolic structure, where each species depends directly on another species to generate its unique food source. In our model, the large number of resource types (M = 100 in the current study) makes spontaneous strategy opti- mization extremely unlikely. And our generic protocol for sampling the metabolic matrix Dαβ allows a variety of community-level energy flux topologies to emerge, as illustrated in Figure 3, which can sometimes be quite different from the tree networks of Goyal et al.. The absence of highly specialized metabolic structure in our model makes it especially well-suited for interpreting pat- terns in large-scale sequence-based datasets such as the Earth Microbiome Project [49]. Our model predictions can also be directly tested using experiments with natural communities in synthetic lab- Ecological regimes and nestedness in mi- FIG. 7. (A) 16S OTU compositions of tropical crobiome data. mesopelagic zone samples from the Tara Oceans database, collected at a depth of 200 to 1,000 meters [47]. Each dot is the projection of one sample onto the first two principal com- ponents of the collection of mesopelagic zone samples. (B) Same as A, but for tropical surface water layer samples, col- lected at a depth of 5 meters. (C) Presence (black) or absence (white) of each OTU above 0.5% relative abundance across all Tara Oceans samples. companying Figure 14, we quantify the nestedness us- ing the same metric employed in the Earth Microbiome Project analysis [2, 49], and show that the score is signif- icantly higher than the mean scores from two standard null models. DISCUSSION Advances in sequencing technology have opened new horizons for the study of microbial ecology, generating massive amounts of data on the composition of both nat- ural and synthetic communities. But the complexity of these systems make it difficult to extract robust general principles suitable for guiding medical and industrial ap- plications. Numerical simulations provide a powerful tool for addressing this problem. By rapidly iterating numer- ical experiments under a variety of modeling choices with random parameters, one can identify robust patterns and use the resulting insights to guide targeted experiments. Following this strategy, we developed a thermody- namic consumer resource model that explicitly includes energetic fluxes and metabolically-mediated cross-feeding and competition. Using this model, we identified two qualitatively distinct phases in these simulations as we varied the amount of energy supplied to ecosystem and the fraction of energy leaked back into the environment: a low diversity "resource-limited" phase and a "diverse" phase. The structure of the resource-limited phase is (A)(C)(B)9 oratory environments [12, 23]. Our model predicts that beta-diversity patterns and community-level metabolic networks can be significantly altered by increasing the ecosystem's energy supply, inducing a transition from the resource-limited to the diverse regime. In the experimen- tal set-up of [12], this can be done by directly adding chitinase enzymes to the sludge reactor to increase the degradation of chitin-based organic particles on which the ocean-derived microbial communities subsist. One could then look for shifts in the resulting diversity pat- terns, and observe any changes in the topology of the metabolic flux network using isotope labeling. In this work we have largely confined ourselves to studying steady-state properties of well-mixed microbial communities. Microbial communities often exhibit com- plex temporal dynamics with well-defined successions [12, 16, 57]. It will be interesting to explore these dynami- cal phenomena using our model. It is also well established that spatial structure can give rise to new ecological phe- nomena [31, 38] and an important area of future work will be to better explore the role of space in microbial community assembly. Finally, we have obtained strong numerical evidence that the two regimes are separated by a phase transition, which is likely closely related to disorder-induced phase transitions in statistical physics [6]. In Appendix D, we examine the steady-state richness in the three examples of Figure 2 under increasing values of M from M = 40 to M = 560. We find that the richness is proportional to M in the diverse regime, but scales sub-linearly with M in both examples from the resource-limited regime. In the M → ∞ limit, therefore, we expect to find a sharp line between the regimes, with the ratio of the richness to M vanishing on the resource-limited side. But we do not yet know the exact location of this boundary, or the critical exponents describing the behavior of the system near the transition. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The funding for this work partly results from a Scialog Program sponsored jointly by Research Corporation for Science Advancement (RCSA) and the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation. This work was also supported by NIH NIGMS grant 1R35GM119461, by a Cottrell Scholar award from RCSA to KK, and by Simons Investigator in the Mathematical Modeling of Living Systems (MMLS) awards to PM and KK. The authors are pleased to ac- knowledge that the computational work reported on in this paper was performed on the Shared Computing Clus- ter which is administered by Boston Universitys Research Computing Services. [1] Madhu Advani, Guy Bunin, and Pankaj Mehta. Statis- tical physics of community ecology: a cavity solution to MacArthur's consumer resource model. Journal of Sta- tistical Mechanics, page 033406, 2018. [2] M´ario Almeida-Neto, Paulo Guimaraes, Paulo R Guimaraes Jr, Rafael D Loyola, and Werner Ulrich. A consistent metric for nestedness analysis in ecological systems: reconciling concept and measurement. Oikos, 117(8):1227, 2008. [3] Manimozhiyan Arumugam, Jeroen Raes, Eric Pelletier, Denis Le Paslier, Takuji Yamada, Daniel R Mende, Gabriel R Fernandes, Julien Tap, Thomas Bruls, Jean- Michel Batto, et al. Enterotypes of the human gut mi- crobiome. Nature, 473:174, 2011. [4] Matthieu Barbier, Jean-Fran¸cois Arnoldi, Guy Bunin, and Michel Loreau. Generic assembly patterns in com- plex ecological communities. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2018. [5] A. Bekker, H. D. Holland, P.-L. Wang, D. Rumble III, H. J. Stein, J. L. Hannah, L. L. Coetzee, and N. J. Beukes. Dating the rise of atmospheric oxygen. Nature, 427:117, 2004. [6] Giulio Biroli, Guy Bunin, and C. Cammarota. Marginally stable equilibria in critical ecosystems. New Journal of Physics, 20:083051, 2018. [7] G. Bunin. Ecological communities with Lotka-Volterra dynamics. Physical Review E, 95:042414, 2017. [8] Stacey Butler and James O'Dwyer. Stability criteria for complex microbial communities. bioRxiv, 2018. [9] Jonathan M Chase. Community assembly: when should history matter? Oecologia, 136:489, 2003. [10] Peter Chesson. Macarthur's consumer-resource model. Theoretical Population Biology, 37:26, 1990. [11] Luca D'Alessio, Yariv Kafri, Anatoli Polkovnikov, and Marcos Rigol. From quantum chaos and eigenstate ther- malization to statistical mechanics and thermodynamics. Advances in Physics, 65:239, 2016. [12] Manoshi S. Datta, Elzbieta Sliwerska, Jeff Gore, Mar- tin F. Polz, and Otto X. Cordero. Microbial interactions lead to rapid micro-scale successions on model marine particles. Nature Communications, 7:11965, 2016. [13] Benjamin Dickens, Charles K. Fisher, and Pankaj Mehta. Analytically tractable model for community ecology with many species. Physical Review E, 94:022423, 2016. [14] Michael Doebeli, Yaroslav Ispolatov, and Burt Simon. Point of view: Towards a mechanistic foundation of evo- lutionary theory. Elife, 6:e23804, 2017. [15] Mallory Embree, Joanne K Liu, Mahmoud M Al- Bassam, and Karsten Zengler. Networks of energetic and metabolic interactions define dynamics in microbial communities. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 112:15450, 2015. [16] Tim N. Enke, Gabriel E. Leventhal, Matthew Metzger, Jos´e T. Saavedra, and Otto X. Cordero. Micro-scale ecology regulates particulate organic matter turnover in model marine microbial communities. bioRxiv, 2018. [17] Farnoush Farahpour, Mohammadkarim Saeedghalati, Verena S Brauer, and Daniel Hoffmann. Trade-off shapes diversity in eco-evolutionary dynamics. eLife, 7:e36273, 2018. [18] Charles K. Fisher and Pankaj Mehta. The transition between the niche and neutral regimes in ecology. PNAS, 111:13111, 2014. [19] Jonathan Friedman, Logan M. Higgins, and Jeff Gore. Community structure follows simple assembly rules in microbial microcosms. Nature Ecology and Evolution, 1:0109, 2017. [20] Jonathan Friedman, Logan M Higgins, and Jeff Gore. Community structure follows simple assembly rules in microbial microcosms. Nature ecology & evolution, 1:0109, 2017. [21] G. F. Gause and A. A. Witt. Behavior of mixed popula- tions and the problem of natural selection. The American Naturalist, 69:596, 1935. [22] Theo Gibbs, Jacopo Grilli, Tim Rogers, and Stefano Allesina. The effect of population abundances on the stability of large random ecosystems. arXiv, 1708.08837, 2017. [23] Joshua E. Goldford, Nanxi Lu, Djordje Baji´c, Sylvie Estrela, Mikhail Tikhonov, Alicia Sanchez-Gorostiaga, Daniel Segr`e, Pankaj Mehta, and Alvaro Sanchez. Emer- gent simplicity in microbial community assembly. Sci- ence, 361:469, 2018. [24] Benjamin H. Good, Stephen Martis, and Oskar Hal- latschek. Directional selection limits ecological diversifi- cation and promotes ecological tinkering during the com- petition for substitutable resources. bioRxiv, 2018. [25] Akshit Goyal and Sergei Maslov. Diversity, stability, and reproducibility in stochastically assembled microbial ecosystems. Physical Review Letters, 120:158102, 2018. [26] William R. Harcombe, William J. Riehl, Ilija Dukovski, Brian R. Granger, Alex Betts, Alex H. Lang, Gracia Bonilla, Amrita Kar, Nicholas Leiby, Pankaj Mehta, Christopher J. Marx, and Daniel Segr`e. Metabolic resource allocation in individual microbes determines ecosystem interactions and spatial dynamics. Cell Re- ports, 7:1104, 2014. [27] Curtis Huttenhower, Dirk Gevers, Rob Knight, Sa- har Abubucker, Jonathan H Badger, Asif T Chinwalla, Heather H Creasy, Ashlee M Earl, Michael G FitzGerald, Robert S Fulton, et al. Structure, function and diversity of the healthy human microbiome. Nature, 486:207, 2012. [28] Patricio Jeraldo, Maksim Sipos, Nicholas Chia, Jen- nifer M Brulc, A Singh Dhillon, Michael E Konkel, Charles L Larson, Karen E Nelson, Ani Qu, Lawrence B Schook, F Yang, Bryan A White, and Nigel Golden- feld. Quantification of the relative roles of niche and neutral processes in structuring gastrointestinal micro- biomes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109:9692, 2012. [29] Clive G. Jones, John H. Lawton, and Shachak Moshe. Organisms as ecosystem engineers. Oikos, 69:373, 1994. [30] David A. Kessler and Nadav M. Shnerb. General- ized model of island biodiversity. Physical Review E, 91:042705, 2015. [31] Kirill S Korolev, Mikkel Avlund, Oskar Hallatschek, and David R Nelson. Genetic demixing and evolution in lin- ear stepping stone models. Reviews of Modern Physics, 82:1691, 2010. [32] Simon A Levin. Community equilibria and stability, and an extension of the competitive exclusion principle. The American Naturalist, 104:413, 1970. 10 [33] Mark V. Lomolino. Investigating causality of nestedness of insular communities: Selective immigrations or extinc- tions? Journal of Biogeography, 23:699, 1996. [34] Michel Loreau. Consumers as maximizers of matter and energy flow in ecosystems. The American Naturalist, 145:22, 1995. [35] Robert MacArthur. Species Packing and Competitive Equilibrium for Many Species. Theoretical Population Biology, 1:1, 1970. [36] Robert MacArthur and Richard Levins. The Limiting Similarity, Convergence, and Divergence of Coexisting Species. The American Naturalist, 101:377, 1967. [37] Robert M. May. Stability and complexity in model ecosys- tems. Princeton University Press, Princeton, N.J., 2001. [38] Rajita Menon and Kirill S Korolev. Public good diffu- sion limits microbial mutualism. Physical Review Letters, 114:168102, 2015. [39] Babak Momeni, Li Xie, and Wenying Shou. Lotka- volterra pairwise modeling fails to capture diverse pair- wise microbial interactions. Elife, 6:e25051, 2017. [40] Hidetoshi Nishimori. Statistical Physics of Spin Glasses and Information Processing. Oxford University Press, New York, NY, 2001. [41] Benjamin Obadia, Z.T. Guvener, Vivian Zhang, Javier A. Ceja-Navarro, Eoin L. Brodie, William W. Ja, and William B. Ludington. Probabilistic invasion under- lies natural gut microbiome stability. Current Biology, 27:1999, 2017. [42] Bruce D Patterson and Wirt Atmar. Nested subsets and the structure of insular mammalian faunas and archipela- gos. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 28:65, 1986. [43] F. Pedregosa, G. Varoquaux, A. Gramfort, V. Michel, B. Thirion, O. Grisel, M. Blondel, P. Prettenhofer, R. Weiss, V. Dubourg, J. Vanderplas, A. Passos, D. Cour- napeau, M. Brucher, M. Perrot, and E. Duchesnay. Scikit-learn: Machine learning in Python. Journal of Ma- chine Learning Research, 12:2825 -- 2830, 2011. [44] Anna Posfai, Thibaud Taillefumier, and Ned S. Wingreen. Metabolic trade-offs promote diversity in a model ecosystem. Physical Review Letters, 118:028103, 2017. [45] Bettina E. Schirrmeister, Muriel Gugger, and Philip C. J. Donoghue. Cyanobacteria and the great oxidation event: Evidence from genes and fossils. Palaeontology, 58:769, 2015. [46] Wenying Shou, Carl T Bergstrom, Arup K Chakraborty, and Frances K Skinner. Theory, models and biology. Elife, 4:e07158, 2015. [47] Shinichi Sunagawa, Luis Pedro Coelho, Samuel Chaf- fron, Jens Roat Kultima, Karine Labadie, Guillem Salazar, Bardya Djahanschiri, Georg Zeller, Daniel R. Mende, Adriana Alberti, Francisco M. Cornejo-Castillo, Paul I. Costea, Corinne Cruaud, Francesco d'Ovidio, Stefan Engelen, Isabel Ferrera, Josep M. Gasol, Lionel Guidi, Falk Hildebrand, Florian Kokoszka, Cyrille Lep- oivre, Gipsi Lima-Mendez, Julie Poulain, Bonnie T. Pou- los, Marta Royo-Llonch, Hugo Sarmento, Sara Vieira- Silva, C´eline Dimier, Marc Picheral, Sarah Searson, Ste- fanie Kandels-Lewis, Chris Bowler, Colomban de Var- gas, Gabriel Gorsky, Nigel Grimsley, Pascal Hingamp, Daniele Iudicone, Olivier Jaillon, Fabrice Not, Hiroyuki Ogata, Stephane Pesant, Sabrina Speich, Lars Stem- mann, Matthew B. Sullivan, Jean Weissenbach, Patrick Wincker, Eric Karsenti, Jeroen Raes, Silvia G. Acinas, and Peer Bork. Structure and function of the global ocean microbiome. Science, 348:1261359, 2015. [48] Thibaud Taillefumier, Anna Posfai, Yigal Meir, and Ned S. Wingreen. Microbial consortia at steady supply. eLife, 6:e22644, 2017. [49] Luke R. Thompson, Jon G. Sanders, Daniel McDon- ald, Amnon Amir, Joshua Ladau, Kenneth J. Locey, Robert J. Prill, Anupriya Tripathi, Sean M. Gibbons, Gail Ackermann, Jose A. Navas-Molina, Stefan Janssen, Evguenia Kopylova, Yoshiki V´azquez-Baeza, Antonio Gonz´alez, James T. Morton, Siavash Mirarab, Zhen- jiang Zech Xu, Lingjing Jiang, Mohamed F. Haroon, Jad Kanbar, Qiyun Zhu, Se Jin Song, Tomasz Kosciolek, Nicholas A. Bokulich, Joshua Lefler, Colin J. Brislawn, Gregory Humphrey, Sarah M. Owens, Jarrad Hampton- Marcell, Donna Berg-Lyons, Valerie McKenzie, Noah Fierer, Jed A. Fuhrman, Aaron Clauset, Rick L. Stevens, Ashley Shade, Katherine S. Pollard, Kelly D. Goodwin, Janet K. Jansson, Jack A. Gilbert, Rob Knight, and Earth Microbiome Project Consortium. A communal catalogue reveals Earth's multiscale microbial diversity. Nature, 551:457, 2017. [50] Mikhail Tikhonov and Remi Monasson. Collective phase in resource competition in a highly diverse ecosystem. Physical Review Letters, 118:048103, 2017. [51] Mikhail Tikhonov and Remi Monasson. Innovation Rather than Improvement: A Solvable High-Dimensional Model Highlights the Limitations of Scalar Fitness. Jour- nal of Statistical Physics, 2018. [52] Hanna Tuomisto. A consistent terminology for quanti- fying species diversity? Yes, it does exist. Oecologia, 164:853, 2010. [53] Nicole M. Vega and Jeff Gore. Stochastic assembly pro- duces heterogeneous communities in the Caenorhabditis elegans intestine. PLoS Biol., 15:e2000633, 2017. [54] Ophelia S Venturelli, Alex V Carr, Garth Fisher, Ryan H Hsu, Rebecca Lau, Benjamin P Bowen, Susan Hromada, Trent Northen, and Adam P Arkin. Deciphering mi- crobial interactions in synthetic human gut microbiome communities. Molecular systems biology, 14:e8157, 2018. [55] Stefanie Widder, Rosalind J Allen, Thomas Pfeiffer, Thomas P Curtis, Carsten Wiuf, William T Sloan, Otto X Cordero, Sam P Brown, Babak Momeni, Weny- ing Shou, Helen Kettle, Harry J Flint, Andreas F Haas, B´eatrice Laroche, Jan-Ulrich Kreft, Tobias Grosskopf, Jef Huisman, Andrew Free, Cristian Picioreanu, Christopher Quince, Isaac Klapper, Simon Labarthe, Barth F. Smets, Harris Wang, and Orkun S Soyer. Challenges in microbial ecology: building predictive understanding of commu- nity function and dynamics. The ISME journal, 10:2557, 2016. [56] Eugene P. Wigner. Characteristic vectors of bordered matrices with infinite dimensions. Annals of Mathematics (ser. 2), 62:548, 1955. [57] Benjamin E. Wolfe and Rachel J. Dutton. Fermented foods as experimentally tractable microbial ecosystems. Cell, 161:49, 2015. [58] Ali R. Zomorrodi and Daniel Segr`e. Synthetic ecology of microbes: Mathematical models and applications. J. Mol. Biol., 428:837, 2016. 11 SI Appendices In Appendix A, we provide a full explanation of the Microbial Consumer Resource Model. We describe its numerical implementation in Appendix B, and present additional data illustrating the robustness of the qualitative results in Appendix C. Finally, Appendix D contains preliminary evidence for the existence of a bona fide phase transition in the M → ∞ limit. All data and code for generating figures can be found at https: //github.com/Emergent-Behaviors-in-Biology/ crossfeeding-transition. Appendix A: Model details 1. Generalities We begin by defining an energy flux into a cell J in, an energy flux that is used for growth J growth, and an outgoing energy flux due to byproduct secretion J out. Energy conservation requires J in = J growth + J out (A1) for any reasonable metabolic model. Now consider a model with M resources Rβ with β = 1 . . . M each with "energy" or quality wβ. It will be useful to divide the in- put and output energy fluxes that are consumed/secreted in metabolite β by J in respectively. We define the fraction f out of the output energy secreted as resource β by β and J out β β J out β ≡ f out β J out. We can define corresponding mass fluxes by and νout β ≡ J out β /wβ νin β ≡ J in β /wβ (A2) (A3) (A4) In general, all these fluxes depend on the species under consideration and will carry an extra roman index i in- dicating the species. We assume that a fixed quantity mi of power per cell is required for maintenance of species i, and that the per-capita growth rate is proportional to the remaining energy flux (J growth − mi), with proportionality constant gi. Under these assumptions, the time-evolution of the population size Ni of species i can be modeled using the equation dNi dt = giNi(J growth i − mi). (A5) We can model the resource dynamics by functions of the form dRα dt = hα(Rα) − Njνin jα + Njνout jα , (A6) j j (cid:88) (cid:88) 12 A direct consequence of energy conservation (Equation (A1)) is that (cid:88) (1 − lα)J in α iα = (cid:88) α J growth i = (1 − lα)wασ(ciαRα) α. Note that by definition(cid:80) (A14) All that is left is to determine how to compute the prob- ability of producing a byproduct β when consuming α. Let us denote by Dβα the fraction of the output energy that is contained in metabolite β when a cell consumes β Dβα = 1. These Dβα and lα uniquely specify the metabolic model for independent resources and we can write all fluxes in terms of these quantities. The total energy output in metabolite β is thus (cid:88) (cid:88) J out iβ = DβαlαJ in iα = Dβαlαwασ(ciαRα). (A15) α This also yields νout iβ = α Dβαlα wα wβ (cid:88) α σ(ciαRα) (A16) We are now in position to write down the full dynamics in terms of these quantities: (cid:35) (cid:34)(cid:88) (cid:88) j α (cid:88) dNi dt dRα dt = giNi (1 − lα)wασ(ciαRα) − mi = hα(Rα) − Njσ(cjαRα) (cid:20) (cid:21) wβ wα lβ (A17) + Njσ(cjβRβ) Dαβ where the function hα describes the resource dynamics in the absence of consumers. We can consider two kinds of dynamics: externally supplied and self-renewing. For externally supplied resources, we take a linearized form of the dynamics: hexternal α (Rα) = κα − τ−1 α Rα (A7) while for self-renewing we take a logistic form for the dynamics hself−renewing α (Rα) = rαRα(Kα − Rα). (A8) In the present study, we only consider externally supplied resources. These equations specify the general dynamics of all the models we consider. Metabolism is encoded in the relationship between input, output, and growth fluxes. 2. Input fluxes and output partitioning We will now specify the form of the input fluxes νin β and the output partitioning f out β . This involves specify- ing how an input resource is turned into an metabolic byproducts. To try to capture metabolic structure, we will divide the M resources into T classes (e.g. sug- ars, amino acids, etc.), each with MA resources where A MA = M . We will be interested in capturing coarse metabolic structure (i.e. metaboliz- ing sugars outputs carboxylic acids, etc). We will limit ourselves to considering strictly substitutable resources. A = 1, . . . T and (cid:80) In all consumer resource models, we assume that νin iβ = σ(ciβRβ) (A9) jβ where σ encodes the response function of consumer i for resource α. In the microbial context the consumer prefer- ences ciα can be interpreted as expression levels of trans- porters for each of the resources. We consider three kinds of response functions: Type-I, linear response functions where σI (x) = x, a Type-II saturating Monod function, σII (x) = x 1 + x K and a Type-III Hill or sigmoid-like function σIII (x) = 1 +(cid:0) x xn K (cid:1)n , (A10) (A11) (A12) where n > 1. In all the simulations of this paper, we assume that resources independently contribute to the growth rate. We define a leakage fraction 0 ≤ lα ≤ 1 for resource α such that α = lαJ in J out α . (A13) Notice that when σ is Type-I (linear) and lα = 0 for all α (no leakage or byproducts), this reduces to MacArthur's original model [35]. 3. Choosing consumer preferences We will now choose consumer preferences ciα as fol- lows. We assume that each specialist family has a pref- erence for one resource class A (where A = 1 . . . F ) with 0 ≤ F ≤ T , and we denote the consumer coefficients for this family by cA iα. We will also consider generalists that have no preferences, with consumer coefficients cgen iα . We will consider three kinds of models: one where the coef- ficients are drawn from Gaussian distributions, another where they are drawn from Gamma distributions (which ensure positivity of the coefficients), and finally a dis- crete, binary preference model. a. Gaussian consumer preferences The Gaussian model allows a continuous gradation of transporter expression levels. We assume that the vari- ance is fixed to so that for all coefficients for all families for the generalists. 13 (cid:104)(δcA iα)2(cid:105) = (cid:104)(δcgen iα )2(cid:105) = σ2 c M . (A18) In the generalist family, the mean is also the same for all resources, and is given by Note that the mean of the distribution is (cid:104)ciα(cid:105) = piαc1 + c0 M , and the variance is (cid:104)(δciα)2(cid:105) = piα(1 − piα). Both of these scale as 1/M when M → ∞, just like the Gaussian and Gamma versions, as long as c1, c0 and µc are held fixed. (cid:104)cgen iα (cid:105) = µc M . (A19) 4. Constructing the metabolic matrix (cid:104) (cid:40) µc M µc (cid:105) The specialist families sample from a distribution with a larger mean for resources in their preferred class: (cid:104)cA iα(cid:105) = 1 + M−MA MA qA M (1 − qA), , if α ∈ A otherwise, (A20) where MA is the number of resources in class A, and qA controls how much more species from family A prefer resources from class A. We have put a factor of M in the denominators of the expressions for mean and variance, because the sums over ciα in the dynamical equations (A17) always give rise to terms with means M(cid:104)ciα(cid:105) or S(cid:104)ciα(cid:105) and variances M(cid:104)(δciα)2(cid:105) or S(cid:104)(δciα)2(cid:105). The factor of M allows us to keep σc, µc fixed when exploring the M, S → ∞ limit in Appendix D below. b. Gamma consumer preferences We will also consider the case where consumer prefer- ences are drawn from Gamma distributions, which guar- antee that all coefficients will be positive. Since the Gamma distribution only has two parameters, it is fully determined once the mean and variance are specified. We parameterize the mean and variance for this model in the same way as for the Gaussian model. c. Binary consumer preferences In the binary model, there are only two possible ex- M and a pression levels for each transporter: a low level c0 high level c0 M + c1. The elements of cA iα are given by cA iα = c0 M + c1Xiα, (A21) where Xiα is a binary random variable that equals 1 with probability (cid:40) µc (cid:104) (cid:105) pA iα = M c1 µc M c1 qA MA 1 + M−MA (1 − qA), , if α ∈ A otherwise (A22) for the specialist families, and pgen iα = µc M c1 (A23) We choose the metabolic matrix Dαβ according to a three-tiered secretion model. The first tier contains a preferred class of byproducts, such as carboyxlic acids for fermentative and respiro-fermentative bacteria, which includes Mc members. The second contains byproducts of the same class as the input resource (when the import resource is not in the preferred byproduct class). For ex- ample, this could be attributed to the partial oxidation of sugars into sugar alcohols, or the antiporter behavior of various amino acid transporters. The third tier in- cludes everything else. We encode this structure in Dαβ by sampling each column of the matrix from a Dirichlet distribution with concentration parameters dαβ that de- pend on the byproduct tier, so that on average a fraction fc of the secreted flux goes to the first tier, while a frac- tion fs goes to the second tier, and the rest goes to the third: d0 d0 d0 d0 fc+fs , Mc 1−fc−fs M−Mc fs , MA(β) , 1−fs−fc M−MA(β)−Mc , if α = c if α (cid:54)= c and β = c if α, β (cid:54)= c and A(α) = A(β) if α, β (cid:54)= c and A(α) (cid:54)= A(β). (A24)  dαβ = The parameter d0 controls the randomness of the parti- tioning, ranging from the maximum value where all the weight is put on a single resource for d0 = 1, to deter- ministic partitioning as d0 → ∞. The mean of the Dirichlet distribution is always equal to 1/M , and the variance under this parameterization also scales as 1/M when the f 's and d0 are held fixed. The sampling of Dαβ thus following the same scaling be- havior as our scheme for the consumer matrices in the M, S → ∞ limit of Appendix D. Appendix B: Simulation and data analysis 1. The Community Simulator We implemented the above modeling framework in a Python package called "Community Simulator," which can be downloaded and installed from https: //github.com/Emergent-Behaviors-in-Biology/ community-simulator. Once this package is stalled, //github.com/Emergent-Behaviors-in-Biology/ in- the data can be downloaded from https: crossfeeding-transition, and the accompanying Jupyter notebook can be used to regenerate all the figures. The one exception is the energy flux network figure, which was generated in MATLAB using a file ex- ported from the notebook. The repository also contains a sample MATLAB script for loading and visualizing the network file. Community Simulator is designed to run dynamics on multiple communities in parallel, inspired by the paral- lel experiments commonly performed with 96-well plates. The central object of the package is a Community class, whose instances are initialized by specifying the initial population sizes and resource concentrations for each par- allel "well," along with the functions and parameters that define the population dynamics. This class contains two core methods. Propagate(T) sends each community to a separate CPU (for however many CPU's are available), runs the given population dynamics for a time T using the SciPy function odeint, and updates the population sizes and resource concentrations in each well to the time- evolved values. Passage(f) initializes a fresh set of wells by adding a fraction fµν of the contents of each old well ν to each new well µ. (Fresh media can also be added at this point, but this feature was not relevant for the current work). The resulting values of Ni are converted from arbitrary concentration units to actual population sizes using a specified scale factor, and then integer pop- ulation sizes are obtained by multinomial sampling based on these values. The Community Simulator package also contains a set of scripts for generating models and randomly sampling parameters. MakeConsumerDynamics and MakeResourceDynamics from the usertools module take a dictionary of assumptions concerning the re- sponse type, metabolic regulation and resource replen- ishment (as described above), and generate the corre- sponding functions for dNi/dt and dRα/dt. The func- tion MakeMatrices, from the same module, samples the consumer matrix ciα and the metabolic matrix Dαβ ac- cording to the scheme described in the previous section. 2. Simulation Details For this paper, we generated a binary consumer matrix with c0 = 1, c1 = 1 and µc = 10, and a metabolic matrix with d0 = 0.2. This matrix defined a regional pool of S = 200 species, consuming M = 100 possible resource types. We used only one family and one resource class in constructing the ciα and Dαβ matrices (but arbitrarily assigned each resource and each species to one of four categories, as a null model for comparison with future structured simulations). We set wα = gi = 1 for all i and α, and set the lα for all resources equal to each other. For the multinomial sampling described above, we chose the scale factor so that Ni = 1 corresponds to a population of 106 cells. We generated dynamics with Type-I response, no regulation, and a "renewable" resource replenishment 14 model. Only resource type 0 was supplied externally, with flux κ0, and all the other κα's were set to zero. To simulate stochastic colonization, we initialized each of 10 wells with 100 randomly chosen species from the regional pool, with a population size of 106 cells per species per well. We propagated each well under Equa- tions (A17) for a time ∆t = 11, 500, which is much longer than the maximum time required to relax to the steady state for any of the parameter regimes sampled. We used the Passage method with fµν = δµν to periodically elim- inate species whose populations became too small. For the large steady-state population sizes we consider here (∼ 104− 109, see Figure 11 below), the multinomial sam- pling eliminates species whose populations are heading for extinction while minimally perturbing the dynamics of the survivors. We passaged after every 5 time units of propagation from the beginning of the simulation up to time t = 500, then every 100 time units until time t = 1, 500, and finally every 1,000 time units up to the final time t = 11, 500. The timeseries shown in Figure 1E was generated un- der these assumptions, with w0κ0 = 500. We propagated these 10 initial states using this proce- dure for 100 different combinations of externally supplied energy flux w0κ0 and leakage fraction l, with 10 w0κ0 val- ues evenly spaced on a logarithmic scale from 10 to 100, and 10 l values evenly spaced from 0 to 0.9. Figure 2 of the main text shows the mean richness over the 10 parallel wells for each combination of w0κ0 and l. The richness is defined as the number of species with non-zero abundance at the end of the simulation. We focused on three representative examples for fur- ther analysis: 1. Syntrophy-Limited: w0κ0 = 1000, (cid:104)lα(cid:105) = 0.1 2. Energy-Limited: w0κ0 = 28, (cid:104)lα(cid:105) = 0.6 3. Similarity-Limited: w0κ0 = 1000, (cid:104)lα(cid:105) = 0.9. (cid:80) The rank-abundance plots in Figure 2 of the main text show the population sizes in all 10 wells from each of these examples, after normalizing them by the total biomass i Ni. The plots were truncated at a relative abundance of 0.5% for clarity. Rank-abundance plots for these same three examples in absolute units with no truncation can be found in Figure 11 below. 3. Susceptibilities One important property of an ecosystem is its sensi- tivity to changes in environmental conditions. Figure 3 of the main text quantifies this sensitivity in terms of a set of susceptibilities, defined by ∂ ¯Rα ∂κβ ∂ ¯Ni ∂κβ χαβ ≡ ηiβ ≡ (B1) (B2) where ¯Ni, ¯Rα are the steady-state consumer populations and resource concentrations, respectively. 5. Beta Diversity 15 For the case of externally supplied resources and Type- I growth, setting Equations (A17) equal to zero and dif- ferentiating with respect to κβ yields: 0 = −τ−1 α δαβ = (1 − lα)wαciαχαβ cjγNj Dαγ (cid:20) (cid:20) ×χγβ + cjγ Dαγ (cid:88) (cid:88) α γ j (cid:88) (cid:88) (cid:18)(cid:88) (cid:19) (cid:20) (cid:88) α δγα jγ γ j (cid:88) − τ−1 + jγ (cid:21) (cid:21) lγ − δγα lγ − δγα wγ wα wγ wα (B3)  − τ−1 α δγα Rγηjβ (B4) (cid:20) (cid:21) The last equation can be reorganized as −τ−1 α δαβ = cjγNj Dαγ wγ wα lγ − δγα χγβ (cid:21) wγ wα lγ − δγα Rγηjβ (B5) cjγ Dαγ For each value of β, this system of linear equations can be solved for χγβ and ηjβ by simply inverting a matrix (once the terms corresponding to extinct species have been removed). The histograms of Figure 3D in the main text contain the diagonal elements χαα for all resources except for the one supplied externally (α = 0), which might be ex- pected to behave somewhat differently. The χαα values from all 10 parallel communities are included in the his- togram. We generated one histogram for the similarity- limited regime, and one for the energy-limited regime, using the examples defined in Section B 2 above. 4. Niche Overlap To find out what controls the diversity of the diverse regime, we varied the niche overlap, which quantifies the similarity among consumer preferences within the re- gional species pool. We did this by holding µc fixed, and varying c1 from its original value of 1 down to a mini- mum value of 0.12. For each value of c1, we generated 10 ciα matrices, which each defined a regional pool of 200 species. We then repeated the procedure of Section B 2 above for each of these regional pools: initializing 10 wells with 100 species and running them to the steady state with the same sequence of propagation and passage steps. The final richness of each community is plotted in Fig- ure 4 of the main text as a translucent point, such that more common richness values are darker. We included all three examples defined at the end of Section B 2 in the plot, and colored both examples from the resource- limited regime blue, while the diverse regime was colored red. To examine the beta diversity patterns in each regime, we initialized 200 wells with 100 randomly chosen species from the regional pool of 200 species, and propagated them to steady state following Section B 2 under the three different choices of w0κ0 and l listed at the end of that section. To visualize the variation among these commu- nities, we used the Python package scikit-learn [43] to compute the first two principle components of the set of composition vectors in each regime. We then projected the compositions onto the plane spanned by these vec- tors, and generated a scatter plot of the results. We also computed the percentage of the total variance accounted for by each of these two principal components, and indi- cated the value in parentheses on each axis. 6. Data Format The output of all the simulations was saved to a set of Microsoft Excel spreadsheets, which can be easily im- ported into Python for analysis using the Pandas pack- age. Each simulation generated four files: final consumer populations ('Consumers'), final resource concentrations ('Resources'), a metadata summary ('Parameters'), and initial conditions ('Initial_State'). The ciα and Dαβ matrices as well as the mi and wα were pickled into a binary file ('Realization'). The file names also include the date on which the data was generated, and a task ID when multiple files were generated on the same day. The first column in the consumer and resource tables is the index of the simulation run. The second and third columns of the consumer file are the family ID and species ID, respectively. In the resource file, these columns contain the class ID and resource ID. The re- maining columns contain the populations/concentrations for each well. The consumer populations are in units of 106 cells. All the parameters that change between runs are in- cluded in the metadata file ('Parameters'). The first col- umn of this file is the simulation run index, corresponding to the index in the consumer and resource files. The initial conditions file contains the initial popula- tion sizes for each of the wells. Appendix C: Robustness of qualitative results In this Appendix, we test the robustness of our quali- tative results by modifying the modeling assumptions in five ways. We have given each way a descriptive name, which can be used to look up the raw data files from the supplemental data folder using the file_list.csv table: • main_dataset is the data from the main text • type_II uses a Type II functional response, with K = 20. • dense_metabolism has a dense metabolic matrix with d0 = 0.001. • randomness adds (quenched) random variation to wα and lα, with standard deviations 0.1 and 0.03, respectively. • Gaussian_sampling samples the ciα's from Gaus- sian distributions, with the same mean 0.11 and standard deviation 0.3 as the binary matrix used in the main text. • Gamma_sampling samples the ciα's from Gamma distributions, with the same mean and variance. The following sections describe each of these choices in more detail. Figures 8, 11, 12 and 13 show the key plots from the main text along with the new versions generated under all these modified assumptions. Figures 9 and 10 display another diversity measure not discussed in the main text: the Simpson Diversity (S. D.). This is defined analogously to the "effective number of resources consumed" presented in Equation (6) of the main text: (cid:34)(cid:88) (cid:18) Ni (cid:19)2(cid:35)−1 (C1) S.D. = N i (cid:80) where N ≡ i Ni. As discussed in the main text in con- nection with resource fluxes, this quantity approaches 1 when there is one large Ni ≈ N and all the other popula- tions are very small. It approaches the number of species (i.e., the richness) as the biomass distribution becomes more uniform. 1. Type-II Growth We chose the Monod parameter K = 20 in the Type-II growth simulations in order to ensure that at least one species would survive in the steady state in all simula- tions. The maximum possible incoming energy flux in the Type-II model is equal to 0.1K when wα = 1 and l = 0.9, and this must exceed mi ≈ 1 for a species to survive. K = 20 provides a maximum flux of 2 in this case. 2. Metabolic Matrices The metabolic matrices Dβα are plotted in Figure 3 of the main text for main_dataset and dense_metabolism (all other simulations use the same metabolic parame- ters as main_dataset). We see that d0 = 0.2 leads to a very sparse matrix, with only a few secreted byprod- ucts per input resource, while the secretion fractions for d0 = 0.001 are much more uniform. 16 3. Randomness in wα and lα To relax the assumption of all the wα's and lα's being equal, we sampled these two vectors from Gaussian dis- tributions. We chose the standard deviations of the dis- tributions to be small enough that both quantities would almost always be positive, and lα would remain less than 1. 4. Gaussian and Gamma Sampling Sampling consumer preferences from the continuous Gaussian and Gamma distributions makes the differen- tial equations much more stiff than in the binary case. To ensure stable operation of the integrator, we "passaged" the cells every 0.1 time units. Each call of the "passage" method zeros out small negative values of resource con- centration or consumer population that arise because of numerical error, in addition to setting small consumer populations to zero. This high frequency of passaging made the simulation more computationally intensive, so we only propagated these simulations for 200 time units. We computed the root-mean-square difference between the per-capita growth rates (1/Ni)(dNi/dt) and zero to check whether the simulations had converged. We found that all of them had acceptably converged, except for some of the runs at w0κ0 < 100 in the Gaussian case. The Gaussian model is unphysical, because almost half of the consumer preferences are less than 0 for these simula- tions, and so we decided not to spend more computation time in pursuit of convergence. 5. Quantification of Nestedness Almeida-Neto et al. have introduced a quantitative measure of nestedness, called the "Nestedness metric based on Overlap and Decreasing Fill," or NODF [2]. Figure 14 shows how the NODF depends on the relative abundance threshold for the Tara Oceans data, as com- pared with two null models taken from the Earth Mi- crobiome Project analysis [49]. Null Model 1 keeps the richness of each sample the same while randomly alter- ing the identities of the surviving species. It tells us how much nestedness we should expect by chance from a set of samples with the given levels of diversity, in the ab- sence of any ecological mechanisms. Null Model 2 keeps the prevalence of each species the same while randomly assigning it to different samples. This procedure gener- ates another well-defined family of random matrices with similar bulk statistics to the original data, but lacks the operational interpretation of Null Model 1. For this rea- son, the comparison with Null Model 1 is more meaning- ful, but we include Null Model 2 for completeness. For each of the null models and each value of the rela- tive abundance threshold, we generated 100 random per- mutations of the data matrix and computed the mean and standard deviation of their NODF scores. We found that the actual nestedness exceeds that of Null Model 1 by at least 20 standard deviations for all values of the threshold. For the relative abundance threshold of 0.5% employed in Figure 7, the true NODF also exceeds Null Model 2 by 5.8 standard deviations. The figure also shows histograms generated with the two null models from the simulation data of Figure 6A. The actual NODF (=0.46) is more than 100 standard deviations above the mean nestedness for both models. To compute the NODF, we employed the following al- gorithm, which is implemented in the Community Sim- ulator package (in the analysis module). Let n be the number of columns, and m the number of rows in a ma- trix A. Let Dc be an n × n matrix, such that (Dc)ij = 1 if the sum of column i is greater than the sum of column j, and 0 otherwise. Similarly, let Dr be an m × m ma- trix such that (Dr)ij = 1 if the sum of row j is greater than the sum of row i, and zero otherwise. Let B be the row-normalized matrix, where each row of A has been divided by the sum over the row. And let C be the column-normalized matrix, where each column has been normalized by the sum over the column. Then the NODF of the matrix A is Tr(AT DrB) + Tr(ADcC T ) NODF = 2 n(n − 1) + m(m − 1) where Tr represents the trace operation. (C2) Appendix D: Phase Transition A phase transition in physics is characterized by a dis- continuous change in the value of an observable or its in the derivative as an intensive parameter is varied, "thermodynamic limit" of infinite system size. In an ecological context, the analog to system size is the num- ber of possible resource types M , or the initial num- ber of species S. Several recent works have explored the analytic computations that become tractable in the M, S → ∞ limit of various models, while γ ≡ M/S remains constant (when the model is resource-explicit) [1, 4, 7, 50]. Taking this limit requires several decisions about how to scale the rest of the parameters. Our sam- pling scheme for the ciα and Dαβ matrices, described in Appendix B, follows the canonical strategy for studying spin glasses, where the random coupling parameters Jij are chosen such that the mean and variance are both proportional to 1/M [40]. The maintenance costs mi, on the other hand, are sampled from the same distribution regardless of the value of M . Finally, we note that the total amount of energy w0κ0 supplied to the system is an "extensive" parameter, and that the scaling analysis should be performed with the corresponding "intensive" parameter w0κ0/M held fixed. Figure 15 shows how the consumer richness scales with M for each of the three examples discussed in the main 17 text. The first two examples come from the resource- limited regime. The "syntrophy-limited" example has w0κ0/M = 10, l = 0.1, while the "energy-limited" exam- ple has w0κ0/M = 0.28, l = 0.6. The third, "similarity- limited" example comes from the diverse regime, with w0κ0/M = 10, l = 0.9. The richness appears to scale like M α with exponent α < 1 for the resource-limited examples, and α = 1 for the diverse example. If this scaling holds asymptotically as M → ∞, then the sys- tem exhibits a true phase transition, with the normalized richness (richness/M ) vanishing in the resource-limited regime, while remaining finite in the diverse regime. The gray line in the right-hand panel illustrates what this would look like, with a discontinuity in the derivative of the normalized richness as a function of l or w0κ0/M . This evidence is by no means conclusive, since we only have access to a single decade of M values. To reach three decades of M values would require solving 40,000 coupled ODE's involving matrices ciα and Dαβ with size 20, 000 × 20, 000. Each matrix would thus have 4 × 108 entries, corresponding to 50 MB of memory for binary entries or 800 MB of memory for floating-point entries. This computation is feasible but non-trivial, demanding significantly more attention to how the matrix multipli- cations are implemented and how the matrices are passed around in memory. We are currently working on an up- date to the Community Simulator package that imple- ments the core computations in PyTorch, which enables GPU acceleration of matrix multiplication and may allow for calculations on this scale. For completeness, Figure 16 shows how four other natural observables scale with system size. These are the Simpson and Shannon diversity of the steady-state consumer and resource abundances [52]. To compute these quantities, one first obtains relative abundances α Rα. In terms of these fi = Ni/(cid:80) fractions, the Simpson diversity is i Ni and fα = Rα/(cid:80) (cid:32)(cid:88) DSim = (cid:33)−1 (D1) and is related to the Inverse Participation Ratio com- monly analyzed in spin glass problems, while the Shan- non diversity is f 2 i i (cid:88) i (cid:32) (cid:33) DSh = exp − fi ln fi , (D2) and is simply the exponential of the Shannon entropy of the distribution (where the sum is taken only over the species with nonzero abundance). Both of these quanti- ties are equal to 1 in the limit where a single type domi- nates the distribution, and equal the total number of sur- viving types when all the types have the same abundance. The Simpson and Shannon diversity of the consumers ap- pear to saturate at a finite values in the large M limit of the resource-limited regime. When measured in these ways, the diversity of this regime thus appears to be in- sensitive to the size of the regional species pool and to the number of possible resource types, and is controlled by the energy supply, leakage fraction, and probably also the sparsity of the Dαβ matrix. 18 19 FIG. 8. Richness vs. w0κ0 and (cid:104)lα(cid:105) We generated 200 species, initialized 10 communities of 100 species each from this pool, and ran the dynamics to steady state under different combinations of w0κ0 and (cid:104)lα(cid:105), for each of the six model choices listed at the end of Section B 2. The color of each square indicates the mean number of non-extinct species at the end of the simulation, over all 10 communities at each combination of w0κ0 and (cid:104)lα(cid:105). FIG. 9. Simpson Diversity vs. w0κ0 and (cid:104)lα(cid:105). Simpson Diversity was computed according to Equation (C1), using the same data as Figure 8. Leakage Fraction l101001000Supplied Energy Flux w00main_datasetLeakage Fraction lSupplied Energy Flux w00type_IILeakage Fraction lSupplied Energy Flux w00dense_metabolism0.00.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9Leakage Fraction l101001000Supplied Energy Flux w00randomness0.00.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9Leakage Fraction lSupplied Energy Flux w00Gaussian_sampling0.00.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9Leakage Fraction lSupplied Energy Flux w00Gamma_sampling051015202530051015202530051015202530051015202530051015202530051015202530Leakage Fraction l101001000Supplied Energy Flux w00main_datasetLeakage Fraction lSupplied Energy Flux w00type_IILeakage Fraction lSupplied Energy Flux w00dense_metabolism0.00.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9Leakage Fraction l101001000Supplied Energy Flux w00randomness0.00.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9Leakage Fraction lSupplied Energy Flux w00Gaussian_sampling0.00.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9Leakage Fraction lSupplied Energy Flux w00Gamma_sampling04812162004812162004812162004812162004812162004812162020 FIG. 10. Richness (blue solid) and Simpson Diversity (red dotted) for cuts through the heat map. All six modeling choices are plotted, going from dark to light in the order listed in the text. Error bars are plus and minus one standard deviation, where the standard deviation is computed over the 10 parallel communities at each set of parameter values. 02004006008001000Supplied Energy Flux w00051015202530High Leakage (l=0.9)0.00.20.40.60.8Leakage Fraction lHigh Energy Supply (w00=1000)21 FIG. 11. Rank-abundance curves for three representative examples. The abundance is plotted in absolute number of cells, as opposed to the relative abundance of the main text, and includes all species, with no truncation. The lower limit of the vertical axis is set to 1 cell, which is the smallest possible population size once the Passage method described in Appendix B has generated integer population values. The three examples are the same ones highlighted in Figure 2 of the main text, and listed in Section B 2 above. Rank100102104106108Absolute Abundancemain_datasetSyntrophy-LimitedRankEnergy-LimitedRankSimilarity-LimitedRank100102104106108Absolute Abundancetype_IIRankRankRank100102104106108Absolute Abundancedense_metabolismRankRankRank100102104106108Absolute AbundancerandomnessRankRankRank100102104106108Absolute AbundanceGaussian_samplingRankRank0102030Rank100102104106108Absolute AbundanceGamma_sampling0102030Rank0102030Rank22 FIG. 12. Effective number of resources consumed. The effective number of resources consumed M eff is computed as described in the main text for the same three examples. The y axis indicates the total number of species falling into each bin from the combination of all 10 parallel communities in each example. i FIG. 13. Resource susceptibility. Histograms of the logarithm log10 ∂ ¯Rα/∂κα are plotted for the same three examples. The y axis indicates the total number of species falling into each bin from the combination of all resources for all 10 parallel communities in each example, excepting the externally supplied resource α = 0. 020406080Number of Speciesmain_datasetEnergy-LimitedSyntrophy-LimitedSimilarity-Limitedtype_IIdense_metabolism051015020406080Number of Speciesrandomness051015Effective Number of Resources ConsumedGaussian_sampling051015Gamma_samplingFrequencymain_datasetEnergy-LimitedSyntrophy-LimitedSimilarity-Limitedtype_IIdense_metabolism3210Frequencyrandomness3210Log Resource SusceptibilityGaussian_sampling3210Gamma_sampling23 FIG. 14. Quantification of nestedness. (a) Nestedness as quantified by NODF [2] of the Tara Oceans data, for different values of the relative abundance threshold. See Appendix C 5 for the full quantification algorithm. Also shown are the mean NODF over 100 samples from two null models, with error bars representing ±1 standard deviation. Null Model 1 keeps the richness of each sample the same while randomly altering the identities of the surviving species. Null Model 2 keeps the prevalence of each species the same while randomly assigning it to different samples. (b) Histograms of 1000 samples from each null model at the relative abundance threshold of 0.005 used in the main text, and indicated with a black line in the first panel. (c), (d) Null models for comparison with the NODF value of 0.46 obtained for the simulation data. The two panels show histograms of 1,000 samples from null models 1 and 2, respectively. FIG. 15. Scaling of consumer richness with system size. Left: Community richness in the three examples of Section B 2 as a function of the number of resource types M (with the rest of the parameters scaled as described in Appendix B). The thin black line shows the slope corresponding to a linear scaling with M . Error bars are standard deviations over 100 samples per point. Right: Normalized richness as a function of leakage fraction at high energy supply w0κ0/M = 10. The top red line comes from the simulations of Figure 2 of the main text (M = 100), and the middle blue line comes from new simulations with M = 500. The bottom gray line illustrates a possible M → ∞ limit, which would correspond to a continuous phase transition. Error bars are standard deviations over 10 samples per point. (a)(b)(c)(d)102103M100101102RichnessSimilarity-LimitedEnergy-LimitedSyntrophy-Limited0.00.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9Leakage0.000.050.100.150.200.250.300.35Richness/MM = ∞?M = 100M = 50024 FIG. 16. Scaling of other observables. Diversity of steady-state consumer and resource abundances in the three examples of Section B 2, as a function of the number of resource types M (with the rest of the parameters scaled as described in Appendix B). The thin black line shows the slope corresponding to a linear scaling with M . Error bars are standard deviations over 100 samples per point. FIG. 17. Flux network topology. We generated flux networks like those of Figure 3 for both the sparse ('main dataset') and the dense ('dense metabolism') metabolic matrices shown there. We pruned the graphs as in the main text figure by removing edges with flux less than 1% of maximum flux in the network. For each condition, we determined how many of the ten replicates had acyclic graphs, which could thus be topologically ordered like the left-hand panels of the figure. The color of each square represents the fraction of acyclic graphs for the given values of l and w0κ0. 100101102Consumer DiversitySyntrophy-LimitedRichnessSimpsonShannonEnergy-LimitedSimilarity-Limited102103M100101102Resource Diversity102103M102103M00.20.40.60.8Leakage Fraction l101001000Supplied Energy Flux w00main_dataset00.20.40.60.8Leakage Fraction ldense_metabolism0.00.20.40.60.81.0Fraction of wells with no metabolic cycles0.00.20.40.60.81.0Fraction of wells with no metabolic cycles25 FIG. 18. Number of available resources. The mean number of resources (over all ten initial communities) with abundances Rα above 0.1 is plotted for each of the conditions summarized in Figure 2. This threshold is the level at which an average consumer equally consuming 10 resources would be able to satisfy its full maintenance cost. 00.20.40.60.8Leakage Fraction l101001000Supplied Energy Flux w0020406080Mean Number of Available Resources26 FIG. 19. Maintenance costs mi. The maintenance cost mi for each species is plotted against the relative abundance of that species in its community, for each of the simulations in Figure 2. The ten panels contain data for each of the ten initial pools of species. In each panel, each species has 100 data points, one for each of the 100 combinations of l and w0κ0. The points are colored by the richness of the steady-state community, with blue being least diverse and red the most diverse. Every point in a given panel corresponds to a species that was initially present in the community, so points on the mi axis where all the relative abundances vanish are species that never survive to steady state in any of the sampled conditions.
1705.02624	1	1705	2017-05-07T13:51:39	State assignment problem in systems biology and medicine: on the importance of state interaction network topology	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.dis-nn", "cond-mat.stat-mech", "physics.med-ph" ]	A fundamental problem in medicine and biology is to assign states, e.g. healthy or diseased, to cells, organs or individuals. State assignment or making a diagnosis is often a nontrivial and challenging process and, with the advent of omics technologies, the diagnostic challenge is becoming more and more serious. The challenge lies not only in the increasing number of measured properties and dynamics of the system (e.g. cell or human body) but also in the co-evolution of multiple states and overlapping properties, and degeneracy of states. We develop, from first principles, a generic rational framework for state assignment in cell biology and medicine, and demonstrate its applicability with a few simple theoretical case studies from medical diagnostics. We show how disease-related statistical information can be used to build a comprehensive model that includes the relevant dependencies between clinical and laboratory findings (signs) and diseases. In particular, we include disease-disease and sign-sign interactions. We then study how one can infer the probability of a disease in a patient with given signs. We perform comparative analysis with simple benchmark models to check the performances of our models. This first principles approach, as we show, enables the construction of consensus diagnostic flow charts and facilitates the early diagnosis of disease. Additionally, we envision that our approach will find applications in systems biology, and in particular, in characterizing the phenome via the metabolome, the proteome, the transcriptome, and the genome.	physics.bio-ph	physics	State assignment problem in systems biology and medicine: on the importance of state interaction network topology Abolfazl Ramezanpoura,b, Alireza Mashaghia,c,∗ aLeiden Academic Centre for Drug Research, Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, Leiden University, Leiden, The Netherlands bDepartment of Physics, University of Neyshabur, Neyshabur, Iran cHarvard Medical School, Harvard University, Boston, Massachusetts, USA and ∗Correspondence to [email protected] (Dated: July 12, 2021) Abstract A fundamental problem in medicine and biology is to assign states, e.g. healthy or diseased, to cells, organs or individuals. State assignment or making a diagnosis is often a nontrivial and chal- lenging process and, with the advent of omics technologies, the diagnostic challenge is becoming more and more serious. The challenge lies not only in the increasing number of measured proper- ties and dynamics of the system (e.g. cell or human body) but also in the co-evolution of multiple states and overlapping properties, and degeneracy of states. We develop, from first principles, a generic rational framework for state assignment in cell biology and medicine, and demonstrate its applicability with a few simple theoretical case studies from medical diagnostics. We show how disease-related statistical information can be used to build a comprehensive model that includes the relevant dependencies between clinical and laboratory findings (signs) and diseases. In par- ticular, we include disease-disease and sign-sign interactions. We then study how one can infer the probability of a disease in a patient with given signs. We perform comparative analysis with simple benchmark models to check the performances of our models. This first principles approach, as we show, enables the construction of consensus diagnostic flow charts and facilitates the early diagnosis of disease. Additionally, we envision that our approach will find applications in systems biology, and in particular, in characterizing the phenome via the metabolome, the proteome, the transcriptome, and the genome. 1 I. INTRODUCTION Human body as a whole or in part may adopt various states, like a Rubik's Cube. Home- ostatic mechanisms, medical interventions and aging all involve evolution from certain body states to others. Similarly, evolution of states is commonly seen in cells that constitute our bodies. Immune cells for example can manifest substantial plasticity and develop into distinct phenotypes with different functions [2, 3]. Identifying dysfunctional states in cells is in many ways similar to identifying diseases in organisms and is confronted by similar difficulties. State assignment, as we describe below, is often a nontrivial and challenging process and in many cases it is hard to diagnose the state of a cell or conditions of a pa- tient. The progress in systems biology and availability of large data has made diagnostics even more challenging. For instance, mass cytometric analysis of immune cells has led to identification of many new cell subtypes (states) [4]. Metabolomic analysis of cells and body fluids revealed a large number of biomarkers and disease subtypes [5]. There is a huge need in the fields of cell biology, immunology, clinical sciences and pharmaceutical sciences for approaches to identify states, assigning states and characterizing co-emerging or co-existing states. Moreover, it is often important to be able to identify emerging states even before they are fully evolved. From physics point of view, it is interesting to yield a generic un- derstanding of the state assignment problem in cell biology or medicine (although specific details might be crucial in each context in practice). Without loss of generality, in what fol- lows we focus on medical diagnostics and draw a simple picture that captures many generic aspects of assignment problems in medicine and systems cell biology. Decision-making is at the heart of medicine. Decisions are made at various stages in clinical practice, particularly during diagnostic investigations and when assigning the find- ings to a disease [6, 7]. Diagnostic strategies are typically available in the form of clinical algorithms and flow charts that define the sequence of actions to be taken to reach a diag- nosis. The diagnosis itself is typically made based on consensus diagnostic criteria [8, 9]. In addition, there are a number of clinical decision support systems and software systems that are used to assign findings (symptoms and signs) to disease conditions. The most commonly used technologies are WebMD Symptom Checker, Isabel Symptom Checker, DXplain and Internist[10]. These algorithms compute the most likely disease that is associated with a given set of findings by using only a small part of the existing probabilistic data on findings 2 and diseases. Internist, which is one of the most sophisticated systems, relies on two pa- rameters, the probability of a finding given a disease and the probability of a disease given a finding [11]. These technologies inform us if a patient satisfies the criteria of a disease but do not provide guidance on how to approach a patient and mostly ignore the interactions between diseases. Currently, we lack a solid conceptual framework for medical diagnostics. As a conse- quence, there is no consensus on the diagnostic flow charts available today, and clinicians differ widely in their approaches to patients. Here, we take a step towards solving this prob- lem by formulating first principles medical diagnostics. We evaluate the performance of the platform and discuss how one can optimize it. Using simple theoretical examples, we show how including relevant statistical data and often-ignored inherent disease-disease linkages significantly reduces diagnostic errors and mismanagement and enables the early diagnosis of disease. The problem of associating a subset of observed signs (clinical signs/symptoms and labo- ratory data) with specific diseases was easy if we could assume the findings originate from a single disease, we had clear demonstrations for the diseases, and inter-sign and inter-disease interactions were negligible. In practice, however, we typically have no certain relationships that connect signs to diseases, and one often must address interference effects of multiple diseases; in the early stages of a disease, we do not even have sufficient findings to make a definite decision [12 -- 14]. There are a number of studies that have attempted to quantify such dependencies under uncertainty and obtain estimations for the likelihood of diseases given a subset of findings [11, 15 -- 20]. An essential simplifying assumption in these studies was that only one disease is behind the findings (exclusive diseases assumption). Among recent developments, we should mention Bayesian belief networks, which provide a proba- bilistic framework to study sign-disease dependencies [21 -- 24]. These models are represented by tables of conditional probabilities that show how the state of a node (sign or disease) variable in an acyclic directed graph depends on the state of the parent variables. Here, it is usually assumed that the signs are conditionally independent of one another given a disease hypothesis and that diseases are independent of one another after marginalizing over the sign variables (marginally independent diseases)[22]. In other words, there exist no causal dependencies or interactions (directed links in the acyclic graph) that connect the signs/diseases. In this study, however, we shall pursue a more principled approach to 3 highlight the significance of direct disease-disease and sign-sign interactions (dependencies). Evidences are rapidly growing to support the existence of such interactions [25 -- 32]. Our approach is of course computationally more expensive than the previous approaches, but it shows how different types of interactions could be helpful in the course of diagnosis. Addi- tionally, because of recent developments in related fields [33 -- 36], we now have the necessary concepts and tools to address difficulties in more sophisticated (realistic) problems of this type. This study does not involve usage of real medical data, which is by the way fun- damentally incomplete at this moment for such modeling; however, it provides a rationale as to why certain often-neglected statistical information and medical data can be useful in diagnosis and demonstrates that investments in collecting such data will likely pay off. II. PROBLEM STATEMENT Consider a set of ND binary variables D = {Da = 0, 1 : a = 1, . . . , ND}, where Da = 0, 1 shows the absence or presence of disease a. We have another set of NS binary variables S = {Si = ±1 : i = 1, . . . , NS} to show the values of sign (symptom) variables. Suppose we have the conditional probability of symptoms given a disease hypothesis, P (SD), and prior probability of diseases P0(D). Then, the joint probability distribution of sign and disease variables reads as P (S; D) ≡ P (SD)P0(D). We shall assume, for simplicity, that the probability distributions describe the stationary state of the variables. The distributions may be subject to environmental and evolutionary changes and may also change in the course of the disease. Here, we limit our study to the time scales that are smaller than the dynamical time scale of the model and leave the temporal dynamics for a future study. In addition, we assume that we are given sufficient statistical data, e.g., the true marginal probabilities Ptrue(Si, SjD), to reconstruct simple models of the true probability III A, we propose distribution [37]. This is indeed the first part of our study: In Sec. statistical models of sign and disease variables, and employ efficient learning algorithms to compute the model parameters, given the appropriate data. Fortunately, recent advances in machine learning and inference techniques enable us to work with models that involve very large number of variables [36, 38 -- 45]. Let us assume that a subset O = {i1, i2, . . . , iNO} of the sign variables has been observed with values So, and size NO = O. We will use U for the remaining subset of unobserved 4 signs with values which are denoted by Su. Then, the likelihood of disease variables given the observed signs is: The most likely diseases are obtained by maximizing the above likelihood: L(DSo) ≡XSu P (S; D). DM L = arg max D log L(DSo). (1) (2) Here, we are interested in the posterior probability marginals P (Da = 0, 1) of the disease variables. The marginal probability P (Sj = ±1) of an unobserved sign, and the most likely signs, are obtained from the following distribution: M(SuSo) ≡XD P (S; D), SM L = arg max Su log M(SuSo). (3) The main task in the second part of our study is computation of the sign and disease marginal probabilities P (Da) ∝ X{Db:b6=a} L(DSo), P (Sj) ∝ X{Sk:k∈U \j} M(SuSo) j ∈ U. (4) In general, computing the exact values of these marginals is a hard problem. However, one can find highly accurate approximation methods developed in the artificial intelligence and statistical physics communities to address such computationally difficult problems [33, 34, 46 -- 49]. In Sec. III B, we propose an approximate message-passing algorithm for inferring the above information in a large-scale problem. Finally, the last and main part of our study is devoted to the problem of choosing a finite sequence of unobserved signs for observation, which maximizes an appropriate objective functional of the sequence of observations. In principle, the objective function should be designed to approach the right diagnosis in a small number of observations. To this end, we assign larger values to the objective function if the observations result to larger polarization in the disease probabilities; obviously, it is easier to decide if disease a is present or not when the marginal probability P (Da) is closer to 0 or 1 (more polarized). Computing such an objective functional of the disease probabilities for a given sequence of observations is not an easy task. We have to consider also the stochastic nature of the observations; we know the sign probabilities P (Sj), but, we do not know a priori the value Sj of an unobserved sign, 5 which is chosen for observation. To take into account this uncertainty, we shall work with an objective function which is averaged over the possible outcomes of the observation. More precisely, the above diagnosis problem is a multistage stochastic optimization problem, a subject that has been extensively studied in the optimization community [35, 50 -- 52]. Suppose we are to observe T ≤ NS − NO signs with an specified order OT ≡ {j1, . . . , jT}; there are (NS − NO)!/(T !(NS − NO − T )!) different ways of choosing T signs from NS − NO ones, and T ! different orderings of the selected signs to identify such a sequence of observations. Therefore, the number of possible sequences grows exponentially with T . Add to this the computational complexity of working with an objective functional of the sequence of observations, which has to be also averaged over the stochastic outcomes of the observations. In Sec. III C, we present simple heuristic and greedy algorithms to address the above problem, and leave a detailed study of the multistage stochastic optimization problem for future. III. RESULTS A complete description of a collection of stochastic variables, like the sign and disease variables, is provided by the joint probability distribution of the variables P (S; D). Having the probability distribution (model) that describes a system of interacting variables does not, however, mean that one can readily extract useful statistical information from the model. In fact, both the model construction and the task of extracting information from the model are computationally hard, with computation times that in the worst cases grow exponentially with the number of involved variables [53 -- 57]. In the following, we address the above sub- problems in addition to the main problem of optimizing an appropriate objective functional of observations, which are made during the course of diagnosis. A. Learning the model: Maximum entropy principle Let us assume that we are given the marginal probabilities Ptrue(Si, SjD) of the true conditional probability Ptrue(SD). Then, we use the maximum entropy principle to con- struct an appropriate model P (S; D) ≡ P (SD)P0(D) of the sign and disease variables [58 -- 60]. Here, P0(D) is the prior probability of the diseases depending on the age, gender, 6 P(SD) P (D) 0 b a P(S0) j i α Prior Disease Interaction Sign Leak FIG. 1. The interaction graph of disease variables (left circles) and sign variables (right circles) related by Ma one-disease and Mab two-disease interaction factors (middle squares) in addition to interactions induced by the leak probability (right square) and the prior probability of diseases (left square). In general, an interaction factor α = a, ab is connected to kα signs and lα diseases. and other characteristics. In the following, we simply take a product prior distribution, P0(D) = Qa P0(Da). In the absence of any prior information, the above probability dis- tribution is uniform. The conditional probability P (SD) represents all the sign/disease interactions that are allowed by the maximum entropy principle, P (SD) = 1 Z(D) exp Xi hi(D)Si +Xi<j Jij(D)SiSj! . (5) Here Z(D) is the normalization (or partition) function. In practice, we are given only a small subset of the conditional probabilities, for instance, Ptrue(Si, SjonlyDa) and Ptrue(Si, SjonlyDa, Db). The former is the probability that signs i and j take values (Si = ±1, Sj = ±1) conditioned to the presence of disease a and the absence of all other diseases. The latter conditional probabilities are defined similarly. Therefore, we have to consider only interactions between a small number of disease variables. To this end, we expand the model parameters, hi(D) = h0 ha i +Xa ij +Xa i Da +Xa<b ijDa +Xa<b J a Jij(D) = J 0 hab i DaDb + · · · , J ab ij DaDb + · · · , (6) (7) and keep only the leading terms of the expansion. Putting all together, given the above 7 information, we rewrite P (SD) = 1 Z(D) φ0(S) ×Ya φa(SDa) ×Ya<b φab(SDa, Db). (8) Here, φ0 is responsible for the leak probabilities P (Snodisease), to account for the missing disease information and other sources of error [22, 24]. In the following, we assume that local sign fields are sufficient to produce an accurate representation of the leak probabilities, i Si) . The other interaction factors, φa and φab, are present only if the associated diseases are present; they are written in terms of local sign fields and two-sign i.e., φ0 = exp(Pi K 0 interactions: K a φa = exp(Da[Xi φab = exp(DaDb[Xi K a i Si +Xi<j i Si +Xi<j K ab ijSiSj]), K ab ij SiSj]). (9) (10) Figure 1 shows a graphical representation of the model, which has Ma one-disease and Mab two-disease interaction factors, each of which is connected to ka and kab sign variables, respectively. From the above model, we obtain the simpler one-disease-one-sign (D1S1) model in which we have only the one-disease factors (i.e., Mab = 0) and local sign fields (i.e., K a ij = 0). In a two-disease-one-sign model (D2S1), we have both the one- and two-disease factors, but only the local sign fields. In the same way, we define the one-disease-two- sign (D1S2) and two-disease-two-sign (D2S2) models. In the following, unless otherwise mentioned, we shall work with the fully connected graphs with parameters: Ma = ND, ka = NS for the D1S1 and D1S2 models, and Ma = ND, Mab = ND(ND − 1)/2, ka = kab = NS for the D2S1 and D2S2 models. Moreover, the interaction factors in the D1S2 and D2S2 models include all the possible two-sign interactions in addition to the local sign fields. To obtain the model parameters (K 0 ), we start from the conditional marginals Ptrue(Sinodisease). This information is sufficient to determine the couplings K 0 from the following consistency equations: , and K a,ab i , K a,ab ij i i Ptrue(Sinodisease) = X{Sj :j6=i} P (SD = 0) ∀i. (11) If we have Ptrue(Si, SjonlyDa), then in principle we can find K a consistency equations, assuming that we already know the K 0 i and K a ij from similar i . Note that P (Si, SjonlyDa) 8 is different from P (Si, SjDa), which is conditioned only on the value of disease a. In the same way, having the Ptrue(Si, SjonlyDa, Db) allow us to find the couplings K ab i and K ab ij , In general, the problem of finding the couplings from the above conditional and so on. probabilities is computationally expensive. However, there are many efficient approximate methods that enable us to find good estimations for the above couplings given the above conditional probabilities [36, 38 -- 41, 43, 45]. The reader can find more details about the models in Appendix A, where we provide a very simple learning algorithm, which is based on the Bethe approximation, for estimating the model parameters, given the above marginal probabilities. B. Computing the marginal probabilities: An approximate inference algorithm Let us consider a simple benchmark model to check the performances of the above con- structed models. As the benchmark, we take the true conditional probability Ptrue(SD) = 1 Ztrue(D) e−H(S,S∗(D)), (12) where S∗(D) gives the symptoms of hypothesis D; we choose these symptoms randomly and i (D))2/4 is the Hamming distance (number of different signs) of the two sign configurations. Note uniformly from the space of sign variables. Moreover, H(S, S∗(D)) ≡PNS i=1(Si − S∗ that there is no sign-sign interaction in the above true model. Therefore, given the true con- ditional marginals, we can exactly compute the model parameters, as described in Appendix A. For small numbers of sign/disease variables, we can use an exhaustive inference al- gorithm to compute the exact marginal probabilities. Figure 2 displays the sensitivity P (Si = +1Da = 1) and specificity P (Si = −1Da = 0) of the diseases [24], which have been obtained by the one-disease-one-sing (D1S1) and two-disease-one-sing (D2S1) models for a typical realization of the symptoms S∗(D) in the true model. As the figure shows, both the probabilities are in average closer to the true values in the D2S1 model. This computa- tion is intended to exhibit the high impact of two-disease interactions on the behavior of the marginal probabilities. We will soon see that these large effects of interactions can indeed play a constructive role also in the process of diagnosis. To infer the marginal probabilities of the models for larger number of sign/disease vari- 9 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0.3 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 y t i v i t i s n e s y t i c i f i c e p s 0.35 0.4 0.45 0.5 0.55 0.6 0.65 0.1 0.35 0.4 0.45 0.5 0.55 0.6 0.65 0.7 FIG. 2. Sensitivity, P (Si = +1Da = 1), and specificity, P (Si = −1Da = 0), of the D1S1 (open circles) and D2S1 (filled circles) models versus the true values for a typical realization of the exponential true model. The model parameters are obtained from the conditional marginals of the true model. Here we have ND = 5 diseases, NS = 20 signs. ables, we resort to the Bethe approximation and the Belief-Propagation algorithm [34, 47]. First, we suggest an approximate expression for the normalization function Z(D), which appears in the denominator of the conditional probability distribution P (SD). In words, we consider this non-negative function of the diseases to be a probability measure, and we approximate this measure by a factorized probability distribution, using its one- and two- variable marginal probabilities (see Appendix B). This approximation enables us to employ an efficient message-passing algorithm such as belief propagation for computing statistical properties of the above models. As mentioned before, we shall assume that the prior prob- ability P0(D) can also be written in an appropriate factorized form. The quality of our ap- proximations depends very much on the structure of the interaction factors and the strengths of the associated couplings in the models. The Bethe approximation is exact for interaction 10 graphs that have a tree structure. This approximation is also expected to work very well in sparsely connected graphs, in which the number of interaction factors (Ma, Mab) and the number of signs associated with an interaction factor (ka, kab) are small compared with the total number of sign variables. In Appendix B we display the relative errors in the marginal signs/diseases probabilities that were obtained by the above approximate algorithm. The time complexity of our approximate inference algorithm grows linearly with the number of interaction factors and exponentially with the number of variables that are involved in such interactions; with ND = 500, NS = 5000, Ma = 500, Mab = 1000, ka = 10, kab = 5, the algorithm takes approximately one minute of CPU time on a standard PC to compute the local marginals. We recall that the INTERNIST algorithm works with 534 diseases and approximately 4040 signs (or manifestations), with 40740 directed links that connect the diseases to the signs [22]. C. Optimization of the diagnosis process: A stochastic optimization problem Suppose that we know the results of NO observations (medical tests), and we choose another unobserved sign j ∈ U for observation. To measure the performance of our decision, we may compute deviation of the disease probabilities from the neutral values (or "disease polarization") after the observation: DP (j) ≡ 1 ND Xa (cid:18)P (Da = 1) − 1 2(cid:19)2!1/2 . (13) One can also add other measures such as the cost of observation to the above function. In a two-stage decision problem, we choose an unobserved sign for observation, with the aim of maximizing the averaged objective function E(j) ≡ hDP (j)iO. Note that before doing any real observation, we have access only to the probability of the outcomes P (Sj); the actual or true value of an unobserved sign becomes clear only after the observation. That is why here we are taking the average over the possible outcomes, which is denoted by h·iO. One can repeat the two-stage problem for T times to obtain a sequence of T observations: each time an optimal sign is chosen for observation followed by a real observation, which reveals the true value of the observed sign. In a multistage version of the problem, we want to find an optimal sequence of decisions OT = {j1,· · · , jT}, which maximizes the following objective functional of the observed 11 signs: E[OT ] ≡ PT t=1hDP (jt)iO. Here, at each step, the "observed" sign takes a value that is sampled from the associated marginal probability P (Sj). This probability depends on the model which we are working with. Note that here we are interested in finding an optimal sequence of observations at the beginning of the process before doing any real observation. In other words, in such a multistage problem, we are doing an "extrapolation" or "simulation" of the observation process without performing any real observation. In practice, however, we may fix the sequence of observations by a decimation algorithm: i.e., we repeat the multistage problem for T times, where each time we observe the first sign suggested by the output sequence, and reduce the number of to-be-observed sings by one. In the following, we consider only simple approximations of the multistage problem; first we reduce the difficult multistage problem to simpler two-stage problems. More precisely, at each time step, we choose an unobserved sign jt, which results to the largest disease polarization hDP (jt)iO, for observation (greedy strategy). Then, we consider two cases: (I) we perform a real observation to reveal the true value of the suggested sign for observation, (II) we treat the suggested sign variable for observation as a stochastic variable with values that are sampled from the associated marginal probability. Let us start from the case in which we observe the true values of the signs chosen for observation. Once again, we take the exponential benchmark model given by Eq. 12 as the true model. We use the conditional marginals extracted from this true model to construct the simple one-disease-one-sign (D1S1) and two-disease-one-sign (D2S1) models. Suppose that we are given a disease hypothesis D and the associated symptoms S∗(D). We start from a few randomly chosen observed sings from the set of symptoms. Then, at each time step t, we compute the inferred sign probabilities P (Sj), and use the greedy strategy to choose an unobserved sign for observation. The observed sign at each step takes the true value given by S∗(D). To see how much the disease probabilities obtained from the models are correlated with the true hypothesis D, after each observation, we compute the following overlap function (or "disease likelihood"): DL(t) ≡ 1 ND Xa (2Da − 1)(cid:18)P (Da = 1) − 1 2(cid:19) . (14) Besides the magnitude, our decisions also affect the way that the above quantity behaves with the number of observations. In Fig. 3 we see how the above overlap function, DL(t), behaves for cases in which 12 d o o h i l e k i l e s a e s d i d o o h i l e k i l e s a e s d i 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 (a) 0 2 (b) 0 2 D1S1 (G) D2S1 (G) D1S1 (Random) D2S1 (Random) 6 4 number of observations 8 10 12 14 16 D1S1 (G) D2S1 (G) D1S1 (Random) D2S1 (Random) 6 4 number of observations 8 10 12 14 16 FIG. 3. Overlap of the inferred disease marginals with the true hypothesis for the exponential benchmark model. The data are for the cases in which only one (a) or two (b) diseases are present. The model parameters are obtained from the conditional marginals of the true model. There are ND = 5 diseases, NS = 20 signs, and the algorithm starts with NO = 3 observed signs for a randomly selected hypothesis D. An unobserved sign is chosen for observation by the greedy (G) or random strategy using the inferred probabilities, and the observed sign takes the true value given by S∗(D). The data are results of averaging over 1000 independent realizations of the true model and the observation process. only one or two diseases are present in D (see also Appendix C). For comparison, we also show the results obtained by a random strategy, where an unobserved sign is chosen for observation randomly and uniformly from the subset of unobserved signs. The number of sign/disease variables here is small enough to allow for an exact computation of all the marginal probabilities. It is seen that both the D1S1 and D2S1 models work very well when only one disease is present and all the other diseases are absent. The D1S1 model already fails when two diseases are present in the hypothesis, whereas the other model can still find 13 the right diseases. However, we observe that even the D2S1 model gets confused when there are more than two diseases in the hypothesis; in such cases, we would need to consider more sophisticated models with interactions involving more than two diseases. Moreover, we observe that the difference in the performances of the greedy and random strategies decreases as the number of involved diseases increases. In Appendix C, we observe similar behaviors for a more complex benchmark model Ptrue(SD) ∝ 1/(1 + H(S, S∗(D))), including also the sign-sign interactions. Next, we consider the case of simulating the diagnosis process without doing any real ob- servation. Here, we assume that an observed sign takes a value which is sampled from the as- sociated marginal probability P (Sj) at that time step. For comparison with the greedy strat- egy, we also introduce two other strategies for choosing an unobserved sign for observation. A naive strategy is to choose the most positive (MP) sign jmax = arg maxj{P (Sj = +1)} for observation (MP strategy); jmax is the sign with the maximum probability of being positive. In the early stages of the diagnosis, this probability is probably close to zero for most of the signs. So, it makes sense to choose the most positive sign for observation to obtain more information about the diseases. A more complicated strategy works by first computing the conditional probabilities P (SjDM L) for the maximum likelihood hypothesis DM L, and then selecting the most positive sign for observation (MPD strategy). To have a more general comparison of the constructed models, in the following, we assume , and K a,ab ij i that the model parameters (K a,ab ) are iid random numbers uniformly distributed in an appropriate interval of real numbers. The leaky couplings are set to K 0 i = −1, which correspond to small sign probabilities P (Si = 1nodisease) ≃ 0.05. We assume that all the possible one-disease and two-disease interaction factors are present in the models. Moreover, inside each factor we have all the possible two-sign interactions in addition to the local sign fields. As before, the prior disease probabilities P0(Da) are uniform probability distributions. Figure 4 shows the performances for different models and strategies with a small number of sign/disease variables. Here, the "disease likelihood" gives the overlap of the disease probabilities with the maximum likelihood hypothesis DM L of the models. Moreover, all the quantities are computed exactly. We see that in this case the average performance of the greedy strategy is close to that of the MPD strategy at the beginning of the process. For larger number of observations, the greedy performance degrades and approaches that of the MP strategy. 14 n o i t l a z i r a o p e s a e s d i n o i t a z i r a o p l e s a e s d i 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 D1S1 D2S1 D1S2 D2S2 (a) 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations (c) D2S2: MPD G MP Random 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations d o o h i l e k i l e s a e s d i d o o h i l e k i l e s a e s d i 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 D1S1 D2S1 D1S2 D2S2 (b) 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations (d) D2S2: MPD G MP Random 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations FIG. 4. Diagnostic performance of the models vs the number of observations for a small number of sign/disease variables. (top) The exact disease-polarization (a) and disease-likelihood (b) obtained by the MP strategy in the one-disease-one-sign (D1S1), two-disease-one-sign (D2S1), one-disease- two-sign (D1S2), and two-disease-two-sign (D2S2) models. There are ND = 5 diseases, NS = 20 signs, and the algorithm starts with NO = 4 observed signs with positive values. The couplings in the interaction factors are iid random numbers distributed uniformly in the specified intervals: i = −1, K a,ab K 0 (c) and likelihood (d) of the diseases obtained by the MP, greedy (G), MPD, and random strategies, ij ∈ (−1, +1)/√NS. (bottom) Comparing the exact polarization ∈ (−1, +1), K a,ab i for the D2S2 model. The data are results of averaging over 1000 independent realizations of the model parameters. The models with disease-disease and sign-sign interactions exhibit larger polarizations of the disease probabilities and larger overlaps of the disease probabilities with the maximum- likelihood hypothesis (see also Appendix C); we find that already the D2S1 model works considerably better than the D1S1 model for disease-disease interactions of relative strengths K ab i ≃ 0.3. A larger polarization means that we need a smaller number of observations (medical tests) to obtain more definitive disease probabilities. A larger disease likelihood, i /K a 15 here means that we are following the direction that is suggested by the most likely diseases. In this sense, it appears that the two-sign/disease interactions could be very helpful in the early stages of the diagnosis. We checked that the above picture also holds if we start with different numbers of observed signs, and if we double the magnitude of all the couplings. Similar behaviors are observed also for larger problem sizes (see Appendix C). However, we see that for i = −1, ij ∈ (−2, +2)/√NS, the MP strategy gets closer to the random strongly interacting models with much larger higher-order interactions, e.g., K 0 and K a,ab i ∈ (−2, +2), K a,ab strategy. The fact that the MP strategy does not work well in this strongly correlated regime was indeed expected. Here, the greedy strategy is working better than the MPD strategy, and both are still performing better than the random strategy. IV. DISCUSSIONS In summary, we showed that considering the sign-sign and disease-disease interactions can significantly change the statistical importance of the signs and diseases. More importantly, we found that these higher-order correlations could be very helpful in the process of diagnosis, especially in the early stages of the diagnosis. The results in Figs. 3 and 4 (and similar figures in appendices) also indicate the significance and relevance of optimization of the diagnosis procedure, where a good strategy could considerably increase the polarization and likelihood of the diseases compared to the random strategy. In addition, we devised an approximate inference algorithm with a time complexity that grows linearly with the number of interaction factors connecting the diseases to the signs, and exponentially with the maximum number of signs that are associated with such interaction factors. For clarity, in this work, we considered only algorithms of minimal structure and complexity. It would be straightforward to employ more accurate learning and inference algorithms in constructing the models and inferring the statistical information from the models. The challenge is, of course, to go beyond the heuristic and greedy algorithms that we used to study the multistage stochastic optimization problem of deciding on the relevance and order of the medical observations. In this study, we considered very simple structures for the prior probability of the dis- eases P0(D) and the leak probability of the signs P (Snodisease). Obviously, depending 16 on the available statistical data, we can obtain more reliable models also for these prob- ability distributions. Alternatively, we could employ the maximum entropy principle to construct directly the joint probability distribution of the sign and disease variables using the joint marginal probabilities P (Si, Sj; Da, Db). Note that, in practice, it is easier to ob- tain this type of information than the stronger conditional probabilities P (Si, SjonlyDa) and P (Si, SjonlyDa, Db). However, these measures are easier to model (or estimated by experts), in the absence of enough observational data, because they present the sole effects of single (or few) diseases. The emphasize, in this study, was more on the diagnostic performances of the inferred models than on the statistical significance of the selected models for a given set of clinical data. A more accurate treatment of the model selection, for a finite collection of data, accounts also the complexity of the models to avoid the over-fitting of the data. However, we note that including the sign-sign and disease-disease interactions in the models is indeed more natural than ignoring such correlations. Finally, to take into account the role of noises in the model parameters, one should take the average of the objective function over the probability distribution of the parameters, which is provided by the likelihood of the model parameters. Our proposed framework can be adapted to address assignment problems in cell biology, immunology, and evolutionary biology [61 -- 63, 65]. In contrast to clinical problems, here data availability might be less of a problem in near future. Advances in genomics, transcrip- tomics, proteomics and metabolomics promise high resolution molecular characterization of cells. Intensive research has also been directed towards live single cell analysis which allows characterization of pathways from an initial state to a final state [64]. Our approach can be used to do early assignments and thus not only provides accuracy but also an improved sensitivity for diagnostics at the cellular level. 17 Appendix A: Details of the models In this section, we give more details of the models, and show how the model parameters are computed given the following true marginal probabilities: Ptrue(Sinodisease), Ptrue(Si, SjonlyDa), Ptrue(Si, SjonlyDa, Db), ∀i, ∀i 6= j&a, ∀i 6= j&a 6= b. (A1) (A2) (A3) 1. Case of one-disease-one-sign interactions: D1S1 model The simplest model is obtained by considering only the one-disease factors besides the leaky interactions. In addition, we assume that each factor contains only local sign fields, i.e., φ0(S) = ePi K 0 i Si, φa(SDa) = eDa Pi K a i Si, φab(SDa, Db) = · · · = 1. Here, the couplings are K 0 i = K a i = 1 2 1 2 Ptrue(Si = −1nodisease)(cid:19) , ln(cid:18) Ptrue(Si = +1nodisease) Ptrue(Si = −1onlyDa)(cid:19) − K 0 ln(cid:18) Ptrue(Si = +1onlyDa) i . Then the partition function reads Z(D) =Yi 2 cosh(K 0 i +Xa DaK a i )! . The likelihood of diseases is given by (A4) (A5) (A6) (A7) (A8) P0(Da). (A9) L(DSo) =Yi∈O e(K 0 i +Pa DaK a i )Si 2 cosh(K 0 i +Pa DaK a i )! ×Ya Note that after summing over the sign variables the disease variables become correlated and the problem of computing the marginals is not straightforward. The same problem arises in computation of the probability distribution of unobserved signs, M(SuSo) =XD Yi e(K 0 i +Pa DaK a i )Si 2 cosh(K 0 i +Pa DaK a i )! ×Ya 18 P0(Da). (A10) For the moment, we assume the number of involved variables ND,S are small enough to do the above computations exactly. For larger number of variables, we have to resort to an approximate algorithm. We will describe such an approximate algorithm later when we consider more serious examples. 2. Case of two-disease-one-sign interactions: D2S1 model Now we consider the more interesting case of one- and two-disease interaction factors. Again, we assume that each factor contains only local sign fields, i.e., φ0(S) = ePi K 0 i Si, φa(SDa) = eDa Pi K a i Si, φab(SDa, Db) = eDaDb Pi K ab i Si, φabc(SDa, Db, Dc) = · · · = 1. Here, the couplings are K 0 i = K a i = K ab i = 1 2 1 2 1 2 Ptrue(Si = −1nodisease)(cid:19) , ln(cid:18) Ptrue(Si = +1nodisease) Ptrue(Si = −1onlyDa)(cid:19) − K 0 ln(cid:18) Ptrue(Si = +1onlyDa) Ptrue(Si = −1onlyDa, Db)(cid:19) − K 0 ln(cid:18) Ptrue(Si = +1onlyDa, Db) i , i − K a i − K b i . Still, we can easily obtain the partition function Z(D) =Yi 2 cosh(K 0 i +Xa DaK a i +Xa<b DaDbK ab i )! . (A11) (A12) (A13) (A14) (A15) (A16) (A17) The likelihood reads L(DSo) =Yi∈O Similarly, e(K 0 2 cosh(K 0 i +Pa DaK a i +Pa<b DaDbK ab i )Si i +Pa DaK a i +Pa<b DaDbK ab i )! ×Ya P0(Da). (A18) M(SuSo) =XD Yi e(K 0 2 cosh(K 0 i +Pa DaK a i +Pa<b DaDbK ab i )Si i +Pa DaK a i +Pa<b DaDbK ab 19 i )! ×Ya P0(Da). (A19) 3. Introducing the two-sign interactions: D1S2 and D2S2 models A more challenging model is obtained with the two-sign interactions φ0(S) = ePi K 0 i Si, φa(SDa) = eDa[Pi K a i Si+Pi<j K a ijSiSj ], φab(SDa, Db) = eDaDb[Pi K ab i Si+Pi<j K ab ij SiSj], (A20) (A21) (A22) φabc(SDa, Db, Dc) = · · · = 1. Here, even computing the partition function is difficult, and from the beginning we have to resort to approximations. First of all, we need to obtain the couplings given the conditional probabilities, P0(Si) ≡ Ptrue(Sinodisease), Pa(Si, Sj) ≡ Ptrue(Si, SjonlyDa), Pab(Si, Sj) ≡ Ptrue(Si, SjonlyDa, Db), Pa(Si) ≡ Ptrue(SionlyDa), Pab(Si) ≡ Ptrue(SionlyDa, Db). As before, the zero-order couplings are given by K 0 i = 1 2 P0(Si = −1)(cid:19) . ln(cid:18) P0(Si = +1) (A23) (A24) (A25) (A26) To obtain the other couplings, we resort to the so-called independent-pair approximation [43], where we assume Pa(Si, Sj) ∝ eK a Pab(Si, Sj) ∝ eK ab ijSiSj +ha ijSi+ha jiSj , ij SiSj +hab ij Si+hab ji Sj , i Si Pa(Si) ∝ eha Pab(Si) ∝ ehab i Si. In this way we obtain, K a ij = K ab ij = 1 4 1 4 Pa(Si = +1, Sj = −1)Pa(Si = −1, Sj = +1)(cid:19) , ln(cid:18)Pa(Si = +1, Sj = +1)Pa(Si = −1, Sj = −1) Pab(Si = +1, Sj = −1)Pab(Si = −1, Sj = +1)(cid:19) − K a ln(cid:18)Pab(Si = +1, Sj = +1)Pab(Si = −1, Sj = −1) ij − K b ij, and K a i = 1 4Xj6=i ln(cid:18) Pa(Si = +1, Sj = +1)Pa(Si = +1, Sj = −1) Pa(Si = −1, Sj = −1)Pa(Si = −1, Sj = +1)(cid:19) (NS − 2) 2 − 20 ln(cid:18) Pa(Si = +1) Pa(Si = −1)(cid:19) − K 0 i , (A27) (A28) (A29) (A30) (A31) i g n g n a h c f o y t i l i b a b o r p i e s a e s d P M e h t i g n g n a h c f o y t i l i b a b o r p i n g s P M e h t 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 (a) D1S1 D2S1 D1S2 D2S2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 noise strength (b) D1S1 D2S1 D1S2 D2S2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 noise strength FIG. 5. Probability of changing the most probable (MP) disease (a) and sign (b) variable in the one-disease-one-sign (D1S1), two-disease-one-sign (D2S1), one-disease-two-sign (D1S2), and two- disease-two-sign (D2S2) models. There are ND = 5 diseases, NS = 15 signs, and NO = 3 observed signs with positive values. The couplings in the interaction factors are iid random numbers dis- tributed uniformly in the specified intervals: K 0 i = −1, K a,ab i ∈ (−1, +1), K a,ab ij ∈ (−1, +1)/√NS. ij ∈ (−ǫ, +ǫ)/√NS. The A noise of strength ǫ changes the couplings by δK a,ab i ∈ (−ǫ, +ǫ), δK a,ab data have been obtained from 1000 independent realizations of the model parameters. K ab i = 1 4Xj6=i ln(cid:18) Pab(Si = +1, Sj = +1)Pab(Si = +1, Sj = −1) Pab(Si = −1, Sj = −1)Pab(Si = −1, Sj = +1)(cid:19) ln(cid:18) Pab(Si = +1) Pab(Si = −1)(cid:19) − K 0 (NS − 2) − 2 i − K a i − K b i . (A32) One can find other approximation methods in the literature to address the above inverse problem. For example, one can employ the exact fluctuation-response relations within the Bethe approximation to obtain more accurate estimations for the marginal probability dis- tribution of sign variables [36, 45]. 21 Note that the model parameters are usually noisy because they may come from an ap- proximate learning algorithm with a finite collection of clinical data. Thus, it is important to know how the noise strength affects the marginal sign/disease probabilities. In Fig. 5, we show how much the uncertainties in the model parameters are likely to change the sign/disease with the highest probability of being positive/present. We see that this prob- ability increases linearly with the relative strength of the noise in the model parameters ǫ ≡ δK/K; for example, in a small model of ND = 5 diseases, NS = 15 signs with NO = 3 observed signs, a noise of strength ǫ = 0.1 changes the most probable sign/disease in nearly %10 of the cases. Appendix B: An approximate inference algorithm In this section, we present an approximate way of computing the sign/disease marginal probabilities. To be specific, we will focus on the two-disease-two-sign (D2S2) model. We will consider the joint measure P (S; D) = P (SD)P0(D) ∝ e−H(S;D), (B1) of the disease and sign variables. Here, we defined the energy function H(S; D) ≡ −Xi K 0 i Si −Xa Xa<b Da[Xi DaDb[Xi K a ijSiSj]− K a i Si +Xi<j i Si +Xi<j K ab K ab ij SiSj] + ln Z(D) − ln P0(D). (B2) We may obtain the local probability marginals by a Monte Carlo (MC) algorithm for the above system of interacting variables. But computing the above energy function for a given configuration of the variables is computationally hard because computing Z(D) is in general hard. Thus, to reduce the computation time we have to find a good approximation for the partition function. The exact expression for the partition function is Z(D) =XS φ0(S) ×Ya φa(SDa) ×Ya<b φab(SDa, Db), (B3) 22 which in terms of the couplings reads ePi hi(D)Si+Pi<j Jij(D)SiSj , DaDbK ab i , Z(D) =XS hi(D) ≡ K 0 Jij(D) ≡Xa DaK a i +Xa<b i +Xa DaK a DaDbK ab ij . ij +Xa<b (B4) (B5) (B6) We are going to use the Bethe approximation to find an estimation for the above partition function [34, 46, 47]. More precisely, in this approximation, we assume that the interaction graph of the variables (defined by the couplings Jij) is a tree graph. We know how to compute exactly and efficiently the local marginal probabilities and the partition function in tree interaction graphs. The fact that there is no loop in a tree graph allows us to write the marginal probability of a variable in terms of the cavity probabilities of the neighboring variables, computed in the absence of the interested variable. These cavity probabilities are the main quantities of the Bethe approximation. Here, e.g., we need to compute the cavity marginals µi→j(Si), giving the probability of value Si for sign i in the absence of sign j. The Bethe equations governing these cavity marginals are the following recursive equations [34]: µi→j(Si) = 1 zi→j ehiSi Yk6=i,j XSk eJikSiSkµk→i(Sk)! , (B7) where zi→j is a normalization constant. We can solve these equations by iteration starting from random initial cavity marginals; the cavity marginals are updated according to the above equations in a random and sequential way, until the algorithm converges. Then, we use these stationary cavity marginals to compute the local probabilities and the partition function [34]. In this way, for the partition function within the Bethe approximation, we obtain Z(D) ≃ ePi ∆i(D)−Pi<j ∆ij(D),  XSj e∆i(D) ≡XSi e∆ij (D) ≡ XSi,Sj ehiSiYj6=i eJijSiSj µi→j(Si)µj→i(Sj). eJij SiSj µj→i(Sj)  , (B8) (B9) (B10) Notice that here the cavity marginals µi→j(Si) depend implicitly on the disease variables. Now, we can compute efficiently an approximate change in the energy function H(S; D) 23 when a disease variable is chosen for updating in a Monte Carlo algorithm. In the same way, we may find an estimate of the likelihood of diseases by L(DSo) = Z(DSo) Z(D) P0(D), where Z(DSo) =XSu φ0(S) ×Ya φa(SDa) ×Ya<b φab(SDa, Db), (B11) (B12) can be estimated within the Bethe approximation, as we did for Z(D), but with fixed values for the observed signs. This approximate expression for the likelihood is useful to find the most likely diseases DM L maximizing the likelihood. Finding the maximum likelihood hypothesis DM L, and obtaining good estimations for the probability marginals of P (S; D) could be still very time consuming for a large number of variables and frustrating energy functions. In the following, we will utilize the Bethe approximation to estimate the above marginal probabilities. 1. Belief propagation equations The interaction factors associated to diseases a and (ab) are K a φa = exp Da[Xi φab = exp DaDb[Xi K a i Si +Xi<j i Si +Xi<j K ab ijSiSj]! , ij SiSj]! , K ab (B13) (B14) respectively. Let us label the above interactions with α ∈ {a, b, . . . , (ab), (ac), . . .} and use φα(SαDα) for the corresponding interaction factors. We represent the subset of sign and disease variables in an interaction factor with ∂Sα and ∂Dα. The subset of interaction factors depending on sign i and disease a are denoted by ∂i and ∂a, respectively. We will assume that the resulting interaction graph is sparse, that is the numbers of interaction factors (Ma, Mab) are small compared to NS, and the numbers of sign variables involved in the interaction factors (ka, kab) are of order one. We take νi→α(Si) for the probability of having value Si for sign i in the absence of interaction factor α. Similarly, define the cavity probabilities νa→α(Da). In the Bethe approximation, we write approximate expressions for 24 these cavity marginals in terms of the messages received from the other interaction factors in the system [34, 47]. More precisely, Ψβ→i(Si), i Si Yβ∈∂i6=α νi→α(Si) ∝ eK 0 νa→α(Da) ∝ P0(Da) Yβ∈∂a6=α Ψβ→a(Da)ΨZ→a(Da). (B15) (B16) Note that the equation for νi→α(Si) gives the cavity marginal for an unobserved sign; the cavity marginals of observed signs are fixed to values determined by the observations. The cavity messages received from the interaction factors are given by Ψα→i(Si) ∝ X{Da:a∈∂Dα} X{Sj:j∈∂Sα\i} Ψα→a(Da) ∝ X{Db:b∈∂Dα\a} X{Sj :j∈∂Sα} φα(SαDα) Ya∈∂Dα φα(SαDα) Yb∈∂Dα\a νa→α(Da) Yj∈∂Sα\i νb→α(Db) Yj∈∂Sα νj→α(Sj), (B17) νj→α(Sj). (B18) It remains to write the cavity marginals related to the partition function Z(D), Ψα→a(Da), νa→Z(Da) ∝ P0(Da) Yα∈∂a ΨZ→a(Da) ∝ X{Db:b6=a} e− ln Z(D)Yb6=a νb→Z(Db). (B19) (B20) The main difficulty comes from the last equation, where one has to sum over all possible values of the disease variables and compute Z(D) for each configuration. We already know how to compute the partition function by the Bethe approximation. But, the sum over the disease variables grows exponentially with the number of variables. A naive approximation to get around this complexity is obtained by a Bethe factorization of the partition function; this is a nonnegative function of the disease variables, therefore, up to a normalization constant, it can be interpreted as a probability measure of the associated variables. Suppose µa(Da) and µα(Dα) are the local probability marginals of this measure. Then we may approximate the partition function (up to a constant multiplication factor) by Z(D) ∝Ya µa(Da)Yα µα(Dα) Qa∈∂Dα µa(Da)! . (B21) Note that, we can obtain approximate expressions for the above local marginals by solving the above equations without considering the interactions induced by the partition function 25 y t i l i b a b o r P y t i l i b a b o r P (a) 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0 50 100 Sign 150 200 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 (b) 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 Disease FIG. 6. The sign (a) and disease (b) marginal probabilities computed by the approximate belief propagation algorithm for a single instance of the two-disease-two-sign (D2S2) model. The pa- rameters are ND = 20, NS = 200, NO = 10, Ma = 20, Mab = 40, ka = 6, kab = 3. Each factor includes all the possible two-sign interactions in addition to the local sign fields. The couplings are iid random numbers distributed uniformly in the specified intervals: K 0 and K a ij ∈ (−1, +1)/√ka, K ab ∈ (−1, +1), ij ∈ (−1, +1)/√kab. The sign and disease variables in each factor are i = −1, K a,ab i chosen randomly with a uniform probability. Z(D). Moreover, the above approximation can be improved by considering the higher-order marginals in the above factorization. Now that Z(D) is factorized, we do not need any longer the cavity messages introduced in Eqs. B19 and B20. Instead, we will absorb the factors in the interaction factors φα, 26 working with the modified interactions φa , µa(Da) φa ≡ φab ≡ µa(Da)µb(Db) φab µab(Da, Db) . (B22) (B23) In summary, within the above approximation of the partition function, we first solve the following equations for the cavity marginals, considering the modified interactions, i Si Yβ∈∂i6=α νi→α(Si) ∝ eK 0 νa→α(Da) ∝ P0(Da) Yβ∈∂a6=α Ψβ→i(Si), Ψβ→a(Da), (B24) (B25) and Ψα→i(Si) ∝ X{Da:a∈∂Dα} X{Sj:j∈∂Sα\i} Ψα→a(Da) ∝ X{Db:b∈∂Dα\a} X{Sj :j∈∂Sα} φα(SαDα) Ya∈∂Dα φα(SαDα) Yb∈∂Dα\a νa→α(Da) Yj∈∂Sα\i νb→α(Db) Yj∈∂Sα νj→α(Sj), (B26) νj→α(Sj). (B27) These equations are solved by iteration; we start from random initial messages, and update the cavity marginals according to the above equations until the algorithm converges. Then, we obtain the sign and disease marginal probabilities from similar equations, but taking into account all the neighboring interactions, that is, i Si Yα∈∂i P (Si) ∝ eK 0 P (Da) ∝ P0(Da) Yα∈∂a Ψα→i(Si), Ψα→a(Da). (B28) (B29) Figure 6 shows the sign and disease probabilities we obtain for the two-disease-two-sign (D2S2) model with ND = 20 diseases, NS = 200 signs, and NO = 10 observed signs of positive values. Here, we take a sparse interaction graph with Ma = 20 one-disease factors and Mab = 40 two-disease factors connected randomly to ka = 6 and kab = 3 sign variables, respectively. The quality of our approximation depends very much on the structure of the interaction factors and strength of the associated couplings in the models. The Bethe approximation is exact for interaction graphs that have a tree structure. It is expected to work very well also in sparsely connected graphs, where the number of interaction factors 27 r o r r e e v i t l a e R y t i l i b a b o r p e s a e s d i n i r o r r e e v i t l a e R y t i l i b a b o r p n g s i n i 0.24 0.2 0.16 0.12 0.08 0.04 0 0.16 0.12 0.08 0.04 0 (a) 1 2 3 4 5 ka 6 7 8 9 (b) 1 2 3 4 5 ka 6 7 8 9 FIG. 7. Relative errors of the disease (a) and sign (b) marginal probabilities computed by the approximate belief propagation algorithm for the two-disease-two-sign (D2S2) model. The pa- rameters are ND = 5, NS = 20, NO = 3, Ma = 5, kab = 2, with Mab and ka taking different values. Each factor includes all the possible two-sign interactions in addition to the local sign fields. The couplings are iid random numbers distributed uniformly in the specified intervals: i = −1, K a,ab K 0 variables in each factor are chosen randomly with a uniform probability. ij ∈ (−1, +1)/√kab. The sign and disease ij ∈ (−1, +1)/√ka, K ab ∈ (−1, +1), and K a i (Ma, Mab) and the number of signs associated to an interaction factor (ka, kab) are small compared to the total number of sign variables. This behavior is observed in Fig. 7, which displays the relative errors in the marginal probabilities of sign/disease variables, obtained by the above approximate algorithm. The time complexity of our approximate inference algorithm grows linearly with the number of interaction factors, and exponentially with the number of variables involved in such interactions; with ND = 500, NS = 5000, Ma = 500, Mab = 1000, ka = 10, kab = 5 the algorithm takes about one minute of CPU time on a standard PC to compute the local marginals. 28 Appendix C: Comparing the diagnostic performance of the models As explained in the main text, we reduce the multistage problem of diagnosis to a sequence of two-stage problems. At each step, we use a greedy or heuristic strategy to choose the next sign for observation. We study two different cases depending on the values that are assigned to the observed signs: (I) in a real observation we find the true value of the observed sign, (II) in a simulation of the observation process, the value of observed sign j is sampled from its marginal probability P (Sj). In this section, we present more details of the two cases. 1. Case I Here, we need to know the true sign values, therefore, we choose a true model with a clear association of symptoms to diseases. As the benchmark, we take the exponential conditional probability, Ptrue(SD) = 1 Ztrue(D) e−H(S,S∗(D)), (C1) where S∗(D) gives the symptoms of hypothesis D. We choose the symptoms randomly and i)2/4 is the Hamming distance (number of different signs) of the two sign configurations. As before, uniformly from the space of sign configurations. Here H(S, S′) = PNS i=1(Si − S′ we will take a factorized and unbiased prior disease probability P0(D). Note that there is no sign-sign interaction in the above true model. Therefore, we need to consider only the effects of disease-disease interactions, and study the D1S1 and D2S1 models. Let us assume that we are given the true conditional marginals Ptrue(Sinodisease), Ptrue(SionlyDa), and Ptrue(SionlyDa, Db). From these information, we can exactly obtain the model parameters i , K a K 0 Let us take a single realization of the true model for a small number of sign/disease i as described in Appendix A. i , and K ab variables. This allows us to compute exactly the conditional marginal probabilities P (Si = +1Da = 1) and P (Si = −1Da = 0), which are known in the literature as sensitivity and specificity, respectively. As Fig. 8 shows, both the probabilities are in average closer to the true values in the D2S1 model. Now, we consider a sequential process of T decisions and real observations; at each step an unobserved sign is chosen for observation and the observed sign takes the true value, given by the symptoms S∗(D) of the true hypothesis D. This hypothesis is selected randomly and 29 y t i c i f i c e p s y t i v i t i s n e s 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 True D1S1 D2S1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 sign 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 sign FIG. 8. Sensitivity, P (Si = +1Da = 1), and specificity, P (Si = −1Da = 0), in the D1S1 and D2S1 models for the exponential benchmark model. The data are for one of the diseases in a single realization of the true model. The model parameters are obtained from the conditional marginals of the exponential true model. Here we have ND = 5 diseases, NS = 20 signs. uniformly at the beginning of the process. At each step, we compute the sign marginals P (Sj) in the constructed models, and use the MP (or greedy) strategy to choose the next observation. Figure 9 shows the RMS errors ∆D and ∆S in the marginal disease and sign probabilities, respectively, during such a process. Here, we are using the MP strategy and the errors are defined as follows, ∆D ≡ 1 ∆S ≡ 1 ND Xa NU Xi∈U (P (Da = 1) − Ptrue(Da = 1))2!1/2 (P (Si = 1) − Ptrue(Si = 1))2!1/2 , , (C2) (C3) where U is the subset of unobserved signs with NU = U. Figure 10 displays the inferred disease probabilities P (Da = 1) in the same process for cases in which only one or two 30 0.6 y t i l i 0.5 D1S1 D2S1 (a) r o r r e b a b o r p e s a e s d n i i y t i l i r o r r e b a b o r p n g s n i 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 2 6 8 4 number of observations 10 12 14 16 D1S1 D2S1 (b) 0.25 0.2 0.15 i 0.1 0 2 6 8 10 12 14 16 4 number of observations FIG. 9. The RMS error in disease (a) and sign (b) marginal probabilities in the D1S1 and D2S1 models for the exponential benchmark model. The model parameters are obtained from the conditional marginals of the true model. There are ND = 5 diseases, NS = 20 signs, and the algorithm starts with NO = 3 observed signs for a randomly selected hypothesis D. An unobserved sign is chosen for observation by the MP strategy using the inferred sign probabilities, and the observed sign takes the true value given by S∗(D). The data are results of averaging over 1000 independent realizations of the true model and the observation process. diseases are present. It is seen that both the D1S1 and D2S1 models end up with the right diagnosis when only one diseases is present (D1 = 1, D2 = D3 = · · · = 0). But, the D1S1 model fails when there are two diseases in the hypothesis (D1 = D2 = 1, D3 = D4 = · · · = 0), whereas the other model can still find the right diseases. However, we find that even the D2S1 model gets confused when there are more than two diseases in the hypothesis. Then, we would need to consider more sophisticated models with interactions involving more than two diseases. To see the importance of sign-sign interactions, we consider another benchmark model 31 (b) D2S1: only D1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 number of observations (d) D2S1: only D1,D2 (a) D1S1: only D1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 number of observations (c) D1S1: only D1,D2 5 4 e s a 3 e s d 2 i 1 5 4 e s a 3 e s d 2 i 1 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 0.2 5 4 e s a 3 e s d 2 i 1 5 4 e s a 3 e s d 2 i 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 number of observations 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 number of observations 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 FIG. 10. The inferred disease probabilities vs the number of observations for the exponential benchmark model. The data are for the cases in which only one (a,b) or two (c,d) diseases are present. The model parameters are obtained from the conditional marginals of the true model. There are ND = 5 diseases, NS = 20 signs, and the algorithm starts with NO = 3 observed signs for a randomly selected hypothesis D. An unobserved sign is chosen for observation by the MP strategy using the inferred sign probabilities. The observed sign takes the true value given by S∗(D). The data are results of averaging over 1000 independent realizations of the true model and the observation process. given by the following conditional probability: Ptrue(SD) = 1 Ztrue(D)(cid:18) 1 1 + H(S, S∗(D))(cid:19) . (C4) Given a disease hypothesis D and the associated symptoms S∗(D), we start from a few number of randomly chosen observed sings from the set of symptoms S∗(D). At each step, we compute the inferred sign probabilities P (Si) and use the greedy algorithm to choose an unobserved sign for observation. The observed sign at each time step takes the true value given by S∗(D). Figure 11 shows the overlap of the inferred probabilities P (Da = 1) with the true hypothesis for cases in which only one or two diseases are present. For comparison, 32 d o o h i l e k i l e s a e s d i d o o h i l e k i l e s a e s d i (a) D1S1 (G) D2S1 (G) D2S2 (G) D2S2 (Random) 0.1 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0 0 2 6 4 number of observations 8 10 12 14 16 (b) D1S1 (G) D2S1 (G) D2S2 (G) D2S2 (Random) 0.1 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0 0 2 6 4 number of observations 8 10 12 14 16 FIG. 11. Overlap of the inferred disease marginals with the true hypothesis for the power-law benchmark models. The data are for the cases in which only one (a) or two (b) diseases are present. The model parameters are obtained from the conditional marginals of the true model. There are ND = 5 diseases, NS = 20 signs, and the algorithm starts with NO = 3 observed signs for a randomly selected hypothesis D. An unobserved sign is chosen for observation by the greedy (G) strategy using the inferred sign probabilities. The observed sign takes the true value given by S∗(D). The data are results of averaging over 1000 independent realizations of the true model and the observation process. we also show the results obtained by the random strategy. The figure shows that we can obtain higher overlaps between the inferred disease marginals and the true hypothesis by considering the sign-sign interactions. Nevertheless, we find that even the D2S2 model fails in cases with more than two diseases. 33 2. Case II Here, the model parameters are chosen randomly and uniformly in symmetric intervals of real numbers; e.g., K a,ab ij ∈ (−1, +1)/√NS. The leaky couplings are i = −1, corresponding to small sign probabilities P (Si = 1nodisease) ≃ 0.05. We assume that all the possible one-disease and two-disease interaction factors are present ∈ (−1, +1), K a,ab set to K 0 i in the models. Moreover, inside each factor we have all the possible two-sign interactions in addition to the local sign fields; that is why we scale the two-sign couplings K a,ab ij with the inverse square root of the number of sign variables. The prior disease probabilities are uniform P0(Da = 1) = 0.5. We start from a small number of randomly selected observed signs with random values. Then, at each step, we choose an unobserved sign for observation with stochastic findings sampled from the associated probability distributions. The process is repeated 1000 times for different realizations of the couplings and findings of the observations to obtain the average polarization and likelihood of diseases. For reference, we also show the results that were obtained by a random strategy, where an unobserved sign is chosen randomly and uniformly for observation. In Fig. 12 we see that the average performance of the greedy strategy changes from that of the MPD strategy for small number of observations to that of the MP strategy for larger number of observations. However, as Fig. 13 shows, for strongly correlated models with much larger higher-order interactions, e.g., K 0 i = −1 and K a,ab i ∈ (−2, +2), K a,ab ij ∈ (−2, +2)/√NS, the difference between the performances of the most positive (MP) strategy and the random strategy diminishes. Furthermore, here the greedy strategy performs better than the MP and MPD strategies. The fact that such a heuristic algorithm does not work well in this regime was indeed expected; it is this type of finding that makes strongly interacting systems interesting, and in need for more elaborate methods and algorithms. Finally, Fig. 14 displays the average polarization of disease probabilities obtained by the approximate inference algorithm (BP) for much larger number of sign/disease variables. Here, the maximum likelihood hypothesis (DM L in the MPD strategy) is simply approxi- mated by the most probable diseases suggested by the marginal disease probabilities. That 34 n o i t l a z i r a o p e s a e s d i n o i t l a z i r a o p e s a e s d i l n o i t a z i r a o p e s a e s d i 0.4 0.38 0.36 0.34 0.32 0.3 0.28 0.48 0.45 0.42 0.39 0.36 0.33 0.3 0.45 0.42 0.39 0.36 0.33 0.3 (a) d o o h i l e k i l e s a e s d i d o o h i l e k i l e s a e s d i d o o h i l e k i l e s a e s d i D1S1: MPD G MP Random 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations (c) D2S1: MPD G MP Random 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations (e) D1S2: MPD G MP Random 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations 0.38 0.36 0.34 0.32 0.3 0.28 0.26 0.24 0.46 0.44 0.42 0.4 0.38 0.36 0.34 0.32 0.3 0.28 0.26 0.44 0.42 0.4 0.38 0.36 0.34 0.32 0.3 0.28 0.26 (b) D1S1: MPD G MP Random 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations (d) D2S1: MPD G MP Random 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations (f) D1S2: MPD G MP Random 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations FIG. 12. Diagnostic performance of the models vs the number of observations for different strate- gies. The exact disease-polarization (DP) and disease-likelihood (DL) obtained by the greedy, MP, MPD, and random strategies in the one-disease-one-sign (D1S1, (a)-(b)), two-disease-one- sign (D2S1, (c)-(d)), and one-disease-two-sign (D1S2, (e)-(f)) models. There are ND = 5 dis- eases, NS = 20 signs, and the algorithm starts with NO = 4 observed signs with positive values. The coupling constants are iid random numbers distributed uniformly in the specified intervals: i = −1, K a,ab K 0 independent realizations of the model parameters. ij ∈ (−1, +1)/√NS. The data are results of averaging over 1000 ∈ (−1, +1), K a,ab i 35 n o i t l a z i r a o p e s a e s d i n o i t a z i r a o p l e s a e s d i 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.5 0.48 0.46 0.44 0.42 0.4 0.38 0.36 (a) D1S1 D2S1 D1S2 D2S2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations (c) D2S2: MPD G MP Random 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations d o o h i l e k i l e s a e s d i d o o h i l e k i l e s a e s d i 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.5 0.48 0.46 0.44 0.42 0.4 0.38 0.36 0.34 (b) D1S1 D2S1 D1S2 D2S2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations (d) D2S2: MPD G MP Random 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 number of observations FIG. 13. Diagnostic performance of the models vs the number of observations for larger couplings. (top) The exact disease polarization (a) and disease likelihood (b) obtained by the MP strategy in the one-disease-one-sign (D1S1), two-disease-one-sign (D2S1), one-disease-two-sign (D1S2), and two-disease-two-sign (D2S2) models. There are ND = 5 diseases, NS = 20 signs, and the algorithm starts with NO = 4 observed signs with positive values. The couplings in the interaction i = −1, K a,ab ∈ ij ∈ (−2, +2)/√NS. (bottom) Comparing the exact polarization (c) and likelihood factors are iid random numbers distributed uniformly in the specified intervals: K 0 (−2, +2), K a,ab (d) of the diseases obtained by the greedy, MP, MPD, and random strategies, for the D2S2 model. i The data are results of averaging over 1000 independent realizations of the model parameters. is, we take Da = 0 if P (Da = 0) > 1/2, otherwise Da = 1. [1] Merrell, A.J. and Stanger, B.Z. (2016) Adult cell plasticity in vivo: de-differentiation and transdifferentiation are back in style. Nature Review Molecular Cell Biology, 17(7), 413-425. [2] DuPage, M., and Bluestone, J.A. (2016). Harnessing the plasticity of CD4+ T cells to treat immune-mediated disease. Nature Review Immunology, 16(3), 149-163. 36 [3] Holzel, M., Bovier, A., and Tuting, T. (2016). Plasticity of tumour and immune cells: a source of heterogeneity and a cause for therapy resistance? Nature Review Cancer, 13(5), 365-376. [4] Saeys, Y., Van Gassen, S., and Lambrecht, B.N. (2016). Computational flow cytometry: help- ing to make sense of high-dimensional immunology data. Nature Reviews Immunology 16, 449462. [5] Patti, G.j., Yanes, O., Siuzdak, G. (2012). Metabolomics: the apogee of the omics, trilogy. Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology 13, 263-269. [6] Kasper, D., Fauci, F., Hauser, S., Longo, D., Jameson, J., Loscalzo, J. (2015). Harrison's Prin- ciples of Internal Medicine. 19 edition, McGraw-Hill Education, 3000 pages, ISBN: 0071802150. [7] Papadakis, M., McPhee, S.J., Rabow, M.W. (2016). Current Medical Diagnosis and Treat- ment. 55 edition, LANGE CURRENT Series, 1920 pages, ISBN: 0071845097. [8] Lerner, A. J. (2006). Diagnostic gold standards or consensus diagnostic criteria. Diagnostic criteria in neurology, Humana Press. [9] Coggon, D., Martyn, C., Palmer, K.T., Evanoff, B. (2005). Assessing case definitions in the absence of a diagnostic gold standard. International Journal of Epidemiology, 34(4), 949-52. [10] Greenes, R. (2014). Clinical Decision Support, The Road to Broad Adoption. 2nd Edition, Academic Press, 930 pages, ISBN: 9780123984760. [11] Miller, R. A., Pople Jr, H. E., and Myers, J. D. (1982). Internist-I, an experimental computer- based diagnostic consultant for general internal medicine. New England Journal of Medicine, 307(8), 468-476. [12] Heckerman, D. E. (1987). Formalizing heuristic methods for reasoning with uncertainty. Tech- nical Report KSL-88-07, Medical Computer Science Group, Section on Medical Informatics, Stanford University, Stanford, CA. [13] Horvitz, E. J., Breese, J. S., and Henrion, M. (1988). Decision theory in expert systems and artificial intelligence. International journal of approximate reasoning, 2(3), 247-302. [14] Shortliffe, E. H. (1993). The adolescence of AI in medicine: will the field come of age in the'90s?. Artificial intelligence in medicine, 5(2), 93-106. [15] Adams, J. B. (1976). A probability model of medical reasoning and the MYCIN model. Math- ematical biosciences, 32(1), 177-186. [16] Buchanan, B. G., and Shortliffe, E. H. (Eds.). (1984). Rule-based expert systems (Vol. 3). Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. 37 [17] Miller, R., Masarie, F. E., and Myers, J. D. (1985). Quick medical reference (QMR) for diagnostic assistance. MD computing: computers in medical practice, 3(5), 34-48. [18] Barnett, G. O., Cimino, J. J., Hupp, J. A., and Hoffer, E. P. (1987). DXplain: an evolving diagnostic decision-support system. Jama, 258(1), 67-74. [19] Spielgelharter, D. J. (1987). Probabilistic Expert Systems in Medicine. Statistical Science, 2, 3-44. [20] Bankowitz, R. A., McNeil, M. A., Challinor, S. M., Parker, R. C., Kapoor, W. N., and Miller, R. A. (1989). A computer-assisted medical diagnostic consultation service: implementation and prospective evaluation of a prototype. Annals of Internal Medicine, 110(10), 824-832. [21] Heckerman D., A tractable inference algorithm for diagnosing multiple diseases, In Machine Intelligence and Pattern Recognition: Uncertainty in artificial Intelligence 5, Henrion M., Shachter R., Kanal L. N., Lemmer J. F., eds. Amsterdam North Holland Publ. Comp. 1990: 163-172. [22] Shwe, M. A., Middleton, B., Heckerman, D. E., Henrion, M., Horvitz, E. J., Lehmann, H. P., and Cooper, G. F. (1991). Probabilistic diagnosis using a reformulation of the INTERNIST- 1/QMR knowledge base. Methods of information in Medicine, 30(4), 241-255. [23] Heckerman, D. E., and Shortliffe, E. H. (1992). From certainty factors to belief networks. Artificial Intelligence in Medicine, 4(1), 35-52. [24] Nikovski, D. (2000). Constructing Bayesian networks for medical diagnosis from incomplete and partially correct statistics. Knowledge and Data Engineering, IEEE Transactions on, 12(4), 509-516. [25] Przulj, N. and Malod-Dognin, N. (2016). Network analytics in the age of big data. Science 353(6295), 123-124. [26] Hamaneh, M.B. and Yu, Y-K. (2015). DeCoaD: determining correlations among diseases using protein interaction networks. BMC Research Notes, 8:226. [27] Zitnik, M., Janjic, V., Larminie, C., Zupan, B., and Natasa Przuljb, N. (2013). Discovering disease-disease associations by fusing systems-level molecular data. Sci Rep. 3: 3202. [28] Liu, W., Wu, A., Pellegrini, M., and Wanga, X. (2015). Integrative analysis of human protein, function and disease networks. Sci Rep. 2015; 5: 14344. [29] Suratanee, A., and Plaimas, K. (2015). DDA: A Novel Network-Based Scoring Method to Identify DiseaseDisease Associations. Bioinform Biol Insights. 9: 175186. 38 [30] Gustafsson, M., Nestor, C.E., Zhang, H., Barabasi, A.L., Baranzini, S., Brunak, S., Chung, K.F. et al. (2014) Modules, networks and systems medicine for understanding disease and aiding diagnosis. Genome Medicine 6:82. [31] Liu, C-C., Tseng, Y-T., Li, W., Wu, C-Y., Mayzus, I., Rzhetsky, A., Sun, F., Waterman, M., et al. (2015). DiseaseConnect: a comprehensive web server for mechanism-based diseasedisease connections. Nucl. Acids Res. 42 (W1): W137-W146. [32] Sun, K., Goncalves, J.P., Larminie, C., and Przulj, N. (2014). Predicting disease associations via biological network analysis. BMC Bioinformatics 15:304 [33] Jordan, M. I. (2004). Graphical models. Statistical Science, 140-155. [34] Mezard, M., and Montanari, A. (2009). Information, physics, and computation. Oxford Uni- versity Press. [35] Altarelli, F., Braunstein, A., Ramezanpour, A., and Zecchina, R. (2011). Stochastic matching problem. Physical review letters, 106(19), 190601. [36] Ricci-Tersenghi, F. (2012). The Bethe approximation for solving the inverse Ising problem: a comparison with other inference methods. Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment, 2012(08), P08015. [37] Edwin, T. (2003). Jaynes. Probability theory: the logic of science. Cambridge university press, 10, 33. [38] Kappen, H. J., and Rodriguez, F. B. (1998). Efficient learning in Boltzmann machines using linear response theory. Neural Computation, 10(5), 1137-1156. [39] Tanaka, T. (1998). Mean-field theory of Boltzmann machine learning. Physical Review E, 58(2), 2302. [40] Schneidman, E., Berry, M. J., Segev, R., and Bialek, W. (2006). Weak pairwise correlations imply strongly correlated network states in a neural population. Nature, 440(7087), 1007-1012. [41] Cocco, S., Leibler, S., and Monasson, R. (2009). Neuronal couplings between retinal gan- glion cells inferred by efficient inverse statistical physics methods. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 106(33), 14058-14062. [42] Weigt, M., White, R. A., Szurmant, H., Hoch, J. A., and Hwa, T. (2009). Identification of direct residue contacts in proteinprotein interaction by message passing. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 106(1), 67-72. [43] Roudi, Y., Aurell, E., and Hertz, J. A. (2009). Statistical physics of pairwise probability 39 models. Frontiers in computational neuroscience, 3. [44] Bailly-Bechet, M., Braunstein, A., Pagnani, A., Weigt, M., and Zecchina, R. (2010). Infer- ence of sparse combinatorial-control networks from gene-expression data: a message passing approach. BMC bioinformatics, 11(1), 355. [45] Nguyen, H. C., and Berg, J. (2012). Mean-field theory for the inverse Ising problem at low temperatures. Physical review letters, 109(5), 050602. [46] Pearl, J. (2014). Probabilistic reasoning in intelligent systems: networks of plausible inference. Morgan Kaufmann. [47] Kschischang, F. R., Frey, B. J., and Loeliger, H. A. (2001). Factor graphs and the sum-product algorithm. Information Theory, IEEE Transactions on, 47(2), 498-519. [48] Mzard, M., Parisi, G., and Zecchina, R. (2002). Analytic and algorithmic solution of random satisfiability problems. Science, 297(5582), 812-815. [49] Yedidia, J. S., Freeman, W. T., and Weiss, Y. (2003). Understanding belief propagation and its generalizations. Exploring artificial intelligence in the new millennium, 8, 236-239. [50] Birge, J. R., and Louveaux, F. (2011). Introduction to stochastic programming. Springer Science & Business Media. [51] Kleywegt, A. J., Shapiro, A., and Homem-de-Mello, T. (2002). The sample average approx- imation method for stochastic discrete optimization. SIAM Journal on Optimization, 12(2), 479-502. [52] Heyman, D. P., and Sobel, M. J. (2003). Stochastic Models in Operations Research: Stochastic Optimization (Vol. 2). Courier Corporation. [53] Garey, M. R., and Johnson, D. S. (1979). Computers and intractability: A guide to the theory of NP-completeness. W.H. Freeman. [54] Cooper, G. F. (1990). The computational complexity of probabilistic inference using Bayesian belief networks. Artificial intelligence, 42(2), 393-405. [55] Henrion, M. (1990), Towards efficient probabilistic diagnosis in multiply connected belief net- works. Oliver, R. M., Smith, J. Q., eds. Influence Diagrams, Belief Nets and Decision Analysis. Chichester: Wiley, 385-407. [56] Heckerman, D., Geiger, D., and Chickering, D. M. (1995). Learning Bayesian networks: The combination of knowledge and statistical data. Machine learning, 20(3), 197-243. [57] Chickering, D. M. (1996). Learning Bayesian networks is NP-complete. In Learning from data 40 (pp. 121-130). Springer New York. [58] Lezon, T. R., Banavar, J. R., Cieplak, M., Maritan, A., and Fedoroff, N. V. (2006). Using the principle of entropy maximization to infer genetic interaction networks from gene expression patterns. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 103(50), 19033-19038. [59] Bialek, W., and Ranganathan, R. (2007). Rediscovering the power of pairwise interactions. arXiv preprint arXiv:0712.4397. [60] Banavar, J. R., Maritan, A., and Volkov, I. (2010). Applications of the principle of maximum entropy: from physics to ecology. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 22(6), 063101. [61] Barabsi, A.L. and Oltvai Z.A. (2004) Network biology: understanding the cell's functional organization. Nature Reviews Genetics 5, 101-113. [62] Kim, M., Rai, N., Zorraquino, V., and Tagkopoulos, I. (2016) Multi-omics integration accu- rately predicts cellular state in unexplored conditions for Escherichia coli. Nature Communi- cations 7,13090. [63] Ebrahim, A., Brunk, E., Tan, J., O'Brien, E.J., Kim, D., Szubin, R., Lerman, J.A., Lechner, A., Sastry, A., Bordbar, A., Feist, A.M., and Palsson, B.O. (2016) Multi-omic data integration enables discovery of hidden biological regularities. Nature Communications 7, 13091. [64] Spiller, D.J., Wood, C.D., Rand, D.A., and White, M.R.H. (2010) Measurement of single-cell dynamics. Nature 465, 736745. [65] Candia, J., Maunu, R., Driscoll, M., Biancotto, A., Dagur, P., et al. (2013) From Cellular Characteristics to Disease Diagnosis: Uncovering Phenotypes with Supercells. PLOS Compu- tational Biology 9(9): e1003215. 41 l n o i t a z i r a o p e s a e s d i l n o i t a z i r a o p e s a e s d i (a) 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0 D1S1 D2S1 D1S2 D2S2 100 200 300 400 500 number of observations 0.5 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 D2S2: MPD MP Random (b) 0 100 200 300 400 500 number of observations FIG. 14. Diagnostic performance of the models vs the number of observations for a larger number of sign/disease variables. (a) The approximate disease-polarization (DP) obtained by the MP strategy in the one-disease-one-sign (D1S1), two-disease-one-sign (D2S1), one-disease-two-sign (D1S2), and two-disease-two-sign (D2S2) models. Here we have ND = 200 diseases, NS = 2000 signs, and the algorithm starts with NO = 50 observed signs with positive values. The graph parameters are: Ma = 200, Mab = 0, ka = 8 in the D1S1 and D1S2 models, and Ma = 200, Mab = 1000, ka = 8, kab = 4 in the D2S1 and D2S2 models. The interaction factors in the D1S2 and D2S2 models include all the possible two-sign interactions in addition to the local sign fields. The couplings in the interaction factors are iid random numbers distributed uniformly in the specified intervals: K 0 i = −1, K a,ab i ∈ (−1, +1), K a,ab polarization of the diseases obtained by the MP, MPD, and random strategies, for the D2S2 model. ij ∈ (−1, +1)/pka,ab. (b) Comparing the approximate The data are results of averaging over 100 independent realizations of the model parameters. 42
1710.06914	1	1710	2017-09-26T20:05:50	The Influence of Ceramide Tail Length on the Structure of Bilayers Composed of Stratum Corneum Lipids	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "physics.chem-ph" ]	Lipid bilayers composed of non-alpha hydroxy sphingosine ceramide (CER NS), cholesterol (CHOL), and free fatty acids (FFA), which are components of the human skin barrier, are studied via molecular dynamics simulations. Since mixtures of these lipids exist in dense gel phases with little molecular mobility at physiological conditions, care must be taken to ensure that the simulations become decorrelated from the initial conditions. Thus, we propose and validate an equilibration protocol based on simulated tempering in which the simulation takes a random walk through temperature space, allowing the system to break out of metastable configurations and hence become decorrelated form its initial configuration. After validating the equilibration protocol, the effects of the lipid composition and ceramide tail length on bilayer properties are studied. Systems containing pure CER NS, CER NS + CHOL, and CER NS + CHOL + FFA, with the CER fatty acid tail length varied within each CER NS-CHOL-FFA composition, are simulated. The bilayer thickness is found to depend on the structure of the center of the bilayer, which arises as a result of the tail length asymmetry between the lipids studied. The hydrogen bonding between the lipid headgroups and with water is found to change with the overall lipid composition, but is mostly independent of the CER fatty acid tail length. Subtle differences in the lateral packing of the lipid tails are also found as a function of CER tail length. Overall, these results provide insight into the experimentally observed trend of altered barrier properties in skin systems where there are more ceramides with shorter tails present.	physics.bio-ph	physics	The Influence of Ceramide Tail Length on the Structure of Bilayers Composed of Stratum Corneum Lipids T. C. Moore, R. Hartkamp, C. R. Iacovella, A. L. Bunge, and C. McCabe Condensed Title: Stratum Corneum Lipid Bilayers 1 ABSTRACT Lipid bilayers composed of non-alpha hydroxy sphingosine ceramide (CER NS), cholesterol (CHOL), and free fatty acids (FFA), which are components of the human skin barrier, are studied via molecular dynamics simulations. Since mixtures of these lipids exist in dense gel phases with little molecular mobility at physiological conditions, care must be taken to ensure that the simulations become decorrelated from the initial conditions. Thus, we propose and validate an equilibration protocol based on simulated tempering in which the simulation takes a random walk through temperature space, allowing the system to break out of metastable configurations and hence become decorrelated form its initial configuration. After validating the equilibration protocol, the effects of the lipid composition and ceramide tail length on bilayer properties are studied. Systems containing pure CER NS, CER NS + CHOL, and CER NS + CHOL + FFA, with the CER fatty acid tail length varied within each CER NS-CHOL-FFA composition, are simulated. The bilayer thickness is found to depend on the structure of the center of the bilayer, which arises as a result of the tail length asymmetry between the lipids studied. The hydrogen bonding between the lipid headgroups and with water is found to change with the overall lipid composition, but is mostly independent of the CER fatty acid tail length. Subtle differences in the lateral packing of the lipid tails are also found as a function of CER tail length. Overall, these results provide insight into the experimentally observed trend of altered barrier properties in skin systems where there are more ceramides with shorter tails present. 2 INTRODUCTION The stratum corneum (SC) layer of the skin acts as the main barrier against chemical penetrants and water loss and is composed of a brick-and-mortar-like arrangement of corneocytes surrounded by a dense, lamellar-structured extracellular lipid matrix. This matrix is a complex mixture primarily composed of an equimolar ratio of ceramides (CERs), which are composed of a sphingoid base linked to a saturated fatty acid chain (in most cases), cholesterol (CHOL), and free fatty acids (FFAs) (1, 2). Since the extracellular matrix is widely thought to be the only continuous path for permeation through the SC, proper lipid organization and composition of the lamellar membrane is generally considered crucial for a fully functioning skin barrier. This is supported by the fact that many skin diseases that are characterized by a reduced barrier function also exhibit an altered lipid composition and organization compared to healthy skin (3-6). For example, a decrease has been observed in the average number of CER carbon atoms in the SC of patients who suffer from atopic eczema (3, 7) and, compared with controls, less dense lipid packing and changes in x-ray scattering patterns (3). Of the two CER tails, reduced CER carbon numbers appear to correspond with a shorter fatty acid (FA) tail rather than the sphingoid base tail (8). The complex nature of the human SC lipid matrix, in that it features 15 unique subclasses of CER lipids and a distribution of CER and FFA chain lengths, has made it challenging to establish the influence of individual lipid species on barrier properties (9). As a result, many experiments have focused on model systems that are composed of simpler mixtures of synthetic lipids, whose composition and chain lengths can be precisely controlled (10-21). For example, considering studies of mixtures containing non-alpha hydroxyl sphingosine CER (NS), CHOL, and FFA, similar to those considered in this work, Mojumdar et al. (14) showed that CHOL is 3 essential to the characteristic phase behavior, and hence barrier properties, of such mixtures, and Školová et al. (19) found that CER NS-based membranes with short acyl chains had increased permeability compared to long acyl chain CERs. However, while global structural properties of SC lipid lamellae can be inferred from experiment (e.g., from spectroscopic, scattering, and diffraction data), including information about the localization of molecules across the lamellae, the underlying molecular-level details and in-plane morphology often remain elusive. Furthermore, structural examination using neutron scattering is quite laborious, as many independent systems, each with different deuterated lipids and/or concentrations of deuterated lipids, must be considered to provide a single picture of the structure, and the availability of deuterated lipids may limit the study of specific systems (15, 22-24). Molecular simulation, which offers atomic-level resolution of the entire 3-dimensional structure of the lipids at picosecond timescales, has been used to provide a more direct understanding of the molecular interactions in CER-based membranes (25-38), with several studies focusing on the dependence of membrane structure on lipid composition. For example, Das et al. (26) found that CHOL compresses a CER NS bilayer membrane and increases the interdigitation of CER tails in opposing bilayer leaflets. Gupta and Rai (31) simulated a series of lipid bilayers composed of CER NS, CHOL, and FFA with varying compositions and found that CHOL tends to sit away from the lipid-water interface and increases the thermal stability of the bilayers. The effect of the CER tail length on bilayer properties has received considerably less attention. Paloncyová et al. showed that extremely short CER NS FA tails (e.g., 6 carbons) cause a disruption in the headgroup packing of CER bilayers, which gives rise to an increased permeability (37); however, the CER NS FA tail lengths considered were much shorter than those found in the SC. More recently, Gupta et al. showed that the permeability of water across 4 pure CER NS bilayers with more biologically relevant tail lengths decreases monotonically with the CER FA tail length (30), although a structural explanation for this trend was not presented. While these computational studies have provided important insight, they also highlight a significant challenge in studying SC lipids with molecular simulation. Specifically, due to the dense packing of the lipid tails, the CER-rich bilayer systems demonstrate negligible molecular diffusion at physiologically relevant temperatures (i.e., 305 K). Even in simulations conducted at elevated temperatures, e.g., 340 K, studies have demonstrated minimal in-plane diffusion of the lipids, despite considering simulations in excess of 200 ns (32). Additionally, lipids in the gel phase have low rates of rotational relaxation (39). As such, on typical simulation timescales, systems likely exist in metastable configurations that are highly dependent on the initial bilayer structure. While this may be of little consequence for single component lipid bilayers, many properties of multicomponent lipid mixtures depend on the in-plane morphology of the individual lipid components, e.g., aggregation versus dispersion of lipid species in the bilayer leaflets; furthermore, the morphology on this size scale is typically not known from experiment (40). While self-assembled bilayers would, in principle, avoid these problems, it is not currently practical to study the self-assembly of multicomponent bilayers with atomistically detailed models due to the high computational cost and a rough free energy landscape that could hinder the formation of equilibrium structures; for example, Das et al. found inverted micelle structures formed in mixtures of 3 different CERs with CHOL and FFA unless constrained by a wall (27), in contrast to experiments, where lamella structures form in bulk. Therefore, since preassembled structures remain more practical for simulating atomistic models, care must be taken that system properties are not biased by the initial configuration, so that reliable conclusions can be made. 5 Here, molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are used to examine the structural behavior of model SC membranes, similar to those studied experimentally (19, 41), to examine the role of the CER FA tail length and overall lipid composition on structural properties. Specifically, this work focuses on CER NS, as this is the most abundant CER species in healthy human SC and is typically used in model systems. Three sets of systems are studied: pure CER NS, binary mixtures of CER NS and CHOL in 2-1 and 1-1 molar ratios, and equimolar mixtures of CER NS, CHOL, and FFA C24:0. The structure of each of the lipids used in this work is shown in Figure 1. Mixtures of different length CERs are used in each set to examine the impact of the CER FA tail length on the systems, which, to date, has not been the focus of any computational studies. To ensure robust results, a random walk MD (RWMD) algorithm is validated and employed to reduce the dependence of the final bilayer configuration on the assumed, initial morphology. a) HO HO O b) HO HO O c) d) e) NH NH HO O HO eCER2 uCER2 CHOL FFA Figure 1. Chemical structure of the lipids in this study. a) CER NS C16 (eCER); b) CER NS C24 (uCER); c) cholesterol (CHOL); d) FFA C24:0 (FFA); and e) a snapshot of a typical configuration for the equimolar uCER2-CHOL-FFA bilayer. CER is shown in gray, CHOL is 6 shown in yellow, FFA is shown in purple, and water is shown in transparent red (oxygens) and white (hydrogen). MATERIALS AND METHODS Model CER NS consists of a sphingosine base, 18 carbons in length, linked to a saturated fatty acid (FA) chain of variable length. Two different FA tail lengths were considered: CER NS C16:0 (Figure 1a), in which the FA tail is 16 carbons long and approximately equal in length to the sphingosine chain (denoted as equal-length CER NS, or eCER); and CER NS C24:0 (Figure 1b), in which the FA tail is 24 carbons long, a typical length in the SC(11) (denoted as unequal-length CER NS, or uCER). FFA, when present in this work, is always 24 carbons in length (Figure 1d), which has been shown to be a useful model for the FFAs in healthy human SC (11, 42). The fully atomistic CHARMM36 force field (43) supplemented by the CHARMM-compatible CER headgroup parameters from Guo et al. (29) were used to describe the CER NS, CHOL, and FFA. The CER headgroup parameters have been shown to accurately reproduce the thermotropic phase behavior of bilayers composed of pure CER NS (29), and have been used to study the hydration of CER NS headgroups in solution (44, 45). Water was modeled using TIP3P (46). Methods Lipid monolayers were first constructed by placing 64 lipids on a rectangular lattice in the xy plane with 50 Å2 per lipid. Four initial lateral distributions of a binary mixture of eCER and CHOL (i.e., different arrangements of lipid species on the lattice) were considered for validating the ST-based approach: completely phase-separated, consisting of one 8 x 4 block of either lipid species (Figure 2a); a coarse-grained checkerboard, consisting of alternating 4 x 4 blocks of each lipid species (Figure 2b); randomly mixed, where both lipid species are randomly dispersed 7 throughout the lattice (Figure 2c), and a fine-grained checkerboard, consisting of alternating lipid species on the lattice sites (Figure 2d). To examine the impact of the CER NS FA chain length on the structural properties, each of the four lipid compositions studied (pure CER NS, 2-1 CER NS-CHOL, 1-1 CER NS-CHOL, and equimolar CER NS-CHOL-FFA) was subdivided into five subcompositions, where the CER NS fraction consists of 0, 25, 50, 75, 100 mol% eCER. Thus, in total, 20 such systems were considered. For these simulations, the effect of the initial lateral distributions of the lipids was not explored, and the different lipid species were initially randomly dispersed throughout the lattice, with the number of each specific lipid dictated by the system composition. In all cases, each lipid was rotated about its long axis by a random integer multiple of 60°, since a high degree of alignment between lipid backbones has been shown to cause unphysically large tilt angles in the lipid tails of gel-phase bilayers (39). The monolayer was then rotated about the x-axis, and translated in z such that the ends of the tails in opposing leaflets were in contact, forming a bilayer; note, in this procedure each leaflet starts with the same in- plane configuration. Twenty water molecules per lipid were then added to hydrate the outside of the bilayers (2,560 total water molecules for 128 total lipids). System sizes ranged from 19,136 to 24,192 atoms. The systems were relaxed through a series of energy minimization, NVT simulations, and NPT simulations. First, a steepest descent energy minimization was performed on each initial configuration to reduce the large non-bonded repulsions caused by (inadvertently) overlapping atoms. Next, the systems were simulated for 10 ps in the NVT ensemble at 305 K (i.e., skin temperature), followed by a 10 ns simulation in the NPT ensemble at 305 K and 1 atm. Unless otherwise noted, the systems were further simulated using the RWMD algorithm. In the RWMD 8 algorithm, the system temperature is adjusted at small time intervals, such that the system takes a random walk through temperature space. Specifically, the sequence is defined within an interval between Tmin and Tmax, with discrete temperatures defined every !". In this work, RWMD was performed for 50 ns, with temperature changes of !"=5×& (&∈ −1,0,1) / every 5 ps, Tmin = 305 K, and Tmax set to 355 K for the first 25 ns, and the upper bound linearly reduced to 305 K over the final 25 ns. A representative plot of temperature versus time during the RWMD equilibration is shown in Figure S1, where we note the sequence is defined such that it samples all temperature states equally. Systems were further simulated at 305 K for at least 150 ns after ST. Note that 200 ns of simulation at a fixed temperature range are used for the comparison to the results obtained from simulations with RWMD in the RWMD validation section (i.e., for the RWMD validation, the 305 K systems were simulated for 200 ns at 305 K, and the RWMD systems were simulated for 200 ns with Tmin = 305 K and Tmax = 355 K). To avoid modification to the simulation code itself, we note this random walk was determined separately and the sequence of temperatures provided to the thermostat. The RWMD approach is designed to mimic key aspects of the Monte Carlo simulated tempering (ST) algorithm (47), used to find minima on a rough free energy surface by performing a random walk through temperature space. The general idea of the ST algorithm is that increasing the system temperature lowers free energy barriers, allowing different local minima to be explored each time the system returns from an elevated temperature to the (lower) temperature of interest, all while keeping the system at equilibrium due to the short timescale (47). The latter distinguishes this approach from the widely-used simulated annealing method, in which a system is driven out of equilibrium by increasing its temperature and simulating for a long time at the elevated temperature, followed by a slow cooling to the temperature of interest. 9 We note that the original ST algorithm involves attempting a temperature swap after each sweep in a Monte Carlo simulation to achieve a random walk through temperature space using the standard Metropolis acceptance/rejection criteria, rather than the predetermined walk used in the RWMD implementation here. All simulations were performed in GROMACS 5.1 (48), employing the Nosé-Hoover thermostat (49) with a coupling constant of 1 ps and, for the NPT simulations, a Parrinello- Rahman barostat (50) with a coupling constant of 10 ps. The pressure was controlled semi- isotropically for all NPT simulations, where the box lengths of the bilayer lateral directions were coupled. van der Waals interactions were smoothly switched off between 10-12 Å, beyond which they were neglected. Long-range electrostatic interactions were treated via the PME algorithm (51) with a real-space cutoff of 12 Å. A timestep of 1 fs was used for all simulations. Note that separate thermostats were used for the lipids and the water, although both groups follow the same temperature walk to avoid introducing temperature gradients into the system. Analysis System properties were calculated over the final 100 ns of simulation at 305 K. To quantify the structure of the bilayer, various properties were calculated, including: the area per lipid (APL), the tilt angle of the lipid tails with respect to the bilayer normal (i.e., the z-axis), the area per tail (APT), the nematic order parameter, density profiles of various groups across the bilayer normal, the bilayer thickness, the width of the lipid-water interface, the width of the low density tail region, and the hydrogen bonding. The coordination numbers (CNs) of different lipid tail pairs in the bilayer plane are used to describe the lateral distributions of lipids; the center of mass of each tail is projected onto the z = 0 plane for these calculations. Note that the tails were chosen for the 10 CN calculations, as the lipid tails pack in an ordered hexagonal lattice, in contrast to the relatively more disordered packing of the lipid headgroups. The lipid backbone orientation is used to describe the rotational motion of the lipids about their long axes. A detailed description of each of these calculations is given in the Supporting Information. RESULTS Random Walk Molecular Dynamics Before using the RWMD scheme in the rest of this work, the efficacy of the approach is first evaluated for equimolar mixtures of eCER and CHOL. This composition was chosen as eCER and CHOL have similar hydrophobic lengths, which should yield bilayers without a considerable interdigitation region in the middle; prior work has shown that CHOL can reside in this interdigitation region in lipid mixtures with uCER (28). Thus, the lipids (especially CHOL) in this mixture should stay in their canonical bilayer conformation, i.e., with their headgroups at the lipid-water interface and their tails creating a hydrophobic core, therefore allowing evaluation of the ability of RWMD to enhance the in-plane lateral and rotational rearrangements of the lipids. Figure 2 shows the initial configuration of each system studied, the final configurations at 200 ns at 305 K, the final configurations after 200 ns of RWMD, and the evolution of the CHOL- CHOL CNs for each equilibration scheme. Note that the CHOL-CHOL CN was chosen because it is the least biased CN (e.g., the FA-SPH CN is skewed because the FA and SPH tails are part of the same molecule, and hence will show a high level of association). Since lipids of the equimolar eCER-CHOL mixture are expected to mix, the fully separated and coarse-grained checkerboard morphologies (Figures 2a and 2b) serve as "bad" initial configurations, and the randomly mixed and fine-grained checkerboard systems (Figures 2c and 2d) serve as naïve, but 11 reasonable, guesses of how to initialize mixed-lipid bilayers. Each initial morphology was equilibrated for 200 ns with two different schemes: standard MD at 305 K, and RWMD with 305 K < T < 355 K. Both visual inspection and the evolution of the CHOL-CHOL CN can be used to compare the in-plane morphologies, and hence equilibration, of the different systems and equilibration procedures. At 305 K, the final morphologies visually resemble the corresponding initial morphologies; this is reflected in the steady-state nature of the CNs at 305 K, which are listed in Table 1. This is especially notable for the fully-separated and coarse-grained checkerboard systems, where the large CHOL aggregates make it easy to visually establish that there are only slight changes in the shape of the initial aggregates. These results highlight the frozen nature of these systems at 305 K; only small rearrangements occur in 200 ns if RWMD is not applied. Note that in the fine-grained (FG) checkerboard system, small linear aggregates of CHOL form relatively quickly, indicated by the increase in the CN during the first 25 ns, although the system does not evolve much after this initial change. 12 Figure 2. System configurations and CHOL-CHOL coordination number (CN) as a function of initial configuration and equilibration procedure for the equimolar mixture of eCER2 and CHOL. The first column shows the different initial configurations: a) maximum phase separation; b) coarse-grained checkerboard; c) randomly mixed; and d) fine-grained checkerboard. The second column shows the systems after 200 ns of MD at 305 K, the third column shows the systems after 200 ns of RWMD, and the fourth column shows the evolution of the CHOL-CHOL CN for each initial configuration. Snapshots are taken along the z-axis, i.e., along the bilayer normal direction. eCER2 is represented as blue spheres, CHOL is represented as yellow spheres. For clarity, water is not shown. Table 1. CHOL-CHOL coordination number over the final 50 ns of MD simulation. Separated refers to the initial configuration shown in Figure 2a, CG Checker refers to that in Figure 2b, Random Mix refers to Figure 2c, and FG Checker refers to Figure 2d. The uncertainties here, and in all subsequent tables and figures, are given as the standard error of the measured property. 13 Initial Configuration Equilibration Separated CG Checker Random Mix FG Checker 305 K 1.75 ± 0.07 2.5 ± 0.1 RWMD 4.46 ± 0.03 3.72 ± 0.04 2.3 ± 0.1 2.4 ± 0.1 2.53 ± 0.08 2.4 ± 0.2 With RWMD, the final lateral distributions of the lipids are visually distinct from the initial configuration, showing that the lipids were able to reorganize within the bilayer leaflets. For the two most separated systems, the larger CHOL aggregates mostly break up into smaller aggregates (Figure 2a, i and Figure 2b, j), while small CHOL aggregates form in the fine- grained checkerboard system (Figure 2d, l). Importantly, all of the final configurations after RWMD visually resemble each other and have nearly identical CN values, as listed in Table 1, and systems that start close to the final morphology (i.e., the random and fine-grained checkerboard) rapidly converge to their final coordination number. Since each of these systems started from qualitatively different initial configurations, this result shows that the final configurations are decorrelated from the initial configurations and RWMD can reproducibly form the structures with matching properties without strong bias from the starting configuration. We note this does not necessarily indicate that RWMD has found the true free-energy minimum of the system, but this does strongly suggest that it is a stable, low energy configuration, given that multiple independent trajectories converge to the same state. Analysis of the rotational motion of the eCER molecules also suggests that the systems equilibrated with RWMD are more decorrelated from their initial configurations than those equilibrated at 305 K. Figure 3 shows the autocorrelation function of the lipid backbone angle in the bilayer plane for the different initial configurations and equilibration methods. The lipid 14 backbone orientations become completely uncorrelated from the initial orientations by 25 ns of RWMD, while slower relaxation is observed for the systems simulated at 305 K. Interestingly, the phase-separated system shows the slowest relaxation of the eCER backbone orientations, likely because the large, dense eCER domain has a larger energy barrier for lipid rotation due to lipid-lipid hydrogen bonding. Since the systems that were equilibrated at 305 K all converge to different morphologies and the lipid backbone orientations are correlated to the initial orientations, at least three of the four systems must be metastable configurations. Often in bilayer simulations, a specific property, such as the area per lipid (APL), is monitored over time, and equilibrium is assumed when that property reaches a steady state. This practice, however, may lead to spurious assumptions of equilibrium since other features of the bilayer structure may not exist in their preferred state, but this cannot be easily verified since the preferred state is not always known a priori. For example, the APLs of the systems equilibrated at 305 K are compared to the APLs of the systems equilibrated with RWMD (after running at 305 K for a more direct comparison) in Table 2, from which it is apparent that the systems equilibrated at 305 K show a larger spread in the APLs than the systems equilibrated with RWMD. The two systems with the highest level of CHOL aggregation have similar APLs, while the other two systems have lower APLs that are similar to each other. Due to the different morphologies and packing densities of the lipids in these systems, they likely have different properties, e.g., permeability, which is related to the in-plane density of the lipids (52). In contrast, all of the systems equilibrated with RWMD have APLs consistent within the standard deviation, further illustrating the reproducibility, and hence confidence gained, when equilibrating with RWMD. Table 2. Area per lipid (in Å2) of systems as a function of initial configuration and equilibration methodology. The systems equilibrated with RWMD were simulated at 305 K for 50 ns for a 15 more direct comparison with the other systems. Separated refers to Figure 2a, CG Checker refers to Figure 2b, Random Mix refers to Figure 2c, and FG Checker refers to Figure 2d. Initial Configuration Equilibration Separated CG Checker Random Mix FG Checker 305 K RWMD 38.8 ± 0.4 38.8 ± 0.4 39.6 ± 0.5 39.7 ± 0.4 39.4 ± 0.2 39.5 ± 0.4 39.6 ± 0.2 39.4 ± 0.3 Figure 3. Autocorrelation function C(t) of the eCER backbone orientations during simulations at 305 K and with RWMD from different initial configurations. Separated refers to Figure 2a, CG Checker refers to Figure 2b, Random Mix refers to Figure 2c, and FG Checker refers to Figure 2d. The shaded area shown is the standard deviation over the rotational autocorrelation function of all eCER molecules in the bilayer. 16 This lack of mobility and difficulty in proper equilibration is a recognized problem when simulating CER-based bilayers, with many studies running the systems at elevated temperatures in an attempt to overcome mobility issues (25-28, 30, 31, 34, 35). Here, we also compare to equilibration and production runs at 340 K, as several MD studies of SC lipids have used this temperature (25-28). Figure 4 shows the evolution of the CN for the fully separated system (Fig. 2a) simulated for 600 ns at 305 K, 340 K, and with RWMD. As expected, the system at 305 K is still frozen in simulations in excess of 0.5 µs, while the system simulated with RWMD reaches its steady state CN number after ~110 ns. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the system simulated at 340 K shows behavior somewhere in between that of the other systems; while lateral reorganization does occur, the CN reaches a steady state value after ~520 ns, which we note is significantly longer than the simulation times typically studied. Note that this system also reaches a pseudo- steady state CN between 80 and 150 ns; with many studies performed on simulations run for 100 ns or less, this metastable state could be erroneously mistaken for equilibrium, if one were relying on CN to determine convergence. At 600 ns, the rotational relaxation of the lipids for this system at 340 K is higher than 305 K, but still lower than RWMD (Figure 3a). While the fully phase-separated system is likely a poorly chosen starting configuration given some level of prior knowledge of this particular system, we emphasize that the actual morphology is typically not known a priori. Thus, these results indicate that RWMD is more efficient than simply running at a high temperature to equilibrate multicomponent, gel-phase lipid bilayers and can provide increased confidence in the reproducibility of the results, particularly for systems in which the lateral organization is unknown and expected to play an important role in properties of interest. 17 Figure 4. Evolution of the CHOL-CHOL coordination number (CN) for the fully phase- separated systems equilibrated with three different methodologies as a function of time (t). Dependence of Structural Properties on Bilayer Composition The effect of the composition of CER-based lipid bilayers on structural properties is now examined. Note, all systems start from a randomly dispersed morphology, given that, in the prior section, this arrangement relaxed the fastest and appears to be reasonably representative of the morphology for this family of systems; these systems were also relaxed using RWMD as described in Methods. General Structural Properties. All systems exist in dense, highly ordered, gel phases, as indicated by high nematic order parameters ranging from 0.95 to 0.99, shown in Figure S4 and Table S1. The addition of CHOL decreases the nematic order, consistent with Das et al. (26), but the magnitude of this decrease is quite small, (e.g., ranging from 0.988 for pure uCER to 0.954 for 1-1 CER-CHOL with 3-1 eCER-uCER) and the lipids are still highly ordered from visual inspection (Figure 1e), indicating no phase change upon addition of CHOL for these compositions. 18 The tilt angle shows a weak dependence on composition, as shown in Figure 5a. The tilt angle depends significantly on the CER FA tail length for the pure CER systems, where a strong increase is seen with increasing eCER for systems with 50% or more eCER. This trend is a result of the balance between headgroup and tail interactions: steric repulsions between lipid headgroups dictate the APL, while van der Waals attractions between the lipid tails cause them to tilt to optimize their spacing (53). For the CER bilayers that are predominantly uCER, the tail length asymmetry gives rise to a wide low density tail region in the center of the bilayer (discussed below), which increases the effective optimal tail packing, leading to a lower tilt angle. The addition of CHOL and FFA causes the tails to tilt less and show almost no change as a function of increasing eCER, likely because CHOL has a bulky ring structure with a small headgroup, and therefore acts as a spacer between the lipid tails, buffering the head-tail effects seen in the pure systems. Hence, there is a smaller mismatch between the packing densities of the headgroups and tails, leading to a smaller tilt. Notably, the 1-1 CER-CHOL and ternary mixtures have very similar tilt angles, which we attribute to the fact that these systems have a similar fraction of alkyl tails. 19 Figure 5. (a) Average tilt angle (q) of the lipid tails with respect to the bilayer normal, (b) area per lipid (APL) and (c) area per tail (APT) as a function of eCER2 composition. Note that the abscissa is the fraction of CER NS that is eCER, not the total eCER fraction in the system. The APL and APT trends as a function of the fraction of eCER are shown in Figure 5b,c. While the APL describes the density of lipids in the bilayer plane, irrespective of the number of tails that each lipid has, the APT describes the tail packing density in the plane of the lipid tails (i.e., APT accounts for both the number of tails and the tilt angle). All CER NS and CER NS- CHOL systems have similar APLs, between 38-40 Å2, as expected since CER and CHOL have similar cross-sectional areas (54). There is only a slight, nonmonotonic dependence of the APL on the CER FA tail length. This trend is expected since the headgroups dictate the APL and these systems have the same headgroups for a given composition. Systems containing FFA have smaller APLs, since FFA contains a single alkyl chain. The APT increases with the CHOL content, as CHOL and CER NS have similar cross-sectional areas, but CHOL is treated as a 20 (DMPC, a phospholipid with single tail. The ternary systems have APTs more similar to the 2-1 CER NS-CHOL systems, which is reasonable considering they have the same ratio of CHOL to alkyl chains. The mixed lipid systems all show a slightly increasing APT with increasing eCER fraction. Interestingly, there appears to be some level of APT non-additivity in these systems. For example, consider the APL and APTs of the 1-1 CER NS-CHOL systems. Since they have similar APLs as the pure CER NS systems, but ¾ the number of tails, ideal mixing would yield APL values that are 4/3 that of the pure CER NS values. However, the actual values are lower, suggesting a relative attraction between CHOL and the saturated tails of CER NS, similar to what was observed for dimyristoylphosphocholine tails), but not dioleoylphosphocholine (DOPC, a phospholipid with unsaturated tails) (55). Although perhaps expected based on chain saturation, this behavior is nontrivial for CER systems, since the CER NS headgroups are much smaller than PC headgroups and CHOL presumably has less empty space to occupy. Density Profiles. The bilayer thickness, calculated from the water density profiles, is a function of both overall lipid composition and CER FA tail length (Figure S5 and Table S2). The bilayer thickness decreases with increasing eCER and CHOL content, as one would expect since these lipids have shorter tail lengths than uCER or FFA. However, the tail length asymmetry leads to a richer behavior, which can be observed via examination of the lipid density profiles, as shown for each system in Figure 6. saturated The pure CER bilayers exhibit mass density profiles that contain the expected features of a lipid bilayer. Near the lipid-water interface, the profiles contain a peak (Figure 6a), which represents the heavy atoms in the CER headgroups. Just inside the headgroup region, there is a high density tail region where the tails are densely packed and highly ordered (see discussion of 21 nematic order above), consistent with prior work (37). In the center of the bilayer is a low density tail region, where the lipid tails are less densely packed and less ordered. This region exists primarily due to the asymmetry in the lengths of the tails in the systems and is composed of the terminal part of the uCER tail and FFA tails, as shown in Figure S6. In the systems with less asymmetry (i.e., high eCER and CHOL concentrations), the profile is more V-shaped in the middle since there is little interdigitation between tails in opposing leaflets. Comparing the high and low density tail regions for the different bilayers, the width of the high density tail region is found to be nearly constant across all compositions, whereas the width of the low density tail region varies with eCER and CHOL content. Figure 7 shows the total bilayer thickness as a function of the thickness of this low density tail region in the center of the bilayer. Clearly, the thickness of the low density tail region dictates the total bilayer thickness for a given composition. The width of the high density tail region is determined by the smallest hydrophobic length in the system, where the tails must pack densely to fit in the area dictated by the headgroups. For the lipids in this study, this is roughly 16 carbons, or the length of the sphingosine chain that is not part of the CER NS headgroup, which is also similar to the length of a CHOL molecule (56). 22 The profiles for the 5 subcompositions are shown for all compositions and are labelled as Figure 6. Total lipid mass density profiles across the bilayer for all systems considered: a) pure CER NS, b) 2-1 CER NS-CHOL, c) 1-1 CER NS-CHOL, d) equimolar CER NS-CHOL-FFA. follows: Solid black line 100 mol% eCER, dashed red line 75 mol% eCER, dot-dashed blue line 50 mol% eCER, solid orange line 25 mol% eCER, dotted purple line 0 mol% eCER. Note that these percentages denote the fraction of CER NS that is eCER, not the total fraction of eCER in the system. 23 Figure 7. Total bilayer thickness as a function of the thickness of the low density tail region, with the different points on each line denoting the different eCER fractions; the smallest values indicate 100 mol% eCER, and the largest 0 mol% eCER. The presence of CHOL and FFA has two main effects on the density profiles. First, the smaller headgroups of CHOL and FFA lead to smaller peaks in the headgroup region, compared to a pure CER NS bilayer; these peaks are dramatically reduced going from pure CER to 2-1 CER NS-CHOL and are mostly absent in the 1-1 CER NS-CHOL and ternary systems. Second, the width of the low density tail region increases with the addition of CHOL and FFA, as shown in Figure 6 and Figure 7. Additionally, the low density tail regions tend to have more features in the mixed lipid systems, e.g., shoulders representing intermediate densities due to the different tail lengths. Peaks also appear in the middle of the density profiles for the mixed systems, due both to the long FA chain of uCER (and FFA for the 3 component system) and the presence of CHOL that has migrated from the ordered bilayer region into the low density tail region (28). In the eCER-CHOL systems, the lack of significant interdigitation means this peak is absent; 24 however, all systems containing FFA demonstrate a peak in the middle of the density profile because of the long tail of FFA. Figure 8 shows the density profiles for the ternary system with 1-1 eCER-uCER, along the bilayer normal direction, broken down by the contribution of specific lipid components. The CHOL headgroup sits ~3 Å deeper into the bilayer with respect to the CER headgroups, which is consistent with prior simulation and experimental studies (23, 26, 31). There is also a small subpopulation of CHOL lying flat in the middle of the bilayer, illustrated by the peak in the middle of the CHOL ring density profile, which is consistent with the work of Das et al. (28) Additionally, the FFA headgroups tend to sit slightly further into the water than the CER headgroups. Figure 8. Mass density profiles of various groups in the ternary bilayer with a 1-1 eCER2- uCER2 composition. Note that the profiles for different groups are shifted vertically for clarity. Each curve is offset by 0.1 g/mL for each subsequent dataset in the legend. The interfacial width, which can indicate the hydrophobicity of the surface (e.g., a larger interfacial width would indicate a more hydrophilic surface), is defined as the width of the region over which the water density drops from the bulk value to 1/e of the bulk value. The bilayers in this work appear hydrophobic, having interfacial thicknesses between 3.5-6 Å2, compared to 25 phospholipid bilayers, which are generally greater than 10 Å (57). There is little dependence on the bilayer composition or CER FA tail length, as shown in Figure S7 and Table S3. Thus, we conclude that while the lamellar organization near the middle of the bilayer depends on the lipid composition, the apparent hydrophobicity of the lipid-water interface does not. Hydrogen Bonding. The total number of lipid-lipid hydrogen bonds in each system is listed in Table 3. The lipid-lipid hydrogen bonding is a function of the total CER content, with a reduction in CERs resulting in fewer lipid-lipid hydrogen bonds because CHOL and FFA molecules have fewer hydrogen bonding sites. The lipid-lipid hydrogen bonding is also independent of the eCER fraction, which may be expected since eCER and uCER have identical headgroups and their relative position at the interface is essentially unchanged as a function of the eCER2 fraction. 26 Table 3. Total number of lipid-lipid and lipid-water hydrogen bonds for each system studied. i d p i l - d i i p L r e t a w - d p L i i Fraction eCER 0.25 0.50 0.75 1.0 0 Composition 62 63 63 Pure CER NS 38 37 2-1 CER NS-CHOL 40 26 27 1-1 CER NS-CHOL 28 19 19 19 Ternary 173 168 173 176 171 Pure CER NS 2-1 CER NS-CHOL 173 169 173 175 176 1-1 CER NS-CHOL 168 170 164 167 173 154 152 158 158 155 Ternary 61 38 28 19 63 39 28 19 The hydrogen bonding between specific pairs of lipids for the ternary mixture with 1-1 eCER-uCER is listed in Table S4. Negligible CHOL-CHOL hydrogen bonding is observed, which can be rationalized by the fact that CHOL only has 1 hydrogen bond donor and acceptor, and two neighboring CHOL molecules would have to adopt a strained configuration to form a hydrogen bond. There are also very few CHOL-FFA hydrogen bonds, likely a result of CHOL sitting deeper into the bilayer. An appreciable number of CER-CHOL hydrogen bonds are seen, with slightly more eCER-CHOL (4.3) than uCER-CHOL (3.7) hydrogen bonds. Interestingly, the level of CER-CHOL hydrogen bonding is similar in the 2-1 and 1-1 CER-CHOL systems with, for example, 11.4 and 11.1 total CER-CHOL hydrogen bonds for the 2-1 and 1-1 CER- CHOL systems with 50 mol% eCER (Table S5 and Table S6); this trend may suggest that the CER-CHOL hydrogen bonding is saturated at or below 33 mol% CHOL. Additionally, when 27 CER is replaced by CHOL (i.e., comparing the pure CER NS and the 2-1 CER NS-CHOL or 1-1 CER NS-CHOL systems), there are fewer hydrogen bonds relative to the total number of hydrogen bonding sites in the system, indicating that CER-CER hydrogen bonds are preferred over CER-CHOL hydrogen bonds. There are comparatively fewer CER-CHOL hydrogen bonds in the ternary systems, since FFA is present and is competing with CHOL to form hydrogen bonds with the CER. There is a surprisingly low amount of FFA-FFA hydrogen bonding, given that FFA prefers to be near other FFA molecules (discussed below); however, FFA sits deeper into the water and thus forms more hydrogen bonds with water. The amount of lipid-water hydrogen bonding in each system is also listed in Table 3. Despite the relatively hydrophobic lipid-water interface, there are significantly more lipid-water hydrogen bonds than lipid-lipid hydrogen bonds. As with the lipid-lipid hydrogen bonds, the lipid-water hydrogen bonding is independent of the CER FA tail length. Interestingly, the pure CER and 2-1 CER-CHOL systems have similar amounts of lipid-water hydrogen bonds, despite the fact that CHOL has significantly fewer hydrogen bonding sites than CER, while the 1-1 CER-CHOL and ternary systems have comparably less lipid-water hydrogen bonds, since these systems have less CER (and hence fewer hydrogen bonding sites) than the systems with other two compositions. This trend in lipid-water hydrogen bonding is perhaps explained by the "spacer" effect of CHOL, discussed above with respect to the tilt angles. Although less CER results in fewer available hydrogen bonding sites, the spacing effect of CHOL allows the water to more thoroughly hydrate the CER headgroups and hence results in more lipid-water hydrogen bonds per hydrogen bonding site. In-Plane Morphology. For a general view of the in-plane morphology of each system, we examine coordination numbers (CNs) between specific lipid tails in the bilayer plane. The 28 CHOL-CHOL CNs depend on the amount of CHOL and available neighbors in a given system, and not on the CER FA tail length, as detailed in Figure S8 and Table S7. This result suggests a random distribution of CHOL throughout the bilayer leaflets. For example, there are equal numbers of three different types of tails in the 1-1 CER-CHOL systems (i.e., CER-FA, CER- SPH, and CHOL). Random mixing would give the observed CHOL-CHOL CN of 2. Applying this logic to the 2-1 CER-CHOL and ternary systems, random mixing would imply CHOL- CHOL CNs of 1.2 and 1.5 for each composition, respectively, which is observed. In contrast to CHOL, FFA shows a preference for specific neighbors, and thus has a less random distribution throughout the bilayer leaflets. In the uCER-CHOL-FFA system, the FFA-CERFA and FFA- CERSPH CNs are 1.39 ± 0.08 and 1.20 ± 0.07, respectively (where CERFA and CERSPH represent the fatty acid and sphingosine tails of CER, respectively). This result suggests that FFA has a preference for the FA chain of CER compared to the SPH chain. Additionally, a significant preference for FFA to be near FFA is observed, with a FFA-FFA CN of 2.3 ± 0.1, compared to 1.39 ± 0.08 for FFA-CERFA, the second highest. This has also been observed experimentally, with FFA-enriched domains forming with the tails tightly packed on an orthorhombic lattice (19). However, unlike experimental results on similar systems (41), we do not see any chain length-dependent behavior in regards to the mixing of CER and FFA. We note though that comparable experimental systems consider multilamellar structures, whereas we consider a single hydrated bilayer, which could account for the differences observed. We also note that the systems studied in the current work are several orders of magnitude smaller than comparable experimental systems (nm vs. µm), and that an in-depth study of lateral distributions of lipids is beyond the scope of this work. 29 DISCUSSION Relevance to Experimental Models of the Short Periodicity Phase. The localization of different groups within an experimental model of the short periodicity phase (SPP) of the SC has been studied with neutron diffraction (22, 23). These experimental systems resemble the systems studied here, with a few differences. First, we only consider CER NS, whereas experimental systems tend to include a mixture of CERs with different headgroups, although uCER typically accounts for the majority (~60%) of the CERs (11, 23). Secondly, we also only consider FFA C24, whereas experimental systems often include FFAs with a distribution of tail lengths. We note, however, recent work has shown that CER headgroup chemistry does not play a strong role in the lamellar organization of SPP models, and that systems with a distribution of FFA tail lengths had the same lamellar organization as a similar system with only FFA C24 (11). Perhaps the biggest difference between experimental systems and the systems studied here is that we consider a single bilayer, which is the typical approach to studying these systems with molecular simulation. Experimental systems usually contain membranes with numerous diffraction orders detected, indicating multilayer structures. Nonetheless, we can directly compare neutron scattering length density (NSLD) profiles from simulation and experiment. Additionally, we can compare the localization of specific groups based on mass density profiles from simulation and those reconstructed from selective deuteration of specific groups from experiment. In Figure 9 we compare the total NSLD profiles from experiment (22, 23) and simulation. The most obvious features of each are the large peaks at ±27 Å (experiment) and ±25 Å (simulation). Given the experimental resolution of ~5.4 Å, the locations of these peaks are in good agreement. Both simulation and experiment show valleys in the NSLD at ~7 Å, which we note aligns with the dips in the low tail density region from Figure 6d. Additionally, subtle 30 shoulders in the NSLDs are present at ±15 Å in both simulation and experiment, which aligns with the edges of the low tail density region shown in Figure 6d. Figure 9. Neutron scattering length density (NSLD) profiles, reconstructed from experiment(22) and calculated from simulation. Note that the profiles were shifted such that the minimum lies at 0, and the simulation curve was scaled to have the same height as the experimental curve. Focusing next on the localization of specific groups within the bilayer, we compare the mass density profiles from simulation with the difference between the protonated and deuterated NSLDs from experiment, shown in Figure S9. In this manner, we can compare the localization of specific groups between simulation and experiment. Comparing the location of the FA tail of uCER that was measured in Groen et al., (22) we find good agreement, with a single broad peak spanning ±7.5 Å (Figure S9a), which corresponds to the region where the uCER FA tails from opposing leaflets interdigitate. The CHOL tails are localized at ±2 Å in both simulation and experiment (Figure S9b) (23). The CHOL headgroups show some deviation between experiment and simulation, localized at ±23 Å and ±21 Å, respectively (Figure S9c). This discrepancy, however, is again within the experimental resolution of 5.4 Å (23). Despite the fact that we are 31 studying single bilayers, the locations of specific groups within the bilayer agree very well with experimental data on systems with similar compositions. Therefore, we can conclude that the model systems accurately approximate the model SPP systems from experiment, and conclusions from this work also likely apply to model SPP systems, and also the SPP in the SC. Effects on Barrier Properties of SC. In this work, the lipid composition and CER FA tail length were found to have the largest impact on lamellar organization, with the bilayer thickness and shape of the density profile in the low density tail region most affected. If we consider how these changes would affect the barrier properties (i.e., the permeability) of these bilayers, we can provide some insight into the observed experimental behavior. The permeability of a membrane is a product of the solute diffusion and partitioning, where the partitioning has an exponential dependence on the free energy of solvation. Due to this exponential dependence, small changes in local packing (i.e., depth-dependent density), can have a dominant impact on the bilayer permeability. Since the lipid mass density profiles are not constant across the bilayers, the resistance experienced by a permeant molecule would vary with bilayer depth. Moreover, since the low density tail regions are qualitatively different for the bilayers with different compositions, these depth-dependent partition coefficients would also change, albeit nontrivially. Thus, if one was interested in comparing the permeability of these different systems, a simple homogeneous solubility-diffusion model would not suffice. This indeed is not unrecognized in the field, as the few simulation studies of SC lipid permeability in the literature to date have used an inhomogeneous solubility-diffusion model (30, 52). While the structure of the lipids at the lipid-water interface changes with composition, it does not change with CER FA tail length. This is illustrated by the fact that the thickness of the interfacial region and lipid density profiles near the headgroups are unchanged with the CER FA 32 tail length for a given composition (Figure 6 and Figure S7). Additionally, both the total number of lipid-water and lipid-lipid hydrogen bonds is constant for a given composition. Thus, we expect any changes in the barrier properties of model SC membranes with CER FA tail length to be a result of changes in the structure of the bilayers in the hydrophobic core, and that changes in the headgroup region would play only a small role. This observation is consistent with the permeability measurements reported by Uchiyama et al., which show that the permeability of ethyl-p-aminobenzoic acid through membranes composed of synthetic mixtures of CER, CHOL, and FFA is independent of the CER composition, but strongly dependent on the FFA tail length dispersity (11). CONCLUSIONS We have studied via molecular dynamics simulations the structure of lipid bilayers relevant to the stratum corneum layer of the skin, as well as proposed and validated a thorough relaxation protocol for such systems. We first illustrated several difficulties in simulating SC lipid mixtures and multicomponent gel-phase bilayers in general e.g., systems tend to be frozen at physiological temperatures with only small lateral rearrangements possible. Since the most realistic morphologies are not generally known a priori, systems must be allowed to find the most realistic morphology. This task is shown to be computationally impractical at physiological temperatures and inefficient at commonly used elevated temperatures, as well as likely to lead to metastable states being confused for equilibrium states. The proposed random walk MD methodology, based on simulated tempering, was shown to be an efficient and reproducible method for minimizing the influence of an assumed, initial membrane configuration for multicomponent, gel-phase bilayers. We therefore expect this method to be especially useful as 33 simulations incorporate more complex lipid mixtures. Using the random walk MD protocol, we examined a series of SC lipid bilayers with varying lipid compositions and CER FA tail length. We showed that the lamellar organization is most affected by the lipid composition and CER FA tail length. Subtle changes to the lateral organization of the lipid tails as a function of the CER FA tail length were also seen. Additionally, since it was observed that the behavior at the lipid- water interface does not change with the CER FA tail length, we speculate that any tail length- dependent changes in barrier function are a result of changes in the lipid tail region and not the headgroup region. 34 Supporting Information. The Supporting Information contains the content listed below. An explanation of the various metrics used to quantify the structure of the bilayers in this study. Figure S1. Representative plot of temperature versus time during RWMD equilibration. Figure S2. Schematic of the bilayer thickness and interfacial thickness calculations. Figure S3. Visualization of the low tail density region. Figure S4. Nematic order parameter of lipid tails. Figure S5. Bilayer thickness as a function of lipid composition. Figure S6. Mass density profiles of the "unequal" part of the uCER2 tail and terminal 8 carbons of the FFA tail in the equimolar uCER2-CHOL-FFA system. Figure S7. Thickness of lipid water interface as a function of system composition. Figure S8. CHOL-CHOL coordination number as a function of system composition. Figure S9. Localization of various lipid components compared to neutron scattering results. Table S1. Nematic order parameter of lipid tails as a function of bilayer composition. Table S2. Bilayer thickness as a function of bilayer composition. Table S3. Thickness of lipid-water interface as a function of bilayer composition. Hydrogen bonding, broken down by lipid component, for the ternary system with Table S4. a 1-1 eCER2-uCER2 ratio. 35 Hydrogen bonding, broken down by lipid component, for the 2-1 CER2-CHOL Table S5. system with a 1-1 eCER2-uCER2 ratio. Hydrogen bonding, broken down by lipid component, for the 1-1 CER2-CHOL Table S6. system with a 1-1 eCER2-uCER2 ratio. Table S7. CHOL-CHOL coordination numbers as a function of system composition. AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS C.M., C.R.I., and A.L.B. designed research; T.C.M., and C.R.I. performed research; T.C.M. and R.H. contributed analytic tools; all authors analyzed data and wrote the article. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This work was supported by grant number R01 AR057886-01 from the National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases and National Science Foundation grant number CBET-1028374. This work was conducted in part using computational resources provided by the National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center, supported by the Office of Science of the Department of Energy under Contract No. DE-AC02-05CH11231 and the Advanced Computing Center for Research and Education at Vanderbilt University. REFERENCES 1. 2. Madison, K. C. 2003. Barrier Function of the Skin: ''La Raison d'Etre'' of the Epidermis. The Journal of Investigative Dermatology 121:231-241. Weerheim, A., and M. Ponec. 2001. Determination of stratum corneum lipid profile by tape stripping in combination with high-performance thin-layer chromatography. Archives of Dermatological Research 293:191-199. 36 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Janssens, M., J. van Smeden, G. S. Gooris, W. Bras, G. Portale, P. J. Caspers, R. J. Vreeken, T. Hankemeier, S. Kezic, R. Wolterbeek, A. P. M. Lavrijsen, and J. A. Bouwstra. 2012. Increase in short-chain ceramides correlates with an altered lipid organization and decreased barrier function in atopic eczema patients. The Journal of Lipid Research 53:2755-2766. Lavrijsen, A. P. M., J. A. Bouwstra, G. S. Gooris, A. Weerheim, H. E. Bodde, and M. Ponec. 1995. Reduced Skin Barrier Function Parallels Abnormal Stratum Corneum Lipid Organization in Patients with Lamellar Ichthyosis. The Journal of Investigative Dermatology 105:619-624. Pilgram, G. S. K., D. C. Vissers, H. van der Meulen, S. Pavel, A. P. M. Lavrijsen, J. A. Bouwstra, and H. K. Koerten. 2001. Aberrant lipid organization in stratum corneum of patients with atopic dermatitis and lamellar ichthyosis. The Journal of Investigative Dermatology 117:710-717. van Smeden, J., M. Janssens, W. A. Boiten, V. van Drongelen, L. Furio, R. J. Vreeken, A. Hovnanian, and J. A. Bouwstra. 2014. Intercellular skin barrier lipid composition and organization in Netherton syndrome patients. The Journal of Investigative Dermatology 134:1238-1245. Ishikawa, J., H. Narita, N. Kondo, M. Hotta, Y. Takagi, Y. Masukawa, T. Kitahara, Y. Takema, S. Koyano, S. Yamazaki, and A. Hatamochi. 2010. Changes in the ceramide profile of atopic dermatitis patients. The Journal of Investigative Dermatology 130:2511- 2514. Joo, K.-M., J.-H. Hwang, S. Bae, D.-H. Nahm, H.-S. Park, Y.-M. Ye, and K.-M. Lim. 2015. Relationship of ceramide-, and free fatty acid-cholesterol ratios in the stratum corneum with skin barrier function of normal, atopic dermatitis lesional and non-lesional skins. Journal of Dermatological Science 77:71-81. Rabionet, M., K. Gorgas, and R. Sandhoff. 2014. Ceramide synthesis in the epidermis. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta - Molecular and Cell Biology of Lipids 1841:422-434. de Jager, M., W. Groenink, R. Bielsa i Guivernau, E. Andersson, N. Angelova, M. Ponec, and J. A. Bouwstra. 2006. A novel in vitro percutaneous penetration model: evaluation of barrier properties with p-aminobenzoic acid and two of its derivatives. Pharmaceutical Research 23:951-960. Uchiyama, M., M. Oguri, E. H. Mojumdar, G. S. Gooris, and J. A. Bouwstra. 2016. Free fatty acids chain length distribution affects the permeability of skin lipid model membranes. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA) - Biomembranes 1858:2050-2059. Garidel, P., B. Fölting, I. Schaller, and A. Kerth. 2010. The microstructure of the stratum corneum lipid barrier: mid-infrared spectroscopic studies of hydrated ceramide:palmitic acid:cholesterol model systems. Biophysical Chemistry 150:144-156. 13. Lafleur, M. 1998. Phase behaviour of model stratum corneum lipid mixtures: an infrared spectroscopy investigation. Canadian Journal of Chemistry 76:1501-1511. 14. Mojumdar, E. H., G. S. Gooris, and J. A. Bouwstra. 2015. Phase behavior of skin lipid mixtures: the effect of cholesterol on lipid organization. Soft Matter 11:4326-4336. 15. Mojumdar, E. H., G. S. Gooris, D. Groen, David J. Barlow, M. J. Lawrence, B. Demé, and J. A. Bouwstra. 2016. Stratum corneum lipid matrix: location of acyl ceramide and cholesterol in the unit cell of the long periodicity phase. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA) - Biomembranes 1858:1926-1934. 9. 10. 11. 12. 37 21. 22. 19. 20. 16. Moore, D. J., M. E. Rerek, and R. Mendelsohn. 1999. Role of ceramides 2 and 5 in the structure of the stratum corneum lipid barrier. International Journal of Cosmetic Science 21:353-368. 17. Mueller, J., A. Schroeter, R. Steitz, M. Trapp, and R. H. H. Neubert. 2016. Preparation of a new oligolamellar stratum corneum lipid model. Langmuir 32:4673-4680. Rowat, A. C., N. Kitson, and J. L. Thewalt. 2006. Interactions of oleic acid and model 18. stratum corneum membranes as seen by 2H NMR. International Journal of Pharmaceutics 307:225-231. Školová, B., B. Januìššová, J. Zbytovská, G. S. Gooris, J. A. Bouwstra, P. Slepička, P. Berka, J. Roh, K. Palát, A. Hrabálek, and K. Vávrová. 2013. Ceramides in the skin lipid membranes: Length matters. Langmuir 29:15624-15633. Školová, B., B. Janůšová, and K. Vávrová. 2016. Ceramides with a pentadecasphingosine chain and short acyls have strong permeabilization effects on skin and model lipid membranes. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta - Biomembranes 1858:220-232. Velkova, V., and M. Lafleur. 2002. Influence of the lipid composition on the organization of skin lipid model mixtures: An infrared spectroscopy investigation. Chemistry and Physics of Lipids 117:63-74. Groen, D., G. S. Gooris, D. J. Barlow, M. J. Lawrence, J. B. van Mechelen, B. Demé, and J. A. Bouwstra. 2011. Disposition of ceramide in model lipid membranes determined by neutron diffraction. Biophysical Journal 100:1481-1489. 23. Mojumdar, E. H., D. Groen, G. S. Gooris, D. J. Barlow, M. J. Lawrence, B. Demé, and J. A. Bouwstra. 2013. Localization of cholesterol and fatty acid in a model lipid membrane: A neutron diffraction approach. Biophysical Journal 105:911-918. 24. Mojumdar, E. H., Z. Kariman, L. van Kerckhove, G. S. Gooris, and J. A. Bouwstra. 2014. The role of ceramide chain length distribution on the barrier properties of the skin lipid membranes. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA) - Biomembranes 1838:2473-2483. Akinshina, A., C. Das, and M. G. Noro. 2016. Effect of monoglycerides and fatty acids on a ceramide bilayer. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 18:17446-17460. Das, C., M. G. Noro, and P. D. Olmsted. 2009. Simulation studies of stratum corneum lipid mixtures. Biophysical Journal 97:1941-1951. Das, C., M. G. Noro, and P. D. Olmsted. 2013. Lamellar and Inverse Micellar Structures of Skin Lipids: Effect of Templating. Physical Review Letters 111:148101-148101. Das, C., M. G. Noro, and P. D. Olmsted. 2014. Fast cholesterol flip-flop and lack of swelling in skin lipid multilayers. Soft Matter 10:7346-7352. Guo, S., T. C. Moore, C. R. Iacovella, L. A. Strickland, and C. McCabe. 2013. Simulation study of the structure and phase behavior of ceramide bilayers and the role of lipid head group chemistry. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 9:5116-5126. Gupta, R., B. S. Dwadasi, and B. Rai. 2016. Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Skin Lipids: Effect of Ceramide Chain Lengths Bilayer Properties. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 120:12536-12546. Gupta, R., and B. Rai. 2015. Molecular Dynamics Simulation Study of Skin Lipids: Effects of the Molar Ratio of Individual Components over a Wide Temperature Range. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 119:11643-11655. Hoopes, M. I., M. G. Noro, M. L. Longo, and R. Faller. 2011. Bilayer structure and lipid dynamics in a model stratum corneum with oleic acid. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 115:3164-3171. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 38 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. Imai, Y., X. Liu, J. Yamagishi, K. Mori, S. Neya, and T. Hoshino. 2010. Computational analysis of water residence on ceramide and sphingomyelin bilayer membranes. Journal of Molecular Graphics & Modelling 29:461-469. Notman, R., J. Anwar, W. J. Briels, M. G. Noro, and W. K. den Otter. 2008. Simulations of skin barrier function: free energies of hydrophobic and hydrophilic transmembrane pores in ceramide bilayers. Biophysical Journal 95:4763-4771. Notman, R., W. K. den Otter, M. G. Noro, W. J. Briels, and J. Anwar. 2007. The permeability enhancing mechanism of DMSO in ceramide bilayers simulated by molecular dynamics. Biophysical Journal 93:2056-2068. Paloncýová, M., R. H. DeVane, B. P. Murch, K. Berka, and M. Otyepka. 2014. Rationalization of reduced penetration of drugs through ceramide gel phase membrane. Langmuir 30:13942-13948. Paloncýová, M., K. Vávrová, Ž. Sovová, R. H. DeVane, M. Otyepka, and K. Berka. 2015. Structural Changes in Ceramide Bilayers Rationalize Increased Permeation through Stratum Corneum Models with Shorter Acyl Tails. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 119:9811-9819. Pandit, S. A., and H. L. Scott. 2006. Molecular-dynamics simulation of a ceramide bilayer. The Journal of Chemical Physics 124:14708-14708. Uppulury, K., P. S. Coppock, and J. T. Kindt. 2015. Molecular Simulation of the DPPE Lipid Bilayer Gel Phase: Coupling Between Molecular Packing Order and Tail Tilt Angle. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B. Sparr, E., L. Eriksson, J. A. Bouwstra, and K. Ekelund. 2001. AFM study of lipid monolayers: III. Phase behavior of ceramides, cholesterol and fatty acids. Langmuir 17:164-172. Školová, B., K. Hudska, P. Pullmannova, A. Kovacik, K. Palat, J. Roh, J. Fleddermann, I. Estrela-Lopis, and K. Vávrová. 2014. Different Phase Behavior and Packing of Ceramides with Long (C16) and Very Long (C24) Acyls in Model Membranes: Infrared Spectroscopy Using Deuterated Lipids. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 118:10460- 10470. Oguri, M., G. S. Gooris, K. Bito, and J. A. Bouwstra. 2014. The effect of the chain length distribution of free fatty acids on the mixing properties of stratum corneum model membranes. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA) - Biomembranes 1838:1851-1861. Klauda, J. B., R. M. Venable, J. A. Freites, J. W. O'Connor, D. J. Tobias, C. Mondragon- Ramirez, I. Vorobyov, A. D. MacKerell, and R. W. Pastor. 2010. Update of the CHARMM all-atom additive force field for lipids: validation on six lipid types. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 114:7830-7843. Gillams, R. J., J. V. Busto, S. Busch, F. M. Goñi, C. D. Lorenz, and S. E. McLain. 2015. Solvation and hydration of the ceramide headgroup in a non-polar solution. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 119:128-139. Gillams, R. J., C. D. Lorenz, and S. E. McLain. 2016. Comparative atomic-scale hydration of the ceramide and phosphocholine headgroup in solution and bilayer environments. The Journal of Chemical Physics 144:225101-225101. Jorgensen, W. L., J. Chandrasekhar, J. D. Madura, R. W. Impey, and M. L. Klein. 1983. Comparison of simple potential functions for simulating liquid water. The Journal of Chemical Physics 79:926-926. 39 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 47. Marinari, E., and G. Parisi. 1992. Simulated Tempering: A New Monte Carlo Scheme. Europhysics Letters 19:451-458. 48. Abraham, M. J., T. Murtola, R. Schulz, S. Pall, J. C. Smith, B. Hess, and E. Lindahl. 2015. Gromacs: High performance molecular simulations through multi-level parallelism from laptops to supercomputers. SoftwareX 1-2:19-25. Hoover, W. G. 1985. Canonical Dynamics: Equilibrium Phase-Space Distributions. Physical Review A 31:1695-1967. Parrinello, M., and A. Rahman. 1981. Polymorphic transitions in single crystals: A new molecular dynamics method. Journal of Applied Physics 52:7182-7190. Essmann, U., L. Perera, M. L. Berkowitz, T. Darden, H. Lee, and L. G. Pedersen. 1995. A smooth particle mesh Ewald method. The Journal of Chemical Physics 103:8577-8593. Das, C., P. D. Olmsted, and M. G. Noro. 2009. Water permeation through stratum corneum lipid bilayers from atomistic simulations. Soft Matter 5:4549-4549. Hartkamp, R., T. C. Moore, C. R. Iacovella, M. A. Thompson, P. Bulsara, D. J. Moore, and C. McCabe. 2016. Investigating the Structure of Multicomponent Gel Phase Lipid Bilayers. Biophysical Journal 111:813-823. Gunstone, F. D., J. L. Harwood, and F. B. Padley. 1994. The Lipid Handbook. Chapman and Hall. Boughter, C. T., V. Monje-Galvan, W. Im, and J. B. Klauda. 2016. Influence of Cholesterol on Phospholipid Bilayer Structure and Dynamics. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 120:11761-11772. Shieh, H. S., L. G. Hoard, and C. E. Nordman. 1977. Crystal structure of anhydrous cholesterol. Nature 267:287-289. Tieleman, D. P., and H. J. C. Berendsen. 1996. Molecular dynamics simulations of a fully hydrated dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer with different macroscopic boundary conditions and parameters. Journal of Chemical Physics 105:4871-4880. 54. 55. 56. 57. 40
1704.06685	1	1704	2017-04-21T19:20:00	A Continuum Poisson-Boltzmann Model for Membrane Channel Proteins	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	Membrane proteins constitute a large portion of the human proteome and perform a variety of important functions as membrane receptors, transport proteins, enzymes, signaling proteins, and more. The computational studies of membrane proteins are usually much more complicated than those of globular proteins. Here we propose a new continuum model for Poisson-Boltzmann calculations of membrane channel proteins. Major improvements over the existing continuum slab model are as follows: 1) The location and thickness of the slab model are fine-tuned based on explicit-solvent MD simulations. 2) The highly different accessibility in the membrane and water regions are addressed with a two-step, two-probe grid labeling procedure, and 3) The water pores/channels are automatically identified. The new continuum membrane model is optimized (by adjusting the membrane probe, as well as the slab thickness and center) to best reproduce the distributions of buried water molecules in the membrane region as sampled in explicit water simulations. Our optimization also shows that the widely adopted water probe of 1.4 {\AA} for globular proteins is a very reasonable default value for membrane protein simulations. It gives an overall minimum number of inconsistencies between the continuum and explicit representations of water distributions in membrane channel proteins, at least in the water accessible pore/channel regions that we focus on. Finally, we validate the new membrane model by carrying out binding affinity calculations for a potassium channel, and we observe a good agreement with experiment results.	physics.bio-ph	physics	A Continuum Poisson--‐Boltzmann Model for Membrane Channel Proteins Li Xiao1, Jianxiong Diao2, D'Artagnan Greene2, Junmei Wang3, and Ray Luo1,2,4,5 University of California, Irvine, CA 92697, Biochemistry, 4. Chemical and Materials Physics Graduate Program, 5. Department of Chemical Engineering and Materials Science, 1. Department of Biomedical Engineering, 2. Department of Molecular Biology and 3. Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Pittsburg, Pittsburgh, PA 15261 Membrane proteins constitute a large portion of the human proteome and perform a variety of important functions as membrane receptors, transport proteins, enzymes, signaling proteins, and more. The computational studies of membrane proteins are usually much more complicated than those of globular proteins. Here we propose a new continuum model for Poisson--‐Boltzmann calculations of membrane channel proteins. Major improvements over the existing continuum slab model are as follows: 1) The location and thickness of the slab model are fine--‐tuned based on explicit--‐solvent MD simulations. 2) The highly different accessibility in the membrane and water regions are addressed with a two--‐ step, two--‐probe grid labeling procedure, and 3) The water pores/channels are automatically identified. The new continuum membrane model is optimized (by adjusting the membrane probe, as well as the slab thickness and center) to best reproduce the distributions of buried water molecules in the membrane region as sampled in explicit water simulations. Our optimization also shows that the widely adopted water probe of 1.4 Å for globular proteins is a very reasonable default value for membrane protein simulations. It gives an overall minimum number of inconsistencies between the continuum and explicit representations of water distributions in membrane channel proteins, at least in the water accessible pore/channel regions that we focus on. Finally, we validate the new membrane model by carrying out binding affinity calculations for a potassium channel, and we observe a good agreement with experiment results. 1 Please send correspondence to: [email protected] Introduction Membrane proteins constitute a large portion of the human proteome and perform a variety of important functions, such as membrane receptors, transport proteins, enzymes, and signaling proteins 1. These important proteins have become primary drug targets in modern medicine: over 60% of all drugs target these proteins 2--‐4. However, the study of membrane proteins is usually much more complicated than that of globular proteins, both experimentally and computationally. For experimental studies, the difficulty of obtaining a high--‐resolution structure is an obstacle, especially for studies that involve proteins found in humans. For computational studies, modeling of the membrane environment is also an important consideration. Since most biomolecular systems exist in an aqueous environment, it is important to account for solvent effects. There are two ways to include solvent effects in a computational simulation: explicit and implicit solvation. In explicit solvation modeling, each solvent atom is modeled explicitly. Although this is the most accurate method, what we are interested in is often not the properties of the solvent itself, but rather its influence on the solute molecules. In addition, accurately capturing the solvent influence in a statistically meaningful way requires sampling either from an ensemble of trajectories or from a single very long trajectory, which is very computationally demanding. Implicit solvation modeling provides an attractive alternative wherein the solvent molecules are collectively modeled as a continuum. In implicit solvent models, although the details of individual solvent atoms are lost, the relevant important statistically averaged effects can still be preserved by design. Since solvent molecules typically constitute the major portion of molecules for an explicit solvent simulation, implicit solvent modeling can lead to much 2 more efficient simulations 5--‐21. In addition to water, membrane molecules should also be included when modeling solvation effects, and implicit membrane modeling has also been developed 22--‐28. A key issue in developing implicit solvent models is the modeling of electrostatic interactions. The Poisson--‐Boltzmann equation (PBE) has been established as a fundamental equation to model continuum electrostatic interactions 29--‐47. The solvent molecules are modeled as a continuum with a high dielectric constant, and the solute atoms are modeled as a continuum with a low dielectric constant and buried atomic charges. The effect of charged ions in the solvent region is included by adding mobile charge density terms that obey Boltzmann distributions. The potential of the full system is then governed by the partial differential equation: where ∇ is the spatial gradient operator, ε is the dielectric constant distribution, 𝜙 is the electrostatic potential distribution, 𝜌! is the charge density of the solute (usually modeled as a set of discrete point charges), ci is the concentration of the ith solvent ion species in bulk, e is the absolute charge of an electron, zi is the valence for the ith ion, kB is Boltzmann's constant, T is the temperature, and λ is the Stern layer masking function, which is 0 within or 1 outside of the Stern layer. The PBE is a non--‐linear elliptical partial differential equation. There is no closed form solution, and thus, numerical methods are often required for biomolecular applications 22, 36, 44, 45, 48--‐87. Efficient numerical PBE--‐based solvent models have been widely used to study biological processes including predicting pKa values 88--‐91, computing solvation and binding free energies 92--‐101, and protein folding 102--‐112. Predicting protein--‐ ∇⋅ε∇φ= −4πρ0 − 4π eziciλexp(−eziφ/ kBT) 3 (1) i∑ ligand binding affinities is one of the major applications for implicit solvent free energy calculations. In the Amber software package, MMPBSA is the module performing such calculations 113--‐118. Implicit membrane modeling has also been applied and developed in binding free energy calculations. There are a noticeable number of pioneer works that implement implicit membrane modeling in several PB packages, such as APBS 27, Delphi 28, 119, PBEQ 78, 120, and PBSA 121--‐123. All of them add the membrane as a slab with a relatively low dielectric constant that is embedded in water for PBE calculations. Our previous work implemented an implicit membrane model into the PBE framework 121. The implicit membrane model can be readily interfaced with the existing MMPBSA program 113--‐118 to perform binding free energy calculations of several protein structures embedded in a membrane 87, 124. However, a problem arises when those membrane proteins contain a pore or a gated channel, since the region of the channel is usually permeable and should be composed of water. Therefore, a simple slab--‐like membrane setup may cause problems if the membrane protein contains pore--‐ or channel--‐ like region(s). Similar to the approaches adopted in the community 28, 119, 125, we dealt with this issue by manually defining the pore region as a cylinder, and we then set the dielectric constant within the cylindrical region as that of water if it was not occupied by protein atoms. The limitation of this method is that, for every snapshot of a trajectory, we need to visualize and locate the cylinder by hand, which is neither efficient nor practical given the large number of snapshots that must be processed for converged calculations. In this work, we propose a new continuum membrane model for PBE calculations of biomolecules. Major improvements from the existing continuum slab model are the following: 1) an explicit solvent MD simulation was exploited to fine tune the slab model, 4 i.e. its exact location and thickness, to best reproduce the solvent accessibility and the water accessible channel, 2) a two--‐step, two--‐probe initial grid labeling procedure was adopted to address highly different accessibility in the membrane region and water region, and 3) a depth--‐first search algorithm was introduced to detect the water pores/channels automatically based on the initial grid labels. This procedure follows our basic algorithm proposed for globular proteins, and adds little overall overhead in the application of linear finite--‐difference PBE solvers to typical membrane proteins. Methods The Poisson--‐Boltzmann equation (Eqn (1)) is widely used in capturing electrostatic energy and forces in implicit solvent modeling. For systems with dilute ion concentrations, the second term on the right--‐hand side is usually linearized, giving the simpler form: (2) where κ2 = 4π ciei The finite--‐difference method 22, 43, 71--‐83, 86 is one of the most popular methods used in the numerical implementation of the PBE. In a typical procedure, the rectangular grid covering the solution system is first defined. Next, the atomic point charges are mapped onto the grid points with a predefined assignment function. Third, the dielectric constant distribution is mapped to the grid edges. The discretized linear system is then turned to a linear solver to solve for potentials on the grid points, which can be expressed as: ∇ ⋅ε∇φ= −4πρ0 +λκ2φ . 2 / kBT 2zi i∑ 5 ⎡ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎣ 4πρ(i, j,k) h εx,εy, εz − ⎤ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎦ + h2λ(i, j,k)κ2φ(i, j,k) = − εx(i, j,k)φ(i +1, j,k) +εx(i −1, j,k)φ(i −1, j,k) ⎤ ⎡ ⎥ ⎢ εy(i, j,k)φ(i, j +1,k) +εy(i, j −1,k)φ(i, j −1,k) ⎥ ⎢ εz(i, j,k)φ(i, j,k +1) +εz(i, j,k −1)φ(i, j,k −1) ⎥ ⎢ ⎦ ⎣ εx(i −1, j,k) +εx(i, j,k) +εy(i, j −1,k) ⎤ ⎡ ⎥φ(i, j,k) ⎢ εy(i, j,k) +εz(i, j,k −1) +εz(i, j,k) ⎦ ⎣ (3) and Here represent the dielectric constants for grid edges along the x, y, and z directions respectively, and h represents the grid spacing. This study focuses on how to set up linear PBE applications for membrane systems. A major issue is the presence of the membrane and its influence on the dielectric constant distribution. In globular proteins, the solvent excluded surface (SES)43, 126--‐130 is often used as a boundary separating the high dielectric water exterior and the low dielectric protein interior. The presence of the membrane introduces at least a third region. In this study, we adopt the uniform membrane dielectric model, though our procedure can be easily extended to accommodate another often used depth--‐dependent membrane dielectric model. The first step is to introduce a membrane region to the existing solvent excluded surface procedure with minimum invasion to the program and minimum efficiency lost. The SES is the most common surface definition used to describe the dielectric interface between the two piece--‐wise dielectric constants. In fact, comparative analysis of PB--‐based solvent models and TIP3P solvent models have shown that the SES definition is reasonable in the calculation of reaction field energies and electrostatic potentials of mean force fields. 131--‐133 Here, we follow the idea from Rocchia et al. 130 and Wang et al. 43 of mapping the SES to a finite--‐difference grid. While keeping the variables used to label the solvent and solute regions, we also introduce a new variable to label the membrane region. Considering the 6 membrane molecules are usually larger than solvent molecules, we use two different solvent probe radii to set up the membrane and solvent regions. And finally, we assign the dielectric constant on each region and the interface. Grid point labeling Our general strategy is to model the membrane as a second continuum solvent of finite region, i.e. a slab located at a user specified position. The essence of the algorithm is to determine both the membrane accessibility and water accessibility around a molecular solute. Assisted with both sets of accessibility data, the presence of water channels or water pores within the membrane region can then be identified in the next step. Due to the much larger size of lipid molecules, a separate solvent probe (mprob) must be used to determine the membrane accessibility. This is apparently much larger than the water probe (dprob). The influence of both probes on reproducing the solvent accessible surface of a membrane protein is presented in Results and Discussion. In Amber/PBSA, an integer array insas is used to label whether the grid point is outside the solute region (insas<0) or inside the solute region (insas>0) for fast mapping of solvent accessibility information 43. This labeling scheme has been extended to map all commonly used surfaces, SES, SAS, VDW, and DEN in recent Amber and AmberTools releases.36, 43, 80, 82, 87, 134, 135 To minimize the interference to existing procedures and maximize efficiency, a separate integer array inmem is used to label whether a grid point is inside the membrane (inmem>0) or outside the membrane (inmem=0). Specifically, the grid labeling algorithm can be summarized as the following five steps: 7 0. Initialize insas of all grid points as "-4", i.e. in the bulk solvent and salt region, and inmem of all grid points as "0", i.e. outside the membrane region. 1. Using mprob as the solvent probe radius, label insas of all grid points as "-3" if within the stern layer; "-2" if within the solvent accessible surface layer; "-1" if within the reentry region but outside the SES; "1" if within the reentry region but inside the SES; "2" if inside the VDW surface. 2. Add a slab perpendicular to the z-axis as the membrane region at the specified location. Label inmem of the membrane-region grid points with insas<0 as "1". 3. Apply the depth-first search algorithm to detect any possible membrane accessible grid point that is not connected to the bulk membrane. If so, relabel its inmem as "0". 4. For each grid point with (inmem=0) within the slab, if it has a neighbor with (inmem=1) within the distance cutoff of memmaxd, relabel its inmem as "2". 5. Using dprob as the solvent probe radius, relabel insas of all grid points as "-3" if within the stern layer; "-2" if within the solvent accessible surface layer; "-1" if within the reentry region outside the SES; "1" if within the reentry region inside the SES; "2" if inside the VDW surface. A few explanations are in order here. First, inmem is determined in Step 2 through Step 4, so that its value is controlled by both the mprob--‐generated insas and the depth--‐first search algorithm. Second, a new variable (memmaxd) is introduced in Step 4. Since mprob is usually much larger than dprob, there exists a thin layer of grid points with insas>0 and inmem=0 between the membrane region and the protein region. If the grid labels are set this way, these grid points would be labeled as water in a later processing stage of our method, thus leading to an artificial layer of water between the protein and membrane. To resolve this issue, a cutoff distance of memmaxd is introduced to represent the maximum difference between the SES surfaces generated by mprob and dprob. This is estimated to be mprob−dprob assuming maximum reentry by dprob. Thus Step 4 changes the inmem labels of the grid points from 0 (mprob inaccessible) to 2 (mprob accessible) if they are memmaxd inside the mprob--‐generated SES. The correction effectively removes the artificial layer of water between the protein and the membrane. Here the revised inmem values are 8 set to be "2" so these grid points would not interfere with the subsequent search. Note too that this correction does not change the protein interior definition, which is defined with the water dprob. Nevertheless, it does have the effect of pushing back the potential buried water pockets, if any, from the protein--‐membrane interface. In summary, the three different regions that are readily available for further processing after the grid--‐labeling step are: 1. Solute region: insas(i,j,k)>0 2. Membrane region: insas(i,j,k)<0 and inmem(i,j,k)>0 3. Solvent region: insas(i,j,k)<0 and inmem(i,j,k)=0 Membrane pore/channel detection Step 3 in the above general grid--‐labeling algorithm is meant to identify pore--‐ or channel--‐ like water--‐accessible water pockets within a user--‐specified membrane region. Given the convention that the membrane is parallel with the xy plane, the membrane region can be mathematically defined to be all grid points within [zmin, zmax]. Thus the method starts by initializing all grid points that are defined as solvent (insas<0) within [zmin, zmax] as inmem=1. Next the recursive depth-first search algorithm is used to traverse all grid points to see whether they are connected or not. Our goal of using the algorithm is to walk and label recursively all grid points in the non-protein regions within [zmin, zmax]. Upon completion, all grid points that are not connected to the membrane region (i.e. the pore region) are labeled back as the water region (inmem=0). To facilitate the bookkeeping of the search, the variable kzone is introduced to label the different regions: the protein region (kzone=0), the membrane region (kzone=1), and the water regions (kzone>1). Since the search starts from the edge of the membrane slab, the first region found is always the membrane region (kzone=1), and the rest are the water regions or the protein region. In general multiple kzone values are assigned 9 because most water-accessible regions are not connected. The algorithm can be summarized as shown below: nzone = 0; kzone = -1 for k = zmin:zmax for j,i = 1:n cycle if kzone(i,j,k) != -1 then end if if insas(i,j,k) > 0 then else kzone(i,j,k) = 0 nzone = nzone + 1 kzone(i,j,k) = nzone call walk(i,j,k,kzone,nzone) end if end end recursive subroutine walk(i,j,k,kzone,nzone) kzone(i,j,k) = nzone if (kzone(i+1,j,k) == -1 .and. insas(i+1,j,k)<0) call walk(i+1,j,k,kzone,nzone) if (kzone(i-1,j,k) == -1 .and. insas(i-1,j,k)<0) call walk(i-1,j,k,kzone,nzone) if (kzone(i,j+1,k) == -1 .and. insas(i,j+1,k)<0) call walk(i,j+1,k,kzone,nzone) if (kzone(i,j-1,k) == -1 .and. insas(i,j-1,k)<0) call walk(i,j-1,k,kzone,nzone) if (k+1<=zmax .and. kzone(i,j,k+1) == -1 .and. insas(i,j,k+1)<0) call walk(i,j,k+1,kzone,nzone) if (k-1>=zmin .and. kzone(i,j,k-1) == -1 .and. insas(i,j,k-1)<0) call walk(i,j,k-1,kzone,nzone) In this way, all grid points with kzone>1 are water accessible, and inmem of these end recursive subroutine walk grid points are set back to 0, i.e. membrane inaccessible. Mapping solvent/membrane accessibility to dielectric constants 10 In this study, we adopted a three--‐dielectric model to model the membrane--‐protein electrostatics. The dielectric constants for the three different regions are denoted as inε outε (solvent) and εmem (membrane), respectively. (solute), The next step is to map the grid labeling information into the dielectric constants at the midpoints on all grid edges. The general principle, to be consistent with Wang et al, 43 is that the dielectric constant of a grid edge should be equal to the dielectric constant in the region where the two flanking grid points reside. When the two neighboring grid points belong to different dielectric regions, the weighted harmonic averaging (WHA) method is used to calculate the "fractional" dielectric constant based on the precise intersection point where the molecular surface cut the grid edge 43. Specifically the dielectric constant is assigned as: (4) where a denotes the fraction of the grid edge in region 1. Eqn (4) is applied on three different kinds of interfaces: (5) The assignment of dielectric constants on the solute and solvent interface is the same as Wang et al 43. We now consider the grid edge between (i,j,k) and (i+1,j,k); the grid edge can be classified according to the rules in Table I. The procedure of assigning the dielectric constants on the membrane related region and interface is as follows, for each of the x--‐, y--‐, and z--‐edges, respectively. ε1 = εin,ε2 = εout solute and solvent interface ε1 = εin,ε2 = εmem solute and membrane interface ε1 = εout,ε2 = εmem solvent and membrane interface 11 , 1 1− a ε2 + a ε1 ε= insas(i,j,k) >0 >0 >0 >0 >0 >0 >0 >0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 <0 insas(i+1,j,k) >0 >0 >0 >0 <0 <0 <0 <0 >0 >0 >0 >0 <0 <0 <0 <0 inmem(i,j,k) >0 >0 =0 =0 >0 >0 =0 =0 >0 >0 =0 =0 >0 >0 =0 =0 inmem(i+1,j,k) >0 =0 >0 =0 >0 =0 >0 =0 >0 =0 >0 =0 >0 =0 >0 =0 region inside solute inside solute inside solute inside solute solute and membrane interface solute and solvent interface solute and membrane interface solute and solvent interface solute and membrane interface solute and membrane interface solute and solvent interface solute and solvent interface inside membrane inside solvent inside solvent inside solvent Table I: Different edges of dielectric constants defined by adjacent values of insas and inmem. For x--‐edges, fractional membrane edges are only possible with the membrane--‐ solute interface, so that the following pseudo code can be added to the existing dielectric mapping procedure: If (inmem(i,j,k)>0 .or. inmem(i+1,j,k)>0) then If (insas(i,j,k)>0 .and. insas(i+1,j,k)>0) then εx(i, j,k) =εin // grid edge in solute else if ((insas(i,j,k)>0 .and. inmem(i+1,j,k)>0) .or. (insas(i+1,j,k)>0 .and. inmem(i,j,k)>0) ) then // grid edge between membrane and solute else if (insas(i,j,k)>0 .or. insas(i+1,j,k)>0) then εx(i, j,k) = εx(i, j,k) = 1 1− a + εmem a εin 1 1− a + εout a εin // grid edge between solvent and solute else if(inmem(i,j,k)>0 .and. inmem(i+1,j,k)>0) then εx(i, j,k) = εmem // grid edge in membrane end if 12 end if Here a is the fraction of grid edge in the solute region. The algorithm along the y--‐axis is similar to the x--‐axis, as follows: If (inmem(i,j,k)>0 .or. inmem(i,j+1,k)>0) then If (insas(i,j,k)>0 .and. insas(i,j+1,k)>0) then εy(i, j,k) = εin // grid edge in solute else if ((insas(i,j,k)>0 .and. inmem(i,j+1,k)>0) .or. (insas(i,j+1,k)>0 .and. inmem(i,j,k)>0) ) then // grid edge between membrane and solute else if (insas(i,j,k)>0 .or. insas(i,j+1,k)>0) then εy(i, j,k) = εy(i, j,k) = 1 1− a + εmem a εin 1 1− a + εout a εin // grid edge between solvent and solute else if(inmem(i,j,k)>0 .and. inmem(i,j+1,k)>0) then εy(i, j,k) = εmem end if // grid edge in membrane end if For the dielectric constant mapping along the z--‐axis, the algorithm also involves the solvent--‐membrane interface; the algorithm should also take care of this, as follows: If (inmem(i,j,k)>0 .or. inmem(i,j,k+1)>0) If (insas(i,j,k)>0 .and. insas(i,j,k+1)>0) then εz(i, j,k) =εin else if ((insas(i,j,k)>0 .and. inmem(i,j,k+1)>0) .or. (insas(i,j,k+1)>0 .and. inmem(i,j,k)>0) ) then εz(i, j,k) = // grid edge between membrane and solute else if (insas(i,j,k)>0 .or. insas(i,j,k+1)>0) then 1 1− a + εmem a εin 1 1− a + εout a εin εz(i, j,k) = // grid edge between solvent and solute else if(inmem(i,j,k)>0 .and. inmem(i,j,k+1)>0) then 13 εz(i, j,k) = εmem 1 + εz(i, j,k) = a εout 1− a εmem else if (grid edge is cross the slab) end if // grid edge cross the slab // a is fraction of edge in solvent end if Finally, all the edges in the water are assigned the dielectric constant of water, all the edges in the membrane are assigned the dielectric constant of membrane, and all the edges in the protein interior are assigned the dielectric constant of protein. For all the edges crossing different regions, i.e. between any two of water, membrane, or protein, weighted harmonic averages between the two corresponding dielectric constants are assigned. Protein and complex structure preparation To calibrate the new continuum membrane model for channel detection, we simulated three channel proteins with crystal structures: 1K4C 136, a KcsA potassium channel; 5CFB 137, an alpha1 GlyR Glycine receptor; and 5HCJ 138, a prokaryotic pentameric ligand--‐gated ion channel. To demonstrate the feasibility of the new continuum membrane model in data intensive binding affinity calculations, we chose the hERG K+ channel protein, given its importance in drug discovery and the availability of high--‐quality experimental data 139. A homology model of hERG K+ channel was built based on the X--‐ray crystal structure of KcsA 136 (PDB ID: 1K4C) using MODELLER 140 (version 9.15) with the default settings. The amino acid sequence of hERG K+ channel was directly extracted from the Swiss--‐Prot 14 database 141 (accession number: Q12809 and entry: KCNH2_HUMAN). Sequence alignment was generated using CLUSTALX 142 (version 2.1), showing a good match in helices S5, S6, and the pore region, with identity about 44% (Figure 1). After automatic model building and loop refinement, candidate models were evaluated based on the DOPE score from MODELLER 140. The final homology model of the hERG K+ channel is shown in Figure 2, which is found to be highly consistent with a previously reported model based on a different procedure 143--‐146. Figure 1: Sequence alignment of KcsA and hERG by ClustalX version 2.1. The identified S5 helix, S6 helix, amphipathic helix and pore helix are labeled above the sequence. Asterisks (*): conserved amino acid residues; colons (:): conserved substitutions; dots (.): semi-conserved substitutions. 15 Figure 2: Comparison of target and parent structures, showing the secondary structure elements in homology models of hEGH (red) and KcsA (blue). The plot shows three orientations of the aligned structure. Top: side view with the binding pocket on the top. Bottom left: viewed from the binding pocket/extracellular side. Bottom right: viewed from the intracellular side. Initial complex structures of the hERG K+ channel with its inhibitors were generated with the SURFLEX--‐DOCK program in Sybyl--‐X (version 1.3). Ten different inhibitors with experimental binding affinities 139 were chosen to assess the quality of the MMPBSA procedure, including astemizole (AST), sertindole (SER), pimozide (PIM), droperidol 16 (DRO), terfenadine (TE0, TE1), domperidone (DOM), loratadine (LOR), mizolaatine (MIZ), perhexiline (PE0, PE1) and amitriptyline (AMI). The terfenadine and perhexiline are chiral molecules with two enantiomers, so both enantiomers were used in the docking. Molecular dynamics simulation MMPBSA calculations of binding affinities The protein was first inserted into a membrane layer using the CHARMM--‐GUI lipid builder 147--‐151. Lipid DPPC was used for the membrane layer with a lipid to water ratio of 29. The solvated membrane system first underwent a 10,000--‐step energy minimization using a 5,000--‐step steepest descent followed by a 5,000--‐step conjugate gradient. The main chain atoms for the protein were then restrained with a force constant of 2 kcal/mol--‐Å2. Subsequently, a 5 ps MD simulation was conducted to heat the system from 0 to 100K followed by a 100 ps MD simulation to heat the system from 100K to 310K. This was then followed with a 5 ns simulation for equilibration. Finally, production MD was run for 50 ns. Binding free energies were computed using a revised MMPBSA module124 of Amber 16 or AmberTools 2016 134, 135, 152. The production run trajectory was post--‐processed with CPPTRAJ 153 in order to remove the solvent, membrane, and counter ions from the receptor--‐ligand complex. Snapshots from the last 10 ns of the production run were processed to compute molecular mechanics potential energies and solvation free energies in the MMPBSA procedure. The binding free energy for the protein--‐ligand complex was computed as the difference between the complex free energy and the sum of the receptor and ligand free energies, as outlined in our previous work 124. The electrostatic solvation 17 free energies were calculated using the linearized PBE model as implemented in PBSA 36, 43, 80, 82, 87. The non--‐electrostatic solvation free energies were calculated using either the classical model or the modern model as documented previously 154. Additional computational details In each PBSA calculation, a finite--‐difference grid spacing of 0.5 Å was used for MMPBSA calculations, which was found to be sufficient due to MD sampling and the approximate nature of the binding affinity calculation 118. Production snapshots up to 10ns were found to be sufficient to converge the averaging process used in MMPBSA calculations of these membrane protein--‐ligand complexes. The periodic geometric multigrid solver option was employed with a convergence threshold of 1.0 x 10--‐3, and electrostatic focusing was turned off due to the presence of the membrane 87. The use of a periodic boundary also allowed a somewhat small fillratio (i.e. the ratio of the finite--‐difference box dimension over the solute dimension) of 1.25 to be used in these calculations 37. The solvation system physical constants were set up as follows. The membrane was modeled as a solid slab as simulated in the explicit water MD trajectories. The water relative dielectric constant was set at 80.0. The membrane dielectric constant was set to be 7.0 124. And the protein dielectric constant was set to be 20.0 due to the presence of charged ligand molecules 118, 124. The water phase ionic strength was set to be 150 mM. The lower dielectric region within the molecular solutes was defined with the classical solvent excluded surface model using a water solvent probe and a membrane solvent probe to be optimized as described in Results and Discussion. The default weighted harmonic averaging was employed to assign 18 dielectric constants for boundary grid edges to reduce grid dependency 43. Charges and radii were assigned as in the simulation topology files. Results and Discussion Optimization of the new slab membrane model Given the automatic procedure in place to identify water channels/pores with the depth--‐first search method, we further optimized the membrane probe value and the slab membrane model (i.e. its thickness) to best reproduce the distributions of buried water molecules in the membrane region as sampled in explicit water MD simulations. Three different membrane proteins with channels were utilized in this optimization: 1K4C, 5HCJ, and 5CFB. Three different slab definitions were evaluated to set up the continuum membrane model, i.e. the inner and outer faces are chosen to be positioned at (1) the average z--‐ coordinates of nitrogen atoms of the lipid head groups; (2) the average z--‐ coordinates of the phosphorus atoms of the lipid head groups; (3) the average z--‐ coordinates of both nitrogen and phosphorus atoms in the lipid head groups. Here the average z--‐coordinates are computed from the explicit--‐water MD simulations. Next, mprob values were scanned from 1.4 Å upwards to 3.0 Å with an increment of 0.1 Å. The smallest mprob value with which these known channels can be displayed was recorded as the mprob threshold in Table II for all three slab membrane definitions. It should be pointed out that a small mprob produces excessive membrane accessibility in the protein interior so that it is more likely for the buried membrane pockets to be 19 connected to the bulk membrane. Excessive membrane accessibility can also be lessened by reducing the membrane thickness, as in the use of phosphorus atoms to define the boundaries of the continuum membrane. Indeed, our analysis showed this setup caused the least penetration of the continuum membrane into the protein interior, so the smallest mprob (2.7 Å) was needed to capture the water channels/pores for all three tested proteins. Figure 3 shows the rendering of water--‐channels/pores of the three tested membrane proteins with the optimized mprob. The advantage of the optimal mprob over the default solvent probe of 1.4 Å is apparent by comparing the renderings generated with the two probes. For all the channel proteins, the new model automatically detects the water channels/pores. Figure 4 further shows the benefit of the depth--‐first--‐search feature that is a must in the new slab membrane model. Without it, it is apparent that none of the water channels/pores can be identified for any of the tested proteins, even using the larger probe for the membrane region. Protein mthick (Å) mcenter(Å) mprob (Å) 1K4C 5CFB 5HCJ 1K4C 5CFB 5HCJ 1K4C 5CFB 5HCJ mthick=N+–N– -1.10 64.95 68.60 mthick=P+–P– -0.97 64.97 68.40 mthick=N+P+– N–P– -1.04 64.96 68.50 >2.2 >1.7 >3.0 >2.2 >1.6 >2.7 >2.2 >1.7 >3.0 39.24 40.72 41.11 36.13 37.27 37.89 37.69 39.00 39.50 20 Table II The thickness of membrane and mprob thresholds based on the different criterion measured from MD simulations. Here the mprob threshold is the minimum value with which the channel is visible with the SES approach. (Top) mthick=N+–N–: The thickness of the membrane slab is defined as the z-distance between the average head group nitrogen atoms of the lipid molecules. (Middle) mthick=P+–P–: The thickness of the membrane slab is defined as the z- distance between the average head group phosphorus atoms of the lipid molecules. (Bottom) mthick=N+P+– N–P–: the membrane slab is defined as the z-distance between the average head group centers (i.e. the means of nitrogen and phosphorus atoms) of the lipid molecules. The membrane center locations were then computed as the mean of the upper and lower bounds. 21 Figure 3 Solvent-solute interface determined with the new continuum membrane model. Left: mprob is set to be 1.4 Angstroms, the default value of the solvent probe. Right: mprob is set to be 2.7 Angstroms, the optimized value of the membrane probe. Three proteins are tested: 1K4C (top); 5CFB (middle); 5HCJ (bottom). 22 Figure 4 Same as Figure 3, except without turning on the depth-first search in the pore region detection. Three proteins are tested: 1K4C (top); 5CFB (middle); 5HCJ (bottom). Impact of the water solvent probe upon agreement with an explicit solvent simulation It is worth pointing out that the agreement of the continuum membrane model also depends on how we model the water accessible region. The standard practice has been to consider the finite size of the water molecule with a predefined probe radius, often taken as 1.4 Å. The probe is then used to compute the solvent excluded surface used as the interface separating the protein interior from the water region. It is apparent that the size of the water accessible pores/channels would depend on how large the water probe is defined. Thus, it is interesting to analyze how well the widely used water probe performs in the context of membrane channel proteins. This analysis was conducted in the following manner. The distributions of water molecules (in the water pore/channel regions) in explicit water MD simulations were sampled every 50 ps over the course of a 5 ns production run. Note that the protein atoms were all restrained to the reference structure after equilibration since the focus was on the water distribution. A total of 100 frames worth of water sampling were collected and were combined into one snapshot for visualization. This water distribution map was used as a reference to evaluate how the hard sphere SES surface behaves with one single adjustable parameter, i.e. the water solvent probe (dprob in Amber/PBSA). The same three membrane channel proteins were analyzed to address this question. Specifically, the counts for the following disagreements/mismatches were recorded: (1) the absence of explicit water molecules in the continuum water accessible regions; and (2) the 23 presence of explicit water molecules in the continuum water inaccessible regions. The overall summary of both mismatches is reported in Table III. Sample mismatches are shown in Figure 5. It is interesting to note that the standard value of the water solvent probe of 1.4 Å is a very reasonable default value, which gives an overall minimum number inconsistencies between the continuum and explicit representations of water of distributions in the tested membrane channel proteins, at least in the water accessible pore/channel regions that we have focused on. Protein dprob (Å) No. solvent region w/o water molecules No. water molecules in non-solvent region Table III Discrepancies in the solvent accessible region between explicit water MD simulations and the membrane PBSA calculations. Two types of discrepancies were recorded: (1) how many continuum solvent pockets do not have water molecules; and (2) how many explicit water molecules are observed in the non-continuum solvent pockets defined in the membrane PBSA calculation. The water probe (dprob) was scanned from 1.2 Å to 1.6 Å for three different proteins: 1K4C, 5CFB, 5HCJ. The membrane setup has been optimized according to the values given in Table II. For each protein, the samples of water molecules were taken from a 5ns equilibrium MD simulation with all protein atoms restrained to the initial structure, which was obtained from the last snapshot of the unconstrained normal MD, which is also the reference for the water sampling run. The listed values are the averages of 100 snapshots evenly selected from the 5ns MD simulation. 24 1K4C 5CFB 5HCJ 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 23 18 15 14 12 20 17 14 10 7 22 18 9 9 7 4 8 11 14 15 5 10 11 17 22 4 7 11 17 23 Figure 5 Discrepancy between implicit and explicit water simulations. The protein surface of 1K4C (blue) is overlaid with a bond representation and sampled water positions (yellow). Left: a solvent region defined by the PBSA model but with no explicit water. Right: explicit water is detected in a region where no solvent is defined in the PBSA model. It is instructive to point out that the inconsistency between the two representations may be due to the setup of the explicit water MD simulation and also to the limitations of MD sampling of water distributions. First, it is well known that isolated water cavities exist in the protein interior, which are disconnected from the bulk water. Unless crystal water molecules were observed and retained in the initial setup of the MD simulations, these isolated cavities are most likely modeled as water--‐free due to the default closeness tolerance used in the placement of explicit water molecules when building the topology files. This issue would lead to the type (1) mismatches described above. Second, although protein atoms were restrained during the MD simulations, they are not as inflexible as frozen hard spheres as in the case of the continuum solvent model that must use a single mean structure as input. Their motions allow minor structural changes, leading to the opening and closing of buried water cavities. If the mean structure 25 happens to correspond to a closed form, the continuum model would not capture the water--‐accessible cavity. Finally, the protein atom cavity radii that were used to present the size of each atom were chosen to be best for energetics and/or stability of the MD simulations. These may or may not be optimal to quantify water accessibility in the protein interior. This points to future efforts to model the protein--‐water interface more self--‐consistently based on the consistent energy model as defined by the protein--‐water force field used in both explicit and implicit simulations. MMPBSA calculations of binding affinities Finally, as an illustration of our new continuum membrane model, we conducted a set of binding free energy calculations of ten different ligands independently bound to a potassium channel protein. The computed binding affinities and experimental IC50 values are summarized in Table IV. The correlation analysis between computation and experiment is shown in Figure 6. Both the classical and modern nonpolar solvent models (INP=1 and INP=2 respectively) were tested, and the correlations for these two methods are similar, which is consistent with what we expected. Overall good correlations with experiment were observed: with correlation coefficients of 0.79 for INP=1 and 0.73 for INP=2 (due to the smaller range of the data). Name RTln(IC50) mthick Amitriptyline Perhexline (PE0) Perhexline (PE1) -7.08 -7.23 -7.23 36.086 36.661 36.473 26 mcenter MMPBSA (INP=1) -38.23 -40.73 -41.96 -10.383 -1.620 -5.681 MMPBSA (INP=2) -9.84 -12.44 -13.63 Mizolastine Loratadine Domperidone Terfenadine (TE0) Terfenadine (TE1) droperidol Pimozide Sertindole Astemizole -9.15 -9.58 -9.62 -9.82 -9.82 -10.61 -10.97 -11.13 -12.81 36.260 36.126 35.979 36.616 37.216 36.459 36.910 36.438 34.133 1.360 -0.969 0.707 -2.319 -0.611 3.308 0.190 -1.161 -0.043 -61.25 -52.48 -59.53 -69.67 -72.91 -59.04 -60.04 -62.91 -67.64 -24.59 -18.64 -20.69 -29.00 -30.56 -24.78 -20.09 -23.89 -26.21 Table IV: MMPBSA binding affinities (kcal/mol) in comparison with experiment (IC50). The slab membrane geometry (the thickness and z-center in Å) compiled from the explicit solvent MD simulation are also shown for each complex. Figure 6: MMPBSA binding affinities compared with experimental measurements. Binding affinities are in kcal/mol. Top: MMPBSA was computed with the classical nonpolar solvent 27 model (INP=1), the correlation coefficient is 0.79. Bottom: MMPBSA was computed with the modern nonpolar solvent model (INP=2), the correlation coefficient is 0.73. Timing analysis Finally, we conducted a timing analysis of the new membrane model. Table V summarizes the average CPU times over 100 frames that are used for setting up the dielectric grids with or without the membrane model in the MMPBSA calculation of the receptor. We can see the average time for the surface calculation increases by more than four times; this is mainly because two separate SES calls are made, once with the water probe and once with the membrane probe. Furthermore, the SES calculation with the much larger membrane probe is behind the much higher cost in the total SES time due to the longer non--‐bonded list and many more overlaps among larger probe--‐augmented atomic volumes. In addition, the grid--‐ labeling step is also about three times slower, though not a significant portion of the overall CPU cost. Finally, the mapping from grid labels to dielectric constants changes little due to the virtually linear nature of the algorithm 43. Overall the PBSA calculations are about 25% slower with the new continuum membrane model than those without any continuum membrane (i.e. modeled as a globular protein) for the tested protein--‐ligand binding calculations. Globular Protein Setup 3.76 1.61 0.21 Membrane Protein Setup 15.63 4.79 0.22 SES Calculations (s) Grid Labeling (s) EPS Mapping (s) Table V: Average CPU times (in seconds) used in setting up the dielectric grid for 100 snapshots in the MMPBSA calculation of the receptor. The membrane-free set up was run using memopt=0, and the membrane setup was run using memopt=1 in Amber/PBSA. 28 Conclusions We have proposed a new continuum membrane model for Poisson--‐Boltzmann calculations of biomolecules. Major improvements from the standard continuum slab model are the following: 1) explicit--‐solvent MD simulations were utilized to fine tune the slab model, i.e. its exact location and thickness, to best reproduce the solvent accessibility and the water accessible channel; 2) A two--‐step, two--‐probe initial grid labeling procedure was adopted to address highly different accessibility in the membrane region and water region; and 3) A depth--‐first search algorithm was introduced to detect the water pores/channels automatically based on the initial grid labels. This procedure follows our basic algorithm proposed for globular proteins and does not add significant overhead to the numerical PB calculations. Given the revisions proposed above, we optimized the membrane probe value and the slab membrane model (i.e. its thickness) to best reproduce the distributions of buried water molecules in the membrane region as sampled in explicit water MD simulations. Three different membrane proteins with channels were utilized in this optimization. Our analysis showed that a slab membrane model using the mean phosphate atom positions as the membrane boundary and the smallest membrane probe of 2.7 Å caused the least penetration of the continuum membrane into the protein interior. Apparently, the solvent accessibility also depends on how the continuum water is modeled. Thus, we used a water distribution map from an explicit water MD simulation as benchmark data to evaluate how the hard sphere SES behaves with one single adjustable parameter, i.e. the water solvent probe. The same three membrane channel proteins were 29 analyzed to address this question. It is interesting to note that the standard value for the water solvent probe of 1.4 Å is very reasonable, which gives an overall minimum number of inconsistencies between the continuum and explicit representations of water distributions in the membrane channel proteins, at least in the water accessible pore/channel regions that we have focused on. Finally, we conducted a set of binding affinity calculations of ten different ligands independently bound to a potassium channel using the new continuum membrane model. Both the classical and modern nonpolar solvent models were tested, and the correlations with experiment are similar with both models, which is consistent with our findings in globular proteins. Overall good correlations with experiment were observed, with correlation coefficients of 0.79 for INP=1 and 0.73 for INP=2. Finally, our timing analysis showed that the average time for the surface calculation increased by more than four times. The grid--‐labeling step is also about three times slower even though it is not a significant portion of the overall CPU cost. The mapping from grid labels to dielectric constants changed little due to the virtually linear nature of the algorithm. Future efforts will be conducted to model the protein--‐water interface more self--‐ consistently based on the consistent energy model as defined using the protein--‐water force field in both explicit and implicit simulations. This work is supported in part by the NIH (GM093040 & GM079383). Acknowledgements 30 References 1. Almen, M. S.; Nordstrom, K. J. V.; Fredriksson, R.; Schioth, H. B., Mapping the human membrane proteome: a majority of the human membrane proteins can be classified according to function and evolutionary origin. Bmc Biol 2009, 7. Arinaminpathy, Y.; Khurana, E.; Engelman, D. M.; Gerstein, M. B., Computational 2. analysis of membrane proteins: the largest class of drug targets. Drug Discov Today 2009, 14, 1130--‐1135. Yildirim, M. A.; Goh, K. I.; Cusick, M. E.; Barabasi, A. L.; Vidal, M., Drug--‐target network. 3. Nat Biotechnol 2007, 25, 1119--‐1126. 4. Overington, J. P.; Al--‐Lazikani, B.; Hopkins, A. L., Opinion --‐ How many drug targets are there? Nat Rev Drug Discov 2006, 5, 993--‐996. Davis, M. E.; Mccammon, J. A., Electrostatics in Biomolecular Structure and 5. Dynamics. Chem Rev 1990, 90, 509--‐521. 6. Honig, B.; Sharp, K.; Yang, A. S., Macroscopic Models Of Aqueous--‐Solutions --‐ Biological And Chemical Applications. J. Phys. Chem. 1993, 97, 1101--‐1109. Honig, B.; Nicholls, A., Classical Electrostatics in Biology and Chemistry. Science 7. 1995, 268, 1144--‐1149. 8. Beglov, D.; Roux, B., Solvation of complex molecules in a polar liquid: An integral equation theory. Journal of Chemical Physics 1996, 104, 8678--‐8689. 9. Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G., Implicit solvation models: Equilibria, structure, spectra, and dynamics. Chem Rev 1999, 99, 2161--‐2200. Bashford, D.; Case, D. A., Generalized born models of macromolecular solvation 10. effects. Annual Review Of Physical Chemistry 2000, 51, 129--‐152. 11. Baker, N. A., Improving implicit solvent simulations: a Poisson--‐centric view. Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 2005, 15, 137--‐143. Chen, J. H.; Im, W. P.; Brooks, C. L., Balancing solvation and intramolecular 12. interactions: Toward a consistent generalized born force field. Journal of the American Chemical Society 2006, 128, 3728--‐3736. Feig, M.; Chocholousova, J.; Tanizaki, S., Extending the horizon: towards the efficient 13. modeling of large biomolecular complexes in atomic detail. Theoretical Chemistry Accounts 2006, 116, 194--‐205. 14. Koehl, P., Electrostatics calculations: latest methodological advances. Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 2006, 16, 142--‐151. Im, W.; Chen, J. H.; Brooks, C. L., Peptide and protein folding and conformational 15. equilibria: Theoretical treatment of electrostatics and hydrogen bonding with implicit solvent models. Peptide Solvation and H--‐Bonds 2006, 72, 173--‐+. Lu, B. Z.; Zhou, Y. C.; Holst, M. J.; McCammon, J. A., Recent progress in numerical 16. methods for the Poisson--‐Boltzmann equation in biophysical applications. Communications in Computational Physics 2008, 3, 973--‐1009. 17. Wang, J.; Tan, C. H.; Tan, Y. H.; Lu, Q.; Luo, R., Poisson--‐Boltzmann solvents in molecular dynamics simulations. Communications in Computational Physics 2008, 3, 1010--‐ 1031. Altman, M. D.; Bardhan, J. P.; White, J. K.; Tidor, B., Accurate Solution of Multi--‐Region 18. Continuum Biomolecule Electrostatic Problems Using the Linearized Poisson--‐Boltzmann 31 Equation with Curved Boundary Elements. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2009, 30, 132--‐153. 19. Cai, Q.; Wang, J.; Hsieh, M.--‐J.; Ye, X.; Luo, R. Chapter Six --‐ Poisson–Boltzmann Implicit Solvation Models. In Annual Reports in Computational Chemistry, Ralph, A. W., Ed.; Elsevier: 2012; Vol. Volume 8, pp 149--‐162. Xiao, L.; Wang, C.; Luo, R., Recent progress in adapting Poisson–Boltzmann methods 20. to molecular simulations. Journal of Theoretical and Computational Chemistry 2014, 13, 1430001. Botello--‐Smith, W. M.; Cai, Q.; Luo, R., Biological applications of classical electrostatics 21. methods. Journal of Theoretical and Computational Chemistry 2014, 13, 1440008. 22. Forsten, K. E.; Kozack, R. E.; Lauffenburger, D. A.; Subramaniam, S., Numerical--‐ Solution of the Nonlinear Poisson--‐Boltzmann Equation for a Membrane--‐Electrolyte System. J. Phys. Chem. 1994, 98, 5580--‐5586. Spassov, V. Z., Yan, L., and Szalma, S. , Introducing an Implicit Membrane in 23. Generalized Born/Solvent Accessibility Continuum Solvent Models. J Phys. Chem. B 2002, 106. Im, W., Feigh, M., and Brooks III, C. L. , An Implicit Membrane Generalized Born 24. Theory for the Study of Structure, Stability, and Interactions of Membrane Proteins. Biophysical Journal 2003, 85, 2900--‐18. Tanizaki, S.; Feig, M., A generalized Born formalism for heterogeneous dielectric 25. environments: Application to the implicit modeling of biological membranes. Journal of Chemical Physics 2005, 122. Tanizaki, S.; Feig, M., Molecular dynamics simulations of large integral membrane 26. proteins with an implicit membrane model. J Phys Chem B 2006, 110, 548--‐556. 27. Callenberg, K. M.; Choudhary, O. P.; de Forest, G. L.; Gohara, D. W.; Baker, N. A.; Grabe, M., APBSmem: A Graphical Interface for Electrostatic Calculations at the Membrane. PloS One 2010, 5. Li, L.; Li, C.; Sarkar, S.; Zhang, J.; Witham, S.; Zhang, Z.; Wang, L.; Smith, N.; Petukh, M.; 28. Alexov, E., DelPhi: a comprehensive suite for DelPhi software and associated resources. BMC biophysics 2012, 5, 9. 29. Warwicker, J.; Watson, H. C., Calculation of the Electric--‐Potential in the Active--‐Site Cleft Due to Alpha--‐Helix Dipoles. J Mol Biol 1982, 157, 671--‐679. 30. Bashford, D.; Karplus, M., Pkas Of Ionizable Groups In Proteins --‐ Atomic Detail From A Continuum Electrostatic Model. Biochemistry 1990, 29, 10219--‐10225. Jeancharles, A.; Nicholls, A.; Sharp, K.; Honig, B.; Tempczyk, A.; Hendrickson, T. F.; 31. Still, W. C., Electrostatic Contributions To Solvation Energies --‐ Comparison Of Free--‐Energy Perturbation And Continuum Calculations. Journal of the American Chemical Society 1991, 113, 1454--‐1455. 32. Gilson, M. K., Theory Of Electrostatic Interactions In Macromolecules. Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 1995, 5, 216--‐223. Edinger, S. R.; Cortis, C.; Shenkin, P. S.; Friesner, R. A., Solvation free energies of 33. peptides: Comparison of approximate continuum solvation models with accurate solution of the Poisson--‐Boltzmann equation. J Phys Chem B 1997, 101, 1190--‐1197. 34. Tan, C.; Yang, L.; Luo, R., How well does Poisson--‐Boltzmann implicit solvent agree with explicit solvent? A quantitative analysis. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2006, 110, 18680--‐18687. 32 35. Cai, Q.; Wang, J.; Zhao, H.--‐K.; Luo, R., On removal of charge singularity in Poisson--‐ Boltzmann equation. Journal of Chemical Physics 2009, 130. 36. Wang, J.; Cai, Q.; Li, Z.--‐L.; Zhao, H.--‐K.; Luo, R., Achieving energy conservation in Poisson--‐Boltzmann molecular dynamics: Accuracy and precision with finite--‐difference algorithms. Chemical Physics Letters 2009, 468, 112--‐118. Ye, X.; Cai, Q.; Yang, W.; Luo, R., Roles of Boundary Conditions in DNA Simulations: 37. Analysis of Ion Distributions with the Finite--‐Difference Poisson--‐Boltzmann Method. Biophysical Journal 2009, 97, 554--‐562. Ye, X.; Wang, J.; Luo, R., A Revised Density Function for Molecular Surface Calculation 38. in Continuum Solvent Models. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2010, 6, 1157--‐ 1169. 39. Luo, R.; Moult, J.; Gilson, M. K., Dielectric screening treatment of electrostatic solvation. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 1997, 101, 11226--‐11236. 40. Wang, J.; Tan, C.; Chanco, E.; Luo, R., Quantitative analysis of Poisson--‐Boltzmann implicit solvent in molecular dynamics. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2010, 12, 1194--‐1202. 41. Hsieh, M. J.; Luo, R., Exploring a coarse--‐grained distributive strategy for finite--‐ difference Poisson--‐Boltzmann calculations. Journal of Molecular Modeling 2011, 17, 1985--‐ 1996. Cai, Q.; Ye, X.; Wang, J.; Luo, R., On--‐the--‐Fly Numerical Surface Integration for Finite--‐ 42. Difference Poisson--‐Boltzmann Methods. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2011, 7, 3608--‐3619. 43. Wang, J.; Cai, Q.; Xiang, Y.; Luo, R., Reducing Grid Dependence in Finite--‐Difference Poisson--‐Boltzmann Calculations. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2012, 8, 2741--‐2751. 44. Liu, X.; Wang, C.; Wang, J.; Li, Z.; Zhao, H.; Luo, R., Exploring a charge--‐central strategy in the solution of Poisson's equation for biomolecular applications. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2013. 45. Wang, C.; Wang, J.; Cai, Q.; Li, Z. L.; Zhao, H.; Luo, R., Exploring High Accuracy Poisson--‐Boltzmann Methods for Biomolecular Simulations. Computational and Theoretical Chemistry 2013, 1024, 34--‐44. 46. Xiao, L.; Cai, Q.; Ye, X.; Wang, J.; Luo, R., Electrostatic forces in the Poisson--‐Boltzmann systems. The Journal of Chemical Physics 2013, 139, 094106. Xiao, L.; Cai, Q.; Li, Z.; Zhao, H. K.; Luo, R., A Multi--‐Scale Method for Dynamics 47. Simulation in Continuum Solvent I: Finite--‐Difference Algorithm for Navier--‐Stokes Equation. Chemical Physics Letters 2014, submitted. 48. Miertus, S.; Scrocco, E.; Tomasi, J., Electrostatic Interaction of a Solute with a Continuum --‐ a Direct Utilization of Abinitio Molecular Potentials for the Prevision of Solvent Effects. Chemical Physics 1981, 55, 117--‐129. 49. Hoshi, H.; Sakurai, M.; Inoue, Y.; Chujo, R., Medium Effects on the Molecular Electronic--‐Structure .1. the Formulation of a Theory for the Estimation of a Molecular Electronic--‐Structure Surrounded by an Anisotropic Medium. Journal of Chemical Physics 1987, 87, 1107--‐1115. 50. Zauhar, R. J.; Morgan, R. S., The Rigorous Computation of the Molecular Electric--‐ Potential. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1988, 9, 171--‐187. 33 51. Rashin, A. A., Hydration Phenomena, Classical Electrostatics, and the Boundary Element Method. J. Phys. Chem. 1990, 94, 1725--‐1733. Yoon, B. J.; Lenhoff, A. M., A Boundary Element Method for Molecular Electrostatics 52. with Electrolyte Effects. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1990, 11, 1080--‐1086. 53. Juffer, A. H.; Botta, E. F. F.; Vankeulen, B. A. M.; Vanderploeg, A.; Berendsen, H. J. C., The Electric--‐Potential Of A Macromolecule In A Solvent --‐ A Fundamental Approach. Journal of Computational Physics 1991, 97, 144--‐171. 54. Zhou, H. X., Boundary--‐element Solution of Macromolecular Electorstatic--‐interaction energy Between 2 Proteins. Biophysical Journal 1993, 65, 955--‐963. Bharadwaj, R.; Windemuth, A.; Sridharan, S.; Honig, B.; Nicholls, A., The Fast 55. Multipole Boundary--‐Element Method for Molecular Electrostatics --‐ an Optimal Approach for Large Systems. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1995, 16, 898--‐913. Purisima, E. O.; Nilar, S. H., A Simple yet Accurate Boundary--‐Element Method for 56. Continuum Dielectric Calculations. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1995, 16, 681--‐689. 57. Liang, J.; Subramaniam, S., Computation of molecular electrostatics with boundary element methods. Biophysical Journal 1997, 73, 1830--‐1841. Vorobjev, Y. N.; Scheraga, H. A., A Fast Adaptive Multigrid Boundary Element Method 58. For Macromolecular Electrostatic Computations In A Solvent. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1997, 18, 569--‐583. Cortis, C. M.; Friesner, R. A., Numerical Solution Of The Poisson--‐Boltzmann Equation 59. Using Tetrahedral Finite--‐Element Meshes. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1997, 18, 1591--‐1608. Holst, M.; Baker, N.; Wang, F., Adaptive Multilevel Finite Element Solution Of The 60. Poisson--‐Boltzmann Equation I. Algorithms And Examples. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2000, 21, 1319--‐1342. 61. Baker, N.; Holst, M.; Wang, F., Adaptive multilevel finite element solution of the Poisson--‐Boltzmann equation II. Refinement at solvent--‐accessible surfaces in biomolecular systems. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2000, 21, 1343--‐1352. 62. Totrov, M.; Abagyan, R., Rapid Boundary Element Solvation Electrostatics Calculations In Folding Simulations: Successful Folding Of A 23--‐Residue Peptide. Biopolymers 2001, 60, 124--‐133. 63. Boschitsch, A. H.; Fenley, M. O.; Zhou, H. X., Fast boundary element method for the linear Poisson--‐Boltzmann equation. J Phys Chem B 2002, 106, 2741--‐2754. Shestakov, A. I.; Milovich, J. L.; Noy, A., Solution Of The Nonlinear Poisson--‐Boltzmann 64. Equation Using Pseudo--‐Transient Continuation And The Finite Element Method. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 2002, 247, 62--‐79. 65. Lu, B. Z.; Cheng, X. L.; Huang, J. F.; McCammon, J. A., Order N Algorithm For Computation Of Electrostatic Interactions In Biomolecular Systems. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2006, 103, 19314--‐19319. 66. Xie, D.; Zhou, S., A New Minimization Protocol For Solving Nonlinear Poisson– Boltzmann Mortar Finite Element Equation. BIT Numerical Mathematics 2007, 47, 853--‐871. Chen, L.; Holst, M. J.; Xu, J. C., The Finite Element Approximation Of The Nonlinear 67. Poisson--‐Boltzmann Equation. Siam Journal on Numerical Analysis 2007, 45, 2298--‐2320. 68. Lu, B.; Cheng, X.; Huang, J.; McCammon, J. A., An Adaptive Fast Multipole Boundary Element Method for Poisson--‐Boltzmann Electrostatics. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2009, 5, 1692--‐1699. 34 69. Bajaj, C.; Chen, S.--‐C.; Rand, A., An Efficient Higher--‐Order Fast Multipole Boundary Element Solution For Poisson--‐Boltzmann--‐Based Molecular Electrostatics. Siam Journal on Scientific Computing 2011, 33, 826--‐848. 70. Bond, S. D.; Chaudhry, J. H.; Cyr, E. C.; Olson, L. N., A First--‐Order System Least--‐ Squares Finite Element Method for the Poisson--‐Boltzmann Equation. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2010, 31, 1625--‐1635. 71. Klapper, I.; Hagstrom, R.; Fine, R.; Sharp, K.; Honig, B., Focusing of Electric Fields in the Active Site of Copper--‐Zinc Superoxide Dismutase Effects of Ionic Strength and Amino Acid Modification. Proteins Structure Function and Genetics 1986, 1, 47--‐59. Davis, M. E.; McCammon, J. A., Solving The Finite--‐Difference Linearized Poisson--‐ 72. Boltzmann Equation --‐ A Comparison Of Relaxation And Conjugate--‐Gradient Methods. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1989, 10, 386--‐391. Nicholls, A.; Honig, B., A Rapid Finite--‐Difference Algorithm, Utilizing Successive 73. over--‐Relaxation to Solve the Poisson--‐Boltzmann Equation. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1991, 12, 435--‐445. Luty, B. A.; Davis, M. E.; McCammon, J. A., Solving the Finite--‐Difference Nonlinear 74. Poisson--‐Boltzmann Equation. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1992, 13, 1114--‐1118. 75. Holst, M.; Saied, F., Multigrid Solution of the Poisson--‐Boltzmann Equation. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1993, 14, 105--‐113. Holst, M. J.; Saied, F., Numerical--‐Solution Of The Nonlinear Poisson--‐Boltzmann 76. Equation --‐ Developing More Robust And Efficient Methods. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1995, 16, 337--‐364. Bashford, D., An Object--‐Oriented Programming Suite for Electrostatic Effects in 77. Biological Molecules. Lecture Notes in Computer Science 1997, 1343, 233--‐240. 78. Im, W.; Beglov, D.; Roux, B., Continuum Solvation Model: computation of electrostatic forces from numerical solutions to the Poisson--‐Boltzmann equation. Comput. Phys. Commun. 1998, 111, 59--‐75. Rocchia, W.; Alexov, E.; Honig, B., Extending The Applicability Of The Nonlinear 79. Poisson--‐Boltzmann Equation: Multiple Dielectric Constants And Multivalent Ions. J Phys Chem B 2001, 105, 6507--‐6514. 80. Wang, J.; Luo, R., Assessment of Linear Finite--‐Difference Poisson--‐Boltzmann Solvers. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2010, 31, 1689--‐1698. 81. Luo, R.; David, L.; Gilson, M. K., Accelerated Poisson--‐Boltzmann calculations for static and dynamic systems. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2002, 23, 1244--‐1253. Cai, Q.; Hsieh, M.--‐J.; Wang, J.; Luo, R., Performance of Nonlinear Finite--‐Difference 82. Poisson--‐Boltzmann Solvers. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2010, 6, 203--‐211. 83. Xiao, L.; Cai, Q.; Ye, X.; Wang, J.; Luo, R., Electrostatic forces in the Poisson--‐Boltzmann systems. Journal of Chemical Physics 2013, 139. 84. Wang, J.; Cieplak, P.; Li, J.; Wang, J.; Cai, Q.; Hsieh, M.; Lei, H.; Luo, R.; Duan, Y., Development of Polarizable Models for Molecular Mechanical Calculations II: Induced Dipole Models Significantly Improve Accuracy of Intermolecular Interaction Energies. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2011, 115, 3100--‐3111. 85. Lu, B.; Holst, M. J.; McCammon, J. A.; Zhou, Y. C., Poisson--‐Nernst--‐Planck Equations For Simulating Biomolecular Diffusion--‐Reaction Processes I: Finite Element Solutions. Journal of Computational Physics 2010, 229, 6979--‐6994. 35 86. Lu, Q.; Luo, R., A Poisson--‐Boltzmann dynamics method with nonperiodic boundary condition. Journal of Chemical Physics 2003, 119, 11035--‐11047. Botello--‐Smith, W. M.; Luo, R., Applications of MMPBSA to Membrane Proteins I: 87. Efficient Numerical Solutions of Periodic Poisson–Boltzmann Equation. Journal of Chemical Information and Modeling 2015, 55, 2187--‐2199. Georgescu, R. E.; Alexov, E. G.; Gunner, M. R., Combining conformational flexibility 88. and continuum electrostatics for calculating pK(a)s in proteins. Biophysical Journal 2002, 83, 1731--‐1748. Nielsen, J. E.; McCammon, J. A., On the evaluation and optimization of protein X--‐ray 89. structures for pKa calculations. Protein Sci 2003, 12, 313--‐326. 90. Warwicker, J., Improved pK(a) calculations through flexibility based sampling of a water--‐dominated interaction scheme. Protein Sci 2004, 13, 2793--‐2805. Tang, C. L.; Alexov, E.; Pyle, A. M.; Honig, B., Calculation of pK(a)s in RNA: On the 91. structural origins and functional roles of protonated nucleotides. J. Mol. Biol. 2007, 366, 1475--‐1496. Swanson, J. M. J.; Henchman, R. H.; McCammon, J. A., Revisiting free energy 92. calculations: A theoretical connection to MM/PBSA and direct calculation of the association free energy. Biophysical Journal 2004, 86, 67--‐74. 93. Bertonati, C.; Honig, B.; Alexov, E., Poisson--‐Boltzmann calculations of nonspecific salt effects on protein--‐protein binding free energies. Biophysical Journal 2007, 92, 1891--‐ 1899. 94. Brice, A. R.; Dominy, B. N., Analyzing the Robustness of the MM/PBSA Free Energy Calculation Method: Application to DNA Conformational Transitions. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2011, 32, 1431--‐1440. Luo, R.; Gilson, H. S. R.; Potter, M. J.; Gilson, M. K., The physical basis of nucleic acid 95. base stacking in water. Biophysical Journal 2001, 80, 140--‐148. David, L.; Luo, R.; Head, M. S.; Gilson, M. K., Computational study of KNI--‐272, a potent 96. inhibitor of HIV--‐1 protease: On the mechanism of preorganization. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 1999, 103, 1031--‐1044. 97. Shivakumar, D.; Deng, Y. Q.; Roux, B., Computations of Absolute Solvation Free Energies of Small Molecules Using Explicit and Implicit Solvent Model. J Chem Theory Comput 2009, 5, 919--‐930. 98. Nicholls, A.; Mobley, D. L.; Guthrie, J. P.; Chodera, J. D.; Bayly, C. I.; Cooper, M. D.; Pande, V. S., Predicting small--‐molecule solvation free energies: An informal blind test for computational chemistry. Journal of Medicinal Chemistry 2008, 51, 769--‐779. 99. Korman, T. P.; Tan, Y.--‐H.; Wong, J.; Luo, R.; Tsai, S.--‐C., Inhibition kinetics and emodin cocrystal structure of a type II polyketide ketoreductase. Biochemistry 2008, 47, 1837--‐ 1847. 100. Luo, R.; Head, M. S.; Given, J. A.; Gilson, M. K., Nucleic acid base--‐pairing and N--‐ methylacetamide self--‐association in chloroform: affinity and conformation. Biophysical Chemistry 1999, 78, 183--‐193. 101. Mardis, K. L.; Luo, R.; Gilson, M. K., Interpreting trends in the binding of cyclic ureas to HIV--‐1 protease. J. Mol. Biol. 2001, 309, 507--‐517. 102. Marshall, S. A.; Vizcarra, C. L.; Mayo, S. L., One--‐ and two--‐body decomposable Poisson--‐ Boltzmann methods for protein design calculations. Protein Sci 2005, 14, 1293--‐1304. 36 103. Hsieh, M. J.; Luo, R., Physical scoring function based on AMBER force field and Poisson--‐Boltzmann implicit solvent for protein structure prediction. Proteins--‐Structure Function and Bioinformatics 2004, 56, 475--‐486. 104. Wen, E. Z.; Luo, R., Interplay of secondary structures and side--‐chain contacts in the denatured state of BBA1. Journal of Chemical Physics 2004, 121, 2412--‐2421. 105. Wen, E. Z.; Hsieh, M. J.; Kollman, P. A.; Luo, R., Enhanced ab initio protein folding simulations in Poisson--‐Boltzmann molecular dynamics with self--‐guiding forces. Journal of Molecular Graphics & Modelling 2004, 22, 415--‐424. 106. Lwin, T. Z.; Luo, R., Overcoming entropic barrier with coupled sampling at dual resolutions. Journal of Chemical Physics 2005, 123. 107. Lwin, T. Z.; Zhou, R. H.; Luo, R., Is Poisson--‐Boltzmann theory insufficient for protein folding simulations? Journal of Chemical Physics 2006, 124. 108. Lwin, T. Z.; Luo, R., Force field influences in beta--‐hairpin folding simulations. Protein Science 2006, 15, 2642--‐2655. 109. Tan, Y.--‐H.; Luo, R., Protein stability prediction: A Poisson--‐Boltzmann approach. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2008, 112, 1875--‐1883. 110. Tan, Y.; Luo, R., Structural and functional implications of p53 missense cancer mutations. BMC Biophysics 2009, 2, 5. 111. Lu, Q.; Tan, Y.--‐H.; Luo, R., Molecular dynamics simulations of p53 DNA--‐binding domain. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2007, 111, 11538--‐11545. 112. Wang, J.; Tan, C.; Chen, H.--‐F.; Luo, R., All--‐Atom Computer Simulations of Amyloid Fibrils Disaggregation. Biophysical Journal 2008, 95, 5037--‐5047. 113. Srinivasan, J.; Cheatham, T. E.; Cieplak, P.; Kollman, P. A.; Case, D. A., Continuum solvent studies of the stability of DNA, RNA, and phosphoramidate --‐ DNA helices. Journal of the American Chemical Society 1998, 120, 9401--‐9409. 114. Kollman, P. A.; Massova, I.; Reyes, C.; Kuhn, B.; Huo, S. H.; Chong, L.; Lee, M.; Lee, T.; Duan, Y.; Wang, W.; Donini, O.; Cieplak, P.; Srinivasan, J.; Case, D. A.; Cheatham, T. E., Calculating structures and free energies of complex molecules: Combining molecular mechanics and continuum models. Accounts Chem Res 2000, 33, 889--‐897. 115. Gohlke, H.; Case, D. A., Converging free energy estimates: MM--‐PB(GB)SA studies on the protein--‐protein complex Ras--‐Raf. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2004, 25, 238--‐ 250. 116. Yang, T. Y.; Wu, J. C.; Yan, C. L.; Wang, Y. F.; Luo, R.; Gonzales, M. B.; Dalby, K. N.; Ren, P. Y., Virtual screening using molecular simulations. Proteins--‐Structure Function and Bioinformatics 2011, 79, 1940--‐1951. 117. Miller, B. R.; McGee, T. D.; Swails, J. M.; Homeyer, N.; Gohlke, H.; Roitberg, A. E., MMPBSA.py: An Efficient Program for End--‐State Free Energy Calculations. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2012, 8, 3314--‐3321. 118. Wang, C.; Nguyen, P. H.; Pham, K.; Huynh, D.; Le, T.--‐B. N.; Wang, H.; Ren, P.; Luo, R., Calculating protein–ligand binding affinities with MMPBSA: Method and error analysis. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2016, n/a--‐n/a. 119. Li, C.; Li, L.; Zhang, J.; Alexov, E., Highly efficient and exact method for parallelization of grid‐based algorithms and its implementation in DelPhi. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2012, 33, 1960--‐1966. 37 120. Jogini, V.; Roux, B., Electrostatics of the intracellular vestibule of K+ channels. J. Mol. Biol. 2005, 354, 272--‐288. 121. Botello--‐Smith, W. M.; Liu, X.; Cai, Q.; Li, Z.; Zhao, H.; Luo, R., Numerical Poisson--‐ Boltzmann Model for Continuum Membrane Systems. Chemical Physics Letters 2012. 122. Botello--‐Smith, W. M.; Luo, R., Applications of MMPBSA to Membrane Proteins I: Efficient Numerical Solutions of Periodic Poisson--‐Boltzmann Equation. J Chem Inf Model 2015, 55, 2187--‐2199. 123. Homeyer, N.; Gohlke, H., Extension of the free energy workflow FEW towards implicit solvent/implicit membrane MM--‐PBSA calculations. Bba--‐Gen Subjects 2015, 1850, 972--‐982. 124. Greene, D.; Botello--‐Smith, W. M.; Follmer, A.; Xiao, L.; Lambros, E.; Luo, R., Modeling Membrane Protein–Ligand Binding Interactions: The Human Purinergic Platelet Receptor. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2016, 120, 12293--‐12304. 125. Callenberg, K. M., Choudhary, O. P., de Forest, G. L., Gohara, D. W., Baker, N. A., and Grabe, M. , APBSmem: A Graphical Interface for Electrostatic Calculations at the Membrane. PLoS One 2010, 5, 1--‐11. 126. Richards, F. M., Areas, Volumes, Packing, and Protein--‐Structure. Annual Review of Biophysics and Bioengineering 1977, 6, 151--‐176. 127. Connolly, M. L., ANALYTICAL MOLECULAR--‐SURFACE CALCULATION. Journal of Applied Crystallography 1983, 16, 548--‐558. 128. Connolly, M. L., SOLVENT--‐ACCESSIBLE SURFACES OF PROTEINS AND NUCLEIC--‐ ACIDS. Science 1983, 221, 709--‐713. 129. Gilson, M. K.; Sharp, K. A.; Honig, B. H., Calculating the Electrostatic Potential of Molecules in Solution --‐ Method and Error Assessment. Journal of Computational Chemistry 1988, 9, 327--‐335. 130. Rocchia, W.; Sridharan, S.; Nicholls, A.; Alexov, E.; Chiabrera, A.; Honig, B., Rapid grid--‐ based construction of the molecular surface and the use of induced surface charge to calculate reaction field energies: Applications to the molecular systems and geometric objects. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2002, 23, 128--‐137. 131. Swanson, J. M. J.; Mongan, J.; McCammon, J. A., Limitations of atom--‐centered dielectric functions in implicit solvent models. J Phys Chem B 2005, 109, 14769--‐14772. 132. Tan, C. H.; Yang, L. J.; Luo, R., How well does Poisson--‐Boltzmann implicit solvent agree with explicit solvent? A quantitative analysis. J Phys Chem B 2006, 110, 18680--‐18687. 133. Wang, J.; Tan, C.; Chanco, E.; Luo, R., Quantitative analysis of Poisson--‐Boltzmann implicit solvent in molecular dynamics simulations. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2010, 12, In press. 134. Case, D. A.; Betz, R. M.; Botello--‐Smith, W.; Cerutti, D. S.; T.E. Cheatham, I.; Darden, T. A.; Duke, R. E.; Giese, T. J.; Gohlke, H.; Goetz, A. W.; Homeyer, N.; Izadi, S.; Janowski, P.; Kaus, J.; Kovalenko, A.; Lee, T. S.; LeGrand, S.; Li, P.; Lin, C.; Luchko, T.; Luo, R.; Madej, B.; Mermelstein, D.; Merz, K. M.; Monard, G.; Nguyen, H.; Nguyen, H. T.; Omelyan, I.; Onufriev, A.; Roe, D. R.; Roitberg, A.; Sagui, C.; Simmerling, C. L.; Swails, J.; Walker, R. C.; Wang, J.; Wolf, R. M.; Wu, X.; Xiao, L.; York, D. M.; Kollman, P. A. Amber 16; University of California, San Francisco: 2016. 135. Case, D. A.; Betz, R. M.; Botello--‐Smith, W.; Cerutti, D. S.; T.E. Cheatham, I.; Darden, T. A.; Duke, R. E.; Giese, T. J.; Gohlke, H.; Goetz, A. W.; Homeyer, N.; Izadi, S.; Janowski, P.; Kaus, J.; Kovalenko, A.; Lee, T. S.; LeGrand, S.; Li, P.; Lin, C.; Luchko, T.; Luo, R.; Madej, B.; 38 Mermelstein, D.; Merz, K. M.; Monard, G.; Nguyen, H.; Nguyen, H. T.; Omelyan, I.; Onufriev, A.; Roe, D. R.; Roitberg, A.; Sagui, C.; Simmerling, C. L.; Swails, J.; Walker, R. C.; Wang, J.; Wolf, R. M.; Wu, X.; Xiao, L.; York, D. M.; Kollman, P. A. AmberTools 16; University of California, San Francisco: 2016. 136. Zhou, Y. F.; Morais--‐Cabral, J. H.; Kaufman, A.; MacKinnon, R., Chemistry of ion coordination and hydration revealed by a K+ channel--‐Fab complex at 2.0 angstrom resolution. Nature 2001, 414, 43--‐48. 137. Huang, X.; Chen, H.; Michelsen, K.; Schneider, S.; Shaffer, P. L., Crystal structure of human glycine receptor--‐alpha 3 bound to antagonist strychnine. Nature 2015, 526, 277--‐+. 138. Laurent, B.; Murail, S.; Shahsavar, A.; Sauguet, L.; Delarue, M.; Baaden, M., Sites of Anesthetic Inhibitory Action on a Cationic Ligand--‐Gated Ion Channel. Structure 2016, 24, 595--‐605. 139. Cavalli, A.; Poluzzi, E.; De Ponti, F.; Recanatini, M., Toward a pharmacophore for drugs inducing the long QT syndrome: Insights from a CoMFA study of HERG K+ channel blockers. Journal of Medicinal Chemistry 2002, 45, 3844--‐3853. 140. Webb, B.; Sali, A. Comparative Protein Structure Modeling Using MODELLER. In Current Protocols in Bioinformatics; John Wiley & Sons, Inc.: 2002. 141. O'Donovan, C.; Martin, M. J.; Gattiker, A.; Gasteiger, E.; Bairoch, A.; Apweiler, R., High--‐ quality protein knowledge resource: SWISS--‐PROT and TrEMBL. Briefings in bioinformatics 2002, 3, 275--‐84. 142. Larkin, M. A.; Blackshields, G.; Brown, N. P.; Chenna, R.; McGettigan, P. A.; McWilliam, H.; Valentin, F.; Wallace, I. M.; Wilm, A.; Lopez, R.; Thompson, J. D.; Gibson, T. J.; Higgins, D. G., Clustal W and Clustal X version 2.0. Bioinformatics (Oxford, England) 2007, 23, 2947--‐8. 143. Österberg, F.; Åqvist, J., Exploring blocker binding to a homology model of the open hERG K+ channel using docking and molecular dynamics methods. FEBS letters 2005, 579, 2939--‐2944. 144. Du, L.; Li, M.; You, Q.; Xia, L., A novel structure--‐based virtual screening model for the hERG channel blockers. Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 2007, 355, 889--‐894. 145. Stansfeld, P. J.; Gedeck, P.; Gosling, M.; Cox, B.; Mitcheson, J. S.; Sutcliffe, M. J., Drug block of the hERG potassium channel: Insight from modeling. Proteins: Structure, Function, and Bioinformatics 2007, 68, 568--‐580. 146. Masetti, M.; Cavalli, A.; Recanatini, M., Modeling the hERG potassium channel in a phospholipid bilayer: Molecular dynamics and drug docking studies. J Comput Chem 2008, 29, 795--‐808. 147. Jo, S.; Kim, T.; Im, W., Automated builder and database of protein/membrane complexes for molecular dynamics simulations. PLoS One 2007, 2, e880. Jo, S.; Kim, T.; Iyer, V. G.; Im, W., CHARMM--‐GUI: a web--‐based graphical user interface 148. for CHARMM. J Comput Chem 2008, 29, 1859--‐65. 149. Jo, S.; Lim, J. B.; Klauda, J. B.; Im, W., CHARMM--‐GUI Membrane Builder for mixed bilayers and its application to yeast membranes. Biophys J 2009, 97, 50--‐8. 150. Wu, E. L.; Cheng, X.; Jo, S.; Rui, H.; Song, K. C.; Davila--‐Contreras, E. M.; Qi, Y.; Lee, J.; Monje--‐Galvan, V.; Venable, R. M.; Klauda, J. B.; Im, W., CHARMM--‐GUI Membrane Builder toward realistic biological membrane simulations. J Comput Chem 2014, 35, 1997--‐2004. 39 151. Lee, J.; Cheng, X.; Swails, J. M.; Yeom, M. S.; Eastman, P. K.; Lemkul, J. A.; Wei, S.; Buckner, J.; Jeong, J. C.; Qi, Y.; Jo, S.; Pande, V. S.; Case, D. A.; Brooks, C. L., 3rd; MacKerell, A. D., Jr.; Klauda, J. B.; Im, W., CHARMM--‐GUI Input Generator for NAMD, GROMACS, AMBER, OpenMM, and CHARMM/OpenMM Simulations Using the CHARMM36 Additive Force Field. J Chem Theory Comput 2016, 12, 405--‐13. 152. Case, D. A.; Cheatham, T. E.; Darden, T.; Gohlke, H.; Luo, R.; Merz, K. M.; Onufriev, A.; Simmerling, C.; Wang, B.; Woods, R. J., The Amber biomolecular simulation programs. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2005, 26, 1668--‐1688. 153. Roe, D. R.; Cheatham, T. E., PTRAJ and CPPTRAJ: Software for Processing and Analysis of Molecular Dynamics Trajectory Data. J Chem Theory Comput 2013, 9, 3084--‐95. 154. Tan, C.; Tan, Y.--‐H.; Luo, R., Implicit nonpolar solvent models. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2007, 111, 12263--‐12274. 40
1112.2731	1	1112	2011-12-12T22:01:22	Reactive Molecular Dynamics study on the first steps of DNA-damage by free hydroxyl radicals	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.chem-ph", "physics.comp-ph" ]	We employ a large scale molecular simulation based on bond-order ReaxFF to simulate the chemical reaction and study the damage to a large fragment of DNA-molecule in the solution by ionizing radiation. We illustrate that the randomly distributed clusters of diatomic OH-radicals that are primary products of megavoltage ionizing radiation in water-based systems are the main source of hydrogen-abstraction as well as formation of carbonyl- and hydroxyl-groups in the sugar-moiety that create holes in the sugar-rings. These holes grow up slowly between DNA-bases and DNA-backbone and the damage collectively propagate to DNA single and double strand break.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Reactive Molecular Dynamics study on the first steps of DNA-damage by free hydroxyl radicals Ramin M. Abolfath1,2, A. C. T. van Duin3, Thomas Brabec2 1School of Natural Sciences and Mathematics and Department of Materials Science, University of Texas at Dallas, Richardson, TX 75080 2Physics Department, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON, K1N 6N5, Canada 3Department of Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering, Pennsylvania State University, PA 16802 (Dated: September 16, 2018) 1 1 0 2 c e D 2 1 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 1 3 7 2 . 2 1 1 1 : v i X r a We employ a large scale molecular simulation based on bond-order ReaxFF to simulate the chem- ical reaction and study the damage to a large fragment of DNA-molecule in the solution by ionizing radiation. We illustrate that the randomly distributed clusters of diatomic OH-radicals that are primary products of megavoltage ionizing radiation in water-based systems are the main source of hydrogen-abstraction as well as formation of carbonyl- and hydroxyl-groups in the sugar-moiety that create holes in the sugar-rings. These holes grow up slowly between DNA-bases and DNA-backbone and the damage collectively propagate to DNA single and double strand break. PACS numbers: 87.56.-v,87.55.-x,87.64.Aa It is known that megavoltage radiation (X/γ-rays, α- particles, and heavy ions) ionizes the water molecule and creates neutral free-radicals and aqueous electrons1 -- 9. In particular OH-radicals with a very short life-time that is reported to be within nano-seconds10, are major contrib- utors to the single/double strand breaking of the DNA molecules and the nucleotide-base damage, as 2/3 of envi- ronment surrounding DNA molecules in the cell-nucleus is composed of water molecules4. Various effects of the ionizing radiation on biological systems that ranges from the development of genetic aberrations, carcinogenesis to aging, have attributed to the role of free radicals. Computational modeling is a valuable tool in under- standing the basic mechanisms that underlie DNA dam- age. Great effort has been devoted to the statistical mod- eling of the damage sites based on Monte-Carlo (MC) sampling, using empirical reaction rates and radiation scattering cross-sections4 -- 9. These models are limited to MC sampling on a static structure of DNA or dynamical models based on molecular-mechanics (MM) and empir- ical force-fields (FF), e.g. AMBER/CHARMM FF, that are developed for simulation of the non-reactive aspects of bio-molecules. The reactive aspects and the time evolution of the multi-site DNA damages driven by cascade of chemical reactions, that are beyond MM methods and empirical FF, require the calculation of the potential energies on- the-fly using first-principle quantum mechanical (QM) models. Recently ab-initio simulations of the hydrogen abstraction were developed11 -- 15. However realistic mod- eling of DNA molecule with its environment requires ex- tensive computer resources and is a major draw-back of QM methods. The DFT calculation for hydrogen ab- straction in vacuum is limited to the initial damage of a single base11 -- 13 or single sugar-moiety15. Despite recent advances in QM/MM methods that allows simulation of larger molecules14 and inclusion of solvation15, the real time simulation of DNA-damage remains still elusive. To address the above considerations regarding to the large scale modeling of DNA-damage, we have studied the evolution of randomly distributed hydroxyl-radicals in small pockets surrounding the DNA-molecule at room temperature using molecular dynamics simulations where the atomic interactions are described by the reactive force field potential, ReaxFF17. ReaxFF is a general bond- order dependent potential that provides accurate descrip- tions of bond breaking and bond formation. Recent sim- ulations on a number of hydrocarbon-oxygen systems17 and graphene-oxides18 showed that ReaxFF reliably pro- vides energies, transition states, reaction pathways and reactivity trends in agreement with QM calculations and experiments. To enable a reactive simulation of solvated DNA we combined the recently developed ReaxFF reactive force field parameters for peptide/water systems19 with the ReaxFF description for organophosphates, as used pre- viously by Zhu et al. 20 to investigate the active site of RNA polymerase and by Quenneville et al.21 to study dimethyl methylphosphonate (DMMP) reactions in sil- ica. ReaxFF is a bond-order dependent empirical force field method, which includes a polarizable charge func- tion, enabling application to a wide range of materials and accurate reproduction of reaction energies and barri- ers17,22 -- 24. The ReaxFF peptide/phosphate descriptions is fully transferable with the aqueous-phase ReaxFF de- scriptions used by Raymand et al.25 to study water dis- sociation reactions on zinc oxide surfaces and by Fogarty et al.26 to study water reactions on silica surfaces, and as such was tested against DFT-data describing proton transfer reactions to solvated hydroxyl species. To validate ReaxFF for hydroxyl ion/water interaction and in order to describe the chemistry and physics of OH- in the aqueous environment we compared the ReaxFF parameters with a set of DFT-data. The DFT-data was obtained at the X3LYP/6-311G** level30,31 and describes two cases (1) binding energies of HO[H2O]n-clusters, with n = 1 and (2) proton migration between HO-/H2O at HO -- OH2 distances ranging from 2.4 to 3.4 A. While ReaxFF overpredicts the OH-[H2O]n-binding energies for n=1 and n=2, it gives an accurate description for the n = 3 and n = 4 cases, which are the most relevant for normal-density aqueous phases. ReaxFF displays ex- cellent agreement for the proton migration barriers for O -- O distances of 2.3, 2.48 (global minimum) and 2.8 A, which are the most relevant cases for normal-density aqueous phases, but overpredicts the barriers for large O -- O distances. We will provide a more elaborate de- scription of the ReaxFF water/H3O+/OH− development in a subsequent publication. The equilibration of the system of DNA-water was performed in solvated 1276- atom DNA-strand with 2500 water molecules at T=300K for 30 ps. We found that during this time-frame the DNA retained its overall helical configuration, indicating that ReaxFF retains the overall structural integrity of the DNA over such time-frames and that reactive events observed during exposure to OH radicals can indeed be associated with the radical reactivity. We examined the stability of DNA surrounded by water-molecules against ReaxFF by equilibrating a solvated 1276-atom DNA-strand (with 2500 water molecules) at room temperature for 30 ps. We found that during this time-frame the DNA retained its overall helical configuration, indicating that ReaxFF retains the overall structural integrity of the DNA over such time- frames and that reactive events observed during exposure to OH radicals can indeed be associated with the radical reactivity. In this work we demonstrate that ReaxFF gives valu- able insight on the details of the microscopic events observed in agreement with the ab-initio CPMD and QMMM CPMD-GROMACS calculation including: (1) the DNA-backbone hydrogen abstraction and forma- tion of water molecules (2) nucleotide-sugar-moiety bond breaking and formation of carbonyl- and hydroxyl-groups in sugar-moiety-rings (3) nucleotide-nucleotide hydrogen bond disruption, (4) nucleotide structural damage, (5) ef- ficiency of the radiation generated OH radicals in making direct hydrogen-abstraction and (6) deactivation mecha- nisms of OH-radicals within a cluster of radicals due to formation of ozone-molecules and network of hydrogen bonds. Most significantly we illustrate that the collective dam- age that breaks the bonds between nucleotide-bases and DNA-backbone can be attributed to the formation of the carbonyl- and hydroxyl-groups in the sugar-moiety rings. The holes created by OH-radicals between the nucleotide- bases and DNA-backbone grow up and evolve to large holes that contain number of bases and a large segment of DNA-backbone. It further propagates to the structural base-damage, DNA single- and double-strand break. 2 FIG. 1: (a) Initial structure of DNA surrounded by randomly generated small pockets of OH-radicals shown in the circles. (b) DNA structure after t = 0.24 ps. A large scale double strand damage is clearly visible. Water molecules that are the product of hydrogen-abstraction and two OH-OH bounded by hydrogen bonds are shown in the circles. Carbon, oxygen, nitrogen, phosphorus and hydrogen atoms are shown as green, red, blue, gold and white, respectively. FIG. 2: (a) Small cluster of OH radicals close to DNA- backbone is shown in circles. (b) One OH interacts with DNA- backbone and the others combine in form of ozone molecule H2O2. (c) Hydrogen abstraction from backbone is complete and H2O molecule forms. Carbon, oxygen, nitrogen, phos- phorus and hydrogen atoms are shown as green, red, blue, gold and white, respectively. Our model for the initial distribution of OH-radicals surrounding DNA molecule is based on well established description of water and ionizing-radiation interaction in which a mega-voltage beam interacts with water molecules through Compton effect and electron-positron pair production and produce spurs and blobs identified as small pockets of ion-pairs with typical diameter of 4-7 (a) (b) (a) (b) (c) 3 FIG. 3: A DFT calculation used for the confirmation of the chemical pathways obtained by ReaxFF. Initial configura- tion of OH-radical with deoxyribose sugar-moiety attached to amino group (representing the nucleotide-base) shown in (a) leads to formation of water molecule (b), hydrogen molecule (c), hydroxyl group (d), and carbonyl group (e) as a func- tion of initial location of the OH-radical with respect to sugar-moiety ring. The bond strain created by hydroxyl and carbonyl groups lead to the creation of the hole in the deoxyribose-ring. Carbon, oxygen, nitrogen and hydrogen atoms are shown as green, red, blue and white, respectively. nm that fit approximately 3-12 ion pairs1. The information on the type of chemical reactions and the time-evolution of the damage is collected via run- ning the MD up to 30 ps where the rearrangement of the atomic coordinates have been deduced from a dynamical trajectory calculated by ReaxFF. These simulations per- formed using periodic boundary conditions in a canonical moles, pressure and temperature (NPT) ensemble with a Nose-Hoover thermostat for temperature control and a time step of 0.25 fs. Fig. 1(a) shows the initial structure of the DNA- molecule used in our simulation. The computational box comprise of DNA taken from the protein data base33, water molecules and randomly generated OH-radicals in small clusters around the DNA molecule. The DNA molecule and solvated system was first energy minimized so as to eliminate any bad contact with water molecules arising from solvation. Small clusters of OH-radicals close to the DNA-backbone are shown within the circles. Fig. 1(b) shows an early stage of the molecular-structure at t = 0.24 ps, where the initial hydrogen-abstraction from DNA-backbone takes place. As it is seen, one OH- radical diffuses the distance (cid:96) ≈ 6A and removes H5(cid:48) from the sugar-moiety, consistent with the experimental data2,3 and CPMD calculation13. Another interesting feature revealed in this simulation consists of the cor- related states formed by OH-radicals that lead to their passivation. For example in Fig. 1(b) we observe that the two OH-radicals that do not participate in hydrogen- FIG. 4: (a) Initial configuration of an adenine in a double strand DNA in the presence of OH-radicals (not shown in the figure) and (b) the configuration of the distorted adenine with a hole (formed by C-C broken bond) at 500fs. The numbers represent the bond-length. The large separation of adenine from the backbone and the stretched backbone that are indi- cation of the base-damage and single-strand break are clearly visible. For comparison an undamaged cytosine is shown be- low the adenine. (c) The damaged cytosine, located one base above the adenine shown in (a) at t = 3500 fs, illustrating a collective damage to the base, deoxyribose-ring and DNA strand. The opened gap in the deoxyribose pentagon-ring corresponding to C4(cid:48) -O4(cid:48) missing bond is visible. It indicates formation of stable carbonyl group. Carbon, oxygen, nitro- gen, phosphorus and hydrogen atoms are shown as green, red, blue, gold and white, respectively. abstraction form hydrogen-bonds with smaller thermal diffusion length than an isolated OH-radical. In a cluster of OH-radicals, we find that not all of the OH-radicals thermally diffuse and interact with DNA. Fig. 2 reveals more details on H2O2 formation and their lower reac- tivity with DNA-molecule. Consistent with our recent QM/MM calculation in the solution15, we observe that because of the hydrogen bond network forming between OH-radicals and water molecules the time for hydrogen abstraction is longer compare to similar simulation in vacuum. From ReaxFF-MD we realized that the initial damage that evolves to the separation of the nucleotide-base from DNA-backbone and DNA single strand break can be at- tributed to the formation of the hydroxyl- and carbonyl- groups in the sugar-rings in the backbone. The oxygen from OH radical weaken the C-N bond that attaches the sugar-moiety with the nucleotide-base. To investi- gate such possibility and the consistency of ReaxFF with DFT, we employed an ab-initio CPMD calculation in vacuum as well as a QMMM CPMD-GROMACS that allows adding realistic solution15. The results are shown in Fig. 3. The molecular structure consists of deoxyri- bose sugar-moiety attached to amino group in the pres- (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (a) (b) (c) 4 Time-evolution of C4(cid:48) -O4(cid:48) bond distance, corre- FIG. 5: sponding to the opened gap in the pentagon-ring of deoxyri- bose shown in Fig. 4(c). As a result of series of chemical reactions due to OH-radicals, the C4(cid:48) -O4(cid:48) bond undergoes strong fluctuations close to t ≈ 500 fs. It takes another 500 fs that C4(cid:48) -O4(cid:48) bond breaks and the carbonyl-group forms. The establishment of carbonyl-group and its dynamical stability beyond t ≈ 1000 fs is clearly visible. The C4(cid:48) -O4(cid:48) distance in open-ring fluctuates around dCO ≈ 1.8A due to thermal vi- brations. For comparison, the time-evolution of C4(cid:48) -O4(cid:48) bond distance corresponding to a deoxyribose far from OH-radicals is shown (dashed lines). It shows an undamaged bond length of dCO ≈ 1.4A, predicted by ReaxFF. ence of OH-radical. Fig. 3 (d) and (e) show the result of CPMD in vacuum on hydroxyl- and carbonyl-formation and breaking of the bond in the sugar-ring that connects the amino-group to the backbone. Our CPMD consists of four stages of wave function optimization, dynamical equilibration at T=300 K with ionic temperature control that allows step-wise increase of temperature, requenching of the wave function, and fi- nally the microcanonical dynamics (constant energy en- semble) as described in Ref.13. We have performed a constant pressure and temperature MD simulation with a reference temperature of 300K and a time step of 1fs. Our CPMD wave-function optimization is implemented in a plane-wave basis within local spin density approx- imation (LSDA) with an energy cutoff of 75 Rydberg (Ry), and with Becke27 exchange and Lee-Yang-Parr (BLYP) gradient-corrected functional28. Norm conserv- ing ultrasoft Vanderbilt pseudo-potentials were used for oxygen, hydrogen, nitrogen and carbon. A cubic cell of size (13A × 13A × 13A) is used together with Poisson solver of Martyna and Tuckerman29 for the wave function minimization in CPMD. For the QMMM calculation, the sugar-moiety, guanine (as a representative of a nucleotide base) and OH-radicals are in the QM part and the rest of DNA fragment including phosphorous and its two oxygen (O1P and O2P) and water molecules are in MM part. The CPMD structural energy minimization and GROMACS FIG. 6: (a) Schematic diagram of the chemical pathway lead- ing to single strand break observed in ReaxFF MD. DOXi and DOXi+1 denote two neighboring deoxyribose pairs labeled by the indices ith and i + 1th. Donation of oxygen from one OH- radical lead to formation of free PO3 and two disconnected DOX's. (b) P-O5(cid:48) DOXi and P-O5(cid:48) DOXi+1 bond distances as a function of time shown by circles, selected from a site of damage in which a cluster of OH-radicals are chemically ac- tive. Simultaneous increase in bond distances is a signature of the single strand break. For comparison the red dashed line shows typical P-O5(cid:48) bond distance for a part of DNA back-bone that is far from OH-radicals. force-field are implemented for QM and MM parts. The details of this calculation will be presented elsewhere15. Fig. 4 focuses on a fragment of the DNA that the base- sugar-moiety bond-breaking by OH-radicals is seen in ReaxFF. The initial configuration of the base (an ade- nine) is shown in Fig. 4(a). There are two OH-radicals close to the sugar-moiety (not shown in the figure). Two intermediate configurations are shown in Fig. 4(b) and (c) corresponding to t = 500 fs and t = 3500 fs respec- tively. Fig. 4(b) shows the damaged adenine and an un- damaged cytosine that is one base below the adenine (far from OH-radicals). In Fig. 4(c) we show the damaged adenine with another cytosine (one base above the ade- nine). Both adenine and cytosine were initially close to free radicals. A substantial damage in adenine-groups into a ring and chain is clearly observed. While some of this dis- tortion may be related to secondary reactions related to 0200040006000800010000time (fs)11.21.41.61.82dCO (A)damaged siteundamaged sitePO5' -- DOXi+1 -- baseOOO5' -- DOXi -- baseHO-radicalOH-radicalH -- O5' -- DOXi+1 -- base -- OH -- O5' -- DOXi -- baseP -- OOO(a)0200040006000800010000time (fs)246810dPO(A)damaged site: PO5'-DOXidamaged site: PO5'-DOXi+1undamaged site(b)5 ab-initio CPMD and QMMM. We now turn to DNA back-bone damage and obser- vation of the single strand break (SSB) in ReaxFF MD. We define dPO as the relative distance between P and two neighboring deoxyribose-rings denoted by DOXi and DOXi+1 as shown in Fig. 6(a). This figure summarizes a pathway that leads to SSB observed in ReaxFF MD. Two OH-radicals participate in the chemical reaction. One OH donates an oxygen to phosphorous in the back-bone that results to formation of PO3 and strong fluctuation in the links between P and two neighboring DOX that finally lead to disjointing two DOX's from back-bone as shown in Fig. 6(b). Here solid lines marked by circles show the time evolution of P-DOXi and P-DOXi+1 bond- distances close to one of the clusters of OH-radicals. Note that in our simulation SSB has been observed only in lo- cations where OH-radicals actively participate in chem- ical reactions. Clearly simultaneous stretch in P-DOXi and P-DOXi+1 bonds is indication of concerted events that lead to SSB. For comparison a typical time evolu- tion of dPO is shown (the dashed-line) selected from an undamaged site of DNA located far from OH-radicals. As it is seen, ReaxFF predicts an average bond-length of dPO ≈ 2A. Note that the cut-off, set for bond visu- alization, chosen for carbon bonds with d = 1.5A. The phosphate fragments seen in the figures are the artifact of VMD visualization. The remaining H from the frag- mented OH-radical either forms a water molecule by com- bining with the other OH-radical [not shown in Fig. 6(a)] or passivate the dangling bond of O5(cid:48)-DOXi and forming a hydroxyl group. In the latter, the other OH disinte- grates to H and O where H passivates the dangling bond of O5(cid:48)-DOXi+1 and O oxidizes the base [see Fig. 6 (a)]. Fig. 7 reveals similar features in a larger scale. Here the initial and final configurations corresponding to t = 2 ps are shown in Fig. 7(a) and (b). For comparison, a part of DNA that is far from concentration of OH-radicals is shown in Fig. 7(c). The damage and disconnectivity of the bases-backbone is clearly visible in Fig. 7(b), where the stability of the DNA in the absence of OH-radicals is obvious from Fig. 7(c). The horizental/vertical blue dash-lines show the base pair/stacking hydrogen bonds. As shown in Fig. 7(b) the network of hydrogen bonds is disrupted because of the damaged sites. In contrast, in undamaged fragment, as shown in Fig. 7(c), the network of hydrogen bonds are preserved by MD. In conclusion, we have examined the MD simulation based on ReaxFF on a large fragment of DNA molecule to simulate the hydrogen abstraction by OH-radicals. The simulation reveals various type of dehydrogenation from DNA back-bone and DNA-base that evolve into the dis- connectivity of the bases from the backbone due to car- bonyl and hydroxyl formation in sugar-moiety by OH- radicals. We further confirmed the results obtained by ReaxFF-MD using an ab-initio CPMD calculation. Close examination of damage with various length scales show that the damage collectively disrupt the base-pair hy- drogen bonds and lead to base-backbone bond breaking, FIG. 7: (a) Initial configuration of a DNA-fragment in the presence of OH-radicals (not shown in the figure) and (b) the configuration of that part at t =2000 fs with a pronounced separated between bases and backbone. (c) For comparison another part of the DNA that has no exposure with OH- radicals is shown at t =2000 fs. Carbon, oxygen, nitrogen, phosphorus and hydrogen atoms are shown as green, red, blue, gold and white, respectively. The blue dash lines show the inter-base and base-stacking hydrogen bounds. the OH-damage, it is possible that the current ReaxFF description overestimates the distortion rate. We aim to replicate the distortion pathway at the DFT-level to confirm the results obtained by ReaxFF and if neces- sary will improve this aspect of the ReaxFF description to make it consistent with DFT. We note that based on our experimental results, such a substantial distortion is qualitatively consistent with the absorption spectrum of unirradiated and that receiving ionizing radiation where the effect of irradiation can be visible in the blurring of the absorbance peaks. Our quantitative comparison between computational modeling and experimental data obtained from photo-emission is on the way16. Finally the observed damage in cytosine is mainly associated with a dislocated hydrogen. As it is shown in the fig- ure, both bases are moved away from sugar-moiety with a distance that is approximately around 5 A, hence they are completely disconnected from the backbone. In Fig. 4(c) we observe an opened gap in deoxyribose- ring due to C4(cid:48)-O4(cid:48) broken bond. The corresponding time evolution of the bond-distance is shown in Fig. 5. The bond undergoes a severe fluctuation in t ≈ 500 − 1000 fs due to occurrence of series of chemical reactions by two OH-radicals initially located at opposite sides of deoxyribose-ring including (a) hydrogen abstraction of H3(cid:48) by OH radical incorporated by formation of water molecule and (b) formation of hydroxyl group with C4(cid:48). Finally beyond t ≈ 1000 fs the open-gap with dCO ≈ 1.8A is established. These collection of events including base- damage incorporated with formation of a hydroxyl- and carbonyl-group is consistent with the picture deduced by (a) (b) (c) single-strand break and finally double strand break. The present work that is in complement with previous calcu- lation on smaller system in vacuum and solution using DFT and QM/MM can be used as a computational plat- form for energy scoring and the effects of radiation on biological systems. Authors would like to thank Dr. Kyeongjae Cho and Dr. Yves Chabal for useful comments and discussion. 6 1 Hall, E. J. Radiobiology for the Radiologist, (Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Fifth Edition, 2000); Becker, D.; Adhikary, A.; and Sevilla, M.; in Charge Mi- gration in DNA, Ed. Chakraborty, T.; (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 2007). 2 Pogozelski, W. K.; Tullius, T. D.; Chem. Rev. 1998, 98, 1089. 3 Tullius, T. D. ; Greenbaum, J. A.; Curr. Opin. Chem. Biol. 2005, 9, 127. 4 Aydogan, B. ; Bolch, W. E.; Swarts, S. G.; Turner, J. E.; and Marshall, D. T.; Radiat. Res. 2008, 169 223. 5 Friedland, W.; Jacob, P.; Paretzke, H. G.; Merzagora, M.; and Ottolenghi, A.; Radiat. Environ. Biophys. 1999, 38, 39. 6 Terrisol, M.; and Beaudre, A.; Radiat. Prot. Dosimetry 1990, 31, 171. 17 van Duin, A. C. T.; Dasgupta, S.; Lorant, F.; Goddard, W. A. Journal of Physical Chemistry A 2001, 105, 9396. 18 Bagri, A.; Mattevi, C.; Acik, M.; Chabal, Y. J.; Chhowalla, M.; and Shenoy, V. B.; Nature Chem. 2010, 2, 581; Bagri, A.; Grantab, R.; Medhekar, N. V.; and Shenoy, V. B.; J. Phys. Chem. C 2010, 114, 12053. 19 Rahaman, O.; van Duin, A. C. T.; Goddard, W. A., III; Doren, D. J. Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2011, ASAP. 20 Zhu, R.; Janetzko, F.; Zhang, Y.; van Duin, A. C. T.; Goddard, W. A.; Salahub, D. R. Theoretical Chemistry Accounts 2008, 120, 479. 21 Quenneville, J.; Taylor, R. S.; van Duin, A. C. T. Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2010, 114, 18894. 22 LaBrosse, M. R.; Johnson, J. K.; van Duin, A. C. T. J. Phys. Chem. A 2010, 114, 5855. 23 Chenoweth, K.; van Duin, A. C. T.; Goddard, W. A. Jour- 7 Wilson, W. E.; and Paretzke, H. G.; Radiat. Prot. Dosime- nal of Physical Chemistry A 2008, 112, 1040. try 1994, 52, 249. 8 Nikjoo, H.; and Charlton, D. E.; Calculation of range and distributions of damage to DNA by high- and low- LET radiations. In Radiation Damage to DNA: Struc- ture/Function Relationships at Early Times (A. F. Fucia- relli and J. D. Zimbrick, Eds.). Battelle Press, Columbus, OH, 1995; Nikjoo, H.; O'Neill, P.; Terrissol, M.; and Good- head, D.T.; Int. J. Radiat. Biol. 1994; 66, 453. 9 Semenenko, V. A.; and Stewart, R. D.; Radiat. Res. 2005, 164, 180; ibid. 2005, 164, 194. 10 Sies, H.; Europ. J. Biochem. 1993, 215, 213. 11 Mundy, C. J.; Colvin, M. E.; Quong, A. A.; J. Phys. Chem. A. 2002, 106 10063; Wu, Y.; Mundy, C. J.; Colvin, M. E.; Car, R.; J. Phys. Chem. A. 2004, 108 2922. 12 Close, D. M.; and Ohman, K. T.; J. Phys. Chem. A 2008, 112, 11207. 13 Abolfath, R. M.; J. Phys. Chem. B, 2009, 113, 6938; Abol- fath, R. M.; and Brabec, T.; J. Compt. Chem. 2010, 31, 2601. 14 Gervasio, F. L.; Laio, A.; Iannuzzi, M.; and Parrinello, M.; Chem. Eur. J. 2004, 10, 4846. 15 Abolfath, R. M.; Biswas, P. K.; Rajnarayanam, R.; Brabec, T.; Kodym, R.; Papiez, L.; under prepration. 16 Abolfath, R. M.; Kodym, R.; unpublished. 24 Cheung, S.; Deng, W. Q.; van Duin, A. C. T.; Goddard, W. A. Journal of Physical Chemistry A 2005, 109, 851. 25 Raymand, D.; van Duin, A. C. T.; Spangberg, D.; God- dard, W. A.; Hermansson, K. Surf. Sci. 2010, 604, 741. 26 Fogarty, J. C.; Aktulga, H. M.; Grama, A. Y.; van Duin, A. C. T.; Pandit, S. A. J. Chem. Phys. 2010, 132, 174704/1. 27 A. D. Becke, Phys. Rev. A 38, 3098 (1988). 28 C. Lee, W. Yang, and R. G. Parr, Phys. Rev. B 37, 785 (1988). 29 G. J. Martyna, M. E. Tuckerman, J. Chem. Phys. 110, 2810 (1999). 30 Bryantsev, V. S.; Diallo, M. S.; van Duin, A. C. T.; God- dard, W. A. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2009, 5, 1016. 31 Xu, X.; Goddard, W. A. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci USA 2004, 101, 2673. 32 Hutter, J.; Ballone, P.; Bernasconi, M.; Focher, P.; Fois, E.; Goedecker, S.; Parrinello, M.; Tuckerman, M. E.; CPMD code, version 3.13, MPI fuer Festkoerperforschung, Stuttgart IBM Zurich Research Laboratory, 1990-2008. 33 Zegar, I.S.; Setayesh, F.R.; DeCorte, B.L.; Harris, C.M.; Harris, T.M.; Stone, M.P.; Biochemistry 1996, 35 4334; http://www.pdb.org/pdb/
1809.10000	1	1809	2018-09-26T14:00:04	Order parameter allows classification of planar graphs based on balanced fixed points in the Kuramoto model	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.stat-mech", "nlin.AO" ]	Phase balanced states are a highly under-explored class of solutions of the Kuramoto model and other coupled oscillator models on networks. So far, coupled oscillator research focused on phase synchronized solutions. Yet, global constraints on oscillators may forbid synchronized state, rendering phase balanced states as the relevant stable state. If for example oscillators are driving the contractions of a fluid filled volume, conservation of fluid volume constraints oscillators to balanced states as characterized by a vanishing Kuramoto order parameter. It has previously been shown that stable, balanced patterns in the Kuramoto model exist on circulant graphs. However, which non-circulant graphs first of all allow for balanced states and what characterizes the balanced states is unknown. Here, we derive rules of how to build non-circulant, planar graphs allowing for balanced states from the simple cycle graph by adding loops or edges to it. We thereby identify different classes of small planar networks allowing for balanced states. Investigating the balanced states' characteristics, we find that the variance in basin stability scales linearly with the size of the graph for these networks. We introduce the balancing ratio as a new order parameter based on the basin stability approach to classify balanced states on networks and evaluate it analytically for a subset of the network classes. Our results offer an analytical description of non-circulant graphs supporting stable, balanced states and may thereby help to understand the topological requirements on oscillator networks under global constraints.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Order parameter allows classification of planar graphs based on balanced fixed points in the Kuramoto model Franz Kaiser and Karen Alim∗ Biological Physics and Morphogenesis Group, Max Planck Institute for Dynamics and Self-Organization, 37077 Gottingen, Germany and Institute for Nonlinear Dynamics, Faculty of Physics, University of Gottingen, 37077 Gottingen, Germany (Dated: September 27, 2018) Phase balanced states are a highly under-explored class of solutions of the Kuramoto model and other coupled oscillator models on networks. So far, coupled oscillator research focused on phase synchronized solutions. Yet, global constraints on oscillators may forbid synchronized state, ren- dering phase balanced states as the relevant stable state. If for example oscillators are driving the contractions of a fluid filled volume, conservation of fluid volume constraints oscillators to bal- anced states as characterized by a vanishing Kuramoto order parameter. It has previously been shown that stable, balanced patterns in the Kuramoto model exist on circulant graphs. However, which non-circulant graphs first of all allow for balanced states and what characterizes the balanced states is unknown. Here, we derive rules of how to build non-circulant, planar graphs allowing for balanced states from the simple cycle graph by adding loops or edges to it. We thereby identify different classes of small planar networks allowing for balanced states. Investigating the balanced states' characteristics, we find that the variance in basin stability scales linearly with the size of the graph for these networks. We introduce the balancing ratio as a new order parameter based on the basin stability approach to classify balanced states on networks and evaluate it analytically for a subset of the network classes. Our results offer an analytical description of non-circulant graphs supporting stable, balanced states and may thereby help to understand the topological requirements on oscillator networks under global constraints. I. INTRODUCTION Weakly interacting systems are ubiquitous in nature. They play a crucial role for oscillations and timing in bi- ological systems [1]. Examples include circadian clocks, cell metabolism, chemical oscillations or pacemaker cells. Various models have been developed to describe such in- teracting systems in terms of coupled oscillators [2, 3]. Here, the most well-studied model is the so-called Ku- ramoto model due to its tractability [4 -- 6] and due to the possibility to derive Kuramoto-like models on very general grounds [6 -- 8]. Research regarding the Kuramoto model has focused mainly on oscillator phase synchronization phenom- ena [3, 4, 9]. Synchronization phenomena can be ob- served in a broad variety of oscillator network topologies and are comparably easy to study. Yet, little research has addressed so-called balanced states, characterized by a vanishing Kuramoto order parameter. These states have mainly been of interest in the field of control theory [10 -- 13], where they represent desired states to coordinate autonomous vehicles. Yet, balanced states are of much broader concern as they describe coupled oscillators with global constraints that are preventing phase synchroniza- tion. For example, such a global constraint is given by conservation of fluid volume in a tubular network with periodically contracting tube walls. A living example are the contraction patters on the networks formed by ∗ [email protected] the slime mold Physarum polycephalum [14]. Fascinat- ingly, these living networks are dynamic in their topol- ogy, which poses the question of how network topology affects phase balanced states. The only class of network topologies so far known to support stable, balanced states in the Kuramoto model are circulant graphs [9, 10]. However, many real-world graphs are non-circulant, planar graphs. A dynamical model leading to balanced states independent of the un- derlying topology was introduced by Scardovi et al. [15] as a modification to the Kuramoto model, but it intro- duces an additional dynamical variable thus resulting in a different model. Therefore, it is still unknown which non- trivial planar network topologies support balanced states Here, we construct planar graphs that support stable, phase balanced states in the Kuramoto model. Starting from the cycle graph as a prototype for graphs with bal- anced stable fixed points in the Kuramoto model, we first study the effect of loops added to such a graph and show how these may be chosen to preserve balanced states. A balanced state is only preserved if the loops repre- sent the symmetries of the roots of unity found in many balanced states. Subsequently, we probe how additional edges change the balanced fixed points and identify the possible changes leading to balanced topologies, which are given by edges connecting two vertices of equal phase. In particular, we demonstrate how these two building blocks of balanced graphs may be combined to create a large network of Kuramoto oscillators having stable, bal- anced fixed points. For the graphs created this way, we then show that the variance of basin stability in terms of the winding numbers at stable fixed points scales linearly 8 1 0 2 p e S 6 2 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 0 0 0 0 1 . 9 0 8 1 : v i X r a with the size of the graph. Finally, we introduce the bal- ancing ratio as a new measure that allows to compare different graphs in terms of their balanced fixed points using the basin stability approach. We are able to derive analytical scaling laws for this parameter for the exam- ined balanced graphs using the scaling calculated for the variance. Thereby, we manage to capture the effect of loops or additional edges on balanced fixed points in cy- cle graphs in a quantitative manner. Our results show that topologies other than circulant graphs may support balanced fixed points and offer a new way of looking at balanced topologies. II. METHODS A. Theoretical methods - The Kuramoto model on complex networks 2 by CN for a cycle graph with N vertices. A cycle is a path that starts and ends in the same vertex without passing through any other vertex twice. If the whole graph is given by a single cycle, it is referred to as a cycle graph. We are now ready to express the equation of motion for the Kuramoto model on a graph G with N vertices as ϑ = ω − KB sin(cid:0)BT ϑ(cid:1), where B is the graph's incidence matrix. Here, ϑ = (ϑ1, ..., ϑN )T ∈ T N are the phase variables evolv- ing dynamically on the N -torus T N over time, ω = (ω1, ..., ωN )T ∈ RN is a vector of frequencies that is typ- ically drawn from some frequency distribution g(ω) and K is the coupling constant determining the strength of the mutual interaction between different oscillators. We assume this coupling constant to be identical for each in- teraction. In general, one may shift to a rotating frame such that 1T ω = N · (cid:104)ω(cid:105) = 0. In order to study the Kuramoto model on networks, we will first introduce some tools from graph theory [16, 17]. Consider a graph G(E, V ) consisting of N vertices with vertex set V and edge set E. Then one may define its adjacency matrix A ∈ NN×N by the components Aij representing the number of edges starting in vertex i and ending in vertex j. Furthermore, one can define the in- cidence matrix B ∈ ZN×NE , where NE = E(G) is the number of edges in G. It is defined by its components as 1, −1, 0, Bij = if (j, i) ∈ E(G), i.e., ej → vi if (i, j) ∈ E(G), i.e., ej ← vi otherwise , where ej → vi denotes the fact that edge j is incident in vertex i and vice versa. Furthermore, the Laplacian matrix L ∈ ZN×N of a graph G is defined by L = BBT . A graph is called circulant, if its Laplacian matrix is a cir- culant matrix. Circulant matrices are defined by the fact that each row is a cyclic permutation of the previous one. The eigenvalues λj and eigenvectors vj, j ∈ {1, ...N} of the Laplacian matrix for circulant graphs take the simple form of the roots of unity which reads [18], N(cid:88) lk(ρj)k, λj = vj =(cid:0)1, ρj, ρ2 k=1 j , ..., ρN−1 j (cid:1)T , j ∈ {0, ..., N − 1}, (1) where ρj,N = ei2πj/N are the N th roots of unity, i.e. the complex numbers such that (ρj,N )N = 1, ∀j. In this publication, we focus exclusively on so-called planar graphs. A graph is called planar if there exists a drawing of the graph in which no two edges cross. A particularly simple example of a circulant planar graph is given by the cycle graph or simple cycle, which we refer to Our main focus will be the Kuramoto model with zero- frequency vector ω = 0. In this case, one may simply assume a coupling constant equal to unity K = 1 which can be achieved by rescaling time by the coupling con- stant t(cid:48) = K · t. The new dynamics will then potentially take shorter or longer times to reach a stable fixed point, but will still follow the same dynamics. This leaves us with the following simplified equation of motion ϑ = −B sin(cid:0)BT ϑ(cid:1). (2) We will be interested in fixed points of this dynamics which are characterized by a vanishing time derivative of the phase variables ϑ = 0. Identifying such fixed points which are balanced points at the same time is the main goal of this work. For coupled oscillator models, one can define a mea- sure of synchrony of oscillators as already introduced by Kuramoto [6] which is given by p(ϑ) = R(t) · ei(cid:104)ϑ(t)(cid:105) = eiϑj (t), (3) N(cid:88) j=1 1 N N where (cid:104)ϑ(t)(cid:105) = 1 i=1 ϑi(t) denotes the average angle. Typically, the length of this complex vector R(t) = p(ϑ) is used as an order parameter for synchrony. This or- der parameter assumes values between zero for balanced states [10, 19], also termed incoherent [20], and one for complete phase synchronization. Based on this order parameter, we define the set of balanced states B(N ) for a given number of oscillator N by ϑ ∈ TN(cid:12)(cid:12) N(cid:88) j  . B(N ) := eiϑj = 0 (4) Consequently, a planar graph on which the Kuramoto dynamics in Eq.(2) has a stable fixed point that is a bal- anced state will be called a balanced graph in the follow- ing. The interplay between the existence and stability of (cid:80)N fixed points in the Kuramoto model on the one hand - which is highly dependent on the underlying topology - and the state being balanced on the other hand - which is a requirement unrelated to the topology - will be the main interest of this work. An observable that we will make use of in the follow- ing sections is the winding number q. Assume that an orientation was assigned to the planar graph underlying the model resulting in an oriented graph Gσ and its cycle basis, i.e. a basis of the graph's cycles space consisting only of simple cycles [17], is given by BC = {C1, ..., CM}. Then the winding number for some cycle Ck in the graph reads (cid:88) (i,j)∈Ck qk = 1 2π ∆ij, (5) where (i, j) are edges composing the cycle and ∆ij = ϑi − ϑj is the phase difference along that edge taken modulo 2π to project it onto the interval ∆ij ∈ (−π, π]. This winding number qk ∈ Z assumes integer values since all phases along the path following the cycle need to be uniquely defined and in order to retrieve the phase at the starting point, the overall phase difference needs to total to zero modulo 2π. B. Stable fixed points of the Kuramoto dynamics - the basin stability approach In order to be able to study stable balanced fixed points, we will classify a fixed point's stability based on the concept of basin stability introduced in Ref. 21. It is based on the fixed point's basin of attraction B, which is the set of all initial conditions from which the system converges to the fixed point. The basin's volume may then be interpreted as the probability of returning to the fixed point after a perturbation [21, 22]. In case of the Kuramoto model, the overall phase space volume reads V = [0, 2π]N . When estimating the basin of attraction B(ϑ0) of some fixed point ϑ0 ∈ V , the fixed point's indi- cator function needs to be evaluated in the whole phase space. It reads for some ϑ(cid:48) ∈ V (cid:40) 1B(ϑ0)(ϑ (cid:48)) = 1, if ϑ(cid:48) ∈ B(ϑ0) 0, if ϑ(cid:48) (cid:54)∈ B(ϑ0) . The basin stability SB(ϑ0) of some fixed point ϑ0 ∈ TN is then simply given by the integral over this indicator function normalized by the overall phase space volume SB(ϑ0) = V 1B(ϑ0)(ϑ(cid:48)) dN ϑ(cid:48) (2π)N ∈ [0, 1]. (6) (cid:82) A different notion typically used to find stable fixed points in dynamical systems is linear stability analysis. It is based on the eigenvalues of the dynamical system's Jacobian matrix [23]. Based on this notion, one may cal- culate the following sufficient criterion for a fixed point 3 to be linearly stable in the Kuramoto dynamics indepen- dent of the underlying topology [10, 24] cos(∆ϑe) > 0, ∀e ∈ E(G), (7) where ∆ϑe is the phase difference along some edge e in the graph respecting its orientation. C. The roots of unity as a special class of balanced states Little knowledge is available about the mathematical structure of balanced states [11, 20]. Here, we will discuss particular solutions for balanced states formed by the roots of unity. Consider a vector of phase variables forming the N th roots of unity ϑ = (ϑ1, .., ϑN )T , where ϑj = 2πj N , j ∈ {1, ..., N}. , where (cid:80) A well known property of the roots of unity ρj,N = eϑj is the fact that they sum up to zero thus making the corresponding angles balanced states, see section C in the appendix for a proof. Since this is true for all roots of unity, one may choose as well different subgroups of different roots of unity ϑj = 2πj k Nk = N , Nk without changing the fact that they sum up to zero and are thus solutions of balanced states [14]. Note that for the particularly simple case where N = Nk, i.e. the case of evenly distributed oscillators, this set of angles is also referred to as splay states in the literature and plays an important role in neuroscience [25, 26]. Importantly, the overall state remains balanced if one adds potentially time-dependent angles αk(t) ∈ S1 to each group of roots of unity summing up to zero sep- arately ϑ∗ j = 2πj Nk + αk(t). Note that it is possible to choose different αk for each k roots of unity. Therefore, a subset BR(N ) group of N th of the set of balanced states reads (cid:110) ϑ ∈ TN(cid:12)(cid:12)ϑj = Nk = N, Nk ∈ N, αk(t) ∈ S1(cid:111) ⊂ B(N ). (cid:88) + αk(t), 2πj Nk BR(N ) = (8) For small N < 5, all balanced states may be created this way. The Nk may in general either be constructed using the prime factors of the overall number of oscillators N , or any combination of prime numbers summing up to N according to a theorem by Lam and Leung [27]. We will show how these solutions may be realized on a graph- level. D. Computational methods - Monte Carlo method and cycle flows allow to identify stable fixed points In this work, we make use of two different methods to analyze the Kuramoto model's fixed points numerically. On the one hand, we use an algorithm presented [28] that may be used to recently by Manik et al. find stable fixed points in the Kuramoto model. It is based on the fact that different solutions to the equa- tion characterizing fixed points in the Kuramoto model may only differ by constant flows around the underly- ing graph's cycles [28 -- 30]. In addition to that, it al- lows to establish a one-to-one correspondence between fixed points and winding numbers in the case where all phase differences between neighboring vertices are con- tained within a π-interval centered around the origin ∆ij ∈ [−π/2, π/2], i, j ∈ E(G) [28, 30]. This also guar- antees the fixed points to be stable due to the stability criterion in Eq. 7. For many planar graphs, all stable fixed points for the Kuramoto model with all-equal fre- quencies will have phase differences contained in this in- terval as established by a theorem due to Delabays et al. [31]. On the other hand, we use Monte Carlo sampling to determine a fixed point's basin stability. The phase space in the Kuramoto model has a volume of V = [0, 2π]N for N oscillators. Using the Monte Carlo method, M = 105 initial conditions were drawn at random from a uniform distribution spanning V and the number of initial condi- tions that converged to each of the stable fixed points was counted to estimate the basin stability SB similar to the approach in Ref. 32. Since this is a repeated Bernoulli experiment, it carries the standard error [21], σ(SB(ϑ0)) =(cid:112)(SB(ϑ0) · (1 − SB(ϑ0)))/M where ϑ0 ∈ TN is the fixed point of interest and SB(ϑ0) its basin stability. One can easily see that this error reaches its maximal value σ(0.5) ≈ 2 · 10−3 at a basin stability of SB(ϑ0) = 0.5 given the number of initial con- ditions used here M = 105. Integration of the Kuramoto equation of motion was performed using a standard ODE solver contained in the scipy package with stepsize dt = 0.5. Convergence to a stable fixed point was ensured by checking that the last change was small and calculating the Jacobian eigen- values. When evaluating the balancing ratio, all fixed point were counted as balanced if their order parameter was smaller than a graph-specific threshold value. This threshold value was calculated based on the order pa- rameter at the smallest non-balanced fixed point for the given graph, which varies a lot between different graphs. Using these two approaches, we could identify all stable fixed points that occupy a significant amount of the over- all basin stability and may thus be found by the Monte Carlo method or have all phase differences contained in the above interval and are therefore identified by the al- gorithm. In addition to that, we were able to find ana- lytical approximations for the phase differences at stable 4 fixed points which we used to recheck in specific cases that we did not miss stable balanced fixed points, which, however, did not reveal any new balanced fixed points not accounted for by either of the two methods. III. RESULTS A. Creating non-circulant balanced graphs from cycle graphs We will build non-circulant balanced graphs starting with the simplest example of planar, circulant graphs, the cycle graph and the 3-regular prism graph. The cy- cle graph is denoted CN , where the index represents the number of vertices in the graph N . A cycle is a path that starts and ends in the same vertex consisting of dis- tinct vertices V (CN ) = {v1, ..., vN} and edges of the form E(CN ) = {(v1, v2), (v2, v3), ..., (vN , v1)} [17, p.8]. If the whole graph is given by one cycle, we refer to the graph as a cycle graph. For this graph and the version of the Kuramoto equation of motion (2) used here, the phase differences at fixed points of the dynamics may be calcu- lated analytically. These phase differences at stable fixed points read [13] ∆ϑc(qc) = 2πqc N , qc ∈ [−(cid:98)Nc/4(cid:99),(cid:98)Nc/4(cid:99)] ⊂ Z, where qc are the winding numbers characterizing the fixed point and the domain represents stable fixed points. The 3-regular prism graphs is denoted YN , where the index once again represents the number of vertices in the graph. They may be created by connecting two cy- cle graphs to each other at pairs of vertices. For these graphs, phase differences at stable fixed points take the same form as for the cycle graph with the crucial dif- ference that the winding number qY characterizing sta- ble fixed points is now smaller qY ∈ [−(cid:98)NY /8(cid:99),(cid:98)NY /8(cid:99)]. This is due to the fact that the number of stable fixed points is limited by the number of vertices in the cen- tral cycle which consists of half of the overall number of vertices. Importantly, the stable fixed points in these two topologies are all balanced except for the synchronized state. Starting from this observation, we will now con- struct other, non-circulant balanced graphs. 1. Only a few building blocks may be used to create balanced graphs from cycle graphs As we have seen, all circulant graphs are balanced graphs including the simple cycle. For this reason one may try to construct other balanced graphs by modifying the cycle graph. However, most modifications will make the graphs non-balanced. In Fig. 1, two examples of bal- anced and non-balanced graphs created from balanced graphs are shown to highlight the difficulties of finding 5 FIG. 1. Balanced graphs may be constructed by making use of the two different building blocks. (a) Balanced graph rep- resenting the symmetries of the fourth roots of unity with respect to the corresponding winding number q1 = +1 in the spectral drawing. (b) Graph consisting of two cycles con- nected to each other but with additional loops added in such a way, that they are symmetric with respect to each of the big faces with winding numbers q2,1 = q2,2 = +1. (c) Two cycle graphs connected at more than one edge do no longer possess any stable balanced fixed points. Fixed point shown with q3,1 = q3,2 = 1 is balanced if cycles are only connected at a single edge. (d) A graph that is not symmetric with respect to the winding number q4,1 = +1 of the big face. The stable state shown is not balanced. Faces with no winding number indicated carry winding number zero. All graphs shown here have automorphism groups with basis elements being rotation and reflection along horizontal axis. appropriate modifications. The graphs shown in panels c and d are non-balanced whereas the graphs in panels a and b are although their overall symmetries in terms of graph automorphisms are the same. They are given by elementary rotation and reflection along the horizontal symmetry axis. Here, we will show how one may add edges to cycle graphs, or add loops to them such that the resulting graphs are non-circulant, but still balanced graphs. To achieve this, we will make use of our knowledge about a special class of balanced states constructed from the roots of unity as defined in Eq. 8. In general, we found two different ways of modifying cycle graphs that lead to balanced graphs which we will discuss in the following paragraph. 2. Loops added symmetrically to a cycle graph may result in a balanced graph An obvious way to modify cycle graphs is given by adding loops consisting of several vertices to the graph. Yet, most such operations will destroy the balancing properties of fixed points. The only way to add loops to the graph preserving this property is a symmetric addi- tion of loops reflecting the symmetries of balanced states. For example, if one was to add k loops consisting of m FIG. 2. (a) The cycle graph C18 to which k = 6 loops of size m = 1 have been added with angular variables showing a stable, phase balanced fixed point (colorbar). The fixed point has winding number q = 1 in the central cycle. (b) Angular variables corresponding to the fixed point shown in (a) plotted on the unit circle. The angles in each of the loops are visible and form roots of unity themselves resulting in a balanced fixed point. vertices each to a cycle graph with a total of N vertices in such a way that the resulting graph will be balanced, we found that one may in general only do so by choos- ing k as an integer divisor of N kN = n ∈ N. In this case, one may choose the loops to be equidistant in terms of the vertices between them, which corresponds to the roots of unity in angular space. An example representing the 6th roots of unity on the cycle graph C18 is shown in Fig. 2. Panel (a) shows the cycle graph to which k = 6 loops consisting of m = 1 vertex each have been added and the corresponding color code represents phase vari- ables at this stable fixed point of the Kuramoto dynam- ics. Panel (b) shows the corresponding angular variables on the unit circle at this fixed point, which makes the one- to-one correspondence between topology and the roots of unity characterizing it obvious. 3. Adding edges to balanced graphs may preserve balanced states Suppose a balanced graph G was found along with the corresponding stable balanced fixed point ϑ character- ized by some winding number with absolute value larger than one, q > 1, in one of the graph's cycles. If there are two vertices that have exactly the same phase vari- able ϑi = ϑj then one may add an edge to the graph connecting these two vertices E(G(cid:48)) = E(G) ∪ {(i, j)}. The corresponding fixed point in the new graph G(cid:48) will still be a stable, balanced fixed point. One may see that the new fixed point is still stable as follows; suppose that J (ϑ) ∈ RN×N is the Jacobian matrix characterizing the fixed point in the old system before adding an edge with eigenvalues λk(J ) < 0, ∀k ∈ {1, ..., N}, which guarantees the fixed point's linear sta- bility by using linear stability analysis [23]. If the edge added to the graph reads (i, j) ∈ E(G(cid:48)), then the Jaco- bian at the new fixed point J(cid:48)(ϑ(cid:48)) differs from the old one by a matrix J(cid:48)(ϑ(cid:48)) = J (ϑ) + j which has the trivial +1+1+1+1+1+10π2π3π22πabcdbalancednotbalanced+10π2π3π20π2π3π22πab6 created by adding cycles to the graph. In Fig. 3, exam- ples of cycle graphs to which edges have been added with- out destabilizing the corresponding balanced fixed points are shown. Balanced fixed points in the cycle graph C20 characterized by winding numbers q = 2 (a), q = 3 (b) and q = 5 (c) do not become unstable if edges are added connecting vertices having the same phase variable (red dotted lines). The winding number is distributed in cor- respondence with the number of vertices to the new cycles in the modified graphs. Importantly, although all graphs shown here have non- trivial automorphism groups, the two building blocks dis- cussed here may also be combined to create graphs with no trivial symmetry properties, see section A 1 a in the appendix. B. Towards a general classification of balanced graphs using the balancing ratio Now that we showed how a class of balanced graphs may be constructed, we are going to quantify how bal- anced they are. In general, there is little knowledge avail- able about the structure of balanced fixed points in bal- anced graphs apart from the fact that the Kuramoto or- der parameter vanishes at such points. To be able to compare different balanced graphs in an easily accessible way, we introduce the balancing ratio as a new measure based on the basin stability approach. We define this as the fraction of basin stability occupied by all balanced states in a graph G taken together (cid:88) SB(ϑ) ∈ [0, 1]. (9) b(G) = ϑ∈BG(N ) Here, BG(N ) is the set of balanced states consisting of N angles, now referring exclusively to the stable balanced states in the graph G as indicated by the subscript and defined by Eq. 4. This measure may be understood as the probability of ending up in a balanced state when starting from a randomly chosen state. Importantly, most graphs will have vanishing balancing ratio b(G) = 0 since they are not balanced. In practice, the balancing ratio may be calculated by performing repeated Monte Carlo ex- periments and counting the number of times a balanced state is reached. 1. Variance of basin stability scales linearly with number of vertices for many balanced topologies In order to calculate this balancing ratio of a circulant graph for an arbitrary number of vertices in the graph, we need to derive an expression for the basin stability of the graph's fixed points. The basin stability SB(qc) in de- pendence of the winding number qc for the fixed points in the Kuramoto model on a cycle graph is known to follow a Gaussian distribution SB(q) = 1√ 2πσ2 e−q2/(2σ2) FIG. 3. Additional edges (red, dotted lines) added to cycle graphs may not change the overall stability properties of sta- ble, balanced fixed points. (a) A stable, balanced fixed point in a cycle graph (top) with winding number q1 = +2 (center of graph) does not loose stability upon addition of an edge connecting two vertices having the same angular value (bot- tom). The overall winding number is distributed equally over the two resulting graphs (bottom) q1,1 = q1,2 = +1 (cen- ter of the graphs). (b) The same procedure may be applied for higher order fixed points (top) by connecting again ver- tices of equal phases (bottom). The overall winding number q2 = +4 is again distributed on the different resulting graphs with q2,1 = +1, q2,2 = +2 and q2,3 = +1 from left to right. (c) The same mechanism can be applied starting from wind- ing number q3 = +5 (center) and connecting vertices of same phase. The last graph's automorphism group has only one ele- ment which is the reflection along the horizontal axis, whereas all other graphs have an additional rotational symmetry. entries jkl = 1· (δkiδlj + δkjδli)− 1· (δkiδli + δkjδlj), i.e. a symmetric matrix with non-zero entries only at the en- tries characterizing the new edge. The entry unity is due to the fact that the new edge has zero phase difference such that cos(0) = 1. This matrix has only one non-zero eigenvalue λ(j) = −2. Using Weyl's inequality for the eigenvalues of symmetric matrices [33], one can see that the Jacobian eigenvalues λ(cid:48) k at the new fixed point fulfill k ≤ λk + 0 due to the fact that zero is the maximal λ(cid:48) eigenvalue of the additional matrix j. Thus, all Jacobian eigenvalues at the new fixed point are negative as well and the fixed point is stable. On the other hand, the fixed point stays balanced since the new fixed point has exactly the same phase variables ϑ(cid:48) = ϑ and the balancing condition is independent of topology. An example is shown in Fig. 1,b, where an edge was added to a cycle graph with loops. Using this pro- cedure, we made use of the fact that one may subdivide the overall balancing property into individual subgroups summing to zero separately, see section II C. If the underlying graph is a cycle graph, this procedure may be applied if the winding number is an integer divi- sor of N qN = m ∈ N. Then there are groups of q ver- tices having the same angular value since q = N · ϕ/(2π), where ϕ = ϑi − ϑi−1, ∀i, implies that ϑi = ϑi+m mod 2π, i.e. each angular value is repeated at every m-th posi- tion. It is important to note that although the addition of edges as described above does not change the stabil- ity property of the corresponding fixed point it will affect the basin stability of a fixed point as new fixed points are +2+4+5+1+1+2+1+1+2+2+10π2π3π22π⇓⇓⇓abc7 if plotted against the winding numbers of the two cycles q1 and q2. If the two cycles have the same number of vertices n = N/2 + 1, the Gaussian distribution is well- described by a single standard deviation σ1 = σ2 = σ. This variance shows the same scaling as for the single cycle if plotted against the number of vertices in each of the cycles n. In terms of the number of vertices n in a cycle, it reads (n) = (3.2 · n − 1.1) · 10−2. σ2 Gc This scaling is shown in terms of the overall number of vertices N in Fig. 4 a (blue). Finally, this scaling is also valid for graphs to which loops have been added according to the scheme described in section III A 2. The variance of the Gaussian scaling observed in terms of the winding number was evaluated for the winding number in the central loop. In terms of the number of vertices in this central loop N∗ = N−k·m, where N is the overall number of vertices in the graph, k is the number of loops added and m is the number of vertices in each loop, the overall variance shows a similar scaling compared to the cycle graph (N∗) = (3.1 · N∗ − 4.9) · 10−2. σ2 Gl This scaling was obtained using a linear fit on the Monte Carlo results of 18 different graphs with k ∈ {2, 3, 5} loops and different number of vertices. It is shown in Fig. 4 a (purple). 2. Balancing ratio for circulant graphs shows a simple square root scaling Inspired by the numerical results, we will now proceed to show how one may calculate the balancing ratio in circulant graphs. Importantly, all states except for the synchronized state with winding number qc = 0 are bal- anced for circulant graphs. Therefore, the balancing ra- tio is calculated by summing over all stable states' basin stability except for the synchronized state which is the √ peak of the Gaussian distribution. This peak is of height 2πσCN (N ))−1 for a normalized Gaussian distribution ( where σCN (N ) is the Gaussian's standard deviation. Us- ing the linear scaling for the variance σ2 (N ), we get the following expression for the balancing ratio of a cycle graph CN in dependence of the overall number of vertices in the graph CN SB(q) = 1 −(cid:16)√ (cid:88) (cid:17)−1 ≈ 1 −(cid:16)(cid:112)2π(3.2 · 10−2N ) q(cid:54)=0 . (cid:17)−1 b(CN ) = 2πσCN (N ) (10) Here, we neglected the y-intercept due to its negligible effect on the result. This approximation is shown for different numbers of vertices N in Fig. 6 (purple). It coincides very well with the results from Monte Carlo sampling. (a) Scaling of the variance σ2 characterizing the FIG. 4. Gaussian distribution describing the basin stability with the number of vertices N in different graphs. Linear fits (dotted lines) and data points from Monte Carlo sampling (mark- ers) are shown for cycle graphs CN (dark purple dots), cycle graphs with loops Gl (light purple squares), a cycle graph with a central edge added Gc (blue diamonds) and prism graphs YN (green stars). Fit parameters for linear relationship σ2(N ) = m · N + b are mCN = 3.2 · 10−2, bCN = −1.7 · 10−3, mGl = 3.1··10−2, bGl = −4.9·10−2, mGc = 1.6·N·10−2, bGc = −1.1· 10−3 and mYN = 1.3· 10−2, bYN = −1.0· 10−2 from top to bottom. Note that for Gl, fit was performed in terms of the number of vertices in the central cycle. (b) Scaling of share of basin stability occupied by the stable fixed points with all winding numbers in outer loops equal to zero AG(k) in depen- dence of the number of loops k added to a cycle graph. Data points from Monte Carlo sampling represented by dots and analytical approximation as dotted line are shown. Errors in both figures take a maximal value of σ(SB(ϑ)) = 2 · 10−3 for each dot and are thus too small to be visible in the figure. and different explanations for this scaling have been sug- gested [22, 34]. As we found here, the variance σ2 (N ) of this Gaussian distribution scales to good approxima- tion linearly with the number of vertices N as shown in Fig. 4a (dark purple line), i.e., CN (N ) = 3.2 · 10−2 · N − 1.7 · 10−3. σ2 CN This fit was calculated by fitting a linear function to the results obtained using Monte Carlo sampling and calculating the variance in the winding number distri- bution [35]. For moderate values of N , the scaling is (N ) = 3.2 · 10−2 · N effectively since the y-intercept σ2 is negligible. CN In addition to the linear scaling observed for the vari- ance in case of the cycle graph, we found this scaling to hold for other graphs as well. For the prism graph YN , (N ) = (1.3 · N − 1.0) · 10−2 the variance scales as σ2 if fitted linearly to the data. This result coincides very well with the data points obtained from simulation, see Fig. 4,a, green stars. YN Another example for which we found the linear scaling to hold is the graph created by adding a single edge to a cycle graph thus creating two cycles of the same size connected at a single edge as described in section III A 3 and shown in Fig. 3 a, bottom. In this case, the basin stability follows a two-dimensional Gaussian scaling SB(q1, q2) = 1 2πσ1σ2 e−1/2((q1/σ1)2+(q2/σ2)2), 20406080100N01234σ2linearfitMCCNMCGlMCGcMCYN0102030k0.70.80.91.0AG(k)predictionMCsimulationsab8 Along the same lines, one may calculate a similar scal- ing law for the prism graph YN . Again plugging in the linear scaling obtained for the variance, the balancing ratio for this graph is calculated to be SB(q) = 1 −(cid:16)√ (cid:17)−1 (cid:88) ≈ 1 −(cid:16)(cid:112)2π(1.3 · N − 1.0) · 10−2) (cid:17)−1 2πσYN (N ) q(cid:54)=0 (11) . b(YN ) = Here, q is the winding number in the central cycle of the prism graph. This approximation is shown in Fig. 6 (dark green line) again coinciding with the results ob- tained from Monte Carlo sampling. = = making use of the fact that the basin stability in terms of the winding numbers follows a two-dimensional Gaussian distribution and the scaling of this Gaussian's variance in terms of the number of vertices n is again linear. This allows us to evaluate the balancing ratio for the graph Gc b(Gc) = (cid:88) (cid:88) (cid:88) q∈Dc(q) 1 q∈[1,(cid:98)n/4(cid:99)] q∈[1,(cid:98)n/4(cid:99)] 1 1 +q2 2 )/(2σ2)δq1,q2 − 1 2πσ2 2πσ2 e−(q2 πσ2 e−q2/σ2 π(3.2 · n − 1.1) · 10−2 e−q2/(3.2·n−1.1)·10−2 1 . (12) 3. Balancing ratio depends on newly created cycles when adding edges to cycle graphs Having solved balancing ratios for simple circulant graphs, we now consider the balanced graph obtained by adding a single edge to a cycle graph CN such that each of the newly created cycles has the same number of vertices n = N/2 + 1. We will refer to this graph by Gc. This graph is the most simple balanced graph one may obtain using the above building block of adding edges to balanced graphs and thus provides a natural extension of cycle graphs. Exemplarily, such a graph is shown in Fig. 3 a, bottom. Making use of the results obtained for the cycle graph, we will show how one may calculate the balancing ratio for this graph. Fixed points in this graph are characterized by the winding numbers in the two cycles q = (q1, q2)T . In this case, the only balanced states that we found were states where the two cycles have the same winding number, i.e. opposite flows at the shared edge, which are precisely the fixed points described in section III A 3 and in one- to-one correspondence with the balanced fixed points in the cycle graph without additional edge. Here, we assume the cycles and edges to be both oriented counterclockwise and the edge shared between the cycles to be oriented along the first cycle characterized by q1. We define the set characterizing all states where the two cycles have identical winding number by Qc = {q ∈ Dc(q)(cid:12)(cid:12)q1 = q2, q1 (cid:54)= 0}. 4(cid:99)(cid:3)2 ⊂ Z2 is the domain where Here, Dc(q) = (cid:2)−(cid:98) n 4(cid:99),(cid:98) n the fixed points are guaranteed to be stable, but not all combinations of winding numbers in this set may nec- essarily be realized in a stable fixed point. Again, the synchronized state is not balanced for this topology and thus excluded from this set. Using this definition, the balancing ratio may be calculated as (cid:88) (cid:88) b(Gc) = SB(ϑ) = SB(q)δq1,q2−SB((0, 0)T ), ϑ∈BGc (N ) q∈Dc(q) This result is shown in Fig. 6, (dark blue) and agrees very well with the result obtained from Monte Carlo sampling. Comparing this result to the one obtained for the cycle graph CN in Eq. 10, one may notice that it is always smaller by a prefactor of (2π)−1/2. In addition to that, the variance σ2(N ) shows a more moderate scaling with the number of vertices for the given graph and the sum scales with σ−2 ∝ N−1 in the prefactor compared to the σ−1 ∝ N−1/2 scaling observed for the cycle graph. This explains the different scalings observed in Fig. 6. 4. Balancing ratio for cycle graph with loops depends on graph symmetries In this section, we will show how a similar result may be obtained for cycle graphs to which loops have been added. Consider a cycle graph to which k loops have been added by adding m = 3 vertices to the graph for each of the loops and connecting them to a single edge of the graph, thus creating loops consisting of m + 2 = 5 vertices, see e.g. Fig. 5 b, for an example with two loops. Each such loop results potentially in the creation of two new stable fixed points characterized by the two non- zero loop winding numbers ql ∈ {1,−1}. For this reason, stable fixed points with all phase differences contained in the interval [−π/2, π/2] centered around the origin may be uniquely characterized using the winding vector q = (q1, ql,1, ..., ql,k)T , where q1 is the winding number in the central loop and the ql,k are the k winding numbers characterizing the loops. In order to be able to calculate the balancing ratio for such graphs, we will first study the effects of loops on the overall basins stability occupied by the newly cre- ated fixed points. The basin stability occupied by such a stable state in which exactly one loop has a non-zero winding number stays roughly constant over all numbers of vertices and loops with the average value being SB(ql = 1) = SB(ql = −1) = (7.1 ± 0.3) · 10−3, where δq1,q2 is the Dirac delta such that δq1,q2 = 1, if q1 = q2 and 0 otherwise. This sum may be evaluated by where the given error is the standard deviation over all samples. This value was obtained for cycle graphs C120 to 9 central loop's winding numbers at balanced fixed points in dependence of the number of loops added to the graph k by Ql,1(k) = {q1 ∈ (cid:21)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:64)n1 ∈ N0 s.t. q1 = n1 · k}. (cid:20) (cid:99) −(cid:98) N 4 (cid:99),(cid:98) N 4 In Fig. 5, a stable fixed point that is balanced in the corresponding cycle graph, but became non-balanced due to the loops is shown. The figure shows the cycle graph C28 to which k = 2 loops have been added making the stable fixed point with q1 = 2 now non-balanced. This is due to an asymmetry in the phase variables towards ϑ = 0 making the resulting fixed point non-balanced as indicated by a non-zero order parameter, Fig. 5 a, (black square). For this reason, such fixed points need to be excluded when calculating the balancing ratio. Using these two results, we are now ready to write down an estimate for the basin stability in a graph with loops b(Gl, k) = (cid:88) = AG(k) · (1 − (cid:88) ϑ∈BGl (N ) q∈Ql,1 SB(q) SB(ϑ) ≈ (cid:88) 1 − (cid:88) 1√ 2πσ2 q1∈Ql,1(k),ql=0 e−q2/(2σ2)) (15)  . q∈Ql,1 ≈ (1 − 1.42 · 10−2)k · e−q2/(6.4·10−2·N∗) √ 2π · 3.2 · 10−2 · N∗ Here, N∗ = N − k · m refers once again to the number of vertices in the central cycle without loops. Analyzing this expression, one may notice the relationship to the basin stability of a simple cycle in Eq. 10. This expression dif- fers from the one for the simple cycle in terms of a factor accounting for the basin stability in states with non-zero winding numbers in loops and in terms of several winding numbers other than the synchronized state being now ex- cluded from the summations due to the additional sym- metries induced by the loops. Importantly, this result will always yield lower values of basin stability in com- parison to the corresponding cycle graph. This approx- imation is shown in Fig. 6 (light purple) for k = 2, 3, 5 along with the corresponding results from Monte Carlo sampling where the number of loops for the respective graph is indicated by a purple number. 5. Balancing ratio allows to compare balanced states in different types of balanced graphs Finally, the balancing ratio may also be calculated nu- merically using the Monte Carlo method for different types of balanced graphs for which there are no ana- lytical results available so far. To compare the results for those and the previously discussed topologies among each other, we plotted the balancing ratio b(G) against the overall number of vertices in the graph N in Fig. 6. Different colors and symbols encode different types of FIG. 5. Winding numbers multiple of the number of loops in- duce asymmetries in the phase variables at stable fixed points. (a) Phase variables at the stable fixed point depicted in (b). The asymmetry towards ϑ = 0 is clearly visible and indicated by the Kuramoto order parameter in Eq. 3 (black square), which assumes a non-zero value for this configuration. (b) Cycle graph C28 to which k = 2 loops have been added. The stable fixed point shown here with central winding number q = 2 is not balanced. which k ∈ {0, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10, 12, 15, 20, 24, 30} loops have been added, but was also confirmed for much smaller cycle graphs C30 with loops added where a similar value was obtained. Thus, the probability of finding a non-zero winding number in one of the loops when starting from a random initial condition for the given graphs reads p(ql = 1) = 2 · SB(ql = 1) = (1.42 ± 0.06) · 10−2. (13) This allows us to estimate the average basin stability oc- cupied by states with a non-zero winding number in de- pendence of the number of loops k by AG(k) = (1 − p(ql = 1))k, (14) due to the fact that the probability of observing a zero winding number in a given loop reads 1 − p(ql = 1). Here, we assumed the probability of observing non-zero winding numbers in different loops to be independent. In order to calculate the balancing ratio for this topol- ogy, we need to derive an expression for the basin stabil- ity occupied by balanced states. In general, such cycle graphs with loops allow for a lot of different balanced states with non-zero winding numbers in some of the loops according to their symmetry properties, see sec- tion III B 4 in the appendix for a detailed discussion. However, in the given setting where loops consist only of a small number of vertices in comparison to the main cycle, the basin stability taken by such states is negli- gible. For this reason, we will focus on balanced states where all loops have a zero winding number. Compared to the balancing ratio for the cycle graph, basin stability for such graphs will then be reduced by the above factor AG(k). In addition to that, the symmetry of the added loops makes a few previously available balanced fixed points now non-balanced ones. This is the case if the winding number is a multiple of the number of loops. To formalize this argument, define the following set characterizing the +20π2π3π20π2π3π22πab10 FIG. 6. Balancing ratio b(G) plotted for different balanced graphs against total number of vertices in graph N . Color code and symbols represent different prototypes for the graphs analyzed here as shown in legend, right. For the cycle graph with loops purple numbers 2, 3 and 5 correspond to the number of loops added. For graphs on the left side of the legend, only the central cycle grows with increasing N whereas the added loops - if they exist - stay constant in size. For graphs on the right side of the legend, loops grow accordingly with increasing N (top). Graph at the bottom right of the legend marked by yellow color is the only asymmetric graph analysed here. Results marked by symbols were obtained using Monte Carlo sampling performed for respective graph except for analytical results indicated by colored lines. See text for detailed information on how the respective graph was constructed exactly. Errors take a maximal value of σ(SB(ϑ)) = 2 · 10−3 for each dot and are thus too small to be visible in the figure. graphs as indicated by different prototypes shown in the legend on the right. The cycle graph appears as an upper bound on the bal- ancing ratio for a given number of vertices N out of all balanced graphs. This might be due to the simple struc- ture of cycle graphs making the balanced states most easily accessible for random initial configurations and the fact that there is only one non-balanced fixed point for this topology. Furthermore, we note that all of the graphs analyzed here show a monotonic scaling with the number of ver- tices in the graph. While most graphs show an increase in the balancing ratio with the number of vertices in the graphs, cycles with long loops added and growing in ver- tices by growing loop vertices as well show a monotonic decrease with the overall number of vertices, see sym- bols × and + and light green color in Fig. 6. These graphs were constructed by adding two loops of equal lengths l to both sides of a cycle graph symmetrically with the loops spanning l − 1 of the cycle's vertices such that the additional cycles now share more than one edge with the central cycle. For the graphs represented by symbol ×, loops are of lengths l ∈ {2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7} added to the cycle graph C18 resulting in graphs of sizes N ∈ {22, 24, 26, 28, 30, 32}, respectively. Other copies of this kind of graph are marked by symbol + and cre- ated from the cycle graph C46 with higher numbers of vertices N ∈ {50, 52, 54, 56, 62, 70} and loops of lengths l ∈ {2, 3, 4, 5, 8, 12} and show similar values of balanc- ing ratios and a similar scaling. These graphs show a clear decrease with the length of the loops added which can be explained by noticing that the length of the loops corresponds to the number of possible fixed points in the graphs due to the increase in cycle length. The new fixed points will occupy some basin stability themselves such that the balanced fixed points occupy less and less basin stability with increasing length of loops. This scaling was confirmed by some preliminary analysis counting the share of fixed points being balanced. The upper bound given by the corresponding cycle graphs C46 and C18 is reached if the length of the loops is reduced to zero. Furthermore, the graphs represented by symbol (cid:72) and light green color represent cycle graphs to which more complicated structures have been added on two symmet- ric ends resulting in three additional cycles at both sides. This graph shows the same trend as the simple cycle graphs to which loops have been added, which are shown as light purple numbers. This is due to the fact that these graphs are similar to the latter graphs but different in terms of the number of cycles in the graph. 20406080100N0.00.20.40.60.81.0b(G)loopsizeconstantloopsizegrowsasymmetricIn terms of the effect additional loops have on balanced states in cycle graphs, it is easily visible that they result in a lower balancing ratio compared to the correspond- ing cycle, see graphs represented by purple numbers 2, 3 and 5 indicating the number of loops. Counterintuitively, more loops added to the graph might lead to a higher balancing ratio than fewer loops, although the former represent a stronger perturbation to the circular topol- ogy. This is due to the fact that more states with lower winding number remain balanced if the number of loops is increased, which take a higher amount of basin stabil- ity compared to the states with higher winding numbers. This effect compensates the additional factor AG(k) for increasing numbers of vertices in the graph leading to higher balancing ratios for the graphs with more loops. However, the reduction in the balancing ratio for any number of loops added symmetrically to the graph is al- ways smaller than adding a central edge to the graph which leads to a much stronger decrease in the balancing ratio, see blue markers (cid:5). All loops added here consist of m = 3 additional vertices. For the graph formed by a cycle graph to which a cen- tral edge and loops have been added, represented by sym- bol (cid:68) and cyan color, the two small cycles were of size n ∈ {13, 20, 36} each and k ∈ {2, 3, 4} loops of size m = 3 have been added to each of the cycles resulting in the points shown at N ∈ {42, 52, 60, 84, 90, 96}, respectively. In contrast to the results for the single cycle to which loops have been added, the graphs show similar values of balancing ratios as for the corresponding graph created from adding a central edge to the cycle graph. Finally, the graph represented by yellow color and symbol (cid:78) is the only asymmetric graph shown here. This graph is created by adding two edges to the cy- cle graph C60 asymmetrically, thus resulting in a graph with cycles of length 31, 21 and 11. The only balanced fixed points for this graph are characterized by winding number q = 6 in the corresponding cycle graph. It shows a small, non-vanishing balancing ratio of around b(G) ≈ 3 · 10−3. IV. SUMMARY AND OUTLOOK In this work, we showed how additional loops and edges affect stable, balanced fixed points in the Kuramoto model on cycle graphs. To do so, we used the roots of unity as a particular class of balanced states to construct graphs that support stable balanced states. We exam- ined the basin stability of stable fixed points in the con- structed topologies as a measure of stability and used the results to evaluate the balancing ratio as a new order parameter for balanced graphs. In order to quantify the effect of additional connections on balanced states, we evaluated this parameter both analytically and numeri- cally for different topologies. Our results show that there are numerous non-circulant balanced topologies that may be constructed using simple building blocks. In general, 11 the addition of loops or edges to cycle graphs was shown to worsen the graph's balancability, with the effect of adding a central edge to the balanced graph being much stronger than the one of additional loops. The balancing ratio introduced here as an order pa- rameter for balanced graphs provides an easily accessible tool to classify stability in balanced graphs. We offer an analytical description of this parameter for a subset of balanced topologies which might help to yield more insight into the structure of balanced fixed points in gen- eral. On the other hand, the balancing ratio may be eas- ily calculated for any topology using numerical methods. It also offers the simple interpretation of the probability of ending up in a balanced state. This could be rele- vant for real-world networks if balanced states describe a desired mode of operation. Using two basic building blocks, we showed how a large class of balanced graphs may be constructed. In princi- ple, the building blocks shown here might also be used to create graphs representing tilings of two dimensional space but still being balanced. An important task for fu- ture work would be to find a classification for the building blocks on more mathematical grounds and to check which planar balanced graphs exist that may not be produced using the above schemes. Furthermore, one might move away from planar graphs and graphs with small degree being the main focus in this work and look for classifica- tion schemes for balanced graphs in general. We found that the standard deviation of basin stabil- ity in terms of the winding numbers scales linearly with the number of vertices in the graph for many topologies. This result yields new insights about the winding number distribution of stable states in cycle graphs and beyond. However, it is unclear how the prefactor 3.2 · 10−2 found to describe the slope of the variance σ2 in terms of the number of vertices in a cycle graph N may be explained theoretically. Neither is there a theoretical explanation for the probability of finding a state with non-zero wind- ing number in one of the loops p(ql = 1) nor a scaling of this number with number of loops k, size of loops m or number of vertices N . One possible way to continue the study of these graphs would be to quantify this probabil- ity for different sizes of loops and relate them to the Gaus- sian scaling observed for connected cycles of the same size or single cycles. On the other hand, it would be interest- ing to see if the linear scaling of the Gaussian's standard deviation with the number of vertices found here to be valid for two circulant graphs extends to other circulant graphs - or even other topologies. Using this scaling and combining different graphs, it could be possible to ana- lytically calculate the basin stability of single fixed points for much larger graphs. Although most of the networks constructed show an obvious symmetry in correspondence with the roots of unity, we were not able to relate our findings to results on cluster synchronization in coupled oscillator models in relationship to graph symmetry [36, 37] or symme- tries in the master stability function [38]. It would be an important goal for future works to be able to relate the results found here to graph symmetries in the underlying networks. The present work is the first one to study planar graphs under global constraints that manifest through phase bal- ancing of oscillators on more general grounds. The build- ing blocks studied here allow to create large networks of oscillators supporting balanced states, providing the mathematical framework to understand constrained os- cillators in nature but also to encode control in robotics 12 and autonomous vehicles. The methods introduced here further allow to quantify the stability of the balanced states in such networks - for many networks even analyt- ically. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work was funded by the Max Planck Society. [1] A. T. Winfree, The Geometry of Biological Time, 2nd ed. (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2010). [2] A. Pikovsky, M. Rosenblum, and J. Kurths, Synchroniza- tion: A Universal Concept in Nonlinear Sciences (Cam- bridge University Press, Cambridge, England, 2003). [24] A. Jadbabaie, N. Motee, and M. Barahona, in Proceed- ings of the 2004 American Control Conference, Vol. 5 (2004) pp. 4296 -- 4301. [25] P. Hadley and M. R. Beasley, Appl. Phys. Lett. 50, 621 (1987). [3] A. Arenas, A. D´ıaz-Guilera, J. Kurths, Y. Moreno, and [26] S. Nichols and K. Wiesenfeld, Phys. Rev. A 45, 8430 C. Zhou, Phys. Rep. 469, 93 (2008). (1992). [4] J. A. Acebr´on, L. L. Bonilla, C. J. P´erez-Vicente, F. Ri- tort, and R. Spigler, Rev. Mod. Phys. 77, 137 (2005). [27] T. Y. Lam and K. Leung, J. Algebra 224, 91 (2000). [28] D. Manik, M. Timme, and D. Witthaut, Chaos 27, [5] S. H. Strogatz, Physica D 143, 1 (2000). [6] Y. Kuramoto, Chemical Oscillations, Waves, and Turbu- 083123 (2017). [29] F. Dorfler, M. Chertkov, and F. Bullo, Proc. Natl. Acad. lence (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 1984). Sci. USA 110, 2005 (2013). [7] F. C. Hoppensteadt and E. M. Izhikevich, Weakly Con- [30] R. Delabays, T. Coletta, and P. Jacquod, J. Math. Phys. nected Neural Networks (Springer, 2012). 57, 032701 (2016). [8] E. M. Izhikevich and Y. Kuramoto, in Encyclopedia of Mathematical Physics (Academic Press, Oxford, 2006) pp. 448 -- 453. [9] F. Dorfler and F. Bullo, Automatica 50, 1539 (2014). [10] R. Sepulchre, D. A. Paley, and N. E. Leonard, "Group coordination and cooperative control of steered particles in the plane," in Group Coordination and Cooperative Control (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2006) pp. 217 -- 232. [11] D. A. Paley, Cooperative control of collective motion for ocean sampling with autonomous vehicles, Ph.D. thesis, Princeton University (2007). [12] D. A. Paley, N. E. Leonard, R. Sepulchre, D. Grunbaum, and J. K. Parrish, IEEE Contr. Syst. Mag. 27, 89 (2007). [13] J. Jeanne, N. E. Leonard, and D. Paley, in Proceedings of the 44th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (2005) pp. 3929 -- 3934. [14] K. Alim, G. Amselem, F. Peaudecerf, M. P. Brenner, and A. Pringle, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 110, 13306 (2013). [15] L. Scardovi, A. Sarlette, and R. Sepulchre, Systems & Control Letters 56, 335 (2007). [16] C. Godsil and G. Royle, Algebraic Graph Theory (Springer New York, 2001). [17] R. Diestel, Graph Theory (Springer, 2017). [18] R. M. Gray, Found. Trends Commun. Inf. Theory 2, 155 (2006). [19] R. Sepulchre, D. A. Paley, and N. E. Leonard, in in Proc. Int. Symp. NOLTA (2005). [20] S. Watanabe and S. H. Strogatz, Physica D 74, 197 (1994). [21] P. J. Menck, J. Heitzig, N. Marwan, and J. Kurths, Nat. Phys. 9, 89 (2013). [22] D. A. Wiley, S. H. Strogatz, and M. Girvan, Chaos 16, 015103 (2006). [23] H. K. Khalil, Nonlinear Systems, 3rd ed. (Pearson, 2001). [31] R. Delabays, T. Coletta, and P. Jacquod, J. Math. Phys. 58, 032703 (2017). [32] L. DeVille and B. Ermentrout, Chaos 26, 094820 (2016). [33] H. Weyl, Math. Ann. 71, 441 (1912). [34] R. Delabays, M. Tyloo, and P. Jacquod, Chaos 27, 103109 (2017). 2πσ)−1(cid:82) q+0.5 the Gaussian SB(q) q−0.5 e−x2/(2σ2) dx as is done in Ref. [35] Alternatively, one might calculate the variance by != √ fitting the integral under [22]. ( However, we found the given approach to yield better results when comparing it to results from Monte Carlo sampling. [36] L. M. Pecora, F. Sorrentino, A. M. Hagerstrom, T. E. Murphy, and R. Roy, Nat. Commun. 5, 4079 (2014). [37] M. T. Schaub, N. O'Clery, Y. N. Billeh, J.-C. Delvenne, and M. Barahona, Chaos 26, 094821 R. Lambiotte, (2016). [38] T. Dahms, J. Lehnert, and E. Scholl, Phys. Rev. E 86, 016202 (2012). Appendix A: Non-symmetric balanced networks 1. Graph automorphisms and symmetries An important tool to study dynamical systems evolv- ing on graphs - and in particular balanced states as possible dynamics - are graph symmetries. Graph au- tomorphisms in this section being the major tool used for studying symmetries on graphs. We will introduce them following Ref. [17, ch. 1]. Consider two graphs G and G(cid:48) with vertex sets V (G), V (G(cid:48)) and edge sets 13 FIG. 8. A balanced graph with empty automorphism group may be created by combining the two building blocks of adding loops to cycle graphs and connecting copies of the resulting graphs. (a) A balanced graph with N = 12 ver- tices and three symmetrically placed loops. (b) A balanced graph with N = 36 vertices created by joining together three copies of the graph in (a) resulting in a graph with empty automorphism group. graphs. Appendix B: Set of balanced states for N < 5 In this section, we show that for N < 5, all balanced states may be constructed making use of the roots of unity. Consider the case N = 2. We will show that the balanced states are given by the second roots of unity, i.e. that B(2) =(cid:8)ϑ1 = α, ϑ2 = α + π, α ∈ S1(cid:9). Proof. We have eiϑ1 + eiϑ2 = 0 ⇒ ei(ϑ2−ϑ1) = −1 ⇒ ϑ2 − ϑ1 = π, This means that in general, we have ϑ1 = α1 ⇒ ϑ2 = α1 + π, which are the angles building the second roots of unity. Along the same lines, the set of balances states for (cid:8)ϑj = 2πj 3 + α(t), α(t) ∈ S1, j ∈ {1, 2, 3}(cid:9), N = 3 is given by B(3) i.e. the third roots of unity. = Proof. Fixing ϑ1 = 0 without loss of generality, we get eiϑ2 + eiϑ3 = −1 ⇒ sin(ϑ2) + sin(ϑ3) = 0 ∧ cos(ϑ2) + cos(ϑ3) = −1 ⇒ (ϑ2 = −ϑ3 ∨ ϑ2 = π + ϑ3) ∧ cos(ϑ2) + cos(ϑ3) = −1. Only the first solution, namely ϑ2 = −ϑ3, is compat- ible with the second equation as ϑ2 = π + ϑ3 yields cos(ϑ2) + cos(ϑ3) = cos(π + ϑ3) + cos(ϑ3) = cos(ϑ3) − cos(ϑ3) = 0 (cid:54)= −1. Thus we arrive at 2 cos(ϑ2) = −1 which implies ϑ2 = ± 2π 3 , which are the angles corresponding to the third roots of unity. 3 , i.e. ϑ3 = ∓ 2π Finally, a similar result can be proven for N = 4. We will show that the balanced states are given by pairs of FIG. 7. Automorphisms for a cycle-like graph with k = 5 loops symmetrically added to the graph and a total of N = 25 vertices. Numbers on vertices (light blue circles) label vertices uniquely which are connected through edges (dotted, black lines). The graph displayed (a) is modified by applying two different automorphisms, namely the two basis elements of its automorphism group. (b) The first basis element is a reflection along a symmetry axis of the graph (straight, dotted line, reflection indicated by arrow). (c) The second one is a rotation (grey, dotted arrow) by a length corresponding to the distance between individual loops. Together, these symmetries represent the dihedral symmetries. E(G) and E(G(cid:48)). A map ϕ : V → V (cid:48) between their ver- tex sets is a homomorphism between the two graphs if it preserves the adjacency of vertices (vi, vj) ∈ E(G) ⇒ (ϕ(vi), ϕ(vj)) ∈ E(G(cid:48)). It is an isomorphism if the opposite is true as well, i.e. the map is bijective and its inverse is a homomorphism as well, which implies (ϕ(vi), ϕ(vj)) ∈ E(G(cid:48)) ⇒ (vi, vj) ∈ E(G). Finally, an automorphism is an isomorphism from G to itself. The set of all automorphisms of a graph forms a group. Since automorphisms are bijective, the combination of two au- tomorphisms is an automorphism once again and the map preserving each vertices' position, i.e. the identity map, is an automorphism itself which shows their group struc- ture. The main graphs of interest in this publication are cycle graphs and its modifications. The basis elements forming the automorphism group of the cycle graph with loops added symmetrically are shown in Fig. 7. Panel (a) shows the cycle graph C20 to which k = 5 loops of size m = 1 have been added symmetrically. Panel (b) and (c) show the basis elements of the graph's automor- phism group, namely an elementary reflection along one of the graph's symmetry axis (b) and an elementary ro- tation corresponding to the distance between different loops (c). a. Non-symmetric balanced graphs Besides the types of graphs discussed in section III A, the building blocks may be used to construct balanced graphs with empty automorphism group, graphs without any graph symmetries. This can easily be achieved by combining the building blocks in such a way that the added graphs do no longer have trivial symme- try properties. A simple example obtained by connecting three cycle graphs with loops in an asymmetric way is shown in Fig. 8. In general, this shows that automor- phism groups alone cannot be used to classify balanced i.e. 0π2π3π22π⇒ab(cid:110) second roots of unity, i.e. that (cid:111) ∧ indices non-equal . B(4) = ϑj = ϑk + π, ϑl = ϑm + π; j, k, l, m ∈ {1, 2, 3, 4} Proof. We have the following requirements on the angular variables eiϑ1 + eiϑ3 = −(eiϑ2 + eiϑ4 ) (P1) e−iϑ1 + e−iϑ3 = −(e−iϑ2 + e−iϑ4) . (P2) Now assume without loss of generality that eiϑ1 +eiϑ3 (cid:54)= 0 and eiϑ1 + eiϑ4 (cid:54)= 0. If one of the two equations held, we would have ϑ3 − ϑ1 = π or ϑ4 − ϑ1 = π, respectively, using the proof for the second roots of unity and would thus be done. Now one can make use of the equality e−iϑ1 + e−iϑ3 = (eiϑ1 + eiϑ3)/(eiϑ1 · eiϑ3) to obtain the following result from equation (P2) eiϑ1 + eiϑ3 eiϑ1 · eiϑ3 = eiϑ2 + eiϑ4 eiϑ2 · eiϑ4 . Together with equation (P1), this implies that ei(ϑ2+ϑ4) = ei(ϑ1+ϑ3) must hold since eiϑ1 + eiϑ3 (cid:54)= 0. Along the same lines, one may show that ei(ϑ1+ϑ4) = ei(ϑ2+ϑ3) is true. Multiplying these two equations with each other yields the identities e2iϑ2 = e2iϑ1 and e2iϑ3 = e2iϑ4. This implies the two equalities ϑ2 = ϑ1∨ϑ2−ϑ1 = π and ϑ4 = ϑ3∨ϑ4−ϑ3 = π. Only the latter possibilities ϑ2−ϑ1 = π and ϑ4 − ϑ3 = π are compatible with equations (P1) and (P2) which completes the proof. Appendix C: Summation over roots of unity The following theorem states that N th roots of unity sum up to zero. Theorem C.1 (Summation of roots of unity). Let N ∈ N be a natural number and consider the vectors of N th roots of unity rN,k = eikθN , where θN = (θ1, ..., θN ) and θj = arg(ρj,N ) = 2πj/N ∈ S1 are angular variables and k ∈ N<N is a natural number. Then for any natural number k ∈ N the sum of the roots of unity vanishes N(cid:88) j=1 1T rN,k = eikj2π/N = 0. 14 FIG. 9. Sketch of a cycle graph with k = 6 loops. The winding numbers in the loops for balanced fixed points are not limited to be all-zero (top left) or all unity (bottom left, unity value indicated by colour), but also patterns where the loop winding numbers are prime divisors of k may result in balanced fixed points (centre and right plots). (cid:80)N j=1 eik(j+1)2π/N . Now one can solve for 1T rN,k, since k < N and thus 1 − eik2π/N (cid:54)= 0 obtaining 1T rN,k = (cid:80)N j=1 eikj2π/N −(cid:80)N = eik2π/N 1 − eik2π (1 − eik2π/N ) 1 − eik2π/N = 0, j=1 eik(j+1)2π/N where eik2π = 1, ∀k ∈ Z was used in the last step. Appendix D: Balanced states in cycle graphs with loops In this section, we want to discuss the balanced states in cycle graphs with loops in more detail. Here, we will focus on the case where loops consist of m = 3 vertices added to the graph for all loops such that the winding number of the loops characterizing stable fixed points reads ql,i ∈ {−1, 0, 1}. To characterize these winding numbers, we will make use of results on the geometry of balanced states discussed in section II C. As an exam- ple, consider a cycle graph with k = 6 loops. In this case, states with ql ∈ {(1, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0)T , (1, 0, 1, 0, 1, 0)T} representing the loop number's prime factors can lead to balanced states as indicated in Fig. 9. To characterize these states on more mathematical grounds and express their relationship to the central loop's winding number q1, lets define the set of factors of the number of loops k whose factors are not a divisor of some integer q by RQl (k, q) = {p1 ∈ N<k(cid:12)(cid:12)∃p2 ∈ N<k : p1 · p2 = k ∧ p2 (cid:45) q}, tion yields (1 − eik2π/N )1T rN,k = (cid:80)N Proof. Multiplying both sides of the equation by eik2π/N and subtracting the result from the original equa- j=1 eikj2π/N − where the expression p1 (cid:45) q expresses the fact that p1 is not a divisor of q. Using this idea, one may write down the set of all loops' winding numbers leading to balanced 15 states. These states occur if the factor between the num- ber of loops k and the overall number of vertices in the new graph N∗ = N + k · m is a multiple of the number of edges added in each loop N∗/k = (m + 1) · p, p ∈ N. They are characterized by all equal, non-zero winding numbers in all loops ql,j (cid:54)= 0, ∀j, and a non-zero wind- ing number q1 in the central cycle with the same sign sign(q1) = sign(ql,j) which reads q1 = sign·(ql,j)(p−1)·k, see for example Fig. 3 b. states l,2 (q, k) = {ql ∈ D>0 Q>0 l,2 (ql)(cid:12)(cid:12) (cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) ql ∈ span(σp((1, 0, 0, .. (cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) p ∈ {1, ..., p1 − 1}), p1 ∈ RQl (k, q)}, , ..., 1, 0, 0, .. p1 p1 )T ), where σp denotes again the cyclic shift applied p times and the >0 superscript indicates that this set is restricted to positive winding numbers. Note that this set only con- tains symmetric states if the integer p1 is an integer di- visor of the number of loops k such that p1 wise RQl is the empty set. The cyclic shift represents the graph's rotational symmetry. In general, the sign of the loops' possible winding numbers needs to coincide with the sign of the central cycle's winding number. Thus, one may classify the balanced fixed points with positive winding numbers by (cid:12)(cid:12)k ∈ N, other- (k) = {q ∈ Dl(q)(cid:12)(cid:12)q1 ∈ Q>0 l Q>0 Here, Qc = {q ∈ Dc(q)(cid:12)(cid:12)q1 = q2, q1 (cid:54)= 0} is the set defin- c (k), ql ∈ Q>0 l,2 (q1)}. ing the possible winding numbers in the inner cycle as defined in section III B. The set of negative winding num- bers may be defined correspondingly and represents bal- anced states as well. Note that we now take the set of loop winding numbers in dependence of the winding num- ber in the inner cycle q1 Q>0 l,2 (q1) such that the main cy- cle's winding number induces the possible factors for the loops' winding numbers and thus their symmetry prop- erties. The cases where p2q1 in the set of factors RQl in- duces again a global symmetry similar to the one shown in Fig. 9 b and the resulting states are not balanced. Note that this definition only characterizes balanced states for m < 5 and needs to be redefined otherwise. In some cases, the combination of positive main wind- ing number and negative loop winding numbers q1 ∈ c (k), ql ∈ Q<0 Q>0 l,2 (q1) and vice versa leads to balanced states as well, that do, however, not always exist. In most cases, these states do exist for q1 = 1. Nonetheless, these fixed points might possess phase differences larger than π/2, in particular for small graphs. Take for example the cycle graph C40 to which k = 4 loops have been added. Then the state characterized by q = (1,−1, 0,−1, 0)T is stable and balanced, but has two phase differences larger than the threshold ϕ ≈ π/2 + 0.141 > π/2. For this rea- son, these states may not be studied using the algorithm for finding stable, balanced states, but will be accounted for by the Monte Carlo method if they take a significant amount of the system's basin stability. However, most of the states with non-zero loop numbers occupy only a small share of basin stability in practice and may thus be neglected when calculating the graph's balancing ratio. Even though almost complete, this set still doesn't fully account for the balanced states. The stable fixed points that appear through zero-energy edges in higher order winding numbers of the corresponding cycle graph need to be included when summing over all balanced
1510.07259	1	1510	2015-10-25T15:01:27	Long-range Acoustic Interactions in Insect Swarms: An Adaptive Gravity Model	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.stat-mech", "nlin.AO" ]	The collective motion of groups of animals emerges from the net effect of the interactions between individual members of the group. In many cases, such as birds, fish, or ungulates, these interactions are mediated by sensory stimuli that predominantly arise from nearby neighbors. But not all stimuli in animal groups are short range. Here, we consider mating swarms of midges, which interact primarily via long-range acoustic stimuli. We exploit the similarity in form between the decay of acoustic and gravitational sources to build a model for swarm behavior. By accounting for the adaptive nature of the midges' acoustic sensing, we show that our "adaptive gravity" model makes mean-field predictions that agree well with experimental observations of laboratory swarms. Our results highlight the role of sensory mechanisms and interaction range in collective animal behavior. The adaptive interactions that we present here open a new class of equations of motion, which may appear in other biological contexts.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Long-range Acoustic Interactions in Insect Swarms: An Adaptive Gravity Model Dan Gorbonos,1 Reuven Ianconescu,1, 2 James G. Puckett,3 Rui Ni,4 Nicholas T. Ouellette,5 and Nir S. Gova1 1Department of Chemical Physics, The Weizmann Institute of Science, P.O. Box 26, Rehovot, Israel 76100 2Shenkar College of Engineering and Design, Ramat-Gan, Israel 3Department of Physics, Gettysburg College, Gettsyburg, Pennsylvania 17325, USA 4Department of Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Pennsylvania 16802, USA 5Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305, USA The collective motion of groups of animals emerges from the net effect of the interactions between individual members of the group. In many cases, such as birds, fish, or ungulates, these interactions are mediated by sensory stimuli that predominantly arise from nearby neighbors. But not all stimuli in animal groups are short range. Here, we consider mating swarms of midges, which interact primarily via long-range acoustic stimuli. We exploit the similarity in form between the decay of acoustic and gravitational sources to build a model for swarm behavior. By accounting for the adaptive nature of the midges' acoustic sensing, we show that our "adaptive gravity" model makes mean-field predictions that agree well with experimental observations of laboratory swarms. Our results highlight the role of sensory mechanisms and interaction range in collective animal behavior. The adaptive interactions that we present here open a new class of equations of motion, which may appear in other biological contexts. 5 1 0 2 t c O 5 2 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 9 5 2 7 0 . 0 1 5 1 : v i X r a a Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to N.S.G. (email: [email protected]). I. INTRODUCTION 2 Collective behavior of groups of social animals is widespread in nature [1], and occurs on size scales ranging from single-celled organisms [2, 3] to insects [4 -- 7] to larger animals such as birds [8, 9] or fish [10 -- 12]. Animals are thought to aggregate and move cooperatively for many reasons; collective behavior may, for example, reduce the risk of predation for an individual in a group [1, 13], promote efficient mating and decrease inbreeding in dispersed populations [14], modulate the energetic cost of migration [15], or enable enhanced sensing [12]. Because of both its ubiquity and the potentially advantageous properties it conveys for groups, collective behavior has engaged a broad cross-section of scientists, ranging from physicists and applied mathematicians who hope to tease out the general principles that drive the emergence of collective states in non-equilibrium systems to engineers who hope to develop bio-inspired control strategies for distributed multi-agent systems. Collective behavior therefore has a long modeling history [1, 16, 17]. Models are useful both as a check on our fundamental understanding of the kinds of low-level interactions that lead to the emergent group properties and as a stepping stone to the design of engineered systems that exploit them. Many models treat the group as a collection of self-propelled agents that are in some way coupled [18, 19]. Building such an agent-based model therefore requires several fundamental choices [20]. We must specify the base-case, non-interacting behavior of each individual; we must choose a functional form for the interactions that couple the individuals; we must decide whether these rules are uniform throughout the population and in time; and we must decide which individuals interact. Each of these choices can be difficult to make with certainty, and yet has significant ramifications for model performance and fidelity. Here, we focus on the last of these modeling assumptions: the choice of which individuals interact. From passive observations alone, it is difficult to discern the correct interactions in a group of animals [5], since it requires the solution of a challenging inverse problem. Thus, it is common to replace the difficult-to-measure interaction network with the more straightforward proximity network [21]; that is, one assumes that the local neighborhood of an individual dominates that individual's behavior. This local neighborhood may be defined by, for example, either metric or topological distance [22, 23], but it is still the local environment that is assumed to matter. This assumption is reasonable, and appears to be valid [10, 11, 22, 24, 25], for dense groups of animals such as flocks of birds or schools of fish that interact primarily through vision and that move in a coordinated, directed fashion. But it need not always be true; crowds of humans moving toward goals, for example, can show emergent collective behavior while "interacting" with other individuals with whom they are likely to collide in the future rather than those who are closest to them [26]. We consider here a canonical example of collective animal behavior -- mating swarms of flying insects -- where local interactions do not clearly play a major role and yet where the animals display group-level cohesion [5]. Recently this system has also generated interest for possible indications of critical behavior [7, 27]. Previous descriptions of insect swarms have accounted for the tight binding of individuals to the group either by introducing a confining potential [6, 7] or by invoking external environmental cues [14]. Here, we instead develop a swarm model inspired by the dominant sensory mechanism of the insects, and show that group cohesion can emerge naturally instead of being externally imposed. Swarming species of Chironomid midges, such as those we consider here, are known to be very sensitive to acoustic signals [28], and are thought to be attracted to swarms by the sound they produce. We thus make the ansatz that midges accelerate toward the sound produced by others; in essence, we hypothesize that in addition to their known pairwise function, acoustic interactions are the basis for coordinating the large-scale collective behavior of the swarm. The exact structure of the acoustic field produced by a freely flying midge is not known, and to our knowledge there are no direct measurements of its detailed spatial structure. However, in other flying insects (flies, for example) the acoustic field produced has been found to have both monopole and dipole components [29]. Since the monopole field decays more slowly compared to the dipole (and any higher multipole) component, in the model we present we have concentrated on its contribution. The monopole sound intensity falls off according to an inverse-square law, and so this hypothesis results in a effective gravity-like force that promotes group cohesion while still allowing for complex individual motion. We additionally account for the possibility that the midges' sensory perception may adapt to the overall sound level they experience. Our model is thus not derived from an underlying kinetic theory, as is commonly done in models of collective behavior [18], but rather is explicitly long-range and (because of the adaptivity) many-body; and, as the model bears some similarity to self-gravitating systems, we can exploit our intuition for gravity in analyzing our model. To benchmark this model, we compare some of its predictions with laboratory measurements of several hundred swarms of the non-biting midge Chironomus riparius, and find surprisingly good agreement. Since the acoustic interactions in our model are long-range and adaptivity renders them inherently many-body, our results suggest that the midges process more than just local information, as has also recently been proposed for bird flocks [30]. We use in this work concepts and techniques from classical N -body self-gravitating systems, to explain the collective swarming behavior of insects (midges). Although models of collective behavior abound in the literature, this particular approach 3 has never been applied to the swarming problem. What we find especially appealing about it is both that a gravity-like model can produce very complex behavior from simple interactions, as is expected to occur in collective behavior in biology. At the same time, we introduce a concept to the gravitational physics community that is taken from biology, namely the adaptivity of the sensory mechanism, ending up with a new form of gravitational interaction that we term "adaptive gravity". II. EXPERIMENTAL SETUP Before discussing our model and its comparison with our empirical data, we describe our laboratory experiments with midge swarms. The details of these measurements have been discussed elsewhere [4, 5, 31], and so we only give a brief overview here. Our self-sustaining colony of C. riparius midges was originally established from egg sacs purchased from Environ- mental Consulting and Testing, Inc. The colony is maintained in a transparent cubical enclosure, 91 cm on a side, at a constant 22◦C. The midges are exposed to overhead light on a circadian cycle, with 16 hours of light and 8 hours of darkness per day. When the overhead light turns on and off (corresponding to "dawn" and "dusk"), adult males spontaneously form swarms. To promote swarm nucleation and to position the swarm in the enclosure, we use a black felt "swarm marker" measuring 30 × 30 cm2 placed just above the development tanks. Further details of our husbandry procedures are given in refs. [4] and [5]. To quantify the motion of the midges, we record movies of swarming events with three hardware-synchronized Point Grey Flea3 cameras at a rate of 100 frames per second. We have shown previously that this data rate is sufficient to resolve even the acceleration of the midges [4]. The cameras are arranged in a horizontal plane about 1 m from the center of the swarm with angular separations of approximately 30◦ and 70◦. Prior to recording data, the camera system is calibrated using Tsai's model [32]; subsequently, the two-dimensional coordinates of each midge on each camera (found by simple image segmentation and intensity-weighted averaging) can be combined to find the midge positions in three-dimensional space. The sequences of time-resolved positions are then linked into trajectories using a fully automated multi-frame predictive tracking algorithm [33]. For various reasons, trajectories may sometimes be broken; thus, in a post-processing step we link trajectory fragments using Xu's method of re-tracking in a six-dimensional position-velocity space [34]. After trajectory construction, we compute accurate time derivatives by convolving the tracks with a smoothing and differentiating kernel [4]. For the results shown here, we analyzed data from 128 swarming events. Although the number of individuals was not uniform from swarm to swarm, we have shown previously that the swarms reach a statistical "asymptotic" regime at surprisingly small population sizes [31]; here, the mean number of individuals per swarm was about 10. Finally, for reference below, we note that the body size of a male C. riparius midge is about 7 mm in length. Typical flight speeds of the midges are roughly 0.5 m/s, and peak instantaneous accelerations are on the order of 5 m/s2. The sound produced by a male's beating wings is broadband, but has a fundamental frequency of about 575 Hz, as measured in our experiments [35]. It is difficult to measure the sound amplitude produced by a freely flying midge precisely; within a few body lengths of the midge, we have measured it to be roughly 55 dB. In previous work, we have analyzed data from these swarms to characterize their dynamics [4, 5, 31, 36]. Without going into detail here, we briefly summarize our primary findings. Although our midge swarms remain confined to a compact region of space with a statistically sharp boundary (in a way that appears to be self-organized [31]), teasing out pairwise interactions within the swarm is very challenging [5, 36] and the swarms show no net internal order [4]. At a mean-field level, the statistics of the swarms share some features of an ideal gas in a harmonic trap [4, 5]. Thus, with our model, we attempt to capture these primary effects: strong binding of individuals to the swarm as a whole but no strong signature of pairwise interaction at the mean-field level, overall disorder inside the swarm, and complex individual trajectories. III. MODEL In the absence of viscous damping, the intensity of the monopole component of the sound produced by an isotropic point emitter decays purely geometrically: since the acoustic energy in the spherical wavefront is fixed and the surface area of these wavefronts grows as r2, where r is the distance from the emitter, the sound intensity must fall off as 1/r2. The typical fundamental frequency produced by the wingbeats of a male midge in our experiments is roughly 575 Hz [35], corresponding to a wavelength of about 60 cm. Given the typical size of a swarm (diameters of roughly 20 cm in our experiments) and nearest-neighbor distance (about 4 − 7 cm [4]), midges in a swarm are therefore in the near-field regime of the acoustic field of their neighbors. In refs. [37, 38], the decay of the pressure field due to the wing-beat of a fly was measured, and it was found that both in the near-field and far-field the decay follows a 1/r 4 behavior. This results in a decay of the intensity as 1/r2, which is the form we use in our model. We note that due to interference effects between the incoherent sources, the acoustic field decays roughly as a Gaussian for length scales larger than the wavelength, i.e. & 60 cm; this size is, however, much larger than the typical swarms we have studied. Next, we make the hypothesis that an individual midge accelerates towards a neighbor via an effective "force" that is proportional to the sound intensity. Given the estimates above, this means that the force between a pair of midges i and j separated by a distance rij = ~ri − ~rj will scale as 1/r2 ij, just as the gravitational attraction between a pair of point masses would. At present, we must treat this choice purely as an ansatz, as the details of the form of any pairwise interactions between midges is very difficult to access experimentally [5, 36]. However, the assumption the midge response to acoustic signals is an acceleration towards the sound source is the simplest choice one can make. Choosing the response to be at the velocity level would be somewhat unnatural, since velocity cannot be directly controlled by the insects: changes to the velocity must come from forces applied by the insect, and therefore accelerations. And strong (albeit indirect) experimental support for this assumption comes from the observation of a net linear restoring force acting towards the swarm center (Fig. 1b). The only form of binary interactions that gives this linear restoring force towards the swarm center is an inverse-square force relation. For many animals, the perception of sound is not fixed, but rather adapts to the total sound intensity so that acoustic sensitivity drops when there is strong background noise. This is a common feature of biological sensory organs, preventing their damage and saturation. We thus make a second ansatz: that in general the midges' acoustic perception adapts to the overall sound level, and that specifically it follows the fold-change detection mechanism [39], which is ubiquitous in nature. In that case, the effective force on midge i due to midge j is given by ~F i ef f = CXj rij 1 ~ri − ~rj2(cid:18) R−2 R−2 ad ad +Pk ~ri − ~rk−2(cid:19) , (1) where rij is the unit vector pointing from midge i to midge j, C is a constant with dimensions of mass·length3/time2, and Rad is the length scale over which adaptivity occurs. In other words, when a single midge is closer than Rad the sound it emits is strong enough that the receiving midge needs to adapt its sensitivity to reduce the perceived signal. Beyond this distance there is no need for such adaptivity for the sound of a single midge. Equation (1) constitutes the core of our "adaptive gravity" model (AGM) for the acoustic interactions of the midges. We note that this model assumes that the midges can sense both the intensity and the direction of the sound produced by others; it is thought, however, that the specialized Johnston's organs of male swarming insects are indeed able to do so [40]. We also note that we are making the simplifying assumption that each midge is identical; although this assumption is certainly not fully accurate, it should allow us to make reasonable mean-field predictions. With the assumption of adaptivity, the force felt by each midge is inherently many-body and cannot be written as a sum of two-body interactions (Eqs. (3) and (4)) due to the sum over all the midges that appears in the denominator of the adaptivity factor (Eq. (1)). Thus, in this formulation, every midge feels a force that contains global, long-range information about the swarm, but this force cannot be parsed to distinguish the effects of any single neighbor. Thus, in this AGM the force that binds individual midges to the swarm is truly an emergent, group-level property that arises naturally from within the swarm without any appeal to external effects. To build intuition for the behavior of this model, let us consider two limits. For rij ≫ √N Rad (that is, when the distance between a pair of midges far exceeds the range of adaptivity, and N is the number of midges in the swarm), the effective force reduces to a purely gravitational interaction and becomes ~F i ef f,g → CXj rij 1 ~ri − ~rj2 . (2) In the opposite limit, when rij < √N Rad, the adaptive nature of the acoustic sensitivity becomes dominant. In that case, the adaptivity simply reduces to a rescaling of the sound perceived by each midge by the total buzzing noise amplitude, and the effective force becomes ~F i ef f,a → ad ·Pj rij C R2 Ntot 1 ~ri−~rj2 , (3) where the total buzzing noise amplitude at ~ri is Ntot =Pj(~ri − ~rj)−2. In pure gravity, the potential is additive, and the principle of superposition applies. Due to adaptivity, however, this property is lost in our model. That is, the effective potential felt by a midge due to many other midges is not the sum of two-body interactions using Eq. (A3). This can be seen by considering many interacting midges. The effective force felt by midge i due to the others (indices j) is given in Eq. (1) which is not equal to the sum over two-body 5 Figure 1. Mean-field effective forces. a. Calculated mean effective force acting on a midge within a spherical swarm as a function of the radial position r. The solid line shows the force due to adaptive gravity (Eq. (1)) for a swarm of uniform density and radius Rs, compared to the case of pure gravity (dashed line). When the density has a Gaussian profile (with spatial variance Rs/2, Eqs. (8)-(10)), the adaptive-gravity interactions give rise to the force shown with the dotted line. b. Measured mean acceleration as a function of position for laboratory swarms with different numbers of midges (shown with different colors), showing the roughly linear behavior near the swarm center. forces (see Eq. (A1) in the Appendix), which would be ~F i ef f,2 = CXj rij 1 R−2 ad ~ri − ~rj2 R−2 ad + ~ri − ~rj−2 . (4) Unlike in pure gravity, the forces on midge i due to others are not additive and the superposition principle does not apply, since the total buzzing noise term does not depend on direction. As a consequence, there are no conservation laws in such a system (except mass conservation), and the sum of forces felt by all the midges within an isolated swarm need not vanish, as it must in regular gravity. Thus, in this model the center of mass of the swarm can experience accelerations; so, even though the AGM naturally leads to swarm cohesion, one may need to posit external effects to prevent drift of the swarm as a whole. IV. RESULTS Effective spring constants: Spherical swarms. Gauss's law for gravity states that the gravitational flux through a closed surface is proportional to the enclosed mass [41]. In our analogy, each midge has an effective unit "mass," and therefore Gauss's law for the force in the "pure gravity" regime (Eq. (2)) is Z∂V ~Fef f · d ~A = −4 π C ZV ρ(~r)d3r, (5) where V is a three-dimensional volume, ∂V is its boundary, d ~A is a surface element, and ρ(~r) is the density of midges. We begin with a spherical swarm of uniform density ρ and radius Rs = hri. The characteristic value of the total S, where N is the number of midges. Thus, when RS ≫ √N Rad buzzing noise intensity at the origin is Ntot ∼ N / R2 we are in the pure gravity regime. In this case, from the analog of Gauss's law (Eq. (5)), the force is restoring and linear with respect to the distance ~r of a midge from the center of the swarm (Fig. 1a), and is given by ~Fef f = − 4 π C ρ 3 ~r. (6) Since this force is harmonic (that is, restoring and linear in ~r), we can characterize its strength with an effective "spring constant" K = 4 π C ρ/3. We stress that this behavior is unique for rij /r2 ij interactions, assuming that the motion arises only from interactions between the midges. Previously, we found that the average acceleration of midges 6 Figure 2. Effective spring constants in the horizontal directions (Kx and Ky) and the vertical direction (Kz) as a function of the average swarm radius Rs, plotted on logarithmic axes. The black circles denote the raw data for each swarm, the red circles show binned averages, and the dashed lines denote the R−1 scaling predicted by the AGM (Eq. (7)). We also plot the R−2 scaling predicted for cylindrical swarms (regular gravity, Eq. (A7)), which seems to fit the behavior of larger swarms. Note that in the vertical z-direction the data is more scattered, which may be due to Earth's gravity. s s in laboratory swarms also has this harmonic form [4], providing support for our model. However, in these laboratory swarms, the spring constants were found to depend on the swarm size Rs (Fig. 1(b)), unlike in pure gravity. For swarms with large numbers of individuals, however, our model enters its adaptive regime, where RS < √N Rad. In this regime, the net force is still linear and restoring; but due to the adaptive terms in Eq. (1), the spring constant ad Rs)−1. This result K will depend on the swarm size Rs. To leading order in r/Rs, the model predicts that K ∝ (R2 is derived in the Appendix (Eqs. (A1)-(A3)), and also follows from Eq. (3) using simple dimensional analysis, since Xj R2 ad r2 ij  −1 → R2 ad Z Rs 0 ij!−1 d3r r2 ∼(cid:0)R2 ad Rs(cid:1)−1 . (7) When we examine the experimental data for Kx and Ky (where x and y are in the plane and z is vertical), we find good agreement with the model prediction that K ∝ R−1 (Fig. 2a,b). This agreement is a consequence of the roughly constant density in swarms of different sizes (except for small swarms of fewer than ∼ 10 midges [31]), and gives a lower bound on Rad & 45mm since the adaptive regime applies to the smallest swarms. For Kz we find a decrease that is faster than predicted (Fig. 2c), as discussed further below. s We note that away from the swarm center the adaptive-gravity interaction gives rise to a restoring force that deviates from the form of pure gravity even for a uniform density swarm (Fig. 1a). Thus, we also calculated the force for a swarm with a Gaussian density profile, as was observed in experiments [4](Fig. 1a), and find that it is roughly linear over the entire swarm size, but saturates at large radii. The calculation of the adaptive force near the swarm center, for a Gaussian density profile, is as follows. We take a Gaussian density profile with width σs, so that the density in cylindrical coordinates is given by The gravitational force at z0 is then ρ(r, z) = exp (− r2+z2 2 σ2 s 2 σ3 (2 π) S 3 ) . Fef f,g(z0) = 2 πZ ∞ −∞ dz′Z ∞ 0 r′dr′ρ(r′, z′) z′ − z0 [r′2 + (z′ − z0)2] , 3 2 and the total buzzing noise is Ntot(z0) = 2 πZ ∞ −∞ dz′Z ∞ 0 ρ(r′, z′) r′dr′ r′2 + (z′ − z0)2 . (8) (9) (10) The integrals were solved numerically using M athematica 9.0, and were used to plot the dotted line in Fig. 1a. To conclude this part, we find that the accelerations of midges near the swarm center follow the linear relation expected from gravity-like interactions. Furthermore, the effective spring constant decreases with swarm size, exactly as predicted by adaptivity. The effects of non-spherical swarms are dealt with next. 7 Figure 3. (a) Observed average inertia eigenvalue ratio I1/I3 as a function of the swarm size Rs (blue circles: raw data for each swarm, red circles: binned average). For smaller swarms, the ratio is ∼ 1 which is the spherical limit, while for larger swarms this ratio is larger than 1 due to the elongation of the swarm in the z-direction (I3 > I1, Fig. 4a). (b) Calculated spring constant ratio K1/K3 for a prolate, axisymmetric swarm, using Eq. (21), as a function of the aspect ratio p ≡ a/c (solid line). For small p the behavior is linear, as given in Eq. (22). A. Effective spring constants: Ellipsoidal swarms. In the measured swarms, the effective spring constant in the vertical (z) direction is consistently smaller than those in the horizontal (x, y) directions [4]; additionally, it is also observed to decrease faster with swarm size than is predicted by our AGM for spherical swarms (Fig. 2c). For real swarms, the z direction differs from the x and y directions in several ways. First, along this direction midges are affected by the earth's gravitational pull. Additionally, swarms tend to form over visual features on the ground [31], which breaks the isotropic symmetry. Empirically, all these differences tend to cause larger swarms to elongate along the z axis [4, 31] (Fig. 3a). As we calculate below (and show in Fig. 3b), for swarms that are elongated along the z-axis, our model predicts that the effective spring constant in the x, y-plane (K1,2) is larger than in the z-direction (K3). We therefore attribute the observed smaller spring constant in the z-direction for larger swarms (Fig. 2) to the elongation of the swarms along the vertical axis. Furthermore, we can calculate the scaling of K3 with swarm size in the limit of a highly elongated (cylindrical) swarm, such that it has a fixed radius R in the xy-plane and a variable length L ≫ R along the z-axis. In this limit we find the scaling K3 ∝ R−2 (Eq. (A7)), as denoted in Fig. 2c. Note that in this limit, we are beyond the perfect adaptivity regime, and the scaling result for K3 is identical to that of pure gravity. s In Fig. 4a we show the shape of a typical elongated swarm. We treat the swarm shape using an ellipsoidal approximation to refine the analysis of the effective spring constants along the different directions. We assume that the swarm is an ellipsoid with semi-axes a, b, and c, where c < b < a (see Fig. 4a), along the x, y, z-axes. The effective spring constants are then given by (see Appendix, Eqs. (A1)-(A31)) 0 K1 = π a b c ρZ ∞ K2 = π a b c ρZ ∞ K3 = π a b c ρZ ∞ 0 0 dv dv (c2 + v)pβ(v) (b2 + v)pβ(v) (a2 + v)pβ(v) dv , , , (11) (12) (13) where β(v) ≡ (a2 + v)(b2 + v)(c2 + v) and K1 > K2 > K3 since c < b < a. Eqs. (11) -- (13) relate the effective forces in the swarm to its overall shape. The measured values of the spring constants and shapes of the swarms are summarized in Table 1. We characterize the shapes by the ratios of the moments of inertia-tensor eigenvalues η1 = I1/I2 and η2 = I1/I3. As part of our ellipsoid approximation, we assume that the inertia eigenvectors are oriented along the principal axes of the ellipsoid and that each inertia tensor eigenvalue corresponds to one of the axes. Let us assume 8 Figure 4. Swarm shape. a. Example of the shape of a laboratory swarm of N = 7 midges, which is elongated along the vertical (z) direction. Also shown is the ellipsoid that approximates the swarm shape, which by construction has the same ratios of inertia eigenvalues. b. The ratio of the effective spring constants Kx,y/Kz as a function of the swarm radius Rs, using the data in Table 1. Measured values are shown in blue, and those calculated from the model are shown in purple. that I1 > I2 > I3, without loss of generality. Then and I1 = I2 = I3 = 4 π 15 4 π 15 4 π 15 ρ a b c(cid:0)a2 + b2(cid:1) , ρ a b c(cid:0)a2 + c2(cid:1) , ρ a b c(cid:0)b2 + c2(cid:1) , η1 ≡ η2 ≡ I1 I2 I1 I3 = = a2 + b2 a2 + c2 , a2 + b2 b2 + c2 . From Eqs. (17, 18), one can express the parameters of the ellipsoid as a function of η1 and η2: b2 c2 = a2 c2 = η1 + (η1 − 1) η2 η1 + η2 − η1 η2 η1 − (η1 + 1) η2 η1 (η2 − 1) − η2 , , (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) and then the ratios K1/K2 and K1/K3 can be obtained from Eqs. (11)-(13). Note that in this analysis (Table 1) the direction of each Ki can be different, as they are defined by their relative strength so that K1 > K2 > K3. In all cases, however, the smallest effective spring constant is in the z direction (K3 = Kz), since we always observe that swarms are stretched in the vertical direction (Fig. 3). The ellipsoid parameters can be expressed in terms of the ratios of the inertia-tensor eigenvalues (Eqs. (14)-(20)), thereby relating the effective spring constant ratios K1/K2 and K1/K3 to the measured shape. We plot these ratios for both measured swarms and for the model in Fig. 4b. For smaller swarms, we find good agreement between the theoretical and measured values, where the discrepancies are primarily due to misalignment of the inertia-tensor eigenvectors with the principal axes of the ellipsoid. For the largest swarms, however, there is a significant deviation between the two. In those cases, the ellipsoidal approximation may not be valid, as we sometimes observed a tendency for these large swarms to split into a main body and satellite swarm and thus violate the assumptions of the model. In the case of a prolate axisymmetric ellipsoid b = c < a, we have K2 = K3 and from Eqs. (11)-(13) we get K1 K3 = Z ∞ 0 2,Z ∞ 0 dv dv (1 + v)2 (p2 + v) 1 (1 + v) (p2 + v) = 3 2 p(cid:16)p − p3 +pp2 − 1 cosh−1 p(cid:17) 2(cid:16)p2 − 1 − ppp2 − 1 cosh−1 p(cid:17) , (21) TABLE I. Experimental data for the dependence of the mean swarm shape (given by the inertia eigenvalues I1, I2, I3) and effective spring constants along the principle directions, on the swarm size given by the average radius Rs (binned averages). 9 Rs(mm) K1(1/sec2) K2(1/sec2) K3(1/sec2) η1 = I1/I2 η2 = I1/I3 43.22 52.58 58.40 63.97 70.77 76.53 81.59 88.15 98.62 108.89 120.99 15.83 12.33 10.62 10.12 9.09 8.83 7.36 6.65 5.94 6.94 4.82 14.72 11.06 9.50 10.06 7.98 7.60 6,55 6.11 5.49 6.34 4.62 11.80 8.34 7.17 5.83 4.84 5.33 3.31 3.10 3.05 4.56 3.15 1.38 1.27 1.37 1.26 1.32 1.25 1.40 1.26 1.43 1.64 1.57 1.81 1.70 1.68 1.61 1.77 1.54 1.98 1.62 1.74 2.07 2.06 where p ≡ a/c. For small deviations from spherical symmetry p = 1 + ǫ, ǫ ≪ 1 we have K1 K3 = 1 + 6 5 ǫ + O(ǫ2). (22) This result is shown in Fig. 3b. To summarize the results of this part, our AGM explains why the elongation of the swarms along the vertical axis gives rise to lower effective spring constant that is observed in this direction, as well as to the different scaling with the swarm size (Fig. 2). B. The virial relation. Despite the fact that adaptivity prevents us from formulating many conservation laws, we can still develop an analog to the virial theorem, based on mass conservation. We can define analogous kinetic and potential energies, and write a conservation law that relates them in case of stationarity. For this purpose we follow here Chandrasekhar [42] and ideas that are used in galactic dynamics (see for instance [43]) to derive the virial equations for an ideal self-gravitating fluid described in terms of density ρ(~r, t) and an isotropic pressure p(~r, t). The virial equations that we derive here are equations of the second order, since they relate second-order moments. There are equations of higher order as well. Later we will show how this derivation is related to the midge swarms. We assume that, in addition to pressure gradients, the only fields that act on the fluid are the internal self- gravitational field of the fluid ~g(in)(~r) and the external gravity field in the z direction, given by Then the hydrodynamic equation governing the motion of the fluid is given by ~g(ext) = −g z. where vi(~r, t) is the velocity of the fluid, ρ dvi dt = − ∂p ∂ri + ρ gi(~r), d dt = ∂ ∂t + vj ∂ ∂rj is the total time derivative (typically called the material derivative in fluid mechanics) and gi(~r) = g(in) i (~r) − gδiz. (23) (24) (25) In order to obtain the second order virial equations we multiply Eq. (24) by rj and integrate over the entire volume V . Integration of the term on the left hand side of Eq. (24) gives ZV ρ rj dvi dt d3~r =ZV ρ(cid:20) d dt (rj vi) − vj vi(cid:21) d3~r = d dt(cid:18)ZV ρ vi rj d3~r(cid:19) − 2 Tij, (26) where we use integration by parts (assuming that the fluid is concentrated in a bounded region of space), and Π is the total internal pressure of the fluid. The last term of Eq. (24) gives us a "potential energy" term: Collecting the terms together we get d dt(cid:18)ZV We can write Eq. (31) in a form similar to Newton's second law by introducing the moment of inertia tensor ρ rjgi(~r)d3~r. Wij =ZV ρ vi rj d3~r(cid:19) = 2 Tij + Wij + δijΠ. Iij =ZV ρ ri rjd3~r, 10 (27) (28) (29) (30) (31) (32) (33) where is the kinetic energy tensor. The last equality of Eq. (26) is a direct consequence of mass conservation, namely The same procedure with the first term on the right hand side of Eq. (24) gives d ρ vivj d3~r, Tij =ZV dt(cid:18)ZV ρ(~r, t)d3~r(cid:19) = 0. d3~r = δijZV ∂p ∂ri p d3~r ≡ δijΠ, ZV rj and since the tensors on the right hand side of Eq. (31) are symmetric we get 1 2 d2 Iij dt2 = 2 Tij + Wij + δij Π. When the system is stationary the moment of inertia does not change over time, and we arrive at the tensor form of the virial theorem: In order to apply the tensor virial equations presented above to the midge swarms, we will have to write its discrete analogues for N particles with equal (unit) masses. The moment of inertia tensor is now 2 Tij + Wij + δijΠ = 0. (34) where the bar denotes an average value per midge. Its derivative with respect to time can give us an indication for deviations of the system from stationarity, namely ¯I ij ≡ 1 N nrj ri n, NXn=1 (35) ¯M ij ≡ d ¯I ij dt = 1 2 N NXn=1(cid:0)ri nvj n + vi nrj n(cid:1) . (36) We use upper indices for the quantities that are defined with discrete summation. In Fig. 5 we show the values of ¯M ij taken for swarms of different sizes. Out of 126 measured swarms, we consider in this section binned data from 69 swarms that consisted of five midges or more, since for swarms with too few midges the average is meaningless. In addition we take time averages of the quantities over roughly one minute, so that the swarm is approximately in a steady state. The average values of the different components of ¯M ij are small compared to the typical angular momentum, which is two orders of magnitude larger. We therefore conclude that the midge swarms are stationary, and we therefore expect that the virial relation (Eq. (34)) should hold. Deviations from stationarity might occur due to influx or outflux of midges (negligible) or irreversible processes. The small increase in the values of ¯M zz and s 2 m c 2 0 1 0.06 0.04 0.02 0.00 -0.02 -0.04 M xx M yy M zz ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae s 2 m c 2 0 1 70 80 90 100 110 120 0.06 0.04 0.02 0.00 -0.02 -0.04 M xy M xz M yz ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae 11 ae ae ae ae ae ae 70 80 90 100 110 120 Rsmm Rsmm Figure 5. The six components of the tensor ¯M ij (Eq. (36)) that captures deviations from stationarity, as a function of the swarm size Rs ¯M yz for large swarms might be an indication for such an irreversible process, such as fragmentation as a result of the elongation along the vertical direction. Given the stationarity that we have found in the swarms, we now test the validity of the virial relation (Eq. (34)), using its discrete analogue. The mean kinetic energy tensor of a midge in the swarm is and ¯T ij ≡ 1 2 N nvj vi n, NXn=1 ¯W ij ≡ 1 2 N NXn=1 ri nF j n + F i nrj n is its "potential energy" tensor. The discrete virial equation is therefore 2 ¯T ij + ¯W ij + δij ¯Π = 0, (37) (38) (39) where ¯Π is the average pressure on a midge. This pressure term represents the effect of the mutual repulsion when the midges arrive too close to each other. It is easier to interpret and check the trace of the tensorial equation (39), namely the scalar form of the virial equation 2 ¯T + ¯W + 3 ¯Π = 0. (40) Here ¯T is the mean total kinetic energy of a midge, ¯W is its mean "potential energy", and ¯Π is the mean isotropic pressure on a midge. In Fig. 6 we show the measured ¯T and − ¯W /2 for different swarm sizes, when integrating over all the midges in the swarm. We can see that they are approximately constant as functions of Rs and their mean values are h ¯Ti = (3.42 ± 0.08) · 102 h− ¯W /2i = (2.80 ± 0.08) · 102 cm2/s2, cm2/s2. Therefore, according to Eq. (40), the difference between the two gives the mean pressure in the swarm: ¯Π = −(0.41 ± 0.07) · 102cm2/s2. (41) (42) In order to confirm that the identification of the mean pressure is correct, we consider each diagonal component of Eq. (39) separately as is shown in Fig. 7. From the mean values we get that 2 ¯T xx + ¯W xx = (0.42 ± 0.03) · 102cm2/s2, 2 ¯T yy + ¯W yy = (0.46 ± 0.04) · 102cm2/s2, 2 ¯T zz + ¯W zz = (0.38 ± 0.03) · 102cm2/s2. (43) 12 ae à ae ae ae à ae à ae ae ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae 2 s 2 m c 2 0 1 2 W - , T 5 4 3 2 1 0 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 Rs mm Figure 6. The mean kinetic energy ¯T (red) and half of the mean potential energy − ¯W /2 (blue) as a function of the swarm size Rs (Eq. (40)). Since these values are roughly equal it gives us a good confirmation for the isotropic origin of the pressure term in the virial relation. Note that the observation that ¯W is independent of the swarm size when calculated over the observed density profile [4] of the whole swarm is in agreement with a calculation done using regular gravity [44]. In addition we see from Fig. 7 that the mean values of kinetic and potential energies, which are related to the movement in the z direction, are significantly lower than the x and y directions. This is a result of the external gravitational force in this direction that enters the equations (see Eq. (25)). From the point of view of the midge, it seems that it is more beneficial to respond to the effective pull of neighboring midges, rather than waste energy moving up and down against gravity (which holds no information regarding location within the swarm). ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae à ae ae ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae 2 s 2 m c 2 0 1 2 x x W - , x x T 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae 2 s 2 m c 2 0 1 2 y y W - , y y T 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 2 s 2 m c 2 0 1 2 z z W - , z z T 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae ae à à ae ae ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 Rs mm Rs mm Rs mm Figure 7. The diagonal components of the kinetic ¯T ii (red) and potential − ¯W ii/2 (blue) energy tensors. The off-diagonal components of the tensors T ij and W ij are roughly null (compared to the diagonal ones) as we show in Fig. 8. This is expected for a system without dissipation, which maintains stationarity. Note that on the "microscopic" level of each midge, this system is obviously dissipative and out of equilibrium as the midge consumes chemical energy to power its flight. However, we find that on the coarse-grained scale of equivalent particles and forces, the system is effectively dissipation-less. So far, we have not considered the adaptive nature of the interactions. Let us assume a uniform density spherical swarm and first calculate the dependence on Rs without adaptivity. In order to calculate the behavior of the potential energy with Rs, we consider again the continuous version of the mean potential energy ¯W = 3Xk=1Z ρ(~r) rk (Fad)k d3~r,Z ρ(~r)d3~r, (44) where rk is the k-th component of the vector ~r. ae ae à ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae 2 s 2 m c 2 0 1 2 z x W - , z x T 0.4 0.2 0.0 -0.2 -0.4 ae ae à ae à à ae ae ae ae ae ae à ae ae ae ae à à ae ae ae ae ae ae ae à ae à ae ae ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae à ae 2 s 2 m c 2 0 1 2 z y W - , z y T 0.4 0.2 0.0 -0.2 -0.4 ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae à à à à ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae 13 ae ae à ae à ae ae ae ae à ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae ae 2 s 2 m c 2 0 1 2 y x W - , y x T 0.4 0.2 0.0 -0.2 -0.4 ae ae à ae ae ae à ae ae à à ae ae ae ae ae ae ae à ae 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 Rs mm Rs mm Rs mm Figure 8. The off-diagonal components of kinetic ¯T ij (red) and potential − ¯W ij/2 (blue) energy tensors. In the case of a uniform spherical symmetric swarm we have where ¯W = Z r (Fad)r d3~r(cid:30) V, V = 4 π R3 s 3 is the volume of the spherical swarm. For a linear restoring force of the form where K is a positive constant, we get (Fad)r = −K r ¯W = − 3 5 K R2 s. In the case of gravitational interaction without adaptivity (Eq. (A1)), the effective spring constant is and then we get a quadratic dependence on Rs: K = 4 3 π ρ C, ¯W = − 4 5 π ρ C R2 s. The force with the adaptive correction is obtained by substituting Eq. (A2) into Eq. (3): Fef f (r) = − 3 R2 ad [2 Rs r − (R2 4 C r2 Rs+r(cid:17)] s − r2) ln(cid:16) Rs−r . Substitution into Eq. (45) gives: ¯W = − 4 C Rs ad Z 1 0 R2 x5 dx 2 x + (x2 − 1) ln(cid:16) 1−x 1+x(cid:17) ∼ −0.3 C R2 ad Rs where x ≡ r/Rs. Thus, for adaptive gravity in the purely adaptive regime, the potential energy behaves as ¯W ∝ Rs. (45) (46) (47) (48) (49) (50) (51) (52) We now compare this result to the potential energy contribution of the midges near the center of the swarm, where we expect to find the strongest effect of adaptivity. When we include all the midges of the swarm, the adaptivity is not significant since the midges with large radius (r > Rs) and low density dominate the contribution to the total potential energy. For this purpose we calculated the potential and kinetic energies of the same swarms (more than 14 five midges) but this time the summation was carried out only up to an upper cutoff (Rs and Rs/2). Near the center of the swarm the density is roughly constant and high, so that the adaptive calculation of Eqs. (44)-(52) should apply. The results are presented in Fig. 9. The mean kinetic energy is similar to the previous one (Fig. 6), i.e. independent of Rs, except for some under-sampling of the fastest midges: h ¯Ti(r<Rs) = (3.07 ± 0.17) · 102 cm2/s2. The potential energy is not constant and it is increasing as a function of Rs. In Fig. 9b we show that as the center of the swarm is approached (i.e. r is constrained to smaller values), the increase of ¯W with Rs approaches a linear behavior, as we predict in Eq. (52). Note that this is very different from the quadratic behavior for regular gravity (Eq. (49)). This observation therefore constitutes an additional independent and strong source of support for our adaptive-gravity form of the interactions within the midge swarm. The virial relation also allows us to estimate the effect of the swarm size on the mean distance of closest approach between two midges, which was found to decrease for increasing swarm size. This relation is given in the Appendix (Eqs. (A1)-(A8), Fig. A4). 2 s 2 m c 2 0 1 2 W - , T 5 4 3 2 1 0 ae à ae ae à à ae à ae à ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae à ae ae ae ae à à ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae à ae ae ae ae à ae ae ae 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 Rs mm a 1.0 ae ae ae ae ae ae à à à à à 2 W - g o L 0.5 0.0 -0.5 ì ì 4.2 4.3 ì ì ì 4.4 ae à ae à à ae ae à ae à ì ì ì ì ì 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8 LogRs b Figure 9. (a) The mean kinetic ¯T (red) and potential − ¯W /2 (blue, constrained for r < Rs/2, Rs from bottom to top) energies as a function of Rs. (b) Log-Log plot for the potential energy in the center of the swarm with a linear fit, constrained for r < Rs/2, Rs, ∞ (yellow, purple and blue respectively). The power-law slopes are (yellow and purple respectively): 1.16 ± 0.12, 0.71 ± 0.05. C. Particle-based simulations. So far, we have demonstrated that the mean-field predictions of the AGM are in good agreement with the exper- imental results. To explore the AGM further, we performed molecular dynamics-type, agent-based simulations. To focus on the effects of the proposed adaptive-gravity interactions, we did not include in the simulation any explicit noise terms. Thus, the motion of each midge arises purely from their mutual interactions. However, to maintain numerical stability and cohesion of the swarm, it was necessary to augment the basic AGM (Eq. (1)) in three ways. First, we added a short-range repulsion between midges. This repulsion prevents the fragmentation of the swarm into small groups (such as pairs or triplets) that can become effectively isolated from the rest of the swarm due to adaptivity-induced screening (Eq. (A1), Fig. A5); additionally, we previously found experimental evidence for this kind of short-range repulsion in real swarms [5]. With this repulsion, the effective force in Eq. (1) becomes ~F i ef f = CXj brij r2 ij [1 − 2 exp(−(rij /Rr)2](cid:18) R−2 R−2 ad ad +Pk ~ri − ~rk−2(cid:19) . (53) To prevent runaway midges and to be physically realistic, we also imposed a maximum midge velocity vmax. If the midge velocity exceeds this value, we re-scale it as And finally, we added an overall confining force to prevent the swarm from drifting in space, as discussed above. This force is significant only far from the swarm center, and is intended to model the attraction to ground-based ~vnew = ~vvmax/v. (54) 12 Rmarker (ri/Rmarker)11, ~F i marker = −bri 15 (55) visual features that localize natural swarms [31]. It is given by where the marker size is set by Rmarker = 1.5Rad. We do not, however, impose any differences between the vertical direction and the in-plane directions, and so our simulated swarms are statistically isotropic in space. The initial conditions in the simulations are as follows. The spatial coordinates for each midge are expressed in spherical coordinates r, θ, and ϕ, and are initially random variables uniformly chosen between [0,Rmarker], [0,π] and [0,2π], respectively. The initial velocities are all zero. We then update the locations and velocities of each of the particles in time by solving the (Newton's) equations of motion of the particles (that is, ~vi = ~F i marker) using Runge-Kutta integration. Note that, unlike in real life and unlike in most models, the midges in these simulations do not have any intrinsic self-propelled motion; rather, their motion arises purely due to interactions, and can itself be viewed as an emergent property of the swarm. ef f + ~F i A sample trajectory of a single midge from a simulated swarm of N = 50 midges, is shown in Fig. 10a, which qualitatively resembled an observed trajectory (Fig. 10b). The simulated mean acceleration of a midge towards the swarm center as a function of the distance from the center is shown in Fig. 10c. We recover the linear behavior near the swarm center, as expected, while the forces saturate near the swarm edge due to the Gaussian density profile of the swarm (Fig. 1b). The slopes near the center define the effective spring constants, and are found to decrease with the number of midges, just as they do in the experiments. In Fig. 10d, we plot the distribution of midge accelerations, and find that it displays the same qualitative features found in the experiments [4]: the distributions are close to Gaussian for very small accelerations, but show heavy, exponential tails for large accelerations. And just as in the experiments, we find that these distributions are largely independent of the swarm size. We also compared the velocity distributions from the simulations (Fig. 10e) as a function of the swarm size, and again found the same trend observed in the experiments [4]: as the swarm size increases, the velocity distributions also develop a long exponential tail. This behavior can be quantified by calculating the excess kurtosis of the x-component velocity distribution as a function of the swarm size (Fig. 10f), which follows the same qualitative behavior seen in experiments [31]. For very small swarm sizes, the excess kurtosis is slightly negative (meaning that the tails of the velocity distribution are slightly sub-Gaussian), and becomes positive for larger swarms. Let us note that in these simulations we did not fit any parameters in an aim to reproduce the experimental observations quantitatively. Rather, we focus here on exploring the qualitative features that arise due to the adaptive- gravity interactions. It is quite satisfying that the distinctly non-Gaussian distributions of the accelerations (Fig. 10d) and of the velocity (Fig. 10e,f) already appear within our simple model, as well as the overall dependence of various features on swarm size. We anticipate that a more detailed model that includes, for example, the stochastic motion of an individual midge in isolation [31] or the earth's gravitational field may be able to capture the mean-field behavior of the swarms quantitatively as well. V. DISCUSSION We have presented here a new model of collective behavior in insect swarms that is based on the way that midges are thought to sense their environment, i.e. through acoustic signals. The AGM we have constructed introduces features that are not typically considered in models of collective motion, including long-range interactions and a sensitivity to the global properties of the group (through adaptivity). As we have shown, these features combine to produce group cohesion as a natural emergent property. Basic assumptions of the model, such as the precise relation between the received sound and the force produced by the midge await future direct experimentation, by, for example, studying external acoustic perturbations of swarms [35]. However, by comparing the predictions of the model with detailed statistical data extracted from real insect swarms measured in the laboratory, we have demonstrated that our model is able to capture not just the cohesion of swarms but also many of their many-body dynamical properties. The excellent agreement between the AGM and the observed behavior of both the spatial profile of the average forces within the swarm (Figs. 2,4) and the virial relation (Fig. 9), gives strong support to the model, and to its two main long-range (gravity-like) 1/r2 interactions and an adaptive response that renormalizes the effective forces features: according to the local noise amplitude. To conclude, this model opens the door for further tests of the large-scale behavior and stability of swarms. Intriguingly, the success of the adaptive-gravity approach raises the question of whether some of the well known phenomena that occur in self-gravitating systems, such as the Jeans instability or gravitational collapse [45, 46], can occur in this biological system as well. This will be probed in future experiments, using acoustic perturbations of the swarm [35]. From the more general physics point of view, we introduce here a new class of "adaptive" interactions, which have novel physical features as well as apply to other biological systems -- for example in the context of chemical 16 Figure 10. Comparison of the adaptive-gravity simulations to experimental observations. (a) A sample simulated trajectory from a swarm of N = 50 midges, as compared with (b) an observed trajectory in a swarm of N = 25 midges [31]. (c) Simulated mean acceleration along the x-axis as a function of position for swarms of various sizes (N = 15, 25, 40, 90, from top to bottom). The top right inset shows the simulated linear behavior near the swarm center, and the dependence of the slope on the swarm size (different colors) is similar to the observed behavior shown in Fig. 1a. (d) Observed acceleration distribution (left panel, [4]), compared to the simulation results (right panel). Both display highly non-Gaussian tails. (e) Observed x-component velocity distribution (left panel, [4]), compared to the simulation results (right panel). Both show that small swarms have a roughly Gaussian velocity distribution, but large swarms develop heavy tails. This tendency is quantified in f, where the excess kurtosis is plotted as a function of swarm size, and both observations (left panel, [31]) and simulations (right panel) indicate a negative excess kurtosis for small swarms and a positive kurtosis (due to the roughly exponential tails in the distributions) for large swarms. All the simulations were carried out using Rad = 10, Rr = 0.3Rad, Rmarker = 1.5Rad, and vmax = 1. sensing, chemotaxis-driven interactions between swarming cells (see for example [47]). This work opens a new class of physical systems with adaptive interactions, whose properties may be very different from their non-adaptive analogs. APPENDIX Appendix A: Adaptive-gravity potential between two midges Let us consider two interacting midges. In this case the effective force (Eq. (1)) felt by one midge due to a second can be written as (taking C = 1) ~Fef f = r12 1 ~r1 − ~r22A(~r1 − ~r2) (A1) where r12 = (~r1 − ~r2)/~r1 − ~r2 is the unit vector connecting the two midges and the adaptivity function is given by A(~r1 − ~r2) = R−2 ad R−2 ad + ~r1 − ~r2−2 . (A2) 17 Rad is a measure of the maximal distance between midges over which the adaptivity of the midge acoustic sensing can function. Beyond this distance, the sound reaching the midge is so weak that the hearing sensitivity (that is, the effective gain provided by the adaptivity) of the midge reaches its maximal value. See Fig. A1. Note that as the midges come closer than Rad, the effective force approaches a constant, while in pure gravity the force between two bodies increases without bound as they come together, leading to collapse. For r12 ≥ Rad the effective force approaches the long-range gravity behavior of 1/r2 12. We can integrate this force and calculate the effective midge-midge potential to be Uef f (r12) = 1 Rad (arctan [r12/Rad] − π/2) . (A3) See Fig. A2. Unlike in gravity, where the potential energy diverges when the two particles overlap, due to adaptivity the potential approaches a finite value with a "cusp" shape, so that it is linear in r12. For r12 ≥ Rad the effective potential approaches the long-range gravity behavior of 1/r12. Figure A1. Magnitude of the effective force Fef f calculated according to Eqs. (A1) and (A2) using Rad = 10 (blue line). The red line denotes pure gravity without adaptivity, i.e. for A = 1. Figure A2. Effective potential Uef f calculated from Eq. (A3) using Rad = 10 (blue line). The red line denotes pure gravity without adaptivity, i.e. for A = 1. Appendix B: Explicit Calculation of the Effective Force on a Midge Let us compute explicitly the adaptive-gravitational field at a point inside a spherical swarm with radius Rs and uniform density ρ, according to Eq. (3). We will use cylindrical coordinates (r, z, ϕ) and calculate the field at (r = 0, 18 z (r',z') A z0 r Figure A3. The cylindrical coordinates (r, z) (and ϕ) that we use for the calculation of the effective gravitational field at a point A in a uniform-density spherical swarm. z = z0) without loss of generality (the point A in Fig. A3). The symmetry of the problem implies that the field is along the z axis. The contribution of a point at (r′, z′) to the gravitational force at (0, z0) is and the angle is 1 r′2 + (z′ − z0)2 , Hence the gravitational force at z0 is cos α = . z′ − z0 pr′2 + (z′ − z0)2 dz′Z √R2 s−z ′2 r′dr′ 0 z′ − z0 [r′2 + (z′ − z0)2] 3 2 Fef f,g(z0) = 2 π C ρZ Rs −Rs 4 π ρ C = − 3 which agrees with the result obtained from Gauss's law in Eq. (5). The normalization factor, which is given by the summation of the absolute values of the contributions to the point (0, z0), reads z0, (A1) Ntot(z0) = 2 π ρZ Rs −Rs = πρ[2Rs − To leading order in z0, we have dz′Z √R2 0 (R2 s − z2 0) z0 s−z ′2 r′dr′ r′2 + (z′ − z0)2 Rs + z0(cid:19)]. ln(cid:18) Rs − z0 Ntot(z0) = 4πρRs + O(z2 0), (A2) (A3) which confirms the 1/Rs leading behavior of the effective spring constant in the purely adaptive regime (Eq. (3)). We find that the profile of Fef f (z) has the following behavior (Fig. 1a): The force is approximately linear in the distance out to at least half of the swarm size, and only grows faster than linear close to the edge. Note that we have assumed a uniform distribution here. Since the real distribution is close to Gaussian (see Fig. (2) of [4]) and decreases significantly when r ∼ Rs, we do not expect to see such an increase in the force near the edges in real swarms. Appendix C: Limit of cylindrical swarm In the case of an elongated swarm in the form of a cylinder with radius R and length 2 L, the gravitational force at z0 is Fef f,g(z0) = 2 π C ρZ L dz′Z R = −4 π ρ C (cid:18)1 − −L 0 r′dr′ z′ − z0 3 2 [r′2 + (z′ − z0)2] √L2 + R2(cid:19) z0 + O(cid:18) z3 L3(cid:19) , L 0 (A1) When we have a very long cylinder L ≫ R, The normalization factor in this case is Fef f,g(z0) ∼ −2 π C ρ R2 L2 z0 Ntot(z0) = 2 π ρZ L dz′Z R = 4 R π ρ arctan(cid:18) L −L 0 r′dr′ r′2 + (z′ − z0)2 R(cid:19) + 2 L π ρ ln(cid:18)1 + R2 L2(cid:19) + O(cid:16) z0 L(cid:17) , and for a long cylinder From Eqs. (A2) and (A4) we get the effective spring constant in the vertical direction as Ntot(z0) ∼ 2 π2 ρ R. Kz ∼ C R π L2 The radius of a long cylindrical swarm is Then in terms of the swarm radius Rs = hri = 2 πR L −L dzR R 0 2 π R2 L √r2 + z2 r dr L 2 ∼ + O(cid:0)L−1(cid:1) Kz ∝ R−2 s . 19 (A2) (A3) (A4) (A5) (A6) (A7) Appendix D: Calculation of the effective spring constants in the ellipsoidal approximation Here we show how to derive Eqs. (11)-(13). We start from a computation of the gravitational potential inside an ellipsoid, and from it we will derive the effective "spring constants." The derivation here follows Ref. [48]. Let us start from an ellipsoid centered at the origin such that x2 a2 + y2 b2 + z2 c2 = 1, (A1) whose semi-axes are a, b, and c, and where we assume c < b < a without loss of generality. Let us now consider a family of ellipsoids x2 a2 + y2 b2 + z2 c2 = u2 (A2) for 0 < u < 1. Our goal is to find the gravitational potential of an ellipsoid (A1) with a uniform mass density ρ. For this purpose, we will calculate the potential due to an ellipsoidal shell between u and u + du and then sum over all shells for 0 < u < 1. It is convenient to introduce ellipsoidal coordinates (λ, µ, ν) defined by x2 = y2 = z2 = (a2 u2 + λ)(a2 u2 + µ)(a2 u2 + ν) u4 (a2 − b2)(a2 − c2) (b2 u2 + λ)(b2 u2 + µ)(b2 u2 + ν) u4 (b2 − a2)(b2 − c2) (c2 u2 + λ)(b2 u2 + µ)(b2 u2 + ν) , , , u4 (c2 − a2)(c2 − b2) where the ellipsoidal coordinates (λ, µ, ν) have the following ranges: λ > −c2 u2 > µ > −b2 u2 > ν > −a2u2. (A3) (A4) (A5) (A6) Note that in the definition of ellipsoidal coordinates that we use, λ, µ, ν depend on u since we define them for the ellipsoidal shell (A2). Surfaces of constant λ are ellipsoids: x2 a2 u2 + λ + y2 b2 u2 + λ + z2 c2 u2 + λ = 1. (A7) Thus, λ is the equivalent of the radial coordinate for ellipsoids. The original shell surface is λ(u) = 0 and λ(u) > 0 covers the region outside the shell (A2). A natural assumption (based on the ellipsoidal symmetry) is that the potential depends only on λ and not on µ or ν. In this case, the Laplace equation outside the shell (for φ(λ, u), λ > 0) is 20 where 4pβ(λ, u) (λ − µ)(λ − ν) ∂ ∂λ(cid:18)pβ(λ, u) ∂φ ∂λ(cid:19) = 0, β(λ, u) ≡ (a2 u2 + λ)(b2 u2 + λ)(c2 u2 + λ). The solution of this equation can be written as φ(λ, u) = −Z ∞ λ(u) , u2 D ds pβ(s, u) where D is a constant that will be related to the surface mass density of the shell, and the u2 factor is due to the fact that the total charge scales as u2. Using Gauss's law for the shell, (A8) (A9) (A10) (A11) (A12) (A13) (A14) (A15) (A16) (A17) (A18) we get − ∇φ · nλλ=0 = 4 π σ, where gλλ comes from the metric in ellipsoidal coordinates: = 4 π σ, ∂φ − 1 √gλλ ∂λ(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)λ=0 ∂λ(cid:19)2 ∂λ(cid:19)2 +(cid:18) ∂z +(cid:18) ∂y gλλ =(cid:18) ∂x ∂λ(cid:19)2 = (λ − µ)(λ − ν) 4 β(λ, u) , so that On the other hand, the surface mass density can be expressed as σ = ρ dh, D = 2 πσ√µν. where dh is the local thickness of the shell. In order to find the thickness dh, let us start with a calculation of the distance from the origin to a point (x, y, z) on the surface of the ellipsoid shell. The normal to the point (x, y, z) is and the distance of the origin to a point (x, y, z) on the surface of the ellipsoid shell is then a4 + y2 b4 + z2 c4 , z a2 , y b2 , n =(cid:16) x c2(cid:17) /r x2 h = (x, y, z) · n = u2/r x2 a4 + y2 b4 + z2 c4 = u a b c √µν . Therefore the local thickness is dh = du a b c √µν , which allows us to express the surface density σ of the shell in terms of ρ as Substituting into the expression for D (Eq. (A14)), we get σ = ρ a b c √µν du. The potential of such a shell is thus D = 2 π a b c ρ du. φ(λ, u)du = −2 π a b c ρ u2 duZ ∞ λ(u) Then the gravitational potential of an ellipsoid is obtained by integration over such shells, ds . pβ(s, u) φ(λ, u)du. 0 U (λ) =Z 1 U (v) = −2 π a b c ρZ 1 0 uZ ∞ v(u) du, dt pβ(t) Let us change variables to v ≡ λ/u2, t ≡ s/u2, so that where β(t) ≡ (a2 + t)(b2 + t)(c2 + t). Since we are interested in the force inside the ellipsoid, let us consider the potential field at a point (x0, y0, z0) inside the ellipsoid. It corresponds to a shell at u0 (0 < u0 < 1): x2 0 a2 + y2 0 b2 + z2 0 c2 = u2 0. (A24) For shells inside this shell (u < u0) the point (x0, y0, z0) is outside and therefore v = v(u) is the lower bound of the integral. Shells outside this shell (u > u0) contribute the same value as on the shell surface (since u0 is inside the shells) and then the lower bound is v = 0. Therefore 21 (A19) (A20) (A21) (A22) (A23) (A25) (A26) (A28) (A29) (A30) Integration by parts of the first integral gives dt pβ(t)!# . dv du du. U (v) = −2 π a b c ρ"Z u0 0 u Z ∞ Z u0 0 0 dt dt u0 0 dt v(u) v(u) v(u) u2 u du(cid:19) Z ∞ pβ(t)! du +(cid:18)Z 1 u Z ∞ pβ(t)#u0 pβ(t)! du =" u2 +Z u0 2 Z ∞ 2pβ(v) u Z ∞ pβ(t)! du = 2Z ∞ 2 Z ∞ Z u0 pβ(t) − pβ(v)! dv. 0 1 − u2 U (v) = −π a b c ρZ ∞ u2 dv pβ(v) u2 0 v(u) dt 1 0 0 0 0 dt Notice that v(u0) = 0 and v(0) = ∞. Hence, Together with the second integral in (A25) we get From (A7) we get the following relation between u and v: Then the potential is u2 = x2 a2 + v + y2 b2 + v + z2 c2 + v . U (x, y, z) = −π a b c ρZ ∞ 0 (cid:18)1 − x2 a2 + v − y2 b2 + v − z2 c2 + v(cid:19) dv 1 pβ(v) . (A27) for a point (x, y, z) inside the ellipsoid. Effectively, we have a harmonic potential with different "spring constants" in each direction. Taking the derivative of Eq. (A30) with respect to the coordinates x,y and z gives us Eqs. (11)-(13), respectively. To calculate the correction due to adaptivity to leading order, we have to write the expression for the total buzzing noise (A2) for the ellipsoidal case. The only change is in the limits of integration and the fact that there is no longer any cylindrical symmetry. Here we integrate over an ellipsoid and get 22 r′dr′ dz′Z Rel 0 0 0 Ntot(z0)=2 ρZ 2 π dϕZ c =2 √2 ρ a b cZ 2 π 0 r′2 + (z′ − z0)2 arccoth(cid:18) √2 a b √Q(a,b,c,ϕ)(cid:19) pQ(a, b, c, ϕ) dϕ (A31) + O(z2 0 ), Q(a, b, c, ϕ) ≡ 2 a2 b2 − (a2 + b2)c2 + (a2 − b2)c2 cos 2 ϕ, R2 el ≡ 1 − z ′2 a2 + sin2 ϕ b2 c2 cos2 ϕ . where and It turns out that this expression is symmetric under the interchange of a, b and c, and therefore there is no change to the ratios of the effective spring constants due to the asymmetries of the ellipsoid in the leading-order correction. Appendix E: Mean closest approach distance. It was observed that the mean nearest-neighbor distance dnn between midges decreases with increasing swarm size [4, 7, 31] (Fig. A4). We now demonstrate that this decrease can be explained to arise from the adaptive nature of the interactions. Due to the adaptive interactions (Eq. (1)), when two midges happen by chance to come very close to each other, they may form a bound pair that is effectively screened from the rest of the swarm. In order to study the closest approach of midges in the swarm, let us consider the interaction of such a pair in the background provided by the rest. We assume that the separation between the two midges is small compared to their distance to the rest of the swarm, and thus that the interactions with the rest of the swarm will be negligible except for a contribution to the adaptivity factor in Eq. (1), so that the effective force felt by one member of the pair is ~Fef f,pair ≃ C r12 1 ~r1 − ~r22(cid:18) ad + Ibackground + ~r1 − ~r2−2(cid:19) . R−2 ad R−2 (A1) Ibackground is the sum over all the midges in the background. Near the center of the swarm this "background noise" takes, according to Eq. (A3), the form where we assume spherical symmetry (radius Rs) and a constant density ρ of the swarm. Integrating this force we can calculate the effective two-body potential to be (see Eq. (A3)) Ibackground = 4 π ρ Rs, (A2) (A3) (A4) Upair = where rpair ≡ ~r1 − ~r2 and C γ Rad(cid:18)arctan(cid:18) γ rpair Rad (cid:19) − π 2(cid:19) , γ ≡q1 + 4 π ρ R2 ad Rs. We thus effectively have two-body motion under the influence of a mutual central force. Note that in the case of two bodies, additivity of the effective force is valid and as a result we can use all the conservation laws of a central force (namely energy and angular momentum). Therefore this two-body system can be reduced to an equivalent one-dimensional motion in the effective potential 23 Uef f,12(rpair) = β r2 pair + C γ Rad(cid:18)arctan(cid:18) γ rpair Rad (cid:19) − π 2(cid:19) , (A5) where β is a positive constant [49] and the first term is the "centrifugal barrier." Let us assume that the system of the two midges has an energy E. Then the minimal distance dnn is a turning point of the effective potential, given by the solution of the equation For very short distances rpair ≪ Rad, it is determined by the "centrifugal barrier", so that Uef f,12(dnn) = E. β nn − d2 π C = E. 2 γ Rad For swarms where Rs < √N Rad, we can expand dnn to obtain 2 γ Rad! 1 dnn = E + π C β 2 ≃r β E . (A6) (A7) (A8) For the central part of spherical swarms the mean energy of a midge depends on the swarm size (Eq. (52)), as E = ¯T + ¯W, and ¯W ∝ Rs (Fig. 9). We therefore expect the closest approach distance to decrease with increasing swarm size. The experimental data shown in Fig. A4 for the center of the swarms (where our adaptivity calculation is applicable), indicates a very weak decrease with swarm size, consistent with this prediction. n n d g o L ae aeaeae aeae ae ae ae 5.0 4.5 4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 ae ae ae aeae ae ae ae aeae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae aeae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae ae 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 Rs Figure A4. Measured mean minimal midge separation dnn in different swarms (with at least four midges) [31], plotted against the mean swarm radius Rs (blue circles: raw data, red circles: binned averages). We observe a decrease in the average minimal separation with increasing swarm size. The AGM predicts a shallow decrease, as indicated by the dashed line (Eq. (A8)), which is in good agreement with the binned data (using the observed energies for ¯T , ¯W from Fig. 9, and treating β as the only fit parameter). Appendix F: Tendency for swarm fragmentation due to the adaptive "screening" As discussed above, two nearby midges may form a bound pair due to screening by adaptivity. When the pair of midges are very close to each other, we can have that 1 ~ri − ~rnn2 ≫ 1 R2 ad + Ibackground (A1) 24 Figure A5. (a) Traces of a simulated swarm with N = 50 midges, demonstrating that without close-range repulsion there is a tendency to form very tight pairs that leave the swarm. (b) As in (a) but with short-range repulsion that prevents the formation of bound pairs, but no "marker" potential. (c) Traces of simulated trajectories of a swarm with N = 5 midges, demonstrating the need for the "marker" potential and short-range repulsion to prevent midges from leaving the swarm. which means that the interactions with all the other midges is reduced immensely by the huge factor of Eq. (1) in the denominator. The resulting behavior is shown in Fig. A5. Including the "marker" potential and short-range repulsion (Eqs. (53)-(55)) prevents midges from leaving the swarm (Fig. A5b,c), while otherwise pairs may form and shoot out of the swarm (Fig. A5a,b). Occasionally, larger number of midges (such as triplets) also form such fragments. [1] J. K. Parrish and L. Edelstein-Keshet, Science 284, 99 (1999). [2] G. Gerisch, Annu. Rev. Physiol. 44, 535 (1982). [3] K. Drescher, K. C. Leptos, I. Tuval, T. Ishikawa, T. J. Pedley, and R. E. Goldstein, Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 168101 (2009). [4] D. H. Kelley and N. T. Ouellette, Sci. Rep. 3, 1073 (2013). [5] J. G. Puckett, D. H. Kelley, and N. T. Ouellette, Sci. Rep. 4, 4766 (2014). [6] A. Attanasi, A. Cavagna, L. Del Castillo, I. Giardina, S. Melillo, L. Parisi, O. Pohl, B. Rossaro, E. Shen, E. Silvestri, and M. Viale, PLoS Comput. Biol. 10, e1003697 (2014). [7] A. Attanasi, A. Cavagna, L. Del Castillo, I. Giardina, S. Melillo, L. Parisi, O. Pohl, B. Rossaro, E. Shen, E. Silvestri, and M. Viale, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 238102 (2014). [8] M. Ballerini, N. Cabibbo, R. Candelier, A. Cavagna, E. Cisbani, I. Giardina, A. Orlandi, G. Parisi, A. Procaccini, M. Viale, and V. Zdravkovic, Anim. Behav. 76, 201 (2008). [9] M. Nagy, Z. ´Akos, D. Biro, and T. Vicsek, Nature 464, 890 (2010). [10] Y. Katz, K. Tunstrom, C. C. Ioannou, C. Huepe, and I. D. Couzin, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108, 18720 (2011). 25 [11] J. E. Herbert-Read, A. Perna, R. P. Mann, T. M. Schaerf, D. J. T. Sumpter, and A. J. W. Ward, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108, 18726 (2011). [12] A. Berdahl, C. J. Torney, C. C. Ioannou, J. J. Faria, and I. D. Couzin, Science 339, 574 (2013). [13] W. D. Hamilton, J. Theor. Biol. 31, 295 (1971). [14] J. A. Downes, Annu. Rev. Entomol. 14, 271 (1969). [15] S. J. Portugal, T. Y. Hubel, J. Fritz, S. Heese, D. Trobe, B. Voelkl, S. Hailes, A. M. Wilson, and J. R. Usherwood, Nature 505, 399 (2014). [16] A. Okubo, Adv. Biophys. 22, 1 (1986). [17] A. J. Bernoff and C. M. Topaz, SIAM Review 55, 709 (2013). [18] T. Vicsek, A. Czir´ok, E. Ben-Jacob, I. Cohen, and O. Shochet, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1226 (1995). [19] I. D. Couzin, J. Krause, R. James, G. D. Ruxton, and N. R. Franks, J. Theor. Biol. 218, 1 (2002). [20] N. T. Ouellette, Pramana-J. Phys. 84, 353 (2015). [21] N. W. F. Bode, A. J. Wood, and D. W. Franks, Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 65, 117 (2011). [22] M. Ballerini, N. Cabibbo, R. Candelier, A. Cavagna, E. Cisbani, I. Giardina, V. Lecomte, A. Orlandi, G. Parisi, A. Pro- caccini, M. Viale, and V. Zdravkovic, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 105, 1232 (2008). [23] F. Ginelli and H. Chat´e, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 168103 (2010). [24] J. Buhl, D. J. T. Sumpter, I. D. Couzin, J. J. Hale, E. Despland, E. R. Miller, and S. J. Simpson, Science 312, 1402 (2006). [25] R. Lukeman, Y.-X. Li, and L. Edelstein-Keshet, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 107, 12576 (2010). [26] S. J. Guy, S. Curtis, M. C. Lin, and D. Manocha, Phys. Rev. E 85, 016110 (2012). [27] H. Chat´e and M. A. Munoz, Physics 7, 120 (2014). [28] M. V. Federova and R. D. Zhantiev, Entomol. Rev. 89, 896 (2009). [29] J. Sueur, E. J. Tuck, and D. Robert, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 118, 530 (2005). [30] D. J. G. Pearce, A. M. Miller, G. Rowlands, and M. S. Turner, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 111, 10422 (2014). [31] J. G. Puckett and N. T. Ouellette, Journal of The Royal Society Interface 11, 20140710 (2014). [32] R. Y. Tsai, IEEE J. Robotic. Autom. RA-3, 323 (1987). [33] N. T. Ouellette, H. Xu, and E. Bodenschatz, Exp. Fluids 40, 301 (2006). [34] H. Xu, Meas. Sci. Technol. 19, 075105 (2008). [35] R. Ni, J. G. Puckett, E. R. Dufresne, and N. T. Ouellette, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 118104 (2015). [36] J. G. Puckett, R. Ni, and N. T. Ouellette, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 258103 (2015). [37] M. Lighthill, in Proc. Roy. Soc. A, Vol. 267 (1962) pp. 147 -- 182. [38] H. Bennet-Clark, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 353, 407 (1998). [39] O. Shoval, L. Goentoro, Y. Hart, A. Mayo, E. Sontag, and U. Alon, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 107, 15995 (2010). [40] L. J. Cator, K. R. Ng'Habi, R. R. Hoy, and L. C. Harrington, Behav. Ecol. 21, 1033 (2010). [41] W. Greiner, Classical mechanics: point particles and relativity (Springer, 2004). [42] S. Chandrasekhar, Ellipsoidal figures of equilibrium, Silliman Foundati Lect. (Yale Univ. Press, New Haven, CT, 1969). [43] J. Binney and S. Tremaine, Galactic dynamics (Princeton university press, 2011). [44] D. Gorbonos, R. Ni, J. G. Puckett, N. T. Ouellette, and N. Gov, work in progress (2015). [45] J. Jeans, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 82, 122 (1922). [46] J. Binney, Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics 20, 399 (1982). [47] T. Lammermann, P. V. Afonso, B. R. Angermann, J. M. Wang, W. Kastenmuller, C. A. Parent, and R. N. Germain, Nature 498, 371 (2013). [48] Based on: Wei Cai, "Appendix - Potential Field of a Uniformly Charged Ellipsoid," as part of the lecture notes to the course: "Theory and Applications of Elasticity," Department of Mechanical Engineering, Stanford University, CA 94305- 4040. http://micro.stanford.edu/∼caiwei/me340/A Ellipsoid Potential.pdf. [49] In the case of gravity we take β = l2 2 µ where l is the angular momentum and µ is the reduced mass of the system. Acknowledgements. N.S.G. and D.G. thank Sam Safran for useful discussion. J.G.P., R.N., and N.T.O. acknowl- edge support from the US Army Research Office under grant W911NF-13-1-0426. N.S.G. gratefully acknowledges funding from the ISF (Grant No. 580/12). This research is made possible in part by the generosity of the Harold Perlman Family.
1011.3051	1	1011	2010-11-12T21:10:36	Life around the scallop theorem	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "physics.flu-dyn" ]	Locomotion on small scales is dominated by the effects of viscous forces and, as a result, is subject to strong physical and mathematical constraints. Following Purcell's statement of the scallop theorem which delimitates the types of swimmer designs which are not effective on small scales, we review the different ways the constraints of the theorem can be escaped for locomotion purposes.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Life around the scallop theorem Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Eric Lauga∗ University of California San Diego, 9500 Gilman Drive, La Jolla CA 92093-0411, USA. (Dated: May 28, 2018) Locomotion on small scales is dominated by the effects of viscous forces and, as a result, is subject to strong physical and mathematical constraints. Following Purcell's statement of the scallop theorem which delimitates the types of swimmer designs which are not effective on small scales, we review the different ways the constraints of the theorem can be escaped for locomotion purposes. I. INTRODUCTION Swimming cells, such as bacteria (prokaryotes) or spermatozoa (eukaryotes), represent the prototypical example of active soft matter. They are active as they transform chemical energy (ATP for eukaryotes, ion flux for prokaryotes) into mechanical work [1] and, as a result, are able to continuously change shape and move in viscous environments [2]. As mechanical entities, cells belong to the world of soft matter, displaying complex rheological properties on a range of time and spatial scales and responding to external forcing in a time-dependent and nonlinear fashion [3]. In their micron-size environment, the fluid forces acting on swimming cells are dominated by the effect of viscous dissipation [4, 5]. Seminal papers in the 1950s laid the ground work for detailed investigations on the hydrodynamics of cell locomotion [6–9], with the main goal of predicting cell kinematics, energetics, the interactions with their environment, and the general importance of fluid forces in biological form and function [10–15]. In 1977, Purcell's influential paper "Life at low Reynolds number" put a somewhat different spin on a field which was already mature [16]. In it, Purcell brought to light the counter-intuitive physical and mathematical constraints arising from locomotion in an inertialess world. He demonstrated that for organisms moving in very viscous fluids, there exists a class of shape change that can never be used for locomotion, a result beautifully summarized under the name "scallop theorem", borrowing the name of such an organism - a hypothetical microscopic scallop - which could not locomote in the absence of inertia. In this short review, we look back at the scallop theorem, and pose the question: What are the basic ingredients necessary to design swimmers able to move on small scales? What are the different ways offered by physics to get around the constraints of the theorem? After stating the various assumptions for the theorem to be valid (§II), we show how non-reciprocal shape changes (§III), inertia (§IV), hydrodynamic interactions (§V), and coupling with the physical environment (§VI) can all be exploited to provide locomotion on small scales. II. THE SCALLOP THEOREM The scallop theorem has a relatively simple statement [16]. Consider a body changing shape in a time-periodic fashion. In the absence of inertia, the equations describing the motion of an incompressible Newtonian fluid are Stokes equations, which are linear and independent of time [4, 5]. In addition, in the absence of inertia, the swimmer remains perpetually force- and torque-free [15]. Purcell's scallop theorem can then be stated as follows. If the sequence of shapes displayed by the swimmer is identical to the sequence of shapes displayed when seen in reverse - so-called reciprocal motion - then the average position of the body cannot change over one period. Another manner to describe reciprocal motion is stated in Purcell's original paper as: ∗Electronic address: [email protected] 2 "... I change my body into a certain shape and then I go back to the original shape by going through the sequence in revere... So, if the animal tries to swim by a reciprocal motion, it can't go anywhere." Time is not explicitly mentioned in the theorem and in fact, because of the linearity and time-independence of the equations, the rate at which the sequence of shapes is being displayed is irrelevant [15]. In Purcell's own words, "Fast, or slow, it exactly retraces its trajectory, and it's back where it started." Physically, the absence of time in the equations of motion means there is no intrinsic time scale to the swimming problem, which prevents distinguishing between forward and backward in a reciprocal motion. Purcell's statements may appear simple, but are in fact far-reaching. They form the basis of a purely geometrical approach to cell locomotion [17–20] and have sparked considerable attention in the area of biolocomotion from the physics and soft matter community - so much so that "Life at low Reynolds number" is now the most cited paper in the field. The name for the theorem originates from the simplest kind of reciprocal swimmers, namely those deforming with a single degree of freedom, such as the hinge of a hypothetical micron-scale scallop. For any swimmer with a single geometrical degree of freedom, say θ(t), then by properties of Stokes equations, its swimming speed, u, necessarily scales as u ∼ θF (θ), which is always an exact derivative, and thus averages in time to zero hui = 0. Swimmers with only one degree of freedom can thus never swim on small scales. Strictly speaking, the scallop theorem is valid only with the following assumptions: a single swimmer displaying reciprocal motion in an infinite quiescent Newtonian fluid and in the absence of inertia and external body forces1. Examining each of these assumptions in detail suggests a way around the theorem and a design for a swimmer, which we now review. As in Purcell's original paper, we will focus only on swimming by shape change or motion and we will thus not consider chemical swimmers [21–24] or solid bodies powered by external fields [25]. III. NON-RECIPROCAL KINEMATICS A. Biological swimmers: waves The main message of Purcell's paper is that swimmers should change their shapes in a non-reciprocal fashion. The manner in which motion occurs should thus indicate a clear direction of time, which leads naturally to the occurrence of waves. Indeed, most of swimmings cells locomote by using traveling wave-like deformation of their bodies or appendages [10–15]. Swimming bacteria rotate one or more helical flagella using rotary motors embedded in the cell walls [38–40] leading to flagella kinematics akin to that of traveling helical waves, and thus propulsion [41–43] (Fig. 1a). Other types of bacteria swim using whole-body wave deformation propelled by flagella beneath the cell's outer membrane [44] or wave-like propagation of kinks in their shapes in the absence of flagella [45]. Spermatozoa and other singly flagellated eukaryotes swim using traveling waves [12] induced by molecular motors-driven internal sliding of polymeric filaments inside the flagellum [46–48] (Fig. 1b). The flagella kinematics can be planar [49], helical [43], or even doubly helical [50]. The many cilia covering some eukaryotes [51] also deform as so-called metachronal waves [52–54] (Fig. 1c). B. Synthetic swimmers Beyond the swimming methods displayed by biological swimmers, some simpler modes of non-reciprocal motion can be devised theoretically and in the lab. 1 The theorem is also valid in a confinement environment as long as the boundaries display no motion. 3 FIG. 1: Illustration of experimental and computational escapes from the scallop theorem. (a): E. coli bacterium with four helical flagella [26]; (b): Superimposed pictures of a swimming spermatozoon of Ciona intestinalis [27]; (c): Paramecium cell covered with short cilia [28]; (d): Macro-scale experimental realization of Purcell's three link swimmer [29]; (e): Micro-scale experimental realization of three-sphere swimmer using optical tweezers [30]; (f): Computations showing the locomotion of shape-changing vesicles [31]; (g): Microscopic realization of flexible swimming using elastic superparamagnetic filaments driven by an external magnetic field (the two images show the filament deforming at different times) [32]; (h): Locomotion of flexible Au/Ag/Ni nanowires swimmers driven by an external magnetic field [33]; (i): Experimental demonstration that a symmetric flapping wing can undergo unidirectional locomotion if the Reynolds number is above a critical value [34]; (j): Computations showing that a flexible, flapping wing with asymmetric actuation undergoes locomotion at all finite Reynolds number [35]; (k): Experimental measurement of the net flow and vorticity induced by a reciprocal flapper beneath a free surface [36]; (l): Computations for the net flow and vorticity induced by a small-amplitude reciprocal flapper in a polymeric fluid [37]. All images reproduced with permission; (a): from Turner, Ryu, and Berg, J. Bacteriol. 182, 2793 (2000), Copyright 2000 American Society for Microbiology; (b): from C. J. Brokaw, J. Exp. Biol. 43, 155 (1965), Copyright 1965 The Company of Biologists; (c): Copyright CNRS Phototh`eque / Anne Aubusson-Fleury; (e): from Leoni et al. Soft Matt. 5, 472 (2009), Copyright 2009 Royal Society of Chemistry; (f): from Evans, Spagnolie, and Lauga, Soft Matter 6, 1737 (2010), Copyright 2010 Royal Society of Chemistry; (g): from Dreyfus et al. Nature 437,862 (2005), Copyright 2005 Nature Publishing Group; (h): from Gao et al. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 132, 14403 (2010), Copyright 2010 American Chemical Society; (i): from Vandenberghe, Childress, and Zhang, Phys. Fluids 18, 014102 (2006), Copyright 2010 American Institute of Physics; (j): from Spagnolie et al., Phys. Fluids 22, 041903 (2010), Copyright 2010 American Institute of Physics; (k): from Trouilloud et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 048102 (2008), Copyright 2008 American Physical Society; (l): from Pak, Normand, and Lauga, Phys. Rev. E 81, 036312 (2010), Copyright 2010 American Physical Society. 1. Imposing non-reciprocal kinematics As shown by Purcell, swimmers with a single degree of freedom cannot move. One needs therefore at least two degrees of freedom and their prescribed variation in time should sweep a finite area in parameter space. In his original paper, Purcell proposed such a swimmer [16], namely an elongated body with two rotational hinges [55–57] (Fig. 1d). Subsequently, non-reciprocal swimmers of very simple shapes have been devised theoretically, including ones composed of three spheres [30, 58–61] (Fig. 1e), two volume-changing spheres [62], and two-orientation changing spheres [63] or ellispoids [64]. Beyond geometry, the two degrees of freedom could also be physical parameters, for example the volume and spontaneous curvature of a lipid vesicle [31] (Fig. 1f). Alternatively, the swimmer's shape and deformation change could be topologically equivalent to the inside-out rotation of a torus [65, 66] or tank-treading [67] for which periodicity is achieved by a continuous series of displacements tangent to the swimmer shape. Continuous normal flows in the form of fluid jets can also be used [68]. 4 2. Flexible swimmers: Non-reciprocal kinematics from reciprocal forcing A second class of simple swimmers can be designed for which a reciprocal actuation combined with flexibility or elasticity can lead to kinematics of shape change which are non-reciprocal, and thus to locomotion. The prototypical example of this class of swimmers is a flexible filament actuated periodically up and down at one end where it is clamped, and free on the other [69]. If the filament is rigid, its motion is reciprocal and cannot be used for propulsion. In contrast, if the filament is flexible and is actuated near the typical frequency at which viscous drag and elastic forces balance, its shape as it is actuated up (respectively down) is concave (respectively convex), leading to non-reciprocal kinematics and propagation of an elasto-hydrodynamic wave. Mathematically, the scallop theorem breaks down because time enters the problem through the viscous drag term in the equation for the filament shape (via a partial time-derivative), and thus a relevant time scale can be defined. The generation of propulsive force and locomotion using flexibility filaments has been the center of many theo- retical and computational investigations [69–72]. A macro-scale experiment confirmed the physical picture outlined above [73]. Related phenomena include elastic buckling instabilities [74–76] and shape transitions [77–79] for rotated elastic filaments. At the micro-scale, an experimental realization of a flexible swimmer was achieved using elastic superparamagnetic filaments [80] actuated by external magnetic fields and attached to a red blood cell (Fig. 1g) [32], prompting subsequent modeling efforts [81–84]. A similar implementation was achieved using a nanometric silver filament attached to an externally-driven ferromagnetic nickel head (Fig. 1h) [33]. In all these cases however, it is the presence of external torques (via external magnetic fields) that allows locomotion, and thus they do not represent true self-propelled motion. IV. INERTIA For the scallop theorem to be valid, all inertial terms in the equation of motion of the swimmer should be set to zero. Naturally, they cannot exactly disappear unless no motion occurs, and thus a fundamental question arises, namely how much inertia is needed to escape the constraints of the theorem? Is the scallop theorem valid only asymptotically, or does it stand as long as inertia is below a certain limit? These questions were first posed by Dudley and Childress [85] who studied the behavior of a mollusk able to use both reciprocal and non-reciprocal modes of locomotion, and who postulated that a finite amount of inertia was necessary for locomotion to be able to occur. Mathematically, three qualitatively different Reynolds numbers can be defined. Consider a swimmer of typical size L and density ρs undergoing reciprocal motion of amplitude A and frequency ω in a Newtonian fluid of density ρ and shear viscosity µ. Using a typical velocity scale U ∼ Aω, the natural Reynolds number for the reciprocal motion is given by Re = ρLAω/µ, and is the one corresponding to the nonlinear advection term in the Navier Stokes equations (for example, in water, Re ≈ 10−4 for E. coli while Re ≈ 10−2 for human spermatozoa). The oscillatory Reynolds number, corresponding to the linear unsteady Stokes term, is given by Reω = ρL2ω/µ. Finally, the Reynolds number based on the body inertia is Res = ρsL2ω/µ, sometimes called a Stokes number, which quantifies the typical ratio between the rate of change of the swimmer momentum and the magnitude of the viscous forces in the fluid. For small amount of inertia, the breakdown of the scallop theorem occurs either continuously or discontinuously with these Reynolds numbers depending on the geometrical symmetries in the reciprocal actuation. In the case of symmetric shapes - typically simple flappers - experiments and modeling demonstrated that a finite, order one, amount of inertia is necessary, indicating a discontinuous transition through an inertial hydrodynamic instability [34, 85–89] (Fig. 1i). As a difference, in the case of asymmetric shapes or actuation, the transition is continuous, with locomotion occurring either as some power of Re [90] or both Re and Reω (with Re/Reω constant) [35, 91] (Fig. 1j). Interestingly, for asymmetric shapes, a continuous transition with swimmer inertia was obtained in the absence of fluid inertia (Re = Reω = 0), with locomotion occurring as powers of Res [92]. 5 V. HYDRODYNAMIC INTERACTIONS The inertialess scallop envisioned by Purcell as the prototypical non-swimmer is isolated in the fluid. It turns out however that hydrodynamic interactions with other such non-swimmers, or more generally flexible entities, can be exploited to swim. Physically, as cells or other synthetic swimming devices do work on the surrounding fluid, they act as hydrodynamic disturbances on the otherwise-quiescent environment, thereby setting up flow fields which are in general dipolar [15]. In biology these flow fields have important consequence on the generation of collective modes of locomotion [93–97] and rheology at the whole-population level [98, 99]. Although a body undergoing reciprocal motion cannot swim, two bodies undergoing reciprocal motion with nontriv- ial phase differences are able to take advantage of the unsteady hydrodynamic flows they create to undergo nonzero collective and relative dynamics; there is thus no many-scallop theorem [100, 101]. As each reciprocal swimmer be- haves in general as an unsteady dipole, the collective effect arises from the time-rectification of such unsteadiness, and thus decays generically as 1/d3, where d is the typical swimmer-swimmer distance (or even faster if additional geometrical symmetries are present [100, 102]). Naturally, two reciprocal non-swimmers taken as a whole are not unlike a single non-reciprocal swimmer, although the qualitative details of their locomotion do differ [100]. Experimentally, this effect was demonstrated for hydrodynamic interactions between a rigid flapper, beating in a reciprocal fashion, and a flexible boundary (free surface). The rectification of the reciprocal flow by the free surface motion leads to flow and forces scaling quadratically with the applied flapping frequency, and the creation of a reciprocal pump [36] (Fig. 1k). The experimental application of these ideas to a collection of free-swimming bodies remains however to be confirmed. To generate reciprocal motion with nontrivial phase-differences, one possibility would be to use elastic field-responsive particles under a uniform AC forcing; particles with different relaxation times would respond to fields with different phases, and thus would be able to move collectively [100]. In the case of purely identical non-swimmers, two of them cannot swim, but three or more are able to move [102]. In that case, the phase differences in body kinematics are induced by hydrodynamic flows, leading to a slow 1/d7 effect [102]. VI. PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT In the scallop theorem, the assumption that locomotion takes place in a Newtonian environment is crucial, as it allows the inertialess equations of fluid motion to be linear and independent of time. A change of the mechanical and rheological properties of the fluid would however naturally lead to a different type of conclusion. Complex fluids are abundant in biology, and cell locomotion often takes place in strongly elastic polymeric fluids [103–105], which has been the focus of much recent work [106–111]. As the fluid becomes non-Newtonian, three different physical effects can potentially be exploited to generate small- scale locomotion [112, 113]. First, complex fluids possess in general rheological properties which are rate dependent. In particular, viscosities often display shear-thinning behavior, meaning they decrease with shear rates. In this type of fluid, and in contrast with the Newtonian case, the rate at which the reciprocal sequence of shapes is being displayed would matter, a result which could be used to design a reciprocal swimmer. This was recently demonstrated theoretically for bodies swimming using a reciprocal helical actuation at different rates in model polymeric fluids [109]. The second physical effect to be exploited is that of normal stress differences, which arise from the stretching by the flow of the microstructure suspended in the complex fluids. Normal stress differences scale quadratically with the applied shear [112] and remain thus identical under a reversal a time, allowing propulsion. Locomotion using normal stress differences was demonstrated theoretically for a three-dimensional body undergoing small-amplitude reciprocal motion at constant rate [110]. The generation of forces and flow by reciprocal flapping was also reported [37, 114] (Fig. 1l). The last physical effect to be exploited is that of stress relaxation. Even for small-amplitude motion and linearized dynamics, the simplest evolution equation for the stress in a polymeric fluid contains a memory term in the form of a partial time derivative times a relaxation time. Whether, even in the linear regime, stress relaxation can be taken advantage of for locomotion purposes is an intriguing, but yet unexplored, possibility. 6 VII. CONCLUSION In this short review, we have used Purcell's scallop theorem as a framework to lay out the basic physical principles behind the design of small-scale swimming devices. We have shown how non-reciprocal kinematics, inertia, hydrody- namic interactions, and the nature of surrounding environment can all be physically exploited to achieve small-scale propulsion. With advances in micro- and nano-fabrication, the discussion on the theorem can now move from that akin to a mathematical exercise to a true engineering challenge. As briefly mentioned in Ref. [13], there exists at least another class of body motion which always leads to zero locomotion in a Newtonian fluid, namely those for which the time-reversal of the motion is identical to its mirror- image (for example, the motion of a rod sweeping the envelope of a cone). The formal derivation of the complete class of non-swimming body kinematics would provide a new thrust in small-scale locomotion research by allowing novel opportunities to get around these mathematical constraints. Acknowledgements Discussions with Denis Bartolo are gratefully acknowledged. I thank B. Chan, A. E. Hosoi, A. Aubusson-Fleury and the CNRS Phototh`eque for providing me with the images reproduced in Fig. 1c and d, as well as the authors from Refs. [26, 27, 29–37] who gave us permission to reproduce their images. This work was supported in part by the US National Science Foundation through grant number CBET-0746285. [1] D. Bray, Cell Movements (Garland Publishing, New York, NY, 2000). [2] G. T. Yates, Am. Sci. 74, 358 (1986). [3] B. D. Hoffman and J. C. Crocker, Annu. Rev. Biomed. Eng. 11, 259 (2009). [4] J. Happel and H. Brenner, Low Reynolds Number Hydrodynamics (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1965). [5] S. Kim and J. S. Karilla, Microhydrodynamics: Principles and Selected Applications. (Butterworth-Heinemann, Boston, MA, 1991). [6] G. I. Taylor, Proc. Roy. Soc. A 209, 447 (1951). [7] G. I. Taylor, Proc. Roy. Soc. A 211, 225 (1952). [8] G. J. Hancock, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 217, 96 (1953). [9] J. Gray and G. J. Hancock, J. Exp. Biol. 32, 802 (1955). [10] J. Lighthill, Mathematical Biofluiddynamics (SIAM, Philadelphia, 1975). [11] J. Lighthill, SIAM Rev. 18, 161 (1976). [12] C. Brennen and H. Winet, Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. 9, 339 (1977). [13] S. Childress, Mechanics of Swimming and Flying (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge U.K., 1981). [14] L. J. Fauci and R. Dillon, Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. 38, 371 (2006). [15] E. Lauga and T. R. Powers, Rep. Prog. Phys. 72, 096601 (2009). [16] E. M. Purcell, Am. J. Phys. 45, 3 (1977). [17] A. Shapere and F. Wilczek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 58, 2051 (1987). [18] A. Shapere and F. Wilczek, J. Fluid Mech. 198, 557 (1989). [19] J. Koiller, K. Ehlers, and R. Montgomery, J. Nonlinear Sci. 6, 507 (1996). [20] E. Yariv, J. Fluid Mech. 550, 139 (2006). [21] W. F. Paxton, K. C. Kistler, C. C. Olmeda, A. Sen, S. K. S. Angelo, Y. Y. Cao, T. E. Mallouk, P. E. Lammert, and V. H. Crespi, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 126, 13424 (2004). [22] R. Golestanian, T. B. Liverpool, and A. Ajdari, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 220801 (2005). [23] J. R. Howse, R. A. L. Jones, A. J. Ryan, T. Gough, R. Vafabakhsh, and R. Golestanian, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 048102 7 (2007). [24] G. Ruckner and R. Kapral, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 150603 (2007). [25] S. J. Ebbens and J. R. Howse, Soft Matt. 6, 726 (2010). [26] L. Turner, W. S. Ryu, and H. C. Berg, J. Bacteriol. 182, 2793 (2000). [27] C. J. Brokaw, J. Exp. Biol. 43, 155 (1965). [28] CNRS phototh`eque, URL http://phototheque.cnrs.fr/. [29] B. Chan, Ph.D. thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA (2009). [30] M. Leoni, J. Kotar, B. Bassetti, P. Cicuta, and M. C. Lagomarsino, Soft Matt. 5, 472 (2009). [31] A. A. Evans, S. E. Spagnolie, and E. Lauga, Soft Matt. 6, 1737 (2010). [32] R. Dreyfus, J. Baudry, M. L. Roper, M. Fermigier, H. A. Stone, and J. Bibette, Nature 437, 862 (2005). [33] W. Gao, S. Sattayasamitsathit, K. M. Manesh, D. Weihs, and J. Wang, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 132, 14403 (2010). [34] N. Vandenberghe, S. Childress, and J. Zhang, Phys. Fluids 18, 014102 (2006). [35] S. Spagnolie, L. Moret, M. Shelley, and J. Zhang, Phys. Fluids 22, 041903 (2010). [36] R. Trouilloud, T. S. Yu, A. E. Hosoi, and E. Lauga, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 048102 (2008). [37] O. S. Pak, T. Normand, and E. Lauga, Phys. Rev. E 81, 036312 (2010). [38] R. M. Macnab, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 74, 221 (1977). [39] H. C. Berg, Phys. Today 53, 24 (2000). [40] H. C. Berg, E. coli in Motion (Springer-Verlag, New York, 2004). [41] A. T. Chwang and T. Y. Wu, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. B 178, 327 (1971). [42] W. Schreiner, J. Biomech. 4, 73 (1971). [43] J. J. L. Higdon, J. Fluid Mech. 94, 331 (1979). [44] S. F. Goldstein, N. W. Charon, and J. A. Kreiling, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 91, 3433 (1994). [45] J. W. Shaevitz, J. Y. Lee, and D. A. Fletcher, Cell 122, 941 (2005). [46] K. E. Summers and I. R. Gibbons, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 68, 3092 (1971). [47] C. J. Brokaw, Science 243, 1593 (1989). [48] S. Camalet and F. Julicher, New J. Phys. 2, 1 (2000). [49] J. J. L. Higdon, J. Fluid Mech. 90, 685 (1979). [50] M. Werner and L. W. Simmons, Biol. Rev. 83, 191 (2008). [51] J. R. Blake and M. A. Sleigh, Biol. Rev. Camb. Phil. Soc. 49, 85 (1974). [52] S. Gueron, K. Levit-Gurevich, N. Liron, and J. J. Blum, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94, 6001 (1997). [53] S. Gueron and K. Levit-Gurevich, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 96, 12240 (1999). [54] B. Guirao and J. F. Joanny, Biophys. J. 92, 1900 (2007). [55] L. E. Becker, S. A. Koehler, and H. A. Stone, J. Fluid Mech. 490, 15 (2003). [56] D. Tam and A. E. Hosoi, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 068105 (2007). [57] J. E. Avron and O. Raz, New J. Phys. 10, 063016 (2008). [58] A. Najafi and R. Golestanian, Phys. Rev. E 69, 062901 (2004). [59] A. Najafi and R. Golestanian, J. Phys. - Cond. Mat. 17, S1203 (2005). [60] R. Dreyfus, J. Baudry, and H. A. Stone, Europ. Phys. J. B 47, 161 (2005). [61] R. Golestanian, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 018103 (2010). [62] J. E. Avron, O. Kenneth, and D. H. Oaknin, New J. Phys. 7, 234 (2005). [63] A. Najafi and R. Zargar, Phys. Rev. E 81, 067301 (2010). [64] M. Iima and A. S. Mikhailov, Epl 85, 44001 (2009). [65] R. M. Thaokar, H. Schiessel, and I. M. Kulic, European Phys. J. B 60, 325 (2007). [66] A. M. Leshansky and O. Kenneth, Phys. Fluids 20, 063104 (2008). [67] A. M. Leshansky, O. Kenneth, O. Gat, and J. E. Avron, New J. Phys. 9, 126 (2007). [68] S. Spagnolie and E. Lauga, Phys. Fluids 22, 081902 (2010). 8 [69] C. H. Wiggins and R. E. Goldstein, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 3879 (1998). [70] C. P. Lowe, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London, Ser. B 358, 1543 (2003). [71] M. C. Lagomarsino, F. Capuani, and C. P. Lowe, J. Theor. Biol. 224, 215 (2003). [72] E. Lauga, Phys. Rev. E 75, 041916 (2007). [73] T. S. Yu, E. Lauga, and A. E. Hosoi, Phys. Fluids 18, 091701 (2006). [74] C. W. Wolgemuth, T. R. Powers, and R. E. Goldstein, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 1623 (2000). [75] S. Lim and C. S. Peskin, SIAM J. Sci. Comput. 25, 2066 (2004). [76] H. Wada and R. R. Netz, Europhys. Lett. 75, 645 (2006). [77] M. Manghi, X. Schlagberger, and R. R. Netz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 068101 (2006). [78] N. Coq, O. du Roure, J. Marthelot, D. Bartolo, and M. Fermigier, Phys. Fluids. 20, 051703 (2008). [79] B. Qian, T. R. Powers, and K. S. Breuer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 1, 078101 (2008). [80] A. Cebers, Curr. Opin. Colloid Int. Sci. 10, 167 (2005). [81] M. Roper, R. Dreyfus, J. Baudry, M. Fermigier, J. Bibette, and H. A. Stone, J. Fluid Mech. 554, 167 (2006). [82] E. Gauger and H. Stark, Phys. Rev. E 74, 021907 (2006). [83] E. E. Keaveny and M. R. Maxey, J. Fluid Mech. 598, 293 (2008). [84] M. Roper, R. Dreyfus, J. Baudry, M. Fermigier, J. Bibette, and H. A. Stone, Proc. Roy. Soc. A 464, 877 (2008). [85] S. Childress and R. Dudley, J. Fluid Mech. 498, 257 (2004). [86] N. Vandenberghe, J. Zhang, and S. Childress, J. Fluid Mech. 506, 147 (2004). [87] S. Alben and M. Shelley, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 102, 11163 (2005). [88] X. Y. Lu and Q. Liao, Phys. Fluids 18, 098104 (2006). [89] S. Childress, in Proceedings of the 2004 International Workshop on Mathematical Fluid Dynamics and Applications, edited by S.-I. S. J. R. Kweon, S.-C. Kim (2004), pp. 9–21. [90] E. Lauga, Phys. Fluids 19, 061703 (2007). [91] M. Roper, Ph.D. thesis, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA (2007). [92] D. Gonzalez-Rodriguez and E. Lauga, J. Phys. - Cond. Mat. 21, 204103 (2009). [93] N. H. Mendelson, A. Bourque, K. Wilkening, K. R. Anderson, and J. C. Watkins, J. Bacteriol. 181, 600 (1999). [94] X. L. Wu and A. Libchaber, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 3017 (2000). [95] C. Dombrowski, L. Cisneros, S. Chatkaew, R. E. Goldstein, and J. O. Kessler, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 098103 (2004). [96] L. H. Cisneros, R. Cortez, C. Dombrowski, R. E. Goldstein, and J. O. Kessler, Exp. Fluids 43, 737 (2007). [97] A. Sokolov, I. S. Aranson, J. O. Kessler, and R. E. Goldstein, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 158102 (2007). [98] A. Sokolov and I. S. Aranson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 148101 (2010). [99] S. Rafaı, L. Jibuti, and P. Peyla, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 098102 (2010). [100] E. Lauga and D. Bartolo, Phys. Rev. E 78, 030901 (2008). [101] G. P. Alexander and J. M. Yeomans, Euro. Phys. Lett. 83, 34006 (2008). [102] D. Bartolo and E. Lauga, Phys. Rev. E 81, 026312 (2010). [103] J. B. Shukla, B. R. P. Rao, and R. S. Parihar, J. Biomech. 11, 15 (1978). [104] D. F. Katz and S. A. Berger, Biorheol. 17, 169 (1980). [105] S. S. Suarez and X. B. Dai, Biol. Reprod. 46, 686 (1992). [106] E. Lauga, Phys. Fluids 19, 083104 (2007). [107] H. C. Fu, T. R. Powers, and H. C. Wolgemuth, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 258101 (2007). [108] H. C. Fu, C. W. Wolgemuth, and T. R. Powers, Phys. Rev. E 78, 041913 (2008). [109] H. C. Fu, C. W. Wolgemuth, and T. R. Powers, Phys. Fluids 21, 033102 (2009). [110] E. Lauga, Europhys. Lett. 86, 64001 (2009). [111] J. Teran, L. Fauci, and M. J. Shelley, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 038101 (2010). [112] R. B. Bird, R. C. Armstrong, and O. Hassager, Dynamics of Polymeric Liquids. Second Edition. Vol. 1: Fluid Mechanics. (Wiley-Interscience, New York, NY, 1987). [113] R. B. Bird, C. F. Curtiss, R. C. Armstrong, and O. Hassager, Dynamics of Polymeric Liquids. Second Edition. Vol. 2: Kinetic Theory. (Wiley-Interscience, New York, NY, 1987). [114] T. Normand and E. Lauga, Phys. Rev. E 78, 061907 (2008).
1604.00412	2	1604	2016-06-05T20:18:22	Stabilizing membrane domains antagonizes n-alcohol anesthesia	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.CB", "q-bio.NC" ]	Diverse molecules induce general anesthesia with potency strongly correlated both with their hydrophobicity and their effects on certain ion channels. We recently observed that several n-alcohol anesthetics inhibit heterogeneity in plasma membrane derived vesicles by lowering the critical temperature ($T_c$) for phase separation. Here we exploit conditions that stabilize membrane heterogeneity to further test the correlation between the anesthetic potency of n-alcohols and effects on $T_c$. First we show that hexadecanol acts oppositely to n-alcohol anesthetics on membrane mixing and antagonizes ethanol induced anesthesia in a tadpole behavioral assay. Second, we show that two previously described `intoxication reversers' raise $T_c$ and counter ethanol's effects in vesicles, mimicking the findings of previous electrophysiological and behavioral measurements. Third, we find that hydrostatic pressure, long known to reverse anesthesia, also raises $T_c$ in vesicles with a magnitude that counters the effect of butanol at relevant concentrations and pressures. Taken together, these results demonstrate that $\Delta T_c$ predicts anesthetic potency for n-alcohols better than hydrophobicity in a range of contexts, supporting a mechanistic role for membrane heterogeneity in general anesthesia.	physics.bio-ph	physics	000 Volume: 00 Month Year 1–20 1 Stabilizing membrane domains antagonizes n-alcohol anesthesia B.B. Machta, E. Gray, M. Nouri, N.L.C. McCarthy, E.M. Gray, A.L. Miller, N.J. Brooks and S.L. Veatch 6 1 0 2 n u J 5 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 2 v 2 1 4 0 0 . 4 0 6 1 : v i X r a © 2013 The Authors 0006-3495/08/09/2624/12 $2.00 2 ABSTRACT Diverse molecules induce general anesthesia with potency strongly correlated both with their hydrophobicity and their effects on certain ion channels. We recently observed that several n-alcohol anesthetics inhibit heterogeneity in plasma membrane derived vesicles by lowering the critical tem- perature (Tc) for phase separation. Here we exploit conditions that stabilize membrane heterogeneity to further test the correlation between the anesthetic potency of n-alcohols and effects on Tc. First we show that hexadecanol acts oppositely to n-alcohol anesthetics on membrane mixing and antag- onizes ethanol induced anesthesia in a tadpole behavioral assay. Second, we show that two previ- ously described 'intoxication reversers' raise Tc and counter ethanol's effects in vesicles, mimick- ing the findings of previous electrophysiological and behavioral measurements. Third, we find that hydrostatic pressure, long known to reverse anesthesia, also raises Tc in vesicles with a magnitude that counters the effect of butanol at relevant concentrations and pressures. Taken together, these results demonstrate that ∆Tc predicts anesthetic potency for n-alcohols better than hydrophobicity in a range of contexts, supporting a mechanistic role for membrane heterogeneity in general anesthesia. INTRODUCTION The potencies of many general anesthetics are roughly proportional to their oil:water partition coeffi- cient over more than five orders of magnitude in overall concentration (1). This Meyer-Overton correla- tion suggests membrane involvement, and anesthetics have been shown to decrease lipid chain ordering, lower the main chain melting temperature, and increase membrane spontaneous curvature, fluidity, and conductance (2–4). However, these effects are small (5) and often cannot account for those molecules which deviate from Meyer-Overton (6). Most recent attention focuses on the ion channels known to be most sensitive to these compounds (7), where extensive structural work (8–10) suggests that anesthetic effects are mediated by specific residues in hydrophobic, membrane spanning regions. High potency general anesthetics such as etomidate and barbiturates are more effective at potentiating channels and producing anesthesia than predicted from their hydrophobicity alone, and evidence is accumulating that these compounds bind directly and specifically to channels at the interface between subunits (11). Many researchers also favor a direct binding mechanism of anesthetic action for lower potency anesthetics, including the n-alcohol anesthetics investigated here (8). However, channels are proposed to contain more numerous binding sites for these compounds (11–13), each with low affinity, leaving open the possibility that these anesthetics interact with channels more as a solvent than as a ligand. 000 00(00) 1–20 3 Our understanding of the structure and function of the animal plasma membrane has grown dramat- ically since most membrane theories of anesthesia were put forward. It is now appreciated that animal plasma membranes have a thermodynamic tendency to separate into coexisting liquid domains, some- times referred to as 'lipid rafts' or 'lipid shells' (14, 15) and that this heterogeneity localizes and regulates ion channels, sometimes in a subtype specific manner (16). Much of this regulation likely arises from the membrane's unusual thermodynamic properties. Cholesterol containing membranes of purified lipids can support two distinct liquid phases (17), and giant plasma membrane vesicles (GPMVs) isolated from mammalian cell lines display analogous phase coexistence at low temperature (18). Remarkably, GPMVs are near the critical point of this transition (19), a non-generic region of phase space distinguished by large correlation times and large but finite domain sizes that requires fine tuning both composition and temperature in synthetic systems (20). We recently found (21) that incubating several general anesthetics with isolated GPMVs low- ered their critical temperatures (Tc) in a way that scales well with their anesthetic dose as pre- viously measured in tadpole loss of righting reflex (LRR) assays (22). While our assay mea- sures a change in Tc somewhat below growth temperature, we predict that at higher tempera- tures these treatments would destabilize sub-micron liquid domains both in vesicles and the intact plasma membranes from which they were derived. While suggestive, we wanted to rule out the possibility that our observed correlation is derivative of a more fundamental correlation of both ∆Tc and anesthetic potency with hydrophobicity. As a first step towards this, we demonstrated that two hydrophobic but non-anesthetic analogs of general anesthetics did not affect Tc at con- centrations where Meyer-Overton predicts they would (21). Here we explore a more direct chal- lenge to the connection between changes in Tc and anesthetic potency by investigating the anes- thetic effects of hydrophobic compounds and conditions that raise transition temperatures in GPMVs. MATERIALS AND METHODS Giant plasma membrane vesicle (GPMV) measurements: RBL-2H3 cells (23) were maintained in MEM media with 20% FBS and 0.1% Gentamycin at 37◦C in 5% CO2. XTC-2 cells (24) were maintained in L-15 Media diluted 1:1.5 with water for amphibian cells with 10% FBS, sodium bicarbonate (2.47 g/liter), pen strep (100 units/ml) at room temperature in 5% CO2. Freshly seeded cells were incubated in 000 00(00) 1–20 4 complete media for at least 18h at the growth temperature indicated prior to GPMV isolation. All cul- ture reagents were purchased from Fisher Scientific (Hampton, New Hampshire). Other reagents were purchased from Sigma Aldrich (St. Louis, MO) at the highest available purity unless otherwise indicated. GPMVs from RBL cells were prepared through incubation with low concentrations of dithiothreitol (DTT, 2mM) and formaldehyde (25mM) in the presence of calcium (2mM) for 1h as described previously (21). GPMVs isolated from RBL cells contain 20-40 mol% cholesterol, sphingolipids, phospholipids, and gangliosides typically associated with the plasma membrane, along with many transmembrane and peripheral plasma membrane proteins (18, 25, 26). For XTC-2 derived GPMVs, the vesiculation buffer was diluted 1:5 while maintaining calcium, formaldehyde, and DTT concentrations, and cells were incu- bated for at least 2h at room temperature. Prior to GPMV formation, cells were labeled with DiI-C12 (Life Technologies, Carlsbad, CA; 2µg/ml in 1% methanol) for 10min at room temperature. GPMVs probed at atmospheric pressure were imaged on an inverted microscope (IX81; Olympus, Center Valley, PA) with a 40x air objective (0.95 NA), epi-illumination using an Hg lamp and Cy3 filter set (Chroma Technology, Bellows Falls, VT). Temperature was controlled using a home built Peltier stage described previously (21) coupled to a PID controller (Oven Industries, Mechanicsburg, PA), and images were recorded using a sCMOS camera (Neo; Andor, South Windsor, CT). GPMV suspensions with hexadecanol were prepared either using super-saturated solutions or equi- librated solutions. To make super-saturated solutions, hexadecanol was suspended in either DMSO or ethanol using volumes corresponding to the final concentration indicated in figures, then mixed directly with the GPMV suspension in aqueous buffer while mixing. The maximum DMSO con- centration used was 0.5% v/v, and previous work demonstrates that Tc is not affected by DMSO treatment alone (21). Equilibrated solutions were prepared by first adding a concentrated hexade- canol stock directly to the GPMV suspension such that it precipitated out of solution. Then, the desired volume of ethanol was added and the solution mixed to facilitate the resuspension of hex- adecanol. In all cases where ethanol and hexadecanol were added in combination, they were main- tained at a 120mM ethanol to 30µM hexadecanol ratio, as indicated in figures. Equilibrated solutions could be made for the following: 60mM:1.5µM, 120mM:3µM, 180mM:4.5µM, and 240mM:6µM (ethanol:hexadecanol), although for higher concentrations some small fraction of hexadecanol lacked solubility. Only super-saturated solutions could be made for 600mM ethanol:15µM hexadecanol. 000 00(00) 1–20 5 Fig. 1. Determination of the average critical temperature or pressure of DiIC12 labeled GPMVs through fluorescence imaging. (A) Fields containing multiple GPMVs were imaged over a range of temperatures and at fixed pressure, with rep- resentative subsets of images shown on the left. At high temperature, most GPMVs appear uniform, while an increasing fraction of vesicles appear phase separated as temperature is lowered, with phase separated vesicles indicated by yellow arrows. We manually tabulate the fraction of GPMVs that contain two coexisting liquid phases as a function of temperature from these images, constructing the plot on the right. These points are fit to the sigmoid function described in Methods to determine the extrapolated temperature where 50% of vesicles contain coexisting liquid phases. (B) Fields contain- ing multiple GPMVs were imaged over a range of pressures at fixed temperature, and representative subsets of images are shown on the left. At low pressure, most GPMVs appear uniform, while an increasing fraction of vesicles appear phase separated as pressure is increased. As with the fixed pressure data in A, these points are fit to the sigmoid func- tion described in Methods to determine the extrapolated pressure where 50% of vesicles contain coexisting liquid phases. 000 00(00) 1–20 6 Measurements conducted at elevated hydrostatic pressures were made using a custom built microscopy compatible pressure cell mounted on a Nikon Eclipse TE2000-E inverted microscope as described previously (27, 28) with a 20x extra long working distance air objective (0.4 NA) and G2-A filter set (Nikon Instruments, Richmond, UK) The pressure cell temperature was controlled via a circu- lating water bath. Images were acquired using a sCMOS based camera (Zyla; Andor, Belfast, UK) and recorded using custom built software with temperature and pressure logging. GPMV transition temperatures at constant pressure were measured as described previously (21) and as illustrated in Fig 1A. Briefly, images were acquired of fields of GPMVs over a range of temperatures such that at least 100 vesicles were detected at each temperature. After imaging, individual vesicles were identified as having a single liquid phase or two coexisting liquid phases. This information was compiled into a plot showing the percentage of vesicles with two liquid phases as a function of temperature, which was fit to a sigmoid function to extrapolate the temperature where 50% of vesicles contained two coex- , where B is a parameter describing the width of the transition. The width of the transition within a population of vesicles (∼ 10◦C) is much broader than the width of the transition for a single GPMV (< 2◦C) (19), most likely due to heterogeniety in composition between GPMVs (29). isting liquid phases, % Phase Separated = 100×(cid:16) 1+e−(T−Tc)/B 1 − (cid:17) 1 We have previously demonstrated that these GPMVs pass through a critical temperature at the tran- sition, even in the presence of anesthetics, therefore we refer to this temperature as the average critical temperature (Tc) of the sample. Errors in single measurements of Tc (σTc) are 68% confidence interval estimates of this parameter determined directly from the fit. For the example shown in Fig 1A, the critical temperature is Tc=19.5±0.6◦C. We generally observe that average critical temperatures measured in this way vary between 12◦C < Tc < 27◦C for untreated RBL-derived GPMVs prepared as described above, depending on the growth conditions of the cells from which the GPMVs were derived (29). XTC-2 cells produced GPMVs with average critical temperatures of 14.8±0.4◦ and 20.7±0.4◦C. Error bounds for C where σC is the error in measuring Tc of the untreated control and σM is the error in measuring Tc of the treated sample. The average critical pressure in the sample (Pc) at constant temperature was determined by a similar procedure, as illus- . As with previous studies varying only temperature (19), we find that the fraction of phase separated vesicles present in a population of vesicles at a given temperature/pressure does not depend on the order in which temperature or pressures are sampled, suggesting the transition is fully reversible. a transition temperature shift (∆Tc) are given by(cid:112)σ2 trated in Fig1B, although fit to a slightly different equation, % Phase Separated = 100×(cid:16) 1+e−(P−Pc)/B M + σ2 (cid:17) 1 000 00(00) 1–20 7 Tadpole loss of righting reflex (LRR) measurements: Studies with Xenopus laevis tadpoles were con- ducted in compliance with the US Department of Health and Human Services Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals and were approved by the University of Michigan IACUC. Xenopus laevis embryos were collected, fertilized, and dejellied as described previously (30). Embryos were stored at room temperature in 0.1X MMR (1X MMR = 100mM NaCl, 2mM KCl, 2mM CaCl2, 1mM MgCl2, 5mM Hepes, pH 7.4) and allowed to develop to swimming tadpole stage (stage 43-45). The LRR response was determined by placing tadpoles in a clean glass container filled with 50ml well water and the specified concentration of n-alcohols. At 10min intervals, tadpoles were probed with a smooth glass rod and their responses recorded. Measurements with ethanol or ethanol and hexade- canol in equilibrated solutions were conducted on three separate occasions each with five tadpoles per condition, totaling fifteen tadpoles per condition. Some measurements were conducted double-blind in order to avoid possible systematic bias in the behavioral scoring. Fewer tadpoles were probed for the other n-alcohol combinations investigated. Error bars on LRR measurements are 68% confidence inter- vals with binomial errors calculated according to: LB = 1 − BetaInv(0.32/2, n − nk, nk + 1) and U B = 1 − BetaInv(1 − 0.32/2, n − nk + 1, nk) where LB and U B are the lower and upper bounds of the confidence interval, n is the number of tadpoles investigated, k is the fractional LRR, and BetaInv is the Beta inverse cumulative distribution function. 1 To estimate AC50, LRR measurements at a range of ethanol concentrations were fit to the form LRR = 1 − 1+e−([EtOH]−AC50)/B . Errors reported are 68% confidence intervals of parametric uncer- tainty in AC50. These are calculated by inverting the expectation value of the Fisher Informa- tion and then taking the square root of its diagonal entry. Error bars are much larger for hex- adecanol containing titrations because all data is taken below the extrapolated AC50 concentration. RESULTS Fig. 2A shows that incubating super-saturated solutions of hexadecanol (n=16 alcohol) with isolated Rat Basophilic Leukemia (RBL) and XtC-2 derived GPMVs acts to raise Tc. Here, GPMVs derived from both mammalian (RBL) and Xenopus laevis (XtC-2) cells were used to demonstrate robustness of this effect across species, since later measurements are conducted in Xenopus laevis tadpoles. The sign change in ∆Tc for hexadecanol compared to shorter chain n-alcohols mirrors past work which found that hexadecanol acted to increase chain order within native isolated membranes, while shorter 000 00(00) 1–20 8 anesthetic n-alcohols acted to decrease chain order. (31). We find that the effect on Tc is approximately additive when ethanol (n=2 alcohol) and hexadecanol are used in combination, with 3µM hexadecanol required to counter the effect of an AC50 of ethanol (120mM) over a range of ethanol and hexadecanol concentrations (Fig. 2A,B). Fig. 2. Hexadecanol raises Tc in GPMVs from rat (RBL) and Xenopus (XtC-2) cell lines and can counteract the Tc low- ering effects of ethanol. (A) Values indicate the average shift in Tc (∆Tc) in a population of vesicles upon treatment with the compounds indicated. Solutions containing hexadecanol were prepared to be super-saturated as described in Methods. Each point represents a single measurement and error bounds represent the 68% confidence interval on the extrapolated ∆Tc. (B) Plots showing fraction of phase separated vesicles vs. temperature for the three points inside the gray box in A. 000 00(00) 1–20 9 Fig. 3. (A) (Upper panel) Tadpole loss of righting reflex (LRR) for a titration of ethanol alone and combinations of ethanol and hexadecanol (EtOH+Hex) or ethanol and tetradecanol (EtOH+Tet) measured after 1h incubation in equilibrated solu- tions. At a given ethanol concentration,the presence of hexadecanol increases the fraction of tadpoles which respond to stimulus. (Lower panel) ∆Tc in RBL derived GPMVs for identical titrations of ethanol and EtOH+Hex. All solutions con- tain the ethanol concentration indicated by the lower horizontal axis. Red circle points additionally contain hexadecanol concentrations indicated by the upper horizontal axis, and green triangle points additionally contain either 5 or 10µM tetrade- canol. (B) Time-course of LRR for one ethanol and ethanol+hexadecanol combination. (C) (Left) Points in A replotted as LRR vs ∆Tc, including additional experiments with other n-alcohol combinations as indicated in the legend. (Center) LRR plotted vs. aggregate hydrophobicity, tabulated by summing the concentration of each n-alcohol present normalized by its AC50 (22), using 3µM as a proxy AC50 for hexadecanol and 5µM as a proxy AC50 for tetradecanol. (Right) LRR plot- ted vs. the net anesthetic concentration, tabulated by summing the concentration of each n<14 alcohol anesthetic present normalized by its AC50 (22). (Top panels) In each case the dashed line represents a best fit to the data with R2 values giving the fraction of explained variance and f values comparing the quality of the fit to a null model where all points have the same probability. All fits are linear and constrained to go through the origin. (Bottom Panels) In each case the black line is fit to all conditions that exclude hexadecanol, the red line is fit to all conditions that include hexadecanol, and the gray dashed line is fit to all points as in the upper panels. These fits are substantially different from each other except when plotted vs ∆Tc, indicating that ∆Tc has the most quantitative predictive power across chemical species. Mimicking results from our previous study with n-alcohols (21), we again find that relatively small concentrations of both hexadecanol and ethanol lead to a steep change in Tc, while larger concentrations lead to a less steep and approximately linear regime. This nonlinearity implies an interaction between 000 00(00) 1–20 10 the added molecules, but we cannot specify the nature of their interaction from our measurements. It could be that the concentration of n-alcohol in the membrane becomes a sub-linear function of their con- centration in the bulk. Past work has demonstrated that n-alcohol membrane partition coefficients can depend on n-alcohol concentration (32), membrane composition (32, 33), and temperature (33), and it is possible that these or related effects could lead to the observed nonlinearity. Another possibility is that the addition of small molecules could increase the area of the membrane, thereby reducing its tension. This could have a direct effect on Tc (34), or could alter the membrane's affinity for additional small molecules. It is also possible that membrane concentration is linear with that of the bulk, but that Tc is a nonlinear function of n-alcohol concentration in the membrane. We note that ethanol can induce a novel interdigitated membrane phase in purified phosphatidylcholine membranes when at high enough con- centration (35, 36) so it is plausible that specific interactions between certain lipids and alcohols could drive at least some of the nonlinearity that we observe. At AC50, small molecules make up several mol% of the membrane (22), a relatively high concentration which makes it plausible that n-alcohols interact directly, or indirectly through membrane mediated mechanisms that can be very sensitive near the critical point (37). Our observation that hexadecanol can counteract the effects of ethanol in GPMVs led us to speculate that hexadecanol could antagonize ethanol anesthesia. To test this hypothesis, we examined the tadpole loss of righting reflex (LRR) in Xenopus laevis tadpoles (Fig.3A). We also measured the extent to which identical n-alcohol treatments alter Tc in RBL derived GPMVs. Here equilibrated solutions of hexade- canol and ethanol were used, leading to small differences from the results presented in Fig 2. In ethanol alone, 50% of tadpoles did not exhibit a righting reflex upon inverting with a glass rod at 118±15mM ethanol in agreement with previous reports of 120mM (22). Tadpoles incubated in ethanol and hexade- canol remained alert to much higher ethanol concentrations, more than doubling the extrapolated AC50 value to 294±61mM. Co-incubation with tetradecanol (n=14) had little effect on either GPMV transition temperatures or on the tadpole LRR, suggesting that competitive inhibition at a putative ethanol binding site is not the mechanism through which hexadecanol reverses the effects of ethanol on LRR. Fig.3B shows the time dependent effects of ethanol and ethanol-hexadecanol mixtures on tadpole LRR. LRR is not initially affected by the presence of hexadecanol, but instead reduces LRR over the span of 1h compared to those incubated in ethanol alone. Experiments were not extended beyond 1h as we observed some adaptation of ethanol treated tadpoles beyond this time-frame. The slow onset of hexadecanol action is consistent with past work using radio-labeled n-alcohols, which demonstrated 000 00(00) 1–20 11 that their absorption dynamics depend on carbon length, with longer n-alcohols requiring longer times for incorporation (31). We note that the apparent difference in LRR for ethanol+hexadecanol vs. ethanol alone is not significant at early time-points, nor is the apparent upward trend in LRR vs. time for tadpoles treated with ethanol alone. In Fig.3C we plot LRR vs ∆Tc, aggregate hydrophobicity, or anesthetic con- centration for a range of conditions. We find that ∆Tc captures substantially more of the variance in LRR across trials (R2 = .82) than summed anesthetic potency (R2 = .53), while aggregate hydrophobicity has no predictive power (R < 0). This is partially due to our carefully chosen treatments, many of which are hydrophobic but raise critical temperatures and antagonize LRR. Furthermore, we find that ∆Tc pre- dicts LRR with the same function whether for treatments containing hexadecanol or treatments without hexadecanol, while both aggregate hydrophobicity and summed anesthetic potency do not. Together this demonstrates that ∆Tc predicts LRR across molecular species. This indicates that ∆Tc is significantly more predictive of anesthetic potency than aggregate hydrophobicity or anesthetic concentration for the n-alcohol mixtures examined. The extremely low solubility of hexadecanol presents some experimental difficulties. Ethanol is required as a co-solvent in these measurements and this prevented a more systematic exploration of how hexadecanol modulates anesthesia mediated by other n-alcohols and anesthetics. Our reliance on ethanol as a general anesthetic introduces technical challenges since it has low potency, can harbor impurities that modulate LRR measurements (31), and produces alternate functional out- comes when used at high concentrations (38). While a more water soluble Tc raising compound would alleviate some of these problems, most membrane soluble molecules with reasonable water solubility either lower GPMV transition temperatures or leave them unchanged. Notable excep- tions are some detergents (39), which are not suitable for this investigation because they also permeabilize membranes. Molecules which raise Tc must partition more strongly than the aver- age component into one low temperature membrane phase (40) and our observations suggest that this often requires a large hydrophobic interaction area, with consequent low solubility in water. 000 00(00) 1–20 12 Fig. 4. Ro15-4513 and DHM block the acute toxicity and intoxicating effect of ethanol. Each raise Tc and can- cel the effects of ethanol when added to GPMVs at the same concentration at which they are effective in vivo. Several other compounds are reported to reverse the intoxicating effects of ethanol in both cultured neurons and intact organisms, and their effects on RBL derived GPMVs are shown in Fig 4. 100nM RO15-4513, a therapeutic agent used to reverse acute ethanol toxicity, has been demonstrated to reverse effects of 30mM ethanol in the GABA current in oocytes (41). We find that 100nM RO15-4513 raises critical temperatures in GPMVs by 1.2 ± 0.4◦C. Similarly, 3µM Dihydromyricetin (DHM) was recently reported to antagonize the effects of 60mM ethanol on the GABA-induced current in acutely dissociated rat hippocampal slices as well as on behavioral assays in vivo (42). We find that 3µM DHM raises criti- cal temperatures by 1.3 ± 0.5◦C. In each of these cases, the effect of these compounds on Tc appears to saturate at concentrations well below their solubility. While we have no mechanistic explanation for this saturation, we note that it is mirrored in past behavioral measurements (41, 42) which find that they are only able to counter ethanol effects to concentrations well below its AC50 of 120mM. While the correlation between ∆Tc and anesthetic function is robust for the compounds investi- gated, we note that an additional compound, menthol, raises Tc by nearly 2◦C when added to RBL derived GPMVs at 100µM (43), yet acts as an anesthetic in tadpole LRR measurements at some- what lower concentration (AC50 ≈20µM) (44). This could be due to menthol having specific inter- actions with GABAA receptors, as has been proposed previously (44). It is also possible that men- thol has different effects on Xenopus laevis neuronal vs. mammalian immune plasma membranes. 000 00(00) 1–20 13 Fig. 5. (A) The fraction of vesicles which are macroscopically phase separated is plotted as a function of hydrostatic pressure at three different temperatures, both for control vesicles and vesicles incubated with 12mM bBtOH. In each case, increasing the pressure leads to an increase in the fraction of vesicles which are macroscopically phase sepa- rated. (B) Tc is raised with increasing hydrostatic pressure in both control GPMVs and GPMVs incubated in butanol (BtOH). Here, 240±30 bar of hydrostatic pressure is required to reverse the effects of 12mM BtOH (shaded region). Closed symbols are obtained by extrapolating to find Tc from data acquired at constant pressure while open symbols are obtained by extrapolating to find Pc at constant temperature. At temperatures above Tc most vesicles are com- posed of a macroscopically uniform single liquid, while below Tc most are separated into two co-existing liquid phases. DISCUSSION We also investigated the effects of hydrostatic pressure on GPMVs in the presence and absence of butanol (n=4 alcohol). It has long been known that 150-200 bar of pressure reverses animal anesthe- sia (45). Here we show that the fraction of vesicles with two phase coexistence increases monotonically 000 00(00) 1–20 14 with pressure, for vesicles incubated with and without butanol (Fig 5A). We observe that 240±30 bar is needed to counter the effects of one AC50 of butanol (12mM (22)) on the Tc of RBL derived GPMVs (Fig 5B). Pressure reversal of general anesthesia is not accounted for by current models involving direct binding of anesthetics to channels because protein conformational equilibria are typically sensitive only to much larger pressures (>1000 bar) (46, 47). These smaller pressures can have large effects on some membrane properties, and past work has shown that 200 bar raises the main chain melting temperature in synthetic single component lipid systems by ∼ 4.5◦C (48, 49), even more than is observed here for the miscibility transition in GPMVs (2-3◦C). While our results are not sufficient to specify a mechanism, they do strongly suggest that n-alcohol anesthetic inhibition of membrane heterogeneity plays an important role in mediating anesthesia, likely by interfering with normal membrane regulation of ion channels. We have previously argued that the presence of a critical point in GPMVs near or below room temperature leads to extended and dynamic composition fluctuations at growth temperature (typically 37◦C), both in isolated vesicles and in the intact plasma membranes from which they are derived (19, 50). Theory and experiment suggest that the size of fluctuations varies as (T − Tc)−1 (19, 51), so that lowering Tc through the addition of an n-alcohol anesthetic is expected to reduce the size of compositional heterogeneity at fixed growth temper- ature (Fig. 6). This suggests several plausible mechanisms through which changes in plasma membrane Tc could modulate channel function. First, reducing the size of membrane structures could in princi- ple increase (or decrease) accessibility of native regulators of channel function such as neurosteroids, phosphoinositides and G-proteins (16). Second, different membrane domains are expected to have dif- fering physical properties such as hydrophobic thickness, lateral pressure profiles, viscosity, and bending rigidity (52–56). Destabilizing these membrane domains could act to modulate the response of channels directly by stabilizing different internal protein states. Thirdly, membrane domains are argued to play important roles in organizing channels at neuronal synapses (16) and destabilizing these domains could lead to altered localization of channels with disruption of higher level neuronal functions. Each of these mechanistic possibilities have distinct experimental signatures that can be explored in future studies. 000 00(00) 1–20 15 Fig. 6. Anesthetics lower the transition temperature of a biologically tuned critical point which could lead to mis-regulation of ion channels and other membrane bound proteins. (A) Schematic phase diagrams for the plasma membrane of an untreated and n-alcohol treated cell. Guided by experiments (19) we hypothesize that the plasma membrane lies in the white region where lipids, proteins and other membrane components are well mixed macroscopically into a single two dimensional liquid phase. However, due to their close proximity to the critical point (star), thermal fluctuations lead to relatively large domains enriched in particular components. When cooled into the gray two phase region, GPMVs separate into two coexisting liquid phases termed liquid-ordered and liquid-disordered. Several n-alcohol general anesthetics lower the critical temperature of the membrane (21), changing the distance above the critical point, T − Tc. Here we also show that treatments which antag- onize anesthetic action raise critical temperatures reversing the effects of n-alcohols on Tc. (B) Under normal conditions a hypothetical ion channel (large blue inclusion) has a tendency to inhabit relatively large domains enriched in particular lipids and proteins. When the membrane is taken away from the critical point, the structure of these domains is altered, possibly leading to changes in ion channel gating and function through a variety of mechanisms discussed in the text. One naive prediction of our model is not borne out by experiment, namely that the functional effects of anesthetics are not readily reversed by lowering ambient temperature (57), even though this should reverse anesthetic effects on the parameter T − Tc. While this finding is at odds with a simple interpreta- tion of our results, we note that other biological functions have been shown to be explicitly temperature compensated (58, 59). In these examples individual reaction rates often display sharp temperature sensi- tivity, but the effects of these changes on certain important axes (e.g. the timing of the circadian clock) roughly cancel, leaving function robust (60). Thus, while many cellular processes relevant to neuronal 000 00(00) 1–20 16 function have sensitive temperature dependence (61–63), we expect that organisms, especially those able to live over a range of temperatures, have evolved to a regime where neural function is temperature com- pensated (63) and is thus surprisingly insensitive to changes in temperature. However, we might still expect that triggering only temperature's effects on membrane criticality in an uncompensated way, as we argue occurs with n-alcohol anesthesia, might lead to dramatic changes in function (60). We note that past studies which demonstrate a lack of temperature dependence on anesthetic potency have conducted behavioral measurements in temperature adapted animals (64, 65), where other studies have found evi- dence for concurrent changes in membrane composition (66, 67). Acute temperature changes mimicking or exceeding those produced by relevant concentrations of anesthetic (±4◦C) do produce behavioral changes in animals ranging from lethargy to death (64). Finally, while the evidence for anesthetic-channel interactions is significant, several features may suggest the interaction is more akin to two dimensional solvent-solute rather than binding site-ligand interactions. Some channels contain multiple proposed binding sites for low potency anesthetics, each with low affinity but diffusion limited association rates (12), with clinically relevant concentrations of anesthetic as high as several mol% of the membrane (68). Additionally, many anesthetic sensitive chan- nels are also sensitive to membrane properties, and in particular cholesterol modulation both in recon- stituted (69) and cellular systems (70), suggesting a commonality with broader regulation by membrane domains. Our results suggest that these effects on channel function are likely to be altered by anes- thetics through their effects on membrane mixing even without binding of anesthetic to protein targets. CONCLUSION Overall, the results presented here demonstrate that a condition's effect on GPMV Tc is more pre- dictive of anesthetic potency than hydrophobicity. By exploiting rare conditions where ∆Tc > 0 we have shown that behavioral measures and existing electrophysiological assays for anesthesia are remark- ably tied to the membrane's thermodynamic propensity to form small domains. While our results do not suggest a specific mechanism through which these conditions reverse anesthesia, they do support the hypothesis that at least some n-alcohol targets may be influenced through effects on membrane criticality. Acknowledgements We thank Keith Miller and James Sethna for helpful converstaions, Ned Wingreen for a close reading of the manuscript and Margaret Burns, Jing Wu, and Kathleen Wisser for assis- tance with some experiments. Research was funded by the NIH (R01 GM110052 to SLV and R01 000 00(00) 1–20 GM112794 to ALM), startup funds from the University of Michigan (to SLV), EPSRC Programme grant (EP/J017566/1 to NJB), a EPSRC Centre for Doctoral Training Studentship awarded by the Institute of Chemical Biology to NLCM (EP/F500076/1) a Lewis-Sigler Fellowship (BBM) and by NSF PHY 0957573 (BBM). 17 References 1. Meyer, H., 1899. Zur Theorie der Alkoholnarkose. Archiv fr experimentelle Pathologie und Pharmakologie 42:109–118. 2. Gruner, S. M., and E. Shyamsunder, 1991. Is the mechanism of general anesthesia related to lipid membrane spontaneous curvature? Ann N Y Acad Sci 625:685–97. 3. Wodzinska, K., A. Blicher, and T. Heimburg, 2009. The thermodynamics of lipid ion channel formation in the absence and presence of anesthetics. BLM experiments and simulations. Soft Matter 5:3319–3330. 4. Ing´olfsson, H. I., and O. S. Andersen, 2011. Alcohol's Effects on Lipid Bilayer Properties. Biophysical Journal 101:847–855. 5. Herold, K. F., R. L. Sanford, W. Lee, M. F. Schultz, H. I. Inglfsson, O. S. Andersen, and H. C. Hemmings, 2014. Volatile anesthetics inhibit sodium channels without altering bulk lipid bilayer properties. The Journal of General Physiology 144:545–560. 6. Franks, N. P., and W. R. Lieb, 1986. Partitioning of long-chain alcohols into lipid bilayers: implications for mechanisms of general anesthesia. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 83:5116–20. 7. Franks, N. P., and W. R. Lieb, 1994. Molecular and cellular mechanisms of general anaesthesia. Nature 367:607–14. 8. Mihic, S. J., Q. Ye, M. J. Wick, V. V. Koltchine, M. A. Krasowski, S. E. Finn, M. P. Mascia, C. F. Valenzuela, K. K. Hanson, E. P. Greenblatt, R. A. Harris, and N. L. Harrison, 1997. Sites of alcohol and volatile anaesthetic action on GABA(A) and glycine receptors. Nature 389:385–389. 9. Borghese, C. M., D. F. Werner, N. Topf, N. V. Baron, L. A. Henderson, S. L. Boehm, Y. A. Blednov, A. Saad, S. Dai, R. A. Pearce, R. A. Harris, G. E. Homanics, and N. L. Harrison, 2006. An Isoflurane- and Alcohol-Insensitive Mutant GABAA Receptor ?1 Subunit with Near-Normal Apparent Affinity for GABA: Characterization in Heterologous Systems and Production of Knockin Mice. Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics 319:208–218. 10. Nury, H., C. Van Renterghem, Y. Weng, A. Tran, M. Baaden, V. Dufresne, J. P. Changeux, J. M. Sonner, M. Delarue, and P. J. Corringer, 2011. X-ray structures of general anaesthetics bound to a pentameric ligand-gated ion channel. Nature 469:428–+. 11. Forman, S. A., and K. W. Miller, 2016. Mapping General Anesthetic Sites in Heteromeric γ-Aminobutyric Acid Type A Receptors Reveals a Potential For Targeting Receptor Subtypes. Anesth Analg. in press. 12. Xu, Y., T. Seto, P. Tang, and L. Firestone, 2000. NMR study of volatile anesthetic binding to nicotinic acetylcholine receptors. Biophys J 78:746–51. 13. Brannigan, G., D. N. LeBard, J. Hnin, R. G. Eckenhoff, and M. L. Klein, 2010. Multiple binding sites for the general anesthetic isoflurane identified in the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor transmembrane domain. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 107:14122–14127. 14. Simons, K., and E. Ikonen, 1997. Functional rafts in cell membranes. Nature 387:569–72. 15. Anderson, R. G., and K. Jacobson, 2002. A role for lipid shells in targeting proteins to caveolae, rafts, and other lipid domains. Science 296:1821–5. 16. Allen, J. A., R. A. Halverson-Tamboli, and M. M. Rasenick, 2007. Lipid raft microdomains and neurotransmitter signalling. Nat Rev Neurosci 8:128–140. 000 00(00) 1–20 18 17. Veatch, S. L., and S. L. Keller, 2005. Seeing spots: Complex phase behavior in simple membranes. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA) - Molecular Cell Research 1746:172 – 185. 18. Baumgart, T., A. T. Hammond, P. Sengupta, S. T. Hess, D. A. Holowka, B. A. Baird, and W. W. Webb, 2007. Large-scale fluid/fluid phase separation of proteins and lipids in giant plasma membrane vesicles. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104:3165–70. 19. Veatch, S. L., P. Cicuta, P. Sengupta, A. Honerkamp-Smith, D. Holowka, and B. Baird, 2008. Critical fluctuations in plasma membrane vesicles. Acs Chemical Biology 3:287–293. 20. Honerkamp-Smith, A. R., P. Cicuta, M. D. Collins, S. L. Veatch, . den Niljs, M. Schick, and S. L. Keller, 2008. Line Tensions, Correlation Lengths, and Critical Exponents in Lipid Membranes Near Critical Points. Biophysical Journal 95:236–246. 21. Gray, E., J. Karslake, B. B. Machta, and S. L. Veatch, 2013. Liquid general anesthetics lower critical temperatures in plasma membrane vesicles. Biophys J 105:2751–9. 22. Pringle, M. J., K. B. Brown, and K. W. Miller, 1981. Can the lipid theories of anesthesia account for the cutoff in anesthetic potency in homologous series of alcohols? Mol Pharmacol 19:49–55. 23. Barsumian, E. L., C. Isersky, M. G. Petrino, and R. P. Siraganian, 1981. IgE-induced histamine release from rat basophilic leukemia cell lines: isolation of releasing and nonreleasing clones. European Journal of Immunology 11:317–323. 24. Pudney, M., M. G. Varma, and C. J. Leake, 1973. Establishment of a cell line (XTC-2) from the South African clawed toad, Xenopus laevis. Experientia 29:466–7. 25. Fridriksson, E. K., P. A. Shipkova, E. D. Sheets, D. Holowka, B. Baird, and F. W. McLafferty, 1999. Quantitative Analysis of Phospho- lipids in Functionally Important Membrane Domains from RBL-2H3 Mast Cells Using Tandem High-Resolution Mass Spectrometry. Biochemistry 38:8056–8063. 26. Levental, K. R., J. H. Lorent, X. Lin, A. D. S. ad Michal A. Surma, E. A. Stockenbojer, A. A. Gorfe, and I. Levental, 2016. Polyunsaturated Lipids Regulate Membrane Domain Stability by Tuning Membrane Order. Biophysical Journal 110:1800–1810. 27. McCarthy, N. L. C., O. Ces, R. V. Law, J. M. Seddon, and N. J. Brooks, 2015. Separation of liquid domains in model membranes induced with high hydrostatic pressure. Chem. Commun. 51:8675–8678. 28. Purushothaman, S., P. Cicuta, O. Ces, and N. J. Brooks, 2015. Influence of High Pressure on the Bending Rigidity of Model Membranes. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 119:9805–9810. 26146795. 29. Gray, E. M., G. Diaz-Vazquez, and S. L. Veatch, 2015. Growth Conditions and Cell Cycle Phase Modulate Phase Transition Temperatures in RBL-2H3 Derived Plasma Membrane Vesicles. PLoS ONE 10:1–16. 30. Miller, A. L., and W. M. Bement, 2009. Regulation of cytokinesis by Rho GTPase flux. Nat Cell Biol 11:71–77. 31. Miller, K. W., L. L. Firestone, J. K. Alifimoff, and P. Streicher, 1989. Nonanesthetic alcohols dissolve in synaptic membranes without perturbing their lipids. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 86:1084–7. 32. Fraser, D. M., L. C. Van Gorkom, and A. Watts, 1991. Partitioning behaviour of 1-hexanol into lipid membranes as studied by deuterium NMR spectroscopy. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA) - Biomembranes 1069:53–60. 33. Trandum, C., P. Westh, K. Jrgensen, and O. G. Mouritsen, 2000. A Thermodynamic Study of the Effects of Cholesterol on the Interaction between Liposomes and Ethanol. Biophysical Journal 78:2486 – 2492. 34. Portet, T., S. E. Gordon, and S. L. Keller, 2012. Increasing Membrane Tension Decreases Miscibility Temperatures; an Experimental Demonstration via Micropipette Aspiration. Biophysical Journal 103:L35 – L37. 35. Rowe, E. S., and C. T. A., 1990. Differential Scanning Calorimetric Studies of Ethanol Interactions with Distearoylphosphatidyl- choline: Transition to the Interdigitated Phase. Biochemistry 29:10398–10404. 36. McIntosh, T. J., H. Lin, S. Li, and C. hsien Huang, 2001. The effect of ethanol on the phase transition temperature and the phase structure of monounsaturated phosphatidylcholines. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA) - Biomembranes 1510:219 – 230. 000 00(00) 1–20 19 37. Widom, B., 1967. Plait points in 2 and 3-Component liquid mixtures. J. Chem. Phys. 46:3324. 38. Downes, H., and P. M. Courogen, 1996. Contrasting effects of anesthetics in tadpole bioassays. Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics 278:284–296. http://jpet.aspetjournals.org/content/278/1/284.abstract. 39. Zhou, Y., K. N. Maxwell, E. Sezgin, M. Lu, H. Liang, J. F. Hancock, E. J. Dial, L. M. Lichtenberger, and I. Levental, 2013. Bile Acids Modulate Signaling by Functional Perturbation of Plasma Membrane Domains. Journal of Biological Chemistry 288:35660–35670. 40. Meerschaert, R. L., and C. V. Kelly, 2015. Trace membrane additives affect lipid phases with distinct mechanisms: a modified Ising model. Eur Biophys J 44:227–33. 41. Wallner, M., H. J. Hanchar, and R. W. Olsen, 2006. Low-dose alcohol actions on α4β3γ GABAA receptors are reversed by the behavioral alcohol antagonist Ro15-4513. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 103:8540–8545. 42. Shen, Y., A. K. Lindemeyer, C. Gonzalez, X. M. Shao, I. Spigelman, R. W. Olsen, and J. Liang, 2012. Dihydromyricetin As a Novel Anti-Alcohol Intoxication Medication. The Journal of Neuroscience 32:390–401. 43. Raghunathan, K., A. Ahsan, D. Ray, M. K. Nyati, and S. L. Veatch, 2015. Membrane Transition Temperature Determines Cisplatin Response. PLoS ONE 10:e0140925. 44. Watt, E. E., B. A. Betts, F. O. Kotey, D. J. Humbert, T. N. Griffith, E. W. Kelly, K. C. Veneskey, N. Gill, K. C. Rowan, A. Jenkins, and A. C. Hall, 2008. Menthol shares general anesthetic activity and sites of action on the GABAA receptor with the intravenous agent, propofol. European Journal of Pharmacology 590:120 – 126. 45. Johnson, F. H., and E. A. Flagler, 1950. Hydrostatic pressure reversal of narcosis in tadpoles. Science 112:91–2. 46. Moss, G. W., W. R. Lieb, and N. P. Franks, 1991. Anesthetic inhibition of firefly luciferase, a protein model for general anesthesia, does not exhibit pressure reversal. Biophysical Journal 60:1309–1314. 47. Mozhaev, V. V., K. Heremans, J. Frank, P. Masson, and C. Balny, 1996. High pressure effects on protein structure and function. Proteins 24:81–91. 48. Liu, N.-I., and R. L. Kay, 1977. Redetermination of the pressure dependence of the lipid bilayer phase transition. Biochemistry 16:3484–3486. 49. Winter, R., and C. Jeworrek, 2009. Effect of pressure on membranes. Soft Matter 5:3157–3173. 50. Machta, B. B., S. Papanikolaou, J. P. Sethna, and S. L. Veatch, 2011. Minimal model of plasma membrane heterogeneity requires coupling cortical actin to criticality. Biophys J 100:1668–77. 51. Zhao, J., J. Wu, and S. L. Veatch, 2013. Adhesion stabilizes robust lipid heterogeneity in supercritical membranes at physiological temperature. Biophys J 104:825–34. 52. Diaz-Rohrer, B. B., K. R. Levental, K. Simons, and I. Levental, 2014. Membrane raft association is a determinant of plasma membrane localization. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111:8500–8505. 53. Lin, Q., and E. London, 2013. Altering Hydrophobic Sequence Lengths Shows That Hydrophobic Mismatch Controls Affinity for Ordered Lipid Domains (Rafts) in the Multitransmembrane Strand Protein Perfringolysin O. J Biol Chem. 288:1340–1352. 54. Niemela, P. S., S. Ollila, M. T. Hyvonen, M. Karttunen, and I. Vattulainen, 2007. Assessing the Nature of Lipid Raft Membranes. PLoS Comput Biol 3:1–9. 55. Cicuta, P., S. L. Keller, , and S. L. Veatch, 2007. Diffusion of Liquid Domains in Lipid Bilayer Membranes. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 111:3328–3331. 56. Baumgart, T., S. T. Hess, and W. W. Webb, 2003. Imaging coexisting fluid domains in biomembrane models coupling curvature and line tension. Nature 425:821–824. 57. Franks, N. P., and W. R. Lieb, 1982. Molecular mechanisms of general anaesthesia. Nature 300:487–93. 58. Oleksiuk, O., V. Jakovljevic, N. Vladimirov, R. Carvalho, E. Paster, W. S. Ryu, Y. Meir, N. S. Wingreen, M. Kollmann, and V. Sourjik, 000 00(00) 1–20 20 2011. Thermal Robustness of Signaling in Bacterial Chemotaxis. Cell 145:312–321. 59. Kidd, P. B., M. W. Young, and E. D. Siggia, 2015. Temperature compensation and temperature sensation in the circadian clock. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 112:E6284–E6292. 60. Daniels, B. C., Y.-J. Chen, J. P. Sethna, R. N. Gutenkunst, and C. R. Myers, 2008. Sloppiness, robustness, and evolvability in systems biology. Current Opinion in Biotechnology 19:389 – 395. 61. Smith, S. M., R. Renden, and H. von Gersdorff, 2008. Synaptic vesicle endocytosis: fast and slow modes of membrane retrieval. Trends in Neurosciences 31:559 – 568. 62. Thompson, S. M., L. M. Masukawa, and D. A. Prince, 1985. Temperature dependence of intrinsic membrane properties and synaptic potentials in hippocampal CA1 neurons in vitro. J. Neurosci. 5:817–24. 63. Tang, L. S., M. L. Goeritz, J. S. Caplan, A. L. Taylor, M. Fisek, and E. Marder, 2010. Precise Temperature Compensation of Phase in a Rhythmic Motor Pattern. PLoS Biol 8:1–13. 64. Meyer, H., 1901. Zur Theorie der Alkoholnarkose. 3. Mittheilung: Der Einfluss wechselnder Temperatur auf Wirkungsstrke und Theilungscoefficient der Narcotiea. Arch. exp. Path. Pharmak. (Naunyn-Schmiedebergs) 46:338346. 65. Cherkin, A., and J. F. Catchpool, 1964. Temperature Dependence of Anesthesia in Goldfish. Science 144:1460–1462. 66. Baraska, J., and P. Wlodawer, 1969. Influence of temperature on the composition of fatty acids and on lipogenesis in frog tissues. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 28:553–570. 67. Anderson, T. R., 1970. Temperature adaptation and the phospholipids of membranes in goldfish (carassius auratus). Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 33:663–687. 68. Janoff, A. S., M. J. Pringle, and K. W. Miller, 1981. Correlation of General Anesthetic Potency with Solubility in Membranes. Biochimica Et Biophysica Acta 649:125–128. 69. Bristow, D. R., and I. L. Martin, 1987. Solubilisation of the gamma-aminobutyric acid/benzodiazepine receptor from rat cerebellum: optimal preservation of the modulatory responses by natural brain lipids. J Neurochem 49:1386–93. 70. Sooksawate, T., and M. Simmonds, 2001. Effects of membrane cholesterol on the sensitivity of the GABAA receptor to GABA in acutely dissociated rat hippocampal neurones. Neuropharmacology 40:178 – 184. 000 00(00) 1–20
1503.06206	1	1503	2015-03-17T14:12:09	Analysis of the unilateral contact problem for biphasic cartilage layers with an elliptic contact zone and accounting for the tangential displacements	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.med-ph", "q-bio.TO" ]	A three-dimensional unilateral contact problem for articular cartilage layers attached to subchondral bones shaped as elliptic paraboloids is considered in the framework of the biphasic cartilage model. The main novelty of the study is in accounting not only for the normal (vertical), but also for tangential vertical (horisontal) displacements of the contacting surfaces. Exact general relationships have been established between the contact approach and some integral characteristics of the contact pressure, including the contact force. Asymptotic representations for the contact pressure integral characteristics are obtained in terms of the contact approach and some integral characteristics of the contact zone. The main result is represented by the first-order approximation problem.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Analysis of the unilateral contact problem for biphasic cartilage layers with an elliptic contact zone and accounting for the tangential displacements A.A. Koroleva∗, S.V. Rogosin†, G.S. Mishuris‡ July 2, 2021 Abstract: A three-dimensional unilateral contact problem for articular cartilage layers at- tached to subchondral bones shaped as elliptic paraboloids is considered in the framework of the biphasic cartilage model. The main novelty of the study is in accounting not only for the normal (vertical), but also for tangential vertical (horisontal) displacements of the contacting surfaces. Exact general relationships have been established between the contact approach and some integral characteristics of the contact pressure, including the contact force. Asymptotic representations for the contact pressure integral characteristics are ob- tained in terms of the contact approach and some integral characteristics of the contact zone. The main result is represented by the first-order approximation problem. 1 Introduction Biomechanical contact problems involving transmission of forces across biological joints are of considerable practical interest (see, e.g. [2, 3, 11, 13]). Many analytical solutions to the problem of contact interaction of articular cartilage surfaces in joints are available. In particular, Ateshian et al. [8] obtained an asymptotic solution for the axisymmetric contact problem for two identical biphasic cartilage layers consisting of a solid phase and a fluid ∗Belarusian State University, Belarus. †Aberystwyth University, UK, and Belarusian State University, Belarus. ‡Aberystwyth University, UK. The research leading to these results has received funding from the People Programme (Marie Curie Actions) of the European Union's Seventh Framework Programme FP7/2007-2013/ under REA grant agree- ment PIRSES-GA-2013-610547 - TAMER and by FP7-PEOPLE-2012-IAPP through the grant PIAP-GA- 2012-284544-PARM2. The authors are thankful to Dr. I. Argatov for important suggestions improving the proposed model. 1 phase and attached to two rigid impermeable spherical bones of equal radii. Later, Wu et al. [14] extended this solution to a more general axisymmetric model by combining the assumption of the kinetic relationship from classical contact mechanics [12] with the joint contact model [8] for the contact of two biphasic cartilage layers. An improved solution for the contact of two biphasic cartilage layers in the axisymmetric setting, which can be used for dynamic loading, was obtained by Wu et al. [15]. An asymptotic modeling approach to study the contact problem for biphasic cartilage layers has been performed by Argatov and Mishuris in a series of articles (see [4, 5, 7]). In particular, it was shown [4] that accounting for the tangential displacements is important in the case of diseased cartilage where the measurement of indentation depth may differ even as much as 10% in comparison with the healthy case. In [5], the unilateral contact problem for articular cartilages bonded to subchondral bones with a contact zone in the shape of an arbitrary ellipse has been considered, and a closed form analytic solution was found. Exploiting this exact result, Argatov and Mishuris [7] have performed perturbation analysis of the contact problem with approximate geometry of the contact surfaces. Other analytic solutions for the contact problem were found using the viscoelastic cartilage model for elliptic contact zone in [6]. A new methodology for modeling articular tibio-femoral contact based on the developed asymptotic model of frictionless elliptical contact interaction between thin biphasic cartilage layers was presented in [2]. The mathematical model of articular contact was extended to the case of contact between arbitrary viscoelastic incompressible coating layers. In this study we extend results obtained in papers [4] and [5] by considering the influence of the tangential displacements on the contact problem for cartilage layers with the contact zone of elliptic shape based on the biphasic material model. Note that the perturbation method proposed in [7] could be one of the options for the analysis, however, the procedure is too complex to perform even a few asymptotic steps. Here, employing some technique and ideas from [4] and [5], we propose another way to construct the asymptotics which utilises the assumption that the shape of the contact zone is an ellipse at the initial stage of deformation and can be regarded as a small perturbation of the ellipse at any other stage of deformation. The paper is organized as follows. The unilateral contact problem formulation and its linearization are presented in Section 2, where a special case of the contact configuration with one cartilage layer being plane and rigid is also considered in detail. In Section 3, we derive exact general relationships between the contact approach and some integral char- acteristics of the contact pressure, including the contact force. In Section 3.3, we obtain asymptotic representations for the contact pressure integral characteristics in terms of the contact approach and some integral characteristics of the contact zone. The zero-order and first-order asymptotic approximations for the solution to the contact problem are obtained in Sections 4.1 and 4.2, respectively. Namely, the first-order approximation problem constitutes the main result of the present study. 2 2 Formulation of the contact problem We consider a frictionless contact between two thin linear biphasic cartilage layers firmly attached to rigid bones shaped like elliptic paraboloids. In the Cartesian co-ordinates (x1, x2, z) = (x, z) the equations for the two cartilage surfaces can be written in the form z = (−1)nΦ(n)(x), n = 1, 2, where Φ(n)(x) = x2 1 2R(n) 1 + x2 2 2R(n) 2 (2.1) with R(n) 1 , R(n) 2 being the curvature radii of the n-th bone surface at its apex. In the undeformed state, the cartilage-bone systems occupy convex domains z ≤ −Φ(1)(x) and z ≥ Φ(2)(x), respectively. They are in the initial contact with the plane z = 0 at the origin of the co-ordinate system. We denote by w1(x, t), w2(x, t) the local vertical displacements of the corresponding cartilage surfaces. Let also u1(x, t), u2(x, t) be the local horizontal (tangential) displacements of the corresponding surface of the cartilages. Finally, we denote by P (x, t) the contact pressure density. In this notation the equations for the cartilage surfaces can be written in the following form: z = δ1(t) − Φ(1) (x + u1(x, t)) + w1(x, t), z = −δ2(t) + Φ(2) (x + u2(x, t)) − w2(x, t). (2.2) Here, δ1, δ2 are some (positive) vertical displacements of the rigid bones. Note also that the vertical displacements w1, w2 are positive, while the tangential displacements u1, u2 are directed outside of the contact zone. Denoting by δ∗(t) = δ1(t) + δ2(t) the contact approach of the bones, we get from (2.2) the following inequality: δ∗(t) + w1(x, t) + w2(x, t) ≤ Φ(1) (x + u1(x, t)) + Φ(2) (x + u2(x, t)) . (2.3) It was shown in [8] (see also [4]) that vertical and the tangential displacements of each bone can be represented in the form wn(x, t) = ∆P (x, t) + 3 Hn tZ0 hnǫ2 n 3µs,n un(x, t) = − hnǫn 2µs,n∇P (x, t), n = 1, 2. ∆P (x, τ )dτ , n = 1, 2, (2.4) (2.5) Here ǫn = hn/a0 are dimensionless small parameters, h1, h2 mean the thicknesses of the cartilage layers, and a0 denotes a characteristic measure of the contact zone (see the detailed description of the role of this parameter in [4]), Hn = (λs,n + 2µs,n)/µs,n are material pa- rameters of cartilages, where λs,n and µs,n represent the first Lame coefficient and the shear 3 modulus of the solid phase of the n-th cartilage tissue. Note that u1 and u2 in (2.5) do not necessarily coincide, they depend on both spatial variables x1, x2, and on the time variable t. Following [8], we introduce new spatial variables and time variable via formulas x′ j = xj a0 , j = 1, 2, t′ = χt µ0 , where χ = 3µs,1k1 h2 1 + 3µs,2k2 h2 2 , µ0 = µs,1 λs,1 + 2µs,1 + µs,2 λs,2 + 2µs,2 , a0 is a characteristic measure of the contact zone, and k1, k2 are the cartilage's permeabilities. In these variables we have the following relations on the contact area ω(t) encircled by the curve Γ(t) = ∂ω(t): ∆P (x′, t′) + χ , (2.6) h3 2 3µs,2(cid:19) t′Z0 ∆P (x′, τ ′)dτ ′ w1(x′, t′) + w2(x′, t′) =(cid:18) h3 1 3µs,1 + Φ(n)(x′ + un(x′, t′)) ≃ Φ(n)(x′) − h2 na0 2µs,n∇Φ(n)(x′) · ∇P (x′, t′), n = 1, 2. (2.7) Further the equality in (2.3), i.e., δ∗(t′) + w1(x′, t′) + w2(x′, t′) = Φ(1) (x + u1(x, t)) + Φ(2) (x + u2(x, t)) , (2.8) determines the contact area ω(t). Now we substitute (2.6), (2.7) into (2.8) and obtain the governing equation relating the contact pressure with the vertical approach of the bones δ∗(t) in the following form (from now on we keep the names of new unknown functions, e.g. Φ(x) := Φ(x′a0) etc.): ∆P (x, t) + χ tZ0 ∆P (x, τ )dτ = m(cid:16)Φ(x) − δ∗(t) − ∇eΦ(x) · ∇P (x, t)(cid:17) . Here we have introduced the notation m =(cid:18) h3 1 3µs,1 + h3 2 3µs,2(cid:19)−1 , Φ(x′) = Φ(1)(x′) + Φ(2)(x′). Thus, it follows from (2.1) and (2.11) that the functions Φ and eΦ are given by Φ(x) = Φ(x1, x2) = Ax2 1 + Bx2 2 4 (2.9) (2.10) (2.11) (2.12) with and A = 1 2R(1) 1 + 1 2R(2) 1 , B = 1 2R(1) 2 + 1 2R(2) 2 eΦ(x) =eΦ(x1, x2) = eAx2 1 + eBx2 2. (2.13) (2.17) (2.18) (2.19) than unit. Note that the coefficients in eA and eB are positive dimensionless numbers, which are less Without loss of generality, one can assume that A > B. Then, Eq. (2.9) can be rewritten in an equivalent form, using all dimensionless parameters: ∆Pε(x, t) + χ tZ0 ∆Pε(x, τ )dτ = µ(cid:0)Ψ1(x) − δε(t) − ε∇Ψ2(x) · ∇Pε(x, t)(cid:1), where the following notation has been introduced: Ψj(x) = x2 1 + e2 j x2 2, j = 1, 2, δε(t) = µ = Am, It is important to note that e1 =pB/A, e2 =qeB/eA, χ = O(1), µε ≪ χ. 1 A δ∗(t), ε = eA A . (2.14) (2.15) (2.16) Discussion of the characteristic values of the introduced parameters is presented in Section 5 (see also [8, 4]). Since the solution of (2.14) depends on the parameter ε, it is customer to denote an unknown contact pressure by P = Pε in what follows. Note that the problem for ε = 0 coincides with that considered in [5], where an exact solution to this problem was found. Equation (2.14) is the equation for determination of the contact pressure Pε(x, t) ≥ 0, x ∈ ωε(t). In particular, in the case when the contact domain is represented by an ellipse ωε(t) =(cid:26)x ∈ R2 : x2 1 b2(t, ε) + β2(t, ε)x2 2 b2(t, ε) ≤ 1(cid:27) . We supply Eq. (2.14) with the following boundary conditions: Pε(x, t) = 0, x ∈ Γ(t), ∂Pε ∂n (x, t) = 0, x ∈ Γ(t). Note that in the axisymmetric case formula (2.14) coinsides with formula [4, (8)]. 5 The equilibrium equation ZZωε(t) Pε(x, t)dx = F (t) (2.20) connects the external load F (t), unknown contact pressure Pε(x, t), and unknown contact domain ωε(t). 2.1 Special case of the contact configuration In order to check the content of formula (2.9) we consider here a special case, namely, we suppose that the lower part cartilage layer is plane and rigid (the same assumption was employed in [14]), it means that µs,2 = ∞ and R(1) 2 = ∞, i.e., 1 = R(1) Φ(1) ≡ 0, Φ ≡ Φ(2). In this case we have got the following equation for determination of the contact domain ω(t) in the form similar to (2.9): ∆P (x, t) + χ Here we will have tZ0 ∆P (x, τ )dτ = m(cid:16)Φ(x) − δ∗(t) − ∇eΦ(x) · ∇P (x, t)(cid:17) . m = 3µs,2 h3 2 , χ = 3µs,2k2 h2 2 . At the same time, small changes have to be made in the right-hand side of Eq. follows: Φ(x) = x2 1 2R(2) 1 h2 2a0x2 1 2µs,2R(2) 1 + + , x2 2 2R(2) 2 h2 2a0x2 1 2µs,2R(2) 1 . Φ(x) = Thus Eq. (2.21) can be rewritten as ∆P (x, t) + 3µs,2k2 h2 2 tZ0 ∆P (x, τ )dτ = 2 x2 1 2R(2) 1 3µs,2 h3 + x2 2 2R(2) 2 − δ∗(t)! 3a0 h2 " x1 R(2) 1 − ∂x1P (x, t) + x2 R(2) 2 ∂x1P (x, t)# . (2.21) (2.22) (2.21) as (2.23) (2.24) It can be easily checked that in the axisymmetric case Eq. (2.23) reduces to the governing differential equation obtained in [4]. 6 3 General relationships between the solution compo- nents 3.1 Determination of the contact approach In our model we assume that the external load is non-decreasing. Thus, the contact domain is monotonically expanded, i.e. ωε(t1) ⊆ ωε(t2), ∀t1 ≤ t2. (3.1) It is convenient to suppose also that the contact pressure is defined on the whole plane. For this we simply extend the density Pε(x, t) by assuming that Integrating (2.14) over contact domain ω(t), we get Pε(x, t) = 0, ∀x 6∈ ωε(t). ZZω(t) ∆Pε(x, t)dx + χZZω(t) tZ0 ∆Pε(x, τ )dτ dx = = µZZω(t) (Ψ1(x) − δε(t)) dx − εµZZω(t) ∇Ψ2(x) · ∇Pε(x, t)dx. (3.2) (3.3) For simplicity of notation, we omit here (and everywhere in the next two sections) the subindex ε in ωε. From the monotonicity of the contact domain (3.1) and assumption (3.2), it follows that the second integral on the left-hand side can be written in the form ZZω(t) tZ0 ∆Pε(x, τ )dτ dx = tZ0 ZZω(t) ∆Pε(x, τ )dxdτ. (3.4) Using the second Green's formula ZZω(t) (u(x)∆v(x) − v(x)∆u(x)) dx = ZΓ(t) (cid:18)u(x) ∂v ∂n (x) − v(x) ∂u ∂n (x)(cid:19) ds (3.5) with u ≡ 1 and v = Pε(x, t) we get the following relation in view of the boundary condition (2.19): ZZω(t) ∆Pε(x, τ )dx = ZΓ(t) ∂Pε ∂n (x, s)ds = 0, ∀τ ≤ t. (3.6) Therefore, the both integrals on the left-hand side of (3.3) vanish. 7 Further, we use the first Green's formula ZZω(t) (ϕ∆ψ + ∇ϕ · ∇ψ) dx = ZΓ(t) ϕ ∂ψ ∂n ds (3.7) with ψ(x) = Ψ2(x) and ϕ(x) = Pε(x, t). In this case the integral on the right-hand side vanishes in view of (2.18), and we obtain the relation ZZω(t) ∇Ψ2(x) · ∇Pε(x, t)dx = −ZZω(t) Pε(x, t)∆Ψ2(x)dx = −2(1 + e2 2)F (t), (3.8) where we used the equilibrium equation (2.20) and the identity ∆Ψ2(x) = 2(1 + e2 2) (3.9) with e2 being defined in (2.15). In what follows, it is convenient to have the following notation for the integrals of the product of k-th power of the function Ψ1 and l-th power of the function Ψ2: Ak,l(ω) =ZZω Ψk 1(x)Ψl 2(x)dx > 0, k, l = 0, 1, 2, . . . (3.10) In particular, A0,0(ω) is the area of the contact domain. It is to remember that the constants Ak,l(ω) depend finally on t, but we omitted this fact in the notation in order to avoid cumbersome expressions. Computations of Ak,l(ω) for the elliptic domain (2.17) we included into Appendix (see Section 6.1). Taking into account Eqs. (3.6) and (3.8), we get δε(t) = A1,0(ωε(t)) A0,0(ωε(t)) + 2(1 + e2 2)ε A0,0(ωε(t)) F (t). (3.11) This formula allows us to compute the contact approach δε(t) as a function of the total external force F (t) and the main axes of the ellipse describing the shape of the contact zone, which in fact depends on time too. 3.2 Some integral identity for the contact pressure In order to write out a more informative equation for the contact load, we use the following trick. We multiply both sides of (2.14) by the function v(x) = Ψ2(x) and integrate the 8 obtained equation over the contact domain ω(t) ZZω(t) Ψ2(x)∆Pε(x, t)dx + χZZω(t) = µZZω(t) − µεZZω(t) Ψ2(x)∆Pε(x, τ )dτ dx = tZ0 Ψ2(x)Ψ1(x)dx − µδε(t)ZZω(t) Ψ2(x)dx Ψ2(x)∇Ψ2(x) · ∇Pε(x, t)dx. (3.12) Let us calculate the integrals in this relation by using Green's formulas. For the first integral on the left-hand side we use formula (3.5) with u = Ψ2, v = Pε and the boundary conditions (2.18), (2.19). Hence, we obtain ZZω(t) Ψ2(x)∆Pε(x, t)dx =ZZω(t) ∆Ψ2(x)Pε(x, t)dx. Now taking into account (3.9), we get ZZω(t) Ψ2(x)∆Pε(x, t)dx = 2(1 + e2 2)F (t). (3.13) For the second integral on the left-hand side, we apply the same approach, but interchange first the integrals over ωε(t) and over τ ∈ (0, t) exploiting the load monotonicity. Therefore, we arrive at the equation ZZω(t) tZ0 Ψ2(x)∆Pε(x, τ )dτ dx = tZ0 ZZω(t) Ψ2(x)∆Pε(x, τ )dτ dx = 2(1 + e2 2) tZ0 F (τ )dτ. (3.14) For the first and second integrals on the right-hand side, we simply use the notation (3.10), which gives ZZω(t) Ψ1(x)Ψ2(x)dx = A1,1(b; β), ZZω(t) Ψ2(x)dx = A0,1(b; β). (3.15) Finally, for the third integral on the right-hand side, we make use of the following simple formula which follows immediately from the definition of Ψ2: Ψ2∇Ψ2 = 1 2∇Ψ2 2. 9 Then we can apply Green's formula (3.7) and the boundary conditions (2.18), (2.19) to find ZZω(t) Ψ2(x)∇Ψ2(x) · ∇Pε(x, t)dx = − 1 2ZZω(t) ∆Ψ2 2(x)Pε(x, t)dx. By applying the second Green's formula (3.5) with u = Pε, v = Ψ2 conditions (2.18), (2.19), we represent this integral in the form 2, and the boundary ZZω(t) Ψ2(x)∇Ψ2(x) · ∇Pε(x, t)dx = − 1 2ZZω(t) Ψ2 2(x)∆Pε(x, t)dx. (3.16) This integral still contains the unknown density of contact pressure Pε(x, t). Let us define M(j)Pε(t) ≡ZZω(t) Ψj 2(x)∆Pε(x, t)dx. (3.17) Now we rewrite the relation (3.12) by using the results for all integrals (3.13) -- (3.16) in the following form: 2(1 + e2 2)KF (t) = µA1,1(ωε(t)) − µδε(t)A0,1(ωε(t)) + µε 2 M(2)Pε(t). (3.18) Here, we have introduced the Volterra operator K as follows: KF (t) = F (t) + χ F (τ )dτ. (3.19) tZ0 Note that the integral in the right-hand side of the equation (3.18) allows to continue the same procedure to deliver an asymptotic estimate for this equation. We continue to proceed with Eq. (3.18) on the next steps. 3.3 Asymptotic estimates of the integral characteristics M(j)Pε(t) Now we proceed to calculate the last integral in (3.18). For this we multiply the governing integral equation (2.14) by Ψj 2(x) (j ≥ 2) and integrate over contact domain ω(t): ZZω(t) Ψj 2(x)∆Pε(x, t)dx + χZZω(t) = µZZω(t) − µεZZω(t) Ψj 10 Ψj 2(x)∆Pε(x, τ )dτ dx = tZ0 2(x)Ψ1(x)dx − µδε(t)ZZω(t) Ψj 2(x)dx Ψj 2(x)∇Ψ2(x) · ∇Pε(x, t)dx. (3.20) By using the same argument as on the previous step, we get KM(j)Pε(t) = µA1,j − µδε(t)A0,j(a; β) − µεZZω(t) Ψj 2(x)∇Ψ2(x) · ∇Pε(x, t)dx. (3.21) For the last integral we use the relations Ψj 2(x)∇Ψ2(x) = 1 j + 1∇Ψj+1 2 (x) and ZZω(t) ∇Ψj+1 2 (x) · ∇Pε(x, t)dx = −ZZω(t) ∆Ψj+1 2 (x)Pε(x, t)dx. Therefore, the integral M(j)Pε(t) = µK−1(cid:26)A1,j(ωε(t)) − δε(t)A0,j(ωε(t)) + ε j + 1KM(j+1)Pε(t)(cid:27) (3.22) has been obtained as a solution of the integral equation (3.21). Here the inverse operator K−1 is defined by the formula K−1Y (t) = Y (t) − χ tZ0 Y (τ )e−χ(t−τ )dτ. (3.23) Performing the same computation, we obtain the following representation for the integral in the right-hand side of (3.18): M(2)Pε(t) = 2εj−1 (j + 1)! NXj=1 µjK−j {A1,j+1(ωε(t)) − δε(t)A0,j+1(ωε(t))} + 2εN (N + 2)! Substituting this representation into Eq. µNK−NM(N +2)Pε(t). (3.18), we finally get 2(1 + e2 2)KF (t) = NXj=0 + εj (j + 1)! µj+1K−j {A1,j+1(ωε(t)) − δε(t)A0,j+1(ωε(t))} εN +1 (N + 2)! µN +1K−NM(N +2)Pε(t), or equivalently 2(1 + e2 2)KN +1F (t) = εj (j + 1)! NXj=0 µj+1KN −j {A1,j+1(ωε(t)) − δε(t)A0,j+1(ωε(t))} 11 (3.24) (3.25) + εN +1 (N + 2)! µN +1M(N +2)Pε(t). (3.26) The latter relation allows us to determine the problem parameters asymptotically with any prescribed accuracy. Note that apart from the fact that the shapes of the contacting bones are elliptical paraboloids, no additional assumptions on the shape of the contact zone have been made. On the other hand, no proof was offered to show that the contact zone is approximately represented by an ellipse. This will be done later. Remark 1. For every t for which the contact pressure Pε(t) is bounded and the contact region ω(t) belongs to a bounded domain, the remainder εN+1 (N +2)! µN +1M(N +2)Pε(t) in formula (3.26) tends to zero as N → ∞. Thus, the series corresponding to the sum on the right hand-side of (3.26) is converging. 4 Asymptotic solution to the contact problem 4.1 Zero-order approximation First, we get solution of the problem for ε = 0. In this case Eq. (2.14) has the form ∆P (0)(x, t) + χ tZ0 ∆P (0)(x, τ )dτ = µ(cid:0)Ψ1(x) − δ(0)(t)(cid:1) , (4.1) where Ψ1(x) is defined in (2.15). Since we know from [5] that the contact zone is an ellipse at this stage of approximation we will have δε = δ(0)(t) = δε(b0(t); β0(t)) = A1,0(ω0(t)) A0,0(ω0(t)) . (4.2) Using formula (4.2) and calculations presented in Section 6.1 (see formula (6.6)), one can find that and therefore A0,0(ω0(t)) = πb2 0 β0 , A1,0(ω0(t)) = πb4 0 4β3 0(cid:0)β2 0 + e2 1(cid:1) , δ(0)(t) = b2 0 (β2 0 + e2 1) 4β2 0 . Note that formulas (4.3) and (4.4) contain two known constants e1 and e2 defined in (2.15) and two still unknown functions b0(t) and β0(t), which are the main semi-axis and the eccentricity of the ellipse ω0(t) =(cid:26)x ∈ R2 : β2 0(t)x2 2 b2 0(t) ≤ 1(cid:27) . + x2 1 b2 0(t) 12 (4.3) (4.4) (4.5) πb6 0 24β5 0(cid:8)3β4 0(cid:8)3β4 πb6 0 48β5 2(cid:9) , 2(cid:9) . 1e2 2(1 + e2 2)KF (t) = µ 0 − (e2 1 + e2 2)β2 0 + 3e2 To find the functions b0(t) and β0(t) together with the pressure distribution over the contact zone, P (0)(x, t), we follow [5] and introduce a new unknown function p(0)(x, t) = P (0)(x, t) + χ tZ0 P (0)(x, τ )dτ = KP (0)(x, t). (4.10) In the case of monotone external load, this function should satisfy the Poisson equation (following from (2.9)) ∆p(0)(x, t) = µ(cid:0)Ψ1(x) − δ(0)(t)(cid:1) , x ∈ ω0(t), with the boundary conditions (2.18), (2.19). It is customary to rewrite this relation in the form G0(x, t) = 0, where (4.7) (4.8) (4.9) (4.11) (4.12) (4.13) (4.14) The leading terms in (3.26) imply (for N = 0) the following equation: 2(1 + e2 2)KF (t) = µA1,1(ω0(t)) − µδ(0)(t)A0,1(ω0(t)). (4.6) Here, K is the Volterra integral operator defined in (3.19). Analogously, using some results from Section 6.1 (see, in particular, formula (6.6)), we obtain and and thus A0,1(ω0(t)) = 0 + e2 πb4 0 4β3 0 (cid:0)β2 2(cid:1) A1,1(ω0(t)) = 0 + (e2 1 + e2 2)β2 0 + 3e2 1e2 G0(x, t) = G0(b0, β0, δ0) ≡ ∆p(0)(x, t) − µ(cid:0)Ψ1(x) − δ(0)(t)(cid:1) , x ∈ ω0(t). Bearing in mind that the function Ψ1(x) is a quadratic polynomial (compare with (2.15)), it is natural to look for the solution of such problem in the form of a polynomial in x1, x2 of the fourth degree, that is p(0)(b0, β0, η0, x, t) = η0(t)(cid:18)1 − x2 1 0 − b2 β2 0x2 2 b2 0 (cid:19) Q0(x1, x2). (4.15) 13 Note that the term in the brackets vanishes on the boundary ω0, and thus the condition (2.18) is satisfied automatically. In Section 6.2, it has been shown that Q0 is a polynomial of the second order having the form so that x2 1 0 − b2 Q0(x1, x2) =(cid:18)1 − p(0)(x1, x2; t) = η0(t)(cid:18)1 − β2 0x2 2 b2 0 (cid:19) , 0 (cid:19)2 x2 1 0 − b2 β2 0x2 2 b2 (4.16) (4.17) . Taken into account this representation we arrive at the following relations (see Section 6.3): η0(t) = µδ(0)(t) 4(1 + β2 0) b2 0, η0(t) = η0(t) = µb4 0 2(6 + 2β2 0) µb4 0 + 6β4 0) 0e2 1 2(2β2 = = µb4 0 , 4(3 + β2 0) 0e2 1 µb4 0(1 + 3β2 0) 4β2 (4.18) (4.19) (4.20) . This system allows us to determine the unknown functions b0(t) and β0(t). Indeed, eliminating η0 from the last two equations, we get a bi-quadratic equation defining the value of the parameter β0, i.e., By definition, β0 is a positive parameter, thus the unique positive solution of (4.21) has the form 3β4 0 + (1 − e2 1)β2 0 − 3e2 1 = 0. (4.21) β0 =s (e2 1 − 1) +pe4 6 1 + 34e2 1 + 1 . (4.22) Note that at the zero-approximation the parameter β0 does not depend on time. The other parameter, η0(t), can be computed directly from (4.19) or (4.20), if one knows the remaining constant b0(t). Moreover, taking into account (4.18) and (4.4), one can use an equivalent formula η0(t) = µb4 16β2 0 + e2 0(β2 1) 0(1 + β2 0) . (4.23) In the same way, one can offer, in addition to (4.4), two equivalent representations for the indentation parameter δ(0)(t) = 1 + β2 0 3 + β2 0 b2 0(t) = 0)e2 (1 + β2 1 0(1 + 3β2 β2 0) b2 0(t). (4.24) Finally, the major semi-axis b0 of the ellipse ω0 is determined as follows: b0(t) =F (t) + χ tZ0 F (τ )dτ(cid:18) µπ(3β4 96β5 0 − β2 0(1 + e2 2) 2) + 3e2 1 + e2 0(e2 1e2 14 1/6 2)(cid:19) . (4.25) Note that the parameters b0, η0 as well as the indentation, δ0, depend on time t in contrast to the ellipse eccentricity β0. Now, it remains only to find the pressure over the contact area. Using (4.10) and (4.17), we get P (0)(b0, β0, η0, x1, x2, t) = K−1(cid:0)η0(t)Q0(x1, x2)2(cid:1) . 0(t) − β2 b2 1 x2 1 0(t) − b2 If (x1, x2) belongs to the initial contact zone, i.e. 1 − x2 P (0)(x1, x2, t) = η0(t)(cid:18)1 − η0(τ )(cid:18)1 − 0(t) − β2 If (x1, x2) lies outside of the initial contact zone, i.e. 1 − x2 P (0)(x1, x2, t) = η0(t)(cid:18)1 − η0(τ )(cid:18)1 − 0(t)(cid:19)2 β2 0 x2 2 b2 0(t)(cid:19)2 x2 1 0(t) − b2 tZt∗(x1,x2) 0x2 β2 2 b2 tZ0 − χ −χ b2 1 x2 1 0(τ ) − b2 x2 1 0(τ ) − b2 0 x2 0(t) > 0, then 2 b2 β2 0x2 2 b2 0(τ )(cid:19)2 e−χ(t−τ )dτ. (4.27) 0x2 0(t) < 0, then 2 b2 (4.26) 0x2 β2 2 b2 0(τ )(cid:19)2 e−χ(t−τ )dτ. (4.28) The critical moment of time t∗ is determined by the formula b2 0(t∗) = x2 1 + β2 0x2 2. Using (4.25), we get F (t∗) + χ t∗Z0 F (τ )dτ = µπ 96β5 0(cid:18)3β4 0 − β2 0(e2 1 + e2 1 + e2 2 2) + 3e2 1e2 2 (cid:19) (x2 1 + β2 0x2 2)3. (4.29) If the load is stepwise, we have F (t) = F0. Hence, we find that t∗ = µπ 96β5 0χF0(cid:20)(3β4 0 − β2 0(e2 1 + e2 1 + e2 2 2) + 3e2 1e2 2) (x2 1 + β2 0x2 2)3(cid:21) − 1 χ . (4.30) Note that in this case b6 0(t∗) = 96β5 0(1 + e2 0 − β2 0(e2 µπ(3β4 2)(1 + χt∗) 1 + e2 2) + 3e2 1e2 2) F0. (4.31) This finishes the zero iteration step. Note that the results of this Section after changing the notation coincide with those obtained in [4]. 15 4.2 First-order approximation problem For the next steps we consider an appropriately deformed contact domain ω(1) ε , defined as a perturbation of the zero-order one ω0. Namely, we assume that it can be written in the form ω(1) ε = ω(1) ε (t) =n(x1, x2) : Q0(x, t) + εQ1(x, t) ≥ 0o, where unknown polynomials are taken in the forms Q0(x, t) = Q0(x, β1, b1), Q1(x, t) = a40(t)x4 1 + a22(t)x2 1x2 2 + a04(t)x4 2. (4.32) (4.33) (4.34) Note that for ε = 0 the solution form coincides with (4.5), if one take b1 ≡ b0, β1 ≡ β0. The idea behind such choice of the asymptotic anzatz is to satisfy the boundary condi- tions (2.18) and (2.19) automatically. This will be archived by putting P (1) ε = K−1(cid:16)η(1)(t)(cid:0)Q0(x1, x2, β1(t), b1(t)) + εQ1(x, t)(cid:1)2(cid:17). Now, when the boundary conditions are valid, we will satisfy the governing equation (2.9). Note that P (1) ε = P0 + εP1 + O(ε2), where pj = K(Pj), j = 0, 1, and p0 = η(1)(t)(cid:18)1 − p1 = 2η(1)(t)(cid:18)1 − K(cid:0)∆(P (0) + εP1 + O(ε2))(cid:1) = µ(cid:0)Ψ1 − δ(1) Substituting this representation into Eq. , β2 1(t)x2 2 b2 x2 1 1(t) − b2 β2 1(t)x2 2 b2 1(t) (cid:19)2 1(t) (cid:19) Q1(x, t). x2 1 1(t) − b2 (2.9), we obtain where the parameter δ(1) ε is represented in the same form as P (1) ε , i.e., ε − ε∇Ψ2 · (∇P (0) + ε∇P (1) + O(ε2))(cid:1) , (4.35) (4.36) (4.37) (4.38) (4.39) (4.40) (4.41) δ(1) ε = δ0 + εδ1 + O(ε2) = δ(1) + O(ε2). We can write Eq. (4.39) with the accuracy to the terms of O(ε2) as follows: ∆p(0) + ε∆p1 = µ(cid:0)Ψ1 − δ(1) − ε∇Ψ2 · ∇P (0)(cid:1) . An extended variant of this equation can be written by using the definition of all com- ponents of the equation and by comparing coefficients at different powers of x1, x2, so that 16 4η(1) b2 1 − (1 + β2 1) = −µδ(1), 1 4η(1)(cid:20)3 + β2 4η(1)(cid:20) β2 1(1 + 3β2 1) + ε(6a40 + a22)(cid:21) = µ(1 − 8εθ2,0), + ε(a22 + 6a04)(cid:21) = µ(e2 1 − 8εe2 b4 1 b4 1 2θ2,2), 24η(1) b2 1 − ε (a40β2 1 + a22(1 + β2 1) + a04) = 8εµ(1 + e2 2)θ4,2, 4η(1) b2 1 − ε 4η(1) − ε b2 1 (a40(15 + β2 1) + a22) = 8εµθ4,0, (a04(15β2 1 + 1) + a22β2 1) = 8εµe2 2θ4,4, (4.42) (4.43) (4.44) (4.45) (4.46) (4.47) (4.48) where θ2k,2l(t) = K−1(cid:0)η(1)b−2k 1 β2l 1(cid:1) , k, l = 0, 1, 2. In the system (4.42) -- (4.47) we have 6 equations and 7 unknowns: η(1)(t), δ(1) ε , b1(t), β1(t), and a40, a22, a04 (coefficients of the polynomial Q1). Therefore, we have to add an extra equation to the above system, namely δ(1)(t) = A1,0(ωε(t)) A0,0(ωε(t)) + 2(1 + e2 2)ε A0,0(ωε(t)) F1(t), (4.49) where F1(t) can be represented in the form F1(t) =ZZω(1) ε P (1) ε (x, t)dx. We also make use of Eq. O(ε2) in the form (3.26) written for this approximation step with the accuracy of 2(1 + e2 2)K2F (t) = 1Xj=0 εj (j + 1)! µj+1K1−j(cid:8)A1,j+1(ωε(t)) − δ(1)(t)A0,j+1(ωε(t))(cid:9) . (4.50) Remark 2. Note that putting ε = 0, the system (4.42) -- (4.47), (4.49) transforms to the previous case evaluated in the previous section. Remark 3. In the case when ε > 0, the system (4.42) -- (4.47), (4.49) has to be solved numerically. Note that the parameter ε in the last three equations (4.45) -- (4.47) can be canceled. We left these multipliers here to explain the limiting case (ε = 0). 17 5 Discussion and conclusion First of all, observe that at t = 0, the contact problem for biphasic layers reduces to that for elastic incompressible layers. The contact problem in the latter case were studied in a number of papers [1, 9, 10, 16], however, without taking into account the tangential displacements. To solve the resulting problem (4.42) -- (4.47) and (4.49), we suggest the following iterative algorithm: • Taking ε = 0, we have computed all values η, b, β, δ = η0, b0, β0, δ0 from the zero-order approximation. • Having them we can compute the quantity θ2k,2l(t) from (4.48), • Then, from the system of three equations (4.45) -- (4.47) we compute the constants a40, a22, a04 assuming the values of η, b, β as above. • Finally from the system of four equations (4.42) -- (4.44) and (4.49) considering the right- hand side known (computed by the values know from the previous computations), we found new values η, b, β, δ and compare them with the previous computations. If the required accuracy has achieved we stop the computation, if not we are going to the second step of this iterative procedure. We note that formulas (2.4) and (2.5) for the vertical and tangential displacements contain different powers of parameters ǫ, namely, ǫ2 and ǫ, respectively. Note also that our analysis (with the values of another parameters taken into account) shows, that the role of these magnitudes (vertical and tangential displacements) is quite opposite. In the final equation (see (2.14)) the leading terms, corresponding to the vertical displacement, contain the zero power of the new small parameter ε, but the leading terms, corresponding to the tangential displacements, contain the first power of ε. References [1] Aleksandrov, V.M. Asymptotic solution of the axisymmetric contact problem for an elastic layer of incompressible material. J. Appl. Math. Mech. 67, 589 -- 593 (2003) [2] Argatov, I. Development of an asymptotic modeling methodology for tibio-femoral con- tact in multibody dynamic simulations of the human knee joint. Multibody Syst. Dyn. 28, 3 -- 20 (2012). [3] Argatov, I. Contact problem for a thin elastic layer with variable thickness: Application to sensitivity analysis of articular contact mechanics. Appl. Math. Model. 37, 8383 -- 8393 (2013). 18 [4] Argatov, I., Mishuris, G. Axisymmetric contact problem for a biphasic cartilage layer with allowance for tangential displacements on the contact surface. Eur. J. Mech. A/Solids 29, 1051 -- 1064 (2010). [5] Argatov, I., Mishuris, G. Elliptical contact of thin biphasic cartilage layer: Exact solu- tion for monotonic loading. J. Biomech. 44, 759 -- 761 (2011). [6] Argatov, I., Mishuris, G. Frictionless elliptical contact of thin viscoelastic layers bonded to rigid substrates. Applied Math. Model. 35, 3201 -- 3212 (2011). [7] Argatov, I., Mishuris, G. Contact problem for thin biphasic cartilage layers: perturba- tion solution. Quart. J. Mech. Appl. Math. 64, 297 -- 318 (2011). [8] Ateshian, G.A., Lai, W.M., Zhu, W.B., Mow, V.C. Anasymptotic solution for the con- tact of two biphasic cartilage layers. J. Biomech. 27, 1347 -- 1360 (1994). [9] Barber, J.R.: Contact problems for the thin elastic layer. Int. J. Mech. Sci. 32, 129 -- 132 (1990). [10] Chadwick, R.S. Axisymmetric indentation of a thin incompressible elastic layer. SIAM J. Appl. Math. 62, 1520 -- 1530 (2002). [11] Hunziker, E. B. Articular cartilage repair: basic science and clinical progress. A review of the current status and prospects. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage. 10, 432 -- 463 (2001). [12] Johnson, K. L. Contact Mechanics. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press (1985). [13] Owen, J. R., Wayne, J. S. Contact models of repaired articular surfaces: influence of loading conditions and the superficial tangential zone. Biomech Model Mechanobiol. 10, 461 -- 471 (2011). [14] Wu, J. Z., Herzog, W., and Ronsky, J. Modeling axi-symmetrical joint contact with biphasic cartilage layers -- An asymptotic solution. J. Biomech. 29, 1263 -- 1281 (1996). [15] Wu, J. Z., Herzog, W., and Epstein, M. An improved solution for the contact of two biphasic cartilage layers. J. Biomech. 30, 371 -- 375 (1997). [16] Yang, F. Indentation of an incompressible elastic film. Mech. Mater. 30, 275 -- 286 (1998). 19 6 Appendix 6.1 Calculation of the constants Akl Here, we compute the values of the constants Ak,l(b; β) =ZZω(t) Ψk 1(x)Ψl 2(x)dx > 0, k, l = 0, 1, 2, . . . First of all, we note that an unknown contact domain ω(t) is of the same type as sections of the initial gap elliptical paraboloid, i.e., it is an ellipse coaxial to the ellipse ω(t) = ωε(t) =(cid:26)x ∈ R2 : x2 1 b2(t; ε) + x2 2β2(t; ε) b2(t; ε) ≤ 1(cid:27) . In order to avoid long formulas, we use the short notation for ω(t), writing all parameters without variables they depend on, i.e., ω(t) =(cid:26)x ∈ R2 : x2 1 b2 + 2β2 x2 b2 ≤ 1(cid:27) . Performing the standard change of variables x1 = br cos θ, x2 = b β sin θ, we represent the integral for Ak,l(t) in the form Ak,l(b; β) = 1Z0 2πZ0 (cid:18)b2r2 cos2 θ + b2e2 2 β2 r2 sin2 θ(cid:19)l b2 β b2e2 1 β2 r2 sin2 θ(cid:19)k(cid:18)b2r2 cos2 θ + 2πZ0 kXi=0 i!(k − i)! k! e2i 1 β2i sin2i θ cos2k−2i θ r2k+2l+1dr = b2k+2l+2 β 1Z0 = × lXj=0 l! j!(l − j)! b2k+2l+2 (2k + 2l + 2)β × lXj=0 l! j!(l − j)! e2j 2 β2j sin2j θ cos2l−2j θdθ 2πZ0 kXi=0 k! i!(k − i)! e2i 1 β2i sin2i θ cos2k−2i θ e2j 2 β2j sin2j θ cos2l−2j θdθ. 20 rdrdθ (6.1) (6.2) Since the trigonometric functions are presented here only in even powers, then the last integration can be performed over the interval [0, π/2] as follows: Ak,l(b; β) = 4b2k+2l+2 (2k + 2l + 2)β π/2Z0 kXi=0 k! i!(k − i)! e2i 1 β2i sin2i θ cos2k−2i θ × lXj=0 l! j!(l − j)! e2j 2 β2j sin2j θ cos2l−2j θdθ = 4b2k+2l+2 (2k + 2l + 2)β × lXj=0 l! j!(l − j)! kXi=0 e2j 2 β2j k! i!(k − i)! e2i 1 β2i π/2Z0 sin2i+2j θ cos2k−2i+2l−2j θdθ. (6.3) The integrals in (6.3) are calculated by using formulas π/2Z0 sin2p θ cos2q θdθ = 1 2 Γ(p + 1/2)Γ(q + 1/2) Γ(p + q + 1) , p, q > 0, (6.4) and Legendre's duplication formula for the Gamma-function Γ(n + 1/2) = √2πΓ(2n) 22n−1/2Γ(n) , n ∈ N, (6.5) as well as the relation Γ(n + 1) = n!. Finally, we arrive at the following representation of Ak,l = Ak,l(b; β) valid for all k, l ∈ N0 = N ∪ {0}: Ak,l = 2πb2 (b/2)2k+2l β(2k + 2l + 2)(k + l)! kXi=0 k! i!(k − i)! e2i 1 β2i × lXj=0 l! j!(l − j)! e2j 2 β2j (2i + 2j)!(2k − 2i + 2l − 2j)! (i + j)!(k − i + l − j)! (6.6) . 6.2 Computation of the polynomial Q0 In order to determine the coefficients of the polynomial Q0(x1, x2) = 1 + q1,0x1 + q0,1x2 + q2,0x2 1 + q1,1x1x2 + q0,2x2 2, we need to compute the normal derivative of the unknown functions p(0) (4.15) along the elliptic boundary Γ: ∂p(0) ∂n Γ = ∇p(0) · −→n Γ = η0(t)(cid:18)− 2x2 1 0 − b2 2β4 0x2 2 b2 0 (cid:19) Q0Γ = 0. 21 (6.7) Here we take into account the fact that, since the contact domain is an ellipse (4.5), the tangential and normal vectors to the boundary Γ = ∂Ω are given by Then, to satisfy the boundary condition (2.19) the following equation should be valid: −→r =(cid:0)−β2 0x2, x1(cid:1) , −→n =(cid:0)x1, β2 0x2(cid:1) . (6.8) (6.9) (6.10) , (6.11) (6.12) (6.13) (6.14) (6.15) (6.16) This, in turn, is equivalent to the representation Q0Γ = 0. Q0(x1, x2) =(cid:18)1 − x2 1 0 − b2 β2 0x2 2 b2 0 (cid:19) . 6.3 Evaluation of the ellipse parameters Since we have Therefore, by straightforward computations, we find that β2 0x2 2 b2 0 (cid:19)2 0 (cid:19) , 0 (cid:21) . 2x1 b2 p(0)(x, t) = p(0)(x1, x2, t) = η0(t)(cid:18)1 − x2 1 0 − b2 ∂p(0) ∂x1 ∂2p(0) ∂x2 1 x2 1 0 − b2 x2 1 0 − b2 2 b2 2 b2 0 ∂2p(0) ∂x2 1 = 2η0(t)(cid:18)1 − 0(cid:18)1 − = 2η0(cid:20)− = 2η0(cid:20)− = 2η0(cid:18)1 − x2 1 0 − b2 0 (cid:18)1 − x2 1 0 − b2 = 2η0(t)(cid:20)− 2β2 0 b2 0 2β2 0 b2 + ∂p(0) ∂x2 = 2η0(cid:20)− β2 0x2 2 b2 β2 0x2 2 b2 2x1 b2 2x1 b2 0 0 (cid:19) ·(cid:18)− 0 (cid:19) + 0 (cid:21) . 0 (cid:19) , 2β2 0x2 2 b4 + 0x2 β2 2 b2 β2 0x2 2 b2 0 (cid:19) ·(cid:18)− 0 (cid:19) + 2β2 0x2 b2 2β2 0x2 b2 0 6x2 1 b4 0 + 0x2 6β4 2 b4 0 (cid:21) . 2β2 0x2 b2 0 (cid:21) . ∂2p(0) ∂x2 2 Thus, we obtain 0x2 2β2 1 b4 0 Substituting (6.13) and (6.15) into the main equation ∂2p(0) ∂x2 2 + where G0 = 2η0(t)(cid:20)(−2) G0(b0, β0, δ0) ≡ ∆p(0)(x, t) − µ(cid:0)Ψ1(x) − δ(0)(t)(cid:1) = 0, 1 + β2 0 b2 0 +(cid:18) 6 + 2β2 0 (cid:19) x2 1 +(cid:18) 6β4 b4 0 b4 0 0 + 2β2 0 22 2(cid:21) − µ(cid:0)Ψ1(x1, x2) − δ(0)(t)(cid:1) , (cid:19) x2 and taking into account that Ψ1(x) = Ψ1(x1, x2) = x2 1 + e2 1x2 2, one concludes that the expression for G0 is represented by a second order polynomial with respect to the independent variables x1 and x2 in the following form: G0(b0, β0, η0, δ(0)) = q0(b0, β0, η0, δ(0)) + q1(b0, β0, η0)x2 1 + q2(b0, β0, η0)x2 2. (6.17) Here the coefficients are defined as follows: q0(b0, β0, η0, δ(0)) = 4η0 µb2 0 (1 + β2 0) − δ(0), q1(b0, β0, η0) = (3 + β2 0) − µ, q2(b0, β0, η0) = (1 + 3β2 0) − µe2 1. 4η0 b4 0 4η0β2 0 b4 0 6.4 Auxiliary computation Taking into account (4.37), we can represent p0(x, t) in the form p0(x, t) = η(1)(t)(cid:18)1 − 2x2 1 1 − b2 1x2 2β2 2 b2 1 + Hence, applying the Laplace equation, we get 2β2 1x2 2 1x2 b4 1 + x4 1 b4 1 + (1 + β2 1) + x2 1 4 b4 1 (3 + β2 1) + x2 2 4β2 1 b4 1 (1 + 3β2 Next, by using representation (4.38), we can write p1(x, t) in the form 1x4 β4 2 b4 1 (cid:19) . 1)(cid:19) . (6.18) (6.19) (6.20) (6.21) (6.22) (6.24) (6.25) 4 b2 1 ∆p0(x, t) = η(1)(t)(cid:18)− p1(x, t) = 2η(1)(t)(cid:18)a40x4 − Therefore, we obtain 1 + a22x2 1x2 2 + a04x4 1x2 2 1x4 a40β2 b2 1 1x4 2 1x2 a22β2 b2 1 − − a40x6 1 2 − 1x6 a04β2 2 b2 1 − b2 1 (cid:19) . 1x2 a22x4 2 1 − b2 1x4 2 a04x2 b2 1 (6.23) ∆p1(x, t) = 2η(1)(t)(cid:18)(12a40 + 2a22)x2 1 + (2a22 + 12a04)x2 2 12β2 1a40 + 12a22(1 + β2 1) + 12a04 x2 1x2 2 − − b2 1 a40(30 + 2β2 1) + 2a22 b2 1 23 x4 1 − 2a22β2 1 + a04(2 + 30β2 1) b2 1 x4 2(cid:19). We also use the following representations: Ψj(x) = x2 1 + e2 j x2 2, j = 1, 2. Thus, applying the gradient operator, we simply get and It yields the following representation: ∇Ψ2(x) =(cid:0)2x1, 2e2 2x2(cid:1) ∇P0(x, t) =(cid:0)K−1∇p0(x,·)(cid:1) (t). 1 (cid:19)(cid:18)x2 1 (cid:19)(cid:19) (t) + 8x4 x2 1 1 − b2 β2 1x2 2 b2 1 b2 1 b2 + ∇Ψ2(x) · ∇P0(x, t) = −8(cid:18)K−1(cid:20)η(1)(cid:18)1 − = −8x2 1(cid:18)K−1(cid:18)η(1) 2x2 b2 1 (cid:19)(cid:19) (t) − 8e2 2(cid:18)K−1(cid:18)η(1)β2 2(cid:18)K−1(cid:18)η(1)β2 1 (cid:19)(cid:19) (t) + 8e2 1x2 1 1 b4 2θ2,2(t) + 8x4 +8(1 + e2 2)x2 =: −8x2 1θ2,0(t) − 8e2 2x2 (6.26) 2β2 1x2 e2 2 b2 1 (cid:19)(cid:21)(cid:19) (t) 1(cid:18)K−1(cid:18)η(1) 1 (cid:19)(cid:19) (t) b4 1 1 (cid:19)(cid:19) (t) 2x4 2(cid:18)K−1(cid:18)η(1)β4 b4 1θ4,0(t) + 8(1 + e2 2)x2 1x2 2θ4,2(t) + 8e2 2x4 2θ4,4(t). Here we have introduced the notation Combining the above results we obtain the system of equations (4.42) -- (4.47). θ2k,2l =(cid:0)K−1(cid:0)η(1)b−2k 1 β2l 1(cid:1)(cid:1) (t). 24
1503.04669	2	1503	2016-02-19T09:32:53	Alzheimer's disease: a mathematical model for onset and progression	[ "physics.bio-ph", "math.DS", "physics.med-ph", "q-bio.TO" ]	In this paper we propose a mathematical model for the onset and progression of Alzheimer's disease based on transport and diffusion equations. We regard brain neurons as a continuous medium, and structure them by their degree of malfunctioning. Two different mechanisms are assumed to be relevant for the temporal evolution of the disease: i) diffusion and agglomeration of soluble polymers of amyloid, produced by damaged neurons; ii) neuron-to-neuron prion-like transmission. We model these two processes by a system of Smoluchowski equations for the amyloid concentration, coupled to a kinetic-type transport equation for the distribution function of the degree of malfunctioning of neurons. The second equation contains an integral term describing the random onset of the disease as a jump process localised in particularly sensitive areas of the brain. Our numerical simulations are in good qualitative agreement with clinical images of the disease distribution in the brain which vary from early to advanced stages.	physics.bio-ph	physics	ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE: A MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR ONSET AND PROGRESSION MICHIEL BERTSCH, BRUNO FRANCHI, NORINA MARCELLO, MARIA CARLA TESI, AND ANDREA TOSIN Abstract. In this paper we propose a mathematical model for the onset and progression of Alzheimer's disease based on transport and diffusion equations. We regard brain neurons as a continuous medium, and structure them by their degree of malfunctioning. Two different mechanisms are assumed to be relev- ant for the temporal evolution of the disease: i) diffusion and agglomeration of soluble polymers of amyloid, produced by damaged neurons; ii) neuron-to- neuron prion-like transmission. We model these two processes by a system of Smoluchowski equations for the amyloid concentration, coupled to a kinetic- type transport equation for the distribution function of the degree of malfunc- tioning of neurons. The second equation contains an integral term describing the random onset of the disease as a jump process localised in particularly sensitive areas of the brain. Our numerical simulations are in good qualitative agreement with clinical images of the disease distribution in the brain which vary from early to advanced stages. 1. Introduction Alzheimer's disease (AD) is one of the most common late life dementia, with huge social and economic impact [6, 18, 24]. Its global prevalence, about 24 millions in 2011, is expected to double in 20 years [38]. In silico research, based on mathem- atical modelling and computer simulations [1, 8, 10, 13, 17, 28, 36, 42], effectively supplements in vivo and in vitro research. We present a multiscale model for the onset and evolution of AD which accounts for the diffusion and agglomeration of amyloid-β (Aβ) peptide (amyloid cascade hypothesis [16, 22]), and the spreading of the disease through neuron-to-neuron transmission (prionoid hypothesis [7]). Indeed, to cover such diverse facets of AD in a single model, different spatial and temporal scales must be taken into account: microscopic spatial scales to describe the role of the neurons, macroscopic spatial and short temporal (minutes, hours) scales for the description of relevant diffusion processes in the brain, and large temporal scales (years, decades) for the description of the global development of AD. The way in which we combine distinct scales in a single model forms the core and major novelty of the paper. Following closely the biomedical literature on AD, we briefly describe the pro- cesses which we shall include in our model. In the neurons and their interconnec- tions several microscopic phenomena take place. It is largely accepted that beta amyloid (Aβ), especially its highly toxic oligomeric isoforms Aβ40 and Aβ42, play an important role in the process of the cerebral damage (the so-called amyloid cas- cade hypothesis [22]). In this note we focus on the role of Aβ42 in its soluble form, which recently has been suggested to be the principal cause of neuronal death and eventually dementia [43]. At the level of the neuronal membrane, monomeric Aβ peptides originate from the proteolytic cleavage of a transmembrane glycoprotein, 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification. 35M13, 35Q92, 92B99. Key words and phrases. Alzheimer's disease, transport and diffusion equations, Smoluchowski equations, numerical simulations. 1 2 M. BERTSCH, B. FRANCHI, N. MARCELLO, M. C. TESI, AND A. TOSIN the amyloid precursor protein (APP). By unknown and partially genetic reasons, some neurons present an unbalance between produced and cleared Aβ (we refer to such neurons as damaged neurons). In addition to this, it has been proposed that neuronal damage spreads in the neuronal net through a neuron-to-neuron prion-like propagation mechanism [7, 36]. On the other hand, macroscopic phenomena take place at the level of the cereb- ral tissue. The monomeric Aβ produced by damaged neurons diffuses through the microscopic tortuosity of the brain tissue and undergoes a process of agglomeration, leading eventually to the formation of long, insoluble amyloid fibrils, which accu- mulate in spherical deposits known as senile plaques. Moreover, soluble Aβ shows a multiple neurotoxic effect: it induces a general inflammation that activates the microglia (the resident immune cells in the central nervous system) which in turn secretes proinflammatory innate cytokines [15] and, at the same time, increases intracellular calcium levels [13] yielding ultimately apoptosis and neuronal death. The model we present is a conceptual interdisciplinary construction based on clinical and experimental evidence, yielding in particular numerical simulations and related graphs, that can be compared with time-dependent trajectories of AD biomarkers (see e.g., [20, 21]). In particular, Figure 2 fits the core of the model proposed in [20] for the temporal progression of the abnormalities in AD biomarkers, which identifies two subsequent periods: − a first period of β-amyloidosis characterised prevalently by reductions in CSF Aβ42 and increased amyloid plaque formation (biomarkers of this first period in our model correspond to CSF-Aβ42 and PIB-PET, Pittsburgh compound B - Positron Emission Tomography); − a second one characterised by neuronal dysfunction and neurodegeneration (for this period we only take into account the structural MRI). Of particular medical interest is the initial stage of the second period, which is commonly referred to as Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI): see e.g., [33]. 2. Mathematical model Highly toxic oligomeric isoforms of beta amyloid, Aβ40 and Aβ42, cause cereb- ral damage. Here we restrict our attention to Aβ42 (shortly Aβ in the sequel) in soluble form, generally considered the principal cause of neuronal death and dementia [43]. Monomeric Aβ peptides originate from proteolytic cleavage of a transmembrane glycoprotein, the amyloid precursor protein (APP). In AD, neur- ons progressively present an unbalance between produced and cleared Aβ, but the underlying mechanism is still largely unknown. On the other hand it was proposed that neuronal damage spreads in the neural pathway through a neuron-to-neuron prion-like propagation mechanism [7, 36]. Soluble Aβ diffuses through the microscopic tortuosity of the brain tissue and undergoes an agglomeration process. Eventually this leads to the formation of long, insoluble fibrils, accumulating in spherical deposits known as senile plaques. Soluble Aβ has a multiple neurotoxic effect [13, 15]. In our model we do not enter the details of the brain tissue, we neglect the action of the τ -protein, we simplify the role of microglia and neglect its multifaceted mechanism (see e.g., [10] and [35]). We simply assume that high levels of soluble amyloid are toxic for neurons. We identify a portion of the cerebral tissue with a 3-dimensional region Ω and x ∈ Ω indicates a generic point. Two temporal scales are needed to simulate the longitudinal evolution of the disease over a period of years: a short (i.e., rapid) s- scale (unit time coincides with hours) for the diffusion and agglomeration of Aβ [25], and a long (i.e., slow) t-scale (unit time coincides with several months) for the progression of AD, so ∆t = ε∆s for a small constant ε (cid:28) 1. ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE: A MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR ONSET AND PROGRESSION 3 We denote the molar concentration of soluble Aβ polymers of length m at point x and time s by um(x, s), with 1 ≤ m < N . That of clusters of oligomers of length ≥ N (fibrils) is denoted by uN (x, s) and may be thought as a medical parameter (the plaques), clinically observable through PIB-PET ( [30]). To model the aggregation of Aβ m-polymers (1 < m < N ) we follow [1], [variation in (short) time] = [diffusion] + [agglomeration], which, in mathematical terms, leads to the Smoluchowski equation with diffusion:  1 2 m−1(cid:88) N(cid:88)  . (1) ∂sum = dm∇2um + aj,m−jujum−j − um am,juj j=1 j=1 where dm > 0, m = 1, . . . , N , and ai,j = aj,i > 0, i, j = 1, . . . , N (giving the factor 1 2 in (1)). We refer to [1, 12] for an extensive discussion of (1). For reasons related to the model, we can assume that the diffusion coefficients dm are small when m is large, since big assemblies do not move. In fact, the diffusion coefficient of a soluble peptide scales approximately as a reciprocal of the cube root of its molecular weight (see [14] and also [29]). Applications of the Smoluchowski equation to the description of the agglomera- tion of Aβ amyloid appear in [28]. In this paper, the authors compare experimental data, obtained in vitro, with numerical simulations based on the Smoluchowski equation (without diffusion) in order to describe the process leading to insoluble fibril aggregates from soluble amyloid. The form of the coefficients ai,j (the coagu- lation rates) we use has been considered by in vitro Murphy & Pallitto (see [28] and [32]). According to formula (13) in [28], the coagulation rates in silico in our equations take the form (2) ai,j = const. 1 i + j · + ln(j/d) + νj j i (cid:18) ln(i/d) + νi (cid:19) , where i, j are the lengths of the fibrils, d is their diameter, and νi = 0.312 + 0.565(i/d)−1 − 0.1(i/d)−2. The physical arguments leading to formula (2) rely on sophisticated statistical mechanics considerations (see also [40]). νi = ν for = 1, . . . , N − 1. Thus we can replace (2) by Since d can be assumed very small, without loss of generality we can assume (cid:19) ·(cid:0)ν + ln d + O(ln N )(cid:1). (3) ai,j = const. 1 i + j · + ln(j/d) + ν j = 1 ij i (cid:18) ln(i/d) + ν Since N is finite, in our numerical simulations we use a slightly approximate form of these coefficients, taking (4) ai,j = α 1 ij , where α > 0. Smoluchowski equations with diffusion have already been considered in the lit- erature (without reference to Aβ amyloid and Alzheimer's disease) with diverse boundary conditions: see for instance [9] for a general introduction, and [23, 2, 44, 4, 3]. term F: Neurons produce Aβ monomers, whence the equation for u1 contains a source (5) ∂su1 = d1∇2u1 − u1 a1,juj + F. N(cid:88) j=1 4 M. BERTSCH, B. FRANCHI, N. MARCELLO, M. C. TESI, AND A. TOSIN Since fibrils are assumed not to move, the equation for uN has no diffusion term, and takes the form (see (4) in [1]): (6) ∂suN = 1 2 aj,kujuk. (cid:88) j+k≥N k, j<N (cid:88) j+k≥N N(cid:88) j=1 N−1(cid:88) m−1(cid:88) j=1 m−1(cid:88) (cid:88) It is coherent with experimental data to assume aN,N = 0 for large N . This is equivalent to saying that large oligomers do not aggregate with each other. The justification of the condition j, k < N in (6) requires a few more words. In fact, we must remember that the meaning of uN differs from that of um, m < N , as well as the identity (7) 1 2 j+k≥N,k<N,j<N aj,kujuk = 1 2 aj,kujuk − uN aN,juj. The idea is that uN should describe the sum of the densities of all the "large" assem- blies. We assume that large assemblies exhibit all the same coagulation properties and do not coagulate with each other. Let us briefly show how (6) is obtained: we start by writing the exact Smoluchowski equation for all m ≥ 1 using um instead of um in order to avoid confusion, i.e. nothing but the PDE in (1) with m ranging from 2 to ∞. We have N(cid:88) j=1 (8) um = dm∇2 um − um ∂ ∂t am,j uj + 1 2 aj,m−j uj um−j, where, coherently with our assumptions, we assume i) dm = dN for m ≥ N ; ii) am,j = aN,j for m ≥ N . In particular, if m, j ≥ N , am,j = aN,j = aN,N = 0. Therefore, if m ≥ N , (8) becomes ∂ ∂t um = dN∇2 um − um (9) aN,j uj + Now we sum up (9) for m ≥ N , and we set for a while v :=(cid:80) m−1(cid:88) m≥N um. We want to show precisely that v satisfies the equation (6) (satisfied by uN ). By i), we have aj,m−j uj um−j, N−1(cid:88) (cid:88) j=1 j=1 1 2 um aN,j uj + ai,m−i ui um−i 1 2 m≥N i=1 ∂v ∂t = dN∇2v − (cid:88) m≥N := dN∇2v − I1 + j=1 1 2 I2. It is clear that I1 = (cid:88) m≥N N−1(cid:88) j=1 N−1(cid:88) j=1 aN,j uj, aN,j uj = v um that is precisely the second term in (7), since aN,N = 0. As for I2, if we set j := i and k := m − i, we obtain the first term in (7). Finally, if set um = um for m < N and uN = v we recover the PDE in (6), as desired. We model the degree of malfunctioning of a neuron with a parameter a ranging from 0 to 1: a close to 0 stands for "the neuron is healthy" whereas a close to 1 for "the neuron is dead". This parameter, although introduced for the sake of mathematical modelling (see also [36]), can be compared with medical images from Fluorodeoxyglucose PET (FDG-PET [27]). ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE: A MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR ONSET AND PROGRESSION 5 Given x ∈ Ω, t ≥ 0, and a ∈ [0, 1], f (x, a, t) da indicates the fraction of neurons close to x with degree of malfunctioning at time t between a and a + da. The progression of AD occurs at the long time scale t, over decades, and is determined by the deterioration rate, v = v(x, a, t), of the health state of the neurons: (10) ∂tf + ∂a(f v[f ]) = 0. Here v[f ] indicates that the deterioration rate depends on f itself. The onset of AD will be included in a subsequent step. We assume that (cid:90)(cid:90) (11) v[f ] = Ω×[0, 1] K(x, a, y, b)f (y, b, t) dy db + S(x, a, u1(x, s), . . . , uN−1(x, s)). The integral term describes the possible prion-like propagation of AD through the neural pathway. Malfunctioning neighbours are harmful for a neuron's health state, while healthy ones are not: K(x, a, y, b) ≥ 0 K(x, a, y, b) = 0 ∀ x, y ∈ Ω, a, b ∈ [0, 1], if a > b. Typically with, for example, K(x, a, y, b) = G(x, a, b)H(x, y) G(x, a, b) = CG(b − a)+, H(x, y) = h(x − y), (cid:82) where (·)+ denotes the positive part (x+ := max{0, x}) while h(r) is a non- negative and decreasing function, which vanishes at some r = r0 and satisfies y<r0 h(y) dy = 1. In the limit r0 → 0, (11) reduces to (12) v[f ] = G(x, a, b)f (x, b, t) db + S(x, a, u1(x, s), . . . , uN−1(x, s)). (cid:90) 1 0 Since we aim at a minimal effective model, we avoid precise assumptions on the underlying biological processes expressed by K. The term S ≥ 0 in (11) and (12) models the action of toxic Aβ oligomers, ultimately leading to apoptosis. For example (13) S = CS (1 − a) mum(x, s) − U m=1 The threshold U > 0 indicates the minimal amount of toxic Aβ needed to damage neurons, assuming that the toxicity of soluble Aβ-polymers does not depend on m. In reality length dependence has been observed [31], but, to our best knowledge, quantitive data are only available for very short molecules (see [31, Table 2]). For long molecules any analytic expression would be arbitrary. Since Aβ monomers are produced by neurons and the production increases if neurons are damaged, we choose in (5) (14) F = F[f ] = CF (µ0 + a)(1 − a)f (x, a, t) da. The small constant µ0 > 0 accounts for Aβ production by healthy neurons (dead neurons do not produce amyloid). 0 (cid:90) 1 (cid:32)N−1(cid:88) (cid:33)+ 6 M. BERTSCH, B. FRANCHI, N. MARCELLO, M. C. TESI, AND A. TOSIN To describe the onset of AD we assume that in small, randomly chosen parts of the cerebral tissue, concentrated for instance in the hippocampus, the degree of malfunctioning of neurons randomly jumps to higher values due to external agents or genetic factors. This leads to an additional term in the equation for f , where (cid:18)(cid:90) 1 ∂tf + ∂a (f v[f ]) = J[f ], (cid:19) J[f ] = η P (t, a∗ → a)f (x, a∗, t) da∗ − f (x, a, t) (15) P (t, a∗ → a) is the probability to jump from state a∗ to state a ∈ [0, 1] (obviously, P (t, a∗ → a) = 0 if a < a∗), χ(x, t) describes the random jump distribution, and η is the jump frequency. In most of our numerical tests we choose χ(x, t). 0 P (t, a∗ → a) ≡ P (a∗ → a) =  2 1 − a∗ 0 if a∗ ≤ a ≤ 1+a∗ otherwise, 2 i.e., we neglect randomness and we set χ(x, t) ≡ χ(x) concentrated in the hippo- campus. For a simulation with a random jump distribution, see Figure 10. To model the phagocytic activity of the microglia as well as other bulk clearance processes [19], we add to (1) and (5) a term −σmum, where σm > 0. This leads to the system  ∂tf + ∂a (f v[f ]) = J[f ] ε∂tu1 = d1∇2u1 − u1 ε∂tum = dm∇2um + ε∂tuN = 1 2 (cid:80) j+k≥N k, j<N N(cid:80) m−1(cid:80) N(cid:80) j=1 j=1 1 2 − um j=1 aj,kujuk, (16) a1,juj + F[f ] − σ1u1 aj,m−jujum−j am,juj − σmum (2 ≤ m < N ) where v[f ] is given by (11) or (12) (with s replaced by ε−1t), F[f ] by (14), and J[f ] by (15). Since we are interested in longitudinal modelling, we assume that initially, at t = 0, the brain is healthy, with a small uniform distribution of soluble amyloid. 3. Problem setting and discretisation of the equations In this section we detail the structure of the domain and the boundary conditions which we will use, in the next Section 4, to produce numerical simulations. We also discuss the discretisation of the equations (16). 3.1. Physical domain and boundary conditions. We consider the two-dimen- sional transverse section of the brain illustrated in Fig. 1. Since approximating a real brain section is a quite complicated issue, for the sake of simplicity we schematise it as a box Ω ⊂ R2, Ω = [0, Lx]×[0, Ly], with two inner rectangular holes representing the sections of the cerebral ventricles. We also identify, close to the front part of the ventricles, the two sections of the hippocampus, which we represent as two small circles. Unlike the cerebral ventricles, the sections of the hippocampus are meant as actual portions of the domain Ω, not as holes. On the outer boundary of Ω, say ∂Ωout, we assume vanishing normal polymer flow. Therefore we impose a homogeneous Neumann condition for the diffusing ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE: A MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR ONSET AND PROGRESSION 7 Figure 1. Left: A real transverse section of the brain (repro- duced from [26] with kind permission of the publisher). Right: Two-dimensional schematisation for numerical purposes. Black dots are the internal nodes of the numerical grid, where discretised equations are solved, while white dots are boundary nodes, where boundary conditions are imposed. amyloid polymers: (17) − dm ∇um · n = 0 on ∂Ωout, m = 1, . . . , N − 1, n being the outward normal unit vector to ∂Ωout. Notice that no boundary condi- tion is required for the concentration uN of the fibrillar amyloid, since its equation does not feature space dynamics (cf. the last equation in (16)). On the inner boundary of Ω, say ∂Ωin, that is the boundaries of the cerebral ventricles, we model the removal of Aβ from cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) through the choroid plexus (cf. [19, 39]) by an outward polymer flow proportional to the concentration of the amyloid. For this, we impose a Robin boundary condition of the form: (18) − dm ∇um · n = βum on ∂Ωin, m = 1, . . . , N − 1, with β > 0 a constant. We discretise Ω by means of a two-dimensional structured orthogonal grid, whose points have coordinates xi,j = (xi, yj) = (i∆x, j∆y) with ∆x = Lx/Nx, ∆y = Ly/Ny, Nx, Ny being the numbers of discretisation points in the x and y-direction, respectively, and i = 0, . . . , Nx, j = 0, . . . , Ny. See Fig. 1. We also introduce a time lattice tn = n∆t, n = 0, 1, 2, . . . . i,j ≈ um(xi,j, tn) denote an approximation of the concentration of the m-polymers of amyloid in the point xi,j ∈ Ω at time tn, on the numerical grid Letting (um)n 8 M. BERTSCH, B. FRANCHI, N. MARCELLO, M. C. TESI, AND A. TOSIN the Neumann boundary condition (17) becomes simply: (um)n (um)n Nx,j = (um)n (um)n 0,j = (um)n 1,j Nx−1,j i,0 = (um)n i,1 = (um)n i,Ny−1 (um)n i,Ny j = 1, . . . , Ny − 1 i = 1, . . . , Nx − 1 (cid:27) (cid:27)  m = 1, . . . , N − 1. Concerning the Robin boundary condition (18), we discretise the components of the gradient via the forward Euler formula, then we take into account the orientation of the vector n as indicated in Fig. 1 to find: − along the left boundary of each cerebral ventricle where ib ∈ {0, . . . , Nx} denotes the grid index in the x-direction such that xib = ib∆x is the abscissa of the boundary; − along the right boundary of each cerebral ventricle − along the lower boundary of each cerebral ventricle where jb ∈ {0, . . . , Ny} denotes the grid index in the y-direction such that yjb = jb∆y is the ordinate of the boundary; − along the upper boundary of each cerebral ventricle (um)n ib,j = (um)n ib−1,j 1 + β∆x/dm (um)n ib,j = (um)n ib+1,j 1 + β∆x/dm (um)n i,jb = (um)n i,jb−1 1 + β∆y/dm , ; , (um)n i,jb = (um)n i,jb+1 1 + β∆y/dm . 3.2. Discretisation of the Smoluchowski equations. In order to approximate the equations for the um's, m = 1, . . . , N − 1, we use a fractional step procedure in time: first we solve the diffusion and reaction parts, then we add the coagulation and possibly the source (for u1) parts. Adopting a Finite Difference discretisation of the Laplace operator ∇2 we obtain the scheme: (um)∗ i,j = (um)n i,j + ∆t dm (um)n i−1,j−2(um)n ∆x2 i,j +(um)n i+1,j (cid:16) (cid:17) − σm(um)n i,j (cid:18) (um)n+1 i,j = (um)∗ i,j + ∆t +dm m−1(cid:80) 1 2 h=1 (um)n i,j−1−2(um)n ∆y2 i,j +(um)n i,j+1 ah,m−h(uh)∗ i,j(um−h)∗ i,j (cid:19) −(um)∗ i,j am,h(uh)∗ i,j , N(cid:80) h=1  where (um)∗ i,j denotes the temporary solution computed after the first fractional time step. For an alternative Finite Element discretisation of Smoluchowski equa- tions see e.g., [1]. The scheme above applies to all inner nodes xi,j of the numerical grid (that means 1 ≤ i ≤ Nx − 1, 1 ≤ j ≤ Ny − 1 excluding furthermore the indexes ib, jb identifying the inner boundary ∂Ωin) and to the Aβ m-polymers with m = 2, . . . , N − 1. Because of the adopted approximation of the diffusion part, the following constraint ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE: A MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR ONSET AND PROGRESSION 9 on the time and space steps has to be enforced for the stability of the numerical scheme: (19) ∆t ≤ 4 · min{∆x2, ∆y2} . max 1≤m≤N−1 dm For m = 1 the equation is discretised in a similar way but for the addition of the source term F. We refer the reader to the next subsection for discretisation methods of the integral contained in it. Finally, for m = N the equation is actually an ODE, which we approximate by the explicit Euler formula: (uN )n+1 i,j = (uN )n i,j + ∆t 2 ah,k(uh)n i,j(uk)n i,j. (cid:88) h+k≥N h, k<N 3.3. Discretisation of the equation for f . In the interval [0, 1], which consti- tutes the domain of the variable a, we introduce a Finite Volume partition made of Na cells of the form [ak−1/2, ak+1/2] with central point ak =(cid:0)k − 1 (cid:1) ∆a, where ∆a = 1 Na in (16) using again a fractional step procedure in time. . The cell index k runs from 1 to Na. Then we discretise the first equation 2 (20) (cid:0)f n i,j,k ≈ f (xi,j, ak, tn), we have: First, we solve the homogeneous transport part by means of the push-forward scheme introduced by e.g., [34, 41], which is particularly suited to deal with non- local fluxes. Denoting f n i,j,k − ∆t ∆a f∗ i,j,k = f n i,j,k ≈ v(xi,j, ak, tn) indicates an approximation of the deterioration rate of where vn the neurons and (·)− is the negative part (x− := max{0, −x}). Here we compute vn i,j,k by approximating the integral contained in the expression (12) via a zeroth order Euler formula and then adding the expression (13): i,j,k+1)−(cid:1) , i,j,k−1)+ − f n i,j,k − f n i,j,kvn i,j,k−1(vn i,j,k+1(vn vn i,j,k = G(xi,j, ak, ah)f n i,j,h∆a + CS (1 − ak) m(um)n i,j − U . If the form G(x, a, b) = CG(b − a)+ is used then in the formula above we simply have G(xi,j, ak, ah) = CG(ah − ak)+. The stability of the scheme (20) requires that the grid steps ∆a, ∆t be linked (cid:32)N−1(cid:88) m=1 (cid:33)+ Na(cid:88) h=1 by the following CFL condition: (21) ∆t ≤ ∆a vn i,j,k . max i, j, k (cid:32) Na(cid:88) Second, we update the values f∗ i,j,k by including the jump process: i,j,k = f∗ f n+1 h f∗ P k i,j,h∆a − f∗ i,j,k χn i,j, i,j,k + η∆t h := P (ah → ak) and χn h=1 where we have denoted P k i, j := χ(xi,j, tn). (cid:33)  3.4. Final choice of the time step. On the whole, the time step of the com- plete numerical scheme has to comply with both the parabolic and the hyperbolic constraints (19), (21), respectively. Therefore, it is ultimately chosen as:  4 ∆t ≤ min · min{∆x2, ∆y2} max 1≤m≤N−1 dm , ∆a vn i,j,k max i, j, k 10 M. BERTSCH, B. FRANCHI, N. MARCELLO, M. C. TESI, AND A. TOSIN at each time iteration of the numerical scheme. 3.5. Computing physiological indicators. Several macroscopic (aggregate) quant- ities can be computed out of the results of model (16). In the next Section 4 the outputs of the simulations will be discussed in terms of a few of such quantities, which can be directly compared with real clinical images and known qualitative time evolution of Alzheimer's disease. The macroscopic distribution of neuron malfunctioning A = A(x, t) is computed over the cerebral domain Ω as the local average of the degree of malfunctioning a: A(x, t) := af (x, a, t) da, which is numerically approximated as 0 A(xi,j, tn) ≈ An i,j = Na(cid:88) k=1 akf n i,j,k. Following [21], we relate then the local brain atrophy φ(x, t) to the average neuron malfunctioning A as: (cid:90) 1 (cid:26) (cid:26) (cid:27) , A(x, t) − A0 1 − A0 (cid:27) . i,j − A0 An 1 − A0 φ(x, t) := max 0, φn i,j = max 0, A0 ∈ (0, 1) being a threshold of malfunctioning over which the brain is considered locally atrophic. The corresponding numerical approximation is Next we define the global brain atrophy in time Φ = Φ(t) as the average of φ over the whole domain Ω, i.e., Ω denoting the area of Ω, which is numerically approximated as Φ(t) := φ(x, t) dx, 1 Ω (cid:90) Ny−1(cid:88) Nx−1(cid:88) Ω Φn := 1 Ω φn i,j∆x∆y, j=0 In this formula we conventionally consider φn belong to the domain Ω, i.e., if it is a point inside the cerebral ventricles. i,j = 0 if the grid point xi,j does not i=0 The total concentration of soluble amyloid US = US(t) in the brain occipital region, to be related to the Aβ concentration found in the cerebrospinal fluid by clinical exams (CSF Aβ), is given by: (cid:90) N−1(cid:88) Ω m=1 US(t) := 1 Ω mum(x, t) dx, where Ω ⊂ Ω is a subdomain located in the bottom part of Ω, entirely contained in the region below the cerebral ventricles. Assuming for simplicity that it is a rectangle as well, whose grid coordinates are comprised between two indexes 0 < i1 < i2 < Nx in the x-direction and between j = 0 and j = j > 0 in the y-direction, we obtain the numerical values of US as: i2−1(cid:88) j−1(cid:88) N−1(cid:88) i=i1 j=0 m=1 U n S := 1 Ω m(um)n i,j∆x∆y = 1 (i2 − i1)j i2−1(cid:88) j−1(cid:88) N−1(cid:88) i=i1 j=0 m=1 m(um)n i,j, where we have used that Ω = (i2 − i1)j∆x∆y. ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE: A MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR ONSET AND PROGRESSION11 Finally, the average quantity of brain Aβ deposits in time is: UN (t) := which is naturally discretised as N uN (x, t) dx, (cid:90) Nx−1(cid:88) Ω i=0 Ny−1(cid:88) 1 Ω 1 Ω by letting conventionally (uN )n UN (tn) ≈ U n N (uN )n j=0 i,j∆x∆y N = i,j = 0 if xi,j (cid:54)∈ Ω (inside the cerebral ventricles). 4. Numerical results To begin with, we provide a typical output of the numerical simulations. In Figure 2 we plot the evolution of three crucial biomarkers of AD (as a function of the computational time): − the CSF Aβ42 (purple dashed curve); − the average quantity of brain Aβ42 deposits (red solid curve); − the global brain atrophy (blue dash-dot curve). All curves are normalised to their maxima. The values of the constants used in the simulation are specified in the figure caption. Figure 2. Graph for the following constants: β = 1, D = 0.01, α = 10, ε = 0.1, T = 100, N = 50, CG = 0.1, CS = 0.001, CF = 10, r0 = 0.0, U = 0.1, µ0 = 0.01, η = 1, and σm = 1/m. The level of Aβ42-deposition (red solid curve) grows rapidly, reaches its max- imum, and then stabilises. The purple dashed curve, corresponding to CSF-Aβ42, decreases after having reached a peak. The blue dash-dot curve corresponds to the brain atrophy and increases in time as expected. The graphs in Figure 2 can be well illustrated by the following quote from [20]: The initiating event in AD is related to abnormal processing of β-amyloid peptide, ultimately leading to formation of Aβ plaques in the brain. This process occurs while individuals are still cog- nitively normal. Biomarkers of brain β-amyloidosis are reductions in CSF Aβ42 and increased amyloid PET tracer retention. After a lag period, which varies from patient to patient, neuronal dys- function and neurodegeneration become the dominant pathological 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140Normalized valuesComputational timeCSF Aβ42Brain Aβ42 depositsGlobal brain atrophy12 M. BERTSCH, B. FRANCHI, N. MARCELLO, M. C. TESI, AND A. TOSIN processes. Biomarkers of neuronal injury and neurodegeneration are increased CSF tau and structural MRI measures of cerebral atrophy. Neurodegeneration is accompanied by synaptic dysfunc- tion, which is indicated by decreased fluorodeoxyglucose uptake on PET. We propose a model that relates disease stage to AD biomarkers in which Aβ biomarkers become abnormal first, be- fore neurodegenerative biomarkers and cognitive symptoms, and neurodegenerative biomarkers become abnormal later, and correl- ate with clinical symptom severity. The plots we obtain should be compared with the clinical graphs in [21], [45], [11] and [37]. For the reader's convenience we reproduce [5], and with the data of here a picture from [21], see Figure 3, and a picture from [45], see Figure 4. Figure 3. Fig. 6 reproduced from [21] with kind permission of the publisher. Figure 4. Fig. 4 reproduced from [45] with kind permission of the publisher. There is a satisfactory agreement between the plots of the qualitative temporal behaviour of the biomarkers and those obtained from clinical data. Observe that not only the shapes of the curves are comparable (CSF Aβ corresponds to CSF Aβ42, Brain Aβ deposits correspond to Amyloid PET and Global brain atrophy corresponds to MRI + FDG PET)), but also the temporal order of the events is in good agreement with clinical data. Obviously the details of the numerical output depend on the choice of the con- stants used in the mathematical model. Performing a considerable amount of nu- merical runs with different values of the constants in the model, we have reached the conclusion that, at least qualitatively, the behaviour of the solutions does not ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE: A MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR ONSET AND PROGRESSION13 depend on the precise choice of those constants, as long as their variation is re- stricted to reasonable ranges. In other words, the values of the constants taken in Figure 2 can be considered as an indication for the order of magnitude. For ex- ample, the longitudinal graphs of the biomarkers CFS-Aβ, brain Aβ deposits and brain atrophy are - in this sense - qualitatively stable under variations of CS , CF , CG and α. It is particularly instructive to consider the constants U in (13) and β in (18). We recall that U is a threshold value for the minimal amount of toxic Aβ necessary to damage neurons (see (13)). In Figure 2 we have used the value U = 0.1, but if we make it considerably larger, for example U = 1 (the remaining constants are unchanged), then the threshold becomes so high that the illness does not develop at all. The constant β enters the model through condition (18) at the boundary of the cerebral ventricles. Smaller values of β mean that less Aβ is removed from the CSF through the choroid plexus. Figure 5 shows what happens if we change it into β = 0.01: the three curves are moved to the left and become steeper: the illness starts earlier and develops faster. Recalling that in Figures 2 and 5 we have plotted values which are normalised with respect to their maximal values, one could wonder how the latter ones depend on β. It turns out that the maximal values of CSF Aβ and the brain atrophy are essentially independent of β. The Aβ deposits (the plaques) however increase by a factor 6 if β is changed from 1 to 0.01. This result is compatible with our modelling Ansatz (in accordance with the medical literature) that plaques are not toxic (even healthy brains may contain plaques). Figure 5. Graph for the following constants: β = 0.01, D = 0.01, α = 100, ε = 0.1, T = 100, N = 50, CG = 0.1, CS = 0.001, CF = 10, r0 = 0.0, U = 0.1,µ0 = 0.01, η = 1, and σm = 1/m. The comparison of the cases β = 1 and β = 0.01 becomes even clearer when we create spatial plots of f and of the distribution and density of the cerebral plaques at fixed computational times t = T . The plots of f at different times are meant to be compared with FDG-PET images (see e.g., [11]). More precisely, we take a schematic image of a transverse section of the brain and attribute different colors (varying from red to blue) to those parts of the brain where probabilistic- ally the level of malfunctioning lies in different ranges. As in the FDG-PET, the 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140Normalized valuesComputational timeCSF Aβ42Brain Aβ42 depositsGlobal brain atrophy14 M. BERTSCH, B. FRANCHI, N. MARCELLO, M. C. TESI, AND A. TOSIN red corresponds to a healthy tissue. Here AD originates only from the hippocam- pus and propagates, at the beginning, along privileged directions (such as those corresponding to denser neural bundles) mimicked by two triangles. In Figures 7 and 8 we compare plots of f at, respectively, times T = 34 and T = 52 for the two different values of β = 0.01 and β = 1. Figures 7 and 8 do not only confirm the temporal acceleration of the development of the illness for smaller values of β, but also show that the spatial pattern and heterogeneity become less evident as β becomes smaller. Since experimental data suggest a strong spatial heterogeneity of the illness, this could indicate the potential importance of the removal of Aβ through the choroid plexus to slow down the temporal development of AD. In Figure 9 we plot the plaques' distribution for the two different values of β = 0.01 and β = 1 and at T = 52. This figure confirms the strong increase of the plaques when β becomes smaller. We stress that, though our images represent a mean value of brain activity instead of a single patient's brain activity, still they show a good agreement with clinical neuroimaging: compare Figures 7 and 8 with Figure 6 below. Figure 6. FDG -PET images showing patterns of metabolic activity: an elderly individual with no dementia (left) and with AD (right). Reproduced from [26] with permission. Figure 7. Neuron malfunctioning: β = 0.01 (left), β = 1 (right), T = 34. Looking for more realistic images, we have to take into account randomness of the spatial distribution of the sources of the disease. For example, we have performed 0 0.8 0 1 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0 0.8 0 1 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE: A MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR ONSET AND PROGRESSION15 Figure 8. Neuron malfunctioning: β = 0.01 (left), β = 1 (right), T = 52. Figure 9. Density of plaques for β = 0.01 (left), β = 1 (right), T = 52. some runs where the AD does not only originate from the hippocampus, but also from several sources of Aβ randomly distributed in the occipital part of the brain. We report the outputs of such runs in Figure 10. The random distributed sources appear as the small blue spots. 5. Discussion and future research directions We have presented a new mathematical model for the onset and evolution of AD. The model is characterised by a high level of flexibility, which potentially allows one to simulate different modelling hypotheses and compare them with clinical data. In fact, the model provides a flexible tool to test in the future alternative hypotheses on the evolution of the disease. In the paper we have chosen some specific aspects of the illness, such as the aggregation, diffusion and removal of Aβ, the possible spread of neuronal damage in the neural pathway, and, to describe the onset of AD, a random neural deterioration mechanism. Numerical simulations are compared with clinical data and, although oversimplified and restricted to a 2-dimensional rectangular section of the brain, they are in good qualitative agreement with the 0 0.8 0 1 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0 0.8 0 1 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 0 0.8 0 1 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 0 0.8 0 1 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.516 M. BERTSCH, B. FRANCHI, N. MARCELLO, M. C. TESI, AND A. TOSIN Figure 10. Neuron disease with random sources with β = 1 at T = 47 spread of the illness in the brain at various stages of its evolution. In particular, our model captures the cerebral damage in the early stage of MCI. There are multiple future research developments in quite different directions, each of which requires substantial research efforts. We mention some of them. Further development of the model is needed and should be carefully guided by clinical data. The constants appearing in the equations should be well calibrated to optimise quantitative agreement with clinical data. Simulations should become more realistic, in a three-dimensional domain which matches the geometric charac- teristics of the brain. The true challenge in AD research is a breakthrough which allows one to develop effective therapies to stop or slow down the evolution of AD, possibly in an early stage of the illness. Also effective mathematical models can give a contribution in this direction. For example, a certain sensibility of the numerical output to the value of the constant β in (18), which models the removal of Aβ through the choroid plexus, spontaneously leads to the question whether dialysis-mechanisms can be introduced to enhance Aβ-removal artificially. Most probably, a serious answer to this question requires, in addition to a detailed comparison with clinical data, a more refined modelling of the removal which takes into account the transport of soluble Aβ by the cerebral fluid. Finally, some mathematical effort is necessary to check the mathematical cor- rectness (well-posedness) of the model. Acknowledgments B. F. and M. C. T. are supported by a grant of the University of Bologna (Ricerca Fondamentale Orientata). B. F. and M. C. T. are supported by GNAMPA (Gruppo Nazionale per l'Analisi Matematica, la Probabilit`a e le loro Applicazioni) of INdAM (Istituto Nazionale di Alta Matematica), Italy. A. T. acknowledges that this work has been written within the activities of GNFM (Gruppo Nazionale per la Fisica Matematica) of INdAM (Istituto Nazionale di Alta Matematica), Italy. 0 0.8 0 1 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE: A MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR ONSET AND PROGRESSION17 References 1. Y. Achdou, B. Franchi, N. Marcello, and M. C. Tesi, A qualitative model for aggregation and diffusion of β-amyloid in Alzheimer's disease, J. Math. Biol. 67 (2013), no. 6-7, 1369–1392. MR 3125569 2. H. Amann, Coagulation-fragmentation processes, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 151 (2000), no. 4, 339–366. 3. H. Amann and C. Walker, Local and global strong solutions to continuous coagulation- fragmentation equations with diffusion, J. Differential Equations 218 (2005), no. 1, 159–186. 4. H. Amann and F. Weber, On a quasilinear coagulation-fragmentation model with diffusion, Adv. Math. Sci. Appl. 11 (2001), no. 1, 227–263. 5. R. J. Bateman, C. Xiong, T. L. S. Benzinger, A. M. Fagan, A. Goate, N. C. Fox, D. S. Marcus, N. J. Cairns, X. Xie, T. M. Blazey, D. M. Holtzman, A. Santacruz, V. Buckles, A. Oliver, K. Moulder, P. S. Aisen, B. Ghetti, W. E. Klunk, E. McDade, R. N. Martins, C. L. Masters, R. Mayeux, J. M. Ringman, M. N. Rossor, P. R. Schofield, R. A. Sperling, S. Salloway, and J. C. Morris, Clinical and biomarker changes in dominantly inherited Alzheimer's disease, New Engl. J. Med. 367 (2012), no. 9, 795–804. 6. K. Blennow, M. J. de Leon, and H. Zetterberg, Alzheimer's disease, Lancet Neurol. 368 (2006), 387–403. 7. Heiko Braak and Kelly Del Tredici, Alzheimer's pathogenesis: is there neuron-to-neuron propagation?, Acta Neuropathol. 121 (2011), no. 5, 589–595 (English). 8. L. Cruz, B. Urbanc, S. V. Buldyrev, R. Christie, T. G´omez-Isla, S. Havlin, M. McNamara, H. E. Stanley, and B. T. Hyman, Aggregation and disaggregation of senile plaques in Alzheimer disease, P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94 (1997), no. 14, 7612–7616. 9. R. L. Drake, A general mathematical survey of the coagulation equation, Topics in Current Aerosol Research (Part 2), International Reviews in Aerosol Physics and Chemistry (G. M. Hidy and J. R. Brock, eds.), Pergamon Press, Oxford, UK, 1972, pp. 203–376. 10. Leah Edelstein-Keshet and Athan Spiross, Exploring the formation of Alzheimer's disease senile plaques in silico, J. Theor. Biol. 216 (2002), no. 3, 301–326. 11. A. S. Fleisher, K. Chen, Y. T. Quiroz, L. J. Jakimovich, M. G. Gomez, C. M. Langois, J. B. S. Langbaum, N. Ayutyanont, A. Roontiva, P. Thiyyagura, W. Lee, H. Mo, L. Lopez, S. Moreno, N. Acosta-Baena, M. Giraldo, G. Garcia, R. A. Reiman, M. J. Huentelman, K. S. Kosik, P. N. Tariot, F. Lopera, and E. M. Reiman, Florbetapir PET analysis of amyloid-β deposition in the presenilin 1 E280A autosomal dominant Alzheimer's disease kindred: a cross-sectional study, Lancet Neurol. 11 (2012), no. 12, 1057–1065. 12. B. Franchi and M. C. Tesi, A qualitative model for aggregation-fragmenattion and diffusion of β-amyloid in Alzheimer's disease, Rend. Semin. Mat. Univ. Politec. Torino 70 (2012), no. 1, 75–84. 13. T. A. Good and R. M. Murphy, Effect of β-amyloid block of the fast-inactivating K+ channel on intracellular Ca2+ and excitability in a modeled neuron, P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 93 (1996), 15130–15135. 14. Geoffrey J. Goodhill, Diffusion in axon guidance, European Journal of Neuroscience 9 (1997), no. 7, 1414 – 1421. 15. W. S. T. Griffin, J. G. Sheng, M. C. Royston, S. M. Gentleman, J. E. McKenzie, D. I. Graham, G. W. Roberts, and R. E. Mrak, Glial-neuronal interactions in Alzheimer's disease: the potential role of a cytokine cycle in disease progression, Brain Pathol. 8 (1998), no. 1, 65–72. 16. C. Haass and D. J. Selkoe, Soluble protein oligomers in neurodegeneration: lessons from the Alzheimer's amyloid beta-peptide, Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell. Biol. 8 (2007), no. 2, 101–112 (eng). 17. M. Helal, E. Hingant, L. Pujo-Menjouet, and G. F. Webb, Alzheimer's disease: analysis of a mathematical model incorporating the role of prions, J. Math. Biol. 69 (2013), no. 5, 1–29. 18. M. D. Hurd, P. Martorell, A. Delavande, K. J. Mullen, and K. M. Langa, Monetary costs of dementia in the United States, New Engl. J. Med. 368 (2013), no. 14, 1326–1334. 19. J. J. Iliff, M. Wang, Y. Liao, B. A. Plogg, W. Peng, G. A. Gundersen, H. Benveniste, G. E. Vates, R. Deane, S. A. Goldman, E. A. Nagelhus, and M. Nedergaard, A paravascular pathway facilitates CSF flow through the brain parenchyma and the clearance of interstitial solutes, including amyloid β, Sci. Transl. Med. 4 (2012), no. 147, 147ra111. 20. C. R. Jack Jr., D. S. Knopman, W. J. Jagust, L. M. Shaw, P. S. Aisen, M. W. Weiner, R. C. Petersen, and J. Q. Trojanowski, Hypothetical model of dynamic biomarkers of the Alzheimer's pathological cascade, Lancet Neurol. 9 (2010), no. 1, 119–128. 21. , Tracking pathophysiological processes in Alzheimer's disease: an updated hypothetical model of dynamic biomarkers, Lancet Neurol. 12 (2013), no. 2, 207–216. 18 M. BERTSCH, B. FRANCHI, N. MARCELLO, M. C. TESI, AND A. TOSIN 22. E. Karran, M. Mercken, and B. De Strooper, The amyloid cascade hypothesis for Alzheimer's disease: an appraisal for the development of therapeutics, Nat Rev. Drug Discov. 10 (2011), no. 9, 698–712. 23. P. Lauren¸cot and S. Mischler, Global existence for the discrete diffusive coagulation- fragmentation equations in l1, Rev. Mat. Iberoamericana 18 (2002), no. 3, 731–745. 24. M. P. Mattson, Pathways towards and away from Alzheimer's disease, Nature 430 (2004), 631–639. 25. M Meyer-Luehmann, TL Spires-Jones, C Prada, M Garcia-Alloza, A De Calignon, A. Rozkalne, J. Koenigsknecht-Talboo, D. M. Holtzman, B. J. Bacskai, and B. T. Hyman, Rapid appearance and local toxicity of amyloid-β plaques in a mouse model of Alzheimer's disease, Nature 451 (2008), no. 7179, 720–724. 26. J. C. Miller, Neuroimaging for dementia and Alzheimer's disease, Radiology Rounds 4 (2006), no. 4, 1–4. 27. L. Mosconi, V. Berti, L. Glodzik, A. Pupi, S. De Santi, and MJ. de Leon, Pre-clinical detection of Alzheimer's disease using FDG-PET, with or without amyloid imaging, J. Alzheimer's Dis. 20(3) (2010), 843–854. 28. R. M. Murphy and M. M. Pallitto, Probing the kinetics of β-amyloid self-association, Bio- physical Journal 130 (2000), no. 2-3, 109–122. 29. Charles Nicholson and Eva Sykov´a, Extracellular space structure revealed by diffusion analysis, Trends in Neurosciences 21 (1998), no. 5, 207 – 215. 30. A. Nordberg, Amyloid imaging in Alzheimer's disease, Neuropsychologia 46 (2008), no. 6, 1636–1641. 31. Kenjiro Ono, Margaret M. Condron, and David B. Teplow, Structure-neurotoxicity relation- ships of amyloid β-protein oligomers, P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 106 (2009), no. 35, 14745– 14750. 32. M. M. Pallitto and R. M. Murphy, A mathematical model of the kinetics of β-amyloid fibril growth from the denatured state, J. Struct. Biol. 81 (2001), no. 3, 1805–1822. 33. R. C. Petersen, R. O. Roberts, D. S. Knopman, B. F. Boeve, Y. E. Geda, R. J. Ivnik, G. E. Smith, and C. R. Jack Jr., Mild cognitive impairment: Ten years later, Arch. Neurol. 66 (2009), no. 12, 1447–1455. 34. B. Piccoli and A. Tosin, Time-evolving measures and macroscopic modeling of pedestrian flow, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 199 (2011), no. 3, 707–738. 35. R. A. Quinlan and B. Straughan, Decay bounds in a model for aggregation of microglia: application to Alzheimer's disease senile plaques, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. Ser. A Math. Phys. Eng. Sci. 461 (2005), no. 2061, 2887–2897. 36. A. Raj, A. Kuceyeski, and M. Weiner, A network diffusion model of disease progression in dementia, Neuron 73 (2012), no. 6, 1204–1215. 37. E. M. Reiman, Y. T. Quiroz, A. S. Fleisher, K. Chen, C. Velez-Pardo, M. Jimenez-Del-Rio, A. M. Fagan, A. R. Shah, S. Alvarez, A. Arbelaez, M. Giraldo, N. Acosta-Baena, R. A. Sper- ling, B. Dickerson, C. E. Stern, V. Tirado, C. Munoz, R. A. Reiman, M. J. Huentelman, G. E. Alexander, J. B. S. Langbaum, K. S. Kosik, P. N. Tariot, and F. Lopera, Brain imaging and fluid biomarker analysis in young adults at genetic risk for autosomal dominant Alzheimer's disease in the presenilin 1 E280A kindred: a case-control study, Lancet Neurol. 11 (2012), no. 12, 1048–1056. 38. C. Reitz, C. Brayne, and R. Mayeux, Epidemiology of Alzheimer disease, Nat. Rev. Neurol. 7 (2011), 137–152. 39. J.-M. Serot, J. Zmudka, and P. Jouanny, A possible role for CSF turnover and choroid plexus in the pathogenesis of late onset Alzheimer's disease, J. Alzheimer's Dis. 30 (2012), no. 1, 17–26. 40. S. J. Tomsky and R. M. Murphy, Kinetics of aggregation of synthetic β-amyloid peptide, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 294 (1992), no. 2, 630–638. 41. A. Tosin and P. Frasca, Existence and approximation of probability measure solutions to models of collective behaviors, Netw. Heterog. Media 6 (2011), no. 3, 561–596. 42. B. Urbanc, L. Cruz, S. V. Buldyrev, S. Havlin, M. C. Irizarry, H. E. Stanley, and B. T. Hyman, Dynamics of plaque formation in Alzheimer's disease, Biophys. J. 76 (1999), no. 3, 1330–1334. 43. D. M. Walsh and D. J. Selkoe, Aβ oligomers: a decade of discovery, J. Neurochem. 101 (2007), no. 5, 1172–1184. 44. D. Wrzosek, Existence of solutions for the discrete coagulation-fragmentation model with diffusion, Topol. Methods Nonlinear Anal. 9 (1997), no. 2, 279–296. 45. Wai-Ying Wendy Yau, Dana L Tudorascu, Eric M McDade, Snezana Ikonomovic, Jeffrey A James, Davneet Minhas, Wenzhu Mowrey, Lei K Sheu, Beth E Snitz, Lisa Weissfeld, Peter J ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE: A MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR ONSET AND PROGRESSION19 Gianaros, Howard J Aizenstein, Julie C Price, Chester A Mathis, Oscar L Lopez, and Wil- liam E Klunk, Longitudinal assessment of neuroimaging and clinical markers in autosomal dominant alzheimer's disease: a prospective cohort study, The Lancet Neurology 14 (2015), no. 8, 804 – 813. Dipartimento di Matematica, Universit`a di Roma "Tor Vergata", Via della Ricerca Scientifica 1, 00133 Roma, Italy Istituto per le Applicazoni del Calcolo "M. Picone", Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche, Via dei Taurini 19, 00185 Roma, Italy E-mail address: [email protected] University of Bologna, Department of Mathematics, Piazza di Porta S. Donato 5, 40126 Bologna, Italy E-mail address: [email protected] S.C. Neurologia, Azienda Ospedaliera Santa Maria Nuova-IRCCS, Viale Risorgi- mento 80, 42123 Reggio Emilia, Italy E-mail address: [email protected] University of Bologna, Department of Mathematics, Piazza di Porta S. Donato 5, 40126 Bologna, Italy E-mail address: [email protected] Istituto per le Applicazioni del Calcolo "M. Picone", Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche, Via dei Taurini 19, 00185 Roma, Italy E-mail address: [email protected]
1601.03655	2	1601	2017-02-22T14:10:22	Shape regulation generates elastic interaction between living cells	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft" ]	The organization of live cells to tissues is associated with the mechanical interaction between cells, which is mediated through their elastic environment. We model cells as spherical active force dipoles surrounded by an infinite elastic matrix, and analytically evaluate the interaction energy for different scenarios of their regulatory behavior. We obtain attraction for homeostatic (set point) forces and repulsion for homeostatic displacements. When the translational motion of the cells is regulated, the interaction energy decays with distance as $1/d^4$, while when it is not regulated the energy decays as $1/d^6$. This arises from the same reasons as the van der Waals interaction between induced electric dipoles.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Shape regulation generates elastic interaction between living cells Roman Golkov and Yair Shokef∗ School of Mechanical Engineering and The Sackler Center for Computational Molecular and Materials Science, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv 69978, Israel. The organization of live cells to tissues is associated with the mechanical interaction between cells, which is mediated through their elastic environment. We model cells as spherical active force dipoles surrounded by an infinite elastic matrix, and analytically evaluate the interaction energy for different scenarios of their regulatory behavior. We obtain attraction for homeostatic (set point) forces and repulsion for homeostatic displacements. When the translational motion of the cells is regulated, the interaction energy decays with distance as 1/d4, while when it is not regulated the energy decays as 1/d6. This arises from the same reasons as the van der Waals interaction between induced electric dipoles. I. INTRODUCTION A. Mechanobiological background Live cells exert contractile forces on their environment [1]. The elastic behavior of the extracellular matrix (ECM) and its rigidity affect the forces that cells apply and consequently the resultant displacements [2 -- 5], the cell migratory behavior [6 -- 10], and cell division [11]. Alterations of the shape and size [12] and also of the rigidity [13] of cells in response to changes of the ECM rigidity were also observed experimentally. For stem cells the rigidity of the ECM may even affect their biological phenotype, from neuronal on soft substrates, muscle on substrates with intermediate rigidity to bone on rigid substrates [14]. It was also shown experimentally that the interaction behavior between cells is related to the elastic moduli and the non-linear elastic behavior of the substrate [6], and that presence of rigid boundaries affects the behavior of cells [15]. One of the immediate conclusions from these experimental results is that cells sense changes in their mechanical environment and respond to those changes in a variety of ways: by modifying the applied forces and displacements, their size and shape and even their rigidity. This, in turn suggests that there are mechanical interactions between cells ∗ [email protected] 2 through the environment [16]. Indeed, the dependence of the interaction distance between live cells on the rigidity of the substrate was observed [6]. It was also shown that on nonlinear substrates, cells respond to the presence of each other over relatively long distances (up to 10 cell diameters) [2] in contrast to linear substrates, on which the response distance is limited to 1-2 cell diameters. This fact is attributed to the strain-stiffening behavior of the ECM [2, 17] or to fiber buckling [9]. Improved models of biopolymer gels predict an increase in the range of transmission of internal cellular forces [18, 19]. An alternative hypothesis is that the fibrous nature of the ECM makes the transmission of mechanical signals to such long distances possible [20 -- 24]. In this paper we model cells as spherical force dipoles, which create contractile forces on their surface. We seek the interaction energy between two such cells surrounded by an infinite ECM. Realistically, this ECM has nonlinear material properties, thus theoretically analyzing such interactions is a very ambitious goal [25, 26]. Here we lay the conceptual foundations for reaching this goal by focusing on active force dipoles surrounded by a linearly-elastic, or Hookean material. We suggest that the concepts we introduce and the physical mechanisms that we identify would be relevant also to nonlinear media. We define the interaction energy as the additional amount of work performed by the force dipoles as a result of the presence of neighboring dipoles. From studies of the micromechanics of elastic inclusions we know that in the case of two bodies of any shape that apply a hydrostatic pressure on a surrounding linearly elastic material, their interaction energy vanishes [27, 28]. We define this type of force dipoles as "dead". As an example of such behavior one may think of heating a system with inclusions in a medium with a different thermal expansion coefficient. The self-displacements applied by each such inclusion do not depend on the distance to neighboring inclusions. In contrast to this, in this paper we introduce "live" behavior as self-regulation of the applied forces or displacements in order to preserve their shape in the presence of the interaction with other cells, or force dipoles. We calculate the interaction energy between two "live" force dipoles as a function of the separation distance between them. The mechanical environment of the cell may change due to the presence of other cells, due to external forcing, or due to changes in the medium's rigidity, and it is not clear how cells respond to such changes. The working hypothesis of many studies, and which we will adopt here, is that there is some sort of mechanical homeostasis in the cell. Namely, the cell tends to maintain certain quantities [29, 30]. For instance, cells may regulate the forces that they apply, and then the displacement that they generate will vary with environmental changes, or alternatively, cells may regulate their deformation, and then the forces required to generate those displacements will vary. We show that shape regulation of the force dipoles leads to attractive interaction for force homeostasis and to repulsive interaction 3 for displacement homeostasis. The interactions we find are analogous to the van der Waals interaction between two induced electric dipoles, thus corroborating the mechanobiological elasticity-electrostatics analogy [31 -- 33]. It is important to emphasize that real cells probably do not keep their exact shape, however we suggest that gener- ically self-regulation related to the interplay between active forces and the cell's shape could generate an interaction which is qualitatively similar to what we find. Our work deals with an abstract model of the cell and its mechanical behavior, which in real life are clearly more complicated. Yet we hope that insights obtained from our analytical solu- tion of this ideal picture will shed light on the understanding of interactions in more realistic scenarios. In particular it would be interesting to relate our work to recent work on the relation between cell morphology and the polarization of the active forces that the cell applies in response to its mechanical environment [5, 34, 35]. B. Cells as spherical active force dipoles In analogy to Eshelby's elastic inclusions as force-generating centers [36, 37], the contractile activity of cells can be modeled as contractile force dipoles [31], see Fig. 1. We adopt this approach, and for simplicity introduce spherical force dipoles as spherical bodies, which apply isotropic contractile forces on their environment [25]. The contractile forces at the surface of each spherical force dipole represent the cellular forces that are generated by the contraction of the actin network by myosin motors and are transferred to the ECM trough focal adhesions. By analogy with electric dipoles in electrostatics, a force dipole is defined in mechanics as two equal and opposite point forces applied at some distance from each other, see Fig. 1(a). Our spherical force dipole consists of an infinite number of such linear force dipoles with the same center point, distributed isotropically on the surface of the sphere, see Fig. 1(b). (a) (b) FIG. 1: (a) Linear and (b) spherical force dipoles. C. No interaction between "dead" spherical force dipoles 4 The interaction energy vanishes for two spherical inclusions in an infinite, linearly-elastic medium, each of which induces symmetric displacements or stresses in the principal directions; namely an initial volume change only with no distortion of their shapes [27, 28], see Fig. 2. This result may be explained in the following way: the dilation of each sphere creates a pure shear field around it and a solely compressive field inside. The energy of interaction between the two spheres may be expressed in terms of the stress from one sphere times the strain from the other sphere, integrated over the interior of the spheres [28, 38]. Since one field is a pure shear and the other is pure compression, their coupling does not generate an additional energy. Explicit evaluation of the vanishing interaction energy in this case [39] is given in Appendix A. We note that this result holds if the elastic moduli inside the inclusions are identical to those of their environment, while if the elastic moduli differ, the interaction energy will not vanish [40]. r1 d θ1 R0 u0 1 r2 θ2 θ′ 2 u0 2 FIG. 2: Two spherical force dipoles each with radius R0, both applying a radial isotropic displacement u0 on their surfaces. The coordinate system of sphere 1 is right handed (green) and the coordinate system of sphere 2 is left handed (blue) and may be written as θ2 = π − θ′ 2 where θ′ 2 is the commonly-used right-handed azimuthal coordinate for sphere 2. For calculating the interaction energy in an infinite periodic array of spherical active force dipoles, we first note that this situation is equivalent to a single force dipole in its Wigner-Seitz unit cell, see Fig. 3. The symmetry of this periodic array dictates that the normal displacement on the midplane between each two neighboring force dipoles must vanish, and thus we may equivalently analyze a spherical force dipole surrounded by elastic ECM limited by a rigid polyhedral Wigner-Seitz unit cell. Since we describe the material as linearly elastic, if we do not take into account regulation in the activity of the force dipoles due to the deformations generated by their neighbors, we can employ the aforementioned result regarding two "dead" force dipoles and conclude that also for a system of many such force dipoles the interaction energy vanishes. 5 FIG. 3: Triangular lattice of spherical force dipoles, its Wigner-Seitz unit cell (blue dashed line), and approximated spherical unit cell (red dashed line). D. Spherical Wigner-Seitz unit cell approximation Instead of solving the displacement field with the boundary condition of vanishing displacement on the actual boundaries of the polyhedral Wigner-Seitz unit cell, we previously approximated the unit cell as having a spherical shape [30]. Within this approximation we could exactly calculate the interaction energy by solving the spherically- symmetric equations of mechanical equilibrium. We define the interaction energy as the difference between the work performed by the spherical force dipole to displace the medium by u0 when it is surrounded by a rigid spherical Wigner-Seitz unit cell and the work when it is surrounded by an infinite ECM. For a force dipole of radius R0 surrounded by ECM with bulk modulus K and shear modulus G. The self-energy of a single force dipole in an infinite medium is given by (see Section II E below): E0 = 8πGR0u2 0. This is the basic energy scale in our problem, and all interaction energies we obtain scale with E0. For a single force dipole enclosed by a spherical Wigner-Seitz unit cell of radius Rc, we relate Rc to the distance between neighboring force dipoles, and define the dimensionless distance as Rc = Rc/R0. The interaction energy in the displacement-homeostasis scenario is given by [30]: Eint = 3−ν 4(1−ν) E0 eR3 c , where ν = 3K−2G 2(3K+G) is the Poisson ratio of the ECM. This interaction energy represents a repulsive force which decays algebraically with dipole-dipole separation. If instead we consider stress homeostasis and fix the stress σ0 that the force dipole applies on the medium, we may write E0 = πσ2 0 R3 0 2G and now Eint = − 3−ν 4(1−ν) E0 eR3 c , representing an attractive interaction. E. Motivation 6 At first glance it seems that these results [30] contradict the previously-mentioned general result [27, 28] that bodies of any shape included in a continuous linear elastic material and applying on it isotropic dilational displacements on their surface do not interact. In order to resolve this seeming contradiction, in this paper we compare the case of a spherical force dipole inside a concentric spherical Wigner-Seitz unit cell (see Fig. 3) to the realistic configuration in which two spherical force dipoles are embedded at some distance d between them in an infinite ECM with linear properties (see Fig. 2). This comparison enables us to demonstrate that the reason for the contradiction is the difference between the definitions of the geometries in the two cases; In the two-sphere case the force dipoles obtain a drop-like shape due to the interaction [see Fig. 4(a)], while a spherical force dipole inside a spherical Wigner-Seitz unit cell preserves its spherical shape even when it interacts with other force dipoles. Since the displacements created by each force dipole distort its neighbor, shape preservation may be achieved in the two-force-dipole setup only by application of appropriate anisotropic displacements by each dipole on its surface [see Fig. 4(b),4(c)], and these give rise to the interaction energy that we study in this paper. II. METHODS A. Theoretical framework We consider two identical spheres of radius R0 surrounded by an infinite material with linear elastic, or Hookean behavior defined by bulk modulus K and shear modulus G and denote the distance between their centers by d. In addition to the isotropic displacement u0, each sphere applies an anisotropic displacement, which is intended to cancel the anisotropic displacements on its surface that are caused by the other sphere. In order to simplify the calculations we choose a left-handed coordinate system for sphere 2; namely the newly defined angle θ2 equals π − θ′ 2, see Fig. 2. B. General displacements generated by spherical force dipoles The displacement field around each force dipole must satisfy mechanical equilibrium, which we write in terms of the displacements field ~u as [41]: 1 1 − 2ν ∇∇ · −→u + ∇2−→u = 0. (1) 7 (a)"Dead" (b)"Live", fixed-size, fixed-position (c)"Live", variable-size, variable-position FIG. 4: Two contractile spherical force dipoles in an infinite elastic medium: (a) "Dead" force dipoles applying an isotropic elastic force, (b-c) "Live" force dipoles regulating the force they apply in order to remain spherical even in the presence of the other force dipole. Red arrows are forces applied by each force dipole, black dashed lines are the corresponding self displacements, blue dotted lines are the displacements caused by the other force dipole, and green solid line is the total displacement. For illustration purposes, the initial distance between the spheres was set to d = 3R0, and the self-displacement to u0 = 0.4R0. The Poisson ratio is ν=0.05. We show two of the "live" cases that we describe below, which differ in whether the volumes and positions of the spheres are preserved during the interaction (b) or not (c). Due to the symmetry with respect to rotation about the axis connecting the centers of the two force dipoles, there is no dependence on the azimuthal angle φ, thus we write Eq. (1) in spherical coordinates as: 8 1 1 − 2ν 1 1 r 1 − 2ν r2 ∂ ∂r(cid:20) 1 ∂θ(cid:20) 1 ∂ r2 ∂ ∂r ∂ ∂r (r2ur) + (r2ur) + 1 r sin θ 1 r sin θ ∂ ∂θ ∂ ∂θ (uθ sin θ)(cid:21) + ∇2ur − (uθ sin θ)(cid:21) + ∇2uθ + 2 r2 2 r2 ur − ∂ur 2 ∂θ − r2 ∂uθ ∂θ − uθ = 0, 2uθ cot θ r2 = 0. r2 sin2 θ where the Laplacian in spherical coordinates excluding terms depending on φ is given by: ∇2 = 1 r2 sin θ(cid:20) ∂ ∂r(cid:18)r2 sin θ ∂ ∂r(cid:19) + ∂ ∂θ(cid:18)sin θ ∂ ∂θ(cid:19)(cid:21) . (2) (3) (4) Based on the general solution for the displacement field of a sphere with given cylindrically symmetric displacements on its surface [41], we write the anisotropic displacements field satisfying (2-3) outside the spherical force dipole (r > R0) as a multipole expansion in terms of spherical harmonics Yn(θ) =q 2n+1 4π Pn(cos θ): uri = + u0 u0R2 0 r2 i ∞Xn=0(cid:20)n(n + 3 − 4ν) uθi = u0 k=0 xk n k ∞Xn=0(cid:20)(−n + 4 − 4ν)   n+k−1 n 2 DnRn+2 0 rn+2 i CnRn 0 i − (n + 1) rn (cid:21) dYn(θi) DnRn+2 0 rn+2 i dθi , CnRn 0 rn i + (cid:21) Yn(θi), (5) (6)  the Legendre polynomial of order n [42]. Here uri and uθi are the radial and angular components of the displacement field caused by sphere i, and the infinite sums represent the anisotropic corrections that each force dipole produces in order to cancel the shape distortion caused by its neighbor. u0 and R0 have been inserted so that the coefficients Cn and Dn are dimensionless. Defining the dimensionless displacementseuri = uri dimensionless form as: and positioner = r R0 , we rewrite Eqs. (5) and (6) in with Pn(x) = 2n·Pn 1 u0 u0 + , euθi = uθi ∞Xn=0(cid:20)n(n + 3 − 4ν) ern er2 ∞Xn=0(cid:20)(−n + 4 − 4ν) Cn i i + euri(ri, θi) = euθi(ri, θi) = Dn Cn i − (n + 1) ern+2 (cid:21) dYn(θi) Dn dθ . i ern ern+2 i (cid:21) Yn(θi), (7) (8) Note that (7-8) solve Eq. (1) only when each force dipole is surrounded by an infinite homogeneous linearly-elastic medium, including in the interior of the neighboring force dipole. Biological cells clearly have a rigidity which differs from that of the ECM surrounding them, and thus this assumption seems to be problematic. We overcome this by realizing that we may first solve the mechanical problem in which the cells are assumed to have the same linear elastic properties as the ECM. The resultant solution includes a certain stress and displacement on the surface of each cell, and the solution outside the cells is independent on how the cell generates this stress on its surface. In particular, the stress that actual cells apply on their surrounding includes a passive stress coming from the rigidity of the cell plus an active stress coming from the external forces generated by molecular motors inside the cell. In our analysis we consider only the total stress and the work performed by it, which determines the interaction energy, and our results are valid irrespective of the mechanical rigidity of the cells themselves. 9 C. Cancellation condition For our "live" force dipoles the sum of the anisotropic displacements caused by the neighbor force dipole and of all the corrections applied by the discussed force dipole must vanish on its surface. From this we derive conditions for the coefficients Cn and Dn so that each force dipole will preserve its spherical shape even in the presence of the interaction with its neighboring force dipole. In order to apply the cancellation condition and to derive from it the expressions for Cn and Dn, we transform the expressions for the displacement field of force dipole 2 to the coordinate system of force dipole 1 by substitution of the expressions for r2 and θ2 in terms of r1 and θ1 and then multiplying the displacement vector −→u2 = (ur2, uθ2) by the rotation matrix: B = − cos (θ1 + θ2) sin (θ1 + θ2) cos (θ1 + θ2) sin (θ1 + θ2)  . (9) (10) (11) We then write the resultant expressions for the radial and angular displacements caused by force dipole 2 on the surface of force dipole 1 in terms of the spherical harmonics of sphere 1 by writing: (ur)n = (uθ)n = 2 2n + 1 Z π 2n(n + 1)Z π 2n + 1 0 0 ur(θ)Yn(θ)sinθdθ, uθ(θ) Yn(θ) dθ sinθdθ. As may be seen from (10,11), every spherical-harmonic mode of force dipole 2 contributes to all the modes on the surface of force dipole 1. As explained above, the sum of the anisotropic displacements caused by force dipole 2 must be canceled on the surface of force dipole 1 by the corrections that it applies. We write the dimensionless displacement eu11 created by force dipole 1 on its surface (namely ater1 = 1): ∞Xn=0hn(n + 3 − 4ν)Cn − (n + 1)(Dn − ∞Xn=0 √4πδn,0)i Yn(θ1), eur11(θ1) ≡eur1(1, θ1) = euθ11(θ1) ≡euθ1(1, θ1) = [(−n + 4 − 4ν)Cn + Dn] dYn(θi) (12) (13) . dθ The term δn,0 in (12) is a Kronecker delta, which represents the isotropic radial displacement created by sphere 1 on its surface without the anisotropic cancellation corrections. This constant term does not depend on changes in the environment of the force dipole. The remaining terms are different modes of additional displacement created by this "live" force dipole in response to the displacement field induced on its surface by the neighboring force dipole. The 10 dimensionless displacementeu21 created by force dipole 2 on the surface of force dipole 1 is: √4πδm,0)i Yn(θ1), √4πδm,0)i dYn(θ1) ∞Xm=0hf Cr ∞Xm=0hf Cθ nm(ed)Cm + f Dr nm(ed)Cm + f Dθ nm(ed)(Dm − nm(ed)(Dm − eur21(θ1) = euθ21(θ1) = ∞Xn=0 ∞Xn=0 dθ1 (14) (15) , where the sum over m originates from the fact that the displacement eu2 created by force dipole 2 is given by a multipole expansion (7-8) with the corrective magnitudes Cm and Dm. The sum over n originates from the fact that after the coordinate transformation, when these modes are expressed in terms of the spherical harmonics in the coordinate system of force dipole 1, each mode from force dipole 2 contributes to all the modes of force dipole 1. R0 The functions f Cr between the spherical force dipoles. nm(ed), f Cθ nm(ed), f Dr nm(ed) and f Dθ nm(ed), given in Appendix B depend only on the dimensionless distance ed = d We now require that for "live" force dipoles the total displacementeu11(θ1) +eu21(θ1) on the surface of force dipole 1 is isotropic. We begin by considering the simplest (but strictest) regulation scenario, for which not only is this total displacement isotropic, but its magnitude remains equal to the displacement u0 in the absence of interactions between the force dipoles. Moreover, we require that the center of symmetry of each force dipole does not move. We will later consider three additional scenarios in which the interaction causes the force dipoles to change their volume and/or to move, yet they remain spherically symmetric. Thus at this point we require that: Substituting (12,13,14,15) in (16,17) yields: eur11(θ1) +eur21(θ1) ≡ 1, euθ11(θ1) +euθ21(θ1) ≡ 0. (16) (17) ∞Xn=0(hn(n + 3 − 4ν)Cn − (n + 1)(Dn − ∞Xn=0([(−n + 4 − 4ν)Cn + Dn] + ∞Xm=0hf Cθ √4πδn,0)i + nm(ed)Cm + f Dθ ∞Xm=0hf Cr nm(ed)(Dm − nm(ed)Cm + f Dr nm(ed)(Dm − √4πδm,0)i) dYn(θ1) dθ1 √4πδm,0)i) Yn(θ1) = 1, (18) = 0. (19) Due to the orthogonality of the Legendre polynomials, for these infinite sums to satisfy these cancellation conditions, each term in the sums must cancel independently. Thus for all n ≥ 1 we require: n(n + 3 − 4ν)Cn − (n + 1)Dn + nmCm + f Dr nm(Dm − (−n + 4 − 4ν)Cn + Dn + nmCm + f Dθ nm(Dm − ∞Xm=0hf Cr ∞Xm=0hf Cθ √4πδm,0)i = 0, √4πδm,0)i = 0. 11 (20) (21) Note that for n = 0, from (7-8) C0 is irrelevant, thus we set it to zero. Moreover, since Y0(θ1) = 1, dY0(θ1) dθ1 = 0 and (19) holds trivially, thus for n = 0 we obtain only one equation, from Eq. (18): −D0 + ∞Xm=0hf Cr 0mCm + f Dr 0m (Dm − √4πδm,0)i = 1. (22) We obtain closure of the infinite coupled linear Eqs. (20, 21, 22) by assuming that Cn = 0 and Dn = 0 for n > nmax. This is justified since we will be interested in large separations between the force dipoles, and due to the fact that the solutions decay as 1/rn, thus at large r, large n terms become negligible. We verify this numerically by increasing nmax until convergence, see Section III below. D. The n=0,1 modes Each of the spherical harmonics Yn(θ) represents a different mode of deformation of the force dipole. For scalar fields the first two modes represent volume change (n = 0) and translation of the center of symmetry (n = 1). However, as can be seen from Eqs. (7,8), since the displacement field is vectorial, here the n = 1 mode may represent a combination of translation and deformation. Since our definition of "live" force dipoles focuses only on shape regulation, inclusion in the solution of the terms n = 0 and the part of the n = 1 term that controls translation is not mandatory. Inclusion of one or both of these terms will result in complementary condition(s) in addition to the shape preservation condition and will describe a different type of self-regulation of the force dipoles. Overall there are four combinations for the inclusion or exclusion of the n = 0 and n = 1 terms and thus we analyze four possible scenarios of homeostasis or self-regulation, see Fig. 5 and Fig. 4(b)-4(c) above. As a result of exclusion of one or more of the terms of the sum, Eqs. (20-22) will not vanish anymore at the corresponding modes, i.e. non-zero resultant displacement will exist. At the same time the force applied by the dipole and the resulting elastic stress will vanish at these modes. Mode n = 0 of the displacement never vanishes since it includes the constant term u0 which represents the fixed symmetric displacement created by the force dipole, which does not depend on the interaction. For the size (n = 0) we have two options - fixed size (FS) namely displacement homeostasis, in which we regulate this mode, and variable size (VS) namely stress homeostasis, in which we allow it Fixed Position: Variable Position: 12 Fixed Size: Variable Size: FIG. 5: The four possible scenarios of shape regulation, depending on whether the size (n = 0) and the position (n = 1) are regulated or not. to have an additional contribution due to the interaction. Similarly we consider either fixed position (FP) or variable position (VP) of the force dipole (n = 1). In the VP case instead of the cancellation condition (20-21), the coefficients C1, D1 obey the following: (4 − 4ν)C1 − 2D1 + (f Cr 1mCm + f Dr 1m Dm) = (3 − 4ν)C1 + D1 + (f Cθ 1mCm + f Dθ 1m Dm) = ∞Xm=0 ∞Xm=0 2 ∞Xm=0(cid:18) f Cr ∞Xm=0(cid:18) f Cr 2 1m + f Cθ 1m f Dr 1m + f Dθ 1m Cm + 2 1m + f Cθ 1m Cm + f Dr 1m + f Dθ 1m 2 Dm(cid:19) , Dm(cid:19) . (23) (24) Equations (23-24) allow us to find C1 and D1 that cancel the deformation at mode 1 without canceling the transla- tional motion of the force dipole. They follow from Eqs. (20-21) and from the fact that for translation the coefficients of P1(cosθ) = cos(θ) in the radial direction and of dP1(cosθ) dθ = sin(θ) in the tangential direction must be equal. E. Interaction energy After obtaining the coefficients Cn and Dn and substituting them in Eqs. (12-15) we compute the interaction energy from the work performed by the force dipoles to generate this deformation: Here the integration is over the surfaces of both spheres, −→F is the force per unit area applied by each force dipole on ∆E = E − 2E0 = 1 2ZS(cid:16)−→u · −→F − −→u0 · −→F0(cid:17) ds. (25) its environment. It is important to emphasize the difference in calculation of the interaction energies in the cases of dead versus live force dipoles. In the general case of two dead force dipoles the displacements and forces applied by each one of them are not affected by changes in its environment and thus the amount of additional work done by it equals [43] [see Eq. (25)]: ∆Ei = 1 2ZSih(−→ui + −→uj) · −→Fi − −→ui · −→Fii dSi = 1 2ZSi −→uj · −→FidSi. (26) In the particular case that the force dipoles apply isotropic forces or displacements causing only volume change without distortion (as for two "dead" spherical force dipoles) the interaction energy ∆E vanishes [27]. In contrast, for two "live" force dipoles the forces and displacements created by each one of them are modified due to the interaction with the neighbor. The resultant forces and displacements applied by "live" force dipoles are not isotropic and the interaction energy does not vanish anymore. Here the additional work that is performed by each force dipole is: 13 ∆Ei = = 1 2ZSih(−→ui + δ−→ui + −→uj + δ−→uj)(−→Fi + δ−→Fi) − −→ui · −→Fii dSi 2ZSih−→uj · −→Fi + δ−→ui · −→Fi + δ−→uj · −→Fi + −→ui · δ−→Fi + −→uj · δ−→Fi + δ−→ui · δ−→Fi + δ−→uj · δ−→Fii dSi. 1 (27) Here δ−→u and δ−→F are the "live" parts of the displacement and the force created by the force dipoles due to their interaction. For two "live" force dipoles, we evaluate the interaction energy using the stress tensor τ that arises in the elastic environment of each force dipole in response to the displacement −→u on its surface. The energy evaluated in Eq. (27) equals the work done by spherical force dipole i on its surface and thus we add the index i and the total interaction energy is E1 + E2. The forces applied by each force dipole are equal and opposite to the forces applied on it by the environment: −→F = −τ · r, where r is the outward pointing unit vector normal to the surface of the sphere after its deformation and movement. Since we allow only volume change and translational motion of the entire force dipoles, the direction of the normal does not change due to the interaction. The terms of the stress tensor τ based on the general solution of the displacements field Eqs. (5-6) [41] are given in Appendix C. −→F0 = 4Gu0 unit area on the surface of the sphere in the case of a single force dipole with known isotropic displacement −→u0 = u0r r is the force per R0 on its surface and without interactions with other spheres, and thus the self energy is E0 = 8πGu2 0R0. Evaluation of the integral in Eq. (25) may be simplified by noting that both the displacements −→u and the stresses τ are expressed in terms of Legendre polynomials and their derivatives [see Eqs. (20-21)] and using their orthogonality we get (see Appendix D): E = 2 · 1 2ZS −→u · −→F ds = 2E0 1 + D0 −(−D0 + ∞Xm=0hf Cr 0mCm + f Dr 0m (Dm − √4πδm,0)i)! . In the FS cases D0 is evaluated from the cancellation condition and Eq. (28) becomes: EF S = 2E0 (1 + D0) = 2E0 1 −( ∞Xm=0hf Cr 0mCm + f Dr 0m(cid:16)Dm − √4πδm,0(cid:17)i)! , while in the VS cases D0 is zero and Eq. (28) becomes: EV S = 2E0(1 + ∞Xm=0hf Cr 0mCm + f Dr 0m(cid:16)Dm − √4πδm,0(cid:17)i) . (28) (29) (30) The meaning of the sum of the last two terms in Eqs. (29-30) is the change of the volume of force dipole 1 caused by all the modes of displacement created by force dipole 2 (see Fig. 2). We thus define: 14 ∆V21 ≡ ∞Xm=0hf Cr 0mCm + f Dr 0m(cid:16)Dm − Thus the interaction energies in the FS cases become: and in the VS cases: ∆EF S = −2E0∆V21, ∆EV S = 2E0∆V21. III. RESULTS √4πδm,0(cid:17)i . (31) (32) (33) We evaluated the interaction energy by terminating the infinite sums (20-21) at different values of nmax, up to nmax = 15 for all four regulation scenarios. Figure 6 shows the normalized interaction energy ∆ E = ∆E/E0 vs the normalized distance between the force dipoles d = d/R0 for all four regulation scenarios. Figure 7 shows the convergence of the interaction energy with increasing the value of nmax. Even at the smallest dipole-dipole separations the solution converges with moderate value of nmax = 4 − 5. Moreover, for distances larger than 4 sphere radii in the FSVP, VSFP and VSVP cases and for distances larger than 6 sphere radii in the FSFP case the energy is well 0.01 4 10 6 10 8 10 E(cid:2) (cid:1) a FSFP 1 2 14 FSVP 2 3 15 0.01 4 10 6 10 8 10 E(cid:3) (cid:2) (cid:1) b VSFP 1 2 14 VSVP 2 3 15 2 5 10 20 50 100 2 5 10 20 50 100 d(cid:1) d(cid:1) FIG. 6: Dimensionless interaction energy ∆ eE = ∆E E0 vs dimensionless distance between the two force dipoles ed = d R0 , with different values of nmax as indicated in the legend. Poisson ratio was set to ν = 0.45. Note that the interaction energy in the FS cases is positive (repulsive), and in the VS cases negative (attractive). The far-field behavior in the FP cases is given by 1/ d4 and for VP by 1/ d6. 15 FIG. 7: Interaction energy vs inverse of highest term nmax included in the solution. Energy is rescaled by the result with the minimal possible value of nmax. Results are shown for Poisson ratio ν = 0.45 and dimensionless distance d = 2.5 between the centers of the two force dipoles. approximated by taking the minimal nmax possible. Namely for the FP cases nmax = 1 suffices, and for the VP cases we take nmax = 2, see Table I. Since in Eq. (20) the coefficient of C0 vanishes and Eq. (21) vanishes for n = 0 there is no need to evaluate the coefficient C0. Thus in the FS cases we get three coupled linear equations and in the VS cases two coupled linear equations. It is important to reiterate the role of the n = 0 and n = 1 terms in the solution. Excluding the n = 1 term of the sum in Eqs. (5-6) constitutes the VP cases in which the force dipoles are free to move but preserve their size and shape, and excluding the n = 0 term constitutes the VS cases in which the force dipoles preserve their spherical shape but are free to change their volume due to the interaction. We see from Eq. (28) that the presence of the coefficient D0 determines the sign of the interaction energy, see also Fig. 6 and Table I; Force dipoles with FS regulation (D0 6= 0), are repelled, while force dipoles with VS regulation (D0 = 0) are attracted. This is similar to our analysis within the spherical unit-cell approximation of different homeostasis scenarios, where we found repulsion when the force dipole generates a fixed displacement on its boundary and attraction when it applies a fixed stress on its environment [30]. Relating this to our present results, in the FS cases the resultant displacement on the boundary of each force dipole is fixed and does not depend on the changes in its environment, which corresponds to displacement homeostasis. In the VS cases the size of each force dipole changes due to the interaction, namely the displacement is not fixed. There is no correction to the n = 0 mode, which means that there is no additional active force or stress at this mode, and we relate this to stress homeostasis, in which indeed the interaction is attractive. Fixed Size Fixed Size Variable Size Variable Size Fixed Position Variable Position Fixed Position Variable Position (F SF P ) (F SV P ) (V SF P ) (V SV P ) 16 nmax 1 2 (1−2ν) 5−6ν 1 ed4 5(1−2ν) 4−5ν 1 ed6 1 0 2 0 D0 C1 D1 C2 D2 − 3 2(5−6ν) 1 ed2 9(2−3ν) 4(4−5ν)(5−6ν) 1 ed7 − 3 2(5−6ν) 1 ed2 9(2−3ν) 4(4−5ν)(5−6ν) 1 ed7 − 1 2(5−6ν) 1 ed2 9(2−3ν)(7−8ν) 4(4−5ν)(5−6ν) 1 ed7 − 1 2(5−6ν) 1 ed2 9(2−3ν)(7−8ν) 4(4−5ν)(5−6ν) 1 ed7 0 0 − 5 4(4−5ν) 1 ed3 − 3 2(4−5ν) 1 ed3 0 0 − 5 4(4−5ν) 1 ed3 − 3 2(4−5ν) 1 ed3 ∆V21 − 2(1−2ν)C1 3 ed2 − 4(1−2ν)C2 ed3 − 2(1−2ν)C1 3 ed2 − 4(1−2ν)C2 ed3 ∆ eE∞ 2(1−2ν) (5−6ν) · 1 ed4 10(1−2ν) (4−5ν) · 1 ed6 − 2(1−2ν) (5−6ν) · 1 ed4 − 10(1−2ν) (4−5ν) · 1 ed6 TABLE I: Coefficients Cn and Dn of the multipole expansion at asymptotically long-distances, ed ≫ 1. Here nmax defines the highest order term taken into account, and ∆ eE∞ is the asymptotic long-distance behavior of the resultant dimensionless interaction energy ∆ eE ≡ Eint E0 . ed = d R0 is the dimensionless distance between the force dipoles, and ∆V21 is defined in Eq. (33). The corresponding expressions for arbitrary distance are given in Appendix E. An intuitive explanation for the sign difference in the interaction may be considered as follows; FS means that in the proximity to other force dipoles, each force dipole has to exert an additional force in order to generate the displacement that it was programmed to have. Thus more energy is required and the force dipoles would benefit energetically from moving away from each other. As noted above, VS is related to stress homeostasis, for which the tension that neighboring contractile force dipoles generate around themselves add up, and less energy is required in order to reach the homeostatic stress value, thus it is beneficial for cells to be close to other cells. The position regulation (n = 1) sets the strength of these attractive or repulsive interactions. For VP, C1 = D1 = 0 and at long distances the interaction energy decays as 1/d6, while for FP, C1 and D1 are nonzero, which leads to a 1/d4 decay, see Fig. 6 and Table I. To quantitatively relate these functional forms to the results of our spherical unit-cell approximation, we consider an infinite array of active force dipoles. Using our results for the interaction between two active force dipoles, we now evaluate the interaction energy in an infinite 3D array of such shape-regulating spherical force dipoles (see Fig. 3). In a linear medium and for small displacements generated by each force dipole, by superposition the total interaction energy per force dipole is: Etot =Z ∞ r=0 nEint(r) · 4πr2dr ≈Z ∞ r=D nEint(r) · 4πr2dr, 17 (34) where n is the density of force dipoles at distance r from any given force dipole, which for large distances we assume is uniform, and we introduce a near-field cutoff distance equal to the lattice spacing D. Substituting the expressions for the two-force-dipole interactions from Table I in Eq. (34) and performing the integrations, yields: Etot ∝ 1/D (FP), 1/D3 (VP). The VP cases are quantitatively consistent with the results of our previous work within the spherical unit-cell approximation [30] that the interaction energy in an array of "live" force dipoles scales as 1/R3 c, since the radius Rc of the periodic unit cell is related to the distance D between force dipoles in the periodic array. Due to the symmetry of the spherical unit-cell setup, by definition there is no need for the force dipole to exert any force in order to remain in place and thus there is no regulation of the position, which corresponds to our VP case. The expressions for the interaction energy given in Table I (and similarly in Table II in Appendix E for arbitrary distance) all vanish in the incompressible limit (ν = 0.5). The self-displacement generated by each force dipole separately includes a pure compressive mode inside that force dipole, and sustaining this in an incompressible medium with a fixed displacement u0 on the boundary requires an infinite force. Thus the problem of mechanical interactions between force dipoles in a completely incompressible medium deserves a separate analysis, which we defer to future work. IV. DISCUSSION We model live cells as spherical force dipoles surrounded by a linear, or Hookean elastic environment. Since in the case of isotropic displacements and forces the interaction energy between force dipoles vanishes, we distinguish between "dead" behavior in which the force dipoles apply constant forces and self-displacements on their surface, and "live" behavior in which the forces and self-displacements applied change in response to changes in the environment of the force dipoles. We solved the interaction energy for four different types of such regulation in which the force dipoles preserve their spherical shape and in addition volume, position, both or none of them. We found the interaction energy to be inversely proportional to the distance between the force dipoles to the fourth power in the case of fixed position and to the sixth power in the case of variable position. These results are similar to and stem from the same reasons as the van der Waals dipole-induced dipole interaction in electrostatics [44]. We also found that in the case of volume 18 preservation the force dipoles are repelled while without volume preservation they are attracted. We solved the deformation fields for the case when the rigidity of the force dipoles is identical to that of their environment. However, biological cells are complex entities and their rigidity differs from point to point and also differs from the rigidity of the extracellular matrix. In order to relate our results to live cells we describe each of them as a mechanism that applies forces on its environment on the surface and responds by their variation to application of external force or displacement. The displacements and forces applied by a cell may be divided into "passive" and "active" parts. The "passive" part of the forces or displacements would stay the same if the cells were dead and preserve their elastic properties, while the "active" part depends on the programmed behavior of the cells and is generated by the contraction of acto-myosin networks inside them. Since the resultant force and displacement are the sum of those two parts cells may create such "active" response such that the resultant forces and displacements will coincide with the case considered here, for which their rigidity coincides with the rigidity of their environment. Stress homeostasis vs displacement homeostasis is believed to occur in different cell types and in different mechanical environments [45]. We suggest to examine in experiments the correlation that we find here between these distinct regulatory behaviors and attraction vs repulsion. Specifically, for cells that are known to regulate their stress or displacement one could test whether they indeed are attracted or repelled, respectively. Alternatively, when the regulatory behavior is not known, we suggest that our results will enable to infer it from the direction of the interaction. It would be interesting to consider also more complicated regulatory behaviors on top of the two extreme limits of fixed stress and fixed displacement. In particular, it would be interesting to test whether our fixed-position vs variable- position cases could generate more complex scenarios, since we predict that that would relate to the interaction strength. Clearly the interaction energy that we focus our analysis on may not be directly probed in experiments. We suggest that our predictions on attraction or repulsion between cells could be tested by studying other experimental indications of inter-cellular interactions. For instance, cells that are attracted to each other tend to try and move closer together but in rigid environments may not move and instead send protrusions one toward each other [6]. Moreover, focusing of mechanical stress between interacting cells may be experimentally visualized [2]. Following our work on three-dimensional spherical force dipoles, it would be interesting to solve the case of two- dimensional disks on an elastic medium. The same four regulatory possibilities can be considered. This could more directly be related to experiments in which cells are grown on surfaces of different elastic materials [6]. We expect that in this case the interaction energy will not vanish even for "dead" force dipoles. Clearly the work presented in this paper is a first step toward theoretical analysis of interactions that stem from mechanobiological regulation, and in particular shape regulation of live cells. Our focus on linearly-elastic, homogeneous and isotropic media enabled us to obtain the detailed analytical description presented above. It would be important to continue this line of research and study the influence of the material nonlinearity, heterogeneity and anisotropy of the ECM on the interaction between cells. 19 Acknowledgments We thank Dan Ben-Yaakov, Kinjal Dasbiswas, Haim Diamant, Erez Kaufman, Ayelet Lesman, Sam Safran, Nimrod Segall, Eial Teomy, Daphne Weihs and Xinpeng Xu for helpful discussions. This work was partially supported by the Israel Science Foundation grant No. 968/16, by a grant from the United States-Israel Binational Science Foundation and by a grant from the Ela Kodesz Institute for Medical Physics and Engineering. Appendix A: Vanishing interaction energy between "dead" cells Here we calculate the vanishing interaction energy between two "dead" spherical force dipoles each with radius R0 applying an isotropic radial force F on its environment, see Fig. 2. The environment behaves as a linear elastic material with shear modulus G. The displacements field around a single such force dipole is given by [46]: In order to evaluate the resultant displacement of two such force dipoles we superimpose the displacement fields of both force dipoles. To do so, we translate the displacement field created by force dipole 1 to the coordinate system of force dipole 2. Using the cosine theorem we rewrite the displacement fields created by the force dipoles in terms of θ2 and d, see Fig. 2: Here br1 and br2 are unit vectors in the radial directions of force dipoles 1 and 2, respectively. The resultant displacement in the radial direction of force dipole 2 is: ur =(cid:20) F R 4G br2 + 4G (R2 F R3 0 0 + d2 + 2R0d cos θ2)br1(cid:21) · br2 = F R0 4G "1 + R2 0 (R0 + d cos θ2) 0 + d2 + 2ad cos θ2)3/2# . (R2 (A4) −→u (R) = F R3 0 4Gr2br. F R3 0 0 + d2 + 2R0d cos θ2)br1, −→u1 = −→u2 = 4G (R2 F R0 4G br2. (A1) (A2) (A3) The symmetry of the system imposes that the total work done by the system reads: E =Z π 0 (cid:18)2 · 1 2 F ur · 2πR0 sin θ2(cid:19) R0dθ2 = After evaluation we obtain: πF 2R3 0 2G Z π 0 "sin θ2 + (R0 + d cos θ2) R2 0 + d2 + 2R0d cos θ2)3/2# dθ2. 0 sin θ2 (R2 E = πF 2R3 0 2G = 2 · 4πR2 0 · 1 2 F · F R0 4G = 2E0. 20 (A5) (A6) Thus the interaction energy vanishes in this case. A similar analysis may be done for two force dipoles which apply radial displacements u0 on their surfaces. The energy in this case may be written as: E = 16R0πu2 0G = 2E0, (A7) and also here the interaction energy vanishes. Appendix B: The functions f Cr nm, f Dr nm, f Cθ nm and f Dθ nm The expressions for the functions f Cr nm, f Dr nm, f Cθ nm and f Dθ nm appearing in Eqs. (18-31) are: 2 2 (2n + 1) (2n + 1) Z π 0 (cid:2)g1 Z π 0 (cid:2)g3 2n(n + 1)r 2n + 1 2n(n + 1)r 2n + 1 (2n + 1) (2n + 1) 4π f Cr f Dr nm(ed) = nm(ed) = nm(ed) = nm(ed) = f Cθ f Dθ 4π Z π 0 (cid:2)g5 Z π 0 (cid:2)g7 =r 2n + 1 4π We used the identity [47] mYm (ψ) + g2 mYm (ψ) + g4 mYm+1 (ψ)(cid:3) Yn(θ1)dθ1, mYm+1 (ψ)(cid:3) Yn(θ1)dθ1, mYm (ψ) + g6 mYm (ψ) + g8 mYm+1 (ψ)(cid:3) [cos(θ1)Pn(θ1) − Pn+1(θ1)]dθ1, mYm+1 (ψ)(cid:3) [cos(θ1)Pn(θ1) − Pn+1(θ1)]dθ1. dYn(θ) dθ (n + 1)(cid:20) Pn+1(cos θ) sin θ − cot θPn(cos θ)(cid:21) to rewrite the derivatives dYn(θ) dθ in terms of θ, and for the sake of brevity we defined: g1 m =ned2(cid:2)m2 − m(3 − 4ν) − 4(1 − ν)(cid:3) − 2ed(cid:0)m2 − 2 + 2ν(cid:1) cos(θ1) + m2 + m(3 − 4ν)o sin(θ1)/ζm+1, g2 m = −hed(m + 1)(m − 4 + 4ν)i sin(θ1)/ζm, g3 m = − (m + 1) sin(θ1)/ζm+1, g4 m = ed(m + 1) sin(θ1)/ζm+2, (B1) (B2) (B3) (B4) (B5) (B6) (B7) (B8) (B9) m = −(cid:16)ed2 + 1(cid:17) (m + 1)(m − 4 + 4ν) cos(θ1) +ed(cid:2)m(m − 6 + 8ν) − 6(1 − ν) +(cid:0)m2 − 2 + 2ν(cid:1) cos(2θ1)(cid:3) sin(θ1)ζm+2 g5 where g6 m = −(m + 1)(m − 4 + 4ν)/[sin(θ1)ζm], g7 m = (m + 1) cot(θ1)/ζm+1, g8 m = −[ed cos(θ1) − 1](m + 1)/[sin(θ1)ζm+2], ψ ≡hed − cos(θ1)i /ζ, ζ ≡pd2 − 2d cos(θ1) + 1. Appendix C: The stress tensor 21 , (B10) (B11) (B12) (B13) (B14) (B15) Here we develop the expressions for the stress tensor in the cases discussed in the paper. The applied displacements are symmetric about an axis passing through the centers of the two force dipoles. The expressions are taken from [41] for the case of the displacement field given by Eqs. (5-6), excluding the first term in Eq. (5) which corresponds to volume change. The stress tensor τ may be written in the following form in this case: (C1) τ = ∞Xn=0 τ (n) rr τ (n) rθ τ (n) rϕ τ (n) θr τ (n) θθ τ (n) θϕ τ (n) ϕr τ (n) ϕθ τ (n) ϕϕ   , Dn eri , dθi stress tensor τ = τ G R0 u0 , the elements of which are given by: n+3 (n + 1)(n + 2)(cid:21) Yn (cosθi) Cn n+1 n(n2 + 3n − 2ν) + Dn eri n+3 (n + 2)(cid:21) dYn (cosθi) n+1 n(n2 − 2n − 1 + 2ν) − The stress tensor is symmetriceτij =eτji and thus only six components are to be evaluated. We define the dimensionless RR =2(cid:20)− eτ (n) eri Rθ =2(cid:20) Cn eτ (n) n+1 (n2 − 2 + 2ν) − eri θθ =2(cid:26)(cid:20) Cn eτ (n) eri ϕϕ =2(cid:26)(cid:20) Cn eτ (n) eri Rϕ =eτ (n) eτ (n) n+3 (n + 1)2(cid:21) Yn(cosθi) −(cid:20) Cn eri n+3 (n + 1)(cid:21) Yn(cosθi) +(cid:20) Cn eri n+3(cid:21) dYn(cosθi) eri n+3(cid:21) dYn(cosθi) eri ctgθ(cid:27) , ctgθ(cid:27) , (C4) n+1 n(n + 3 − 4nν − 2ν) − n+1 (−n + 4 − 4ν) + n+1 (−n + 4 − 4ν) + Dn Dn eri eri dθi dθi Dn Dn (C2) (C3) (C5) (C6) θϕ = 0. Appendix D: Derivation of Eq. (28) 22 Here we evaluate the integral (28) for the interaction energy of two "live" spherical force dipoles. Without loss of generality, we take the initial isotropic displacement in the positive direction: 2 · 1 2ZS = − 2πu2 0 1 [(urFr) + (uθF θ)] 2πR2 0 sin θdθ(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)er=1 2Z π −→u · −→F ds = 2 er2 +eur11 +eur21(cid:19)(cid:20)−(cid:18) 4 11(cid:19)(cid:21) + (euθ11 +euθ21)(cid:16)−τ −1(cid:26)(cid:18)− 0GR0Z 1 er3 + τ 1 22(cid:17)(cid:27) dcosθ(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)er=1 Hereeur11, eur21, euθ11, euθ21 and τ are defined below [see Eqs. (12-15) and (C1-C6)]. The terms − 1 isotropic self-displacement created by each spherical force dipole and the corresponding force applied on it in response er2 and − 4 er2 are the (D1) by the environment. Noting the fact that all the terms in (D1) are given in terms of Legendre polynomials Pn(cosθ) and their derivatives dPn(cosθ) dθ and using their orthogonality, after integration and cancellation of the appropriate terms we get: 0mCm + f Dr 0m (Dm − √4πδm,0)i) nmCm + f Dr nm(Dm − √4πδm,0)i) 16πu2 − 0GR0 1 + D0 −(−D0 + ∞Xm=0hf Cr ∞Xn=1(n(n + 3 − 4ν)Cn − (n + 1)Dn + ·(cid:2)n(n2 + 3n − 2ν)Cn − (n + 1)(n + 2)Dn(cid:3) · ∞Xn=1((−n + 4 − 4ν)Cn + Dn + ∞Xm=0hf Cθ 2n + 1 ! · 2(cid:2)−(n2 − 2 + 2ν)Cn + (n + 2)Dn(cid:3) n(n + 1) − ∞Xm=0hf Cr 2 4(2n + 1) nmCm + f Dθ nm(Dm − √4πδm,0)i) (D2) In the FP cases the coefficients Cn, Dn for any n were either evaluated using the appropriate cancellation condition, Eqs. (20-21) or assumed to be zero. In both FP cases the last two terms in Eq. (D1) vanish and the result becomes: 1 2ZS 2 · −→u · −→F ds = 16πu2 0GR0 1 + D0 −(−D0 + ∞Xm=0hf Cr 0mCm + f Dr 0m (Dm − √4πδm,0)i)! (D3) In the VP cases on the other hand we do not calculate the coefficients C1 and D1 using the cancellation conditions, but using the conditions (23-24) instead. Thus in VP cases neither the displacements, nor the stress vanish for n = 1. Using (23-24) we get in these cases: 1 2ZS 2 · −→u · −→F ds = 16πu2 0GR0 1 + D0 −(−D0 + ∞Xm=0(cid:18) f Cθ ∞Xm=0(cid:18) f Cr [(1 − 2ν)C1 + 3D1] [(4 − 2ν)C1 − 6D1] 1 6 − 4 3 − ∞Xm=0hf Cr 0mCm + f Dr 0m (Dm − 1m − f Cr 1m 2 Cm + f Dθ 1m − f Dr 1m 2 1m − f Cθ 1m 2 Cm + 1m − f Dθ f Dr 1m 2 √4πδm,0)i) Dm(cid:19) Dm(cid:19)! (D4) The last two terms in Eq. (D4) are proportional to higher powers of Cn and Dn. It may be seen from Table I that the coefficients Cn and Dn are inversely proportional to ed, and thus at large distances the last two terms in Eq. (D4) may be neglected and Eq. (D4) reduces to Eq. (D3). 23 Appendix E: D0, C1, D1, C2, D2 and ∆E for arbitrary distance In Table II we present the expressions for the coefficients D0, C1, D1, C2, D2 and for the dimensionless interaction energy ∆eE without the large-distance assumption that appears in Table I. Variable Size Variable Size Fixed Size Fixed Size Fixed Position Variable Position Fixed Position Variable Position (F SF P ) (F SV P ) (V SF P ) (V SV P ) nmax 1 D0 C1 5(1−2ν) ed2 Λ1 − 15 ed4 2Λ1 2 λ1 Λ2 1 0 2 0 315(2−3ν) ed6 Λ2 − 15 ed4 2Λ3 63(2−3ν) ed3 Λ4 D1 − ed[5 ed3 −(8−12ν)] 2Λ1 315(2−3ν)(7−8ν) ed6 Λ2 ed[5 ed3 − −(8−12ν)] 2Λ3 63(2−3ν)(7−8ν) ed3 Λ4 C2 D2 ∆ eE − 0 0 10(1−2ν) ed2 Λ1 35[5(5−6ν) ed3 +(2−3ν)] ed7 Λ2 − λ2 Λ2 λ3 Λ2 2 0 0 − − 10(1−2ν) ed2 Λ3 − 35(5−6ν) ed7 Λ4 6(7 ed5 −28+40ν) ed2 Λ4 − λ4 Λ4 ∆ eE∞ 2(1−2ν) (5−6ν) · 1 ed4 10(1−2ν) (4−5ν) · 1 ed6 − 2(1−2ν) (5−6ν) · 1 ed4 − 10(1−2ν) (4−5ν) · 1 ed6 TABLE II: Coefficients Cn and Dn of the first terms of the multipole expansion. nmax denotes the highest-order term taken into account, ∆ eE ≡ Eint E0 is the resultant dimensionless interaction energy and ∆ eE∞ is its asymptotic long-distance behavior given also in Table I. ed = d R0 is the dimensionless distance between the force dipoles. We use the following expressions: Λ1 = 5(5 − 6ν)ed6 − 30(1 − ν)ed5 + 10ed3 − (5 − 10ν)ed2 − (8 − 12ν), Λ2 = 140(cid:0)20 − 49ν + 30ν2(cid:1)ed13 − 28(cid:0)242 − 403ν + 135ν2(cid:1)ed10 + 2520(5 − 6ν)ed8 − 35(cid:0)86 − 283ν + 216ν2(cid:1)ed7 − 1260(cid:0)10 − 27ν + 18ν2(cid:1)ed5 + 70(cid:0)2 − 7ν + 6ν2(cid:1)ed4 − 720(cid:0)35 − 92ν + 60ν2(cid:1)ed3 − 36(cid:0)14 − 41ν + 30ν2(cid:1) , Λ3 = 5(5 − 6ν)ed6 − 30(1 − ν)ed5 + 10ed3 − (8 − 12ν), (E1) (E2) (E3) Λ4 = 4(5 − 6ν)h7(4 − 5ν)ed10 − 35(2 − ν)ed7 + 126ed5 − 36(7 − 10ν)i , λ1 = 70(1 − 2ν)h10(5 − 6ν)ed3 − (2 − 3ν)ied4, 24 (E4) (E5) (E6) λ2 =h35ed8(5 − 6ν) + 7ed5(2 − 3ν) − 20ed3(cid:0)35 − 92ν + 60ν2(cid:1) −(cid:0)14 − 41ν + 30ν2(cid:1)i 6ed2, λ3 = 70ed4h2800(5 − 6ν)2(cid:0)10ν2 − 13ν + 4(cid:1)ed16 + 420(cid:0)330ν4 + 1411ν3 − 3961ν2 + 2898ν − 640(cid:1)ed13 − 50400(5 − 6ν)2(2ν − 1)ed11 − 14(cid:0)40230ν4 − 81594ν3 + 50371ν2 − 6691ν − 1586(cid:1)ed10 − 630(cid:0)7074ν4 − 17937ν3 + 15963ν2 − 5636ν + 580(cid:1)ed8 − 105(cid:0)3396ν4 − 11879ν3 + 15041ν2 − 8232ν + 1652(cid:1)ed7 − 14400(5 − 6ν)2(cid:0)20ν2 − 24ν + 7(cid:1)ed6 − 504(2 − 3ν)2(cid:0)375ν2 − 643ν + 275(cid:1)ed5 − 140(cid:0)6ν2 − 7ν + 2(cid:1)2 ed4 − 360(cid:16)14940ν4 − 46008ν3 + 52895ν2 −26907ν + 5110)ed3 − 18(2 − 3ν)2(cid:0)790ν2 − 1263ν + 497(cid:1)i , λ4 = 28edh1400(5 − 6ν)2(cid:0)4 − 13ν + 10ν2(cid:1)ed13 − 70(cid:0)8000 − 39830ν + 71471ν2 − 54759ν3 + 15030ν4(cid:1)ed10 + 25200(5 − 6ν)2(1 − 2ν)ed8 − 525(cid:0)250 − 1465ν + 3163ν2 − 2988ν3 + 1044ν4(cid:1)ed7 − 945(cid:0)500 − 2180ν + 3431ν2 − 2277ν3 + 522ν4(cid:1)ed5 + 1890(2 − 3ν)2(cid:0)25 − 54ν + 29ν2(cid:1)ed4 − 7200(5 − 6ν)2(cid:0)7 − 24ν + 20ν2(cid:1)ed3 − 567(2 − 3ν)2(cid:0)300 − 673ν + 377ν2(cid:1)ed2 + 540(cid:0)1750 − 9255ν + 18281ν2 − 15984ν3 + 5220ν4(cid:1)i . (E7) (E8) [1] G. Salbreux, G. Charras, and E. Paluch, Trends in Cell Biology 22, 536 (2012). [2] J. P. Winer, S. Oake, and P. A. Janmey, PloS one 4, e6382 (2009). [3] M. Ghibaudo, A. Saez, L. Trichet, A. Xayaphoummine, J. Browaeys, P. Silberzan, A. Buguinb, and B. Ladoux, Soft Matter 4, 1836 (2008). [4] N. Nisenholz, K. Rajendran, Q. Dang, H. Chen, R. Kemkemer, R. Krishnanb, and A. Zemel, Soft Matter 10, 7234 (2014). [5] V. B. Shenoy, H. Wang, and X. Wang, Interface Focus 6, 20150067 (2016). [6] C. A. Reinhart-King, M. Dembo, and D. A. Hammer, Biophysical Journal 95, 6044 (2008). [7] T. Korff and H. G. Augustin, Journal of Cell Science 112, 3249 (1999). [8] Q. Shi, R. P. Ghosh, H. Engelke, C. H. Rycroft, L. Cassereau, J. A. Sethian, V. M. Weaver, and J. T. Liphardt, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111, 658 (2014). [9] J. Notbohm, A. Lesman, P. Rosakis, D. A. Tirrell, and G. Ravichandran, Journal of The Royal Society Interface 12, 20150320 (2015). [10] C.-L. Guo, M. Ouyang, J.-Y. Yu, J. Maslov, A. Price, and C.-Y. Shen, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 25 109, 5576 (2012). [11] A. Lesman, J. Notbohm, D. A. Tirrell, and G. Ravichandran, The Journal of Cell Biology 205, 155 (2014). [12] J. Solon, I. Levental, K. Sengupta, P. C. Georges, and P. A. Janmey, Biophysical Journal 93, 4453 (2007). [13] S. Y. Tee, J. Fu, C. S. Chen, and P. A. Janmey, Biophysical Journal 100, L25 (2011). [14] A. J. Engler, S. Sen, H. L. Sweeney, and D. E. Discher, Cell 126, 677 (2006). [15] H. Mohammadi, P. A. Janmey, and C. A. McCulloch, Biomaterials 35, 1138 (2014). [16] S. He, Y. Su, B. Ji, and H. Gao, Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids 70, 116 (2014). [17] W. S. Leong, C. Y. Tay, H. Yu, A. Li, S. C. Wu, D.-H. Duc, C. T. Lim, and L. P. Tan, Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 401, 287 (2010). [18] X. Xu and S. A. Safran, Physical Review E 92, 032728 (2015). [19] P. Rosakis, J. Notbohm, and G. Ravichandran, Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids 85, 16 (2015). [20] M. S. Rudnicki, H. A. Cirka, M. Aghvami, E. A. Sander, Q. Wen, and K. L. Billiar, Biophysical Journal 105, 11 (2013). [21] X. Ma, M. E. Schickel, M. D. Stevenson, A. L. Sarang-Sieminski, K. J. Gooch, S. N. Ghadiali, and R. T. Hart, Biophysical Journal 104, 1410 (2013). [22] A. Abhilash, B. M. Baker, B. Trappmann, C. S. Chen, and V. B. Shenoy, Biophysical Journal 107, 1829 (2014). [23] P. Ronceray, C. Broedersz, and M. Lenz, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113, 2827 (2016). [24] H. Wang, A. S. Abhilash, C. S. Chen, R. G. Wells, and V. B. Shenoy, Biophysical Journal 107, 2592 (2014). [25] Y. Shokef and S. A. Safran, Physical Review Letters 108, 178103 (2012). [26] Y. Shokef and S. A. Safran, Physical Review Letters 109, 169901 (2012). [27] G.Sines and R.Kikuchi, Acta Metallurgia 6, 500 (1958). [28] T. Mura, Micromechanics of Defects in Solids (Cluwer Academic Publishers, 1991), 2nd ed. [29] R. De, A. Zemel, and S. A. Safran, Biophysical Journal 94, L29 (2008). [30] D. Ben-Yaakov, R. Golkov, Y. Shokef, and S. A. Safran, Soft Matter 11, 1412 (2015). [31] U.S.Schwarz and S.A.Safran, Physical Review Letters 88, 048102 (2002). [32] I. B. Bischofs, S. A. Safran, and U. S. Schwarz, Phys. Rev. E 69, 021911 (2004). [33] U. S. Schwarz and S. A. Safran, Reviews of Modern Physics 85, 1327 (2013). [34] K. M. Hakkinen, J. S. Harunaga, A. D. Doyle, and K. M. Yamada, Tissue Engineering Part A 17, 713 (2011). [35] S. J. Mousavi and M. H. Doweidar, Physical Biology 11, 046005 (2014). [36] J. Eshelby, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A 241, 376 (1957). 26 [37] J. Eshelby, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A 252, 561 (1959). [38] R. Simes, Physica Status Solidi 30, 645 (1968). [39] F. Bitter, Physical Review 37, 1527 (1931). [40] J. Eshelby, Acta Metallurgica 3, 487 (1955). [41] A. Lurie, Three-Dimensional Problems of the Theory of Elasticity (Interscience Publishers, 1964), english ed., chapter 6. [42] G. B. Arfken, H. J. Weber, and F. E. Harris, Mathematical Methods for Physicists (Elsevier, 2013), 7th ed. [43] J. D. Eshelby, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 244, 87 (1951). [44] J. N.Israelachvili, Intermolecular and Surface Forces (Harcourt Brace and Company, 1992), 2nd ed. [45] J. Notbohm, A. Lesman, D. A. Tirrell, and G. Ravichandran, Integrative Biology 7, 1186 (2015). [46] L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Theory of Elasticity (Pergamon Press, 1970), 2nd ed. [47] http://functions.wolfram.com/Polynomials/SphericalHarmonicY/20/01/01/0002/.
1701.01225	1	1701	2017-01-05T06:52:55	Contact enhancement of locomotion in spreading cell colonies	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.CB" ]	The dispersal of cells from an initially constrained location is a crucial aspect of many physiological phenomena ranging from morphogenesis to tumour spreading. In such processes, the way cell-cell interactions impact the motion of single cells, and in turn the collective dynamics, remains unclear. Here, the spreading of micro-patterned colonies of non-cohesive cells is fully characterized from the complete set of individual trajectories. It shows that contact interactions, chemically mediated interactions and cell proliferation each dominates the dispersal process on different time scales. From data analysis and simulation of an active particle model, we demonstrate that contact interactions act to speed up the early population spreading by promoting individual cells to a state of higher persistence, which constitutes an as-yet unreported contact enhancement of locomotion. Our findings suggest that the current modeling paradigm of memoryless interacting active particles may need to be extended to account for the possibility of internal states and history-dependent behaviour of motile cells.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Contact enhancement of locomotion in spreading cell colonies Joseph d'Alessandro∗†‡, Alexandre Solon§, Yoshinori Hayakawa¶, Christophe Anjard†, Fran¸cois Detcheverry†, Jean-Paul Rieu† and Charlotte Rivi`ere∗† The dispersal of cells from an initially constrained location is a crucial aspect of many physiological phenomena ranging from morphogenesis to tumour spreading. In such processes, the way cell-cell interactions impact the motion of single cells, and in turn the collective dynamics, remains unclear. Here, the spreading of micro-patterned colonies of non-cohesive cells is fully characterized from the complete set of individual trajectories. It shows that contact interactions, chemically mediated interactions and cell proliferation each dominates the dispersal process on different time scales. From data analysis and simulation of an active particle model, we demonstrate that contact interactions act to speed up the early population spreading by promoting individual cells to a state of higher persistence, which constitutes an as-yet unreported contact enhancement of locomotion. Our findings suggest that the current modeling paradigm of memoryless interacting active particles may need to be extended to account for the possibility of internal states and history-dependent behaviour of motile cells. Understanding how cell assemblies regulate their motility is a major challenge of current bio- physics.1 Indeed, collective effects in the motion of cells play a crucial role in vivo in processes such as wound healing2, tumour progression3 or morphogenesis4. In understanding the often in- tricate relationship between the behaviours at the cellular level and the population scale, two basic questions arise: how do cell-cell interac- tions alter the properties of individual cell mo- tion? How do they impact the population dy- namics? in descriptions based on the Fisher-Kolmogorov- Petrovski-Piskunov (FKPP) equation7,8. How- ever, the assumption of non-interacting cells is often unwarranted9,10, as several types of cell-cell interactions affecting the collective dy- namics have been uncovered experimentally. A first class involves long-range interactions, which may be mediated by a chemical11,12 as in quo- rum sensing, or by the substrate13. A second class includes short-range contact interactions: volume exclusion, cell-cell adhesion or contact inhibition of locomotion (CIL)14, which acts to change the direction of motion of a cell upon contact with another cell. 7 1 0 2 n a J 5 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 5 2 2 1 0 . 1 0 7 1 : v i X r a The trajectory of a cell crawling on a surface is akin to a correlated random walk characterized by a persistence time beyond which the motion becomes diffusive5,6. In the absence of interac- tions, this would lead on long time to simple dif- fusion dynamics at the colony level, as captured ∗<To whom correspondence should be addressed. E- mail: joseph.d'[email protected], charlotte.riviere@univ- lyon1.fr> †Institut Lumi`ere Mati`ere, CNRS UMR 5306, Univer- sit´e Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Universit´e de Lyon, Lyon, 69622 Villeurbanne Cedex, France ‡Current adress: Institut Jacques Monod (IJM), CNRS UMR 7592 et Universit´e Paris Diderot, 75013 Paris, France §Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA ¶Center for Information Technology in Education, To- hoku University, Sendai 980-8578, Japan Despite their local nature, contact interactions have proven essential to the collective behaviour of cells, at least for dense assemblies with den- sity near close-packing. On the edge of a dense colony, CIL15 or excluded volume16 combined with a density gradient acts to bias the mo- tion towards free space10,17,18, hence facilitating the spreading of the colony9,16,19. This effect is further reinforced by the tension created by leader cells through adherens junctions17,20. In the bulk of a tissue, force transmission through adherens junctions21,22 (but also nematic align- ment23,24 or simple volume exclusion25) can lead to coordinated motion over several cell sizes and induce active jamming and glassy be- haviour26,27,28. The slowing down of tissue dy- 1 namics is especially clear in cell systems domi- nated by CIL15, which reduces the cell persis- tence29 or effective speed30. Here, we investigate collective cell migration at moderate density in assemblies lacking cell-cell adhesion. In contrast to the high-density regime, this region has received comparatively much less attention so far. By studying the spreading dynamics of micropatterned Dictyostelium dis- coideum cell colonies, we find that cell-cell con- tacts enhance the cell persistence, an effect that we refer to as contact enhancement of locomo- tion (CEL). This phenomenon results in a speed- up of the colony spreading upon increasing the packing fraction and defines a novel kind of interaction, which, instead of acting instanta- neously as a physical force, modifies the internal state of the moving agents and their subsequent behaviour. A highly controlled model of cell colony We used vegetative Dictyostelium discoideum (D.d.) cells, which are often considered as a benchmark for the amoeboid motility of fast- moving cells31,32,33. Moreover, they are espe- cially adapted to study the role of interactions in the absence of strong cell-cell adhesion, as they do not form such adhesions in nutrient-rich con- ditions34. To experimentally mimic the disper- sal of cells from an initial location in a repro- ducible way, we constrained a controlled num- ber of cells in a disk of diameter 320 µm, using PDMS micro-stencils35,17 (Fig. 1a). Taking off the micro-stencil, we let them migrate freely out- wards and image the colony for durations rang- ing from 8 h to 48 h (see snapshots in Fig. 1b and Supplementary Movie 1). We caracterize the colony spreading both at the population and individual cell levels (Fig. 1c). Making use of the circular symmetry, field quan- tities such as the density (Fig. 1c) are aver- aged over concentric rings and depend only on time t and the distance r from the centre of the colony. At short times, we first observe a de- crease of the density in the centre of the colony as it spreads to invade free space. Then, on time scales of the order of the doubling time β−1 ∼ 9 h, the density starts increasing uni- formly because of cell divisions. Finally, after 2 about 40h the density saturates at a carrying capacity ρmax ≈ 5 − 8 × 105 cell/cm2 (Fig. 1c). The spreading of the colony is found to be faster in the first few hours of the experiment. Us- ing the single cell trajectories obtained by au- tomated cell tracking, this observation can be related to the average cell speed (see Supplemen- tary Figure 1): After an initial increase, the cell speed decreases until it reaches a low-motility plateau at t ≈ 10 h. This behaviour at long times is well explained by the overall regula- tion of the motility through a secreted quorum- sensing factor, which has been evidenced in our group before11. Indeed, when repeating the spreading experiments with a continuous per- fusion of fresh medium to rinse out secreted molecules, the decrease in motility is suppressed and the colony instead rapidly reaches a high- motility plateau (see Supplementary Figure 1a). As soon as the perfusion stops, the concentration of quorum-sensing factors builds up and the cell speed falls down. Collective effects on the short- time spreading We now focus on the short-time spreading of the colony. It strikingly reveals that the higher the cell density, the faster the colony spreads (Fig. 2a-b and Supplementary Movies 2-3). This collective effect is seen on the density profiles or on the gyration radius, Rg = phr2i, which quantifies the size of the colony (see Fig. 2c -- e). To better characterise this effect, we com- pute the radial component vr of the velocity of each cell, and average over the colony. We find that this averaged hvri exhibits a positive peak around 100 min in the colonies with higher ini- tial density N0 = 246 ± 66 (Fig. 2f and Sup- plementary Figure 1). This implies that, in this time frame, cells move outward in average. The existence of a non-vanishing radial velocity is not surprising in itself since it is the analogue, for self-propelled particles36, of an outward dif- fusive flux. However, one expects the peak to be located at a time of the order of the persis- tence time of the particles (see Fig. 4), which is found around τp ∼ 5 min for D.d. cells in simi- lar conditions11,37. On the contrary, the radial velocity peak happens here on a much longer time scale ∼ 100 min. It strongly suggests that Figure 1: A highly-controlled experimental set-up gives full access to colony spreading dynamics at both individual and population scales. (a) Cartoon of the patterning technique. The cells are first deposited in a home-made well (brown) on top of a PDMS stencil (light gray) made by soft-lithography techniques (top). After 45 min of adhesion, the well and the stencil are removed (centre), creating an initial circular pattern of 320 µm in diameter (bottom), whose spreading is then followed by time-lapse microscopy. (b) Snapshots of a colony with N0 = 245 cells initially at t = 0 min (top) and t = 150 min (bottom). Scale bars: 200 µm. (c) Top: Evolution of the density profiles ρ(r, t) over 60 h (from blue to red) for one colony with initially N0 = 349 cells. All the curves are separated by a 2 h interval. The first three curves are drawn thicker to highlight the fast initial spreading of the colony. Bottom: Cell trajectories at the edge of the initial spot, from t = 0 min to t = 60 min. Scale bar 100 µm. an unknown effect speeds up the spreading on this longer time scale. Importantly, this effect neither originates from cell division (it happens on a time-scale much shorter than the doubling time) nor from distant chemically-mediated in- teractions arising from bulk soluble molecules (see Supplementary Figure 1) or from deposited trails (see Supplementary Figure 2). Most interestingly, we find that the amplitude of the peak in radial velocity strongly depends on the number of cells in the colony (Fig. 2f). Thus, the spreading rate is collectively increased through local interactions likely occurring when cells are in contact. To understand this density- dependent spreading dynamics, we now turn to a more refined analysis of the motion of individual cells. 3 Cell-cell contacts increase their persistence From our dataset of trajectories, we find that the short-time speed-up of colony spreading is con- trolled by a transient increase in the persistence of the cells, the effect being more pronounced the denser the initial colony. This statement, il- lustrated by sample trajectories in Figure 3a-b and Supplementary Figure 4, is motivated by a body of quantitative measurements. First, the cells appear more elongated, hence more polarised, in denser colonies (Fig. 3a). It is quantified by computing the cell contours' ec- centricity, which increases with density at early times before relaxing to values corresponding to more isotropic cell shapes (see Supplementary Figure 3). Second, we used the coefficient of movement effi- ciency (CME, see Methods) to estimate the per- t=0 mint=150 min02004006000246x 105r (µm)ρ (cm−2)Time increasesabcFigure 2: Density-dependent colony spreading. The experiments are divided in three groups to study the effect of the initial cell number N0. (a-b) "Snapshots" of the colonies for two different groups N0 = 35 ± 12 (blue, left, 208 cells in total) and 246 ± 66 (red, right, 1229 cells in total), at t = 0 and t = 150 min. The positions of all cells in each group of experiments are represented as coloured points. The dashed circle denotes the edge of the stencil. (c-d) Normalised density profiles for each group at t = 0 min (c) and t = 150 min (d). (e) Gyration radius Rg =phr2i of the colonies as a function of time. (f) Radial velocity hvri as a function of time averaged over the colony (same colour code for every panel). The error bars are the standard deviation (n = 6, 8, 5 experiments respectively for N0 = 35 ± 12, N0 = 97 ± 25, N0 = 246 ± 66). sistence of the trajectories with good time and space accuracy. This quantity, for a given in- terrogation time ∆t, ranges from 0 for a mo- tion with persistence time much smaller than ∆t to 1 for ballistic motion. From the spatio- temporal evolution of the CME measured with ∆t = 5 min, it is clear that the persistence in- creases with density (Fig. 3c). This is especially pronounced at short times and near the periph- ery of the colony, where the radial velocity map also exhibits high values (Fig. 3d). Finally, another quantitative characterisation is provided by the velocity direction autocorrela- tion function C(t0 − t) = hu(t0)· u(t)i, where u is the direction of motion of a cell. The simplest models of persistent motion (Ornstein- Uhlenbeck, active Brownian particle or run-and- tumble motion) all lead to an autocorrelation function which decays exponentially over the persistence time. In contrast, our data is better described by a sum of two exponentials (Fig. 3e): (1) This form could equally arise because of two dis- tinct populations of cells with different persis- C(t) = c e−γt + c0 e−γ0t. tence time or because of a bimodal motion of individual cells41,44,42. However, the first possi- bility can be ruled out since the relative weights c and c0 are not constant in time. Thus, all experimental clues point to the fact that each cell is able to increase its persis- tence upon collision. For modeling simplicity, although we cannot rule out completely a con- tinuous change, we consider cells that switch be- tween two modes of motion, a mode 1 whith per- −1 and average duration τ1, sistence time is Dr1 and a mode 2 with Dr2 < Dr1 and τ2. We used this model to fit all experimental data, as ex- plained in the Supplementary Information, as- suming for simplicity that the mode of higher persistence is ballistic (Dr2 = 0). Fig. 3e shows representative examples for this fitting proce- dure. As an output, we obtain the estimates −1 =2 min and τ2 =10 min (see Supple- Dr1 mentary Figure 5), and the fraction φ2(t) = τ2/ (τ1 + τ2) of cells in mode 2 (Fig. 3f). Like the radial velocity, φ2(t) reaches a maximum at around 100 min, and exhibits an overall increase with density, showing that higher densities pro- 4 Figure 3: Local interactions between cells lead to an increase in cell persistence. (a -- d) Comparison of trajectory properties at low (hN0i = 35, top row) and high (hN0i = 246, bottom row) initial densities. (a) Typical cell trajectory (plotted over 100 min), with "Start" denoting the initial cell position, the white circle representing the border of the initial pattern and the arrows pointing to collision events; (b) 64 examples of trajectories from t = 100 min to t = 130 min, picked randomly over all cell trajectories; (c) spatio temporal dynamics of the CME with ∆t = 5 min and (d) of the radial velocity vr (the dashed lines represent the border of the initial colonies). (e) Velocity direction autocorrelation function at t = 67 − 133 min for various hN0i (symbols, same colour code for panels e and f) and fits using the expression detailed in Supplementary Information (solid lines) with D−1 r1 = 2 min and τ2 = 10 min. The thick black line represents the best single-exponential ('Single exp') fit for hN0i = 246, which misses the experimental behaviour at both very short and long times. (f) Proportion φ2 of cells in mode 2 as extracted from the fit of the correlation functions (the lines are guides for the eye). The error bars represent the 95% confidence interval for the fit parameter. (g -- h) Normalised speed (g) and CME computed with ∆t = 5 min (h) for cells undergoing a single collision at t = tcol within a 30 min interval. v (resp. CME), denote the basal speed (resp. CME) before collision. The error bars show the SEM for the n = 464 pieces of trajectory from 232 collisions. mote switching to the persistent mode. Because this enhancement of persistence is not chemically mediated (see Supplementary Figs. 1 and 2) and depends strongly on the density (Figs. 2 and 3), we conclude that contacts -- understood here as collisions or short-range in- teractions -- are the primary cause for the phe- nomenon. Paralleling the CIL acronym, here- after we refer to this effect as CEL, or contact enhancement of locomotion. To confirm more 5 aCbhN0i = 35hN0i = 246bdd6004002000r (µm)012vr (µm.min-1)0200400t (min)6004002000r (µm)cc00.51CME (5 min)0200400t (min)01020t (min)0.10.20.30.4C(t)ehN0i = 35hN0i = 97hN0i = 246Single exp0200400t (min)00.10.20.30.4φ2f-10010t-tcol (min)11.1CME/CMEh11.21.4v/vgdirectly the existence of this phenomenon, we look at the statistics of cell-cell contacts. As de- scribed in the Supplementary Information, we retain only "clean" contacts (between cells un- dergoing no other collision for 15 min before and after). We compare the speed and CME of each single cell before and after collision and then average over all available data (see Fig. 3g -- h, and Suplementary Figures 10 -- 12). Both com- puted quantitites exhibit a significant transient increase, demonstrating that CEL is indeed re- sponsible for the density-dependent spreading rate of the colonies. Note that the analysis of the angular scattering (see Supplementary Fig- ures 8-9) show that the cell-cell contacts have no aligning effect likely to promote collective mo- tion and to increase the spreading rate by itself. Comparison with minimal active particle models To support our experimental findings, we now investigate several minimal active particle mod- els. Discarding other types of contact interac- tions, we show that a collision-induced increase in persistence is necessary and sufficient to ac- count for the salient features of the short-time dynamics of the colony spreading. Let us consider self-propelled hard disks mov- ing at a constant velocity v. In addition, the direction of motion θ of a particle is subject to rotational diffusion with coefficient Dr. The mo- tion of the ith particle is thus governed by the following equations fij(ri − rj) (2) ∂tri = vu(θi) +X ∂tθi =p2Drηi(t), j6=i (3) where u(θi) = (cos θi, sin θi) and ηi is a delta- correlated Gaussian white noise with zero mean and unit variance. fij is the steric repelling force exerted by particle j on particle i (see Methods for more details). As such, Eqs. (2-3) describe the active Brownian particle (ABP) model, well- studied as a minimal model of phase-separating active particles30,38, and a suitable basis for the modelling of the persistent random motion of cells. Consistently with the experiments, we take v = 5 µm.min−1 and initially place the par- ticles in a disk of 320 µm in diameter. The re- sulting average radial velocity and radius of gy- ration measured in the simulations are shown as a function of time in Fig. 4. Indeed, First, we checked whether this simple interac- tion rule could yield a density-dependent spread- ing. if we think of moving cells as hard-core spheres undergoing a persistent ran- dom walk, the excluded-volume (EV) between the cells gives rise to an outward pressure38. This effect is also present for Brownian hard spheres, for which it can be taken into account by an effective diffusion coefficient increasing with concentration39. However, in the present experiments where cells are relatively sparse -- with packing fractions up to 0.3 -- this pressure is not expected to play an important role and in- deed, simulations of Eqs. (2)-(3) with only hard- core repulsion exhibit no effect of density (Fig. 4, left). a contact: ΓP We then further implemented the effect of CIL that is, upon collision, cells actively reorient away from the contact. To that end, we added an angular repulsion to the equations of motion, in the form of a torque acting on cells undergoing j6=i H(krj − rik − σr) sin(θi − βij) in equation (3), where βij = arg(rj − ri), H is the Heaviside step function implementing the fi- nite radius of interaction and σr is the contact distance (see Methods). Qualitatively, one can imagine that by reorienting the direction of mo- tion of particles toward free space, active reori- entation could explain the experimental data15. However, even with a large value Γ = 100 min−1 corresponding to quasi-instantaneous reorienta- tion, the density-dependent increase in average radial velocity and spreading rate is an order of magnitude smaller than in the experiment (Fig. 4, centre). In addition, the (very limited) peak in radial velocity appears at a very early time, at odds with the experimental observation. In both situations, the rotational diffusion was set to D−1 r = 5 min to match the average per- sistence time of experimental trajectories. Finally, guided by the experimental observa- tions, we tested a minimal model of CEL: After each contact, two particles involved in a collision enter a mode of high persistence (Fig. 4, right). For simplicity, the speed is kept constant and the motion is taken to be ballistic in this high per- sistence (mode 2) state. The particles then relax to the basal (mode 1) state at a rate λ2 = τ−1 2 . We fix D−1 r1 = 2 min and τ2 = 10 min, as deter- mined from the fit of the experimental data (see 6 Figure 4: Spreading colonies in a particle-based model mimicking the experiments. Radial velocity hvri (dashed lines, left axes) and colony radius Rg (solid lines, right axes) in simulated colonies with different numbers of particles N0 in the three models considered. The cartoons on the top row illustrate the different contact rules: Excluded-volume only (EV, left), excluded-volume and angular repulsion (EV + CIL, center), excluded-volume and contact enhancement of locomotion (EV + CEL, right). Fig. 3). The proportion φ2 of cells in the persis- tent mode (shown in Supplementary Figure 6a) evolves with time in a density-dependent man- ner due to changes in the collision frequency. We find that this model captures well the collec- tive spreading of the colony. Indeed, as shown in Fig. 4, the amplitude and density-dependence of the peak in radial velocity, as well as the faster increase of Rg at higher density, are well captured. Overall, given the simplicity of the model, the agreement between simulations and experiments appears surprisingly good (see Sup- plementary Movies 2 -- 5 for a visual comparison). Discussion We studied the dynamics of spreading colonies of D.d. cells. Using a micro-fabrication technique, we were able to produce initial colonies with con- trolled shape and number of cells. We showed that the long-time dynamics of the spreading is controlled by cell divisions and long-range in- teractions through a quorum-sensing factor. On the contrary, these two effects are absent from the short-time dynamics, thus allowing us to study the effect of cell-cell contacts. We found that cell contacts enhance the spreading of the colony by increasing the speed and the persis- tence time of the cells motion. This contact en- hancement of locomotion is further supported by a simple active particle model reproducing the main characteristics of the experimental data. The phenomenon of "CEL" that we have de- scribed here seems a priori different from CIL, which acts to change the direction of motion of colliding cells. However, they are not mu- tually exclusive (see Supplementary Figure 12) and could even share a common microscopic ori- gin.Indeed, the current explanation for CIL is that the protrusions driving the motion are in- hibited in the contact region15,45. Other protru- sions can thus develop elsewhere on the cell's periphery, leading to a new direction of mo- tion. We could hypothesize that, similarly, ei- ther the inhibition of ruffling in the contact re- gion or the stabilisation of the new protrusions reinforces the new polarity thereby increasing the speed and persistence of the motion. An important difference between the two effects is that CEL involves memory while CIL is usu- ally modeled as an "instantaneous" contact pro- cess46,47,48,49. The two could have different rel- ative importances depending on the situation. For example, in dense cell clusters, the reorien- tation induced by CIL forces the particles on the 7 0200400100200300400t (min)Rg (µm)020040000.511.5t (min)〈vr〉 (µm.min−1) 0200400t (min) EVEV+CILEV+CELN0 = 20N0 = 50N0 = 100N0 = 200N0 = 300edge to move outward4,47 whereas, as we saw, in sparser colonies the increase in persistence is the dominating effect. The importance of contact interactions in vivo is not completely understood. CIL has been found to play an important role in neural crest migra- tion4 and the loss of heterotypic CIL (between different cell types) is thought to be crucial in the invasion of healthy tissues by cancer cells3,50. Similarly, CEL could be an advantage in invad- ing the surrounding environment efficiently, in the case of a less cohesive group of cells. Such a situation can be encountered during the escape of highly metastatic and invasive cancer cells, as well as in cell morphogenesis and microbial dis- persal. More generally, it should be noticed that CEL is reminiscent of escape mechanisms, found in various organisms, which involve a temporary change of the motile behaviour and can lead to surprising collective effects51. Finally, the new type of interaction uncovered here opens questions for active matter. Indeed, it exemplifies the wide range of possible interac- tions between active particles, compared to the usual "physicist's particles", which can lead to a rich phenomenology. It opens the door to fur- ther studies of interactions that act on an ad- ditional internal degree of freedom, which could exhibit other interesting effects. METHODS coated on the mould for 1 min at 750 rpm to a target thickness of 70 µm. The squares were cut and peeled off. Usually a thin PDMS membrane obstructed the hole. It was then removed with a surgical blade un- der the microscope at low magnification. The square stencil was stuck on the ground of a 3.5 cm wide culture dish and a homemade small plas- tic well was stuck on it using silicon seal. A droplet of medium was deposited into the well and the sam- ple was placed under vacuum for 15 min to help the medium enter the central hole of the stencil and wet the dish's surface. The cell suspension was added in the well and the sample was placed in the incubator for 45 min to let the cells sediment and adhere. Then, the plastic well and the stencil were removed with surgical tweez- ers. Last, the spreading colony was imaged using a slightly defocused bright-field microscope (TE2000, Nikkon) at 10X magnification and a wide-field An- dor Zyla sCMOS camera. A time-lapse movie was recorded for up to 48 h using MicroManager software with a 20 s time-interval, while the temperature was kept constant at 22.5◦C. For perfusion experiments, we designed a macroflu- idic chamber by sealing the culture dish with an adapted cover containing an input and an output tube. The former was linked to a 1 L supply bottle of fresh HL5 medium under controlled overpressure (OB1 controller, Elveflow) while the latter was linked to a disposal bottle. All the system was closed ster- ilely. We used a flow rate of 100 mL/h so that the chamber volume of about 10 mL was completely re- newed every 6 minutes. We were thus able to main- tain a stable medium renewal over 9 hours. Cell culture Image processing We used Dictyostelium discoideum cells from the strain AX2. The cells were cultured on cell- culture-treated Petri dishes (BD Falcon) in HL5 medium with glucose (Formedium) and kept in a temperature-controlled incubator at 22.5◦C, with a doubling time β−1 ∼ 9 h. Before every experiment, the cells were detached from the dish, centrifuged 5 min at 663g, harvested and resuspended at the seeding density. Sample preparation A reusable mould on Si wafer comprising an array of squares with circular pillars of height ∼ 150 µm and diameter 320 µm in the centre was fabricated in SU8 photoresist using classical soft lithography tech- niques and its surface was silanized to make it non- adherent. PolyDiMethylSulfoxyde (PDMS, Corning) mixed with curing agent at a 1:10 mass ratio was spin based minimization ImageJ macros trajectories were on the Then the The cells' positions were retrieved using home- 'Find made Maxima' built-in function. indi- reconstructed with a vidual squared-displacement algorithm (http://site.physics.georgetown.edu/matlab/) and the data analysed using homemade Matlab programs. In particular, the CME was defined as: 2 ) − r(t − δt 2 )k kv(t0)kdt0 CMEδt(t) = kr(t + δt R t+ δt 2 t0=t− δt 2 (4) Simulations Simulations were carried out by integrating the Langevin equations Eqs. (2-3) using a Euler integra- tion scheme with time steps ∆t = 10−3 min. The 8 hard-core repulsion between particles is modelled by a Weeks-Chandler-Andersen potential V (r) = (cid:1)6i + 1 if r < 21/6σ and 0 otherwise, (cid:1)12 −(cid:0) σ 4h(cid:0) σ r r where σ = 10 µm is the particle diameter. We define two particles as being in contact when their relative distance r < σr = 21/6σ. In the simulations with CIL, the torque term is turned on only during the contacts, when r < σr. In the simulation including CEL, a contact triggers a ballistic run which lasts for an exponentially distributed time with rate λ2. References [1] Travis, J. Mysteries of the cell: Cell biol- ogy's open cases. Science 334, 1051 (2011). [2] Friedl, P. & Gilmour, D. Collective cell mi- gration in morphogenesis, regeneration and cancer. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 10, 445 -- 457 (2009). [3] Friedl, P. & Wolf, K. Tumour-cell invasion and migration: diversity and escape mech- anisms. Nature Reviews Cancer 3, 362-374 (2003). [4] Carmona-Fontaine, C. et al. Contact inhi- bition of locomotion in vivo controls neu- ral crest directional migration. Nature 456, 7224 (2008). [5] Selmeczi, D. et al. Cell motility as random motion: A review. European Physical Jour- nal: Special Topics 157, 1 -- 15 (2008). [6] Li, L., Norrelkke, S.F. & Cox, E.C. Per- sistent cell motion in the absence of exter- nal signals: A search strategy for eukaryotic cells. PLoS ONE, 3, 5 (2008). [7] Kolmogorov, A., Petrovskii, I. & Piscounov, N. A study of the diffusion equation with increase in the amount of substance, and its application to a biological problem. Math. Mech. 1, 1-âĂŞ25 (1937). [8] Simpson, M.J. et al. Quantifying the roles of cell motility and cell proliferation in a circular barrier assay. Journal of the Royal Society, Interface / the Royal Society 10, 20130007 (2013). [9] Sengers, B.G., Please C.P. & Oreffo R.O.C. Experimental characterization and compu- tational modelling of two-dimensional cell spreading for skeletal regeneration. Journal 9 of the Royal Society, Interface / the Royal Society, 4, 1107 -- 1117 (2007). [10] Marel, A.K. et al. Flow and Diffusion in Channel-Guided Cell Migration. Biophys. J., 107, 1054 -- 1064 (2014). [11] Gol´e, L., Rivi`ere, C., Hayakawa, Y. & Rieu, J.P. A quorum-sensing factor in vegetative Dictyostelium Discoideum cells revealed by quantitative migration analysis. PLoS ONE 6, 1 -- 9 (2011). [12] Phillips, J. & Gomer, R. A secreted pro- tein is an endogenous chemorepellant in Dictyostelium discoideum. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 109, 10990 -- 10995 (2012). [13] Angelini, T.E., Hannezo, E., Trepat, X., Fredberg, J.J. & Weitz, D.A. Cell migration driven by cooperative substrate deforma- tion patterns. Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 168104 (2010). [14] Abercrombie, M. & Heaysman, J.E. Ob- servations on the social behaviour of cells in tissue culture: I. Speed of movement of chick heart fibroblasts in relation to their mutual contacts. Experimental cell research 5, 111 -- 131 (1953). [15] Mayor, R. & Carmona-Fontaine, C. Keep- ing in touch with contact inhibition of loco- motion. Trends in cell biology 20, 319 -- 328 (2010). [16] Dyson, L. & Baker, R.E. The importance of volume exclusion in modelling cellular mi- gration. J. Math. Biol. 71, 679 -- 711 (2014). [17] Serra-Picamal, X. et al. Mechanical waves during tissue expansion. Nat. Phys. 8, 628 -- 634 (2012). [18] Nnetu, K.D., Knorr, M., Strehe, D., Zink, M. & Kas, J.A. Directed persistent mo- tion maintains sheet integrity during multi- cellular spreading and migration. Soft Mat- ter 8, 6913 (2012). [19] Yates, C.A., Parker, A. & Baker, R.E. Incorporating pushing in exclusion-process models of cell migration. Phys. Rev. E 91, 052711 (2015). [20] Sep´ulveda, N. et al. Collective cell motion in an epithelial sheet can be quantitatively described by a stochastic interacting parti- cle model. PLoS Comput. Biol. 9, e1002944 (2013). [32] Friedl, P. & Wolf, K. Plasticity of cell mi- gration: a multiscale tuning model. J. Cell Biol. 188, 11 -- 9 (2010). [21] Petitjean, L. et al. Velocity fields in a col- lectively migrating epithelium. Biophysical J. 98, 1790 -- 1800 (2010). [33] Levine, H. Learning Physics of Living Sys- tems from Dictyostelium. Phys. Biol. 11, 053011 (2014). [22] Tambe, D.T. et al. Collective cell guid- ance by cooperative intercellular forces. Nat. Mat. 10 469 -- 475 (2011). [23] Coburn, L., Cerone, L., Torney, C., Couzin, I.D. & Neufeld, Z. Interactions lead to co- herent motion and enhanced chemotaxis of migrating Cells. Phys. Biol. 10, 046002 (2013). [24] Duclos, G., Garcia, S., Yevick, H.G. & Sil- berzan, P. Perfect nematic order in con- fined monolayers of spindle-shaped cells. Soft Matter 10, 2346 (2014). [25] Londono C. et al. Nonautonomous contact guidance signaling during collective cell mi- gration. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 111 1807 -- 1812 (2014). [26] Angelini, T.E. et al. Glass-like dynamics of collective cell migration. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 108, 4714 -- 4719 (2011). [27] Park, J.-A. et al. Unjamming and cell shape in the asthmatic airway epithelium. Nat. Mat. 14, 1040 -- 1049 (2015). [28] Garcia, S. et al. Physics of active jam- ming during collective cellular motion in a monolayer. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 112, 15314 -- 15319 (2015). [29] Vedel, S., Tay, S., Johnston, D.M., Bruus, H. & Quake, S.R. Migration of Cells in a Social Context. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 110, 129-134 (2013). [30] Fily, Y. & Marchetti, M.C. Athermal Phase Separation of Self-Propelled Parti- cles with No Alignment. Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 235702 (2012). [31] Friedl, P., Borgmann, S. & Brocker, E. B. Amoeboid leukocyte crawling through ex- tracellular matrix: lessons from the Dic- tyostelium paradigm of cell movement. Journal of Leukocyte Biology 70, 491-509 (2001). [34] Coates, J. C. & Harwood, A. J. Cell-cell ad- hesion and signal transduction during Dic- tyostelium development. J. Cell Sci. 114, 4349-4358 (2001). [35] Poujade, M. et al. Collective migration of an epithelial monolayer in response to a model wound. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 104, 15988 -- 15993 (2007). [36] Cates, M.E. & Tailleur, J. When are active Brownian particles and run-and- tumble particles equivalent? Consequences for Motility-induced Phase Separation. Eu- rophys. Lett. 101, 20010 (2013). [37] Bosgraaf, L. & Van Haastert, P.J.M. The ordered extension of pseudopodia by amoe- boid Cells in the absence of external cues. PLoS ONE 4, 4 (2009). [38] Solon, A.P. et al. Pressure and phase equilibria in interacting active Brownian spheres. Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 198301 (2015). [39] Bruna, M. & Chapman, S.J. Excluded- volume effects in the diffusion of hard spheres. Physical Review E 85, 011103 (2012). [40] Peruani, F. & Morelli, L.G. Self-propelled particles with fluctuating speed and direc- tion of motion in two dimensions. Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 010602 (2007). [41] Potdar, A.A., Jeon, J., Weaver, A.M., Quaranta, V. & Cummings, P.T. Hu- man mammary epithelial cells exhibit a bimodal correlated random walk pattern. PLoS ONE 5, e9636 (2010). [42] Metzner, C. et al. Superstatistical analy- sis and modelling of heterogeneous random walks. Nat. Commun. 6, 7516 (2015). [43] Selmeczi, D. et al. Cell motility as persis- tent random motion: theories from experi- ments. Biophys. J. 89, 912 -- 931 (2005). 10 AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS J.d.A., J.P.R. and C.R. designed experiments; J.d.A. performed experiments and analysed experimental data; J.d.A. and A.S. conceived the particle-based models; A.S. performed simulations and analysed simulation data; C.A. contributed to design of ex- periments in Supplementary Figure 1 and provided AprA− cells; F.D. computed the analytical results on bimodal trajectories and helped with the fitting procedure; Y.H. assisted in the data analysis and in- terpretation; J.d.A. and A.S. wrote the manuscript; F.D., J.P.R. and C.R. made substantial contribu- tion to the manuscript; all authors discussed and interpreted the data, read and commented on the manuscript; J.P.R. and C.R. supervised the project. [44] Maiuri, P. et al. Actin Flows Mediate a Universal Coupling between Cell Speed and Cell Persistence. Cell 161, 374 -- 386 (2015). [45] Stramer, B.A. & Mayor, R. Mechanisms and in vivo functions of contact inhibition of locomotion. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell. Biol. 118 (2016). [46] Davis, J.R., et al. Emergence of embry- onic pattern through contact inhibition of locomotion. Development 139, 4555-4560 (2012) [47] Zimmermann, J., Camley, B.A., Rappel, W.-J. & Levine, H. Contact inhibition of locomotion determines cell-cell and cell- substrate forces in tissues. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 113, 2660-2665 (2016). [48] Camley, B.A., Zimmermann, J., Levine, H. & Rappell, W.-J. Emergent collec- tive chemotaxis without single-cell gradi- ent sensing. Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 098101 (2016). [49] Szabo, A., et al. In vivo confinement pro- motes collective migration of neural crest cells. J. Cell. Biol. 213, 543 -- 555 (2016). [50] Abercrombie, M. Contact inhibition and malignancy. Nature 281, 259 -- 262 (1979). [51] Ramdya, P. et al. Mechanosensory in- in teractions drive collective behaviour Drosophila. Nature 519, 233 -- 236 (2015). [52] Heid, P. J. et al. The role of myosin heavy chain phosphorylation in Dictyostelium motility, chemotaxis and F-actin localiza- tion. J. Cell Sci. 117, 4819 -- 4835 (2004). ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors are grateful to R. Fulcrand for his help in micro-fabrication, to V. Hakim for stimulating dis- cussions and to C. Cottin-Bizonne for her comments on the manuscript. J.d.A. has been partially sup- ported by the Fondation ARC pour la Recherche sur le Cancer and by the Programme d'Avenir Lyon- Saint ´Etienne. A.S. acknowledges funding through a PLS fellowship of the Gordon and Betty Moor foun- dation. J.d.A., C.R. and J.P.R. belong to the CNRS consortium CellTiss and to the LIA ELyTLab. 11 Supplementary information 1 An effect of local interactions Supplementary Figure 1: The cells' outward motion is not due to a large-scale chemical communi- cation. Colony-averaged speed (top row) and radial velocity (bottom row) in various conditions. (a) Medium exchange. Control (blue) and samples with continuous medium exchange (red). The speed is main- tained constant until the exchange is stopped (vertical dashed line), whereas the radial motion hvri is robust to medium exchange. (b) aprA− cells still exhibit outward motion, although they do not secrete AprA, the only known endogenous chemorepellent in Dictyostelium discoideum (c) Cells in highly conditioned medium (HCM), prepared by letting cells in culture in it before filtering, so that all secreted molecules are already at a high concentration. The cell motion is affected but there is still a density-dependent peak in hvri(t). We checked that long-distance interactions were not responsible for the enhancement of the colony spreading rate. To that end, we measured the average speed hvi and radial velocity hvri during the spreading of cell colonies in three different control conditions, as described below. We looked especially at the presence of the peak in hvri(t), which, in our experiments, is the macroscopic signature of the collective enhancement of the spreading. Firstly, we designed a fluidic system that allowed to continuously change the sample's medium, so that any secreted (or depleted) molecule was rinsed out (or rescued), hence preventing any large-scale chemical sensing such as chemorepulsion or quorum-sensing. It efficiently suppressed the overall regulation of cell motility through a known quorum-sensing factor (QSF)11 (Supplementary Figure 1a, top), but did not affect the outward motion (Supplementary Figure 1a, bottom) which shows that the collective effect is still present. Secondly, we used aprA− cells which do not produce the protein AprA, so far the only endogenous chemorepellent molecule known for Dictyostelium discoideum 12. Although the motility of these cells is slightly different from the wild-type cells, resulting in slightly modified colony dynamics, the main effect of outward motion was still observed (Supplementary Figure 1b). Last, experiments were done in highly conditioned medium (HCM). This medium is prepared by letting cells in culture in fresh HL5 medium for typically 2 days, so that it is supplemented with molecules secreted by the cells, at high concentration. Thus, one would expect the concentrations in slowly degraded molecules to be above the saturation of their detection by the cells, hence screening any additional secretion 12 020040060080034567t (min)〈v〉 (µm.min−1)A a. Medium change020040060080000.511.52t (min)〈vr〉 (µm.min−1)02004000246t (min)〈v〉 (µm.min−1) b. AprA− cells020040000.20.40.60.8t (min)〈vr〉 (µm.min−1)0200400012345t (min)〈v〉 (µm.min−1) c. Highly conditionedmedium 020040000.20.40.6t (min)〈vr〉 (µm.min−1) 〈N0〉=35〈N0〉=74〈N0〉=292during the experiment. Although the dynamics is again modified mainly due to the presence of QSF at high concentration in HCM11, the collective effect of outward motion is still apparent in this situation (Supplementary Figure 1c). We also tested the hypothesis of cell-cell communication through the deposition of chemicals on the surface as follows. First, the sample dishes were treated by letting cells adhere on their entire surface at high density for 45 min. Then the cell layer was washed out and fresh cells were added at a low, homogeneous density with fresh medium for imaging and the single cells were tracked after 45 min adhesion. The controls include prior incubation with FM or HCM but no cell layer. If cell-cell communication through deposited trails on the surface affects the motility, there should be measurable differences between those conditions. Conversely, since the system is homogeneous and isotropic and the cells undergo almost no cell-cell contact, no effect of geometry or interaction is expected to interfere with those prior treatments. Yet, the probability density functions (PDFs) of speed and CME in the three conditions are well overlaid, showing no effect of a putative chemical deposition mechanism. Those PDFs compare very well with those measured in the low density colonies, while they differ from the high density colonies, especially around the peak of hvri(t) at t = 1 -- 2 h (Supp. Fig. 2). Supplementary Figure 2: Modifications of the surface by the cells do not affect cell motility. Distribution of speed (left) and CME with ∆t = 5 min (right) computed from trajectories with δt = 1 min, gathered for all times t = 0 − 1 h (top) and t = 1 − 2 h (bottom) with various surface treatments (solid lines) or in spreading colonies (dashed lines). Cells ⇒ FM: cells were seeded at high density, let adhere for 45 min and washed out before adding fresh cells in fresh medium (FM) for imaging. FM ⇒ FM: the sample dish was filled with FM for 45 min before cells and FM were added for imaging. HCM ⇒ FM: the sample dish was filled with HCM for 45 min before cells and FM were added for imaging. Taken together, these results show that a large-scale communication using secreted or deposited molecules is very unlikely to be at the origin of the density-dependent spreading at short times. In consequence, the interactions behind this effect must be local, whether mediated by actual cell- cell contacts or by rapidly degraded, locally accumulated chemicals. Although the latter is not inconceivable, it is less likely at stake and can be described as an "effective contact" interaction. 13 00.10.20.3PDF (A.U.)hN0i=35hN0i=24600.10.20.3PDF (A.U.)t=0 -- 1hCells => FMFM => FMHCM => FM0510152025hvi (µm.min-1)00.10.20.30.4PDF (A.U.)t=1 -- 2h00.51CME00.10.20.30.4PDF (A.U.)2 Increase in single cell persistence Supplementary Figure 3: Cells tend to be more elongated at high density. Time evolution of the average eccentricity of the cell shapes' obtained by fitting ellipses for different initial densities hN0i. The error bars are the standard deviations of the e distributions. q In Dictyostelium discoideum, the more persistent cells are also the more elongated ones, while the ones that exhibit rounded shapes usually move in a more random fashion11,52. A way to measure the elongation of cells is to fit their shape with ellipses and compute the eccentricity e = a, where a and b are respectively the long and short axes of the ellipse. The eccentricity varies between 0 for a circle and 1 for an infinitely elongated ellipse. For instance, e = 0.5 corresponds to a/b = 1.33, e = 0.7 to a/b = 1.96 and e = 0.9 to a/b = 5.26. We measured the colony average of e as a function of time for different cell densities (Supplementary Figure 3). At early times, hei goes up with cell density. It then relaxes to hei ≈ 0.55 for all hN0i. Although this elongation seems to be partly defined prior to the release of the stencil (see hei at t = 0), a peak still appears in the densest condition, concomitantly with the peaks in hvri and φ2. As for the persistence of cell trajectories, it increases transiently with no detectable pre-set depen- dence on density. To illustrate this fact, we show randomly sampled trajectories -- all of the same 30 min duration -- taken from experiments with low (hN0i = 35) or high (hN0i = 246) cell densities at different times (Supplementary Figure 4). At early times, most trajectories show a low persis- tence for both densities. This changes in the high density case where trajectories appear "unfolded" around t = 100 min, demonstrating the existence of runs with persistence time comparable to the 30 min path duration. At later times, the motion becomes again less persistent. 1 − b 14 Supplementary Figure 4: Increase in single cell persistence. Example of single cell trajectories from the lowest (hN0i = 35) or highest (hN0i = 246) cell density experiments, at times t = 0− 30 min, t = 100− 130 min, t = 200− 230 min, t = 300− 330 min. The persistence is seen to increase transiently around t = 100 min in the high density case, while at low density it does not change markedly in time. Grid spacing: 200 µm. 15 Time0 - 30 min100 - 130 min200 - 230 min300 - 330 minhN0i = 35hN0i = 2463 Bimodal persistent motion We found two modes in the decay of the velocity direction auto-correlation function (VDACF). As mentioned, either those two modes arise from two separate populations of cells, each having a single correlation time, or every single cell exhibit both modes. The first hypothesis is ruled out since it does not allow changes in the weights of the modes. In the second hypothesis, the motion of each cell follows a process with two characteristic times: this is the case of bimodal motion41,44,42, but other models have this same property43. Here we focus on the first option because it offers the simplest interpretation of a change in the weights c and c0 in Equation (1). In the model proposed by Selmeczi et al.43, it would mainly involve tuning their α parameter, which is the strength of a memory in a modified O.U. process: the underlying principle -- regulation of the relative importance of two time-scales -- is the same, but the formulation involves a higher degree of complexity which seems unnecessary here. Model. We first characterise analytically a simple model of bimodal persistent motion. Assume a particle moves in the plane with velocity of constant magnitude v0. Its orientation is subject to rotational diffusion, but with a coefficient that alternates between two values Dr1 and Dr2. The times spent in mode 1 and 2 are both exponentially distributed, with mean τ1 = λ−1 1 and τ2 = λ−1 2 respectivelya. What are the properties of such a random motion? The essential quantity is the velocity direction autocorrelation function C(t0 − t) = hu(t0)· u(t)i = hcos(cid:2)θ(t0) − θ(t)(cid:3)i, (5) where u = (cos θ, sin θ) is the direction of motion. Let's introduce the probability densities pi=1,2(θ, t) to be in mode i with orientation θ at time t, they are governed by p1(θ, 0) = φ1δ(θ), p2(θ, 0) = φ2δ(θ), (6a) (6b) where φ1 = λ2/(λ1 + λ2) (resp. φ2 = λ1/(λ1 + λ2)) is the fraction of time spent in mode 1 (resp. mode 2), and we have taken for initial orientation θ = 0. Now, introducing p(θ, t) = p1(θ, t)+p2(θ, t), C(t) can be expressed as ∂tp1 = Dr1 ∂2 ∂tp2 = Dr2 ∂2 θθp1 + λ2p2 − λ1p1, θθp2 − λ2p2 + λ1p1, Z π −π C(t) = dθ p(θ, t) cos θ. (7) The system (6) can be solved using Laplace transforms for time and Fourier series for orientation, yielding C(s) = (λ1 + λ2)2 + λ1(s + Dr1) + λ2(s + Dr2) (λ1 + λ2) [(s + Dr1)(s + Dr2) + λ1(s + Dr2) + λ2(s + Dr1)] , where variable s is the Laplace variable. Going back to time domain, this expression translates into the sum of two exponentials with the notations C(t) = c e−γt + c0 e−γ0t, κ2 = (Dr1 + Dr2 + λ1 + λ2)2 − 4(Dr1Dr2 + Dr1λ2 + Dr2λ1), κ02 = (Dr1 − Dr2 + λ1 − λ2)2 + 4λ1λ2, γ = (κ + Dr1 + Dr2 + λ1 + λ2)/2, γ0 = γ − κ, c = 1 − c0 = −(Dr1 − Dr2) (λ1 − λ2) + (λ1 + λ2) (λ1 + λ2 − κ0) . 2κ (λ1 + λ2) (8) (9a) (9b) (9c) (9d) (9e) aThe value of Dr is thus a Telegraph process. 16 It can be shown that the following inequalities hold c, c0 (cid:62) 0, Dr2 (cid:54) γ0 (cid:54) Dr1 < γ, (10) showing that both terms are always decaying, and that the slowest relaxation is intermediate between Dr1 and Dr2. In the limit Dr1 → ∞, i.e. when all directional persistence is lost in mode 1, all expressions greatly simplify γ = Dr1, γ0 = Dr2 + λ2, c0 = λ1 λ1 + λ2 , (11) where only the first term in the expansion has been retained. In this case, C(t) exhibits a rapid drop with characteristic time ∼ Dr1 −1, followed by a slowest decay whose constant γ0 = Dr2 + λ2 is independent of Dr1 and whose prefactor c0 is the fraction of time spent in mode 2. On further assuming that mode 2 involves ballistic motion (Dr2 = 0), then γ0 = λ2, giving access to the mean duration of mode 2. In this particular case, the relationship between the biexponential form of correlation function and the model parameters is simple. This is not so, however, in the general case, and accordingly we have resorted to a fitting procedure. Fitting procedure -- experimental data. We use the expressions above (8 & 9) to fit all experimental correlation functions. Since mode 2 is assumed ballistic, Dr2 = 0. The parameters Dr1 and τ2, considered as intrinsic properties of the cells, are common to all curves and are thus heavily constrained. The free parameters remaining for each curve are τ1, and an additional constant prefactor that allows C(t = 0) to differ from unity. In practice, we first varied systematically the values of Dr1 and τ2. For each couple, we fitted the complete set of 15 C(t) curves (5 first time-windows for each of the 3 density conditions) with the two mentioned free parameters. We used the value of R2 averaged on these 15 curves to estimate the quality of the fit for a given −1 = 1.7 min and τ2 = 8.6 min couple (Dr1, τ2). This yielded unambiguously the optimal values Dr1 (Supplementary Figure 5). Then we measured τ1 by fitting again all the curves using these optimised fixed parameters. Supplementary Figure 5: Parameter space for the fitting procedure. The average R2 computed from 25 experimental curves of correlation functions exhibits a clear peak −1 = 1.7 min and τ2 = 8.6 min. Here, the time-windows for t (cid:62) 200 min were not considered at Dr1 in order not to overweight the long-term behaviours. Using the complete set of 39 curves slightly moves the peak of R2 but then Dr1 −1 = 2 min and τ2 = 10 min remain excellent estimates. In using the model, we have tacitly assumed that at each time, the population of cells is "equili- brated" between the two modes. This is reasonable since the residence time in each mode (τ1 and 17 τ2 (min)Dr1−1 (min) 12320151050.9650.970.9750.980.9850.99τ2 = 10 min) remains smaller than the time scale over which λ1 (or the density) significantly varies (around 100 min). Supplementary Figure 6: Simulations -- Results of the fitting of the velocity autocorrelation functions applied to simulations with CEL. (b) Prefactor c0 of the longest relaxation in the correlation (a) Proportion of cells in mode 2. function. Theoretical prediction from φ2 ( -- ) and measurement from the correlation functions (o). Fitting - simulations with CEL. We computed the proportion of particles in persistent mode φ2 at all times (direct output from the simulations, Supplementary Figure 6a) and the velocity autocorrelation functions at various times and for all particle numbers N0. From the latter, we could extract the parameters from a fit with expression (8). In particular we compared the obtained c0 values to the theoretical predictions (9e) (Supplementary Figure 6b). They are in close agreement with each other, showing that the hypothesis of equilibration between the two modes through λ1, under the control of collisions, is reasonable. 4 Analysis of pair collisions 4.1 Detection of contacts. Supplementary Figure 7: Radial distribution function, averaged over all the experiments, at various time points. 18 010020030040000.20.40.60.81t (min)φ2 aN0=20N0=50N0=100N0=200N0=300010020030040000.20.40.60.81t (min)c′b01020304050r(µm)00.511.5g(r)t=0.5ht=1ht=1.5ht=2ht=2.5ht=3ht=3.5ht=4hWe study here the effect of cell-cell contacts on the trajectories. To that end, we need to find a way to disentangle this effect from other biases related to the occurence of contacts: For instance, contacts are more likely to happen in dense areas, where the behaviour is known to be different on average from sparser zones. For that reason, and to avoid increasing the number of spurious underlying parameters, we only focused on two-body interactions. A cell-cell contact was defined by two cell positions being closer than a distance dmax. If the cells remain close longer than one time frame, the collision time t0 is defined as the time at which the cell-cell distance is minimal. Moreover, since our measurements cannot be instantaneous -- ie they are based on pieces of trajectories extending over several time frames -- we selected only those collisions involving two cells that did not encounter any other collision for a time tf ree before and after t0, hence reducing drastically the number of exploitable data. Contrary to the simulations, for which the interaction radius is well-defined, the choice of dmax is not trivial in experiments because cell shapes and sizes are distributed. Thus, to fix dmax we first measured the radial distribution function g(r) (Supp. Fig. 7). The profiles, computed at different times, all show a marked peak at r = 10 µm. As a consequence, we chose a slightly larger dmax = 11 µm to detect reliably the contacts between cells. 4.2 Angular deflection Supplementary Figure 8: Sketch of the angle definition. (a) A cell-cell contact is detected in the frame of the picture. (b) The frame is rotated so that the (O1OO2) axis becomes the new x-axis, where Oi is the position of cell i and O is the barycentre of the collision. (c) The incidence (resp. scattering) angle θ1/2(−t) (resp. θ1/2(t)) is measured from the cell's position at −t respective to its position at the time of the contact. (d) The incidence (resp. scattering) angle separation ∆θi (resp. ∆θf) is the difference between the two directions of motion of the cell couple. We studied in details the statistics of incidence and scattering angles, both in simulations and experiments. To that end, we detected the collisions with tf ree = 3 min before and after the collision. 19 As depicted in Fig. 8 the cell coordinates were rotated so that the (O1OO2) axis is the new x-axis, where O1 and O2 are the positions of cell 1 and 2 at collision time, and O is the center of [O1O2]. We then measured the mean angles of motion θi(±t), where i ∈ {1, 2} and t ∈ {1, 2, 3} min, defined as the angle between (OiXi(t)) and (OOi) and computed ∆θi = θ2(−t)−θ1(−t) and ∆θf = θ2(t)−θ1(t), the incidence and scattering angles respectively. Trying to decipher the effect of the collision, we are especially interested in the relative scattering ∆θf as a function of ∆θi. In Fig. 9, we show the heat maps for the probability densities P(∆θf∆θi). Supplementary Figure 9: Angular deflection at collision in simulations and experiments. P(∆θf∆θi) for collisions detected with dmax = 11.2 µm, tf ree = 3 min, at tf /i = ±1 min. Simulations without (CIL -- ) or with (CIL+) repulsive torque and monomodal (D−1 ) or bimodal (CEL+) motion. (b) Experimental data gathered from all experiments. In simulations without CIL, the probability distribution P(∆θf∆θi) is concentrated around the main diagonal ∆θf = ∆θi. It means that the relative direction of motion remains unaffected by the collision, hence that the particles cross "without seeing" each other (in terms of direction of motion). It is consistent with the simulation rule that the interaction only involves a pushing force during the contact, but the intrinsic direction of motion is not modified. (a) r = 10 min, CEL -- The results are completely different in simulations with CIL (introduced in the form of a repulsive torque). Most of the probability concentrates in a zone where ∆θi and ∆θf have opposite signs, a signature of the angular repulsion. In the experimental data, two distinct behaviors seem to be present: There is both a concentration of probability around both diagonals, ∆θf = ∆θi denoting crossing, and ∆θf = −∆θi, a signature of specular reflection. In particular, ∆θf = −∆θi seems more likely for small ∆θi, when the incident trajectories are close to being parallel, while ∆θf = ∆θi is predominant near k∆θik = π. These results support the idea that even in the event of a collision, Dictyostelium discoideum cells reorient smoothly so as to bypass their encounter: at low incidence angle crossing is difficult while almost specular reflection demands only a slight turn, and at higher incidence it is easier to circumvent each other. It is different from the usual view of CIL, according to which colliding cells reorient specifically away along the contact axis. It could be related to the increased probability for D. 20 discoideum cells to form new pseudopods in the protruded area rather than along the cell body37, acting together with a CIL-like inhibition of protrusions in the cell-cell contact zone. In any case, they show that the cell-cell contacts have no aligning effect on the direction of motion, and thus could not generate a coherent motion that would be responsible for the increase of the colony spreading rate 4.3 Contact enhancement of locomotion. Supplementary Figure 10: Increase in cell speed after collisions. (a) Average speed before and after a single collision, using smoothed trajectories with δt = 1 min and tf ree = 3 (black), 10 (green), 15 (blue) and 20 min (red). Mean±SEM for n = 6578, 376, 232 and 153 cell pairs respectively. (b) Average normalised speed v/v, where v is the basal speed of a single cell before and after collisions. Same δt, tf ree and number of contacts as in (a). (c) Logarithm of the p-value obtained from the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test against the null hypothesis that v(t)/v is distributed with the same PDF as v(−tf ree)/v. Values above 1 denote when the null hypothesis can be rejected with more than 95% confidence. Cell speed. Similarly as for the direction of motion, we measured the instantaneous speed of cells undergoing a single collision in a frame with free motion tf ree before and after the collision. We found that on average, the cells exhibit a transient increase of their speed after collisions. Because of positional noise, this effect is not completely clear using the experimental time frame δt = 20 s. Yet it is better seen after smoothing the trajectories over δt = 1 min, and varying tf ree from 3 min to 20 min: tf ree = 20 min provides a view of the long-term dynamics; with shorter tf ree, the complete time-frame is not accessible, but the trend for hvi(t) is confirmed with much more statistics (up to 6578 cell-cell contacts measured with tf ree = 3 min). The cells accelerate for 7− 8 min following collisions, reaching an average speed approximately 20% higher than the "basal" average speed, and then the speed decreases back to its basal value at a similar rate. When the speed of each single cell is normalised by its own basal speed v (i.e. its mean speed prior to the collision), one even gets a 30% increase on average. Although these changes are relatively small compared to the standard deviation of the speed distribution in the cell population, a statistical analysis using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test shows that the distribution differs significantly from the distribution at t = −tf ree only for ∼ 12 min after collisions. Persistence time. Using again smoothed trajectories with δt = 1 min to make the patterns of evolution more apparent, we repeat the analysis on the CME computed for ∆t = 5 min (see Methods). This revealed a CME drop around the contacts, as well as a subsequent transient increase (Supp. Fig. 11a-b). Both effects seemingly arise from significant changes in the distribution of the 21 -20020t−tcol(min)012345hvi(µm.min−1)atfree=3mintfree=10mintfree=15mintfree=20min-20020t−tcol(min)0.811.21.4hv/vib-20020t−tcol(min)0246log(p)/log(0.05)cSupplementary Figure 11: Increase in CME after collisions. (a) Average CME before and after a single collision, using smoothed trajectories with δt = 1 min and tf ree = 10 (green), 15 (blue) and 20 min (red). Mean±SEM for n = 376, 232 and 153 cell pairs respectively. (b) Average normalised CME CME/CME, where v is the basal speed of a single cell, before and after collisions. Same δt, tf ree and number of contacts as in (a). (c) Logarithm of the p-value obtained from the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test against the null hypothesis that CME(t) is distributed with the same PDF as CME(−tf ree). Values above 1 denote when the null hypothesis can be rejected with more than 95% confidence. CME (Supp. Fig. 11c). The depression is probably related to changes in direction during the contact. The increase, between 10 and 15% for single cells on average, shows that the persistence of the motion is enhanced for at least a few minutes after a cell-cell contact. Supplementary Figure 12: Single-cell-normalised CME: comparison of various simulation conditions with experimental data. Mean±SEM, tf ree = 15 min. Sensitivity of CME measurements to the presence of CEL. While in the case of the speed the measurement is direct, the CME is only a proxy to estimate whether the trajectories are more or less persistent on a given time-scale ∆t. As a consequence, we also tested our CME-based analysis of collisions on the simulation data. It makes apparent that a drop in CME around 10% is the signature of CIL (in the sense of turning upon contact), while a transient increase in CME of 10 -- 20% is observed only in the presence of CEL (Supp. Fig. 12). Finally, the experimental curve aligns closely with that of the CIL+/CEL+ simulations (Supp. Fig. 12). Without proving that the cells follow the precise rules implemented in the simulations, it 22 -20020t−tcol(min)0.50.60.70.8CMEtfree=10mintfree=15mintfree=20min-20020t−tcol(min)0.911.11.2CME/CME-20020t−tcol(min)02468log(p)/log(0.05)c-10-50510t-tcol (min)0.850.90.9511.051.11.151.2CME/CMECIL-/CEL-CIL+/CEL-CIL+/CEL+CIL-/CEL+Expeshows that CIL and CEL seem to be necessary to account for the experimental collision data. Supplementary movies Supplementary movie 1 Long-time spreading of a colony with high cell density. Supplementary movie 2 Short-time (200 min) dynamics of a colony with low cell density. N0 = 18. Supplementary movie 3 Short-time (200 min) dynamics of a colony with high cell density. N0 ' 275. Supplementary movie 4 Simulation of active particles at low density undergoing CEL. N0 = 20. Supplementary movie 5 Simulation of active particles at high density undergoing CEL. N0 = 200. 23
1111.2707	1	1111	2011-11-11T11:18:46	Measuring the viscous and elastic properties of single cells using video particle tracking microrheology	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.CB" ]	We present a simple and \emph{non-invasive} experimental procedure to measure the linear viscoelastic properties of cells by passive video particle tracking microrheology. In order to do this, a generalised Langevin equation is adopted to relate the time-dependent thermal fluctuations of a bead, chemically bound to the cell's \emph{exterior}, to the frequency-dependent viscoelastic moduli of the cell. It is shown that these moduli are related to the cell's cytoskeletal structure, which in this work is changed by varying the solution osmolarity from iso- to hypo-osmotic conditions. At high frequencies, the viscoelastic moduli frequency dependence changes from $\propto \omega^{3/4}$ found in iso-osmotic solutions to $\propto \omega^{1/2}$ in hypo--osmotic solutions; the first situation is typical of bending modes in isotropic \textit{in vitro} reconstituted F--actin networks, and the second could indicate that the restructured cytoskeleton behaves as a gel with "\textit{dangling branches}". The insights gained from this form of rheological analysis could prove to be a valuable addition to studies that address cellular physiology and pathology.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Measuring the viscous and elastic properties of single cells using video particle tracking microrheology. Rebecca L. Warren, Manlio Tassieri∗, Xiang Li, Andrew Glidle, Allan Carlsson, Jonathan M. Cooper Division of Biomedical Engineering, School of Engineering, University of Glasgow, 1 Glasgow, U.K. ∗ E-mail: [email protected] Abstract We present a simple and non-invasive experimental procedure to measure the linear viscoelastic properties of cells by passive video particle tracking microrheology. In order to do this, a generalised Langevin equation is adopted to relate the time -- dependent thermal fluctuations of a bead, chemically bound to the cell's exterior, to the frequency -- dependent viscoelastic moduli of the cell. It is shown that these moduli are related to the cell's cytoskeletal structure, which in this work is changed by varying the solution osmolarity from iso -- to hypo -- osmotic conditions. At high frequencies, the viscoelastic moduli frequency dependence changes from ∝ ω3/4 found in iso -- osmotic solutions to ∝ ω1/2 in hypo -- osmotic solutions; the first situation is typical of bending modes in isotropic in vitro reconstituted F -- actin networks, and the second could indicate that the restructured cytoskeleton behaves as a gel with "dangling branches". The insights gained from this form of rheological analysis could prove to be a valuable addition to studies that address cellular physiology and pathology. Introduction As many authors have noted, the mechanical properties of a cell's cytoskeleton can influence factors such as growth, apoptosis, motility, signal transduction and gene expression [1]. Related to this, there is a desire to be able to provide a rheological interpretation of the cell's viscoelastic response that has the potential to yield quantitative information on the cell's cytoskeletal structure. Consequently, in this work, we have developed a means of using passive video particle tracking microrheology measurements to quantitatively measure changes in the viscoelastic properties of a cell as a consequence (in this case) of simple changes in its external environment, i.e. subjecting a cell to a hypo -- osmotic shock. 1 1 0 2 v o N 1 1 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 7 0 7 2 . 1 1 1 1 : v i X r a 2 Osmotic regulation and the transport of osmotically active molecules are fundamental to both metabolic processes and homeostasis of cells and require precise regulation and maintenance of intracellular water [2]. The ability of many cells to regulate their volume, via internal restructuring, in response to osmotic changes in their environment is an essential component of normal cellular function. This regulatory vol- ume change is linked to a reorganisation of the cytoskeletal actin networks [3, 4]. Exposure to a hypotonic solution typically induces an initial rapid swelling followed by a shrinkage of the cell that occurs over a slower timescale of several minutes. The modulation of the actin dynamics and polymerisation that accompanies these regulatory volume changes has been shown in various cell types by methods such as DNase I inhibition assay and fluorescence measurements of phalloidin -- labelled actin [3]. In this work we have developed a video particle -- tracking tool to study the microrheology of cells, using a Jurkat lymphocyte cell line as a model system. In general, lymphocytes have been shown to have a response to hypo -- osmotic solutions that is influenced by tyrosine kinase activity [5] and cytoskeleton (F -- actin) participation in ion channel activation [6]. Furthermore, the interest in T -- cells stems from their important role in the regulation of immune responses. In particular, Jurkat cells, as used in this study, are CD4+ T -- lymphoma cells that are often utilised as models to understand T -- cell signalling [7] and HIV-1 dissemination in viral pathogenesis [8]. The linear viscoelastic properties of a material can be represented by the frequency -- dependent dy- namic complex modulus G∗(ω), which provides information on both the viscous and the elastic nature of the material (i.e. on how the matter dissipates and stores the energy transferred to it) at different frequencies ω; it is defined as the ratio between the Fourier transforms (denoted by the symbol " ") of the applied stress σ(t) (which is proportional to the applied force) and the resulting strain γ(t) (which is proportional to the material/cell deformation): G∗(ω) = ≡ σ(t) γ(t) (cid:82) +∞ (cid:82) +∞ −∞ σ(t)e−iωtdt −∞ γ(t)e−iωtdt (1) where i is the imaginary unit (i.e. i2 = −1). The standard method of measuring G∗(ω) is based on the imposition of an oscillatory stress σ(ω, t) given by a formula such as: σ(ω, t) = σ0 sin(ωt) (2) where σ0 is the amplitude of the stress function, ω is the frequency and t the time. The resulting oscillatory strain γ(ω, t) then has the formula: γ(ω, t) = γ0 sin(ωt + δ(ω)) 3 (3) where γ0 is the strain amplitude and δ(ω) is the frequency -- dependent phase shift between the stress and the strain. The amplitudes of the complex modulus in -- phase and out -- of -- phase components are propor- tional to the ratio between amplitudes of the stress and of the strain, with constants of proportionality defining the storage (elastic) G(cid:48)(ω) and the loss (viscous) G(cid:48)(cid:48)(ω) moduli, respectively: G∗(ω) = G(cid:48)(ω) + iG(cid:48)(cid:48)(ω) = σ0 γ0 cos(δ(ω)) + i σ0 γ0 sin(δ(ω)) (4) For example, in the case of a purely elastic solid, the stress and the strain are in phase (i.e. Hooke's law, the material deformation is directly proportional to the applied force) and δ(ω) = 0; whereas, for a purely viscous fluid, such as water or glycerol, δ(ω) = π/2. For complex solids (e.g. gels, cells) or viscoelastic fluids (e.g. blood, saliva) δ(ω) would take any value between these limits (i.e. 0 (cid:54) δ(ω) (cid:54) π/2) depending on the frequency at which the force (stress) is applied. The aim of this article is to present a straightforward and non -- invasive procedure for measuring the in vivo linear viscoelastic properties of single cells via passive video particle tracking microrheology of single beads attached to the cells' exterior. This method has advantages over both complicated active microrheology techniques, where complex experimental set -- ups are necessary to exert an external force for performing stress -- controlled measurements; and invasive passive video particle tracking of submicron -- probes embedded (either via endocytosis or micropipette injection) within the cell's cytoskeleton (e.g. [9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15]. In particular, the procedure consists of measuring the thermal fluctuations of a bead chemically bound to the cell's exterior (Figure 1), for a sufficiently long time. A generalised Langevin equation was adopted to relate the time -- dependent bead trajectory, (cid:126)r(t), to the frequency -- dependent moduli of the cell. Notably, the procedure presented here represents an alternative methodology that can be extended to many experimental formats and provides a simple addition to existing cellular phys- iology studies (e.g. those monitoring cell pharmacological response). Indeed, when compared to single cell viscoelasticity assays such as magnetic tweezers, atomic force microscopy and optical stretcher, as employed in [9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15], our method has the advantage of revealing the changes of the cell's viscoelastic properties over a wide range of frequencies (here from ∼0.6 Hz up to ∼600 Hz), to a high level of accuracy, whilst it experiences an induced physiological process. 4 Figure 1. (Left) Top-view of a 5 µm diameter silica bead bound to the surface of a Jurkat cell. (Centre) Schematic side-view of the left image. (Right) The thermal fluctuations of a 5 µm silica bead chemically bound to the surface of a Jurkat cell. Images were analysed in real -- time and the coordinates of the bead's centre of mass were stored directly on the random -- access memory (RAM) of the computer, at time intervals down to 1/600s, using our own suite of image analysis software written in LabVIEW [23]. Analytical model The equation describing the pseudo Brownian fluctuation of the randomly varying bead position (cid:126)r(t)∀t can be derived by means of a generalised Langevin equation, which was originally derived to describe the Brownian motion of a freely diffusing particle suspended in a purely viscous fluid [16] and represents Newton's second law as written for stochastic processes: (cid:90) t m(cid:126)a(t) = (cid:126)fR(t) − [ζc(t − τ ) + ζs(t − τ )](cid:126)v(τ )dτ (5) 0 where m is the mass of the particle, (cid:126)a(t) is its acceleration, (cid:126)v(t) is the bead velocity and (cid:126)fR(t) is the usual Gaussian white noise term that models stochastic thermal forces acting on the particle. The integral term represents the total damping force acting on the bead, which, based on the superposition principle, incorporates two generalised time -- dependent memory functions ζc(t) and ζs(t) that are representative of the viscoelastic nature of the cell and the solvent, respectively. These memory functions are directly related to the materials' complex modulus as shown hereafter. In the case of the solvent, which in this work is the media surrounding the cell, the relationship between memory function and complex modulus is straightforward. Indeed, to a first approximation, using the assumptions adopted by Mason and Weitz [17] when studying the motion of thermally excited 0246810-100-50050100 r(t) [nm]Time [s]5 free particles, at thermal equilibrium the complex viscoelastic modulus of the solvent is related to the memory function ζs(t) by the expression: G∗ is the Fourier transform of ζs(t). In the case of the cell, we assume a similar relationship between G∗ s(ω) = iω ζs(ω)/6πR, where R is the bead radius and ζs(ω) c (ω) and ζc(t) to that given above for the solvent, but with a different constant of proportionality that we will call β; i.e., G∗ c (ω) = iω ζc(ω)/β. Note that, β may vary for different cells because it depends on (i) the cell radius (Rc), (ii) the number of the chemical bonds between the bead and the cell, (iii) the contact area between the cell and the glass coverslip, and (iv) the relative position of the bead with respect to both the cell's equatorial plane and the glass coverslip. In this study we will only focus on the changes in cell dynamics due to variations in osmolarity. This can be achieved since all the above experimental parameters, with the exception of Rc, are (in good approximation) time -- independent, and will not change significantly during the course of a set of measurements, as shown in Figure 4 for measurements performed on cells in iso -- osmotic condition. In addition, it is important to highlight that the cells maintained a spherical shape well beyond the duration of the experiment. Moreover, the cells adhered to the coverslip and no drift was observed during the experiment. Finally, given that we measure an increase of the cell radius (Rc) of (cid:54) 5% for the hypo -- osmolarity experiments described below, we also make the assumption that this small change does not affect the dynamics of the system appreciably. We now describe how the thermal fluctuations of a bead, chemically bound to a cell, can be investigated to determine the viscoelastic properties of the cell through the analysis of the time dependence of the bead's mean -- square displacement (MSD)(cid:10)∆r2(τ )(cid:11) ≡(cid:68) [(cid:126)r(t + τ ) − (cid:126)r(t)]2(cid:69) , in the radial direction of the t cell; where t is the absolute time and τ is the lag -- time (i.e. time interval). The average is taken over all initial times t. Under these circumstances, it is an easy step to show that, at thermal equilibrium, Equation 5 can be reorganised to express the viscoelastic moduli of the cell as function of the Fourier transform of the mean -- square displacement: G∗ c (ω) G(cid:48) 0 = 1 iω Π(ω) + mω2 βG(cid:48) 0 − 6πRG∗ βG(cid:48) 0 s(ω) (6) where G(cid:48) (i.e. cell plus solvent), which in this work is G(cid:48) 0 is the limiting value, for vanishingly low frequencies, of the elastic modulus of the whole system c (ω) for ω → 0; and Π(ω) is the Fourier transform of the normalised mean -- square displacement Π(τ ) =(cid:10)∆r2(τ )(cid:11) /(cid:10)r2(cid:11), introduced by Tassieri et al. [18] 0 ≡ G∗ in the study of the thermal fluctuations of an optically trapped bead suspended in a viscoelastic fluid. The term(cid:10)r2(cid:11) is the time -- independent variance of (cid:126)r(t) measured for a sufficiently long time. Moreover, 6 it has been shown [18] that for a constrained bead (e.g. one that is optically trapped or, as in this work, chemically bonded to the cell) Π(τ ) = 1 at large time intervals. It is important to highlight that (as in the case of an optically trapped bead) the term βG(cid:48) 0 (representing the coefficient of the elastic restoring force) can be determined by means of the principle of equipartition of energy, which in one dimension is written as: kBT = βG(cid:48) 0(cid:104)r2(cid:105) (7) Usefully, two further simplifications can be made to Equation 6 because (a) for micron-sized silica beads, the inertia term mω2 is negligible up to frequencies on the order of M Hz and (b) for solvents having frequency -- independent viscosity η (e.g. water), G∗ viscoelastic properties of the cell (scaled by G(cid:48) s(ω) simplifies to iωηs. Thus, Equation 6 provides the 0) over a range of frequencies that is limited at the top end by the rate of acquisition of images to determine the bead position, and at the bottom end by a cutoff frequency given by ωcutof f = βG(cid:48) 0/η0, where η0 is the limiting value, for vanishing frequencies, of the viscosity of the whole system. Finally, in order to evaluate the Fourier transform in Equation 6 we adopt the analytical method introduced by Evans et al. [19] (i.e. Eq. (10) of Ref. [19]), which is applied directly to the experimental data points and has the advantage of removing the need for Laplace and inverse -- Laplace transformations of experimental data [20]. Experimental details Anti-CD4+ (Invitrogen) was attached to 5µm carboxylate functionalised silica beads (Bangs Laboratories Inc) using a method based on a previously described protocol [21]. The adaptation of this method involved first binding a short polyethylene glycol chain to the beads so as to provide a flexible linker on to which the anti-CD4+ could be bound. In detail, the microspheres were washed (3x) with 0.1 M N a2CO3 buffer (pH 9.6) using centrifugation between washes to remove the supernatant liquid. This ensured that all the carboxylate groups were deprotonated. Following the final wash, the beads were resuspended in RO water and centrifuged again. After removal of the water, the remaining pellet was resuspended in freshly prepared 0.02 M sodium phos- phate buffer (pH 6) containing 2 mM 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)-carbodiimide (EDC, Sigma) and 7 5 mM sulfo-N-hydroxysuccinimide (sulfo-NHS, Thermo-Fisher). The microsphere solution was then ag- itated for 15 minutes to allow the sulfo-NHS to activate the carboxylate groups on the surface of the microspheres. The solution was centrifuged, then the supernatant removed and replaced by a 10 mM solu- tion of the flexible linker, O-(2-Aminoethyl)-O'-(2-carboxyethyl)polyethylene glycol 3,000 hydrochloride (Aldrich) in pH 7.4 phosphate buffer. The activated microspheres were then agitated in the flexible linker solution for 2 h at 4oC, before further centrifugation and washing with pH 7.4 buffer. The anti-CD4+ was then bound to the carboxylate terminals of the PEG linker from a 1 mg/ml solution of anti-CD4+, using the same EDC/sulfo-NHS activation procedure outlined above. The Jurkat cells were obtained from ATCC (clone E6-1, TIB-152) and maintained in RPMI 1640 (1x) media containing L-Glutamine and 25mM HEPES [Gibco, Invitrogen]. Prior to the experiment they were suspended in PBS [Gibco, Invitrogen] with an osmolarity of 275-304 mOsm, then mixed with the functionalised beads and allowed to equilibrate for ∼10min. Beads were optically trapped and moved to the equatorial plane of the cell, where they were held for a sufficient time (∼2 min) until the binding process was completed. Trapping was achieved by using a CW Ti:sapphire laser system (M Squared, SolsTiS) which provides up to 1 W at 830 nm. Holographic optical traps were created via the use of a spatial light modulator (Boulder XY series) in the Fourier plane of the optical traps [22]. The microscope was equipped with a 100x 1.3NA (Zeiss, Plan-Neofluor) objective lens, which was used both to focus the trapping laser beam and to visualise the particles via a Prosilica PCI-6713 camera. Samples were mounted on a motorised microscope stage (Prior Pro-Scan II). The beads' trajectories were measured and stored on a personal computer in real-time, at frequencies up to ∼kHz (depending on the size of the analysed region of interest (ROI) within the camera field of view), using our own suite of image analysis software written in LabVIEW [23]. Results and Discussion In order to validate the analytical model introduced in this work, we measured the dynamic response of an analytical system that could be considered as an ideal viscoelastic medium with known storage and loss moduli; i.e. an optically trapped bead suspended in a Newtonian fluid. Indeed, for such a system, the elastic modulus must be proportional to the optical tweezers' (OT) trap stiffness (κ), this being the only elastic component present in the system (i.e. the ensemble of Newtonian fluid, bead and OT); and the viscous modulus must be linearly proportional to the frequency (ω) with constant of proportionality given by the viscosity of the Newtonian fluid (η). 8 Figure 2. (A) The mean-square displacements vs. lag-time of optically trapped beads in Newtonian fluids. The square and the triangle symbols refer to measurements performed with 2 µm diameter silica bead in Glycerol/water mixtures at 10% and 20% w/w, having viscosity values of 1.15 mP as and 1.54 mP as, and trap constants of 0.85 µN/m and 0.81 µN/m, respectively; The circle symbols refer to a measurement performed with 5 µm diameter silica bead in water having viscosity value of 0.89 mP as and trap constants of 1.68 µN/m (note that for this measurement only we used an off-line faster camera with internal memory; not suitable for continuous acquisition). The inset shows the same data as above but with the abscissa scaled by κ/(6πηR). (B) The normalised viscoelastic moduli vs. the normalised frequency for all three analytical systems described above. In Figure 2B we present the normalised viscoelastic moduli versus the normalised frequency for three systems made up with diverse combinations of Newtonian fluids and beads having different viscosities and size, respectively. For each system, the moduli have been derived by the analysis of the thermal c (ω) in Equation 6 represents the viscoelastic nature of the analytical system; fluctuations of an optically trapped bead by means of Equation 6 via the relative MSD shown in Figure 2A. In this case, the term G∗ the term G∗ c (ω)] (and therefore it does not need to be 0 ≡ κ is determined by means of the principle of equipartition of accounted for in Eq. 6); the term βG(cid:48) energy with β ≡ 6πR. In summary, for both moduli, the normalising factor is given by κ/(6πR); whereas, s(ω) simplifies to iωη and is coincident with (cid:61)[G∗ for the abscissa, the scaling factor is given by a cut-off frequency defined as κ/(6πRη), which also works in the time-domain as shown in the inset of Figure 2A. In Figure 2B it is interesting to highlight that at low frequencies (i.e. up to the cut-off frequency) the elastic modulus G(cid:48)(ω) is actually normalised to 1, as expected; whereas, at high frequencies (i.e. for ω > κ/(6πR)) G(cid:48)(ω) vanishes towards zero. The latter phenomenon is itself an interesting feature that is currently an object of discussion in literature (A) (B) (A) (B) 9 [24, 25, 26]. In particular, it is argued that the analytical models adopted so far for data analysis of the thermal fluctuation of an optically trapped bead suspended into a Newtonian fluid are unable to provide the high frequency elastic component of the optical tweezers (OT), because they would "suffer from systematic truncation errors at high frequencies". In contrast, we believe that the absence of the optical tweezers' high frequency elastic component is an intrinsic feature of the system made up by the ensemble of (Newtonian) fluid, bead and OT [27]; on which we will provide a detailed explanation, but in a different work. On the other hand, the viscous modulus G(cid:48)(cid:48)(ω) grows linearly with the frequency (thus in a Log-Log plot it is represented by a line with unity slope) over the entire experimental frequency window, with constant of proportionality given by the viscosity of the Newtonian fluid, as expected. Note that the results shown in Figure 2 are in good agreement with those published in literature [24, 25, 26] for an optically trapped bead in water, but they used a different analytical method for data analysis and they overlooked the scaling process introduced in this work. Having demonstrated the validity of our analytical model, we now investigate its applicability to cellular physiology studies by focussing on changes in the cells' microrheology due to changes in osmolarity of the surrounding solution. It is anticipated that there are two major physiological processes that accompany the changes in osmolarity of the solution surrounding the Jurkat cell: (I) an actin cytoskeleton reorganisation and (II) an increase of the cell volume as the solution becomes hypo -- osmotic. In order to quantify the changes in cell volume, we assumed that the cells were spherical, Figure 1. In particular, Figure 3 shows that the relative radius changes are < 6% when the surrounding PBS solution was made hypo-osmotic by addition of 10% v/v distilled water. The data of Figure 3 also shows that, after an initial swelling, the cells contract to a still swollen state that is ∼5% larger than when they were in isotonic PBS. Based on these observations, which are in good agreement with those already existing in literature (e.g. [28]), we assume that these small radius changes do not affect the dynamics of the system appreciably. To study how the in vivo viscoelastic properties of Jurkat cells vary with the osmolarity of the solution, we have adopted the model described in the Analytical Section. In particular, analysis of different time regimes in the time dependent normalised mean-squared displacement, Π(τ ), has the potential to reveal information both on the pure elastic component of the cell (at long time intervals or low frequencies) and on the fast dynamics occurring at small length scales (e.g. those related to the transverse bending modes of single actin filaments in the cytoskeleton). 10 Figure 3. Averaged relative cell radius changes vs. time as a consequence of the change in osmolarity of the cell solution; from iso-osmotic conditions in PBS buffer towards a hypo-osmotic condition obtained by adding 10% v/v of distilled water to the initial solution. The osmotic shock causes a rapid swelling of the cells, followed by a partial recovery of the cells' volume. These results are in good agreement with those reported in literature, e.g. [28]. Elastic properties of the cell derived from Π(τ ) The first result that can be obtained through the analysis of the thermal fluctuations of the bound bead (Figure 1) is the relative change of the cell's low frequency elastic plateau modulus G(cid:48) c(0), Figure 4. This can be evaluated from the time -- independent variance (cid:104)r2(cid:105) of the constrained bead in the radial direction of the cell, by adopting the principle of equipartition of energy as in Equation 7. In particular, although the absolute value of G(cid:48) change between different values of βG(cid:48) c(0) can not be determined because of the unknown factor β, the relative c(0), obtained from n sequential measurements performed on the same cell, differ from each other only because of both the small increase of the cell radius (measured as ∼5%) and the variation of G(cid:48) c(0). Thus, from Figure 4 it is clear that a change of 10% in osmolarity towards hypotonicity, which occurs at t ∼9min as a result of adding distilled water to the iso-osmotic solution, induces a temporary increase of βG(cid:48) this change in the low frequency elastic modulus dependent term, βG(cid:48) c(0) that lasts for approximately 15-30min. At its greatest, c(0), is over 3 fold in magnitude. The explanation for such a large increase may in part be due to the change in radius; however, if this were solely responsible, it would be expected that βG(cid:48) c(0) would remain significantly above its original 0510152011.011.021.031.041.051.06Time [min]Rc/Rc011 Figure 4. The absolute value of βG(cid:48) symbols) and when the solution is made 10% hypotonic (square symbols) The arrow indicates the time at which the isotonic solution is made hypotonic. The dotted line is a guide for the eye, so that the later points in the graph can be compared to the first points measured in isotonic condition. c(0) measured in isotonic (PBS) condition (circle value, as the cells do not regain their original radius. Thus, since βG(cid:48) c(0) does return to close to the original value (at t ∼25 min), consideration should be given to the temporary increase in electrostatic intermolecular interactions within the cell due to the reduction in ionic strength of the solution (i.e. a reduction in screening of the charges on cytoskeleton molecules by solution based ions). This latter phenomenon would also alter the cell's viscoelastic properties and any resulting actin cytoskeleton re- arrangement may be seen as part of an attempt of the cell to re -- equilibrate the solution osmolarity, as discussed below. Evidence for an increase in intermolecular interactions in the cytoskeleton being the cause of the observed increase in βG(cid:48) modulus (G(cid:48)(0)) of an ideal cross-linked polymer network can be written: c(0) comes from studies of polymer gels [29, 30, 31], for which the elastic plateau G(cid:48)(0) ∼= ψkBT (f − 2) f (8) where kB is the Boltzmann constant, T is the absolute temperature, and ψ and f are the number of network strands and cross -- links per unit volume, respectively (see Figure 5). Here, an increase in 12 number of strands and/or number of cross -- linking interactions causes an overall increase in G(cid:48)(0). Note that although it is appreciated that there may be more order associated with macromolecules within the cell's cytoskeleton, the generalised polymer network of Figure 5 nevertheless has many similarities with the complex structure of the cytoskeleton. For example, it is well known that all cells possess a host of actin -- binding proteins that can align actin filaments into bundles and then cross-link filaments or bundles into networks [32]. Bundled actin and scruin in vitro networks act similarly to cross -- linked networks and show a strong increase in elasticity as the degree of bundling increases [33]. Figure 5. Schematic view of a randomly cross-linked network with "dangling branches" defects. Circles represent cross-linking junctions and arrows denote attachments to the macroscopic network. The "dangling branches" do not contribute to the gel elasticity because they cannot bear stresses; in contrast, they can dissipate energy by friction with the solvent. Thus, by analogy with the models for a polymer network, a >3 fold increase in the cell elastic plateau modulus could be explained by an increase of intermolecular interactions (i.e. electrostatic interactions) that would have the effect of forming temporary cross -- linkages and reshaping the isotropic cytoskeleton structure. This scenario is in good agreement with confocal microscopy results already reported for multiple cell lines and the observations that actin forms bundles in aortic bovine endothelial cells after hypotonic exposure [34]. Cross-linksDangling ends13 Fast dynamics of the cell derived from Π(τ ) In order to study the high frequency behaviour of cells, we have used Equation 6, which directly relates the normalised mean-square displacement, Π(τ ), of the bead to the cell complex modulus, G∗ c (ω). In particular, we have applied Equation 6 to the Π(τ ) derived from measurements that were collected at fixed time intervals after the solution was made hypotonic. In Figure 6, these are compared with the normalised MSD of the same cell in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) solution, prior to hypotonic exposure. Note that in order to more easily discern visually the changes in Π(τ ), caused by the hypotonicity, the normalised MSD for the cell in PBS is plotted in each of the panels. The elastic (G(cid:48) c(ω)) and viscous (G(cid:48)(cid:48) c (ω)) components of the complex modulus, G∗ c (ω), derived from the measurements shown in Figure 6 are shown in Figure 7 (scaled by the plateau modulus G(cid:48) c(0)). It is clear that, in PBS (Figure 7A), the high frequency behaviour of the cell's elastic and viscous moduli both show a frequency dependence of ∝ ω3/4, which is characteristic of isotropic in vitro reconstituted actin filament solutions [35, 36]. As the solution is made hypo -- osmotic, the cell cytoskeleton starts to reorganise and the frequency behaviour of the moduli drastically change as (sequentially) shown in Figure ??. In particular, after ∼10min in the hypo -- osmotic solution both moduli tend to assume a high frequency behaviour ∝ ω1/2 (see Figures 7C and 7D). This change in the degree of elasticity may be explained by two alternative (and possibly concomitant) processes: (i) an increase in cytoskeletal tension as response to a stretching force caused by the cell swelling and (ii) the consequent formation of "dangling branches" [29, 30, 31] (Figure 5) generated during the reorganisation process of the cell cytoskeleton (including those possibly obtained from the rupture of the cytoskeletal protein filaments because of stress overload). However, whilst the increase in cytoskeletal tension would explain both the initial increase of the cell stiffness and the change in the frequency scaling laws of the moduli (i.e. from ∝ ω3/4 to ∝ ω1/2), it would fail to explain the softening process occurring during the cell volume re -- equilibration, which ends with a breakdown, at high frequency, of the cell's elastic modulus (Figures 7G). This latter phenomenon could be simply justified by an excess of "dangling branches". Indeed, from a rheological point of view, these would only contribute to the capability of the cell to dissipate energy but not to the cell elasticity, since they cannot bear stress and hence do not contribute to the cell's rigidity. Finally, it is important to highlight that the results that have been obtained here using a video particle tracking method are in good agreement with those presented in the review written by Papakonstanti and Stournaras [3], where a set of assessments of actin cytoskeleton dynamics and actin architecture in cell volume regulation are summarised. However, none of the techniques reviewed in that work [3] are able to provide quantitative information on the cell viscoelasticity, as is the case here. 14 Figure 6. The normalised mean -- square displacement vs. lag -- time of a 5 µm diameter silica bead chemically bound to a Jurkat cell in iso -- osmotic (PBS) solution (square symbols) and in hypo-osmotic solution (circle symbols) after the addition of 10% v/v distilled water to the PBS buffer and measured at time intervals (∆t) of (A) 2 min, (B) 7 min, (C) 12 min, (D) 18 min, (E) 23 min, (F) 28 min, respectively. At short time intervals, the Π(τ ) has the potential to reveal the dynamics occurring at molecular level (as shown in Figure ??); whereas, at large lag -- times it provides information on the stiffness of the whole cell (as shown in Figure 4). 15 c(ω)) and the imaginary (loss, G(cid:48)(cid:48) 0 vs. frequency of a Jurkat cell in iso-osmotic (PBS) solution Figure 7. The real (storage, G(cid:48) modulus (G∗ c (ω)) scaled by G(cid:48) (A) and in hypo-osmotic solution (B-G) after the addition of 10% v/v distilled water to the PBS buffer and measured at time intervals (∆t) of (B) 2 min, (C) 7 min, (D) 12 min, (E) 18 min, (F) 23 min, (G) 28 min, respectively. The moduli have been evaluated by using Equation 6 on the normalised mean-square displacement data shown in Figure 6. The lines are guides for the gradients. Note that, the scatter in the data at high frequencies and the ripples in the low frequency portions of the curves in Figure 7 are due to the analytical method that we have adopted [19] for performing the Fourier transforms of the normalised MSDs. As explained in detail in Ref. [37], this c (ω)) parts of the complex method works directly on the experimental data points (i.e. (cid:8)τk, Πk (cid:9), where k = 1..N ) and therefore preserves genuine experimental noise. 16 Conclusions In summary, we have presented a straightforward and non -- invasive experimental procedure, coupled with a new analytical method to interpret the data, which leads to quantitative determination of the in vivo viscoelastic properties of cells in the frequency domain. The method has the potential to monitor the internal dynamics and re -- organisation of the actin cytoskeleton up to frequencies on the order of kHz, representing a valuable addition to studies that address cellular physiology and pharmacological response. Indeed, in this work we report, for the first time, the high frequencies (up to ∼600Hz) changes of the Jurkat cells' viscoelastic spectrum from ∝ ω3/4 to ∝ ω1/2, as response to a change in osmolarity of the solution. The rheological interpretation of the results gives a direct insight of the cell cytoskeleton structure and its re -- organisation. In the future, it is envisaged that these interpretations could be coupled with advanced molecular biology techniques to resolve the detailed interactions underlying these rheological changes and that faster dynamics could be studied by means of a quadrant photo -- diode based tracking system Acknowledgments We thank Mike Evans for helpful conversations. M.T. is Research Fellow of the Royal Academy of Engineering/EPSRC; research program title: "Rheology at the Microscale: New Tools for Bio-analysis". We are grateful to EPSRC and BBSRC for supporting this work through grants EP/F040857/1 and BB/C511572/1, respectively, and to the DTC in Proteomic and Cell Technologies (EPSRC) for funding RLW. References [1] Chicurel ME, Chen CS, Ingber DE (1998) Cellular control lies in the balance of forces. Curr Opin Cell Biol 10: 232-9. [2] Nagy T, Balasa A, Frank D, Rab A, Rideg O, et al. (2010) O-glcnac modification of proteins affects volume regulation in jurkat cells. Eur Biophys J 39: 1207-17. 17 [3] Papakonstanti EA, Stournaras C (2007) Actin cytoskeleton architecture and signaling in osmosens- ing. Methods Enzymol 428: 227-40. [4] Ebner HL, Cordas A, Pafundo DE, Schwarzbaum PJ, Pelster B, et al. (2005) Importance of cy- toskeletal elements in volume regulatory responses of trout hepatocytes. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 289: R877-90. [5] Lepple-Wienhues A, Szab`o I, Laun T, Kaba NK, Gulbins E, et al. (1998) The tyrosine kinase p56lck mediates activation of swelling-induced chloride channels in lymphocytes. J Cell Biol 141: 281-6. [6] Levitan I, Almonte C, Mollard P, Garber SS (1995) Modulation of a volume-regulated chloride current by f-actin. J Membr Biol 147: 283-94. [7] Abraham R, Weiss A (2004) Timeline - jurkat t cells and development of the t-cell receptor signalling paradigm. Nature Reviews Immunology 4: 301 -- 308. [8] Cheng-Mayer C, Iannello P, Shaw K, Luciw PA, Levy JA (1989) Differential effects of nef on hiv replication: implications for viral pathogenesis in the host. Science 246: 1629-32. [9] Bausch A, Ziemann F, Boulbitch A, Jacobson K, Sackmann E (1998) Local measurements of vis- coelastic parameters of adherent cell surfaces by magnetic bead microrheometry. Biophysical Journal 75: 2038 -- 2049. [10] Bausch A, Hellerer U, Essler M, Aepfelbacher M, Sackmann E (2001) Rapid stiffening of integrin receptor-actin linkages in endothelial cells stimulated with thrombin: A magnetic bead microrheology study. Biophysical Journal 80: 2649 -- 2657. [11] Deng L, Trepat X, Butler JP, Millet E, Morgan KG, et al. (2006) Fast and slow dynamics of the cytoskeleton. Nature Materials 5: 636 -- 640. [12] Hoh JH, Schoenenberger CA (1994) Surface morphology and mechanical properties of mdck mono- layers by atomic force microscopy. J Cell Sci 107 ( Pt 5): 1105-14. [13] Uhde J, Feneberg W, Ter-Oganessian N, Sackmann E, Boulbitch A (2005) Osmotic force-controlled microrheometry of entangled actin networks. Phys Rev Lett 94: 198102. 18 [14] Wirtz D (2009) Particle-tracking microrheology of living cells: principles and applications. Annu Rev Biophys 38: 301-26. [15] Lu YB, Franze K, Seifert G, Steinhauser C, Kirchhoff F, et al. (2006) Viscoelastic properties of individual glial cells and neurons in the cns. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103: 17759-64. [16] Langevin P (1908) The theory of brownian movement. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires Des Seances De L Academie Des Sciences 146: 530 -- 533. [17] Mason, Weitz (1995) Optical measurements of frequency-dependent linear viscoelastic moduli of complex fluids. Phys Rev Lett 74: 1250-1253. [18] Tassieri M, Gibson GM, Evans RML, Yao AM, Warren R, et al. (2010) Measuring storage and loss moduli using optical tweezers: Broadband microrheology. Physical Review E 81: 026308. [19] Evans RML, Tassieri M, Auhl D, Waigh TA (2009) Direct conversion of rheological compliance measurements into storage and loss moduli. Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys 80: 012501. [20] Mason T, Ganesan K, vanZanten J, Wirtz D, Kuo S (1997) Particle tracking microrheology of complex fluids. Physical Review Letters 79: 3282 -- 3285. [21] Kulin S, Kishore R, Hubbard JB, Helmerson K (2002) Real-time measurement of spontaneous antigen-antibody dissociation. Biophys J 83: 1965-73. [22] Preece D, Warren R, Evans RML, Gibson GM, Padgett MJ, et al. (2011) Optical tweezers: wideband microrheology. Journal of Optics 13: 044022. [23] Gibson GM, Leach J, Keen S, Wright AJ, Padgett MJ (2008) Measuring the accuracy of particle position and force in optical tweezers using high-speed video microscopy. Opt Express 16: 14561-70. [24] Yanagishima T, Frenkel D, Kotar J, Eiser E (2011) Real-time monitoring of complex moduli from micro-rheology. J Phys Condens Matter 23: 194118. [25] Pesce G, De Luca AC, Rusciano G, Netti PA, Fusco S, et al. (2009) Microrheology of complex fluids using optical tweezers: a comparison with macrorheological measurements. Journal of Optics A-Pure and Applied Optics 11: 034016. 19 [26] Addas K, Schmidt C, Tang J (2004) Microrheology of solutions of semiflexible biopolymer filaments using laser tweezers interferometry. Physical Review E 70: 021503. [27] Wu P, Huang R, Tischer C, Jonas A, Florin EL (2009) Direct measurement of the nonconservative force field generated by optical tweezers. Phys Rev Lett 103: 108101. [28] Cantiello H (1997) Role of actin filament organization in cell volume and ion channel regulation. Journal of Experimental Zoology 279: 425 -- 435. [29] Rouse PE (1953) A theory of the linear viscoelastic properties of dilute solutions of coiling polymers. Journal of Chemical Physics 21: 1272 -- 1280. [30] Ferry JD (1980) Viscoelastic properties of polymers. Wiley, 3d ed edition. [31] Rubinstein M, Colby R (2003) Polymer Physics (Chemistry). Oxford University Press, USA. [32] Pollard TD, Cooper JA (1986) Actin and actin-binding proteins. a critical evaluation of mechanisms and functions. Annu Rev Biochem 55: 987-1035. [33] Gardel ML, Shin JH, MacKintosh FC, Mahadevan L, Matsudaira P, et al. (2004) Elastic behavior of cross-linked and bundled actin networks. Science 304: 1301-5. [34] Koyama T, Oike M, Ito Y (2001) Involvement of rho-kinase and tyrosine kinase in hypotonic stress- induced atp release in bovine aortic endothelial cells. J Physiol 532: 759-69. [35] Farge E, Maggs A (1993) Dynamic scattering from semiflexible polymer. Macromolecules 26: 5041 -- 5044. [36] Tassieri M, Evans RML, Barbu-Tudoran L, Khaname GN, Trinick J, et al. (2008) Dynamics of semiflexible polymer solutions in the highly entangled regime. Physical Review Letters 101: 198301. [37] Evans RML (2009) Transforming from time to frequency without artefacts. British Society of Rhe- ology Bulletin 50: 76.
1011.4688	2	1011	2011-08-29T15:35:12	Rather than resonance, flapping wing flyers may play on aerodynamics to improve performance	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "physics.flu-dyn" ]	Saving energy and enhancing performance are secular preoccupations shared by both nature and human beings. In animal locomotion, flapping flyers or swimmers rely on the flexibility of their wings or body to passively increase their efficiency using an appropriate cycle of storing and releasing elastic energy. Despite the convergence of many observations pointing out this feature, the underlying mechanisms explaining how the elastic nature of the wings is related to propulsive efficiency remain unclear. Here we use an experiment with a self-propelled simplified insect model allowing to show how wing compliance governs the performance of flapping flyers. Reducing the description of the flapping wing to a forced oscillator model, we pinpoint different nonlinear effects that can account for the observed behavior ---in particular a set of cubic nonlinearities coming from the clamped-free beam equation used to model the wing and a quadratic damping term representing the fluid drag associated to the fast flapping motion. In contrast to what has been repeatedly suggested in the literature, we show that flapping flyers optimize their performance not by especially looking for resonance to achieve larger flapping amplitudes with less effort, but by tuning the temporal evolution of the wing shape (i.e. the phase dynamics in the oscillator model) to optimize the aerodynamics.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Behind the performance of flapping flyers Sophie Ramananarivo, Ramiro Godoy-Diana & Benjamin Thiria Physique et Mécanique des Milieux Hétérogènes (PMMH) UMR7636 CNRS; ESPCI; UPMC; Université Denis Diderot 10, rue Vauquelin, F-75231 Paris Cedex 5, France 1 1 0 2 g u A 9 2 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 2 v 8 8 6 4 . 1 1 0 1 : v i X r a Saving energy and enhancing performance are secular preoccupations shared by both nature and human beings. In animal locomotion, flapping flyers or swimmers rely on the flexibility of their wings or body to passively increase their efficiency using an appropriate cycle of storing and releasing elastic energy. Despite the convergence of many observations pointing out this feature, the underlying mechanisms explaining how the elastic nature of the wings is related to propulsive efficiency remain unclear. Here we use an experiment with a self-propelled simplified insect model allowing to show how wing compliance governs the performance of flapping flyers. Reducing the description of the flapping wing to a forced oscillator model, we pinpoint different nonlinear effects that can account for the observed behavior -- in particular a set of cubic nonlinearities coming from the clamped- free beam equation used to model the wing and a quadratic damping term representing the fluid drag associated to the fast flapping motion. In contrast to what has been repeatedly suggested in the literature, we show that flapping flyers optimize their performance not by especially looking for resonance to achieve larger flapping amplitudes with less effort, but by tuning the temporal evolution of the wing shape (i.e. the phase dynamics in the oscillator model) to optimize the aerodynamics. INTRODUCTION Flying animals have since long inspired admiration and fueled the imagination of scientists and engineers. Along- side biologists studying form and function of flapping fly- ers in nature [1, 2], the last decade has seen an impressive quantity of studies driven by engineering groups using new techniques to develop and study artificial biomimetic flapping flyers [3, 4]. The widespread availability of high- speed video and in particular the merging of experimental methods borrowed from fluid mechanics into the toolbox of the experimental biologist have permitted to elucidate various key mechanisms involved in the complex dynam- ics of flapping flight (see e.g. [5 -- 7]). A recent field of investigation concerns the efficiency of flapping flyers, the major interrogation being about how natural systems optimize energy saving together with performance enhancement. In particular, the passive role of wing flexibility to increase flight efficiency through the bending of the wings while flapping has attracted a lot of attention. It is commonly agreed that this efficiency en- hancement comes from the particular shape of the bent wing, which leads to a more favorable repartition of the aerodynamic forces (see [8] and [9] for an extensive re- view). For flying animals in air, such as insects, it has been proposed [10 -- 12] that wing inertia should play a major role in competing with the elastic restoring force, compared to the fluid loading. The mechanism govern- ing the propulsive performance of the flapping flyer can therefore be seen at leading order as a two-step process, where the instantaneous shape of the wings is determined by a structural mechanics problem which then sets the moving boundaries for the aerodynamic problem. From a dynamical point of view, if we consider chord- wise bending of a wing with a given flapping signal im- posed at the leading edge, the instantaneous shape of the structure is strongly dependent on the phase lag be- tween the forcing and the response of the wing (respec- tively the leading and trailing edges). Recent works by [13] and [14] using a simplified model of a flexible wing as a combination of heaving and passive pitching have shown that a transition from enhanced thrust to under- performance occurs for a critical phase value close to the resonant frequency of the system. This sustains the com- monly invoked argument suggesting that flapping flyers could take advantage of a structural property to save en- ergy by matching the relaxation frequency of their com- pliant wings to the wingbeat frequency [13, 15 -- 17]. In nature this has been observed in particular for undu- latory swimming fish or other swimmers that use de- forming propulsive structures, such as jellyfish or scal- lops (see [18] and references therein). In the case of in- sects, however, the few available observations (especially for large species) report wingbeat frequencies far below the natural relaxation frequencies [19 -- 22]. Recent exper- iments using a self-propelled model with large-flapping- amplitude elastic wings [12] are consistent with the lat- ter, since the propulsive efficiency of the model peaks for a flapping frequency lower than the primary linear resonance of the wings. Fully predicting the wing beat rate as the undamped resonant frequency of a linear os- cillator (see e.g. [15]) should be therefore taken with reserve. Super-harmonic nonlinear resonances have been invoked [23], suggesting that flying animals may effec- tively flap their wings far below the primary resonance while increasing their performance. This is probably one mechanism among others governing the dynamics of flap- ping flyers, but it is clear that the details of the underly- ing fluid-structure interaction problem are poorly under- stood. More specifically, the underlying phase dynamics 2 EXPERIMENTS Setup and physical quantities The experimental setup is the same described by Thiria & Godoy-Diana [12], inspired from the pioneer 19th cen- tury experiment by Marey [24]: a flapping wing device is attached to a mast that is ball bearing mounted to a cen- tral shaft in such a way that the thrust force produced by the wings makes the flyer turn around this shaft. A par- ticular attention has been paid to reduce friction losses in the whole system. Wings are made of Mylar R(cid:13) semi- circles of diameter S = 2L = 6 cm. The experimental parameters are the forcing frequency (f), the flapping amplitude (Aω) and the chordwise rigidity of the wings (B) governed by their thickness h. In contrast with the first study reported with this setup [12], the set of wings used here covers a larger range of bending rigidities, from near-rigid to very soft materials. Six pairs of wings have been tested. Their structural properties (thickness, mass, and rigidity) are summarized in Table 1. This specific setup allows to measure various averaged quantities (see [12] for details): the cruising speed U when the device is allowed to turn around, and the thrust force FT when it is held at a fixed station (see Fig. 2 (a) and (b)) which gives the averaged aerodynamic thrust power, being the product PT = U F . In both cases, the power consumption Pi is measured. On the other hand, we performed a precise dynamical study of the flapping wing. For each set of parameters (Aω, ff , B), the phase and amplitude of the trailing edge, with respect to the forcing flapping motion, has been measured using a fast cadenced camera (1000 fps) in both air and vacuum. It is important to recall that for this setup, and more generally for flapping flyers in air, the main bending mo- tor of the flexible wings is wing inertia [10 -- 12]. The com- petition between the wing inertia and the elastic restoring force is captured by the scaled elasto-inertial number Nei [12]: (cid:18) ωf (cid:19)2 (1) Nei = µsAwω2 f L3 B = Aω L ω0 The first expression is a direct comparison between both the moments of inertial and elastic forces. Inter- estingly, this number can also be expressed as a func- tion of the ratio between the forcing and relaxation fre- quencies times the non-dimensional forcing amplitude of the driving motion, which allows to express directly the bending rate as function of a non-dimensional oscillator forcing term. The second expression is therefore useful to explore the nearness of the resonance and will be used to analyze the experimental data in this paper. Results will therefore displayed as a function of the reduced fre- quency ¯ωf = (ωf /ω0) = ¯Aω−1/2N 1/2 L is , where ¯Aω = Aw ei FIG. 1: Experimental setup: a) Pioneer experiment from Marey [24]. b) Actual setup. c) Details of the flapping flyer model used for this study. that set the instantaneous wing shape and lead first to an increase and then a loss of the thrust power (and even a reversal of the propulsive force as in the case of [13]) remain unexplained. In this paper we address these questions using the ex- perimental self-propelled flapping-wing model with elas- tic wings described in [12]. Exploring a wide range of bending rigidities we show that, in the simplified context of chordwise-compliant wings, the performance optima of the system are far from being set by a simple resonant condition. We develop a nonlinear one-dimensional beam model for the bending wing which is reduced to a forced oscillator model suitable to study different nonlinear ef- fects. In particular, a set of cubic nonlinearities coming from the clamped-free beam equation and a quadratic damping term representing the fluid drag associated to the fast flapping motion permit to account for the ob- served behavior. We show that the nonlinear nature of the fluid damping is an essential feature to determine the phase lag that leads to an increase/decrease of the efficiency. As a whole fluid-solid interaction process leading to propulsion, we provide evidence that flapping flyers may optimize their performance not by especially looking for resonance but by using passive deformation to streamline the instantaneous shape of the wing with the surrounding flow. (cid:1)(cid:2)(cid:3)(cid:1)(cid:4)(cid:1)(cid:5)(cid:6)(cid:7)(cid:8)(cid:6)(cid:5)(cid:9)(cid:5)(cid:10)(cid:6)(cid:11)(cid:7)(cid:9)(cid:12)(cid:10)(cid:3)(cid:13)(cid:6)(cid:5)(cid:6)(cid:8)(cid:14)(cid:15)(cid:9)(cid:8)(cid:3)(cid:2)(cid:6)(cid:11)(cid:11)(cid:15)(cid:2)(cid:5)(cid:10)(cid:11)(cid:14)(cid:8)(cid:6)(cid:16)(cid:3)(a)(b)(c)3 FIG. 2: (a) Cruising speed, (b) thrust force and nondimen- sional (c) thrust (pT ) and (d) input (pi) powers as a function of ¯ωf . The gray area represents the optimum region, the dashed line indicates the location of the reduced natural fre- quency of the wing (linear resonance). the reduced flapping amplitude. In order to compare the aerodynamic performance in all the experiments, both the thrust force and cruising speed were rendered non- dimensional using the appropriate scalings fT = FT L/B and u = U/Aωω. The non-dimensional powers (displayed in Fig. 2 (c) and (d)) then read pT = U FT L/BAωω and pi = PiL/Bω. In both the thrust force and cruising speed curves, it is clear that increasing wing flexibility brings out two distinct regimes: up to a certain flapping frequency, the more flexible wings outperform the rigid linear U (f ) re- lationship (see also [25]). The measurements for the two most flexible wings evidence the appearance of an under- performance regime in which both FT and U lie below the rigid wing case. Looking now at the nondimensional thrust power, the data from all wings collapse on a single curve with a clear performance peak, which agrees with what has been observed by [13, 14] for heaving/pitching systems. An important point is that the maximum in performance does not take place at the resonant fre- quency, but much below (around 0.7ω0, represented by the gray shaded area). Moreover, the nondimensional thrust power at ¯ωf = 1 (see dahsed line in Fig. 2 (c)) is even more than 4 times lower than the optimum value. At last, we remark that there is also no sign of a resonant behavior in the consumed power curve (Fig. 2 (d)). Wing dynamics We proceed now to study the behavior of the wings considered as a forced oscillator, assuming the oscillation FIG. 3: a): Photograph of the flapping wing showing succes- sive states of the bending wing during one stroke cycle (thick- ness is 0.050 mm and ¯ωf = .5). As can be seen, the main deformation is mainly performed on the first mode. In this case the phase lag is quite large, leading to a strong increase of flight performance. b): Typical time series tracking the motion of the leading (black curve) and trailing (red curve) edges of the wing at mid-span, obtained from video record- ings at 1000 fps. c): Same as b) but with a forcing near 1 3 ω0, exhibiting super-harmonic resonance typical from dynamical systems containing cubic nonlinearities. of the leading edge to be the forcing and that of the trailing edge to be the response (which means to assume that the wings bend following only the first deformation mode). As said before, the amplitude and phase shift of the response can thus be measured by following the two wing edges on a high cadenced camera recording (as seen on Fig. 3 (a)). Figs. 3 (b) and (c) display two characteristic time evolutions of the driving oscillation (the imposed wing beat, shown as black dots) and the wing elastic response (the motion of the trailing edge, red dots) in the moving frame. The first case shows a typical response, at ¯ωf = 0.79, mainly sinusoidal at the driving frequency, which supports the assumption that the oscillations of the wing follow a single mode. In the second case, the driving frequency is near one third of the resonant frequency ω0. As can be observed in Fig. 3 (c), the response is then a combination between ω0/3 and ω0, giving evidence of a super-harmonic resonance [26], pointing out the fact that the system integrates cubic nonlinearities. The non dimensional amplitude a (i.e. scaled by the length of the wing L) and phase γ have therefore been extracted from those signals for each pair of wings as a function of the reduced driving frequency for two different amplitudes. Results are displayed in Fig. 4. In parallel, the same experiments have been conducted in a vacuum chamber at 10 % of the ambient pressure. Results are also displayed in Fig. 4 for comparison. 10203000.010.020.030.04f(Hz)FT(N)1015202530350123f(Hz)U(m.s−1)00.5100.511.52¯ωfpt00.510200400600800¯ωfpi(b)(c)(d)nearrigidcase(a)00.020.040.060.08 0.1 0.020.04 t(s)(b)(c)(a)Table 1. Wing properties wing thickness, h (mm) mass per unit area µs (kg.m−2) rigidity B (N.m) relaxation frequency f0 (Hz) color label in figures 0.050 4.50 10−2 3.34.10−5 25.4 blue 0.078 10.63 10−2 1.83.10−4 34.2 red 0.130 17.67 10−2 1.02.10−3 62.2 green 0.175 24.12 10−2 2.26.10−3 89.5 yellow 0.250 34.92 10−2 7.31.10−3 117.1 purple 0.360 47.95 10−2 14.00.10−3 160.8 black 4 As can be seen, the evolution of the amplitude a shows a fast increase from very low flapping frequencies. This is the expected behavior owing to the inertial charac- ter of the forcing. A slight but rather broad peak can be observed in the nearness of ω0/3 in the amplitude curve, confirming the occurrence of the super-harmonic resonance hinted above and strengthening the fact that this type of mechanism may play a role as a strategy for performance enhancement in nature [23]. Two more points have to be underlined: first, measurements in air and vacuum are approximately the same, in accordance with the hypothesis that inertia is the main bending fac- tor for flapping flyers [10 -- 12]. The second point is that no clear resonance is observed around ¯ωf = 1 (only a barely visible peak in the case of the lowest forcing am- plitude shown in the insert in Fig. 4(a)). Concerning the phase γ, the present results recover the trend of what γ increases has been observed recently [9, 13, 14, 16]: monotonically with ¯ωf . Considering the experiments in air at normal conditions, this observation together with the performance increase shown in the first part of the pt(¯ωf ) (Fig. 2 (c)), brings the following conclusion: the increasing phase shift γ, which corresponds to a situation where the wing experiences a larger bending at the max- imal flapping velocity, leads to a more favorable reparti- tion of the aerodynamic forces (as discussed in [12]). A simple argument widely shared in the community con- necting the phase dynamics to the propulsive perfor- mance is: the larger the phase lag is, the best the thrust power would be [13, 14], until the point where the wing experiences its largest bending at γ = π/2. However, while the argument reasonably agrees with the observa- tions in the range of forcing frequencies where perfor- mance increases with ¯ωf , the maximum performance does not actually match with the maximum of bending that occurs at γ = π/2, but relatively far below this expected optimum (which lies actually around π/4). One last important remark to be made concerns the phase evolution in vacuum. It is clearly observed that γ decreases more slowly in the low density environment within the whole range of flapping frequencies studied. In contrast with the amplitude measurements, where the data from the experiments in vacuum follow roughly the same curve of those in air at atmospheric pressure, the large difference in the γ curves between both cases points out unequivocally the importance of the surround- ing fluid in determining the phase dynamics. This point will be discussed later. At this stage, we have shown that, FIG. 4: Evolution of the non-dimensional amplitude a) and phase b) of the trailing edge wing response as a function of the reduced driving frequency for both flapping amplitudes ¯Aω = 0.8 and ¯Aω = 0.5 (filled symbols correspond to measurements in air, open symbols in vacuum). Those results are compared to nonlinear predictions from Eq. 12 with (gray line) and without (black line) nonlinear air drag (discussed further in the text). as observed in the pitching/heaving systems of [13, 14], the increase in performance of elastic wings undergoing large oscillations is essentially governed by a fast grow- ing phase evolution. However, the physical mechanisms governing the propulsive performance remain unclear. In particular, the mechanisms leading to the useful evolu- tion of γ as well as the link between resonance and per- formance are still looking for a definitive answer. NONLINEAR 1D BEAM MODEL In order to understand those crucial points, one can consider the elastic wing as a clamped-free beam under base harmonic forcing. For simplicity, the beam is con- sidered as one-dimensional taken at mid length in the spanwise direction of the wing. We assume here, accord- ing to the experiment, that only flexural displacements (i.e. perpendicular to the direction of the flight motion) are allowed. The structural properties of the beam are determined by measuring experimentally the relaxation frequency. Thus, the equation governing the motion of the non- linear flexural oscillations of clamped-free beam writes [27]: 00.511.500.20.40.60.81a¯ωf0.511.50.20.40.60.800.511.5(cid:239)pi/2(cid:239)pi/40γ(rad)¯ωf(a)(b)EIW (cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48) + µ W = −EI(W (cid:48)W (cid:48)(cid:48)2 + W (cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48)W (cid:48)2)(cid:48) (cid:34) (cid:90) x L − µ 2 W (cid:48) ∂2 ∂t2 (cid:35) (cid:35)(cid:48) (2) W (cid:48)2dx dx (cid:34)(cid:90) x 0 where W is the transversal local displacement, E the Young modulus, I the second moment of inertia and µ the mass per unit of length. Writing W as W (x, t) = w(x, t) + w0(t), where w0(t) is the driving motion defined by w0(t) = Aω cos(ωf t), and using the non-dimensional τ ; with quantities for space and time w = w L ; x = x L; t = t τ =(cid:0) µ EI (cid:1)1/2 L2, equation 2 reads: w(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48) + w = −( w(cid:48) w(cid:48)(cid:48)2 + w(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48) w(cid:48)2)(cid:48) (cid:34) (cid:90) x 1 − 1 2 w(cid:48) ∂2 ∂t2 (cid:34)(cid:90) x 0 (cid:35) (cid:35)(cid:48) − ¯Aω w0(3) w(cid:48)2dx dx which has to satisfy the clamped-free boundary condi- tions w(0, t) = w(cid:48)(0, t) = w(cid:48)(cid:48)(1, t) = w(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48)(1, t) = 0. The last term on the right hand side in Eq. 3, − ¯Aω w0 = 2 cos( ¯ωf t) = Nei cos( ¯ωf t), is a forcing term due to ¯Aω ¯ωf the wing inertia whose amplitude is given by the elasto- inertial number and which is dependent on the square of the driving frequency as seen before. The next step is to set apart the spatial dependence by projection of Eq. 3 onto the complete set of eigenfunc- tons defined by the linear part. The displacement is ex- pended as w(x, t) =(cid:80)∞1 Xp(t)Φp(x) (see [28]) where Φp are the non-dimensional linear modes for clamped-free beams which are not recalled here for the sake of brevity. The problem then writes (the have been removed for simplicity): i,j,k=1 (cid:90) 1 (cid:90) x 0 Φ(cid:48)i hp ijk = (Φ(cid:48)iΦ(cid:48)(cid:48)j Φ(cid:48)(cid:48)k + Φ(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48)i Φ(cid:48)jΦ(cid:48)k)(cid:48)Φpdx (5) (cid:34) (cid:90) 1 0 f p ijk = (cid:90) u (cid:35)(cid:48) Φ(cid:48)j(y)Φ(cid:48)k(y)dydu Φpdx (6) 1 0 The projection of the forcing term on the pth mode, Fp, writes at the trailing edge: Xp + Xp = − N(cid:88) − N(cid:88) i,j,k=1 hp ijkXiXjXk where hp ijk and f p ijk are determined by: ijk(XiXj Xk + Xi Xj Xk) + Fp(t)(4) f p (cid:90) 1 0 Φp(x)dx Fp = ¯Aω ¯ωf 2Φp(1) 5 (7) As the propulsive regimes observed in this work lie be- low the first relaxation frequency of the wing, we assume that the response of the wing is mainly governed by the first eigenmode. Hence, equation 4 can be considerably simplified and reduces for the only mode 1 to: X + X = −h1 111X 3 − f 1 111(X 2 X + X X 2) + F1(t) (8) A crucial feature is now to choose a damping term to this dynamical system. During a stroke cycle, the wing follows very fast motions involving high local Reynolds numbers, which prompt us to include a non- linear quadratic fluid drag term [29] in addition to the classical linear viscous friction law. The damping is then chosen as a combination of linear and nonlinear terms as follows: Ξ(X, X) = ξ X + ξnl X X (9) The linear and nonlinear coefficients ξ and ξnl are estimated studying the impulse response for each wing [26].The solution of Eq. 8 including damping is deter- mined by using a classical multiple scale method at first order (see [26]). To this end, we introduce a small pa- rameter and a detuning parameter σ = ( ¯ωf − 1)/. The problem to be solved reads. X + X = −(h1 + Ξ(X, 111X 3 + f 1 X) + F1(t)) 111(X 2 X + X X 2) (10) According to the multiple scales theory, we express the solution in terms of different time scales as X = X0(t0, t1) + X1(t0, t1) + .... where t0 = t and t1 = t are respectively short (relative to the oscillation of the wing) and long times scales. The system at order 0 is t0X0 + X0 = 0 an gives the straightforward solution ∂2 X0 = A(t1)eit0 + A∗(t1)e−it0 where A and A∗ are com- plex functions. At order 1, we obtain: t0 X1 + X1 = −h1 ∂2 − Ξ(X0, 111X 3 111(X 2 0 X0 + X0 X0 0 − f 1 X0) − 2∂t1t0X0 + F1 cos(t0 + σt1) (11) ) 2 Using the expression of X0 found at order 0 into Eq. 11, an equation for A is obtained by elimination of the secular terms: AA) = 4ξnl 3π 1 2 111−2f 1 A2A∗(3h1 111)+i(2∂t1 A+ξA+ F1eiσt1 (12) where the pre-factor 4 3π in front of the nonlinear damp- ing coefficient is obtained during the special integration over one period of the Fourier expansion of the function X0 X0 (see [26]).As can be seen, Eq. 12 is a charac- teristic equation of a forced damped oscillator with cu- bic nonlinearities. At last, substituting the polar form 2 aei(σt1−γ), separating into real and imaginary parts A = 1 and looking only to the steady-state solutions, we find two relations for the amplitude a and phase γ.[32] (cid:0)Γ1a3 − aσ(cid:1)2 + (ξa + ξnla2)2 = (cid:18) (ξa + 4 4 3π Γ1a3 − aσ F 2 1 4 3π ξnla2) (cid:19) γ = arctan (13) (14) 111 − 2f 1 where Γ1 = 1 coefficient, which is computed from Eq. 5 and 6. 111) is the nonlinear cubic term 8 (3h1 Eq. 14 closely resembles a classic nonlinear Duffing oscillator except that the forcing amplitude is frequency dependent and that a nonlinear damping term is present. ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION Resonance and phase evolution Predictions of the above model for the parameters of the experiments are plotted in Fig. 4 for both cases in air and vacuum. In addition, for a clear understanding of the underlying dynamics described by Eqs. 13 and 14, a comparison between predictions from a linear model, a nonlinear with linear damping and a nonlinear with nonlinear damping is displayed in Fig. 5 for two flapping amplitudes ¯Aω. It can be seen that the model based on a single mode is capable of reproducing all the observations made from the experiments both in normal and low den- sity environments. The good agreement between experi- ments and model allows us to pinpoint some mechanisms underlying the complex mechanisms of flapping flight. The first concerns the question of resonance: from Fig. 5, it can be observed that the only case (apart from the lin- ear case) exhibiting a slight resonance peak corresponds to relatively small flapping amplitude and damping co- efficient [i.e. only linear damping term, see Fig. 5 (a)]. Cases for higher amplitude and/or presence of nonlin- ear damping behave as a non-resonant like system in the range of flapping frequencies studied. In nonlinear oscil- lators, it is known that the main effect of the nonlinear term is to distort the resonance curve and shift the reso- nance peak to higher frequencies (for a hardening coeffi- cient Γ1 > 0, as in the present study) [26]. An important 6 FIG. 5: Dependence of the amplitude a and phase γ with the reduced forcing frequency ¯ωf for the first mode of a clamped-free beam forced by inertia for two different (high and medium) amplitudes Aω (chosen arbitrarily for clarity). The blue line corresponds to the linear prediction, the black line to the non-linear model from Eq 12 with linear damping (ξnl = 0), the red line to the non-linear model with nonlinear damping (ξnl (cid:54)= 0). As can be seen only cases with relatively small flapping amplitude and linear damping can exhibit a slight resonance peak. Greater amplitudes and/or presence of nonlinear damping behave as a non-resonant system in the domain of flyers capabilities. Concerning the phase, models including only linear damping do not produce "useful" phase lag except in the nearness of the phase jump. In contrast, the presence of a nonlinear damping produces a fast and helpful evolution. feature of such nonlinear systems is that the distortion of the shape of the resonance curve is directly dependent on the amplitude of the excitation. In the present case where the forcing is inertial, the response depends on the square of the forcing frequency (or on the elasto-inertial number Nei), which provides an increase of the amplitude plotted in Fig. 4 independent of an intrinsic resonance mecha- nism. Hence, we can expect the actual resonance curve of the system to be all the more distorted that the flap- ping frequency increases. Another feature that makes it difficult for the flapping flyer to benefit from a resonance mechanism is the presence of a geometric saturation due to the finite length of the wing. Always due to the in- ertia effects, this geometrical saturation will be reached all the more soon that the demand for larger amplitude (i.e. better performances) is increased. Coming back to the distorted resonance curve, the visible consequence is that the wing, even for a small nonlinear cubic coefficient, behaves as a system never reaching a peak in the range of frequencies commonly used by flapping flyers. Addi- tionally, the presence of strong damping accentuates this behavior by smoothing the value of a possible resonance peak. This last observation is consistent with the fact that birds or insects may not especially look for struc- 01230123a0123012345a0123(cid:239)3(cid:239)2(cid:239)10¯ωfγ0123(cid:239)3(cid:239)2(cid:239)10¯ωfγAω/L=0.45Aω/L=1.2ξnl=0.4ξnl=0tural resonance to improve their performance. The second point is the crucial role of fluid damping in triggering the phase lag that is useful for thrust en- hancement. For the phase, shifting the resonance peak as a result of the nonlinear spring in the oscillator model means shifting the phase jump at γ = π/2 to higher frequencies as well. Thus, without air drag, as can be seen in Fig. 5 (c) and (d), the nonlinear evolution of the phase γ(¯ωf ) would be even slower than in the linear case for which the phase evolution is already not espe- cially favorable except in the nearness of the resonance. This is exactly what is observed for the vacuum measure- ments where the nonlinear damping due to fluid drag is negligible. On the contrary, the presence of a quadratic fluid damping determines a fast increase of the phase lag (and a so a thrust improvement) even from the very first flapping frequencies. This implies of course that strong flapping velocities are a necessary condition for the bend- ing to become efficient (i.e. elasticity will play a minor role if the flapping beat amplitude is not strong enough). Summarizing, the instantaneous wing shape is given by the two following ingredients: inertia provokes the bend- ing (gives the amplitude) and damping, by controlling the phase lag, allows this bending to be usefully exploited. Large phase lags will provide largest bending of the wing at maximum flapping speed, leading to a more favorable repartition of aerodynamics forces. Optimum Since classic resonance mechanisms cannot answer it, the question of the performance optimum (or the tran- sition to underperformance) remains unclear. We there- fore proceeded to study the kinematics of the wing in the laboratory frame. In particular, we have compared both characteristic angles relative to the global wing motion. The first characteristic angle is dependent on the ratio between the maximal vertical flapping veloc- ity uω = ωAω and the cruising velocity U and reads: φ = arctan(ωAω/U ). φ is considered as the instanta- neous angle of attack of the wing and as can be seen, is directly related to the Strouhal number St = ωAω/U which determines as well the performance of flapping fly- ers [30]. We define a second characteristic angle θ as the trailing-edge angle taken at the maximum flapping velocity. This angle is directly related to the phase lag γ, and thus determines to what extent the bending of the wing will be useful in terms of performance. Fig. 6 shows the evolution of the ratio θ/φ, which is naturally a growing function of ¯ωf because both an increase in θ or a decrease in φ lead to an enhancement of the propulsive performance. The interesting point is that the location of the per- formances/under performances transition takes place at θ/φ = 1 (i.e. when both angles point instantaneously at 7 FIG. 6: Evolution of the two characteristic angles of the wing motion θ and φ as a function of the reduced driving frequency ¯ωf . Two regimes can be distinguished: (I): φ < θ correspond- ing to the performances increasing stage due to a useful phase lag. (II): φ > θ corresponding to the transition to under- performances due to a loss of the effective wing area. The optimum occurs therefore when φ and θ point at the same direction (best phase lag). the same direction). Thus, the optimum value of θ does not corresponds to the maximum bending experienced by the wing (which would be the optimal solution) but to the moment when the deflection angle matches the angle of attack as sketched in Fig. 6. For a rigid wing, because θ is fixed (= 0), the optimization problem is here nonex- istent and thrust only depends on the driving frequency (for a given amplitude). With flexibility and according to what has been previously observed, θ starts increasing and tends to align the wing trailing-edge with the flow. As discussed earlier, this leads to a more favorable repar- tition of the aerodynamics forces as sketched in Fig. 6. However, this argument is only valid if the surrounding flow is totally attached to the wing (i.e. separation oc- curs only at the trailing-edge). A situation where θ > φ is strongly subjected to flow separation before the wing trailing edge. In this case the effective surface relative to the aerodynamic load can be expected to be drastically reduced leading to a loss of aerodynamic performance. It has to be noticed that the value of π/2, or more gener- ally values of phases greater than θopt observed in this experiments should be, theoretically, more optimal (i.e. should give more optimal bending shapes for useful pro- jection of forces). However, if a separation occurs, the corresponding loss of thrust force (and so cruising speed) will accelerate the decoherence of both angles and hence, will provoke the subsidence of the performance, as has been observed on Fig. 2. The more economic strategy to fly is therefore to set θ ≈ φ which corresponds to the optimum way to transfer useful momentum. 0.40.60.811.200.511.5¯ωfθ/φ(II)(I)CONCLUDING REMARKS In this work, we aimed at describing the dynamics gov- erning the performance of flapping flyers. Considering large flapping amplitude and relatively large wings (as for big insect species), we have shown that nonlinear and in- ertia effects, together with geometric limitation, question the prevailing idea that energy-saving strategies in flap- ping flight must be related to resonance mechanisms. In search of improving performances, animals may actually stay below the resonance point. Besides, the nonlinear nature of air drag (which implies sufficiently strong flap- ping amplitudes) seems to be a fundamental ingredient to create the phase lag between the leading and trailing edges of the flapping wing that allows the elasticity en- ergy to be used at its best. One last comment is that the presence of structure resonances for flyers in nature is not invalidated by the mechanism described here. For instance, small insects may not use much elasticity and bending because either their wings are too small or the local Reynolds number is not sufficiently high to produce enough damping, and thus a useful phase lag. However, studies containing a large bank of comparative resonant frequencies and wingbeats of insects or birds being rare in the literature, it is consequently hard to draw any conclu- sion about the existence of two distinct strategies at this state. According to biologists, resonant mechanisms lie at the muscle level more than in the wing structure itself (see [2, 31] and reference therein) which would strengthen that there is no reason, a priori, for flapping flyers to look for structural resonance of the wing. Further analysis on such a way would certainly help to discern if there are, or not, universal characteristics for flapping flyers. The authors are grateful to Daniel Pradal for his help concerning the experimental setup, Cyril Touzé for hav- ing shared his knowledge of nonlinear systems and Sarah Tardy for her careful reading of the manuscript. This work was supported by the French Research Agency through project ANR-08-BLAN-0099. [1] David E. Alexander. Nature's Flyers: Birds, Insects, and the Biomechanics of Flight. The Johns Hopkins Univer- sity Press, 2004. [2] R. Dudley. The Biomechanics of Insect Flight. Princeton University Press, 2000. [3] S Ho, H Nassef, N Pornsinsirirak, YC Tai, and CM Ho. Unsteady aerodynamics and flow control for flapping wing flyers. Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 39(8):635 -- 681, 2003. [4] Wei Shyy, Yongsheng Lian, Jian Tang, Dragos Viieru, and Hao Liu. Aerodynamics of low Reynolds number fly- ers. Cambridge Aerospace Series. Cambridge University Press, 2008. [5] MH Dickinson, FO Lehmann, and SP Sane. Wing rota- tion and the aerodynamic basis of insect flight. Science, 8 [6] ZJ Wang. Dissecting insect flight. Annu. Rev. Fluid 284(5422):1954 -- 1960, 1999. Mech., 37:183 -- 210, 2005. [7] Geoffrey R Spedding and Anders Hedenström. Piv-based investigations of animal flight. Exp Fluids, 46(5):749 -- 763, 2009. [8] J. M. Anderson, K. Streitlien, D. S. Barret, and M. S. Tri- antafyllou. Oscillating foils of high propulsive efficiency. J. Fluid Mech., 360:41 -- 72, 1998. [9] W. Shyy, H. Aono, S.K. Chimakurthi, P. Trizila, C.-K. Kang, C.E.S. Cesnik, and H. Liu. Recent progress in flapping wing aerodynamics and aeroelasticity. Progr. Aerospace Sci., 2010. In press, corrected proof. DOI: 10.1016/j.paerosci.2010.01.001. [10] T. L. Daniel and S. A. Combes. Flexible Wings and Fins: Integr. Bending by Inertial or Fluid-Dynamic Forces? Comp. Biol., 42(5):1044 -- 1049, 2002. [11] S.A. Combes and T.L. Daniel. Into thin air: contribu- tions of aerodynamic and inertial-elastic forces to wing bending in the hawkmoth manduca sexta. J. Exp. Biol., 206:2999 -- 3006, 2003. [12] B. Thiria and R. Godoy-Diana. How wing compliance drives the efficiency of self-propelled flapping flyers. Phys. Rev. E, 82:015303(R), 2010. [13] S. E. Spagnolie, L. Moret, M. J. Shelley, and J. Zhang. Surprising behaviors in flapping locomotion with passive pitching. Phys. Fluids, 22(4):041903, 2010. [14] J. Zhang, L. Nan-Sheng, and L. Xi-Yun. Locomotion of a passively flapping flat plate. j. fluid mech. in press. J. Fluid Mech., 659:43 -- 68, 2010. [15] C.H. Greenewalt. The wings of insects and birds as me- chanical oscillators. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., 104:605 -- 611, 1960. [16] H. Masoud and A. Alexeev. Resonance of flexible wings at low Reynolds number. Phys. Rev. E, 81:056304, 2010. [17] S. Michelin and S. G. Llewellyn Smith. Resonance and propulsion performance of a heaving flexible wing. Phys. Fluids, 21(7):071902, 2009. [18] J. H. Long and K. S. Nipper. The importance of body stiffness in undulatory propulsion. Amer. Zool., 36:678 -- 694, 1996. [19] S. Sunada, L. Zeng, and K. Kawachi. The relationship between dragonfly wing stricture and torsional deforma- tion. J. Theor. Biol., 193:39 -- 45, 1998. [20] S. Sunada and et al. Optical measurement of the de- formation motion, and generated force of the wings of a moth, mythimna separa (walker). JSME International Journal Series B, 45:836 -- 842, 2002. [21] M. Nakamura, A. Iida, and A. Mizuno. Visualization of three-dimensional vortex structures around a dragonfly with dynamic piv. J. Visualization, 10:159 -- 160, 2007. [22] J. S. Chen, J.-Y. Chen, and Y.-F. Chou. On the natu- ral frequencies and mode shapes of dragonfliy wings. J. Sound Vib., 313:643 -- 654, 2008. [23] M. Vanella, T. Fitzgerald, S. Preidikman, E. Balaras, and B. Balachandran. Influence of flexibility on the aero- dynamic performance of a hovering wing. J. Exp. Biol., 212(1):95 -- 105, Jan 2009. [24] Antoine Magnan. La locomotion chez les animaux: I-Le vol des insectes. Hermann & Cie., 1934. [25] N. Vandenberghe, J. Zhang, and S. Childress. Symmetry breaking leads to forward flapping flight. J. Fluid Mech., 506:147 -- 155, 2004. [26] A.H. Nayfeh and D.T. Mook. Nonlinear oscillations. John Wiley & sons, New-York, 1979. [27] M.R.M Crespo Da Silva and C.C. Glynn. Nonlin- ear flexural-flexurale-torsional dynamics of inextensional beams. II. Forced Motions. J. Struct. Mech., 6:449 -- 461, 1978. [28] A.H. Nayfeh. Method of Normal Forms. John Wiley & [30] G. K. Taylor, R. L. Nudds, and A. L. R. Thomas. Flying and swimming animals cruise at a strouhal number tuned for high power efficiency. Nature, 425:707 -- 711, 2003. [31] P. W. Willmott and C. P. Ellington. The mechanics of [29] D. J. Tritton. Physical Fluid Dynamics. Oxford Univer- sons, New-York, 1993. sity Press, 1988. 9 flight in the hawkmoth manduca sexta. J. Exp. Biol., 200:2705 -- 2722, 1997. [32] It has to be noted that the linear damping term aξ cor- responds to structural damping (and viscous fluid damp- ing relative to very small displacements) and is therefore mainly dependent on the only displacement X (i.e. in the 3π ξnla2 is strongly dependent wing frame). In contrast, 4 on the global motion of the wing and has therefore to be estimated in the laboratory frame. Thus, at first or- der, a reasonable corrected approximation for this term is 4 3π ξnl(a + Aω)2.
1703.03926	1	1703	2017-03-11T07:48:34	Osmotaxis in Escherichia coli through changes in motor speed	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	Bacterial motility, and in particular repulsion or attraction towards specific chemicals, has been a subject of investigation for over 100 years, resulting in detailed understanding of bacterial chemotaxis and the corresponding sensory network in many bacterial species. For Escherichia coli most of the current understanding comes from the experiments with low levels of chemotactically-active ligands. However, chemotactically-inactive chemical species at concentrations found in the human gastrointestinal tract produce significant changes in E. coli's osmotic pressure, and have been shown to lead to taxis. To understand how these nonspecific physical signals influence motility, we look at the response of individual bacterial flagellar motors under step-wise changes in external osmolarity. We combine these measurements with a population swimming assay under the same conditions. Unlike for chemotactic response, a long-term increase in swimming/motor speeds is observed, and in the motor rotational bias, both of which scale with the osmotic shock magnitude. We discuss how the speed changes we observe can lead to steady state bacterial accumulation.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Osmotaxis in Escherichia coli through changes in motor speed Jerko Rosko1, Vincent Martinez2, Wilson Poon2 and Teuta Pilizota1 March 14, 2017 1 Centre for Synthetic and Systems Biology, Institute of Cell Biology, School of Biological Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Alexander Crum Brown Road, EH9 3FF, Edinburgh, UK 2 Scottish Universities Physics Alliance and School of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Edinburgh, JCMB, Peter Guthrie Tait Road, Edinburgh EH9 3FD Abstract Bacterial motility, and in particular repulsion or attraction towards specific chemicals, has been a subject of investigation for over 100 years, resulting in detailed understanding of bacterial chemotaxis and the corresponding sensory network in many bacterial species. For Escherichia coli most of the current understanding comes from the experiments with low levels of chemotactically-active ligands. However, chemotactically-inactive chemical species at con- centrations found in the human gastrointestinal tract produce significant changes in E. coli's osmotic pressure, and have been shown to lead to taxis. To understand how these nonspecific physical signals influence motility, we look at the response of individual bacterial flagellar motors under step-wise changes in external osmolarity. We combine these measurements with a population swimming assay under the same conditions. Unlike for chemotactic response, a long term increase in swimming/motor speeds is observed, and in the motor rotational bias, both of which scale with the osmotic shock magnitude. We discuss how the speed changes we observe can lead to steady state bacterial accumulation. Introduction 1 Many bacterial species are not only able to self propel (exhibit motility), but also direct their motion towards more favorable environments. This behavior, called taxis [Krell et al., 2011, Pur- cell, 1977], has long been a subject of scientific investigation, as it serves a variety of purposes: seeking out nutrients and avoiding toxic substances [Wadhams and Armitage, 2004, Adler, 1969], identifying thermal [Paster and Ryu, 2007] and oxygen [Adler et al., 2012] gradients, as well as aid- ing pathogenic species in infecting their hosts [Rivera-Chávez et al., 2013, Cullender et al., 2013]. The understanding of bacterial taxis is not only important when it comes to bacterial motility and accumulation; it also serves as a model for biological signal processing. Of particular interest are the precision [Segal et al., 1986, Neumann et al., 2014], sensitivity [Cluzel et al., 2000] and robustness [Yuan et al., 2012,Lele et al., 2012] that can be achieved with biological networks, and potentially utilized for human design purposes [Navlakha and Bar-Joseph, 2014, Babaoglu et al., 2006]. Specifically, bacterial chemotaxis, motion towards or away from specific chemicals [Wad- hams and Armitage, 2004], was first described over 120 years ago [Massart, 1889]. Since then, the systematic research efforts made it one of the best-studied topics in biology, especially when it comes to Escherichia coli. E. coli swims by rotating a bundle of flagellar filaments [Berg, 1973, Turner et al., 2000], each powered by a bacterial flagellar motor (BFM), a rotary nano-machine that spins in the clockwise (CW) or counter-clockwise (CCW) direction [Sowa and Berry, 2008]. Each bacterium possesses several individual motors randomly distributed along the cell body [Tang and Blair, 1995, Turner et al., 2000], which when rotating CCW enable formation of a stable filament bundle that propels the cell forward [Berg, 2003]. When one or, most likely, a few motors switch to CW rotation, their respective filaments fall out of the bundle, leading to a tumble event [Turner et al., 2000]. Forward swimming, likely in a different direction due to Brownian rotation of the bacterial cell during the tumble event, resumes when motors switch back to CCW direction and the bundle reforms [Berg, 1973, Turner et al., 2000]. 1 The probability of switching increases with the intracellular concentration of phosphorylated CheY protein (CheY-P) that interacts with the rotor of the BFM [Welch et al., 1993]. CheY-P is a part of a feedback control circuit, the chemotactic network [Wadhams and Armitage, 2004], which relays outside information to the motor and allows E. coli to direct its motion. Inputs of the circuit are the methyl-accepting chemotactic proteins (MCPs), transmembrane proteins that bind specific ligands in the cell exterior [Wadhams and Armitage, 2004], and through a signaling cascade affect the CheY-P to CheY ratio. When sensing attractants or repellents in µM range, the change in CheY-P to CheY ratio resets to the initial level within seconds, a characteristic feature of the network termed perfect adaptation [Block et al., 1982]. Thus, directionality in the net motion of the cell arises through transient tuning of motor switching frequency in response to external stimuli [Wadhams and Armitage, 2004]. The majority of work on E. coli chemotaxis over the last 40 years has been performed in a minimal phosphate buffer (termed Motility Buffer [Ryu et al., 2000]). However, one of the primary habitats of E. coli is the gastrointestinal tract of humans and other warm-blooded animals [Berg, 1996, Gordon and Cowling, 2003]. This complex environment features not only various chemoattractants and repellents, but also spatial and temporal changes in osmolarity [Fordtran and Locklear, 1966,Datta et al., 2016,Begley et al., 2005], which, in the stomach and small intestine of humans, reach up to 400 mOsmol. The exact composition and osmolarity depend on the meal, ingestion history and location within the gastrointestinal tract [Fordtran and Locklear, 1966]. Sudden osmotic increases, termed hyperosmotic shocks or upshocks, cause cell volume shrinkage and require solute pumping and/or synthesis to re-inflate the cell and re-establish osmotic pressure [Wood, 2015, Pilizota and Shaevitz, 2012]. Non-specific spatial taxis away from sources of high concentrations, termed osmotaxis, has been observed in agar plates [Li et al., 1988]. Osmotic stimuli can also send a signal down the network through mechanical stimulation of chemoreceptors [Vaknin and Berg, 2006]; yet, osmotaxis was observed in gutted mutants lacking all chemotactic network components [Li and Adler, 1993]. To clarify the exact nature of osmotactic response, we study the phenomenon on both single cell and population levels, observing the rotation of individual flagellar motors under stepwise increases in osmolarity, and measuring the swimming speeds of a population of ∼ 10000 bacteria after exposure to an osmotic shock. The shock magnitudes we administer mimic those encountered in the human gastrointestinal tract [Fordtran and Locklear, 1966]. We find that a stepwise increase in osmolarity results in an elevated CCW-CW switching frequency that scales with the shock magnitude. In addition, we observe osmokinesis post osmotic shock, i.e. significant changes in the motor, and consequently, swimming speeds of bacteria. Lastly, for higher shock magnitudes, we observe a loss of motor speed immediately post shock, followed by a transient, attractant-like response that is coupled with a speed recovery. We discuss how the observed non-adaptive response and osmokinesis can lead to taxis. 2 Results 2.1 Single motor response to an osmotic shock is complex We begin with the reasonable assumption that at least one component of the chemotactic network responds to an osmotic stimulus in order to generate previously observed osmotactic behavior [Li et al., 1988]. Then, the response should be evident in the output of the chemotactic network, the Clock-Wise (CW) bias of a single BFM. CW bias is defined as the fraction of time the BFM spends rotating in the clockwise direction [Bai et al., 2010]: CW Bias = Ncw Ntot (1) where Ncw is the number of data points corresponding to CW rotation and Ntot is the total number of data points in a given time interval. To compute the CW Bias, we measured the speed of an individual BFM when exposed to a step-wise increase in the external osmolarity. SI Appendix Fig. 5 gives a schematic of the bead assay used for measuring the motor speed [Ryu et al., 2000,Bai et al., 2010]. Briefly, we attach cells to the cover slip and attach a latex bead, 0.5 µm in diameter, to a short filament stub [Ryu et al., 2000, Bai et al., 2010]. The rotation of the BFM-driven bead is recorded using back-focal-plane interferometry at a 10 kHz sampling rate [Pilizota et al., 2007, Denk and Webb, 1990, Svoboda 2 et al., 1993]. A representative single-motor rotation trace so obtained is shown in Fig. 1A. The shaded light blue interval shows the motor speed and rotational direction prior to osmotic stimulus. Positive motor speed values represent CCW rotation and negative CW. Fig. 1B shows the histogram of the CW Bias obtained from the motor speed trace in A (Methods). Prior to the stimulus, the motor switches from CCW to CW rotation ∼ 4 times per minute at CW Bias = 0.07, agreeing with previous studies [Bai et al., 2010, Bai et al., 2013]. At t = 5min, the extracellular osmolarity is elevated by delivering 400 mM sucrose, at a local flow rate of 0.68 µl/min [Buda et al., 2016], causing an osmotic upshock of 488 mOsmol/kg. Immediately upon upshock, the motor stops switching rotational direction and speed drops. Then, a recovery phase begins (Fig. 1A and B, non-shaded time interval) with the motor speed gradually increasing while switching is absent. Post-recovery phase, which we define as the period after motor switching has resumed, is characterized by an increased switching frequency. Consequentially, the CW Bias is also elevated (to 0.16), and is maintained over at least 20 min, suggesting that, unlike chemotaxis, the osmotactic response does not exhibit perfect adaptation [Segal et al., 1986, Block et al., 1982]. The color map at the bottom of Fig. 1B is a compact representation of the histogram in Fig. 1B. To determine if CheY-P is necessary for the osmotic response observed in Fig. 1A and B, we performed single-motor measurements on a strain lacking CheY (∆CheY mutant [Berg and Turner, 1993, Fahren, 1995]). A representative trace is shown in Fig. 1C. The Recovery Phase of the ∆CheY mutant is the same as observed in Fig. 1A for the chemotactic wild type. However, the Post-recovery Phase of the mutant shows no switching events, indicating that CheY-P is necessary for the elevated bias observed in Fig. 1A and B. 2.2 Osmotactic response does not exhibit perfect adaptation We analyzed 69 cells exposed to three up-shock magnitudes to confirm the absence of perfect adaptation observed in Post-recovery Phase (Fig. 1A and B). Up-shocks were delivered as in Fig. 1, by exchanging VR Buffer (Methods) with the same buffer supplemented with 100, 200 and 400 mM sucrose, corresponding to osmotic shocks of 111, 230 and 488 mOsmol/kg (similar to osmolalities found in the small intestine [Fordtran and Locklear, 1966], see also SI Appendix for osmolality measurements of all our buffers). Fig. 2A shows color map histograms of each individual single-motor bias trace, where darker color represents higher CW Bias and white represents smooth swimming. The Recovery Phase, characterized by motor speed recovery and zero CW Bias period, scales with the shock magnitude. SI Appendix Fig. 6 A shows the duration of the Recovery Phase, Trec,CW , against the shock magnitude, where for the highest shock administered Trec,CW ∼5 min. The length of the Recovery Phase roughly corresponds to the time E. coli takes to recover its volume and osmotic pressure upon the hyperosmotic shock [Pilizota and Shaevitz, 2014]. Throughout the Post-Recovery Phase, CW Bias levels do not, on average, relax to their initial pre-shock values. In our measurements this phase lasts for ∼ 10-20 min, which is significantly longer than chemotactic adaptation times [Segal et al., 1986] even when saturating attractant concentrations are used [Berg and Tedesco, 1975]. Evidence for this assertion is shown in the CW Bias histograms in Fig. 2B, which shows a distribution computed from 5 min recordings in VR Buffer prior to shock, and Fig. 2C, which shows a distribution computed from 3 min intervals taken at various time points, 12 or more minutes after shock with 200 mM sucrose. Total of 120 single-motor recordings were used for the pre-shock condition and 96 for after. The median value of the population CW Bias shifts from 0.01 pre-shock to 0.06 after addition of 200 mM sucrose. Fig. 2D shows the median CW Bias in time for each of the three different shocks, calculated from the raw speeds of individual cells presented in Fig. 2A, using a 60 s wide moving window. Here, only medians are shown for clarity and the means, together with the interquartile range for each shock magnitude, are plotted in SI Appendix Fig. 6 B-D. While the CW Bias shows some recovery in time, in particular for 111 mOsmol/kg and 230 mOsmol/kg shocks, it proceeds on a slow time scale and the median values at the end of our measurement time remain elevated with respect to the initial value. A further corroboration of long-term increase in CW Bias post osmotic shock comes from separating the CW Bias values of Fig. 2B according to the time point at which they were measured, relative to the administration of the osmotic shock (t=0). This is displayed in the inset of Fig. 2B and shows that the elevated CW Bias persists over a time scale as long as 1 h. 3 Figure 1: (A) An example 30 min speed trace obtained from a single BFM. The cell was initially in VR Buffer (Methods), indicated in shaded light blue, and exposed to an osmotic upshock of 488 mOsmol/kg at t=5 min. The shock was delivered as a step increase by flowing in VRB containing additional 400 mM Sucrose, resulting in shock magnitude of 488 mOsmol/kg. (B) A histogram of clockwise bias computed by binning the trace in Fig. 1A into 30 second bins and dividing the time spent rotating clockwise by the bin length (see also equation 1 and Methods). Below is the same histogram condensed into a color map, with an intensity scale to the right. (C) Single-motor speed trace of a ∆CheY mutant exposed to the same osmotic upshock as in Fig. 1A. 4 Figure 2: (A) Stacked single cell color maps (histograms) of CW Bias for three different shock magnitudes (indicated on the left). Bin widths are 30 s. VR Buffer was exchanged for the same buffer with the addition of sucrose at t=5 min. The white hatched column represents the period of the media exchanged whose duration was ∼10-15 s. 22, 24 and 23 cells are given for the 111, 230 and 488 mOsmol/kg condition, respectively. Color map scale is given at the top. (B) Histogram of CW Bias for cells prior to osmotic upshock (in VR Buffer) and (C) post osmotic upshock, administered by exchanging VRB with VRB + 200 mM sucrose. Bin width is set to 0.020. Total of 120 motors (each on a different cell) were used to construct Fig. 2B and 96 motors for Fig. 2C. Inset in Fig. 2C plots these 96 single motor biases against the time after their respective osmotic upshift. Gray shading represents the range between 25th and 75th percentile of the CW bias distribution in VR Buffer given in B. (D) Median population CW Bias in time, computed from cells given in Fig. 2A, for different shock magnitudes: 111 mOsmol/kg (red), 230 mOsmol/kg (green) and 488 mOsmol/kg (dark blue). Black arrow indicates the time at which hyperosmotic shock was administered. 5 00.570.27CW Bias111230Osmotic upshift [mOsmol/kg]488ACDB+111 mOsmol/kg+230 mOsmol/kg+488 mOsmol/kg2.3 Osmotic response shows osmokinesis, i.e. changes in motor speed The response to an osmotic upshock includes not only CW Bias dynamics, but also changes in motor and free-swimming speed. Fig. 3A shows a color map plot of normalized single-motor speeds of the same 69 cells presented in Fig. 2A. All cells were originally in VR Buffer and subsequently exposed to an osmotic upshock using 100, 200 or 400 mM sucrose, corresponding to upshifts of 111, 230 and 488 mOsmol/kg. BFM speeds were normalized with respect to the initial speed of each motor, i.e. to the average value of the first 15 seconds of the recording. Following the osmotic upshock, motors show two kinds of behavior. If a shock is of a large magnitude, such as 488 mOsmol/kg, the speed drops sharply and significantly, with a phase of speed recovery that follows. As can be seen from Fig. 3A and B the speed recovery (Trec,ω) lasts ∼4.4 min on average (5.2 min median). Additionally, this is of similar magnitude as Trec,CW (5.4 min mean, 5.0 min median, SI Appendix Fig. 6) and likely corresponds to the period of post-hyperosmotic shock volume recovery [Pilizota and Shaevitz, 2014]. After recovery, the speed increase continues, leading to elevated levels compared to the pre-shock values, Fig. 3C. Weaker upshocks, 111 and 230 mOsmol/kg, are characterized by an increase in motor speed without a significant speed drop, as seen in Fig. 3A-C. The 0 mOsmol/kg condition is a buffer to buffer control flush, where we used the same shocking protocol as for osmotic upshocks. To explore the population-level significance of our observation of osmokinesis in single cells, we next performed Differential Dynamic Microscopy (DDM) (see Methods) [Wilson et al., 2011, Martinez et al., 2012]. DDM is a fast, high-throughput method for measuring the distribution of swimming speeds in populations of a range of different self-propelled particles, averaging over up to ∼ 104 particles at the same time. The technique is well suited for rapid scanning of parameter space, so that it also allowed us to extend the range of external osmolarities studied. DDM characterizes the motility of a population of particles (in our case E. coli) by analyzing the statistics of temporal fluctuations of pixel intensities in a sequence of low-optical resolution microscopy images, where the intensity fluctuations are caused by the variation in number density of particles. Specifically, we measure the differential image correlation function (DICF), which is effectively a power spectrum of the difference between two images taken at separate time points [Wilson et al., 2011,Martinez et al., 2012]. If a theoretical motility model exists, such as in the case of E. coli [Berg, 2003], the expected DICF can be calculated and fitted to experimental data [Wilson et al., 2011], allowing accurate estimates of the distribution of free-swimming speeds of a large number of bacteria [Martinez et al., 2012]. Prior to DDM measurements cells were kept in VRB and osmotically shocked in a microfuge tube. Upon the upshock cells were quickly placed into a capillary for DDM measurements and the capillary was sealed, resulting in a fixed amount of oxygen present during the experiment. Swimming speed recordings commenced within 2 min after the upshock (Methods) and are shown in Fig. 3D. The gradual decrease of swimming speed with time observed in Fig. 3D for all magnitudes of osmotic upshocks was previously characterized in Motility Buffer, where E. coli maintains Proton Motive Force (PMF) using endogenous energy sources [Dawes and Ribbons, 1965, Schwarz-Linek et al., 2016]. At fixed buffer composition, the time it takes to consume all available oxygen is inversely proportional to the cell concentration, and upon oxygen exhaustion a sudden 'crash' in swimming speed occurs [Schwarz-Linek et al., 2016]. Interestingly, we do not see such a 'crash' in swimming speed for the lowest five values of the imposed upshock, but do see a 'crash' when the upshock is at the highest value of 785 mOsmol/kg. Since the cell concentration is fixed, this implies that cells consume oxygen at a significantly higher rate at the highest osmotic shock. The increase in BFM speed observed in single cells, Fig. 3A, translates to an increase in popu- lation swimming speed with increasing upshock magnitudes, Fig. 3D. Similarly, in agreement with Fig. 3A, for high shock magnitudes, in particular for 473 mOsm/kg and 785 mOsm/kg sucrose upshocks, a sharp speed drop is observed immediately upon upshock. We also see a Recovery Phase, with duration increasing with the shock magnitude. Increasing sucrose concentrations results in the increased viscosity of the media, consequently increasing the drag coefficient on the motor (measured values of viscosity of our solutions are given in SI Appendix). In Fig. 3 we show BFM speeds and cell swimming speeds uncorrected for this effect, as the actual speed of the cell will be relevant for taxis and effective diffusivity. The viscosity corrected BFM speeds, calculated under the assumption that the motor torque does not change with the increasing viscosity, are shown in SI Appendix Fig. 8. Furthermore, we check for the presence of steps during single motor speed recovery. To that end, in SI Appendix Fig. 9 we show examples of BFM speeds during the Recovery Phase after 6 Figure 3: (A) Stacked single-motor (also single-cell) speed histograms, where the motor speed for each BFM is normalized to the average value of the first 15 s. Bin widths are 15 s and the color represents the bin height. Results are grouped by upshock magnitude, as indicated on the left hand edge. The white hatched column represents the point where an osmotic shock was performed by exchanging VR Buffer for VR Buffer + sucrose and the flow lasted for 10-15 s. 22, 24 and 23 cells are given for the 111, 230 and 488 mOsmol/kg conditions, respectively. The color map scale is given at the top of the figure. (B) Time necessary to recover the average value of pre-shock speed. Red horizontal bars are mean, and yellow triangles are median values, and the graph contains 18, 22, 23 and 20 single motor data points for the 0, 111, 230 and 488 mOsmol/kg upshocks. One value for the 230 mOsmol/kg condition and three for the 488 mOsmol/kg have been excluded from the graph as these motors do not recover average initial speed in the course of recording. The 0 mOsmol/kg condition is a buffer to buffer control flush. (C) Single motor speeds calculated as 3 min averages corresponding to a section between t=17 and t=20 min in A. The graph contains 12, 22, 24 and 23 single motor data points for the 0, 111, 230 and 488 mOsmol/kg upshocks. The 0 mOsmol/kg condition contains 12 out of 18 control flushes that were at least 20 min long. (D) DDM measurement of swimming speeds following an osmotic shock. Cells were shocked in microfuge tubes and brought into a microscope within 2 minutes. The legend shows shock magnitudes and the mean speed is the average of swimming speeds obtained for each time point in a range of different length scales (Methods). The systematic error of our measurements is then calculated as the standard deviation of the mean, and falls within ∼ 5% of the mean value. Here it was not plotted for clarity. 7 DNormalized motor speed051015202530Time [min]111230488 Osmotic upshift [mOsmol/kg]00.81.64365110215473785A2.4CBω17-20 [Hz]mOsmol/kgΔ[∙102mOsmol/kg]Δ[∙102mOsmol/kg]Trec,ω488 mOsmol/kg upshock, starting just after the osmotic shock was administered. Majority of the traces do not show obvious steps during the BFM speed Recovery Phase. 3 Discussion 3.1 Origins of osmotaxis With no external stimuli E.coli swims in an almost straight line and re-orients every so often in a nearly-random fashion, performing a random walk with an effective diffusion constant D ∼ v2/α [Schnitzer, 1993,Tailleur and Cates, 2008], where v is the swimming speed and α the tumbling rate given by 3(1 − cos φ0)(τrun + τt) α = (2) with τrun mean run time, φ0 (cid:118) 71◦ mean reorientation angle following a tumble, and τt the τ 2 run duration of the tumble event [Schnitzer, 1993, Lovely and Dahlquist, 1975]. Upon sensing a sudden increase in attractant concentration, E. coli sharply elevates the CCW bias for ∼ 1 s and then slightly lowers it for ∼ 3 s, returning to the prestimulus level in ∼ 4 s [Block et al., 1982]. It is this characteristic impulse response of modulating the tumbling rate that allows E. coli to navigate towards a favorable environment. The detailed chemotactic performance and its origins have often been studied [Schnitzer, 1993,Clark and Grant, 2005,de Gennes, 2004,Strong et al., 1998, Cates, 2012, Schnitzer et al., 1990, Celani and Vergassola, 2010]. The observation that a chemotactic mutant of E. coli (CheRCheB) lacking normal methylation and demetylation enzymes does not show chemotactic accumulation, but does respond to raised attractant concentrations by lowering the tumble rate without adaptation [Block et al., 1982,Segal et al., 1986] lead researchers to calculate the consequences of spatially varying α(x) and v(x) on steady state bacterial density [Schnitzer, 1993, Schnitzer et al., 1990]. Similar calculations were performed for particles with v and α dependent on the local density [Tailleur and Cates, 2008], or when studying diffusion of bacteria in porous media [Licata et al., 2016]. These calculations offer possible explanations for previously observed osmotaxis, given the characteristic speed and bias response we here observed. If we assume the simplest scenario, where there is no directional dependency of α(x) and v(x); the steady state E. coli density will be inversely proportional to its swimming speed [Tailleur and Cates, 2008]: ρ(x) ∼ 1 v(x) (3) In Fig. 3C we show motor speeds, ω, and in Fig. 4 mean CCW motor interval (τ CCW ) and tumbling rate (α) at a given osmolality. The ω and τ CCW were obtained from the last 3 min of the post-osmotic shock recordings presented in Fig. 3A, which represent the long term osmolarity dependent changes. We then calculated α from τ CCW and τ CW (Fig. 4 and SI Appendix Fig. 10) using equation 2. The assumption was made that swimming speed v and the mean run time τ run are proportional to the motor speed ω and the mean CCW interval τ CCW , in agreement with previous studies [Magariyama et al., 1995], and our own DDM and motor measurements given in Fig. 3. Thus, based on experimental results we present here and previous theoretical calculations (equa- tion 3 [Tailleur and Cates, 2008, Schnitzer, 1993]) we would expect accumulation at lower osmo- larities, equivalent to negative taxis previously observed [Li et al., 1988]. The changes in tumbling rates suggest differences in the time dependent approach to steady state, but not the steady state density distribution itself [Schnitzer, 1993, Schnitzer et al., 1990]. The theoretical calculations we refer to make the assumption that spatial gradients of v(x) and α(x) are small [Tailleur and Cates, 2008, Schnitzer, 1993], such that we do not expect local gradients in steady state bacterial densities. For steeper osmotic gradients we expect a more complex osmotactic response, in particular since the Recovery Phases shown in Fig. 2 and Fig. 3 will no longer be vanishingly short, as we assumed above, which could explain some previous contradictory osmotactic observations [Li and Adler, 1993]. Our assumption that α(x) and v(x) lack directional dependence in the case of osmotaxis, could be satisfied if the observed changes in α are not due to signaling within the chemotactic network, but 8 Figure 4: Mean counter clockwise motor interval, corresponding to cell runs, as a function of osmotic upshift. The "0" condition box contains 96 mean run intervals, calculated by averaging interval lengths over 5 min before osmotic upshift. Subsequent conditions, osmotic upshifts of 111, 230 and 488 mOsmol/kg, contain 21, 20 and 22 single-motor values calculated by averaging interval lengths over the time span from t=12 min to t=15 min after an osmotic shock. Not all cells were used to obtain τ CCW as note all cells had bound CCW intervals (see SI Appendix Fig. 11). In the inset, we calculate the tumbling rate α according to equation 2, approximating the run times with ¯τccw and tumble times with ¯τcw given in SI Appendix Fig. 10. 9 purely due to changes in the interaction of CheY-P with the rotor units of the motor. For example, previous observations indicate that at higher external osmolarities, osmotic pressure is kept the same [Pilizota and Shaevitz, 2014]. Thus, the crowding in an already crowded cytoplasm [Parry et al., 2014] increases, which can affect cytoplasmic interactions [Klumpp et al., 2013, Paudel and Rueda, 2014] and the binding of CheY-P to the BFM, perhaps in a similar fashion to that observed at higher hydrostatic pressures [Nishiyama et al., 2013]. However, it is also possible that the observed changes in τ CCW and ω are a consequence of signal processing by the chemotactic network. In particular, Vaknin et al. reported that osmotically induced changes in cell volume can perturb the chemoreceptors, and that the signal could travel down some of the network components [Vaknin and Berg, 2006]. In such a scenario, α(x) and v(x) would be directionally dependent (as in chemotactic response) and steady-state cell density would need to be calculated taking into account the directional dependency as well as the characteristic signal response we observed. Future work needs to investigate strains lacking specific parts of the network to determine the contribution of signaling and different components of the network to the osmotactic response. 3.2 Origins of osmokinesis The large increase in motor speed post osmotic shock could be due to increases in PMF, possibly through alterations in cell metabolism; or, as an alternative explanation, due to the increase in number of stator units through mechanosensation [Lele et al., 2013,Tipping et al., 2013] or adaptive motor remodeling [Yuan et al., 2012]. The BFM has been shown to act as a mechanosensor, increasing the number of stator units in response to higher loads [Lele et al., 2013, Tipping et al., 2013]. As the viscosity of the medium rises with addition of sucrose, the speed increase we observed could be due to the incorporation of additional stator units. In fact, at higher loads, an increase in the mean CW interval has been reported as well [Fahrner et al., 2003,Lele et al., 2013]. At our load, a 0.5 µm bead attached to the motor via a short filament stub, the motor is still expected to operate in the high-load, 'plateau' region of the torque-speed curve [Inoue et al., 2008, Lo, 2007] with the estimated full stator number [Lo, 2007]. In addition, we observe an average 30 Hz increase in motor-speeds even at our lowest osmotic shocks where the viscosity of the solution hardly changes (it increases by 1.057 times) and even free-swimming cells with the motor operating in the linear- torque regime do not increase the swimming speed at viscosity we use in our experiments [Martinez et al., 2014]. Therefore, it is less likely that additional stator incorporation or adaptive motor remodeling are sole explanations for the speed increases we observe. SI Appendix Fig. 9 shows the motor speeds during the speed recovery phase for all of the BFMs recorded in the +488 mOsmol/kg condition. In majority of the traces no obvious steps are observed, suggesting that the increase in motor speed could be due to the increase in PMF with full set of stators present. Here we note that stator engagement with the rotor has been reported as torque dependent [Tipping et al., 2013], where in absence of torque (motor rotation) stators disengage from the rotor. We would then expect stator resurrection during the Recovery Phase shown in SI Appendix Fig. 9. Absence of obvious step-wise increases indicates that volume shrinkage caused by the osmotic shock could affect motor dynamics and perhaps prevent, or slow down, stator disengagement. The length of the motor Recovery Phase observed in Fig. 2 and 3 is ∼5-15 min, in line with the volume recovery timescales observed previously post osmotic upshocks [Pilizota and Shaevitz, 2012, Pilizota and Shaevitz, 2014]. The timescales of speed recovery (at similar shock magni- tudes) observed from DDM data in Fig. 3D are longer, with recovery lasting ∼40 min for the 473 mOsmol/kg upshock. Some variation in these times scales can be due to the difference be- tween individual motor speed recovery and subsequent bundle formation. However, based on Fig. 3D, we suspect that greater contribution to the difference comes from alterations in oxygen consumption rate, which in turn shifts the time it takes to reach the maximum swimming speeds. By looking at individual BFMs and population swimming speeds together, we reveal the main characteristics of E. coli's motility response to step increases in external osmolarity. The response consists of long term CW Bias and motor rotation/cell swimming speed increase. This is the first observation of chemokinesis (osmokinesis) in E. coli. We discuss how such observed speed increases can lead to negative taxis previously reported. Our study emphasizes the importance of investigating bacterial motility in environments that mimic natural habitats, in the effort to 10 understand the role and evolutionary advantage swimming offers to bacterial cells [Lackraj et al., 2016, Gauger et al., 2007, Tamar et al., 2016]. 4 materials 4.1 E. coli strains and plasmids E. coli strains KAF84 and KAF95 [Berg and Turner, 1993] were used for BFM speed and bias, and MG1655 [Blattner et al., 1997] for DDM experiments. Both KAF84 and KAF 95 carry the fliC726 allele, (produce nonflagellate phenotypes), and contain a plasmid carrying an ampicillin resistance and a fliC sticky gene (produces flagellar fillaments that stick readily to surfaces). Additionally, KAF84 is a chemotactic wild type and KAF95 is a ∆CheY strain and therefore can not perform chemotaxis, producing a smooth swimmer phenotype. MG1655 is a K-12 strain and a chemotactic wild type. 4.2 E. coli Growth and culturing KAF95, KAF84 and MG1655 cells were grown in Tryptone Broth (1% Bacto tryptone, 0.5% NaCl) at 30◦C while shaken at 200 RPM [Bai et al., 2010, Martinez et al., 2012]. KAF95 and KAF84 were supplemented with 100 µg/ml of ampicillin and grown to OD=0.8-1.0 (Spectronic 200E Spec- trophotometer, Thermo Scientific, USA), and MG1655 to OD=0.6. After growth cells were washed into VR buffer (Volume Recovery) composed of the Modified Motility Buffer (MMB), which is 10 mM sodium phosphate buffer, pH=7.1 (an aqueous solution with 6.1mM of Na2HPO4, 3.9 mM of NaH2PO4) and 0.01 mM of Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), with added Glycine Betaine, Potassium Chloride and Choline Chloride to final concentrations of 10, 20 and 10 mM, respectively. These compounds act as osmoprotectants and allow the cell to recover volume after an osmotic shock. MMB is a variant of the Motility Buffer, commonly used in flagellar motor and chemotaxis experiments [Ryu et al., 2000,Bai et al., 2010], with sodium phosphates substituted for potassium phosphates. After washing, all the experiments were performed in VR buffer. KAF95 and KAF84 cells were washed by centrifuging them into a pellet and exchanging solution, while MG1655 cells were washed by gentle filtration to preserve filaments [Schwarz-Linek et al., 2016] and experiments were performed in VR buffer as for motor speed measurements. 4.3 Sample preparation and osmotic shock For BFM experiments flagellar filaments were truncated by passing a bacterial suspension through two syringes with narrow gauge needles (26G) connected with a plastic tube ('shearing device' [Bai et al., 2010, Ryu et al., 2000, Pilizota et al., 2009]). Subsequently, cells with truncated filaments were washed by centrifugation. Slides for BFM experiments were prepared as before [Bai et al., 2010, Pilizota et al., 2009] by layering two parallel strips of double sided sticky tape onto a micro- scope slide and covering them with a cover glass, forming a tunnel slide (SI Appendix Fig. 5) of approximate volume of ∼ 8 µl. 1% poly-L-lysine was loaded into the tunnel and extensively washed out after keeping it in for ∼10 s to allow glass coating. Cells with truncated filaments were loaded into the tunnel and incubated for 10 min in a humid environment to prevent evaporation. Subse- quently, non attached cells were washed out. Next, 0.5 µm beads in diameter (Polysciences) were added and incubated for 10 min to allow sticking to the filaments and excess beads were washed out post incubation. Osmotic shocks were performed while the slide was in the microscope by adding 24 µl of the shocking solution to one end and immediately bringing a piece of tissue paper to the other, resulting in flow and exchange of media. The flow duration was approximately 10-15 s and the local flow rate that the attached bacterium experienced was 0.68 µl/min [Buda et al., 2016]. Tunnel was sealed after the shock to prevent evaporation and thus potential further increase in osmolarity throughout the course of the experiment. For DDM experiments an ∼400 µm deep flat capillary (Vitrocom) glass sample was filled with ∼150 µl of bacterial suspensions immediately after upshock, and subsequently sealed to prevent evaporation during the experiment. 4.4 Microscopy and data collection For BFM experiments backfocal plane interferometry [Denk and Webb, 1990,Svoboda et al., 1993] was performed using a custom built microscope and a 855 nm laser (Blue Sky Research, USA) 11 which formed a weak optical trap. The rotating bead attached to a flagellar stub was brought into the focus of the laser and the back-focal plane of the condenser was imaged onto a position sensitive detector (PSD Model 2931, New Focus, USA). The voltage signal from the PSD was passed through an analog anti-aliasing filter (low pass, Bessel type filter with a cut off frequency of 2.5 kHz, Krohn- Hite Corporation, USA) and sampled at 10 kHz (PCIE-6351 DAQ, National Instruments). For DDM experiments imaging within the glass capillary was performed at 100 µm away from the bottom of the capillary to avoid any interaction with the glass wall. The imaging begun within ∼ 2min post upshock, and consisted of a time-series of phase-contrast images (Nikon TE300 Eclipse fitted with a Nikon Plan Fluor 10×Ph1 objective, NA=0.3, Ph1 phase-contrast illumination plate). Imaging was performed at 100 Hz sampling rate (Mikrotron high-speed camera (MC 1362) and frame grabber (Inspecta 5, 1-Gb memory)) for ∼ 40 s per movie duration and using 512x512 pixels field of view. Both DDM and BFM experiments were performed at room temperature (21±1◦C). 4.5 Data analysis Data collected during BFM experiments was analyzed in the following way. X and Y signals (obtained from voltages from the PSD) were passed through a moving window discrete Fourier transform, where the window moves point by point and the window size was 1.684 s. Time traces of single motor speed obtained in such a way were processed to calculate the CW Bias using Equation 1. CW Biases were calculated for a fixed interval sizes (30 s in Fig. 2A, 3 min in Fig. 2C and 5 min in Fig.2B), and using a 60 s long moving window in Fig. 2D and SI Appendix Fig. 7B-E. To calculate τ CCW we first take a mean of the τCCW intervals belonging to each individual BFM rotation trace. We then pool so obtained mean cell intervals into a distribution and obtained its mean (similar is true for τ CW , but in opposite direction). We include only bound CCW and CW intervals (see Fig. 11). In DDM experiments, the mean swimming speed was calculated from DDM movies as an average over ∼104 cells/ml. Details of the image processing and data analysis were as before [Wilson et al., 2011,Martinez et al., 2012,Martinez et al., 2014,Schwarz-Linek et al., 2016]. DDM allows the measurement of an advective speed, simultaneously, over a range of spatial- frequency q, where each q defines a length-scale L=2*pi/q (for more details, see [Wilson et al., 2011, Martinez et al., 2012]). A mean swimming speed is extracted by averaging over q. Data plotted in Fig. 3D were obtained by averaging over the range 0.5 (cid:46) q (cid:46) 2.2 µm−1, corresponding to a range in length-scale 3 (cid:46) L (cid:46) 13 µm. 5 Acknowledgments This work was supported by Chancellor's Fellowship to TP. WCKP and VM were funded by an EP- SRC Programme Grant EP/J007404/1 and an ERC advanced grant (AdG 340877 PHYSAPS). We thank all of the members of the Pilizota lab, Poon Lab, and Alex Morozov and Filippo Menolascina for useful discussions and support. 12 6 SUPPORTING INFORMATION 6.1 Growth Media Osmolarities Growth media osmolalities were measured with an osmometer (Micro-Digital Osmometer MOD200 Plus, Camlab, Cambridge, UK) and are given in Table 1. 6.2 Motility Media Viscosities Motility media viscosities were measured with a rheometer (TA Instruments AR2000, cone-plate geometry, 60 cm, 0.5◦) and are given in Table 2. 6.3 Supporting Figures Supporting Figures to the main text are given with the captions. 13 Table 1: Media osmolalities Osmolality (mOsmol/kg) Media VRB VRB+40 mM sucrose VRB+60 mM sucrose VRB+100 mM sucrose VRB+200 mM sucrose VRB+400 mM sucrose VRB+600 mM sucrose 92 135 157 203 320 580 877 Table 2: Measured media viscosities (in agreement with listed in [Swindells, 1958]) Media Motility Media Motility Media + 300 mM sucrose Motility Media + 600 mM sucrose Motility Meida + 900 mM sucrose Motility Media + 1850 mM sucrose Viscosity (Pa s) 0.00112 ± 0.00001 0.00146 ± 0.00001 0.00192 ± 0.00002 0.00290 ± 0.00007 0.0172 ± 0.0001 Figure 5: Schematic representation of the bead assay and tunnel slide used for measurements. (A) Genetically modified bacterial flagellar filament (FliCSticky [Fahren, 1995]) stub was attached to a latex bead of 0.5 µm diameter. The bead was placed in a heavily attenuated optical trap and the bead rotation recorded via back focal plane interferometry (Methods). (B) A tunnel slide, formed by a double sided sticky tape separating a microscope slide and a glass cover slip, was used to deliver osmotic shocks. The slide was sealed with vaseline upon the osmotic shock to prevent evaporation. 14 Figure 6: (A) Recovery Phase duration (Trec,CW ), calculated as the time needed for the post-shock median population bias to recover to the median VR Buffer bias (CW Bias=0.01, histogram in main text Fig. 2B). Trec,CW was calculated for each of the three shock conditions, whose biases are presented in panels C-D. The points represent times at which the post shock median reaches 0.01, relative to the time of shock delivery. The error bars give the populational variability in terms of recovery times for the 25th and the 75th percentile of population bias. (B) Buffer to buffer control flush CW Bias during the course of the experiment is given. Biases were calculated on a moving window of 60 s length and the VR Buffer was flown into the tunnel slide in the same way and duration as for the osmotic shock experiments. 12 cells in total are presented, the solid black line is the median, dashed is the mean and the shading represents the area between the 25th and 75th percentile. (C) Same as B but for the 111 mOsmol/kg osmotic upshift and the plot represents the median of the 22 single cell bias traces (thick red line), the mean (dashed black line) and the red shading is the area between the 25th and the 75th percentile. (D) and (E) are the same as C, only for the 230 mOsmol/kg (24 cells) and the 488 mOsmol/kg (23 cells) osmotic upshifts, respectively. 15 ATrec,cw[min]Δ[mOsmol/kg]BCDEFigure 7: Histogram of single-motor speeds for E. coli KAF84 in the Volume Recovery Buffer (VRB). Each motor comes from a different single cell. Each speed is computed by taking the first 15 s of various recordings made in VRB, selecting the CCW speed from the trace and averaging it. The histogram contains 118 cells and the mean value of the distribution is 116±2 Hz. 16 Figure 8: (A) Version of the main Fig. 3 where the motor and swimming speeds have been corrected for sucrose viscosity, under the assumption that no additional stators are incorporated at this increased load (see Discussion in the main text). Viscosity correction for 100, 200 and 400 mM sucrose used are a multiplicative factor of 1.057, 1.195 and 1.444, respectively (measured and listed in [Swindells, 1958]). Each line represents a single motor speed trace binned into 15 s intervals where the color represents the height of the bin, normalized to the first bin. Results are grouped by upshock magnitude, as indicated on the left hand edge. The white hatched column represents the point where an osmotic shock was administered by exchanging VR Buffer for VR Buffer + sucrose and the flow lasted for 10-15 s. There are 22, 24 and 23 cells for the 111, 230 and 488 mOsmol/kg condition, respectively. The color map scale is given at the top of the figure. (B) DDM measurement of swimming speeds following an osmotic shock. Cells were shocked in microfuge tubes and brought into a microscope within 2 min. The legend shows shock magnitudes and the mean speed is the average of swimming speeds obtained for each time point in a range of different length scales (Methods). The systematic error of our measurements is then calculated as the standard deviation of the mean, and falls within ∼5% of the mean value (here not plotted for clarity). The traces shown have been viscosity corrected as well, as free-swimming cells with the motor operating in liner-torque regime do not increase the swimming speeds with viscosities we used in our experiments [Martinez et al., 2014]. (C) Viscosity corrected single motors speeds calculated as 3 min averages corresponding to a section between t=17 and t=20 min in A. The 0 mOsmol/kg condition is sampled from a set of buffer to buffer control flushes which were at least 20 minutes long (12 out of 18 control flushes). Red horizontal bars represent mean and yellow triangles median values. 17 Normalized motor speed051015202530Time [min]111230488 Osmotic upshift [mOsmol/kg]0.41.22.0AC2.80Δ[∙102mOsmol/kg]ω17-20 [Hz]4365110215473785mOsmol/kgB050100150200Time [min]02468101214Swimming speed [μm/s]Figure 9: Traces of motor rotation after addition of 400 mM sucrose (all cells given in Fig. 2A and Fig. 3A of the main text are given). We do not plot the initial motor speed, and start at the point of speed drop due to an osmotic shock. Motor speeds were obtained as described in Methods. 18 Figure 10: Top: Mean CW interval distribution (τ CW ) for cells in Volume Recovery Buffer. Motor rotation of 102 cells was sampled for 5 min and intervals counted as illustrated in SI Appendix Fig. 11. Bottom: Mean CW interval distribution for motors where the sampling interval (3 min) begins 12 or more minutes after an osmotic shock with 200 mM sucrose in VRB (+230 mOsmol/kg). The inset contains data from the histogram plotted against the start time of the sampling interval and t=0 corresponds to the osmotic shock. 19 Figure 11: A portion of a single-motor speed trace illustrating the counting of interval lengths within a given sampling window. Positive speeds correspond to CCW rotation and negative to CW rotation. Intervals i1 and i7 are not included when calculating the mean CCW interval due to uncertainty in their beginning or end. Only intervals bounded by two CW intervals are counted. Similar holds true when calculating mean CW interval, only those bounded by two CCW intervals were included. 20 i1i7References [Adler, 1969] Adler, J. (1969). Chemoreceptors in bacteria. Science, 166(3913):1588–1597. [Adler et al., 2012] Adler, M., Erickstad, M., Gutierrez, E., and Groisman, A. (2012). Studies of bacterial aerotaxis in a microfluidic device. Lab Chip, 12(22):4835–4847. [Babaoglu et al., 2006] Babaoglu, O., Canright, G., Deutsch, A., Di Caro, G., Ducatelle, F., Gam- bardella, L., Ganguly, N., Jelasity, M., Montemanni, R., Montresor, A., and Urnes, T. (2006). Design patterns from biology for distributed computing. ACM Trans. Auton. Adapt. Syst., 1:26–66. [Bai et al., 2010] Bai, F., Branch, R., Nicolau, D. J., Pilizota, T., Steel, B., Maini, P., and Berry, R. (2010). Conformational spread as a mechanism for cooperativity in the bacterial flagellar switch. Science, 327(5966):685–689. [Bai et al., 2013] Bai, F., Che, Y., Kami-ike, N., Ma, Q., Minamino, T., Sowa, Y., and Namba, K. (2013). Populational heterogeneity vs. temporal fluctuation in escherichia coli flagellar motor switching. Biophys J, 105(9):2123–2129. [Begley et al., 2005] Begley, M., Gahan, C., and Hill, C. (2005). The interaction between bacteria and bile. FEMS Microbiol Rev, 29(4):625–651. [Berg, 1973] Berg, H. (1973). Bacteria swim by rotating their flagellar filaments. Nature, 245:380– 382. [Berg, 2003] Berg, H. (2003). The rotary motor of bacterial flagella. Annual Review of Biochem- istry, 72:19–54. [Berg and Tedesco, 1975] Berg, H. C. and Tedesco, P. (1975). Transient response to chemotactic stimuli in escherichia coli. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 72(8):3235–3239. [Berg and Turner, 1993] Berg, H. C. and Turner, L. (1993). Torque generated by the flagellar motor of escherichia coli. Biophys J, 65(5):2201–2216. [Berg, 1996] Berg, R. (1996). The indigenous gastrointestinal microflora. Trends Microbiol, 4(11):430–435. [Blattner et al., 1997] Blattner, F., Plunkett, G. r., Bloch, C., Perna, N., Burland, V., Riley, M., Collado-Vides, J., Glasner, J., Rode, C., Mayhew, G., Gregor, J., Davis, N., Kirkpatrick, H., Goeden, M., Rose, D., Mau, B., and Shao, Y. (1997). The complete genome sequence of escherichia coli k-12. Science, 277(5331):1453–1462. [Block et al., 1982] Block, S., Segall, J., and Berg, H. (1982). chemotaxis. Cell, 31(1):215–226. Impulse responses in bacterial [Buda et al., 2016] Buda, R., Liu, Y., Yang, J., Hegde, S., Stevenson, K., Bai, F., and Pilizota, T. (2016). Dynamics of escherichia coli's passive response to a sudden decreases in external osmolarity. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, September:doi:10.1073/pnas.1522185113. [Cates, 2012] Cates, M. (2012). Diffusive transport without detailed balance in motile bacteria: does microbiology need statistical physics? Rep Prog Phys, 75(4):042601. [Celani and Vergassola, 2010] Celani, A. and Vergassola, M. (2010). Bacterial strategies for chemo- taxis response. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 107(4):1391–1396. [Clark and Grant, 2005] Clark, D. and Grant, L. (2005). The bacterial chemotactic response re- flects a compromise between transient and steady-state behavior. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 102(26):9150–9155. [Cluzel et al., 2000] Cluzel, P., Surette, M., and Leibler, S. (2000). An ultrasensitive bacterial motor revealed by monitoring signaling proteins in single cells. Science, 287(5458):1652–1655. 21 [Cullender et al., 2013] Cullender, T., Chassaing, B., Janzon, A., Kumar, K., Muller, C., Werner, J., Angenent, L., Bell, M., Hay, A., Peterson, D., Walter, J., Vijay-Kumar, M., Gewirtz, A., and Ley, R. (2013). Innate and adaptive immunity interact to quench microbiome flagellar motility in the gut. Cell Host Microbe, 14(15):571–581. [Datta et al., 2016] Datta, S., Preska Steinberg, A., and Ismagilov, R. (2016). Polymers in the gut compress the colonic mucus hydrogel. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 113(26):7041–7046. [Dawes and Ribbons, 1965] Dawes, E. and Ribbons, D. (1965). metabolism of escherichia coli. Biochem J., 95:332–343. Studies on the endogenous [de Gennes, 2004] de Gennes, P. (2004). Chemotaxis: the role of internal delays. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 33(8):691–693. [Denk and Webb, 1990] Denk, W. and Webb, W. (1990). Optical measurement of picometer dis- placements of transparent microscopic objects. Appl Opt., 29(16):2382–2891. [Fahren, 1995] Fahren, K. A. (1995). Studies of bacterial flagellar motors and filaments. Ph.D. thesis, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA. [Fahrner et al., 2003] Fahrner, K., Ryu, W., and Berg, H. (2003). Biomechanics: Bacterial flagellar switching under load. Nature, 423:938–938. [Fordtran and Locklear, 1966] Fordtran, J. and Locklear, T. (1966). Ionic constituents and osmo- lality of gastric and small-intestinal fluids after eating. Am J Dig Dis, 11(7):503–521. [Gauger et al., 2007] Gauger, E., Leatham, M., Mercado-Lubo, R., Laux, D., Conway, T., and Cohen, P. (2007). Role of motility and the flhdc operon in escherichia coli mg1655 colonization of the mouse intestine. Infect Immun, 75(7):3315–24. [Gordon and Cowling, 2003] Gordon, D. and Cowling, A. (2003). The distribution and genetic structure of escherichia coli in australian vertebrates: host and geographic effects. Microbiology, 149:3575–3586. [Inoue et al., 2008] Inoue, Y., Lo, C., Fukuoka, H., Takahashi, H., Sowa, Y., Pilizota, T., Wad- hams, G., Homma, M., Berry, R., and Ishijima, A. (2008). Torque–speed relationships of na+- driven chimeric flagellar motors in escherichia coli. J. Mol. Biol, 376(5):1251–1259. [Klumpp et al., 2013] Klumpp, S., Scott, M., Pedersen, S., and Hwa, T. (2013). Molecular crowd- ing limits translation and cell growth. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 110(42):16754–16759. [Krell et al., 2011] Krell, T., Lacal, J., Muñoz-Martínez, F., Reyes-Darias, J., Cadirci, B., García- Fontana, C., and Ramos, J. (2011). Diversity at its best: bacterial taxis. Environmen. Microbiol., 13(5):1115–1124. [Lackraj et al., 2016] Lackraj, T., Kim, J., Tran, S., and Barnett Foster, D. (2016). Differential modulation of flagella expression in enterohaemorrhagic escherichia coli o157: h7 by intestinal short-chain fatty acid mixes. Microbiology, 162(10):1761–1772. [Lele et al., 2012] Lele, P., Branch, R., Nathan, V., and Berg, H. (2012). Mechanism for adaptive remodeling of the bacterial flagellar switch. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 109(49):20018–20022. [Lele et al., 2013] Lele, P., Hosu, B., and Berg, H. (2013). Dynamics of mechanosensing in the bacterial flagellar motor. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 110(29):11839–44. [Li and Adler, 1993] Li, C. and Adler, J. (1993). Escherichia coli shows two types of behavioral responses to osmotic upshift. J Bacteriol, 175(9):2564–25675. [Li et al., 1988] Li, C., Boileau, A., Kung, C., and Adler, J. (1988). Osmotaxis in escherichia coli. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 85(24):9451–9455. [Licata et al., 2016] Licata, N., Mohari, B., Fuqua, C., and Setayeshgar, S. (2016). Diffusion of bacterial cells in porous media. Biophys. J, 110(1):247–257. 22 [Lo, 2007] Lo, C. (2007). Sodium energetics of chimeric flagellar motors in escherichia coli. Ph.D. thesis. University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. [Lovely and Dahlquist, 1975] Lovely, P. and Dahlquist, F. (1975). Statistical measures of bacterial motility and chemotaxis. J Theor Biol, 50(2):477–496. [Magariyama et al., 1995] Magariyama, Y., Sugiyama, S., Muramoto, K., Kawagishi, I., Imae, Y., and Kudo, S. (1995). Simultaneous measurement of bacterial flagellar rotation rate and swimming speed. Biophys. J, 69(5):2154–2162. [Martinez et al., 2014] Martinez, V., Scwarz-Linek, J., Reufer, M., Wilson, L., Morozov, A., and Poon, W. (2014). Flagellated bacterial motility in polymer solutions. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 111(50):17771–17776. [Martinez et al., 2012] Martinez, V. A., Besseling, R., Croze, O., Tailleur, J., Reufer, M., Schwarz- Linek, J., Wilson, L., Bees, M., and Poon, W. C. (2012). Differential dynamic microscopy: A high-throughput method for characterizing the motility of microorganisms. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 103(8):1637–1647. [Massart, 1889] Massart, J. (1889). Sensibilité et adaptation des organismes à la concentration de solutions salines. Arch. Biol., 9:515–570. [Navlakha and Bar-Joseph, 2014] Navlakha, S. and Bar-Joseph, Z. (2014). Algorithms in nature: the convergence of systems biology and computational thinking. Mol Syst Biol., 7:546–546. [Neumann et al., 2014] Neumann, S., Vladimirov, N., Krembel, A., Wingreen, N., and Sourjik, V. (2014). Adaptation in escherichia coli chemotaxis. PLoS ONE, 9(1):e84904. [Nishiyama et al., 2013] Nishiyama, M., Sowa, Y., Kimura, Y., Homma, M., Ishijima, A., and Terazima, M. (2013). High hydrostatic pressure induces counterclockwise to clockwise reversals of the escherichia coli flagellar motor. J Bacteriol, 195(8):1809–1814. [Parry et al., 2014] Parry, B., Surovtsev, I., Cabeen, M., O'Hern, C., Dufresne, E., and Jacobs- Wagner, C. (2014). The bacterial cytoplasm has glass-like properties and is fluidized by metabolic activity. Cell, 156(1-2):183–194. [Paster and Ryu, 2007] Paster, E. and Ryu, W. (2007). The thermal impulse response of Es- cherichia Coli. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 105(14):5373–5377. [Paudel and Rueda, 2014] Paudel, B. and Rueda, D. (2014). Molecular crowding accelerates ri- bozyme docking and catalysis. J Am Chem Soc, 136(48):16700–16703. [Pilizota et al., 2007] Pilizota, T., Bilyard, T., Bai, F., Futai, M., Hosokawa, H., and Berry, R. (2007). A programmable optical angle clamp for rotary molecular motors. Biophys J, 93(1):264– 275. [Pilizota et al., 2009] Pilizota, T., Brown, M., Leake, M., Branch, R., Berry, R., and Armitage, J. (2009). A molecular brake, not a clutch, stops the rhodobacter sphaeroides flagellar motor. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 106(28):11582–11587. [Pilizota and Shaevitz, 2012] Pilizota, T. and Shaevitz, J. (2012). Fast, multiphase volume adap- tation to hyperosmotic shock by Escherichia coli. PLoS One, 7(4):e35205. [Pilizota and Shaevitz, 2014] Pilizota, T. and Shaevitz, J. W. (2014). Origins of escherichia coli growth rate and cell shape changes at high external osmolality. Biophys J, 107(8):1962–1969. [Purcell, 1977] Purcell, E. (1977). Life at low reynolds number. American Journal of Physics, 45:3–11. [Rivera-Chávez et al., 2013] Rivera-Chávez, F., Winter, S., Lopez, C., Xavier, M., Winter, M., Nuccio, S., Russell, J., Laughlin, R., Lawhon, S., Sterzenbach, T., Bevins, C., Tsolis, R., Harshey, R., and Adams, LG ad Bäumler, A. (2013). Salmonella uses energy taxis to benefit from intestinal inflammation. PLOS Pathog, 9(4):e1003267. 23 [Ryu et al., 2000] Ryu, W., Berry, R., and Berg, H. (2000). Torque-generating units of the flagellar motor of escherichia coli have a high duty ratio. Nature, 403(6768):444–447. [Schnitzer, 1993] Schnitzer, M. (1993). Theory of continuum random walks and application to chemotaxis. Phys Rev E, 48(4):2553–2568. [Schnitzer et al., 1990] Schnitzer, M., Block, S., Berg, H., and Purcell, E. (1990). Strategies for chemotaxis. Symp Soc Gen Microbiol, 46:15–33. [Schwarz-Linek et al., 2016] Schwarz-Linek, J., Arlt, J., Jepson, A., Dawson, A., Vissers, T., Miroli, D., Pilizota, T., Martinez, V., and Poon, W. (2016). Escherichia coli as a model ac- tive colloid: A practical introduction. Colloids Surf B Biointerfaces, 137:2–16. [Segal et al., 1986] Segal, J., Block, S., and Berg, H. (1986). Temporal comparisons in bacterial chemotaxis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 83(23):8987–8991. [Sowa and Berry, 2008] Sowa, Y. and Berry, R. (2008). Bacterial flagellar motor. Quarterly Re- views of Biophysics, 41(02):103–132. [Strong et al., 1998] Strong, S., Freedman, B., Bialek, W., and Koberl, R. (1998). Adaptation and optimal chemotactic strategy for e. coli. Phys Rev E, 57(4):4604–4617. [Svoboda et al., 1993] Svoboda, K., Schmidt, C., Schnapp, B., and Block, S. (1993). Direct obser- vation of kinesin stepping by optical trapping interferometry. Nature, 365(6448):721–727. [Swindells, 1958] Swindells, J. (1958). Viscosities of sucrose solutions at various temperatures: tables of recalculated values. United States, National Bureau of Standards. [Tailleur and Cates, 2008] Tailleur, J. and Cates, M. (2008). Statistical mechanics of interacting run-and-tumble bacteria. Phys Rev Lett, 100(21):218103. [Tamar et al., 2016] Tamar, E., Koler, M., and Vaknin, A. (2016). The role of motility and chemo- taxis in the bacterial colonization of protected surfaces. Sci Rep, 2016(6):19616. [Tang and Blair, 1995] Tang, H. and Blair, D. (1995). Regulated underexpression of the flim protein of escherichia coli and evidence for a location in the flagellar motor distinct from the mota/motb torque generators. J Bacteriol, 177(12):3485–3495. [Tipping et al., 2013] Tipping, M., Delalez, N., Lim, R., Berry, R., and Armitage, J. (2013). Load- dependent assembly of the bacterial flagellar motor. mBio, 4:e00551–13. [Turner et al., 2000] Turner, L., Ryu, W., and Berg, H. (2000). Real-time imaging of fluorescent flagellar filaments. Journal of Bacteriology, 182(10):2793–2801. [Vaknin and Berg, 2006] Vaknin, A. and Berg, H. (2006). Osmotic stress mechanically perturbs chemoreceptors in escherichia coli. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 103(3):592–596. [Wadhams and Armitage, 2004] Wadhams, G. and Armitage, J. (2004). Making sense of it all: bacterial chemotaxis. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol, 5(12):1024–1037. [Welch et al., 1993] Welch, M., Oosawa, K., Aizawa, S., (1993). Phosphorylation-dependent binding of a signal molecule to the flagellar switch of bacteria. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 90(19):8787–8791. and Eisenbach, M. [Wilson et al., 2011] Wilson, L., Martinez, V., Schwarz-Linek, J., Tailleur, J., Bryant, G., Pusey, P., and Poon, W. (2011). Differential dynamic microscopy of bacterial motility. Phys. Rev. Lett, 106(1):018101. [Wood, 2015] Wood, J. (2015). Bacterial responses to osmotic challenges. 145(5):381–388. J Gen Physiol, [Yuan et al., 2012] Yuan, J., Branch, R., Hosu, B., and Berg, H. (2012). Adaptation at the output of the chemotaxis signalling pathway. Nature, 484(7393):233–236. 24
1802.07169	1	1802	2018-02-20T16:07:17	Self-organization principles of intracellular pattern formation	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.SC" ]	Dynamic patterning of specific proteins is essential for the spatiotemporal regulation of many important intracellular processes in procaryotes, eucaryotes, and multicellular organisms. The emergence of patterns generated by interactions of diffusing proteins is a paradigmatic example for self-organization. In this article we review quantitative models for intracellular Min protein patterns in E. coli, Cdc42 polarization in S. cerevisiae, and the bipolar PAR protein patterns found in C. elegans. By analyzing the molecular processes driving these systems we derive a theoretical perspective on general principles underlying self-organized pattern formation. We argue that intracellular pattern formation is not captured by concepts such as "activators"', "inhibitors", or "substrate-depletion". Instead, intracellular pattern formation is based on the redistribution of proteins by cytosolic diffusion, and the cycling of proteins between distinct conformational states. Therefore, mass-conserving reaction-diffusion equations provide the most appropriate framework to study intracellular pattern formation. We conclude that directed transport, e.g. cytosolic diffusion along an actively maintained cytosolic gradient, is the key process underlying pattern formation. Thus the basic principle of self-organization is the establishment and maintenance of directed transport by intracellular protein dynamics.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Self-organization principles of intracellular pattern formation J. Halatek. F. Brauns, and E. Frey∗ Arnold–Sommerfeld–Center for Theoretical Physics and Center for NanoScience, Department of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universitat Munchen, Theresienstrasse 37, D-80333 Munchen, Germany (Dated: February 21, 2018) Abstract Dynamic patterning of specific proteins is essential for the spatiotemporal regulation of many important intracellular processes in procaryotes, eucaryotes, and multicellular organisms. The emergence of patterns generated by interactions of diffusing proteins is a paradigmatic example for self-organization. In this article we review quantitative models for intracellular Min protein patterns in E. coli, Cdc42 polarization in S. cerevisiae, and the bipolar PAR protein patterns found in C. elegans. By analyzing the molecular processes driving these systems we derive a theoretical perspective on general principles underlying self-organized pattern formation. We argue that intracellular pattern formation is not captured by concepts such as "activators", "inhibitors", or "substrate-depletion". Instead, intracellular pattern formation is based on the redistribution of proteins by cytosolic diffusion, and the cycling of proteins between distinct conformational states. Therefore, mass-conserving reaction-diffusion equations provide the most appropriate framework to study intracellular pattern formation. We conclude that directed transport, e.g. cytosolic diffusion along an actively maintained cytosolic gradient, is the key process underlying pattern formation. Thus the basic principle of self-organization is the establishment and maintenance of directed transport by intracellular protein dynamics. Keywords: self-organization; pattern formation; intracellular patterns; reaction-diffusion; cell polarity; NTPases 8 1 0 2 b e F 0 2 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 9 6 1 7 0 . 2 0 8 1 : v i X r a 1 INTRODUCTION In biological systems self-organization refers to the emergence of spatial and temporal structure. Examples include the structure of the genetic code, the structure of proteins, the structure of membrane and cytoplasm, or those of tissue, and connected neural networks. On each of these levels, interactions resulting from the dynamics and structural comple- mentarities of the system's constituents bring about the emergence of biological function. Biological systems are the perfect example for the Aristotelian notion that "the whole is more than the sum of it's parts". For centuries this phrase expressed nothing more than a vague intuition that some set of organizational principles must underlie the complex phe- nomena we observe around us. Owing to the advances in quantitative biology and theoretical biological physics in recent decades, we have begun to understand how biological structure and function originates from fundamental physical principles of self-organization. While we are not yet in a position to define any universal physical principles of self-organization in general, we are now able to identify recurring themes and principles in particular, important areas like intracellular pattern formation. This will be the main focus of this review article. The generic equilibrium state of any diffusion process is spatially uniform as diffusion re- moves spatial gradients in chemical concentration. Self-organized pattern formation implies that this equilibrium can be destabilized, such that an initially uniform system evolves to- wards a non-uniform steady state - a pattern [1, 2]. Historically, the field of self-organized pattern formation in chemical systems was initiated by Alan Turing in 1952 [1]. In his seminal article on "The chemical basis of morphogenesis", Turing showed that the interplay between molecular diffusion and chemical interactions can give rise to an instability of the spatially uniform state. His general finding was that in a system with multiple reacting components diffusing laterally on different time scales, the diffusive coupling itself can cause an instability even if the system is in a stable chemical equilibrium. Turing was the first to introduce a linear stability analysis for reaction-diffusion systems. To give the reader an impression of the generality of his ideas let us briefly summarise the underlying mathemat- ical concepts: The initial idea is that any random perturbation of a uniform steady state can be decomposed in Fourier modes ∼ cos(qx) (Figure 1a). As long as amplitudes are small, each of these modes grows or decays exponentially ∼ exp(σqt) cos(qx), depending on the sign of the growth rate σq (or more precisely the real parts Re[σq]). By linear stability 2 analysis one computes the growth rates for modes with any wavenumber q. Turing found that the interaction between chemical reactions and molecular diffusion can give rise to bands of unstable modes with positive growth rates, i.e. situations where some modes with particular wavelengths are amplified out of a random perturbation (Figure 1a). This gives rise to pattern formation. In the following we will refer to the pattern forming instability as lateral instability since it originates from lateral diffusive coupling. As proof of principle Turing demonstrated this stability analysis for a general reaction- diffusion system with two chemical components, but also discussed (oscillatory) cases with three components. For 20 years his results received very little attention. It was only in 1972 when Segel and Jackson [3] first interpreted Turing's linear stability analysis of the two-component model, while Gierer and Meinhardt [4] in the same year proposed a num- ber of specific two-component models and coined the terms "activator", "inhibitor", and "activator–inhibitor mechanism" in this context. Unfortunately, nowadays the terms "activator–inhibitor mechanism" and "Turing insta- bility" are often thought to refer to identical concepts, despite the fact that the "activator– inhibitor mechanism" only represents a particular interpretation of Turing's proof of princi- ple analysis that is specific to some but not all two-component models. Furthermore, note that Turing's general idea of a lateral instability is in fact not even limited to a particular number of chemical components. In the literature the "activator–inhibitor mechanism" is usually considered as a combination of "short range activation" and "long range inhibition" or of "local activation" and "lateral inhibition" in order to convey the following heuristic picture [2, 5, 6]: Consider two chemical components. First – the (short range) activator – enhances its own production in some autocatalytic fashion such that its concentration can increase expo- nentially. If the diffusion coefficient of this component is small – any concentration peak will only slowly disperse in the lateral direction. Secondly, the (long range) inhibitor, which is also produced by the activator, but has a much large diffusion coefficient. Hence, it does not accumulate locally with the activator but disperses laterally, where it inhibits the action of the activator (see Fig. 1b). It is crucial to realize that this mechanisms is merely a heuristic interpretation of a formal linear stability analysis presented by Turing. A quite common misunderstanding in the biological literature is that pattern formation requires an activator and an inhibitor. This does not in any way follow from the analysis by Turing [1], Segel and 3 Jackson [3], Gierer and Meinhardt [4–6], or any other analysis – activator–inhibitor models are simply mathematically idealized examples of pattern forming systems. Moreover, the underlying interpretation is actually restricted to systems with only two interacting chemical components. Note that "chemical component" does not refer to a protein species, but to the conformational state of a protein that determines its interactions with specific (conforma- tions of) other proteins. Clearly, protein interaction networks include many conformational states – not just two [7]. Furthermore, the activator–inhibitor interpretation inextricably links chemical properties (e.g. autocatalytic action) to the diffusibility of the components (e.g. short range activation). However, in the context of intracellular protein pattern formation the general distinction be- tween diffusibilities is that between membrane-bound and cytosolic (conformational) states. Accordingly, membrane-bound protein conformations would have to be considered as acti- vators in the activator–inhibitor picture, and cytosolic protein conformation as inhibitors, respectively. There are many reasons why this picture is not applicable to intracellular protein dynamics – the most glaring discrepancy is that proteins are not produced auto- catalytically on the membrane, which is the major (implicit) assumption underlying all activator–inhibitor interpretations. As we will discuss in detail below, intracellular protein pattern formation is generically independent of protein production and degradation (cf. [8]), and intracellular protein dynamics are generically driven by the cycling of proteins between membrane-bound and cytosolic conformations. Another interpretation of Turing's mathematical analysis of two-component systems, which appears to take these considerations into account, is the "activator–depletion" model [4, 6] (see Fig. 1c). It differs from the activator–inhibitor model in making a specific choice of the reaction terms and reinterpreting the rapidly diffusing component (formerly the in- hibitor) as a substrate that is depleted by conversion into the activator. In this interpretation the autocatalytic production (which increases activator and inhibitor concentrations) is re- placed by an autocatalytic conversion of substrate to activator, which could be understood as membrane attachment of a cytosolic protein. However, this type of model [4, 6] crucially depends on cytosolic production of the substrate and degradation of the activator on the membrane. In particular, concentration minima are not the result of a depleted cytosol (as one might expect intuitively), but arise from the dominance of the activator degradation, which effectively suppresses the autocatalytic conversion process [4, 6] (Fig. 1c). In other 4 words, accumulation of cytosolic proteins on the membrane is suppressed by concomitant degradation of their membrane-bound forms. Obviously, this assumption is highly specific and biologically implausible in terms of intracellular protein dynamics. The use of a metalanguage with terms like "activator" and "depletion" suggests that these concepts account for intracellular protein dynamics where finite cytosolic particle pools play an important role. But the draining of finite reservoirs is not actually the mechanism that drives pattern formation in activator–depletion models. Like the activator–inhibitor model the activator–depletion model strictly depends on production and degradation processes to explain pattern formation, and hence, it cannot account for pattern formation in mass conserving systems. These issues clearly demonstrate that heuristic interpretations and reinterpretations of specific mathematical models do not generalize Turing's insight in a useful way. Indeed, "activator–inhibitor" and "activator– depletion" models do not even provide a general picture of two-component systems, and two-component systems are already a gross simplification of the biological reality. Hence, there is no reason to assume that an intracellular pattern forming system must contain activators and inhibitors, or involve depletion of substrates. In our opinion, the use of such metalanguage to describe the results of quantitative theoretical models does more harm than good. It suggests that a unifying theoretical understanding is provided by the idealized mathematical models to which intuitive terms like "activator", "inhibitor", and "depletion" refer, whereas in reality, little is known about the actual general principles of actual intracellular pattern formation. Activator–inhibitor models do provide a legitimate phenomenological description of sys- tems based on production (e.g. growth or gene regulation) and degradation, which is appli- cable to some developmental phenomena [9] or vegetation patterns [10, 11]. However, even in theses cases, it can be argued [10] that such models should be integrated in a more com- plete modelling framework to account for specific details alone, rather than being treated as paradigmatic models that convey the essence of pattern formation in general. In this article, we provide a molecular perspective on intracellular pattern formation, and review the underlying quantitative biological models, without reference to concepts like "activators", "inhibitors", or depleting substrates. Instead, we review in the following the specific implementation of pattern forming mechanisms by various protein interaction systems – i.e. the Min system in Escherischia coli, the Cdc42 system in Saccharomyces 5 cerevisiae, and the PAR system in Caenorhabditis elegans. Based on these systems we will then extract and discuss recurring principles of the pattern forming dynamics, in particular the fact that intracellular protein dynamics are based on cycling between different confor- mational states. We conclude that intracellular pattern formation is, in essence, a spatial redistribution process. Cytosolic concentration gradients are the primary means by which directed transport is facilitated. The establishment and maintenance of such gradients is the key principle underlying self-organized pattern formation. The proper theoretical framework to study intracellular pattern formation is set by mass-conserving reaction-diffusion systems. We will review recent theoretical advanced in this field [12] at the end of this article. The Min system in E. coli Cell division in E. coli requires a mechanism that reliably directs the assembly of the Z-ring division machinery (FtsZ) to midcell [13]. How cells solve this task is one of the most striking examples for intracellular pattern formation: the pole-to-pole Min protein oscillation [14]. In the past two decades this system has been studied extensively both experimentally [15–27] and theoretically [12, 27–31]. The Min protein system consists of three proteins, MinD, MinE, and MinC. In its ATP bound form the ATPase MinD associates cooperatively with the cytoplasmic membrane (see Fig. 2a). Membrane-bound MinD forms a complex with MinC, which inhibits Z-ring assembly. Thus, to form a Z-ring at midcell, MinCD complexes must accumulate in the polar zones of the cell but not at midcell. The dissociation of MinD from the membrane is mediated by its ATPase Activating Protein (AAP) MinE, which is also recruited to the membrane by MinD, forming MinDE complexes. MinE triggers the ATPase activity of MinD initiating the detachment of both MinD-ADP and MinE. Subsequently, MinD-ADP undergoes nucleotide exchange in the cytosol such that its ability to bind to the membrane is restored (see Fig. 2a). The joint action of MinD and MinE gives rise to oscillatory dynamics: MinD accumulates at one cell pole, detaches due to the action of MinE, diffuses, and accumulates at the opposite pole. The oscillation period is about 1 min, and during that time almost the entire mass of MinD and MinE is redistributed through the cytosol from one end of the cell to the other and back. 6 This example nicely illustrates the fact that pattern forming protein dynamics are in essence protein redistribution processes [12, 30]. In other words, the emergent phenomenon is directed transport, and not localized production and degradation (depletion), which serve as the basis of activator–inhibitor (or activator–depletion) models. It was suggested that binding of MinE to the membrane is essential for self-organized pattern formation [23, 24, 32]. However, theses results were critically debated in the litera- ture [33] and more recent experiments [34] have explicitly confirmed that MinE membrane binding is not required for self-organized pattern formation. Therefore, we will not discuss this process any further. Furthermore, we note that Min protein oscillations are highly regular and therefore amenable to a deterministic description. Instances where stochastic effects [35] were re- ported turned out to be overexpression artifacts [36] and not an indication for intrinsic noise due to low copy numbers. A striking lesson to be learned from the study of Min protein dynamics is the dependence of the pattern forming process on cell geometry [14, 26, 27, 30, 37–39]. The pole-to-pole oscillation in itself is a phenomenon intrinsically tied to the cell's geometry, which facilitates the detection of a specific location in the cell. Over the past two decades a plethora of fascinating observations has been made: (i) In filamentous cells, in which cell division is inhibited, the pole-to-pole oscillation develops additional wave nodes showing that the Min oscillation is a standing wave [14]. (ii) Experiments with nearly spherical cells show that, in the majority of cases, the pattern forming process is able to detect the long axis, even though it is much less pronounced than in wild-type, rod-shaped cells [37, 38]. (iii) In mutant cells that were grown in nanofabricated chambers of various shapes a broad range of patterns has been observed [26, 27]. In rectangular cells the oscillation can align with the long axis or the short axis for the same dimensions of the cell. This shows that patterns with distinct symmetries are stable under the same conditions: Min patterns are multistable. The Cdc42 system in S. cerevisiae Budding yeast (S. cerevisiae) cells are spherical and divide asymmetrically by growing a daughter cell from a localized bud. The GTPase Cdc42 spatially coordinates bud formation and growth via its downstream effectors. To that end, Cdc42 must accumulate within a 7 restricted region of the plasma membrane (a single Cdc42 cluster) [40]. Formation of a Cdc42 cluster, i.e. cell polarization, is achieved in a self-organized fashion from a uniform initial distribution even in the absence of spatial cues (symmetry breaking) [41]. Like all other GTPases, Cdc42 switches between an active GTP-bound state, and an inactive GDP-bound state. Both active and inactive Cdc42 forms associate with the plasma membrane, with Cdc42-GTP having the higher membrane affinity. Furthermore, Cdc42- GDP is preferentially extracted from the membrane by its Guanine Nucleotide Dissociation Inhibitor (GDI) Rdi1, which enables it to diffuse in the cytoplasm (see Fig. 2b) [42, 43]. Switching between GDP- and GTP-bound states is catalyzed by two classes of proteins: Guanine nucleotide Exchange Factors (GEFs) catalyze the replacement of GDP by GTP, switching Cdc42 to its active state; GTPase Activating Proteins (GAPs) enhance the slow intrinsic GTPase activity of Cdc42, i.e. hydrolysis of GTP to GDP [44] (Note that owing to their biochemical role, GAPs are called activating proteins, even though they switch GTPases into their inactive, GDP-bound state. Moreover, these "activating proteins" are in no way related to "activators" in the sense of "activator–inhibitor" models.). Cdc42 in budding yeast has only one known GEF, Cdc24, and four GAPs: Bem2, Bem3, Rga1, and Rga2. Further, a key player of the Cdc42 interaction network is the scaffold protein Bem1 which is recruited to the membrane by Cdc42-GTP, and itself recruits the GEF (Cdc24) to form a Bem1–GEF complex (Fig. 2b) [45, 46]. Establishment and maintenance of Cdc42 polarization has been shown to rely on two distinct and independent pathways of Cdc42 transport: (i) vesicle trafficking of vesicle- bound Cdc42 along actin cables which require Cdc42-GTP (via its downstream effector Bni1) [44, 47], and (ii) diffusive transport of GDI bound Cdc42 in the cytosol. Cytosolic Cdc42 is recruited to the membrane by Bem1–GEF complexes (Fig. 2b) [45, 46, 48]. Either of these transport pathways is sufficient for viability, as has been shown by either suppressing vesicle trafficking (by depolymerizing actin) or inhibiting cytosolic diffusion of Cdc42-GDP (by knocking out the GDI Rdi1) [47, 49, 50]. Since both pathways depend on Cdc42- GTP, the pattern formation mechanism in both cases relies on polar activation (nucleotide exchange) of Cdc42 by Bem1–GEF complexes, which are in turn recruited by Cdc42-GTP [48, 51–54]. Various computational models of the Cdc42-Bem1-GEF interaction network confirm that a positive feedback loop mediated by Bem1 is able to establish and maintain polarization [55, 56]. 8 Replacing Cdc42 with a constitutively active mutant suppresses GTPase cycling of Cdc42 and hence restricts it to membranes [47, 57]. Such mutants show that self-amplified directed vesicle trafficking of Cdc42-GTP provides a viable self-organized polarization mechanism in itself [57, 58]. Because the mutant Cdc42 is locked in its active state, these cells can forego the polar activation of Cdc42 by Bem1–GEF complexes. Conceptual computational models confirm that an actin mediated transport of Cdc42-GTP can in principle maintain polarity [49, 57, 59–61], although studies of more realistic models show that key details of the involved processes – endocytosis, exocytosis, and vesicle trafficking – are still unclear [62, 63]. Interestingly, experiments where Bem1 was knocked out (or deprived of its ability to recruit the GEF to active Cdc42) in cells with wild-type Cdc42 revealed that a third polar- ization mechanism must exist, which is independent of both, Bem1 and vesicle trafficking [64, 65]. Furthermore, polarization in the complete absence of Cdc42 transport has also been observed [66], hinting at yet another pattern forming mechanism encoded within the inter- action network of Cdc42. How these mechanisms operate independently of Bem1-mediated feedback remains an open question that awaits experimental and theoretical analysis. Normal cell division of budding yeast requires the reliable formation of a single bud-site, i.e. a single Cdc42 cluster (polar zone, sometimes also called "polar cap"). Various mutant strains exhibit initial transient formation of multiple Cdc42 clusters [67, 68], which then compete for the limited total amount of Cdc42, leading to a "winner-takes-all" scenario where only one cluster remains eventually [51, 69, 70]. The PAR system in C. elegans So far we have discussed examples for intracellular pattern formation in unicellular prokaryotes (Min) as well in eukaryotes (Cdc42). A well studied instance of intracellular pattern formation in multicellular organisms is the establishment of the anterior-posterior axis in the C. elegans zygote [71–74]. The key players here are two groups of PAR proteins: The aPARs, PAR-3, PAR-6, and aPKC (atypical protein kinase C) localize in the anterior half of the cell. The pPARs, PAR-1, PAR-2, and LGL, localize in the posterior half. In the wild type, polarity is established upon fertilisation by cortical actomyosin flow oriented towards the posterior centrosomes, in other words by active transport of pPAR proteins 9 [73, 75]. After polarity establishment this flow ceases, but polarity is maintained. In ad- dition, it has been shown that polarity can be established without flow [75]. These results suggest that PAR protein polarity in C. elegans is based on a reaction-diffusion mechanism. The protein dynamics are based on the antagonism between membrane-bound aPAR and pPAR proteins, mediated by mutual phosphorylation which initiates membrane detachment at the interface between aPAR and pPAR domains near midcell (see Fig. 2c). Thus, PAR- based pattern formation is driven by (mutual) detachment where opposing zones come into contact, and is therefore quite different than the attachment (recruitment) based systems discussed above. Despite these apparent differences we will argue in the following sections that patterns formation in all three systems is based on the same general principles. GENERAL BIOPHYSICAL PRINCIPLES OF INTRACELLULAR PATTERN FOR- MATION Let us take a bird's eye view and ask: What are the general concepts and recurring themes that are common to pattern formation in all of these biological systems? In all cases the biological function associated with the respective pattern is mediated by membrane-bound proteins alone, in other words: intracellular patterns are membrane-bound patterns (exceptions are discussed further below). Furthermore, the diffusion coefficients of membrane-bound proteins are generically at least two orders of magnitude lower than those of their cytosolic counterparts, e.g. a typical value for diffusion along a membrane would be between 0.01 µm2/s and 0.1 µm2/s, while a typical cytosolic protein has a diffusion coefficient of about 10 µm2/s, e.g. see [66, 76]. The key unifying feature of all protein interaction systems is switching between different protein states or conformations. The conformation (state) of a protein can change as a consequence of interactions with other biomolecules (lipids, nucleotides, or other proteins). Likewise, the interactions available to a protein are determined by its conformation. This can be summarized as the switching paradigm of proteins (Fig. 2d), which is best exemplified for NTPases such as MinD or Cdc42 whose dynamics are in essence driven by deactivation and reactivation through nucleotide exchange. The phosphorylation and dephosphorylation of PAR proteins by kinases and phosphatases, respectively, exemplifies the same principle. 10 In all these cases, switching is tied to membrane affinity, and thus to the flux of proteins into and out of the cytosol. Dynamics based on conformational switching conserve the copy number of the protein. Therefore, intracellular protein dynamics are generically represented by mass-conserving reaction-diffusion systems – and pattern formation in a mass-conserving system can only be based on transport (redistribution), it cannot depend on production or degradation of proteins. In the absence of active transport mechanisms (such as vesicle trafficking) the only available transport process is molecular diffusion. Given that membrane-bound proteins barely diffuse, we can assert that the biophysical role of the cytosol in these systems is that of a (three-dimensional) 'transport layer'. Hence, the (functionally relevant) membrane- bound protein pattern must originate from redistribution via the cytosol, i.e. the coupling of membrane detachment in one spatial region of the cell to membrane attachment in another region, through the maintenance of a diffusive flux in the cytosol. However, transport by diffusion eliminates concentration gradients. Hence, if a diffusive flux is to be maintained, a gradient needs to be sustained. Note that due to fast cytosolic diffusion, this gradient can be rather shallow and still induce the flux necessary to establish the pattern (the flux is simply given by the diffusion coefficient times the gradient). Intracellular pattern formation is the localized accumulation of proteins on the membrane by cytosolic redistribution. In this context, self-organization is the emergence of directed transport that manifests itself as the formation of spatially separated attachment and de- tachment zones, due to the interplay between cytosolic diffusion and protein interactions (reactions). Furthermore, we note that patterns can also be bound to other structures such as the nucleoid [13] or the cytoskeleton [77–79]. In several of these pattern forming systems, the dynamics of a nucleoid-bound, ParA-like ATPase results in different patterns, e.g. midcell localization [80, 81] and pole-to-pole oscillations on the nucleoid of a single cargo as well as equidistant positioning of multiple cargoes [82]. Various mechanisms to explain these patterns have been proposed [83], including models that require ParA filament formation [82, 84, 85] and ones which are based on a self-organizing concentration gradient of the ATPase along the nucleoid [86–90]. In all these cases the dynamics of patterns are based on the conformational switching of proteins between the cytosolic and the nucleoid-bound (slowly diffusing) state. For midcell localization, the diffusive flux of the ATPase on the 11 nucleoid was found to be important [80, 91, 92]. Finally, we want to mention pattern forming systems that are based on a preexisting template. The cell geometry itself is such a template, and macromolecules (phospholipids or specific proteins) can have preferential affinity to accumulate in regions of specific membrane curvature, e.g. the cell poles [93, 94]. However, theoretical analysis of Min protein dynamics indicates that self-organized pattern formation based on lateral instability is robust against heterogeneities in the membrane [95]. The elementary (i.e. most simple) intracellular pattern is cell polarization: the asym- metric accumulation of proteins in a cell. It lacks any intrinsic length scale and merely serves to define a specific region of a cell (anterior/posterior domain, budding site). In the following we will use cell polarity patterns as a paradigm to obtain a mechanistic picture of intracellular pattern formation. Cell polarity: The elementary pattern for intracellular pattern formation How can one construct a general conceptual model for self-organized intracellular pat- tern formation building on the principles discussed in the preceding section? The protein dynamics are based on cycling of proteins between membrane-bound and cytosolic states, and do not depend on production and degradation of proteins (cf. [8]). Hence, in a steady state where the protein distribution is spatially uniform, attachment and detachment pro- cesses must be balanced throughout the cell. Lateral instability, e.g. a Turing instability, simply means that small spatial perturbations will be amplified. Let us therefore imagine a perturbation of the density of a membrane-bound species where at some membrane po- sition the protein concentration will be slightly larger than elsewhere on the membrane. If this perturbation is to be amplified, proteins must be transported to the position where the membrane density is (already) highest. For this transport of proteins, we only have cytosolic diffusion at our disposal. To facilitate a directed transport to a specific position by cytosolic diffusion, the cytosolic density at this position must itself be at a minimum (Fig. 3). In order to reduce the cytosolic density at the position where the membrane density is highest, the balance between attachment and detachment must shift in favour of attachment such that protein mass flows from the cytosol to the membrane. Conversely, in the region where the membrane density is lowest, the attachment-detachment balance must shift in favour of 12 detachment, thereby increasing the cytosolic density in this region. Only if changes in den- sity shift attachment–detachment balance in this fashion will the initial perturbation on the membrane be amplified by further attachment and detachment due to cytosolic transport (Fig. 3). To concisely summarize: Intracellular pattern formation can be understood as the forma- tion of attachment and detachment zones, which are coupled through cytosolic gradients that facilitate protein mass redistribution. In this light, we will now look again at the specific biological systems introduced earlier, and attempt to uncover the basic molecular mechanisms that lead to the formation and maintenance of attachment and detachment zones. QUANTITATIVE MODELS FOR INTRACELLULAR PATTERN FORMING SYS- TEMS The Cdc42 system in S. cerevisiae The key interaction that drives self-organized Cdc42 polarization is the recruitment of GEF by Cdc42, mediated by Bem1, giving rise to mutual recruitment of Cdc42, Bem1 and GEF. In a minimal model, the role of Bem1 and GEF can be summarized by an effective Bem1–GEF complex, which is recruited to Cdc42-GTP on the membrane (Fig. 4a). There, the GEF then recruits more Cdc42 from the cytosol and converts it into the GTP- bound form. As a further simplification, recruitment and nucleotide exchange of Cdc42 by Bem1–GEF complexes can be subsumed into a single step. Similarly hydrolysis of GTP (catalyzed by GAPs) and extraction of CDC42 from the membrane can be conflated to a single membrane dissociation step. Effectively, only active Cdc42 on the membrane and inactive Cdc42 in the cytosol are considered (Fig. 4a). How can this interaction scheme of mutual recruitment establish spatially separated at- tachment and detachment zones for the polarity marker Cdc42? Cdc42-GTP on the mem- brane acts as a "recruitment template" for Bem1–GEF complexes: a zone of high Cdc42- GTP density on the membrane creates an attachment zone for Bem1, which in turn creates an attachment zone for the GEF Cdc24, such that effectively Cdc42-GTP creates an at- tachment zone for Bem1–GEF complexes (cf. panels (1) and (2) in Fig. 4b). A region of 13 high Bem1–GEF density on the membrane, in turn, acts as recruitment template for Cdc42, creating a Cdc42 attachment zone, and locally enhances Cdc42 nucleotide exchange leading to increased local Cdc42-GTP density (cf. panels (1') and (2') in Fig. 4b). In the absence of Cdc42-GTP, very little Bem1 attaches to the membrane, such that detachment dominates. Similarly, in the absence of GEF, Cdc42 is dominantly inactive, such that membrane extrac- tion by GDI, i.e. detachment of Cdc42, dominates. Starting from a uniform state, a spatial perturbation of either density will establish a mutual recruitment zone, with Cdc42–GTP sustaining the attachment zone for Bem1–GEF, which in turn maintains the recruitment and activation zone of Cdc42 (Fig. 4c). Conceptually, cell polarization need not require two protein species that mutually re- cruit each other: conceptual theoretical models for cell-polarity involving only two chemi- cal components (effectively describing a single protein type in two conformational states – membrane-bound and cytosolic) have also been studied [61, 96, 97]. In these models, patters with multiple density peaks show "winner-takes-all" coarsening dynamics due to competi- tion for the conserved total mass of proteins [96] (cf. the discussion of wavelength selection and mass-conserving reaction–diffusion systems below). The Min system in E. coli Pole-to-pole oscillations are the result of interactions between MinD and MinE. In Fig. 5, the key phases of the oscillation cycle are shown. Membrane-bound MinD facilitates further accumulation of MinD and MinE on the membrane through recruitment. The recruitment of MinD shifts the attachment-detachment balance towards further attachment. In contrast, the recruitment of MinE shift this balance towards detachment. The structure of a polar zone is such that MinE is accumulated in the form of MinDE complexes at its rim (sometimes called the "E-ring"), whereas MinD accumulates at its tip (see Fig. 5 panels (2) and (4)). A theoretical analysis of Min protein dynamics revealed that self-organized Min protein pattern formation is based on two requirements [30]: The total copy number of MinD must exceed that of MinE, and the recruitment rate of MinE must be larger than that of MinD. The first condition ensures that all of the MinE can be bound as MinDE complexes on the membrane (MinE-MinD detachment zone, panels (2) and (4) in Fig. 5) while leaving a fraction of MinD free to initiate and maintain a MinD attachment zone. The second 14 condition causes MinE to be trapped immediately upon entry into a polar zone (MinD-MinE attachment zone) and thereby "sequestrated" at the rim, creating a localized MinE-MinD detachment zone (panels (1) and (3) in Fig. 5). Rebinding of MinE to the MinD-MinE attachment zone at the tip of the polar zone is favoured due to the faster recruitment of MinE and the fact that MinD is temporarily inactive after detachment. This leads to the progressive conversion of attachment zones into detachment zones due to the shifting balance in favor of MinDE complexes (detachment). Below we will discuss that the inactivation of MinD upon MinE-stimulated hydrolysis is essential for the establishment of intrinsic length scales and for the dependence of the pattern–forming process on cell geometry (see also Fig. 7). Biochemically the Min system of E. coli and the Cdc42 system of S. cerevisiea, are closely related: both MinD and Cdc42 are NTPases regulated by enzymatic proteins such as NTPase-activating proteins (NAPs), even though the regulation of Cdc42 activity is much more complex. As we have argued above, the pattern forming dynamics of both systems follow the same underlying physical principle: self-organized spatial separation of attachment and detachment zones. Indeed, theoretical models have predicted that Min protein dynamics can also give rise to stationary polar patterns [30]. Conversely, oscillations of Cdc42-marked polar zones in budding yeast have been observed experimentally [98], while the non-spherical fission yeast exhibits pole-to-pole oscillations of Cdc42 clusters during the polar growth phase [99]. This raises the question whether there is a common underlying mechanism that unifies Min protein patterns and Cdc42 polarization at the physical level. The PAR system in C. elegans PAR protein polarization in C. elegans is based on an antagonism between membrane- bound aPAR and pPAR protein through mutual phosphorylation, cf. [75]. The major differ- ence relative to the above discussed systems is the lack of an evident biochemical mechanism for the formation of attachment zones, such as recruitment. Instead for C. elegans, attach- ment zones result from mutual exclusion. In a zone with high aPAR concentration on the membrane only aPAR can attach, as pPARs are immediately phosphorylated. Similarly, in zones with high pPAR membrane concentration only pPAR can attach. At the interface be- tween aPAR and pPAR zones each protein class drives the other off the membrane. Hence, 15 the interface acts as detachment zone for both aPAR and pPAR, whereas the anterior pole (aPAR dominant) acts as aPAR attachment zone, and the posterior pole (pPAR) acts as pPAR attachment zone. The key to pattern formation is the detachment zone, i.e. the maintenance of the interface. There, aPAR and pPAR domains are actively separated from each other, and cycling between the interface and the respective attachment zones maintains the bi-polar pattern. Theoretical analysis [75] shows that a stable interface requires the rates of the antagonistic interactions to be comparable. A very interesting aspect of PAR protein pattern formation is the role of the cortical flow [73, 75]. In the wild type it is used to segregate aPAR zones from pPAR zones, i.e. to form the respective attachment zones. The polarized state is maintained after the flow ceases, showing that maintenance of the interface is independent of the flow, i.e. it is self-organized. ADVANCED INTRACELLULAR PATTERN FORMATION: WAVELENGTH SE- LECTION, DEPENDENCE ON CELL GEOMETRY, AND MULTISTABILITY OF PATTERNS Pattern formation and length scale selection: the classical picture Traditionally the phenomenon of self-organized pattern formation in reaction-diffusion systems has been intrinsically linked to the postulated existence of a characteristic length scale [2]. In particular, most authors define a Turing pattern as a pattern with a character- istic length scale [100]. In our discussion so far such a length scale has only been mentioned in passing as a phenomenon observed in specific E. coli mutants, and in budding yeast mu- tants as a transient pattern of multiple Cdc42 clusters. Indeed, the theoretical analysis of all quantitative models [30, 55, 71] discussed so far reveals that the existence of such a length scale is in no way generic – despite the fact that all patterns emerge from a lateral instabil- ity induced by diffusive coupling, i.e. a Turing instability. On the contrary, it appears that the phenomenon biologists refer to as "the winner takes all" and physicist as "coarsening" is the generic case, cf. [27, 30, 101, 102]. Hence, the generic pattern is a polarized state with a single concentration maximum and a single concentration minimum for each chemical component irrespective of the system size. In fact, the question of length scale selection is a highly nontrivial problem, and can only 16 be addressed in general by numerical simulations. Linear stability analysis (as introduced by Turing) only predicts the length scale of the (transient) pattern that initially forms from the uniform state (see Fig. 1a). This should not be confused with the length scale of the final pattern. For instance, coarsening dynamics ("the winner takes all") are generic examples for dynamics where the length scale collapses to the system size (or an intermediate length scale) regardless of the initially selected length scale [103]. A case where the length scale is predicted correctly by the linear stability analysis is when the growth of the pattern saturates at small amplitude [2]. Some authors include saturation at small amplitude in their definition of a Turing pattern [104]. While this definition is mathematically rigorous, it is also very restrictive: For technical mathematical reasons this (supercritical bifurcation, near threshold) case implies that the pattern must vanish if some system parameters are slightly changed. If the pattern does not saturate at a very small amplitude early on, no (reliable) prediction about the final pattern can be made based on the linear stability analysis (except that some non-uniform pattern exists). From the mathematical point of view this specific case (supercritical bifurcation, near threshold) is very attractive as it lends itself to analytical calculations [2]. To readers less interested in the mathematical details, these points may seem overly technical. However, it is crucial to realize that – from the biological perspective – such technical limitations (a pattern with very small amplitude (weak signal) that is highly sensitive to parameter changes) imply patterns that are highly fragile (cf. [105]), and will therefore be eliminated by natural selection. In that light it is not surprising that (robust) quantitative models of biological systems, like those presented above, do not meet the constraints of small amplitude and vicinity to a supercritical bifurcation. Partly because most mathematically motivated work on pattern selection is based on the assumption that these constraints are met, very little is known about pattern selection in (evolutionarily robust) biological systems. Yet, several key aspects of pattern selection can be inferred from the theoretical analysis of models for actual biological systems. For example, theoretical analysis of Min protein patterns [30] showed that standing wave patterns with a finite wavelength emerge if the lat- eral redistribution of Min proteins is canalized, see Fig. 7. In terms of the general principles discussed above, this means that attachment and detachment zones are strongly coupled through cytosolic transport. The flux off the membrane in a detachment zone is of the same order of magnitude as the flux onto the membrane in the attachment zone. Hence, the frac- 17 tion of cytosolic proteins remains approximately constant during the redistribution process (Fig. 7a). As we have discussed, attachment and detachment zones are regulated by the membrane kinetics of the specific biochemical model, while transport depends on cytosolic kinetics and diffusion. Canalized transfer leads to the emergence of a characteristic sepa- ration distance between attachment and detachment zones which depends in a nontrivial manner on the system parameters (Fig. 7a). The particular parameter dependence of such characteristic redistribution length scales remains an open question for the Min system, and even more so for general reaction diffusion systems. However, it was demonstrated that the total mass flux due to canalized transfer can be inferred from the linear stability analysis for the Min model [30]. The flux coupling (cytosolic exchange) between detachment and at- tachment zones is weak, if a cytosolic reservoir is filled and depleted during detachment- and attachment-dominant phases, respectively (see Fig. 7b). It seems intuitive that a redistribu- tion process through a "well-mixed" cytosolic reservoir does not dictate an intrinsic length scale for pattern forming dynamics. Moreover, the analysis of quantitative models (such as the Min model) does provide strong evidence that length scale selection in reaction-diffusion systems essentially relates to the length scales of directed ("canalized") transport. However, the precise details underlying the emergence of intrinsic length scales remain unknown. Cell geometry and pattern selection In the previous section we discussed why it is important to consider the seemingly tech- nical limitations underlying some mathematical results about pattern formation in order to correctly understand quantitative biological models for intracellular pattern formation. Besides the question of length scale selection, the effect of system geometry (i.e. cell shape) is in this respect another case in point. At first, linear stability analysis of reaction-diffusion systems was exclusively restricted to planar geometries such as lines and flat surfaces. Only very recently, the method was extended to account for (2d) circular geometries where dynamics can take place on the boundary of the circle (membrane) as well as in the bulk (cytosol), and proteins exchange between the two domains (membrane-cytosol cycling) [106]. This important first step to- wards quantitative modeling of intracellular protein dynamics was still limited to purely linear attachment-detachment dynamics (thus excluding the cases of cooperative attach- 18 ment, recruitment, or antagonistic detachment). Later, linear stability analysis methods were extended to general attachment-detachment kinetics by for (3d) spherical geometry [55], and for (2d) elliptical geometry [30]. The extension to elliptical geometry revealed a very important point [30]: it is in no way generic that patterns align with the long axis of a cell, i.e. there is in general no intrinsic preference for the selection of long axis patterns over short axis patterns. From a biological perspective this is a crucial finding, since proper axis selection is typically linked to the spatial nature of the biological function mediated by the pattern in the first place. Intuitively, one may expect that axis selection is connected to the "characteristic length scale" of the pattern obtained from a linear stability analysis in a planar (flat) geometry: whichever axis length of the cell is closer to this "characteristic length scale" determines the axis that is selected. The intuition behind this is that the pattern has "to fit" into the cell. So far, however, there is no evidence to support this intuition. On the contrary, it appears that the question of axis selection is much more complicated. In a study combining theory and experiments Wu et al. [26, 27] analyzed the Min protein patterns in rectangular cell geometries of various sizes and aspect ratios. The experiments found that a broad range of patterns (aligned with the long axis or the short axis) can emerge in the same system geometries. Hence, intracellular Min protein patterns are multistable, and can conform to a variety of intrinsic length scales instead of one "characteristic" length scale. Theoretical analysis [27] confirmed multistability of Min patterns, and was able to link all observations to the emergence of an intrinsic length scale for diffusive cytosolic redistribution ("canalized transport") in the model: the stronger the flux-coupling between attachment and detachment zones, the stronger was the dependence of the pattern-forming process on cell geometry, and the greater the number of multistable patterns with distinct symmetries (long axis or short axis alignment) observed in a broad range of rectangular cell geometries [27]. This strongly suggest that pattern selection and the influence of cell geometry are – just like wavelength selection – closely tied to the length scale of lateral transport and the strength of the coupling between attachment and detachment zones. Note that this is a very different picture from the one presented by "activator–inhibitor" models. In the latter, the length scale is set by the degradation and production length scale, e.g. the length scale over which autocatalytic production of the slowly diffusing component (activator) dominates over its own degradation. In contrast, for intracellular protein dynamics the essential length 19 scale appears to be the (mean) distance over which membrane-bound proteins (the slowly diffusing components) are redistributed in the (fast diffusing) cytosolic state following their detachment. We will next discuss how the switch-like behaviour of proteins appears to be essential for the emergence and regulation of such transport length scales. The different roles of cytosolic kinetics and membrane kinetics As we discussed above, the switch-like behaviour of proteins between active and inactive states is a central paradigm of protein dynamics. In many cases the switch alters the affinity of proteins for the membrane and can thus be utilized to stimulate attachment or detachment. In case of the Min system in E. coli only active MinD-ATP can bind and be recruited to the membrane. As theoretical analysis [30] has shown, this property is essential for the regulation of intracellular transport and the establishment of "canalized transfer": Since MinD detaches from the membrane in the inactive MinD-ADP form it cannot immediately rebind. Hence, if the timescale of cytosolic reactivation (nucleotide exchange) is sufficiently long, a MinD protein detaching from a polar zone with high MinD membrane density can leave the polar zone, by diffusion, before being reactivated. In this way, rebinding of detached MinD to polar zones can be suppressed even if the affinity of cytosolic MinD-ATP for membrane-bound MinD is very high. In fact, a very high affinity for membrane-bound MinD can serve to promote rebinding of MinD-ATP in new (weak) polar zones. In other words: to promote directed transport of MinD from high (MinD and MinE membrane) density region to a low density region. In this way, the high density region becomes a detachment zone and the low density region an attachment zone. Increasing the affinity of cytosolic MinD-ATP to membrane-bound MinD (recruitment rate) simply increases the attachment in the low density region – but not in the high density region where MinD detached and cannot rebind due to delayed nucleotide exchange. Hence, the coupling (mass flux) between detachment and attachment zones increases with the MinD recruitment rate, which leads to "canalized transfer". A recent study [107] has also shown that the interplay between a membrane affinity switch and cell geometry can lead to an entirely new type of intracellular patterning that is not based on lateral instabilities (such as the Turing instability) or excitability. In this case the 20 uniform steady state does not become laterally unstable but is replaced by a non-uniform pattern, i.e. it ceases to exist. The experimental observation [108] is that the MinD homolog AtMinD from Arabidopsis thaliana forms a bipolar pattern in ∆MinDE E. coli cells. There is evidence that the ATPase AtMinD can bind (cooperatively) to the membrane in both, its ADP and its ATP form. Assuming that AtMinD detaches from the membrane in the ADP bound form, the theoretical analysis shows that the membrane distribution of AtMinD in steady state is always non-uniform (bi-polar) if, (i) the membrane affinities of AtMinD-ADP and AtMinD-ADP are different, and (ii) the geometry of the cell deviates from a spherical shape. The mechanism underlying such geometry induced pattern formation is based on the local ratio of membrane surface area to cytosolic volume: in an elliptical cell geometry, a protein detaching from a cell pole is more likely to re-encounter the membrane in unit time than a protein that detaches from a site closer to midcell. By utilizing different membrane affinities (of ADP and ATP states) and cytosolic switching (between these states) a protein system can then establish highly robust bipolar patterns that reflect the cell's geometry. Again, they key process underlying pattern formation is cytosolic redistribution – in this case combined with geometry-dependent reattachment. MASS-CONSERVING REACTION DIFFUSION MODELS: A NEW PARADIGM? In the preceding sections we emphasized that mass conservation is the major unifying property of intracellular pattern-forming protein dynamics. Over the past decade, mass- conserving reaction-diffusion systems received considerable attention in the theoretical lit- erature [12, 96, 97, 102, 109–113]. These studies try to answer how mass-conservation affect reaction-diffusion dynamics. But what is the relevance for biological systems? In [97] a mass-conserving model for cell polarity is proposed – where mass-conservation leads to the halting of a propagating wave front. This "pinned" wave represents the polarized pattern. It has been argued that the corresponding pattern-forming mechanism is not related to a Turing instability but instead based on excitability and bistability [97, 112]. A similar line or reasoning is presented in [102]. However, it has been pointed out recently [114, 115] that a Turing instability in the "wave-pinning" model is recovered upon parameter change. Other studies report that mass-conserving reaction diffusion systems are prone to coarsening [96, 109]. However, it remains elusive whether a general relation between mass-conservation 21 and coarsening exists. Recently, it has been shown that the general mechanism of pattern formation in mass- conserving reaction diffusion systems is based on the lateral redistribution of the conserved quantities [12]. The total amount of conserved quantities (protein copy number) determines the position and stabilities of chemical equilibria. Spatiotemporal redistribution of conserved quantities shifts local chemical equilibria and is generically induced by any lateral instability with unequal diffusion coefficients (such as the Turing instability). The pattern forming dynamics simply follow the movement of local equilibria and the final patterns are scaffolded by the spatial distribution of local equilibria. This study further demonstrated that "wave- pinning" patterns originate from the same physical processes as Turing instabilities: the redistribution of conserved quantities and the shifting local chemical equilibria. In future research it will be interesting to see how the formation of attachment and detachment zones can be formalized within the mass-redistribution framework. SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION It should be clear by now that activator–inhibitor models do not provide the appropriate concepts to account for intracellular pattern formation. Rather, the generic key feature of pattern forming protein system is conformational switching. Proteins cycle between different states such as active and inactive, or membrane-bound and cytosolic. It is the switching of (conformational) states that drives the system and leads to pattern formation, not the production and degradation of proteins, which is the basis of any activator–inhibitor or activator–depletion model. Any dynamics based on the switching (conformational) states conserved the total copy number. Therefore, the proper models for intracellular protein dynamics are mass-conserving reaction-diffusion systems. In any mass-conserving system pattern formation has to be based on redistribution of mass. The question to be asked about self-organization in such systems is how redistribution comes about, i.e. how directed transport is established and maintained. In the context of intracellular protein pattern formation there is a clear functional division between membrane-bound and cytosolic protein distributions: The biologically (function- ally) relevant pattern is that of the membrane-bound factor(s), while the cytosol acts as a transport medium which facilitates the formation and maintenance of the membrane-bound 22 pattern. The basis of intracellular pattern formation is therefore the emergence of spatially separated attachment and detachment zones and their coupling (transport from detach- ment to attachment zone) through cytosolic gradients. The key design principle for pattern forming protein networks is therefore the ability to set up and maintain attachment and detachment zones in the presence of ongoing protein redistribution. We have discussed how pattern formation in three different biological systems is facili- tated by the formation of attachment and detachment zones. In budding yeast, cell polarity is established by localized accumulation of Cdc42 on the inner face of the plasma mem- brane. Pattern formation is based on the localized formation of mutual attachment zones for Cdc42-GTP and Bem1–GEF complexes through mutual recruitment. In E. coli, pole- to-pole oscillations emerge due to the interactions of MinD and MinE. This process is based on the formation of attachment zones with high MinD membrane density due to the re- cruitment of MinD and MinE from the cytosol. If the balance in a polar zone is shifted towards higher MinE/MinD ratios, an attachment zone becomes a detachment zone. The sequestration of MinE in detachment zones enables the formation of new attachment zones some distance away. The conversion of attachment zones to detachment zones and vice versa by the slow shift in the MinE/MinD ratio within a zone is the basis for the oscillation. The establishment of the anterior-posterior axis in C. elegans is based on PAR protein polar- ization. Here, pattern formation originates from the formation of a (mutual) detachment zone near midcell, and attachment zones exclusive for pPAR or aPAR, respectively, at the two cell poles. The establishment and maintenance of this pattern requires that the rates of both antagonistic processes are balanced. The question about length scale selection and pattern selection in general is still open. Apart from mathematically idealized cases that do not apply to biological systems no general statements about the wavelengths of patterns can be made. However, theoretical studies of Min protein pattern formation suggest that the emergence and selection of finite wave- lengths is closely tied to the simultaneous formation and diffusive coupling of attachment and detachment zones. A key step in the regulation of the diffusive coupling between at- tachment and detachment zones is the cytosolic switching between conformation with high and low affinity for the membrane (cytosolic nucleotide exchange). Strikingly, there is evi- dence that such cytosolic switching processes play a key role in mediating the sensitivity of self-organized pattern formation to cell geometry [27]. 23 Many key questions about intracellular pattern formation remain open. In our opin- ion, the focus on concepts based on activator–inhibitor models in the discussion of pattern formation phenomena has been a hindrance to progress rather than a help. Intracellular pattern forming protein dynamics are most generally expressed by mass- conserving reaction-diffusion systems. Local equilibria, as recently suggested [12], are a promising candidate for a general and unifying theoretical framework for such systems. To advance our understanding of intracellular protein dynamics a theoretically rigorous analysis of pattern forming instabilities in mass-conserving reaction-diffusion systems would be highly desirable. In his seminal article Turing presented the general idea of pattern forming instabilities in reaction-diffusion systems. Since its publication 65 years ago only little has been learned about the general physical principles underlying the Turing instability. We expect that a focus on the mass-conserving case will finally enable us to extract some general physical principles of pattern formation systems based on Turing's lateral instability. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This research was funded by the German Excellence Initiative via the NanoSystems Ini- tiative Munich, and by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) via Project B02 within SFB 1032 (Nanoagents for SpatioTemporal Control of Molecular and Cellular Reactions), Areas A and C within GRK2062 (Molecular Principles of Synthetic Biology), and Project P03 within TRR174 (Spatiotemporal Dynamics of Bacterial Cells). The authors thank S. Bergeler and W. Daalman for feedback on the manuscript. ∗ [email protected] [1] Turing AM. The chemical basis of morphogenesis. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B, Biological Sciences. 1952;237(641):37–72. DOI: 10.1007/BF02459572. [2] Cross M, Hohenberg P. Pattern formation outside of equilibrium. Reviews of Modern Physics. 1993;65(3). [3] Segel La, Jackson JL. Dissipative structure: an explanation and an ecological example. Journal of theoretical biology. 1972;37:545–559. DOI: 10.1016/0022-5193(72)90090-2. 24 [4] Gierer A, Meinhardt H. A theory of biological pattern formation. Kybernetik. 1972 dec;12(1):30–9. [5] Meinhardt H, Gierer A. Pattern formation by local self activation and lateral inhibition. BioEssays. 2000;22:753–760. [6] Meinhardt H. Models of Biological Pattern Formation: From Elementary Steps to the Or- ganization of Embryonic Axes. Current Topics in Developmental Biology. 2008;81:1–63. DOI: 10.1016/S0070-2153(07)81001-5. [7] Frey E, Halatek J, Kretschmer S, Schwille P. Protein Pattern Formation. Springer-Verlag GmbH, Heidelberg; 2018. Edited by P. Bassereau and P. C. A. Sens; to be published [arXiv:1801.01365]. [8] Shamir M, Bar-On Y, Phillips R, Milo R. SnapShot: Timescales in Cell Biology. Cell. 2016 Mar;164(6):1302–1302.e1. DOI: 10.1016/j.cell.2016.02.058. [9] Kondo S, Miura T. Reaction-diffusion model as a framework for understanding biological pattern formation. Science. 2010 Sep;329(5999):1616–20. DOI: 10.1126/science.1179047. [10] Tarnita CE, Bonachela JA, Sheffer E, Guyton JA, Coverdale TC, Long RA, et al. A theoret- ical foundation for multi-scale regular vegetation patterns. Nature. 2017 01;541(7637):398– 401. DOI: 10.1038/nature20801. [11] Rietkerk M, van de Koppel J. Regular pattern formation in real ecosystems. Trends Ecol Evol. 2008 Mar;23(3):169–75. DOI: 10.1016/j.tree.2007.10.013. [12] Halatek J, Frey E. Rethinking pattern formation in reaction–diffusion systems. Nature Physics. 2018;DOI: 10.1038/s41567-017-0040-5. [13] Lutkenhaus J. Assembly dynamics of the bacterial MinCDE system and spatial regula- tion of the Z ring. Annual Review of Biochemistry. 2007 Jan;76:539–62. DOI: 10.1146/an- nurev.biochem.75.103004.142652. [14] Raskin DM, de Boer Pa. Rapid pole-to-pole oscillation of a protein required for directing division to the middle of Escherichia coli. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 1999 Apr;96(9):4971–6. [15] Hu Z, Mukherjee A, Pichoff S, Lutkenhaus J. The MinC component of the division site se- lection system in Escherichia coli interacts with FtsZ to prevent polymerization. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 1999 Dec;96(26):14819–14824. 25 [16] Hu Z, Gogol EP, Lutkenhaus J. Dynamic assembly of MinD on phospholipid vesicles regulated by ATP and MinE. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2002 May;99(10):6761– 6766. [17] Szeto TH, Rowland SL, Rothfield LI, King GF. Membrane localization of MinD is me- diated by a C-terminal motif that is conserved across eubacteria, archaea, and chloro- plasts. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2002 Nov;99(24):15693–15698. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.232590599. [18] Lackner LL, Raskin DM, de Boer PAJ. ATP-dependent interactions between Escherichia coli Min proteins and the phospholipid membrane in vitro. Journal of Bacteriology. 2003 Feb;185(3):735–749. DOI: 10.1128/JB.185.3.735-749.2003. [19] Mileykovskaya E, Fishov I, Fu X, Corbin BD, Margolin W, Dowhan W. Effects of phospho- lipid composition on MinD-membrane interactions in vitro and in vivo. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 2003 Jun;278(25):22193–22198. DOI: 10.1074/jbc.M302603200. [20] Hu Z, Lutkenhaus J. Topological regulation of cell division in Escherichia coli involves rapid pole to pole oscillation of the division inhibitor MinC under the control of MinD and MinE. Molecular Microbiology. 1999 Oct;34(1):82–90. [21] Hu Z, Lutkenhaus J. Topological regulation of cell division in E. coli. spatiotemporal oscilla- tion of MinD requires stimulation of its ATPase by MinE and phospholipid. Molecular Cell. 2001 Jun;7(6):1337–1343. [22] Touhami A, Jericho M, Rutenberg AD. Temperature Dependence of MinD Oscillation in Escherichia coli: Running Hot and Fast. Journal of Bacteriology. 2006 Oct;188(21):7661– 7667. DOI: 10.1128/JB.00911-06. [23] Park KT, Wu W, Battaile KP, Lovell S, Holyoak T, Lutkenhaus J. The Min Oscillator Uses MinD-Dependent Conformational Changes in MinE to Spatially Regulate Cytokinesis. Cell. 2011;146(3):396–407. [24] Schweizer J, Loose M, Bonny M, Kruse K, Monch I, Schwille P. Geometry sensing by self-organized protein patterns. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2012 Sep;109(38):15283–15288. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1206953109. [25] Loose M, Fischer-Friedrich E, Ries J, Kruse K, Schwille P. Spatial regulators for bac- terial cell division self-organize into surface waves in vitro. Science (New York, NY). 2008;320(5877):789–92. DOI: 10.1126/science.1154413. 26 [26] Wu F, van Schie BGC, Keymer JE, Dekker C. Symmetry and scale orient Min protein patterns in shaped bacterial sculptures. Nature Nanotechnology. 2015 Jun;10:719–726. [27] Wu F, Halatek J, Reiter M, Kingma E, Frey E, Dekker C. Multistability and dynamic tran- sitions of intracellular Min protein patterns. Molecular Systems Biology. 2016 jun;12(6):642– 653. DOI: 10.15252/MSB.20156724. [28] Huang KC, Meir Y, Wingreen NS. Dynamic structures in Escherichia coli: spontaneous formation of MinE rings and MinD polar zones. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2003 oct;100(22):12724–8. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2135445100. [29] Fange D, Elf J. Noise-induced Min phenotypes in E. coli. Plos Computational Biology. 2006 Jun;2(6):e80. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.0020080. [30] Halatek J, Frey E. Highly canalized MinD transfer and MinE sequestration explain the origin of robust MinCDE-protein dynamics. Cell reports. 2012 jun;1(6):741–52. DOI: 10.1016/j.celrep.2012.04.005. [31] Hoffmann M, Schwarz US. Oscillations of Min-proteins in micropatterned environ- ments: a three-dimensional particle-based stochastic simulation approach. Soft Matter. 2014;10(14):2388–2396. DOI: 10.1039/c3sm52251b. [32] Vecchiarelli AG, Li M, Mizuuchi M, Hwang LC, Seol Y, Neuman KC, et al. Membrane-bound MinDE complex acts as a toggle switch that drives Min oscillation coupled to cytoplasmic de- pletion of MinD. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2016 Mar;113(11):E1479– 88. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1600644113. [33] Halatek J, Frey E. Effective 2D model does not account for geometry sensing by self-organized proteins patterns. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2014 May;111(18):E1817. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1220971111. [34] Kretschmer S, Zieske K, Schwille P. Large-scale modulation of reconstituted Min protein patterns and gradients by defined mutations in MinE's membrane targeting sequence. PLoS One. 2017;12(6):e0179582. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0179582. [35] Fischer-Friedrich E, Meacci G, Lutkenhaus J, Chate H, Kruse K. Intra- and intercellular fluctuations in Min-protein dynamics decrease with cell length. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2010 Mar;107(14):6134–6139. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.0911708107. [36] Sliusarenko O, Heinritz J, Emonet T, Jacobs-Wagner C. High-throughput, subpixel precision analysis of bacterial morphogenesis and intracellular spatio-temporal dynamics. Molecular 27 Microbiology. 2011 Mar;80(3):612–627. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2958.2011.07579.x. [37] Corbin BD, Yu XC, Margolin W. Exploring intracellular space: function of the Min system in round-shaped Escherichia coli. The EMBO journal. 2002 Apr;21(8):1998–2008. DOI: 10.1093/emboj/21.8.1998. [38] Shih YL, Kawagishi I, Rothfield L. The MreB and Min cytoskeletal-like systems play indepen- dent roles in prokaryotic polar differentiation. Molecular Microbiology. 2005 Oct;58(4):917– 928. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2958.2005.04841.x. [39] Varma A, Huang KC, Young KD. The Min system as a general cell geometry detection mecha- nism: branch lengths in Y-shaped Escherichia coli cells affect Min oscillation patterns and di- vision dynamics. Journal of Bacteriology. 2008 Mar;190(6):2106–17. DOI: 10.1128/JB.00720- 07. [40] Johnson DI. Cdc42: An essential Rho-type GTPase controlling eukaryotic cell polarity. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev. 1999 Mar;63(1):54–105. [41] Chant J, Herskowitz I. Genetic control of bud site selection in yeast by a set of gene products that constitute a morphogenetic pathway. Cell. 1991 Jun;65(7):1203–12. [42] Koch G, Tanaka K, Masuda T, Yamochi W, Nonaka H, Takai Y. Association of the Rho family small GTP-binding proteins with Rho GDP dissociation inhibitor (Rho GDI) in Sac- charomyces cerevisiae. Oncogene. 1997 Jul;15(4):417–22. DOI: 10.1038/sj.onc.1201194. [43] Johnson JL, Erickson JW, Cerione RA. New insights into how the Rho guanine nucleotide dissociation inhibitor regulates the interaction of Cdc42 with membranes. J Biol Chem. 2009 Aug;284(35):23860–71. DOI: 10.1074/jbc.M109.031815. [44] Bi E, Park HO. Cell polarization and cytokinesis in budding yeast. Genetics. 2012 Jun;191(2):347–87. DOI: 10.1534/genetics.111.132886. [45] Butty AC, Perrinjaquet N, Petit A, Jaquenoud M, Segall JE, Hofmann K, et al. A positive feedback loop stabilizes the guanine-nucleotide exchange factor Cdc24 at sites of polarization. EMBO J. 2002 Apr;21(7):1565–76. DOI: 10.1093/emboj/21.7.1565. [46] Bose I, Irazoqui JE, Moskow JJ, Bardes ES, Zyla TR, Lew DJ. Assembly of scaffold-mediated complexes containing Cdc42p, the exchange factor Cdc24p, and the effector Cla4p required for cell cycle-regulated phosphorylation of Cdc24p. J Biol Chem. 2001 Mar;276(10):7176–86. [47] Slaughter BD, Das A, Schwartz JW, Rubinstein B, Li R. Dual modes of cdc42 recycling fine-tune polarized morphogenesis. Dev Cell. 2009 Dec;17(6):823–35. 28 DOI: 10.1016/j.devcel.2009.10.022. [48] Kozubowski L, Saito K, Johnson JM, Howell AS, Zyla TR, Lew DJ. Symmetry-breaking polarization driven by a Cdc42p GEF-PAK complex. Curr Biol. 2008 Nov;18(22):1719–26. DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2008.09.060. [49] Freisinger T, Klunder B, Johnson J, Muller N, Pichler G, Beck G, et al. Establishment of a robust single axis of cell polarity by coupling multiple positive feedback loops. Nat Commun. 2013;4:1807. DOI: 10.1038/ncomms2795. [50] Marco E, Wedlich-Soldner R, Li R, Altschuler SJ, Wu LF. Endocytosis optimizes the dynamic localization of membrane proteins that regulate cortical polarity. Cell. 2007 Apr;129(2):411– 22. [51] Witte K, Strickland D, Glotzer M. Cell cycle entry triggers a switch between two modes of Cdc42 activation during yeast polarization. Elife. 2017 Jul;6. DOI: 10.7554/eLife.26722. [52] Rapali P, Mitteau R, Braun C, Massoni-Laporte A, Unlu C, Bataille L, et al. Scaffold- mediated gating of Cdc42 signalling flux. Elife. 2017 Mar;6. DOI: 10.7554/eLife.25257. [53] Woods B, Kuo CC, Wu CF, Zyla TR, Lew DJ. Polarity establishment requires localized activation of Cdc42. J Cell Biol. 2015 Oct;211(1):19–26. DOI: 10.1083/jcb.201506108. [54] Irazoqui JE, Gladfelter AS, Lew DJ. Scaffold-mediated symmetry breaking by Cdc42p. Nat Cell Biol. 2003 Dec;5(12):1062–70. DOI: 10.1038/ncb1068. [55] Klunder B, Freisinger T, Wedlich-Soldner R, Frey E. GDI-mediated cell polarization in yeast provides precise spatial and temporal control of Cdc42 signaling. PLoS Comput Biol. 2013;9(12):e1003396. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1003396. [56] Goryachev AB, Pokhilko AV. Dynamics of Cdc42 network embodies a Turing- type mechanism of yeast cell polarity. FEBS Lett. 2008 Apr;582(10):1437–43. DOI: 10.1016/j.febslet.2008.03.029. [57] Wedlich-Soldner R, Altschuler S, Wu L, Li R. Spontaneous cell polarization through actomyosin-based delivery of the Cdc42 GTPase. Science. 2003 Feb;299(5610):1231–5. DOI: 10.1126/science.1080944. [58] Wedlich-Soldner R, Wai SC, Schmidt T, Li R. Robust cell polarity is a dynamic state established by coupling transport and GTPase signaling. J Cell Biol. 2004 Sep;166(6):889– 900. DOI: 10.1083/jcb.200405061. 29 [59] Muller N, Piel M, Calvez V, Voituriez R, Gon¸calves-S´a J, Guo CL, et al. A Predictive Model for Yeast Cell Polarization in Pheromone Gradients. PLoS Comput Biol. 2016 Apr;12(4):e1004795. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1004795. [60] Hawkins RJ, B´enichou O, Piel M, Voituriez R. Rebuilding cytoskeleton roads: active- transport-induced polarization of cells. Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys. 2009 Oct;80(4 Pt 1):040903. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.80.040903. [61] Altschuler SJ, Angenent SB, Wang Y, Wu LF. On the spontaneous emergence of cell polarity. Nature. 2008 Aug;454(7206):886–9. DOI: 10.1038/nature07119. [62] Layton AT, Savage NS, Howell AS, Carroll SY, Drubin DG, Lew DJ. Modeling vesicle traffic reveals unexpected consequences for Cdc42p-mediated polarity establishment. Curr Biol. 2011 Feb;21(3):184–94. DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2011.01.012. [63] Savage NS, Layton AT, Lew DJ. Mechanistic mathematical model of polarity in yeast. Mol Biol Cell. 2012 May;23(10):1998–2013. DOI: 10.1091/mbc.E11-10-0837. [64] Smith SE, Rubinstein B, Mendes Pinto I, Slaughter BD, Unruh JR, Li R. Independence of symmetry breaking on Bem1-mediated autocatalytic activation of Cdc42. J Cell Biol. 2013 Sep;202(7):1091–106. DOI: 10.1083/jcb.201304180. [65] Laan L, Koschwanez JH, Murray AW. Evolutionary adaptation after crippling cell polariza- tion follows reproducible trajectories. Elife. 2015 Oct;4. DOI: 10.7554/eLife.09638. [66] Bendez´u FO, Vincenzetti V, Vavylonis D, Wyss R, Vogel H, Martin SG. Spontaneous Cdc42 polarization independent of GDI-mediated extraction and actin-based trafficking. PLoS Biol. 2015 Apr;13(4):e1002097. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pbio.1002097. [67] Caviston JP, Tcheperegine SE, Bi E. Singularity in budding: a role for the evolutionarily conserved small GTPase Cdc42p. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2002 Sep;99(19):12185–90. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.182370299. [68] Knaus M, Pelli-Gulli MP, van Drogen F, Springer S, Jaquenoud M, Peter M. Phosphorylation of Bem2p and Bem3p may contribute to local activation of Cdc42p at bud emergence. EMBO J. 2007 Oct;26(21):4501–13. DOI: 10.1038/sj.emboj.7601873. [69] Howell AS, Savage NS, Johnson SA, Bose I, Wagner AW, Zyla TR, et al. Singularity in polarization: rewiring yeast cells to make two buds. Cell. 2009 Nov;139(4):731–43. DOI: 10.1016/j.cell.2009.10.024. 30 [70] Wu CF, Lew DJ. Beyond symmetry-breaking: competition and negative feedback in GTPase regulation. Trends Cell Biol. 2013 Oct;23(10):476–83. DOI: 10.1016/j.tcb.2013.05.003. [71] Goehring NW, Trong PK, Bois JS, Chowdhury D, Nicola EM, Hyman AA, et al. Po- larization of PAR proteins by advective triggering of a pattern-forming system. Science. 2011;334(Nov):1137–1141. arXiv:1011.1669v3. DOI: 10.1126/science.1208619. [72] Hoege C, Hyman AA. Principles of PAR polarity in Caenorhabditis elegans embryos. Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology. 2013;14(5):315–322. DOI: 10.1038/nrm3558. [73] Munro E, Nance J, Priess JR. Cortical flows powered by asymmetrical contraction transport PAR proteins to establish and maintain anterior-posterior polarity in the early C. elegans embryo. Developmental Cell. 2004 Sep;7(3):413–424. DOI: 10.1016/j.devcel.2004.08.001. [74] Goehring NW. PAR polarity: From complexity to design principles. Experimental Cell Research. 2014 Nov;328(2):258–266. [75] Goehring NW, Trong PK, Bois JS, Chowdhury D, Nicola EM, Hyman AA, et al. Polar- ization of PAR proteins by advective triggering of a pattern-forming system. Science. 2011 Nov;334(6059):1137–41. DOI: 10.1126/science.1208619. [76] Meacci G, Ries J, Fischer-Friedrich E, Kahya N, Schwille P, Kruse K. Mobility of Min-proteins in Escherichia coli measured by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. Physical biology. 2006 Nov;3(4):255–263. DOI: 10.1088/1478-3975/3/4/003. [77] Graf IR, Frey E. Generic Transport Mechanisms for Molecular Traffic in Cellular Protrusions. Physical Review Letters. 2017 Mar;118(12). DOI: 10.1103/physrevlett.118.128101. [78] Yochelis A, Ebrahim S, Millis B, Cui R, Kachar B, Naoz M, et al. Self-organization of waves and pulse trains by molecular motors in cellular protrusions. Sci Rep. 2015 Sep;5:13521. DOI: 10.1038/srep13521. [79] Pinkoviezky I, Gov NS. Exclusion and Hierarchy of Time Scales Lead to Spatial Segrega- tion of Molecular Motors in Cellular Protrusions. Phys Rev Lett. 2017 Jan;118(1):018102. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.118.018102. [80] Schumacher D, Bergeler S, Harms A, Vonck J, Huneke-Vogt S, Frey E, et al. The PomXYZ Proteins Self-Organize on the Bacterial Nucleoid to Stimulate Cell Division. Dev Cell. 2017 May;41(3):299–314.e13. DOI: 10.1016/j.devcel.2017.04.011. [81] Schumacher D, Søgaard-Andersen L. Regulation of Cell Polarity in Motility and Cell Division in Myxococcus xanthus. Annu Rev Microbiol. 2017 Sep;71:61–78. DOI: 10.1146/annurev- 31 micro-102215-095415. [82] Ringgaard S, van Zon J, Howard M, Gerdes K. Movement and equipositioning of plasmids by ParA filament disassembly. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009 Nov;106(46):19369–74. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.0908347106. [83] Howard M, Gerdes K. What is the mechanism of ParA-mediated DNA movement? Mol Microbiol. 2010 Oct;78(1):9–12. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2958.2010.07316.x. [84] Gerdes K, Howard M, Szardenings F. Pushing and Pulling in Prokaryotic DNA Segregation. Cell. 2010;141(6):927–942. DOI: 10.1016/j.cell.2010.05.033. [85] Banigan EJ, Gelbart MA, Gitai Z, Wingreen NS, Liu AJ. Filament depolymeriza- tion can explain chromosome pulling during bacterial mitosis. PLoS Comput Biol. 2011 Sep;7(9):e1002145. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002145. [86] Sugawara T, Kaneko K. Chemophoresis as a driving force for intracellular organization: Theory and application to plasmid partitioning. Biophysics (Nagoya-shi). 2011;7:77–88. DOI: 10.2142/biophysics.7.77. [87] Surovtsev IV, Campos M, Jacobs-Wagner C. DNA-relay mechanism is sufficient to explain ParA-dependent intracellular transport and patterning of single and multiple cargos. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2016 Nov;113(46):E7268–E7276. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1616118113. [88] Hu L, Vecchiarelli AG, Mizuuchi K, Neuman KC, Liu J. Brownian Ratchet Mechanism for Faithful Segregation of Low-Copy-Number Plasmids. Biophys J. 2017 Apr;112(7):1489–1502. DOI: 10.1016/j.bpj.2017.02.039. [89] Murray SM, Sourjik V. Self-organization and positioning of bacterial protein clusters. Nature Physics. 2017 Jun;13(10):1006–1013. DOI: 10.1038/nphys4155. [90] Walter JC, Dorignac J, Lorman V, Rech J, Bouet JY, Nollmann M, et al. Surfing on Protein Waves: Proteophoresis as a Mechanism for Bacterial Genome Partitioning. Physical Review Letters. 2017 Jul;119(2). DOI: 10.1103/physrevlett.119.028101. [91] Ietswaart R, Szardenings F, Gerdes K, Howard M. Competing ParA structures space bac- terial plasmids equally over the nucleoid. PLoS Comput Biol. 2014 Dec;10(12):e1004009. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1004009. [92] Bergeler S, Frey E. Regulation of Pom cluster dynamics in Myxococcus xanthus. [arXiv:180106133]. 2018;. 32 [93] Huang KC, Ramamurthi KS. Macromolecules that prefer their membranes curvy. Molecular Microbiology. 2010 Apr;76(4):822–832. DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2958.2010.07168.x. [94] Laloux G, Jacobs-Wagner C. How do bacteria localize proteins to the cell pole? Journal of Cell Science. 2013 Dec;127(1):11–19. DOI: 10.1242/jcs.138628. [95] Halatek J, Frey E. Highly canalized MinD transfer and MinE sequestration ex- plain the origin of robust MinCDE-protein dynamics. Cell Rep. 2012 Jun;1(6):741–52. DOI: 10.1016/j.celrep.2012.04.005. [96] Otsuji M, Ishihara S, Co C, Kaibuchi K, Mochizuki A, Kuroda S. A mass conserved reaction- diffusion system captures properties of cell polarity. PLoS Comput Biol. 2007 Jun;3(6):e108. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.0030108. [97] Mori Y, Jilkine A, Edelstein-Keshet L. Wave-pinning and cell polarity from a bistable reaction-diffusion system. Biophysical journal. 2008 may;94(9):3684–97. DOI: 10.1529/bio- physj.107.120824. [98] Howell AS, Jin M, Wu CF, Zyla TR, Elston TC, Lew DJ. Negative feedback enhances robustness in the yeast polarity establishment circuit. Cell. 2012 Apr;149(2):322–33. DOI: 10.1016/j.cell.2012.03.012. [99] Das M, Drake T, Wiley DJ, Buchwald P, Vavylonis D, Verde F. Oscillatory dynamics of Cdc42 GTPase in the control of polarized growth. Science. 2012 Jul;337(6091):239–43. DOI: 10.1126/science.1218377. [100] Yang L, Dolnik M, Zhabotinsky AM, Epstein IR. Turing patterns beyond hexagons and stripes. Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science. 2006;16(3):037114. http://aip.scitation.org/doi/pdf/10.1063/1.2214167. DOI: 10.1063/1.2214167. [101] Otsuji M, Ishihara S, Co C, Kaibuchi K, Mochizuki A, Kuroda S. A mass conserved reaction- diffusion system captures properties of cell polarity. PLoS Comput Biol. 2007 Jun;3(6):e108. [102] Semplice M, Veglio A, Naldi G, Serini G, Gamba A. A bistable model of cell polarity. PLoS One. 2012;7(2):e30977. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0030977. [103] Berry J, Brangwynne C, Haataja MP. Physical Principles of Intracellular Organization via Active and Passive Phase Transitions. Reports on Progress in Physics. 2018 Jan;. [104] Yang HC, Pon LA. Actin cable dynamics in budding yeast. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2002 Jan;99(2):751–6. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.022462899. 33 [105] Maini PK, Woolley TE, Baker RE, Gaffney EA, Lee SS. Turing's model for biological pattern formation and the robustness problem. Interface Focus. 2012 Aug;2(4):487–96. DOI: 10.1098/rsfs.2011.0113. [106] Levine H, Rappel WJ. Membrane-bound Turing patterns. Phys Rev E. 2005 Dec;72(6 Pt 1):061912. [107] Thalmeier D, Halatek J, Frey E. Geometry-induced protein pattern formation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2016;113(3):548–553. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1515191113. [108] Zhang M, Hu Y, Jia J, Gao H, He Y. A plant MinD homologue rescues Escherichia coli HL1 mutant (DeltaMinDE) in the absence of MinE. BMC Microbiol. 2009 May;9:101. DOI: 10.1186/1471-2180-9-101. [109] Ishihara S, Otsuji M, Mochizuki A. Transient and steady state of mass-conserved reaction- diffusion systems. Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys. 2007 Jan;75(1 Pt 2):015203. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.75.015203. [110] Pogan A, Scheel A. Layers in the Presence of Conservation Laws. J Dyn Diff Equat. 2012 Apr;24:249–287. [111] Goh RN, Mesuro S, Scheel A. Spatial Wavenumber Selection in Recurrent Precipitation. SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics. 2011;10(1):360–402. [112] Mori Y, Jilkine A, Edelstein-Keshet L. Asymptotic and bifurcation analysis of wave-pinning in a reaction-diffusion model for cell polarization. SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics. 2011;71(4):1401. [113] Kessler DA, Levine H. Nonlinear self-adapting wave patterns. New Journal of Physics. 2016 Dec;18(12):122001. DOI: 10.1088/1367-2630/18/12/122001. [114] Goryachev AB, Leda M. Many roads to symmetry breaking: molecular mechanisms and theoretical models of yeast cell polarity. Mol Biol Cell. 2017 Feb;28(3):370–380. DOI: 10.1091/mbc.E16-10-0739. [115] Trong PK, Nicola EM, Goehring NW, Kumar KV, Grill SW. Parameter-space topology of models for cell polarity. New Journal of Physics. 2014;16. 34 FIG. 1. Turing's general linear stability analysis and heuristic ad-hoc interpretations in terms of the activator–inhibitor picture based on the production and degradation of reactants. (a) Any random perturbation (black line) of a spatially uniform state (gray line) can be decomposed into Fourier modes. Linear stability analysis yields the growth rates σq of the amplitude of all modes q. This is represented in the dispersion relation (blue line σq). Unstable modes (marked red) grow in amplitude an determine the pattern emerging out of the random perturbation during the incip- ient time evolution. (b) The activator–inhibitor model is based on autocatalytic production of a slowly diffusing activator, which in turn stimulates the production of a fast-diffusing inhibitor that suppresses autocatalytic activator production. Both activator and inhibitor are subject to degra- dation. The faster diffusion of the inhibitor leads to the formation of an inhibition zone in which degradation dominates over activator (and inhibitor) production. (c) In the activator–depletion model the inhibitor is replaced by a substrate that is subject to degradation, and autocatalytic activator production is replaced by the autocatalytic conversion of substrate into activator. The rate of conversion is limited by the available substrate. Heuristically, this conversion could be equated with the attachment of cytosolic proteins to the membrane. However, the reverse process (detachment) is not taken into account. Both substrate and activator are steadily degraded and are produced at a finite rate. If the activator density is too low, the conversion process is suppressed and the degradation process dominates, as in the activator–inhibitor model. 35 =+++++Conc.Spaceautocatalyticproductionproductiondominatesdegradationdominatesslow activator diffusionfast inhibitor diffusionActivator-Inhibitorbautocatalyticconversionconversiondominatesdegradationdominatesfast substrate diffusionslow activator diffusionActivator-Depletioncno detachmentatimeevolutionSpaceConc.band ofunstable modesFIG. 2. Biochemical interaction networks of three model systems for self-organized intracellular pattern formation. (a) The Min system of E. coli [28, 30]. (b) Cdc42 system of S. Cerevisiae [49, 55] . (c) PAR system of C. elegans [71]. (d) Switching between two conformal states of the proteins involved is a recurring theme in the biochemical networks (a-c). Cycling between membrane bound and cytosolic states is driven by the ATPase/GTPase cycle of MinD and Cdc42 respectively, while the PAP-proteins each cycle between different phosphorylation states. In general we expect switching between distinct conformal states – catalyzed by "switch regulators" such as NTPase-activating proteins (NAPs), nucleotide exchange factors (NEFs), phophatases, and kinases – to be a core element of biochemical networks that mediate intracellular pattern formation. 36 Bem1-GEF mediatedCdc42 recuritmentand activationCdc42-GDPGDIBem1GEFCdc42-GTP recruits Bem1-GEFmembranecytosolCdc42 GTPase cycleMinD-ATPMinD-ADPMinEmutual detachmentof aPAR and pPARaPARpPARMinD recruitsitself and MinEMinDE-complexdetachmentacbDTNEFNAPNDPNTPPDPhosphataseKinasePhosphorylatedDephosphorylateddABSwitch regulatorsState AState BFIG. 3. Linear (in)stability of a uniform initial distribution of proteins. (a) In a uniform steady state, attachment and detachment must balance everywhere. An external cue or a random per- turbation due to stochastic noise can lead a local increase in membrane density. How the relative balance of attachment and detachment processes shifts in the region of increased membrane den- sity, determines the stability of the uniform state. If the balance in a region of increased membrane density shifts in favour of attachment (b), the region becomes an attachment zone leading to a further increase in membrane density due to redistribution through the cytosol. Hence the spatially separated attachment and detachment zones are maintained, leading the establishment of a pat- tern. If the balance in a region of increased membrane density shifts the attachment-detachment balance in favour of detachment (b'), this region becomes a detachment zone, while the region of lower membrane density becomes an attachment zone, such that the system returns to its uniform balanced state (c'). 37 attachment zonedetachment zoneCytosol concentrationrandom perturbationattachment zonedetachment zoneredistributionReturn to uniform stateredistributionIncrease of membrane density shifts reaction balancein favour of attachementattachment zonedetachment zoneredistributionmembranediffusionuniform attachment-detachment balanceMaintained pattern stateTime evolutionIncrease of membrane density shifts reaction balancein favour of detachementabb'cc'FIG. 4. Mutual recruitment of Cdc42 and Bem1–GEF complexes is the core mechanism of Cdc42 polarization. (a) The interaction network of Cdc42, Bem1 and GEF (Cdc24) can conceptually be simplified to two key processes: Bem1–GEF complexes on the membrane recruit Cdc42-GDP from the cytosol, which is followed by immediate nucleotide exchange (conversion to Cdc42-GTP). Reversely, Cdc42-GTP recruits Bem1 to the membrane by, where it immediately recruits Cdc24 to form Bem1–GEF complexes. (b) A local accumulation of Cdc42-GTP thereby acts as recruitment template for Bem1–GEF complexes (1), creating an attachment zone for Bem1–GEF, while de- tachment of Bem1–GEF dominates in zones of low Cdc42-GTP density (2). Bem1–GEF complexes then accumulate in their attachment zone. This accumulation acts as a recruitment template for Cdc42 (2), creating co-polarized attachment zones of Cdc42 and Bem1–GEF (1') and (2'). (c) Taken together, the mutual recruitment processes establish and maintain Cdc42-polarization. 38 ++mutual recruitmentzonedetachment zoneredistribution++cytosolic densitycytosolic densityBem1-GEFrecruitmentBem1,GEFdetachmentredistributionCdc42 recruitment,nucleotide exchangeCdc42 detachmentredistribution++Bem1-GEF template for Cdc42 recruitmentCdc42 template for Bem1-GEF recruitmentBem1-GEFCdc42-GDPMutual recruitment ofBem1-GEF and Cdc42-GTPabc11'22'FIG. 5. Pole-to-pole oscillations of MinD and MinE: MinD recruits both itself and MinE from the cytosol creating an attachment zone for both proteins (1). As MinDE complexes accumulate in the polar zone, their detachment begins to dominate over MinD attachment. (2) The old polar zone traps MinE because it is both an attachment and a detachment zone for MinE, which only cycles locally, as long as there is free MinD left on the membrane. This allows cytosolic MinD to form a new polar zone at the other end of the cell. MinE trapping ends when all MinD has detached from the old polar zone, such that the new polar zone becomes an attachment zone for MinE (3), and the process starts over at the opposite end of the cell (4). 39 +cytosolic density+redistributionMinDE detachmentMinD recruits itselfand MinE++MinD self-recruitmentMinDE detachmentlocal MinE cyclingredistribution++MinD self-recruitmentMinDE detachmentlocal MinE cyclingredistribution++redistributionMinDE detachmentMinD recruits itselfand MinE1234FIG. 6. Mutual antagonism between aPAR and pPar proteins creates a detachment zone at the interface between aPAR- and pPAR-dominated regions. A region of high aPAR density on the membrane is a detachment zone for pPAR, such that detaching pPARs can only attach to a region of low aPAR density, and vice versa. A balance of the mutual antagonistic processes is necessary to prevent one protein species from dominating over the other and taking over the whole membrane. 40 mutual detachmentaPAR attachmentpPAR attachmentredistributionredistributioncytosolic densitiesFIG. 7. Canalized transfer of MinD imposes a length scale intrinsic to the reaction–diffusion dynamics in the model developed by Halatek and Frey [30]. (a) Canalized transfer refers to the case where attachment-flux and detachment-flux are of similar magnitude such that the cytosolic density does not vary (left). To maintain the flux between detachment and attachment zone a cytosolic gradient must be maintained. The length scale of this gradient dictates the distance between attachment and detachment zones independently of system size. Thus, canalized transfer can give rise to patterns with an intrinsic wavelength in large systems (right). (b) If a detachment zone forms when no attachment zone is available, the detaching proteins fill up a cytosolic reservoir. Once the reservoir reaches a critical density an attachment zone will form. In this case no length scale between attachment and detachment zones is set, since both zones exchange proteins through a (uniform) cytosolic reservoir. 41 Simultaneous attachment and detachmentSequential attachment and detachmentweak attachmentstrong detachmentcytosolic reservoirstrong attachmentno detachmentcytosolic reservoirLength = LLength = 2Lno attachmentdetachmentattachment zonedetachment zonemembranecytosolcanalized transferintrinsic transportlength scaleweak attachmentstrong detachmentcytosolic reservoirstrong attachmentno detachmentcytosolic reservoirno attachmentdetachmentTime evolutionattachment zonedetachment zonecanalized transferdetachment zonecanalized transferintrinsic transportlength scaleintrinsic transportlength scaleabCytosolic reservoir does not impose length scaleCanalized transfer determines pattern length scale
1001.4850	1	1001	2010-01-27T04:35:43	Multi Scale Investigation of Surface Topography of Ball Python (Python Regius) Shed Skin in Comparison to Human skin	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	Constructing a surface that is an integral part of the function of tribosystems (deterministic surface) is an intriguing goal. Inspirations for such surfaces come from studying natural systems and deducing design rules. The major attraction is that natural systems, while functionally complex, are, in general, of optimized shape and performance. It is further believed that functional complexity of natural systems is what affords natural species to morph continuously to adapt with the operating environment. One bio-species that is of interest is the Ball Python. This is because such a species continuously slides against various surfaces, many of which are deemed tribologically hostile, without sustaining much damage. Much of the success of that species in adapting to its environment is attributed to surface design features. In that respect, studying these features and how do they contribute to the control of friction and wear is very attractive. This paper is a step in this direction. In this work we apply a multi scale surface characterization approach to study surface design features of the Python Regius. The focus is on those features that are typically used to assess the performance of high quality lubricating surfaces. To this end, topographical features are studied by SEM and through White Light Interferrometery (WLI). We probe the roughness of the surface on multi scale and as a function of location within the body. In addition we draw a comparison of these features to those of human skin.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Multi Scale Investigation of Surface Topography of Ball Python (Python Regius) Shed Skin in Comparison to Human skin H. A. Abdel-Aal 1 M. El Mansori S. Mezghani Arts et Métier ParisTech, Rue Saint Dominique BP 508, 51006 Chalons-en-Champagne, France 1 corresponding author: [email protected] ABSTRACT A major concern in designing tribo-systems is to minimize friction, save energy, and to reduce wear. Conventional philosophy for design centers on mechanical and material considerations. In particular designers pay more attention to material properties and material choices based on mechanical properties rather than the design and shape of the contacting surfaces and the relation of that surface to the function of the device. As a result of thriving for miniaturization, focus has shifted toward optimal surface design (that is to construct a surface that is an integral part of the function of the tribosystem). Inspirations for such a trend come from studying natural systems and mimicking natural design rules. The major attraction is that natural systems, while functionally complex, are, in general, of optimized shape and performance. It is further believed that functional complexity of natural systems is what affords natural species to morph continuously to adapt with the operating environment. One bio-species that is of interest is the Ball Python. This is because such a species continuously slides against various surfaces, many of which are deemed tribologically hostile, without sustaining much damage. Much of the success of that species in adapting to its environment is attributed to surface design features. In that respect, studying these features and how do they contribute to the control of friction and wear is very attractive. This paper is a step in this direction. In this work we apply a multi scale surface characterization approach to study surface design features of the Python Regius. The focus is on those features that are typically used to assess the performance of high quality lubricating surfaces (such as those obtained through plateau honing). To this end, topographical features are studied by SEM and through White Light Interferrometery (WLI). We probe the roughness of the surface on multi scale and as a function of location within the body. In addition we draw a comparison of these features to those of human skin. 1. Introduction In order for many next generation products to succeed they must offer greater functiona lity and improved performance. Ultra precision and structured surfaces are increasingly being adopted to gain such advantages. As such, the development of higher performing products through the application of ultra precise, complex and structured surfaces, such as those textured through plateau honing for improved lubrication capability, is an active area of research. In seeking inspirations for such custom designed surfaces many engineers turn toward natural systems (i.e., bio-species, plants, insects etc.,). There are many features that deserve attention within natural systems. These may include superior functionality, the ability to harness functional complexity to achieve optimal performance, and harmony between shape form and function. From a tribology perspective, the existence of surfaces that are design features, of the particular species, intended to facilitate functional performance is a point of deserving interest. Tribological investigations often deal with complex systems that, while nominally homogeneous, are practically 1 compositionally heterogeneous. Compositional heterogeneity is either inherent (structural), or evolutionary (functional) [1]. Inherent heterogeneity is due to initial variation in composition, material selection, component chemistry, etc. Evolutionary heterogeneity, on the other hand, arises because of the evolution of the local response of different parts of a sliding assembly during operation. Subsystem components, for example, since they entertain different loads will react in a manner that is proportional to the local loading conditions. Distinct responses cause system subcomponents to evolve into entities that differ from their initial state. System heterogeneity, thus, introduces a level of functional complexity to the sliding assembly. Functional complexity, in turn, characterizes the interaction of system subcomponents, and of the system as a unit, with the surroundings. Most of such interaction, it is to be noted, takes place through the surface. Natural systems, regardless of the degree of functional complexity inherited within, display harmonious characteristics and an ability to self-regulate. Whence, as a general rule they operate at an optimal state marked by economy-of-effort. Man-engineered systems (MES), in contrast, do not exhibit such a level of optimized performance. Much of the ability of natural systems to self regulate is attributed to optimized relationship between shape, form and function especially when surface design is considered. That is, shape and form in natural systems are always targeted toward optimal function. Such customization, however, is not advanced in MES. Bio-species, in that respect, offer many a lesson. This is because biological materials, through million years of existence, have evolved optimized topological features that enhance wear and friction resistance [2]. One species of remarkable tribological performance that may serve as an inspiration for optimal surface texturing is that of snakes. This is due to the Objective-targeted design features associated with their mode of legless locomotion. Snakes are limbless animals. They have multi-modes of motion (slithering, crawling, serpentine movement etc) that take place during propulsion. Such motion modes are initiated through muscular activity. That is, through a sequence of contraction and relaxation of appropriate muscle groups. Transfer of motion between the body of the snake and the substrate depends on generation of sufficient tractions. This process, generation of traction and accommodation of motion, is handled through the skin. Thus the skin of the snake assumes the role of motion transfer and accommodation of energy consumed during the initiation of motion. The number, type and sequence of muscular groups responsible for the initiation of motion, and thus-employed in propulsion, will vary according to the particular mode of motion to be initiated. It will also depend on the habitat and the surrounding environment. This also will affect the effort invested in initiation of motion and thereby also affects the function of the different parts of the skin and the amount of energy required to be accommodated. So that, in general, different parts of the skin will have different functional requirements. Moreover, the life habits of the particular species, e.g., defense, hunting, and swallowing) will require different deterministic functions of the different parts of the skin. That is the snake species, is a true representative of a heterogeneous tribo-system with a high degree of functional complexity, despite which, they don’t suffer damaging levels of wear and tear. Many researchers investigated the intriguing features of the serpentine family. Adam and Grace [3] studied the ultra structure of pit organ epidermis in Boid snakes to understand infrared 2 sensing mechanisms. Johnna et al [4] investigated the permeability of shed skin of pythons (python molurus, Elaphe obsolete) to determine the suitability as a human skin analogue. Mechanical behavior of snake skin was also a subject of several studies as well. Jayne [5] examined the loading curves of six different species in uni-axial extension. His measurements revealed substantial variation in loads and maximum stiffness among samples from different dorsoventral regions within an individual and among homologous samples from different species. Rivera et al.[6] measured the mechanical properties of the integument of the common garter snake (Thomnophis sirtalis-Serpentine Colubridae). They examined mechanical properties of the skin along the body axis. Data collected revealed significant differences in mechanical properties among regions of the body. In particular, and consistent with the demands of macrophagy, it was found that the pre-pyloric skin is more compliant than post pyloric skin. Prompted by needs to design bio-inspired robots several researchers probed the frictional features of snake motion to understand the mechanisms responsible for regulating legless locomotion. Hazel et al [7] used AFM scanning to probe the nano-scale design features of three snake species. The studies of Hazel and Grace revealed the asymmetric features of the skin ornamentation to which both authors attributed frictional anisotropy. In order to mimic the beneficial performance features of the skin, an engineer should be provided with parametric guidelines to aid with the objective-oriented design process. These should not only be dimensional. Rather, they should extend to include metrological parameters used to characterize tribological performance of surfaces within the MES domain. Thus, in order to deduce design rules there exists a need for quantification of the relationship governing micro - structure and strength topology of the bio-surface; exploring the quantitative regulation of macro and micro texture, and finally devising working formulae that describe (and potentially predict) load carrying capacity during locomotion in relation to geometrical configuration at both the micro and the macro scale. This paper is a preliminary step toward that goal. In this work, we apply a multi-scale surface characterization approach to probe the design features of shed skins obtained from a Ball Python (Python Regius). Such a species is of tribological interest because of its locomotion taking place within a non-breakable boundary lubrication regime. Such a performance feature is facilitated by the topology of skin ornamentation. This renders such a species of interest to designers of plateau honing engineers where surfaces are designed for minimal lubricant consumption and for designers of hip and knee prostheses where maintaining a continuous boundary lubrication regime is a must. The emphasis in the current work, therefore, is on deducing those metrological aspects of the shed skin that are deemed essential to quantify the quality of tribological performance of industrial sliding assemblies (e.g., cylinder-piston). 2. Background 2.1. The Python species Python Regius, figure 1-a, is a constrictor type non-venomous snake species that is typically found in Africa. Due to the reaction of the animal of curling into a spherical position, where the head is tucked under the trunk, figure 1-b,, for protection when distressed, it is also called “ball- python”. The build of the snake is non-uniform as the head-neck region as well as that of the tail is thinner than the-region containing the trunk. The trunk meanwhile is the region of the body where most of the snake body mass is concentrated. Consequently it is more compact and thicker 3 than other parts with the overall cross section of the body is more elliptical rather than circular. The tail section also is rather conical in shape. Skin of the python contains blotches imposed upon an otherwise black background. The blotches are of a non uniform shape and contour and are colored in dark and light brown. The ventral part of the body is typically cream, or extremely light yellow, color with occasional black spots scattered within. . Figure 1. A Ball Python (Python Regius) species., a) normal position, b) curled-up “Ball” position 2.2. general features The skin of reptiles, as well as that of snakes, is covered with scales. These maybe thought of as elevated folds or wrinkles within the skin. The pattern of the scales, shape, number, and ornamentation differ according to the species. A snake will typically hatch with a constant number of scales. This number remains fixed throughout the life duration of the snake. Each snake type has a different number of scales that is unique to the particular species. While the total number of scales remains constant, the size and shape change during the life span of the snake to accommodate growth and changes in size. There are several functions for scales in a snake. They provide protection from the environment, they regulate energy exchange between the animal and environment, further they aid in camouflage and capture of prey [8]. Scales also perform a tribological function as they regulate frictional interaction, and help generate tractions upon propulsion. In snakes, skin cell division, occur periodically and that causes the reptile, to grow a second skin underneath the current (old) skin, and then “sheds” the old one. That is due to the cell division process the snake periodically sheds its entire outer skin layer. 3. Materials and Methods All observations reported herein pertain to shed skin obtained from a 115 cm, 14 years old male Ball Python (Python Regius) housed individually in a glass container with news paper subs trate. For optical microscopy observations skin was observed as is, whereas all samples for Scan Electron Microscopy observations were coated by a vacuum deposited Tungsten layer of thickness 10 nm. Surface topography analysis took place through two methods: SEM imaging in topography mode and through examination using a white light interferometer (WYKO NT3300 3D Automated Optical Profiling System). For comparison purposes, we obtained replicas of human skin. Samples were obtained by replicating the skin of a 40 years old female in two places: back of the hand and upper inside portion of the arm. All replicas were made using a light 4 silicone rubber impression material (Silflo ®-Lexico, Plandent, UK) after using alcohol to clean subject skin. 4. Results and discussion 4.1. Initial Observations Initial observations on the structure of the scales were performed using two methods: photography of the life species and optical microscopy. These were done without any treatment of the skin. 4.2. Photographical Observations Figure 2 (a and b) depicts details of the surface structure of two regions on the life snake. Figure 2-a details the skin geometry in the head region from the inner (sliding side), whereas figure 2 -b depicts the details of the stomach (belly-again the sliding side) of the snake. The photographs reveal that polygons constitute the geometrical building block of the surface. This polygon has eight sides, octagon, in the general area of the mouth (represented by the letter O in the figure). Past a line that joins the eyes, line AA, the pattern of the skin changes to hexagonal. The size of individual unit cells (octagons or hexagons) is not generally the same. The size of the octagons in the mouth region is not uniform. However, compared to the hexagonal patterns within the throat region, the area of the unit octagon is, in general, greater than that of the hexagonal unit. Hexagonal cells on the other hand are of uniform shape and size and seem to be of uniform density per unit area. Within the mouth zone (above the line AA) the aspect ratio of the octagonal unit cell is, qualitatively, uniform. The major axis of the polygon, moreover, appears to point in the same direction of the body major longitudinal axis of the snake (BMLA). Considering the function of the head frontal part, feeding, some design features may be pointed out. Pythons feed by constricting the prey then swallowing it to be digested in the stomach. Upon inhaling the prey, the jaws have to stretch to accommodate the volume, and shape of the p rey. The prey may offer some resistance that leads to multi-axial displacements of the surface material. Under such conditions, the design requirement of the surface is to allow for global flexibility and to facilitate local multi-axis displacements (stretching) all while minimizing possible damage to the skin. Observing the build of the skin above line AA, one would note that the skin is built of small patches of uniform shape (octagon), and are linked by a channel of what seems to be flexible strips of skin. Such a design allows for multi-axis stretching of the surface with possible damping of sudden jerks (caused by prey resistance) provided through the flexible links. A similar trend is noted in the throat region. Here the need to accommodate volume dilatation is greater since the prey by this point would, most likely, be subdued. Within this zone hexagonal unit cells make up the surface. 5 body major axisAAOHO-OctagonH-HexagonBody Longitudinal major axis unit cell of ventral skin building block dorsal scalesventral scalesFigure 2. Details of scale structure at two positions on the life species. a) Shields within the head-throat region b) Ventral scales close to the waist section. The uniform distribution of hexagonal cells is likely to aid the compliance of the surface and increase its flexibility. Interestingly such a hexagonal pattern is noted to be the most efficient way to pack the largest number of similar objects in a minimum space [9] . Naturally, had the skin been made of larger patches, or one continuous sheet, the probability of surface rupture would have increased. Figure 2-b depicts the surface geometry in the sliding side of the skin (general region of the belly). The photograph reveals that the hexagonal pattern constitutes the basic building block of the skin. The size of the hexagons differs around the circumference of the body. Large cells are particular to the main sliding area whereas cells of smaller size are particular to the back and the sides. Consistent with the construction of the head-throat region, the aspect ratio of the cells is variable. Of interest is the orientation of the major axis of the skin unit cells with respect to the BMLA. In the head-throat region the major axis of the cells is oriented parallel to the body major axis whereas in the belly (ventral scales) the major cell axis is perpendicular to the main body axis. Varenberg and Gorb [10], based on experiments on the hexagonal structures found on tarsal attachment pads of the bush cricket (tettigonia viridissima) suggest that variation in the aspect ratio of hexagonal structures may alter the friction force of elastomers by at least a factor of two. Additionally, we propose that the perpendicular orientation of the cells, with respect to the major axis of the snake, within the main sliding region aids in shifting the weight, and hence the contact angle and area of the snake upon sliding. Note that since the body of the snake is of cylindrical shape, the highest curvature of the skin will be oriented along the major cell axis. As such, upon sliding, the area of contact, and therefore the total tractions, will depend on the direction of motion (higher sideways and minimal forward). That is the orientation of the hexagon axis renders the friction forces isotropic. Such an observation is consistent with the findings of Zhang et al [11] who studied the frictional mechanism and anisotropy of Burmese python's ventral scales. They reported that the friction coefficient of the ventral scale had closely relationship with moving direction. The frictional coefficient for backward and lateral motion was one third higher than that in forward motion. 4.3. Structure of Shed Skin 4.3.1. Optical Microscopy Observations In snakes the epidermis is made up of different layers with the innermost called the stratum germinativum. The outer layers, which are renewed during shedding, are, from the inside, -, mesos-, -layer, and Oberhautchen. The Oberhautchen, mainly consisting of -keratin, is in direct contact with the environment and possesses a fine surface structure called micro- ornamentation [12]. Details of the micro-ornamentation were described by earlier authors [13- 16]. Initial observations on the structure of the scales were performed using optical microscopy. without any treatment of the skin. Figure 3 depicts the structure of the scales at two positions within the skin in a region close to the waist of the snake. The first was from the back (dorsal scale) whereas the second position represented the belly of the snake (ventral). Note that although the general form of the cells is quite similar for both positions the size of a unit cell within the skin is quite different in both cases. In particular the cell is wider for the ventral (belly) positions. Each cell (scale) is also composed of a boundary and a membrane like structure. Note also the overlapping geometry of the skin and the scales (the so called scale and 6 hinge structure). The skin from the inner surface hinges back and forms a free area, which overlaps the base of the next scale, which emerges below this scale figure 4. Figure 3. The structure of the scales on the inside of the shed skin at a region close to the mid section of the species at two orientations: back (dorsal) and abdominal (ventral). Figure 4. The details of dorsal scales from the inside of shed skin. The terminology used is: membrane to denote the major area of the scale and boundary to denote the raised part forming the circumference of the scale. Scale marker is 1mm. 4.3.2. Scan Electron Microscopy (SEM) Observations Four positions on the shed skin were identified for initial examination. The choice of the positions was based on the functional profile of each position in the live species (figure 5). Position I is a representative of the neck region, position II represents the beginning of the trunk (waist) region, position III marks the boundary between the trunk and the tail region, finally position IV represents the tail region (containing the so called subcaudal scales). Skin swatches from each of the chosen positions were examined at different magnifications (X250-X15000) in topography mode. In order to suppress charging phenomena and improve the quality of observation, the surface of each sample was metalized by depositing a 10nm thin layer of platinum (Pt) using a sputter coater EMITECH K575X. Comparison of the uncoated and coated pictures is given in figure 6. 7 membraneBoundaryHinge Figure 5. Equivalent positions chosen on the snake shed skin for SEM observations Figure 6: Comparison of the quality of SEM pictures at two positions on the shed skin at X1000. Upper row represents pictures of the uncoated skin samples while the lower row represents those of the coated samples. 8 IIIIIIIVDark Skinlight skinFor each position samples from the dark and the light colored skin (see figure 5) were also examined along with samples from the underside of the body. Major features of the observations are shown in figures 7 and 8. ventral scales- Scale boundary ventral scales: Membrane dorsal scales- light skin boundary dorsal scales- light skin Membrane dorsal scales- dark skin boundary dorsal scales- dark skin Membrane Figure 7: Major features of SEM observations of the skin swatches.(X-250) 9 ventral scales- Scale boundary ventral scales: Membrane dorsal scales- light skin boundary dorsal scales- light skin Membrane dorsal scales- dark skin boundary dorsal scales- dark skin Membrane Figure 8: Major features of SEM observations of the skin swatches.(X-5000) Note the inner structure that comprises pores. Two types of pores (or micro pits) may be distinguished: those located within the boundary and those located within the membrane. Image analysis of the pictures indicates that the diameter of the boundary-pores ranges between (200 nm – 250 nm). An estimate of the diameter of the membrane-pores was estimated by Hazel et al 10 [7] using AFM analysis to be in the range (50nm -75 nm). Worth noting, is that within the same study [7] Hazel and co-workers scanned the contour of the fibril tips, within the membrane, using AFM and deduced that the tips are of asymmetric shape. Based on this observation, combined to the inter-lamellar layout of the fibrils, they suggested that such design features would lead to anisotropic frictional properties of the body. The locomotion mechanism responsible for such anisotropy is, however, considered, beyond the scope of the current work since the focus is on the topographical features and the metrology of the surface. Surface protrusions are also noted within the boundary. These protrusions are of an asymmetric shape and irregular distribution. The surface of the membrane also comprises micro-nano fibrile structures. These are not of consistent shape and spacing. Note for example that the shape of fibril located in the dark colored skin region is different than that located within the light colored skin region (compare the X-5000 pictures). Moreover the density of the fibrils seems to be different within the different color regions (denser within the dark colored region). The spacing between different rows of fibrils also differs by skin color and position within the body (ventral> dorsal light skin> dorsal dark skin). Further analysis of images revealed that the density of the boundary-pores vary by position. That is the number of pores per unit area is not constant along the body, rather it changes relative to the position. Figure 9 is a plot of the variation in the density of the pores relative to the two sides of the skin (back-Dorsal scales and abdominal- Ventral scales) and in relation to the color of the skin (Light Patches (L) Vs Dark Patches D) within the back also. Figure 9. The variation in the density of the boundary pores (pore /mm2) with position, and with color of skin. 4.4. Metrology of the Surface Examination of the surface topography features of the skin using White Light Interferometry (WLI) on a swatches of skin (1500 μm x 1500 μm) yielded the basic parameters that describe the surface (asperity radii and curvature etc., ). Figure 10 depicts a typical WLI graph of the skin. The shown inteferogram pertains to a skin spot that is located along the waist of the snake from 11 02004006008001000IIIIIIVIVentralDorsal-lightDorsal-DarkPosition on BodyDensity of Boundary Pores (pore/mm)2the belly side (ventral). Two interferograms are depicted: the one to the right hand side of the figure represents the topography of the cell- membrane whereas the one depicted to the left represents a multi-scale scan for the whole skin swatch. Note the scale on the right of the pictures as it indicates the deepest valley and highest point of the skin topography. For these typical skin swatches the value of the deepest part of the membrane was about -120 μm, whereas the highest summit is about 100 μm. The comparable values for the whole swatch are about -5.5 μm and 8.2 μm respectively. Figure 10. Multi scale WLI graphs depicting the topography of the skin building block (Scale) boundary and membrane (scale bar is in m). To establish a measure of comparison between the topography of the snake skin, we compared scans of snake skin to human skin scans. The results are given in figure 11. Human scans from two different positions are depicted in the figure. The first scan is from skin located at the back of the hand whereas the second pertains to skin located at the inside of the upper arm of a 40 years old Caucasian female. Samples were obtained by replicating the skin using a replicating silicone. For the snake we chose to compare scans of the ventral scales located in the waist section of the body since it is a major load bearing area during locomotion. Again, it is noted that the peak summit and valley values of the surface of the snake skin are in the order of magnitude of one third that of human skin. Such a comparison highlights, qualitatively, the origins of the superior tribological performance exhibited by the snake. Note that under the conditions of examination in this work quantitative comparison between both skin types are not possible. This is because the tribological performance of human skin is not a mere function of surface topography. Rather, it also depends on the water content within skin cells. As such, comparing the frictional features of snake skin used in the current work, which is dry by default since it is shed from the species, to human skin in vivo is meaningless. Moreover, the friction of skin in general is dominated by acoustic emission. Again, provisions to monitor such effect were not undertaken in this study as it was judged that such feature warrants detailed investigation (which is currently undergone in our laboratory). 12 Human skin-back of the hand Human skin-inside of upper arm Python- Ventral close to waist-membrane Figure 11. Comparison between the surface texture of snake skin and that of human skin replicas as revealed by White light interferometer (scale bar in m) 4.5. Bearing curve analysis To complete the analysis, we studied the load bearing characteristics of the skin at each of the predetermined positions (I through IV). Surface parameters were extracted from SEM topography photographs. The complete set of analyzed pictures provided a matrix of roughness parameters that describe the texture of the shed skin at variable scales ranging from X-100 to X- 5000. Table 1 (a and b) provides a summary of the parameters extracted from the analysis. It can be seen that the scale of the analysis affects the value of the parameters, which may point at a fractal nature of the surface. Discussion of the implication of such finding is considered out of the scope of this work. However, of interest is to point out one of the features that directly relates to the design of the surface. Comparing the ratios between the Reduced Peak Height Rpk, Core Roughness Depth Rk, and Reduced Valley Depth Rvk reveals symmetry between the positions (compare the columns Rpk/Rk, Rvk/Rk, and Rvk/Rpk of table 1-b, and figure 12 a and b). This symmetry is interesting on the count that positions II and III represent the boundaries of the main load bearing regions (trunk). That is the regions on the body where the snake has most of his body weight concentrated (refer to figure 5) and thereby it is the region that is principally used in locomotion. Such symmetry may very well be related to the wear resistance ability of the surface or to the boundary lubrication quality of locomotion. Of interest also, is to find if 13 implementing a surface of such characteristic parameters (functionally textured surface) in plateau honing for example would be conducive to an anti-scuffing and economical lubricant consumption performance. Such a point is a subject of ongoing investigation. Table-1 effect of magnification on surface parameters a- Surface parameters based on X-250 pictures Position I Position II Position III Position VI Cr/Cf Cl/Cf Rpk/Rk 0.718 0.861 0.391 0.612 2.010 2.011 0.733 1.628 2.066 1.388 0.926 0.617 Rvk/Rk 0.159 0.545 0.436 0.195 Rvk/Rpk 1.144 0.656 0.621 0.749 b- Surface parameters based on X-5000 pictures Position I Position II Position III Position VI Cr/Cf Cl/Cf Rpk/Rk 0.654 1.207 1.930 0.478 1.803 1.273 0.484 1.622 1.671 1.772 1.158 0.636 Rvk/Rpk 0.679 0.812 0.800 0.688 Rvk/Rk 0.285 0.404 0.359 0.260 Figure 12: Plot of the ratio of the load bearing parameters Rvk/Rk and Rpk/Rk at two magnifications X-250 and X-5000. 5. Conclusions and Future Outlook In this work we presented the results of an initial study to probe the geometric features of the skin of the Python Regius. It was found the structure of the unit cells is of regionally similar shape (octagonal and hexagonal). Although almost identical in size and density, the skin constituents (pore density and essential size of the unit cell) vary by position on the body. Comparison of the topography of the snake skin to that of a human female revealed that the surface roughness of the snake species is around one third that of the human samples. Analysis of the surface roughness parameters implied a multi-scale dependency of the parameters. This may point at a fractal nature of the surface a proposition that needs future verification. The analysis of bearing curve characteristics revealed symmetry between the front 14 Rpk/RkR/RvKk00.10.20.30.40.50.6IIIIIIIVX250X5000Position on body00.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.8IIIIIIIVX250X5000R/RpKkPosition on bodyand back sections of the body. It also revealed that the trunk region is bounded by two cross- sections of identical bearing curve ratios. This has implications in design of textured surfaces that retain an unbreakable boundary lubrication quality and high wear resistance. Clearly much work is needed to further probe the essential features of the surface geometry. Namely, the basic parametric make up of the topography, form, and their relation to friction and wear resistance. Acknowledgment The authors acknowledge Mr. Benjamin Favre for assistance in SEM imaging and Mrs Ruth Ann Jones, of Troup county GA School System, for donating the shed skin used in this work. References 1. Abdel-Aal, H. A., Complexity, Synergy and emergence in tribosystems, Int. J. Mat. Prod. Tech, 38 (1), 1-3, (2010). 2. Tong, J., H. Wang, Ma, Y.Ren, L.: Two-body abrasive wear of the outside shell surfaces of mollusc Lamprotula fibrosa Heude, Rapana venosa Valenciennes and Dosinia anus Philippi, Trib. Let. 19, 331-338 (2005). 3. Adam B. Safer and Michael S. Grace, Infrared imaging in vipers: differential responses of crotaline and viperine snakes to paired thermal targets, Behavioral Brain Research 154, 1, 55-61 (2004) 4. Johnna B. Roberts, Harvey B. Lillywhite, Lipids and the permeability of epidermis from snake, Journal of Experimental Zoology 228, 1 - 9 (2005). 5. Jayne, B.C. : Mechanical behavior of snake skin. J. Zool. 214, 125-140 (1988) 6. G. Rivera, A. H. Savitzky, J. A. Hinkley, Mechanical properties of the integument of the common gartersnake, Thamnophis sirtalis (Serpentes: Colubridae), J. Exp. Bio. 208, 2913-2922 (2005). 7. J. Hazel, M. Stone, M. S. Grace and V. V. Tsukruk. : Nanoscale design of snake skin for reptation locomotion via friction anisotropy, Journal of Biomechanics 32, 477-484 (1999). 8. Sepkoski, J.: A compendium of fossil marine animal genera (Reptilia entry). Bulletins of American Paleontology 364, 560 (2002). 9. Ball, P., The Self-Made Tapestry: Pattern Formation in Nature, Oxford University Press, New York (2001) 10. Varenberg, M. and S. N. Gorb. :Hexagonal surface micropattern for dry and wet friction, Advanced Materials 21, 483-486 (2009). 11. Zhang, H., Z. Dai, Yang, S.:Structure and friction characteristics of snake abdomen, Journal of Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics 40, 360-363 (2008). 12. Price R.M.: Microdermatoglyphics: an appeal for standardization of methodology and terminology with comments on recent studies of North American natricines, J Herpet. 24, 324–325(1990) 13. R. Ruibal.: The ultrastructure of the surface of lizard scales, Copeia 4, 698–703 (1968) 14. Price R. M. , Kelly P.: Microdermatoglyphics: basal patterns and transition zones, J Herpet. 23,244–261(1989) 15. Chiasson R.B., Bentley D.L., Lowe C.H.: Scale morphology in Agkistrodon and closely related crotaline genera. Herpetologica 45, 430–438 (1989) 15 16. Gower D. J.: Scale micro-ornamentation of uropeltid snakes, J Morph. 258, 249–268 (2003). 16
1006.1825	2	1006	2010-12-03T19:31:41	Kinetic Theory of Flocking: Derivation of Hydrodynamic Equations	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.stat-mech" ]	It is shown how to explicitly coarse-grain the microscopic dynamics of the Vicsek model for self-propelled agents. The macroscopic transport equations are derived by means of an Enskog-type kinetic theory. Expressions for all transport coefficients at large particle speed are given. The phase transition from a disordered to a flocking state is studied numerically and analytically.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Kinetic Theory of Flocking: Derivation of Hydrodynamic Equations Thomas Ihle1, 2 1Department of Physics, North Dakota State University, Fargo, North Dakota, 58108-6050, USA 2Max Planck Institute for the Physics of Complex Systems, Nothnitzer Strasse 38, 01187 Dresden, Germany It is shown how to explicitly coarse-grain the microscopic dynamics of the rule-based Vicsek model for self-propelled agents. The hydrodynamic equations are derived by means of an Enskog- type kinetic theory. Expressions for all transport coefficients at large particle speed are given. The phase transition from a disordered to a flocking state is studied numerically and analytically. 0 1 0 2 c e D 3 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 2 v 5 2 8 1 . 6 0 0 1 : v i X r a Pattern formation and collective motion in systems of self-propelled objects are fascinating phenomena which have attracted much attention. Systems of interest in- clude animal flocks [1], chemically powered nanorods [2], and actin networks driven by molecular motors [3]. Theo- retical studies of these systems are usually based on phe- nomenological transport equations. In most cases, the equations are postulated by means of symmetry argu- ments, which define only the general form of the terms but leave their coefficients undetermined. One goal of this Letter is to provide a system- atic derivation of all relevant coefficients for the two- dimensional Vicsek model (VM) of self-propelled parti- cles [4]. In the VM, pointlike particles are driven with constant speed. At each time step, a given particle as- sumes the average direction of motion of its neighboring particles, with some added noise. As the noise amplitude decreases, the system undergoes a phase transition from a disordered state, in which the particles have no pref- ered global direction, to an ordered state, in which the particles move collectively in the same direction. This long-range order motivated renormalization group stud- ies by Toner and Tu [5]. They found that the stabiliza- tion of the ordered phase is due to the nonzero speed of the particles, allowing two originally distant particles to interact with each other at a later time. The phase transition was originally thought to be continuous [4] but recent numerical work [6] indicates that the transition is discontinuous with strong finite size effects. There are few analytical studies on this transition [7, 8]. They do not treat the original VM but simple models related to it. For example, Bertin et al. [7], study a model with simplified interactions and a continuous time dynamics by means of a Boltzmann equation. Numerical simulations of the VM [4, 6] show localized high-density structures, for which a Boltzmann descrip- tion, which is restricted to low densities, is not sufficient. Enskog's proposal to generalize the Boltzmann equation to dense gases was a major milestone in kinetic theory. In this Letter, it is shown how an Enskog-type equation with genuine multi-body collisions can be obtained for the VM and how this can be used to rigorously derive hydrody- namic equations. In addition to the terms postulated by Toner and Tu [5], the derived equations contain several new relevant terms which describe an intricate coupling between density and order parameter gradients. The co- efficients of all terms, compatible with the symmetries of the system, are calculated explicitly in third order of a gradient expansion. The new kinetic equation is used to determine the mean-field phase diagram of the VM, which agrees well with direct numerical simulations but disagrees with the results of a related continuous time model [7]. This shows the importance of explicitely tak- ing the discrete time, rule-based nature of the VM into account. The derived hydrodynamic equations are ap- plied to study the stability of a homogeneous flocking state against spatio-temporal perturbations. I discuss how an instability at the onset of collective motion can change the appearance of the phase transition from sec- ond to first order. Predictions for the system size where this change is expected to happen, are given. In the VM, a system of N pointlike particles with continuous spatial coordinates ri(t) and velocities vi(t) evolves via two steps: streaming and collision. During a time step τ , particles stream ballistically: xi(t + τ ) = xi(t) + τ vi(t). The magnitude of the particle velocities is fixed to v0. Only the directions θi of the velocity vectors are updated in the collision step: a circle of radius R is drawn around a given particle and the average direction ¯θi of motion of the particles within the circle is deter- mined according to ¯θi = arctan[Pn j cos(θj )]. The new directions follow as θi(t + τ ) = ¯θi(t) + ξi, where ξi is a random number chosen with uniform probabil- ity from the interval [−η/2, η/2]. Since explicitly coarse- graining the dynamics of the VM is difficult, in previ- ous work [9], I have first validated the formalism on a simpler equilibrium model [10] which shares essential fea- tures with the VM. The kinetic formalism starts with the Liouville equation for the N-particle probability density j sin(θj)/Pn P (θ(N ), X(N ) + τ V(N ), t + τ ) = ×Z 2π 0 dθ(N ) P (θ(N ), X(N ), t) N Yi=1 1 dξ(N ) −η/2 ηN Z η/2 δ(θi − ξi − ¯θi) (1) where X(N ) ≡ (x1, x2, . . . , xN ), θ(N ) ≡ (θ1, θ2, . . . , θN ), and δ(x) = P∞ m=−∞ δ(x + 2πm) is the periodically The velocities V(N ) ≡ continued delta function. (v1, v2, ..., vN ), are given in terms of angle variables, vi = v0(cos θi, sin θi). The collision integral contains integrations over the pre-collisional angles θj. Assum- ing that the particles are uncorrelated prior to the col- lisions, the probability distribution can be expressed as a product of identical one-particle probability distribu- i=1 P1(θi, xi). This approxi- mation of molecular chaos is valid at moderate and large noise strength η and when the mean free path (mfp) is large compared to the radius of interaction R. Here, the mfp is defined as the distance a particle travels between collisions, τ v0, and is density-independent due to the dis- crete nature of the dynamics. Multiplying Eq. (1) by tions: P (θ(N ), X(N )) = QN Pi δ(v − vi)δ(x − xi) and integrating over all particle positions xi and angles θi, yields in the large N -limit [9], a kinetic equation for the one-particle distribution func- tion, f (θ, x, t) = N P1(θ, x, t), 4 η 3 C 2 1 Numerics: Nagy et al. Theory: Aldana et al. Numerics 0 1 2 a) M 3 4 5 2 0.01 ω R L* 103 102 101 0.01 100 1 M 0 0 b) k 0.2 0.4 0.6 FIG. 1. a) The critical noise ηC as a function of the average number of collision partners, M = ρ0πR2, and the prediction of Eq. (35) for large v0 from Ref. [7], (dashed line), in com- parison with results from Refs. [4, 8, 11]. b) Real part of the growth rate, ωR, of a small longitudinal perturbation of the ordered state versus dimensionless wave number k at M = 5, very close to the threshold, (ηC −η)/ηC = 0.00057. The insert shows a lower and an upper bound for the crossover length L∗ (in units of the mfp) beyond which the phase transition is expected to become discontinuous. f (θ, x + τ v, t + τ ) = ×f (θ1, x, t) δ(θ − ξ − ¯θi) n Yi=2 1 η Z η/2 −η/2 e−MR dξ(cid:28)(cid:28) N Xn=1 f (θi, xi, t)(cid:29)θ(cid:29)x n! n (2) ability. Below a critical noise ηC (ρ0) there exists another fixed-point solution which breaks rotational symmetry. It has a maximum at some arbitrary angle θ and de- scribes ordered motion into this direction. The critical noise follows from the condition λ = 1, with 0 where MR(x, t) = RR ρ(y, t) dy is the average number of particles in a circle of radius R centered around x. The local particle density ρ is given as a moment of the distribution function, ρ(x, t) = R 2π 0 f (θ, x, t) dθ; h...ix = RR ... dx2 dx3...dxn denotes the integration over all posi- tions, n − 1 particles can assume within the interaction circle; h...iθ = R 2π ...dθ1dθ2...dθn is the average over all pre-collisional angles of n particles in the interaction cir- cle. Since particles in the VM have zero volume, there is a non-zero probability that a large number of parti- cles can be found in the collision circle of a given parti- cle. This leads to the unusual structure of the collision integral in which every term in the sum accounts for a n-particle collision. For example, the n = 4 term involves the product of four distribution functions and describes a four body collision. Interactions between particles which are not at the same position but a distance ≤ R apart are explicitely taken into account by Eq. (2). This leads to collisional momentum transfer which is a key feature of the Enskog equation and not included in Boltzmann- type equations. Hence, Eq. (2), can be interpreted as an Enskog-like equation for pointlike particles with discrete time evolution; it remains valid even at infinite density. Let us first consider a spatially homogeneous system and study stationary solutions of Eq. (2). This amounts to solving the fixed-point equation f0(θ) = C(f0) for the stationary distribution function f0, where C denotes the r.h.s. of Eq. (2). It can be easily checked that the con- stant distribution f0 = ρ0/2π is a fixed-point at any noise and average density, ρ0 = N/A, where A is the area of the system. This solution corresponds to the disordered phase, where all velocity directions occur at equal prob- λ = I(n) = 2(cid:17) e−MR 4 η sin(cid:16) η (2π)n Z 2π 1 0 N Xn=1 n2M n−1 R n! I(n) dθ1 . . .Z 2π 0 dθn cos ¯θ cos θ1 (3) Here, MR is equal to πR2ρ0 and ¯θ is the average angle de- fined above Eq. (1). The fixed-point equation was solved numerically for η ≤ ηC . The solution approaches a cosine with vanishing amplitude when η approaches the critical noise. By means of a Fourier cosine series in θ − θ the behavior at the critical point was extracted analytically. The order parameter, defined as the amplitude g1 of the first non-trivial Fourier coefficient, is found to behave as g1 ∝ √ηC − η. Thus, the order-disorder transition ap- pears to be continuous with the mean-field critical expo- nent of 1/2. Fig. 1a) shows the calculated phase diagram (solid line). Evaluating Eq. (3) in the low density limit gives ηC ∝ R√ρ. This scaling with the square root of the density agrees with previous numerical [4] and theoreti- cal results [6, 7]. However, there is no dependence of the critical noise on the particle speed in the large mfp limit, which is consistent with numerical simulations of the VM [4, 11] but disagrees with the scaling ηC ∝ √ρRv0 for [7]. The dashed ρ → 0 of the continuous model of Ref. line in Fig 1a) shows that the phase diagram of this model (obtained from Eq. (35) in [7] with v0τ /R = 5) does not describe the VM. Evaluating Eq. (3) in the infinite den- sity limit yields ηC → 2π. In order to see whether the homogeneous ordered state is stable under time evolu- tion, I derive the hydrodynamic equations by means of a Chapman-Enskog expansion [9, 12]. The basic idea be- hind this expansion is to take the local stationary state as a reference state and expand around it in powers of the hydrodynamic gradients. To systematically account for these gradients a dimensionless ordering parameter ǫ is introduced, which is set to unity at the end of the cal- culation. The procedure starts with a Taylor expansion of the l.h.s of Eq. (2) around (θ, x, t). The spatial gradi- ents that occur are scaled as ∂α → ǫ∂α, and multiple time scales ti are introduced in the temporal gradients. These time scales describe different physical processes, for ex- ample, in regular fluids, the time scale proportional to ǫ describes convection. For the VM, this is expressed as ∂t = ∂t0 + ǫ∂t1 + ǫ2∂t2 . . . . Expanding the distribution function and the collision integral in powers of ǫ, f = f0 + ǫf1 + ǫ2f2 + ..., and C = C0 + ǫC1 + ǫ2C2 + ..., inserting into Eq. (2), and collecting terms of the same order in ǫ leads to a hi- erarchy of evolution equations for the fi. Due to the absence of momentum conservation and Galilean invari- ance this set of equations is dramatically different from the usual one. It is not a priori evident whether the scaling ansatz for the time derivatives is correct. How- ever, it turns out that this choice avoids any incon- sistencies if additionally the expansion of the distribu- tion function f is identified as an angular Fourier series with f0(x, t) = ρ(x, t)/2π and, for n > 0, fn(x, θ, t) = [an(x, t) cos (nθ) + bn(x, t) sin (nθ)] /πvn 0 . Many moments of the collision integral such as hvxvyC2i = R 2π 0 vxvyC2 dθ are required in the Chapman- Enskog expansion. For simplicity, these moments are evaluated in the limit of large mfp, τ v0 ≫ R. This in- volves solving the following four integrals, Jm(n) = 1 (2π)n Z 2π 0 dθ1 . . .Z 2π 0 dθn Ψm (4) where Ψm is given by Ψ1 = cos2 ¯θ cos 2θ1, Ψ2 = cos ¯θ sin ¯θ cos θ1 sin θ2, Ψ3 = cos ¯θ cos θ1 cos 2θ2, and Ψ4 = cos ¯θ cos θ1 cos θ2 cos θ3. The average angle ¯θ is a function of the angles θ1, θ2, . . . θn. moments of f , namely the particle density ρ = R 2π (wx, wy), ~w = R 2π We seek a hydrodynamic description of the first two 0 f dθ and the macroscopic momentum density vector ~w = 0 ~vf dθ. Inserting the Fourier represen- tation of f into these moments shows that the first order coefficients are given by the momentum density, a1 = wx and b1 = wy. Multiplying the hierarchy of evolution equations by powers of the microscopic velocity vector ~v = (vx, vy) and integrating over θ gives a set of equa- tions for the time development of the density and the moments ai and bi. This analysis is performed in the vicinity of the critical point, λ − 1 ≪ 1, in order to sig- nificantly simplify the consistent closure of the hierarchy of moment equations, see [11]. For simplicity, all equations are rescaled by expressing time in units of τ and distances in units of the mfp, τ v0, which also makes ρ and ~w dimensionless. After straight- 3 j 1 hj 1+p 8(p−1) qj S kj S 2(p−1) 8(p−1) 96(p−1)2 2 − p2+10p+1 3 − q 2(p−1) 4 q(1+p) 4(p−1)2 4(p−1)2 − S Γ − Sq 2 − Sq(p−3) 2(p−1)2 p−1 Γ 5 − q(p2+10p+1) 48(p−1)3 Γ 24 − Sq(p2 −2p+13) 24(p−1)3 Γ 4(p−1) 96(p−1)2 − S(p+5) 4 − Sq 12 − Sq(p−4) − Sq(p+5) 48(p−1)3 12(p−1)2 Γ TABLE I. The transport coefficients hj , qj and kj, defined in Eq. (6), are expressed as functions of Γ, S, p, q, see Eq. (8). forward, but tedious, calculations one obtains the con- tinuity equation ∂tρ + ∂αwα = 0, and a rotationally- invariant equation for the momentum density, ∂t ~w +∇ · H = −b∇ρ + (λ− 1) ~w + Q1 · ~w + Q2 ·∇ρ (5) with b = (3 − λ)/4. The momentum flux tensor H and the tensors Q1, Q2, 5 5 5 H = hi Ωi Q1 = qi Ωi Q2 = ki Ωi Xi=1 Xi=1 Xi=1 (6) are given in terms of five symmetric traceless tensors Ωi, Ω1,αβ = ∂αwβ + ∂βwα − δαβ∂γwγ Ω2,αβ = 2∂α∂βρ − δαβ∂2 γρ Ω3,αβ = 2wαwβ − δαβw2 Ω4,αβ = wα∂βρ + wβ ∂αρ − δαβwγ∂γρ Ω5,αβ = 2(∂αρ)(∂βρ) − δαβ(∂γ)2 . (7) The tensor Ω1 is the viscous stress tensor of a two- dimensional fluid. The transport coefficients in Eq. (6) are given in Table I. They depend on the following vari- ables, p = 4 η sin (η) N Xn=1 e−MR n! n2M n−1 R J1(n) q = S = 4πγ2 η 8πγ2 η sin (η) e−MR n! n2(n − 1)M n−2 R J2(n) sin η 2 e−MR n! n2(n − 1)M n−2 R J3(n) (8) N N Xn=2 Xn=2 Xn=3 N Γ = 8π2γ4 3η sin η 2 e−MR n! n2(n − 1)(n − 2)M n−3 R J4(n) where γ is the ratio of the interaction radius to the mfp, γ = R/τ v0. Eq. (5) is consistent with the one postulated in Ref. [5] but contains additional gradient terms. It has a homogeneous flocking solution: ~w = w0 n and ρ = ρ0. The amplitude of the flow is given by w0 = p(1 − λ)/q3. In order to study the spontaneous onset of collective motion, a perturbation around this state is considered, ρ(x, t) = ρ0 + δρ eik·x+ωt, ~w(x, t) = w0 n + δ ~w eik·x+ωt, and Eq. (5) is linearized in δρ and δ ~w. The characteristic equation for the growth rate ω(~k) describes three possible modes. I found that in a small window, ηS < η < ηC , di- rectly below the onset of flocking, one of the longitudinal modes is always unstable against long wavelength pertur- bations: the real part of ω is positive for 0 < k < k0 as shown in Fig. 1b). A similar instability was reported by Bertin et al. [7]. Chat´e et al. [6] found numerically that the order/disorder transition is discontinuous for system sizes L larger than the crossover length L∗. Assuming that the long wave instability is the reason for this fi- nite size effect, I calculated the largest value of k0 within the narrow instability window at constant density, k∗, in order to obtain a lower bound for L∗. Plotting 2π/k∗ gives the lower curve in the insert of Fig. 1b). An up- per bound was obtained by determining the wave number kmax where the growth rate has the largest value inside the instability window. The upper curve in the insert shows 2π/kmax as a function of density. The minimum around M ≈ 2 and the divergences at small and large densities are consistent with numerical results [6]. To see what happens to a growing perturbation be- yond the linear instability, the continuity equation and Eq. (5) were integrated on a L × L lattice with peri- odic boundaries by means of a predictor-corrector scheme [13]. These simulations confirmed that the ordered phase is stable for small system sizes L < 2π/k0. For slightly larger system sizes one observes a stable, inho- mogeneous steady state with a global order parameter, h ~wi = R ~w dx/L2, larger than the amplitude of the homo- geneous state, w0. Finally, for much larger system sizes, it turns out that the system is both linearly and nonlin- early unstable for ηS < η < ηC . Longitudinal pertur- bations grow without bound; they do not lead to stable solitons as suggested in Ref. [7]. However, direct simula- tions of the VM at large mfp do show solitary structures such as traveling high-density bands in a window just be- low the transition [6, 11]. At lower noise these structures disappear. Identifying this "solitary" window with the instability window, its size can be predicted by the cur- rent theory which takes all the details of the VM such as multi-body interactions into account. However, inside this window, the hydrodynamic equations are driven out of the range of their validity and are not suited to describe solitons. Nagy et al [4] did not see high-density bands at small velocity v0. To treat this limit of small mfp theoret- ically, one has to abandon the molecular chaos approx- imation i.e. go beyond the mean-field approximation, which is outside the scope of this paper. 4 In summary, a first-principle derivation of the hydro- dynamic equations of the VM by means of a novel ki- netic theory is presented and a stability analysis of the resulting equations, Eq. (5), is performed. The mean- field phase diagram for arbitrary density is calculated. It agrees within a few percent with simulation results and is shown to be independent of the particle speed in the large mfp limit. It is also shown that the continuous theory of [7] fails to reproduce the phase diagram of the VM and that one has to explicitely incorporate the discrete time dynamics and genuine multi-body interactions in order to achieve agreement. The theory presented here is con- sistent with numerical studies [4, 6], and suggests the fol- lowing picture of the nature of the flocking transition in the large mfp limit considered here: At η = ηC a homo- geneous ordered state bifurcates continuously from the disordered state. At the threshold, this state is unstable to longitudinal, long wavelength fluctuations. Perturba- tions from a large range of wave numbers k < k0 become unstable, already in close vicinity to the threshold. The transition appears to be continuous in small systems but becomes a discontinuos transition in large systems due to the emergence of density waves which abruptly in- crease the global order parameter. An estimate of the system size L∗, above which the discontinuous nature of the transition is expected to emerge, is given. This length is found to diverge at small and large densities, consistent with numerical results. Support from the National Science Foundation under grant No. DMR-0706017 is gratefully acknowledged. I thank F. Julicher, L.S. Schulman, H. Chat´e, A. Denton, A. Wagner and D. Kroll for valuable discussions. [1] I.D. Couzin et al., Nature 433, 513 (2005). [2] Y.G. Tao and R. Kapral, Soft Matter 6, 756 (2010). [3] J. F. Joanny et al., New J. Phys. 9 422 (2007). [4] T. Vicsek et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1226 (1995); A. Czir´ok, H. E. Stanley, T. Vicsek, J. Phys. A, 30, 1375 (1997); M. Nagy, I. Daruka, T. Vicsek, Physica A 373, 445 (2007). [5] J. Toner and Y. Tu, Phys. Rev. E 58, 4828 (1998). [6] G. Gr´egoire and H. Chat´e, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 025702 (2004); H. Chat´e et al., Phys. Rev. E 77, 046113 (2008); Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 229601 (2007). [7] E. Bertin, M. Droz, and G. Gr´egoire, Phys. Rev. E 74, 022101 (2006); J. Phys. A 42, 445001 (2009). [8] M. Aldana et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 095702 (2007). [9] T. Ihle, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 11, 9667 (2009). [10] G. Gompper et al., Adv. Polym. Sci. 221, 1 (2009). [11] T. Ihle, A. Gebremariam, in preparation. [12] D. McQuarrie, Statistical Mechanics, New York, 1976. [13] R.W. MacCormack, AIAA Journal 20, 1275 (1982).
1803.09516	1	1803	2018-03-26T11:24:30	Role of salt valency in the switch of H-NS proteins between DNA-bridging and DNA-stiffening modes	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.BM", "q-bio.GN" ]	This work investigates the interactions of H-NS proteins and bacterial genomic DNA through computer simulations performed with a coarse-grained model. The model was developed specifically to study the switch of H-NS proteins from the DNA-stiffening to the DNA-bridging mode, which has been observed repeatedly upon addition of multivalent cations to the buffer, but is still not understood. Unravelling the corresponding mechanism is all the more crucial, as the regulation properties of H-NS proteins, as well as other nucleoid proteins, are linked to their DNA-binding properties. The simulations reported here support a mechanism, according to which the primary role of multivalent cations consists in decreasing the strength of H-NS/DNA interactions compared to H-NS/H-NS interactions, with the latter ones becoming energetically favored with respect to the former ones above a certain threshold of the effective valency of the cations of the buffer. Below the threshold, H-NS dimers form filaments, which stretch along the DNA molecule but are quite inefficient in bridging genomically distant DNA sites (DNA-stiffening mode). In contrast, just above the threshold, H-NS dimers form 3-dimensional clusters, which are able to connect DNA sites that are distant from the genomic point of view (DNA-bridging mode). The model provides clear rationales for the experimental observations that the switch between the two modes is a threshold effect and that the ability of H-NS dimers to form higher order oligomers is crucial for their bridging capabilities.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Role of salt valency in the switch of H-NS proteins between DNA-bridging and DNA-stiffening modes Marc Joyeux(#) Laboratoire Interdisciplinaire de Physique, CNRS and Université Grenoble Alpes, Grenoble, France Running title: bridging/stiffening modes of H-NS Abstract: This work investigates the interactions of H-NS proteins and bacterial genomic DNA through computer simulations performed with a coarse-grained model. The model was developed specifically to study the switch of H-NS proteins from the DNA-stiffening to the DNA-bridging mode, which has been observed repeatedly upon addition of multivalent cations to the buffer, but is still not understood. Unravelling the corresponding mechanism is all the more crucial, as the regulation properties of H-NS proteins, as well as other nucleoid proteins, are linked to their DNA-binding properties. The simulations reported here support a mechanism, according to which the primary role of multivalent cations consists in decreasing the strength of H-NS/DNA interactions compared to H-NS/H-NS interactions, with the latter ones becoming energetically favored with respect to the former ones above a certain threshold of the effective valency of the cations of the buffer. Below the threshold, H-NS dimers form filaments, which stretch along the DNA molecule but are quite inefficient in bridging genomically distant DNA sites (DNA-stiffening mode). In contrast, just above the threshold, H-NS dimers form 3-dimensional clusters, which are able to connect DNA sites that are distant from the genomic point of view (DNA-bridging mode). The model provides clear rationales for the experimental observations that the switch between the two modes is a threshold effect and that the ability of H-NS dimers to form higher order oligomers is crucial for their bridging capabilities. (#) [email protected] 1 INTRODUCTION Nucleoid Associated Proteins (NAP) are DNA-binding proteins with low to medium sequence specificity, which participate actively in bacteria' chromosome organization and gene expression regulation by bridging, bending, or caging the DNA molecule (1-3). Despite continuous efforts of several groups (see (1-3) and references therein), the mechanisms by which NAP achieve these goals remain in most cases elusive and controversial. Part of the difficulty arises from the fact that these mechanisms appear to be specific to each NAP. For example, the histone-like nucleoid structuring protein (H-NS), ParB, and structural maintenance of chromosome proteins (SMC) are all believed to bridge DNA, but the bridges are qualitatively different, which results in different effects on chromosome organization and gene expression regulation (4). Even worse, a single NAP may display several binding modes to DNA, depending on a variety of external factors, like pH, temperature, and the composition of the buffer (5-9). For example, atomic force microscopy and optical tweezers experiments first suggested that H-NS binding to DNA leads to the formation of bridges between DNA duplexes (this is the so-called bridging mode) (5), while subsequent magnetic tweezers experiments instead concluded that the DNA molecule rather adopts a more extended and stiffer conformation upon binding of the proteins (this is the so-called stiffening mode) (6). It was later pointed out that the discrepancy between the two sets of experiments may arise from the fact that the buffer used in the first set of experiments contained divalent salt cations, while the buffer used in the second set did not, and it was accordingly shown that both binding modes do exist and that a switch between the two of them can be driven by changes in divalent cations concentrations (7). More recent small angle neutron scattering experiments (8), as well as experiments performed in confined geometries (9), confirmed the crucial role of divalent cations. Still, it should be pointed out, as stated in (7), that "the specific mechanism by which magnesium and calcium ions alter H-NS binding properties is currently unknown", which is an all the more regrettable lack, as the regulation properties of H-NS (10,11), as well as other NAP (12,13), are probably linked to their DNA-binding properties. The purpose of the present paper is to propose an explanation for the role of divalent cations, based on our current knowledge of the properties of H-NS proteins and the results of simulations performed with a coarse-grained model, which was developed specifically for this purpose. H-NS is a small protein (137 residues, 15.5 kDa), which is functional as a dimer. Each monomer consists of a N-terminal oligomerization domain (residues 1-64) (14,15) and a C- 2 terminal DNA-binding domain (residues 91-137) (16) connected by a flexible linker (17). A secondary dimerization site at the C-terminal end of the main oligomerization domain allows H-NS dimers to organize in superhelical chains in crystals (18) and is probably also responsible for the oligomerization of H-NS in solution, where dimers, tetramers, and larger oligomers have been observed under different conditions (14,19,20). A thermodynamic analysis of such solutions led to a value of the enthalpy change upon dimerization or tetramerization of H-NS proteins of the order of 10 TkB at room temperature (20), which is very close to the value that was reported for the enthalpy change upon formation of a complex between DNA and a H-NS protein in solution (21). As will be developed below, this similarity of the values of the enthalpy changes upon oligomerization of H-NS and binding of H-NS to DNA is crucial for the dynamics of H-NS/DNA mixtures. A second important point deals with the very peculiar properties of DNA when immersed in a solution containing dilute cations. Naked DNA is indeed a highly charged polyanion with two phosphate groups per base pair, resulting in a bare linear charge density of about -5.9 nm/e , where e is the absolute charge of the electron. However, the Manning- Oosawa condensation theory (22,23) stipulates that the net linear charge density along a polyion immersed in a buffer containing counterions of valency Z cannot be larger than BZe ℓ /( ) , where =ℓ B 2 e pe 4/( e 0 Tk Br ) denotes the Bjerrum length of the buffer, that is, the distance at which the electrostatic interaction between two elementary charges e is equal to the thermal energy TkB . If the bare charge density along the naked polyion is larger than the critical value BZe ℓ /( ) , then an instability occurs and counterions coalesce on the polyion and neutralize an increasing number of its charges, till the net density reduces to the critical value BZe ℓ /( ) . Owing to its relative dielectric constant e r 80 , the Bjerrum length of water at 25°C is ℓ B 7.0» nm and the critical charge density nm/4.1 e (for a buffer with monovalent cations) or nm/7.0 e (for a buffer with divalent cations). This implies that (i) counterions do coalesce on the DNA molecule for both monovalent and divalent cations, and (ii) increasing the valency of the cations leads to a proportional reduction of the net charge density along the DNA. Counterion condensation is expected to have important consequences on H-NS/DNA interactions. Indeed, except in the vicinity of a few high-affinity binding sites (24), H- NS/DNA interactions are mainly non-specific, as indicated by the very small variation of the change in heat capacity with temperature in the range 10-25°C (21) and by the fact that protein occupation on DNA decreases as monovalent salt concentration increases (7). H-NS 3 » - » - » proteins and cationic counterions therefore compete for binding to the DNA and theory indicates that the binding of polypeptides to the DNA is indeed accompanied by the release of counterions in the buffer (25-28). The counterions regain translational entropy upon release from the DNA (25-28), so that the net energy balance for the binding of ligands to the DNA results from subtle enthalpy-entropy compensations (29,30). Of outmost importance for the present work is the fact that this balance depends sensitively on the valency of the cationic counterions present in the buffer. It has indeed repeatedly been observed that addition of small amounts of divalent cations provokes a substantial decrease of the free energy of binding of polypeptides and proteins to nucleic acids (31-33). In contrast, the bare charge density is much smaller along proteins than along nucleic acids, usually smaller than Manning-Oosawa's critical density, so that counterion condensation is expected to be much less marked for proteins than for nucleic acids, although there are theoretical indications that it might not totally vanish (34). Still, the short length of H-NS proteins should contribute to further diminish the eventual importance of counterion condensation (34), if it does take place. As a consequence, H-NS/H-NS interactions are expected to remain mostly insensitive to the valency of the cations of the buffer. More precisely, both H-NS/H-NS and H-NS/DNA interactions depend on the ionic strength of the buffer through the variation of the Debye length, but H-NS/DNA interactions depend additionally very sensitively on the valency of the cations through the mechanisms of counterion condensation and release. Considered together, the arguments sketched above consequently suggest that binding of H-NS to DNA is favored in buffers with monovalent cations, while oligomerization of H- NS proteins is favored in buffers containing substantial amounts of divalent cations, the role of divalent cations (like magnesium and calcium ions) consisting precisely in displacing the equilibrium from predominant H-NS/DNA interactions towards predominant H-NS/H-NS interactions. While this assumption is the key point of the present work, there still remains to understand why displacing the equilibrium towards leading H-NS/H-NS interactions drives H-NS from the stiffening to the bridging mode. In the same spirit as for previous work dealing with facilitated diffusion (35-37) and the compaction of genomic DNA inside the nucleoid (38-42), a mesoscopic beads and springs-type model was developed specifically to answer this question. This model incorporates the effective valency of the cations, Z, as a free parameter and simulations were launched with different values of Z. The results presented in Results and Discussion highlight the fact that a small variation of Z is indeed able to induce 4 strong changes in the conformations of the system. More precisely, in the range of values of Z where H-NS/DNA interactions prevail over H-NS/H-NS interactions, the dynamics of the system is driven by the attachment of protein chains to the DNA chain in cis configuration, their sliding along the DNA, and the formation of filaments of proteins along the DNA duplex, with the length and internal connectivity of the filaments increasing with Z. Such filaments have repeatedly been reported as a characteristic of the stiffening mode (6,7,10). For slightly larger values of Z, H-NS oligomerization however takes over the binding of H-NS to DNA and the system rather organizes in the form of 3-dimensional H-NS clusters, which efficiently bind regions of the DNA duplex that are broadly separated from the genomic point of view. This is the bridging mode, which leads to the collapse of the DNA for sufficiently large protein concentrations. This work consequently supports a mechanism for the switch of H-NS proteins from the DNA-stiffening mode to the DNA-bridging mode upon increase of the concentration of divalent cations, which consists of (i) the displacement of the equilibrium from predominant H-NS/DNA interactions towards predominant H-NS/H-NS interactions, and (ii) the resulting switch of the preferred organization of H-NS proteins from filaments stretching along a genomic contiguous part of the DNA molecule to clusters able to connect parts of the DNA molecule that are genomically broadly separated. METHODS The mesoscopic model which has been developed for the present study is described in detail in Model and Simulations in the Supporting Material. In brief, the DNA is modelled as a circular chain of 2880 beads with radius 1.0 nm separated at equilibrium by a distance 5.2 nm and enclosed in a sphere with radius 120 nm. Two beads represent 15 DNA base pairs. Both the contour length of the DNA molecule and the cell volume are reduced by a factor of approximately 200 with respect to their actual values in E. coli cells, so that the nucleic acid concentration of the model is close to the in vivo one. DNA beads interact through stretching, bending, and electrostatic terms. The bending rigidity constant is chosen so that the model reproduces the known persistence length of DNA (50 nm). Electrostatic repulsion between DNA beads is written as a sum of Debye-Hückel terms, which depend on effective electrostatic charges placed at the center of each bead. These charges are assumed to be inversely proportional to a parameter Z, which represents the effective valency of the cations of the buffer, in order to account for counterion condensation along the DNA molecule. Z is 5 equal to 1 (respectively, 2) for monovalent (respectively, divalent) cations, but may take any real value between 1 and 2 when divalent cations are added to a buffer that contains monovalent cations. This point is discussed in more detail in Results and Discussion. Repulsion between DNA beads decreases as 2 /1 Z upon increase of Z. H-NS dimers are modeled as chains of 4 beads with radius 1.0 nm separated at equilibrium by a distance 4.0 nm. For most simulations, 200 protein chains were introduced in the confining sphere together with the DNA chain, which corresponds to a protein concentration approximately twice the concentration of H-NS dimers during the cell growth phase and six times the concentration during the stationary phase (43). Protein chains have internal stretching and bending energy and interact with each other and with the DNA chain. The value of the bending constant is assumed to be as low as TkB2 , in order to account for the flexible linker that connects the C-terminal and N-terminal domains of H-NS (17). A major approximation of the model consists in assuming that the interactions among protein beads and between protein beads and DNA beads are mediated uniquely by effective electrostatic charges placed at the center of each protein bead and to disregard all interactions beyond the crude electrostatic ones. The charges are positive for the two terminal beads of each chain and negative for the two central beads. The terminal beads of each protein chain can therefore bind either to the beads of the DNA chain or to the central beads of other protein chains, so that the model accounts for both H-NS oligomerization and binding of H-NS to DNA. The values of the charges at the center of protein beads are assumed to be independent of Z, thereby reflecting the fact that counterion condensation on proteins is negligible. Consequently, the attraction term between terminal beads of a protein chain and central beads of another protein chain does not depend on Z, while the attraction term between DNA beads and terminal protein beads evolves as Z/1 . This is one of the key points of the model. A Lennard-Jones-type excluded volume term is added to the attractive Debye-Hückel term for pairs of beads with opposite charges. For the sake of simplicity, this excluded volume potential is assumed to be independent of Z and identical for protein/protein and protein/DNA pairs of beads. The two parameters of the potential were adjusted manually in order that the enthalpy changes upon forming a complex between two protein chains and between a protein chain and the DNA chain are comparable to the experimentally determined value for H-NS (20,21). As shown in Figs. S1 and S2 of the Supplemental Material, this enthalpy change is equal to TkB0.12 both for two protein chains approaching one another perpendicularly, and for a protein chain approaching the linear DNA chain perpendicularly at 37.1=Z . Since H- 6 - NS/DNA attraction decreases like Z/1 , while H-NS/H-NS attraction does not depend on Z, it is expected that this value Z = 1.37 plays a critical role in the model, with the formation of H- NS/DNA bonds being energetically favored for favored for Z > 1.37 . This particular value Z < 37.1=Z 1.37 and oligomerization of H-NS being will therefore be labelled critZ in the remainder of the paper. The evolution with Z of the enthalpy change upon formation of a H- NS/DNA bond is shown as a solid line in Fig. 1 and the enthalpy change upon formation of a H-NS/H-NS bond as a horizontal dot-dashed line. The dashed line indicates the energy of the saddles that separate two minima, see Fig. S2. The distance between the solid and dashed lines therefore represents the gap that proteins must overcome to translocate from one DNA binding site to the next one. It is worth emphasizing that the model proposed here relies on a rather crude approximation, in the sense that it ignores most of the complexity of the binding of H-NS proteins to the DNA. The model indeed assumes that binding dynamics is governed by electrostatic interactions between protein beads and the DNA chain, which carries the critical charge density for a given value of Z, and disregards more complex mechanisms, like the release of counterions. This model was used in spite of its naivety, because it nonetheless reproduces the marked decrease of the H-NS/DNA binding energy upon addition of multivalent cations, which is central to this work. The dynamics of the complete system was investigated by integrating numerically the Langevin equations of motion with kinetic energy terms dropped and with time step set to 1.0 ps for simulations with 200 protein chains and 0.5 ps for 1000 protein chains. After each integration step, the position of the centre of the confining sphere was slightly adjusted so as to coincide with the centre of mass of the DNA molecule. Temperature T was assumed to be 33.1=Z 298 K throughout the study. Representative snapshots for 200 protein chains and , 1.42, and 1.50, are shown in Fig. 2. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION As mentioned in the Introduction, the Manning-Oosawa condensation theory (22,23) stipulates that the effective linear charge along a highly charged polyion immersed in a buffer containing counterions of valency Z is BZe ℓ /( ) as soon as counterion condensation occurs. The case of a buffer containing cations of two different valencies 2Z is more complex, because the cations compete for condensation. Still, the fractions of DNA phosphate sites 1Z and 7 neutralized by cations of type 1 and 2 ( 1 the equations derived in (44). One can then compute the effective valency of the cations of the q , respectively) can be readily obtained from q and 2 buffer, according to = Z ℓ B Z 11 b ( q 1 17.0=b q Z 22 where + q Z 11 , ) q 22 Z (1) nm is the effective distance between two charges along naked DNA, and the total fraction of DNA phosphate charges neutralized by the different cations. Z is always comprised between 1Z and 2Z and the net linear charge density along the DNA backbone is BZe ℓ /( ) . Application of Eq. (1) to a buffer containing 10mM of MgCl2 in addition to 60mM of KCl, as was used in (5) and also investigated in (31-33), leads to an effective valency 63.1=Z , meaning that addition of a relatively small amount of divalent cations results in a significant increase of Z. Addition of this amount of MgCl2 also increases the Debye length by about 30%, but this variation affects H-NS/DNA and H-NS/H-NS interactions essentially in the same way, so that this effect will be disregarded in the present simulations, which focus on the effects of varying Z on the dynamics of the system. In the model, the effective valency Z is actually considered as a free parameter, which affects only the charge placed at the center of each DNA bead, this charge being obtained as the product of the equilibrium distance between two beads and the net linear charge density BZe ℓ /( ) . Simulations were run for 9 different values of Z ranging from 1.0 to 1.67 and two different numbers of protein chains (200 and 1000), while keeping all other parameters of the system constant. Representative snapshots of the conformations obtained with 200 proteins chains and Z=1.33, 1.42, and 1.50, are shown in Fig. 2. It is reminded that H-NS/DNA , while H-NS/H-NS interactions are interactions are energetically favored for < ZZ 37.1 = crit favored for Z > critZ . Visually, one indeed observes a qualitative difference between the three snapshots in Fig. 2, with the protein chains organizing principally in short filaments stretching along the DNA for Z=1.33, in rather loose clusters connected to the DNA for Z=1.42, and in bigger, more compact clusters connected to the DNA for Z=1.50. A more quantitative insight into the evolution of the conformations of the system can be gained by plotting, for increasing values of Z, the probability distribution )(sp for a protein chain to be bound to s DNA beads (Fig. 3, left column), the probability distribution ( )q s for a protein chain to be bound to s other protein chains (Fig. 3, right column), as well as the probability distribution ( )u s for this protein chain to belong to a cluster composed of s 8 - - - - protein chains (Fig. 4) (the closely related plot of the size distribution of protein clusters is shown is Fig. S3 of the Supporting Material). For this purpose, it was considered that the protein chain is bound to a DNA bead if their interaction is attractive and of total magnitude (computed according to Eq. (S11)) larger than B3 k T , and that two protein chains are bound if the interaction between one chain and one terminal bead of the other chain is attractive and of total magnitude (computed according to Eq. (S9)) larger than B3 k T . The choice of the threshold is somewhat arbitrary but the principal features of the distributions do not depend critically thereon. It is seen in Fig. 3 that for Z=1.00, that is, when H-NS/DNA interactions are energetically favored with respect to H-NS/H-NS ones, most protein chains bind to four DNA beads but do not bind to other protein chains. Remembering that tight binding of a protein chain to the DNA chain involves two consecutive DNA beads (see Fig. S2), this indicates that most protein chains bind the DNA chain with their two terminal beads (that is, in cis) while remaining separated from the other protein chains. This is confirmed by the distribution of cluster sizes (Fig. 4), which indicates that about 70% of the protein chains belong to clusters of size 1 (and about 25% to clusters of size 2). In contrast, for Z=1.67, that is, when H-NS/H- NS interactions are energetically favored with respect to H-NS/DNA ones, most protein chains do not bind to the DNA chain but bind instead on average to 5 other protein chains (Fig. 3). This suggests that protein chains form large clusters, which interact only loosely with the DNA chain. The distribution of cluster sizes (Fig. 4) accordingly indicates that large clusters with size up to 100 chains sequestrate the majority of protein chains. For 200 protein chains, the transition between these two limiting regimes occurs around Z crit = 37.1 , as may be checked in Fig. 3. In this range of values of Z, many protein chains bind to one other protein chain and form simultaneously one strong bond (involving two DNA beads) with the DNA chain. This suggests that filaments of connected protein chains form along the DNA chain, where each protein chain binds with one terminal bead to the DNA chain and with the other terminal bead to the neighboring protein chain. The plot of ( )u s in Fig. 4 accordingly indicates that, for Z=1.33, about 35% of the protein chains belong to filaments of size 3 to 6 (and about 35% to filaments of size 2). These filaments are admittedly not very long and they are furthermore dispersed rather randomly over the whole contour length of the DNA chain. It should however be reminded that 200 protein chains correspond approximately to one H-NS dimer per 100 DNA base pair, that is, about twice the physiological concentration during the cell growth phase (43). This concentration is much smaller than the typical protein concentrations used in (6,7,9,10), which were of the order of 9 one H-NS dimer per one to ten DNA base pairs and led to the collapse of the DNA molecule when no stretching force was applied to its extremities. Simulations indicate that, for 1000 protein chains, filaments form at lower values of Z, are much longer, and cover significantly larger portions of the DNA contour length, as may be checked in Fig. 5, which shows a representative snapshot of the system for Z=1.17. Careful analysis of the results of simulations indicate that the mechanical properties of the DNA chain (like its persistence length) are not significantly altered by the assembly of protein filaments on the DNA chain, even for 1000 protein chains. This is probably due to the fact that the bending rigidity of the protein chains was assumed to be much smaller than the rigidity of the DNA chain, in order to account for the flexible linker that connects the C- terminal and N-terminal domains of H-NS (17). As a consequence, the protein chains and the filaments merely adapt to the deformations of the DNA chain without hampering them significantly. This property of the model is in clear contradiction with experimental results, which indicate that the formation of filaments is accompanied by an increase in the persistence length and stiffness of the DNA molecule (6,7,10). Such a discrepancy between the results of simulations and experiments strongly suggests that protein filaments are in themselves not responsible for the increased stiffness and that the mechanism behind it is more probably related to the way H-NS dimers bind to the DNA duplex. More precisely, it has been shown that H-NS dimers insert one C-terminal loop inside the minor groove of double-stranded DNA (45). Binding of a H-NS dimer to a DNA site consequently decreases the flexibility of the DNA chain at this particular location, a point not accounted for in the model, and the many H-NS/DNA bonds associated with the formation of protein filaments are probably responsible for the observed increase in overall DNA stiffness. Another important feature of protein filaments is that they stretch along the DNA chain but only seldom bridge sites that are broadly separated from the genomic point of view. However, the geometry of protein clusters changes drastically above Z = crit 37.1 , where H- NS/H-NS interactions become energetically favored with respect to H-NS/DNA ones. Indeed, above critZ protein clusters grow in three dimensions in the buffer, instead of growing in one dimension along the DNA chain, which enables them to form simultaneous contacts with several sites along the DNA chain that are not contiguous from the genomic point of view, as may be checked in the middle and bottom vignettes of Fig. 2. Particularly striking is the plot, as a function of Z, of the number of indirect connections between pairs of DNA beads mediated by H-NS clusters, which is shown in Fig. 6. Two DNA beads are considered to be 10 connected if they are linked by protein chains that form a continuous series of contacts of the form d-p-p-p-... -p-p-p-d, where d denotes a DNA bead and p a protein chain, and there is no limit on the number of intercalated protein chains p. The same threshold as above is used for defining a contact ( B3 k T for both DNA/H-NS and H-NS/H-NS contacts), and only pairs of DNA beads d separated along the DNA chain (genomic separation) by 50 or more other DNA beads are taken into account (the result is essentially independent of the exact value of the separation threshold, as soon as it is larger than the contour length of the short protein filaments observed for 200 protein chains). It is seen in Fig. 6, that the number of connections increases sharply just above critZ , which indicates that connection of distant DNA sites by H- NS proteins is efficient only when H-NS/H-NS interactions are favored with respect to H- NS/DNA ones and H-NS proteins are able to form clusters in three dimensions. Let us mention for the sake of completeness that other quantities, like the coverage of the DNA chain by protein chains, may however display smoother variations around critZ than the quantities discussed above, as can be checked in Fig. S4 of the Supporting Material. For the specific case of the coverage of the DNA chain by protein chains, the smoother behavior is due to the fact that the formation of both protein filaments and 3-dimensional clusters contribute to reduce the coverage of DNA (because of the overlap of protein chains in the former case and of protein chains not being bound to the DNA chain in the latter case), so that coverage of DNA decreases steadily and rather uniformly over the full range of variation of Z. It is worth emphasizing that the present work consequently describes the DNA- bridging mode of H-NS proteins as consisting of protein clusters that bind broadly separated sites along the DNA chain, and not, as is often more or less implicitly assumed, as tracts of parallel proteins that bridge two parallel DNA duplexes. This latter description emerges quite naturally when looking at atomic force micrographs of DNA/protein complexes deposited on mica plates (5), but simulations have shown that the conformations of DNA/protein complexes are significantly different in bulk and in planar conditions and that the parallel protein bridges geometry arises from the rearrangement of the complexes after their deposition on the charged surface (38,39). Moreover, recent single-molecule experiments have reported the presence of clusters of H-NS proteins buried inside the nucleoid (46), while other experiments have shown that mutants of H-NS, which have disrupted dimer-dimer interactions and cannot form higher order oligomers, are also unable to form bridges between two DNA duplexes (47). The ability for H-NS dimers to clusterize therefore appears as a prerequisite for their ability to bridge distant DNA sites, which strongly supports the 11 conclusions of the present work. Finally, it has been shown in the same work that the transition from no bridging to complete bridging is very abrupt upon increase of the concentration of magnesium ions (47), which is again in agreement with the threshold effect observed in Fig. 6. CONCLUSION The coarse-grained model developed in the present work fully supports the mechanism proposed in the Introduction, according to which the primary role of divalent cations in the switch of H-NS proteins from the DNA-stiffening mode to the DNA-bridging mode consists in decreasing the strength of H-NS/DNA interactions with respect to the strength of H-NS/H- NS interactions, with the latter ones becoming energetically favored above a certain threshold of the effective valency. The geometry of H-NS clusters changes drastically at this threshold. Below the threshold, H-NS dimers form filaments, which stretch along the DNA molecule but are quite inefficient in bridging DNA sites that are not contiguous from the genomic point of view. This is the DNA-stiffening mode. In contrast, above the threshold, H-NS dimers form 3-dimensional clusters, which are able to connect DNA sites that are distant from the genomic point of view. This is the DNA-bridging mode. The model does not reproduce the increase in DNA stiffness induced by the assembly of protein filaments on the DNA molecule, because it does not account for the local increase of rigidity associated with the insertion of the C-terminal loop of H-NS proteins inside the minor groove of the DNA molecule. In contrast, it provides clear rationales for the experimental observations that the switch between the two modes is a threshold effect and that the ability of H-NS dimers to further oligomerize is crucial for their bridging capabilities. This work suggests that the switch of H-NS proteins between the DNA-stiffening and DNA-binding modes can be explained on the basis of simple, general arguments. According to the recent study quoted above (47), it may instead result from a more involved mechanism, where divalent cations let H-NS dimers switch between a "closed" and an "open" geometry, which have different oligomerization and DNA-binding properties (47). While it is not clear, why such a mechanism would display a threshold, it can of course not be excluded that both mechanisms cooperate to let H-NS proteins switch between the two DNA-binding modes. Last but not least, it appears that the concentration of divalent cations where the switch occurs falls within the physiological range, which may be considered as an indication that the 12 mechanism described here may play an important role in the global regulation scheme of bacterial cells. SUPPORTING MATERIAL Model and Simulations section. Figures S1 to S4. SUPPORTING CITATIONS Reference (48) appears in the Supporting Material. 13 REFERENCES 1. Luijsterburg, M. S., M. F. White, R. van Driel, and R. T. Dame. 2008. The major architects of chromatin: Architectural proteins in bacteria, archaea and eukaryotes. Crit. Rev. Biochem. Mol. Biol. 43:393-418. 2 Johnson, R. C., L. M. Johnson, J. W. Schmidt, and J. F. Gardner. 2005. Major nucleoid proteins in the structure and function of the Escherichia coli chromosome. In The bacterial Chromosome. N. P. Higgins, editor. American Society for Microbiology, Washington DC. 65-132. 3 Dame, R. T. 2005. The role of nucleoid-associated proteins in the organization and compaction of bacterial chromatin. Mol. Microbiol. 56:858-870. 4. Song, D., and J. J. Loparo. 2015. Building bridges within the bacterial chromosome. Trends in Genetics 31:164-173. 5. Dame, R. T., C. Wyman, and N. Goosen. 2000. H-NS mediated compaction of DNA visualised by atomic force microscopy. Nucleic Acids Res. 28:3504-3510. 6. Amit, R., A. B. Oppenheim, and J. Stavans. 2003. Increased bending rigidity of single DNA molecules by H-NS, a temperature and osmolarity sensor. Biophys. J. 84:2467-2473. 7. Liu Y. J., H. Chen, L. J. Kenney, and J. Yan. 2010. A divalent switch drives H- NS/DNA-binding conformations between stiffening and bridging modes. Gene Dev. 24:339- 344. 8. Zhang, C., D. Guttula, F. Liu, P. P. Malar, S. Y. Ng, L. Dai, P. S. Doyle, J. A. van Kan, and J. R. C. van der Maarel. 2013. Effect of H-NS on the elongation and compaction of single DNA molecules in a nanospace. Soft Matter 9:9593-9601. 9. van der Maarel, J. R. C., D. Guttula, V. Arluison, S. U. Egelhaaf, I. Grillo, and V. T. Forsyth. 2016. Structure of the H-NS-DNA nucleoprotein complex. Soft Matter 12:3636- 3642. 10. Lim, C. J. , S. Y. Lee, L. J. Kenney, and J. Yan. 2012. Nucleoprotein filament formation is the structural basis for bacterial protein H-NS gene silencing. Sci. Rep. 2:509. 14 11. Kotlajich, M. V., D. R. Hron, B. A. Boudreau, Z. Sun, Y. L. Lyubchenko, and R. Landick. 2015. Bridged filaments of histone-like nucleoid structuring protein pause RNA polymerase and aid termination in bacteria. eLife 4:e04970. 12. Lim, C. J., Y. R. Whang, L. J. Kenney, and J. Yan. 2012. Gene silencing H-NS paralogue StpA forms a rigid protein filament along DNA that blocks DNA accessibility. Nucleic Acids Res. 40:3316-3328. 13. Lim, C. J., S. Y. Lee, J. Teramoto, A. Ishihama, and J. Yan. 2013. The nucleoid- associated protein Dan organizes chromosomal DNA through rigid nucleoprotein filament formation in E. coli during anoxia. Nucleic Acids Res. 41:746-753. 14. Esposito, D., A. Petrovic, R. Harris, S. Ono, J. F. Eccleston, A. Mbabaali, I. Haq, C. F. Higgins, J. C. D. Hinton, P. C. Driscoll, and J. E. Ladbury. 2002. H-NS oligomerization domain structure reveals the mechanism for high-order self-association of the intact protein. J. Mol. Biol. 324:841-850. 15. Bloch, V., Y. Yang, E. Margeat, A. Chavanieu, M. T. Augé, B. Robert, S. Arold, S. Rimsky, and M. Kochoyan. 2003. The H-NS dimerization domain defines a new fold contributing to DNA recognition. Nat. Struct. Biol. 10:212-218. 16. Gordon, B. R. G., Y. Li, A. Cote, M. T. Weirauch, P. Ding, T. R. Hughes, W. W. Navarre, B. Xia, and J. Liu. 2011. Structural basis for recognition of AT-rich DNA by unrelated xenogeneic silencing proteins. P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 108:10690-10695. 17. Dorman, C. J., J. C. D. Hinton, and A. Free. 1999. Domain organization and oligomerization among H-NS-like nucleoid-associated proteins in bacteria. Trends Microbiol. 7:124-128. 18. Arold, S. T., P. G. Leonard, G. N. Parkinson, and J. E. Ladbury. 2010. H-NS forms a superhelical protein scaffold for DNA condensation. P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 107:15728- 15732. 19. Smyth, C. P., T. Lundbäck, D. Renzoni, G. Siligardi, R. Beavil, M. Layton, J. M. Sidebotham, J. C. D. Hinton, P. C. Driscoli, C. F. Higgins, and J. E. Ladbury. 2000. Oligomerization of the chromatin-structuring protein H-NS. Mol. Microbiol. 36:962-972. 15 20. Ceschini, S., G. Lupidi, M. Coletta, C. L. Pon, E. Fioretti, and M. Angeletti. 2000. Multimeric self-assembly equilibria Involving the histone-like protein H-NS: a thermodynamic study. J. Biol. Chem. 275:729-734. 21. Ono, S., M. D. Goldberg, T. Olsson, D. Esposito, J. C. D. Hinton, and J. E. Ladbury. 2005. H-NS is a part of a thermally controlled mechanism for bacterial gene regulation. Biochem. J. 391:203-213. 22. Manning, G. S. 1969. Limiting laws and counterion condensation in polyelectrolyte solutions. I. Colligative properties. J. Chem. Phys. 51:924-933. 23. Oosawa, F. 1971. Polyelectrolytes. Marcel Dekker, New York. 24. Bouffartigues, E., M. Buckle, C. Badaut, A. Travers, and S. Rimsky. 2007. H-NS cooperative binding to high-affinity sites in a regulatory element results in transcriptional silencing. Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 14:441-448. 25. Record, M. T., T. M. Lohman, and P. L. de Haseth. 1976. Ion effects on ligand-nucleic acid interactions. J. Mol. Biol. 107:145-158. 26. Record, M. T., C. F. Anderson, and T. M. Lohman. 1978. Thermodynamic analysis of ion effects on the binding and conformational equilibria of proteins and nucleic acids: the roles of ion association or release, screening, and ion effects on water activity. Q. Rev. Biophys. 111:103-178. 27. Mascotti, D., and T. M. Lohman. 1990. Thermodynamic extent of counterion release upon binding oligolysines to single-stranded nucleic acids. P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 87:3142- 3146. 28. Fenley, M. O., C. Russo, and G. S. Manning. 2011. Theoretical assessment of the oligolysine model for ionic interactions in protein-DNA complexes. J. Phys. Chem. B 115:9864-9872. 29. Breslauer, K. J., D. P. Remeta, W.-Y. Chou, R. Ferrante, J. Curry, D. Zaunczkowski, J. G. Snyder, and L. A. Marky. 1987. Enthalpy-entropy compensations in drug-DNA binding studies. P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 84:8922-8926. 16 30. Wang, S., A. Kumar, K. Aston, B. Nguyen, J. K. Bashkin, D. W. Boykin, and W. D. Wilson. 2013. Different thermodynamic signatures for DNA minor groove binding with changes in salt concentration and temperature. Chem. Commun. 49:8543-8545. 31. Record, M. T., P. L. de Haseth, and T. M. Lohman. 1977. Interpretation of monovalent and divalent cation effects on the lac repressor-operator interaction. Biochemistry 16:4791- 4796. 32. Lohman, T. M., P. L. de Haseth, and M. T. Record. 1980. Pentalysine- deoxyribonucleic acid interactions: A model for the general effects of ion concentrations on the interactions of proteins with nucleic acids. Biochemistry 19:3522-3530. 33. Mascotti, D. P., and T. M. Lohman. 1992. Thermodynamics of single-stranded RNA binding to oligolysines containing tryptophan. Biochemistry 31:8932-8946. 34. Nyquist, R. M., B.-Y. Ha, and A. J. Liu. 1999. Counterion condensation in solutions of rigid polyelectrolytes. Macromolecules 32:3481-3487. 35. Florescu, A.-M., and M. Joyeux. 2009. Description of non-specific DNA-protein interaction and facilitated diffusion with a dynamical model. J. Chem. Phys. 130:015103. 36. Florescu, A.-M., and M. Joyeux. 2009. Dynamical model of DNA protein interaction: effect of protein charge distribution and mechanical properties. J. Chem. Phys. 131:105102. 37. Florescu, A.-M., and M. Joyeux. 2010. Comparison of kinetic and dynamical models of DNA-protein interaction and facilitated diffusion. J. Phys. Chem. A 114:9662-9672. 38. Joyeux, M., and J. Vreede. 2013. A model of H-NS mediated compaction of bacterial DNA. Biophys. J. 104:1615-1622. 39. Joyeux, M. 2014. Equilibration of complexes of DNA and H-NS proteins on charged surfaces: A coarse-grained model point of view. J. Chem. Phys. 141:115102. 40. Joyeux, M. 2015. Compaction of bacterial genomic DNA: Clarifying the concepts. J. Phys.: Condens. Matter. 27:383001. 41. Joyeux, M. 2016. In vivo compaction dynamics of bacterial DNA: A fingerprint of DNA/RNA demixing ? Curr. Opin. Colloid Interface Sci. 26:17-27. 17 42. Joyeux, M. 2017. Coarse-grained model of the demixing of DNA and non-binding globular macromolecules. J. Phys. Chem. B 121:6351-6358. 43. Azam, T. A., A. Iwata, A. Nishimura, S. Ueda, and A. Ishihama. 1999. Growth phase- dependent variation in protein composition of the Escherichia coli nucleoid. J. Bacteriol. 181:6361-6370. 44. Wilson, R. W., and V. A. Bloomfield. 1979. Counterion-induced condensation of deoxyribonucleic acid. A light-scattering study. Biochemistry 18:2192-2196. 45. Gordon, B. R. G., Y. Li, A. Cote, M. T. Weirauch, P. Ding, T. R. Hughes, W. W. Navarre, B. Xia, and J. Liu. 2011. Structural basis for recognition of AT-rich DNA by unrelated xenogeneic silencing proteins. P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 108:10690-10695. 46. Stracy, M., C. Lesterlin, F. G. de Leon, S. Uphoff, P. Zawadski, and A. N. Kapanidis. 2015. Live-cell superresolution microscopy reveals the organization of RNA polymerase in the bacterial nucleoid. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 112:E4390-E4399. 47. van der Valk, R. A., J. Vreede, L. Qin, G. F. Moolenaar, A. Hofmann, N. Goosen, and R. T. Dame. 2017. Mechanism of environmentally driven conformational changes that modulate H-NS DNA-bridging activity. eLife 6:27369. 48. Jian, H., A. Vologodskii, and T. Schlick. 1997. A combined wormlike-chain and bead model for dynamic simulations of long linear DNA. J. Comp. Phys. 136:168-179 18 FIGURE CAPTIONS Figure 1 : Plot, as a function of the effective valency Z of the cations of the buffer, of the minimum of the potential energy felt by a linear protein chain approaching the linear DNA chain perpendicularly (solid red curve) and of the energy of the saddle separating two minima (dashed blue curve). The potential energy surface itself is shown in Fig. S2 of the Supporting Material for Z = Z crit = 37.1 . The dot-dashed green horizontal line represents the minimum of the potential energy felt by a linear protein chain approaching another linear protein chain perpendicularly. The potential energy surface itself is shown in Fig. S1 of the Supporting Material. The solid and dot-dashed lines intersect at Z = Z crit = 37.1 . Figure 2 : Representative snapshots of the system with 200 proteins chains for Z=1.33 (top), 1.42 (middle) and 1.50 (bottom). The blue line connects the centers of successive DNA beads. Red (respectively, green) spheres represent terminal (respectively, central) beads of protein chains. The confining sphere is not shown. Figure 3 : Probability distribution )(sp for a protein chain to be bound to s DNA beads (left column) and probability distribution ( )q s for a protein chain to be bound to s other protein chains (right column), for values of Z increasing from 1.00 to 1.67. Note that binding of a protein chain to the DNA chain usually involves two successive DNA beads. Each plot was obtained from a single equilibrated simulation with 200 protein chains by averaging over a time interval of 0.1 ms. Figure 4 : Decimal logarithm of ( )u s , the probability distribution for a protein chain to belong to a cluster containing s protein chains, for values of Z increasing from 1.00 to 1.67. Each plot was obtained from a single equilibrated simulation with 200 protein chains by averaging over a time interval of 0.1 ms. Figure 5 : Representative snapshots of the system with 1000 proteins chains for Z=1.17. The blue line connects the centers of successive DNA beads. Red (respectively, green) spheres represent terminal (respectively, central) beads of protein chains. The confining sphere is not shown. 19 Figure 6 : Plot, as a function of Z, of the average number of connections between pairs of DNA beads mediated by protein chains, for 200 protein chains. Only pairs of beads separated along the chain by 50 (or more) other DNA beads are taken into account. 20 Figure 1 21 Figure 2 22 Figure 3 23 Figure 4 24 Figure 5 25 Figure 6 26 Role of salt valency in the switch of H-NS proteins between DNA-bridging and DNA-stiffening modes M. Joyeux LIPhy, CNRS and Université Grenoble Alpes, Grenoble, France MODEL AND SIMULATIONS Temperature T is assumed to be 298 K throughout the study. The model for the DNA molecule consists of a circular chain of =n 2880 beads with radius 0.1=a nm separated at equilibrium by a distance =l 0 5.2 nm and enclosed in a sphere with radius =R 0 120 nm. Two beads represent 15 DNA base pairs. The contour length of the DNA molecule and the cell volume correspond approximately to 1/200th of the values for E. coli cells, so that the nucleic acid concentration of the model is close to the physiological one. The potential energy of the DNA chain consists of 4 terms, namely, the stretching energy sV , the bending energy bV , the electrostatic repulsion eV , and a confinement term wallV = E DNA + VV b s + V e + V wall . The stretching and bending contributions write n ∑ ( l k 2 l 0 ) = V s = V b h 2 g 2 k = 1 n ∑ = 1 k q 2 k , (S1) (S2) where kr denotes the position of DNA bead k, kl = r k r k 1+ the distance between two successive beads, and q k = r arccos(( k r k + 1 r )( k + 1 r k + 2 /() r k r k + 1 r k + 1 r k + 2 )) the angle formed by three successive beads. The stretching energy sV is a computational device without biological meaning, which is aimed at avoiding a rigid rod description. The stretching force constant h is set to h = 100 / lTk B 2 0 , which insures that the variations of the distance between successive beads remain small enough (1). In contrast, the bending rigidity constant is 27 - - - - - - obtained from the known persistence length of the DNA, 50=x nm, according to = x g / lTk B 0 = 20 Tk B . Electrostatic repulsion between DNA beads that are not close neighbours along the chain is written as a sum of repulsive Debye-Hückel terms with hard core = ( V e e DNA Z 2 ) n n 4 ∑ ∑ = 1 k += kK ( r kH 4 r K ) , where )( rH = 1 pe 4   exp  r r a 2 Dr    . (S3) (S4) Interactions between close neighbours ( 1 Kk 3 ) are not included in Eq. (S3) because it is considered that they are already accounted for in the stretching and bending terms. e = denotes the dielectric constant of the buffer. The value of the Debye length Dr is set 80 e 0 to 3.07 nm, which corresponds to a concentration of monovalent salt of 0.01 M. DNAe is the electric charge, which is placed at the centre of each DNA bead when considering that the buffer contains only monovalent cations ( 1=Z ). The numerical value -= e DNA .3 525 e , where e is the absolute charge of the electron, is the product of 0l and the net linear charge density derived from Manning's counterion condensation theory ( e / ℓ B 41.1 e nm/ , see the main text). The charge placed at the center of each bead reduces to e DNA / Z when considering that the buffer contains cations of effective valency 1>Z . Finally, the confinement term wallV is taken as a sum of repulsive terms = V wall 10 Tk B n ∑ = 1 k f ( r k ) , where f is the function defined according to if 0Rr £ : )( =rf 0 if 0Rr > : )( rf =   r R 0 6  -  1 . (S5) (S6) H-NS dimers are modeled as chains of 4 beads with radius a separated at equilibrium by a distance =L 0 0.4 nm. For each protein chain j, charges e j = = e j 1 4 -== e j 3 3 e are placed at the 3 e at the centre of centre of terminal beads central beads 2=m and and 4=m , and charges e j 2 1=m 3=m . The values of these effective charges were obtained from a naive counting of the number of positively and negatively charged residues in published 28 - - - - £ - £ - » - crystallographic structures (2). It is considered that the density of charges along the naked protein chain is small enough for counterion condensation not to take place in the range £ Z the DNA chain or to the central beads of other protein chains, so that the model accounts for . Moreover, the terminal beads of each protein chain can bind either to the beads of 2 1 both H-NS oligomerization and binding of H-NS to the DNA chain. In most simulations, =P which corresponds to a protein concentration approximately twice the concentration of H-NS protein chains were introduced in the confining sphere together with the DNA chain, 200 dimers during the cell growth phase and six times the concentration during the stationary phase (3). The potential energy of the protein chains consists of 4 terms E P = V )P( s + )P( V b + )P/P( V e + V (P) wall , (S7) where the stretching, bending, and confining energies are very similar to their DNA counterparts 2 jm (S8) h 2 G 2 P 3 ∑∑ = 1 j m = 1 = P m 2 ∑∑ = 1 j = 1 m = = = )P( V s )P( V b V (P) wall ( L jm 2 L 0 ) 10 Tk B P 4 ∑∑ = 1 j = 1 m f ( R jm ,) with jmR the position of bead m of protein chain j, jmL the distance between beads m and m+1 of protein chain j, and jm the angle formed by beads m, m+1, and m+2 of protein chain j. The value of the bending constant is assumed to be as low as G B2= Tk , in order to account for the flexible linker that connects the C-terminal and N-terminal domains of H-NS. The interaction energy between protein chains, )P/P( eV , is taken as the sum of (attractive or repulsive) Debye-Hückel terms with hard core and (repulsive) excluded volume terms, with the latter ones contributing only if the corresponding Debye-Hückel term is attractive )P/P( V e = P ∑ = 1 j Hee j 4 1 j ( R j 1 R j 4 + ) 4 P 1 4 P ∑∑ ∑ ∑ = 1 j = 1 m += 1 j J = 1 M P + c ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ P F 3,2 = 1 j m = 4,1 = = 1 J M J j ( R jm R JM ,) Hee jm JM ( R jm R JM ) where F is the function defined according to r £ if 0r : )( rF = r 0 r 2 a 2 a ( r 0 r 2 a 2 a + 1)2 29 (S9) (S10) £ Q - Q „ - - - - - - - - - if r > : 0r )( =rF 0 , and 0r denotes the threshold distance below which the excluded volume term, taken as the repulsive part of a 2h order Lennard-Jones-like function with hard core, creates a repulsion force between oppositely charged beads. The first term in the right-hand side of Eq. (S9) insures that the two terminal beads of the same chain do not overlap. The numerical values of the two parameters of the excluded volume potential, TkB1=c and =r 0 5.3 nm, were adjusted manually in order that the enthalpy change upon forming a complex between two protein chains is comparable to the experimentally determined value for H-NS. As shown in Fig. S1, this enthalpy change is equal to TkB0.12 for two protein chains at equilibrium approaching one another perpendicularly, which is close to the experimentally determined value for H-NS ( TkB2.10 (4)). Finally, the potential energy describing the interactions between the DNA chain and the protein chains, E DNA/P , is similarly taken as the sum of (attractive or repulsive) Debye- Hückel terms with hard core and (repulsive) excluded volume terms, with the latter ones contributing only if the corresponding Debye-Hückel term is attractive E DNA/P = e DNA Z 4 n P ∑∑∑ = 1 k = 1 j = 1 m He jm ( Rr k jm ) + c n P ∑∑ ∑ = 1 k = 1 j m = 4,1 F ( Rr k jm .) (S11) It is emphasized that the attraction term between DNA beads and terminal protein beads scales as Z/1 in Eq. (S11), while the attraction term between terminal beads of a protein chain and central beads of another protein chain does not depend on Z in Eq. (S9). This is a key point of the model, see the main text. The potential energy felt by protein chains at equilibrium approaching perpendicularly the linear DNA chain at equilibrium is shown in Fig. S2 for an effective valency of the cations 37.1=Z . For this particular value of Z, the enthalpy change upon binding of a protein chain to the DNA chain is TkB0.12 , which is equal to the enthalpy change upon binding of a protein chain to another protein chain, and comparable to experimentally determined values ( TkB0.11 (5)). In contrast, as illustrated in Fig. 1 of the main text, binding of protein chains to the DNA chain is favored for 37.1<Z , while binding to other protein chains is favored for 37.1>Z . It may also be noted in this figure that the evolution of the enthalpy change upon binding of H-NS to DNA deviates slightly from an Z/1 law, which results from the fact that the excluded volume term is assumed to be independent of Z in Eq. (S11). 30 - - » - - - - » The total potential energy of the system, potE , is the sum of the energies of DNA and protein chains and DNA/protein interactions E pot = E DNA + E P + E . DNA/P (S12) The dynamics of the model was investigated by integrating numerically the Langevin equations of motion with kinetic energy terms neglected. Practically, the updated position vector for each bead (whether DNA or protein), ( +n )1 jr , is computed from the current position vector, )(n jr , according to n =+ )1 r ( j r )( n j + tD t Tk B + F )( n j 2 tD t x )( n , (S13) where the translational diffusion coefficient tD is equal to ( TkB ph 6/() a ) and .0=h 00089 Pa s is the viscosity of the buffer at arising from the potential energy potE , =T )(nx 298 K. )(n jF is the vector of inter-particle forces a vector of random numbers extracted at each step n from a Gaussian distribution of mean 0 and variance 1, and which is set to 1.0 ps for =P 200 protein chains and 0.5 ps for the integration time step, t =P chains. After each 1000 integration step, the position of the center of the confining sphere was slightly adjusted so as to coincide with the center of mass of the DNA molecule. 31 D D D SUPPORTING REFERENCES 1. Jian, H., A. Vologodskii, and T. Schlick. 1997. A combined wormlike-chain and bead model for dynamic simulations of long linear DNA. J. Comp. Phys. 136:168-179 2. Arold, S. T., P. G. Leonard, G. N. Parkinson, and J. E. Ladbury. 2010. H-NS forms a superhelical protein scaffold for DNA condensation. P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 107:15728- 15732. 3. Azam, T. A., A. Iwata, A. Nishimura, S. Ueda, and A. Ishihama. 1999. Growth phase- dependent variation in protein composition of the Escherichia coli nucleoid. J. Bacteriol. 181:6361-6370. 4. Ceschini, S., G. Lupidi, M. Coletta, C. L. Pon, E. Fioretti, and M. Angeletti. 2000. Multimeric self-assembly equilibria involving the histone-like protein H-NS. A thermodynamic study. J. Biol. Chem. 275:729-734. 5. Ono, S., M. D. Goldberg, T. Olsson, D. Esposito, J. C. D. Hinton, and J. E. Ladbury. 2005. H-NS is a part of a thermally controlled mechanism for bacterial gene regulation. Biochem. J. 391:203-213. 32 Figure S1 : Potential energy felt by a protein chain aligned along the y axis when approaching another protein chain elongated along the x axis and centered on (0,0). Both chains are at equilibrium with respect to their stretching and bending degrees of freedom. The black disks represent two beads of the protein chain elongated along the x axis. In this geometry, the potential is symmetric with respect to the y axis, in addition to having rotational symmetry along the x axis. (x,y) denote the coordinates of the center of the terminal bead of the vertical chain that lies closest to the horizontal chain. The minimum of the potential energy surface ( ) is located on the y axis. Contour lines are separated by TkB0.12 TkB2 . 33 - Figure S2 : Potential energy felt by a protein chain aligned along the y axis when approaching an infinite DNA chain elongated along the x axis, for an effective valency Z=1.37. Both chains are at equilibrium with respect to their stretching and bending degrees of freedom. The black disks represent DNA beads. In this geometry the potential has rotational symmetry along the x axis. (x,y) denote the coordinates of the center of the terminal bead of the vertical protein chain that lies closest to the horizontal DNA chain. The minima of the potential ) are located at equal distances from two successive DNA beads. energy surface ( Contour lines are separated by TkB0.12 TkB2 . 34 - Figure S3 : Decimal logarithm of ( )v s , the probability distribution for a protein cluster to contain s protein chains, for values of Z increasing from 1.00 to 1.67. Each plot was obtained from a single equilibrated simulation with 200 protein chains by averaging over a time interval of 0.1 ms. 35 Figure S4 : Plot, as a function of Z, of the fraction of the DNA chain covered by protein chains, for 200 protein chains. A bead k of the DNA chain is considered to be "covered" by a protein chain if it is bound to a protein chain or surrounded, in the range [ , by two beads that are bound to protein chains belonging to the same cluster. ] 5 k + k 5, 36 -
1304.3789	1	1304	2013-04-13T08:23:41	Detection of atomic spin labels in a lipid bi-layer using a single-spin nanodiamond probe	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.mes-hall" ]	Magnetic field fluctuations arising from fundamental spins are ubiquitous in nanoscale biology, and are a rich source of information about the processes that generate them. However, the ability to detect the few spins involved without averaging over large ensembles has remained elusive. Here we demonstrate the detection of gadolinium spin labels in an artificial cell membrane under ambient conditions using a single-spin nanodiamond sensor. Changes in the spin relaxation time of the sensor located in the lipid bilayer were optically detected and found to be sensitive to near-individual proximal gadolinium atomic labels. The detection of such small numbers of spins in a model biological setting, with projected detection times of one second, opens a new pathway for in-situ nanoscale detection of dynamical processes in biology.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Detection of atomic spin labels in a lipid bi-layer using a single-spin nanodiamond probe Stefan Kaufmann1,2, David A. Simpson1,3, Liam T. Hall1, Viktor Perunicic1, Philipp Senn4,5, Steffen Steinert6, Liam P. McGuinness1, Brett C. Johnson7, Takeshi Ohshima7, Frank Caruso4, Jörg Wrachtrup6, Robert E. Scholten8, Paul Mulvaney2, Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg1,3+ 1 Centre for Quantum Computation and Communication Technology, School of Physics, University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia. 2 School of Chemistry and Bio21 Institute, University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia. 3 Centre for Neural Engineering, University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia. 4 Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, University of Melbourne, Victoria 3010, Australia. 5 Bionics Institute, Victoria 3065, Australia. 6 3. Physikalisches Institut, Research Center SCOPE, and MPI for Solid State Research, University of Stuttgart, Pfaffenwaldring 57, 70569 Stuttgart, Germany. 7 Semiconductor Analysis and Radiation Effects Group, Japan Atomic Energy Agency, Takasaki, Japan. 8 Centre for Coherent X-Ray Science, School of Physics, University of Melbourne, Victoria *These authors contributed equally to this work. 3010, Australia +Corresponding author: Lloyd Hollenberg - School of Physics, University of Melbourne, Victoria, 3010, Australia. Tel: +61 3 8344 4210, Email: [email protected] Classification: PHYSICAL SCIENCES: Applied Physical Sciences 1 Key words: nanomagnetometry, diamond, nitrogen-vacancy centre, biophysics, lipid bilayers Abstract Magnetic field fluctuations arising from fundamental spins are ubiquitous in nanoscale biology, and are a rich source of information about the processes that generate them. However, the ability to detect the few spins involved without averaging over large ensembles has remained elusive. Here we demonstrate the detection of gadolinium spin labels in an artificial cell membrane under ambient conditions using a single-spin nanodiamond sensor. Changes in the spin relaxation time of the sensor located in the lipid bilayer were optically detected and found to be sensitive to near- individual (4 ± 2) proximal gadolinium atomic labels. The detection of such small numbers of spins in a model biological setting, with projected detection times of one second, opens a new pathway for in-situ nanoscale detection of dynamical processes in biology. The development of sensitive and highly localized probes has driven advances in our understanding of the basic processes of life at increasingly smaller scales (1). In the last decade there has been a strong drive to expand the range of probes that can be used for studying biological systems (2-6), with emphasis on the detection of atoms and molecules in nanometer sized volumes in order to gain access to information that may be hidden in ensemble averaging. However, at present there are no nanoprobes suitable for directly sensing the weak magnetic fields arising from small numbers of fundamental spins in nanoscale biology, occurring naturally (e.g. free-radicals) or introduced (e.g. spin-labels), which can be a rich source of information about processes at the atomic and molecular level. Magnetic resonance techniques such as electron spin resonance (ESR) have played an important role in the development of our 2 understanding of membranes, proteins and free radicals (7); however, ESR sensitivity and resolution are fundamentally limited to mesoscopic ensembles of at least 107 spins with a sensitivity of ~ 2 × 109 spins/(Hz)1/2 (8). In a typical ESR application small electron spin label moieties are attached to the system of interest and their environment is investigated through spin measurements on the labels. Because of the large ensemble required nanoscopic detail at the few spin level can be lost in the averaging process. Recently, magnetic resonance force microscopy techniques have demonstrated single spin detection (9-11), but these require cryogenic temperatures and vacuum. Here we demonstrate a nanoparticle probe – a nitrogen-vacancy spin in a nanodiamond – which is situated in the target structure itself and acts as a nanoscopic magnetic field detector under ambient conditions with non-contact optical readout. We employ this probe to detect near-individual spin labels in an artificial cell membrane at a projected sensitivity of ~ 5 spins/(Hz)1/2, effectively bridging the gap between traditional ESR ensemble based techniques and the ultimate goal of few-spin nanoscale detection under biological conditions. Results and discussion The overall set-up of our experiment is shown schematically in Figure 1A. The nanoparticle probe is the single spin of a nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centre contained in a nanodiamond particle (Figure 1B). NV-nanodiamonds are attractive nanoprobes for biology as they exhibit low toxicity and are photostable (12-14). Here we investigate the magnetic field sensing capabilities of the NV centre in a biological context. Around these NV-nanodiamonds we formed a supported lipid bilayer (SLB) on a glass substrate. The SLB was created with lipids labeled with Gd3+, a common MRI contrast agent with spin 7/2 (Figure 1C) which produce characteristic magnetic 3 fluctuations in the lipid environment (Figure 1D) and form our detection target. The ground state of the NV centre has a zero-field splitting of D = 2.87 GHz between the 0〉 and ±1〉 spin levels and optical-based spin state readout is possible due to the significantly lower fluorescence of the ±1〉 compared to the 0〉 state (15) (Figure 1E). These properties have led to demonstrations of DC and AC magnetic field detection using single NV spins (16-18), and wide-field detection schemes employing ensembles of NV centres (19-22). For biological applications, where atomic level processes produce magnetic field fluctuations, it has been proposed that changes in the quantum decoherence of the NV spin could provide a more sensitive detection mechanism (23- 25). Ensemble relaxation based imaging has been demonstrated with sub-cellular resolution and detection of ~103 spins (26). Towards the goal of using single NV spins as in situ nano- magnetometer probes in biology, quantum measurements on single NV spins have been carried out in a living cell (27), and with the recent detection of external spins in well controlled environments (28-30), the critical milestone is to demonstrate nanoscopic external spin detection in a biological context. Here we achieve this with near individual spin sensitivity by monitoring the relaxation time (T1) of a single NV spin probe (Figure 1E, F) embedded in the SLB target itself. In addition, our results indicate that the NV spin is sensitive to cross-lipid magnetic fluctuations arising from the small number of Gd labeled lipids in the SLB in the vicinity of the nanodiamond (Figure 1A, D). 4 Figure 1: Schematic of nanoscopic detection of spin labels in an artificial cell membrane using a single-spin nanodiamond sensor. A. A supported lipid bilayer (SLB) is formed around a nanodiamond immobilized on a glass substrate. B. The nanodiamond contains a single nitrogen-vacancy (NV) optical centre which acts as a single spin sensor by virtue of the magnetic levels in the ground state. C. Gadolinium (Gd) spin labeled lipids are introduced into the SLB. D. Magnetic field fluctuations arising from Gd spin labels affect the quantum state of the NV spin, measured through the NV relaxation time, T1. E. The electronic energy structure of the NV centre showing the fluorescent cycle and optical spin readout of the spin states 0〉 and ±1〉, and the protocol for the T1 measurement. F. A schematic illustration of the T1 measurement. The relaxation of the NV spin in the target environment is compared to that in the reference environment. Measurement at a single time point in the evolution allows faster detection. The SLB was formed on the nanodiamond-glass substrate in tris-buffered saline (TBS) solution via the vesicle fusion technique (31) (Figure 2A), and characterized by both fluorescence recovery after photo-bleaching (FRAP) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) (Figure 2B, and Supplementary Information). AFM investigations showed that the SLB formed mainly around the nanodiamond particles (mean size = 15.9 ± 9.5 nm). The T1 time of the NV spin was 5 measured by optically polarizing into the 0〉 state and measuring the probability P0(t) of finding the NV in the initial 0〉 state at a later time t through spin state fluorescence contrast. In a low background field the ±1〉 spin states of the NV are approximately degenerate so the P0(t) decays as: tP )( 0 = 1)(3/1( + exp( Tt / − 1 ) + exp( Tt /2 − 1 )) . (1) This form is a consequence of the 3-state nature of the NV spin manifold and the broad spectrum of the target spin bath (see Supplementary Information for the derivation). Figure 3A (green dashed curve) shows P0(t) (normalised fluorescence) for a single NV centre (NV1) under the TBS control conditions. Fitting to Equation (1) we obtain a reference relaxation time T1[TBS] = 117±11 µs. T1[TBS] includes intrinsic nanodiamond sources of relaxation such as N donors (electron spin bath), and 13C spins (nuclear spin bath), but is dominated by surface electronic spins fluctuating in the GHz regime. After the formation of a SLB without Gd spin labels (under the same TBS conditions), the measurement was repeated on the same NV (green data points) to give T1[SLB] = 139±18 µs, showing no statistically significant change for the unlabeled lipid case. Removal of the SLB, which included a 2 min oxygen plasma etching step, was followed by a new TBS reference T1 measurement (blue dashed curve). Upon formation of the SLB with Gd spin labeled lipids at 10% (w/w) concentration (blue data points), we observed a 61% reduction in the NV relaxation time to T1[SLB:Gd] = 48±3 µs. 6 Figure 2: Formation and characterisation of a supported lipid layers (SLB) on nanodiamond/glass substrates. A. SLBs were formed by the vesicle fusion technique and characterized by fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP). B. Confocal images of FRAP measurements directly after the bleaching cycle for a SLB+10% (w/w) of the Gd spin label and 1% (w/w) of a fluorescent label. For characterisation, three different substrate conditions were investigated. Confocal and atomic force microscopy images show nanodiamond density and size distribution. To demonstrate the consistency of the effect, this sequence was performed for five NV centres (NV1-NV5), in distinct nanodiamonds. Figure 3B shows the percentage changes in the T1 times for all five NV centres relative to their TBS reference values. For the SLB with no spin labels there is no statistically significant change verifying that the NV T1 relaxation time remains intact under control conditions. For the SLB labeled with 10% Gd the average reduction in the NV T1 relaxation time from the reference value is 74 ± 6 %, and is remarkably consistent across the set 7 of nanodiamonds. We next investigated the Gd concentration dependence of the change in the T1 relaxation time. In Figure 3C the T1 curves of a single NV centre (NV6) are given for 10% and 1% Gd concentrations, showing the change in T1 decreasing as the number of proximate Gd spins is reduced. The percentage changes in T1 from the respective TBS reference values as a function of Gd concentration are given in Figure 3D for another set of four individual NV centres (NV6-NV9) confirming this trend. 0% Gd-SLB 10% Gd-SLB 0% Gd-SLB fit 10% Gd-SLB fit TBS (ref) TBS (ref) NV1 B ) % ( 1 T ∆ 75 50 25 0 -25 -50 -75 -100 0% Gd-SLB 10% Gd-SLB 400 500 NV1 NV2 NV3 NV4 NV5 A 1 ) u . a ( e c n e c s e r o u l F 0.95 0.9 0.85 0.8 0.75 C 1 ) u . a ( e c n e c s e r o u l F 0.95 0.9 0.85 0.8 0.75 0 100 200 300 Time (µs) 10% Gd-SLB 1% Gd-SLB 10% Gd-SLB fit 1% Gd-SLB fit TBS (ref) TBS (ref) NV6 1% Gd-SLB 10% Gd-SLB D ) % ( 1 T ∆ 50 25 0 -25 -50 -75 -100 -125 0 100 200 300 Time (µs) 400 500 NV6 NV7 NV8 NV9 Figure 3: Detection of spin labeled lipids in a supported lipid bilayer (SLB) using the T1 time of single NV spins in nanodiamonds. A. Relaxation of the spin of a single NV centre (NV1) in a nanodiamond in a SLB without spin labels (green) and in a SLB with 10% (w/w) Gd spin labels (blue). B. The percentage change in T1 (relative to TBS) of five single NV spins (NV1-NV5) in distinct nanodiamonds: SLB+0% Gd (green) and SLB+10% Gd (blue). C. Relaxation of the spin of NV6 for SLB+ 10% Gd (blue) and SLB+1% Gd (orange). D. Concentration dependence of 8 the percentage change in T1 for a set of centres, NV6-NV9. The data in B and C, after fitting to determine the relaxation times, have been scaled to the same asymptotic value for ease of presentation. All error bars represent the fitting uncertainties at the 95% confidence interval. Solid curves are the corresponding fits of the data to Equation (1) which determine T1. Dashed curves correspond to the fitted data of the corresponding reference TBS measurement prior to each SLB measurement. In order to understand these results quantitatively we consider the quantum evolution of the NV spin in the presence of magnetic field fluctuations arising from the various atomic processes involving the Gd spins in the SLB (see Supplementary Information). The characteristic timescales of these fluctuations produce specific changes in the measured T1 relaxation time of the NV spin from the reference value. In terms of external sources of decoherence, the quantum evolution of the NV spin is determined by the overall spectral distribution function, efS (ω ) , which is governed by the characteristic environmental magnetic field fluctuation frequency, fe. The Gd-labeled lipid environment produces magnetic field fluctuations due to cross-lipid Gd-Gd spin dipole interactions, motional diffusion of individual Gd-labeled lipids, and intrinsic Gd spin relaxation effects, each with characteristic frequencies dipf , diff , and inf respectively that contribute to fe. From efS (ω ) we obtain the NV relaxation time T1[Gd] due to Gd-lipid effects: T 1 ]Gd[ = ( f 2 e + ( D − 2 D Gd 2 2/)) 2 Bf e eff , where B eff = 63 ( γγµπσ 0 NV Gd /) h 128 2 is the characteristic Gd-NV dipolar magnetic field interaction, h is the NV depth below the nanodiamond surface, σ is the areal Gd spin density, and DGd is the zero field splitting parameter of the Gd spin, with the dominant contribution to T1 coming from the 2DGd transition. We note that the 4DGd and 6DGd transitions are too far detuned from D to have any significant effect on T1. We obtain dipf by integrating the Gd-Gd dipolar auto-correlation function over a planar SLB distribution to give f dip = 2 63 ( ) πσγµ  Gd 0 2/3 32/ π . For the diffusion of Gd-lipids in the SLB we 9 obtain f diff = 9 D l 16/ h 2 where Dl is the Gd-lipid diffusion constant. The intrinsic Gd spin relaxation is characterized by in ≈f GHz 1 (32). For the NV depths expected in these 16 nm nanodiamonds and Gd concentrations employed here, the effect of Gd-Gd interactions on the NV relaxation time dominate over Gd diffusion effects. Expanding around the low Gd density limit we arrive at a theoretical model for the NV relaxation time T1[Gd], due to proximate Gd labeled lipids: T 1 ]Gd[ = 4 h w 2/3 ( aw + b ) , (2) where w is the %w/w Gd-lipid concentration, and a and b are constants involving the physical parameters D, DGd and fin (see Supplementary Information). Because the nanodiamond surface spins comprise a two-dimensional distribution we also obtain T1[TBS] ∝ h4. Hence there is a cancelation of the depth dependence in the percentage change in relaxation times, ∆T1[SLB:Gd]/T1[TBS], which may explain the uniformity of the effect across the set of NV- nanodiamonds shown in Figure 3B. To directly compare our data with Equation (2) we extract T1[Gd] by subtracting the reference rate (i.e. Γ1[Gd] = Γ1[SLB:Gd] – Γ1[TBS]) and in Figure 4 plot this quantity for all NV1-NV9 against Gd concentration, w. Generally, the data points lie in a NV depth range consistent with the measured AFM nanodiamond size distribution indicating that we observe T1[Gd] times in broad agreement with those predicted by Equation (2). The trend to shallower NV depths as we move from 10% → 1% Gd-lipid concentration is consistent with the etching step in the processing of the sample between the 10% and 1% measurements which is likely to have removed several nm of material from the nanodiamonds. However, we note that for low 10 concentrations we also expect some deviation to the scaling in Equation (2) due to the statistics of low Gd spin numbers. 1E+06 106 ) 1E+05 105 s µ ( ] 1E+04 104 d G [ 1 1E+03 103 T , e m 1E+02 102 i t n o 1E+01 101 i t a x a 1E+00 100 l e r V 1E-01 10-1 N 10-2 1E-02 0.5 NV1 NV3 NV5 NV7 NV9 NV2 NV4 NV6 NV8 13nm h= 18nm h= 13nm h= 8nm h= 5nm h= 3nm 50 5 Gd lipid-label concentration (w%) Figure 4: The NV relaxation time due to the presence of Gd spin labeled lipids, T1[Gd], as a function of Gd lipid concentration (%w/w) for all measured centres, NV1-NV9 (data points). Theoretical curves (dashed) based on Equation (2) are given for a range of NV depths, h, with a lower bound h = 2nm corresponding to the photostability limit (33). The effective number of spins detected, Neff, for a given Gd concentration w is estimated by comparing the RMS field expectation 〈B2〉1/2 at the NV contributing to the change in relaxation time integrated over all Gd spins in the membrane, to that of a single Gd spin at distance h, to obtain N eff 2 πσ (see Supplementary Information). Using the NV depth range h ≈ 8 ± 5 h )8/3(~ nm from the AFM distribution we arrive at a lower bound estimate of the effective number of spins detected of 4 ± 2 (1% Gd) and 28 ± 24 (10% Gd). Finally, from the data we can determine projected single time-point detection times assuming the reference TBS value has been well 11 characterised and the measured fluorescence contrast is normalised. For the case of NV7, which had a relatively fast value of T1[TBS], to detect the fluorescence change at the 95% CL corresponding to 1% Gd-SLB at a single time point requires a total measurement time of ~1.3s (see Supplementary Information). In conclusion, we have demonstrated nanoscopic magnetic detection of spin labels in an artificial cell membrane using the T1 relaxation time of a single spin NV-nanodiamond probe. Our results for Gd-labeled lipid concentrations down to 1% w/w correspond to the detection of near- individual Gd spin labels, with projected single time point detection times of order 1s. The data are in broad agreement with cross-lipid Gd-Gd spin interactions as the dominant atomic process detected. These results highlight the potential of the NV-nanodiamond system as a nanoscopic magnetic probe in biology which circumvents the fundamental problems associated with ensemble averaging. Materials and Methods Nanodiamond preparation Nanodiamond were purchased from VanMoppes, Switzerland (SYP 0 - 0.03) and irradiated with high-energy electrons (2 MeV with a fluence of 1×1018 electrons/cm2) and vacuum annealed at 800 oC for 2 hours at the Japan Atomic Energy Agency. The powder was heated to 425 oC in air for 3 hours, dispersed in water and sonicated with a high-power sonicator (Sonicator 4000, Qsonica2) for 30 hours. The suspension was centrifuged at 12000 rcf for 120 s and the supernatant was removed and used as stock suspension. For the adsorption of nanodiamonds, 12 cleaned glass substrates (No. 1, Menzel) were immersed in a 1 mg/ml solution of polyallylamine hydrochloride (PAH, 70kDa) in 0.5 M NaCl in Milli-Q water for 5 minutes. After rinsing with Milli-Q water nanodiamonds were adsorbed in the desired concentration in Milli-Q water for 5 minutes. The glass substrates were treated in a 40 W oxygen plasma (25% oxygen in argon, 40 sccm flow rate) for 5 minutes to remove the polyelectrolyte from the substrate. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) in air was performed with an Asylum MFP-3D in tapping mode with cantilevers from Olympus (AC160TS, 42 N/m). Formation of supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) All chemicals are of analytical grade reagent quality if not otherwise stated. The lipids (Avanti Polar Lipids Inc., USA) 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC), 1- palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-L-serine (sodium salt) (POPS) and 1-palmitoyl-2-12- [(7-nitro-2-1,3-benzoxadiazol-4-yl)amino]dodecanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (NBD-PC) were dissolved in chloroform and the spin label 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3- phosphoethanolamine-N-diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid (gadolinium salt) (DMPE- DTPA(Gd)) was dissolved in the mixture chloroform:methanol:water (65:35:8) (v:v). The lipids were mixed in the desired ratios and were dried under a stream of nitrogen for 1 hour followed by re-suspension in TBS buffer. TBS buffer was prepared by mixing 10 mM Tris(hydroxymethyl)-aminomethane (Sigma-Aldrich Pty. Ltd., Australia) and 150 mM sodium chloride (Sigma-Aldrich Pty. Ltd., Australia) in water with the pH adjusted to 7.4 by stepwise addition of 1 M hydrochloric acid. Milli-Q water (18.2 MΩ and at most 4 ppm (TOC), Millipore, USA) was used throughout. The buffer was filtered through 0.2 µm filters (PALL Acrodisc Syringe Filter) before use. Supported lipid bilayers (SLB) were formed with vesicles extruded 31 13 times through two stacked, 100 nm pore-size polycarbonate membranes (Avanti Polar Lipids Inc., USA) at a concentration of 0.1 mg/ml with an exposure time of 1 hour (overnight exposure for quantum measurements in liquid cell). The vesicle size was measured by dynamic light scattering resulting in an average size of 113 ± 3 nm (s.d). Before the formation of SLBs, 3 mM Ca +2 (CaCl 2 , Chem-Supply Pty Ltd, Australia) was added to the buffer solution. This improved the adhesion onto the negatively charged, glass surface (34). After the measurements the liquid cell was cleaned with 2% (v/w) of sodium dodecyl sulfate in water and isopropyl alcohol and thoroughly rinsed with water. Before quantum measurements the coverslip was treated in a 40 W oxygen plasma (25% oxygen in argon, 40 sccm flow rate) for 2 minutes. T1 measurements Confocal imaging was performed on a home-built microscope using an oil-immersion objective (100x, Nikon). T1 measurements were performed using a Spincore PulseBlaster card and a Fast ComTech P7889 Multiple-Event Time Digitizer card. Typical measurement time for a full evolution of a T1 curve was 1 hour. Spin relaxation curves were fitted using Equation (1) in the main manuscript. Acknowledgements This work was supported by the Australian Research Council under the Centre of Excellence (CE110001027) scheme, the Centre for Neural Engineering, ERC Project SQUTEC, EU Project DINAMO, and the Baden-Wuerttemberg Foundation. SK was supported by a Swiss National Science Foundation fellowship PBEZP3-133244. FC is supported by the ARC Australian Laureate Fellowship scheme (FL120100030). 14 References 1. 15. 16. 18. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 2. 3. Michalet X, et al. (2005) Quantum Dots for Live Cells, in Vivo Imaging, and Diagnostics. Science 307(5709):538-544. Ament I, Prasad J, Henkel A, Schmachtel S, & Sönnichsen C (2012) Single Unlabeled Protein Detection on Individual Plasmonic Nanoparticles. Nano Lett. 12(2):1092-1095. Sorgenfrei S, et al. (2011) Label-free single-molecule detection of DNA-hybridization kinetics with a carbon nanotube field-effect transistor. Nat. Nanotech. 6(2):126-132. Heller D A, et al. (2009) Multimodal optical sensing and analyte specificity using single- walled carbon nanotubes. Nat. Nanotech. 4(2):114. Li J F, et al. (2010) Shell-isolated nanoparticle-enhanced Raman spectroscopy. Nature 464(7287):392-395. Matsumoto K, Subramanian S, Murugesan R, Mitchell J B, & Krishna M C (2007) Spatially resolved biologic information from in vivo EPRI, OMRI, and MRI. Antioxidants & redox signaling 9(8):1125-1142. Borbat P, Costa-Filho A, Earle K, Moscicki J, & Freed J (2001) Electron spin resonance in studies of membranes and proteins. Science 291(5502):266-269. Blank A, Dunnam C R, Borbat P P, & Freed J H (2004) Pulsed three-dimensional electron spin resonance microscopy. Appl. Phys. Lett. 85(22):5430-5432. Rugar D, Budakian R, Mamin H, & Chui B (2004) Single spin detection by magnetic resonance force microscopy. Nature 430(6997):329-332. 10. Mamin H, Poggio M, Degen C, & Rugar D (2007) Nuclear magnetic resonance imaging with 90-nm resolution. Nat. Nanotech. 2(5):301-306. Degen C L, Poggio M, Mamin H J, Rettner C T, & Rugar D (2009) Nanoscale magnetic resonance imaging. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 106(5):1313-1317. Fu C C, et al. (2007) Characterization and application of single fluorescent nanodiamonds as cellular biomarkers. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 104(3):727. Neugart F, et al. (2007) Dynamics of diamond nanoparticles in solution and cells. Nano Lett. 7(12):3588-3591. Chang Y R, et al. (2008) Mass production and dynamic imaging of fluorescent nanodiamonds. Nat Nano 3(5):284-288. Gruber A, et al. (1997) Scanning confocal optical microscopy and magnetic resonance on single defect centers. Science 276(5321):2012. Balasubramanian G, et al. (2008) Nanoscale imaging magnetometry with diamond spins under ambient conditions. Nature 455(7213):648-651. 17. Maze J R, et al. (2008) Nanoscale magnetic sensing with an individual electronic spin in diamond. Nature 455(7213):644-648. Balasubramanian G, et al. (2009) Ultralong spin coherence time in isotopically engineered diamond. Nat. Mater. 8(5):383-387. 19. Maletinsky P, et al. (2012) A robust scanning diamond sensor for nanoscale imaging with single nitrogen-vacancy centres. Nat. Nanotech. 7(5):320. Steinert S, et al. (2010) High sensitivity magnetic imaging using an array of spins in diamond. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 81(4). 12. 11. 13. 14. 20. 15 25. 26. Pham L M, et al. (2011) Magnetic field imaging with nitrogen-vacancy ensembles. New J. Phys. 13(4):045021. Acosta V M, et al. (2010) Broadband magnetometry by infrared-absorption detection of nitrogen-vacancy ensembles in diamond. Appl. Phys. Lett. 97(17):174104-174103. Cole J H & Hollenberg L C L (2009) Scanning quantum decoherence microscopy. Nanotechnology 20(49):10. Hall L T, Cole J H, Hill C D, & Hollenberg L C L (2009) Sensing of Fluctuating Nanoscale Magnetic Fields Using Nitrogen-Vacancy Centers in Diamond. Phys. Rev. Lett. 103(22):220802. Hall L T, et al. (2010) Monitoring ion-channel function in real time through quantum decoherence. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 107(44):18777-18782. Steinert S, et al. (2012) Magnetic spin imaging under ambient conditions with sub- cellular resolution. http://www.arXiv:1211.3242 [cond-mat.mes-hall] . 27. McGuinness L P, et al. (2011) Quantum measurement and orientation tracking of fluorescent nanodiamonds inside living cells. Nat Nano 6(6):358-363. 28. McGuinness L P, et al. (2012) Ambient Nanoscale Sensing with Single Spins Using Quantum Decoherence. http://www.arXiv:1211.5749 [cond-mat.mes-hall] . Grotz B, et al. (2011) Sensing external spins with nitrogen-vacancy diamond. New J. Phys. 13(5):055004. 30. Mamin H J, Sherwood M H, & Rugar D (2012) Detecting external electron spins using nitrogen-vacancy centers. http://www.arXiv:1209.3748 [cond-mat.mes-hall] . 31. McConnell H, Watts T, Weis R, & Brian A (1986) Supported planar membranes in studies of cell-cell recognition in the immune system. Biochim Biophys Acta 864(1):95- 106. Bertini I, et al. (2004) Persistent contrast enhancement by sterically stabilized paramagnetic liposomes in murine melanoma. Magnetic resonance in medicine 52(3):669-672. Bradac C, et al. (2010) Observation and control of blinking nitrogen-vacancy centres in discrete nanodiamonds. Nat Nano 5(5):345-349. Rossetti F F, Bally M, Michel R, Textor M, & Reviakine I (2005) Interactions between titanium dioxide and phosphatidyl serine-containing liposomes: formation and patterning of supported phospholipid bilayers on the surface of a medically relevant material. Langmuir 21(14):6443-6450. 29. 32. 34. 33. 21. 22. 23. 24. 16
1309.3637	2	1309	2013-10-17T15:23:06	Nanotribology of biopolymer brushes in aqueous solution using dissipative particle dynamics simulations: an application to PEG covered liposomes in theta solvent	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft" ]	We undertake the investigation of sheared polymer chains grafted on flat surfaces to model liposomes covered with polyethylene glycol brushes as a case study for the mechanisms of efficient drug delivery in biologically relevant situations, for example, as carriers for topical treatments of illnesses in the human vasculature. For these applications, specific rheological properties are required, such as low viscosity at high shear rate to improve the transport of the liposomes. Therefore non - equilibrium, DPD simulations of polymer brushes of various length and shear rates are performed to obtain the average viscosity and friction coefficient of the system as functions of the shear rate and polymerization degree under theta solvent conditions, and find that the brushes experience shear thinning at large shear rates.The viscosity and the friction coefficient are shown to obey scaling laws at high shear rate in theta solvent, irrespective of the brushes degree of polymerization. These results confirm recent scaling predictions and reproduce very well trends in measurements of the viscosity at high shear of red blood cells in a liposome containing medium.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Nanotribology of biopolymer brushes in aqueous solution using dissipative particle dynamics simulations: an application to PEG covered liposomes in theta solvent A. Gama Goicochea†1, E. Mayoral1, J. Klapp1,2, and C. Pastorino3 1Instituto Nacional de Investigaciones Nucleares, Carretera México – Toluca s/n, La Marquesa Ocoyoacac, Estado de México 52750, Mexico 2Departamento de Matemáticas, CINVESTAV del IPN, México D. F. 07360, Mexico 3Departamento de Física, Centro Atómico Constituyentes, CNEA – CONICET, Av. General Paz 1499, Provincia de Buenos Aires 1650, Argentina Abstract We undertake the investigation of sheared polymer chains grafted on flat surfaces to model liposomes covered with polyethylene glycol brushes as a case study for the mechanisms of efficient drug delivery in biologically relevant situations, for example, as carriers for topical treatments of illnesses in the human vasculature. For these applications, specific rheological properties are required, such as low viscosity at high shear rate to improve the transport of the liposomes. Therefore, extensive non- equilibrium, coarse – grained dissipative particle dynamics simulations of polymer brushes of various lengths and shear rates are performed to obtain the average viscosity and the friction coefficient of the system as functions of the shear rate and polymerization degree under theta – solvent conditions, and find that the brushes experience considerable shear thinning at large shear rates. The viscosity () and † Corresponding author. Electronic mail: [email protected] 1 the friction coefficient () are shown to obey the scaling laws 𝜂~𝛾 −0.31 , and 𝜇~𝛾 0.69 at high shear rate (𝛾 ) in theta solvent, irrespective of the brushes degree of polymerization. These results confirm recent scaling predictions and reproduce very well trends in measurements of the viscosity at high ( 𝛾 ) of red blood cells in a liposome containing medium. Keywords: viscosity, friction coefficient, dissipative particle dynamics, biopolymer brushes, drug-delivering liposomes. 2 I. INTRODUCTION Polymer brushes, formed when polymer molecules grafted to a surface are stretched, are important because they play a key role in the stability of colloidal dispersions [1, 2], in the process of enhanced oil recovery [3], in the design and applications of stimuli – responsive materials [4], and even in the characterization of the mechanical properties of cancerous human cells [5], among other reasons [6]. They display some general fundamental properties, and scaling relations have been derived for them under circumstances such as high grafting density or negligible chain – chain interaction [7-9]. When polymer brushes are sheared a plethora of phenomena that are intrinsic to the non – equilibrium nature of the shearing appear. For example, experiments on fluids compressed between plates under the influence of external shear have shown that the viscosity of the fluid can be substantially reduced if a polymer brush is grafted to each plate [10]. Biological examples of sheared polymer brushes occur in articular cartilage surfaces [11] and synovial joints [12], in glycocalyx filaments that coat the human circulatory system [13], and in glycosylated cell surfaces and liposomes, which can be used as carriers for drug delivery [14]. Despite all these studies, the experimental understanding of the molecular mechanisms that take place in the various environments cited before is still incomplete because, among other reasons, characterizing variables such as the thickness of the polymer brushes on the sheared surfaces is still difficult to accomplish [6]. These difficulties arise partly because the self – assembly processes typically used for the modification of surfaces depend on chemical reactions that do not necessarily yield a well – defined brush length [6]. In this regard, computer simulations have come to play an increasingly important role, and there are now various works investigating the role of the polymer brush length, the spacing between the 3 plates, the properties of the solvent and the influence of the electrostatic interactions, the fluid´s shear thinning as the shear rate is increased, and the effect of changing the polymer grafting density on the plates, to name but a few [15-24]. However, most works have been carried out for polymers in good solvent conditions , with very few exceptions [19, 21 – 23]. It is known that some biopolymers found in an aqueous environment are in the borderline between good solvent and theta solvent conditions [21, 25]. An important example is that of polyethylene glycol (PEG) polymer brushes on liposomes, which are used as carriers under flow for efficient drug delivery [26, 27]. PEG is known to have a diminishing solubility as its molecular weight increases [28], and for molecular weights in the range of 2000 to 10000 g/mol in water it has been reported to be slightly below its theta temperature, when placed at the human body temperature [29]. Since the mechanisms of drug delivery are of paramount importance for pharmaceutical design, and their understanding is still far from complete, we have undertaken here the study of the viscosity and friction of PEG brushes on surfaces that experience an external force under theta solvent conditions, for the first time. To reach scales comparable to those of typical non-equilibrium experiments we have carried out particle – based, mesoscopic molecular dynamics simulations, using the method known as dissipative particle dynamics (DPD) [30], which has been successful in predicting correctly properties of polymer brushes both in equilibrium and non-equilibrium situations [31]. In what follows we report DPD simulations of the rheological properties of biopolymer (PEG) brushes grafted to parallel flat plates (liposomes), including the solvent explicitly, which is crucial to reproduce experiments measuring friction between polymer brushes [17, 18]. We want to model the behavior of tethered proteins and biopolymers in environments 4 such as vessels, where the separation between plates is essentially constant but allow for variations in the degree of polymerization, at fixed grafting density and substrate separation. In particular, we would like to determine the optimal conditions under which PEG brushes on liposomes promote the flow of the latter as mechanisms for efficient drug delivery. We obtain the viscosity and the friction coefficient as functions of the shear rate, and degree of polymerization. To our knowledge, this is the first report of scaling behavior for the viscosity and the friction coefficient at high shear rate of polymer brushes in theta solvent using soft potentials. Understanding of these phenomena is useful for the interpretation of several recent experiments in biological and other mesoscopic systems of current academic and industrial interest. This article is organized as follows. In the following section we introduce the interaction model, the simulation algorithm and the details of the systems studied. In Section III the main results are presented, accompanied by their discussion. The final section is devoted to our major conclusions. II. MODELS AND METHODS We have performed DPD simulations of linear grafted polymers in the canonical ensemble (fixed density and temperature). The DPD model is by now well known; therefore we shall 𝑪 ), that be brief here. Three forces make up the basic DPD structure: a conservative force (𝑭⃗⃗ 𝒊𝒋 accounts for the local pressure and is proportional to an interaction constant, 𝑎𝑖𝑗 ; a dissipative force ( 𝑭⃗⃗ 𝑫 ), which represents the viscosity arising from collisions between 𝒊𝒋 particles, proportional to the relative velocity of the particles and to a constant, ; and a 5 random force (𝑭⃗⃗ 𝑹 ), that models the Brownian motion of the particles, with an intensity 𝒊𝒋 given by the constant all acting between any two particles, i and j. The spatial dependence of these forces is usually chosen as shown in equations (1-3). 𝑭⃗⃗ 𝑪 = 𝑎𝑖𝑗 (1 − 𝒊𝒋 𝑟𝑖𝑗 ⁄ ) 𝒆 𝒊𝒋 𝑅𝑐 𝑭⃗⃗ 𝑫 = −𝛾 (1 − 𝒊𝒋 2 𝑟𝑖𝑗 ⁄ ) 𝑅𝑐 [𝒆 𝒊𝒋 ∙ 𝒗⃗⃗ 𝑖𝑗 ]𝒆 𝒊𝒋 𝑭⃗⃗ 𝑹 = 𝜎 (1 − 𝒊𝒋 𝑟𝑖𝑗 ⁄ ) 𝒆 𝒊𝒋 ξ𝑖𝑗 . 𝑅𝑐 (1) (2) (3) In equations (1-3), 𝒓𝑖𝑗 = 𝒓𝑖 − 𝒓𝑗 represents the relative position vector between particles i and j, 𝒆 𝑖𝑗 is the unit vector in the direction of 𝒓𝑖𝑗 , while 𝒗𝑖𝑗 = 𝒗𝑖 − 𝒗𝑗 is the relative velocity between particles i and j, with 𝒓𝑖 , 𝒗𝑖 being the position and velocity of particle i, respectively. The random variable ξij is generated between 0 and 1 with a Gaussian distribution, zero mean and unit variance; 𝑅𝑐 is the cut off distance, beyond which all forces are zero. The DPD beads are all of the same size, with radius 𝑅𝑐 , which is set equal to 1. The constants in the dissipation and random forces are not independent, and satisfy the relation [32]: 𝜎 2 2𝛾 = 𝑘𝐵 𝑇 (4) which, in effect, fixes the temperature; here, kB is Boltzmann’s constant. This natural thermostat that arises from the balance between the dissipative and random forces is a defining feature of the DPD model [31]. Also, the short-range nature of the DPD forces, and their linearly decaying spatial dependence, allow the use of relatively large time steps 6 when integrating the equation of motion. The DPD particles are representations of sections of fluid rather than physical particles, and can group several atoms or molecules, making the DPD method an attractive alternative to study systems at the mesoscopic level. Note also that the forces in equations (1)-(3) obey Newton’s third law, which means momentum is conserved locally, and globally, which in turn preserves any hydrodynamic modes present in the fluid. This is a feature of fundamental importance when studying non equilibrium properties of fluids, since loss of information about these modes can lead to a different phase from that obtained when they are fully accounted for [33]. The DPD interaction model has been used successfully to predict equilibrium properties of polymer melts [34], surfactants in solution [35], and colloidal stability [36], among others. For further reading, see reference [31]. All our simulations are performed in reduced units (marked with asterisks); distances are reduced with the cutoff radius, Rc, which for a coarse – graining degree equal to 3 water molecules per DPD particle is equal to Rc,=6.46 Å [31], hence r=rRc. The time step t is 2 𝑘𝐵𝑇⁄ reduced with 𝛿𝑡 = (𝑚𝑅𝐶 )1 2⁄ 𝛿𝑡 ∗ , where m is the mass of a DPD particle, while energy is reduced with kBT. All other quantities can be reduced through combinations of the 3⁄ these relations, for example, the viscosity: 𝜂 = 𝜂 ∗(𝑘𝐵𝑇𝛿𝑡 𝑅𝐶 ). Using the mass of 3 water molecules per DPD particle, at room temperature, one obtains 𝛿𝑡 ≈ (6.3 × 10−12s)𝛿𝑡 ∗ and ∗ = 1, t=0.03. In 𝜂 ≈ (9.64 cP)𝜂∗ . All our simulations are performed for 𝑘𝐵𝑇 ∗ = 𝑚∗ = 𝑅𝐶 addition to the fluid monomeric particles, our system contains soft parallel surfaces as models for biological membranes, and polymer chains attached to them, forming brushes. The polymers are built as linear chains of DPD beads joined by freely rotating harmonic 2⁄ springs [37]. The spring constant is chosen as 𝜅 = 𝜅 ∗(𝑘𝐵𝑇 𝑅𝐶 ), where 𝜅 ∗ =100 and the 7 ∗ 𝑅𝐶 , with 𝑟𝑒𝑞 ∗ = 0.7 in all cases [38]. In our spring’s equilibrium position as 𝑟𝑒𝑞 = 𝑟𝑒𝑞 simulations we have fixed the distance between the plates, which are placed perpendicular to the z-direction, at a distance of D=7. Periodic boundary conditions are applied on the xy – plane but not in the z – direction, to reinforce the confinement. The equation of motion is solved using the velocity Verlet algorithm, adapted to DPD [39]. The parameters of the dissipative and random forces intensities are, respectively,  = 4.5 and  = 3.0, so that kBT = 1 (see equation (4)). The value of the conservative force intensity (see equation (1)) was set to aij = 78.0 for all cases, namely for the interaction between particles of the same type (solvent – solvent, monomer – monomer) and for particles of different type (solvent – monomer). The choice aij = 78.0 is obtained when one uses a coarse graining degree that groups 3 water molecules in a single DPD bead [35]. Since all particle – particle interactions are equal, the polymers are in a theta – solvent, as is the case for PEG – covered liposomes in the human circulatory system [29]. It has been shown that this model for PEG on colloidal surfaces can successfully predict brush scaling laws [27], as well as adsorption isotherms on metallic oxides and disjoining pressure profiles [36]. The soft membranes on which these biopolymers are tethered are modeled as linearly decaying forces that act on the ends of the simulation box (in the z – direction), given by the following expression: 𝐹𝑤 (𝑧𝑖 ) = 𝑎𝑤 [1 − 𝑧𝑖 𝑧𝐶 ]. (5) In equation (5), 𝐹𝑤 (𝑧𝑖) symbolizes the force exerted by the effective wall on particle i, whose position component in the z – direction is zi. The intensity of the force is given by the constant 𝑎𝑤 , while zC is the cutoff distance set also equal to 1, which defines the reach 8 of this force, i.e., 𝐹𝑤 (𝑧𝑖) = 0 for zi > zC. Equation (5) represents a soft membrane because the maximum repulsion between the beads and the surface is 𝑎𝑤 when zi =0; harder walls can be used for other DPD applications [36]. It is known that liposomes can be up to about 3 orders of magnitude larger than their brush thickness, and the solvent [2, 40], therefore we consider planar walls only. To fix one end of the polymers on these substrates we chose their interaction equal to aw=70.0 (reduced DPD units), while the rest of the polymer beads and the solvent interact with the walls with an intensity given by aw=140.0. With this choice of parameters, the polymer end experiences a less repulsive force toward the walls than the rest of the polymer (and solvent) beads, and is therefore adsorbed on them. The tethered ends of the polymers remain free to move on the xy – plane, of course, as occurs also for biopolymers interacting with membranes. Although this model for membrane is soft, it remains impenetrable to polymer and solvent molecules, and we assume moreover that the drug molecules have already been incorporated into the structure. To carry out non equilibrium simulations of these systems, we apply a constant shear velocity to the polymer ends adsorbed on the walls, of equal magnitude but opposite sign for beads on different plates. This is equivalent to moving the plates in opposite direction under the influence of a fixed external force that keeps the plates moving with constant speed, known as Couette flow [19 – 23], see Figure 1. Some of the solvent monomers are seen to penetrate the PEG brushes and carry them along in their flow to produce lubrication, while there is no interpenetration of the brushes. As pointed out before, our simulations are performed in the canonical ensemble, where particle density and temperature are kept constant; previous works have shown that completely equivalent results are obtained if one performs the simulations in the grand canonical ensemble, at 9 fixed chemical potential, volume and temperature [17]. To keep the simulations results invariant to the particular choice of aij interaction parameters, we fix the global dimensionless density to 3 [35] in all the simulations reported here; this means that when the degree of polymerization of the PEG brushes (N) is increased, the number of solvent molecules is reduced. Figure 1. Snapshot of two linear PEG brushes made up of N=7 beads. The lateral dimensions of the ∗ =35, and the spacing between the plates is 𝐿𝑧 ∗ =35, 𝐿𝑦 ∗ = 𝐷 ∗=7. The grafting simulation box are 𝐿𝑥 density is equal to =0.3. A constant shear velocity of magnitude v0 =1.0 is applied to the tethered beads of each polymer (in dark blue); the rest of the polymer beads are shown in yellow. The solvent monomers are shown in red. Notice how the solvent penetrates the polymer brushes all the way up to the surfaces for this grafting density. See text for details. The grafting density is defined as =Np/A, where Np is the number of polymer chains ∗ 𝐿𝑦 ∗ is its reduced area. Our simulations are performed at tethered on the surface and A=𝐿𝑥 grafting densities that lie within the brush regime (, where N is the degree of 10 polymerization, see [27]), where the “stealth” properties of the PEG brushes work best [41]. We obtain the viscosity (), and the friction coefficient () of the fluid, through the relations [19] 𝜂 = 〈𝐹𝑥 (𝛾 )〉 𝐴⁄ 𝛾 , 𝜇 = 〈𝐹𝑥 (𝛾 )〉 〈𝐹𝑧 (𝛾 )〉 . (6) (7) In equations (6) and (7) above, 〈𝐹𝑥 (𝛾 )〉 and 〈𝐹𝑧(𝛾 )〉 are the mean forces that the particles on the surfaces experience along the flow direction, and perpendicularly to it, respectively; the brackets indicate an ensemble average. Equation (6) can be understood as the local definition of viscosity, applied to the entire sample. Considering a liquid confined between two planar walls, a linear flow can be generated by moving for example the top wall at constant velocity. This motion requires that a steady force be applied on the top wall, and an equal in magnitude but opposite in direction force, on the bottom wall, see Figure 1. In linear flow, the velocity gradient (shear rate, 𝛾 ) is constant throughout the liquid. The shear ∗ 𝐷∗⁄ rate 𝛾 is defined as 2𝑣0 , where v0 is the flow velocity exerted on the grafted monomers, and D* is the surface separation (see Figure 1). To obtain first a local definition of viscosity, a small cubic volume in the fluid (fluid element) can be considered. This fluid element undergoes strain, being deformed from a cubic to a parallelepiped shape, with increasing deformation in time. The amount of strain is the added lateral displacement of top and bottom planes of the fluid volume divided by its height. This strain increases at constant rate in time for linear flow, such that the strain rate i.e. the strain per unit time, is the velocity gradient in the limit of an infinitesimal fluid element. The strain rate of deformation is therefore the shear rate, 𝛾 . On the other hand, a force acts on the top and 11 bottom planes of the fluid element, with identical magnitude and opposite direction. The center of mass of the fluid element, suffers no acceleration and therefore the total external force on it must vanish. These forces must be proportional to the area of the top and bottom planes of the fluid element. Also, the force-per-unit-area or stress, , must be uniform from top to bottom in the fluid element since the fluid is not accelerating. For linear flow, this is true not only for a fluid element but for the whole fluid: every part of the fluid is under the same stress, which produces everywhere the same velocity gradient (𝛾 ). The definition of viscosity assumes that the shear rate (𝛾 ) produced in a fluid element is proportional to the shear stress () exerted on it. The viscosity is defined as the constant of proportionality between them:  = 𝛾 , or = 𝛾 . The total shear stress on the sample () can be determined from the average total force on the brush heads divided by the wall area (Fx/A) while the shear rate (𝛾 ) is extracted from the slope of the linear fit of the average velocity profile. The viscosity is then expressed by equation (6). As for the friction coefficient, shown in equation (7), its calculation follows directly from the analogy with the friction coefficient between solid surfaces, namely Fx=Fz, where Fz is the force acting perpendicularly to the surface, and Fx is the force acting parallel to it, which is responsible for the shear stress ( = Fx/A) [24]. Our results were obtained from averages of simulations of up to 4×103 blocks, with each block composed of 2×104 time steps, using the first 2×105 time steps for equilibration and the rest for the production phase; when properly dimensionalized this represents a time observation window of 0.12 ms. A typical density profile of the solvent and polymer monomers is shown in Figure 2, where it is clear that the solvent penetrates the PEG brushes and reaches the surfaces, at that given grafting density. 12 Figure 2. Density profiles of the PEG brushes (dashed line, in blue) with polymerization degree N=7, and the solvent (full line, in black). The polymer monomers order near the walls, which leads to their structuring, represented here by peaks near the walls, while there is a relatively free (bulk like) fluid made up of solvent molecules at the center of the simulation box. For the case shown in ∗ =𝐿𝑦 ∗ =7, D=7, v0 this figure, 𝐿𝑥 =1.0 and =1.0. Note there is very little interpenetration between the brushes. The brush structuring is rather strong because the chains are relatively short. The profiles of the opposing polymer brushes show very little interpenetration and an almost bulk like concentration of solvent monomers at the center of the simulation box (see Figure 2), which reduces the viscosity of the system. The structuring of the PEG brush monomers, represented by the maxima in Figure 2, coincides with that of the solvent monomers, indicating that even for a relatively large grafting density as that shown in the figure, the solvent is able to reach the membrane. The maxima of both profiles (the solvent’s and the brushes’) occur at the same positions because the interactions between 13 0123456702468 (z)z solvent brushthem are the same (recall aij=aii=78.0 for all i and j), as it is befitting for theta – solvent conditions. The strong layering is expected when the chains are relatively short, as in Figure 2, because in such case monomers are more easily arranged that when long chains form the brushes [16-20]. In Figure 3 we present the velocity profile for PEG brushes of polymerization degree N=14 and grafting density =0.30 under a shear velocity equal to v0 =0.1. Clearly, there appears a linear gradient in the center of the channel formed between ∗ 𝐷 ∗⁄ , liposomes, from which the shear rate 𝛾 can be obtained, through the relation 𝛾 = 2𝑣0 as pointed out before. The inset in Figure 3 shows the temperature profile of the complex fluid in the z-direction, which indicates the brushes are at the temperature fixed by the thermostat (kBT=1), although at large shear rates one expects the brush to “heat up” somewhat [19], as a consequence of the increased dissipation rate. 14 Figure 3. Velocity profile at the center of the channel between liposomes for PEG brushes with N=14 and =0.30, using v0 =0.1. The box size is Lx =Ly =7, D=7. The inset shows the temperature profile (Tx ) in the z-direction. All quantities are reported in reduced units. Most simulations were performed for a brush grafting density =0.30, except where indicated otherwise, because for this value the average distance between grafted heads on the surface is smaller than their radius of gyration in theta solvent, for all values of N we studied [27]. By doing so one makes sure that the grafted polymer chains are in the brush, rather than the mushroom regime [27], which is important for the situation we are interested in modeling. The polymerization degree was varied in the range N=1 up to N=25, so that scaling laws could be extracted from the data. Finally, the shear rate was chosen to vary from 𝛾 = 0 to 𝛾 = 0.30, except where indicated otherwise, so that we could compare our results with those available in the literature [16-20]. Molecular dynamics simulations like ours solve the equation of motion essentially exactly [33], although the use of soft forces in DPD (see, for example, equation (1)) might limit its applicability to situations where atomistic detail is not important, as is the case for the nanotribology studies that are the focus of this work. III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION One would like to simulate systems with a large number of particles so that realistic situations can be reproduced, while simultaneously keeping such number manageable to obtain results in a timely fashion. Therefore, we have carried out simulations to quantify the extent of finite size effects in the viscosity of the polymer brushes, if any. Figure 4 shows the mean viscosity of the PEG brushes and the solvent, calculated with equation (6), as a 15 function of the lateral size of the membranes (Lx =Ly ), at fixed separation between them (D=7), grafting density (=0.30) and shear rate (𝛾 =0.28). The results in Figure 4 cover a range that goes from 103 particles up to 105 particles while the relative change in the viscosity amounts to less than 1 %, showing that finite size effects are not important in the calculation of the viscosity, which allows us to make correct predictions using relatively small systems. Figure 4. Finite size effects in the viscosity, . The symbol Lx represents the size of the simulation box in the x – direction, which is equal to that in the y – direction, Ly . In all cases, Lz =D=7, the shear rate is 𝛾 = 0.28, and the grafting density is =0.30. All quantities are reported in reduced units. Lines are only guides for the eye. 16 010203040506070801.4801.4851.4901.4951.5001.5051.5101.5151.520 Lx Similar results have been found in equilibrium DPD simulations [42] which proved that finite size effects in the interfacial tension between two model fluids were as small as those found in the viscosity and shown in Figure 4, when the appropriate ensemble was used. This behavior is to be attributed to the soft, short – range repulsive nature of the DPD forces (see equations (1)-(3)), although these effects may become non negligible if a long – range interaction is included, such as the electrostatic one. In the remainder of this work we present results obtained using only the smallest simulation box in Figure 4. Let us now proceed to discuss the results obtained for the mean viscosity of a complex fluid made up of PEG brushes and an aqueous solvent, as a function of the shear rate for different degrees of polymerization (N), as seen in Figure 5. The simulations were performed with a cubic box of lateral size L=7 and for =0.30. For very small values of 𝛾 (less than 10-4) the calculation of  requires of very long simulations due to poor signal – to – noise ratios [19], which makes it very difficult to obtain accurately the zero – shear viscosity, 0, from simulations. However, a good estimate of it can be obtained from the extrapolation of the rheology profiles in Figure 5 as 𝛾 approaches zero. For the shorter PEG brushes (N=1 and N=3) the fluid displays essentially Newtonian behavior, whereas for the case with N=7 the fluid shows shear – thinning. One observes also that as N is increased so is the extrapolated 0 value, which is a consequence of the combined effects of an increasing brush thickness and a reduced number of solvent particles (to keep the global density =3). Increasing N is equivalent to reducing the separation between the membranes, D, when the grafting density is kept constant, and yields increasing values of 0 [18]. Hence, we have opted to vary N rather than D* in this work. The simulations shown in Figure 5 were carried out for relatively short polymers with the purpose of establishing 17 the minimum polymerization degree at which the fluid started to show shear thinning, which, from Figure 5, is N=7. For polymerization degree smaller than 7, it is difficult for the polymer chains to interact with the solvent monomers enough to reduce the viscosity as the shear rate is increased, hence the fluid remains approximately Newtonian (N=1 and N=3 in Figure 5). Figure 5. Viscosity for a fluid made of polymer brushes of various degrees of polymerization (N) and monomeric solvent particles. Notice how the shorter brushes show virtually no shear – thinning, and behave almost like Newtonian fluids. In all cases, Lx =Ly =D=7, and the grafting density is =0.30. All quantities are reported in reduced units. Lines are only guides for the eye. It has been reported that increasing the polymerization degree of PEG brushes on liposomes increases their circulation longevity [28], which would be a desirable aspect to improve 18 drug delivery mechanisms. However, as its degree of polymerization grows, PEG’s solubility in aqueous environment is reduced [29], hence there would be a competition between these trends that can be investigated with DPD simulations, varying N. Also, it is important to find out if the viscosity behaves qualitatively the same as a function of shear rate, regardless of the value of N, so that general conclusions are obtained that can be used to interpret a variety of experiments [24]. Before presenting our results for the effective mean viscosity of systems where PEG brushes have larger polymerization degrees we comment on the behavior of the mean shear stress on the membranes along the direction of the flow as a function of the shear, 〈𝐹𝑥 (𝛾 )〉. Following Galuschko and coworkers [43], we find a critical shear rate for our systems, 𝛾 ∗ , as the value of the shear rate when the behavior of 〈𝐹𝑥 (𝛾 )〉 changes from linear to sub linear, which depends on N, being 𝛾 ∗~8.6 × 10−3 for N=14, and 𝛾 ∗~2.9 × 10−3 for N=25. Finding 𝛾 ∗ is tantamount to finding the Weissenberg number, We, since 𝑊𝑒 = 𝛾 𝛾 ∗⁄ , and it signal when shear – thinning behavior starts to set in (We ≥ 1). Figure 6 shows the dependence of the normalized shear stress, 𝑢 ≡ 〈𝐹𝑥 (𝛾 )〉 〈𝐹𝑥 (𝛾 ∗)〉 ⁄ , on We for fluids with brushes with polymerization degrees equal to N=14, 20 and 25. The data for the three brushes are seen to collapse reasonably well, especially at low We; this is the so called linear regime, 𝑢~𝑊𝑒, (dashed blue line in Figure 6). For larger values of the Weissenberg number, we find that the power law 𝑢~𝑊𝑒 𝜅 is obeyed with 𝜅 = 0.69 (solid black line in Figure 6) for our systems under theta – solvent ⁄ conditions. Galuschko et al. [43] predict 𝜅 = 9 13 ≈ 0.69 using scaling arguments for what they call “dry” polymer brushes, which are brushes where the hydrodynamic and excluded volume interactions are screened out , for fairly concentrated solutions and polymer melts, where the corresponding Flory exponent is =0.5 [44]. Our simulations 19 predict a  value in excellent agreement with scaling arguments [43] because under theta – solvent conditions and at the concentrations we modeled, the brushes are almost indistinguishable from the solvent, and act as a melt. Figure 6. Normalized mean shear stress (u) on the surfaces in the direction of the flow as a function of the Weissenberg number, We, for PEG brushes of three different polymerization degrees, N. In all cases, Lx =Ly =D=7, and the grafting density is =0.30. The dashed blue line represents the linear regime, 𝑢~𝑊𝑒 (We < 1), and the solid black line the power law 𝑢~𝑊𝑒 𝜅 , with 𝜅 = 0.69. See text for details. Recent molecular dynamics simulations [45] of strongly compressed polyelectrolyte brushes under shear at melt concentrations find that the shear force 〈𝐹𝑥 (𝛾 )〉 that appears in equations (6) and (7) behaves at high shear rate (𝛾 ) as 〈𝐹𝑥 (𝛾 )〉~𝛾 0.69 , in agreement with our predictions in Figure 6, and with the scaling arguments of Galuschko et al. [43]. Although 20 10-210-110010110210-210-1100101 N=14 N=20 N=25uWethere are explicit electrostatic interactions in the work of Spirin and Kreer [45], they argue that their brush and solvent system behaves as a melt of neutral polymers at high We because of the immobilization of the counterions. Therefore, the scaling exponent =0.69 we obtained in Figure 6 is very robust. The effective mean viscosity data of these systems can also be collapsed as a function of We if one defines 𝑠 = 𝜂 𝜂0⁄ [43], for We > 1, as seen in Figure 7(a). The value of the zero shear viscosity 𝜂0 was obtained from extrapolation, using the same procedure as the one described in the discussion of Figure 5. All three cases experience considerable shear thinning as the Weissenberg number is increased, and in this regime the data follow the power law 𝑠~𝑊𝑒 𝜁 , with 𝜁 = −0.31, see the black line in Figure 7(a). To our knowledge, this is the first time such scaling law has been obtained in theta solvent. In reference [43] the value 𝜁 = −0.43 was obtained for linear Lennard – Jones brushes in good solvent. A similar value ( 𝜁 = −0.42 ) was found in simulations of bottle – brush polyelectrolytes in good solvent [18]. Hence, polymer architecture appears to be of secondary importance, compared with the quality of the solvent or the polymer concentration. Galuschko and collaborators [43] proposed also the following relation between 𝜅 and 𝜁 : 𝜅 − 𝜁 = 1 (8) which is clearly fulfilled in our theta solvent simulations. Therefore the relation between the scaling exponents is the same regardless of solvent quality, and is more fundamental than the architecture of the polymer chains or the particular values of the exponents themselves, separately, as is known to be the case for equilibrium scaling exponents [46]. 21 22 10-210-110010110210-1100 sWe N=14 N=20 N=25s~We -0.31(a)101102103101102. RBC(mPa s)(s-1).(b)Figure 7. (a) Normalized effective mean viscosity 𝑠 = 𝜂 𝜂0⁄ as a function of the Weissenberg number, We, for fluids with PEG brushes of three different polymerization degrees, N. In all cases, Lx =Ly =D=7, and the grafting density is = 0.30. The line represents the power law, 𝑠~𝑊𝑒 𝜁 , with 𝜁 = −0.31. (b) Viscosity of a fluid made up of red blood cells (RBC) dispersed in a 40 kDa liposome – dextran medium, as a function of the shear rate [47]. The blue line represents the power law 𝜂~𝛾 −0.31. See text for details. In Figure 7(b) we have included the high shear rate values of the viscosity of human red blood cells (RBC) in a liposomal suspension [47], which shows evidently shear – thinning. This non – Newtonian behavior is interpreted as being the result of the dissociation of flocculated liposomes at the higher values of the shear rate, an interpretation that is consistent with our predictions in Figure 7(a). The blue line in figure 7(b) represents the power law we have obtained for PEG – grafted surfaces in a theta solvent, which models accurately the results for RBC at high values of the shear rate, providing confirmat ion for our predictions. Experiments carried out for gels used as vehicles for drug delivering liposomes [48], such as hydroxyethylcellulose (HEC) and a mixture of HEC and an acrylic acid – based polymer (carbopol 974) yield values of the viscosity at high shear rates very close to that found in Figure 7(a), namely 𝜁 = 0.30 ± 0.01 for HEC and 𝜁 = 0.310 ± 0.009 for the mixture. The fact that the exponent in these experiments is found to be very close to our prediction suggests that it is of paramount importance to take into account the properties of the solvent (theta conditions), as well as those of the brush (PEG) , and lends additional support to these calculations. Adding polymer brushes to sheared surfaces not only modifies the viscosity of the system but it has been shown to reduce its friction coefficient [10] also. Since this is a parameter 23 that can be directly compared with experiments, we have obtained the friction coefficient of PEG brushes in an explicitly included, theta solvent. Using equation (7) one calculates the mean friction coefficient between the two sliding surfaces. The data in Figure 8(a) show that the friction coefficient  at constant PEG grafting density, increases with the shear rate, in agreement with trends found by others [18, 43, 49]; it increases also with N because the overlap between the brushes also grows. Moreover, the  values for PEG brushes in theta solvent are somewhat larger than those obtained in simulations of linear brushes in good solvent [17]; this is of course expected because the brush thickness is reduced when it is immersed in a theta solvent, and the contacts between the polymers grow when going from good to theta solvent [2]. Experiments by Klein and collaborators [50] on the friction of polymer brushes in theta solvent compared to good solvent show that the friction coefficient can be larger in the former by up to three orders of magnitude than in the latter. The reason relies on the fact that in theta solvent conditions the brushes can interdigitate and the solvent can penetrate the brushes (see Figure 2), reducing the freely flowing solvent in the center of the channel, thereby increasing the shear force and the friction. Klein and coworkers [50] obtain values for  which are close to our predictions, shown in Figure 8(a). When electrostatic interactions are included the values for  obtained from computer simulations turn out to be slightly larger and closer to 1 for good solvent conditions at high values of the shear rate [18, 49], due to the added osmotic pressure of the ions. However, in biological systems like those modeled here, the quality of the solvent plays a key role in providing a mechanism that promotes a lower viscosity environment. 24 25 0.000.050.100.150.200.250.300.000.050.100.150.200.250.300.35  N=25 N=20 N=14 N=7(a).10-210-110010110210-210-110010110-410-310-210-110010-410-310-210-1 N=25 N=20 N=14We(b). N=7Figure 8. (a) Friction coefficient for polymer brushes of various degrees of polymerization (N), obtained using equation (7). In all cases, Lx =Ly =D=7, and the grafting density is = 0.30. Lines are only guides for the eye. (b) The friction coefficient data shown in (a), normalized by its value at 𝛾 ∗ for the largest 3 brushes, , as a function of the Weissenberg number, 𝑊𝑒 = 𝛾 𝛾 ∗⁄ . The black line represents the fit to the power law 𝜇 𝜇∗⁄ ~𝑊𝑒 𝜅 , with =0.69. The inset shows the friction coefficient for the polymer with the smallest degree of polymerization (N=7, pink rhombi), with the blue line representing a linear fit, 𝜇~𝛾 . In Figure 8(b) we show the same data as in Figure 8(a), on logarithmic scales to emphasize power law behavior. For the shortest brush (see inset in Figure 8(b)), made up of chains with polymerization degree equal to N=7, there is a linear relation between the friction coefficient and the shear rate, 𝜇~𝛾 , for the entire range of shear rate values used in the simulations (blue line). To see sublinear behavior here one would have to impose larger shear. For the other polymerization degrees shown (N=14 to 25) the main panel in Figure 8(b) shows that the data collapse rather well on a single curve when the friction coefficient () is normalized by its value (*) at the start of the shear – thinning regime (𝛾 ∗ ). The black line is the fit to the power law 𝜇 𝜇∗⁄ ~𝑊𝑒 𝑘 , with =0.69. This is the same exponent as the one obtained from the normalized shear stress data, in Figure 6, indicating that the force 〈𝐹𝑧(𝛾 )〉 (see equation (7)) is essentially independent of shear once the brushes have reached a certain length. At the same time, the fact that the exponent is =0.69 at 𝑊𝑒 > 1 in all three cases (N=14, 20 and 25) shows that 〈𝐹𝑥 (𝛾 )〉 (see equation (7)) is responsible for the behavior of the friction coefficient in the high shear rate regime. The same behavior is found for Lennard – Jones brushes [43], namely that the friction coefficient dependence on 26 We scales with same exponent as that of the shear stress, although in such case =0.57 because that system is under good – solvent conditions. IV. CONCLUSIONS We have shown that complex fluids with polymer brushes under theta solvent conditions display rheological characteristics that differ in detail from their good solvent counterparts, but that obey nevertheless the same general scaling properties, in particular for the shear stress and the viscosity. The exponent for the shear stress as a function of We obtained from our simulations, =0.69, is in excellent agreement with the value predicted using scaling arguments [43] for dense polymer brushes where excluded volume interactions are screened out, as in our model. The viscosity we obtained scales with the shear rate with an exponent equal to 𝜁 = −0.31 , which reproduces remarkably well measurements of the viscosity of red blood cells dispersed in a liposome carrying aqueous fluid at high shear rate [47], as well as other experiments [48]. The friction coefficient data as a function of shear rate for different polymerization degrees of the chains making up the brushes were found to collapse on a universal curve whose behavior at We > 1 follows the same power law as the shear force, i.e., 𝜇~𝑊𝑒 𝜅 , with =0.69, in agreement with trends found in simulations under good – solvent conditions [43], albeit with a value of  particular to those conditions. Ours are the first simulations, to the best of our knowledge, of the scaling of viscosity and the friction coefficient for systems under theta – solvent conditions. It is argued that our simulations are useful for understanding the behavior of biopolymer brushes coating drug – carrying liposomes in an aqueous environment that acts as a theta 27 solvent, under shear. Increasing the thickness of the brush through the degree of polymerization or the shear velocity on the surfaces is shown to raise the friction coefficient, which is a deleterious effect for the transport properties of these liposomes. However, when liposomes are covered by PEG bushes in a theta solvent at high shear rates, their flowing characteristics make them optimal carriers for drug delivery, as the polymer brushes imprint them with efficient injectable characteristics (low viscosity at high shear rate) while at the same time providing them with thermodynamically stable (“stealth”) mechanisms. These simulations have the additional advantage of including hydrodynamic interactions, as well as the solvent explicitly, and being mesoscopic they reproduce length and time scales comparable with those of environments of biological interest. Therefore, we believe our work should be useful in the improved design of drug – carriers, the rheological characterization of sheared brushes, and in the establishing of general scaling laws for non – equilibrium polymer brushes. V. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would like to thank ABACUS, CONACyT grant EDOMEX-2011-C01- 165873, for funding. AGG thanks M. A. Balderas Altamirano, C. Carmín, E. de la Cruz, J. P. López Neria and E. Pérez for instructive discussions. VI. REFERENCES 28 [1] D. H. Napper, Polymeric Stabilization of Colloidal Dispersions, Academic Press, London, 1983. [2] J. N. Israelachvili, Intermolecular and Surfaces Forces, 3rd. Ed., Academic Press, New York, 2011. [3] A. Mollaei, B. Maini, J. Can. Petroleum Tech. 49, 65 (2010). [4] M. A. Cohen Stuart, W. T. S. Huck, J. Genzer, M. Müller, C. Ober, M. Stamm, G. B. Sukhorukov, I. Szleifer, V. V. Tsukruk, M. Urban, F. Winnik, S. Zauscher, I. Luzinov, S. Minko, Nature Materials, 9, 101 (2010). [5] S. Iyer, R. M. Gaikwad, V. Subba – Rao, C. D. Woodworth, I. Sokolov, Nature Nanotech. 4, 389 (2009). [6] R. Advincula, W. J. Brittain, K. C. Caster, J. Rühe (eds.), Polymer Brushes, Wiley- VCH, 2004. [7] P. G. de Gennes, Macromolecules 13, 1069 (1980). [8] S. Alexander, J. Phys. (Paris) 38, 983 (1977). [9] S. T. Milner, T. A. Witten, M. E. Cates, Europhys. Lett. 5, 413 (1988). [10] J. Klein, E. Kumacheva, D. Mahalu, D. Perahia, L. J. Fetters, Nature 370, 634 (1994). [11] L. Han, D. Dean, P. Mao, C. Ortiz, A. J. Grodzinsky, Biophys. J. 92, 1384 (2007). [12] J. Klein, Science 323, 47 (2009). [13] S. Weinbaum, J. M. Tarbell, E. R. Damiano, Annu. Rev. Biomed. Engng. 9, 121 (2007). [14] A. Samal, Y. Sultana, M. Aqil, Curr. Drug Delivery 4, 297 (2007). [15] P. Y. Lai, C. Y. Lai, Phys. Rev. E 54, 6958 (1996). [16] T. Kreer, M. H. Müser, K. Binder, J. Klein, Langmuir 17, 7804 (2001). [17] F. Goujon, P. Malfreyt, D. J. Tildesley, Mol. Phys. 103, 2675 (2005). 29 [18] J. M. Carrillo, W. M. Brown, A. V. Dobrynin, Macromolecules 45, 8880 (2012). [19] C. Pastorino, K. Binder, T. Kreer, M. Müller, J. Chem. Phys. 124, 064902 (2006). [20] F. Goujon, P. Malfreyt, D. J. Tildesley, Soft Matter 6, 3472 (2010). [21] M. Deng, X. Li, H. Liang, B. Caswell, G. E. Karniadakis, J. Fluid Mech. 711, 192 (2012). [22] D. Irfachsyad, D. J. Tildesley, P. Malfreyt, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 4, 3008 (2002). [23] C. Pastorino, K. Binder, M. Müller, Macromolecules 42, 401 (2009). [24] K. Binder, A. Milchev, J. Pol. Sci. Part B: Pol. Phys. 50, 1515 (2012). [25] F. Alarcón, E. Pérez, A. Gama Goicochea, Eur. Biophys. J. 42, 661 (2013). [26] D. D. Lasic, F. Martin (eds.), Stealth Liposomes, CRC Press, Florida, 1995. [27] P. L. Hansen, J. A. Cohen, R. Podgornik, V. A. Parsegian, Biophys. J. 84, 350 (2003). [28] C. Allen, N. Dos Santos, R. Gallagher, G. N. C. Chiu, Y. Shu, W. M. Li, S. A. Johnstone, A. S. Janoff, L. D. Mayer, M. S. Webb, and M. B. Bally, Bioscience Reports 22, 2, (2002). [29] C. Ö. Dinç, G. Kibarer, A. Güner, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 117, 1100 (2010). [30] P. J. Hoogerbrugge and J. M. V. A. Koelman, Europhys. Lett. 19, 155 (1992). [31] T. Murtola, A. Bunker, I. Vattulainen, M. Deserno, M. Karttunen, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 11, 1869 (2009). [32] P. Español and P. Warren, Europhys. Lett. 30, 191 (1995). [33] D. Frenkel and B. Smit, Understanding Molecular Simulation, Academic, New York, 2002. [34] R. D. Groot, J. Chem. Phys. 118, 11265 (2003). [35] R.D. Groot and P.B. Warren, J. Chem. Phys. 107, 4423 (1997). [36] A. Gama Goicochea, Langmuir 23, 11656 (2007). 30 [37] M. Murat and G. S. Grest, Phys. Rev. Lett. 63, 1074 (1989). [38] A. Gama Goicochea, M. Romero-Bastida, R. López-Rendón, Mol. Phys. 105, 2375 (2007). [39] I. Vattulainen, M. Karttunen, G. Besold, J. M. Polson, J. Chem. Phys. 116, 3967 (2002). [40] D. D. Verma, S. Verma, G. Blume, A. Fahr, Intl. J. Pharm. 258, 141 (2003). [41] D. Needham, K. Hristova, T. J. McIntosh, M. Dewhirst, N. Wu, D. D. Lasic, J. Liposome Res. 2, 411 (1992). [42] M. E. Velázquez, A. Gama Goicochea, M. González-Melchor, M. Neria, J. Alejandre, J. Chem. Phys. 124, 084104 (2006). [43] A. Galuschko, L. Spirin, T. Kreer, A. Johner, C. Pastorino, J. Wittmer, J. Baschnagel, Langmuir 26, 6418 (2010). [44] P. G. de Gennes, Scaling Concepts in Polymer Physics, Cornell University Press, New York, 1979. [45] L. Spirin and T. Kreer, ACS Macro Lett. 2, 63 (2013). [46] N. Goldenfeld, Lectures on Phase Transitions and the Renormalization Group, Addison Wesley Publishing Company, 1992. [47] H. Sakai, A. Sato, N. Okuda, S. Takeoka, N. Maeda, E. Tsuchida, Am. J. Physiol. Heart Circ. Physiol. 297, 583 (2009). 31 [48] S. Mourtas, S. Fotopoulou, S. Duraj, V. Sfika, C. Tsakiroglou, S. G. Antimisiaris, J. Coll. Interface Science 317, 611 (2008). [49] J. M. Carrillo, D. Russano, A. Dobrynin, Langmuir 27, 14599 (2011). [50] J. Klein, E. Kumacheva, D. Perahia, D. Mahalu, S. Warburg, Faraday Discuss. 98, 173 (1994). 32
1612.03146	1	1612	2016-12-07T23:52:17	Scattering and Absorption Control in Biocompatible Fibers towards Equalized Photobiomodulation	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.optics" ]	Transparent tissue scaffolds enable illumination of growing tissue to accelerate cell proliferation and improve other cell functions through photobiomodulation. The biphasic dose response of cells exposed to photobiomodulating light dictates that the illumination to be evenly distributed across the scaffold such that the cells are neither under nor over exposed to light. However, equalized illumination has not been sufficiently addressed. Here we analyze and experimentally demonstrate spatially equalizing illumination by three methods, namely, engineered surface scattering, reflection by a gold mirror, and traveling-waves in a ring mesh. Our results show that nearly equalized illumination is achievable by controlling the light scattering-to-loss ratio. This demonstration opens opportunities for dose-optimized photobiomodulation in tissue regeneration.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Scattering and Absorption Control in Biocompatible Fibers towards Equalized Photobiomodulation J. George,1 H. Haghshenas,1 D. D'Hemecourt,1 W. Zhu2, L. Zhang2, V. Sorger1,* 1Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, The George Washington University, Washington, D.C. 20052, USA 2Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, The George Washington University, Washington, D.C. 20052, USA *Corresponding author: [email protected] Abstract: Transparent tissue scaffolds enable illumination of growing tissue to accelerate cell proliferation and improve other cell functions through photobiomodulation. The biphasic dose response of cells exposed to photobiomodulating light dictates that the illumination to be evenly distributed across the scaffold such that the cells are neither under nor over exposed to light. However, equalized illumination has not been sufficiently addressed. Here we analyze and experimentally demonstrate spatially equalizing illumination by three methods, namely, engineered surface scattering, reflection by a gold mirror, and traveling-waves in a ring mesh. Our results show that nearly equalized illumination is achievable by controlling the light scattering-to-loss ratio. This demonstration opens opportunities for dose-optimized photobiomodulation in tissue regeneration. Main Body: Photobiomodulation is the use of light to regulate biological activity in cellular or tissular level. Light at red and near-infrared (NIR) frequencies has shown to promote cell proliferation in both in vitro and in vivo experiments [1, 2]. There are three potential mechanisms for the increased proliferation. The first mechanism is the direct absorption of red or NIR photons by cytochrome c oxidase in the mitochondria of the cells. This absorption increases the rate of the electron transport chain, and consequently the available adenosine triphosphate (ATP), cellular energy, of the cell, increasing the proliferation rate. The second potential mechanism is that red light (670nm and 633nm) decreases the viscous friction of interfacial water layers surrounding the mitochondrial nano-motor, thus speeding up the mitochondrial production of ATP [3]. The third mechanism is that light generates low levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) within the cell, triggering a survival mechanism that increases the production of mitochondria. This increase in mitochondria then adds to the available ATP within the cell, which increases proliferation. This third mechanism is optical dose dependent. With too small a dose of light, insufficient ROS will be generated and the cell will not increase its production of mitochondria. On the other hand, if the dose is too high, too much ROS will be generated and the cell will enter apoptosis. As such, the dose response in cell photobiomodulation has been shown to follow a biphasic response curve [4], growing incrementally with increased dosage and leveling at some optimal range before falling precipitously (Inset, Fig 1). This biphasic dose response requires care in the selection of power for in vivo use. If tissue is exposed from the outside of the patient, the cells close to the source will receive exponentially more dosage than cells farther from the source, due to Beer's Law of absorption. This optical absorption is not straightforward function of tissue type for all tissues between the source and the target cells. It is therefore reasonable to expect that in a complex organism only a small number of subsurface target cells will reach the exact dose required for optimal effect, while others remain either unaffected or damaged. Addressing such optimized dosage of light delivery to cells deep inside tissue scaffolds and ultimate to the body is the motivation of the work presented here. Tissue scaffolds are mechanical structures with engineered morphology used to hold cells while they develop to create artificially structured tissues. Tissue scaffolds are created from biocompatible materials such as hydrogels, poly-lactic acid (PLA), and silk fibroin by 3D printing, molding, lithography and other manufacturing techniques [5-8]. Transparent hydrogel scaffolds have been combined with optics for sensing, optogenetics, and photobiomodulation [9]. While the transparent scaffolds do allow light to enter the tissue more easily, they can suffer from the same dose dependence seen in external photobiomodulation where uneven illumination of the growing tissue causes some cells to be overexposed and others to be underexposed. In this paper we introduce and test three illumination methods for engineering transparent tissue scaffolds with equalized power profiles. These methods can be applied with minimal changes to the mechanical structure of the scaffold, allowing them to be added to existing scaffold designs. The first proposed method utilizes engineered diffusion; optical diffusion is the scattering of light from surface boundaries within a media. The light-loss inside a waveguide depends on both the internal absorption [10-12], scattering events, and any other loss mechanisms such as evanescent coupling [13], bending losses in ring structures, and proximity to metals found in the field of plasmonics [14-18]. Regarding the material loss leading to internal waveguide absorption, this can be in principle complex if the waveguide consists of a multitude of materials where an effective mode index determines the modal loss [19]. Here, however, we only consider waveguides comprised of homogeneous materials. Let us now consider such as homogeneous waveguide comprised entirely of the biocompatible material PLA extending in the x direction into the scaffold. In this case the optical power within the waveguide can be modeled by the differential equation, Eq. 1. (1) where light is only lost by absorption, , or by scattering into the fiber surrounding scaffold, . Solving Eq. 1 for the power P at any point within the waveguide is given by Eq. 2. (2) The optical power along the length of the waveguide decays exponentially with distance in the absence of gain. We wish to design the scattering along the length of the waveguide in order to equalize the distribution of power over the surface of the waveguide. Therefore, we seek a scattering profile, , as a function of distance along the x-axis that provides the least power difference between input and end of the fiber, , with no power left at the end, , for maximum efficiency. An optimally flat irradiance will therefore have a derivative of zero. If we set the derivative of the irradiance to zero we need to find a function, , that meets the following two criteria: as(cid:9)(cid:9)P(L)=0(cid:9)(cid:9)s(x)(cid:9)(cid:9)s(x) (3) (4) When we naively attempt to match to the inverse of the exponential function, for example , we see that in turn increases the exponential decay function. In fact the only function that can satisfy (3) and (4) for all x is , which violates our requirement that the power at the end of the waveguide reaches 0. Hence the optimum we can accomplish with an engineered scattering function with distance, , is leveling the distribution over the waveguide length (i.e. waveguide surface area), as discussed next. Starting with transparent PLA waveguides, we explore two processes to control the scattering in transparent PLA; in the first process we heat PLA in water causing hydrolyzation of the polymer, increasing optical diffusion (Fig. 2) [20]. In the second process NaOH is used as a solvent to PLA to create roughness by etching the PLA surface, which again increases optical diffusion. Both methods result in a biocompatible PLA waveguide with increased optical scattering into the scaffold. For the second illumination method we introduce an added biocompatible gold film at the end of the PLA waveguide (Fig. 1(c)). The gold acts as a mirror to fold or reflect the light back into the waveguide. Within certain ranges of input power, the reflected light acts to partially compensate for the exponential decay of the original waveguide. The power reflected from the mirror can be modeled as an additional exponential term, except now it decays from the end of the mirror, L, back to the source at x = 0. (5) This leads to a two-term equation for irradiance, I, from a gold-mirror waveguide where R is the mirror reflectivity. (6) The additional exponential term reflecting power from the end of the waveguide acts in the same manner as reflection occurs in a Fabry-Pérot cavity [21, 22]. This levels the illumination over the length of the waveguide (Fig. 1). The gold mirror also effectively sets the power leaving the end of the waveguide to 0, satisfying the second goal of our optimization. The difference between a waveguide's radial power leakage with and without a mirror is summarized in Figure 1. It confirms that with a single reflection the total scattered power is more evenly distributed along the waveguide. This leveling effect continues as the number of reflections in a Fabry-Pérot cavity increases. It is apparent that the leveling of the spatial distribution of the scattered light is proportional to the quality (Q) factor of the cavity. For a sufficiently-high Q-factor the average scattering function no longer depends on the distance from the source but only on local scattering from within the cavity such as surface roughness, bending, and internal defects. In our first experiment we treated transparent 3D printer grade filament obtained from BluMat PLA by heating the PLA causing water hydrolyzation of the polymer to increasing optical diffusion while wrapped in damp blotting paper in a microwave oven with varying time intervals. We then attached the treated PLA filaments to a laser light source and measured the scattering and absorption of the PLA filaments (Fig. 2(a)). To identify the source of the observed increased scattering (Fig. 2), we measured the change in surface roughness of the microwaved PLA via atomic force microscopy (AFM) and measured the change in Raman absorption spectrum of the PLA. The surface roughness was higher in the microwaved samples when compared to the control. The Raman spectrographs also showed an upward shift at the 875 cm-1 peak, indicating that both surface roughness and hydrolysis are contributing factors to the increased scattering. In our next (cid:9)(cid:9)s(x)=emx(cid:9)(cid:9)s(x)(cid:9)(cid:9)s(x)=0(cid:9)(cid:9)s(x)experiment we capped the end of the untreated BluMat PLA filament with several micrometers of gold deposited via electron beam deposition. The gold deposition was confined to a cap at the end of the PLA by masking all but the last millimeter of the PLA with Kapton tape. After deposition, we measured the optical scattering from the segments to compare them to PLA segments without gold caps (Fig. 3). Fitting the power decay resutls to eqn (6), we extrated a reflection ratio from the mirror to be approximately R = 0.7 In a final third illumination method we build on the cavity-power-leveling effect from the one-dimensional waveguide discussed above, and introduce a ring-resonator mesh as a means to evenly distribute light across a 2-dimensional area (Fig. 4) [24]. A long photon lifetime of a ring resonator results in an equalized spatial illumination over its surface similar to the leaky Fabry-Pérot cavity has an even distribution of light over its surface. The single round trip electric field, E1, becomes a function of the input field [23] , Ei, via (7) where the loss coefficient 𝛼𝑟 is for one round trip in the ring and denotes the change in phase as the wave travels around the circumference of the ring when . The total electric field, ET, is a sum of the contribution of the electric field from each pass around the ring. (8) This is a geometric series and for 𝛼 < 1, we can solve for the power at any cross section of the ring. (9) Assuming losses around the ring exponential decay with distance, we can restate 𝛼𝑟 as a function fractional distance along the ring. (10) where, as before, 𝜶 is the absorption coefficient and 𝝈 is the scattering coefficient. Averaging (10) over lengths greater than 𝜆 to allow 2 𝑒𝑗𝜃 = 1, we can state the irradiance of the ring in terms of material scattering and absorption coefficients. As with the leaky Fabry-Pérot cavity, we wish to show that increasing the quality factor decreases spatial variation of the irradiance. To demonstrate this, we restate the electric field offset by some angle 𝜙 around the resonator. (11) (12) The irradiance as a function of angle around the ring is a function of input power, and both the absorption and scattering coefficients leading to Eq. (13). (13) (cid:9)(cid:9)exp(jq)(cid:9)(cid:9)q=w2pr/cWith the aim to minimize the change in irradiance with respect to angle around the ring, towards flattening the irradiance across the ring, we rewrite (13) to become (14) With the total loss coefficient 𝛼𝑇 defined as 𝛼𝑇 = 𝛼 + 𝜎. We see that as the total loss coefficient 𝛼𝑇 approaches zero, the resulting variation of irradiance over the ring also approaches zero. As light travels around a ring resonator the contribution of scattering from any one interval around the ring becomes minimal and the ring glows evenly, independent of the location of the source. Extending this principle to an array of ring resonators, an entire mesh-like surface can be constructed with an equal scattering distribution provided that coupling losses are minimized. Since the ring Q is a function of both the waveguide width and bending radius, we next explore their influence on equalizing light distribution [24]. A larger bending radius results in a smaller bending loss and vise versa. This principal allows larger and smaller radius and waveguide width rings to be engineered into the mesh to quantitatively vary the illumination at specific locations within the mesh. In this manner if some cells of the scaffold require a higher dose while others require a lower dose, the scaffold itself can be designed to accommodate the cell-dependent variations in optical dose. To test such equalized light delivery using traveling waves in ring structures, we fabricate a set of four connected ring cavities towards demonstrating cavity-enhanced even spatial light distribution across millimeter areas using by laser cutting PLA film (Fig. 4). The rings are 2.5mm in diameter and formed from a 790μm width waveguide. Light is sourced into the four-ring mesh through a stem of 8.5mm length from a red laser. The biphasic dose response of cells to optical power in photobiomodulation highlights the necessity of illumination engineering in designing transparent, biocompatible tissue scaffolds. Here we model and demonstrate experimentally three optical methods for leveling the illumination in transparent tissue scaffold structures. While not exhaustive, these three methods: engineering scattering, placement of Fabry-Pérot cavities, and placement of ring resonators; form the underlying principles behind most passive illumination structures. While spatially equalized illumination is only one factor to consider in designing transparent tissue scaffolds, without it, photobiomodulation will be uneven in dose and the tissue scaffold will not reach its full potential. As such engineering optical nanostructures enable next generation devices for with applications in both biomedical treatments and opto-electronics [25-31] . Figures Fig. 1. Modeled irradiance (a) along a 10cm length of PLA without the mirror cap, circles, the contribution of the mirror cap, diamonds, and the total irradiance, crosses, with , R = 0.9, shows a leveling of the power distributed over the length of the waveguide in order to reach the optimal biphasic dose response (b), along the length of the fiber, schematic (c). (cid:9)(cid:9)a=10[m-1](cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(a) (a) (b) dose result (b) (a) (c) (aInput Light Reflected Light Scattered Light 1.75mm Gold Mirror PLA Waveguide (cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(c) (a) (d) σ (a) α (a) - α - σ (a) (e) seconds (a) (b) Fig. 2. PLA waveguide absorption ( ) and scattering ) loss test. (a) PLA waveguides were attached to a mini-laser and output power was recorded along with an image from above while the fiber was illuminated. (b) Raman shift of the waveguide prior to treatment (dotted line) and after treatment (solid line) at the 875cm-1 peak indicate hydrolysis. PLA waveguides were treated to incur water hydrolyzation of the polymer to increasing optical diffusion through microwave water vaporization. Two measurements of total losses (c) scattering (d) and absorption (e) calculated from curve fitting images and measuring the output power of 11 treated PLA waveguides shows increasing scattering with microwaving time. This light extinction control of these waveguides allows targeting the optimal dosage on the biphasic response curve of cells in biophotomodulation treatments. . Fig. 3. Light distribution effect from a leaky Fabry-Perot cavity. (a) The cavity is formed on surface-treated PLA fibers where one end is capped with a mirror (100 nm of gold). The mirror folds light back into the fiber, thus distributing the energy more evenly along the fiber. (b) Gold mirror cap. (c) Image of the illuminated PLA fiber with out gold mirror. (d) Image of the illuminated PLA fiber with gold mirror. (cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(b) (c) (a) (d) 1.75mm Fig. 4. A four-ring mesh fabricated from transparent 180μm thick PLA film shows leveling of the distribution of power over the surface of the structure (a). The intensity plotted with angle where the angle 0 is the left most point in each ring, shows an average 4.9dB variance in irradiance around each ring (b), limited by the rough edges of the laser cut PLA. References 1. E. Mester, B. Szende, and P. Gärtner, "The effect of laser beams on the growth of hair in mice," Radiobiol. Radiother. 9, 621 (1968). 2. K. M. AlGhamdi, A. Kumar, and N. A. Moussa, "Low-level laser therapy: a useful technique for enhancing the proliferation of various cultured cells," Lasers in Medical Science 27, 237-249 (2011). 3. A. Sommer, M. Haddad, and H. Fecht, "Light Effect on Water Viscosity: Implication for ATP Biosynthesis," SCIENTIFIC REPORTS 5, 12029 (2015). 4. Y. Huang, A. C. Chen, J. D. Carroll, and M. R. Hamblin, "Biphasic dose response in low level light therapy," Dose-response : a publication of International Hormesis Society 7, 358 (2009). 5. R. Langer and J. Vacanti, "Tissue engineering," Science 260, 920-926 (1993). 6. C. X. F. Lam, X. M. Mo, S. H. Teoh, and D. W. Hutmacher, "Scaffold development using 3D printing with a starch-based polymer," Materials Science and Engineering C 20, 49-56 (2002). (cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)(cid:9)1 2 3 4 (a) (b) 7. G. H. Altman, F. Diaz, C. Jakuba, T. Calabro, R. L. Horan, J. Chen, H. Lu, J. Richmond, and D. L. Kaplan, "Silk-based biomaterials," Biomaterials 24, 401-416 (2003). 8. U. Kim, J. Park, H. Joo Kim, M. Wada, and D. L. Kaplan, "Three-dimensional aqueous-derived biomaterial scaffolds from silk fibroin," Biomaterials 26, 2775-2785 (2005). 9. M. Choi, J. W. Choi, S. Kim, S. Nizamoglu, S. K. Hahn, and S. H. Yun, "Light-guiding hydrogels for cell- based sensing and optogenetic synthesis in vivo," Nature Photonics 7, 987-994 (2013). 10. R. F. Oulton, X. Zhang, D. A. Genov, V. J. Sorger, and D. F. P. Pile, "A hybrid plasmonic waveguide for subwavelength confinement and long-range propagation," Nature Photonics 2, 496-500 (2008). 11. V. J. Sorger, Z. Ye, R. F. Oulton, Y. Wang, G. Bartal, X. Yin, and X. Zhang, "Experimental demonstration of low-loss optical waveguiding at deep sub-wavelength scales," Nature communications 2, 331 (2011). 12. Z. Ma, M. H. Tahersima, S. Khan, and V. J. Sorger, "Two-Dimensional Material-Based Mode Confinement Engineering in Electro-Optic Modulators," IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics 23, 1-8 (2017). 13. P. O'Connor and J. Tauc, "Light scattering in optical waveguides," Appl. Opt. 17, 3226 (1978). 14. Z. Ma, Z. Li, K. Liu, C. Ye, and V. J. Sorger, "Indium-Tin-Oxide for High-performance Electro-optic Modulation," Nanophotonics 4, 198-213 (2015). 15. K. Liu, C. R. Ye, S. Khan, and V. J. Sorger, "Review and perspective on ultrafast wavelength-size electro- optic modulators," Laser & Photonics Reviews 9, 172-194 (2015). 16. C. Ye, S. Khan, Z. R. Li, E. Simsek, and V. J. Sorger, "λ-Size ITO and Graphene-Based Electro-Optic Modulators on SOI," IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics 20, 40-49 (2014). 17. A. Fratalocchi, C. Dodson, R. Zia, P. Genevet, E. Verhagen, H. Altug, and V. Sorger, "Nano-optics gets practical," NATURE NANOTECHNOLOGY 10, 11-15 (2015). 18. C. Huang, R. J. Lamond, S. K. Pickus, Z. R. Li, and V. J. Sorger, "A Sub- λ-Size Modulator Beyond the Efficiency-Loss Limit," IEEE Photonics Journal 5, 2202411-2202411 (2013). 19. H. Huang, K. Liu, B. Qi, and V. J. Sorger, "Re-Analysis of Single-Mode Conditions for Silicon Rib Waveguides at 1550 nm Wavelength," J. Lightwave Technol. 34, 3811-3817 (2016). 20. B. S. Ndazi, S. Karlsson, Polymerteknologi, Skolan för kemivetenskap (CHE), KTH, and Fiber- och polymerteknik, "Characterization of hydrolytic degradation of polylactic acid/rice hulls composites in water at different temperatures," Express Polymer Letters 5, 119-131 (2011). 21. V. J. Sorger, R. F. Oulton, J. Yao, G. Bartal, and X. Zhang, "Plasmonic Fabry-Pérot nanocavity," Nano letters 9, 3489 (2009). 22. K. Liu and V. Sorger, "Enhanced interaction strength for a square plasmon resonator embedded in a photonic crystal nanobeam cavity," JOURNAL OF NANOPHOTONICS 9, (2015). 23. D. G. Rabus, Integrated Ring Resonators: The Compendium (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2007). 24. R. T. Schermer and J. H. Cole, "Improved Bend Loss Formula Verified for Optical Fiber by Simulation and Experiment," IEEE J. Quant. Electron. 43, 899-909 (2007). 25. C. Ye, K. Liu, R. A. Soref, and V. J. Sorger, "A compact plasmonic MOS-based 2×2 electro-optic switch," Nanophotonics 4, 261-268 (2015). 26. K. Liu, N. Li, D. K. Sadana, and V. J. Sorger, "Integrated Nanocavity Plasmon Light Sources for On-Chip Optical Interconnects," ACS Photonics 3, 233-242 (2016). 27. N. Li, K. Liu, V. Sorger, and D. Sadana, "Monolithic III-V on Silicon Plasmonic Nanolaser Structure for Optical Interconnects," SCIENTIFIC REPORTS 5, 14067 (2015). 28. S. V. Boriskina, M. A. Green, K. Catchpole, E. Yablonovitch, M. C. Beard, Y. Okada, S. Lany, T. Gershon, A. Zakutayev, M. H. Tahersima, V. J. Sorger, M. J. Naughton, K. Kempa, M. Dagenais, Y. Yao, L. Xu, X. Sheng, N. D. Bronstein, J. A. Rogers, A. P. Alivisatos, R. G. Nuzzo, J. M. Gordon, D. M. Wu, M. D. Wisser, A. Salleo, J. Dionne, P. Bermel, J. Greffet, I. Celanovic, M. Soljacic, A. Manor, C. Rotschild, A. Raman, L. Zhu, S. Fan, and G. Chen, "Roadmap on optical energy conversion," Journal of Optics 18, 073004 (2016). 29. S. Sun, A. H. A. Badawy, V. Narayana, T. El-Ghazawi, and V. J. Sorger, "The Case for Hybrid Photonic Plasmonic Interconnects (HyPPIs): Low-Latency Energy-and-Area-Efficient On-Chip Interconnects," IEEE Photonics Journal 7, 1-14 (2015). 30. K. Liu and V. Sorger, "Electrically-driven carbon nanotube-based plasmonic laser on silicon," OPTICAL MATERIALS EXPRESS 5, 1910-1919 (2015). 31. K. Liu, C. Zhang, S. Mu, S. Wang, and V. J. Sorger, "Two-dimensional design and analysis of trench-coupler based Silicon Mach-Zehnder thermo-optic switch," Optics express 24, 15845 (2016).
1502.06416	1	1502	2015-02-23T13:25:52	Differential growth of wrinkled biofilms	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "nlin.AO", "nlin.CG", "q-bio.TO" ]	Biofilms are antibiotic-resistant bacterial aggregates that grow on moist surfaces and can trigger hospital-acquired infections. They provide a classical example in biology where the dynamics of cellular communities may be observed and studied. Gene expression regulates cell division and differentiation, which affect the biofilm architecture. Mechanical and chemical processes shape the resulting structure. We gain insight into the interplay between cellular and mechanical processes during biofilm development on air-agar interfaces by means of a hybrid model. Cellular behavior is governed by stochastic rules informed by a cascade of concentration fields for nutrients, waste and autoinducers. Cellular differentiation and death alter the structure and the mechanical properties of the biofilm, which is deformed according to Foppl-Von Karman equations informed by cellular processes and the interaction with the substratum. Stiffness gradients due to growth and swelling produce wrinkle branching. We are able to reproduce wrinkled structures often formed by biofilms on air-agar interfaces, as well as spatial distributions of differentiated cells commonly observed with B. subtilis.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Differential growth of wrinkled biofilms Centro Nacional de Biotecnolog´ıa, CSIC, Madrid 28049, Spain D. R. Espeso A. Carpio∗ Departamento de Matematica Aplicada, Universidad Complutense 28040, Madrid, Spain Center for Complex and Nonlinear Science, UC Santa Barbara, California 93106, USA (Dated: Feb 2015, published in Physical Review E 91, 022710 (2015)) B. Einarsson Biofilms are antibiotic-resistant bacterial aggregates that grow on moist surfaces and can trigger hospital-acquired infections. They provide a classical example in biology where the dynamics of cellular communities may be observed and studied. Gene expression regulates cell division and differentiation, which affect the biofilm architecture. Mechanical and chemical processes shape the resulting structure. We gain insight into the interplay between cellular and mechanical processes during biofilm development on air-agar interfaces by means of a hybrid model. Cellular behavior is governed by stochastic rules informed by a cascade of concentration fields for nutrients, waste and autoinducers. Cellular differentiation and death alter the structure and the mechanical properties of the biofilm, which is deformed according to Foppl-Von K´arm´an equations informed by cellular processes and the interaction with the substratum. Stiffness gradients due to growth and swelling produce wrinkle branching. We are able to reproduce wrinkled structures often formed by biofilms on air-agar interfaces, as well as spatial distributions of differentiated cells commonly observed with B. subtilis. PACS numbers: 87.10.Mn, 87.18.Hf, 87.18.Fx I. INTRODUCTION From bacterial communities to multicellular tissues, three dimensional biological structures emerge through poorly understood interactions between mechanical forces and cellular processes. Being apparently less com- plex than multicellular organisms, bacterial biofilms may provide model systems for analyzing the interplay be- tween cellular and mechanical features of three dimen- sional self-organization during growth. Biofilms are bacterial aggregates that form on moist surfaces and are sheltered from external aggressions by a self-produced extracellular matrix (ECM) made of exopolymeric substances (EPS) [1, 2]. This matrix makes them uncommonly resistant to antibiotics, disin- fectants, flows and other chemical or mechanical agents [3]. Biofilms are involved in chronic infections associ- ated to biomedical implants [4, 5] and in many industrial problems, such as biocorrosion, biofouling, efficiency re- duction in heat exchange systems and food poisoning [6 -- 8]. They are beneficial in bioremediation and biocontrol [9, 10] or in wastewater treatments [11]. Biofilm structure depends among other variables on the bacterial strain and the nutrient source, but is also influenced by environmental conditions. Biofilms grown in flows [12, 13] differ noticeably from biofilms expand- ing on air-solid or air-liquid interfaces not exposed to a shear force [14, 15]. These vary depending on the sur- ∗ Corresponding author: [email protected] face, as it is the case for Bacillus subtilis forming pellicles on air-fluid interfaces [16] or wrinkled films on agar [17]. Pattern formation is crucial to the development of biolog- ical systems. In cellular organisms, growth is a complex process implicating biochemical and physical mechanisms occurring at a variety of length and timescales [18]. On one side, genetic programs govern cellular processes, such as growth and differentiation. On the other, mechan- ical properties and physical forces induce macroscopic movements of cell populations and chemical compounds [17, 19]. Detailed models trying to describe biofilm evolu- tion on surfaces should take into account the interaction of these processes. Many models have been proposed for biofilm expan- sion in flows [20, 21], focussing typically on growth due to nutrient consumption. The standard geometry con- sists of a biofilm attached to a solid substratum sub- merged in a fluid. Growth is limited by diffusion of oxygen and nutrients from the surrounding flow into the biofilm. EPS production favors vertical spread, pushing cells into the flow to improve access to nutrients and oxy- gen [1, 22]. Depending on the nutrient and oxygen avail- ability, the bacterial strain and the hydrodynamic condi- tions, biofilms evolve to form a variety of patterns: mush- rooms, streamers, mounds, ripples and patchy shapes are observed [12, 13, 23, 24]. The volume fraction of EPS in these biofilms is large [13]. Some models view them as cells embedded in a fluid EPS matrix [25]. Experimen- tal observations and measurements suggest that biofilms behave as viscoelastic materials, i.e., exhibit elastic solid- like response to short time scale stimuli and viscous fluid- like response to long time scale stimuli [26]. Two-phase 5 1 0 2 b e F 3 2 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 6 1 4 6 0 . 2 0 5 1 : v i X r a flow models of biofilm spread in fluids [27] coexist with models that consider the growing biofilm an hyperelas- tic material [28]. The interplay of biofilm filaments with the flow, however, is described as interaction between an elastic structure and a fluid [29, 30]. These models rep- resent the microbial community as a continuum. To in- vestigate the influence of interactions at bacterium level, 'agent' based models have been developed. Bacteria are described as individuals whose behavior responds to ex- ternal continuum fields. Different modeling frameworks characterize individual bacteria in different ways. Cellu- lar automata [31 -- 33], cellular Potts [34] and individual- based [22, 25, 35] representations have been proposed for biofilms in flows. We will comment on the general ap- proaches in Section II. Basic mechanisms incorporated in them include biofilm expansion due to cell division, phenomenological descriptions of EPS production and biofilm erosion caused by the external flow. Biofilms grown in other environments show a differ- ent structure and undergo different processes. Under- standing their evolution requires different models, that must take into account the specific behavior of the se- lected bacterial strain. We consider here the develop- ment of B. subtilis biofilms on air-agar interfaces, for which detailed experimental evidence is becoming avail- able [14, 15, 17, 36, 37]. Recent observations reveal the role of cellular behavior and inner mechanical processes on the biofilm constitution. These biofilms extract nu- trients and water from the agar substratum itself. Cells are densely packed, glued together by a small volume fraction of extracellular substances [36]. The specific autoinducer sequence triggering EPS secretion has been identified [14]. EPS production favors water absorption and horizontal spread [36]. Localized cell death leads to mechanical stress relief through buckling [17]. Instead of networks of vertical mushrooms or filaments undulat- ing with the external flow, wrinkled films are observed [15, 17, 37]. Partial aspects of this picture have been modeled. Ref. [36] analyzes accelerated horizontal ex- pansion due to EPS production and swelling by means of thin film approximations calibrated to experiments. A reaction-diffusion model for the density of living cells combined with equations for the accumulation of EPS and waste provides understanding of the cell death pat- terns in Ref. [17]. We introduce here a hybrid framework that might be suitable to simulate the interplay between the mechanical and cellular processes identified so far. We couple a stochastic treatment of individual cellular activities with a continuum description of elastic defor- mations. To facilitate the coupling of stochastic cell di- vision, death, differentiation and swelling processes with macroscopic elastic deformations and the description of the complex interaction with the substratum, we have represented bacteria as cellular automata. Cells respond to a number of concentration fields (nutrients, waste, secreted substances), and are affected by water migra- tion processes and elastic deformations resulting of inner stresses due to growth, swelling and the interaction with 2 the substratum. Our numerical simulations suggest that the wrinkle branching observed in experiments may be the result of elastic deformations triggered by stiffness gradients. FIG. 1. (Color online) (a) B. subtilis biofilm grown on a 1.5% agar surface in a biofilm-inducing medium. Photograph taken after four days. Reprinted with the permission of Cambridge University Press from Chai L, Vlamakis H, Kolter R, MRS Bulletin, 36: 374-379 (2011), [14]. (b) In silico film showing a corona of radial wrinkles emerging from a central core. Typical wild type B. subtilis biofilms on agar show a central core with highly connected wrinkles surrounded by a corona with radial branches, as in Figure 1. Succes- sive branching is also reported, see Figure 2. These struc- tures differ from those commonly observed in biofilm pel- licles formed on air-liquid interfaces [16]. Such pellicles spread on a space confined by the walls of the vessel con- taining the liquid. Ref. [16] assumes an expression for the compression stresses and performs a stability analysis of the equilibria of a plate model, concluding that a buckling instability should appear above a threshold. The pres- ence of walls stresses the pellicles as they grow, produc- ing wrinkles. In contrast, the biofilms studied here spread on an air-agar interface with no boundaries around. The mechanism for wrinkle formation is bound to be differ- 3 of springs. On the other hand, neither energy nor linear stability approaches answer the question of how different patterns emerge and evolve from one to another. Here we aim to compute the development of wrinkled struc- tures as the biofilm expands horizontally, starting from an almost flat initial state. We will solve time depen- dent equations coupling the film to the substratum. The residual stresses will be computed numerically averaging information from growth and water absorption processes. This allows to observe how wrinkles develop and how they respond to localized variations in the microstruc- ture. We recall below some experimental observations to bear in mind in the sequel. During biofilm expansion, B. subtilis populations dif- ferentiate in several types in response to local environ- ments created by growth, waste production, nutrient con- sumption and cell-cell communication [14]. Cells produce a signaling molecule, ComX. When a threshold concen- tration is reached, a percentage of the population of cells expresses some genes that induce a change in their pheno- type, becoming surfactin producers. Surfactin may signal other cells (that do not make surfactin) to produce ex- tracellular matrix. As the biofilm thickens, starving cells in the top become inert spores. Initially, part of the cells are motile and express flag- ella allowing to swarm on the surface. As the production of ECM increases, most cells lose their individual motil- ity [14]. Flagella are downregulated and biofilm spread is influenced by ECM production [36]. In early stages of the biofilm evolution, dividing cells interact with their neighbors and push them. The biofilm becomes thicker and the edges spread slowly on the surface. Later in- crease in the exopolysaccharide concentration raises the osmotic pressure, causing swelling of the biofilm due to water intake from the agar gel [36]. Cells are pushed from the bulk outwards, speeding up horizontal growth and increasing nutrient intake from the agar surface. The origin of the wrinkles seems to be controlled by the mechanical properties of the biofilm, which are in part governed by the production of extracellular matrix. In early stages of the evolution of the central biofilm core, localized cell death takes place at high density re- gions due to biochemical stress. Cell death is usually followed by cell shrinkage and resorption. Lateral me- chanical stresses built up during growth are relieved at those sites through vertical biofilm buckling, leading to wrinkle formation [17]. Wrinkles are filled with water extracted from agar, as in Figure 3, forming a network of channels that enhances nutrient and waste transport driven by surface evaporation [37]. The emergence of the outer radial wrinkles shown in Fig. 1(a) or successive wrinkle branching in Fig. 2(a) is less understood. Recent developments in the study of the wrinkling of gels and thin films on viscoelastic substrata might have a counterpart in biofilm growth. A difference with cel- lular films though, is that there is no feedback between mechanical stresses, rates of swelling and growth and cel- lular differentiation. Swelling of the outer biofilm corona FIG. 2. (Color online) (a) B. subtilis biofilm grown on the air-solid surface of agar gel containing water and nutrients. Reprinted with the permission of Cambridge University Press from Wilking JN, Angelini TE, Seminara A, Brenner MP, Weitz DA, MRS Bulletin, 36: 385-391 (2011) [15]. (b) In silico film showing successive wrinkle branching. ent, even if elastic deformations are involved too. Ref. [38] uses a neo-Hookean energy to study the elastic de- formations of a growing circular film moderately adhered to a rigid substrate and subject to anisotropic growth. Tracking bifurcations in families of analytical solutions as the anisotropy degree increases, they predict the ap- pearance of contour undulations, delamination, buckling on the scale of the sample after delamination and, finally, a periodic distribution of folds. As Ref. [38] points out, such buckling patterns are not experimentally observed in B. subtilis biofilms. However, the analysis may be use- ful to understand delamination and folding phenomena. Those models do not consider the microscopic processes occurring in a biofilm. The complex interaction with the substratum is reduced to attachment using a collection might produce radial wrinkles provided the center of the biofilm was stiffer and swelled less than the corona. This "corona instability" is commonly observed in swelling gels when they are radially graded [39]. Such gels do not grow but swell by absorbing water while their elastic modulus diminishes. Contact of a film with a viscoelas- tic substratum may also induce wrinkles, and select the dynamics that form them [40, 41]. Wrinkle patterns that switch smoothly from an intricate core to branching ra- dial wrinkles have been observed in thin films on a vis- coelastic substratum due to solvent diffusion in the film, which creates residual stresses and stiffness gradients [42]. Based on the previous observations we propose a hy- brid biofilm description, combining a stochastic treat- ment of cellular processes coupled to the continuum con- centration fields and a continuum description of defor- mation mechanisms informed by cellular activities and the interaction with the substratum. Biofilm growth and physiology rely on the diffusion and transport of nutri- ents, waste, and signaling molecules, facilitated by wa- ter. The elastic deformation of the biofilm is described by Foppl-Von K´arm´an equations with residual stresses generated by growth and swelling [43 -- 45], formulated for a thin biofilm expanding on a substratum [40, 42] con- taining water and nutrients. We introduce a strategy to estimate residual stresses, as well as spatial variations in the elastic parameters of the biofilm, averaging and smoothing stochastic information on cell type distribu- tion, cell division and water absorption. We are able to reproduce qualitatively patterns and trends observed in experiments, gaining insight on the way biofilms are shaped. We argue that stiffness gradients due to growth and swelling may cause wrinkle branching and wrinkled coronae. We identify governing parameters and study their influence on the wrinkled structure. The substra- tum properties should be carefully measured since they largely affect the time scales for biofilm deformation. Variations in the values of its viscosity and Poisson ratio may change the wrinkling time scales from minutes to days, as argued in Section IV A. Experimental observa- tions show time variations too, compare Figures 1(a) in Refs. [14] and [37] after four and one days, respectively. The influence of the agar substratum on the dynamics of biofilms and bacterial communities has already been noticed in different contexts. Ref. [46] shows the rele- vance of the agarose concentration in the transition from planar to three dimensional behavior during the invasion of a three dimensional agar matrix by E. coli. Ref. [47] observes that the water content of the agar substratum affects the motility of Pseudomonas strains. Section II describes the basic structure of the hybrid model. Cellular processes are considered in Section III. Stochastic division, death, differentiation and EPS pro- duction mechanisms are introduced. Section IV discusses film deformation according to Foppl-Von K´arm´an equa- tions and presents water absorption strategies, together with procedures to estimate residual stresses and spatial variations in the elastic constants. The coupling between 4 stochastic and continuous descriptions is detailed in Sec- tion V. Simulations of biofilm evolution activating single or a few mechanisms are presented throughout the pa- per. Section VI explores the coupling between processes through a few selected tests. Finally, Section VII sum- marizes our conclusions. II. HYBRID MODEL To investigate the influence of processes at bacterium level, cells (or small clusters of similar cells) are repre- sented by discrete 'agents'. Different modeling frame- works describe those 'agents' and their evolution in di- verse ways. Cellular automata distribute them over the sites of a regular lattice [48]. The 'agents' have inter- nal state variables, that change according to a set of rules, stochastic or deterministic. Standard cellular au- tomata for biofilms in flows and in porous media allocate biomass (cells and EPS), fluids and solids over the lattice sites [32, 33]. The dynamics of the biomass in each tile is governed by rate equations coupled to concentrations and fluid equations. Whenever a threshold is surpassed, a neighboring tile is occupied, pushing biomass further in the direction of minimal mechanical resistance. Be- low a threshold, dead occurs with a certain probability. Biomass fragments can detach due to erosion by the flow. Refs. [33, 49] use this approach to predict local diffusion coefficients, permeability coefficients and Young modulus variations taking into account the microstructure. Cellular Potts approaches (in particular, the Glazier- Graner-Hogeweg variant) have been mostly applied to describe aggregation and migration of cells and tissue growth, see Ref. [50] for a review of applications. These models use energy based Monte-Carlo updating and are able to account for cell volume and shape. This is impor- tant when describing interactions strongly dependent on cell geometry [48]. Effective (not physical) energies typ- ically include terms representing contact between neigh- boring cells, a volume constraint on cells, plus chemo- taxis terms [50]. Liquids and other substances are rep- resented as additional cells. According to Ref. [48], the DAH (differential adhesion hypothesis) guarantees that final shapes correspond to the minima of effective ener- gies. This hypothesis assumes that an aggregate of cells behaves as a mixture of immiscible fluids [48]. Individual-based models developed for biofilms in aquatic media consider cells as particles (usually spheres) distributed in a three dimensional space, whose volume and mass grow due to nutrient consumption, see Refs. [35, 51] for a survey of applications. Cell division and death occur when specified size thresholds are reached. Daughter cells are distributed randomly and dead cells are removed. The EPS matrix may be represented as a fluid continuum, particulates and/or capsular EPS. Biomass is eroded according to a law depending on shear. Agent growth, division, death and shrinking cause agent movement, via shoving algorithms and a pressure field. 5 in the system is the diffusion produced by the presence of chemical concentration gradients of the chemical com- pounds (oxygen, nutrients, waste products and autoin- ducers) between the biofilm and the other phases (agar, water and air). Cellular processes inform inner mechan- ical stresses that shape the biofilm. We consider a B. subtilis biofilm patch (subdomain Ω3 in Figure 3(a)) attached to an agar-gel surface (subdo- main Ω1) and exposed to the atmosphere (subdomain Ω2). Eventually, the biofilm may contain channels car- rying water (subdomain Ω4) dragged from the agar sub- stratum, as in Figure 3(b). To perform their metabolic activities, the biofilm obtains nutrients and other sub- stances from the gel-water substratum, and from the at- mosphere. All the subdomains are divided in a grid of cubic tiles. The spatial step a chosen for this description was the size of one bacterium (around 3-5 µm) to be able to consider individual interactions among bacteria. Each tile can be filled with either agar, air, fluid or biofilm biomass (either cells or ECM). Partition in tiles allows to track the status of individual bacteria, which repre- sent a fraction of the total biomass, and discretize the equations governing the evolution of continuum fields. FIG. 4. (Color online) Flow chart of the hybrid model. The computational evolution of a biofilm in our model is schematized in Figure 4. First, we update the cellular status, detecting dividing, dead or differentiated cells and allocating newborn cells and water. Then we deform the biofilm according to its internal stresses and revise the concentration fields and the cellular status. The next sections describe how we take into account cellular be- havior and mechanical processes. FIG. 3. (Color online) Schematic representation of a biofilm. (a) Biofilm without water network, (b) Biofilm with water channels. For computational purposes, space is partitioned in a grid of tiles of size a, a being the average length of a bacterium. Each tile may be filled with air, water, agar, or biofilm biomass (either a bacterium or ECM). This grid is used to discretize the continuum concentration and displace- ment fields, and to track the status of individual bacteria, which constitute a fraction of the total biofilm biomass. Biomass is advected following a Darcy's law involving the pressure and the dynamic viscosity of the biofilm, which is therefore assimilated to a fluid [35]. To investigate the effect of the shape of bacteria on the alignment of mi- crobial communities expanding on a surface, rod-spring and sphere-spring representations have been recently im- plemented [51]. Each bacterial rod or sphere is charac- terized by its mass, velocity and position. The EPS ma- trix is represented by springs that join the rods together, and to the substratum. Cells divide when they reach a threshold mass due to nutrient consumption. New cells and springs must be created in the network. Then, the system relaxes to a new equilibrium following Newton's laws. A similar strategy is applied in Ref. [46] to describe the influence of the shape of bacteria in the invasion of a three dimensional agar matrix by E. coli. We are interested here in understanding the elastic de- formations caused by cell division, death, EPS produc- tion, swelling, and the interaction with the substratum. A framework facilitating the coupling of the relevant mi- croscopic and macroscopic phenomena is advisable. We resort to a cellular automata based hybrid description. Hybrid models combine stochastic representations of cel- lular processes with continuous descriptions of other rele- vant fields, in our case, concentrations and deformations. This allows to take into account the inherent randomness of individual bacterial behaviors observed in the exper- iments [14, 52]. It also permits to consider local inter- actions around each cell to describe differentiation pro- cesses. In this model, cells are regarded as creatures living in a grid, that reproduce, differentiate or die with certain probability, informed by the status of the concentration fields nearby. In a biofilm, cells are immersed in extracel- lular matrix. The dominating mass transport mechanism III. DESCRIPTION OF CELLULAR PROCESSES It is commonly accepted that biofilms are able to gen- erate molecular signals as cell-cell communication mech- anisms to activate gene expressions that unleash differ- ent survival strategies adapted to the environmental con- ditions [12, 14]. The basic approach relies on the idea that the same organism that is sensible to certain chem- ical inducers is also responsible of producing those com- pounds, creating a self-feeding loop which regulates both the genetic expression and the generation of autoinducer. Quorum sensing mechanisms provide a way for bacteria to count their population prior to unleashing different behaviors such as differentiation, virulence or spreading [53 -- 56]. Differentiation is a mechanism through which some bacteria inside a population display physiological alter- ations, developing different phenotypes without a change in their genotype. These modifications lead to the de- velopment of specialized cells with certain characteristics which perform specific tasks. 6 and generate ComX. They are sensible to all autoinduc- ers and may be deactivated due to a lack of nutrients or oxygen. They may turn into surfactin generators or cells expressing matrix genes when threshold concentrations of ComX or surfactin are reached. • Surfactin producers. They generate surfactin and do not reproduce. Proliferation of these cells may be inhib- ited by the presence of EPS producers in their neighbor- hood. • EPS matrix producers. They secrete EPS matrix, and are able to reproduce at lower rate than normal cells because their metabolism also spends resources on gen- erating EPS. • Inert cells, or spores. These cells do not perform any metabolic activities, neither reproduction, nor differen- tiation. EPS producers become spores when there is a severe lack of nutrients in the local environment of the cell. Spores may activate again when the environmental conditions improve. As time progresses, a fraction of cells expresses surfactin genes. Later on, an increasing number of cells secretes EPS matrix. Cells may also die as a result of biochem- ical stresses [17]. This has been shown to occur at the interface agar-biofilm as a result of biochemical stresses at localized high density regions. Eventually, sporulation starts and few normal cells remain. Spores are usually located in upper regions of the biofilm, whereas normal cells are restricted to the bottom edges [14]. We describe below the rules for cell differentiation, death and reproduction. A. Cellular division, deactivation and death When there is an excess of oxygen, the concentration of nutrients cn becomes the limiting concentration that restricts biofilm growth inside the biofilm Ω3: cn,t − Dn,b∆cn = −kn cn cn + Kn . (1) Nutrient uptake is simply described by a Monod law. Inside the agar substratum Ω1: FIG. 5. (Color online) Directional signaling in B. subtilis. When a threshold concentration of ComX is reached, a per- centage of the population of cells expresses genes that induce a change in their phenotype, becoming surfactin producers. Surfactin may signal other cells to produce extracellular ma- trix. Starving cells become inert spores. cn,t − Dn,a∆cn = 0. In the water phase Ω4 (if present): cn,t − Dn,l∆cn + v · ∇cn = 0. (2) (3) Differentiation processes have been observed to depend on the local conditions around each cell, in particular, the state of the neighbours and the local chemical composi- tion found around them [52, 57]. B. subtilis provides a well known example, where initial biofilm cells may differ- entiate in four well defined cell types. Two autoinducers, ComX and surfactin, relate the four types of differenti- ated cells [14], see Figure 5. The different cell types are: • Normal cells. They perform all metabolic activities Here, Dn,b, Dn,a and Dn,l are diffusion constants in the biofilm, agar and water, respectively, Kn is the Monod half-saturation coefficient, and kn(x) is the uptake rate of the nutrient at the particular location. It will be set equal to kn in tiles occupied by alive cells and equal to zero elsewhere. v is the transport velocity in the water chan- nels. On the interfaces agar-biofilm and water-biofilm (if present) we impose transmission boundary conditions (continuity of concentrations and fluxes). On the inter- face biofilm-air, the interface agar-air and the edges of the agar substratum, we have zero flux conditions. Ini- tially, the nutrient concentration is usually taken to be constant cn = C in agar. Tiles occupied by alive cells C are assumed to divide with probability [31]: Pd(C) = cn(C) , cn(C) + Kn cn being the limiting concentration. Initially, we real- locate newborn cells inside biofilm by pushing existing cells in the direction of minimum mechanical resistance, that is, the shortest distance to the biofilm-air interface [31, 33]. (4) Figure 6 illustrates the expansion of a biofilm seed. The initial round cluster grows in size in a radial way. Brick-like colonies are formed. Their border may advance in a wavy way depending on the velocity, as usual when a free boundary expands outwards [58]. This spread mech- anism may change as the biofilm develops and water is absorbed, as explained later. FIG. 6. (Color online) Expansion of a circular biofilm seed driven only by nutrient consumption. The initial seed is formed by two layers of cells with a diameter of 40 cells. Only division and spread mechanisms are involved. Snapshots taken every 100 steps. The initial nutrient concentration in the substratum is C = 3Kn and the ratio kna2 DnKn = 8. The constants Kn affecting the probability laws are numeric constants that should be calibrated with experi- mental data to have a real description in the simulations and do not have to match with saturation constants used in the source terms of the reaction-diffusion equations for the concentrations, which are related with a chemical sat- uration limit. To simplify, they have been chosen to agree with the values for saturation constants. 7 Cells may suffer a shortage of nutrients, triggering a sporulation mechanism to preserve bacteria in a "deacti- vated" state until the environmental conditions improve. To reflect this, cells with a local limiting concentration below a certain threshold will become spores in our simu- lations. We deactivate cells C with probability 1 − Pd(C) whenever Pd(C) < γd for a certain threshold γd > 0. These cells may activate again when the conditions im- prove. As mentioned before, cells may also die due to bio- chemical stress in high density regions where waste prod- ucts and toxins accumulate but nutrients deplete. Taking for instance the concentration of waste cw at a location as an indicator of death, a cell C is scheduled to die with probability: Pw(C) = cw(C) cw(C) + Kw , (5) whenever Pw(C) > γw for a certain threshold γw > 0. The concentration of waste is governed by cw,t − Dw,b∆cw = kw δi,w, (6) i inside the biofilm Ω3. δi,w(x) equals 1 in regions occupied by alive cells Ci and vanishes otherwise. On agar-biofilm and air-biofilm interfaces we impose no flux boundary conditions. If a fluid phase Ω4 is present, we impose transmission boundary conditions at the interface and include a diffusion-convection equation similar to Eq. (3) for waste transport in the liquid. Dw,b, Dw,l are the diffusion constants, and kw the production rate of waste and toxins at the particular location. B. Surfactin and EPS production (cid:88) (cid:18) (cid:19)(cid:88) Normal cells may turn into surfactin generators when a threshold concentration of ComX is reached. ComX is a molecule related with quorum sensing mechanisms in B. subtilis [14]. It is produced by all the cells in the biofilm, except those which are not metabolically active. The concentration ccx of ComX inside the biofilm Ω3 is governed by: ccx,t − Dcx,b∆ccx = kcx 1 − ccx ccx + Kcx i δi,cx, (7) with no flux boundary condition on agar-biofilm and air- biofilm interfaces. kcx is the production rate, and Dcx,b the diffusivity. δi,cx(x) equals 1 if cell Ci produces ComX and vanishes otherwise. kcx is multiplied by an inhibition factor for large concentrations. A guess for Kcx may be the half-saturation constant of ComX. If a liquid phase Ω4 is present we impose transmission boundary condi- tions at the interface and include a convection-diffusion equation similar to Eq. (3) for ComX transport in the liquid. Normal cells C are assumed to become surfactin producers with probability: 8 Ps(C) = ccx(C) ccx(C) + Kcx (8) whenever Ps(C) > γs. The threshold γs reflects that dif- ferentiation should start when a minimum background concentration of ComX is reached. , ccx ccx+Kcx When EPS producers are present, they act as in- hibitors. We may set Ps = Pinhib with Pinhib the ratio of neighbors producing EPS to total number of neighbors. If a cell is surrounded by EPS producers, there is no any chance of differentiation into a surfactin generator. A similar effect is obtained setting a much lower threshold for differentiation into a surfactin pro- ducer compared to EPS producers, as we usually do in our simulations. Surfactin acts as an autoinducer in normal bacteria, changing their phenotype to become EPS producers [36]. The concentration cs of surfactin inside the biofilm is governed by: cs,t − Ds,b∆cs = ks 1 − cs cs + Ks δi,s, (9) (cid:18) (cid:19)(cid:88) i with no flux boundary condition on agar-biofilm and air- biofilm interfaces. ks is the production rate, Ds,b the dif- fusivity and Ks the half-saturation of surfactin. δi,s(x) equals 1 if cell Ci produces surfactin and vanishes oth- erwise. When a liquid phase Ω4 is present transmis- sion boundary conditions hold at the interface and a convection-diffusion equation similar to Eq. (3) governs surfactin transport in the liquid. We assume that ac- tive cells C not secreting surfactin become EPS producers with probability: (cid:19)(cid:18) cs(C) (cid:19) cs(C) + Ks , (10) (cid:18) Pe(C) = 1 − cn(C) cn(C) + Kn cs(C) cs(C)+Ks > γe1 , which means that a minimum whenever concentration of surfactin is required. The probability increases with the availability of surfactin and the scarce- ness of nutrients. This is consistent with measurements reported in Ref. If we want to enforce a level of nutrient depletion to allow differentiation into EPS pro- ducers we may further impose < γe2. This may forbid differentiation below a certain height. cn(C)+Kn cn(C) [59]. Figure 7 illustrates the distribution of cells when we ac- tivate the differentiation processes, in combination with standard growth and spread. As the size of the biofilm increases, the concentration of ComX raises until the threshold γs is reached. At this point bacteria start to differentiate and secrete surfactin. This triggers differ- entiation of cells into EPS producers when the surfactin threshold γe1 is reached. As the number of EPS cells increases, the rate of differentiation into surfactin gen- erators stabilizes and may even decay due to an inhibi- tion mechanism induced by the EPS cells [14]. Relative proportions for each type of cell were adjusted by fitting FIG. 7. (Color online) Slices of a biofilm showing the cell type distribution during early stages of the differentiation process. All the slices correspond to the same biofilm and are taken at the same time. The evolution started from an initial seed with a diameter of 60 cells and variable thickness, represented by three small peaks. Dead cells appear first where the initial peaks where located. In later stages, inert cells proliferate at the top whereas normal cells are restricted to the bottom and the edges. Each colored box is one cell. Parameter values: = 0.01, C = Kn, ksa2 DsKs 0.00001,γe2 = 0.2. = 0.8, γw = 0.005, γd = 0.00001, γs = 0.001, γe1 = kcxa2 DcxKcx kw a2 Dw Kw kna2 DnKn = 0.001, = 0.01, parameters, but there should be an experimental calibra- tion to improve these values. Normal cells are found in the edges and near the interface biofilm-agar. EPS pro- ducers appear once surfactin is generated and a certain thickness is reached so that the nutrient concentration depletes. Dead cells concentrate on the bottom surface at inhomogeneity peaks when the initial seed has variable height, due to higher waste concentration. As the biofilm increases its thickness, scarcity of nutrients is felt in the upper part due to the high resistance to mass transfer across the increasing thickness. This effect induces the appearance of spores in the upper part, slowing down the growth of the biofilm. The geometric distribution of each type of cell seems to follow qualitatively trends reported in Refs. [14, 17, 59]. Implementing the differentiation strategy described above requires measuring a number of kinetic constants for different concentrations. Since these values are cur- rently unknown, we have scaled the parameters to obtain the expected behaviors in small clusters of cells, lower- ing the computational cost. For Gram negative Vibrio harveyi, quorum sensing processes triggering biolumines- cence have been modeled in terms of feedback loops [56] and applying information theory to the quorum sensing circuit [60], which may reduce the number of parameters involved. Signaling parameters have been deduced from in vivo data for V. harveyi [61]. For simplicity, the biofilm in Figure 7 does not include the ECM phase, only cells. We might include it following the procedure described below. Once EPS production starts, a new concentration ce diffuses in the environ- ment: ce,t − De,b∆ce = ke 1 − ce ce + Ke δi,e. (11) (cid:18) (cid:19)(cid:88) i ke is the production rate, De,b the diffusivity and Ke the half-saturation of EPS. δi,e(x) equals 1 if cell Ci is an EPS producer and vanishes otherwise. Initially, these sub- stances are just compounds diffusing in the environment. As the concentration increases they become a polymeric envelop for the cells. This description can be improved taking into account the presence of molecules of different size. Monomers diffuse, but longer molecules stay where they are produced. The concentration of momoners is governed by a diffusion equation coupled to the concen- tration of larger molecules, whereas the latter is governed by rate equations, that substitute Eq. (11). Images in Ref. The volume fraction of biofilm occupied by extracel- lular substances varies largely depending on the type of biofilm. [13] show biofilms in flows, formed by scattered cells embedded in a dominant EPS phase. On the contrary, imaging biofilms on air-semisolid interfaces at hight resolution shows a structure of densely packed cells glued by EPS, see references [36], [14] and [17]. Space is mostly occupied by cells. This suggests skipping the creation of an EPS phase and thinking of it as a virtual glue that keeps cells together and modifies the mechanical properties of the biofilm, in particular, its elastic constants and the osmotic pressure. If we choose to create an EPS phase, we may exploit the concentra- tion ce of EPS to generate new biofilm tiles filled with it. At any tile, we set Pm(C) = ce(C) ce(C) + Ke . (12) If this value is larger that a threshold γm, we create an EPS tile at that location and shift biomass around in the direction of least mechanical resistance. γm should be calibrated so that the fractions of biomass corresponding to cells and EPS fit the experimental observations. The true cells are a fraction of the total amount of tiles occu- pied by biomass. They divide and differentiate according to the same probabilistic rules we have already described. 9 Individual-based models for biofilms on agar surfaces represent the EPS as springs joining the cells [51]. For biofilms in flows, expressing larger fractions of EPS, each 'individual' contains cellular mass and capsular EPS, that vary according to user defined rate equations. Ad- ditional EPS particulates may be created as EPS pro- duction increases following user defined rules [35]. Refs. [22, 62] study EPS dynamics in a quorum sensing frame- work, defining competing strains: EPS producers, EPS non producers, strains that downregulate EPS produc- tion for large cell densities. This is not the reported quo- rum sensing circuit for B. subtilis, see Ref. [14]. Cellu- lar automata models for biofilms in flows distribute cel- lular mass and EPS in each lattice site following phe- nomenological rate equations [32, 33]. Spread to neigh- boring sites occurs as a threshold mass is surpassed. In both frameworks, cells are scheduled to die when their mass or volume falls below a threshold. No memory of their former presence, relevant for elastic deformations, is kept. Neither the relevance of waste accumulation for cell death, pointed out in Ref. [17], nor the currently known quorum sensing circuits for EPS production are incorporated in those models. Dynamic energy budget descriptions of cell dynamics [63] might provide a sophis- phicated framework to describe the evolution of individ- ual cells taking into account their mass, volume, mainte- nance, substance secretion and the presence of nutrients, oxygen and toxicants. However, extensions to biofilms are yet to be devised. C. Nondimensionalization of the concentration equations Nondimensionalization of the equations for the con- centrations listed above reveals a key governing param- eter for each concentration: F = ka2 , where k is the KDb uptake or production rate, a the bacterium size, K the half-saturation constant and Db the diffusivity inside the biofilm. Setting c = c a , the equations for concentrations become: K and x = x − ∆xc = F f , (13) (cid:16) c (cid:17) c + 1 inside the biofilm, where f represents the production or consumption terms, and (14) − ∆xc + v · ∇xc = 0, in the water channels, where v = v a . We have sup- D(cid:96) pressed the time dependence because diffusion of chemi- cal species is faster than the cellular processes considered. For each biofilm configuration, we solve these nondimen- sionalized stationary equations with the corresponding boundary conditions by a relaxation technique. Then we compute all the probabilities for division, death and differentiation, detect the different types of cells and allo- cate newborn cells. This generates a new biofilm config- uration for which the procedure is repeated. A complete reproductive cycle of a bacterium was set as the basic time step for the cellular processes in the model (which is typically in the order of 26-45 minutes depending on nutrient and temperature). This choice implies that our system is discrete in space and time [31]. IV. DESCRIPTION OF MECHANICAL PROCESSES Differentiated cells produce chemicals, which may in- duce further differentiation of other cells or trigger me- chanical processes that alter the biofilm structure, im- proving its chances of spread and survival. EPS produc- tion increases the stiffness of the biofilm [17], which may be identified with a material undergoing macroscopic de- formations caused by growth [16] over a substratum. The spatial distribution of dead and inert cells, together with water absorption, may induce additional stiffness gradi- ents. This motivates allowing our biofilm to move along the tiles according to microscopically informed contin- uum descriptions of the underlying mechanical processes. A. Out-of-plane deformations and wrinkle formation Due to the interaction of components in the extracellu- lar matrix, dissipative phenomena take place inside soft tissues during deformation processes and the mechani- cal response of tissues if often viscoelastic. Nevertheless, growth induced deformations on time scales much larger than those of relaxation may be regarded as purely elas- tic [45]. Since the height of real biofilms is about 10-100 times smaller than their radius and they are initially thin and flat, we may use Foppl-von K´arm´an [43] equations for thin elastic plates to study their elastic deformation reducing dimensionality [16]. Residual stresses due to growth are incorporated in the description in terms of the growth tensor, see Refs. [44, 45]. The shape of the body is then determined by both growth and elastic de- formation. The equilibrium deformation of a growing tis- sue is described by a variant of the Foppl-Von K´arm´an equations [45]: D(∆2ξ − ∆CM ) − h ∂ ∂xβ σα,β (cid:18) (cid:19) ∂ξ ∂xα ∂σα,β ∂xβ = P, (15) = 0, (16) 10 (cid:19) (cid:18) ∂uα ∂xβ growth term. The components of the tensor g are the growth rates, that is, the rate of volume supply per unit volume. Defining consistently a growth tensor g is a non trivial issue. A possibility is to set g = ∇w [64], w being the vector field of displacement of growing biomass in the biofilm w, which is determined by the cellular division and spread mechanism and water absorption processes. Stresses σ and strains ε are defined in terms of in-plane displacements u = (ux, uy) [39, 45] by: εα,β = 1 2 + ∂uβ ∂xα + ∂ξ ∂xα ∂ξ ∂xβ + ε0 α,β, (17) σxx = E 1 − ν2 (εxx + νεyy), σxy = E 1 + ν εxy, (18) σyy = E 1 − ν2 (εyy + νεxx). The Poisson ratio of different tissues has been measured to be about 0.49999 [65]. We will set the Poisson ratio of the biofilm ν = 1 2 (incompressibility) [45]. The average elastic modulus E of a wild type B. subtilis biofilm has been measured to be about 25 kP a [17]. When the resid- ual strains ε0 α,β are due to growth, they are expressed in terms of the growth tensor as: α,β = − 1 ε0 2 (gαβ + gβα + gzαgzβ) . (19) A growing biofilm is in a state of compression due to cell division and, eventually, water absorption. Alternatively, this may be represented by a residual strain α,β(x, t) = −ε0(x, t)δα,β, ε0 ε0 > 0. (20) If we assume that cells do not grow at expense of their neighbors, δα,β is a diagonal unit tensor in polar coordi- nates in a circular film. For a biofilm growing on a surface no external loads act on the edges, therefore, P = 0. However, the interaction with the surface affects the deformation process and has to be included in the description. A correction to Eqs. (15)-(16) applicable to thin elastic films growing on a viscoelastic substratum is proposed in Ref. [40]: (cid:34) D(−∆2ξ + ∆CM ) (cid:19)(cid:35) ∂ξ ∂t = 1 − 2νv 2(1 − νv) hv ηv (cid:18) + h ∂ ∂xβ σα,β(u) ∂ξ ∂xα ∇ · σ(u) − µv ηv u, ∂u ∂t = hvh ηv − µv ηv ξ, (21) (22) where α, β stand for x, y and summation over repeated indexes is intended. The first equation describes out-of- plane bending ξ(x, y) and the second one in-plane stretch- ing for the displacements u = (ux(x, y), uy(x, y)). (x, y) vary along the 2D projection of the 3D biofilm structure. The bending stiffness is D = Eh3 12(1−ν2) , and h the initial plate height. P is the external pressure at the border of the sample. CM = ∂(gzx+gxz) is a residual + ∂(gzy+gyz) ∂x ∂y where hv is the thickness of the viscoelastic substratum and µv, νv, ηv its rubbery modulus, Poisson ratio, and viscosity, respectively. The equilibrium equations describe possible equilib- rium configurations, and yield information on their sta- bility or changes of stability. To describe the dynam- ics of wrinkle formation and the finally selected pattern we must solve the time dependent equations. Equations (21)-(22) were derived for the interface between the thin film and the substratum. This interface moves vertically following the displacement field ξ. This shifts all the tiles in the three dimensional biofilm-substratum system ver- tically. Choosing new dimensionless variables: 11 x = x L , u = u L , ξ = ξ h , σ = σ E , t = t T , and setting L = γh, the dimensionless equations read: (cid:34) ∂ ξ ∂t = 12(1 − ν2)γ2 ∂ ∂ xβ + (−∆2 x ξ + ∆x CM ) (cid:33) ∂ ξ ∂ xα (cid:32) (cid:35) σα,β(u) − T µv ηv ξ, ∂ u ∂t = τ ∇x · σ(u) − T µv ηv u, with T = 12(1 − ν2)γ4 2(1 − νv) ηvh 1 − 2νv hv E (1 − νv) (1 − ν2)γ2. (1 − 2νv) τ = 24 (23) (24) (25) , We set L equal to the maximum averaged radius of the biofilm in study. Common experimental values for the parameters defining the spatial scales are h ∼ 100µm, hv ∼ 100h. The size of the biofilm may vary with the nutrients and the agar gel nature. Figure 1(a) in Ref. [14] shows a wrinkled biofilm with L ∼ 50h grown in four days on a 1.5% agar surface. Figure 1 (a) in Ref. [37] reproduces wrinkled biofilms with L ∼ 50h within one day. u and T µv ηv The linear terms T µv ηv ξ are just damping contributions from the substratum slowing down the evo- lution. We will neglect them in our preliminary stud- ies. Wrinkling behavior is observed when the coefficient 12(1 − ν2)γ2 is large enough, so that the contribution of nonlinear effects and residual stresses in Eq. (23) be- comes relevant and drives the plate out of the flat equi- librium state, see Figure 8. The factor τ in Eq. (24) separates the time scales for the evolution of u and ξ. The closer to 0.5 the Poisson ratio νv is, the larger this separation is. The in-plane dis- placements u may reach a quasistatic situation in which their evolution is driven by slower changes in the resid- ual stresses created by growth, swelling, and off-plane displacements. The constitutive parameters for an agar gel may vary depending on the agar source, its content of agar and other products, in particular, water. When an hydro- gel is fully swollen, its mechanical behavior is similar to those of rubber-like materials [66], which have a Poisson ratio of about 0.5. For some agar gelatines the Young modulus is measured to be 0.4999, with an elastic mod- ulus about 27 kPa [65]. In other agar gels these numbers FIG. 8. (Color online) Connected network of wrinkles switch- ing from an intricate core to radial branches, formed in a ho- mogeneous circular film when a circular front of residual com- pression stresses of magnitude ε0 = 0.1 expands at constant velocity. Parameter values: ν = 0.5, E = 25 kP a, νv = 0.45, µv = 0 and γ = 16. dx = 0.1 h, where h is the film thickness before wrinkling. go down to νv = 0.32 with an elastic modulus Ev = 52 kPa [67]. This modulus increases with the agar concen- tration from ∼ 30 kPa in 0.5% samples up to 700 kPa in 5% samples. The viscosity ηv of agar gels is reported in the range of 100 cp = 0.1 Pa·s for 1.5% samples, see Ref. [68]. As the agarose concentration increases to 8%, the viscosity raises to 1− 1.5 Pa·s [69]. These values increase as the temperature diminishes. According to Ref. [69], no measurements can be obtained below 36o C. Standard experiments are carried out at room temperature, usu- ally below that threshold. Effective values for viscosities in a MPa·s range are adjusted in Ref. [70]. A large variability in the time scales may arise due to uncertainty in the experimental values of νv and ηv. Setting for instance νv = 0.4999, ηv = 0.1 Pa·s, we find T ∼ 31 hours. This value varies enormously depending on νv, that changes with the water content. Switching to νv = 0.45 and ηv = 1 Pa·s, we find T ∼ 2480 s ∼ 40 m. The time scale scale for u is T (cid:48) = T τ ranges from 10−3 s in the first case to 10−2 s in the second one. If ηv enters the range of kPa·s or MPa·s, this value increases by a factor 103 − 106. B. Water absorption and water channels As mentioned earlier, variations in the osmotic pres- In Ref. sure extract water from the agar substratum. [36], a macroscopic model for water migration from the agar substratum into the biofilm is proposed in terms of the volume fractions of water and biofilm at each lo- cation. The biofilm is formed by cells and extracellular matrix, which is often considered a gel with ability to swell. As observed in Ref. [37], flat regions of the biofilm are very resistant to flow. Water cannot be driven inside without fracturing the biofilm or delaminating it from the substratum. By contrast, water flows beneath the wrinkles, forming an intricate network of channels [37]. Wrinkles origin in the core of the biofilm associated with dead areas [17]. Water flows along the channels driven 12 by surface evaporation [37]. These observations suggest a strategy to incorporate water into our biofilm description. Water absorption by the biofilm increases the volume of the cells and the EPS phase. Enlarging the size of the tiles to reflect that fact is unpractical. We resort instead to inserting water tiles in the biofilm, representing water absorption by the biomass. In that way, the biofilm contains a volume frac- tion of adsorbed water that changes its volume. A low cost strategy, easy to implement in our hybrid framework is the following. As in Ref. [36], we propose for the os- motic pressure a law of the form π = Πφ, but replacing the volume fraction φ of biomass by our information of the biomass available at biofilm columns π = Π N Nmax , (26) where N is the number of tiles occupied by biomass in a column and Nmax is the total number of tiles in the column, including water. Water tiles are created with probability: Pl(C) = π(C) , π(C) + E(C) (27) where E(C) is the Young modulus at tile C and the height of the columns in Eq. (26) is updated as we create wa- ter tiles. The status of neighboring tiles is shifted in the direction of minimal mechanical resistance, except when water occupies a dead cell. More water will be absorbed in the columns containing a larger fraction of biomass, and in softer regions. Scattered inner tiles do not consti- tute a separate phase, but are considered to be part of the swollen biomass. We compute E(C) modulating the measured reference value of the Young modulus of the biofilm with an av- erage of weights representing status of the neighboring tiles. Weights range from zero for water, a small posi- tive value for dead cells, a larger value for normal cells, up to one for EPS producers. Alive cells attached to the substratum contribute much larger weights than the rest. E(C) will be small wherever we have dead cells. As Fig- ure 9 shows, those regions fill with water in successive steps, becoming a water phase that expands following the wrinkles. Combining water transport through those channels, with the cellular processes described in Section III, we see that cell death due to waste accumulation is reduced and the colony is able to expand in a sustained way. In early stages we do not allow newborn cells into this water phase due to the pressure gradients that drift water from the agar gel into the biofilm. As the water content of the agar gel diminishes we might allow cell expansion around the channels, as observed in Ref. [37]. This would keep water inside the biofilm. In Figure 9, we have distributed dead cells above the substratum, in the wrinkled regions. The value of Π is chosen small enough to avoid water proliferation inside the biofilm, about E/20. These simple probability laws produce compression residual stresses that vary with the FIG. 9. (Color online) (a) Biofilm-substratum system de- formed following out-of-plane displacements ξ predicted by Eqs. (21)-(22) for residual stresses expanding as a radial com- pression front. (b) Bottom slice of (a) displaying the arrange- ment of biofilm and substratum. (c) Intemediate slice of (a) showing the allocation of dead cells. (d) and (e) Accumula- tion of absorbed water in slice (c) triggered by the presence of weakened dead areas after 1 and 40 steps of the water ab- sorption process, respectively. biofilm height, as shown in Figure 10, where Π = E/3. Values in the range Π ∼ E are suggested in Ref. [15]. A time scale for water absorption processes may be inferred from the analysis in Ref. [36], where a thin film description of biofilm spread due to swelling and growth is proposed. For radial biofilms and small departures from osmotic balance, a similarity approximation for the height h and the radius R of the biofilm yields a time scale 1/q for the spread process, where q is the rate of biomass production. We cannot directly couple the model in Ref. [36] to a cellular automata description of cell division, death and differentiation to describe biofilm spread due to swelling. The main reason is that it already includes a source rep- resenting growth. An alternative model of fluid transport in the biofilm would be necessary for a better description of the water absorption process and biofilm spread in our framework. Once water channels have been carved in the biofilm, we might couple our cellular automata description to the hydrodynamics of the flow as done for biofilms in porous media [33]. This assumes that the deformation of the biomass and the extracellular fluid flow can be computed in a sequential manner, which happens when the biomass behaves as an elastic material or the flow induced de- formation of the biomass matrix is negligible [71]. Us- ing order-of-magnitude analysis, Ref. [72] establishes do- mains of validity of different models for liquid transport in a fluid-solid system depending on the volume fraction and viscosity of the fluid, the volume fraction, elastic con- stants and density of the solid, the hydraulic permeability of the system, the characteristic times for displacement of the solid, and the characteristic macroscopic length of the system. C. Growth tensor and elastic constants The components of the tensor g entering Eqs. (23)-(24) are the growth rates, that is, the rate of volume supply per unit volume. New tiles may add to our biofilm due to cell division, EPS creation or water adsorption. Wher- ever they are created, they shift another tile in the direc- tion of minimal mechanical resistance. The growth ten- sor at each grid location (ix, iy, iz) is computed by keep- ing track of all the new tiles inserted and the direction in which their predecessors where shifted. We define a vector w = (w1(ix, iy, iz), w2(ix, iy, iz), w3(ix, iy, iz))a. w1(ix, iy, iz) is determined by cumulatively adding ±1 for each tile shifted in the x direction in the positive or negative sense, respectively. w2 and w3 are evaluated in a similar way, along the y and z directions. The final vector is normalized to have norm a. Then, we com- pute ∇w, where the derivatives are approximated by fi- nite differences that use the known grid values. To es- timate g(ix, iy) we consider all the contributions from ∇w(ix, iy, iz) for varying iz. The resulting tensor usually presents abrupt oscilla- tions due to stochasticity, constrained motion along a restricted set of directions in a cubic grid and varying biofilm thickness. Such oscillations in the grid scale may destabilize numerical solutions of Eq. (23). Averaging and smoothing these tensors to avoid numerical instabil- ities, we obtain residual stresses that serve as a basis for the numerical tests, see Figure 10. Averaging rapidly os- cillating coefficients and sources is a standard practice to study macroscopic deformations of materials. The reference Young modulus of the biofilm is esti- mated from experimental measurements [17]. The knowl- edge of its microstructure gained from our simulations al- lows to introduce spatial modulations. At each location, we may regulate the reference value multiplying it by the sum of weights describing the status of its neighboring tiles, as we did in section IV B. A possible qualitative choice for those weights are zero for air, a small fraction 13 FIG. 10. (Color online) Residual stresses ε0 xx for the biofilm seeds depicted in (a), (b) and (c). (d), (e) and (f) represent their values after one step of the stochastic division and spread process, with C = 2Kn and kna2 = 0.01. Spatial variations DnKn related to thickness are identifiable in (g), (h), (i), obtained averaging a few trials of the stochastic procedure. These fields approach their average values (about −0.1). A single trial already gives the average value used in rough approximations by constants. (j), (k), and (l) show the effect of including dead spots in the biofilm seed. Localized depressions are observed. (m), (n), (o) reproduce the residual stresses generated by the water absorption scheme when Π = E/3. The average values are about −0.2. ε0 xy is about 3-2 times smaller. xx in all cases. ε0 yy resembles ε0 of one for dead cells, a larger fraction for normal cells and one for cells producing EPS. The biofilm becomes softer where it swells easily. In this way, we obtain spa- tially dependent elastic moduli that allow to investigate variations in the macroscopic deformation of the biofilm in response to changes in its microstructure. V. COUPLING OF CELLULAR AND MECHANICAL PROCESSES The interaction between the previous descriptions of cellular and mechanical processes is visualized in Figure 4. The scheme below details a practical implementation. 1. Initialization. A matrix is created to indicate the status of the tiles in the computational grid of step a. At first, we usually set S(ix, iy, iz) = 2 in the regions occupied by a biofilm seed, assuming that it is formed by undifferentiated cells stuck together. As tiles (ix, iy, iz) are filled with differentiated cells, EPS or water in the next steps, S will take different positive integer values. Sections occupied by air or substratum correspond to zero or negative values. This grid is used to keep track of cellular processes and also to discretize continuum equations. As the biofilm enlarges, we might resort to a coarser grid for the latter purpose. Initially, the concentration of nutrients is set equal to a constant C in the sub- stratum and zero elsewhere. The concentrations of waste, ComX, surfactin and EPS are set equal to zero everywhere. 2. Cellular processes. (a) Concentration update. The concentrations of nutrients, waste and ComX are evaluated solving Eqs. (1)-(3), (6) and (7) with the specified bound- ary and initial conditions. Whenever surfactin or EPS producers are present, Eqs. (9) and (11) are solved too. All the equations are nondimensional- ized as indicated in expressions (13)-(14). The so- lutions of the time dependent diffusion problems for these chemicals relax to their stationary states in a short time, compared to the typical time scales for cellular processes. Explicit finite difference schemes provide a low cost approximation to the stationary concentrations after a number of steps. Those ap- proximations are stored and used in the next stages to evaluate behavioral probabilities. (b) Probabilities for cell activities. They are only computed at tiles (ix, iy, iz) occupied by cells. Cells that are not already dead are killed with probabil- ity Pw whenever the concentration of waste sur- passes a threshold γw. We evaluate expression (5) and generate a random number r ∈ [0, 1]. If max(r, γw) < Pw, we kill the cell. Alive cells de- activate with probability 1 − Pd, Pd given by for- mula (4), as long as the nutrient concentration is low enough. Active cells become surfactin produc- ers with probability Ps defined in formula (8) if the concentration of ComX surpasses a threshold. Ac- tive cells not releasing surfactin become EPS pro- ducers with probability Pe given by formula (10) when a minimum surfactin level is reached and the nutrient concentration is depleted. 14 (c) Cellular division and spread. Active cells not secreting surfactin divide with probability Pd. The newborn cells are placed in neighboring tiles in the direction of minimal mechanical resistance. In early stages, this may be taken to be the shortest dis- tance to the biofilm-air interface. (d) EPS phase. Accumulation of EPS may prompt the creation of an EPS phase according to Eq. (12). (e) Growth tensor and elastic parameters. As EPS production increases, the biofilm acquires consis- tency. We have used in our simulations average measured values of the Young modulus. Informa- tion on the spatial distribution of different types of cells allows to spatially modulate that value. Com- puting the out-of-plane deformations in the next stage requires the previous derivation of a growth tensor from the biomass growth process. This is done as indicated in subsection IV C. 3. Mechanical processes. (a) Water absorption and water phase. EPS pro- duction changes the osmotic pressure and prompts water migration from the substratum towards the biofilm. Water absorption by the biomass may be accounted for by means of formula (27). Dead zones near the surface will easily fill with water, which may expand along the wrinkles between the biomass and the substratum. A water phase is cre- ated. As the volume fraction of water increases and water channels develop, a description of liquid flow in the system might be necessary. (b) Growth tensor and elastic parameters. Infor- mation on the spatial distribution of absorbed wa- ter allows to spatially modulate the average Young modulus, decreasing it in swollen regions. The growth tensor is updated to reflect the volume sup- ply due to water absorption. This is done as indi- cated in subsection IV C. (c) Out-of-plane displacements. Vertical displace- ments due to internal stresses are estimated solving Eqs. (21)-(22). The equations are nondimension- alized following Eqs. (23)-(24). Basic explicit dif- ference schemes provide low cost approximations. Alternatively, faster spectral methods may be used [40, 42]. As the biofilm becomes more heteroge- nous we might need to solve a three dimensional elasticity problem or include lower order terms in the Von-K´arm´an equations. (d) Biofilm deformation. Tiles (ix, iy, iz) at the interface biofilm-substratum are shifted vertically a number of tiles equal to the integer part of ξ(ix, iy)/a, pushing their neighbors in the three di- mensional biofilm. This is done shifting the status of such tiles in the matrix S(ix, iy, iz). Relative status of neighbors in the vertical direction is pre- served. 4. Iteration. The biofilm evolution is calculated al- ternating the computation of cellular processes up to a time tC (estimated from the doubling time), with steps of the water absorption processes in a time scale tW ∼ tC (estimated from biomass pro- duction) and steps of the deformation processes in a time scale tD (which requires precise measurements of the substratum parameters). Summarizing, the mechanical processes change the ge- ometry of the biofilm. The equations for the differ- ent concentrations must be solved in the new geometry, which affects the cellular processes altering the probabili- ties for the different behaviors. The cellular processes al- ter the elastic parameters and the pressure in the biofilm, contributing residual stresses for its deformation due to growth, death and fluid migration. VI. SIMULATION RESULTS Series of simulations were performed to illustrate the behavior of the model and its limitations, choosing sin- gle mechanisms or combinations of a few of them. The results show wrinkled patterns and cell distributions in qualitative agreement with recent experimental observa- tions. They provide insight on the influence of parame- ters, cellular activities and mechanical processes on the biofilm shape and structure. Basic growth and spread mechanisms do not produce wrinkled shapes. Even if we activate water absorption processes, the biofilm will spread faster, but no wrinkles appear. When elastic deformation mechanisms are incor- porated, wrinkles begin to form. We revisit the simula- tion described in Figure 7 for the same parameter values and a similar initial biofilm seed containing five peaks, see Figure 11(a). During the third step of the growth, spread and differentiation processes, EPS producers ap- pear. At the fourth step, we consider that enough matrix has been produced to regard the biofilm as an elastic film with Young modulus E. During the 10-th step, dead cells appear at the bottom of the initial peaks. Dead areas ex- pand during the 11-th step. In the 12-th step, growth in the central region has slowed down due to depleted nu- trient levels and increased waste presence. Figures 11(b)-(f) illustrate the spatial structure of the corresponding growth tensor. Initial peaks diffuse as the biofilm grows and become depressions when dead cells ap- pear. Once growth in the core is depleted, compression is higher in the border regions. A randomly perturbed ini- tial biofilm deforms according to Eqs. (23)-(24) generat- ing small wrinkles that coarsen as time evolves. Figures 11(g)-(k) represent the out-of-plane deformation of the film at selected steps of the growth, spread and differen- tiation processes. After each step, the average radius of the biofilm increases about one cell. The deformation of the biofilm is then calculated for a time τ 24 s. As wrin- kles develop, the growth processes must be implemented 15 FIG. 11. (Color online) (a) Initial biofilm seed. (b), (c), (d), (e), (f) Residual stresses ε0 xx averaged after 100 trials of the stochastic processes at steps 4, 8, 10, 11, 12. The average compression is −0.132, −0.1425, −0.146, −0.1437, −0.124. yy has a similar structure and average. ε0 respectively. ε0 xy takes smaller values and is neglected. (g), (h), (i), (j), (k) Vertical displacements. The height mark dx corresponds to one cell. Parameter values are γ = 8, ν = 0.5, E = 25 kP a, νv = 0.45 and µv = 0. in biofilms with a wavy bottom, contributing additional spatial variations to the growth tensor (higher compres- sion in the valleys, lower compression in the peaks). Unless we activate the water absorption mechanism, as in Figure 9, a necrotic region will develop in the biofilm core. Water absorption facilitates nutrient diffusion and waste removal, maintaining the cell normal functions. In the computations, we have approximated the resid- ual stresses ε0 yy by their constant average, mod- ified by peaks or depressions that represent increased or xx and ε0 decreased compression in certain areas. More accurate smooth approximations can be automatically produced using denoising strategies borrowed from image process- ing [73]. As time evolves, singularities may develop due to the presence of 'hanging' cells in the border. Such cells are poorly connected to the rest of the biofilm. This ar- tifact is solved by discarding such cells when computing deformations. For the selected parameter values, biofilms are roundish. Therefore, we may alternatively smooth the biofilm border using the averaged support obtained when averaging trials of the stochastic processes to iden- tify spatial variations of the growth tensor. Wavy borders like the ones observed in Figure 6 are usually found for large values of kna2 . This number depends on the nutri- DnKn ent source and the bacterial strain, but tends to be small ( << 1) in practice. What causes the successive wrinkle branching and the radial branching observed in Figures 1(a) and 2(a)? As we have noticed, EPS production gives the cellular ag- gregate a certain cohesion. As shown by Figures 10 and 11, an expanding biofilm is under compression due to cell division, EPS production and water absorption. The de- velopment of wrinkles in Figure 11 is limited by size con- siderations. The radius of the biofilm increases from 60 to 80 cells, it thickness is about 10 cells and γ = 8. Dou- bling the biofilms maximum radius, and consequently γ, it appears that a simple round compression front expand- ing at a certain speed may produce wrinkle branching, structured differently depending on the front speed and the compression magnitude. Motivated by previous observations, the residual stresses ε0(x, t) are assumed to behave like a radial front ε0(r−vt) expanding at a certain speed v, r being the dis- tance to the seed center. This allows to lower the compu- tational cost. Figures 2(b) and 8 are generated deforming circular biofilm seeds according to Eqs. (23)-(24) for such residual stresses. The evolution starts from a configura- tion with small random vertical displacements. Figure 8 takes ε0(r) = −0.1 constant in the central region. Then, it decreases sharply. The front advances one tile every 14/τ s. Figure 12 shows the time evolution of the wrin- kled area. Small wrinkles similar to those in Figure 11 form that coarsen as shown in those images. Figure 8 is a three dimensional view of the two dimensional projection depicted in Figure 12(d). The biofilm contains scattered dead spots where the residual stresses decrease by a cer- tain factor, affecting the way wrinkles nucleate. Once the wrinkled area attains a certain extension, the height of the wrinkles decreases unless we vary the compression magnitude. If we wish to increase the wrinkle branching rate, while maintaining or enhancing their height as the wrinkled region expands, the magnitude of the compres- sion has to increase radially. Figure 2(b) was computed raising the speed to one tile every 1.4/τ s and increasing the compression magnitude by r/80 as the radius of the compressed region grows. When the compression front expands too slowly, rings may form around the wrinkled area. If it expands too fast, we may see different types 16 τ , 560 T τ , 1120 T FIG. 12. (Color online) Snapshots of the formation of wrin- kles for ε0 = 0.1. (a), (b), (c), (d) images taken at times 280 T τ , 840 T τ . An initial random state coarsens to produce a connected wrinkle network that opens up into radial branches as the compressed region spreads. The biofilm has Poisson ratio ν = 0.5 and Young modulus E = 25 kP a. The Poisson ratio and rubbery modulus of the substratum are νv = 0.45 and µv = 0. T and τ are defined in Eq. (25). The ratio of the in-plane spatial scale to the out-of-plane spatial scale is set to γ = 16. The equations are nondimensionalized so that the dimensionless biofilm thickness becomes h = 1. τ dx2. The spatial step is dx = 0.1h. The time step is dt = 0.14 of geometric shapes. In between, the network of wrinkles opens up radially as it expands. The outer branches are connected to the inner network and interact with it. So far, we have discussed branching of wrinkles. What produces the wrinkled corona in Figure 1(a)? A sud- den stop of an advancing compression front may arrange branching wrinkles in a corona type structure temporar- ily. The whole network changes its structure later. A uni- formly compressed film whose elastic modulus decreases in an outer corona develops stable radial wrinkles, as in Figure 1(b). The Young modulus E has been decreased by a factor 0.5 in the outer corona. Radial residual com- pression of constant magnitude −0.1 is applied every- where, for the same parameter values as in Figures 8 and 12. Now, there is no advancing front. The biofilm boundary remains fixed and the residual stresses are con- stant everywhere. Radial decrease of the Young modulus might be due to larger water absorption rates in the outer regions, presumably softer, due to the larger presence of normal cells. Too sharp a decrease in the elastic modulus, for the se- lected parameters, combined with smaller values of Pois- son's ratio, may result in fast coarsening and disappear- ance of the central wrinkles, as in Figure 13(a). The compression factor is kept constant in a central core but increases radially in an outer corona. The inner network of wrinkles vanishes with time, but a corona of increas- ing radial wrinkles is formed. Both the Young modulus E and the Poisson ratio ν affect the time scales. Wrinkles coarsen faster in regions with higher Young modulus or lower Poisson ratio. Central wrinkles, however, are an- chored by the presence of a couple of dead spots in Fig- ure 13(b). Decreasing the Poisson ratio enhances height. Lowering the Poisson's ratio to 0.3, the outer wrinkles not only maintain their heights, but also may increase it for increasing radial compression. Unlike Figure 1(b) or Figure 8, a radially increasing compression factor ε0 pro- duces an inner network of wrinkles that opens up form- ing branches whose height can be kept uniform over the biofilm, see Figure 13(c). Notice also that γ is decreased by a half. Radial increase of the compression might be due to larger growth rates in the outer regions caused by increasing availability of nutrients. VII. CONCLUSIONS Replicating cell populations create three dimensional organisms of diverse shapes. Elucidating how those dif- ferent geometries arise is an intriguing question that has motivated many theories. Small cellular systems, such as bacterial biofilms, seem to develop from the interplay be- tween cellular and mechanical processes. Studying the in- teraction of those two mechanisms from an experimental point of view requires concurrent measurement of both processes, posing a major challenge. Developing mathe- matical and computational frameworks able to incorpo- rate the increasing amount of experimental observations in their governing rules may provide insight on the feed- back between microscopic cell behavior and macroscopic continuum processes. We have proposed a hybrid model to describe the growth dynamics of a small cluster of biofilm on an air-agar interface. We are able to trans- fer information from a stochastic description of cellular processes into a continuum model for the deformation of the film, and use these deformations as a feedback for the cell activities. We have shown that mechanical processes change the geometry of the biofilm. The rele- vant concentrations must be computed in a new geome- try. This fact influences the cellular processes, modifying the probabilities for the cell behaviors. In turn, the cel- lular processes modulate the elastic parameters and the pressure in the biofilm, and generate residual stresses due to death, growth, and fluid migration. This microscopic feedback determines the subsequent mechanical processes and so on. We have observed that the properties of the substratum together with the mechanical properties of the biofilm and residual stresses due to death, growth and swelling seem to control wrinkled biofilm shapes. Our in silico biofilms agree qualitatively with some ex- perimental observations, in the sense that their shape and the spatial distribution of the different types of dif- ferentiated cells is similar. Biomass, air, water and agar distribute through the tiles of a computational grid. We confer tiles occupied by alive cells the ability to change 17 FIG. 13. (Color online) Wrinkled structures obtained vary- ing the residual stresses and the elastic moduli for a smaller film with lower Poisson's ratio. (a) Transition from a harder central region with larger Young modulus to a softer outer corona: radial branches in the corona are separated from the core by rings. (b) Uniform residual compression in the cen- tral region with localized sinks due to dead spots plus radially increasing compression in the outer corona: small wrinkles an- chored by the dead spots in the center merge with larger ra- dial wrinkles in the outer corona. (c) Residual compression in- creasing slowly with distance to the center: labyrinths formed in the center become radial branches in the outer corona. Pa- rameter values: Same as previous figures except ν = 0.3 and γ = 8. dx is the spatial step. their status according to probability laws informed by a cascade of concentration fields: nutrients, waste, ComX and surfactin. Local inhomogeneities trigger cell death at the bottom of biofilm peaks. Nutrient depletion deacti- vates cells at the top. When a threshold level of ComX is reached, surfactin producers appear. When a threshold level of surfactin is achieved, EPS producers proliferate. Once EPS release activates, we consider the biofilm an elastic film, whose elastic parameters are modulated by its microstructure. We also launch a mechanism for wa- ter absorption triggered by variations in osmotic pressure caused by EPS production. Weighting at each biofilm lo- cation the average values of elastic moduli taken from experiments according to the status of the neighboring tiles, we may produce spatially varying parameters tak- ing into account the microstructure. The biofilm weak- ens due to the presence dead cells. It also softens in swollen regions, due to water absorption. Biofilm expan- sion is quantified by means of a growth tensor computed from the stochastic growth, death and water absorption processes. In this way, we estimate the residual stresses caused by these mechanisms. The compression residual stresses and the spatially varying moduli used in the nu- merical tests presented here are motivated by those com- putations. We study biofilm deformation in response to those stresses by means of a Foppl-Von K´arm´an approx- imation, obtaining intricate wrinkled cores that split in radial branches. Water erodes the regions were cells die, expanding along the wrinkles. This improves transport of waste and nutrients, hindering cell death and favoring growth. 18 outer corona, also enhance the outer radial wrinkles. Quantitative comparison with experiments should re- quire careful calibration of several parameters, in par- ticular, regarding substratum properties and heuristic probability laws. Substratum parameters such as its Poisson ratio, thickness, viscosity and rubbery modulus should be accurately measured since they affect the time scales for the biofilm dynamics. Uptake rates, produc- tion rates, saturation constants and diffusivities of the involved chemical compounds should be determined too, since they influence the extend of growth, death and dif- ferentiation processes. As the biofilm thickens and its spatial heterogeneity increases, the Foppl-Von K´arm´an approximation should likely be replaced by a fully three dimensional elasticity model. The spread mechanism and the dynamics of water in the system should be revised too. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Our simulations show that wrinkling seems to be as- sociated with stiffness fluctuations. Variations in inner residual stresses and elastic constants due to growth, swelling and death seem to govern wrinkle nucleation and branching. Compression stresses expanding radially due to swelling and growth produce wrinkled cores that split in radial wrinkles. The presence of dead regions alters the way the core wrinkles are nucleated. It also favors wrinkle formation and persistence around dead areas as the compression rate is reduced or time increases. Suc- cessive wrinkle branching may occur depending on the expansion velocity. Radially graded compression stresses may enhance the outer radial wrinkles. Spatially depen- dent elastic moduli, harder at the center and softer in the A. Carpio and D.R. Espeso thank M.P. Brenner for hospitality while visiting Harvard University. D. R. Es- peso and A. Carpio were supported by Comunidad de Madrid and the spanish MICINN through grants No. S2009/DPI-1572, No. FIS2011-28838-C02-02 and No. FIS2010-22438-E. A. Carpio was also supported by a mo- bility grant of Fundaci´on Caja Madrid. B. Einarsson was supported by the NILS Mobility project (European eco- nomic area-EEA grant) and MICINN grant No. FIS2008- 04921-C02-01. Part of the computations of this work were performed in EOLO, the HPC of Climate Change of the International Campus of Excellence of Moncloa, funded by MECD and MICINN. This is a contribution to CEI Moncloa. [1] R.D. Monds and G.A. O'Toole, Trends Microbiol. 17, 73 [12] B. Purevdorj, J.W. Costerton and P. Stoodley, Appl. En- (2009). viron. Microbiol. 68, 4457 (2002). [2] H.C. Flemming and J. Wingender, Nature Rev. Micro- [13] K. Drescher, Y. Shen, B.L. Bassler and H.A. Stone, Proc. biol. 8, 623 (2010). Nat. Acad. Sc. 110, 4345 (2013). [3] N. Hoiby, T. Bjarnsholt, M. Givskov, S. Molin and O. [14] L. Chai, H. Vlamakis and R. Kolter, MRS Bulletin 36, Ciofu, Int. J. Antimicrob. Agents 35, 322 (2010). 374 (2011). [4] J.W. Costerton, P.S. Stewart and E.P. Greenberg, Sci- [15] J.N. Wilking, T.E. Angelini, A. Seminara, M.P. Brenner ence 284, 1318 (1999). [5] R.O. Darouiche, Clin. Infect. Dis. 33, 1567 (2001). [6] C.C. de Carvalho, Recent Pat. Biotechnol. 1, 49 (2007). [7] E. Eguia, A. Trueba, B. Ro-Calonge, A. Giron, C. Bielva, Int. Biodeter. Biodeg. 62, 79 (2008). [8] Y. Xiong, Y. Liu, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 86, 825 (2010). [9] R. Singh, D. Paul and R.K. Jain, Trends Microbiol. 14, 389 (2006). [10] B. Schachter, Nature Biotechnol. 21, 361 (2003). [11] S. Wuertz, P.L. Bishop and P.A. Wilderer, Biofilms in wastewater treatment: An interdisciplinary approach (IWA Publishing, 2003). and D.A. Weitz, MRS Bulletin 36, 38 (2011). [16] M. Trejo, C. Douarche, V. Bailleux, C. Poulard, S. Mar- iot, C. Regeard and E. Raspaud, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sc. 110, 2011 (2013). [17] M. Asally, M. Kittisopikul, P. Ru´e, Y. Du, Z. Hu, T. C¸ agatay, A.B. Robinson, H. Lu, J. Garcia-Ojalvo and G.M. Suel, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sc. 109, 18891 (2012). [18] E. Coen, A.G. Rolland-Lagan, M. Matthews, J.A. Bang- ham and P. Prusinkiewicz, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 101, 4728 (2004). [19] T. Mammoto and D.E. Ingber, Development 137, 1407 (2010). [20] O. Wanner, H. Eberl, E. Morgenroth, D. Noguera, C. Picioreanu, B. Rittmann, and M.C.M. van Loosdrecht, 19 Mathematical modeling of biofilms (IWA Publishing, Lon- don UK, 2006). [21] I. Klapper and J. Dockery, SIAM Rev. 52, 221 (2011). [22] J.B. Xavier and K.R. Foster, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sc. 104, 876 (2007). [23] J.B. Xavier, E. Martinez-Garcia, and K.R. Foster, The American Naturalist 174, 1 (2009). cations, Computation, and Finance, 2003, The IMA Vol- umes in Mathematics and its Applications, Vol. 134, p.1. [49] C.S. Laspidou, L.A. Spyrou, N. Aravas and B.E. Rittmann, Math. Biosci. 251, 11 (2014). [50] M.H. Swat, G.L. Thomas, J.M. Belmonte, A. Shirinifard, D. Hmeljak and J.A. Glazier, Methods Cell Biol. 110, 325 (2012). [24] D. Rodriguez, B. Einarsson and A. Carpio, Phys. Rev. E [51] T. Storck, C. Picioreanu, B. Virdis and D.J. Batstone, 86, 061914 (2012). Biophys. J. 106, 2037 (2014). [25] E. Alpkvist, C. Picioreanu, M.C.M. Loosdrecht and A. [52] P. Mehta, R. Mukhopadhyay and N.S. Wingreen, Phys. Heyden, Biotechnol. Bioeng. 94, 961 (2006). Biol. 5, 026005 (2008). [26] T. Shaw, M. Winston, C.J. Rupp, I. Klapper and P. [53] W.C. Fuqua, S.C. Winans and E.P. Greenberg, J. Bac- Stoodley, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 098102 (2004). teriol. 176, 269 (1994). [27] N.G. Cogan and R.D. Guy, HFSP J. 4, 11 (2010). [28] H.J. Dupin and P.K. Kitanidis, P.L. McCarty, Water Res. 37, 2965 (2001). [29] D. Taherzadeh, C. Picioreanu, U. Kuttler, A. Simone, W.A. Wall and H. Horn, Biotech. Bioeng. 105, 600 (2009). [30] N. Autrusson, L. Guglielmini, S. Lecuyer, R. Rusconi, and H.A. Stone, Phys. Fluids 23, 063602 (2011). [31] S.W. Hermanowicz, Math. Biosci. 169, 1 (2001). [32] C.S. Laspidou and B.E. Rittmann, Water Res. 38, 3349 [54] B.A. Hense, C. Kuttler, J. Muller, M. Rothballer, A. Hartmann and J.U. Kreft, Nature Rev. Microbiol. 5, 231 (2007). [55] T. Long, K.C. Tu, Y. Wang, P. Mehta, N.P. Ong, B.L. Bassler and N.S. Wingreen, PLOS Biol. 7, e1000068 (2009). [56] S.W. Teng, J.N. Schaffer, K.C. Tu, P. Mehta, W. Lu, N.P. Ong, B.L. Bassler and N.S. Wingreen, Mol. Syst. Biol. 7, 491 (2011). [57] P.S. Stewart and M.J. Franklin, Nature Rev. Microbiol. (2004). [33] G.E. Kapellos, T.S. Alexiou and A.C. Payatakes, Adv. Water Resour. 30, 1648 (2007). [34] N.J. Poplawski, A. Shirinifard, S. Macie and J.A. Glazier, Math. Biosc. Eng. 5, 355 (2008). [35] L.A. Lardon, B.V. Merkey, S. Martins, A. Dotsch, C. Pi- cioreanu, J.U. Kreft and B.F. Smets, Environ. Microbiol. 13, 2416 (2011). [36] A. Seminara, T.E. Angelini, J.N. Wilking, H. Vlamakis, S. Ebrahim, R. Kolter, D.A. Weitz and M.P. Brenner, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sc. 109, 1116 (2012). [37] J.N. Wilking, V. Zaburdaev, M. De Volder, R. Losick, M.P. Brenner and D.A. Weitz, Proc. Nac. Acad. Sc. 110, 848 (2013). [38] M. Ben Amar and M. Wu, EPL 108, 38003 (2014). [39] T. Mora and A. Boudaoud, Eur. Phys. J. E 20, 119 6, 199 (2008). [58] T.Y. Hou, Acta Numerica 4, 335 (1995). [59] W. Zhang, A. Seminara, M. Suaris, M.P. Brenner, D.A. Weitz and T.E. Angelini, New J. Phys. 16, 015028 (2014). [60] P. Mehta, S. Goyal, T. Long, B.L. Bassler and N.S. Wingreen, Mol. Syst. Biol. 5, 325 (2009). [61] L.R. Swem, D.L. Swem, N.S. Wingreen and B.L. Bassler, Cell 134, 461 (2008). [62] C.D. Nadell, J.B. Xavier, S.A. Levin and K.R. Foster, PLOS Biol. 6, e14 (2008). [63] M. Hendrata and B. Birnir, Phys. Rev. E 81, 061902 (2010). [64] Z. Hejnowicz and J.A. Romberger, J. Theor. Biol. 110, 93 (1984). [65] T. Glozman, H. Azhari, J. Ultrasound Med. 29, 387 (2006). (2010). [40] R. Huang and S.H. Im, Phys. Rev. E 74, 026214 (2006). [41] Z. Liu, S. Swaddiwudhipongc and W. Hongd, Soft Matter 9, 577 (2013). [66] K.S. Anseth, C.N. Bowman and L Brannon-Peppas, Bio- materials 17, 1647 (1996). [67] K.A. Ross and M.G. Scanlon, J. Texture Stud. 30, 17 [42] Y. Ni, D. Yang and L. He, Phys. Rev. E 86, 031604 (1999). (2012). [68] S. Istini, M. Ohno and H. Kusunose, Bull. Mar. Sci. Fish. [43] L.D. Landau and E.M. Lifschitz, Theory of elasticity Kochi Univ. 14, 49 (1994). (Pergamon Press, 1986). [44] J. Dervaux and M. Ben Amar, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 068101 (2008). [69] E. Fernandez, D. Lopez, C. Mijangos, M. Duskova- Smrckova, M. Ilavsky and K. Duseck, J. Polym Sci: Part B: Polym. Phys. 46, 322 (2008). [45] J. Dervaux, P. Ciarletta and M. Ben Amar, J. Mech. [70] M. Ahearne, Y. Yang, A.J. El Haj, K. Then and K.K. Phys. Solids 57, 458 (2009). Liu, J. R. Soc. Interface 2, 455 (2005). [46] M.A.A. Grant, B. Waclaw, R.J. Allen and P. Cicuta, J.R. [71] G.E. Kapellos, T.S. Alexiou and A.C. Payatakes, Math. Soc. Interface 11, 20140400 (2014). Biosci. 225, 83 (2010). [47] A. Dechesne, G. Wang, G. Gulez, D. Or and B.F. Smets, [72] G.E. Kapellos, T.S. Alexiou and A.C. Payatakes, Int. J. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sc. 107, 14369 (2010). Eng. Sc. 51, 241 (2012). [48] M.S. Alber, M.A. Kiskowski, J.A. Glazier and Y. Jiang, in Mathematical Systems Theory in Biology, Communi- [73] A. Torres, A. Marquina, J.A. Font, J.M. Ib´anez, Phys. Rev. D 90, 084029 (2014).
1204.4361	2	1204	2012-05-17T12:33:55	Super-sensitive Molecule-hugging Graphene Nanopores	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "physics.ins-det" ]	Longitudinal resolution and lateral sensitivity are decisive characteristics that determine the suitability of a nanopore sensor for sequencing a strand of DNA as well as other important polymers. Previous modeling of DNA induced ionic current blockades in single atom thick graphene nanopores has shown these nanopores to have sufficient longitudinal resolution to distinguish individual nucleobases along the length of a DNA molecule. Here we experimentally focus on the sensitivity to small changes in DNA diameter that can be discerned with graphene nanopores. We show that remarkably large sensitivities (0.5 nA/A)are obtained when the nanopore is tailored to have a diameter close to that of the polymer of interest. Our results have been obtained with double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). Smaller graphene nanopores that can be tuned to the diameter of single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) for sequencing have only recently been demonstrated. Our results indicate that nanopore sensors based on such pores will provide excellent resolution and base discrimination, and will be robust competitors to protein nanopores that have recently demonstrated sequencing capability.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Super-sensitive Molecule-hugging Graphene Nanopores Slaven Garaj1, Song Liu1,2, Daniel Branton3, and Jene A. Golovchenko1,4* 1Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge Massachusetts, 02138, USA 2Department of Physics, Peking University, Beijing 100871, P.R. China 3Department of Molecular and Cellular Biology, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 02138, USA 4School of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 02138, USA *Corresponding author, email: [email protected] 1 Longitudinal resolution and lateral sensitivity are decisive characteristics that determine the suitability of a nanopore sensor for sequencing a strand of DNA as well as other important polymers. Previous modeling of DNA induced ionic current blockades in single atom thick graphene nanopores has shown these nanopores to have sufficient longitudinal resolution to distinguish individual nucleobases along the length of a DNA molecule1. Here we experimentally focus on the sensitivity to small changes in DNA diameter that can be discerned with graphene nanopores. We show that remarkably large sensitivities (0.5 nA/Å) are obtained when the nanopore is tailored to have a diameter close to that of the polymer of interest. Our results have been obtained with double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). Smaller graphene nanopores that can be tuned to the diameter of single- stranded DNA (ssDNA) for sequencing have only recently been demonstrated2. Our results indicate that nanopore sensors based on such pores will provide excellent resolution and base discrimination, and will be robust competitors to protein nanopores that have recently demonstrated sequencing capability3,4. Biological5 and solid-state6 nanopore sensors are becoming key elements in next generation DNA sequencing technologies7,8. They are increasingly being used for rapid characterization of many individual DNA molecules9-11, proteins12,13, and protein-DNA complexes14,15. In a nanopore sensor, a charged biopolymer in solution is electrophoretically driven through a nanometer scale pore in an insulating membrane separating two voltage biased reservoirs filled with aqueous ionic solution. As the negatively charged DNA molecules pass through a nanopore, they block the flow of ions through the nanopore, leading to a transient drop of the ionic current through the nanopore (a blockade). The instantaneous ionic current during 2 the blockade is related to the geometrical and chemical properties of the pore and the part of the polymer in the pore at that given time. Here we demonstrate an extraordinary sensitivity of graphene nanopores to DNA molecules when the pore and molecule diameters are very closely matched. We fabricated single nanopores in graphene membranes1, see also16,17, with a focused beam of a 200 KeV transmission electron microscope (TEM). The graphene membranes were suspended over 200 nm x 200 nm apertures in thin, free-standing SiNx films supported on silicon frames (Fig. 1a and Methods section). DNA translocation through these graphene nanopores was investigated in high salt and high pH solutions (3M KCl, pH 10). Under these conditions electrostatic and chemical stick-slip forces between DNA molecules and the graphene surface are largely suppressed as will be demonstrated below. The applied voltage bias between the reservoirs on either side of the graphene membrane was 160 mV. Figure 1b shows individual current blockades in graphene nanopores of various diameters induced by 10kb dsDNA molecules. A strong nanopore diameter dependence is evident, with c) or protein nanopores. This is especially clear for the nanopores whose diameters approach the blockade currents that are much larger than have been observed in SiNx nanopores (Fig. 1b and size of the translocating polymer. As we show below, such polymer-hugging nanopores are extraordinarily sensitive to small changes in the difference between the molecule and nanopore diameter. Figure 1d shows ionic conductivity vs. nanopore diameter for a series of open graphene nanopores. The linear dependence of conductivity on diameter is expected only when the membrane is much thinner than the pore diameter1. This is consistent with the predicted access 3 resistance of a small circular pore18, our numerical solutions of the Laplace equation for the ionic current density1, and molecular dynamic calculations19. To understand the sensitivity of graphene nanopores to single molecule DNA translocation, we investigated many DNA translocation events for pores of different diameters (Figs. 2a & b). In nanopores with diameters greater than ~4 nm, dsDNA molecules translocate through the pore either as extended linear molecules (leading to a single-dip event, Fig. 2c, left the blockade (Fig. 2c, right trace). In nanopores with diameters ≤3.2 nm, only unfolded trace) or as a folded molecule (typically doubling the current blockade during the folded part of molecules were observed (single-dip events), consistent with the notion that these nanopores are too small to admit folded dsDNA molecules for passage. We characterize each DNA translocation event by two parameters: the event duration, which indicates the time it takes for the molecule to fully translocate through the nanopore, and the average current blockade magnitude, which reflects the extent to which the molecule obstructs or blocks the flow of ionic current through the nanopore. The product of these two parameters is the electronic charge deficit10 (ecd) during the event. Note the clustering of all the dsDNA translocation events around the hyperbolic line of constant ecd in Fig. 2a. This, together with the short average translocation time (Tm~150μs), shows that dsDNA molecules in 3M KCl, pH 10, freely translocate through the graphene nanopore and are minimally retarded by stochastic sticking interactions with the graphene membrane or nanopore10. Raising the pH of the salt solution from 10 to 12.5 denatures the dsDNA into single- stranded DNA (ssDNA) molecules11. Unfolded ssDNA translocation events (Fig. 2d right) show blockade magnitudes less than half that of dsDNA (Fig. 2d, left trace), a reflection of the reduced diameter of ssDNA. To our knowledge this is the first observation of ssDNA translocating 4 through a graphene nanopore. Many ssDNA events are observed far from the line of constant ecd because of their extended translocation times (Fig. 2c). This strongly suggests that many of the ssDNA molecules stick to, or interact, with graphene. This is not surprising since the nucleobases in ssDNA are accessible and known to form π-π stacking/van der Waals interactions with a graphene surface20. The average current blockade for unfolded dsDNA translocations in graphene nanopores was measured as a function of nanopore diameter, and the results are shown as the filled circles in Fig. 3a. A steep increase in blockade current with decreasing nanopore diameter, from 6.5 to 2.7 nm, is observed. This indicates a continuing increase in sensitivity to the difference in molecule diameter and pore diameter as the fit between the two gets closer and closer. The open circles are data obtained from e-beam drilled nanopores in 30 nm thick SiNx which, because of the membrane thickness, show virtually no change in blockade current with nanopore diameter. To understand the experimental data in Fig. 3a, we calculated (see Methods) current flow through an open pore (I0) vs. pore diameter, and through the same pore containing a DNA molecule passing through its center, to obtain the blockade current (IB). The electrolyte solution is modeled as a continuous medium with appropriate ionic conductivity, and we numerically solved the Laplace equation with appropriate boundary conditions. We fitted the results to the experimental data using the dimensions of the boundary conditions as the fitting parameters. We call DIC the ionic conducting diameter of the pore, ITL the membrane insulating thickness and DNAd the diameter of the insulating DNA molecule at the center of the pore. Actually, rather than fit the value of each pore diameter we set the effective diameter of each nanopore DIC = Dpore – δDIC, to be reduced from each TEM measured pore diameter poreD by δDIC . The latter is a single fitting parameter used for all pores. This correction allows for the fact that solution ions 5 do not approach the hydrophobic TEM determined pore perimeter due to various chemical size effects. The best fit to the data in Fig. 3a is given by the solid line for which δDIC =( 0.65 ± 0.05) nm , DNAd    1.93 0.02 nm  , and LIT =( 0.37 ± 0.08) nm. The value of LIT determined here is in the range of our previously reported value (0.6 [+0.9, –0.6] nm)1 and agrees with theoretical predictions21 for a graphene-water distance of 0.31-0.34 nm. It seems reasonable that the effective diameter reduction δDIC be similar to the membrane insulating thickness LIT with any deviations attributed to the energy cost of an ion shedding its hydration shell within the nanopore22,23, or the consequences of chemical groups bound to the graphene nanopore’s edge22. The modeled dependence of blockade current vs. pore diameter is shown as the solid curve in Fig. 3a based on the parameters given above. The fit to the data (solid circles) is seen to be rather good and we conclude that the calculation captures the essential physics with the parameters LIT and DIC absorbing all the molecular interaction effects24. We define the nanopore’s sensitivity as the change in current blockade caused by a S ( DIC , d poly )  change in the diameter of the translocating polymer This is the slope of the solid curve as a function of nanopore diameter. The approximation assumes dpoly  DIC > LIT.  I B d poly    I B  DIC The value of S from Fig. 3a, remarkably, exceeds 0.5 nA/Å, predicting that a change of a tenth Angstrom molecule diameter in our close fitting pore results in a current blockade change of 50 pA in BI for dsDNA. Similar results should be obtained for ssDNA ( d  1.4 nm ) with a similarly tight fitting nanopore. 6 Figure 3b shows the current density in and near a 2.5 nm DNA threaded pore using the relevant fitting parameters. The high sensitivity is due to the very concentrated current density in the narrow solution space between the DNA and nanopore periphery. Figure 3c shows a plot of the Sensitivity Gradient along the DNA molecule surface defined by where D is the polymer diameter, R the pore resistance, z the distance from the symmetry plane 1 lim D R   D 0  dV D dz dV D D   dz    dS dz      of the pore along the surface of the polymer, and DV z is the electrostatic potential along the ( ) surface of a polymer of diameter D as a function of distance from the pore z. The Sensitivity Gradient identifies where the contributions to S come from along the molecule’s length and thus reveals the spatial resolution of the molecule pore system. The Sensitivity Gradient “full width half max” of 0.5 nm in Figure 3c, for the 2.5 nm pore, is the order of expected base separations in ssDNA. The excellent spatial resolution along the molecule is closely connected with the rapid drop in current density on leaving the vicinity of the pore as seen in Fig. 3b. The sensitivity to molecule size demonstrated here and the high spatial resolution along the molecule’s length shown previously1 are the direct consequence of the atomic thinness of a molecule-hugging graphene nanopore. This, together with the recent proof-of-principle demonstration that very small diameter graphene nanopores can be fabricated with atomic-scale precision2, suggest that graphene nanopores will be an ideal nanopore sensor. Achieving ssDNA strand sequencing with graphene nanopores will also require solutions to several of the same problems that have been addressed when utilizing protein pores: the need for ratcheting control of DNA translocation to suppress Brownian molecular motions25, and the suppression of large 1/f electronic noise that can severely degrade the ionic current signal-to- 7 noise. It remains to be seen if some of the solutions for translocation control used with biological pores3 may be applied to graphene pores or otherwise engineered26. Likewise, further research will be required to determine how to optimally suppress the large observed 1/f electronic noise frequently observed in graphene (Fig. 1e). This noise can be reduced by applying various coatings16,17, but these coatings increase the length of the nanopore and are incompatible with the high resolution detector strategy reported here. We have achieved noise reduction by simply reducing the free standing area of the graphene membrane (Fig. 1e). In conclusion we believe the longitudinal sub-nanometer resolution possible in graphene nanopores1 together with the radial super-sensitivity discovered here bode well for the application of graphene nanopores to many molecular sensing, characterization, and sequencing problems. Methods The graphene was grown via chemical vapor deposition (CVD) on a copper foil27, and subsequently transferred28 over the aperture on a free-standing SiNx film covering a silicon chip, and carefully processed to remove any residual hydrocarbon impurities from the polymer support film used during the transfer process1. Individual graphene nanopores were drilled with a JEOL 2010F TEM operating at 200kV. Micro-Raman measurements (model WITec CRM 200) and TEM imaging with atomic resolution (aberration-corrected Zeiss Libra 200, operating at 80keV electron energies) demonstrated that the transferred graphene film was single-layer and largely free of hydrocarbon contaminants. The graphene chip was sealed in a fluidic cell so as to separate two chambers that were subsequently filled with 3 M potassium-chloride solutions, pH 10 or pH12.5. The graphene nanopore was the only path through which ions and DNA 8 molecules (10kBase fragments) could pass between the two chambers. Applying a constant 160 mV bias voltage with Ag/AgCl electrodes in each chamber, we measured the ionic current and DNA translocation through the nanopore using standard electrophysiological methods. The numerical simulations were performed using the COMSOL Multiphysics finite element solver in 3D geometry, cylindrically symmetric along the axis of the nanopore. A DNA molecule was modeled as a long stiff insulating rod threading the nanopore along its axis. We solved the full set of Poisson–Nerst–Planck (PNP) equations, with the boundary conditions at the graphene corresponding to idealized, uncharged membrane impermeable to ions. In our experimental regime with high KCl concentration and small applied voltage, the PNP solution was found to differ only by few percents from the numerical solution of the Laplace equation with the appropriate electrolyte conductivity. The total ionic current was calculated by integrating current density across the diameter of the nanopore. References 1. Garaj, S. et al. Graphene as a subnanometre trans-electrode membrane. Nature 467, 190- 194 (2010). 2. Russo, C.J. & Golovchenko, J.A. Atom-by-atom nucleation and growth of graphene nanopores. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 109, 5953-5957 (2012). 3. Cherf, G.M. et al. Automated forward and reverse ratcheting of DNA in a nanopore at 5- Å precision. Nature Biotechnology 30, 344-348 (2012). 4. Manrao, E.A. et al. Reading DNA at single-nucleotide resolution with a mutant MspA nanopore and phi29 DNA polymerase. Nature Biotech. 30, 349-353 (2012). 9 5. Kasianowicz, J.J., Brandin, E., Branton, D. & Deamer, D.W. Characterization of individual polynucleotide molecules using a membrane channel. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 93, 13770-13773 (1996). 6. 7. Li, J. et al. Ion-beam sculpting at nanometre length scales. Nature 412, 166-169 (2001). Branton, D. et al. The potential and challenges of nanopore sequencing. Nature Biotechnology 26, 1146-1153 (2008). 8. Venkatesan, B.M. & Bashir, R. Nanopore sensors for nucleic acid analysis. Nature Nanotechnology 6, 615-624 (2011). 9. Deamer, D. & Branton, D. Characterization of nucleic acids by nanopore analysis. Acc. Chem. Res. 35, 817-825 (2002). 10. Li, J., Gershow, M., Stein, D., Brandin, E. & Golovchenko, J. DNA molecules and configurations in a solid-state nanopore microscope. Nature Materials 2, 611-615 (2003). 11. Fologea, D. et al. Detecting single stranded DNA with a solid state nanopore. Nano Lett. 5, 1905-1909 (2005). 12. Han, A. et al. Sensing protein molecules using nanofabricated pores. Appl. Phys. Lett. 88, 093901 (2006). 13. Talaga, D.S. & Li, J. Single-molecule protein unfolding in solid state nanopores. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 131, 9287-9297 (2009). 14. Olasagasti, F. et al. Replication of individual DNA molecules under electronic control using a protein nanopore. Nature Nanotechnology 5, 798-806 (2010). 15. Venkatesan, B.M. et al. Stacked graphene-Al2O3 nanopore sensors for sensitive detection of DNA and DNA-protein complexes. ACS Nano 6, 441-450 (2012). 10 16. Merchant, C.A. et al. DNA translocation through graphene nanopores. Nano Lett. 10, 2915-2921 (2010). 17. Schneider, G.F. et al. DNA translocation through graphene nanopores. Nano Lett. 10, 3163–3167 (2010). 18. Hall, J.E. Access resistance of a small circular pore. The Journal of General Physiology 66, 531-532 (1975). 19. Sathe, C., Zou, X., Leburton, J.-P. & Schulten, K. Computational investigation of DNA detection using graphene nanopores. ACS Nano 5, 8842-8851 (2011). 20. Gowtham, S., Scheicher, R.H., Ahuja, R., Pandey, R. & Karna, S.P. Physisorption of nucleobases on graphene: Density-functional calculations. Phys. Rev. B 76, 033401 (2007). 21. Alexiadis, A. & Kassinos, S. Molecular simulation of water in carbon nanotubes. Chem. Rev. 108, 5014-5034 (2008). 22. Sint, K., Wang, B. & Kral, P. Selective ion passage through functionalized graphene nanopores. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 130, 16448-16449 (2008). 23. Zwolak, M., Lagerqvist, J. & Di Ventra, M. Quantized ionic conductance in nanopores. Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 128102 (2009). 24. Eijkel, J.C.T. & Berg, A.V.D. Nanofluidics: what is it and what can we expect from it? Microfluidics and Nanofluidics 1, 249-267 (2005). 25. Lu, B., Albertorio, F., Hoogerheide, D.P. & Golovchenko, J.A. Origins and consequences of velocity fluctuations during DNA passage through a nanopore. Biophys. J. 101, 70-79 (2011). 11 26. Luan, B. et al. Base-by-base ratcheting of single stranded DNA through a solid-state nanopore. Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 238103-238101 - 238103-238104 (2010). 27. Li, X. et al. Large-area synthesis of high-quality and uniform graphene films on copper foils. Science 324, 1312-1314 (2009). 28. Lin, Y.-C. et al. Clean transfer of graphene for isolation and suspension. ACS Nano 5, 2362-2368 (2011). 12 Acknowledgements This work was funded by a grant (number R01HG003703) to J.A. Golovchenko and D. Branton from the National Human Genome Research Institute, National Institutes of Health. S. Liu acknowledges support from the State Scholarship Fund of China. Author Contributions The experiments were designed by S.G., D.B, and J.A.G. Measurements and sample preparation were done by S.G. and S.L. All other activities, including data interpretation, conclusions, and manuscript writing, were carried out collaboratively by S.G, D.B. and J.A.G. Additional Information The authors declare no competing financial interests. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to J.A.G. ([email protected]). Figure Legends Figure 1. (a) The experimental device with dsDNA translocating through a graphene nanopore. (b) Typical current blockades as dsDNA translocates through a 5 nm SiNx pore and through graphene pores of various diameters (D). (c) dsDNA blocked currents through nanopores of different diameters, defined by the open pore current. (d) Open pore currents through a series of different diameter pores before addition of DNA. (e) Noise power spectral density of a 5 nm graphene nanopore suspended across a 200 x 200 nm SiNx aperture (graphene 1) and a similar 13 nanopore across a 20 nm diameter SiNx aperture (graphene 2) with greatly reduced noise. A 5 nm nanopore in SiNx with no graphene is also shown. Figure 2. (a & b) Event plots for different diameter nanopores. Each circle corresponds to a DNA translocation event. Blue, extended, unfolded molecule translocations (pH 10), green, folded translocations (pH 10), and black, single stranded translocations (pH 12.5). Dashed lines represent contours of constant ecd. (c & d) Single typical event current traces corresponding to one of the events from the event plots in (a) and (b), for folded DNA, unfolded DNA and for single stranded DNA. The event plots and current traces in panels (b) and (d) were all performed with the same nanopore before the DNA was denatured (blue) and after the DNA was denatured (black) by raising the solution pH to 12.5. Figure 3. (a) Average current blockade for dsDNA translocations vs. nanopore diameter (solid circles: graphene nanopores, open square: 30nm thick SiNX pores). Solid and dashed lines are fit to the data using the numerical model. Inset: Nanopore conductivity vs. pore diameter. Red line is simulated using best-fit values. (b) Calculated current density in a 2.5 nm graphene nanopore traversed by dsDNA, the latter represented by a 1.93 nm cylinder. (c) Calculated Sensitivity Gradient along a DNA molecule for the conditions in (b. 14 a SiN pore x graphene pores b D = 5.0 nm D = 4 nm A n 4 I0 DNA c B I ) A n ( I 15 10 7 6 5 4 3 6 10 14 18 Open pore current I (nA) 0 400 ms d 25 20 ) A 15 n ( 0 I 10 5 2 4 6 D (nm) pore ) Z H / 2 A n ( D S P -310 -510 D = 3.2 nm D = 2.7 nm e graphene 1 graphene 2 SiN x -710 -910 410 210 010 Frequency (Hz) ) A n ( B I 5 4 3 2 1 0 a ds-DNA 5 4 3 2 1 ) A n ( B I D = 4.5 nm pore 0 200 400 Event Duration (ms) c IB IB 0 0 -1 -2 -3 ) A n ( B I b ds-DNA ss-DNA D = 3.2 nm pore 0 400 200 0 200 Event Duration (ms) d 0 -1 -2 -3 ) A n ( B I dsDNA IB ssDNA 400 IB 400 ms 400 ms 2 a ) A n ( B I 4 3 2 1 0 2 3 4 5 6 Ion Conducting Diameter, D [nm] IC TEM Diameter, D [nm] pore 4 3 5 6 7 4 150 ) A 100 n ( G 50 2 4 6 D [nm] pore b +160mV graphene 0 1 nm dsDNA ground -2 0 +2 D i s t a n c e [ n m ] 0 8 6 2 4 Sensitivity Gradient (nA/nm) 2 2 ) m / A G ( c j 0
1002.3552	1	1002	2010-02-18T15:56:39	Entropy analyses of spatiotemporal synchronizations in brain signals from patients with focal epilepsies	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.data-an", "q-bio.NC" ]	The electroencephalographic (EEG) data intracerebrally recorded from 20 epileptic humans with different brain origins of focal epilepsies or types of seizures, ages and sexes are investigated (nearly 700 million data). Multi channel univariate amplitude analyses are performed and it is shown that time dependent Shannon entropies can be used to predict focal epileptic seizure onsets in different epileptogenic brain zones of different patients. Formations or time evolutions of the synchronizations in the brain signals from epileptogenic or non epileptogenic areas of the patients in ictal interval or inter-ictal interval are further investigated employing spatial or temporal differences of the entropies.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Entropy analyses of spatiotemporal synchronizations in brain signals from patients with focal epilepsies Çağlar Tuncay [email protected] Abstract: The electroencephalographic (EEG) data intracerebrally recorded from 20 epileptic humans with different brain origins of focal epilepsies or types of seizures, ages and sexes are investigated (nearly 700 million data). Multi channel univariate amplitude analyses are performed and it is shown that time dependent Shannon entropies can be used to predict focal epileptic seizure onsets in different epileptogenic brain zones of different patients. Formations or time evolutions of the synchronizations in the brain signals from epileptogenic or non epileptogenic areas of the patients in ictal interval or inter-ictal interval are further investigated employing spatial or temporal differences of the entropies. Key words: Distribution, Shannon entropy, Interdependency, Synchronization, Pre-ictal state, Post-ictal state, Seizure. Pacs: ; 87.19.xm; 87.19.Nn; 87.19.le; 87.90.+y; 05.45.Tp; 05.90.+m Introduction: Automatic (computer based) detection or prediction of epileptic seizures is a challenging subject in quantified electroencephalography [1-13] where the underlying dynamics for the recordings are usually not completely known. Thus, it is difficult to select a priori most suitable method for an analysis [14]. Fortunately, the ictal state is characterized by occurrence of synchronous oscillations and two scenarios of how a spontaneous seizure could evolve are suggested in [15-16]: If a seizure is caused by a sudden and abrupt transition, then it would not be preceded by detectable dynamical changes in EEG data. Such a scenario is suggested for the initiation of seizures in primary generalized epilepsy. On the other hand, if the transition occurs gradually then it could be detected, at least in principle. This type of transition is proposed to be more likely in focal epilepsies. In this case, the seizure begins in a restricted brain region and either remains localized or spreads to the adjacent cortex. These hypotheses are considered and tested by various methods in several papers. For example in [17 and 18], the interdependence between intracranial EEG electrodes in human subjects with epilepsy is investigated. It is reported in both publications that there is strong evidence for non-linear interdependence between the focus of epileptic activity and other brain regions and this interdependence can be detected for up to 30 seconds prior to a seizure. Different researchers [19] studied single electrode scalp EEG from 60 healthy humans and found that non-linear structure is only present weakly and infrequently. More recently, the same hypotheses were tested by comparing 30 measures in terms of their ability to distinguish between the inter-ictal period and the pre-seizure period [20 and 21]. These publications provide statistically significant evidence for the existence of a pre-ictal state which is supported by numerous clinical evidence involving an increase in cerebral blood flow [22-23], oxygen availability [24] and blood-oxygen-level-dependent signal [25] as well as changes in heart rate [26-28] before seizure onsets. Thus, the interdependence between several brain sites and the existence of pre-ictal state may be important for computer based investigations of focal epilepsy. The above mentioned approaches based on amplitude, time or frequency domain measurements [21, 29-31] have a shared property in that they all try to figure out whether - 1 - there is any common information between the EEG time series as an indication of their relationship. Then, direct investigations by means of information-theoretic approaches can be favored [29]. Following this idea in this work, multi channel univariate time dependent entropy analyses are performed on various electroencephalograms intracerebrally recorded from humans with focal epilepsies [32]. The basic aim is to predict and detect numerous seizure onsets covered in the investigated data. In the meantime, several properties in the EEG data will be disclosed and used to distinguish between the inter-ictal period and the pre- seizure period [20-21]. It is clear that a method capable of predicting the occurrence of seizures from the electroencephalograms of epilepsy patients would open new therapeutic possibilities. Time dependent entropy: In this study, time dependent interrelated multi channel EEG activities of numerous humans are investigated. The ability of an information measure (entropy) index [6, 33, 34], which is defined below, is determined to distinguish between pre- ictal, ictal or post-ictal periods as well as the inter-ictal interval. The multi channel univariates are cut into consecutive sections of convenient length of 10 seconds, and then entropy is calculated for the distribution of data in each of the windows which do not overlap [35, 36]. In other words, the analyses are performed in a time window of defined length and this time window is moved step wise to produce a continuously updated entropy spectrum for the recordings from different brain sites. Note that the model used is time invariant as stipulated in [35]. Entropy is known to be a quantity describing the amount of disorder in a system or a measure of uncertainty in the information content of a signal. Shannon entropy [37 and 38] is used to investigate various properties of integrated neuronal activity in this work, where the recorded voltages (Xk(i)) from the contact position (k=1-6) have integer values in micro Volt (μV) [32]. Let Q(Xk(i)) be the frequency of Xk(i) in the data and be abbreviated as Qk(i). The (discrete) empirical distribution Pk(i) is obtained by normalizing Qk(i); where N is the number of samples (which is 2560 per window since the sampling rate is 256 Hertz (Hz) in [32] and the length of a time window is 10 seconds in this contribution). In what follows, ED refers to empirical distribution and an ED is said to be discrete uniform (or homogeneous) if P(i) ∝ 1/N or delta-like if data are distributed in a narrow peak around a voltage. Then estimation of Shannon entropy (Sk) of a time window of a univariate recorded from the contact position (k) is In Eq. (2), the summation is over the states (i) which are accessible with probability Pk(i)≤1 and log is logarithm with any base [37 and 38] which is taken as the natural logarithm, here. Note that Sk is zero for delta-like ED. Moreover, Sk attains its maximum value which is ln(N) [29] if the ED of a given set of N samples is homogeneous. Thus, an entropy measure index (χk) may be defined as Sk = -∑i=1;N Pk(i)log(Pk(i)) . χk = Sk/ln(N) Pk(i) = Qk(i)/∑i=1;N Qk(i) , (3) (2) (1) - 2 - which is zero for delta-like ED or 1 for homogeneous ED and 0<χk<1 otherwise. (See, Appendix for further discussion of the subject.) One may refer to [20, 21, 39, 40] for several utilizations of the parameter in Eq. (3) with different aims. In this work, the ED for each time window starting at the time (τ-Δτ) and ending at the time (τ) with Δτ=10 seconds are calculated and a continuously updated entropy index spectrum χk(τ) is obtained for each univariate recorded from the contact position k=1-6. The number of samples, N in Eq. (3), is the same for the windows and hence it is possible to select these time windows with small values of χk in the time profile (χk(τ)) when the EEG signal in the window is narrow (oscillations with small magnitudes about a voltage). On the other hand, the value of χk is close to 1 when the EEG signals are broad (oscillations with large magnitudes). Numerous further criteria may be applied to predict the characteristics of a sample distribution, if needed [29, 39, 41-45]. Space and time differences of the entropy indices: Due to the occurrence of synchronous EEG oscillations in the ictal state as discussed in the Introduction section, it is expected that the time dependent indices (χk(τ)) become similar at times close to or during a seizure. In other words, the values of the indices χk(τ) and χk’(τ) are synchronously close to each other when the brain sites for the contact positions (k) and (k’) are coupled. Thus, the pairwise differences Dk,k’(τ) of χk(τ) and χk’(τ) may provide information about the strength (with small absolute value of Dk,k’(τ)) and duration (number of the time windows with small absolute value of Dk,k’(τ)) of a coupling between two brain sites. Note that Dk,k’(τ) may be considered as the approximate spatial derivatives of the index profiles for those contacts which are closely positioned. The seizure time terms last for several seconds or minutes and they are clearly short with respect to several hours (h) for the registration periods of the data from a patient. Hence, a new parameter (z) is used to help the inspection of the similarities in the time profiles of χk(τ): where (.) stands for the absolute value. Obviously, z(τ) defined in Eq. (5) is big when the values of the entropy indices (χk(τ)) are close to each other. Thus, the predictive power of the marker depends on the strength of the couplings before or during onsets. In this work, the first and second order successive time differences of the entropy indices, χ’k(τ) and χ’’k(τ), respectively are also investigated with the aim of obtaining a better description of the properties of integrated neuronal activity in ictal and inter-ictal intervals, where z(τ) = 1 / ∑k=1;6,k≠k’∑k’=1;6Dk,k’(τ) Dk,k’(τ) = χk(τ) - χk’(τ) (5) (4) χ’k(τ) = χk(τ) - χk(τ-Δτ) (6) χ’’k(τ) = χ’k(τ) - χ’k(τ-Δτ) . and In Eqs. (6) and (7), Δτ is equal to 10 seconds which is the length of a time window. These time rates of change provide additional information for the formations and time evolutions of the synchronized behaviors in entropy indices (χk(τ)). Thus, the attempts to understand the underlying mechanisms of the synchronizations in the EEG signals of the patients entail the analysis of the time series χ’k(τ) and χ’’k(τ) as well as χk(τ) and the spatial differences (χk(τ)- (7) - 3 - χk’(τ)) in the presented work. Obviously, comparison of the distributions of these quantities is further illuminating. Correlations: Auto-correlation and cross-correlation functions are widely used in the literature to investigate the interdependence between physiological signals [29-31]. However, the values of the spatial differences of the electrodes (Dk,k’(τ)) or their distributions may be used confidently with the same aim. For example, narrow and high peaks around zero in these distributions will imply strong correlations and long durations, respectively between the related individual recordings (Xk and Xk’) or vice versa. As a result, sample distributions of the values of Dk,k’(τ) for several k or k’ are used to investigate the strengths and durations of the correlations in this contribution. Material: Some brief information about all of the patients (PatNM) is given in Table I where the patients are grouped with respect to their origins of epilepsy. It is declared in [32] that “The EEG database contains invasive EEG recordings of 21 patients suffering from medically intractable focal epilepsy.” Yet, the data from the Pat02 is missing there. Thus the available data are from 20 patients. Let us follow the lines of the declaration: “In order to obtain a high signal-to-noise ratio, fewer artifacts, and to record directly from focal areas, intracranial grid-, strip, and depth-electrodes were utilized. The EEG data were acquired using a Neurofile NT digital video EEG system with 128 channels, 256 Hz sampling rate, and a 16 bit analogue-to-digital converter. Notch or band pass filters have not been applied. For each of the patients, there are data sets called ‘ictal’ and ‘inter-ictal’, the former containing files with epileptic seizures and at least 50 minute pre-ictal data. The latter containing approximately 24 h of EEG-recordings without seizure activity. At least 24 h of continuous interictal recordings are available for 13 patients. For the remaining patients interictal invasive EEG data consisting of less than 24 h were joined together, to end up with at least 24 h per patient. For each patient, the recordings of three focal and three extra-focal electrode contacts is available.” This pool of data has been downloaded by nearly hundred research groups from different countries [46] and treated with several aims [47-52]. The data recorded from epileptogenic zones will be designated with (k=1-3) and those from non epileptogenic ones with (k=4-6) for each patient, here. As a result, data recorded from each of the six contact positions (k) in the ictal interval or in the inter-ictal interval of each patient are cut into consecutive sections of length of 10 seconds. These time windows include 2560 data per individual recordings (k) with 256 Hz sampling rate. Then, χk(τ) is calculated for the distribution of the data in each of the non overlapping windows. Hence, six time dependent trajectories of the entropy measure (χk(τ)) are obtained for the data recorded from each patient in ictal interval and another 6 trajectories for the data from the same patient in the inter-ictal interval. The results are compared for a characteristic behavior significant to pre- ictal, ictal or inter-ictal states. The seizure terms of each patient are indicated in [32] and the given numbers are utilized to select the seizure time windows in this work. The one-hour- data-blocks with consecutive integer numbers are assumed to be continuous due to the declaration [32]. Please note that numerous pin-like topographies are expected to occur temporarily in the index profiles for the collective behaviors where the topographies will be upward if the signals broaden in the meantime, or vice versa; namely, downward pin-like patterns will appear if narrow signals accompany the synchronized interdependencies. The original results are presented in the following section. The last section is devoted to discussion and conclusion. - 4 - Results: In this section the continuously updated entropy index spectrum for each of the individual recordings from different brain sites (χk(τ) with k=1-6) of 20 patients with different origins of epilepsy, seizure types, ages and genders are analyzed. The results are exemplified for six patients with different origins of epilepsy, types of seizures, ages and sexes where various characteristic behaviors are found in the data from pre-ictal, ictal or post ictal terms. The available [32] electrode types or electrode contacts of the considered six patients are shown in Figure 1. The theoretical results for χk(τ) or z(τ) are plotted with a linear axis on the left and logarithmic axis on the right, respectively where the common horizontal axis shows the time (τ) with the unit of 1 h, for 360 windows and the seizure terms are indicated by arrows in Figures 2-5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 15, 18, 21, 22, 25. The number of the significant digits is taken three after the decimal point in the results. Moreover, the bin sizes of the distributions displayed in Figures 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 17, 19, 20, 23 are the same, which is 0.001 and that in Figure 24 is 0.002. The parameter for k in the legends of the figures indicates the electrode number. CASE 1: Pat03 with Frontal Lobe Epilepsy The time spectra of the entropy indices (χk(τ)) with k=1-6 of the EEG data recorded from the Pat03 during the ictal interval and the inter-ictal interval are illustrated in Figs. 2 (a) and (b), respectively. It may be inspected that all of the (four out of four) indicated seizures [32] are detected by means of the marker z(τ) in Fig. 2 (a). Thus, all of the seizures of the patient are accompanied by strong simultaneous couplings (synchronous interdependency) between the brain sites for the contact positions. Please note that the patterns of the trajectories of the entropy indices in the ictal interval and in the inter-ictal interval are different: The profiles are more oscillatory in Fig. 2 (a) with regard to those in Fig. 2 (b). However, several strong or weak couplings occur temporally in both of the intervals as the big values in the time courses of (z(τ)) indicate in Figs. 3 (a) and (b). Here, a distinguishing property is that the coupled entropy indices do not come close to 1 in the inter-ictal interval. Moreover, no formations similar to these which occur nearly 20 minutes before the imminent seizure onset in Fig. 3 (a) can be found in those profiles for the inter-ictal interval; see, Figs. 2 (b) or 3 (b). Furthermore, similar pre-ictal formations occur before the known seizures of the Pat03 as exemplified in Figs. 4 (a) and (b) where the data are continuous for 2 h in each plot. It should be noted that the temporal couplings; namely, the pin-like topographies covering a few windows are not strong during the seizure indicated in Fig. 4 (b) with respect to those in Fig. 3 (a). However, the values of the indices are close to 1 with broad signals in all. Moreover, various pin-like formations occur also after the seizures for nearly 20 minutes. Therefore, it may be claimed that the spontaneous occurrences of individual strong or weak couplings are not decisive for the initiation of a seizure, where an important criterion is the emergence of a pre-ictal stage as stressed in [20-21]. In summary, a pre-ictal stage originates nearly 20 minutes before the first indicated seizure (Fig. 5 (a), which is the same as Fig. 3 (a) with different time domain) and it evolves intermittently through several coupling epochs, each of which continues nearly one minute covering five or six windows, usually. It is reported in [17 and 18] that, the interdependences can be detected for up to 30 seconds prior to a seizure. Also, see [14-16], and [20] and [21]. The indices come very close to each other around 1 during the seizure terms. The transitions from an ictal state to inter-ictal state also continue for nearly 20 minutes with various strong or weak coupling terms as in the pre-ictal stage and the index values decrease after the offsets; namely, in the post-ictal stage, to their log-run or inter-ictal averages. Thus, a cycle for a seizure is completed. Similar cyclic behavior consisting of pre-ictal, ictal and post-ictal states accompany all of the seizures of the patient (see, Figs. 4 (a) and (b) for example). It is known that various focal seizures begin in a restricted brain region and either remain localized or spread to the adjacent cortex, as considered in the Introduction section. Let us - 5 - focus on 3 (a) or 5 (a) to inspect the approach, onset and offset of the first seizure. The pre- ictal stage is presumably originated (due to an unknown biological reason) at about τ=1.45 h where the entire entropy index values decrease for a few minutes. This means that the in- focus or out-focus contact positions are temporarily coupled. The couplings are weakened in the next five or six minutes. Afterwards, the strength and occurrence frequency of the couplings increase intermittently with time and the tops of the pin-like topographies ascend towards 1. All of the contact sites are coupled at about τ=1.65 h, i.e., a few minutes before the onset of the seizure which occurs at about τ=1.7 h; where the maximum values of the indices with k=1-6 are nearly the same. During the seizure, integrated neural activity reaches a climax, where all of the indices have nearly the same value which is very close to 1 and EEG signals broaden. Apparently, more brain sites are coupled with increasing strengths while approaching to the seizure onset. It may be claimed that the spread of the seizure is not a continuous process but an intermittent one since strong couplings occur intermittently. The relaxation of the indices is gradual and accompanied by numerous couplings, which are also intermittent. Figs. 5 (b) and (c) show the first and second order successive time differences (approximate time derivatives) of the indices with the same time domain of Fig. 5 (a), where the intermittent couplings are clear. Therefore, not only the indices but also their time differences are coupled at several time epochs. Moreover, the brain electricity may be unique and locally modulated when close to or during a seizure. (Various different suggestions on the subject may be found on page 198 in [39].) This subject will be held while investigating other cases for different patients and further discussed in the last section. Let us now treat the distributions of the index values for the data from the Pat03 in the ictal interval (Fig. 6 (a)) or in the inter-ictal interval (Fig. 6 (b)), where the aim is to search for statistical evidence about the electrical couplings between different brain sites. The plots for the data from the inter-ictal interval are evidently parabolic in logarithmic scale (or Gaussian in linear scale) whereas those for the ictal interval depict important deviations from Gauss, where the deviations are outstanding especially for the data from the out-focus electrodes, with k=4-6. This shows that the out-focus sites are strongly affected by the epileptogenic activities. Note that the modes of the ED plots of the index values occur at the intermediate values which match the values for the pre-ictal and post-ictal stages. Hence, these stages can be predicted if the modes of the ED plots of the index values show certain deviations from Gauss. Conclusively, the ED plots of the entropy index values can be utilized to distinguish between the inter-ictal data and ictal data or more specifically, the inter-ictal period and the pre-ictal period (see, [20-21]). The time series of the mutual arithmetical differences of the in-focus (k=1-3) or out-focus (k=4-6) index values are displayed in Figs. 7 (a) and (b), respectively which cover the first seizure. Note that the differences remain close to each other around zero for a few minutes after the seizure offsets and depart gradually afterwards. This behavior can also be monitored during the other seizures of the Pat03 (Fig. 7 (c)) and the seizures of several other patients as will be considered in further cases. The over-all behavior of these electrode differences can be understood in terms of the distributions of their values as displayed in Figs. 8 (a) and (b). Inspection of these figures shows that the in-focus and out-focus electrodes are more strongly correlated in the ictal- interval than in the inter-ictal interval since the modes occur at zero in Fig. 8 (a). Moreover, the heights of these modes are nearly the same for all of the electrodes which indicate a strong collective behavior where the heights are much bigger than the number of the windows for the seizures. This is because numerous very strong couplings occur in the pre-ictal and post-ictal stages as well as in the ictal stages. However, the index values come out very close to 1 for these strong couplings only during the seizures, which is a distinguishing property for the - 6 - onsets. Furthermore, all of the out-focus electrodes and only two of the three in-focus electrodes (k=1 and k=3); namely, FE1 and FD1 (Table I and Fig. 1) are strongly correlated in the inter-ictal interval since the highest and narrowest peak around zero comes out for these electrode differences (DFE1,FD1) in Fig. 8 (b). Hence the total duration of the DFE1,FD1 is the longest in-between the in-focus or out-focus couplings during the inter-ictal interval. Whereas, all of the out-focus electrodes are strongly coupled in both of the intervals where the couplings are stronger in the ictal interval, Figs. 8 (a) (also, Fig. 7 (c)). Note that, the plots for D1,2(τ) and D2,3(τ) are nearly anti-symmetric about zero. This is because, the time profile of χ1(τ) is similar to that of χ3(τ); namely, (χ1(τ)↔χ3(τ)) where the symbol (a↔b) is used to designate the similarity (or coupling) between a and b. Two trajectories are said to be similar if their time courses are the same up to the minor fluctuations, in this work. Hence, the ED plot for D1,3(τ) depict a narrow peak around zero since D1,3(τ)=χ1(τ)-χ3(τ)↔0 due to Eq. (4). Therefore, (χ1(τ)-χ2(τ)) is similar to (χ3(τ)-χ2(τ)) and D1,2(τ)↔D3,2(τ)=-D2,3(τ). Moreover, the in-focus electrode k=1 is strongly coupled with all of the out-focus electrodes in the ictal interval whereas the in-focus electrode k=3 is strongly coupled with all of the out-focus electrodes in the inter-ictal interval (not shown). Hence, the strength or durations of the synchronous electrode interdependence may vary with the time. The distributions of the values of the first or second order temporal differences are (Eqs. (6) or (7), respectively) exponential and symmetric about zero for each electrode in the ictal interval or in the inter-ictal interval (not shown). This subject will be discussed in detail in further sections. CASE 2: Pat14 with Fronto/temporal Epilepsy Only three of four indicated seizures are detected in this case (Fig. 9 (a)) where the first indicated seizure which occurs a few minutes after an abrupt decrease in the indices (for a narrow signal) is missed (Fig. 9 (b)). During this or other downward pin-like behaviors in the ictal and the inter-ictal data, the electrodes show intermediately strong cross-correlations as displayed in Fig. 9 (c). Moreover, a diversity of EEG signals from narrow to broad signals is generated at different times in this case. (Note that there are no downward pin-like patterns for narrow signals in the previous case.) The entropy profiles from the in-focus electrodes have big magnitudes and fluctuate with small magnitudes around nearly 0.9 whereas these from the out-focus positions fluctuate with big magnitudes around nearly 0.85 in the ictal interval (Figs. 9 (a) and (b)). The values of the oscillations are above 0.8 also in the inter-ictal interval aside from the frequently occurring downward pin-like behaviors (see Fig. 9 (c), for a short time domain). Durations of the pre-ictal and post-ictal states are nearly 30 minutes or longer, as can be seen in Fig. 9 (c) where the data are continuous for 3 h and two ictal cycles consisting of pre- ictal, ictal and post-ictal stages are included. The profiles are inter-ictal-like up to τ∼4.6 h where weak couplings occur between the electrodes and the entropies little increase. The following pre-ictal state for the onset at τ∼4.8 h involves several weak synchronizations and these interdependencies evolve into strong ones during the seizure which starts and terminates abruptly. The post-ictal state lasts for nearly 30 minutes with numerous strong and synchronized interdependencies. The adjacent inter-ictal state also lasts for about 30 minutes, up to τ∼6.0 h while strong couplings start which become stronger at τ∼6.2 h. Thus, the pre- ictal state for the next seizure which occurs at τ∼6.6 h initiates. Note that the values of the entropy indices are bigger in the considered post-ictal stages with respect to these in the inter- ictal or pre-ictal stages. The first and second order time differences of the individual indices also display the couplings (upward or downward pin-like topographies) in the ictal interval and the inter-ictal interval (not shown). Moreover, the ED plots of the values of these differences are symmetric and exponentially decreasing around zero as in the previous case for the Pat03 (not shown). - 7 - On the other hand, the ED of the ictal and inter-ictal index values are characteristically different (as in the previous case) with some noisy behaviors in both of the ED (in this case), as can be seen in Figs. 10 (a) and (b). The noisy behaviors and deformations from Gauss in Fig. 10 (a) are due to the pre-ictal and post-ictal states as discussed in the previous case whereas these in the data from the inter-ictal interval can be attributed to the time lengths of the patient’s pre-ictal or post-ictal stages, both of which are nearly 30 minutes or longer. Thus, various data from the pre-ictal or post-ictal epochs might have been mistakenly counted within the one-hour-data-segments of the inter-ictal EEG in [32]. Namely, various pre-ictal states manifest weak or intermediately strong couplings without leading to completed seizure onsets, in the time epochs far from the experienced seizures and these data are counted for the inter-ictal interval. However, the ictal and inter-ictal intervals can be clearly distinguished in terms of the ED plots since these plots, especially for the out-focus electrodes from the ictal interval show important deformations with respect to those from the inter-ictal interval as in the previous case. Moreover, the maximum values of the indices of this patient are very close to 1 (see, Fig. 10 (a) and (b) also Figs. 6 (a) and (b), 14 (a) and (b), 23 (a) and (b)) whereas the minimum values are 0 due to various narrow signals. Hence very broad and narrow brain signals are generated in this case. Various simultaneous couplings between the local electrodes of the Pat14 can be utilized to detect seizure cycles as considered in the previous case. Yet, the focus will be on the simultaneous couplings between the non-local electrodes, here; see, Figs. 11 (a) and (b). Although the cyclic behavior is not clear, the ability of the electrode differences to capture the seizure term is obvious in Fig. 11 (a). Moreover, the differences D1,5(τ) and D2,5(τ) (the dotted lines in different colors in Fig. 11 (a)) follow each other closely in the given time domain. This feature implies that D1,2(τ)↔0 due to Eq. (4); namely, the contact positions at k=1 and k=2 are strongly correlated: χ1(τ)↔χ2(τ) thus, (χ1(τ)-χ5(τ))↔(χ2(τ)-χ5(τ)) and D1,5(τ)↔D2,5(τ). The related cyclic behavior can be inspected in Fig. 11 (b) which shows the time courses of a different set of non-local electrode couplings. The first and second integrated behaviors in the profiles towards 0 at τ∼3.2 h and τ∼3.3 h, respectively indicate the pre-ictal stage. These couplings are very strong during the seizure and weakened afterwards. They continue for several minutes in the post-ictal stages as can be inspected in Fig. 11 (c) for different seizure terms, where all of the time profiles of the non-local couplings are designated by dotted lines. The ED plots in Fig. 12 (a) and (b) show that several simultaneous non-local cross- correlations are weak but they follow each other closely through the ictal interval possibly with a time phase difference; see, also Fig. 11 (a). (Please note that the frequency or time phase domain analyses are kept beyond the scope of this contribution.) Figs. 12 (c) and (d) are for the cross-correlations of local electrodes which depict that the cross-correlations may vary with time. For example, the D1,3 follows the D2,3 or D1,2 in different time windows and with different magnitudes. Relying upon the predictions made in the previous paragraph, it may be remarked that the unique brain electricity may be modulated differently at different times in different brain sites, but in coordination with some other site(s). Because, the partnerships in the brain couplings continue for long times yet the partners may be exchanged temporarily. CASE 3: Pat20 with Tempo/Parietal Epilepsy The data registration from the Pat20 in the ictal interval (the seventh one-hour-data-block; 020322aa_0054_k with k=1-6 in [32]) is interrupted (at i=837632 with k=1-6) for several minutes (Fig. 13 (a) at τ∼6.9 h) and no reason for the disconnection is given in [32]. The brain states might have been affected radically if some medical treatment were performed during the disconnection. For the effects - 8 - of medications such as drugs and anesthetics such as nitrous oxide on the brain states, or several examples of the related Shannon entropy applications, see [53-56] and [36], respectively and the references therein. Whatsoever this situation is, three out of four indicated seizures are detected in this case. Yet, numerous false alerts are produced due to the synchronized behavior in the data except those from the electrode k=4 as exemplified in Fig. 13 (b) where the data are continuous for 3 h. In the same figure, the pre-ictal stage for the first seizure, which is undetected, is very long and consisting of several sub-stages with various durations. At τ∼0.2 h, the index values decrease collectively. Afterwards, the values increase and various couplings occur between the contact positions except at k=4. These oscillations continue till τ∼0.7 h where a new collective decrement similar to the previous one occurs. This time, the separation between the profiles, from the contact position at k=4 and others, are obvious. The tops of the pin-like topographies increase gradually and approach 1 very closely at τ∼1.6 h where a seizure might have been expected to onset as z(τ) indicates. However, the values decrease abruptly and this state continues for nearly 20 minutes till τ∼1.9 h where an onset is realized. Therefore, numerous false attempts for an onset can be found in both of the ictal or inter-ictal data from this patient. (See, Fig. 3 (a) for two similar incomplete formations before the experienced seizure of a different patient.) It can be observed in Fig. 13 (b) and (c) that the onset and offset of the seizure at τ∼1.9 h are abrupt. Moreover, the electrode positions at k=1 and k=6 or k=2-5 are coupled strongly right after the offset for nearly 5 minutes as depicted in Fig. 13 (c). The electrodes change couples afterwards and this epoch continues for nearly 20 minutes. Various false inclinations for a seizure onset might have been observed in the several epochs of the ictal data from this patient (for example, between τ∼2.6 h and τ∼2.9 h). The couple exchanges can be monitored in the ED plots of the index values from the ictal interval and the inter-ictal interval (Figs. 14 (a) and (b)) where the collective phenomena are clear for big values of the indices from both of the intervals. Note the strong coupling between the electrodes k=1 and k=6 where this partnership continues throughout the ictal interval and inter-ictal interval. The time series for the time differences also exhibit the pin-like topographies for the couplings and the ED plots of their values come out symmetric and exponentially decreasing around zero. The local or non-local spatial couplings may run with the same partners in several epochs and the couples may be changed in others. Moreover, these differences may be utilized to detect the same seizure onsets which are captured by means of the marker. Thus, further investigations of the spatiotemporal differences of the electrodes do not provide new information in this case, because they are obtainable using different methods as shown in the previous analyses. However, it should be noted that the aforementioned (the first paragraph in this CASE) disconnection occurs at τ∼6.9 h but the index values decrease to zero much earlier than the disconnection; namely, at τ∼6.4 h and this behavior continues till the disconnection. The index profiles with k=1-6 decrease to zero much earlier than the disconnections occur also in the data from several patients in different cases. Hence, there may be a causal relation between the narrowness of the EEG signals before the disconnections and the reason(s) for the disconnections. This subject is further discussed in the last section. CASE 4: Pat11 with Parietal Epilepsy The entropy indices from the Pat11 are obviously non-stationary as displayed in Fig 15 (a). The indices from the continuous first two one-hour- data-blocks have small values and the seizure term at τ∼1.05 h is undetected by the current method. However, both of the two indicated seizures in the continuous data for the following 4 hours (2 h<τ≤6 h) are captured. Yet, the last seizure which occurs in the last continuous data - 9 - set (6 h<τ≤8 h) is missed. As a result, two of the four indicated seizures are detected in this case. It should be noted that the patterns of the profiles for the second and third seizure terms are similar to each other and thus there are three sets of continuous data and three types of seizure profiles in this case (Figs. 15 (a)-(c)). The first set of the continuous data deliver nearly homogenous index profiles where no pre-ictal, ictal or post-ictal stages are distinguished. Obviously, the first seizure does not show a cyclic behavior. Whereas, the cyclic interdependence is clear in the second and third seizure terms (Fig. 15 (b)). The index values gradually increase from τ∼2.0 h up to τ∼2.5 h and abruptly decrease to the previous levels a little later (at τ∼3.0 h). Afterwards, they increase again gradually up to τ∼3.1 h and then relax. Both of these eras are clearly not inter-ictal-like but they resemble the pre- ictal states for the imminent two seizures. Thus, they can be taken as failed alerts for a seizure. A clear pre-ictal state for the onset at τ∼3.6 h stars at τ∼3.3 h where the out-focus index values rise more rapidly than the in-focus ones. This behavior can be inspected also in the pre-ictal stage of the onset at τ∼4.8 h. The onsets and offsets of both of these seizures are abrupt and the couplings are not strong in-between them. The intermediate (inter-ictal) stages are depicted at τ∼4.0 h and τ∼6.5 h both of which continue for nearly half an hour. The ED plots of the ictal or inter-ictal indices are depicted in Figs. 16 (a) and (b), respectively where the integration is clear for big values. However, the maximum values come out bigger in the ictal interval (for the onsets). Moreover, the plots for the in-focus electrode at k=1 and out-focus one at k=6 are similar in both of the intervals, which shows that the k=1 and k=6 sites are less affected by the other sites. Whereas the same plots for the data from the k=4 position show big variation from one interval to the other and hence it can be claimed that the brain site at k=4 is more effected by the others at the times close to the seizures. The analyses of the ED plots for the spatial differences of the electrodes show that the in- focus electrodes are strongly correlated in both of the ictal interval and inter-ictal interval, Figs. 17 (a) and (b). Three further strong local or mixed cross-correlations come out in the inter-ictal interval; between the positions at k=4 and k=6, or k=1 and k=6, and k=2 and k=6, respectively. But, the non-local coupling between the sites at k=4 and k=6 weakens in the ictal interval. Please note that numerous time windows involving disconnections or very narrow signals (with zero index values) in the inter-ictal interval are omitted in Fig. 17 (b). CASE 5: Pat15 with Temporal Epilepsy The first four one-hour ictal data blocks with k=1-6 are continuous which cover two seizures as depicted in Figs. 18 (a) and (b). The pre- ictal state for the first onset starts at τ∼0.2 h and continues till τ∼0.9 h where the onset is experienced. The post-ictal state is not clear for this seizure. As a result, the pre-ictal state for the second seizure can be hardly detected. The second onset occurs at τ∼3.1 h and the post- ictal stage of this seizure continues till τ∼3.7 h without a doubt. Also the next three one-hour-data blocks with k=1,6 are continuous and they cover one seizure (Figs. 18 (a) and (c)) where the indices oscillate with big magnitudes. The oscillations are minor in the time interval between τ∼4.8 h and τ∼5.2 h which may be taken as the intermediate state. The pre-ictal state starts at τ∼5.2 h as distinguished in terms of collective behavior. In other words, the pin-like synchronous interdependencies start at that time and gain importance with time; namely, the maximum values ascend towards 1 and the frequency of the occurrences increase with time. At τ∼5.2 h, the integrated behavior reaches a climax, where all of the indices have nearly the same value which is very close to 1. Moreover, the indices drop two times; one during the seizure and one right after the seizure offset. The index values increase abruptly or gradually afterwards till τ∼5.85 h and this instant can be taken as - 10 - the termination of the post-ictal stage which indicates the completion of a seizure cycle. Note that, the electrode couplings continue till τ∼6.05 h with big index values which become close to 1 at τ∼6.3 h. The time epoch between τ∼5.85 h and τ∼6.05 h should be considered not as a part of the last post-ictal term but a new pre-ictal state for an unrealized onset at τ∼6.3 h. Two more similar inclinations which failed before an onset can be monitored in Fig. 18 (c). The related clinical evidence is not reported in [32]. The last seizure onset occurs at τ∼8.6 h in the interval 7.0 h<τ≤10.0 h which contains continuous data. The index values collectively increase towards 1 with various strength of the couplings several times before the onset; such as at τ∼7.3 h and τ∼7.9 h. Yet, the strong couplings start at τ∼8.3 h which can be taken as the beginning of the pre-ictal stage of the seizure and thus, this stage continues for nearly 20 minutes. An abrupt decrease in the index values occur within the seizure term and these decrements are followed by gradual increments. Hence, the seizure offsets before the completion of the gradual increment term. The values come close to each other around 0.95, that is, a few minutes after the offset and then the post-ictal state occurs and continues till τ∼7.3 h. All of the indicated seizures (four out of four) are detected in this case besides numerous pre-ictal stages of the assumed uncompleted seizure cycles. The pre-ictal or post-ictal transition terms of the realized seizures may last half an hour or longer. Thus, also the ED plots from the inter-ictal interval come out with noise and various deformations from Gauss in the range for the intermediate index values, as those from the ictal-interval in the declared range of the index values; see Figs. 19 (a) and (b). Moreover, the tails of the plots for the big values in Fig. 19 (b) indicate that, the inter-ictal data involve several pre-ictal stages for uncompleted seizure cycles which are manifest also in the time profiles (not shown). Furthermore, the couplings between all of the electrodes, with the exception of the one at k=4 are strong during the ictal-interval with long durations. The individual behavior of the electrode at k=4 is clear in the ED plots for the spatial differences from ictal interval and inter-ictal interval in Figs. 20 (a) and (b), respectively. Note that no strong cross-correlations involve data from the site at k=4 in both of the intervals. Moreover, the groups of the ED plots for D4,5 and D4,6 (local) or D1,4, D2,4 and D3,4 (non-local) are similar to each other and the groups of the plots are nearly anti-symmetric about zero in the ictal interval (Fig. 20 (a)). This anti-symmetry is exemplified in Fig. 21 (a) within the three-hour-continuous data which cover the third seizure term as in Fig. 18 (c). This anti- symmetry occurs since the plots of D1,4, D2,4, D3,4, and -D4,5 (=D5,4) and -D4,6 (=D6,4) come out similar. In other words, the index from the electrode at k=4 follow a different trajectory than the other electrodes where the differences in the trajectories of the indices from the electrodes with k≠4 can be neglected (the central group in Fig. 20 (a)). As a result, the plots of Dk,4 with k≠4 come out similar. Therefore, all of the brain sites except at k=4 couple strongly in the ictal interval of this patient. Fig. 21 (b) is the same as Fig. 21 (a) for a shorter time range and for all of the electrode couplings, where the following properties are inspected: All of the electrodes are coupled strongly for a while which implies that the brain electricity is unified at every site in these time terms. Moreover, the seizure offsets whilst the electricity is unique. The couplings become strong once again at τ∼6.8 h with a longer duration. Fig. 21 (c) covers the last seizure where a similar behavior to the one described in the last lines of the previous paragraph is manifest yet the offset occurs during the strong couplings of the brain sites. The time profiles of the successive time differences of the individual recordings display the temporal couplings and their values are distributed symmetrically and exponentially around zero as in the previous cases (not shown). - 11 - CASE 6: Pat09 with Temporo/Occipital Epilepsy The continuously updated index values of the patient oscillate with big magnitudes in ictal interval (Fig. 22 (a)) where, four out of five of the indicated seizures are detected and several false alerts are obtained. The beginning of the pre-ictal stage for the first seizure (τ∼1.05 h) is not clear. Weak couplings with short durations are inspected at the beginning of the first one-hour-data-blocks with k=1-6. These weakly synchronized interdependencies become stronger and the event frequencies increase with the time. The post-ictal stage continues nearly 20 minutes after the offset and several pin-like formations appear afterwards till τ∼2.0 h, which is the end of the first set of continuous one-hour-data-blocks. The data for 2 h<τ≤6 h are also continuous and they involve two seizures (Fig. 22 (a)) which are accompanied by clear pre-ictal states with the time durations of nearly 30 minutes. These pre-ictal states can be distinguished from the intermediate-states in terms of the increasing number of strong couplings with time. Whereas, the time durations of the post-ictal states of these seizures are shorter than these of the pre- ictal ones. The most interesting feature in the results from the patient is the strong couplings between all of the electrodes at 8.1 h<τ<8.4 h which continue for nearly 20 minutes (Figs. 22 (a) and (b)). Nearly at the beginning of the eighth one-hour-data-blocks (010906ea_0070_k with k=1- 6), the entropies of the individual recordings follow each other very closely for about nearly 20 minutes yet no seizure is indicated in [32] for the current interval. Note that a similar formation occurs also in the data from the inter-ictal interval as displayed in Fig. 22 (c), where the data are continuous along the interval. The ED plots of the index values from the ictal interval (Fig. 23 (a)) and inter-ictal interval (Fig. 23 (b)) are capable of distinguishing these intervals, clearly. Note that the electrodes do not exchange partners in the regime for small index values and the out focus electrode at k=6 is coupled with the in-focus electrodes in both of the intervals. The maximum values of the indices are very close to 1 with very broad or homogeneous signals as in CASE 2. The cross-correlations between the electrodes at k=5 and k=6 are strong in the ictal and inter-ictal interval where the ED plots for these correlations and that for the group of D1,5, D2,4, D3,4 and D3,5 are anti-symmetric. The temporal differences of the individual recordings do not provide additional information since they are similar to those from the other patients. These two subjects are further discussed in the next section. In summary, nearly 700 million ictal or inter-ictal EEG data intracerebrally recorded from 20 patients with different ages, genders, origins of the epilepsy, seizure types and electrode types or insertion places are investigated in terms of the continuously updated entropy indices χk(τ) with k=1-6. A common property predicted in the results, which are exemplified in detail for 6 patients, is that the index values increase and then decrease several times before the imminent seizures and reach at locally maximum values close to 1 during the onsets. The characteristic features of these similarities are: 1) The indices from the ictal interval may fluctuate about different values for different k with weak couplings. This era may be called the intermediate (inter-ictal) state during which no seizure is expected to occur soon. 2) When the number of the couplings per a given time interval and their strength increase with the time, this means that the patient is approaching an onset of a seizure. This era stars 20-30 minutes before the onset and it may be called the pre-ictal state. If the tops; namely, the local maximum values of the entropy indices increase and the synchronizations cover more univariates from different brain sites then the onset is expected to occur within a few minutes. 3) The detected seizure onsets are accompanied by synchronized and strong couplings in the entropy indices with values very close to 1. This means that the brain signals are unified at several sites and broad during these seizures. 4) The indices relax after the offsets gradually in most of the cases or abruptly in forms downward pin-like formations in a few cases; as in - 12 - Case 5, for example). This era may be taken as the post-ictal stage which continues for 20-30 minutes usually. It may be remarked that the synchronization in the EEG signals can be monitored as a parallelization in the time profiles of the entropy indices or their successive time differences, χ’k(τ) or χ’’k(τ). The time courses of variation of these parallel behaviors are investigated also in terms of the electrode couplings in order to better understand the underlying mechanisms. Discussion and conclusion: The presented approach provides a reasonable description of various spatiotemporal similarities in between the brain states before, during and after the captured seizures. These similarities are predicted to be cyclic spatiotemporal synchronization (coupling) of the brain sites where the spatial couplings may be local; namely, between two (or three) in-focus electrodes or between two (or three) out-focus ones, or non-local; namely, between numerous in-focus and out-focus electrodes. Moreover, the durations of these partnerships or the partner sites may change with time. The patterns of the integrated neuronal behavior observed in the entropy indices, as well as in the spatiotemporal differences (approximate derivatives) of the indices, come out patient- specific, which may be related to psychological fluctuations such as, vigilance (wakefulness, drowsiness or sleep), attention and anxiety in a patient. These interrelationships are found to be weak and infrequent in the inter-ictal intervals and when they intermittently evolve into strong and frequent ones then this stage is distinguished as a pre-ictal state. Thus, the epileptogenic processes are predicted to be intermittent. Similar results are reported in [58] where long-term intracranial recordings of five patients by employing a measure of phase synchronization are investigated. Furthermore, it is observed that extremely strong couplings occur between the brain sites during the predicted seizure onsets and the transitions from these onsets to post-ictal or inter- ictal stages also follow patient-specific patterns in the time profiles of the entropy indices and their spatiotemporal differences. As a result, all of the patterns in these time profiles are clearly patient dependent. Therefore, not only the epileptogenic processes but also the relaxation processes are patient-specific, intermittent and cyclic where a cycle for the entire ictal process consists of three stages: (pre-ictal) preparation for, (ictal) realization of and (post-ictal) recovery from a seizure. However, the distributions of the values of the first order successive time derivatives of the indices (Eq. (6)) seem patient independent as displayed in Fig. 24 where all of the available data in [32] from 20 patients in ictal interval or inter-ictal interval are used. (The total number of the utilized time windows with no disconnection or non-zero entropy values in Fig. 24 is 234,879.) It should be noted that the plots of these distributions are symmetric and exponentially decreasing for each of the patients in ictal interval or inter-ictal interval as considered in the previous section for various cases. Moreover, the ED plots of the values of the second order successive time derivatives (Eq. (7)) come out similar to those in Fig. 24. It can be claimed that the distribution curves of χ’k(τ) and χk’’(τ) with k=1-6 are similar not only for focal epilepsies but for all of the epileptic and possibly healthy brains. (The tails, for the big magnitudes, will come out presumably clear for healthy brains). Furthermore, the presented approach can be considered successful since nineteen out of the twenty six studied seizures are captured as discussed in detail in the previous section. This constitutes a more than 70 % success rate. A similar success rate is achieved also in [58]. The types or insertion places of the used in-focus or out-focus electrodes are different (Fig. 1). Hence, the capability of the marker z(τ) (Eq. (4)) to capture the seizure onsets may change from one case to the other. Moreover, a smoothed version of z(τ) (namely, the application of a known smoothing function on z(τ)) or averages of z(τ) over a fixed number of the backward - 13 - or forward time windows at a time τ, may yield more precise detections where some big powers of χk(τ) or χk’(τ) can also be utilized in Eq. (4). It can be expected that the accuracy of the results may depend on the length of the time windows used due to the non-stationary character of the epileptic EEG signals. Length dependence: Various analyses of magnitude square coherence and phase coherence, entropy or entropy and complexity show that the results depend on the data length; see Table 1 in [59] and the results in [60] or [61], respectively. In the results of this work presented above, the window length is 10 seconds. Thus each window involves 2560 data per electrode (k), since the sampling rate is 256 Hz. Therefore, numerous bins in the ED of the EEG voltages (Qk(i) in Eq. (1)) come out empty (Qk(i)=0) since the bin size is 1 μV and the range of the voltages is from -10,000 μV to 10,000 μV or broader. Hence, the window length may be crucial for the results, especially when a spiky behavior or narrow or broad signal is dominant in a given epoch. In this case, longer time windows can be used in order to reduce the effect of these irregularities on the results and to avoid abnormal values for the indices. The values of the entropy indices decrease to zero before various indicated disconnections occur during the data registration in [32]. For example, in CASE 3 in the Results section, the index values of the Pat20 in the ictal interval descend towards zero at τ∼6.4 h (Fig. 13 (a)) and the values remain zero till a disconnection occurs in the data registration nearly 30 minutes later; namely, at τ∼6.9 h (i=837632 with k=1-6). This appearance is observed in the EEG from the same patient in the inter-ictal interval or from different patients in both of the intervals. Hence, there may be a causal relationship between several irregular behaviors in the EEG signals and the simultaneous clinical symptoms of the relevant patients before the disconnections. These symptoms are not reported in [32]. Moreover, the effect of these irregular data may be reduced in the entropy estimations when longer time windows are used as exemplified in Fig. 25(b). Figs. 25 (a)-(c) are obtained using time windows of length 100 seconds in the presented approach. In Figs. 25 (a) and (b), the index values come out smaller than those in Fig. 13 (a)- (c) by a factor of nearly 1.3 (∼10.15/7.85=∼ln(25600)/ln(2560), see Eq. (3)). The time domain of Fig. 25 (a) is the same as that of Fig. 13 (b) where the following three features can be clearly observed: the ictal cycle of the experienced onset at τ∼1.9 h, several unsuccessful inclinations for a seizure before the onset and the individual behavior of χ4(τ) (thick line in dark cyan in Fig. 25 (a)). The individual behavior of χ4(τ) can also be observed in Fig. 25 (b) where the data contains a disconnection as discussed in the previous paragraph and Results section (CASE 3: Pat20). It must be noted that the index values are non-zero also after τ∼6.4 h till the occurrence of the disconnection at τ∼6.9 h in Fig. 25 (b). The successive differences of the indices (χk’(τ)) with the newly used longer time windows (Δτ=100 seconds in Eq. (6)) are displayed in Fig. 25 (c) where the time domain includes the first indicated seizure of the Pat20, at τ∼1.8 h which was undetected previously. The patterns obviously depend on the length of the time windows; however, the characteristic features of the results (for example, the cyclic topographies of the ictal patterns) remain invariant within reasonable limits for the length of the time windows. Couplings and brain electricity: If the entropy indices from the brain sites at k and k’ are similar (χk(τ)↔χk’(τ)) in a time interval then these sites are called coupled or synchronously interdependent in this work as referred to above. Thus, the four fundamental states of an epileptic brain; namely, the inter-ictal, pre-ictal, ictal and post-ictal states can be distinguished in terms of the simultaneous interrelationships. The couplings are found to be infrequent and - 14 - weak in an inter-ictal stage, as in [19] for healthy brains. The event frequency and strength of the couplings usually increase with time in a pre-ictal state [20 and 21] and they decline after the offsets for a post-ictal stage. In the meantime the strengths reach a climax for a few minutes for a seizure. If the number of the coupled brain sites also increase in a pre-ictal state then the brain electricity and possibly the seizure may be taken as spreading. Various similarities between the brain electricity recorded from different sites are detected in this contribution for different cases and thus the spread of the brain electricity is discussed. However, these results could not be associated with the seizure types because no further information about the individual seizure types is available in [32]. In other words, the predictive power of the presented approach depends on the number and strength of the brain couplings at a time. Thus, if a seizure onset occurs either with weak or a few brain couplings then it could not be detected. It is not known which of the noted seizure types [32]; namely, simple partial (SP), complex partial (CP) or generalized tonic-clonic (GTC) onsets fits which of the investigated seizures. The presented approach might provide statistical evidence between a seizure type and brain couplings if individual seizure types were known. Let us consider the aforementioned (two paragraphs above) similarity between the two entropy index trajectories, χk(τ) and χk’(τ). It is clear that, if (χk(τ)↔χk’(τ)) then (χk(τ)- χk’’(τ))↔(χk’(τ)-χk’’(τ)). Thus, Dk,k’(τ)↔0 and Dk,k’’(τ)↔Dk’,k’’(τ). Such a situation was considered in CASE 1 for the Pat03 in the Results section where D1,3(τ)↔0 and D1,2(τ)↔ -D2,3(τ)=D3,2(τ) for 1 h<τ< 2 h which covers a seizure with unknown type, (Fig. 7 (c)). Another example is given in CASE 2 for the Pat14 as depicted in Fig. 11 (a) where D1,5(τ)↔D2,5(τ) (dotted lines) as a result D1,2(τ)↔0 as shown in Fig 12 (a). Thus, if two brain sites k and k’ are coupled strongly then Dk,k’’(τ) and Dk’,k’’(τ) with k’’≠k’≠k, follow each other very closely. The stronger is the coupling between the brain sites at k and k’, the smaller is the difference between the trajectorıes of Dk,k’’(τ) and Dk’,k’’(τ) in a given time epoch. In this case, the ED plots for Dk,k’’(τ), Dk’,k’’(τ) and Dk,k’(τ) coincide with each other about the zero. Therefore, the modes of the ED plots of Dk,k’’(τ) and Dk’,k’’(τ) are far from or close to each other if that of Dk,k’(τ) is far from or close to zero, respectively. See, the trajectories of various spatial differences in Figs. 7 (a) and (b), 11 (a)-(c), and 21 (a)-(c) and their ED plots in Figs. 8 (a) and (b), 12 (a)-(d), and 20 (a), respectively. - 15 - APPENDIX Suppose that the number of the samples X(i) in a finite set is N. Let us consider Eq. (1) in the main text with P(X(i))=Q(X(i))/N where P(X(i))=P(i) and Q(X(i))=Q(i) are the normalized and un normalized empirical distributions of X(i), respectively and 1 ≤ i ≤ N; U = -N∑N i=1P(i)log(NP(i)) (A1) (A5) (A3) (A6) (A2) (A4) U/N = S - log(N) U = NS - Nlog(N) U/(Nlog(N)) = S/log(N) - 1 1 + U/(Nlog(N)) = S/log(N) = χ i=1(P(i)log(P(i) + P(i)log(N)) U = -N∑N or or since P is normalized, ∑N i=1P(i)=1. Thus, or or where χ is the same as the index in Eq. (2) in the main text. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The author is thankful to the University of Freiburg for their kindness in giving permission to investigate their database and use all of the related material. - 16 - REFERENCE LIST [1] F. H. Lopes da Silva, EEG analysis: theory and practice; in: E. Niedermeyer, F. H. Lopes da Silva, eds. Electroencephalography: basic principles, clinical applications and related fields, Baltimore: Williams and Wilkins, 3rd ed. 1993. [2] F.H. Lopes da Silva, S. van Leeuwen, A. Réemond, Handbook of Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology, Vol. II: Clinical Application of Computer Analysis of EEG and Other Neurophysiological Signals, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1986. [3] F. H. Lopes Silva, A. Hoeks, T. H. M. T. van Lierop, C. F. Schrijer and W. S. van Leeuwen, Confidence intervals of spectra and coherence functions—Their relevance for quantifying thalamo-cortical relationships; in Quantitative Analysis of the EEG M. Matejcek and G. K. Schenk, eds. AEG Telefunken, Constanz, 1975. [4] P. Kellawou and I. Peterson, Automation of Clinical EEG, eds. New York: Raven, 1973. [5] S. Faula, G. Boylanb, S. Connollyc, L. Marnanea, G. Lightbodya, An evaluation of automated neonatal seizure detection methods, Clinical Neurophysiology 116, 1533, 2005. [6] J. D. Bronzino, M. L. Kelly, C. T. Cordova, N. H. Oley, and P. J. M., Utilization of Amplitude Histographs to Quantify the EEG Effects of Systemic Administration of Morphine in the Chronically Implanted Rat, IEEE BME-28, 673, 1981. [7] J. S. Barlow, Computerized Clinical Electroencephalography in Perspective, IEEE BME- 26, 377, 1979. [8] A. S. Gevins, C. L. Yeager, S. L. Diamond, J.-P. Spire, G. M. Zeitlin, and A. H. Gevins, Automated analysis of the electrical activity of the human brain (EEG): A progress report, Proc. IEEE, vol. 63, 1382, 1975. [9] Y.U. Khan and J. Gotman, Wavelet based automatic seizure detection in intracerebral Electroencephalogram, Clinical Neurophysiology 114, 898, 2003. [10] C. D. Binnie, B. G. Batchelor, P. A. Bowring, C. E. Darby, L. Herbert, D. S. L. Lloyd, D. M. Smith, G. F. Smith, and M. Smith, Computer-assisted interpretation of clinical EEGs, Electroencephalogr. Clinical Neurophysiology, 44, 575, 1978. [11] H. W. Shipton, EEG analysis: A history and a prospective, Annu. Rev. Biophys. Bioeng., 4, 1, 1975. [12] N. V. Thakor and S. Tong, Advances in quantitative electroencephalogram analysis methods. Annu. Rev. Biomed. Eng. 6, 453, 2004. [13] I. Osorio, M-G. Frei, S. B. Wilkinson. Real-time automated detection and quantitative analysis of seizures and short-term prediction of clinical onset, Epilepsia, 39, 615, 1998. [14] T. Kreuz, F. Mormann, R. G. Andrzejak, A. Kraskov, K. Lehnertz, P. Grassberger, Measuring synchronization in coupled model systems: A comparison of different approaches, Physica D 225, 29, 2007. [15] F. H. Lopes da Silva, W. Blanes, S. Kalitzin, J. Parra, P. Suffczynski, D. Velis, Dynamical diseases of brain systems: different routes of epileptic seizures. IEEE BME-50, 540, 2003. [16] R. G. Andrzejak, D. Chicharro, C. E. Elger, F. Mormann, Seizure prediction: Any better than chance?, Clinical Neurophysiology 120, 1465, 2009. [17] M. Le Van Quyen, J. Martinerie, C. Adam, F. Varela, Nonlinear analyses of interictal EEG map the interdependencies in human focal epilepsy. Physica D, 127, 250, 1999. [18] J. Arnhold, P. Grassberger, K. Lehnertz, C. Elger, A robust method for detecting interdependencies: application to intracranially recorded EEG. Physica D, 134, 419, 1999. [19] C. Stam, J. Pijn, P. Suffczynski, F. H. Lopes da Silva, Dynamics of the alpha rhythm: evidence for non-linearity? Clinical Neurophysiology 110, 1801, 1999. - 17 - [20] F. Mormann, T. Kreuz, C. Rieke, R. G. Andrzejak, A. Kraskov, P. David, C. E. Elger, Klaus Lehnertz, On the predictability of epileptic seizures, Clinical Neurophysiology 116, 569, 2005. [21] F. Mormann, R. G. Andrzejak, C. E. Elger and K. Lehnertz, Seizure prediction: the long and winding road, Brain, 130, 314, 2007. [22] M. E. Weinand, L. P. Carter, W. F. El-Saadany, P. J. Sioutos, D. M. Labiner, K. J. Oommen, Cerebral blood flow and temporal lobe epileptogenicity, J. Neurosurg, 86, 226, 1997. [23] C. Baumgartner, W. Serles, F. Leutmezer, E. Pataraia, S. Aull, T. Czech, U. Pietrzyk, A. Relic, I. Podreka, Preictal SPECT in temporal lobe epilepsy: regional cerebral blood flow is increased prior to electroencephalography-seizure onset, J. Nucl. Med. 39, 978, 1998. [24] P. D. Adelson, E. Nemoto, M. Scheuer, M. Painter, J. Morgan, H. Yonas, Noninvasive continuous monitoring of cerebral oxygenation periictally using nearinfrared spectroscopy: a preliminary report. Epilepsia 40, 1484, 1999. [25] P. Federico P, D. F. Abbott, R. S. Briellmann, A. S. Harvey, G. D. Jackson, Functional MRI of the pre-ictal state, Brain 128, 1811, 2005. [26] R. Delamont, P. Julu, G. Jamal, Changes in a measure of cardiac vagal activity before and after epileptic seizures, Epilepsy Res., 35, 87, 1999. [27] V. Novak, A. L. Reeves, P. Novak, P. A. Low, F. W. Sharbrough, Time-frequency mapping of R-R interval during complex partial seizures of temporal lobe origin. J. Auton Nerv. Syst. 77, 195, 1999. [28] D. H. Kerem and A. B. Geva, Forecasting epilepsy from the heart rate signal, Med. Biol. Eng. Comput. 43, 230, 2005. [29] E. Pereda, R. Q. Quiroga, J. Bhattacharya, Nonlinear multivariate analysis of neurophysiological signals, Progress in Neurobiology, 77, 1, 2005. [30] M.J. van der Heydena, D.N. Velis, B.P.T. Hoekstra, J.P.M. Pijn, W. van Emde Boas, C. W. M. van Veelen, P.C. van Rijen, F.H. Lopes da Silva, J. De Goede, Non-linear analysis of intracranial human EEG in temporal lobe epilepsy, Clinical Neurophysiology 110, 1726, 1999. [31] T. Schreiber, Interdisciplinary application of nonlinear time series methods, Physics Reports 308, 1, 1999. [32] Freiburg University, http://epilepsy.uni-freiburg.de/prediction-contest/data-download [33] B. Bein, Entropy, Best Practice & Research Clinical Anaesthesiology 20, 101, 2006. [34] P. Viola, N. N. Schraudolph, T. J. Sejnowski, Empirical Entropy Manipulation for Real- World Problems, in Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 8 (NIPS*96), D. Touretzky, M. Mozer and M. Wasselmo (eds.), MIT Press, 1996; pp.851-857. [35] A. Isaksson, A. Wennberg, L. H. Zetterberg, Computer Analysis of EEG Signals with Parametric Models, PROCEEDINGS OF THE IEEE, 69, 451, 1981. [36] A. Bezerianos, S. Tong S, N. Thakor, Time-dependent entropy estimation of EEG rhythm changes following brain ischemia, Ann. Biomed. Eng, 31, 221, 2003. [37] C. E. Shannon, W. Weaver, The Mathematical Theory of Communication, University of Illinois Press, Urbana, 1948. [38] C. E. Shannon, Bell Systems Technol. J. 27, 379, 1948. [39] S. M. Zoldi, A. Krystal, H. S. Greenside, Stationarity and Redundancy of Multichannel EEG Data Recorded During Generalized Tonic-Clonic Seizures, Brain Topography, 12, 187, 2000. [40] M. Breakspear and J.R. Terry, Detection and description of non-linear interdependence in normal multichannel human EEG data, Clinical Neurophysiology 113, 735, 2002. [41] J. S. Richman and J. R. Moorman, Physiological time-series analysis using approximate entropy and sample entropy, Am. J. Physiol. Heart. Circ. Physiol. 278, 2039, 2000. - 18 - [42] O. Vasicek, A Test for Normality Based on Sample Entropy, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society B, 38, 54, 1976. [43] E. J. Dudewicz and E. C. van der Meulen, Entropy-Based Tests of Uniformity, Journal of the American Statistical Association, 76, 967, 1981. [44] S. Park, A goodness-of-fit test for normality based on the sample entropy of order statistics, Statistics & Probability Letters, 44, 359, 1999. [45] R. A.H. Lorentz, On the entropy of a function, Journal of Approximation Theory, 158, 145, 2009. [46] J. Timmer, from Freiburg University (private communication). [47] R. Aschenbrenner-Scheibe, T. Maiwald T, M. Winterhalder, H. U. Voss, J. Timmer, A. Schulze-Bonhage, How well can epileptic seizures be predicted? An evaluation of a nonlinear method, Brain, 126, 2616, 2003. [48] M. Winterhalder, B. Schelter, T. Maiwald, A. Brandt, A. Schad, A. Schulze-Bonhage, J. Timmer, Spatio-temporal patient-individual assessment of synchronization changes for epileptic seizure prediction. Clinical Neurophysiology 117, 2399, 2006. [49] M. Winterhalder, T. Maiwald T, H. U. Voss, R. Aschenbrenner-Scheibe, J. Timmer, A. Schulze-Bonhage, The seizure prediction characteristic: a general framework to assess and compare seizure prediction methods, Epilepsy Behav., 4(3), 318, 2003. [50] T. Maiwald, M. Winterhalder, R. Aschenbrenner-Scheibe R, H. U. Voss, A. Schulze- Bonhage, J. Timmer, Comparison of three nonlinear seizure prediction methods by means of the seizure prediction characteristic, Physica D, 194, 2004. [51] B. Schelter, M. Winterhalder, T. Maiwald, A. Brandt, A. Schad, J. Timmer, A. Schulze- Bonhage.: Do false predictions of seizures depend on the state of vigilance? A report from two seizure prediction methods and proposed remedies, Epilepsia, 47, 2058, 2006. [52] B. Schelter, M. Winterhalder, T. Maiwald, A. Brandt, A. Schad, A. Schulze-Bonhage, and J. Timmer Testing statistical significance of multivariate time series analysis techniques for epileptic seizure prediction, Chaos 16, 013108, 2006. [53] J. Bruhn, L. E. Lehmann, H. Ropcke, T. W. Bouillon, A. Hoeft, Shannon entropy applied to the measurement of the electroencephalographic effects of desflurane, Anesthesiology, 95, 30, 2001. [54] I. J. Rampil, A primer for EEG signal processing in anesthesia, Anesthesiology, 89, 980, 1998. [55] W. D. Smith, R. C. Dutton, N. T. Smith, Measuring the performance of anesthetic depth indicators, Anesthesiology 84, 38, 1996. [56] D. T.J. Liley, K. Leslie, N. C. Sinclair, M. Feckie, Dissociating the effects of nitrous oxide on brain electrical activity using fixed order time series modeling, Computers in Biology and Medicine, 38, 1121, 2008. [58] M. Le Van Quyen, J. Soss, V. Navarro, R. Robertson, M. Chavez, M. Baulac, J. Martinerie, Preictal state identification by synchronization changes in long-term intracranial EEG recordings, Clinical Neurophysiology 116, 559, 2005. [59] S. Whiting, T. Ning, and J. D. Bronzino, Data length effects on the coherence estimate of EEG, Bioengineering Conference, 1989., Proceedings of the 1989 Fifteenth Annual Northeast, page 93, 1989. [60] T. D. de Wit, When do finite sample effects significantly affect entropy estimates? Eur. Phys. J. B 11, 513, 1999. [61] M. A. Jime´nez-Montano, W. Ebeling, T. Pohl, Paul E. Rapp, Entropy and complexity of finite sequences as fluctuating quantities, BioSystems 64, 23, 2002. - 19 - TABLES CP,GTC Pat11 10,f Pat14 41,f Frontal G_A4, IH4, IH3; G_D2, IHA1, IH1 Pat01 SP,CP 15,f Pat03 14,m SP,CP FE1, FE2, FD1; G_F8, G_G8, G_H8 SP,CP,GTC G_A3, G_A4, IHB4; G_D1, IHB1, LL1 Pat05 16,f FRA2, FRA3, FRC1; G_A8, FLA4, FLC6 Pat08 32,f SP,CP Pat18 25,f G_A7, G_C5, G_E5; IHC4, IHB4, G_F3 SP,CP SP,CP,GTC G_B5, G_D8, G_G7; G_C1, G_A1, G_H4 Pat19 28,f Fronto/Temporal FRA1, FRB1, TRB2; TRA1, TRC1, TRC6 Tempo/Parietal Pat20 33,m SP,CP,GTC G_D3, G_B4, G_A2; H_5, FLB4, TLC1 Parietal SP,CP,GTC G_G3, G_G4, G_E3; G_C8, G_D8, G_F7 Temporal SP,CP,GTC HR_2, HR_5, TBB1; HR_9, G_D6, G_A1 Pat04 26,f Pat07 SP,CP,GTC TLA1, TLB2, TLC2; TLA5, TLB5, TLC6 42,f Pat10 47,m SP,CP,GTC TLA1, TLB1, TLB2; TRB2, TRC2, TRC5 Pat12 42,f SP,CP,GTC TBA4, TBB6, HR_7; TLB2, TLB3, TLC2 Pat15 31,m SP,CP,GTC TBA1, TLR4, TLA4; HR_8, FRA6, FRB3 Pat16 50,f SP,CP,GTC HL_2, HL_3, TBB1; G_H1, HL_9, TBC2 Pat17 28,m SP,CP,GTC TBA1, TBA2, TLA1; G_B5, G_B8, G_C5 TBB1, G_E6, TBA3; G_A2, G_B2, G_C2 Pat21 13,m SP,CP Temporo/Occipital Pat06 31,f TLC1, TLC2, OBB1; TRC1, GD8, OBB4 CP,GTC Pat09 44,m CP,GTC TBA3, TBB2, TBC4; G_A1, G_A8, TBC1 Pat13 22,f SP,CP,GTC TBC1, TBC2, TBB1; POA1, POB1, TRA1 Table I Brief information about the patients with focal epilepsies [32] grouped with regard to the origins of the epilepsies. The patients are designated on the left column (PatNM) and the numbers on the second column show the ages where f or m stands for female or male, respectively. The seizure types are shown on the third column which are simple partial (SP), complex partial (CP) or generalized tonic-clonic (GTC). The first three of the electrodes given on the fourth column are in-focus and the others (after the semicolons) are out-focus. - 20 - FIGURES Figure 1 The available electrode types and contact positions of the declared patients where the red and blue dots indicate in-focus or out-focus electrodes, respectively [32]. - 21 - 1.0 0.9 k χ 0.8 1.0 0.9 k χ 0.8 Pat03 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 1M 100k 10k 1k 100 z Pat03 inter-ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 1M 100k 10k 1k 100 z 0.7 10 0.7 3 2 1 0 8 7 6 5 4 τ (hour) 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 τ (hour) (b) (a) Figure 2 The time profiles of the entropy indices for the available [32] ictal (a) and inter-ictal (b) data from the Pat03 (see, Table I) where the arrows in (a) indicate the seizure terms. The black line at the bottom is for z(τ) in the plots. 0 2 4 6 8 1.0 0.9 k χ 0.8 1.0 0.9 k χ 0.8 Pat03 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 1M 100k 10k 1k 100 z Pat03 inter-ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 1M 100k 10k 1k 100 z 0.7 10 0.7 2 0 1 τ (hour) 21 τ (hour) (b) (a) Figure 3 The plots (a) and (b) are same as Figs. 2 (a) and (b), respectively where the time domains are different. 20 22 10 10 1.0 0.9 k χ 0.8 0.7 2 Figure 4 1.0 k χ 0.9 Pat03 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 1M 100k 10k 1k 100 z 1.0 0.9 k χ 0.8 Pat03 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 1M 100k 10k 1k 100 z 10 4 3 τ (hour) τ (hour) (b) (a) The plots are same as Figs. 2 (a) with different time domains. 5 10 6 0.7 4 Pat03 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.08 k ' χ 0.00 Pat03 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.8 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 τ (hour) (a) 1.8 1.9 2.0 -0.08 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.8 1.9 2.0 1.7 τ (hour) (b) - 22 - 0.14 0.00 k ' ' χ Pat03 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 -0.14 1.4 1.8 1.9 1.5 2.0 1.7 1.6 τ (hour) (c) Figure 5 The time series of χk(τ) is depicted in (a) which is same as with 3 (a) for a shorter time domain. The successive time differences χ’k(τ) and χ’’k(τ) are displayed in (b) and (c), respectively with the same time domain as in (a), here. 1k 100 10 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( s t n u o c 1 0.8 Pat03 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.9 χ 1.0 1k 100 10 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( s t n u o c 1 0.8 Pat03 inter-ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.9 χ 1.0 (a) (b) Figure 6 The distributions of the entropy index values for all of the data from the patient in ictal interval (a) and in inter-ictal interval (b). 0.1 ' k , k D 0.0 Pat03 ictal D1,2 D1,3 D2,3 0.1 0.0 ' k , k D Pat03 ictal D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 -0.1 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 τ (hour) 1.8 2.0 (a) -0.1 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 τ (hour) 1.8 2.0 (b) 0.1 0.0 ' k , k D Pat03 ictal D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 -0.1 0 1 2 3 5 4 τ (hour) 6 7 8 (c) - 23 - Figure 7 The synchronous differences of the entropy index values of the in-focus electrodes (a) and out-focus electrodes (b) and (c) of the patient in ictal interval. Pat03 ictal D1,2 D1,3 D2,3 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 0.00 0.08 1k 100 10 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = D δ ( s t n u o c 1 -0.1 Pat03 inter-ictal D1,2 D1,3 D2,3 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 0.0 0.1 Dk,k' Dk,k' (a) (b) Figure 8 The distribution of the values of the synchronous spatial differences of the in- focus electrodes of the Pat03 in ictal interval (a) and in inter-ictal interval (b). 1k 100 10 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = D δ ( s t n u o c 1 -0.08 0 1 2 1.0 k χ 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 1.0 k χ 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 4 5 6 τ (hour) (d) (c) Figure 9 Entropy index profiles from the Pat14 in ictal interval and in inter-ictal interval are shown in (a)-(c) and (d), respectively with different time domains. 21.3 21.4 τ (hour) 21.5 1k 100 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( s t n u o c 10 1 Pat14 inter-ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.6 0.7 0.8 χ 0.9 1.0 Pat14 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 1k 100 10 1 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( s t n u o c - 24 - 0.6 0.7 0.8 χ 0.9 1.0 10k 1k 100 Pat14 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 10 z 1 1.0 k χ 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 1 τ (hour) (b) 6 7 5 4 3 τ (hour) (a) 1.0 k χ 0.5 0.0 21.2 10k 1k 100 Pat14 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 10 z 1 7 10k 1k 100 Pat14 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 10 z 1 2 Pat14 inter-ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 (a) (b) Figure 10 The ED of the index values of the EEG from the Pat14 in ictal interval (a) and in inter-ictal interval where the tails are noisy due to several irregular behaviors in the data. 0.18 0.09 ' k , k D 0.00 Pat14 ictal D1,5 D2,3 D2,4 D2,5 0.1 ' k , k D 0.0 -0.1 Pat14 ictal D3,4 D3,5 D3,6 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 -0.09 3.0 3.2 3.4 3.6 τ (hour) 3.8 4.0 3.0 3.2 3.4 3.6 τ (hour) 3.8 4.0 (b) (a) 0.2 ' k , k D 0.0 -0.2 5 6 τ (hour) 7 Pat14 ictal D1,2 D1,3 D1,4 D1,5 D1,6 D2,3 D2,4 D2,5 D2,6 D3,4 D3,5 D3,6 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 (c) Figure 11 The time profiles of several local and non-local electrode couplings about the same (a) and (b) or different seizure terms (c). 100 10 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = D δ ( s t n u o c 1 -0.1 Pat14 ictal D1,2 D1,3 D1,5 D2,3 D2,5 0.0 0.1 Dk,k' 0.2 100 10 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = D δ ( s t n u o c 1 -0.2 Pat14 ictal D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 -0.1 Dk,k' 0.0 0.1 (a) (b) - 25 - 100 10 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = D δ ( s t n u o c 1 -0.2 Pat14 ictal D1,2 D1,3 D2,3 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 1k 100 10 1 -0.2 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = D δ ( s t n u o c -0.1 0.0 Dk,k' 0.1 Pat14 inter-ictal D1,2 D1,3 D2,3 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 -0.1 0.0 Dk,k' 0.1 0.2 (d) (c) Figure 12 Various cross-correlations between the in-focus and out-focus electrodes of the patient in ictal interval (a)-(c) and in inter-ictal interval (b). 1.0 k χ 0.9 0.8 0.7 1.0 k χ 0.9 0 1 2 3 4 5 9 10 11 12 13 8 6 7 τ (hour) (a) 1.0 k χ 0.9 0.8 0.7 0 1 2 τ (hour) (b) 100k 10k 1k Pat20 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 100 z 10 3 100k 10k 1k Pat20 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 100 z 10 Pat20 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.8 1.8 2.0 2.2 2.4 τ (hour) (c) Figure 13 The time profiles of the indices of the Pat20 in ictal interval with different time domains (a)-(c). 1k 100 10 1 0.8 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( s t n u o c Pat20 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 1k 100 10 1 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( s t n u o c Pat20 inter-ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.9 χ 1.0 0.8 0.9 χ 1.0 (b) (a) Figure 14 The ED plots for the index values from the Pat20 in ictal interval (a) and in inter-ictal interval (b). - 26 - 1.0 k χ 0.9 0.8 0.7 1.0 k χ 0.9 1.0 k χ 0.9 Pat11 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 100k 10k 1k z 100 Pat11 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 100k 10k 1k z 100 0 1 2 3 (a) 4 τ (hour) 5 6 7 8 0.8 2 3 5 6 4 τ (hour) (b) Pat11 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 100k 10k 1k z 100 0.8 6 8 7 τ (hour) (c) Figure 15 The time profiles of the ictal entropy indices of the Pat11 in (a)-(c) with various time domains. 1k 100 10 1 0.8 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( s t n u o c Pat11 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.9 χ 1.0 1k 100 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( s t n u o c 10 1 0.8 Pat11 inter-ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.9 χ 1.0 (b) (a) Figure 16 The ED plots of the index values of the Pat11 in ictal interval (a) and in inter- ictal-interval (b). - 27 - 1k 100 10 1 -0.05 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = D δ ( s t n u o c Pat11 ictal D1,2 D1,3 D1,4 D1,5 D1,6 D2,3 D2,4 D2,5 D2,6 D3,4 D3,5 D3,6 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 1k 100 10 1 -0.05 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = D δ ( s t n u o c Pat11 inter-ictal D1,2 D1,3 D1,4 D1,5 D1,6 D2,3 D2,4 D2,5 D2,6 D3,4 D3,5 D3,6 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 0.00 Dk,k' 0.05 0.00 Dk,k' 0.05 (b) (a) Figure 17 The local and non-local cross-correlations between the electrodes of the Pat11 in ictal interval (a) and in inter-ictal interval (b). Pat15 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 10M 1M 100k 10k 1k 100 z 10 0 1 2 3 5 4 τ (hour) 6 7 8 9 1 10 (a) 1.0 k 0.9 χ 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0 1.0 k 0.9 χ 0.8 0.7 0.6 1 2 τ (hour) 3 (b) Pat15 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 10M 1M 100k 10k 1k 100 z 10 1 4 Pat15 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 10M 1M 100k 10k 1k 100 z 10 0.5 7 1 10 Pat15 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 10M 1M 100k 10k 1k 100 z 10 1 1.0 k 0.9 χ 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 1.0 k 0.9 χ 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 4 5 6 7 τ (hour) (d) (c) Figure 18 The time profiles of the index values from the Pat15 in ictal interval with different time domains. τ (hour) 8 9 1k 100 10 1 0.6 ) 2 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( χ f o s t n u o c Pat15 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.7 0.8 χ 0.9 1.0 (a) 1k 100 10 1 0.7 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( s t n u o c - 28 - Pat15 inter-ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.8 0.9 χ 1.0 (b) Figure 19 The ED plots of the index values from the Pat15 in ictal interval (a) and in inter-ictal interval. 1k 100 10 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = D δ ( s t n u o c 1 -0.15 -0.10 -0.05 0.00 Dk,k' 0.05 0.10 0.15 Pat15 ictal D1,2 D1,3 D1,4 D1,5 D1,6 D2,3 D2,4 D2,5 D2,6 D3,4 D3,5 D3,6 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 1k 100 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = D δ ( s t n u o c 10 1 -0.15 -0.10 -0.05 0.00 Dk,k' 0.05 0.10 0.15 Pat15 inter-ictal D1,2 D1,3 D1,4 D1,5 D1,6 D2,3 D2,4 D2,5 D2,6 D3,4 D3,5 D3,6 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 (b) (a) Figure 20 The cross-correlations between the electrodes of the Pat15 in ictal interval (a) and in inter-ictal interval (b). 0.2 0.1 ' k , k D 0.0 -0.1 -0.2 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 τ (hour) 5.8 5.9 (b) Pat15 ictal D1,2 D1,3 D1,4 D1,5 D1,6 D2,3 D2,4 D2,5 D2,6 D3,4 D3,5 D3,6 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 0.1 0.0 ' k , k D -0.1 -0.2 4 0.2 0.1 ' k , k D 0.0 -0.1 -0.2 8.4 Pat15 ictal D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 Pat15 ictal D1,2 D1,3 D1,4 D1,5 D1,6 D2,3 D2,4 D2,5 D2,6 D3,4 D3,5 D3,6 D4,5 D4,6 D5,6 5 6 τ (hour) (a) 7 8.6 8.8 τ (hour) 9.0 (c) Figure 21 The cross-correlations between the out-focus electrodes (a) and all of the electrodes ((b) and (c)) of the Pat15 in ictal interval within different time domains. - 29 - 10k 100k Pat09 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 1k 0 1 2 3 4 5 τ (hour) (a) 6 7 8 9 10 100 10 1 Pat09 inter-ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 1.0 k 0.9 χ 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 1.0 k χ 0.9 0.8 8 9 τ (hour) 10 11 1k 100 10 1 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( s t n u o c Pat09 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.8 0.9 χ 1.0 (c) Figure 22 The time profiles of the index values from the Pat09 in ictal interval (a) and (b) and in inter-ictal interval (c) with different time domains. (b) (a) Figure 23 ED plots of the index values from the Pat09 in ictal interval (a) and in inter- ictal interval (b). 1.0 k 0.9 χ 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 8 100k 1M Pat09 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 10k 1k 100 10 10 9 τ (hour) (b) 1k 100 10 1 0.7 ) 1 0 0 . 0 = χ δ ( s t n u o c Pat09 inter-ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 0.8 0.9 χ 1.0 - 30 - 100k ) 2 0 0 . 0 = ' χ δ ( ' χ f o s t n u o c 10k 1k 100 10 1 k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 -1.0 -0.5 χ' 0.0 0.5 1.0 Figure 24 The distributions of the values χ’k(τ) which are obtained using all of the data from 20 patients in ictal interval or in inter-ictal interval. 1.0 0.9 k χ 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0 0.2 k ' χ 0.0 1 2 τ (hour) (a) 100k Pat20 ictal 10k k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 100 1k 10 1 z 100m 3 0.8 k χ 0.7 0.6 6.0 6.2 Pat20 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 100 1k Pat20 ictal k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5 k=6 10 1 z 6.8 100m 7.0 6.4 6.6 τ (hour) (b) -0.2 1.0 1.2 2.0 1.8 1.4 1.6 τ (hour) (c) Figure 25 Various applications of the method with a window time length of 100 seconds where (a) and (b) show the indices and (c) is for the temporal differences of the indices. - 31 -
1401.0165	1	1401	2013-12-31T16:00:53	Orthogonal invariant sets of the diffusion tensor and the development of a curvilinear set suitable for low-anisotropy tissues	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.QM" ]	We develop a curvilinear invariant set of the diffusion tensor which may be applied to Diffusion Tensor Imaging measurements on tissues and porous media. This new set is an alternative to the more common invariants such as fractional anisotropy and the diffusion mode. The alternative invariant set possesses a different structure to the other known invariant sets; the second and third members of the curvilinear set measure the degree of orthotropy and oblateness/prolateness, respectively. The proposed advantage of these invariants is that they may work well in situations of low diffusion anisotropy and isotropy, as is often observed in tissues such as cartilage. We also explore the other orthogonal invariant sets in terms of their geometry in relation to eigenvalue space; a cylindrical set, a spherical set (including fractional anisotropy and the mode), and a log-Euclidean set. These three sets have a common structure. The first invariant measures the magnitude of the diffusion, the second and third invariants capture aspects of the anisotropy; the magnitude of the anisotropy and the shape of the diffusion ellipsoid (the manner in which the anisotropy is realised). We also show a simple method to prove the orthogonality of the invariants within a set.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Orthogonal Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor and the Development of a Curvilinear Set Suitable for Low-Anisotropy Tissues ∗ Robin A. Damion1,2 , Aleksandra Radjenovic3,† , Eileen Ingham2 , Zhongmin Jin2,4 , Michael E. Ries1,†† 1 School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Leeds, Leeds, West Yorkshire, UK. 2 Institute of Medical and Biological Engineering, School of Mechanical Engineering, University of Leeds, Leeds, West Yorkshire, UK. 3 National Institute for Health Research, Leeds Musculoskeletal Biomedical Research Unit, Chapel Allerton Hospital, University of Leeds, Leeds, West Yorkshire, UK. 4 School of Mechanical Engineering, Xi'an Jiaotong University, Xi'an, Shaanxi, People's Republic of China. † E-mail: [email protected] †† E-mail: [email protected] Abstract We develop a curvilinear invariant set of the diffusion tensor which may be applied to Diffusion Tensor Imaging measurements on tissues and porous media. This new set is an alternative to the more common invariants such as fractional anisotropy and the diffusion mode. The alternative invariant set possesses a different structure to the other known invariant sets; the second and third members of the curvilinear set measure the degree of orthotropy and oblateness/prolateness, respectively. The proposed advantage of these invariants is that they may work well in situations of low diffusion anisotropy and isotropy, as is often observed in tissues such as cartilage. We also explore the other orthogonal invariant sets in terms of their geometry in relation to eigenvalue space; a cylindrical set, a spherical set (including fractional anisotropy and the mode), and a log-Euclidean set. These three sets have a common structure. The first invariant measures the magnitude of the diffusion, the second and third invariants capture aspects of the anisotropy; the magnitude of the anisotropy and the shape of the diffusion ellipsoid (the manner in which the anisotropy is realised). We also show a simple method to prove the orthogonality of the invariants within a set. ∗Published in PLoS ONE, November 2013. This article is reproduced here because of formatting errors by PLoS ONE in the post-production article. PLoS ONE 8(11): e78798. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0078798 1 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor Introduction Fluids in partially-ordered biological tissues such as brain [1], muscle [2,3] and cartilage [4 -- 6] have been shown to exhibit anisotropic translational diffusion when measured with techniques such as diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) [7]. The fluids, which usually consist primarily of water, are inherently isotropic liquids and therefore any measured anisotropy in their translational motion is a result of the influence of a locally anisotropic environment on the motional statistics of the liquid molecules. The fact that the anisotropy is caused by the local environment is useful because it provides a source of additional contrast in magnetic resonance images and it is often possible to infer something about the local microstructure of the tissue (or porous medium) from the anisotropy of the diffusion tensor and its eigenvectors. Normalised eigenvectors provide information about the local orientation of structures in the tissue, while the anisotropy (a comparison of the eigenvalues) provides a measure of the relative magnitudes of the eigenvectors. However, there is no single definition of anisotropy. Currently, the most common measure of diffusion anisotropy is fractional anisotropy [8] Af = vuut 3 2P3 i=1(cid:0)λi − ¯λ(cid:1)2 P3 i=1 λ2 i , (1) Pi λ2 i which provides a scale-independent, dimensionless measure. (displayed in its most familiar form) where λi (i = 1, 2, 3) are the three eigenvalues of the diffusion tensor, and ¯λ = (λ1 + λ2 + λ3)/3 is the mean of the eigenvalues. Fractional anisotropy quantifies anisotropy by the spread (standard deviation) of the eigenvalues and is normalised by the quantity Importantly, and unlike some previous attempts to define anisotropy [8], Af is invariant. That is, the quantity is independent of the choice of coordinate system; in particular, with regard to rotations, but also more general coordinate transformations. This coordinate independence is a consequence of the application of tensor calculus which can be used to express Af , as was done by Basser and Pierpaoli [8]. Invariant quantities derived from tensor calculus are typically symmetric functions of the eigenvalues, as can be seen in Eq. (1). Some other invariant measures that have been proposed in the literature are relative anisotropy [7, 8], geodesic anisotropy [9, 10], and volume ratio [7]. The first two of these are similar to fractional anisotropy in the sense that they are based on the spread of the eigenvalues. Volume ratio is a little different in structure and is based on the volume of the diffusion ellipsoid which is proportional to the determinant of the diffusion tensor. However, like fractional anisotropy, these quantities do not give us the full picture of the anisotropy. Except for volume ratio, these quantities calculate, in different ways, measures of the magnitude of the anisotropy but give us little idea of the shape of the diffusion ellipsoid. Volume ratio gives a single mixed measure of anisotropy magnitude and ellipsoid shape [11]. The shape of the diffusion ellipsoid can be generally classified by four archetypal cases or states; isotropic, orthotropic, prolate, and oblate, although only three are independent. For these, sets of eigenvalues can take the form {λ1, λ2, λ3} =   (cid:8)¯λ, ¯λ, ¯λ(cid:9) , (cid:8)¯λ (1 + α) , ¯λ, ¯λ (1 − α)(cid:9) , (cid:8)¯λ (1 + 2α) , ¯λ (1 − α) , ¯λ (1 − α)(cid:9) , (cid:8)¯λ (1 + α/2) , ¯λ (1 + α/2) , ¯λ (1 − α)(cid:9) , Oblate Isotropic Orthotropic Prolate (2) PLoS ONE 2 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor where α ∈ (0, 1). Note that these states are parameterized by α strictly on the open interval. That is, α = 1 should be regarded as an asymptotic limit because at this point one or more eigenvalues would be zero and the determinant of the diffusion tensor would vanish, rendering the tensor noninvertible. At the other end of the interval α = 0 and the states become a single degenerate state; the isotropic case. Fractional anisotropy does not easily distinguish between the states indicated above. For prolate ellipsoids, Af ∈ (0, 1), for oblate ellipsoids Af ∈ (0, 1/√2), and for the orthotropic case Af ∈ (0,p3/5). Thus, only when Af ∈ [p3/5, 1) can we identify the ellipsoid shape: prolate. In principle, the isotropic case is also identifiable as Af = 0 but experimental noise [12] inevitably places a lower limit on the measured value of fractional anisotropy, meaning that Af = 0 is unachievable in practice. There have been some attempts to define quantities which describe the shape of the ellipsoid. For example, Peled et al. [13] and Westin et al. [14] defined three quantities to measure the linear (prolate), planar (oblate) and spherical (isotropic) aspects of the diffusion tensor. These quantities were defined as functions on magnitude-ordered eigenvalue sets and therefore the functions treated the eigenvalues asymmetrically. The main difficulty with this approach is that averaging of magnitude- ordered eigenvalues usually introduces a statistical bias in the distribution of the eigenvalues, leading to inaccurate measurements of anisotropy [15, 16]. A solution to the problem of finding invariant measures of anisotropy which encode the shape of the diffusion ellipsoid, and which do not depend on having to magnitude-order the eigenvalues, was proposed by Ennis and Kindlmann [17]. These authors, basing their work on that of Criscione et al. [18], showed that there exist orthogonal sets (triplets) of tensor invariants which can be applied to the diffusion tensor to give useful measures of anisotropy. They found two sets of invariants which are related to cylindrical and spherical coordinates in eigenvalue space. The latter set was shown to contain fractional anisotropy as a measure of the magnitude of anisotropy, and an invariant known as the mode; a measure of the shape of the diffusion ellipsoid. In the next section of this paper we review the orthogonal cylindrical and spherical sets using a more geometric approach than was used by Ennis and Kindlmann. These authors gave a proof of the orthogonality of these measures in the same way as Criscione et al. but this proof is based on tensors in the full six-dimensional space of the diffusion tensor and the connection with the coordinate system of the eigenvalue space is obscured. Here, we give an alternative proof of the orthogonality of these invariant measures which maintains a direct connection with the eigenvalue coordinates and therefore presents a clearer picture of the geometry and the meaning of the invariants. In fact the geometrical, coordinate-based approach we take here is similar to that used by Bahn [11] prior to the work of the abovementioned authors. Bahn was able to show how the spherical coordinates of eigenvalue space were invariant themselves or related to the invariants forming an orthogonal set. What he did not show was how these invariants were related to invariants of the full diffusion tensor and also explicitly how his skewness parameter (related to the mode) determined the shape of the ellipsoid, nor did he fully explore the invariants relating to the cylindrical set. We also look at two further orthogonal sets. One set is related to recent work using the log- Euclidean metric for averaging and interpolation of the diffusion tensor [9, 10]. The final set, the curvilinear set, has a different structure to the previous three and makes the orthotropic ellipsoid case more apparent. The incentive behind the definition of the latter set was our discovery that the third invariants (measuring the mode or its equivalent) of the previous three sets (spherical, cylindrical, log-Euclidean) do not function well for diffusion exhibiting isotropy or a low degree of anisotropy. PLoS ONE 3 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor The primary purpose of this paper is to introduce the curvilinear invariant set and relate it and compare it mathematically to the other invariant sets. It is not our intention to carry out a numerical or experimental validation of the curvilinear invariants here but to present their definition, mathematical properties, and to propose them as potentially useful invariants which warrant further study. Theory Orthogonality and the Metric To prove the orthogonality of invariants, we are going to treat them as if they were the coordinates on some manifold M and use the metric tensor gij, where i, j ∈ {1, 2, . . . , n}, and n is the dimension of the manifold. The metric is a symmetric tensor which is used to calculate the distance along a specified path on a manifold. Here, we shall only be concerned with infinitesimal distances ds given by (using the Einstein summation convention) ds2 = gijdxidxj, (3) where dxi are infinitesimal changes in the coordinates xi ∈ M. This is merely an alternative way of displaying the metric tensor. For our purposes, the significance of using the metric is that for real orthogonal coordinates the metric is diagonal and hence there will be only terms of the form gii(dxi)2 and no terms of the form gijdxidxj with i 6= j. Let µ : M → N be a map from manifold M to N (which, for simplicity, we will assume to be of the same dimension as M) such that µ : xi 7→ X i ∈ N . If N is the same manifold as M, µ : M → M is merely a coordinate transformation on M. To calculate the new metric γij on N , j = ∂xi/∂X j . The new metric and the orthogonality can we need the Jacobian matrix J such that J i then be assessed by substituting dxi = J i j dX j into Eq. (3) or by computing the new metric directly by γ = JTgJ, where JT is the transpose of the Jacobian matrix. In index notation γij = gklJ k i J l j. Although coordinates are usually designated with superscript indices, as we have employed in the above two paragraphs, below for convenience we will use subscripted indices to avoid confusion between indices and exponents. This should not lead to any ambiguity since, from here on, index notation will not be used extensively. Cartesian Coordinates Since tensor invariants are scalar functions of eigenvalues only, we will consider the three-dimensional eigenvalue space only. We begin with the eigenvalues as orthogonal coordinates in three-dimensional Euclidean space E. Strictly, since the eigenvalues must be positive real numbers, they reside only in the open subset that is one octant of the full Euclidean space such that λ1, λ2, λ3 > 0. The Euclidean metric tensor is given by and the infinitesimal distance element is given by g =   1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1   , ds2 = gijdλidλj = dλ2 1 + dλ2 2 + dλ2 3. (4) (5) PLoS ONE 4 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor However, it will be convenient to use a slightly different coordinate system defined, for example, by x y z     =   1/√6 1/√6 −p2/3 −1/√2 1/√2 0 1/√3 1/√3 1/√3 λ1 λ2 λ3       , (6) where the matrix in this equation is an orthogonal matrix (a rotation matrix similar to that used by Bahn [11]) and has been chosen because it preserves the orthogonality of the coordinates while defining the z-direction to be proportional to the tensor trace. The component of the rotation about the z-axis, however, is arbitrary. The matrix shown in Eq. (6) is the inverse Jacobian matrix, as we have defined it above, and since in this case it is also an orthogonal matrix, J−1 = JT. The convenience of this choice is that in the case of isotropy, when the eigenvalues are identical, x = y = 0 and therefore isotropic tensors will be represented by points on the z-axis and the anisotropy is dependent on the x and y coordinates only. Note that while the z-coordinate, being proportional to the tensor trace, is an invariant, the x and y coordinates are not invariants and therefore we will need either to find another coordinate system or appropriate functions of the coordinates. However, this Cartesian system will serve as an important first step in establishing the geometry. In defining our new Cartesian coordinates, we used a rotation matrix. Therefore, we know that the new coordinates will also be orthogonal and the standard Euclidean metric will be preserved. Calculating the new metric, ds2 = dx2 + dy2 + dz2, (7) we verify the orthogonality of these coordinates by the absence of off-diagonal terms such as dxdy. Cylindrical Coordinates and Invariants Let us change to a cylindrical polar coordinate system {z, ρ, θ} such that the z-axis remains unchanged and x = ρ cos θ, y = ρ sin θ, (8) (9) (10) and the metric becomes ds2 = dz2 + dρ2 + ρ2dθ2. The cylindrical invariant set [17] can now be defined in terms of these coordinates by K1 = K2 = √3z ρ = tr(D), = norm( D), K3 = − cos 3θ = 3√6 det( D) norm( D)3 , where D is the diffusion tensor, D = D − 1 3 tr(D)I is the deviatoric tensor, I is the identity tensor, tr is the trace, det is the determinant, and norm(A)2 = tr(A2) for an arbitrary tensor A. The trace, norm and determinant are tensor invariants and thus Eq. (10) can be defined directly in terms of the PLoS ONE 5 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 eigenvalues of D. In terms of the eigenvalues, the basic tensor invariants used here and below are Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor i=1 λi, tr(D) = P3 norm(D) = qP3 norm( D) = qP3 det( D) = Q3 i=1 λ2 i , i=1(λi − ¯λ)2, i=1(λi − ¯λ), (11) (of which only three are independent) and the relations in (10) between the cylindrical invariants and the cylindrical coordinates can be verified using (6), (8), and (11). The cylindrical invariants have the following interpretation. K1 ∈ (0,∞) is proportional to the tensor trace and is a measure of the magnitude of the diffusion tensor. K2 and K3, being functions on the plane perpendicular to the z-axis, quantify the anisotropy. Like fractional anisotropy, K2 ∈ (0,∞) measures the magnitude of the anisotropy by the spread of the eigenvalues. However, unlike fractional anisotropy, K2 is not normalised and therefore not scale-independent. In the cylindrical coordinate system K2 has the direct interpretation of being the perpendicular distance between point (z, ρ, θ) and the z-axis; i.e. the radius ρ. K3 ∈ [−1, 1] is known as the mode and quantifies the shape of the diffusion ellipsoid. For the three ellipsoid shapes given by (2), K3 = 1, 0,−1 for the prolate, orthotropic and oblate cases respectively. In the case of isotropic ellipsoids, a little care needs to be taken because K3 is not defined and depends on how this point (the z-axis) is approached. For example, let us parameterize the prolate and oblate cases with a single parameter β ∈ (− 1 2 , 1) via {λ1, λ2, λ3} = (cid:8)¯λ (1 + 2β) , ¯λ (1 − β) , ¯λ (1 − β)(cid:9) , (12) where β ∈ (− 1 2 , 0) corresponds to oblate ellipsoids and β ∈ (0, 1) corresponds to the prolate case. Calculating the mode as a function of β, K3 = β3/β3 = sgn(β), and it is clear that a discontinuous jump occurs as we pass through the z-axis (β = 0). A similar discontinuous jump occurs along any radial path through the z-axis except for those angles, θ, which correspond to the orthotropic ellipsoids. In these cases, the mode is zero along the whole radial path. The invariant set (10) can be regarded as a triplet of scalar functions on the eigenvalue space with the metric (9) but it is also possible to regard these functions as coordinates on a related manifold K. Because the function K3 : θ → − cos 3θ is a six-to-one mapping, the eigenvalue manifold is a six-fold covering of the manifold associated with coordinates {Ki}. This is a consequence of the invariance of the {Ki} which treats the eigenvalues symmetrically; there are six equivalent permutations of (λ1, λ2, λ3). The metric on K is ds2 = 1 3 dK 2 1 + dK 2 2 + K 2 2 9(1 − K 2 3 ) dK 2 3 . (13) Again, the absence of off-diagonal terms dKidKj verifies the orthogonality of the coordinates and hence the set {Ki} are orthogonal tensor invariants. We also note that despite the singularity in the metric on the boundary K3 = ±1, the metric is completely flat. That is, the Ricci scalar curvature vanishes everywhere. PLoS ONE 6 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor Spherical Coordinates and Invariants The invariant K2 is similar to fractional anisotropy but lacks a normalisation which makes it scale- independent. Ennis and Kindlmann [17] showed that it is possible to modify the set to include fractional anisotropy and that this new set is closely related to spherical polar coordinates: x = r sin φ cos θ, y = r sin φ sin θ, z = r cos φ. The metric in these coordinates is ds2 = dr2 + r2dφ2 + r2 sin2 φdθ2. The invariants associated with these coordinates are defined as [17] R1 = r = norm(D), 2 sin φ = r 3 R2 = q 3 R3 = − cos 3θ = 3√6 2 , norm( D) norm(D) det( D) norm( D)3 (14) (15) (16) , where, using the definition of the norms in Eq. (11), one can see that R2 is equivalent to the usual definition of fractional anisotropy (see Eq. (1)). The structure of these spherical invariants is very similar to the cylindrical invariants. R1, like K1, is a measure of the magnitude of the diffusion tensor but is now the radial coordinate, r, which corresponds to the norm of the diffusion tensor. Again, R2 and R3 measure the anisotropy of the tensor. R2, as we have already mentioned, is exactly equivalent to fractional anisotropy, Af , and is related to the polar angle, φ. It is also similar to K2 in its geometrical interpretation in that it is also (proportional to) the perpendicular distance from a point (r, φ, θ) to the z-axis (φ = 0 direction) but normalised by the radius, r. R3 is exactly the same as K3, the mode, and thus quantifies the diffusion ellipsoid shape. As with the cylindrical coordinates, it is also related to the azimuthal angle, θ. As with the cylindrical set, we can regard {Ri} as coordinates on a related manifold R and demonstrate the orthogonality of these invariants by showing that the metric is purely diagonal; ds2 = dR 2 1 + 3 1 R 2 2 − R 2 2 dR 2 2 + 2 1 R 2 2R 2 27(1 − R 2 3 ) dR 2 3 . (17) Log-Euclidean Coordinates and Invariants Recently in the literature there has been some debate over the way in which diffusion tensors should be averaged and interpolated [19]. The simplest way to average tensors is to treat them as one would treat real numbers by directly adding them and dividing by the number of tensors. A consequence of this (Euclidean-averaging) method is that if the original tensors had the same traces then the resulting tensor also has this trace. There is then a natural affinity between this method and the invariant set PLoS ONE 7 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor {Ki} since K1 (the trace) is preserved in such circumstances. This is because the condition that K1 is constant defines a flat plane in the eigenvalue space (with its assumed Euclidean metric) and geodesics between points in this plane are straight lines and therefore will remain in the plane. The set {Ri} is also consistent with Euclidean averaging even though none of the set members are generally preserved in the sense that K1 is. This is because this set is also derived from the assumption of a Euclidean metric on the eigenvalue space. However, if one were interested in preserving R1 in the same way that K1 is preserved in the cylindrical set, then one would need to average over the surface of a sphere. As far as we are aware, no such averaging method has been proposed in the literature but one such method would be to simply average the square of the diffusion tensors and find the appropriate square-root. This method would preserve the tensor norm for tensors of equal norm. An alternative method of averaging which has been discussed and explored in the literature is the log-Euclidean method [9,10,20]. This is similar to the Euclidean method except that the logarithm of the tensors is averaged. This method preserves the tensor determinant. It would therefore be natural to ask whether there exists an invariant set {Li} such that L1 is related to the determinant. Here we show that such a set does exist and had already been found by Criscione et al. [18]. We begin with Eq. (6) but insert the map ℓκ : (λ1, λ2, λ3) 7→ (ln κλ1, ln κλ2, ln κλ3), (18) where κ > 0 is an arbitrary real parameter with dimensions s/m2, prior to the application of the rotation matrix. ℓκ maps the octant of eigenvalue space to the full Euclidean space. We now assume that the metric of Eq. (7) is valid. This is now our starting point, not the metric of Eq. (5), which is no longer valid. We now follow the construction of the cylindrical invariant set equations (8) to (10) except that now we have L1 = L2 = √3z ρ = tr(Λ), = norm(Λ), (19) L3 = − cos 3θ = 3√6 3 tr(Λ)I. By using the fact that tr(Λ) = ln(κ3 det(D)) and Λ = det(Λ) norm(Λ)3 , where Λ = ln κD and Λ = Λ − 1 ln(cid:2)D/ det(D)1/3(cid:3) we can re-express the above as L2 = vuut 3 L1 = ln(κ3D), L3 = , D1/3(cid:19)(cid:21)2 Xi=1 (cid:20)ln(cid:18) λi 3√6Q3 i=1 ln(cid:18) λi D1/3(cid:19) L 3 2 (20) , where λi are the eigenvalues of D and D = det(D) = λ1λ2λ3. As we remarked earlier, the set of invariants {Li} is identical to that found in the paper by Criscione et al. [18] (except for the inclusion of the parameter κ). The cylindrical invariants {Ki} of PLoS ONE 8 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor Ennis and Kindlmann [17] were derived from the invariants of Criscione et al. but the latter authors' log-Euclidean invariants were not mentioned in the former authors' paper. Furthermore, L2 was discovered independently by Batchelor et al. [9] and Fletcher and Joshi [10] from their investigations of the space of diffusion tensors. Both sets of authors referred to L2 as geodesic anisotropy. The structure of these log-Euclidean invariants is similar to the cylindrical and spherical sets. L1 ∈ (−∞,∞) is the measure of overall magnitude of the diffusion tensor. L2 ∈ [0,∞) is similar to fractional anisotropy in these log-Euclidean coordinates and has a similar interpretation, being the perpendicular distance, ρ, between the point (z, ρ, θ) and the z-axis (isotropy). Since this is the distance of a path which is also a geodesic in this space (a straight line in Euclidean space), L2 was called geodesic anisotropy [9, 10]. The same appellation could equally be applied to K2, however. A difference worth noting between K2 and L2 is that the latter is scale-independent, as is evidenced by the absence of the parameter κ. L3 ∈ [−1, 1] plays an identical role to the mode as defined by K3 (and R3). However, since we have now assumed a different metric on the eigenvalue space, the parameterised description of the four archetypal cases is now different to that given in (2) and can be given by   (cid:8)D1/3, D1/3, D1/3(cid:9) , (cid:8)D1/3eα, D1/3, D1/3e−α(cid:9) , (cid:8)D1/3e2α, D1/3e−α, D1/3e−α(cid:9) , Prolate (cid:8)D1/3eα, D1/3eα, D1/3e−2α(cid:9) , Oblate Isotropic Orthotropic (21) {λ1, λ2, λ3} = where α ∈ (0,∞). Alternatively, as we did previously in (12), the prolate and oblate cases can be parameterized together as {λ1, λ2, λ3} = nD1/3e2β, D1/3e−β, D1/3e−βo , (22) where β ∈ (−∞,∞) can be broken into a union of three intervals as β ∈ (−∞, 0)∪ [0] ∪ (0,∞). These first and last intervals correspond to the oblate and prolate cases respectively and the point β = 0 is the isotropic case. Using this parameterisation, L3 = sgn(β). As with K3, a discontinuity exists as β passes from negative to positive and L3 at β = 0 (isotropy) is undefined. For the orthotropic case, L3 = 0 for all α including the isotropic case, i.e. α ∈ [0,∞). The orthogonality of these invariants is guaranteed by the fact that they have exactly the same relation to the cylindrical coordinates as the {Ki}. Therefore, the metric is exactly analogous to Eq. (13). Conformal Maps, Curvilinear Coordinates and Invariants In the previous sections, the orthogonal invariant sets have a common structure; the first invariant measures the magnitude of the diffusion tensor; the second invariant measures the magnitude of the anisotropy and the third invariant provides a measure of the shape of the ellipsoid. In this final section, we will describe an invariant set with a slightly different structure. We begin by recalling that the invariant sets {Li} and {Ki} were based on an underlying cylindrical coordinate system {z, ρ, θ} and that the second and third members of these sets are related to the plane of the polar coordinates {ρ, θ}. This plane is naturally regarded as the two-dimensional space PLoS ONE 9 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor of real numbers R2 but can equally be viewed as the complex plane C and, in this context, there are a family of transformations which preserve angles; the conformal maps [21]. We therefore seek conformal transformations of these coordinates which produce alternative in- variant measures {Ci} (other than those in Eqs. (10) or (19)) such that C1 = K1 or L1. Defining the complex number Z = x + ıy = ρeıθ, we seek conformal maps F : C → C such that W = F (Z) = U (x, y) + ıV (x, y). Such conformal maps are complex analytic functions with non- vanishing complex derivative (except at critical points) and guarantee the preservation of orthogonality via the Cauchy-Riemann equations ∂U ∂x = ∂V ∂y and ∂U ∂y ∂V ∂x . = − (23) Potential invariants can then be constructed from (C2, C3) = (f2(U ), f3(V )), where f2 and f3 are differentiable functions. The simplest maps to provide invariants appear to be Fn : Z 7→ Z 3n for integers n ≥ 1, with more complicated maps being constructed from convergent polynomials or fractional linear transformations thereof. Using the simplest, non-trivial map F1, with an additional π/2 rotation, we make the following assignments; ρ3 sin 3θ, C2 = C3 = −ρ3 cos 3θ. (24) At this stage, the invariants C2 and C3 are expressed in terms of polar coordinates and we could choose to relate them to {Ki} or {Li}. From this point on, we will relate them to the log-Euclidean set since the resulting invariants will then be scale-independent. The rotation used in obtaining the invariants above conveniently introduces the minus sign for C3 3 . These two so that, comparing it to the mode L3 (Eq. (19)), we see that C3 ∝ L3 and C2 ∝ p1 − L 2 invariants can therefore be re-expressed as (25) (26) C2 = L 3 C3 = L 3 2 p1 − L 2 2 L3. 3 , The metric for coordinates {Ci} on the related manifold C is 2 + dC 2 3 (cid:1)2/3 . 2 + C 2 9(cid:0)C 2 ds2 = dC 2 1 + 1 3 dC 2 3 The invariants {Ci} therefore form an orthogonal set and, as mentioned above, these invariants possess a slightly different structure to the previous three sets {Ki}, {Ri}, and {Li}. In the previous sets, the second invariant (i = 2) measures the magnitude of anisotropy whereas the third invariant (i = 3) measures the shape of the ellipsoid. As shown above in Eq. (25), C2 and C3 are both functions of L2 and L3; both contain information about the magnitude of the anisotropy and the ellipsoid shape but C2 and C3 contain different information about the shape. Table 1 shows a comparison between the spherical measures, R2 and R3, and the curvilinear measures, C2 and C3. It can be seen that C3 is similar to R3 except that the magnitude of C3 is modulated by a positive function of L2. Therefore, C3 measures the degree of prolateness or oblateness of the ellipsoid, the two cases being differentiated by the sign of C3. C2, on the other hand, measures the degree of orthotropy. This is in contrast to PLoS ONE 10 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor Table 1. Spherical and curvilinear anisotropies Isotropic Orthotropic C2 Ellipsoid shape R2 R3 0 0 0 > 0 0 > 0 > 0 1 > 0 −1 Prolate Oblate C3 0 0 0 > 0 0 < 0 Comparison of the spherical (R2, R3) and curvilinear measures (C2, C3) of anisotropy for the four archetypical ellipsoid shapes. the spherical measures in which orthotropy is inferred from the absence of prolateness or oblateness; R3 = 0 but R2 6= 0. We also note that the discontinuity in L3 and R3 as one passes through the isotropic state is absent from C2 and C3. If the parameterisation of Eq. (22) is used for the prolate and oblate cases, the pair (C2, C3) = (0, 63/2β3) and it is clear that smooth behaviour is exhibited for all values of β. Likewise, using the parameterisation for the orthotropic case in Eq. (21), (C2, C3) = (23/2α3, 0), which is also smooth (up to second derivative) for all values of α, even if we extend the parameterisation to negative values; α ∈ (−∞,∞). To calculate the curvilinear measures, we can first calculate the log-Euclidean measures using Eq. (19) or (20) and use (25) together with C1 = L1, but it is also interesting and useful to show how they can be calculated directly from the diffusion and deviatoric tensors; C1 = tr(Λ), C2 = qnorm(Λ)6 − 54 det(Λ)2, C3 = 3√6 det(Λ). (27) Finally, we note that in constructing the curvilinear set of invariants {Ci}, we have done so using the invariant sets related to cylindrical coordinates on the eigenvalue space. This was convenient because the polar coordinates define a plane on which we could employ the conformal transformations. However, something similar can be done with the spherical set {Ri}. In this case, a stereographic projection can be used to conformally map the spherical coordinates {φ, θ} to the complex plane and then invariants can be defined similarly to those in this section. Discussion Up to permutations of the eigenvalues, any invariant set can be inverted to return the eigenvalues (see Criscione et al. [18]). Therefore any two invariant sets contain the same information. However, different sets display this information in different ways and can make certain aspects of this information less or more clear. As described in the Theory section, the sets {Ki}, {Ri} and {Li} are all similar in structure. What distinguishes the set {Ci} is that it makes orthotropic anisotropy more explicit. In the previous three sets, orthotropy is inferred from the combination of, for example, R2 > 0 and R3 = 0, whereas C2 is PLoS ONE 11 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor a more direct measure of the degree of orthotropy. That is the single invariant C2 provides a much clearer picture of this aspect of the anisotropy. Whilst it could be seen as a disadvantage that the invariants C2 and C3 have a cubic non-linearity (see equation (25)), it is this property that has removed the discontinuity of the mode at isotropy. This feature of C2 and C3 may prove to be advantageous when dealing with noisy diffusion tensors that are close to isotropic. Since the mode, R3, possesses a discontinuity at isotropy, small fluctuations in the eigenvalues can produce large fluctuations in R3. On the other hand, since C2 and C3 behave smoothly at isotropy it is expected that the effects of noise will be decreased in the region of isotropic tensors. Limitations of the Study, Open Questions and Future Work In the current work, we have focused on the mathematical development of the curvilinear invariants, their properties and their relation to other invariants. Our current interest is in the application of the new invariant set to DTI measurements on articular cartilage in the hope that it will aid in understanding the nature of the collagen architecture which might exhibit a depth-dependence. Our initial investigations suggest that our invariants show there is a difference in the structure between the superficial zone (oblateness) and the deep zone (prolateness) of articular cartilage. We are currently in the process of preparing this data for publication. What also remains to be verified is the claim that the curvilinear invariants possess better noise tolerance for approximately isotropic tensors. This could be achieved, for example, via the statistics of computer simulations of noisy tensors. Conclusions We have explored the cylindrical and spherical invariant sets of the diffusion tensor that were proposed by Ennis and Kindlmann [17], showing how they relate to the geometry of the eigenvalue space and providing an alternative method for the proof of their orthogonality (via the metric). We have also shown how a log-Euclidean set is closely related to the cylindrical set and how this and the other sets are consistent with various averaging schemes. A curvilinear invariant set {Ci} was developed which has a different structure to the preceding three sets, making orthotropy more explicit, and which is expected to be more suitable for measuring low degrees of anisotropy and isotropy. In addition to the usual analysis of eigenvectors and fractional anisotropy from DTI studies on tissues such as articular cartilage, the curvilinear invariants may provide an improved assessment of morphology and function of cartilage and other biological tissues. References 1. Le Bihan D, Johansen-Berg H (2012) Diffusion MRI at 25: Exploring brain tissue structure and function. Neuroimage 61: 324 -- 341. PLoS ONE 12 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor 2. Sinha U, Sinha S, Hodgson JA, Edgerton RV (2011) Human soleus muscle architecture at different ankle joint angles from magnetic resonance diffusion tensor imaging. Journal of Applied Physiology 110: 807 -- 819. 3. Benson AP, Bernus O, Dierckx H, Gilbert SH, Greenwood JP, et al. (2011) Construction and val- idation of anisotropic and orthotropic ventricular geometries for quantitative predictive cardiac electrophysiology. Interface Focus 1: 101 -- 116. 4. de Visser SK, Crawford RW, Pope JM (2008) Structural adaptations in compressed articular cartilage measured by diffusion tensor imaging. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage 16: 83 -- 89. 5. Filidoro L, Dietrich O, Weber J, Rauch E, Oerther T, et al. (2005) High-resolution diffusion tensor imaging of human patellar cartilage: Feasibility and preliminary findings. Magnetic Res- onance in Medicine 53: 993 -- 998. 6. Meder R, de Visser SK, Bowden JC, Bostrom T, Pope JM (2006) Diffusion tensor imaging of articular cartilage as a measure of tissue microstructure. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage 14: 875 -- 881. 7. Le Bihan D, Mangin JF, Poupon C, Clark CA, Pappata S, et al. (2001) Diffusion tensor imaging: Concepts and applications. Journal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging 13: 534 -- 546. 8. Basser PJ, Pierpaoli C (1996) Microstructural and physiological features of tissues elucidated by quantitative-diffusion-tensor MRI. Journal of Magnetic Resonance Series B 111: 209 -- 219. 9. Batchelor PG, Moakher M, Atkinson D, Calamante F, Connelly A (2005) A rigorous framework for diffusion tensor calculus. Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 53: 221 -- 225. 10. Fletcher PT, Joshi S (2007) Riemannian geometry for the statistical analysis of diffusion tensor data. Signal Processing 87: 250 -- 262. 11. Bahn MM (1999) Invariant and orthonormal scalar measures derived from magnetic resonance diffusion tensor imaging. Journal of Magnetic Resonance 141: 68 -- 77. 12. Hasan KM, Alexander AL, Narayana PA (2004) Does fractional anisotropy have better noise im- munity characteristics than relative anisotropy in diffusion tensor MRI? An analytical approach. Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 51: 413 -- 417. 13. Peled S, Gudbjartsson H, Westin CF, Kikinis R, Jolesz FA (1998) Magnetic resonance imaging shows orientation and asymmetry of white matter fiber tracts. Brain Research 780: 27 -- 33. 14. Westin CF, Maier SE, Mamata H, Nabavi A, Jolesz FA, et al. (2002) Processing and visualization for diffusion tensor MRI. Medical Image Analysis 6: 93 -- 108. 15. Basser PJ, Pajevic S (2000) Statistical artifacts in diffusion tensor MRI (DT-MRI) caused by background noise. Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 44: 41 -- 50. 16. Pierpaoli C, Basser PJ (1996) Toward a quantitative assessment of diffusion anisotropy. Mag- netic Resonance in Medicine 36: 893 -- 906. PLoS ONE 13 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798 Invariant Sets of the Diffusion Tensor 17. Ennis DB, Kindlmann G (2006) Orthogonal tensor invariants and the analysis of diffusion tensor magnetic resonance images. Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 55: 136 -- 146. 18. Criscione JC, Humphrey JD, Douglas AS, Hunter WC (2000) An invariant basis for natural strain which yields orthogonal stress response terms in isotropic hyperelasticity. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids 48: 2445 -- 2465. 19. Pasternak O, Sochen N, Basser PJ (2010) The effect of metric selection on the analysis of diffusion tensor MRI data. Neuroimage 49: 2190 -- 2204. 20. Arsigny V, Fillard P, Pennec X, Ayache N (2006) Log-euclidean metrics for fast and simple calculus on diffusion tensors. Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 56: 411 -- 421. 21. Jeffrey A (1986). Mathematics for Engineers and Scientists. Third ed. Berkshire, England: Van Nostrand Reinhold (UK). pp. 444 -- 455. PLoS ONE 14 2013 Volume 8 Issue 11 e78798
1808.09764	1	1808	2018-08-29T12:40:02	Is Actin Filament and Microtubule Growth Reaction- or Diffusion-Limited?	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.SC" ]	Inside cells of living organisms, actin filaments and microtubules self-assemble and dissemble dynamically by incorporating actin or tubulin from the cell plasma or releasing it into their tips' surroundings. Such reaction-diffusion systems can show diffusion- or reaction-limited behaviour. However, neither limit explains the experimental data: while the offset of the linear relation between growth speed and bulk tubulin density contradicts the diffusion limit, the surprisingly large variance of the growth speed rejects a pure reaction limit. In this Letter, we accommodate both limits and use a Doi-Peliti field-theory model to estimate how diffusive transport is perturbing the chemical reactions at the filament tip. Furthermore, a crossover bulk density is predicted at which the limiting process changes from chemical reactions to diffusive transport. In addition, we explain and estimate larger variances of the growth speed.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Is Actin Filament and Microtubule Growth Reaction- or Diffusion-Limited? Johannes Pausch, Gunnar Pruessner Department of Mathematics, Imperial College London, UK August 30, 2018 Abstract Inside cells of living organisms, actin filaments and microtubules self-assemble and dissemble dynamically by incorpo- rating actin or tubulin from the cell plasma or releasing it into their tips' surroundings. Such reaction-diffusion systems can show diffusion- or reaction-limited behaviour. However, neither limit explains the experimental data: while the offset of the linear relation between growth speed and bulk tubulin density contradicts the diffusion limit, the surprisingly large variance of the growth speed rejects a pure reaction limit. In this Letter, we accommodate both limits and use a Doi-Peliti field-theory model to estimate how diffusive transport is perturbing the chemical reactions at the filament tip. Furthermore, a crossover bulk density is predicted at which the limiting process changes from chemical reactions to diffusive transport. In addition, we explain and estimate larger variances of the growth speed. Microtubules and actin filaments are structures that poly- merise by incorporating and releasing their diffusively mov- ing building blocks, tubulin and actin. They are responsi- ble for growth, shape, movement, and transport processes, among others, and can span the entire cell [3]. Their dynam- ics have been studied intensively experimentally1 and the- oretically.2 However, many questions about their dynamics remain debated or completely unanswered. This includes: Is their growth limited by diffusion to their tip [18, 8] or by the chemical reaction rates for incorporation [1, 8]? How can the large variance of their growth be explained [12]? In experiments, the filament growth speed (cid:104)v(cid:105) can be measured as a function of the bulk density ζ of tubulin or actin. An effective incorporation coefficient kon and effec- tive release rate koff are determined as parameters of a linear fit of growth speed data over bulk concentration ζ (cid:104)v(cid:105) = h(konζ − koff), (1) where h is the effective growth length per incorporated par- ticle. There are two mean field approaches for modeling the filament growth speed (cid:104)v(cid:105). The first approach assumes that diffusive transport is quicker than the chemical reactions [16, 4, 6, 25, 1] and that polymerisation is therefore reaction-limited. This ef- fectively infinite diffusivity D implies that particle concen- tration is homogeneous, and in particular, that there is no significant depletion close to the filament tip. Thus, fila- ment growth is determined by two Poisson processes, incor- poration with rate λζ and release with rate τ, each of which is associated with a step of length h. The two competing corresponding author: [email protected] 1See Table S1 in the Supplemental Information of [12] for microtubule assembly rates. For actin filaments, assembly rates can be found in [20, 10, 15, 11]. 2Theoretical work includes [16, 9, 4, 6, 25, 1, 18] for microtubules and [9, 10, 14] for actin filaments. 1 processes create a Skellam distribution [21] with expected growth speed (cid:104)v(cid:105)R and effective diffusion constant Deff and Deff = h2(λζ + τ ). (2) (cid:104)v(cid:105)R = h(λζ − τ ) However, in comparison with experiments [12, 10, 15], Deff is too small. Furthermore, it implies an independence of the growth speed from the viscosity of the medium, which was rejected experimentally for actin filaments [8] and micro- tubules [26]. Thus, a purely reaction-limited behaviour is rejected. The second approach assumes that transport by diffusion is slower than the chemical reactions [8, 18] and that self- assembly is therefore diffusion-limited. This implies that, due to the incorporation into the tip, the building blocks are depleted locally. The growth speed is determined by the diffusive flux to the tip. If the protein concentration c(x, t) follows a steady state diffusion equation 0 = D∆c(x, t), the particle flux J through the absorbent reaction sphere of radius R and the growth length h determine the growth speed (cid:104)v(cid:105)D, which is equivalent to Smoluchowski coagula- tion [24] (cid:104)v(cid:105)D = Jh = 4πDRhζ. (3) However, this limit cannot accommodate a release rate as any released particle would immediately be reabsorbed be- fore diffusion can transport it away from the reaction sur- face. Furthermore, using this approach with typical pa- rameters of microtubule assembly, only a small reduction of the bulk tubulin density to 89% is found at the reac- tion surface [18]. It therefore is not completely absorbent, as is theoretically suggested in [5]. According to the Stokes-Einstein equation [22] for small Reynolds numbers, diffusion-limited growth implies that viscosity and incor- poration rate are inversely proportional [2] without offset. Tested in [8] and [26], small offsets for the growth of micro- tubules and the barbed actin filament ends are found, while Figure 1: Filament growth speed (cid:104)v(cid:105) as function of the bulk density ζ of its building blocks. The diffusion-limited (cid:104)v(cid:105)D (red), the reaction-limited (cid:104)v(cid:105)R (blue), and the real growth speed (cid:104)v(cid:105) (black) are shown. A: The system is reaction- limited, B: Reaction-limited growth changes to diffusion- limited growth at the crossover bulk density ζ×. Local densities at the tip can be read off as the bulk density at which reaction-limited growth leads to the same speed (dot- ted line). a significant offset is found for the pointed ends of actin fila- ments. Thus, filament growth cannot be perfectly diffusion- limited either. Furthermore, this model is not probabilistic and therefore, it is not clear how to derive a variance of the growth speed. The diffusion- (Eq. (3)) and reaction-limited (Eq. (2)), as well as the measured growth speed are schematically de- picted in Fig. 1. Measured growth and shrinking speeds will always be slower than both limits. When shrinking, the chemically possible shrinking speed is not attained as dif- fusion slows down transport away from the tip, leading to a locally higher particle density. It can be read off the plot as the density at which the reaction-limited is equal to the measured speed (dotted line). Analogously, when growing, the reaction-limited speed is not attained either because dif- fusion fails to maintain the bulk particle density around the tip. The local density at the tip can be read off again as the density at which the reaction-limited speed is equal to the measured one (dotted line). In principle, there are three cases: the purely reaction limited case A, the mixed case B, where a crossover from reaction-limited to diffusion- limited behaviour occurs at the crossover bulk density ζ×, and case C (not shown), where shrinking does not occur and the growth is limited by diffusion at all particle densities. Theoretically, progress can be made by going beyond mean field theory which allows to calculate how chem- ical reactions are perturbed by diffusive transport of the reactants. Here, filament self-assembly is modelled on a three-dimensional lattice and described by a master equa- tion (Supplementary Material, Eq. A2). Following work by Doi [7] and Peliti [19], this model is transformed into a field theory. The derivation of the field theory is outlined briefly in the Supplementary Material, in Sections A2 and A3. In our model, the building blocks and the filament tip are represented by fields, which are interpreted as time- dependent probability distributions of their positions. Due Figure 2: Schematic of the filament self-assembly process. Its building blocks move diffusively in R3. The filament tip is on a lattice with spacing h. Particles can be incorporated in the filament (coefficient λ) and released by it (rate τ). to the field representation, they do not have a size. How- ever, the finite size of the proteins is an important element of the step-wise filament growth. Therefore, our model is set up on a hybrid, three dimensional space: While parti- cles move in continuous space R3, the filament tip is re- stricted to a discrete line Z with lattice constant h, over- laying the z-axis in R3, see Fig. 2. The persistence length P and flexural rigidity K of the filament we model are thus effectively infinite. This is a good approximation for micro- tubules (P ≈ 5200µm, K ≈ 2·10−23N m2), while for actin filaments, this approximation is slightly worse (P ≈ 18µm, K ≈ 7 · 10−26N m2) [13]. As we are modelling only a sin- gle polymer instead of the 13 microtubule protofilaments or the 2 actin filament strands, we interpret the lattice spacing h as the effective growth step length. Each of the fields exists as an annihilation field and a creation field: ϕ(x, t) and ϕ†(x, t) for the building blocks, as well as ψj(t) and ψ†j (t) for the filament tip. The creation field initiates a single particle or filament tip at the specified position and time, whereas the annihilation field measures their number at the point stated. Creation fields often appear as Doi-shifted fields [7], e.g. ϕ†(x, t) = (cid:101)ϕ(x, t) + 1. In addition, the particle annihilation field is shifted to measure deviations from the bulk density ζ, i.e. ϕ(x, t) = ϕ(x, t) + ζ. Between creation and annihilation, the system evolves by the stochastic processes included in the model. There are six microscopic processes in our model. The units of the corresponding coefficients, denoted by [. . . ], are written as monomials of T (time) and L (length). • particle diffusion with constant D, [D] = T −1L2 • actin or tubulin absorption by the filament tip with co- efficient λ and subsequent movement of the tip by dis- tance h in the +z direction, [λ] = T −1L3 • particle release from the filament tip with rate τ and subsequent movement of the tip by distance h in the −z direction, [τ ] = T −1 • actin/tubulin creation with coefficient γ, [γ] = 2 ζhvihviDhviRhvi4πDRhhλhkonhτhkoff0AζhvihviDhviRhvi4πDRhhλhkonζ×hτhkoff0BλτhT −1L−3 corporation or release of tubulin. It is described by • extinction of actin/tubulin with rate r, [r] = T −1 • extinction of the filament tip with rate , [] = T −1 Alin-F-stat = However, due to incorporation and release, the bilinear part includes jumps in steps of 1z Creation and extinction of the building blocks is balanced such that a constant bulk density ζ = γ/r is created. The two extinction processes are included in the field theory to enforce causality. After calculations, we let parameters γ, r and tend to zero while keeping the ratio γ/r = ζ constant. Thus, the spontaneous extinction and creation are removed while a bulk density remains included. All of the processes above are reflected in the action func- tional A of our model which splits up into a bilinear part and an interaction part A = Alin + Aint. The diffusion and extinction of particles is represented in the particle bilinear part (cid:101)ϕ(x, t)(cid:0) −∂t + D∆ − r(cid:1) ϕ(x, t)d3xdt, Alin-P = (4) (cid:90) R4 where ∆ is the spatial Laplace operator. (cid:90) (cid:88) R j∈Z (cid:90) (cid:88) (cid:16) R j∈Z Alin-F-mov = (cid:101)ψj(t)(cid:0) −∂t − (cid:1)ψj(t)dt. (5) growing (cid:125)(cid:124) (cid:123) (cid:122) λζ(cid:0)(cid:101)ψj+1z − (cid:101)ψj (cid:1)ψj + τ(cid:0)(cid:101)ψj−1z − (cid:101)ψj (cid:1)ψj (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:124) shrinking (6) (cid:17) (cid:125) dt, where we omitted the time dependence of the fields for better readability. The first part corresponds to filament growth, while the second part describes shrinking of the fil- ament. Jumps on the lattice are indicated by ±1z. Alin-P + Alin-F-stat + Alin-F-mov. All three bilinear actions together make up Alin = The filament tip is stationary without the processes of in- (cid:90) (cid:20) (cid:17) (cid:16)(cid:0)(cid:101)ψj+1z − (cid:101)ψj (cid:88) (cid:1)ψj ϕ(hj) The interaction part of A has the form −(cid:101)ψjψj(cid:101)ϕ(hj) ϕ(hj) − ψj(cid:101)ϕ(hj) ϕ(hj) (cid:124) (cid:125) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:124) (cid:125) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:125) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:124) (cid:21) (cid:1)ψj(cid:101)ϕ(hj) +(cid:0)τ(cid:101)ψj−1z − λζ(cid:101)ψj + (τ − λζ)(cid:101)ϕ(hj)ψj (cid:125) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:124) (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:124) (cid:125) Aint = j∈Z dt, (a) (c) (b) λ R (d) (e) (7) The interplay between propagation and interaction in a system governed by the action A can be calculated using the path integral. The system may be initialised by placing a filament tip at position hj0 = 0 at time t0 = 0. Then, the system evolves and particle concentrations, the filament tip positions, or moments of their distributions can be mea- sured at a later point in time. In general, if the observable where the time dependency is omitted for better readability. The different parts of the interaction describe the follow- ing processes: (a) the filament grows, i.e. the filament tip moves one step in the positive z direction upon incorporating an actin/tubulin particle; (b) as particles are incorporated into the tip, its density is reduced locally, resulting in anticorrelations of the tip and the particle density; (c) particle density is reduced by incorporation into the tip; (d) in the presence of a tip, the particle density is increased by spontaneous release (τ) and decreased by incorpo- ration (λζ), leading to corresponding correlations of tip and particle densities; (e) τ: particle density is increased because the filament releases a particle; λζ: particle density is decreased because the filament incorporates a particle. and propagations Field-theoretic are schematically represented by Feynman diagrams. Particle propagation is drawn as a straight red line, filament propa- gation is depicted as a curly blue line, and interactions are illustrated as vertices, see Fig. 3. interactions Figure 3: The stochastic processes that appear in Aint, Eq. (7), are represented as amputated vertices in Feyn- man diagrams. Curly blue lines represent filaments, while straight red lines stand for their building blocks, actin or tubulin. All Feynman diagrams are read from right to left. 3 λψeψϕ(a)−λψeψeϕϕ(b)−λϕeϕψ(c)τ−λζψeψeϕ(d)τ−λζψeϕ(e)The loop correction term takes into account that, due to diffusive transport, the reaction-limited speed is reduced further because the locally depleted particles have to reach the reaction sphere of radius R. Considering the first term of the loop correction, if the diffusion is strong, the chem- ical reactions are less hindered by slow transport and the growth speed is closer to its reaction limit. This diffusion correction is itself corrected in the second term of the loop correction which describes how quickly the tip reaches re- gions that are less depleted. It predicts a non-linear depen- dence of the growth speed (cid:104)v(cid:105) on the bulk particle density ζ, which so far has not been observed experimentally. There- and ignore the latter in fore, we assume the following. Thus, given the diffusion-limited growth co- efficient 4πDR and the observed kon and koff, Eq. (1), we can calculate the reaction-limited λ as well as the offset τ 4πDR (cid:29) hλζ−τ 8πD2 1 λ = kon 4πDR 4πDR − kon and τ = koff 4πDR 4πDR − kon , (12) to the results in [17] for general which is equivalent reaction-diffusion systems. It follows, that the observed growth coefficient kon is smaller than the reaction- and the λ < 1 and diffusion-limited growth coefficients, i.e. 4πDR < 1, as shown in Fig. 1. Furthermore, there is a bulk particle density ζ× at which diffusion becomes the defining limitation in comparison to reaction (Fig. 1, B): kon kon ζ× = koff 2kon − 4πDR . (13) For koff = 0, if 4πDR > 2kon, then growth is reaction- limited otherwise it is diffusion-limited. One of the open questions for microtubule and actin fila- ment growth is the origin of large fluctuations [12, 10]. In part, they can be explained as an overlap of the fluctuations of the reaction and diffusion processes. This is quantified by the effective diffusion constant (derived in SI, Sec. A6) (cid:18) (cid:19) Deff,2 =h2(λζ + τ ) λ 4πDR 1 − + λ hλζ − τ 2Dπ , (14) which is larger than the reaction-limited effective diffusion in Eq. (2). In conclusion, the field theoretic model allows us to cal- culate how the reaction limit of microtubule and actin fila- ment growth is undermined due to imperfect diffusive sup- ply of tubulin or actin. It also predicts larger growth fluctua- tions compared to a model purely based on reactions. Given the overlap of fluctuations due to chemical reactions and diffusive transport, it is likely for the filament growth speed to exhibit correlations in time, the study of which would be compelling for future research. The authors thank Robert Endres, Guillaume Salbreux and Thomas Surrey for very helpful discussions. that we want to measure is represented by a combination of fields O(t), then its time-dependent, spatial probability distribution is given by the following path integral (see e.g. [23] for a detailed review) (cid:90) ∞(cid:88) (cid:104)O(t)ψ†0(0)(cid:105):= (cid:96)=0 D[ϕ, ψ]O(t)ψ†0(0)e−Aprop (−Aint)(cid:96) (cid:96)! . (8) (cid:90) ∞(cid:88) (cid:96)=0 Formally, this integral is summing all variations of all fields involved of all stochastic processes possibly occurring. The path integral is normalised such that (cid:104)1(cid:105) = D[ϕ, ψ]e−Aprop (−Aint)(cid:96) (cid:96)! = 1. (9) The (cid:96)-th term of the series is the contribution of all pro- cesses with (cid:96) interactions.3 The distribution of the fila- ment's tip position j is given by (cid:104)ψj(t)ψ†0(0)(cid:105). The ex- pected growth speed and its variance are then determined by calculating the filament's expected position and its vari- ance after time t. In the following, we consider three ap- proximations of (cid:104)ψj(t)ψ†0(0)(cid:105): Firstly, (cid:104)ψj(t)ψ†0(0)(cid:105)0 is the reaction-limited distribution, cutting the sum in Eq. (8) at (cid:96) = 0, which results in only one Feynman diagram shown in Eq. (10a). Secondly, (cid:104)ψj(t)ψ†0(0)(cid:105)2 is terminating the sum at (cid:96) = 2, resulting in two diagrams shown in Eq. (10a) and (10b). Thirdly, (cid:104)ψj(t)ψ†0(0)(cid:105)Dy is the Dyson sum, which contains terms of all orders but selects only those Feynman diagrams whose loops are arranged daisy-chain- like, shown in Eq. (10): (cid:104)ψj(t)(cid:101)ψ0(0)(cid:105)Dy = + + (10a) (10b) + . . . (10c) A priori, it is not clear which truncation of the path integral is a good approximation of the observable. However, a good agreement of the approximate result with experimental data indicates that the processes which were not included in the calculation rarely occur under experimental conditions. The second and third approximation for the average fila- ment growth speed are (cid:18) (cid:16) (cid:124) (cid:104)v(cid:105)2 =h(λζ − τ ) 1 − λ 4πDR − 1 hλζ − τ 8πD2 Loop correction term (cid:104)v(cid:105)Dy = 1 + λ (cid:16) 1 h(λζ − τ ) 4πDR − hλζ−τ 8πD2 (cid:123)(cid:122) (cid:17) . (cid:19) (cid:17) (cid:125) , (11a) (11b) The approximation (cid:104)v(cid:105)0 is given by (cid:104)v(cid:105)2 without the loop correction term. The derivation of Eq. (11) is outlined in the Supplementary Material, in Section A5. 3These interactions are in the field-theoretic sense. In fact, the term for (cid:96) = 0 already includes an arbitrary number of chemical interactions. 4 References [1] Peter Bayley, Why microtubules grow and shrink, Na- ture 363 (1993), 309. [15] Jeffrey R. Kuhn and Thomas D. Pollard, Real-time measurements of actin filament polymerization by to- tal internal reflection fluorescence microscopy, Bio- phys. J. 88 (2005), 1387 -- 1402. [2] Otto G. Berg and Peter H. von Hippel, Diffusion- controlled macromolecular interactions, Ann. Rev. Biophys. Chem. 14 (1985), 131 -- 160. [16] Tim Mitchison and Marc Kirschner, Dynamic insta- bility of microtubule growth, Nature 312 (1984), 237 -- 242. [17] Richard M. Noyes, Effects of diffusion rates on chem- ical kinetics, Prog. React. Kinet. 1 (1961), 129 -- 160. [18] David J. Odde, Estimation of the diffusion-limited rate of microtubule assembly, Biophys. J. 73 (1997), 88 -- 95. [19] L. Peliti, Path integral approach to birth-death pro- cesses on a lattice, J. Phys.-Paris 46 (1985), 1469 -- 1483. [20] Thomas D. Pollard, Polymerization of adp-actin, J. Cell Biol. 99 (1984), 769 -- 777. [21] J. G. Skellam, The frequency distribution of the differ- ence between two poisson variates belonging to differ- ent populations, J. Roy. Stat. Soc. 109 (1946), 296. [22] William Sutherland, A dynamical theory of diffusion for non-electrolytes and the molecular mass of albium, Phil. Mag. 9 (1905), 781 -- 785. [23] Uwe C. Tauber, Critical dynamics, Cambridge Uni- versity Press, 2014. [24] M. v. Smoluchowski, Versuch einer mathematischen theorie der koagulationskinetik kolloider losungen, Z. Phys. Chem. 92 (1917), 129 -- 168. [25] R.A. Walker, E.T. O'Brien, N.K. Pryer, M.F. Soboeiro, W.A. Voter, H.P. Erickson, and E.D. Sla- mon, Dynamic instability of individual microtubules analyzed by video microscopy: Rate constants and transition frequencies, J. Cell Biol. 107 (1988), 1437 -- 1448. [26] Michal Wieczorek, Sami Chaaban, and Gary J. Brouhard, Macromolecular crowding pushes cat- alyzed microtubule growth to near the theoretical limit, Cell. Mol. Bioeng. 6 (2013), 383 -- 392. [3] David Boal, Mechanics of the cell, Cambridge Univer- sity Press, 2012. [4] M. F. Carlier, R. Melki, D. Pantaloni, T.L. Hill, and Y. Chen, Synchronous oscillations in microtubule polymerization, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. Unit. States Am. 84 (1987), 5257 -- 5261. [5] Frank C. Collins, Diffusion in chemical reaction pro- cesses and in the growth of colloid particles, J. Colloid Sci. 5 (1950), 499 -- 505. [6] Yi der Chen and Terrell Hill, Theoretical studies on oscillations in microtubule polymerization, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. Unit. States Am. 84 (1987), 8419 -- 8423. [7] Masao Doi, Second quantization representation for classical many-particle system, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 9 (1976), 1465 -- 1477. [8] Detlev Drenkhahn and Thomas D. Pollard, Elonga- tion of actin filaments is a diffusion-limited reaction at the barbed end and is accelerated by inert macro- molecules, J. Biol. Chem. 261 (1986), 12754 -- 12758. [9] Carl Frieden, Actin and tubulin polymerization: The use of kinetic methods to determine mechanism, Annu. Rev. Biophys. Bio. 14 (1985), 189 -- 210. [10] Ikuko Fujiwara, Shin Takahashi, Hisashi Tadakuma, Takashi Funatsu, and Shin'ichi Ishiwata, Microscopic analysis of polymerization dynamics with individual actin filaments, Nat. Cell Biol. 4 (2002), 666 -- 673. [11] Ikuko Fujiwara, Dimitrios Vavylonis, and Thomas D. Pollard, Polymerization kinetics of adp- and adp-pi- actin determined by fluorescence microscopy, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. Unit. States Am. 104 (2007), 8827 -- 8832. [12] Melissa K. Gardner, Blake D. Charlebois, Imre M. J´anosi, Jonathan Howard, Alan J. Hunt, and David J. Odde, Rapid microtubule self-assembly kinetics, Cell 146 (2011), 582 -- 592. [13] Frederick Gittes, Brian Mickey, Jilda Nettleton, and Jonathan Howard, Flexural rigidity of microtubules and actin filaments measured from thermal fluctua- tions in shape, J. Cell Biol. 120 (1993), 923 -- 934. [14] Kunkun Guo, Julian Shillcock, and Reinhard Lipowsky, Self-assembly of actin monomers into long filaments: Brownian dynamics simulations, J. Chem. Phys. 131 (2009), 1 -- 11. 5
1305.5434	3	1305	2013-10-16T13:06:51	Quantifying the sorting efficiency of self-propelled run-and-tumble swimmers by geometrical ratchets	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft" ]	Suitable asymmetric microstructures can be used to control the direction of motion in microorganism populations. This rectification process makes it possible to accumulate swimmers in a region of space or to sort different swimmers. Here we study numerically how the separation process depends on the specific motility strategies of the microorganisms involved. Crucial properties such as the separation efficiency and the separation time for two bacterial strains are precisely defined and evaluated. In particular, the sorting of two bacterial populations inoculated in a box consisting of a series of chambers separated by columns of asymmetric obstacles is investigated. We show how the sorting efficiency is enhanced by these obstacles and conclude that this kind of sorting can be efficiently used even when the involved populations differ only in one aspect of their swimming strategy.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Quantifying the sorting efficiency of self-propelled run-and-tumble swimmers by geometrical ratchets I. Berdakin1,2, A. V. Silhanek3, H. N. Moyano1, V. I. Marconi1,2, and C. A. Condat1,2 1Facultad de Matem´atica, Astronom´ıa y F´ısica, Universidad Nacional de C´ordoba, X5000HUA C´ordoba, Argentina. 2IFEG-CONICET, X5000HUA C´ordoba, Argentina. 3D´epartement de Physique, Universit´e de Li`ege, B-4000 Sart Tilman, Belgium. Suitable asymmetric microstructures can be used to control the direction of motion in microor- ganism populations. This rectification process makes it possible to accumulate swimmers in a region of space or to sort different swimmers. Here we study numerically how the separation process de- pends on the specific motility strategies of the microorganisms involved. Crucial properties such as the separation efficiency and the separation time for two bacterial strains are precisely defined and evaluated. In particular, the sorting of two bacterial populations inoculated in a box consisting of a series of chambers separated by columns of asymmetric obstacles is investigated. We show how the sorting efficiency is enhanced by these obstacles and conclude that this kind of sorting can be efficiently used even when the involved populations differ only in one aspect of their swimming strategy. PACS numbers: 87.17.Jj, 87.17.Aa, 05.40.Fb I. INTRODUCTION Self-propelled objects moving in confining environ- ments at low Reynolds numbers exhibit interesting physi- cal properties, some of which are not yet well understood and deserve to be studied in view of their technologi- cal applications. These objects range from artificial mi- croswimmers that can be actuated upon by using applied magnetic fields [1] to motile cancer [2, 3] and stem [4] cells, to motile bacteria [5, 6] and spermatozoa [7, 8]. The study of their properties in confined regions has been made possible by recent advances in microfabrica- tion [9, 10] and observation [11, 12] techniques. Aside from the intrinsic problems posed by the motion of confined, self-propelled, run-and-tumble microorgan- isms, there is strong interest in the biomedical and en- gineering communities in efficiently controlling microor- ganism motion. A physical, nondestructive method of achieving this control is suggested by the geometrically- induced guidance caused by the walls of asymmetric openings, the funnels. This ratchet effect was first used by Galajda and coworkers to generate an inhomogeneous bacterial distribution [5]. The otherwise random motion of bacteria was controlled, i.e rectified, by the funnels in the box. Since bacteria swim parallel to the funnel walls, it is easier for them to cross the barrier from the wide to the narrow funnel opening than in the opposite direc- tion. The funnels then define a preferred direction for the swimmer motion, leading to an increase in the cell concentration on one side of the box and a consequent decrease on the other. This effect was also recently ob- served in the puller eukaryote swimmer Chlamydomonas reinhardtii [13]. Interestingly, the rectification process can be reversed if chemotactic or collective motions pre- vail, as shown in Refs. [14, 15]. Various aspects of the microorganism dynamics have been the subject of recent studies [16 -- 23]. This rectification effect can be particularly useful when there are mixtures of microorganisms exhibiting differ- ent motility strategies. In this connection it is worth mentioning that various microfluidic techniques for sort- ing motile microscopic objects have been developed in the last few years. This is the case for the separation of motile from non-motile sperm cells [24], the sorting of E. coli by length [25], the use of self-driven artificial microswimmers for the separation of binary mixtures of colloids [26] and the study of the dynamics of several kinds of particles combining asymmetric obstacles and a time-dependent voltage [27]. One of their objectives is to eliminate the cellular stress and damage associated with alternative techniques such as centrifugation. Geometri- cal sorting also avoids the use of applied fields or chemical gradients, whose maintenance at scales of the millimeter or longer is difficult [28]. Would it be also possible to use the rectification effect to efficiently sort cells by their swimming strategies? This is the question we would like to answer in this paper. Given their ubiquity, motile bacteria are of particular interest. They swim by rotating thin helical filaments called flagella; each flagellum is driven by a rotary mo- tor powered by the flow of ions (H + or N a+) across the cytoplasmic membrane. In order to take advantage of chemotactic gradients, many of these bacteria have evolved a run-and-tumble swimming strategy [29]. In the case of the paradigmatic Escherichia coli, during the run mode the flagella rotate counterclockwise and the mi- 3 1 0 2 t c O 6 1 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 3 v 4 3 4 5 . 5 0 3 1 : v i X r a croorganism moves in a forward, relatively straight direc- tion, whereas during the tumble mode, one or more flag- ella rotate clockwise and the bacterium is reoriented in a new direction [30]. As shown forty years ago by Berg and Brown for E. coli [31]: (A) runs are not strictly straight due to rotational diffusion, (B) run lengths are exponen- tially distributed, and (C) bacterial heading changes at tumbles by less than 90◦, preserving some memory of the previous run, a fact that is often neglected in theoretical treatments. It is worth noting that some marine bacteria show anti-persistency, in what is called a run-and-reverse strategy [32, 33]. The case of bacterial directed motion under asym- metrical geometrical confinement, first observed and ex- plained in Ref. [5], was modeled phenomenologically in Ref. [34]. The authors considered point-like swimming bacteria following run-and-tumble dynamics with a con- stant motor force magnitude and thermal fluctuations. Although this model neglects the details of the swim- mer dynamics, it reproduces the most important exper- imental findings and has been an inspiration for fur- ther theoretical work. In Ref. [35] the relation between the ratchet effect and symmetry breaking by the fun- nel array geometry was clarified. It was shown there that the break of time-reversal symmetry needed for rec- tification is provided by the forced rotation of bacte- ria when colliding with a wall, and not by the motor force of bacteria. This is so because the break of time- reversal symmetry provided by the bacterial motor is lost at a coarse-grained level of diffusion where detailed bal- ance is restored. Later, the influence of the specific dy- namical properties, from (A) to (C), described by Berg and Brown, on the accumulation of cells in presence of asymmetric obstacles was studied in detail in Ref. [36]. This numerical analysis used experimental values of the motility parameters. It was found that different swim- ming strategies may yield very different microorganism accumulation efficiencies, being measured as the device capacity to concentrate cells (number of concentrated cells/number of inoculated cells of the same type). We summarize the main results of that work: 1. In unbounded environments there are two processes that degrade the orientational correlation: tum- bling and rotational diffusion. The first is much more important for systems with short runs, while rotational diffusion gives the dominant contribu- tion to memory loss in systems characterized by long runs. These effects can be quantified by the velocity correlation function. 2. A study of the mean square displacement in un- bounded environments reveals that the transla- tional diffusion coefficient DT decreases strongly as the change-of-heading angle at a tumble increases. Unless typical runs are very long, DT is approx- imately given by its value in the absence of ro- tational diffusion. These results indicate that, to make accurate predictions about swimmer sorting, 2 TABLE I. Motility parameters of two different E. coli strains: s1 corresponds to AW405 and s2 to CheC497 in Ref. [31]. Swimmer ¯v[µm/s] σv[µm/s] ¯φ[◦] σφ[◦] τ [s] DR[rad2/s] s1 (wild type) s2 (mutant) 14.2 20.0 3.4 4.9 68 33 36 0.86 15 6.30 0.18 0.06 it is necessary to consider the specific motility prop- erties of the microorganisms involved. 3. When the dynamics of free swimmers is incor- porated into a spatially constrained environment (asymmetric geometry) long run lengths and small tumble emergence angles lead to an increased cell density near the walls and, consequently, to fast net displacement in the easy ratchet direction. In general, long permanence near the walls and suit- able wall-of-funnels architecture, i.e., funnel walls at least as long as the run length and funnel open- ings of the order of the cell size, favor rectification or cell concentration. 4. Increasing the average run duration, τ , increases the time of permanence close to the walls, lead- ing to enhanced rectification. If τ is negligible, the swimmers cannot take advantage of swimming along the funnel walls and directed motion does not ensue. 5. Increasing the average speed during the run and decreasing the average change-of-heading angle at a tumble, i.e. increasing persistence, enhance wall accumulation and rectification. 6. Good agreement was obtained with available ex- perimental data, specifically regarding the time of rectification and the efficiency of a microfabricated wall of funnel-shaped openings as the one used in Ref. [5]. In this work, we use the improved phenomenological model introduced by Berdakin et. al. in Ref. [36] to in- vestigate the efficiency of asymmetric microarrays used as sorting devices, and their dependence on the swimming strategies of the microorganisms involved. Our objective is to help to design good sorters, using a model that incor- porates real motility parameters. In Section 2 we review the computational model and define the quantities to be calculated, such as the extraction time and the sorting efficiency. In Section 3 we present our numerical results, which are briefly discussed in the concluding section. II. METHODS The model. We study numerically a dilute system of 2N0 microscopic self-propelled particles, the swim- mers, moving under low Reynolds number conditions and confined to a micro-patterned two-dimensional box of size Lx×Ly. The box contains M identical, equidis- tant columns of obstacles, each consisting of Nf openings (asymmetric funnels), of gap size lg and wall length lf (see Fig. 1(a)). We choose Nf = 3 and M from 5 to 20. The M − 1 inner chambers and the last chamber have all the same length lD = 150 µm. The length of the in- oculation (leftmost) chamber is kept constant, lI = 450 µm, in order to have a fixed fractional occupied area to define a high dilution initial condition at t = 0. The rele- vant geometrical parameters are illustrated in Fig. 1: (a) for the array configuration and (b) for the single-funnel shape. Each swimmer, whose location is given by a vector (cid:126)ri, is represented by a soft disk of radius rs, moving in two dimensions with speed vi and heading in the direction of the unit vector v(Φi) = cos(Φi)i + sin(Φi)j. In a con- fined space, the swimmer dynamics is determined by the overdamped equation of motion, γ(cid:126)vi = (cid:126)F m i + (cid:126)F sw i + (cid:126)F s i (1) where γ is the medium damping constant and the act- ing forces are explained in detail below. The runs de- scribed by Eq. (1) are interrupted by tumbles and af- fected by rotational diffusion, all of which results in a change of swimmer heading given by, (cid:112) ∆Φi = ∆φχ + ν 2DR∆t(1 − χ) (2) where ν is a Gaussian-distributed random number, χ is a state variable equal to 0 during a run and 1 dur- ing a tumble, DR is the rotational diffusion coefficient and ∆t the numerical integration time step. Aside from the frictional damping, the forces operating on the mi- croswimmer are: 1. Self propulsion. When starting to move under low Reynolds number conditions, swimmers in an un- bounded fluid get almost instantly to a constant final speed. In our model this constant speed is given by F m/γ, where F m is the modulus of the propelling force. The initial condition for the swim- mer population speed is chosen from a normal dis- tribution with mean ¯v and standard deviation σv. Based on this distribution, each cell is assigned a given speed at t = 0, which remains the same dur- ing the whole simulation. The heading of the swimmer is altered only by tum- bling or rotational diffusion. Tumbles are assumed to be instantaneous (real tumbles last 0.1 seconds in mean about 10 % of the run time for wild type E. coli and a smaller percentage for longer run bac- teria - see Table I ). Tumbles result in a rotation, ∆φ, from the previous direction of motion, which we consider Gaussian-distributed and centered at ¯φ with a width σφ, (see Table I and Ref. [36]). 3 Successive tumbles are spaced by almost straight runs exponentially distributed with mean duration τ . During a run, asymmetries in the self propul- sion system and environmental fluctuations result in deviations from a perfectly straight path. These deviations are measured by the rotational diffusion coefficient, DR, and included in our model via the changes in the swimmer heading [38] expressed by Eq. (2). 2. Interaction with the walls. It is modeled by a steric repulsive force (cid:126)F sw i normal to the walls, i = f sw(1 − rik/a)Θ(1 − rik/a)nk, (cid:126)F sw (3) where f sw is the maximum strength of the force, Θ is the step function, nk is a unit vector nor- mal to the k-th wall, rik is the distance between the i-th particle and the center of the k-th wall, a = rs + w/2, and w is the wall width. Since the swimming direction is unchanged during the collision and the normal component of the propul- sion force is counteracted by the repulsion of the wall, the swimmer keeps lightly bouncing against the wall. The component of (cid:126)F m that is parallel to the wall propels the bacterium along the wall with a reduced speed that is proportional to the sine of the angle formed by the incidence direction and nk. This phenomenological representation of the interaction has the interesting property of re- ducing the speed of the cells when they swim par- allel to a wall without the need of adding an extra parameter to the model. The speed reduction of a bacterium swimming parallel to a wall has been studied experimentally in Ref. [37]. Either a tum- ble or rotational diffusion may allow the swimmer to move away from the wall. This interaction is responsible for the observed ac- cumulation at the walls [38] and for the directed motion and sorting of bacteria [5]. As remarked with measurements of wall accumulation for bacte- ria with different swimming strategies in Ref. [39], the wild-type E. coli was significantly less attracted to the surfaces than a mutant strain that does not display tumbling. 3. A purely steric swimmer-swimmer repulsion of maximum intensity f s, ij = f s(1− (cid:126)rij /2rs)Θ(1− (cid:126)rik /2rs)(cid:126)rij, (cid:126)F s with (cid:126)rij = (cid:126)ri − (cid:126)rj. The hydrodynamic interac- tion between microswimmers is not important at very low swimmer concentrations [38], and we dis- regard it here. Our approximations are buttressed (4) 4 FIG. 1. Color online. (a) Sketch of the geometry of a 21−chamber microarray with M = 20 identical asymmetric funnel columns and Nf = 3 (number of funnels). All chambers, except for the first inoculation chamber, lI , have the same length lD = 150µm. (b) Single funnel geometry showing its relevant parameters: lf , lg and θ. (c) Time evolution in minutes of the normalized bacterial populations (Nch/N0) in the inoculation (leftmost) and last (rightmost) chambers where N0 is the number of cells of each kind inoculated at t = 0 s. The bacterial populations are wild-type E. coli and a mutant used in [31]: s1 (red/grey) and s2 (blue/black) respectively. Only s2 is present in the last chamber in the window of time considered, 26 min. The time to pick up s2 completely pure in ch21 is t∗ = 24.1 min and the s2 extraction efficiency is % = 85 %. (d) Time evolution as in (c), but in the intermediate chambers. Chambers 17 to 19 are not shown but are all similar, without s1. by recent measurements of cell-cell and cell-wall in- teractions using E. coli, which show that thermal and intrinsic stochasticity wash out the effects of long-range fluid dynamics [40]. These experimen- tal results imply that physical interactions between bacteria are mainly determined by steric collisions and lubrication forces. A comparison with the model of reference [34] is in order. In that reference the runs were assumed to have a constant duration, all the swimmers moved with the same speed and started in a completely random direc- tion after each tumble (the emergence angles are uni- formly distributed in [0, 2π]). Our model differs from that of Ref. [34] in all these aspects. A further difference is that we take into account rotational diffusion, which was neglected in Ref. [34], where instead the center-of- mass motion is affected by thermal random forces. These changes were already introduced in Ref. [36] to obtain a more faithful description of the observational facts. Taking into account all the interactions described above we arrive to our set of dynamical equations to be solved numerically [36] for the 2N0 run-and-tumble microswimmers. We assume that the mixed swimmers population is initially randomly distributed in the inoc- ulation chamber. Using a fourth order Runge-Kutta al- gorithm we integrate the dynamical equations of motion and we obtain the trajectories for each confined swim- mer. The averages over realizations are later performed. For simplicity we will always compare only two swimmer strategies, a situation that is easiest to implement in the laboratory using two different fluorescent markers. Of è (a)(b)(c )(d)course more than two swimmers could also be sorted as shown in Ref. [36]. Table I specifies the motility param- eters of the swimmers simulated in this work, the wild type E. coli, s1, and a faster, less frequently tumbling mutant, s2. The radius of the soft disks is taken to be rs = 0.5 µm for all swimmers. The optimal single-funnel geometric parameters for an efficient rectification of wild- type E. coli, s1, were found in Ref. [36] to be lg = 2 µm, lf = 30 µm, and θ = 68◦, so we keep these parame- ters fixed for all simulations. The box width used here is Ly = 80 µm and the wall width is taken to be w = 2 µm for both, the box walls and the funnel walls. The width of the inoculation chamber, lI = 450 µm, has been chosen to keep an initially low swimmer density. The number of swimmers, N0, of each strain is adapted to maintain an initial occupied area fraction of 0.05 at the inoculation chamber for all array geometries. If γ = 6πηrs, the fric- tional drag coefficient, rs = 0.5 µm and η = 10−2 poise (the viscosity of water at 20◦C), then γ ∼ 9.425 x 10−6 g/s. Under these conditions, the strength of the motor force of a bacterium swimming at 20 µm/s is 0.17 pN . The magnitudes of the forces acting upon the swimmers are f s = 200 and f sw = 300 in units of γ, equivalent, respectively, to ten and fifteen times the force exerted by the motor on the fluid at 20 µm/s. With this choice in our phenomenological model bacteria penetrate no more than 10 % of rs inside walls or other bacteria. Calculated quantities. With the aim of quantifying the efficiency of the sorters we propose two parameters as convenient indicators of the separation process: (a) the separation time, t∗, defined as the time elapsed between the arrival of the first swimmer in the fast, s2, class, and that of the first swimmer in the slow, s1, class, to the last chamber (chamber from where a pure cell population could be extracted or concentrated), and (b) the separa- tion efficiency, %, which we define as the fraction of the fastest type that has arrived at the last chamber by the time t∗. It is convenient to define the percent extraction efficiency as follows, % = 100 NF (t∗) N0 , (5) being NF (t∗) being the number of swimmers of the fast species that is present in the last chamber at t∗, when its purity is still 100%. III. RESULTS We first consider a sample with M = 20 funnel columns and two homogeneous bacterial distributions ini- tially inoculated in the first chamber. These bacteria are wild-type E. coli and a mutant studied by Berg and Brown [31]; their characteristic dynamical parameters are specified in Table I. We compute the variations of the to- tal bacterial populations of each mutant in the first and the last chambers, which are shown in Fig. 1(c). After 30 independent realizations, the average separation time 5 for this system is t∗ = 16 min and the average sepa- ration efficiency for the mutant s2 is % = 67 ± 19%. Three factors contribute to the high extraction efficiency for this mutant: its higher average speed, its higher per- low ¯φ, and, mainly, the longer duration of sistence, i.e. the runs, which increases both DT and the contact time with the rectifying walls. The advance of both popula- tions through the various chambers is shown in Fig. 1(d), where we see that the purification process improves with successive chambers. From chamber 12 onwards, we also observe that the time evolution of the s2 pulse (blue) is almost position-independent until it reaches the last column. Instantaneous snapshots of the bacterial pop- ulations considered in Fig. 1 are shown, as functions of time, in Fig. 2(a), where they are seen to start from a uniform distribution in the inoculation chamber and ad- vance at different rates in the easy ratchet direction. A comparison between corresponding panels in Figs. 2(b) and 2(c) shows clearly how these rates are enhanced by the ratchet geometry of the column array, giving an es- timated 5 µm/s drift velocity for the s2 population, five times larger than that found for s1. As a result of these different velocities inside the box, both populations are soon largely separated and can be readily sorted out. It is interesting to compare what happens in the spe- cially designed box, an array of funnel columns, with the result obtained in a single channel with the same area and clean of obstacles, when the bacterial populations are subject to the same initial conditions. In the clean box, as the histograms in Fig. 2(b) show, the fast type also moves forward first, in part taking advantage of its longer runs along the side walls, but the separation is much less efficient than for the funnel-containing box, for which at t = 20 min there is no s1 swimmer from chamber 16 to 21. Purification is complete there. For the particular realization represented in Fig. 2(b) the ex- traction time and extraction efficiency are, respectively, t∗ = 24.1 min and % = 85%. At very long times, a uniform distribution is expected for the single-chamber configuration, while an exponentially increasing popula- tion of each bacterial type is expected in the specially designed box. This exponential increase is responsible for the high concentrations near the end of the array of columns, which permit the extraction of a high fraction of the first bacterial type arriving there. This situation is clearly shown in Fig. 2(c), where it is also possible to ob- serve s2 concentration spikes where the obstacle columns are located. The stronger tendency of s2 to concentrate near the walls, as compared to s1, was recently studied in detail [36]. Now we study the sorter efficiency of two swimmers (one real and the second real or artificial) as a function of the specific dynamical parameters characterizing the microswimmers. In Fig. 3 we show the extraction times and sorting efficiencies for two swimmers, one of which is wild-type E. coli, s1, and the other sx, for which a sin- gle motility parameter is changed. From Figs. 3(a) and 3(b), for which only the mutant speed was changed, we 6 FIG. 3. Color online. (a) Extraction or pick up time and (b) sorting efficiency for the fastest swimmer to reach the last chamber when we simultaneously simulate wild-type E. coli, s1, and a mutant, sx, for which only the average run speed is changed. (c) and (d): the same quantities when only the average tumbling angle ¯φx of the mutant is changed. Inset: sorting efficiency when only the mean run duration, τx, of the second swimmer is changed. Note the different vertical scales between (b) and (d). Here we use a smaller array with M = 10. changing the mean speed, the corresponding sorting ef- ficiencies, panel (d), are markedly lower. In this case, we compared a hypothetical swimmer sx, whose average tumbling angle ¯φx is modified, with the wild type, for which ¯φ1 = 68◦. Easiest to separate are the persistent- walk bacteria, for which ¯φx = 0◦ and the run-and-reverse bacteria, for which ¯φx = 180◦. It is worth noting that large t∗ does not necessarily mean large %. For example, if ¯φx = 180◦, t∗ = 16 min, but % is only 5%, a relatively low value when compared with % = 20% that results for ¯φx = 0◦, for which t∗ is only 7 min. IV. DISCUSSION We have investigated arrays of asymmetric-funnel columns built for the purpose of concentrating or sort- ing out one type of self-propelled swimmer in a run-and- tumble microorganism mixture. As characteristic param- eters to measure the suitability of a given architecture, we introduced the extraction time and the sorting efficiency. The first is important because it gives us the length of the temporal window available to the experimentalist to pick up the chosen strain, but does not tell us anything about the number of swimmers ready to be extracted. This is given by the separation or sorting efficiency. The separation efficiency depends both on the motil- ity parameters of the swimmers and on the geometrical dimensions of the device, which we can modify accord- ing to the swimmer types we are dealing with. Here we have considered the competition between swimmers hav- FIG. 2. Color online. (a) Snapshots illustrating the separa- tion of the two bacterial types considered in Fig. 1. After being uniformly inoculated in the first chamber, both popu- lations are rapidly segregated. (b) Comparative profiles for the spatial evolution of the s1 (red/grey) and s2 (blue/black) bacterial populations for a clean box (upper histograms) and for the 21-chamber box of the same overall size (lower his- tograms) at the indicated times. The 21-chamber box is a far more efficient extraction device than the single-chamber box. see that, when vx < v1 = 14.2 µm/s (shadowed region), the wild-type bacteria arrive first and can be purified dur- ing a time t∗. This purification window is, for instance, of 20.3 min if vx = 8 µm/s. The window gets narrower when vx is close to v1, but grows monotonically when vx > v1. Similarly, the sorting efficiency has a minimum when vx = v1 but increases with the difference between bacterial speeds. We can purify 18% of 30 µm/s mutants and we have 7.5 minutes to do it. This behavior was to be expected, since a faster bacterium diffuses farther, and more importantly, can take advantage of longer runs par- allel to the walls. The saturation value of t∗ is given by the average time it would take the "slow" bacterial strain to travel from the inoculation chamber to the end of the box (this would be the separation time for a hypothet- ical infinitely fast strain). The inset in panel (b) shows that varying the mean run duration has an effect qual- itatively similar to changing the mean speed (τ1 = 0.86 s). Although changing the mean tumbling angle, see panel (c), yields extraction times of the same order as 205080110counts(b)t=1min2050801100.20.50.8counts(c)t=6min0.20.50.8t=10min0.20.50.8t=20min0.20.50.8x/Lx 4 8 12 16 20t* [min](a) 0 20 40 60 801030507090ε% -vsx [µm/s](b)0.010.1110110-τsx [s]ε% 4 8 12 16 20(c)3070110150 0 5 10 15 20-φsx [degrees](d)ing different intrinsic dynamical properties. Currently, we are working out in detail the effect of modifications in the geometrical array parameters that define the asym- metric confining system. The following are some predictions from our study: • Asymmetric funnel arrays are capable of sorting di- luted distributions of run-and-tumble swimmers in a controlled way, enhancing the efficiency obtained using a box free of geometrical constraints. • A sizable fraction of the chosen swimmers can be 100% purified even if the original mixture is composed of swimmers that are dynamically only slightly different. • In general, unless the motility properties of the swimmers are very similar, for M of the order of 10 the extraction time should be long enough to allow the experimentalist to purify the sample. In our simulations we did not include fluid flow, so that the net bacterial motion from left to right is solely due to funnel asymmetry. Under flow our results would be very different. Flow in a narrow channel is known to change the accumulation of cells on the walls and even to cause upstream swimming. Moreover, the response to flow de- pends upon the tumbling rate of the cells [12, 41]. We could hypothesize that flow may lower the sorting effi- ciency when pointing in the easy ratchet direction (left- right) and enhance the efficiency otherwise, but this is something that deserves careful study. In this paper our goal was to efficiently sort swimmers at low concentrations as experiments in view of how tech- nological applications in this field are generally made. But what would happen at high concentrations? One way to look at these problems is to adapt the well-known Vicsek's model [42 -- 45]. Hydrodynamic equations have also been obtained in the high density limit using a Boltz- mann approach [45] and through the coarse-graining of the microscopic dynamics [46]. Recently, Drocco and coworkers [15] added steric repulsion to the Vicsek flock- ing algorithm and studied the motion of self-propelled particles in a confining microenvironment such as the one considered in this paper. These authors found rectifica- tion effects induced by the high particle concentration in 7 the absence of preferential motion along the walls. The nature of this rectification process is therefore quite dif- ferent from the one we have considered here and opens the way to the analysis of a possibly rich phenomenology and other types of applications. Another extension of the studies in this paper that would be specially profitable in the case of the smallest self-propelling microorganisms could be made by explic- itly considering the influence of passive and active fluctu- ations on the system behavior. The impact of the differ- ent fluctuation types on the collective dynamics of active Brownian particles with velocity alignment has already been studied [47, 48]. Our understanding of microswim- mer dynamics would be enhanced by the analysis of the behavior of these active particle systems in asymmetric confining microarchitectures. To summarize, the purpose of this paper was twofold: First, to introduce new definitions, those of extraction ef- ficiency and of separation time, which are advantageous to quantify how effective is a given microarchitecture to sort different types of run-and-tumble self-propelling mi- croorganisms. Second, to specifically investigate how these microorganisms can be sorted by their motility strategies. We have shown how testable predictions can be made using realistic bacterial parameter values. These predictions can be very useful to design efficient microflu- idic devices. We further point out that, although run- and-tumble strategies are common in the bacterial world, this type of motion is not restricted to bacteria. The lo- comotion of the unicellular alga chlamydomonas exhibits, in the dark, nearly straight swimming runs interrupted by abrupt changes in direction. The run distributions are exponentially distributed, with ¯τ = 11.2 s [49]. Conse- quently, the dynamics of this eukaryote are likely to be describable by the model discussed in this paper as well. Our numerical calculations can be easily generalized to include the possibility of bacterial birth/death during the experiment, work we have in progress. Acknowledgments This work was supported by CONICET (PIP 112- 200801-00772 and PIP 112-201101-00213) and SeCyT- UNC (Projects No. 05/B354 and No. 30720110101526) (Argentina), (Belgium)-CONICET, FWO- MINCyT FW/09/04 and KU Leuven-UNC bilateral projects. FNRS [1] E. E. Keaveny, S. W. Walker, M. J. Shelley, Nano Lett. [7] J. Elgeti, U. B. Kaupp, G. Gompper, Biophys. J. 99, 13, 531 (2013) 1018 (2010) [2] G. Mahmud et al., Nature Phys. 5, 606 (2009) [3] K. Konstantopoulus, P. Wu, D. Wirtz, Biophys. J. 104, 279 (2013) [4] R. Peng, X. Yao, J. Ding, Biomaterials. 32, 8048 (2011) [5] P. Galajda, J. Keymer, P. Chaikin, R. Austin, J. [8] P. Denissenko, V. Kantsler, D. J. Smith, J. Kirkman- Brown, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 109, 8007 (2012) [9] T. M. Squires, S. R. Quake, Rev. Mod. Phys. 77, 977 (2005) [10] K. Leung et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 109, 20 Bacteriol. 189, 8704 (2007) (2012) [6] S. Y. Kim, E. S. Lee, H. J. Lee, S. Y. Lee, S. K. Lee, T. Kim, J. Micromech. Microeng. 20, 0950061 (2010) [11] L. G. Wilson et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 018101 (2011) [12] E. Altshuler, G. Mino, C. P´erez-Penichet, L. del R´ıo, 8 A. Lindner, A. Rousselet, E. Cl´ement, Soft Matter 9, 1864 (2013) [31] H. C. Berg, D. A. Brown, Nature 239, 500 (1972) [32] G.M. Barbara, J.G. Mitchell, FEMS Microbiol. Ecol. 44, [13] V. Kantsler, J. Dunkel, M. Polin, R. E. Goldstein, Proc. 79 (2003) Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 110, 4 (2013) [33] L. Xie, T. Altindal, S. Chattopadhyay, X.L. Wu, Proc. [14] G. Lambert, D. Liao, R. H. Austin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108, 22462251 (2011) 168102 (2010) [34] M. Wan, C. J. O. Reichhardt, Z. Nussinov, C. Reich- [15] J. A. Drocco, C. J. O. Reichhardt, C. Reichhardt, Phys. hardt, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 018102 (2008) Rev. E 85, 056102 (2012) [16] C. A. Condat, J. Jackle, S. A. Mench´on. Phys. Rev. E 72, 021909, (2005) [17] F. Peruani, L. G. Morelli, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 010602 (2007) [35] J. Tailleur, M. E. Cates, Eur. Phys. Lett. 86, 60002 (2009) [36] I. Berdakin,Y. Jeyaram, V. V. Moshchalkov, L. Venken, S. Dierckx, S. J. Vanderleyden, A. V. Silhanek, C. A. Condat, V. I. Marconi, Phys. Rev. E 87, 052702 (2013) [18] V. Garcia, M. Birbaumer, F Schweitzer, Eur. Phys. J. B [37] P. D. Frymier, R. M. Ford, H. C. Berg, P. T. Cummingssi, 82, 235 (2011) [19] M. E. Di Salvo, C. A. Condat, Phys. Rev. E 86, 061907 (2012) [20] G. Gr´egoire, H. Chat´e, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 025702 (2004) [21] E. Bertin, M. Droz, G. Gr´egoire, J. Phys. A 42, 445001 (2009) [22] C. A. Weber et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 208001 (2013) [23] P. Romanczuk, L. Schimansky-Geier, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 230601 (2011) [24] B. S. Cho, T. G. Schuster, X. M. Zhu, D. Chang, G. D. Smith, S. Takayama, Anal. Chem. 75, 4671 (2003) [25] S. E. Hulme, W. R. DiLuzio, S. S. Shevkoplyas, L. Turner, M. Mayer, H. C. Berg, G. M. Whitesides, Lab on a Chip 8, 1888 (2008) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 92,6195-9 (1995) [38] G. Li, J. X. Tang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 078101 (2009) [39] G. Mino, T. E. Mallouk, T. Darnige, M. Hoyos, J. Dauchet, J. Dunstan, R. Soto, Y. Wang, A. Rous- selet, E. Cl´ement, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 0481021 (2011) [40] K. Drescher, J. Dunkel, L. H. Cisneros, S. Ganguly, R. E. Goldstein, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108,10940 (2011) [41] A. Costanzo, R. Di Leonardo, G. Ruocco, L. Angelani, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 24 065101 (2012) [42] T. Vicsek, A. Czirok, E. Ben-Jacob, O. Shochet, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1226 (1995) I. Cohen, [43] G. Gr´egoire, H. Chat´e, Y. Tu, Physica D 181, 157 (2003). [44] H. Chat´e, F. Ginelli ,G. Gr´egoire, F. Raynaud, Phys. Rev. E 77, 046113 (2008) [26] W. Yang, V. R. Misko, K. Nelissen, M. Kong, [45] E. Bertin, M. Droz, G. Gr´egoire, Phys. Rev. E 74, 022101 F. M. Peeters, Soft Matter 8, 5175 (2012) (2006) [27] L. Bogunovic, R. Eichhorn, J. Regtmeier, D. Ansel- metti, P. Reimann, Soft Matter 8, 3900 (2012) [46] T. Ihle, Phys. Rev. E 83, 030901(R) (2011). [47] R. Grossmann, L. Schimansky-Geier, P. Romanczuk, [28] J. Voldman, Nature Phys. 5, 536 (2009) [29] H. C. Berg, Random Walks in Biology (Princeton Uni- versity Press, Princeton, New Jersey, 1993) [30] H. C. Berg, E. coli in motion (Springer, New York, 2004) New Journal of Physics14, 073033 (2012) [48] P. Romanczuk, M. Baer, W. Ebeling, B. Lindner, L. Schimansky-Geier, Eur. Phys. J. Special Topics 202, 1 (2012) [49] M. Polin, I. Tuval, K. Drescher, J. P. Gollub, R. E. Goldstein, Science 325, 487 (2009)
1203.3005	1	1203	2012-03-14T06:11:59	On the Theory of Dielectric Spectroscopy of Protein Solutions	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft" ]	We present a theory of the dielectric response of a solution containing large solutes, of a nanometer size, in a molecular solvent. It combines the molecular dipole moment of the solute with the polarization of a large subensemble of solvent molecules at the solute-solvent interface. The goal of the theory is two-fold: (i) to formulate the problem of the dielectric response avoiding the reliance on the cavity-field concepts of dielectric theories and (ii) to separate the non-additive polarization of the interface, jointly produced by the external field of the laboratory experiment and the solute, from specific solute-solvent interactions contributing to the dielectric signal. The theory is applied to experimentally reported frequency-dependent dielectric spectra of lysozyme in solution. The analysis of the data in the broad range of frequencies up to 700 GHz shows that the cavity field susceptibility, critical for the theory formulation, is consistent with the prediction of Maxwell's electrostatics in the frequency range of 10--200 GHz, but deviates from it outside this range. In particular, it becomes much smaller then the Maxwell result and shifts to negative values at small frequencies. The latter observation implies a dia-electric response, or negative dielectrophoresis, of hydrated lysozyme. It also implies that the effective protein dipole recorded by dielectric spectroscopy is much smaller than the value calculated from protein's charge distribution. We suggest an empirical equation that describes both the increment of the static dielectric constat and the decrement of the Debye water peak with increasing protein concentration. It gives fair agreement with broad-band dispersion and loss spectra of protein solutions, but misses the delta-dispersion region.	physics.bio-ph	physics	On the Theory of Dielectric Spectroscopy of Protein Solutions Dmitry V. Matyushov Center for Biological Physics, Arizona State University, PO Box 871504, Tempe, AZ 85287-1504 E-mail: [email protected] Abstract. We present a theory of the dielectric response of a solution containing large solutes, of a nanometer size, in a molecular solvent. It combines the molecular dipole moment of the solute with the polarization of a large subensemble of solvent molecules at the solute-solvent interface. The goal of the theory is two-fold: (i) to formulate the problem of the dielectric response avoiding the reliance on the cavity- field concepts of dielectric theories and (ii) to separate the non-additive polarization of the interface, jointly produced by the external field of the laboratory experiment and the solute, from specific solute-solvent interactions contributing to the dielectric signal. The theory is applied to experimentally reported frequency-dependent dielectric spectra of lysozyme in solution. The analysis of the data in the broad range of frequencies up to 700 GHz shows that the cavity field susceptibility, critical for the theory formulation, is consistent with the prediction of Maxwell's electrostatics in the frequency range of 10 -- 200 GHz, but deviates from it outside this range. In particular, it becomes much smaller then the Maxwell result and shifts to negative values at small frequencies. The latter observation implies a dia-electric response, or negative dielectrophoresis, of hydrated lysozyme. It also implies that the effective protein dipole recorded by dielectric spectroscopy is much smaller than the value calculated from protein's charge distribution. We suggest an empirical equation that describes both the increment of the static dielectric constat and the decrement of the Debye water peak with increasing protein concentration. It gives fair agreement with broad-band dispersion and loss spectra of protein solutions, but misses the δ-dispersion region. Keywords: protein electrostatics; dielectric spectroscopy; solution; nanoscale interface PACS numbers: 87.15.-v, 87.15.He, 87.15.By, 87.10.Pq Submitted to: J. Phys.: Condens. Matter Protein dielectrics 1. Introduction 2 Dielectric spectroscopy is a linear response technique, monitoring the dynamics of the dipole moment of a macroscopic sample of a polarizable material [1, 2]. While it is highly sensitive and provides wealth of information about the dynamics of polarization modes active in a medium, the interpretation and the assignment of the observed relaxation processes often require theoretical approaches. The standard theoretical tool to study mixtures is the Maxwell-Wagner theory [2, 3] and its modifications, also in terms of effective-medium approaches [4]. All these theories assume that macroscopic dielectric constants can be assigned to all components of the mixture. This often becomes a significant oversimplification when highly heterogeneous solutes of nanometer dimension, such as hydrated proteins, are involved [5, 6]. The description of the polar response in terms of the molecular charge distribution is more accurate for these solutes [7]. Given the length-scale of the external field variation in a typical dielectric or light-absorption experiment, the overall charge and the dipole moment are the two main multipoles to consider [8]. Once a dipole is assigned to a protein, one might assume that standard models of dipolar liquids [9, 10], involving the statistics and dynamics of molecular dipoles, can be directly extended to study protein solutions. One has, however, to recognize that proteins, and other solutes of similar dimension, possess an extended interface with a molecular solvent, such as water, which is absent in the case of mixtures composed of molecules of comparable size. The interface of a hydrated protein involves a large number, ∼ 300 − 500, water molecules only in the first hydration layer. Given that the perturbation of the water polarization propagates at least into the second hydration layer [11, 12], the actual size of the protein-water interface is significantly larger. These new physical realities pose the requirement to develop new theoretical approaches to describe the polar response of protein solutions. The key question for this development is how to extend the classical theories of polar response of molecular dipoles into the realm of large solutes with an extended interfaces. The key parameter for the development of dielectric theories is the Onsager cavity (or directing) field [13] producing the torque on the molecular dipole when the macroscopic sample is placed in an external electric field [14]. The standard result of the classical theories is that the field of external charges E0 is screened by the polarization of the interface to the cavity field [14, 15] Ec = 3 2ǫs + 1 E0, (1) where ǫs is the dielectric constant of the solvent. This cavity field then directly leads to the Onsager mean-field [16] equation for the dielectric constant and, when mutual short-range correlations of dipoles are included, to the Onsager-Kirkwood relation [14]. The problem one faces in an attempt to describe a mixture of nanometer-size solutes with a molecular solvent is that there is no analog of either of these two equations. The fundamental line of inquiry here is whether one can extend equation (1), or its Protein dielectrics 3 analog, to such mixtures, or a new set of rules is required. This question is nontrivial to answer, even though some initial computer simulations indicate that, indeed, polarized nanoscale interfaces follow rules different from those established for cavities carved in dielectrics [17, 18, 12]. The simulations are however limited by the nanosecond range of time-scales. The question of what is the polar response of a nanoscale interface at low frequencies remains therefore open. This study aims to address this question by analyzing recent dielectric data obtained for solutions of lysozyme in water [19, 20]. We first develop a general formalism that does not anticipate any particular solution for the local field acting on the protein dipole. As a result of this analysis, we arrive at a surprising conclusion that the hydration layers of the protein screen its dipole even more substantially than anticipated by the standard result for a dielectric cavity given by equation (1). We start with introducing the polarization of the solute-solvent interface by the combined effect of the external electric field and the solute dipole moments. This interfacial polarization integrates into an interface dipole moment, which is assigned to each solute even in the absence of its own dipole. This development leads to the equation for the dielectric constant of an ideal solution of dielectric voids inside the polar liquid. We show that this equation is quite useful in describing the high-frequency dielectric response of a real solution, when the relaxation of the solute dipoles is dynamically frozen. We then proceed to a mixture of polar solutes in a polar liquid. Here, the cross-correlations of the solute and solvent dipoles [21] are expressed in terms of the cavity-field susceptibility, which can take different forms depending on the microscopic structure of the water layer interfacing the solute [18]. 2. Dielectric Response of a Mixture Dissolving a polar solute in a polar solvent leads to two distinct effects on the response of the medium to an external electric field. The first effect is the exclusion of the solvent from the volume of the solute. The second effect is the response of the charge distribution within solute to the orienting torque of the external field. The two effects are entangled in the polarization of the interface by the solute charges and by the external field. However, their contributions to the overall dielectric response of the solution can be separated in the frequency domain. Since they also originate from distinct physical interactions, repulsive expulsion on the one hand and electrostatic interactions on the other, we start with considering the effect of the solute excluded volume and then add the contribution of the solute dipole moment to the dielectric response of the solution. 2.1. Non-polar Solutes in a Polar Solvent Excluding the solvent from the solute volume creates the solute-solvent interface. From the standard viewpoint of dielectric theories, any interface carries an interfacial polarization when the solution is placed in a uniform field of external charges (capacitor Protein dielectrics 4 plates of the dielectric experiment). The polarization of the interface is described in the Maxwell theory of dielectrics by the surface charge density [15]. It is given as the projection of the dipolar polarization of the dielectric PS at the dividing surface S on the outward normal to the surface nS. The surface charge density then becomes σP = n·PS. This charge density integrates to a dipole moment of the interface Mint 0 = ZS rSσP (rS)dS, (2) where the surface integral is taken over the closed surface S enveloping the solute. The interface dipole polarizes the surrounding dielectric by its own electric field such that the inhomogeneous Maxwell field E(r) around the solute is a sum of the uniform Maxwell field of the external charges ǫ−1 s E0 and the dipolar field of the polarized interface E(r) = ǫ−1 s E0 +Xj T(r − rj) · Mint 0 . (3) Here, T(r − rj) is the dipolar tensor describing the electric field at point r inside the solvent by a point dipole placed at rj; the sum runs over N0 solutes with coordinates rj. The Maxwell field E(r) polarizes the liquid, with the resulting local inhomogeneous polarization P(r) = (4π)−1(ǫs − 1)E(r), decaying to the homogeneous polarization P of the external charges far from the solute-solvent interface. The overall dipole created in the solution is the integral of P(r) over the volume Ω occupied by the solvent Mmix = ZΩ P(r)dr. (4) Here, subscript "mix" identifies the solvent-solute mixture. Assuming that the interfacial dipoles of solutes are independent of each other, one gets [12] Mmix = Mhom − N0Ω0P − (2/3)(ǫs − 1)N0Mint 0 . (5) Here, Mhom = V P is the dipole moment of the corresponding homogeneous (without solutes) polarized solvent and Ω0 is the volume of the solute; P = (4π)−1(1 − ǫ−1 s )E0 is the polarization of the homogeneous solvent. The second summand in equation (5) represents the dipole moment cut from the liquid by inserting N0 voids. Finally, the last term is an additional polarization induced in the surrounding liquid by the surface charge density σP . The value of the interface solute dipole M int 0 will depend on the specifics of the solute-solvent interactions and the local polarization of the solvent created by these interactions. While it is a complex function of the entire mosaic of pairwise solute- solvent interactions for a realistic solute, an estimate of this parameter can be obtained from dielectric theories for a spherical void in a dielectric. The interface dipole reads in this case [15] MM 0 = −3Ω0P/(2ǫs + 1), (6) Protein dielectrics 5 where the subscript "M" specifies Maxwell's electrostatics of a dividing surface not affected by local solute-solvent interactions. In order to quantify deviations from this generic result, one can introduce the ratio α = M int 0 /M M 0 . (7) The dipole moment of the mixture is related to the mixture dielectric constant ǫmix mix)E0. One then obtains for the dielectric constant of the as Mmix/V = (4π)−1(1 − ǫ−1 mixture ǫs ǫmix = 1 + η0(ǫs − 1)(cid:20)1 − 2α ǫs − 1 2ǫs + 1(cid:21) + R1(η0), (8) where η0 = N0Ω0/V is the volume fraction of the solutes in the sample with the overall volume V . We have put an extra term R1(η0) in the above equation to indicate terms non-linear in the volume fraction that appear in the dielectric constant when mutual polarization of the interfacial dipoles is taken into account [22]. Similar non-linear terms appear in the response of a mixture of water with dipolar solutes discussed below. There is presently no consistent formalism to include these effects and we neglect them at the current stage of the theory development recognizing that the theory might run into conflict with the data collected for concentrated solutions. If the Maxwell result for a void in a dielectric holds, α = 1 and the dielectric constant of the mixture becomes ǫs ǫmix = 1 + η0 3(ǫs − 1) 2ǫs + 1 . (9) Equation (8), with R1(η0) omitted, and (9) describe the dielectric constant of an ideal mixture of non-polar solutes and a polar solvent. Equation (9) also reduces to the standard result of the Maxwell-Wagner theory in the limit of low volume fraction of the solutes [2, 3]. One can also account for the electronic polarizability of the protein not mentioned so far. If the refractive index np can be assigned to the protein, one needs only to realize that the boundary conditions of the dielectric theories are sensitive to the ratio of the two dielectric constants at the dividing surface, ǫs/n2 p. Equation (9) then extends to ǫs ǫmix = 1 + η0 3(ǫs − n2 p) 2ǫs + n2 p . (10) Equation (8) can be alternatively written in terms of the cavity field Ec inside a spherical void in a uniformly polarized liquid. The electric field inside the cavity is proportional to the external field, with the susceptibility χc = Ec/E0. In terms of this susceptibility, (8) becomes [18] ǫs ǫmix = 1 + 3η0 [χcǫs − 1] . The standard prescription of Maxwell's theory of dielectrics predicts [14, 23] χM c = 3 2ǫs + 1 . (11) (12) Protein dielectrics 6 The connection between the susceptibility χc and the parameter α (equation (7)) that is required to obtain equation (11) from equation (8) is derived from the following arguments. The polarization P(r) in the solvent, induced by the Maxwell field given by equation (3), creates a non-vanishing electric field inside the solute that is given by the equation Ec = E0 +ZΩ T(r) · P(r)dr. (13) Upon substitution of equation (3) into this relation, one arrives at the connection between χc and α 3ǫsχc = ǫs + 2 − α 2(ǫs − 1) 2ǫs + 1 . (14) Combining equations (8) and (14), one arrives at equation (11). 2.2. Polar Solutes in a Polar Solvent When a solute carries dipole moment m0, it aligns along the external field such that the average dipole hm0iE in a weak external field is given by linear susceptibility [23] χ0 hm0iE = χ0Ω0E0, where h. . .iE denotes an ensemble average in the presence of the external field and χ0 = χ00 + χ0s = (β/3Ω0)hδm0 · δMmixi. (15) (16) In this equation, δm0 = m0 − hm0i and δMmix = Mmix − hMmixi are the deviations of the solute dipole and the dipole of the sample Mmix from their average values and β = 1/(kBT ) is the inverse temperature. The solute susceptibility in equation (16) is split into the self, χ00, and solute- solvent, χ0s, parts. The former is given by the variance of a single solute dipole χ00 = (β/3Ω0)h(δm0)2i. (17) Correspondingly, the cross susceptibility is the correlation of a single solute dipole with the dipole moment δMs of the entire solvent in the sample [21] χ0s = (β/3Ω0)hδm0 · δMsi. (18) Equation (17) neglects correlations between dipole moments of the solutes in the solution represented by the corresponding Kirkwood factor. Since the latter describes short-range correlations, of the length-scale of the molecular diameter [9], they can be safely omitted in the type of theory developed here. Both standard arguments of the dielectric theories [14] and microscopic derivation [12] suggest a simple connection between the solute dipolar susceptibility χ0 and the self susceptibility χ00 χ0 = χcχ00. (19) This relation implies that the account of the solute-solvent cross-correlations entering susceptibility χ0s amounts to introducing the cavity field acting on the average solute Protein dielectrics 7 dipoles, which also defines the torque acting on a selected dipole in the Onsager theory of dipolar liquids (directing field) [13]. Adding the dipolar polarization of the solutes to equation (11) for the dielectric constant of the liquid with spherical voids, one arrives at the dielectric constant of the solution ǫs ǫmix = 1 − 3η0 + 3η0ǫsχc (1 − y0) , (20) where y0 = (4π/3)χ00. This equation clearly reduces to (11) in the limit of non-polar solutes when y0 → 0. 2.3. Frequency-Dependent Response The static arguments presented in the previous sections can be extended to the frequency domain of main interest to broad-band dielectric spectroscopy. The dielectric constants of both the solvent and the mixture become frequency-dependent functions, ǫs(ω) and ǫmix(ω). The dipolar susceptibility of an isolated solute transforms into a linear response function, instead of a static correlator of equation (17). The relevant formalism is well developed and the result is the following response function of the solute dipolar fluctuations [24, 25] χ00(ω) = χ00h1 + iω S00(ω)i . (21) Here, S00(ω) is the Laplace-Fourier transform of the normalized time correlation function of the solute dipole m0(t) S00(t) = (cid:2)h(δm0)2i(cid:3)−1 hδm0(t) · δm0(0)i. (22) This function was fitted to multi-exponential decay when applied to the analysis of the MD simulation data presented below S00(t) = Xi Aie−t/τi, Xi Ai = 1, (23) where τi are the relaxation times and Ai are the relative weights of the relaxation components. From this equation, one gets the frequency-dependent function y0(ω) y0(ω) = y0Xi Ai 1 − iωτi . The frequency-dependent dielectric constant of the solution becomes ǫs(ω) ǫmix(ω) = 1 − 3η0 + 3η0ǫs(ω)χc(ω) (1 − y0(ω)) . (24) (25) Our arguments so far have not included any approximations except neglecting mutual polarization of solutes at their high concentration and the short-range correlations of solute dipoles entering the Kirkwood factor of the solutes. However, equations (20) and (25) contain an unknown cavity-field susceptibility χc(ω). The Maxwell's result for this function refers to a free surface separating a dielectric from It is a priory not obvious that this function can describe the complex and a void. Protein dielectrics 8 ] c χ [ e R 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 110 mg/mL 28 mg/mL 57 mg/mL 111 mg/mL water/buffer 0 0.01 0.1 1 ν, GHz 10 100 Figure 1: Real part of the cavity-field susceptibility χc(ω) extracted from experimental dielectric measurements according to (25). The results combine the broad-band dielectric measurements from [19] with high-frequency data from [20]. The dotted line indicates χM from equation (12) for pure water (at lower frequencies) and the buffer (at c higher frequencies). The gap between the two sets of curves represents the frequency window between the measurements. heterogeneous protein-water interface involving both weak protein-water interactions at hydrophobic patches and strong binding to charged surface residues. However, one can use the experimental input for the dielectric constants of the mixture and pure water in equation (25) to extract the cavity-field susceptibility χc(ω). c(ω) extracted from equation (25) using frequency- Figure 1 shows the real part χ′ lysozyme solutions from broad-band dielectric dependent dielectric constants of spectroscopy below 50 GHz [19] and from separate measurements in the frequency range 70 -- 700 GHz [20]. The dotted line shows Re[χM c ] from equation (12); the break in the curve signals the transition from water to buffer used at higher frequencies in [20]. The cavity-field susceptibility follows very closely the Maxwell prediction in the range of frequencies 10 -- 200 GHz, but then deviates downward outside this range. The behavior at low frequencies is particularly noteworthy. It turns out that the dipole moment induced at the protein by an external field is over-screened [26] by the hydration layers, and perhaps the ionic atmosphere, to nearly zero. In fact, χc is below zero at ν < 1 GHz, implying a die-electric response, i.e. repulsion of the protein dipole from a region of a stronger electric field. This phenomenon, known as negative dielectrophoresis, is well-documented for hydrated nanoparticles [27], but has not been broadly observed for proteins. Our recent extensive simulations of ubiquitin [12], which is neutral at pH= 7.0, have indicated exactly this scenario: a negative χ0s, larger in magnitude than the positive χ00, thus resulting in a slightly negative χ0 in equation (16). However, this result has not been detected by simulations of charged proteins, including lysozyme, probably due to the neglect of the ionic atmosphere in the analysis. Figure 1 suggests that dielectric models of the cavity-field susceptibility do not provide an adequate description in the entire range of frequencies of interest to broad- Protein dielectrics 9 band spectroscopy. However, the modeling can proceed along separate routes since the expulsion of polar water from the solute core is significant only at high frequencies, while the polar response of the protein dipole, described by y0(ω), dominates at low frequencies. One therefore can keep the Maxwell result for χc(ω) for the former component, as realized in equation (9). Since there is currently no model allowing to describe the overscreening observed at low frequencies, we have resorted to an empirical approximation. Replacing χcǫsy0 in eqs (20) and (25) with χM c y0 accomplishes most of what is seen to occur in figure 1 and allows us to arrive at a compact relation for the dielectric constant of the solution ǫs(ω) ǫmix(ω) = 1 + 3η0 2ǫs(ω) + 1 [ǫs(ω) − 1 − 3y0(ω)] . (26) 2.4. Dielectric instability Equation (20) predicts a point of dielectric instability at which the assumption of a uniform solution of weakly interacting protein dipoles breaks down. The instability is toward clustering of dipoles and is associated with the divergence of the dielectric constant ǫmix. It is reached at the critical volume fraction 3ηc = [1 + ǫsχc(y0 − 1)]−1 . (27) If the Maxwell form of the cavity-field susceptibility is used in this equation, the critical point ηc = 0.01 (y0 ≃ 16) corresponds to the concentration of 8 mg/mL for lysozyme in solution. Lysozyme solutions are stable in this range of concentrations and this estimate is clearly too low. On the contrary, the overscreening scenario shown in figure 1 makes ηc negative, thus removing the instability altogether. While other forms of aggregation are still possible [28, 29], it might be quite possible that overscreening of the protein dipole eliminates instability toward dipolar clustering (such as formation of dipolar chains) and lowers the sensitivity of proteins in solutions to inhomogeneous electric fields always present in vivo. 3. Application to Experiment: Lysozyme Solution Dielectric measurements of solutions typically provide the real and imaginary parts of the dielectric constant as functions of frequency and solution composition [30, 31, 19, 32, 33]. The existence of these two coordinates, frequency and solute concentration, allows one to learn about the specific pattern of interfacial polarization realized for a given solute and the dynamics of processes contributing to the relaxation of the sample dipole moment. We start with the analysis of the concentration dependence at a given frequency, followed with the analysis of the frequency dependence at a fixed concentration. 3.1. Decrement of the water Debye peak Independently of the details of the dynamics of a protein itself and its coupling to the interfacial waters, the time-scales of these motions are significantly lower than the Protein dielectrics 10 0 -0.05 s ε / ε ∆ -0.1 -0.15 72 GHz 18 GHz 0 50 100 C, mg/mL 150 200 Figure 2: Decrement of the water dielectric constant in the solution of lysozyme in water, ∆ǫ(ω)/ǫs(ω) = ǫmix(ω)/ǫs(ω) − 1, as a function of the protein concentration C. The points are the experimental data at the frequency of the water Debye peak νD ≃ 18 GHz (circles) [19], and at ν = 72 GHz (diamonds) [20]. The solid and dash-dotted lines refer to the calculations using equations (9) and (10) in the order of increasing frequency. The dashed line is the calculation incorporating the dynamics of the protein dipole according to equation (26) with y0(ωD) calculated from MD simulations [12]. The lysozyme molecular volume of Ω0 = 29.8 nm3 is used to convert from the volume fraction to the solution concentration. The dotted line connects the experimental points. characteristic time of dielectric relaxation of water. The global motions of the solute are dynamically frozen at the frequency of the water Debye peak (νD ∼ 18 GHz). This implies that y0(ωD) can be dropped from equation (26). One then arrives at the dielectric constant of the mixture of polar water and effectively non-polar solutes (eqs (8) and (9)). Any sufficiently high frequency can in principle be taken for this analysis. The decrement of the Debye peak of water in the solution vs the solute concentration is often reported [8] and can be used, in the framework of the present theory, as a convenient source of data to extract the information about the parameters α and χc. Our formalism is applied to recent measurements of dielectric spectra of lysozyme solutions [19, 20]. Figure 2 shows the dependence of the decrement in the amplitude of the water Debye peak ωD in the solution ∆ǫ(ωD) = ǫmix(ωD) − ǫs(ωD) vs the protein concentration. Circles show the experimental data from [19], while the solid and dashed lines refer to equations (9) and (26), respectively. For the latter, y0(ωD) calculated from MD simulations [12], and discussed below for the analysis at lower frequencies, was used. Clearly, the protein permanent dipole can be safely neglected. The transformation from the solution concentration reported experimentally to the volume fraction required by (9) and (25) was performed by using the volume of lysozyme Ω0 = 29.8 nm3. The latter was calculated from the crystallographic structure of the protein (3FE0, PBD database) by using the algorithm developed by Till and Ullmann [34]. In accord with the results shown in figure 1, the cavity-field susceptibility is well described by the Maxwell form (equation (12)) at the frequency of the water Debye peak, and the agreement between theory and experiment is excellent. It becomes less Protein dielectrics 11 (a) ] ) ν ( ε [ e R 80 60 40 20 110 mg/mL (exp) 28 mg/mL (exp) water (exp) 28 mg/mL (calc) 110 mg/mL (calc) 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 (b) ] ) ν ( ε [ m I 10 1 0.1 0.001 0.01 0.1 ν, GHz 1 10 100 Figure 3: Real (a) and imaginary (b) parts of the dielectric constant of the lysozyme solution measured experimentally [19] (points) and calculated theoretically (lines). The dotted lines show the real and imaginary parts of the dielectric spectrum of water from [36]. satisfactory at a higher frequency of 72 GHz [20], also shown in figure 2. The refractive index of the protein starts to affect the result at this high frequency and np = 1.7 from [35] was adopted in the calculations using equation (10). The theoretical slope with increasing protein concentration is higher than experimentally reported and is likely related to deviations from the Maxwell form of the cavity-field susceptibility seen in figure 1. 3.2. Dielectric spectra of solutions The results for the dispersion and loss spectra of lysozyme solutions are shown in figure 3. Experimental data from [36] were used for ǫs(ω) and Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of a single lysozyme protein hydrated in a simulation box of TIP3P waters [12] were used to produce y0(ω) in (24). The relaxation parameters in (24) are: Ai = {0.13, 0.06, 0.81}, τi = {0.037, 0.295, 14.6} ns, y0 = 16.3. The dominant relaxation component of the solute dipole, with the relaxation time of 14.6 ns, can be assigned to protein tumbling. The relaxation time of 9.1 ns was reported for this relaxation component from the analysis of proton NMR at low resonance frequencies [37]. The usefulness of MD simulations is somewhat limited for the sake of comparison with experiment since the charge distribution in the protein studied by simulations might not entirely fit the experimental conditions. The standard force-field prescriptions for protonating/deprotonating the surface residues of lysozyme at pH = 7.0 produce the overall protein charge of +7, while the charge of +10 is reported at pH= 5.5 in the Protein dielectrics 12 experimental study [19]. Overall, permanent dipole moments of proteins arise from slight deviations from highly symmetric distribution of charge minimizing the total dipole moment [38, 39]. Shifts of pKa values of surface residues due to local electrostatic environment [40], ion association, and pH can therefore alter the dipole moment. Despite remaining uncertainties regarding the magnitude of the protein dipole when experimental conditions are concerned, the dipole hm0i = 223 D from MD results in a fair agreement between theoretical and experimental dispersion curves ǫ′ mix(ω) at the lower concentration of the protein, 28 mg/mL (figure 3a). The theory misses some of the static dielectric constant at the higher concentration, c = 110 mg/mL, but the difference actually comes from the missing increment at intermediate frequencies associated with δ-dispersion. This part of the spectrum is also missing in the loss spectrum (figure 3b). This outcome is expected since specific protein-water binding contributing to this signal [21, 41, 30] has not been incorporated into the model. 4. Summary Broad-band dielectric spectroscopy is a widely used tool to interrogate the dynamics of complex systems, including protein solutions. The interest in the field in the recent years has been to extract the polarization properties and dynamics of protein hydration layers from frequency-dependent spectra. The standard approach to the problem is to fit the dispersion and loss spectra to a sum of Debye or stretch-exponential functions, assuming that each component represents a separate relaxation process in a complex environment. The obvious limitation of this approach is the non-additivity of interfacial polarization, well recognized by classical theories of dielectric mixtures [2, 3, 4]. While these classical theories were developed for mixtures of dielectric materials, when each component can be represented by a macroscopic dielectric body, their application to hydrated proteins is clearly limited. At the same time, standard theories of dipolar liquids [10, 9] are not of much use either since they do not recognize the existence of an extended polarizable interface, which is in fact the central concept of the dielectric theories of mixtures. The present theoretical development aims to fill the void existing in each approach by recognizing both the molecular nature of the protein dipole and a quasi-macroscopic subensemble of interfacial waters producing interfacial polarization. The theory thus aims to study if the standard rules established for cavities carved in dielectrics, and also applied to calculate the local field acting on molecular dipoles [13], can be applied to hydrated proteins. Equations (25) is central to this analysis since it allows us to extract the cavity-field susceptibility χc(ω) directly from the frequency-dependent dielectric constants of the protein solution and pure water. The remarkable result of this analysis is that at ω < 1 GHz the susceptibility χc(ω) is below ≃ 0.02 predicted by the Maxwell equation (12) and is in the negative territory, down to ≃ −10−3. Therefore, the standard prescription derived for dielectric cavities (equations (1) and (12)) cannot be used in successful theories of dielectric response of protein solutions. Protein dielectrics 13 Granted, the cavity susceptibility extracted from experimental measurements might reflect the combined response of the dielectric interface and the ionic atmosphere. However, as a cumulative signature of the protein-water interface, it dramatically downscales the permanent dipole sensed by the dielectric experiment compared to its value calculated from atomic charges. Its low value can also help to explain the puzzling ability of proteins to stay in solution in vivo, despite significant electric field gradients that should pull a paraelectric particle to stick to, for instance, the bilipid membrane. The die-electric response suggested by the present analysis of experimental data, and our previous simulations [12], might be an answer to this puzzle since a die-electric solute repels from a charged interface creating the field gradient. It also eliminates the dielectric instability toward clustering of the solute dipoles predicted by (20) and (27) when the Maxwell form of the cavity-field susceptibility is used there. Acknowledgments This research was supported by the National Science Foundation (DVM, CHE-0910905). CPU time was provided by the National Science Foundation through TeraGrid resources (TG-MCB080116N). The author is grateful to Drs. Cametti and Nguyen for sharing their experimental results. References [1] C. J. F. Bottcher and P. Bordewijk. Theory of electric polarization. Deielctrics in time-dependent fields, volume 2. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1978. [2] S. Takashima. Electrical properties of biopolymers and membranes. Adam Hilger, Bristol, 1989. [3] B. K. P. Scaife. Principles of dielectrics. Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1998. [4] T. C. Choi. Effective Medium Theory. Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1999. [5] P. E. Smith, R. M. Brunne, A. E. Mark, and W. F. van Gunsteren. Dielectric properties of trypsin inhibitor and lysozyme calculated from molecular dynamics simulations. J. Phys. Chem., 97:2009 -- 2014, 1993. [6] J. W. Pitera, M. Falta, and W. F. van Gunsteren. Dielectric properties of proteins from simulations: The effects of solvent, ligands, ph, and temperature. Biophys. J., 80:2546, 2001. [7] G. King, F. S. Lee, and A. Warshel. Microscopic simulations of macroscopic dielectric constant of solvated proteins. J. Chem. Phys., 95:4366, 1991. [8] G. P. South and E. H. Grant. Dielectric dispersion and dipole moment of myoglobin in water. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 328:371 -- 387, 1972. [9] G. Stell, G. N. Patey, and J. S. Høye. Dielectric constants of fluid models: Statistical mechanical theory and its quantitayive implementation. Adv. Chem. Phys., 48:183, 1981. [10] P. Madden and D. Kivelson. A consistent molecular treatment of dielectric phenomena. Adv. Chem. Phys., 56:467, 1984. [11] A. D. Friesen and D. V. Matyushov. Local polarity excess at the interface of water with a nonpolar solute. Chem. Phys. Lett., 511:256 -- 261, 2011. [12] D. V. Matyushov. Dipolar response of hydrated proteins. J. Chem. Phys., 136:085102, 2012. [13] L. Onsager. Electric moments of molecules in liquids. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 58:1486, 1936. [14] C. J. F. Bottcher. Theory of Electric Polarization, volume 1. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1973. [15] J. D. Jackson. Classical electrodynamics. Wiley, 1999. Protein dielectrics 14 [16] J. S. Høye and G. Stell. Statistical mechanics of polar systems. II. J. Chem. Phys., 64(5):1952 -- 1966, 1976. [17] D. R. Martin and D. V. Matyushov. Cavity field in liquid dielectrics. Europhys. Lett., 82:16003, 2008. [18] D. R. Martin, A. D. Friesen, and D. V. Matyushov. Electric field inside a "Rossky cavity" in uniformly polarized water. J. Chem. Phys., 135:084514, 2011. [19] C. Cametti, S. Marchetti, C. M. C. Gambi, and G. Onori. Dielectric relaxation spectroscopy of lysozyme aqueous solutions: Analysis of the delta-dispersion and the contribution of the hydration water. J. Phys. Chem. B, 115(21):7144 -- 7153, 2011. [20] N. Q. Vinh, S. James Allen, and Kevin W. Plaxco. Dielectric spectroscopy of proteins as a quantitative experimental test of computational models of their low-frequency harmonic motions. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 133(23):8942 -- 8947, 05 2011. [21] S. Boresch, P. Hochtl, and O. Steinhauser. Studying the dielectric properties of a protein solution by computer simulation. J. Phys. Chem. B, 104:8743, 2000. [22] D. V. Matyushov. Terrahertz response of dielectric mixtures. Phys. Rev. E, 81:021914, 2010. [23] H. Frohlich. Theory of dielectrics. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1958. [24] J. P. Hansen and I. R. McDonald. Theory of Simple Liquids. Academic Press, Amsterdam, 2003. [25] Nilashis Nandi and Biman Bagchi. Anomalous dielectric relaxation of aqueous protein solutions. J. Phys. Chem. A, 102(43):8217 -- 8221, 1998. [26] V. Ballenegger and J.-P. Hansen. Dielectric permittivity profiles of confined polar liquids. J. Chem. Phys., 122:114711, 2005. [27] T. B. Jones. Electromechanics of Particles. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1995. [28] Yun Liu, Lionel Porcar, Jinhong Chen, Wei-Ren Chen, Peter Falus, Antonio Faraone, Emiliano Fratini, Kunlun Hong, and Piero Baglioni. Lysozyme protein solution with an intermediate range order structure. J. Phys. Chem. B, 115(22):7238 -- 7247, 2010. [29] Fr´ed´eric Cardinaux, Emanuela Zaccarelli, Anna Stradner, Saskia Bucciarelli, Bela Farago, Stefan U. Egelhaaf, Francesco Sciortino, and Peter Schurtenberger. Cluster-driven dynamical arrest in concentrated lysozyme solutions. J. Phys. Chem. B, 115(22):7227 -- 7237, 2011. [30] A. Oleinikova, P. Sasisanker, and H. Weingartner. What can really be learned from dielectric spectroscopy of protein solutions? a case study of Ribonuclease A. J. Phys. Chem. B, 108:8467, 2004. [31] Hermann Weingartner, Andrea Knocks, Stefan Boresch, Peter Hochtl, and Othmar Steinhauser. Dielectric spectroscopy in aqueous solutions of oligosaccharides: Experiment meets simulation. J. Chem. Phys., 115:1463 -- 1472, 2001. [32] K.-J. Tielrooij, J. Hunger, R. Buchner, M. Bonn, and H. J. Bakker. Influence of concentration and temperature on the dynamics of water in the hydrophobic hydration shell of tetramethylurea. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1332:15671 -- 15678, 2010. [33] Hafiz M. A. Rahman, Glenn Hefter, and Richard Buchner. Hydration of formate and acetate ions by dielectric relaxation spectroscopy. J. Phys. Chem. B, page 10.1021/jp207504d, 2011. [34] Mirco S. Till and G. Matthias Ullmann. Mcvol - a program for calculating protein volumes and identifying cavities by a monte carlo algorithm. J. Mol. Mod., 16:419, 2010. [35] J. Knab, J.-Y. Chen, and A. Markelz. Hydration dependence of conformational dielectric relaxation of lysozyme. Biophys. J., 90:2576 -- 2581, 2006. [36] H. Yada, M. Nagai, and K. Tanaka. The intermolecular stretching vibration mode in water isotopes investigated with broadband terahertz time-domain spectroscopy. Chem. Phys. Lett., 473:279, 2009. [37] A. Krushelnitsky. Intermolecular electrostatic interactions and Brownian tumbling in protein solutions. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 8:2117 -- 2128, 2006. [38] D. J. Barlow and J. M. Thornton. Charge distribution in proteins. Biopolymers, 25:1717 -- 1733, 1986. [39] S. Takashima. Electric dipole moment of globular proteins: measurement and calculation with Protein dielectrics 15 nmr and x-ray databases. J. Noncrystal. Solids, 305:303 -- 310, 2002. [40] B. L. Mellor, S. Khadka, D. D. Busath, and B. A. Mazzeo. Influence of pka shifts on the calculated dipole moments of proteins. Protein J., 30:490 -- 498, 2011. [41] Hermann Weingartner, Andrea Knocks, Stefan Boresch, Peter Hochtl, and Othmar Steinhauser. Dielectric spectroscopy in aqueous solutions of oligosaccharides: Experiment meets simulation. J. Chem. Phys., 115(3):1463 -- 1472, 2001.
1208.2837	1	1208	2012-08-14T11:52:56	Glucose oxidase immobilization onto carbon nanotube networking	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	When elaborating the biosensor based on single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs), it is necessary to solve such an important problem as the immobilization of a target biomolecule on the nanotube surface. In this work, the enzyme (glucose oxidase (GOX)) was immobilized on the surface of a nanotube network, which was created by the deposition of nanotubes from their solution in 1,2-dichlorobenzene by the spray method. 1-Pyrenebutanoic acid succinimide ester (PSE) was used to form the molecular interface, the bifunctional molecule of which provides the covalent binding with the enzyme shell, and its other part (pyrene) is adsorbed onto the nanotube surface. First, the usage of such a molecular interface leaves out the direct adsorption of the enzyme (in this case, its activity decreases) onto the nanotube surface, and, second, it ensures the enzyme localization near the nanotube. The comparison of the resonance Raman (RR) spectrum of pristine nanotubes with their spectrum in the PSE environment evidences the creation of a nanohybrid formed by an SWNT with a PSE molecule which provides the further enzyme immobilization. As the RR spectrum of an SWNT:PSE:GOX film does not essentially differ from that of SWNT:PSE ones, this indicates that the molecular interface (PSE) isolates the enzyme from nanotubes strongly enough. The efficient immobilization of GOX along the carbon nanotubes due to PSE is confirmed with atom-force microscopy images. The method of molecular dynamics allowed us to establish the structures of SWNT:PSE:GOX created in the aqueous environment and to determine the interaction energy between hybrid components. In addition, the conductivity of the SWNT network with adsorbed PSE and GOX molecules is studied.	physics.bio-ph	physics	V.A. KARACHEVTSEV, A.YU. GLAMAZDA, E.S. ZARUDNEV et al. GLUCOSE OXIDASE IMMOBILIZATION ONTO CARBON NANOTUBE NETWORKING V.A. KARACHEVTSEV,1 A.YU. GLAMAZDA,1 E.S. ZARUDNEV,1 M.V. KARACHEVTSEV,1 V.S. LEONTIEV,1 A.S. LINNIK,1 O.S. LYTVYN,2 A.M. PLOKHOTNICHENKO,1 S.G. STEPANIAN1 1B. Verkin Institute for Low Temperature Physics and Engineering, Nat. Acad. of Sci. of Ukraine (47, Lenin Ave., Kharkov 61103, Ukraine) PACS 78.67.Ch c(cid:13)2012 2V. Lashkaryov Institute of Semiconductor Physics, Nat. Acad. of Sci. of Ukraine (41 Nayki Ave., 03028 Kyiv, Ukraine) When elaborating the biosensor based on single-walled carbon nan- otubes (SWNTs), it is necessary to solve such an important prob- lem as the immobilization of a target biomolecule on the nan- otube surface. In this work, the enzyme (glucose oxidase (GOX)) was immobilized on the surface of a nanotube network, which was created by the deposition of nanotubes from their solution in 1,2- dichlorobenzene by the spray method. 1-Pyrenebutanoic acid suc- cinimide ester (PSE) was used to form the molecular interface, the bifunctional molecule of which provides the covalent binding with the enzyme shell, and its other part (pyrene) is adsorbed onto the nanotube surface. First, the usage of such a molecular interface leaves out the direct adsorption of the enzyme (in this case, its activity decreases) onto the nanotube surface, and, sec- ond, it ensures the enzyme localization near the nanotube. The comparison of the resonance Raman (RR) spectrum of pristine nanotubes with their spectrum in the PSE environment evidences the creation of a nanohybrid formed by an SWNT with a PSE molecule which provides the further enzyme immobilization. As the RR spectrum of an SWNT:PSE:GOX film does not essentially differ from that of SWNT:PSE ones, this indicates that the molec- ular interface (PSE) isolates the enzyme from nanotubes strongly enough. The efficient immobilization of GOX along the carbon nanotubes due to PSE is confirmed with atom-force microscopy images. The method of molecular dynamics allowed us to establish the structures of SWNT:PSE:GOX created in the aqueous envi- ronment and to determine the interaction energy between hybrid components. In addition, the conductivity of the SWNT network with adsorbed PSE and GOX molecules is studied. The adsorp- tion of PSE molecules onto the SWNT network causes a decrease of the conductivity, which can be explained by the appearance of scattering centers for charge carriers on the nanotube surface, which are created by PSE molecules. 1. Introduction Due to their unusual physical, optical, thermal, and electronic properties, single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs) have a huge potential of different promising applications including the biosensing. The main chal- lenge in the development of the devices is the biofunc- tionalization of nanomaterial surfaces and the creation of appropriate interfaces between the nanotubes and the biosystems. Carbon-nanotube-based biological sensors could find applications, for example, in measuring the concentrations of glucose in blood. This is particularly important because the number of diabetics in the world increases continuously and dramatically. In the last few years, the applications of conducting properties of carbon nanotubes in the biological sensor- ing have demonstrated the high efficiency of this ap- proach, despite the elaborations being in their infancy [1 -- 3]. The use of the conductivity of carbon nanotubes as the detection and measuring method in midget biosen- sors showed some preferences over the optical methods currently being employed in the clinical work. This is related to the fact that the most of biological processes involve electrostatic interactions and/or a charge trans- fer, which can be directly detected with the electronic equipment. Carbon nanotubes can be easily integrated into the electronic device. Moreover, the average size of an nanotube is usually compatible with the molecu- lar size of a compound being analyzed, which increases the sensitivity of the measurement. The conductivities of individual nanotubes or carbon nanotube networks can be utilized in the investigation and the develop- ment of biosensors [4, 5]. Networks formed by hundreds or thousands of carbon nanotubes distributed randomly between metallic contacts have a larger active area for the detection and can operate at higher currents. The technology for the fabrication of carbon-nanotube net- works is well developed and does not require the ex- pensive equipment to operate. The networks can be produced from solutions by deposition onto various sub- strates. 700 ISSN 2071-0186. Ukr. J. Phys. 2012. Vol. 57, No. 7 GLUCOSE OXIDASE IMMOBILIZATION ONTO CARBON NANOTUBE NETWORKING When working out biological sensors, in which an SWNT network is used, it is necessary to solve such an important problem as the immobilization of a recogni- tion biomolecule on the nanotube surface. In researches, an enzyme immobilized on a nanotube is often used as the recognition element. In some works, the enzyme was immobilized directly onto the nanotube surface [6]. However, the recent work [7] showed that the activity of two enzymes (R-chymotrypsin and soybean peroxi- dase) decreased significantly after their adsorption onto the surface of single-walled carbon nanotubes. Thus, the problem of enzyme immobilization on a nanotube that needs to be solved is to retain the enzyme native activity despite its immobilization on the nanotube surface. The problem is closely related to the nanotube functional- ization. Some success on this front has been achieved owing to the use of a molecular anchor [8, 9] or the polymer-wrapping of nanotubes [6]. The efficient non- covalent carbon nanotube functionalization by organic molecules for the biocompatibility testing was suggested by Chen and co-workers [8]. Their approach utilizes a bi- functional molecule containing succinimidyl ester and a pyrene moiety to bind proteins to the nanotube surface. Pyrene attaches to the nanotube surface by means of the π − π stacking and the hydrophobic interaction and does not disrupt the nanotube backbone. Another fragment of the anchor molecule is succinimidyl ester that binds enzymes to the nanotube surface. This molecular in- terlayer provides a sufficiently strong attachment of the enzyme to the nanotube surface and leaves the enzyme activity unaffected. The enzyme localization near the nanotube needs to provide the reliable detection of the charge, which appears as a result of the biochemical re- action of enzymes with the probe. In the present work, the enzyme (glucose oxidase (GOX)) was immobilized onto the surface of a nanotube network, which was created by the deposition of nan- otubes from their solution in dichlorbenzene by the spray method. 1-pyrenebutanoic acid N-hydroxysuccinimide ester (PSE) was used to form the molecular interface. The comparison of the resonance Raman (RR) light scat- tering spectrum of pristine nanotubes with their spec- trum in the PSE environment evidences the creation of a nanohybrid formed by SWNT with a PSE molecule which ensures the further enzyme immobilization. As the RR spectrum of an SWNT:PSE:GOX film does not essentially differ from that of SWNT:PSE ones, this in- dicates that the molecular interface (PSE) isolates the enzyme from nanotubes efficiently. The immobilization of GOX near a carbon nanotube due to PSE is con- firmed by atom-force microscopy (AFM). The method of molecular dynamics allows us to establish the struc- tures of SWNT:PSE:GOX and to determine the energies of the intermolecular interaction between components of the triple complex in the aqueous environment. In ad- dition, we study the conductivity of the SWNT network with adsorbed PSE and GOX molecules. The adsorp- tion of PSE molecules on the SWNT network results in a decrease of the conductivity, which is most likely in- duced by the appearance of scattering centers for charge carriers in nanotubes. 2. Experimental SWNTs have been produced by the CoMoCAT method (SouthWest NanoTechnologies Inc., USA). This method yields nanotubes with narrow diameters (0.75 -- 0.95 nm) and chirality (6,5) [10]. PSE was purchased from Sigma- Aldrich, Europe. All compounds have been used without additional purification. Nanotube suspensions were prepared in dichloroben- zene (Sigma-Aldrich, Europe), which is the most effi- cient organic solvent for nanotubes. Suspensions were obtained by ultrasonication (44 kHz, UZDN-2, Sumy, Ukraine) and by the following ultracentrifugation (up to 18 000 g). As a result, all insoluble thick bundles of nanotubes, as well as the metallic catalyst, were precipi- tated. To get one sample, we used 0.2 mg of nanotubes, being dissolved in 4 ml of dichlorobenzene. The carbon nanotube network on the substrate (quartz) was created by the spray method. To form this network, a special electronic device was constructed to control the nanotube network density, by using the conductivity of the deposited network and a quartz mi- crobalance. This density was regulated by the variation of the deposition time, as well as with the nanotube con- centration in a solution. After the drying of such a nan- otube network, two gold contact areas with 10 µm gap between them were thermodeposited. Glucose oxidase (GOX) was immobilized onto the carbon nanotube net- work through PSE, which formed a molecular interface between nanotubes and the enzyme [8]. PSE was ad- sorbed from its solution in methanol (10−4 M), and then GOX from its solution in water (10−4 M) was deposited. The GOX immobilization onto carbon nanotubes was controlled with an AFM Nanoscope D3000 (Digital In- struments,USA), as well as with RR spectroscopy. For AFM measurements, nanotubes were sprayed on mica. For Raman measurements, three dried films were pre- pared: pristine nanotubes, nanotubes with PSE, and SWNT:PSE:GOX. To prepare the film of nanotubes with adsorbed PSE molecules, SWNTs were mixed with PSE ISSN 2071-0186. Ukr. J. Phys. 2012. Vol. 57, No. 7 701 V.A. KARACHEVTSEV, A.YU. GLAMAZDA, E.S. ZARUDNEV et al. Fig. 1. AFM image of the carbon nanotube network on a mica substrate obtained by the spray method from an SWNT solution in dichlorobenzene in methanol (with 1:1 weight ratio, 0.3 mg/ml). The mixture was treated with the sonication (1 W, 44 kHz) for 30 min. Then the suspension was deposited on the quartz substrate and dried under a stream of warm air. SWNT:PSE:GOX hybrids were prepared by the adsorption of GOX from an aqueous solution on an SWNT:PSE film. Raman experiments have been per- formed in the 90◦ scattering configuration relative to the laser beam, by using 632.8 nm (1.96 eV) light from a He-Ne laser. The spectra were analyzed using a Ra- man double monochromator with the reverse dispersion of 3A/mm and were detected with a thermocooled CCD camera. The position of peaks of the bands in the RR spectrum of a nanotube film was determined with the ac- curacy not worse than 0.3 cm−1. This level of accuracy has been achieved due to the observation of the plasma lines of a laser in the spectra in a vicinity of the bands corresponding to the tangential mode (G) and the radial breathing mode (RBM) of nanotubes, which were used in the internal calibration of a spectrometer. Volt-ampere characteristics of the nanotube network were determined by the home-built set-up based on a microcontroller, by means of which the required range of voltages was formed. A microamperemeter, which measured a current through the network, was connected with a computer. A minimal step of the output voltage was 2 mV, and the current sensitivity reached 0.1 nA. SWNT hybrids with PSE and with GOX were mod- eled by the molecular dynamics method employing NAMD programs [11]. In these calculations, the force field Charmm27 was used [12]. For the enzyme, the stan- dard force parameters were applied, and the force param- eters of aromatic carbon were given to carbon nanotube atoms. Glucose oxidase was obtained from the Protein Data Bank. Its structure parameters were determined earlier [13]. A PSE molecule has no standard parameters in this force field. Therefore, an additional calculation within the DFT method was made (PSE parametriza- a b Fig. 2. substrate AFM image of SWNT:PSE:GOX hybrids on a mica tion is described in details in [14]). In this work, carbon nanotubes 7.95 A in diameter, 95.2 A in length, and with chirality (10,0) were used. Each system was placed in a cubic water box. The distance between the hybrid un- der study and walls of the water box was not less than 12 A. Upon modeling, periodic conditions were used. Upon modeling the pressure (1 bar), the temperature (293 ◦K) and the atom number in the system were un- changed. At the modeling beginning, the energy of the system was minimized during 1000 cycles. The VMD Program was applied for the visualization of the results of calculations [15]. 3. Results and Discussion 3.1. Analysis of the enzyme immobilization onto SWNTs by AFM We used the AFM method to study the morphology of the network of SWNT deposited onto mica from a so- lution of nanotubes in dichlorobenzene. Figure 1 shows the network of SWNTs obtained by the spray method on mica. Both single nanotubes and their bundles can 702 ISSN 2071-0186. Ukr. J. Phys. 2012. Vol. 57, No. 7 GLUCOSE OXIDASE IMMOBILIZATION ONTO CARBON NANOTUBE NETWORKING Fig. 3. Raman spectra of SWNTs (1), SWNT:PSE (2) SWNT:PSE:GOX (3) hybrids in the range of the RBM and G modes. Each experimental spectrum obtained by the laser excita- tion at λexc = 632.8 nm Fig. 4. Low-frequency fragment of the spectra of SWNTs (bold line), SWNT:PSE (thin line), and SWNT:PSE:GOX (broken line) in the RBM range be seen in Fig. 1. Then we deposited the molecular in- terface (PSE) on the network, and finally the enzyme GOX was immobilized. The AFM image of these hy- brids is presented in Fig. 2. As is seen from Fig. 2, the GOX globular structures are mainly placed along nan- otubes, and their heights are in the 4.38 -- 6.37-nm range. As the height of one enzyme globule is about 4 nm [6], the obtained heights are the sum of heights of a COX globule and a nanotube. The surface of some nanotubes is fully covered with the enzyme. The detailed analysis of hybrid heights revealed that they may be 8 -- 8.5 nm in some cases, and this indicates that the enzyme dimer is created on a nanotube. Thus, it may be concluded that, due to the PSE molecular interface, the enzyme is placed near the nanotube surface. 3.2. Raman spectroscopy of carbon nanotubes in the PSE and GOX environments Information on the noncovalent interactions of organic molecules with the nanotube surface can be obtained from the analysis of the RR spectra of carbon nanotubes before and after the deposition of these molecules [16]. The noncovalent interaction of a nanotube and an or- ganic molecule results in a shift of the nanotube vibra- tional modes and in the intensity redistribution between bands. At first, we studied such spectra of pristine nan- otubes in bundles. Then we measured the spectra of nanotubes with deposited PSE molecules and, finally, after the immobilization of GOX molecules. Figure 3 presents the RR spectra of a nanotube network in the 225 -- 1650 cm−1 range before (1) and after (2) the de- position of PSE, as well as after the addition of GOX (3). It should be noted that the spectra are similar, but the detailed analysis of some bands reveals some slight change in the spectrum after the PSE deposition onto the nanotube surface. To analyze these changes in more details, we studied the most informative fragments of the RR spectra of nanotubes: ranges of the RBM (225 -- 350 cm−1) and G (1500 -- 1650 cm−1) modes. 3.2.1 Radial breathing mode Figure 4 presents the low-frequency fragment of the RR spectrum of nanotubes, in which the RBM is observed. At the excitation by a He -- Ne laser in the 225 -- 350 cm−1 range, seven intense bands are observed for nanotubes obtained by the CoMoCat method. The spectra were approximated with a sum of seven Lorentzians. The fre- quency position of the peaks, area, and width at the half of the height of bands for the both samples were determined. These results are presented in Table 1. The nanotube chirality shown in Table 1 was determined ear- lier for these nanotubes [17]. As follows from Table 1, all bands were assigned to semiconducting nanotubes. The spectra were normalized to the intensity of the high- frequency component of the G-mode (G+), which al- lowed us to compare the band intensities in the spectra of three samples. As follows from Table 1, the spectral shift in the RBM (∼1.4 cm−1) is observed for SWNT:PSE in comparison with SWNT bundles. This shift is caused by the in- teraction of PSE molecules with nanotubes. In addi- tion, a decrease and an enhancement of the band inten- ISSN 2071-0186. Ukr. J. Phys. 2012. Vol. 57, No. 7 703 V.A. KARACHEVTSEV, A.YU. GLAMAZDA, E.S. ZARUDNEV et al. T a b l e 1. Position (ωRBM, cm−1), width at the half of the height (∆Γ, cm−1), integral intensity of Lorentzian curves normalized to the band corresponding to the G+ band, chirality of nanotubes (n,m), and second electronic transition of the semiconducting SWNTs (ES 22, eV) located close to the excitation energy of a He -- Ne laser (1.96 eV) (n,m) E S 22, eV [17] ω, cm−1 10.3 11.1 7.6 7.5 8.3 6.5 6.4 1.90 2.00 1.90 1.88 1.87 2.18 2.09 252.4 257.9 265.5 284.2 298.1 310.7 337.2 SWNT ∆Γ, cm−1 7.4 8.6 7.4 7.1 9.6 7.2 4.9 S/S+ G ×100% ω, cm−1 0.24 0.56 0.37 2.49 1.23 0.26 0.21 251.4 257.9 264.1 283.6 297.3 310.8 336.7 SWNT:PSE SWNT:PSE:GOX ∆Γ, cm−1 7.2 7.0 6.9 7.2 9.4 8.3 5.2 S/S+ G ×100% 0.25 0.40 0.22 1.36 0.59 0.21 0.29 ω, cm−1 252.4 257.9 265.8 284.7 299.2 311.0 336.6 ∆Γ, cm−1 5.8 7.4 7.1 6.7 8.8 6.9 4.7 S/S+ G ×100% 0.12 0.59 0.19 1.22 0.36 0.19 0.37 a b Fig. 5. Scheme of the resonant windows of semiconducting nanotubes with different chiralities (6,4) (a) and (7,5) (b) in the SDS surrounding (solid curve), SWNTs in the film (thin line) and SWNT:PSE (broken line). The energy (1.96 eV) of a He-Ne laser is shown by the vertical line. Lorentzian curves were used to describe the contours of resonant windows sities are seen at 265.5, 284.2, 298.1 cm−1 and at 257.9, 310.7, 337.2 cm−1, respectively. It is known that the RBM bands are very sensitive to resonance conditions, which are determined by the location of the nanotube electronic level relative to the laser energy. It is well known that the position of the nanotube electronic level depends on the interaction with the environment [18]. Thus, when the nanotube electronic level (in our case, it is the second electronic level (E S 22)) is located higher than the energy of a laser, it becomes lower upon the environmental interaction, the resonance conditions are improved, and the intensity of the corresponding band increases. Otherwise, the resonance conditions become worse, and the intensity of the corresponding band de- creases. The resonance windows for two semiconducting nan- otubes with different positions of electronic levels rel- atively to the laser energy (1.96 eV) are schematically shown in Fig. 5. The laser energy is marked with the ver- tical line. Other lines are obtained using Lorentz func- tions. In addition, the bands corresponding to the aque- ous suspension of nanotubes with a surfactant (sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)) (thick line) and in the film (thin line) and their hybrids with PSE (thin broken line) are shown in Fig. 5. The energy of the electronic transi- tion for nanotubes (E S 22) in the aqueous suspension of individual nanotubes with the SDS is by 60 -- 160 meV higher, than the energy of this level for nanotubes in a film [18, 19]. This red shift is due to the strong in- teraction of nanotubes in bundles, which are situated in a film. For SWNT:PSE, the bundling effect is much smaller, because the organic molecules become embed- ded between nanotubes in bundles in a solution during the ultrasonication and, thus, decrease the interaction of nanotubes. As a result, due to the interaction between nanotubes and organic molecules, the E S 22 level for such 704 ISSN 2071-0186. Ukr. J. Phys. 2012. Vol. 57, No. 7 GLUCOSE OXIDASE IMMOBILIZATION ONTO CARBON NANOTUBE NETWORKING SWNTs is still lower than that for individual nanotubes in an aqueous suspension. In our case, the nanotubes with (11,1), (6,5), and (6,4) chiralities have the electronic level (E S 22), which is higher than the laser energy. So, under the interaction of nan- otubes with PSE, the band intensity increases. This rule works unambiguously for nanotubes with (6,4) chiral- ity. Contrary to this, the level E S 22 of nanotubes with (10,3), (7,6), (7,5), and (8,3) chiralities is lower than the laser energy. Therefore, under the interaction of these nanotubes with PSE, the band intensity must decrease, which is observed experimentally. We note that, after the adsorption of GOX molecules onto SWNT:PSE, the spectral transformation is weaker. For example, the intensities of bands assigned to (7,5), (10,3) and (7,6) nanotubes do not change practically. 3.2.2 Tangential mode The most intense band in the RR spectra of SWNTs lies in the 1550 -- 1620 cm−1 range and corresponds to the high-frequency component of the tangential G mode [20]. This band for nanotubes and their hybrids with PSE and PSE:GOX is shown in Fig. 6. As is seen from Fig. 6, the intense band in the RR spectrum of the nanotubes in bundles (1592.4 cm−1) is low- shifted by 1.7 cm−1 in the SWNT:PSE film. This shift takes place, because the interaction energy of nan- otubes in bundles decreases due to a weaker nanotube- PSE binding energy. The intense band in the spec- trum of the SWNT:PSE:GOX complex has a peak at 1590.5 cm−1, which indicates the insignificant influence of GOX on the RR spectrum of nanotubes:PSE (located at 1590.7 cm−1). Some differences in the band positions and intensi- ties were obtained after the fitting with the sum of approximation functions. Each experimental spectrum has been fitted with a minimal number of approxima- tion functions (Fig. 6) consisting of the sum of four Lorentzians and one Breit -- Wigner -- Fano (BWF) func- tion, I(ω) = I0{1+(ω−ω0)/qΓ}2/{1+[(ω−ω0)/Γ]2} [21], where I0, ω0, Γ, and q are the intensity, BWF frequency, broadening parameter, and asymmetry parameter, re- spectively. The BWF function is used for describing the low-frequency spectral band, which appears due to the presence of metallic nanotubes. On the basis of a good coincidence between the experimental spectrum and the sum of approximating curves, the parameters of these curves were determined (Table 2). The total intensity of the whole spectral fragment was set as 100%. As is seen from Table 2, a low-frequency shift from 0.3 to 3.4 cm−1 Fig. 6. High-frequency fragment of SWNTs (bold line), SWNT:PSE (thin line), and SWNT:PSE:GOX (broken line) hy- brids in the G mode range range was observed in the film with PSE for all bands of nanotubes. Thus, in accordance with changes in the RR spec- tra of nanotubes in the PSE environment relative to the spectrum of pristine nanotubes, we can conclude that the PSE molecule forms a noncovalent hybrid with a carbon nanotube, which favors the further immobi- lization of enzyme molecules. At the same time, the absence of significant changes in the RR spectrum of the SWNT:PSE:GOX hybrid (as compared with the SWNT:PSE one) evidences that these PSE molecules isolate efficiently the GOX molecules from nanotubes, preventing their direct interaction with the nanotube surface. 3.3. Structure and interaction energy of the SWNT:PSE:GOX complex in the water environment: molecular dynamics modeling While modeling the SWNT:PSE:GOX complex, we were aimed to reveal whether one PSE molecule is able to keep one GOX molecule (covalently bound to it) near the nanotube surface. The other task was to determine the interaction energies between the PSE:GOX complex and SWNTs. It is known that PSE reacts with amino groups of peptides [8[. In this case, the CO-NH bond is formed. One PSE molecule was attached to one of the lysine side residues of GOX. As a result, a new com- pound was obtained (denoted as PSE:GOX). It consists of the pyrene fragment and a GOX molecule joined with a linker. The PSE:GOX complex was connected to the SWNT surface by the pyrene fragment at a distance of 3.5 A. The system was minimized during 1000 cycles ISSN 2071-0186. Ukr. J. Phys. 2012. Vol. 57, No. 7 705 V.A. KARACHEVTSEV, A.YU. GLAMAZDA, E.S. ZARUDNEV et al. T a b l e 2. Position (ωRBM, cm−1), width at the half of the height (∆Γ, cm−1), and integral intensities of curves described by Lorentzian and BWF (with the asymmetry parameter 1/q) functions normalized to the total intensity of the band assigned to G band (S/Smax) SWNT SWNT:PSE SWNT:PSE:GOX ω, cm−1 1521.7 1539.7 1551.2 1592.2 1601.4 ∆Γ, cm−1 30.1 12.6 15.0 15.4 31.9 −1/q 0.17 S/SG ×100% 3.1 5.7 11.1 48.8 31.3 ω, cm−1 1520 1539.1 1550.0 1590.5 1598.5 ∆Γ, cm−1 29.2 12.2 14.6 15.1 31.4 −1/q 0.15 S/SG ×100% 3.9 6.1 10.3 46.5 33.2 ω, cm−1 1518.4 1539.4 1550.5 1590.0 1598.0 ∆Γ, cm−1 37.8 16.5 13.2 15.4 28.9 −1/q 0.17 S/SG ×100% 5.3 8.3 7.4 45.8 33.2 Fig. 7. scale) and PSE-GOX and SWNT (b, right scale) Interaction energies between PSE and SWNT (a, left and then equilibrated for 10 ns with a 1-fs step. After modeling the total energy of interaction between SWNT and the whole PSE:GOX complex, the interaction en- ergies of SWNT and various parts of this complex were determined. They are shown in Fig. 7. The equilibrated structure of the SWNT:PSE:GOX complex is presented in Fig. 8. As is seen from Fig. 7, the energy of the interac- tion between the pyrene fragment and the nanotube sur- face in the SWNT:PSE:GOX complex (curve a) is in the interval (−20 -- −25) kcal/mol. This result agrees very well with the interaction energy between pyrene and nanotubes calculated for the SWNT:PSE complex [14]. Moreover, Fig. 7 demonstrates that, during the whole period of modeling, the pyrene fragment is strongly at- tached to the nanotube. This evidences that one pyrene "anchor" is able to hold efficiently the GOX enzyme on the nanotube. The total interaction energy between a nanotube and the PSE:GOX complex (Fig. 7, curve b) (from −22 to −27 kcal/mol) is equal to the sum of energies of interactions between PSE and a nanotube, as well as between GOX and a nanotube. Thus, we can determine the energy of interaction between GOX Fig. 8. Equilibrated structure of the SWNT-PSE-GOX complex. Water molecules are not shown and a nanotube, by subtracting the SWNT:PSE inter- action energy from the total interaction energy (Fig. 7, curve b). Thus, the energy of interaction between GOX and a nanotube changes during the modeling from −5 to −2 kcal/mol. This energy is due to the interac- tions between a nanotube and outward side residues of a GOX molecule. The mutual orientation of GOX and the nanotube surface changes slowly during the model- ing. As a result, the GOX -- nanotube interaction energy changes as weakly. It may be concluded that the model- ing of the SWNT:PSE:GOX complex demonstrates the absence of strong interactions between GOX and the nanotube surface. This fact allows us to suppose that the GOX activity is not changed under the formation of the SWNT:PSE:GOX complex. 3.4. Conductivity of single-walled carbon nanotube networks: effects of environment We carried out studies of the conductive properties of the single-walled carbon nanotube network sprayed onto a quartz substrate from their solution in dichloroben- 706 ISSN 2071-0186. Ukr. J. Phys. 2012. Vol. 57, No. 7 GLUCOSE OXIDASE IMMOBILIZATION ONTO CARBON NANOTUBE NETWORKING Fig. 9. Current versus voltage for an SWNT network placed be- tween two gold contacts separated by 10 µm gap (curve 1). Curve 2 corresponds to the conductivity of a sample after the adsorption of PSE zene. The dependence of the current through the car- bon nanotube network in the dry state at variations of the voltage (U ) between two contacts is shown in Fig. 9 (dotted line). The voltage is changed in ( -- 8 -- +8) V range, the maximum current (I) runs up to 4 mA, and the I(U ) dependence has nonlinear character. Most likely, the nonlinearity is related to Schottky barriers, which originate at the contact between nanotubes and a gold contact or between nanotubes of different conduc- tivities [22]. In addition, the I(U ) dependences man- ifest a small hysteresis. To avoid the effects of a so- lution on the volt-ampere characteristics, the presented dependences were obtained in 4 -- 6 days after the fabri- cation of a nanotube network or after the deposition of biomolecules. In this study, the effects of bioorganic compounds (PSE and GOX) deposited on the carbon nanotube net- work on its conductivity have been investigated. Af- ter the deposition of the molecular interface (PSE) from methanol and the drying of the film, its conductivity was about 20% less than the initial value (Fig. 9, solid line). Most probably, such a decrease is caused by adsorbed PSE molecules, which induce the appearance of scatter- ing centers for charge carriers on the nanotube surface, as it was observed earlier [2]. It should be noted that the following GOX adsorption (Fig. 9, inside curve 2) has practically no effect on the conductivity of the nan- otube network. It is obvious that this molecular inter- face (PSE) isolates the enzyme from the nanotube sur- face rather efficiently. The appearance of the hysteresis for the I(U ) dependence in similar measurements was explained earlier by the presence of charge traps on the SiO2 surface. These traps are occupied under the pas- Fig. 10. Time dependence of the maximal current (obtained at 8 V) for a SWNT network placed between two gold contacts sepa- rated by 10 µm gap (black column). Dashed and shaded columns correspond to the current through the network measured after the deposition of PSE and the GOX immobilization, respectively sage of a current in one direction and are not depleted yet, when the current has the opposite direction [19]. In addition, the time dependence was built for the cur- rent passing through the nanotube network, beginning from the nanotube network fabrication up to the PSE de- position and the immobilization of GOX (Fig. 10). As is seen from Fig. 10, some spread of current values is ob- served right away after the nanotube network treatment with a bioorganic substance, which is caused by drying the network after its wetting with methanol or water. After some days, this spread of values becomes narrower. A change in the conductivity is especially noticeable af- ter the treatment of the nanotube network with water. At once after the water evaporation, the film conductiv- ity rises appreciably. Then it reduces in the course of the time, but this takes a rather long time (some days at room temperature). 4. Conclusion The efficient immobilization of GOX onto a carbon nan- otube network through the molecular interface formed by PSE is carried out. This conclusion is based on the analysis of AFM images of the network with the ad- sorbed enzyme, whose globules locate mainly along a nanotube. The band corresponding to the high-frequency com- ponent of the G mode in the RR spectrum of the nan- otube with adsorbed PSE is downshifted by 0.7 cm−1 relative to this band in the spectrum of pristine nan- ISSN 2071-0186. Ukr. J. Phys. 2012. Vol. 57, No. 7 707 V.A. KARACHEVTSEV, A.YU. GLAMAZDA, E.S. ZARUDNEV et al. otubes. The analysis of the intensities of bands assigned to the RBM of nanotubes with adsorbed PSE in compar- ison with the spectrum of pristine SWNTs revealed the intensity transformation, which can be explained by a change of the resonance condition with variation of the laser energy. Thus, we concluded that PSE molecules create nanohybrids with SWNTs, which ensures the fur- ther enzyme immobilization. As the RR spectrum of an SWNT:PSE:GOX film does not essentially differ from SWNT:PSE ones, this indicates that the molecular inter- face (PSE) isolates the enzyme from nanotubes strongly enough. Our studies on the conductive properties of a single- walled carbon nanotube network sprayed onto a quartz substrate from a solution of nanotubes in dichloroben- zene demonstrated that the I(U ) dependence has non- linear character. Most likely, the nonlinearity is related to Schottky barriers, which originate on the contact be- tween nanotubes and the gold electrode, as well as be- tween nanotubes with different conductivities. The deposition of bioorganic compounds (PSE and GOX) on the carbon nanotube network is accompanied by a decrease of their conductivity. Most probably, such a decrease is caused by adsorbed PSE molecules, which induce the appearance of scattering centers for charge carriers on the nanotube surface. The following GOX adsorption has practically no effect on the conductiv- ity of the nanotube network that evidences the reliable isolation of the nanotube surface from the enzyme by means of the molecular interface (PSE). While studying the properties of carbon nanotube networks, whose sur- face underwent the treatment with a solution, it is neces- sary to consider the gradual desorption of a solvent from the nanotube surface (especially, this concerns water). The authors acknowledge the Computational Center at B. Verkin Institute for Low Temperature Physics and Engineering of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine. 1. K. Balasubramanian and M. Burghard, Anal. Bioanal. Chem. 385, 452 (2006). 7. S.S. Karajanagi, A.A. Vertegel, R.S. Kane, and J.S. Dordick, Langmuir 20, 11594 (2004). 8. R.J. Chen, Y. Zhang, D. Wang, and H. Dai, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 123, 3838 (2001). 9. S.G. Stepanian, V.A. Karachevtsev, A.Yu. Glamazda, U. Dettlaff-Weglikowska, and L. Adamowicz, Mol. Phys. 101, 2609 (2003). 10. W.E. Alvarez, F. Pompeo, J.E. Herrera, L. Balzano, and D.E. Resasco, Chem. Mater. 14, 1853 (2002). 11. C.P. James, B. Rosemary, W. Wang, J. Gumbart, E. Tajkhorshid, E. Villa, C. Chipot, R.D. Skeel, L. Kale, and K. Schulten, J. Comput. Chem. 26, 1781 (2005). 12. A.D. MacKerell jr., D. Bashford, M. Bellott, R.L. Dun- brack jr., J.D. Evanseck, M.J. Field, S. Fischer, J. Gao, H. Guo, S. Ha, D. Joseph-McCarthy, L. Kuchnir, K. Kuczera, F.T.K. Lau, C. Mattos, S. Michnick, T. Ngo, D.T. Nguyen, B. Prodhom, W.E. Reiher, B. Roux, M. Schlenkrich, J.C. Smith, R. Stote, J. Straub, M. Watanabe, J. Wiorkiewicz-Kuczera, D. Yin, and M. Karplus, J. Phys. Chem. B 102, 3586 (1998). 13. G. Wohlfahrt, S. Witt, J. Hendle, D. Schomburg, H.M. Kalisz, and H.-J. Hecht, Acta Cryst. D 55, 969 (1999). 14. V.A. Karachevtsev, S.G. Stepanian, A.Yu. Glamazda, M.V. Karachevtsev, V.V. Eremenko, O.S. Lytvyn, and L. Adamowicz, J. Phys. Chem. C 115, 21072 (2011). 15. W. Humphrey, A. Dalke, and K. Schulten, J. Molec. Graphics 14, 33 (1996). 16. S.G. Stepanian, M.V. Karachevtsev, A.Yu. Glamazda, V.A. Karachevtsev, and L. Adamowicz, J. Phys. Chem. A 113, 3621 (2009). 17. C. Fantini, A. Jorio, A.P. Santos, V.S.T. Peressinotto, and M.A. Pimenta, Chem. Phys. Lett. 439, 138 (2007). 18. S.K. Doorn, J. Nanosci. Nanotech. 5, 1023 (2005). 19. S.G. Chou, H.B. Ribeiro, E.B. Barros, A.P. Santos, D. Nezich, Ge.G. Samsonidze, C. Fantini, M.A. Pimenta, A. Jorio, F. Plentz Filho, M.S. Dresselhaus, G. Dres- selhaus, R. Saito, M. Zheng, G.B. Onoa, E.D. Semke, A.K. Swan, M.S. Unlu, and B.B. Goldberg, Chem. Phys. Lett. 397, 296 (2004). 20. M.S. Dresselhaus and P.C. Eklund, Adv. Phys. 49, 705 2. G. Gruner, Anal. Bioanal. Chem. 384, 322 (2006). (2000). 3. S. Roy and Z. Gao, Nano Today 4, 318 (2009). 21. A.M. Rao, P.C. Eklund, S. Bandow, A. Thess, and 4. K. Besteman, J.O. Lee, F.G. Wiertz, H.A. Heering, and R.E. Smalley, Nature 388, 257 (1997). C. Dekker, Nano Lett. 3, 727 (2003). 5. X. Dong, C.M. Lau, A. Lohani, S.G. Mhaisalkar, J. Kasim, Z.Shen, X. Ho, J.A. Rogers, and L-J. Li, Adv. Mater. 20, 2389 (2008). 22. S. Heinze, J. Tersoff, R. Martel, V. Derycke, J. Ap- penzeller, and P. Avouris, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 106801 (2002). 23. W. Kim, A. Javey, O. Vermesh, Q. Wang, and H. Dai, 6. P.W. Barone, S. Baik, D.A. Heller, and M.S. Strano, Na- Nano Lett. 3, 193 (2003). ture Mater. 4, 86 (2005). Received 12.12.11 708 ISSN 2071-0186. Ukr. J. Phys. 2012. Vol. 57, No. 7 GLUCOSE OXIDASE IMMOBILIZATION ONTO CARBON NANOTUBE NETWORKING IММОБIЛIЗАЦIЯ ГЛЮКОЗООКСИДАЗИ НА СIТКУ ОДНОСТIННИХ ВУГЛЕЦЕВИХ НАНОТРУБОК В.О. Карачевцев, О.Ю. Гламазда, Є.С. Заруднєв, М.В. Карачевцев, В.С. Леонтьєв, О.С. Лiнник, О.С. Литвин, О.М. Плохотниченко, С.Г. Степаньян Р е з ю м е При створеннi бiологiчних сенсорiв з використанням одностiн- них вуглецевих нанотрубок (ОВНТ) треба вирiшити таку ва- жливу проблему, як iммобiлiзацiя молекули, яка повинна роз- пiзнати мiшень, на поверхнi нанотрубок. В данiй роботi про- ведена iммобiлiзацiя ферменту глюкозооксидаза (ГОК) на по- верхню сiтки нанотрубок, яка була одержана шляхом осадже- ння нанотрубок з їх розчину у дiхлорбензолi за допомогою спрей-методу. У ролi молекулярного iнтерфейсу було застосо- вано сукцинiмiдний ефiр 1-пiренбутанової кислоти (ПСЕ), бi- функцiональна молекула якого забезпечує хiмiчний зв'язок з оболонкою ферменту, а друга її частина (пiренова) адсорбує- ться на поверхню нанотрубки. Використання такого молеку- лярного iнтерфейсу виключає, з одного боку, пряму адсорбцiю ферменту на поверхню нанотрубки, яка знижує його актив- нiсть, а з другого, забезпечує локалiзацiю ферменту поблизу нанотрубки. Порiвняння спектрiв резонансного комбiнацiйно- го розсiювання свiтла (РКРС) нанотрубок з їх спектром в ото- ченнi ПСЕ вказує на створення наногiбриду молекулою ПСЕ з нанотрубкою, що дає пiдставу для подальшої iммобiлiзацiї ферментiв. Оскiльки спектри РКРС плiвок ОВНТ:ПСЕ:ГОК суттєво не вiдрiзняються вiд спектрiв ОВНТ:ПСЕ, то можна стверджувати, що молекулярний iнтерфейс ПСЕ достатньо мi- цно iзолює фермент вiд нанотрубки. Ефективна iммобiлiзацiя ферменту ГОК поблизу вуглецевої нанотрубки завдяки ПСЕ пiдтверджується за допомогою зображень, отриманих атом- силовим мiкроскопом. Молекулярна динамiка дозволила вста- новити структури отриманих нанобiогiбридiв та енергiї мiж- молекулярної взаємодiї мiж компонентами потрiйного компле- ксу у водному оточеннi. Було також дослiджено провiднi вла- стивостi сiтки ОВНТ з адсорбованими молекулами ПСЕ та ГОК. Адсорбцiя молекул ПСЕ на сiтку з ОВНТ супроводжу- ється зменшенням провiдностi, яке, скорiш за все, пов'язано з появою розсiювальних центрiв для носiїв заряду у нанотруб- ках. ISSN 2071-0186. Ukr. J. Phys. 2012. Vol. 57, No. 7 709
1803.03425	2	1803	2018-11-09T16:17:08	Role of hydrodynamic flows in chemically driven droplet division	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.CB" ]	We study the hydrodynamics and shape changes of chemically active droplets. In non-spherical droplets, surface tension generates hydrodynamic flows that drive liquid droplets into a spherical shape. Here we show that spherical droplets that are maintained away from thermodynamic equilibrium by chemical reactions may not remain spherical but can undergo a shape instability which can lead to spontaneous droplet division. In this case chemical activity acts against surface tension and tension-induced hydrodynamic flows. By combining low Reynolds-number hydrodynamics with phase separation dynamics and chemical reaction kinetics we determine stability diagrams of spherical droplets as a function of dimensionless viscosity and reaction parameters. We determine concentration and flow fields inside and outside the droplets during shape changes and division. Our work shows that hydrodynamic flows tends to stabilize spherical shapes but that droplet division occurs for sufficiently strong chemical driving, sufficiently large droplet viscosity or sufficiently small surface tension. Active droplets could provide simple models for prebiotic protocells that are able to proliferate. Our work captures the key hydrodynamics of droplet division that could be observable in chemically active colloidal droplets.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Role of hydrodynamic flows in chemically driven droplet division Rabea Seyboldt1, ∗ and Frank Julicher1, 2, † 1Max Planck Institute for the Physics of Complex Systems, 01187 Dresden, Germany 2Center for Systems Biology Dresden, 01307 Dresden, Germany We study the hydrodynamics and shape changes of chemically active droplets. In non-spherical droplets, surface tension generates hydrodynamic flows that drive liquid droplets into a spherical shape. Here we show that spherical droplets that are maintained away from thermodynamic equi- librium by chemical reactions may not remain spherical but can undergo a shape instability which can lead to spontaneous droplet division. In this case chemical activity acts against surface ten- sion and tension-induced hydrodynamic flows. By combining low Reynolds-number hydrodynamics with phase separation dynamics and chemical reaction kinetics we determine stability diagrams of spherical droplets as a function of dimensionless viscosity and reaction parameters. We determine concentration and flow fields inside and outside the droplets during shape changes and division. Our work shows that hydrodynamic flows tends to stabilize spherical shapes but that droplet division occurs for sufficiently strong chemical driving, sufficiently large droplet viscosity or sufficiently small surface tension. Active droplets could provide simple models for prebiotic protocells that are able to proliferate. Our work captures the key hydrodynamics of droplet division that could be observable in chemically active colloidal droplets. Keywords: hydrodynamic flows, phase separation, nonequilibrium shape dynamics Living cells are compartmentalized in order to organize their biochemistry in space. Many cellular compartments do not possess membranes and are formed by the assem- bly of proteins and RNA in compact condensates1 -- 16. Such condensates often have liquid like properties and resemble droplets that form by phase separation of a complex mixture1,11 -- 13. Indeed protein droplets are ob- served to form in vitro by phase separation in physiologi- cal buffer13,15,17 -- 19. Such droplets can organize chemical reactions in space, and the droplet dynamics can in turn be influenced by the reactions, as has been shown both in theory8,20 -- 26 and experiments13,15,17 -- 19,27,28. The ubiq- uitous nature of RNA-protein condensates in a large va- riety of different cells and organisms suggests that the physical chemistry of macromolecular phase separation represents an evolutionary old mechanism for the com- partmentalization of chemistry and that droplet forma- tion could have played a key role at the origins of life and the emergence of prebiotic protocells15,18,29 -- 40. A minimal model of a protocell consists of a droplet that turns over by a chemical reaction and is constantly supplied with droplet material by diffusion from the outside39. In such a scenario droplets are maintained away from thermodynamic equilibrium and can reach a non-equilibrium steady state with a radius that is set by reaction parameters26. An interesting possibility is that the spherical shape of active droplets becomes un- stable and droplets spontaneously divide in two smaller daughters drops, providing a physical mechanism for the division of prebiotic cells39. Such droplet dynamics is a hydrodynamic problem because surface tension in non- spherical droplets drives hydrodynamic flows that redis- ∗ Email: [email protected] † Email: [email protected] FIG. 1. Chemically active droplet described by an effec- tive droplet model. Shown is the concentration field c (blue and green color) of a stationary droplet (interface in black). Chemical reactions B → A create a sink of droplet material B in the droplet, and reactions A → B create a supersaturation of droplet material in the A-rich phase outside. This creates concentration gradients of B, which drive diffusion fluxes of droplet material, while A flows in the opposite direction. The stationary droplet size results from the balance of the fluxes (Parameters: = 0.176, A = 10−2, across the interface. η+/η− = 1, k+/k− = 1, ν−/(k−∆c) = 1, D+/D− = 1, β− = β+, c(0) + = 0) tribute material and deform the droplet shape41 -- 44. Here we develop a hydrodynamic theory of the dynam- ics of chemically active droplets. We show that chemical reactions in active droplets can perform work against sur- face tension and flows, giving rise to a shape instability that can result in droplet division. We investigate the conditions for which droplets divide and determine hy- drodynamic flow fields of dividing droplets. We consider an incompressible liquid consisting of B-richA-richdroplet material B and solvent component A which can phase separate. The local composition is characterized by the concentration field c(x) of component B. Volume preserving chemical reactions can transform component A into component B and back, A (cid:10) B. For simplicity, we first discuss an effective droplet model. A single droplet characterized by high concentration c of component B co- exists with the surrounding fluid that mainly consists of A and contains B at low concentration, see Fig. 1. Both phases are separated by a sharp interface. The concentra- tion of B satisfies a balance equation, where the chemical reaction provide a source or sink term s±(c), ∂tc + ∇ · j = s±(c) j = −D±∇c + vc . (1) (2) Here, the indices + and − refer to quantities outside and inside the droplet, respectively. The flux j consists of advection by the fluid velocity v and a diffusion flux, where D± denotes the diffusion constant of the droplet material in the two phases. is by The reaction chemical described the rate s±(c) which in gen- concentration-dependent eral is a nonlinear function of c. For simplicity, we linearize the chemical reaction rates in the vicinity of reference concentrations c(0)± in each phase: s±(c) (cid:39) −k±(c − c(0)± ) ± ν± , (3) where c(0)± are the equilibrium concentrations that coex- ist at equilibrium across a flat interface. We have defined the reaction rate ν± = s(c(0)± ) and the reaction constants k± = ds(c(0)± )/dc. We focus on the case of positive coef- ficients k± > 0 and ν± > 0, where B is produced outside the droplet, and degraded inside, see Fig. 1. The hydrodynamic flow velocity v obeys Stokes equa- tion of an incompressible fluid, η±∇2v = ∇p , (4) which accounts for momentum conservation ∂ασαβ = 0, where the stress tensor is given by σαβ = η±(∂αvβ + ∂βvα)− pδαβ. Here η± denotes the fluid shear viscosities inside and outside of the droplet. The pressure p plays the role of a Lagrange multiplier to impose the constraint ∇ · v = 0. The bulk equations (1-4) are connected by boundary conditions at the droplet interface which we parameterize in spherical coordinates by the radial interface position R(θ, φ) as a function of the polar and azimuthal angles θ and φ. The stress boundary conditions read nn(R) − σ− σ+ nt(R) − σ− σ+ nn(R) = 2γH(R) nt(R) = 0 , (5) (6) where H(R) is the local mean curvature of the interface and γ is the droplet surface tension. The stresses at the interface on the inner and outer side of the droplet are de- noted by σ± αβ(R). The tensor indices n and t refer to ten- sor components normal and tangential to the interface, 2 nn = nασ± αβnβ and σ± respectively. The normal and tangential tensor compo- nents are defined as σ± αβtβ, where nα is a unit vector normal to the surface and tα is a unit vector tangent to the surface. Eq (6) is valid for all tangent vectors and summation over repeated indices is implied. Using no-slip boundary conditions, the velocity field is continuous at the interface, nt = nασ± v+(R) = v−(R) . (7) The concentration field c is discontinuous across the in- terface with values given by c−(R) = c(0)− + β−γH(R) c+(R) = c(0) + + β+γH(R) (8) (9) which are set by the physics of phase coexistence and a lo- cal equilibrium assumption. The coefficients β± describe the effects of the Laplace pressure on the equilibrium con- centrations at phase coexistence. In the presence of fluxes at the interface, the interface moves in normal direction. The radial growth velocity is (R) − j+(R) − · j c−(R) − c+(R) n n · er dR dt (10) = , where n is a unit vector normal to the surface and er is a unit vector in radial direction. Eq. (10) captures both convection of the interface by flows and droplet growth and shrinkage by addition or removal of material. We find nonequilibrium steady state solutions to Equa- tions (1-10) with a spherical droplet of stationary radius ¯R and stationary concentration field ¯c(r), where r is the radial coordinate, see Appendix A. The stationary pres- sure ¯p exhibits a jump 2γ/ ¯R across the interface and no hydrodynamic flows exist, ¯v = 0. An example for a sta- ble non-equilibrium steady state with steady state con- centration profile inside and outside the droplet of radius ¯R is shown in Fig. 1. We first discuss the properties of these stationary states as a function of external supersaturation = ν+/(k+∆c) and the dimensionless reaction rate A = ν−τ /∆c inside the droplet. The supersaturation is in our system generated by reactions outside the droplet and in steady state corresponds to the concentration for which s+ = 0. Here, ∆c = c(0)− − c(0) + and we have intro- duced the time scale τ = w2/D+, where w = 6β+γ/∆c is a characteristic length scale. The stationary radii as a function of supersaturation are shown In Fig. 2A-C as solid lines for different values of A. For values of smaller than a threshold value 0, no stationary radius exists. For values > 0 two steady state radii ¯Rc and ¯Rs exist, which become equal at 0 where they approach a value ¯R0. The smaller steady state radius ¯Rc is a crit- ical nucleation radius similar to the critical droplet radii found in passive systems. The larger radius denoted ¯Rs stems from the interplay of phase separation and chemi- cal reactions26,39. As the supersaturation reaches a value ∞ =(cid:112)(D−k−)/(D+k+)ν−/(k−∆c), the stationary ra- dius ¯Rs diverges. 3 FIG. 2. Stationary radii and onset of shape instability. A -- C: Stationary radius as a function of supersaturation for different reaction amplitudes A = 10−8, 10−7, . . . , 101. The station- ary radii (lines) are independent of the dimensionless viscosity F = wη−/(γτ ), while the onset of instability (red dots, connected by dotted red line) for the different curves varies in the three figures, which show dimensionless viscosities F = ∞, 1000, 10 (left to right). The blue line colors mark stable, the red ones unstable stationary radii with respect to the elongational l = 2 mode. In panel B the scaling behavior of the nucleation radius ¯Rc and the stationary radius ¯Rs are indicated. D -- F: Stability diagram of stationary droplets of size ¯Rs, as a function of reaction amplitude A and supersaturation for different dimensionless viscosities F = ∞, 1000, 10 (left to right). For small supersaturation and large reaction amplitudes, no stationary radius exists (white). For large supersaturation, the stationary radius diverges (gray). In the region between these regimes, the stationary solution can be stable (blue) or unstable (red) with respect to shape perturbations of the l = 2 mode. For decreasing F , the stable regime grows, and the minimal supersaturation ∗ at which an instability can be found increases, as well as the corresponding reaction amplitude A∗. The scaling relations (dashed lines) for the regime of stable droplets and the onset of instability are indicated, with prefactors according to A 5. (Parameters: η+/η− = 1, k+/k− = 1, ν−/(k−∆c) = 1, D+/D− = 1, β− = β+, c(0) + = 0) We can find simple expressions for the stationary radii in the limit of small A while keeping the ratios ν−/(k−∆c) and k+/k− of reaction parameters fixed. In this limit, the chemical reactions fluxes vanish as s± ∝ A and the threshold value 0 vanishes as 0 ∝ A1/3. The critical nucleation radius then behaves as ¯Rc (cid:39) w/(6) and the larger steady state radius ¯Rs (cid:39) w(3A)1/2 where 0 (cid:28) (cid:28) ∞, see Fig. 2B and A 5. The steady state solutions are independent on the fluid viscosity, however the droplet dynamics is affected by hy- drodynamic effects. We now investigate the role of hy- drodynamic flows on chemically driven shape instabilities that can give rise to droplet division. We perform a lin- ear stability analysis at the stationary state given by ¯X = (¯c, ¯R, ¯p, ¯v) for small perturbations δX = (δc, δR, δp, δv). The dynamics of these perturbations can be represented using eigenmodes (cid:88) δX = nlmXnlmeµnlmt , (11) n,l,m with Xnlm = (cnlYlm, ¯RYlm, plYlm, vlm), where Ylm(θ, φ) are spherical harmonics with angular mode indices with SupersaturationSupersaturationSupersaturationSupersaturationSupersaturationSupersaturationStationary radiusStationary radiusStationary radiusDimensionless reaction rateDimensionless reaction rateDimensionless reaction rateABCDEFno stationarydropletsshape instabilitystable dropletsno stationarydropletsno stationarydropletsstable dropletsstable dropletsshape instabilityshape instabilityl = 0, 1, . . . and m = −l, . . . , l. The index n = 0, 1, . . . denotes radial modes. The eigenmodes exhibit an expo- nential time dependence with a relaxation rate given by the eigenvalue µnlm. The mode amplitudes are denoted nlm. The concentration modes are characterized by the radial functions cnl(r). The pressure modes are described by pl(r) and the velocity modes vlm(r, θ, ϕ) can be ex- pressed as lm Φlm . vlm = vr lmY lm + v(1) lm Ψlm + v(2) lm(r), v(1) lm (r) and v(2) (12) where Y lm(θ, ϕ) = erYlm, Ψlm(θ, ϕ) = r∇Ylm and Φlm(θ, ϕ) = er × Ψlm are vector spherical harmonics45 and the radial functions vr lm (r) char- acterize the velocity field. The radial functions can be obtained by solving the linearized dynamic equations us- ing the corresponding boundary conditions, see A. The Stokes equation can be solved for a given shape pertur- bation independent of the concentration field so that the velocity field and pressure field is independent of the ra- dial mode n. The radial part of the concentration field obeys a Helmholtz equation with an inhomogeneity that stems from hydrodynamic flows. The homogeneous part is solved by modified spherical Bessel functions and the inhomogeneous solution can be found using Greens func- tions. Using the dynamic equation for the shape changes of the droplet Eq. (10), we obtain an equation for the eigenvalue µnlm, (cid:18) µnlm = l ( ¯R) vr ¯R (cid:18) + D+ ∆c − D− ∆c c(cid:48) nl( ¯R+) ¯c(cid:48)(cid:48)( ¯R+) + ¯R c(cid:48) nl( ¯R−) ¯c(cid:48)(cid:48)( ¯R−) + (cid:19) (cid:19) . ¯R (13) Here, the primes denote radial derivatives. Note that Eq. (13) is an implicit equation for the eigenvalues µnlm because the radial concentration modes cnl(r) depend on µnlm, see A. Eq. (13) is independent of the index m, therefore the degeneracy of an eigenvalue µnl is at least 2l + 1. When all µnl are negative, the spherical shape is stable. The modes with l = 0 correspond to changes in droplet size without flows. They are always stable for ¯R = ¯Rs and unstable for ¯R = ¯Rc. Thus droplet smaller than ¯Rc will vanish and droplets larger will grow towards the size ¯Rs. Thus we consider the stability of ¯R = ¯Rs in the following. The modes with l = 1 do not involve shape deformations of the droplet and are thus not asso- ciated with flows. There always exists a marginal mode with µl=1 = 0 corresponding to overall translations where the droplet and all concentration fields are displaced and then stay in the new position. Here we consider shape in- stabilities for which a mode with l > 1 becomes unstable. Because shape deformations induce flows, this instability depends on the dimensionless viscosity F = wη−/(γτ ), as well as the ratio of viscosities in the two phases, η+/η−. If we increase the supersaturation while keeping the other parameters fixed, the steady state can become un- stable with respect to the mode l = 2 for a critical value 4 = c. In Fig. 2A-C, the onset of instability µ = 0 for the largest eigenvalue µ of the stationary radius is shown as a red dot, and unstable radii are indicated by red lines. Different lines correspond to different supersatu- rations, and the panels show different values of F . In Fig. 2D-E, the corresponding stability diagrams of sta- tionary droplets are shown as a function of the supersat- uration and the reaction amplitude for different values of F . For large A and small , no stationary radius exists (white regions), so that any droplet would shrink and dis- appear. For large , the stationary state diverges (gray regions). Spherical droplets are stable in the blue regions. Stationary spherical droplets are unstable inside the red region, the surrounding black line marks the shape insta- bility with respect to the l=2 mode. The region where spherical droplets undergo a shape instability exists for ≥ ∗, which depends on F . The value of A for which the shape instability occurs at = ∗ is denoted A∗, see Fig 2E. For small A, the onset of instability can be describes by simple scaling behaviors. In the limit of small A and for (cid:28) ∞, we find ∗ ∝ F −1/2 and A = A∗ with A∗ ∼ F −3/2 (compare Fig. 2E-F). For A < A∗, hydrodynamic flows govern the onset of instability which occurs at a value of A which behaves as A ∝ −1F −2. For A > A∗, hydrodynamic flows can be neglected as compared to diffusion fluxes and the onset of instability occurs for A ∝ 3. These two scaling regimes are indicated in in Fig. 2D-F by dashed lines. A derivation of these results including prefactors is given in A 5. We next address the question whether the shape in- stability found in the linear stability analysis can indeed give rise to droplet divisions in the presence of hydro- dynamic flows in the nonlinear regime of the dynamics. We use a Cahn-Hilliard model46 for phase separation dy- namics, extended to include chemical reactions and hy- drodynamic flows, that can capture topological changes of the interface. We include chemical reactions via a source term linear in the concentration as well as advec- tion by the hydrodynamic flow which is described by the incompressible Stokes equation. Using a semi-spectral method47, we obtain numerical solutions in a cubic box with no-flux boundary conditions, see B. Starting from a weakly deformed spherical droplet, we find regimes where the droplet disappears, where it re- laxes to a stable spherical shape and where it undergoes a shape instability, consistent with the linear stability analysis of the effective droplet model. The transitions between these regimes occur for parameter values close to those predicted by the linear stability analysis. In the unstable regime, droplets typically divide. This shows that the droplet division reported previously can also oc- curs in the presence of hydrodynamic flows. Fig. 3 shows snapshots of the droplet shape together with correspond- ing hydrodynamic flow fields on the symmetry plane of a dividing droplet at different times. At early times when the droplet deformation is weak, the flow field is similar to the l = 2 mode obtained from the linear theory, Fig. 3 5 between the daughter droplets has very small magnitude, while strong flows at the outer sides move the droplets apart Fig. 3 D. This example shows that division of active droplets can occur even if hydrodynamic flows that oppose divi- sion are taken into account. Because flows act in oppo- sition to the initial deformation of the sphere, the linear stability analysis already provides the key information of whether droplet division can occur for a given value of di- mensionless viscosity F , see Fig. 2. This raises the ques- tion under what experimental conditions active droplets would become unstable and division could be observed. Ignoring hydrodynamic flows, F → ∞, it was shown that oil-water droplets and soft colloidal liquids or p-granules with sizes of a few micrometers could divide in the pres- ence of chemical reactions39. To address the influence of hydrodynamic flows, we have to estimate the dimen- sionless viscosity F = wη−/(γτ ) (cid:39) kBT /(6πγwa), where we have used τ = w2/D and D (cid:39) kBT /(6πηa) with molecular radius a. Thus, F is an equilibrium property of the phase separating fluid. For an oil-water system, we estimate F ≈ 0.1, see C. For soft colloidal liquids or p-granules, we estimate values between F ≈ 10 − 104. We can discuss these values using the stability diagrams in Fig. 2D-F. Oil-water like droplets with F ≈ 0.1 are unlikely to divide, as the unstable region in the stability diagram is very narrow. For soft colloidal systems with F ≈ 10 − 104, droplet division might be experimentally observable. We can estimate typical reaction rates re- quired for division to occur based on the reaction rate A∗ for which the range of supersaturation is maximal. The value of A∗ corresponds to a reaction rate in the droplet of the order of ν− = 10−4mM/s, see C. A comparison with reported enzymatic reaction rates48 suggests that such values can be achieved in real systems. We have shown that spontaneous division of chemi- cally active droplets involves mechanical work against surface tension as droplets deform. Active droplets thus can transduce chemical energy to mechanical work and droplet division is therefore a mechano-chemical process. The surface tension of the droplet creates pressure gra- dients as the droplet becomes non-spherical that lead to hydrodynamic flows. Because the flows generated act against the shape deformation, droplets divide only for sufficiently large viscosity or sufficiently small surface tension and sufficiently large reaction rates. We show that the dependence of the onset of stability on parame- ters is captured for small reaction fluxes by simple scaling relations. Our work shows that droplet division would be suppressed in oil-water systems due to large surface tension and low viscosity. However it could be realized in soft colloidal systems for chemical reaction parameters that could be achieved experimentally. Furthermore flux- driven droplet divisions could be observable in biological systems, as both chemical reactions and phase-separating membrane-less organelles with low surface tensions can be found within cells. FIG. 3. Numerical solution in 3d of an extended Cahn- Hilliard model with chemical reactions and hydrodynamic flows reveals that droplets can divide despite the presence of hydrodynamic flows. Panels A-D correspond to time points t/τ = 100, 2100, 2700, 2800, respectively, where τ = w2/D is a diffusion time, with diffusion constant D and interfacial width w. The dynamic equations were solved numerically in a three-dimensional box. Shown are two-dimensional cross- sections of the droplet shape (black) together with streamlines (grey). Arrows (colored) indicate the direction and magni- tude of the flow (normalized by respective maximal veloci- ties vmax · w/D = 0.0016(in A), 0.0048(B), 0.0034(C) and 0.0047(D) ). (Parameters: F = 24, A = 8 · 10−3, = 0.2, η−/η+ = 1, c(0) + /∆c = 0, k+/k− = 1, ν−/(k−∆c) = 0.8) A. As the droplet elongates and its waistline shrinks, the flow field becomes more complex, see Fig. 3 B,C. The flow field shown in Fig. 3 C exhibits two additional vortex lines that form rings around the axis of rotational sym- metry. Similarly, after division, two further vortex rings occur, see Fig. 3 D. Interestingly, for small deformations the hydrodynamic flow direction opposes the directions of interface motion at the main droplet axes, see Fig. 3 A,B. For larger deformations at later times the flow switches its direction along the long droplet axis where it assists interface motion. At the waistline, the flow velocity be- comes small, see Fig. 3 C. After division, the flow field ABCDAppendix A: Effective droplet model with hydrodynamic flows 1. Stationary state of a spherical active droplet 6 Here, we discuss stationary solutions to equations (1-10) in the main text with spherical symmetry and without hydrodynamic flows ¯v = 0, where the bar indicates a steady state value. In this case, the pressure is constant both inside and outside the droplet, with a pressure difference due to Laplace pressure between the inside and outside of the droplets, The steady state concentration profiles in the presence of chemical reactions are given by39, ¯p− = ¯p+ + 2γ ¯R . + c(0) + + A+k0(r/l+) ν+ ¯c+(r) = + k+ ¯c−(r) = − ν− k− (A3) where i0(x) = 2 sinh(x)/x and k0(x) = e−x/x denote modified spherical Bessel functions of order zero of the first and second kind, respectively. The characteristic length scales l± = (D±/k±)1/2 are set by reaction rate constants and diffusion coefficients. The parameters A± are determined by the boundary condition at the droplet interface, Eq. (8-9) in the main text, + c(0)− + A−i0(r/l−) , A+ = A− = Stationarity of the droplet radius ¯R implies (cid:18) γβ+ (cid:18) γβ− ¯R ¯R (cid:19) (cid:19) − ν+ k+ ν− k− + 1 k0( ¯R/l+) 1 i0( ¯R/l+) . D+¯c(cid:48) +( ¯R) = D−¯c(cid:48) −( ¯R) , see Eq. (10) in the main text. Note that this equation typically has zero, one or two solutions for a given set of parameters. 2. Linearized dynamics We introduce small perturbations to the spherically symmetric stationary state, with p = ¯p + δp, v = δv, c = ¯c + δc and R = ¯R + δR and write the dynamics of these perturbations to linear order. The linearized dynamics reads (A1) (A2) (A4) (A5) (A6) (A7) (A8) (A9) (A10) (A11) ∇δp = η±∆δv ∇ · δv = 0 ∂tδc = −δvr¯c(cid:48) + D±∇2δc − k±δc ∂tδR = δvr( ¯R) + −( ¯R)(cid:3) δR (cid:2)D+∂rδc+( ¯R) − D−∂rδc−( ¯R)(cid:3) . (cid:2)D+¯c(cid:48)(cid:48) +( ¯R) − D−¯c(cid:48)(cid:48) 1 ∆c + 1 ∆c Here δvr denotes the radial part of the hydrodynamic velocity. With δc− and δc+ we denote perturbations of the concentration field inside and outside the droplet. The same notation holds for the other fields. In this linear analysis, boundary conditions apply at the stationary radius ¯R, δc±( ¯R) = β±γδH − ¯c(cid:48) ±( ¯R)δR , The linearized dynamics can be decomposed in spherical harmonics, see Eq (11) in the main text. The curvature with perturbation of the curvature δH = H(R) − H( ¯R). perturbation then takes the form δH = with hl = (l2 + l − 2)/2. nlm (cid:88) hl ¯R nlmYlm , (A12) 3. Hydrodynamic eigenmodes of the linearized dynamics 7 We can expand the hydrodynamic eigenmodes using a basis of vector spherical harmonics, see Eq. (12) in the main text. The velocity boundary conditions Eq. (7) in the main text for the mode amplitudes read 0 = vr+ 0 = v(1)+ 0 = v(2)+ lm ( ¯R) − vr− lm ( ¯R) lm ( ¯R) − v(1)− lm ( ¯R) lm ( ¯R) − v(2)− lm ( ¯R) . The stress boundary conditions (see Eq. (5-6) in the main text) at the interface read lm( ¯R) − 2γlm hl ¯R 0 = 2η+(vr+ 0 = η+ (cid:34) (cid:35) lm )(cid:48)( ¯R) + p− lm ( ¯R) (cid:35) lm )(cid:48)( ¯R) − p+ lm )(cid:48)( ¯R) + (cid:34) (v(1)+ lm( ¯R) − 2η−(vr− − v(1)+ lm ( ¯R) vr+ ¯R ¯R − v(1)− vr− lm ( ¯R) lm ( ¯R) (cid:35) (cid:34) ¯R ¯R lm )(cid:48)( ¯R) − v(2)+ (v(2)+ ¯R (v(1)− lm )(cid:48)( ¯R) + lm ( ¯R) − η− −η− (cid:34) 0 = η+ lm )(cid:48)( ¯R) − v(2)− (v(2)− lm ( ¯R) ¯R (cid:35) . (A13) (A14) (A15) (A16) (A17) (A18) (A19) (A20) (A21) (A22) (A23) (A24) (A25) (A26) (A27) We solve the radial profiles of the modes with a polynomial ansatz and exclude functions that diverge for r → 0 or r → ∞ inside and outside the droplet, respectively. The pressure is then given by (cid:16) r (cid:17)l+1 (cid:17)−l (cid:16) r p− lm(r) = γfA lm(r) = −γfB p+ R R . For the hydrodynamic flow velocity we obtain (cid:20) (cid:16) r (cid:20) l + 3 fC1 R l(l + 1) (cid:17)l+1 − fC3 (cid:16) r (cid:17)l−1(cid:21) (cid:16) r (cid:17)l+1 − l + 1 fC1 R R l(l + 1) (cid:16) r (cid:17)l−1(cid:21) R fC3 γ η− γ η− vr− lm (r) = v(1)− lm (r) = v(2)− lm (r) = 0 and vr+ lm (r) = γ η− γ η− v(2)+ lm (r) = 0 . v(1)+ lm (r) = (cid:17)−l−2(cid:21) (cid:20) (cid:16) r (cid:20) l − 2 −fC2 R (cid:17)−l (cid:16) r fC2 l(l + 1) R (cid:16) r (cid:17)−l − 1 R + fC4 fC4 l + 1 (cid:16) r (cid:17)−l−2(cid:21) R Here, we have defined fA = fB = fC1 = fC2 = fC3 = fC4 = (l − 1) (l + 1) (l + 2) (2l + 3) ∆ (2l2 + 4l) + (2l2 + 4l + 3) l (l − 1) (l + 2) (2l − 1) (2l2 + 1) + (2l2 − 2) /∆ 1 2 1 2 ∆ (2l2 + 4l) + (2l2 + 4l + 3) l (l − 1) (l + 1) (l + 2) ∆ (2l2 + 1) + (2l2 − 2) l (l − 1) (l + 1) (l + 2) l (l − 1) (l + 1) (l + 2)(cid:0)∆(cid:0)2l2 + 4l + 3(cid:1) +(cid:0)2l2 + 4l(cid:1)(cid:1) l (l − 1) (l + 1) (l + 2)(cid:0)∆(cid:0)2l2 − 2(cid:1) +(cid:0)2l2 + 1(cid:1)(cid:1) (∆ (2l2 + 1) + (2l2 − 2)) (∆ (2l2 + 4l) + (2l2 + 4l + 3)) (∆ (2l2 + 1) + (2l2 − 2)) (∆ (2l2 + 4l) + (2l2 + 4l + 3)) 1 2 1 2 where ∆ = η+/η− denotes the ratio of the viscosities inside and outside the droplet. 4. Concentration eigenmodes The equation for the radial part of the concentration eigenmode is l (r)¯c(cid:48)(r) = vr 1 D± d dr r2 d dr − λ±2 nl − l(l + 1) r2 (cid:20) 1 r2 (cid:21) cnl(r) with The boundary conditions at ¯R are λ±2 nl = (k± + µnl)/D± . cnl( ¯R±) = γβ± − ¯R ¯c(cid:48)( ¯R±) . hl ¯R The left-hand side of Eq. (A34) constitutes an inhomogeneity l (r) = − 1 f± D± l (r)¯c(cid:48)(r) . vr , 8 (A28) (A29) (A30) (A31) (A32) (A33) (A34) (A35) (A36) (A37) The solution c± constructed from a particular solution c± homogeneous equation with f± as nl(r) of the inhomogeneous equation (A34) that satisfies the boundary condition Eq. (A36) can be nl,h(r) of the l = 0 are added to satisfy the boundary conditions, Eq. (A36). This can be expressed nl,p(r) of the inhomogeneous equation to which solutions c± c− nl(r) = α− c+ nl(r) = α+ nlc− nlc+ nl,h(r) + c− nl,h(r) + c+ nl,p(r) nl,p(r) , where the coefficients α± read α± nl = nl,p( ¯R) l − c± a± c± nl,h( ¯R) , (A38) (A39) (A40) nl( ¯R). l = c± with a± equation (A34) for λ±2 equation which is solved by modified spherical Bessel functions, c− We are especially interested in the case of unstable modes with µnl > 0. Therefore we focus on the solution of l = 0 is a modified Helmholtz nlr), where il nl > 0 and k± > 0. In this case, the homogeneous equation with f± nl,h(r) = il(λ− nl,h(r) = kl(λ+ nlr) and c+ and kl denote the modified spherical Bessel functions of first and second order, respectively. The particular solution of the inhomogeneous equation can be obtained by a Green's function approach, c− l,p(r) = λ− nlkl(λ− nlr) nlr2)f− l (r2)r2 2 +λ− nlil(λ− nlr) nlr2)f− l (r2)r2 c+ l,p(r) = λ+ nlkl(λ+ nlr) nlr2)f + l (r2)r2 2 +λ+ nlil(λ+ nlr) nlr2)f + l (r2)r2 2 0 (cid:90) r (cid:2)il(λ− (cid:90) ¯R (cid:2)kl(λ− (cid:90) r (cid:2)il(λ+ (cid:90) ∞ (cid:2)kl(λ+ ¯R r r (cid:3) dr2 (cid:3) dr2 (cid:3) dr2 (cid:3) dr2 , 2 9 (A41) (A42) (A43) (A44) (A45) (A46) with the radial part of the inhomogeneity f± l (r) given by Eq. (A37). The explicit calculation of these functions has to be handled with care, since the functions kl and il have divergences for large and small arguments r that cancel in the final result but can still lead to numerical difficulties when evaluated directly. The derivative of the concentration profile at ¯R can be expressed as − l c(cid:48) nl( ¯R−) = a c(cid:48) nl( ¯R+) = a+ ¯R gl,i(λ− ¯R gl,k(λ+ nl l ¯R) + nl ¯R) + c − l,p( ¯R) ¯R l,p( ¯R) c+ ¯R ·(cid:2)gl,k(λ− ·(cid:2)gl,i(λ+ nl nl ¯R) − gl,i(λ− ¯R) − gl,k(λ+ nl nl ¯R)(cid:3) ¯R)(cid:3) , with gl,i(x) = xi(cid:48) gl,k(x) = xk(cid:48) l(x) il(x) l(x) kl(x) . Using the equation for the shape perturbations (A10), and using Eqns (A43) and (A44), we obtain Eq. (13) in the main text. This equation determines the eigenvalue µnlm of the hydrodynamic modes. 5. Scaling relations in the limit of small reaction fluxes In the limit of small chemical reaction fluxes s± we obtain simple scaling expressions for stationary radii and their shape instability conditions. Here we present the method and discuss the results. a. Stationary radius Here we discuss the stationary radius in the limit of small chemical reaction amplitude A = ν−τ /∆c while keeping the ratios ν−/(k−∆c) and k+/k− of reaction parameters fixed. This corresponds to the curves ¯R() shown in Fig. 2A for different values of A. We can identify two regimes in the figure. The first is the region of small , ∼ 0, which corresponds to the minimum of ( ¯R). The second is the region of ∞ where the stationary radius diverges. For A → 0, we see that 0 goes to zero while ∞ stays constant, and both are connected by a straight line that indicates scaling behavior of ¯R = ¯Rs. This increasing separation between 0 and ∞ (and the corresponding stationary radii) in the limit of small A means that we can analyze the behavior of the stationary radius in these two regimes separately. For this we consider Equations (A.2) and (A.3) for the concentration field and (A.6) for the stationary radius. We can rewrite (A.6) to obtain an expression relating the supersaturation to the stationary radius, (cid:18) β−γ ∆c ¯R (cid:19) D− ν− + k−∆c D+ = β+γ ∆c ¯R + l− − 1 ¯R l− coth ¯R 1 + ¯R l+ . (A47) In this limit of small A, the characteristic length-scales of the concentration field become large with l± ∝ A−1/2. To find scaling regimes in equation ((A47)), we change variables in Eq. (A47) from (A, ¯R) to (A, R) with R = ¯RAa/w, where a is an exponent. For a = 1/3 we find the behavior of (R) close to 0 and ¯R0, = R−1 + 1 6 1 3 R2 + O(A1/6) (A48) where = A−1/3 becomes independent of A for small A. This function describes the supersaturation as a function of radius around the threshold value 0. Due to the inverted presentation ( ¯R) instead of ¯R() the function captures both the nucleation radius ¯Rc and the larger radius ¯Rs. The threshold value 0 can be obtained from Eq. (A48) by minimizing for fixed A as ∂/∂ R = 0. It behave as 10 (A49) For large and small R, Eq (A48) describes the steady radii ¯Rs and ¯Rc, respectively, for which ≥ 0. For large , the critical radius obeys . 0 = 4−2/3A1/3 + O(A1/2) while the larger stationary radius is ¯Rc (cid:39) w 6 , ¯Rs (cid:39) w(3A)1/2 . (A50) (A51) In Fig. 2B, the scaling behaviors given by Eq. (A51) and Eq. (A50) are indicated by dashed lines. At = 0 both radii meet at ¯R = ¯R0, where ¯R0 = w(4A)−1/3 + O(A−1/2) . For a = 1/2, ¯R/l± becomes independent of A and = D− D+ ν− k−∆c (cid:16) ¯R (cid:17) − 1 ¯R l− coth l− 1 + ¯R l+ + O(A1/2) (A52) (A53) For ¯R/l± (cid:28) 1, the stationary radius obeys Eq. (A51) and is thus the larger stationary radius ¯Rs. For ¯R/l± (cid:29) 1, we obtain the divergence of ¯Rs as approaches ∞ with (cid:115) ∞ = D−k− D+k+ ν− k−∆c . (A54) b. Shape instability We now discuss scaling relations for the onset of instability in the (A, ) plane in the limit of small A, which give the trends shown as dashed lines in Fig. 2D-F. We use the scaling of the stationary radius ¯R = ¯Rs close to 0 with R = ¯RA1/3/w, = A−1/3 and l± = l±A1/2 in Eq. (13) to obtain µnlm = − dl R A−2/3 F + 2 3 (l − 1) − D+ D− (l − 1)gl R3 + O(A1/6) (A55) where µnlm = µnlmτ /A and R is related to by (A48). Here, dl = fC3 − fC1, where fC1 and fC3 are defined in Eq. (A33) and gl = with hl = (l2 + l − 2)/2. For large mode index l, hl(l + 1) + D− D+ l − 1 β− β+ hll dl = l 2(η+/η− + 1) + O(1/l) . (A56) (A57) We now consider conditions for which µnlm = 0 for small A and the mode (n, l, m) becomes unstable. Using (A48) in (A55), we find a relation between and R at the onset of instability µnlm = 0, (cid:18) 1 6 (cid:19) = dl 2(l − 1) 1 F R + + D+ D− 1 2 gl R−1 + O(A1/6) . (A58) 11 This curve captures the scaling behavior of the onset of instability for different parameters in the ¯R − plane, corresponding to the red dotted line in Fig. 2A-C. We now focus on finding the scaling relations for the onset of stability of the stationary radius as function of A, and F , as shown in Fig. 2D-F. At this onset, both (A58) and (A48) need to be satisfied. We use both equations to eliminate R. We find a crossover regime with relations A∗ ∼ F −3/2 between the region where hydrodynamic flows are relevant (A < A∗) and where they can be neglected (A > A∗). For A > A∗ we find for µnlm = 0 as relation between A and (cid:1)3 3 . A (cid:39) 54 gl 2 gl (cid:0)1 + 1 (cid:19)2 (cid:18) 2(l − 1) (A59) (A60) For A < A∗ we find A (cid:39) 1 3 −1F −2 . dl In Fig. 2D-F, the dashed lines indicate these two scaling solutions in the limit A → 0 and F → ∞ for l = 2, which we find to be the first mode to become unstable. We find that the general trends of the stability diagram is captured well, with small deviations from the full solution of Eq. (13) for small , and larger deviations in the regime close to ∞ where the scaling of the stationary radius ¯Rs ∝ A−1/3 breaks down. Appendix B: Continuum model for active droplets with flows 1. Continuum model for active droplets 12 We study an extended Cahn-Hilliard equation with chemical reactions coupled to Stokes equation for hydrodynamic flows at low Reynolds numbers. We consider an incompressible fluid containing two components A and B, with number concentration fields cA(r, t) and c = cB(r, t) that depend on position r and time t, and with molecular masses mA and mB and molecular volumes vA and vB. We are interested in the case where component A forms the background fluid and B is a droplet material that forms droplets by phase separation. Additionally, chemical reactions convert the two components into each other, A (cid:10) B. For simplicity, we consider mass and volume conserving chemical reactions with mA/vA = mB/vB, which encodes that volume is conserved in the reaction if mass is conserved. Together with incompressibility, this implies that the mass density ρ = mAcA + mBcB is constant. Therefore, we can describe the system by the concentration c(r, t) of the droplet material B only. We use the following double-well free energy density46 c − c(0)− f (c) = b (cid:16) (cid:17)2(cid:16) (cid:17)2 c − c(0) (cid:0)∇c(cid:1)2 κ 2 with ∆c =(cid:12)(cid:12)c(0)− − c(0) + (cid:12)(cid:12). Here, the positive parameter b characterizes molecular interactions and entropic contributions. 2(∆c)2 (B1) + + , This free energy describes the segregation of the fluid in two coexisting phases49: one phase rich in droplet material with c ≈ c(0)− and a dilute phase with c ≈ c(0) + . The coefficient κ is related to surface tension and the interface width46. The state of the system is characterized by the free energy (cid:90) F [c] = d3r f (c) , (B2) where the integral is over the system volume. We work with an ensemble T , ρ, c here, where T denotes temperature and the system is considered isothermal. The chemical potential ¯µ = δF [c]/δc, governs demixing and can be split into local and nonlocal contributions, ¯µ = ¯µ0 − κ∇2c with (cid:0)c − c(0) + (cid:1)(cid:0)c − c(0)− (cid:1)(cid:0)2c − c(0)− − c(0) + (cid:1) . ¯µ0 = b (∆c)2 (B3) (B4) (B5) The dynamics of the concentration field is described by50,51 ∂tc = −∇ · j + s(c) j = −M∇¯µ + vc . Here, M is a mobility coefficient of the droplet material and v is the hydrodynamic velocity. The source term s(c) describes chemical reactions, for which we choose for simplicity a linear concentration dependence, s(c) = ν − k(c − c(0) + ) . (B6) The reaction flux given in Eq. (B6) does not obey detailed balance with respect to the free energy, and thus describes a situation where an external energy source maintains the system away from equilibrium39. The hydrodynamic velocity v can be calculated using momentum conservation, with momentum ρvα and stress tensor σαβ, where α and β number cartesian coordinates x, y, z. We can write the stress tensor σαβ as ∂t(ρvα) = ∂βσαβ , (B7) σαβ = −(ρvα)vβ + σeq αβ + σd αβ , (B8) where the first term describes advection of the stress tensor, σeq tensors. The equilibrium stress tensor is given by αβ and σd αβ denote the equilibrium and dissipative stress αβ = −(¯µc − f )δαβ − ∂f σeq ∂(∂αc) ∂βc − P0δαβ . (B9) 13 Here, ¯µc − f is the osmotic pressure of the droplet material, and δαβ denotes the Kronecker delta. Incompressibility is enforced by an additional partial pressure P0. The deviatory stress tensor can be found as thermodynamic force related to momentum by writing the entropy production rate, (cid:18) (cid:19) σd αβ = 2η vαβ − 1 3 vγγδαβ + η(cid:48)vγγδαβ , (B10) where η and η(cid:48) denote viscosities, and vαβ = (∂αvβ + ∂βvα)/2 is the symmetric strain tensor. In the Stokes limit, the inertial terms are neglected, Dt(ρvα) = 0, with advected derivative Dt = ∂t + vβ∂β, leaving 0 = ∂β(σeq αβ + σd αβ). This yields52 βvα = 3¯µ0∂αc − κc∇2(∂αc) + ∂αP0 . η∂2 (B11) Eqs. (B3) -- (B6) and Eqs. (B11) and incompressibility ∂αvα = 0 define the continuum model of active droplets. 2. Numerical solution of the continuum model We numerically solve the dynamic equations of the continuum model of active droplets, Eqs. (B3) -- (B6) and Eqs. (B11) with Eq. (B13) and incompressibility ∂αvα = 0. For this we use a spectral method in a 3d rectangular box. This has the advantage that in a spectral decomposition, the spatial operators become simple multiplications with the wavenumber47. However, our equations contain a number of nonlinear functions, which are easier to evaluate in real space. We therefore transform forward and back in each time step. To calculate the next timestep ti from the fields found in timestep ti−1, we use a semi-implicit Runge-Kutta method53 (method (2,3,3)) for the concentration field. This evaluates the gradient term in ¯µ, Eq. (B3), implicitly, while evaluating the rest of ¯µ as well as the advection term of the fluxes, vc, explicitly. This effectively means that the terms related to the interfacial profile are calculated implicitly, which allows for larger time steps as an explicit scheme. For the concentration field, we choose no-flux boundary conditions (∂nc = 0, where the derivative is in a direction normal to the simulation box), which leads to a decomposition in cosine functions in the spectral description. The Laplacian then is −k2 for a mode with wave vector k. The Stokes equation can also be solved using spectral methods. Here, no-flux conditions lead to vn = 0. Additionally we enforce incompressibility using a reprojection method. For this, the velocity field calculated by neglecting the partial pressure, Pp = 0, can be split into two parts (Helmholtz decomposition), v = vψ + vφ = ∇ × ψ − ∇φ with vector field ψ and scalar field φ, and velocity parts vψ = ∇ × ψ and vφ = −∇φ. With this, we find (B13) and thus, using incompressibility, ∇ · v = 0, we can calculate φ. We thus find the incompressible part of the velocity field ∇ · v = ∆φ vψ = v − ∇φ . (B12) (B14) We can evaluate this in Fourier space using a spectral method. For a rectangular box aligned with the coordinate system, we thus find that each velocity component vα is decomposed by sines in one direction and cosines in the other direction. Spatial derivatives convert a sine-description into cosines, and vice versa. We normalize concentration, length, time and energy by ∆c = c(0)− − c(0) + , w = 2(κ/b)1/2, t0 = w2/D and e0 = κ w(∆c)2/3, respectively, where the characteristic length scale is w = 2(κ/b)1/2. The relevant dimensionless model + /∆c = 0, kt0 = 10−2, νt0 = 2 · 10−3 and η w3/(t0e0) = 2. parameters are c(0) Additionally, we use as box-length L/ w = 100 in all 3 dimensions, number of grid-points in one direction N = 128 and simulation time T /t0 = 4 · 103. For the time step, we start with a timestep of ∆t/t0 = 10−4, and double the timestep to a final step size of ∆t/t0 = 0.01. + /∆c, kt0, and ν−t0/∆c. We choose c(0) We start with initial conditions R = R0(1 + Y2,0), with R0/ w = 7 and = 1. The concentration field at positions r is initialized by the function c(r) = c(0) + + c(0)− 2 + − c(0)− c(0) 2 + tanh d(r) w . (B15) where d(r) is the oriented distance of r to the nearest point on the ellipsoid. The value of d(r) is negative for points inside the droplet and positive for points outside. 3. Effective droplet model as a limit of the continuum model We now discuss the relationship between the effective droplet model and the continuum model. To relate the two models, we first use the continuum model to derive jump conditions for the concentration in the effective droplet model in equilibrium. We then consider stress balance across this interface and derive stress boundary conditions in the effective droplet model. Finally we discuss the dynamical equations in the bulk and at the interface in non-equilibrium situations. 14 a. Derivation of jump conditions for equilibrium phase separation First we consider the phase separation in equilibrium without chemical reactions in the continuum model. In a one-dimensional system with a mean concentration ¯c with c(0) + < ¯c < c(0)− , the free energy of the system in Eq. (B2) is minimized by the concentration profile c∗(x) = c(0)− + c(0) + 2 c(0)− − c(0) + 2 + tanh x w , (B16) where w = 2(κ/b)1/2 denotes the interfacial width and x is the normal distance to the interface. The concentration profile describes two phases of concentration c(0)− and c(0) + separated by a flat interface of width w. The surface tension can be defined as For the free energy Eq. (B2) with the concentration profile Eq. (B16), this can be written as γ = (cid:82) ∞ (F [c(0)− ] + F [c(0) + ])dx . γ = F [c∗(x)] − 1 2 (B17) −∞ κ(∇c∗)2dx which yields γ = (∆c)2/6 κb or54. √ (cid:90) ∞ −∞ This interfacial tension governs the concentration jump condition in the effective droplet model, which can be derived as follows. To describe a curved interface, we consider two homogeneous phases with concentrations c±. For a finite volume Vs with a droplet of size V and area A the concentrations c± can be found by minimizing the free energy F = f (c−)V + f (c+)(Vs − V ) + γA with ∂F/∂c−V = 0 and ∂F/∂V c− = 0, where the concentration of both phases are related by Vs¯c = V c− + (Vs − V )c+ where ¯c denotes the average concentration in the system. Thus for two phases to be in equilibrium, their chemical potential ¯µ and osmotic pressure Π = c¯µ − f need to obey 0 = ¯µ(c−) − ¯µ(c+) 0 = Π(c+) − Π(c−) − 2γH , (B18) (B19) where H the mean curvature of the droplet and 2γH is the Laplace pressure. These equations determine the concen- trations in the phases c± of coexisting phases54. For small Laplace pressures, we can express the equilibrium concentrations c± of a curved interface by the concen- trations of a flat interface c(0)± plus a small perturbation, (B21) where β± = 2/(f(cid:48)(cid:48)(c(0)± )∆c). For the free energy Eq. (B2), we find β± = 2/(b∆c), which is related to the interfacial width as w = 6γβ+/∆c. c− = c(0)− + β−γH c+ = c(0) + + β+γH (B20) b. Stress balance across the interface We now consider stress balance of the continuum model across the droplet interface to derive stress jump conditions at the interface in the effective droplet model. We discuss the mechanical equilibrium in a small volume across a curved interface with a local mean curvature H corresponding to a (local) effective radius R = 1/H. We focus on the case where the interface is rotationally symmetric around the considered point R, and where the curvature does not change along the interface. We use spherical coordinates, where the radial vector er is aligned with the (outward pointing ) normal vector n and the tangential vectors t and s are aligned with eθ and eφ, respectively (with the vector directions 15 FIG. 4. Geometry for the force balance. We consider a spherical cap of the droplet interface, with a box with constant distance δ to the interface inside and outside. The normal and tangential vectors n, t and s of the interface are shown, as well as the normal vector n of the box. The origin of the spherical coordinate system is the center of the sphere that describes the interfacial curvature, with radius R, while θ0 gives the polar angle of the cap. for φ = 0 in the limit θ = 0). We consider a small box enclosing R where the outer and inner surfaces Aout and Ain have a constant distance of δ to the interface, and the lateral surface Alat is at a constant angle θ0 with respect to the symmetry axis. The geometry is shown in Fig. 4. Now let us consider the balance of the stress tensor Eq. (B7) across the box, taking into account the curved geometry. The stress balance ∂βσαβ can be written as 0 = dA nβσαβ (B22) (cid:73) (cid:90) (cid:90) (cid:90) where α and β are cartesian coordinates and n the (local, outward pointing) normal vector of the box-surface. We can split this in three terms, 0 = dAoutσαn − dAinσαn + dAlatσαt , (B23) where we used that the orientation of the normal vectors of the box coincides with the normal/tangential vector of the interface. On the inner and outer areas Ain and Aout, the stress tensor presented in Eq. (B8) with equilibrium stress tensor in Eq. (B9) reduces to the form of the effective droplet model given after Eq. (6) in the main text, as the gradient terms are negligible for δ (cid:29) w. We now consider the limit of a sharp interface w → 0 with finite surface tension γ, and consider the case of a small box of thickness δ, which remains larger than the interfacial width. The components α = x, y of Eq. (B23) vanish by symmetry. For α = z we find where σ± Integration over the lateral box surface Alat yields the last term,(cid:82) dAlatσαt nn are the stress tensor components of the effective model, Eq. (4), inside and outside the interface at R. ∼= 2π R sin2 θ0 γ. We thus find that the 0 = π R2 sin2 θ0 σ+ nn − π R2 sin2 θ0 σ− nn − 2π R sin2 θ0 γ , (B24) mechanical equilibrium of a curved interface introduces a Laplace pressure 2γH, 0 = σ+ nn − σ− nn − 2γH . (B25) We therefore recover the stress jump conditions of the effective droplet model, Eq. (6). Additionally, (B25) together with (B19) implies that the partial pressure needed to satisfy incompressibility is continuous across the interface, 0 = P − P + 0 . c. Dynamics of the effective droplet model 16 We now consider the dynamics of a non-equilibrium system with a droplet. We show how the continuum model is related to the bulk equations and jump conditions of the effective droplet model. For this we consider a droplet with a interface that is thin compared to the dynamical length scales l±, so that we can describe the interface by local equilibrium. In the bulk phases we focus on the case where deviations from the equilibrium concentrations are small. In the bulk phases, we expand the chemical potential Eq. (B3) around the reference concentrations c(0)± . The gradient term −κ∇2c in the chemical potential is important within the interface, but can be ignored in the bulk phases, where the length-scales on which the concentration field varies are much larger than the interfacial width. Thus we can describe the chemical potential by ¯µ±(c) ≈ d¯µ0 dc (c − c(0)± ) , (B26) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)c(0)± which is ¯µ±(c) ≈ b(c − c(0)± ) for our specific free energy. With this simplification, Eqns. (B4) and (B5) become the reaction-diffusion-convection equations (1) and (2) with diffusion constants D± = M (d¯µ0/dc)c(0)± or D± = M b. Similarly we linearize the chemical reaction rate Eq. (B6) in both phases. As we already chose a linear rate for the continuum model, we only need to relate the parameters k and ν with the constants k± and ν± of the effective model, with k± = k, ν+ = ν and ν− = k∆c − ν. Inserting the linearized chemical potential Eq. (B26) into the equilibrium stress tensor (B9) we find that momentum conservation in the bulk phases is given by the Stokes equation (4) with viscosities η± = η, where the pressure p is determined by the incompressibility condition ∂αvα = 0. We consider the droplet interface to be in local equilibrium. We therefore obtain Eq. (8) for the jump of the concentration field in the effective model. The incompressibility condition ∂αvα = 0 implies v− n (R) at a sharp interface, and we consider an interface without slip length, so that v−(R) = v+(R). We thus find Eq. (7) of the effective model. The normal stress balance in Eq. (6) is derived in B 3 b. n (R) = v+ As a last point we need to find Eq. (10) for the interface movement. We consider the concentration change in a box of width δ around the interface, see Fig. 4. We consider a box enclosing a point R on the interface at the time t aligned with the normal and tangential directions of the interface at R. The interface may move with normal movement ∂t R(t), with R(t) = R(t)· n and normal vector n, while the box stays at a fixed position. The total change of material in the volume is given by (cid:90) (cid:90) dV c = − dA n · j + ∂t V A V (cid:90) dV s(c) (B27) where V denotes the volume and A the area of the box. For small w and finite δ the concentration field c makes a jump from the surface Ain to Aout given by conditions (8) and (9) at R. Within each phase, we can express the field by the boundary values at the interface Eq. (B21) and a linear expansion, c(r, t) (cid:39) c−(R(t)) + ∇c−(r, t) · (r − R(t)) c+(R(t)) + ∇c+(r, t) · (r − R(t)) inside droplet outside droplet (B28) The chemical reaction is given in both phases by Eq. (B6). For small δ and θ0, we find for the left-hand side of Eq. (B27) that δc vanishes to lowest order and dV c = AR(c−(R(t)) − c+(R(t)))∂t R + O() + O(θ0) (B29) for a small box,(cid:82) where AR is the area of the droplet interface enclosed by the box. For a spherical cap, AR = 2π(1 − cos θ0) R2. We further find that the source term due to the chemical reaction scales with the volume of the box, and thus vanishes V dV s(c) = 0 + O() + O(θ0). The flux across the box can be expressed as − dA n · j = ARn · (j−(R(t)) − j+(R(t))) + O() + O(θ0) (B30) where j±(R(t)) denotes the flux at R inside/outside the droplet. We thus find the normal movement of the interface, ∂t R = n · j−(R(t)) − j+(R(t)) c−(R(t)) − c+(R(t)) . (B31) (cid:40) (cid:90) ∂t V (cid:90) A 17 In the main text we use spherical coordinates centered at the droplet center. For a spherical droplet, the normal and radial movement would thus be the same. For a deformed droplet, we need to consider the relation between the normal interface movement, R(t) = R(t) · n and the radial movement R(t) = R(t) · er. At fixed angles θ and φ, the interface movement is given by ∂tR = ∂tR er. Using ∂t R = ∂tR(t) · n, we find a relation between the radial and normal movement, ∂tR = ∂t R/(n · er). This relation, together with Eq. (B31), yields the interfacial movement Eq. (10) presented in the main text. We thus recover all dynamical equations of the effective droplet model from the continuum model based on irre- versible thermodynamics. Note that the specific choice of the free energy leads to specific relations between parameters of the effective model such as D+ = D−. Our derivation shows the relation between both models in the case where the interface width w is small compared to the droplet size, R/w (cid:29) 1, and the chemical diffusion length, l±/w (cid:29) 1. Additionally, we focused on the case where the concentrations in the phases are similar to the concentrations in equi- librium and have small concentration gradients. These conditions are not valid in all systems. Most importantly, the chemical reactions can drive concentrations far away from the equilibrium phase concentrations c(0)± . The resulting behaviors, such as the formation of new interfaces associated with instabilities of the spinodal decomposition regime, are not captured in the effective droplet model. 18 FIG. 5. Growth of shape perturbations of the l = 2 mode for different normalized viscosities F = ηw/(γτ ) for the continuous model (red crosses) and effective model (blue curve). The last data point (with arrow) corresponds to F → ∞. (Parameters: A = 8 · 10−3, = 0.2, η−/η+ = 1, c(0) + /∆c = 0, k+/k− = 1, ν−/(k−∆c) = 0.8) 4. Comparison of the droplet dynamics in the continuum model and the effective model Here we compare the analytical predictions of the effective model for the instability with numerical calculations of the continuous model for different values of the renormalized viscosity F . For this we numerically solved the dynamic equations of the continuous model starting with a droplet with a small initial deformation of mode l = 2. We fitted the dynamical behavior of the mode to an exponential function, with yields a numerical estimate for the eigenvalue µ2. In figure 5 the resulting eigenvalues are shown, together with the eigenvalue of corresponding parameters of the effective model. We find that the value of F for which droplet shapes become unstable is very similar to the value predicted by the effective model. The eigenvalues are qualitatively similar to the ones of the effective model, despite working in an a parameter regime where the interfacial width and the differences of concentration within a phase cannot be considered very small, so that the models are not necessarily comparable. To generate the data in the figure, we initialized droplets with a small shape perturbation for different values of F . All parameters and initial conditions were chosen as described in B 2. We found that for F ≥ 100 droplets divide, while they are stable for F ≤ 1. For F = 10, the shape deformation was very slow, so that division was not seen in the time interval T /τ = 4000. For 10 < F < 100, as well as F = ∞, we fitted radius and spherical harmonic deformation to the concentration field using Eq. (B15). For short times, the droplet radius changes as the concentration field and droplet size go towards the stationary values. After that, the shape deformation grows until the droplet deforms so strongly that the fitting fails. By hand we chose intermediate time windows for the simulations where the size was stationary and the shape deformation small. In these windows we fitted the deformation amplitude (compare Eq. (B15)) with an exponential function, Aeµ2t + B with parameters A, B and eigenvalue µ2 to the l = 2 mode of the shape deformation. Dimensionless viscosityDimensionless eigenvalueAppendix C: Estimation of parameters 19 Here we estimate the hydrodynamic parameter for two physical phase-separating systems to understand the impor- tance of hydrodynamic flows on the droplet division in experimental systems. We discuss two cases, water-oil phase separation, and soft colloidal systems (such as protein-RNA phase-separation in cells). We have already estimated pa- rameter values for both systems without the influence of hydrodynamic flows39, where we found that droplet division should be possible for realistic values of chemical reaction rates in both systems, and that corresponding stationary radii would have sizes of a few micrometers. Here we estimate the value of the dimensionless viscosity F for water-oil and soft colloidal systems, and compare them to the analytical phase diagrams presented in Fig. 2. To calculate the hydrodynamic parameter F for experimental systems, we need an estimation of the diffusion coefficient of the droplet material D+ outside the droplet, of the interfacial width w (which corresponds to length- scale w in the paper39), of the surface tension γ and of the viscosity η− inside the droplet. For water-oil systems, the interfacial width is of the order of w ≈ 1nm and the diffusion constant is D+ ≈ 10−9m2/s. We can estimate the surface tension as γ ≈ 10−2N/m, and the viscosity η− ≈ 10−3(N · s)/m254,55. With these values, we find F ≈ 0.1. In this case droplet division is strongly suppressed, see Fig. 2 of the main text. For soft colloidal systems, we estimate w ≈ 10nm, D+ ≈ 10−10m2/s and γ ≈ 10−6N/m1,54. The value of F depends on the viscosity of the droplet. For values η− ≈ 10−3(N · s)/m2, F ≈ 10, and for η− ≈ 1− 10(N · s)/m2, we have F ≈ 104. In both cases droplet division is possible, but more easy to achieve for larger F . We convert A∗ to the reaction rate ν− inside the droplet using the droplet concentration given in39. We can use Eq. (A59) and (A60) from the scaling analysis to estimate the instability of the concrete parameter examples discussed in39 under the influence of hydrodynamic flows. In these scaling equations, the ratios η+/η− and D−β−/(D+β+) enter the calculation of A∗ and ∗ but we find that they do not lead to relevant changes in the results. The scaling analysis thus yields results very similar to the estimation using Fig. 2. 20 1 C. P. Brangwynne, C. R. Eckmann, D. S. Courson, A. Rybarska, C. Hoege, J. Gharakhani, F. Julicher, and A. A. Hyman, Science 324, 1729 (2009). 2 C. P. Brangwynne, Soft Matter 7, 3052 (2011). 3 A. A. Hyman and K. Simons, Science 337, 1047 (2012). 4 P. Li, S. Banjade, H.-C. Cheng, S. Kim, B. Chen, L. Guo, M. Llaguno, J. V. Hollingsworth, D. S. King, S. F. Banani, P. S. Russo, Q.-X. Jiang, B. T. Nixon, and M. K. Rosen, Nature 483, 336 (2012). 5 S. C. C. Weber and C. P. P. Brangwynne, Cell 149, 1188 (2012). 6 C. P. Brangwynne, J. Cell Biol. 203, 875 (2013). 7 J. a. Toretsky and P. E. Wright, The Journal of Cell Biology 206, 579 (2014). 8 D. Zwicker, M. Decker, S. Jaensch, A. A. Hyman, and F. Julicher, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 111, E2636 (2014). 9 S. Elbaum-Garfinkle, Y. Kim, K. Szczepaniak, C. C.-H. Chen, C. R. Eckmann, S. Myong, and C. P. Brangwynne, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 112, 201504822 (2015). 10 A. Molliex, J. Temirov, J. Lee, M. Coughlin, A. P. Kanagaraj, H. J. Kim, T. Mittag, and J. P. Taylor, Cell 163, 123 (2015). 11 A. Patel, H. O. Lee, L. Jawerth, S. Maharana, M. Jahnel, M. Y. Hein, S. Stoynov, J. Mahamid, S. Saha, T. M. Franzmann, A. Pozniakovski, I. Poser, N. Maghelli, L. A. Royer, M. Weigert, E. W. Myers, S. Grill, D. Drechsel, A. A. Hyman, and S. Alberti, Cell 162, 1066 (2015). 12 M. Feric, N. Vaidya, T. S. Harmon, D. M. Mitrea, L. Zhu, T. M. Richardson, R. W. Kriwacki, R. V. Pappu, and C. P. Brangwynne, Cell 165, 1686 (2016). 13 S. Saha, C. A. Weber, M. Nousch, O. Adame-Arana, C. Hoege, M. Y. Hein, E. Osborne-Nishimura, J. Mahamid, M. Jahnel, L. Jawerth, A. Pozniakovski, C. R. Eckmann, F. Ju, and A. A. Hyman, Cell 166, 1 (2016). 14 S. F. Banani, H. O. Lee, A. A. Hyman, and M. K. Rosen, Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology 18, 285 (2017). 15 E. Sokolova, E. Spruijt, M. M. K. Hansen, E. Dubuc, J. Groen, V. Chokkalingam, A. Piruska, H. A. Heus, and W. T. S. Huck, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 110, 11692 (2013). 16 Y. Lin, D. S. W. Protter, M. K. Rosen, and R. Parker, Molecular Cell 60, 1 (2015). 17 W. M. Aumiller and C. D. Keating, Nature Chemistry 8, 129 (2015). 18 E. A. Frankel, P. C. Bevilacqua, and C. D. Keating, Langmuir 32, 2041 (2016). 19 K. K. Nakashima, J. F. Baaij, and E. Spruijt, Soft Matter 14, 361 (2018). 20 S. C. Glotzer, D. Stauffer, and N. Jan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 4109 (1994). 21 S. Puri and H. Frisch, J. Phys. A 27, 6027 (1994). 22 J. J. Christensen, K. Elder, and H. C. Fogedby, Phys. Rev. E 54, R2212 (1996). 23 D. Carati and R. Lefever, Phys. Rev. E 56, 3127 (1997). 24 A. Z. Patashinski, R. Orlik, K. Paclawski, M. A. Ratner, and B. A. Grzybowski, Soft Matter 8, 1601 (2012). 25 L. Giomi and A. DeSimone, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 147802 (2014). 26 D. Zwicker, A. A. Hyman, and F. Julicher, Phys. Rev. E 92, 012317 (2015). 27 J. Crosby, T. Treadwell, M. Hammerton, K. Vasilakis, M. P. Crump, D. S. Williams, and S. Mann, Chemical Communications 48, 11832 (2012). 28 T.-Y. Dora. Tang, D. van Swaay, A. DeMello, J. L. Ross Anderson, and S. Mann, Chem. Commun. 51, 11429 (2015). 29 A. I. Oparin, Izd.Moskovhii RabochiI (1924). 30 A. I. Oparin, Origin of Life (Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh, 1957). 31 S. W. Fox, Orig. Life 7, 49 (1976). 32 M. M. Hanczyc and J. W. Szostak, Curr. Opin. Chem. Biol. 8, 660 (2004). 33 K. P. Browne, D. A. Walker, K. J. M. Bishop, and B. A. Grzybowski, Angew. Chem. 49, 6756 (2010). 34 S. Koga, D. S. Williams, A. W. Perriman, and S. Mann, Nature Chemistry 3, 720 (2011). 35 G. Murtas, Mol. BioSyst. 9, 195 (2013). 36 A. A. Hyman, C. A. Weber, and F. Julicher, Annual Review of Cell and Developmental Biology 30, 39 (2014). 37 M. Li, X. Huang, T. Y. D. Tang, and S. Mann, Current Opinion in Chemical Biology 22, 1 (2014). 38 T.-Y. Dora Tang, C. Rohaida Che Hak, A. J. Thompson, M. K. Kuimova, D. S. Williams, A. W. Perriman, and S. Mann, Nature Chemistry 6, 527 (2014). 39 D. Zwicker, R. Seyboldt, C. A. Weber, A. A. Hyman, and F. Julicher, Nature Physics 13, 408 (2017). 40 S. Lach, S. M. Yoon, and B. A. Grzybowski, Chem. Soc. Rev. 65, 1392 (2016). 41 L. Rayleigh, The London, Edinburgh, and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science 34, 145 (1892). 42 S. Chandrasekhar, Hydrodynamic and hydromagnetic stability (Dover Publications, Inc., New York, 1981). 43 P. Constantin, T. F. Dupont, R. E. Goldstein, L. P. Kadanoff, M. J. Shelley, and S. M. Zhou, Physical Review E 47, 4169 (1993). 44 J. D. Paulsen, R. Carmigniani, A. Kannan, J. C. Burton, and S. R. Nagel, Nature Communications 5, 3182 (2014). 45 R. G. Barrera, G. a. Estevez, and J. Giraldo, European Journal of Physics 6, 287 (1985). 46 J. W. Cahn and J. E. Hilliard, The Journal of Chemical Physics 28, 258 (1958). 47 L. Q. Chen and J. Shen, Computer Physics Communications 108, 147 (1998). 48 J. Stenesh, Biochemistry (Springer US, 2013). 49 R. C. Desai and R. Kapral, Dynamics of Self-organized and Self-assembled Structures (Cambridge University Press, 2009). 50 S. R. De Groot and P. Mazur, Non-equilibrium thermodynamics (Dover Publications, Inc., New York, 2011). 51 J. Prost, F. Julicher, and J.-F. Joanny, Nature Physics 11, 131 (2015). 52 M. E. Cates, Soft Interfaces: Lecture Notes of the Les Houches Summer School: Volume 98, July 2012 98, 317 (2017). 53 U. Ascher, S. Ruuth, and R. Spiteri, Applied Numerical Mathematics 25, 151 (1997). 54 S. A. Safran, Statistical thermodynamics of surfaces, interfaces, and membranes, Frontiers in Physics, Vol. 90 (Addison- Wesley, Reading, 1994). 55 W. M. Haynes, CRC handbook of chemistry and physics (CRC press, 2014). 21
1801.02464	2	1801	2018-04-16T12:06:26	Fluid flows shaping organism morphology	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.TO" ]	A dynamic self-organized morphology is the hallmark of network-shaped organisms like slime moulds and fungi. Organisms continuously re-organize their flexible, undifferentiated body plans to forage for food. Among these organisms the slime mould Physarum polycephalum has emerged as a model to investigate how organism can self-organize their extensive networks and act as a coordinated whole. Cytoplasmic fluid flows flowing through the tubular networks have been identified as key driver of morphological dynamics. Inquiring how fluid flows can shape living matter from small to large scales opens up many new avenues for research.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Fluid flows shaping organism morphology 1Max Planck Institute for Dynamics and Self-Organization, Am Fassberg 17, D-37077 Gottingen, Germany∗ Karen Alim1 A dynamic self-organized morphology is the hallmark of network-shaped organisms like slime moulds and fungi. Organisms continuously re-organize their flexible, undifferentiated body plans to forage for food. Among these organisms the slime mould P. polycephalum has emerged as a model to investigate how organism can self-organize their extensive networks and act as a coordinated whole. Cytoplasmic fluid flows flowing through the tubular networks have been identified as key driver of morphological dynamics. Inquiring how fluid flows can shape living matter from small to large scales opens up many new avenues for research. Many organisms, including a broad range of species of slime moulds and fungi, grow and forage as a single large network. Networks change their morphology over and over again during growth and migration to locate food in a patchy environment [1, 2], see also Fig. 1. More- over, network morphology adapts in response to newly acquired food sources, even connecting food sources in an efficient and robust manner [3]. The striking similar- ity of the morphological dynamics in foraging fungi and slime moulds is even more surprising if one takes into account that slime moulds and fungi are genetically dis- tinct, with slime moulds being genetically even closer to animals than fungi. It is therefore likely that not bio- logical make-up but the physics of fluid flows within the tubular networks are critical to the self-organization of network morphology across an individual. Both kinds of living, adaptive networks exhibit oscillatory, long-ranged fluid flows [4–6]. Here, the syncytial plasmodia of the slime mould Physarum polycephalum emerged as a model system to understand the role of flows in coordinating morphology. Fluid flows in this organism are highly co- ordinated, driving intracellular transport on short time scales but also migration and likely morphological self- organization at long time scales. CYTOPLASMIC FLOWS ORGANIZED IN PERISTALTIC WAVE In P. polycephalum the fluid cytoplasm within the tubular network streams forth and back in a shuttle flow [6, 7]. Network sizes are macroscopic ranging from about 500 µm to 0.5 m - experiments are typically conducted on specimen of up to few cm in size. Flows generally exhibit a Poiseuille profile [6, 8] with deviations likely in smaller tubes [9]. Flow is dominated by small Reynolds num- ber Re = 2U R/ν ≈ 0.002 and small Womersley num- ber α = R(cid:112)ω/ν ≈ 0.004, based on a representative tube radius of R = 50 µm, a flow velocity reaching up to U = 1 mm/s [6], a kinematic viscosity of cytoplasm ν = 6.4 × 10−6 m2/s [10] and an oscillation frequency of ω = 0.05 Hz. The cytoplasm is enclosed by gel-like walls that are lined with an actin cortex [11, 12]. Actin orga- nizes in circumferential fibrils that contract periodically [13] and drive the cytoplasms' shuttle flow. Contrary to long-lasting speculations about localized pumps driv- ing pressure difference, the common understanding now is that flows arise through network-wide, self-organized contractions of the actin cortex [14, 22]. The shuttelling cytoplasm itself is very rich in actin. In 1 mm sized cytoplasm extract droplets, so called proto-plasmic droplets, the actin cortex and the con- tractions self-organize over time, showing first irregular contraction patterns and later highly coordinated spatio- temporal patterns including standing, travelling and spi- ral waves [15–18]. Similar dynamics and patterns can be reproduced in models by describing the proto-plasmic droplets by two phases of a viscoelastic solid phase rep- resenting the cytoskeleton, interpenetrated by a second fluid phase representing the cytosol and coupling both phases by a soluble molecule that activates tension in the solid phase [19, 20]. Even on the much larger scale of an entire tubular network contractions are also highly coordinated, forming a peristaltic wave spanning speci- men of at least 2 cm in size [21, 22], see Fig. 1. While the contraction period only increases moderately with net- work size [24, 25], the wavelength of the peristaltic wave matches organism size spanning two orders of magnitude [22]. It is fascinating to investigate how this scaling can arise. Given the success of mechanochemical models for proto-plasmic droplets it is likely that also the organism spanning peristaltic wave is a result of mechanochemical patterning, which could nicely complement our emerg- ing understanding of this novel patterning mechanism widespread in biological systems [26, 27]. From a fluid mechanics point a view a peristaltic wave matching or- ganism size induces the highest flow velocities through- out a network. As flows change with organism morphol- ogy, they are likely not only important for organism ho- moeostasis but also for the coordination of morphological adaptation itself. EFFECTIVE INTRACELLULAR TRANSPORT BY OSCILLATORY FLOW Peristalsis is a common mechanism in biological sys- tems, creating oscillatory flow and pumping fluid along 8 1 0 2 r p A 6 1 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 2 v 4 6 4 2 0 . 1 0 8 1 : v i X r a 2 FIG. 1. Network morphology and peristaltic wave driving long-ranged cytoplasmic flows in the plasmodial slime mould P. polycephalum (a) Self-organization of the network morphology over the course of 12.5 h. An initially well-reticulated network migrates to the left thereby retracting connections and altering tube radius hierarchy. Scale bar, 5 mm. (b) Bright-field microscopy image of P. polycephalum network trimmed to a rectangular shape. Scale bar, 2 mm. (c) Analysis of actin- cytoskeleton-driven contractions of tube walls in (b) reveal phases of contractions to be patterned in a roughly linear gradient. The wavelength of this peristaltic phase pattern on a network matches the organism size. (d) Simulation results of the spread of particles (copper colour) due to the streaming of fluid flow driven by the peristaltic contractions. a tube [28–31]. In P. polycephalum the tubular network can be considered to be of fixed volume on the time scales of tens of contraction periods. Therefore, net fluid trans- port is not relevant on these short time scales [22, 32]. Yet, creating shuttle flows by a peristaltic wave of con- tractions is a simple but powerful mechanism to increase the spread of any particles, like metabolites or signalling molecules within this closed network. Rare measure- ments show organism-wide ∼ 2 cm transport of particles within half a contraction period [21] out-competing dif- fusive spread that would have travelled only 0.25 mm in that time frame. Because of the oscillatory nature of flow, particles flow mainly back to their initial site after a whole period. But the peristaltic flow also increases the effective diffusion κ → κ + U 2R2/48κ according to Taylor dispersion in long slender tubes [33, 34] also ap- plicable to contractile tubes [35, 36]. Here, κ denotes the bare molecular diffusivity. Rapid diffusion across the tiny tube cross-sections allows particles to transition be- tween fast and slow streamlines of the Poiseuille profile rapidly increasing their dispersion along the tube by an order of magnitude, see Fig. 2 c. The adjacency of big and small tubes and therefore different flow velocities in a slime mould network make it a hard task to theoret- ically map out how far particles can spread [37]. One successful strategy is to map out an effective dispersion [38, 39], which unveils for example that particle spread is increased by pruning/coarsening of the network when P. polycephalum is left to starve [39]. This already pro- vides a glimpse of the challenging question on how net- work morphology impacts network-wide transport [21]. Is morphology geared to optimizing dispersion? If so, how does it evolve toward an optimized morphology? Transport by fluid flow seems to lie at the basis of net- work self-organization since advected signaling molecules may propagate information about the acquisition of a food source throughout the network by hijacking fluid flows [40]. Here, signaling molecules advected by fluid flow directly increase contraction activity. Further, flow is necessary to synchronize and coordinate contractions [41–43]. It is therefore likely that flows play a crucial role in coordinating contractions over space and time. 0h6:15h12:30hadbcCELL MIGRATION BY PUMPING OF PERISTALTIC WAVE Cytoplasmic flows form the basis of fast locomotion of very different kinds of amoeba [44–47]. Flows arise by local expansion of the actin cortex and subsequent myosin dependent contraction [45]. Flows and contrac- tility underlying cell migration are well accessible in the amoeboid plasmodia of P. polycephalum. Plasmodia of 100 µm to 500 µm length adopt an amoeboid shape mi- grating rapidly [48, 49] by net fluid transport generated by a contractile peristaltic wave and cortex expansion at the front [50]. Changes in contraction pattern affect lo- comotion velocity [51]. Plasmodia that exceed ∼ 500 µm form a full network structure often including multiple migration fronts. Over the peristaltic cycle a front lo- cation advances and retracts asymmetrically leading to net advancement at long time scales [52]. As networks grow they move faster [24]. When confined to lanes, mi- gration velocity scales linearly with maximal plasmodium height, reaching locomotion speeds of up to v = 0.4mm/s [24]. Reorientation of migration direction for example to- ward a food source is associated with a redirection of the peristaltic wave direction to that site [40] further sub- stantiating that migration is governed by fluid flows on long time scales. Given that signaling molecules are ad- vected by fluid flows affecting actin cortex dynamics [40] it is seems possible that flows play an important role in the navigation of organisms, acting for example during chemotaxis. MORPHOLOGICAL CHANGES TRIGGERED BY CYTOPLASMIC FLOWS Fluid flows not only transport particles and fluid mass but also exert forces themselves that may induce long- term changes to morphology. Forces may directly feed back onto biochemical reactions triggering complex spa- tiotemporal dynamics due to this mechanochemical cou- pling as currently more and more observed in morpho- genetic processes [26, 27]. Even without the ability to pin down a specific feedback on chemical reactions the influence of forces generated by flow can be investigated on a coarse-grained level. For example, in animal vas- culature it is observed that tube diameters grow with increased flow rate regulating shear force to a balanced level [53]. This observation inspired the idea that fluid shear force induces morphological changes in vasculature, a concept also successfully used in models of P. poly- cephalum dynamics [21]. Further support is the success of Murray's law particularly in plant and animal vascu- lature [54] which predicts the ratio of tube diameters at a network node under the assumption of conserved shear force. Murray's law is also consistent with minimizing dissipation inspiring theoretical work on optimal network 3 architectures [55–57]. Given that P. polycephalum grows its almost transparent tubes in a planar network, testing principles such as Murray's law [58] and in general re- lating morphological dynamics to flow properties is very feasible. In particular, the adaptability of the network morphology makes it a very suitable system to explore how well certain properties like dissipation, robustness [3] or transport capabilities [59, 60] are optimized by liv- ing organisms. Equally, as flows are globally coupled throughout the network, there is considerable additional complexity in this system. Indeed, it might well be that precisely this added complexity due to the coupling is the key to have simple mechanisms based on fluid flow give rise to the complex dynamics of self-organization of morphology we observe. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT This work has been supported by the Max Planck So- ciety ∗ [email protected] [1] L Boddy, J Hynes, D P Bebber, and M D Fricker. Sapro- trophic cord systems: Dispersal mechanisms in space and time. Mycoscience, 50:9–19, 2009. [2] S L Stephenson and H Stempen. Myxomycetes: a hand- book of slime molds. Timber Press, Inc., Oregon, 1994. [3] A Tero, S Takagi, T Saigusa, K Ito, D P Bebber, M D Fricker, K Yumiki, R Kobayashi, and T Nakagaki. Rules for biologically inspired adaptive network design. Sci- ence, 327:439–42, 2010. [4] M Tlalka, S C Watkinson, P R Darrah, and M D Fricker. Continuous imaging of amino-acid translocation in intact mycelia of Phanerochaete velutina reveals rapid, pulsatile fluxes. New Phytol., 153:173–184, 2002. [5] M Tlalka, D P Bebber, P R Darrah, S C Watkinson, and M D Fricker. Emergence of self-organised oscillatory domains in fungal mycelia. Fungal Genet. Biol., 44:1085– 1095, 2007. [6] N Kamiya. The rate of the protoplasmic flow in the myx- omycete plasmodium I. Cytologia, 15:183–193, 1950. [7] P A Stewart and B T Stewart. Protoplasmic movement in slime mold plasmodia: The diffusion drag force hy- pothesis. Exp. Cell Res., 17:44–58, 1959. [8] Alexander V Bykov, Alexander V Priezzhev, Janne Lauri, and Risto Myllyla. Doppler OCT imaging of cy- toplasm shuttle flow in Physarum polycephalum. J. Bio- photon., 2(8-9):540–547, 2009. [9] Yurii Romanovskii and VA Teplov. The physical bases of cell movement. The mechanisms of self-organisation of amoeboid motility. Phys.-Usp., 38(5):521–542, 1995. [10] R Swaminathan, C P Hoang, and A S Verkman. Pho- tobleaching recovery and anisotropy decay of green flu- orescent protein GFP-S65T in solution and cells: cy- toplasmic viscosity probed by green fluorescent protein translational and rotational diffusion. Biophys. J., 72(4): 1900–1907, 1997. [11] G Isenberg and K sE Wohlfarth-Bottermann. Transfor- mation of cytoplasmic actin. Importance for the organi- zation of the contractile gel reticulum and the contraction – Relaxation cycle of cytoplasmic actomyosin. Cell Tiss. Res., 173:495–528, 1976. [12] W Naib-Majani, W Stockem, K Weber, J Wehland, and K E Wohlfarth-Bottermann. Cytoplasmic actin patterns in Physarum as revealed by NBD-phallacidin staining. Cell Biol. Int., 7(8):637–640, 1983. [13] J-P Rieu, H Delanoe-Ayari, S Takagi, Y Tanaka, and T Nakagaki. Periodic traction in migrating large amoeba of Physarum polycephalum. J. R. Soc. Interface, 12(106): 20150099, 2015. [14] Vladimir A Teplov. Role of mechanics in the appear- ance of oscillatory instability and standing waves of the mechanochemical activity in the Physarum polycephalum plasmodium. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys., 50(21):213002–22, 2017. [15] K Matsumoto, T Ueda, and Y Kobatake. Reversal of thermotaxis with oscillatory stimulation in the plasmod- ium of Physarum polycephalum. J. Theor. Biol., 131(2): 175–182, 1988. [16] T Ueda. An intelligent slime mold: A self-organizing sys- tem of cell shape and information. World Scientific Lec- ture Notes in Complex Systems: Network of Interacting Machines. World Scientific Publishing Co., 2005. [17] S Takagi and T Ueda. Emergence and transitions of dy- namic patterns of thickness oscillation of the plasmodium of the true slime mold Physarum polycephalum. Physica D, 237:420–427, 2008. [18] S Takagi and T Ueda. Annihilation and creation of rotat- ing waves by a local light pulse in a protoplasmic droplet of the Physarum plasmodium. Physica D, 239(11):873– 878, 2010. [19] Markus Radszuweit, Sergio Alonso, Harald Engel, and Markus Bar. Intracellular mechanochemical waves in an active poroelastic model. Phys. Rev. Lett., 110(13): 138102, 2013. [20] Sergio Alonso, Ulrike Strachauer, Markus Radszuweit, Markus Bar, and Marcus J B Hauser. Oscillations and uniaxial mechanochemical waves in a model of an ac- tive poroelastic medium: Application to deformation patterns in protoplasmic droplets of Physarum poly- cephalum. Physica D, 318-319:58–69, 2016. [21] T Nakagaki, H Yamada, and T Ueda. Interaction be- tween cell shape and contraction pattern in the Physarum plasmodium. Biophys. Chem., 84(3):195–204, May 2000. [22] K Alim, G Amselem, F Peaudecerf, M P Brenner, and A Pringle. Random network peristalsis in Physarum poly- cephalum organizes fluid flows across an individual. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 110(33):13306–13311, 2013. [23] M D. Fricker. personal communication, 2014. [24] S Kuroda, S Takagi, T Nakagaki, and T Ueda. Allometry in Physarum plasmodium during free locomotion: size versus shape, speed and rhythm. J. Exp. Biol., 218(23): 3729–3738, 2015. [25] T Ueda and Y Kobatake. Initiation, development and termination of contraction rhythm in plasmodia of myx- omycete Physarum polycephalum. J. Theor. Biol., 97(1): 87–93, 1982. [26] Jonathon Howard, Stephan W Grill, and Justin S Bois. Turing's next steps: the mechanochemical basis of mor- phogenesis. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol., 12(6):392–398, 2011. 4 [27] Peter Gross, K Vijay Kumar, and Stephan W Grill. How active mechanics and regulatory biochemistry combine to form patterns in development. Annu. Rev. Biophys., 46 (1):337–356, 2017. [28] AH Shapiro, MY Jaffrin, and SL Weinberg. Peristaltic pumping with long wavelengths at low Reynolds number. J. Fluid Mech., 37:799–825, 1969. [29] A H Shapiro and M Y Jaffrin. Reflux in peristaltic pump- ing - is it determined by Eulerian or Lagrangian mean velocity. J. Appl. Mech., 38(4):1060–1062, 1971. [30] K P Selverov and H A Stone. Peristaltically driven chan- nel flows with applications toward micromixing. Phys. Fluids, 13(7):1837–1859, 2001. [31] M Li and J G Brasseur. Non-steady peristaltic transport in finite-length tubes. J. Fluid Mech., 248:129–151, 1993. [32] M Iima and T Nakagaki. Peristaltic transport and mixing of cytosol through the whole body of Physarum plasmod- ium. Math. Med. Biol., 29(3):263–281, 2012. [33] R Aris. On the dispersion of a solute in a fluid flowing through a tube. Proc. R. Soc. A, 235:67–77, 1956. [34] G Taylor. Dispersion of soluble matter in solvent flowing slowly through a tube. Proc. R. Soc. A, 219:186–203, 1953. [35] G N Mercer and A J Roberts. A center manifold descrip- tion of contaminant dispersion in channels with varying flow properties. SIAM J. Appl. Math., 50(6):1547–1565, 1990. [36] G N Mercer and A J Roberts. A complete model of shear dispersion in pipes. Japan J. Indust. Appl. Math., 11(3): 499–521, 1994. [37] Luke L Heaton, Eduardo L´opez, Philip K Maini, Mark D Fricker, and Nick S Jones. Advection, diffusion, and de- livery over a network. Phys. Rev. E, 86(2):021905, 2012. [38] PG Saffman. A theory of dispersion in a porous medium. J. Fluid Mech., 6:321–349, 1959. [39] S Marbach, K Alim, N Andrew, A Pringle, and M P Brenner. Pruning to increase Taylor dispersion in Physarum polycephalum networks. Phys. Rev. Lett., 117 (17):178103, 2016. [40] K Alim, N Andrew, A Pringle, and M P Brenner. Mech- anism of signal propagation in Physarum polycephalum. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 114(20):5136–5141, 2017. [41] Y Yoshimoto and N Kamiya. Studies on contraction rhythm of plasmodial strand 3. Role of endoplasmic streaming in synchronization of local rhythms. Proto- plasma, 95(1-2):111–121, 1978. [42] K.E. Samans, I. Hinz, Z. Hejnowicz, and K.E. Wohlfarth- Bottermann. Phase relation of oscillatory contraction cycles in Physarum plasmodia: I. A serial infrared regis- tration device and its application to different plasmodial stages. J. Interdiscip. Cycle Res., 15(4):241–250, 1984. [43] U Achenbach and KE Wohlfarth-Bottermann. Synchro- nization and signal transmission in protoplasmic strands of Physarum. Planta, 151:574–583, 1981. [44] D L Taylor, J S Condeelis, P L Moore, and R D Allen. The contractile basis of amoeboid movement: I. The chemical control of motility in isolated cytoplasm. J. Cell Biol., 59(2):378–394, 1973. [45] T Lammermann, B L Bader, S J Monkley, T Worbs, R Wedlich-Soldner, K Hirsch, M Keller, R Forster, D R Critchley, R Fassler, and M Sixt. Rapid leukocyte mi- gration by integrin-independent flowing and squeezing. Nature, 453(7191):51–55, 2008. [46] G Charras and E Paluch. Blebs lead the way: How to migrate without lamellipodia. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol., 9(9):730–736, 2008. [47] K Yoshida and T Soldati. Dissection of amoeboid move- ment into two mechanically distinct modes. J. Cell Sci., 119:3833–3844, 2006. [48] K Matsumoto, S Takagi, and T Nakagaki. Locomotive mechanism of Physarum plasmodia based on spatiotem- poral analysis of protoplasmic streaming. Biophys. J., 94:2492–504, 2008. [49] S Zhang, R D Guy, J C Lasheras, and J C del ´Alamo. Self-organized mechano-chemical dynamics in amoeboid locomotion of Physarum fragments. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys., 50(20):204004, 2017. [50] O L Lewis, S Zhang, R D Guy, and J C del Alamo. Coordination of contractility, adhesion and flow in mi- grating Physarum amoebae. J. Roy. Soc. Interface, 12 (106):20141359, 2015. [51] B Rodiek, S Takagi, T Ueda, and M J B Hauser. Patterns of cell thickness oscillations during directional migration of Physarum polycephalum. Eur. Biophys. J., 44(5):349– 358, 2015. [52] W Baumgarten and M J B Hauser. Dynamics of frontal extension of an amoeboid cell. Europhys. Lett., 108(5): 50010, 2014. 5 [53] A Kamiya and T Togawa. Adaptive regulation of wall shear-stress to flow change in the canine carotid-artery. Am. J. Physiol., 239(1):H14–H21, 1980. [54] C D Murray. The physiological principle of minimum work: I. The vascular system and the cost of blood vol- ume. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 12(3):207–214, 1926. [55] F Corson. Fluctuations and redundancy in optimal trans- port networks. Phys. Rev. Lett., 104:048703, 2010. [56] E Katifori, G J Szollosi, and M O Magnasco. Damage and fluctuations induce loops in optimal transport networks. Phys. Rev. Lett., 104:048704, 2010. [57] M Durand. Structure of optimal transport networks sub- ject to a global constraint. Phys. Rev. Lett., 98(8):088701, 2007. [58] D Akita, I Kunita, M D Fricker, S Kuroda, KA Sato, and T Nakagaki. Experimental models for Murray's law. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys., 50(2):024001, 2016. [59] F. J. Meigel and K. Alim. Flow rate of transport network controls uniform metabolite supply to tissue. Roy. Soc. Interface, in press, 2018. [60] S-S Chang, S Tu, Y-H Liu, V Savage, S-P L Hwang, and M Roper. Optimal occlusion uniformly partitions red blood cells fluxes within a microvascular network. PLos Comput. Biol., 13:e1005892, 2017.
1607.06836	1	1607	2016-07-22T20:37:37	Allosteric Regulation by a Critical Membrane	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "cond-mat.stat-mech", "q-bio.SC" ]	Many of the processes that underly neural computation are carried out by ion channels embedded in the plasma membrane, a two-dimensional liquid that surrounds all cells. Recent experiments have demonstrated that this membrane is poised close to a liquid-liquid critical point in the Ising universality class. Here we use both exact and stochastic techniques on the lattice Ising model to explore the ramifications of proximity to criticality for proteins that are allosterically coupled to Ising composition modes. Owing to diverging generalized susceptibilities, such a protein's activity becomes strongly influenced by perturbations that influence the two relevant parameters of the critical point, especially the critical temperature. In addition, the protein's kinetics acquire a range of time scales from its surrounding membrane, naturally leading to non-Markovian dynamics.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Allosteric Regulation by a Critical Membrane Ofer Kimchi,1 Sarah L. Veatch,2 and Benjamin B. Machta3, 1, ∗ 1Department of Physics, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, 08544 2Department of Biophysics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI. 48109 3Lewis Sigler Institute, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, 08544 Many of the processes that underly neural computation are carried out by ion channels embedded in the plasma membrane, a two-dimensional liquid that surrounds all cells. Recent experiments have demonstrated that this membrane is poised close to a liquid-liquid critical point in the Ising universality class. Here we use both exact and stochastic techniques on the lattice Ising model to explore the ramifications of proximity to criticality for proteins that are allosterically coupled to Ising composition modes. Owing to diverging generalized susceptibilities, such a protein's activity becomes strongly influenced by perturbations that influence the two relevant parameters of the critical point, especially the critical temperature. In addition, the protein's kinetics acquire a range of time scales from its surrounding membrane, naturally leading to non-Markovian dynamics. PACS numbers: 87.15.kt, 87.15.Ya,87.16.dt Every cell is surrounded by the plasma membrane, a two dimensional (2D) liquid composed of lipids and embedded proteins. In addition to separating the cell from its surroundings, the plasma membrane is home to diverse functional processes. In neurons, membrane- bound ion channels sense chemical and electrical signals and control conductance to specific ions, leading to the complex dynamics that underly neural function. Recent progress suggests a role for the membrane itself in regu- lating these processes. The membrane is heterogeneous, with liquid structures often termed 'rafts' at length scales of 10 − 100 nm, much larger than the 1 nm scale of individual lipids [1, 2]. Experiments have suggested a physical mechanism underlying these structures. Vesi- cles isolated from a mammalian cell line have membranes tuned close to a liquid-liquid miscibility critical point [3]. When cooled below their critical temperature, Tc, these vesicles macroscopically phase separate into two liquid phases termed liquid ordered (lo) and liquid disordered (ld) which differ in the partitioning of lipids, proteins and a fluorescent dye [4]. Previously we have argued that proximity to this criti- cal point is likely to underly much of the 'raft' heterogene- ity seen in diverse membrane systems [5] with embedded proteins subject to long-range critical Casimir forces [6]. More recently we have shown that n-alcohol anesthetics take membrane derived vesicles away from criticality by lowering Tc [7]. Despite structural diversity, anesthetics are known to exert similar effects on diverse ion chan- nels [8] leading us to speculate that these effects might arise because anesthetics mimic or interfere with native regulation of channels by their surrounding membrane. In support of this, we found that conditions that re- verse anesthetic effects on ion channels and organisms also raise critical temperatures in vesicles [9]. Here we explore consequences of thermodynamic criti- cality for a membrane-bound protein whose internal state is coupled to the state of its surrounding membrane. While most ion channels are broadly classified as lig- and gated or voltage gated, many are also sensitive to a wide range of modulators including calcium levels, pH, lipids, and temperature [10]. Ion channel function can also depend on the 2D solvent properties of the mem- brane in which they are embedded, both in reconstituted [11, 12] and in vivo assays [13, 14]. In this manuscript we develop a simple model for a protein regulated by its surrounding membrane. We show that when the mem- brane is held close to a critical point this type of coupling leads to a qualitatively distinct regime including strong responses to perturbations which influence Tc, a hierar- chy of time scales, and non-Markovian dynamics. As we show, these effects are critical phenomena, arising from the diverging generalized susceptibilities and correlation times that emerge near the critical point. Throughout the manuscript we consider a system con- sisting of membrane degrees of freedom {s} and a single hypothetical ion channel (Fig. 1A) with state R and Hamiltonian Htot({s}, R) = Hmem({s}) + ER + Hint({s}∂, R) (1) where Hmem describes interactions of membrane lipids with one another, ER measures the (free) energy of state R without considering membrane interactions, and Hint describes the interaction between the protein in state R and the components that it contacts at its boundary, s ∈ ∂. In equilibrium, the system consisting of pro- tein and membrane will be in a given state with prob- ability determined by an appropriate Boltzmann distri- bution, P ({s}, R) = e−βHtot({s},R)/Z. We can inte- grate over membrane degrees of freedom to isolate the protein whose internal states are occupied according to P (R) = exp(−βFR)/Z, where (cid:88) {s} exp(−βFR) = exp (−βHtot({s}, R)) (2) defines FR, the free energy of state R. 6 1 0 2 l u J 2 2 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 6 3 8 6 0 . 7 0 6 1 : v i X r a 2 (See Fig. 1B). These interactions between our protein's state R and surrounding spins mimic a coupling between a protein's functional state and the membrane's state as seen experimentally [11, 13, 14]. They could arise from hydrophobic mismatch [17, 18], distinct lateral pressure profiles in the different phases [19], or specific interac- tions with particular components that partition strongly into distinct phases [20]. We consider three types of BCs in this manuscript: fixed BCs in which hi(R) = ±JR, free BCs in which hi(R) = 0 and Janus BCs in which hi(R) = +JR on one side of the protein and hi(R) = −JR on the other side. We first wanted to investigate how a change in the membrane's properties might influence average channel activity, as would be measured by a whole cell recording or other technique probing the response of many channels together. In the context of our model this means exam- ining the dependance of P (R) on the details of Hmem. As this is a static property of our equilibrium system we can make use of a remarkable algorithm developed for spin glasses that uses Pfaffian elimination to exactly cal- culate partition functions to user specified precision on lattices with arbitrary nearest neighbor couplings Jij in zero field [21]. We implement our Hamiltonian by set- ting all interactions Jij between spins to βJ, interactions between lattice sites internal to the protein to a large negative value (here −10) and interactions between lat- tice sites contained in the protein and spins to hi(R) [36] (see Fig. 1B). Changes to Hmem will lead to a change in a state's free energy ∆FR with resulting changes in P (R). In this two-state example, only the difference in free en- ergy changes, ∆Fdif f = ∆F+ − ∆F− will influence P (R = ±1) through: FIG. 1: (A) Schematic representation of our model. We consider a protein embedded in a nearly critical membrane with which it interacts through distinct boundary interactions in distinct functional states. When the parameters of the membrane change, the free energies of different protein states changes, altering function. (B) We probe these effects using a lattice Ising model in which a single protein is modeled as a group of sites which transition together, while the remaining membrane is composed of Ising spins that can take values si = ±1 As in previous work, we model the membrane as a square-lattice of spins si = ±1 with the usual Ising Hamiltonian Hmem = −J(cid:80)(cid:104)i,j(cid:105) sisj, where the sum runs over all nearest neighbor pairs neither of which are contained in the protein. In our model, up/down spins roughly correspond to more lo/ld partitioning com- ponents, with a lattice constant which corresponds to l ∼ 1 − 2 nm of membrane. This scale corresponds both to the approximate size of a lipid of ∼ .8 nm2[15, 16] and to measurements of the correlation length near the criti- cal point of cell-derived vesicles that suggest an analogy to a lattice model with l ∼ 2 nm [3]. Our model also con- tains a protein whose internal state can take two values, R = ±1 which could correspond to open/closed, and a chemical potential (perhaps modulated by a ligand) that contributes a term in the Hamiltonian ER = −µR. Cru- cially we also include an interaction between membrane i hi(R)si where this sum is over spins which border the protein, whose bound- ary conditions (BCs) in state R are determined by hi(R) and protein of the form Hint = (cid:80) P (R = +1) P (R = −1) → P (cid:48)(R = +1) P (cid:48)(R = −1) exp (−β∆Fdif f ) (3) Thus exp(−β∆Fdif f ) measures the degree to which a change in Hmem potentiates the + state (see Fig. 2A). We estimate the potentiation of function that accom- panies a 1% change in Tc, comparable both to the natural variation seen in cell derived vesicles [3], and to the mag- nitude of the effect seen with physiologically relevant con- centrations of anesthetics [7]. We examine BCs in which the R = −1 state has fixed BCs (hi = +∞, here 10 for numerical purposes) while the R = +1 state has either free BCs (hi = 0) or Janus BCs. The results are shown in Fig. 2B-D. In Fig. 2B this potentiation is shown for pro- teins in which the R = +1 has free BCs, at T = 1.05Tc for proteins with a range of radii. Larger proteins see more pronounced potentiation due to the increased sur- face area of interaction. In Fig. 2C the potentiation is shown for the same proteins over a range of tempera- tures. Away from the critical point, this change has only a small effect on the state occupancy -- the potentiation is small. However, near the critical point the potentiation 3 the free energy associated with the insertion of an inclu- sion should have a singular contribution that depends on inclusion size, BCs and the distance to the critical point: F s R = U(rt1/yt, h/tyh/yt , ...) (4) where yt = ν = 1 and yh = γ = 15/8 are the scaling dimension of the fields t and h, r is the radius of the in- clusion and U is a universal function. Taking a derivative with respect to t, we expect that ∂F s dif f ∂t = rytU(rt1/yt, h/tyh/yt, ...) (5) We verify that our measured potentiation can indeed be collapsed in this manner in Fig. 2D for the fixed/Janus BCs. However, for the fixed/free particles we find an additional contribution that arises more directly from the boundary. This term is proportional to the length of the boundary and should scale as F s R,∂ = r/l U(lt1/yt, h/tyh/yt, ...) (6) leading to a similar collapse but with lytt on the x-axis (see supplement for discussion). While scaling suggests that coupling to changes in h would diverge more strongly near criticality, membranes are at fixed magnetization (composition) in which there is no divergence. We next looked at the role a critical membrane could play in shaping the kinetics of ion channel function as would be measured in single channel voltage clamp ex- periments. To do this we employ the local Kawasaki algorithm [22] as we have done previously [5] which im- plements diffusive 'model B' dynamics [23]. Using these dynamics a sweep (in which every spin is proposed to ex- change with its neighbors once) corresponds to roughly a microsecond of real time since each lattice site corre- sponds to the size of a lipid and lipids diffuse at a rate of ∼ 1 µm2/s [5][37]. Our Kawasaki dynamics forbid ex- change with spins in the protein, but every sweep the protein changes state with the Metropolis probability to ensure detailed balance. While our protein attempts to change its state R dur- ing every sweep, its apparent kinetics are much slower. Representative traces of R(τ ) are shown in Fig. 3A af- ter convolution with a Gaussian of width σ = 103 sweeps [38]. These traces share qualitative features with real ion channels spanning many time scales [24]: 'flick- ers' shorter than σ, single 'openings' (which often con- tain many short flickers), and 'bursts' in which a series of openings occur close to each other. The time-scale of these features increases as the critical point is approached (Fig. 3A). Similar changes in the time-scale of ion chan- nel dynamics arising from the addition of some anesthet- ics have been observed experimentally [25]. These could result from perturbations to the proximity of the mem- brane to criticality, though they are typically interpreted FIG. 2: Changes in membrane properties lead to changes in the conformational equilibrium of a membrane-bound pro- tein. (A) In this example P (R = +1) is potentiated by a change in the critical temperature of the membrane. As µ is varied (for example through addition of ligand) the protein transitions from the off (R = −1) to on (R = +1) state. Af- ter a perturbation has been applied that changes Tc, the free energy difference between the R = ±1 states has changed by β∆Fdif f , shifting the curve of P (R = +1) vs µ to the left (from the black line to the black dashed line). (B) β∆Fdif f is plotted for a perturbation in which Tc is lowered by 1% for ion channels of different sizes, in all cases from T = 1.05Tc and with fixed boundary conditions when R = −1 and free boundary conditions when R = +1. β∆Fdif f is larger for larger inclusions, and is ∼ 0.5 for the largest inclusions ex- amined, comparable to the GABAA channel which is ∼ 6 nm across and which is potentiated by ∼ 50% by analogous (C) β∆Fdif f is plotted vs t = T − Tc/Tc treatments [8]. for different sized inclusions (symbols as in B) for the same fixed-free BCs (red) and for BCs in which R = +1 has Janus BCs (blue). In each case, the magnitude of β∆Fdif f becomes much larger closer to the critical point. (D) We verify through the scaling collapse discussed in the text that this effect can be understood as a critical phenomenon. becomes much larger, even for the modest 1% change in Tc explored here. This change in Tc is comparable to that seen with addition of clinically relevant concentra- tions of anesthetic [7, 9]. For the largest proteins sizes explored here, our observed potentiation is similar to that observed for the GABAA channel (see Fig. 2 of Ref [8]) whose radius is ∼ 6 nm. While we don't know details of GABAA's interaction with it's surrounding membrane, our results suggest that anesthetic effects on membrane Tc could in principle lead to observed changes in channel function. We next wanted to verify that our effect could be un- derstood as a critical phenomenon. According to scaling, as arising from direct binding interactions between anes- thetic and channel. We quantify these findings by looking at the time auto- correlation of the simulated protein, χ(τ ) = (cid:104)R(0)R(τ )(cid:105), for a range of temperatures (Fig. 3B), demonstrating that correlations in state persist much longer as the crit- ical point is approached. We also perform simulations for proteins of different radii all at T = 1.05Tc (Fig. 3C), demonstrating that larger proteins have slower kinetics due to the increased area for interaction with surrounding membrane. These curves quantify the many time-scales that can be seen qualitatively in Fig. 3A; they are not closely approximated by single exponentials. Although the system as a whole is Markovian, when considered in isolation the protein displays non-Markovian dynamics, implying that some memory of its history is stored in the membrane degrees of freedom surrounding it. The non-Markovianity of several real ion channels and other membrane-embedded proteins has been well character- ized and various internal states of these proteins have been hypothesized [26, 27]; however, our results suggest that in some cases the history of the protein's state may be stored in the membrane rather than in internal states of the protein itself. We expect that the long time-scales seen in Fig. 3A are inherited from the surrounding membrane. Near the Ising critical point the correlation length diverges as ξ ∝ t−ν, and the correlation time diverges like τcor ∝ ξz where a dynamic exponent is z = 4 − η = 3.75 for the Kawasaki dynamics employed here [23]. If the curves of R(t) reflect properties of these slow critical fluctuations, then we might expect that autocorrelation functions in systems with different radii and correlation lengths χ(τ, r, ξ) might take a universal form: χ(τ, r, ξ) = rλU (r/ξ, τ /ξz) (7) with λ = 2yb = 1 where yb is the scaling dimension of the boundary operator which is expected to be 1/2 from con- formal field theory arguments (See [1] and supplement for a brief discussion). To check this, we performed simula- tions for the same proteins shown in Fig. 3C but now at different temperatures chosen so that r/ξ is fixed. While the bare curves decay over time-scales that differ by a fac- tor of 102, when we plot χ(τ )/r vs τ /ξz, we see collapse onto a single curve within stochastic error (Fig. 3D) as predicted by equation 7. Conclusion- Regulation by the nearly critical mem- brane might be very widespread both in ion channels and for other membrane-bound proteins. There are hints that the membrane may be playing an important role in this localization [29] and in some cases in direct regula- tion [14] of channels. Our model could account for the sensitivity of many diverse ion channels to chemically di- verse anesthetics [8] which we have demonstrated lower the critical temperature of cell-derived vesicles by ∼ 4K, just over 1% [7]. This explanation is appealing in that 4 FIG. 3: (A) Simulated ion channel dynamics, R(τ ), have prominent features at many distinct time-scales, qualitatively resembling traces from real single-channel recordings [24]. Near Tc, protein state changes occur on a timescale orders of magnitude larger than that of attempted state changes which happen once per sweep. (B) The autocorrelation function of χ(τ ) is shown at different temperatures, with proximity to criticality leading to longer lived correlations. (C) χ(τ ) also depends on channel radius r at a single temperature, T = 1.05 Tc (colors as above). (D) These long time scales are critical phenomena. When we plot χ(τ )/r vs τ /ξz for r and ξ values chosen so that r/ξ is constant, these curves collapse onto a single universal function as predicted by scaling. it might also explain why cholesterol depletion, which changes the membrane's 'magnetization' [30] also effects many anesthetic-sensitive channels [13]. Our results sug- gest that such channels should have their partitioning into small domains modulated by addition of ligand, a prediction that could be tested using super-resolution techniques. While most previous studies, both by ourselves [5, 6] and others [31] have focused on the role of membrane thermodynamics in localizing proteins into domains, this work suggests the same domains could couple more di- rectly to function. We predict that when a receptor binds ligand it will change its preference for its surrounding lipid environment, leading to different interaction part- ners and an imprint on the state of the local membrane that will persist even after the ligand has dispersed. We have highlighted a specific impact of thermodynamic crit- icality on a single ion channel, and further work will clar- ify how this mechanism contributes to neural function. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We thank Bill Bialek, Colin Clement, Jim Sethna and Ned Wingreen for useful discussions. This work was sup- ported by NIH R01 GM110052 (SLV) and a Lewis-Sigler Fellowship (BBM). BBM thanks CK Thomas and AA Middleton for making their code available on their web- site (https://aamiddle.expressions.syr.edu/). ∗ Electronic address: [email protected] [1] Simons K, Toomre D (2000) Lipid rafts and signal trans- duction. Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology 1:31 -- 39. [2] Dart C (2010) Lipid microdomains and the regulation of ion channel function. The Journal of Physiology 588:3169 -- 3178. [3] Veatch SL, et al. (2008) Critical fluctuations in plasma membrane vesicles. Acs Chemical Biology 3:287 -- 293. [4] Baumgart T, et al. (2007) Large-scale fluid/fluid phase separation of proteins and lipids in giant plasma mem- brane vesicles. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 104:3165 -- 3170. [5] Machta BB, Papanikolaou S, Sethna JP, Veatch SL (2011) Minimal model of plasma membrane heterogeneity re- quires coupling cortical actin to criticality. Biophys J 100:1668 -- 77. [6] Machta BB, Veatch SL, Sethna JP (2012) Critical casimir forces in cellular membranes. Phys. Rev. Lett. 109:138101. [7] Gray E, Karslake J, Machta BB, Veatch SL (2013) Liquid general anesthetics lower critical temperatures in plasma membrane vesicles. Biophys J 105:2751 -- 9. [8] Franks NP, Lieb WR (1994) Molecular and cellular mech- anisms of general anaesthesia. Nature 367:607 -- 14. 5 [17] Andersen OS, Roger E. Koeppe I (2007) Bilayer thickness and membrane protein function: An energetic perspective. Annual Review of Biophysics and Biomolecular Structure 36:107 -- 130 PMID: 17263662. [18] Soubias O, Niu SL, Mitchell DC, Gawrisch K (2008) Lipid-rhodopsin hydrophobic mismatch alters rhodopsin helical content. J Am Chem Soc 130:12465 -- 71. [19] Gruner SM, Shyamsunder E (1991) Is the mechanism of general anesthesia related to lipid membrane spontaneous curvature? Ann N Y Acad Sci 625:685 -- 97. [20] Levitan I, Singh DK, Rosenhouse-Dantsker A (2014) Cholesterol binding to ion channels. Frontiers in Phys- iology 5. [21] Thomas CK, Middleton AA (2013) Numerically exact correlations and sampling in the two-dimensional ising spin glass. Phys. Rev. E 87:043303. [22] Kawasaki K (1972) Phase transitions and critical phe- (Academic Press, nomena eds Domb C, Green MS Waltham, Massachusetts) Vol. 4. [23] Hohenberg P, Halperin B (1977) Theory of dynamic crit- ical phenomena. Rev. Mod. Phys. 49:435 -- 479. [24] Mortensen M, Smart TG (2007) Single-channel recording of ligand-gated ion channels. Nat. Protocols 2:2826 -- 2841. [25] Wachtel RE (1995) Relative potencies of volatile anes- thetics in altering the kinetics of ion channels in bc3h1 cells. Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Thera- peutics 274:1355 -- 1361. [26] Yamashita M, Mori T, Nagata K, Yeh J, Narahashi T (2005) Isoflurane modulation of neuronal nicotinic acetyl- choline receptors expressed in human embryonic kidney cells. Anesthesiology 102:76 -- 84. [27] Rankin S, Addona G, Kloczewiak M, Bugge B, Miller K (1997) The cholesterol dependence of activation and fast desensitization of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. Biophysical Journal 73:2446 -- 2455. [28] Cardy J (2004) Boundary Conformal Field Theory. [9] Machta BB, et al. (2016) Stabilizing membrane domains ArXiv High Energy Physics - Theory e-prints. antagonizes n-alcohol anesthesia. In press, Biophys J. [10] Kinnunen PK (1991) On the principles of functional or- dering in biological membranes. Chemistry and Physics of Lipids 57:375 -- 399. [11] Bristow DR, Martin IL (1987) Solubilisation of the gamma-aminobutyric acid/benzodiazepine receptor from rat cerebellum: optimal preservation of the modulatory responses by natural brain lipids. J Neurochem 49:1386 -- 93. [12] Rankin SE, Addona GH, Kloczewiak MA, Bugge B, Miller KW (1997) The cholesterol dependence of activa- tion and fast desensitization of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. Biophysical Journal 73:2446 -- 2455. [13] Sooksawate T, Simmonds M (2001) Effects of membrane cholesterol on the sensitivity of the gabaa receptor to gaba in acutely dissociated rat hippocampal neurones. Neu- ropharmacology 40:178 -- 184. [14] Allen JA, Halverson-Tamboli RA, Rasenick MM (2007) Lipid raft microdomains and neurotransmitter signalling. Nat Rev Neurosci 8:128 -- 140. [15] Chiu S, Jakobsson E, Mashl RJ, Scott HL (2002) Cholesterol-induced modifications in lipid bilayers: A sim- ulation study. Biophysical Journal 83:1842 -- 1853. [16] Alwarawrah M, Dai J, Huang J (2010) A molecular view of the cholesterol condensing effect in dopc lipid bilay- ers. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 114:7516 -- 7523 PMID: 20469902. [29] Li X, Serwanski DR, Miralles CP, Bahr BA, De Blas AL (2007) Two pools of triton x-100-insoluble gabaa recep- tors are present in the brain, one associated to lipid rafts and another one to the post-synaptic gabaergic complex. Journal of Neurochemistry 102:1329 -- 1345. [30] Zhao J, Wu J, Veatch SL (2013) Adhesion stabilizes robust lipid heterogeneity in supercritical membranes at physiological temperature. Biophys J 104:825 -- 34. [31] Katira S, Mandadapu KK, Vaikuntanathan S, Smit B, Chandler D (2016) Pre-transition effects mediate forces of assembly between transmembrane proteins. eLife 5:e13150. [32] Honerkamp-Smith AR, Machta BB, Keller SL (2012) Experimental observations of dynamic critical phenomena in a lipid membrane. Phys. Rev. Lett. 108:265702. [33] Hamill O, Marty A, Neher E, Sakmann B, Sigworth F (1981) Improved patch-clamp techniques for high- resolution current recording from cells and cell-free mem- brane patches. Pflegers Archiv 391:85 -- 100. [34] Kasianowicz J, Brandin E, Branton D, Deamer D (1996) Characterization of individual polynucleotide molecules using a membrane?channel. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 93:13770 -- 13773. ing (Springer Science & Business Media, Berlin). [35] Sakmann B, Neher E, eds (2009) Single-Channel Record- [36] This procedure more precisely calculates βF + log 2 since it integrates over both the correct boundary conditions 6 and those where every hi is flipped. [37] One caveat is that cells are likely in the regime where hydrodynamic relaxation [32] competes with diffusive dy- namics. [38] Because patch clamp recordings measure times on the or- der of 50-100 µs [2 -- 4], we plot R(τ ) after convolution with the Gaussian k(τ ) = e−τ 2/σ2 where σ = 103 (see supple- ment for bare curves and a discussion). Thus, while our model has only two states, the recording shows short spikes reaching levels in between the two, a feature common to real recordings that presumably has a similar explanation [2]. (cid:90) (cid:126)x>r SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION In supplemental information we first provide a more detailed argument for the form of the scaling function needed to capture fixed/free BCs used to make Fig. 2D of the main text. We then discuss the scaling form of the dynamic correlation function χ(τ, r, ξ). Finally, we discuss subtleties in our gaussian blurring procedure used to make Fig. 3A in the main text. Scaling of ∂F/∂J for free BCs In a suitable continuum limit we can write the Hamil- tonian conditioned on particular boundaries as: H = J d(cid:126)x((cid:126)x) (8) where ((cid:126)x), the energy operator, is the continuum ver- sion of ij = si,jsi+1,j. Both here and on the lattice, we can write the free energy change associated with a change in Hamiltonian parameters as: (cid:28)(cid:90) ∂F ∂J = (cid:29) d(cid:126)x((cid:126)x) (9) Here we use conformal field theory techniques to ex- actly calculate the field ((cid:126)r) that surrounds inclusions with our fixed and free BCs exactly at the critical point and in the continuum. Although we are unable to carry out this calculation away from Tc, we can use scaling to find the form of the relevant function. At the critical point we make use of exact methods that we and others have previously used to calculate Casimir forces between inclusions with particular BCs. Here we take a different limit, wherein one of the inclusions is infinitesimal and serves only as a 'test particle' for mea- suring the strength of the the other inclusion's induced field ((cid:126)d), which is a function of its BCs. To calibrate our test particle we first note that ( (cid:126)d) is a primary scaling field with scaling dimension 1 so that: (cid:68) 7 + higher order in d (cid:69) UF r−F r(d, r, r) ∼ h2 (r) ((cid:126)0)( (cid:126)d) (11) This in conjunction with the exact results allows us to infer the coupling h(r) ∼ r. Next we use the same exact results this time with one protein of radius r and one of infinitesimal radius a0. At the critical point, conformal invariance allows implies that their interaction energy can be written as a function of just one number, x = (d+2a0)(d+2r) . As a0 becomes small, x becomes large, even when d << r, allowing for a measurement of (r) everywhere in space includ- ing closeby to our inclusion of interest. In this limit, the scaling form is sufficient, and we find: ra0 (cid:68) (cid:69) ((cid:126)d) = r (cid:126)d((cid:126)d + 2r) (12) ( (cid:126)d) (cid:69) (cid:68) Where the expectation values are conditioned on the presence of an inclusion with Free BCs of radius r at the origin, and where d measures the distance from the sur- face of the protein. We are interested in the integral over space of which diverges at both large and short distances. The short distance divergence we will cut off by starting our integration at a cutoff motivated by a lat- tice at l0. Since we are primarily interested in the nearly critical, rather than critical regime, we assume that the off-critical energy field takes the following form, which is certainly true in a regime where ξ > r > l: ( (cid:126)d) = r (cid:126)d( (cid:126)d + 2r) × U(d/ξ, r/ξ, l/ξ, ...) (13) (cid:68) (cid:69) where the universal function presumably depends pri- marily on its first argument (the latter will henceforth be omitted). Though we do not know the exact form of U(d/ξ) we expect that it is close to 1 when d/ξ << 1 and that it goes to 0 when d/ξ >> 1. Our desired integral can now be written ∂F ∂J U(d/ξ) (14) Now we split this into two terms determined by whether their contribution diverges as l → 0 or only as ξ → ∞. 2π(r+ (cid:126)d)d (cid:126)d (cid:90) ∞ (cid:28)(cid:90) d(d + 2r) d (cid:126)d((cid:126)d) (cid:29) = = l0 r (cid:90) ∞ (cid:90) ∞ l0 πd (cid:126)d r d U(d/ξ) (15) (16) (17) (cid:68) (0)( (cid:126)d) (cid:69) ∼ 1 (cid:126)d2 (10) and An inclusion with Free BCs in the Ising model will not couple to the order parameter, and so its leading contri- butions arise from its coupling to the energy field ((cid:126)x). When two inclusions of radius r are placed a large dis- tance d apart, their interactions are closely approximated as arising from point like insertions of field so that their interaction energy goes like: πd (cid:126)d r ( (cid:126)d + 2r) U(d/ξ) l0 In the first we change coordinates to x = d/l0 (cid:90) ∞ πr 1 U ((l/ξ) x) x dx which is of the form r U1(l/ξ) for a (different) universal function U. For the second term, we can take l → 0 and instead change variables to x = d/r yielding (cid:90) ∞ which, for small r1/2Jr, small k and fixed Jr can be writ- ten as 8 U ((r/ξ) x) (x + 2) dx (18) χ(τ, r, ξ) = r2ybU(τ /ξz) (23) πr 0 which is of the form r U2(r/ξ). From the above we can write ∂F ∂J = r U1(l/ξ) + r U2(r/ξ) (19) As both terms diverge as the arguments of U1/2 become large, we generally expect the first to dominate when except when it is 0 for some reason. This is the case for the fixed/free BCs as can be seen in Fig. 2D of the main text. This calculation does not easily extend to the Janus/fixed case, where (for example) the field ((cid:126)d) presumably has angular dependance. However, since the boundary of the janus BCs look locally similar to the boundary of the fixed BCs, we might expect that the term with l/ξ dependance cancels, leaving only a term with r/ξ dependance, as is seen in Fig.2D of the main paper. Scaling of dynamics with radius for the argue scaling We wish to form of χ(τ, r, ξ) = (cid:104)R(0)R(τ )(cid:105) defined in the paper. First consider a simpler version where a site magnetic field adds a term in the Hamiltonian −hs0R. We assume that at a rate k, R switches or not so as to satisfy detailed balance so that: < R(0)R(τ ) >= U(h, kτ, τ /ξz) (20) If we assume k is very fast we can ignore the k depen- dance. Furthermore, h dependance must be even, so that when h is small we have: < R(0)R(τ ) >= h2U(τ /ξz) + O(h4) (21) where, in fact, this is just (cid:104)R(0)R(τ )(cid:105) = h2 (cid:104)s0(0)s0(τ )(cid:105). We would like to do a similar calculation here, but now we must replace h with hef f (r, Jr). We suspect that ours is best understood as a 'boundary field', whose dimension is yb = 1/2 [1] so that hef f (r) ∼ r1/2Jr so that χ(τ, r, ξ) = U(ryb Jr, k τ, τ /ξz) (22) This analysis predicts that had we also scaled Jr ∼ r−yb that we could have found results that collapsed even for larger proteins for which our relatively large Jrs almost never flip. Gaussian Blurring Patch clamp recordings measure times on the order of 50-100 µs [2 -- 4] while the dynamics of the ion channels we simulate here occur on timescales of 0.1 µs. There- fore, in order to simulate the comparitively low temporal resolution of patch clamp recordings, we plot the state of the channel as a function of time, R(t), after convolu- tion with the Gaussian k(τ ) = e−τ 2/σ2 . In Fig. 4 (top), we show the resulting simulated recordings for a range of σs spanning several orders of magnitude. Gaussian blur- ring leads to the emergence of a timescale of ion channel dynamics on the order of tens of ms, and this result is robust to changes in σ. This feature appears to be a non- Markovian phenomenon: a similar analysis performed on an ion channel simulated at high temperature far from criticality, for which the channel's dynamics are Marko- vian, does not lead to the emergence of such timescales (Fig. 4, bottom). ∗ Electronic address: [email protected] [1] Cardy J (2004) Boundary Conformal Field Theory. ArXiv High Energy Physics - Theory e-prints. [2] Hamill O, Marty A, Neher E, Sakmann B, Sigworth F (1981) Improved patch-clamp techniques for high- resolution current recording from cells and cell-free mem- brane patches. Pflegers Archiv 391:85 -- 100. [3] Kasianowicz J, Brandin E, Branton D, Deamer D (1996) Characterization of individual polynucleotide molecules using a membrane?channel. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 93:13770 -- 13773. [4] Sakmann B, Neher E, eds (2009) Single-Channel Record- ing (Springer Science & Business Media, Berlin). 9 FIG. 4: Results Are Robust to Resolution of Gaussian Blurring Top: The simulated protein attempted to flip every sweep (corresponding to 0.1 µs), and without any blurring, the simulated ion channel recording includes state changes on the corresponding timescale (top left). However, when the low temporal resolution of standard patch-clamp techniques is accounted for through convolution of the data with the Gaussian k(t) = e−t2/σ2 as in Fig. 3A, a timescale for protein dynamics on the order of tens of ms can be seen. This result is not changed when the resolution of the Gaussian blurring, σ, is varied, even by orders of magnitude. Bottom: No such timescale emerges in the Markovian case.
1608.06918	1	1608	2016-08-19T14:51:33	Growth and Scaling during Development and Regeneration	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.TO" ]	Life presents fascinating examples of self-organization and emergent phenomena. In multi-cellular organisms, a multitude of cells interact to form and maintain highly complex body plans of well-defined size. In this thesis, we investigate theoretical feedback mechanisms for both self-organized body plan patterning and size control. The thesis is inspired by the astonishing scaling and regeneration abilities of flatworms. These worms can perfectly regrow their entire body plan even from tiny amputation fragments like the tip of the tail. Moreover, they can grow and actively de-grow by more than a factor of 40 in length depending on feeding conditions. These capabilities prompt for remarkable physical mechanisms of self-organized pattern formation and scaling. First, we explore the basic principles and challenges of pattern scaling in mechanisms previously proposed to describe biological pattern formation. Next, we present a novel class of patterning mechanisms yielding entirely self-organized and self-scaling patterns. This framework captures essential features of body plan regeneration and scaling in flatworms. Further, we analyze shape and motility of flatworms. By applying principal component analysis, we characterize shape dynamics during different motility modes and also identify shape variations between different flatworm species. Finally, we investigate the metabolic control of cell turnover and growth. We identify three mechanisms of metabolic energy storage; theoretical descriptions thereof can explain the measured organism growth by rules on the cellular scale. In a close collaboration with experimental biologists, we combine minimal theoretical descriptions with state-of-the-art experiments and data analysis. This allows us to identify generic principles of scalable body plan patterning and growth control in flatworms.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Max-Planck-Institut fur Physik komplexer Systeme Growth and Scaling during Development and Regeneration Dissertation zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades Doctor rerum naturalium Institut fur Theoretische Physik Fakultat fur Mathematik und Naturwissenschaften Technische Universitat Dresden vorgelegt von Steffen Werner geboren am 3. September 1984 in Bad Mergentheim Dresden, 2016 Eingereicht am 04. Dezember 2015 Promotionskommission: Prof. Dr. D. Inosov (Vorsitz) Prof. Dr. F. Julicher (Gutachter) Prof. Dr. St. Grill (Gutachter) Prof. Dr. N. Barkai (Gutachter) Prof. Dr. G. Pospiech Verteidigt am 17. Juni 2016 Abstract in English Life presents fascinating examples of self-organization and emergent phenomena. In multi-cellular organisms, a multitude of cells interact to form and maintain highly complex body plans. This requires reliable communication between cells on various length scales. First, there has to be the right number of cells to preserve the integrity of the body and its size. Second, there have to be the right types of cells at the right positions to result in a functional body layout. In this thesis, we investigate theoretical feedback mechanisms for both self-organized body plan patterning and size control. The thesis is inspired by the astonishing scaling and regeneration abilities of flat- worms. These worms can perfectly regrow their entire body plan even from tiny amputation fragments like the tip of the tail. Moreover, they can grow and actively de-grow by more than a factor of 40 in length depending on feeding conditions, scaling up and down all body parts while maintaining their functionality. These capabilities prompt for remarkable physical mechanisms of pattern formation. First, we explore pattern scaling in mechanisms previously proposed to describe biological pattern formation. We systematically extract requirements for scaling and high- light the limitations of these previous models in their ability to account for growth and regene- ration in flatworms. In particular, we discuss a prominent model for the spontaneous formation of biological patterns introduced by Alan Turing. We characterize the hierarchy of steady states of such a Turing mechanism and demonstrate that Turing patterns do not naturally scale. Second, we present a novel class of patterning mechanisms yielding entirely self- organized and self-scaling patterns. Our framework combines a Turing system with our derived principles of pattern scaling and thus captures essential features of body plan regenera- tion and scaling in flatworms. We deduce general signatures of pattern scaling using dynamical systems theory. These signatures are discussed in the context of experimental data. Next, we analyze shape and motility of flatworms. By monitoring worm motility, we can identify movement phenotypes upon gene knockout, reporting on patterning defects in the lo- comotory system. Furthermore, we adapt shape mode analysis to study 2D body deformations of wildtype worms, which enables us to characterize two main motility modes: a smooth gliding mode due to the beating of their cilia and an inchworming behavior based on muscle contrac- tions. Additionally, we apply this technique to investigate shape variations between different flatworm species. With this approach, we aim at relating form and function in flatworms. Finally, we investigate the metabolic control of cell turnover and growth. We estab- lish a protocol for accurate measurements of growth dynamics in flatworms. We discern three mechanisms of metabolic energy storage; theoretical descriptions thereof can explain the ob- served organism growth by rules on the cellular scale. From this, we derive specific predictions to be tested in future experiments. In a close collaboration with experimental biologists, we combine minimal theoret- ical descriptions with state-of-the-art experiments and data analysis. This allows us to identify generic principles of scalable body plan patterning and growth control in flatworms. i Zusammenfassung auf Deutsch Die belebte Natur bietet uns zahlreiche faszinierende Beispiele fur die Phanomene von Selbstorganisation und Emergenz. In Vielzellern interagieren Millionen von Zellen miteinander und sind dadurch in der Lage komplexe Korperformen auszubilden und zu unter- halten. Dies verlangt noch einer zuverlassigen Kommunikation zwischen den Zellen auf ver- schiedenen Langenskalen. Einerseits ist stets eine bestimmte Zellanzahl erforderlich, sodass der Korper intakt bleibt und seine Grosse erhalt. Anderseits muss fur einen funktionstuchtigen Korper aber auch der richtige Zelltyp an der richtigen Stelle zu finden sein. In der vorliegenden Dissertation untersuchen wir beide Aspekte, die Kontrolle von Wachstum sowie die selbstor- ganisierte Ausbildung des Korperbaus. Die Dissertation ist inspiriert von den erstaunlichen Skalierungs- und Regene- rationsfahigkeiten von Plattwurmern. Diese Wurmer konnen ihren Korper selbst aus winzigen abgetrennten Fragmenten -- wie etwa der Schwanzspitze -- komplett regenerieren. Daruberhinaus konnen sie auch, je nach Futterungsbedingung, um mehr als das 40fache in der Lange wachsen oder schrumpfen und passen dabei alle Korperteile entsprechend an, wobei deren Funktionalitat erhalten bleibt. Diese Fahigkeiten verlangen nach bemerkenswerten physikali- schen Musterbildungsmechanismen. Zunachst untersuchen wir das Skalierungsverhalten von fruheren Ansatzen zur Beschreibung biologischer Musterbildung. Wir leiten daraus Voraussetzung fur das Skalieren ab und zeigen auf, dass die bekannten Modelle nur begrenzt auf Wachstum und Regeneration von Plattwurmern angewendet werden konnen. Insbesondere diskutieren wir ein wichtiges Modell fur die spontane Entstehung von biologischen Strukturen, das von Alan Turing vorgeschlagen wurde. Wir charakterisieren die Hierarchie von stationaren Zustanden solcher Turing Mechanismen und veranschaulichen, dass diese Turingmuster nicht ohne weiteres skalieren. Daraufhin prasentieren wir eine neuartige Klasse von Musterbildungsmechanis- men, die vollstandig selbstorgansierte und selbstskalierende Muster erzeugen. Unser Ansatz vereint ein Turing System mit den zuvor hergeleiteten Prinzipien fur das Skalieren von Mustern und beschreibt dadurch wesentliche Aspekte der Regeneration und Skalierung von Plattwurmern. Mit Hilfe der Theorie dynamischer Systeme leiten wir allgemeine Merkmale von skalierenden Mustern ab, die wir im Hinblick auf experimentelle Daten diskutieren. Als nachstes analysieren wir Form und Fortbewegung der Wurmer. Die Auswer- tung des Bewegungsverhaltens, nachdem einzelne Gene ausgeschaltet wurden, ermoglicht Ruck- schlussse auf die Bedeutung dieser Gene fur den Bewegungsapparat. Daruber hinaus wenden wir eine Hauptkomponentenanalyse auf die Verformungen des zweidimensionalen Wurmkorpers wahrend der naturlichen Fortbewegung an. Damit sind wir in der Lage, zwei wichtige Fortbe- wegungsstrategien der Wurmer zu charakterisieren: eine durch den Zilienschlag angetriebene gleichmassige Gleitbewegung und eine raupenartige Bewegung, die auf Muskelkontraktionen beruht. Zusatzlich wenden wir diese Analysetechnik auch an, um Unterschiede in der Gestalt von verschiedenen Plattwurmarten zu untersuchen. Grundsatzlich zielen alle diese Ansatze da- rauf ab, das Aussehen der Plattwurmer mit den damit verbundenen Funktionen verschiedener Korperteile in Beziehung zu setzen. ii Schlussendlich erforschen wir den Einfluss des Stoffwechsels auf den Zellaustausch und das Wachstum. Dazu etablieren wir Messungen der Wachstumsdynamik in Plattwurmern. Wir unterscheiden drei Mechanismen fur das Speichern von Stoffwechselenergie, deren theoreti- sche Beschreibung es uns ermoglicht, das beobachtete makroskopische Wachstum des Organis- mus mit dem Verhalten der einzelnen Zellen zu erklaren. Basierend darauf leiten wir Vorher- sagen ab, die nun experimentell getestet werden. In enger Zusammenarbeit mit Kollegen aus der experimentellen Biologie fuhren wir minimale theoretische Beschreibungen mit modernsten Experimenten und Analyse- techniken zusammen. Dadurch sind wir in der Lage, Grundlagen sowohl der skalierbaren Ausbildung des Korperbaus als auch der Wachstumskontrolle bei Plattwurmern herauszuar- beiten. iii Acknowledgements I would like to acknowledge all the people who supported me during my PhD. My special thanks go to: My supervisors Frank Julicher und Benjamin Friedrich for their great support and assistance and for teaching me their inspiring way of doing science. Thanks to Frank Julicher for his enthusiasm about my projects, for always making sure to be available for insightful discussions and advice and generally for all the stimulating input. Thanks to Benjamin Friedrich for his valuable and highly appreciated guidance, for encouraging me to pursue my own ideas and for always being there to help structuring my work, to make sure I stay on track and to provide new food for thoughts. Jochen Rink for being the driving force in this exciting and fruitful colla- boration, for his open-mindedness towards our theoretical ideas and for sharing his visionary thoughts on the flatworm project with us. Thanks also for creating such an enjoyable and inspiring atmosphere in the lab. Tom Stuckemann and Albert Thommen not only for working hard to produce some amazing data but also for sharing this data with me, which triggered major parts of this thesis. Thanks for all the motivating discus- sions and the productive team spirit. Nicole Alt, Johanna Richter and many further student helpers for putting a lot of effort and dedication in taming the beasts under the macro- scope, generating beautiful movies for me to analyze. Sarah Mansour, Olga Frank, James Cleland and Shang-Yun Liu for the exciting times we are having discussing science and beyond. All the other members of the Rink lab for creating such a fun atmos- phere to work in. Lutz Brusch and Michael Kucken for many fruitful discussions during the theory gatherings. iv Daniel Aguilar-Hidalgo for being a motivating sparring partner with respect to the scaling project and for the great time we had developing theories. The summer interns Manuel Beir´an-Amigo and Yihui Quek for the intruiging questions they asked and for their enthusiasm about the flatworm project creating an extra thrust pushing it forward. Ulrike Burkert and many other members of the administration and the IT department for making everything run so smoothly and for the quick and non-bureaucratic help with no matter what question. Vivien Scherr and her colleagues from the library for the great efforts to track down any exotic piece of literature I was asking for. My colleagues and friends for contributing in many ways to provide a great working environment and to make my time at the PKS really enjoy- able. Thanks for all the discussions and the advice about science and life in general, all the coffee breaks, kicker sessions, whisky tastings, tango lessons, movie nights, sciency pub outings ... My parents and my brother Jochen for their enduring support during my whole life and for the great feeling that I always can rely on them. Ruth for all her patience and support, for her understanding of my late night working sessions and for giving me great backup during the final stretch as well as for the proofreading of my thesis. I also gratefully acknowledge the funding by the Max Planck Society and the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF). v Contents 1. Introduction 1.1. Development, growth and regeneration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1.1. From cells to tissues to organisms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1.2. Cellular communication and chemical signals . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1.3. From signals to genes and back . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.1.4. Gene expression can be modified in experiments . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Flatworms as a model organism for scaling, growth and regeneration . . 1.3. Theories of body plan patterning by morphogens . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4. Turing mechanism yields self-organized patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5. Open questions in growth control and scalable body patterning . . . . . 1.6. Organization of the thesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Scaling in morphogen systems 2.1. Scaling of biological patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2. Morphogen dynamics and concentration profiles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. Scaling of concentration profiles with system size . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4. Scaling of morphogen profiles in pre-patterned systems . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.1. The concept of an expander as a chemical size reporter . . . . . 2.4.2. A simple mechanism of gradient scaling: 1 1 2 4 6 8 8 13 16 19 21 22 22 23 24 27 27 The expander-dilution model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 2.4.3. Perfect shape scaling vs. approximate scaling: The expansion-repression model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.4. Other feedback schemes for self-organized gradient scaling . . . . 2.4.5. Conclusions from our analysis of expander models . . . . . . . . 2.5. Revisiting the absence of scaling in Turing patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.1. A hierarchy of steady state solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5.2. Higher order patterns form in larger systems . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 32 32 34 35 38 41 vi Contents 3. Scaling and regeneration of self-organized patterns 3.1. Self-scaling and self-organization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. A minimal model for self-organized pattern scaling . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. Numeric solution shows scaling and pattern regeneration . . . . . . . . . 3.4. Dynamical systems analysis of scaling and regeneration . . . . . . . . . 42 42 43 44 44 3.5. As single source pattern is attractive for a large region of the phase space 50 3.6. Structural robustness for pattern scaling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.7. Signatures of self-scaling patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.8. Comparison to experiments in flatworms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.9. Summary and discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Flatworm shape dynamics and motility 4.1. Modes, movement and morphology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. Worm motility reports on patterning defects upon gene knockout . . . . 4.3. Shape mode analysis of 2D worm outlines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4. Shape dynamics during crawling and inchworming . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.1. A bending mode and two width-changing modes . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2. The second and third modes characterize inch-worming . . . . . 4.5. Discriminating flatworm species by shape . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6. Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Quantitative study of flatworm growth and cell turnover 5.1. Homeostasis is a dynamic steady state . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. Size-dependent growth and degrowth dynamics in flatworms . . . . . . . 5.2.1. Allometric scaling laws . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.2. Characterizing the immediate growth response upon feeding . . . 5.2.3. Small worms grow and degrow faster than large worms . . . . . . 5.3. Theoretical descriptions of cell turnover dynamics and energy flux . . . 5.3.1. Model 1: Dynamic energy storage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.2. Model 2: Fixed proportion energy storage . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.3. Model 3: Size-dependent energy storage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.4. Discussion of the turnover models 5.4. Control logic for cell turnover and growth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.1. Measuring cell turnover on various scales 5.4.2. Analyzing turnover of the epidermis as an example tissue . . . . 5.5. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Summary and outlook 51 53 54 56 58 58 60 63 65 65 66 66 68 70 70 72 72 77 79 83 85 87 89 89 91 91 92 97 98 vii Contents A. Reaction-diffusion systems: fixed points and scaling 102 A.1. Morphogen dynamics with linear degradation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 A.1.1. Reaction, diffusion, advection and dilution . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 A.1.2. Steady state solution neglecting tissue growth . . . . . . . . . . . 102 A.1.3. Relaxation to the steady state . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103 A.1.4. Steady state without morphogen degradation in the source . . . 104 A.2. Gradient scaling with expander . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 104 A.2.1. On the scaling with an autonomously controlled expander . . . . 104 A.2.2. Scaling by expander feedback with a switch-like production . . . 105 A.2.3. Scaling by expander feedback with a graded production . . . . . 106 A.3. Linear stability analysis of a Turing system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107 A.3.1. Eigenvalues of the linearized reaction-diffusion matrix . . . . . . 107 A.3.2. The principle of local activation and lateral inhibition . . . . . . 109 A.4. Motivation for the Hill function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110 A.5. Homogeneous steady state of our Turing system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112 A.6. Inhomogenous steady states of our Turing system . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114 A.6.1. First order steady state solution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114 A.6.2. Source size of the first order steady state . . . . . . . . . . . . . 115 A.6.3. Hierarchy of higher order steady states . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 A.6.4. Stability of the inhomogeneous steady state of our Turing system 117 A.7. On our scalable Turing system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 120 A.7.1. A homogeneous dynamic state for low expander levels . . . . . . 120 A.7.2. Generalized scalable Turing system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 A.7.3. Scaling of downstream targets with a constant amplitude . . . . 121 A.7.4. On knockout experiments in scalable Turing systems . . . . . . . 122 B. On the numerical solution of reaction-diffusion equations 125 B.1. Euler method and Courant criterion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125 B.2. Algorithmic speed-up using a convolution with a Gauss kernel . . . . . . 126 C. Worm handling and measurements of size and shape 129 C.1. Worm handling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 129 C.2. Image acquisition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 129 C.3. Extracting size and shape from worm movies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 130 D. Shape reconstruction and worm bending 132 D.1. On the reconstruction of a closed worm outline . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132 D.2. On the reconstruction of head shapes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132 viii Contents E. On growth and cell turnover 133 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 133 E.1. Signatures of aging in flatworms E.2. Additional size measurements and growth dynamics . . . . . . . . . . . 134 E.3. Measuring cell cycle times . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137 E.4. Measuring cell turnover dynamics on the organism level . . . . . . . . . 138 E.4.1. Measurement of C14 reveals dynamics of neurogenesis in humans 138 E.4.2. Adapting the C14 technique to cell turnover in flatworms . . . . 140 E.4.3. Label dynamics after a single feeding event . . . . . . . . . . . . 142 E.4.4. Challenges and advantages of the application to flatworms . . . . 144 List of Figures List of Variables References 145 147 150 ix 1. Introduction 1.1. Development, growth and regeneration The world around us is populated by a great variety of organisms of very different shapes, sizes and levels of complexity. Many of the most complex organisms, including humans, develop from a single fertilized egg cell, see Fig. 1.1(a). The egg divides multiple times to give rise to the many cells that form the dif- ferent tissues of the adult organism (68, 244). This embryonic development results in a well- defined body plan of the organism, which eventu- ally can reproduce again. One important aspect "Cell and tissue, shell and bone, leaf and flower, ... Their problems of form are in the first in- stance mathematical problems, their problems of growth are essentially physical problems, and the morphologist is, ipso facto, a student of physical science." -- D'Arcy W. Thompson, On Growth and Form, 1945 (217) of development is growth, i.e. the increase in organism size. The growth at the scale of the organism follows from processes at the cellular scale: (i) an increase in cell number by cell division, (ii) an increase in cell size by cellular growth and (iii) an increase in the extra-cellular material (244). During most of its lifetime, an organism maintains shape and function of its body, despite the fact that cells continuously become damaged and get lost (68, 158, 244). This homeostasis requires the sustained addition of new cells by cell division as well as mechanisms of controlled cell death such as apoptosis. Importantly, the turnover processes have to be well orchestrated at the cell, tissue and organism level. Imperfect homeostasis results in aging of the organism (158). Furthermore, many organisms can regenerate after injury to some extent, see Fig. 1.1(b) (68, 184, 244). Regeneration refers to de-novo formation of large parts of tissues and organs that have been damaged or lost. In contrast to embryonic development, which comprises a fixed sequence of morphogenetic events starting from the fertilized egg as a well-defined initial condition, the starting point of regeneration strongly depends on the injury and is thus variable. It is a major question to what extent both processes are guided by the same principles and depend on the same mechanisms (184). The ability to reproduce and the permanent struggle against decay are important cha- racteristics of life in general (192). We are only beginning to understand the respective 1 1. INTRODUCTION Figure 1.1.: (a) Human development starts from a single fertilized egg cell, from which the body plan emerges and grows to its final size. (b) Many multi-cellular organisms like lizards and salamanders can regenerate major parts of their body. processes of development, growth and regeneration in simple model systems with the help of modern molecular biology. In this thesis, we combine minimal theoretical de- scriptions with the analysis of biological data in flatworms as model systems in order to extract fundamental physical principles for body plan patterning and growth control in multicellular organisms. 1.1.1. From cells to tissues to organisms The question of how an organism forms has puzzled natural philosophers and researchers for more than two millennia. It was Aristotle who performed one of the earliest do- cumented experiments in developmental biology in 350 BC (68, 216, 244). He opened chicken eggs at various time intervals after fertilization and observed that the embryo gradually resembles a chicken. The gradual formation of an organism, called epige- nesis, was confronted with the alternative hypothesis of preformation (68, 244). The latter assumes a completely pre-formed miniature body, which then only grows. De- spite the work of Aristotle, the theory of preformation was still prevalent in Europe until the 18th century and is embodied in the idea of the "homunculus", the tiny version 2 1.1 Development, growth and regeneration of a person encapsulated in the sperm cell (68, 228, 244). Later a related discussion arose about the concepts of pre-encoded and emergent complexity, as will be mentioned below (188). The basic building blocks of higher order organisms are the cells, which come at very different shapes and sizes (68, 244). For example, a muscle cell and a blood cell have a completely different appearance and very different properties but they both originate from a single egg cell, which has divided many times to give rise to all the cells of the body (68, 244). The cells become committed to fulfill specific tasks and change their properties during the process of differentiation. Uncommitted cells that can differentiate into other cell types are called stem cells. Often, there are also tissue- specific stem cells that are already partially committed and can only turn into a subset of cell types. In some organisms, differentiated cells are able to de-differentiate into less committed cells (15, 214). During embryonic development and regeneration, cells differentiate and organize in a position dependent manner to form a well-defined body plan. Most modern animals are Bilaterians, characterized by three main body axis, see Fig. 1.2(a): the anterior- posterior axis from tail to head, the dorso-ventral axis from the front to the backside and a mirror symmetric medio-lateral axis (141). Yet, how is the cellular behavior choreographed with respect to this internal coordinate system? With the advancements in light microscopy and the ability to observe microscopic structures, biologists could address this question and perform experiments, in which they selectively perturbed a specific part of an organism in order to reveal its functions in body plan patterning (42, 68, 108, 125, 128, 244). As a result, biological research changed from a descriptive to an experimental science. Here, we will highlight three early experiments by Chabry, Driesch and Morgan to discuss important concepts of morphogenesis. Chabry selectively killed individual cells in the early embryo of the marine invertebrate Tunicate after the first or second cell division with a needle. In consequence, only certain parts of the organism developed, depending on which cells he had destroyed (68, 188). The results were later confirmed by completely removing the two muscle precursor cells of the 8-cell embryo (68, 241). These separated cells became muscle cells by themselves, while the remaining embryo was lacking the muscles. Driesch performed a similar experiment in sea-urchins but obtained completely opposite results (42). He separated the two cells after the first round of cell division and observed that a single cell can develop into a perfectly patterned organism, just of a smaller size. 3 1. INTRODUCTION Figure 1.2.: (a) The bilaterian body plan, for example of a frog, is characterized by three perpendicular axes in anterior-posterior (AP), dorso-ventral (DV) and medio- lateral (ML) direction. (b) Two concepts of morphogenesis: mosaic development based on pre-encoded structures (exemplified by purple cells forming the head), self-organized formation of a body plan as an emergent phenomenon based on mutual interactions between cells. At the same time, Morgan was performing various regeneration experiments especially with the freshwater polyp Hydra and flatworms, and he reported that these animals could re-grow perfectly patterned heads, tails and other body parts after amputation (128). These observations can be discussed in the light of two fundamental concepts of mor- phogenesis, see Fig. 1.2(b) (68, 188): First, the theory of self-differentiation (or mosaic development) builds on the idea of a pre-encoded (hidden) complexity in the early par- titioning of the tissue that then only enfolds. Second, the converse theory (sometimes called conditional specification) considers complexity of the body plan as an emergent phenomenon by the interaction of different parts. Today, we begin to appreciate that embryonic development combines both paradigms. The second one has the appeal to account for regeneration in a natural fashion and will be studied in this thesis in the context of self-organized body plan patterning. 1.1.2. Cellular communication and chemical signals At the end of the 19th and the beginning of the 20th century, the existence of "forma- tive substances" was postulated to control cell fate during development and regenera- tion (128, 129, 174, 188). It was proposed that these substances are found in graded abundance originating from the animal poles as the organizing centers and that they determine polarity and growth of an organism by controlling the cellular behavior (128, 129, 174). Related concepts were built on a "physiological gradient", inspired for example by the fact that the regenerative capability in some flatworm species varies along the body axis from head to tail (36). 4 AMVDPLL(a)(b)pre-encodedself-organized??body planbody plan1.1 Development, growth and regeneration These considerations lead to the notion of morphogens as specific signaling molecules that are secreted in distinct source regions and spread in the tissue. The morphogen concentrations provide chemical cues that control division and differentiation of cells (68, 79, 138, 244). The term was originally coined by Turing, who proposed a purely theoretical mechanism for the spontaneous emergence of chemical patterns as a tem- plate for the body plan layout (221). As a complementary theoretical approach, it was discussed how a pre-existing organizing region can instruct tissue patterning by secretion of morphogens (174, 243). It was proposed that graded concentration profiles provide cells with the information about their position within the tissue. We will dis- cuss a well-known illustration of this idea, the French flag model, in Section 1.3. Next, we provide biological examples for organizing regions and concentration gradients of signaling molecules. Early experiments by Mangold and Spemann found evidence for an organizing region that instructs body plan patterning in the embryo of the frog Xenopus laevis (204). When transplanting the now so-called Spemann organizer into another frog embryo, the latter developed a second perfectly patterned head. Furthermore, experimental evidence for "organizing substances" at the animal poles was found in leaf hoppers (100, 186, 187). After splitting the embryo in a head and a tail fragment, in most cases neither part developed normally. Yet, if substances from the tail tip were moved to the head fragment, the head fragment developed into a complete embryo. Interestingly, also the tail fragment developed further, indicating a concentration-dependent effect of these tail substances. Pioneering work by Nusslein-Volhard and colleagues could identify the protein Bicoid as a signaling molecule in the embryo of the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster and demonstrated its instructive role in tissue patterning, see Fig. 1.3(a) (45, 52, 56). They also visualized its graded concentration profile decreasing from the anterior tip, which could be fitted by an exponential function (43, 44). Additionally, they showed that Bicoid influences cellular behavior in a concentration-dependent manner (44). There are several key signaling systems for patterning and growth control that are widespread across the animal kingdom. Prominent examples belong to the Transform- ing growth factor β (TGF-β) superfamily and to the Wnt family. TGF-β proteins can be found in a wide range of organisms from simple worms to mammals. They control growth, patterning, tissue homeostasis and even the immune system (88). In this thesis, we will encounter four examples of these proteins: Activin in the clawed frog Xenopus (72, 75, 80) and Decapentaplegic (Dpp) in the fruit fly (5, 109, 205, 234), see Fig. 1.3(b), 5 1. INTRODUCTION Figure 1.3.: (a) Bicoid protein gradient (black) in the embryo of the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster at different stages of development (anterior side at the left, modified with permission from (43), scale bar and approximate timing added by the author) (b) Decapentaplegic protein in the imaginal wing disc of the fruit fly labeled by GFP and quantification by GFP fluorescence (green) and GFP immunostaining (red) (modified with permission from (109)). as well as Bone morphogenetic protein (Bmp) and Anti-dorsalizing morphogenic pro- tein (Admp) in flatworms (4, 61). Also Wnt family members are found in organisms from invertebrates to humans (9, 40, 107, 141, 144, 164). The name is a portmanteau of Wingless (the corresponding protein in the fruit fly), and Integration 1 (the homolog originally identified in mammal cancer research). These proteins control the division, differentiation and migration of cells as well as the specification of the main body axes. In this thesis, we especially consider the head-tail polarity in flatworms associated with Wnts. 1.1.3. From signals to genes and back The function of a cell is largely determined by the proteins inside (244). There are several classes of proteins. Housekeeping proteins for the maintenance of the basic cellular functions such as protein synthesis, structural support and cell metabolism are present in all cells under physiological conditions. Other proteins are only found in certain types of cells and are involved in specific tasks such as division, developmental signaling, force generation, sensory perception or immune responses. The blueprint for all proteins is chemically encoded in the genome. The genome consists of Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) macromolecules, in which characteristic base pair sequences (genes) represent the proteins. This genetic information can be read out from the DNA strands by a gene expression pathway as depicted in Fig. 1.4(a). First, the DNA unfolds at the respective gene site and the gene sequence is successively copied 6 (a)(b)00.250.50.751-1001020304050RelativefluorescenceDistance to source boundary [μm]Stage 1 (0 h)Stage 3 (1.5 h)Stage 4 (2 h, midplane)Stage 4 (2 h, surface)100 μm1.1 Development, growth and regeneration Figure 1.4.: (a) Gene expression: proteins are synthesized by transcribing the genetic information saved in the DNA to mRNA molecules, which then act as a blueprint for the protein. (b) Gene expression can be activated or de-activated by signaling molecules (here exemplified for canonical Wnt signaling). In the absence of Wnt molecules, β-catenin is tagged for degradation by a destruction complex, which in- cludes Axin, Adenomatosis polyposis coli (APC), Glycogen synthase kinase 3 (GSK3) and Casein kinase 1α (CK1α). If Wnt is bound to the Frizzled receptors and the Low density lipoprotein receptor-related protein 5 or 6 (LRP5/6), the formation of the destruction complex is suppressed and β-catenin can translocate to the nucleus to act as a co-activator of various genes (68, 143, 244). to a messenger ribonucleic acid strand (mRNA) during a process called transcription. Again a sequence of nitrogenous bases encodes the specific protein. Second, during translation, the mRNA acts as a template for protein synthesis with the help of ribosomes (i.e. large complexes consisting of proteins and RNA strands). All somatic cells (with a few exceptions) are genetically equivalent because they all stem from the same initial egg cell. During cell division, the DNA becomes duplicated and one copy remains in each daughter cell (68, 244). The cells acquire different fates if different genes are activated and thus different proteins are present in the cells. This activation of genes is in turn also controlled by signaling molecules. Fig. 1.4(b) illustrates the signaling cascade of canonical Wnts as an example. In the absence of Wnt molecules, β-catenin is tagged for degradation by a destruction complex involving several molecules such as Adenomatous poluposis coli (APC) and Axin. Upon binding of Wnt molecules to the Frizzled receptors and co-receptors (LRP5/6), Axin is recruited to the membrane and the formation of the destruction complex is suppressed. Thus, β-catenin can accumulated and reach the nucleus, where it acts as a transcription co-activator for specific target genes. In effect, Wnt has an activating effect on the expression of these target genes. The resulting proteins can fulfill certain tasks for the cell in which they have been 7 DNAmRNAnucleustranscriptionproteinribosometranslation(a)(b)target genetarget geneWnttranscriptionrepressorstarget geneWntFrizzledLRP5/6β-cateninβ-cateninβ-cateninβ-cateninβ-cateninDishevelledAxinAxinAPCβ-cateninGSK3CK1αtranscrip.factorstranscrip.factors1. INTRODUCTION synthesized, yet they can also be released and act as morphogens to activate or de- activate parts of the genome in other cells. This realizes positive and negative feedback loops, from which complex cellular signaling networks are built. 1.1.4. Gene expression can be modified in experiments Experimentalists can interfere with the synthesis of specific proteins by exploiting the control and error correction machinery of the cells, which ensures robustness of the important processes of DNA duplication, transcription and translation and modifies their outcome (68). One such mechanism is RNA interference (RNAi), for which small interfering RNA (siRNA) pieces are used by the cell to target specific mRNA strands, mainly for destruction (6). For example, this can be an immune response against exoge- nous RNA introduced by viruses. Similarly, experimentalists can artificially suppress a protein of choice by introducing a RNA sequence for this protein in the cell. Such RNAi techniques are applied to obtain some of the data presented in this thesis. 1.2. Flatworms as a model organism for scaling, growth and regeneration Classic experiments on flatworm regeneration already inspired the idea of morpho- genetic gradients (36, 128, 129). In recent years, the flatworm Schmidtea mediterranea (Smed ) has become increasingly popular as a model organism to study regeneration and growth, aging, and even behavior (63, 140, 151, 158, 162, 179, 183, 198, 212). There are many different flatworm species populating very diverse habitats all around the world. They are found in saltwater, in freshwater and in the soil; some live more than 1000 m under the sea and some parasitic species (like flukes and tapeworms) in the body of other organisms (151, 170, 179, 202). Smed is a non-parasitic flatworm living in freshwater. Such free-living species are sometimes also referred to as "planarians" (50). Flatworms (Greek: Platyhelminthes) bridge the gap between other model organisms of lower complexity such as the freshwater polyp Hydra and the C. elegans worm and those of higher complexity, such as fruit fly, clawed frog, axolotl, zebrafish and mouse (184, 244), see Fig. 1.5. Many members of the flatworm phylum seem to represent the most evolved organisms that are still able to regenerate any part of their body (50, 128, 140, 184). For example, Smed can restore its complete body plan from amputation 8 1.2 Flatworms as a model organism for scaling, growth and regeneration Figure 1.5.: Flatworms are the most complex model organisms that can still regene- rate every tissue. This regeneration capability is shared with simpler organisms such as Hydra. At the same time, flatworms possess organ systems like a centralized nervous system and two distinct brain lobes, which are characteristic for the most complex organisms (50, 68, 128, 140, 143, 184, 244). fragments as tiny as the very tip of the tail with only about 104 cells (126). By re-growing missing body parts and re-modeling oversized organs, they recover their normal shape scaled to the size of the amputation fragment within 1-2 weeks (4, 170). This astonishing regeneration capability is comparable to the much simpler Hydra and distinguishes flatworms from other model organisms with much less body plan plasticity (158, 184). Thereby, the body plan of Smed shows already key characteristics that are usually asso- ciated with higher order organisms (140), see Fig. 1.6. The bilaterally symmetric Smed possess a central nervous system with a distinct bilobed brain and two ventral nerve cords connected by commissural neurons (69, 95, 165, 170, 171, 183). The sensory sys- tem processes information from chemo-, rheo- and photorecetors leading to a complex behavioral repertoire (69, 95, 153, 171). Their usual mode of motility is a gliding motion on a secreted layer of mucus being propelled by the beating of numerous short flagella (or cilia) that project from their multi-ciliated ventral epithelium (8, 169, 179, 180). However the worms also use the numerous muscles situated along their inner body wall for (i) steering, (ii) quick escape responses, (ii) exploratory head motion and (iv) a back-up movement strategy (152, 153, 169, 180, 220). 9 AxolotlZebrafishClawed frogFruit flyC. elegansHydraMouseFlatworm"Complexity"Regeneration capabilityHydra:regenerates even from cell aggregatesno regeneration, rigid lineagevery limited regeneration in the embryoregeneration very limited and only in tadpolesregeneration of major body parts like limbs, heart, spinal cord, brainregeneration of major body parts like fin, heart, spinal cordregeneration limited to some tissues like liverregeneration of all body partsC. elegans:Flatworm:Fruit fly:Clawed frog:Axolotl:Zebrafish:Mouse:1. INTRODUCTION Figure 1.6.: The body plan of the flatworm Schmidtea mediterranea (Smed ) shows already key characteristics that are usually associated with higher order organisms (37, 51, 171, 173, 231, 245). Smed belong to the taxon Tricladida, which is reflected by the fact that their highly ramified gut splits in three main branches (69, 140, 165, 170), see Fig. 1.6(b). During feeding, the carnivorous worms suck in food through their extensible pharynx opening. After digestion, the pharynx also functions as an anus for excretion. Protonephridia constitute a further part of the excretory system, which performs similar functions as the kidneys in humans (171). Turnover, growth and regneration completely relies on a pool of stem cells called neoblasts. The fraction of neoblasts among all cells had been estimated to be as large as 25− 35% (15, 16, 17, 18). If the worms are depleted of all neoblasts by γ-irradiation, they will show a regression of the body starting from the head and finally they fall apart (15, 46, 159, 170). The time scale until the decay sets in varies between species in the range from several days to a few weeks (46, 159). This indicates that there is no de-differentiation of cells to restore the stem cell pool. A subpopulation of neoblasts is pluripotent (and maybe even totipotent) and can develop into every other cell type (15, 63, 84, 140, 158, 170). Wagner et al. have shown that irradiated worms can be res- cued by transplanting a single pluripotent neoblast from an intact worm (229). Even though neoblasts are well defined by their progression through the cell cycle resul- ting in cell division, there is increasing evidence that the neoblast population is not 10 (a) locomotory and sensory system(b) digestive and excretory system(c) hermaphrodite reproductive systemeye spotsbrain lobesventral nerve cordscilia(mostly ventral)pharynx (ventral)gutprotonephridiaovariestestescopulatory organs1.2 Flatworms as a model organism for scaling, growth and regeneration homogeneous (85, 132, 194, 225). Most likely, they also comprise lineage-restricted subpopulations and transiently amplifying cells that go through a few more rounds of cell division during differentiation. Smed show both sexual and asexual reproduction (48, 140, 170, 183). Some strains are hermaphrodites, which develop testes and ovaries symmetrically along their body axis as well as copulatory organs for cross-fertilization, see Fig. 1.6(c). In contrast, asexual strains do not possess a reproductive system and reproduce by fissioning: the worm attaches its tail to the substrate and glides on until the body is ripped into two or more pieces, which develop into new worms after regeneration (140). Fissioning depends strongly on the environmental conditions, in particular on temperature, feeding, light and worm density (48, 131, 140, 161). For example, fissioning frequency is reduced in crowded envi- "Wenn einem beim Duell ein Ohr oder sonst ein Glied abgeschlagen wurde, so wuchs inner- halb von acht Tagen erstens ein neues Ohr an den Menschen und zweitens ein neuer Mensch an das Ohr. ... Wer sich vermehren wollte, schnitt sich zum Beispiel einen oder zwei oder zehn Finger ab und wartete acht Tage lang." -- Joachim Ringelnatz, Abseits der Geogra- phie, 1924 (168) ronments. Like regeneration abilities, reproduction strategies also vary widely among flatworm species (50). In particular, one observes various approaches to asexual repro- duction. Some species like Smed first split and regenerate afterwards, others already grow the respective organs of the new body plan before fissioning. The second stra- tegy comes in two forms: as paratomy with the new body aligned to the old axis and budding with a non-aligned outgrowth at the side or pointing backward. Smed are well-suited model organisms to study growth and cell turnover. First, all somatic cells are continuously replaced by cell turnover at a time scale of weeks (158, 170). Second, growth and cell turnover rely completely on the division of a large population of neoblasts, some of which are pluripotent (15, 63, 85, 140, 158, 170). Third, depending on feeding conditions, the worms can grow and actively shrink (usually referred to as "degrow"), while scaling their body plan over more than one order of magnitude in length in the range of 0.5 mm to 2 cm (140, 151, 170), see Fig. 1.7(a). Active degrowth enables the worms to survive long starvation periods of several months. It has been suggested that worms recycle apoptotic material during degrowth to fuel the metabolism of the remaining cells (69, 70). Smed are also well-suited to study scalable patterning during growth and regeneration. Being able to reversibly grow by a factor of 40 in length and perfectly regenerate even from scrambled body fragments prompts for patterning mechanisms that are not only highly robust and self-organizing but also functional across a wide range in sizes, 11 1. INTRODUCTION Figure 1.7.: Growth and regeneration in flatworms: (a) Schmidtea mediterranea (Smed ) can reversibly grow over a 40fold range depending on feeding conditions (Im- ages taken by Nicole Alt under the supervision of the author). (b) Amputation frag- ments regenerate to form a perfectly shaped worm within 2 weeks (green lines mark the cuts, white tissue parts indicate the regeneration site before all pigments have been reestablished, modified with permission from (116)). see Fig. 1.7. For example, regeneration comprises a tightly controlled sequence of responses (4, 10, 13, 14, 69, 81, 117, 128, 158, 165, 170, 237). After an immediate muscle contraction to close the wound, a peak in cell division together with the migration of stem cells within the first 12 h generates an outgrowth of undifferentiated tissue at the wound site, the blastema. In a second step, the now oversized, remaining body parts are re-patterned to match the size of the amputation fragment. The corresponding process is called morphollaxis and comprises a more sustained proliferation and cell death response during the following days. All this pattern formation is guided by an internal coordinate system that is re-established as one of the earliest cues in the remaining worm fragment independently of cell differentiation (81, 141). Our work is especially focussed on the anterior-posterior (AP) axis specifying head and tail position. The Wnt/β-catenin system is a conserved pathway for such AP patterning in many animals and it is also key for the AP polarity in flatworms (4, 9, 54, 81, 82, 141, 160). There are 9 Wnt genes in flatworms. In particular the canonical Wnts (activating β-catenin signaling) are highly expressed in the tail. Inhibition of the Wnt/β-catenin system leads to formation of additional heads, while overexpression induces tail identity everywhere in the worm (3, 82, 82, 160). Remarkably, reducing the level of β-catenin is sufficient to induce full regenerative power to some flatworm species that are usually deficient in head regeneration (116, 200, 222). Taken together, the experiments suggest that β-catenin is instructive for positional information along the AP axis in a concentration-dependent manner. 12 1mm(a)(b)Growth and DegrowthRegeneration1.3 Theories of body plan patterning by morphogens Perpendicular to the AP axis, the dorsal-ventral (DV) axis and the medial-lateral (ML) axis are formed (54, 117). For example, the DV axis is specified by the interplay between the TGF-β family members Bmp and Admp. Together, all three body axes are charac- terized by gradients in abundance and expression of specific molecules, in neoblast mitotic activity as well as in membrane potential (4, 9, 23, 62, 81, 149, 201) and it is a major open question how these gradients robustly guide body plan patterning irre- spective of the size of the organism. 1.3. Theories of body plan patterning by morphogens Here, we will discuss two ideas of pattern formation based on cell-cell communication via morphogens. The first type of mechanisms describes how a pre-existing structure can act as an organizing center for the development of further patterns. Such theories are built on the idea of a well-defined, sequential developmental program where existing patterns determine the formation of new patterns, see Fig. 1.8(a). Maternal patterning cues provide a pre-pattern for the embryonic tissues forming from an egg cell and the layout in the embryo determines the future body plan of the animal (2, 57, 172). For example the localization of bicoid mRNA to the anterior pole of the fly embryo is a maternal effect. However, the impressive capabilities of flatworms to regenerate from almost arbitrary initial fragments challenge these concepts, see Fig. 1.8(b). In contrast to the sequential patterning from predefined cues, Alan Turing introduced a second class of mechanisms for self-organized pattern formation (221). We will discuss both approaches and assess them from a biological perspective. Body plan patterning requires that cell fates are assigned depending on the relative position of the cells in the tissue or the organism (68, 244). In order to obtain the information about their spatial position, cells sense their environment and communicate with each other. For that, cells respond to mechanical cues as well as chemical signals such as morphogens (89, 112, 147, 174, 224). Signaling molecules often establish long-range, graded concentration profiles, which can be accounted for by the interplay of transport and degradation (76, 223, 232). Cells respond to the concentration of these molecules in their local environment. Thus, a graded morphogen concentration can provide cells with the information about its spatial distance from the morphogen source (243), see Fig. 1.9(a). This idea forms the basis for the French flag model, which draws a simplified picture of how body plan patterning might be guided by graded morphogen profiles. For example, a stripe pattern can be 13 1. INTRODUCTION Figure 1.8.: (a) Idea of sequential development: The emerging tissues in the fertilized egg determine the future body plan of the juvenile chicken and later of the adult hen. Finally maternal signals break again the spatial symmetry in the new egg and guide development of another chicken. (b) Regeneration in flatworms: Diverse initial fragments are repatterned to form the same body plan scaled to fragment size. generated if cellular differentiation depends on discrete, genetically encoded threshold levels. In Fig. 1.9(a), cells turn blue if the morphogen concentration is above the first threshold level and red if it is below the second threshold level. Several intersecting gradients can generate more complex patterns. Dose-dependent responses have indeed been observed in experiments, yet in a more complex way than given by the simplified French flag model (72, 74, 75, 80, 104, 191, 242). For example, cells of the frog Xenopus show a distinct differentiation response to at least five concentration thresholds of Activin (72, 75). However, the early response of the individual cells is less specific and very inhomogeneous (73, 242). It appears that only the interaction between cells leads to the well-defined behavior of the cell aggregate. Furthermore, the cells in the tissue are reported to respond in a ratchet-like manner to the highest level of Activin to which they were exposed (80). Similar dose- dependent responses have also been recently reported for Wnts in the frog embryo with respect to the AP axis patterning (104). Thus, although the simple concept of a direct threshold-comparison has been questioned in some organisms, the French flag model continues to provide a pictorial representa- tion of the case where a feedback on the concentration gradient by the responding cells can be neglected. As an extension, it also has been proposed that the cells might com- pare spatial and temporal differences in morphogen concentration and correspondingly adjust cell division, differentiation and motility (135, 167, 175, 233, 234, 235). The described mechanisms can explain patterning, given a pre-defined source region where morphogens are produced locally. Yet, how is this source region established in the first place? One possibility is that another graded morphogen profile specified 14 (a)(b)1.3 Theories of body plan patterning by morphogens Figure 1.9.: (a) The French flag model substantiates the idea that a graded mor- phogen profile provides positional information for cells in a tissue. Specifically, cells adopt distinct cell fates (sketched blue, white, red) by responding to the local mor- phogen concentration depending on whether a certain threshold is met. The model assumes a pre-defined source region (grey), which secretes the morphogens. (b) In a Turing system, at least two chemical species (morphogen 1 and 2, red and blue) interact. Source regions (gray) of the morphogens are established in a self-organized way (here: a source forms where the concentration of the first morphogen is larger than the concentration of the second morphogen). this source by a threshold rule and a sequential developmental program establishes one pattern from an already existing one, see Fig. 1.8(a). An alternative explanation dates back to Alan Turing. In a seminal paper from 1952, he proposed a general framework for the spontaneous formation of biological patterns, independent of pre-patterning cues (221). Turing's framework was later further explored by Meinhardt and Gierer (64, 65, 66, 106, 120). Turing demonstrated how the interaction of at least two diffusing molecular species can result in chemical patterns in a completely self-organized manner, see Fig. 1.9(b). Thereby, these (often periodic) patterns specify their own production regions. It is an appealing idea that the chemical patterns layout the body plan of an animal. Yet for the following 50 years, there was only little experimental evidence for Turing's ideas and the focus of developmental biology was shifted to other patterning mechanisms like the French flag model (74). Certainly this was partly due to the fact that it is generally difficult to demonstrate experimentally that a specific pattern is generated by a Turing mechanism. While a unidirectional relationship like in the French flag model (where a concentration of one molecule has a particular effect on other molecules or the cells) is straight forward to analyze, this is less so for Turing patterning which includes cross-reaction terms. The behaviour of a Turing system is often counterintuitive and its analysis might easily yield misleading results. For example, the concentration of some 15 morphogen concentrationthreshold level 1threshold level 2(a)(b)Pre-patterned: morphogencellsSelf-organized:morphogen 1morphogen concentrationsmorphogen 21. INTRODUCTION Turing molecules peak at the maximum concentration of their repressors, compare to Section 1.4. Furthermore, if there are more than two chemical species involved, the con- centration of one of them might decrease upon knockout of its direct activator because of additional indirect effects, see Appendix A.7.4 for an example. Despite the chal- lenging task of revealing the existence of Turing patterns and identifying the involved molecules, recently more and more evidence has been accumulated that Turing's ideas might be the guiding principles for the formation of a wide range of biological patterns, ranging from the formation of digits in vertebrate limbs to the emergence of left-right asymmetry (49, 119, 134, 137, 164, 191, 197). Some of these examples combine Turing patterning with a French flag model. In fact, in many biological systems, pattern formation might result from a combination of both concepts (74). The feedback loop of a Turing mechanism ensures high robust- ness and possesses the ability to generate chemical patterns from random fluctuations. In particular, Turing systems can spontaneously generate graded concentration profiles like required for the French flag model. In turn, biological patterns hardly emerge in a completely homogeneous environment without any pre-patterning cues, as Turing al- ready remarked (221). During development as well as during regeneration, pre-existing morphogen profiles and tissue structures can guide the formation of chemical patterns. Thus, Turing mechanisms might often be found downstream of morphogen profiles that modify the respective patterns (74, 164). 1.4. Turing mechanism yields self-organized patterns In 1952, Alan Turing introduced a generic framework for the self-organized formation of chemical patterns in biology (221). He asked the very general question whether there are conditions, under which a system of two or more diffusing and reacting chemical species possesses a homogeneous steady state, which is linearly unstable with respect to inhomogeneous perturbations, such that inhomogeneous patterns form spontaneously. Very importantly, in consequence, any model for self-organized patterning based on diffusing and cross-reacting molecules can be understood within the Turing framework (64, 65, 120, 147, 195, 221). Recently, there are attempts to further generalize the Turing mechanism to generic interactions between two players without a diffusion term (136, 236). In the following we show that the conditions for a Turing instability can be derived from the linear stability analysis of the homogeneous steady state. For this, we briefly 16 1.4 Turing mechanism yields self-organized patterns recall the basic Turing model comprising two chemical species with concentrations A and B. Details on the derivations are provided in Appendix A.3 or in the literature (64, 65, 146, 195, 221). The general reaction-diffusion system for two molecular species in one space dimension is ∂tA = RA(A, B) + DA ∂2 ∂tB = RB(A, B) + DB ∂2 x A x B , (1.1) with diffusion coefficients DA and DB and two generic functions RA and RB describing the reactions between the different molecules and the effects of each molecular species on itself. In order to spontaneously form stable patterns from random fluctuations, h, B∗ these reaction functions have to fulfill two requirements: the homogenous steady state (A∗ h) = 0, has to be (i) stable with respect to homogeneous perturbations (to avoid a diverging behavior), yet (ii) unstable h), defined by RA(A∗ h) = 0 and RB(A∗ h, B∗ h, B∗ with respect to inhomogeneous perturbations. It is possible to derive a set of necessary conditions for spontaneous pattern formation from these two conditions above by applying linear stability analysis. For this, we consider a small perturbation (a, b) about the homogeneous steady state: A = A∗ and B = B∗ h + b. The linearized form of Eq. 1.1 can be written as h + a . (1.2) (cid:32)as (cid:33) ∂t bs = Ms (cid:32)as (cid:33) bs (cid:90) (cid:90) Here, the perturbation modes as(t) and bs(t) with wavenumber s represent the spatial Fourier transform of a(t, x) and b(t, x), respectively: as(t) = a(x, t) e−2πsx/L dx , bs(t) = b(x, t) e−2πsx/L dx (1.3) The matrix Ms is given by (cid:32)∂ARA − DA(2πs/L)2 ∂ARB (cid:33) , (1.4) ∂BRA ∂BRB − DB(2πs/L)2 Ms = h, B = B∗ h. where derivatives are evaluated at A = A∗ In order to fulfill the two conditions on the stability above, (i) the real parts of both eigenvalues qI s of the matrix Ms have to be negative for s = 0 and (ii) at least one has to be positive for s (cid:54)= 0. As shown in Appendix A.3, this results in the following conditions for the trace Tr and the determinant Det of the matrix Ms: s and qII Tr[M0] < 0 , Det[M0] > 0 and ∃ s > 0 with Det[Ms] < 0 . (1.5) 17 1. INTRODUCTION Figure 1.10.: There are two possible feedback topologies that lead to pattern for- mation in a Turing system with two molecular species (A and B): (a) an activator- inhibitor scheme with activator A and inhibitor B, (b) a second topology where both chemical species have activating and inhibiting effects. We show two examples of typical concentration profiles corresponding to the two feedback topologies. The self- organized source regions are indicated in gray. In consequence, we obtain several constraints on the reaction design, which have been summarized by the principle of local activation and lateral inhibition (64, 65, 120, 146, 147), see Appendix A.3 for details and Fig. 1.10 for illustration of the allowed feedback topologies. The necessary conditions for spontaneous pattern formation are: 1. One molecule has to be self-activating and the other self-inhibiting. In the following, we choose A to be the self-activator and B the self-inhibitor: 2. There have to be cross-reaction terms of opposing sign: (cid:16) ∂ARB ∂BRA < 0 ∂ARA > 0 and ∂BRB < 0 . (cid:17)(cid:16) (cid:17) (1.6) (1.7) 3. The diffusion coefficient of the self-activator has to be sufficiently smaller than the diffusion coefficient of the self-inhibitor: DA < DB . (1.8) As a result for a Turing system with two chemical species, there are two possible network topologies as depicted in Fig. 1.10. In Turing feedback 1, the concentration A has only 18 (a)(b)Morphogen concentrationPositionPositionsource of A & BMorphogen concentrationsource of AFeedback 1Feedback 21.5 Open questions in growth control and scalable body patterning activating effects and B has only inhibiting effects both on itself and the respective other player. In this case, we can shortly refer to A and B as the concentrations of activator and inhibitor instead of self-activator and self-inhibitor. In Turing feedback 2, both molecular species have activating and inhibiting effects. This includes depletion models, where, for example, binding of both molecular species enhances the production of A but consumes B (66). Note that there is a formal correspondence between the two Turing topologies by the replacement B → Bc − B with a constant parameter Bc. How the principle of local activation and lateral inhibition leads to spontaneous pat- tern formation can be nicely demonstrated for the Turing feedback 1 of Fig. 1.10(a). At the source, the activator dominates because the inhibitor is diffusing away more quickly. Consequently, the source region stabilizes itself and initially tends to expand. In contrast, some distance away from the source, the inhibitor dominates due to its fast diffusion. This creates at least two distinct regions, which already comprises a simple pattern. In contrast to other systems where diffusion homogenizes a pattern, here dif- fusive spreading in combination with specific reactions enhances small inhomogeneities in the concentrations. Therefore, it is sometimes also referred to as a diffusion-driven instability (145, 146, 181). 1.5. Open questions in the study of growth control and scalable body patterning During development, growth and regeneration, cells communicate with each other and mutually influence their behavior, especially by changing the expression status of their genes. This information exchange orchestrates cell division, cell death and differen- tiation. It can also guide cell migration and can elicit the release of further signals, e.g. the secretion of morphogens. As a common theme of this thesis, we devise theo- retical descriptions of how cell fate decisions based on local rules on the microscopic scale result in the formation and maintenance of a macroscopic body plan, drawing inspiration from flatworms as a specific model organism. In particular, we address the following questions: How is the turnover of cells regulated during growth and homeostasis and how are fluxes in cell number related to fluxes of metabolic energy? Organisms have to control the number of cells to ensure homeostasis and growth in a well-defined manner. As changes in cell number depend on the balance between cell proliferation and cell loss, there needs to be a communication between dividing and differentiated 19 1. INTRODUCTION cells (158). Furthermore, the environment and in particular the availability of food provides an external stimulus to influence cell behavior, such as proliferation and cell death (113, 244). What are minimal requirements for self-organized patterns that scale with organism size? Organisms also have to control the type and position of cells for a reliable body plan patterning. Again, this requires a communication between cells, ranging from direct neighbor-neighbor interactions to long range signaling via mobile molecules such as morphogens (54, 68, 244). Importantly, pattern formation can be observed on all length scales from the development of a fertilized egg to growth and regeneration of large scale tissues in mature organisms. Yet, patterning mechanisms of- ten possess fixed characteristic length scales defined by the intrinsic physical properties of the system (76, 223, 232), which is challenged by cases of biological pattern scaling like regeneration in flatworms. We aim to understand scalable body plan patterning and cell turnover dynamics by building on the framework of dynamical systems theory and birth-death processes. Biological systems add a new perspective to those classical concepts. They usually operate far from equilibrium and form patterns with unconventional properties (39, 87, 120). Development and regeneration are subject to a high level of noise ranging from external perturbation like a variable environment to the intrinsically stochastic nature of gene expression (77, 218, 219). Thus, robust growth control and body plan patterning require reliable sensing, transmitting and processing of noisy information (47, 218). We address the question of robustness with respect to initial conditions and physical parameters as well as the structural robustness of the models. This thesis is mainly inspired by the astonishing scaling and regeneration capabilities of flatworms, yet the results obtained here are likely also to be relevant for other bio- logical organisms as well as related questions in biological physics, nonlinear dynamics and pattern formation. 20 1.6 Organization of the thesis 1.6. Organization of the thesis In this thesis, we investigate biological shape and size control on various levels, for which we combine theoretical descriptions and state-of-the-art analyses of experimental data in flatworms. First, we explore mechanisms for self-organized and self-scaling pattern formation (Chapter 2). We discuss to what extent previously proposed theories can account for the scaling of morphogen profiles. For this, we adhere to a strict mathematical definition of scaling and illustrate the difference between perfect scaling and approxi- mate scaling with system size. Furthermore, we demonstrate the absence of scaling in classical Turing pattering, going beyond linear stability analysis. Second, flatworms like Smed challenge existing theories on body plan patterning, which typically can at most only explain one of both: either scaling or self-organization. Here, we introduce and characterize a novel class of mechanisms that combine both features (Chapter 3). The developed theory can act as a framework to understand robust body plan scaling during growth and regeneration in flatworms. Next, worm shape variations cannot only be observed between different stages of de- velopment, growth and regeneration. Individual worms also show large body deforma- tion during movement, driven by muscle contractions. We apply a method based on "Principal component analysis" to characterize shape dynamics and analyze movement patterns. A similar shape mode analysis also enables us to compare shapes of different related species. Analyzing motility patterns and comparing shape variations between worm species is the first step towards relating form and function (Chapter 4). Finally, we analyze growth and degrowth dynamics and their dependence on feeding conditions. We investigate mechanisms for size control by metabolic energy balances to explain the macroscopic growth and degrowth behavior in terms of microscopic cell turnover dynamics. Our theory makes testable predictions for the ongoing experiments. Beyond, we develop the theoretical basis for additional measurements on various scales to reveal further details about the control logic of cell turnover (Chapter 5). 21 2. Scaling in morphogen systems 2.1. Scaling of biological patterns The development of multi-cellular organisms with a well-defined, complex body plan is one of the most fascinating processes in nature. A series of patterning events take place "The continuous change in form that takes place from hour to hour puzzles us by its very simpli- city. The geometric patterns that present them- selves at every turn invite mathematical analy- sis." -- Experimental embryology, Thomas H. Morgan, 1927 (130) across various length scales leading to a distinct layout, which is scaled to match the size of the organism. The scaling of body plan patterns be- comes especially apparent if a juvenile organism already resembles its adult counterpart or if indi- viduals of different, yet related species look very much alike besides their great differences in size (27, 76, 223). A third, more subtle example is the robust formation of proportionate patterns in the same organism during development despite size variations that arise from varying environmental conditions or stochastic fluctuations of growth rates (24, 76). In this chapter, we analyze to what extent previously proposed theories can account for pattern scaling. First, we introduce a mathematical definition of gradient scaling. Based on these considerations, we revisit and assess scaling mechanisms proposed for morphogen gradients in pre-patterned systems and extract the main principles under- lying scaling. This will later allow us to point out the important differences between scaling mechanisms for pre-patterned and self-organized systems in Chapter 3. Fur- thermore, we discuss the absence of scaling in self-organized Turing systems beyond the classical approach of linear stability analysis. The latter has been published in Werner et al. (239). 22 2.2 Morphogen dynamics and concentration profiles 2.2. Morphogen dynamics and concentration profiles One of the most simple morphogen systems that result in graded concentration profiles draws on diffusion from a localized source with an effective diffusion coefficient D and a linear degradation with rate β (232). It has been frequently applied to describe mor- phogen gradients in the fruit fly (24, 44, 76, 78, 234). Note that effective diffusion might result from a wide range of underlying undirected processes, such as active transport or even signaling between neighboring cells without secretion of motile molecules. For simplicity, we consider a one-dimensional system of size L with reflecting boundary conditions. The corresponding time evolution of the morphogen concentration C = C(t, x) is given by x C − β C + ν ∂tC = D ∂2 ∂xCx=0 = ∂xCx=L = 0 . (2.1) (2.2) Here, ν(x) = α Θ(w − x) describes localized morphogen production with rate α in a source of width w. Θ denotes the Heaviside step function. Eq. 2.1 also holds in two and three dimensions, if the system is symmetric with respect to the other dimensions and, thus, the morphogen concentration still only depends on x, see Appendix A.1.1. If the tissue grows at a time scale comparable to the time scale of the morphogen dynamics, one has to consider additional terms for advection and dilution. The steady state solution to Eq. 2.1-2.2 is computed in Appendix A.1.2. Here, we are mainly concerned with the steady state concentration outside the source region, which is given by with amplitude C∗(x) = C0 cosh(L/λ − x/λ) cosh(L/λ) for w ≤ x ≤ L and a characteristic length scale C0 = α sinh(w/λ) β tanh(L/λ) λ =(cid:112)D/β . (2.3) (2.4) (2.5) Within the course of a characteristic time scale (which is of the order of 1/β in our example, see Appendix A.1.3), the morphogen will relax towards this steady state pro- file. Analyzing the steady state is well justified in a case of separated time scales, where other dynamics (e.g. growth and differentiation) are slow in comparison to the relaxation time of the morphogen profile. In the following, we will often assume such 23 2. SCALING IN MORPHOGEN SYSTEMS a quasi steady state. One should keep in mind that this is a simplifying assumption which is not always fulfilled. In fact, it has been argued that many gradients might be already read out before the steady state is reached as a means to increase robustness (20, 29, 55, 167). Yet, even in these cases, the steady state is the reference state and provides a first order approximation to the concentration the cells actually respond to. 2.3. Scaling of concentration profiles with system size Profiles of signaling molecules have been measured for example in the fruit fly Droso- phila melanogaster, which is an important model organism to study biological pattern formation (123, 206). Quantifications of morphogen concentrations in the developing wing and eye of the fly at different stages of development revealed that the concentration profiles maintain an approximately constant shape relative to the changing size of the growing tissue (26, 83, 234, 235). This biological observation of profiles that scale with system size inspired the development of a number of theoretical mechanisms that can account for pattern scaling (11, 24, 26, 27, 96, 135, 148, 154, 223, 233, 234). In this section, we discuss examples, which represent two major classes of these mechanisms. We define a mathematical property of perfect shape scaling and analyze approximations of this property. We define perfect shape scaling as the ideal case of strictly proportional scaling of a concentration profile with system size. In this case, the concentration at steady state can be written as C(x; L) = C0(L) · Z(x/L) , (2.6) where C0(L) denotes a possibly size-dependent amplitude and Z(x/L) defines the shape of the profile, which only depends on the relative spatial coordinate x/L. As a result, scaling profiles from systems of different sizes perfectly collapse onto a single master curve if plotted as a function of relative coordinates and normalized by their amplitude, see Fig. 2.1(a). For the steady state solution in Eq. 2.3, perfect shape scaling arises if the characteristic gradient range λ is not constant but strictly proportional to the length of the system L: λ ∝ L . (2.7) In a more general case, if the length scale λ increases with L in a monotonic, yet nonlinear fashion, we will classify this as approximate scaling, see Fig. 2.1(b): ∂Lλ > 0 . (2.8) 24 2.3 Scaling of concentration profiles with system size Figure 2.1.: Illustration of the mathematical concept of perfect shape scaling and approximate scaling: (a) Perfect shape scaling: normalized concentration profiles col- lapse onto a master curve when plotted as a function of the relative position. (b) In a more general case, concentration profiles might expand with system size, though the collapse onto a single master curve is only approximate. We classify this case as approximate scaling. In the following, we will strictly distinguish between the two notions of approximate scaling and perfect shape scaling. This slightly academic distinction will prove use- ful in the subsequent mathematical analysis. Nonetheless, we want to emphasize that approximate scaling can be virtually indistinguishable from the ideal case of perfect shape scaling, both in measurements and simulations. In contrast to our theoretical description, real systems are generally prone to intrinsic fluctuations and measurement inaccuracies. Furthermore, the separation of time scales between system growth and morphogen dynamics assumed here will always be an approximation, such that the mor- phogen concentration never exactly corresponds to the theoretically computed steady state profile. Therefore, even if the underlying mechanism is in principle able to gener- ate profiles that perfectly scale like in Fig. 2.1, we will never observe a perfect collapse of the measured concentration profiles. On the contrary, mechanisms of approximate scal- ing that cannot yield perfect shape scaling in the sense of Eq. 2.6, may still fully account 25 Perfect shape scaling:PositionRel. ConcentrationRel. ConcentrationRelative positionPositionRel. ConcentrationRel. ConcentrationRelative positionApproximate scaling:(a)(b)2. SCALING IN MORPHOGEN SYSTEMS Figure 2.2.: Size-dependent amplitudes of scaling profiles: Models for the scaling of morphogen profiles often assume the adjustment of degradation rate β or diffusion coefficient D with system size L. As a result, the amplitude of the morphogen concen- tration might change depending on whether the morphogen source size (gray) is fixed (upper row) or scales with L (lower row). The reference profile (red) is the same in all plots (Eq. 2.3, α/β = 10, L/λ = 2, L/w = 5). The other profiles correspond to either half (blue) or twice the system size (green) with constant ratio L/λ and either scaling or non-scaling source size w. for gradient scaling as observed in biological systems. As an example for a mechanism that yields approximate scaling, we discuss a simple realization of a prominent scaling mechanism, the expansion-repression model. We emphasize that this mechanism has been successfully applied to analyse profile scaling in fly wing development (24, 26, 27). According to the definition of λ in Eq, 2.5, scaling can be achieved if either the diffusion coefficient or the degradation rate or both depend on system size. Two simple choices are: (i) D ∝ L2, β = const and (ii) β ∝ L−2, D = const. In Eq. 2.6, we defined scaling of morphogen profiles as a shape property, irrespective of the amplitude C0(L). This amplitude might be a function of system size L, compare also to (223). The variation of the amplitude with L can reveal details of the underlying scaling mechanism, see Fig. 2.2. We discuss this for the two limiting cases of (i) a source of fixed width w and (ii) a scaling source w ∝ L. (i) Fixed source: If we increase λ by enhancing diffusion, the amplitude will decrease because the same amount of morphogen is distributed more homogeneously in the system, compare to Eq. 2.4 or Eq. A.5. In contrast, if we increase λ by reducing degradation, the amplitude will increase due to a longer lifetime of the molecules. If D 26 ConcentrationConcentrationRelative ConcentrationConcentrationConcentrationRelative ConcentrationAbsolute PositionAbsolute PositionRelative PositionAbsolute PositionAbsolute PositionRelative PositionAdjusting DegradationAdjusting Diffusion(i) Fixed Source(ii) Scaling Source2.4 Scaling of morphogen profiles in pre-patterned systems and β both depend on size, the amplitude can be kept constant. (ii) Scaling source: Eq. 2.4 shows that for this case the amplitude does not explicitely depend on D but depends inversely on β. Scaling by changing the diffusion properties does not affect the amplitude but scaling by adjustment of degradation leads to a strong size dependence C0 ∝ L2. Measurements of the signaling protein Dpp in the fruit fly found a decreasing degra- dation rate with size as well as the characteristic increase in the amplitude (76, 78, 135, 233, 234). In the clawed frog, both cases have been reported, adjustment of diffu- sion properties for Bmp as well as adjustment of degradation for the Bmp antagonist Chordin (25, 94). Next, we discuss two classes of simple models for the scaling of morphogen profiles, which represent minimal versions of scaling mechanisms proposed in the literature (11, 24, 26, 27, 96, 135, 148, 154, 223, 233, 234). We will illustrate that models of the second class rely on a changing amplitude during scaling. Thus, the amplitude of the morphogen profile encodes the system size. 2.4. Scaling of morphogen profiles in pre-patterned systems 2.4.1. The concept of an expander as a chemical size reporter In order to achieve scaling of a morphogen profile in a simple set-up as introduced in Section 2.2, the length scale of the concentration profile has to couple to the size of the system. Several mechanisms have been proposed for the expansion of a morphogen profile with system size L that assume an additional molecular species, often called "expander" (11, 24, 27, 96, 135, 148, 154, 233, 234). If the concentration E of such an expander is a function of L, the interaction of these expander molecules with the morphogen can result in profile expansion with system size. Depending on whether the expander concentration increases or decreases with system size, the expander might enhance or reduce either diffusion or degradation of the morphogen, respectively. Yet, how does the expander obtain its size-dependent concentration and become a chemical size reporter? In the following, we discuss two main classes of expander me- chanisms that have been proposed for the scaling of morphogen profiles. The first class is characterized by the fact that the expander couples to the system size independently of the morphogen. The second class subsumes mechanisms that allow for self-scaling of the morphogen profile by a feedback loop between the expander and the morphogen. 27 2. SCALING IN MORPHOGEN SYSTEMS We illustrate the scope and the limits of the mechanisms at hand. This allows us to systematically extract the main principles that lead to robust scaling as applied later to self-organized systems. 2.4.2. A simple mechanism of gradient scaling: The expander-dilution model The most simple idea for how an expander concentration can report on system size is given by the expander-dilution mechanism (135, 233, 234), see Fig. 2.3(a). It requires a constant amount of a long-lived expander, which is neither produced nor degraded. As the system size increases, the expander gets diluted and, thus, the expander concentra- tion depends on system size. Hence, E ∝ 1/L in a one-dimensional system. However, such a mechanism is highly vulnerable to the loss of expander and in particular could not easily cope with amputations of parts of the system. A similar mechanism can overcome this issue by reading out system size from geo- metrical features like area-volume ratios. As a specific example, we assume that the expander of concentration E is degraded everywhere in the one-dimensional system and produced in a source of constant width wE at the boundary: ∂tE(t, x) = DE ∂2 x E(t, x) − βE E(t, x) + αE Θ(wE − L + x) , (2.9) Again, DE is an effective diffusion coefficient, βE the degradation rate and αE the pro- duction rate of the expander. In the limit of fast expander diffusion (λE =(cid:112)DE/βE (cid:29) L), the steady state concentration is given by E∗ = αE wE βE 1 L . (2.10) Thus, the expander level E∗ encodes the system size L, see Fig. 2.3(b). In order for the morphogen to scale with L, the morphogen degradation could for example be coupled to the expander as β ∝ E2 . (2.11) The size read-out can also be established differently from the specific choice of Eq. 2.9, see Appendix A.2.1 for a general derivation. For example, the expander could be produced everywhere in the system and only be degraded at the boundary, as discussed by other authors (78, 90, 96, 148, 154). The mechanism is robust against loss of expander, but it requires λE (cid:29) L irrespective of system size. Note that a small degradation rate results in a large λE, yet also in a slow relaxation to the steady state, see Appendix A.1.3. Furthermore, the mechanism 28 2.4 Scaling of morphogen profiles in pre-patterned systems Figure 2.3.: Schematic illustration of how the concentration of an expander becomes size-depend. (a) Expander-dilution model: a conserved amount of expander gets di- luted in a larger system. (b) Dynamic size-sensing in a system with constant influx and size-dependent outflow of the expander. relies on a tightly controlled size of the source and the degradation zone. In the example above, the expander source has to keep its width although the system size changes. This shifts the problem from scaling the morphogen profile to establishing a source pattern for the expander. Finally, regeneration of arbitrarily shaped fragments seems unlikely to agree with the notion of a fixed geometry of source and degradation zone. Therefore, we next discuss the second class of scaling mechanisms, in which the morphogen itself controls the expander expression leading to a self-regulating feedback loop. 2.4.3. Perfect shape scaling vs. approximate scaling: The expansion-repression model The discussion on morphogen scaling has been enriched by the proposal of a class of models that adjust gradient shape to system size in a self-organized manner (24, 26). These mechanisms build on a feedback loop between morphogen and expander. Interestingly, this relates to the engineering framework of an integral feedback control, where the gradient is adjusted by the expander as long as it does not meet its target range (19, 24). One prominent example is the expansion-repression model. In order to illustrate the main principles, we discuss one specific simple realization of this model, in which the expander production is only turned on where the morphogen level falls below a threshold Cth like considered in (135), see Fig. 2.4(a). Alternative feedback topologies are analyzed in Appendix A.2.3 and lead qualitatively to the same conclusions. 29 (a) Expander-dilution with long-lived expander(b) Dynamic size-sensing with short-lived expanderconserved amountconst. influxsize-dep. outflow2. SCALING IN MORPHOGEN SYSTEMS For our choice, Eq. 2.9 of the expander dynamics is modified to x E(t, x) − βE E(t, x) + αE Θ(cid:0)Cth − C(x)(cid:1) . ∂tE(t, x) = DE ∂2 (2.12) In order to close the feedback loop and adjust the morphogen length scales, the expander has to affect either diffusion or degradation of the morphogen, see Section 2.3. A simple feedback scheme that yields approximate scaling, though not perfect shape scal- ing. -- Let us start with a simple realization of the expansion-repression mechanism, which has been first proposed for gradient scaling in the developing fly wing (24). In this realization, it is considered that the expander suppresses the degradation of the morphogen (24, 26, 135). Thus, β in Eq. 2.1 is not constant anymore but obeys β = β0 1 + E/Eth (2.13) with two constant parameters β0 and Eth. In consequence, increasing expander levels enlarge the range of the morphogen. Yet, in turn, this suppresses the expander pro- duction. Eventually, a steady state is reached, in which the expander production is just cancelled by the total expander degradation in the system. The source size of the expander in this steady state is determined by C∗(L − w∗ E) = Cth , (2.14) where C∗ is given by Eq. 2.3 and w∗ E denotes the size of the self-organized source region of the expander, see Fig. 2.4(a). In the limit of a quickly spreading expander (λE (cid:29) L), its steady state concentration is E∗ = αE w∗ E βE L . (2.15) From this, we can note the following observations: First, the expander source (estab- E (cid:54)∝ L), because this lished by the feedback with the morphogen) must not scale (w∗ would result in a constant expander level irrespective of system size. Second, the mor- phogen amplitude must change for perfect scaling. Otherwise, if the amplitude were constant with a scaling gradient range λ ∝ L, we would obtain w∗ E ∝ L from Eq. 2.14 and the expander would not encode the system size. This generally arises from the fact that in such a mechanism for scaling via a feedback loop both players, morphogen and expander, have to encode the system size in the steady state. Third, the particu- lar feedback scheme including Eq. 2.13 yields approximate scaling of the concentration profiles, though not a perfectly linear relationship of λ ∝ L as required for perfect shape scaling, see Fig. 2.4(b)-(c). 30 2.4 Scaling of morphogen profiles in pre-patterned systems Figure 2.4.: A simple realization of the expansion-repression models that yields ap- proximate scaling, yet no perfect shape scaling. (a) In this specific model the mor- phogen confines the expander source to the region where the morphogen concentra- tion is below Cth. (b) Rescaled steady state profiles do not perfectly collapse. (c) The gradient range λ increases with system size in a sub-linear fashion. We deter- mine λ by (i) computing λ =(cid:112)D/β at various positions in the system (blue dots), (ii) fitting the solution of Eq. 2.3 (solid red line) and (iii) calculating it directly in the limit of λE (cid:28) L (dashed green line). We use typical parameters for the fly wing: D = 1 µm2/s, DE = 10 µm2/s, α = 0.01 µM/s, αE = 0.001 µM/s, w/L = 0.1, Cth = 0.1 µM, βE = 10−4/s, β0 = 10−2/s, Eth = 1 µM, L = 25...135 µm (24, 26). This choice of parameters allows us to illustrate deviations from perfect shape scal- ing. Other parameter sets might approximate scaling better and might be practically indistinguishable from the mathematical limit of perfect shape scaling. The latter can be understood most clearly if we ask what relationship between β and E would be needed for the steady-state morphogen range λ∗ = χλL to scale with a constant factor χλ. In Appendix A.2.2, we provide a detailed derivation for different scenarios. Here, we only discuss the case of a scaling morphogen source (w ∝ L) as a representative example. If we combine Eq. 2.3, 2.14 and 2.15, we obtain (cid:18) βE αEχλ E∗(cid:19) λ∗ = χλL ⇒ β∗ ∝ cosh (2.16) Thus, this functional relationship between β∗ and E, which would be required to achieve perfect shape scaling, is different from the relationship, we had originally assumed in Eq. 2.13. Note the qualitative difference between the two relationships: whereas Eq. 2.16 corresponds to a positive feedback loop, Eq. 2.13 describes a negative feed- back loop. We conclude that the considered case of Eq. 2.12 and Eq. 2.13 does not yield perfect shape scaling, though approximate scaling is nonetheless possible. Such approximate scaling can be practically indistinguishable from perfect shape scaling as has been demonstrated by numerical simulations of the discussed feedback and related versions (24, 26, 135). 31 (a)(b)PositionMorphogen concentrationmorphogen sourceexpandersourcethreshold0Relative position0 0.250.5 0.751 Relative concentration00.20.40.60.81(c)System size050100150Gradient range 101520252. SCALING IN MORPHOGEN SYSTEMS 2.4.4. Other feedback schemes for self-organized gradient scaling The classical expansion-repression mechanism relies on a feedback in which the mor- phogen suppresses the expander while the expander increases the range of the mor- phogen. In consequence, this forms an overall negative feedback loop. In Sec. 2.4.3 we discussed an example which does robustly lead to approximate scaling, though not perfect shape scaling. Would perfect shape scaling be possible if we deviate from the scheme of a negative feedback loop? Eq. 2.16 provides the functional relationship between β and E that would be required for perfect shape scaling in the steady state. Thus, we could replace Eq. 2.13 by β ∝ cosh (E/Eth) . (2.17) Then, the system possesses a steady state pattern that scales perfectly by construction. However, this steady state is unstable in numerical simulations as it forms an overall positive feedback loop. An excess in expander would reduce the level of morphogen by enhanced degradation and thus the expander production and consequently the expander level would increase even further. Depending on the initial conditions, the system shows two distinct dynamics. For small expander levels below the unstable steady state, the expander source will eventually be suppressed completely and the morphogen concentration will diverge. For large expander levels, the system will converge to a second, non-scaling steady state. Variations of the expander feedback show qualitatively similar results. -- In Ap- pendix A.2.2-A.2.3, we discuss further variations of the feedback scheme of Eqs. 2.12- 2.13. For these variations, we likewise find approximate scaling, though no perfect shape scaling in a strict mathematical sense over a large size range. As a general rule, the ideal case of perfect shape scaling and stability are not easily teamed up. We strongly emphasize that this does not imply that the mechanisms for approximate scaling can- not provide suitable theoretical descriptions for gradient scaling in biological systems. Furthermore, more complex feedback schemes might be able to achieve perfect shape scaling or at least closely mimic perfect scaling over a considerable size range (24). 2.4.5. Conclusions from our analysis of expander models Above, we discussed simple realizations of scaling mechanisms for morphogen profiles, representing two main classes of such mechanisms, see Fig. 2.5. If the expander mea- sures system size independently of the morphogen, this can result in a robust size 32 2.4 Scaling of morphogen profiles in pre-patterned systems Figure 2.5.: Various mechanisms have been proposed for the scaling of morphogen profiles using an expander as a chemical size-reporter: (a) the first class of models considers an expander which reads out system size independently of the morphogen, see (78, 90, 96, 135, 148, 154, 233, 234) for examples, (b) the second class of models assumes a feedback loop between the morphogen and the expander such that the mor- phogen profile scales itself (24, 26). We demonstrated that in this case it is challenging to obtain a perfectly scaling steady state. The table summarizes the results for a mor- phogen that acts on the expander production like in Eq. 2.12, see Appendix A.2.2-A.2.3 for details. For all cases, it is possible to construct a robust feedback yielding good approximations to the idealized case perfect shape scaling. read-out and potentially lead to scaling (78, 90, 96, 135, 148, 154, 233, 234). Yet, it re- quires a tightly controlled layout of the system, e.g. pre-patterned sources and sinks for the expander. Thus, it does not easily comply with the ability to regenerate and might just shift the problem from the scaling of the morphogen gradient to the establishment of a source and sink pattern for the expander. The second class of models aims to establish scaling of the morphogen profile in a self- organized manner by a feedback loop between the morphogen and the expander (24, 26). It turns out that it is challenging to find mechanisms with steady state patterns that are both: perfectly scaling in the sense of Eq. 2.6 and stable. If a feedback is chosen, such that a perfectly scaling steady state exists like in Eq. 2.17, this fixed point might not to be stable. Still, many models like the one defined by Eqs. 2.12-2.13 yield stable steady states, which can well approximate perfect scaling, depending on the choice of parameters (24, 26). 33 perfectly scaling steady state is stable in a finite size rangeIndependently controlled expander (e.g. expander-dilution model)Expander feedback loop(e.g. expansion-repression model)- stable scaling(if sources and sinks of the expander are well controlled)degradation ratediffusion coefficientadjustment ofperfectly scaling steady state is unstableno perfectly scaling steady statescaling morphogen sourceconstant morphogen source(a)(b)- approximate scaling is well achievable, perfect shape scaling is challenging- for the simple model variants discussed here, we obtain:perfectly scaling steady state is stable in a finite size range2. SCALING IN MORPHOGEN SYSTEMS The intuitive picture is that an overall negative feedback loop between morphogen and expander ensures a stable steady state. In contrast, two mutually suppressing molecular species, which might yield perfect shape scaling, form an overall positive feedback loop. Thus, they will not result in a stable steady state unless there are additional feedback loops. In Chapter 3, we discuss a novel self-organizing scaling mechanism that builds on such feedback regulations. An important signature of the second class of models is that the morphogen amplitude varies with size L. This is a direct consequence of the feedback with a quickly spreading expander, which ensures a uniform expansion of the gradient range across the system. It can be understood intuitively because the morphogen not only couples to the expander but also the expander couples to the morphogen, hence, both have to encode the system size. This can result in constraints on the system design. For example, it led to the observation that the combination of a scaling morphogen source and an adjustment of morphogen diffusion by the expander could not yield scaling of the morphogen profile. We will have to take this into account when discussing scaling in self-organized systems in Chapter 3. 2.5. Revisiting the absence of scaling in Turing patterns In this thesis, we consider one specific choice of a Turing system, which is particularly suitable for analytical treatment. We restrict our analysis to a one-dimensional system with reflecting boundary conditions. The dynamics of the two molecules are described by ∂tA = αA P (A, B) − βA A + DA ∂2 x A ∂tB = αB P (A, B) − βB B + DB ∂2 x B . (2.18) Thus, we specifically consider linear degradation with rates βA, βB and production with rates αA, αB. The function P (A, B) implements a switch-like response to the concentrations A and B. Production is switched on if the activator concentration exceeds the inhibitor concentration, A (cid:29) B. We choose a Hill function, which arises naturally from cooperative and competitive chemical reactions in biological systems, see Appendix A.4: (2.19) In the limit h → ∞, the Hill function can be replaced by the Heaviside theta function Ah + Bh . P (A, B) = Ah P (A, B) = Θ(A − B) . (2.20) 34 2.5 Revisiting the absence of scaling in Turing patterns As a technical point, we have to define Θ(0) != 0, in order for the homogeneous steady state to always exist, see Appendix A.5. A Fermi function could be another choice to account for switch-like production, yielding similar results. In the case of the production switch in Eq. 2.20, the relative source size is defined by (cid:90) L 0 (cid:96)/L = (cid:104)P(cid:105) = 1 L P dx , (2.21) where brackets denote a spatial average over the system. We use the same quantity also to define the source size for the Hill-type production function. This is especially well justified if the Hill exponent h in Eq. 2.19 is large. Next, we analyze our example of a Turing system given by Eq. 2.18 and demonstrate the absence of scaling. We derive the full hierarchy of steady state patterns and discuss their existence and stability, thereby going significantly beyond linear stability analysis of the homogeneous steady state. This will put us in the position to understand the mechanisms for scaling of a Turing system. 2.5.1. A hierarchy of steady state solutions Eq. 2.18 together with the production function in Eq. 2.19 possesses a unique homoge- neous steady state: A∗ h = αA/βA 1 + (βAαB/(αAβB))h , B∗ h = For h → ∞, the steady state concentrations approach zero, A∗ pendix A.5. The inhomogeneous steady states can be computed analytically in the limit of h → ∞, corresponding to the source switch of Eq. 2.20, see Appendix A.6. We find a hierarchy h = 0, see Ap- αB/βB 1 + (βAαB/(αAβB))h . h = B∗ (2.22) of steady state patterns, which can be characterized by the number m of contiguous source regions with A > B and the number n of source regions touching the system boundaries, see Fig. 2.6. Any (m, n)-pattern can be constructed as a concatenation of σ = 2m−n copies of the (1, 1)-pattern as a basic building block, see Appendix A.6. Note that s = σ/2 is the corresponding leading order Fourier mode of the spatial patterns. The (1, 1)-pattern with a single source, located in the interval 0 ≤ x < (cid:96), is given by sinh(L/λA) 1 − sinh(L/λA−(cid:96)/λA) (cid:16) x−L 1 − sinh(L/λB−(cid:96)/λB) (cid:16) x−L sinh((cid:96)/λA) sinh(L/λA) cosh sinh((cid:96)/λB) sinh(L/λB) cosh sinh(L/λB) λB λA (cid:17) (cid:17) cosh cosh (cid:17) (cid:17) (cid:16) x (cid:16) x λA λB A∗ (1,1) = B∗ (1,1) = αA βA αB βB , 0 ≤ x ≤ (cid:96) , (cid:96) < x ≤ L , 0 ≤ x ≤ (cid:96) , (cid:96) < x ≤ L . (2.23) (2.24) 35 2. SCALING IN MORPHOGEN SYSTEMS Figure 2.6.: (a) The steady state solutions of Eq. 2.18 with Eq. 2.20 can be char- acterized by a pair of pattern numbers (m, n), where m is the number of contiguous source regions (gray) with A > B and n is the number of source regions touching the system boundaries. (b) Any (m, n)-pattern can be constructed as a concatenation of σ = 2m − n copies of the (1, 1)-pattern as a basic building block, here shown for (m, n) = (2, 2). (c) Thus, we obtain a complete hierarchy of steady state solutions, exemplified for the concentration A up to m = 3 sources. Parameters: DB/DA = 30, αB/αA = 4, βB/βA = 2, λA/L = 0.1 ≈ 0.3, λB/L = 1.5 ≈ 1.2. √ √ Patterns are characterized by two pattern length scales for A and B, respectively, analogous to Eq. 2.5.: λA =(cid:112)DA/βA and λB =(cid:112)DB/βB . The source size (cid:96) has to satisfy the implicit equation αA βB βA αB sinh((cid:96)/λA) sinh(L/λA) cosh = sinh((cid:96)/λB) sinh(L/λB) cosh (cid:18) (cid:96) − L (cid:19) λA (cid:18) (cid:96) − L (cid:19) λB (2.25) (2.26) [0.1cm] Fig. 2.7 depicts the relative source size (cid:96)/L, which is a function of only three dimensionless ratios: L/λA, L/λB and αAβB/(βAαB), see also Appendix A.6. A dimen- sional analysis of Eq. 2.18 shows that this is true also for finite h and other production 36 (a)(b)=+(c)source2.5 Revisiting the absence of scaling in Turing patterns Figure 2.7.: Pattern length scales set size of source: The relative source size (cid:96)/L of the (1, 1)-pattern at steady state is uniquely determined by the pattern length scales L/λA and L/λB. If only the system size is varied, while the other parameters are kept constant, the relative source size changes along the red curve (here: λB/λA = 5). Following the red curve, the source size approaches (cid:96)/L ∝ λB/L for λB (cid:28) L. Fur- thermore, we obtain a threshold for the existence of the (1, 1)-pattern (green) and a scaling regime in the limit of λB (cid:29) L (cid:29) λA (saturation of blue curve). Parameter: αAβB/(βAαB) = 0.5. functions. The red line illustrates the variation of the relative source size (cid:96)/L as a function of L, when all other parameters are kept constant. Note that an identical curve could be obtained if instead of L, the length scales λA and λB would be varied via a common control parameter. This will become important in Chapter 3 when we combine the Turing system with an expander feedback. The source size is zero in systems that are very small relative to the characteristic length scales, see Fig. 2.7 (green curve). For these small systems, the homogeneous steady state is the only existing solution. The (1, 1)-pattern begins to appear only above a critical size L1, where L1 obeys βA αB αA βB tanh(L1/λA) L1/λA = tanh(L1/λB) L1/λB . (2.27) This equation implies in particular that λA has to be sufficiently small in comparison to L and λB for the existence of inhomogeneous patterns, see Appendix A.6. 37 00.12551015210300.25changing, whileconstantthreshold for:limit of:2. SCALING IN MORPHOGEN SYSTEMS The relative source size (cid:96)/L strongly increases with L beyond L1. In the limit of λB (cid:29) L, it eventually saturates, see Fig. 2.7 (blue curve). This observation of source scaling for an existing (1, 1)-pattern has been reported before (66, 67, 120). In contrast, following the red curve for a finite inhibitor range λB, the source size (cid:96) approaches a constant value independent of L. In the limit λB (cid:28) L, we obtain (cid:96)/L ∝ λB/L. The source does not sense the system boundaries but instead is restricted by λB. Analogous to the (1, 1)-pattern, any higher order (m, n)-pattern only exists if the system size L exceeds a critical size Lσ = σ L1. Fig. 2.8(a) shows the region of existence (gray) for patterns of different pattern numbers. 2.5.2. Higher order patterns form in larger systems We have shown that the number of coexisting patterns increases with increasing size. Next, we investigate which of these patterns are stable and can in fact be observed in systems of different sizes. Higher order modes become linearly unstable in larger systems. -- The homogeneous steady state is linearly unstable with respect to inhomogeneous perturbations for pa- rameter values that fulfill the Turing conditions discussed in Section 1.4. A linear stability analysis as detailed in Appendix A.5 provides the corresponding parameter range for our specific choice of Eq. 2.18 and Eq. 2.19. For a certain choice of parame- ters and a specific system size, there is a range of perturbation modes s ∈ [smin, smax], which grow exponentially and might result in inhomogeneous patterns. Importantly, the mode number s scales with system size L as can already be seen from the struc- ture of the general linear stability matrix in Eq. 1.4. Thus, both interval bounds smin and smax linearly depend on L as does the mode that becomes unstable first, when changing one control parameter. Therefore, in a larger system, more and higher order perturbation modes become unstable (64, 96, 148). Nevertheless, the linear instability of the homogeneous steady state is only a necessary condition for the formation of inhomogeneous patterns. The mode number s of the per- turbation can provide a first clue about the type of pattern that might form, yet there is no general relationship between the growing perturbation modes and final patterns. In fact, it is not even clear that an inhomogeneous steady state exists in a system of finite size, even if the homogeneous steady state is linearly unstable. We encounter such a situation in our system. 38 2.5 Revisiting the absence of scaling in Turing patterns Figure 2.8.: Classical Turing patterning implies that in larger systems higher-order patterns form. (a) Typical profiles of the activator concentration A(m,n)(x) for the (m, n)-pattern are shown in red as steady state solutions to Eq. 2.18. Size ranges are shown, where the (m, n)-pattern is linearly stable (black), or exists, but is not stable (gray). In the blue region, the (1, 1)-pattern is the only stable pattern. (b) Basins of attraction: final pattern type at steady state as a function of system size on the horizontal axis and initial conditions on the vertical axis. Initial conditions linearly interpolate between the (1,1)- and (1,0)-pattern, i.e., A(x, t=0) = (1 − ξ) A(1,1)(x) + ξ A(1,0)(x), and analogously for B(x, t=0). Parameters: DB/DA = 30, αB/αA = 4, βB/βA = 2, h→∞ (a), h = 5 (b). 39 0102030(a)pattern numbers(0, 0)(1, 1)(1, 0)(2, 2)(2, 1)100.50102030System sizeInitial conditions(b)2. SCALING IN MORPHOGEN SYSTEMS The Turing system possesses a rich dynamics including oscillations due to a finite system size and the multistability of several steady states. -- Fig. 2.8(a) summarizes size ranges of existence (gray) and stability (black) of steady state patterns of our model. For very small systems with L < L1, the homogeneous steady state is the only steady state pattern that exists in agreement with reflecting (and also periodic) boundary conditions. Still, the homogeneous steady state can be linearly unstable. As there are no diverging terms in Eq. 2.18, we observe homoclinic orbits and oscillations. These oscillations induced by boundary effects take place far away from the homogeneous steady state. Thus, they appear even if all eigenvalues of the linear perturbation matrix Ms are real. For larger systems with L > L2, several inhomogeneous steady states coexist and are linearly stable. We numerically determined the region of linear stability (black) for several inhomogeneous steady states, see Appendix A.6.4. We did not find any upper size limit for the linear stability for a particular pattern. However, we observed increasingly smaller basins-of-attraction in systems of increasing size. Thus, lower order patterns become unstable with respect to finite-amplitude perturbations in favor of higher wavenumber patterns, as exemplified in Fig. 2.8(b). In conclusion, steady state patterns of increasing wavenumber emerge with increasing system size. -- In particular, the interplay between the characteristic length scales λA and λB and the system size L determines whether a certain pattern fits into the system and whether it will preferentially form. For example, the (1, 1)-pattern is globally stable only in a limited size range, see Fig. 2.8(a) (blue shading). Therefore, only if the system is pinned to this blue region by changing the characteristic length scales with system size, the (1, 1)-pattern emerges reliably from arbitrary initial conditions. In a hypothetical case, in which λA and λB scale with L, while αAβB/(βAαB) stays constant, we can hope to find a range of parameters, for which a particular (1, 1)-pattern with a scaling source is the only stable steady state, see Eq. 2.26 and Fig. 2.7. In the next Chapter, we introduce a corresponding feedback that couples the Turing system to the dynamics of an expander molecule. 40 2.6 Summary 2.6. Summary In this chapter we analyzed scaling of morphogen profiles in pre-patterned and self- organized systems. For this, we especially paid attention to the difference between (perfect) scaling of the profiles and approximate scaling. For the case of pre-patterned systems, several scaling mechanisms have been proposed, drawing on the idea of additional expander molecules, which encode system size (24, 26, 135, 233, 234). We distinguish two classes of scaling mechanisms. In the first class, the expander reads out system size independently of the morphogen like in the expander- dilution model. The second class comprises mechanisms of self-scaling by a feedback loop between expander and morphogen like in the expansion-repression model. These latter models typically yield robust approximate scaling but often do not perfectly scale. We highlight several requirements of such expander feedbacks, in particular the fact that the amplitude of the morphogen profile has to vary with system size. As a prototype example for self-organized patterning, we discussed a classical Turing system with two players. Our specific choice of equations is especially suitable for analytical treatment. We illustrated the absence of scaling in a comprehensive way: Besides the linear stability analysis of the homogeneous steady state, we also assessed existence and stability of the inhomogeneous patterns. We found a hierarchy of in- homogeneous steady state patterns, for which higher order patterns are favored with increasing system size. Thereby, the behavior is governed by the ratio of system size L to the characteristic length scales λA and λB of the two considered molecules, indi- cating that scaling might be achieved by adjusting these length scales with L. In fact similar ideas have already been explored in earlier works (90, 96, 148, 154). It has been shown that by coupling λA and λB to an autonomous chemical size reporter like in the expander-dilution model, the Turing patterns scale. In Chapter 3, we demonstrate that we can also devise an expander feedback loop in the spirit of the expansion-repression model to generate self-organized scaling of a Turing system. 41 3. Scaling and regeneration of self-organized patterns 3.1. Self-scaling and self-organization Flatworms challenge previous theories of pattern scaling and self-organization. Regene- ration from minute amputation fragments of strongly varying size prompts for patter- ning mechanisms that are both: scalable and self-organizing. Turing systems, as promi- nent frameworks for self-organized patterning, do not naturally scale (74, 148, 223). They typically generate the same patterns repeated multiple times in a growing system as depicted in Fig. 3.1. In Chapter 2, we have illustrated that this is due to fixed characteristic length scales, which define the wave length of the patterns. However, it has been demonstrated that Turing patterns can in fact scale if the charac- teristic length scales are coupled to a chemical size-reporter, which we called expander "Everywhere nature works true to scale, and everything has its proper size accordingly." -- D'Arcy W. Thompson, On Growth and Form, 1945 (217) (90, 96, 148, 154). These previous works assumed an expander that is independently controlled by a pre-patterned system like in Section 2.4.2. Thus, the proposed mechanisms account for scaling, but not in a fully self-organized way. Conversely, self- scaling mechanisms have been discussed previously (e.g. for fly development), yet for systems that are not fully self-organized (11, 24, 27, 223, 234), see Section 2.4.3. Now, in this chapter, we combine the two features of scaling and self-organization and present a generic mechanism that yields fully self-organized and self-scaling patterns. Importantly, the expander feedback in a Turing system with a self-organized source follows a very different control logic than in systems with a pre-existing source. In con- sequence, perfectly scaling steady states are stable across a wide range of system sizes. Our novel class of self-scaling Turing patterning provides a conceptual framework to address scaling and regeneration in flatworms and guides the design and interpretation of experiments. This result has been published in Werner et al. (239). First, we present a specific example which combines ideas from Turing patterning, dis- cussed in Section 2.5, with theoretical concepts for the scaling of morphogen profiles, 42 3.2 A minimal model for self-organized pattern scaling Figure 3.1.: Classical Turing patterns show more periodic repeats in larger systems as a result of fixed intrinsic length scales (a), instead of being a scaled-up version of the patterns in small systems (b). analyzed in Section 2.4. We demonstrate that this system is capable of self-organized scaling and explain the underlying mechanism. In a second step, we discuss generaliza- tions of the mechanism and predictions for experiments in flatworms. 3.2. A minimal model for self-organized pattern scaling Analogous to Section 2.4, we add another molecular species, termed expander, whose concentration E will provide a read-out of system size L. As a specific case, we assume the expander is produced homogeneously, spreads by diffusion and is subject to degra- dation ∂tE = αE − βE E + DE ∂2 x E . (3.1) Again, αE denotes the respective production rate, βE the degradation rate and DE an effective diffusion coefficient. In order to achieve self-organized scaling, the dynamics of the three molecular species have to be mutually coupled in a similar manner as for the expander feedback in Section 2.4.3. As an illustrative example, we choose a feedback loop, in which the inhibitor of the Turing system controls the degradation rate of the expander via βE = κE B (3.2) with a positive constant κE. This choice ensures that the expander concentration is approximately homogeneous even for small DE because the inhibitor concentration itself is typically rather homogeneous in a Turing system. In turn, the expander also feeds back on the Turing system and changes the length scales of the morphogen profiles, see Fig. 3.2(a). Analogously to Eq. 3.2, we choose a linear regulation of the degradation rates by the expander (with κA, κB > 0) βA = κA E , βB = κB E . (3.3) Note that Eqs. 2.18 and 3.1 can be considered as a classical three component Turing system, yet with specifically chosen coupling terms given by Eqs. 2.19, 3.2 and 3.3. 43 (a) Classical Turing(b) Scaled Patterns3. SCALING & REGENERATION OF SELF-ORGANIZED PATTERNS 3.3. Numeric solution shows scaling and pattern regeneration Before analyzing this system of equations analytically, we numerically demonstrate that the steady state pattern scales with system size over several orders of magnitude, see Fig. 3.2(b)-(c). Small deviations from the perfect collapse of the concentration profiles arise due to a finite diffusion coefficient of the expander and a finite h of the production function. Still, the source size (cid:96)∗ at steady state and the characteristic length scales λ∗ A and λ∗ B show almost perfect scaling with system size. In the limit of an homogeneous expander and a switch-like source with h → ∞, we analytically show in Section 3.4 that the scaling becomes exact. Pattern scaling does not come at the cost of robustness for the Turing system. We can challenge patterning by perturbations that mimic amputation experiments, see Fig. 3.2(d). Here, the activator concentration A reliably adjusts to fit the smaller system size. Note that the system part with the initially oversized source and thus higher morphogen concentrations takes longer to re-adjust. 3.4. Dynamical systems analysis of scaling and regeneration Next, we provide insight into how and why scaling works. First, we identify steady states, each of which scales with system size. For the simple case of adiabatically slow expander dynamics, we then show that the (1,1)-pattern is a stable steady state. A phase space description allows us to characterize fixed points and understand the non- linear dynamics. We illustrate the behavior by considering a two-dimensional projection of the phase space of our dynamical system, spanned by the relative source size given by Eq. 2.21 and the mean expander level, see Fig. 3.3(a). An implicit scaling relation holds at steady state. -- We first show that all steady states of the extended Turing system are characterized by the same relative source size (cid:96)∗/L = (cid:104)P ∗(cid:105) independent of system size L. Thus, in Fig. 3.3(a) all steady states (circles) are found on a horizontal line. By spatial averaging of Eq. 2.18 and 3.1, we obtain for steady state concentrations B∗ and E∗ 0 = αB(cid:104)P ∗(cid:105) − κB(cid:104)B∗E∗(cid:105) 0 = αE − κE(cid:104)B∗E∗(cid:105) . Hence, the relative source size in the steady state is constant (cid:96) * L = αE κB αB κE . 44 (3.4) (3.5) (3.6) 3.4 Dynamical systems analysis of scaling and regeneration Figure 3.2.: Scalable pattern formation in a Turing system with expander feedback. (a) The Turing system and the expander mutually control their degradation rates, re- sulting in a stable feedback loop. (b) Scaling corresponds to morphogen profiles that collapse as a function of relative position x/L (normalized by respective concentrations A0, B0, E0 at x = 0). (c) The feedback self-consistently adjusts the length scales λA and λB of the morphogen profiles and thus the source size (cid:96) with system size (sym- bols: numerical results; lines: analytical solution of Eqs. 2.18 and 3.1 at steady state √ for homogeneous expander concentration and h→∞). Here, λ0 = [DA/ αAκA]1/2 denotes the characteristic length scale of the system. (d) Regeneration of concentra- tion profiles: after cutting the system in two (initial size L/λ0 = 20), the expander feedback adjusts the activator concentration to fit the smaller system size both in a tail fragment (upper row) and head fragment (lower row). Repatterning of the tail fragment takes significantly longer due to the initially higher morphogen concentration √ αAκA). Parameters: DB/DA = 30, DE/DA = 10, (time given in units of τ0 = 1/ αB/αA = 4, αE/αA = 0.4, κB/κA = 2, κE/κA = 2, h = 5. 45 (a)10−110010110210010110200.511.500.51(c)Pattern length scalesRescaled concentration profilesRelative positionSystem size(b)(d)Activator profile001224366060120180240Activator profile3. SCALING & REGENERATION OF SELF-ORGANIZED PATTERNS In contrast, the length scales defined in Eq. 2.25 are not constant anymore but change (cid:114) DA κAE A and λ∗ (cid:114) DB κBE with expander level: λA = and λB = . (3.7) We have seen in Fig. 3.2(c) that λ∗ with system size. B at steady state scale with high precision In order to explain this scaling behavior, we consider the limit of a spatially homogeneous expander concentration E, for which we can show that the scaling becomes exact. This limit corresponds to either a large expander range λE =(cid:112)DE/(κEB) (cid:29) L or a large inhibitor range λB =(cid:112)DB/(κBE) (cid:29) L. The latter condition is in compliance with the requirements for a typical Turing system and is promoted by the scaling feedback. If the expander level was imposed as constant E = E0, we would obtain a Turing system without expander feedback, as discussed in Section 2.5. Thus, the concentrations would converge towards one of the (m, n)-patterns discussed in Section 2.5.1 with pattern length scales λA(E0) and λB(E0). The relative source size f(m,n) = l/L of such a pattern depends on E0 only via the dimensionless ratios λA(E0)/L and λB(E0)/L, see Eq. 2.26. This fact is illustrated by Fig. 2.7, where the red curve displays f(1,1) in the limit of h → ∞. Importantly, f(m,n) = f(m,n)(L2E0) is only a function of L2E0 and changing E0 has analogous effects on the relative source size as changing L2. The same argument also implies that a (m, n)-pattern can only exist above a critical value of E0, corresponding to the minimum system size for the existence of patterns in Fig. 2.8(a). Below this critical value, f(m,n) is zero. Above this value, f(m,n) displays a nonmonotonic dependence on E0, which results from opposing effects of the pattern length scales of the activator and the inhibitor on the source size (cid:96), see Fig. 3.3(a). The intersections of the curves f(m,n) (obtained from the steady states of the Turing sys- tem without expander) with the constant value (cid:96)∗/L given by Eq. 3.6 define the steady states of the full system with expander feedback. For each pattern type (m, n), we find two steady-state patterns, denoted (m, n)+ and (m, n)−, with respective expander levels E+ The fact that f(m,n)(L2 E∗) = (cid:96)∗/L is independent of system size L by Eq. 3.6, implies that also L2E∗ is independent of L for each steady state. We conclude E∗ ∝ L−2 and B ∝ L at each fixed point, consistent with our numerical results in thus λ∗ Fig. 3.2(c). (m,n), see the black and white circles in Fig. 3.3(a). (m,n) < E− A ∝ L, λ∗ The stability in the vicinity of the scaling fixed points can be assessed in the simple limit of adiabatically slow expander feedback. -- In this limit, the source size first relaxes to 46 3.4 Dynamical systems analysis of scaling and regeneration Figure 3.3.: Fixed points and dynamics in a Turing system with expander feedback. (a)-(b) Two-dimensional projection of the phase space: all fixed points (circles) are characterized by the same relative source size. For adiabatically slow expander dy- namics, the system relaxes along the nullclines of the Turing system f(m,n) (shown for h → ∞, λE (cid:29) L, corresponding to Eq. 2.26). As each nullcline intersects the steady- state condition of Eq. 3.6 twice, the system possesses two fixed points (n, m)+ and (n, m)− for each pair (n, m). In the blue region, the (1,1)-pattern is the only stable steady state of the Turing system, compare to Fig. 2.8, implying that all trajectories starting there must converge to this fixed point. Here, E0 = (αA/κA)1/2 denotes a characteristic concentration of the system. (c) Example trajectories, mimicking am- putation experiments (labeled i,ii ), and uniform, one-time injection of the expander (labeled iii,iv ); all converge to the same stable fixed point, an appropriately scaled (1,1)-pattern. (d) Parameter regions for stable, self-scaling pattern formation (green), and regions of expander divergence (orange, purple). Parameters of panel (c) and Fig. 3.2 indicated by cross. Parameters: DB/DA = 30, DE/DA = 10, αB/αA = 4, αE/αA = 0.4, h = 5, L/λ0 = 10, unless indicated otherwise. κB/κA = 2, κE/κA = 2, 47 10−110000.10.2(c)10−110000.10.2(a)(b)025500123Relative source sizeRelative source sizeMean expander concentrationMean expander concentrationstable scaling(1,1)+(d)(1,1)−(1,0)+(1,0)−(2,2)−(2,2)+(1,1)(2,2)(1,1)+(1,1)−(1,0)+(2,2)+(1,0)−(2,2)−3. SCALING & REGENERATION OF SELF-ORGANIZED PATTERNS (cid:96)/L = f(m,n)(L2 E) for some (m, n), corresponding to the fast time scale of the Turing system. Then, by Eq. 3.1, the system moves slowly along this nullcline according to ∂tE = αE − κE αB κB f(m,n)(L2 E) . (3.8) Stability of steady-state patterns requires ∂Ef(m,n) > 0, which is observed to hold only for E+ (m,n), see Fig. 3.3(a). Which branch f(m,n) is selected for arbitrary initial conditions by the fast Turing dy- namics? As we consider the limit of slow expander feedback, the expander concentra- tion is approximately constant within the time scale of the Turing relaxation. Thus, the question of which pattern (m, n) is selected is formally equivalent to the stability of (m, n)-patterns in the Turing system without expander feedback as a function of system size L. The blue region in Fig. 2.8(a), in which the (1, 1)-pattern is the only stable pattern, can be associated with the blue range of expander concentration in Fig. 3.3(a). Therefore, we can deduce that this represents a basin-of-attraction for the (1, 1)+-pattern. A numerical analysis reveals a large basin-of-attraction for the first order pattern. -- Fig. 3.3(c) shows that the (1, 1)+-pattern is an attractive fixed point also for trajectories starting outside this blue region and for nonadiabatic expander dynamics. Two example trajectories, labelled (i ) and (ii ), corresponding to head and tail fragments, respectively, converge to the (1, 1)-pattern, after a transient under- and over-shoot of the source size. Two additional trajectories, labeled (iii) and (iv ), simulating uniform injection of the expander, likewise converge to this fixed point. We can understand these observations by drawing on the results for the Turing system without expander in Section 2.5.1 and 2.5.2. The dynamics for large expander concentrations are characterized by a successive move- ment through higher order patterns. -- The (1, 1)+-state is also attractive for trajec- tories like (iv) with initially high values of E. Here, a (2, 2)-pattern with an additional source is transiently emerging. Yet, according to the expander dynamics given by Eq. 3.8, the system moves towards the fixed point (2, 2)+ as long as the (2, 2)-pattern comprises a stable fixed point of the Turing system without expander. However, the fixed point (2, 2)+ of the Turing system with expander lies in a region of the phase space where the (2, 2)-pattern of the Turing system alone is unstable for our choice of parameters. Thus, the fixed point (2, 2)+ is in fact a saddle point, attractive with respect to the expander dynamics along the nullcline f(2,2) but unstable with respect to the Turing system. Again, this can be understood from Fig. 2.8(a) by noting the 48 3.4 Dynamical systems analysis of scaling and regeneration formal correspondence between changes in E for a fixed system size L and changes in L2 for the classical Turing system without expander. Fig. 2.8(a) illustrates that the (2, 2)-pattern is unstable outside the blue region. The result would be different for the (1, 0)-pattern. Note that the nullclines of the (1, 0)-pattern and the (2, 2)-pattern are congruent in our projection of the phase space. In consequence, there exists a trajectory starting with a (1, 0)-pattern that looks identical to (iv), besides the fact that it ends in the fixed point (1, 0)+, which is stable for our choice of parameters, as illustrated in Fig. 2.8(a). Dynamics of homogeneous states allows to understand regeneration of patterns. -- For small expander values, there are no inhomogeneous steady state patterns of the Turing system, yet homogeneous patterns exist. To understand the relaxation of the full system, we will discuss two limiting cases, assuming again the separation of time scales between Turing dynamics and expander system: a) In the limit of fast Turing dynamics, the Turing system will first approach the homogeneous steady state, given by Eq. 2.22 for a certain value of E. On the larger time scale of the expander relaxation, the system moves along the corresponding nullcline (cid:96)/L = f(0,0) according to ∂tE = αE − αBκE κB f(0,0) with f(0,0) = P (A∗ h, B∗ h) . (3.9) If f(0,0) < (cid:96)∗/L, the expander level increases and consequently the Turing length scale decreases until the homogeneous pattern becomes unstable and inhomogeneous patterns can form. b) As a second case, we consider the opposite limit, for which the Turing dynamics are adiabatically slow and the inhibitor concentration B does hardly change within the time scale of relaxation of the expander towards αE/(κE B). We find a qualitatively similar behavior. It exists another homogeneous, yet dynamic solution of the Turing system, in which the ratio χ = B/A and thus P (A, B) = g(χ) is approximately constant. The ratio χ is determined by the following implicit relation, see Appendix A.7.1: 1 1 + χh = αE κE κA − κB αA χ − αB . (3.10) In order for E to increase such that the system enters the regime where inhomogeneous patterns exist, B has to decrease. According to ∂tB = αB g(χ) − κB αE κE , (3.11) this requires that g(χ) < (cid:96)∗/L. 49 3. SCALING & REGENERATION OF SELF-ORGANIZED PATTERNS Depending on the choice of parameters, both transient homogeneous states (corre- sponding to the two limiting cases of a separation of time scales) can be observed when mimicking regeneration experiments in the Turing system with expander. In Fig. 3.3(c), the horizontal stretch of trajectory (i) corresponds to g(χ). Both production terms f(0,0) and g(χ) of the transient homogeneous states have to be smaller than (cid:96)∗/L, explaining the transient undershoot during regeneration. Note that from g(χ) = (cid:96)∗/L follows that also f(0,0) = (cid:96)∗/L. The set of parameters corresponding to this joint condition mark the breakdown of robust regeneration, see horizontal line in Fig. 3.3(d). Beyond this thres- hold, the homogeneous morphogen concentrations diverge while the expander vanishes (purple region). If the parameters obey this constraint, the basin-of-attraction of the (1, 1)-state extends towards small values of E outside the blue region in Fig. 3.3(a). 3.5. As single source pattern is attractive for a large region of the phase space Based on the discussion above, we expect the (1, 1)-pattern to be re-established even when simulating more drastic amputation experiments, as shown in Fig. 3.4. Again, we find the source (cid:96)/L of each smaller system first approaching the horizontal line corresponding to g(χ). Eventually, the expander value is sufficiently large such that the homogeneous state becomes unstable and inhomogeneous patterns can form. Tran- siently, the (2, 1)-pattern arises but as the (2, 1)+-solution is unstable with respect to the Turing dynamics, the additional source vanishes and the system returns to the (1, 1)-pattern. Details of the relaxation dynamics and whether (1, 1)+ is the only stable fixed point or whether a second stable fixed point (1, 0)+ with a smaller basin-of-attraction exists like in our example, depends on the choice of parameters. In general, we observe robust pattern scaling for a vast parameter range, provided (i) inhibitor diffusion is sufficiently fast (a necessary condition for pattern formation in any Turing system) and (ii) the feedback strength is similar for both Turing molecules, see Fig. 3.3(d). The threshold above which the expander concentration vanishes, resulting in a divergence of A and B (purple), can be analytically determined from the condition f(0,0) = g(χ) = (cid:96)∗/L. This corresponds to the fact that the expander should increase for homogeneous morphogen concentrations. 50 3.6 Structural robustness for pattern scaling Figure 3.4.: Numerical solution of the Turing system with expander mimicking an amputation experiment with 10 cuts. All trajectories converge to the fixed point (1, 1)+ after a transient formation of the (2, 1)-pattern. Parameters: DB/DA = 30, DE/DA = 10, αB/αA = 4, αE/αA = 0.4, κB/κA = 2, κE/κA = 2, h = 5, L/λ0 = 10. 3.6. Structural robustness for pattern scaling Several generalizations of the proposed minimal mechanism are conceivable. First, the feedback of the Turing system on the expander level could be likewise implemented via the production rate, e.g. αE ∝ B, instead via the degradation rate βE = κEB. Then, scaling would require βA ∝ 1/E , βB ∝ 1/E as well as a fast spreading expander, yielding analogous steady states. As a second possibility for pattern scaling, the feedback in Eq. 3.3 could also be medi- ated by A (instead of B or additional to B), provided the expander diffuses sufficiently fast. For example, the following system can be interpreted in the sense that pairs of A 51 10−310−210−110000.10.2Relative source sizeMean expander concentration(2,1)+(1,1)+(1,0)+(2,2)+(1,1)−3. SCALING & REGENERATION OF SELF-ORGANIZED PATTERNS and E as well as B and E are only degraded together when bound to each other ∂tA = αA P (A, B) − κA AE + DA ∂2 x A ∂tB = αB P (A, B) − κB EB + DB ∂2 x B ∂tE = αE − κA AE − κB BE + DE ∂2 x E . (3.12) More generally, the degradation term does not even have to be linear in A, B and E. Two increasing functions of A and E, and B and E, respectively, that fulfill the Turing conditions together with P (A, B) are sufficient to generate robust scaling by the same arguments as above, see Appendix A.7.2. Remarkably, the feedback loop considered here, featuring two mutually suppressing concentration profiles (B and E), would be unstable for a pre-patterned morphogen source of fixed size as discussed for the expander feedback in Section 2.4.3. The feedback mechanism becomes stable, only due to the self-stabilizing effect of the Turing system itself. Our mechanism yields pattern scaling by scaling of the morphogen profiles via a feed- back on the degradation rates of A and B. As discussed in Section 2.3, scaling of expo- nential profiles can in principle also be achieved by mechanisms affecting the diffusion of morphogens. However, controlling only diffusion is not compatible with self-organized pattern scaling as presented here. Our mechanism relies on a size-dependent amplitude of the morphogen profiles, which is lacking for pure diffusion control, as discussed in Section 2.4.5. The morphogen amplitude in our feedback scheme changes quadratically with system size as can be seen from Eq. 2.23-2.24. It is interesting to note that the flux βAA has a size-independent amplitude. The spatial profile of this flux could provide a read-out of the scaling morphogen profiles independent of their amplitudes, see Appendix A.7.3. For example, if degradation only happens by internalization upon binding to a receptor, the concentration of down-stream targets of the morphogen A would be proportional to the flux βAA. 52 3.7 Signatures of self-scaling patterns 3.7. Signatures of self-scaling patterns Our minimal model for the scaling of self-organized patterns can act as a framework to understand scaling and regeneration in flatworms. We find a number of signatures characterizing this class of patterning mechanism, which can be identified in experi- ments. (i) First, the over-all morphogen levels depend on system size. As already discussed in Section 2.4.5 for self-scaling feedback loops, this is necessary for the morphogens to influence the expander in a size-dependent manner. However, downstream targets might scale with a constant amplitude. (ii) Second, for the simple scalable Turing systems discussed here, a size-dependent morphogen amplitude requires the adjustment of degradation rates. For the experi- ments, we have to take into account that many processes can effectively lead to a change in degradation by expander molecules. For example, binding of the expander could disintegrate or alter the morphogen such that it cannot fulfill its signaling task. Alternatively, the expander could act as a co-receptor that facilitates internalization and thus removes the morphogen from the system. Conversely, the expander might reduce degradation by preventing disintegration, modifications or internalization by binding to the morphogen or its suppressors. (iii) Third, the expander by definition shows a size-dependent concentration. If the expander level is proportionally to L2, it can couple linearly to the degradation rate to achieve scaling. Note that the expander is likely not a single molecule but an entire signaling module, for which some components might already be expressed in a size- dependent manner. Thus, analyzing changes in expression levels between animals of different size can help to identify the expander mechanism. (iv) Fourth, a perturbation of the expander feedback by over-expression or gene knock- out or also by hindered spreading is expected to lead to a change in the wave number of the pattern. Depending on the coupling of the expander to the morphogen dynamics, one might observe the most severe effects in either small or large animals. (v) Fifth, the source is expected to exhibit a non-monotonic dynamics after ampu- tation. In particular, an initially oversized source might show an undershoot during regeneration. (vi) Sixth, there might be additional fixed points of the system with small basins-of- attraction. In our example, the (1, 0)+-pattern was also stable and locally attractive. If the system is initialized close to this pattern, the pattern will be maintained, even in the presence of small perturbations. 53 3. SCALING & REGENERATION OF SELF-ORGANIZED PATTERNS 3.8. Comparison to experiments in flatworms The signatures discussed in Section 3.7 can to some extent be found in flatworms, in particular for the Wnt/β-catenin pathway associated with head-tail polarity (4, 9, 51, 54, 81, 82, 141, 160). The Wnt molecules are expressed in the posterior part of the animal and shape the graded β-catenin profile with a maximum at the tail, see Fig. 3.5. The expression regions of components of the Wnt pathway as well as independent anterior and posterior markers fit to the size of the worm (81). Furthermore, first preliminary data by our experimental collaborators suggests that also the β-catenin profile matches worm size with a constant amplitude, see (i). After amputation, this graded cue has to be quickly scaled to fit the remaining body fragment. Indeed, it has been observed that the position-dependent expression pattern along the AP axis changes within the existing cells to adjust to the new fragment size in the course of a few days (81, 82, 245). Thus, the robust re-establishment of a scaled chemical pattern seems to predate the remodelling of the body plan. Thereby, the expression region of one of the Wnt molecules is reported to show similar dynamics as the source size in our model, see (v). After cutting the worm, the expression of Wnt11.5 is strongly reduced and undershoots its target range before it eventually scales up again to fit the fragment size (81). Knockdown of β-catenin leads to the formation of multiple heads (3, 51, 82, 82, 160). Interestingly, after a transient drug treatment, the double-headed phenotype persists even after consecutive amputations (117). This agrees with our discussed example for which one second order pattern (and even more specifically the (1, 0)-pattern) seems to be a locally attractive fixed point, see (vi). Additionally, very narrow slices of the worm can also sometimes result in a double- headed phenotype (4, 51, 117, 127). Again, this compares to our model, for which the morphogen profile transiently flattens after amputation. In the model, the profile becomes the more homogeneous the smaller the fragment. Starting from a homogeneous profile can occasionally result in the emergence of a higher order pattern with a small basin-of-attraction, see (vi). Candidates for the expander molecules still have to be identified. However, a first sequencing screen by our experimental collaborators found several genes which are expressed in a size-dependent manner. Some of them are even approximately homoge- neously expressed and show a strong (possibly quadratic) dependence on worm length, see (iii). 54 3.8 Comparison to experiments in flatworms Figure 3.5.: The β-catenin concentration forms a gradient from tail to head defining the AP axis in flatworms. Quantitative Western Blot by Tom Stuckemann in the group of Jochen Rink (lysate refers to dissolved cell material). For a homogeneous effect of the expander on the morphogen, the expander might be a rather small and fast diffusion molecule. Such small molecules could for example quickly travel between cells via gap junctions. Interesting, it has been reported that the blocking of gap junctions in flatworms leads to body patterns with a larger wavelength (152), see (iv). In summary, we could identify several signatures of our simple model, which help us to lay out the route for further experiments such as targeted gene knockouts. Thereby, it is important not to confuse patterns with processes. The same steady state pattern can arise from very different underlying mechanisms. This is particularly true for the case of Turing models (147). Already for a simple three component model as we discussed in this chapter, the knockout of activator or inhibitor might easily provoke misleading interpretations of the data, see Appendix A.7.4. Considering not an endpoint assay but a time course of the system after amputations or gene knockouts might to some extent circumvent this problem. The dynamics typically reveal additional, valuable details that might enable us to distinguish between different mechanisms. 55 12345678910051015AP axis positionpg β-catenin / μg lysate3. SCALING & REGENERATION OF SELF-ORGANIZED PATTERNS 3.9. Summary and discussion In this chapter, we introduced a new class of pattern forming mechanisms, which gene- rate patterns that perfectly scale with system size in a completely self-organized manner. The patterning scheme relies on expander molecules that dynamically adjust the degra- dation rates of morphogens in a Turing system. Thereby, the expander controls the pattern length scales and the source size of the resulting Turing patterns. Conversely, the expander concentration is dynamic itself and is regulated by the concentrations of the Turing morphogens. For the feedback introduced here, the relative source size at steady state is always independent of the system size, see Eq. 3.6. Furthermore, we showed that a head-tail polarity pattern with a single source region scales as a function of the system size, is stable with respect to perturbations, and regenerates in amputation fragments. Previous works have already discussed scaling of morphogen profiles and patterns in pre-patterned systems. Either the morphogen source was specified by other pre-existing cues (24, 26) or the morphogen profile was self-organized according to a Turing mecha- nism but scaling relied on a predefined geometry (90, 96, 148, 154). Such frameworks are challenged by the regeneration capabilities of flatworms. In addition, we will show in Chapter 5 that the length-width ratio of the worms does not stay constant during growth, which is also not compatible with mechanisms relying on a fixed geometry. Now, our self-organized model for pattern scaling is able to read out system size in the absence of any pre-patterns and without strong dependence on specific geometrical features. Certainly, body plan patterns in flatworms do not emerge in the total absence of po- tential pre-patterning cues. For example, it has been shown that the contact of dorsal and ventral tissue at the wound site causes a regeneration response (102). Still, our self-organized patterning system captures main characteristics of body plan scaling and regeneration in flatworms and allows to discuss generic concepts. Thereby, it provides the basis for further investigations and more sophisticated modeling approaches. In the minimal theory formulated here, we neglected spontaneous expander degradation. Such spontaneous degradation would cap the expander concentration and set a lower size limit for pattern scaling. Additionally, in size-monitoring systems as considered here, a key challenge relates to the simple fact that these obviously require long-range communication across the scale of the system. This implies a trade-off between an upper size limit for scaling, and the time-scale of pattern formation. Here, this time scale is set by morphogen diffusion and system size. For example, assuming a maximum 56 3.9 Summary and discussion diffusion coefficient of 100 µm2/s and a maximum organism size of 20 mm, relevant for the flatworms considered, we infer a patterning time scale of 3−30 days, roughly consistent with the experimental range of 1−2 weeks for the restoration of body plan proportions after amputation (4, 140). Note that active, non-directional transport in addition to passive diffusion could accelerate morphogen dispersal and thus allow for faster pattern formation (76). In fact, it has been suggested for flatworms that fast long-range communication might be implemented via gap junctions or the central nervous system (9, 152, 157). Besides the transmission of actual nervous signals, a molecular transport along the nerve cords was proposed (9, 169, 245). Moreover, a gradient of membrane voltage has been discussed to mediate long range patterning and scaling of body parts (22, 23, 115). Yet, even when considering faster transport processes than normal diffusion, eventually we can expect a physical limit to scaling, which would be revealed by the emergence of higher order body plan patterns. Interestingly, it has been reported that a second head forms in very large animals of some species (50, 98). So far, we were mainly concerned with the Wnt/β-catenin system and the gradient for- mation along the anterior-posterior (AP) axis. Yet, there are also two additional axes, which are specified by other signaling molecules (141). For example, the Admp/Bmp system appears to be responsible for the establishment of a dorsal and a ventral side (61). In flatworms, these molecules seem to cross-react analogous to a Turing system. Previously, they have also been proposed to be a Turing pair in the frog Xenopus laevis (122) and a shuttling mechanism has been discussed as a means to adjust the Bmp gradient to the size of the frog embryo (25). The theory developed in this chapter provides a framework to understand robust axis formation and scalable body plan patterning. In the future, it will be important to test the generic concepts presented here in regeneration experiments and to quantify spatial profiles of signaling molecules and genetic activity. With this, we aim to identify the key modules leading to scaling and regeneration. 57 4. Flatworm shape dynamics and motility 4.1. Modes, movement and morphology While the previous chapters were concerned with the patterning of a specific body layout, this chapter aims to analyze motility-induced and inter-species variations of the body shapes as a first step to relate form and function. Ultimately, we would like to understand why worms look and behave the way they do. Most of the results of this chapter have been published in Werner et al. (238). Evolutionary adaption to a specific environment manifests itself in the emergence of characteristic body morphologies, which among others allow the organism to effi- ciently sense its environment and steer its path. Thus, motility phenotypes reveal abnormal body plan patterns. Flatworms usually display a smooth gliding motility, "Whether it be the sweeping eagle in his flight, or the open apple-blossom, the toiling work-horse, the blithe swan, the branching oak, the win- ding stream at its base, the drifting clouds, over all the coursing sun, form ever follows function, and this is the law." -- Louis H. Sullivan, The Tall Office Building Artistically Considered, 1896 (210) resulting from a coordinated beating of the cilia in their densely ciliated ventral epithelium (8, 169, 179, 180). For the cilia to act in synchrony, they have to be oriented in parallel to each other, which is coordinated by a structural polarity of the epi- thelial cells in the plane of the epithelial tissue. This planar cell polarity system (PCP) comprises several molecules that asymmetrically localize to the anterior or posterior side of each cell, respectively, and bind through the membrane to the corresponding counterpart in the neighbouring cells (51, 196, 226). It has been described that the PCP system, which is based on local cell-cell interactions, couples to global polarity cues provided by organism-scale / tissue-scale concentration gradients of signaling molecules as discussed in the previous chapter (51, 196, 226). Together with our experimental collaborators, we aim to explore this coupling by quantifying the gliding speed after knocking out genes of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway as a long range patterning system. In a second approach, we analyze and characterize the movement patterns of flatworms in detail. How do the worms steer their path? We find that a characteristic bending posture correlates with active turning during gliding, presumably caused by unilateral 58 4.1 Modes, movement and morphology muscle contractions. Thus, during gliding motility, speed is generated by beating cilia whereas steering is controlled by muscles. Occasionally, flatworms also show a second type of motility behavior, called "inch-worming", sometimes also referred to as "peri- staltic movement" (8, 169, 179, 180). Switching to this motility mode is associated with escape responses and impaired cilia functionality. We characterize inch-worming by stereotypic width changes of these worms. Our method reveals regular lateral con- traction waves with a period of about 4 s in inch-worming worms. Since then, body contractions have been further analyzed and a recent publication reports on distinct differences between "scrunching" as a quick escape response and "peristalsis" as a more persistent gait if cilia functionality is impaired (38). We will compare these results to our previous findings. Finally, we employ shape analysis methods to characterize the morphologies of various flatworm species, which come at very different shapes and sizes. The taxonomic identi- fication is usually challenging, relying largely on the time-consuming mapping of inter- nal characters. Here, we illustrate how to systematically and quantitatively distinguish different flatworm species by head shape. The head is one of the most characteristic external hallmarks of the flatworm body plan. Many sensory organs for various stimuli (e.g. light, temperature, touch, chemical signals) are located in the head (21, 95). This includes two eyespots and the auricles with a high density of nerve cells. Yet, also other, less prominent shape characteristics might be crucial for the worm to survive, for example by allowing for more efficient movement and navigation. The systematic characterization and quantitative comparison of body plan morphologies provides the basis for relating worm shape to fitness of a species in its specific environmental niche (103, 199). We analyzed the motility patterns of Smed and head shapes of different flatworm species using shape mode analysis based on principal component analysis (PCA) (97, 99, 156). The technique has been previously applied to biological data to e.g. analyze the dy- namics of human arm postures, crawling C. elegans worms or swimming sperm cells (58, 118, 189, 207, 208, 209). In contrast to those examples, which are well described by their center line, the flatworm body is constantly deforming during movement depend- ing on the contraction of their muscular plexus due to the absence of skeletal elements or a rigid body wall. Thus, we adapted PCA to analyze and quantify motility patterns of a closed non-convex boundary outline. The starting point of PCA is typically a large data set comprising Na measurements of Nb features. An example would be the curvature at Nb discrete positions along 59 4. FLATWORM SHAPE DYNAMICS AND MOTILITY a winding worm at Na time points. are often correlated, e.g. the curvature at adjacent positions is similar due to a finite In biological data sets the individual features stiffness of the body. Therefore, the data might be well described by a much smaller set of characteristic shape modes. For example a sine wave might be a good first approximation to the wiggling of a worm. The most descriptive shape modes are found in a systematic way by determining the largest variations in the data set. At best, a small number of empirical modes characterizes most of the data and can be interpreted in a meaningful way. As a side-effect, this method reduces measurement noise by averaging over several, partially redundant features. PCA can also be seen as a rotation of the phase-space coordinate system such that it is more suitable for the data at hand. Afterwards, the data can be projected with only negligible information loss onto a subset of the phase-space spanned by a small number of axes. These axes correspond to the shape modes. 4.2. Worm motility reports on patterning defects upon gene knockout We analyze movies of gliding worms as described in Appendix C and extract the center line of the worm body. The midpoint of the center line is tracked to determine the median worm speed. We observe that wild type worms actively regulate their gliding speed up to a maximum of 2 mm/s with a weak dependence on size, see black circles in Fig. 4.1(a). The range in speed is in quantitative agreement with earlier works in Smed and Dugesia tigrina (155, 212). Next, we compare this result to the speed of modified worms, for which pathway components of the Wnt/β-catenin patterning system have been silenced by RNA interference (RNAi). Imaging of wild type worms has been performed by Nicole Alt under the supervision of the author. The RNAi experiments have been performed by Sarah Mansour in the group of Jochen Rink (two RNAi feedings per week). All analysis has been done by the author. The canonical Wnt/β-catenin signaling cascade is illustrated in Fig. 4.1(b) (82, 107). In the absence of canonical Wnts, β-catenin is degraded by a destruction complex, which includes APC as a key component. If Wnt ligands bind to the Frizzled receptors, the destruction complex is inhibited via Dishevelled (Dvl). Thus, β-catenin can accumulate in the cell and reach the nucleus to control transcription. Canonical Wnt/β-catenin signaling has been associated with tail formation (82). Knockout of Dvl by RNAi feedings leads to the emergence of multiple heads, while knockout of APC leads to the formation of a second tail after head amputation. 60 4.2 Worm motility reports on patterning defects upon gene knockout Figure 4.1.: (a) Speed of wild type worms (black circles) and worm speed after APC RNAi feeding for one week (red dots), two weeks (green dots) and three weeks (blue dots), respectively (705 wild type worms, 41/38/39 RNAi worms). (b) Canonical Wnt pathway: binding of Wnt ligands leads to β-catenin translocation to the nucleus (via Dvl activation and subsequent APC inhibition), adapted with permission from (82). (c) Quantification of the APC RNAi experiment in panel (a) for small worms (1-3 mm2) and large worms (3-7 mm2). At week 4 worms still show body contractions but no net displacement anymore. (small: 271 wild type worms, 20/15/14 RNAi worms; large: 130 wild type worms, 19/22/12 RNAi worms) (d) Speed measurements after 3 weeks of Dvl RNAi feeding (322 wild type worms, 12 RNAi worms of size 1-4 mm2). (e) Speed measurements after 3 weeks of RNAi of the non-canonical Wnt2 and Wnt5 (154 wild type worms, 17 Wnt2 RNAi worms and 25 Wnt5 RNAi worms of size 2.2- 5 mm2). (Imaging of wild type worms by Nicole Alt under the supervision of the author. RNAi experiments by Sarah Mansour. All analyses performed by the author. Asterisks denote the significance level of the p-value test: * 5% and 1%. Error bars correspond to standard deviations.) 61 0510152000.511.52Speed in mm/sMean size in mm2WTW1W2W3W400.511.5Mean speed in mm/ssmallWTW1W2W3W400.511.5Mean speed in mm/sWTWnt2Wnt500.511.52Mean speed in mm/sWTDvl00.511.5Mean speed in mm/sWntFrizzledDishevelled (Dvl)Destruction complex with APCβ-cateninDNA(a)(e)(d)(c)(b)large************4. FLATWORM SHAPE DYNAMICS AND MOTILITY In intact worms, we observe a motility phenotype for APC RNAi, see colored points in Fig. 4.1(a). Worm speed is reduced over the course of the experiment. We can quantify this trend for two size classes and see a significant effect already after two weeks of RNAi feeding, see Fig. 4.1(c). It remains to determine whether APC acts directly on the PCP pathway or whether a graded β-catenin signal is required to maintain planar cell polarity. Similarly, when knocking down both Dvl genes of Smed , we observe a reduced speed suggesting a disoriented cilia carpet, see Fig. 4.1(d). In fact, it is known that Dvl is not only a component of the canonical Wnt signaling cascade, leading to a translocation of β-catenin to the nucleus, Dvl also acts in non-canonical Wnt signaling, where it activates the PCP pathway (8, 60, 107). It has been shown that silencing Dvl leads to a less, shorter and more disorganized cilia (8, 9). In order to determine to what extent non-canonical Wnt signaling is related to PCP in flatworms, Sarah Mansour performed RNAi of Wnt2 and Wnt5. Unlike the canonical tail Wnts, Wnt2 is expressed in the head and Wnt5 is expressed around the body margin and especially along the central nervous system (9, 81). Especially Wnt5 has been discussed to act in non-canonical signaling in flatworms and is also involved in PCP systems of other organisms (9, 59). Fig. 4.1(e) shows no movement phenotype for Wnt2 RNAi, but Wnt5 RNAi results in a significant reduction in speed. Interestingly, the Wnt5 phenotype is rather subtle. While for APC and Dvl RNAi, the worms seem to loose the ability to glide, switch to inch-worming motility and eventually cease being motile altogether, the Wnt5 RNAi worms are still capable of normal gliding motion, just slower. It is an interesting question, whether this is due to an incomplete knockdown or the particular effect of Wnt5 on the PCP system. In summary, analyzing worm movement upon RNAi is a simple and non-lethal approach to identify patterning phenotypes. The method reveals even subtle effects as for Wnt5 and inspires further more elaborate measurements of cilia orientation and gene expres- sion profiles. 62 4.3 Shape mode analysis of 2D worm outlines 4.3. Shape mode analysis of 2D worm outlines Next, we analyze the behavioral repertoire of flatworms in greater detail. Different movement strategies are reflected in bending of the worm body. Due to the large body plasticity, motility-induced changes in body posture are not well described by only the center line but require an analysis of the perimeter dynamics. Thus, we face the challenge of characterizing the shape of closed, planar curves. For non-convex shapes, this can be non-trivial. We extract the midline and the perimeter of the worms from movie sequences as de- scribed in Appendix C, see Fig. 4.2(a). The imaging has been performed by Nicole Alt under the supervision of the author. The worm shape corresponds to a closed curve described by a position vector r(s) as a function of arc-length s along its circumference, see Fig. 4.2(b). We use the tip of the worm tail as a distinguished reference point r1 that specifies the position of s = 0. We further specify a center point r0, using the midpoint of the tracked center line of the worms. The profile of radial distances ρ(s) = r(s)− r0 measured with respect to the center point r0 characterizes outline shape, even for non- convex outlines. Shapes of convex curves might also be characterized by a profile of radial distances ρ(ϕ) as a function of a polar angle ϕ. However, this definition does not generalize to non-convex curves (or, more precisely, to curves that are not radially convex with respect to r0). To adjust for different worm sizes, we normalize the radial distance profiles by the mean radius ρ = (cid:104)ρ(s)(cid:105) as ρ = ρ(s)/ρ and plot it as a function of normalized arc-length s = s/L, where L is the total length of the circumference. As a mathematical side-note, we remark that using the signed curvature κ(s) = (∂2 s r(s))· (∂sr(s)) along the circumference, instead of the radial distance profile ρ(s), would amount to a significant disadvantage: The property that a certain curvature profile corresponds to a closed curve imposes a non-trivial constraint on the set of admissi- ble curvature profiles. For the normalized radial distance profiles, however, there is a continuous range of distance profiles that correspond to closed curves, making this choice of definition more suitable for applying linear decomposition techniques such as shape mode analysis. In fact, given a particular normalized radial distance profile, the corresponding circumference length L/ρ is reconstructed self-consistently by the requirement that the associated curve must close on itself, see Appendix D.1. 63 4. FLATWORM SHAPE DYNAMICS AND MOTILITY Figure 4.2.: Three shape modes characterize projected flatworm body shape dyna- mics. (a) Our custom-made MATLAB software tracks worms in movies and extracts worm boundary outline (red) and centerline (blue). (b) The radial distance ρ(s) be- tween the boundary points and midpoint of the centerline (r0, red dot) is calculated as a parameterization of worm shape. We normalize the radial distance profile of each worm by the mean radius ρ. (c) Covariance matrix of the radial distance profiles: the second symmetry axis (dotted line) corresponds to statistically symmetric behavior of the worm with respect to its midline (745 worm movies, imaging by Nicole Alt under the supervision of the author, all analysis performed by the author). (d) The three shape modes with the largest eigenvalues account for 94% of the shape variations. The first shape mode characterizes bending of the worm and alone accounts for 61% of the observed shape variance. We show its normalized radial profile on the left as well as the boundary outline corresponding to the superposition of the mean worm shape and this first shape mode (solid red: B1 = 1, dashed red: B1 = −1, black: mean shape with B1 = 0). The second shape mode describes lateral thinning (B2 = 0.3), while the third shape mode corresponds to unlike deformations of head and tail (B3 = 0.8), giving the worm a wedge-shaped appearance. (e) The first shape mode with score B1, describing worm bending, strongly correlates with the instantaneous turning rate of worm midpoint trajectories. (f) We manually selected 30 movies where worms clearly show inch-worming and 50 movies with no inch-worming behavior. The variance of score B2 and B3 increases for the inch-worming worms. (g) The autocorrelation of mode B3 and the crosscorrelation between mode B2 and mode B3 reveals an inch- worming frequency of approximately 1/4 Hz, hinting at generic behavioral patterns. 64 −2−1012−0.4−0.200.20.4Turning rate (1/s)Score B1 of first moder0r1 tailheadtail −0.2−0.100.10.2Third shape mode v3 tailheadtail −0.2−0.100.10.2Second shape mode v2 tailheadtail −0.2−0.100.10.2First shape mode v160.7 %24.8 %8.8 %(a)(d)(b)correlation 0.52(e)(c)1 mm(f)tailtailhead(g)0246810−0.5−0.2500.250.50.751correlationtime interval (s)autocorrelation B3crosscorrelation B2 - B3no inchworminginchworming00.10.20.30.4variancevar(B2)var(B3)var(B2)var(B3)stailtailhead4.4 Shape dynamics during crawling and inchworming 4.4. Shape dynamics during crawling and inchworming 4.4.1. A bending mode and two width-changing modes We extracted Nw = 29 993 worm outlines from a total of 745 analyzed movies. We computed normalized radial distance profiles as described above, each profile being represented by Nr = 200 radii, resulting in a large Nw × Nr data matrix Ri,j = ρi(sj). From the average of all radial profiles, we define a mean worm shape that averages out shape variations ρ0(s) =(cid:80)Nw we can devise a Nw × Nr matrix R0 the mean profile. Next, we computed the Nr × Nr covariance matrix i=1 ρi(s)/Nw, see Fig. 4.2(d) (right inset, black). From this, i,j = [ρ0; ...; ρ0], for which all the rows are equal to C = (R − R0)T (R − R0) (4.1) between the individual radial profiles, using the centered (mean-corrected) data ma- trix, see Fig. 4.2(c). The covariance matrix is by construction symmetric along the dashed line. The approximate symmetry of the covariance matrix along the dotted diagonal shows that shape variations are statistically symmetric with respect to the worm midline. For example the worm bends as often to the left as to the right. The Nr eigenvectors vj(s) or shape modes of this covariance matrix correspond to axes of a new coordinate system. In this coordinate system, the variation of the data along each axis is linearly uncorrelated and the corresponding variance is given by the respective eigenvalue. The shape modes with the largest eigenvalues are those with maximal descriptive power. We can uniquely express the worm shape as Nr(cid:88) ρ(s) = Bjvj(s) , (4.2) j=1 where the shape scores Bj can be computed by a linear least-square fit. Due to corre- lations, many data sets can be well described by a truncated sum, using only a small number of shape modes with the largest eigenvalues. Fig. 4.2(d) shows the first three shape modes, which together account for 94% of the ob- served variation in shape. We find that the dominant shape mode v1 is anti-symmetric, describing an overall bending of the worm. In contrast, the second and third mode de- scribe symmetric width changes of the worm: The second shape mode v2 characterizes a lateral thinning of the worm associated with a pointy head and tail. Correspondingly, a negative contribution of the second shape mode with B2 < 0 describes lateral thicke- ning of the worm (with a slightly more roundish head and tail). The third shape mode 65 4. FLATWORM SHAPE DYNAMICS AND MOTILITY v3, finally, is associated with unlike deformations of head and tail, giving the worm a wedge-like appearance. Superpositions of these three shape modes describe in-plane bending of the worms, and a complex width dynamics of head and tail. We find that shape changes control the direction of gliding motility and thus steer the worm's path: Fig. 4.2(e) displays a significant correlation between the rate of turning along the worm trajectory and the first shape score B1, which characterizes bending of the worm. The sign and magnitude of this "bending score" directly relates to the direction and rate of turning. For simplicity, we restricted the analysis to a medium size range of 8-10 mm length, analogous results are found for other size classes. 4.4.2. The second and third modes characterize inch-worming In addition to cilia-driven gliding motility, flatworms employ a second, cilia-independent motility pattern known as inch-worming, which provides a back-up motility system in case of dysfunctional cilia (8, 169, 179, 180). We test whether modes two and three might relate to this second motility pattern. For this, we analyzed movies of small worms known to engage more frequently in this kind of behaviour. We manually clas- sified 80 movies of worms smaller than 0.9 mm that had been starved for 10 weeks, yielding a number 30 inch-worming and 50 non-inch-worming worms for a differentiated motility analysis (cases of ambiguity were not included). We find that the second and third shape mode, which characterize dynamic variations in body width, are indeed more pronounced in inch-worming worms, see Fig. 4.2(f). Next, we computed the tem- poral autocorrelation of time series of the second shape mode B3, see Fig. 4.2(g) (solid blue). We observe stereotypical shape oscillations with a characteristic frequency of 0.26 Hz. From the cross-correlation between B3 and B2 in Fig. 4.2G (dashed black), we find that both shape scores oscillate with a common frequency and relative phase lag of −0.6 π (where B2 lags behind). Thus, both shape modes act together in an orches- trated manner to facilitate inch-worming, hinting at coordinated muscle movements and periodic neuronal activity patterns. 4.5. Discriminating flatworm species by shape After having developed tools to measure shape changes of the same species over time, we next explored the utility of shape mode analysis for comparing different species. The model species Schmidtea mediterranea is but one of many hundred flatworm species existing worldwide (50, 116). We aim to introduce shape mode analysis as a technique 66 4.5 Discriminating flatworm species by shape Figure 4.3.: (a) Application of our method to parametrize head morphology of four different flatworm species. For each species, time-lapse sequences of 4 different worms were recorded as two independent runs of 16 frames each. The head is defined as the most anterior 20% of the worm body. Radial distances ρ(s) are computed with respect to the midpoint of the head (red dot at 10% of the worm length from the tip of the head). (b) By applying PCA to this multi-species data set, we obtain two shape modes, which together account for 88% of the shape variability. Deformations of the mean shape with respect to the the two modes are shown (black: mean shape, red: superposition of mean shape and first mode with B1 = ±0.4 and second mode with B2 = ±0.2, respectively). We represent head morphology of the four species in a combined shape space of these two modes. Average head shapes for each species are indicated by crosses, with ellipses of variance including 68% (dark color) and 95% (light color) of motility-associated shape variability, respectively. (Imaging by Nicole Alt and Miquel Vila-Farr´e, data analysis by the author) to facilitate taxonomic classification of these species. PCA enables us to extract typi- cal shape variations between species without "a priori" assumptions on characteristic features. Having available a large live collection of flatworm species, we choose four species repre- senting the genera Girardia, Phagocata, Schmidtea and Polycelis. Besides potentially size-dependent variations in aspect ratio, the four species differ by their characteristic head shapes, see Fig. 4.3(a). Accordingly, we restrict the shape analysis to the head region only (defined as the most anterior 20% of the worm body). In analogy to the procedure described above for the full worm body, we characterize each head shape by a vector of distances from the midpoint of the head (red dot, 10% of the worm length from the tip of the head) to the outline ρ(s) of the head region. Next, PCA is applied to the normalized radial distance profiles like before. 67 GirardiaPhagocataSchmidteaPolycelis1 mm−0.500.5−0.200.2Score of second mode B2Score of first mode B1(a)(b)4. FLATWORM SHAPE DYNAMICS AND MOTILITY We found that the first two eigenmodes captured 88% of head shape variability within this multi-species data set. Fig. 4.3(b) shows species-specific mean shapes for each of the four species in a combined head shape space, as well as ellipses of variance covering 68% (dark color) and 95% (light color) of motility-associated shape variability, respectively. Shape reconstruction from individual modes is explained in Appendix D.2. The first mode seems to describe the extent of the auricles while the second mode can be associated with the auricle position. This comparison of flatworm species represen- ting four genera illustrates linear dimensionality reduction as a simple means to map morphological differences across species. 4.6. Discussion In this chapter, we have discussed several approaches to relate form and function in flatworms focussing on motility. Movement patterns are generated by various features of the body plan such as cilia and muscle layout. By analyzing worm motility, we gained first insights into their functionality and coordination. In a first approach, we measured worm speed in wild type and RNAi treated animals and could quantify subtle motility phenotypes, which hint at patterning defects of the PCP system. In a second approach, we analyzed the shape variations during movement, adapting principal component analysis in order to apply it to 2D outlines. We characterized inchworming as a second motility mode, different from cilia-based gliding motility, which is driven by well-coordinated muscle contractions with a characteristic frequency of about 0.26 Hz. In a recent work, contractile motility gaits have been further analyzed (38). Cochet-Escartin et al. distinguish between two behavioral traits: (i) scrunching as a transient and fast response to cutting as well as electrical, acidic and temperature shocks, (ii) peristalsis as a more persistent and slow movement strategy if cilia func- tionality is impaired. The authors could induce the latter in two different ways: (i) by RNAi of the iguana gene leading to defective ciliogenesis and (ii) by increasing the viscosity of the media (by adding 16% ficoll). Interestingly, they extracted frequen- cies of the area oscillations during peristalsis and obtain 0.28 ± 0.03 Hz (iguana) and 0.26 ± 0.02Hz (ficoll), respectively. These values are very similar to our result. To- gether, the three conditions illustrate a very generic inchworming/peristalsis behavior despite their higher level of complexity compared to other model organisms such as C. elegans (173, 184, 208, 244). It remains to determine how this relates to the underlying structure of the muscular plexus and the nervous system. 68 4.6 Discussion In a third approach, we apply PCA to head shapes of different flatworm species as a tool for taxonomic classification. We captured the main characteristics of head shapes of four species belonging to different genera by just two shape modes. The result suggests that head morphogenesis is mainly controlled by two molecular networks: one to determine the head width and a second one for the anterior positioning of the auricles. The availability of transcriptome sequence data for these species will now provide us with the opportunity to test this hypothesis. We also have planned to extend the analysis to many more species of the collection in the laboratory of Jochen Rink and relate the characteristic body plan features to the conditions in the respective environmental niche. A similar inter-species comparison with respect to evolutionary selected traits has been performed for beaks of Darwin finches, phalanxes of vertebrates, heads of ants and wings of bats (103, 199). Based on these analyses, we expect for flatworms that a small number of shape modes with the largest eigenvalues spans the feature space, in which most of the shape variations take place. Highly specialized species have typically rather extreme morphologies and can be found at the corners of the observed shape set. In contrast, generalists show mixtures of different traits, which simultaneously optimizes the fitness to fulfil several tasks. It will be interesting to test this hypothesis for flatworm species, some of which inhabit extreme environments. 69 5. Quantitative study of flatworm growth and cell turnover 5.1. Homeostasis is a dynamic steady state Multicellular organisms in their adult stages have a relatively constant outward ap- pearance but the integrity of a functional body is only maintained due to a permanent replacement of damaged or lost cells (158). In humans, it has been estimated that the total mass of cells we replace every year is almost as much as our entire body weight (166). The time scales of the cellular turnover range from a few days for blood cells and the stomach to several years for cells in the heart and the skeleton (124). Only a small fraction of cells like some nerve cells might never be replaced. From the point of view of dynamical systems theory, a constant outward appearance in the face of permanent turnover can be considered as a steady state, for which inflows (i.e. the generation of new cells) and outflows (i.e. the loss of old cells) are balanced. "ποταοσι τοσιν ατοσιν βαίνουσιν τερα κα τερα δατα πιρρε." (On those stepping into rivers staying the same other and other waters flow.) -- Heraclitus of Ephesus, 500 BC (105) The underlying processes of cell division and cell loss have to be well controlled in order to avoid a disintegration of the organism or an uncontrolled overgrowth such as cancer. For this to function robustly, there is likely a communication between the dying cells in the tissue and the dividing stem cells in their niche, see Fig. 5.1. A limited capacity to replace cells is related to sickness and aging of organisms (158). During growth, the balance between inflows and outflows is shifted to an increased cell division in comparison to cell loss. Importantly, growth is not only controlled by a developmental program but also influenced by the availability of food (113, 244). In many organisms, nutrition levels affect the speed of growth and the final size. In this chapter, we address the link between the microscopic scale of cell turnover and the macroscopic growth in our favourite multicellular organism the flatworm Smed . Previous research has mainly been devoted to cell death and cell division as individual processes but little is known about how these two processes are jointly regulated and mutually influence each other to result in coordinated growth at the organism scale 70 5.1 Homeostasis is a dynamic steady state Figure 5.1.: (a) Stem cell division and the loss of cells have to be balanced to maintain a constant size of the tissue. (b) For growth and degrowth, the balance of these processes is slightly shifted in a well controlled manner. (158). Flatworms are suitable model organisms to study cell turnover and growth in a comprehensive way as they permanently replace all of their cells within a few weeks and reversibly grow over a 40-fold range in size (16, 140, 151, 158, 170). Thereby, the cell size appears to be approximately constant and the reversible growth mainly corresponds to a change in cell number (16, 140, 150, 193). Interestingly, changes in worm size has been previously related to aging and small worms have been described to be more juvenile. In Appendix E.1, we discuss signatures of aging in sexual and asexual flatworms. Two basic models of growth and turnover control have been discussed for flatworms: (i) stem cell control and (ii) cell death control (159), see Fig. 5.2. In the first scenario, dividing stem cells or their descendants induce cell death in differentiated cells for replacement. In order to generate growth, the replacement must not be perfect. We might hypothesize that cells only respond with a certain probability (maybe depending on their age or fitness) to the death signal from the stem cell pool. In the second scenario, the dying cells send out signals to enhance cell division and recruit progenitor cells to the tissue. In both cases, an additional input from the nutritional status of the worm is needed for growth. By studying flatworms as a model system, we aim to bridge the scales between cellular turnover processes and growth and degrowth on the organismal level. First, we quantify 71 (a) Replacement & Repair?divisionlossstem cellsdifferentiated tissue(b) Growth & Degrowthlossdivision5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER Figure 5.2.: Two paradigms of turnover control: (a) stem cells and their descendants induce the death of differentiated cells, (b) dying cells induce cell division and recruit progenitor cells to the tissue. In both cases feeding enhances cell division. the size of the worms as well as growth dynamics and find a non-trivial size-dependence of the growth and degrowth rates. All experiments were performed in the laboratory of Jochen Rink. Several members have been involved in this close collaboration as we will explicitly state for each data set. In a second step, we theoretically discuss three paradigmatic models for how cell division and cell loss might be linked to the metabolic status of the worm. Each model is able to explain the observed behavior within the accuracy of the measurements. We obtain several predictions of the models that can be tested in further experiments. The results directly relate to the questions of how these worms can survive long starvation periods and what determines the limits to growth. Finally, we establish the theoretical framework for future measurements to reveal the control logic of turnover processes. 5.2. Size-dependent growth and degrowth dynamics in flatworms 5.2.1. Allometric scaling laws 5.2.1.1. Measurements of area, cell number and mass of the worm The first step towards measuring growth dynamics is to accurately determine worm size. Together with our experimental collaborators we performed experiments to extract the outer dimensions like length and width as well as the cell number and the mass of the worms. From these measurements we obtained allometric scaling laws that relate the various quantities for cross-validation and to gain further information about the body plan of Smed, see Fig. 5.3. One important quantity is the area of the worm, which refers to the 2D-projection of the worm body. Area as well as other outer dimensions are readily accessible by microscopic imaging and we have developed a protocol to measure these quantities in 72 (a) stem cell control(b) cell death control5.2 Size-dependent growth and degrowth dynamics in flatworms a precise and reproducible way, see Appendix C. Several student helpers in the group of Jochen Rink have been involved in the imaging of the worms. The author designed the experiments, provided training and supervision and performed the analysis of the data. Fig. 5.3(a) reveals an allometric scaling relation between worm area and length with an exponent of 1.81± 0.01. Thus, large worms are relatively thinner than small worms. Remarkably, the scaling law holds across the entire size range with a very small trans- verse spread and a high reproducibility. These worms were starved for at least a week. The respective scaling law for well fed worms can be found in Appendix E.2. There we also discuss the details of the data analysis. The scaling exponents have been deter- mined using a robust regression algorithm with bi-squared weights implicitly obtained from the spread of the data. Ultimately, we are most interested in the changes in cell number because this quantity directly relates to the rates of cell division and cell death. However, measurements of cell numbers are fatal for the worms. As a solution, we establish a functional relationship between cell number and worm area. By using the worm area as a read-out for size, we can reduce the number of worms needed for various experiments and perform time- course experiments with well-defined initial sizes. The cell number itself has been measured in two different ways by Albert Thommen in the group of Jochen Rink. First, he determined the amount of histones in the worm. Histones are structural units that organize the DNA in eukaryotic cells (68). The DNA strands are wrapped around the histones in the nuclei for compaction. Histones are only synthesized during cell division and the amount of histones was measured to be constant throughout the lifetime of the cells. After the amount of histones per cell has been determined, the total amount of histones in a worm can be used as a read-out for cell number. For this, the amount of histones was measured via Western blotting in a known fraction of the total protein mass. In a second experiment, cell numbers were obtained by disintegrating the worm into individual cells and automatically counting cells in microscope images of a well defined volume fraction of the worm. The resulting cell numbers are plotted in Fig. 5.3(b) as a function of worm size. We find that the number of cells scales almost linearly with the area of the worms with a scaling exponent of 1.11± 0.02. The most simple explanation would be that the height hardly changes and also the large worms remain rather flat. Alternatively, the size of cavities like the gut might increase over-proportionately, compensating for an potential increase in height for larger worms. Furthermore, it might be possible that the fraction 73 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER Figure 5.3.: Allometric scaling laws: (a) Width and length of the worm do not change proportionately. Large worms are thinner than small worms (Imaging by Nicole Alt under the supervision of the author, analysis by the author, 722 measurements of star- ving worms). (b) Cell numbers are measured by direct cell counting (green circles) and by histone quantifications (blue dots). The cell number changes almost propor- tionally with worm area (Imaging and cell number quantifications by Albert Thommen, analysis by the author, 31 and 45 worms, respectively). (c) In contrast, the dry mass increases stronger than area and cell number (Imaging and mass measurements by Albert Thommen, analysis by the author, 21 worms). 74 051005101520Area in mm2Length in mmLog lengthLog area(a)01020304002468Area in mm2Cell number in 106(b)05101502004006008001000(c)Area in mm2Dry mass in µgLog cell numberLog areaLog areaLog dry mass5.2 Size-dependent growth and degrowth dynamics in flatworms of cell types changes, which might also explain a linear scaling despite variations in height. Irrespective of which scenario applies, the scaling exponent shows that our area measurements are a good proxy for cell number. Finally, we also determine the dry mass of the worms. Again, the experiment has been carried out by Albert Thommen, while the analysis of the movies has been performed by the author. Although more data is needed for a more reliable result, the analysis of the first data points suggests that the scaling exponent of 1.33 ± 0.06 for the dry mass is larger than the exponent for the cell number. Therefore, the mass per cell seems to slightly increase with size. Interestingly, some preliminary measurements suggest that in contrast the protein mass per cell is independent of worm size, see Appendix E.2. 5.2.1.2. Comparison and interpretation of scaling laws Previously, contradictory results have been published on scaling laws in Smed and other related species, see Tab. 5.1. For Planaria maculata, the scaling of worm mass with area to the power of 1.38 agrees well with our result (227). For Dugesia lugubris, Lange measured the volume in serial sections and found a quadratic relationship with length, which is in agreement with our scaling law for the cell number (110, 111). Bagun`a et al. have measured cell number and worm volume in Smed (13, 16). In agreement with our data, they find similar values for the cell numbers and from them we can obtain a quadratic scaling with the length of the worm. However, a few years later, the same group published various scaling laws for four different species including sexual and asexual flatworms which do not agree with our results. Further, more recent measurements of the worm mass by Oviedo et al. also deviate from our scaling law (150). However, a scaling with L0.9 is a rather questionable result considering that the worm width also increases. In the same paper, the authors counted the number of cintillo cells, which are found around the margin of the head and are involved in mechanosensing. If we assume that the head can be approximated by a semicircle and that the number of cintillo cells increases proportionately to the head margin, the width of the worm at the head follows L0.68, see Appendix E.2, which is similar to our results. For Schmidtea polychroa, the wet weight and the protein content have been measured (133). At least the protein content might show a similar dependence on area as in our experiment. Finally, Takeda et al. measured the total DNA mass in Dugesia japonica and find an approximately linear dependence on body length (211). As the cell number can be assumed to be roughly proportional to the total DNA mass, this is not in agreement with our measurements in Fig. 5.3(b). In analogy 75 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER scaling law M ∝ A1.38 V ∝ L2.02 N ∝ L2 N ∝ L1.81 N ∝ A1.44 A ∝ L1.26 Mwet? ∝ L0.9 Mwet ∝ A Mprot ∝ A N ∝ L species our result (Smed ) reference Planaria maculata ? Dugesia lugubris† Smed Smed Smed Schmidtea polychroa† Schmidtea polychroa† Dugesia japonica† M ∝ A1.33 (N ∝ L2.01) N ∝ L2.01 N ∝ L2.01 N ∝ A1.11 A ∝ L1.81 M ∝ L2.40 M ∝ A1.33 Mprot ∝ A1.13 N ∝ L2.01 (227) (110, 111) (13, 16) (177) (150) (133) (133), Appendix E.2 (211) Table 5.1.: Scaling laws for various flatworm species found in the literature. Our experiments are done in asexual worms, † denotes the sexual strains, ? marks a species, which cannot be taxonomically classified. to the argument about the worm mass of Oviedo et al., such a linear relationship of cell number with length is unlikely given the significant increase in worm width in larger worms. Note that the spectroscopic quantification of flatworm DNA is rather unreliable because it interferes with the absorption peak of the pigments. Hence, we apply different approaches. Thus, while we could confirm several measurements of scaling laws in flatworms ob- tained before 1980, we find much less agreement with recently published results. This discrepancy with respect to our data might only in parts be explained by species- specific variations and differences between sexual and asexual strains and could relate to the general problem of size measurements in animals with flexible body shapes. In our experiments, we have paid particular attention to accuracy and reproducibility by analyzing movie sequences of individual worms, following a strict protocol. Exten- sive cross-checks as well as consistency-checks between redundant measurements were performed. Our results on the scaling of the cell number suggest that flatworms indeed stay rather flat. As the worms lack a blood system, this would ensure that all cells can be provided with oxygen by diffusion from the outer epithelium. While this is the most likely yet not the only explanation for the observed scaling relation in Fig. 5.3(b), further measurements of worm heights are necessary to confirm our hypothesis. More data points are also needed for the scaling relation of the dry mass. The data at hand 76 5.2 Size-dependent growth and degrowth dynamics in flatworms suggests that the characteristics of the cell population depend on size in the sense that in larger worms there are more cells with an increased mass. Note, however, that a first approximate estimation of protein content in the worm does indicate that the protein content per cell roughly stays constant, see Appendix E.2. Thus, a possible explanation for the increase in cell mass could be the storage of lipids as energy resources in larger worms. Having established size measurements, next, we aim to analyze growth dynamics. 5.2.2. Characterizing the immediate growth response upon feeding Worms respond to feeding with a fast mitotic peak within the first 12 hours that lasts for 3 − 5 days (12, 13, 16, 71, 139, 142). We would like to relate this mitotic feeding response to the increase in worm size. Fig. 5.4(a) shows the changes in worm area immediately after feeding. After an initial increase of the worm area, the worms shrink again and return to their initial sizes within approximately two weeks. Note that the worm area already approaches its maximum very rapidly within the first 12 hours after feeding, although the mitotic response lasts for following next days. Thus, we were wondering which part of the peak can be explained by pure stuffing of the gut and which part reflects the actual cell division response. To this end, we measured the growth response also for irradiated animals without stem cells, see red curves in Fig. 5.4(b). Interestingly, the stuffing effect last for at least the first 4 days until the irradiated worms dissociate. Thus, the initial increase in worm area after feeding actually reflects stuffing. Nevertheless, these measurements provide us with the following information: First, the food fills the gut for at least 4 days, most likely providing the dividing cells with nutrients during this time. Second, the growth response appears to be rather generic and food intake is approximately proportional to worm size. We also have not found an obvious dependence on feeding history. Growth peaks after longer starvation periods look similar to the results above, see Appendix E.2. Finally, the growth effect decays within two weeks. Thus, worms should approximately keep their size when being fed every two weeks. After one week, the worm size has been roughly increased by 2%. Further experiments will aim to extract changes in cell number upon feeding to reveal the actual growth response. 77 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER Figure 5.4.: Growth response upon feeding (after one week of starvation): (a) The worm area increases rapidly within the first day and returns again to its initial value after 2 weeks. The area is normalized by the average of day 0−7. The individual worm tracks are shown in gray, the black line illustrates the average behavior across all worms (Imaging by Johanna Richter, Jordan Ferria and Nicole Alt under the supervision of the author, analysis by the author, 21 worms). (b) Irradiated worms (red) and non- irradiated worms show the same initial increase in area due to intake of food. The area is normalized by the average of day 0− 4 (Imaging by Ashutosh Mishra under the supervision of the author, analysis by the author, 5 irradiated and 5 non-irradiated worms each). 78 0h12h24h36h2d3d4d5d0.70.80.911.11.2Normalized areaTime after feeding1.3 - 2.3 mm20h12h24h36h2d3d4d5d0.70.80.911.11.2Time after feeding6 - 9 mm2−10123456789140.70.80.911.11.2Time after feeding (days)Normalized area3 - 6.5 mm2(a)(b)wildtypeirradiated5.2 Size-dependent growth and degrowth dynamics in flatworms 5.2.3. Small worms grow and degrow faster than large worms 5.2.3.1. Measurement of growth rates Even though we have learned that stuffing effects compromise tracking of the short term growth pulse, we can still quantify the averaged growth behavior on the time scale of weeks and in particular analyze how the growth and degrowth rates depend on feeding. Fig. 5.5(a)-(c) shows the growth tracks for individual worms of different sizes for three feeding conditions: starvation, feeding every second week and feeding every week. In agreement with Fig. 5.4, the worms that are fed every second week approximately maintain a constant size. One can clearly recognize the growth response upon feeding that decays until the next feeding event. The concatenation of short-term growth pulses results in a zig-zag line. For the other two cases, we compute average growth rates, see Fig. 5.5(d). The data is very noisy for the well-fed worms because of the stuffing effect and the excretion of digested food. Still, we can obtain a clear linear trend using two independent fitting procedures. Besides the robust regression of the growth rates (black, with 95% confidence intervals), we construct a master curve from the growth tracks assuming negligible effects of the feeding history, see Fig. 5.5(e). The growth tracks of Fig. 5.5(c) are shifted horizontally in an iterative procedure to minimize the variance from the average curve. Finally, we fit a Fermi function as the master curve, which corresponds to a growth rate that linearly depends on size. Both approaches agree well with each other. Fig. 5.5(d) shows a clear size-dependence of the growth and degrowth rates. Small worms appear to grow faster than large worms. Note that even the largest worms have a positive growth rate, meaning worms usually undergo fissioning before reaching the limits to growth. Surprisingly, small worms also degrow faster. This trend appears to be rather independent from the feeding history, see Fig. 5.5(f). 5.2.3.2. Discussion of growth and degrowth dynamics As for the allometric scaling laws, our results on the growth dynamics rather agree with very early measurements and less so with more recent publications. At the beginning of the 20th century, Abeloos investigated growth dynamics in another flatworm species (1). In analogy to our conclusion, he found that the increase in dry mass is stronger for smaller species. Bagun`a et al. have analyzed growth and degrowth dynamics of Girardia tigrina for various feeding conditions (15, 18). We can extract from these data sets that their growth rates are also decreasing with size during feeding, see Appendix E.2. The 79 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER Figure 5.5.: (a)-(c) Measurements of worm area for different feeding conditions (Ima- ging by Nicole Alt und Johanna Richter under the supervision of the author, analysis by the author includes 66, 41 and 48 worms, respectively). (d) Degrowth rates (red circles) have been computed from data in panel (a) by linear fits across three windows with 6 data points each using a robust algorithm. The size dependence is fitted by the function c1 + c2 A/(c3 + A) with c1 = −3.17 ± 0.38 %/day, c2 = 2.72 ± 0.33 %/day, c3 = 2.11 ± 1.26 mm2 (black curve). (continued on next page) 80 FMMMMMMM2d17d7d2d17d......FMFMFFMF7d3d3d3d4d4d4d...FMFMFMFM7d7d7d3d3d4d4d(a) Starvation(b) Feeding every second week(c) Feeding every week1471005101520WeeksArea in mm213579010203040WeeksArea in mm22468024681012WeeksArea in mm21471001234WeeksArea in mm2(d)0102030−6−4−20246Area in mm2Area growth rate in percent / day(e) Feeding every weekStarvation(f) 0246−3−2−10Area in mm2Area degrowth rate in %/ dayearly (1./4. week)middle (4./7. week)late (7./10. week)050100150010203040Area in mm2Time in days05010015010−1100101102Time in daysArea in mm25.2 Size-dependent growth and degrowth dynamics in flatworms Figure 5.5.(continued from previous page): Growth rates (blue cicles) have been determined from the growth tracks in (c) by an exponential fit across two windows with 5 data points each. The trends in the growth rates are fitted by the robust regression c1 − c2 A with c1 = 4.18 ± 0.35 %/day, c2 = 0.10 ± 0.03 %/day/mm2 (black line with 95% confidence intervals in gray). A direct fit of the master curve in (e) agrees well (red). (e) Growth tracks in (c) can be shifted horizontally (blue) to collapse onto a master curve (red), which is fitted by the Fermi function c1/(c2 + c3 e−c1t) with c1 = 4.4 ± 0.3 %/day, c2 = 0.077± 0.012 %/day/mm2, c3 = 19± 5 %/day/mm2. Inset with log-linear plot illustrates the deviation from an exponential law. (f) Magnification of the degrowth rates for time intervals after the initial feeding shows no obvious dependence on feeding history. Error bars represent the standard error of the mean. growth rates are smaller than in our case, which could be a species-specific effect or due to gut stuffing. Furthermore, it might also be related to the lower temperature of 12◦C, while our experiments are conducted at 20◦C. More importantly, the degrowth rates during starvation seem not to depend on the sizes of the worms in contrast to our data. Other groups have also measured growth dynamics and typically fitted exponential functions with constant growth rates (34, 71, 215). Gonz´alez-Est´evez et al. pooled all worms together and therefore their data cannot discriminate between constant and weakly size-dependent rates (71). Nevertheless, the value of 1.8 %/day for the degrowth rate agrees well with our results in the considered size range of 1 − 5 mm2. Thomas et al. tracked the growth of individual worms but did not explicitly analyze a size- dependence of the rates (215). They obtain values below 5 %/day and most of them lie in the range of 2 − 3 %/day, which is in good agreement with our data. Oviedo et al. even claim to find linear functions for growth and degrowth with size (150). In consequence, the absolute values for growth and degrowth rates become smaller in larger worms like in Fig. 5.5(d). Yet, otherwise the result does only roughly agree with our data, mainly for the case of starvation, see Appendix E.2. Although they even feed twice a week, they obtain very low growth rates, which are even lower than their degrowth rates. Finally, it has previously been claimed that nutritional status and not size determines the growth dynamics (71). Yet, the respective measurements might not be able to resolve this issue because it does not compare size matched worms of different feeding histories. In fact, our data with a controlled feeding history supports the opposite hypothesis. 81 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER Figure 5.6.: (a) Hypothetical case of growth and degrowth dynamics with steady state sizes (crosses). (b) Trends of the growth rates in terms of cell numbers for Smed obtained from fits to the growth rates of Fig. 5.5(d) and the conversion curve to cell numbers of Fig. 5.3(b). Note that gut stuffing might slightly change the obtained values. In summary, our measurements of growth dynamics agree in some cases quantitatively and in others qualitatively with studies published by other groups but also go signifi- cantly beyond. In particular, we were able to reveal the size dependence of the growth rates by establishing a strict protocol of feeding and imaging and a highly accurate image analysis. Furthermore, we were tracking individual worms and our measure- ments span the full range in size in contrast to the previous works discussed. Our analysis clearly shows that small worms show faster growth and degrowth dynamics than large worms. Fig. 5.6 illustrates why this is a non-trivial observation. Naively one could have assumed that there is one limiting quantity that makes the use of food less efficient in larger worms, resulting in a decreasing growth rate with size, see Fig. 5.6(a). Different amounts of food would result in a shift of the curve. In consequence, worms would approach a steady state size, depending on the feeding frequency (crosses). In contrast, the trends of the curves for Smed change between feeding and starvation and the worms either grow or degrow. Fig. 5.6(b) shows our result in terms of cell numbers. It suggests that there might be two different effects that depend in opposite ways on the size of the worm and each of which dominates for either starvation or maximum feeding. Stuffing effects as discussed in Sec. 5.2.2 might introduce correction factors to the obtained growth rates. However, we expect no change in the qualitative trends. In the next section, we explore three theoretical models that can account for the size-dependence of the growth rates. 82 0246−505Cell number in 106Growth rate (cell number) in %/ day(a)(b) feeding every weekstarvationWorm sizeGrowth rateXXless feedingmore feeding5.3 Theoretical descriptions of cell turnover dynamics and energy flux 5.3. Theoretical descriptions of cell turnover dynamics and energy flux Fig. 5.6(b) shows nontrivial growth dynamics in flatworms depending on feeding con- ditions. Growth corresponding to a change in cell number can be described by the two processes of cell division and cell loss with effective rates kdiv and kloss, respectively: N = kdivN − klossN . With this, the growth rates plotted in Fig. 5.5(d) are given by N /N = kdiv − kloss . (5.1) (5.2) Thus, K = kdiv − kloss has to depend on N such that it decreases with N for feeding and increases with N for starvation. One possible scenario to explain this behavior is a change in the fraction of stem cells. In fact, it has been reported that the neoblast fraction in Dugesia lugubris (110, 111) and Dugesia tigrina (13, 16, 18) decreases as the worm grows. A higher stem cell fraction in smaller worms would lead to a larger growth rate during feeding. Additionally, it might be associated with a higher basal cell turnover, yielding a faster degrowth rate in the absence of food. However, the difference in the neoblast fraction was estimated to be less than 10%, which can not account by far for the observed size dependence of the growth rates. Thus, it is rather unlikely that the fraction of neoblasts in Smed varies by a factor of 2 or 3 like the growth rates. In fact, preliminary experimental data obtained by the group of Jochen Rink suggests that the stem cell fraction stays rather constant in animals of different sizes. Feeding has a major effect on the growth dynamics. Therefore, we propose to consider the metabolic energy Et in the worm as a limiting factor that influences cell proliferation and cell death. At this point, we need to properly define this quantity, even though the conclusion will be largely independent of the exact definition. For the rest of the chapter, Et refers to the total amount of ATP and the ATP equivalent of any other molecule storing metabolic energy like glucose and lipids, whether it is found inside or outside the cells. Analogous descriptions can be found if only the freely available energy outside the cells is considered or if one takes into account the abundance of other limiting molecules like amino acids that need to be taken up by the food and that are necessary for the worm to stay healthy and alive. 83 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER In a minimal model, the total energy Et increases due to net influx Jf by feeding and decreases due to consumption by metabolic housekeeping with rate µ: ∂tEt = Jf − µN . (5.3) A typical value for the metabolic consumption per cell µ would be of the order of 10 pW as estimated for Schmidtea polychroa (133). In humans with 4· 1013 cells and an energy consumption of 107J/day (124), we estimate µ ≈ 1 pW. Further values obtained for 228 mammalian species from shrimp to elephant also show a decrease with size across the range of 1 − 10 pW (240). Eq. 5.3 assumes for simplicity that the energy stored in the dying cells can be completely taken up by the remaining cells. We could consider an additional term of the form −ρloss ec klossN , accounting for imperfect recycling upon cell death. Here, ec denotes the metabolic energy per cell and ρloss is the fraction of it that is lost per dying cell. The main conclusions of this chapter remain unchanged even for ρloss > 0. We define the metabolic energy per cell as ec = Et/N and find for its dynamics ∂tec = jf − µ − K ec . (5.4) Here, jf = Jf /N is the net influx per cell and the last term describes a dilution effect. As the worm grows, the same amount of energy has to be shared among a larger number of cells. In the following, we discuss three basic models on how the metabolic energy per cell might effect cell division and loss. Given the simplicity of the models, they all fit the noisy data reasonably well. Yet, they result in very different predictions about the respective variables and parameters such as metabolic consumption and storage of energy, which will be tested in future experiments. The models describe three distinct scenarios of energy storage: (i) dynamic energy storage, for which feeding increases the fraction of energy stored in the worm, (ii) energy storage of fixed proportion, for which the worm is not able to store additional amount of energy upon feeding, and (iii) size-dependent energy storage, for which the fraction of energy stored depends on the size of the worm and not explicitly on feeding. In the first model, the metabolic energy per cell ec changes as a direct read-out of size and feeding conditions and directly regulates cell division and cell loss. In the second and third model, the metabolic energy is quickly regulated to a physiologically preferred target value e0 by adjusting the cell turnover rates. Thereby, the mechanism implicitly draws on the idea of integral feedback control, which is commonly used in engineering applications to drive a dynamic variable to a pre-set value. 84 5.3 Theoretical descriptions of cell turnover dynamics and energy flux 5.3.1. Model 1: Dynamic energy storage In a most simple model for metabolic growth control, the cells are assumed to directly respond to the amount of metabolic energy per cell ec. If there is an excess in energy, cells divide more often, and if there is a lack of energy, the death rate increases. Let us consider a simple case, for which the growth rate depends linearly on ec: K = K0 (ec/es − 1) (5.5) with the constant parameters K0 and es, which determine the rate of growth and the energy, for which the worm switches between growth and degrowth, respectively. The change in energy ec as a function of ec is plotted in Fig. 5.7(a). During starvation periods, when jf = 0, the growth rate is decreasing, which requires ec < 0 (red curve). The maximum of ec is at ec = es/2 and from ec < 0 follows that µ > esK0/4. During feeding with jf > µ, the curve in Fig. 5.7(a) is shifted upwards and ec ends up in a regime, for which the organism grows (blue). If jf was constant, there would be a stable steady state with e∗ c > es for jf > µ and the system is in the growing regime. In order for the growth rate to decrease with worm size as seen in Fig. 5.6(b), the influx due to feeding jf (N ) must not be constant but has to be a decreasing function of N . c = es/2 +(cid:112)(es/2)2 + (jf − µ)es/K0. We see that e∗ Fig. 5.7(b) illustrates a time course of N , when going through several rounds of feeding and starvation, always switching at a certain size (horizontal lines). Especially in the beginning of the starvation interval, we see an overshoot, for which the worm still grows although the feeding has stopped. Nevertheless, we want to stress that the growth and degrowth behavior is rather generic. The growth and degrowth rates in Fig. 5.7(c) collapse and show the same size-dependence, irrespectively of the initial values for energy and cell number. Any perturbation decays quickly and there is no strong dependence on feeding history. We can fit this model to the experimental data, see Fig. 5.8(a). The plots shows the size dependence of the influx jf and illustrate that the metabolic energy per cell ec acts as a read-out for both feeding conditions and size at the same time. 85 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER Figure 5.7.: Model 1 assumes that cell division and cell death directly depend on the metabolic energy per cell ec, which represents a dynamic energy store. (a) During starvation, ec and thus the degrowth rate decreases. During feeding, ec approaches the growing regime. Note that e∗ √ c > es is not a steady state of the total system N ) decreases with N . (b) Time course of the cell because the influx jf (N ) = j0/(1 + number when switching between feeding (blue) and starvation (red) for N = 0.5 · 106 and N = 4.5 · 106, respectively (dashed lines). (c) We observe a generic dynamics, irrespective of the initial cell number, energy or feeding scheme. 86 0growthdegrowthfeedingstarvation02004006008001000012345Time in daysCell number in 106(a)(b)(c)Varying the intial cell number:Varying the intial energy per cell:Varying the switching between feeding and starvation:−202412345Cell number in 106Growth rate in %/day0−202412345Cell number in 106Growth rate in %/day0−202412345Cell number in 106Growth rate in %/day05.3 Theoretical descriptions of cell turnover dynamics and energy flux 5.3.2. Model 2: Fixed proportion energy storage We now assume that the energy per cell ec is quickly regulated to a physiologically preferred target value e0. In this scenario, there might still be specialized energy stores like fat cells but they are only formed proportionally to the worm size and not in response to feeding. Any metabolic energy outside the cells is also quickly regulated, which is typical for the metabolism of animals. For example, sugar levels in the human blood are under tight regulation by the insulin pathway and insulin-like molecules are found even in the simplest unicellular eukaryotes (114). Yet again in contrast to humans, here we assumed that no additional long-term storage cells are formed upon feeding. Instead, the metabolic energy is regulated by adjustment of cell division and cell death. We can picture an integral feedback scheme, according to which K changes depending on the difference between ec and e0: τK K = K0(ec/e0 − 1) (5.6) This control theoretic approach substantially differs from the case of model 1 in Eq. 5.5. Given a fast regulation to the target value e0 (τK → 0), K relaxes to K∗ = jf − µ e0 , (5.7) which defines the nullcline of ec = 0 according to Eq. 5.4. Fig. 5.6(b) shows that the degrowth rate is decreasing during starvation, where jf = 0. Thus, µ has to increase for smaller worms. Fig. 5.8(b) illustrates the size-dependence of µ based on our measurements. This can be interpreted in the sense that the metabolism is less efficient in smaller animals, which is in agreement with the typical metabolic sca- ling laws found across the animal kingdom (7, 190) and which have also been observed in flatworms (71, 92, 133). During feeding the growth rate decreases with size. Thus, jf has to decrease with N and even has to overcompensate for the opposite effect of µ. This suggests that food uptake is less efficient in larger animals, see Fig. 5.8(b). Taken together, we assumed that the metabolic energy is the limiting factor determined by the corresponding nutrition influx and consumption, to which turnover rates are adjusted accordingly. We obtained two functions, one for µ and one for jf , which depend on worm size in opposite ways and therefore can account for the opposite trends in the growth and degrowth dynamics. As a side note, one might question what is cause and what is consequence. While it is likely that the metabolic energy is the limiting factor during starvation periods, 87 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER Figure 5.8.: (a) Model 1 is characterized by energy stores that are filled and depleted depending on feeding and worm size. The stored energy per cell ec as well as the metabolic rate µ and the feeding influx jf are obtained by minimizing the variance between the experimental data and numerical solutions of our model. The values are given relative to the energy es, for which the worm switches between growth and degrowth. (b) Model 2 draws on energy stores with fixed proportions. We compute µ and jf relative to the energy per cell from the fits to the growth and degrowth rates in Fig. 5.5(d). The energy per cell ec = e0 is assumed to be constant. (c) In model 3 with size-dependent energy stores, the energy per cell ec changes in a size-dependent manner, while µ = µ0 and jf are constant. Degrowth and growth rates are fitted by the same function with a different amplitude corresponding to the feeding influx. (d) Basic scheme of model 3: During feeding, small worms invest their metabolic energy in growth, yet large worms store an increasing fraction of the available energy. During starvation, large worms degrow more slowly as they can deplete their energy stores. 88 02468012345Cell number in 106Feeding influx ( )01234500.511.52Cell number in 106Metabolic rate ( )02468012345Cell number in 106Feeding influx ( in %/day)02468101214012345Cell number in 106Feeding influx ( in %/day)01234500.511.52Cell number in 106Energy per cell ( )0123450123Cell number in 106Energy per cell ()01234501234Cell number in 106Metabolic rate ( in %/day)(b) Model 2: Fixed proportion energy storage012345−4−20246Cell number in 106Growth rate in %/ day(c) Model 3: Size-dependent energy storage012345−4−20246Cell number in 106Growth rate in percent / dayfeeding of small worms:storagegrowth++feeding of large worms:storagegrowthstarvation of large worms:storagemaintenance+012345050100150Cell number in 106Energy per cell ( in days)(d) Energy storage in model 301234500.511.52Cell number in 106Metabolic rate ( in %/day)(a) Model 1: Dynamic energy storage012345−4−20246Cell number in 106Growth rate in %/dayfeedingstarvation5.3 Theoretical descriptions of cell turnover dynamics and energy flux this is not necessarily the case for maximum feeding. In the presence of an abundance of food in the gut, cell division response could rather be limited by other factors as the maximum rate of DNA replication and the available number of stem cells. This would invert the argument: there would be a generic, yet size-dependent response of cell division (and maybe cell death) and the size dependence of the net influx jf is merely a consequence of it. 5.3.3. Model 3: Size-dependent energy storage In the scenario above, we introduced a constant target value e0 for the metabolic energy that determined the turnover rates. In our third and final model, we again consider a quick relaxation to such a target energy, but now this energy e0(N ) changes with worm size. For example, the fraction of energy-rich cells could increase in large worms. We again obtain Eq. 5.7 but now µ and jf are assumed to be constant for simplicity, while e0 depends on N . The three variables are plotted in Fig. 5.8(b). Even with only one size-dependent quantity, we obtain a reasonable fit to the data. If additionally µ was allowed to change as suggested by the measurements of metabolic scaling laws (7, 92, 133, 190), the fits would even improve. The basic logic of such a mechanism based on energy storage cells is shown in Fig. 5.8(d). While small worms invest all available energy into growth, large worms store part of their energy uptake and thus grow more slowly. In consequence, large worms deplete these energy stores during starvation and initially degrow more slowly. Importantly, we assume that the size of the stores scales with worm size. Thus, only an effective size-dependence of growth and degrowth is observed, but no explicit dependence on feeding history. 5.3.4. Discussion of the turnover models We have explored three models that are based on very different assumptions and dif- fer greatly in the microscopic details, yet they all can account for the observed size- dependent growth behavior. This is an interesting observation, which one should gen- erally take into consideration when comparing microscopic models to more macroscopic data. A theoretical model is typically associated with a specific coarse-graining level. As a necessary condition, it needs to agree with observations on larger scales, but this is not sufficient for the model to be unique. In order to distinguish between several microscopic models, one usually needs measurements on the same level. 89 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER In our case, the theory makes specific testable predictions about the influx, consump- tion and storage of energy, as illustrated in Fig 5.8. In close collaboration with our experimental colleagues, we have planned further experiments to measure these quan- tities and to parametrize the models. First, it needs to be verified that the fraction of stem cells is approximately constant in Smed and cannot explain the growth dynamics. Furthermore, our collaborators are conducting experiments at the time of writing to determine metabolic rates and feeding influx. Additionally, they aim to identify po- tential stores for the metabolic energy and probe the effects of inhibiting them. The existence of fat cells has already been reported for other flatworm species (93). Fig. 5.4 already shows that the stuffing peak is approximately proportional to worm size. If therefore the average amount of food that becomes available per cell is independent of the size of the worm, it will support the third model. Furthermore, we have discussed in Section 5.2.1 that the scaling laws for worm mass and total protein mass might also be in agreement with an increased storage of lipids or glycogen in larger worms. It remains to be answered whether the scaling of metabolic rates and storage cells can explain the growth and degrowth behavior in Smed . Even though the models are highly simplified and gut stuffing might introduce cor- rections, we can extract order of magnitude estimates from the fits to the data. For example, we can estimate from all three models that each cell stores on average as much energy as needed to maintain it for approximately ec/µ = 50 to 150 days. In compari- son, the metabolic rate in humans is µ ≈ 1 pW and the total energy stored in human fat cells (as the main energy storage) is 4 · 108 J (124). Thus, ec = 10−5 J, which amounts to a similar ratio of ec/µ = 130 days. Furthermore, based on measurements in the flat- worm Schmidtea polychroa and on the typical metabolic scaling laws (124, 133, 240), we expect the metabolic rate of Smed to be in the range of µ ≈ 10 pW per cell. Thus, according to our models, each cell stores as much as ec ≈ 10−5 to 10−4 J. Note that this estimate is based on the assumption of perfect recycling of the energy upon cell death. For imperfect recycling, the value is reduced. Metabolic energy can be stored in various ways: in lipids or glycogen, in specialized fat cells or distributed among many different cell types. An interesting observation in this respect is the presence of germ line precursor cells in asexual flatworms. Cells without a purpose should vanish during evolution. Thus, we might speculate that the germ line precursors in asexual worms might have an additional function for the metabolic housekeeping. In analogy to the third model, they are especially prominent in large worms and can potentially serve as energy stores during starvation. 90 5.4 Control logic for cell turnover and growth 5.4. Control logic for cell turnover and growth 5.4.1. Measuring cell turnover on various scales So far, we have investigated how the cellular behavior might depend on feeding condi- tions and worm size but we have not explicitly distinguished between the adjustment of cell division on the one hand and cell loss or death on the other hand. In this section, we now discuss how these individual processes might be controlled. In order to unravel the control logic, we propose experiments on various scales, ranging from the level of individual cells to a whole tissue and to the averaged turnover dynamics across the entire worm. The main questions are: • Does feeding and worm size affect rather cell proliferation or cell death? • How do both processes influence each other? • To what extent does aging play a role on the cellular scale? The first question will be addressed mainly at the cellular level and the second and third question at the tissue level. Turnover dynamics at the cellular level. -- Previous measurements indicate that there is an catabolic default state during starvation periods, in which cell loss dominates over cell division. Upon feeding, there are short-term mitotic bursts leading to growth, as sketched in Fig. 5.9 (12, 13, 16, 71, 101, 139, 142, 170). However, it is not clear whether the cell loss rate also changes as part of the feeding response and to what extent division and loss depends on feeding history. It has been suggested that apoptosis rates might in fact increase after the flatworms have been fed, especially after long starvation periods, as a means of cell renewal (71, 159). Assessing these questions is complicated by the fact that cell loss is poorly defined. Apart from the classical apoptosis pathway many other processes might contribute to cell loss such as other mechanisms of programmed cell death but also uncontrolled shedding of epidermis cells. In contrast, cell division can be well characterized. In Appendix E.3 we discuss a measurement scheme to extract division rates. By comparing cell division to worm growth, we will also be able to determine to what extent cell death rates are regulated. Turnover dynamics at the tissue level. -- By monitoring the turnover dynamics in epidermis cells, we can exemplify how cell addition and removal work together to result 91 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER Figure 5.9.: A hypothetical model that comprises (i) an catabolic default state, for which the cell loss rate (dashed green) is larger than the cell division rate (solid red), and (ii) short proliferation responses upon feeding. in a well controlled size regulation. In the next section, we introduce a respective measurement protocol. We show preliminary data, which suggests that cell death depends on the age of the cells. We also discuss further experiments to confirm the effect of aging and to investigate how the individual turnover processes influence each other. On the one hand, turnover could be a rather stochastic process, in which cells are inserted in the tissue and deleted independently, yet on average at balanced rates. On the other hand, insertion and deletion could be tightly linked such that a cell is preferentially removed in the presence of a new cell that replaces it. We suggest a double labeling experiment which can potentially distinguish the two control paradigms. Turnover dynamics at the organismal level. -- After constructing a comprehensive model on how turnover and growth is regulated based on the experiments on the cellular and the tissue scale, we can validate the model by measurements across the entire worm. To this end, we adapt a protocol that has originally been developed to analyze cell turnover in human brain cells (203). In Appendix E.4, we provide the theoretical framework to set up the experiment. 5.4.2. Analyzing turnover of the epidermis as an example tissue Epidermis cells as the outermost skin cells can be non-invasively labeled by soaking the worms in CFSE solution (carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl ester). It has been observed that the labeled cells disappear within days as a result of turnover of the epithelial tissue. From this experiments, we can estimate turnover rates of the 92 Loss / Division rateTime(i)(i)(ii)5.4 Control logic for cell turnover and growth tissue and investigate whether older cells are more prone to die. We will also propose a protocol with two consecutive labeling pulses, which might enable us to understand how insertion and deletion of cells is coordinated. 5.4.2.1. Measuring turnover rates by single pulse labeling Cell turnover processes. -- We describe turnover in a cell population by three different processes: (i) deletion of cells, (ii) insertion of cells and (iii) replacement of cells (i.e. coupled insertion and deletion), see Fig. 5.10(a). Note that deletion potentially includes many different processes: the induced removal by long range signals or quorum sensing in the tissue, cell-autonomous decisions as well as uncontrolled shedding. In order to measure turnover dynamics, we labeled all cells in the epidermis by soaking in CFSE and counted the fraction of labeled cells in the field of view after time t, see Fig. 5.10(b)-(c). The experiments were performed by Sarah Mansour in the group of Jochen Rink. The author analyzed the data by automatically counting the cells with a custom MATLAB code. Dynamics of a labeled cell population. -- Let us consider the number density n(a) of cells of a certain age a. The total number of cells N in the tissue and the number of labeled cells N(cid:96) are given by (cid:90) ∞ (cid:90) ∞ N = n(a) da , N(cid:96) = n(a) da . (5.8) Due to cell turnover, these quantities change in time as follows 0 t N = (ki − ¯kd) N N(cid:96) = −(¯kd(cid:96) + ¯kr(cid:96)) N(cid:96) . (5.9) (5.10) (cid:90) ∞ Here, we consider the rate for cell insertion ki and average rates for the replacement of labeled cells ¯kr(cid:96) as well as for the deletion of labeled and unlabeled cells ¯kd(cid:96) and ¯kd: ¯kr(cid:96) = kr(a) n(a) t N(cid:96) da , ¯kd(cid:96) = kd(a) n(a) t N(cid:96) da , ¯kd = kd(a) n(a) 0 N (cid:90) ∞ (cid:90) ∞ da . (5.11) (5.12) When taking snapshots of only part of the tissue, we do not obtain absolute numbers but the fraction of labeled cells in the field of view Φ(cid:96) = N(cid:96)/N , which obeys Φ(cid:96) = −(cid:0)¯kr(cid:96) + ki + (¯kd(cid:96) − ¯kd)(cid:1) Φ(cid:96) . The fraction of labeled cells might not only decrease due to replacement (first term), but also due to a dilution effect as unlabeled cells get inserted into the tissue (sec- ond term). Furthermore, the third term arises if labeled cells and unlabeled cells are 93 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER Figure 5.10.: (a) We distinguish three processes of cell turnover. (b) Labeled epider- mis cells (CFSE staining - green) disappear within a few days due to turnover. Nuclei are labelled in blue (Hoechst staining). (c) Measurement scheme of the CFSE labeling experiment. (d) Fraction of labeled cells at a certain time after the label is applied. We fit an exponential curve with a constant tissue turnover rate ktis = 0.27/day (dashed blue) as well as linear function corresponding to a fixed life time of the cells amx = 7.8 days (red). (e) Measurement scheme with irradiated (stem cell depleted) worms. (f) For T = 1 day, the turnover in irradiated worms (green) compares to non-irradiated worms (black). Yet, for T = 5 days after irradiation, the labeled epidermis cells do not vanish from the tissue anymore (red). All measurements were performed by Sarah Mansour in the group of Jochen Rink. The author analyzed the data and fitted the models. 94 (a)(b)(i) deletion(ii) insertion(iii) replacementas independent processesas tightly coupleddeletion & insertion(c)labelingmeasuringTime t(e)(d)(f)irradiatingmeasuringTtlabelingTime t in days0246Label fraction00.20.40.60.8101234Time t in daysLabel fraction00.20.40.60.815.4 Control logic for cell turnover and growth deleted at different rates (e.g. in an age-dependent manner). In contrast, if cells are deleted stochastically (e.g. according to a Poisson process), kd(a) is constant and the corresponding term vanishes: ¯kd(cid:96) − ¯kd = 0. Feeding conditions and the sizes of the worms are approximately constant during the course of the experiment. Thus, if the turnover does not depend on the age of the cells (i.e. kd and kr are constant), we can expect an exponential solution Φ(cid:96) = Φ(cid:96),0 e−t ktis to Eq. 5.12 with a constant rate ktis = kr + ki. Yet, the preliminary data in Fig. 5.10(d) does not strongly support an exponential law (dashed blue). Another limiting case is that cells have a fixed live span and only die at age amx. Thus, the rates of deletion and replacement are kd(a) = δ(a − amx) and kr(a) = δ(a − amx). Note that the worms only grow and degrow by a few percent per day, such that we can assume that the tissue size only changes very little in comparison to the turnover time scales of a few days. In consequence, the age distribution n(a) will be approximately homogeneous and the solution to Eq. 5.12 a linear function Φ(cid:96) = Φ(cid:96),0 − t/amx. This simple linear model (solid red) appears to agree better with the data in Fig. 5.10(d). In fact, the truth might be in between the two limiting cases. This would resonate with an age-dependent turnover of the cells in the tissue such that old cells are more prone to deletion or replacement. The time dependence enters because the age distribution of labeled cells is shifted over time. In order to extract in what way the cellular age influences deletion or replacement and which of the two processes is mostly affected, we need more sophisticated experi- ments as discussed below. Also note that the presented data is only very preliminary and has to be confirmed by further measurements. Labeled cell fraction in irradiated worms. -- We briefly comment on a second pilot experiment by Sarah Mansour, see Fig. 5.10 (e)-(f). Here, the measurement started at varying times T after the worms were depleted of all stem cells by γ-irradiation. First, we observe that tissue turnover is not directly affected by the loss of stem cells: for small T the label fraction (green) decreases in the same way as for non-irradiated worms (black). Labeled cells are replaced by progenitor cells, which were not deleted by irradiation. Thus, there seems not to be a long-range signaling effect from the stem cell pool. In contrast, T = 5 days after irradiation (red), the fraction of labeled cells does not decrease anymore. In conclusion, dividing cells (which are affected by irradiation) or corresponding signals need 5 days to reach the epidermal tissue. 95 5. QUANTIFYING FLATWORM GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER 5.4.2.2. Monitoring cell turnover by double pulse labeling We propose a double-labeling experiment using a second labeling pulse of a different marker (DDAO-SE) applied after a short time interval ∆t, see Fig. 5.11(a). As a result, there are two labeled cell populations -- cells with both labels N2 and young cells with (cid:90) ∞ only the second label N1: (cid:90) t+∆t N1 = n(a) da , N2 = n(a) da . (5.13) t t+∆t Similar to Eq. 5.12, the ratio Φ12 = N1/N2 obeys Φ12 = −(cid:0)(¯kd1 − ¯kd2) + (¯kr1 − ¯kr2)(cid:1) Φ12 , (5.14) which includes the deletion and replacement rates of both labeled cell populations. Additionally, we propose an irradiation experiment as depicted in Fig. 5.11(b). For this, we choose the time interval T such that there are still new cells arriving in the epidermis during ∆t but not so after the second labeling pulse. According to our measurements with a single label in Fig. 5.10(f), T + ∆t ≈ 5. In consequence, (¯kr1 − ¯kr2) = 0 during the time interval t: Φ12,irr = −(¯kd1 − ¯kd2) Φ12 . (5.15) This shows that Φ12,irr only changes for age-dependent deletion rates. Thus, by com- paring the dynamics of Φ12 in non-irradiated and Φ12,irr in irradiated worms given by Eq. 5.14 and 5.15, respectively, we can deduce whether deletion or replacement depends on the age of the cell, as illustrated in Fig. 5.11(c). If Φ12,irr changes according to a time-dependent rate, deletion is related to the age of the cells. If instead only the dynamics of Φ12 are determined by a time-dependent rate, replacement relies on the age of the cells. Furthermore, we can extract actual rates for the individual processes by comparing the results to the previous experiments. For example, ¯kd2 + ¯kr2 in Eq. 5.14 is equivalent to ¯kr(cid:96) + ¯kd(cid:96) of the experiment with a single label. By combining these measurements, we can find the functional relationship for how deletion and replacement changes with the age of the cells. The same experiments can be performed in starving and well fed animals to reveal the connection between feeding status and turnover rates. One hypothesis would be that there is no insertion during starvation, yet replacement dominates and the tissue slowly shrinks due to a small deletion rate. After feeding, insertion leads to growth of the tissue. 96 5.5 Summary Figure 5.11.: Double pulse labeling scheme in (a) non-irradiated and (b) irradiated animals. (c) The double labeling experiment allows us to deduce whether deletion or replacement depend on the age of the cells. 5.5. Summary Our aim is to study cell turnover and growth in a comprehensive way, bridging the scales from a single cell to the average behavior at the level of the organism. For this, we have carefully designed several experiments to determine the flatworm size and to characterize its growth dynamics. In particular, we developed a protocol for precise measurement of the worm area based on the analysis of movie sequences with a custom MATLAB routine. The data was compared to previous studies, which in parts yielded controversial results. We observed that the growth and degrowth rates are dependent on worm size. Smaller worms grow and shrink faster. This resonates with the picture that small worms might be more juvenile with a potentially higher turnover rate and a different metabolism (71, 111). Based on the idea that the available metabolic energy is the main deter- minant for growth, we have developed three distinct classes of microscopic models, which can all be fitted to the macroscopic growth data. The models describe different paradigms of energy storage and make specific predictions that are tested by our col- laborators in current experiments. In particular, they also differ in the way energy inflow (i.e. digestion of food) and energy outflow (i.e. metabolic consumption) varies with size, which directly relates to the question about the limits to growth. Finally, we propose further experiments, which can unravel the control logic of cell and tissue turnover. We provide the theoretical framework and discuss first preliminary data suggesting an age-dependent death of cells. The experiments will be performed in the laboratory of Jochen Rink by the author and other members of the group. 97 (a)irradiatingmeasuringTt1. labeling2. labelingΔtmeasuringt1. labeling(CFSE)2. labeling(DDAO-SE)Δtwild-typetime interval tno age-dependenceonly replacement is age-dependentonly deletion is age-dependenttime interval ttime interval tage-dependecies of replacement & deletion add uptime interval ttime interval tirradiatedage-dependecies of replacement & deletion cancel(b)(c)6. Summary and outlook In this thesis, we analyzed various aspects of growth and body plan scaling, drawing particular inspiration from the flatworm Schmidtea mediterranea (Smed ) as a model animal. For this purpose, we combined theoretical descriptions and analysis of experi- mental data. As a first approach, we analyzed previously proposed mechanisms for self-organized pattern formation as well as pattern scaling in Chapter 2. We systematically extracted the requirements for scaling and demonstrated that they are challenged by the fas- cinating regeneration and re-patterning capabilities of flatworms. On this basis, we presented a minimal model for fully self-organized and self-scaling pattern formation in Chapter 3. This mechanism is capable of spontaneously generating concentration gradients and expression regions of involved molecules that robustly adjust to the size of the system. In the future, it will be interesting to further compare the theoretical framework and the derived predictions to the Wnt/β-catenin system, which is associated with head-tail (AP) polarity in Smed (4, 9, 81, 82). Preliminary measurements by our collaborators indicate that the β-catenin gradient as well as expression profiles of various Wnts in fact scale with worm size. Our theory enables us to interpret the data and to suggest additional experiments to unravel the mechanism of scaling in flatworms. Further beyond, the results might also enrich the discussions on signaling gradients in other systems, such as the developing fly wing, for which it is still a matter of debate how scaling is established (11, 26, 55, 233). Smed only recently evolved to become a model organism, thus the basic mechanisms for axis specification are far from being well understood (117). It is known that components of the Wnt/β-catenin system are especially present in the tail (4, 9, 81, 82). However, there could be also an additional patterning system originating from the head or even a compartmentalization by several systems along the body axis. If there are several anterior-posterior (AP) polarity systems, how do they interact? And to what extent is the patterning self-organized or relies on pre-existing cues such as a polarized tissue or wound-specific signals after amputation? We are currently analyzing a large data set 98 comprising the spatial changes in gene expression after RNAi treatment and expression time courses during regeneration in order to answer these questions. Perpendicular to the AP axis, there are also two more body axes in dorsal-ventral and medial-lateral direction (117). How do the patterning systems for the different body axis influence each other? Is there a hierarchy of axis formation or do the axes emerge simultaneously? One particular curious case is the formation of a straight midline as an important signaling center. The experimental data suggests that a repulsive signal from the body margin positions the midline (3, 117, 121). Yet, is it sufficient to account for this narrow, straight row of distinct cells, which tends to re-emerge from the anterior and posterior poles during regeneration? As a complementary approach, we have started to design a model explaining midline formation on the basis of cell proliferation and resulting cellular flows in the tissue. Besides these long-range patterning mechanisms that are classically assumed to rely on secreted, motile molecules, there are also other polarity cues. For example, the planar- cell-polarity (PCP) system is based on direct cell-cell interactions and results in cellular polarisation consistently across the tissue. In order to determine the coupling between both mechanisms, we have started analyzing the motility of flatworms, when various Wnt-pathway components have been knocked out by RNAi feeding, see Chapter 4. Resulting movement phenotypes report on a dysfunctional cilia carpet associated with an impaired PCP system. For a further, more detailed investigation of worm motility, we adapted principal com- ponent analysis to apply it to the highly deformable worm body. We could demonstrate that during normal gliding motion worms steer their path by bending in the preferred direction of movement. Additionally, we provided the first quantitative account of an alternative motility mode, called inchworming. This appears to be a tightly controlled behavioral response to impaired cilia functionality with a characteristic frequency of about 1/4 Hz. Such stereotypic behaviors have been previously described in the much simpler nematode C. elegans (207, 208, 209). It is a fascinating observation that more complex organisms such as flatworms still show very generic motility patterns, which might have emerged during evolution as an optimized strategy and are expected to relate to the structure of the muscular plexus and the nervous system. Similarly, we were able to demonstrate the applicability of shape mode analysis to the variable head shapes between different species. We are planning to extend this analysis to many more species of the large flatworm collection in the laboratory of Jochen Rink. As both, spe- cific morphologies and specific movement strategies, are expected to emerge due to the 99 6. SUMMARY AND OUTLOOK evolutionary pressure in the respective environmental niche, our analysis provides the basis for future research relating form and function. In the last chapter, we quantified growth and turnover dynamics in flatworms. Interes- tingly, we obtained size-dependent growth rates. Small worms appear to grow and degrow faster than large worms. This particular growth and degrowth behavior of the worms is the coarse-grained result from the underlying processes of cell division and cell loss. Thus, we devised several microscopic models describing specific rules on the cellular scale to explain the observed growth dynamics on the macroscopic level of the organism. The models are based on the idea that there is a limiting quantity that "Nothing in biology makes sense except in the light of evolution." -- ditto, Theodosius Dobzhansky, 1973 (41) (i) is provided by feeding, (ii) is permanently con- sumed by the cells and (iii) affects the division and loss rates of cells. As an example, we expli- citly consider the metabolic energy as the limiting quantity. All of our three models fit the growth data equally well. Importantly, each model is based on distinct assumptions on how the energy is stored and how the energy availability affects the division and loss rates. Furthermore, each model makes specific predictions about how the three considered processes of energy influx by feeding, energy storage and energy consumption have to depend on the size of the worm to account for the measured growth data. With this result in mind, we contribute to the design of future experiments that will enable us to distinguish between the models. Thereby, we aim to bridge scales by providing an explanation for the organismal growth dynamics on the macroscopic level in terms of cellular behavior on the microscopic scale. The outcome might also hint at systemic limitations to growth. For example, if the food uptake is size-dependent and relatively decreases with worm size, there will be an upper limit at which the worm is not capable to sustain growth anymore. It then poses the question whether this is a physical limit set by constraints of the worm body or whether evolution has not selected for a more efficient uptake because worms anyways do not grow bigger for other reasons. Similarly, energy stores that depend on either size or feeding will trigger further investigations on the specific cells that store the energy. Are there specialized fat cells or does a broad range of cells store the energy? An interesting idea is related to the formation of the germ line. For sexual flatworms, there might be a tradeoff between growth and the development of a reproductive system. Small worms would rather grow to survive, large worms would rather invest in reproduction. Yet, germ line precursor cells still exist in the asexual strain used in the experiments. From an 100 evolutionary viewpoint, this might hint at a dual role of these cells, suggesting that they are involved in growth control or energy storage. The level of detail in the theory reflected the coarse-graining level of the experimental data. In a next step, we aim to go beyond and include further measurements to dissect the control logic of growth and cell turnover. Which of the two processes of cell division and loss is affected by feeding status and worm size in which way? How do the two processes influence each other? To what extent are these turnover processes related to aging of the cells as well as aging of the organism? There are many open questions and we started looking into some of them. For example, we have discussed a theoretical framework for measurements from the cellular to organismal scale and also analyzed preliminary data, which suggests an age-dependent replacement of cells. Eventually, we aim to develop a comprehensive picture of how cell turnover and organism growth is controlled. This thesis addresses various aspects of growth, cell turnover and scalable body plan patterning in flatworms. It illustrates the sheer diversity of biological processes, which are fascinating for biologists and physicists alike. Within a collaboration between ex- perimentalists and theoreticians, we applied physical concepts to quantitatively analyze and interpret experimental data. Importantly, the gained insights enabled us to ask new questions and to suggest future experiments, which will ultimately help to grow our general understanding of homeostasis and growth, development and regeneration in multicellular organisms. 101 A. Reaction-diffusion systems: fixed points and scaling A.1. Morphogen dynamics with linear degradation A.1.1. Reaction, diffusion, advection and dilution Here, we consider general morphogen dynamics in a growing tissue. We assume that the morphogens are produced by a source term ν = ν((cid:126)r) and spread in the system with an effective diffusion coefficient D while being subject to linear degradation with rate β. The dynamics can be described by the following convection-diffusion equation for the morphogen concentration C = C(t, (cid:126)r) (11, 31) ∂tC = D ∇2 C − β C + ν − ∇(cid:0)(cid:126)u C(cid:1) . (A.1) The last term corresponds to dilution and convection due to tissue growth with a velocity field (cid:126)u = (cid:126)u(t, (cid:126)r). Spreading of morphogens from a localized source results in graded concentration pro- files. Many systems can be considered to be homogeneous with respect to all but one direction (e.g. the x-direction). In this case, the graded profiles C = C(t, x) only depend on the respective spatial coordinate and the differential equation simplifies to ∂tC = D ∂2 = D ∂2 x C − β C + ν − ux∂xC − C∇(cid:126)u x C − (β + ∂yuy + ∂zuz) C + ν − ∂x(uxC) . (A.2) Note that dilution by growth in the directions perpendicular to the graded profile can effectively be described by a degradation term. For slow growth dynamics, we can neglect the convection-dilution terms and recover Eq. 2.1. A.1.2. Steady state solution neglecting tissue growth The steady state solution of Eq. A.2 can be found in (31). Yet, often the effect of tissue growth is considered to be negligible or a second order perturbative effect to the solution of Eq. 2.1. Thus, let us consider this limit of slow tissue growth. Furthermore, D and 102 A.1 Morphogen dynamics with linear degradation β are assumed to be constant in space across the tissue and constant in time within the time scale of the morphogen dynamics. As a result, the morphogen concentration approaches a steady state profile of the form C∗(x) = c1 exp(x/λ) + c2 exp(−x/λ) . The steady state solution for reflecting boundary conditions is given by for 0 ≤ x < w for w ≤ x ≤ L sinh(L/λ) cosh(L/λ − x/λ) C∗(x) = cosh(x/λ) α β In the limit of a small source and a large system (w (cid:28) λ, λ (cid:28) L), the steady state simplifies to sinh(L/λ) sinh(w/λ) 1 − sinh(L/λ−w/λ) (cid:40)e−x/λ C∗(x) ≈ α w√ D β 2 e−L/λ for x (cid:28) L for x = L . (A.3) (A.4) (A.5) (A.6) (A.7) (A.8) The square-root of D and β in the amplitude also emerges if there is no degradation in the source region, see Appendix A.1.4. A.1.3. Relaxation to the steady state The degradation rate defines the time scale of relaxation to the steady state of Eq. 2.1. Let us consider a concentration C(t, x) = C∗(x) + c(t, x) that deviates from the steady state by a perturbation c(t, x). The dynamics of c(t, x) are described by ∂t c = D ∂2 x c − β c . The concentration in Fourier space c = c(t, s) obeys ∂t c = −(cid:0)(2πs)2D + β(cid:1) c ⇒ c = c,0 e −(cid:0)(2πs)2D+β(cid:1)t and the back-transform yields (see Eq. B.7 for details) c(t, x) = e−βt dx(cid:48) c(0, x(cid:48)) −(x(cid:48)−x)2 4Dt√ e 4πDt . (cid:90) ∞ −∞ Besides the term for diffusive spreading that homogenizes the initial perturbation c(0, x), there is an exponential damping term. Thus, the perturbation of the steady state C∗ decays on a time scale of 1/β. 103 A. REACTION-DIFFUSION SYSTEMS: FIXED POINTS & SCALING A.1.4. Steady state without morphogen degradation in the source The reaction-diffusion equation without morphogen degradation in the source region is ∂tC = D ∂2 x C − β C Θ(x − w) + α Θ(w − x) . (A.9) With reflecting boundary conditions as in Eq. 2.2, we obtain  C∗(x) = √ √ α w Dβ tanh(L/λ−w/λ) α w Dβ sinh(L/λ−w/λ) 2D (w2 − x2) + α cosh(L/λ − x/λ) for 0 ≤ x < w for w ≤ x ≤ L (A.10) While we obtain a power law inside the source, the expression outside the source is identical to the limit w (cid:28) λ of Eq. A.4. A.2. Gradient scaling with expander A.2.1. On the scaling with an autonomously controlled expander We consider a three-dimensional domain of volume V = AL, in which the graded morphogen profile forms along the x-direction of length L, whereas A denotes the cross-sectional area. Now, we aim to achieve scaling with respect to some part of the system L1 with L = L1 + L2. For example, L1 could be the target tissue without the morphogen source (if L2 = w) or the whole system (if L2 = 0). The expander dynamics are described by ∂tE = DE ∇2 E − βE E + νE (A.11) with a constant diffusion term DE and the terms for degradation βE = βE(x) and production νE = νE(x) that depend on the position in the tissue. In the limit of a fast diffusing expander, the general steady state of Eq. A.11 is given by where (cid:90) (cid:104)βE(cid:105) = 1 V E∗ = (cid:104)νE(cid:105) /(cid:104)βE(cid:105) , βE dV and (cid:104)νE(cid:105) = (cid:90) 1 V (A.12) sE dV (A.13) denote the spatial averages. In order to achieve scaling of the morphogen profile with respect to L1, the expander level has to be a function of L1 in the steady state. Hence, (cid:104)νE(cid:105) and (cid:104)βE(cid:105) must not depend on L1 in the same way. 104 A.2 Gradient scaling with expander If the expander is degraded everywhere in the system part of length L1 und produced in a source of constant width wE like in Eq. 2.9, we recover the result from Eq. 2.10 by computing (cid:104)βE(cid:105) = βE A L1 , (cid:104)νE(cid:105) = V αE A wE V . (A.14) The steady state of the expander would be a function of L1 and thus could couple to the morphogen dynamics to generate scaling. Analogously, degradation could happen only at the boundary in a stripe of width wE and production might be turned on everywhere along the length L1, thus (cid:104)βE(cid:105) = βE A wE V would also make E∗ a function of L1. (cid:104)νE(cid:105) = , αE A L1 V (A.15) A.2.2. Scaling by expander feedback with a switch-like production We assume that the expander is suppressed by the morphogen in a switch-like manner according to Eq. 2.9 and discuss implications for scaling and robustness of the feedback schemes. By combining Eq. 2.14 and the steady state solution for reflecting boundary conditions given by Eq. 2.3, we obtain sinh(w/λ∗) sinh(L/λ∗) α β∗ cosh(wE/λ∗) = Cth . (A.16) We can derive a relationship between β∗ and E∗ by replacing w∗ E using Eq. 2.15 β∗ = α Cth sinh(w/λ∗) sinh(L/λ∗) cosh (cid:18) βE L E∗ (cid:19) αE λ∗ . (A.17) In order to illustrate the behavior of the feedback system, we are considering the two limiting cases of (i) a scaling morphogen source with w = χwL and (ii) a constant morphogen source. For both, we assume that there exists a perfectly scaling steady state with λ∗ = χλL and a constant scaling factor χλ. Next, we show what this implies for the coupling between expander and morphogen and discuss the consequences. (i) For a scaling morphogen source, the following relation between β∗ and E∗ has to hold in order for the morphogen profile to scale in the steady state: β∗ = α Cth sinh(χw/χλ) sinh(1/χλ) cosh . (A.18) (cid:18) βE αEχλ E∗(cid:19) The coefficient χλ is a free parameter encoding the effect of the expander on β. Note that it is not possible to achieve scaling by only adjusting the diffusion coefficient D 105 A. REACTION-DIFFUSION SYSTEMS: FIXED POINTS & SCALING instead of β because this equation does not depend on D. Eq. A.18 challenges the stability of the feedback loop because the expander has a suppressing effect on the morphogen (at least in the steady state), while according to our Eq. 2.9 the morphogen also suppresses the expander. Thus, this feedback tends to be unstable. (ii) For a constant morphogen source, we obtain (cid:32) sinh(w(cid:112)β/D) β (cid:33)∗ = α Cth sinh(1/χλ) cosh . (A.19) (cid:18) βE αEχλ E∗(cid:19) Now, either of both, β or D, can be adjusted for scaling. The question on the stability is a bit more complicated than in the case above, where an increase in β results in a decrease of the morphogen level everywhere in the system. In contrast, for example, an increase in D results in a decrease of the morphogen level close to the morphogen source and an increase at the other side of the system because the morphogen is dis- tributed more homogeneously. In consequence, the feedback can be stable in a limited size range, as long as the resulting expander source is sufficiently far away from the morphogen source. As the size of the expander source changes stronger than linearly with L (compare to Eq. 2.10), the system will eventually reach a size at which this is not fulfilled anymore. Analogously, if β is adjusted, there also is a size limit. At this size, β is too small such that the effect of E on β is positive according to Eq. A.19. The size limit corresponds to λ larger than w, which is likely the case for most of the systems as w is kept constant. A.2.3. Scaling by expander feedback with a graded production The step-like production term in Eq. 2.12 yields rather complicated relationships be- tween expander and morphogen dynamics, see Eq. A.18 and A.19. Instead, when considering a non-linear production term ∂tE(t, x) = DE ∂2 x E(t, x) − βE E(t, x) + αE C(x)h (A.20) with an arbitrary real number h, one obtains analogous results in a more general and much clearer fashion. The exponent h can be positive or negative, corresponding to an enhancing or a repressing effect on the source size, respectively. The term can be understood as an approximation to a Hill function for concentrations below the saturation. The expander concentration in the steady state for the limit of fast diffusion is (cid:90) L/λ∗ E∗ = αE λ∗ βE L 0 106 C∗(x(cid:48))h dx(cid:48) with x(cid:48) = x/λ∗ . (A.21) A.3 Linear stability analysis of a Turing system Again, we will distinguish between the limiting cases of (i) a scaling morphogen source and (ii) a morphogen source of constant size. (i) For a scaling source, we obtain from Eq. 2.3 (cid:18) α β∗ (cid:19)h I1(L/λ∗) ⇒ β∗ ∝ E∗ −1/h , E∗ = αE βE (A.22) where I1 is a short-hand form of the integral term. In analogy to the switch-like source in Section A.2.2, we cannot obtain scaling by solely adjusting the diffusion properties. If the degradation rate is adjusted, the steady state tends to be unstable, irrespective of the exponent h, which characterizes whether the morphogen has an enhancing or suppressing effect. (ii) If we assume w is constant, it follows (cid:32) α sinh(w(cid:112)β/D) (cid:33)∗ h I2(L/λ∗) + O(w/λ∗)2 E∗ = αE βE β ⇒ (β D)∗ ∝ E∗ −2/h for w (cid:28) λ∗ (A.23) (A.24) with I2 denoting the integral. A corresponding expression like in Eq. A.24 can be derived without the limit w (cid:28) λ if there is no morphogen degradation in the source, see Appendix A.1.4. As before, there can be a stable scaling fixed point if either β or D is controlled, yet only in a limited size range. A.3. Linear stability analysis of a Turing system A.3.1. Eigenvalues of the linearized reaction-diffusion matrix The linearized reaction-diffusion system in Fourier space given by Eq. 1.2 is character- ized by the 2 × 2-matrix Ms in Eq. 1.4: (cid:33) (cid:32)M 1 s M 2 s M 3 s M 4 s Ms = (A.25) The two eigenvalues qI s of Ms determine the linear stability of the homogeneous steady state, about which the system is linearized. If the real parts of both eigenvalues s , qII are negative, the steady state is stable, otherwise the steady state is unstable. 107 A. REACTION-DIFFUSION SYSTEMS: FIXED POINTS & SCALING Figure A.1.: (a) The trace-determinant plot summarizes the properties of the two eigenvalues of the 2 × 2-matrix Ms. (b) The two eigenvalues of the matrix Ms for the parameters used in Section 2.5 with finite DB (red) and DB → ∞ (blue). For our choice of parameters and reflecting boundary conditions only the first mode (s = 0.5) is linearly unstable, compare to Fig. 2.8. Parameters: DB/DA = 30, αB/αA = 4, 1.5 ≈ 1.2, h = 5 (if not stated otherwise). βB/βA = 2, λA/L = 0.1 ≈ 0.3, λB/L = √ √ The eigenvalues are given by (cid:16) (cid:16) s − qI/II s M 1 M 4 (cid:17)2 − Tr[Ms] qI/II qI/II s (cid:17)(cid:16) s s M 2 s = 0 s − qI/II (cid:17) − M 3 (cid:115)(cid:18) Tr[Ms] (cid:19)2 − Det[Ms] , s + Det[Ms] = 0 2 qI/II s = Tr[Ms] 2 ± (A.26) where "Tr" denotes the trace and "Det" denotes the determinant. The properties of the eigenvalues can be summarized in the Tr-Det-diagram in Fig. A.1(a). If Tr[Ms]2 < 4 Det[Ms], both eigenvalues are complex and, in fact, are complex conjugates of each other. For Tr[Ms] < 0 both real parts are negative, otherwise both real parts are positive. Instead, if Tr[Ms]2 < 4 Det[Ms], both eigenvalues are real. For Det[Ms] > 0 both eigenvalues have the same sign: a positive sign for Tr[Ms] > 0 and a negative sign for Tr[Ms] < 0. This can be easily seen from qI s + qII s = Tr(Ms) and qI s · qII s = Det(Ms) . (A.27) 108 both eigenvalues complex with positive real partsboth eigenvalues real and negativeboth eigenvalues real and positiveboth eigenvalues real but of opposite signboth eigenvalues real but of opposite signstablestableunstableunstableunstableunstableTraceDet(a)(b)both eigenvalues complex with negative real parts1432-0.50.5-115-5-10A.3 Linear stability analysis of a Turing system Finally, for Det[Ms] < 0 both eigenvalues are real but of opposite sign. For the homogeneous steady state to be stable with respect to homogeneous perturba- tion (s = 0), both real parts of the eigenvalues qI 0 have to be negative. Thus, the 0, qII matrix M0 should be located in the second quadrant, where Tr(M0) < 0 and Det(M0) > 0 . (A.28) For the homogeneous steady state to be unstable with respect to inhomogeneous per- turbation (s (cid:54)= 0), at least one of the eigenvalues qI s has to have a positive real part. It turns out that by changing s, the trace cannot become positive if Tr(M0) < 0: s , qII s + M 4 Tr(Ms) = M 1 (A.29) Thus, the instability for s (cid:54)= 0 has to correspond to the third quadrant, for which both eigenvalues are real and one of them is positive: s = M 1 0 + M 4 0 − (DA + DB)(2πs/L)2 < 0 . Det(Ms) < 0 with s (cid:54)= 0 . (A.30) Note that Tr(Ms) decreases with increasing s, while Det(Ms) first decreases and later increases again according to Det(Ms) = Det(M0) − (DA M 4 0 + DB M 1 0 )(2πs/L)2 + DA DB (2πs/L)4 . (A.31) As a consequence, the eigenvalues of a Turing system depend on the mode number s as depicted in Fig. A.1(b). For an intermediate range of s one eigenvalue is positive and the system is linearly unstable with respect to the corresponding modes. A.3.2. The principle of local activation and lateral inhibition We derive necessary conditions for spontaneneous pattern formation in a two-component reaction diffusion system. This section is based on analogous derivations in the litera- ture (64, 65, 146, 195, 221). For the following, we define (cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ (cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ h h,B∗ h,B∗ h RAA = ∂ARA RBA = ∂ARB , RAB = ∂BRA , RBB = ∂BRB (cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ (cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ , . h h,B∗ h,B∗ h (A.32) (A.33) (A.34) The conditions in Eq. A.28 and A.30 result in the relations (cid:16) RAA − DA(2πs/L)2(cid:17)(cid:16) RAA + RBB < 0 RAA RBB − RAB RBA > 0 RBB − DB(2πs/L)2(cid:17) < RBA RAB . (A.35) 109 A. REACTION-DIFFUSION SYSTEMS: FIXED POINTS & SCALING The last two inequalities can be combined to RAA DB > −RBB DA + DA DB (2πs/L)2 . (A.36) Eq. A.33 tells us that at least one of the two species has to have a self-inhibiting effect. Here, we choose species B: RBB < 0. From Eq. A.36, we see that the other one, i.e. A, has to be self-enhancing: RAA > 0. From Eq. A.34 follows that RAB RBA < 0. The cross-reaction terms must be of opposing signs. As RBA RAB < 0 and RBB − DB(2πs/L)2 < 0 in Eq. A.35, it follows that RAA − DA(2πs/L)2 > 0 . (A.37) The diffusion coefficient DA of the self-activator has to be sufficiently small for certain modes to become unstable ("local activation"). This becomes even more apparent if we consider the reaction term RA = αAP (A, B) − βA A like in Eq. 2.18. Now, the char- acteristic wavelength of the reaction-diffusion equation has to be sufficiently small in /βA − 1)/(2πs)2. The weaker the self-activating effect and the larger the wave number s of the perturbation, the comparison to the system size: (λA/L)2 < (αA∂AP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ h,B∗ h smaller λA has to be. Finally, from Eq. A.36, we obtain RAA DB > −RBB DA. With Eq. A.33, hence RAA < −RBB, we see that the self-inhibitor has to diffuse faster than the self-activator ("lateral inhibition"): DB > DA . (A.38) A.4. Motivation for the Hill function The production function P (A, B) is a switch-like element that takes two inputs and com- pares them. In a biological system the inputs are the concentrations of two molecules that bind to the receptors of a cell. We discuss two possibilities to compare the concen- trations of activator A and the inhibitor B by simple generic mechanisms that describe binding and unbinding to receptors. The number of unbound receptors on a cell is given by Q. The output could be the number of receptors QA that are bound to the activator molecule. 1. Case: The activator A binds to the receptor Q while the inhibitor B leads to unbinding of A. The dynamic equation for concentration of receptors bound to A is QA = γ1 Ah1 Q − γ2 Bh2 QA − γ3 QA , (A.39) 110 A.4 Motivation for the Hill function where h1 and h2 describe cooperativity effects for binding and unbinding. For example, if the activator only binds in pairs, h1 = 2. The coefficients γ1, γ2 and γ3 are the rates of binding as well as induced and spontaneous unbinding. If the total concentration of receptors Q0 = Q + QA is constant, the steady state reads QA = γ1 Ah1 Q0 γ3 + γ2 Bh2 + γ1 Ah1 h=h1=h2 −−−−−−→ γ3=0 γ1 Q0 (A/B)h γ2/γ1 + (A/B)h . (A.40) If the cooperativity exponents are the same and the activator rarely unbinds spona- neously, the standard Hill function is recovered. A finite γ3 (cid:54)= 0 allows to compute the limit A = B = 0. 2. Case: We have seen that if the inhibitor facilitates the unbinding of the activator, we obtain a Hill function for the concentration of receptors bound to the activator. Another option for implementing the inhibiting effect is competitive binding. Here, the inhibitor binds to the same receptors as the activator and thus blocks activator binding. Now, the dynamic equations are QA = γ1 Ah1 Q − γ2 QA QB = γ3 Bh2 Q − γ4 QB Q = −(γ1 Ah1 + γ3 Bh2) Q + γ2 QA + γ4 QB . In the steady state Eq. A.41 results in Q = γ2 γ1 Ah1 QA (A.41) (A.42) (A.43) (A.44) and Eq. A.42 yields γ3 Bh2(Q0 − QA) γ3 Bh2 γ4 Q = QB = (A.45) with Q = Q0 − QA − QB, again assuming a constant total receptor number Q0. When inserting these two equations in the steady state of Eq. A.43, we finally get γ3 Bh2(Q0 − QA) γ4 + γ3 Bh2 −(γ1 Ah1 + γ3 Bh2) γ2 γ1 Ah1 QA + γ2 QA + γ4 γ4 + γ3 Bh2 = 0 γ2 γ3 Bh2 γ1 Ah1 QA + γ4 γ3 Bh2 γ4 + γ3 Bh2 QA = γ4 γ3 Bh2 γ4 + γ3 Bh2 Q0 γ2 γ4 + γ2 γ3 Bh2 γ4 γ1 Ah1 QA + QA = Q0 QA = γ4 γ1 Ah1 Q0 γ2 γ4 + γ2 γ3 Bh2 + γ4 γ1 Ah1 . 111 (A.46) A. REACTION-DIFFUSION SYSTEMS: FIXED POINTS & SCALING This is also a Hill function with exactly the same structure as the one above. It becomes apparent that this function stands for a wide class of realizations of a logical element that compares the magnitude of two inputs in a biological system. A.5. Homogeneous steady state of our Turing system The homogeneous steady state of our choice of Turing system given by Eq. 2.18 is characterized by B∗ h (A.47) A∗ h = αAβB αBβA h, B∗ βA αA Fig. A.2 illustrates the steady state in terms of A∗ h for the Hill function of Eq. 2.19 and the step function of Eq. 2.20. The solid red line corresponds to the left side and the (A.48) h) = P (A∗ A∗ h . dotted line to the right side of Eq. A.48. The intersections mark the steady state value of A∗ We use a specific definition of the theta function at position zero h. There is a second case for the step function (purple dashed line). 0 Θ(0) != if αAβB αBβA if αAβB 1 αBβA h ≤ B∗ h and A∗ > 1 . h > B∗ ≤ 1 (A.49) h,B∗ h = h,B∗ h h βA/αA h/B∗ h)h 1 + (A∗ ∂AP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ = − A∗ B∗ h h h,B∗ h (A.51) (A.52) . 112 These two cases correspond to A∗ h, respectively. This definition is chosen to ensure the existence of a steady state and to avoid artificial oscillations in the simulations. Moreover, it establishes the correspondence between the theta function and the Hill function in the limit of h → ∞. Next, we will show that only the case of A∗ h ensures spontaneous pattern formation irrespectively of h. For this, we explicitly perform a linear stability analysis of our h ≤ B∗ specific Turing system. The matrix of Eq. A.25 for the linearized system reads αA ∂AP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ Ms = − βA − DA(2πs/L)2 αA∂BP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ h,B∗ h αB∂BP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ h,Bh − βB − DB(2πs/L)2  . (A.50) It includes the derivatives of the Hill functions with respect to A and B at steady state: h,B∗ h h,B∗ h αB ∂AP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ ∂AP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ ∂BP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ A.5 Homogeneous steady state of our Turing system Figure A.2.: Homogeneous steady state of our Turing system for (a) a Hill function and (b) a theta function. Solid red (and dashed purple) lines correspond to the left side of Eq. A.48, dotted red lines to the right side. The limit of h → ∞ diverges for αAβB ≤ αBβA: ∂AP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ → h,B∗ h ∞ if αAβB αBβA if αAβB αBβA 0 ≤ 1 > 1 . (A.53) This is in in agreement with the theta function, for which the derivative diverges at position zero and is zero everywhere else. The determinant of the matrix Ms is (cid:16) βA + DA(2πs/L)2(cid:17)(cid:16) βB + DB(2πs/L)2(cid:17) − βA βb (2πs/L)2 h (cid:16) (cid:17) . B − λ2 λ2 A Det(Ms) = 1 + (A∗ h/B∗ h)h (cid:16) B − λ2 λ2 A (cid:17) (A.54) . (A.55) Thus, the instability condition of Eq. A.30 is given by (cid:16) βA + DA(2πs/L)2(cid:17)(cid:16) βB + DB(2πs/L)2(cid:17) < βA βb (2πs/L)2 h 1 + (A∗ h/B∗ h)h First of all, this requires λB > λA, typical for Turing systems. Furthermore, in order to fulfill this inequality for arbitrary h and in particular in the limit h → ∞, it follows that h ≤ B∗ A∗ h , αAβB αBβA ≤ 1 (A.56) Our choice of parameters in Chapter 2 amounts to (αAβB)/(αBβA) = 1/2. The second set of conditions of Eq. A.28 result in h 1 + (A∗ h/B∗ h)h (βA − βB) < βA + βB βA + βB > 0 (A.57) (A.58) 113 (a)(b)1A. REACTION-DIFFUSION SYSTEMS: FIXED POINTS & SCALING While Eq. A.58 is trivially fulfilled, Eq. A.57 requires βA < βB in order to hold for arbitrarily large h. In our parameter sets of Chapter 2, we have chosen βB/βA = 2. A.6. Inhomogenous steady states of our Turing system A.6.1. First order steady state solution First, we solve Eq. 2.18 of our Turing system with a step-like production function by assuming a single source region which is touching the boundary as shown in Fig. A.3(a). We refer to this as the (1, 1)-pattern. The general steady state solution for A∗ (1,1) is a piecewise function A∗ in(x) = Ain,1 ex/λA + Ain,2 e−x/λA + A∗ out(x) = Aout,1 ex/λA + Aout,2 e−x/λA αA βA for 0 < x ≤ (cid:96) (A.59) for (cid:96) < x < L (A.60) for the region inside and outside the source. In order to determine the four constant factors, we use the two reflecting boundary conditions and two continuity conditions at the source boundary: out(x)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:96) . out((cid:96)) ∂xA∗ ∂xA∗ A∗ in((cid:96)) = A∗ ∂xA∗ in(x)(cid:12)(cid:12)0 = 0 out(x)(cid:12)(cid:12)L = 0 in(x)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:96) = ∂xA∗ (cid:18) x (cid:19) (cid:18) x − L λA + λA (A.61) (A.62) (A.63) (A.64) (A.65) (A.66) (A.67) From Eq. A.61-A.62, we obtain Ain,1 = Ain,2 and Aout,1 = Aout,2 e−2L/λA, respectively. Thus, the solution becomes A∗ in(x) = Ain,0 cosh A∗ out(x) = Aout,0 cosh αA βA (cid:19) for 0 ≤ x ≤ (cid:96) for (cid:96) < x ≤ L 1 − sinh(L/λA−(cid:96)/λA) cosh(x/λA) sinh(L/λA) cosh(x/λA − L/λA) sinh(L/λA) sinh((cid:96)/λA) for 0 ≤ x ≤ (cid:96) for (cid:96) < x ≤ L . A∗ (1,1) = αA βA Finally, from Eq. A.63-A.64, we compute the (1, 1)-solution The solution for B∗ (1,1) is determined analogously, see Eq. 2.24. 114 A.6 Inhomogenous steady states of our Turing system Figure A.3.: (a) The concentration profile of A∗ (1,1) can be written as a piecewise function for the part inside and outside the source. (b) The intersections (circles) of the blue and the red curves mark the steady state source size according to Eq. A.69. √ Parameters like in Section 2.5: DB/DA = 30, αB/αA = 4, βB/βA = 2, λA/L = 0.1 ≈ 0.3, λB/L = 1.5 ≈ 1.2. √ A.6.2. Source size of the first order steady state For the step-like production function, the source size is defined by A∗ (1,1)((cid:96)) = B∗ FA((cid:96)) = (1,1)((cid:96)) with F((cid:96)) = sinh((cid:96)/λ) sinh(L/λ) cosh((cid:96)/λ − L/λ) = 1 2 αBβA αAβB FB((cid:96)) (cid:18) 1 − sinh(L/λ − 2(cid:96)/λ) sinh(L/λ) (A.68) (A.69) (cid:19) . (A.70) Next, we show that the source size (cid:96) has only one non-trivial solution. First, we compute F(0) = 0 , F(L/2) = 1/2 , F(L) = 1 , (A.71) and we see that (cid:96) = 0 is always a solution to Eq. A.69. The curve F((cid:96)) is essentially a shifted hyperbolic sine function und is monotonously increasing ∂(cid:96)F((cid:96)) = cosh(2(cid:96)/λ − L/λ) λ sinh(L/λ) > 0 . The largest slope is found at the interval bounds: ∂(cid:96)F((cid:96))(cid:12)(cid:12)0 = ∂(cid:96)F((cid:96))(cid:12)(cid:12)L = 1 λ tanh(L/λ) . (A.72) (A.73) 115 (a)(b)0010.5Source sizeA. REACTION-DIFFUSION SYSTEMS: FIXED POINTS & SCALING In particular, we see that (cid:18) (cid:19) ∂λ 1 λ tanh(L/λ) 2 L/λ − sinh(2L/λ) 2 λ2 sinh(L/λ)2 < 0 because L/λ > 0 . = (A.74) Thus, the larger λ the smaller the slope at (cid:96) = 0 and (cid:96) = L. In consequence, the curve for λB lies below the curve for λA if (cid:96) < L/2 and above if (cid:96) > L/2, as shown in Fig. A.3(b). We can demonstrate this fact explicitly by computing (cid:18) sinh(2(cid:96)/λ) (L − (cid:96)) (cid:96) ∂λF((cid:96)) = λ3 sinh(L/λ)2 2(cid:96)/λ (cid:19) − sinh(2L/λ − 2(cid:96)/λ) 2(L − (cid:96))/λ ≶ 0 if (cid:96) ≶ L/2 . (A.75) Therefore, FA((cid:96)) and FB((cid:96)) always have three intersection points at 0, L/2 and L. If we now consider Eq. A.69 with αAβB < αBβA and λA < λB (as required for the Turing system to form patterns, see Section A.5), (cid:96) = L is not a solution anymore and the second solution is shifted to smaller values of (cid:96) (intersection with dashed blue line in Fig. A.3(b)). In summary, there is always a solution with (cid:96) = 0 (no source). Additionally, for our Turing condition αAβB ≤ αBβA, there can be a second solution with a finite source size (cid:96) < L/2 if αBβA αAβB λA tanh(L/λA) < λB tanh(L/λB) . (A.76) For αAβB < αBβA, there are no further solutions. The condition of Eq. A.76 marks a bifurcation point of the system, beyond which the (1, 1)-solution exists in addition to the (0, 0)-solution. From Eq. A.76, we see that λA is constrained by either L or λB, depending on which one is smaller. If L (cid:28) λB, the equation becomes αAβB αBβA tanh(L/λA) < L/λA . (A.77) For αAβB < αBβA, this is only fulfilled if L/λA is large enough. In contrast for L (cid:29) λB, we obtain λA < λB . (A.78) (cid:18) For αAβB < αBβA, this is only fulfilled if λA is sufficiently smaller than λB. Finally, we consider two limiting cases of Eq. A.70: F((cid:96)) = 1 2 1 − sinh(L/λ (1 − 2(cid:96)/L)) sinh(L/λ) → (cid:96)/L for L/λ (cid:28) 1 for L/λ (cid:29) 1 . 1/2 (A.79) Note that the absolute value of 1 − 2(cid:96)/L is smaller than 1. Thus, for L (cid:28) λB and L (cid:29) λA, we obtain (cid:96)/L = (αAβB)/(2αBβA), see Fig. 2.7. 116 αAβB αBβA (cid:19) (cid:40) A.6 Inhomogenous steady states of our Turing system A.6.3. Hierarchy of higher order steady states We can successively derive the higher order steady states. First, we consider the second order solution with two sources at the boundaries, denoted as (2, 2)-pattern, see Fig. A.6.4(a). Thus, there are maxima of concentration A∗ (2,2) at each boundary. Furthermore, there is a minimum for each concentration in between the two (2,2) and B∗ source regions. We now prove that the system is completely symmetric as depicted in Fig. A.6.4(b). For that it is sufficient to show that the minima for A∗ (2,2) are at the same position, i.e. LA = LB. Let us consider the solutions left of the respective (2,2) and B∗ minima in Fig. A.6.4(a). These solutions correspond to the (1, 1)-pattern, which we have characterized above. If the minima are at the same position (LA = LB), there is at most one (cid:96) with 0 < (cid:96) < L in agreement with A∗ (1,1)((cid:96)), see Section A.6.2. However, B∗ (1,1)((cid:96)) is a strictly monotonic function of LB if (cid:96) > 0: (1,1)((cid:96)) = B∗ ∂LB B∗ (1,1)((cid:96)) = − αB sinh((cid:96)/λB) cosh((cid:96)/λB) sinh(L/λB)2λB < 0 . (A.80) Therefore, there is no other choice of LB also solving the equation for (cid:96). In consequence we conclude that LA = LB in the steady state. For LA = LB, we can cut the (2,2)-pattern at this position, which results in two (1,1)- patterns. But since these two (1,1)-patterns have in fact the same concentration A at their common boundary, their system size must be equal. An analogous reasoning can be applied to the (1, 0)-pattern. Finally, Fig. A.6.4(b) exemplifies that any higher order pattern can be considered as a concatenation of (1, 1)-patterns as the basic building blocks. Each adjacent pair of these fundamental sections is either a (1, 0)-pattern or a (2, 2)-pattern and thus completely symmetric. In consequence, any higher order pattern can be constructed by a concatenation of (1, 1)-patterns of identical size. A.6.4. Stability of the inhomogeneous steady state of our Turing system We are probing the stability of the inhomogeneous steady states in various ways. First, we can add a set of small perturbations to the steady state profiles and monitor the relaxation behavior in numerical simulations. Second, we can start with a linear com- bination of two steady state patterns with varying weights and observe to which steady state they converge, as shown in Fig. 2.8(b). Finally, for the case of the Hill-type pro- duction function, we can numerically perform a linear stability analysis, as we will show next. 117 A. REACTION-DIFFUSION SYSTEMS: FIXED POINTS & SCALING Figure A.4.: (a) The concentrations A and B of the (2, 2)-pattern possess maxima at boundaries and one minimum each between the source regions. (b) All patterns can be constructed by a concatenation of (1, 1)-patterns of identical size. Parameters 0.1 ≈ 0.3, like in Section 2.5: DB/DA = 30, αB/αA = 4, βB/βA = 2, λA/L = λB/L = 1.5 ≈ 1.2. √ √ Let us consider small perturbations a(t, x) and b(t, x) about the inhomogeneous steady states: A(t, x) = A∗ (m,n)(x) + a(t, x) , B(t, x) = B∗ (m,n)(x) + b(t, x) . The linearized dynamics of the perturbations is given by with the operators (cid:32)P1 P2 (cid:33)(cid:32)a (cid:33) P3 P4 b (m,n),B∗ (m,n),B∗ (m,n),B∗ (m,n),B∗ (m,n) (m,n) (m,n) (m,n) − βA + DA∂2 x − βB + DB∂2 x . b = ∂t (cid:33) (cid:32)a P1 = αA ∂AP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ P2 = αA∂BP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ P3 = αB ∂AP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ P4 = αB∂BP(cid:12)(cid:12)A∗ (cid:88) (A.81) (A.82) (A.83) (A.84) (A.85) (A.86) Now, we express the perturbations in terms of a set orthonormal modes that agree with the reflecting boundary conditions: a(t, x) = a0 + aj(t) mj(x) with mj(x) = √ 2 cos(π j x/L) . (A.87) j=1 118 (a)(b)A.6 Inhomogenous steady states of our Turing system Figure A.5.: Maximum eigenvalue of the linear operator matrix for the (1, 0)-pattern as a function of system size. The pattern becomes stable at L/λA ≈ 5.5, see also Fig. 2.8. Approximation with 20 modes and a spatial discretization of the profiles with 200 grid points. Parameters like in Fig. 2.8: DB/DA = 30, αB/αA = 4, βB/βA = 2, h = 5. The coefficients aj(t) can be determined by (cid:90) L 0 aj(t) = a(t, x) mj(x) dx . (A.88) The linearized system in terms of these modes is  =  (cid:82) L (cid:82) L  a1 a2 ... b1 b2 ... ∂t (cid:82) L (cid:82) L 0 mjP1mi dx 0 mjP2mi dx 0 mjP3mi dx 0 mjP4mi dx    a1 a2 ... b1 b2 ... (A.89) If the largest eigenvalue of the linear operator matrix is negative, the steady state is stable and this maximum eigenvalue provides the time scale of relaxation of the slowest decaying mode. If at least one eigenvalue is positive, the steady state is linearly unstable. Fig. A.5 shows the maximum eigenvalue for the (1, 0)-pattern as a function of the system size. We can determine the lower bound for which this pattern becomes stable, as illustrated in Fig. 2.8. For none of the inhomogeneous patterns, we observe a maximum system size, at which these patterns would become unstable again. 119 4.555.566.5-0.0600.060.12System sizeMaximum eigenvalueA. REACTION-DIFFUSION SYSTEMS: FIXED POINTS & SCALING A.7. On our scalable Turing system A.7.1. A homogeneous dynamic state for low expander levels For low expander values, the concentrations in the Turing system with expander feed- back become homogenous. Here, we consider the adiabatic limit for which the expander relaxation is much faster than the dynamics of the Turing molecules. In consequence, the expander tightly follows the much slower dynamics of the inhibitor concentration B: E = αE κE B . (A.90) It exists a dynamic state of the Turing system for which the concentrations A and B relax in synchrony such that the ratio χ = B/A stays constant. As a result, the Hill-type production function has a constant value P (A, B) = g(χ) given by g(χ) = 1 1 + χh . The ratio χ is is obtained from ∂tχ = 0 αBg(χ) − κBEB − αAg(χ)χ + κAEB = 0 g(χ) = κA − κB αA χ − αB . αE κE (A.91) (A.92) The system can leave the homogeneous regime if E increases. For this, B has to decrease, according to Eq. A.90. We have discussed for Eq. 3.11 that this requires g(χ) < (cid:96)∗/L, where (cid:96)∗/L = (αEκB)/(κEαB). For the threshold where g(χ) = (cid:96)∗/L, we obtain κA − κB αA χ − αB αE κE = αEκB κEαB χ = αBκA αBκB . (A.93) Thus, the ratio B/A equals the ratio of the homogeneous steady state concentrations B∗ h/A∗ h. Therefore, from g(χ) = (cid:96)∗/L follows that f(0,0) = (cid:96)∗/L. 120 A.7 On our scalable Turing system A.7.2. Generalized scalable Turing system We can generalize our approach of scalable Turing patterning by considering the fol- lowing generic equations for A, B and E ∂tA = αA P (A, B) + RA(A, E) + DA ∂2 ∂tB = αB P (A, B) + RB(B, E) + DB ∂2 x A ∂tE = αE + LE RA(A, E), RB(B, E) (cid:16) (cid:17) x B + DE ∂2 x E . (A.94) (A.95) (A.96) Here, RA and RB are generic functions fulfilling the Turing conditions and LE is a linear function of RA(A, E) and RB(B, E). By computing the spatial averages in the steady state, one obtains αE + (cid:104)LE αE + LE RA(A, E), RB(B, E) (cid:17)(cid:105) = 0 (cid:16) (cid:16)(cid:104)RA(A, E)(cid:105),(cid:104)RB(B, E)(cid:105)(cid:17) (cid:16) αA(cid:104)P(cid:105), αB(cid:104)P(cid:105)(cid:17) = 0 . = 0 αE + LE (A.97) If RA, RB and LE are chosen such that LE((cid:104)P(cid:105)) = LE(αA(cid:104)P(cid:105), αB(cid:104)P(cid:105)) is a monotonic function in (cid:104)P(cid:105), this uniquely determines the source size in the steady state. Thus, if a steady state exists, the size of the source will be independent of the system size. Let us again consider a homogeneous expander distribution. Furthermore, we assume that the relaxation of the Turing system is much faster than the relaxation of the expander. Thus, Eq. A.94-A.95 define the size of the source as a function of slowly varying E. The intersection of this nullcline with the solution for (cid:104)P(cid:105) from Eq. A.97 provides the steady state values of E. For the steady state to be linearly stable, it requires that ∂(cid:104)P(cid:105) LE((cid:104)P(cid:105)) · ∂E(cid:104)P(cid:105)E∗ < 0. A.7.3. Scaling of downstream targets with a constant amplitude One important feature of our scalable Turing system is that the amplitude of the morphogens increases quadratically with L, see Section 3.7. This is a general property of such scaling mechanisms for which the degradation rate is adjusted, see Section 2.4.5. As the degradation rate changes proportional to L−2, the products βAA and βBB are characterized by a constant amplitude independent of system size. If the cell responds to this flux, the expression of down-stream targets scales with a constant amplitude. Yet, how might the cell read out the degradation flux? Signaling often requires binding of the molecules to receptors on the cell surface. The concentration of activator molecules bound to receptors is Ab ∝ βAb A, where βAb 121 A. REACTION-DIFFUSION SYSTEMS: FIXED POINTS & SCALING is the binding rate. If the molecules become internalized or degraded upon binding, this binding removes the molecules from the system and the binding rate βAb in fact contributes to the degradation rate βA. As a simple example, let us consider the following dynamics of the bound molecules ∂tAb = βAb A − βAr Ab . (A.98) Free molecules bind with rate βAb and bound molecules are removed with rate βAr. The steady state of this equation is A∗ b = A∗ . βAb βAr (A.99) If spontaneous degradation of the free molecules can be neglected in comparison to binding and internalization, it follows that βA = βAb and the cells read out the flux βA A∗. In this scenario, the expander could be a co-receptor that controls the binding rate and thus the effective degradation rate in a size-dependent manner. The down- stream targets would perfectly scale with a constant amplitude. A.7.4. On knockout experiments in scalable Turing systems In Chapter 3, we presented a simple mechanism that couples a classical Turing system including two molecules of concentration A and B to the dynamics of an additional expander molecule. Here, we will show that knockout of A or B (for example by RNAi feedings) can yield misleading results. If the production of the activator is blocked, one observes that both concentrations fade away, see Fig. A.6(a). Thus, one would correctly conclude that A activates B. Yet, after removing the inhibitor from the system, both concentrations decrease as well. In particular, A is vanishing after an initial increase because of the indirect effect via E. In consequence one would conclude that B is activating A, despite its direct inhibiting effect within the Turing feedback loop. In the case of the flatworms, the Wnt/β-catenin system has an instructive role for tail identity. RNAi experiments indicate that respective pathway components are expressed in the tail and have a positive effect on themselves and each other. In contrast, the inhibitors of this system reside in the head. This is not in agreement with any of the two most simple Turing systems based on two key players. Fig. 1.10 illustrates that we would expect either additional inhibiting effects of molecules that are expressed in the same region or additional activating effects of molecules that are expressed on opposite ends of worm. Including an expander feedback could solve this problem, as shown in 122 A.7 On our scalable Turing system Fig. A.6(b). A Turing system of the first type, with both Turing molecules expressed in the same region, might appear like a mutually enhancing feedback during gene knock- out. A Turing system of the second type, with both Turing molecules expressed on opposite ends, might appear like a mutually suppressing feedback. Monitoring the dynamics of the concentrations upon RNAi feeding over time is more informative than endpoint assays, see Fig. A.6(a). After knockout of the inhibitor, the activator first expands before the pattern vanishes, hinting at the suppressive effect of B. 123 A. REACTION-DIFFUSION SYSTEMS: FIXED POINTS & SCALING √ √ Figure A.6.: (a) The scalable Turing system discussed in Chapter 3 can appear like a mutually activating feedback loop in knockout experiments of A and B (dashed lines are the initial steady states, fading of colors denote the time evolution). Parameters 0.1 ≈ 0.3, like in Chapter 3: DB/DA = 30, αB/αA = 4, βB/βA = 2, λA/L = (b) Examples of the two possible Turing topologies λB/L = plus an appropriate expander feedback and the interpretation of knockouts of the two Turing molecules. The results compare to experimental observations with respect to the Wnt/β-catenin system in flatworms. 1.5 ≈ 1.2, h = 5. 124 (a)ABEPositionConcentration BPositionConcentration AKnockout of A:PositionConcentration BPositionConcentration AABEKnockout of B:(b)seemsto beseemsto beTuring feedback 1:Turing feedback 2:B. On the numerical solution of reaction-diffusion equations B.1. Euler method and Courant criterion A reaction-diffusion equation of type ∂tC(t, x) = −β C(x, t) + D∂2 xC(t, x) (B.1) describes diffusion and linear degradation of a chemical species of concentration C in a one-dimensional domain. It can be solved numerically by discretizing time and space and using the Euler method as the most simple approach (163). The concentration Ci at position i at time t + ∆t is then given by Ci(t + ∆t) = Ci(t) − β Ci(t) ∆t + D∆t ∆x2 (cid:16) Ci+1(t) − 2Ci(t) + Ci−1(t) (cid:17) . (B.2) In order for the Euler update to be numerically stable and not to violate causality, the following Courant-L´evy-Friedrich criterion has to be fulfilled (163) ∆t < 2∆x2 4D + β∆x2 . (B.3) In this thesis, we often analyze systems of several coupled reaction-diffusion equations. At least one of which usually contains a very fast diffusing chemical species, like the inhibitor in the Turing system or the expander in Chapter 2 and 3. Usually 4Df (cid:29) β∆x2 with Df of the fastest diffusing species and β of any species. Thus, ∆t < ∆x2/(2Df ) has to be chosen to be very small. Note that ∆x is bounded from above especially by the non-homogeneity of the slowest diffusing species. Yet, the time scale of relaxation to the steady state is determined by the reaction rates β. The number of iterations to reach the steady state is of order O(cid:2)1/(β∆t)(cid:3) = O(cid:2)2Df /(β∆x2)(cid:3), which is very large as stated above. Next, we show how to avoid such long computing times. 125 B. ON THE NUMERICAL SOLUTION OF REACTION-DIFFUSION EQUATIONS B.2. Algorithmic speed-up using a convolution with a Gauss kernel If diffusion of one or several species is fast in comparison to the other processes of the system, we can apply a separation of time scales to avoid long computing times. During one rather large time step of the Euler scheme that would violate the Courant criterion due to the fast diffusion but would be still in agreement with the other slow processes, we account for the fast diffusion by using the analytical solution of the pure diffusion equation A Fourier transform yields with the solution ∂tC(t, x) = D∂2 xC(x, t) . ∂t C(t, s) = −(2πs)2D C(t, s) C(t, s) = C0(s) e−(2πs)2Dt in Fourier space. The back-transform yields an integral with a Gauss kernel −∞ (cid:90) ∞ (cid:90) ∞ (cid:90) ∞ (cid:90) ∞ −∞ −∞ −∞ C(t, x) = = = = ds C(t, s) e2iπxs (cid:90) ∞ −∞ (cid:90) ∞ dy C0(y) dy C0(y) e ds e −∞ −(y−x)2 4Dt ds dy C0(y) e−2iπys e−(2πs)2Dt e2iπxs (cid:16) (cid:17)2 −4π2Dt s+ i(y−x) 4π2Dt −(y−x)2 4Dt e 1√ 4πDt . (B.4) (B.5) (B.6) (B.7) This solution can be used to describe the propagation within one time step of the Euler scheme. (cid:90) yj +∆y/2 (cid:88) yj−∆y/2 j The solution has to be computed in discrete spatial coordinates. It can be written as C(t + ∆t, x) = dy C(t, y) e −(y−x)2 4D∆t 1√ 4πD∆t . (B.8) We define Cj(t) as the average of C(t, y) in the interval [yj − ∆y/2, yj + ∆y/2]. If ∆y is sufficiently small, such that C(t, y) ≈ Cj(t) (i.e. approximately homogeneous) in the interval [yj − ∆y/2, yj + ∆y/2], we find (cid:18) (cid:20) (yj + ∆y/2) − x (cid:21) √ 4D∆t Cj(t) 2 j Erf (cid:20) (yj − ∆y/2) − x (cid:21)(cid:19) √ 4D∆t − Erf C(t + ∆t, x) ≈(cid:88) , (B.9) 126 B.2 Algorithmic speed-up using a convolution with a Gauss kernel including the error function Erf[z] = 2√ π concentration at the next time point, we compute the average (cid:82) z 0 e−ξ2dξ. In order to obtain the discretized Ci(t + ∆t) = 1 ∆x ≈ (cid:88) j (cid:90) xi+∆x/2 (cid:32) xi−∆x/2 Cj(t) 2 −2(i − j) Erf √ √ 4D∆t π ∆x + (cid:18) dx C(t + ∆t, x) (cid:21) (cid:20) (i − j + 1)∆x (cid:21) 4D∆t √ + (i − j − 1) Erf (i − j + 1) Erf (cid:20) (i − j)∆x √ 4D∆t −(i−j+1)2∆x2 4D∆t e − 2e −(i−j)2∆x2 4D∆t + e (cid:20) (i − j − 1)∆x (cid:19)(cid:33) −(i−j−1)2∆x2 4D∆t √ 4D∆t (B.10) (cid:21) . Here, we used ∆x = ∆y and identified xi−yj = (i−j)∆x. Note that this approximation is well justified for small ∆x, in particular ∆x < 4D∆t. Next, we demonstrate that for ∆x (cid:29) √ √ k = i − j and ∆r = ∆x/ Ci(t + ∆t) ≈ (cid:88) 4D∆t the result is not in agreement with Eq. B.4. We can substitute + (k − 1) Erf (k − 1)∆r (k + 1) Erf (k + 1)∆r Ci−k(t) 4D∆t. (cid:105) (cid:104) (cid:104) (cid:105) √ e−(k+1)2∆r2 − 2e−k2∆r2 + e−(k−1)2∆r2 (cid:33) = Ci(t) 2 2 Erf ∆r + (cid:32) (cid:105) (cid:104) k −2k Erf k∆r 2 (cid:104) (cid:32) (cid:32) (cid:32) + + + Ci−1(t) 2 Ci+1(t) 2 (cid:88) k>2 (k − 1) Erf + (cid:105) (cid:104) (cid:104) (cid:32) √ ∆r π (cid:33) (cid:105) (cid:105) + + ∆r ∆r 2 e−∆r2 − 2 √ π ∆r (cid:105) − 2 Erf (cid:104) (cid:105) − 2 Erf (cid:104) (cid:104) 2 Erf 2∆r 2 Erf 2∆r Ci−k(t) 2 (cid:104) (cid:105) + (k − 1)∆r e−(2∆r)2 − 2 e−∆r2 + 1 ∆r π √ √ e−(2∆r)2 − 2 e−∆r2 + 1 ∆r (cid:105) − 2k Erf (cid:104) π (cid:105) (B.11) (cid:33) (cid:33) (cid:33) (k + 1) Erf (k + 1)∆r k∆r + e−(k+1)2∆r2 − 2e−k2∆r2 + e−(k−1)2∆r2 √ ∆r π The Taylor expansion of the error function is given by Erf[1/x] = sign[x] − e−x2(cid:18) x√ (cid:19) + O[x3] π . (B.12) 127 B. ON THE NUMERICAL SOLUTION OF REACTION-DIFFUSION EQUATIONS Thus, we obtain Ci(t + ∆t) ≈ Ci(t) + = Ci(t) + π∆r Ci+1(t) − 2Ci(t) + Ci−1(t) √ √ D∆t π∆x Def f ∆t √ 2 Ci+1(t) − 2Ci(t) + Ci−1(t) Ci+1(t) − 2Ci(t) + Ci−1(t) (cid:16) (cid:16) (cid:17) (cid:17) = Ci(t) + with Def f = (cid:112)D/(π∆t)∆x. Even though the result looks similar to Eq. B.2 of the limit ∆x (cid:29) √ Euler method, the diffusion appears to be effectively faster than D. As we consider the 4D∆t, it follows that (B.13) ∆x2 , (cid:32)√ (cid:33)2 4D∆t ∆x < 4D∆t ∆x √ √ (cid:114) √ √ D∆t π∆x D∆t 2∆x < D∆t ∆x2 < D < D π∆t ∆x = DEf f . (B.14) The effectively faster diffusion comes from the fact that the concentration within each interval [yj − ∆y/2, yj + ∆y/2] becomes equally distributed instantaneously by setting C(t, y) = Cj(t). In order to avoid this numerical effect, ∆x < 4D∆t is required. In a system with a slow and a fast diffusion species (Ds (cid:28) Df ), which combines the Euler method with a Gauss kernel, two conditions have to be fulfilled: √ ∆x2 4Df < ∆t < 2∆x2 4Ds + βs∆x2 . (B.15) 128 C. Worm handling and measurements of size and shape C.1. Worm handling If not specified otherwise, we use a clonal line of an asexual strain of Schmidtea mediter- ranea (28, 185). Worms were maintained at 20◦C as described in (35). Other flatworm species were taken from the flatworm collection established by the lab of Jochen Rink (CBG, Dresden). Large worms kept in isolation increasingly tend to fission, while social crowding is known to reduce fissioning rates (48, 161). In order to prevent fissioning during long term measurements but still track individual worms, we added small worm pieces in the dishes of large worms. In long term experiments, we occasionally also added antibiotics (ciprofloxacin, gentamicin) to ensure that the worms stay healthy during the entire time course. C.2. Image acquisition Flatworms were placed one at a time into a plastic petri dish (90 mm) and filmed using a Nikon macroscope (AZ 100M, 0.5x objective) and a Nikon camera set-up (DS-Fi1, frame rate 3 Hz, exposure time 6 ms, total observation period 15 s, resolution 1280 x 960 pixel, conversion factor 44 pixel/mm). The movies were converted from AVI (provided by the Nikon imaging software) to MP4 using Handbreak, reducing the bit-size by a factor of 30 and facilitating further processing. For this purpose, we wrote a bash script which calls HandbrakeCLI (the command line interface version) and transcodes the AVI files using the H.264 standard for video compression and fixed optimized settings. We carefully tested the conversion procedure to exclude distorting effects on the data. It turns out that the worm tracking and shape analyses are even more robust if we first transcode the files in comparison to loading the AVI files directly into the MATLAB program. 129 C. WORM HANDLING AND MEASUREMENTS OF SIZE AND SHAPE For the size measurements, we aimed to obtain movies in which the worms are moving rather straight and stretched out. This behavior corresponds to a flight response which can be seen after the worms have been exposed to light. After the worms are placed in the center of the petri dish, they try to escape the illumination of the macroscope by moving towards the slightly darker region near the rim of the dish. The stage is adjusted such that the worms traverse the field of view and are imaged just after an initial acceleration phase. Student helpers have been thoroughly trained at the macroscope to strictly adhere to the fixed imaging protocol. C.3. Extracting size and shape from worm movies Movies were analyzed off-line using custom-made MATLAB software, see Fig. C.1. A first shape proxy was determined from movie frames via edge detection using a canny- filter, followed by a dilation-erosion cycle and a filling of the shape. If possible, the shape was extracted twice for each frame -- with and without background correction. By comparing the two results, the program can reduce errors from particles touching the worm boundary. In a subsequent refinement step, the worm perimeter was adjusted by finding the steepest drop in intensity along directions transverse to the perimeter proxy. This procedure together with interpolation steps allowed us to extract the worm shape with sub-pixel accuracy, After the perimeter was determined, we were able to compute further quantities such as the worm area. The midline was obtained by searching for points with equal distances to both sides of the worm boundary. Due to the large body plasticity, the measured quantities such as worm area or length can easily vary by up to 30% during normal, rather stretched gliding motion. It requires an extensive imaging training and a large number of worms to extract reliable and reproducible data. Often, we analyzed several movies per worm and experimental condition. In contrast to the biological variability, the analysis software works very robustly and can cope with different noise levels and manyfold intensity variations. 130 C.3 Extracting size and shape from worm movies Figure C.1.: Extracting size and shape information from worm movies. 131 D. Shape reconstruction and worm bending D.1. On the reconstruction of a closed worm outline In order to reconstruct a worm shape from a given radial distance profile, we have to determine the constant increment ds along the worm perimeter such that the outline (D.1) closes on itself. This corresponds to (cid:88) increasing with ds for radially convex shapes. (cid:80) monotonously increasing (cid:80) αi = 2π i with the angle αi between two consecutive radii ρi and ρi+1. The angle αi is monotonously i αi can even be monotonously in- creasing with ds if the shapes are not strictly radially convex but close to it. For a i αi, there exists one choice for ds such that Eq. D.1 is fulfilled. Small variations of the radial distance profile yield similar results for ds. D.2. On the reconstruction of head shapes The head perimeter does not completely close on its own. Instead of Eq. D.1, the following condition has to be fulfilled(cid:88) i αi = 2π − α0 , (D.2) including the opening angle α0 towards the trunk. The angle α0 can be determined un- der the assumption of an approximately symmetric head shape. For N radial distances ρi describing the head, we obtain α0 = arccos(ρN/2/ρ1) + arccos(ρN/2/ρN ) . (D.3) 132 E. On growth and cell turnover E.1. Signatures of aging in flatworms Large and small worms are not only different in size but also show size-dependent changes in system behavior, which have been previously related to characteristics of more adult or juvenile animals, respectively (15, 18, 71, 111, 133). For this, we need to distinguish between two different notions of "aging". The first one refers to the progression of the physical time since birth. Secondly, there would be physiological aging that is determined by varying characteristics of the body such as sexual maturity and also symptoms of decline as well as an increased mortality. Aging in the second sense might potentially be independent of the life time of the organism and might instead rather depend on its size or environmental conditions. For sexual flatworms, it has in fact been reported that growth, metabolic rate, regene- ration abilities and reproduction change with age (1, 86, 92, 111). Additionally, aging is often attributed to a decreasing length of telomeres (i.e. the end regions of the chromosomes) with each cell division. Indeed, this telomere erosion has been described in sexual Smed and it correlates with the total life time of the worm (213). In contrast, other features seem to rather depend on size instead of the life time. For example, sexual flatworms develop reproductive organs when growing but also reabsorb their germ line cells again when shrinking during starvation periods (30, 33, 140, 193). For asexual worms, as we consider in the experiments, aging effects are even more difficult to discuss. There is no well-defined birth and, at most, fissioning could be considered as death and birth at the same time. Nevertheless, asexual Smed still show size-dependent physiological changes. For example, the fissioning rate increases for large worms (215) and precursor cells of the germ line, which still exist in asexual flatworms, show a similar size-dependence as the germ line in sexual worms (84, 230). Telomere erosion has also been observed in asexual Smed , yet the length is restored during regeneration in contrast to the sexual strains (213). In this sense, physiological aging in asexual worms might be considered to be reversible and regeneration might be interpreted as a rejuvenation event, which also includes the renewal of many somatic 133 E. ON GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER cells during remodeling (50, 86). It is an interesting question whether the worms also show a physiologically rejuvenation while starving (86, 91, 140). In summary, there is some evidence that sexual worms show irreversible signatures of aging with progression of their life time while asexual strains might be able to return to a more juvenile state. As a sidenote, sexual worms survive longer than asexual worms after irradiation (229), which could be due to a reduced turnover rate. One might speculate that sexual worms rather invest in producing a germ line on the cost of body maintenance. Such a potentially insufficient replacement of damaged cells and the corresponding deterioration of function alongside with a higher mortality can be considered as a hallmark of aging (158). However, most importantly, the discussion shows how difficult it is to unambiguously characterize aging, especially as it is in general lacking a clear definition (53). It will be left for future works to investigate whether size-dependent changes in flatworms might be linked to aging and rejuvenation. E.2. Additional size measurements and growth dynamics In this section, we provide more details and additional measurements of worm sizes and growth dynamics to back up our discussion in Section 5.2. We define the worm area for a particular measurement as the average over the 10 frames with the largest values. Scaling laws are fitted by a robust algorithm with bi-squared weights. Thus, the spread of the data is assumed to correspond to the measurement uncertainty. This circumvents the difficulties with estimating the error for each data point from the size measurements. Fig. E.1(a) shows the scaling relation between area and length for well-fed worms (3 days after feeding). The fit yields a scaling exponent of 1.69 ± 0.01, which is slightly lower than for the starving worms in Fig. 5.3(a). As a byproduct of the cell number measurements using histones, Albert Thommen also determined the protein mass in the worms. Even though the measurements are not sufficiently calibrated to obtain absolute numbers, the respective scaling laws might still be meaningful. While the total mass per cell seems to change with worm size, the protein content per cell appears to stay rather constant, see Fig. E.1(b). It remains to validate this result with additional experiments and to investigate whether it could be linked to potential lipid stores. Oviedo et al. have counted the number of cintillo cells around the head margin (150). If we assume an equidistant positioning of these sensory cells and approximate the head by a semi-circle, the width of the worm head can be considered to be proportional to the number of cintillo cells, see Fig. E.1(c). The resulting scaling law for the width 134 E.2 Additional size measurements and growth dynamics Figure E.1.: (a) Relationship between area and length in well-fed worms. The red curve represents the result of a robust fit in the double-logarithmic plot (inset). In comparison, the dashed line denotes the scaling law of starved worms with exponent 1.8 (Imaging by Nicole Alt under the supervision of the author, analysis by the author includes 281 measurements 3 days after feeding). (b) Protein content per cell does not depend on worm size (measurement by Albert Thommen, analysis by the author, 45 worms, absolute values are only approximate). (c) Scaling of the number of cintillo cells along the head margin with worm length. Data measured by Oviedo et al. (150). (d) Feeding response after two weeks of starvation (Imaging by Ian Smith under the supervision of the author, analysis by the author, 20 worms). 135 051015202501020304050Area in mm2Length in mmLog lengthLog area(a)(b)0123456700.20.40.60.81Cell number in 106Protein content per cell in ng0246810020406080Number of cintillo cellsLength in mm(c)(d)0135790.70.80.911.11.2Time after feeding (days)Normalized areaE. ON GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER Figure E.2.: (a) Growth dynamics in Girardia tigrina based on measurements by Bagun`a et al. (15, 18). (b) The plot of our data for Smed corresponding to the plot in (a) shows a similar trend for the growth rates (blue) but a different behavior for the degrowth rates (red). (c) Growth and degrowth rates extracted from the data of Oviedo et al. for Smed are shown as black curves (150). These curves (for starvation and feeding twice a week) show a similar trend to our data (for starvation and feeding once a week), yet they do not agree quantitatively. with an exponent of 0.67 ± 0.03 is in agreement with our measurements of area versus length. Upon feeding, worms show a characteristic growth response. The immediate increase in worm size is mainly due to stuffing as discussed in Section 5.2.2. When comparing the feeding response after two weeks of starvation with the peak after one week of starvation of Fig. 5.4, we see no obvious dependence on feeding history. When being fed regularly, worms grow and degrow depending on the feeding frequency. Bagun`a et al. have determined the rates of addition and removal of cells in Girardia tigrina for various feeding conditions (15, 18). From this data, we can back-calculate the growth rates which they originally measured, see Fig. E.2(a). While the growth trends are similar to our results, the degrowth rates seem not to vary with size in contrast to our data, see Fig. E.2(b). Oviedo et al. have obtained linearly increasing and decreasing functions of the worm length with time during feeding and starvation, respectively (150). We can compute growth and degrowth rates from their data sets and compare them to our measurements in terms of worm length, see Fig. E.2(c). The linear growth behavior yields L/L ∝ ±1/L. Thus, the absolute rates are decreasing for large worms in agreement with our results. However, the curves do not fit our data points very well. They are shifted downwards even though the growing worms are even fed twice a week. In particular, the absolute values for the growth rate are smaller than for the degrowth rate, which contradicts our observation. 136 Length in mm24681012Growth rate (cell number) in %/ day-10122x/week1x/week2x/month1x/monthstarvation05101520−4−20246Length in mmGrowth rate (cell number) in %/day051015−2−101234Length in mmGrowth rate (length) in %/day(b)(c)(a)1x/weekstarvationstarvation2x/weekE.3 Measuring cell cycle times Figure E.3.: Dividing stem cells progress through four distinct cell cycle stages, which can be identified by respective markers. DNA replication happens in S-phase and cells divide in M-phase, while G1 and G2 are merely resting phases including check points for error control. We discuss an experiment to measure the cell division rates by blocking the transition from M-phase to G1 (red cross). E.3. Measuring cell cycle times Stem cells move through four distinct cell cycle phases, which can be characterized by different biochemical markers: pcna (all stem cells), clumping pcna (S-phase), cycling B (G2-phase), H3P (M-phase), see Fig. E.3. An increase of H3P marker has been measured upon feeding (71). Under the assumption that the duration of the M-phase is relatively constant, this can be interpreted as an increase in cell division rate. However, one cannot extract actual rates from this measurement if one does not know the duration of the M-phase. Bagun`a et al. have performed experiments from which they obtained cell division rates (12, 13, 15, 18, 176, 178). They blocked the progression through M-phase using colchicine as indicated by the red cross in Fig E.3, which results in an increasing number of cells in M-phase. Under the assumption that the M-phase has a constant duration and cell death can be neglected, the time derivative of the number of accumulating cells in M is a direct read-out of cell division rate. We plan to perform similar experiments using the cell cycle markers discussed above, which have not been available for the previous works. In particular, we aim to reveal how the division rates depend on size and feeding. By subtracting division rates from growth rates, we will also be able to extract the corresponding cell loss rates. Thus, we hope to reveal whether the control points of cell turnover are associated with the mechanisms for the addition or loss of cells. Furthermore, the time scale of the first response upon feeding might also hint at how the cell division rate is controlled. It has been discussed that there might be a population of slowly cycling cells that mainly stay in G2 to allow a fast regeneration and feeding 137 SMG1G2 celldifferentiation(H3P)(clumped pcna)(cyclin B)E. ON GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER response (12, 13, 139, 142, 170, 182). This represents a major investment of cellular resources as G2 cells already have a duplicated DNA. It would also be in contrast to the arrest in G1, typically observed for other organisms. If we were to measure a very fast division response, it would support the hypothesis of G2 arrested cells. E.4. Measuring cell turnover dynamics on the organism level Here, we discuss the theoretical framework for measuring turnover dynamics on the organismal level. It will enable us to test and compare various models with specific assumptions on how cell division and loss rates depend on feeding and worm size. The experimental approach relies on Histone labeling by heavy isotopes (SILAC). It is inspired by the measurements of neurogenesis dynamics in adult humans exploiting the known C14 concentration in the atmosphere due to nuclear bomb tests (203). First, we present the main principles of this paper. Next, we apply the idea to flatworms suggesting an adapted experimental protocol. Finally, we discuss details of histone labeling. E.4.1. Measurement of C14 reveals dynamics of neurogenesis in humans First, we briefly review the main ideas of the work by Spalding et al. (203) and introduce our notation. The paper describes a measurement of the turnover of hippocampal neurons in humans. It is based on the known C14 concentration in the atmosphere due to nuclear bomb tests, which becomes incorporated into the DNA as a label when a new cells is made. From this, we can compute the total C14 concentration in the DNA of a person of a particular age if we assume a particular model for the turnover dynamics. This result can then be benchmarked using the measured C14 in dead people. The starting point is that we have a list of several possible scenarios for how cell birth and cell death depends on each other as well as on the age of the cells and the age of the person. For each of these scenarios, we can compute a distribution n(A, a) that describes the number of cells of age a in a person of age A. This distribution changes over time because of aging (left) and because of cell death (right) ∂A n(A, a) + ∂a n(A, a) = −kloss(A, a) n(A, a) , (E.1) where kloss is the loss rate which might depend on the age of the person as well as the age of the cell. Cell birth is considered by the boundary condition n(A, 0) = n0(A) , (E.2) 138 E.4 Measuring cell turnover dynamics on the organism level Figure E.4.: Schematic representation of the C14 experiment for the measurement of turnover dynamics in human neurons (203). where n0(A) is the influx of cells due to cell division. Cell birth might depend on the age of the person explicitly but also implicitly by e.g. depending on the number of dying cells at each time point. Furthermore, as an initial condition it is assumed that a first set of cells is made in the embryo half a year before the person is born, resulting in an initial condition n(−0.5, a) = δ(a) . (E.3) This includes a delta function δ (which is zero for a (cid:54)= 0), describing the fact that cells are born with age 0. By solving the system of Eqs. E.1 - E.3, we determine the number of cells n(A, a) of age a for any age A of the person, given a specific model for kloss(A, a) and n0(A). In particular, we can predict the age distribution n(Ad, a) in a person who died at age Ad. For a person who died in year td, we can compute the total concentration of C14 label by (cid:90) Ad+0.5 C(td, Ad) = 0 N (Ad) Cin(td − a) n(Ad, a) da , (E.4) if the concentration Cin(t) of C14 inside the body (which could thus be incorporated in new cells) is known at any time point. The integral sums over all cells of all ages, multiplied by the amount of label Cin at the respective time of birth td − a. The result is normalized by the total number of all considered cells in a dead person, which is given by N (Ad) =(cid:82) Ad+0.5 0 n(Ad, a) da. The upper bound of integration reflects the maximum age obtained by cells, which persist during the full life span of the person. Note that the summand of 0.5 was missing in the original publication. 139 Knowing time course of C14 concentrationin the bodyGuessing models for the rates of cell death & birthCalculating total C14 label in a person that died at age in year :Comparing tomeasurementof Rating modelsEq.G.1-G.4E. ON GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER The concentration Cin of C14 inside the body is estimated from the known C14 concen- tration in the atmosphere by introducing a heuristic time lag of one year. Variations in the time lag are claimed not to significantly change the result. Different turnover models can be rated using the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC), which avoids over-fitting when comparing models with a different number of parameters. In brief, this technique calculates the likelihood that a certain model has generated the measured data. As a more complex model with more parameters tends to fit the data better, it introduces a simple but mathematically well-justified penalty term for the number of parameters based on information theory. E.4.2. Adapting the C14 technique to cell turnover in flatworms In contrast to the neurogenesis paper, we need to consider a different label than the C14 concentration in the atmosphere for flatworms. We choose to use the SILAC protocol (stable isotope labeling of amino acids) (32). The worms are fed with mouse liver, in which more than 96% of the amino acid lysine is replaced by the heavy isotope form 13C6-lysine. and in particular into histones, which package the DNA in the nucleus. Histones are In consequence, the labeled lysine gets incorporated into proteins believed to be only synthesized when a cell is made and to remain stable throughout the lifetime of the cell. Thus, the fraction of labeled histones can serve as a read-out for cell turnover. The technique from the neurogenesis paper has to be modified due to the unknown initial age distribution. -- In flatworms, we encounter two main differences: On the positive side, we can directly measure (and to some extent even deliberately vary) the label content in the body Cin(t). On the negative side, we do not know an initial age distribution analogous to Eq. E.3. In the following, we suggest experimental protocols that resolve this problem. Similar to Eq. E.1-E.2, we can describe the time evolution by ∂t n(t, a) + ∂a n(t, a) = −kloss(t, a) n(t, a) n(t, 0) = n0(t) . (E.5) (E.6) This set of equations can be solved analytically n(t, a) = n0(t − a) exp − . (E.7) (cid:90) a kloss(t − a + a(cid:48), a(cid:48)) da(cid:48)(cid:19) (cid:18) 0 140 E.4 Measuring cell turnover dynamics on the organism level The number of cells of age a at time t is the same number that was born at time t − a, but reduced by all the death events in between, described by the exponential term with the integral over the cell death time course. If we knew or were able to model all the cell birth and death processes for all times in the past, this solution would give us the full age distribution at time t. Alternatively, one could only consider birth and death rates starting from a particular time point, if one knew the initial distribution at this time, see Eq. E.3. Unfortunately, in flatworms we do neither know the age distribution at one initial time point nor the full feeding and growth history, which would enable us to model n0 and kloss. Luckily, there are two options to solve this problem, each relies on a particular assumption. First option: Assuming a stem cell control model. -- If there is no feedback from kloss(t, a) or n(t, a) on cell birth n0(t) (i.e. mainly negligible apoptosis-induced cell division), we can determine the age distribution n(t, a) at least partially for all ages a < t − t0, assuming the experiment (i.e. the well-controlled feeding conditions) starts at t0. The longer we perform the experiment, the more of the distribution we can compute. As cells do not live forever and the number of old cells decays exponentially (see Eq. E.7), we will approximately obtain the full age distribution with time. Second option: Assuming the system relaxes to a steady state for a reference feeding condition. -- If we provide a constant feeding condition, for which the worms neither grow nor degrow, we might assume that the age distribution eventually relaxes to a steady state n∗(a), which is a solution to the equation This equation can be solved for a particular choice of kloss(a) and n∗ 0: 0 e−(cid:82) a n∗(a) = n∗ ∂a n∗(a) = −kloss(a) n∗(a) . 0 kloss(a(cid:48)) da(cid:48) . (E.8) (E.9) In order to obtain such a steady state, we would need to constantly provide the worms with a small and well-controlled amount of food. Even though, theoretically it would be the most clean approach, experimentally it is rather difficult to frequently pipette a well-defined amount of food to each worm. Modified second option: Assuming a quasi-steady state for a reference feeding condition. -- If worms are fed every second week, on average, they will also neither grow nor degrow but show size oscillations with a frequency of two weeks. Importantly, the 141 E. ON GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER steady state argument can be modified for such a periodically oscillating quasi-steady state n∗(t, a). This quasi-steady state can be used as an initial condition for other feeding schemes in analogy to Eq. E.3. E.4.3. Label dynamics after a single feeding event Here, we illustrate the measurement scheme by discussing the effect of a single feeding pulse with labeled lysine in a simplified example. The total influx of the amino acid lysine is given by JAF = e−t/τF , NAF τF (E.10) where NAF is the total amount of the amino acid lysine in the gut after feeding and τF is the digestion time of the food. A certain fraction ΦAF of the lysine in the food is assumed to be labeled by heavy isotopes. After feeding with labeled food, the fraction ΦA of the labeled amino acid lysine in- creases in the animal. Lysine belongs to the building blocks of histones and other proteins, which also will become labeled by the incorporation the amino acid. As a simple example, let us assume there are only two proteins in the body that take up lysine: a fast turnover protein and histone. The result is qualitatively the same, inde- pendent of the number of proteins that incorporate lysine and might be turned over at very different rates. We define the label fraction ΦH of lysine in histones as the ratio between all labeled lysine in histones and the total amount of lysine in histones. Analogously, we also define the label fraction of the lysine in the fast turnover protein ΦP . If we furthermore assume that cell death happens stochastically and does not depend on the age of the cell, the dynamics of ΦA are captured by (1 − ρH )NAH NA (1 − ρP )NAP NA (ΦAF−ΦA)+ JAF NA ∂tΦA = (ΦP−ΦA)JP + (ΦH−ΦA) kloss N . (E.11) Here, NA denotes the total amount of lysine in the worm, (1 − ρP ) is the fraction of lysine that can be recycled from fast turnover proteins and NAP is the amount of lysine per protein. Analogously, (1 − ρH ) is the fraction of lysine that can be recycled from histones and NAH is the amount of lysine in all the histones in a cell. The label fraction of the amino acid only changes via recycling or feeding. Each further protein that incorporates lysine would be represented by an analogous term. 142 E.4 Measuring cell turnover dynamics on the organism level Figure E.5.: (a) Example dynamics for a single labeling pulse. The label fraction of a fast turnover protein (dashed green) acts as an approximate read-out of the available amount of labeled amino acid lysine (gray), which can be incorporated into other proteins such as histones (red). As an example, we have chosen the fast turnover half as fast as the label digestion and ten times as fast as the cell turnover. If digestion and the fast turnover happen at comparable time scales, the gray and the green curves collapse. (b) Labeling scheme: the label dynamics in the fast turnover protein corresponds to labeled lysine in the worm, while the label incorporation in histones reflects the cell turnover. Similarly, the dynamics of the label fractions of the fast turnover proteins and the histones are ∂tΦP = ∂tΦH = (ΦA − ΦP ) JP (ΦA − ΦH ) n0 . NAP NP NAH NH (E.12) (E.13) The label fractions of lysine ΦA, the fast turnover protein ΦP and histone ΦH are shown in Fig. E.5(a) for a single feeding pulse with labeled food. ΦA (gray) cannot be measured directly, yet the fast turnover protein (dashed green) immediately follows and can be used as a read-out of labeled lysine. Finally, the histones (red) also incorporate the label on a much longer time scale given by the life times of the cells. Fig. E.5(b) sketches the main principle of the experiment. By combining the measured fraction of labeled fast turnover proteins with a model on cell turnover, we can compute ΦH = (cid:90) ∞ ΦP (t − a) n(t, a) 0 N (t) da (E.14) and compare it to the measured value of ΦH (t). Here, ΦP (t) takes over the role of Cin(t) in Eq. E.4. Yet, in contrast to the neurogenesis paper, the concentration of label 143 TimeLabel fractionAmino acidFast turnover proteinHistone(a)(b)feedingamino acid lysinefast turnover proteinhistoneclose to equilibriumtime scale of cell turnover(read out of labeled amino acid)E. ON GROWTH AND CELL TURNOVER in the worm (which can be incorporated into histones) can be directly measured by monitoring the label in high turnover proteins. E.4.4. Challenges and advantages of the application to flatworms Lacking knowledge about an initial age distribution, we have to rely on experimental protocols and specific assumptions that eliminate a potential history-dependence. We can tackle this problem by assuming a periodically varying quasi-steady state when feeding every second week and maybe independently measure the respective cell birth rate. We will be able to estimate the time scale of the relaxation to this quasi-steady state based on the spreading of neoblast clones in irradiated worms. Once it has been characterized, the quasi-steady state can act as the initial configuration for other feeding schemes. As an advantage in flatworms, we might be able to deliberately vary the time course of the internalized label by alternating between labeled and non-labeled food. This might help to distinguish different models for birth rate n0 and death rate kloss to a higher resolution. Note that the more Cin(t) or ΦP (t) varies with time, the more details of the models can be resolved. If the internal label was kept constant, almost any model would fit the data equally well. As a second advantage, we can directly determine the label in the body using high turnover proteins. 144 List of Figures 1.1. Development and Regeneration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2. Body axes and morphogenesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3. Morphogen gradients . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4. Gene expression . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5. Complexity and regneration capabilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.6. Organs of Smed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.7. Growth and regeneration of Smed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 4 6 7 9 10 12 1.8. Sequential development vs. regeneration from arbitrary initial conditions 14 1.9. French flag model and Turing mechanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.10. Two possible topologies with two Turing molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1. Perfect versus approximate shape scaling of morphogen gradients . . . . 2.2. Gradient scaling and implications for the amplitude . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3. Scaling with an autonomously controlled expander . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4. Expander-repression model and deviations from scaling . . . . . . . . . 2.5. Two main classes of expander models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6. Hierarchy of Turing patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7. Relative source size of a Turing system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.8. Absence of scaling in classcial Turing patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1. Turing patterns vs. scaling patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2. Scaling in a Turing system with expander feedback . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3. Fixed points and dynamics in a Turing system with expander feedback . 3.4. Amputation experiment with ten cuts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5. β-catanin gradient in flatworms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1. Flatworm speed and phenotypes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2. Three shape modes characterize body shape dynamics . . . . . . . . . . 4.3. Distinguishing head morphologies of flatworm species. . . . . . . . . . . 15 18 25 26 29 31 33 36 37 39 43 45 47 51 55 61 64 67 5.1. Cell turnover and growth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71 145 LIST OF FIGURES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2. Stem cell control vs. cell death control . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3. Allometric scaling Laws 5.4. Growth response upon feeding . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5. Growth and degrowth rates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.6. Non-trivial growth dynamics in flatworms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.7. Dynamic energy storage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.8. Growth models with energy storage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.9. Catabolic default state and mitotic bursts upon feeding . . . . . . . . . 5.10. Turnover of epidermis cells . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.11. Measuring cell turnover dynamics with two labels . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72 74 78 80 82 86 88 92 94 97 A.1. Eigenvalues of the reaction-diffusion matrix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 108 A.2. Homogeneous steady state of our Turing system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 113 A.3. (1, 1)-pattern and its source size . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 115 A.4. Constructing a hierarchy of Turing patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118 A.5. Linear stability analysis of inhomogeneous Turing patterns . . . . . . . . 119 A.6. RNAi experiments in Turing systems with expander . . . . . . . . . . . 124 C.1. Extracting size and shape from worm movies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 131 E.1. Additional scaling laws and feeding peaks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 135 E.2. Previously measured growth dynamics in flatworms . . . . . . . . . . . . 136 E.3. Cell division rates from cell cycle dynamics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137 E.4. Measurement of turnover dynamics in humans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 139 E.5. Measuring turnover dynamics on the organism scale in flatworms . . . . 143 146 List of Variables In Chapter 2. Scaling in morphogen systems, and Chapter 3. Scaling and regeneration of self-organized patterns: C C0 Z ν w α β D λ =(cid:112)D/β E νE wE αE βE DE λE Cth β0 Eth χλ = λ/L χw = w/L A, B Bc a, b RA, RB P h (cid:96) = (cid:104)P(cid:105) L αA, αB βA, βB DA, DB λA, λB M s q m concentration profile of morphogens amplitude of morphogen profile shape function of morphogen profile production function of morphogen source size of morphogen production rate of morphogen effective degradation rate of morphogen effective diffusion coefficient of morphogen length scale of morphogen profile concentration profile of expander source function of expander source size of expander production rate of expander effective degradation rate of expander effective diffusion coefficient of expander length scale of expander profile threshold for expander production (expansion-repression model) morphogen degradation in the absence of expander (exp.-rep. model) conc. threshold for feedback of expander on morphogen degradation proportionality factor between λ and L proportionality factor between w and L concentration profiles of Turing molecules (activator and inhibitor) formal shift of inhibitor concentration between the two Turing topologies small perturbations of steady state profiles generic reaction functions of Turing system switch-like source function of Turing system (Hill or Heaviside function) exponent for Hill function size of self-organized source region (includes spatial average of P ) production rates of Turing molecules degradation rates of Turing molecules diffusion coefficients of Turing molecules characteristic length scales of Turing molecules linearized reaction-diffusion matrix wavenumber of Fourier modes eigenvalues of reaction-diffusion matrix number of contiguous source regions 147 LIST OF FIGURES number of source regions touching the system boundary n σ = 2m − n pattern number Lσ κA, κB, κE E0 f(m,n) g χ = B/A system size beyond which a Turing pattern of pattern number σ exists coupling constant for degradation rates in scalable Turing system hypothetically imposed expander level in scalable Turing system source size on the nullcline of scalable Turing system for ∂tE = 0 source size of a homogeneous dynamic state for low expander levels constant ratio in a homogeneous dynamic state for low expander levels In Chapter 4. Flatworm shape dynamics and motility: arc-length along worm circumference total length of circumference normalized arc-length radial position vector center point of worm radial distance mean radius normalized radius profile defining the shape average shape variations number of worm outlines number of data points along worm perimeter s L s = s/L r r0 ρ = r − r0 ρ ρ = ρ(s)/ρ ρ0 Nw Nr Ri,j = ρi(sj) data matrix C v B covariance matrix eigenvectors or shape modes eigenvalues or shape scores In Chapter 5. Quantitative study of flatworm growth and cell turnover: N kdiv kloss K = kdiv − kloss Et ec = E/N Jf jf = jf /N µ K0 es τK e0 a n N(cid:96) total cell number average cell division rate average cell loss rate average growth rate total stored metabolic energy in the worm stored metabolic energy per cell influx of metabolic energy due to feeding influx of metabolic energy per cell metabolic consumption rate per cell degrowth rate in the absence of any stored energy (model 1) energy threshold for the switch between growth and degrowth (model 1) relaxation time of the growth rate to a quasi steady state (model 2,3) target value of the metabolic energy (model 2,3) age of cells number density of cells of age a number of labeled cells 148 LIST OF FIGURES ki, kd, kr ¯kd ¯kd(cid:96), ¯kr(cid:96) φ(cid:96) N1, N2 ¯kd1, ¯kr1 ¯kd2, ¯kr2 φ12 = N1/N2 age-dependent rates of insertion, deletion and replacement of cells averaged rate of deletion across the tissue averaged rates of deletion and replacement of labeled cells fraction of labeled cells number of cells with one or two labels averaged rates of deletion and replacement of cells with one label averaged rates of deletion and replacement of cells with two labels label ratio 149 References [1] Abeloos, M. (1929). Recherches exp´erimentales sur la croissance et la r´eg´en´eration chez les planaires. Ph.D. thesis, Paris. 79, 133 [2] Abrams, E.W. & Mullins, M.C. (2010). Early zebrafish development: maternal genes. Current opinion in genetics & development, 19, 396 -- 403. 13 It's in the [3] Adell, T., Sal`o, E., Boutros, M. & Bartscherer, K. (2009). Smed-Evi/Wntless is required for beta-catenin-dependent and -independent processes during planarian re- generation. Development (Cambridge, England), 136, 905 -- 910. 12, 54, 99 [4] Adell, T., Cebri`a, F. & Sal´o, E. (2010). Gradients in planarian regeneration and homeostasis. Cold Spring Harbor perspectives in biology, 2, a000505. 6, 9, 12, 13, 54, 57, 98 [5] Affolter, M. & Basler, K. (2007). The Decapentaplegic morphogen gradient: from pattern formation to growth regulation. Nature reviews. Genetics, 8, 663 -- 74. 5 [6] Agrawal, N., Dasaradhi, P.V.N., Mohmmed, A., Malhotra, P., Bhatnagar, R.K. & Mukherjee, S.K. (2003). RNA Interference: Biology, Mechanism, and Appli- cations. Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reviews, 67, 657 -- 685. 8 [7] Agutter, P.S. & Wheatley, D.N. (2004). Metabolic scaling: consensus or contro- versy? Theoretical biology & medical modelling, 1, 13. 87, 89 [8] Almuedo-Castillo, M., Sal´o, E. & Adell, T. (2011). Dishevelled is essential for neural connectivity and planar cell polarity in planarians. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 108, 2813 -- 2818. 9, 58, 59, 62, 66 [9] Almuedo-Castillo, M., Sureda-G´omez, M. & Adell, T. (2012). Wnt signaling in planarians: new answers to old questions. The international journal of developmental biology, 56, 53 -- 65. 6, 12, 13, 54, 57, 62, 98 [10] Almuedo-Castillo, M., Crespo, X., Seebeck, F., Bartscherer, K., Sal`o, E. & Adell, T. (2014). JNK Controls the Onset of Mitosis in Planarian Stem Cells and Trig- gers Apoptotic Cell Death Required for Regeneration and Remodeling. PLoS Genetics, 10. 12 [11] Averbukh, I., Ben-Zvi, D., Mishra, S. & Barkai, N. (2014). Scaling morphogen gradients during tissue growth by a cell division rule. Development, 141, 2150 -- 6. 24, 27, 42, 98, 102 150 REFERENCES [12] Bagun`a, J. (1974). Dramatic mitotic response in planarians after feeding, and a hypoth- esis for the control mechanism. Journal of Experimental Zoology, 190, 117 -- 122. 77, 91, 137, 138 [13] Bagun`a, J. (1976). Mitosis in the Intact and Regenerating Planarian Dugesia mediter- ranea n.sp. I. Mitotic studies during growth, feeding and starvation. Journal of Experi- mental Zoology, 195, 53 -- 64. 12, 75, 76, 77, 83, 91, 137, 138 [14] Bagun`a, J. (1976). Mitosis in the Intact and Regenerating Planarian Dugesia mediter- ranea n.sp. II. Mitotic studies during regeneration, and a possible mechanism of blastema formation. Journal of Experimental Zoology, 195, 65 -- 79. 12 [15] Bagun`a, J. (2012). The planarian neoblast: the rambling history of its origin and some current black boxes. The International journal of developmental biology, 19 -- 37. 3, 10, 11, 79, 133, 136, 137 [16] Bagun`a, J. & Romero, R. (1981). Quantitative analysis of cell types during growth, degrowth and regeneration in the planarians Dugesia mediterranea and Dugesia tigrina. Hydrobiologia, 84, 181 -- 194. 10, 71, 75, 76, 77, 83, 91 [17] Bagun`a, J., Sal´o, E. & Auladell, C. (1989). Regeneration and pattern formation in planarians. III. Evidence that neoblasts are totipotent stem cells and the source of blastema cells. Development, 107, 77 -- 86. 10 [18] Bagun`a, J., Romero, R., Sal´o, E., Collet, J., Auladell, C., Ribas, M., Ri- utort, M., Garc´ıa-Fern`andez, J., Burgaya, F. & Bueno, D. (1990). Growth, degrowth and regeneration as developmental phenomena in adult freshwater planarians. In H.J. Marthy, ed., Experimental embryology in aquatic plants and animals, 129 -- 162, Plenum Press, New York. 10, 79, 83, 133, 136, 137 [19] Barkai, N. & Ben-Zvi, D. (2009). 'Big frog, small frog' -- maintaining proportions in embryonic development. The FEBS journal , 276, 1196 -- 1207. 29 [20] Barkai, N. & Shilo, B.Z. (2009). Robust generation and decoding of morphogen gra- dients. Cold Spring Harbor perspectives in biology, 1, 1 -- 15. 24 [21] Barnard, C. (2004). Animal Behaviour. Mechanism, Development, Function, and Evo- lution. Pearson Education Canada. 59 [22] Beane, W.S., Morokuma, J., Adams, D.S. & Levin, M. (2012). A Chemical Genetics Approach Reveals H,K-ATPase-Mediated Membrane Voltage is Required for Planarian Head Regeneration. Chemical Biology, 18, 77 -- 89. 57 [23] Beane, W.S., Morokuma, J., Lemire, J.M. & Levin, M. (2013). Bioelectric sig- naling regulates head and organ size during planarian regeneration. Development (Cam- bridge, England), 140, 313 -- 22. 13, 57 [24] Ben-Zvi, D. & Barkai, N. (2010). Scaling of morphogen gradients by an expansion- repression integral feedback control. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of 151 REFERENCES the United States of America, 107, 6924 -- 9. 22, 23, 24, 26, 27, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 41, 42, 56 [25] Ben-Zvi, D., Shilo, B.Z., Fainsod, A. & Barkai, N. (2008). Scaling of the BMP activation gradient in Xenopus embryos. Nature, 453, 1205 -- 11. 27, 57 [26] Ben-Zvi, D., Pyrowolakis, G., Barkai, N. & Shilo, B.Z. (2011). Expansion- repression mechanism for scaling the Dpp activation gradient in Drosophila wing imaginal discs. Current biology, 21, 1391 -- 6. 24, 26, 27, 29, 30, 31, 33, 41, 56, 98 [27] Ben-Zvi, D., Shilo, B.Z. & Barkai, N. (2011). Scaling of morphogen gradients. Cur- rent opinion in genetics & development, 21, 704 -- 10. 22, 24, 26, 27, 42 [28] Benazzi, M., Ballester, R., Bagun´a, J. & Puccinelli, I. (1972). The Fissiparous Race of the Planarian Dugesia Lugubris S.L. Found in Barcelona (Spain) Belongs to the Biotype G: Comparative Analysis of the Karyotypes. Caryologia, 25, 59 -- 68. 129 [29] Bergmann, S., Sandler, O., Sberro, H., Shnider, S., Schejter, E., Shilo, B.Z. & Barkai, N. (2007). Pre-Steady-State Decoding of the Bicoid Morphogen Gradient. PLoS Biology, 5, e46. 24 [30] Berninger, J. (1911). Uber die Einwirkung des Hungers auf Planarien. In J. Spengel, ed., Zoologische Jahrbucher , 181 -- 216, Verlag Gustav Fischer, Jena, 30th edn. 133 [31] Bittig, T. (2008). Morphogenetic signaling in growing tissues. Ph.D. thesis, TU Dresden. 102 [32] Boser, A., Drexler, H.C.A., Reuter, H., Schmitz, H., Wu, G., Scholer, H.R., Gentile, L. & Bartscherer, K. (2013). SILAC proteomics of planarians identifies Ncoa5 as a conserved component of pluripotent stem cells. Cell reports, 5, 1142 -- 55. 140 [33] Bowen, I.D., Ryder, T.A. & Dark, C. (1976). The effects of starvation on the pla- narian worm Polycelis tenuis iijima. Cell and Tissue Research, 169, 193 -- 209. 133 [34] Calow, P. (1977). The joint effect of temperature and starvation on the metabolism of triclads. Oikos, 29, 87 -- 92. 81 [35] Cebri`a, F. & Newmark, P.A. (2005). Planarian homologs of netrin and netrin receptor are required for proper regeneration of the central nervous system and the maintenance of nervous system architecture. Development (Cambridge, England), 132, 3691 -- 703. 129 [36] Child, C.M. (1911). Studies on the dynamics of morphogenesis and inheritance in ex- perimental reproduction. I. The axial gradient in planaria dorotocephala as a limiting factor in regulation. Journal of Experimental Zoology, 10, 265 -- 320. 4, 8 [37] Chong, T., Stary, J.M., Wang, Y. & Newmark, P.A. (2011). Molecular mark- ers to characterize the hermaphroditic reproductive system of the planarian Schmidtea mediterranea. BMC Developmental Biology, 11, 69. 10 152 REFERENCES [38] Cochet-Escartin, O., Mickolajczyk, K.J. & Collins, E.M.S. (2015). Scrunching: a novel escape gait in planarians. Physical Biology, 12, 056010. 59, 68 [39] Cross, M.C. & Hohenberg, P.C. (1993). Pattern formation outside of equilibrium. Reviews of Modern Physics, 65, 851 -- 1112. 20 [40] Davidson, K.C., Adams, A.M., Goodson, J.M., McDonald, C.E., Potter, J.C., Berndt, J.D., Biechele, T.L., Taylor, R.J. & Moon, R.T. (2012). Wnt/β-catenin signaling promotes differentiation, not self-renewal, of human embryonic stem cells and is repressed by Oct4. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 109, 4485 -- 90. 6 [41] Dobzhansky, T. (1973). Nothing in biology makes sense except in the light of evolution. The American Biology Teacher , 35, 125 -- 129. 100 [42] Driesch, H. (1908). The science and philosophy of the organism. Adam and Charles Black, London. 3 [43] Driever, W. & Nusslein-Volhard, C. (1988). A gradient of bicoid protein in Drosophila embryos. Cell , 54, 83 -- 93. 5, 6 [44] Driever, W. & Nusslein-Volhard, C. (1988). The bicoid protein determines position in the Drosophila embryo in a concentration-dependent manner. Cell , 54, 95 -- 104. 5, 23 [45] Driever, W., Siegel, V. & Nusslein-Volhard, C. (1990). Autonomous determi- nation of anterior structures in the early Drosophila embryo by the bicoid morphogen. Development (Cambridge, England), 109, 811 -- 820. 5 [46] Dubois, F. (1949). Contribution a l'´etude de la migration des cellules de r´eg´en´eration chez les Planaires Dulcicoles. Ph.D. thesis, Strasbourg. 10 [47] Dubuis, J.O., Tkacik, G., Wieschaus, E.F., Gregor, T. & Bialek, W. (2013). Positional information, in bits. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 110, 16301 -- 16308. 20 [48] Dunkel, J., Talbot, J. & Schotz, E.M. (2011). Memory and obesity affect the population dynamics of asexual freshwater planarians. Physical biology, 8, 026003. 11, 129 [49] Economou, A.D., Ohazama, A., Porntaveetus, T., Sharpe, P.T., Kondo, S., Basson, M.A., Gritli-Linde, A., Cobourne, M.T. & Green, J.B.A. (2012). Peri- odic stripe formation by a Turing mechanism operating at growth zones in the mammalian palate. Nature Genetics, 44, 348 -- 351. 16 [50] Egger, B., Gschwentner, R. & Rieger, R. (2007). Free-living flatworms under the knife: Past and present. Development Genes and Evolution, 217, 89 -- 104. 8, 9, 11, 57, 66, 134 153 REFERENCES [51] Elliott, S.A. & S´anchez Alvarado, A. (2013). The history and enduring contribu- tions of planarians to the study of animal regeneration. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Developmental Biology, 2, 301 -- 326. 10, 54, 58 [52] Ephrussi, A. & St Johnston, D. (2004). Seeing Is Believing: The Bicoid Morphogen Gradient Matures. Cell , 116, 143 -- 152. 5 [53] Flatt, T. (2012). A New Definition of Aging? Frontiers in Genetics, 3, 1 -- 2. 134 [54] Forsthoefel, D.J. & Newmark, P.A. (2009). Emerging patterns in planarian regen- eration. Current opinion in genetics & development, 19, 412 -- 20. 12, 13, 20, 54 [55] Fried, P. & Iber, D. (2014). Dynamic scaling of morphogen gradients on growing domains. Nature Communications, 5, 5077. 24, 98 [56] Frohnhofer, H.G. & Nusslein-Volhard, C. (1986). Organization of anterior pattern in the Drosophila embryo by the maternal gene bicoid. Nature, 324, 120 -- 125. 5 [57] Fu, J., Posnien, N., Bolognesi, R., Fischer, T.D., Rayl, P., Oberhofer, G., Kitzmann, P., Brown, S.J. & Bucher, G. (2012). Asymmetrically expressed axin required for anterior development in Tribolium. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109, 7782 -- 7786. 13 [58] Gallagher, T., Bjorness, T., Greene, R., You, Y.J. & Avery, L. (2013). The geometry of locomotive behavioral states in C. elegans. PloS one, 8, e59865. 59 [59] Gao, B., Song, H., Bishop, K., Elliot, G., Garrett, L., English, M.A., Andre, P., Robinson, J., Sood, R., Minami, Y., Economides, A.N. & Yang, Y. (2011). Wnt Signaling Gradients Establish Planar Cell Polarity by Inducing Vangl2 Phosphory- lation through Ror2. Developmental Cell , 20, 163 -- 176. 62 [60] Gao, C. & Chen, Y.G. (2010). Dishevelled: The hub of Wnt signaling. Cellular Sig- nalling, 22, 717 -- 727. 62 [61] Gavino, M.A. & Reddien, P.W. (2011). A Bmp/Admp regulatory circuit controls maintenance and regeneration of dorsal-ventral polarity in planarians. Current Biology, 21, 294 -- 299. 6, 57 [62] Gavino, M.A., Wenemoser, D., Wang, I.E. & Reddien, P.W. (2013). Tissue ab- sence initiates regeneration through Follistatin-mediated inhibition of Activin signaling. eLife, 2013, 1 -- 13. 13 [63] Gentile, L., Cebri`a, F. & Bartscherer, K. (2011). The planarian flatworm: an in vivo model for stem cell biology and nervous system regeneration. Disease models & mechanisms, 4, 12 -- 19. 8, 10, 11 [64] Gierer, A. (1981). Generation of biological patterns and form: Some physical, math- ematical, and logical aspects. Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol , 37, 1 -- 47. 15, 16, 17, 18, 38, 109 154 REFERENCES [65] Gierer, A. (1988). Biological Pattern Formation and Physico-Chemical Laws. Synerget- ics and Dynamic Instabilities, 151 -- 174. 15, 16, 17, 18, 109 [66] Gierer, A. & Meinhardt, H. (1972). A theory of biological pattern formation. Kyber- netik , 12, 30 -- 9. 15, 19, 38 [67] Gierer, A. & Meinhardt, H. (1974). Biological pattern formation involving lateral inhibition. In S.A. Levin, ed., Some Mathematical Questions in Biology. VI, Lectures on Mathematics in the Life Sciences, Vol. 7 , 163 -- 183, American Mathematical Soc. 38 [68] Gilbert, S.F. (2014). Developmental Biology. Sinauer Associates, Incorporated, Sun- derland, MA. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 13, 20, 73 [69] Gonz´alez-Est´evez, C. (2009). Autophagy meets planarians. Autophagy, 5, 290 -- 297. 9, 10, 11, 12 [70] Gonz´alez-Est´evez, C., Felix, D.A., Aboobaker, A.A. & Sal´o, E. (2007). Gtdap- 1 promotes autophagy and is required for planarian remodeling during regeneration and starvation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of Amer- ica, 104, 13373 -- 13378. 11 [71] Gonz´alez-Est´evez, C., Felix, D.A., Rodr´ıguez-Esteban, G. & Aboobaker, A.A. (2012). Decreased neoblast progeny and increased cell death during starvation- induced planarian degrowth. The International journal of developmental biology, 56, 83 -- 91. 77, 81, 87, 91, 97, 133, 137 [72] Green, J.B., New, H.V. & Smith, J.C. (1992). Responses of embryonic Xenopus cells to activin and FGF are separated by multiple dose thresholds and correspond to distinct axes of the mesoderm. Cell , 71, 731 -- 9. 5, 14 [73] Green, J.B., Smith, J.C. & Gerhart, J.C. (1994). Slow emergence of a multithresh- old response to activin requires cell-contact-dependent sharpening but not prepattern. Development (Cambridge, England), 120, 2271 -- 8. 14 [74] Green, J.B.A. & Sharpe, J. (2015). Positional information and reaction-diffusion: two big ideas in developmental biology combine. Development (Cambridge, England), 142, 1203 -- 1211. 14, 15, 16, 42 [75] Green, J.B.A. & Smith, J.C. (1990). Graded changes in dose of a Xenopus activin A homologue elicit stepwise transitions in embryonic cell fate. Nature, 347, 391 -- 394. 5, 14 [76] Gregor, T., Bialek, W., de Ruyter van Steveninck, R.R., Tank, D.W. & Wi- eschaus, E.F. (2005). Diffusion and scaling during early embryonic pattern formation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 102, 18403 -- 7. 13, 20, 22, 23, 27, 57 [77] Gregor, T., Tank, D.W., Wieschaus, E.F. & Bialek, W. (2007). Probing the limits to positional information. Cell , 130, 153 -- 64. 20 155 REFERENCES [78] Gregor, T., Wieschaus, E.F., McGregor, A.P., Bialek, W. & Tank, D.W. (2007). Stability and nuclear dynamics of the bicoid morphogen gradient. Cell , 130, 141 -- 52. 23, 27, 28, 33 [79] Gurdon, J.B. & Bourillot, P.Y. (2001). Morphogen gradient interpretation. Nature, 413, 797 -- 803. 5 [80] Gurdon, J.B., Mitchell, A. & Mahony, D. (1995). Direct and continuous assessment by cells of their position in a morphogen gradient. 5, 14 [81] Gurley, K., Elliott, S. & Simakov, O. (2010). Expression of secreted Wnt path- way components reveals unexpected complexity of the planarian amputation response. Developmental biology, 347, 24 -- 39. 12, 13, 54, 62, 98 [82] Gurley, K.A., Rink, J.C. & S´anchez Alvarado, A. (2008). Beta-catenin defines head versus tail identity during planarian regeneration and homeostasis. Science (New York, N.Y.), 319, 323 -- 7. 12, 54, 60, 61, 98 [83] Hamaratoglu, F., de Lachapelle, A.M., Pyrowolakis, G., Bergmann, S. & Affolter, M. (2011). Dpp signaling activity requires Pentagone to scale with tissue size in the growing Drosophila wing imaginal disc. PLoS biology, 9, e1001182. 24 [84] Handberg-Thorsager, M. & Sal´o, E. (2007). The planarian nanos-like gene Smednos is expressed in germline and eye precursor cells during development and regeneration. Development genes and evolution, 217, 403 -- 11. 10, 133 [85] Handberg-Thorsager, M., Fernandez, E. & Sal´o, E. (2008). Stem cells and re- generation in planarians. Frontiers in bioscience : a journal and virtual library, 13, 6374 -- 6394. 11 [86] Haranghy, L. & Bal´azs, A. (1964). Ageing and rejuvenation in planarians. Experi- mental Gerontology, 1, 77 -- 91. 133, 134 [87] Haynie, D.T. (2001). Biological Thermodynamics. Cambridge University Press. 20 [88] Herpin, A. (2004). Transforming growth factor-β-related proteins: an ancestral and widespread superfamily of cytokines in metazoans. Developmental & Comparative Im- munology, 28, 461 -- 485. 5 [89] Howard, J., Grill, S.W. & Bois, J.S. (2011). Turing's next steps: the mechanochem- ical basis of morphogenesis. Nature reviews. Molecular cell biology, 12, 392 -- 8. 13 [90] Hunding, A. & Sørensen, P.G. (1988). Size adaptation of Turing prepatterns. Journal of mathematical biology, 26, 27 -- 39. 28, 33, 41, 42, 56 [91] Hyman, L.H. (1919). Physiological studies on Planaria. I. Oxygen consumption related to feeding and starvation. American Journal of Physiology, 49, 377 -- 402. 134 [92] Hyman, L.H. (1919). Physiological Studies on Planaria. III . Oxygen Consumption in Relation to Age (Size) Differences. Biological Bulletin, 37, 388 -- 403. 87, 89, 133 156 REFERENCES [93] Hyman, L.H., Willier, B.H. & Rifenburgh, S.A. (1924). Physiological studies on Planaria. VI. A respiratory and histochemical investigation of the source of the increased metabolism after feeding. Journal of Experimental Zoology, 40, 473 -- 494. 90 [94] Inomata, H., Shibata, T., Haraguchi, T. & Sasai, Y. (2013). Scaling of Dorsal- Ventral Patterning by Embryo Size-Dependent Degradation of Spemann's Organizer Sig- nals. Cell , 153, 1296 -- 1311. 27 [95] Inoue, T., Kumamoto, H. & Okamoto, K. (2004). Morphological and functional re- covery of the planarian photosensing system during head regeneration. Zoological science, 21, 275 -- 283. 9, 59 [96] Ishihara, S. & Kaneko, K. (2006). Turing pattern with proportion preservation. Jour- nal of theoretical biology, 238, 683 -- 93. 24, 27, 28, 33, 38, 41, 42, 56 [97] Jackson, J.E. (2005). A user's guide to principal components. John Wiley & Sons. 59 [98] Jenkins, M.M. (1963). Bipolar Planarians in a Stock Culture. Science (New York, N.Y.), 142, 1187. 57 [99] Jolliffe, I. (2005). Principal component analysis. Wiley Online Library. 59 [100] Kalthoff, K. (1976). Analysis of a Cytoplasmic Determinant in an Insect Egg. In M. Karkinen-Jaaskelainen & L. Weiss, eds., Cell Interactions in differentiation, 5 -- 21, Academic Press, London. 5 [101] Kang, H. & Alvarado, A.S. (2009). Flow cytometry methods for the study of cell-cycle parameters of planarian stem cells. Developmental Dynamics, 238, 1111 -- 1117. 91 [102] Kato, K., Orii, H., Watanabe, K. & Agata, K. (1999). The role of dorsoventral interaction in the onset of planarian regeneration. Development (Cambridge, England), 126, 1031 -- 1040. 56 [103] Kavanagh, K.D., Shoval, O., Winslow, B.B., Alon, U., Leary, B.P., Kan, A. & Tabin, C.J. (2013). Developmental bias in the evolution of phalanges. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 110, 18190 -- 18195. 59, 69 [104] Kiecker, C. & Niehrs, C. (2001). A morphogen gradient of Wnt/beta-catenin sig- nalling regulates anteroposterior neural patterning in Xenopus. Development (Cambridge, England), 128, 4189 -- 4201. 14 [105] Kirk, G.S. (1954). Heraclitus: The Cosmic Fragments. Cambridge University Press. 70 [106] Koch, A. & Meinhardt, H. (1994). Biological pattern formation: from basic mecha- nisms to complex structures. Reviews of Modern Physics, 66. 15 [107] Komiya, Y. & Habas, R. (2008). Wnt signal transduction pathways. Organogenesis, 4, 68 -- 75. 6, 60, 62 [108] Kriss, T.C. & Kriss, V.M. (1998). History of the Operating Microscope: From Mag- nifying Glass to Microneurosurgery. Neurosurgery, 42, 899 -- 907. 3 157 REFERENCES [109] Kruse, K., Pantazis, P., Bollenbach, T., Julicher, F. & Gonz´alez-Gait´an, M. (2004). Dpp gradient formation by dynamin-dependent endocytosis: receptor trafficking and the diffusion model. Development (Cambridge, England), 131, 4843 -- 56. 5, 6 [110] Lange, C.S. (1967). A quantitative study of the number and distribution of neoblasts in Dugesia lugubris (Planaria) with reference to size and ploidy. Journal of embryology and experimental morphology, 18, 199 -- 213. 75, 76, 83 [111] Lange, C.S. (1968). A possible explanation in cellular terms of the physiological ageing of the planarian. Experimental gerontology, 3, 219 -- 230. 75, 76, 83, 97, 133 [112] Lawrence, P.A. (2001). Morphogens: how big is the big picture? Nature cell biology, 3, E151 -- E154. 13 [113] Layalle, S., Arquier, N. & L´eopold, P. (2008). The TOR Pathway Couples Nu- trition and Developmental Timing in Drosophila. Developmental Cell , 15, 568 -- 577. 20, 70 [114] LeRoith, D., Shiloach, J., Heffron, R., Rubinovitz, C., Tanenbaum, R. & Roth, J. (1985). Insulin-related material in microbes: similarities and differences from mammalian insulins. Canadian journal of biochemistry and cell biology = Revue canadi- enne de biochimie et biologie cellulaire, 63, 839 -- 49. 87 [115] Levin, M. (2012). Molecular bioelectricity in developmental biology: new tools and recent discoveries: control of cell behavior and pattern formation by transmembrane potential gradients. BioEssays: news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology, 34, 205 -- 17. 57 [116] Liu, S.Y., Selck, C., Friedrich, B., Lutz, R., Vila-Farr´e, M., Dahl, A., Brandl, H., Lakshmanaperumal, N., Henry, I. & Rink, J.C. (2013). Reactivating head regrowth in a regeneration-deficient planarian species. Nature, 500, 81 -- 4. 12, 66 [117] Lobo, D., Beane, W.S. & Levin, M. (2012). Modeling planarian regeneration: a primer for reverse-engineering the worm. PLoS computational biology, 8, e1002481. 12, 13, 54, 98, 99 [118] Ma, R., Klindt, G.S., Riedel-Kruse, I.H., Julicher, F. & Friedrich, B.M. (2014). Active Phase and Amplitude Fluctuations of Flagellar Beating. Physical Review Letters, 113, 048101. 59 [119] Marcon, L. & Sharpe, J. (2012). Turing patterns in development: what about the horse part? Current opinion in genetics & development, 22, 578 -- 84. 16 [120] Meinhardt, H. (1982). Models of biological pattern formation. Academic Press, London. 15, 16, 18, 20, 38 [121] Meinhardt, H. (2004). Different strategies for midline formation in bilaterians. Nature reviews. Neuroscience, 5, 502 -- 10. 99 158 REFERENCES [122] Meinhardt, H. (2009). Models for the generation and interpretation of gradients. Cold Spring Harbor perspectives in biology, 1, a001362. 57 [123] Michael Bate & Alfonso Martinez Arias, eds. (1993). The Development of Drosophila Melanogaster , vol. 1. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, New York. 24 [124] Milo, R., Jorgensen, P., Moran, U., Weber, G. & Springer, M. (2010). BioNumbers -- the database of key numbers in molecular and cell biology. Nucleic acids research, 38, D750 -- 3. 70, 84, 90 [125] Mocek, R. (1971). Wilhelm Roux und Hans Driesch - Zur Geschichte der Entwick- lungsphysiologie der Tiere. Gustav Fischer, Jena. 3 [126] Montgomery, J.R. & Coward, S.J. (1974). On the minimal size of a planarian capable of regeneration. Transactions of the American Microscopical Society, 93, 386 -- 391. 9 [127] Morgan, T.H. (1898). Experimental studies of the regeneration of Planaria maculata. Archiv fur Entwicklungsmechanik der Organismen, 7, 364 -- 397. 54 [128] Morgan, T.H. (1901). Regeneration. New York, The Macmillan Company; London, Macmillan & Co., ltd. 3, 4, 8, 9, 12 [129] Morgan, T.H. (1905). "Polarity" considered as a phenomenon of gradation of materials. Journal of Experimental Zoology, 2, 495 -- 506. 4, 8 [130] Morgan, T.H. (1927). Experimental embryology. Columbia University Press, New York. 22 [131] Morita, M. & Best, J.B. (1984). Effects of photoperiods and melatonin on planarian asexual reproduction. Journal of Experimental Zoology, 231, 273 -- 282. 11 [132] Moritz, S., Stockle, F., Ortmeier, C., Schmitz, H., Rodr´ıguez-Esteban, G., Key, G. & Gentile, L. (2012). Heterogeneity of planarian stem cells in the S/G2/M phase. The International journal of developmental biology, 56, 117 -- 25. 11 [133] Mouton, S., Willems, M., Houthoofd, W., Bert, W. & Braeckman, B.P. (2011). Lack of metabolic ageing in the long-lived flatworm Schmidtea polychroa. Ex- perimental Gerontology, 46, 755 -- 761. 75, 76, 84, 87, 89, 90, 133 [134] Muller, P., Rogers, K.W., Jordan, B.M., Lee, J.S., Robson, D., Ramanathan, S. & Schier, a.F. (2012). Differential Diffusivity of Nodal and Lefty Underlies a Reaction-Diffusion Patterning System. Science, 336, 721 -- 724. 16 [135] Mumcu, P. (2011). Self-organized Growth in Developing Epithelia. Ph.D. thesis, TU Dresden. 14, 24, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 33, 41 [136] Nakamasu, A., Takahashi, G., Kanbe, A. & Kondo, S. (2009). Interactions between zebrafish pigment cells. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 106, 8429 -- 8434. 16 159 REFERENCES [137] Nakamura, T., Mine, N., Nakaguchi, E., Mochizuki, A., Yamamoto, M., Yashiro, K., Meno, C. & Hamada, H. (2006). Generation of Robust Left-Right Asym- metry in the Mouse Embryo Requires a Self-Enhancement and Lateral-Inhibition System. Developmental Cell , 11, 495 -- 504. 16 [138] Neumann, C. & Cohen, S. (1997). Morphogens and pattern formation. BioEssays, 19, 721 -- 729. 5 [139] Newmark, P.A. & S´anchez Alvarado, A. (2000). Bromodeoxyuridine specifically labels the regenerative stem cells of planarians. Developmental biology, 220, 142 -- 153. 77, 91, 138 [140] Newmark, P.A. & S´anchez Alvarado, A. (2002). Not your father's planarian: a classic model enters the era of functional genomics. Nature reviews. Genetics, 3, 210 -- 9. 8, 9, 10, 11, 57, 71, 133, 134 [141] Niehrs, C. (2010). On growth and form: a Cartesian coordinate system of Wnt and BMP signaling specifies bilaterian body axes. Development (Cambridge, England), 137, 845 -- 857. 3, 6, 12, 54, 57 [142] Nimeth, K.T., Mahlknecht, M., Mezzanato, A., Peter, R., Rieger, R. & Ladurner, P. (2004). Stem Cell Dynamics during Growth, Feeding, and Starvation in the Basal Flatworm Macrostomum sp. (Platyhelminthes). Developmental Dynamics, 230, 91 -- 99. 77, 91, 138 [143] Nusse, R., He, X. & van Amerongen, R., eds. (2013). Wnt Signaling: A Subject Col- lection from Cold Spring Harbor Perspectives in Biology. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, New York. 7, 9 [144] Oberhofer, G., Grossmann, D., Siemanowski, J.L., Beissbarth, T. & Bucher, G. (2014). Wnt/β-catenin signaling integrates patterning and metabolism of the insect growth zone. Development (Cambridge, England), 1 -- 11. 6 [145] Okubo, A. (1980). Diffusion and ecological problems: Mathematical models. Springer, Berlin. 19 [146] Okubo, A. & Levin, S.A. (2002). Diffusion and Ecological Problems, Modern Perspec- tives, Second Edition. Springer. 17, 18, 19, 109 [147] Oster, G.F. (1988). Lateral inhibition models of developmental processes. Mathematical Biosciences, 90, 265 -- 286. 13, 16, 18, 55 [148] Othmer, H.G. & Pate, E. (1980). Scale-invariance in reaction-diffusion models of spa- tial pattern formation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 77, 4180 -- 4. 24, 27, 28, 33, 38, 41, 42, 56 [149] Oviedo, N.J. & Levin, M. (2007). Smedinx-11 Is a Planarian Stem Cell Gap Junction Gene Required for Regeneration and Homeostasis. Development (Cambridge, England), 134, 3121 -- 3131. 13 160 REFERENCES [150] Oviedo, N.J., Newmark, P.A. & S´anchez Alvarado, A. (2003). Allometric scaling and proportion regulation in the freshwater planarian Schmidtea mediterranea. Develop- mental Dynamics, 226, 326 -- 333. 71, 75, 76, 81, 134, 135, 136 [151] Oviedo, N.J., Nicolas, C.L., Adams, D.S. & Levin, M. (2008). Planarians: a ver- satile and powerful model system for molecular studies of regeneration, adult stem cell regulation, aging, and behavior. CSH protocols, 2008, pdb.emo101. 8, 11, 71 [152] Oviedo, N.J., Morokuma, J., Walentek, P., Kema, I.P., Gu, M.B., Ahn, J.M., Hwang, J.S., Gojobori, T. & Levin, M. (2010). Long-range neural and gap junc- tion protein-mediated cues control polarity during planarian regeneration. Developmental Biology, 339, 188 -- 199. 9, 55, 57 [153] Paskin, T.R., Jellies, J., Bacher, J. & Beane, W.S. (2014). Planarian Phototac- tic Assay Reveals Differential Behavioral Responses Based on Wavelength. PloS one, 9, e114708. 9 [154] Pate, E. & Othmer, H.G. (1984). Applications of a model for scale-invariant pattern formation in developing systems. Differentiation, 28, 1 -- 8. 24, 27, 28, 33, 41, 42, 56 [155] Pavlova, G.A. (2000). Ciliary locomotion of the mollusk is different from that of the planaria. Doklady biological sciences : proceedings of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR, Biological sciences sections / translated from Russian, 375, 630 -- 2. 60 [156] Pearson, K. (1901). On lines and planes of closest fit to systems of points in space. Philosophical Magazine Series 6 , 2, 559 -- 572. 59 [157] Peiris, T.H. & Oviedo, N.J. (2013). Gap junction proteins: Master regulators of the planarian stem cell response to tissue maintenance and injury. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta - Biomembranes, 1828, 109 -- 117. 57 [158] Pellettieri, J. & S´anchez Alvarado, A. (2007). Cell turnover and adult tissue homeostasis: from humans to planarians. Annual review of genetics, 41, 83 -- 105. 1, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 20, 70, 71, 134 [159] Pellettieri, J., Fitzgerald, P., Watanabe, S., Mancuso, J., Green, D.R. & S´anchez Alvarado, A. (2010). Cell death and tissue remodeling in planarian regener- ation. Developmental biology, 338, 76 -- 85. 10, 71, 91 [160] Petersen, C.P. & Reddien, P.W. (2008). Smed-betacatenin-1 is required for antero- posterior blastema polarity in planarian regeneration. Science (New York, N.Y.), 319, 327 -- 330. 12, 54 [161] Pigon, A., Morita, M. & Best, J.B. (1974). Cephalic mechanism for social control of fissioning in planarians. II. Localization and identification of the receptors by election micrographic and ablation studies. Journal of Neurobiology, 5, 443 -- 462. 11, 129 [162] Prados, J., Alvarez, B., Howarth, J., Stewart, K., Gibson, C.L., Hutchinson, C.V., Young, A.M.J. & Davidson, C. (2013). Cue competition effects in the planarian. Animal Cognition, 16, 177 -- 186. 8 161 REFERENCES [163] Press, W., Teukolsky, S., Vetterling, W., Flannery, B., Ziegel, E., Press, W., Flannery, B., Teukolsky, S. & Vetterling, W. (2002). Numerical Recipes: The Art of Scientific Computing, vol. 29. Cambridge University Press, 2nd edn. 125 [164] Raspopovic, J., Marcon, L., Russo, L. & Sharpe, J. (2014). Digit patterning is controlled by a Bmp-Sox9-Wnt Turing network modulated by morphogen gradients. Science, 566, 10 -- 15. 6, 16 [165] Reddien, P.W. & S´anchez Alvarado, A. (2004). Fundamentals of planarian regen- eration. Annual review of cell and developmental biology, 20, 725 -- 57. 9, 10, 12 [166] Reed, J.C. (1999). Dysregulation of apoptosis in cancer. Journal of Clinical Oncology, 17, 2941 -- 2953. 70 [167] Richards, D.M. & Saunders, T.E. (2015). Spatiotemporal analysis of different mech- anisms for interpreting morphogen gradients. Biophysical journal , 108, 2061 -- 73. 14, 24 [168] Ringelnatz, J. (1924). Abseits der Geographie. In Nervosipopel. Elf Angelegenheiten, chap. 2, Gunther Langes, Munchen. 11 [169] Rink, J., Gurley, K., Elliott, S. & S´anchez Alvarado, A. (2009). Planarian Hh signaling regulates regeneration polarity and links Hh pathway evolution to cilia. Science, 326, 1406. 9, 57, 58, 59, 66 [170] Rink, J.C. (2013). Stem cell systems and regeneration in planaria. Development Genes and Evolution, 223, 67 -- 84. 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 71, 91, 138 [171] Rink, J.C., Vu, H.T.K. & S´anchez Alvarado, A. (2011). The maintenance and regeneration of the planarian excretory system are regulated by EGFR signaling. Devel- opment (Cambridge, England), 138, 3769 -- 80. 9, 10 [172] Rivera-Pomar, R. & Jackle, H. (1996). From gradients to stripes in Drosophila embryogenesis: filling in the gaps. Trends in Genetics, 12, 478 -- 483. 13 [173] Roberts-Galbraith, R.H. & Newmark, P.A. (2015). On the organ trail: insights into organ regeneration in the planarian. Current Opinion in Genetics & Development, 32, 37 -- 46. 10, 68 [174] Rogers, K.W. & Schier, A.F. (2011). Morphogen gradients: from generation to in- terpretation. Annual review of cell and developmental biology, 27, 377 -- 407. 4, 5, 13 [175] Romanczuk, P. & Salbreux, G. (2015). Optimal chemotaxis in intermittent migration of animal cells. Physical Review E , 91, 42720. 14 [176] Romero, R. & Bagun`a, J. (1988). Quantitative cellular analysis of cell cycle strategies of iteroparous and semelparous triclads. Fortschritte der Zoologie, 36, 283 -- 289. 137 [177] Romero, R. & Bagun`a, J. (1991). Quantitative cellular analysis of growth and repro- duction in freshwater planarians (Turbellaria; Tricladida). I. A cellular description of the intact organism. 76 162 REFERENCES [178] Romero, R., Bagun`a, J. & Calow, P. (1991). Intraspecific Variation in Somatic Cell Turnover and Regenerative Rate in the Freshwater Planarian Dendrocoelum Lacteum. Invertebrate Reproduction & Development, 20, 107 -- 113. 137 [179] Rompolas, P., Patel-King, R.S. & King, S.M. (2009). Schmidtea mediterranea: a model system for analysis of motile cilia., vol. 93. Elsevier, first edit edn. 8, 9, 58, 59, 66 [180] Rompolas, P., Patel-King, R.S. & King, S.M. (2010). An outer arm Dynein confor- mational switch is required for metachronal synchrony of motile cilia in planaria. Molec- ular biology of the cell , 21, 3669 -- 79. 9, 58, 59, 66 [181] Ruan, S. (1998). Diffusion-driven instability in the Gierer-Meinhardt model of morpho- genesis. Natural Resource Modeling, 11. 19 [182] Sal´o, E. & Bagun`a, J. (1984). Regeneration and pattern formation in planarians. J. Embryol exp. Morph., 83, 63 -- 80. 138 [183] Sal´o, E., Abril, J.F., Adell, T., Cebri`a, F., Eckelt, K., Fernandez-Taboada, E., Handberg-Thorsager, M., Iglesias, M., Molina, M.D. & Rodr´ıguez- Esteban, G. (2009). Planarian regeneration: achievements and future directions after 20 years of research. The International journal of developmental biology, 53, 1317 -- 1327. 8, 9, 11 [184] S´anchez Alvarado, A. & Tsonis, P.a. (2006). Bridging the regeneration gap: genetic insights from diverse animal models. Nature reviews. Genetics, 7, 873 -- 884. 1, 8, 9, 68 [185] S´anchez Alvarado, A., Newmark, P.A., Robb, S.M. & Juste, R. (2002). The Schmidtea mediterranea database as a molecular resource for studying platyhelminthes, stem cells and regeneration. Development (Cambridge, England), 129, 5659 -- 65. 129 [186] Sander, K. (1960). Analyse des ooplasmatischen Reaktionssystems vonEuscelis plebe- jus Fall (Cicadina) durch Isolieren und Kombinieren von Keimteilen II. Mitteilung Die Differenzierungsleistungen nach Verlagern von Hinterpolmaterial. Wilhelm Roux' Archiv fur Entwicklungsmechanik der Organismen, 151, 660 -- 707. 5 [187] Sander, K. (1975). Pattern Specification in the Insect Embryo. In R. Porter & J. Rivers, eds., Ciba Foundation Symposium 29 - Cell Patterning, chap. 12, 241 -- 263, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., Chichester, UK. 5 [188] Sander, K. (1997). Landmarks in Developmental Biology 1883-1924 , vol. 53. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg. 3, 4 [189] Sanger, T.D. (2000). Human arm movements described by a low-dimensional superpo- sition of principal components. The Journal of neuroscience : the official journal of the Society for Neuroscience, 20, 1066 -- 72. 59 [190] Savage, V.M., Allen, A.P., Brown, J.H., Gillooly, J.F., Herman, A.B., Woodruff, W.H. & West, G.B. (2007). Scaling of number, size, and metabolic rate of cells with body size in mammals. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 104, 4718 -- 4723. 87, 89 163 REFERENCES [191] Schier, A.F. (2009). Nodal morphogens. Cold Spring Harbor Perspectives in Biology, 1, a003459 -- a003459. 14, 16 [192] Schroedinger, E. (1944). What is life? . Cambridge University Press. 1 [193] Schultz, E. (1904). Uber Reduktionen. I. Uber Hungerserscheinungen bei Planaria lactea. Archiv fur Entwicklungsmechanik der Organismen, 18, 555 -- 577. 71, 133 [194] Scimone, M.L., Kravarik, K.M., Lapan, S.W. & Reddien, P.W. (2014). Neoblast Specialization in Regeneration of the Planarian Schmidtea mediterranea. Stem Cell Re- ports, 3, 1 -- 14. 11 [195] Segel, L.A. & Jackson, J.L. (1972). Dissipative structure: an explanation and an ecological example. Journal of theoretical biology, 37, 545 -- 59. 16, 17, 109 [196] Seifert, J.R.K. & Mlodzik, M. (2007). Frizzled/PCP signalling: a conserved mecha- nism regulating cell polarity and directed motility. Nature Reviews Genetics, 8, 126 -- 138. 58 [197] Sheth, R., Marcon, L., Bastida, M.F., Junco, M., Quintana, L., Dahn, R., Kmita, M., Sharpe, J. & Ros, M.A. (2012). Hox Genes Regulate Digit Patterning by Controlling the Wavelength of a Turing-Type Mechanism. Science, 338, 1476 -- 1480. 16 [198] Shomrat, T. & Levin, M. (2013). An automated training paradigm reveals long-term memory in planaria and its persistence through head regeneration. The Journal of exper- imental biology. 8 [199] Shoval, O., Sheftel, H., Shinar, G., Hart, Y., Ramote, O., Mayo, A., Dekel, E., Kavanagh, K. & Alon, U. (2012). Evolutionary trade-offs, Pareto optimality, and the geometry of phenotype space. Science (New York, N.Y.), 336, 1157 -- 60. 59, 69 [200] Sikes, J.M. & Newmark, P.A. (2013). Restoration of anterior regeneration in a pla- narian with limited regenerative ability. Nature, 500, 77 -- 80. 12 [201] Simanov, D., Mellaart-Straver, I., Sormacheva, I. & Berezikov, E. (2012). The flatworm macrostomum lignano is a powerful model organism for ion channel and stem cell research. Stem Cells International , 2012. 13 [202] Sluys, R., Timoshkin, O.A. & Kawakatsu, M. (1998). A new species of giant pla- narian from Lake Baikal, with some remarks on character states in the Dendrocoelidae (Platyhelminthes, Tricladida, Paludicola). Hydrobiologia, 383, 69 -- 75. 8 [203] Spalding, K.L., Bergmann, O., Alkass, K., Bernard, S., Salehpour, M., Hut- tner, H.B., Bostrom, E., Westerlund, I., Vial, C., Buchholz, B.A., Possnert, G., Mash, D.C., Druid, H. & Fris´en, J. (2013). Dynamics of hippocampal neuroge- nesis in adult humans. Cell , 153, 1219 -- 27. 92, 138, 139 [204] Spemann, H. & Mangold, H. (1924). Uber Induktion von Embryonalanlagen durch Implantation artfremder Organisatoren. Roux's Arch. Entw. Mech., 599 -- 638. 5 164 REFERENCES [205] Spencer, F.a., Hoffmann, F.M. & Gelbart, W.M. (1982). Decapentaplegic: a gene complex affecting morphogenesis in Drosophila melanogaster. Cell , 28, 451 -- 461. 5 [206] St Johnston, D. & Nusslein-Volhard, C. (1992). The origin of pattern and polarity in the Drosophila embryo. Cell , 68, 201 -- 19. 24 [207] Stephens, G.J., Johnson-Kerner, B., Bialek, W. & Ryu, W.S. (2008). Dimen- sionality and dynamics in the behavior of C. elegans. PLoS Comp Biol , 4, e1000028. 59, 99 [208] Stephens, G.J., Johnson-Kerner, B., Bialek, W. & Ryu, W.S. (2010). From modes to movement in the behavior of Caenorhabditis elegans. PloS one, 5, e13914. 59, 68, 99 [209] Stephens, G.J., Bueno de Mesquita, M., Ryu, W.S. & Bialek, W. (2011). Emer- gence of long timescales and stereotyped behaviors in Caenorhabditis elegans. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 108, 7286 -- 7289. 59, 99 [210] Sullivan, L.H. (1896). The Tall Office Building Artistically Considered. Lippincott's Magazine, 403 -- 409. 58 [211] Takeda, H., Nishimura, K. & Agata, K. (2009). Planarians maintain a constant ratio of different cell types during changes in body size by using the stem cell system. Zoological science, 26, 805 -- 813. 75, 76 [212] Talbot, J. & Schotz, E.M. (2011). Quantitative characterization of planarian wild- type behavior as a platform for screening locomotion phenotypes. The Journal of experi- mental biology, 214, 1063 -- 1067. 8, 60 [213] Tan, T.C.J., Rahman, R., Jaber-Hijazi, F., Felix, D.A., Chen, C., Louis, E.J. & Aboobaker, A. (2012). Telomere maintenance and telomerase activity are differentially regulated in asexual and sexual worms. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109, 4209 -- 4214. 133 [214] Tata, P.R., Mou, H., Pardo-Saganta, A., Zhao, R., Prabhu, M., Law, B.M., Vinarsky, V., Cho, J.L., Breton, S., Sahay, A., Medoff, B.D. & Rajagopal, J. (2013). Dedifferentiation of committed epithelial cells into stem cells in vivo. Nature, 503, 218 -- 223. 3 [215] Thomas, M.A., Quinodoz, S. & Schotz, E.M. (2012). Size Matters! Journal of Statistical Physics, 148, 664 -- 676. 81, 133 [216] Thompson, D.W. (1910). A history of animals. Clarendon Press, Oxford. 2 [217] Thompson, D.W. (1945). On Growth and Form. Cambridge : University Press ; New York : Macmillan, 2nd edn. 1, 42 [218] Tkacik, G. & Bialek, W. (2014). Information processing in living systems. arXiv , 1 -- 21. 20 165 REFERENCES [219] Tkacik, G. & Walczak, A.M. (2011). Information transmission in genetic regulatory networks: a review. Journal of physics. Condensed matter , 23, 153102. 20 [220] Travis, G. (1981). Replicating Replication? Aspects of the Social Construction of Learn- ing in Planarian Worms. Social Studies of Science, 11, 11 -- 32. 9 [221] Turing, A.M. (1952). The Chemical Basis of Morphogenesis. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B , 237, 37 -- 72. 5, 13, 15, 16, 17, 109 [222] Umesono, Y., Tasaki, J., Nishimura, Y., Hrouda, M., Kawaguchi, E., Yazawa, S., Nishimura, O., Hosoda, K., Inoue, T. & Agata, K. (2013). The molecular logic for planarian regeneration along the anterior-posterior axis. Nature, 500, 73 -- 6. 12 [223] Umulis, D.M. & Othmer, H.G. (2013). Mechanisms of scaling in pattern formation. Development, 140, 4830 -- 43. 13, 20, 22, 24, 26, 27, 42 [224] Urdy, S. (2012). On the evolution of morphogenetic models: mechano-chemical inter- actions and an integrated view of cell differentiation, growth, pattern formation and morphogenesis. Biological Reviews, 87, 786 -- 803. 13 [225] van Wolfswinkel, J.C., Wagner, D.E. & Reddien, P.W. (2014). Single-Cell Anal- ysis Reveals Functionally Distinct Classes within the Planarian Stem Cell Compartment. Cell Stem Cell , 1 -- 14. 11 [226] Vladar, E.K., Antic, D. & Axelrod, J.D. (2009). Planar cell polarity signaling: the developing cell's compass. Cold Spring Harbor perspectives in biology, 1, a002964. 58 [227] von Bertalanffy, L. (1940). Untersuchungen uber die Gesetzlichkeit des Wachstums - III. Teil. Quantitative Beziehungen zwischen Darmoberflache und Korpergrosse bei Pla- naria maculata. Wilhelm Roux' Archiv fur Entwicklungsmechanik der Organismen, 140, 81 -- 89. 75, 76 [228] von Goethe, J.W. (1933). Faust - Der Tragodie zweiter Teil . J.G. Cotta'sche Buch- handlung, Stuttgart, Tubingen. 3 [229] Wagner, D.E., Wang, I.E. & Reddien, P.W. (2011). Clonogenic neoblasts are pluripotent adult stem cells that underlie planarian regeneration. Science (New York, N.Y.), 332, 811 -- 6. 10, 134 [230] Wang, Y., Zayas, R.M., Guo, T. & Newmark, P.A. (2007). Nanos Function Is Essential for Development and Regeneration of Planarian Germ Cells. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 104, 5901 -- 5906. 133 [231] Wang, Y., Stary, J.M., Wilhelm, J.E. & Newmark, P.A. (2010). A functional genomic screen in planarians identifies novel regulators of germ cell development. Genes & development, 24, 2081 -- 92. 10 [232] Wartlick, O., Kicheva, A. & Gonz´alez-Gait´an, M. (2009). Morphogen gradient formation. Cold Spring Harbor perspectives in biology, 1, a001255. 13, 20, 23 166 REFERENCES [233] Wartlick, O., Mumcu, P., Julicher, F. & Gonz´alez-Gait´an, M. (2011). Under- standing morphogenetic growth control -- lessons from flies. Nature reviews. Molecular cell biology, 12, 594 -- 604. 14, 24, 27, 28, 33, 41, 98 [234] Wartlick, O., Mumcu, P., Kicheva, A., Bittig, T., Seum, C., Julicher, F. & Gonz´alez-Gait´an, M. (2011). Dynamics of Dpp signaling and proliferation control. Science (New York, N.Y.), 331, 1154 -- 9. 5, 14, 23, 24, 27, 28, 33, 41, 42 [235] Wartlick, O., Julicher, F. & Gonz´alez-Gait´an, M. (2014). Growth control by a moving morphogen gradient during Drosophila eye development. Development, 141, 1884 -- 93. 14, 24 [236] Watanabe, M. & Kondo, S. (2015). Is pigment patterning in fish skin determined by the Turing mechanism? Trends in Genetics, 31, 88 -- 96. 16 [237] Wenemoser, D. & Reddien, P.W. (2010). Planarian regeneration involves distinct stem cell responses to wounds and tissue absence. Developmental Biology, 344, 979 -- 991. 12 [238] Werner, S., Rink, J.C., Riedel-Kruse, I.H. & Friedrich, B.M. (2014). Shape Mode Analysis Exposes Movement Patterns in Biology: Flagella and Flatworms as Case Studies. PLoS ONE , 9, e113083. 58 [239] Werner, S., Stuckemann, T., Beir´an Amigo, M., Rink, J.C., Julicher, F. & Friedrich, B.M. (2015). Scaling and Regeneration of Self-Organized Patterns. Physical Review Letters, 114. 22, 42 [240] West, G.B., Woodruff, W.H. & Brown, J.H. (2002). Allometric scaling of metabolic rate from molecules and mitochondria to cells and mammals. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 99 Suppl 1, 2473 -- 2478. 84, 90 [241] Whittaker, J.R. (1982). Muscle lineage cytoplasm can change the developmental ex- pression in epidermal lineage cells of ascidian embryos. Dev Biol , 93, 463 -- 470. 3 [242] Wilson, P.a. & Melton, D.a. (1994). Mesodermal patterning by an inducer gradient depends on secondary cell-cell communication. Curr Biol , 4, 676 -- 86. 14 [243] Wolpert, L. (1969). Positional information and the spatial pattern of cellular differen- tiation. Journal of theoretical biology, 25, 1 -- 47. 5, 13 [244] Wolpert, L. & Tickle, C. (2011). Principles of Development. Oxford University Press, New York. 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 13, 20, 68, 70 [245] Yazawa, S., Umesono, Y., Hayashi, T., Tarui, H. & Agata, K. (2009). Planarian Hedgehog/Patched establishes anterior-posterior polarity by regulating Wnt signaling. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 106, 22329 -- 34. 10, 54, 57 167 Eigenstandigkeitserklarung Hiermit versichere ich, dass ich die vorliegende Arbeit ohne unzulassige Hilfe Dritter und ohne Benutzung anderer als der angegebenen Hilfsmittel ange- fertigt habe; die aus fremden Quellen direkt oder indirekt ubernommenen Gedanken sind als solche kenntlich gemacht. Die Arbeit wurde bisher weder im Inland noch im Ausland in gleicher oder ahnlicher Form einer anderen Prufungsbehorde vorgelegt. Die vorliegende Arbeit wurde im Zeitraum zwischen Oktober 2011 und Dezember 2015 unter der Betreuung durch Prof. Dr. Frank Julicher und Dr. Benjamin M. Friedrich am Max-Planck-Institut fur Physik komplexer Systeme in Dresden angefertigt. Ich versichere, dass ich bisher keine erfolglosen Promotionsverfahren un- ternommen habe. Ich erkenne die Promotionsordnung der Fakultat der Mathematik und Naturwissenschaften der Technischen Universitat Dresden an. Teile dieser Arbeit wurden schon in folgender Form veroffentlicht: - S. Werner, J.C. Rink, I.-H. Riedel-Kruse, B.M. Friedrich: Shape mode analysis exposes movement patterns in biology, PLoS ONE, 9(11), e113083, 2014 - S. Werner, T. Stuckemann, M. Beiran Amigo, J.C. Rink, F. Julicher, B.M. Friedrich: Scaling and regeneration of self-organized patterns, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 138101, 2015 (Editors' suggestion) Dresden,
1007.0315	1	1007	2010-07-02T08:08:52	A simple theory of protein folding kinetics	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.chem-ph", "q-bio.BM" ]	We present a simple model of protein folding dynamics that captures key qualitative elements recently seen in all-atom simulations. The goals of this theory are to serve as a simple formalism for gaining deeper insight into the physical properties seen in detailed simulations as well as to serve as a model to easily compare why these simulations suggest a different kinetic mechanism than previous simple models. Specifically, we find that non-native contacts play a key role in determining the mechanism, which can shift dramatically as the energetic strength of non-native interactions is changed. For protein-like non-native interactions, our model finds that the native state is a kinetic hub, connecting the strength of relevant interactions directly to the nature of folding kinetics.	physics.bio-ph	physics	A simple theory of protein folding kinetics Departments of Chemistry, Structural Biology, and Computer Science, Stanford University, Stanford, CA (Dated: May 29, 2018) Vijay S. Pande We present a simple model of protein folding dynamics that captures key qualitative elements recently seen in all-atom simulations. The goals of this theory are to serve as a simple formalism for gaining deeper insight into the physical properties seen in detailed simulations as well as to serve as a model to easily compare why these simulations suggest a different kinetic mechanism than previous simple models. Specifically, we find that non-native contacts play a key role in determining the mechanism, which can shift dramatically as the energetic strength of non-native interactions is changed. For protein-like non-native interactions, our model finds that the native state is a kinetic hub, connecting the strength of relevant interactions directly to the nature of folding kinetics. PACS numbers: Introduction.- Protein folding has been an important problem at the crossroads of statistical mechanics, com- puter simulation, and biophysics. There has been a long history of theoretical advances in the study of protein folding, and we refer the reader to reviews [1–4]. Re- cent advances in computer simulations have enabled one to use detailed, atomistic models to simulate the com- plete process of folding, on relatively long (millisecond) timescales [5]. This has become possible due to the ad- vent of Markov State Models (MSMs) (see Refs. [4, 6] for recent reviews), an approach which uses detailed sim- ulation to construct a Master equation for the statistical dynamics of a particular protein. By examining and comparing MSMs for different pro- teins (as well as by direct examination of simulations), some surprises have emerged. Perhaps most importantly, the role of non-native contacts has now been highlighted as a key part of protein folding [5, 7]; in hindsight, this is natural, since amino acid interactions are not particularly specific and there often is little free energetic difference between say a native-like interaction between two aro- matic residues vs a non-native like interaction [5]. This opens a new door to re-examine simple models of pro- tein folding and to develop a new theoretical formalism to more naturally include non-native interactions. In this work, we take a Master equation approach to dynamics, much like one does computationally with MSMs. The key question is how to model the rate ma- trix. Previous models for protein folding kinetics [8, 9] (derived from models of spin glass dynamics [10]) have made very simple approximations for the nature of the rate matrix. Here, we develop a new theoretical frame- work for the rate matrix which allows for a more detailed model of kinetics, especially the natural inclusion of non- native interactions. The application of this model to var- ious regimes of protein-sequences allows one to make a direct connection to recent simulations [5] and, via a sim- ple, solvable analytic model, describe the essence of na- tive hubs (i.e. transitions between non-native states occur via the native state) recently seen in simulation [7]. Model.- We first introduce a phenomenological Hamil- tonian for the energy of structure α: Hα = ǫN X ij Cα ij CN ij + ǫN N X ij Cα ij(1 − CN ij ) (1) where Cα ij is the contact map of structure (microstate) α (i.e. either 1 if a contact between residues i and j is present in the structure α or 0 otherwise) and CN ij is the contact map of the native state. We choose the native contacts and non-native contacts to have differing ener- getic contributions (ǫN and ǫN N , respectively), noting that these quantities could naturally be negative (espe- cially ǫN ). Note that we are including terms such as solvent entropy in the "energy" term above. This Hamiltonian reduces to Hα = ǫN qα,N + ǫN N (qα,α − qα,N ) = ǫxqα,N + ǫN N qα,α, where ǫx ≡ ǫN − ǫN N is the extra energetic preference for native over non-native contacts and qα,β ≡ Pij Cα ij is the number of contacts in common between structures α and β (also note that thus qα,α is shorthand for the total number of contacts in structure α). This Hamiltonian is simple, yet captures the main element of interest in this work: the interplay between native and non-native interactions. ij Cβ However, in order to make a connection to more de- tailed calculations, it is useful to note that a simi- lar expression can be derived from more direct physi- from a microscopic Hamiltonian with cal grounds, i.e. the explicit concept of sequence design [2]. Starting from the more general, microscopic contact Hamiltonian Hα = Pij Cα ij Bsi,sj , where BIJ is a general matrix of monomer-monomer interactions (and we use capital let- ters to designate the space of different types of residues). This is analogous to problems that have already been solved [2], yielding (to lowest order in 1/Td) the effective Hamiltonian for α is Heff α = Fα + T Sloop α = Bqαα − B2 c 2Td qαN (2) where Td is the design temperature (lower Td means bet- ter optimized sequences), and we see terms involving the mean (B) and the variance (B2 c ) of the BIJ ma- trix take the roles of of ǫN N and ǫx, respectively, in our phenomenological Hamiltonian. Having both rep- resentations (i.e. the phenomenological as well as the microscopic Hamiltonian) allows us also to make a natu- ral connection to previous work [2]. We will return to the sequence-based Hamiltonian results at the end, in order to make a more direct connection to protein biophysics. Kinetics formalism.- To build a kinetic model, we con- sider the master equation: dpα dt = X β kαβ pβ (3) which means that we must consider the nature of the rate matrix kαβ. To more easily see the impact of these elemental rates on the overall dynamics, we propose a simple model for the rate matrix: a block-diagonal ma- trix with a block diagonal form of n blocks each of size m rows but now with one additional row for the folded (native) state. Specifically, with elements of the form 2 where k is the microscopic rate of interconversion, Fα is the free energy of α, and F ‡ αβ is the free energy of the transition state (denoted by ‡) between α and β (note that this is not the global transition state, but just the transition state between structures α and β). Since the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the kαβ matrix define the relevant timescales and dynamics, respectively, the next step is to flesh out this matrix in more detail. There have been previous approximations to model kαβ, notably setting kαβ = k exp(−Eβ/T ) [10] or kαβ = k exp(Eα/T ) [11], which yielding solvable models within the Random Energy Model (REM) leading to power- law [10] and stretched exponential [11] relaxation, re- spectively. Also of note is an extension to GREM [8]. However, there are two key limitations to these methods. First, they only directly apply to a theory for kinetics of random sequences. Second, as we argue below, by consid- ering the structure of the transition state for transitions explictly, we can improve upon the previous models. We propose that the transition state between struc- tures α and β can be approximated in terms of the con- tacts in common between these structures: k1 k0 k0N kN 0 within a nonnative block between nonnative blocks from non−native to native from native to non−native kαβ =   −Pβ6=α kαβ on diagonal (4) Here, the n blocks are meant to represent n mestastable states, each consisting of m highly related conformations. Note that this matrix obeys detailed balance, although we have made the simplifying approximation that the free energy of states within a block are similar and the free energy between non-native blocks is also similar. This rate matrix has a well defined set of degener- ate eigenvalues: a non-degenerate eigenvalue of 0 (the equilibrium eigenvalue), a (n − 1)-fold degenerate eigen- value of κ0 ≡ nmk0 + kN 0 (for transitions between non- native blocks), a [n(m − 1)]-fold degenerate eigenvalue of m(n − 1)k0 + mk1 + kN 0) (for transitions within a block), and a non-degerate eigenvalue of κN ≡ nmk0N +kN 0 (for transitions to the native state). We note in passing that the degeneracy in the eigenvalues seen here is naturally broken by some small variations in rates between states (i.e. the rates between all non-native states would not be all exactly k0). Also, variations in the value of m between blocks do not change the results discussed below. In the large n limit, the ratio of rates of transforma- tions between non-native blocks vs those from non-native to native will be κ0/κN = (nmk0 + kN 0)/(nmk0N + kN 0) ≈ k0/k0N . Thus, our primary goal will be to com- pare these elemental rates. To do so, we take a Kramer's approximation for dynamics between α and β, i.e. kαβ = k exp[−(F ‡ αβ − Fα)/T ] (5) C ‡ ij = Cα ij Cβ ij (6) (here, we take advantage of the fact that contacts are either valued at 0 or 1, so multiplication works like a binary AND operator). Physically, this models the tran- sition between α and β as breaking the contacts in α not present in β and then forming the contacts present in β that were not originally present in α. We note in pass- ing that this approach is potentially broadly applicable to a range of problems, whose state information can be encapsulated into a binary vector analogous to Cα ij . Eq (6) is an advance over previous work in two ways. First, we consider directly the microscopic transitions be- tween states, i.e. not considering these transitions in terms of all going through a single barrier, but many different pair-wise barriers. Second, we look directly to structural properties of the state to determine the na- ture of the transition state structure. However, we stress that eq (6) is most appropriate for transitions between collapsed (or mostly collapsed) states. To calculate the free energy as a function of a given state, we must include the energy (from the Hamiltonian above) as well as a model for the polymeric entropy. We follow the model described in [12] and say that for a chain of N persistence lengths, the number of contacts present (qα,α) in the structure α lead to qα,α loops, each of length ℓ ∼ N/qα,α; these loops each contribute an entropy of /kB = −σ+(3/2) ln qα,α, where σ ≡ s−(3/2) ln N ∆Sloop and s is a positive quantity related to the flexibility of the chain and kB is Boltzmann's constant; note that the value of ∆Sloop (eg as seen in lattice model calculations [2]) is dominated by the σ term. α α This leads to the transition state energy E‡ αβ = ǫN X ij ij Cβ Cα ij CN ij + ǫN N X ij ijCβ Cα ij (1 − CN ij ) = ǫxqα,β,N + ǫN N qα,β (7) where qα,β,N ≡ Pij Cα ij is the three-conformation overlap between α, β, and the native state. Combining terms above (and including the entropy), we get ij CN ij Cβ F ‡ αβ − Fα = ǫx(qα,β,N − qα,N ) + fN N (qα,β − qα,α) + −(3/2)kBT (qα,β ln qα,β − qα,α ln qα,α) (8) where we have defined the effective free energy of contact formation fN N = ǫN N + kBT σ. With this barrier height now directly connected to properties of the Hamiltonian, we are now ready to examine specific models for folding. Exploring the model.- To examine the model, we con- sider some limiting cases below. First, we wish to con- sider a model for protein-like sequences, i.e. those which resulted from evolution (or alternatively protein sequence design). In order to obtain reasonable estimates for the key transition rates in our model, i.e. k0 = kαβ vs k0N = kαN (where α and β are representative non- folded structures and N is the native state), we look to equations (3), (5), and (8). First, we consider the case ǫN < ǫN N < 0, i.e. both native and non-native contacts are energetically preferred, but native more so. The intrastate conversion rate will be the fastest rate, since the states are very similar (i.e. qα,β ≈ qα,α and qα,β,N ≈ qα,N ), which leads to a very low barrier height from eq (8). In order to compare k0N to k0, consider that both ǫN and ǫN N are negative, but the drive to form native contacts is stronger; thus, the barrier height determined in eq (8) will be lower for transitions to N . More specifically, it is instructive to compare the bar- rier transitions from α to some other non-folded struc- ture β vs folding from α to N . The difference in bar- rier heights ∆∆F ‡ ≡ (F ‡ αN − Fα) = ∆∆E‡ − T ∆∆S‡ = −kBT ln(kαβ /kαN ) is given by the combination of an energetic αβ − Fα) − (F ‡ ∆∆E‡ = −ǫx(qα,N − qα,β,N ) − ǫN N (qα,N − qα,β) (9) and entropic ∆∆S‡ = (S‡ αβ − Sα) − (S‡ αN − Sα) − T ∆∆S‡ = −kBT σ(qα,N − qα,β) + (10) (3/2)kBT (qα,N ln qα,N − qα,β ln qα,β) contributions. 3 three-body overlaps are much more rare than two-body overlaps in the unfolded state, then qα,N > qα,β,N . Fi- nally, due to the nature of our Hamiltonian, it would be rare for two structures at random to have more con- tacts in common with each other than with the native state; thus, we can make the approximation that at least qα,N ≈ qα,β, or more likely qα,N ≥ qα,β. Thus, putting this all together, we find that, for this regime, ∆∆F ‡ is positive, which yields k0N > k0. As the strength of non-native interactions gets more attractive (i.e. ǫN N more negative) and the difference between native and non-native strength grows (i.e. ǫN and ǫN N negative and ǫx < 0), the more that k0N is greater than k0, emphasiz- ing this effect. Moreover, since the different collapsed globules have roughly the same number of total contacts, the rates for unfolded state globule folding to the native state are largely uniform (justifying our model as constructed in Eq (4)), yielding single exponential kinetics even though there are many parallel pathways. Due to the exponential nature of the relationship be- tween rates and free energies, this leads to the relation- ship k0N > k0. What are the implications of this? In this limit, we would find that folding to the native state is fast, compared to dynamics from one non-folded state to another. This makes the folded state a kinetic hub, i.e. transitions between states are typically mediated through the native state. Moreover, generalizations of this model with a higher level hierarchy show (as could be seen from numerical solutions of this model) that the native state is a kinetic hub, i.e. transitions between non-native states usually go through the native state. Finally, we use the previous model to examine another regime, where native contacts dominate, i.e. ǫN is neg- ative but fN N is positive. In this case, native contacts are strongly preferred and non-native contacts are dis- couraged (eg with excluded volume repulsion and no at- traction due to interactions, as is common in computer simulations of G¯o models [3]). Specifically, as we see di- rectly from eq (9), when fN N is sufficiently positive, we obtain a negative value for ∆∆F ‡. Thus, this would lead to the model parameters of the form k0 ≫ k0N . Physically, interconversion between non-native states is fast, since they are not separated by barriers (their transition state energies have no contributions from the free energy of breaking non-native contacts). This regime leads to a very different picture (akin to the "smooth energy landscape" picture previously described [3]), in which the unfolded state interconverts quickly in general, waiting for the rare chance to fold. Consider the regime where both ǫx and fN N are neg- ative quantities. Note that fN N represents the effective free energetic drive to form contacts in general and is negative when there is a sufficient general attraction that beats out the loss of entropy of forming contacts. Since Discussion and Conclusions.- While previous theoret- ical approaches [8, 9] have made seminal contributions to the theoretical framework for understanding folding, these models did not model the transition state struc- turally, which has particularly important implications for a) b) 3 5 6 1 4 6 4 2 N 5 3 2 1 N FIG. 1: Two different kinetic regimes result from our theory, as demonstrated in a simple numerical example with n = 3 blocks and m = 2 states per block, plus the native state (7 states total); see eq. (4) for details of the rate matrix struc- ture. The theory presented here is used to calculate the mean first passage time (MFPT) between states; edges are shown as solid lines if the MFPT is fast (< 30/k), with the MFPT of an edge listed to one signficant digit. In both examples, we set kN 0 = k0N exp(−8/0.6) and k1 = 1k. a) For estimates based on the MJ matrix regime (k0N = 0.05k, k0 = 0.001k), we see that the native state (N) is a kinetic hub. b) For a G¯o model regime (k0N = 0.005k, k0 = 0.5k) we see that there is fast interconversion between unfolded states (1-6), with slow interconversion to the native state (shown by dotted lines). the impact of non-native interactions. As we have seen above, the inclusion of non-native interactions critically changes the qualitative behavior of the model; indeed, this regime has been shown to be particularly relevant in recent all-atom protein folding simulation. Moreover, we can derive estimates for our parame- ters from previous studies of proteins. For example, the Miyazawa and Jernigan [13] matrix's mean (B ≈ c )1/2 ≈ 1.5kBT ), −3.2kBT ) and a standard deviation ((B2 respectively. These results, consistent with other such estimates (such as amino acid solvation free energies [13]), combined with estimates that kTd ≈ 0.8kBT and kBT s ≈ 1.5kBT [2] indicate that fN N < 0; our the- ory therefore predicts that proteins would fold with the native state as a kinetic hub (i.e. fast folding to the na- tive state, compared to equilibration between unfolded states) [7], depicted in Fig. 1. These averages are formally weighted by the amino acid composition [2] of the protein sequence and a uniform composition is used above. We also note in passing that while an overall collapsed model is handled by our theory, the limiting case of min- imal (or repulsive) non-native interactions is not, since that regime would not lead to collapsed configurations and thus eq (6) would not be valid; however, this regime is already well understood: the preponderance of con- tacts are native in this case, and thus folding proceeds by the formation of these contacts, as seen previously [2]. With this new formalism, we are able to recover and potentially explain the behavior seen in all-atom simu- lations [5, 7]. Specifically, we get the primary result 4 that the dynamics of interconversion from one non-folded state to another can be very slow. This also leads to a secondary result that native state is a kinetic hub when there is some non-native attraction. This suggests that simple, previous choices for a single dimensional reaction coordinate (such as using the number of native contacts) can lead to a misconception in terms of the fundamen- tal dynamics of proteins, since these approaches assume that the unfolded state is rapidly interconverting. This is correct for some G¯o models of protein folding, but not for models which include non-native attraction. Finally, we stress that the property of the unfolded state predicted from this theory does not apply to the chemically denatured state, in which most experiments probing the "unfolded state" of proteins have been per- formed; our theory predicts that experiments directly ex- amining the true unfolded state will see a much slower relaxation time compared to the denatured state. To conclude, one of the motivations of this work was to develop a model which was simple enough that it could be solved analytically, but with the key essence of pro- tein folding seen in detailed simulations. The qualitative change which derives from the simple addition of the role of non-native contacts shows how this model can easily be used to probe folding dynamics. By combining de- tailed simulations with analytic approaches, insight in a single system studied by simulation could be extended to a broad range of proteins and protein folding phenomena. Acknowledgements.- We thank S. Bacallado, K. Beauchamp, G. Bowman, J. Chodera, J. England, A. Grosberg, P. Kasson, M. Levitt, L. Maibaum, and V. Voelz for discussions and NSF (EF-0623664) and NIH (R01-GM062868) for funding. [1] K.A. Dill, S.B. Ozkan, M.S. Shell, T.R. Weikl. Annu. Rev. Biophys. 37, 289-316 (2008). [2] V. S. Pande, A. Y. Grosberg, and T. Tanaka. Rev. Mod. Phys. 72, 259-286 (2000). [3] J. Onuchic, Z. Luthey-Schulten, P. G. Wolynes. Ann. Rev. of Phys. Chem. 8, 545-600 (1997). [4] F No´e, S Fischer. Transition networks for modeling the kinetics of conformational change in Curr. Opin. In Struct. Bio., 18, 154-62 (2008). [5] V. A. Voelz, G. R. Bowman, K. Beauchamp, and V. S. Pande. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 132, 1526-1528 (2010). [6] G. R. Bowman, K. A. Beauchamp, G. Boxer, and V. S. Pande. J. Chem. Phys., 131, 124101 (2009). [7] G. R. Bowman and V. S. Pande. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., USA, submitted (2010). [8] J. Wang, J.G. Saven, P.G. Wolynes. J. Chem. Phys., 105, 11276 (1996). [9] E.I. Shakhnovich, A.M. Gutin. Europhys. Lett., 9, 569- 574 (1989). [10] G. J. M. Koper and H. J. Hilhorst. Europhys. Lett. 3, 1213-1217 (1987). [11] C. De Dominicis, H. Orland and F. Laine. J. Physique [13] S Miyazawa, and RL Jernigan. J. Mol. Bio., 256, 623-44 Lett. 46, 463-466 (1985). (1996). [12] V. S. Pande, A. Grosberg, and T. Tanaka. Fold. Des., 2, 109-14 (1997). 5
1906.07605	1	1906	2019-06-18T14:24:57	Hypothesis of collective state in biomolecules and discussion on the possibility of its experimental verification	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	The analogy between the phenomenon of live and collective states in Condensed Matter was supposed by several well-known physicists. The possibility of experimental verification of this hypothesis is discussed.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Hypothesis of collective state in biomolecules and discussion on the possibility of its experimental verification Anatoly M. Smolovich Kotel'nikov Institute of Radio Engineering and Electronics (IRE) of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia e-mail: [email protected] Abstract: The analogy between the phenomenon of live and collective states in Condensed Matter was supposed by several well-known physicists. The possibility of experimental verification of this hypothesis is discussed. In the Forward to the first edition of his monograph Superfluids [1] F. London supposed the possibility of some quantum behavior akin to superfluidity that might play a role in biological processes. He said that certain actions between macromolecules in biochemistry could be understood unless they could be conceived by some quantum mechanism involving the system as whole. It is conceivable that in some biological processes the concept of fluid state of entropy zero could play a decisive role, for it combines the characteristic stability of quantum states with the possibility of motion (i.e. of matter transfer and change of shape) without necessarily implying dissipation processes. In [2] W.A. Little paid attention on this remark of Fritz London and noted that if this should be the case, an entirely new and important consideration would be added to the problem of understanding living systems. Then, W.A. Little suggested that superconductivity near room temperature might be achieved in an organic polymer, which was loosely related to the structure of DNA. In [3] H. Frohlich conjectured that some collective quantum effects can take place in living systems. My hypothesis is that some special type of macroscopic quantum phenomena (also called collective states) is the basic property the life phenomenon itself. The question is how to verify this hypothesis in experiment. This is the subject of a following discussion. the Fermi energy. The superconducting energy gap gives stability I suppose that here the presence of energy gap can be used as an indicator of some collective state presence. For superconductors the energy gap is a region of suppressed density of states around to superconductivity because it can be considered as a portion of energy that should be applied to destroy superconductivity. The size of the energy gap indicates the energy gain for two electrons upon formation of a Cooper pair. BCS theory predicts that the size Δ of the superconducting energy gap for conventional superconductors Δ(T=0) = 1.76 kBTc, where Tc is the temperature superconducting transition and kB is Boltzmann constant [4]. The energy gap width of high temperature superconductors [5] and charge density wave (CWD) [6] differs but also have an order about kBTa, where Ta is the temperature of superconducting or Peierls transition, respectively. My hypothesis is that the life phenomenon is also characterized by presence of some correspondence energy gap. We don't know is it true or not but we can try to search for this energy gap in an experimental investigation. I suppose that the width of this energy gap has an order of kBTV, where TV is some temperature typical for living organisms, for example 300K. This gives the estimation for energy gap about 0.026 eV. Some simple organisms should be chosen for this research. Indeed, even simple living organisms like unicellulate, prokaryotes or viruses are significantly more complicated than the majority of physical research subjects. All organisms contain DNA or RNA, which store the biological information. The simplest organisms are viruses, which consist of nucleic acid (DNA or RNA) surrounded by a protective coat of protein called a capsid. However, opinions differ on whether viruses are a form of life or organic structures that interact with living organisms. They have been described as "organisms at the edge of life." In [7] viruses are considered to act an important part in the evaluation process. The viruses don't demonstrate the life characters as metabolism, replications, etc. when they are out of the host-cell. This allows us to use the phage's state inside and outside the host-cell as markers of alive (V, vita) and dead (M, mort) states [8]. Besides, viruses can be simply inactivated, for example by UV illumination or by heating. The inactivated virus doesn't demonstrate the life characters inside the host-cell. We don't know exactly where the border between V and M virus states is situated. We can't a priory exclude that this border is located between the normal and inactivated states of virus. The electronic energy levels of these states should be compared. The electronic density of states (DOS) of the viruses inside and outside of the host-cell should be measured. Now, let's discuss what experimental methods can be used for identification of the energy gap. Tunnelling spectroscopy is the appropriate technique for measuring the DOS including identification of the superconducting and CDW energy gaps [9, 10]. Scanning tunnelling spectroscopy (STS) is very useful for various molecular objects and nanoparticles deposited on substrates. Also, there were attempts of single DNA molecules STS investigation across the helices [11-16]. However, its clear interpretation was inhibited by technical hurdles including a great data spread. There is another problem. As I have mentioned, it is desirable to compare the results of spectroscopic measurements of the phages outside and inside of the host- cells. However, the possibility of STS investigation of phages inside the host-cell casts doubt. The other method I would like to mention is the traditional optical spectroscopy in different wavelength region of the electromagnetic radiation spectrum. The first spectroscopic measurement of the superconducting energy gap was made with microwaves [17] and far infrared techniques [18]. This spectroscopy also was used for investigations of biomolecules [19-22]. Note, that interpretation of the biomolecules optical spectrum is very difficult task due to the complicated structure of these molecules. The additional problem is that the size of light spot significantly exceeds the thickness of DNA molecule. This leads to necessity of desired signal measuring against the strong background noise. I see the way for overcoming these difficulties in using of both STS and optical spectroscopy methods for the same DNA molecules. Comparison of the results obtained by these methods should help in their interpretation. The other point is comparison of the spectroscopy results for V and M virus states. The zone of spectra where some difference between V and M virus states will be found should be the subject of farther detailed investigations. For decision of research methodology let's pay attention on publications [23-25] where the virus UV inactivation was investigated. The bacteriophages Lambda (λ) and phi X 174 (ΦX174) were used in the experiments. The virus inactivation after UV irradiation was checked by phages seeding on the corresponding strains of Escherichia coli (host-cell). Now, I would like to propose the following research methodology. Both phages and corresponding host-cells should be investigated to find the difference in the DOS between V and M states of phages. The border between V and M states of phages can be situated between the normal and inactivated phages or between the normal phage inside and outside the host-cell. We should check both options. Firstly, the spectroscopy of host-cells should be performed before their infecting by phages. The spectroscopy of phages in normal state should be performed both outside and inside the host-cell. The spectroscopy of phages outside the host-cell should be done by two different methods: STS and optical spectroscopy. In [26] the discrimination of bacteria and bacteriophages by Raman spectroscopy and surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy was demonstrated. In [27] detection and discrimination of viruses was fulfilled by the use of Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. Also see the subsequent publications [28-33]. The spectroscopy of phages inside the host-cell should be done only by optical spectroscopy. The same measurement of the UV inactivated phages should be done. The DOS in V and M states of the phages should differ even in case if the hypothesis of energy gap existence is wrong. The difference between the DOS of V and M phages states can be found by comparison of the measured data. The specific energy gap of living state can be possibly identified by this way. In summary, the possibility of experimental verification of hypothesis of some macroscopic quantum state in living organisms was discussed. I thank A.A. Sinchenko and S.V. Chekalin for useful consulting and discussions. REFERENCES 1. London F. Superfluids, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1950, Vol. 1. 2. Little, W. A. Possibility of synthesizing an organic superconductor. Physical Review 134.6A (1964): A1416. 3. Fröhlich H. Long‐range coherence and energy storage in biological systems. International Journal of Quantum Chemistry 2.5 (1968): 641-649. 4. Schmidt V. V. The physics of superconductors: Introduction to fundamentals and applications. -- Springer Science & Business Media, 2013, Section 6. 5. Timusk T., & Statt B. (1999). The pseudogap in high-temperature superconductors: an experimental survey. Reports on Progress in Physics, 62(1), 61. 6. Monceau P. (2012). Electronic crystals: an experimental overview. Advances in Physics, 61(4), 325-581. 7. Koonin E. V., Wolf Y. I., & Katsnelson M. I. (2017). Inevitability of the emergence and persistence of genetic parasites caused by evolutionary instability of parasite-free states. Biology direct, 12(1), 31. 8. Ivanitskii, G. R. (2010). 21st century: what is life from the perspective of physics?. Physics-Uspekhi, 53(4), 327. 9. Giaever I. (1960). Energy gap in superconductors measured by electron tunneling. Physical Review Letters, 5(4), 147. 10. Latyshev Y. I. (2008). Interlayer tunneling in stacked junctions of high temperature superconductors, CDW materials and graphite. In Electron Transport in Nanosystems (pp. 155-177). Springer, Dordrecht. 11. Iijima, M., Kato, T., Nakanishi, S., Watanabe, H., Kimura, K., Suzuki, K., & Maruyama, Y. (2005). STM/STS study of electron density of states at the bases sites in the DNA alternating copolymers. Chemistry letters, 34(8), 1084-1085. 12. Lindsay, S. M., Li, Y., Pan, J., Thundat, T., Nagahara, L. A., Oden, P., ... & White, J. W. (1991). Studies of the electrical properties of large molecular adsorbates. Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B: Microelectronics and Nanometer Structures Processing, Measurement, and Phenomena, 9(2), 1096-1101. 13. Xu, M. S., Tsukamoto, S., Ishida, S., Kitamura, M., Arakawa, Y., Endres, R. G., & Shimoda, M. (2005). Conductance of single thiolated poly (GC)-poly (GC) DNA molecules. Applied Physics Letters, 87(8), 083902. 14. Shapir E., Cohen H., Calzolari A., Cavazzoni C., Ryndyk D. A., Cuniberti G., ... & Porath D. (2008). Electronic structure of single DNA molecules resolved by transverse scanning tunnelling spectroscopy. Nature Materials, 7(1), 68. 15. Ryndyk D. A., Shapir E., Porath D., Calzolari A., Di Felice R., & Cuniberti G. (2009). Scanning tunneling spectroscopy of single DNA molecules. Acs Nano, 3(7), 1651-1656. 16. Shapir E., Sagiv L., Molotsky T., Kotlyar A. B., Felice R. D., & Porath D. (2010). Electronic structure of g4-DNA by scanning tunneling spectroscopy. The Journal of Physical Chemistry C, 114(50), 22079-22084. 17. Biondi M. A., Garfunkel M. P., & McCoubrey A. O. (1957). Microwave measurements of the energy gap in superconducting aluminum. Physical Review, 108(2), 495. 18. Glover R.E. and Tinkham M., Conductivity of Superconducting Films for Photon Energies between 0.3 and 40kTC. Phys. Rev. 108, 243 (1957). Phys. Rev., 108, 243. 19. Letokhov V.S. Section 1 in Laser picosecond spectroscopy and photochemistry of biomolecules: Edited by V.S. Letokhov, Adam Hilger, Bristol, 1987. 20. Telser J., Cruickshank K. A., Morrison L. E., Netzel T. L., & Chan C. K. (1989). DNA duplexes covalently labeled at two sites: synthesis and characterization by steady-state and time-resolved optical spectroscopies. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 111(18), 7226-7232. 21. Elhadj S., Singh G., & Saraf R. F. (2004). Optical properties of an immobilized DNA monolayer from 255 to 700 nm. Langmuir, 20(13), 5539-5543. 22. Downes, A., Mouras, R., & Elfick, A. (2010). Optical spectroscopy for noninvasive monitoring of stem cell differentiation. BioMed Research International, 2010. 23. Gurzadyan G. G., Nikogosyan D. N., Kryukov P. G., Letokhov V. S., Balmukhanov T. S., Belogurov A. A., & Zavilgelskij G. B. (1981). Mechanism of high power picosecond laser UV inactivation of viruses and bacterial plasmids. Photochemistry and photobiology, 33(6), 835-838. 24. Nikogosyan D. N., Oraevsky A.A. and Zavilgelsky G.B. (1986) Picosecond laser UV inactivation of bacteriophage λ and various Escherichia coli strains. Photobiochem. Phofobiophys. 10, 189-198. 25. Nikogosyan D. N. and Zavilgelsky G.B. Section 8 in Laser picosecond spectroscopy and photochemistry of biomolecules: Edited by V.S. Letokhov, Adam Hilger, Bristol, 1987. 26. Goeller, L. J., & Riley, M. R. (2007). Discrimination of bacteria and bacteriophages by Raman spectroscopy and surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy. Applied spectroscopy, 61(7), 679-685. 27. Vargas, C. A., Wilhelm, A. A., Williams, J., Lucas, P., Reynolds, K. A., & Riley, M. R. (2009). Integrated capture and spectroscopic detection of viruses. Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 75(20), 6431-6440. 28. Hamasha, K., Mohaidat, Q. I., Putnam, R. A., Woodman, R. C., Palchaudhuri, S., & Rehse, S. J. (2013). Sensitive and specific discrimination of pathogenic and nonpathogenic Escherichia coli using Raman spectroscopy -- a comparison of two multivariate analysis techniques. Biomedical optics express, 4(4), 481-489. 29. Vishnupriya, S., Chaudhari, K., Jagannathan, R., & Pradeep, T. (2013). Single‐Cell Investigations of Silver Nanoparticle -- Bacteria Interactions. Particle & Particle Systems Characterization, 30(12), 1056-1062. 30. Chen, J., Zhang, Y., & Kohler, B. (2014). Excited states in DNA strands investigated by ultrafast laser spectroscopy. In Photoinduced phenomena in nucleic acids II (pp. 39-87). Springer, Cham. 31. Tayyarcan, E. K., Soykut, E. A., & Boyaci, I. H. (2018). A Raman-spectroscopy-based approach for detection and discrimination of Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus bulgaricus phages at low titer in raw milk. Folia microbiologica, 63(5), 627-636. 32. de La Harpe, K., Kohl, F. R., Zhang, Y., & Kohler, B. (2018). Excited-State Dynamics of a DNA Duplex in a Deep Eutectic Solvent Probed by Femtosecond Time-Resolved IR Spectroscopy. The Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 122(9), 2437-2444. 33. Li, R., Dhankhar, D., Chen, J., Krishnamoorthi, A., Cesario, T. C., & Rentzepis, P. M. (2019). Identification of Live and Dead Bacteria: A Raman Spectroscopic Study. IEEE Access, 7, 23549-23559.
1506.08051	1	1506	2015-06-26T13:12:33	Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.SC" ]	Cells moving on a two dimensional substrate generate motion by polymerizing actin filament networks inside a flat membrane protrusion. New filaments are generated by branching off existing ones, giving rise to branched network structures. We investigate the force-extension relation of branched filaments, grafted on an elastic structure at one end and pushing with the free ends against the leading edge cell membrane. Single filaments are modeled as worm-like chains, whose thermal bending fluctuations are restricted by the leading edge cell membrane, resulting in an effective force. Branching can increase the stiffness considerably; however the effect depends on branch point position and filament orientation, being most pronounced for intermediate tilt angles and intermediate branch point positions. We describe filament networks without cross-linkers to focus on the effect of branching. We use randomly positioned branch points, as generated in the process of treadmilling, and orientation distributions as measured in lamellipodia. These networks reproduce both the weak and strong force response of lamellipodia as measured in force-velocity experiments. We compare properties of branched and unbranched networks. The ratio of the network average of the force per branched filament to the average force per unbranched filament depends on the orientation distribution of the filaments. The ratio exhibits compression dependence and may go up to about 4.5 in networks with a narrow orientation distribution. With orientation distributions measured in lamellipodia, it is about two and essentially independent from network compression, graft elasticity and filament persistence length.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments Mohammadhosein Razbin1, Martin Falcke2, Panayotis Benetatos3 and Annette Zippelius1 1 Max Planck Institute for Dynamics & Selforganization, Am Fassberg 17 and Institute for Theoretical Physics, Georg August University, Friedrich-Hund-Platz 1, 37077 Gottingen, Germany; 2Max Delbruck Center for Molecular Medicine, Robert Rossle Str. 10, 13092 Berlin, and Dept. of Physics, Humboldt University, Newtonstr. 15, 12489 Berlin, Germany; 3 Department of Physics, Kyungpook National University, 80 Daehakro, Bukgu, Daegu 702-701, Korea E-mail: [email protected] [email protected] Abstract. Cells moving on a 2dimensional substrate generate motion by polymerizing actin filament networks inside a flat membrane protrusion. New filaments are generated by branching off existing ones, giving rise to branched network structures. We investigate the force-extension relation of branched filaments, grafted on an elastic structure at one end and pushing with the free ends against the leading edge cell membrane. Single filaments are modeled as worm-like chains, whose thermal bending fluctuations are restricted by the leading edge cell membrane, resulting in an effective force. Branching can increase the stiffness considerably; however the effect depends on branch point position and filament orientation, being most pronounced for intermediate tilt angles and intermediate branch point positions. We describe filament networks without cross-linkers to focus on the effect of branching. We use randomly positioned branch points, as generated in the process of treadmilling, and orientation distributions as measured in lamellipodia. These networks reproduce both the weak and strong force response of lamellipodia as measured in force-velocity experiments. We compare properties of branched and unbranched networks. The ratio of the network average of the force per branched filament to the average force per unbranched filament depends on the orientation distribution of the filaments. The ratio exhibits compression dependence and may go up to about 4.5 in networks with a narrow orientation distribution. With orientation distributions measured in lamellipodia, it is about 2 and essentially independent from network compression, graft elasticity and filament persistence length. PACS numbers: 00.00, 20.00, 42.10 Keywords: Branched actin networks, lamellipodium, force-extension relation Accepted in Physical Biology Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 2 1. Introduction The crawling of many different cell types is essential for life. Undifferentiated cells move towards the site, where they form a tissue or organ in the developing embryo. Skin cells start crawling when they have to close a wound [1]. During metastasis, cancer cells dissociate from the primary tumor, crawl towards blood vessels and spread all over the body [2, 3]. Branched actin filaments carry forces during cell motion, and consequently understanding their elastic properties is central to understanding the mechanics of cell motility. In vitro, cells are plated on a two dimensional substrate to observe their dynamics. They form a flat membrane protrusion in the direction of motion, the lamellipodium, which is only about 100-200 nm thick but several µm deep and wide [4]. A dense network of actin filaments (F-actin) inside the lamellipodium pushes the leading edge membrane forward [5]. Treadmilling of the filaments drives motion [6]: Filament barbed (or plus) ends polymerize at the leading edge of the lamellipodium and the pointed (or minus) ends depolymerize at the rear. Usually cells move in response to an external signal. A variety of signals stimulate the activation of nucleation promoting factors (NPFs) (like WASp or WAVE) located in the leading edge membrane of the lamellipodium. They activate the actin related protein complex Arp2/3. It binds to an existing filament very close to or at its barbed end at the lamellipodium's leading edge. That initiates the growth of a new filament branch out of the Arp2/3 complex. Many of these branched structures consisting of mother filament and branch form the F-actin network in the lamellipodium. The branched structure itself is dynamic. The branch point with the Arp2/3 complex moves rearward due to treadmilling in the same degree as mother filament and branch grow. Since Arp2/3 binding to the individual filaments is not synchronous we find at any time many different positions of branch points in the lamellipodium F-actin network. The elastic properties of the F-actin network crucially depend on the density of links between filaments [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13]. Molecular links arise in two ways: Cross- links connecting two filaments at some point along their contour length are formed by cross-linker molecules like filamin or α-actinin, and branching attaches the minus end of a filament laterally to a mother filament. Intuition suggests that branching alone could stiffen the network to some degree, since branching is a geometrical constraint on the configuration of two filaments. That intuition has never been quantified before, but is supported by our results presented below. On the other hand, the network region close to the leading edge was found to be as soft as weakly cross-linked actin networks [9, 10, 11, 12, 13], and experiments in actin solutions suggest that branching contributes very little to the elastic modulus of F-actin networks [14]. Here, we would like to present a first step in quantifying the contribution of branching to the elastic and semi-flexible properties of the lamellipodial F-actin network. How much stiffer than single filaments are branched filaments? How are their properties reflected in network behavior? We will answer these questions by investigating a single branched filament and Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 3 networks of branched structures in an approximation neglecting interactions between them in order to focus on branching effects. This neglect of interactions implies that we consider only elastic properties on short time scale and not the visco-elastic properties arising from cross-linking. The mother filament is grafted at one end and has a free tip at the other one in our model system (see Fig. 1). The graft is provided by a highly cross-linked part of the F-actin network. This idea is based on the increasing degree of cross-linking and filament bundling towards the rear of the lamellipodium, which has been observed in many different experiments and simulations [5, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23] (see [24] for a detailed discussion). The graft moves in the direction of cell motion due to cross-linker binding and bundling, and thus contour length 'flows' into the graft. In the steadily moving cell, the balance between polymerization and cross-linking creates a stationary distance between graft and leading edge membrane. At any time, the branched structure is in a configuration similar to Fig. 1, but the branch point moves with treadmilling towards the graft point. Both mother filament and branch polymerize such that their barbed ends stay at the leading edge membrane. Consequently, we will vary the position of the branch point on the mother filament from 0 to its full length L when we investigate the elastic properties. We model the filaments in the weakly bending regime, i.e. bending does not affect the end-to-end distance. We allow for an elastic graft of stiffness Ks and model the membrane by a constraint, enforcing the filaments to be entirely on the left side of the membrane. After the introduction of the model, we will discuss results for a single branched filament. The F-actin network in the lamellipodium comprises filaments with many different tilt angles and branch point positions. Hence, we consider it as an ensemble of branched structures with varying branch point and tilt angle and calculate its properties as the average over this ensemble. The network average of the force will be compared to experimental results from force-velocity measurements and the force of unbranched networks. 2. Results 2.1. The model: semiflexible branched filaments in the weakly bending limit We model the interior of the lamellipodium as a two-dimensional space, since it is approximately flat as described above. Furthermore, the results are easily generalised to three dimensions. We always assume a sufficiently large persistence length, such that the weakly bending approximation applies and the fluctuations perpendicular to the mean orientation of the polymer segment are small and can be treated on a Gaussian level. Our elemental structure is a grafted filament of contour length L. The probability to find its tip at position (x, y) with orientation θ, given that it is grafted at (x0, y0) with orientation ω is denoted by GL(x, y, θ(x0, y0, ω). For the simple case of perpendicular Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 4 Figure 1. Left: Single branched filament grafted on a soft graft and confined in the x-direction by a flat membrane. Thermal bending fluctuations are not shown in this drawing. L1 is the contour length between graft point and branch point, L3 is the contour length between branch point and filament tip. The contour length of the mother filament is L = L1 + L3, Lb is the branch contour length. The branch angle is γ = 70◦ throughout the study, and ω is the tilt angle. The numbers 1, 2 and 3 refer to the filament tip coordinates in Eq. 7. Right: Network of branched filaments with various orientations and locations of branch points. The length δ0 is the distance of the filament tips from the graft plane without bending and fluctuations. The lengths cos(ω) , Lb = L3 cos(ω) L and Lb obey L = δ0 cos(ω−γ) , and δ denotes the distance between the graft point and the leading edge membrane. grafting, ω = 0, at (x0, y0) = (0, 0), GL obeys [25] )]δ(x − L). The general case is obtained by a translation and rotation according to GL(x, y, θ0, 0, 0) ∝ exp[− 3lp L3 (y2 − Lyθ + L2θ2 3 θ → θ − ω y → (y − y0) cos ω − (x − x0) sin ω x → (x − x0) cos ω + (y − y0) sin ω and explicitly given by Eq. 16. (1) (2) In a first step we compute the probability, Pt(xx0), that the endpoint of the tilted polymer is at a distance of x − x0 from the graft point: Pt(xx0) ≡ Z Z dydθ GL(x, y, θx0, 0, ω). (3) We consider an elastic, fluctuating structure into which the filament is grafted and hence model it by a fluctuating spring in x-direction with spring constant Ks = (kBT )K, zero equilibrium length and a distribution of the spring extension proportional to exp(−(Kx2 0)/2). The stiffness of the substrate, K, is assumed to be large as compared to the stiffness for transverse fluctuations, K ≫ K⊥ = 2lp 3L3 , of a filament of contour 3(L cos(ω))3 . The probability Pt(x) to find the length L. In this study we take K = 100 filament tip at x then follows by averaging over all graft point positions x0: 2lp Pt(x) = Z dx0√2πK Pt(xx0) exp(− Kx2 0 2 ). (4) Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 5 The filament exerts a force on an impenetrable flat membrane at a distance δ from the graft plane (see Fig. 1). The force originates from the reduction in the number of filament configurations due to the constraint x − x0 ≤ δ imposed by the membrane; we therefore call it an entropic force. The fraction of configurations satisfying the constraint is given by Zt(δ) = Z dxPt(x)Θ(δ − x). The derivative of Zt with respect to δ is the entropic force [26] ft(L, δ, ω) = kBT ∂ ∂δ ln Zt(δ). (5) (6) These results for a single grafted polymer are easily generalised to the branched structure shown in Fig. 1. The probability to find the two endpoints at x2 and x3 respectively given that the structure is grafted at point x0 is calculated by the following expression: Pb(x2, x3 x0) = Z Z Z dx1dy1dθ1GL1(x1, y1, θ1 x0, 0, ω) ×Z Z dy2dθ2GLb(x2, y2, θ2 x1, y1, θ1 − γ) ×Z Z dy3dθ3GL3(x3, y3, θ3 x1, y1, θ1) (7) The stiffness of the graft is again taken into account by averaging over the positions of the graft: Pb(x2, x3) ∝ Z dx0Pb(x2, x3x0) exp(− Kx2 0 2 ) (8) The explicit expression for Pb(x2, x3) is given by Eq. 22 in the Appendix. The fraction of configurations satisfying the constraint obeys in analogy to Eq. 5 Zb(δ) = Z dx2Z dx3Pb(x2, x3)Θ(δ − x2)Θ(δ − x3), and the entropic force follows from fb(L, Lb, L3, δ, ω) = kBT ∂ ∂δ ln Zb(L, Lb, L3, δ, ω). (9) (10) The force fb depends on the parameters L ≡ (L1 + L3), L3, ω and δ (Lb is fixed by ω, L and L3). We will present our results as dimensionless quantities, and scale lengths by δ0 and force by kBT /δ0 for that purpose. We comment on which specific values of parameters are suggested by experimental observations in the Discussion and the Appendix below. Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 6 Figure 2. Left panel: graft point for the symmetric case ω = 35◦ and L3 = Lb = L versus tilt angle ω for δ = δ0. The curves represent the ratio of lp from top to bottom in both figures. force versus relative distance, δ/δ0, between membrane and force = 10, 5 and 10 3 2 . Right panel: δ0 2.2. Properties of single branched filaments The entropic force exerted by the branched filament on the membrane is shown in the left panel of Fig. 2 for the symmetric case ω ∼ 35◦ and branching at the midpoint of the mother filament. The force decreases with increasing distance δ between grafting plane and membrane. An infinitely stiff filament (lp very large) would just touch the membrane, if δ equals δ0 = L cos ω. But the force exerted by a semiflexible filament is nonzero even for δ > δ0, because the tilted branched structure exhibits fluctuations with the endpoint reaching beyond δ0. In this regime the force is nearly independent of persistence length, whereas for δ < δ0 we observe a strong increase with lp. The force exerted by the filament on the membrane is crucially affected by the tilt angle. It is plotted as a function of tilt angle ω for fixed δ = δ0 in the right panel of Fig. 2. Remarkably, there is a shoulder in all three curves around ω ∼ 35◦, indicating that the symmetric structure generates comparatively large forces. For ω → 0, the force would diverge for a stiff graft, since Eq. 1 excludes longitudinal fluctuations of the filament tip. The high but finite stiffness of the graft limits the force which can be exerted on the membrane. These two opposite effects generate the maximum in the force close to ω = 0. Figure 3 shows the entropic force of a branched structure for the whole range of branch point positions on the mother filament. At the time of Arp2/3 binding to the mother filament (Lb=0), the complete structure has of course the properties of the mother filament. When the branch point has reached the graft plane, the branched structure corresponds to two filaments with the corresponding tilt angles. In between, the force has a maximum at Lb = 0.484L. The maximum force is about 2.25 times the force of two filaments with length L. For the special case under consideration, δ = δ0, the maximum of the force scales like the square root of lp, as shown in the right panel of Fig. 3. For the compressed case, δ < δ0, we observe a crossover to linear scaling. To understand this behaviour of the force, we consider the case of a single filament: The Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 7 force versus relative length of the daughter branch. Below: the Figure 3. Left: configurations of the branched filament corresponding to Lb/L = 0, 0.5, 1.0. The parameter values are: L3 = Lb, ω = 35◦, δ = δ0. From high to low force values the symbols represent the ratio of lp 3 , respectively. Right: log-log plot δ0 of the maximum force as a function of persistence length lp, fitted to a square root = 10, 5 and 10 dependence fmax ∝ plp. force has a thermal (entropic) and a nonthermal (energetic) contribution. The thermal force dominates for δ > δ0. Evaluating the force given in Eq 21 for δ = δ0 and large K, b we explicitly see f ∝ plp. As we compress the filament the energetic force becomes the dominant contribution. It can be computed as the force to bend a grafted cantilever beam resulting in f = ( 3lpkBT . Hence we observe a crossover from the scaling of the force with plp to linear scaling as δ is decreased below δ0 Both, the maximum force, fmax, as well as its branch point position, Lmax 2L3 ) (δ−L cos(ω)) sin2(ω) , depend on the tilt angle ω. The general dependence on ω is shown in the top left panel of Fig. 4 for fmax and in the top right panel for Lmax . Since the dependencies are nonmonotonic, we plot in the bottom panel the configurations which give rise to the maximum force and help to understand the non-monotonic dependence. For very small ω, i.e. almost perpendicular grafting, Lmax is very small and hence also the distance between the branch point and the endpoint of the mother filament, denoted by Lmax . As the tilt angle, ω, increases, the branch point moves further away from the leading edge membrane and hence both, Lmax increase. As ω approaches 70◦, the branch is almost perpendicular to the membrane and the maximum force is obtained for branching at the grafting plane, implying Lmax /L as in the top right panel of Fig. 4, one actually observes a decrease of Lmax /L, because L grows faster than Lmax Lmax as ω → 70◦. is independent of the persistence length, but does depend on δ. For 3 = L. Plotting Lmax and Lmax 3 b 3 b b b b b 3 Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 8 Figure 4. Upper left: Maximum of the force fmax obtained by varying Lb, versus tilt angle ω; we have δ = δ0 for the curves. From high to low force values the curves represent the ratio of lp 3 , respectively. Upper right: Relative branch δ0 length Lmax /L of the maximum force versus tilt angle ω for the same parameters (independent of the persistence length lp). Bottom: Relative partial contour length of the mother filament in between the endpoint and the branch point with maximal force Lmax cos(ω − γ)/ cos ω; also shown are three representative configurations. = 10, 5 and 10 3 = Lmax b b 3 3 δ ≥ δ0 entropic contributions dominate and the force is largest for two independently fluctuating filaments, such that Lmax /L quickly approaches 1 as δ extends beyond δ0. On the other hand, for δ < δ0, elastic contributions are important. In the symmetric case, we find 0.435 ≤ Lmax /L ≤ 0.484 for 0.5 ≤ δ/δ0 ≤ 1.0. The maximum force is observed for ω ∼ 0 and ω ∼ 70◦, because either the mother filament or the daughter filament are perpendicular to the membrane (upper left panel of ) . When the branch is perpendicular, the force is mainly determined by the fluctuations of the branch point, and when the mother filament is perpendicular by the fluctuations of the graft point. Moving away from perpendicular incidence the force has to decrease, giving rise to a minimum for intermediate ω. Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 9 800 600 400 200 > T B k / 0 d b f < 0 0.5 0.7 0.9 d/d 0 1.1 1.3 6 0 36 30 24 18 12 lp /d 0 1500 1000 f k 500 0 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 d/d 0 1 1.1 1.2 1.3 0 6 36 30 24 18 12 /d lp 0 Figure 5. Left panel: Average force per branched structure of the network as a function of δ/δ0 and lp/δ0. Right panel: The force constant kf , which is the derivative of fbδ0/kBT with respect to δ/δ0. R d/d 0 Figure 6. Ratio R of the average force per filament of branched to unbranched networks versus relative distance δ/δ0 between the membrane and the graft point; lp = 10. The squares refer to the random network with a uniform orientation δ0 distribution in the range −70◦ ≤ ω ≤ 70◦ as measured in ref. [27], the circles show results with a narrow uniform distribution of orientations in 30◦ ≤ ω ≤ 40◦, the dots refer to the orientation distribution given by Eq. 13 as measured in ref. [28]. 2.3. Extension to the F-actin network: Properties of an ensemble of branched filaments We would like to obtain an estimate of how branching affects the network properties. With the theoretical means set up above and in the spirit of the study, we calculate the force as an average across an ensemble of branched structures, in which all interactions between the branched filaments are neglected. The ensemble is described by branch point (L3)and orientation (ω) distributions. The branch point is equally likely anywhere on the mother filament, corresponding to 0 ≤ L3 ≤ δ0/ cos ω. The length of the branch obeys Lb = L3 cos ω cos(ω−γ) . As far as the orientation of the mother filaments is concerned, several scenarios have been discussed in the literature. In ref. [27], electron microscopy was used to determine the orientation of filaments in lamellipodial actin networks. The distribution was found to be approximately uniform in the range of angles between 0 < fb(δ) >= Z ωmax ×Z dL3 fb( ωmin δ0 cos ω 0 δ0 cos ω , L3 cos ω cos(ω − γ) , L3, δ, ω). Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 10 and 60◦ with a small contribution between between 60◦ and 75◦. We describe it here as a uniform distribution between -70◦ and 70◦. The force for fixed δ0 averaged over branch point positions and tilt angles is given by dω cos ω δ0∆ω (11) where ∆ω = ωmax − ωmin denotes the range of the distribution. The average force is a monotonic function of both, the persistence length and the distance δ between grafting plane and membrane, as shown in Fig. 5. We can compare our results with measurements of the force-velocity relation of fish keratocyte lamellipodia. The forces exerted by the leading edge of the freely running cell immediately upon collision with the cantilever were below the force resolution of the cantilevers [13, 11, 12], but caused an immediate decrease of leading edge velocity by 1-3 orders of magnitude. Hence, the leading edge is much softer than the softest cantilever used in the experiments, which had a force constant of 9.1 nN/µm. If the leading edge had the same force constant, a single branched structure would need to have a constant of about 11.8 pN/µm with 220 filaments/µm [29] and a contact length of about 7 µm [12]. The value of δ0 in the freely running cell was estimated to be ∼1.3 µm [13], and such a value is also supported by the data in ref. [30]. Hence, if the leading edge had the same force constant as the softest cantilever, the dimensionless 0(kBT)−1=4748 force constant of a single branched structure would be 11.8 pNµm−1δ2 (kBT=4.2 10−3 pNµm). The values in the right panel of Fig. 5 show that the branched filaments are much softer on average, which is in agreement with the dramatic velocity drop of the lamellipodium leading edge upon collision with the cantilever. We do not know measurements of the pressure exerted by the filaments on the leading edge membrane in the freely running fish keratocyte but can estimate it from our results. Assuming δ0=1.3 µm, lp/δ0 ≈ 10, δ/δ0 ≈ 0.8 [13] we obtain f δ0/kBT ≈ 20 and a force per branched structure of 0.063 pN. The pressure exerted by the filaments on the leading edge membrane is in the range of 46 Pa (with 110 branched structures per micrometer and a lamellipodium height of 150 nm as in [12]). The value of δ0 decreases during the force-velocity measurement due to a dynamic equilibrium between polymerization and cross-linking [13]. In the stalled state, δ0 ≈0.27 µm applies (Fig. S3 of [13]). The measured stall pressure exerted on the leading edge by the cantilevers is 300-750 Pa [13] and 110-430 Pa [12]. These pressures correspond to stall forces of 0.045-0.1125 nN [13] and 0.0165-0.0645 nN [12] per micrometer leading edge. The values of f δ0/kBT resulting from these force densities are in the range 10-70. That entails δ/δ0 . 1 (see Fig. 5) in agreement with modelling results in ref. [13]. To assess the effects of branching on network properties, we calculate the ratio R Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 11 of the force exerted by a branched network to the force of an unbranched network with the same angular distribution. We use the same number of filaments in the unbranched network as there are branched structures in the branched network: < fb > dω ft(δ0/ cos ω, δ, ω) . (12) R(δ) = 1 ∆ω R ωmax ωmin The ensemble averages of branched and unbranched networks with the uniform orientation distribution between -70◦ and 70◦ behave very similar under compression (Fig. 6, squares). This ratio has the remarkable property of depending only very weakly on δ. It is almost independent of the persistence length lp and the graft stiffness K as well (data not shown). Hence, the behavior of both networks scales very similar in dependence on these parameters. The ratio is about 2, i.e., the average force per filament tip for a given value of δ is the same for branched and unbranched networks. However, there are obvious qualitative differences between single filaments and branched structures illustrated by the non-trivial dependency of the properties of branched structures on the branch point position in Figs. 3 and 4. if we use a narrow orientation distribution around ω = 35◦ the value of R increases with increasing compression. Therefore, we also investigate non-uniform measured lamellipodial orientation distributions to investigate whether the dependency of R on the distribution affects the behavior of lamellipodial networks. Distributions peaked either at ω = 0 or ω = ±35◦ have been observed in refs. [28, 31, 32]. The distribution in ref. [28], their Fig. 4, is typical for the measured non-uniform distributions and can be approximated by Indeed, P (ω) = 0.008012(cid:20)e −(ω−35)2 2·20.52 + e + 0.0006907, −85◦ ≤ ω ≤ 85◦. −(ω+35)2 2·20.52 (cid:21) (13) The dots in Fig. 6 show the results for R. They are very similar to the results for the uniform distribution. Obviously, the width of 40◦-45◦ of the peaks in lamellipodial orientation distributions is too large for an essential effect of branching on the parameter dependencies. 3. Discussion We investigated the properties of branched filaments grafted into an elastic graft. Their stiffness has a maximum in its dependence on the branch point position. Branched structures with the optimal graft point position can be more than four times as stiff as a single filament with the same tilt angle as the mother filament (Fig. 3), while requiring only 1.5 times the polymer length of the mother filament. The mechanical properties of branched F-actin networks depend on their orientation distribution. With measured lamellipodial distributions, networks of branched structures are about twice as stiff as unbranched networks. The total network force of branched networks scales essentially the same as the one of unbranched networks Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 12 with the parameters F-actin persistence length, graft stiffness and compression (δ). An intuitive explanation would be, that in the end it is the single filament behaviour determining the stiffness for both unbranched and branched filaments, since the branch leans on the (single) mother filament when experiencing a force. Our theory considers individual branched filaments and thus establishes the constitutive relations on which complex network studies including cross-linking can be based. We considered F-actin networks as defined by their geometrical property distributions without interactions of filaments by cross-linking or entanglement. This implies that we cannot account for visco-elastic properties. A variety of evidences suggests the existence of a region close to the leading edge, where cross-linking is not dominating the network properties and to which our theory directly applies. Measurements of the ratio of number of the cross-linkers to the number of actin molecules in fibroblasts show the existence of a gradient for α-actinin and ABP-280/filamin. The number ratios are low in a region juxtaposed to the leading edge with a depth of about 1.5 µm (see Fig. 5 of ref. [15]). Svitkina and Borisy conclude from these results and structural information from electron micrographs that the impact of ABP- 280 and α-actinin on filament cross-linking is likely to be expressed more deeply in the cytoplasm [15]. Their statement is supported by the immediate response of the leading edge of fish keratocytes to small forces indicating also weak cross-linking in the network region close to the leading edge [13, 11, 12]. This suggests that while understanding of the visco-elastic properties of the network in the lamellipodium bulk requires taking cross-linking into account, our ensemble average is applicable to a network region close to the leading edge. The reproduction of both the weak and strong force responses of the lamellipodium leading edge measured in force-velocity relations by our network calculations strongly supports that conclusion (Fig. 5). We did not take contributions from entanglement or excluded volume effects into account when calculating the network forces. This implies that R provides only a meaningful approximation, if these effects are similar in branched and unbranched networks. To the best of our knowledge, that has not been investigated quantitatively yet. We can only provide heuristic considerations in favour of our assumption based on comparing a variety of simulations with and without excluded volume effects with force-velocity measurements. Model networks of semi-flexible filaments not taking into account excluded volume effects reproduce the elastic properties measured in force-velocity experiments quantitatively [13]. Schreiber et al. simulated the force-velocity relation of motile cells with rigid rods as model filaments taking excluded volume effects into account [33]. They found excluded volume effects to be stronger in branched than in unbranched systems. The model network of Schreiber et al. shows a response to external forces in the force- velocity relation at about 8 nN/µm [33]. However, the lamellipodium leading edge exhibits elastic responses to forces smaller than 0.05 nN/µm in experiments [13, 11, 12]. Additionally, bending of filaments has been observed in lamellipodia [27, 34, 35], i.e., filaments do not behave like stiff rods. Hence, the lamellipodium network is likely to be Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 13 in a parameter regime where excluded volume effects are less relevant than suggested by a network of stiff rods. Branching has also been observed with microtubule [36]. The branching angle varies between 0 ◦ and 90 ◦, and it is not known, how rigid the connection to the mother filament is. If the branch is rigidly connected, our results should apply also to these branched structures with the adapted persistence length (a few millimeters [37]) and γ-values. In summary, single branched filaments with intermediate branch point positions and tilt angles exert larger forces and are stiffer than two unbranched filaments. The stiffness of a whole network of branched filaments is largest, if the orientation distribution is sharply peaked around ±γ/2 = ±35◦. For lamellipodial orientation distributions, the stiffness of branched and unbranched networks scales approximately the same with a variety of parameters (Fig. 6), suggesting that the effect of branching on network stiffness can be accounted for by rescaling the filament number of an unbranched network. These results are in agreement with the elastic properties of lamellipodia found in force-velocity measurements with fish keratocytes [13, 11, 12]. 4. APPENDIX 4.1. Tilted filament The Green function of a free semiflexible polymer in two spatial dimensions (see Fig. 1) and in the weakly bending limit satisfies the partial differential equation (PDE) [ ∂ ∂s + θ ∂ ∂y − 1 lp ∂2 ∂θ2 ]G(s, y, θ 0, y0, ω) = 0. The arc length of the filament contour is denoted s here. The boundary condition lim s→0 G(s, ys, θs0, y0, ω) = δ(θ − ω)δ(ys − y0) (14) (15) realizes the graft. The solution is Eq. 1, after a switch from the coordinates (s, y, θ) to (x, y, θ). We obtain the Green function for a tilted filament simply by a rotation: GL(x, y, θx0, y0, ω) ∝ exp[− lp − L × exp[+ × δ[(x − x0) cos(ω) + (y − y0) sin(ω) − L]. 3lp L3 ((y − y0) cos(ω) − (x − x0) sin(ω))2 (θ − ω)2] 3lp L2 ((y − y0) cos(ω) − (x − x0) sin(ω))(θ − ω)] (16) The probability distribution of the position x of the endpoint follows by integration (see Eq. 4) Pt(xx0) ∝ exp(− (x − x0 − L cos(ω))2 σ2 t0 ) (17) Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments where σ2 t0 = 4L3 sin(ω)2 3lp . 14 (18) Representing the stiffness of the graft by a spring and averaging over all grafting points, x0, yields: (19) (20) (21) (22) (23) (24) Pt(x) = 1 Nt exp(− (x − L cos(ω))2 σ2 t ). Here Nu accounts for the proper normalization and t = σ2 σ2 t0 + 2 K . The entropic force on the wall is then explicitly given by: ft(δ) = 2kBT (√πσt) 4.2. Branched filament exp(− (δ−L cos(ω))2 erfc( L cos(ω)−δ σ2 t ) σt ) . Starting from Eq. 7 and averaging over graft point positions x0, we obtain Pb(x2, x3) = ( (det(M)) 1 2 π ) exp(ηiMijηj), where η = (cid:18)x2 − L1 cos(ω) − Lb cos(ω − γ) x3 − (L1 + L3) cos(ω) (cid:19) and M is a 2 × 2-Matrix with components M11 = − lp C [K(L1 + L3)3 sin(ω)2 + 3 2 lp] and M12 = M21 = 3 2 [KL2 1(L1 + L3) sin(ω)2 + lp C 3 KL1Lb(L1 + 2L3) sin(ω) sin(ω − γ)] 2 lp + 3 2 M22 = −lp C 3KL2 b(3L1 + Lb) sin(ω − γ)2 + [KL2 1Lb sin(ω) sin(ω − γ) + KL3 3 2 lp + 1 sin(ω)2], 4 3 C = K sin(ω)2[(L1 + − 2(L2 + L2 3)L2 1L2 L3)L3 3 sin(ω)2 1LbL3 sin(ω) sin(ω − γ)] 1 − 2L2 bK sin(ω)2 sin(ω − γ)2[L4 1LbL3 + 4L1L2 3(Lb + L3)] L3)L2 3 sin(ω)2 − 2L1LbL3 sin(ω) sin(ω − γ) 1Lb + LbL3 3) (L3 1 + 4 3 1 3 + 6lp[(L1 + + 4L2 + (L1 + 1 3 Lb)L2 b sin(ω − γ)2] Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 15 4.3. Parameter values The independent parameters of the model are the F-actin persistence length lp, the equilibrium distance of the filament tips from the graft plane δ0, the stiffness K of the graft, and the branching angle γ which is fixed by the Arp2/3 complex at about 70 ◦ [38, 39, 40]. The branch point position is uniformly distributed and the tilt angle ω according to the above distributions. The tilt angle and δ0 fix the mother filament contour length as L = δ0/ cos(ω). We explained in the Discussion, that a region juxtaposed to the leading edge membrane with a width of 1.0-1.5 µm is similar to an experimental realization of the network configuration in Fig. 1, since it is weakly cross-linked. Values for δ0 suggested by these observations are in the range 1.0-1.5 µm. Branching will have an effect on network properties in a configuration like shown in Fig. 1, if most filaments are branched, i.e., if δ0 is larger than the average branch distance. The average branch distance in steadily moving cells has been a matter of debate in recent years. Svitkina et al. concluded 20-50 nm from early electron micrographs of lamellipodia from Xenopus keratocytes and fibroblasts [15], and 50-200 nm from another study in fibroblasts [41]. Later measurements substantially increased that value. The average branch distance has been determined to be about 800 nm for B16 melanoma cells and fish keratocytes in ref. [35]. Other studies provide number densities of branch points per lamellipodium area for 3T3 fibroblasts. Calculating the average branch distance from that branch point density implies assumptions on the F- actin concentration. The number of filaments per micrometer lamellipodium width in a distance of 0.1-1 µm from the leading edge is 170-190 [29]. Taking into account that filament orientation is approximately uniformly distributed between 0◦ and 60◦ [27], this density means 1.16(170-190) µm filament contour length per µm2 lamellipodium area. The factor 1.16 arises from averaging over all tilt angles of the filaments. Yang and Svitkina measured 277 branch points/µm2 [40] in the same sample, i.e. an average branch point distance in terms of contour length between 700 nm and 800 nm. Small et al. measured less than 225 branch points/µm2 [30], i.e. an average distance of more than 860 nm. The in vivo persistence length is not known. We can only conclude a reasonable range from in vitro measurements. Results from fluctuation analysis and measurements of network elastic properties yield values of the in vitro persistence length of 15- 18 µm [37, 42, 9, 43]. The filaments in these experiments were stabilized with phaloidin which most likely increases the value of lp. Filaments labeled with rhodamine but not stabilized with phaloidin exhibited values of lp between 9 µm and 13.5 µm [43]. The in vivo persistence length might be even shorter, since cofilin can substantially reduce it even down to 2.2 µm [44, 45]. Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 16 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS AZ acknowledges financial support by the DFG through Grant No. SFB 937/A1. MF acknowledges financial support by the DFG through Grant No. FA350/11-1. References [1] D. Bray. Cell Movements. Garland, New York, 2nd edition, 2001. [2] Hidekiand Yamaguchi, Jeffrey Wyckoff, and John Condeelis. Cell migration in tumors. Curr Opin Cell Biol, 17:559 -- 564, Oct 2005. [3] John Condeelis and Jeffrey W. Pollard. Macrophages: Obligate partners for tumor cell migration, invasion, and metastasis. Cell, 124(2):263 -- 266, 2006. [4] J. Victor Small, Theresia Stradal, Emmanuel Vignal, and Klemens Rottner. The lamellipodium: where motility begins. Trends Cell Biol, 12(3):112 -- 120, 2002. [5] T. M. Svitkina, A. B. Verkhovsky, K. M. McQuade, and G. G. Borisy. Analysis of the Actin- Myosin II System in Fish Epidermal Keratocytes: Mechanism of Cell Body Translocation. J Cell Biol, 139:397 -- 415, 1997. [6] TD Pollard. The cytoskeleton, cellular motility and the reductionist agenda. Nature, 422:741 -- 745, 2003. [7] Jingyuan Xu, Denis Wirtz, and Thomas D. Pollard. Dynamic cross-linking by α-actinin determines the mechanical properties of actin filament networks. J Biol Chem, 273(16):9570 -- 9576, 1998. [8] Alex Mogilner and George Oster. Force Generation by Actin Polymerization II: The Elastic Ratchet and Tethered Filaments. Biophys J, 84(3):1591 -- 1605, 2003. [9] M. L. Gardel, J. H. Shin, F. C. MacKintosh, L. Mahadevan, P. Matsudaira, and D. A. Weitz. Elastic behavior of cross-linked and bundled actin networks. Science, 304(5675):1301 -- 1305, 2004. [10] Sophie Bohnet, Revathi Ananthakrishnan, Alex Mogilner, Jean-Jacques Meister, and Alexander B. Verkhovsky. Weak force stalls protrusion at the leading edge of the lamellipodium. Biophys J, 90(5):1810 -- 1820, 2006. [11] Marcus Prass, Ken Jacobson, Alex Mogilner, and Manfred Radmacher. Direct measurement of the lamellipodial protrusive force in a migrating cell. J Cell Biol, 174(6):767 -- 772, 2006. [12] Fabian Heinemann, Holger Doschke, and Manfred Radmacher. Keratocyte lamellipodial protrusion is characterized by a concave force-velocity relation. Biophys J, 100(6):1420 -- 1427, 2011. [13] Juliane Zimmermann, Claudia Brunner, Mihaela Enculescu, Michael Goegler, Allen Ehrlicher, Josef Kas, and Martin Falcke. Actin filament elasticity and retrograde flow shape the force- velocity relation of motile cells. Biophys J, 102(2):287 -- 295, 2012. [14] Fumihiko Nakamura, Eric Osborn, Paul A. Janmey, and Thomas P. Stossel. Comparison of filamin a-induced cross-linking and arp2/3 complex-mediated branching on the mechanics of actin filaments. J Biol Chem, 277(11):9148 -- 9154, 2002. [15] Tatyana M. Svitkina and Gary G. Borisy. Arp2/3 complex and actin depolymerizing factor/cofilin in dendritic organization and treadmilling of actin filament array in lamellipodia. J Cell Biol, 145(5):1009 -- 1026, 1999. [16] A.B. Verkhovsky, T.M. Svitkina, and G.G. Borisy. Self-polarization and directional motility of cytoplasm. Curr Biol, 9(1):11 -- 20, 1999. [17] Pascal Vallotton, Gaudenz Danuser, Sophie Bohnet, Jean-Jacques Meister, and Alexander B. Verkhovsky. Tracking Retrograde Flow in Keratocytes: News from the Front. Mol Biol Cell, 16(3):1223 -- 1231, 2005. [18] Kinneret Keren, Zachary Pincus, Greg M. Allen, Erin L. Barnhart, Gerard Marriott, Alex Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 17 Mogilner, and Julie A. Theriot. Mechanism of shape determination in motile cells. Nature, 453(7194):475 -- 480, 2008. [19] Juliane Zimmermann, Mihaela Enculescu, and Martin Falcke. Leading edge - gel coupling in lamellipodium motion. Phys Rev E, 82(5):051925, Nov 2010. [20] Boris Rubinstein, Maxime F. Fournier, Ken Jacobson, Alexander B. Verkhovsky, and Alex Mogilner. Actin-myosin viscoelastic flow in the keratocyte lamellipod. Biophys J, 97(7):1853 -- 1863, 2009. [21] Mihaela Enculescu, Mohsen Sabouri-Ghomi, Gaudenz Danuser, and Martin Falcke. Modeling of protrusion phenotypes driven by the actin-membrane interaction. Biophys J, 98(8):1571 -- 1581, 2010. [22] Erin L. Barnhart, Kun-Chun Lee, Kinneret Keren, Alex Mogilner, and Julie A. Theriot. An adhesion-dependent switch between mechanisms that determine motile cell shape. PLoS Biol, 9(5):e1001059, 05 2011. [23] Danying Shao, Herbert Levine, and Wouter-Jan Rappel. Coupling actin flow, adhesion, and morphology in a computational cell motility model. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA, 109(18):6851 -- 6856, 2012. [24] M. Falcke and J. Zimmermann. Polymerization, bending, tension: What happens at the leading edge of motile cells? EPJ ST, 223(7):1353 -- 1372, 2014. [25] P. Benetatos and E. Frey. Depinning of semiflexible polymers. Phys. Rev. E, 67:051108, May 2003. [26] Azam Gholami, Jan Wilhelm, and Erwin Frey. Entropic forces generated by grafted semiflexible polymers. Phys Rev E, 74(4):041803, Oct 2006. [27] Stefan A. Koestler, Sonja Auinger, Marlene Vinzenz, Klemens Rottner, and J. Victor Small. Differentially oriented populations of actin filaments generated in lamellipodia collaborate in pushing and pausing at the cell front. Nat Cell Biol, 10(3):306 -- 313, 2008. [28] Ivan V. Maly and Gary G. Borisy. Self-organization of a propulsive actin network as an evolutionary process. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 98(20):11324 -- 11329, 2001. [29] W Urban, S Jacob, M Nemethova, GP Resch, and JV Small. Electron tomography reveals unbranched networks of actin filaments in lamellipodia. Nat Cell Biol, 12:429 -- 435, 2010. [30] J.V. Small, C. Winkler, M. Vinzenz, and C. Schmeiser. Reply: Visualizing branched actin filaments in lamellipodia by electron tomography. Nat Cell Biol, 13(9):1013 -- 1014, 2011. [31] Alexander B. Verkhovsky, Oleg Y. Chaga, Sebastien Schaub, Tatyana M. Svitkina, Jean-Jacques Meister, and Gary G. Borisy. Orientational Order of the Lamellipodial Actin Network as Demonstrated in Living Motile Cells. Mol Biol Cell, 14(11):4667 -- 4675, 2003. [32] Julian Weichsel, Edit Urban, J. Victor Small, and Ulrich S. Schwarz. Reconstructing the orientation distribution of actin filaments in the lamellipodium of migrating keratocytes from electron microscopy tomography data. Cytometry Part A, 81A(6):496 -- 507, 2012. [33] Christian H. Schreiber, Murray Stewart, and Thomas Duke. Simulation of cell motility that reproduces the force-velocity relationship. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA, 107(20):9141 -- 9146, 2010. [34] Dylan T. Burnette, Suliana Manley, Prabuddha Sengupta, Rachid Sougrat, Michael W. Davidson, Bechara Kachar, and Jennifer Lippincott-Schwartz. A role for actin arcs in the leading-edge advance of migrating cells. Nat Cell Biol, 13(4):371 -- 382, 2011. [35] Marlene Vinzenz, Maria Nemethova, Florian Schur, Jan Mueller, Akihiro Narita, Edit Urban, Christoph Winkler, Christian Schmeiser, Stefan A. Koestler, Klemens Rottner, Guenter P. Resch, Yuichiro Maeda, and J. Victor Small. Actin branching in the initiation and maintenance of lamellipodia. J Cell Sci, 125(11):2775 -- 2785, 2012. [36] Sabine Petry, AaronC. Groen, Keisuke Ishihara, TimothyJ. Mitchison, and RonaldD. Vale. Branching microtubule nucleation in xenopus egg extracts mediated by augmin and {TPX2}. Cell, 152(4):768 -- 777, 2013. [37] F Gittes, B Mickey, J Nettleton, and J Howard. Flexural rigidity of microtubules and actin Mechanical properties of branched actin filaments 18 filaments measured from thermal fluctuations in shape. The Journal of Cell Biology, 120(4):923 -- 934, 1993. [38] R. Dyche Mullins, John A. Heuser, and Thomas D. Pollard. The interaction of Arp2/3 complex with actin: Nucleation, high affinity pointed end capping, and formation of branching networks of filaments. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA, 95(11):6181 -- 6186, 1998. [39] Niels Volkmann, Kurt J. Amann, Svetla Stoilova-McPhie, Coumaran Egile, Dirk C. Winter, Larnele Hazelwood, John E. Heuser, Rong Li, Thomas D. Pollard, and Dorit Hanein. Structure of arp2/3 complex in its activated state and in actin filament branch junctions. Science, 293(5539):2456 -- 2459, 2001. [40] Yang C. and Svitkina T. Visualizing branched actin filaments in lamellipodia by electron tomography. Nat Cell Biol, 13(9):1012 -- 1013, 2011. [41] James E. Bear, Tatyana M. Svitkina, Matthias Krause, Dorothy A. Schafer, Joseph J. Loureiro, Geraldine A. Strasser, Ivan V. Maly, Oleg Y. Chaga, John A. Cooper, Gary G. Borisy, and Frank B. Gertler. Antagonism between ena/vasp proteins and actin filament capping regulates fibroblast motility. Cell, 109(4):509 -- 521, 2002. [42] Loıc Le Goff, Oskar Hallatschek, Erwin Frey, and Fran¸cois Amblard. Tracer studies on f-actin fluctuations. Phys Rev Lett, 89(25):258101, Dec 2002. [43] H Isambert, P Venier, AC Maggs, A Fattoum, R Kassab, D Pantaloni, and MF Carlier. Flexibility of actin filaments derived from thermal fluctuations. effect of bound nucleotide, phalloidin, and muscle regulatory proteins. J Biol Chem, 270(19):11437 -- 11444, 1995. [44] Brannon R. McCullough, Laurent Blanchoin, Jean-Louis Martiel, and Enrique M. De La Cruz. Cofilin increases the bending flexibility of actin filaments: Implications for severing and cell mechanics. J Mol Biol, 381(3):550 -- 558, 2008. [45] Jim Pfaendtner, Enrique M. De La Cruz, and Gregory A. Voth. Actin filament remodeling by actin depolymerization factor/cofilin. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA, 107(16):7299 -- 7304, 2010.
1802.05769	3	1802	2019-01-21T20:23:23	The polar clasps of a bank vole PrP(168--176) prion protofibril revisiting	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.BM" ]	On 2018-01-17 two electron crystallography structures (with PDB entries 6AXZ, 6BTK) on a prion protofibril of bank vole PrP(168-176) (a segment in the PrP $\beta$2-$\alpha$2 loop) were released into the PDB Bank. The paper published by [Nat Struct Mol Biol 25(2):131-134 (2018)] reports some polar clasps for these two crystal structures, and "an intersheet hydrogen bond between Tyr169 and the backbone carbonyl of Asn171 on an opposing strand." - this hydrogen bond is not between the neighbouring Chain B and Chain A directly. In addition, by revisiting the polar clasps, we found another two hydrogen bonds ([email protected]@OE1, [email protected]@N) between the strand A of one sheet and the opposing strand B of the mating sheet. For the neighbouring two single $\beta$-sheets AB, the two new hydrogen bonds are completely different from the experimental one (an intersheet hydrogen bond between Tyr169 and the backbone carbonyl of Asn171 on an opposing strand) in [Nat Struct Mol Biol 25(2):131-134 (2018)].	physics.bio-ph	physics	The polar clasps of a bank vole PrP(168 -- 176) prion protofib- ril revisiting Jiapu Zhang Centre of Informatics and Applied Optimisation, The Federation University Australia, Mount Helen Campus, Mount Helen, Ballarat, Victoria 3353, Australia; *Tel: +61-3-5327 6335; Email: [email protected] Abstract: On 2018-01-17 two electron crystallography structures (with PDB entries 6AXZ, 6BTK) on a prion protofibril of bank vole PrP(168-176) (a segment in the PrP β2-α2 loop) were released into the PDB Bank. The paper published by [Nat Struct Mol Biol 25(2):131-134 (2018)] reports some polar clasps for these two crystal structures, and "an intersheet hydrogen bond between Tyr169 and the backbone carbonyl of Asn171 on an opposing strand." - this hydrogen bond is not between the neighbouring Chain B and Chain A directly. In addition, by revisiting the polar clasps, we found another two hydrogen bonds ([email protected]@OE1, [email protected]@N) between the strand A of one sheet and the opposing strand B of the mating sheet. For the neighbouring two single β-sheets AB, the two new hydrogen bonds are completely different from the experimental one (an intersheet hydrogen bond between Tyr169 and the backbone carbonyl of Asn171 on an opposing strand) in [Nat Struct Mol Biol 25(2):131-134 (2018)]. Key words: PrP structured region · Fibril formation peptides · The 'polar clasps' · Mathematical formulas and optimizations · The hydrogen bonds 1 Introduction Prion diseases were caused by the conformational change from normal cellular prion protein PrPC into diseased infectious prion PrPSc. Numerous structures of PrPC are known and have been deposited into the Protein Data Bank (rcsb.org) (PDB). How- ever, the atomic structure of the infectious, protease-resistant, β-sheet-rich and fibrillar mammalian PrPSc remains unknown, being due to the unstable, noncrystalline and in- soluble nature of the fibrils. Only during recent a decade the lab of Eisenberg DS at University of California Los Angeles and other labs are producing the atomic struc- tures of some segments of PrPSc. On 2018-01-17 two electron crystallography structures (with PDB entries 6AXZ, 6BTK) on a prion protofibril of bank vole PrP(168 -- 176) (a segment in the PrP β2-α2 loop) were released into the PDB Bank. The structures belong to the ordinary Class 2 steric zipper with β-strands parallel and sheets pair front to back [1], but they have an outstanding hallmark: within a sheet there are very rich hydrogen bonds (HBs) - even constructing several 'circles' by polar residues Gln, Asn and Tyr of the two neighboring β-strands of a sheet; and between two neighbor- ing β-sheets (if each is with one and only one β-strand) there are two additional HBs (B.Asn171@H -- A.Gln172@OE1, B.Tyr169@OH -- A.Gln172@N) too - besides the one of [2]. The authors named this character as 'polar clasps'. This brief paper is revisiting the 'polar clasps' from the points of view in crystal mathematical formulas and math- ematical optimization. Detailed HBs will be presented and illuminated for the 'polar 1 clasps'. First we introduce the definition of 'polar clasps' in [2]. 'Polar clasp' is a motif whose neighboring polar ladders in the PrPSc are linked by HBs within a strand. Stacks of aromatic residues Phe175 and Tyr169 will shield these clasps at the core of PrPSc. In [3], the author showed us in Year 2016 a table listing all the PrP segments with cross-β structures and each model is with its mathematical formulas and a color photo. Now we insert two elements ((21) -- (22)) of bank vole (Myodes glareolus) PrP(168 -- 176) of Year 2018 into the table and produce a new table, Tab. 1. We organize this paper as follows. Firstly, we present the approaches and tools that will be used in this paper and our major discovery about (molecular modelling) optimization skills will be given in the Methods Section. In the Results and Discussion Section, for models (21) -- (22), the first Subsection will present mathematical formulas accompanied by graphs, then the second Subsection will revisit HBs of the 'polar clasps'. Lastly, the Summary Section gives four concluding remarks. Table 1: The cross-β structures known in the PDB Bank of PrP segments: Class of the cross-β PDB ID PrP segment Species (01) PrP(126 -- 131) (02) (03) (04) PrP(126 -- 132) (05) (06) (07) PrP(127 -- 132) (08) (09) (10) (11) (12) (13) PrP(127 -- 133) (14) (15) (16) PrP(137 -- 142) (17) PrP(137 -- 143) (18) PrP(138 -- 143) (19) (20) PrP(142 -- 166) (21) PrP(168 -- 176) (22) (23) PrP(170 -- 175) (24) (25) PrP(177 -- 182, 211 -- 216) (26) human human-V129 human-L129 human-L129 human human-V129 human human-V129 human human-V129 human human-V129 human human-V129 human-L129 mouse mouse Syrian hamster human sheep bank vole bank vole human elk human human 4TUT 4UBY 4UBZ 4W5L 4W5M 4W5P 4WBU 4WBV 3MD4 3MD5 3NHC 3NHD 4W5Y 4W67 4W71 3NVG 3NVH 3NVE 3NVF 1G04 6AXZ 6BTK 2OL9 3FVA 4E1I 4E1H Class 7[1, 4] Class 8[1, 4] Class 8[1, 4] Class 8[1, 4] Class 8[1, 4] Class 8[1, 4] Class 8[1, 4] Class 8[1, 4] antiparallel (P 21 21 21) parallel (P 1 21 1) Class 8[1] Class 8[1] Class 6[1, 4] Class 6[1, 4] Class 6[1, 4] Class 1[1] Class 1[1] Class 6[1] Class 1[1] β-hairpin[5] Class 2[2, 1] Class 2[2, 1] Class 2[1] Class 1[1] β-prism I fold[6] (P 21 21 21) β-prism I fold[6] (P 21 21 21) 2 2 Methods - The Molecular Modelling Approaches and Tools The molecular modelling approaches used in the paper are the deep analyses for the files from the PDB library, optimization theory and the hybrid of optimization meth- ods. The tools used are JSmol (http://www.jmol.org) - an open-source JavaScript computer software for molecular modelling chemical structures in 3-dimensions, VMD [7] (where the VMD is the most recent version VMD1.9.3Win32cuda downloaded from http://www.ks.uiuc.edu/Research/vmd/) - a molecular visualization program for dis- playing, animating, and analysing large biomolecular systems using 3-D graphics and built-in scripting, and the Swiss-PdbViewer 4.1.0 (https://spdbv.vital-it.ch/) [8, 9] - a free package for comparative protein modelling. Optimization plays important roles in molecular modelling, and molecular simula- tions of molecular dynamics and/or quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics. Large- scale optimization computations have drawn considerable attention. The existing lo- cal/global optimization techniques effectively solve many problems when the number of variables is not very large and, as a rule, fail to solve many large-scale problems. The study of new algorithms which allow one to solve large-scale optimization problem is very important. One technique is to use hybrid of local/global and local/global search algorithms. This paper advocates the use of hybrid algorithmic approaches [10]. It is clearly possible that different optimization strategies would have made different results. In the second subsection of the Results and Discussion section we will use the hybrid of local search optimization methods Steepest Descent (SD) method + Conjugate Gra- dient (CG) method + Steepest Descent (SD) method when using Swiss-PdbViewer 4.1.0. 3 Results and discussion 3.1 Mathematical formulas and graphs In this subsection, we will give the mathematical formulas for the fibrils of bank vole PrP(168 -- 176) with PDB entries 6AXZ and 6BTK respectively, then we will illuminate their respective photos. The mathematical formulas can be gotten after reading the PDB files at websites: https://files.rcsb.org/view/6AXZ.pdb, https://files.rcsb.org/view/6BTK.pdb, where the coordinates of the A Chain were given and we were told clearly "APPLY THE FOLLOWING TO CHAINS: A" to get other Chains. Their photos can be gotten from the websites https://www.rcsb.org/3d-view/6AXZ/1, https://www.rcsb.org/3d- view/6BTK/1 respectively by selecting the viewer JSmol (JavaScript). 3 3.1.1 PDB entry 6AXZ -- bank vole PrP(168 -- 176) Model (21): In Fig. 1 we see that B chain (i.e. β-sheet 2) of 6AXZ.pdb can be obtained from A chain (i.e. β-sheet 1) by B = A +   −2.18510 10.10648 0   , and other chains can be got by , 0 0 4.94 C(D) = A(B) +     E(F ) = A(B) +   2 ∗ 4.94   G(H) = A(B) +     I(J) = A(B) +     3 ∗ 4.94 4 ∗ 4.94 0 0 0 0 0 0 . , , (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) 3.1.2 PDB entry 6BTK -- bank vole PrP(168 -- 176) Model (22): In Fig. 2 we see that B chain (i.e. β-sheet 2) of 6BTK.pdb can be obtained from A chain (i.e. β-sheet 1) by B = A +   −2.04266 9.89843 0   , and other chains can be got by , 0 0 4.874 C(D) = A(B) +     E(F ) = A(B) +   2 ∗ 4.874   G(H) = A(B) +     I(J) = A(B) +     4 ∗ 4.874 3 ∗ 4.874 0 0 0 0 0 0 . , , 4 (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Figure 1: Protein fibril structure of QYNNQNNFV segment 168 -- 176 from bank vole prion (PDB entry 6AXZ). The dashed lines denote the HBs. A, B, ..., I, J denote the 10 chains of the fibril. 3.2 Revisiting the HBs We used the above mathematical formulas and the Figs. 1-2 to get (I) AC-Chains and (II) AB-Chains for 6AXZ.pdb and 6BTK.pdb respectively, and (III) ABCD-Chains for 6AXZ.pdb. We used VMD to visualize the HBs of (I) -- (III) for each pdb but we cannot find HBs yet (where the HB parameters are the default ones of VMD: Donor-Acceptor Distance Cutoff 3.0 A, Angle cutoff 20 degrees). Thus we used Swiss- PdbViewer 4.1.0 (the file SPDBV 4.10 PC.zip downloaded from https://spdbv.vital- it.ch/) to optimize (I) -- (III) (Tab. 2), where we found the hydrogen atoms were added after the optimization by the Swiss-PdbViewer. The Swiss-PdbViewer is the most recent version Swiss-PdbViewer 4.1.0 and we set the Energy Minimization Preferences as follows: 100 Steps of Steepest Descent (SD) method, then 100 Steps of Conjugate Gradient (CG) method, and at last 50 Steps of 5 Figure 2: Protein fibril structure of QYNNQNNFV segment 168 -- 176 from bank vole prion (PDB entry 6BTK). The dashed lines denote the HBs. A, B, ..., I, J denote the 10 chains of the fibril. SD method to slightly optimize the model - i.e. here we used the hybrids of SD-CG- SD optimization methods. The optimization considered the Bonds, Angles, Torsions, Improper, Non-bonded, Electrostatic, and we selected the Cutoff as 12.000 A. The stopping criteria when delta E between two steps is below 0.050 KJ/mol and when Force acting on any atom is below 10.000 are selected. The computations were done in vacuo with the GROMOS96 43B parameters set, without reaction field, and the energy computations were done with the GROMOS96 implementation of Swiss-PdbViewer 4.1.0. After the optimization, we got the HBs network for (I) -- (III) respectively (Tabs. 3-5), where the HB detection threshold parameters are the default ones of Swiss- PdbViewer 4.1.0: when Hydrogens are present, Min cutoff distance 1.200 A, Max cutoff distance 2.760 + 0.050 A, Min Cutoff Angle 120.000 degrees; and when Hydrogens are not present, Min cutoff distance 2.195 A, Max cutoff distance 3.300 + 0.050 A, Min 6 Table 2: The energy decreases during the optimization: PrP segment (21) PrP(168 -- 176) Species bank vole PDB ID Chains Energy (KJ/mol) decreases 6AXZ (22) bank vole 6BTK AC -2250.996 → -2264.804 → -2268.384 ACE -3617.681 → -3635.713 → -3646.515 ABCD -4706.212 → -4715.012 → -4726.107 -1885.567 → -1901.603 → -1904.400 -2268.958 → -2269.830 → -2274.719 -3664.371 → -3674.300 → -3678.038 -1916.021 → -1919.213 → -1922.448 AB AC ACE AB Cutoff Angle 90.000 degrees. (I) AC-Chains. There are 20 HBs for the optimized AC Chains of 6AXZ and 6BTK respectively (Tab. 3 and Fig. 3). Here we found 14 interchain HBs, including the 6 interchain HBs in Fig. 2 of [2] labeled by blue arrows. Table 3: The 20 HBs between the optimized AC Chains or within its each Chain for each pdb model: in C Chain in A Chain Asn174@OD1 -- Gln172@H Asn174@OD1 -- Gln172@H ASN171@OD1 -- Asn173@H Asn171@OD1 -- Asn173@H Asn170@H -- Gln168@OE1 Asn170@H -- Gln168@OE1 between C -- A Chains Val176@H -- Phe175@O Asn174@O -- Phe175@H Asn174@H -- Asn173@O Asn174@H -- Asn174@OD1 Asn173@OD1 -- Asn173@H Gln172@H -- Asn171@O Gln172@OE1 -- Gln172@H Gln172@O -- Asn173@H Asn171@OD1 -- Asn171@H Asn170@O -- Asn171@H Asn170@H -- Asn170@OD1 Asn170@H -- Tyr169@O Gln168@O -- Tyr169@H Gln168@OE1 -- Gln168@H Figure 3: The optimized AC Chains in the fibril structures of QYNNQNNFV segment 168 -- 176 from bank vole prion (left: 6AXZ, right: 6BTK). The dashed lines denote the HBs. The photos were produced by Swiss-PdbViewer 4.1.0. The green coloured A and C denote the A Chain and C Chain respectively. (II) AB-Chains. There are 7 HBs for the optimized AB Chains of 6AXZ and 7 6BTK respectively (Tab. 4 and Fig. 4). Here the single intersheet HB Asn171@H -- Gln172@OE1 is different from the one in Fig. 2 of [2] labeled by a red arrow (a note: if we set the Max distance 3.4 A when Hydrogens are not present, we can find a HB B.Tyr169@OH -- A.Gln172@N with distance 3.44 A (Fig. 5) where the coordinate of B.Tyr169@OH is (-3.491, 1.826, 6.481), the coordinate of A.Gln172@N is (-1.581, - 0.424, 8.254), and B Chain is got from A Chain by mathematical formula (6). We should notice here the AB Chains are not optimized yet). The intrachain three HBs labeled by orange arrows in Fig. 2 of [2] are found here (see Tab. 4 and Fig. 4). Table 4: The 7 HBs between the optimized AB Chains or within its each Chain for each pdb model: between B -- A Chains Asn171@H -- Gln172@OE1 in A Chain in B Chain Asn174@OD1 -- Gln172@H Asn174@OD1 -- Gln172@H Asn173@H -- Asn171@OD1 Asn173@H -- Asn171@OD1 Asn170@H -- Gln168@OE1 Asn170@H -- Gln168@OE1 Figure 4: The optimized AB Chains in the fibril structures of QYNNQNNFV segment 168 -- 176 from bank vole prion (left: 6AXZ, right: 6BTK). The dashed lines denote the HBs. The photos were produced by Swiss-PdbViewer 4.1.0. The green coloured A and B denote the A Chain and B Chain respectively. The AB sheets stack in a parallel face-to-back configuration, the convex face of sheet A nestles against the concave back of its neighboring sheet B, with a high degree of surface complementarity (Fig. 4). Seeing Fig. 6, in AB Chains, the most colored in pink are the polar residues Gln168 -- Asn174, another color of residues are the hydrophobic residues Phe175 and Val176. (III) ABCD-Chains. In ABCD Chains, 28.9% of the atoms are hydrogen. There are a lot of HBs for the optimized ABCD Chains of 6AXZ model (see Fig. 7, and the supplementary Tab. 2 of [2] where B is the C in here and C is the B here), including the Asn171@H -- Gln172@OE1 in Tab. 4 linking B and A Chains, the HBs Asn171@O -- Tyr169@H and Asn174@H -- Asn173@OD1 linking A and D Chains, and Gln172@OE1 -- Asn171@H linking C and D Chains (Tab. 5 and Fig. 7). By Figs. 7-8 and Tab. 5, we can confirm the "intersheet hydrogen bond between Tyr169 (of D Chain) and the backbone carbonyl of Asn171 (of A Chain) on an opposing 8 Figure 5: The HB B.Tyr169@OH -- A.Gln172@N between AB Chains (not optimized yet, directly got by mathematical formula (6)) in the fibril structures of QYNNQNNFV segment 168 -- 176 from bank vole prion (6BTK.pdb). The dashed lines denote the HBs. The photo was produced by Swiss-PdbViewer 4.1.0. Figure 6: The distributions of residues of AB Chains in the fibril structures of QYN- NQNNFV segment 168 -- 176 from bank vole prion (PDB entry 6AXZ). Pink: polar residues Gln168 -- Asn174, gray: hydrophobic residues Phe175 -- Val176. Table 5: The 4 special HBs between the optimized ABCD Chains for the 6AXZ.pdb model: The pair of Chains HBs BA AD CD Asn171@H -- Gln172@OE1 Asn171@O -- Tyr169@H, Asn174@H -- Asn173@OD1 Gln172@OE1 -- Asn171@H strand" of [2], bearing in mind that D = A +   −2.18510 + 4.94 10.10648 0   . (11) 9 Figure 7: The optimized ABCD Chains in the fibril structures of QYNNQNNFV segment 168 -- 176 from bank vole prion (PDB entry 6AXZ). The dashed lines denote the HBs. The photos were produced by Swiss-PdbViewer 4.1.0. Figure 8: The HB A.Asn171@O -- D.Tyr169@H between the optimized AD Chains in the fibril structures of QYNNQNNFV segment 168 -- 176 from bank vole prion (6AXZ.pdb). The dashed lines denote the HB. The photo was offered by Rodriguez JA (University of California Los Angeles). 10 At the end of this subsection, we revisit the HBs of the optimized ACE Chains. We illuminate them in Fig. 9, where there are some 'polar clasps' (as shown in the supplementary Fig. 7 of [2]). Figure 9: The optimized ACE Chains in the fibril structures of QYNNQNNFV segment 168 -- 176 from bank vole prion (left: 6AXZ, right: 6BTK). The dashed lines denote the HBs. The photos were produced by Swiss-PdbViewer 4.1.0. The green coloured A, C, E denote the A Chain, C Chain and E Chain respectively. 4 Summary This short paper revisited the 'polar clasps' and presented detailed HBs of the 'polar clasps'. We found out more HBs for the neighboring two β-strands, for the block of two β-sheets - each sheet being with two β-strands, and the most important, for the neighboring two single β-sheets AB, two new HBs B.Asn171@H -- A.Gln172@OE1, B.Tyr169@OH -- A.Gln172@N were found out, which is completely different from the experimental one (an intersheet HB between Tyr169 and the backbone carbonyl of Asn171 on an opposing strand) in [2]. The structures of some segments of PrPSc have been determined, including the most recent bank vole PrPSc(168 -- 176) one of [2]. In Fig. 16.3 of [11], we have predicted that some segments PrP(126 -- 133), PrP(137 -- 143), PrP(168 -- 176), PrP(170 -- 175), PrP(177 -- 182), PrP(211 -- 216) should have the amyloid fibril forming property. This brief paper also showed us the importance of optimization. Before optimiza- tion, we could not find out any HBs (where the distance and angle cutoffs are the default values of VMD) from the structures calculated by mathematical formulas given according to crystal informatics in the PDB files. However, after optimization, all the HBs were revealed. The correct hybrid skill of optimization algorithms is also worth having a mention here. In the short comments, the author revisited two recently re- vealed Crystal structures of PrP segments with "polar collapse" and found extra HBs in the network after optimization. The manuscript is clear written. Here we discuss more on comparing the structures in the PDB library and those after optimizations. How far away the current structures deposited in the PDB library from the refined structures are listed as follows. For 6AXZ.pdb, its RMSD [12] values are 0.077589, 0.058435, 0.075521, and 0.098501 angstroms for ABCD Chains, AB Chains, AC Chains, and ACE Chains respectively. For 6BTK.pdb, its RMSD values are 0.056441, 0.045499, and 0.075953 angstroms for AB Chains, AC Chains, and ACE Chains respectively. These RMSD values could further highlight the importance/necessity of refinement in the protein structure study. 11 In this paper, we revisited the 'polar clasps' in the structures of PrP and presented detailed HBs of the "polar clasps" after optimization. It is possible that different optimization strategies would have made different results. However, if the local searches in Swiss-PdbViewer 4.1.0 were carried out thoroughly, the optimization results should be the same ones. Acknowledgments This research was supported by a Melbourne Bioinformatics grant numbered FED0001 on its Peak Computing Facility at the University of Melbourne, an initiative of the Victorian Government (Australia). The author thanks Rodriguez JA (University of California Los Angeles) for his helps to understand their paper [2] deeply. The author is also grateful to some comments from reviewers, which have improved this paper greatly. References [1] Sawaya MR, Sambashivan S, Nelson R, Ivanova MI, Sievers SA, Apostol MI, Thompson MJ, Balbirnie M, Wiltzius JJ, McFarlane HT, Madsen A, Riekel C, Eisenberg D (2007) Atomic structures of amyloid cross-β spines reveal varied steric zippers. Nature 447(7143):453 -- 457 [2] Gallagher-Jones M, Glynn C, Boyer DR, Martynowycz MW, Hernandez E, Miao J, Zee CT, Novikova IV, Goldschmidt L, McFarlane HT, Helguera GF, Evans JE, Sawaya MR, Cascio D, Eisenberg DS, Gonen T, Rodriguez JA (2018) Sub-ngstrm cryo-EM structure of a prion protofibril reveals a polar clasp. Nat Struct Mol Biol 25(2):131 -- 134 [3] Zhang JP (2016) Mathematical formulas for prion all cross-β structures listed in the Protein Data Bank. Med Chem 6(3):179 -- 188 [4] Yu L, Lee SJ, Yee VC (2015) Crystal structures of polymorphic prion protein β1 peptides reveal variable steric zipper conformations. Biochemistry 54(23):3640 -- 3648 [5] Kozin SA, Bertho G, Mazur AK, Rabesona H, Girault JP, Haertl T, Takahashi M, Debey P, Hoa GH (2001) Sheep prion protein synthetic peptide spanning helix 1 and beta-strand 2 (residues 142-166) shows beta-hairpin structure in solution. J Biol Chem 276(49):46364 -- 46370 [6] Apostol MI, Perry K, Surewicz WK (2013) Crystal structure of a human prion for oligomer formation. J Am Chem Soc protein fragment reveals a motif 135(28):10202 -- 10205 [7] Humphrey W, Dalke A, Schulten K (1996) VMD: visual molecular dynamics. J Mol Graph 14(1):33 -- 38 12 [8] Guex N, Peitsch MC, Schwede T (2009) Automated comparative protein structure modeling with SWISS-MODEL and Swiss-PdbViewer: a historical perspective. Electrophoresis 30 Suppl 1:S162 -- 173 [9] Guex N, Peitsch MC (1997) SWISS-MODEL and the Swiss-PdbViewer: An envi- ronment for comparative protein modeling. Electrophoresis 18: 2714 -- 2723 [10] Zhang JP (2011) Derivative-free hybrid methods 2010. global opti- in LAMBERT Aca- (Available online and mization applications demic Publishing, Gemany. http://researchonline.federation.edu.au/vital/access/HandleResolver/1959.17/137122) ISBN 978 -- 3 -- 8454 -- 3580 -- 0 in December [11] Zhang JP (2015) Molecular Structures and Structural Dynamics of Prion Proteins and Prions: Mechanism Underlying the Resistance to Prion Diseases. Springer, Dordrecht. ISBN:978 -- 94 -- 017 -- 7317 -- 1 [12] Zhang JP (2018) Molecular Dynamics Analyses of Prion Protein Structures (1st ed. 2018 Edition): The Resistance to Prion Diseases Down Under, Springer, Singapore. ISBN 978 -- 981 -- 10 -- 8814 -- 8 13
1804.09711	2	1804	2018-06-12T16:01:53	Delocalized excitons in natural light harvesting complexes	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "quant-ph" ]	Natural organisms such as photosynthetic bacteria, algae, and plants employ complex molecular machinery to convert solar energy into biochemical fuel. An important common feature shared by most of these photosynthetic organisms is that they capture photons in the form of excitons typically delocalized over a few to tens of pigment molecules embedded in protein environments of light harvesting complexes (LHCs). Delocalized excitons created in such LHCs remain well protected despite being swayed by environmental fluctuations, and are delivered successfully to their destinations over hundred nanometer length scale distances in about hundred picosecond time scales. Decades of experimental and theoretical investigation have produced a large body of information offering insights into major structural, energetic, and dynamical features contributing to LHCs' extraordinary capability to harness photons using delocalized excitons. The objective of this review is (i) to provide a comprehensive account of major theoretical, computational, and spectroscopic advances that have contributed to this body of knowledge, and (ii) to clarify the issues concerning the role of delocalized excitons in achieving efficient energy transport mechanisms. The focus of this review is on three representative systems, Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex of green sulfur bacteria, light harvesting 2 complex of purple bacteria, and phycobiliproteins of cryptophyte algae. Although we offer more in-depth and detailed description of theoretical and computational aspects, major experimental results and their implications are also assessed in the context of achieving excellent light harvesting functionality. Future theoretical and experimental challenges to be addressed in gaining better understanding and utilization of delocalized excitons are also discussed.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Delocalized excitons in natural light harvesting complexes Seogjoo J. Jang Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Queens College, City University of New York, 65-30 Kissena Boulevard, Queens, NY 11367 & PhD programs in Chemistry and Physics, and Initiative for Theoretical Sciences, Graduate Center, City University of New York, 365 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10016 Benedetta Mennucci Department of Chemistry, University of Pisa, via G. Moruzzi 13, 56124 Pisa, Italy (Dated: Accepted for publication in the Reviews of Modern Physics on March 26, 2018; Revised on June 8, 2018) Natural organisms such as photosynthetic bacteria, algae, and plants employ complex molecular machinery to convert solar energy into biochemical fuel. An important com- mon feature shared by most of these photosynthetic organisms is that they capture pho- tons in the form of excitons typically delocalized over a few to tens of pigment molecules embedded in protein environments of light harvesting complexes (LHCs). Delocalized excitons created in such LHCs remain well protected despite being swayed by environ- mental fluctuations, and are delivered successfully to their destinations over hundred nanometer length scale distances in about hundred picosecond time scales. Decades of experimental and theoretical investigation have produced a large body of information offering insights into major structural, energetic, and dynamical features contributing to LHCs' extraordinary capability to harness photons using delocalized excitons. The objective of this review is (i) to provide a comprehensive account of major theoretical, computational, and spectroscopic advances that have contributed to this body of knowl- edge, and (ii) to clarify the issues concerning the role of delocalized excitons in achieving efficient energy transport mechanisms. The focus of this review is on three representa- tive systems, Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex of green sulfur bacteria, light harvesting 2 complex of purple bacteria, and phycobiliproteins of cryptophyte algae. Although we offer more in-depth and detailed description of theoretical and computational aspects, major experimental results and their implications are also assessed in the context of achieving excellent light harvesting functionality. Future theoretical and experimental challenges to be addressed in gaining better understanding and utilization of delocalized excitons are also discussed. I. INTRODUCTION The energy for life on earth begins with harvesting of photons from sunlight. To perform this quantum mechanical process, photosynthetic organisms have de- veloped a wide range of highly tuned forms of light harvesting complexes (LHCs) (van Amerongen et al., 2000; Blankenship, 2014; Cogdell et al., 2006; Hu et al., 2002), while utilizing surprisingly few kinds of pigment molecules (Blankenship, 2014; Croce and van Ameron- gen, 2014) as primary units that absorb photons and create electronic excitations (excitons) (Agranovich and Galanin, 1982; Davydov, 1971). Most LHCs consist of about 10 − 100 pigment molecules held by protein scaf- folds, with typical inter-pigment distances (cid:38) 1nm, and harness excitons that are typically delocalized over a few to tens of such pigment molecules. In general, the light harvesting unit of a specific photosynthetic organism is formed by aggregates or super-complexes of those LHCs. Each LHC exhibits unique structural and energetic fea- tures realized through specific arrangement of pigment molecules with finely tuned excitation energies (Blanken- ship, 2014), which in turn determine the energetics and the dynamics of delocalized excitons. These are believed to embody certain design principles that have been de- veloped through long evolutionary adaptation processes, and ensure optimal light harvesting capability for given living environments and specific light conditions. Figure 1 provides a simple overview of the evolutionary tree of photosynthetic organisms and major LHCs. To what extent do such design principles owe their suc- cess to quantum effects associated with the delocalized nature of excitons? Answering this question might have been the underlying motivation for decades of research on 8 1 0 2 n u J 2 1 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 2 v 1 1 7 9 0 . 4 0 8 1 : v i X r a LHCs. However, only during the past decade, this ques- tion has become much more explicit, attracting numer- ous experimental and theoretical studies. While there have been excellent review articles on various aspects of LHCs (Cheng and Fleming, 2009; Chenu and Scholes, 2015; Cogdell et al., 2006; Curutchet and Mennucci, 2017; Hu et al., 2002; Jang and Cheng, 2013; Jankowiak et al., 2011; Kondo et al., 2017; Konig and Neugebauer, 2012; Lambert et al., 2013; Lee et al., 2016; Levi et al., 2015; Mirkovic et al., 2017; Olaya-Castro et al., 2012; Olaya- Castro and Scholes, 2011; Pach´on and Brumer, 2012; Renger, 2009; Renger et al., 2001; Renger and Muh, 2013; Schroter et al., 2015), a comprehensive review for the general physics community, which encompasses all of the energetic, dynamic, and spectroscopic information, seems currently lacking to the best of our knowledge. Our ob- jective is to offer such a review with particular focus on quantum mechanical aspects of delocalized excitons in LHCs. Excitons created in most LHCs are generally viewed as Frenkel type (Davydov, 1971; Frenkel, 1931), for which the Hamiltonian representing a single exciton can be ex- pressed as He = Ejsj(cid:105)(cid:104)sj + Jjksj(cid:105)(cid:104)sk , (1) (cid:88) (cid:88) k(cid:54)=j j (cid:88) j where sj(cid:105) represents an exciton localized at site j, namely, an individual pigment or chromophore in LHCs, with Ej as the corresponding energy. The term Jjk rep- resents the electronic coupling between site local exciton states sj(cid:105) and sk(cid:105). In general, this is a sum of Coulomb and exchange interactions between the two site excita- tion states. Another commonly accepted assumption of Frenkel-type exciton, although not essential, is that sj(cid:105)'s form an orthogonal basis. This assumption can be jus- tified for most LHCs, where different pigment molecules are separated well enough to have negligible overlap inte- grals between respective electronic excited states. Under these assumptions, the exciton Hamiltonian can be diag- onalized easily as He = Ejϕj(cid:105)(cid:104)ϕj , (2) j where Ej is the eigenvalue and ϕj(cid:105) is the corresponding eigenstate. This is related to the site excitation state through a unitary transformation with matrix element, Ujk = (cid:104)skϕj(cid:105), as follows: ϕj(cid:105) = Ujksk(cid:105) . (cid:88) (3) k (cid:88) 2 (a) (b) FIG. 1 (a) A simple evolutionary tree of photosynthetic or- ganisms (provided by Gregory D. Scholes) (b) Major light harvesting antennas and their spectral regions adapted with permission from (Scholes, 2010). Copyright 2010 American Chemical Society. the magnitudes of Jjk's relative to those of δEjk's, where δEjk = Ej − Ek. However, as in most condensed phase molecular systems, Eq. (1) or (2) alone is severely lim- ited in representing the full quantum nature of excitons in LHCs. Other factors such as molecular vibrations and polarization response of protein environments have to be taken into consideration as well. This requires consider- ation of additional Hamiltonian terms. For Frenkel excitons, delocalization occurs only through a quantum mechanical superposition of site-local exciton states, sj(cid:105)'s. In other words, the extent of the superposition represented by Eq. (3) is solely dictated by Let us introduce X as a collective variable representing all the degrees of freedom coupled to the exciton states. These include the nuclear degrees of freedom of pigment molecules as well as protein residues, and the environ- mental electronic degrees of freedom that do not par- ticipate directly in the electronic excitations of pigment molecules. Then, the total Hamiltonian representing the entirety of the exciton and its environments (the bath) can be expressed as follows: Hex = He + Heb(X) + Hb(X) , (4) where Hb(X) is the bath Hamiltonian and Heb(X) is the exciton-bath Hamiltonian that can be expressed as (cid:88) (cid:88) (cid:88) (cid:88) k j j(cid:48) k(cid:48) Heb(X) = (cid:88) (cid:88) = j k Bjk(X)sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sk U∗ jj(cid:48) Bj(cid:48)k(cid:48)(X)Ukk(cid:48) ϕj(cid:105)(cid:104)ϕk . (5) All the parameters entering the Hamiltonian Hex of Eq. (4), δEjk's, Jjk's, and Bjk(X)'s, affect the nature of ex- citons directly. In addition, some features of Hb(X) may also have indirect influence on the dynamics of excitons. In general, information on all of these is necessary for quantitative characterization of excitons. This in turn leads to reliable assessment of the overall exciton migra- tion mechanism and helps elucidate the design principle of each LHC. However, establishing a satisfactory level of informa- tion on all the components of Hex of Eq. (4) has remained difficult for most LHCs. This has been true even for well known LHCs such as the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex (Fenna and Matthews, 1975) of green sulfur bac- teria and the light harvesting 2 (LH2) complex of purple bacteria (Cogdell et al., 2006; Hu et al., 2002), for which the X-ray crystal structures (Fenna et al., 1977; Fenna and Matthews, 1975; Koepke et al., 1996; McDermott et al., 1995) were discovered more than two decades ago. Even when main features of the exciton Hamiltonians of these systems were understood, much still needed to be established regarding the details of the full exciton bath Hamiltonian. As a result, theoretical interpretations of many spectroscopic data have remained ambiguous for a long time. The past decade has seen a surge of new efforts in the spectroscopy, computational modeling, and theoreti- cal description of delocalized excitons in LHCs. This has become possible through advances in nonlinear electronic spectroscopy with femtosecond time resolution, improve- ment in computational capability, and advances in quan- tum calculations. Another important source of motiva- tion that has inspired a large group of recent works was the suggestion (Collini et al., 2010; Engel et al., 2007; Scholes, 2010) that coherent quantum dynamics of exci- tons might play much more central role than what had been perceived before. While definite assessment of this suggestion remains open, especially under natural light condition, it is true that various attempts to understand the role of quantum coherence have led to significant ad- vances in the spectroscopy and theoretical description of excitons in LHCs. 3 A fundamental feature being shared by many LHCs, which has become clearer during the past decade, thanks to a large body of newly gathered information, is the intermediate nature of the terms constituting Hex. In other words, for LHCs, it is common that δEjk's, Jjk's, and Bjk(X)'s constituting the Hamiltonian are of com- parable magnitudes. Typically, these parameters are on the same order as those of the room temperature ther- mal energy and also of the major portion of the energy spectrum comprising Hb(X). The energetic convergence of these multiple terms endows LHCs with a rich reper- toire of pathways and mechanisms for exciton dynamics and energy harvesting. At the same time, the lack of ap- parent small parameters in these systems renders simple perturbation theories to be rather unreliable quantita- tively. Therefore, advanced levels of quantum dynamics theories and computational approaches have become nec- essary for accurate description of exciton dynamics and relevant spectroscopic observables. In this sense, delocal- ized excitons in LHCs have served as prominent testing cases of modern quantum dynamics, electronic structure calculation approaches, and spectroscopic methods. The objective of this review is to provide a self- contained exposition of excitons in LHCs, with particular attention to the sources and implications of their quan- tum delocalization. For this, we first introduce three major LHCs for which sufficient level of experimental information is available and extensive theoretical and computational studies have also been made. In order to clarify assumptions behind prevailing models of exci- tons in LHCs, we provide a derivation of the commonly used form of exciton-bath Hamiltonian, and make criti- cal assessment of underlying assumptions. Then, we offer a comprehensive overview of major computational and quantum dynamical methods to study and model these excitons, and summarize applications of these methods to the three representative systems. While this review is devoted more to theoretical and computational aspects as outlined above, we also provide a wide range of ex- perimental results that are crucial for understanding the energetics and the dynamics of excitons. We also discuss features that are deemed important for their functional- ity. Ultimately, this work offers both rigorous theoretical framework and comprehensive information that can stim- ulate future endeavor to elucidate important quantum mechanical design principles behind efficient and robust harvesting of excitons by LHCs. A. FMO complex of green sulfur bacteria 4 FIG. 3 (a) FMO trimer complex. (b) View of the eight BChls of the monomer unit A (only the heavy atoms of the BChls ring are shown). (c) Chemical structure of the BChl pigment. FMO complex is an LHC found in green sulfur bacteria (Blankenship, 2014) and serves as the conduit for exci- tons migrating to reaction centers from a large chloro- some super-complex. Each functional unit of such a conduit is formed by a trimer of FMO complexes as- sembled in C3 point group symmetry, although actual pathway of each exciton appears to be confined to one complex for each transfer. There are 7 well-established bacteriochlorophyll-a (abbreviated as BChl hereafter) forming each FMO complex, which had long been be- lieved to form a complete set of pigment molecules. How- ever, recent findings and analyses confirmed (Schmidt am Busch et al., 2011; Tronrud et al., 2009) the existence of the eighth BChl as well. This serves as a linker molecule to the chlorosome, a super-aggregate of BChls serving as the major LHC of the green sulfur bacteria, and mediates initial inception of the exciton into the FMO complex. Figure 3 shows the trimer and the monomer unit of the FMO complex and the constituting BChl. The FMO complex has historical significance because it is the first LHC for which X-ray crystallography struc- tural data became available (Fenna et al., 1977; Fenna and Matthews, 1975) and has been subject to exten- sive spectroscopic and computational studies since then. However, its functional significance as an LHC was con- sidered rather minor. FMO complex does not have an apparent internal symmetry in its arrangement of pig- ment molecules. Thus, it was a nontrivial task to assign complete details of its exciton states and to determine the extent of their couplings to protein environments. Ear- lier spectroscopic and computational investigations (Cho et al., 2005; Louwe et al., 1997; Renger et al., 2001; Vulto et al., 1998; Wendling et al., 2002) thus focused on quan- tifying such parameters, as will be described in more de- FIG. 2 A schematic of three domains constituting photosyn- thesis, performing light harvesting (LH), charge separation (CS), and biochemical reaction (BR). Their respective time scales are denoted as τLH , τCS, and τBR. The length scales of these domains are denoted as lLH , lCS, and lBR, respectively. The ranges of energy changes that occur in these domains are respectively denoted as ∆ELH , ∆ECS, and ∆EBR. TABLE I Time, length, and energy scales of photosynthesis. τLH τCS τBR lLH 100ps 1ns 1µs 100nm 10nm 1µm 0.1eV 0.5eV 1eV lBR ∆ELH ∆ECS ∆EBR lCS II. OVERVIEW OF MAJOR LIGHT HARVESTING COMPLEXES Photosynthesis consists of three distinctive processes as shown schematically in Fig. 2, which we call here as light harvesting (LH), charge separation (CS), and bio- chemical reaction (BR). Although it remains difficult to make definite assessment of the length, time, and energy scales of all the photosynthetic processes, it is possible to offer rough estimates of these parameters based on the observation of many systems studied so far, which are listed in Table I. There is amazing diversity in how each of these processes is executed and how the three processes are integrated together, as has been reviewed comprehensively down to molecular level (Blankenship, 2014). Recent efforts to model the chromatophore of purple bacteria also offer unique insights into the syn- ergistic organization of all the photosynthetic processes (Cartron et al., 2014; Sener et al., 2016; Strumpfer et al., 2012). In this review, we will focus on only one of the three processes, namely the LH process. In this section, we present a general introduction of three major LHCs, Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex of green sulfur bacteria, light harvesting 2 (LH2) complex of purple bac- teria, and phycobiliproteins (PBPs) of cryptophyte algae. TABLE II Excitation energies (in cm−1) of BChls in the for sets A1 (Wendling et al., 2002), A2 FMO complex, (Adolphs and Renger, 2006), A3 (Schmidt am Busch et al., 2011), T1 (Vulto et al., 1998), and T2 (Adolphs and Renger, 2006) P. aestuari A1 12160 A2 12230 A3 12195 C. tepidum T1 T2 12140 12210 190 305 190 440 320 300 215 220 125 450 330 280 200 230 180 405 320 270 505 260 460 140 360 360 290 200 320 110 270 420 230 E3 E1 − E3 E2 − E3 E4 − E3 E5 − E3 E6 − E3 E7 − E3 E8 − E3 tail in the next section. The zeroth order exciton Hamiltonian of the FMO complex can be expressed through Eq. (1) where the sum runs over the 8 BChl molecules. Tables II and III provide representative model parameters for two differ- ent species, P. aestuari and C. tepidum, with known X- ray crystallography structural data. The consensus es- tablished through the earlier works was that excitons formed in the FMO complex are modestly delocalized (Cho et al., 2005) (up to 2-3 BChl molecules at most) and are weakly coupled to protein environments. These assessments were also consistent with the functional role of the FMO complex as a "drain" of highly delocalized excitons of the chlorosome into much more localized ones at the reaction center. In 2007, a 2-dimensional electronic spectroscopy (2DES) measurement (Engel et al., 2007) reported direct time domain observation of off-diagonal signals (in the 2DES frequency plot of signals) with beating in time that lasts more than 500 fs at 77 K, which was suggested as be- ing purely due to electronic coherence. This was viewed by many researchers as surprising because direct obser- vation of electronic coherence surviving more than 100 fs was rare in such disordered environments. However, con- sidering relatively small magnitudes of electronic cou- plings (about 30 − 80 cm−1) among BChl molecules and weak couplings of their electronic excitations to molec- ular vibrations or surrounding protein environments, it was not unreasonable to expect the existence of electronic coherence with such time scale. This also appeared to be consistent with an earlier interpretation of the oscillating anisotropy from a pump-probe spectroscopy as being due to electronic coherence (Savikhin et al., 1997). However, for the electronic coherence to be detected as real time coherent signals, dephasing due to the inhomo- geneity should be eliminated successfully. Whether the 2DES signal observed (Engel et al., 2007) indeed rep- resents such condition was not clear initially, let alone the question of whether the coherent signals can indeed 5 TABLE III Electronic coupling constants of FMO complex. The labels for sets are the same as Table II. Jjk (cm−1) j 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 k 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 3 4 5 6 7 8 4 5 6 7 8 5 6 7 8 6 7 8 7 8 8 P. aestuari A1 -102 6 -6 7 -15 -14 32 8 1 14 9 -56 -2 -10 2 -69 -19 -60 89 -4 37 A2 -98.2 5.4 -5.9 7.1 -15.2 -13.5 30.5 7.9 1.4 13.1 8.5 -55.7 -1.8 -9.5 3.1 -65.7 -18.2 -58.2 88.9 -3.4 36.5 A3 -94.8 5.5 -5.9 7.1 -15.1 -12.2 39.5 29.8 7.6 1.6 13.1 5.7 7.9 -58.9 -1.2 -9.3 3.4 1.4 -64.1 -17.4 -62.3 -1.6 89.5 -4.6 4.4 35.1 -9.1 -11.1 C. tepidum T2 T1 -87.7 -106 5.5 -5.9 6.7 -13.7 9.9 8 -5 6 -8 -4 28 6 2 13 1 -62 -1 -9 17 -70 -19 -57 40 -2 32 30.8 8.2 0.7 11.8 4.3 -53.5 -2.2 -9.6 6.0 -70.7 -17.0 -63.3 81.1 -1.3 39.7 be confirmed and validated by other independent mea- surements (Duan et al., 2017; Thyrhaug et al., 2016). Another key suggestion they made (Engel et al., 2007) was that "wavelike energy motion owing to long-lived co- herence terms" may be active for the exciton dynam- ics rather than "semiclassical hopping mechanism," re- viving an old debate (Fleming and Scholes, 2004; Knox, 1996). They also alluded that the FMO complex is im- plementing a kind of quantum search algorithm. This suggestion drew particular attention of the quantum in- formation community and motivated exploring LHCs as natural quantum information processing machines. During the past decade, the FMO complex has been subject to a new level of quantum dynamics studies, elec- tronic structure calculations, all-atomistic simulations, and spectroscopic measurements. These were particu- larly focused on (i) describing the exciton dynamics as ac- curately as possible while accounting for all major atom- istic details of the system, (ii) rigorous understanding and modeling of the 2DES signals and their implications, (iii) and deeper understanding of how quantum coherence and other quantum features make positive contribution to the functionality of the FMO complex. 6 (a) (b) (c) FIG. 4 (a) Side view of the pigment arrangement in LH2: α and β BChl molecules of the B850 ring constitute the upper circular aggregate whereas γ BChl molecules of B800 form the lower circular aggregate. The carotenoids are also reported in purple. (b) Side view of LH2 within the its membrane from a snapshot of an all-atomistic MD simulation (the carotenoids are not shown). (c) Geometric representation of the arrange- ment of the BChl molecules in B800 and B850 rings adapted with permission from (Montemayor et al., 2018). Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society. Here a reflection of 180 de- grees has been used for clarity's sake leading the B800 ring above the B850 ring. B. LH2 complex of purple bacteria LH2 complex is the primary LHC responsible for har- vesting and delivering excitons in purple photosynthetic bacteria. The first X-ray crystal structure (McDer- mott et al., 1995) was determined for a bacterium called Rhodopseudomonas (Rps.) acidophila, now reclassified as Rhodoblastus acidophilus (Cogdell et al., 2006), reveal- ing a cylindrical form with C9 symmetry that contains three BChl molecules, two helical polypeptides, and a carotenoid in each symmetry unit. Soon after, a different LH2 complex with C8 symmetry called Rhodospirillum (Rsp.) molischianum , now reclassified as Phaeospirillum molischianum (Cogdell et al., 2006), was also reported (Koepke et al., 1996). Another well-known LH2 complex from Rhodobacter (Rb.) sphaeroides, although its struc- ture has not been determined, is often assumed to have almost the same structure as Rps. acidophila. All the LH2 complexes firmly confirmed to date are known to have CN symmetry with N = 8 − 10 only (Cleary et al., 2013; Cogdell et al., 2006). As an LHC with the highest level of symmetry while being finite in its size (cylin- drical forms with both the diameter and height about 7 nm), LH2 has been subject to a wide range of spec- troscopic studies (Cogdell et al., 2006; Sundstrom et al., 1999). There have also been various theoretical and com- putational studies (Hu et al., 2002) modeling/explaining spectroscopic data and also addressing important issues such as coherence length, dynamical time scales, and en- ergetics of excitons. Figure 4(a) shows the structure of the complex from Rps. acidophila without proteins, and Fig. 4(b) depicts the whole complex embedded in lipid membrane environ- ments. Figure 4(c) shows a geometric representation of LH2 (with the upside direction switched). Out of the 3N BChl molecules constituting an LH2 with N -fold sym- metry, N of them in the cytoplasmic side form an ex- citon band near 800 nm wavelength and the remaining 2N in the periplasmic side form an exciton band near 850 nm wavelength at room temperature. Thus, the for- mer is called B800 band and the latter B850 band. The N BChl molecules constituting the B800 band are ar- ranged circularly, with their nearest neighbor distances about 2 nm. The 2N BChl molecules constituting the B850 band are also arranged circularly and are formed by two intervening concentric rings (α and β) of BChl molecules of similar radii. In this B850 unit, the nearest neighbor (formed by two adjacent α- and β-BChl pairs) distances are about 1 nm. The exciton Hamiltonian of LH2 in the absence of dis- order can be compactly expressed as (Jang et al., 2001, 2007; Montemayor et al., 2018) N(cid:88) n=1 H 0 LH2 = {Eααn(cid:105)(cid:104)αn + Eββn(cid:105)(cid:104)βn + Eγγn(cid:105)(cid:104)γn +Jαβ(0)(αn(cid:105)(cid:104)βn + βn(cid:105)(cid:104)αn) +Jαγ(0)(αn(cid:105)(cid:104)γn + γn(cid:105)(cid:104)αn) +Jβγ(0)(βn(cid:105)(cid:104)γn + γn(cid:105)(cid:104)βn)} N(cid:88) N(cid:88) + (cid:88) n=1 m(cid:54)=n s,s(cid:48)=α,β,γ Jss(cid:48)(n − m)sn(cid:105)(cid:104)s(cid:48) m , (6) where sn(cid:105), with s = α, β, or γ, represents the excited state where only sn BChl is excited with its energy Es, and Jss(cid:48)(n − m) is the electronic coupling between sn(cid:105) and s(cid:48) m(cid:105). The coordinates of BChl molecules and tran- sition dipole moments can also be expressed as follows (Jang et al., 2007; Jang and Silbey, 2003a; Montemayor et al., 2018): Rs,n = Rs sin [2π(n − 1)/9 + νs]  ,  Rs cos [2π(n − 1)/9 + νs]  ,  sin θs cos[2π(n − 1)/9 + νs + φs] sin θs sin[2π(n − 1)/9 + νs + φs] Zs cos θs (7) (8) and µs,n = µs where s = α, β, γ and n = 1,··· , 9. Table IV provides values of the above parameters for Rps. acidophila. TABLE IV Geometric parameters representing the coordi- nates and the transition dipole orientations of BChls in Rps. acidophila. Both values derived from the crystal structure and molecular dynamics (MD) simulation are shown (Mon- temayor et al., 2018). Crystal Structure MD Simulation γ α β γ β 27.0 α Rs (A) 25.8 Zs (A) θs (◦) 95.8 νs (◦) 10.2 φs (◦) -108.2 64.0 94.9 -10.2 0 0 0 0 26.0 27.5 32.1 31.0 16.5 16.8 96.5 97.3 98.2 97.3 23.6 -10.2 10.2 23.3 65.2 -106.6 60.6 63.7 Table V provides data for the electronic coupling con- stants calculated by various approaches, which will be explained in detail in Sec. IV. For the B800 band, the magnitudes of the nearest neighbor electronic couplings are ∼ 20 cm−1. These electronic couplings are estimated to be smaller, by about a factor of 2 ∼ 3, than the dis- order in the energy and the dynamic coupling to protein environments of the excitation of each BChl. For the B850 band, the magnitudes of electronic couplings be- tween nearest neighbor BChls (formed by two adjacent α and β BChl pairs) are known to be about 200−300 cm−1. These are comparable to the disorder in the excitation 7 energy of each BChl and are somewhat larger than the reorganization energy of the coupling between the exci- tation of a BChl to its environment. Therefore, excitons in this B850 unit are more delocalized than those in the B800 unit, although the debate on the coherence lengths of excitons in both units still remain somewhat unset- tled. In particular, the B850 exciton serve as a unique example of intermediate coupling regime, where all ma- jor energetic and dynamical parameters are of compara- ble magnitudes. This regime defies simple classifications normally applicable in limiting situations. For example, there have been different estimates (Book et al., 2000; Dahlbom et al., 2001; Jang et al., 2001; Trinkunas et al., 2001) of the delocalization lengths of excitons ranging from about 4 to the entire set of the BChl molecules. TABLE V Major electronic coupling constants among BChls in LH2 of Rps. acidophila (see Fig. 3 for notations). All values are in cm−1. C-1: Transition dipole coupling data based on X-ray crystal structure (Sundstrom et al., 1999). C-2: Transition density cube method data based on X-ray crystal structure (Krueger et al., 1998). C-3: TD-DFT/MM data based on X-ray crystal structure (Segatta et al., 2017). C-4: RASSCF/RASPT2 data with MM solvation based on X-ray crystal structure (Segatta et al., 2017). C-5: TD-DFT data with MMPol solvation based on X-ray crystal structure (Cupellini et al., 2016). MD-1: TD-DFT data with MMPol based on structures from MD simulation (Cupellini et al., 2016). MD-2: TrESP calculation data based on structures from MD simulation (Montemayor et al., 2018). Parameter C-1 C-2 C-3 C-4 C-5 MD-1 MD-2 Jαβ(0) Jαβ(1) Jαα(1) Jββ(1) Jβα(1) Jαβ(2) Jγγ(1) Jαγ(1) Jβγ(1) Jγα(0) Jγβ(0) 339 317 322 238 336 563 362 288 213 288 474 409 245 140 -46 -91 -83 -87 −66 −59 -37 -63 -69 -59 −51 −29 18 14 11 20 13 13 -32 −25 42 28 27 23 −11 −11 −6 −3 3 -16 −12 -13 -19 -22 -20 −3 -10 5 -12 24 25 -22 -27 -47 -46 -50 59 23 24 22 26 44 46 -8 -9 Both the B800 and B850 units serve as active absorbing units of photons of LH2, but the excitons formed in the B800 unit transfer quickly to the B850 unit, which serves as main reservoir and relayer of excitons. Pump-probe and photon echo spectroscopy measurements (Jimenez et al., 1996; Pullerits et al., 1997) suggested that this transfer occurs within about 1 ps and is fairly insensi- tive to temperature. This is much larger than theoreti- cal estimates based on the Forster theory (Forster, 1948, 1959; Scholes, 2003), and has been the subject of theoret- ical and experimental studies (Cheng and Silbey, 2006; Herek et al., 2000; Jang et al., 2004, 2007; Kimura and Kakitani, 2003; Mukai et al., 1999; Novoderezhkin et al., 2003; Scholes and Fleming, 2000). Other important issues concerning the LH2 complex 8 include understanding the role of carotenoids and their dark states, and elucidating the effects of hydrogen bond- ing on the structure and energetics of BChls. More re- cently, the availability of the atomic force microscopy (AFM) images of membranes containing aggregates of LH2 complexes (Bahatyrova et al., 2004; Scheuring et al., 2006; Scheuring and Sturgis, 2005, 2009) made it pos- sible to investigate the nature of arrangement of LH2 complexes. Along with theoretical studies (Cleary et al., 2013; Jang et al., 2015), this information helps address- ing the dynamics of excitons in the aggregates of LH2 and their physical implications. 15,16-dihydrobiliverdin (DBV), whereas each β polypep- tide chain (C or D) is linked to three phycoerythrobilins (PEB). The corresponding pigments are labeled DBV19A, DBV19B, PEB158C, PEB158D, PEB50/61C, PEB50/61D, PEB82C, and PEB82D, where the subscripts denote the protein subunit and cysteine residue linked to the chro- mophore. The central PEB50/61D pigments are linked to the protein by two cysteine residues. The overall PE545 structure displays a pseudo-symmetry about the 2-fold axis relating the α1β and α2β monomers (Doust et al., 2004). C. Phycobiliproteins (PBP) of cryptophyte algae Phycobiliproteins (PBPs) are primary LHCs of cryp- tophyte algae, a diverse group of eukaryotic single-cell photosynthetic organisms (Blankenship, 2014) that can be found in both sea and fresh water. These organisms live under water where spectrum of incident light lacks the chlorophyll-absorbing region but still has significant intensities in blue and green spectral regions. The pig- ment molecules of PBPs are linear tetrapyrroles called bilins, which are covalently attached to the protein scaf- fold through single or double cysteine bonds. In the FMO and LH2 complexes, tuning of excitation energies of pig- ment molecules and their electronic couplings are main factors dictating the excitonic features, respectively, as they contain a single type of pigment. In PBPs, how- ever, different types of bilins can be found in the same complex, and the possibility to tune their protonation states or their conformation provides further mechanisms to adapt the spectral range for efficient light-harvesting. Another distinctive feature is that pigment molecules are bound to proteins by covalent boding. There are two well-known PBPs. One is phycoerythrin 545 (PE545), the structure of which was first determined with rather low resolution (Wilk et al., 1999) and later with higher resolution (Doust et al., 2004). The other is called phycocyanin 645 (PC645), the detailed structure of which was confirmed quite recently (Harrop et al., 2014). Figure 5 shows the structures of PBPs and bilins. The capability of PE545 to photosynthesize under low- light conditions has been an important subject of both experimental (Collini et al., 2010; Doust et al., 2005; Harrop et al., 2014; Wong et al., 2012) and computa- tional (Aghtar et al., 2017, 2014; Curutchet et al., 2011a, 2013; Hossein-Nejad et al., 2011; Huo and Coker, 2011; Viani et al., 2014, 2013) studies. A possible explana- tion of this efficiency is in terms of the flexible structural nature of the pigments. This allows the optimal mod- ulation of the absorption and energy transfer processes through local pigment-protein interactions. The crystal structure of PE545 contains eight bilins (Doust et al., 2004). In particular, each α chain (A and B) contains a FIG. 5 (a) PBP complex. (b) View of the eight bilins (only the heavy atoms are shown) present in PE545 (black) and PC645 (orange or grey in print). (c) Chemical structure of the different bilins present in PE545 (PEB,DBV) and PC645 (PCB,DBV, MBV). The ellipses indicate the double bond which is used to create the second cysteine bond to the protein in PE545(PEB) and PC645(DBV). Though the protein scaffolds of the PE545 and PC645 complexes are nearly identical, the compositions of pig- ment molecules and their π-conjugation lengths are dif- ferent. In PE545, the lowest energy states are localized on the peripheral DVB19 molecules. For the PC645 com- plex, which functions at lower absorption energy, the DBV molecules reside at the dimer interface and play the role of the source states, while the phycocyanobilin (PCB) and the mesobiliverdin (MBV) molecules form lower energy intermediate and sink states, respectively (Collini et al., 2010; Huo and Coker, 2011; Lee et al., 2017; Mirkovic et al., 2007). We can express the exciton Hamiltonian for both PE5454 and PC645 commonly by abbreviating the two pigments with the highest excitation energies H1 and H2, the two lowest ones L1 and L2, and the four in- termediate ones as Mn, n = 1,··· , 4. Thus, for PE545, PEB50/61C(D) and DBVs are the H and the L pairs, re- spectively, while for PC645, DBVs are the Hs and PCBs the Ls. With these notations, the zeroth order exciton TABLE VI Electronic coupling constants of PE545 and PC645. MD1: CIS/MMPol calculations on structures ob- tained from an MD simulation (couplings are obtained as a sum of Coulomb interactions of transition densities and an environment term) (Curutchet et al., 2013). MD2: CIS/MM calculations on structures obtained from an MD simulation (couplings are obtained as dipole-dipole interactions of transi- tion dipoles positioned at the center-of-mass of the bilin sites. The resulting couplings were then multiplied by a value of 0.72 to take into account screening effects from the environ- ment.) (Lee et al., 2017). C1: CIS/PCM calculations on the crystal structure (Collini et al., 2010; Mirkovic et al., 2007). s s(cid:48) H1 H2 M1 M2 M3 M4 L1 L2 H2 M1 M2 M3 M4 L1 L2 M1 M2 M3 M4 L1 L2 M2 M3 M4 L1 L2 M3 M4 L1 L2 M4 L1 L2 L1 L2 Jss(cid:48) (cm−1) PE545 PC645 MD1 71.7 -21.5 24.5 34.0 12.1 2.2 -46.6 -15.2 19.1 -16.0 -35.6 -39.3 1.4 -6.1 7.3 6.4 -27.3 -3.7 6.8 8.2 3.5 26.3 4.0 -11.4 -36.1 34.3 11.6 -4.3 MD2 163.9 -29.5 20.6 38.8 17.9 2.7 -45.3 -22.1 29.8 -19.3 -38.1 -47.8 3.2 -6.3 7.9 6.4 -37.4 -3.5 6.2 8.7 3.6 38.7 6.2 -13.0 -48.2 45.0 13.8 -4.8 C1 319.4 -43.9 -9.6 25.3 23.8 -20.0 -46.8 7.7 43.9 29.5 30.5 21.5 48.0 4.3 86.2 3.4 53.8 -14.7 -2.9 -86.7 -15.8 49.3 7.8 29.0 -10.7 11.0 10.0 48.0 MD2 212.3 -53.4 -10.8 34.9 31.9 -19.9 -43.4 11.0 49.0 24.4 33.7 19.9 48.9 3.4 77.6 2.3 69.3 -16.0 -2.0 -78.2 -17.2 66.8 10.8 11.8 -12.4 11.2 10.7 9.8 Hamiltonian for both can be expressed as 2(cid:88) 4(cid:88) n=1 n=1 H 0 P BP = + {EHnHn(cid:105)(cid:104)Hn + ELnLn(cid:105)(cid:104)Ln} EM nMn(cid:105)(cid:104)Mn + Js,s(cid:48)s(cid:105)(cid:104)s(cid:48) ,(9) (cid:88) (cid:88) s(cid:48)(cid:54)=s s where s and s(cid:48) run over all possible sites. Table VI pro- vides data for these electronic coupling constants calcu- lated by various approaches. As LHCs with their struc- tures known most recently among the three being con- sidered here, spectroscopic data as well as the X-ray data played key role early on. Detailed account of these spec- troscopic studies are provided in the next section. 9 III. SPECTROSCOPY OF EXCITONS IN LIGHT HARVESTING COMPLEXES Absorption spectroscopy can identify distinctive sig- natures of LHCs in terms of the positions and widths of major excitonic peaks (see Fig. 1(b)). Given the struc- tural information of an LHC, it is possible to assign some exciton states corresponding to the peaks of the absorp- tion lineshape directly. However, unambiguous modeling of the entirety of the absorption line shape was difficult in the beginning, and assignment of some peaks, espe- cially in large LHCs without apparent symmetry, still re- mains difficult. Excitation energies of pigment molecules in LHCs can easily be modulated by pigment-protein in- teractions, typically in the range of 1, 000 cm−1. De- spite significant advances, present day electronic struc- ture calculation methods cannot yet reliably determine these modulations with sufficient efficiency and accuracy. In addition, the three important factors influencing the absorption lineshape, namely, electronic couplings be- tween pigment molecules, vibronic couplings, and the dis- order/fluctuations are of comparable magnitudes in the range of 100 − 500 cm−1, making it difficult to discern their effects on detailed features of the lineshape. Earlier efforts to interrogate the energetics and the dy- namics of excitons in LHCs employed conventional sub- ensemble nonlinear spectroscopic techniques (Mukamel, 1995). For example, pump-probe and photon-echo spec- troscopies (Cho et al., 2005; Sundstrom et al., 1999) gave time resolved information on the response of a subensemble of excitonic states. Hole burning spec- troscopy (Jankowiak et al., 2011; Purchase and Volker, 2009) allowed identification of narrow zero-phonon exci- ton states and their distributions hidden in the ensem- ble lineshape. For LH2 and LH1 complexes of purple bacteria and for other limited examples of LHCs, sin- gle molecule spectroscopy (SMS) (Oellerich and Kohler, 2009; van Oijen et al., 1999; Saga et al., 2010; Schlau- Cohen et al., 2011b) has also played an important role. These nonlinear spectroscopic and SMS data helped ex- tracting information on exciton relaxation kinetics, ho- mogeneous broadening, and the disorder/fluctuations. However, they in general fell short of offering unambigu- ous interpretation of experimental signals for excitons in LHCs, the complexity of which typically causes multi- tudes of competing models/scenarios to be viable for in- terpreting the spectroscopic signals. Further advances in laser technology have made it pos- sible to conduct a general 2DES (Cho, 2008; Fuller and Ogilvie, 2015; Jonas, 2003) and allowed investigating new energetic and temporal details of exciton dynamics in LHCs (Ginsberg et al., 2009; Schlau-Cohen et al., 2011a). 2DES is a femtosecond pump-probe technique that re- solves both pump and probe frequencies. It thus corre- lates the visible-light absorption spectrum, which enables related excitonic states to be identified by cross-peaks. 2DES is similar to transient absorption spectroscopy. However, two excitation pulses are used cooperatively to excite the sample followed by a third "probe-pulse" which interacts with the sample after the pump-probe time delay. More detailed account of these spectroscopic studies are outlined below for the FMO complex, LH2 complex, and the PBPs of cryptophyte algae. 1. Spectroscopy on FMO complex FIG. 6 Experimental and theoretical absorption spectra of FMO complex at three different temperatures adapted from (Renger et al., 2012) with permission. Copyright 2012 Ameri- can Chemical Society. The two simulation data in the middle and right panel show that improvement in the bath spectral density brings qualitative features of theoretical line shapes closer to those of experimental ones. Already in 1990s, high quality steady state linear spec- troscopic data for FMO complexes such as absorption, linear dichroism (LD), and circular dichroism (CD) be- came available (Louwe et al., 1997; Miller et al., 1994; Savikhin and Struve, 1996; Vulto et al., 1998; Wendling et al., 2002). Earlier efforts (Gulen, 1996; Louwe et al., 1997; Pearlstein, 1992; Vulto et al., 1998; Wendling et al., 2002) to explain these spectroscopic data were based on simple exciton models of the form of Eq. (1), without including bath interactions. Thus, line broadening due to environmental relaxation of exciton states and inter- exciton dynamics were not properly taken into consider- ation in these works. Nonetheless, the fittings of spectral data and the resulting model parameters turned out to be reasonable. This indicates that the exciton-bath cou- pling and inter-exciton couplings in the FMO complex are not dominant factors. Later, the quality of fitting was improved by including proper lineshape functions and utilizing more systematic fitting algorithms (Adolphs and Renger, 2006). The model parameters obtained from these fittings are compared in Tables II and III. Figure 10 6 shows experimental absorption lineshapes of the FMO complex compared with a recent set of theoretical line- shapes (Renger et al., 2012). More detailed account of computational methods underlying these theoretical cal- culations will be provided in the later sections of this work. Subensemble nonlinear spectroscopies such as pump probe (van Amerongen and Struve, 1991; Buck et al., 1997; Freiberg et al., 1997; Savikhin et al., 1997; Savikhin and Struve, 1994, 1996), hole burning (Johnson and Small, 1991; Ratsep et al., 1999), and photon echo (Prokhorenko et al., 2002) were employed to gain infor- mation on the dynamics and the energetics of exciton states that are not clearly visible in ensemble linear spec- troscopic data. These experiments revealed signatures of relaxation dynamics ranging from sub-hundred femtosec- onds to hundred picoseconds. However, definite assess- ment and quantitative quantum dynamical modeling of these data have not been pursued extensively. Advances in 2DES technique made it possible to ac- cess new information on exciton states of the FMO com- plex that had not been available otherwise. Earlier suc- cess was made in determining detailed excitonic path- ways (Brixner et al., 2005; Cho et al., 2005) that were largely consistent with a model exciton Hamiltonian de- veloped earlier (Vulto et al., 1998, 1999). This was soon followed by direct observation of beating signals lasting more than 500 fs at 77 K (Engel et al., 2007). Engel and coworkers made further progress, and have reported more detailed experimental results (Hayes and Engel, 2011; Hayes et al., 2010) including the evidence that beating signals can be observed even at room temperature (Pan- itchayangkoon et al., 2010). While these were exciting results that have motivated a broad community of experi- mentalists and theoreticians, interpretation of such 2DES signals was not straightforward because of the fact that the FMO complex has more than two exciton states and the exciton-bath couplings are more complicated than simple models that are typically used for analyzing 2DES signals. There was strong possibility that the beating signals might have originated from any of electronic, vi- brational, and vibronic contributions. In fact, whether all of these contributions can be discerned by any 2DES was not clear at all (Butkus et al., 2012). Thus, there has been ongoing debate and various analyses on the ori- gins and sources of the beating signal (Christensson et al., 2012; Fransted et al., 2012; Fujihashi et al., 2015; Liu and Kuhn, 2016; Plenio et al., 2013; Tempelaar et al., 2014; Tiwari et al., 2013). Furthermore, such beating signals have not yet been independently confirmed in different 2DES data by other groups (Duan et al., 2017; Thyrhaug et al., 2016). Due to the unique arrangement of pigment molecules in the FMO complex, different exciton states have well- defined directions of transition dipole moments. Thus, control and information of the light polarization can play an essential role in characterizing the dynamics directly associated with electronic coherence. Indeed, utilization of the information on polarizations of light pulses has been shown to be critical in deducing structural data (Read et al., 2008). More recent work demonstrated that full polarization control allows accurate description of electronic structure and population dynamics (Thyrhaug et al., 2016). With further advances in spectroscopic and sample preparation techniques, efforts to clarify detailed char- acteristics of excitons have continued in different direc- tions. A new hole burning spectroscopy of FMO trimer and modeling in terms of excitonic calculations were re- ported (Kell et al., 2014). Transient absorption and time- resolved fluorescence spectroscopies were conducted for several mutants of C. tepidum (Magdaong et al., 2017). A new 2DES spectroscopy provided evidence that FMO indeed functions as a conduit of exciton energy (Dost´al et al., 2016). A single molecule spectroscopy has finally become possible for the FMO complex (Lohner et al., 2016). 2. Spectroscopy on LH2 Thanks to the high symmetry of the LH2 complex, the number of independent parameters minimally necessary for fitting its lineshape is relatively small compared to the total number of pigment molecules involved. Indeed, the average values of excitation energies of α-, β-, and γ-BChls, nearest neighbor electronic couplings, and the magnitudes of the disorder for each of the B800 and B850 units seem sufficient for fairly accurate fitting of ensemble lineshape. However, on the other hand, the easiness of fitting the ensemble lineshape has also been a contribut- ing factor for the lack of clear consensus on some details of the exciton Hamiltonian. For example, modeling of both absorption and CD spectra (Georgakopoulou et al., 2002) based on the crys- tal structure support the assumption that the excitation energy of α-BChl is about 300 cm−1 higher than that of β-BChl. However, more recent computational studies (Cupellini et al., 2016; Montemayor et al., 2018) suggest that the conformations and local environments of α- and β-BChls are virtually the same in membrane environ- ments without indicating significant difference in their excitation energies. Efforts to refine the exciton-bath model of LH2 by combining more comprehensive spec- troscopic data and advanced computational tools have continued, for example, based on temperature depen- dent absorption spectra (Urboniene et al., 2007; Zer- lauskiene et al., 2008) and combination of temperature dependent absorption, fluorescence, and fluorescence- anisotropy (Pajusalu et al., 2011a). As yet, there has not been any attempt to explain all existing steady state spectroscopic data over all the temperatures based on a 11 universal exciton model. The determination of the X-ray crystal structures of LH2 complexes coincided with new advances in nonlinear spectroscopic theories and techniques. Thus, LH2 soon became an important testing ground for evolving nonlin- ear spectroscopic techniques. Along with the standard pump-probe and hole burning spectroscopies, various versions of four wave mixing optical spectroscopy have been used to interrogate mechanistic details and time scales of exciton dynamics (Lampoura et al., 2000; Sund- strom et al., 1999). Ultrafast fluorescence up-conversion (Jimenez et al., 1996) provided information on time scales of exciton dynamics within B800 and B850 units. It also showed that the time scale of the exciton transfer from the B800 unit to B850 at room temperature is about 1.5 ps. Pump-probe spectroscopies at a few different temperatures (Pullerits et al., 1997) also provided sim- ilar estimates, and demonstrated that the transfer time decreases with temperature moderately from 1.5 ps at 4.2 K to 0.7 ps at 300 K. Time resolved transient absorption spectroscopy of isolated and native membrane-embedded LH2 complexes of Rb. sphaeroides at 10 K (Timpmann et al., 2000b) showed that the inter-LH2 exciton transfer time is larger than 1 ps. Three pulse photon echo peak shift suggested that (Agarwal et al., 2002) the intra-LH2 exciton relaxation takes about 200 fs, and the inter-LH2 exciton transfer about 5 ps. Combination of various spec- troscopic techniques were made to interrogate the delo- calization length of excitons and its dynamical localiza- tion with time scales less than 200 fs (Book et al., 2000). As in the case of the FMO complex, real time coher- ent beating signal was observed in 2DES data of LH2 complex. Angle resolved coherent four wave mixing spec- troscopy showed evidence for coherent dynamics that can be well separated from the relaxation signal due to en- ergy transfer (Mercer et al., 2009). 2DES has also been used to determine parameters of the Hamiltonian for LH3 complex (Zigmantas et al., 2006), which is similar to LH2 and appears under low light condition. Clear peaks cor- responding to exciton transfer from the B800 unit to the B850 unit were shown to emerge even at about 200 fs after excitation (Harel and Engel, 2012). Recent 2DES spectroscopy suggested new aspects on the possible role of dark states of carotenoids (Ostroumov et al., 2013) and dark charge transfer states of BChls (Ferretti et al., 2016) in energy transfer dynamics. Hole burning spectroscopy (Jankowiak et al., 2011; Purchase and Volker, 2009; Wu et al., 1997) has long played a unique role in gaining quantitative information on the low lying exciton states, and has helped validating the exciton Hamiltonian model for LH2. However, more direct experimental demonstration of the validity of the Frenkel exciton model for LH2 came from low tempera- ture single molecule spectroscopy based on fluorescence- excitation technique (Berlin et al., 2007; Brotosudamo et al., 2009; Kunz et al., 2012, 2014; Lohner et al., 2015; 12 et al., 2011). 3. Spectroscopy on PBPs of cryptophyte algae FIG. 7 Single LH2 fluorescence-excitation spectra (solid black lines) and emission spectra (dashed blue and red lines, or dashed grey lines in print) provided by Jurgen Kohler. The corresponding ensemble lineshapes are shown in the top. The left panel is for LH2 complexes with sharp emission line shapes, and the right panel is for LH2 complexes with broad emission line shapes. Detailed experimental method and more comprehensive set of data are available in (Kunz et al., 2012). van Oijen et al., 1999). In particular, the SMS lineshapes for the B850 unit clearly consisted of two major exciton peaks (k = ±1), which are perturbed due to the disorder, and one or two minor exciton peaks at higher energies. Figure 7 shows line shapes reported from a recent SMS experiment (Kunz et al., 2012). Following the success of low temperature SMS exper- iments, room temperature SMS experiments were also conducted to investigate the nature and the dynamics of excitons at physiological temperature (Bopp et al., 1997, 1999). However, the noisiness of the data made it difficult to obtain any definite microscopic information. More recently, room temperature single molecule emis- sion spectroscopy of LH2 was shown to be able to iden- tify three emissive states switching at room temperature (Schlau-Cohen et al., 2011b). Single molecule femtosec- ond pump probe spectroscopy employing ultrafast phase coherent excitation was also reported recently (Hildner et al., 2013). How excitons migrate in aggregates of LH2 complexes has important implication for understanding the design principle of efficient energy conversion. To this end, de- tailed information on the arrangement of LH2 complexes is needed. AFM images have revealed various patterns of aggregates depending on light conditions (Scheuring and Sturgis, 2005). The extents of order and disorder also vary with other growth conditions and species (Olsen et al., 2008; Sturgis et al., 2009). AFM images and pump probe spectroscopy of aggregates reconstituted in phos- pholipids have become available (Sumino et al., 2013). Time resolved spectroscopy of exciton migration in ar- rays of LH2 complexes has also been reported (Pflock FIG. 8 Spectroscopic data for PC645 adapted from (Dean et al., 2016) with permission from Elsevier. (a) Absorption lineshapes at 77 K (dashed black line) and ambient temper- ature (solid black line), and fluorescence lineshape (solid red line, or grey line in print) at ambient temperature. (b) Vi- brational frequencies extracted from transient absorption by Fourier transform at three different emission frequencies. (c) 2DES taken at 295 K. t2 refers to population time. (d) 2DES taken at 77 K. Linear ensemble spectroscopy, polarization anisotropy, and transient grating were employed early on as a tool to augment X-ray crystallography to construct an exci- ton model for PE545 (Doust et al., 2004). Oscillations lasting up to about 1 ps were observed, which were as- signed mostly coming from vibrational coherence (Doust et al., 2004). Transient absorption spectroscopy (Doust et al., 2005) also revealed broad time scales of energy transfer within the PE545 ranging from 250 fs to picosec- onds. A comprehensive set of absorption, CD, fluores- cence, and time resolved transient absorption at both 77 K and 300 K were reported (Novoderezhkin et al., 2010). This work also employed the experimental results to construct the exciton Hamiltonian and model exciton transfer kinetics. Photon echo spectroscopy (Collini et al., 2010) of both PE545 and PC645 at 294 K reported oscillatory cross peaks in the two dimensional representation lasting more than 400 fs, which were initially interpreted as originating from electronic coherence. Further interrogation of the sources and implications of these signals have continued, and ensuing studies (McClure et al., 2014; Turner et al., 2012) clarified that most of them have vibrational origin, confirming the earlier suggestion (Doust et al., 2004). In fact, this was not surprising considering the covalent na- ture of the pigment-protein bonding and rather strong vi- bronic coupling (Kolli et al., 2012). Recent studies (Dean et al., 2016; O'Reilly and Olya-Castro, 2014) suggest that vibronic couplings are in fact being utilized positively for efficient and robust light harvesting capability. Figure 8 provides the absorption and fluorescence lineshapes of PC645, vibrational spectra obtained from different sec- tions of transient absorption, and 2DES profiles at two different temperatures. IV. EXCITON-BATH HAMILTONIAN The fact that the Frenkel exciton Hamiltonian of Eq. (1) provides reasonable description of the electronic spec- tra of many LHCs was well established at phenomeno- logical level. However, computational efforts to vali- date its assumption and to determine the parameters di- rectly through first principles calculation are fairly recent and are relatively in early stage. For further progress in this direction, it is important to clarify assumptions and approximations involved in the exciton Hamiltonian, or more generally, the exciton-bath Hamiltonian (EBH). To this end, we here provide a comprehensive review of quantum mechanical assumptions implicit in the EBH typically used for LHCs and computational methods to calculate key elements of the EBH such as the excitation energies, electronic couplings, and the spectral densities of the bath. A. Derivation 1. Aggregates of pigment molecules Consider an aggregate of pigment molecules or chro- mophores (pigment molecules or part of them) more gen- erally. The total molecular Hamiltonian representing the aggregate can in general be expressed as Nc(cid:88) j=1 Hc = Hj + 1 2 Nc(cid:88) Nc(cid:88) j=1 k(cid:54)=j Hjk , (10) where Nc is the total number of chromophores, Hj is the full molecular Hamiltonian of the jth chromophore, and Hjk is the interaction Hamiltonian between the jth and the kth chromophores. For the jth chromophore, we denote the positions and momenta of the ith electron as rj,i and pj,i, and those of the lth nucleus as Rj,l and Pj,l. Given that the jth chromophore has Lj nuclei and Nj electrons, Hj in the 13 Zj,lZj,l(cid:48)e2 Rj,l − Rj,l(cid:48) above equation can be expressed as P2 j,l 2Mj,l + l=1 Lj(cid:88) Nj(cid:88) Nj(cid:88) i=1 1 2 − p2 j,i 2me Nj(cid:88) i=1 i(cid:48)(cid:54)=i Hj = + + Lj(cid:88) l(cid:48)(cid:54)=j Lj(cid:88) Nj(cid:88) Lj(cid:88) 1 2 l=1 l=1 i=1 e2 rj,i − rj,i(cid:48) Zj,le2 Rj,l − rj ,i = Tj,n + Vj,nn + Tj,e + Vj,en + Vj,ee , (11) where the terms following the second equality are ab- breviations of the kinetic ( T ) and potential ( V ) energy operator terms. The subscripts n and e in these terms respectively refer to nuclear and electron degrees of free- dom. The second term in Eq. (10) represents interactions between all chromophores. These are pairwise at the level of explicit description of all Coulomb interactions among electrons and nuclei. Namely, each component, Hjk, represents the interaction between the jth and the kth chromophores, and consists of four potential terms as follows: l=1 Lj(cid:88) Lj(cid:88) Nj(cid:88) l=1 l(cid:48)=1 Lk(cid:88) Nk(cid:88) Nk(cid:88) i=1 i=1 i(cid:48)=1 Hjk = − + Zj,lZk,l(cid:48)e2 Rj,l − Rk,l(cid:48) Rj,l − rk,i − Lk(cid:88) Zj,le2 l=1 Nj(cid:88) i=1 Zk,le2 Rk,l − rj,i e2 rj,i − rk,i(cid:48) = Vjk,nn + Vjk,ne + Vjk,en + Vjk,ee , (12) where each term in the last line is again an abbreviation of the corresponding interaction potential term. One can employ the standard quantum mechanical procedure to derive an EBH corresponding to Eq. (11). Appendix A provides a detailed description of such pro- cedure, based on the assumption that the ground elec- tronic state and the site excitation state can be defined in terms of direct products of adiabatic electronic states of independent chromophores defined at reference nuclear coordinates. The default choice for these reference nu- clear coordinates are those of the optimized ground elec- tronic states of chromophores. Thus, the ground elec- tronic state and the site excitation states are defined by Eq. (A29) and Eq. (A30). Collecting all the terms in Appendix A, Hc can thus be expressed as Nc(cid:88) j=1 Hc = Ec,0 g g(cid:105)(cid:104)g + Nc(cid:88) (cid:88) Ec,0 j=1 j + + sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sj + gj g(cid:105)(cid:104)sj) jg sj(cid:105)(cid:104)g + J c,0 ( J c,0 (cid:88) (cid:88) jk sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sk J c,0 k(cid:54)=j j Bc,0 j sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sj + H c,0 b . (13) j g In the above expression, Ec,0 is the energy of the ground electronic state and is defined by Eq. (A36). J c,0 jg and J c,0 gj are the electronic couplings between the site excita- tion state sj(cid:105) and the ground electronic state g(cid:105), and are defined by Eqs. (A33) and (A34). These terms originate from interactions between electrons in the excited state of the jth chromophore and the nuclear degrees of freedom in the ground electronic state of all others. Note that these are in general operators with respect to the nuclear degrees of freedom and may be responsible for nonadia- batic transitions, although small. Ec,0 is the electronic energy of the site excitation state sj(cid:105) as defined by Eq. (A37), J c,0 jk is the electronic coupling between site exci- tation states sj(cid:105) and sk(cid:105), and is defined by Eq. (A35). represents the coupling between sj(cid:105) and all the nu- Bc,0 clear degrees of freedom, as described by Eq. (A39), and H c,0 represents the bath Hamiltonian originating from the nuclear degrees of freedom of all the chromophores. The definition of this is given by Eq. (A38). b j j It is important to note that we have labeled all the terms defined in Eq. (13) with an additional superscript 0. This was to make it clear that they are defined with re- spect reference adiabatic states of independent pigment molecules. In fact, even for simple aggregates of pig- ments, there are many-body effects of other pigments, which affect the definition and calculation of adiabatic electronic states of each pigment molecule, making the actual values of parameters and Hamiltonian terms dif- ferent from the zeroth order ones in Eq. (13). For LHCs, these implicit effects due to other pigment molecules are expected to be less significant than those due to pro- tein environments in general, which can be considered together. 2. Light harvesting complex The presence of the protein environment in the LHC affects the molecular Hamiltonian of the aggregate in all of its terms, and adds an additional one referring to its own degrees of freedom. Expressing all these in the site excitation basis, one can obtain the following expression for the Hamiltonian of the LHC: 14 gj)g(cid:105)(cid:104)sj(cid:111) gj + J r g )g(cid:105)(cid:104)g jg)sj(cid:105)(cid:104)g + ( J c (cid:88) (cid:88) k(cid:54)=j j HLHC = (Ec g + Er ( J c jg + J r (cid:110) j=1 Nc(cid:88) Nc(cid:88) Nc(cid:88) j=1 + + + Nc(cid:88) (Ec j + Er j )sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sj + (J c jk + J r jk)sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sk ( Bc j δjk + Br jk)sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sk + H c b + H r b , (14) j=1 k=1 where δjk in the last line is the Kronecker-delta symbol. All the terms with superscript c represents contributions from chromophores, which also include all the implicit effects on the adiabatic state of each chromophore by the protein environments and the other chromophores in the ground electronic state. The terms with superscript r represent explicit contributions of the protein environ- ment. Equation (14) is the final and the most general form of the exciton-bath Hamiltonian for LHC, and includes all possible interactions between single excitons and other degrees of freedom. The terms that are missing here are intra-pigment non-adiabatic terms, spontaneous emission terms of the site excitation states and interaction terms with the radiation, which will be considered later. The common assumption implicit in most theoretical models developed so far is that the environment induced nonadi- abatic coupling between the ground and the exciton state (cross terms between g(cid:105) and sj(cid:105) of Eq. (14)) are neg- ligible compared to the spontaneous emission term and the interaction terms with the radiation. Thus, we also assume that they are negligible. Combining the contributions of the chromophores and protein environments, we define the following parame- ters: Eg = Ec Ej = Ec Jjk = J c Bjk = Bc Hb = H c g + Er g j + Er j , jk + (cid:104) J r jk(cid:105) , j δjk + Br jk + J r b + H r b . jk − (cid:104) J r jk(cid:105) , (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) Employing the above definitions and neglecting the envi- ronment induced nonadiabatic terms between the ground electronic and the single exciton states, as noted above, Eq. (14) can be simplified as HLHC = Egg(cid:105)(cid:104)g + He + = Egg(cid:105)(cid:104)g + Hex , Bjksj(cid:105)(cid:104)sk + Hb j=1 k=1 (20) where He has the same form as Eq. (1) and the second equality serves as the definition of Hex. As can be seen Nc(cid:88) Nc(cid:88) above, this also has the same form as Eq. (4) except that the variables X is not explicitly shown. The full determi- nation of HLHC given by Eq. (20) is a challenging task in general. Furthermore, even if the full information on the Hamiltonian of the above type were available, the actual quantum dynamical calculation poses as another theo- retical challenge. Thus, in consideration of practicality, further approximations have been made. 3. Site diagonal coupling to bath of harmonic oscillators Given the structural and spectroscopic stability of LHCs, it is reasonable to assume that the displacements of the bath degrees of freedom remain small enough to be governed by almost linear restoring forces. Under this condition, the bath Hamiltonian can be approximated as a set of harmonic oscillators, and the exciton-bath inter- action terms can be assumed to be linear in the bath co- ordinates. While these interaction terms may in general involve both diagonal and off-diagonal terms of the exci- ton Hamiltonian in the site excitation basis, most models of LHCs developed and considered so far have assumed the existence of only diagonal couplings. At least for the case of the FMO complex, explicit calculation of normal modes confirmed that (Renger et al., 2012) off-diagonal exciton-bath couplings are about an order of magnitudes smaller than diagonal ones, offering microscopic justifi- cation for such assumption. Thus, the typical form of the EBH that has been used for LHC so far assumes that Bjk is diagonal and linear in the displacement of bath coordinates. Within this ap- proximation, Eq. (20) can be expressed as ωngj,n(bn + b† (cid:19) b† n bn + 1 2 , (21) where b† n and bn are raising and lowering operators of the nth normal mode constituting all the bath degrees of freedom. This approximation also ignores Duschin- sky rotation, which can be significant if excitation causes nontrivial structural change of chromophores. Even though the exciton-bath coupling is assumed to be diagonal in the site excitation basis, certain delocal- ized vibrational normal modes can be coupled to different site excitation states together, which are called common modes. Thus, in general, the complete specification of the exciton-bath coupling requires specification of the fol- lowing spectral densities of the bath for all pairs of j and Ejsj(cid:105)(cid:104)sj + Jjksj(cid:105)(cid:104)sk Nc(cid:88) (cid:88) j=1 k(cid:54)=j n)sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sj Nc(cid:88) j=1 HLHC ≈ Egg(cid:105)(cid:104)g + (cid:88) Nc(cid:88) (cid:88) j=1 n + + (cid:18) n ωn 15 k: Jjk(ω) = π(cid:88) n δ(ω − ωn)ω2 ngj,ngj,k . (22) For practical calculations, it is convenient to decompose the spectral density into the sum of contributions from the intramolecular vibrational modes of the given chro- mophore itself and those of the environments. It is rea- sonable to assume that the former is local to each site excitation state in general. Thus, Eq. (22) can be de- composed into Jjk(ω) = J c j (ω)δjk + J r jk(ω) . (23) The reorganization energy of the bath upon the creation of each site excitation is thus given by λj = λc j + λr j , where (cid:90) ∞ (cid:90) ∞ 0 0 λc j = λr j = 1 π 1 π J c j (ω) ω J r j (ω) ω , . dω dω B. Electronic structure calculation 1. Excitation energies (24) (25) (26) The EBH for LHC given by Eq. (20) or (21) serves as an efficient framework for describing excitons in LHCs, and can be used for practical calculations even for large aggregates of many interacting pigments by keeping the computational cost limited (Curutchet and Mennucci, 2017). Moreover, as the cost is mainly due to the calcu- lation of localized excitations, accurate quantum chemi- cal methods can in principle be used within this model. However, even with this simplification, typically large molecular dimensions of the pigments present in natural LHCs (around 50-60 heavy atoms) prevent routine use of highly accurate methods such as ab initio multi-reference or coupled-cluster methods. A good compromise between cost and accuracy is rep- resented by the Density Functional Theory (DFT) and its excited-state extension, commonly known as Time- Dependent (TD) DFT. Beside its computational effi- ciency, this approach has two main limitations, (i) to be highly sensitive to the selected functional and (ii) to be a single-reference description. The first issue is particu- larly relevant for excitations that have a (partial) charge- transfer character. TD-DFT is in fact well known to be inaccurate in those cases due to its intrinsic limit, com- monly known as "self-interaction error"; this arises from the spurious interaction of an electron with itself in the Coulomb term of the DFT Hamiltonian, which is not ex- actly canceled by the exchange contribution, e.g., as in the Hartree-Fock (HF) approach. More recently, functionals which introduce range sep- aration into the exchange component and replace the long-range portion of the approximate exchange by the HF counterpart, have been proposed to correct this error (Tsuneda and Hirao, 2014). By using these long-range corrected functionals, CT-like transitions can be semi- quantitatively described at TD-DFT level. The second issue, namely of being a single-reference approach, is in- stead particularly relevant for excitations in long conju- gated systems such as carotenoids. In those systems, in fact, a multi-reference approach is compulsory if a cor- rect evaluation of the different ("dark" and "bright") ex- cited states is needed. For such systems, good perfor- mances have been shown by the multi-reference exten- sion of DFT, known as DFT/MRCI approach (Andreussi et al., 2015; Grimme and Waletzke, 1999; Kleinschmidt et al., 2009). The optimal electronic structure calculation method for LHCs should not only give accurate excitation ener- gies for the different pigments, but should also provide correct description of the variation of the electronic den- sity upon excitation and the transition density. The for- mer is required for accurate evaluation of excited state properties such as the geometrical gradients, which are used for calculating relaxed geometries and the coupling between electronic and nuclear degrees of freedom (see below). The latter (transition density) determines not only the transition dipole corresponding to a selected excitation but also the inter-pigment interactions defin- ing the electronic coupling, Jjk (see below). These re- quirements on the electronic densities largely limit the range of methods that can be used safely. For exam- ple, many semi-empirical approaches, which have been largely used in the past, should be used with care. In fact, by construction (e.g. by parameterization), they often give correct excitation energies but this does not mean that the corresponding transition densities are cor- rect as well. Moreover, only by chance, they could give a reliable description of the variation of the electronic den- sity upon excitation, as excited state properties are not used in their parameterization. Once more, at present, TD-DFT represents the only feasible approach available in most cases even if the same two limitations, (i) and (ii), mentioned in regard to the excitation energies also apply for excited state densities and transition densities. As a matter of fact, some DFT functionals can give quite accurate transition energies but may completely fail in correctly describing the change in the electronic den- sity upon excitation. In general, transition densities are known to be less sensitive to errors of the DFT functional than excited state densities (Munoz-Losa et al., 2008). However, benchmark data should always be used to be fully confident about the selected functional. Another as- 16 pect that should be preliminarily checked before selecting an electronic structure calculation method is the robust- ness with respect to the change of geometry. Some calcu- lation methods, especially those based on semi-empirical formulation, can behave very differently if the molecular system is out of the minimum region of the potential en- ergy surface. For pigment molecules in LHCs, significant deviations from the minimum geometry are possible due to the temperature-dependent effects and/or to geomet- rical constraints due to the protein matrix. Indeed, this is a very important aspect to consider when selecting a reliable electronic structure calculation method. In this respect, at present, systematic studies providing satis- factory references are not available to the extent of our knowledge. 2. Electronic couplings The electronic coupling Jjk in Eq. (1), (20), or (21) is a key quantity determining both the dynamics and the mechanism of exciton transfer. The magnitude of the electronic coupling, compared to the exciton-phonon in- teractions, determines whether states localized on differ- ent sites are mixed to generate delocalized exciton states. An accurate computation of the electronic coupling is thus necessary not only to predict the rates of energy transfer processes, but also to determine their mecha- nism. As shown in Eq. (17), Jjk consists of two terms, one direct interaction term between chromophores, J c jk jk(cid:105). Here- and the other environmental contribution, (cid:104) J r after, we denote this latter contribution simply as J r kj. Thus, Eq. (17) can be expressed as Jjk = J c jk + J r jk . (27) Within the derivation of Appendix A, the direct elec- tronic coupling between chromophores J c jk is defined by generalizations of Eqs. (A35) and (A28) that include the implicit effect of environments as well. Following the convention, this can also be expressed as (cid:90) J c jk = (28) drdr(cid:48)ρtr∗ j (r)ρtr e2 k (r(cid:48)) r − r(cid:48) , k (r(cid:48)) = ρ10 j (r) = ρ01 j (r) and ρtr k (r(cid:48)), transi- where ρtr∗ tion densities of chromophores j and k including the implicit effects of environments. Thus, this represents the Coulomb coupling between de-excitation of the jth chromophore and the excitation of the kth chromophore within the given LHC. More generally, additional terms due to exchange interactions and overlap between or- bitals of different chromophores should be included. This is missing in Eq. (28) because it has been assumed that electrons from different chromophores are distin- guishable and have zero overlap. For most LHCs, the inter-chromophore distances are far enough to make the Coulomb term by far the most dominant one. The ap- proximation of Eq. (28) is well justified under such con- dition. Of course, short-range non-Coulomb interactions are not always negligible. For example, contributions originating from charge-transfer states were shown to make modest contribution to the nearest-neighbor cou- plings in the B850 unit of LH2 (Scholes et al., 1999) and to constitute significant portion of the interaction be- tween the special pairs of purple bacteria and PS1 (Mad- jet et al., 2009), where the BChls are closely packed to- gether. The simplest but still widely used approximation for the Coulomb coupling is to use the expansion of the tran- sition densities up to dipolar terms, which leads to the following point transition dipole approximation: J c,dp jk = µj · µk r3 jk − 3(µj · rjk)(µk · rjk) r5 jk , (29) where rjk is the distance vector between pigments j and k, and µj and µk are the corresponding electronic tran- sition dipole moments. The dipolar term given by Eq. (29) yields the well known r−3 jk asymptotic dependence of the singlet elec- tronic coupling. Where applicable, the dipole approxi- mation has the clear advantage of only needing experi- mental data, namely the transition dipole moments and the distance between the centers of pigment molecules, provided that the orientation of the transition dipole mo- ments is known. For this reason, the dipole approxi- mation has been widely employed (Adolphs and Renger, 2006; Damjanovi´c et al., 2002; Georgakopoulou et al., 2002; Jang et al., 2001; Wan et al., 2014). However, par- ticular care should be taken in using the approximation because it can result in significant error in the estima- tion of the Coulomb coupling between proximate pigment molecules. For example, this is the case for the electronic couplings between the nearest neighbor BChl molecules in the B850 unit of LH2 complex and for the two central bilins of PBPs of cryptophyte algae. On the other hand, for FMO complex, the transition dipole approximation serves as reasonable approximation for all the electronic couplings. Another widely used method to compute J c jk is based on the projection of the transition densities onto atomic transition charges (TrCh). The Coulomb coupling is then computed as the electrostatic interaction between those charges: (cid:88) n∈j m∈k J c,TrCh jk = qn qm rnm , (30) where the indices n and m run over the atoms of j and k, respectively, qn and qm are the transition charges of atoms n and m, and rnm is the distance between them. Atomic transition charges with various definitions have 17 been used for a long time to compute Coulomb couplings (Carbonera et al., 1999; Chang, 1977; Duffy et al., 2013). Arguably, a definition of atomic charges that is physi- cally accurate and adequate for electrostatic interaction is the one based on electrostatic potential (ESP) fitting. The calculation of the Coulomb coupling with transi- tion ESP charges (TrEsp) was developed by Renger and coworkers (Madjet et al., 2006), and represents now a widely used method (Kenny and Kassal, 2016; Olbrich and Kleinekathofer, 2010; van der Vegte et al., 2015). The Coulomb coupling can also be obtained by directly evaluating the integral, Eq. (28). The first calculation of this kind was developed by using a numerical integration over a three-dimensional grid (Krueger et al., 1998). This numerical approach is called the Transition Density Cube (TDC) method, and in principle gives the exact Coulomb contribution of the electronic coupling with an appropri- ately chosen grid. The TDC method has been employed extensively (Bricker and Lo, 2014, 2015; Scholes, 2003; Scholes and Fleming, 2000; Scholes et al., 1999). How- ever, more reliable and efficient approach is to perform the integration of Eq. (28) analytically. This also allows the inclusion of explicit screening of the Coulomb inter- action due to the environment (Curutchet et al., 2009; Hsu et al., 2001a; Iozzi et al., 2004). The coupling is also significantly affected by the presence of the environment surrounding the pigments. While for site energies, environment effects are generally seen as a shift depending on the nature of the transi- tion and the characteristic of the environment, the elec- tronic couplings are affected through two mechanisms, each leading to a specific change. First of all, the environment can change both the ge- ometrical and the electronic structure of the pigment molecules and modify their transition properties, i.e. transition dipoles and transition densities. These changes will be "implicitly" reflected in a change of the Coulomb coupling which will be generally enhanced. The second effect is due to the polarizable nature of the environment which acts as a mediator of the pigments' excitations. The resulting "explicit" effect acts to reduce the magni- tude of the direct (Coulomb) coupling. For this reason it is common to say that the coupling is "screened" by the environment. jk, where J c The simplest way to account for the explicit effect of the environment is to introduce a screening factor s such that Jjk = sJ c jk is the direct electronic coupling between chromophores with the implicit effect taken into consideration. This definition is in line with the standard definition of dielectric screening by environ- ment in electromagnetism but may not always be easy to determine. In practice, one may introduce a total screen- ing factor st such that Jjk = stJ c,0 jk is the bare electronic coupling between chromophores without including the implicit effect. The difference between s and st can be significant, and care should be taken in jk , where J c,0 using the proper definition. More discussion of this issue will be provided later. The screening factor s can be clearly related to the inverse of an effective dielectric constant ∞ which repre- sents the electronic response of the environment approxi- mated as a dielectric. ∞ is generally approximated with the square of the refractive index of the medium: when the environment is characterized by a refractive index of 1.4 (typical for hydrophobic region of protein environ- ments) the screening factor is ∼ 0.5 and the electronic coupling is reduced by a factor ∼ 4. Within this approx- imation, the screening does not depend on the interact- ing chromophores, neither on their relative orientation and distance. Moreover, at short distances, the dielectric medium can be excluded from the intermolecular region, leading to more complex effects. In particular cases, this can also enhance the coupling. To achieve a more accurate modeling of the environ- mental effects on electronic couplings, a combination of a quantum mechanical description of the pigments with a continuum model can be introduced. Various formula- tions of continuum solvation models (Tomasi et al., 2005) can be used to this end. By applying the polarizable con- tinuum model (PCM) (Mennucci, 2012) described in Ap- pendix B, the response of the environment (i.e. the polar- ization of the dielectric) is described by a set of induced (or apparent) charges spreading on the surface of the molecular cavity embedding the chromophores. Within this framework, J r jk becomes: J r,PCM jk = drρtr∗ j (r) 1 r − rt qt(∞; ρtr k ) (31) (cid:20)(cid:90) (cid:88) t (cid:21) jk)/J c jk +J r Conceptually, the electronic transition in the chro- mophore k drives a response in the polarizable medium, which in turn, affects the transition in the chromophore j. It is important to note that the induced charges qt are calculated using the optical permittivity of the medium, in order to account for the fact that only the electronic component of the polarization can respond. Also in this case, we can define an effective screening factor as the ra- tio between the total coupling and the direct interaction, namely s = (J c jk. A QM/PCM study has been conducted to investigate the dependence of the screening factor on the nature of the interacting chromophores and their relative arrangement, using different pairs (chloro- phylls, carotenoids and bilins) extracted from LHCs (Sc- holes et al., 2007). It has been shown that at large inter- chromophore separation ( > 2 nm ) the screening factor is practically constant. At closer distances, instead, the screening shows an exponential behavior approaching to ∼ 1 for distances of the order of few tenths of nanome- ter. At such close distance, the chromophores share a common cavity in the medium (the environment cannot access the region where the two chromophores are at close contact) and the screening effect is reduced. 18 jk/J c,0 As noted above, the scaling factor s accounts for only the explicit screening. On the other hand, the environment can also affect the transition densities of chromophores, causing implicit change of electronic cou- plings, which we call here si. A detailed analysis of si = J c jk was reported in detail in a follow-up paper (Curutchet et al., 2007), which showed that it is not pos- sible to define a similar empirical expression for si as has been done for s. The total empirical screening factor we defined earlier is given by st = s· si. In general, it cannot be fitted by a simple function of the distance. Thus, care should be taken in estimating the distance dependence of the total screening factor. An alternative way to account for environment effect in the coupling, is through the so-called Poisson-TrEsp method developed by Renger an coworkers (Adolphs et al., 2008; Renger and Muh, 2011). The TrEsp charges of the pigments are placed in molecule-shaped cavities that are surrounded by a homogeneous dielectric with a dielectric constant, which represents the optical permit- tivity of the protein and solvent environments. A Poisson equation is then solved for the electrostatic potential of the TrEsp of each pigment and the resulting potential is finally used to calculate the coupling. Despite the success of these continuum approaches, an atomistic description of the protein environment is ex- pected to give a more complete description. In those cases, in fact, the dielectric response varies locally and specific interactions between the chromophores and the protein can be established. A classical formulation can still be used by introducing a Molecular Mechanics (MM) description in which each atom of the environment is rep- resented by a fixed point charge to mimic the electrostatic effects. In order to properly account for all the environ- mental effects, however, the MM model has also to be po- larizable. Various strategies are possible (see Appendix B). In the context of LHCs, the most used approach is represented by the induced dipole (ID) formulation where an atomic polarizability is added to the fixed charge to describe each atom of the environment. Within this MM- Pol framework, the J r jk term becomes (Curutchet et al., 2009): (cid:20)(cid:90) = −(cid:88) p J r,MMPol jk (cid:21) drρtr∗ j (r) (rp − r) rp − r3 µp(ρtr k ) (32) where the transition densities ρtr k induce a response in the environment which is represented by the induced dipoles µp. As in the case of the QM/PCM, ρtr k here is also calculated self consistently with the polarization of the environment. A mixed continuum/atomistic strategy has also been proposed (Caprasecca et al., 2012): in this case, jk is the sum of J r,PCM J r , and both terms are obtained in a fully polarizable scheme. and J r,MMPol jk jk As a cautionary remark, we note that, in the case of any atomistic description, the QM-environment interac- tions, particularly those at short range, depend critically on the configuration of the environment. Therefore, sev- eral configurations of the whole system need to be taken into consideration to get a correct sampling. Commonly, the sampling is obtained by using classical Molecular Dy- namics (MD). This sampling is not needed when a con- tinuum approach is employed since it implicitly gives a configurationally averaged effect due to the use of macro- scopic properties. A completely alternative way for the calculation of the electronic coupling between two sites is that based on a full quantum calculation on the dimeric unit, which is also known as super-molecule approach. These schemes are based on the diabatization of the electronic Hamilto- nian of the whole donor-acceptor system, and in principle yield the "exact" coupling including exchange and over- lap interactions within the electronic structure method used (Hsu, 2009; You and Hsu, 2014). Consider a molecular system composed of two moi- eties, which can be either two separate molecules or two fragments of the same molecule. An electronic structure calculation on the entire system necessarily yields the adi- abatic states, which are the eigenstates of the electronic Hamiltonian at a specific nuclear geometry. However, a diabatic picture better describes the states involved in en- ergy transfer. Within this picture, the electronic Hamil- tonian is written in a basis of localized states, and is not diagonal. For example, considering only two states, the Hamiltonian matrix reads as follows: (cid:18) Ej Jjk (cid:19) Jjk Ek Hel = , (33) where Ej and Ek are the energies of the diabatic states, and Jjk is the electronic coupling between those states. At the avoided crossing point, the condition Ej = Ek means that the energy gap between the adiabatic states is 2Jjk. Therefore, Jjk may be computed as half of the energy gap. Obviously, this condition holds at all ge- ometries when the two fragments are identical. In more general cases, a localization scheme is needed to define the diabatic states, and to find the transformation matrix between adiabatic and diabatic bases. There is no unique choice for the diabatic states, the choice of which also can alter the definitions of Coulomb and exchange interactions (Vura-Weis et al., 2010). Sev- eral schemes have been proposed, such as the fragment excitation difference (FED) (Hsu et al., 2008) or the more recent fragment transition difference (FTD) scheme (Voityuk, 2014). Within this framework, an additional operator (which we shall call Y ), representing an observ- able that has its extrema in the diabatic states, is intro- duced; Y can be defined in such a way that it has eigen- values 0 and ±1. The localized states are therefore those states that diagonalize Y . The eigenvectors of the matrix Y form the unitary matrix transformation U (i.e., U†YU is diagonal), which is the adiabatic-to-diabatic (ATD) 19 transformation, within the assumption that the two adi- abatic states are a linear combination of the localized states of interest. By applying the same transformation to the diagonal energy matrix, one can obtain the Hamil- tonian in the diabatic basis, and the electronic coupling Jjk as the off-diagonal elements. Namely, Jjk = (Ek − Ej) (cid:113) Yjk (Yj − Yk)2 + 4Y 2 jk . (34) Applying the transformation U to the adiabatic states yields states that are localized as much as possible, and similar to the initial and final states. However, in many cases, a 2-state adiabatic basis is not sufficient to re- trieve completely localized states. In fact, an adiabatic state could be a combination of many diabatic states of both the donor and the acceptor. Moreover, charge- transfer states can mix with excitonic states, and vice- versa (Voityuk, 2013; Yang and Hsu, 2013; You and Hsu, 2014). Another issue with the 2-state model is its in- ability to compute the couplings between states that are more weakly coupled. To overcome these limits, one can resort to a multi-state formulation. The generalization to a multi-state model is not straightforward, as the ad- ditional operators only have three different eigenvalues (0 or ±1). This means that the diagonalization of these operators will only separate the adiabatic basis in three subspaces, and therefore there is no unique choice for the transformation U from the adiabatic to the diabatic basis. C. Applications of electronic structure calculations to LHCs We present here a summary of three computational studies aimed at understanding the molecular origin of the protein tuning of the excitonic properties of three LHCs introduced earlier, the FMO complex of green sul- fur bacteria, LH2 complex of purple bacteria, and phy- coerythrin PE545 of cryptophyte algae. 1. FMO complex As mentioned in the overview of Sec. II, the spectral features in FMO arise from the subtle tuning of the indi- vidual site energies due to the surrounding protein envi- ronment. To shed light on this effect, the environment- induced changes in the site energies were analyzed in de- tail using the combination of TDDFT and different clas- sical models based either on the atomistic or continuum descriptions (Jurinovich et al., 2014). The trimeric crystal structure of Prosthecochloris aes- tuarii (pdb entry 3EOJ, res. 1.30 A), which contains eight BChl per monomer, was used (Tronrud et al., 2009). Considering the C3 symmetry of the system, the QM analysis was performed only on the monomer system shown in Figure 3. The corresponding excitation ener- gies of BChl were computed at the TD-B3LYP/6-31G(d) level of theory, the results of which are shown in Fig. 9. FIG. 9 Site energies (eV) of the eight BChls computed on the crystal structure with three different models: the Full model (full line and circles) includes all BChl atoms, the Truncated model (dotted line and triangles) does not include the atoms of the phythyl chain, the Tail@MMPol model (diamonds) de- scribes the atoms of the phythyl chain as MMPol sites. Inset: Structure of BChl 1 for which the chain is folded in a confor- mation capable of interacting with the porphyrin ring. In FMO complex, like in other LHCs, each pigment is confined in a specific binding pocket, surrounded by the protein matrix, which may perturb the pigment's ex- citation through two distinct effects: 1) a direct effect on the electronic states determined by pigment-protein interactions; 2) an indirect effect due to the modifica- tions induced by the environment on the geometry of the pigment. The effect of this can be seen clearly in the results of calculations: if the direct environmental effects are switched off, the resulting site energies are still differ- ent for the different BChls due to the indirect effects on geometries induced by the local environment. In particu- lar, the isolated BChl has a planar equilibrium structure (excluding the flexible phythyl chain). However, when embedded in the protein environment, such planarity be- comes perturbed differently in different binding pockets. The phythyl chain of BChl also plays a role in differ- entiating the excitation energy through variation in its conformations. According to the crystal structure, all the chains adopt an outstretched configuration, except for BChl 1 and 4, for which the chain is folded in a con- formation capable of interacting with the porphyrin ring (see Figure 9). To investigate these effects, site energy calculations were performed using the crystallographic 20 structure of the pigments and 1) including all the BChl atoms at full quantum mechanical level calculations, 2) replacing the phythyl chain with a methyl group but still treated at the full quantum level, and 3) replacing the entire phythyl chain with classical polarizable MM sites through the MMPol approach (tail@MMPol). In this last model, the boundary between the QM and the classical subsystem was treated by using the link atom scheme. The results shown in Figure 9 reveal that, when the phythyl chain is close to the porphyrin ring (BChl 1 and 4), the site energy is lowered, as if it introduces an "additional environmental" effect not present in the other pigments. This effect seems to be largely due to a classical electrostatic and polarization interaction. In fact, when the chain is treated at MMPol level, a similar lowering of the energy is observed, albeit not as large as in the full QM description. An important question concerning the role of protein environments in tuning the excitation energies of pigment molecules is the relative importance of specific molecu- lar level interactions versus mean-field (or bulk) effects. This issue can be analyzed through detailed and careful analysis of the two contributions. As an example, val- ues of excitation energies for 1 through 7 BChl molecules obtained either with the atomistic (MMPol) or the con- tinuum (PCM) model are compared in Figure 10. BChl 8 is excluded from this analysis because of the exter- nal location of its binding site, being more exposed to the solvent. This is manifested in drastic difference be- tween PCM and MMPol descriptions of the environment, in particular when the MMPol model is based on the crystal structure and does not contain surrounding wa- ter molecules. FIG. 10 Site energies (eV) for the 1-7 BChls computed on the crystal structure including the environment effects at PCM (dotted line) and MMPol level (full line). A third (me)QM/PCM model combining PCM with a QM descrip- tion of the interacting residues is also shown (dashed line). As described in the previous section, the PCM model describes the bulk effect of the environment through an effective dielectric constant, which corresponds to a re- sponse averaged over many different configurations of the environment. It is evident that when some specific or directional interactions are present (i.e. H-bond or co- ordination bonds), their effects cannot be accounted for in such an "average over the medium" model. A practi- cal solution for this deficiency is to enlarge the definition of the quantum mechanical subsystem being in the di- electric medium by including not only the pigment but also its proximate protein residues. Through this mini- mal environment (so called "me") approach, the effects of short-range interactions can be taken into account within the PCM model. The between comparison QM/PCM and (me)QM/PCM shows very similar energies for BChls 2 and 5. These two BChls have weaker axial interactions (a water molecule for BChl 2 and a carbonyl group belonging to the protein backbone for BChl 5) with respect to the other pigments, which are coordinated with the nitrogen of a histidine residue. In the lat- ter cases, the site energies are red-shifted by about 160 cm−1 when including the QM residues. In principle, the QM/MMPol description should be able to describe both the bulk effect of the protein and the specific electrostatic interactions of the closer residues. Indeed, the QM/MMPol and the (me)QM/PCM site energies are in good agreement for all pigments except for BChl 6. It has to be also noted that, for such a pigment, a positively charged residue (an arginine) directly interacts with the side group of the porphyrin ring. In this case, the description of this residue at a QM level allows to include non classical interactions (such as possible charge transfers) between the BChl and the protein, which can significantly affect the electronic excitation. In summary, the inclusion of the interaction with the protein environment results in a redshift of the excita- tion energies of BChls in the FMO complex, but in ways depending on different local environments. Thus, a sim- ple continuum model alone is not able to properly ac- count for both short and long-range environmental ef- fects. This point is also supported by a detailed electro- static analysis of the site energy funnel in FMO (Muh et al., 2007), which showed that the electric field from the α-helices defines the direction of excitation energy flow in the FMO protein, whereas the effects of amino acid side chains largely compensate each other. Thus, it is important to have a complete and balanced picture of the fine tuning by protein environments in order to characterize the FMO complex properly. An effective and still practical way for this is to include the residues more strongly interacting with the pigments in the defi- nition of the QM subsystem, while keeping a continuum description for the rest. Nonclassical short-range effects can in fact have a non-negligible contribution to the pat- 21 tern of BChl excitation energies in the FMO complex. In addition, the BChl phythyl chain can play a subtle but significant role, given the small differences found in the energies of the pigments. In particular, the largest effects are found when a folded conformation close to the porphyrin ring is possible, such as for BChl 1 and 4. The effects of the tail can be explained as a combination of overlap interaction at the quantum level and electrostatic plus polarization at purely classical level. It is worthwhile to note that the latter components can be recovered by using an MMPol description of the chain. 2. LH2 The early atomistic level calculations (Hsu et al., 2001b; Hu et al., 2002, 1997; Krueger et al., 1998) were based on the X-ray crystal structures (Koepke et al., 1996; McDermott et al., 1995) and focused on calculating electronic coupling constants between excitations. The outcomes of these calculations, in combination with em- pirical correction factors to complement numerical errors, laid the foundation for many exciton models that fol- lowed. In addition, already in 2002, all atomistic MD simulation of LH2 complex was shown to be feasible (Damjanovi´c et al., 2002), providing the basis for more recent advances (Cupellini et al., 2016; Jang et al., 2015; Montemayor et al., 2018; Olbrich and Kleinekathofer, 2010; Sisto et al., 2017). In this section, some of the out- comes of these recent computational studies for the LH2 antenna complex of Rps. acidophila are summarized. QM/MM calculations (Cupellini et al., 2016) have been performed using (i) the crystal structure resolved at 2.0 A (PDB code: 1NKZ) (Papiz et al., 2003) and (ii) the configurations extracted from a room-temperature sam- pling, carried out through an MD simulation of the LH2 complex within a solvated lipid membrane. Environmen- tal effects on the calculations of the excitonic parameters have been introduced in terms of the polarizable (MM- Pol) embedding combined with a TD-DFT description based on the CAM-B3LYP functional and the 6-31G(d) basis set. The comparison of a "static" description using a single crystal structure with a "dynamic" one includ- ing structural and electronic fluctuations of the pigments coupled to electrostatic and polarization fluctuations of the environment, allows detailed and molecular-level in- vestigation of the key factors contributing to the charac- teristics of excitons and their changes in temperature. For the case of the dynamic model, a different Hamil- tonian matrix was calculated for each of the 88 config- urations extracted from the MD simulation and the re- sulting "instantaneous" excitonic parameters were finally averaged to be compared with those obtained on the sin- gle crystal structure. Indeed, the two sets of data show significant differences. The B850 exciton splitting de- creases from 1517 to 1275 cm−1 (-16%) moving from the static description based on the crystal structure to that based on the MD simulation, which is consistent with experimental variation between low and room tempera- ture Davydov splittings (-13%) (Pajusalu et al., 2011b). This behavior is also reflected on the absorption spec- trum, where the B850 band blue shifts when the tem- perature is increased, whereas the B800 peak does not shift (Trinkunas et al., 2012). These results suggest that the B850 blue shift is mainly due to a reduction of the inter-pigment couplings. In addition, the site energy dif- ference between B800 and B850 pigments is also reduced on average by ∼50 cm−1 in the calculation based on the MD simulation. The static and the dynamic models also give different descriptions of the environment effects. Using the crys- tal structure, the inclusion of the MMPol environment causes a redshift of the BChls' excitations of ∼880 cm−1, with small differences among the different pigment types (< 25 cm−1). A red shift is also obtained for the struc- tures coming from the MD trajectory. However, in this case, the shift in the excitation energies of α and β BChls of the B850 unit is about 830 cm−1, whereas the shift for B800 is only 610 cm−1. When considered within the ap- proximation of transition dipole moments, an interesting environment effect can be observed with respect to their orientations. In both models, the environment does not affect the out-of-plane tilt, but it has a non-negligible in- fluence on the in-plane tilt. The changes are almost the same for α and β BChls of the B850 unit. The different features that can be found between the two static and dynamic models are well reflected in the exciton delocalization. There are various measures of ex- citon delocalization (Dahlbom et al., 2001; Jang et al., 2001), and a well-known measure is the following inverse participation ratio (IPR): (cid:34) (cid:104)(cid:88) (cid:35)−1 L IPR D = (Ujk)4(cid:105) (35) k IPR where Ujk is the unitary transformation as defined above Eq. (3), j is the index for each exciton state, k is the in- dex for each site excitation state, and (cid:104)···(cid:105) represents averaging over all exciton states with proper thermal D ranges from 1, for a fully weights. By definition, L localized state, to the number of total sites for a com- pletely delocalized state. Due to the CN symmetry (with N = 8−10) of the LH2 complex, in the absence of disorder, the exciton states are all doubly degenerate with the exception of the lowest energy exciton states for both the B850 and B800 units (plus the highest exciton state for B850 with odd N ). In such a perfectly symmetric arrangement for N = 9, for example, the delocalization lengths are maximum 18 (9) for the non degenerate states of the B850 (B800) unit, and 12 (6) for the doubly degenerate states. The cal- culations in the static model indeed give delocalization 22 lengths which are close to the maximum values, even in the B800 unit, despite small electronic couplings between BChls. Instead, adding disorder in the BChls' site ener- gies through the dynamic model results in a localization of the excitons with a general reduction of L D . In the B850 unit, the large couplings allow the exciton to remain delocalized even in the presence of disorder but with a significant reduction of L D to an average value of typi- cally 8±2. On the contrary, in the B800 ring the average delocalization length reduces to ∼ 1.4. IPR IPR Although LIPR D is a well established measure of delocal- ization, its physical implication in the partially delocal- ized regime is not always clear. For this reason, different measures of delocalization length have been tested, which have different degrees of sensitivity (Dahlbom et al., 2001; Jang et al., 2001). For example, a simple alter- native measure can be defined as follows: jk}(cid:105) . D = (cid:104)(cid:88) min{1, NcU 2 (36) JDS L k IPR This measure does not give a weight more than one for D while approaching the same values each site unlike L in both full localized and delocalized limits. For the B850 unit (Jang et al., 2001), this measure was shown to be D to the nature of the disorder and more sensitive than L also results in larger estimate of delocalization length. IPR The computational results obtained for both the single crystal structure and MD configuration can also be used to simulate the circular dichroism (CD) spectrum of LH2. The CD spectrum represents a fingerprint that is unique for each LHC as it is determined by the nature of the excitons and the geometrical characteristics of the aggre- gate of pigments. Figure 11 compares the two calculated CD spectra with those measured at low (77K) and room temperature. In the case of the dynamic model based on the MD simulation, the spectrum reported in Fig. 11 is the average of the instantaneous spectra obtained for each of the 88 configurations. The experimental CD spectrum is characterized by two "couplets" corresponding to the excitonic signal due to the B800 and B850 ring, respectively. Due to the in- crease of the temperature (from 77 K to room temper- ature) both the broadening and the relative intensities of the couplets change. In particular, the B800 positive band almost vanishes. The CD spectrum is sensitive to the inter-ring coupling, and the B850 couplet borrows in- tensity from the B800 band. The small B800–B850 mix- ing happens despite the site energy differences and the static disorder, and breaks the symmetry of the B800 and B850 couplets. The only way to reproduce the asymmet- rical B800 couplet is to consider some B800–B850 mixing. Unlike the spectrum obtained from the crystal structure, here the B800 couplet amplitude is nearly half of the B850 couplet. This can be explained as an effect due to the disorder in excitation energy of each BChl, combined with the small intra–B800 coupling. 23 ble multi-configurational character of ground and excited states of the pigments can lead to new insights with re- spect to DFT-based investigations, as it has been shown by recent ab initio multi-reference calculations on bac- teriochlorophylls and carotenoids of LH2 (Anda et al., 2016; Segatta et al., 2017). 3. PE545 The effect of the protein (and the surrounding sol- vent) on the excitonic properties of PE545 has been in- vestigated through QM/MMPol calculations for a series of structures extracted from a classical MD simulation of the LHC in water at room temperature (Curutchet et al., 2011b). The QM/MMPol results were comple- mented with those based on a continuum (PCM) descrip- tion of the protein and water environment. The compar- ison between the two sets of calculations can in fact be used to show how the heterogeneous properties of the protein can modify the local screening of the electronic couplings between the bound pigments. MMPol results were averaged over 140 configurations of PE545 and wa- ter molecules extracted from the MD simulation, whereas PCM results were obtained using the cluster of the pig- ments as found in the ultrahigh resolution crystal struc- ture of the complex. In all cases, the first low-lying π−π∗ excited state of the 8 bilins were computed together with all the corresponding electronic couplings between them. The full transition densities of the pigments were used for these calculations employing Eqs. (28), (31), and (32). A comprehensive set of calculation results performed at the CIS/6-31G level are available (Curutchet et al., 2011b). The heterogeneous nature of the protein environment can significantly modulate the coupling through both changes in the transition density of each pigment and in the extent of screening of the corresponding interactions. In the QM/MMPol approach, both effects are included in the coupling term by considering both interchromophore distances and orientations, as well as the heterogeneous polarization of the protein and solvent environment. For more quantitative understanding, it is useful to compare the screening factor (and a related effective permittivity) defined differently for each pair j and k as follows: sjk = 1 jk = jk + J r,MMPol J c jk J c jk , (37) where J c jk is the Coulomb interaction given by Eq. (28), which includes the implicit effect of the environment on transition densities, whereas J r,MMPol is the explicit MM- Pol term as described in Eq. (32). jk As illustrated in Figure 12, PCM values of jk are sim- ilar for all pairs while MMPol values present a significant spread (from 2.6 to 1.2). On the other hand, PCM and MMPol values become very similar when averaged over FIG. 11 Upper Panel: The crystal structure used in the static model (left) and examples of configurations extracted from MD used in the dynamic model (right) of LH2. Lower panel: (left) measured CD spectra at 77 K (dotted line) and room temperature (full line) and (right) calculated TDDFT/MMPol spectra using the static (dotted line) and the dynamic model (full line). The modeling of the CD spectra suggests the static and the dynamic models can be effectively used to rep- resent LH2 in two different situations, namely, at zero- temperature limit and at room temperature. The main features of the CD spectra and their temperature depen- dence are in fact well reproduced. Moreover, this analysis indicates that the difference in the exciton structure of LH2 at low and room temperatures are mainly related to fluctuations in the relative orientations of the BChls (and of the corresponding couplings), rather than changes in the ring size as was previously suggested (Pajusalu et al., 2011b). Despite impressive advances as described above and recent demonstration of the capability of on the fly cal- culations (Sisto et al., 2017), further improvements in accuracy and efficiency are still needed. Some of key issues to be addressed in this respect include the differ- ences in the excitation energies of α-, β-, and γ-BChls, solvatochromic shift due to hydrogen bonding, and con- tribution of carotenoids. Although some of the early ex- citon models based on the X-ray crystal structure sug- gested that (Rancova et al., 2012) α- and β-BChls have about 300 cm−1 difference in their excitation energies, QM/MM calculations for configurations extracted from MD simulation showed that the two energies are virtually the same in actual protein environments (Cupellini et al., 2016). Combination of MD simulation and DFT cal- culations also demonstrated that hydrogen bonding can cause red shift of excitation energies by about 500 cm−1 or larger (Jang et al., 2015; Montemayor et al., 2018). Moreover, accounting for the contribution of the possi- all pairs. The agreement between averaged results can be explained through a careful analysis of the components of each model. In the continuum method, the screening is described in terms of a set of induced charges spreading on the surfaces of the cavities embedding the pigments. These charges represent the polarization of the environ- ment induced by the electronic transition in the donor. These are calculated in terms of the optical component of the dielectric permittivity used to represent the mixed protein-water environment (namely 2.0). In the MMPol approach, instead, the screening is calculated in terms of induced dipoles originating from the electronic transi- tion in the donor. Within this description, the induced dipoles are determined by the atomic polarizabilities used to mimic the protein (and the water) atoms. The latter, when used to simulate the macroscopic polarization of the whole environment, gives an effective permittivity of 2.3, which is very close to that used in the PCM model. The similarity between the continuum and the atomistic model, however, disappears when the pigment pairs are analyzed separately. Each of them in fact is expected to feel a different local environment determined by the vari- ety of residues, respectively presenting a different degree of polarization. FIG. 12 Effective dielectric constant corresponding to each pair (ik ) reported as a function of the interchromophore dis- tance: circles refer to the average QM/MMPol@MD data and squares to the QM/PCM calculations on the crystal struc- ture. The dotted line indicates the average value obtained on all MMPol@MD values. The two insets indicate the two pairs showing the smallest (DBV19A − DBV19B) and largest (PEB50/61C − PEB50/61D) ik value. The smallest effective permittivity (1.35) is experi- enced by the peripheral DBV19A-DBV19B pair. On the contrary, for the central PEB50/61C − PEB50/61D pair, the coupling is significantly more attenuated by the pro- tein than in other pairs and the resulting effective permit- tivity is the highest (2.57). To understand the origin of these differences, the screening obtained by the MMPol approach can be dissected into contributions arising from the different protein residues and waters. Examination of the central pair shows that all the polypeptide chains, together with waters, act to reduce the interaction, re- 24 sulting in a large screening effect. A completely different picture appears for the peripheral pair. In this case, it seems that the protein is organized in such a way as to enhance the electronic coupling while further effect of the surrounding water adds a strong screening contribution. D. Bath spectral density As represented by Eq. (23), the contribution to the bath modes for a molecule embedded in a flexible en- vironment can be classified into two different sources, one from the internal vibrations of the molecule and the other from the motions of the molecule within the envi- ronment. Conventionally, it is assumed that the internal vibrations constitute only high-frequency underdamped modes, which are reflected in sharp peaks of the spec- tral density. The low frequency intermolecular modes are often viewed as being induced entirely by the surround- ing environment, resulting in a continuous contribution to the spectral density. However, for the case of pig- ment molecules in LHCs, intramolecular vibrations are also shown to make significant contributions to the low frequency modes. Accurate determination of spectral densities Jjk(ω) of Eq. (22) is a difficult task in general, let alone confirm- ing the validity of the form of the HLHC as assumed in Eq. (21). For the case where there is only one pig- ment molecule, the corresponding spectral density can be determined experimentally using either spectral hole burning (SHB) or fluorescence line narrowing (FLN). The former removes inhomogeneity by burning specific zero- phonon transition and the latter by obtaining fluores- cence lineshape following excitation at the red edge of the ensemble absorption lineshape. Model spectral den- sities fitted to these experimental ones have been used for the construction of EBHs. A popular example of the model bath spectral density is the following Ohmic spectral density with Drude cutoff: JDrude (ω) = 2λ ω/ωc 1 + (ω/ωc)2 . (38) For this spectral density, the well-known choice of pa- rameters for the FMO complex is λ = 35 cm−1 and ωc = 106 cm−1. Although not as widely as in the case of the FMO complex, this spectral density was also used for the LH2 complex (Chen et al., 2009; Meier et al., 1997a; Zhang et al., 1998) with λ = 240 cm−1 and ωc = 40.8 cm−1 based on the fitting (Meier et al., 1997a) of photon-echo data (Jimenez et al., 1997). Another well-known form is the Ohmic or super-Ohmic spectral density with exponential cutoff. A combination of these forms were constructed for the B850 unit of the LH2 com- plex based on the fitting of fluorescence-line narrowing data as follows: JJN S (ω) = π (cid:18) γ1ωe−ω/ωc,1 + γ2 e−ω/ωc,2 ω2 ωc,2 (cid:33) +γ3 ω3 ω2 c,3 e−ω/ωc,3 , (39) with γ1 = 0.22, γ2 = 0.78, γ3 = 0.31, ωc,1 = 170 cm−1, ωc,2 = 34 cm−1, and ωc,3 = 69 cm−1. The above spec- tral density (or simpler version with only Ohmic term) was used for the modeling of low temperature SMS line- shapes (Jang and Silbey, 2003a; Jang et al., 2011; Kumar and Jang, 2013) and calculation of exciton transfer rates (Jang et al., 2014, 2004, 2007). Recently, more refined experimental technique called ∆-FLN, which combines the merits of SHB and FNL, was developed (Ratsep and Freiberg, 2007; Timpmann et al., 2000a) and applied to various LHCs (Kell et al., 2013; Pieper et al., 2011; Ratsep et al., 2008). In particu- lar, a recent analysis (Kell et al., 2013) suggested that low frequency region of the model Ohmic spectral density is not consistent with the experimental lineshape, propos- ing a new form with log-normal distribution in the low frequency limit. While this exposes a potential deficiency of conventional model spectral densities that typically as- sume algebraic behavior in the small frequency limit, it is not yet clear whether such log-normal distribution is an apparent effect of residual degree of inhomogeneity and anharmonic contribution of the bath. In addition, for general LHCs with more than one pigment molecules with similar excitation energies, it is not yet clear how even the ∆-FLN approach can accurately determine site- specific spectral densities represented by Eq. (22). Computational determination of the spectral densities are feasible, but are also beset with a few theoretical and practical issues. A well-known approach is to use a mixed quantum-classical approach assuming that the bath is classical, and to calculate the following bath en- ergy gap correlation function through classical MD simu- lation (Aghtar et al., 2013; Chandrasekaran et al., 2015; Olbrich et al., 2011b; Shim et al., 2012; Viani et al., 2014; Zwier et al., 2007): Ccl E,jk(t) = (cid:104)∆Ej(t)∆Ek(0)(cid:105)cl , (40) where ∆Ej(t) is the difference of the bath energy for sj(cid:105), which is created at time t = 0, and that for the ground electronic state. Assuming that this is related to the real part of the quantum correlation function of Bjk defined in Eq. (20), one can calculate the spectral density using the following relation (Olbrich et al., 2011b): Jjk(ω) = 2 tanh( βω 2 ) dt Ccl E,jk(t) cos(ωt) . (41) (cid:90) ∞ 0 On the other hand, if we rely on the approximation of Eq. (21) and introduce mass-weighted normal mode Qn such √ 2ω3/2 n gj,nQn, it is straightfor- 25 gj,ngk,nω3 n(cid:104)Qn(t)Qn(0)(cid:105)cl dω Jjk(ω) cos(ωt) ω . (42) that ωjgj,n(bn + b† ward to show that Ccl n) = E,jk(t) = 2(cid:88) (cid:90) ∞ (cid:90) ∞ 2 πβ Jjk(ω) = βω n 0 = 0 Then, through cosine transformation, dt Ccl E,jk(t) cos(ωt) . (43) While this becomes equivalent to Eq. (41) if the vibra- tional quanta of all the bath modes are smaller than ther- mal energy, the discrepancy between the two becomes substantial for high frequency vibrational modes. Given that harmonic oscillator approximation is more appropri- ate for high frequency modes, which result mostly from intramolecular vibration, Eq. (43), known as harmonic approximation, is considered more reliable than Eq. (41) in general (Chandrasekaran et al., 2017; Valleau et al., 2012). For the bath modes coming from protein envi- ronments, this may not be necessarily true because of anharmonic and nonlinear effects. Another important issue is that a long time window is required in order to achieve a complete sampling for low-frequency vibrations. For example, a vibration at ∼10 cm−1 has a period of ∼3 ps, requiring a sampling time window of at least 100 ps. Conversely, to sample in- tramolecular modes, one needs a rather short time step, i.e. ≤ 5 fs (Chandrasekaran et al., 2015; Shim et al., 2012; Valleau et al., 2012). These two opposing factors make the mixed approach computationally very expen- sive, requiring tenths of thousands of electronic structure calculations for a single spectral density. The most concerning issue of the mixed quantum- classical approach is the quality of the MD trajectory involved. In fact, an assumption of the spectral density approach is that the relevant dynamics come from the evolution of the energy gap dictated by the ground-state Hamiltonian. However, the dimensions of the systems under study and the time scales involved compel the nu- clear trajectory to be computed with a classical force field, i.e., using fitted parameters, whereas the energy gap is calculated with a quantum mechanical Hamilto- nian. The Hamiltonian used to propagate the nuclear positions may be critically different from the one used in the calculation of the energy gap, leading to an effec- tive excited-state PES that is completely different from the "real" quantum mechanical one. The ground-state PES could differ in equilibrium position, normal modes, and frequencies. All of these factors contribute to the shape of the spectral density (Kim et al., 2015; Lee et al., 2016; Zwier et al., 2007). Indeed, it has been observed that the resulting spectral density is strongly dependent on the force field parameters, rather than on the quan- tum mechanical Hamiltonian (Aghtar et al., 2013; Chan- drasekaran et al., 2015; Wang et al., 2015). For this reason, in order to effectively use the mixed quantum- classical method, one should carefully assess the quality of the force field parameters by comparing them to the quantum-mechanically calculated PES, and possibly de- velop ad-hoc parameters specifically designed for subse- quent excitation energy calculations (Prandi et al., 2016). Another well-established approach to the calculation of spectral densities is the direct calculation of Huang- Rhys factors from the gradient of the excited-state PES at the ground-state equilibrium geometry. The peaks of the spectral density can be broadened by gaussian or Lorentzian functions in order to take into account the finite vibrational lifetime and the inhomogeneous distri- bution of vibrational frequencies (Lee et al., 2016). Usu- ally, only the discrete part of the spectral density can be included in such a treatment, but the effect of the surrounding environment on the normal mode frequen- cies and Huang-Rhys factors can be included by using multiscale approaches (Lee et al., 2016). At the ground-state equilibrium, the gradient of the excited state PES is equal to the gradient of the energy gap U . In this position, the excited-state gradient is of- ten called vertical gradient (VG). For multiple modes, the energy gap can be expressed, in mass-weighted coor- dinates, as follows: ∆Ej(Q) = Ej−Eg−(cid:88) (cid:18) (cid:19) ω2 ndj,nQn + 1 2 ω2 nd2 j,n , (44) n where the displacement dj,n of mode n is related to the derivative fj,n of the excited-state PES by dj,n = −fj,n/ω2 n. The VG in normal coordinates fj can be ob- tained from the cartesian VG, fc,j, as follows: fj = P†M 1 2 fc,j , (45) where M is a diagonal matrix containing nuclear masses and P is a rectangular matrix whose columns are the normal modes expressed in mass-weighted Cartesian co- ordinates. Finally, the Huang-Rhys factor of each mode can be calculated by Sj,n = λj,n ωn = ωnd2 j,n 2 = f 2 j,n 2ω3 n . (46) In this explicit approach, the linear dependence of the en- ergy gap on all normal coordinates can be assessed. More recently, it was confirmed that the mixed approach of the MD simulation and direct calculation of Huang-Rhys fac- tor results in a spectral density in fairly good agreement with experimental result (Lee and Coker, 2016). Notably, the Huang-Rhys factors may be explicitly calculated also for the intermolecular motions. The dimensions of the system, however, do not allow a quantum-mechanical cal- culation of normal modes and vertical gradients, which 26 can instead be obtained through classical modeling of the PES and the pigment-protein interactions (Renger et al., 2012). However, the intermolecular motions may not be well described by harmonic potentials, and the energy gap could be highly nonlinear with the intermolecular coordinates. Very recently, an extension of the method has been pre- sented by combining VG with force-field based MD (Lee et al., 2017): the sampled configurations are used to ini- tiate QM ground state optimization of chromophore ge- ometries in the presence of the instantaneous local fields provided by the MM partial charges of the surrounding protein environment. Ground and excited state proper- ties are then computed at these optimized geometries to parametrize an ensemble of instantaneous local system- bath model Hamiltonians. The method has been success- fully applied to two phycobiliprotein structures, namely PE545 and PC645 complexes. Contrary to the discrete part of the spectral density, the continuous, low-frequency part is much more chal- lenging to be computed at QM level, and it may require extensive calculations along an MD trajectory. More- over, the intermolecular motions that give rise to the low-frequency part are strongly dependent on the tem- perature, as some barriers become accessible only when enough thermal energy is present in the system. There- fore, the size and shape of the continuous spectral density may indeed be dependent on temperature (Rancova and Abramavicius, 2014). FIG. 13 Bath spectral densities for BChl-3 of the FMO com- plex. "Exp." represents the experimental ∆-FNL data in (Ratsep and Freiberg, 2007), "Simulation (LC)" the theoreti- cal spectral density of (Lee and Coker, 2016), and "Simulation (KWC)" the theoretical spectral density of (Kim et al., 2018). The inset shows close-up of the lower frequency region. All the data have been provided by Young Min Rhee. As an alternative approach, Rhee and coworkers re- cently developed (Kim and Rhee, 2016; Park and Rhee, 2012) a new scheme that combines interpolated DFT- level calculations of pigment and molecular mechanics calculations of protein environments. This approach constructs on-the-fly quantum portion of potential en- ergy surface through interpolation from pre-calculated database, and is efficient while maintaining reasonable accuracy of the dynamics. As a result, dynamics lasting up to about 100 ns has been shown to be possible (Kim et al., 2018). Figure 13 compares the spectral densities calculated in this manner with that based on the mixed MD and HR factor calculation method (Lee and Coker, 2016). Although there is discrepancy between the two theoretical approaches, which can be related to motional narrowing effects and different force fields and conditions, both of these are in reasonable agreement with the ex- perimental results. Although the issues of anharmonic and nonlinear coupling effects of the bath still need to be examined more carefully, the level of agreement as can be seen in Fig. 13 provides a strong support for the validity of the conventional EBH for the FMO complex. V. EXCITON-RADIATION INTERACTION, LINESHAPE FUNCTIONS, AND RESPONSE FUNCTIONS The total Hamiltonian for the LHC in the presence of radiation is the sum of Eq. (20) and the matter-radiation interaction Hamiltonian Hint(t) as follows: HT (t) = Egg(cid:105)(cid:104)g + Hex + Hint(t) , (47) where Hex is the single exciton-bath Hamiltonian defined by Eq. (20). In general, double exciton states should also be included for a complete description of general four- wave mixing spectroscopy. While this is straightforward, we omit this contribution here for the sake of simplicity. We denote the transition dipole vector for the excitation from g(cid:105) to sk(cid:105) as µk. Then, the total electronic polar- ization operator for the transitions to the single exciton space is given by P = µk (sk(cid:105)(cid:104)g + g(cid:105)(cid:104)sk) (Djϕj(cid:105)(cid:104)g + g(cid:105)(cid:104)ϕjDj) , (48) (cid:88) (cid:88) k j = where Dj =(cid:80) k µkU∗ kj. The theories of absorption and emission lineshapes for Eq. (47) are well established. For example, for the case of radiation with frequency ω and polarization η, the absorption lineshape function is given by (cid:90) ∞ (cid:110) (49) j η · Djϕj(cid:105) and (cid:104)···(cid:105) represents all aver- aging over the disorder within the ensemble of the sample and polarization direction. For the sake of completeness, e− i t HexD(cid:105)(cid:104)Dρbe (cid:111)(cid:69) I(ω) = ×(cid:68) where D(cid:105) =(cid:80) e i tEg T r dt eiωt i t Hb 1 π Re 0 , 27 Appendix C provides a derivation of the above expression starting from a more general time dependent Hamilto- nian. Alternatively, one can obtain the above expression from the time correlation function of the polarization op- erator, Eq. (C5). Similarly, the emission lineshape func- tion is given by (cid:90) ∞ (cid:110) 0 E(ω) = ×(cid:68) 1 π Re e− i tEg T r dt e−iωt e− i t HbD(cid:105)(cid:104)Dρexe (cid:111)(cid:69) i t Hex , (50) where ρex = e−β Hex/T r{e−β Hex}. Appendix C provides a derivation of the above expression as well. Four wave mixing spectroscopies are useful for interro- gating the dynamics of excitons because they offer more selective information on the exciton space with appropri- ate choice of pulse sequences and phase matching condi- tions. Theories of four wave mixing and multidimensional electronic spectroscopy are well established (Abramavi- cius et al., 2009; Cho, 2008; Mukamel, 1995). However, in comparison to 2D vibrational spectroscopy for which accurate computational modeling of signals have been shown to be feasible for a broad range of systems, accu- rate modeling of 2DES remains challenging for most of systems. Appendix C provides a general expression for the third order polarization, Eq. (C40), the major observable of four-wave mixing spectroscopy, and detailed expressions for its components, Eqs. (C43)-(C46). The key quanti- ties containing the information on the material system are the third order response functions defined by Eqs. (C43)-(C46). 2DES is a collection of resulting third or- der polarizations, typically represented with respect to two frequencies of Fourier transform for the initial and final coherence times, t2 − t1 and tm − t3, respectively (see Appendix C for the definition of these times). In the absence of time dependent fluctuations and consider- ing only transitions between the ground electronic state and single exciton states, the four response functions can be expressed as (see Appendix C for the details of deriva- χ(1)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = i (t(cid:48)−t(cid:48)(cid:48))Eg e− i (tm−t)Eg e− i (tm−t(cid:48)) HbDm(cid:105)(cid:104)D2e− i (t(cid:48)−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hex tion): (cid:68) e ×T r × ρbD1(cid:105)(cid:104)D3e χ(2)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = (cid:68) ×T r × ρbD1(cid:105)(cid:104)D2e χ(3)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = (cid:68) ×T r ×ρbD2(cid:105)(cid:104)D1e χ(4)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = (cid:68) (cid:110) (cid:110) (cid:110) (cid:111)(cid:69) (cid:111)(cid:69) (cid:111)(cid:69) i (tm−t) Hex i (t−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hb e e− i (tm−t)Eg e i (t(cid:48)−t(cid:48)(cid:48))Eg , (51) e− i (tm−t) HbDm(cid:105)(cid:104)D3e− i (t−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hex i (tm−t(cid:48)) Hex i (t(cid:48)−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hb e e− i (tm−t)Eg e− i (t(cid:48)−t(cid:48)(cid:48))Eg e− i (tm−t) HbDm(cid:105)(cid:104)D3e− i (t−t(cid:48)) Hex (cid:110) i (tm−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hex i (t(cid:48)−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hb e e− i (tm−t)Eg e− i (t(cid:48)−t(cid:48)(cid:48))Eg , (52) , (53) ×T r ×D2(cid:105)(cid:104)D3e e− i (tm−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) HbDm(cid:105)(cid:104)D1ρbe i (tm−t) Hex i (t−t(cid:48)) Hb e i (t(cid:48)−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hex (cid:111)(cid:69) . (54) Figure 14 provides diagrammatic representations of the above four response functions, which are rephasing and non-rephasing terms of the ground state bleaching and stimulate emission terms. Excited state absorption terms are not shown because we limited the consideration to only single exciton states here. Despite recent advances, theoretical understanding of 2DES signals for the exciton states of LHCs remains chal- lenging. Vibronic couplings of pigment molecules in pro- tein environments are more pronounced than those of isolated pigment molecules. Their contribution to spec- troscopic signals can be significant even for BChls that are known to have very small HR factors. Due to the fact that the exciton Hamiltonian does not commute with the exciton-bath coupling in general, a specific exciton state ϕj(cid:105) created by an incoming photon starts decoher- ing and relaxing to other exciton states almost immedi- ately. These are depicted explicitly in Fig. 14 by dashed (and blue, on line) lines. In addition, the states of bath can be complicated in the exciton manifold because of non-adiabatic effects associated with multiple electronic states. In LHCs, the rates of these decoherence and re- laxation processes, which are due to vibronic couplings, are comparable to those due to purely electronic cou- plings that can happen if a specific site excitation state sj(cid:105) can be created. Furthermore, additional complica- tions can arise due to the fact that excitations created spectroscopically in LHCs are far from localized site ex- citation states in general. Even for highly tuned excitation wavelength, what is being created is most likely to be a subensemble of exci- ton states mixed together, which are degenerate in energy (a) (b) 28 (c) (d) FIG. 14 Diagrams representing four terms contributing to the third order polarization. The first two terms (a) and (b) corre- spond to echo signals satisfying the phase matching condition of km = k3 + k2 − k1, and are in general called rephasing terms. The last two terms satisfy a different phase matching condition of km = k3 − k2 − k1 and are in general called non- rephasing terms. Blue dashed curves represent relaxation and decoherence caused by the bath that continue propagating across interaction with radiation pulse, and Rk with different k represents a different bath relaxation operator. Bg repre- sents the bath of ground electronic state and Be the bath of the manifold of the single exciton states. Different bath states created following interaction with the radiation are expressed as different number of primes in the superscript. but have different extent in linear combinations of exciton states and in vibronic contributions. Selection of specific polarizations can reduce the size of the subensemble, but the qualitative nature of the subensemble is expected to remain the same. As a result, any attempt to detect the electronic coherence directly from 2DES in time is expected to be significantly hampered by the effect of subensemble dephasing. There are additional complications that can arise in the four-wave mixing spectroscopy of excitons in LHCs. For the simple case with a well isolated single excited state, dephasing due to the disorder in the excitation energy is cancelled in the rephasing signal when t2 − t1 = tm − t3. However, as can be seen from Eqs. (51) and (52) (and also Figs. 12(a) and (b)), the rephasing signal contains multiple contributions involving closely spaced exciton states. Therefore, full recovery of phase relation is not possible in this case because the disorder affects different exciton states within the subensemble in a different man- ner. In addition, the contributions of vibrational modes in both the ground electronic state and single exciton states are non-negligible. Unlike the electronic coherence, vibrational coherence is less susceptible to dephasing and can survive longer. The initial interpretation that 2DES beating signals (Collini et al., 2010; Engel et al., 2007) might reflect purely electronic coherence, is based on the assumption that vibronic couplings are negligible. Even if this is the case, such coherence may not have significant implication in the context of exciton dynamics unless it links exci- ton states that are spatially well separated. Let alone the question of how much the 2DES signal reflects the creation and evolution of excitons under natural irradia- tion of sun light, unambiguous interpretation of beating signals in general require clear resolution of major fea- tures of underlying Hamiltonian governing the dynam- ics of excitons and details of matter-radiation interaction (Ginsberg et al., 2009). Unambiguous interpretation of spectroscopic signals and detailed computational study of spatio-temporal evolution of excitons are important in this respect. Significant advances have been made in dealing with these issues in the past decade, but much still need to be accomplished. VI. THEORETICAL DESCRIPTION OF EXCITON DYNAMICS AND SPECTROSCOPIC OBSERVABLES A. Overview of theoretical and computational approaches Theoretical research on the dynamics of excitons has a long history dating back to early days of quantum me- chanics. In particular, for excitons formed in molecu- lar aggregates and solids, there have been extensive the- oretical and computational efforts to understand exci- ton migration kinetics and absorption/emission spectro- 29 scopic data (Agranovich and Galanin, 1982; Agranovich and Hochstrasser, 1982; Kenkre and Reineker, 1982; Sil- bey, 1976). While these have laid fundamental basis for modern research on the dynamics of molecular excitons, they have relied heavily on phenomenological treatment of exciton relaxation and dephasing dynamics, and have focused mostly on steady state properties. In addition, because systems that were studied consisted of either identical molecules or binary mixtures of host and guest molecules at most, underlying exciton Hamiltonians have had rather simple features. With the exception of chlorosome of green sulfur bacte- ria, which is a superaggregate of BChls, all LHCs can be viewed as host-guest systems of 10− 100 nm length scale sizes. Proteins serve as host environments, and pigment molecules are guest molecules, serving as site basis for excitations. The distinctive nature of LHCs compared to simple molecular host-guest systems is that protein hosts play an active role in tuning excitation energies and con- trols spatial arrangement of pigment molecules to a great extent. Therefore, accurate specification of the exciton Hamiltonian, exciton-bath coupling, and bath Hamilto- nian terms themselves are important for reliable charac- terization of LHCs. Because the magnitudes of these pa- rameters are in the intermediate range, well established theoretical approaches developed for simple or limiting situations are either inappropriate or in need of verifica- tion by more advanced approaches. In this regard, LHCs have motivated new advances in theories and computa- tional methods. Theoretical approaches to describe and simulate ex- citon dynamics can be classified into three classes, de- pending on the level of information and the degree of accuracy sought after. The minimal approach is to con- sider the time evolution of excitation/exciton popula- tions. Broadly, this can be called master equation (ME) approach. The next level of description is to consider the time evolution of a reduced exciton density operator (RDO). We here call this RDO approach. Finally, the most complete but expensive one is to describe the time evolution of the full density operator (FDO) represent- ing both exciton and the bath. In practice, this FDO approach relies on being able to effectively represent the bath of infinite size in terms of finite ones. Below we provide a brief overview of the three major approaches, and then explain how the outcomes of these theoretical calculations enable new understanding of the nature of excitons in LHCs. 1. Master equation approach and rate description In ME approach, the physical observables of interest are exciton populations, which are sufficient for calculat- ing exciton mobility and the extent of delocalization. An obvious choice of the unit of exciton here is each pigment. In principle, it is possible to formally construct exact and generalized ME (Kenkre and Knox, 1974) as follows: {Wk→j(t)pk(t) − Wj→k(t)pj(t)} , (55) (cid:88) k(cid:54)=j d dt pj(t) = where pj(t) is the exciton population at the jth pigment molecule and Wj→k(t) is the transfer rate of exciton pop- ulation from the jth to the kth pigment that can be de- fined to be formally exact by accounting for all possible pathways. This approach can serve as a general method- ology for all LHCs if accurate rate expressions are avail- able. However, in practice, calculating the exact rate kernel entails accounting for all the many body quantum interactions and thus remains a challenging theoretical task. If the electronic couplings between site excitations of pigment molecules are small compared to other parame- ters and the steady state limit is assumed, one can ap- proximate Wj→k(t) with the following Forster resonance energy transfer (FRET) rate expression (Forster, 1948, 1959): (cid:90) ∞ −∞ kF j→k = J 2 jk 2π2 dωLj(ω)Ik(ω) . (56) where we have adopted a more general definition of FRET by assuming that Jjk is not limited to transition dipole interactions. In the above expression, Lj(ω) and Ik(ω) are lineshape functions for the emission of the jth pigment and absorption of the kth pigment. For exam- ple, let us assume that Eq. (20) can be simplified as HLHC = Egg(cid:105)(cid:104)g + Jjksj(cid:105)(cid:104)sk Nc(cid:88) (cid:16) Bjsj(cid:105)(cid:104)sj + Hb,j j=1 Ejsj(cid:105)(cid:104)sj + (cid:17) Nc(cid:88) (cid:88) j=1 k(cid:54)=j , (57) where Bj and Hb,j are exciton-bath coupling and bath Hamiltonian localized to the site exciton state sj(cid:105). Then, the lineshape functions introduced in Eq. (56) are defined as dte−iωt+i(Ej−Eg)t/ ei( Hb,j + Bj )t/ e−i Hb,j t/ e−β( Hb,j + Bj )(cid:111) , dt eiωt−i(Ek−Eg)t/ ei Hb,kt/ e−i( Hb,k+ Bk)t/ e−β Hb,k (58) , (59) (cid:111) Nc(cid:88) j=1 + −∞ (cid:90) ∞ (cid:110) (cid:90) ∞ (cid:110) −∞ Lj(ω) = × 1 Z(cid:48) b,j T rb,j Ik(ω) = × 1 Zb,k T rb,k b,j = T rb,j{e−β( Hb,j + Bj )} and Zb,k = where Z(cid:48) T rb,k{e−β Hb,k}. (cid:90) ∞ −∞ 30 The normalized emission lineshape (in the unit of ν = ω/(2πc)) for the jth pigment is expressed as fj(ν) = τj 25π3nj,rµ2 j c 3 ν3Lj(2πcν) , (60) where nj,r is the refractive index around the jth chro- mophore. The molar extinction coefficient for the kth pigment is related to the lineshape function by the fol- lowing relation: Ik(2πcν) = 3000(ln 10)nk,r (2π)2NAµ2 k ν k(ν) , (61) where nk,r is the refractive index around the kth pigment. Then, Eq. (56) can be expressed as kF j→k = 9000(ln 10) 128π5NAτj nj,r nk,r J 2 jk j µ2 µ2 k dν fj(ν)k(ν) ν4 . (62) This expression becomes the well-known Forster's spec- tral overlap expression (Forster, 1948) in the limit where Jjk is due to the transition dipole-dipole interaction and the dielectric constants around jth and kth chro- mophores are the same. More general expressions than Eq. (56), which in- clude nonequilibrium (Jang and Cheng, 2013; Jang et al., 2002b) and inelastic effects (Jang, 2007; Jang and Cheng, 2013), are also available. However, the FRET rate ex- pression or its generalizations, which are based on the second order approximation with respect to the electronic coupling between a pair of pigment molecules, are inap- propriate for many LHCs because not many excitons are localized at single chromophores. Alternatively, one can extend the unit of exciton pop- ulation as that residing in a group of strongly coupled pigment molecules. If groups of chromophores can be identified such that electronic couplings between pigment molecules in different groups are weak enough, the rates of exciton transfer between them can be calculated, again employing a second order approximation with respect to the inter-group electronic couplings. This is the idea be- hind the multichromophoric FRET (MC-FRET) (Jang et al., 2004; Sumi, 1999), which was recently re-derived and tested more extensively (Ma and Cao, 2015). The use of MC-FRET rates as kernels of ME was for- mulated more rigorously by introducing the concept of modular excitons (Jang et al., 2014). Under the assump- tion that all the pigment molecules constituting an LHC can be divided into disjoint modules and that only the coarse-grained overall exciton population of each mod- ule, pn(t), (modular exciton density) is of interest, one can consider the following generalized ME: (cid:110) Wm→n(t)pm(t) − Wn→m(t)pn(t) (cid:111) (cid:88) . d dt pn(t) = m(cid:54)=n (63) As in the case of Eq. (55), exact formal expression for Wn→m(t) can be found easily (Jang et al., 2014). In prac- tice, approximations are needed. Under the assumption that the inter-module electronic couplings are small com- pared to other parameters and that the exciton density within each module reaches the stationary limit quickly, it is possible to show that (Jang et al., 2014) Wn→m(t) = Jj(cid:48)k(cid:48)Jj(cid:48)(cid:48)k(cid:48)(cid:48) 2π2 dωLn j(cid:48)(cid:48)j(cid:48)(t, ω)I m k(cid:48)k(cid:48)(cid:48) (ω) , 0 formally exact QME is well-known: 31 σI (t) = (cid:26) d dt −iT rb (cid:90) t − (cid:20) −i (cid:90) t (cid:20) 0 (cid:26) Leb,I (t) exp(+) (cid:27) Leb,I (t) exp(+) ×Q Leb,I (τ )ρb dτ T rb (cid:21) (cid:27) (cid:21) dτQ Leb,I (τ ) QρI (0) −i dτ(cid:48)Q Leb,I (τ(cid:48)) (cid:90) t τ σI (τ ) . (68) (cid:88) (cid:88) j(cid:48)j(cid:48)(cid:48) k(cid:48)k(cid:48)(cid:48) (cid:90) ∞ −∞ j(cid:48)(cid:48)j(cid:48)(t; ω) and I m (64) where Ln k(cid:48)k(cid:48)(cid:48)(ω) are lineshape matrix ele- ments representing the time dependent emission of mod- ule n and the absorption of module m. These are respec- tively expressed as (cid:20)(cid:90) t (cid:110)(cid:104)sn,j(cid:48)(cid:48)e−i Hb,nt(cid:48)/ j(cid:48)(cid:48)j(cid:48)(t; ω) ≡ 2Re Ln (cid:90) ∞ × T rbn (cid:110)(cid:104)sm,k(cid:48)ei Hb,mt(cid:48)/ k(cid:48)k(cid:48)(cid:48)(ω) ≡ I m ×T rbm −∞ 0 dteiωt+iEgt/ dt(cid:48)e−iωt(cid:48)−iEgt(cid:48)/ ρnsei Hnt(cid:48)/sn,j(cid:48)(cid:105)(cid:111)(cid:105) bmsm,k(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:105)(cid:111) e−i Hmt(cid:48)/ ρg , (65) ,(66) where Hn ( Hm) and Hb,n ( Hb,m) are respectively the EBH in the single exciton space and the bath Hamilto- nian of the nth (mth) module. In the limit of t → ∞, Eq. (64) approaches the MC-FRET rate (Jang et al., 2014, 2004). 2. Reduced density operator approach For pigment molecules with moderate or strong elec- tronic couplings, description of the dynamics at the level of a reduced density operator (RDO) in the exciton man- ifold serves as a better platform than restricting the focus on the exciton population only. Let us denote the RDO at time as σ(t). Then, the quantum master equation (QME) governing the time evolution equation of σ(t) can in general be expressed as d dt σ(t) = − i [ He, σ(t)] − R[t; σ] + I[t] , (67) where the first term represents the dynamics due to the exciton Hamiltonian, R[t; σ] accounts for the relaxation and dephasing due to environments, and I[t] is the in- homogeneous term that reflects the effect of the initial condition. There is a large body of literature available on the derivation of formally exact QME and approximations. For example, for the case of the interaction picture RDO defined as σI (t) = T rb{ρI (t)}, where ρI (t) is the total density operator in the interaction picture, the following (cid:90) t (cid:90) t 0 d dt − − 0 In the above equation, Leb,I (·) = [ Heb,I (t), (·)]/, Q(·) = 1 − T rb{(·)}. Equation (68), although exact, is not useful in prac- tice because exp(+)[−i(cid:82) t τ dτ(cid:48)Q Leb,I (τ(cid:48))] cannot be deter- mined without full information on the system and bath degrees of freedom. For practical calculations, approxi- mations are made in general, although recent theoretical advances (Cohen et al., 2013; Kelly et al., 2016; Shi and Geva, 2004; Zhang et al., 2006) suggest that exact nu- merical evaluation of this term is feasible. One of the simplest and most popular approximation is the 2nd order approximation with respect to Leb,I (t), which results in (cid:110) Lsb,I (t)ρI (0) (cid:111) (cid:110) Lsb,I (t) Lsb,I (τ )QρI (0) (cid:111) σI (t) = −iT rb dτ T rb dτ T rb {Lsb,I (t)Lsb,I (τ )ρb} σI (t∗) , (69) where t∗ can be either τ or t. In the former case, the above equation becomes time-nonlocal (TN). In the lat- ter case, it becomes time-local (TL). Which choice works better depends on the nature of the system-bath cou- plings and the bath dynamics, but most numerical exam- ples so far suggest that the TL equation performs bet- ter than the TN equation, at least at room temperature where the bath dynamics become most likely Gaussian (Chen et al., 2009; Palenberg et al., 2001). Analyses of the fourth order QME (Jang et al., 2002a) and steady state limits (Fleming and Cummings, 2011) suggest that this is because the 2nd order TL equation can account for some of the effects of the 4th order terms of TN equa- tions. In Eq. (69), the super-operator involving the second order correlations of Lsb(t), which appears commonly in both inhomogeneous and homogeneous terms, can be ex- pressed as (cid:90) t (cid:88) 0 = dτ T rb (cid:88) (cid:110) Lsb,I (t) Lsb,I (τ )ρb (cid:90) t (cid:111) (·) dτCjk(t − τ )[sj(t), sk(τ )(·)] + H.c. , j k 0 (70) where H.c. denotes Hermitian conjugates of all the pre- vious terms, sj(t) = eiHet/sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sje−iHet/ , and Cjk(t) is the bath correlation function for sites j and k defined as Cjk(t) = ngj,rgk,r (cid:88) (cid:90) ∞ r (cid:8)(bre−iωt + b† (cid:18) ω2 ×T rb dωJjk(ω) coth( (cid:9) (cid:19) r)ρb reiωt)(br + b† βω 2 ) cos(ωt) − i sin(ωt) , = 1 π 0 (71) where Jjk(ω) is the bath spectral densities defined by Eq. (22). The 2nd order QMEs in various forms and approx- imations have served as major theoretical tools for de- scribing exciton dynamics and calculating spectroscopic data in early pioneering quantum dynamical studies on LHCs, and still remain as key theoretical methods offer- ing qualitative and/or semiquantitative information. As is well-known, the 2nd order approximation with respect to the system-bath interaction causes the QME to be non-positive definite, without rotating wave ap- proximation (Kohen et al., 1997; Pechukas, 1994), and to be unreliable as the system-bath interaction becomes larger. An alternative approach addressing this issue but still based on the assumption of weak system-bath cou- pling is the Lindblad equation (Lindblad, 1976). Having been constructed axiomatically, the Lindblad equation guarantees complete positivity and thus can be used to model the effects of environments on any quantum sys- tem. For this reason, it has been used extensively in the quantum information community and was brought to the study of the FMO complex following the 2DES spectroscopy (Engel et al., 2007). However, due to the assumption of Markovian-bath intrinsic in the theory and the phenomenological nature of relaxation and dephas- ing super-operators used, it has primarily served as a useful analysis tool rather than a quantitative modeling method. Of course, it is possible to obtain some micro- scopic expressions for the terms of Lindblad equation, for example, from the 2nd order QME. However, this involves additional approximations the physical implica- tions of which are not always clear. Considering typically moderate nature of system-bath interactions found in most LHCs, it is not likely that the errors caused by QMEs based on perturbative approxi- mations are substantial. However, in general, assessment of the accuracy of the 2nd order QMEs is possible only when benchmarked against more accurate approaches. For this reason, different approaches employing higher order approximations or nonperturbative methods have been applied to LHCs. Among various higher order methods developed for decades, the hierarchical equations of motion (HEOM) approach (Tanimura, 2006, 2015; Tanimura and Mukamel, 1993) has gained popularity recently and its results are considered as benchmark data by many re- 32 searchers. The HEOM approach was originally formu- lated and developed within the path integral influence functional formalism for open system quantum dynam- ics, and is based on the idea that higher order terms of the system-bath interactions can be accounted for by introducing a hierarchy of coupled auxiliary opera- tors, an assumption valid as long as the bath correlation functions have exponential functional form. With fur- ther advances in practical schemes (Ishizaki and Flem- ing, 2009b; Schroter et al., 2015; Tanimura, 2006; Zheng et al., 2012) to bring closure to the hierarchy and com- putational power, application of the HEOM approach to LHCs became feasible recently. There are also other approaches that have been de- veloped more recently and can account for higher order system-bath interactions in different manner. These in- clude polaron-transformed QME approach (Jang, 2011; Jang et al., 2013; McCutcheon and Nazir, 2011; Nazir, 2009), generalized QME approach (Cohen et al., 2013; Kelly et al., 2016; Shi and Geva, 2004; Zhang et al., 2006), and transfer tensor approach (Kananeka et al., 2016; Rosenbach et al., 2016). Well-known variations of QME approaches with modified definitions of system (Iles-Smith et al., 2016, 2014) or system-bath couplings (Hwang-Fu et al., 2015; Novoderezhkin and van Gron- delle, 2017) have also been demonstrated to be accurate enough with appropriate corrections. While QME approaches are in general appropriate for describing the effects of quantum mechanical bath, they tend to neglect the effects of classical and stochas- tic fluctuations, which cannot be captured well in the form of Hamiltonian but may still be substantial in ac- tual environments. For example, for LHCs embedded in membrane, there can be various noises being prop- agated from distant sources but having effects on dy- namics around pigment molecules. In addition, some of anharmonic and nonlinear effects of the bath, which are neglected in constructing the model Hamiltonian with harmonic oscillator bath, may still affect the dynamics by appearing in the form of uncontrollable noises due to the chaotic/irregular nature of the trajectories they incur in general multidimensional space. The effects of these noises can be significant at ambient condition and may have to be included along with the quantum bath. While the contributions of these noises to the exciton dy- namics can be treated at a simple phenomenological level such as Haken-Strobl equation (Haken and Strobl, 1973), more satisfactory QME level description incorporating them into a consistent quantum description of bath is not available to the best of our knowledge. Functional integration (Ritschel et al., 2011) and Heisenberg picture time evolution (Ghosh et al., 2009) approaches, which in- voke somewhat different approximations but are general otherwise, may be better suited to this end. 3. Full density operator approaches The QMEs and the HEOM approaches, despite having been successful, are limited mostly to the harmonic oscil- lator bath model. Little is understood regarding the ef- fects of anharmonic contribution of the bath Hamiltonian on the nature and dynamics of excitons in LHCs. For sat- isfactory account of these effects, it is often necessary to consider the dynamics of the full density operator (FDO) representing the system and the bath. In addition, even for the bath of harmonic oscillators, accurate calculation of higher order response functions in general require time evolution of FDO unless a new kinds of coupled QMEs are developed. Well-known FDO approaches are semi- classical dynamics methods (Cotton and Miller, 2016; Huo and Coker, 2010; Miller, 2001), mixed quantum- classical approaches (Tully, 2012; Zheng et al., 2017) such as surface hopping and mean field approximations. While these offer more realistic treatment of the bath degrees of freedom and their interactions with excitons, they entail different levels of approximations in the quantum dynam- ics. In addition, the bath has to be finite for practical calculations. Given that these approximations and issues are well addressed, the results of these FDO approaches can offer important information for LHCs that are not accessible through QME and HEOM approaches. 4. Computational methods for lineshape and response functions All the QME approaches can be used to calculate the absorption and emission lineshapes, employing the prod- uct of the transition dipole and the density operator in either ground or excited state as an initial condition. Al- ternatively, a specific QME method can be modified to derive an appropriate lineshape theory using the coher- ent term of the density operator as the initial condition and applying mixed time evolutions, one on the ground electronic state and the other on the manifold of excited electronic states, respectively, to the two different sides of the density operator. One popular approach for calculat- ing the lineshape is the so called modified Redfield equa- tion (Kleinekathofer and Schreiber, 2006; Zhang et al., 1998), which includes the diagonal components of the exciton-bath coupling as part of the effective system part and treat the off-diagonal components in a perturbative manner. Most recently, this approach was extended fur- ther to account for the finite relaxation time of nuclei (Dinh and Renger, 2016). Modified Redfield equation can also be extended for the simulation of exciton dy- namics (Hwang-Fu et al., 2015; Novoderezhkin and van Grondelle, 2017; Yang and Fleming, 2002), although care should be taken in identifying the unit of population in this case. An important issue is that response functions of four- wave mixing spectroscopy cannot be calculated exactly 33 even at a formal level using a conventional QME ap- proach without modification. The diagrams in Fig. 14 clarify the reason for this. Each interaction with pulse corresponds to the creation of a non-equilibrium state, which also depends on previous time evolution of both excitons and the bath that are again dependent on the nature of previous pulses. For this reason, the relaxation and dephasing terms due to the bath are expected to be functionals of whole sequence of pulses, which are in gen- eral different from those of equilibrium bath. Therefore an FDO approach is necessary in general (McRobbie and Geva, 2009). A perturbative approach addressing this issue has also been formulated (Jang, 2012). B. Applications 1. FMO complex Early theoretical works on the FMO complex employed the 2nd order ME and QME approaches. Application of the Redfield equation (Redfield, 1957), the 2nd order TL-QME in the Markovian bath limit, with the secu- lar approximation (Renger and May, 1998) showed that the approach can reproduce the major features of tem- perature dependence in the absorption lineshape and the time dependence of pump-probe spectroscopic data. They also provided estimate for the relaxation of a higher exciton state (4th state) to be about 2 ps. This ap- proach was later combined with an optimal control the- ory (Bruggemann and May, 2004) to explore the possi- bility of controlling the exciton dynamics in the FMO complex through pulse shaping. On the other hand, the ME approach in the exciton basis was employed (Vulto et al., 1999) to describe time resolved absorption differ- ence spectra and the exciton population dynamics. They have also identified various relaxation time scales of exci- ton dynamics ranging from sub 100 fs up to about 2.3 ps. The phenomenological assumption used in this model Hamiltonian was later justified microscopically (Adolphs et al., 2008). The suggestion of quantum information processing (Engel et al., 2007) motivated new theoretical works (Caruso et al., 2009, 2010; Chin et al., 2010; Mohseni et al., 2008; Palmieri et al., 2009; Pelzer et al., 2012; Ple- nio and Huelga, 2008; Rebentrost et al., 2009b,c; Sarovar et al., 2010; Skochdopole and Mazziotti, 2011) aimed at understanding the role of entanglement, quantum coher- ence, and noise. Earlier versions of these (Caruso et al., 2009; Mohseni et al., 2008; Plenio and Huelga, 2008; Rebentrost et al., 2009c) employed the Lindblad equation (Lindblad, 1976) or its stochastic implementation, which are based on the assumption of weak system-bath cou- pling and Markovian bath. Later works improved these by including the effects of non-Markovian bath (Caruso et al., 2010; Chin et al., 2010; Rebentrost et al., 2009a), correlated bath fluctuations (Rebentrost et al., 2009b), and full consideration of system-bath coupling at the level of HEOM (Sarovar et al., 2010). According to these studies, the effect of entanglement, which is limited to mode entanglement, is not significant for single excitons in the FMO complex. On the other hand, dephasing and noise were identified as significant factors for the overall efficiency of energy transport, as espoused by new terms such as environment-assisted quantum transport (Lam- bert et al., 2013; Rebentrost et al., 2009c) and dephasing- assisted transport (Chin et al., 2010). Studies based on the Haken-Strobl equation (Hoyer et al., 2010; Vlaming and Silbey, 2012) have also offered new insights into the potential complications and effects of noise. It was also suggested that the redundancy (Skochdopole and Mazz- iotti, 2011) of energy transfer pathways plays an impor- tant role. Due to the intermediate nature of the exciton-bath coupling in the FMO complex, the Lindblad equation and the 2nd order ME/QME approaches were not perceived as quantitatively reliable. HEOM calculations were per- formed to investigate the population dynamics (Ishizaki and Fleming, 2009a), which served as the first set of key benchmark data in this respect. This work showed that coherent population dynamics persists up to sev- eral hundred femto seconds even at room temperature. Calculations (Chin et al., 2013) based on density matrix renormalization group technique (Prior et al., 2010) also support this result and suggest the contribution of sig- nificant nonequilibrium effects. Later, other approaches have been employed to calculate the excitation dynam- ics. For example, non-Markovian quantum state diffusion (Ritschel et al., 2011), mixed quantum-classical Poisson bracket mapping equation approach (Kelly and Rhee, 2011), and quasiclassical dynamics (Cotton and Miller, 2016) have been shown to produce results in reasonable agreement with the HEOM approach. These approaches are applicable to more general exciton-bath couplings and bath Hamiltonians, and can be used to understand the effects of anharmonic effects of the bath modes and non- linear exciton-bath couplings. Theoretical observation of coherent real time dynam- ics for the FMO complex was an important step for elu- cidating the quantum dynamical details of exciton dy- namics. However, such oscillatory population dynamics were mostly between proximate BChls with significant electronic couplings, and did not yet imply long range "wave-like" motion of excitons. On the other hand, for the overall description of exciton dynamics and calcula- tion of ensemble-averaged spectroscopic observables, sim- pler perturbative ME and QME approaches seemed to offer reasonable answers (Moix et al., 2011; Schmidt am Busch et al., 2011; Wu et al., 2012). Most recently, a full HEOM calculation for trimers (Wilkins and Dattani, 2015) demonstrated that the time scale of exciton trans- port is similar to that based on a simple ME approach us- 34 ing FRET rate as its kernel. This result suggests that the interpretation based on earlier theoretical studies based on approximate theories is valid in general. There have been further progress in theoretical model- ing of spectroscopic data. While theoretical calculation of linear spectroscopic data was well established and could be used for the refinement of model parameters (Adolphs and Renger, 2006; Jansen and Knoester, 2009; Schmidt am Busch et al., 2011), accurate modeling and unambigu- ous interpretation of 2DES signals has remained challeng- ing. One of the earliest simulations of 2DES was based on equation of motion approach, while assuming simple Redfield tensor and secular approximation for the bath relaxation (Sharp et al., 2010). This suggested that it is difficult to explain the off-diagonal beating signal ob- served from 2DES (Engel et al., 2007). A different the- oretical modeling based on the secular Redfield equation led to a similar conclusion, while leaving the possibil- ity of contribution of correlated bath (Abramavicius and Mukamel, 2011). Another theoretical modeling based on the Redfield equation and including the vibronic states explicitly suggested that the beating signal may have originated from vibrational motion (Christensson et al., 2012). HEOM calculations of absorption spectra (Hein et al., 2012) and 2DES echo spectra (Hein et al., 2012; Kreisbeck and Kramer, 2012) on the other hand provided support for coherence signal of electronic nature lasting up to about 500 fs, but in the absence of static disor- der and other sources of fluctuations. Although based on rather simple model Hamiltonian, careful analysis (Ti- wari et al., 2013) demonstrated that electronic coherence can easily dephase when the effect of reasonable magni- tude of disorder is taken into consideration, whereas beat- ing that originates from vibrational motion can last much longer. Th contribution of vibronic terms can be an- other possibility (Mourokh and Nori, 2015; Plenio et al., 2013). As yet, because of the sensitivity of 2DES signals to various factors and the lack of fully reliable model and quantum dynamics methods, a definite assessment of the implications of 2DES signals remains open. From the functionality point of view, to what extent the quantum effects contribute to the overall efficiency of the exciton migration remains a central question even to date (Wu et al., 2012). Accurate determination of the spectral density of the bath has a significant implication in answering this question. High frequency modes of the spectral density in general do not affect the mechanis- tic details of exciton dynamics (Abramavicius and Abra- mavicius, 2014). However, low frequency modes with en- ergies comparable to the exciton band width and their coupling strengths can be detrimental to the exciton dy- namics mechanism and the interpretation of 2DES spec- troscopic data. There have been various efforts to address these issues through all-atomistic simulations (Olbrich et al., 2011a; Shim et al., 2012) and direct calculation of Huang-Rhys factors (Adolphs and Renger, 2006). The contributions of correlated fluctuations (Olbrich et al., 2011a) and non-Gaussian bath fluctuations (Jansen and Knoester, 2009) were also suggested as potentially sig- nificant factors that can complicate the exciton dynam- ics. As yet, depending on the approximations and as- sumptions involved, the assessment of the bath spectral density can be different. It was once suggested that the exciton-bath coupling might be too strong to allow any coherent dynamics unless the dynamics starts from a coherent initial state (Muhlbacher and Kleinekathofer, 2012). However, more recent calculations based on differ- ent methods indicate weaker bath spectral densities that are more in tune with older models. Ultimately, on-the- fly ab initio nonadiabatic dynamics but with sufficient accuracy may be necessary to settle this issue. New de- velopment in first principles linear scaling ab initio calcu- lation can be a promising avenue to explore in achieving this goal (Cole et al., 2013). 2. LH2 complex Soon after the structural information of the LH2 com- plex became available, advanced quantum dynamical theories, for example, addressing the exciton coherence length (Leegwater, 1996; Meier et al., 1997c), super- radiance (Meier et al., 1997c), and four-wave mixing spectroscopy signals (Meier et al., 1997b; Zhang et al., 1998) have been developed. Although based on exciton- bath Hamiltonians of appropriate features but yet with quite simplified forms, these works have not produced quantitative modeling of linear spectroscopic data. In- stead, earlier attempts to fit experimental lineshapes used simple exciton Hamiltonians with disorder terms (Hu et al., 1997), while dressing each exciton peak with phenomenologically chosen lineshape functions (Alden et al., 1997; Georgakopoulou et al., 2002; Wu and Small, 1998). These produced reasonable fitting of linear ensem- ble lineshapes, which indicates that the inhomogeneous broadening due to disorder is large enough to screen the line broadening due to the exciton-bath coupling. As yet, the disorder is still in the moderate regime that makes it difficult to tell what types of disorder, diago- nal or off-diagonal in site excitation basis, are dominant (Jang et al., 2001). In addition, detailed information on the disorder was shown to be important for proper in- terpretation of nonlinear spectroscopic data (Yang et al., 2001). The SMS data (van Oijen et al., 1999) for the LH2 complex offered the first direct evidence for the delocal- ized nature of excitons in its B850 unit, and offered new opportunities and challenges for theoretical and compu- tational modeling. On one hand, large gaps between two major excitonic peaks of the B850 unit were inexplica- ble based on existing exciton models. This initially led to the suggestion of elliptic distortion of LH2 (Demp- 35 ster et al., 2001; Mostovoy and Knoester, 2000; van Oi- jen et al., 1999). Later, it was explained by models with modulation in site energies (Hofmann et al., 2004; Kete- laars et al., 2001) and correlated disorder (Jang et al., 2011). Another important theoretical issue was eluci- dating details of SMS lineshapes. The first step to un- derstand the physical implication of such lineshapes is to calculate the effects of exciton-bath coupling at each single LH2 level. To this end, an exciton-bath model (Jang and Silbey, 2003a) incorporating the bath spectral density (Renger and Marcus, 2002) extracted from spec- troscopic data was developed. Lineshapes were then cal- culated by using the 2nd order TN-QME approximation (Jang and Silbey, 2003a,b). The features of the theoreti- cal line shapes (Jang and Silbey, 2003a) were in qualita- tive agreement with experimental ones (van Oijen et al., 1999). However, the widths of the former were much narrower than the latter. This was attributed to fluc- tuations during the long SMS measurement time scales, which are possible even in the very low temperature limit because of numerous excitation and de-excitation pro- cesses needed to collect the photons. Another source for the discrepancy is the approximate nature of the 2nd order TN-QME. Indeed, later calculations of absorption lineshapes by alternative or higher order methods (Chen et al., 2009; Kleinekathofer and Schreiber, 2006), while based on somewhat different bath spectral densities and calculated at higher temperatures, showed that the 2nd order TN-QME approach underestimates the broadening due to exciton-phonon couplings. Application of these approaches with improved spectral densities may allow better explanation of SMS lineshapes. In parallel, there have been advances in the modeling of 2DES spectroscopy data of the LH2 complex, for exam- ple, providing intriguing insights into anharmonic effects of the bath (Rancova and Abramavicius, 2014). More re- cently, all-atomistic modeling has offered detailed infor- mation on physical implications of 2DES signals (Segatta et al., 2017; van der Vegte et al., 2015). The dark states of carotenoids of LH2, which had long been speculated to be present, was investigated recently based on quan- tum chemical calculations and simulation of 2DES spec- troscopic data (Feng et al., 2017; Segatta et al., 2017). However, the results obtained so far are not yet sufficient to lead to a general consensus. Thus, further investiga- tions are needed. In a given LH2 complex, the exciton dynamics within B800, between B800 and B850, and within B850 have all different characteristics. It is generally accepted that the dynamics within B800 can be well described by a hopping model of excitons localized at each BChl. The exciton transfer from B800 to B850 can also be described by hopping dynamics, but the coherent delocalization of the exciton in the B850 unit has to be taken into con- sideration. Two early theoretical studies (Mukai et al., 1999; Scholes and Fleming, 2000) accounted for this by employing approximate versions of the MC-FRET theory (Jang et al., 2004; Sumi, 1999), which included only the contribution of population terms in the exciton basis and used phenomenological lineshape functions. Later works (Jang et al., 2004, 2007) employing a more satisfactory exciton-bath Hamiltonian (Jang and Silbey, 2003a) and full MC effect within the 2nd order TN-QME approach (Jang and Silbey, 2003a,b) confirmed that neglecting co- herence terms in the exciton basis of the MC-FRET the- ory does not have significant effect on the distribution of transfer rates. In addition, these works (Jang et al., 2004, 2007) provided more solid evidence that the theoretical results based on the exciton-bath model (Jang and Sil- bey, 2003a) and the MC-FRET theory (Jang et al., 2004; Sumi, 1999) are indeed consistent with experimental re- sults (Jimenez et al., 1996; Pullerits et al., 1997). The exciton dynamics within the B850 unit requires full quantum dynamical approach. Although hoping dy- namics (Abramavicius et al., 2004) and Haken-Strobl ap- proach (Liuolia et al., 1997) provided some insights, ac- curate theoretical description has remained challenging. Recent applications of the HEOM approach (Chen et al., 2009; J. Strumpfer and K. Schulten, 2012; Strumpfer and Schulten, 2009; Yeh et al., 2012) are important advances in this respect, and confirm fast decoherence and relax- ation of excitons in the range of 100 − 200 fs time scales as seen experimentally (Agarwal et al., 2002; Book et al., 2000). However, these calculations are still based on rather simplified spectral densities. In addition, these have made no or limited consideration of the effects of the disorder. On the other hand, it was demonstrated that the ensemble dephasing due to disorder, while using relatively simple dynamics theory, is sufficient to explain fast anisotropy decay in LH2 (Stross et al., 2016). Thus, to clarify which of the two factors determines major time resolved experimental data on the B850 unit, large scale HEOM calculations sampled over sufficient number of re- alizations of the disorder is necessary. Some advances have already been made in this direction for the calcu- lation of absorption and emission lineshapes (Jing et al., 2013). The dynamics of excitons between LH2s and aggre- gates of LH2s have important implications for the overall energy collection efficiency, and has been subject to var- ious computational studies (Caycedo-Soler et al., 2010; J. Strumpfer and K. Schulten, 2012; Jang et al., 2014, 2015; Ritz et al., 2001; Strumpfer and Schulten, 2009; Xiong et al., 2012; Yang et al., 2012). The earliest in this endeavor was the kinetic Monte Carlo simulation of exci- ton dynamics in simple aggregates of LH2, LH3, and LH1 (Ritz et al., 2001). In this work, a fixed value of LH2- LH2 exciton transfer time of 10 ps was used, which was calculated based on an approximate version of the MC- FRET theory (Jang et al., 2004; Sumi, 1999) for a single LH2-LH2 distance (Ritz et al., 2001). This transfer time was also adopted in later simulation of exciton dynam- 36 ics in the entire PSU of purple bacteria (Caycedo-Soler et al., 2010). While the value has been validated to be in reasonable agreement with an accurate calculation based on the HEOM approach (Strumpfer and Schulten, 2009), it is not yet representative of all the inter-LH2 exciton transfer dynamics that are plausible. An HEOM cal- culation demonstrated significant potential effect of the correlation of the bath (J. Strumpfer and K. Schulten, 2012). Application of the GME-MED approach (Jang et al., 2014, 2015) showed that the rate can change signif- icantly depending on the realization of the disorder and the inter-LH2 distances that are consistent with AFM im- ages. Figure 15 shows the distribution of rates at 300 K between two LH2 complexes separated by a center-to- center distance of 7.5 nm. In this result, the distribution of rates is purely due to the Gaussian disorder in the ex- citation energy of each BChl with standard deviation of 200 cm−1. Consideration of the distribution of inter-LH2 distances will result in wider distribution of rates (Jang et al., 2015). FIG. 15 Distribution of LH2-LH2 rates (left panel) and av- erage population decay (right panel) of exciton on the initial LH2. More details can be found in (Jang et al., 2015). 3. PBPs Redfield equation Modified employed was linear spec- (Novoderezhkin et al., 2010) to model troscopic data, excitation anisotropy measurement, and transient absorption spectra, and then to deduce excitation energy transfer kinetics based on these modelings. Following the observation of the beating signal from the 2DES result (Collini et al., 2010), an FDO quantum dynamics method called iterative density matrix propagation approach was used for the simulation of the exciton population dynamics (Huo and Coker, 2011). The results of this work supported the observation from the 2DES (Collini et al., 2010) that the electronic coherence between central dimers lasts up to about 400 fs, but also showed that such coherence does not have significant effect on the exciton population dynamics of peripheral pigment molecules. On the other hand, it was also suggested that quantum vibrational modes have significant effect on the exciton transfer (O'Reilly and Olya-Castro, 2014). QM/MM approaches (Aghtar et al., 2017, 2014; Cu- rutchet et al., 2013; Lee et al., 2017) were used to model spectroscopic data and to simulate the exciton transfer dynamics. The earliest effort was focused on investigat- ing the nature of the bath spectral density, and employed a quantum-classical dynamics simulation by conducting wave-packet dynamics on fluctuating potential energy surfaces (Curutchet et al., 2013). It was also confirmed that significant portion of the bath spectral density re- sults from the intramolecular vibrations (Aghtar et al., 2014). The population dynamics were also shown to be non-oscillatory, even much less than that of the FMO complex. The methodology of QM/MM simulation has pro- gressed to the level of constructing comprehensive EBH models for PBPs of both PE545 and PC645 with rea- sonable accuracy (Lee et al., 2017). These models were then combined with lineshape theories employing the 2nd order TL-QME approach so as to model the absorption and CD spectra (Lee et al., 2017), demonstrating satis- factory agreement between theory and experiment. Anal- yses based on these calculations confirmed significant ef- fects of vibronic couplings, and also suggested potential importance of correlated fluctuations of the site excita- tion energies. A different QM/MM study, also including the effects of the polarizable medium, showed that fluc- tuations in couplings and site energies do not have sig- nificant effects on the overall exciton dynamics (Aghtar et al., 2017). Theoretical analysis of a recent 2DES spec- troscopy for PC645 (Dean et al., 2016) also suggests that vibronic redistribution enhances the exciton transfer rate by about a factor of 3.5. VII. DISCUSSION LHCs have characteristics and challenges that are dis- tinctively different from any other biological complexes in relation to their specific function. While the impor- tance of structural information for LHCs is inarguable, it is necessary to recognize that the functionality of an LHC is determined by how and where excitons are formed and how fast and efficiently the excitons move from one re- gion to another, while conserving their energies as much as possible even in the presence of disorder and fluctua- tions. Elucidating these details require reliable informa- tion on the energetics and the dynamics of excitons in the excited potential energy surfaces. In addition to struc- tural data, a comprehensive collection of spectroscopic and computational data are needed even for establishing 37 a Hamiltonian that can represent the behavior of excitons with reasonable accuracy. Calculation and simulation of quantum dynamical evolution of excitons in these sys- tems are equally challenging due to their complexity and sizes. Furthermore, the disorder and environmental fluc- tuations are important factors to consider because they can have significant effects on how excitons are formed and evolve in time. They also make significant contribu- tions to spectroscopic observables. Ideally, a spectroscopic measurement with both nanoscale spatial resolution and femtosecond time res- olution, or an on-the-fly ab initio quantum dynamical simulation with sufficient accuracy (with errors less than 100 cm−1 in energy) and efficiency (to run up to tens of picosecond and to be repeated over many realizations of disorder) is needed to probe excitons in LHCs di- rectly. However, in the absence of feasible spectroscopic and computational tools meeting these needs at present, the best strategy is to develop a well-designed theory- experiment collaboration focused on addressing promi- nent issues and testing important assumptions. Advances made for the FMO complex, the LH2 complex, and the PBPs of cryptophyte algae as reviewed here, provide lessons and future guidelines that can be applied to other LHCs with more complexity and larger scales. The results of various investigations on these three LHCs serve as concrete examples for addressing many im- portant issues concerning the excitons in LHCs. Among them, we discuss here three topics that are in fact in- timately connected together and have generated heated discussion and investigation in the past decade, namely, optimality (Cao and Silbey, 2009; Jang and Cheng, 2013; Jang et al., 2007, 2015; Mohseni et al., 2014), quantum coherence (Kassal et al., 2013; Olaya-Castro et al., 2012) and robustness (Chen et al., 2013; Cleary et al., 2013; Huh et al., 2013; Mohseni et al., 2014; Wu et al., 2012). In a sense, the fact that delocalized Frenkel excitons can be identified and used to understand spectroscopic data is a good evidence that the electronic quantum co- herence, defined here simply as having the quality of co- herent superposition of site excitation states, plays a sig- nificant role in the functionality of LHCs. However, this does not necessarily mean that a specific phase relation- ship defining a certain exciton state should be preserved, or change coherently, during a time interval comparable to that of exciton migration. Rather, the behavior of elec- tronic quantum coherence can be dynamic or inhomoge- neous (Ishizaki and Fleming, 2011). These two features make it extremely difficult to directly detect quantum coherences that are active in real time through a spec- troscopic measurement. On the other hand, such features may in fact play crucial role in positive and cost-effective utilization of quantum coherence for robust and optimal exciton dynamics. In other words, the vast parameter space of quantum superposition makes it possible for ex- citons to migrate through different regions while conserv- ing energy. In such dynamics, quantum coherence offers (i) redundancy to seek for alternatives when one path is blocked and (ii) buffering mechanism to help counteract negative effects of disorder and fluctuations. Thus, gen- uine understanding of efficient and robust exciton migra- tion in LHCs seems to require quantitative elucidation of such redundancy and buffering mechanisms, which in turn require a holistic approach that considers structure, energetics, dynamics, disorder, and fluctuations all to- gether. The fact that the rate-based ME approach provides a good description of exciton transfer dynamics in some LHCs (or some of their parts) does not necessarily mean that quantum coherence does not play a role as it has been often assumed. To the contrary, the rate behavior can be a manifestation of cumulation or averaging of all possible effects of quantum coherences. In other words, the extent to which certain signatures of quantum coher- ences become explicit can be different depending on the starting point or level of averaging. However, even when an apparent signature cannot be observed, underneath the apparent classical-like phenomenology, quantum dy- namical processes taking advantage of the coherently de- localized excitons can play important roles. There are two issues that have significant implications but were not addressed carefully in this work. One is the consideration of multiple exciton states and the other is the dynamics of excitons under natural light condi- tion. For a complete description of four-wave mixing spectroscopy and 2DES in particular, it is necessary to include the double exciton space in order to account for excited state absorption. Three kinds of double excitons can be created in general: (i) double excitation of a pig- ment molecule, (ii) double exciton in the same LHC; (iii) single excitons in almost two independent LHCs within the ensemble of spectroscopic measurements. Except for the trivial case of (iii), calculating energies and couplings that are relevant to (i) and (ii) are challenging, and can make the determination of the Hamiltonian much more complicated. Nonetheless, investigation of the character- istics of the double excitons and their dynamics have been shown to be useful even for understanding the behavior of single excitons (Bruggemann et al., 2001; Trinkunas et al., 2001). Another important issue is the understanding of the nature and the dynamics of excitons under natural inco- herent light sources from the sun and also how/whether lessons learned from femtosecond laser spectroscopy can be used to understand this issue (Brumer and Shapiro, 2012; Chenu et al., 2015, 2014). To this end, formulations involving excitations by steady incoherent light sources have been developed (Chenu and Brumer, 2016; Grinev and Brumer, 2015). Understanding this issue involves describing photons and their quantum mechanical inter- actions with nanoscale objects, and can best be studied through quantum optics experiments of clean and more well-controlled nanoscale experimental objects. 38 VIII. CONCLUSION AND OUTLOOK Experimental and theoretical evidences cumulated so far support that the majority of excitons residing in pig- ment molecules of LHCs can be well described by the Frenkel exciton theory. This is in contrast to the excitons found in most man-made solar energy conversion sys- tems. For example, excitons created in the first genera- tion semiconductor-based materials are dominantly Wan- nier excitons. Even for organic photovoltaic devices con- sisting of conjugated organic molecules, excitons tend to have intermediate character and cannot be represented by simple Frenkel exciton Hamiltonians. Why nature takes special advantage of Frenkel excitons, which have been difficult to utilize in man-made systems so far, is an interesting issue to investigate. A possible explana- tion based on current experimental and theoretical evi- dences is that it is related to the properties of proteins as insulating media and to their superb capability to fine tune excitation energies and spatial arrangement of pig- ment molecules. In other words, despite the short coher- ence length and fragility of Frenkel excitons compared to Wannier excitons, the versatility of proteins as host- ing environments allows connecting excitons in energet- ically and dynamically favorable ways, thereby making it possible to create efficient and robust exciton-relaying mechanisms. The three LHCs reviewed here exemplify different ways proteins can tune the properties of Frenkel excitons. For the case of the FMO complex, the main mechanism ap- pears to be the downhill structure of site excitation ener- gies through subtle interaction of BChl-protein interac- tions, whereas weaker electronic couplings and exciton- bath couplings, also realized through protein's capabil- ity to control arrangements of BChls, play supporting roles. For the case of the LH2 complex, circular arrange- ment of tens of BChls with nearest electronic couplings on the order of 200 − 300 cm−1 in the B850 unit, main- tained through stable coordination and hydrogen bonds to protein residues, seems to be the key feature. Be- cause the excitation-bath couplings are of moderate mag- nitudes (on the order of 100 cm−1), the band of dis- crete Frenkel exciton states spanning about 1, 000 cm−1 are dynamically well connected yet without losing their identity. Because of alternating in-plane directions of transition dipoles of α- and β-BChls, the lowest exci- ton state remains almost dark state, preventing radia- tive loss through super-radiance. For the case of PBPs, downhill structure of excitation energies by using differ- ent pigment molecules and large enough excitation-bath coupling (Dean et al., 2016; Killoran et al., 2015) real- ized through covalent bonds, provide efficient pathways for the migration of Frenkel excitons. Another important point to consider and, potentially, a good lesson for developing new generation of photovoltaic systems, comes from the observation of how LH and CS domains are put together in natural photosynthetic sys- tems. In all the cases known so far, the two domains are always separate, and back exciton transfer pathway from the CS domain to the LH domain is blocked as much as possible through ingenious mechanisms. There is also a "moderating" mechanism of exciton transfer from LH to RC so as to prevent too fast exciton transfer dynamics that can damage the CS capability. For purple bacteria, the moderating function is performed by the size of the LH1 complex; for green sulfur bacteria, the FMO com- plex serves such a role by acting as a moderating "valve" of excitons between chlorosome and reaction centers. In summary, LHCs are valuable natural systems that offer great insights into the quantum dynamics of co- herently delocalized excitons in disordered and insulat- ing host media. Experimental and theoretical studies of LHCs involve challenging issues of large scale excited state quantum dynamics in condensed and complex envi- ronments, and provide strong motivations and resources for further advances in these areas of research. Clear molecular level assessment of the natural design princi- ples of LHCs should be based on outcomes of these stud- ies, which in turn can guide the development of genuinely biomimetic solar light harvesting systems. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS SJJ acknowledges the support of the Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Department of Energy (Grant No. de- sc0001393) as major sponsor of this research, and the Na- tional Science Foundation (Grant. No. CHE-1362926) as the sponsor of research on quantum dynamics methods. SJJ also thanks Daniel Montemayor and Eva Rivera for their assistance. BM acknowledges the support of the European Research Council (ERC) through the Start- ing Grant, proposal No. 277755 (EnLight). We thank Greg Scholes, Thomas Renger, Jurgen Kohler, Young Min Rhee, and David Coker for offering data/images and for valuable comments. We also thank Tonu Pullerits and Donatas Zigmantas for discussion and comments. Appendix A: From molecular Hamiltonian to exciton-bath Hamiltonian: A review For the jth pigment molecule, Ψj(cid:105) is defined as the full and general molecular quantum state. We also ab- breviate the collective position state of all the nuclear coordinates of the jth chromophore as Rcj and define the corresponding position state as follows: Rcj(cid:105) ≡ Rj,1(cid:105)···Rj,Lj(cid:105) , (A1) 39 where the righthand side represents direct product of states representing Lj (3-dimensional) nuclear coordi- nates constituting the jth pigment, as has been indicated in the main text. Then, (cid:104)Rcj HjΨj(cid:105) =(cid:0)Tj,n(∇cj ) + Vj,nn(Rcj ) (cid:17)(cid:104)RcjΨj(cid:105) , + Hj,e(Rcj ) where Tj,n(∇cj ) = − Lj(cid:88) Lj(cid:88) l=1 2 2Mj,l Lj(cid:88) ∇2 j,l , (A2) (A3) (A4) 1 2 Vj,nn(Rcj ) = Zj,lZj,l(cid:48)e2 Rj,l − Rj,l(cid:48) , Hj,e(Rcj ) = Tj,e + Vj,en(Rcj ) + Vj,ee . l(cid:48)(cid:54)=l l=1 (A5) In the above expression, the definitions of Tj,e and Vj,ee can be found from Eq. (11). In addition, Vj,en(Rcj ) is a quantum operator with respect to the electronic degree of freedom, while depending parametrically on nuclear coordinates, as follows: Vj,en(Rcj ) = − Zj,le2 Rj,l − rj,i . (A6) Lj(cid:88) Nj(cid:88) l=1 i=1 a. Adiabatic approximation for each chromophore We denote the αth adiabatic electronic state of the jth chromophore at Rcj with eigenvalue Ej,α(Rcj ) as Ej,α(Rcj )(cid:105). Thus, Hj,e(Rcj )Ej,α(Rcj )(cid:105) = Ej,α(Rcj )Ej,α(Rcj )(cid:105) . (A7) Given that electrons are in one of the adiabatic electronic states, Ej,α(Rcj )(cid:105), for nuclei at Rcj , (cid:104)RcjΨj(cid:105) = Φj,α(Rcj )Ej,α(Rcj )(cid:105) , (A8) where Φj,α(Rcj ) is the nuclear wave function for the αth adiabatic state of the jth pigment. Alternatively, one can introduce a nuclear state Φj,α(cid:105) such that Φj,α(Rcj ) = (cid:104)RcjΦj,α(cid:105) . (A9) Inserting Eqs. (A8) and (A9) into the right hand side of Eq. (A2), we obtain (cid:16) (cid:17) Tj,n(∇cj ) + Vj,nn(Rcj ) + Hj,e(Rcj ) = Ej,α(Rcj )(cid:105)(cid:0)Tj,n(∇cj ) + Uj,α(Rcj )(cid:1) Φj,α(Rcj ) ×Φj,α(Rcj )Ej,α(Rcj )(cid:105) Lj(cid:88) (cid:0)∇j,lΦj,α(Rcj )(cid:1) ·(cid:0)∇j,lEj,α(Rcj )(cid:105)(cid:1) Lj(cid:88) 2 Mj,l 2 − l=1 Φj,α(Rcj )∇2 j,lEj,α(Rcj )(cid:105) , (A10) − 2Mj,l l=1 where Uj,α(Rcj ) is the effective nuclear potential energy for the αth adiabatic state of the jth pigment. It is the sum of the nuclear potential energy and the electronic energy as follows: resolution for the electronic degrees of freedom can be expressed as 1jk,e = Ej,α(cid:105)(cid:104)Ej,α ⊗ Ek,α(cid:48)(cid:105)(cid:104)Ek,α(cid:48) Uj,α(Rcj ) = Vj,nn(Rcj ) + Ej,α(Rcj ) . (A11) = Ej,α(cid:105)Ek,α(cid:48)(cid:105)(cid:104)Ej,α(cid:104)Ek,α(cid:48) . (A18) (cid:88) (cid:88) α (cid:88) (cid:88) α(cid:48) α α(cid:48) 40 Within the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, the derivatives of Ej,α(Rcj )(cid:105) with respect to Rcj can be ne- glected. In addition, assuming that the adiabatic elec- tronic state is insensitive to the small displacements of the nuclear coordinate around a reference nuclear coor- dinate R0 cj , we can approximate that Ej,α(Rcj )(cid:105) ≈ Ej,α(R0 cj )(cid:105) ≡ Ej,α(cid:105) , (A12) where we have assumed that R0 can be defined com- cj monly for all adiabatic states, namely, independent of α, for the jth pigment. Taking the inner product of (cid:104)Ej,α with Eq. (A2), em- ploying Eqs. (A8) and (A10), and applying the Born- Oppenheimer approximation, we obtain (cid:104)Ej,α(cid:104)Rcj HjΨj(cid:105) = (Tj,n(∇cj ) + Uj,α(Rcj ))Φj,α(Rcj ) = (cid:104)Rcj( Tj,n + Uj,α( Rcj ))Φj,α(cid:105) . (A13) The above relation holds for any value of Rcj (within the approximation of Eq. (A12)), and thus leads to the following identity: (cid:104)Ej,α HjΨj(cid:105) = ( Tj,n + Uj,α( Rcj ))Φj,α(cid:105) . (A14) Applying the same procedure as described above for all other adiabatic electronic states and considering linear combination of them, we can express the general molec- ular quantum state of the jth chromophore as follows: Cj,αΦj,α(cid:105)Ej,α(cid:105) , (A15) (cid:88) malization condition (cid:80) Ψj(cid:105) = α where Cj,α's are complex coefficients satisfying the nor- α Cj,α2 = 1. Applying Hj to Eq. (A15) and invoking the Born-Oppenheimer approx- imation for each adiabatic electronic state, we obtain HjΨj(cid:105) = Cj,α( Tj,n+Uj,α( Rcj ))Φj,α(cid:105)Ej,α(cid:105) . (A16) (cid:88) α This expression is equivalent to the following representa- tion of the Hamiltonian of the jth pigment molecule: (cid:88) ( Tj,n + Uj,α( Rcj ))Ej,α(cid:105)(cid:104)Ej,α . Hj = (A17) α The set of Ej,α(cid:105)'s forms a complete basis and constitutes the site basis of the Frenkel exciton states. In the direct product space of the electronic states con- stituting the jth and kth pigment molecules, the identity function: ρα(cid:48)(cid:48)α(cid:48) j (rj,1) = Nj Each term constituting Hjk of Eq. (12) can be projected into this basis of electronic states. The first term rep- resenting nuclear-nuclear repulsion, Vjk,nn, remains the same and diagonal in the electronic basis. The second term representing the attraction between electrons in the jth pigment and nuclei in the kth pigment can be ex- pressed as Vjk,ne = V α(cid:48)α(cid:48)(cid:48) jk,ne ( Rcj ) (cid:88) (cid:88) α α(cid:48),α(cid:48)(cid:48) ×Ej,α(cid:105)Ek,α(cid:48)(cid:105)(cid:104)Ej,α(cid:104)Ek,α(cid:48)(cid:48) , (A19) where V α(cid:48)α(cid:48)(cid:48) jk,ne ( Rcj ) = − Lj(cid:88) Nk(cid:88) (cid:104)Ek,α(cid:48) l=1 i=1 Zj,le2 Rj,l − rk,iEk,α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:105) . (A20) Similarly, the third term representing the attraction be- tween electrons of the jth pigment and the nuclei of the kth pigment can be expressed as (cid:88) (cid:88) Vjk,en = V αα(cid:48) jk,en( Rck ) α(cid:48)(cid:48) α,α(cid:48) ×Ej,α(cid:105)Ek,α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:105)(cid:104)Ej,α(cid:48)(cid:104)Ek,α(cid:48)(cid:48) , where (A21) (A22) V αα(cid:48) jk,en( Rck ) = − Lk(cid:88) l=1 Nj(cid:88) (cid:104)Ej,α Zk,le2 (cid:88) (cid:88) i=1 Vjk,ee = V αα(cid:48),α(cid:48)(cid:48)α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48) jk,ee Rk,l − rj,iEj,α(cid:48)(cid:105) . Finally, the fourth term representing repulsion between electrons of the jth and kth pigment can be expressed as α(cid:48)(cid:48),α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48) α,α(cid:48) Ej,α(cid:105)Ek,α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:105)(cid:104)Ej,α(cid:48)(cid:104)Ek,α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48) , (A23) where V αα(cid:48),α(cid:48)(cid:48)α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48) jk,ee Nj(cid:88) Nk(cid:88) = i=1 i(cid:48)=1 (cid:104)Ej,α(cid:104)Ek,α(cid:48)(cid:48) e2 rj,i − rk,i(cid:48)Ej,α(cid:48)(cid:105)Ek,α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:105) . (A24) We here define the following electron density matrix (cid:90)  Nj(cid:89) (cid:104)Ej,α(cid:48)rcj(cid:105)(cid:104)rcjEj,α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:105) , drj,i i=2 (A25) where rcj refers to the collection of all the electron co- ordinates of the jth pigment. For α(cid:48) = α(cid:48)(cid:48), this cor- responds to the single electron density at rj,1. On the other hand, for α(cid:48) (cid:54)= α(cid:48)(cid:48), it becomes the transition den- sity. All the interaction terms between different pigment molecules shown above can then be expressed in terms of the above electron density matrix. First, Eq. (A20) can be shown to be V α(cid:48)α(cid:48)(cid:48) jk,ne ( Rcj ) = − Nk(cid:88) (cid:104)Ek,α(cid:48)rck(cid:105)(cid:104)rck Lj(cid:88) Rj,l − rk,iEk,α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:105) Zj,le2 drck l=1 i=1 dr ρα(cid:48)(cid:48)α(cid:48) k (r) Zj,le2 Rj,l − r . Lk(cid:88) Nj(cid:88) (cid:104)Ej,αrcj(cid:105)(cid:104)rcj Zk,le2 Rk,l − rj,iEj,α(cid:48)(cid:105) (cid:90) Lj(cid:88) l=1 (cid:90) = − Similarly, V αα(cid:48) jk,en( Rck ) = − (cid:90) = − Lk(cid:88) (cid:90) drcj l=1 l=1 i=1 dr ρα(cid:48)α j (r) (cid:90) Zk,le2 Rk,l − r . (A27) On the other hand, the off-diagonal elements are given by (A26) (cid:104)sj Hcsj(cid:105) = (cid:104)g Hcg(cid:105) + Uj,1( Rcj ) − Uj,0( Rcj ) 41 where the product is over all k = 1,··· , Nc except for j. The molecular Hamiltonian for the aggregate of pig- ments, Hc, can be expressed in the basis spanned by g(cid:105) and sj(cid:105) as defined above by employing the expressions obtained in the previous subsection. First, the diagonal elements of Hc in the site excitation basis are given by (cid:104)g Hcg(cid:105) = (cid:17) (cid:16) Tj,n + Uj,0( Rcj ) Nc(cid:88) (cid:16) Nc(cid:88) (cid:88) j=1 Vjk,nn( Rcj , Rck ) + V 00 jk,ne( Rcj ) + 1 2 j=1 k(cid:54)=j (cid:17) +V 00 jk,en( Rck ) + V 00,00 jk,ee , (A31) (cid:16) Nc(cid:88) k(cid:54)=j + 1 2 (cid:104)sj Hcg(cid:105) = (cid:104)g Hcsj(cid:105) = kj,ne( Rcj ) jk,en( Rcj ) kj,ee + V 11,00 +V 11 +V 00,11 kj,ne( Rcj ) − V 00 V 11 jk,en( Rcj ) − V 00 kj,ee − V 00,00 (cid:16) Nc(cid:88) (cid:16) Nc(cid:88) k(cid:54)=j 1 2 1 2 k(cid:54)=j kj,ne( Rck ) + V 10 V 10 jk,ee jk,ee − V 00,00 (cid:17) (cid:17) jk,en( Rck ) kj,ne( Rck ) + V 01 V 01 jk,en( Rck ) (cid:17) . (A32) = J c,0 jg (A33) = J c,0 gj (A34) jk,ee = J c,0 jk , for j (cid:54)= k . (cid:104)sj Hcsk(cid:105) = V 10,01 In Eqs. (A33) and (A34), the fact that V 00,10 jk,ee = V 00,01 kj,ee = V 01,00 jk,ee = 0 has been used, which can be proved from the fact that the integration of the transition density over the entire electronic coordinates becomes zero. kj,ee = V 10,00 (A35) Let us define Nc(cid:88) Nc(cid:88) j=1 j=1 k(cid:54)=j Uj,0( R0 cj ) (cid:88) (cid:16) Ec,0 g = + 1 2 Vjk,nn( R0 cj , R0 ck ) + V 00 jk,ne( R0 cj ) +V 00 ) + V 00,00 jk,ee , (A36) (cid:17) jk,en( R0 ck ) − Uj,0( R0 ) − V 00 ) cj Ec,0 j = Ec g + Uj,1( R0 cj Nc(cid:88) (cid:16) k(cid:54)=j +V 11 + 1 2 kj,ne( R0 V 11 ck kj,ne( R0 ck ) jk,en( R0 ck kj,ee − V 00,00 ) − V 00 jk,en( R0 ck kj,ee + V 11,00 +V 00,11 ) jk,ee − V 00,00 jk,ee (cid:17) .(A37) Finally, it is easy to show that V αα(cid:48),α(cid:48)(cid:48)α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48) jk,ee = drdr(cid:48)ρα(cid:48)α j (r)ρα(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48)α(cid:48)(cid:48) k (r(cid:48)) e2 r − r(cid:48) . (A28) This corresponds to the Coulomb interaction term be- tween α → α(cid:48) electronic transition of the jth pigment and α(cid:48)(cid:48) → α(cid:48)(cid:48)(cid:48) electronic transition of the kth pigment. b. Hamiltonian in the site excitation basis The site basis for the electronic states of the aggre- gates of pigments can be constructed by taking direct product of all the adiabatic electronic states. For the sake of simplicity, we here assume that the index α can be represented by nonnegative integers and there is no degeneracy in the ground and the first excited adiabatic electronic states of each pigment. Thus, α = 0 represents the ground electronic state and α = 1 the first excited state of each pigment. First, the ground electronic state of the aggregates can be expressed as g(cid:105) = Ej,0(cid:105) . (A29) Nc(cid:89) j=1 The state where only the jth pigment is excited (site excitation state) is defined as (cid:89) k(cid:54)=j Ej,1(cid:105) , sj(cid:105) = Ek,0(cid:105) (A30) Collecting all the terms involving nuclear degrees of free- dom, we can also define Nc(cid:88) Nc(cid:88) j=1 (cid:16) Tj,n + Uj,0( Rcj ) − Uj,0( R0 (cid:16) (cid:88) ) cj (cid:17) j=1 k(cid:54)=j Vjk,nn( Rcj , Rck ) − Vjk,nn( R0 (cid:17) jk,ne( Rcj ) − V 00 jk,en( Rck ) − V 00 jk,ne( R0 cj jk,en( R0 ck c,j = Uj,1( Rcj ) − Uj,0( Rcj ) − Uj,1( R0 ) + Uj,0( R0 B0 cj , R0 ck ) +V 00 +V 00 cj cj ) ) , ) (A38) H 0 c,b = + 1 2 (cid:16) Nc(cid:88) k(cid:54)=j + 1 2 kj,ne( Rck ) − V 11 V 11 kj,ne( R0 ck ) −V 00 +V 11 −V 00 kj,ne( Rck ) + V 00 jk,en( Rck ) − V 11 jk,en( Rck ) + V 00 kj,ne( R0 ck jk,en( R0 ck jk,en( R0 ck ) ) ) (cid:17) . (A39) Collecting all these terms, we obtain the exciton-bath Hamiltonian defined by Eqs. (13). It is important to note that the ground electronic state and the single exciton state in this section has been defined as direct product of those of independent pigment molecules. In practice, these can be improved further by defining them as those accounting for the implicit effect of the other pigment molecules in the ground electronic states. Appendix B: Modeling of Environmental effects In the context of the modeling of electronic processes in embedded systems, the most used multiscale approach is that combining the QM description of the chromophores with a classical description of the environment. The suc- cess of such QM/classical formulation is mostly related to the accuracy with which the interactions between the QM and the classical parts are treated. Generally speak- ing, we can identify two different classes of QM/classical formulations, namely that describing the environment as a continuum, in terms of its macroscopic properties (QM/continuum), and that keeping an atomistic descrip- tion through MM force fields (QM/MM). Both methods allow to account for the presence of the environment in the description of a molecular system at an affordable computational cost, increasing both the possibilities of molecular modeling and the manifold of treatable sys- tems. In both versions of QM/classical models, an im- portant common aspect is that the QM part can be mod- ified in its electronic and nuclear degrees of freedom by the presence of the classical part. From a QM point of view, the Hamiltonian of the whole system can be written as: H = HQM + Henv + Hint (B1) 42 where HQM is the Hamiltonian of the gas-phase (iso- lated) QM subsystem, Henv is the Hamiltonian of the rest of the system, which is purely classical, and finally Hint represents the interaction between the QM and the classical parts. In the QM/classical models the degrees of freedom of the sole environment are not of great rele- vance. In continuum solvation models, the solvent atom- istic nature disappears together with the Henv term. In the case of QM/MM approach, Henv is maintained, but such term only adds a constant term to the total energy. In continuum models, the QM subsystem is placed in a suitably shaped molecular cavity C immersed in the di- electric medium representing the environment. The po- larization response of the medium to the QM charge dis- tribution is obtained by solving the Poisson equation of classical electrostatics (Tomasi et al., 2005). If we assume that the charge distribution (ρ) of the QM subsystem is entirely contained inside the cavity and that the dielectric outside the cavity is characterized by a scalar dielectric constant, we obtain (cid:40)−∇2V (r) = 4πρ(r) within the cavity −∇2V (r) = 0 outside the cavity (B2) A possible strategy to solve this equation is to write the electrostatic potential V as a sum of the solute potential plus the contribution due to the reaction of the environ- ment (i.e. the polarization of the dielectric). Among the possible approaches to define the reaction poten- tial, a very effective one is the apparent surface charges (ASC) approach, where an apparent surface density σ(s) spread on the cavity surface Γ is used to represent the reaction (polarization) of the dielectric (Tomasi et al., 2005). From a computational point of view, the solution is achieved by partitioning the cavity surface into a set of finite elements and substituting σ(s) with a set of point charges (qt), each corresponding to a surface element. There have been different definitions of qt proposed, leading to different formulations of the so-called Po- larizable Continuum Models (PCMs)(Mennucci, 2012), or to Conductor-like Screening Model (COSMO)(Klamt, 2011). Within this framework, the operator Hint in Eq. (B1) represents the electrostatic interaction between the QM charge density and the apparent charges on the sur- face of the cavity: Hint = HQM/PCM = qt VQM(rt) , (B3) t where qt is the ASC at the position rt in the Cartesian coordinate system, and VQM (rt) is the electrostatic po- tential operator due to the QM charge density calculated at rt. The summation runs over all the Nt surface ele- ments. Since HQM/PCM depends on the QM charge den- sity which is modified by the environment through Hint, a non-linear problem is obtained and its solution leads to a mutually polarized QM/continuum system. (cid:88) Continuum models are often the ideal strategy to ac- count for the bulk effects of the environment. On the other hand, the use of a structureless medium, does not allow to include the effects of the heterogeneity, as well as specific interactions between the two parts. In par- ticular, when the heterogeneity of the environment acts at a small scale as in a protein matrix, where each po- sition/orientation of the QM subsystem feels a different local environment or in the presence of specific interac- tions such as hydrogen bonds, an atomistic description is preferred. In these cases, QM/MM models represent a very effective strategy. However, they also suffer from a drawback: the QM-environment interaction depends critically on the configuration of the environment, par- ticularly those at short range. Therefore, to correctly account for the dynamical nature of the interactions, sev- eral configurations of the whole system need to be taken into consideration. This is not needed when a continuum approach is employed since it implicitly gives a configu- rationally sampled effect due to the use of macroscopic properties. Indeed, the sampling issue may introduce an additional difficulty related to the fact that it often in- volves classical MD simulation, which can incur errors resulting from the inaccuracy of the force-field used and the intrinsic approximation of classical MM simulations. In the most common formulation, the MM part of QM/MM systems is described through a set of fixed point charges, generally placed at the atoms of the envi- ronment. The QM/classical interactions are therefore of electrostatic nature. The MM charges are chosen to best represent the molecular electrostatic properties. Eventu- ally, higher multipole moments can be used to improve the electrostatic description. The Hint term in Eq. (B1) is given by the interaction between the electronic density of the QM subsystem ρs(r) and the MM charge distribution ( HQM/MM). Namely, Hint = HQM/MM = qm VQM(rm) , (B4) m where qm's are the fixed partial charges placed at position rm's in the Cartesian coordinate system and VQM (rm) is the electrostatic potential operator due to the QM charge density calculated at rm. The summation runs over all the number of charges. This scheme is also known as "electrostatic embedding" in the sense that the electronic structure of the QM part is modified by the presence of the charge distribution representing the environment and consequentially is polarized by it. However, the use of fixed point charges to describe the MM system implies that, while the QM density is polarized by the MM one, the opposite is not true. This is a serious limitation, as the explicit response arising from the environment po- larization can be crucial, particularly when charged or very polar systems are studied, or when electronic ex- citation processes are considered. In order to improve the QM/MM description, a possible strategy is to use (cid:88) 43 a "flexible" MM model which can be polarized back by the QM charge distribution. Three main groups of meth- ods include these mutual polarization effects (Mennucci, 2013; Senn and Thiel, 2009). In the induced dipole (ID) approach, atomic polarizabilities are assigned to atoms that lead to induced dipoles in the presence of an elec- tric field. The source of the electric field are the QM charge distribution, the MM point charges and the in- duced dipoles themselves. A self-consistent procedure is required to solve the QM/MM problem because the dipoles interact with each other and act back on the QM electron density. The parameters to be defined in addi- tion to the MM charges are the atomic polarizabilities. If Drude oscillators (DO) are used, instead, atoms are represented by a pair of point charges separated by a variable distance (namely a spring). When interacting with an electric field, a dipole is generated. The pa- rameters are the magnitude of the mobile charge and the force constant of the spring. Finally, when the fluctuating charges (FQ) model is used, charges placed on the atoms are allowed to fluctuate so as to represent the charge flow within the molecule. Two sets of atomic parameters are needed (hardness and electronegativities) as the model is based on the electronegativity equalization principle, which states that, at equilibrium, the instantaneous elec- tronegativity of each atom has the same value. In the ID approach, a set of atomic polarizabilities is assigned to MM atoms. The polarizability αi is a 3 × 3 tensor. However, in most formulations of the model, only isotropic component αiso is used. Within this framework, the induced dipole moment µ at the MM site i can be written as Eext i − Np(cid:88) j(cid:54)=i  µi = αiso i Tijµj (B5) i where Eext is the electric field due to the QM subsystem and the set of MM atomic charges. The Tij is known as the dipole-dipole interaction tensor and is defined as:  r2  Tij = fe r3 ij I − 3ft r5 ij rxry rxrz x r2 ryrz ryrx y r2 rzrx rzry z (B6) where I is the 3 x 3 unit tensor and rx, ry and rz are Cartesian components of the vector connecting the two atoms i and j. The fe and ft factors are distance- dependent screening functions that depend on the spe- cific dipole interaction models. In recent years, atomistic (MM) and continuum ap- proaches have been coupled to give fully polarizable QM/MM/continuum approaches (Boulanger and Thiel, 2012; Caprasecca et al., 2012; Lipparini and Barone, 2011; Steindal et al., 2011). In these methods, on top of the polarizable discrete model, one adds a further exter- nal polarizable continuum layer, coupled to the former. In this way the continuum description of the environment is combined together with the polarizable QM/MM, thus obtaining a three level model which allows to exploit the advantages of each method. The polarizable MM model is used to describe short-range directional interactions, whereas the continuum one accounts for long-range (or bulk) effects. When hybrid QM/classical models are used to describe ultrafast processes such as electronic excitations in em- bedded chromophores, a new aspect regarding the char- acteristic response time of the environmental degrees of freedom has to be taken into account. When a ver- tical excitation occurs, in fact, the electronic (or dy- namic) component of the response, which is assumed to be sufficiently fast, immediately follows any change in the chromophore charge distribution. On the contrary, the slower (or inertial) response that arises from nuclear and molecular motions remains frozen in its initial state. The possible delay of the slower component results in a nonequilibrium regime, which eventually relaxes into a new equilibrium where all the degrees of freedom of the environment reach the equilibrium with the excited state chromophore. Especially for highly polar environ- ments, equilibrium and nonequilibrium regimes represent very different configurations and their energy difference is generally known as "reorganization energy." The nonequilibrium regime can be properly taken into account with both the QM/continuum and QM/MM models. In the first case, if we adopt the ASC frame- work, the fast (or dynamic) response will be represented in terms of apparent charges obtained from the the opti- cal component (∞) of the dielectric permittivity instead of the static one. By contrast, the slow response is ob- tained as the difference of the equilibrium charges and the dynamic ones. In the QM/MM framework, instead, the slow component is automatically taken into account if the MM charge distribution does not change during the excitation process (charges are fixed in position and in value). For what concerns the fast component, this can be properly taken into account only if a polarizable embedding is considered. Appendix C: Lineshape and response functions The model considered here is more general than what is considered in the main text because we assume here that the EBH can have additional time dependence due to fluctuating energies and couplings. Thus, the total Hamiltonian including interaction with the radiation has the following form: 44 Nc(cid:88) Nc(cid:88) where Hint(t) is the matter-radiation interaction Hamil- tonian and Hex(t) = He(t) + Bjksj(cid:105)(cid:104)sk + Hb , (C2) j=1 k=1 with He(t) = Nc(cid:88) j=1 Ej(t)sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sj + Nc(cid:88) (cid:88) j=1 k(cid:54)=j Jjk(t)sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sk . (C3) The time dependences in Eg(t), Ej(t), and Jjk(t) repre- sent the influence of all other sources that are not rep- resented by the bath Hamiltonian. The details of these time dependent terms depend on specific experimental conditions under which a specific spectroscopic measure- ment is made. The eigenstates of He(t) are denoted as ϕj(t)(cid:105)'s, and we introduce Mkj(t) = (cid:104)skϕj(t)(cid:105). Thus, kj(t)ϕj(t)(cid:105) . (cid:88) sk(cid:105) = M∗ (C4) j The transition dipole vector for the excitation from g(cid:105) to sk(cid:105), µk, is assumed to be time dependent in general. Then, the polarization operator for the transitions to the single exciton space at time t is given by µk(t) (sk(cid:105)(cid:104)g + g(cid:105)(cid:104)sk) (Dj(t)ϕj(t)(cid:105)(cid:104)g + g(cid:105)(cid:104)ϕj(t)Dj(t)) ,(C5) (cid:88) (cid:88) where Dj(t) =(cid:80) P(t) = = k j kj(t). The time evolution operator for the total Hamiltonian Eq. (C1) is denoted as k µk(t)M∗ (cid:26) (cid:90) t t0 (cid:27) UT (t, t0) = exp(+) − i dt(cid:48) HT (t(cid:48)) , (C6) where (+) represents chronological time ordering. Thus, given that the total density operator at time t0 is prepared to be ρ(t0), at time t, it evolves into ρ(t) = UT (t, t0)ρ(t0) U† T (t, t0) . (C7) For the discussion that follows, it is convenient to in- troduce the total Hamiltonian (without matter-radiation interaction) in the ground electronic state and the man- ifold of single exciton states as follows: Hg(t) = Eg(t)g(cid:105)(cid:104)g + Hb , H(t) = Eg(t)g(cid:105)(cid:104)g + Hex(t) . (C9) (C8) We also denote the collection of all the time dependent parameters as HT (t) = Eg(t)g(cid:105)(cid:104)g + Hex(t) + Hint(t) , (C1) Γ(t) ≡ (Eg(t), Ej(t)'s, Jjk(t)'s, µk(t)'s) (C10) Ie = sj(cid:105)(cid:104)sj , 2. Emission (C14) 1. Absorption For t ≤ t0, the system is in the ground electronic state and the bath is in thermal equilibrium. Therefore, ρ(t0) = g(cid:105)(cid:104)gρb , (C11) where ρb = e−β Hb /T rb{e−β Hb} with β = 1/kBT . For a monochromatic radiation with frequency ω and polar- ization η, the matter-radiation interaction Hamiltonian (within the semiclassical approximation for the radiation and the rotating wave approximation) can be expressed as Hint(t) = Ae−iωtD(t)(cid:105)(cid:104)g + A∗eiωtg(cid:105)(cid:104)D(t) , (C12) where A is the amplitude of the radiation including the wave vector, and D(t)(cid:105) = η · Dj(t)ϕj(t)(cid:105) . (C13) Expanding Eq. (C7) up to the second order of Hint(t) and introducing the following identity operator in the single exciton space, (cid:88) j (cid:88) j the probability to find the population of exciton at time t, when approximated up to the second order of matter- radiation interaction, becomes (cid:90) t dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t t0 t0 1 2 (cid:90) t (cid:110) Ie U(t, t(cid:48)) Hint(t(cid:48)) (cid:111) (cid:110) Ug(t0, t(cid:48)(cid:48))g(cid:105)(cid:104)D(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Pe(t) = dt(cid:48)(cid:48) T r × U(t(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) U†(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0) Hint(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) U†(t, t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = A2 2 × Uex(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t(cid:48))D(t(cid:48))(cid:105)(cid:104)g Ug(t(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) dt(cid:48)(cid:48)eiω(t(cid:48)(cid:48)−t(cid:48))T r t0 t0 (cid:111) (cid:27) dt(cid:48) H(t(cid:48)) − i (C16) dτ Eg(τ )g(cid:105)(cid:104)ge− i Hb(t−t0) , (C17) , (cid:27) dt(cid:48) Hex(t(cid:48)) . (C18) where (cid:90) t (cid:90) t t0 t0 − i (cid:26) U(t, t0) = exp(+) − i(cid:82) t Ug(t, t0) = e Uex(t, t0) = exp(+) (cid:90) t (cid:26) t0 A2 2 Re Taking time derivative of Eq. (C15), one obtains Pe(t) = 2 d dt × g(cid:105)(cid:104)D(t) Uex(t, t(cid:48))D(t(cid:48))(cid:105)(cid:104)g Ug(t(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) dt(cid:48)eiω(t−t(cid:48))T r t0 .(C19) (cid:110) Ug(t0, t) (cid:111) 45 Let us introduce the following "ideal" lineshape by di- viding the above time derivative with appropriate nor- malization factor: Iid[ω, Γ(t)] = 2 Pe(t) 2πA2 d dt dt(cid:48) eiω(t−t(cid:48))e (cid:90) t i(cid:82) t (cid:110) Uex(t, t(cid:48))D(t(cid:48))(cid:105)(cid:104)D(t)ρbe t0 Re 1 = π ×T r t(cid:48) dτ(cid:48)Eg(τ(cid:48)) i Hb(t−t(cid:48))(cid:111) . (C20) In general, the absorption line shape can be defined as I(ω) = lim t→ts (cid:104)Iid[ω; Γ(t)](cid:105)Γ(t) . (C21) For the simple case where there is no time dependent fluctuation of Eg(t) and parameters constituting Hex(t), Eq. (C20) reduces to (cid:110) Iid(ω) = ×T r 1 π Re 0 dτ eiωτ e i τ Eg (cid:111) e− i τ HexD(cid:105)(cid:104)Dρbe i τ Hb (C22) Taking the limit of t − t0 → ∞ and making average over the disorder, orientation, and polarization leads to Eq. (49). . (cid:90) t−t0 Assume that the matter is in single exciton space and is in equilibrium at time t0. Then, the initial density operator can be expressed as ρ(t0) = e−β Hex(t0) T r{e−β Hex(t0)} . (C23) For the above initial density operator, following a pro- cedure similar to obtaining Eq. (C15), the population of the ground state at time t, when approximated up to the second order of matter-radiation interaction, can be shown to be (cid:110)g(cid:105)(cid:104)g U(t, t(cid:48)) Hint(t(cid:48)) (cid:111) (cid:110) Uex(t0, t(cid:48)(cid:48))D(t(cid:48)(cid:48))(cid:105)(cid:104)g × U(t(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) U†(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0) Hint(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) U†(t, t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = A2 2 × Ug(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t(cid:48))g(cid:105)(cid:104)D(t(cid:48)) Uex(t(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) dt(cid:48)(cid:48)eiω(t(cid:48)−t(cid:48)(cid:48))T r t0 t0 (cid:111) . (C24) (cid:90) t dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t t0 t0 1 2 (cid:90) t Then, 2 Eid[ω, Γ(t)] = d dt Pg(t) 2πA2 dt(cid:48) e−iω(t−t(cid:48))e− i(cid:82) t (cid:90) t (cid:110) Uex(t0, t)e− i (t−t(cid:48)) HbD(t)(cid:105)(cid:104)D(t(cid:48)) Uex(t(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) (cid:111) t(cid:48) dτ(cid:48)Eg(τ(cid:48)) t0 Re 1 = π ×T r (C25) . (C15) Pg(t) = dt(cid:48)(cid:48) T r In general, the emission line shape can be defined as where E(ω) = lim t→ts (cid:104)Eid[ω; Γ(t)](cid:105)Γ(t) . (C26) For the simple case where there is no time dependent fluctuation of Eg(t) and parameters constituting Hex(t), Eq. (C25) reduces to (cid:110) Eid[ω, Γ(t)] = ×T r 1 π Re 0 dτ e−iωτ e− i τ Eg (cid:111) e− i τ HbD(cid:105)(cid:104)Dρexe i τ Hex , (C27) (cid:90) t−t0 where ρex = e−β Hex/T r{e−β Hex}. Taking the limit of t − t0 → ∞ and making average over the disorder, orien- tation, and polarization of the above expression leads to Eq. (50). 46 (C33) dt dt(cid:48)(cid:48) U(tm, t) ρI (tm) = − i 3 × Hint(t) U(t, t(cid:48)) Hint(t(cid:48)) U(t(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) × U†(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0) Hint(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) U†(tm, t(cid:48)(cid:48)) , 0 0 (cid:90) tm (cid:90) tm (cid:90) t (cid:90) t dt(cid:48)(cid:90) tm dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t(cid:48) 0 0 0 0 dt dt(cid:48)(cid:48) U(tm, t0)ρ(t0) ρII (tm) = − i 3 × U†(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0) Hint(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) U†(t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hint(t(cid:48)) × U†(t, t(cid:48)) Hint(t) U†(tm, t) . (C34) In Eq. (C33), the integration over t(cid:48)(cid:48) can be split into three regions, 0 < t(cid:48)(cid:48) < t(cid:48), t(cid:48) < t(cid:48)(cid:48) < t, and t < t(cid:48)(cid:48) < tm. Relabeling the dummy time integration variables in each region such that t ≥ t(cid:48) ≥ t(cid:48)(cid:48), the three terms can be rewritten so as to have the same time integration bound- aries as ρII (tm). The resulting third order components can therefore be expressed as (cid:90) tm (cid:90) t dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t(cid:48) dt(cid:48)(cid:48) 4(cid:88) dt 0 0 0 j=1 Tj(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) (C35) T1(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) ≡ U(tm, t(cid:48)) Hint(t(cid:48)) U(t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hint(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) × U(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0)U†(t, t0) Hint(t)U†(tm, t) , T2(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) ≡ U(tm, t) Hint(t) U(t, t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hint(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) × U(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) U†(t(cid:48), t0) Hint(t(cid:48)) U†(tm, t(cid:48)) , T3(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) ≡ U(tm, t) Hint(t) U(t, t(cid:48)) Hint(t(cid:48)) × U(t(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) U†(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0) Hint(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) U(tm, t(cid:48)(cid:48)) , T4(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) ≡ U(tm, t0)ρ(t0) U†(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0) Hint(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) × U†(t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hint(t(cid:48)) U†(t, t(cid:48)) Hint(t) U†(tm, t) . (C36) (C37) (C38) (C39) The corresponding third order contribution to the po- larization can be calculated by taking the trace of the scalar product between P(tm), Eq. (C5), and ρ(3)(tm), Eq. (C35). The resulting expression for the third order polarization at time tm can be shown to be 4(cid:88) (cid:110) P(tm) Tj(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) (cid:111) 2 3 Im j=1 (cid:90) tm dt 0 , (C40) ¯P(3)(tm) ≡ T r{ P(tm)ρ(3)(tm)} = (cid:90) t dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t(cid:48) × dt(cid:48)(cid:48)T r 0 0 where "Im" implies imaginary part of the complex func- tion. Let us assume that we are interested in the polarization along the direction of ηm at time tm, and also define Dm(tm)(cid:105) = ηm · Dj(t)ϕj(t)(cid:105) , j Pmg(tm) = Dm(tm)(cid:105)(cid:104)g . (C41) (C42) (cid:88) 3. Four wave mixing spectroscopy ρ(3)(tm) = − i 3 For three incoming pulses, the matter-radiation inter- action Hamiltonian is given by +H.c. , where 3(cid:88) (cid:88) Hint(t) = Eν(t − tν) · Dj(t)ϕj(t)(cid:105)(cid:104)geikν·r−iων t j ν=1 +H.c. Eν(t − tν)Dν(t)(cid:105)(cid:104)geikν·r−iων t + H.c. . (C28) 3(cid:88) ν=1 = In the above expression, Eν(t − tν) = Eν(t − tν)ην, with Eν(t−tν) and ην respectively defining the amplitude and unit polarization vector of the νth pulse. It is assumed that t3 ≥ t2 ≥ t1. In the last line of Eq. (C28), Dν(t)(cid:105) is the sum of all the exciton states weighted by the com- ponents of the transition dipoles along the direction ην and has the following expression: Dν(t)(cid:105) = ην · Dj(t)ϕj(t)(cid:105) . (C29) j In representing the final expressions, it is useful to intro- duce the following polarization operators: Pgν(t) = g(cid:105)(cid:104)Dν(t) , Pνg(t) = Dν(t)(cid:105)(cid:104)g = P † gν(t) . (C30) (C31) Expanding UT (t, t0) and U† T (t, t0) with respect to Hint(t), and collecting all the terms of the third order, we find the following third order components of the density operator: † † ρ(3)(tm) = ρI (tm) + ρ I (tm) + ρII (tm) + ρ II (tm) , (C32) (cid:88) χ(2)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = T r (cid:110) Ug(tm, t) Pg3(t) Uex(t, t(cid:48)(cid:48)) 47 × P1g(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Ug(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) U† × Pg2(t(cid:48)) U† (cid:111) g (t(cid:48), t0) ex(tm, t(cid:48)) Pmg(tm) , (C48) (cid:110) Ug(tm, t) Pg3(t) Uex(t, t(cid:48)) χ(3)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = T r × P2g(t(cid:48)) Ug(t(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) U† × Pg1(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) U† , (cid:111) g (t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0) ex(tm, t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Pmg(tm) (cid:110) Ug(tm, t0)ρ(t0) U† (cid:111) ex(t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) P2g(t(cid:48)) U† g (t, t(cid:48)) ex(tm, t) Pmg(tm) . χ(4)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = T r × Pg1(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) U† × Pg3(t) U† g (t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0) (C49) (C50) The above general expressions for the response functions are equivalent to those in previous works (Cho, 2008; Cho et al., 2005; Jonas, 2003; Mukamel, 1995; Schlau- Cohen et al., 2011a) within the assumption that only single exciton states contribute. Fourier transforms of these with respect to t(cid:48) − t(cid:48)(cid:48) and tm − t can be related to the spectra of 2DES if proper averaging over the ensemble of disorder is made. Now, for the initial state given by Eq. (C11), the re- sponse functions can be simplified as follows: i(cid:82) t(cid:48) t(cid:48)(cid:48) dτ Eg(τ )e− i(cid:82) tm t e− i (tm−t(cid:48)) HbDm(tm)(cid:105)(cid:104)D2(t(cid:48)) Uex(t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) i (t−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hb U† ex(tm, t) , (C51) (cid:110) t (cid:110) χ(1)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = e ×T r × ρbD1(t(cid:48)(cid:48))(cid:105)(cid:104)D3(t)e χ(2)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = e− i(cid:82) tm ×T r × ρbD1(t(cid:48)(cid:48))(cid:105)(cid:104)D2(t(cid:48))e χ(3)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = e− i(cid:82) tm ×T r ×ρbD2(t(cid:48))(cid:105)(cid:104)D1(t(cid:48)(cid:48))e χ(4)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = e− i(cid:82) tm ×T r ×D2(t(cid:48))(cid:105)(cid:104)D3(t)e (cid:110) (cid:110) t i (t(cid:48)−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hb U† ex(tm, t(cid:48)) dτ Eg(τ )e− i(cid:82) t(cid:48) t(cid:48)(cid:48) dτ Eg(τ ) ,(C52) (cid:111) e− i (tm−t) HbDm(tm)(cid:105)(cid:104)D3(t) Uex(t, t(cid:48)) ex(tm, t(cid:48)(cid:48)) i (t(cid:48)−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Hb U† dτ Eg(τ )e− i(cid:82) t(cid:48) (cid:111) e− i (tm−t(cid:48)(cid:48)) HbDm(tm)(cid:105)(cid:104)D1(t(cid:48)(cid:48))ρb U† t(cid:48)(cid:48) dτ Eg(τ ) t i (t−t(cid:48)) Hb U† ex(tm, t) . ex(t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) (C54) ,(C53) dτ Eg(τ ) (cid:111) (cid:111) i(cid:82) t(cid:48) t(cid:48)(cid:48) dτ Eg(τ ) e− i (tm−t) HbDm(tm)(cid:105)(cid:104)D3(t) Uex(t, t(cid:48)(cid:48)) dτ Eg(τ )e 0 0 0 0 0 0 dt = e−i(k3+k2−k1)·rei(ω3t3+ω2t2−ω1t1) × dt(cid:48)(cid:48) ηm · T r (cid:90) tm (cid:90) t (cid:90) tm dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t(cid:48) dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t(cid:48) (cid:90) t dt 3 (t − t3)eiω3(t−t3)E∗ ×E∗ ×E1(t(cid:48)(cid:48) − t1)e−iω(t(cid:48)(cid:48)−t1) (cid:90) t (cid:90) tm (cid:90) tm dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t(cid:48) dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t(cid:48) (cid:90) t dt 3 (t − t3)eiω3(t−t3)E∗ ×E∗ ×E1(t(cid:48)(cid:48) − t1)e−iω1(t(cid:48)(cid:48)−t1) , (cid:90) tm (cid:90) t (cid:90) tm dt(cid:48)(cid:48) ηm · T r dt(cid:48)(cid:48) ηm · T r = e−i(k3+k2−k1)·rei(ω3t3+ω2t2−ω1t1) × dt 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (C44) (C45) 0 0 0 0 dt dt(cid:48)(cid:48)χ(3)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) (cid:111) (cid:110) P T3(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = e−i(k3−k2+k1)·rei(ω3t3−ω2t2+ω1t1) × dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t(cid:48) (cid:90) t dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t(cid:48) dt 3 (t − t3)eiω3(t−t3)E2(t(cid:48) − t2)e−iω2(t(cid:48)−t2) ×E∗ 1 (t(cid:48)(cid:48) − t1)eiω1(t(cid:48)(cid:48)−t1) , ×E∗ (cid:90) tm (cid:90) t (cid:111) (cid:110) P T4(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) (cid:90) tm dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t(cid:48) dt(cid:48)(cid:90) t(cid:48) (cid:90) t dt ×E∗ 3 (t − t3)eiω3(t−t3)E2(t(cid:48) − t2)e−iω2(t(cid:48)−t2) 1 (t(cid:48)(cid:48) − t1)eiω1(t(cid:48)(cid:48)−t1) . ×E∗ = e−i(k3−k2+k1)·rei(ω3t3−ω2t2+ω1t1) × dt(cid:48)(cid:48)χ(4)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) dt(cid:48)(cid:48) ηm · T r dt 0 0 0 0 0 0 (C46) where χ(k), k = 1 − 4, are response functions. Under the assumption that excited state absorption or double exci- ton formation can be neglected, these can be expressed as (cid:110) Ug(tm, t(cid:48)) Pg2(t(cid:48)) Uex(t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) χ(1)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) = T r × P1g(t(cid:48)(cid:48)) Ug(t(cid:48)(cid:48), t0)ρ(t0) U† × Pg3(t) U† ex(tm, t) Pmg(tm) g (t, t0) (cid:111) Then, taking scalar product of ηm with the integrand of Eq. (C40) and considering only those terms where inter- actions with E1, E2, and E3 occur in the chronological order at t(cid:48)(cid:48), t(cid:48), and t, respectively, we obtain the following general expressions: (cid:110) P T1(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) (cid:111) dt(cid:48)(cid:48)χ(1)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) 2 (t(cid:48) − t2)eiω2(t(cid:48)−t2) (C43) (cid:110) P T2(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) (cid:111) dt(cid:48)(cid:48)χ(2)(tm, t, t(cid:48), t(cid:48)(cid:48)) 2 (t(cid:48) − t2)eiω2(t(cid:48)−t2) , (C47) For the case where the Hamiltonians are time indepen- dent, the above expressions become Eqs. (51)-(54). 48 REFERENCES Abramavicius, D., L. Valkunas, and R. van Grondelle (2004), Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 6, 3097. Abramavicius, D., and S. Mukamel (2011), J. Chem. Phys. 134, 174504. Brixner, T., J. Stenger, H. M. Vaswani, M. Cho, R. E. Blankenship, and G. R. Fleming (2005), Nature 434, 625. Brotosudamo, T. H. P., R. Kunz, P. Bohm, A. T. Gardiner, V. Moulisov´a, R. J. Cogdell, and J. Kohler (2009), Bio- phys. J. 97, 1491. Bruggemann, B., J. L. Herek, V. Sundstrom, and V. May Abramavicius, D., B. Palmieri, D. V. Voronine, F. Sanda, (2001), J. Phys. Chem. B 105, 11391. and S. Mukamel (2009), Chem. Rev. 109, 2350. Bruggemann, B., and V. May (2004), J. Phys. Chem. B 108, Abramavicius, V., and D. Abramavicius (2014), J. Chem. 10529. Phys. 140, 065103. Brumer, P., and M. Shapiro (2012), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., Adolphs, J., F. Mueh, M. E.-A. Madjet, and T. Renger USA 109, 19575. (2008), Photosyn. Res. 95, 197. Adolphs, J., and T. Renger (2006), Biophys. J. 91, 2778. Agarwal, R., A. H. Rizvi, B. S. Prall, J. D. Olsen, C. N. Hunter, and G. R. Fleming (2002), J. Phys. Chem. A 106, 7573. Aghtar, M., U. Kleinekathofer, C. Curutchet, and B. Men- nucci (2017), J. Phys. Chem. B 121, 1330. Aghtar, M., J. Strumpfer, C. Olbrich, K. Schulten, and U. Kleinekathofer (2013), J. Phys. Chem. B 117, 7157. Aghtar, M., J. Strumpfer, C. Olbrich, K. Schulten, and U. Kleinekathofer (2014), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 5, 3131. Agranovich, V. M., and M. D. Galanin (1982), Modern Prob- lems in Condensed Matter Sciences: Vol.3, Electronic exci- tation energy transfer in condensed matter (North-Holland, Amsterdam). Agranovich, V. M., and R. M. Hochstrasser, Eds. (1982), Modern Problems in Condensed Matter Sciences: Vol.4, Spectroscopy and excitation dynamics of condensed molec- ular systems (North-Holland, Amsterdam). Alden, R., E. Johnson, V. Nagarajan, W. W. Parson, C. J. Law, and R. J. Cogdell (1997), J. Phys. Chem. B 101, 4667. van Amerongen, H., R. van Grondelle, and L. Valkunas (2000), Photosynthetic Excitons (World Scientific, River Edge, NJ). van Amerongen, H., and W. S. Struve (1991), J. Phys. Chem. 95, 9020. Buck, D. R., S. Savikhin, and W. S. Struve (1997), Biophys. J. 72, 24. Butkus, V., D. Zigmantas, L. Valkunas, and D. Abramavicius (2012), Chem. Phys. Lett. 545, 40. Cao, J., and R. J. Silbey (2009), J. Phys. Chem. A 113, 13825. Caprasecca, S., C. Curutchet, and B. Mennucci (2012), J. Chem. Theory Comput. 8 (11), 4462. Carbonera, D., G. Giacometti, U. Segre, E. Hofmann, and R. G. Hiller (1999), J. Phys. Chem. B 103 (30), 6349. Cartron, M. L., J. D. Olsen, M. Sener, P. J. Jackson, A. A. Brindley, P. Qian, M. J. Dickman, G. J. Leggett, K. Schul- ten, and C. N. Hunter (2014), Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1837, 1769. Caruso, F., A. W. Chin, A. Datta, S. F. Huelga, and M. B. Plenio (2009), J. Chem. Phys. 131, 105106. Caruso, F., A. W. Chin, A. Datta, S. F. Huelga, and M. B. Plenio (2010), Phys. Rev. A 81, 062346. Caycedo-Soler, F., F. J. Rodriguez, L. Quiroga, and N. F. Johnson (2010), Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 158302. Chandrasekaran, S., M. Aghtar, S. Valleau, A. Aspuru-Guzik, and U. Kleinekathofer (2015), J. Phys. Chem. B 10, 9995. Chandrasekaran, S., K. R. Pothula, and U. Kleinekathofer (2017), J. Phys. Chem. B 121, 3228. Chang, J. C. (1977), J. Chem. Phys. 67 (9), 3901. Chen, G.-Y., N. Lambert, C.-M. Li, Y.-N. Chen, and F. Nori (2013), Phys. Rev. E 88, 032120. Anda, A., T. Hansen, and L. D. Vico (2016), J. Chem. Theory Chen, L., R. Zheng, Q. Shi, and Y. Yan (2009), J. Chem. Comput. 12, 1305. Andreussi, O., S. Knecht, C. M. Marian, J. Kongsted, and B. Mennucci (2015), J. Chem. Theory Comput. 11 (2), 655. Bahatyrova, S., R. N. Frese, C. A. Siebert, J. D. Olsen, K. O. van der Werf, R. van Grondelle, R. A. Niederman, P. A. Bullough, C. Otto, and N. Hunter (2004), Nature 430, 1058. Berlin, Y., A. Burin, J. Friedrich, and J. Kohler (2007), Phys. Life. Rev. 4, 64. Phys. 131, 094502. Cheng, Y. C., and G. R. Fleming (2009), Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 60, 241. Cheng, Y. C., and R. J. Silbey (2006), Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 028103. Chenu, A., A. M. Branczyk, and G. D. Scholes (2015), Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 213601. Chenu, A., and P. Brumer (2016), J. Chem. Phys. 144, 044103. Blankenship, R. E. (2014), Molecular Mechanisms of Photo- Chenu, A., P. Mal'y, and T. Mancal (2014), Chem. Phys. synthesis, 2nd Ed. (Wiley Blackwell, Oxford). Book, L. D., A. E. Ostafin, N. Ponomarenko, J. R. Norris, and N. F. Scherer (2000), J. Phys. Chem. B 104, 8295. Bopp, M. A., Y. Jia, L. Li, R. J. Cogdell, and R. M. Hochstrasser (1997), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 94, 10630. Bopp, M. A., A. Sytnik, T. D. Howard, R. J. Cogdell, and R. M. Hochstrasser (1999), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 96, 11271. Boulanger, E., and W. Thiel (2012), J. Chem. Theory Com- 439, 100. Chenu, A., and G. D. Scholes (2015), Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 66, 69. Chin, A. W., A. Datta, F. Caruso, S. F. Huelga, and M. B. Plenio (2010), New J. Phys. 12, 065002. Chin, A. W., J. Prior, R. Rosenbach, F. Caycedo-Soler, S. F. Huelga, and M. B. Plenio (2013), Nature Phys. 9, 113. Cho, M. (2008), Chem. Rev. 108, 1331. Cho, M., H. M. Vaswani, T. Brixner, J. Stenger, and G. R. Fleming (2005), J. Phys. Chem. B 109, 10542. put. 8, 4527. Bricker, W. P., 118 (31), 9141. and C. S. Lo (2014), J. Phys. Chem. B Christensson, N., H. Kauffmann, T. Pullerits, and T. Mancal (2012), J. Phys. Chem. B 116, 7449. Bricker, W. P., and C. S. Lo (2015), J. Phys. Chem. B Cleary, L., H. Chen, C. Chuang, R. J. Silbey, and J. Cao 119 (18), 5755. (2013), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 110, 8537. Cogdell, R. J., A. Gali, and J. Kohler (2006), Quart. Rev. 49 Biophys. 39, 227. Cohen, G., E. Y. Wilner, and E. Rabani (2013), New J. Phys. 15, 073018. Cole, D. J., A. W. Chin, N. D. M. Hine, P. D. Haynes, and M. C. Payne (2013), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 4, 4206. Fenna, R. E., and B. W. Matthews (1975), Nature 258, 573. Ferretti, M., R. Hendrikx, E. Romero, J. Southall, R. J. Cogdell, V. I. Novoderezhkin, G. D. Scholes, and R. van Grondelle (2016), Sci. Rep. 6, 20834. Fleming, C. H., and N. I. Cummings (2011), Phys. Rev. E Collini, E., C. Y. Wong, K. E. Wilk, P. M. G. Curmi, 83, 03117. P. Brumer, and G. D. Scholes (2010), Nature 463, 644. Cotton, S. J., and W. H. Miller (2016), J. Chem. Theoy Comput. 12, 983. Croce, R., and H. van Amerongen (2014), Nat. Chem. Bio. 10, 492. Cupellini, L., S. Jurinovich, M. Campetella, S. Caprasecca, C. A. Guido, S. M. Kelly, A. T. Gardiner, R. Cogdell, and B. Mennucci (2016), J. Phys. Chem. B 120, 11348. Curutchet, C., J. Kongsted, A. M. noz Losa, H. Hossein- Nejad, G. D. Scholes, and B. Mennucci (2011a), J. Am. Chem. Soc. 133, 3078. Curutchet, C., J. Kongsted, A. Munoz-Losa, H. Hossein- Nejad, G. D. Scholes, and B. Mennucci (2011b), Journal of the American Chemical Society 133 (9), 3078. Curutchet, C., A. M. noz Losa, S. Monti, J. Kongsted, G. D. Scholes, and B. Mennucci (2009), J. Chem. Theory Com- put. 5, 18238. Fleming, G. R., and G. D. Scholes (2004), Nature 431, 256. Forster, T. (1948), Ann. Phys. 6, 55. Forster, T. (1959), Discuss. Faraday Soc. 27, 7. Fransted, K. A., J. Caram, D. Hayes, and G. S. Engel (2012), J. Chem. Phys. 137, 125101. Freiberg, A., S. Lin, K. Timpmann, and R. E. Blankenship (1997), J. Phys. Chem. B 101, 7211. Frenkel, J. (1931), Phys. Rev. 37, 17. Fujihashi, Y., G. R. Fleming, and A. Ishizaki (2015), J. Chem. Phys. 142, 212403. Fuller, F. D., and J. P. Ogilvie (2015), Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 66, 667. Georgakopoulou, S., R. N. Frese, E. Johnson, C. Koolhaas, R. J. Cogdell, R. van Grondelle, and G. van der Zwan (2002), Biophys. J. 82, 2184. Ghosh, P. K., A. Yu, and F. Nori (2009), J. Chem. Phys. 131, 035102. Curutchet, C., and B. Mennucci (2017), Chem. Rev. 113, Ginsberg, N. S., Y.-C. Cheng, and G. R. Fleming (2009), 294. Curutchet, C., V. I. Novoderezhkin, J. Kongsted, A. M. noz Losa, R. van Grondelle, G. D. Scholes, and B. Mennucci (2013), J. Phys. Chem. B 117, 4283. Acc. Chem. Res. 42, 1352. Grimme, S., and M. Waletzke (1999), J. Comp. Phys. 111, 5645. Grinev, T., and P. Brumer (2015), J. Chem. Phys. 143, Curutchet, C., G. D. Scholes, B. Mennucci, and R. Cammi 244313. (2007), J. Phys. Chem. B 111, 13253. Dahlbom, M., T. Pullerits, S. Mukamel, and V. Sundstrom (2001), J. Phys. Chem. B 105, 5515. Gulen, D. (1996), J. Phys. Chem. 100, 17683. Haken, H., and G. Strobl (1973), Z. Phys. 262, 5. Harel, E., and G. Engel (2012), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA Damjanovi´c, A., I. Kosztin, U. Kleinekathofer, and K. Schul- 109, 706. ten (2002), Phys. Rev. E 65, 031919. Davydov, A. S. (1971), Theory of molecular excitons (Plenum press, NewYork-London). Dean, J., T. Mirkovic, Z. S. D. Toa, D. G. Oblinsky, and G. D. Scholes (2016), Chem. 1, 858. Dempster, S. E., S. Jang, and R. J. Silbey (2001), J. Chem. Phys. 114, 10015. Dinh, T.-C., and T. Renger (2016), J. Chem. Phys. 145, 034105. Harrop, S. J., K. E. Wilk, R. Dinshaw, E. Collini, T. Mirkovic, C. Y. Teng, D. G. Oblinsky, B. R. Green, K. Hoef-Emden, R. G. Hiller, G. D. Scholes, and P. M. G. Curmi (2014), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., USA 111, E2666. Hayes, D., and G. S. Engel (2011), Biophys. J. 100, 2043. Hayes, D., G. Panitchayangkoon, K. A. Fransted, J. R. Caram, J. Wen, K. F. Freed, and G. S. Engel (2010), New. J. Phys. 12, 065042. Hein, B., C. Kreisbeck, T. Kramer, and M. Rodriguez (2012), Dost´al, J., J. Psenc´ık, and D. Zigmantas (2016), Nat. Chem. New. J. Phys. 14, 023018. 8, 705. Doust, A. B., C. N. J. Marai, S. J. Harrop, K. E. Wilk, P. M. G. Curmi, and G. D. Scholes (2004), J. Mol. Biol. 344, 135. Doust, A. B., I. H. M. van Stokkum, D. S. Larsen, K. E. Wilk, P. M. G. Curmi, R. van Grondelle, and G. D. Scholes (2005), J. Phys. Chem. B 109, 14219. Duan, H.-G., V. I. Prokhorenko, R. J. Cogdell, K. Ashraf, and R. J. Dwayne-Miller A. L. Stevens, M. Thorwart, (2017), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., USA 114, 8493. Duffy, C. D. P., J. Chmeliov, M. Macernis, J. Sulskus, and a. V. Ruban (2013), J. Phys. Chem. L. Valkunas, B 117 (38), 10974. Engel, G. S., T. R. Calhoun, E. L. Read, T.-K. Ahn, T. Man- cal, Y.-C. Cheng, R. E. Blankenship, and G. R. Fleming (2007), Nature 446, 782. Feng, J., C.-W. Tseng, T. Chen, X. Leng, H. Yin, Y.-C. Cheng, M. Rohlfing, and Y. Ma (2017), Nat. Commun. 8, 71. Herek, J. L., N. J. Fraser, T. Pullerits, P. Martinsson, T. Pol´ıvka, H. Scheer, R. J. Cogdell, and V. Sundstrom (2000), Biophys. J. 78, 2590. Hildner, R., D. Brinks, J. B. Nieder, R. J. Cogdell, and N. F. van Hulst (2013), Science 340, 1448. Hofmann, C., T. J. Aartsma, and J. Kohler (2004), Chem. Phys. Lett. 395, 373. Hossein-Nejad, H., C. Curutchet, A. Kubica, and G. D. Sc- holes (2011), J. Phys. Chem. B 115, 5243. Hoyer, S., M. Sarovar, and K. B. Whaley (2010), New. J. Phys. 12, 065041. Hsu, C.-P. (2009), Acc Chem Res 42 (4), 509. Hsu, C.-P., G. R. Fleming, M. Head-Gordon, and T. Head- Gordon (2001a), J. Chem. Phys. 114 (7), 3065. Hsu, C.-P., P. J. Walla, M. Head-Gordon, and G. R. Fleming (2001b), J. Phys. Chem. B 105, 11016. Hsu, C.-P., Z.-Q. You, and H.-C. Chen (2008), J. Phys. Chem. C 112 (4), 1204. Hu, X., T. Ritz, A. Damjanovic, F. Autenrieth, and K. Schul- Fenna, R. E., L. F. T. Eyck, and B. W. Matthews (1977), ten (2002), Quar. Rev. Biophys. 35, 1. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 75, 751. Hu, X., T. Ritz, A. Damjanovic, and K. Schulten (1997), J. 50 Phys. Chem. B 101, 3854. Kassal, I., J. Yuen-Zhou, and S. Rahimi-Keshari (2013), J. Huh, J., S. K. Saikin, J. C. Brookes, S. Valleau, T. Fujita, and Phys. Chem. Lett. 4, 362. A. Aspuru-Guzik (2013), J. Am. Chem. Soc. 136, 2048. Huo, P., and D. F. Coker (2010), J. Chem. Phys. 133, 184108. Huo, P., and D. F. Coker (2011), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2, Kell, A., K. Acharya, V. Zaaubovich, (2014), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 5, 1450. and R. Jankowiak Kell, A., X. Feng, M. Reppert, and R. Jankowiak (2013), J. 825. Phys. Chem. B 117, 7317. Hwang-Fu, Y. H., W. Chen, and Y.-C. Cheng (2015), Chem. Kelly, A., A. Montoya-Castillo, L. Wang, and T. E. Markland Phys. 447, 46. (2016), J. Chem. Phys. 144, 184105. Iles-Smith, J., A. G. Dijkstra, N. Lambert, and A. Nazir Kelly, A., and Y. M. Rhee (2011), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2, (2016), J. Chem. Phys. 144, 044110. 808. Iles-Smith, J., N. Lambert, and A. Nazir (2014), Phys. Rev. A 90, 032114. Kenkre, V. M., and R. S. Knox (1974), Phys. Rev. B 9, 5279. Kenkre, V. M., and P. Reineker (1982), Exciton Dynamics Iozzi, M. F., B. Mennucci, J. Tomasi, and R. Cammi (2004), in Molecular Crystals and Aggregates (Springer, Berlin). J. Chem. Phys. 120 (15), 7029. Kenny, E. P., and I. Kassal (2016), J. Phys. Chem. B 120 (1), Ishizaki, A., and G. R. Fleming (2009a), Proc. Natl. Acad. 25. Sci., USA 106, 17255. Ishizaki, A., and G. R. Fleming (2009b), J. Chem. Phys. 130, 234111. Ketelaars, M., A. M. van Oijen, M. Matsushita, J. Kohler, J. Schmidt, and T. J. Aartsma (2001), Biophys. J. 80, 1591. Ishizaki, A., and G. R. Fleming (2011), J. Phys. Chem. B Killoran, N., S. F. Huelga, and M. B. Plenio (2015), J. Chem. 115, 6227. Phys. 143, 155102. J. Strumpfer and K. Schulten, (2012), J. Chem. Phys. 137, Kim, C. W., B. Choi, and Y. M. Rhee (2018), Phys. Chem. 065101. Jang, S. (2007), J. Chem. Phys. 127, 174710. Jang, S. (2011), J. Chem. Phys. 135, 034105. Jang, S. (2012), Bull. Kor. Chem. Soc. 33, 997. Jang, S., T. Berkelbach, and D. R. Reichman (2013), New J. Chem. Phys. 20, 3310. Kim, C. W., J. W. Park, and Y. M. Rhee (2015), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 6, 2875. Kim, C. W., and Y. M. Rhee (2016), J. Chem. Theory Com- put. 12, 5235. Phys. 15, 105020. Kimura, A., and T. Kakitani (2003), J. Phys. Chem. B , Jang, S., J. Cao, and R. J. Silbey (2002a), J. Chem. Phys. 7932. 116, 2705. Klamt, A. (2011), Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Compu- Jang, S., and Y.-C. Cheng (2013), WIREs Comput. Mol. Sci. tational Molecular Science 1 (5), 699. 3, 84. Kleinekathofer, M. S. U., and M. Schreiber (2006), J. Chem. Jang, S., S. E. Dempster, and R. J. Silbey (2001), J. Phys. Phys. 124, 084903. Chem. B 105, 6655. Jang, S., S. Hoyer, G. R. Fleming, and K. B. Whaley (2014), Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 188102. Jang, S., Y. J. Jung, and R. J. Silbey (2002b), Chem. Phys. 275, 319. Kleinschmidt, M., C. M. Marian, M. Waletzke, S. Grimme (2009), J. Comp. Phys. 130 (4), 044708. and Knox, R. S. (1996), Photosynth. Res. 48, 35. Koepke, J., X. Hu, C. Muenke, K. Schulten, and H. Michel (1996), Structure 4, 581. Jang, S., M. D. Newton, and R. J. Silbey (2004), Phys. Rev. Kohen, D., C. C. Marston, and D. J. Tannor (1997), J. Chem. Lett. 92, 218301. Phys. 107, 5236. Jang, S., M. D. Newton, and R. J. Silbey (2007), J. Phys. Kolli, A., E. J. O'Reilly, G. D. Scholes, and A. Olaya-Castro Chem. B 111, 6807. Jang, S., E. Rivera, and D. Montemayor (2015), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 6, 928. Jang, S., and R. J. Silbey (2003a), J. Chem. Phys. 118, 9324. Jang, S., and R. J. Silbey (2003b), J. Chem. Phys. 118, 9312. Jang, S., R. J. Silbey, R. Kunz, C. Hofmann, and J. Kohler (2012), J. Chem. Phys. 137, 174109. Kondo, T., W. J. Chen, Chem. Rev. 117, 860. and G. S. Schlau-Cohen (2017), Konig, C., and J. Neugebauer (2012), Chem. Phys. Chem. 13, 386. Kreisbeck, C., and T. Kramer (2012), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. (2011), J. Phys. Chem. B 115, 12947. 3, 2828. Jankowiak, R., M. Peppert, V. Zazubovich, J. Pieper, and Krueger, B. P., G. D. Scholes, and G. R. Fleming (1998), J. T. Reinot (2011), Chem. Rev. 111, 4546. Phys. Chem. B 102, 5378. Jansen, T. L. C., and J. Knoester (2009), Acc. Chem. Res. 42, 1405. Jimenez, R., S. Dikshit, S. E. Bradforth, and G. R. Fleming (1996), J. Phys. Chem. 100, 6825. Jimenez, R., F. van Mourik, J. Y. Yu, and G. R. Fleming (1997), J. Phys. Chem. B 101, 7350. Jing, Y., L. Chen, S. Bai, and Q. Shi (2013), J. Chem. Phys. 138, 045101. Johnson, S. G., and G. J. Small (1991), J. Phys. Chem. 95, 471. Jonas, D. M. (2003), Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 54, 425. Jurinovich, S., C. Curutchet, and B. Mennucci (2014), Kumar, P., and S. Jang (2013), J. Chem. Phys. 138, 135101. Kunz, R., K. Timpmann, J. Southall, R. J. Cogdell, A. Freiberg, and J. Kohler (2012), J. Phys. Chem. B 116, 11017. Kunz, R., K. Timpmann, J. Southall, R. J. Cogdell, A. Freiberg, and J. Kohler (2014), Biophys. J. 106, 2008. Lambert, N., Y.-N. Chen, Y.-C. Cheng, C.-M. Li, and G.-Y. Chen (2013), Nature Phys. 9, 10. Lampoura, S., R. van Grondelle, I. H. M. van Stokkum, R. J. Cogdell, D. A. Wiersma, and K. Duppen (2000), J. Phys. Chem. B 104, 12072. Lee, M. K., K. B. Bravaya, and D. F. Coker (2017), J. Am. ChemPhysChem 15 (15), 3194. Chem. Soc. 139, 7803. Kananeka, A. A., C. Y. Hsieh, J. Cao, and E. Geva (2016), Lee, M. K., and D. F. Coker (2016), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 7, J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 7, 4809. 3171. 51 Lee, M. K., P. Huo, and D. F. Coker (2016), Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 67, 639. Leegwater, J. A. (1996), J. Phys. Chem. 100, 14403. Levi, F., S. Mostarda, F. Rao, and F. Mintert (2015), Rep. B. Rabenstein, H. Ishikita, E.-W. Knapp, and T. Renger (2007), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., USA 104, 16862. Muhlbacher, L., and U. Kleinekathofer (2012), J. Phys. Chem. B 116, 3900. Prog. Phys. 78, 082001. Mukai, K., S. Abe, and H. Sumi (1999), J. Phys. Chem. B Lindblad, G. (1976), Commun. Math. Phys. 48, 119. Lipparini, F., and V. Barone (2011), J. Chem. Theory Com- put. 7 (11), 3711. Liu, X., and O. Kuhn (2016), Chem. Phys. 481, 272. Liuolia, V., L. Valkunas, and R. van Grondelle (1997), J. Phys. Chem. B 101, 7347. Lohner, A., K. Ashraf, R. J. Cogdell, and J. Kohler (2016), Sci. Rep. 6, 31875. Lohner, A., A.-M. Carey, K. Hacking, N. Picken, S. Kelly, R. Cogdell, and J. Kohler (2015), Photosyn. Res. 123, 23. Louwe, R. J. W., J. Vrieze, A. J. Hoff, and T. J. Aartsma 103, 6096. Mukamel, S. (1995), Principles of Nonlinear Spectroscopy (Oxford University Press, New York). Munoz-Losa, A., C. Curutchet, I. F. Galv´an, and B. Men- nucci (2008), J. Chem. Phys. 129 (3), 034104. Nazir, A. (2009), Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 146404. Novoderezhkin, V. I., A. B. Doust, C. Curutchet, G. D. Sc- holes, and R. van Grondelle (2010), Biophys. J. 99, 344. Novoderezhkin, V. I., and R. van Grondelle (2017), J. Phys. B: Mol. Opt. Phys. 50, 124003. Novoderezhkin, V. I., M. Wendling, and R. van Grondelle (1997), J. Phys. Chem. B 101, 11280. (2003), J. Phys. Chem. B 107, 11534. Ma, J., and J. Cao (2015), J. Chem. Phys. 142, 094106. Madjet, M. E., A. Abdurahman, and T. Renger (2006), J. Oellerich, S., and J. Kohler (2009), Photosynth. Res. 101, 171. Phys. Chem. B 110, 17268. van Oijen, A. M., M. Ketelaars, J. Kohler, T. J. Aartsma, Madjet, M. E.-A., F. Muh, and T. Renger (2009), J. Phys. and J. Schmidt (1999), Science 285, 400. Chem. B 113 (37), 12603. Magdaong, N. C. M., R. G. Saer, D. M. Niedzwiedzki, and R. E. Blankenship (2017), J. Phys. Chem. B 121, 4700. McClure, S. D., D. B. Turner, P. C. Arpin, T. Mirkovic, and G. D. Scholes (2014), J. Phys. Chem. B 118, 1296. Olaya-Castro, A., A. Nazir, and G. R. Fleming, Eds. (2012), Phil. Trans. A, Vol. 370, no. 1972 - Quantum-coherent energy transfer: implications for biology and new energy transfer (Royal Society Publishing, London). Olaya-Castro, A., and G. D. Scholes (2011), Int. Rev. Phys. McCutcheon, D. P. S., and A. Nazir (2011), J. Chem. Phys. Chem. 30, 49. 135, 114501. Olbrich, C., and U. Kleinekathofer (2010), J. Phys. Chem. B McDermott, G., S. M. Prince, A. A. Freer, A. M. Hawthornthwaite-Lawless, M. Z. Paplz, R. J. Cogdell, and N. W. Issacs (1995), Nature 374, 517. 114, 12427. Olbrich, C., J. Strumpfer, K. Schulten, and U. Kleinekathofer (2011a), J. Phys. Chem. B 115, 8609. McRobbie, P. L., and E. Geva (2009), J. Phys. Chem. A 113, Olbrich, C., J. Strumpfer, K. Schulten, and U. Kleinekathofer 10425. (2011b), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2, 1771. Meier, T., V. Chernyak, and S. Mukamel (1997a), J. Chem. Olsen, J. D., J. D. Tucker, J. A. Timney, P. Qian, C. Vassilev, Phys. 107, 8759. and C. N. Hunter (2008), J. Biol. Chem. 283, 30772. Meier, T., V. Chernyak, and S. Mukamel (1997b), J. Phys. O'Reilly, E. J., and A. Olya-Castro (2014), Nat. Commun. Chem. B 101, 7332. 5, 3012. Meier, T., Y. Zhao, V. Chernyak, and S. Mukamel (1997c), Ostroumov, E. E., R. Mulvaney, R. J. Cogdell, and G. D. J. Chem. Phys. 107, 3876. Scholes (2013), Science 340, 52. Mennucci, B. (2012), WIREs Comput. Mol. Sci. 2, 386. Mennucci, B. (2013), Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 15, 6583. Mercer, I. P., Y. C. El-Taha, N. Kajumba, J. P. Marangos, J. W. G. Tisch, M. Gabrielsen, R. J. Cogdell, E. Springate, and E. Turcu (2009), Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 057402. Pach´on, L. A., and P. Brumer (2012), Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 14, 10094. Pajusalu, M., M. Ratsep, G. Trinkunas, and A. Freiberg (2011a), Chem. Phys. Chem. 12, 634. Pajusalu, M., M. Ratsep, G. Trinkunas, and A. Freiberg Miller, M., R. P. Cox, and J. M. Olson (1994), Photosyn. (2011b), ChemPhysChem 12 (3), 634. Res. 41, 97. Miller, W. H. (2001), J. Phys. Chem. A 105, 2942. Mirkovic, T., A. B. Doust, J. Kim, E. Wilk, C. Curutchet, B. Mennucci, R. Cammi, P. M. G. Curmi, and G. D. Sc- holes (2007), Photochem. Photobiol. Sci. 6, 964. Mirkovic, T., E. E. Ostroumov, J. M. Anna, R. van Grondelle, Govindjee, and G. D. Scholes (2017), Chem. Rev. 113, 249. Mohseni, M., P. Rebentrost, S. Lloyd, and A. Aspuru-Guzik (2008), J. Chem. Phys. 129, 174106. Palenberg, M. A., R. J. Silbey, C. Warns, and P. Reineker (2001), J. Chem. Phys. 114, 4386. Palmieri, B., D. Abramavicius, and S. Mukamel (2009), J. Chem. Phys. 130, 204512. Panitchayangkoon, G., D. Hayes, K. A. Fransted, J. R. Caram, E. Harel, J. Wen, R. E. Blankenship, and G. S. Engel (2010), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 107, 12766. Papiz, M. Z., S. M. Prince, T. Howard, R. J. Cogdell, and N. W. Isaacs (2003), J. Mol. Biol. 326 (5), 1523. Mohseni, M., A. Shabani, S. Lloyd, and H. Rabitz (2014), J. Park, J. W., and Y. M. Rhee (2012), J. Phys. Chem. B 116, Chem. Phys. 140, 035102. 11137. Moix, J. M., J. Wu, P. Huo, D. Coker, and J. Cao (2011), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2, 3045. Montemayor, D., E. Rivera, and S. J. Jang (2018), J. Phys. Chem. B 122, 3815. Mostovoy, M. V., and J. Knoester (2000), J. Phys. Chem. B 104, 12355. Mourokh, L. G., and F. Nori (2015), Phys. Rev. E 92, 052720. Muh, F., M. E. Madjet, J. Adolphs, A. Abdurahman, Pearlstein, R. M. (1992), Photosyn. Res. 31, 213. Pechukas, P. (1994), Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 1060. Pelzer, K. M., G. B. Griffin, S. K. Gray, and G. S. Engel (2012), J. Chem. Phys. 136, 164508. Pflock, T. J., S. Oellerich, L. Krapf, J. Southhall, R. J. Cogdell, G. M. Ullmann, and J. Kohler (2011), J. Phys. Chem. B 115, 8821. Pieper, J., M. Ratsep, I. Trostmann, H. Paulsen, G. Renger, 52 and A. Freiberg (2011), J. Phys. Chem. B 115, 4042. Scheuring, S., R. P. Goncalves, V. Prima, and J. N. Sturgis Plenio, M. B., J. Almeida, and S. F. Huelga (2013), J. Chem. (2006), J. Mol. Biol. 358 (1), 83. Phys. 139, 235102. Scheuring, S., and J. N. Sturgis (2005), Science 309 (5733), Plenio, M. B., and S. F. Huelga (2008), New J. Phys. 10, 484. 113019. Scheuring, S., and J. N. Sturgis (2009), Photosyn. Res. 102, Prandi, I. G., L. Viani, O. Andreussi, and B. Mennucci 197. (2016), J. Comput. Chem. 37, 981. Schlau-Cohen, G. S., A. Ishizaki, and G. R. Fleming (2011a), Prior, J., A. W. Chin, S. F. Huelga, and M. B. Plenio (2010), Chem. Phys. 386, 1. Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 050404. Prokhorenko, V. I., A. R. Holzwarth, F. R. Nowak, and T. J. Aartsma (2002), J. Phys. Chem. B 106, 9923. Schlau-Cohen, G. S., Q. Wang, J. Southall, R. J. Cogdell, and W. E. Moerner (2011b), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., USA 110, 10899. Pullerits, T., S. Hess, J. L. Herek, and V. Sundstrom (1997), Schmidt am Busch, M., F. Muh, M. E.-A. Madjet, and J. Phys. Chem. B 101, 10560. Purchase, R., and S. Volker (2009), Photosynth. Res. 101, 245. Rancova, O., and D. Abramavicius (2014), J. Phys. Chem. B 118, 7533. T. Renger (2011), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2, 93. Scholes, G. D. (2003), Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 54, 57. Scholes, G. D. (2010), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 1, 2. Scholes, G. D., C. Curutchet, B. Mennucci, R. Cammi, and J. Tomasi (2007), J. Phys. Chem. B 111, 6978. Rancova, O., J. Sulskus, and D. Abramavicius (2012), J. Scholes, G. D., and G. R. Fleming (2000), J. Phys. Chem. B Phys. Chem. B 116, 7803. 104, 1854. Ratsep, M., R. E. Blankenship, and G. J. Small (1999), J. Scholes, G. D., I. R. Gould, R. J. Cogdell, and G. R. Fleming Phys. Chem. B 103, 5736. (1999), J. Phys. Chem. B 103, 2543. Ratsep, M., and A. Freiberg (2007), J. Lumin. 127, 251. Ratsep, M., J. Pieper, K.-D. Irrgang, and A. Freiberg (2008), Schroter, M., S. D. Ivanov, J. Schulze, S. P. Polyutov, Y. Yan, T. Pullerits, and O. Kuhn (2015), Phys. Rep. 567, 1. J. Phys. Chem. B 112, 110. Read, E. L., G. S. Schlau-Cohen, G. S. Engel, J. Wen, R. E. Blankenship, and G. R. Fleming (2008), Biophys. J. 95, 847. Segatta, F., L. Cupellini, S. Jurinovich, S. Mukamel, M. Da- por, S. Taioli, M. Garavelli, and B. Mennucci (2017), J. Am. Chem. Soc. 139, 7558. Sener, M., J. Strumpfer, A. Singharoy, C. N. Hunter, and Rebentrost, P., R. Chakraborty, and A. Aspuru-Guzik K. Schulten (2016), eLife 5, e095421. (2009a), J. Chem. Phys. 131, 184102. Senn, H. M., and W. Thiel (2009), Angewandte Chemie (In- Rebentrost, P., M. Mohseni, and A. Aspuru-Guzik (2009b), ternational ed. in English) 48 (7), 1198. Sharp, L. Z., D. Egorova, and W. Domcke (2010), J. Chem. and Phys. 132, 014501. J. Phys. Chem. B 113, 9942. Rebentrost, P., M. Mohseni, I. Kassal, S. Lloyd, A. Aspuru-Guzik (2009c), New J. Phys. 11, 033003. Redfield, A. G. (1957), IBM Journal of Research and Devel- opment 1, 19. Renger, T. (2009), Photosyn. Res. 102, 471. Renger, T., A. Klinger, F. Steinecker, M. Schmidt am Busch, J. Numata, and F. Muh (2012), J. Phys. Chem. B 116, 14565. Renger, T., and R. A. Marcus (2002), J. Chem. Phys. 116, 9997. Renger, T., and V. May (1998), J. Phys. Chem. A 102, 4381. Renger, T., V. May, and O. Kuhn (2001), Phys. Rep. 343, 137. Renger, T., and F. Muh (2011), Photosyn. Res. 111 (1-2), 47. Renger, T., and F. Muh (2013), Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 15, 3348. Shi,, and Geva (2004), J. Chem. Phys. 120, 10647. Shim, S., P. Rebentrost, S. Valleau, and A. Aspuru-Guzik (2012), Biophys. J 102, 649. Silbey, R. (1976), Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 27, 203. Sisto, A., C. Stross, M. W. van der Kamp, M. O. S. M.- S. G. T. Johnson, E. G. Hohenstein, F. R. Manby, D. R. Glowacki, and T. J. Martinez (2017), Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 19, 14924. Skochdopole, N., and D. A. Mazziotti (2011), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2, 2989. Steindal, A. H., K. Ruud, L. Frediani, K. Aidas, and J. Kong- sted (2011), The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 115 (12), 3027. Stross, C., M. W. van der Kamp, T. A. A. Oliver, J. N. Har- vey, N. Linden, and F. R. Manby (2016), J. Phys. Chem. B 120, 11449. Ritschel, G., J. Roden, W. T. Strunz, and A. Eisfeld (2011), Strumpfer, J., and K. Schulten (2009), J. Chem. Phys. 131, New. J. Phys. 13, 113034. 225101. Ritz, T., S. Park, and K. Schulten (2001), J. Phys. Chem. B Strumpfer, J., M. Sener, and K. Schulten (2012), J. Phys. 105, 8259. Chem. Lett. 3, 536. Rosenbach, P., J. Cerrillo, S. F. Huelga, J. Cao, and M. B. Sturgis, J., J. D. Tucker, J. D. Olsen, C. N. Hunter, and Plenio (2016), New J. Phys. 18, 023035. Saga, Y., Y. Shibata, and H. Tamiaki (2010), J. Photochem. Photobiol. C: Photochem. Rev. 11, 15. Sarovar, M., A. Ishizaki, G. R. Fleming, and K. B. Whaley (2010), Nat. Phys. 6, 462. R. A. Niederman (2009), Biochemistry 48, 3679. Sumi, H. (1999), J. Phys. Chem. B 103, 252. Sumino, A., T. Dewa, T. Noji, Y. Nakano, N. Watanabe, R. Hildner, N. Bosch, J. Kohler, and M. Nango (2013), J. Phys. Chem. B 117, 10395. Savikhin, S., D. R. Buck, and W. S. Struve (1997), Chem. Sundstrom, V., T. Pullerits, and R. van Grondelle (1999), J. Phys. 223, 303. Savikhin, S., and W. S. Struve (1994), Biochemistry 33, 11200. Savikhin, S., and W. S. Struve (1996), Photosyn. Res. 48, 271. Phys. Chem. B 103, 2327. Tanimura, Y. (2006), J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 75, 082001. Tanimura, Y. (2015), J. Chem. Phys. 142, 144110. Tanimura, Y., and S. Mukamel (1993), Phys. Rev. E 47, 118. Tempelaar, R., T. L. C. Jansen, and J. Knoester (2014), J. 53 Phys. Chem. B 118, 12865. Phys. Chem. C 118 (43), 24854. Thyrhaug, E., K. Z´ıdek, J. Dost´al, D. B´ına, and D. Zigmantas Wang, X., G. Titschel, S. Wuster, and A. Eisfeld (2015), (2016), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 7, 1653. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 17, 25629. Timpmann, K., M. Ratsep, C. N. Hunter, and A. Freiberg (2000a), J. Phys. Chem. B 104, 10581. Timpmann, K., N. W. Woodbury, and A. Freiberg (2000b), J. Phys. Chem. B 104, 9769. Tiwari, V., W. K. Peters, and D. M. Jonas (2013), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 110, 1203. Wendling, M., M. A. Przyjalgowski, D. Gulen, S. I. E. Vulto, T. J. Aartsma, R. van Grondelle, and H. van Amerongen (2002), Photosyn. Res. 71, 99. Wilk, K. E., S. J. Harrop, L. Jankova, D. Edler, G. Keenan, F. Sharples, R. Hiller, and P. M. G. Curmi (1999), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., USA 96, 8901. Tomasi, J., B. Mennucci, and R. Cammi (2005), Chem. Rev. Wilkins, D., and N. S. Dattani (2015), J. Chem. Theory 105, 2999. Trinkunas, G., J. L. Herek, T. Polivka, V. Sundstrom, and T. Pullerits (2001), Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 4167. Trinkunas, G., O. Zerlauskiene, V. Urboniene, J. Chmeliov, and L. Valkunas (2012), J. Phys. A. Gall, B. Robert, Chem. B 116, 5192. Tronrud, D. E., J. Wen, L. Gay, and R. E. Blankenship (2009), Photosynth. Res. 100, 79. Tsuneda, T., and K. Hirao (2014), Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Computational Molecular Science 4 (4), 375. Tully, J. C. (2012), J. Chem. Phys. 137, 22A301. Turner, D. B., R. Dinshaw, K. K. Lee, M. S. Belsley, K. E. Wilk, P. M. G. Curmi, and G. D. Scholes (2012), Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 14, 4857. Urboniene, V., O. Vrublevskaja, G. Trinkunas, A. Gall, B. Robert, and L. Valkunas (2007), Biophys. J. 93, 2188. and A. Asupuru-Guzik (2012), J. Valleau, S., A. Eisfeld, Chem. Phys. 137, 224103. van der Vegte, C. P., J. D. Prajapati, U. Kleinekathoefer, J. Knoester, and T. L. C. Jansen (2015), J. Phys. Chem. B 119 (4), 1302. Viani, L., M. Corbella, C. Curutchet, E. J. O'Reilly, A. Olaya- Castro, and B. Mennucci (2014), Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 16, 16302. Viani, L., C. Curutchet, and B. Mennucci (2013), J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 4, 372. Vlaming, S. M., and R. J. Silbey (2012), J. Chem. Phys. 136, 055102. Voityuk, A. A. (2013), J Phys Chem C 117 (6), 2670. Voityuk, A. A. (2014), J. Chem. Phys. 140 (24), 244117. Vulto, S. I. E., M. A. de Baat, R. J. W. Louwe, H. P. Per- mentier, T. Neef, M. Miller, H. van Amerongen, and T. J. Aartsma (1998), J. Phys. Chem. B 102, 9577. Vulto, S. I. E., M. A. de Baat, S. Neerken, F. R. Nowak, H. van Amerongen, J. Amesz, and T. J. Aartsma (1999), J. Phys. Chem. B 103, 8153. Vura-Weis, J., M. D. Newton, M. R. Wasielewski, and J. E. Subotnik (2010), J. Phys. Chem. C 114, 20449. Wan, Y., A. Stradomska, S. Fong, Z. Guo, R. D. Schaller, G. P. Wiederrecht, J. Knoester, and L. Huang (2014), J. Comput. 11, 3411. Wong, C. Y., R. M. Alvey, D. B. Turner, K. E. Wilk, D. A. Bryant, P. M. G. Curmi, R. J. Silbey, and G. D. Scholes (2012), Nat. Chem. 4, 396. Wu, H.-M., M. Ratsep, R. Jankowiak, R. J. Cogdell, and G. J. Small (1997), J. Phys. Chem. B 101, 7641. Wu, H.-M., and G. J. Small (1998), J. Phys. Chem. B 102, 888. Wu, J. L., F. Liu, J. Ma, R. J. Silbey, and J. Cao (2012), J. Chem. Phys. 137, 174111. Xiong, S.-J., Y. Xiong, and Y. Zhao (2012), J. Chem. Phys. 137, 094107. Yang, C.-H., and C.-P. Hsu (2013), J. Chem. Phys. 139 (15), 154104. Yang, G., N. Wu, T. Chen, K. Sun, and Y. Zhao (2012), J. Phys. Chem. C 116, 3747. Yang, M., R. Agarwal, and G. R. Fleming (2001), J. Pho- tochem. Photobiol. A: Chemistry 142, 107. Yang, M., and G. R. Fleming (2002), Chem. Phys. 275, 355. Yeh, S.-H., J. Zhu, and S. Kais (2012), J. Chem. Phys. 137, 084110. You, Z.-Q., and C.-P. Hsu (2014), Int J Quantum Chem 114 (2), 102. Zerlauskiene, O., G. Trinkunas, A. Gall, B. Robert, V. Ur- boniene, and L. Valkunas (2008), J. Phys. Chem. B 112, 15883. Zhang, M.-L., B. J. Ka, and E. Geva (2006), J. Chem. Phys. 125, 044106. Zhang, W. M., T. Meier, V. Chernyak, and S. Mukamel (1998), J. Chem. Phys. 108, 7763. Zheng, F., S. Fernandez-Alberti, S. Tretiak, and Y. Zhao (2017), J. Phys. Chem. 121, 5331. Zheng, X., R. X. Xu, J. Xu, J. S. Jin, J. Hu, and Y. J. Yan (2012), Prog. Chem. 24, 1129. Zigmantas, D., E. L. Read, T. Mancal, T. Brixner, A. T. Gardiner, R. J. Cogdell, and G. R. Fleming (2006), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., USA 103, 12672. Zwier, M. C., J. M. Shorb, and B. P. Krueger (2007), J. Comput. Chem. 28, 1572.
1908.08376	1	1908	2019-08-22T13:44:36	Encounter rates between bacteria and small sinking particles	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.flu-dyn" ]	Bacteria in aquatic environments often interact with particulate matter. A key example is bacterial degradation of marine snow responsible for carbon export from the upper ocean in the biological pump. The ecological interaction between bacteria and sinking particles is regulated by their encounter rate, which is therefore important to predict accurately in models of bacteria-particle interactions. Models available to date cover the diffusive encounter regime, valid for sinking particles larger than the typical run length of a bacterium. The majority of sinking particles, however, are small, and the encounter process is then ballistic rather than diffusive. In the ballistic regime, the shear generated by the particle's motion can be important in reorienting bacteria and thus determining the encounter rate, yet the effect of shear is not captured in current encounter rate models. Here, we combine analytical and numerical calculations to quantify the encounter rate between sinking particles and non-motile or motile microorganisms in the ballistic regime, explicitly accounting for the hydrodynamic shear created by the particle and its coupling with microorganism shape. We complement results with selected experiments on non-motile diatoms. We find that the shape-shear coupling has a considerable effect on the encounter rate and encounter location through the mechanisms of hydrodynamic focusing and screening, whereby elongated microorganisms preferentially orient normally to the particle surface downstream of the particle (focusing) and tangentially to the particle surface upstream of the particle (screening). We study these mechanisms as a function of the key dimensionless parameters: the ratio of particle sinking speed to microorganism swimming speed, the ratio of particle radius to microorganism length, and the microorganism's aspect ratio.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Encounter rates between bacteria and small sinking particles Jonasz S(cid:32)lomka,1 Uria Alcolombri,1 Eleonora Secchi,1 Roman Stocker,1 and Vicente I. Fernandez1 1Institute of Environmental Engineering, Department of Civil, Environmental and Geomatic Engineering, ETH Zurich (Dated: August 23, 2019) Bacteria in aquatic environments often interact with particulate matter. A key example is bacte- rial degradation of marine snow responsible for carbon export from the upper ocean in the biolog- ical pump. The ecological interaction between bacteria and sinking particles is regulated by their encounter rate, which is therefore important to predict accurately in models of bacteria-particle in- teractions. Models available to date cover the diffusive encounter regime, valid for sinking particles larger than the typical run length of a bacterium. The majority of sinking particles, however, are small, and the encounter process is then ballistic rather than diffusive. In the ballistic regime, the shear generated by the particle's motion can be important in reorienting bacteria and thus determin- ing the encounter rate, yet the effect of shear is not captured in current encounter rate models. Here, we combine analytical and numerical calculations to quantify the encounter rate between sinking particles and non-motile or motile microorganisms in the ballistic regime, explicitly accounting for the hydrodynamic shear created by the particle and its coupling with microorganism shape. We complement results with selected experiments on non-motile diatoms. We find that the shape -- shear coupling has a considerable effect on the encounter rate and encounter location through the mech- anisms of hydrodynamic focusing and screening, whereby elongated microorganisms preferentially orient normally to the particle surface downstream of the particle (focusing) and tangentially to the particle surface upstream of the particle (screening). We study these mechanisms as a function of the key dimensionless parameters: the ratio of particle sinking speed to microorganism swimming speed, the ratio of particle radius to microorganism length, and the microorganism's aspect ratio. We find that non-motile elongated microorganisms are screened from sinking particles in ballistic interactions because shear aligns them tangentially to the particle surface. As a result, the en- counter rate is reduced by a factor proportional to the square of the microorganism aspect ratio as compared to a spherical microorganism. For motile elongated microorganisms, hydrodynamic fo- cusing increases the encounter rate approximately twofold compared to the case without shear when particle sinking speed is similar to microorganism swimming speed, whereas for very quickly sinking particles hydrodynamic screening can reduce the encounter rate below that of non-motile microor- ganisms. We apply these results to predict the encounter rates of submillimetric marine particles with bacteria under natural ocean conditions. In this size range, which covers the most abundant marine particles, the shear-induced reorientation competes with randomization of the swimming di- rection due to Brownian effects and run-and-tumble motility. We present comprehensive maps that connect the ballistic and diffusive limits and yield the encounter rate as a function of shape, motility and particle characteristics. Overall, our results indicate that hydrodynamic shear is important to consider in the colonization and ultimately degradation of marine particles, with a direct impact on which particles are colonized and where. Shear should thus be taken into account to predict the dynamics of settling particles responsible for the large carbon flux in the ocean's biological pump. I. INTRODUCTION Encounters involving small particles suspended in a fluid underpin many industrial, physical and biological processes. In papermaking, too high a collision rate be- tween cellulose fibers leads to excessive fiber flocculation and poor paper quality [1]. In the atmosphere, pre- cipitation formation relies on encounters between water droplets in clouds under the combined action of grav- ity and turbulence [2]. In the ocean, encounter rates between microscopic phytoplankton following a phyto- plankton bloom determine the formation of marine snow responsible for the biological pump, the vertical flux of carbon from the upper ocean to its depths [3]. Liv- ing organisms extend the complexity of the encounter processes occurring in non-motile systems by additional mechanisms. Microorganisms and plankton dwelling in the oceans can navigate through water in search of food and motility greatly enhances the encounter rates of these microscopic organisms with resource patches [4]. Com- pared to non-motile microorganisms, whose encounter rate is proportional to the low diffusivity associated with Brownian motion, motile microorganisms have a much higher (often, 100- to 1000-fold) encounter rate, since their motility effectively enhances diffusivity [4]. Of par- ticular importance for the biogeochemical cycles of car- bon in the ocean are the encounters between bacteria and sinking particles of organic matter. Once attached to a particle, bacteria can grow on it and solubilize it, thus re- ducing the flux of carbon to the deep ocean [5, 6], a fun- damental process in climate-relevant carbon dynamics. Accurate models of the encounter rate between bacteria and particles valid across a wide range of particle sizes are thus important to estimate the role of bacteria in the carbon pump. To date, however, encounter rate formu- lations have focused on the diffusive regime suitable for large particles. Here, we study the encounter between mi- croorganisms and sinking particles in the ballistic limit, relevant for the most abundant small particles, with fo- cus on the impact of fluid flow and the associated shear generated by the particle on the encounter rates. Theoretical estimates of the encounter rates between microorganisms and sinking particles have thus far pri- marily built on modeling microorganisms as spherical col- loids and motility as a diffusive process [7, 8]. These sim- plifying assumptions map the microbial encounter with particles onto the classical problem of heat and mass transfer [8, 9]. By construction, this approach assumes particles are larger than the run length of a bacterium. Since the latter is of the order of tens to hundred of mi- crons [8, 10], the diffusive approximation is limited to particles larger than several hundred microns. Yet, due to the power-law nature of the marine particle size spec- trum, the most abundant particles in the ocean have sizes below hundred microns [11]. In this increasingly ballis- tic regime, the coupling between the flow generated by the particle and the swimming of bacteria may domi- nate the bacterial orientational dynamics, in contrast to the diffusive regime [12]. There is substantial experimen- tal and theoretical evidence that fluid velocity gradients (shear) can dramatically modify the swimming trajecto- ries of microorganisms [13 -- 15]. A primary mechanism is shear-induced reorientation, whereby the torque as- sociated with fluid velocity gradients reorients microor- ganisms and thus impacts their swimming direction and where they end up in the flow. For example, a sim- ple parabolic flow can lead to shear-trapping and bac- terial accumulation near microchannel walls [14]. Shear- induced reorientation is a general phenomenon, applica- ble to any elongated bacteria that swim in flow, yet its impacts on the fundamental problem of the encounter rate between microorganisms and sinking aggregates in the ballistic range has to date not been considered. Here, we combine analytical and numerical calcula- tions with experiments to study encounters between non- motile and motile microorganisms and sinking particles in the ballistic regime, with focus on how the flow cre- ated by the particle affects bacterial trajectories and ul- timately the encounter rates. For the classical Stokes flow around a sphere, we show analytically that the ori- entational dynamics of elongated bacteria - unlike spher- ical particles - break the fore -- aft symmetry of the flow streamlines, with major consequences on encounter rates and attachment location. Non-motile elongated bacteria orient tangentially to the particle surface as they pass by the particle, which reduces their encounter rate by a factor proportional to the square of the bacterial as- pect ratio. For motile elongated bacteria, the encounter rate is very sensitive to the particle sinking speed rela- tive to the bacterial swimming speed. When both speeds are comparable, shear increases the encounter rate about twofold and leads to preferential attachment to the lee- ward side of the particle. For rapidly sinking particles, shear screens motile bacteria from the sinking particle 2 FIG. 1: The ballistic model of the encounter between bacteria and sinking particles includes the impact of shear on bacterial trajectories. (a) Spherical particle sinks under gravity with speed given by the Stokes law (1) and induces the Stokes flow (2) around it. Bacteria are modeled as self-propelled el- lipsoids of aspect ratio α with the center of mass x(t) and the tail-to-head orientation p(t) obeying Eq. (3). (b) Rep- resentative trajectories for a bacterium starting at [x, y, z] = R[2,−2,−2] with a random initial orientation (U/Ub = 3 and α = 10). Red (black) trajectories correspond to interceptions (misses). Interceptions are characterized by the landing posi- tion on the particle as well as the initial orientation. All such initial orientations define the interception probability starting at the given position [red points in the inset, Eq. (4)]. and surprisingly, the encounter rate drops far below the limit corresponding to non-motile bacteria. This work is organized as follows: we introduce the model of the encounter process and define the relevant observables in Section II. To quantify the impact of shear on bacterial orientation, we classify the asymptotic con- figurations that ellipsoids assume in general flows and then apply the results to the Stokes flow around a sphere in Section III. The encounter of non-motile and motile microorganisms with sinking particles is studied in Sec- tions IV and V. We discuss the biophysical consequences of our mechanistic description of the encounter process in Section VI and draw conclusions in Section VII. II. MODEL We model a marine snow particle as a sphere sinking in a quiescent fluid and bacteria as elongated and self- propelled ellipsoids (Section II A). The encounter process is quantified through encounter rate, encounter efficiency and distribution of interception locations (Section II B). A. Equations of motion The most abundant marine snow particles in the ocean have sizes in the range up to several hundred microns [11] and sinking speeds up to about a millimeter per sec- ond [16], which gives Reynolds number up to about 0.1. x/R02-2y/R2-20z/R2-20Umisshit (b)1.95-2.05-2-2-2.05-1.952.051.952hitinitial orientations:particle shadow2011-1001-1x(t)p(t)(a)2-6-40-2ρ/RRθUz/R2lbUb(cid:17)θ,(2) (cid:16) (cid:17) (cid:16) In this viscosity-dominated regime, the gravitational and viscous forces on the particle balance, implying that a spherical particle of radius R sinks at the constant ter- minal speed given by the Stokes law U = 2 9 ρp/ρw − 1 ν gR2, (1) where ρp and ρw are the densities of the particle and water, respectively, ν is the kinematic viscosity of water and g is the gravitational acceleration. In the reference frame fixed at particle and moving with it [Fig. 1(a)], the flow is described by the classic Stokes flow v = U cos θ 1 + R3 2r3 − 3R 2r r − U sin θ 1 − R3 4r3 − 3R 4r where U is the sinking speed given by Eq. (1). We model a bacterium as a small self-propelled elon- gated ellipsoid characterized by three parameters: length lb, aspect ratio α and swimming speed Ub. The position and orientation of the bacterium at time t are given by x(t) and p(t), where the latter (unit) vector points from the bacterial tail to its head [Fig. 1(b)]. The dynamics of x and p are governed by x = Ubp + v, p = (I − ppT)(γE + W )p. (3a) (3b) Eq. (3a) states that the total bacterial velocity x is a su- perposition of self-propulsion with speed Ub in the direc- tion p and the flow v (2) around the particle. Eq. (3b) is the classic Jeffrey equation for the orientational dy- namics of ellipsoids in flow [17]. The tensors E and W are the symmetric and anti-symmetric parts of the ve- locity gradient Aij = ∂jvi. The bacterial aspect ratio enters the dynamics (3) through the shape parameter γ = (α2 − 1)/(α2 + 1); it vanishes for spheres, is positive for elongated organisms and negative for oblate ones. B. Physical observables Let p(x, p) be the probability of an encounter between the sinking particle and a bacterium starting at the initial position x with head pointing in the direction p. For the ballistic model (3), p is either zero or one since the initial condition (x, p) determines a unique bacterial trajectory; when Eq. (3) is supplemented with rotational diffusion, p can take a range of values between 0 and 1. Averaging over random orientations yields the encounter probability P (x) for an initial position x (cid:90) P (x) = dpp(x, p). (4) Intuitively, P (x) is the relative solid angle extended by initial bacterial orientations that lead to the intercep- tion (red area in the inset of Fig. 1(b)]. Let (z, ρ, φ) be the cylindrical coordinate system with origin fixed at the 3 (cid:90) ∞ sinking particle. Due to rotational symmetry around the z-axis, we have P (x) = P (z, ρ). To define the encounter rate and interception efficiency, suppose that the sink- ing particle enters a region of uniform concentration n of randomly oriented bacteria. Let N (t, z) be the total number of encounters with bacteria that at time t are lo- cated at a z-plane below the sinking particle (upstream of the particle, z < 0) and collide with the particle at some later time. In a short interval (t, t + dt), the change in N due to the encounters with bacteria with initial positions 0 P (z, ρ)ρdρ. Therefore, for a constant sinking speed, the encounter rate d N /dt(z) is independent of time and is given by in the thin sheet (z, z + U dt) is 2πnU dt(cid:82) ∞ d N /dt(z) = 2πnU (5) For a z-plane far away from the sinking particle z (cid:29) R the fluid is practically undisturbed, making it meaningful to define the z-independent encounter rate N = dN/dt P (z, ρ)ρdρ. 0 N = d N /dt(z → ∞). (6) In simulations, we fix the starting plane at z = −6R, which amounts to making the approximation N ≈ d N /dt(z = −6R). To scale out the concentration n, we often focus on N /n, the 'encounter rate kernel' [8]. To further scale out factors intrinsic to the sinking par- ticle, the radius R and velocity U , we follow the notation used in filtration literature and define the dimensionless interception efficiency η as the ratio of volume cleared and volume swept by the particle [9] η = N /n πR2U = 2 R2 P (ρ)ρdρ. (7) Intuitively, η = 1 means that the sinking particle collects bacteria from a volume of water equal to the volume of the cylinder the particle sweeps. For small non-motile colloids, we expect η (cid:28) 1 because the colloids are con- strained to the flow streamlines, which limits the inter- ception to a narrow region near the particle centerline, the 'stagnation line' [Fig. 4(a) and Section IV A]. In addition to computing the encounter rate and en- counter efficiency, we will quantify the location on the sinking particle where the bacteria land. Let ξ(θ, φ) be the distribution of the interception locations, where θ and φ are the colatitude and the azimuth coordinates on the particle, respectively. We normalize ξ(θ, φ) as the probability density function over the unit sphere, ξ(θ, φ)dΩ = 1, where dΩ = sin θdθdφ. Rotational 0 symmetry implies that ξ(θ, φ) = ξ(θ). Finally, the mean interception colatitude is (cid:82) 2π (cid:82) π 0 (cid:90) ∞ 0 (cid:90) π (cid:90) 2π (cid:104)θ(cid:105) = (cid:90) π 0 0 θξ(θ) sin θdθ. θξ(θ, φ)dΩ = 2π (8) For example, 0° < (cid:104)θ(cid:105) < 90° (northern hemisphere, down- stream) implies preferential leeward attachment, while 90° < (cid:104)θ(cid:105) < 180° (southern hemisphere, upstream) indi- cates attachment to the front. 0 4 time limit of the Jeffrey Eq. (3b). Previous studies fo- cused on special cases with A derived from, for exam- ple, simple shear or rotational flows; in the former case the dynamics collapse onto one of the many degenerate limit cycles, the well-known Jeffrey orbits [17, 18]. For a random A, neglecting marginal cases, two scenarios are possible: either a rod asymptotically points towards the direction of the largest effective deformation rate or it rotates in a certain plane. The first possibility has been known [18] and corresponds to the rate of strain E out- competing the rate of rotation W . The second scenario complements the study in [19] and generalizes the Jef- frey orbits to generic rotational flows and arises when W dominates over E. Detailed derivations are given in the Appendices A 1 and A 2. The velocity gradient tensor A has nine components, eight of which are independent for an incompressible flow (since Aii = ∂ivi = 0). The symmetric part of A, the rate of strain E, describes the rate at which the fluid stretches and compresses [20]. The antisymmetric part W represents the fluid rate of rotation and is deter- mined by the vorticity ω = ∇ × u as Wij = − 1 2 ijkωk. Given A, it is the weighted sum Aγ = γE + W that en- ters the Jeffrey Eq. (3b), where γ is the shape parameter γ = (α2− 1)/(α2 + 1) determined by the organism aspect ratio α. In this notation, the Jeffrey Eq. (9) reads p = (I − ppT)Aγp. (9) Eq. (9) is a dynamical system on the unit sphere of ori- entations (Fig. 2). We first discuss the case of spherical microorganisms (α = 1, γ = 0) and then describe in de- tail the response of elongated bacteria (α > 1, γ > 0); the case of oblate microorganisms (α < 1, γ < 0) is dual to that of elongated ones. For spherical microorganisms, the shape parameter vanishes (γ = 0) and Eq. (9) simplifies to p = ω × p, 1 2 (10) where ω is the vorticity. Thus, spherical microorganisms respond to the fluid rotation but are unaffected by the fluid straining motion. Eq. (10) can be solved exactly in this case [18]: for a given initial orientation p(0), the so- lutions of Eq. (10) correspond to p(t) rotating around the vorticity vector ω and in the same sense as ω [Fig. 2(a)]. The angle between p(t) and ω is fixed by the initial orien- tation and the rotation rate is (cid:107)ω(cid:107)/2. Equivalently, the solutions to Eq. (10) on the unit sphere of orientations with ω pointing along the z-axis are given by the circles of a fixed latitude. Elongated or oblate microorganisms respond to both, the fluid rate of strain and rate of rotation. In this case, it appears impossible to find analytical solutions to Eq. (9); instead, standard dynamical system theory helps to identify the long-time response. Since the fixed points of Eq. (9) are given by the real eigenvectors of Aγ [18], it is the eigendecomposition of Aγ that deter- mines the asymptotic response. For a random Aγ, two FIG. 2: In flow, spherical bacteria rotate around the vorticity vector (a), whereas elongated or oblate ones eventually point in the direction of the largest effective deformation rate (b) or rotate in a certain plane (c). (a-c) Phase portraits of the Jeffrey Eq. (9) for the bacterial tail-head vector p(t) reorient- ing under the velocity gradient A for different A and aspect ratios α. (a) Spherical bacteria always rotate around the vor- ticity ω (z-axis). (b,c) Depending on the flow being strain- or rotation-dominated, elongated bacteria (or flat disks) eventu- ally point along the direction of the largest effective deforma- tion rate [z-axis in (b)] or rotate in the plane perpendicular to the real eigenvector of (Aγ)T [equator in (c)]. (d) Time se- ries of the components of p(t) for the case shown in (c). The rotation in the x − y plane is nonuniform: the rod acceler- ates when approaching the straining direction but slows down when near the axis of compression; the rotation frequency is given by the imaginary part of the complex eigenvalue of Aγ. Parameters: A = [0,−1/2, 0; 1/2, 0, 0; 0, 0, 0], α = 1 (a), A = [−3/4, 0, 0; 0,−1/4, 0; 0, 0, 1], α = ∞ (b) and A = [1/2, 1, 0;−1/4, 1/2, 0; 0, 0,−1], α = ∞ (c). III. ELLIPSOIDS IN FLOW Shear preferentially reorients rods and disks, such as elongated bacteria or flat diatoms, along certain direc- tions. Depending on the flow being strain- or rotation- dominated, ellipsoids eventually point in the direction of the largest deformation rate or rotate in a certain plane (Section III A). Applying this classification to the Stokes flow induced by the sinking particle reveals that ellipsoids - unlike spheres - break the fore-aft symmetry of the flow streamlines (Section III B). This quasi-static picture will be essential to rationalize the subsequent sim- ulations of the encounter problem as it underpins the phenomena of hydrodynamic focusing and screening. A. Ellipsoids in general flows The asymptotic orientation of a nonspherical microor- ganism held fixed in flow but free to reorient under the action of the velocity gradient A follows from the long- (a)(b)1-10pz1-10py01-1px10Reorientation speed ║p║.01-1px1-10py1-10pz(c)(d)pi-110pxpypz013Time2(d)1-10pz1-10py01-1pxcases are possible: either Aγ has three real eigenvalues or one real eigenvalue and two complex conjugate eigen- values. In the first case, the eigenvector corresponding to the largest positive eigenvalue is an attractive fixed point of (9) [Fig. 2(b)]. In the second case, when the real eigenvalue is positive, the corresponding eigendirection is still attractive, but once this eigenvalue is negative, the eigendirection becomes unstable and the dynamics col- lapse onto a limit cycle [Fig. 2(c)]. We next discuss these asymptotic scenarios in more detail. = 3 Let λi and λi, where i = 1, 2, 3, be the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of Aγ. The incompressibility of the flow re- quires that λ1 + λ2 + λ3 = 0. When all λi's are real, the Jeffrey Eq. (9) has three pairs of fixed points correspond- ing to p = ±λi. Assuming that λ1 < λ2 < λ3, the fixed points are respectively: a repulsive node (λ1), a saddle (λ2), and an attractive node (λ3). As a consequence, a random initial orientation eventually collapses onto the stable direction p = ±λ3 [Fig. 2(b)]. The timescale τλ3 associated with this reorientation is estimated as inverse of the average of the eigenvalues of the linearized ver- sion of Eq. (9) near the fixed point λ3 and is given by 2 λ3. Since the system orients along ±λ3, the case τ−1 λ3 when all λi's are real corresponds to the rate of strain E outcompeting the rate of rotation W . When Aγ has a pair of complex eigenvalues λ1 and λ∗ 1, and a real eigenvalue λ3, the eigenvectors corresponding 1} are complex, implying that there are only two to {λ1, λ∗ fixed points given by p = ±λ3. When λ3 > 0 (stretch- ing), the fixed point λ3 is an attractive spiral and repre- sents the asymptotic direction. The appearance of com- plex eigenvalues signals the raising importance of the rate of rotation W , but when λ3 > 0, straining still dominates the response. However, when λ3 < 0 (compression), the fixed point λ3 becomes a repulsive spiral and a stable limit cycle emerges. The timescale τλ3 of spiraling onto 2λ3. The limit cycle cor- or away from λ3 is τ−1 responds to a great circle; the circle lies in the plane (cid:48) 3, the eigenvector of the with normal direction given by λ transpose matrix Aγ T with eigenvalue λ3. Thus, when λ3 < 0, the asymptotic state of Eq.(9) corresponds to p (cid:48) 3 [Fig. 2(c)]. The an- rotating in the plane normal to λ gular frequency of the rotation is given by the imaginary part of the complex eigenvalue λ1 [Fig. 2(d)]. = 3 λ3 The above analysis applies to a velocity gradient Aγ under the assumption that all its eigenvalues are differ- ent; a separate analysis is required in the degenerate case. We next study A derived from the Stokes flow around a sinking sphere. B. Ellipsoids in the Stokes flow The above classification of the orientational response of a microorganism is now specified to the velocity gradi- ent derived from the Stokes flow (2). Physically, we de- scribe a bacterium rotating freely under shear but with the center of mass fixed at some position. Self-propulsion 5 and advection are still not included and this simplifi- cation makes analytical progress possible. The long- time orientation depends on bacterial position: spherical bacteria respond identically upstream and downstream of the sinking particle [Fig. 3(a)], whereas nonspherical ones break the streamline fore -- aft symmetry [Fig. 3(b,c)]. This symmetry breaking leads to hydrodynamic focus- ing and screening, crucial shear-induced mechanisms that impact the full encounter problem. Spherical bacteria respond solely to the fluid vorticity (Section III A), which for the Stokes flow (2) reads ω = − 3 2 U R sin θ r2 φ. (11) It follows from Eq. (11) that bacteria rotate around the azimuth φ, [Fig. 3(a)]. The rotation rate decays with the square of the distance from the particle; it is strongest to the side of the particle, near the equator θ = π/2 and vanishes near the stagnation lines θ = 0 and θ = π. In particular, the response of spherical bacteria preserves the fore-aft symmetry of the flow streamlines: at a fixed distance r, the bacterial rotation is identical at colati- tudes θ and π − θ. As discussed next, this symmetry is broken for elongated or oblate microorganisms. We focus on perfect rods of infinite aspect ratio α → ∞, for which the shape factor γ = 1 in the Jeffrey Eq. (3b) [Fig. 3(b)]. Note that moderate elongation gives γ close to unity: for an aspect ratio α = 10, γ ≈ 0.98. The analysis of the response of disks is dual to that of rods and we only state the results [Fig. 3(c)]. For per- fect rods, the rates of strain and rotation, E and W , are weighted equally in the Jeffrey Eq. (9), which reduces to (Aγ=1 = A) p = (I − ppT)Ap, (12) where A is the velocity gradient derived from the Stokes flow (2). For brevity, we take U = 1 and R = 1. In spher- ical coordinates {r, θ, φ} and in the usual basis of unit vectors {r, θ, φ}, the entries of A read (Appendix A 3, see also [21]) Aij = F (r, θ) 2 tan θ 0 −β(r) tan θ −1 0 0 −1 0 (13) where F = 3 cos θ(r−2−r−4)/4 and β = (r2 +1)/(r2−1). To classify the response of rods in the manner outlined in Section III A, we find the eigenvalues of A λ1,2 = F 2 9 − 4β tan2 θ λ3 = −F, , (14) (cid:17)  ,  (cid:16) 1 ±(cid:113) −3 ±(cid:112) and the corresponding eigenvectors λ1,2 = [1, 9 + 4β tan2 θ 2 tan θ , 0], λ3 = φ. (15) From the sing change under the square root in Eq. (14), it follows that the regions in the fluid in which A has 6 FIG. 3: Nonspherical microorganisms break the fore-aft symmetry of the Stokes flow around a sinking particle as revealed by their asymptotic orientation when held fixed in the flow. The velocity gradient A [Eq. (13)] determines the local long- time orientation of the bacterial tail-to-head vector p(t) (Fig. 2). (a) Spherical bacteria respond symmetrically upstream and downstream of the particle: p rotates around the vorticity ω ∝ φ and in the same sense as ω (arrow); the broken line indicates that there are many possible orbits [Fig. 2(a)]. (b) Perfect rods exhibit three regions of different asymptotic orientations. In regions I and III the rate of strain outcompetes the vorticity [Fig. 2(b)], whereas the vorticity dominates in the region II [Fig. 2(c)]. Specifically, in the upstream region I, bacteria eventually point along the azimuth p = ± φ. The two subregions inside the region I differ only by how the asymptotic orientation is attained (attractive node vs spiral). In region II, p eventually rotates in the plane perpendicular to φ [Fig. 2(c)]. The color code shows the rotation rate normalized by (cid:107)ω(cid:107)/2; the sense of rotation is the same as ω (solid line and arrow). In the downstream region III, p orients along the director field (white lines) defined by λ1 in Eq. (15). (c) For perfect disks, the response is a reflection of the case of perfect rods. (d) Ratio between the advective and reorientation timescales, τa and τr. For τa/τr (cid:29) 1, we expect non-motile microorganisms advected by the flow to follow the quasi-static reorientation effects described in (b,c); these reorientation effects are strongest near the sinking particle. this fixed point is an attractive spiral [as in Fig. 2(c) but with arrows reversed]. This change in the nature of the convergence of p onto φ indicates the increasing role of vorticity near the particle equator, but φ remains the at- tractive fixed point in region I because the fluid has to expand along the azimuth to accommodate the sinking sphere in that region. The timescale τI associated with convergence onto φ in region I is τ−1 2 λ3 = − 3 I = 3 2 F. three real eigenvalues or a pair of complex eigenvalues plus a real eigenvalue are separated by two surfaces of revolution defined by [broken red lines in Figs. 3(b,c)] r2(θ) = (9 + 4 tan2 θ)/(9 − 4 tan2 θ). (16) Furthermore, in the region with complex eigenvalues, the real eigenvalue, λ3 = −F (r, θ), changes sign from nega- tive to positive at the plane θ = π/2, which contains the sinking particle's equator. Physically, the sign change re- flects the transition of λ3 = φ from being the direction of fluid expansion to compression as the fluid parcels travel from the southern to the northern hemisphere. The sur- faces (16) and θ = π/2 divide the space outside the parti- cle into three regions I, II and III [Fig. 3(b)]. Region I is the bottom-half of the entire domain, below the equator plane θ = π/2 and upstream of the sinking particle. It is composed of two subregions, Ia and Ib, separated by the surface (16) [lower broken red line in Fig. 3(b)]. In Ia, all the eigenvalues are real, in Ib, there is a pair of com- plex eigenvalues and a positive real eigenvalue λ3 > 0. In both subregions, the rate of strain dominates over the rate of rotation and the asymptotic stable direction is given by the eigenvector λ3 = φ, which always points along the azimuth. The two subregions differ only in the manner this asymptotic orientation is approached: in Ia, the convergence is overdamped [as in Fig. 2(b)] since φ is an attractive node, in Ib, the convergence is under- damped with the bacterium spiraling down onto φ since Region II lies to the side of the particle, in between the equator plane and the surface (16) and is the only region in which the rotation rate out-competes the rate of strain. In this region, λ1,2 are complex and λ3 < 0; physically, the fluid is being compressed along the azimuth as it is rolling over the particle surface due to the no-slip bound- ary conditions. The analysis in Section III A implies that the rods eventually rotate in the plane orthogonal to the 4β tan2 θ − 9. Thus, rods azimuth with frequency F/2 orient orthogonal to the vorticity ω and rotate in the same sense as ω, but the rotation period is longer from the rotation rate of the fluid [color code in region II in Fig. 3(b)]. The timescale τII associated with the reori- entation from pointing along φ to rotating in the plane perpendicular to φ is given by τ−1 (cid:112) 2λ3 = 3 II = 3 Region III lies downstream of the particle, above the surface (16). Here, the strain once again dominates over rotation, but this time the asymptotic direction of rods in flow is given by the eigenvector λ1 [the white director field lines in Fig. 3(b)]. Importantly, just behind the 2 F . 0123ρ/R(a)z/R3-3-2-1102(d)Normalized vorticity ║ω║/(U/R)1.400.710210110010-110-2Advection-reorientation timescales τa/τrz/R3-3-2-11020123ρ/R(c)spheres (α=1, γ=0)(b)Rotation frequency / (║ω║/2)100.80.60.40.20123ρ/Rz/R3-3-2-1102region IIIrods (α=∞, γ=1) region Iaregion IIz/R3-3-2-1102disks (α=0, γ=-1) region Iregion IIregion IIIbp(t→∞)p(t→∞)p(t→∞)region Ibregion IIIa0123ρ/RRotation frequency / (║ω║/2)100.80.60.40.2(cid:16) 1 + (cid:17) . 2 λ1 = 3 4 F (cid:112) 9 − 4β tan2 θ particle, for small colatitudes θ, Eq. (15) clearly pre- dicts that the stable orientation is approximately the radial direction λ1 ≈ [1, 0, 0]. The timescale τIII asso- ciated with the reorientation from rotating in the plane perpendicular to φ in region II to pointing along λ1 is τ−1 III = 3 The response of perfect disks (α = 0, γ = −1) is dual to the case of perfect rods since Aγ=−1 = −E + W = −AT. For brevity, we only summarize the results, which are essentially an upside-down version of the responds of rods [Fig. 3(c)]. Upstream of the sinking particle, disks tend to be oriented almost tangentially to the particle, with their symmetry axis pointing in the nearly radial direction [region I, white director lines in Fig. 3(c)]. To the side of the particle, disks rotate, with their axis of symmetry spinning in the r− θ-planes (region II). Down- stream of the particle (region III), disks preferentially align with the r − θ planes with their axis of symmetry pointing along the azimuth. As for rods, the region III is divided into two subregions: in IIIa, φ is an attractive spiral, in IIIb it is an attractive node. The splitting of the fluid flow into the regions shown in Figs. 3(b,c) is a quasi-static characterization of the dynamical system (3), with microorganisms held fixed at a given position in the flow. However, a non-motile microorganism that is advected by the flow may be sig- nificantly displaced during the time it takes to achieve a given asymptotic orientation. To get further insight into Eq. (3), we compare the two timescales characteriz- ing the advection and shear-induced reorientation. For simplicity, we combine the three timescales τI,II,III asso- ciated with convergence onto the asymptotic solutions r ∼ to Eq. (3b) into a single reorientation timescale τ−1 F ∼ (cid:107)A(cid:107)2. We estimate the advective timescale τa ∼ R/(cid:107)v(cid:107) at a given position as the time needed to travel the distance R at the local speed (cid:107)v(cid:107). Fig. 3(d) shows the ratio τa/τr as a function of the position. In particular, in the bright oval near the particle τa > τr, indicating that, in that region, non-motile bacteria advected by the flow have enough time to orient under the fluid forces in the manner outlined in Figs. 3(b,c) for immobilized bacteria. Finally, we note that the eigenvalues of the velocity gradient A (13) on the stagnation line (θ = 0, π) and the particle surface (r = 1) have multiplicity greater than one. In this case, the analysis of Section III A does not directly apply, yet these special locations are important for the encounter process of non-motile microorganisms, which can only approach the sinking particle near the stagnation line θ = π. In Appendix A 4, we show that on the upstream stagnation line (θ = π) rods align tangen- tially to the sinking particle, while on the downstream stagnation line (θ = 0), rods align vertically. This pic- ture can be inferred from Fig. 3(b) by taking the limit ρ → 0. Similarly, disks align tangentially to the particle surface for θ = π (with axis of symmetry in the verti- cal direction), while they lie in the r − θ plane for θ = 0. Therefore, non-motile rods or disks approaching the sink- 7 ing particle along the θ = π stagnation line orient with their longer dimension tangential to the particle surface. Furthermore, on the particle surface, shear maintains to zeroth order the tangential orientation of rods and disks as they are advected around the sinking particle (Ap- pendix A 4). This suggests that it is the shorter dimen- sion of rods and disks that determines their collision with the particle. However, for any finite size microorganism, one must step away from the stagnation line and the particle surface. In the vicinity of these degenerate sets, the response is captured in Figs. 3(b,c). The asymptotic orientations rods and disks assume in their respective re- gions I suggest that the tangential orientation prevails. However, in regions II and III shear reorients rods and disks away from the tangential orientation. Given the size of the regions II and III for rods and disks, this re- orientation should be stronger for disks, since disks ex- perience it over a larger part of the particle surface. In the next section, we use numerical simulations to confirm this intuition: the collision radius of rods is determined by their width, not length, whereas for disks the collision radius is determined by the longest dimension. IV. NON-MOTILE BACTERIA AND DIATOMS Understanding the interception of non-motile elon- gated and oblate microorganisms by a sinking particle is important for two reasons. First, in its own right, be- cause many marine microorganisms including many bac- teria and phytoplankton species are non-motile and come in a variety of shapes, with bacteria often being spherical or elongated and phytoplankton being either elongated (e.g., chains), spherical or disk-lake (e.g., diatoms). Sec- ond, the non-motile case corresponds to the high sinking speed limit U/Ub → ∞ for motile bacteria. We predict drastically different encounter rates for rods and disks: rods are particularly inefficient at intercepting the sink- ing particle due shear, which aligns them in the direction tangential to the particle surface (Section IV A). Con- versely, disks eventually tumble under shear and explore their long axis to reach the collector. Experiments on elongated diatoms support this picture (Section IV B). A. Interception of non-motile bacteria The ballistic interception of non-motile microorgan- isms by a sinking particle is conceptually identical to the classical problem of filtration, in which a colloid is captured by a large collector [9]. Previous works focused on spherical colloids; through numerical simulations, we extend these results to nonspherical colloids. Rods and disks, such as certain species of bacteria or diatoms, have drastically different effective collision radii. Due to shear- induced reorientation, the collision radius for a rod is determined by its width rather than length, while disks explore their full size to intercept the collector. 8 dius is rc ≈ 1.4(lb/2); the additional 40% arise due to the squeezing of the streamlines near the collector. Had we traced the streamline all the way to z → −∞, the prefactor would change from 1.4 to 1.2 [9]. In general, rc depends very weakly on the size of spherical bacteria lb/R and the formula rc ≈ 1.4(lb/2) works very well for the bacterial sizes in the range 0 < lb/R < 1/10. Fi- nally, for spherical colloids, the effective collision radius and the encounter efficiency [Eq. (7)] are related as ηspheres = (rc/R)2. (18) We now turn to nonspherical organisms, for which the orientational dynamics can no longer be neglected. As nonspherical microorganisms follow the stream- lines, they can intercept the sinking particle using either their shorter or longer dimension. Two extreme scenar- ios are possible: an organism always aligns its longer side tangentially or perpendicular to the particle, which modifies its collision efficiency by a factor of α2. As- suming negligible rotational diffusion, shear impacts the orientation of nonspherical organisms only through the aspect ratio α. This follows from nondimensionalizing Eqs. (3) with Ub = 0 in terms of the particle radius R and timescale R/U . However, while the organism size lb does not directly affect the dynamics, it determines the interception criterion: we take the sinking particle to be a perfect absorber and stop simulations if any part of the rod or disk touches the particle (Appendix A 5). We now systematically vary α and lb/R and measure the encounter probability and typical interception location. The impact of the microorganism aspect ratio α and its relative size lb/R on the encounter problem is sum- marized in Figs. 4(b -- d); lb denotes the longer dimen- sion - length for elongated organisms, width for oblate ones. Varying α [Fig. 4(b)] at fixed R/lb = 10, shows that the collision radius of elongated microorganisms is determined by their width, not length (Movie 1). This is evident from the variation of P (ρ), the interception probability for an initial position at distance ρ from the centerline: P (ρ) decreases sharply from one once ρ > rc/α. The probability tail between rc/α < ρ < rc indicates that rods occasionally reorient and use their length to intercept the particle (Movie 2). However, shear largely suppresses this effect, see the light blue broken line in Fig. 4(b), which represents trajectories without the shear-induced reorientation (parallel transport). In contrast to elongated microorganisms, oblate organisms (disks) utilize their full size to intercept the particle - P (ρ) drops sharply from one to zero near rc. To see the impact of varying the relative size R/lb, we fixed two as- pect ratios, α = 10 [Fig. 4(c)] and α = 0.1 [Fig. 4(d)] and computed P (ρ) as well as the distribution ξ(θ) for R/lb = 10, 100. We observe that, as the colloid gets smaller (or the sinking particle gets larger), the effects described above become more pronounced, in the sense that for rods the probability tail between rc/α < ρ < rc shrinks, whereas for disks P (ρ) approaches a step func- tion with jump at rc. Therefore, the formula (18) for the FIG. 4: Generalizing the classical ballistic interception prob- lem to nonspherical colloids reveals that shear orients non- motile elongated microorganisms tangentially to the sinking particle surface, while oblate organisms tumble near the par- ticle. (a) For spherical organisms, the effective collision radius rc is defined by the critical streamline beyond which no inter- ception occurs (white line). (b) Encounter probability P (ρ) as a function of distance ρ from the origin in the initial plane z = −6R for different aspect ratios α. For spheres and disks, P (ρ) drops from 1 to 0 near rc, whereas for rods the drop oc- curs near rc/α. (c) The probability P (ρ) for rods (α = 10) for two different sizes R/lb = 10, 100 shows that the probability tail between rc/α and rc vanishes as the sinking particle size grows (or the rod becomes smaller). The tail arises to due rare tumbling events to the leeward side of the particle (Movie 2), as can be seen from the distribution of the interception co- latitudes ξ(θ) (inset). (d) Conversely, P (ρ) for α = 0.1 for R/lb = 10, 100 demonstrates that disks tumble very often - as the particle grows, P (ρ) approaches a step function at rc. First, we briefly review the classical interception of small non-motile spherical beads by a large spherical col- lector. The reorientation of beads under the flow does not affect the interception problem, which reduces to identi- fying the streamline of closest approach [Fig. 4(a)]. For the Stokes flow (2), the stream-function is given by (R/r)3(cid:17) sin2 θ. (17) U r2(cid:16) ψ(r, θ) = 1 2 1 − 3 2 R/r + 1 2 The streamlines determined by Eq. (17) have the fore -- aft symmetry, which implies that the critical streamline separating captures from misses is defined by the point r = R + lb/2 and θ = π/2. Tracing the streamline up- stream from this point to z = −6R, where we start the simulations, defines the effective collision radius rc. For a spherical bacterium with lb/R = 1/10, the collision ra- (a)(b)R/lb=102-6-40z/R-202ρ/R00.7501.5-5.5-1.50lb/2-6rc~1.4 (lb/2)lb(c)(d)α=10, γ=0.98R/lb=10R/lb=100α=0.1, γ=-0.98R/lb=10R/lb=10010-210-445°135°180°Colatitude θ90°1ξ(θ)20×10-2rc/αα=1α=2α=10α=.5α=.1lblbα=10, no shear01.5Encounter prob. P(ρ)ξ(θ)45°135°180°Colatitude θ90°01.5Encounter prob. P(ρ)01.5Encounter prob. P(ρ)00.40.8ρ/lbrc00.40.8ρ/lbrc00.40.8ρ/lbrcRθ9 FIG. 5: Experiments with non-motile elongated diatom cells (Phaeodactylum tricornutum) are consistent with the predictions of the model [Eq. (3)] that rods maintain tangential orientation as they are advected around a sinking particle (Section IV A). (a) Minimum intensity projection obtained by phase contrast microscopy shows the streamlines of the suspended diatoms around the alginate particle (Movie 3). (b) The experimental ensemble of diatom positions (dots) and the sine of the angle the diatoms make with the flow direction (see colorbar). (c) The corresponding ensemble obtained from simulations, in which we mimic the same information loss as in the experiment: the plot represents rods lying in the focal plane and we dismiss rods with a significant out-of plane component, see text for more details. As predicted in Section A 4, we observe that rods approaching the particle near the upstream stagnation line orient tangentially to the particle [yellow region below the particle in (b,c)], while rods that leave the particle near the downstream stagnation line point nearly radially (blue region above the particle). As they travel near the particle surface, rods tend to maintain tangential orientation but also occasionally tumble. encounter efficiency by spherical colloids is replaced by ηrods = [rc/(αR)]2 = ηspheres/α2, ηdisks = ηspheres (19) in the case of (small R/lb (cid:29) 10) nonspherical colloids, where rods means α (cid:29) 1 and disks α (cid:28) 1. Different interception efficiency for rods but not disks as compared to spherical colloids is consistent with the analytical arguments presented in Section III B. Initially, shear aligns rods and disks tangentially to the sinking particle surface as they approach it along the stagnation line [regions I in Figs. 3(b,c)]. As they slide near the particle, both rods and disks experience shear that tries to reorient them away from the tangential configuration, potentially increasing their chance to intercept the par- ticle [region II in Fig. 3(b) for rods and regions II and IIIa in Fig. 3(c) for disks]. However, disks are exposed to this reorienting effect over a larger region than rods, sug- gesting that disks complete this reorientation while near the particle, whereas rods orient radially only when they are too far behind the particle (Movie 1). Occasional in- terception by rods caused by the reorientation in region II is responsible for the small probability tail in P (ρ) in Figs. 4(b,c) (Movie 2). In summary, simulations confirm the intuition based on analytical arguments: the colli- sion cross-section for rods is determined by their shorter dimension whereas the opposite is true for disks. B. Experiments with elongated diatom cells Selected experiments with non-motile diatom cells con- firm the predictions of the model (3) discussed in Sec- tions IV A, A 4 in the case of the non-motile rods (Fig. 5 and Movie 3). We ran a suspension of the non- motile, elongated diatom cells Phaeodactylum tricornu- tum (strain CCMP2561) in sea water at a mean flow velocity of 168 µm s−1 through a microfluidic channel with a calcium-alginate spherical particle held fixed in the middle by the channel walls [Fig. 5(a)]; see Ap- pendix A 6 for more details on the experimental proto- col. The particle size was R = 566 µm, the average di- atom length lb = 21.2 µm and their average aspect ratio α = 6.8. Rather than directly estimating the encounter rate, which proved difficult due to the challenge of imag- ing in the immediate vicinity of the particle, we used image analysis to quantify the orientation that the di- atoms assume in the vicinity of the particle in the chan- nel mid-plane. Using this approach, we extracted from 50 consecutive frames an ensemble of diatom positions and orientations [Fig. 5(b)]. Since the shear-induced reorien- tation effects are strongest near the particle [Fig. 3(d)], we focus on diatoms that are at distance R < r < 2R away from the particle center. Importantly, since we only image the focal plane, this ensemble is skewed towards diatoms moving in the focal plane and also oriented in that plane. For this reason, to compare the experimen- tally determined orientations with those predicted by the model (3), we run additional numerical simulations to mimic the same information loss as in the experiments. Specifically, we simulate a front of uniformly distributed and randomly oriented elongated non-motile rods (with R/lb = 21.2 and α = 6.8), as in the previous section. We focus on trajectories lying in the particle mid-plane (as in the imaged region) and extract the rod orientations at positions along the streamlines corresponding to equal time intervals. We reject orientations that have the out- (a)(a)(b)experiment(c)theory100.5Sine of the angle with verticalUx/R0-22-11210z/R-2-1x/R0-22-11210z/R-2-1experiment10 FIG. 6: The shear-shape coupling significantly impacts the encounter rate between motile bacteria and sinking particles N /n (a), encounter efficiency η (b) and mean and the typical interception location on the particle. Encounter rate kernel interception colatitude (cid:104)θ(cid:105) (c) as a function of the sinking speed relative to the bacterial swimming speed U/Ub for different bacterial aspect ratios α. The continuous lines represent the ballistic model (3) while the broken lines denote the quasi-ballistic model with rotational diffusion (20). In the ballistic case, motility, elongation and shear enhance the encounter rate about twofold for slowly sinking particles as compared to the case with shear-induced reorientation switched off (purple and green lines). However, for intermediate to fast sinking particles, the encounter rate falls orders of magnitude below the value set by the interception of non-motile rods. On the particle, elongated motile bacteria attach preferentially to its leeward side. of-plane component larger than sin(30°) = 0.5, to mimic the information loss of diatoms that point out of the fo- cal plane in experiments; the results are robust against variation in this threshold (Fig. A.1). [Figs. 5(b,c)]. The experimentally determined orientations of diatoms agree very well with the numerical results for elon- gated ellipsoids with the same geometrical characteris- tics In particular, as predicted in Ap- pendix A 4, diatoms approaching the particle near the upstream stagnation line orient tangentially to the par- ticle surface, while diatoms departing from the particle near the downstream stagnation line point nearly radially [yellow vs. blue regions in Figs. 5(b,c)]. Close to the par- ticle surface, diatoms tend to maintain tangential orienta- tion but can also occasionally tumble. Tumbling happens most often when diatoms are to the leeward side of the particle, which is consistent with the action of shear de- picted in region II in Fig. 3(b), where vorticity dominates over straining and tries to spin rods in the plane of the picture. In summary, these experiments validate detailed aspects of our model for non-motile microorganisms and demonstrate that the effect of shear -- shape coupling can be substantial for realistic marine microorganisms. V. MOTILE BACTERIA The encounter rate between motile elongated bacte- ria and sinking particles in the ballistic regime depends strongly on the particle sinking speed relative to the bac- terial swimming speed (Section V A). For slow sinking particles, shear increases the encounter rate more than twofold and leads to preferential attachment of bacte- ria to the leeward side of the particle. However, as the sinking speed increases, shear decreases the encounter rate, orders of magnitude below the rate of non-motile organisms. These mechanisms of hydrodynamic focusing and screening are rationalized at the level of individual bacterial trajectories (Section V B) in terms of the quasi static picture derived in Section III. Finally, to connect with the diffusive description of the encounter process, we introduce rotational diffusion to quantify how vari- ous stochastic mechanisms, such as Brownian motion or run-and-tumble reorientation, influence the above ballis- tic description (Section V C). A. Encounter rates for motile bacteria Nondimensionalization of the ballistic model (3) in terms of the particle radius R and the time scale R/U derived from the sinking speed U shows that the only two dynamically relevant variables are the ratio of the sink- ing to swimming speeds U/Ub and the bacterial aspect ratio α. The bacterial size lb and particle size R enter the problem through the interception condition but oth- erwise they do not affect the bacterial trajectories, except for the time it takes to execute them. We assume the par- ticle is a perfect absorber and stop the simulations either if any part of the bacterium touches the particle (inter- ception) or the bacterium ends up far behind the particle. In this section, we fix R/lb = 10, scan velocities in the range U/Ub > 1 (sinking speed greater than swimming speed) and consider several aspect ratios α (Fig. 6). For hypothetical spherical or oblate motile bacte- N /n depends weakly ria [22], the encounter rate kernel on the sinking velocity U/Ub and the encounter efficiency η decays monotonically with U/Ub; for spherical swim- mers, η is close to the values obtained with the reorien- tation by shear switched off [dark blue and green lines in Figs. 6(a,b)]. However, for elongated swimmers, η varies strongly with U/Ub [Fig. 6(a,b)]. For slowly sinking par- 101102Flow speed U/Ub100103102101Encounter rate kernel N/n/(lb3τb-1).10010-210-4Encounter efficiency η0°90°180°Mean colatitude ‹θ›(c)(b)(a)downstreamupstreamshear OFF1asp. ratio α1.755100.1ηspheresEq. (18)101102Flow speed U/Ub100101102Flow speed U/Ub10011 FIG. 7: Motile elongated bacteria preferentially attach to the leeward side of a sinking particle due to hydrodynamic screening and focusing upstream and downstream of the particle. Encounter probabilities P (x) as a function of the position x [Eq. (4)] for perfect spheres (a), moderately elongated swimmers (b) and perfect rods (c). The sinking to swimming speed ratio is fixed at U/Ub = 3. (d -- f) Histograms of the interception colatitudes θ for initial positions in the whole domain shown in (a -- c) show a transition from a nearly uniform coverage of the particle by spherical swimmers (d) to preferential leeward attachment for motile rods (f). (g-i) Representative swimming trajectories (left) and successful initial orientations (right) for rod-like bacteria starting from the initial positions indicated in (c) illustrate the hydrodynamic screening (g) and focusing (h,i). ticles (1 < U/Ub < 2), η ∼ 2 − 3, implying that the particle collects bacteria from the volume of water two- three times bigger than the geometric cylinder the par- ticle swipes as it sinks. Furthermore, elongated bacteria intercept the particle to the leeward side [Fig. 6(c)]. In- terestingly, as the sinking speed increases, the encounter rates drop very rapidly: in the the velocity window 10 < U/Ub < 100, the encounter rate of elongated swim- mers (α ≥ 5) can be orders of magnitude below the value set by the non-motile rods. We next rationalize these encounter rate enhancement and decrease using the con- cepts of hydrodynamic focusing and screening. B. Hydrodynamic focusing and screening The strong dependence of the encounter efficiency on the particle sinking speed for elongated bacte- ria [Fig. 6(b)] is a consequence of hydrodynamic focus- ing and screening. These phenomena are illustrated in Fig. 7, where we compare three swimmers with different aspect ratios; the sinking speed is fixed at U/Ub = 3. Figs. 7(a -- c) show the encounter probabilities P (x) for a bacterium starting at x anywhere inside the indicated domain (not just the plane z = −6R) with head point- ing in a random direction [Eq. (4)]. Since U/Ub > 1, in all three cases there is a cone-like surface of revolution that separates the accessible [P (ρ) > 0] and inaccessi- ble initial positions - if the bacteria start too far away, they cannot reach the particle. The distribution of P (x) inside the accessibility region vary strongly with α. For spheres, P (x) is concentrated below the particle, near the ρ = 0 stagnation line and decays monotonically to zero with ρ reaching the accessibility horizon [Fig. 7(a)]. For somewhat elongated swimmers α = 1.75, the initial positions below the particle become less likely to result in an interception and P (x) starts to concentrate near the edge of the accessible region, which also reaches fur- ther out [Fig. 7(b)]. For perfect swimmers α = ∞, the region ρ ≈ 0 is now almost entirely shielded, with P (x) exhibiting a clear high-probability belt at the edge of the accessible region [Fig. 7(c)]. Far below the particle, the belt slope approaches ∼ U/Ub. Considering the distribu- tion of the interception locations ξ(θ) for initial positions anywhere in the domains shown in Figs. 7(a -- c), elon- gated swimmers show preferential leeward attachment, with the vicinity of the 'north pole' being the most likely location [Figs. 7(d -- f)]. We now rationalize the shape of the distributions P (x) and ξ(θ) at the level of individual swimming trajectories by evoking the quasi-static picture discussed in Section III B and shown in Fig. 3. At the level of individual swimming trajectories, the probability P (x) for spherical swimmers [Fig. 7(a)] is realized by trajectories that correspond to swimmers initially located below the particle and pointing up- wards. However, this intuitive strategy is not avail- (g)(h)-2(i)0222-20z/Ry/Rx/R01-11-10201040222-20-41.95-2.05-2.1.15.05.05-.050-3.95-4.05-4z/R1.851.751.8.05-.050y/R.05-.05044.053.95x/R.01.06-.04(b)(e)1.50×10-2α=1.75, γ~0.5ξ(θ)1.00.50°90°180°Colatitude θ4-6-4-220z/R0246ρ/R(c)(f)60×10-2(i)(g)(h)α=∞, γ=14-6-4-220z/REncounter probability P(x)0.400.20246ρ/Rξ(θ)3~U/Ub0°90°180°Colatitude θ(a)(d)40×10-3α=1, γ=0ξ(θ)24-6-4-220z/R0246ρ/R0°90°180°Colatitude θRθ-2-2012 FIG. 8: Encounter probability P (ρ) (a,b) and distribution of interception colatitudes ξ(θ) (c,d) for bacteria starting at the plane z = −6R with a random initial orientation for different relative sinking speeds U/Ub and aspect ratios α; (a,c) shows the results of numerical simulations of the ballistic model (3) and (b,d) the stochastic model (20). In the parameter range considered, rotational diffusion mainly affects elongated swimmers (bottom panels), for which it decreases the impact of the hydrodynamics focusing at low sinking speeds but also ameliorate the hydrodynamic screening at higher sinking speeds. able for elongated swimmers because of hydrodynamic screening [Fig. 7(b,c)]. Recall that, below the particle, shear tends to align rods along the azimuth [region I in Fig. 3(b)]. This shear-induced reorientation coupled with forward motility implies that rod-like swimmers get reori- ented and swim away as they approach the sinking parti- cle from below [Fig. 7(g), Movie 4]. For the same reason, it is very unlikely that elongated swimmers attach to the front of the particle, which explains the small values of ξ(θ) for colatitudes θ > 90° [Fig. 7(f)]. Instead, suc- cessful interceptions for elongated bacteria must follow a different strategy [Figs. 7(h,i)]. To avoid the screening, elongated swimmers must start on the belt far away from the centerline of the sinking particle, on the edge of the accessibility horizon. Furthermore, their initial orienta- tions have the be roughly horizontal, pointing towards the centerline [Figs. 7(h)]. Such initial conditions allow the bacteria to avoid the screening region I of Fig. 3(b) and explore the shear-induced radial reorientation in re- gion III. This hydrodynamic focusing then leads to pref- erential leeward attachment (Movie 5). The mechanisms of hydrodynamic focusing and screen- ing described above rationalize the strong dependence of the encounter efficiency η on the particle sinking speed U/Ub presented in [Fig. 6(b)]. For slowly sinking speeds, both mechanisms are present. However, the high proba- bility belt at the edge of the accessibility horizon for elon- gated swimmers extends a large volume and hence many swimmers can utilize the focusing effect, which explains why η > 1 in that flow range. However, as U/Ub in- creases, the high probability belt moves closer to the cen- ter line since its diameter scales as Ub/U . This reduces the accessible volume of water at the rate at least ∼ U−2. Furthermore, as the belt shrinks in diameter, it enters the region of hydrodynamic screening and eventually disap- pears [Fig. 8(a)]. Thus, in the range 10 < U/Ub < 100, only screening persists, which explains the very small values of η in that range. Only for swimming speeds U/Ub > 100, η rises again, until it starts to recover the limit set by the interception rate of non-motile rods. C. Impact of rotational diffusion In the purely ballistic picture of the encounter process outlined in the two previous sections, shear is the only factor responsible for microorganism reorientation. In reality, bacteria experience Brownian rotational diffusion as well as perform run-and-tumble or run-and-reverse dy- namics. The combination of these stochastic mechanisms likely interferes with the shear-induced reorientation in a complex manner. As a first step to systematically study the impact of these additional mechanisms, we introduce a single rotational diffusion term to Eq. (3) x = Ubp + v, p = (I − ppT)[(γE + W )p + (20a) (20b) 2Drξ], (cid:112) where Dr is the cell's effective rotational diffusivity and ξ is a delta-correlated 3D white noise with zero mean. We express the diffusive timescale τd = D−1 in terms of the time τb = lb/Ub needed for a bacterium to travel the distance equal to its bodylength. r To study the impact of rotational diffusion on the en- counter rates and attachment location, we fixed the dif- fusive timescale at τd/τb = 100, which corresponds to the (a)(c)(b)α=1α=10P(ρ)10010-110-2P(ρ)10010-110-210-210-1100101ρ/R10-210-1 10010110-3U/Ub=100U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=2U/Ub=5U/Ub=200(d)ξ(θ)10-110-210-30°90°180°Colatitude θ×10-3804ξ(θ)α=1α=1010010-110-210010-110-2ρ/R10-210-1 10010110-3α=1α=10diffusion ON, τd/τb=100×10-380410-210-11001010°90°180°10-210-11001010°90°180°0°90°180°Colatitude θ10-110-210-3α=1α=10diffusion ON, τd/τb=10010-210-11001010°90°180°10-210-11001010°90°180°P(ρ)10010-110-210010-110-2×10-3402ξ(θ)×10-3402U/Ub=30U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=5U/Ub=10U/Ub=200U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=5U/Ub=10U/Ub=30U/Ub=200α=0.1α=0.1α=0.1α=0.1diffusion OFFdiffusion OFFU/Ub=30U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=5U/Ub=10U/Ub=200U/Ub=30U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=5U/Ub=10U/Ub=200U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=5U/Ub=10U/Ub=30U/Ub=200U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=5U/Ub=10U/Ub=30U/Ub=200U/Ub=30U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=5U/Ub=10U/Ub=200U/Ub=30U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=5U/Ub=10U/Ub=200U/Ub=100U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=2U/Ub=5U/Ub=200U/Ub=100U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=2U/Ub=5U/Ub=200U/Ub=100U/Ub=1.25U/Ub=2U/Ub=5U/Ub=200typical time-scale set by the run-and-tumble motility [8]. We then repeated the scans according to the same proto- col as in Section V A, with R/lb = 10 and U/Ub > 1 (the broken lines in Fig. 6). We find that diffusion has lit- tle effect on the encounter rates and attachment location for spherical swimmers. However, for elongated swim- mers, diffusion decreases the impact of hydrodynamics focusing at low sinking speeds but also decreases the hy- drodynamic screening at higher sinking speeds. The uniformizing impact of diffusion is studied in more detail in Fig. 8, where we consider the interception proba- bility P (ρ) for a bacterium starting at the plane z = −6R with random orientation [Figs. 8(a,b)] as well as the corresponding distribution of the interception locations ξ(θ) [Figs. 8(c,d)]. We compare side to side the cases without [Figs. 8(a,c)] and with diffusion [Figs. 8(b,d)] for oblate, spherical and elongated swimmers (top, middle and bottom rows, respectively). The accessibility region [defined as P (ρ) > 0] shrinks under diffusion, because the now erratic motion of bacteria takes longer to reach the particle. and therefore, the bacteria must start closer to the particle to be able to catch it. Within the accessibil- ity region, the distribution P (ρ) for oblate and spherical swimmers is nearly unaffected by diffusion [Figs. 8(a,b), top and middle rows] and so is ξ(θ) [Figs. 8(c,d), top and middle rows]. However, for elongated swimmers, diffusion decreases the size of the high probability belt near the edge of the accessibility region but also raises the probability of interception for initial conditions di- rectly below the sinking particle [Figs. 8(a,b), bottom row]. As a consequence, diffusive elongated swimmers have nonnegligible probability of attaching to the front of the sinking particle [Figs. 8(c,d), bottom rows]. 13 FIG. 9: Given a fixed volume Vb of a non-motile microorgan- ism, what shape minimizes or maximizes the encounter effi- ciency η with a sinking spherical particle of volume V ? Plot- ting η vs the volumetric ratio Vb/V reveals that elongation reduces the encounter rate with large particles (Vb/V → 0), making rods the optimal shape for avoiding sinking particles, at least as long as rotational diffusion is negligible. Con- versely, flattening makes a non-motile microorganism partic- ularly efficient at intersecting the particle. This different be- havior of rods and disks is a consequence of fluid shear, which aligns rods tangentially to the sinking particle surface with rare tumbling events, but induces frequent tumbling in the orientation of disks. As the sinking particle becomes large, Vb/V → 0, the efficiencies for rods and disks approach the exact expression η = 1.42[Vb/(V α)]2/3, which follows from Eqs. (19) after assuming rods and disks can be represented as prolate and oblate ellipsoids with aspect ratio α. As the vol- ume ratio Vb/V grows, the difference between rods and disks decreases due to increasing tumbling of rods. VI. DISCUSSION In this work, we have studied the ballistic limit of the encounter process between microorganisms and sinking particles, with focus on the reorienting effect of shear induced by the sinking particle. Analytical and numeri- cal calculations as well as selected experiments show that the shear -- shape coupling acting on a microorganism im- pacts population-level observables, such as the encounter rate with sinking particles or the typical attachment loca- tion on the particle. For the Stokes flow around a spheri- cal sinking particle, rods and disks break the fore-aft sym- metry of the flow streamlines, in stark contrast to the be- havior of spherical colloids (Fig. 3). This shape-induced symmetry breaking affects the encounter rates (Figs. 4 and 6) through mechanisms we have characterized as hy- drodynamic focusing and screening (Fig. 7). Below, we first rephrase these results as solutions to the optimiza- tion problem: should a microorganism be elongated or flat, to maximize or minimize the encounter rate with a large moving sphere? Subsequently, we discuss the bio- physical consequences of our mechanistic description of the encounter process in the marine environment. From the perspective of evolution, there are many contexts in which microorganisms may seek to maxi- mize or minimize their encounters with moving objects, including encountering sinking resources [8] or symbi- otic partners [23], and avoiding predators [24]. At the same time these, microorganisms are likely to have other constraints on their volume, such as growth maximiza- tion and genome size. For non-motile microorganisms with negligible rotational diffusion (Section IV A), we have seen that shear tends to orient rods tangentially to the sinking particle surface as these move around the particle, whereas disk-shaped microorganisms tum- ble, which makes their longer dimension available for in- terception (Section IV A and Fig. 4). As a consequence, rods have their encounter efficiencies decreased by a fac- tor equal to the square of their aspect ratio compared to spherical colloids with diameter equal to the rod length. Conversely, disks have the same efficiency as spheres with diameter equal to the disk diameter [Eqs. (19)]. For non-motile bacteria, over a broad range of ratios of cell volume relative to particle volume (Vb/V ), disks are the most efficient shape to intercept a sinking particle, while rods are the least efficient (Fig. 9). The contribu- Encounter efficiency η10-210-410-61.42[Vb/(Vα)]2/3α=1α=0.1α=10sideviewtopview10-1010-810-410-6 Volumetric ratio Vb/Vtion of the occasional tumbling of rods grows with Vb/V , decreasing the difference between the efficiencies of rods and disks as cell volume gets larger; rods remain less effi- cient than disks but catch up with spheres. Note that we cannot increase the volumetric ratio further without vi- olating the approximations used in the Jeffrey equation, since the microorganism size becomes comparable with the sinking particle. Conversely, as the sinking particle grows, Vb/V → 0, the encounter efficiencies approach 1.42[Vb/(V α)]2/3 (broken lines in Fig. 9), which follows directly from Eqs. (19) and reflects the fact that, as the sinking particle grows, rods cease to tumble while disks always tumble [Fig. 4(c,d)]. In this limiting regime, the efficiency ratio between disks and rods is (αrod/αdisk)2/3. For example, for rods with αrod = 10 and disks with αdisk = 0.1, disks will be about 20 times more efficient than rods at intercepting large sinking particles. For motile microorganisms, encounter rates are con- trolled by hydrodynamic focusing and screening, which develop from the influence of shear on the direction of swimming. Here we still consider the ballistic regime, with negligible rotational diffusion. In addition, the shear -- shape coupling for motile cells leads to the sen- sitive dependence of the encounter rate on the parti- cle sinking speed relative to the bacterial swimming speed (Section V A and Fig. 6). Hydrodynamic screen- ing and focusing describe the effect on elongated motile microorganisms of the shear upstream and downstream of the particle, respectively. In hydrodynamic screening, the shear upstream of the particle aligns rods tangen- tially to the particle surface (as with non-motile cells), resulting in cells swimming away from the particle. For hydrodynamic focusing, rotation from shear in the down- stream half of the particle turns the swimming rods to- wards the particle. For slowly sinking particles, focus- ing dominates and enhances the encounter rate (Fig. 7), while at sinking speed significantly higher than the cell swimming speed, screening dominates and the encounter rate drops far below that of non-motile rods. In con- trast to elongated organisms, hypothetical spherical and disk-shaped swimmers respond monotonically to changes in the sinking speed (Fig. 6), a consequence of disk- shaped swimmers experiencing hydrodynamic focusing upstream, not downstream, of the particle. For sinking speeds more than twice the swimming speed, this results in disk-shaped microorganisms encountering particles at a higher rate than elongated microorganisms. From an evolutionary perspective, this analysis sug- gests that adopting a disk shape would be optimal for microorganisms (whether non-motile or motile) in order to maximize particle encounter rates at a broad range of sizes and sinking speeds. Of course, this neglects other evolutionary pressures on morphology. However, for par- ticles sinking at speeds close to the organism swimming speeds (i.e., relatively slowly), elongation increases the encounter rates up to twice that of motile disks. Cou- pled with the large reduction in encounter rates for more rapidly sinking particles, elongation can be viewed as bi- 14 asing ballistically swimming organisms strongly towards slowly sinking particles. This could be subject to se- lective pressures for microorganisms in situations where optimal growth occurs near the surface, and therefore rapidly sinking particles are better avoided. For the specific case of marine bacteria encounter- ing sinking marine particles, it is necessary to connect the ballistic description of the encounter process with the classical approach based on approximating bacterial motility as a diffusive process [7, 8, 25]. Marine bacteria are subject to various sources of random reorientation, from Brownian rotational diffusion to self-generated run- and-tumble or run-and-reverse motility, where segments of straight swimming are interrupted by randomization of the swimming direction. As a consequence, on scales larger than the bacterial run length and timescales longer than the reorientation time, bacterial motility can be ef- fectively characterized as a diffusive process [7, 8, 25] - this is a general feature of superimposing a large num- ber of uncorrelated random segments [26]. In this limit, relevant to large sinking particles, the encounter rate is proportional to the bacterial effective diffusion coefficient and the Sherwood number, a flow-induced enhancement factor [25]. Additionally, while the shear-induced reori- entation in the diffusive limit can be neglected in certain regimes [12], precise quantification of its impact on the encounter rate and attachment locations across a wide range of particle speeds and sizes might require kinetic theory approach [26 -- 28]. However, as the particle be- comes smaller or the sinking speed increases, the system becomes ballistic and the diffusive approximation overes- timates the encounter rate. The reason for this overesti- mation comes from the fact that the encounter probabil- ity for a bacterium at distance r from the particle decays as r−1 in the diffusive regime, and as r−2 in the ballistic regime [29], at least for stationary particles and without shear. Since hydrodynamic interactions can significantly bend bacterial trajectories [14, 30, 31], the need to go beyond arguments based on straight-line swimming mo- tivated the above study of the pure ballistic limit. For the marine application, we consider ballistic motile bac- teria supplemented by rotational diffusion (Section V C), which we have shown reduces the strength of hydrody- namic screening on rod-shaped swimming cells. We consider two major classes [8]: motile elongated bacteria and non-motile spherical bacteria. For motile elongated bacteria, we evaluate the predictions of our model for cells of length lb = 2 µm, swimming speed Ub = 50 µm s−1 and aspect ratio α = 3.3. For non- motile spherical bacteria, we choose a diameter lb = 1 µm. These represent typical characteristics of motile copiotrophic bacteria that actively seek and engage ma- rine particles, and more oligotrophic non-motile bacteria which may nevertheless encounter and stick to particles. For these representative marine bacteria, as well as the equivalent motile bacteria without the influence of shear, the corresponding encounter efficiency η [Fig. 10(a -- c)] and mean interception colatitude (cid:104)θ(cid:105) [Fig. 10(d -- f)] have 15 FIG. 10: To quantify the impact of shear and elongation on the encounter rates and interception locations between bacteria and sinking particles in the ocean, we focus on realistic model parameters and compare three cases: motile elongated bacteria of length lb = 2 µm, swimming speed Ub = 50 µm s−1 and aspect ratio α = 3.3 (a,d); the same bacteria, but with the shear- induced reorientation switched off (b,e); and non-motile spherical bacteria of diameter lb = 1 µm (c,f). In these three cases, we compute the encounter efficiency η (a -- c) and mean interception colatitude (cid:104)θ(cid:105) (d -- f) as a function of the sinking particle speed U and radius R. We consider a range of sinking particle sizes (R ∼ 3 µm − 1mm) that covers the most abundant marine particles [11]. In the simulations, the rotational diffusion coefficient for motile swimmers was set to Dr = 0.25s−1, while the translational diffusion coefficient of the non-motile spheres was set to Dt = 0.43 µm2 s−1. For such parameters, the panels capture the ballistic and diffusive regimes, as well as the in-between quasi-ballistic regime. been computed as a function of the sinking particle speed U and particle radius R. The range of sinking speeds we consider is 60 µm s−1 − 5 mm s−1. The range of parti- cles sizes, 3 µm−1 mm, covers the most abundant marine sinking particles [11]. For elongated bacteria, randomiza- tion of orientation is effectively represented by a single ro- tational diffusion coefficient Dr = 0.25 s−1; the diffusive timescale (∼ 4 s) gives the run length of about 200 µm, typical of marine bacteria [8]. For such a run length, the range of particle sizes spans the ballistic and diffusive regimes as well as the intermediate transition range. Fi- nally, the translational diffusion of the non-motile spher- ical bacteria was set to Dt = 0.43 µm2 s−1, which repre- sents Brownian motion of a micron-sized sphere at room temperature [32]. Under these conditions, accounting for the shear reorientation of motile marine bacteria sub- stantially reduces the encounter efficiency for small fast- sinking particles and alters the location of encounters for slow-sinking particles below 100 microns in radius. In contrast, the diffusive spherical swimmers show weak de- pendence of encounter efficiency on sinking speed, but much greater sensitivity to particle size. Since the range of particle sizes considered in Fig. 10 captures the ballistic -- diffusive transition, the stan- dard computation based on a diffusive analogy only matches the encounter rates of marine bacteria (neglect- ing shear) for the largest particles with radii approaching 1 mm (Fig. A.2). For bacteria with higher rotational dif- fusivity, this occurs for smaller particle sizes. As the par- ticles get smaller, the diffusion-based calculation starts to overestimate the encounter rate - in the ballistic limit, with particle sizes reaching tens of microns, the two de- scriptions can differ by more than two orders of magni- tude (Fig. A.2). We now describe in detail the encounter process in the intermediate quasi-ballistic regime, high- lighting the role of bacterial motility and fluid shear. Factoring in shear interactions, motile bacteria en- counter sinking particles at a rate one or two orders of magnitude [Fig. 11(a)] greater than non-motile bacteria. This motility-based enhancement factor is smaller by one or two orders of magnitude (depending on particle size) as compared to what would be predicted by the fully dif- fusive model. The exception when motility decreases the chances of interception (ηmotile shear ON/ηnon-motile < 1) corre- sponds to small and very quickly moving objects. This upper-left part of the panel, close to the full ballistic regime, is dominated by hydrodynamic screening and is probably not relevant for marine particles, even for fast sinking-fecal pellets, since their density differs from that of seawater only by about 10%-20% [33, 34], see the red Sinking speed U [μm/s]500635000(a)(d)103101102103101102500635000Sinking speed U [μm/s]motile, elongated, shear ON lb=2μm, Ub=50μm/s, α=3.3103101102103101102motile, elongated, shear OFF lb=2μm, Ub=50μm/s, α=3.310010-110-210-3Encounter efficiency η140°120°100°80°60°40°Mean colatitude ‹θ›103101102103101102non-motile, spherical lb=1μm, Ub=0, α=1(b)(e)(c)(f)Particle radius R [μm]Particle radius R [μm]Particle radius R [μm]16 this encounter rate is realized by hydrodynamic focusing, which results in most bacteria attaching to the leeward side (θ < 90°) of the sinking particle [compare Figs. 10(d) and (e); see also Fig. A.3]. For small and slowly sinking particles (R < 50 µm, U < 500 µm s−1), for which shear dominates over rotational diffusion, more than 75% of the interceptions occur on the leeward side of the par- ticle. Furthermore, about 25% of the interceptions are concentrated inside the 'Arctic circle' (θ < 23°), which represents a more than five-fold increase as compared to a uniform coverage of the particle. This leaves the southern hemisphere depleted of bacteria, with almost no intercep- tions below the 'tropic of Capricorn' (θ > 113°). Thus, the leeward stagnation point is a flow-induced hotspot where motile and elongated bacteria concentrate due to shear. Since non-motile bacteria intercept the particles on the upstream side [Fig. 10(f)], in the southern hemi- sphere, we conclude that flow and shear lead to a bipolar segregation of motile and non-motile marine bacteria on the two sides of a sinking particle. Although this work has assumed particles to be spher- ical despite the variety of observed shapes exhibited by marine snow aggregates [11], we expect the phenomena of hydrodynamic focusing and screening of elongated bac- teria to be robust to variation in shape. The focusing and screening effects rely on different orientational re- sponses of small rods upstream and downstream of the particle - the key property of the flow that is required for this fore -- aft symmetry breaking is the expansion of the streamlines to the front of the particle and their re- combination to the back, as well as the no-slip boundary conditions on the particle surface. As long as such gen- eral streamline organization is preserved, the effects here described should be robust: while fluid parcels roll on the particle surface (no slip), they stretch upstream of the particle (streamline expansion) but compress down- stream of the particle (streamline recombination). This basic process will hold for objects at low Reynolds num- bers with no-slip surfaces, and one would therefore expect hydrodynamic focusing and screening of motile elongated bacteria to occur for marine particles in general. VII. CONCLUSIONS In this work, we combined analytical and numerical calculations to estimate the encounter rates between non- motile and motile microorganisms of different morpholo- gies and sinking particles in the ballistic regime relevant for the most abundant small sinking particles. Previous estimates have primarily focused on the diffusive regime, effectively assuming that particles are much larger than the bacterial run length. In the ballistic range, bacterial reorientation becomes a significant factor influencing the encounter process, while it is absent by necessity from diffusive models. We have focused on the coupling be- tween microorganism shape and fluid shear induced by the particle, since shear is the dominant external factor FIG. 11: Comparison of the encounter efficiencies between motile elongated and non-motile spherical microorganisms (a) and between motile elongated microorganisms with and with- out shear (b) computed from the panels (a -- c) of Fig. 10. For reference, we plot the absolute values of the sinking/raising speeds as determined by the Stokes law (1) for sinking parti- cles with densities ρp higher than the density of water ρw by 5 − 15% (in black font), such as the fast sinking fecal pellets, as well as raising bubbles with ρp/ρw ≈ 0 (in white font). The white dashed line denotes the ratio equal to unity. and yellow lines in Fig. 11, which represent the Stokes law (1). However, this hydrodynamic screening regime may be relevant for interception by air bubbles, whose vertical speed is high in view of their large density differ- ence with seawater [35] (purple line in Fig. 11). Further- more, comparing the shear on-off cases for motile elon- gated bacteria [Fig. 11(b)], we find that the major im- pact of shear is to reduce the encounter rates with small particles sinking at intermediate or rapid rates by up to a factor of 10. This reduction is a consequence of the competition between the hydrodynamic screening of rods upstream of the sinking particle and rotational diffusion. It suggests that elongation-induced screening may be a passive mechanism that allows motile elongated marine microorganisms to prioritize slowly sinking aggregates, at least in the quasi-ballistic particle size range. For slowly sinking particles in the quasi-ballistic regime (lower parts of the panels in Fig. 11), the observed encounter efficiencies of motile marine bacteria are close to the case without shear, consistent with earlier stud- ies [12]. However, at the level of individual trajectories, Particle radius R [μm]103101102(a)Sinking speed U [μm/s]500635000ratio ηmotile /ηnon-motileshear ON102101ρp/ρw=1.15ρp/ρw=1.10ρp/ρw=1.05ρp/ρw=0100ratio ηmotile /ηmotileshear ONshear OFF10-110-0.5Particle radius R [μm]103101102(b)Sinking speed U [μm/s]500635000100ρp/ρw=1.15ρp/ρw=1.10ρp/ρw=1.05ρp/ρw=0responsible for bacterial reorientation. We have shown that the shape -- shear coupling can significantly affect the encounter rate and attachment location on a particle for both non-motile and motile microorganisms. For non-motile organisms, shear from a sinking particle can significantly alter the encounter rates of organisms with different morphologies. For elongated organisms, this influence occurs by aligning the cells' long axis tan- gentially to the particle surface, and was experimentally validated. When the timescale of rotational diffusion is long with respect to particle interactions, shear from sinking particles interacts with the aspect ratio of non- motile organisms to potentially reduce encounter rates by a factor proportional to the square of the aspect ratio. As a result, encounters could exert evolutionary pressure on non-motile cell morphology [36], favoring elongated or disk-like shapes depending on whether encounters are unfavorable or favorable, respectively. For motile microorganisms, interactions with the shear from a sinking particle give rise to two phenomena, hy- drodynamic screening and focusing, that alter both the rates and locations of encounters. Elongation helps or- ganisms intercept slowly sinking particles but dramat- ically reduces the encounter rate with rapidly sinking particles. In contrast to rods, motile disks experience up- stream focusing, leading to high efficiency at intercept- ing rapidly sinking particles. From the perspective of the particle, motile elongated microorganisms typically attach to the leeward side of the particle, while motile disks cover it more uniformly. Under realistic parameters relevant to marine bacteria and sinking particles, which include the effect of randomization of swimming direction from rotational diffusion, hydrodynamic screening leads to a ten-fold decrease in the interception rate of rapidly sinking aggregates, as compared to motility without the shear-induced reorientation. This reduction in encounter rate suggests that elongation-induced screening may be a passive mechanism that allows motile elongated marine microorganisms to avoid rapidly moving particles. Last but not least, motile elongated bacteria attach to the leeward side of the particle, whereas non-motile bacteria attach to the front. Thus, hydrodynamic focusing is a physical source of heterogeneity in particle colonization characterized by bipolar segregation of motile and non- motile microorganisms, which may influence the degrada- tion rate of marine snow aggregates. Whether in terms of encounter rates or encounter locations, these results indicate that the impact of shear reorientation cannot be neglected when evaluating interactions between motile organisms and sinking particles. The dynamics of shear-driven reorientation are directly relevant to the colonization of marine particles by bac- teria. It is well established that motility can greatly en- hance the encounter rate of bacteria with sinking parti- cles [8, 24]. This enhancement is often estimated via the ratio of the effective diffusivity due to motility and the diffusivity due to Brownian motion, which can be as large as 1000 for highly motile marine bacteria [8, 37, 38]. The 17 more accurate theory developed here, which accounts ex- plicitly for the interaction between flow and motility in elongated bacteria, refines this estimation in a manner that depends on the particle size and sinking speed rela- tive to the bacterial motility. For particles substantially larger than the bacterial run length, the enhancement in attachment due to motility estimated by the ratio of effective diffusivities and neglecting the impact of shear is increasingly more accurate. For the marine bacteria modeled here, this corresponds to particles with radius greater than approximately 1 mm. For smaller particles, which form the bulk of particles in the ocean [39], this work reveals that the enhancement in encounters result- ing from motility is more moderate and is further reduced as the particle sinking speed increases. In extreme cases, potentially applicable to some bubbles, motility may con- fer no benefit in encounter rates. However, in the context of marine particles, motility still enhances encounters by one to two orders of magnitude. Since the enhancement in encounter rate due to motility is greater for slowly- sinking particles, this also highlights the potential signif- icance of neutrally buoyant particles [40] to motile bac- teria. This fundamental knowledge of encounter rates will be a valuable asset in future efforts to rationalize the community composition on marine particles, and ul- timately the role of different groups of bacteria in particle degradation and the ocean's biological pump. In a different domain, the mechanisms of hydrody- namic focusing and screening of rods and disks here de- scribed are relevant to the classical filtration problem [9], because our results suggest that shear renders elongated non-motile colloids more difficult to collect than oblate ones. Furthermore, fabrication of Janus-type artificial swimmers makes it possible to build microscale motile objects with different shapes and swimming speed [32], and these parameters could be tailored to enhance or sup- press the focusing and screening effects. For example, the efficiency in capturing moving spheres may be important in applications such as targeted drug delivery [41] and micromachine-enabled decontamination [42]. In summary, we have demonstrated that hydrody- namic interactions between a small ellipsoid and a large moving sphere break the fore -- aft symmetry of the flow streamlines, leading to practical consequences for mi- croorganisms. This symmetry breaking is a conse- quence of fluid expansion and recombination upstream and downstream of the sphere, but is only revealed when the full tensorial character of the velocity gradient is ac- counted for, including its straining and rotational compo- nents. Such asymmetric two-body couplings are ubiqui- tous, since they arise when a small nonspherical particle travels near a larger obstacle in a fluid; we have exper- imentally verified their impact in the case of non-motile elongated diatoms advected around an alginate bead. In the context of swimming bacteria intercepting a sinking particle, hydrodynamic focusing and screening have prac- tical ecological impacts, but applications to other natural or man-made systems are yet to be explored. Appendix A: Supplementary Information 18 The Appendix is organized as follows: we provide linear stability analysis of the fixed points of the Jeffery equation in Section A 1 and derive the limit cycle solutions and their period in Section A 2; these results were discussed in Section III A of the Main Text. The velocity gradient for the Stokes flow is derived in Section A 3; its matrix form was used in Eq. (13) in Section III B of the Main Text. In Section A 4, we complement the discussion in Section III B of the Main text by analyzing the structure of the velocity gradient on the stagnation lines and the sinking particle surface. The subsequent Sections give details on the numerical simulations (Section A 5) and experimental methods (Section A 6). Finally, the three additional figures supplement the Main Text as follows: Fig. A.1 shows that the results presented in Fig. 5 of the Main Text are robust to variation in the cut-off threshold for rejecting the out-of-plane components of rods in the simulations, Fig. A.2 quantifies the overestimate in the encounter efficiencies as predicted by the classical diffusive arguments in the range of parameters discussed in Figs. 10 and 11 of the Main Text, and Fig. A.3 provides an additional characterization of the landing distributions for the simulations presented in Figs 10 of the Main Text. 1. Stability analysis of the fixed points of the Jeffrey equation In this section, we analyze the linear stability of the fixed points of the Jeffrey Eq. (9) p = (I − ppT)Aγp. (A1) This analysis will also yield the characteristic timescales of the convergence onto the asymptotically stable solutions. As discussed in Section III A and in [18], the fixed points of Eq. (A1) are given by the real eigenvectors of Aγ. Let λ be a normalized real eigenvector of Aγ with eigenvalue λ. Linearizing Eq. (A1) around λ by writing p = λ + ∆p, where the perturbation ∆p lies in the tangent space to the sphere at λ, gives ∆p = −λ∆p + (I − λλT)(Aγ∆p). (A2) Eq. (A2) is a two-dimensional linear dynamical system whose stability can be classified using the standard trace- determinant characterization. To be more explicit, we introduce the basis vectors {e1, e2} for the tangent space to the sphere at λ e1 = n × λ, e2 = e1 × λ, (A3) where n is an arbitrary nonzero vector, noncolinear with λ. In that basis, the perturbation reads ∆p = α(t)e1 +β(t)e2 and the linearized system (A2) reduces to (cid:35)(cid:20)α (cid:21) β (cid:20)α (cid:21) β (cid:35) (cid:34) α (cid:34) (cid:20)α (cid:21) β , = −λ + eT 1 Aγe1 eT eT 2 Aγe1 eT 1 Aγe2 2 Aγe2 = Mλ (cid:34) 1 Aγe1 − λ eT 2 Aγe1 eT (cid:35) 1 Aγe2 eT 2 Aγe2 − λ eT . Mλ = , (A4) (A5) β where To evaluate the trace and determinant of Mλ, we first note that {e1, e2, λ} is an orthogonal basis for Aγ. In that basis, Aγ takes the form eT Aγ = 1 Aγe2 0 1 Aγe1 eT 2 Aγe2 0 2 Aγe1 eT eT λTAγe1 λTAγe2 λ  , (A6) Let {λa, λb, λ} be the three eigenvalues of Aγ. The following identities follow from the above matrix representation TrAγ = eT 1 Aγe1 + eT det Aγ = λaλbλ = λ[(eT 2 Aγe2 + λ = λa + λb + λ = 0, 1 Aγe1)(eT 2 Aγe2) − (eT 1 Aγe2)(eT 2 Aγe1)]. (A7) (A8) where we used fluid incompressibility in the first equation. From the above, we derive the following formulae eT 1 Aγe1 + eT 2 Aγe2) − (eT 1 Aγe2)(eT 2 Aγe2 = −λ, 2 Aγe1) = λaλb, (eT 1 Aγe1)(eT which imply the following expressions for the trace and determinant of M From these expression, the eigenvalues of Mλ read (TrMλ ±(cid:112) λMλ± = 1 2 Since λ = −λa − λb this further simplifies to TrMλ = −3λ, det Mλ = 2λ2 + λaλb. (−3λ ±(cid:112) 1 2 TrM 2 − 4 det Mλ) = λ2 − 4λaλb). (−3λ ±(cid:112)(λa − λb)2). λMλ± = 1 2 19 (A9) (A10) (A11a) (A11b) (A12) (A13) We now use the eigenvalues (A13) to analyze the linear stability of the fixed points of the Jeffrey Eq. (A1). Let's first consider the case when Aγ has all real eigenvalues λ1 < λ2 < λ3 with eigenvectors {λ1, λ2, λ3}, which are also the fixed points of Eq. (A1). In this case, the eigenvalues of the linearized system (A4) are also real and Eq. (A13) simplifies to (A14) Furthermore, since λ1 + λ2 + λ3 = 0 by the incompressibility, we must have λ1 = −λ1 < 0, λ3 > 0 and λ2 < min(λ1, λ3). For the fixed point λ1, the eigenvalues are are always positive λMλ± = 1 2 (−3λ ± λa − λb). Mλ1± = λ 1 2 (−3λ1 ± λ3 − λ2) = [−3λ1 ± (λ3 − λ2)] = 1 2 1 2 [−3λ1 ± (−λ1 − 2λ2)] > 0, implying that λ1 is a repulsive node. For the fixed point λ2, the eigenvalues are Mλ2± = λ 1 2 (−3λ2 ± λ1 − λ3) = 1 2 (−3λ2 ± λ2 + 2λ3) = [−3λ2 ± (λ2 + 2λ3)]. 1 2 Explicitly, + = λ3 − λ2 > 0, Mλ2− = −2λ2 − λ3 = λ1 − λ2 < 0. λ Mλ2 λ Thus, λ2 is a saddle point. Finally, for λ3, the eigenvalues are always negative Mλ3± = λ 1 2 (−3λ3 ± λ1 − λ2) = 1 2 [−3λ3 ± (λ3 + 2λ2)] < 0, (A15) (A16) (A17a) (A17b) (A18) implying that λ3 is an attracting node. We conclude that the asymptotically stable orientations of Eq. (A1) for the case when Aγ has three real eigenvalues are given by ±λ3, since these are the only attracting fixed points on the sphere of orientations. We can estimate the characteristic time τλ3 needed to converge onto the stable orientation λ3 as the inverse of the average of the eigenvalues λ (A19) 1, λ3}. We now consider the case when Aγ has a pair of complex conjugate eigenvalues and one real eigenvalue {λ1, λ∗ We write the complex eigenvalue as λ1 = λr 1. In this case, the only fixed point of the Jeffrey Eq. (A1) is given by the real eigenvector λ3. We estimate the linear stability of this fixed point. The eigenvalues of the linearized system (A4) become 1 + iλi λ3. λ3 Mλ3 + + λ Mλ3− )/2 = 3 2 Mλ3± = −(λ τ−1 [−3λ3 ±(cid:113) Mλ3± = λ 1 2 (λ1 − λ∗ 1)2] = − 3 2 λ3 ± iλi 1. (A20) We see that, if the only real eigenvalue λ3 is positive, then λ3 is an attractive spiral. Otherwise, it's a repulsive spiral and the asymptotic state of Eq. (A1) is given by a stable limit cycle, to be discussed in the next section in more detail. The timescale associated with the convergence on or divergence away from λ3 is given by the absolute value of the real part of λ Mλ3± τ−1 λ3 = λ3. 3 2 (A21) 2. Limit cycle case 20 In the case when Aγ has complex eigenvalues λ1,2 and the real eigenvalue is negative λ < 0, the asymptotic solution to the Jeffrey Eq. (A1) is given by a limit cycle. The limit cycle is the great circle perpendicular to the real eigenvector p∗ of Aγ. To show this, we introduce the orthonormal basis n1 = w × p∗/(cid:107)w × p∗(cid:107), n2 = n1 × p∗, (A22) where w is a random nonzero vector. Note that the two orthogonal vectors n1 and n2 span the plane of the great circle perpendicular to the real eigenvector p∗. We look for solutions of the form Plugging the above ansatz into the Jeffrey Eq. (A1) yields p(t) = sin θ(t)n1 + cos θ(t)n2. θ cos θn1 − θ sin θn2 = [I − (sin θn1 + cos θn2)(sin θnT 1 + cos θnT 2 )](sin θAγn1 + cos θAγn2). To simplify the above expression, we introduce the following notation for the submatrix of Aγ and project Eq. (A24) onto n1 and n2 M = (cid:34) (cid:35) , nT nT 1 An1 nT 2 An1 nT 1 An2 2 An2 θ cos θ(t) = sin θM11 + cos θM12 − sin θ(sin2 θM11 + sin θ cos θM12 + cos θ sin θM21 + cos2 θM22), θ sin θ(t) = − sin θM21 − cos θM22 + cos θ(sin2 θM11 + sin θ cos θM12 + cos θ sin θM21 + cos2 θM22). (A26) (A27) We combine the two equations into a single one by taking a linear combination with weights cos θ and sin θ θ cos2 θ(t) + θ sin2 θ(t) = θ = cos θ sin θM11 + cos2 θM12 − sin2 θM21 − sin θ cos θM22, which further simplifies to θ = M11 − M22 2 M12 + M21 sin 2θ + cos 2θ + 2 M12 − M21 . 2 Introducing A = M11 − M22, B = M12 + M21 and C = M12 − M21, we obtain 2 θ = A sin 2θ + B cos 2θ + C. This is a first-order nonlinear differential equation. Since the nonlinear term is smooth, the unique (up to the 2π period) solution exists, which validates the ansatz (A23) and proves the existence of a limit cycle. We now explicitly calculate the period T of the limit cycle. To this end, integrate Eq. (A30) over T (A23) (A24) (A25) (A28) (A29) (A30) (A31) (A32) (A33) (A34) (A35) 4π = CT + (A sin 2θ + B cos 2θ)dt = CT + (A sin 2θ + B cos 2θ) 1 θ dθ = CT + 2 (1 − C A sin 2θ + B cos 2θ + C )dθ. 0 0 (cid:90) T (cid:90) 2π (cid:90) 2π (cid:90) 2π 0 We get the following equation for T T = This expression can be expressed as 2 dθ. A sin 2θ + B cos 2θ + C 0 (cid:90) 2π 0 T = 2 1 A sin θ(cid:48) + B cos θ(cid:48) + C dθ(cid:48) = 2 (cid:90) 2π 0 √ 1 A2 + B2 sin θ + C dθ, where we changed variables twice using θ(cid:48) = 2θ and θ = θ(cid:48) +α, where sin α = B/ A2 + B2 and we used the periodicity of the integrand to keep the integration limit as [0, 2π). The final integral can be evaluated using contour integration. We first change the variables z = A2 + B2eiθ, which yields √ √ 21 (cid:73) T = 4 dz z2 + 2iCz − (A2 + B2) . (A36) We note that C 2 > A2 + B2 corresponds to A having complex eigenvalues, which is the case of interest. In this case, A2 + B2 centered at the origin) the integrand has one simple pole inside the integration contour (circle of radius given by one of the roots of the integrand denominator. Applying the residue theorem, yields √ √ T = 4π C 2 − A2 − B2 . This can be related to the original matrix A and its negative real eigenvalue λ as (cid:112)2 det A/λ + λ2 − tr(A2) 4π . T = Assuming the complex eigenvalues take the form λ1,2 = α ± iβ, this further simplifies to T = 2π β . (A37) (A38) (A39) Therefore, the angular frequency of the limit cycle is given by the imaginary part of the complex eigenvalue. These results agree with the analysis in [19] obtained using a different method. 3. Velocity gradient of the Stokes flow around a sphere In this section, we compute the velocity gradient in Eq. (13) due to the Stokes flow around a sinking particle. We first carry out the calculation in the curvilinear orthogonal coordinate basis {∂r, ∂θ, ∂φ} with the metric tensor gij = diag(1, r2, r2 sin2 θ) and then transform to the usual orthonormal system {r, θ, φ}. The transformation between the two systems is encoded in the Jacobian J = diag(1, r, r sin θ). In the curvilinear system {∂r, ∂θ, ∂φ}, the Stokes flow (2) reads (cid:16) (cid:17) v = vr∂r + vθ∂θ = U cos θ 1 + R3 2r3 − 3R 2r ∂r + U sin θ (cid:16) − 1 r + R3 4r4 + 3R 4r2 (cid:17) ∂θ. (A40) (A41) To compute the velocity gradient (1,1)-tensor Aij = ∇jvi, we note that the only nonzero Christoffel symbols are φφ = −r sin2 θ, θθ = −r, Γr Γr Γθ rθ = Γθ Γφ rφ = Γφ θr = 1/r, Γθ φr = 1/r, Γφ φφ = − sin θ cos θ, θφ = Γφ φθ = cot θ. Using covariant differentiation, we find the velocity gradient tensor components (in the {∂r, ∂θ, ∂φ} basis) ∇rvr = ∂rvr, ∇rvθ = ∂rvθ + vθ/r, ∇rvφ = 0, ∇θvr = ∂θvr − rvθ, ∇θvθ = ∂θvθ + vr/r, ∇θvφ = 0, ∇φvr = 0, ∇φvθ = 0, ∇φvφ = vr/r + cot θvθ. (A42) (A43) (A44) (A45a) (A45b) (A45c) Explicit calculation gives the following expressions for the tensor entries ∇rvr = U cos θ ∇rvθ = U sin θ ∇rvφ = 0, ∇θvr = −U sin θ ∇θvθ = U cos θ ∇θvφ = 0, ∇φvr = 0, ∇φvθ = 0, ∇φvφ = U cos θ , 3R 2r2 (cid:17) (cid:16) − 3R3 (cid:17) (cid:16) 1 2r4 + r2 − R3 r5 − 3R (cid:16) (cid:17) (cid:16) − 1 2r3 − 3R R3 4r4 + 1 + 2r3 R3 2r + r 3R 4r2 (cid:17) + U sin θ r2 + = U sin θ (cid:16) − 1 (cid:16) (cid:16) 1 r (cid:17) 3R 4r3 R3 4r5 + (cid:17) 2r4 − 3R R3 2r2 (cid:17) + U sin θ 1 − R3 4r3 − 3R 4r = U sin θ + U cos θ + = U cos θ 4r3 (cid:16) − 3R3 4r5 − 3R (cid:17) (cid:16) − 3R3 (cid:17) (cid:16) 3R3 4r3 + 4r4 − 3R 3R 4r 4r2 , , (cid:16) 1 r (cid:17) + U cos θ (cid:16) − 1 r (cid:17) = U cos θ (cid:16) 3R3 4r4 − 3R 4r2 (cid:17) . + R3 4r4 + 3R 4r2 + R3 2r4 − 3R 2r2 As a sanity check, we compute the flow divergence which vanishes, as expected. In the matrix form, the above tensor reads (U = 1 and R = 1)  (cid:0) − 3 (cid:0) − 3 2r4 + 3 2r2 4r5 − 3 4r3 0 Aij = ∇jvi = JAJ−1 = 3 4 ( 1 r2 − 1 ∇rvr + ∇θvθ + ∇φvφ = 0,  . (cid:1) sin θ (cid:1) cos θ 4r (cid:1) cos θ (cid:0) − 3 (cid:1) sin θ (cid:0) 3 4r3 + 3 4r4 − 3  r4 ) cos θ 4r2 0 0 tan θ 2 − r2+1 r2−1 tan θ −1 0 0 0 −1  , 0 0 (cid:0) 3 4r4 − 3 4r2 (cid:1) cos θ Finally, we use the Jacobian J [Eq. (A40)] to express A in the orthonormal basis {r, θ, φ} (cid:17) , 22 (A46a) (A46b) (A46c) (A46d) (A46e) (A46f) (A46g) (A46h) (A46i) (A47) (A48) (A49) which yields Eq. (13), in agreement with the calculation in [21] where the velocity gradient was computed using a different method. 4. Ellipsoids in the Stokes flow: stagnation lines and particle surface The eigenvalues of the velocity gradient A [Eq. (13)] on the stagnation line (θ = 0, π) and the particle surface (r = 1) have multiplicity greater than one. In this case, the analysis of Section III A does not directly apply, yet these special locations will be important for the encounter process of non-motile microorganisms, which can only approach the sinking particle near the stagnation line θ = π. On the stagnation lines θ = 0, π, Eq. (13) reduces to Aij(r, θ = 0, π, φ) = ± 3 4 (cid:16) 1 r2 − 1 r4 (cid:17)2 0 0 0 −1 0 0 0 −1  , (A50) where +/− corresponds to θ = 0 and θ = π, respectively. This simple diagonal structure implies that on the upstream stagnation line (θ = π) rods align tangentially to the sinking particle, while on the downstream stagnation line (θ = 0), rods align vertically. This picture can be inferred from Fig. 3(b) by taking the limit ρ → 0. Since Aγ=−1 = −AT, we immediately obtain the response of disks. Disks align tangentially to the particle surface for θ = π (with axis of symmetry in the vertical direction), while they lie in the r − θ plane for θ = 0. Therefore, non-motile rods or disks approaching the sinking particle along the θ = π stagnation line orient with their longer dimension tangential to the particle surface. We now compute A on the particle surface to see if shear tends to maintain such a tangential orientation. At r = 1, the only nonzero component of the velocity gradient is Aθr(r = 1, θ, φ) = − 3 2 sin θ. This structure implies that the tangential orientations of rods (symmetry axis along θ − φ) and disks (symmetry axis along r) are the null vectors. Thus, to zeroth order, shear maintains the tangential orientation of rods and disks as they are advected around the sinking particle. 23 FIG. A.1: Additional comparison between experiments with non-motile elongated diatoms (a) and simulations (b -- d) shown in Fig. 5 of the Main Text. In simulations, we reject rods with out-of-plane components larger than: 15° (b), 30° (c) and 45° (d). Panels (a) and (c) are the same as panels (b,c) in Fig. 5 of the Main Text. FIG. A.2: Ratios of the encounter efficiencies with and without the impact of shear, ηmotile shear OFF (b), and the encounter efficiency based on the classical diffusive calculation ηmotile diffusive; all parameters are the same as in Fig. 10 and diffusive = 4Sh/Pe, where Fig. 11 of the Main Text. Sh and Pe are the Sherwood and P´eclet number, respectively [25]. For the Sherwood number, we used the following formula valid for low Reynolds number Sh = 0.5[1 + (1 + 2Pe)1/3]. For the P´eclet number, we took Pe = U R/Db, with the bacterial ; for the parameters used, Db = 5 × 10−5cm2/s. As discussed in Section VI, the diffusivity Db = 0.5U 2 diffusive encounter efficiency overestimates the ballistic one and only for the largest sinking particles considered here the two descriptions start to become comparable. In the presence of flow, the diffusive encounter efficiency is given by ηmotile shear ON (a) and ηmotile b τd, where τd = D−1 r 5. Methods: numerical simulations Time stepping. To numerically integrate the ballistic model [Eq. (3)], we discretized the equations of motion using the classical Runge -- Kutta method (RK4). Depending on the sinking speed, the time-step was chosen between ∆t = 0.075τb for U ∼ Ub and ∆t = 0.005τb for U ∼ 100Ub, where τb = lb/Ub is the time needed for the bacterium to travel distance equal to its bodylength. To integrate the quasi-ballistic model with rotational diffusion [Eq. (20)], we used the stochastic version of the Euler method; at each time step, the diffusive term is discretized by sampling a 3 × 1 vector with normally distributed entries with zero mean and variance 2Dr∆t. With the rotational diffusion coefficient Dr = 0.25s−1, the time step varied between 0.04 − 0.2ms. Estimation of the encounter efficiency. For a given sinking particle size R and sinking speed U , we estimated the encounter efficiency by discretizing Eq. (7). We typically sampled the encounter probability P (ρ) on a non-uniform grid to resolve the accumulation of P (ρ) near the accessibility region for slowly sinking particles or near the centerline for fast sinking particles (see Figs. 7 and 8); the number of points on the ρ-grid was always at least 50 for motile bacteria and 10 for non-motile bacteria. Once the estimate of P (ρ) had been obtained, the integral in Eq. (7) was evaluated using the trapezoidal rule. To estimate the encounter probability P (ρ) starting in the initial plane z = −6R at distance ρ away from the centerline for random initial orientations, we considered an ensemble of initial orientations by sampling along a spherical spiral. Such a sampling gives an approximately uniform distribution of points on a unit sphere of orientations. By using spherical spiral to sample initial orientations rather than choosing them randomly (that is, choosing 3 × 1 vectors with normal entries with zero mean and normalizing them to unit length), we obtained faster convergence (a)experiment(c)theory, 30° cutoff 100.5Sine of the angle with verticalx/R0-22-11z/R210-2-1(d)(b)theory, 15° cutoff theory, 45° cutoff x/R0-22-11x/R0-22-11x/R0-22-11(a)103101102Sinking speed U [μm/s]500635000ratio ηmotile /ηmotileshear OFFdiffusive103101102(b)ratio ηmotile /ηmotileshear ONdiffusive10010-110-210-3Particle radius R [μm]Particle radius R [μm]24 Formally, θf is defined as the integral 2π(cid:82) θf FIG. A.3: Additional characterization of the landing distribution function ξ(θ) for the simulations presented in Fig. 10 of the Main Text. Here, we look at the colatitude θf such that the fraction f of the interception positions lies in between 0° < θ < θf . ξ(θ) sin θdθ = f . We display the results for three fractions, f = 0.25 (top row), f = 0.5 (middle row) and f = 0.75 (bottom row). For reference, we note that a uniform coverage of the sphere corresponds to θ0.25 = 60°, θ0.5 = 90° and θ0.75 = 120°. 0 by avoiding random clustering of points on the unit sphere. The number of initial orientations was chosen high enough to guarantee that the solid angle the sinking particle extended at the initial bacterial location contained at least five initial orientations (the number of blue dots in the inset in Fig. 1 was always at least five). For such an angular resolution, the number of initial orientations varied between O(102) for fast sinking particles up to O(104) for slowly sinking particles, for which the accessibility region with P (ρ) > 0 was largest. In general, to estimate the encounter efficiency η for a given (R, U ) pair, we simulated about O(104) trajectories for fast sinking particles and up to O(106) trajectories for slowly sinking particles. In total, due to scanning the (R, U ) parameter space in different shear ON/OFF configurations, the this work summarizes the results of simulating about O(108) bacterial trajectories. Interception criterion. The sinking particle was assumed to be a perfect absorber: geometric overlap between any part of a bacterium and the particle was counted as an encounter. In simulations, for simplicity, we computed this geometric overlap by approximating elongated bacteria (α > 1) of length lb by a cylinder with spherical caps. The cylinder length, including caps, is lb and its width is lb/α. With this simplification, determining the interception is equivalent to determining the distance between the cylinder centerline and the particle center. Similarly, the geometry of oblate particles (α < 1) was approximated by considering four cylinders (with spherical caps) of length lb and width lbα. The centerlines of the cylinders lie in a plane, the centerline midpoints coincide and the centerlines are rotated at angle 45° - the four cylinders form two crosses rotated by 45°. With this simplification, determining the interception is equivalent to determining the distance between the four cylinder centerlines and the particle center. Estimation of the distribution of interception locations. To estimate ξ(θ) for a given (R, U ) pair, we (a)500635000Sinking speed U [μm/s]motile, elongated, shear ON lb=2μm, Ub=50μm/s, α=3.3motile, elongated, shear OFF lb=2μm, Ub=50μm/s, α=3.3103101102103101102103101102non-motile, spherical lb=1μm, Ub=0, α=1(b)(c)180°150°120°90°30°0°Colatitude of 25% coverage60°Particle radius R [μm]103101102103101102103101102103101102103101102103101102500635000Sinking speed U [μm/s]500635000Sinking speed U [μm/s]180°150°120°90°30°0°60°180°150°120°90°30°0°60°Colatitude of 50% coverageColatitude of 75% coverageParticle radius R [μm]Particle radius R [μm]considered the ensemble of the endpoints of trajectories that resulted in the interception. As described above, this ensemble resulted from scanning the ρ-range, the initial position at distance ρ away from the particle centerline in the initial z = −6R-plane, as well as uniform initial orientations. This ensemble yielded a histogram of the interception colatitudes θ. During construction of this histogram, the counts for each scanned position ρ were further weighted by ρ and the ρ-grid spacing, to account for the number of initial positions at distance ρ being proportional to ρ (circles of radius ρ) as well as the non-uniformity of the ρ-grid. Such prepared histogram of θ-counts (30 bins, bin width 6°), normalized to a probability density function over a unit sphere, was used as the estimate of ξ(θ). 25 6. Methods: experiments Cell cultured. Phaeodactylum tricornutum cells (strain CCMP2561) were cultured in f/2 medium (Guillard and Ryther 1962) mixed with artificial seawater. Artificial seawater was prepared by dissolving 35 g of artificial sea salt (Instant Ocean, Spectrum Brands) in 1 L double distilled water, filtered through a 0.2 µm filter and autoclaved. Cultures were propagated in 18° C in AlgaeTron AG 230 PSI (Photon Systems Instruments) with 14h/10h light/dark cycle. For the experiments, cells in the exponential growing phase were used. Cell length and width were 21.2±2.4 µm (n = 14) and 3.12 ± 0.57 µm (n = 14), respectively, as measured by phase microscopy. Experimental procedure. Alginate beads were prepared using a mix of sodium alginate salt from brown algae (1.5% w/v, medium viscosity; Sigma) with 50 mM ethylenediamine tetra acetic acid (EDTA) in double distilled water (DDW). Beads were prepared by dripping the alginate solution from a 1 mL syringe at rate of 60 µL min−1 from a height of 20 cm to beaker containing 0.5 M CaCl2 in DDW. The CaCl2 solution was stirred at 300 rpm, using a magnetic stir-bar. Flow dynamics were studied in microfluidic chip (Sticky-Slide 0.4 IBIDI). For the experiment, single bead was trapped at the center of the channel using a glass cover slide. A syringe pump (Harvard PHD2000) was then used to feed the channels with artificial sea water at the desired flow speed (160 µm s−1). Chanel was visualized using a Nikon (eclipse TI-2) microscope at magnification of 4 × 1.5 × 10 (60×) and 20 fps using Orca flash 4.0 (Hamamatsu) camera. Image analysis was performed on 50 consecutive images using ImageJ (Rueden, C. T et al. (2017)). In general 1098 ± 50 cells/image were measured. To extract the orientation from each cell, median image intensity was calculated using 'Stacks/Z Projection' function and subtract from all images. 'FFT/Bang pass' filter was used with small cutoff of 1 pxl and big cutoff of 10 pxl. 'Minimum' filter was used with 1 pxl cutoff. Data was transformed to binary using 'Make binary' function with default parameters. Finally, 'Analyze particle' function (Particle 30-1000 pxl) was used to collect the orientation data. Image analysis. [1] F. Lundell, L. D. Soderberg, and P. H. Alfredsson. Fluid mechanics of papermaking. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech., 43(1):195 -- 217, 2011. [2] G. Falkovich, A. Fouxon, and M. G. Stepanov. Acceleration of rain initiation by cloud turbulence. Nature, 419(6903):151 -- 154, 2002. [3] G. A. Jackson, A. M. Waite, and P. W. Boyd. Role of algal aggregation in vertical carbon export during SOIREE and in other low biomass environments. Geophys. Res. Lett., 32(13):L13607, 2005. [4] J. S. Guasto, R. Rusconi, and R. Stocker. Fluid mechanics of planktonic microorganisms. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech., 44(1):373 -- 400, 2012. [5] A. R. Longhurst and W. G. Harrison. The biological pump: profiles of plankton production and consumption in the upper ocean. Prog. Oceanogr., 22(1):47 -- 123, 1989. [6] H. W. Ducklow, D. K. Steinberg, and K. O. Buesseler. Upper ocean carbon export and the biological pump. Oceanography, 14(4):50 -- 58, 2001. [7] L. Karp-Boss, E. Boss, and P. A. Jumars. Nutrient fluxes to planktonic osmotrophs in the presence of fluid motion. Oceanogr. Mar. Biol. Annu. Rev., 34:71 -- 107, 1996. [8] T. Kiørboe, H.-P. Grossart, H. Ploug, and K. Tang. Mechanisms and rates of bacterial colonization of sinking aggregates. Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 68(8):3996 -- 4006, 2002. [9] S. K. Friedlander. Mass and heat transfer to single spheres and cylinders at low Reynolds numbers. AIChE J., 3(1):43 -- 48, 1957. [10] K. Son, F. Menolascina, and R. Stocker. Speed-dependent chemotactic precision in marine bacteria. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 113(31):8624 -- 8629, 2016. [11] A. B. Bochdansky, M. A. Clouse, and G. J. Herndl. Dragon kings of the deep sea: marine particles deviate markedly from the common number-size spectrum. Sci. Rep., 6:22633, 2016. [12] T. Kiørboe and G. A. Jackson. Marine snow, organic solute plumes, and optimal chemosensory behavior of bacteria. Limnol. Oceanogr., 46(6):1309 -- 1318, 2001. 26 [13] Marcos, H. C. Fu, T. R. Powers, and R. Stocker. Separation of microscale chiral objects by shear flow. Phys. Rev. Lett., 102(15):158103, 2009. [14] R. Rusconi, J. S. Guasto, and R. Stocker. Bacterial transport suppressed by fluid shear. Nat. Phys., 10(3):212 -- 217, 2014. [15] M. T. Barry, R. Rusconi, J. S. Guasto, and R. Stocker. Shear-induced orientational dynamics and spatial heterogeneity in suspensions of motile phytoplankton. J. Royal Soc. Interface, 12(112):20150791, 2015. [16] A. L. Alldredge and C. C. Gotschalk. Direct observations of the mass flocculation of diatom blooms: characteristics, settling velocities and formation of diatom aggregates. Deep Sea Res. A, 36(2):159 -- 171, 1989. [17] G. B. Jeffery. The motion of ellipsoidal particles immersed in a viscous fluid. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A, 102(715):161 -- 179, 1922. [18] M. Junk and R. Illner. A new derivation of Jeffery's equation. J. Math. Fluid Mech., 9(4):455 -- 488, 2007. [19] F. P. Bretherton. The motion of rigid particles in a shear flow at low Reynolds number. J. Fluid Mech., 14(2):284 -- 304, 1962. [20] G. K. Batchelor. Mass transfer from a particle suspended in fluid with a steady linear ambient velocity distribution. J. Fluid Mech., 95(2):369 -- 400, 1979. [21] T. Kiørboe and A. W. Visser. Predator and prey perception in copepods due to hydromechanical signals. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser., 179:81 -- 95, 1999. [22] S. Hess, L. Eme, A. J. Roger, and A. G. B. Simpson. A natural toroidal microswimmer with a rotary eukaryotic flagellum. Nat. microbiol., 2019. [23] J.-B. Raina, V. I. Fernandez, B. Lambert, R. Stocker, and J. R. Seymour. The role of microbial motility and chemotaxis in symbiosis. Nat. Rev. Microbiol., 17:284 -- 294, 2019. [24] A. W. Visser and T. Kiørboe. Plankton motility patterns and encounter rates. Oecologia, 148(3):538 -- 546, 2006. [25] T. Kiørboe. A mechanistic approach to plankton ecology. Princeton University Press, 2008. [26] S. Chandrasekhar. Stochastic problems in physics and astronomy. Rev. Mod. Phys., 15(1):1 -- 89, 1943. [27] D. Saintillan and M. J. Shelley. Instabilities and pattern formation in active particle suspensions: kinetic theory and continuum simulations. Phys. Rev. Lett., 100(17):178103, 2008. [28] R. N. Bearon and A. L. Hazel. The trapping in high-shear regions of slender bacteria undergoing chemotaxis in a channel. J. Fluid Mech., 771:R3, 2015. [29] H. C. Berg and E. M. Purcell. Physics of chemoreception. Biophys. J., 20(2):193 -- 219, 1977. [30] E. Secchi, A. Vitale, G. L. Mino, V. Kantsler, L. Eberl, R. Rusconi, and R. Stocker. The effect of flow on swimming bacteria controls the initial colonization of curved surfaces (submitted). 2019. [31] G. L. Mino, M. Baabour, R. Chertcoff, G. Gutkind, E. Cl´ement, H. Auradou, and I. Ippolito. E. coli accumulation behind an obstacle. Adv. Microbiol., 8:451 -- 464, 2018. [32] C. Bechinger, R. Di Leonardo, H. Lowen, C. Reichhardt, G. Volpe, and G. Volpe. Active particles in complex and crowded environments. Rev. Mod. Phys., 88(4):045006, 2016. [33] K. W. Bruland and M. W. Silver. Sinking rates of fecal pellets from gelatinous zooplankton (Salps, Pteropods, Doliolids). Mar. Biol., 63(3):295 -- 300, 1981. [34] P. D. Komar, A. P. Morse, L. F. Small, and S. W. Fowler. An analysis of sinking rates of natural copepod and euphausiid fecal pellets. Limnol. Oceanogr., 26(1):172 -- 180, 1981. [35] M. E. Weber, D. C. Blanchard, and L. D. Syzdek. The mechanism of scavenging of waterborne bacteria by a rising bubble. Limnol. Oceanogr., 28(1):101 -- 105, 1983. [36] A. Persat, H. A. Stone, and Z. Gitai. The curved shape of Caulobacter crescentus enhances surface colonization in flow. Nat. Commun., 5:3824, 2014. [37] B. S. Lambert, V. I. Fernandez, and R. Stocker. Motility drives bacterial encounter with particles responsible for carbon export throughout the ocean. Limnol. Oceanogr. Lett., in press, 2019. [38] H. C. Berg. Random walks in biology. Princeton University Press, 1993. [39] L. Stemmann and E. Boss. Plankton and particle size and packaging: From determining optical properties to driving the biological pump. Ann. Rev. Mar. Sci., 4(1):263 -- 290, 2012. [40] X. Mari, U. Passow, C. Migon, A. B. Burd, and L. Legendre. Transparent exopolymer particles: Effects on carbon cycling in the ocean. Prog. Oceanogr., 151:13 -- 37, 2017. [41] J. Wang and W. Gao. Nano/microscale motors: biomedical opportunities and challenges. ACS Nano, 6(7):5745 -- 5751, 2012. [42] W. Gao and J. Wang. The environmental impact of micro/nanomachines: a review. ACS Nano, 8(4):3170 -- 3180, 2014.
1810.07623	1	1810	2018-10-17T15:38:01	Searching for collective behavior in a small brain	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.dis-nn", "q-bio.NC" ]	In large neuronal networks, it is believed that functions emerge through the collective behavior of many interconnected neurons. Recently, the development of experimental techniques that allow simultaneous recording of calcium concentration from a large fraction of all neurons in Caenorhabditis elegans - a nematode with 302 neurons - creates the opportunity to ask if such emergence is universal, reaching down to even the smallest brains. Here, we measure the activity of 50+ neurons in C. elegans, and analyze the data by building the maximum entropy model that matches the mean activity and pairwise correlations among these neurons. To capture the graded nature of the cells' responses, we assign each cell multiple states. These models, which are equivalent to a family of Potts glasses, successfully predict higher statistical structure in the network. In addition, these models exhibit signatures of collective behavior: the state of single cells can be predicted from the state of the rest of the network; the network, despite being sparse in a way similar to the structural connectome, distributes its response globally when locally perturbed; the distribution over network states has multiple local maxima, as in models for memory; and the parameters that describe the real network are close to a critical surface in this family of models.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Searching for collective behavior in a small brain Xiaowen Chen,1 Francesco Randi,1 Andrew M. Leifer,1,2 and William Bialek1,3,4 1Joseph Henry Laboratories of Physics, 2Princeton Neuroscience Institute, and 3Lewis-Sigler Institute for Integrative Genomics, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544 4Initiative for the Theoretical Sciences, The Graduate Center, City University of New York, 365 Fifth Ave., New York, NY 10016 (Dated: October 18, 2018) In large neuronal networks, it is believed that functions emerge through the collective behavior of many interconnected neurons. Recently, the development of experimental techniques that allow simultaneous recording of calcium concentration from a large fraction of all neurons in Caenorhab- ditis elegans -- a nematode with 302 neurons -- creates the opportunity to ask if such emergence is universal, reaching down to even the smallest brains. Here, we measure the activity of 50+ neurons in C. elegans, and analyze the data by building the maximum entropy model that matches the mean activity and pairwise correlations among these neurons. To capture the graded nature of the cells' responses, we assign each cell multiple states. These models, which are equivalent to a family of Potts glasses, successfully predict higher statistical structure in the network. In addition, these models exhibit signatures of collective behavior: the state of single cells can be predicted from the state of the rest of the network; the network, despite being sparse in a way similar to the structural connectome, distributes its response globally when locally perturbed; the distribution over network states has multiple local maxima, as in models for memory; and the parameters that describe the real network are close to a critical surface in this family of models. I. INTRODUCTION The ability of the brain to generate coherent thoughts, percepts, memories, and actions depends on the coordi- nated activity of large numbers of interacting neurons. It is an old idea in the physics community that these collec- tive behaviors in neural networks should be describable in the language of statistical mechanics [1 -- 3]. For many years it was very difficult to connect these ideas with experiment, but new opportunities are offered by the re- cent emergence of methods to record, simultaneously, the electrical activity of large numbers of neurons [4 -- 9]. In particular, it has been suggested that maximum entropy models [10] provide a path to construct a statistical me- chanics description of network activity directly from real data [11], and this approach has been pursued in the analysis of the vertebrate retina as it responds to natural movies and other light conditions [11 -- 14], the dynamics of the hippocampus during exploration of real and vir- tual environments [15 -- 17], and the coding mechanism of spontaneous spikes in cortical networks [18 -- 20]. Maximum entropy models that match low order fea- tures of the data, such as the mean activity of individual neurons and the correlations between pairs, make quan- titative predictions about higher order structures in the network, and in some cases these are in surprisingly de- tailed agreement with experiment [14, 17]. These models also illustrate the collective character of network activ- ity. In particular, the state of individual neurons often can be predicted with high accuracy from the state of the other neurons in the network, and the models that are in- ferred from the data are close to critical surfaces in their parameter space, which connects with other ideas about the possible criticality of biological networks [21 -- 23]. nomena in networks of neurons has been focused on verte- brate brain, with neurons that generate discrete, stereo- typed action potentials or spikes [24]. This discreteness suggests a natural mapping into an Ising model, which is at the start of the maximum entropy analyses, although one could imagine alternative approaches. What is not at all clear is whether these approaches could capture the dynamics of networks in which the neurons generate graded electrical responses. An important example of this question is provided by the nematode Caenorhabdi- tis elegans, which does not have the molecular machinery needed to generate conventional action potentials [25]. The nervous system of C. elegans has just 302 neu- rons, yet the worm can still exhibit complex neuronal functions: locomotion, sensing, nonassociative and asso- ciative learning, and sleep-wake cycles [26 -- 29]. All of the neurons are "identified," meaning that we can find the cell with a particular label in every organism of the species, and in some cases we can find analogous cells in nearby species [30]. In addition, this is the only or- ganism in which we know the entire pattern of connec- tions among the cells, usually known as the (structural) connectome [31]. The small size of this nervous system, together with its known connectivity, has always made it a tempting target for theorizing, but relatively little was known about the patterns of electrical activity in the system. This has changed dramatically with the de- velopment of genetically encodable indicator molecules, whose fluorescence is modulated by changes in calcium concentration, a signal which in turn follows electrical activity [32]. Combining these tools with high resolution tracking microscopy opens the possibility of recording the activity in the entire C. elegans nervous system as the an- imal behaves freely [7 -- 9]. Thus far, almost all discussion about collective phe- In this paper we make a first try at the analysis of 8 1 0 2 t c O 7 1 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 3 2 6 7 0 . 0 1 8 1 : v i X r a 2 FIG. 1: Schematics of data acquisition and processing. (a) Examples of the raw images acquired through the 10× (scale bar equals 100µm) and 40× (scale bar equals 10µm) objectives. The body of the nematode is outlined with light green curves. (b) The intensity of the nuclei-localized fluorescent protein tags -- the calcium-sensitive GCaMP and the control fluorophore RFP -- are measured as functions of time. Photobleaching occurs on a longer time scale than the intracellular calcium dynamics, which allows us to perform photobleaching correction by dividing the raw signal with its exponential fit, resulting in the signals of panel (c). (d) The normalized ratio of the photobleaching-corrected intensity, f , is a proxy for the calcium concentration in each neuron nuclei (dark grey). As described in the text, this signal is discretized using the denoised time derivative f ; we use three states, marked as red, blue, and black after smoothing (lightly offset for ease of visualization). (e) The time derivative f , extracted using total-variation regularized differentiation. experiments in C. elegans using the maximum entropy methods that have been so successful in other contexts. Experiments are evolving constantly, and in particular we expect that recording times will increase significantly in the near future. To give ourselves the best chance of say- ing something meaningful, we focus on sub -- populations of up to fifty neurons, in immobilized worms where sig- nals are most reliable. We find that, while details dif- fer, the same sorts of models, which match mean activity and pairwise correlations, are successful in describing this very different network. In particular, the models that we learn from the data share topological similarity with the known structural connectome, allow us to predict the ac- tivity of individual cells from the state of the rest of the network, and seem to be near a critical surface in their parameter space. II. DATA ACQUISITION AND PROCESSING Following methods described previously [7, 8], nema- todes Caenorhabditis elegans were genetically engineered to expressed two fluorescent proteins in all of their neu- rons, with tags that cause them to be localized to the nuclei of these cells. One of these proteins, GCaMP6s, fluoresces in the green with an intensity that depends on the surrounding calcium concentration, which follows the electrical activity of the cell and in many cases is the proximal signal for transmission across the synapses to other cells [32]. The second protein, RFP, fluoresces in the red and serves as a position indicator of the nu- clei as well as a control for changes in the visibility of the nuclei during the course of the experiment. Parallel control experiments were done on worms engineered to express GFP and RFP, neither of which should be sen- sitive to electrical activity. Although our ultimate goal is to understand neural dynamics in the freely moving animal, as a first step we study worms that are immobi- lized with polystyrene beads, to reduce motion-induced artifacts [33]. As described in Ref. [7], the fluorescence is excited us- ing lasers. A spinning disk confocal microscope and a high-speed, high-sensitivity Scientific CMOS (sCMOS) camera records red- and green-channel fluorescent image of the head of the worm at a rate of 6 brain-volumes per second at a magnification of 40×; a second imag- ing path records the position and posture of the worm at a magnification of 10×, which are used in the track- ing of the neurons across different time frames. The raw data thus are essentially movies, and by using a custom machine-learning approach -- Neuron Registration Vector Encoding [8] -- we are able to reduce the data to the green and red intensities for each neuron i, I g i (t) and I r i (t). As indicated in Fig. 1b, the fluorescence intensity un- (a) (c)0100200300400500time (s)020040060080010001200fluorescence intensity per area (a.u.)(d)f0100200300400500time (s)0.511.5I0100200300400500time (s)0.511.50100200300400500time (s)-0.0500.05(e)f.(b)10× IR40× GCaMP40× RFP10× RFP3 i (t) and ¯I r divide these out to recover normalized intensities in each channel and each cell, ¯I g i (t). Finally, to reduce instrumental and/or motion induced artifacts, we con- sider the ratio of the normalized intensities as the signal for each neuron, i.e. fi(t) = ¯I g In this normalization scheme, if the calcium concentration remains constant, then fi(t) = 1. i (t) (Fig. 1d). i (t)/ ¯I r Our goal is to write a model for the joint probability distribution of activity in all of the cells in the network. To stay as close as possible to previous work, at least in this first try, it makes sense to quantize the activity into discrete states. One possibility is to discretize based on the magnitude of the fluorescence ratio fi(t). But this is problematic, since even in "control" worms where the fluorescence signal should not reflect electrical activity, variations in different cells are correlated; this is illus- trated in Fig. 2a, where we see that the distribution of mutual information between fi(t) and fj(t), across all pairs (i, j), is almost the same in control and experimen- tal worms. A closer look at the raw signal suggests that normalizing by the RFP intensity is not enough to correct for occasional wobbles of the worm; this causes the dis- tribution of the fluorescence ratio to be non-stationary, and generates spurious correlations. This suggests that (instantaneous) fluorescence signals are not especially re- liable, at least given the current processing methods and the state of our experiments. An alternative is to look at the derivatives of these signals, which by definition suffer from the global noise only at a few instances; now there is very little mutual information between fi(t) and fj(t) in the control worms, and certainly much less than in the experimental worms, as seen in Fig. 2b. To give ourselves a bit more help in isolating a mean- ingful signal, we denoise the time derivatives. The op- timal Bayesian reconstruction of the underlying time derivative signal u(t) combines a description of noise in the raw fluorescence signal f (t) with some prior expec- tations about the signal u itself. We approximate the noise in f as Gaussian and white, which is consistent with what we see at high frequencies, and we assume that the temporal variations in the derivative are expo- nentially distributed and only weakly correlated in time. Then maximum likelihood reconstruction is equivalent to minimizing (cid:90) T 0 dtAu − f2 , (2) (cid:90) T 0 F (u) = τf σf dt u + 1 2σ2 nτn where A is the antiderivative operator, the combination σ2 nτn is the spectral density of noise floor that we see in f at high frequencies, while σf is the total standard devia- tion of the signal and τf is the typical time scale of these variations; for more on these reconstruction methods see Ref. [35]. We determine the one unknown parameter τf by asking that, after smoothing, the cumulative power spectrum of the residue Au − f has the least root mean square difference from the cumulative power spectrum of the extrapolated white noise. As an example, Fig. 1e shows the smooth derivative FIG. 2: Comparison of pairwise mutual information distribu- tion for the calcium-sensitive GCaMP worms and the GFP control worms. Mutual information is estimated using bin- ning and finite-sample extrapolation methods as described in [34] for all pairs of neurons. For the normalized fluores- cence ratio, f , the distribution of the mutual information, P (I(fi; fj)), exhibits little difference between the calcium- sensitive GCaMP worm and the GFP control worm (panel (a)). In comparison, for the time derivative of the normalized f , the distribution of the mutual informa- fluorescence ratio, tion, P (I( fi; fj)), is peaked around zero for the GFP control worm, while the distribution is wide for the calcium-sensitive GCaMP worm (panel (b)). This observation suggests that fi, is more informative time derivative of fluorescence ratio, than its magnitude, fi. dergoes photobleaching, fortunately on much longer time scale than the calcium dynamics. Thus, we can extract the photobleaching effect by modeling the observed fluo- rescence intensity with an exponential decay: Ig(t) = Sg(t)(1 + ηg)(e−t/τg + Ag) Ir(t) = Sr(t)(1 + ηr)(e−t/τr + Ar) (1) Here, Sg(t) and Sr(t) are the true signals corresponding to the calcium concentration, ηg and ηr are stochastic variables representing the noise due to the laser and the camera, τg and τr are the characteristic time for photo- bleaching of the two fluorophores, and Ag and Ar repre- sent nonnegative offsets due to a population of unbleach- able fluorophores, or regeneration of fluorescent states under continuous illumination.1 For each neuron, we fit the observed fluorescence in- tensities to Eqs (1) with Sg(t) = S0 g and ηg = 0, and sim- ilarly for Sr(t). As shown by the black lines in Fig. 1b, this captures the slow photobleaching dynamics; we then 1 One may worry that a constant "background" fluorescence should be subtracted from the raw signal, rather than contribut- ing to a divisive normalization. In our data, this background sub- traction leads to strongly non-stationary noise in the normalized intensity after the photobleaching correction, in marked contrast to what we find by treating the constant as a contribution from unbleachable or regenerated fluorophores. (a)(b)00.51I(fi; fj)10-2100102(bits)P(I)(1/bits)00.5110-2100102GCaMP6GFPI(fi; fj)..(bits)P(I)(1/bits)4 FIG. 3: Discretization of the empirically observed fluorescence signals. (a) Heatmap of the normalized fluorescence ratio between photobleaching-corrected GCaMP fluorescence intensity and RFP fluorescence intensity, f , for each neuron as a function of time. (b) Heatmap of the neuronal activity after discretization based on time derivatives of f . Green corresponds to a state of "rising", red "falling", and white "flat". of the trace in Fig. 1d. After the smooth derivative u is estimated, we discretized the smooth estimate of the signal, Au, into three states of "rise," "fall," and "flat," depending on whether the derivative u exceeds a constant multiple of σn/τf , the expected standard deviation of the smooth derivative extracted from a pure white noise. The constant is chosen to be σn/τf = 5, such that the GFP control worm has almost all pairwise mutual information being zero after going through the same data processing pipeline. An example of the raw fluorescence and final discretized signals is shown in Fig. 3. III. MAXIMUM ENTROPY MODEL After preprocessing, the state of each neuron is de- scribed by a Potts variable σi, and the state of the entire network is {σi}. As in previous work on a wide range of biological systems [11, 14, 17, 36 -- 38], we use a maximum entropy approach to generate relatively simple approxi- mations to the distribution of states, P ({σi}), and then ask how accurate these models are in making predictions about higher order structure in the network activity. The maximum entropy approach begins by choosing some set of observables, Oµ({σi}), over the states of the system, and we insist that any model we write down for P ({σi}) match the expectation values for these observ- ables that we find in the data, P ({σi})Oµ({σi}) = (cid:104)Oµ({σi})(cid:105)expt. (3) (cid:88) {σi} Among the infinitely many distributions consistent with these constraints, we choose the one that has the largest possible entropy, and hence no structure beyond what is needed to satisfy the constraints in Eq. (3). The formal solution to this problem is P ({σi}) = 1 Z exp − (cid:34) (cid:35) λµOµ({σi}) , (4) (cid:88) µ where coupling constant λµ must be set to satisfy and Eq. (3), and the partition function Z as usual enforces normalization. Following the original application of maximum entropy methods to neural activity [11], we choose as observables the mean activity of each cell, and the correlations be- tween pairs of cells. With neural activity described by three states, "correlations" could mean a whole matrix or tensor of joint probabilities for two cells to be in par- ticular states. We will see that models which match this tensor have too many parameters to be inferred reliably from the data sets we have available, and so we take a simpler view in which "correlation" measures the proba- bility that two neurons are in the same state. Equation (4) then becomes with the effective Hamiltonian H(σ) = − 1 2 Jijδσiσj − (cid:88) i(cid:54)=j P (σ) = e−H(σ) , (5) 1 Z (cid:88) p−1(cid:88) i r=1 hr i δσir . (6) The number of states p = 3, corresponding to "rise," "fall," and "flat" as defined above. The parameters are the pairwise interaction Jij and the local fields hr i , and these must be set to match the experimental values of the correlations cij ≡ (cid:104)δσiσj(cid:105) = 1 T δσi(t)σj (t) , (7) T(cid:88) t=1 100200300400500102030405060708010020030040050010203040506070800.511.52100200300400500204060800.511.52Neuron ID,iit(sec)t(sec)(a)(b)risefallflatNormalized fluorescence ratio, fDiscretized signal, σ5 FIG. 5: Top: No signs of overfitting are observed for mod- els of up to N = 50 neurons, measured by the difference of per-neuron log-likelihood of the data under the pairwise max- imum entropy model for training sets consists of 5/6 of the data and test sets. Clusters around N = 10, 15, 20, . . . , 50 represent randomly chosen subgroups of N neurons. Error bars are the standard deviation across 10 random partitions of training and test samples. The dashed lines show the ex- pected per-neuron log-likelihood difference and its standard deviation calculated through perturbation methods (see Ap- pendix A). Bottom: The difference between log likelihood of the training data and of the test data is greater than 0 (the red line) within error bars for maximum entropy models on N = 10, 20, . . . , 50 neurons with pairwise correlation tensor constraint (see Appendix B), which suggests that this model does not generalize well. timate from variations across random halves of the data. This training procedure leaves part of the interaction ma- trix Jij zero, while the model is able to reproduce the magnetization mr i and the pairwise correlation cij within the experimental errors (Fig. 4). Because of the large temporal correlation in the data, the number of independent data in the recording is small compared to the number of parameters. This makes us worry about overfitting, which we test by randomly se- lecting 5/6 of the data as training set, inferring the max- imum entropy model from this training set, and then comparing the log-likelihood of both the training data and the test data with respect to the maximum entropy model. No signs of overfitting are found for subgroups of up to N = 50 neurons, as indicated by that fact that the difference of the log-likelihood is zero within error bars (Fig. 5; details in Appendix A). This is not true if we try to match the full tensor correlations (Appendix B), which is why we restrict ourselves to the simpler model. IV. DOES THE MODEL WORK? The maximum entropy model has many appealing fea- tures, not least its mathematical equivalence to statisti- cal physics problems for which we have some intuition. But this does not mean that this model gives an accu- FIG. 4: Model construction: learning the maximum entropy model from data. (a) Connected pairwise correlation ma- trix, Cij, measured for a subgroup of 50 neurons. (b) The inferred interaction matrix, Jij. (c) Probability of neuron i in state r, for the same group of 50 neurons as panel (a). (d) The inferred local field, hr i . (e) Model reproduces pair- wise correlation (unconnected) within variation throughout the experiment. Error bars are extrapolated from bootstrap- ping random halves of the data. (f) Same as panel (e), but for mean neuron activity mr i . and the magnetizations mr i ≡ (cid:104)δσir(cid:105) = 1 T T(cid:88) t=1 δσi(t)r . (8) Note that the local field for the "flat" state, hp i , is set to zero by convention. In addition, the interaction Jij can be non-zero for any pairs of neurons i and j regardless of the positions of the neurons (both physical and in the structural connectome), i.e. the equivalent Potts model does not have a pre-defined spatial structure. The model parameters are learned using coordinate descent and Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sam- pling [39 -- 41]. In particular, we initialize all parame- ters at zero. For each optimization step, we calculate the model prediction cij and mr i by alternating between MCMC sampling with 104 MC sweeps and histogram sampling to speed up the estimation. Then, we choose a single parameter from the set of parameters {Jij, hr i} to update, such that the increase of likelihood of the data is maximized [39]. We repeat the observable estimation and parameter update steps until the model reproduces the constraints within the experimental errors, which we es- 00.51cij, model00.51cij, data00.51mir, model00.51mir, data01020304050Neuron ID00.51mir, data1020304050Neuron ID1020304050Neuron ID-0.500.51020304050Neuron ID1020304050Neuron ID-1011020304050Neuron ID1020304050Neuron ID-0.500.51020304050Neuron ID1020304050Neuron ID-101iijjCijJij01020304050Neuron ID-505hir, modelmirhir(a)(b)(c)(d)iirisefallflatmir, modelmir, datacij, datacij, model(e)(f)N-0.100.1ltest-ltrain1020304050N-0.100.1ltest-ltrainrate description of the real network. Here we test several predictions of the model. In practice we generate these predictions by running a long Monte Carlo simulation of the model, and then treating the samples in this simula- tion exactly as we do the real data. We emphasize that, having matched the mean activity and pairwise correla- tions, there are no free parameters, so that everything which follows is a prediction and not a fit. 6 p(cid:88) r=1 Since we use the correlations between pairs of neurons in constructing our model, the first nontrivial test is to predict correlations among triplets of neurons, Cijk = (cid:104)(δσir − (cid:104)δσir(cid:105))(δσj r − (cid:104)δσj r(cid:105))(δσkr − (cid:104)δσkr(cid:105))(cid:105) . (9) More subtly, since we used only the probability of two neurons being in the same state, we can try to predict the full matrix of pairwise correlations, C rs ij ≡ (cid:104)δσirδσj s(cid:105) − (cid:104)δσir(cid:105)(cid:104)δσj s(cid:105) ; (10) note that the trace of this matrix is what we used in building the model. Scatter plots of observed vs pre- dicted values for Cijk and C rs ij are shown in Fig. 6a and c. In parts b and d of that figure we pool the data, com- paring the root-mean-square differences between our pre- dictions and mean observations (model error) with errors in the measurements themselves. Although not perfect, model errors are always within 1.5× the measurement errors, over the full dynamic range of our predictions. Turning to more global properties of the system, we consider the probability of k neurons being in the same state, defined as (cid:68) p(cid:88) r=1 (cid:69) I(cid:80)N i=1 δσir=k P (k) ≡ , (11) where I is the indicator function. It is useful to com- pute this distribution not just from the data, but also from synthetic data in which we break correlations among neurons by shifting each cell's sequence of states by an independent random time. We see in Fig. 7a that the real distribution is very different from what we would see with independent neurons, so that in particular the tails provide a signature of correlations. These data agree very well with the distributions predicted by the model. Our model assigns an "energy" to every possible state of the network [Eq. (6)], which sets the probability of that state according to the Boltzmann distribution. Be- cause our samples are limited, we cannot test whether the energies of individual states are correct, but we can ask whether the distribution of these assigned energies across the real states taken on by the network agree with what it predicted from the model. Figure 7b compares these distributions, shown cumulatively, and we see that there is very good overlap between theory and experi- ment across ∼ 90% of the density, with the data having a slightly fatter tail than predicted. The good agreement FIG. 6: Model validation: The model predicts unconstrained higher order correlations of the data. Panel (a) shows the comparison between model prediction and data for the con- nected three-point correlation Cijk for a representative group of N = 50 neurons. All 19800 possible triplets are plotted with the blue dot. Error bars are generated by bootstrapping random halves of the data, and are shown for 20 uniformly spaced random triplets in red. Panel (b) shows the error of three-point function ∆Cijk as a function of the connected three-point function Cijk, binned by its value predicted by the model, Cijk, model. The red curve is the difference between data and model prediction. The blue curve is the standard error from mean of Cijk over the course of the experiment, extracted by bootstrapping random halves of the experiment. Panels (c, d) are the same as panels (a, b), but for the con- nected two-point correlation tensor C rs ij . extends over a range of ∆E ∼ 20 in energy, correspond- ing to predicted probabilities that range over a factor of exp(∆E) ∼ 108. The maximum entropy model gives the probability for the entire network to be in a given state, which means that we can also compute the conditional probabilities for the state of one neuron given the state of all the other neurons in the network. Testing whether we get this right seems a very direct test of the idea that activity in the network is collective. This conditional probability can be written as P (σi{σj(cid:54)=i}) ∝ exp gr i δσir , (12) where the effective fields are combinations of the local field hr i and each cell's interaction with the rest of the network. (cid:35) (cid:34)p−1(cid:88) r=1 gr i = hr i + Jij(δσj r − δσj p) . (13) Then the probabilities for the states of neuron i are set N(cid:88) j(cid:54)=i -0.200.2Cijrs, model-0.2-0.100.10.2Cijrs, data-0.100.1Cijrs, model0.0050.010.0150.02Cijrs-0.0100.010.020.03Cijk, model246810Cijk10-3-0.0500.05Cijk, model-0.0500.05ijkC, data(a)(b)(c)(d)datamodelby V. WHAT DOES THE MODEL TEACH US? P (σi = r) P (σi = p) = egr i , (14) A. Energy landscape 7 where the last state p is a reference. In Figure 7c and d we test these predictions. In practice we walk through the data, and at each moment in time, for each cell, we compute effective fields. We then find all moments where the effective field falls into a small bin, and compute the ratio of probabilities for the states of the one cell, col- lecting the data as shown. The agreement is excellent, except at extreme values of the field which are sampled only very rarely in the data. We note the agreement ex- tends over a dynamic range of roughly two decades in the probability ratios.2 FIG. 7: Model validation: comparison between model predic- tion and data for observables not constrained by the model. The neuron network has N = 50 neurons. (a) Probability of k neurons being in the same state. Blue dots are computed from the data. Yellow dash-dot line is the prediction from a model where all neurons are independent, generated by ap- plying a random temporal cyclic permutation to the activity of each neuron. Purple line is the prediction of the pairwise maximum entropy model. (b) Tail distribution of the energy for the data and the model. All error bars in this figure are extrapolated from bootstrapping. (c, d) Probability ratio of the state of a single neuron as a function of the effective field gr i , binned by the value of the effective field. Error bars are the standard deviation after binning. 2 The claim that behaviors are collective requires a bit more than predictability. It is possible that behaviors of individual cells are predictable from the state of the rest of the network, but that most of the predictive power comes from interaction with a sin- gle strongly coupled partner. We have checked that the mutual information I(σi; gr i ) is larger than the maximum of I(σi; σk), in almost all cases. Maximum entropy models are equivalent to Boltz- mann distributions and thus define an energy landscape over the states of the system, as shown schematically in Fig. 8a. In our case, as in other neural systems, the relevant models have interactions with varying signs, al- lowing the development of frustration and hence a land- scape with multiple local minima. These local minima are states of high probability, and serve to divide the large space of possible states into basins. It is natural to ask how many of these basins are supported in subnet- works of different sizes. To search for energy minima, we performed quenches from initial conditions corresponding to the states ob- served in the experiment, as described in [14]. Briefly, at each update, we change the state of one neuron such that the decrease of energy is maximized, and we ter- minate this procedure when no single spin flip will de- crease the energy; the states that are attracted to local energy minimum α form a basin of attraction Ωα. As shown in Fig. 8c, the number of energy minima grows sub-exponentially as the number of neurons increases. Note that this approach only gives us the states that the animal has access to, rather than all metastable states, whose number is approximated by greedy quench along a long MCMC trajectory. Nonetheless, the probability of visiting a basin is similar between the data and the model, shown by the rank-frequency plot (Fig. 8d). Whether the energy minima correspond to well defined collective states depends on the heights of the barriers between states. Here, we calculate the barrier height between basins by single-spin-flip MCMC, initialized at one minimum α and terminating when the state of the system belongs to a different basin Ωβ; the barrier be- tween basins Ωα and Ωβ is defined as the maximum en- ergy along this trajectory. This sampling procedure is repeated 1000 times for each initial basin to compute the mean energy barrier. As shown in Fig. 8b, the distribu- tion of barrier energies strongly overlaps the distribution of the energy minima, which implies that the minima are not well separated. Further visualization of the topography of the energy landscape is performed by constructing metabasins, fol- lowing Ref [42]. Here, we construct metabasins by group- ing the energy minima according to the barrier height; basins with barrier height lower than a given energy threshold, ∆E, are grouped into a single metabasin. This threshold can be varied: at high enough threshold, the system effectively does not see any local minima; at low threshold, the partition of the energy landscape ap- proaches the partition given by the original basins of at- traction. If the dynamics were just Brownian motion on the landscape, states within the same metabasin would transition into one other more rapidly than states be- longing to different metabasins. As shown in Fig. 8e, -505girise-4-20246ln(Prise/Pflat)-4-20246gifall-4-20246ln(Pfall/Pflat)-80-60-40-20Energy10-410-210002040k00.050.1P(k)dataind.pairwise(a)(b)(c)(d)modelmodeldatadataprobability8 FIG. 8: Energy landscape of the inferred maximum entropy model. (a) Schematic of the energy landscape with local minima α, β and the corresponding basin Ωα, Ωβ. Colored in light blue is the metabasin formed at the given energy threshold, ∆E. (b) Typical distribution of the value of the energy minima and the barriers of a maximum entropy model on N = 30 neurons. The global energy minimum, E0, is subtracted from the energy, E. (c) The number of energy minima increases sub-exponentially as number of neurons included in the model increases. Error bars are the standard deviation of 10 different subgroups of N neurons. (d) The rank-frequency plot for frequency of visiting each basin matches well between data and model for a typical subgroup of 40 neurons. (e) The number of metabasins, grouped according to the energy barrier, diverges when the energy threshold ∆E approaches 1 from above. there is a transition at ∆E ≈ 1.2 from single to multiple metabasins for all N = 10, 20, and 30. Since the dynam- ics of the real system do not correspond to a simple walk on the energy landscape (Appendix C and Fig. 12), we cannot conclude that this is a true dynamical transition, but it does suggest that the state space is organized in ways that are similar to what is seen in systems with such transitions. B. Criticality Maximum entropy models define probability distribu- tions that are equivalent to equilibrium statistical physics problems. As these systems become large, we know that the parameter space separates into distinct phases, sep- arated by critical surfaces. In several biological systems that have been analyzed there are signs that these criti- cal surfaces are not far from the operating points of the real networks, although the interpretation of this result remains controversial [21]. Here we ask simply whether the same pattern emerges in C. elegans. One natural slice through the parameter space of mod- els corresponds to changing the effective temperature of the system, effectively scaling all terms in the log prob- ability up and down uniformly. Concretely, we replace H(σ) → H(σ)/T in Eq (5). We monitor the heat ca- pacity of the system, as we would in thermodynamics; here the natural interpretation is of the heat capacity as being proportional to the variance of the log probability, so it measures the dynamic range of probabilities that can be represented by the network. Results are shown in Fig. 9, for randomly chosen subsets of N = 10, 20, ..., 50 neurons. A peak in heat capacity often signals a critical point, and here we see that the maximum of the heat capacity approaches the operational temperature T0 = 1 from below as N becomes larger, suggesting that the full network is near to criticality. C. Network topology The worm C. elegans is special in part because it is the only organism in which we know (essentially) the full pattern of connectivity among neurons. Our models also have a "connectome," since only a small fraction of the possible pairs of neurons are linked by a nonzero value of Jij. The current state of our experiments is such that we αβΩαΩβ10-5100E - E0Emetabasinbasinprobability densitylocal min.barrier10-1101E100102NMBN = 10N=20N=30100rank10-5frequency102100100N100102104Nbasindatamodel20400510152025(a)(c)(d)(e)(b)9 neuron is the all "flat" state, σk = p. Following the maximum entropy model [Eq. (6)], the probability dis- tribution for the rest of the network becomes (cid:101)Pk(σ) ≡ P (σ1, σ2, ...σN−1σk = 3) = (cid:101)Hk(σ) = − where the effective Hamiltonian is Jijδσiσj − (cid:88) (cid:88) 1 2 i(cid:54)=j(cid:54)=k 1(cid:101)Zk e−(cid:101)Hk(σ) , (15) p−1(cid:88) (cid:88) hr i δσir . Jikδσip− i(cid:54)=k r=1 i(cid:54)=k (16) On the other hand, ablation of neuron k means the re- moval of neuron k from the network, which leads to an effective Hamiltonian (cid:98)Hk(σ) = − 1 2 (cid:88) i(cid:54)=j(cid:54)=k (cid:88) p−1(cid:88) r=1 i(cid:54)=k Jijδσiσj − hr i δσir . (17) We examine the effect of clamping and ablation by Monte Carlo simulation of these modified models. We fo- cus on the response of individual neurons i to perturbing neuron k, which is summarized by change in the magne- tizations, mr i . But since these also represent the probabilities of finding the neuron i in each of the states r = 1, ..., p, we can measure the change as a Kullback -- Leibler divergence, i → mr p(cid:88) r=1 (cid:19) (cid:18) mr i mr i DKL = mr i log bits. (18) FIG. 10: The topology of the learned maximum entropy model approaches that of the structural connectome, as the number of neurons being modeled, N , increases. The two global topological properties being measured are the cluster- ing coefficient C (panel (a)) and characteristic path length L (panel (b)). Here, the inferred network topology for three different worms is plotted in blue. Red curves are for the randomized network with the same number of neurons, N , and number of connections, NE, as the model, where we ex- pect Lrandom ∼ ln(N )/ ln(2NE/N ) and Crandom ∼ 2NE/N 2. The dark blue line corresponds to the network property of the structural connectome; the dark red line corresponds to randomized network with number of nodes and edges equal to those of the structural connectome [43]. Error bars are gen- erated from the standard deviation across different 10 sub- groups of N neurons. FIG. 9: The heat capacity is plotted against temperature for models with different number of neurons, N . The maximum of the heat capacity approaches the operational temperature of the C. elegans neural system T0 = 1 from below as N increases. Error bars are the standard error across 10 random subgroups of N neurons. cannot identify the individual neurons, and so we cannot check if the effective connectivity in our model is similar to the anatomical connections. But we can ask statis- tical questions about the connections, and we focus on two global properties of the network: the clustering coef- ficient C, defined as the fraction of actual links compared to all possible links connecting the neighbors of a given neuron, averaged over all neurons; and the characteristic path length L, defined as the average shortest distance between any pair of neurons. As shown in Fig. 10, the topology of the inferred networks for all three worms that we investigated differ from random Erdos-R´enyi graphs with the same number of nodes (neurons) and links (non- zero interactions). Moreover, as we increase the num- ber of neurons that we consider, the clustering coefficient C and the characteristic path length L approaches that found in the structural connectome [43]. D. Local perturbation leads to global response How well can the sparsity of the inferred network ex- plain the observed globally-distributed pairwise correla- tion? In particular, we would like to examine the re- sponse of the network to local perturbations. This test is of particular interest, since its predictions can be exam- ined experimentally, as local perturbation of the neural network can be achieved through optogenetic clamping or ablation of individual neurons. The maximum entropy model can be perturbed through both "clamping" and "ablation." By definition, the only possible state in which we can clamp a single 10-1100101Temperature01020304050Heat capacityN = 10N = 20N = 30N = 40N = 50model(a)(b)randomstruct.struct. rand.clustering coefficientcharacteristic path lengthNN20406000.20.40.60.812040601.522.53As shown in Fig. 11, the response of the network to the local perturbation is distributed throughout the network for both clamping and ablation. However, clamping leads to much larger DKLs, suggesting that the network is more sensitive to clamping, and perhaps robust against (limited) ablation. Interestingly, this result echoes the experimental observation that C. elegans locomotion is easily disturbed through optogenetic manipulation of sin- gle neurons [44, 45], while ablation of single neurons has limited effect on the worms' ability to perform different patterns of locomotion [46 -- 48], although further experi- mental investigation is needed to test our hypotheses on network response. VI. DISCUSSION Soon it should be possible to record the activity of the entire nervous system of C. elegans as it engages in rea- sonably natural behaviors. As these experiments evolve, we would like to be in a position to ask question about collective phenomena in this small neural network, per- haps discovering aspects of these phenomena which are shared with larger systems, or even (one might hope) universal. We start modestly, guided by the state of the data. We have built maximum entropy models for groups of up to N = 50 cells, matching the mean activity and pairwise correlations in these subnetworks. Perhaps our most important result is that these models work, provid- ing successful quantitative predictions for many higher 10 order statistical structures in the network activity. This parallels what has been seen in systems where the neu- rons generate action potentials, but the C. elegans net- work operates in a very different regime. The success of pairwise models in this new context adds urgency to the question of when and why these models should work, and when we might expect them to fail. Beyond the fact that the models make successful quan- titative predictions, we find other similarities with analy- ses of vertebrate neural networks. The probability distri- butions that we infer have multiple peaks, corresponding to a rough energy landscape, and the parameters of these models appear close to a critical surface. In addition, we have shown that the inferred model is sparse, and has topological properties similar to that of the structural connectome. Nevertheless, global response is observed when the modeled network is perturbed locally, in a way similar to experimental observations. With the next generation of experiments, we hope to extend our analysis in four ways. First, longer recording will allow construction of meaningful models for larger groups of neurons. If coupled with higher signal -- to -- noise ratios, it should also be possible to make a more refined description of the continuous signals relevant to C. el- egans neurons, rather than having to compress our de- scription down to a small number of discrete states. Sec- ond, registration and identification of the observed neu- rons will make it possible to compare the anatomical con- nections between neurons with the pattern of interactions in our probabilistic models. Being able to identify neu- rons across multiple worms will also allow us to address the degree of reproducibility across individuals, and per- haps extend the effective size of data sets by averaging. Third, optogenetic tools will allow local perturbation of the neural network experimentally, which can be com- pared directly with the theoretical predictions in §V.D above. Finally, improvements in experimental methods will enable constructions of maximum entropy models for freely moving worms, with which we can map the relation between the collective behavior identified in the neuronal activity and the behavior of the animal. Acknowledgement FIG. 11: Local perturbation of the neural network leads to global response. (a, b) For a typical group of N = 50 neu- rons, the inferred interaction matrix J is sparse. Here, the neuron index i and j are sorted based on mflat , as in Fig. 4. (c, d) When neuron k is clamped to a constant voltage, the Kullback-Leibler divergence (in bits) of the marginal distri- bution of states for neuron i is distributed throughout the network. (e, f) When neuron k is ablated, the DKL is also distributed throughout the network, but is smaller than in response to clamping. i We thank F Beroz, AN Linder, L Meshulam, JP Nguyen, M Scholz, NS Wingreen, and B Xu for many helpful discussions. Work supported in part by the Na- tional Science Foundation through the Center for the Physics of Biological Function (PHY -- 1734030), the Cen- ter for the Science of Information (CCF -- 0939370), and PHY -- 1607612; and by the Simons Collaboration on the Global Brain. 012DKL, ablation10-2100102104-202Jij10-410-2100102probability density-0.500.5S051015012DKL10-2100102(a)(c)(e)-202Jij10-410-2100102probability density-0.500.5S051015012DKL10-2100102DKL, clampingDKL, ablationJijprobability density2040i1020304050j-101Jijji2040i1020304050j-1012040Marginal neuron ID, i1020304050Clamped neuron ID, k00.10.20.30.40.5ik2040Marginal neuron ID, i1020304050Clamped neuron ID, k00.10.20.30.40.5DKLclamping k2040Marginal neuron ID, i1020304050Ablated neuron ID, k00.020.040.060.080.1DKL(PPk)DKLk2040Marginal neuron ID, i1020304050Ablated neuron ID, k00.020.040.060.080.1DKL(PPk)iablatingkprobability densityprobability density(d)(b)(f)11 Now, let us assume that a set of true underlying param- eters, {g∗}, exists for the system we study, which leads to a true expectation value be f∗i = fi(g∗). However, we are only given finite number of observations, σ1, σ2, . . . , σT , from which we construct a maximum entropy model, i.e. infer the parameters {g} by maximizing the likelihood of the data. Our hope is that the difference between the true parameters and the inferred parameters is small, in which case we can approximate the inferred parameters using a linear approximation (cid:88) (21) where gi = g∗i + δgi, ∂gi δgi ≈ ∂fj (cid:101)χijδfj. (22) Here, (cid:101)χ is the inverse of the susceptibility matrix χij = δfj = − −∂fi/∂gj = (cid:104)φiφj(cid:105) − (cid:104)φi(cid:105)(cid:104)φj(cid:105); and δfj is the difference between empirical mean and the true mean of φj, j j δfj = 1 T φj(σt) − f∗j (23) For convenience, we will use short-hand notation φi(σt) = φt i to indicate the value of the observable φi at time t. Let the number of samples in the training data be T1, and the number of samples in the test data be T2. For simplicity, assume that all samples are independent. We maximize the entropy of the model on only the training data to obtain parameters {g}, and we would like to know how well our model generalize to the test data. Thus, we quantify the degree of overfitting by the difference of likelihood of the training data and the test data: (cid:88) T(cid:88) t=1 Author Contributions XC and WB performed the analyses and the simula- tions. FR and AML designed and carried out the ex- periments. All authors contributed to the manuscript preparation. Appendix A: Perturbation methods for overfitting analysis To test if our maximum entropy model overfits, we partition the samples into a set of training data and a set of test data. The difference of the per-neuron log- likelihood for the training data and the test data is used as a metric of whether the model overfits: if the two val- ues for the log-likelihood are equal within error bars, then the model generalizes well to the test data and does not overfit. Here, we outline a perturbation analysis which uses the number of independent samples and the number of parameters of the model to estimate the expectation value of this log-likelihood difference. Consider a Boltzmann distribution parameterized by g = g1, g2, . . . , gm acting on observables φ1, φ2, . . . , φm. The probability for the N spins taking the value σ = σ1, σ2, . . . , σN is (cid:33) (cid:32) m(cid:88) i=1 P (σg) = 1 Z(g) exp − giφi(σ) , (19) where Z is the partition function. Then, the log- likelihood of a set of data with T samples under the Boltzmann distribution parameterized by g is L(σ1, σ2, . . . , σTg) = 1 T T(cid:88) t=1 = − log Z(g) − gi i=1 log P (σtg) m(cid:88) (cid:32) (cid:34) m(cid:88) i=1 − log Z(g) − g∗i − (cid:88) j (cid:33) φt i t=1 1 T T(cid:88) m(cid:88) (cid:101)χij (cid:32) i=1 gi (cid:32) 1 T1 Ltest − Ltrain = = (cid:34) (cid:33)(cid:35) (cid:33)(cid:32) − (20) T2(cid:88) T1(cid:88) t(cid:48)=1 1 T2 (cid:48) φt i j − f∗j φt t=1 (cid:32) m(cid:88) T2(cid:88) i=1 gi T1(cid:88) (cid:33) t=1 . 1 T1 (cid:48) φt i t(cid:48)=1 − log Z(g) − T1(cid:88) t=1 1 T1 φt i − 1 T2 (cid:33)(cid:35) φt i (24) For simplicity of notation, let us write α(1) i = 1 T1 i − f∗i , φt α(2) i = 1 T2 T1(cid:88) t=1 T2(cid:88) t=1 ference [Eq. (24)], have expectation values i − f∗i .(25) φt (cid:104)α(1) i (cid:105) = 0 , i α(1) (cid:104)α((1) j (cid:105) = 1 T1 χij . (26) By the Central Limit Theorem, α(1) are Gaus- sian variables. Terms that appear in the likelihood dif- and α(2) i i In addition, because we assume that the training data and the test data are independent, the cross-covariance between the training data and the test data is Appendix B: Maximum entropy model with the pairwise correlation tensor constraint 12 (cid:104)Ltest − Ltrain(cid:105) = i α(2) (cid:104)α((1) j (cid:105) = 0 . (27) Combining all the above expressions, we obtain the expectation value of the likelihood difference [Eq. (24)], (cid:17)(cid:69) α(1) i − α(2) i (cid:16) (cid:101)χijα(1) j i=1 g∗i − (cid:68) m(cid:88) (cid:88) m(cid:88) m(cid:88) (cid:101)χij(cid:104)α(1) m(cid:88) m(cid:88) (cid:101)χijχij j=1 i=1 j i α(1) j (cid:105) = − = − = − 1 T1 m T1 i=1 j=1 (28) Note that the difference of likelihood is only related to the number of parameters in our model and the number of independent samples in the training data. Similarly, we can evaluate the variance of the likelihood difference to be (cid:104)(Ltest − Ltrain)2(cid:105) = (cid:18) 1 (cid:19) g∗i g∗kχik + 1 T2 T1 (m2 + 2m) + m T1T2 (29) (cid:88) i,k + 1 T 2 1 using Wick's theorem for multivariate Gaussian variables and chain rules of partial derivatives. In order to test whether perturbation theory can be applied to the maximum entropy model learned from the real data, we estimate the number of independent sam- ples using Nind. sample ∼ T /τ , where T is the length of the experiment and τ is the correlation time. The cor- relation time is extracted as the decay exponent of the overlap function, defined to be (cid:68) 1 N(cid:88) N i=1 (cid:69) t q(∆t) = δσi(t)σi(t+∆t) , (30) In our experiment, the correlation time is τ = 4 ∼ 6s. For a typical recording of 8 minutes, the number of inde- pendent samples is between 80 and 120. In Figure 5, we compute the perturbation results using the number of non-zero parameters after the training and the number of independent samples estimated from the data. The prediction is within the error bar from the data, which suggests that the inferred coupling is within the perturbation regime of the true underlying coupling. Note that the plotted difference is computed for the per- neuron log-likelihood, ltest − ltrain = (Ltest − Ltrain)/N . To fully describe the pairwise correlation between neu- rons with p = 3 states, the equal-state pairwise correla- tion cij = (cid:104)δσiσj(cid:105) is not enough; rather, we should con- strain the pairwise correlation tensor, defined as crs ij ≡ (cid:104)δσirδσj s(cid:105) . (31) s crs ij = mr related through normalization requirements,(cid:80) and (cid:80) Here, we constrain the pairwise correlation tensor crs ij to- gether with the local magnetization mr i ≡ (cid:104)δσir(cid:105). No- tice that for each pair of neurons (i, j), the number of constraints are p2 + 2p = 15, but these constraints are i = 1 i , which leads to only 7 independent variables for each pair of neurons. Because of this non- independence, choosing which variables to constraint is a problem of gauge fixing. Here, we choose the gauge where we constrain the local magnetization mr i for states ij ≡ crr "rise" and "fall", and the pairwise correlations cr ij ; in this gauge the parameters can be compared meaning- fully to the equal-state maximum entropy model above. The corresponding maximum entropy model has the form r mr − 1 2 (cid:88) 3(cid:88) r=1 i(cid:54)=j  (cid:88) 2(cid:88) i r=1 P (σ) ∝ exp J r ijδσirδσj r − hr i δσir (32) Note that the equivalence between constraining the equal-state correlation for each state and constraining the full pairwise correlation tensor only holds for the case of p = 3. For p > 3 states, one need to choose more con- straints to fix the gauge, and it is not obvious which variables to fix. We train the maximum entropy model with tensor con- straint [Eq. (32)] with the same procedure as the model with equal-state correlation constraint, described in the main text. The model is able to reproduce the con- straints with a sparse interaction tensor J. However, as shown in the bottom panel of Fig. 5, the difference between ltrain, the per-neuron log likelihood of the train- ing data (randomly chosen 5/6 of all data) and ltest, the per-neuron log likelihood of the test data, is greater than zero within error bars. This indicates that the maxi- mum entropy model with tensor constraint overfits for all N = 10, 20, . . . , 50. Appendix C: Maximum entropy model fails to predict the dynamics of the neural networks as expected By construction, the maximum entropy model is a static probability model of the observed neuronal activ- ities. No constraint on the dynamics was imposed in building the model, and infinitely many dynamical mod- els can generate the observed static distribution. The simplest possibility corresponds to the dynamics being 13 like the dynamics of Monte Carlo itself, which is essen- tially Brownian motion on the energy landscape. To test whether this equilibrium dynamics can capture the real neural dynamics of C. elegans, we compare the mean oc- cupancy time of each basin, (cid:104)τα(cid:105), calculated using the ex- perimental data and using MCMC. The mean occupancy time is defined as the average time a trajectory spends in a basin before escaping to another basin. For equilibrium dynamics, the mean occupancy time is determined by the height of energy barriers according to the transition state theory, or by considering random walks on the energy landscape, which gives the relation τ ∼ −p2/2e ln(Pα), where p = 3 is the number of Potts states and Pα is the fraction of time the system visits basin α. As shown in Figure 12, the mean occupancy time (cid:104)τ MC α (cid:105) found in the Monte Carlo simulation can be predicted by this simple approximation. In contrast, the empirical neural dynam- ics deviates from the equilibrium dynamics, as we might have expected. The dependence between (cid:104)τ data (cid:105) and α 0.5±0.027 P data . is weak; a linear fit gives (cid:104)τ data α α (cid:105) ≈ P data α FIG. 12: Equilibrium dynamics of the inferred pairwise max- imum entropy model fails to capture the neural dynamics of C. elegans. The mean occupancy time of each basin of the energy landscape, (cid:104)τα(cid:105), is plotted against the fraction of time the system visits the basin, Pα. For 10 subgroups of N = 10 (in dots) and N = 20 (in asterisks) neurons, the empirical dynamics exhibits a weak power-law relation between (cid:104)τα(cid:105) and Pα. The striped patterns are artifacts due to finite sam- ple size. In contrast, equilibrium dynamics extracted from a Monte Carlo simulation following detailed balance shows an inverse logarithmic relation between (cid:104)τα(cid:105) and Pα, which can be explained by random walks on the energy landscape. Error bars of the data are extracted from random halves of the data. Error bars of the Monte Carlo simulation are calculated using correlation time and standard deviation of the observables. [1] J. J. Hopfield, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 79, 2554 Sci. USA 106, 14058 (2009). (1982). [13] G. Tkacik, E. Schneidman, I. Berry, J. Michael, and [2] J. J. Hopfield, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 81, 3088 W. Bialek, arXiv preprint arXiv:0912.5409 (2009). (1984). [3] D. J. Amit, H. Gutfreund, and H. Sompolinsky, Phys. Rev. A 32, 1007 (1985). [14] G. Tkaik, O. Marre, D. Amodei, E. Schneidman, W. Bialek, and M. J. Berry, II, PLoS Comp. Biol. 10, 1 (2014). [4] D. A. Dombeck, C. D. Harvey, L. Tian, L. L. Looger, and [15] R. Monasson and S. Rosay, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 098101 D. W. Tank, Nat. Neurosci. 13, 1433 (2010). (2015). [5] M. B. Ahrens, M. B. Orger, D. N. Robson, J. M. Li, and [16] L. Posani, S. Cocco, K. Jezek, and R. Monasson, J. P. J. Keller, Nat. Methods 10, 413 (2013). Comp. Neurosci. 43, 17 (2017). [6] R. Segev, J. Goodhouse, J. Puchalla, and M. J. Berry II, [17] L. Meshulam, J. L. Gauthier, C. D. Brody, D. W. Tank, Nat. Neurosci. 7, 1155 (2004). [7] J. P. Nguyen, F. B. Shipley, A. N. Linder, G. S. Plummer, M. Liu, S. U. Setru, J. W. Shaevitz, and A. M. Leifer, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 113, E1074 (2016). [8] J. P. Nguyen, A. N. Linder, G. S. Plummer, J. W. Shae- vitz, and A. M. Leifer, PLoS Comp. Biol. 13, e1005517 (2017). [9] V. Venkatachalam, N. Ji, X. Wang, C. Clark, J. K. Mitchell, M. Klein, C. J. Tabone, J. Florman, H. Ji, J. Greenwood, et al., Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 113, E1082 (2016). [10] E. T. Jaynes, Phys. Rev. 106, 620 (1957). [11] E. Schneidman, M. J. Berry II, R. Segev, and W. Bialek, Nature 440, 1007 EP (2006). [12] S. Cocco, S. Leibler, and R. Monasson, Proc. Natl. Acad. and W. Bialek, Neuron 96, 1178 (2017). [18] A. Tang, D. Jackson, J. Hobbs, W. Chen, J. L. Smith, H. Patel, A. Prieto, D. Petrusca, M. I. Grivich, A. Sher, et al., J. Neurosci. 28, 505 (2008). [19] I. E. Ohiorhenuan, F. Mechler, K. P. Purpura, A. M. Schmid, Q. Hu, and J. D. Victor, Nature 466, 617 (2010). [20] U. Koster, J. Sohl-Dickstein, C. M. Gray, and B. A. Ol- shausen, PLoS Comp. Biol. 10, e1003684 (2014). [21] T. Mora and W. Bialek, J. Stat. Phys. 144, 268 (2011). [22] M. A. Munoz, Rev. Mod. Phys. 90, 031001 (2018). [23] L. Meshulam, J. L. Gauthier, C. D. Brody, D. W. Tank, and W. Bialek, arXiv preprint arXiv:1809.08461 [q-bio.NC] (2018). [24] F. Rieke, D. Warland, R. de Ruyter van Steveninck, and W. Bialek, Spikes: Exploring the Neural Code (MIT 10-410-310-210-1100P10-1100101102 (sec)datamodelh⌧data↵i/P0.5±0.027↵<latexit sha1_base64="i6SKBv5WghJZpVb2NiJZSL/H21w=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="i6SKBv5WghJZpVb2NiJZSL/H21w=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="i6SKBv5WghJZpVb2NiJZSL/H21w=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="i6SKBv5WghJZpVb2NiJZSL/H21w=">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</latexit>h⌧RW↵i=92e1logP↵<latexit sha1_base64="4SJrWOe/r0wKavyxMei7GxFDvlc=">AAACM3icbVDPSxtBGJ211mpsNa1HL4NB6KVhVwq1B0HwIj2l0hghk4ZvJ98mg7Ozy8y30rDs/+TFf8SDUDy0FK/+D06SPdQfDwYe732Pb74X51o5CsPfwdKr5dcrb1bXGutv321sNt9/OHVZYSV2ZaYzexaDQ60MdkmRxrPcIqSxxl58fjTzexdoncrMD5rmOEhhbFSiJJCXhs1vQoMZaxQExVCAzifwUxD+ovKkVwk79/gB/yQSC7L8WpV7WC14VJVCZ2PeqWPVsNkK2+Ec/DmJatJiNTrD5rUYZbJI0ZDU4Fw/CnMalGBJSY1VQxQOc5DnMMa+pwZSdINyfnPFd70y4klm/TPE5+r/iRJS56Zp7CdToIl76s3El7x+Qcn+oFQmLwiNXCxKCs0p47MC+UhZlKSnnoC0yv+Vywn4RsjX3PAlRE9Pfk5O99pR2I6+f24dhnUdq2yb7bCPLGJf2CE7Zh3WZZJdshv2h/0NroLb4F9wtxhdCurMFnuE4P4BgC+r8g==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="4SJrWOe/r0wKavyxMei7GxFDvlc=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="4SJrWOe/r0wKavyxMei7GxFDvlc=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="4SJrWOe/r0wKavyxMei7GxFDvlc=">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</latexit>(sec)h⌧data↵i<latexit sha1_base64="XOb/o3matVuyZZFJ2VbX83Rdrqw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="XOb/o3matVuyZZFJ2VbX83Rdrqw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="XOb/o3matVuyZZFJ2VbX83Rdrqw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="XOb/o3matVuyZZFJ2VbX83Rdrqw=">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</latexit>(MC sweep)h⌧MC↵i<latexit sha1_base64="ytC6xhkR+dl6rAIVagyF1ctAOPw=">AAACDnicdVDBSiNBEO1Rd3WjuxvXo5fGIHgaZmLcxJuQixchglEhE0NNp5I09vQM3TViGPIFXvZXvHhQlr169rZ/YydGcBd9UPB4r4qqenGmpKUg+OstLC59+ry88qW0uvb12/fy+o9Tm+ZGYFukKjXnMVhUUmObJCk8zwxCEis8iy+bU//sCo2VqT6hcYbdBIZaDqQAclKvvB0p0EOFPCLIexGobAQXEeE1FUfNCY/MzO2VK4G/X937uVfjgV+rh7uNXUeqYb1RDXnoBzNU2BytXvkp6qciT1CTUGBtJwwy6hZgSAqFk1KUW8xAXMIQO45qSNB2i9k7E77tlD4fpMaVJj5T304UkFg7TmLXmQCN7P/eVHzP6+Q0aHQLqbOcUIuXRYNccUr5NBvelwYFqbEjIIx0t3IxAgOCXIIlF8Lrp/xjclr1w8APj2uVg2AexwrbZFtsh4Wszg7YIWuxNhPsht2ye/bg/fLuvN/en5fWBW8+s8H+gff4DAKjnKs=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ytC6xhkR+dl6rAIVagyF1ctAOPw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ytC6xhkR+dl6rAIVagyF1ctAOPw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="hP+6LrUf2d3tZaldqaQQvEKMXyw=">AAAB2XicbZDNSgMxFIXv1L86Vq1rN8EiuCozbnQpuHFZwbZCO5RM5k4bmskMyR2hDH0BF25EfC93vo3pz0JbDwQ+zknIvSculLQUBN9ebWd3b/+gfugfNfzjk9Nmo2fz0gjsilzl5jnmFpXU2CVJCp8LgzyLFfbj6f0i77+gsTLXTzQrMMr4WMtUCk7O6oyaraAdLMW2IVxDC9YaNb+GSS7KDDUJxa0dhEFBUcUNSaFw7g9LiwUXUz7GgUPNM7RRtRxzzi6dk7A0N+5oYkv394uKZ9bOstjdzDhN7Ga2MP/LBiWlt1EldVESarH6KC0Vo5wtdmaJNChIzRxwYaSblYkJN1yQa8Z3HYSbG29D77odBu3wMYA6nMMFXEEIN3AHD9CBLghI4BXevYn35n2suqp569LO4I+8zx84xIo4</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="2O57DSZK9mfx3RPtw5h2brH+nsQ=">AAACA3icbZC9SgNBFIXv+m/8i7Y2gyJYhV0bLQUbG0HBmEA2hruTm2RwdnaZuSuGJU9g46vYWCjiO9j5Nk5iCv8ODBzOmeHO/ZJcK8dh+BHMzM7NLywuLVdWVtfWN6qbq1cuK6ykusx0ZpsJOtLKUJ0Va2rmljBNNDWSm5Nx37gl61RmLnmYUzvFvlE9JZF91KnuxRpNX5OIGYtOjDof4HXMdMfl2clIxHbSdqq7YS2cSPw10dTswlTnnep73M1kkZJhqdG5VhTm3C7RspKaRpW4cJSjvME+tbw1mJJrl5N1RmLPJ13Ry6w/hsUk/f6ixNS5YZr4mynywP3uxuF/Xavg3lG7VCYvmIz8GtQrtOBMjNmIrrIkWQ+9QWmV/6uQA7Qo2ROseAjR75X/mquDWhTWoosQlmAbdmAfIjiEYziFc6iDhHt4hGd4CR6Cp+D1C9dMMOW2BT8UvH0C3uea9g==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PQSt19o7XeD8eef3KCoKuz3z6nI=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="w5CfhoMF57sszR/7ktr2I43mCzs=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ytC6xhkR+dl6rAIVagyF1ctAOPw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ytC6xhkR+dl6rAIVagyF1ctAOPw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ytC6xhkR+dl6rAIVagyF1ctAOPw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ytC6xhkR+dl6rAIVagyF1ctAOPw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ytC6xhkR+dl6rAIVagyF1ctAOPw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ytC6xhkR+dl6rAIVagyF1ctAOPw=">AAACDnicdVDBSiNBEO1Rd3WjuxvXo5fGIHgaZmLcxJuQixchglEhE0NNp5I09vQM3TViGPIFXvZXvHhQlr169rZ/YydGcBd9UPB4r4qqenGmpKUg+OstLC59+ry88qW0uvb12/fy+o9Tm+ZGYFukKjXnMVhUUmObJCk8zwxCEis8iy+bU//sCo2VqT6hcYbdBIZaDqQAclKvvB0p0EOFPCLIexGobAQXEeE1FUfNCY/MzO2VK4G/X937uVfjgV+rh7uNXUeqYb1RDXnoBzNU2BytXvkp6qciT1CTUGBtJwwy6hZgSAqFk1KUW8xAXMIQO45qSNB2i9k7E77tlD4fpMaVJj5T304UkFg7TmLXmQCN7P/eVHzP6+Q0aHQLqbOcUIuXRYNccUr5NBvelwYFqbEjIIx0t3IxAgOCXIIlF8Lrp/xjclr1w8APj2uVg2AexwrbZFtsh4Wszg7YIWuxNhPsht2ye/bg/fLuvN/en5fWBW8+s8H+gff4DAKjnKs=</latexit>Probability of visiting basin α, PαMean occupancy time14 Press, 1997). [25] M. B. Goodman, D. H. Hall, L. Avery, and S. R. Lockery, Neuron 20, 763 (1998). [26] G. J. Stephens, M. Bueno de Mesquita, W. S. Ryu, and W. Bialek, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 108, 7286 (2011). [27] P. Sengupta and A. D. Samuel, Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 19, 637 (2009). [28] E. L. Ardiel and C. H. Rankin, Learn. Mem. 17, 191 (2010). Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 107, 5405 (2010). [38] W. Bialek, A. Cavagna, I. Giardina, T. Mora, E. Silvestri, M. Viale, and A. M. Walczak, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 109, 4786 (2012). [39] M. Dud´ık, S. J. Phillips, and R. E. Schapire, in Pro- ceedings of the 17th annual Conference on Learning The- ory,(COLT 2004), Banff, Canada (Springer, 2004), vol. 3120, pp. 472 -- 486. [40] T. Broderick, M. Dudik, G. Tkacik, R. E. Schapire, and [29] A. L. Nichols, T. Eichler, R. Latham, and M. Zimmer, W. Bialek, arXiv preprint arXiv:0712.2437 (2007). Science 356, eaam6851 (2017). [30] T. Bullock and G. A. Horridge, Structure and function in the nervous systems of invertebrates. (San Francisco, 1965). [31] J. G. White, E. Southgate, J. N. Thomson, and S. Bren- ner, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B Biol. Sci. 314, 1 (1986). [32] T.-W. Chen, T. J. Wardill, Y. Sun, S. R. Pulver, S. L. Renninger, A. Baohan, E. R. Schreiter, R. A. Kerr, M. B. Orger, V. Jayaraman, et al., Nature 499, 295 (2013). [41] M. Schmidt, UGM: A Matlab toolbox for probabilis- tic undirected graphical models, http://www.cs.ubc.ca/ ~schmidtm/Software/UGM.html (2007). [42] O. M. Becker and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys. 106, 1495 (1997). [43] D. J. Watts and S. H. Strogatz, Nature 393, 440 (1998). [44] A. Gordus, N. Pokala, S. Levy, S. W. Flavell, and C. I. Bargmann, Cell 161, 215 (2015). [45] M. Liu, A. K. Sharma, J. Shaevitz, and A. M. Leifer, eLife 7, e36419 (2018). [33] E. Kim, L. Sun, C. V. Gabel, and C. Fang-Yen, PLoS [46] J. M. Gray, J. J. Hill, and C. I. Bargmann, Proc. Nat. One 8, e53419 (2013). Acad. Sci. USA 102, 3184 (2005). [34] N. Slonim, G. S. Atwal, G. Tkacik, and W. Bialek, arXiv [47] B. J. Piggott, J. Liu, Z. Feng, S. A. Wescott, and X. S. preprint cs/0502017 (2005). Xu, Cell 147, 922 (2011). [35] R. Chartrand, ISRN Appl. Math. 2011 (2011). [36] M. Weigt, R. A. White, H. Szurmant, J. A. Hoch, and T. Hwa, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 106, 67 (2009). [37] T. Mora, A. M. Walczak, W. Bialek, and C. G. Callan, [48] G. Yan, P. E. V´ertes, E. K. Towlson, Y. L. Chew, D. S. Walker, W. R. Schafer, and A.-L. Barab´asi, Nature 550, 519 (2017).
1103.2974	1	1103	2011-03-15T17:49:45	Near-Infrared Fluorescence Enhanced (NIR-FE) Molecular Imaging of Live Cells on Gold Substrates	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	Low quantum yields of near infrared (NIR) fluorophores have limited their capabilities as imaging probes in a transparent, low background imaging window. Here for the first time we reported near-infrared fluorescence enhance (NIR-FE) cell imaging using nanostructured Au substrate, which was employed as a general platform for both single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs) and organic fluorescent labels in the NIR region. Fluorescence intensity, as well as cell targeting specificity, was greatly improved by this novel imaging technique. With NIR-FE imaging, we were able to image SWNT-stained cells at short exposure time of 300ms, and push the detectable limit of SWNT staining of cells down to an ultralow concentration of ~50 pM. Further, different degrees of fluorescence enhancement for endocytosed, intracellular SWNTs vs. nanotubes on the cell membrane at the cell/gold interface were observed, suggesting the possibility of using this technique to track the transmembrane behavior of NIR fluorophores.	physics.bio-ph	physics	1 Near-Infrared Fluorescence Enhanced (NIR-FE) Molecular Imaging of Live Cells on Gold Substrates** Guosong Hong, Scott M. Tabakman, Kevin Welsher, Zhuo Chen, Joshua T. Robinson, Hailiang Wang, Bo Zhang and Hongjie Dai Prof. H. Dai, G. Hong, S. M. Tabakman, J. T. Robinson, H. Wang, B. Zhang Department of Chemistry, Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305 E-mail: [email protected] Dr. K. Welsher Department of Chemistry, Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey, 08544 Dr. Z. Chen State Key Laboratory of Chemo/Biosensing and Chemometrics, College of Biology, Hunan University, Changsha, Hunan, 410082 (China) Biological imaging in the near infrared (NIR) window enjoys advantages of deep photon penetration due to relatively high transparency, reduced scattering and low autofluorescence of biological tissues in the 0.8-1.4 μm range.[1-5] Organic dyes[6-9], quantum dots[10-12] and single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs)[4] have been employed for in vitro and in vivo biological imaging in the NIR region. SWNTs are a group of one-dimensional (1-D) macromolecular fluorophores, with intrinsic bandgap fluorescence emission between 0.9-1.4 μm upon excitation in the visible or NIR.[4, 13-14] The large Stokes shift makes SWNTs ideal probes for biological imaging with high contrast and low background.[3] Thus far, SWNTs have been used as in vitro fluorescence tags for cell imaging,[15-16] ex vivo imaging of tissues and organs,[17-18] and in vivo imaging of normal organs as well as tumors.[19-20] A common caveat of NIR fluorophores is the relatively low quantum yields compared to their counterparts (including organic dyes and quantum dots) with shorter emission wavelengths in the visible, which limits their imaging capabilities. For example, the IR800 dye (with a peak emission wavelength of 800 nm) exhibits a ~10% quantum yield,[21] and the indocyanine green (ICG) dye exhibits only ~4.3% quantum yield at the emission wavelength of 805 nm.[22] In contrast, molecules fluorescing at shorter wavelengths typically exhibit much higher quantum yields (IR700 ~24% at 700 nm emission[21]; cyanine-5 ~30% at 660 nm emission[23]; fluorescein ~91% at 521 nm emission[24]). SWNTs exhibit quantum yield ranging 2 from 0.1% to 3%,[13, 25-26] due to intrinsic low-energy excitons that are optically forbidden,[27] and extrinsic quenchers such as metallic SWNTs in bundles[25] and oxygen in acidic environment[28-29]. To fully utilize the spectral advantages of NIR fluorophores, it is desirable to develop a general approach to enhancing the photoluminescence (PL) in the NIR, thus enhancing the biological imaging capability in this important spectral region. Recently, we reported metal-enhanced fluorescence (MEF) by up to 14-fold for surfactant-coated SWNTs placed on top of nanostructured gold films synthesized purely in the solution phase (called ‘Au/Au films’).[30] Here, we demonstrated this Au/Au substrate as a powerful and general platform for NIR fluorescence enhanced (NIR-FE) cellular imaging using both SWNT and organic fluorescent labels. We used SWNTs functionalized by arginine–glycine–aspartic acid (RGD) to selectively tag U87-MG brain cancer cells over MCF-7 breast cancer cells, plated the cells on the Au/Au substrate, and observed a ~9-fold increase in SWNT fluorescence on U87-MG cells. This enabled high quality NIR molecular imaging of molecularly targeted cells using much shorter exposure times (~300 ms) than previously possible with nanotube fluorophores. With NIR-FE imaging, we were able to push the detectable limit of SWNT staining of cells down to an ultralow concentration of ~50 pM. Further, we observed different degrees of fluorescence enhancement for endocytosed, intracellular SWNTs vs. nanotubes on the cell membrane at the cell/gold interface, suggesting the possibility of observing transmembrane endocytosis of live cells based on the degree of fluorescence enhancement. Also important is that our NIR-FE imaging of biological system is general for commonly used low quantum yield organic dyes including IR800. To our knowledge, this is the first fluorescence enhanced imaging of cells on Au nanostructures in the NIR. Previously, Ag substrates were used for fluorescence enhanced biological imaging in the visible with organic dyes.[31-33] Cell-type selective staining and subsequent imaging of cells were carried out with RGD and IR800 conjugated SWNTs, water-solubilized by 25% DSPE-PEG(5k)-NH2 (1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-N-[amino(polyethyleneglycol) 3 5,000]) and 75% C18-PMH-mPEG(90k) (poly(maleic anhydride-alt-1-octadecene) -methoxy(polyethyleneglycol)90,000). The RGD peptide ligand was linked to the amine groups on SWNTs for selectively binding to αvβ3-integrin positive U87-MG cells[34] over the αvβ3-integrin negative MCF-7 cells. Meanwhile, we also covalently attached IR800 dye molecules onto SWNTs to afford SWNT-IR800-RGD conjugates (Figure 1a). Upon excitation at 658 nm, the SWNT-IR800-RGD conjugate emitted in the range of 1000-1400 nm, due to the intrinsic bandgap photoluminescence of SWNTs (Figure 1e and 1f). Upon excitation at 785 nm, the conjugate emitted fluorescence in the 800-1000 nm range due to the attached IR800 molecules (emission tail also seen in Figure 1e and 1f). This unique SWNT-IR800 conjugate allowed for tagging of cells using two NIR fluorophores in two different imaging windows in the 800-1400nm range. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) imaging (Figure 1b) showed the SWNT conjugates with lengths ranging from 100 nm to 3 μm and an average length of ~1.0 μm. We synthesized Au/Au films on quartz (Figure 1c) via solution phase growth, with optimal optical extinction in the NIR (Figure 1d) for the highest fluorescence enhancement of both SWNTs and IR800 placed on top of the gold film.[30, 35] For SWNT-IR800-RGD conjugates drop-dried from a solution onto both bare quartz and Au/Au film on quartz, photoluminescence versus excitation (PLE) spectra revealed fluorescence enhancement of both IR800 (only emission tail showing up at the upper left corner of Figure 1e and 1f in the spectral range) and SWNTs (all other peaks in the 1.0-1.4 μm emission window of Figure 1e and 1f) on the Au/Au film. The average enhancement of SWNT photoluminescence was ~10 times, and the enhancement was ~5 times for the IR800 dye attached to SWNTs. This result clearly showed the excellent capability of fluorescence enhancement by the Au/Au film for fluorophores emitting in the 0.8-1.4 μm NIR window including IR800 and SWNTs. 4 a) RGD RGD Emission: 1000-1400 nm 1000-1400nm Emission: 800-1000 nm b) (a) IR800 IR800 c) ] m n [ n o i t a t i c x E e) 5mm d) D O / n o i t c n i t x E 4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 400 IR800 800 1200 Wavelength/nm 1600 f) Emission [nm] Figure 1. a) A schematic drawing of the SWNT-IR800-RGD conjugate, with the emission ranges of SWNTs and IR800 dye labeled. b) An AFM image of SWNT-IR800-RGD conjugates deposited on a SiO2 substrate. c) A digital photograph of a typical Au/Au substrate used for NIR-FE imaging of cells plated on this substrate. Inset showed an SEM image of the film. d) A UV-Vis-NIR extinction spectrum of the Au/Au film. e) A PLE spectrum of SWNT-IR800-RGD conjugates deposited on quartz. f) A PLE spectrum of SWNT-IR800-RGD conjugates deposited on top of an Au/Au film. For targeted cell staining and imaging, U87-MG cells and MCF-7 cells were trypsinized and mixed with SWNT-IR800-RGD conjugates at a concentration of ~30 nM of SWNTs at 4 ºC for 1h to prevent endocytosis during staining. The cells were split into two groups and placed onto a quartz microscope slide and Au/Au film respectively for immediate fluorescence imaging using an InGaAs camera. The 5 αvβ3-integrin positive U87-MG cells treated with the SWNT-IR800-RGD conjugate showed ~9-fold higher SWNT fluorescence signal (green) on Au/Au (Figure 2a) than on quartz (Figure 2b), excited at 658 nm under a short exposure time of ~300 ms. Much to obtain high quality times (1~3s) were needed longer exposure SWNT-stained cell images on quartz, similar to previous biological imaging with SWNT fluorophores[19, 36]. The αvβ3-integrin negative MCF-7 cells on both Au/Au (Figure 2c) and quartz (Figure 2d) showed little SWNT fluorescence signal. The selectivity of RGD-SWNT labeling of cells, defined as the ratio of SWNT emission intensity of αvβ3-integrin positive U87-MG cells compared to that of αvβ3-integrin negative MCF-7 cells, was as high as ~17 for cells on Au/Au substrate (Figure 2g, higher than the positive/negative ratio of ~7 on quartz), suggesting highly selective staining and molecular imaging of cells with NIR-FE on the gold films. Note that the cells appeared round-shaped since they were imaged immediately after being placed on the substrates prior to adhesion. To show that these imaged cells were alive during and after imaging, we monitored the U87-MG cells in cell medium after increasing the temperature to 37 ºC in a temperature controlled imaging chamber with a 1 L/min CO2 gas flow over a period of 6 hours after the first imaging. Both fluorescence image and optical image showed cells adhesion to the Au/Au surface at 37 ºC, suggesting live cells. We also trypsinized and mixed cells with SWNT-IR800-RGD conjugates at 37 ºC (instead of 4 ºC as above) for 1h, a condition known to afford endocytosis of carbon nanotubes inside cells.[37-39] Single particle tracking of SWNTs in live cells has been studied by Strano and coworkers to reveal the mechanism of endocytosis at 37 ºC.[40-41] The U87-MG and MCF-7 cells thus treated were plated onto Au/Au and quartz for NIR imaging. In contrast to the ~9-fold enhancement observed for cells stained at 4 ºC, nanotube fluorescence in the αvβ3-integrin positive U87-MG cells treated at 37 ºC was enhanced by only ~2-fold on Au/Au film (Figure 2h) compared to on quartz substrate (Figure 2i). Also noticeable was the higher false-positive signal intensity in the αvβ3-integrin negative MCF-7 cells (Figure 2j, 2k), due to the expected increase of non-specific uptake of SWNTs by cells at 37 ºC than at 4 ºC. on Au/Au a) 30µm on quartz b) 4x c) d) 6 4ºC f) Au/Au film quartz e) g) on Au/Au h) 30µm i) on quartz l) 37ºC m) j) k) Au/Au film quartz n) ) + ( G M - 7 8 U ) - ( 7 - F C M ) + ( G M - 7 8 U ) - ( 7 - F C M Figure 2. NIR fluorescence images of a) SWNT-IR800-RGD stained U87-MG cells at 4ºC on Au/Au film, b) on quartz, and similarly treated MCF-7 cells c) on Au/Au and d) on quartz. The schematic drawings showed e) SWNTs sandwiched between cell membrane and gold were enhanced, compared to f) SWNT stained cell on quartz. g) A bar chart showing average cell fluorescence in each case of 2a)-d). NIR fluorescence images of h) SWNT-IR800-RGD stained U87-MG cells at 37ºC on Au/Au film, i) on quartz, and similarly treated MCF-7 cells j) on Au/Au and k) on quartz. The schematic drawings showed l) SWNTs endocytosed by the cell were hardly enhanced by gold, compared to m) SWNT stained cell on quartz due to increased distance between the fluorophores and the enhancing gold substrate. n) A bar chart showing average cell fluorescence in each case of 2h)-k). All false-colored 7 fluorescence images were taken under a 658 nm excitation with photons collected in the 1100-1700 nm region. We attributed the fluorescence enhancement of the molecularly selective SWNT labels on U87-MG cells to coupling between the emissions of SWNT tags and surface plasmon modes in the Au/Au substrates. Resonance coupling between SWNT emission and re-radiating plasmonic modes in the Au/Au films shortened the radiative lifetimes of SWNTs, affording higher fluorescence quantum efficiency.[30, 42-43] It was found that surfactant-coated SWNTs closer to the Au/Au surface exhibited higher fluorescence enhancement, decaying when SWNTs were placed away from the surface with a half-decay distance of ~5 nm,[30] on the same order of cell membrane thickness.[44] At 4 ºC, most of the SWNTs were blocked from endocytotic uptake by the U87-MG cells, and SWNTs on the cell membrane interfacing with the Au/Au substrate were strongly coupled to the surface plasmonic modes in the gold film and thus responsible for the large, ~9-fold enhancement in fluorescence compared to on quartz (Figure 2e, 2f). On the other hand, when incubated at 37 ºC, SWNTs were endocytosed into the cytoplasms of the cells and hence spatially separated from the gold surface, giving a reduced fluorescence enhancement of ~2-fold (Figure 2l, 2m). Also interesting was that we monitored the U87-MG cells stained by SWNTs at 4°C in cell medium after increasing the temperature to 37 ºC in a 1 L/min CO2 gas flow. We observed a ~ 6-fold decrease of SWNT fluorescence intensity in the U87-MG cells over time, from the fluorescence intensity taken right after 4 ºC staining. This decrease was due to transmembrane endocytosis of SWNTs at 37 ºC, which reduced the NIR-FE effect as nanotubes were further away from the Au/Au surface. This also confirmed that the cells were fully alive and functioning. The SWNT-Au distance dependent fluorescence enhancement could also explain the measured increase in cellular targeting selectivity with cells on Au/Au vs. quartz substrate (Figure 2g). For integrin negative MCF-7 cells, the fluorescence signals detected were due to autofluorescence inside the cells and non-specific uptake effects, which were distributed through the cells in three dimensions. These non-specific 8 signals were barely enhanced by the Au/Au substrate, while the specific SWNT signals on the integrin-positive U87-MG cells at the cell-gold interface were enhanced to the maximum degree due to proximity to Au. Thus, preferential enhancement of specific cell membrane surface fluorescence afforded more sensitive and selective imaging of cell membrane receptors. This effect was consistent with little enhancement in the cell labeling selectivity observed on Au/Au substrate for cells treated by SWNT-RGD at 37 ºC (Figure 2n). Interestingly, these results suggested that the distance dependent fluorescence enhancement effect could be used for tracking transmembrane behavior in live cells, since the thickness of cell membrane was on the same order of magnitude as the enhancement decay distance (~5 nm). Besides the distance dependence of fluorescence enhancement, another reason for the observed increase in targeting selectivity on Au/Au film could be the nonlinearity of the enhancement effect. It was known that surface enhanced Raman scattering was non-linear to concentration, i.e., higher concentrations of analytes were usually enhanced more due to a better chance to occupy the enhancing ‘hot spots’.[45-46] Therefore, the negative MCF-7 cells were not enhanced as much due to much fewer SWNTs on the membranes than the positive U87-MG cells, and as a result, targeting selectivity was magnified by this nonlinear effect. Our NIR-FE imaging of cells was general for various NIR fluorescent organic dyes. We chose IR800 as a representative organic dye due to its wide use for biological imaging.[47-48] The IR800 dye molecules (shown as red circle in Figure 1a) bound to SWNTs deposited on the same Au/Au film exhibited a fluorescence enhancement by ~5-fold (Figure 1e vs 1f). We used SWNT-IR800-RGD conjugates to target αvβ3-integrin positive U87-MG cells and performed cell fluorescence imaging in the IR800 fluorescence channel. Comparing Figure 3a and 3c corresponding to SWNT-IR800-RGD stained U87-MG and MCF-7 cell lines respectively, one sees that the αvβ3-integrin positive U87-MG cells showed positive IR800 fluorescence signal (red) in the 790-820 nm region upon 785 nm excitation, while the αvβ3-integrin negative MCF-7 cells showed little IR800 signal under the same imaging condition. This again confirmed high specificity of molecular imaging and the coexistence of 9 IR800 and RGD on SWNTs. Comparison of Figure 3a and 3b revealed a significant fluorescence enhancement on Au/Au vs. quartz by ~6-fold for IR800 labels on cells, with a positive/negative selectivity ratio of ~16 on Au/Au film vs. ~4 on quartz (Figure 3e). These results demonstrated the generality of NIR-FE imaging of cells for high molecular sensitivity and selectivity. on quartz on Au/Au a) b) ) + ( G M - 7 8 U ) - ( 7 - F C M 10µm c) d) e) l l e e c C n d e c e s z e i l a r o m u r l o F N 1.4 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 U87-MG cell line MCF-7 cell line on AuAu on quartz Figure 3. IR800 fluorescence images of SWNT-IR800-RGD stained U87-MG cells on a) Au/Au film and b) on quartz, and similarly treated MCF-7 cells on c) Au/Au and d) on quartz. Incubation was 1 h for both cell lines at 4 ºC. False-colored images were taken under 785 nm excitation with photons collected in the 790-820 nm region. The bar chart in e) showed normalized cell fluorescence in each case of 3a)-d). Compared to organic NIR fluorophores, surfactant-solubilized SWNTs exhibit even lower quantum yield ranging from 0.1% to 3%.[13, 25-26] Relatively high concentrations of SWNTs (~60 nM) are typically needed for biological imaging, where the integrin binding sites to RGD on cell membranes were almost saturated.[16] To investigate the detection limit of NIR-FE cell imaging on gold, we labeled αvβ3-integrin positive U87-MG cells using different staining concentrations of SWNTs from 30 nM to 48 pM and imaged the cells on both Au/Au film (Figure 4, top row) and quartz slide 10 (Figure 4, bottom row). A low detection limit of 1.2 nM SWNT-RGD was reached for labeled cells on quartz substrate, below which cells (visible in optical images in insets of Figure 4h, 4j) were hardly discerned in the SWNT fluorescence images. In contrast, on Au/Au substrates, SWNT fluorescent cell images were observed for cells treated by SWNTs down to ~48 pM in concentration, suggesting a 25-fold improvement in the detection limit on Au/Au film (Figure 4k). 240 pM 4x i) 2x g) 48 pM 8x On Au/Au On quartz a) k)k) b) k) 30 nM 6 nM 1.2 nM 30µm c) e) 4x d) 4x f) 8x h) 16x j) 32x Figure 4. SWNT NIR fluorescence images of αvβ3-integrin positive U87-MG cells, on Au/Au (top panel) and quartz (bottom panel), stained with different concentrations of SWNT-RGD conjugates: a)&b) 30 nM, c)&d) 6 nM, e)&f) 1.2 nM, g)&h) 240 pM and i)&j) 48 pM. Some of these images with weak fluorescence were autoscaled by a certain multiplier as labeled. Insets in h) and j) showed the corresponding optical images in the same field of view. All fluorescence images were false-colored. k) Cell titration curves showed the average fluorescence intensity of SWNTs in each stained U87-MG cell on Au/Au film (red curve) and on quartz (blue curve) at different staining concentrations. 11 In conclusion, we employed plasmonic gold substrates for the first time to perform near-IR fluorescence enhanced molecular imaging of cells in the 0.8-1.4 µm spectral window based on carbon nanotubes and organic fluorophores. The novel solution-grown gold substrate was general in enhancing both carbon nanotubes and infrared dye IR800, by ~9 times and ~6 times respectively, affording higher sensitivity and specificity of molecular cell imaging in the advantageous 0.8-1.4 µm spectral window. Cell labeling at different incubation temperatures blocked or allowed endocytosis of nanotube fluorophores, leading to observation of a distance dependent fluorescence enhancement inside cells. This effect could be used to observe transmembrane behavior of single NIR fluorophores in live cells when the fluorescence enhancement decay distance matches cell membrane thickness. Further possibilities with NIR-FE imaging include single molecule imaging and tracking of SWNTs or other NIR dyes on cell membrane, molecular imaging of low abundance cell membrane proteins, and even some in vivo NIR-FE imaging using smaller yet enhancing Au nanostructures as enhancing platform to serve in a fluidic system. 12 [6] [9] [7] [8] References J. V. Frangioni, Curr. Opin. Chem. Biol. 2003, 7, 626. [1] V. Ntziachristos, J. Ripoll, R. Weissleder, Opt. Lett. 2002, 27, 1652. [2] J. E . Aubin, J. Histochem. Cytochem. 1979, 27, 36. [3] Z. Liu, S. Tabakman, K. Welsher, H. J. Dai, Nano Res. 2009, 2, 85. [4] Z. Liu, S. Tabakman, S. Sherlock, X. L. Li, Z. Chen, K. L. Jiang, S. S. Fan, H. [5] J. Dai, Nano Res. 2010, 3, 222. J. H. Flanagan, S. H. Khan, S. Menchen, S. A. Soper, R. P. Hammer, Bioconjugate Chem. 1997, 8, 751. Y. H. Lin, R. Weissleder, C. H. Tung, Bioconjugate Chem. 2002, 13, 605. R. Weissleder, C. H. Tung, U. Mahmood, A. Bogdanov, Nat. Biotechnol. 1999, 17, 375. V. Ntziachristos, C.-H. Tung, C. Bremer, R. Weissleder, Nat. Med. 2002, 8, 757. [10] M. Bruchez, M. Moronne, P. Gin, S. Weiss, A. P. Alivisatos, Science 1998, 281, 2013. [11] W. C. W. Chan, S. M. Nie, Science 1998, 281, 2016. [12] X. Y. Wu, H. J. Liu, J. Q. Liu, K. N. Haley, J. A. Treadway, J. P. Larson, N. F. Ge, F. Peale, M. P. Bruchez, Nat. Biotechnol. 2003, 21, 41. [13] M. J. O'Connell, S. M. Bachilo, C. B. Huffman, V. C. Moore, M. S. Strano, E. H. Haroz, K. L. Rialon, P. J. Boul, W. H. Noon, C. Kittrell, J. P. Ma, R. H. Hauge, R. B. Weisman, R. E. Smalley, Science 2002, 297, 593. [14] S. M. Bachilo, M. S. Strano, C. Kittrell, R. H. Hauge, R. E. Smalley, R. B. Weisman, Science 2002, 298, 2361. [15] P. Cherukuri, S. M. Bachilo, S. H. Litovsky, R. B. Weisman, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2004, 126, 15638. [16] K. Welsher, Z. Liu, D. Daranciang, H. Dai, Nano Lett. 2008, 8, 586. [17] P. Cherukuri, C. J. Gannon, T. K. Leeuw, H. K. Schmidt, R. E. Smalley, S. A. Curley, R. B. Weisman, P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2006, 103, 18882. [18] T. K. Leeuw, R. M. Reith, R. A. Simonette, M. E. Harden, P. Cherukuri, D. A. Tsyboulski, K. M. Beckingham, R. B. Weisman, Nano Lett. 2007, 7, 2650. [19] K. Welsher, Z. Liu, S. P. Sherlock, J. T. Robinson, Z. Chen, D. Daranciang, H. J. Dai, Nat. Nanotechnol. 2009, 4, 773. J. T. Robinson, K. Welsher, S. M. Tabakman, S. P. Sherlock, H. L. Wang, R. Luong, H. J. Dai, Nano Res. 2010, 3, 779. [21] X. X. Peng, H. X. Chen, D. R. Draney, W. Volcheck, A. Schutz-Geschwender, D. M. Olive, Anal. Biochem. 2009, 388, 220. [22] R. Philip, A. Penzkofer, W. Baumler, R. M. Szeimies, C. Abels, J. Photoch. Photobio. A 1996, 96, 137. [23] R. B. Mujumdar, L. A. Ernst, S. R. Mujumdar, C. J. Lewis, A. S. Waggoner, Bioconjugate Chem. 1993, 4, 105. [24] D. Magde, R. Wong, P. G. Seybold, Photochem. Photobiol. 2002, 75, 327. J. Crochet, M. Clemens, T. Hertel, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2007, 129, 8058. [25] [26] L. J. Carlson, S. E. Maccagnano, M. Zheng, J. Silcox, T. D. Krauss, Nano Lett. [20] 13 [36] 2007, 7, 3698. [27] V. Perebeinos, J. Tersoff, P. Avouris, Nano Lett. 2005, 5, 2495. [28] M. S. Strano, C. B. Huffman, V. C. Moore, M. J. O'Connell, E. H. Haroz, J. Hubbard, M. Miller, K. Rialon, C. Kittrell, S. Ramesh, R. H. Hauge, R. E. Smalley, J. Phys. Chem. B 2003, 107, 6979. [29] S. Y. Ju, W. P. Kopcha, F. Papadimitrakopoulos, Science 2009, 323, 1319. [30] G. S. Hong, S. M. Tabakman, K. Welsher, H. L. Wang, X. R. Wang, H. J. Dai, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2010, 132, 15920. [31] E. Le Moal, E. Fort, S. Leveque-Fort, F. P. Cordelieres, M. P. Fontaine-Aupart, C. Ricolleau, Biophys. J. 2007, 92, 2150. J. Zhang, Y. Fu, D. Liang, R. Y. Zhao, J. R. Lakowicz, Langmuir 2008, 24, 12452. [33] B. Radha, M. Arif, R. Datta, T. K. Kundu, G. U. Kulkarni, Nano Res. 2010, 3, 738. [34] Z. Liu, W. B. Cai, L. N. He, N. Nakayama, K. Chen, X. M. Sun, X. Y. Chen, H. J. Dai, Nat. Nanotechnol. 2007, 2, 47. [35] S. M. Tabakman, Z. Chen, H. S. Casalongue, H. Wang, H. Dai, Small 2011, 7, 499. J. H. Kim, J. H. Ahn, P. W. Barone, H. Jin, J. Q. Zhang, D. A. Heller, M. S. Strano, Angew. Chem. Int. Edit. 2010, 49, 1456. [37] N. W. S. Kam, T. C. Jessop, P. A. Wender, H. J. Dai, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2004, 126, 6850. [38] N. W. S. Kam, H. J. Dai, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2005, 127, 6021. [39] N. W. S. Kam, Z. Liu, H. J. Dai, Angew. Chem. Int. Edit. 2006, 45, 577. [40] H. Jin, D. A. Heller, M. S. Strano, Nano Lett. 2008, 8, 1577. [41] H. Jin, D. A. Heller, R. Sharma, M. S. Strano, Acs Nano 2009, 3, 149. [42] H. Mertens, A. F. Koenderink, A. Polman, Phys. Rev. B 2007, 76. J. Gersten, A. Nitzan, J. Chem. Phys. 1981, 75, 1139. [43] [44] A. Chen, V. T. Moy, Biophys. J. 2000, 78, 2814. [45] Y. Fang, N. H. Seong, D. D. Dlott, Science 2008, 321, 388. [46] Z. Chen, S. M. Tabakman, A. P. Goodwin, M. G. Kattah, D. Daranciang, X. R. Wang, G. Y. Zhang, X. L. Li, Z. Liu, P. J. Utz, K. L. Jiang, S. S. Fan, H. J. Dai, Nat. Biotechnol. 2008, 26, 1285. [47] K. E. Adams, S. Ke, S. Kwon, F. Liang, Z. Fan, Y. Lu, K. Hirschi, M. E. Mawad, M. A. Barry, E. M. Sevick-Muraca, J. Biomed. Opt. 2007, 12. [48] Y. Chen, S. Dhara, S. R. Banerjee, Y. Byun, M. Pullambhatla, R. C. Mease, M. G. Pomper, Biochem. Bioph. Res. Co. 2009, 390, 624. [32]
1904.08216	1	1904	2019-04-17T12:09:53	Exactly solvable model of gene expression in proliferating bacterial cell population with stochastic protein bursts and protein partitioning	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.MN" ]	Many of the existing stochastic models of gene expression contain the first-order decay reaction term that may describe active protein degradation or dilution. If the model variable is interpreted as the molecule number, and not concentration, the decay term may also approximate the loss of protein molecules due to cell division as a continuous degradation process. The seminal model of that kind leads to gamma distributions of protein levels, whose parameters are defined by the mean frequency of protein bursts and mean burst size. However, such models (whether interpreted in terms of molecule numbers or concentrations) do not correctly account for the noise due to protein partitioning between daughter cells. We present an exactly solvable stochastic model of gene expression in cells dividing at random times, where we assume description in terms of molecule numbers with a constant mean protein burst size. The model is based on a population balance equation supplemented with protein production in random bursts. If protein molecules are partitioned equally between daughter cells, we obtain at steady state the analytical expressions for probability distributions similar in shape to gamma distribution, yet with quite different values of mean burst size and mean burst frequency than would result from fitting of the classical continuous-decay model to these distributions. For random partitioning of protein molecules between daughter cells, we obtain the moment equations for the protein number distribution and thus the analytical formulas for the squared coefficient of variation.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Exactly solvable model of gene expression in proliferating bacterial cell population with stochastic protein bursts and protein partitioning Jakub Jędrak,1, ∗ Maciej Kwiatkowski,2 and Anna Ochab-Marcinek1 1Institute of Physical Chemistry, Polish Academy of Sciences, Kasprzaka 44/52, 01-224 Warsaw, Poland 2unaffiliated; ORCID: 0000-0001-7675-4595 (Dated: April 18, 2019) Many of the existing stochastic models of gene expression contain the first-order decay reaction term that may describe active protein degradation or dilution. If the model variable is interpreted as the molecule number, and not concentration, the decay term may also approximate the loss of protein molecules due to cell division as a continuous degradation process. The seminal model of that kind leads to gamma distributions of protein levels, whose parameters are defined by the mean frequency of protein bursts and mean burst size. However, such models (whether interpreted in terms of molecule numbers or concentrations) do not correctly account for the noise due to protein partitioning between daughter cells. We present an exactly solvable stochastic model of gene expression in cells dividing at random times, where we assume description in terms of molecule numbers with a constant mean protein burst size. The model is based on a population balance equation supplemented with protein production in random bursts. If protein molecules are partitioned equally between daughter cells, we obtain at steady state the analytical expressions for probability distributions similar in shape to gamma distribution, yet with quite different values of mean burst size and mean burst frequency than would result from fitting of the classical continuous-decay model to these distributions. For random partitioning of protein molecules between daughter cells, we obtain the moment equations for the protein number distribution and thus the analytical formulas for the squared coefficient of variation. I. INTRODUCTION Genetically identical cells in a proliferating microbial population may differ not only in their cell-cycle age, volume or growth rate, but also in the copy numbers of molecules, in particular, the protein molecules. Even if the dependence of gene expression on growth rate [1 -- 4] and cell-cycle stage [5] can be neglected, there still remain at least two factors causing fluctuations in the molecule numbers between individual cells: First, gene expression is an inherently stochastic process because of the small number of molecules involved in biochemical reactions. Second, molecules, including proteins, are par- titioned between daughter cells at cell division in a more or less random manner [6, 7]. Yet, many stochastic models of gene expression neglect the protein partitioning [8]. The classical models with a first-order decay reaction term [9 -- 12] may be interpreted in two ways: (i) If the model describes the protein levels in terms of molecule numbers, then the degradation term describes not only a possible active protein degradation (rare in bacteria [13]) but it also mimicks the effect of cell division. However, this description neglects the fluctua- tions both due to the abrupt protein loss at cell division (which are present even at the half-by-half protein par- titioning) and due to a possible random partitioning of the molecules between cells. (ii) If the same classical ∗[email protected] model describes the protein levels in terms of concentra- tions, then the continuous degradation term reflects, be- sides possible active degradation, the dilution due to cell growth. Under the assumption of a perfectly equal pro- tein partitioning, the concentrations remain unchanged at cell division. However, if protein partitioning is ran- dom, then it should result in concentration fluctuations (at binomial partitioning, they extinct at high gene ex- pression levels), and these fluctuations are neglected in the conventional model. Based on the classical models of gene expression where proteins are assumed to be produced in random transla- tional bursts [9 -- 12] and on the population balance equa- tions [14 -- 16], we propose a minimal analytically tractable model of gene expression in a population of dividing cells. This model directly accounts for the protein loss at cell division and random partitioning of the molecules be- tween daughter cells. The manuscript is organized as follows: Sec. II presents the theoretical model. In Sec. III A we calculate the moments of the steady-state protein number distribu- tion for any symmetric random partitioning of proteins between daughter cells. III B we show that a noise floor, i.e. the absolute lower bound for noise as a function of mean protein number, occuring for highly ex- pressed proteins, arises in the model as a consequence of protein loss at cell division. This kind of a noise floor is a property of the description in terms of molecule numbers. In Sec. III C we compare the protein number distribu- tions resulting from our model to the distributions from the seminal Friedman's model [11]. III C 1 we In Sec. In Sec. show that if both distributions have the same mean and variance then the underlying mean burst frequency and mean burst size may differ. In Sec. III C 2 we obtain the analytical form of the protein number distribution for the half-by-half protein partitioning and we show that its shape is very similar to the shape of a gamma dis- tribution from the Friedman's model [11]. In Sec. III D we analyze the behavior of the distribution tails for large protein numbers. In Sec. III E we compare the squared coefficient of variation of our model to the existing exper- imental data. Section IV contains discussion and conclu- sions. II. MODEL We combine the analytical framework first introduced by Friedman et al. [11] with the population balance equa- tion (PBE) [14 -- 16], a standard tool for modelling micro- bial populations. In Ref. [11], gene expression was described as a com- pound Poisson process with random Poissonian events of protein production, where a random number of protein molecules was produced at once in each such event. The protein burst size u was drawn from a distribution ν(u). Originally, ν(u) was assumed to be an exponential dis- tribution [11], based on the experimental data for E. coli [10, 17], but here we will relax this assumption. Protein production was counterbalanced in the Friedman's model [11] by a continuous, deterministic protein decay term. The model allowed self-regulation: The burst occurrence rate k was modulated by a transfer function hp(x), de- pendent on the current protein level x. We note that the continuous variable x was assumed to be protein concen- tration in Ref. [11]. However, in this study, we interpret x as the molecule number. This distinction is crucial be- cause cell division exactly by half maintains a constant protein concentration, whereas the protein number drops by 1/2. If protein production bursts are constant in terms of molecule number, then their size in the units of con- centration decreases in growing cells. Therefore, we treat here the theoretical framework of Ref. [11] as a continuous approximation to discrete fixed cell size gene expression models, cf. e.g. [18], and not in its original interpretation, as a model describing evo- lution of protein concentration in growing and dividing cell. Within the model proposed in Ref. [11], the first order decay term describes both true protein degradation (if present) and protein dilution due to cell growth. On the other hand, population balance equation (PBE) describes the time evolution of the cell number density in a proliferating microbial population [14, 15]. At cell division, protein molecules are partitioned according to x → {qx, (1 − q)x}, where x ∈ [0, ∞) is a continu- ous protein copy number, and not protein concentration, whereas the division ratio 0 ≤ q ≤ 1 is a random number, drawn from the division ratio probability density func- tion (PDF) η(q) = η(1 − q). Within the PBE approach 2 as used in [14 -- 16], protein production is described as a deterministic process. However, both protein production rate and cell division rate may depend on x in a nontrvial way. By merging both the above theoretical frameworks, we get the time-evolution equation for p(x, t), a PDF of the protein number x at time t in the population of cells (Appendix A): ∂p(x, t) ∂t = − ∂ ∂x [g(x)p(x, t)] − hd(x)p(x, t) hd(cid:18) x q(cid:19) p(cid:18) x q , t(cid:19) dq hd(ξ)p(ξ, t)dξ 0 q η(q) + 2Z 1 − p(x, t)Z ∞ + kZ x 0 0 w(x − x′)hp (x′) p(x′, t)dx′, (1) In the above equation, x − x′ is the burst size, ν(x − x′) is the burst size PDF, w(x − x′) ≡ ν(x − x′) − δ(x − x′) and δ(x − x′) is Dirac delta distribution [11]. The x- dependence of cell division and protein production rates are given by hd(x) and hp(x), respectively. Thus, khp(x) is the burst frequency, whereas g(x) describes either de- terministic protein production or degradation. Eq. (1) is a generalization of both Eq. (1) of Ref. [11] and Eq. (1) of Ref. [16]. If x cannot be treated as proportional to the cell mass or volume, it is unclear how the division rate should de- pend on the copy number of a given protein, and various functional forms of hd(x) were used in the literature [14 -- 16]. For that reason, and in order to obtain an analyti- cally tractable model, we focus here on the simplest case of the constant cell division rate, 2hd(x) ≡ ∆ = const, which implies R ∞ 0 hd(ξ)p(ξ)dξ = ∆/2. III. RESULTS A. Moments of the steady-state protein number distribution We consider the steady-state solution of Eq. (1), ∂p(x, t)/∂t = 0. Assuming g(x) = −γx, γ ≥ 0 and unregulated protein production (hp(x) = 1), we have −γ d dx [xp(x)] = ∆Z 1 + kZ x 0 0 q(cid:19) − p(x)(cid:21) dq p(cid:18) x η(q)(cid:20) 1 w(x − x′)p(x′)dx′. q (2) The Laplace transform (L{. . .}) of Eq. (2) yields γs dG(s) ds = ∆Z 1 0 η(q) [G(qs) − G(s)] dq + k w(s)G(s), (3) where G(s) = L{p(x)}, and w(s) = L{w(u)} = ν(s) − 1. Moment equations follow from Eq. (3), [(1 − Mr)∆ + rγ] µr = k r Xl=1 (cid:18)r l(cid:19)µr−lml, (4) where µr = R ∞ tein number PDF, mr = R ∞ of the burst size PDF, and Mr = R 1 0 xrp(x)dx is the r-th moment of the pro- 0 urν(u)du is the r-th moment 0 qrη(q)dq is the r-th moment of the division ratio PDF (note that M1 = 1/2). For γ 6= 0, ∆ = 0 (the proteins are degraded, but there is no protein partitioning at cell division) Eq. (4) yields µ1 = am1 ≡ µ1,γ, κ2 = µ2 − µ2 1 = 1 2 am2 ≡ κ2,γ, (5) where a = k/γ [19]. On the other hand, for γ = 0 (the proteins are stable) and ∆ 6= 0, from Eq. (4) we get µ1 = 2ωm1 ≡ µ1,∆, κ2 = 4ω2M2m2 1 + ωm2 (1 − M2) ≡ κ2,∆, (6) where ω = k/∆. The variance of the protein number, κ2,∆ = var[p(x)] (6) is a monotonically increasing func- 1)/M2 tion of (M2 − M2 1 = 4M2 − 1, i.e., of the noise due to protein partitioning. For a given ν(u) and η(q), if a = 2ω, i.e., if µ1,γ (5) is equal to µ1,∆ (6), then from Eqs. (5) and (6) it follows that κ2,∆ > κ2,γ. Therefore, within the present descrip- tion in terms of molecule numbers, the first-order decay such as in the classical model by Friedman et al. [11] is not equivalent to any protein partitioning mechanism. B. Squared coefficient of variation has a noise floor due to cell division Protein degradation is important for eukaryotic organ- isms, but may be neglected in the case of bacteria; hence we put γ = 0. From Eq. (6) we obtain the squared coefficient of variation c2 v(µ1) ≡ κ2,∆ µ2 1,∆ = m2 2m1 1 (1 − M2) 1 µ1 + M2 (1 − M2) . (7) The protein number noise, measured by the squared co- efficient of variation (7) is thus of the form c2 v(µ1) = E1 µ1 + E0, (8) with µ1-independent E0 and E1, which leads to the char- acteristic boomerang-like shape of the log-log plot (Fig. 1A). In Fig. 1, the half-by-half protein partitioning is assumed, η(q) = ηd(q) ≡ δ (q − 1/2) , (9) which does not depend on x and which gives M2 = 1/4. However, for small x, the half-by-half division as given by b=10 b=18.0 +/- 2.1 A β 104 103 102 101 100 b=10 b=5 b=1 ω B 3 104 103 102 101 100 102 ) 12 µ / 2 b=5 101 b=1 100 i κ ( e s o n e c n e c s e r o u F l 10-1 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 Mean fluorescence (µ 1) 10-1 10-1 100 α 10-1 101 FIG. 1: (A) Plot of c2 v(µ1) (7) as a function of µ1 = 2ωm1 for m2/m1 = 2b and for selected mean burst sizes b = m1. Half- by-half protein partitioning is assumed, M2 = 1/4, which does not depend on x. Dashed line: E0 = E0,d = 1/3, the lowest value of the noise floor allowed by the model. Points: [21], see Sec. III E). Symbols Experimental data from Ref. and colors in (A) are used as in Ref. [21]. Symbols, carbon source: arabinose ( ), maltose ((cid:4)), glycerol ((cid:7)), glucose (N), glucose+malate (H). Colors, promoter activity induced by: 10 (blue), 20 (gold), 50 (green), 100 (violet), 1000 (turquoise) µM IPTG. Gray dashed curve: Fit of our model to the data. (B) Mapping of mean burst frequency ω and mean burst size b of our model (where cell division is explicitly taken into account) onto the corresponding values α and β of these pa- rameters appearing in Eq. (12) (where there is no protein loss at cell division but a continuous protein degradation is assumed). Curves: β(α) (14) for variable ω and constant b. Colors denote the value of ω. Circles, squares, and triangles denote ω = 10i, i = −1, 0, 1, 2, 3, 4. Dashed line: upper bound for α within our model, αmax = E −1 0,d = 3. Black dots: The same data as in (A) but the colors and symbols were omit- ted for the sake of clarity. Gray dashed curve: Fit from (A), mapped using Eq. (14). (9) is much less realistic than other continuous approxi- mations to discrete binomial distribution, such as the 'all or none' partitioning (η(q) = ηb(q) ≡ 1 2 [δ(q) + δ(1 − q)]) or even a uniform distribution of partition ratio (η(q) = ηu(q) ≡ Θ(q)Θ (1 − q)), considered in Refs. [16, 20]. E0 = M2/(1 − M2) provides the lower bound for ex- trinsic noise and does not depend on the details of pro- tein production mechanism. However, the contribution of protein partitioning to the value of E0 predicted by the present model for a realistic level of protein partitioning noise is likely to be overestimated for the following rea- son: Eq. (2) is a Master equation with time-independent parameters, hence it describes the cell division events as a Poisson process [22]. In consequence, the cell cycle length has an unrealistic, exponential distribution, contributing with too much noise (see Appendix C). Therefore, the age structure of the population is also unrealistic (Ap- pendix D). This indicates a limitation of the simplest, single-variable version of the PBE approach as a candi- date for a minimal model of gene expression as it assumes the "most random" distribution of cell cycle lengths (i.e., the one that naturally occurs from a Poisson process). Thus, our model provides an "upper bound" for the noise contribution due to cell cycle length fluctuations (meaning the "most random" fluctuations that can be generated by a model based on Master equation [23]): (9) there is no In the case when η(q) is given by Eq. protein partitioning noise (var[δ(cid:0)q − 1 has the minimal value E0 = 1/3 ≡ E0,d. Therefore, E0,d is the contribution to the noise floor coming solely from fluctuations of the cell cycle length, whereas the remaining part, E0 − E0,d = (4M2 − 1)/[3(1 − M2)] is due to protein partitioning noise. 2(cid:1)] = 0) and E0 C. Our model vs. Friedman's model [11]: Similar distributions but different parameters 1. Mean burst frequency and mean burst size differ between the models despite the same mean and variance of protein number distribution Let us consider a single-parameter burst size PDF, ν(u; b) = h (u/b) /b, where u ≡ x − x′ is a burst size, such that m1 = b and m2 = Cb2. C = 2 for the expo- nential burst distribution: ν(u) = b−1e−u/b, ν(s) ≡ L[ν(u)] = (sb + 1)−1. (10) For m2/m1 = Cb = const, the increase in mean protein number µ1 = 2ωb is caused solely by the increase in ω (i. e., by the increase in burst frequency k or decrease in cell division rate ∆). In such a case, we move along the boomerang-shaped trajectories for a fixed value of b, like those depicted in Fig. 1A. In general, µ1 may be varied both due to the change in b and ω. If k = 0 and g(x) = −γx term in Eq. (2) is replaced with g(x) = σ > 0 (this is a special case of the model of Ref. [16]), then instead of (7) we obtain c2 v(µ1) = E0 = M2 1 − M2 = const. (11) In other words, the squared coefficient of variation is then described by some general equation in the form of (8) (but not (7)), where E0 6= 0, E1 = 0 if protein production in our model is deterministic and cell division is stochas- tic. The opposite situation, E1 6= 0, E0 = 0, is encoun- tered for γ 6= 0, ∆ = 0, in particular for the model of unregulated, bursty gene expression with continuous pro- tein degradation [11], which predicts that protein num- bers are gamma-distributed: pγ(x; α, β) ≡ xα−1 exp (−x/β) βαΓ(α) . (12) Then, c2 v(µ1) = 1/α = β/µ1, i. e., E1 = β and E0 = 0. To make a comparison of pγ(x; α, β) (12) to the protein number PDF of the present model, p(x), we assume now 4 that these two distributions have equal means and equal second moments, µr,γ = µr,∆, r = 1, 2. We also assume that the burst size PDF ν(u) is given by (10), but the mean burst size may be different for the two models, m1,γ = β 6= b = m1,∆. These assumptions yield the following mapping: α = µ2 1 κ2 = ω (1 − M2) ωM2 + 1/2 , β = κ2 µ1 = (2M2ω + 1) b 1 − M2 . From (13) we obtain β(α) = b 1 − (1 + α)M2 . (13) (14) For simplicity, we assume now that protein partitioning is deterministic, i.e., that each daughter cell obtains ex- actly half of the total number of protein molecules at cell division. In such a case, η(q) = ηd(q) is given by Eq. (9), so that M2 = 1/4. In Fig. 1B we plot α vs. β (14) to show that the mean burst frequency ω and mean burst size b in our model take different values than the corre- sponding parameters α and β of the gamma distribution (12). In particular, ω is not limited to several bursts per cell cycle as was α, so the mean burst size b does not need to take as high values as would β need to take in order to obtain a high level of gene expression. 2. Analytical form of the protein number distribution for half-by-half protein partitioning. Apparent similarity to gamma distribution. Below, we will show that equating the two first mo- ments of our PDF p(x) with those of the gamma dis- tribution pγ(x) (12) yields similar overall shapes of the distributions. If so, any experimental gamma-shaped dis- tributions with c2 v ≥ E0,d = 1/3 may be as well fitted by the distributions given by our model (under the as- sumption that protein numbers, and not concentrations, were measured in experiment). With η(q) = δ(q − 1 2 ), we can rewrite Eq. (3) as G(s) = R(s)G (s/2), where R(s) ≡ {1 − ω[ν(s) − 1]}−1, R(0) = 1. Solving by itera- i=0 R(cid:0)s/2i(cid:1). For ν(s) (10), G(s) tion, we get G(s) = Q∞ reads G(s) = = ∞ ∞ Yi=0 Xr=0 2−ibs + 1 2−i(1 + ω)bs + 1 = (−bs; 1 2 )∞ (−b(1 + ω)s; 1 2 )∞ ((1 + ω)−1; 1 2 )r 2 ; 1 ( 1 2 )r (−b(1 + ω)s)r, (15) where (a; q)k is a q-Pochhammer symbol. In (15) we used the q-binomial theorem [24], (az; q)∞ (z; q)∞ = ∞ Xn=0 (a; q)n (q; q)n zn. (16) The symbol q appering in Eq. (16) should not be con- fused with protein partitioning ratio q appearing e.g. in Eqs. (1), (2), (3) or (9). The letter q is traditionally used in the branch of mathematics called q-theory or q- analogs (q-binomial theorem or q-Pochhammer symbol are examples of such q-analogs). From Eq. (15) we obtain cumulants of L−1{G(s)}, κr = 2rbr(r − 1)![(1 + ω)r − 1] (2r − 1) . (17) [16] and [20], instead of (18) we obtain a used in Refs. statistical mixture of two broad (c2 v ≥ 1/2) gamma dis- tributions (Appendix G). Therefore in the present case it is no longer true that the "steady-state population distri- bution (...) becomes insensitive to the division details" [20]. For large x, η(q) = Θ(q)Θ (1 − q) is much less real- istic than η(q) = ηd(q) = δ(q − 1 2 ) (9) used here, and it leads to a higher noise floor (E0 = 1/2). 5 We also have L−1{G(s)} = p(x) = ∞ Xi=0 Ci(ω) b exp(cid:18) −2ix b(ω + 1)(cid:19) , (18) where Ci(ω) = 2iω (2(1 + ω)−1; 2)i ( 1 2 (1 + ω)−1; 1 2 )∞ (1 + ω)2 (2; 2)i 2 ; 1 ( 1 2 )∞ . (19) For ω = ωn ≡ 2n − 1, n = 1, 2, 3, . . ., p(x) (18) can be written as a finite series p(x) ≡ pn(x) = 1 b n Xl=1 An,l exp(cid:16)− x 2lb(cid:17) , (20) where An,l = (−1)n−l2 l(l−3) 2 Ql−1 i=1(2i − 1)Qn−l j=1(2j − 1) . (21) Equations (18) and (19) define a two-parameter family of PDFs, resembling the gamma PDF (Fig. 2). In partic- ular, p(x) (18) is right-skewed, unimodal for ω > 1, and monotonically decreasing for ω ≤ 1. D. Distribution tail for large protein numbers In both p(x) (18) and pγ(x) (12), the mean burst size (b and β, respectively) is the scaling parameter. The tail of p(x) (18) is exponential: For large x we have p(x) ∼ exp[−x/(b(ω + 1))]. However, in contrast to the gamma distribution, where the leading term is exp[−x/b], the exponent in our model depends not only on the mean burst size, but also on burst frequency. The same asymptotic behaviour as for p(x) (18) is present if instead of η(q) = δ(q − 1 2 ) any other η(q) for is used (except for some pathological cases, e.g. ηb(q) = 1 2 [δ(q) + δ(1 − q)]) (Appendix F). This is the special case of a yet more general result. Using Eq. (1), it can be shown in a similar manner as in Ref. [16] that for g(x) = 0 and ν(u) (10) the ratio p(x2)/p(x1) at the tail of the PDF is well approximated by exp (−I12), where I12 = Z x2 and R = R ∞ x1 kh′ p(x) + h′ d(x) + hd(x)/b + R/b khp(x) + hd(x) + R dx, (22) 0 hd(ξ)p(ξ)dξ (Appendix F). However, even if the tails are universal, i.e., independent on the division- ratio PDF η(q), the corresponding probability distribu- tions are not. For example, for η(q) = Θ(q)Θ (1 − q) E. Comparison to experimental data In this section, we compare the squared coefficient of variation as a function of the mean protein level in our model to the existing experimental data, under the as- sumption of equal protein partitioning between daugh- ter cells (the lowest possible noise due to cell division, Fig. 1A). In Ref. [21], the authors measured total cell fluores- cence emitted by the green fluorescent protein (GFP), encoded for by a gene controlled by the hyper-spank pro- moter in B. subtilis. The promoter activity was modu- lated by the concentration of isopropyl-D-thiogalactoside (IPTG). An independent parameter varied in the exper- iment was the cell growth rate, depending on the carbon source in the medium. The data points shown in Fig. 1A were obtained in Ref. [21] by variation of these two pa- rameters (we use the symbols and colors as in that Ref- erence; we manually extracted the data points from Fig. 4a therein using the xyscan software). Assuming that the total cell fluorescence scales linearly with the number of reporter proteins, the x variable in our model may be reinterpreted as the fluorescence level and the mean protein burst size m1 ≡ b is then expressed in fluorescence units. Thus, the mean protein number is proportional to the mean total cell fluorescence, and the squared coefficient of variation does not depend on the units in which gene expression was measured (molecule number or fluorescence units). We note that the lin- ear scaling between the GFP molecule number and total cell fluorescence is not necessarily an obvious assumption (see, e.g., Ref. [25]). On the other hand, the authors of Ref. [21] estimated that GFP maturation time did not affect strongly the fluorescence level, which may possibly exclude one source of non-linear scaling of the fluores- cence detected vs. molecule number. The linear scaling was also assumed in Ref. [26]. The range of the mean total cell fluorescence mea- sured in Ref. [21] was too narrow to show a noise floor (Fig. 1A). However, the data provide a hint that if the noise floor exists, it would be lower than that predicted by our model. This suggests that the distribution of cell cy- cle lengths in our model is indeed too wide, as we pointed out in Section III B. For a rough comparison, we also plotted a fit of the squared coefficient of variation c2 v of our model (7) to the data. The slope of c2 v in our model seems to be in agreement with the experimental results. The fit yields an estimation of the mean burst size m1 ≡ b = 18.0 ± 2.1 in the units of fluorescence, as used in Ref. [21]; how- ever, this value should be treated with caution because some other model with a lower noise floor due to a nar- rower distribution of cell-cycle lengths may possibly yield a different value of b. For completeness, we also plotted the data from Ref. [21] in Fig. 1B (we omitted the colors and symbols used in Fig. 1A). We made the assumption that the total cell fluorescence in the experiment was gamma-distributed, as shown in the SI of Ref. [21]. We mapped the mean hf i v,f = var(f )/hf i2 of and squared coefficient of variation c2 the total cell fluorescence onto the corresponding values v,f )−1, β = of parameters of gamma distributions: α = (c2 hf i · c2 v,f . A noise floor was observed in other experiments re- ported in literature [3, 12, 25 -- 29] but most of these data were not suitable for comparison to our model (see an overview in Appendix E) because they were normalized to cell volume or gated to make them independent on cell-cycle stage. Thus, molecule number fluctuations due to loss of proteins at cell division were absent in these data. There are two studies on S. cerevisiae that reported the gene expression noise floor in ungated measurements. Its levels lower than in our model (where E0 = 1/3): In Ref. [27], Fig. 2 and S2 therein, the noise floor measured as the coefficient of variation cv took the values between 0.3 and 0.4, corresponding to the squared coefficient of variation c2 v between 0.09 and 0.16. In Ref. [3], Fig. 2A and S9 therein, c2 v was between 0.1 and 0.2. One reason for that difference may be the too wide distribution of cell cycle lengths in our model. But it should also be noted that our model may be far too simplistic for eukaryotic cells, as it does not account for the discrete promoter activity states due to chromatin remodeling, the nuclear transport, etc. IV. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS [16]. In Ref. [11] and Ref. We have proposed a model of gene expression in a pro- liferating cell population, which is a generalization of the models of Refs. [11], the protein production was stochastic, whereas the decrease of protein concentration was due to a deterministic pro- tein degradation process. Here, we treat the model of Ref. [11] as a continuous approximation (still in the units of protein number) to discrete gene expression models, such as in Ref. [18], that describe non-growing and non- dividing cells. In Ref. [16], the situation was just opposite: Protein partitioning was stochastic and protein production was deterministic. After combining the stochastic protein production (of Ref. [11]) with the stochastic protein par- titioning (used in Ref. [16]), we obtain the boomerang- like shape of the log-log plot of mean protein copy number vs. protein copy number noise. 6 n=1 n=2 n=3 n ω α β/b 1 1 1 2 3 3 7 4 15 1.8 2.333 2.647 2 3.333 6 11.333 20 × 103 ) β , α ; x ( γ p , ) b , ) n ( ω ; x ( n p 15 10 5 0 0 50 100 n=4 150 x 200 250 300 FIG. 2: Protein number PDFs of our model, pn(x) = pn(x; ω(n), b), vs. gamma distributions, pγ(x; α, β). Both distributions have similar shapes and become identical for ω = 1 (n = 1). Red solid line: pn(x) (20) for ω = 2n − 1, n = 1, 2, 3, 4 and b = 5. Black dashed line: pγ(x; α, β) (12) with α = 3ω/(ω + 2) and β/b = 2(ω + 2)/3 given by (13) for M2 = 1/4. Blue lines: Simulations using the Gillespie algo- rithm ([30], see Appendix K). Inset: Parameter comparison. Because the protein copy number and not protein con- centration is the variable in our model, the protein parti- tioning at cell division along with an age structure of the cell population (cf. Eq. (D2)) lead to the existence of the noise floor -- an absolute lower bound for noise, present for highly expressed proteins. Our results suggest that the values of mean burst size and burst frequency that may be obtained by fitting the- oretical distributions to experimental data are strongly model-dependent. Naïve fitting of the gamma distri- bution [11] or its discrete counterpart, negative bino- mial distribution [18], to the data measured in terms of molecule numbers, would neglect protein loss at cell di- vision because the underlying models neglected cell divi- sion, and thus such a fitting might overestimate the mean burst sizes and underestimate mean burst frequencies for higher gene expression levels. Our model, directly accounting for the protein molecule numbers, may be important for interpretation of experimental results. In some studies, data correction for cell size was carried out: In [12], cell volume was mea- sured by image recognition and the protein fluorescence was normalized by the volume. In other studies, the flow cytometry data were gated [25, 26, 28, 29]. Gating filters out the data only for those cells that scatter light to a similar extent, so the observed cells are supposed to be of similar sizes. However, the gating procedure may be im- perfect because setting the size range too narrow leaves too little data, whereas setting the gate too wide results in some variation in cell sizes. One can avoid these prob- lems by measuring the total cell fluorescence [3, 21, 27] and then separating the noise contributions from varying cell sizes (due to cell-cycle progression and other sources of variability) using independent measurements [21] or estimating these contributions theoretically. Our model brings us closer to theoretical determination of the mag- nitude of one of these contributions, namely, the protein loss due to cell division and partitioning between daugh- ter cells. We have compared our model to the existing literature data [21], however, the possibilities of such a comparison are limited so far. The results for B. subtilis, reported in Ref. [21], were measured in too narrow a range of gene expression levels, whereas the results for S. cerevisiae of Refs. [3, 27] may not be comparable to our minimal model because of the complexity of gene expression mech- anisms in eukaryotes. However, a cautious comparison of our model to the above data suggests that the main lim- itation of the model is its prediction of too large a con- tribution of protein loss at cell division to the noise floor. This is due to the exponential distribution of cell cycle lengths, since the cell divisions are modelled as Poisso- nian events (Appendix C). In a more realistic model, the cell cycle length distribution could be modeled, instead of the exponential distribution, as gamma distribution [31] or some other distribution peaked around the mean cell cycle length, with the limiting case of Dirac delta distribution describing a deterministic cell cycle. How- ever, this is beyond the scope of the present paper. In preparation is our new paper [32] that explores the noise levels in a more realistic model. Another limitation of our theoretical approach may be the description of the messenger RNA (mRNA) as very short-lived molecules, only implicitly present in the model [11], and thus the neglect of their partitioning at cell division. Also, the model does not describe the factors that may significantly shape the gene expression noise levels in eukaryotes, e. g., the discrete on-off pro- moter switching or nuclear transport. We may expect that negative gene autoregulation (not considered here) would suppress protein noise [11, 33], and thus decrease the noise floor. Yet, positive autoregu- lation is expected to have the opposite effect [11, 33]. In a similar manner, nontrivial dependence of cell division rate on protein number (hd(x) 6= const) would probably result in a lower noise floor. Still, the analytical solution to our model in presence of gene autoregulation or cell di- vision regulation does not seem feasible. For that reason, we have studied here the non-regulated gene expression and cell division only. Acknowledgments AOM was supported by the National Science Centre SONATA BIS 6 grant no. 2016/22/E/ST2/00558. Author contributions JJ designed the study, performed the analytical calcu- lations and wrote the manuscript. MK wrote the simu- 7 lation code for cell division. AOM participated in the study design by the idea of comparison of the model with experimental data and by making the comparison; designed the simulation algorithm for cell division, su- pervised writing the simulation code and introduced mi- nor modifications in the code; performed the simulations; performed the distribution fitting by maxima matching and observed heuristically the behavior of the probablity distributions described in Appendix J; participated in writing the manuscript. Appendix A: Derivation of Eq. (1) Equation (1) follows from an apparently very similar, but more fundamental equation describing the number density of cells, F (x, t), in a proliferating population, ∂F (x, t) ∂t = − ∂ ∂x [g(x)F (x, t)] − hd(x)F (x, t) + 2Z 1 + kZ x 0 0 η(q) q hd(cid:18) x q(cid:19) F (cid:18) x q , t(cid:19) dq w(x − x′)hp (x′) F (x′, t)dx′. (A1) Namely, F (x, t)dx is the number of those cells in a population, which at time t contain exactly x protein molecules. In order to derive Eq. (1) from Eq. (A1), we define p(x, t) = F (x, t) N (t) , (A2) where N (t) = Z ∞ 0 F (x, t)dx (A3) is the total number of cells in the population [15]. Inte- grating both sides of Eq. (A1) from x = 0 to x = ∞, assuming that F (∞, t) = g(0)F (0, t) = 0 and making use of (A2) and (A3) we obtain dN (t) dt = N (t)Z ∞ 0 hd(x)p(x, t)dx. (A4) Now, Eq. (1) follows from (A1)-(A4) and from obvious identity ∂F (x, t) ∂t = N (t) ∂p(x, t) ∂t + p(x, t) dN (t) dt . (A5) The above derivation is essentially that of Ref. [15], the only difference is the presence of the terms responsible for bursty protein production in the present case. In spite of their apparent similarity, there are impor- tant differences between Eq. (1) and Eq. (A1). First, the terms related to protein partitioning in Eq. (A1) con- serve the total number of protein molecules (molecules are neither created, nor destroyed during cell division), whereas from Eq. (1) it follows that the cell division always decreases the mean protein number in the pop- 0 hd(ξ)p(ξ, t)dξ ulation. This is due to the (−1)p(x, t)R ∞ term in Eq. (1), not present in Eq. (A1). Second, N (t) grows indefinitely according to Eq. (A4), therefore in contrast to Eq. (1), Eq. (A1) does not have nontrivial stationary solutions. Our task now is to determine, for the present model: (i) the population growth rate, νm, (ii) probability distri- bution f (τ ) of generation time (cell cycle length), τ , for each newborn cell, and (iii) the cell age (a) distribution φ(a) in the state of a balanced, exponential growth [35]. This is done in next three sections. Appendix B: Population growth rate νm The steady state solutions of Eq. (1), p(x), corre- spond to the so called state of balanced growth, when the shape of F (x, t) = N (t)p(x) does not change but is only rescaled by N (t) [15]. In such a case, from Eq. (A4) we obtain N (t) = N0eνmt, (B1) where νm, given by νm = Z ∞ 0 hd(x)p(x)dx (B2) is the population growth rate. N (t) as given by (B1) is characteristic for (in fact, defines) the phase of exponen- tial growth [31][36]. If g(x) = −γx and if neither the protein production rate nor the cell division rate depend on the number of protein molecules (hp(x) = 1, hd(x) ≡ ∆/2), Eq. (1) reads 8 It is instructive to show this result in an alternative way. Consider time evolution of the moments of p(x, t), resulting from Eq. (B3), µr = − [(1 − Mr)∆ + rγ] µr + k r Xl=1 (cid:18)r l(cid:19)µr−lml. (B6) In the absence of protein production (k = 0) and degra- dation (γ = 0), from Eq. (B6) it follows that the time dependence of the first moment of p(x, t), i.e., the mean protein number is given by [37] µ1(t) = µ1(0)e−∆0t. (B7) X(t)/N (t), where X(t) ≡ PN (t) On the other hand, from the definition of the popula- tion average, the mean protein number µ1(t) is equal to i=1 xi(t) denotes the to- tal number of protein molecules in a population, and xi(t) is a number of protein molecules in i-th cell at time t. If there is no protein production or degrada- tion, X(t) is constant and equal to its initial value, X(t) = X(0) = N0µ1(0). In such a case, time evolu- tion of the mean protein number µ1(t) is caused solely by the increase in cell number, X(t) N (t) = N0µ1(0) N0eνmt = µ1(0)e−νmt. (B8) Comparing (B7) and (B8) we see that νm = ∆0, i.e., the population growth rate νm is equal to the individual cell division rate ∆0, as it should. So far, we have considered the whole proliferating cell population, for which ∆ = 2∆0 = 2νm (scenario A). However, Eq. (B3), but not Eq. (1), may be also used to describe the time evolution of the protein number dis- tribution p(x, t) in a single cell lineage. In such a case, we discard one of the daughter cells at each cell division, and therefore ∆ = ∆0 (scenario B). ∂p(x, t) ∂t = γ ∂ ∂x [xp(x, t)] + kZ x η(q)(cid:20) 1 p(cid:18) x q q 0 + ∆Z 1 0 w(x − x′)p(x′, t)dx′ , t(cid:19) − p(x, t)(cid:21) dq. (B3) Appendix C: Generation time distribution f (τ ) Central to this paper is the steady-state limit of Eq. (B3), −γ d dx [xp(x)] = ∆Z 1 + kZ x 0 0 q(cid:19) − p(x)(cid:21) dq p(cid:18) x η(q)(cid:20) 1 w(x − x′)p(x′)dx′, q (B4) (2). Although time-independent, Eq. i.e., Eq. (B4) describes the stationary protein distribution p(x) in a growing population of dividing cells (i.e., the state of balanced growth), as discussed above. In particular, for hd(x) = ∆/2 ≡ ∆0, from Eq. (B2) it follows that νm = ∆0, (B5) i.e., the population growth rate νm appearing in Eq. (B1) is equal to individual cell division rate ∆0, as should be expected. In order to find the generation time distribution f (τ ), consider Eq. (B3). This is a special case of the differ- ential Chapman-Kolmogorov equation [22] with x- and t-independent coefficients. We assume once again that there is no protein production (k = 0) and that the pro- tein is stable (γ = 0). In such a case, (B3) becomes the Master equation, describing 'jump process' between dif- ferent states of the system (there is no drift term), and these 'jumps' are solely due to the cell division events. The probability that the system does not undergo such a 'jump', and that it is still in the same state at t = τ as it was at t = 0, is equal to exp(−∆τ ) [22]. Therefore, the probability of a jump occurring in the infinitesimal interval (t, t + dt) is given by [34] π(t)dt = ∆ exp(−∆t)dt. (C1) In the case of a single lineage (scenario B mentioned above), we have ∆ = ∆0, and π(t) must be identified with the cell cycle length distribution, π(τ ) = f (τ ). Therefore, we obtain f (τ ) = ∆0 exp(−∆0τ ). (C2) If we deal with the whole proliferating population, then ∆ = 2∆0 (scenario A), and π(t) (C1) reads π(t) = 2∆0 exp(−2∆0t). (C3) π(τ ) (C3) is identical with the quantity defined as C(τ ) ≡ 2e−νmτ f (τ ) = 2∆0 exp(−2∆0τ ), (C4) and called the 'carrier distribution' in [31]. Appendix D: Cell age distribution φ(a) To convince ourselves that (C2) is valid, and to find the explicit form of the age distribution φ(a), assume that f (τ ) = λ exp(−λt), for λ yet unspecified. From Eq. (9) of Ref. [31] it follows that φ(a) is given by φ(a) = 2νme−νm Z ∞ a f (τ )dτ = 2νme−(νm+λ)a. (D1) R ∞ condition The normalization of φ(a) 0 φ(a)da = 1) yields νm = λ, whereas from Eq. (B5) or from (B7) and (B8) we obtain λ = ∆0, i.e., we recover Eq. (C2). Hence, the age distribution φ(a) is given by (i.e., the φ(a) = 2∆0e−2∆0a. (D2) It should be emphasized that functional forms of f (τ ) (C2), C(τ ) (C4) and φ(a) (D2) are rather unrealistic. This is a consequence of a Poissonian nature of cell di- vision in the present model. In particular, both f (τ ) and C(τ ) should be unimodal, and vanishing not only for τ = 0, but also for the values of τ sufficiently close to zero -- there certainly must be a minimal length of generation time. Because the functional forms of f (τ ) (C2) and C(τ ) (C4) are identical, one can treat the results of numeri- cal simulation of a single cell lineage as referring to the whole proliferating population, if only the division rate is rescaled. Namely, for a single call lineage (scenario B) we obtain identical protein number probability dis- tribution as for the whole growing population (scenario A), provided that in the latter case the the true division rate ∆0 = νm ≡ ∆0(A) is two times smaller then in the former, i.e., 2∆0(A) = ∆0(B). Note that the simulation curves shown in Fig. 2 in the main text were generated by simulation of a single cell lin- eage with the cell division rate ∆0(B) (scenario B, see Ap- pendix K). However, the theoretical curves pn(x; ω(n), b) shown in Fig. 2 in the main text can be interpreted in 9 two ways, depending on how we define the ω parameter: ω = k/∆0(A) assumes Scenario A (whole population) and ω = k/∆0(B) = k/(2∆0(A)) assumes Scenario B (single lineage). Therefore, the simulation results shown in Fig. 2 can also be reinterpreted as the results for Scenario A (whole population) where the cell division rate was twice smaller than the value set in the simulation algorithm: ∆0(A) = ∆0(B)/2. The above discussion applies to the batch culture. Analogous formulas can be derived for the continuous cell culture [31], for which, in fact, conditions for state of balanced growth can be more easily reached and main- tained. Appendix E: Noise floor: Overview of other experimental results in the literature A noise floor was observed in a number of experiments reported in the literature, however, these data were not suitable for comparison to our model. Below we overview the existing studies, which we are aware of, and which report the noise floor in gene expression. In Ref. [12], the noise floor in gene expression in E. coli manifested itself as a boomerang-shaped log-log plot of the squared coefficient of variation vs. mean gene ex- pression. However, protein levels were measured in that Reference as concentrations and not absolute molecule numbers, which excluded the effect of protein loss at cell division inherent to our model. The description of the results in Ref. [12] may seem slightly misleading at first glance because the plots in that reference were shown in the units of protein numbers. In fact, the protein flu- orescence was measured in each cell and then its level for that cell was normalized by the volume of that same cell to get the protein concentration. The protein con- centrations were then again normalized by a mean cell volume to obtain the description in the units of molecule numbers. And therefore, the resulting plots in Ref. [12] show the protein numbers corresponding to the content of average-sized cells, but the underlying method of mea- surement intentionally removed the effects of protein loss at cell division from the data. Thus, the results of Ref. [12] should be interpreted using a model that describes protein levels in terms of concentrations. For that reason, the Friedman's model [11] describing protein concentra- tions was used for data fitting in Ref. [12]. Our model cannot be fitted to these data because it describes protein levels in terms of protein numbers and thus it explicitly accounts for protein loss at cell division. In Refs. [28] and [26], a noise floor was observed in gene expression in E. coli. These data were unsuitable for comparison to our model because they were gated to observe the gene expression levels in only those cells that were in similar cell-cycle stages. Thus, the effect of protein loss due to cell division would not be visible in these data. A noise floor was also observed in gated data in S. cerevisiae [25, 29]. 10 For hd(x) = ∆/2 and hp(x) = 1, from (F7), (F8) and (F9) we obtain the tail of the form exp{−x/[b(ω + 1)]}. Note that the the above derivation is not universally valid. For example, for the 'all or none' mode of pro- tein partitioning, i.e., for ηb(q) = [δ(q) + δ(1 − q)] /2, one cannot simply drop out the integral over q in Eq. (1). However, apart from such rather pathological situations, it seems that the derivation of the large-x asymptotic be- haviour of p(x) proposed in Ref. [16] can be generalized to the present case of stochastic protein production, pro- vided the burst size PDF is of the form (F3) and there are is no protein decay. Appendix G: Distribution of protein numbers for the uniform protein partition ratio distribution. In this section we solve Eq. (B4) (Eq. (2) of the main text) for γ = 0, exponential burst size PDF as given by Eq. (F3), and for uniform partition ratio distribution η(q) = Θ(q)Θ (1 − q) = 1, (G1) for 0 < q < 1, where Θ(q) denotes the Heaviside theta function. η(q) (G1) is not very realistic at large x, where any such distribution should be peaked around q = 1/2, like, e.g., the symmetric beta distribution (a continuous counterpart of the binomial distribution), considered in Ref. [15]. η(q) (G1) becomes more acceptable for x of order of few protein molecules. Yet, η(q) (G1) has been used in Refs. [16, 20], probably due to its mathemati- cal simplicity -- it is one of the few examples of a parti- tion ratio PDF, for which analytical solutions of PBE-like equations are known. For γ = 0 and η(q) (G1), Eq. (3) reads Appendix F: Distribution tails The protein number distribution p(x) as given by Eqs. (18) and (19) in the main text, i.e., p(x) = ∞ Xi=0 Ci(ω) b exp(cid:18) −2ix b(ω + 1)(cid:19) , (F1) where Ci(ω) = 2iω (2(1 + ω)−1; 2)i ( 1 2 (1 + ω)−1; 1 2 )∞ (1 + ω)2 (2; 2)i ( 1 2 ; 1 2 )∞ , (F2) has exponential tail of the form exp{−x/[b(ω + 1)]} (the leading exponent in (F1)). The same is true for pu(x) (G6) (see the next section), i.e. the solution of Eq. (B4) for η(q) = Θ(q)Θ (1 − q) = 1 given by Eq. In fact, it can be shown that for most of functional forms of η(q), the solution of Eq. (B4) has exactly the same exponential tail (there are, however, exceptions: for ex- ample, η(q) = 1 2 [δ(q) + δ(1 − q)] yields the tail of the form exp{−x/[b(2ω + 1)]}). (G1). This is a special case of a yet more general result. We assume here that g(x) = 0 and the burst size PDF is exponential, as given by Eq. (10), ν(u) = e−u/b b , L[ν(u)] ≡ ν(s) = 1/(sb + 1), (F3) (1). Following Ref. but we allow for arbitrary x-dependence of hd(x) and hp(x) in Eq. [16], we neglect the q-integral term in the steady-state limit of Eq. (1) (for large protein number x, the contribution of states with still larger x may be neglected) and obtain 0 = −(cid:20)hd(x) +Z ∞ + kZ x 0 0 w(x − x′)p(x′)dx′. hd(ζ)p(ζ)dζ(cid:21) p(x) Next, we combine the derivative of (F4) with respect to x with the original equation and obtain kh′ p(x) + h′ d(x) + hd(x)/b + R/b khp(x) + hd(x) + R p′(x) p(x) = where R = Z ∞ 0 hd(ζ)p(ζ)dζ = νm, (F7) c.f. Eq. (B2). From (F6) it follows that at the tail of the PDF the ratio p(x2)/p(x1) is well approximated by P12 = exp (−I12) , (F8) (F4) 0 = k w(s)G(s) + ∆Z 1 0 [G(qs) − G(s)]dq. (G2) By differentiating (G2) with respect to s and combining such obtained equation with the original one, integrating by parts and using the identity , (F5) (F6) Z 1 0 qG′(qs)dq = 1 s (cid:20)G(s) −Z 1 0 G(qs)dq(cid:21) , (G3) in order to to cancel the terms containing G(qs) (note that G′(qs) ≡ (dG(y)/dy)y=qs), we finally get G′(s) = ω [s w′(s) + w(s)] s[1 − ω w(s)] G(s). (G4) ODE (G4) is equivalent to the integral equation (G2). For ν(s) (F3) we have w(s) = ν(s) − 1 = −sb/(sb + 1) and Eq. (G4) has the following solution: where I12 = Z x2 x1 kh′ p(x) + h′ d(x) + hd(x)/b + R/b khp(x) + hd(x) + R dx. (F9) G(s) = (1 − ǫ) ξǫ (s + ξ)ǫ + ǫ ξǫ+1 (s + ξ)ǫ+1 , (G5) where ǫ = ω/(ω + 1), ξ = 1/[b(ω + 1)]. The inverse Laplace transform of G(s) (G5) reads pu(x) = (1 − ǫ) ξǫxǫ−1e−ξx Γ(ǫ) + ǫ ξǫ+1xǫe−ξx Γ(ǫ + 1) . (G6) Because pu(x) (G6) is a statistical mixture of two broad gamma distributions (note that 0 < ǫ < 1), pu(x) itself is broad (c2 v ≥ 1/2). For the case of deterministic protein production, in- stead of pu(x) (G6) we obtain a gamma distribution [16, 20], cf. next Section. Appendix H: Distribution of protein numbers for the deterministic protein production and half-by-half protein partitioning We consider here the case of unregulated, deterministic protein production, i.e., in Eq. (1) we put k = 0 and g(x) = σ > 0. For hd(x) = ∆/2, in the steady-state limit instead of Eq. (B4) (Eq. (2)) we obtain λ d dx [p(x)] = Z 1 0 η(q)(cid:20) 1 q p(cid:18) x q(cid:19) − p(x)(cid:21) dq, (H1) where λ = σ/∆. Laplace transform of Eq. (H1) yields λsG(s) = Z 1 0 η(q) [G(qs) − G(s)] dq, (H2) and we have assumed p(0+) ≡ limx→0+ p(x) = 0 (validity of this assumption is checked a posteriori). For the half- by-half protein partitioning, η(q) = δ(q − 1 2 ), Eq. (H2) can be rewritten as G(s) = (1 + λs) −1 G(cid:16) s 2(cid:17) . (H3) Eq. (H3) can be solved by iteration; we obtain G(s) = ∞ Yi=0 1 1 + 2−iλs = 1 (−λs; 1 2 )∞ = ∞ Xr=0 where (a; q)k is a q-Pochhammer Symbol. have used the following identity 1 (z; q)∞ = ∞ Xn=0 zn (q; q)n , (−λs)r ( 1 2 ; 1 2 )r , (H4) In (H4) we (H5) which is a special case of the q-binomial theorem [24]. Note that G(s) (H4) can be also rewritten as G(s) = ∞ Xr=0 (−2λs)r [r] 1 2 ! = e 1 2 (−2λs), (H6) where [r]q! ≡ (1 − q)−r(q; q)r denotes the q-factorial and eq(x) is the q-exponential function. 11 0.5 0.5 0.4 0.4 ) ) λ λ ; ; x x ( ( p p 0.3 0.3 , , ) ) λ λ ; ; x x ( ( γ γ p p 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.1 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 2 3 3 4 4 x x 5 5 6 6 7 7 8 8 FIG. 3: Protein number PDFs of our model in case of deter- ministic protein production. p(x; λ) (H7) (red) is a solution of Eq. (H2) for η(q) = δ(q − 1/2) (9), whereas the gamma distribution pγ(x; λ) = λ−2x exp(−x/λ) (H11) (green) is a so- lution of Eq. (H2) for η(q) = Θ(q)Θ (1 − q) (G1); both are plotted here for λ = 1, i.e., as a function of the rescaled vari- able x/λ. Both distributions have the same average value, hxi = µ1 = 2λ, and identical exponential tails ∼ exp(−x/λ) but seemingly different shapes. The variance of p(x; λ), equal 3 λ2, is smaller than the variance of pγ(x; λ), equal to 2λ2. to 4 In contrast to pγ (x; λ), the maximum of p(x; λ) cannot be for λ = 1 we have xm ≈ 1.2773 and found analytically; p(xm) ≈ 0.4549. Note that, for both p(x; λ) and pγ(x; λ), the squared coefficient of variation is constant (does not depend on λ, i.e., on the mean protein number), and is equal to its minimal value for the corresponding solution with stochastic protein production. The inverse Laplace transform of (H4) reads p(x; λ) = 1 λ ∞ Xi=0 Di exp(cid:18)− 2ix λ (cid:19) , (H7) where the coefficients Di are given by Di = i Yj=1 2 1 − 2j ∞ Yl=1 2l 2l − 1 = 2i (2; 2)i 1 2 ; 1 ( 1 2 )∞ . (H8) For i = 0, we obtain the leading-order term, i.e., the slowest-decaying exponent, e−x/λ, which determines the behaviour of p(x; λ) (H7) at the x → ∞ limit. Note that p(x; λ) (H7) can be regarded as a counterpart of the probability distribution given by (F1) and (F2) (Eqs. (14) and (15) in the main text) in the case of determin- istic protein production. From G(s) (H4) we obtain both the moments (µr) and the cumulants (κr) of L−1[G(s)] ≡ p(x; λ) (H7), namely µr = λrr! 2 ; 1 ( 1 2 )r = 2rλrr! ! [r] 1 2 , κr = 2rλr(r − 1)! 2r − 1 . (H9) (H10) In the present case, µr can be also easily obtained from moments equations. For a uniform distribution of protein division ratio (G1), the solution of Eq. (H1) reads [16] pγ(x; λ) = λ−2xe−x/λ. (H11) The gamma distribution pγ(x; λ) (H11) is therefore a de- terministic counterpart of pu(x) (G6). Both p(x; λ) (H7) and pγ(x; λ) (H11) define a one- parameter family of probability distributions; we have p(x, λ) = λ−1f(x/λ), where f (z) = p(z, 1) is a func- tion of the rescaled variable x/λ. Also, both p(x; λ) and pγ(x; λ) are right-skewed, unimodal, and vanish in the x → 0+ limit, as has been assumed for p(x; λ), cf. Fig 3. However, in contrast to the gamma distribution, for p(x; λ) we have p(k)(0; λ) = 0 for arbitrary k, hence p(x; λ) is not analytic at x = 0. In consequence, the Tay- lor expansion of p(x; λ) at x0 = 0 does not exists. This can be shown using properties of G(s) (H4). We have p(0) = lim s→∞ p′(0) = lim s→∞ p′′(0) = lim s→∞ . . . sG(s) = 0, s [sG(s) − p(0)] = 0, s(cid:2)s2G(s) − sp(0) − p′(0)(cid:3) = 0, (H12) etc., due to the obvious relation lim s→∞ skG(s) = 0, (H13) valid for any k < ∞. 12 n=2 n=3 n=4 ; (n) ; FIG. 4: Gamma distributions pγ (x; α, β) (I2) are almost indis- tinguishable from the pn(x; ω(n), b) distributions of our model as given by Eq. (I1), when fitted by matching their maxima. Red lines: pn(x; ω(n), b) with b = 5 and n = 2, 3, 4. Green lines: The corresponding pγ(x; α, β) (I2), whose parameter values are given in Table I. The coordinates xmax,pn and ymax,pn of the maximum of pn(x; ω(n), b) can be found analytically for small values of n (in our case, the Maple software was able to find them explicitly for n ≤ 5). Otherwise, they can be calcu- lated numerically. In Fig. 4, we put b = 5 and n = 2, 3, 4 (corresponding to ω = 3, 7, 15) in pn(x; ω(n), b). By nu- merically solving the equations Appendix I: Similarity of gamma distributions and the distributions resulting from our model xmax,pn = xmax,pγ , ymax,pn = ymax,pγ , (I4) In this section we present an alternative method of fit- ting of gamma distributions to the distributions resulting from our model: We match the maxima of our distribu- tion, n 1 b x (I1) pn(x; ω(n), b) = 2lb(cid:17) , An,l exp(cid:16)− i=1(2i − 1)Qn−l where An,l = (−1)n−l2 j=1(2j − 1)] (c.f. Eqs. (20) and (21) of the main text) and of the gamma distribution pγ(x; α, β), c.f. Eq. (12) of the main text, i.e.: Xl=1 2 /[Ql−1 l(l−3) pγ(x; α, β) ≡ xα−1 exp (−x/β) βαΓ(α) . (I2) The coordinates of the gamma distribution's maximum for α > 1 are given by: xmax,pγ = β α − β, ymax,pγ = [(α − 1) β]α−1 exp(1 − α) βαΓ (α) . (I3) we found the α and β parameters of the gamma dis- tributions whose maxima exactly match the maxima of pn(x; ω(n), b). Fig. 4 shows that this way of fitting yields the gamma distribution plots that are even more similar to pn(x; ω(n), b) than those obtained by matching the first two moments of the distributions, as in the main text, Fig 2. n ω α β/b 2 3 1.90 3.07 3 7 2.52 5.28 4 15 2.88 9.74 TABLE I: Parameters of the distributions pn(x; ω(n), b) and pγ(x; α, β) shown in Fig. 4. Appendix J: A property of the distribution pn(x) We denote the Laplace transform of pn(x) (I1) as Gn(s). From Eq. (12) of the main text, it follows that Gn(s) = One can show that (cid:0)s + b 4(cid:1) . . .(cid:0)s + b 2n(cid:1) bn 2 2− n(n+1) 2(cid:1)(cid:0)s + b s Gn+1(s) = b 2n+1 [Gn(s) − Gn+1(s)] . Assuming pn+1(0) = 0 for n > 0, it follows from Eq. (J2) that . (J1) (J2) (J3) (J4) d dx pn+1(x) = b 2n+1 [pn(x) − pn+1(x)] . (J4) iteratively for n ≥ 1 to ob- We can solve Eq. tain the formulas for consecutive pn+1(x), starting from p1(x) = (b/2) exp(−bx/2) and using (J3) as the bound- ary condition. From Eq. (J4) it follows that pn+1(x) has a maximum in the point where its plot intersects with the plot of pn(x). Appendix K: Simulation The simulation results shown in Fig. 2 in the main text were obtained using a custom extension of the StochPy package [30]: The standard simulation using the direct Gillespie algorithm was supplemented with cell division. Histograms were calculated along a single trajectory, which mimics the observation of a single cell lineage. The initial part of the trajectory was cut off to obtain only the steady-state behavior. The reaction kinetics (see the file NonRegulatedGeneCellDivision.psc) was given by: 13 where O denotes the gene promoter, M is mRNA, and P is protein. k is transcription rate and kp is transla- tion rate. kdm denotes mRNA degradation rate and its value is chosen such that mRNA life time is much shorter than the mean cell cycle duration 1/∆0(B), consistently with the assumption of the analytical model described in the main text. Additionally, cell division occurs at the rate ∆0(B): The custom function multiple_division() draws a random cell cycle length T from a specified dis- tribution (here: exponential with the mean 1/∆0(B)). In a given cell cycle, the simulation runs until the cell age T and at that time point the molecule numbers M and P are divided by 2. If the remainder of the divi- sion is 1, then the remaining molecule goes to the "ob- served" daughter cell with probability 1/2. The simula- tion for the next cell cycle is initialized with the result- ing molecule numbers M and P for the daughter cell. Simulation parameter values are shown in Table II and III. The simulation code, containing the custom func- tions that implement cell division can be found in the file NonRegulatedGeneCellDivision.ipynb (Jupyter note- book file, Supplemental Material) [38]. ∆0(B) kp kdm max_simulation_time time_cutoff 1 250 50 20000 2000 TABLE II: Simulation parameter values for Fig. 2 in the main text. These values were the same in all simulations. n 1 1 k 2 3 3 7 4 15 O k−−→ O + M kp−−→ M + P M kdm−−→ ∅ M (K1) TABLE III: Simulation parameter values for Fig. 2 in the main text. These values correspond to the specific curves in Fig. 2. [1] M. Hintsche and S. Klumpp, Journal of Biological Engi- 11 (2016). neering 7, 22 (2013). [2] S. Klumpp and T. Hwa, Current Opinion in Biotechnol- ogy 28, 96 (2014). [6] D. Huh and J. Paulsson, Nature Genetics 43, 95 (2011). [7] D. Huh and J. Paulsson, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 108, 15004 (2011). [3] L. Keren, D. Van Dijk, S. Weingarten-Gabbay, D. Davidi, G. Jona, A. Weinberger, R. Milo, and E. Segal, Genome Research 25, 1893 (2015). [8] R. Marathe, V. Bierbaum, D. Gomez, and S. Klumpp, Journal of Statistical Physics 148, 608 (2012). [9] J. Paulsson, Physics of Life Reviews 2, 157 (2005). [4] V. Shahrezaei and S. Marguerat, Current Opinion in Mi- [10] L. Cai, N. Friedman, and X. S. Xie, Nature 440, 358 crobiology 25, 127 (2015). (2006). [5] N. Walker, P. Nghe, and S. J. Tans, BMC Biology 14, [11] N. Friedman, L. Cai, and X. S. Xie, Physical Review 14 Letters 97, 168302 (2006). 441, 840 (2006). [12] Y. Taniguchi, P. J. Choi, G.-W. Li, H. Chen, M. Babu, and X. S. Xie, Science 329, 533 J. Hearn, A. Emili, (2010). [13] M. R. Maurizi, Experientia 48, 178 (1992). [14] N. V. Mantzaris, Computers & Chemical Engineering 29, 897 (2005). [15] N. V. Mantzaris, Journal of Theoretical Biology 241, 690 (2006). [16] T. Friedlander and N. Brenner, Physical Review Letters 101, 018104 (2008). [26] L. Wolf, O. K. Silander, and E. van Nimwegen, eLife 4, 1 (2015). [27] D. Volfson, J. Marciniak, W. J. Blake, N. Ostroff, L. S. Tsimring, and J. Hasty, Nature 439, 861 (2006). [28] O. K. Silander, N. Nikolic, A. Zaslaver, A. Bren, I. Kikoin, U. Alon, and M. Ackermann, PLoS Genet- ics 8, e1002443 (2012). [29] A. Bar-Even, J. Paulsson, N. Maheshri, M. Carmi, E. O'Shea, Y. Pilpel, and N. Barkai, Nature Genetics 38, 636 (2006). [17] J. Yu, J. Xiao, X. Ren, K. Lao, and X. S. Xie, Science [30] T. R. Maarleveld, B. G. Olivier, and F. J. Bruggeman, 311, 1600 (2006). PloS one 8, e79345 (2013). [18] V. Shahrezaei and P. S. Swain, Proceedings of the Na- tional Academy of Sciences 105, 17256 (2008). [19] J. Jedrak and A. Ochab-Marcinek, Physical Review E [31] E. Powell, Microbiology 15, 492 (1956). [32] J. Jędrak and A. Ochab-Marcinek, (2018). [33] C. Jia, P. Xie, M. Chen, and M. Q. Zhang, Scientific 94, 032401 (2016). Reports 7, 16037 (2017). [20] N. Brenner and Y. Shokef, Physical Review Letters 99, [34] N. van Kampen, Stochastic Processes in Physics and 138102 (2007). [21] N. Nordholt, J. van Heerden, R. Kort, and F. J. Brugge- man, Scientific Reports 7, 6299 (2017). [22] C. Gardiner, Stochastic methods (Springer Berlin, 2009). [23] F. Jafarpour, C. S. Wright, H. Gudjonson, J. Riebling, E. Dawson, K. Lo, A. Fiebig, S. Crosson, A. R. Dinner, and S. Iyer-Biswas, Physical Review X 8, 021007 (2018). [24] G. E. Andrews, q-Series: Their development and applica- tion in analysis, number theory, combinatorics, physics, and computer algebra, Vol. 66 (American Mathematical Society, 1986). [25] J. R. Newman, S. Ghaemmaghami, J. Ihmels, D. K. Bres- low, M. Noble, J. L. DeRisi, and J. S. Weissman, Nature Chemistry (Elsevier Science, Amsterdam, 2007). [35] In this section we use notation of Ref. [31], but the cell age is denoted a and not a to avoid confusion with quantity a = k/γ defined in the main text. [36] We assume that the number of cells in the population, N (t), is sufficiently large its fluctuations may be ne- glected, and that N (t) may be regarded as evolving ac- cording to deterministic equation (B1). [37] In such a case the only possible steady state is a trivial one, i.e., limt→∞ p(x, t) = p(x) = δ(x). [38] See Supplemental Material at [URL will be inserted by publisher] for the simulation code.
1704.07407	1	1704	2017-04-24T18:38:12	Exploring A Multi-Scale Method for Molecular Simulations in Continuum Solvent Model: Explicit Simulation of Continuum Solvent As An Incompressible Fluid	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.chem-ph", "physics.comp-ph" ]	A multi-scale framework was recently proposed for more realistic molecular dynamics simulations in continuum solvent models by coupling a molecular mechanics treatment of solute with a fluid mechanics treatment of solvent, where we formulated the physical model and developed a numerical fluid dynamics integrator. In this study, we incorporated the fluid dynamics integrator with the Amber simulation engine to conduct atomistic simulations of biomolecules. At this stage of the development, only nonelectrostatic interactions, i.e., van del Waals and hydrophobic interactions are included in the multi-scale model. Nevertheless numerical challenges exist in accurately interpolating the highly nonlinear van del Waals term when solving the finite-difference fluid dynamics equations. We were able to bypass the challenge rigorously by merging the van del Waals potential and pressure together when solving the fluid dynamics equations and by considering its contribution in the free-boundary condition analytically. The multi-scale simulation engine was first validated by reproducing the solute-solvent interface of a single atom with analytical solution. Next, we performed the relaxation simulation of a restrained symmetrical monomer and observed a symmetrical solvent interface at equilibrium with detailed surface features resembling those found on the solvent excluded surface. Four typical small molecular complexes were then tested, both volume and force balancing analysis showing that these simple complexes can reach equilibrium within the simulation time window. Finally, we studied the quality of the multi-scale solute-solvent interfaces for the four tested dimer complexes and found they agree well with the boundaries as sampled in the explicit water simulations.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Exploring A Multi-Scale Method for Molecular Simulations in Continuum Solvent Model: Explicit Simulation of Continuum Solvent As An Incompressible Fluid Li Xiao1,2 and Ray Luo1,2,3 1. Departments of Biomedical Engineering, 2. Molecular Biology and Biochemistry, and 3. Chemical Engineering and Materials Science, University of California, Irvine, CA 92697 A multi-scale framework was recently proposed for more realistic molecular dynamics simulations in continuum solvent models by coupling a molecular mechanics treatment of solute with a fluid mechanics treatment of solvent, where we formulated the physical model and developed a numerical fluid dynamics integrator. In this study, we incorporated the fluid dynamics integrator with the Amber simulation engine to conduct atomistic simulations of biomolecules. At this stage of the development, only nonelectrostatic interactions, i.e., van del Waals and hydrophobic interactions are included in the multi-scale model. Nevertheless numerical challenges exist in accurately interpolating the highly nonlinear van del Waals term when solving the finite-difference fluid dynamics equations. We were able to bypass the challenge rigorously by merging the van del Waals potential and pressure together when solving the fluid dynamics equations and by considering its contribution in the free-boundary condition analytically. The multi-scale simulation engine was first validated by reproducing the solute- solvent interface of a single atom with analytical solution. Next, we performed the relaxation simulation of a restrained symmetrical monomer and observed a symmetrical solvent interface at equilibrium with detailed surface features resembling those found on the solvent excluded surface. Four typical small molecular complexes were then tested, both volume and force balancing analysis showing that these simple complexes can reach equilibrium within the simulation time window. Finally, we studied the quality of the multi-scale solute-solvent interfaces for the four tested dimer complexes and found they agree well with the boundaries as sampled in the explicit water simulations. Please send correspondence to: [email protected] 1 1. Introduction Atomistic simulation has become an important tool for studying the structures, dynamics, and functions of biomolecular systems. Nevertheless efficient atomistic simulation of large and complex biomolecular systems is still one of the remaining challenges in computational molecular biology. The computational challenges in atomistic simulation of biomolecular systems are direct consequences of their high dimensionalities. Indeed biomolecules are highly complex molecular machines with thousands to millions of atoms. What further complicates the picture is the need to realistically treat the interactions between biomolecules and their surrounding water molecules that are ubiquitous and paramount important for their structures, dynamics, and functions. To appreciate these challenges, it is instructive to highlight the two bottlenecks in biomolecular simulations: (1) the cost of each energy evaluation that is determined by the number of particles in a mathematical model; and (2) the number of time steps of dynamics that it takes for sufficient coverage of different conformations. Hundreds of millions of time steps are routinely required in biomolecular simulations to draw statistically significant conclusions. It is often the case that more particles need more time steps for sufficient coverage. Thus the overall simulation cost usually scale exponentially with the number of particles in the mathematical model used in a simulation. Indeed many fundamental and interesting biomolecular processes remain largely inaccessible to atomistic simulations when system sizes exceed more than a few hundred residues. Since most particles in biomolecular simulations are to represent water molecules solvating the target biomolecules, an implicit treatment of water molecules allows greatly increased simulation efficiency. Indeed, implicit solvation offers a unique opportunity for more 2 efficient simulations without the loss of atomic-level resolution for biomolecules [1-17]. Advance in implicit solvation, coupled with developments in sampling algorithms, classical force fields, and quantum approximations, will prove useful to the larger biomedical community in a broad range of studies of biomolecular structures, dynamics and functions. One class of implicit solvent models, the classical Poisson-Boltzmann (PB) solvent model, has become widely accepted in biomolecular applications after over 30 years of basic research and development. Efficient numerical PBE-based solvent models have been widely used to study biological processes including predicting pKa values [18-21], computing solvation and binding free energies [22-31], and protein folding [32-42]. However, challenges remain to achieve more consistent, accurate, and robust analysis of biomolecules [43-60]. The existing dielectric model based on molecular solvent excluded surface is a major hurdle for applications of the Poisson-Boltzmann solvent models. This dielectric model is ad-hoc, expensive, and numerically unstable due to its treatment of atoms as hard spheres in molecular simulations. In our previous study [61], we explored a multi-scale simulation strategy to explicitly simulate the continuum solvent/solute interface with the solvent fluid dynamics that is coupled to the solute molecular dynamics. This strategy (1) allows a self-consistent treatment of the solvation interactions, i.e. the dielectric interface automatically adjusts to local conformational and energetic fluctuations and is guaranteed to be at the system free energy minimum upon equilibrium; (2) allows a "soft" and more physical dielectric interface for stable dynamics; (3) eliminates atom-specific cavity radii that must be defined, dramatically reducing the freely adjustable parameters of the continuum solvent treatment; (4) eliminates the expensive molecular surface reconstruction step during dynamics; and (5) eliminates the difficult and expensive molecular surface-to-atom mapping of dielectric boundary forces and hydrophobic boundary 3 forces, and applies these surface forces to the continuum solvent instead. In addition, a 3D numerical algorithm was developed to simulate the implicit solvent via the Navier-Stokes equation [61, 62]. It should be pointed out that the use of Navier-Stokes equation, instead of Stokes equation that is sufficient for biomolecular processes of interest, is necessary for the lack of a predefined solute-solvent interface, or in a "free boundary" problem [61, 62]. Our numerical algorithm was validated with multiple model test cases, demonstrating its effectiveness and numerical stability, with observed accuracy consistent with the designed numerical algorithm. In this study, we intended to explore the feasibility of incorporating the fluid dynamics algorithm into the Amber molecular mechanics simulation engine [63-65] to assess the feasibility and quality of the new multi-scale model for potential applications to biomolecular simulations. At the current stage, we are mainly interested in equilibrium properties of the biomolecular solute, and solvent hydrodynamics is not our consideration. Thus certain alterations of the original model can be utilized to artificially accelerate the solvent relaxation process so that the precious computing resources can be focused on sampling of solute conformations. 2. Theoretical Model In the following we first review our physical model for easy understanding of the overall approach. Next we briefly go over the fluid dynamics algorithm and procedure with a focus on what has been revised from our previous study to adapt the method to atomistic molecular simulations. Finally computational details are presented for the numerical tests of specific molecular systems. 2.1 Physical model Our basic model is derived from the Hamiltonian equation. A Hamiltonian for the entire system is thus defined first. Its degrees of freedom are atomic positions (x ) and their velocities (v ) for 4 the solute molecular dynamics (MD) region; and fluid element displacements ( y ) and their velocities (u) for the solvent fluid dynamics (FD) region. For the MD region, all-atom molecular mechanics will be used. Molecular mechanics usually adopts a relatively simple potential energy function, or force field, for efficient computation. Many potential energy functions have been developed for biomolecular applications, such as Amber [66-71], CHARMM [72-74] and OPLS (1) [75-77]. For FD region, an incompressible viscous fluid model is adopted. The Hamiltonian is defined as H = H MD(x,αx) + H FD(y,αy) + H MD/FD(x,αx;y,αy), where αx is the momentum of MD region and αy is the momentum of FD region. H MD is the Hamiltonian of for the MD region modeled by molecular mechanics H MD =U + K , where U is the force field potential energy and K is the kinetic energy. H FD represents the Hamiltonian for the incompressible solvent fluid. HMD/FD =Uele +Uvdw +Uhse , consists of three terms. Uele is the Poisson-Boltzmann electrostatic solvation energy [78-81]. The nonelectrostatic solvation energy is modeled as two components: the van del Waals component Uvdw and the hard sphere entropy/cavity component Uhse [82-86]. Here Uele is defined as ⎞ D⋅E − ΔΠλ ⎠⎟ 1 8π Uele = ρfϕ− ⎛ ∫ ⎝⎜ ∑ (e−qiϕ/kT −1) ΔΠ = kT ci i dv (2) and Uvdw and Uhse are defined as ρaw(raw) Ns∑ ∫a=1 Uvdw = Uhse =γ i SAS + c uLJ(raw)draw (3) 5 Here the sum is over all solute atoms ( Ns ), and the integration is over the solvent-occupied volume. ρaw(raw) is a solvent distribution function around solute 'a' at a given solute-solvent distance. uLJ(r) = A r12 − B r6 is the force field Lennard Jones potential given the coefficient A, B for each atom. γ is the surface tension and c is an offset constant. Now we proceed to derive the dynamics equation by first setting β= (x,y) as the position vector of the system and α= (αx,αy) as the momentum vector of the system. The familiar Newtonian dynamics can be derived from the Hamilton's equation . . α = − ∂H ∂β (4) (5) Here we have adopted the convention that α and β represent the moment and position vectors of each particle/element, respectively. In the molecule dynamics region, the equation of motion for an atom at position vector x can be expressed symbolically as . αx = − ∂H MD ∂x − ∂H MD/FD ∂x . − ∂H MD ∂x represents the usual force field terms in molecule dynamics simulations. The coupling Hamiltonian has three terms, Uele +Uvdw +Uhse . Since Uhse does not depend on atomic positions, the coupling force terms that the atoms feel are only those of electrostatics and van del Waals in nature, i.e., − ∂H MD/FD ∂x ∂x . It is interesting to note that the electrostatic forces − ∂Uele ∂x are simply the qE forces, where q's are the "free" charges, i.e. atomic point charges in a = − ∂Uele ∂x − ∂Uvdw 6 . u. (6) (7) force field model [87]. − ∂Uvdw ∂x modeled as continuum [84] . are the van del Waals forces from the solvent molecules In the fluid dynamics region, consider a small fluid volume element at position y, with volume V and velocity u. The equation of motion of the fluid element is = − ∂H FD ∂y − ∂H MD/FD ∂y i αy As shown below, the variational principle will be applied on this element. The partial derivative can also be written in the variational form as = −δH FD δy . αy u − δH MD/FD δy Here the subscript u denotes that it is fixed during the variation. Notice here y = y(b,t) is the Lagrangian coordinate of the volume element, which is fixed on the fluid element and b is introduced here to denote the actual spatial position [88]. Let us first focus on the variation of H FD , which has the form of H FD = 1 2 ρu2 +Uint(ρ,s) ∫ ⎡ ⎣⎢ ⎤ ⎦⎥dV , (8) where Uint is the internal energy density, ρ represents the fluid density, and s is entropy. For a small fluid volume element at position y and volume V , we impose a variation δy on the element within time dt , and proceed to compute the variation of H FD . The process is assumed δy dt  0 . Since the fluid is incompressible, ∇ iδy = 0 , the work done to the to be very rapid, i.e., environment is dW = pδy i dS ∫ = ∇ i(pδy) ∫ ∫ dV = ∇p iδy dV + p∇ iδy dV = ∇p iδy dV, (9) ∫ ∫ 7 where p is pressure and vector dS denotes the surface element of the element with the direction along the normal direction of the surface. Given that the first and second laws of thermodynamics still hold, the internal energy variation can be expressed as = (Tδs) ∫ The entropy constraint also gives δUint dV ∫ dV − dW = (Tδs) dV − ∇p iδy dV. (10) ∫ ∫ ∫ (Tδs)dV = fvis iδydV ∫ , (11) where q is the heat flux and fvis is the viscous force density. Substitution of eqn (11) into eqn (10) and the fact that the term involving dt can be ignored as δy given the variation of the − dt ∇ iqdV ∫ dt  0 internal energy as δUint dV ∫ = (fvis iδy) ∫ ∫ dV − ∇p iδy dV = (f iδy) dV, (12) ∫ where the total force density f = fvis − ∇p = ∂σij ∂yj is introduced and ⎛ σij = −pδij + µ ⎝⎜ ∂(u⋅yi) ∂yj + ∂(u⋅yj) ∂yi ⎞ ⎠⎟ is the stress tensor and µ is the fluid viscosity constant [89]. of the fluid [89]. Given the assumption that the force density is uniform within the volume element, substitution of eqn (8) and eqn (12) into the variation of H FD gives −δH FD δy u = − ∫ δUint dV δy = −fV = − ∂σij ∂yj V. (13) The variation of HMD/FD is presented next. In Poisson-Boltzmann systems with mobile ions, there is an ionic force term at the Stern layer [87], but it is usually much smaller than other force terms, and is often ignored. If it were not ignored, the ionic force would act upon relevant volume elements. Uhse only depends on the interface boundary so that it does not change under 8 the variation of the volume element. Thus the only significant derivative of HMD/FD is the van del Waals force, which can be treated as the "external force" density (F ) on the fluid element, i.e. −δH MD/FD δy u = −δUvdw δy = FV. (14) Finally, the change of momentum of the fluid volume element is d(ρVu) dt = i αy = ρV ∂u ∂t + ρV ∂u ∂ai ∑ i ∂ai ∂t = ρV ∂u ∂t + ρV(u i ∇)u. (15) Combination of eqns (6) and (13) –(15) gives ρV ∂u ⇒ ρ∂u ∂t + ρV(u i ∇)u = ∂t + ρ(u i ∇)u = ∂σij ∂yj ∂σij ∂yj V + FV + F. (16) Including the conservation of volume/mass for the given volume element, i.e. ∇ iu = 0 , the incompressible Navier-Stokes equation can be expressed as ρ ∂u ⎛ ⎝⎜ ∂t +(u⋅∇)u ⎞ ⎠⎟ = −∇p + µΔu + F ∇⋅u = 0 . (17) 2.2 Derivation of interface conditions To obtain the interface conditions, an infinitely small fluid disk element ε is introduced with small area A and thickness h, and with h  A. The disk surfaces are parallel to the boundary interface and one side of the surface is in the molecule dynamics region. Given a variation of the disk position with δrε , (18) . = −δH FD δrε − δH FD/MD δrε i αε On the left-hand side 9 dt . = ρAh du i αε (19) On the right-hand side, we first introduce the local coordinate system, which consists of one normal direction (n) and two tangential directions (t,τ) at a certain point on the interface, i.e., n = cosα1i + cosα2j+ cosα3k t = cosβ1i + cosβ2j+ cosβ3k τ= cosγ1i + cosγ2j+ cosγ3k . ⎧ ⎪ ⎨ ⎪ ⎩ (20) only exerts on the disk surface in the fluid region, so that Stress −δHFD δrε =σij inA = (− p + 2µ∂u − δHFD δrε ⎡ ⎢ ⎣ ∂nin)n + µ(∂(u⋅n) ∂t + ∂(u⋅t) ∂n )t + µ(∂(u⋅n) ∂τ + ∂(u⋅τ) ∂n ⎤ ⎥ A. (21) )τ ⎦ The last term of eqn (18) can be worked out as = −δUele δrε −δHMD/FD δrε 2σpol DiiDo 1 Don where − ∂Uele ∂rε term − ∂Uhse ∂rε = fdielecA = nA is the dielectric boundary electrostatic force [87]. The = −γκnA is the pressure and surface tension from the hard sphere entropy, aka the − δUhse δrε − δUvdw δrε , (22) hydrophobic term [84], where κ is the curvature. The van del Waals force, δUvdw δrε [84], proportional to the volume of element Ah , can be ignored when comparing to the electrostatic forces and surface tension as h is infinitely small. Combining eqns (18) and (19) and the terms calculated above, the interface conditions can be summarized as 10 −p + pg −γκ+ fdielec + 2µ∂u ∂n in = 0 + ∂(u⋅t) ∂n = 0 + ∂(u⋅τ) = 0, ∂n ∂t ∂(u⋅n) ∂τ ∂(u⋅n) on ∂Ω (23) 3. Numerical Algorithms We explored to implement the multi-scale model in numerical simulations with a strategy similar to those of the classical Car-Parrinello molecular dynamics (CPMD) model [90], which can be regarded as a multi-scale model via coupling equations of motion for ions and electrons in two different mechanics. In CPMD electrons are treated as active degree of freedom, via fictitious dynamics variable, and the fictitious electron dynamics is coupled with ionic dynamics in the Berendsen heat bath to approach the Born-Oppenheimer surface. The CPMD model results in a conservative ionic dynamics that is extremely close to the Born-Oppenheimer surface. Our approach is to couple equations of motion for solute atoms and continuum solvent. The solvent part is also treated by the fictitious dynamics variable, and since our model is based on a finite-difference method, it is the fluid element. The fictitious fluid dynamics is modeled by the incompressible Navier-Stokes (NS) equation. The fictitious fluid dynamics model is coupled with all-atom molecular dynamics model in the Berendsen heat bath to approach the surface provided by all-atom MD simulations at a preset temperature. In doing so, the changes to the existing molecular mechanics simulation engine can be kept at the minimal and there is a very clear boundary between the FD and MD simulation routines, facilitating the development of the new model into a viable simulation engine for future biomolecular applications. 11 3.1 FD time integration Our previous work has addressed the mathematical issues in solving fluid dynamics equations numerically [61, 62]. After setting the water density to unity, the velocity can be solved by the second-order semi-implicit backward Euler method as where 3uk+1 − 4uk + uk−1 2Δt + u⋅∇u ( )k+1 = −∇pk+1 + µΔuk+1 + Fk+1,outside 3uk+1 − 4uk + uk−1 2Δt = µΔuk+1,inside pk+1 = 2pk − pk−1 )k+1 = 2 u⋅∇u ( u⋅∇u ( )k − u⋅∇u ( )k−1. The pressure is solved by: Δpk+1 = −∇ i((uk+1 i ∇)uk+1) + ∇ iFk+1. (24) (25) (26) A new issue facing the application of the FD model to molecular simulation is the presence of van der Waals force ( F ), which has a large gradient nearby the interface because it is too close to the solute atom centers. The large gradient is almost always challenging to address with a finite-difference type of method. In this study, we overcome the issue by introducing a variable p' , where ∇ ′p = µΔu without computing the numerical gradient of the van der Waals potential. Specifically given p'(k+1) = pk+1 + Γk+1 , the equivalent form of eqn (26) to be solved numerically ′p = p + Γ with ∇Γ = −F obtained analytically. Therefore, we can solve (27) as Δp'(k+1) = −∇ i((uk+1 i ∇)uk+1) Accordingly, eqn (24) is updated as 12 3uk+1 − 4uk + uk−1 2Δt + u⋅∇u ( )k+1 = −∇p'(k+1) + µΔuk+1,outside 3uk+1 − 4uk + uk−1 2Δt = µΔuk+1,inside p'(k+1) = 2p'(k) − p'(k−1) where p'(k+1) is taken as Finally the interface boundary condition eqn (23) becomes −p' + Γ + pg −γκ+ fdielec + 2µ∂u ∂nin = 0 + ∂(u⋅t) ∂n = 0 + ∂(u⋅τ) = 0, ∂n ∂t ∂(u⋅n) ∂τ ∂(u⋅n) (28) (29) (30) At each time step, the p' is interpolated with the one-side least square fitting method.[91] Γ is computed analytically for each interface point where the interface boundary condition eqn (30) is enforced. When doing so, we can completely avoid finite-difference operations involving van del Waals energy and forces. As presented in our previous works, the remaining major mathematical challenge in solving these coupled partial differential equations is the presence of the free boundary condition eqn (23) that allows the solute-solvent interface to equilibrate according to our physical model. To enforce the free boundary condition when solving pressure or velocity, we utilized the jump conditions of un and pn as the augmented variables, respectively [61, 62, 92]. The considerations of augmented variables lead to extra correction terms on the right-hand side in eqns (24) and (26). After the correction, each velocity component solver is equivalent to a Helmholtz equation. Once the velocity is updated, the pressure solver is simplified to a Poisson equation. In this 13 implementation, we utilized the MICCG numerical solver to solve these linear differential equations [93-96]. When solving the linear systems, the fluid domain is contained in a rectangular box, the conditions at the outer boundary of the rectangular R are u x=xmin = 0, u x=xmax = 0 ∂u = 0 ∂y y=ymin u z=zmin = 0, u z=zmax = 0 = 0, ∂u ∂y y=ymax on ∂R , (31) p = 0, which represents a pipe flow in the y direction. The use of the boundary condition allows the mass conservation law to be preserved since the incompressible solvent fluid can go in and out of the simulation box freely. 3.2 FD/MD interface update Once the fluid velocity field is known, the next step is to use it to update the solute/solvent interface. The equivalent step in the solute region is to update particle positions based on particle velocities. Numerically we use the level set method based on the finite-difference method [97- 99]. In the level set method, a scalar function, i.e. the level set function, is used to represent the moving interface implicitly. The interface is located where the level set function is zero (d=0), i.e. the zero level set Γ(t) = {y : d(y,t) = 0}. Suppose that Γ(t) moves according to velocity v: ), where v is known after the fluid dynamics equations are solved. Given the ∂Γ(t) / ∂t = v Γ(t) interface velocity, if we want the level set function (d) to satisfy Γ(t) = {y : d(y,t) = 0} after updating, we can impose the following equation upon d(y,t) [97-99] ( ∂d ∂t + v ⋅∇d = 0 (32) 14 with the initial condition Γ(0) = {y : d(y,0) = 0}, i.e. the level set function initially set for the initial configuration in our case. Here the level set function was initially set as a signed distance function to the solvent accessible surface with a specified solvent probe. 3.3 Overview of the FD/MD numerical procedure In our system, the atomic details for the solute region are preserved, and the solvent region is modeled as in 3.1. To simulate the solute particle dynamics, a standard MD engine with the leapfrog time integrator [100] coupled to a heat bath is used. The temperature coupling is realized with the Berendsen thermostat, which has been widely used in molecular simulation community [101]. Once the heat bath is specificed, the procedure of the FD/MD can be summarized into the following steps: 1. Input and initialize system parameters for solute atoms such as temperature, number of particles, time step, etc. Initialize initial positions and velocities of all solute atoms; 2. Initialize FD simulation box and grid points. Initialize velocity and pressure of fluid elements; 3. Compute energy and forces from the potential function of solute atoms; 4. Compute van del Waals forces and pressure between solute atoms and fluid atoms; 5. Use the particle MD engine to update new velocities and positions of solute atoms; 6. Use the FD engine to update new velocities and pressures of fluid elements; 7. Update new FD/MD interface; 15 8. Repeat steps 3-7. Dynamics variables, such as position, velocity, pressure, and level set function, are periodically stored after step 7 as requested. These can be used as input to restart the FD/MD simulation as needed. 4. Other Computational Details For the FD simulations, physical parameters of water are set as those at 300K with viscosity µ= 8.51×10−4Pa ⋅s, density ρ=1.00 ×103kg/m3, tension and hydrophobic surface γ = 8.94 ×10−2 kcal/mol⋅A2 , with the later optimized for biomolecules given the SAS molecular surface definition in a previous work for the Amber force fields [84]. The water probe was set as 1.0 Å to set up the initial SAS surface. In the FD simulation programs, both water viscosity and density are often set as 1.0 in the internal unit. Thus proper interface between FD and MD simulation portions of our model require careful unit conversion. The details in deriving these conversion factors are given in Appendix, and the actual conversion factors are listed in Table I. Variable Time (t) Density (ρ) Energy (E) MD Unit 1 ps 1 kg 1 kcal/mol FD Unit 85.1 1.00 ×1027 9.60 ×10−2 Table I. Conversion factors between FD and MD engines. The FD/MD multi-scale simulation engine was developed in a revised Amber 16 release [63-65]. The Amber ff14 force field is used to generate the topology files and the TIP3P water model is used to model the water molecules. All atomic charges were set to be zero to focus on the nonelectrostatic interactions in this study. The simulations were conducted with bonds involving hydrogen constrained. Time step was set to be 0.002 ps for both fluid dynamics region and molecule dynamics region. The temperature coupling constant is 0.2 ps in the Berendsen's 16 thermostat to couple the temperature of the MD region, which is set to be 5 K to study the relaxation of the solute-solvent interface in this study. Since the goal of the current development is to evaluate how well the MD/FD method reproduce the solvent interface, the MD region are restrained to focus on the FD simulation. Given that the external forces on the FD region are only van der Waals force and hydrophobic force, and they should be balanced each other at equilibrium. To speed up the relaxation, we explored both artificially increase the external force terms (by a factor of 10) or decrease the viscosity terms (by a factor of 10) to accelerate the relaxation towards equilibrium. It was found that the low viscosity runs did not relax as fast as the high force runs (data not shown). Nevertheless all alternatives will be further explored in a future study. A single ion (Na+), a single molecule n-methyl amine (NMA), and four typical small molecular complexes, adenine-thymine (AT), guanine-cytosine (GC), arginine-aspartic acid (RD) and lysine-aspartic acid (KD) were chosen to analyze the solute-solvent surface produced by the FD/MD method. In this stage of our development, the electrostatic interactions were turned off so only van der Waals and hydrophobic interactions of the solute molecules were considered though water molecules were not alternated. As a benchmark to evaluate the quality of the new multi-scale model, we conducted all-atom molecular mechanics simulations for the four tested dimer complexes to sample the solvent interface with explicit TIP3P water molecules. In these simulations, all molecules first underwent a 10,000-step energy minimization starting with a 5,000-step steepest descent followed by a 5,000-step conjugate gradient minimization. Then all solute atoms were restrained with a harmonic force constant of 50 kcal/mol-Å in all subsequent heating, equilibration, and production simulations. The molecular dynamics simulations were first heat up from 0K to 300K in 20 ps. This was then followed with a 10 ns simulation at the 17 constant temperature of 300K and the constant pressure of 1 bar with the Berendsen heat and pressure baths. The water molecules sampled in the last 5 ns was used to analyze the solute- solvent surfaces. 5. Results and Discussion 5.1 Single atom relaxation: Reproduction of analytical solution We first validated the FD/MD engine with a simple system with analytical solution: the solute- solvent interface of a single atom, given that the balance of hydrophobic force and van del Waals force would lead to a final equilibrium surface, a sphere with radius of r0 . The equilibrium can be analytically solved once the solvation free energy of the system is given as G = ρ +∞ A ⎛ ∫ r12 − ⎝⎜ r0 A ⎛ = 4πρ 9r9 − ⎝⎜ B ⎞ ⎠⎟ 4πr2 dr r6 B ⎞ 3r3 +γr2 ⎠⎟ +γ4πr2 (33) Starting from a given initial state, it is expected that the system converge to its free energy minimum if there is no energy barrier, which is the case here. In this test, an Amber sodium ion solvated in TIP3P water was used as an illustration. With the specified surface tension and van der Waals parameters from Amber 14 force field, the r4 + 2γr) (34) B gradient of the free energy can be expressed as A r10 + ∂G ∂r = 4πρ(− of A = 4127 kcal/mol⋅A12, the values and Given γ = 8.94 ×10−2 kcal/mol⋅A2, the numerical solution shows that there is only one root for ∂G ∂r = 0 when r is positive, which gives the radius of the sphere to be 2.45 Å. It is also clear that B = 3.570 kcal/mol⋅A6, 18 ∂r < 0 when r approaches 0+ and ∂G ∂G ∂r > 0 when r approaches infinity. Given that 1) the gradient changes from negative to positive as r changes from 0+ to +∞, and 2) there is only one root for the gradient, it can be concluded that the gradient is negative when r < 2.45 Å, and positive when r > 2.45 Å. Thus free energy G is monotonically decreasing when r < 2.45 Å, and monotonically increasing when r > 2.45 Å. This analysis shows that there is no energy barrier in the physically allowed range of r. Therefore it is possible to use a simple steepest descent minimization or a low- temperature MD relaxation to reach the global minimum in the solvation free energy. Figure I plots the evolution of volume versus time for the tested low-temperature relaxation run. It is apparent that the volume of the solute-solvent interface quickly converges to a constant volume, consistent with our analysis above. The numerical volume agrees with the analytical solution with an error of ~0.3%. Note also that the equilibrium volume is a spherical sphere for the single ion as expected. 19 Figure I. (1) Time evolution of volume (Å3) in the restrained FD/MD simulation of sodium ion. (2) Spherical contour of solute-solvent interface when reaching the equilibrium. 5.2 Monomer relaxation: Symmetric interface Next, we performed the low-temperature relaxation of NMA, a mirror-symmetrical monomer. As shown in Figure II, the volume reaches the equilibrium value within 500 steps (1.0 ps). The contour plot shows the symmetrical monomer possesses a symmetrical interface at equilibrium. VMD visualization in 3D indicates that a detailed surface contour similar to that of the solvent excluded surface can be found (see supplementary materials). 20 Figure II. (1) Time evolution of volume (Å3) in the restrained FD/MD simulation of NMA. (2) SES-like solute-solvent interface is observed when reaching the equilibrium. 5.3 Dimer relaxation Four typical small molecular complexes, adenine-thymine (AT), guanine-cytosine (GC), arginine-aspartic acid (RD) and lysine-aspartic acid (KD) were tested to evaluate the performance of the FD/MD simulation method. As shown in Figure III, the solute volumes reach the equilibrium values within 500 steps (1.0 ps) for all four dimers. Figure IV presents the time evolutions of force balancing on the solute-solvent interface. It is clear that the numerical solvent pressure and viscosity pressure decrease significantly and approach zero as time goes on. On the other hand, the hydrophobic (surface tension) pressure and the analytical van der Waals pressure become the dominant components, reaching steady values while balancing each other out. This is another evidence that the system approach equilibrium. Apparently the balance between hydrophobic and van der Waals components is not perfect, due to the presence of residual fluid flow nearby the solute. This issue will be addressed in our future refinement of the numerical algorithm to be discussed below. 21 AT GC RD KD Figure III. Time evolutions of volume (Å3) in the restrained FD/MD simulations of dimers: adenine-thymine (AT), guanine-cytosine (GC), arginine-aspartic acid (RD) and lysine-aspartic acid (KD). 22 AT GC RD KD Figure IV. Time evolutions of average absolute pressure components on the solute-solvent interface: adenine-thymine (AT), guanine-cytosine (GC), arginine-aspartic acid (RD) and lysine- aspartic acid (KD). (a) Numerical solvent pressure; (b) Hydrophobic pressure; (c) Viscosity pressure; (d) Analytical van der Waals pressure. 5.4 Comparison with explicit solvent simulations Finally, a key issue in the current development of the FD/MD model is to see whether the model at least qualitatively agrees with explicit solvent MD simulations. Discrepancy is possible given that no optimization has been attempted. Therefore, it is interesting to analyze the solute-solvent interfaces as sampled by both the FD/MD model and the explicit solvent MD model. 23 This analysis was conducted in the following manner. The water molecules in explicit solvent MD simulations were sampled every 5 ps over the course of a 5 ns production run for each tested dimer with all solute atoms restrained in the initial position. A total of 1000 snapshots were collected for visualization. To facilitate visualization, water molecules beyond 3.0 Å distance from any solute atom were discarded. The water distribution maps were used as references to assess the solute-solvent surface sampled by the FD/MD simulation method. Figure V shows the distribution of water oxygen atoms and the FD/MD surface when viewed outside of the solute-solvent surface, and Figure VI shows the distribution and surface when viewed inside of the solute-solvent surface. Overall, the FD/MD surfaces match very well with the solute- solvent boundaries as sampled in the explicit MD simulations for all four tested complexes. Note too there are a few places of discrepancies, which indicate that the parameters used in the FD/MD model needs to be optimized. VMD visualization in 3D further illustrates the agreement presented here (see supplementary materials). 24 Figure V. FD/MD surfaces (white wireframe) and water molecules from explicit MD simulations (yellow dots) of four tested dimers: adenine-thymine (AT), guanine-cytosine (GC), arginine-aspartic acid (RD) and lysine-aspartic acid (KD). Here viewer stands outside of the surfaces. 25 Figure VI. FD/MD surfaces (white wireframe) and water molecules from explicit MD simulations (yellow dots) of four tested dimers: adenine-thymine (AT), guanine-cytosine (GC), arginine-aspartic acid (RD) and lysine-aspartic acid (KD). Here viewer stands inside of the surfaces. 5.5 Limitations of the model and future directions There are clearly limitations in the proposed FD/MD model. The first limitation is that we artificially make both hydrophobic and van der Waals term 10 times higher to accelerate the solute-solvent interface relaxation because the focus of the current model is for equilibrium properties of the solute, but not the physically correct solvation relaxation process, which may be 26 important if the FD/MD model is applied to study hydrodynamic properties due to the presence of the molecular solute. Nevertheless, the artificial setting does not affect the converged solute- solvent interface because both hydrophobic and van der Waals pressure are simultaneously increased. Secondly, the finite-difference grid spacing used in the FD engine is 0.5 Å, which is widely used in biomolecular applications of a finite-difference method given a high enough resolution of molecular surface topology can be achieved. However, the relatively fine grid also leads to highly inefficient numerical procedure. To date we have not paid special attention to the numerical efficiency of our FD engine, and this will be a focus in our future development. The development and illustrations here mainly show that the FD/MD model is sound and it does produce physically meaningful observations consistent with the all-atom MD model, which is very promising. As we pointed out in Other Computational Details the FD parameters for the water solvation process was from a previous study to optimize a related nonpolar solvent model. Apparently this is not optimal for the current FD/MD model. Our next step will be to investigate how to optimize the hydrophobic term and van der Waals term to best reproduce the all-atom explicit solvent MD model. In addition, we will also incorporate the electrostatic interaction as modeled by the Poisson-Boltzmann method to build a more realistic FD/MD model for biomolecular applications. To study fluid dynamic properties due to the presence of molecular solutes, we think the best strategy is to incorporate a coarse-grained molecular model instead of the all-atom model to make it a viable approach for systems with interesting hydrodynamic properties. 6. Conclusions 27 A multi-scale framework was recently proposed for more realistic molecular dynamics simulations in continuum solvent models by coupling a molecular mechanics treatment of solute with a fluid mechanics treatment of solvent [61]. Our previous work addressed the mathematical issues in solving fluid dynamics equations numerically [61, 62]. In this study we incorporated the fluid dynamics algorithm with the Amber molecular mechanics package [63-65] to conduct atomistic simulations of biomolecules. A major issue in the application of the multi-scale model in atomistic simulations is the presence of van del Waals potential, which has a large gradient nearby the solute-solvent interface. It is virtually impossible to treat van der Waals potentials with any reasonably fine finite-difference method. We overcame the challenge by removing the van del Waals potential from pressure when solving the finite-difference fluid dynamics equations, and adding back the van del Waals potential analytically in the free-boundary condition. We first validated the FD/MD engine with a simple system with analytical solution: the solute-solvent interface of a single atom. The balance of hydrophobic force and van del Waals force would lead to the final equilibrium surface of a sphere. Our test shows that the volume of the solute-solvent interface quickly converges to the analytical value with an error ~0.3%. Next, we performed the relaxation of NMA, a mirror-symmetrical monomer. The contour plot shows the symmetrical monomer possesses a symmetrical interface at equilibration. VMD visualization in 3D indicates that a detailed surface contour similar to that of the solvent excluded surface can be found. Four typical small molecular complexes were then tested to evaluate the performance of the FD/MD simulation method. The solute volumes reach the equilibrium values within 1.0 ps for all four dimers. The time evolutions of force balancing analysis on the solute-solvent interface show that the numerical solvent pressure and viscosity pressure decrease significantly 28 and approach zero as simulation time goes on. On the other hand, the hydrophobic (surface tension) pressure and the analytical van der Waals pressure become the dominant components, reaching steady values while balancing each other out. This strongly indicates that the systems approach the equilibrium at the end of the simulations. Finally, a key issue at the current stage of the development is to investigate whether the model at least qualitatively agrees with explicit solvent MD simulations. Therefore, it is interesting to analyze the solute-solvent interfaces as sampled by both the FD/MD model and the explicit solvent MD model. Comparisons show that the FD/MD surfaces agree very well with the solute-solvent boundaries as sampled in the explicit MD simulations for all four tested dimers. Note too a few places of discrepancies do exist, which indicate that the parameters used in the FD/MD model needs to be optimized further to achieve higher consistency with the all-atom explicit solvent MD model. In our next phase of the development, we will further improve the quality of hydrophobic and van der Waals terms of the FD model to best reproduce all-atom force field model. It is also interesting to investigate the effect of incorporating the electrostatic forces into the FD/MD model to evaluate its impact on both numerical stability and consistency for a range of model systems. Finally it is also interesting to explore more efficient and more robust numerical FD engines for routine applications to biomolecular systems. Supplementary Materials Supplementary materials are available online for the 3D visualization in VMD for monomer NMA, and the four molecular dimer complexes: adenine-thymine (AT), guanine-cytosine (GC), arginine-aspartic acid (RD) and lysine-aspartic acid (KD). Acknowledgements 29 This work was supported in part by NIH/NIGMS (GM093040 & GM079383). Appendix Since FD programs can use any arbitrary length unit, we set 1 internal length unit as 1 Ångstrom. Given the length unit settled and the water density (ρ=1.00 ×103kg/m3 ) set as 1 internal density unit, the internal mass unit can be computed to be equivalent to 1.00 ×10−27kg. Next we can utilize viscosity to compute the time conversion factor. Given the unit of viscosity Pa ⋅s=kg/(m ⋅s) we can use the mass conversion factor to derive the time conversion factor as follows 1 internal viscosity unit = 8.509 ×10−4kg/(m is) = 8.509 ×10−4 ×1.00 ×1027 /(1010 ×T) A.1 This leads to T = 8.51×1013, which means 1 s = 8.51×1013 internal time unit. And thus we have 1 ps =10−12s = 85.1 internal time unit. The energy unit of 1 kcal/mol can be converted as 1 kcal/mol = 6.948 ×10−21 J = 6.948 ×10−21 kg m2/s2 = 6.948 ×10−21 ×1027 ×(1010)2 /(8.509 ×1013)2internal energy unit = 9.60 ×10−2 internal energy unit A.2 References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] M. E. Davis, and J. A. Mccammon, Chem Rev 90 (1990). B. Honig, K. Sharp, and A. S. Yang, J. Phys. Chem. 97 (1993). B. Honig, and A. Nicholls, Science 268 (1995). D. Beglov, and B. Roux, Journal of Chemical Physics 104 (1996). C. J. Cramer, and D. G. Truhlar, Chem Rev 99 (1999). D. Bashford, and D. A. Case, Annual Review Of Physical Chemistry 51 (2000). N. A. Baker, Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 15 (2005). J. H. Chen, W. P. Im, and C. L. Brooks, Journal of the American Chemical Society 128 (2006). 30 [9] M. Feig, J. Chocholousova, and S. Tanizaki, Theoretical Chemistry Accounts 116 (2006). [10] P. Koehl, Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 16 (2006). [11] W. Im, J. H. Chen, and C. L. Brooks, Peptide Solvation and H-Bonds 72 (2006). [12] B. Z. Lu et al., Communications in Computational Physics 3 (2008). [13] J. Wang et al., Communications in Computational Physics 3 (2008). [14] M. D. Altman et al., Journal of Computational Chemistry 30 (2009). [15] Q. Cai et al., in Annual Reports in Computational Chemistry, edited by A. W. Ralph (Elsevier, 2012), pp. 149. [16] L. Xiao, C. Wang, and R. Luo, Journal of Theoretical and Computational Chemistry 13 (2014). [17] W. M. Botello-Smith, Q. Cai, and R. Luo, Journal of Theoretical and Computational Chemistry 13 (2014). [18] [19] R. E. Georgescu, E. G. Alexov, and M. R. Gunner, Biophysical Journal 83 (2002). J. E. Nielsen, and J. A. McCammon, Protein Sci 12 (2003). [20] J. Warwicker, Protein Sci 13 (2004). [21] C. L. Tang et al., J. Mol. Biol. 366 (2007). [22] [23] J. M. J. Swanson, R. H. Henchman, and J. A. McCammon, Biophysical Journal 86 (2004). C. Bertonati, B. Honig, and E. Alexov, Biophysical Journal 92 (2007). [24] A. R. Brice, and B. N. Dominy, Journal of Computational Chemistry 32 (2011). [25] [26] R. Luo et al., Biophysical Journal 80 (2001). L. David et al., Journal of Physical Chemistry B 103 (1999). [27] D. Shivakumar, Y. Q. Deng, and B. Roux, J Chem Theory Comput 5 (2009). [28] A. Nicholls et al., Journal of Medicinal Chemistry 51 (2008). [29] T. P. Korman et al., Biochemistry 47 (2008). [30] R. Luo et al., Biophysical Chemistry 78 (1999). [31] K. L. Mardis, R. Luo, and M. K. Gilson, J. Mol. Biol. 309 (2001). [32] S. A. Marshall, C. L. Vizcarra, and S. L. Mayo, Protein Sci 14 (2005). [33] M. J. Hsieh, and R. Luo, Proteins-Structure Function and Bioinformatics 56 (2004). 31 [34] E. Z. Wen, and R. Luo, Journal of Chemical Physics 121 (2004). [35] [36] E. Z. Wen et al., Journal of Molecular Graphics & Modelling 22 (2004). T. Z. Lwin, and R. Luo, Journal of Chemical Physics 123, 194904 (2005). [37] T. Z. Lwin, R. H. Zhou, and R. Luo, Journal of Chemical Physics 124, 034902 (2006). [38] T. Z. Lwin, and R. Luo, Protein Science 15 (2006). [39] Y.-H. Tan, and R. Luo, Journal of Physical Chemistry B 112 (2008). [40] Y. Tan, and R. Luo, BMC Biophysics 2 (2009). [41] Q. Lu, Y.-H. Tan, and R. Luo, Journal of Physical Chemistry B 111 (2007). [42] [43] J. Wang et al., Biophysical Journal 95 (2008). J. Warwicker, and H. C. Watson, J Mol Biol 157 (1982). [44] D. Bashford, and M. Karplus, Biochemistry 29 (1990). [45] A. Jeancharles et al., Journal of the American Chemical Society 113 (1991). [46] M. K. Gilson, Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 5 (1995). [47] S. R. Edinger et al., J Phys Chem B 101 (1997). [48] C. Tan, L. Yang, and R. Luo, Journal of Physical Chemistry B 110 (2006). [49] Q. Cai et al., Journal of Chemical Physics 130, 145101 (2009). [50] J. Wang et al., Chemical Physics Letters 468 (2009). [51] X. Ye et al., Biophysical Journal 97 (2009). [52] X. Ye, J. Wang, and R. Luo, Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 6 (2010). [53] R. Luo, J. Moult, and M. K. Gilson, Journal of Physical Chemistry B 101 (1997). [54] J. Wang et al., Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 12 (2010). [55] M. J. Hsieh, and R. Luo, Journal of Molecular Modeling 17 (2011). [56] Q. Cai et al., Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 7 (2011). [57] J. Wang et al., Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 8 (2012). [58] X. Liu et al., Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics (2013). [59] C. Wang et al., Computational and Theoretical Chemistry 1024 (2013). 32 [60] L. Xiao et al., The Journal of Chemical Physics 139 (2013). [61] [62] L. Xiao et al., Chem Phys Lett 616-617 (2014). Z. L. Li et al., Journal of Computational Physics 297 (2015). [63] D. A. Case et al., (University of California, San Francisco, 2016). [64] D. A. Case et al., (University of California, San Francisco, 2016). [65] D. A. Case et al., Journal of Computational Chemistry 26 (2005). [66] P. K. Weiner, and P. A. Kollman, Journal of Computational Chemistry 2 (1981). [67] S. J. Weiner et al., Journal of the American Chemical Society 106 (1984). [68] W. D. Cornell et al., Journal of the American Chemical Society 117 (1995). [69] J. M. Wang, P. Cieplak, and P. A. Kollman, Journal of Computational Chemistry 21 (2000). [70] Y. Duan et al., Journal of Computational Chemistry 24 (2003). [71] [72] L. J. Yang et al., Journal of Physical Chemistry B 110 (2006). B. R. Brooks et al., Journal of Computational Chemistry 4 (1983). [73] A. D. MacKerell et al., J Phys Chem B 102 (1998). [74] N. Foloppe, and A. D. J. MacKerell, J. Comp. Chem. 21 (2000). [75] W. L. Jorgensen, and J. Tiradorives, Journal of the American Chemical Society 110 (1988). [76] W. L. Jorgensen, D. S. Maxwell, and J. TiradoRives, Journal of the American Chemical Society 118 (1996). [77] G. A. Kaminski et al., J Phys Chem B 105 (2001). [78] E. S. Reiner, and C. J. Radke, J Chem Soc Faraday T 86 (1990). [79] K. A. Sharp, and B. Honig, J. Phys. Chem. 94 (1990). [80] [81] L. Xiao et al., Journal of Chemical Physics 139 (2013). L. Xiao, C. H. Wang, and R. Luo, J Theor Comput Chem 13 (2014). [82] D. Chandler, Nature 437 (2005). [83] J. Dzubiella, J. M. J. Swanson, and J. A. McCammon, Phys Rev Lett 96 (2006). [84] [85] C. Tan, Y. H. Tan, and R. Luo, J Phys Chem B 111 (2007). L. T. Cheng et al., Journal of Chemical Physics 127 (2007). 33 [86] P. W. Bates et al., J Math Biol 59 (2009). [87] L. Xiao et al., The Journal of chemical physics 139 (2013). [88] B. D.Jones, (Submitted 2014). J. D. W. Alexander L.Fetter, Theoretical Mechanics of Particles and Continua (Dover [89] Publications Inc., Mineola, New York, 2003). [90] [91] R. Car, and M. Parrinello, Phys Rev Lett 55 (1985). J. Wang et al., Chemical Physics Letters 468 (2009). [92] Z. L. Li et al., Comput Fluids 39 (2010). [93] J. Wang, and R. Luo, Journal of Computational Chemistry 31 (2010). [94] Q. Cai et al., Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 6 (2010). [95] R. Luo, L. David, and M. K. Gilson, Journal of Computational Chemistry 23 (2002). [96] Q. Lu, and R. Luo, Journal of Chemical Physics 119 (2003). [97] S. Osher, and J. Sethian, Journal of Computational Physics 79 (1988). J. A. Sethian, Level set methods and fast marching methods (Cambridge University Press, [98] Cambridge, 1999). S. Osher, and R. Fedkiw, Level Set Methods and Dynamic Implicit Surfaces (Springer, Berlin, [99] 2002). [100] R. W. H. J. W. EastWood, Computer Simulations using Particles (McGraw-Hill, 1981). [101] H. J. C. a. V. G. Berendsen, W.F., (1984). 34
1601.02770	1	1601	2016-01-12T08:54:51	Inversion of hematocrit partition at microfluidic bifurcations	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "physics.flu-dyn" ]	Partitioning of red blood cells (RBCs) at the level of bifurcations in the microcirculatory system affects many physiological functions yet it remains poorly understood. We address this problem by using T-shaped microfluidic bifurcations as a model. Our computer simulations and in vitro experiments reveal that the hematocrit ($\phi_0$) partition depends strongly on RBC deformability, as long as $\phi_0 <20$% (within the normal range in microcirculation), and can even lead to complete deprivation of RBCs in a child branch. Furthermore, we discover a deviation from the Zweifach-Fung effect which states that the child branch with lower flow rate recruits less RBCs than the higher flow rate child branch. At small enough $\phi_0$, we get the inverse scenario, and the hematocrit in the lower flow rate child branch is even higher than in the parent vessel. We explain this result by an intricate up-stream RBC organization and we highlight the extreme dependence of RBC transport on geometrical and cell mechanical properties. These parameters can lead to unexpected behaviors with consequences on the microcirculatory function and oxygen delivery in healthy and pathological conditions.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Inversion of hematocrit partition at microfluidic bifurcations Zaiyi Shen,1 Gwennou Coupier,1 Badr Kaoui,2,3 Benoıt Polack,4,5 Jens Harting,6,7 Chaouqi Misbah,1 Thomas Podgorski1∗ January 13, 2016 affiliations: 1 Laboratoire Interdisciplinaire de Physique (LIPhy) UMR5588 CNRS-Universit´e Grenoble Alpes, Grenoble F-38041, France ; 2 CNRS-Sorbonne University, Universit´e de Technologie de Compi`egne, UMR7338 Biomechanics and Bioengineering, 60203 Compi`egne, France; 3 TP1, University of Bayreuth, D-95447 Bayreuth, Germany; 4 Laboratoire d’H´ematologie, CHU, Grenoble, France; 5TIMC-IMAG/TheREx, CNRS UMR5525, Universit´e Grenoble Alpes, Grenoble, France; 6 Department of Applied Physics, Eindhoven University of Tech- nology, P.O. Box 513, 5600MB Eindhoven, The Netherlands; 7 Faculty of Science and Tech- nology, Mesa+ Institute, University of Twente, 7500 AE Enschede, The Netherlands abbreviated title: Inversion of hematocrit partition corresponding author: Thomas Podgorski, e-mail: [email protected] Abstract Partitioning of red blood cells (RBCs) at the level of bifurcations in the microcirculatory system affects many physiological functions yet it remains poorly understood. We address this problem by using T-shaped microfluidic bifurcations as a model. Our computer simulations and in vitro experiments reveal that the hematocrit (φ0) partition depends strongly on RBC de- formability, as long as φ0 < 20% (within the normal range in microcirculation), and can even lead to complete deprivation of RBCs in a child branch. Furthermore, we discover a deviation from the Zweifach-Fung effect which states that the child branch with lower flow rate recruits less RBCs than the higher flow rate child branch. At small enough φ0, we get the inverse sce- nario, and the hematocrit in the lower flow rate child branch is even higher than in the parent vessel. We explain this result by an intricate up-stream RBC organization and we highlight the extreme dependence of RBC transport on geometrical and cell mechanical properties. These parameters can lead to unexpected behaviors with consequences on the microcirculatory func- tion and oxygen delivery in healthy and pathological conditions. keywords: microcirculation; blood; red blood cell; microfluidics; lattice Boltzmann method 1 1 Introduction Blood flows through a complex network of the circulatory system – from large arteries to very tiny capillaries – in order to ensure oxygen delivery and to remove metabolic waste. This task is mainly carried out by red blood cells (RBCs) that are remarkably deformable, in healthy conditions, and therefore able to squeeze into tiny capillaries. A change in rheological and flow properties of the blood is often associated with hematological diseases or disorders (Fedosov et al., 2011) (e.g. sickle-cell anemia, malaria, polycythemia vera). Understanding blood flow and its dependence on the mechanical properties of its constituents may improve and lead to new applications in biomed- ical technology, for example in blood substitutes development and transfusion techniques. A major open problem in blood circulation is to understand the perfusion in the vasculature networks, especially in the microvasculature where RBCs accomplish their vital functions. For example, an improper hematocrit distribution is observed in heart microcirculation with conse- quences such as occlusion zones (within many patients with apparently healthy coronary arteries). These abnormal traffic zones cause a lack of oxygen supply to tissues that leads to cardiac is- chemic disease (Cokkinos et al., 2006). The precise origin of this dysfunction is still a matter of debate. The principal mechanism that dictates blood heterogeneity in the microvascular networks is the hematocrit partition at the level of bifurcations. RBCs do not behave as passive tracers. Their shape flexibility and dynamics have a decisive role because their size is comparable to that of blood capillaries. A well known phenomenon in microcirculation is the Zweifach-Fung effect (Dellimore et al., 1983; Fenton et al., 1985; Guibert et al., 2010; Pries et al., 1989): If we consider a bifurcation (as in Figure 1), the child branch with the lower flow rate is depleted in RBCs as compared to the parent vessel, while the other, higher flow rate child branch is enriched. That is, if in the parent vessel the total volumetric flow rate is Q0 and the RBC volumetric flux is N0, and in the child branch with the lower flow rate this flow rate is Q1 and the RBC flux N1, then N1/N0 < Q1/Q0. When the flow rate is sufficiently small, the hematocrit in the child branch can even drop down to zero, while it reaches high values in the other branch. Obviously, this phenomenon has physio- logical consequences as it alters the transport of oxygen and other essential metabolites, and may even trigger pathological disorders (e.g. occlusions in high hematocrit regions where the viscosity is higher and cell adhesion is favored). Previous studies have investigated the impact of the confinement (Barber et al., 2008; Chien et al., 1985; Doyeux et al., 2011; Fenton et al., 1985), the bifurcation geometry (Audet and Ol- bricht, 1987; Hyakutake and Nagai, 2015; Roberts and Olbricht, 2003, 2006; Woolfenden and Blyth, 2011), the hematocrit (Ditchfield and Olbricht, 1996; Fenton et al., 1985; Roberts and Ol- bricht, 2003; Yin et al., 2013), and the RBCs deformability (Barber et al., 2008; Li et al., 2012; Xiong and Zhang, 2012; Yin et al., 2013) and aggregation (Sherwood et al., 2012; Yin et al., 2013). Most of these parameters influence RBCs distribution in the feeding flow, which is believed to dic- tates the partition at the bifurcation (Doyeux et al., 2011; Fenton et al., 1985; Li et al., 2012; Yin et al., 2013). The Zweifach-Fung effect results from the existence of a cell free layer (CFL) close to the walls, which is only occupied by plasma. The feeding flow is divided by a separating stream- line into two parts, one feeding the low flow rate branch and the other feeding the high flow rate branch. Due to the CFL, the RBC fraction entering the low flow rate branch is smaller compared to the original RBC fraction in the total feeding flow. The depletion in the low flow rate branch is accompanied by enrichment in the high flow rate branch. In addition to the CFL as the main cause of the Zweifach-Fung effect, it has been argued that there is a relatively small counteracting 2 Figure 1: Snapshots of the RBCs partition, in both experiments and simulations, when the hema- tocrit of the feeding flow is around φ0 =10%. The length ratio between the two child branches is set to 3. A, B: Low viscosity contrast (experiments with λ =0.85 and simulation with λ =1). C, D: High viscosity contrast (experiments with λ =10.3 and simulation with λ =10). effect where cells entering the bifurcation tend to be displaced towards the low flow rate branch compared to fluid streamlines (a fact that slightly reduces the Zweifach-Fung effect) (Barber et al., 2008; Doyeux et al., 2011; Li et al., 2012; Ollila et al., 2013), but this question is still debated (Hyakutake and Nagai, 2015; Xiong and Zhang, 2012). The existence of a CFL is a consequence of the lateral migration of RBCs towards the vessel center. This migration is a result of the wall-induced lift force due to hydrodynamic interactions (Callens et al., 2008; Cantat and Misbah, 1999; Grandchamp et al., 2013), that depends on the nature of RBC dynamics (like tank-treading or tumbling (Abkarian et al., 2007; Dupire et al., 2012)). The final distribution of RBCs in a confined straight vessel is not only due to the lift force, but it is also influenced by other factors: (i) The curved velocity profile of the Poiseuille flow (Coupier et al., 2008; Farutin and Misbah, 2014; Katanov et al., 2015; Shi et al., 2012), and (ii) The cell-cell hydrodynamic interactions (Grandchamp et al., 2013; Hariprasad and Secomb, 2014; Katanov et al., 2015; Kruger et al., 2014; McWhirter et al., 2009). In the present work, we study the hematocrit partition at bifurcations using two-dimensional lattice Boltzmann simulations, whose outcomes are validated and supported by microfluidic exper- iments. We show that RBCs deformability strongly impacts partition as long as the hematocrit is below 20% (within the normal range in microcirculation). RBC deformability is governed by sev- eral parameters such as membrane stiffness (shear, dilatation and bending elastic moduli), swelling degree, membrane viscosity and the viscosity contrast between the hemoglobin and the suspend- 3 ϕ0=10%ALowviscositycontrastHighviscositycontrastϕ1CDBLowviscositycontrastHighviscositycontrastL1L2InletOutletExperiment, λ=0.85 Experiment, λ=10.3 Simulation, λ=1Simulation, λ=10ing fluid. Here we choose to tune the deformability through the latter parameter, the viscosity contrast, that controls the RBC dynamics (tank-treading, tumbling or swinging) then all the mi- gration mechanisms at the origin of the CFL. On the other hand, and more importantly, this study reveals that hematocrit partition can be completely reversed, that is the low flow rate child branch can be enriched in RBCs compared to the parent vessel. This newly reported effect is an outcome of a subtle RBCs structuration in the microcirculatory system. This highlights the importance of the notion of RBCs spatio-temporal organization as the main non-negligible ingredient to further understand blood perfusion in the microvasculature. 2 Materials and methods Design of the microfluidic bifurcations In both simulations and experiments, we use T-shaped bifurcations such as shown in Fig.1: A parent channel divides into two child branches with the same width, but with different lengths L1 and L2 (L1 > L2). The ratio of the flow rates in branches 1 and 2 is then given by Q1/Q2 = (η2L2)/(η1L1), where η1 and η2 are the apparent viscosities of the suspension in branches 1 and 2, respectively. For dilute suspensions, where the viscosity is close to that of the suspending fluid, we simply have Q1/Q2 = L2/L1. In simulations, we set the width of the channels to W = 20µm and we vary L1/L2 from 1.43 to 3. In experiments, we have L1/L2 = 3, W = 20µm and the height of the channel h is 8 µm. The length of the parent vessel was chosen as long as possible to allow for the development of a stationary distribution of RBCs across the channel in the feeding flow (5 mm in experiments and 1.5 mm in simulations). Microfluidic channels were produced by standard soft lithography techniques, with molded PDMS bonded to glass. The RBC suspensions were perfused by a syringe pump (KDS Legato 180) and imaging was performed by a video camera (Imaging Source DMK 31AF03) mounted on an inverted microscope with motorized stage (Olympus IX71) and a blue filter (434± 25 nm) corresponding to an absorption peak of hemoglobin. Blood preparation Blood samples were provided by the Etablissement Franc¸ais du Sang (EFS Rhone-Alpes) from healthy donors. RBCs were isolated by centrifugation after being washed twice in phosphate buffer saline (PBS) supplemented by 0.1 % bovine serum albumin (BSA). To prevent sedimentation of RBCs in channels, the RBCs were re-suspended in density matching PBS and BSA solutions in a mixture of water and iodixanol (Optiprep from Axis-Shield). This iso-dense solution was used either alone (1.94 mPa.s at 20 ◦C) or after adding 5% dextran of molecular weight 2×106 (viscosity 23.4 mPa.s at 20 ◦C). The viscosity of the internal hemoglobin solution of healthy RBCs is around 20 mPa.s at 20 ◦C (Kelemen et al., 2001). This provides two values of the viscosity contrast λ , namely 10.3 and 0.85. The first value corresponds to the blood at 20 ◦C, while the physiological value at body temperature is around 5-6 (Cokelet and Meiselman, 1968). Note that we chose to vary the viscosity contrast λ as one way to tune deformability, and there- fore the dynamics of lift and hydrodynamic interactions of cells. Stiffening cells using diamide or glutaraldehyde was another possibility. However, from the experimental viewpoint, working with hardened cells at high volume fractions in such a confined environment is quite difficult due to jam- 4 ming. It would have been nearly impossible to inject a suspension of very stiff cells at hematocrits larger than 10%. Also, the dynamics of glutaraldehyde hardened cells is pure tumbling, which cor- responds to very high values of the viscosity ratio λ . We do not expect the dynamics (and therefore phase separation) to change much at values of λ greater than 10 and we found more interesting to increase deformability by decreasing λ rather than trying to investigate less deformable cells (with the experimental difficulties mentioned above). Hematocrit measurements Local hematocrit measurements were made by comparing suspension flow images to a reference image without RBC, under identical illumination, and using the Beer-Lambert law of absorption. The absorption coefficient was determined by a calibration with images at low hematocrit, where a direct measurement can be made by counting individual cells. Hematocrit in branch i will be denoted Hi. In experiments, h is small enough (8µm) so that the flow is quasi two-dimensional. To allow a qualitative comparison with 2D numerical simulations, an area hematocrit φi was also derived by multiplying the number of cells per unit area by the average cross-sectional area of RBCs (S =19.8 µm2). Hi and φi are therefore linked by the relationship Hi = φiv/(Sh), where v = 90 µm3 is the average volume of one cell. Simulation method In simulations, we use lattice Boltzmann method (LBM) to compute the fluid flow (Kaoui et al., 2011; Zhang et al., 2007). Each RBC is modeled by 60 nodes interconnected by a potential that allows bending, as well as a stretching modulus that penalizes distance variations between two adjacent nodes. This achieves the RBC membrane incompressibility (Tsubota et al., 2006). In other words, we set the spring constant to values as large as possible in order to keep the ratio between the membrane perimeter and area constant. We define the reduced area as 4πA/p2 (with p is the perimeter and A the enclosed area), which we set to 0.7 to produce a RBCs with a biconcave shape. We use the immersed boundary method (IBM) to couple the fluid flow and RBC deformation (Kaoui et al., 2011; Peskin, 2002; Zhang et al., 2007). For comparison with experiments, we set the viscosity contrast to λ = 1 and λ = 10. 3 Results As a guideline, we shall refer to the empirical law of Pries et al. taken from refs (Pries et al., 1989, 1990) that gives the hematocrit partition at a bifurcation: logit(cid:0)H1Q1 (cid:1) = αlogit(cid:0)Q1/Q0 − β (cid:1), H0Q0 1− 2β (1) where α = 1 + 6.98(1− H0F )/a, β = 0.4/a (with a the tube diameter in microns) and logit(x) = ln[x/(1− x)]. H0 is the volumetric hematocrit in the parent feeding branch, while H1 is the hema- tocrit in a child branch. H0F is the feeding hematocrit in a reservoir that would be located right 5 Figure 2: The relative hematocrit in the low flow rate branch as a function of the hematocrit in the parent vessel. The length ratio between the branches L1/L2 is set to 3. A: Simulations with λ =1 and λ =10. B: Comparison between experiments (λ =0.85 and λ =10.3) and the empirical law of Pries et al. (Pries et al., 1990) (solid line), for the same cross-sectional area. The non-monotonous evolution of the relative hematocrit at low H0 and high λ is related to the inversion of the Zweifach- Fung effect, on which we comment later on (see Fig. 7). before the narrow feeding vessel. Due to the Fahraeus effect, H0F is larger than H0 and a relation- ship between both quantities is also given in Pries et al. (1990): H0/H0F = H0F + (1− H0F )(1 + 1.7e−0.415a − 0.6e−0.011a). (2) Note that the partition law (Eq. 1) has been validated through in-vivo experiments with rats (thus at body temperature), with narrow capillaries (of diameters a lower than 30 microns), but with feeding hematocrits higher than 20%. As we shall compare predictions for 3D hematocrits in a cylindrical tube with either 2D simula- tions or experiments in a rectangular channel, we should avoid any direct quantitative comparisons, but rather use Pries et al. predictions as a guideline to identify where new behavior is exhibited. For comparison with simulations, we set a = W , where W is the channel width, and we shall con- sider only the hematocrit ratios. For the experiments in rectangular channels, we set a to adjust the cross-sectional areas: πa2/4 = W h. 6 0.20.40.60.8100.10.20.3H1/H0H0λ=0.85λ=10.3Empirical,A.Priesetal.AB0.20.40.60.8100.10.20.30.4ϕ1/ϕ0ϕ0λ=1λ=10The role of interactions We analyze in details how RBC deformability affects the hematocrit partition at the bifurcations. Figure 1 illustrates the Zweifach-Fung effect, observed in both experiments and simulations, at a feeding area hematocrit of 10%. In both cases, less RBCs enter the low flow rate branch (the long branch) simply due to the flow rates differences between the two child branches. However, the asymmetry is significantly pronounced at low viscosity contrast λ (when the suspending fluid is more viscous than the hemoglobin). To quantify the partition asymmetry, we measure the relative hematocrit φ1/φ0 (or, equivalently, H1/H0), in the low flow rate branch, while we vary the hemat- ocrit in the parent branch (Fig. 2A). Either in the simulations (Fig. 2A) or in the experiments (Fig. 2B), we see less RBCs in the low flow rate branch than in the parent one (φ1/φ0 < 1), when the inlet hematocrits (φ0 or H0) lies between 5% and 45%, which is precisely a manifestation of the Zweifach-Fung effect. When the viscosity contrast is low, we observe a significantly strong reduc- tion of hematocrit in the low flow rate branch, both in experiments and simulations, at moderate inlet hematocrit. This interesting observation suggests that the RBCs mechanical properties can strongly impact the hematocrit partition in-vivo since the normal hematocrit is usually less than 20% (typically between 10 and 20 % (Fung, 2013)) in microcirculation. However, when the hematocrit is high enough, the viscosity contrast plays a minor role. This is clear in simulations (for φ0 larger than 25%, Fig. 21). Similarly, in the experiments, above H0 = 20%, data for both λ converge to the Pries et al. prediction. The insensitivity to the viscosity contrast beyond a critical hematocrit (φ0 (cid:39) 25%) is a robust phenomenon that is independent of the length ratio between the branches (i.e. roughly the bulk flow rate ratio), as illustrated on Figure 3). It is appealing to suggest that the dependency of the hematocrit partition upon the feeding hematocrit is the result of the up-stream organization of RBCs in the parent vessel due to hydrody- namic interactions. At low hematocrit flows, the cell-cell interaction is weak and the organization of RBCs, within the vessel, depends mainly on the dynamics of each RBCs, thus on λ . The RBCs aggregate at the center of the vessel due to the wall-induced lift force, that increases with decreas- ing λ and increasing RBCs deformability (Grandchamp et al., 2013). This means that suspensions of RBCs with high viscosity contrasts have wider distributions (smaller CFL) in the channel as compared to suspensions having lower viscosity contrast. As a consequence, the asymmetry in the partition is expected to increase when the viscosity contrast decreases, as shown in Figure 3. To support this argument, the CFL thickness in the parent vessel and the configuration of RBCs before the bifurcation are reported in Figure 4A,B. We can clearly see that RBCs distribution at high viscosity contrast (λ =10 in simulations and λ =10.3 in experiments) is wider than that at low viscosity contrast (λ =1 in simulations and λ =0.85 in experiments) when the feeding hematocrit is low (φ0 <20%, see also Figure 4C-I, II). However, when the hematocrit increases, the contribution of the hydrodynamic interactions among RBCs becomes stronger and stronger. This causes a broadening of the distribution that acts against the lift force. Consequently, the partition between the two branches becomes more symmetric (that is φ1/φ0 becomes close to 1). Interestingly, those broad distributions are quasi independent of the viscosity contrast (see Figure 4A and C-III, IV). Consequently, φ1/φ0 does not depend on λ either (see Figure 3). Thus the distribution is independent of the strength of the interactions between cells and be- tween cells and walls, but it is mainly caused by geometrical constraints. In other words, interaction between cells and the lift forces both depend on λ , and this result indicates that they depend more 7 Figure 3: Simulations: the relative hematocrit in low flow rate branch φ1/φ0 as a function of the hematocrit in the parent vessel φ0, for several branches length ratios L1/L2 and viscosity contrasts λ . At low enough φ0, the asymmetry between the two daughter branches is strongly enhanced as the viscosity contrast λ is decreased, while the partitioning becomes independent on λ for hematocrits above 20%. or less on λ in the same way. The λ contributions cancel out once a critical feeding hematocrit is reached. Noteworthy, beyond this critical hematocrit the separating ratio φ1/φ0 quasi plateaus which enforces the idea that in this regime, the feeding flow can be considered as a three-layer fluid (fluid-cell-fluid). The width of each layer will depend neither on the strength of interaction (which is related to deformability) nor on the volume fraction. The low hematocrit limit: Inversion of the Zweifach-Fung effect Now we focus on the low hematocrit case, for which the partition depends strongly on the detail of the interactions and on the volume fraction. Moreover a peculiar effect arises due to the prevalence of the discrete nature of blood at that scale. For all hematocrits, the distribution of RBCs is not homogeneous, but rather exhibits two lateral peaks (Figure 4). This become more pronounced at low hematocrit (φ0 (cid:46) 5%), where a two-file distribution of RBCs is observed, as shown in Figure 5. For λ =10, there is almost no cell flowing in the central part of the vessel, even though the wall-lift force tends to center them. The structure adopted by the suspension can be viewed as a juxtaposition of layers with high and low hematocrits. For example, as shown in Figure 5 (top 8 00.510.050.150.250.35ϕ1/ϕ0ϕ0L1/L2=1.43λ=1λ=1000.510.050.150.250.35ϕ1/ϕ0ϕ0L1/L2=1.86λ=1λ=1000.510.050.150.250.35ϕ1/ϕ0ϕ0L1/L2=2.29λ=1λ=1000.510.050.150.250.35ϕ1/ϕ0ϕ0L1/L2=2.71λ=1λ=10ABCDFigure 4: A: CFL thickness as a function of the hematocrit in the parent vessel, for λ =1 and λ =10, in simulations. Insets : Snapshots showing the suspension at the bifurcation. We define the CFL as a layer where the integrated concentration profile is below 5% (Kumar et al., 2014). B: Snapshots from experiments, for λ =0.85 and 10.3, and hematocrits φ0 =10, 20 and 30%. Every snapshot is a superimposition of 10 successive images in order to highlight the CFL in the parent vessel. C: The stationary volume fraction density functions in the parent vessel obtained from simulations. 9 345670.050.10.150.20.250.30.350.4CFLthickness(µm)ϕ0λ=1λ=10ϕ010%20%30%λ=0.85λ=10.300.20.40.60.805101520ϕy(µm)ϕ0=10%λ=1λ=1000.20.40.60.805101520ϕy(µm)ϕ0=20%λ=1λ=1000.20.40.60.805101520ϕy(µm)ϕ0=30%λ=1λ=1000.20.40.60.805101520ϕy(µm)ϕ0=40%λ=1λ=10IIIIIIVIIIIIIIIVABCFigure 5: The profiles of the hematocrit distribution and the corresponding snapshots of RBCs distribution in the parent vessel. The feeding hematocrits are 5% and 40%, for two different values of λ . panel with λ = 10) the central part is depleted in RBCs, but it is escorted by two enriched layers, which themselves are surrounded by two depleted layers at the periphery (close to the channel walls). This 5-layer configuration (fluid-cell-fluid-cell-fluid) has an extremely interesting impact on the partition. This can be highlighted by measuring φ1/φ0 as a function of the bulk flow rate ratio Q1/Q0 between a child branch and the parent vessel, for fixed φ0 (Figure 6). If we focus first on the results for high φ0 (φ0 (cid:39) 40%), we find again the insensitivity to λ . As Q1/Q0 is increased from 0 to 0.5, the low flow rate branch 1 recruits first the CFL and then the cells. This implies that φ1 starts at 0 and increases until reaching φ0 when the situation is symmetric (Q1 = Q2 = Q0/2). Our results agree with a previous 2D simulation obtained for φ0 (cid:39) 32% (Yin et al., 2013) as well as with the empirical law of Pries and coworkers (Pries et al., 1990). An unexpected phenomenon is observed at low enough hematocrit, for φ0 = 5% and at high viscosity contrast λ = 10, in contrast to the high hematocrit regime (see Figure 6 B, λ = 10). At low Q1/Q0, the peripheral CFL in the parent vessel is recruited by the branch 1 so φ1 starts at 0 and increases when Q1 increases. Around Q1/Q0 = 0.3, φ1 becomes larger than φ0. This means the hematocrit is increased in the low flow rate branch, which is the reverse behavior of the Zweifach- Fung effect. The five-layer structure mentioned above is the key ingredient for understanding this unexpected behavior: In the intermediate range 0.3 < Q1/Q0 < 0.5, the low flow rate branch recruits the lateral CFL layer plus the adjacent RBC-rich layer among the five layers. By contrast, the high flow rate branch recruits the CFL layer close to the opposite wall plus its adjacent RBC- rich layer (exactly as the low flow rate branch) as well as the central (and depleted) layer. Thus, while both branches recruit approximately the same amount of cells per unit time, those are more dilute in the high flow rate branch, which receives more fluid, while in the classical Zweifach-Fung effect, the high flow rate branch is the one that receives more cells. For λ = 1 (see Figure 6B with λ = 1), the two-peak structure is not as marked as in the case of λ = 10, so the reverse Zweifach- Fung effect is not as strong. The subtle role played by the suspension structuring at low hematocrit is also supported by our experiments, where the interplay between the diffusion and the wall-lift force is controlled by varying the width W of the inlet channel (see Figure 7). When W is low (W 10 0510152000.050.10.150.2y(µm)ϕϕ0=5%λ=1λ=100510152000.20.40.60.8y(µm)ϕϕ0=40%λ=1λ=10Figure 6: The relative hematocrit in one child branch as a function of the bulk flow ratio. Solid lines correspond to the empirical law proposed in ref (Pries et al., 1990), for a = W . For simulations, the relative hematocrit is φ1/φ0. For Pries law, it is given by H1/H0. A: high hematocrit (φ0 = H0 = 40%). B: low hematocrit (φ0 = H0 = 5%). = 10 µm), the hematocrit in the low flow rate branch is much lower than expected from Pries et al. predictions (which were not validated on this confinement range). This is caused by the CFL effect that becomes very strong. As in the simulations, for Q1/Q0 = 0.25, this effect is more pronounced at low λ , that corresponds to a more important wall lift force. The 5-layer structure is clearly observed also in the experiments for H0 < 5%, W = 20 or 30 µm and at low λ (Figure 7C), but not at high λ , while it was more strongly marked at high λ in the simulations. This indicates that this peculiar structure is very dependent on the mechanical properties of the cells and also on the degree of confinement. Nevertheless, a robust feature is valid in both simulations and experiments: When the two-file structure of RBCs takes place, a clear inversion of the blood partition at the bifurcation is observed. In the experiments, this corresponds to Figure 7A, where some points lie above the equal partition line when H0 < 2%. There are also situations in which one of the two branches can be even completely devoid of RBCs (Figure 7C). A corresponding prolonged lack of RBCs perfusion to real blood vessels causes dysfunction and possibly ischemia disease. Because RBC mechanical properties are affected by aging and pathologies, these can induce abnormal partitions of the hematocrit in the vascular net- work. 11 00.30.60.91.21.50.20.30.40.50.60.70.8Relative HctQ1/Q0Highhematocritλ=1,simulationλ=10,simulationEmpiricalRelative Hct00.30.60.91.21.50.20.30.40.50.60.70.8Q1/Q0Lowhematocritλ=1,simulationλ=10,simulationEmpiricalABFigure 7: Experiments: the hematocrit in the low flow rate branch H1 as a function of the hematocrit in the parent vessel H0. A: Low λ ; B: High λ . The length ratio between the branches is set to 3. The width W of the inlet channel is set to 10, 20 and 30 µm. The corresponding empirical laws of Pries et al.(Pries et al., 1990) are also shown. The dotted line (the one with highest slope) corresponds to equal partition (H1 = H0). For W = 20 µm, the data are the continuation of the data already reported in Figure 2.C: Snapshots for each width W and two concentrations H0 = 0.6% and 4.5%. Every snapshot is the superimposition of 10 successive images in order to highlight the structure of the suspension in the parent vessel 4 Discussion and conclusions As a result of the interplay between the Zweifach-Fung effect and the Fahraeus effect the hemat- ocrit in microcirculation can reach values as low as 10-20% compared to the average hematocrit in human body (45%). At such a low hematocrit, our simulations and in vitro microfluidic ex- periments have revealed that RBCs partition at the level of bifurcations depends strongly on the viscosity contrast between the viscosities of the RBC hemoglobin and the suspending fluid. In the extreme hemodilution, our results exhibit a newly reported phenomenon: The low flow rate branch may receive higher hematocrit than the high flow rate branch in opposition to the known Zweifach-Fung effect. This phenomenon is observed under moderate confinement and is the result of a peculiar structuring of the cell suspension. Under stronger confinement, other strong discrep- ancy with Pries et al. empirical law was highlighted, with a strong asymmetry in the partitioning 12 λ=10.3λ=10.3ABC00.020.040.060.0800.020.040.06H1H0W=30µm,λ=0.85W=30µm,EmpiricalW=20µm,λ=0.85W=20µm,EmpiricalW=10µm,λ=0.85W=10µm,Empirical00.020.040.060.0800.020.040.06H1H0W=30µm,λ=10.3W=30µm,EmpiricalW=20µm,λ=10.3W=20µm,EmpiricalW=10µm,λ=10.3W=10µm,EmpiricalW=30µmW=20µmW=10µmλ=0.85λ=0.85H0=0.6%H0=4.5%H0=0.6%H0=4.5%(enhanced Zweifach-Fung effect). Our findings suggest that the viscosity contrast must be taken into consideration and carefully analyzed in order to have a firm understanding of RBC distribu- tion in microcirculation. This physiological parameter increases with aging as well as with some pathologies. The results of our present work provide a valuable background needed to pinpoint the various RBCs properties that govern hematocrit partition, and thus oxygen delivery in the microcirculation in general. Acknowledgment Z. S. thanks Vassanti Audemar for experimental advice and assistance. Z. S., G. C., C. M. and T. P. acknowledge financial support from CNES (Centre National d’Etudes Spatiales) and ESA (European Space Agency). The DyFCom team of LIPhy (Z. S., G. C., C. M. and T. P.) is mem- ber of Labex TEC21 (Investissements d’Avenir-Grant Agreement ANR-11-LABX-0030), Struc- ture F´ed´erative de Recherche iDYSCO (CNRS), F´ed´eration Galileo Galilei de Grenoble (FR3345 CNRS-UJF-Grenoble INP-IRSTEA) and Groupement de Recherche MECABIO (GDR3570 CNRS). References M. Abkarian, M. Faivre, and A. Viallat. Swinging of red blood cells under shear flow. Phys. Rev. Lett., 98:188302, 2007. D. M. Audet and W. L. Olbricht. The motion of model cells at capillary bifurcations. Microvasc. Res., 33:377–396, 1987. J. O. Barber, J. P. Alberding, J. M. Restrepo, and T. W. Secomb. Simulated two-dimensional red blood cell motion, deformation, and partitioning in microvessel bifurcations. Ann. Biomech. Eng., 36:1690–1698, 2008. N. Callens, C. Minetti, G. Coupier, M. Mader, F. Dubois, C. Misbah, and T. Podgorski. Hydrody- namic lift of vesicles under shear flow in microgravity. Europhys. Lett., 83:24002, 2008. I. Cantat and C. Misbah. Lift force and dynamical unbinding of adhering vesicles under shear flow. Phys. Rev. Lett., 83:880–883, 1999. S. Chien, C. D. Tvetenstrand, M. A. Epstein, and G. W. Schmid-Schonbein. Model studies on distributions of blood cells at microvascular bifurcations. Am. J. Physiol. Heart Circ. Physiol., 248:H568–H576, 1985. G. R. Cokelet and H. J. Meiselman. Rheological comparison of hemoglobin solutions and erythro- cyte suspensions. Science, 162:275–377, 1968. D. V. Cokkinos, C. Pantos, G. Heusch, and H. Taegtmeyer. Myocardial ischemia: from mechanisms to therapeutic potentials, volume 21. Springer Science & Business Media, 2006. 13 G. Coupier, B. Kaoui, T. Podgorski, and C. Misbah. Noninertial lateral migration of vesicles in bounded Poiseuille flow. Phys. Fluids, 20:111702, 2008. J. W. Dellimore, M. J. Dunlop, and P. B. Canham. Ratio of cells and plasma in blood flowing past branches in small plastic channels. Am. J. Physiol. Heart Circ. Physiol., 244:H635–H643, 1983. R. Ditchfield and W. L. Olbricht. Effects of particle concentration on the partitioning of suspen- sions at small divergent bifurcations. J. Biomech. Eng., 118:287–294, 1996. V. Doyeux, T. Podgorski, S. Peponas, M. Ismail, and G. Coupier. Spheres in the vicinity of a bifurcation: elucidating the Zweifach-Fung effect. J. Fluid Mech., 674:359, 2011. J. Dupire, M. Socol, and A. Viallat. Full dynamics of a red blood cell in shear flow. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109(51):20808–20813, 2012. A. Farutin and C. Misbah. Symmetry breaking and cross-streamline migration of three- dimensional vesicles in an axial poiseuille flow. Physical Review E, 89(4):042709, 2014. D. Fedosov, B. Caswell, S. Suresh, and G. Karniadakis. Quantifying the biophysical characteristics of plasmodium-falciparum-parasitized red blood cells in microcirculation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 108(1):35–39, 2011. B. M. Fenton, R. T. Carr, and G. R. Cokelet. Nonuniform red cell distribution in 20 to 100 µm bifurcations. Microvasc. Res., 29:103–126, 1985. Y.-C. Fung. Biomechanics: circulation. Springer Science & Business Media, 2013. X. Grandchamp, G. Coupier, A. Srivastav, C. Minetti, and T. Podgorski. Lift and down-gradient shear-induced diffusion in red blood cell suspensions. Phys. Rev. Lett., 110:108101, 2013. R. Guibert, C. Fonta, and F. Plouraboue. A New Approach to Model Confined Suspensions Flows in Complex Networks: Application to Blood Flow. Transport Porous Med., 83:171–194, 2010. D. S. Hariprasad and T. W. Secomb. Two-dimensional simulation of red blood cell motion near a wall under a lateral force. Phys. Rev. E, 90:053014, 2014. T. Hyakutake and S. Nagai. Numerical simulation of red blood cell distributions in three- dimensional microvascular bifurcations. Microvasc. Res., 97:115 – 123, 2015. ISSN 0026-2862. B. Kaoui, J. Harting, and C. Misbah. Two-dimensional vesicle dynamics under shear flow: Effect of confinement. Physical Review E, 83(6):066319, 2011. D. Katanov, G. Gompper, and D. A. Fedosov. Microvascular blood flow resistance: Role of red blood cell migration and dispersion. Microvascular research, 99:57–66, 2015. C. Kelemen, S. Chien, and G. Artmann. Temperature transition of human hemoglobin at body temperature: effects of calcium. Biophysical journal, 80(6):2622–2630, 2001. T. Kruger, B. Kaoui, and J. Harting. Interplay of inertia and deformability on rheological properties of a suspension of capsules. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 751:725–745, 2014. 14 A. Kumar, R. G. Henr´ıquez Rivera, and M. D. Graham. Flow-induced segregation in confined multicomponent suspensions: effects of particle size and rigidity. J. Fluid Mech., 738:423–462, 1 2014. ISSN 1469-7645. X. Li, A. S. Popel, and G. E. Karniadakis. Blood-plasma separation in y-shaped bifurcating mi- crofluidic channels: a dissipative particle dynamics simulation study. Phys. Biol., 9:026010, 2012. J. L. McWhirter, H. Noguchi, and G. Gompper. Flow-induced clustering and alignment of vesicles and red blood cells in microcapillaries. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 106 (15):6039–6043, 2009. S. T. Ollila, C. Denniston, and T. Ala-Nissila. One- and two-particle dynamics in microfluidic t-junctions. Phys. Rev. E, 87:050302, 2013. C. S. Peskin. The immersed boundary method. Acta numerica, 11:479–517, 2002. A. R. Pries, K. Ley, M. Claassen, and P. Gaethgens. Red cell distribution at microvascular bifur- cations. Microvasc. Res., 38:81–101, 1989. A. R. Pries, T. W. Secomb, P. Gaehtgens, and J. F. Gross. Blood flow in microvascular networks. experiments and simulation. Circ. Res., 67(4):826–34, 1990. doi: 10.1161/01.RES.67.4.826. B. W. Roberts and W. L. Olbricht. Flow-induced particulate separations. AIChE J., 49:2842–2849, 2003. B. W. Roberts and W. L. Olbricht. The distribution of freely suspended particles at microfluidic bifurcations. AIChE J., 52:199–206, 2006. J. M. Sherwood, E. Kaliviotis, J. Dusting, and S. Balabani. Hematocrit, viscosity and ve- locity distributions of aggregating and non-aggregating blood in bifurcating microchannel. Biomicrofluidics, 6:024119, 2012. L. Shi, T.-W. Pan, and R. Glowinski. Numerical simulation of lateral migration of red blood cells in poiseuille flows. Int. J. Numer. Methods Fluids, 68(11):1393–1408, 2012. K. Tsubota, S. Wada, and T. Yamaguchi. Particle method for computer simulation of red blood cell motion in blood flow. Computer methods and programs in biomedicine, 83(2):139–146, 2006. H. C. Woolfenden and M. G. Blyth. Motion of a two-dimensional elastic capsule in a branching channel flow. J. Fluid Mech., 669:3–31, 2 2011. W. Xiong and J. Zhang. Two-dimensional lattice boltzmann study of red blood cell motion through microvascular bifurcation: cell deformability and suspending viscosity effects. Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol., 11:575–583, 2012. X. Yin, T. Thomas, and J.Zhang. Multiple red blood cell flows through microvascular bifurcations: Cell free layer, cell trajectory, and hematocrit separation. Microvasc. Res., 89:47 – 56, 2013. 15 J. Zhang, P. C. Johnson, and A. S. Popel. An immersed boundary lattice boltzmann approach to simulate deformable liquid capsules and its application to microscopic blood flows. Physical biology, 4(4):285, 2007. 16
1109.5786	1	1109	2011-09-27T06:45:56	Growth of bioluminescent bacteria under modelled gravity of different astronomical bodies in the Solar system	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.CB" ]	Spaceflights and clinostats have been used extensively to study the effects of microgravity on various biological systems ranging from microbes to plants. Similarly hypergravity studies have been carried out using centrifuges where growth retardation has been observed. However, no studies have been carried out yet on how the gravity of astronomical bodies, e.g. Moon having 1/6th the gravity of Earth, affects biological systems. Such studies are important with missions to Moon and Mars to be carried out in future. Also, a comparative study to see the effects of gravity that exists on astronomical bodies such as Moon, Mars and Jupiter on any organism using simulation have not been reported so far. This paper discusses the effects of modelled gravity on the growth of Vibrio harveyi using the clinostat-centrifuge system designed and developed in-house. Results showed that though growth as measured by optical density was significantly higher for simulated microgravity and lunar and Martian gravities, there was no significant difference in viable counts. This is because the relative death rate is also higher for these gravities. Jovian gravity was found to slightly retard the growth. This study also shows that simulated lunar gravity is relatively most suited for the growth of Vibrio harveyi.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Growth of bioluminescent bacteria under modelled gravity of different astronomical bodies in the Solar system Santosh Bhaskaran1,@, Rohan Dudhale1,2,$, Jyotsana Dixit1,2, Ajit Sahasrabuddhe1,3,# and Pandit B. Vidyasagar1 1Biophysics Laboratory, Department of Physics, University of Pune, Pune 411 007, INDIA 2Department of Microbiology, P.E.S. Modern College of Arts, Science and Commerce, Ganeshkhind, Pune 411 053 INDIA. $ Haffkine Institute for Training, Research and Testing, Parel, Mumbai 400 012, INDIA 3Department of Microbiology, P.E.S. Modern College of Arts, Science and Commerce, Shivajinagar, Pune 411 005, INDIA #Quality Control Division, Serum Institute of India, Hadapsar, Pune 411 028, INDIA Abstract Spaceflights and clinostats have been used extensively to study the effects of microgravity on various biological systems ranging from microbes to plants. Similarly hypergravity studies have been carried out using centrifuges where growth retardation has been observed. However, no studies have been carried out yet on how the gravity of astronomical bodies, e.g. Moon having 1/6th the gravity of Earth, affects biological systems. Such studies are important with missions to Moon and Mars to be Biophysics Laboratory, Department of Physics, University of Pune, Pune 411 007, INDIA Fax: +91-44-22232711 Email: [email protected] Present Address @Life Sciences Division, AU-KBC Research Centre, MIT Campus, Chennai 600 044, INDIA carried out in future. Also, a comparative study to see the effects of gravity that exists on astronomical bodies such as Moon, Mars and Jupiter on any organism using simulation have not been reported so far. This paper discusses the effects of modelled gravity on the growth of Vibrio harveyi using the clinostat-centrifuge system designed and developed in-house. Results showed that though growth as measured by optical density was significantly higher for simulated microgravity and lunar and Martian gravities, there was no significant difference in viable counts. This is because the relative death rate is also higher for these gravities. Jovian gravity was found to slightly retard the growth. This study also shows that simulated lunar gravity is relatively most suited for the growth of Vibrio harveyi. Keywords: Microgravity, Hypogravity, Hypergravity, Clinostat-centrifuge, Moon, Jupiter Running Title: Growth of Vibrio harveyi in altered gravity 2 Introduction Experiments on Escherichia coli in space showed a shortened lag phase, an increased duration of exponential growth and an approximate doubling of final cell population density compared to controls (Klaus et al., 1997; Gasset et al., 1994) but no change in growth rate was observed (Brown et al., 2002). Modelled microgravity also showed an enhanced growth of E. Coli while hypergravity retarded the growth (Gasset et al., 1994). Bacillus subtilis showed a higher growth rate in microgravity (Mennigmann & Lange, 1986; Kacena et al., 1999) as well as higher final biomass yield (Mennigmann & Lange, 1986). Bacillus subtilis also showed a shortened lag phase during spaceflight at 23 °C but not at 37 °C (Kacena et al., 1999). Salmonella typhimurium showed a higher growth rate and reduction in generation time under modelled microgravity (Wilson et al., 2002). An increased growth was observed in spaceflight as well (Mattoni, 1968). Modelled microgravity decreased the germination efficiency of Dictyostelium discoideum while hypergravity promoted it (Kawasaki et al., 1990). Fruiting bodies were found to be smaller in modelled microgravity and taller in hypergravity (Kawasaki et al., 1990). Paramecium showed a random swimming behaviour below 0.16g with negative gravitaxis becoming pronounced from 0.3 g suggesting a threshold for gravitaxis between 0.16 and 0.3 g (Hemmersbach et al, 1996). Studies on the contraction activity of Physarum onboard SPACELAB-I showed that the threshold was 0.1 g to elicit a response (Block et al, 1996). In this paper, we discuss how modelled gravity conditions of Moon (0.16g), Mars (0.38g) and Jupiter (2.5g) affects the growth of Vibrio harveyi, a bioluminescent bacterium, isolated from the coastal waters of Goa, India. Bioluminescent bacteria have applications as environmental biosensors and pollution indicators (Girotti et al., 2008). We show that though microgravity, lunar and Martian gravities enhance the growth, they also enhance the death of Vibrio harveyi. To the best of our knowledge, neither studies on the effects of lunar and Martian gravities (hypogravity) nor a comparative study of different gravity environments have been carried out on the growth of any organism. 3 Materials and Methods Bacterial cultures obtained from coastal waters of Goa, India were isolated and identified as Vibrio harveyi (strain NB0903) using 16S rRNA sequencing. The suspension culture was adjusted to OD = 0.2 (approx. 5x109 cells/ml) and 1% inoculum added to sterile BOSS broth (Klein et al., 1998) in each of four identical glass vessels (8 cm x 11 cm), specially designed for the clinostat-centrifuge system (designed and developed in-house) (Fig.1). Two of these cultures were exposed to modelled varied gravity conditions viz. Microgravity (Space), 0.16 g (Lunar), 0.38 g (Martian), 1 g (Earth) as dynamic control and 2.5 g (Jovian) for 15 hours. The g-values were calculated using the standard formula RCF = 1.118x10-5 x r x N2…. (1) where RCF is the relative centrifugal force in g units, R (=17 cm) is the distance of the sample from the centre of the clinostat-centrifuge in cm. This includes the distance of the sample holder from the centre and half the length of the vessel as the rotation is along the vertical axis. In case of microgravity r (= 4 cm) is the radius of the vessel as the rotation is along the horizontal axis. and N is the speed of rotation in rpm 4 In a normal centrifuge, two forces viz., gravitational force downward and the centrifugal force outwards, act on the sample. The net force acting on the sample is the resultant of the two and hence the magnitude of the resultant would be always higher than 1g. However in a clinostat, the sample is in modelled microgravity. Thus in a clinostat-centrifuge system, accelerations less than 1g can also be modelled. The other two cultures acted as static controls. Static controls were used since shaking at 170 rpm would be equivalent to 3g. From the time of inoculation, at regular intervals of one hour, aliquots of 2 ml were taken for measuring optical density at 590 nm using a digital colorimeter and for total viable count using spread plate method in duplicates. Both control and test vessels were shaken well before taking the aliquots so that the cultures were well-mixed. Changes, if any, in morphological characteristics were also observed. Since OD is a function of the total cell number for a particular instant, the difference in OD and TVC can be correlated to the number of dead cells at that instant. The relative death rates for different values of g were calculated as follows. Log CFU versus OD in the exponential phase was plotted and a mathematical function relating them was obtained. Taking this relation as a standard, the total number of cells in the broth for each value of g was estimated by substituting the corresponding OD values in this relation. The difference between the total number of cells in broth and CFU gives us the relative number of dead cells. This was used to obtain the relative death rate. Since the relation for static control is taken as zero, the relative death rate would be zero. All experiments were carried out at room temperature (25±1 °C). Each experiment was repeated three times and consistent results were obtained. All data are represented as Mean ± SEM. The p-values were obtained by Student’s T-test. 5 6 plates have shown similar results (Kacena et al., 1997). Similar results were obtained for Pseudomonas aeruginosa grown under modelled microgravity (Guadarrama et al., 2005). Some studies have attributed this to the influence of motility (Thevenet et al., 1996, Benoit & Klaus, 2007) while some others have attributed this to lack of more efficient metabolic capabilities in microgravity (Kacena et al., 1997). It should however be noted that in our case, liquid cultures were grown under altered gravity while viable counts for all the treated cultures were obtained under normal gravity on agar plates using the aliquots taken from these liquid cultures. Yet similar results have been obtained. From Table 1, it can be seen that growth rate from OD was the highest for modelled lunar gravity. This was followed by the growth rate for modelled microgravity and modelled Martian gravity which were almost the same while Jovian gravity showed the minimum growth rate. However, the relative death rate is also higher in modelled microgravity and lunar and Martian gravities. This shows why the viable cell counts are not significantly different from control. Interestingly, the relative death rate is lesser than the growth rate from OD only for lunar gravity. This is reflected in the form of least generation time and maximum growth rate from viable cell counts. This shows that in effect; modelled microgravity, lunar and Martian gravities enhance the growth of Vibrio harveyi with modelled lunar gravity showing maximum enhancement while Jovian gravity retards the growth. The lag phase was reduced by 50 % for modelled microgravity, lunar and Martian gravities but remained the same for Jovian gravity with respect to control. As far as the exponential phase is concerned, it increased by 50 % in modelled microgravity, 33 % in modelled lunar gravity and 17 % in modelled Martian gravity but remained the same in Jovian gravity with respect to control. No changes in colony morphological characteristics were observed for all samples exposed to each of the altered gravity conditions. SDS-PAGE did not show any change in band patterns for all samples (data not shown). We expected an inverse relation between the growth and gravity and indeed it is the case except for lunar gravity. Hence it was quite surprising to get maximum growth for lunar gravity instead of microgravity. These results can be concluded due to gravity alone and not due to other factors such as aeration since growth for Jovian is less than 1g control. If it was the case, then maximum growth should have been observed for 7 Jovian gravity since the rotation speed is maximum and hence the aeration relative to all other values of g reported in this paper. In summary, we have measured the growth rates by OD and viable counts under different modelled gravity conditions, however a significant difference is found only in the OD. Organism under modelled microgravity, lunar and Martian gravity conditions shows, higher growth rate and reduced generation time with respect to static controls while Jovian gravity did not have a significant impact on the organism studied. Non-significant difference in viable counts is due to an equal number of cells dying under these conditions and not possibly due to similar metabolic activities (Kacena et al., 1997) in microgravity or differences in motility (Benoit & Klaus, 2007). We have shown that modelled lunar gravity, i.e. 0.16g, is most favourable for the growth of Vibrio harveyi. However, it is important to know if our results are a general trend for all organisms or are typical of Vibrio harveyi alone. Similar studies on mammalian cells are important, since they will provide an insight as to how our physiological systems will adapt to such gravity conditions. This has great implications for setting up bases on other planets and their moons. This can also be used in industry to get maximum output from micro-organisms just by optimising the value of g in addition to pH, temperature, etc. References Benoit, M.R., and Klaus, D.M. (2007) Microgravity, bacteria, and the influence of motility. Adv. Space Res. 39, 1225-1232. Block I., Briegleb W. and Wolke A. (1996) Acceleration-sensitivity threshold of Physarum. J. Biotechnol. 47, 239-244 Brown, R.B., Klaus, D. And Todd, P. (2002) Effects of space flight, clinorotation, and centrifugation on the substrate utilization efficiency of E. Coli. Micrograv. Sci. Tech. 13, 24-29. 8 Gasset, G., Tixador, R., Eche, B., Lapchine, L., Moatti, N., Toorop, P., and Woldringh, C. (1994) Growth and division of Escherichia coli under microgravity conditions. Res. Microbiol. 145, 111-120. Girotti, S., Ferri, E.N., Fumo, M.G., and Maiolini, E. (2008) Monitoring of environmental pollutants by bioluminescent bacteria. Anal. Chim. Acta. 608, 2-29 Guadarrama, S., Pulcini, E.L., Broadaway, S.C. and Pyle, B.H. (2005) Pseudomonas aeruginosa growth and production of Exotoxin A in static and modeled microgravity environments. Gravit. Space Biol. 18, 85-86. Hemmersbach R., Voormanns R.,, Briegleb W., Riederb N. and Hider D.P. (1996) Influence of accelerations on the spatial orientation of Loxodes and Paramecium. J. Biotechnol. 47, 271-278 Kacena, M.A., Leonard, P.E. Todd, P, and Luttges, M.W. (1997) Low gravity and inertial effects on the growth of E. Coli and B. Subtilis in semi-solid media. Aviat. Space Environ. Med. 68, 1104-1108. Kacena, M.A., Merrell G.A., Manfredi B., Smith E.E., Klaus D.M. and Todd P. (1999) Bacterial growth in spaceflight: Logistic growth curve parameters for Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis. Appl. Microbiol.Biotechnol. 51, 229-234. Kawasaki, Y., Kiryu, T., Usui, K. And Mizutani, H. (1990) Growth of the cellular slime mold, Dictyostelium discoideum, Is gravity dependent. Plant Physiol. 93, 1568-1572. Klaus, D., Simske, S., Todd, P. And Stodieck, L. (1997) Investigation of space flight effects on Escherichia coli and a proposed model of underlying physical mechanisms. Microbiol. 143, 449-455. Klein, G., mijewski, M., Krzewska, J., Czeczatka, M. And Lipi ska, B. (1998) Cloning and characterization of the dnak heat shock operon of the marine bacterium Vibrio harveyi. Mol. Gen. Genet. 259, 179-189. Mattoni, R.H.T. (1968) Space flight effects and gamma radiation interaction on growth and induction of lysogenic bacteria. Bioscience. 18, 602-608. 9 Mennigmann, H.D. and Lange, M. (1986) Growth and differentiation of Bacillus subtilis under microgravity. Naturwissenschaften 73, 415417. Thevenet, D., D’Ari, R. And Bouloc, P. (1996) The SIGNAL experiment in BIORACK: Escherichia coli in microgravity. J. Biotech. 47, 89-97. Wilson, J.W., Ott, C.M., Ramamurthy, R., Porwollik, S., mcclelland, M., Pierson, D.L., and Nickerson, C.A. (2002) Low-Shear modeled microgravity alters the Salmonella enterica serovar typhimurium stress response in an rpos-independent manner. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 68, 5408– 5416. Acknowledgements We are thankful to the Director, National Centre for Cell Science, Pune, India as well as to Prof. B.A. Chopade and Mr. .Praveen K. Sahu, DNA sequencing Laboratory, Institute of Bioinformatics & Biotechnology, University of Pune, India for carrying out the 16S rrna sequencing of the bacterial isolate. Comments provided by Mr. Vivek Jadhav, University of Pune, Mr. Anant Rajeha, I.I.T. Chennai, Mr. Lasse Folkerson, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm and Ms. Jamila Siamwala, AU-KBC Research Centre, Chennai were of great help in writing this paper. Co-author PBV would like to thank abdus-Salam International Centre of Theoretical Physics, Trieste for Associateship. Author Contributions SB, AS and RD conceived the idea of this work. AS and SB made designs of the vessels while RD and JD isolated and characterised the organism. SB and AS designed the experiments. RD, JD, AS and SB contributed equally to the growth curve experiments. JD carried out the SDS PAGE. SB and JD mainly wrote the paper. PBV supervised this work. 10 Table 1. Growth kinetics in altered gravity g Growth Rate Relative Growth Rate Generation Lag Exponential from OD Death Rate from TVC Time Phase Phase (Hour-1) (Hour-1) (Hour-1) (Minutes) (Hours) (Hours) Static Control (1g) 0.365 ± 0.038 - 0.365 ± 0.038 114.9 ± 11.12 Space (µg) 0.51 ± 0.043 0.651 ± 0.174 0.392 ± 0.043 107.01 ± 11.75 Moon (0.16g) 0.602 ± 0.044 0.57 ± 0.232 0.41 ± 0.056 102.65 ± 12.56 Mars (0.38g) 0.432 ± 0.042 0.485 ± 0.171 0.394 ± 0.037 106.38 ± 9.65 Dynamic Control (1g) 0.294 ± 0.042 0.436 ± 0.159 0.383 ± 0.105 114.92 ± 12.83 Jupiter (2.5g) 0.235 ± 0.041 0.258 ± 0.128 0.34 ± 0.037 123.26 ± 12.89 2 1 1 1 2 2 6 9 8 7 6 6 11
1704.05885	1	1704	2017-04-19T18:27:10	Integrating optimization with thermodynamics and plant physiology for crop ideotype design	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	A computational framework integrating optimization algorithms, parallel computing and plant physiology was developed to explore crop ideotype design. The backbone of the framework is a plant physiology model that accurately tracks water use (i.e. a plant hydraulic model) coupled with mass transport (CO2 exchange and transport), energy conversion (leaf temperature due to radiation, convection and mass transfer) and photosynthetic biochemistry of an adult maize plant. For a given trait configuration, soil parameters and hourly weather data, the model computes water use and photosynthetic output over the life of an adult maize plant. We coupled this validated model with a parallel, meta-heuristic optimization algorithm, specifically a genetic algorithm (GA), to identify trait sets (ideotypes) that resulted in desired water use behavior of the adult maize plant. We detail features of the model as well as the implementation details of the coupling with the optimization framework and deployment on high performance computing platforms. We illustrate a representative result of this framework by identifying maize ideotypes with optimized photosynthetic yields using weather and soil conditions corresponding to Davis, CA. Finally, we show how the framework can be used to identify broad ideotype trends that can inform breeding efforts. The developed presented tool has the potential to inform the development of future climate-resilient crops.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Integrating optimization with thermodynamics and plant physiology for crop ideotype design Talukder Z. Jubery1, Baskar Ganapathysubramanian1, Matthew E. Gilbert2, and Daniel Attinger1 1Department of Mechanical Engineering and Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Iowa State University, Ames, IA, 50011; 2Department of Plant Sciences, University of California, Davis, CA 95616, USA. Correspondence to: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] Abstract A computational framework integrating optimization algorithms, parallel computing and plant physiology was developed to explore crop ideotype design. The backbone of the framework is a plant physiology model that accurately tracks water use (i.e. a plant hydraulic model) coupled with mass transport (CO2 exchange and transport), energy conversion (leaf temperature due to radiation, convection and mass transfer) and photosynthetic biochemistry of an adult maize plant. For a given trait configuration, soil parameters and hourly weather data, the model computes water use and photosynthetic output over the life of an adult maize plant. We coupled this validated model with a parallel, meta-heuristic optimization algorithm, specifically a genetic algorithm (GA), to identify trait sets (ideotypes) that resulted in desired water use behavior of the adult maize plant. We detail features of the model as well as the implementation details of the coupling with the optimization framework and deployment on high performance computing platforms. We illustrate a representative result of this framework by identifying maize ideotypes with optimized photosynthetic yields using weather and soil conditions corresponding to Davis, CA. Finally, we show how the framework can be used to identify broad ideotype trends that can inform breeding efforts. The developed presented tool has the potential to inform the development of future climate-resilient crops. Keywords: ideotypes, optimization, net photosynthesis, hydraulic traits. Introduction To ensure food security, crop grain yields should be increased globally by 70–100% within the next 40 years [1]. To increase yields, plant breeders and plant scientists are working to develop improved and appropriate varieties of crops. However, the intrinsic uncertainty of climate change, limited water supply and reduction of agricultural land increase the challenges in the crop development process [2]. We have limited time and resources to select the most appropriate crop varieties, and crop modeling provides a rational approach to designing new crop varieties [3]. Traditional methods for finding the best crop varieties, or ideotypes [4], rely on agronomic experiments. The evaluated ideotypes are restricted in time and space, making results site- and 1 season-specific, and the experiments are time consuming and expensive. The use of crop models has greatly enabled crop breeding by reducing costs and accelerating the process of identifying/designing ideotypes. Many physiological models of crops [5]–[15] have been developed since the pioneering 1948 model of van den Honert [16]. These models are focused on specific aspects of plant physiology: water transport, time-dependence, influence of environmental conditions, heat and mass transfer, effect of plant geometry, nutrient transport, plant growth, or phloem transport. While these models can determine and explain optimum relationships between existing traits [5], there is increasing interest in coupling them with optimization tools to identify the most promising traits for a desired response [24], [25]. Over the last three decades, publications on numerical optimization methods have emerged and their number has grown at a rate higher than the growth rate of publications on traditional plant breeding. Considering also that breeding is, per se, an optimization problem, the recent emergence of limited publications at the intersection of "breeding" and "numerical optimization" is not unexpected. Some of these publications describe numerical methods inspired by animal breeding strategies [17], [18], while others seek to optimize the management of a breeding program [19], [20] , either by improving the phenotyping associated with breeding [21], or minimizing the genotyping efforts [22]. While these models can determine and explain optimum relationships between existing traits [5], [10], [23], there is work yet to be done to efficiently leverage this knowledge to direct breeding efforts. This is the motivation of our work. We describe our model and how we integrate it with an optimization framework. We then demonstrate an application of the framework by identifying crop ideotypes for a specific location parameterized by weather and soil conditions. Materials and Methods Plant physiology model The backbone of our framework is a mechanistic crop physiological model that is based upon a detailed one-dimensional representation of plant hydraulic characteristics. Liquid-phase, plant- water relations are simply represented as a static series of conductances resistances for stems, leaves and roots ( disregarding capacitive behavior, i.e. stems, leaves and roots do not store any water) , as described in the seminal work of van den Honert [16]. The model is a physiologically explicit representation of C4 maize water-use after canopy closure. The model explicitly accounts for energy balance (convection, radiation, latent heat), transpiration, intercellular CO2 concentration (via both diffusion and biochemical processes), weather conditions (temperature, precipitation, pressure, radiation), and soil type. Seven plant hydraulic 'traits' are considered within the model, as shown in Fig. 1, and can be used to represent the response of leaf evapotranspiration to environmental variation. We next provide details of each submodel that is used to construct the full plant model. Figure 2 shows the various submodels schematically. 2 Water transport submodel Uptake of water by the root from the soil reaches the top of the canopy due to cohesive-adhesion interactions, but the main driving force for this transport is the dryness of the atmosphere. Water travels from the soil to the leaf as a liquid. Subsequently, as a gas it evaporates from the leaf (through the stomatal pores) to the surrounding environment. The evaporation rate depends on the leaf temperature, external relative humidity, air temperature and boundary layer effects. This is called environmental water demand. To fulfill this demand, the plant supplies liquid water to the leaf. This flow is driven by the potential difference of water between the soil and the leaf and is controlled by the hydraulic resistance of the plant. Using a one-dimensional representation of plant hydraulic characteristics, as shown in Fig. 1, the water supply, , can be expressed as [26] , (1) where Kplant is hydraulic conductance of the plant, Ksoil is hydraulic conductance of soil; ψleaf is the water potential at the leaf, ψsoil is water potential at the soil. Water potential is a combined effect of hydrostatic pressure, osmotic pressure, matric pressure, and gravitational pull.1 The hydraulic conductance of the plant can be expressed as , (2) where Kroot is the hydraulic conductance of the root, Kstem is hydraulic conductance of the stem, and Kleaf is hydraulic conductance of the leaf. The hydraulic conductance of the soil, Ksoil, depends on the type of soil, the amount of water in the soil and the relative occupancy of the root in the soil. The effect of these parameters is captured via the following equation [27], , (3) 1 . Osmotic pressure that depends on the presence of ions in the water is neglected in our model, as we considered the water as pure and free from any minerals. 3 sWJ,leafsoilsoilplantsWKKJ1,111111leafstemrootplantKKKKrootsbrootsoilsoilsatsatsoilrLLHkKlog2/32,where ksat, b, ψsat and ψsoil vary among the types of soil, and they represent saturated hydraulic conductivity, texture, water potential of saturated soil, and water potential of the soil, respectively. The rest of the terms are used to capture the effect of the presence of root on the soil conductance. The symbols L, Hs and rroot represent root length density of the absorbing root (length per soil volume), depth of the soil occupied by the root and radius of the root. The water potential of the soil, ψsoil, can be expressed as a function of soil water content using an empirical equation developed by Campbell et al. [28] as , (4) where θsat is the saturated water content in the soil, and θ is current volumetric water content in the soil. In this model, soil water content would gradually deplete as plants fulfill the atmospheric water demand. The depletion of water due to evaporation of water from the soil was not considered here. There is no addition of water in the case of drought conditions. However, under irrigated conditions, based on the irrigation frequency, water is added to the soil until water content reaches θsat of the soil. e.g., for irrigation frequency 7, the soil is fully saturated every 724 hours. Soil water potential at the root (Eq. 3), ψsoil,root, can be evaluated from leaf water potential and water demand by the plants, , (5) Water demand is driven by the gradient of water vapor concentration between the leaves and the surrounding environment and is controlled by the stomatal conductance and air boundary layer conductance. It can be expressed as [26] , (6) where Pvl and Pva represent water vapor pressure in the leaf and atmosphere, respectively. Water vapor pressures are evaluated using Tetens formula [29] , , where RH is the relative humidity, c0 = 0.617 kPa, c1 =17.38, and c2= 239°C. Generally, the leaf inter-cellular space is close to equilibrium with the cells having a relative humidity of greater than 99%, and thus for each of calculation of evaporation we consider the leaf to be fully saturated. gst and gblc are the stomatal conductance and boundary layer conductance to the water vapor transport, respectively. 4 bsatsatsoilsoilplantdWleafrootsoilKKJ11,,avavlblcstdWPPPggJ1,11210,cTTciiviiecRHPBoundary layer conductance to water vapor, gblc depends on the atmospheric wind speed and the morphology as well as the orientation of the leaf. Wind speed and leaf dimension are designated as Uc, and d as in [28]. Conductance of water vapor through the air boundary layer on the leaf can be considered as forced convection and can be expressed via an empirical equation. Note that, here, contribution from the free convection is neglected, as the ratio of dimensionless parameters Re2/Gr which reflects the forced convection/free convection is usually much greater thanone. The empirical correlation among the dimensionless Reynolds number, Re, and Schmidt number, Sc, and the conductance can be calculated as, , (7) where ; ; α=0.6441.4 is an empirical parameter; and de =0.72d, with d being the width of the maize leaf and 0.72 being used to find the equivalent parabola of the leaf where wind is flowing in the width direction of the parabola. Uc , νa and Dwv represent the wind speed on the top of the canopy, kinetic viscosity of air and water vapor diffusivity in air. Wind speed can increase approximately logarithmically with distance above a plant canopy, and is also influenced by the plants. The variation in wind speed can be described by , (8) where 0.4 is related to the von Karman constant, Hc is the height of the plant, mHc is the zero- plane displacement, and nHc is the roughness length. Generally, m is 0.7 and n is 0.1. U is termed the shearing or friction velocity and can be calculated from the wind speed Um that is measured at height Hm from the ground as . (9) Only around 3% of water that is absorbed from the soil is used by the plant for metabolism/growth, and less than 0.1% is used for photosynthesis. CO2 transport and net photosynthesis submodel Along with water, the plant needs CO2, sunlight and enzymes for photosynthesis. From the environment, gaseous CO2 diffuses into the leaf via stomata and then dissolves in water and diffuses to the cells where photosynthesis takes place. The consumption of CO2 during photosynthesis depends on the sunlight and enzyme activity (plants always have sufficient water to split in photosynthesis). 5 eWVblcdScDg3/12/1ReaecdUReWVaDScccccnHmHHUUln4.0ccmmnHmHHUUln4.0The rate of gaseous CO2 transport to the leaf is named as CO2 supply. The supply is driven by the CO2 concentration gradient between the atmosphere and the leaf inter-cellular space, and is controlled by the conductance of stomata and the air boundary layer. This supply can be expressed as [26] , (10) where β and χ are the ratio of CO2 conductance and water vapor conductance through stomata and air boundary layer, respectively. β is the ratio of the molecular diffusivities of H2O and CO2, χ is power ¾ of β, and CC,a and CC,i are the concentration of CO2 at the atmosphere and inside the intercellular space of the leaf. The demand of atmospheric CO2 depends on the supply of sunlight and the performance of the enzymes that control photosynthetic activity. The plant gets some CO2 as a byproduct of metabolism or respiration activity in the mitochondria and lowers the atmospheric CO2 demand. For C4 plants, the electron transport to support CO2 reduction occurs in mesophyll (C4 cycle) and bundle-sheath (C3 cycle) cells. If the supply of sunlight is lowered compared with enzyme performance, which mainly occurs during the morning, sunset, or cloudy days, the photosynthetic rate can be expressed as [30] , (11) where Je,t is the total electron transport rate is at leaf temperature, Rt is the rate of CO2 production from respiration in the mesophyll and bundle sheath cell, and is a fraction of total electrons that are used by the mesophyll. PEPCase, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase, and Rubisco are two enzymes that significantly control the photosynthesis activity in C4 plants. PEP (three-carbon backbone) controls the activity of the mesophyll cell (it catalyzes the primary carboxylation in a tissue that is close to the external atmosphere) and Rubisco controls activity in bundle sheath cell. In the case of no limitations on the supply of reductant to photosynthesis (higher light intensities), the photosynthetic demand can be expressed as, [30] , (12) Where the top expression in the right-hand side depends on the performance of PEPcase in the mesophyll cell, and the bottom expression depends on the Rubisco performance in the bundle 6 iCaCblcstsCCCggJ,,1,ttedCRJxlightJ3)1()(,,xtROmmCbsCPEPdCRVRCgVenzymeJmax,,,min)(sheath cell. gC,bs is the bundle-sheath conductance to CO2 , CC,m is the concentration of CO2 in the , CO2 concentration in inter-cellar space), mesophyll cell (note that we assume that = Rm is mitochondrial respiration in the mesophyll at leaf temperature (i.e. CO2 supply from the respiration of the mesophyll cell), Rt is the total mitochondrial respiration in the mesophyll and bundle sheath at leaf temperature, and VRO max is the maximum rubisco carboxylation rate. VPEP is the effective PEP carboxylation at leaf temperature. It depends on the availability of CO2 and the regeneration of PEP and can be expressed as [30] , (13) where the top expression in right-hand side is related to the carboxylation rate of PEP, expressed with the Michaelis-Menten Equation. is the CO2 partial pressure in Mesophyll, is the maximum PEP carboxylation rate at leaf temperature, and Kp is the Michaelis-Menten constant for PEP carboxylase for CO2 at leaf temperature. Note that the Michaelis-Menten constant, Kp, refers to the concentration of CO2 at which the reaction rate is half of VPEPmax. The carboxylation rate can be decreased if there is not enough PEP, and that depends on the VPEP,R, the PEP regeneration rate at leaf temperature. The temperature-dependent properties in the equations are evaluated using the following equations [31] , , , , , , , 7 (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) mCC,iCC,RPEPpmCPEPmCPEPVKCVCV,,,maxminmCC,maxPEPVCTATBATVROROleafleafleafROeeQVV1110/)25(,10max25max,max10/)25(,10max25max,maxleafPEPTVPEPPEPQVV10/)25(,10,,,25leafRPEPTVRPEPRPEPQVV10/)25(,1025,leafPEPTVPEPPEPQVV10/)25(,1025,leafmTRmmQRR10/)25(,1025,leaftTRttQRR)15.273(00831.025,,leafbaTJJeteeJJwhere, A, B, C , Ja and Jb are physiological parameters related to the carboxylation rate and electron transport rate. The subscript 25 in the symbols indicates the parameters at 25◦C. Hourly Je,25 can be expressed as [30] , (21) where λ is the empirical curvature factor and . fPAR_PSII is the fraction of PAR that contributes to the Photosystem II. Using the photosynthesis rate of the above two limiting cases, the CO2 demand can be expressed as [30] , (22) Energy balance on leaf submodel In the above equations many of the parameters related to leaves, for instance, water vapor pressure, enzyme activities, etc., depend on the leaf temperature. Leaf temperature can be evaluated by using first principles in so-called "big leaf models" [28]. Several assumptions are considered in this model: the leaf is flat and perpendicular to the incident sunlight; leaf does not store any energy; and energy storage ; and there is negligible heat generation due to metabolic activity in the leaf.. Considering the leaf is at steady state, the energy balance equation on a leaf can be expressed as [28] , (23) where the terms are energy input by solar irradiation and the surrounding irradiation, cooling by leaf irradiation, convective/conductive cooling by the air/temperature gradient and heat loss accompanying water evaporation. In Equation (23), a is the absorptance of the leaf, r is the reflectance, S is the solar irradiation, aIR is the absorptance of leaf for thermal infrared radiation, Lvap is the latent heat of vaporization of water, hc is the convective heat transfer coefficient, and ghbc is the air boundary conductance to heat transfer. The boundary layer conductance depends on leaf morphology and wind speed, and can be expressed via empirical relationships of dimensionless parameters Reynolds number, Re, and Prandtl number, Pr. It can be expressed as , (24) 8 2425,225,25,25,maxmaxmaxeeeeIJJIJIJPSIIPARfPARI_)(),(min,,,enzymeJlightJJdCdCdC0]2[]1[,44vapdWaleafhbcpleafIRaIRLJTTgCTeTaSraeHhbcdDg3/12/1PrRewhere ; ; β=0.6441.4 is an empirical parameter; de =0.72d, with d being the width of maize leaf and 0.72 being used to find the equivalent parabola of the leaf where the wind is flowing in the width direction of the parabola. Uc , νa and DH represent the wind speed on the top of the canopy, kinetic viscosity of air and thermal diffusivity in air. The effect of the temporal variation of soil is not explicitly included in Equation (23). Instead, the effect was implemented using the FAO56 algorithm, as in [32]. Stomatal conductance submodel In the pathway of the supply of CO2 (Eq. (10)) from the environment and demand of H2O (Eq. (6)) to the environment, stomatal conductance is the most significant parameter. In general, stomatal conductance is around several orders of magnitude lower than that for air boundary layer conductance. Stomatal conductance is a very complex parameter that is affected by environment, plant physiology and heredity. At least 35 empirical models have been proposed to capture the complex relationship between stomata conductance and various factors including [5], [8], [33]–[38] Such factors include environmental factors, for example, solar radiation, soil water content, humidity and wind speed, etc., and physiological factors, for example, leaf water potential, root water potential, hydraulic root conductance, etc. Few models explicitly include the plant physiological influences on the stomatal conductance apart from entirely empirical functions. Here, we propose a model which is developed based on the sigmodal response of the stomatal conductance with respect to the leaf water potential [39]. The main concept of this model is shown in Fig. 1. Here, the stomatal conductance will start decreasing when leaf water potential touches the threshold potential, which depends on the plant genotype. Closing rate is controlled by the two sensitivity terms Sl and Sr and also the root water potential. The model is expressed as, , (25) where the environmental response on the stomatal conductance is implicitly influenced by JC,d and ψleaf . ψth is the threshold bulk leaf water potential at stomatal closure, and Sr is the slope of are plant the relationship between stomatal conductance and root water potential, ψroot. and physiological properties related to photosynthesis. Z is a parameter to make the exponent dimensionless. Method to evaluate net photosynthesis and water usage Figure 2 shows the schematic of the concept and Fig. 3 shows the flow chart of the model implementation. For the input weather condition, soil and agronomic/management practices the net photosynthesis and water transpiration (Tr) can be evaluated iteratively by satisfying (Eq. 6) 9 aecdUReHaDPrZSSthleafgdCstrrootlJgggg0526.01,min2,1maxmin1g2g(Eq. 10), (Eq. 23) and (Eq. 25). A plant is considered dead and net photosynthesis is zero if the plant experiences a permanent wilting condition or permanent temperature damage. Both states cause irreversible damage to the plant. Framework for crop design Ideotype design requires identifying the optimal combination of plant physiological traits to maximize photosynthesis for specific environmental conditions and management practices. We formulate the design problem as an optimization problem. Thus, by writing photosynthesis as the following functional form, The optimization problem is defined as , (26) where i represents different conditions related with agronomic practices (e.g. no-irrigation, weekly irrigation, etc.), weather conditions, or soil type. is a weighing factor that depends on the preference of the designer. Physiological traits and location/weather/management conditions Physiological Traits: In our model, a plant has been represented by 37 physiological traits. Typical values of most of those traits were collected from the current literature (Table 1). Note that these traits represent the adult crop. The traits used in the photosynthetic submodel were collected via gas exchange calibration. Among the 37 traits in this study, we considered seven hydraulic traits: minimum stomatal opening ( ); maximum stomatal opening ( ); sensitivity of stomatal opening with leaf water potential ( ); threshold bulk leaf water potential at stomatal closure ( ); sensitivity of with root water potential ( ); shoot hydraulic conductance ( ); and root hydraulic conductance ( ). These traits affect the stomatal conductance which is a vital trait for photosynthesis [ref]. For the optimization problem, those traits were bounded within the ranges in Table 2, ranges currently found in nature. Traits related to the photosynthetic submodel: Parameters used in the photosynthetic submodel are difficult to find in literature. Seventeen physiological parameters used in the model (that are related to the photosynthesis equations 14-20) were calibrated using gas exchange data. The net photosynthetic rate (An) was calibrated using gas exchange measurements made on leaves of two maize plants grown in mini-lysimeters at the Davis Agricultural experimental station in June to July 2013. Net photosynthetic rate was modelled as a function of three inputs: intercellular CO2 concentration, photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) and leaf temperature. Thus, these three variables were varied using a LI-COR 6400 gas exchange system to obtain sufficient variation to calibrate the photosynthesis submodel. 10 Traits fANNiiiTraitTraitTraitsAN1....)2,1(maxargmingmaxglSthlSrSshootKrootKThe CO2 response data is shown in Fig. 4(a-b) and the PAR-light-response data in Fig. 4(c-d). The entire dataset was used to calibrate the C4 photosynthetic parameters using an optimization algorithm. Location/weather/management conditions: We considered a drought-prone environment condition, i.e. Davis, CA in 2010 June-July (see S1) with clay soil (see Table 1) and irrigation frequency of seven days. Method to implement crop design framework There are several approaches to solve this optimization problem. Here, we utilize a gradient free, evolutionary optimization strategy. This strategy is selected because, as Figure 5 shows, the cost functional (Equation 26, when varying only two traits) is non-convex and corrugated. This highly-corrugated surface has many local maximum. This precludes the utilization of gradient- based methods, and instead suggests the applicability of stochastic, multistart methods that can explore the phase space efficiently. We specifically use a genetic algorithm (GA) (a gradient-free meta-heuristic evolutionary search algorithm) to identify the optimal traits. GA is well suited to multi-modal, highly corrugated solution spaces, especially when the cost function is not easily adapted to gradient-based methods. Because GA deploys a population of potential solutions distributed over the design space, they are less prone to getting stuck in shallow local minima. GA is an inherently stochastic method, so we repeat each optimization multiple times (10 times) to consider statistical significance of results and attempt to reliably explore the phase space. The implementation framework can be found in Figure 6. Results and discussion Plant Physiology Model Validation The physiological model is implemented in MATLAB with inputs of soil and hourly weather data over a 60-day period. Each model evaluation for a given trait configuration – producing hourly outputs – took about 40 seconds on a standard laptop. The plant physiology model builds on the water transport model, and the temperature model depends on the conservation principles, which are inherently satisfied in our method. Therefore, we perform a validation exercise on the photosynthetic submodel. The excerise was performed where marked leaves on 14 maize plants, growing adjacent to the calibration plants, were monitored repeatedly using the LI-COR 6400 gas exchange system for a day. During that period the plants were subjected to a diurnal gradient of low to high ambient temperature, and a range of light. A subset of the plants also had water withheld to evaluate the photosynthetic submodel's performance under water stress. 11 The photosynthesis submodel, trained on the light, temperature and CO2 response curves, successfully predicted the photosynthesis of the 14 validation plants during the day of drought and varying temperature (Fig. 7). Current models of photosynthesis do not account for major damage to the photosynthetic apparatus in a mechanistic manner. Thus, the model is unable to predict photosynthetic rates of a couple of points that represented very severely stressed plants. Design of ideotypes We deployed the crop design framework on the computing clusters available at Iowa State (CyEnce cluster) and via NSF XSEDE resources at TACC (Stampede). The simulations usually took about 4 hours to run for each optimization run on a server with 16 core 2.0 GHz Processer with 128 GB RAM. Optimizations were initialized with different random seeds and rerun 10 times. In this process, over one million distinct trait combinations were evaluated, and 10 ideotypes were designed. Comparison between Designed Crop and a Typical Crop Figure 8 (A) shows that the ideotype produces 10% higher net photosynthesis (yield) than that of the typical maize. To investigate that, we compare and explore the performances of those two crops on the hottest day of the season, June 27. The weather on that day is shown in Figure 8, with an average daytime temperature of 39.810C. Starting from the morning, the hourly value of solar radiation increases till midday and then decreases till sunset. Relative humidity is high at night and it decreases during the daytime. Hourly precipitations on that day are zero. It is noted that the atmospheric temperature increased as the day progresses and went as high as 430C. This temperature is higher than the optimum functional temperature of maize plants. Thus, plants that can cool their leaves are desirable. Figure 8 (D-E) reveals that for the above weather inputs, at the early and later part of the day, there is no significant variation of hourly net Photosynthesis (An) between the two plants. However, significant variation is observed at the midday. Photosynthesis depends on CO2, PAR, enzyme and temperature. Midday generally has enough PAR, so An depends on CO2 supply, enzyme performance and temperature. In our study, the enzyme performance profile is the same for both of the plants. Therefore, midday variation of An depends on the supply of CO2 and temperature. Figure 8 shows that during the midday period the average CO2 supply is 180 and 200 ppm for the typical maize and ideotype, respectively. The leaf temperature of the ideotype is lower than that of the typical maize. These two conditions enable a higher An for the ideotype (Fig 8). The lower temperature facilitates a shorter duration in which the leaf temperature is above the optimum temperature for photosynthesis. Reduced CO2 and lower temperature are related to high stomatal conductance, as shown in Fig. 8. Therefore, Figure 8 (F &G) shows that the typical maize plant has lower stomatal conductance than that of an ideotype, but should create higher concentration gradient by lower CO2 12 concentration than that of an ideotype in the early part of the day. Figure 8 (E & H) shows that, due to low stomatal conductance of the typical plant, the cooling of the leaf due to transpiration of water is lower, and as a result, leaf temperature is higher than that of an ideotype. In short, the main driver behind the increase of photosynthesis for the ideotype is the positive shift of stomatal opening operating range. Values and Significance of the Traits of the optimized ideotype The positive shift of stomatal conductance depends on the convoluted effect of the seven traits. Here, we present and discuss on the values and significance of the traits. Designed Values of the Traits Our framework provides ten different combinations of traits for the designed crop (Fig 9), all of them has the same yield (photosynthesis). Based on the variability, we came up with following two hypotheses: 1) any values of traits within the upper and lower values of suggested traits can be a design crop; 2) some traits might be insensitive for our condition and some traits have threshold values after which they are insensitive. Hypothesis 1 does not hold when we use arbitrary combinations of traits within the ranges (see Fig S2). To test the second hypothesis, we perform sensitivity analysis for all ten combinations by varying one parameter within the allowable range while keeping the others fixed. The sensitivity plots indicate that there are threshold values for all of the parameters. There are higher limits for Sl, ψth, Sr and lower limits for gmin, gmax, kshoot and kroot. Maintaining those threshold values and subtly changing the other threshold values in the opposite direction shows the decrease in photosynthesis. Significance of the Traits In short, photosynthesis mostly depends on the available sunlight, CO2 and temperature. Among these parameters, CO2 and temperature can be optimized by adjusting hydraulic parameters. Among the hydraulic parameters: gmin and gmax are the most directly constraining. gst (a direct function of gmin and gmax) is the dominating parameter in the transport pathways (causes the highest path resistance for both CO2 and H2O transports). Rate of water transpiration controls the cooling effect on the leaves. Cooling (not freezing) is always beneficial during the night (it reduces the cost of respiration), however, during day it may have positive or negative effect on the photosynthesis based on the optimum temperature for the enzyme activity (Fig 8). Other variables including kshoot, Sl, Sr, ψth, kroot primarily ensure that the plant does not reach the permanent wilting potential. These values will affect the gst if the plant senses water scarcity when leaf water potential reaches the 'red alert' point, indicated by ψth value. More specifically, for our designed ideotype 13 • gmax should be higher than a specific value, so that the plant is able to use its available photosynthetic capacity. The required value of gmax mostly depends on the highest solar radiation (PPF: photosensitive photon flux density, mostly 400 and 700 nm). • gmin should be as high as possible to reduce night-time respiration cost, although it may increase the irrigation cost for the season. gmin sets the minimum transpiration the plant can do under high VPD or extreme soil water deficit, and thus affects the rate of water depletion under the most extreme of circumstances. • Our designed ideotypes do not feel water stress (i.e. red alert) in well-watered conditions, and are never forced to adjust gst due to water-related issues. However, an ideotype's kplant and red alert value, ψth, must be selected appropriately. A lower kplant than the specified value may cause a leaf water potential that is lower than the 'red alert' value, i.e. the plant will register water stress. A similar effect will happen if the plant increases (less negative) the ψth value. Required values for kplant and ψth have an inverse relationship. Therefore, to reduce the cost of root generation, the plant should operate at the lowest (more negative) possible ψth, i.e. a value close to the permanent wilting potential, thus lowering the kplant requirement, i.e. it refers to less root production. Tradeoff between below ground mass and photosynthesis/above ground mass Next, we extrapolate our results from our design space (reproductive stage) to vegetative stage. During the vegetative stage, to increase the photosynthetic capability of the plant (LAI), a bigger shoots could be better, whereas smaller roots would help the plant to invest more resources into growing the shoot. Therefore, we explore the effect of a smaller root, i.e. smaller kroot, on the net photosynthesis of the ideotypes. Figure 10 shows that a 50% reduction of kroot from 40 to 20 reduces the net photosynthesis by only 0.06%. For the reduced kroot plant, the leaf water potential sometimes reaches lower than the threshold leaf water potential (ψth) and closes (Figure 11). The modified plant has the potential to increase LAI during the vegetative stage, leading to improvement in net photosynthesis (yield). Conclusions An integrated framework of optimization, thermodynamics and plant physiology was developed to design a crop ideotype. The backbone of the framework is a 1-D plant physiology model and the coupling of transport and energy conversion models based on laws of thermodynamics. The models were augmented with a nature-inspired meta-heuristic optimization method, the genetic algorithm (GA), and was implemented via the MATLAB® software. The framework was used to design maize crop for a drought-prone weather condition in Davis, CA. Seven physiological traits which are primarily related to plant hydraulics and ultimately affect the photosynthesis and water usage were considered in the study. The traits are minimum stomatal opening ( ); maximum stomatal opening ( ); sensitivity of stomatal opening with leaf water potential ( ); threshold bulk leaf water potential at stomatal closure ( ); and sensitivity of with root 14 mingmaxglSthlSwater potential ( ); shoot hydraulic conductance ( ); and root hydraulic conductance ( ). With enough irrigation, the designed crop showed 10% improvement in yield, and , and are found to be the vital traits. Currently, the model is using hourly data; however, it could be easily modified for more frequent data. The framework is modular and can be easily augmented with other existing mechanistic models to capture more physics. The developed tool can help plant breeders and scientists to determine the optimal crop ideotypes for various climates (climate-smart crops) and locations. Integration of the developed framework with breeding programs can speed the crop development process, wherein the framework can be used to propose ideotypes for target environments and the breeder can breed plants like based on the ideotypes. Potentially, ideotypes designed using a different crop model might look different from those presented, as shown for wheat in [40]. These models can simulate observed yields under a range of environments for the current conditions. However, simulated climate change impacts could vary across models due to differences in model structures and parameter values [41]. Further improvements of crop models and a more rigorous framework will be required for robust crop ideotype design. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS T.Z.J, B.G, D.A gratefully acknowledge financial support from the Presidential initiative for interdisciplinary research of Iowa State University. B.G and T.Z.J gratefully acknowledge the Plant Science Institute at Iowa State University, and computing support via NSF XSEDE CTS110007. M.E.G gratefully acknowledges support via USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture, Hatch project number #1001480. AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS: D.A formed the interdisciplinary team and proposed to couple numerical optimization and plant physiology, D.A, M.E.G, B.G designed research plan, M.E.G. designed the crop hydraulic model, B.G. implemented model, all authors improved the model, B.G and T.Z.J designed the optimization framework, T.Z.J ran the simulations and processed the data, all authors analyzed data and wrote the paper. COMPETING FINANCIAL INTERESTS The author(s) declare no competing financial interests. 15 rSshootKrootKmaxgmingthReferences [1] H. C. J. Godfray et al., "Food Security: The Challenge of Feeding 9 Billion People," Science, vol. 327, no. 5967, pp. 812–818, Feb. 2010. [2] A. J. Challinor, F. Ewert, S. Arnold, E. Simelton, and E. Fraser, "Crops and climate change: progress, trends, and challenges in simulating impacts and informing adaptation," J. Exp. Bot., vol. 60, no. 10, pp. 2775–2789, Jul. 2009. [3] K. J. Boote, M. J. Kropff, and P. S. Bindraban, "Physiology and modelling of traits in crop plants: implications for genetic improvement," Agric. Syst., vol. 70, no. 2–3, pp. 395–420, Nov. 2001. [4] P. Martre, B. Quilot-Turion, D. Luquet, M.-M. O.-S. Memmah, K. Chenu, and P. Debaeke, "Model-assisted phenotyping and ideotype design," in Crop Physiology, Elsevier, 2015, pp. 349–373. [5] K. H. Jensen, J. Lee, T. Bohr, H. Bruus, N. M. Holbrook, and M. A. Zwieniecki, "Optimality of the Münch mechanism for translocation of sugars in plants," J. R. Soc. Interface, vol. 8, no. 61, pp. 1155–1165, Aug. 2011. [6] C. Doussan, L. Pagès, and G. Vercambre, "Modelling of the Hydraulic Architecture of Root Systems: An Integrated Approach to Water Absorption-Model Description," Ann. Bot., vol. 81, no. 2, pp. 213–223, Feb. 1998. [7] C.-T. Lai and G. Katul, "The dynamic role of root-water uptake in coupling potential to actual transpiration," Adv. Water Resour., vol. 23, no. 4, pp. 427–439, Jan. 2000. [8] P. J. Sellers, Y. Mintz, Y. C. Sud, and A. Dalcher, "A Simple Biosphere Model (SIB) for Use within General Circulation Models," J. Atmospheric Sci., vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 505–531, Mar. 1986. [9] T. Vogel, M. Dohnal, J. Dusek, J. Votrubova, and M. Tesar, "Macroscopic Modeling of Plant Water Uptake in a Forest Stand Involving Root-Mediated Soil Water Redistribution," Vadose Zone J., vol. 12, no. 1, Feb. 2013. [10] J. Rings et al., "Bayesian Inference of Tree Water Relations Using a Soil-Tree-Atmosphere Continuum Model," Procedia Environ. Sci., vol. 19, pp. 26–36, Jan. 2013. [11] V. Couvreur, J. Vanderborght, and M. Javaux, "A simple three-dimensional macroscopic root water uptake model based on the hydraulic architecture approach," Hydrol Earth Syst Sci, vol. 16, no. 8, pp. 2957–2971, Aug. 2012. [12] J. Wang, Q. Yu, and X. Lee, "Simulation of crop growth and energy and carbon dioxide fluxes at different time steps from hourly to daily," Hydrol. Process., vol. 21, no. 18, pp. 2474–2492, Aug. 2007. [13] K. Steppe, D. J. W. De Pauw, R. Lemeur, and P. A. Vanrolleghem, "A mathematical model linking tree sap flow dynamics to daily stem diameter fluctuations and radial stem growth," Tree Physiol., vol. 26, no. 3, pp. 257–273, Mar. 2006. [14] F. Somma, J. W. Hopmans, and V. Clausnitzer, "Transient three-dimensional modeling of soil water and solute transport with simultaneous root growth, root water and nutrient uptake," Plant Soil, vol. 202, no. 2, pp. 281–293, May 1998. [15] R. A. Duursma and B. E. Medlyn, "MAESPA: a model to study interactions between water limitation, environmental drivers and vegetation function at tree and stand levels, with an example application to [CO2] ? drought interactions," Geosci. Model Dev. Katlenburg- Lindau, vol. 5, no. 4, p. 919, 2012. [16] T. H. van den Honert, "Water transport in plants as a catenary process," Discuss. Faraday Soc., vol. 3, no. 0, pp. 146–153, 1948. 16 [17] A. Askarzadeh, "Bird mating optimizer: An optimization algorithm inspired by bird mating strategies," Commun. Nonlinear Sci. Numer. Simul., vol. 19, no. 4, pp. 1213–1228, Apr. 2014. [18] I. F. Jr, X.-S. Yang, D. Fister, and I. Fister, "Cuckoo Search: A Brief Literature Review," in Cuckoo Search and Firefly Algorithm, X.-S. Yang, Ed. Springer International Publishing, 2014, pp. 49–62. [19] K. Elofsson, G. Bengtsson, and I.-M. Gren, "Optimal Management of Invasive Species with Different Reproduction and Survival Strategies," Nat. Resour. Model., vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 599–628, Nov. 2012. [20] C. Riedelsheimer and A. E. Melchinger, "Optimizing the allocation of resources for genomic selection in one breeding cycle," TAG Theor. Appl. Genet. Theor. Angew. Genet., vol. 126, no. 11, pp. 2835–2848, Nov. 2013. [21] C. XiangWei, Y. TianLi, and Y. GongMing, "Research advances in non-destructive prediction technologies using VIS/NIR spectroscopy for kiwifruit property," Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, 20-Jul-2006. [Online]. Available: https://eurekamag.com/research/012/927/012927668.php. [Accessed: 21-Mar-2017]. [22] G. Decoux and F. Hospital, "Popmin: A Program for the Numerical Optimization of Population Sizes in Marker-Assisted Backcross Programs," J. Hered., vol. 93, no. 5, pp. 383–384, Sep. 2002. [23] S. Manzoni, G. Vico, S. Palmroth, A. Porporato, and G. Katul, "Optimization of stomatal conductance for maximum carbon gain under dynamic soil moisture," Adv. Water Resour., vol. 62, pp. 90–105, Dec. 2013. [24] M. A. Semenov and P. Stratonovitch, "Designing high-yielding wheat ideotypes for a changing climate," Food Energy Secur., vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 185–196, Dec. 2013. [25] V. Picheny et al., "Finding realistic and efficient plant phenotypes using numerical models," ArXiv Prepr. ArXiv160303238, 2016. [26] N. Park, Physicochemical & environmental plant physiology, Park vols. Academic Press, 2009. [27] I. R. Cowan, "Transport of Water in the Soil-Plant-Atmosphere System," J. Appl. Ecol., vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 221–239, 1965. [28] G. S. Campbell and J. M. Norman, An introduction to environmental biophysics. New York, NY, USA: Springer, 1998. [29] A. L. Buck, "New Equations for Computing Vapor Pressure and Enhancement Factor," J. Appl. Meteorol., vol. 20, no. 12, pp. 1527–1532, Dec. 1981. [30] S. V. Caemmerer, Biochemical models of leaf photosynthesis. 2000. [31] G. J. Collatz, M. Ribas-Carbo, and J. A. Berry, "Coupled Photosynthesis-Stomatal Conductance Model for Leaves of C4 Plants," Funct. Plant Biol., vol. 19, no. 5, pp. 519– 538, Oct. 1992. [32] R. G. Allen, L. S. Pereira, D. Raes, M. Smith, and others, "Crop evapotranspiration- Guidelines for computing crop water requirements-FAO Irrigation and drainage paper 56," FAO Rome, vol. 300, no. 9, p. D05109, 1998. [33] Z. Dong, O. Danilevskaya, T. Abadie, C. Messina, N. Coles, and M. Cooper, "A Gene Regulatory Network Model for Floral Transition of the Shoot Apex in Maize and Its Dynamic Modeling," PLOS ONE, vol. 7, no. 8, p. e43450, Aug. 2012. 17 [34] M. A. Zwieniecki, H. A. Stone, A. Leigh, C. K. Boyce, and N. M. Holbrook, "Hydraulic design of pine needles: one-dimensional optimization for single-vein leaves," Plant Cell Environ., vol. 29, no. 5, pp. 803–809, May 2006. [35] D. N. L. Menge, F. Ballantyne, and J. S. Weitz, "Dynamics of nutrient uptake strategies: lessons from the tortoise and the hare," Theor. Ecol., vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 163–177, May 2011. [36] V. M. Dunbabin, S. McDermott, and A. G. Bengough, "Upscaling from Rhizosphere to Whole Root System: Modelling the Effects of Phospholipid Surfactants on Water and Nutrient Uptake," Plant Soil, vol. 283, no. 1–2, pp. 57–72, May 2006. [37] A. J. Guswa, "Soil-moisture limits on plant uptake: An upscaled relationship for water- limited ecosystems," Adv. Water Resour., vol. 28, no. 6, pp. 543–552, Jun. 2005. [38] G. Damour, T. Simonneau, H. Cochard, and L. Urban, "An overview of models of stomatal conductance at the leaf level," Plant Cell Environ., vol. 33, no. 9, pp. 1419–1438, Sep. 2010. [39] T. J. Brodribb and N. M. Holbrook, "Declining hydraulic efficiency as transpiring leaves desiccate: two types of response," Plant Cell Environ., vol. 29, no. 12, pp. 2205–2215, Dec. 2006. [40] S. Asseng et al., "Uncertainty in simulating wheat yields under climate change," Nat. Clim. Change, vol. 3, no. 9, pp. 827–832, Sep. 2013. [41] R. P. Rötter, T. R. Carter, J. E. Olesen, and J. R. Porter, "Crop-climate models need an overhaul," Nat. Clim. Change Lond., vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 175–177, Jul. 2011. 18 Figures and Legends Figure 1: A conventional resistance or conductance (resistance=1/conductance) model of maize hydraulics (panel a), and the model used for simulating maize hydraulics including feedbacks (panel b). The conductance of the stomata to water vapor (gst) and CO2 is modulated by the water potential of the leaf (ψleaf) if below a threshold (ψth). The stomatal opening is scaled to the maximum stomatal conductance (gmax; a proxy of how many stomata and how wide they open) which sets the maximum water loss rate and the maximum CO2 uptake rate for sunlit leaves. How effective stomatal closure is (minimum stomatal conductance; gmin) is determined by cuticle waxes which stop water loss from the leaf surface, affecting the rate of desiccation under drought, but this state also prevents CO2 uptake. The slope of the response is tuned by an inherent sensitivity (Sl) or a contribution of the root, based upon sensing of soil drying (Sr). The supply of water is proportional to the difference of water potential between soil and air, and inversely proportional to three conductances in series: Ksoil, Kroot, and Kstem+leaf. The demand for water is driven by environmental variables: the boundary layer conductance and the temperature of the leaf. The leaf temperature is determined through an energy balance and influences both transpiration and a coupled model of photosynthesis. 19 ψsoilRsoilRrootRstemRleafTrrstrblcψleafψair1/KsoilYsoilYleaf1/Kleaf1/Kstem1/Kroot1/gblcYairTr1/gsta1/Kroot1/gblcψleaf ψth ψsoilTr1/gmaxbreaks at ψleaf <ψth 1/gmin-1/gmaxResistanceadjustment1/gst1/gstΨair ψrootf(Sl ,Sr)1/Kshoot1/gst-1/gmaxbFigure 1Figure 2: Model input, output and connectivity among the submodels. 20 Figure 3: Flowchart for the implementation of plant physiology model 21 Evaluate ψleaf by satisfying supply and demand of water via minimizing (Jw,d-Jw,s)2. Supply of water from soil to the leaf, Jw,d, and evaporation of water vapor from leaf to the atmosphere Jw,s, are calculated from equations, (1) and (6), respectively. Evaluate leaf temperature (Tleaf) by considering energy equilibrium on the leaf via satisfying equation (23)Evaluate CO2concentration inside the intercellular space of the leaf (Cc,i) by satisfying transport balance via minimizing (JC,s-JC,d)2. supply of CO2 from the environment, JC,sand the damend of CO2by the plant, JC,d, are calculated from equations (10) and (22), respectively.At a particular time step, ticalculate soil water potential using Eq. 4Guess stomatal conductance, gst(gst,new–gst)2<tolCalculate corrected gst,newusing Eq25Two factors must be favorable for a leaf to remain alive: leaf water potential (ψwilt) and temperature (Tdamage) must remain within nonlethal bounds. Check for survival of plant: if ψleaf ≤ψwilt or Tleaf ≤TdamageUsing corrected gst,new, evaluate ψleaf, Tleaf, and Cc,iusing steps 3,4 and 5, respectivley Store water loss/usage, Tr = Jw,d, and net CO2consumption, An = Jc,das photoCumulative photosynthesis, Photo = sum(photoiΔt), and cumulative water usage =sum(TriΔt) gst = gst,newti+1= ti+Δt, Δt is the period of the inputted weather dataAverage net photosynthesis must be positive for a leaf to remain alive. Output: Photo and Water UsageOutput:Photo = 0yesnoyesnoyesnonoyesti+1<periodStartFigure S1Figure 4: (a-b) CO2 responses of maize photosynthesis at varying leaf temperatures for two plants used in the calibration of the photosynthesis submodel. Lines connect points measured at the same leaf temperature. (c-d) Response of maize photosynthesis to photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) measured at varying leaf temperatures for two plants used in the calibration. Lines connect points measured at the same leaf temperature. 22 -1001020304050-1001020304050Predicted An ( mol/m 2/s)Observed An ( mol/m 2/s)abcdeFigure S4 Figure 5: Distribution of photosynthesis, in terms of CO2 assimilation, within the selected ranges of gmin and ψth for typical maize as in Table 1. 23 Figure 6: Flowchart of crop design framework implementation. 24 Figure 7: Validation of the C4 photosynthesis submodel. The circles represent the predicted and observed calibration data for light, CO2 and temperature responses for plant 1 and triangles for plant 2. The diamonds represent the validation data: the observed and predicted photosynthesis of 14 plants measured over a day varying in drought treatments, temperature and light. The points that deviate from the 1:1 relationship were plants that underwent the greatest drought stress during the hottest time of the day, and represent photosynthetic inhibition or damage. 25 -1001020304050-1001020304050Predicted An ( mol/m 2/s)Observed An ( mol/m 2/s)abcdeFigure S4 Figure 8: (A) Hourly cumulative photosynthesis for the typical plant (red line) and the sets of simulated ideotypes at well-irrigated condition. For simulated plants, the profiles are overlapped. Here, instead of days of the months, time has been presented as hours. (B-C) Hourly variation of solar radiation and relative humidity on June 27. (D-E) Hourly variation of photosynthesis (An), concentration inside the leaf. (F) Green for PEP limited case, Orange for Rubisco and CO2 limited case, Red symbol (for ideotypes) is the net effect with CO2 concentration 180 ppm, Gray symbol (for typical) is the net effect with CO2 concentration 120 ppm. Blue lines are light (PAR) limited case. (G-H) Hourly variation of variation stomatal conductance with respect to minimum conductance, and leaf temperature. 26 4am8am124pm8pmAn(mol/m2)0102030404am8am124pm8pmgst-gmin(mol/mss)00.10.20.34am8am124pm8pmCi(ppm)02004006004am8am124pm8pmPAR(mmol/m2s)Ta(o)C00.511.5225303540454am8am124pm8pmRH(%)Uc(m/s)406080123June1June15July31Photo(mol/m2)20406080Photo4am8am124pm8pmTleaf(oC)2025303540An(mol/m2s)Tleaf(0C)0204060204011am1pm9am6am7am6pm4pm2pmABCDEFGHFigure 9: Variation of the traits among the outcomes obtained via optimizations. The big red symbol corresponds to the typical value and the numbers indicate the upper and lower limits of the traits (Table 1). 27 Figure 10: (top) Effect of kroot on the photosynthesis (mid-bottom) hourly variation of stomatal conductance and leaf water potential for the designed ideotype (red) and modified ideotype (blue). 28 Table 1 Management/Agronomic parameters, plant physiological parameters of typical maize, and bio-chemistry parameters for gas exchange calculations. Management/Agronomic parameters , Soil-texture-dependent parameter (unit less) , Saturated soil hydraulic conductivity [mol m-1 s-1 MPa-1] [MPa] ( Saturated water content in the soil) [m3 m-3] (depth of soil) [m] Rs, Radius of soil occupied/supplied for one plant [m] Irrigation frequency (day) Plant physiological parameters L, Root length density (m m-3) rroot, Root radius at the end of rhizosphere (m) d, leaf width (m) Hc, Height of the plant (m) Permanent wilting soil water potential for leaf wilting (MPa) Temperature for permanent leaf damage (0C) LAI, Leaf area index, [m2m-2] Plant Hydraulic Parameters , minimum stomatal conductance mol m-2s-1 , maximum stomatal conductance mol m -2 -1 s , response of stomatal conductance with leaf water potential mol m -2 s -1 MPa -1 , response of stomatal conductance upon sensing drying soil mol m -2 -1 s MPa -2 , threshold of leaf water potential for stomatal closure, MPa , hydraulic conductance of leaf mmol m -2 s -1 MPa -1 Kroot, hydraulic conductance of root mmol m-2s-1MPa-1 Kroot, hydraulic conductance of stem mmol m-2s-1MPa-1 Bio-chemistry parameters from gas exchange data 14.95 1.69 -0.00598 0.39 1 0.1128 7 15200 0.0005 0.1 1 -1.33 60 1 0.02 0.25 15 -1.25 200 45 45 45 (unitless) (unitless) 0.0036 (unitless) 1.1693 x (unitless) 4.93 0.0844 (unitless) (unit less) (unit less) 13.1 (unitless) 0.00445 (unit less) (unit less) A (unit less) 0.945 0.094 (unitless) 0.0715 [mol m-2 s-1] 322.3 B (unit less) 31.6 [mol m-2 s-1] 51 [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] 1.39 1.55 5.57 2.28 96.1 29 bsatksatsatsHmingmaxglSrSthleafK1gbJmax,10PEPVQ2g10,QdRmax,,10RVPEPQaJmax,10ROVQ25,tR25max,J25,,RPEPV25max,PEPVC (unit less) 42.1 [mol m-2 s-1] 126.7 30 25max,ROVTable 2 Bounds to hydraulic parameters varied in the genetic algorithm. Lower bound Upper bound mol m-2s-1 mol m-2s-1MPa-1 mol m-2s-1MPa-2 MPa mmol m-2s-1 MPa-1 1e-6 0.07 =0 =0 -1.33 1e-6 1e-6 3 3.0 =89.99 =89.99 0 30 60 31 mingmaxgllStanrrStanthstemleafKrootKlrlrNomenclature - - - Absorptance of leaf Absorptance of leaf for thermal infrared radiation Constant related with carboxylation rate [mol m-2 s-1] Hourly net assimilation or net photosynthesis - - - - - kPa - ° C - Soil texture dependent parameter Parameter related with probabilistic GA formulation Parameter related with probabilistic GA formulation Parameter related with probabilistic GA formulation Constant related with carboxylation rate Constant related with Tetens formula Constant related with Tetens formula Constant related with Tetens formula Constant related with carboxylation rate [Pa Pa-1] or ppm Atmosphere CO2 partial pressure, or concentration [Pa Pa-1] or ppm Intercellular airspace CO2 partial pressure, or concentration [Pa Pa-1] Mesophyll CO2 partial pressure, or concentration. [J mol-1K-1] Specific heat of air. [m] [m] [m2s-1] [m2s-1] Leaf average width Parameter related with leaf width Thermal diffusivity in air Water vapor diffusivity in air - Fraction of PAR contributes to the Photosystem II 32 aIRaAAnb0b1b2bB0c1c2cCacC,icC,mcC,PCdedHDWVDPSIIPARf_ - - [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] - [m] [m] [m] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] lant physiological parameter related with photosynthesis or CO2 assimilation lant physiological parameter related with photosynthesis or CO2 assimilation Boundary conductance to water transport Boundary conductance to heat transfer on leaf surface. Minimum Stomatal conductance, or stomatal conductance at light compensation point, minimum stomatal conductance to water vapor including epidermal conductance Maximum Stomata conductance Bundle-sheath conductance to CO2 Effective stomata conductance to water Grashof number Depth of soil Height of the plant Height at which wind speed obtained from weather data A parameter related with electron transport rate Physiological parameter related with electron transport rate Physiological parameter related with electron transport rate CO2 demand by photosynthetic activity based enzyme limited condition CO2 demand by photosynthetic activity based sunlight limited condition total electron transport rate is at leaf temperature total electron transport rate is at 25 ° C [mol m-2 s-1] Maximum total electron transport rate is at 25 ° C 33 1g2gblcghbcgmingmaxgbsCg,stgGrsHcHmHIaJbJ(enzyme),dCJ)(,lightJdCteJ,25,eJ25max,eJ [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] Rate of water vapor demanded by atmosphere from leaf Rate of water supplied from soil to leaf [mol m-2 s-1 Pa-1] hydraulic conductivity of saturated soil [mol m-2 s-1 Pa-1] leaf hydraulic conductance to water [mol m-2 s-1 Pa-1] the Michaelis-Menten constant [mol m-2 s-1 Pa-1] plant hydraulic conductance to water [mol m-2 s-1 Pa-1] root hydraulic conductance to water [mol m-2 s-1 Pa-1] soil hydraulic conductance to water [mol m-2 s-1 Pa-1] stem hydraulic conductance to water [m m-3] [J mol-1] [m2m-2] - - [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 ] [mol m-2 s-1] - [Pa] [Pa] [Pa] Root length density , root length per unit volume of soil Latent heat of vaporization of water. Leaf area index a factor related with zero plane displacement for wind speed a factor related to the momentum roughness parameter for wind speed Hourly net CO2 assimilation Total photo Photo active radiation Initial population in genetic algorithm Atmospheric pressure Prandtl number Vapor pressure of air Vapor pressure of leaf surface 34 dWJ,sWJ,satkleafKpKplantKrootKsoilKstemKLvapLLAImnphotoPhotoPARoPaPPrvaPvlP - - - - - Q10 coefficient conversion factor related to mitochondrial respiration calculation Q10 coefficient conversion factor related to maximum PEP carboxylation Q10 coefficient conversion factor related to maximum PEP regeneration Q10 coefficient conversion factor related to maximum rubisco carboxylation Reflectance, i.e. amount of sunlight reflected from surroundings, the [m] Root radius including rhizosphere [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] - - [W m -2] - Total mitochondrial respiration in the mesophyll and bundle sheath at leaf temperature Total mitochondrial respiration in the mesophyll and bundle sheath at 25° C temperature Reynolds number Relative humidity of surrounding air. Solar radiation, Schmidt number [mol m-2 s-1MPa-1] Slope of stomatal conductance with leaf water potential [mol m-2 s-1MPa-2] Slope of with root water potential [° C] [° C] [° C] [mol m-2 s-1] [m s-1] [m s-1] Temperature of air Temperature of leaf leaf temperature at permanent leaf damage Rate of water transpires from soil to environment through the plant Wind speed on the canopy Wind speed from weather data 35 RtQ,10max,10PEPVQmax,,10RVPEPQmax,10ROVQrrootrtR25,tRReRHScSlSrSlSaTleafTwiltTTrcUmU [m s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [mol m-2 s-1] [Pa Pa-1] Shearing velocity Effective Rate of PEP carboxylation at leaf temperature given by Michaelis-Menten Equation Maximum PEP carboxylation rate at leaf temperature Maximum PEP carboxylation rate at 25 C temperature PEP regeneration rate at leaf temperature PEP regeneration rate at 25 C temperature Maximum rubisco carboxylation rate at leaf temperature Maximum rubisco carboxylation rate at 25 C temperature Vapor pressure deficit between atmosphere intercellular space and [mol m-2 s-1] Transpiration of water through the plant Greek - - - - - - is a fitting parameter related to photosynthesis rate parameter to make the exponent dimensionless in stomatal conductance model empirical parameter related with boundary layer conductance ratio of CO2 conductance and water vapor conductance through stomata Empirical curvature factor related with electron transport rate ratio of CO2 conductance and water vapor conductance through air boundary layer [m2s-1] [m3m-3] [m3m-3] kinetic viscosity of air Volumetric water content in the soil Soil volumetric saturation 36 UPEPVmaxPEPV25max,PEPVRPEPV,25,,RPEPVmaxROV25max,ROVVPDLossWater xZasat [Pa] [Pa] [Pa] [Pa] [Pa] [Pa] Leaf water potential Root water potential Saturated soil water potential Soil water potential Soil water potential at root Threshold leaf water potential at stomatal closure [W m−2 K−4] Stefan Boltzmann constant 37 leafrootsatsoilrootsoil,thSupplementary Materials Integrating optimization with thermodynamics and plant physiology for crop ideotype design Talukder Z. Jubery1, Baskar Ganapathysubramanian1, Matthew E. Gilbert2, and Daniel Attinger1 1Department of Mechanical Engineering and Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Iowa State University, Ames, IA, 50011; 2Department of Plant Sciences, University of California, Davis, CA 95616, USA. Correspondence to: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] Justification for selecting June-July weather Maximum solar radiance is observed in this period of year in the northern hemisphere. Our hypothesis was that a crop should be the most productive in this period provided that the plant has access to adequate water and nutrients. Due to high solar radiance that results high temperature, and generally low relative humidity in drought-prone areas, this period should also mimic the highest water demand by the environment from the plant. We considered that the typical maize plant was fully grown, i.e. at the beginning of full canopy closure, and total yielding period was two months. During this two-month period average solar radiation was 489.17 W/m2, relative humidity 45.63%, air temperature was 30.6 0C, and wind speed was 3.048 m/s, precipitation does not occur in drought conditions.. The hourly variations of weather parameters are in Figure S1. 38 Fig. S1 Hourly variation of solar radiation (S), relative humidity (RH), atmospheric temperature (Ta), wind speed (Um), precipitation (Precip) and photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) in June-July 2010, Davis, CA. 39 HoursUm(m/s)050010000246810HoursPrecip(mm)0500100000.511.5HoursPAR(W/m2)050010000500100015002000HoursS(kW/m2)0500100000.20.40.60.81HoursRH(%)0500100020406080HoursTa(oC)0500100010203040ABCDEFFigure S2Figure S2: Sensitivity analysis of the traits obtained from GA optimization. 40
1605.08314	1	1605	2016-05-26T14:53:04	Statistical mechanics of the Huxley-Simmons model	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "cond-mat.stat-mech" ]	The chemomechanical model of Huxley and Simmons (HS) [A. F. Huxley and R. M. Simmons, Nature 233, 533 (1971)] provides a paradigmatic description of mechanically induced collective conformational changes relevant in a variety of biological contexts, from muscles power-stroke and hair cell gating to integrin binding and hairpin unzipping. We develop a statistical mechanical perspective on the HS model by exploiting a formal analogy with a paramagnetic Ising model. We first study the equilibrium HS model with a finite number of elements and compute explicitly its mechanical and thermal properties. To model kinetics, we derive a master equation and solve it for several loading protocols. The developed formalism is applicable to a broad range of allosteric systems with mean-field interactions.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Statistical mechanics of the Huxley-Simmons model M. Caruel1, ∗ and L. Truskinovsky2 1MSME, CNRS-UMR 8208, 61 Avenue du G´en´eral de Gaulle, 94010 Cr´eteil, France 2LMS, CNRS-UMR 7649, Ecole Polytechnique, 91128 Palaiseau Cedex, France (Dated: May 27, 2016) The chemomechanical model of Huxley and Simmons (HS) [A. F. Huxley and R. M. Simmons, Nature 233, 533 (1971)] provides a paradigmatic description of mechanically induced collective conformational changes relevant in a variety of biological contexts, from muscles power-stroke and hair cell gating to integrin binding and hairpin unzipping. We develop a statistical mechanical perspective on the HS model by exploiting a formal analogy with a paramagnetic Ising model. We first study the equilibrium HS model with a finite number of elements and compute explicitly its mechanical and thermal properties. To model kinetics, we derive a master equation and solve it for several loading protocols. The developed formalism is applicable to a broad range of allosteric systems with mean-field interactions. I. INTRODUCTION Passive, mechanically induced conformational change in a parallel bundle of bistable elements subjected to fi- nite temperature was first studied theoretically in the pioneering paper of A.F. Huxley and R.M. Simmons [1]. They modeled in this way the mechanism of fast force recovery in skeletal muscles subjected to shortening un- der a length clamp (isometric) protocol. Such loading defines a hard device ensemble, which has to be distin- guished from a soft device (isotonic) ensemble exhibiting some rather different properties [2]. The HS model interpreted the conformational change, appearing in the muscle context under the name of a power stroke, in a highly simplified way, as a "digital" switch between an extended and a contracted states. HS assumed that the contracted state is biased by the im- posed shortening and treated the ensuing collective fold- ing as a deterministic chemical reaction. The information about the energetic preference of the contracted state and about the corresponding energy barriers was encoded into the reaction rates which became functions of the "me- chanical configuration" of the system. In the muscle literature the chemomechanical descrip- tion of HS was later refined through the inclusion of numerous additional chemical reactions between various intermediate configurations and their kinetics was mod- elled phenomenologically [3–7]. Almost identical descrip- tions of mechanically driven conformational changes were proposed independently in the studies of cell adhesion [8, 9] and in the context of hair cell gating [10, 11]. Other closely related systems include mechanical denat- uration of RNA (ribonucleic acid) and DNA (deoxyri- bonucleic acid) hairpins [12–14], unzipping of biological macromolecules [15–21], collective action of SNARE (sol- uble N-ethylmaleimide sensitive receptor) proteins dur- ing opening of synaptic pores [22] and even formation of ripples in graphene sheets [23]. For all these systems ∗ [email protected] the HS model can be viewed as a fundamental mean-field prototype. The goal of the present paper is to reassess the chem- ical reaction based approach of HS from the perspective of statistical mechanics for a system with a finite num- ber of elements while emphasizing the role of fluctua- tions. In such reformulation of the HS model we follow the pioneering work of T.L. Hill [3, 24] and more recent developments in Refs. [2, 25]. The zero temperature HS model was studied from this viewpoint in Ref. [26] where it was presented as a version of a fiber bundle model [27]. Here we extend the analysis of Ref. [26] to finite temper- atures focusing on thermomechanical coupling that has not been previously addressed in the chemomechanical framework. Viewed from an abstract statistical mechanics perspec- tive, the HS model is quite similar to a paramagnetic Ising model whose thermodynamic and kinetic proper- ties are well known [28]. The equivalence, however, is not complete due to the presence in the HS model of an elastic spring, buttressing each spin element. Another complication is the length clamp control which is uncon- ventional for magnetic analogs of the HS system. Among the new effects revealed by the HS model, which would be unusual for paramagnets in an external field, it is enough to mention negative susceptibility and pseudo-critical be- havior without genuine cooperativity. Given that the explicit formulas for the equilibrium free energy of a spin system with mean-field interactions are rather straightforward, we can easily access both me- chanical and thermal properties of the HS model includ- ing the heat release associated with mechanical loading. We can also specify the entropic contributions to mechan- ical and thermal susceptibilities and distinguish adiabatic from isothermal responses. To complement the equilibrium picture, we study in this paper the stochastic dynamics of a HS system with a finite number of elements. The starting point here is a thermally induced random walk in the energy landscape biased by the mechanical loading [29, 30]. We show that due to the mean-field nature of the interactions, the ki- netic properties of the HS system are fully determined 2 the HS model allows us to interpret x as a spin vari- able. The soft spins (snap-springs) version of the HS model, corresponding to the case when each of the two energy wells is represented by a quadratic potential, was developed in [2, 25], however, the comparison of the two models shows that the additional effects due to elasticity of the conformational states are of mostly quantitative nature. We choose a, denoted by h in Ref. [1], as the "refer- ence" size of the conformational change equal to the dis- tance between two infinitely localized energy wells, and we denote by v0 the intrinsic energy bias distinguishing the two states; see Fig. 1. The energy of the spin element can be now written as v0 vHS(x) = if x = 0, if x = −a, 0 ∞ otherwise. The energy v0 is an implicit representation of the ATP- fueled activity in this otherwise passive system. The pres- ence of such bias ensures that in the reference state the se- ries spring is stretched and generates (active or tetanized) tension. It will be convenient to use dimensionless variables and we choose a as our characteristic distance, assuming that the non-dimensional spin variable x takes values 0 or −1. We normalize the total energy of the system by κ0a2 and obtain (y − x)2, 1 2 v(x; y) = (1 + x)v0 + (1) where x = {0,−1} and y is the length of the combined element that includes a bistable unit and a linear spring. If we define y0 = v0 − 1/2 and use the muscle mechanics jargon, we can say that for y > y0 (respectively y < y0) the global minimum of the energy (1) corresponds to the pre-power-stroke state (respectively post-power- stroke state); in [1], the shifted elongation y − y0 was denoted by y. Note that our variable y plays a role of the external (magnetic) field for the spin variable x and therefore our model resembles the zero dimensional Ising model of paramagnetism [28]. However, due to the presence of a linear spring this Ising model is unusual: The external field has its own "energy" represented by the quadratic term in y. In the original HS experiments a muscle was loaded in a hard device which apparently makes this "energy" irrelevant. However, as we show below, the quadratic term in y brings additional stiffness into the overall mechanical response of the system and is there- fore responsible for some interesting effects. a. Thermal equilibrium. Denoting by T the abso- lute temperature we can write the equilibrium probabil- ity density for the configuration of a single element x at fixed y in the form ρ1(x; y, β) = Z1(y, β)−1 exp [−βv(x; y)] , (2) FIG. 1. Huxley-Simmons (HS) model of a single cross-bridge: (a) mechanical representation a myosin head and (b) energy landscape representing two chemical states. The conforma- tion is characterized by the spin variable x which represents two conformations of the head. The bistable element is linked in series with a linear spring of stiffness κ0. by the behavior of a single element. This justifies the ap- proach of HS who could model the evolution of the first moment of the underlying probability distribution by a single reaction equation. While we did not attempt in this paper to conduct a systematic quantitative comparison of our statistical HS model with experiment, we included at the end of the paper a brief discussion of the relevance of our results for skeletal muscles and for several other allosteric system with mean-field coupling. The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II we study the equilibrium properties of N bi stable elements con- nected in parallel and loaded in a hard device. Sec. III contains the analysis of the mechanical transients in this system. The applicability of the original HS model for the description of skeletal muscles is discussed in Sec. IV. Various non-muscle applications are briefly reviewed in Section V. In Sec. VI we summarize our results and iden- tify some open problems. II. EQUILIBRIUM In this section we study the finite temperature equilib- rium mechanical response of a folding-unfolding system containing a finite number of elements. A. Single HS element The Huxley-Simmons paper [1] deals essentially with a single folding element (representing a myosin cross- bridge). The HS element can be modeled as an elastic spring with stiffness κ0 (denoted by K in Ref. [1]) which is connected in series with a bistable unit, see Fig. 1. The two states represent the two conformations of the myosin head and the variable x (denoted by −θ in Ref. [1]) takes the values 0 (pre-power-stroke or unfolded conformation) and −a (post-power-stroke or folded conformation). The discrete "digital" nature of the conformational state in κ0x(a)yκ0x0vHS(x)v0−a(b)By differentiating Eq. (4) with respect to y we obtain the explicit representation of the equilibrium susceptibil- ity (cid:68) [x − (cid:104)x(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:69) χ(y, β) = (cid:104)x(cid:105) (y, β) = β ∂ ∂y 3 (5) which is always positive, as expected in paramagnetic systems. Given that the elastic element is linear, Eq. (5) does not depend on the particular form of the energy vHS(x). Thus, it also applies to models with more than two discrete states [7] and even to models with continuous energy landscape [2, 25]. Note that the susceptibility is proportional to the vari- ance of x which in the HS model takes the form [x − (cid:104)x(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:69) (cid:68) = (1/4){sech [β (y − y0) /2]}2 . Both quantities will be used in what follows to assess the intensity of fluctuations. In the zero-temperature limit the variance of x is neg- ligible at large absolute elongations. Instead, at y = y0, the strength of fluctuations is independent of tempera- ture and we obtain that χ = β/4, which is an analog of the Curie law in paramagnetism [28]; see Figs. 2(c) and 2(d). For other values of elongation y (cid:54)= y0, one can define a characteristic temperature β = β∗χ(y) solving the equation β∗χ(y − y0) tanh(cid:2)β∗χ(y − y0)/2(cid:3) = 1. At this temperature fluctuations are maximized, see Fig. 2(d). Below the characteristic temperature the system is es- sentially "frozen" and therefore resistant to fluctuations. Fluctuations are also irrelevant at large temperatures where the system is maximally disordered. b. Mechanical behavior. The free energy of a single HS element in a hard device can be computed explicitly, f (y, β) = − 1 β log [Z1(y, β)] = y2 + v0 + 1 2 (cid:26) y − y0 (cid:21)(cid:27) 2 (y − y0) (cid:20) β 2 ln 2 cosh . (6) − 1 β Its dependence on elongation is illustrated in Fig. 3(a). We observe that for β ≤ 4 (large temperatures) the free energy is convex while for β > 4 (small temperatures) it is nonconvex. The emergence of a "pseudo critical" temperature β = βc = 4 in a paramagnetic system is a result of the presence of the quadratic energy associated with the "applied field" y. To study the mechanical manifestations of the implied "criticality" we introduce the tension σ = y − x experi- enced by the series linear spring. Due to the presence of the quadratic term y2 in the energy, the conjugate vari- able to elongation y is not the average "magnetization" (cid:104)x(cid:105) but the average tension (cid:104)σ(cid:105) which is a linear function of (cid:104)x(cid:105) independently of the form of the potential (1). The convexity properties of the free energy can be obtained through the study of the averaged tension- elongation relation which corresponds to Eq. (16) in FIG. 2. Average conformation and susceptibility of a single HS element in thermal equilibrium. (a) and (b), Average con- figuration as a function of the applied elongation at different temperatures (a) and as a function of temperature at differ- ent elongations (b); (c) and (d), susceptibility as a function of elongation at different temperatures (c), and as function of the temperature for selected values of y (d). where β = κ0a2 kbT is the nondimensionalized inverse temperature and kb is the Boltzmann constant. The partition function for a single element is then (cid:20) − β 2 (cid:21) (cid:19)(cid:21) (cid:18) y2 2 Z1(y, β) = exp (y + 1)2 + exp −β + v0 . (3) From (2) we can compute the average conformation (cid:104)x(cid:105) = x={0,−1} xρ1(x; y, β), obtaining, (cid:104)x(cid:105) (y, β) = − 1 2 1 − tanh (y − y0) , (4) (cid:21)(cid:27) (cid:26) (cid:20) (cid:20) β 2 (cid:80) which is the analog of Eq. (15) in Ref. [1] (where the corresponding variable was denoted by −n2). In param- agnetic interpretation, (cid:104)x(cid:105) (y, β) is the "average magne- tization" conjugate to the "applied magnetic field" y. The dependence of (cid:104)x(cid:105) on the relative elongation y−y0 is illustrated in Fig. 2(a). In the zero-temperature limit the system driven through y follows the global minimum of the internal energy (1) and the population of the wells changes discontinuously at y = y0 [26]. As the tempera- ture increases, the transition smoothens and in the limit β → 0 we have (cid:104)x(cid:105) = −1/2 independently of the elonga- tion as illustrated in Fig. 2(b). −1−0.500.51−1−0.50y−y0hxiβ2410∞05101520−1−0.50βhxiy−y0-0.250+0.25−1−0.500.51012y−y0χβ2410∞0510152000.511.5βχ00.250.51y−y0(a)(b)(c)(d)4 FIG. 3. Thermal equilibrium properties of the HS model in a hard device for different values of temperature. (a) Helmholtz free energy; (b) tension-elongation relations; (c) stiffness. Parameters are β = 2 (dotted), β = 4 (solid), β = 10 (dashed) and β → ∞ (dash-dotted). In the limit β → ∞, corresponding to zero temperature, the stiffness κ diverges at y = y0, see (c). Ref. [1], (cid:104)σ(cid:105) (y, β) = ∂f ∂y = σ0 +y−y0− 1 2 tanh (cid:21) , (7) (y − y0) (cid:20) β 2 where σ0 = v0. The dependence of (cid:104)σ(cid:105) on the elongation y − y0 is illustrated in Fig. 3(b) for different values of the temperature. We observe that while the relation (cid:104)x(cid:105) (y) at fixed tem- perature is always monotone, as it is supposed to be in a classical paramagnetic spin system, see Fig. 2, the depen- dence of the tension (cid:104)σ(cid:105) on its conjugate variable y can be nonmonotone, see Fig. 3(b). Behind this nonmono- tonicity is the fact that the equilibrium stiffness κ(y, β) = ∂ (cid:104)σ(cid:105) (y, β)/∂y = 1 − χ(y, β) (cid:68) [σ − (cid:104)σ(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:69) = 1 − β = 1 − (β/4){sech [β (y − y0) /2]}2 (8) is a sign-indefinite sum of two terms. Equation (8) is a representation of the standard [31, 32] decomposition of an elastic susceptibility into a Cauchy- Born part associated with affine deformation κCB = 1, and a fluctuation part associated with nonaffine defor- mation, here κF = (β/4){sech [β (y − y0) /2]}2. Interest- ingly, in the HS model the fluctuation-related term in (8) does not disappear in the zero-temperature limit, produc- ing a singular δ-function-type contribution to the affine response at y = y0. At this value of the elongation the global minimum of the elastic energy is not unique and fluctuations are formally present even in the zero tem- perature (purely mechanical) model. This can be viewed as a manifestation of a glassy behavior [33, 34]. At finite temperatures the fluctuation-related contri- bution to the elastic modulus has a standard tempera- ture dependence in pure phases y − y0 (cid:29) 1 (softening). Instead, we observe a rubber-elasticity-type hardening type behavior around y = y0, see Fig. 4. In this mixture region the negative entropic elasticity starts to dominate the positive enthalpic elasticity at β > βc. The "critical" temperature βc = 4 is defined by the condition that the tension-elongation relation develops In this state κ = 1 − β/4, zero stiffness at y = y0. which can be again viewed as the analog of the Curie law in magnetism. Negative stiffness, resulting from non- additivity of the system, prevails at subcritical tempera- tures; in this range a shortening of an element leads to a tension increase which can be interpreted as a metama- terial behavior [2, 35]. At supercritical temperatures the stiffness becomes positive, reaching asymptotically the value κ = 1. It is remarkable that while fitting their experimental data HS found exactly the critical value β = 4 (which cor- responds to the choice 4/α = 8 nm in the units adopted in Ref. [1]), concluding implicitly that the state of isomet- ric contractions is only marginally stable. The advan- tages of this state are clear from Fig. 4: Small variations of temperature generate large changes in stiffness which can vary from positive to negative values and such tem- perature dependence is almost insensitive to the small FIG. 4. Equilibrium stiffness as function of the tempera- ture at different levels of elongation. In the low temperature regimes (large β), an increase of temperature induces soften- ing while at high temperatures (low β) it induces hardening. Close to the critical point βc, small changes in temperatures have a large impact on the value of the stiffness which may even change its sign. −0.4−0.200.20.40.511.5y−y0fβ2410∞−110.511.5y−y+σ−σ+y−y0hσiσ0−11−101y−y+y−y0κ(a)(b)(c)02040−1−0.500.51βcsofteninghardeningβκy−y000.150.3t FIG. 5. The temperature dependence of the parameter do- main where the HS system exhibits negative stiffness. In (a) and (b) we show the horizontal (y+ and y−) and verti- cal (σ+ and σ−) boundaries of the bistable domain; in (c) the dashed line is a parametric plot of (y−(β), σ+(β)) and (y+(β), σ−(β)) for ranging from β = 4 to β → ∞. Solid line: Tension-elongation relation corresponding to β = 10 and the associated bistable domain is represented by the gray area. changes in the stretching around y0. The "criticality" in HS system at y0, however, is subdued in the hard device ensemble, similar to the behavior of a van-der-Waals gas under controlled volume. The physical picture here is differs from the case of a ferromagnetic system under ap- plied magnetic field where interactions and cooperativity play an important role and zero susceptibility signals the presence of a real critical point with diverging fluctua- tions. To characterize the metamaterial behavior at temper- atures below critical, we define an interval [y−, y+] where the stiffness of the system is negative. The boundaries y− and y+ correspond to the zeros of the second derivative (cid:20)√ of the free energy. For β > 4 we have √ β − 4 (cid:20)√ β − √ β − 4 √ β − 4 √ β − √ β − 4 y+(β) − y0 = y−(β) − y0 = − 1 (cid:21) (cid:21) β + β + √ 1 β log log β (cid:112) (cid:112) 1 2 1 − 4β−1 − 1 β 1 − 4β−1 + 1 β (cid:20)√ (cid:20)√ (cid:21) (cid:21) √ β − √ √ β − √ β + β − 4 β − 4 β − 4 β − 4 In the zero-temperature limit this interval collapses to a single point y = y0. The equilibrium tensions σ− and σ+ corresponding to y+ and y− are given by √ σ+(β) = v0 + β + log 2 √ log σ−(β) = v0 − 1 They become equal to σ+ = v0 + 1/2 and to σ− = v0 − 1/2, when β → ∞, see Ref. [26] for more detail. The evolution of the domain of metamaterial behavior with temperature is shown in Fig. 5. . We finish this subsection with the observation (cid:104)σ(cid:105) (y, β) = y − (cid:104)x(cid:105) (y, β), we have that since 5 (cid:104)[σ − (cid:104)σ(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:105) = (cid:104)[x − (cid:104)x(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:105), which shows that the fluctuations of tension originate from the fluctuations of the conformation. In this sense the "noisy" macro- scopic force-elongation relations can be used as an ex- perimental window into the microscopic behavior of the system. c. Thermal behavior. While the experiments on muscles have been traditionally focused on the mechani- cal response [36–43], our study suggests that measuring the thermal or calorimetric response of such systems may be at least as informative, see some existing work along these lines on muscles in Refs. [44–50]. The statistical HS model has a considerable predictive power in this re- spect. For instance, the entropy of the HS element can be computed explicitly, log [Z1(y, β)] + log [Z1(y, β)] s(y, β) = −β ∂ ∂β (cid:26) = log 2 cosh (cid:20) β 2 (cid:21)(cid:27) (y − y0) (cid:20) β 2 − β 2 (y − y0) tanh (y − y0) (cid:21) (9) . and we illustrate the behavior of the function s(y, β) in Figs. 6(a) and 6(b). We see that the degree of disorder is maximal in the state of isometric contractions, y = y0. Note also that the entropy depends on a single normal- ized coordinate β (y − y0) combining both control param- eters, temperature and displacement. A measure of the dependence of the entropy on tem- FIG. 6. Entropy [(a) and (b)] and specific heat [(c) and (d)] in thermal equilibrium represented as function of elonga- tion at different temperatures [(a) and (d)] and as function of temperature for different elongations [(b) and (d)]. −1−0.500.510.60.811.21.4y−σ−y+σ+y−σ−y+σ+β=4β→∞β→∞β=10β=10y−y0hσiσ0−0.200.2y+y−y−y0σ−σ+051015200.811.2βhσiσ0(c)(a)(b)−2−101200.20.40.6y−y0sβ2410∞0510152000.20.40.6βs00.250.51−2−101200.20.4y−y0c0510152000.20.4βcy−y0(a)(b)(c)(d)6 FIG. 7. from the state y = y0 at different temperatures. Isothermal heat released induced by a displacement FIG. 9. The dependence of the coefficient γ on elongation (a) and temperature (b). (cid:26) β 2 (cid:21)(cid:27)2 , (y − y0) (cid:20) β 2 perature is the specific heat [28] c(y, β) = −β ∂ ∂β s(y, β) = (y − y0) sech which is represented as function of y − y0 and β in Figs. 6(c) and 6(d). As is typical for paramagnetic systems, the specific heat depends only on the com- bination β(y − y0). Since at y = y0, the entropy is temperature insensitive [s(y0) = log(2)], the specific heat vanishes. Similarly, at large elongations, the sys- tems becomes more and more ordered and tempera- ture changes no longer affect the entropy. As a result, the specific heat is maximized at a characteristic value of the temperature β = β∗c which solves the equation β∗c (y − y0) tanh [β∗c (y − y0)/2] = 2. To study the heat release associated with the change of length we can use our knowledge of the entropy vari- ation with y. We introduce the heat release Q(y, β) = −β−1∆s(y, β), where ∆s(y, β) = s(y, β)−s(yin, β), is the entropy change from the initial state yin. The function Q, which is illustrated in Fig. 7, can be potentially measured by calorimetric techniques if the system is first driven away from equilibrium adiabatically by a rapid length change and then allowed to relax reaching the original temperature. Note that the expression for entropy (9) can be also rewritten in the form s = β (cid:104)v(cid:105) − βf where (cid:104)v(cid:105) is the FIG. 8. Average internal energy for β = 2 (dotted), β = 4 (solid), β = 10 (dashed) and in the athermal limit β → ∞ (dot-dashed). average internal energy (cid:104)v(cid:105) (y, β) = y2/2 + v0 − (y − y0)(cid:104)x(cid:105) (y, β). In contrast to the equilibrium free energy, which de- creases with temperature, see Fig. 3(a), the average in- ternal energy increases with temperature, see Fig. 8 . In the opposite zero temperature (athermal) limit (β → ∞) both the average internal energy and the free energy tend to the same limiting curve representing the global mini- mum of the elastic energy which is a nonconvex function of elongation energy [26]. Observe, however, that the av- erage internal energy approaches the mechanical energy "from above" while the free energy approaches the me- chanical energy "from below". Another interesting and potentially measurable quan- tity is the entropic contribution to stress which also serves as a measure of thermal expansion γ = − ∂s ∂y = β2 4 (y − y0) sech (cid:26) (cid:21)(cid:27)2 (y − y0) . (cid:20) β 2 The dependence of γ on elongation and temperature is illustrated in Fig. 9. We observe that for y > y0 (respectivelyy < y0) the growth of temperature enhances (respectively diminishes) the tension, see Fig. 3(b), and the temperature sensitivity of tension is the highest at a particular value of the temperature. In large shorten- ing or stretching regimes and at y = y0, the mechanical response is temperature insensitive. d. Adiabatic response. The knowledge of the ther- mal properties of the HS model allows one to address the question of whether the isothermal approximation is justified when applied to experiments involving fold- ing or unfolding under fast loading. Below, we consider an alternative hypothesis that the response is adiabatic, which implies that in this problem the heat exchange is the rate-limiting process. To remain within the equilib- rium framework, we replace the task of computing the actual adiabats by computing the isoentropes to which we will be still referring as adiabats. We discuss the ap- plicability of the adiabatic assumption for the description of fast force recovery in muscles in Sec. IV. As the entropy of the system depends solely on βy − y0, see Eq. (9), the temperature varies along the adiabats −2−101200.050.10.15β=4β=10β→∞y−y0Q−0.4−0.200.20.411.5y−y0hviβ2410∞−1−0.500.51−202y−y0γβ2410∞024681000.511.5βy−y000.250.51(a)(b)7 FIG. 10. Adiabatic response. (a) Evolution of temperature as function of the applied loading along adiabats for s = 0.2 (dotted), s = 0.4 (solid), and s = 0.6 (dashed). (b) Average conformation following adiabatic length changes from two different thermal equilibrium initial conditions y = y0 (solid) and from y = y0 ± 0.1 (dashed) at βin = 10. The isothermal response is represented by the dotted line. (c) Adiabatic tension-elongation relations. Dotted line, isotherm response for β = 10; dashed line, adiabatic response with initial state at y − y0 = ±0.1 with βin = 10; solid line, adiabatic response with initial state at y = y0 with βin = 10. proportionally to the elongation, see Fig. 10(a). More specifically, along an adiabat starting at y = yin with temperature β = βin, we have βad = βin yin−y0 . Since, y−y0 according to Eq. (4), the average configuration depends only on β(y − y0), the variation of temperature along adiabats must ensure that the average configuration (cid:104)x(cid:105) is preserved. This is true for every value of y except y = y0 where the adiabat experiences a discontinuity. Along adiabats the average configuration evolves according to sign(y − y0) (cid:20) βinyin − y0 (cid:104)x(cid:105)ad (y, β) = − 1 + tanh (cid:21) . 1 2 2 2 The adiabatic response of the microconfiguration of the system to abrupt "length steps" is illustrated in Fig. 10(b), where the initial temperature is always βin = 10. Observe that for the adiabat passing through the point y = y0 the average configuration is frozen at (cid:104)x(cid:105) = −1/2 (solid line); the behavior of a microconfigura- tion along an isotherm passing through y = y0 drastically differs (dotted line). Since equilibrium tension along the adiabats depends linearly on (cid:104)x(cid:105), the adiabatic stress response to shorten- ing from y = y0 is quasilinear elastic, even though the temperature is changing. More specifically, one can show that outside the point y = y0 the adiabatic stiffness is equal to the purely mechanical stiffness κad = ∂2 ∂y2 f (y, βad(y, s)) = κ0 ≥ κ, where the function βad(y, s) describes temperature vari- ation with elongation at a given entropy s. Note that at y = y0, the inverse temperature β diverges and even small adiabatic length change would lead to a dramatic increase of temperature (β → 0). This means, in particular, that reaching this state adiabatically brings about infinite cooling. A Similar effect in a paramagnetic spin system is known as "cooling by adiabatic demagne- tization." In the HS system the applied field y − y0 can be both positive and negative and, in this case, if y < y0, a shortening would lead to a similar "adiabatic heating," which can be, in principle, measured in experiment, see Section IV. For the adiabats starting at other points y (cid:54)= y0 the average configuration (cid:104)x(cid:105) is frozen at its initial value un- til the loading reaches the point y = y0. At this point the continuity of entropy requires that the configuration changes discontinuously. Due to adiabatic cooling at y − y0 the temperature goes to zero and the response be- comes discontinuous (quasimechanical, see [26]). This is in stark contrast with continuous evolution of the config- uration along a typical isotherm also shown in Fig. 10(b) (dotted line). One can say that, during adiabatic re- sponse, the temperature-induced smoothing of the force- elongation relation gets overridden by the anomalous cooling around the point y = y0. The adiabatic tension-elongation relations originating from this behavior of the microconfiguration are piece- wise linear with stiffness equal to 1 for y (cid:54)= y0, see Fig. 10(c). The presence of a discontinuity at y = y0 signifies an extreme metamaterial-type behavior. Inter- estingly, the adiabat originating exactly from the equilib- rium state y = y0 can be confused with the purely elastic isothermal force elongation relation. The associated tem- perature variation, however, is non-negligible and should be, in principle, measurable in experiments. B. Bundle of HS elements Consider now a finite number of HS elements attached in parallel between two rigid backbones. In the skeletal muscle context, such a bundle represents a minimal acto- myosin complex which we refer to as an elementary half- sarcomere, see Fig. 11. The energy of the system with N elements can be writ- −1−0.500.51051015200.20.40.6log(2)y−y0β−1−0.500.51−1−0.50isothermβ=10adiabatfromy=y0±0.1adiabatfromy=y0y−y0hxi−1−0.500.510.60.811.21.4isothermβ=10adiabatfromy=y0±0.1adiabatfromy=y0y−y0hσiσ0(a)(b)(c)8 which, in our case, plays the role of an order parame- ter. The internal energy (per element) corresponding to a given p can be written as e(p, y) = p (y + 1)2 /2 + (1 − p)(cid:0)y2/2 + v0 (cid:1) . (11) (cid:18) N (cid:19) Due to permutational invariance, we can write the prob- ability of a given state with N p elements in the folded state in the form of the binomial law: ρ(p; y, β) = [ρ1(−1; y, β)]N p [ρ1(0; y, β)]N (1−p) , (12) where ρ1 is given by (2) and ρ1(0; y, β) = 1−ρ1(−1; y, β). Note that the distribution (12) can be also written as N p FIG. 11. (a) Schematic representation of an acto-myosin filaments organization in a superstructure of half-sarcomeres. (b) A single half-sarcomere represented as a of cluster con- taining N cross-linkers, see Fig. 1. The control parameter is the total elongation y and the total tension generated by the system is denoted by Σ. ρ(p; y, β) = Z(y, β)−1 exp[−βN f (p; y, β)] f (p; y, β) = e(y, p) − (1/β) s(p), is the marginal free energy, e is the internal energy (11), and s(p) = 1 sponding to a fixed value of p and finite N . (cid:1) is the ideal entropy, all corre- N log(cid:0) N N p (13) ten as e(x; y) = 1 N N(cid:88) (cid:20) (1 + xi) v0 + (cid:21) , (y − xi)2 1 2 where i=1 where x = {x1, . . . , xN}. The individual bistable ele- ments do not interact among themselves while they all interact with the same external field y. The origin of this mean-field type interaction is a hard device constraint which is not affected by the microconfiguration of the sys- tem. In the language of magnetism, we are dealing here with a one-dimensional paramagnetic system. In fact, for such systems, the dimensionality is irrelevant and one can expect the results obtained for the zero-dimensional model to remain valid for the case of N elements. e. Thermal equilibrium. In thermal equilibrium, the probability density for a micro-state x reads ρ(x; y, β) = Z(y, β)−1 exp [−β e(x; y)] , (10) where the partition function is Z(y, β) = exp [−βN e(x; y)] . (cid:88) x∈{0,−1}N ρ(x; y, β) = (cid:81)N Due to the additivity of the energy we obtain Z(y, β) = [Z1(y, β)]N , where Z1 is given by (3). Therefore i=1 ρ1(xi; y, β) which shows that the el- ements are independent. The total free energy can be written as F (y, β) = N f (y, β), where the expression for the free energy of a single HS element f is given by (6); this formula is anal- ogous to the corresponding result for paramagnetic Ising model and other mean-field-type systems, e.g., Ref. [16]. Similarly, other extensive equilibrium variables are also additive and it will be convenient to normalize them by N . To shed light on the internal microconfiguration of the system we introduce the fraction of HS elements in the folded conformation N(cid:88) i=1 xi, p = − 1 N FIG. 12. Nonequilibrium free energy landscape and the cor- responding tension-elongation relations in a hard device for N = 2 [(a) and (b)] and in the limit N → ∞ [(c) and (d)]. Dotted lines, free-energy levels, and tension corresponding to different values of p; thick line, response corresponding to the global minimum of the nonequilibrium free energy; thin lines, response in thermal equilibrium; gray areas, domain of the metastable states in the thermodynamic limit. In (a) and (c), the inserts show the marginal free energy f as function of p for y − y0 = −0.4, 0, 0.4. The plots are obtained with β = 6, which explains the presence of negative stiffness. half-sarcomere(a)ΣΣrigidbackboneuHSκNy(b)0.511.52fN=2N→∞−0.4−0.200.20.4012y−y0⟨σ⟩σ0−0.4−0.200.20.4y−y001pf01pf01pf01pf∞01pf∞01pf∞(a)(b)(c)(d)9 FIG. 13. Hill-type energy landscapes for N = 1 (a) and N = 4 (b). In (c) we show the equilibrium free-energy profile f = F/N (solid line), which is independent of N together with the metastable states for N = 4 (dotted lines). Here v0 = 1/2. To illustrate Eq. (13), consider the simplest case N = 2 when the marginal free energy can take only three values, f (0; y, β) = e(0; y) = 1 2 y2 + v0 f (1/2; y, β) = 1 4 (y + 1)2 + 1 4 y2 + 1 2 v0 − log(2) 2β f (1; y, β) = e(1; y) = 1 2 (y + 1)2, which are shown in Fig. 12 together with the correspond- ing tension-elongation relations. Observe that the global minimum response at finite temperature is characterized by a series of jumps reflecting successive conformational changes in individual elements. Between the jumps, the stiffness is positive, which shows that each metastable state has a finite basin of stability even though the over- all (global) stiffness is negative. The changes in the marginal free-energy profiles with increasing N are illustrated in Fig. 13. At N = 1, we ob- tain the representation of the energy landscape due to T. L. Hill [36]. In this case, the marginal free energy f and the internal energy v are identical (no entropic contri- bution). For finite N we obtain N + 1 metastable states corresponding to different values of p with the global min- imum represented by a (nonconvex) lower envelope. While the lower envelope of the marginal free energy f (y, β) = minp f (p, y, β) is a piece wise smooth function of y with a number of singular points depending on N , the equilibrium free energy f (y, β) = F (y, β)/N is a smooth function laying strictly below: f (y, β) ≤ f (y, β). The N independence of f (y, β)- see Eq. (6)-shows that for the HS system the equilibrium response is size independent. However, in real experiments for systems with small N conducted at finite deformation rates one can expect to see the steps on the force elongation curves associated with the singularities of f (y), see Sec. III B. The average value of the parameter p (which is analo- gous to the variable n2 in Ref. [1]) can be found from p ρ(p; y, β) = −(cid:104)x(cid:105)(y, β) = ρ1(−1; y, β) (cid:104)p(cid:105) (y, β) = (14) (cid:88) This quantity plays the role of the average magnetiza- tion per spin and does not depend on N ; however, the corresponding variance decreases as 1/N , (cid:104)[p − (cid:104)p(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:105) = (1/N )(cid:104)[x − (cid:104)x(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:105). Our Eq. (14) also shows that the whole distribution (12) can be recovered if the parameter N is fixed and (cid:104)p(cid:105) is known as a function of y and β. In particular, we can compute the variance (cid:104)[p − (cid:104)p(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:105) = (cid:104)p(cid:105) (1 − (cid:104)p(cid:105)), (15) which gives after substitution (cid:68) [p − (cid:104)p(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:69)1/2 = √ 1 N 2 sech (cid:21) (y − y0) (cid:20) β 2 . (16) By differentiating Eq. (14) with respect to y we can also obtain the equilibrium susceptibility X(y, β) = − ∂ ∂y (cid:104)p(cid:105) = βN(cid:104)(p − (cid:104)p(cid:105))2(cid:105) = χ(y, β), where χ is the susceptibility of a single HS element, see Eq. (5). We can similarly rewrite all other equilib- rium characteristics of the system in terms of −(cid:104)p(cid:105) and N(cid:104)[p − (cid:104)p(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:105). In the limit N → ∞ the expression for the marginal free energy can be written explicitly f∞(p; y, β) = e(p; y) − (1/β) s∞(p), (17) where s∞(p) = − [p log(p) + (1 − p) log(1 − p)] , is the ideal mixing entropy reflecting the absence of correla- tions between the units. The function f∞(p) is always convex since f∞(p; y, β) =(cid:2)β p(1 − p)(cid:3)−1 > 0, ∂2 ∂p2 which signifies the lack of synchronization: In a similar ferromagnetic system the marginal free energy would be nonconvex. As N → ∞ the domain of the phase space occupied by the metastable states becomes compact, see prepost−2−10100.20.40.60.81y−y0vN=1p=0p=1/4p=1/2p=3/4p=1−2−10100.20.40.60.81y−y0fN=4−2−10100.20.40.60.81y−y0f∀N(a)(b)(c)the gray area in Figs. 12(c) and 12(d) not shown explicitly in Fig. 13(c). where the superscript d indicates that the normalization has been dropped. 10 At large N , the summation over the set of discrete values of p (see Eq. (14)) can be approximated by an integration over the interval [0, 1]. The integrals can be, in turn, computed by using the Laplace method. Then, for the equilibrium free energy, we can write f (y, β) = f∞(p∗(y, β); β), where f and f∞ are given by (6) and (17), respectively. Here p∗(y, β) is a minimizer of f∞, which is a solution of the transcendental equation, p∗/(1 − p∗) = exp(cid:2)−β(y − y0)(cid:3). It is easy to check that p∗(y, β) = (cid:104)p(cid:105) (y, β) where (cid:104)p(cid:105) (y, β) is given by Eq. (14) . The resulting free-energy profile is shown in both Fig. 12(c) and Fig. 13(c). f. Mechanical behavior. For a given configuration x, the tension in the system can be written as (cid:104) (cid:88) (cid:105) Σ(x, y) = N y − (1/N ) xi = N (y + p) . The average tension, conjugate to the control parameter y, is then (cid:104)Σ(cid:105) (y, β) = N [y + (cid:104)p(cid:105) (y, β)] = N (cid:104)σ(cid:105) (y, β), where (cid:104)σ(cid:105) is the average tension of a single element, see Eq. (7). The variance of the total tension can be written as (cid:68) [σ − (cid:104)σ(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:69) . (cid:68) [Σ − (cid:104)Σ(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:69) (cid:68) [Σ − (cid:104)Σ(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:69)1/2 = N The relative fluctuations, (cid:26) (cid:104)Σ(y, β)(cid:105) (cid:20) β 2 (y − y0) = (cid:21) − 1 2 (cid:20) β 2 sinh (18) (cid:21)(cid:27)−1 (y − y0) √ 1 N 2 (y + ) cosh 1 2 decay as 1/N 1/2, which is a sign that the measured force in this model is an extensive quantity. The formula (18) can be used to estimate the number of elements N from the knowledge of the fluctuations of the force. If we denote by K the total stiffness of the system, then we can write K(y, β) = N κ(y, β) = N − β (cid:68) [Σ − (cid:104)Σ(cid:105) (y, β)]2(cid:69) (19) Note, first, that the fluctuation-related contribution to stiffness is an order of one effect in terms of the number of elements N , which means that the effect of fluctu- ations does not disappear in the thermodynamic limit. Also, since the stiffness in the HS model is an extensive property, the analysis of the temperature and elongation dependence of κ(y, β) presented in Sec. II A remains valid here as well. The fact that the stiffness has an nonthermal, purely mechanical part, that can be potentially extracted from structural measurements, and an equally important and even dominating fluctuation-related component, that can be measured independently, has been largely overlooked in the literature on systems with nonconvex internal de- grees of freedom because in classical materials, which can be thought to be composed of almost linear springs, the fluctuational effect on stiffness is usually small. Here we see that in the presence of internal "snap-springs" this ef- fect can be considerable. For instance, the difference be- tween the smaller quasistatic stiffness of myosin II [51, 52] and the larger instantaneous stiffness-believed to be largely unaffected by fluctuations [53] -may be linked to the importance of the second term in our Eq. (20). On the other hand, if N is known and the variance of the total force can be measured, then one can recover the stiffness of a single element κ0. Conversely, knowing κ0 and measuring fluctuations of the force one can estimate N from (20). We emphasize again that the relation (20) is independent of the detailed structure of the energy landscape (1) and can therefore be used in the presence of multiple power-stroke-type energy wells. g. Thermal behavior. Since the entropy of the fi- nite size bundle of HS elements is extensive S(y, β) = N s(y, β), the analysis of the adiabatic response for a sin- gle HS element presented in Sec. II A remains valid for the bundle of N HS elements. III. KINETICS In this section we study kinetics of the HS system and build links between the stochastic dynamics of a single HS element, the evolution of the bundle of HS elements connected in parallel, and a conventional chemomechan- ical modeling of such systems in terms of deterministic chemical reactions. Following the original HS model, we assume for simplicity that during loading the tempera- ture is kept constant. where κ is defined by Eq. (8). As in the case of a single HS element, the total stiffness decomposes into an elastic (or enthalpic) contribution dominating at y − y0 (cid:29) 1 and a term containing entropic contribution which dominates around y = y0. (cid:28)(cid:104) In dimensional form (19) becomes (cid:34) K d = N κ0 − 1 kbT 1 − κ0 a2 4kbT Σd − (cid:104)Σ(cid:105)d(cid:105)2(cid:29) (cid:20) κ a (cid:26) = N κ0 2kbT sech A. Single HS element (cid:1)(cid:21)(cid:27)2(cid:35) , (20) In the paper of Huxley and Simmons [1] the relaxation of the system to equilibrium was modeled as a determin- istic chemical reaction of the first order. In their de- scription HS followed the average population of elements (cid:0)yd − yd 0 FIG. 14. One-dimensional Markov chain description for a single HS element (a) and for a system with N elements (b). in the two conformational states without attempting to trace the dynamics of individual flips experienced by the spin variables x. To simulate stochastic dynamics of a single HS element we need to know the probabilities of the forward and reverse flips P(cid:2) xt+dt = −1(cid:12)(cid:12) xt = 0(cid:3) = k+(y, β)dt P(cid:2) xt+dt = 0(cid:12)(cid:12) xt = −1(cid:3) = k−(y, β)dt. (21) Here k+(y, β) [respectively k−(y, β)] is the transition rate for the jump from the unfolded state (respectively, folded state) to the folded state (respectively, unfolded state), see Fig. 14(a). We assume that the total elongation y and the inverse temperature β are the controlling pa- rameters which may vary at a time scale much larger that the characteristic time of the individual conformational transitions. As the transition probabilities (21) depend only on the current state of the system, the dynamics is described by a discrete Markov chain [30, 54]. To compute the transition rates k±(y, β) we need to know the structure of the actual energy landscape sepa- rating the two conformational states. In their paper [1], HS simply assumed that the hypothetical barrier sepa- 11 rating the two wells of the potential vHS is flat and is characterized by the energy level E1, see Fig. 15. By taking the energy of the elastic spring into account, we can then write the transition rates in the form k+(y, β) = k exp [−β [E0 + max{y + 1/2, 0}]] , k−(y, β) = k exp [−β [E1 + max{−y − 1/2, 0}]] . where E1 = E0 + v0 and the common pre-factor k defines the characteristic time scale for a single well system. If y > −1/2, then only the energy barrier from the unfolded to the folded state depends on y, see Fig. 15(a). In this case, the rates can be written in the form k+(y, β) = k− exp [−β (y − y0)] k−(y, β) = k exp [−β E1] = const (22a) (22b) and the timescale of the jump process is τ = 1/k− = k−1 exp [β E1] . If y < −1/2, see Fig. 15(b), then we ob- tain instead k+(y, β) = k− exp [β v0] = const. k−(y, β) = k− exp [β (y − y0 + v0)] . We see in Fig. 15 that, in response to shortening, the overall transformation rate k = k+ + k− first in- creases exponentially as the forward barrier is lowered (while the reverse barrier remains constant) and then decreases as the reverse barrier is elevated (while the forward barrier remains constant). In addition, we see that for large stretching k ≈ k− and for large shortening k ≈ k− exp[β v0]. Note that HS considered only the case y > −1/2, see Fig. 15(a). To see why the value y = −1/2 is special in the muscle context, we recall that in this case the un- loaded system is symmetric, (cid:104)p(cid:105) = 1/2. Then the tension during the purely elastic phase of the fast force recovery (when (cid:104)p(cid:105) remains constant) is σ = y + 1/2, which be- comes negative exactly at y = −1/2. In experiments on muscles, the relaxation rates have been measured only for y > −1/2 because below this threshold muscle fibers are usually subjected to buckling. Our analysis suggests that near the regimes with y = −1/2 the step size depen- dence of the rate of fast force recovery may deviate from exponential. Schematic representation of the energy barrier in FIG. 15. the HS bistable potential. The energy barriers corresponding to the transition rates in the absence of elastic contribution are denoted E1 and E2. We define the characteristic timescale by τ = exp[βE1]. (a) Energy landscape for y > −1/2 which is the case considered in Ref. [1]; (b) energy landscape for y < −1/2 not considered by HS. (c), Relaxation rate as function of the total elongation y for β = 1 (dashed line) and β = 2 (solid line). The results of numerical simulations of stochastic hop- ping for a single HS element subjected to a quasistatic stretching are shown in Fig. 16. For y < y0 the spin vari- able spends most of the time in the folded conformation (x = −1). When the loading device approaches the point y = y0, the flips between the wells become more frequent before finally the system stabilizes again in the unfolded configuration (x = 0). The stochastic dynamics shown in Fig. 16 can also be seen through the prism of the deterministic evolution of a single-particle probability distribution ρ1(t). For a generic test function q we can write d(cid:104)q(x)(cid:105) = q(−1) [ρ1(−1, t + dt) − ρ1(−1, t)] + q(0) [ρ1(0, t + dt) − ρ1(0, t)] , (a)−10k+k−(b)p−1Npp+1Nφ+(p−1N)φ+(p)φ−(p+1N)φ−(p)x0v0E0E1−1(a)y>−1/2ux0v0E0E1−1(b)y<−1/2u−2−101246β=1β=2ykτ(c)12 between the time t and the time t + dt, then the func- tion p(t) is a one dimensional random walk (see Fig. 14), governed by the jump probabilities (cid:40)P(cid:2)pt+dt = pt + 1/N(cid:3) = φ+(pt; y, β)dt P(cid:2)pt+dt = pt − 1/N(cid:3) = φ−(pt; y, β)dt. (24a) (24b) where φ+(p; y, β) = N (1 − p) k+(y, β) and φ−(p; y, β) = N p k−(y, β). Following a similar procedure as the one leading to Eq. (23), we obtain the master equation for the probability distribution ρ(p, t) ρ(p, t; y, β) = φ+ (1 − p + 1/N ; y) ρ (p − 1/N, t; y, β) ∂ ∂t + φ− (p + 1/N ; y) ρ (p + 1/N, t; y, β) − [φ+(1 − p; y) + φ−(p; y)] ρ (p, t; y, β) , (25) which can be solved numerically since we know the tridi- agonal transfer matrix of the process at each time step. It is clear, however, that since the transition probabilities (21) depend only on the control parameter y, the trajec- tories of individual elements are independent. Hence, at a given y each macro-configuration can be viewed as a realization of N Bernoulli processes with the probability of success ρ1(t) solving Eq. (23). Therefore the probabil- ity density ρ(p, t) = P(pt = p) is a binomial distribution with parameters N and ρ1(t): (cid:18) N (cid:19) N p FIG. 16. Hopping response to a ramp stretch from y = y0 − 1 to y = y0 + 1 (single trajectory with jumps hardly distinguishable around y = y0 ). The time step is ∆t = 10−3τ and the time is measured in the units of τ . The average trajectory is shown by the gray line. Here β = 4. then, using (21), we obtain d(cid:104)q(x)(cid:105) = q(−1){k+[1 − ρ1(−1, t)] − k−ρ1(−1, t)} dt + q(0){k−[1 − ρ1(0, t)] − k+(ρ1(0, t))} dt. In the limit dt → 0, we obtain exactly the HS kinetic equation ∂ ∂t ρ1(t) = k+(y) [1 − ρ1(t)] − k−(y)ρ1(t). (23) ρ(p, t) = [ρ1(t)]N p [1 − ρ1(t)]N−N p . (26) Its general solution can be written as ρ1(t) = ρ1(0) exp [−A(t)] + (cid:90) t 0 where A(t) =(cid:82) t k(t(cid:48)) exp[A(t(cid:48)) − A(t)]ρ∞1 (y(t))dt(cid:48), 0 k(t(cid:48))dt(cid:48) and ρ∞1 = k+/k is the stationary distribution (2). Since (cid:104)x(cid:105) = ρ1, this equation describes the time dependence of the average configuration shown in Fig. 16 by the gray line. The comparison of individual stochastic trajectories with the evolution of averages shows that the information about individual flips, potentially measurable in single molecule experiments, gets lost in the chemomechanical description. In particular, near the point y = y0, fluc- tuations play a dominant role in the stochastic descrip- tion, as is suggested by our equilibrium theory, while from the chemomechanical perspective this particular state is completely indistinguishable from the other equilibrium states. B. Bundle of HS elements The isothermal discrete dynamics of a system with N elements can be described in terms of the macroscopic pa- rameter p ∈ {0, 1/N, . . . , 1}. If only one transition occurs One can verify that that (26) solves (25) and since (cid:104)p(cid:105) (t) = ρ1(t), Eq. (23) can be viewed as the analog of Eq. (9) in Ref. [1]. We have then shown that the dynam- ics of the entire distribution is enslaved to the dynamics of the order parameter (cid:104)p(cid:105) (t) captured by the original HS model. It is also clear that in the long time limit the dis- tribution (26) converges to the Boltzmann distribution (10). h. Quasistatic loading. To illustrate the fact that our dynamical model is fully compatible with the equi- librium behavior studied in Sec. II B, we now consider the quasistatic driving of a cluster of N HS elements, see Fig. 17. The behavior of the individual trajecto- ries generated by the stochastic random walk Eq. (24) is shown for N = 10 (light gray) and N = 100 (dark gray). The system is subjected to continuous stretching from y = y0 − 1 to y = y0 + 1 over the time interval [0, 103 τ ] with the temperature remaining constant; this loading protocol mimics the unzipping tests for biolog- ical macromolecules [12, 15, 18, 55]. The results were obtained using the same numerical procedures as in the case of a single element. The stochastic evolution of the order parameter p and of the corresponding tension are illustrated in Fig. 17. Together with single trajectories, we show the evolution of the average (solid black line) obtained from Eq. (23) and the corresponding equilibrium response curves (open −10x−101y−y005001000012t/τσσ013 FIG. 18. Evolution of the normalized variance N(cid:104)(p − (cid:104)p(cid:105))2(cid:105) and the heat release as function of the elongation during a quasistatic stretching between t = 0 and t = 103τ . For each temperature we show the analytic computations from (16) and (9) (open circles), the results of the stochastic model (24) corresponding to 104 independent realizations with N = 10 (gray lines) and the solution based on the solution of the kinetic equations (23) and (26) (thin lines). that stochastic simulations are fully compatible with the predictions of equilibrium theory, in particular, we see once again that the normalized variance reaches a max- imum at y = y0 becoming independent of the tempera- ture. i. Fast loading. In addition to averages, captured al- ready by the chemomechanical kinetic equation (23), the master equation (25) allows one to follow the evolution of higher order moments. To illustrate this point, we now show how the HS system responds to abrupt per- turbationss which is exactly the type of mechanical test conducted in Ref. [1], see Fig. 19. The system is first maintained in equilibrium at y = y0 = 0.5 before an in- stantaneous length change (to y = 0.) is applied. This protocol is repeated for systems with N = 10 (dotted lines) and N = 100 (solid line). Again, individual real- Stochastic simulation of a quick force recovery FIG. 19. in response to a step of y − y0 = −0.5. (a) Tension per cross-linker; (b) heat released. Dotted lines: Single stochastic trajectory for a system with N = 10; gray line single trajec- tory with N = 100; solid line average over 1000 trajectories with N = 10; squares, response obtained using the HS kinetic equation (23). Inserts in (a), gray (respectively, solid) line, fluctuations obtained using 1000 realizations for N = 100 (re- spectively, N = 10). Here β = 4 and y0 = 0.5. FIG. 17. Response of the HS model to a ramp loading from y0 − 1 to y0 + 1 achieved in 1000 τ , for β = 4 [(a) and (c)] and β = 10 [(b) and (d)]. Individual stochastic trajectories are shown for N = 10 (light gray) and N = 100 (dark gray). [(a) and (b)] Evolution of the order parameter p. The inserts show two samples of a single trajectory around the point where p = 1/2. [(c) and (d)] Tension-elongation relations obtained from σ = y + p. The inserts show the marginal distribution ρ at the two different times indicted by the vertical bars. Solid lines represent the thermal equilibrium averages given by Eq. (14) and Eq. (7) and open symbols show the solutions of the HS kinetic equation (23) and the distribution (26). circles). The inserts in Figs. 17(a) and 17(b) show sam- ples of the trajectories for single elements computed from (21). Observe that individual trajectories reveal at finite N a succession of jumps describing individual folding- unfolding events as is suggested by the analysis of the marginally equilibrated system. As the number of ele- ment increases the fluctuations of p decrease in accor- dance with our Eq. (16), and a single realization tra- jectory (dark gray) gets close to the average trajectory (black). In the inserts in Figs. 17(c) and 17(d) we show the probability density ρ obtained from (26) at different times (solid line) together with the equilibrium density (open circles). As expected, the distribution does not depend on temperature at y = y0 while becoming pro- gressively more localized away from this point. To make the stochastic fluctuations more visible, we compare in Fig. 18 the variance of the order parameter p obtained from the stochastic model (24) (gray lines) with the results of the analytic computations based on the kinetic equation (26) (thin lines) and the equilibrium model, see Eq. (16) (open circles). The system contains N = 10 elements and each stochastic trajectory corre- sponds to 104 realizations of our random walk. We see 0250500750100000.51t/τpβ=402505007501000t/τβ=10−1−0.500.510.60.811.21.4y−y0σσ0−1−0.500.51y−y0300400−10t/τxi600700−10t/τxi400500−10t/τxi500600−10t/τxi01pρ01pρ01pρ01pρ(a)(b)(c)(d)−1−0.500.5100.10.20.25β=2β=10y−y0Nh[p−hpi]2i−1−0.500.5100.050.1β=2β=10y−y0Q(a)(b)−10120.40.60.811.2t/τΣN−101200.050.10.15t/τQ020.10.251Nh(Σ−hΣi)2i(a)(b)14 FIG. 20. Time evolution (snapshots) of the probability den- sity ρ(p, t; y, β) showing gradual equilibration of the system subjected to an abrupt shortening. Lines: histograms ob- tained from 104 trajectories; symbols distributions recovered from the first order kinetic equations (23) and (26). Parame- ters are the same as described in the caption to Fig. 19 izations may strongly depart, especially at low N , from the average behavior described by the HS reaction equa- tion (23) (symbols). These fluctuations can also be seen from the dynam- ics of the density ρ which is reconstructed from a large number of sample trajectories/experiments in Fig. 20. We observe that for a system with a small number of elements [see Fig. 20(a), N = 10) the probability distri- bution remains broad even after the recovery while, for a system with large N [see Fig. 20(b), N = 10), the distri- bution is sharply peaked throughout the process. Again, we find a perfect agreement between the distribution ob- tained from the Monte-Carlo simulations (lines) and the one recovered from the knowledge of the averaged behav- ior given by the HS kinetic equation parametrizing the binomial distribution (26) (symbols). IV. SKELETAL MUSCLES The development of the HS model was originally mo- tivated by the mechanical experiments involving rapid shortening of skeletal muscles with the goal of distin- guishing passive from active contributions to tension re- covery [1, 56–59]. It was shown that the first phase of the response to a quasi-instantaneous shortening imposed on a maximally activated (tetanized) single muscle fiber represents a purely elastic force drop. During the sec- ond phase, the tension recovers to a level which depends nonlinearly on the amplitude of the shortening. This fast force recovery, lasting about 1 ms, precedes a consider- ably slower phase at the end of which the tension fully returns to its original value. The latter, taking place on a 100-ms time scale, is usually interpreted as an active process driven by ATP hydrolysis [7, 60]. j. Biochemistry vs mechanics. In their classical 1971 paper HS conjectured that the force recovery at the ms time scale must be attributed to a rapid folding in an assembly of attached cross-bridges linking actin and myosin filaments. The idea of bistability in the structure FIG. 21. Biochemical vs purely mechanistic description of the power stroke in skeletal muscles: (a) The Lymn-Taylor four-state cycle, LT(71) and (b) the Huxley-Simmons two- state cycle, HS (71). of myosin heads, giving rise to the concept of a power stroke, has been later fully supported by crystallographic studies [61, 62]. While the scenario proposed by HS is in agreement with the fact that the power stroke is the fastest step in the Lymn-Taylor (LT) enzymatic cycle [63, 64], there is a subtle formal disagreement with the existing bio- chemical picture, see Fig. 21. Thus, HS assumed that the mechanism of the fast force recovery is fully passive and can be reduced to a mechanically induced confor- mational change. In contrast, the LT cycle for acto- myosin complexes is based on the assumption that the power stroke can be reversed only actively through the completion of the bio chemical pathway including ADP (adenosine diphosphate) release, myosin unbinding, bind- ing of uncleaved ATP (adenosine triphosphate), splitting of ATP into ADP and Pi, and then rebinding of myosin to actin [6, 63]. In other words, while HS postulated that thermal fluc- tuations experienced by the attached myosin heads can be biased by external loading and that the power stroke can be reversed by mechanical means, most of the bio- chemical literature is based on the assumption that the power-stroke recocking cannot be accomplished without the presence of ATP. In particular, physiological fluctu- ations in muscle response are mostly addressed in the context of active behavior [65–71]. Some authors, however, follow the HS mechanistic ap- proach in assuming that the power-stroke-related leg of the LT cycle can be decoupled from the rest of the bio- chemical pathway; see, for instance, Refs [49, 72]. Below we adopt this perspective, which implies that at a 1-ms time scale the mechanism dominating muscle response is a purely mechanical folding-unfolding. We then col- lect specific predictions, generated by our augmented HS model, and use them as a guidance in designing new ex- periments aimed, in particular, at verifying the correct- ness of the underlying purely mechanistic model. k. Thermal effects. The knowledge of the free en- ergy of the HS system allows one to assess not only me- chanical but also thermal manifestations of the fast force recovery. The latter have been measured in experiments employing calorimetric techniques [49, 50, 73], however, a thermomechanical interpretation of these experiments in the HS framework is still an open question. 00.5100.20.4t=0t=0.1τt=τpρN=1000.5100.050.1t=0t=0.1τt=τpN=100AM(AMADPPi)AM(AMADP)M(MATP)M(MADPPi)(a)LT(71)AMAM(b)HS(71)For instance, studies of the heat exchange following the application of a fast length drop showed an increase of temperature at the time scale of the purely elastic response followed by a slower cooling during the force recovery up to a level which is higher than the baseline preceding the step. While, the temperature decay was linked to the equilibrium heat effect of the conformational change, which was assumed to be negative [73], the HS model predicts a positive heat effect because a "mixed" state with high entropy is transformed into a "pure" state with low entropy. More specifically, the HS-type interpretation of the temperature measurements during the fast force recov- ery would be as follows: (i) The rapid increase of temperature recorded dur- ing the applied length step is a reflection of an adiabatic temperature increase. To justify this claim, we mention that several experimental studies of muscles, involving temperature changes due to rapid switching between, so- lutions showed that the time scale of temperature equi- libration within a typical muscle fiber is of the order of 10 ms [74, 75], which is 10 times slower than the duration of the fast force recovery process. (ii) The subsequent temperature decay is an outcome of the cooling due to heat conduction and the heat release due to the conformational change. The fact that the temperature at the end of the recovery is higher than the baseline temperature is a signature of the exothermic nature of the folding process (of the working-stroke) and the inefficiency of the heat removal mechanism at this time scale. Several groups have also addressed the influence of temperature on the force generation either by perform- ing mechanical experiments in different solutions [45, 46] or by applying rapid temperature changes to tetanized muscle fibers [47, 48, 76]. In both cases the experiments show that the isometric tension increases with tempera- ture while the conformational state of the cross-bridges becomes more homogeneous. Such a response in the case of fast adiabatic changes can be explained by the fact that, in order to maintain the value of the entropy at higher temperature, the HS system must evolve towards a more ordered configuration. This effect, however, is not captured by the HS model where temperature does not affect the value of isometric tension at y = y0, see our Fig. 3. To describe quantitatively the temperature de- pendence of the tension-elongation curves, we may aug- ment the HS model by assuming phenomenologically that the energy bias v0 is a function of temperature [46]. While the value of the isometric tension may depend significantly on temperature, experiments show that the slope of the tension-elongation curve is only weakly tem- perature sensitive [49]. In general, the HS model pre- dicts considerable dependence of the shape of the tension- elongation relation on temperature, including the possi- bility of negative stiffness which is not observed in exper- iment. However, in the range of temperatures considered in experiment (no more than 20°C) this effect is weak. 15 For instance, if we assume that the mechanical properties of the cross-bridges are not affected by temperature, as is observed in experiments [45], and take β = 4 at T = 4°C, we obtain β ∼ 3.8 at T = 24°C. In the HS model, the sensitivity of the equilibrium tension-elongation curves to such variations of β is negligible. Among other interesting thermomechanical effects, in- voked by the HS model, we mention the "infinite" cooling in the process of reaching the state of isometric contrac- tions. To observe this effect the muscle must be first equilibrated after shortening (at the T2 state) and then stretched back to the T0 state. l. Fluctuations. While in myofibrils half-sarcomeres fluctuations can be expected to average out, at the scale of an elementary acto-myosin complex (our half- sarcomere, see Fig. 11), where N ∼ 102, fluctuations may interfere with experiments. For instance, as we have seen in our Fig. 17 and Fig. 19, the abrupt transitions asso- ciated with conformational changes in individual cross- bridges may produce measurable steps in the response curves. Another way of assessing the role of fluctuations is through the measurement of equilibrium susceptibilities. Thus, the effective stiffness of the HS bundle can be rep- resented as a sum of an enthalpic term describing zero- temperature elasticity and an entropic term that can be evaluated from the measurements of tension fluctuations. More specifically, given that such fluctuations can be measured, our Eq. (20) allows one to track the number of the attached elements at different degrees of stretching and different temperatures. On the other hand, in mechanical experiments con- ducted on single fibers and involving x-ray diffraction measurements [77], one can, in principle, test the predic- tion of the model that the configuration with (cid:104)p(cid:105) = 1/2 is the state of maximum disorder. By studying statis- tics of the observed fluctuations in the steady states, one can also search for deviations from the static fluctuation- dissipation relation (5). If found, then they may reveal the presence of out-of-equilibrium active processes at the time scales of fast force recovery which would then recon- cile the mechanical and the biochemical pictures of this phenomenon [78]. of fluctuations m. Cooperativity. Statistics for groups of myosins has been studied exhausively in experiments involving active contraction. Considerable coordination between individual elements was detected, responsible for synchronized oscillations in close to stall conditions (our point y = y0) [56, 79–84]. The coopera- tive behavior was explained by the fact that, due to the presence of long-range elastic interactions transmited through compliant backbones, the mechanical state of one motor influences the kinetics of other motors [40, 41]. The implied myosin-myosin coupling was taken into consideration in models addressing active behavior of motor groups [85, 86] and emergent phenomena characterized by large-scale entrainment signatures were identified [29, 65, 66, 87, 88]. The claims that activity in such systems is crucial for the emergence of synchronized oscillations were supported by in vitro assays [65, 66] showing that the finite size scaling of the fluctuations is fundamentally differs from the equilibrium one N−1/2. It is clear that to capture this effect, the original HS model with rigid backbone and controlled displacement has to be generalized, but the actual role of activity in synchronization of cross-bridges is not obvious. Thus, it has been recently argued [2] that the dominant factor behind collective behavior is not activity but the long- range interactions between cross-bridges. The simplest way to create such "cross-talk" without leaving the HS framework is to consider the response of a HS system subjected to a constant force (soft device) rather than a constant displacement [26]. It has been shown that in the systems of this type the nonconvexity of the free energy can resist thermal fluctuations at sufficiently low temperatures, giving rise to macroscopic cooperativity. Moreover, in the case of soft and mixed (soft-hard) load- ings, the pseudocritical point of HS at β = 4 becomes a real critical point of the Curie type around which fluctu- ations diverge in the thermodynamic limit and can show unusual finite-size scaling [2]. V. NONMUSCLE SYSTEMS The prototypical nature of the HS model makes it rel- evant outside the skeletal muscle context as well. In fact, it can be viewed as a description of a large class of biological systems involving collectively biased multi- stable elements and exhibiting, as a result, sigmoidal or ultrasensitive response at finite temperatures as in our Fig. 2(a). The HS model describes, perhaps, the most elementary molecular system capable of transforming in a Brownian environment a continuous input into a bi- nary, all-or-none output that is crucial for the fast and efficient, stroke-type behavior. We recall that the capacity of multisite systems to flip in a reversible fashion between several metastable confor- mations is essential for many processes in cellular phys- iology, including cell signaling, cell movement, chemo- taxis, differentiation, and selective expression of genes [89, 90]. Usually, both the input and the output in such systems, known as allosteric, are assumed to be of bio- chemical origin. The HS model, dealing with mechanical response and relying on mechanical driving, complements biochemical models and presents a different perspective on allostery. n. Hair cell gating. Our first example of hypersen- sitivity concerns the transduction channels in hair cells [91]. Each hair cell contains a bundle of N ≈ 50 stere- ocilia which are mechanically stimulated by the vibra- tions in the inner ear. The stereocilia possess transduc- tion channels closed by "gating springs" which can open (close) in response to a positive (negative) shear strain X, imposed on the cilia from outside. The broadly accepted model of this phenomenon [10] 16 views the hair bundle as a set of N bistable springs ar- ranged in parallel. It is identical to the HS model if the folded (unfolded) configurations of cross-bridges are identified with the closed (opened) states of the channels. The applied loading, which tilts the potential and biases in this way the distribution of closed and open configu- rations, is treated in this model as a hard device of HS. To stress the equivalence of the results, it is enough to mention the expression for the total stiffness of a hair bundle obtained in Ref. [10], which is a direct analog of our Eq. (15). Moreover, the mechanical experiments, involving a mechanical solicitation of the hair bundle through an effectively rigid glass fiber showed that the stiffness of the hair bundle is negative around the phys- iological functioning point of the system [11] , which is fully compatible with the predictions of the HS model. o. Cell adhesion. A similar analogy can be drawn between the HS model and the models of collective unzip- ping for adhesive clusters [9, 92–95]. At the micro-scale we again deal with N elements representing, for instance, integrins or cadherins, that are attached in parallel to a common, relatively rigid pad. The two conformational states, which can be described by a single spin variable, are the bound and the unbound configurations. The binding-unbinding phenomena in a mechanically biased system of the HS type are usually described by the Bell model [8], which is a soft device analog of the HS model with κ0 = ∞. In this model the breaking of an adhesive bond represents an escape from a metastable state and the corresponding rates are computed by using Kramers' theory [95, 96] as in the HS model. In partic- ular, the rebinding rate is often assumed to be constant [97, 98], which is also the assumption of HS for the reverse transition from the post- to the pre-power-stroke state. More recently, Bell's model was generalized through the inclusion of ligand tethers, bringing a finite value to κ0 and using the master equation for the probability distri- bution of attached units [9, 97]. The main difference between the Bell-type models and the HS model is that the detached state cannot bear force while the unfolded conformation can. As a result, while the cooperative folding-unfolding (ferromagnetic) behavior in the HS model is possible in the soft device setting [2], similar cooperative binding-unbinding in the Bell model is impossible because the rebinding of a fully detached state has zero probablity. To obtain cooperativ- ity in models of adhesive clusters, one must use a mixed device, mimicking the elastic backbone and interpolating between soft and hard driving [9, 26, 95, 99]. p. Synaptic fusion. While muscle tissues maintain stable architecture over long periods of time, it is feasi- ble that transitory muscle-type structures can be also as- sembled to perform particular functions. An interesting example of such assembly is provided by the SNARE pro- teins responsible for the fast release of neurotransmitors from neurons to synaptic clefts. The fusion of synaptic vesicles with the presynaptic plasma membrane [22, 100] is achieved by mechanical zipping of the SNARE com- plexes which can in this way transform from opened to closed conformation [101]. To complete the analogy, we mention that individual SNAREs participating in the collective zipping are at- tached to an elastic membrane that can be mimicked by an elastic or even rigid backbone [102]. The presence of a backbone mediating long-range interactions allows the SNAREs to cooperate in fast and efficient closing of the gap between the vesicle and the membrane. The analogy with muscles is corroborated by the fact that synaptic fusion takes place at the same time scale as the fast force recovery (1 ms) [103]. q. Macromolecular hairpins. Another class of phe- nomena that can be rationalized within the HS frame- work is the ubiquitous flip-flopping of macro-molecular hairpins subjected to mechanical loading [12–14, 16]. We recall that in a typical experiment of this type, a folded (zipped) macromolecule is attached through com- pliant links to micron-sized beads trapped in optical tweezers. As the distance between the laser beams is increased, the force applied to the molecule rises up to a point where the subdomains start to unfold. An indi- vidual unfolding event may correspond to the collective rupture of N molecular bonds or an unzipping of a hair- pin. The corresponding drops in the force accompanied by an abrupt increase in the total stretch can lead to an overall negative stiffness response [12, 15, 55]. Realistic examples of unfolding in macromolecules may involve complex "fracture" avalanches [19] that cannot be modeled by using the original HS model. However, the HS theoretical framework is general enough to ac- commodate hierarchical meta-structures whose stability can be also biased by mechanical loading. In fact, the importance of the topology of interconnections among the bonds and the link between the collective nature of the unfolding and the dominance of the HS-type parallel bonding have been long stressed in the studies of protein folding [104]. The broad applicability of the HS mechan- ical perspective on collective conformational changes is also corroborated by the fact that proteins and nucleic acids exhibit negative stiffness and behave differently in soft and hard devices [18, 20, 21]. The ensemble dependence in these systems suggests that additional structural information can be obtained if the unfolding experiments are performed in the mixed de- vice setting. The type of loading may be affected through the variable rigidity of the "handles" [105, 106] or the use of an appropriate feedback control that can be modeled in the HS framework by a variable backbone elasticity. r. Allosteric systems. As we have already men- tioned, collective conformational changes in distributed biological systems containing coupled bistable units can be driven not only mechanically, by applying forces or displacements, but also biochemically by, say, varying concentrations or chemical potentials of ligand molecules in the environment [107]. Such systems can become ul- trasensitive to external stimulations as a result of the in- teraction between individual units undergoing conforma- 17 tional transformation which gives rise to the phenomenon of allostery also known as conformational spread [90, 108]. The switch-like input-output relations are required in a variety of biological applications because they ensure both robustness in the presence of external perturbations and ability to quickly adjust the configuration in response to selected stimuli [89, 109]. The mastery of control of biological machinery through mechanically induced con- formational spread is an important step in designing ef- ficient biomimetic nanomachines [35, 110–112]. To link this behavior to the HS model, we note that the amplified dose response, characteristic of allostery, is analogous to the sigmoidal stress response of the param- agnetic HS system where an applied displacement plays the role of the controlled input of a ligand. Usually, in allosteric protein systems, the ultrasensitive behavior is achieved as a result of nonlocal interactions favoring all- or-none types of responses; moreover, the required long- range coupling is provided by mechanical forces acting inside membranes and molecular complexes. In the HS model such coupling is modeled by the parallel arrange- ment of elements, which preserves the general idea of non- locality. Despite its simplicity, the appropriately general- ized HS model [2] captures the main patterns of behavior exhibited by allosteric systems, including the possibility of a critical point mentioned in Ref. [107]. VI. CONCLUSIONS In this paper we presented a perspective on the sem- inal work of Huxley and Simmons by viewing their re- sults through the prism of statistical mechanics. This allowed us to place an emphasis on thermal effects and equilibrium fluctuations that cannot be ignored in many biological applications of the HS model. The chemomechanical approach of HS is based on the description of a mechanical system with N elements in a thermal bath in terms of a single deterministic reaction equation. Instead, our analysis starts with the analogy between the HS model in a hard device and the param- agnetic Ising model where the average conformation of a cross-bridge viewed as the counterpart of magnetiza- tion. In view of this analogy, the HS model describes a size indifferent mean-field statistical mechanical system which explains why the many-body stochastic dynamics can be modeled by a single chemical reaction. The anal- ogy with paramagnetism is, however, not complete, as is revealed by the phenomena of negative susceptibility and pseudo-criticality that we identify with the HS model. In particular, we show that while genuine criticality requires cooperativity, in the HS model the collective response is imposed through the rigid backbone rather than being an emergent property. Some of the most interesting findings of this paper con- cern the thermal properties of the HS system. Thus, our analysis highlights the previously unnoticed temper- ature robustness of the pseudocritical state where specific heat vanishes and fluctuations become temperature inde- pendent. We also quantified the temperature variations during fast unfolding and demonstrated that isothermal and adiabatic responses may differ. These observations point towards the importance of the nonorthodox experi- mental protocols combining mechanical and calorimetric measurements. In particular, the revealed fluctuation de- pendence of equilibrium susceptibilities suggests a non- crystallographic way for the evaluation of the number of folding elements. To account for fluctuations in kinetics we, following Refs. [29, 30], went beyond the reaction-based modeling of the averages and studied the time dependence of the probability distributions for various parameters during mechanical transients. The results of the deterministic model of HS are, of course, recovered from the analysis of the evolution of the first moments of these distributions. While being the simplest mean-field description of a broad class of biological phenomena, the HS model clearly misrepresents the important elastic coupling be- tween the folding elements, as has been long realized in muscle physiology [40, 41]. This drawback can be reme- died by taking into account the mechanical feedback in- duced by the backbone elasticity [2] resulting in various 18 degrees of synchronization already at zero temperature [26]. A more important limitation of the HS model is the neglect of the ATP-fueled activity which can crucially in- terfere with passive folding [29, 65, 66, 85–88, 113]. The account of nonthermal driving in the HS setting produces new qualitative effects [78, 114] which opens the possibil- ity to build a fully mechanistic analog of the enzimatic cycle originating in the work of Lymn and Taylor. Quan- titative applications of the HS model in and outside the muscle context also call upon the account of complex geometry, hierarchical architecture, soft-spin-type multi- stability, and short-range interactions. All these poten- tial augmentations, however, will not diminish the role of the original HS model as a source of fundamental physical intuition about the behavior of a wide class of biological systems. VII. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank R. Sheshka, P. Recho, T. Leli`evre and J.-M. Allain and the anonymous reviewers for helpful comments. [1] A. F. Huxley and R. M. Simmons, Nature 233, 533 [18] T. Bornschlogl and M. Rief, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 118102 (1971). (2006). [2] M. Caruel, J. M. Allain, and L. Truskinovsky, Phys. [19] A. Srivastava and R. Granek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, Rev. Lett. 110, 248103 (2013). 138101 (2013). [3] T. L. Hill, Prog. Biophys. Molec. Biol. 29, 105 (1976). [4] A. F. Huxley and S. Tideswell, J. Muscle Re. Cell M. [20] U. Gerland, R. Bundschuh, and T. Hwa, Biophysj 84, 2831 (2003). 17, 507 (1996). [21] N. Thomas and Y. Imafuku, J Theor Biol 312, 96 [5] G. Piazzesi and V. Lombardi, Biophys. J. 68, 1966 (2012). (1995). [6] D. Smith, M. Geeves, J. Sleep, and S. Mijailovich, Ann. [22] T. C. Sudhof, Neuron 80, 675 (2013). [23] L. L. Bonilla, A. Carpio, A. Prados, and R. R. Rosales, Biomed. Eng. 36, 1624 (2008). Phys. Rev. E 85, 031125 (2012). [7] M. Linari, M. Caremani, and V. Lombardi, P Roy. Soc. Lond. B Bio. 277, 19 (2010). [8] G. Bell, Science 200 (1978). [9] T. Erdmann and U. S. Schwarz, Eur. Phys. J. E 22, 123 (2007). [10] J. Howard and A. J. Hudspeth, Neuron 1, 189 (1988). [11] P. Martin, A. Mehta, and A. Hudspeth, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 97, 12026 (2000). [12] J. Liphardt, B. Onoa, S. B. Smith, I. Tinoco, and C. Bustamante, Science 292, 733 (2001). [13] N. Bosaeus, A. H. El-Sagheer, T. Brown, S. B. Smith, and B. Norden, Proc. B. Akerman, C. Bustamante, Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 109, 15179 (2012). [14] M. T. Woodside, C. Garcia-Garcia, and S. M. Block, Curr. Opin. Chem. Biol. 12, 640 (2008). [15] A. N. Gupta, A. Vincent, K. Neupane, H. Yu, F. Wang, [24] T. L. Hill, Prog. Biophys. Molec. Biol. 28, 267 (1974). [25] L. Marcucci and L. Truskinovsky, Phys. Rev. E 81 (2010). [26] M. Caruel, J.-M. Allain, and L. Truskinovsky, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 76, 237 (2015). [27] S. Pradhan, A. Hansen, and B. K. Chakrabarti, Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 499 (2010). [28] R. Balian, From Microphysics to Macrophysics, Meth- ods and Applications of Statistical Physics (Springer Science & Business Media, 2006). [29] A. Vilfan and T. Duke, Biophys. J. 85, 818 (2003). [30] T. Erdmann, P. J. Albert, and U. S. Schwarz, J. Chem. Phys. 139, 175104 (2013). [31] J. S. Rowlinson, Liquids and liquid mixtures, Modern as- pects series of chemistry (Butterworths, London, 1959). [32] D. R. Squire, A. C. Holt, and W. G. Hoover, Physica and M. T. Woodside, Nat Phys 7, 631 (2011). 42, 388 (1969). [16] A. Prados, A. Carpio, and L. L. Bonilla, Phys. Rev. E 86, 021919 (2012). [33] J. F. Lutsko, J. Appl. Physiol. 65, 2991 (1989). [34] J. P. Wittmer, H. Xu, P. Poli´nska, F. Weysser, and [17] V. Munoz, E. R. Henry, J. Hofrichter, and W. A. Eaton, J. Baschnagel, J. Chem. Phys. 138, 191101 (2013). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 95, 5872 (1998). [35] Z. Wu, R. Harne, and K. Wang, J. Intell. Mat. Syst. Struct. 27, 1189 (2016). 19 [36] E. Eisenberg and T. Hill, Prog. Biophys. Molec. Biol. 33, 55 (1978). [37] L. E. Ford, A. F. Huxley, and R. M. Simmons, J. Phys- iol. 269, 441 (1977). [65] L. Hilbert, S. Cumarasamy, N. B. Zitouni, M. C. Mackey, and A.-M. Lauzon, Biophysj 105, 1466 (2013). [66] L. Hilbert, Z. Balassy, N. B. Zitouni, M. C. Mackey, and A.-M. Lauzon, Biophys. J. 108, 622 (2015). [38] L. E. Ford, A. F. Huxley, and R. M. Simmons, The [67] J. E. Baker, C. Brosseau, P. B. Joel, and D. M. War- Journal of physiology 311, 219 (1981). shaw, Biophysj 82, 2134 (2002). [39] H. Kojima, A. Ishuima, and T. Yanagida, Proc. Natl. [68] J. E. Baker, C. Brosseau, P. Fagnant, and D. M. War- Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 91, 12962 (1994). shaw, J. Biol. Chem. 278, 28533 (2003). [40] K. Wakabayashi, Y. Sugimoto, H. Tanake, Y. Ueno, Y. Takezawa, and Y. Amemiya, Biophys. J. 67, 2422 (1994). [69] B. D. Haldeman, R. K. Brizendine, K. C. Facemyer, J. E. Baker, and C. R. Cremo, J. Biol. Chem. 289, 21055 (2014). [41] H. Huxley, A. Stewart, H. Sosa, and T. Irving, Biophys. [70] Anneka M Hooft, Erik J Maki, K. K. Cox, and J. E. J. 67, 2411 (1994). [42] G. Piazzesi, M. Reconditi, M. Linari, L. Lucii, P. Bianco, E. Brunello, V. Decostre, A. Stewart, D. B. Gore, T. C. Irving, M. Irving, and V. Lombardi, Cell 131, 784 (2007). [43] M. Irving, G. Piazzesi, L. Lucii, Y. Sun, J. Harford, I. Dobbie, M. Ferenczi, M. Reconditi, and V. Lombardi, Nat. Struct. Biol. 7, 482 (2000). [44] A. V. Hill, P Roy. Soc. Lond. B Bio. 126, 136 (1938). [45] G. Piazzesi, A. Reconditi, N. Koubassova, V. Decostre, M. Linari, L. Lucii, and V. Lombardi, J. Physiol. 549, 93 (2003). [46] V. Decostre, P. Bianco, V. Lombardi, and G. Piazzesi, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 102, 13927 (2005). [47] K. W. Ranatunga, M. E. Coupland, G. J. Pinniger, H. Roots, and G. W. Offer, J. Physiol. 585, 263 (2007). [48] M. Coupland and K. W. Ranatunga, J. Physiol. 548, 439 (2003). Baker, Biochemistry 46, 3513 (2007). [71] J. Del R Jackson and J. E. Baker, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 11, 4808 (2009). [72] M. Caremani, L. Melli, M. Dolfi, V. Lombardi, and M. Linari, J. Physiol. 593, 3313 (2015). [73] S. H. Gilbert and L. E. Ford, Biophysj 54, 611 (1988). and R. Cooke, [74] E. Pate, G. J. Wilson, M. Bhimani, Biophysj 66, 1554 (1994). [75] M. Linari, R. Bottinelli, M. Pellegrino, M. Reconditi, C. Reggiani, and V. Lombardi, J. Physiol. - London 555, 851 (2004). [76] K. W. Ranatunga, The Journal of physiology 588, 3657 (2010). [77] M. Reconditi, Rep. Prog. Phys. 69, 2709 (2006). [78] R. Sheshka and L. Truskinovsky, Phys. Rev. E 89, 012708 (2014). [79] A. F. Huxley, J. Physiol. 243, 1 (1974). [80] C. F. Armstrong, A. F. Huxley, and F. J. Julian, J. [49] R. C. Woledge, C. J. Barclay, and N. A. Curtin, P Roy. Physiol. 186, 22P (1966). Soc. Lond. B Bio. 276, 2685 (2009). [50] M. Linari and R. C. Woledge, J. Physiol. 487, 699 [81] K. A. P. Edman, J. Physiol. - London 404, 301 (1988). [82] K. Yasuda, Y. Shindo, and S. Ishiwata, Biophys. J. 70, (1995). 1823 (1996). [51] C. Veigel, M. Bartoo, D. White, J. Sparrow, and J. Mol- [83] K. A. P. Edman and N. Curtin, J. Physiol. - London loy, Biophys. J. 75, 1424 (1998). 534, 553 (2001). [52] M. Tyska and D. Warshaw, Cell Motil. Cytoskel. 51, 1 [84] P. Y. Pla¸cais, M. Balland, T. Guerin, J. F. Joanny, and (2002). [53] E. Brunello, M. Caremani, L. Melli, M. Linari, M. Fernandez-Martinez, T. Narayanan, M. Irving, G. Piazzesi, V. Lombardi, and M. Reconditi, The Jour- nal of physiology 592, 3881 (2014). [54] N. van Kampen, Stochastic Processes in Physics and P. Martin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103 (2009). [85] T. A. J. Duke, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 96, 2770 (1999). [86] T. Duke, Philos. T. Roy. Soc. B 355, 529 (2000). [87] M. Badoual, F. Julicher, and J. Prost, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 99, 6696 (2002). Chemistry (North-Holland, Amsterdam, 2001). [88] S. Walcott and S. X. Sun, Physical Chemistry Chemical [55] J.-D. Wen, M. Manosas, P. T. X. Li, S. B. Smith, C. Bustamante, F. Ritort, and I. Tinoco, Biophys. J. 92, 2996 (2007). [56] R. Podolsky, Nature 188, 666 (1960). [57] M. Civan and R. Podolsky, J. Physiol. 184, 511 (1966). [58] R. Podolsky, A. C. Nolan, and S. A. Zaveler, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 64, 504 (1969). [59] A. F. Huxley and R. M. Simmons, J. Physiol. 208, 52P (1970). Physics 11, 4871 (2009). [89] T. A. Duke, N. Le Novere, and D. Bray, J. Mol. Biol. 308, 541 (2001). [90] D. Bray, Journal of Molecular Biology 425, 1410 (2013). [91] V. Bormuth, J. Barral, J. F. Joanny, F. Julicher, and P. Martin, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 111, 7185 (2014). [92] B. Chen and H. Gao, Biophys. J. 101, 396 (2011). [93] H. Yao and H. Gao, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 54, 1120 [60] K. Holmes and M. Geeves, Philos. T. Roy. Soc. B 355, (2006). 419 (2000). [94] H. Gao, J. Qian, and B. Chen, J. R. Soc. Interface 8, [61] I. Rayment, H. Holden, M. Whittaker, C. Yohn, M. Lorenz, K. Holmes, and R. Milligan, Science 261, 58 (1993). 1217 (2011). [95] U. S. Schwarz and S. A. Safran, Reviews of Modern Physics 85, 1327 (2013). [62] R. Dominguez, Y. Freyzon, K. M. Trybus, and C. Co- [96] P. Hanggi, P. Talkner, and M. Borkovec, Reviews of hen, Cell 94, 559 (1998). [63] R. Lymn and E. Taylor, Biochemistry 10, 4617 (1971). [64] B. Alberts, A. Johnson, J. Lewis, M. Raff, K. Roberts, and P. Walter, Molecular Biology of the Cell, 5th ed. (Garland Science, New York, 2007). Modern Physics 62, 251 (1990). [97] T. Erdmann and U. S. Schwarz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 108102 (2004). [98] T. Erdmann and U. S. Schwarz, J. Chem. Phys. 121, 8997 (2004). 20 [99] U. Seifert, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 2750 (2000). [107] J. P. Changeux, J. Thi´ery, Y. Tung, and C. Kittel, [100] T. C. Sudhof and J. E. Rothman, Science 323, 474 Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 57, 335 (1967). (2009). [108] D. Bray and T. Duke, Annu Rev Biophys Biomol Struct [101] D. Min, K. Kim, C. Hyeon, Y. H. Cho, Y.-K. Shin, and 33, 53 (2004). T.-Y. Yoon, Nat. Commun. 4, 1705 (2013). [109] B. M. Slepchenko and M. Terasaki, Current Opinion in [102] F. Li, F. Pincet, E. Perez, W. S. Eng, T. J. Melia, J. E. Rothman, and D. Tareste, Nature Structural & Molec- ular Biology 14, 890 (2007). [103] S. Zorman, A. A. Rebane, L. Ma, G. Yang, M. A. Molski, J. Coleman, F. Pincet, J. E. Rothman, and Y. Zhang, Elife 3, e03348 (2014). [104] H. Dietz and M. Rief, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 098101 (2008). Genetics & Development 14, 428 (2004). [110] O. Miyashita, J. N. Onuchic, and P. G. Wolynes, PNAS 100, 12570 (2011). [111] B. Yurke, A. J. Turberfield, A. P. Mills, F. C. Simmel, and J. L. Neumann, Nature 406, 605 (2000). [112] R. L. Harne, Z. Wu, and K. W. Wang, J. Mech. Des 138, 021402 (2016). [113] T. Guerin, J. Prost, and J. F. Joanny, Eur. Phys. J. [105] R. Cerf, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 75, 2755 (1978). [106] E. Pfitzner, C. Wachauf, F. Kilchherr, and B. Pelz, 34, 60 (2011). [114] Sheshka, R, Recho, P, and Truskinovsky, Lev, Phys. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 52, 335 (2013). Rev. E 93, 052604 (2016).
1606.06594	1	1606	2016-06-20T00:34:03	Comment on Mente, O'Donnell, Rangarajan, et al. "Associations of urinary sodium excretion with cardiovascular events in individuals with an without hypertension: a pooled analysis of data from four studies"	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.QM" ]	Mente, O'Donnell, Rangarajan, et al. ignore a possible source of bias that may invalidate their finding of an anticorrelation between sodium intake and cardiovascular events	physics.bio-ph	physics	Comment on Mente, O'Donnell, Rangarajan, et al. "Associations of urinary sodium excretion with cardiovascular events in individuals with and without hypertension: a pooled analysis of data from four studies" Dept. Physics, Washington University St. Louis, Mo. 63130 J. I. Katz September 3, 2018 Abstract Mente, O'Donnell, Rangarajan, et al. ignore a possible source of bias that may invalidate their finding of an anticorrelation between sodium intake and cardiovascular events. Mente, O'Donnell, Rangarajan, et al. [1] ignore a possible source of bias in their analysis of association of sodium excretion with cardiovascular events. The population at any level of blood pressure will comprise individuals with varying levels of sodium sensitivity, and those with higher sensitivity will achieve that blood pressure if they ingest less sodium. As a result, within any blood pressure level, for example, normotension, there will be an anti- correlation between sodium intake and sodium sensitivity. If sodium sensitivity is causal of cardiovascular events or death this could explain the observational anticorrelation between sodium intake and these events. Such a causal relation between sodium sensitivity and adverse out- comes is plausible: sensitive individuals are likely to have been hypertensive in the past and to be so in the future. As a result, the observational associ- ation of low sodium excretion with cardiovascular events may not be causal, but an artefact of the anticorrelation between sodium intake and sensitivity within the normotensive group. 1 References [1] Mente A, O'Donnell M, Rangarajan S, et al. Associations of urinary sodium excretion with cardiovascular events in individuals with and with- out hypertension: a pooled analysis of data from four studies Lancet on line 20 May 2016 2
1808.04499	1	1808	2018-08-14T01:00:30	Dynamical and Coupling Structure of Pulse-Coupled Networks in Maximum Entropy Analysis	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.NC" ]	Maximum entropy principle (MEP) analysis with few non-zero effective interactions successfully characterizes the distribution of dynamical states of pulse-coupled networks in many experiments, e.g., in neuroscience. To better understand the underlying mechanism, we found a relation between the dynamical structure, i.e., effective interactions in MEP analysis, and the coupling structure of pulse-coupled network to understand how a sparse coupling structure could lead to a sparse coding by effective interactions. This relation quantitatively displays how the dynamical structure is closely related to the coupling structure.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Dynamical and Coupling Structure of Pulse-Coupled Networks in Maximum Entropy Analysis Zhi-Qin John Xu1,∗ Douglas Zhou2,† and David Cai1,2,3 1NYUAD Institute, New York University Abu Dhabi, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, 2School of Mathematical Sciences, MOE-LSC and Institute of Natural Sciences, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, P.R. China, 3Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences and Center for Neural Science, New York University, New York, New York, USA. 8 1 0 2 g u A 4 1 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 9 9 4 4 0 . 8 0 8 1 : v i X r a (Dated: August 15, 2018) Maximum entropy principle (MEP) analysis with few non-zero effective interactions successfully character- izes the distribution of dynamical states of pulse-coupled networks in many experiments, e.g., in neuroscience. To better understand the underlying mechanism, we found a relation between the dynamical structure, i.e., ef- fective interactions in MEP analysis, and the coupling structure of pulse-coupled network to understand how a sparse coupling structure could lead to a sparse coding by effective interactions. This relation quantitatively displays how the dynamical structure is closely related to the coupling structure. PACS numbers: 89.70.Cf, 87.19.lo, 87.19.ls, 87.19.ll Binary-state networks -- each node in one sampling time bin is binary-state -- arise from many research fields, e.g., gene regulatory modeling and neural dynamics [15, 23, 26]. Sta- tistical distributions of network states are essential to encode information [6, 11, 18, 20, 25]. For example, with statisti- cal distributions of network states, experimental studies show that rats can perform awake replays of remote experiences in hippocampus [10]. Many works effectively characterize the distribution of 2n network states for n binary-state nodes in various systems, e.g., a network of ∼ 100 neurons [8], with a low-order maximum entropy principle (MEP) analy- sis [2, 4, 13, 14, 19, 22, 24, 27] -- a method with few (far less than 2n) non-zero effective interactions (see a precise defini- tion in Eq. (1)) constrained by low-order statistics. We can then regard those effective interactions as a sparse coding of the information that encoded in the state distribution. To un- derstand coding schemes of network systems, it is important, however, yet to understand what leads to the sparsity of effec- tive interactions. In this work, we would mainly use neural networks as examples for illustration, while our results apply to general binary-state networks. Estimated by dynamical data of a network system, effec- tive interactions reflect a dynamical structure of the network. This dynamical structure has been used to study the functional connectivity of networks [7, 27]. For example, experimental studies show that the second-order effective interaction map of the retina is sparse and dominated by local overlapping ef- fective interaction modules [7]. Network dynamical structure often closely relates to the underlying coupling structure [29]. For example, when the input of each node is independent to others, i) high-order (≥ 2) effective interactions are zero in a network of no connections, ii) high-order effective interac- tions are large in a dense and strong connected excitatory net- work. To efficiently encode information, a realistic system ∗ [email protected] † [email protected] often incorporates a coupling structure with certain features [3, 17], e.g., sparsity, small-world, or scale-free. However, it is still unclear how the coupling structure affects the dynami- cal structure of effective interactions. In this letter, we consider a general class of pulse-coupled networks. The state of each node is binary-state, i.e., ac- tive when the node sends pulses to its child nodes, otherwise, silent. We observed a Fact that leads to an explicit relation -- which is independent of node dynamics -- between the cou- pling structure and the number of non-zero effective interac- tions in the full-order MEP analysis (constrained by all mo- ments). We examine our observed Fact by numerical simula- tions. Through our analysis, we can estimate an upper bound of the number of non-zero effective interactions for a given coupling structure when the external input of each node is in- dependent with each other. Our results show that a sparse network could lead to a lot of vanishing high-order effective interactions. For illustration, we estimate the number of non- zero effective interactions for each order in a network with Erdos-Renyi connection structure, in which our estimation is much smaller than Ck n, the number of all possible kth-order effective interactions. Our results establish a connection be- tween the dynamical structure and the network coupling struc- ture. This connection provides an insight into how a sparse coupling structure can lead to a sparse coding scheme. In the following analysis, we use binary vector V (l) = (σ1,··· ,σn) ∈ {0,1}n to represent the state of n nodes within the sampling time bin labeled by l. To obtain correlations up to the mth-order requires to evaluate all (cid:104)σi1 ···σiM(cid:105)E, where 1 ≤ i1 < i2 < ··· < iM ≤ n, 1 ≤ M ≤ m, and (cid:104)·(cid:105)E is de- fined by(cid:104)g(l)(cid:105)E = ∑NT l=1 g(l)/NT for any function g(l) and NT is the total number of sampling time bins in the recording. The mth-order MEP analysis is to find the desired probabil- ity distribution P(V ) for n nodes by maximizing the entropy S ≡ −∑V P(V )logP(V ) subject to correlations up to the mth- order (m ≤ n). Then, the unique distribution can be solved as Pm(V ) = 1 Z exp( m ∑ k=1 n ∑ i1<···<ik Ji1···ikσi1 ···σik ), (1) where, following the terminology of statistical physics, we call Ji1···ik a kth-order effective interaction (1 ≤ k ≤ m), the partition function Z is the normalization factor. Eq. (1) is referred to as the mth-order MEP distribution. First, we discuss the relationship between effective inter- actions and the statistical distribution of network states. By (1) for Pn(V ), we taking logarithm of both sides of Eq. can get a set linear equations of all-order effective interac- tions for all states V . Since Pn is the same as the exper- imental observed distribution [1], we can obtain the effec- tive interactions in Pn in terms of the experimental observed distribution [28]. For example, n = 3, we can obtain J1 = log(P100/P000) and J12 = log(P110/P010)− J1, where Pσ1σ2σ3 represents the probability of the network state (σ1,σ2,σ3). By applying P(σ1,σ2,σ3) = P(σ1σ2,σ3)P(σ2,σ3), we have P(σ1=0σ2=0,σ3=0) and J12 = log P(σ1=1σ2=1,σ3=0) J1 = log P(σ1=1σ2=0,σ3=0) P(σ1=0σ2=1,σ3=0) − 1 −J1. Our earlier study has shown a recursive structure J1 (cid:44) J1 among effective interactions, that is, the (k + 1)st-order ef- fective interaction J123...(k+1) can be obtained as follows [28]: First, we switch the state of the (k + 1)st node in J123...k from silent to active to obtain a new term J1 123...k, e.g., from J1 to J1 1 ; Then, we subtract J123...k from the new term to obtain J123...(k+1), i.e., J123...(k+1) = J1 123...k − J123...k. (2) Without lost of generality, we randomly select two nodes la- beled by 1 and 2. By the recursive relation, any kth-order ef- fective interaction that includes node 1 and 2 can be expressed as the summation of terms with the following basic form . 12(σ3,··· ,σn) = log Jb − log P(σ1 = 1σ2 = 1,σ3,··· ,σn) P(σ1 = 0σ2 = 1,σ3,··· ,σn) P(σ1 = 1σ2 = 0,σ3,··· ,σn) P(σ1 = 0σ2 = 0,σ3,··· ,σn) 12(1,0,··· ,0) − Jb (3) 12(0,0,··· ,0) and For example, J123 = Jb 12(0,1,0,··· ,0)]− J123. We can J1234 = [Jb observe that if nodes 1 and 2 are independent conditioned on all other nodes, i.e., P(σ1σ2 = 1,σ3,··· ,σn) = P(σ1σ2 = 0,σ3,··· ,σn), any effective interaction containing these two nodes is zero. 12(1,1,0,··· ,0)− Jb Next, we would show what kind of coupling structure could entail the conditional independence of two nodes. Here, we define some notations. In any sampling time bin [0,∆) with state V = (σ1,··· ,σn), ∀t ∈ [0,∆), we denote Ii,t as node i's input from the outside of the network, denote wi j(t) as the input from the node i to node j, denote C(i) as the set of all child notes of node i, denote Ui = C(i)∪{i}, denote P(e) as the probability of event e, denote U0 = {1,2,··· ,n}. Fact. For n pulse-coupled nodes with binary-state dynam- ics on a network with a coupling structure G0, in any sam- pling time bin [0,∆), ∀t ∈ [0,∆), ∀i1, j1 ∈ U0, we assume that: 2 (a) the external inputs of each node are independent to oth- ers, i.e., P(Ii1,t ,Ij1,t ) = P(Ii1,t )P(Ij1,t ); (b) whether a parent node sends spikes to its child nodes only depends on its state, i.e., P(wi1 j1(t),V ) = W (σi1,i1, j1,t), where W (·,·,·,·) is a real function. ∀i, j ∈ U0, if they neither are connected nor share any common child node, i.e., Ui ∩Uj = φ, then, node i and j are independent conditioned on the state of all other nodes, i.e., P(σi,σ jH) = P(σiH)P(σ jH), where H is a possible state of nodes in U0\{i, j}. (4) We justify our two assumptions as follows. To avoid the in- fluence of correlation in external inputs when we are studying the relation between the dynamical structure and the coupling structure, we assume that the external input of each node is in- dependent to others, i.e., assumption (a). The second assump- tion implicates a Markov-like property; that is, for a connected pair of pulse-coupled nodes in an equilibrium state, the pulse from the parent node to the child node only depends on the state of the parent node but is independent of inputs imposed on the parent node. For example, in neural networks, a neuron sends out spikes only when this neuron is active, regardless of what inputs are imposed on the neuron. The argument for the conclusion in Eq. (4) is as follows. By assumption (a), node i and node j can be dependent only through the coupling structure G0. When we are considering how node i and node j affect each other by changing their states through the coupling structure G0, we can consider a simplified coupling structure, G1, which ignores those con- nections that are independent of states of node i and node j, i.e., σi and σ j. ∀k ∈ Uo\{i, j}, i.e., any other node k, its state σk is fixed when we are considering the conditional probabil- ity in Eq. (4). By assumption (b), for node k's any child node l, the input from node k to node l is independent of σi and σ j. Thus, the connections started from those nodes in Uo\{i, j} are fixed for different states of σi and σ j. Therefore, G1 is a simplified coupling structure that only keeps those connec- tions originated from node i and node j in G0. In G1, any con- nection only exists in either sub-network Ui or sub-network Uj. Under the condition Ui ∩ Uj = φ, i.e., they neither are connected nor share any common child node, sub-network Ui and sub-network Uj are two isolated sub-networks. σi and σ j cannot affect each other by changing their states through the coupling structure G1, that is, node i and j are independent conditioned on the states of all other nodes. Fig.1 displays an example to illustrate our observed Fact. The coupling structure G0 is shown in Fig.1a. We focus on node 1 and node 2, where they neither are connected nor share any child node. When the state of other nodes (black) are fixed, all outputs from black nodes can be ignored in the sim- plified coupling structure G1, as shown in Fig.1b. Node 1 and node 2 respectively belong to two separate sub-networks. Therefore, nodes 1 and node 2 are independent conditioned on the state of all other nodes. Based on the recursive structure of effective interactions and the observed Fact, we reach the following conclusion: with the two assumptions in the observed Fact, for a group of 3 analysis Pn for this ring network. As shown in Fig.2c, the ef- fective interaction strengths of independent pairs (J24 and J13) are within the statistical error of shuffled results (red). Since every high-order (≥ 3) effective interaction includes at least one independent pair of nodes, as predicted, the strengths of all high-order effective interactions are within the statistical error of shuffled results as shown in Fig.2d. The second example in the second row in Fig.2, results are similar that dependent pairs and independent pairs can be identified through our observed Fact, and the strength of any effective interaction that includes the independent pair of nodes (node 1 and node 3) is within the statistical error of shuffled data. In this example, J124 is very small, i.e., within the statistical error of shuffled results. However, in our estima- tion by our conclusion, we do not categorized J124 to the class of zero-strength effective interactions. This example indicates that we estimate an upper bound of the number of non-zero ef- fective interactions. For a network of all excitatory nodes with the same coupling structure as the one in Fig.1e, J124 is sig- nificantly larger than zero (not shown). Since the strength of high-order effective interactions is small, a very long record- ing constraints us from examining ∆i j(H) for a large network. Base on the relation between the coupling structure and ef- fective interactions, the number of non-zero high-order effec- tive interactions can be small in a sparse connected network compared with Ck n, which is the number of all possible kth- order interactions. For example, we estimate the number of each-order non-zero effective interactions in a network with an Erdos-Renyi connection structure. We randomly generate 1000 networks of 100 nodes with an Erdos-Renyi connection. The connection probability between two nodes is 0.05. As shown in Fig.3, the number of non-zero kth-order (k > 1) ef- fective interactions is much smaller than Ck 100 (too large to be shown). The number of high-order effective interactions (or- der higher than 11th) almost vanishes (order higher than 20th not shown). In summary, we have established a relation between effec- tive interactions in MEP analysis and the coupling structure of pulse-coupled networks to understand how a sparse coupling structure could lead to a sparse coding by effective interac- tions. This relation quantitatively displays how the dynamical structure closely relates to the coupling structure. Even though high-order effective interactions are often much smaller compared with low-order ones [28], it is still unclear why small high-order effective interactions do not ac- cumulate to have a significant effect in a large network [8, 21]. For example, MEP distribution with a sparse low-order effec- tive interactions -- non-zero effective interactions are sparse and vanish when the order is high than the eighth-order -- can well capture the state distribution of 99 ganglion cells in the salamander retina responding to a natural movie clip or natural pixel [8]. In this study, we show that a large amount of effec- tive interactions vanish in a sparse coupling structure; thus, rationalizing the absence of the accumulation of high-order interactions for a large network. Finally, we point out that some important issues remain to be elucidated in the future. First, we have ignored correlations in external inputs when estimating the number of non-zero (a) (b) FIG. 1: Structure v.s. Simplified Structure. nodes {i1,i2,··· ,ik}, if there exists at least one pair of nodes that neither are connected nor share any child node, effective interaction Ji1,i2,··· ,ik is zero. In the system we would use to examine our conclusion is an integrate-and-fire (I&F) network, a general pulse-coupled network, with both excitatory and inhibitory nodes [29]. For the ith node, the dynamics of its state variable xi with time scales τ is governed by − (gbg i + gex)(xi − xex)− gin i (xi − xin), (5) xi = −xi τ j,k)/σ in] j,k (T in i j) in gex i i = ∑ j ∑k Sex jth excitatory nodes, and gin where xex and xin are the reversal values of excitation i = f ∑k H(t − gbg (ex) and inhibition (in), respectively. i,k)exp[−(t − T F T F i,k)/σ ex] is the background input with mag- nitude f and time scale σ ex, T F i,k is a Poisson process with rate µ, H(·) is the Heaviside function, gex i j H(t − j,k)exp[−(t − T ex j,k)/σ ex] is the excitatory pulse effective T ex interaction from other i = j,k)exp[−(t − T in i jH(t − T in ∑ j ∑k Sin is the inhibitory pulse effective interaction from other jth inhibitory nodes. The jth excitatory (inhibitory) node x j evolves continuously (5) until it reaches a firing threshold xth. according to Eq. That moment in time is referred to as a firing event (say, the kth spike) and denoted by T ex j,k). Then, x j is reset to the reset value xr (xin < xr < xth < xex) and held xr for an absolute refractory period of τref. Each spike emerging from the jth excitatory (inhibitory) node causes an instantaneous increase Sex i j (Sin i j are the excitatory and inhibitory coupling strengths, respectively. The model (5) de- scribes a general class of physical networks [5, 9, 15, 26, 29]. The first example, two excitatory and two inhibitory I&F nodes form a ring coupling structure (Fig.2a). For any pair of nodes, say, node i and j, we compute ∆i j(H) = P(σi = 1σ j = 1,H) − P(σi = 1σ j = 0,H), where H is one state of other two nodes. By our observed Fact, the conditional indepen- dent pairs are (neuron 1,neuron 3) and (neuron 2,neuron 4), and other pairs are categorized as dependent pairs. In Fig.2b, the strengths of ∆i j(H) of independent pairs (green) are almost two orders of magnitude smaller than those of dependent pairs (red). We then shuffle spike trains of each node. We similarly compute ∆i j(H) for 10 different shuffled data. Blue dots and cyan dots in Fig.2b are results of all shuffled data of depen- dent pairs and independent pairs, respectively. The strength of ∆i j(H) of independent pairs (green) -- computed from the ob- served data -- are within the statistical error of shuffled data. We then solve effective interactions in the full-order MEP i ), where Sex i j and Sin (gin 4 (a) (e) (b) (c) (d) (f) (g) (h) FIG. 2: Structure v.s. effective interactions of I&F networks . Each row shows a numerical case. In the first column, black arrows and red arrows represents excitatory and inhibitory connections, respectively. In the second column, red and green dots are the strengths of ∆i j(H) of dependent and independent pairs, respectively. Blue dots and cyan dots are the strengths of ∆i j(H) of dependent and independent pairs from ten shuffled spike trains, respectively. The third and fourth columns display absolute effective interaction strengths (blue bars). The corresponding node indexes for each effective interaction are shown in the abscissa. The mean and standard deviation of absolute strengths of each effective interaction of ten shuffled spike trains are also displayed by garnet bars. The simulation time for each network is 1.2× 108 ms. The time bin size for analysis is 10ms [22, 24]. Independent Poisson inputs for each network are µ = 0.1ms−1 and f = 0.1ms−1. The firing rate of each node is about 50Hz. Parameters are chosen [9] as xex = 14/3, xin = −2/3, σ ex = 2ms, σ in = 5ms, τ = 20ms, xth = 1, xr = 0, and τref = 2ms, Sex i j = Sin i j = 0.02. large network (e.g., ∼ 100 nodes) are very slow, e.g., Monte Carlo based methods [16, 21]. Our undergoing work is explor- ing a fast algorithm that exploits the sparsity of effective in- teractions. We have seen an indication that the algorithm can work well for an I&F network with sparse coupling structure; however, that work is yet to be fully verified to be conclusive. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank David W. McLaughlin for helpful dis- cussions. This work was supported by NSFC-11671259, NSFC-11722107, NSFC-91630208 and Shanghai Rising- Star Program-15QA1402600 (D.Z.); by NSF DMS-1009575 and NSFC-31571071 (D.C.); by Shanghai 14JC1403800, 15JC1400104, and SJTU-UM Collaborative Research Pro- gram (D.C. and D.Z.); and by the NYU Abu Dhabi Institute G1301 (Z.X., D.Z., and D.C.). FIG. 3: Network of Erdos-Renyi connection. We randomly generate 1000 networks of 100 nodes with an Erdos-Renyi connection. The connection probability between two nodes is 0.05. The number of non-zero effective interaction v.s. effective interaction order. The mean and standard deviation are respectively shown by the black line and shaded area. effective interactions. Correlated inputs can induce non-zero high-order effective interactions [12]. It is yet to consider how the statistics of inputs affect the sparsity of effective inter- actions. Second, current algorithms for estimating non-zero effective interactions (not limited to the second-order) for a 1234123410−410−2100 DepIndRDepRInd(34)(24)(23)(14)(13)(12)10−410−2100Interaction datashuffle(123)(124)(134)(234)(1234)10−410−2100Interaction datashuffle1234123410−410−2100 DepIndRDepRInd(34)(24)(23)(14)(13)(12)10−410−2100Interaction datashuffle(123)(124)(134)(234)(1234)10−410−2100Interaction datashuffle5 [1] S.-I. AMARI, Information geometry on hierarchy of probabil- ity distributions, Information Theory, IEEE Transactions on, 47 (2001), pp. 1701 -- 1711. [2] A. K. BARREIRO, J. GJORGJIEVA, F. RIEKE, AND E. SHEA- BROWN, When do microcircuits produce beyond-pairwise cor- relations?, Frontiers in computational neuroscience, 8 (2014). [3] E. BULLMORE AND O. SPORNS, Complex brain networks: graph theoretical analysis of structural and functional systems, Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 10 (2009), pp. 186 -- 198. [4] T. BURY, Statistical pairwise interaction model of stock mar- ket, The European Physical Journal B, 86 (2013), p. 89. [5] D. CAI, A. V. RANGAN, AND D. W. MCLAUGHLIN, Archi- tectural and synaptic mechanisms underlying coherent spon- taneous activity in v1, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 102 (2005), pp. 5868 -- 5873. [6] Y. DAN, J.-M. ALONSO, W. M. USREY, AND R. C. REID, Coding of visual information by precisely correlated spikes in the lateral geniculate nucleus, Nature neuroscience, 1 (1998), pp. 501 -- 507. [7] E. GANMOR, R. SEGEV, AND E. SCHNEIDMAN, The architec- ture of functional interaction networks in the retina, The journal of neuroscience, 31 (2011), pp. 3044 -- 3054. [8] E. GANMOR, R. SEGEV, AND E. SCHNEIDMAN, Sparse low- order interaction network underlies a highly correlated and learnable neural population code, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 108 (2011), pp. 9679 -- 9684. [9] W. GERSTNER AND W. M. KISTLER, Spiking neuron models: Single neurons, populations, plasticity, Cambridge university press, 2002. [10] M. P. KARLSSON AND L. M. FRANK, Awake replay of re- mote experiences in the hippocampus, Nature neuroscience, 12 (2009), p. 913. [11] D. C. KNILL AND A. POUGET, The bayesian brain: the role of uncertainty in neural coding and computation, TRENDS in Neurosciences, 27 (2004), pp. 712 -- 719. [12] J. H. MACKE, M. OPPER, AND M. BETHGE, Common in- put explains higher-order correlations and entropy in a simple model of neural population activity, Physical Review Letters, 106 (2011), p. 208102. [13] O. MARRE, S. EL BOUSTANI, Y. FR ´EGNAC, AND A. DES- TEXHE, Prediction of spatiotemporal patterns of neural activity from pairwise correlations, Physical review letters, 102 (2009), p. 138101. [14] E. A. MARTIN, J. HLINKA, AND J. DAVIDSEN, Pairwise net- work information and nonlinear correlations, Physical Review E, 94 (2016), p. 040301. [15] R. E. MIROLLO AND S. H. STROGATZ, Synchronization of pulse-coupled biological oscillators, SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics, 50 (1990), pp. 1645 -- 1662. [16] H. NASSER, O. MARRE, AND B. CESSAC, Spatio-temporal spike train analysis for large scale networks using the maximum entropy principle and monte carlo method, Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment, 2013 (2013), p. P03006. [17] M. E. NEWMAN, The structure and function of complex net- works, SIAM review, 45 (2003), pp. 167 -- 256. [18] I. E. OHIORHENUAN, F. MECHLER, K. P. PURPURA, A. M. SCHMID, Q. HU, AND J. D. VICTOR, Sparse coding and high- order correlations in fine-scale cortical networks, Nature, 466 (2010), pp. 617 -- 621. [19] E. SCHNEIDMAN, M. J. BERRY, R. SEGEV, AND W. BIALEK, Weak pairwise correlations imply strongly correlated network states in a neural population, Nature, 440 (2006), pp. 1007 -- 1012. [20] Y. Y. SHEMESH, FORKOSH, T. SHLAPOBERSKY, A. CHEN, AND E. SCHNEIDMAN, High-order social interactions in groups of mice, Elife, 2 (2013), p. e00759. SZTAINBERG, O. [21] J. SHLENS, G. D. FIELD, J. L. GAUTHIER, M. GRESCHNER, A. SHER, A. M. LITKE, AND E. CHICHILNISKY, The struc- ture of large-scale synchronized firing in primate retina, The Journal of Neuroscience, 29 (2009), pp. 5022 -- 5031. [22] J. SHLENS, G. D. FIELD, J. L. GAUTHIER, M. I. GRIVICH, D. PETRUSCA, A. SHER, A. M. LITKE, AND E. CHICHILNISKY, The structure of multi-neuron firing pat- terns in primate retina, The Journal of neuroscience, 26 (2006), pp. 8254 -- 8266. [23] J. STRICKER, S. COOKSON, M. R. BENNETT, W. H. MATHER, L. S. TSIMRING, AND J. HASTY, A fast, robust and tunable synthetic gene oscillator, Nature, 456 (2008), pp. 516 -- 519. [24] A. TANG, D. JACKSON, J. HOBBS, W. CHEN, J. L. SMITH, H. PATEL, A. PRIETO, D. PETRUSCA, M. I. GRIVICH, A. SHER, ET AL., A maximum entropy model applied to spatial and temporal correlations from cortical networks in vitro, The Journal of Neuroscience, 28 (2008), pp. 505 -- 518. [25] W. E. VINJE AND J. L. GALLANT, Sparse coding and decor- relation in primary visual cortex during natural vision, Science, 287 (2000), pp. 1273 -- 1276. [26] Z. WANG, Y. MA, F. CHENG, AND L. YANG, Review of pulse- coupled neural networks, Image and Vision Computing, 28 (2010), pp. 5 -- 13. [27] T. WATANABE, S. HIROSE, H. WADA, Y. IMAI, T. MACHIDA, I. SHIROUZU, S. KONISHI, Y. MIYASHITA, AND N. MA- SUDA, A pairwise maximum entropy model accurately de- scribes resting-state human brain networks, Nature communi- cations, 4 (2013), p. 1370. [28] Z.-Q. J. XU, G. BI, D. ZHOU, AND D. CAI, A dynamical state underlying the second order maximum entropy principle in neu- ronal networks, Communications in Mathematical Sciences, 15 (2017), pp. 665 -- 692. [29] D. ZHOU, Y. XIAO, Y. ZHANG, Z. XU, AND D. CAI, Causal and structural connectivity of pulse-coupled nonlinear net- works, Physical review letters, 111 (2013), p. 054102.
1204.0402	1	1204	2012-04-02T13:17:51	Chemo-mechanical instabilities in polarizable active layers	[ "physics.bio-ph", "nlin.PS" ]	We formulate and explore a generic continuum model of a polarizable active layer with neo-Hookean elasticity and chemo-mechanical interactions. Homogeneous solutions of the model equations exhibit a stationary long-wave instability when the medium is activated by expansion, and an oscillatory short-wave instability in the case of compressive activation. Both regimes are investigated analytically and numerically. The long-wave instability initiates a coarsening process, which provides a possible mechanism for the establishment of permanent polarization in spherical geometry.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Chemo-mechanical instabilities in polarizable active layers M. H. Kopf1 and L. M. Pismen1, 2 1Department of Chemical Engineering, Technion -- Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa 32000, Israel 2Minerva Center for Nonlinear Physics of Complex Systems We formulate and explore a generic continuum model of a polarizable active layer with neo-Hookean elas- ticity and chemo-mechanical interactions. Homogeneous solutions of the model equations exhibit a stationary long-wave instability when the medium is activated by expansion, and an oscillatory short-wave instability in the case of compressive activation. Both regimes are investigated analytically and numerically. The long-wave in- stability initiates a coarsening process, which provides a possible mechanism for the establishment of permanent polarization in spherical geometry. 2 1 0 2 r p A 2 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 2 0 4 0 . 4 0 2 1 : v i X r a PACS numbers: 87.18.Hf, 82.40.Ck, 87.17.Aa, 83.10.Ff Active media are capable to modify their mechanical prop- erties under the influence of chemical signaling; in their turn, chemical transformations may be affected by local stress, strain and polarization. This creates a feedback loop that, on the one hand, makes rheology of the medium flexible and re- sponsive to the environment and, on the other hand, may cause various instabilities, leading to spatial inhomogeneities, oscil- lations, and spontaneous motion. The primary example of an active biological medium is cytoskeleton, which is the princi- pal structural element of eukaryotic cells responsible for their integrity, reshaping, proliferation, and motion [1, 2]. Experimental studies of living tissues give many examples of instabilities involving chemo-mechanical interactions, such as spontaneous oscillatory contraction of muscle fibers [3], traveling waves [4], and intermittent localized oscillations in vivo [5] that occur, in particular, during such tissue reshap- ing processes as dorsal closure [6, 7] and elongation of the Drosophila egg shell [8]. Inhomogeneities and patterns of non-genetic origin are inconspicuous in vivo but are promi- nent in model systems, seen as clusters, swirls and intercon- nected bands in motility assays [9], localized motor activity spots in reconstituted actin-myosin mixtures [10], and veloc- ity spurts in spreading tissues [11]. Mechanical impact on chemical oscillations (though without feedback reaction) has been also detected in inorganic gels [12]. Mechanisms of chemo-mechanical interactions in living cells and tissues are variegated and largely unknown but un- derlying general characteristics can be understood by taking as a basis well-established principles of continuous mechan- ics that account for the symmetries of the medium, and im- posing a simple chemical feedback. The continuum approxi- mation is particularly suitable for analytical studies of insta- bility thresholds. Symmetry-breaking and oscillatory instabil- ities due to chemo-mechanical coupling have been detected in this way in the context of calcium transfer dynamics [13, 14], and much later with myosin motors acting as chemical vari- ables [15]. Further studies included nematic polarization in the continuum theory [16, 17] based on de Gennes' descrip- tion of nematic liquid crystals [18] and adding a term propor- tional to chemical potential to account for the biological activ- ity. The resulting equations of polar gels are quite formidable but their simplified versions have enabled elegant description of structures and defects in nematic gels [17], spontaneous flow [19, 20], and other phenomena in polar active media. In this Letter, we explore an alternative case of a medium with vector polarization. The source of polarization of cy- toskeleton is directionality of actin filaments characterized by a unique direction of treadmilling and motion of myosin mo- tors. In acto-myosin stress fibers, nematic order prevails due to periodic polarity alternation as, for example, in sarcomeric structures. On the other hand, stress fibers in motile cells have a graded polarity pattern [21] implying vector polarization. This kind of polarization is essential for generation of active forces that play a primary role in tissue spreading [22 -- 24]. Another distinctive feature of our approach is allowing for spontaneous emergence of polarization, alongside with me- chanical deformation and chemical activity, whereas in earlier studies of polar active media, with few exceptions [25], only the direction, rather than the absolute value of the nematic order parameter was evolving dynamically. After formulat- ing dynamic equations applicable to a thin flat polarizable de- formable layer on a solid substrate, we will determine analyt- ically the various instabilities thresholds, and further explore numerically the evolution of emerging patterns using the neo- Hookean formulation applicable to strongly deformable soft matter [26]. Dynamics of thin layers dominated by friction is Aris- totelian (overdamped), with velocity rather than acceleration proportional to the force. Close to equilibrium, the force driv- ing the evolution of any dynamic variable Ψ can be derived from an appropriate energy functional F{Ψ}, leading to a dy- namic equation in the variational form Γ DtΨ = −δF/δΨ, where Dt = ∂t+v·∇ is the substantial derivative, v is the local velocity, and Γ is an appropriate friction coefficient. We will write in this form basic dynamic equations for the deforma- tion and polarization fields, and further add non-equilibrium terms accounting for the active character of the medium. The medium is assumed to be incompressible but it can stretch in the horizontal plane x, while modifying the layer thickness h. Since the vertical deformation is small compared to the deformations in the horizontal plane and the latter, in turn, are uniform in the vertical direction, the elastic energy is expressed through the two-dimensional (2D) strain tensor. Let x, X(x) be the dimensionless position vectors, respectively, (cid:18) ωjk (cid:19) in the reference (stress-free) and deformed states. The com- ponents of the strain tensor are ωij = ∂iXk∂jXk − δij, where δij is the Kronecker delta; summation over repeated indices is presumed here and below. The elastic energy is (cid:90) Fel = Leld2x, Lel = µhL0, L0 = 1 4 ωijωij. (1) where µ is the shear modulus. Unlike the standard 2D formulation, the variation of h should be taken into account when the dynamic equations are derived. In view of the incompressibility, h = h0J−1, where h0 is the unperturbed thickness and J is the determinant of the 2D matrix with the components ∂jXi. We write the dynamic equations in the dimensionless form η DtXi = 1 2 ∂j ∂kXi − L0 J 2 ikjl∂lXk J + fi 2J , (2) where F = (µ/ax) f is an active force per unit volume (to be x/(2µh0at), ax, at are the length specified below), η = Γela2 and time scales, and ik is the 2D antisymmetric matrix. integral over the deformed domain: Fp = (cid:82) 2 p2(cid:17) Planar polarization is characterized by the 2D vector order parameter p(X, t). The polarization energy is expressed as an Lpd2X, where the Lagrangian Lp should be expressed through rotationally invariant combinations of p and the 2D gradient operator ∇ with respect to the coordinates Xi. Retaining terms with the added orders in p and ∇ not exceeding four, we write + 2κ1∇ipi + (∇ipi)2 + κ2(ik∇ipk)2 + κ3p2∇ipi (cid:104) α2p2(cid:16) Lp = κh 2a2 x (cid:3) . 1 + (3) κ0 −1/2 0 The second term is irrelevant, unless the coefficient κ1 cou- ples the order parameter with another field. In an active medium, this might be the concentration c of some chemi- −1/2 cal species. We choose κ as the polarization scale and set 0 c, where c(X, t) is interpreted as a scaled devi- κ1 = −κ ation from a reference concentration c0. Setting also κ3 = 0, we write the dynamic equation generated by the Lagrangian (3) in the dimensionless form −1 (∇jpi − ∇ipj)(cid:3) (cid:2)J −1(cid:0)1 + p2(cid:1) pi, −1∇jpj) + κ2∇j γ Dtpi = ∇i(J −1c) − α2J − ∇i(J where γ = Γpa2 x/(κh0at). Generally, one has to include the variation of the polarization energy into the deformation equations; indeed, a polarized medium may deform to releave polarization gradients. We will avoid, however, this compli- cation, assuming κ (cid:28) µ. The coupling between polarization and deformation will be established instead by the active force in Eq. (2) directed along the polarization direction, fi = 2qpi. The feedback loop is closed by making concentration of the active species strain-dependent. We write the equation of the concentration field taking into account that, due to incom- pressibility, the concentration is not affected by deformation; (4) 2 FIG. 1: Stability diagram in the parametric plane α, βq. The oscil- latory instability limits are shown for γ = 5/4 and η = 1/3 (solid line), η = 5/3 (dashes), and η = 10/3 (dots). Inset: the critical wavelength k at the oscillatory bifurcation lines parameterized by α. the diffusional flux is, however, proportional to the local thick- ness. Allowing for the production rate proportional to the lo- cal strain and linear decay with the constant identified with the inverse time scale 1/at, we write the concentration equation in the dimensionless form Dtc = J∇i(J −1∇ic) − c + β(J − 1). (5) where we have chosen as the length scale the diffusion length ax = √Dat, D being the diffusivity. The above equation system becomes extremely convoluted if applied in a fixed coordinate frame where, besides com- puting the substantial derivative that includes the velocity v = ∂tX, one would need to transform the ∇ operator in Eqs. (4), (5) to account for deformations. These complications do not affect, however, linear stability analysis, and will be avoided at large deformations by implementing a Lagrangean numerical procedure. We explore now stability of the homogeneous solution p = 0, c = 0, X = x to infinitesimal perturbations. The linearized system determining the bifurcation threshold can be expressed through the 2D strain ψ = J − 1 = ∇i(Xi − xi) and splay φ = ∇ipi by taking the divergence of linearized Eqs. (2), (4): (6) (7) (8) η ∂tψ = ∇2ψ + qφ, γ ∂tφ = ∇2φ − α2φ − ∇2c, ∂tc = ∇2c − c + βψ. A nontrivial solution of Eqs. (6) -- (8) is sought for as a wave- form exp(λt + i k · x) with a wave vector k. The eigenvalues λ determining stability of the uniform state c = ψ = φ = 0 are computed by setting to zero the determinant of the Fourier transformed linearized system. The bifurcation thresholds are computed in a standard way by requiring supk((cid:60)λ) = 0. In the case of extentional activation (β > 0), one can show that the branch of real eigenvalues first reaches zero in the oscillatoryinstabilitystationaryinstabilitystable-200-150-100-500500123456βqα00.40.81.201234kα3 FIG. 2: Snapshots from a simulation in the oscillatory unstable para- metric region (βq = −210, (βq)c ≈ −196). The time difference √ √ between the two images equals half the oscillation period. The sim- 5 square. Lighter ulation domain is a double-periodic 10 shades correspond to higher concentration levels; scaled arrows indi- cate the polarization p. 5 × 10 FIG. 3: Histogram of the angle ϕ between the directions of the elastic and active force. long-wave mode k = 0 at βq = α2. In the case of com- pressive activation (β < 0), a wave instability at finite k and (cid:61)λ (cid:54)= 0 is observed. The analytic formulas for the critical wavenumber kc and the critical value βc are too cumbersome to be of practical use and will not be listed here. The min- imal gap width between the two instability limits equals to γ + η. The bifurcation diagram in the parametric plane α, βq is shown in Fig. 1. We explore dynamics beyond the bifurcation thresholds for both types of activation by direct numerical simulation, start- ing from randomly perturbed homogeneous initial conditions. We discretize Eqs. (2), (4), and (5) using a flexible grid with nodes following the physical displacement of the medium. In the spirit of mesh-free computations [27], the spatial deriva- tives are calculated based on local approximation of the fields by low-order polynomials. The resulting set of ordinary dif- ferential equations is then solved using an embedded adaptive Runge-Kutta-Fehlberg scheme of the order 4 and 5 [28]. The parameters are set to q = √5/100, α = √5, κ2 = 1, η = 5/3, γ = 5/4. In the oscillatory regime, we observe a wave pattern with the active force (directed from high to low c regions) follow- ing the rotating concentration gradient between the domains oscillating in antiphase, as seen in Fig. 2. The directions of the elastic and active force are, however, disaligned due to de- lay, so that the angle between the two is widely distributed with a shallow maximum about π/2 (Fig. 3). In the case of extensional activation, the behavior is qual- itatively different. Initially, a short-wave pattern correspond- ing to a fastest-growing mode emerges from the initial noise. Then, a slow coarsening process ensues, during which larger domains grow while smaller ones either merge or vanish, so that the dominant wavelength grows, as seen in Fig. 4. The wavelength corresponding to the maximum of the Fourier spectrum is plotted against time in Fig. 5. Due to the finite size of the simulation domain, the plot for each individual run has a number of discontinuous steps but it approaches a mono- tonically growing curve when averaged over 30 runs. FIG. 4: Domain coarsening: snapshots at t = 4 × 103 (a), 2 × 104 (b), 3 × 104 (c), 5 × 104 (d), simulation on the double-periodic √ √ 5 × 100 100 5 square domain for βq = 6, (βq)c = 5. FIG. 5: Time evolution of the wavelength of the dominant Fourier √ √ mode during coarsening (the average of 30 simulations on the 5 × 100 double-periodic 100 5 square domain for βq = 6). 00.511.522.53ϕ5010015020025001000020000300004000050000λtbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb4 [1] J. Howard, Mechanics of Motor Proteins and the Cytoskeleton (Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Mass., 2001). [2] O. Lieleg, M. M. A. E. Claessens, and A. R. Bausch, Soft Mat- ter 6, 218 (2010). [3] H. Fujita and S. Ishiwata, Biophys. J. 75, 1439 (1998). [4] G. Gerisch, T. Bretschneider, and A. Muller-Taubenberger, Bio- phys. J. 87, 3493 (2004). [5] A. C. Martin, Developmental Biol. 341, 114 (2010). [6] J. Solon, A. Kaya-C¸ opur, J. Colombelli, and D. Brunner, Cell [7] N. Gorfinkiel, S. Schamberg, and G. B. Blanchard, Genesis 49, [8] L. He, X. Wang, H. L. Tang, and D. J. Montell, Nature Cell 137, 1331 (2009). 522 (2011). Biol. 12, 1133 (2010). Nature 467, 73 (2010). [9] V. Schaller, C. Weber, C. Semmrich, E. Frey, and A. R. Bausch, [10] M. S. e. Silva, M. Depken, B. Stuhrmann, M. Korsten, F. C. MacKintosh, and G. H. Koenderink, Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 108, 9408 (2011). [11] L. Petitjean, M. Reffay, E. Grasland-Mongrain, M. Poujade, B. Ladoux, A. Buguin, and P. Silberzan, Biophys J 98, 1790 (2010). [12] O. Kuksenok, V. V. Yashin, and A. C. Balazs, Soft Matter 3, 1138 (2007). Biol. 1, 51 (1984). [13] J. D. Murray and G. F. Oster, IMA J. Math. Appl. Math. Med. [14] G. Oster and G. Odell, Physica D 12, 333 (1984). [15] S. Banerjee and M. C. Marchetti, Soft Matter 7, 463 (2011). [16] K. Kruse, J. F. Joanny, F. Julicher, J. Prost, and K. Sekimoto, Eur. Phys. J. E 16, 5 (2005). [17] F. Julicher, K. Kruse, J. Prost, and J.-F. Joanny, Phys. Rep. 449, [18] P. de Gennes and J. Prost, The Physics of Liquid Crystals (Ox- ford University Press, Oxford, U.K., 1993). [19] K. Doubrovinski and K. Kruse, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 258103 3 (2007). (2011). [20] S. Furthauer, M. Neef, S. W. Grill, K. Kruse, and F. Julicher, New J. Phys. 14, 023001 (2012). [21] S. Deguchi and M. Sato, Biorheology 46, 93 (2009). [22] D. L. Nikolic, A. N. Boettiger, D. Bar-Sagi, J. D. Carbeck, and S. Y. Shvartsman, 291, C68 (2006). [23] M. Poujade, E. Grasland-Mongrain, A. Hertzog, J. Jouanneau, P. Chavrier, B. Ladoux, A. Buguin, and P. Silberzan, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 104, 15988 (2007). [24] M. Salm and L. M. Pismen, Phys. Biol. 9 (2012). [25] G. Salbreux, J. Prost, and J. F. Joanny, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 058102 (2009). [26] R. W. Ogden, in Nonlinear Elasticity: Theory and Applications, edited by Y. B. Fu and R. W. Ogden (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K., 2001), pp. 1 -- 58. [27] E. Onate, S. Idelsohn, O. C. Zienkiewicz, and R. L. Taylor, Int. J. Numer. Meth. Engng. 39, 3839 (1996). [28] W. H. Press, Numerical Recipes in C (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K., 1999). [29] C. R. Cowan and A. A. Hyman, Development 134 (2007). [30] N. W. Goehring, P. K. Trong, J. S. Bois, D. Chowdhury, E. M. Nicola, A. A. Hyman, and S. W. Grill, Science 334, 1137 (2011). FIG. 6: Cross section through the dashed line in Fig. 4 (d). The polarization component along the line p · ey and deformation J − 1 are scaled to show all three fields in the same plot. √ FIG. 7: Time evolution of the concentration c at different polar angles θ on a sphere of radius 10 5. Unlike the oscillatory case, the active and elastic forces are almost perfectly anti-aligned: the mutual angle deviates from π by less than 3.5◦ with 98% probability. As the active force is directed against the concentration gradient, the low-c re- gions are squeezed into narrow stripes separating high-c do- mains. In turn, the chemical production is inhibited within these stripes due to strong compression, as the deformation acts as the source of c in Eq. (5). The resulting correlation between J and c is seen in Fig. 6 that shows the cross-section profiles at a late stage of coarsening. The coarsening process provides a natural mechanism for polarity establishment in cortical tissues, as is observed, for example, in the C. elegans embryo [29]. When Eqs. (2), (4), and (5) are solved on a spherical surface, the coarsen- ing consolidates two domains, whereafter the smaller one is compressed into a low-c spot. This is illustrated in Fig. 7, where the evolution of c is plotted for five different polar an- gles θ, where θ = 0 is defined by the location of the high- concentration pole. As the polarization is aligned with the concentration gradient, the active force is directed from one pole to the other. The established polarity axis is permanent, unlike Ref. [30] where advection serves as a mere trigger re- quiring additional means for preserving the polarization. This work has been supported by the Human Frontier Sci- ence Program (Grant RGP0052/2009-C). -60-40-2002040050100150200yc50(ey·p)100(J−1)-200-10001002003004005006007008000200040006000800010000ctθ=0θ=π/4θ=π/2θ=3π/4θ=π
1212.1673	2	1212	2013-11-14T11:43:39	Parasites on parasites: coupled fluctuations in stacked contact processes	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.stat-mech", "q-bio.PE" ]	We present a model for host-parasite dynamics which incorporates both vertical and horizontal transmission as well as spatial structure. Our model consists of stacked contact processes (CP), where the dynamics of the host is a simple CP on a lattice while the dynamics of the parasite is a secondary CP which sits on top of the host-occupied sites. In the simplest case, where infection does not incur any cost, we uncover a novel effect: a nonmonotonic dependence of parasite prevalence on host turnover. Inspired by natural examples of hyperparasitism, we extend our model to multiple levels of parasites and identify a transition between the maintenance of a finite and infinite number of levels, which we conjecture is connected to a roughening transition in models of surface-growth.	physics.bio-ph	physics	epl draft 3 1 0 2 v o N 4 1 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 2 v 3 7 6 1 . 2 1 2 1 : v i X r a Parasites on parasites: coupled fluctuations in stacked contact processes Steven J. Court, Richard A. Blythe and Rosalind J. Allen SUPA, School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Mayfield Road, Edinburgh EH9 3JZ, UK PACS 02.50.Ey -- Stochastic processes PACS 05.70.Fh -- Phase transitions: general studies PACS 87.23.Cc -- Population dynamics and ecological pattern formation Abstract -- We present a model for host-parasite dynamics which incorporates both vertical and horizontal transmission as well as spatial structure. Our model consists of stacked contact processes (CP), where the dynamics of the host is a simple CP on a lattice while the dynamics of the parasite is a secondary CP which sits on top of the host-occupied sites. In the simplest case, where infection does not incur any cost, we uncover a novel effect: a nonmonotonic dependence of parasite prevalence on host turnover. Inspired by natural examples of hyperparasitism, we extend our model to multiple levels of parasites and identify a transition between the maintenance of a finite and infinite number of levels, which we conjecture is connected to a roughening transition in models of surface-growth. Introduction. -- The need to understand and control the dynamics of infections has motivated the development of a variety of statistical mechanical models. One of the most important of these is the contact process (CP) [1 -- 4], which describes the dynamics of an infection in a spatially structured population. In the contact process, each site on a lattice represents a host organism which can be in- fected or susceptible (uninfected). Infection is transmitted to neighbouring susceptible host sites at rate b, and in- fected hosts recover (i.e. become susceptible) at rate d. The contact process provides a baseline model for many problems in ecology and epidemiology. It is also of funda- mental importance in statistical physics. This is because it exhibits a non-equilibrium phase transition between an infected and a non-infected phase at a critical value of λ = b/d [2, 3]. The standard CP model for an infected population as- sumes that the host population is of fixed size, without turnover, i.e. host births and deaths. This is valid if the timescale on which the infection is gained and lost is much shorter than the lifespan of an individual. Some infections, however, are carried by individuals for long times, and may be transmitted to offspring upon reproduction (vertical transmission), as well as being transmitted horizontally -- i.e. upon physical contact between individuals. Examples include plasmids carried by bacteria [5], some microsporid- ian parasites of insects [6] and pathogens including HIV and several hepatitis viruses. Here, we investigate the interplay between vertical and horizontal transmission in such populations. Other authors have determined the con- ditions for parasite persistence in mean-field models that lack spatial structure, in which the parasite may affect host fitness [7 -- 9], and have suggested that these condi- tions may be affected by spatial structure [10]. Here, we show that spatial structure can produce a qualitatively new effect: a coupling between the dynamics of the infec- tion and of the underlying host population, even when the infection does not affect the fitness of the host. We present a two level stacked contact process, in which the host population is represented by a CP on a lattice, and the parasite population is represented by a second CP which sits on top of the host CP. This model in- corporates both vertical and horizontal transmission -- if an infected host reproduces or dies, the parasite is re- produced or dies with it (vertical transmission), and a parasite-infected site can infect a neighbouring site if it is occupied by an uninfected host (horizontal transmission). We characterize the conditions for parasite persistence in the form of a phase diagram and discover an interesting phenomenon: although the steady-state properties of the host population depend only on the ratio of its birth and death rates, λ = b/d, the prevalence of the parasite can de- pend non-monotonically on the host population's turnover rate. This phenomenon has its origins in the fluctuations p-1 S. J. Court et al. of spatial clusters of host individuals, and cannot straight- forwardly be captured by a mean-field theory. Parasitic infections are not always limited to two levels. Hyperparasitism, in which an organism carrying a primary parasite is susceptible to a secondary parasite [11], can be harnessed as a biocontrol mechanism -- examples include viral infections of the fungus Cryphonectria parasitica that causes chestnut blight [12], and cytoplasmic RNA elements that infect the fungus causing Dutch elm disease [13]. In- spired by these scenarios, we extend our model to a multi- level stacked contact process, in which individuals carrying a primary infection may be susceptible to secondary infec- tions, and those carrying the secondary infection may be susceptible to tertiary infections, etc. This raises a number of questions: How does the dynamics of one parasite level couple to the next, and how many levels of parasites are sustainable in a population? We show that in our stacked contact process, there is a well-defined transition between maintenance of an infinite hierarchy of levels of parasites, and limitation to a finite number of levels. The transition between these two regimes appears to be connected to a roughening transition in certain surface growth processes [14 -- 16]. This work presents new challenges to our under- standing of contact processes, with potential implications for the dynamics of long-timescale infections. Two-level stacked contact process. -- We begin by considering the dynamics of a host and a single para- site which can be transmitted vertically or horizontally -- a two-level stacked CP -- on a 2D square lattice. Lattice sites can be either empty or occupied by a host organism. Occupied lattice sites become empty at rate d0, due to death of hosts, and host organisms attempt to replicate into neighbouring empty sites at rate b0 (the attempt rate in any direction is b0/z, z being the coordination number of the lattice). Host organisms may also carry a parasite, which we assume to be neutral in the sense that organ- isms with and without the parasite have identical birth and death rates. Infected individuals pass the parasite to uninfected neighbours at rate b1, and the parasite is lost at a constant rate d1. We assume that the offspring of an infected organism is also infected (vertical transmission), and that when an infected host dies, the parasite dies with it. Thus the infection dynamics consists of a secondary CP, with parameters b1 and d1, which sits on top of the host's birth-death CP. Since the host population does not occupy the whole lattice, the secondary CP does not take place on a regular lattice but rather on the irregular net- work of occupied sites which changes stochastically due to the dynamics of the host population. The processes that occur in our model are illustrated in Figure 1. We sim- ulate this model using a stochastic kinetic Monte Carlo algorithm, in which all events occur as Poisson processes [17], on a 100 × 100 lattice with periodic boundary condi- tions. Averages are calculated after an initial transient to allow the steady state to be reached. b0 z b0 z b1 z d0 d0 d1 Figure 1: The events that constitute the 2-level stacked CP. Red and black circles represent host organisms and parasites respectively. A site can be empty, occupied by a susceptible host or occupied by an infected host. The left panels represent reproduction of a susceptible or in- fected host (top and middle, rate b0), and transmission of the parasite (bottom, rate b1). The right panels represent death of a susceptible or infected host (top and middle, rate d0), and loss of the parasite (bottom, rate d1). z is the number of nearest neighbour sites. The dotted squares indicate the level of the CP at which the event happens. Host dynamics influences parasite persistence. -- In this model, the host population undergoes a simple CP, whose stationary properties are fully determined by the single parameter λ0 = b0/d0 [1 -- 4]. If λ0 is less than a crit- ical value, λcrit, the only steady state is an empty lattice and the population rapidly becomes extinct. If λ0 > λcrit, a non-zero population can be maintained for long times, before eventually becoming extinct due to a rare fluctua- tion. The transition between these two regimes is second order; the values of λcrit and the associated critical ex- ponents have been characterised in detail [3]. Defining τi = 0 or 1 if site i is empty or occupied respectively, the dynamics of the host population obeys d dt hτii = 1 z X j b0 hτj (1 − τi)i − d0 hτii , (1) where the sum is over the z neighbours of lattice site i and the angle brackets denote averages over multiple realizations of the dynamics. The steady-state solution of Eq. (1) satisfies hτii = (λ0/(λ0 − 1)) hτiτji. Ignor- ing correlations between neighbouring sites by assuming that hτiτji ≈ hτii hτji, we arrive at the mean-field result hτ i = 1 − (1/λ0). Considering now the dynamics of the parasite, we de- fine σi = 1 if site i contains an infected host and σi = 0 otherwise (i.e. if site i is either unoccupied or contains a susceptible host). σi obeys d dt hσii = [b0 hσj (1 − τi)i + b1 hσj (τi − σi)i] 1 z X − d0 hσii − d1 hσii . j (2) The first term on the r.h.s. of Eq. (2) corresponds to ver- tical transmission: an empty site is filled by replication of p-2 1 d / 1 b = 1 λ t c n i t x e t s o H 12 8 4 0 Parasite persists 2 Parasite lost 6 10 λ 0 = b0 / d0 14 Figure 2: Phase diagram of the two-level stacked CP. Sym- bols: simulation data showing boundary of parasite persis- tence, for d1 = 1 and d0 = 1 (circles) or d0 = 20 (squares). Dashed line: mean-field prediction λ1 = λ0/(λ0 − 1). an infected host. The second term represents horizontal transmission: a susceptible host, denoted by (τi − σi), is infected by a parasite-carrying neighbour. The final two terms correspond to death of an infected host and loss of the parasite. Eq. (2) can be rewritten as d dt hσii = [b0 hσji + (b1 − b0) hτiσji − b1 hσiσji] 1 z X − (d1 + d0) hσii . j (3) Comparing this with Eq. (1), we see that the cross- correlation hτiσj i perturbs the parasite dynamics from that of a standard CP. Interestingly, however, if b1 = b0 (i.e. if the rates of horizontal and vertical transmission are equal), this term vanishes and the form of Eq. (3) becomes that of a standard CP with parameter λeff = λ0λ1/(λ0 + λ1) = b/ Pk dk. The parasite dynamics also has CP-like behaviour in the mean-field limit, where we neglect spatial correlations: setting hτiσj i ≈ hτii hσj i and hσiσji ≈ hσii hσj i in Eq. (3), we obtain the steady-state solution hσi = 1 − (1/λ0) − (1/λ1) ≡ 1 − (1/λeff ). Figure 2 shows the phase diagram for our model, as a function of λ0 and λ1. Three steady state scenarios are possible: (i) the host population is extinct, (ii) the host population is finite but the parasite is extinct, and (iii) the parasite persists within a finite host population. Since the dynamics of the host population is a standard CP, the host population is extinct (scenario (i)) if λ0 < λcrit. For λ0 > λcrit, the host population persists, with or without the parasite. The condition for parasite persistence (i.e. the boundary separating scenarios (ii) and (iii)) is predicted by the mean field theory to be λ1 = λ0/(λ0 − 1) (obtained by setting hσi = 0) -- shown by the dashed line in Figure 2. As one might expect, as λ0 decreases, the density of the host population decreases, and a higher rate of horizontal transmission (λ1) is needed to maintain the parasite. The symbols in Figure 2 show the boundaries between parasite persistence and loss obtained from our kinetic Parasites on parasites Monte Carlo simulations, for two values of d0, the host death rate. The fact that these are shifted upwards and to the right of the mean-field prediction shows that spatial correlations make it harder to maintain the parasite. It is also interesting that we obtain different results for the two different values of d0. This shows that the parameters λ0 and λ1 do not fully determine the phase behaviour of the system. For fixed λ0 = b0/d0, a higher turnover rate of the host population (i.e. higher d0 and b0) apparently makes it harder to maintain the parasite. In fact the situation is more complex. Figure 3a shows a more comprehensive investigation of the steady-state par- asite density hσi as a function of the host turnover rate. In these simulations, we vary b0 and d0 keeping λ0 = b0/d0 fixed. The steady-state density of the host population is constant, since it depends only on λ0. Remarkably, for some parameter combinations, the density of the parasite actually depends non-monotonically on the host turnover rate. If the host dynamics is slow, increasing the turnover rate increases the parasite density, while if the host dy- namics is fast, the parasite density decreases with the turnover rate. This dependence of the parasite density on the host turnover rate is absent in the mean-field theory and must therefore be a consequence of spatial correlations. To investigate this, we measure in our simulations the spa- tial correlations of the parasite density via the function Ci,j = [hσiσji/hσi] − hσi. Here, the first term is the con- ditional probability of finding a parasite at site j given that there is one at site i, while the second term ensures that Ci,j → 0 as i − j → ∞ (where i − j denotes the distance between sites i and j). We then fit our data to the functional form Ci,j ∼ e−i−j/ξ to extract the spa- tial correlation length ξ, which can be thought of as the parasite cluster size. This is shown in Figure 3b. Strik- ingly, the correlation length is minimal at the turnover rate where the parasite density is maximal. This makes intu- itive sense: since horizontal transmission requires contact 0.4 <σ> 0.1 0 0.12 <σ> 0.08 2 ξ 1.8 1 1.5 0 0.5 d0 (a) 2 3 1 d0 (b) Figure 3: (a) Parasite density hσi as a function of host turnover rate d0 for fixed λ0 (and hence fixed host den- sity). Curves top to bottom correspond to (λ0, b1, d1) = (5, 4, 1),(2.5, 15, 1),(2, 8, 1) and (1.8, 15, 1). (b) Parasite density hσi (triangles, left axis) and spatial correlation length ξ (squares, right axis) for (λ0, b1, d1) = (1.8, 15, 1). p-3 S. J. Court et al. between infected and uninfected hosts, minimal spatial clustering of the parasite population results in maximal parasite density. Why should the turnover rate of the host affect the spa- tial clustering of the parasite? At fast host turnover rates, we observe in our simulations that local patches of host organisms rapidly grow from a single seed and vanish by stochastic extinction, on a faster timescale than that of horizontal transmission. Because offspring are always of the same type as their parents, organisms in a single patch are either all infected or all uninfected. Thus the infected population is highly clustered, leading to low rates of hori- zontal transmission and low parasite density. By contrast, when the host population turnover is slow, the parasite dynamics constitutes a CP on the effectively frozen, dis- ordered network of lattice sites that are occupied by host organisms. This network contains clusters of sites that may be disconnected, or poorly connected, from the rest of the host population; this creates the possibility of local, stochastic parasite extinctions. This is most obviously the case in the low λ0 regime where the host density is low, but it is still true for higher host densities. In this regime, an increase in the host turnover rate serves as a mixing mechanism, by more homogeneously distributing the host population and thereby providing greater opportunity for the parasite to spread. Thus the nonmonotonic dependence of the parasite den- sity on the host turnover rate arises from a coupling of the spatial fluctuations of the underlying host CP to the par- asite dynamics, and can be viewed as a competition be- tween the mixing effect of the host birth-death process at low turnover rates and the population segregation arising from parent-offspring clustering at high turnover rates. Multi-level stacked contact processes. -- Moti- vated by natural examples of hyperparasitism, we now in- vestigate a multi-level stacked CP, where individuals car- rying a primary infection are susceptible to a secondary infection, and those with the secondary infection are sus- ceptible to tertiary infections, and so on. In the M -level stacked CP, a site is labelled 0 if it is empty, 1 if it contains an uninfected host, and m = 2, 3, . . . , M if it contains a host infected with m − 1 levels of parasites. For example, a site labelled 2 contains a host infected with only a pri- mary infection (parasite) while a site labelled 3 contains a host which is infected with primary and secondary in- fections (a parasite and a hyperparasite). Note that the presence of an infection at level m implies the presence of lower-level infections (e.g. one cannot have a secondary infection without a primary infection). Figure 4 illustrates the dynamical processes that can occur in this model. An empty site may be occupied at rate b0/z by reproduction of a neighbouring site of any label (top left), or a site labelled m may be infected at rate bm/z by higher-level parasites from a neighbouring site with label n > m; its label is then promoted to n (middle and bottom left). The host organism of a level m site can die, at rate d0 (top right), b0 z b1 z 2b z d0 d1 d2 Figure 4: Possible transitions for the multi-level CP, con- sidering a site with label m = 3. The symbols are as in Fig. 1; the green circles represent the secondary para- site. Birth processes are shown on the left. The organism in question can reproduce into a neighbouring empty site (top left), transmit its primary parasite to a susceptible neighbour (middle left - note the secondary parasite is also transmitted), or transmit its secondary parasite to a susceptible neighbour (bottom left). Death processes are shown on the right. These consist of death of the host (top right), loss of the primary parasite (middle right) or loss of the secondary parasite (bottom right). or experience loss of one of its parasites, at rate dn (where n ≤ m relates to the level of parasite that is lost). When the latter happens, all higher parasites are also lost and the site is demoted to level n (middle and bottom right panels in Fig. 4). The parameters of the model are the number of levels M , and the set of level-dependent birth and death rates {b0, . . . , bM−1; d0, . . . , dM−1}. We first consider the special case where the birth rates at all levels are equal; bn = b ∀ n. We divide lattice sites into two sets: sites that have labels greater than or equal to m (here denoted M+), and sites that have labels less than m (here denoted M−). An M− site can become M+ by infection by a neighbouring M+ site: this occurs at rate b/z regardless of the level of the M+ site. An M+ site can become M− by death of the host or by loss of a parasite at levels n = 2 . . . m. This occurs at total rate d = Pm−1 ℓ=0 dℓ where the sum is over levels up to m − 1. Thus the dynamics of the M+ density is exactly equivalent to that of a standard CP with parameter λeff = b/ Pm−1 ℓ=0 dℓ. This observation provides us with important insight into the number of levels that are sustainable in a stacked CP. For the standard (one-level) CP, a finite density of oc- cupied lattice sites can only be sustained for λ > λcrit, where λcrit ≈ 1.649 for a 2D square lattice [3]. In the stacked CP with equal birth rates we therefore expect the density of M+ sites, those with label n ≥ m, to be non-zero only if λeff = b0/ Pm−1 ℓ=0 dℓ < λcrit. Figure 5 shows simulation results for the average density of lat- tice sites with label n ≥ m, as a function of m, for a stacked CP with equal birth rates bn = b and death rates dn = d = 1, for several values of b. By mapping onto a standard CP with λeff = b/(md), we predict that all lev- els n ≥ m∗ = ⌈b/(λcritd)⌉ have zero density and are thus p-4 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 y t i s n e D Parasites on parasites 0.6 0.4 y t i s n e D 0.2 f = 1 f = 0.5 f = 0.6 f = 0 . 7 5 l e v e l e t i n i f n i f o y t i s n e D 0.6 0.2 0 0 2 6 4 Level m 8 10 2 4 6 Level m 8 (a) 0.2 0.6 d0 (b) 1 Figure 5: Density of sites with label m or higher, as a function of level m, for a stacked CP with equal birth rates bn = b and death rates dn = 1. Left to right correspond to simulations with b = 2,4,6,10 and 15 respectively. Arrows indicate m∗ = ⌈b/(λcritd)⌉, the boundary for sustainability as predicted by mapping to the standard CP. unsustainable. Our simulation results, shown in Figure 5, bear this out: the system indeed only sustains a finite number m∗ of parasite levels. Are there any circumstances where a stacked CP can be sustained for an infinite number of levels? This is indeed possible if either the birth rate bn increases, or the death rate dn decreases, sufficiently strongly with n. We first suppose that the birth rate bn = b is constant but the death rate decreases by a factor f at successive levels: dn = f dn−1 = f nd0 where 0 < f < 1. In this case, the average density of sites with label n ≥ m is given by that of a standard CP with λeff = b/ Pm−1 ℓ=0 dℓ = b(1 − f )/ [d0(1 − f m)]. To sustain an infinite number of levels, we require that λm→∞ = b(1−f )/d0 ≥ λcrit, which implies that f ≤ 1 − (d0λcrit/b). Our simulation results, Fig. 6a, show that, with d0 = 1 and b = 5, the system indeed sustains an infinite number of levels for values of f above the critical value of f ≈ 0.67. eff Interestingly, this analysis also shows that, for given values of b and f , there exists a critical value of the host death rate d0 which separates regimes where the stacked CP can and cannot sustain an infinite number of levels. This is given by d∗ 0 = b(1 − f )/λcrit. Figure 6b shows, as a function of d0, the predicted density of sites with label n ≥ m, as m → ∞: this is given by the density of a standard CP with λeff = b(1 − f )/d0. The density as m → ∞ indeed falls to zero at d0 = d∗ 0. Finally, we explore briefly the case where, instead of varying the death rate between levels, we instead increase the birth rate by a factor 1/f (i.e. set bn = bn−1/f ). In this case the dynamics no longer maps onto that of a standard CP -- but nevertheless, our simulations show qualitatively similar results (dashed lines in Figure 6a). The transition to an infinite number of levels of para- sites that we observe in this model appears to be related to a transition that occurs in models for the growth of in- terfaces by deposition of particles on surfaces [14 -- 16]. In these models, the interface is modelled as a lattice, with Figure 6: (a) Density of sites with n ≥ m, as a function of level m, in the stacked CP for decreasing death rates dn = f nd0, with d0 = 1, bn = 5 (solid lines) and for increasing birth rates bn = f −nb0, with b0 = 5, dn = 1 (dashed lines). In the former case, the exact CP predicts a nonzero density as m → ∞ only for f ' 0.67. (b) Density of the mth level in the limit m → ∞ with bn = 5, dn = f nd0, f = 0.75 as a function of host death rate d0 from simulations (circles) and as predicted by a standard CP (triangles) with λm→∞ = b(1 − f )/d0. The simulation data is obtained by measuring the plateau values in plots like panel (a), for m values up to 20. The mapping to a standard CP predicts that only a finite number of levels are sustainable for d0 > d∗ 0 ≈ 0.758. eff a given height at each lattice site. According to the bal- listic deposition rule for surface growth [18], particles fall onto the lattice from above and only stick if the neigh- bouring lattice site already contains a particle. In some models, particles can also desorb from the surface [16]. In the stacked CP model, we can think of the label m of a given lattice site as corresponding to the local height of the interface. The transmission of higher-level parasites to a site with label m, from a neighbour with n > m then corresponds to ballistic deposition, while death of a host and loss of parasites loosely correspond to desorption of particles. This apparent mapping is intriguing because these models for surface growth show a roughening tran- sition [14 -- 16]: when the deposition rate is low, the in- terface remains smooth, that is, the width of the surface layer remains finite in the thermodynamic limit, whereas when the deposition rate is high, the surface layer grows and roughens over time, that is, arbitrarily large differ- ences in surface height can arise in the thermodynamic limit. These two cases correspond to finite and infinite hi- erarchies of parasites in our stacked CP model. Although the mapping to the surface growth models is not exact, one expects to see the same phenomenology, e.g. in terms of critical exponents, for the transitions. For example a generic model for coupled directed percolation processes with unidirectional coupling between adjacent levels [25] can show a different β exponent at different levels when the critical points coincide. It would be interesting to see if this is true for models such as the one described here which show bidirectional coupling between all levels. p-5 S. J. Court et al. Discussion. -- In this paper, we have presented a sim- ple model for the dynamics of long-lived infections in spa- tially structured populations. The model is a stacked con- tact process (CP), in which the host population undergoes a standard CP, and a secondary CP representing the par- asite takes place on the dynamically changing network of lattice sites occupied by the host. We find that the cou- pling between the dynamics of the host population and of the infection leads to non-trivial effects, including a non- monotonic dependence of the parasite prevalence on the host population's turnover rate, for fixed host population size. This exposes a connection between spatial and tem- poral scales, since host population turnover affects spatial clustering of infected organisms which in turn affects the prevalence of the infection within the population. We have found that an improved mean-field theory that takes local correlations into account (the ordinary pair approximation [19]) fails to reproduce this nonmonotonic behaviour. This suggests that a deep understanding of the fluctuations in the host CP is required to predict the steady-state prop- erties of the parasite population. It will be interesting in future to investigate how the nature of the CP phase tran- sition for the infection dynamics is affected by the dynam- ics of the underlying host population. Since disorder can alter critical exponents and lead to new dynamics such as Griffiths phases and activated scaling [20, 21], we envisage that the secondary CP may show fundamentally different behaviour to the standard CP. Inspired by natural examples of hyperparasitism, or "parasites on parasites", we have also investigated the properties of a multi-level contact process. For this model, we show that the average density of the m-th (and above) level of the stacked CP maps onto that of a standard, one-level CP, if the birth rates at all levels are equal. We find that a phase transition separates two very different behaviours of the model: maintenance of an infinite hier- archy of levels of parasites, versus collapse to zero density at a finite number of levels. In light of the link to models of surface growth it will be interesting to determine more fully the properties of the parasite maintenance transition that we observe in the multi-layer stacked CP. Finally, we note that the stacked CP model also presents the possibility for a novel study of disorder in contact processes. Classic models for disordered systems usually create disorder by removing a fraction of sites from the dynamics [22] or by allowing different creation or annihi- lation rates for different sites [23]. This disorder is often quenched - i.e. time-invariant. In our model, disorder in the secondary CP (and higher CPs if present) arises nat- urally from the underlying dynamics of the primary CP, and can be controlled by varying the rates. This natu- rally arising disorder is not fixed but varies in time and space (in a fundamentally different process than the mo- bile disorder of Ref. [24]). Future studies of the effects of this natural disorder on the properties of the secondary CP may uncover new principles of CP dynamics on disordered lattices. Acknowledgements. -- We thank Martin Evans for useful discussions. SJC was funded by the Carnegie Trust for the Universities of Scotland, RAB by an RCUK Aca- demic Fellowship and RJA by a Royal Society University Research Fellowship. References [1] Harris T., Ann. Probab. , 2 (1974) 969. [2] Marro J. and Dickman R., Nonequilibrium Phase Tran- sitions in Lattice Models (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) 1999. [3] Henkel M., Hinrichsen H. and Lubeck S., Non- equilibrium phase transitions, Volume 1: Absorbing phase transitions (Springer, Dordrecht) 2008. [4] Liggett T., Interacting Particle Systems (Springer, New York) 1985. [5] Summers D. K., The Biology of Plasmids (Blackwell Sci- ence, UK) 1996. [6] Smith J. and Dunn A., Parasitol. Today , 7 (1991) 14648. [7] Lipsitch M., Nowak M., Ebert D. and May R., Proc. R. Soc. B , 260 (1995) 321. [8] Jones E., White A. and Boots M., Proc. R. Soc. B , 278 (2011) 863. [9] Busenberg S., Cooke K. L. and Pozio M. A., J. Math. Biol. , 17 (1983) 305. [10] Schinazi R., Math. Biosci. , 168 (2000) 1. [11] Sullivan D. and Volkl W., Annu. Rev. Entomol. , 44 (1999) 291. [12] Milgroom M. and Cortesi P., Ann. Rev. Phytopathol. , 42 (2004) 311. [13] Swinton J. and Gilligam C., Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. B , 266 (1999) 437. [14] Alon U., Evans M. R., Hinrichsen H. and Mukamel D., Phys. Rev. Lett. , 76 (1996) 2746. [15] Alon U., Evans M., Hinrichsen H. and Mukamel D., Phys. Rev. E , 57 (1998) 4997. [16] Blythe R. A. and Evans M. R., Phys. Rev. E , 64 (2001) 051101. [17] Bortz A., Kalos M. and Lebowitz J., J. Comput. Phys. , 17 (1975) 10. [18] Meakin P., Ramanlal P., Sander L. M. and Ball R. C., Phys. Rev. A , 34 (1986) 5091. [19] Sato K., Matsuda H. and Sasaki A., J. Math. Biol. , 32 (1994) 251. [20] Griffiths R. B., Phys. Rev. Lett. , 23 (1969) 17. [21] Vojta T. and Dickison M., Phys. Rev. E , 72 (2005) . [22] Moreira A. G. and Dickman R., Phys. Rev. E , 54 (1996) R3090. [23] Noest A. J., Phys. Rev. Lett. , 57 (1986) 90. [24] Dickman R., J. Stat. Mech.: Theor. Exp. , (2009) P08016. [25] Tauber U. C., Howard M. J. and Hinrichsen H., Phys. Rev. Lett. , 80 (1998) 2156. p-6
1603.07182	1	1603	2016-03-19T07:46:58	Dark states in quantum photosynthesis	[ "physics.bio-ph", "quant-ph" ]	We discuss a model of quantum photosynthesis with degeneracy in the light-harvesting system. We consider interaction of excitons in chromophores with light and phonons (vibrations of environment). These interactions have dipole form but are different (are related to non-parallel vectors of "bright" states). We show that this leads to excitation of non-decaying "dark" states. We discuss relation of this model to the known from spectroscopical experiments phenomenon of existence of photonic echo in quantum photosynthesis.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Dark states in quantum photosynthesis S.V.Kozyrev, I.V.Volovich Steklov Mathematical Institute August 9, 2018 Abstract We discuss a model of quantum photosynthesis with degeneracy in the light-harvesting system. We consider interaction of excitons in chromophores with light and phonons (vi- brations of environment). These interactions have dipole form but are different (are related to non -- parallel vectors of "bright" states). We show that this leads to excitation of non- decaying "dark" states. We discuss relation of this model to the known from spectroscopical experiments phenomenon of existence of photonic echo in quantum photosynthesis. 1 Introduction Open quantum systems were investigated in many works, in particular, the stochastic limit method was developed [1]. Degenerate open systems (when the behavior of quantum systems is more complex) were discussed in particular in [2]. In this paper we consider a model of quantum photosynthesis (excitation, transport and ab- sorption of excitons in light-harvesting systems) as a three level quantum system with energy levels ε0, ε1, ε2, ε0 < ε1 < ε2, which interacts with three quantum fields (the reservoirs). The upper level ε2 (which corresponds to one exciton states in the system of chromophores) is degenerate. The two lower levels 0i, 1i are non degenerate and describe the state "exciton in the reaction center" (state 1i with energy ε1) and the state without excitons 0i with energy ε0. Three possible tran- sitions between the energy levels are paired to different reservoirs, which describe correspondingly light, phonons (vibrations of protein matrix) and absorption of excitons in the reaction center. Here the light can be coherent. We consider the dynamics of open quantum systems with dissipation [3], i.e. interaction with any of the reservoirs is described by a generator for density matrices in the Lindblad form, and for the light reservoir we also have an additional term in the generator which describes the interaction with laser. Interaction of degenerate systems with fields generate the so called dark states (or dark -- state polaritons) known in quantum optics [4], [5]. Moreover for different reservoirs the corresponding spaces of bright and dark states can be different. We conjecture that the interactions of chromophores with photons and phonons are different and the bright photonic states generated by interaction with light will contain a dark component for interaction with phonons. States of this kind will not decay in the process of transport of excitons. We discuss the relation of these non-decaying dark states and known from experiments with photonic echo [6], [7] quantum coherencies in photosynthesis systems. 1 Dynamics in the model under consideration is described by a sum of three generators -- photonic, phononic and the generator of absorption of excitons. We consider the following scheme of computation of manipulation of quantum states of the system. 1) First, we consider the approximation of strong light and weak transport. In this approxi- mation we take into account only the photonic generator and neglect the effects of transport and absorption. 2) Second, we switch off the light and for the obtained at the previous stage photonic stationary state we consider joint action of generators of transport and absorption. After this the upper level of the system will contain only the part of the state which is dark with respect to the transport generator. 3) For the obtained at stage 2 state we consider interaction with a coherent light, which allows to investigate the possibility of photonic echo for this state. In non degenerate case (when energy level ε2 is non degenerate) the considered in this paper non-equilibrium quantum system was discussed in [8]. The flow of excitons in the system was computed and excitation of quantum coherencies for interaction with laser was considered. When the laser is switched off these coherencies (in non degenerate case) decay due to interaction with phonons. Quantum dynamics in the stochastic limit in presence of laser field was studied in [9]. Properties of antibunched light are discussed for instance in [10]. In paper [11] effects of degeneracy in exciton transport were investigated by the stochastic limit method. It was shown that, using constructive interference, it is possible to achieve quantum amplification of exciton transport (the supertransport effect). The possibility of excitation of non- decaying dark states in a degenerate system can be considered as a side effect of the supertransport. In [12] dark states in photosynthetic systems were studied experimentally. In [13] application of quantum methods to computations and biology was discussed. In [14] dark states in photosynthesis were considered but dark states in this paper were considered in a different way compared to the present paper (as collective states of excitons, photons and phonons), in particular interactions between excitons and photons, excitons an phonons in [14] are similar (in this case the effect considered in the present paper does not take place). The exposition of the present paper is as follows. In section 2 the Hamiltonian of light- harvesting system interacting with three reservoirs (photons, phonons and absorption) is described. In section 3 the corresponding generators of dynamics of density matrix of the system are con- sidered (there are three such generators which describe excitation, transport and absorption of excitons). In section 4 bright, dark and off-diagonal states for the mentioned generators are dis- cussed. In section 5 preparation of quantum states by interaction with light (including laser field) is considered. In section 6 the state obtained in section 5 is subjected to transport and absorption (when the light is switched off). In section 7 we consider the interaction of the obtained at the previous stage dark state of the system with laser field and discuss the relation to photonic echo experiments. 2 2 Hamiltonian of the model We consider a system with three energy levels ε0 < ε1 < ε2, where the upper level is degenerate, with the Hamiltonian N HS = ε00ih0 + ε11ih1 + ε2 Xj=2 jihj. (1) This Hamiltonian describes a light-harvesting system, 0i corresponds to a state without ex- citons, 1i is a state "exciton in the reaction center", ji correspond to one-exciton states of chromophores. System interacts with three quantum fields (reservoirs) in a dipole way. Transitions between the levels with energies ε0 and ε2 (in particular creation of excitons) are related to interaction with light (Bose field in the Gibbs state with the temperature β−1 em = 6000K, or laser field with the frequency ε2 − ε0), transitions between the levels ε2 and ε1 (transport of excitons to the reaction center) are related to interaction with phonons, or vibrations of protein matrix (described by the Bose field with the temperature β−1 ph = 300K), and transitions between the levels ε1 and ε0 (absorption of excitons in the reaction center) are described by interaction with the sink reservoir in the Fock state (i.e. reservoir with the zero temperature). Thus we have three reservoirs described by Hamiltonians of quantum Bose fields Hem (light, or electromagnetic field), Hph (phonons, or vibrations of protein matrix), Hsink (sink, or absorption of excitons in the reaction center), each of the reservoir Hamiltonians has the form HR = ZR3 ωR(k)a∗ R(k)aR(k)dk, where R = em, ph, sink enumerate the reservoirs, ωR is the dispersion of the Bose field aR. Each of the reservoirs is in a mean zero Gaussian state with the quadratic correlator Here NR(k) (number of the field quanta with wave number k) is equal to (for the inverse ha∗ R(k)aR(k′)i = NR(k)δ(k − k′). temperature βR) The full Hamiltonian has the form NR(k) = 1 eβRωR(k) − 1 . (2) H = HS + Hem + Hph + Hsink + λ (HI,em + HI,ph + HI,sink) , where the interaction Hamiltonians HI,em, HI,ph, HI,sink have dipole forms and are given by for- mulae (3), (4), (5) below. Interaction of the system with light is described by the Hamiltonian HI,em = Aemχih0 + A∗ em0ihχ, A∗ em = ZR3 gem(k)a∗ em(k)dk, (3) where the bright photonic state χ belongs to the level with energy ε2, this state can be taken normalized kχk = 1, gem(k) is the form -- factor of the field. 3 Transport of excitons to the reaction center is related to interaction of the system with phonons HI,ph = Aphψih1 + A∗ ph1ihψ, A∗ ph = ZR3 gph(k)a∗ ph(k)dk, (4) here the bright phononic state ψ with the energy ε2 is normalized kψk = 1. Vectors ψ and χ belong to the same degenerate level with energy ε2 (corresponding to excitons on chromophores). Crucial feature of the model under consideration is as follows -- vectors ψ and χ are non-parallel. Absorption of excitons in the reaction center is described by interaction with the additional field of sink (with the zero temperature) HI,sink = Asink1ih0 + A∗ sink0ih1, A∗ sink = ZR3 gsink(k)a∗ sink(k)dk. (5) Remark. Usually in papers on photosynthesis some different Hamiltonian is used. In particular in this Hamiltonian the part (1) is non-diagonal and contains terms corresponding to the dipole interaction of excitons, the interaction Hamiltonian is also different. Here we consider the result of diagonalization of the system Hamiltonian HS (transition to the so called "global" basis), i.e. in our notations the states jiof the system correspond to the states from the "global" basis. Relation between the "global" and "local" approaches in theory of open quantum systems was discussed in [15]. 3 Generators of the dynamics For investigation of the model we will use the method of quantum stochastic limit [1], [2]. In this limit dynamics of reduced density matrix of a system interacting with reservoir is generated by operator in the Lindblad form, see formulae (7), (12), (13) below. Quantum dynamics in the stochastic limit in presence of a laser field was discussed in [9]. For the considered model with three reservoirs the dynamics will be generated by a sum of three generators d dt ρ(t) = (θem + i[·, Heff] + θph + θsink) (ρ(t)). We will manipulate quantum states of the system by switching different generators in this formula. Actually it is possible to manipulate only with the photonic generator θem + i[·, Heff]. of the dissipative Lindblad term and the term related to coherent field [1, 2]: Creation and annihilation of excitons are described by the photonic generator equal to a sum θem(ρ) = 2γ− Lem = θem + i[·, Heff], Heff = s(χih0 + 0ihχ), 2{ρ,χihχ}(cid:19) − iγ− 2{ρ,0ih0}(cid:19) + iγ+ re,em(cid:18)hχρχi0ih0 − re,em(cid:18)h0ρ0iχihχ − +2γ+ im,em[ρ,0ih0]. 1 1 4 s ∈ R. im,em[ρ,χihχ]+ (6) (7) The constants γ have the form γ+ re,em = πZ gem(k)2δ(ωem(k) − ε2 + ε0)Nem(k)dk, γ+ γ− re,em = πZ gem(k)2δ(ωem(k) − ε2 + ε0)(Nem(k) + 1)dk, im,em = −Z gem(k)2 P.P. im,em = −Z gem(k)2 P.P. ωem(k) − ε2 + ε0 Nem(k)dk, 1 1 (Nem(k) + 1)dk. γ− ωem(k) − ε2 + ε0 Here the function Nem(k) is given by (2), β−1 em = 6000K for the sun light. For the laser field Nem(k) = 0, this implies γ+ re,em = γ+ im,em = 0, but γ− re,em, γ− dissipative part of the generator is non zero even for coherent field). Transport of excitons is described by the phononic generator, here β−1 ph = 300K im,em 6= 0 (i.e. (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) θph(ρ) = 2γ− 1 re,ph(cid:18)hψρψi1ih1 − re,ph(cid:18)h1ρ1iψihψ − 2{ρ,ψihψ}(cid:19) − iγ− 2{ρ,1ih1}(cid:19) + iγ+ 1 +2γ+ Absorption of excitons is described by the sink generator with β−1 im,ph[ρ,ψihψ]+ im,ph[ρ,1ih1]. sink = 0K θsink(ρ) = 2γ− re,sink(cid:18)h1ρ1i0ih0 − 1 2{ρ,1ih1}(cid:19) − iγ− im,sink[ρ,1ih1]. Here coefficients γ+ are equal to zero since the temperature is zero. Constants γ in (12), (13) are given by formulae analogous to (8), (9), (10), (11) with differ- ent Bohr frequencies (differences of energies of the levels), dispersions and temperatures of the reservoirs (i.e. we substitute these parameters by the corresponding for phonons and sink). 4 Bright, dark and off-diagonal states For Lindblad generators of the form (7), (12), (13) one can consider expansion of the space of states of the system in a sum of orthogonal subspaces of bright, dark and off-diagonal states. Bright and dark states were extensively discussed in quantum optics, see [4], [5]. We use here the approach and notations of [11]. These subspaces depend on the generator and are different for different generators. Let us discuss the photonic generator (7). Generator θem describes creation and annihilation of excitons by interaction of chromophores and electromagnetic field. Bright mixed states for this generators are linear combinations of matrices Below we usually will ignore the positivity and normalization for states, i.e. we will talk about matrices instead of states (even if we will use the term state). 0ih0, χihχ. 5 Pure bright state of the upper level (with energy ε2) is the vector χi in (3). Pure dark states Mixed dark states are matrices B which give zero when multiplied by any mixed bright state of the upper level are vectors φi orthogonal to the pure bright state: φ⊥χ. A, i.e. AB = BA = 0. In the case of the generator θem these states are linear combinations of matrices φihφ′, 1ih1, φih1, 1ihφ, φ⊥χ, φ′⊥χ. Off-diagonal matrices are matrices C orthogonal to all bright matrices A and all dark matrices B with respect to the scalar product (·,·) = tr(··), i.e. tr(CA) = tr(CB) = 0. This subspace contains matrices corresponding to transitions between bright and dark sub- spaces, and between levels in the bright subspace, for the generator θem the off-diagonal subspace is generated by matrices χih0, χihφ, χih1, 1ih0, φih0, φ⊥χ and conjugated. Dark states described above are stationary with respect to the dynamics generated by θem. The bright space corresponds to processes of creation and annihilation of excitons (for the generator θem) and to process of transport of excitons (for the generator θph). Off-diagonal matrices decay which corresponds to the decoherence phenomenon. In presence of a coherent field (generator i[·, Heff]) off-diagonal matrices can be created. Described expansion of the state of matrices depends on the generator and for the phononic generator θph will be completely different. In particular matrix 1ih1 is dark for θem and bright for θph, and matrix χihχ is bright for θem and contains a combination of bright, dark and off-diagonal terms for θph (since the phononic pure bright vector ψ is not parallel to the photonic pure bright vector χ). Let us discuss also bright, dark and off-diagonal matrices for the phononic generator θph given by (12). The pure bright vector of the upper level is given by ψi in (4). Mixed bright matrices for θph are linear combinations of The space of mixed dark states is generated by matrices 1ih1, ψihψ. ηihη′, 0ih0, ηih0, 0ihη, η⊥ψ, η′⊥ψ. The off-diagonal space is a linear span of matrices ψih1, ψihη, ψih0, 0ih1, ηih1, η⊥ψ and conjugated. 6 5 Stage 1: light is switched on Let us discuss the process of manipulation of quantum states of light-harvesting system. The initial state is the density matrix without excitons ρ0 = 0ih0. We apply to this initial state the dynamics generated by the photonic generator Lem = θem + i[·, Heff] of the form (6) where the light contains also coherent component. This dynamics puts the system in a stationary state of the form ρ1 = ρ000ih0 + ρχχχihχ + ρχ0χih0 + ρ0χ0ihχ, (14) where ρ00 = re,em − s2 γ− 2 (cid:16) 1 µ20 + 1 µ02(cid:17) γ+ re,em + γ− µ20 re,em − s2(cid:16) 1 re,em − γ+ γ− re,em − s2(cid:16) 1 re,em ρχ0 = is µ20 γ+ re,em + γ− , ρχχ = γ+ re,em + γ− + 1 µ02(cid:17) , µ20 µ02(cid:17) + 1 µ20 = −γ− re,em − γ+ re,em − γ+ µ02 = −γ− ρ0χ = − is µ02 γ+ re,em + γ− re,em + iγ− re,em − iγ− im,em + iγ+ im,em − iγ+ im,em, im,em. + 1 µ02(cid:17) µ20 re,em − s2(cid:16) 1 re,em − γ+ γ− re,em − s2(cid:16) 1 re,em µ20 re,em − s2 γ+ 2 (cid:16) 1 µ20 + 1 µ02(cid:17) , (15) + 1 µ02(cid:17) , (16) (17) (18) One can say that we used the approximation of strong light and ignore the contributions to the dynamics from the phononic generator θph and the sink generator θsink. In particular, if there is no coherent field then off-diagonal elements of the matrix ρ1 vanish ρχ0 = ρ0χ = 0 and diagonal elements ρ00, ρχχ are given by the Gibbs state satisfying ρχχ ρ00 = e−βem(ε2−ε0). In the limit of strong coherent field s → ∞ we get for (15), (16) ρ00 = ρχχ = 1 2 , ρχ0 = ρ0χ = 0. For the photonic generator Lem = θem + i[·, Heff] there exist also dark stationary states which are linear combinations of matrices φihφ′, φih1, 1ihφ, 1ih1, φ, φ′⊥χ. Thus addition of a coherent field does not change the space of dark states. Proof. Dynamics with the generator Lem and the initial sate ρ0 = 0ih0 belongs to the space of matrices of a form (14). In the space of matrices (14) the matrix of the generator Lem is as follows Lem ρχχ ρ00 ρχ0 ρ0χ     =   2γ+ −2γ− re,em; re,em; is; −is re,em; −2γ+ 2γ− re,em; −is; is 0 µ20; −is; is; is; −is; 0; µ02     ρχχ ρ00 ρχ0 ρ0χ   . 7 For the stationary state the third equation of the system Lemρ = 0 implies is(ρχχ − ρ00) = −µ20ρχ0, i.e. (ρχχ − ρ00). Substitution of these ρχ0, ρ0χ in the first equation of Lemρ = 0 gives (ρχχ − ρ00), ρχ0 = − ρ0χ = is µ20 is µ02 (cid:18)2γ+ re,em − s2(cid:18) 1 µ20 + 1 µ02(cid:19)(cid:19) ρ00 = (cid:18)2γ− re,em − s2(cid:18) 1 µ20 + 1 µ02(cid:19)(cid:19) ρχχ. The normalization condition ρ00 + ρχχ = 1 implies (15), (16). It might seem that the described stationary state does not depend on the degeneracy, Remark. in particular the off-diagonal element (16) is similar for both cases with and without degeneracy. This formula follows from the normalization kχk = 1 in (3) which is always possible: if kχk 6= 1 then one can the corresponding normalization add to the expression for the field in (3): HI,em = Aemχih0 + A∗ em0ihχ = kχkAem 1 kχkχih0 + kχkA∗ em 1 kχk0ihχ. Therefore the normalization kχk = 1 means that the parameter s is multiplied by kχk and values γ± em are multiplied by kχk2. This transformation gives γ− re,em − γ+ re,em − s2 γ+ re,em + γ− kχkµ20 ρχ0 = is re,em kχk2 (cid:16) 1 µ20 . + 1 µ02(cid:17) 6 Stage 2: light is switched off The second stage of manipulation of quantum states of light-harvesting system is as follows: we switch off the light, i.e. we use the obtained at the previous step state ρ1 given by (14), (15), (16) as the initial state for dynamics with the generator θph + θsink (sum of phononic generator and sink generator). Let us consider the expansion of the bright photonic state in the sum of contributions parallel and orthogonal to the bright phononic state ψ χ = χ0 + χ1, χ0kψ, χ1⊥ψ χ0i = hψ, χiψi = ψihψχi, χ1i = (1 − ψihψ)χi. Let us substitute this expansion in expression (14), (15), (16) for the stationary photonic state and apply the generator θph + θsink. Discussion of section 4 of dynamics in spaces of bright, dark and off-diagonal matrices implies that all terms in the expansion which contain χ0 will decay since the transport generator θph will transfer excitons to the reaction center where excitons will be absorbed. Hence the system will tend to the stationary state of the form ρ2 = ρ000ih0 + ρχχχ1ihχ1 + ρχ0χ1ih0 + ρ0χ0ihχ1, (19) 8 where ρχχ, ρχ0, ρ0χ are given by (15), (16), and ρ00 is given by the condition that trace of density matrix is equal to one ρ00 = 1 − kχ1k2ρχχ. In the model under consideration the obtained state (19) can exist infinite time (in reality the lifetime should be finite but long). If the bright states for photons and phonons coincide (i.e. χ1i = 0) then we will get ρ2 = 0ih0. In general case of non-parallel ψ, χ the obtained state ρ2 will contain non-decaying dark part. This part can be observed in spectroscopical experiments, see the next section. Remark. Vectors ψ, χ are norm one vectors in multidimensional space. Random independent normed vectors in a multidimensional space are close to orthogonal (since measure of a unit sphere is concentrated near the equator of this sphere). On the other hand, biological systems undergo selection pressure, for the present model this is the selection pressure to increase effectiveness of exciton transport. This selection pressure will aim to make vectors χ and ψ parallel (in this case the transport will be most effective). Therefore the angle between χ and ψ will be related to competition between entropy and selection. 7 Stage 3: light is switched on At the third stage of manipulation of quantum states of excitons we subject the obtained at the previous step state ρ2 of the form (19) to interaction with coherent light. We ignore transport and absorption (for example the light strong and we consider small times). We will show that in this situation it is possible to observe photonic echo. Spectroscopy is the application of dynamics with the generator i[·, Heff] to the off-diagonal part of density matrix proportional to χih0− 0ihχ, see below. Thus we are interested in the term in (19) of the form (20) ρχ0χ1ih0 + ρ0χ0ihχ1, where the matrix elements ρχ0, ρ0χ are given by (16). In particular this term can be non-zero only if s 6= 0, i.e. the state (14) should be excited by light with coherent component. Let us recall that χ1 is the orthogonal complement to projection of χ (bright photonic vector) to ψ (bright phononic vector). We define χ2 as projection of χ1 to χ (i.e. χ2 is parallel to χ), then Applying i[·, Heff] to (20) we will get non-zero contribution only for the following matrix (since χ2i = (cid:0)1 − hψ, χi2(cid:1)χi. the contribution from orthogonal complement to χ2i vanish) ρχ0χ2ih0 + ρ0χ0ihχ2 = = Re ρχ0(cid:0)1 − hψ, χi2(cid:1) (χih0 + 0ihχ) + iIm ρχ0(cid:0)1 − hψ, χi2(cid:1) (χih0 − 0ihχ) , where ρχ0 is given by (16). Non-zero contribution to interaction with the laser here gives the second term, equal to ρ3 = isRe(cid:18) 1 µ20(cid:19) γ+ re,em + γ− re,em γ− re,em − γ+ re,em − 2s2Re(cid:16) 1 µ20(cid:17) (cid:0)1 − hψ, χi2(cid:1) (χih0 − 0ihχ) . (21) 9 In the regime under consideration (s 6= 0) this term is non-zero. This term is largest when the laser amplitude is chosen as follows s2 = − re,em re,em + γ− γ+ µ20(cid:17) 2Re(cid:16) 1 = 1 2 (cid:0)γ−2 re,em + γ+2 re,em + γ−2 im,em + γ+2 im,em(cid:1) , In this case iIm ρχ0 = − i 2√2 re,em − γ+ γ− re,em re,em + γ−2 re,em + γ+2 qγ−2 . im,em + γ+2 im,em If the state ρ1 was excited by purely coherent light when Nem(k) = 0, hence γ+ re,em = γ+ im,em = 0, γ− re,em = πZ gem(k)2δ(ωem(k) − ε2 + ε0)dk, im,em = −Z gem(k)2 P.P. 1 ωem(k) − ε2 + ε0 γ− dk, then Im ρχ0 is maximal. If we ignore the shift γ− im,em we get the simple expression ρχ0 = − i 2√2 . Summary. We have shown that the model of light-harvesting complex as a degenerate system with absorption and interaction with photons and phonons describes excitation of dark states which will have long lifetime and will be visible in spectroscopic experiments. Earlier it was shown [11] that degeneracy can be used for quantum amplification of exciton transport (the supertransport effect). Results of the present paper show that in this case, as a side effect of the supertransport, we will obtain coherent dark states with long lifetime. This result can be discussed in relation of phenomenon of quantum photosynthesis [6], [7] and experimental observation of dark states in photosynthetic systems [12]. Remark. We have discussed manipulations with quantum states, in particular with dark states: excitation of the states by coherent fields and using of Lindblad dissipation for projections of the states to some subspaces of matrices; since the bright vectors for different fields (χ and ψ in the present model) can be non-parallel the manipulations under consideration are nontrivial. The considered manipulations using degeneracy and different ways of interaction with the degenerate energy level of the system are of very special form. Manipulations of quantum states can be used for quantum computations [13]. Long lifetime of dark states could help to avoid decoherence in quantum computers. For another proposal to reduce decoherence in quantum computers by manipulating with macroscopic parameters see [16]. Different ideas of how to use photosynthetic quantum effects for computations are discussed in [6], [17], [18]. It would be interesting also to discuss a possible connection of manipulations with quantum states considered in this our work with those studied in quantum control theory, see for example [19]. 10 Quantum beats. Let us recall the model of interaction of two level system with laser. Dynamics of the density matrix of a system with levels 0i, χi (where kχk = 1) is described by equation d dt ρ(t) = i[ρ(t), H], H = sσx = s(cid:18) 0 1 1 0(cid:19) , s ∈ R. The basis of sigma -- matrices is σz = χihχ−0ih0. σ0 = χihχ+0ih0, Operators σ0, σx are invariant with respect to the dynamics. Action of the generator of the dynamics in the subspace σy = i (−χih0 + 0ihχ) , σx = χih0+0ihχ, is given by ρ = r(χihχ − 0ih0) + ui (−χih0 + 0ihχ) i[·, H](cid:18) r u(cid:19) = (cid:18) 0 −2s 2s 0 (cid:19)(cid:18) r u(cid:19) . The corresponding dynamics reduces to oscillations in this two-dimensional space with Rabi frequency Ω = 2s. Acknowledgments. This research was funded by a grant from the Russian Science Foundation (Project No. 14-50-00005). References [1] L. Accardi, Lu Yun Gang, I. Volovich, Quantum theory and its stochastic limit, Springer- Verlag, Berlin, 2002 [2] L.Accardi, S.V.Kozyrev. Lectures on Quantum Interacting Particle Systems, in: QP-PQ: Quantum Probability and White Noise Analysis - Vol. 14 "Quantum Interacting Particle Systems", World Scientific Publishing, 2002. [3] A. S. Holevo, Quantum systems, channels, information, DeGruyter, 2012. [4] M.O. Scully, M.S. Zubairy, Quantum Optics, Cambridge University Prress, Cambridge, UK, 1997. [5] M. Fleischhauer, M.D. Lukin, Dark-State Polaritons in Electromagnetically Induced Trans- parency, Phys. Rev. Lett. 2000, V.84, P.5094, arXiv:quant-ph/0001094 [6] G.S. Engel, T.R. Calhoun, E.L. Read, T.K.Ahn, T. Mancal, Y.C. Cheng, R.E. Blankenship, G.R. Fleming, Evidence for wavelike energy transfer through quantum coherence in photo- synthetic systems. Nature, 2007, V.446. P.782 -- 786. [7] G.D. Scholes, G.R. Fleming, A. Olaya-Castro, R. van Grondelle, Lessons from nature about solar light harvesting. Nature Chem., 2011, 3, 763774. 11 [8] S.V.Kozyrev, A.Mironov, A.Teretenkov, I.V.Volovich, Three-level system interacting with three reservoirs and quantum photosynthesis, To appear. [9] L. Accardi, S.V.Kozyrev, A.N.Pechen, Coherent Quantum Control of Λ -- Atoms through the Stochastic Limit, P.1-17, in: Quantum Information and Computing, QP-PQ: Quantum Prob- ability and White Noise Analysis - Vol. 19, eds. L.Accardi, M.Ohya, N.Watanabe, 2006, World Scientific. arXiv:quant-ph/0403100 [10] Igor V. Volovich, Cauchy -- Schwarz inequality-based criteria for non-classicality of sub-Poisson and antibunched light, Phys. Lett. A, 380:1-2 (2016), 5658. [11] I. Ya. Aref'eva, I. V. Volovich, S. V. Kozyrev, Stochastic limit method and interference in quantum many-particle systems, Theoretical and Mathematical Physics, 2015, 183:3, 782 -- 799 [12] M. Ferretti, R. Hendrikx, E. Romero, J. Southall, R.J. Cogdell, V.I. Novoderezhkin, G.D. Scholes, R. van Grondelle, Dark States in the Light-Harvesting complex 2 Revealed by Two- dimensional Electronic Spectroscopy, Scientific Reports, 6:20834, DOI: 10.1038/srep20834 [13] Masanori Ohya, Igor Volovich, Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Information and Com- putation and Its Applications to Nano- and Bio-systems, Springer, 2011. [14] Hui Dong, Da-Zhi Xu, Jin-Feng Huang, Chang-Pu Sun, Coherent excitation transfer via the dark-state channel in a bionic system, Light: Science & Applications (2012) 1, e2; doi:10.1038/lsa.2012.2 [15] A. S. Trushechkin, I. V. Volovich, Perturbative treatment of inter-site couplings in the local description of open quantum networks, EPL, 113:3 (2016), 30005. [16] I.V. Volovich, Models of Quantum Computers and Decoherence Problem, arXiv:quant-ph/9902055. [17] M. Mohseni, P. Rebentrost, S. Lloyd, A. Aspuru-Guzik, Environment -- assisted quantum walks in photosynthetic energy transfer, J. Chem. Phys. 129, 174106 (2008). [18] Gabor Vattay, Stuart A. Kauffman, Evolutionary Design in Biological Quantum Computing, arXiv:1311.4688 [cond-mat.dis-nn]. [19] A.N. Pechen, N.B. Il'in, Existence of traps in the problem of maximizing quantum observable averages for a qubit at short times, Proc. Steklov Inst. Math., 289 (2015), 213 -- 220. 12
1502.07082	2	1502	2015-10-22T03:48:04	A New Model for the Collective Behavior of Animals	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	We propose a new model in order to study behaviors of self-organized system such as a group of animals. We assume that the individuals have two degrees of freedom corresponding one to their internal state and the other to their external state. The external state is characterized by its moving orientation. The rule of the interaction between the individuals is determined by the internal state which can be either in the non-excited state or in the excited state. The system is put under a source of external perturbation called "noise". To study the behavior of the model with varying noise, we use the Monte-Carlo simulation technique. The result clearly shows two first-order transitions separating the system into three phases: with increasing noise, the system undergoes a phase transition from a dilute disordered phase to an ordered compact phase and then to the disordered dispersed phase. These phases correspond to behaviors of animals: uncollected state at low noise, flocking at medium noise and runaway at high noise, respectively.	physics.bio-ph	physics	A New Model for Collective Behaviors of Animals P. The Nguyena, V. Thanh Ngob∗ and H. T. Diepc aDepartment of Natural Science, Duytan University, K7/25 Quang Trung, Haichau, Danang, Vietnam bInstitute of Physics - Vietnam Academy of Science and Technology, 10 Daotan, Ngoc Khanh, Badinh, Hanoi, Vietnam cLaboratoire de Physique Th´eorique et Mod´elisation, Universit´e de Cergy-Pontoise, CNRS, UMR 8089, 2 Avenue Adolphe Chauvin, F-95302 Cergy-Pontoise Cedex, France We propose a new model in order to study behaviors of self-organized system such as a group of animals. We assume that the individuals have two degrees of freedom corresponding one to their internal state and the other to their external state. The external state is characterized by its moving orientation. The rule of the interaction between the individuals is determined by the internal state which can be either in the non-excited state or in the excited state. The system is put under a source of external perturbation called "noise". To study the behavior of the model with varying noise, we use the Monte-Carlo simulation technique. The result clearly shows two first-order transitions separating the system into three phases: with increasing noise, the system undergoes a phase transition from a dilute disordered phase to an ordered compact phase and then to the disordered dispersed phase. These phases correspond to behaviors of animals: uncollected state at low noise, flocking at medium noise and runaway at high noise, respectively. I. INTRODUCTION The collective behavior of animals is a widely observed phenomenon in various biological systems. It is one of the main topics which have been extensively investigated during the last two decades using methods borrowed from many different areas of science including physics, ap- plied mathematics and engineering. For recent papers, the reader is referred to works of Couzin and cowork- ers, of Albano and his group among others [2 -- 6]. In these works, many aspects of animal groups have been discussed, among which the collective motion and their origin, the relation between individual and collective be- haviors and the relation between group size and collective decision-making. The flocking is a behavior of some animal species where they stay together in a group for social reasons. They de- rive many benefits from this behavior including defence against predators, easier collective moving, enhanced for- aging success and higher success in finding a mate. When they are faced with a danger such as predators, their nat- ural instinct is to flee not to fight. They use their natural herding instinct to bind together in a group for safety. All individuals of the group will move away from the preda- tor in the same direction and then stampede as fast as they can when being under the predator's attack. If there is no danger, then they are spread to find foods instead of staying in the flocking state. Many experimental facts and observations have been for example mentioned in the review of Vicsek and Zafeiris [1]. Well-known examples are found in populations such as large schools of fish [7] or gatherings of birds [8]. Biologically, it is known that the flocking behavior is advantageous for survival of a ∗Corresponding author, E-mail: [email protected] population [9 -- 11]: reducing the risk of capture by preda- tors, increasing higher mating efficiency, easier search for food, efficient learning of external stimuli, and reducing overall aggression [12 -- 15]. In 1987, Reynolds first suggested a simple model con- sisting of three rules: separation, alignment, and cohe- sion rules [16]. These rules describe the behavior of each individual in interaction with other neighboring individ- uals. All or some of the three rules were mathematically expressed and then analyzed by Vicsek and his cowork- ers [1, 17 -- 19]. They mainly focused on the transition between coherently moving and runaway in a stampede. The flocking behavior has been conventionally stud- ied through simulation in two frameworks: population (Eulerian or continuum models) and individuals (agents or particle-based models) [14, 20, 21]. In the popula- tion framework, the flock was collectively addressed while flock-density was used as a key variable to present spatial and temporal dynamics of aggregation frequently with partial differential equations of advection-diffusion reac- tion [22, 23]. In the individual framework, the flock of agents has been simulated by using ordinary and stochas- tic equations of motion to describe interactions among agents [7, 17, 24 -- 26]. This approach attempted to repli- cate naturally observed phenomena from not only animal groups but also other self-propelled characteristics [27] and to compare the evolved characteristics with those of actual animal flocking [28] in order to better understand possible mechanisms by which these characteristics may have evolved. The previous models have predicted with success flock- ing behavior of animal groups at high noise. They have, however, difficulties to explain uncollected states at very low noise. This has motivated our present work: in addi- tion to the interaction between neighboring animals, we introduce an internal degree of freedom which indicates whether an animal is in a non-excited or an excited state, we will show that the collective behavior of animals in the whole range of noise can be explained. Section II is devoted to the description of the model. Section III shows the Monte Carlo (MC) simulation re- sults for testing our model. Conclusions are given in Sec. IV. II. THE MODEL In biology, all the members of an animal group are spread to find foods if there is no danger. In this situa- tion, they are distributed in the space with a small con- centration and out of alignment. So, we say the group of animals is in a "uncollected" behavior. When the ani- mals are faced with danger such as predators, they bind together in a small area for safety with the same orienta- tion and high concentration. This state is called "flock- ing" state. Facing a danger, animals will move away from the predator in the same direction and then stampede as fast as they can when being under the predator's attack. At the final stage, they are in a "runaway" state. In order to study the phase transition behavior, we have to map the group of animals into a physical system. We consider an animal as a particle i with two degrees of freedom: an external parameter σi characterizing the animal orientation which depends on its interaction with the others, and an internal parameter Si indicating either it is in the non-excited (Si = 0) or in the excited (Si = 1) individual state. Let us define the internal degree of freedom. The inter- nal state of a particle can be described by two levels: the first level is characterized by a negative energy −ǫ which describes the calm, unworried stable state, and the sec- ond level by a positive energy +ǫ which expresses some degree of anxiety. Introducing an external noise η which plays the role of the temperature in statistical physics, we can write the canonical probability of these two states as [29] p1 = eǫ/η z , p2 = e−ǫ/η z where z is the partition function given by z = eǫ/η + e−ǫ/η = 2 cosh(ǫ/η) (1) (2) Note that p1 > p2 because ǫ > 0. So, the "positive" ten- dency towards tranquility is proportional to p1 − p2. The total number of particles having this tranquility state which is called non-excited state is thus given by N0 = N (p1 − p2) = N (cid:20) eǫ/η − e−ǫ/η z (cid:21) = N tanh(ǫ/η) (3) where N is the total number of particles in the system. The number of excited particles is then 2 One sees in the above equations that in zero noise one has N0 = N , namely there is as expected no excited particles. While, when the noise goes to infinity, one has N0 = 0 and Ne = N : all particles are excited. At a given noise, statistically one has a well-defined N0 and Ne with the conservation N = N0 + Ne. In the simulation which will be done below at a given noise, we generate at random N0 according to Eq. (3). The remaining particles in the system are thus in the excited state. Now, we put this system of individuals on the lattice where each individual can move on 2D triangular lattice of linear size L. The number of lattice sites should be greater than that of individuals, i.e., L2 ≫ N . We denote by σi the orientation of individual Si: σi is defined as in a q-state Potts model, i.e. σi = 1, 2, . . . , q. For simplicity, we consider q = 6, so the orientations σi = 1, 2, . . . , 6 of individual Si can be defined by the vectors which connect a site to its nearest neighbors (NN) with the following angles measured from the x axis: ϕi = 0, π/3, . . . , 5π/3. The interaction between nearest-neighboring animals is given by the Hamiltonian H = X<i,j> Ki,j cos[π(σi − σj)/3], (5) where the sum P<i,j> is made over up to the third near- est neighboring individuals Si and Sj. For simplicity, Ki,j is assumed to take the form of the Lennard-Jones potential: Ki,j = 4J (cid:2)(r0/ri,j)12 − (r0/ri,j)6(cid:3) , where ri,j is the distance between two individuals. We choose r0 = 0.89 in order that Ki,j ≃ J at ri,j = 1 which is the lattice spacing, J being a positive constant. The interaction between two individuals depends on their in- ternal state: Ki,j = 0 if both individuals are non-excited Si = Sj = 0, and Ki,j 6= 0 if otherwise. We empha- size that the interaction rule we impose means that an excited particle can interact with non-excited particles, dragging them into a collective motion. Let us note that, without the internal degree of free- dom and without particle motions, the above Hamilto- nian is the localized Potts clock model which has been solved for q = 2, 3 and 4 [30]. The case of very large q has been solved by Frohlich and Spencer [31]. However, for q = 5, 6, ... there are not (yet) exact results. Of course, our model is more complicated because the particles are mobile with an internal degree of freedom. III. THE PHASE-TRANSITION BEHAVIOR We use the MC simulation technique to study the above model. The main physical quantities such as the order parameter Q and the concentration ρ are defined in what follows. Ne = N − N0 (4) For Q, we have where with Q = qMmax − 1 q − 1 Mmax = max(M1, M2, ..., Mq) N Mi = Xj δσj ,i (i = 1, 2, ..., q) (6) (7) (8) where the sum on j is performed over all sites of the system. One sees that in the ordered state where there is only one kind of σj one has Q = 1. In the disordered phase where all values of σj are equally present, namely Mi = N/q for any i = 1, ..., q, one has Q = 0. For the concentration ρ we have ρ = 1 N N Xi=1 ni, (9) where ni is the number of NN individuals around Si. The quantity ρ in Eq. (9) characterizes the spatial distribu- tion of the individuals. The behavior of animals can be adequately described by the two parameters Q and ρ. In the simulations, we use ǫ = 0.04, J = 1.0 (taken as the unit of energy) and N = 100, 400 and 900 with the √N . For the initial configuration of lattice size L = 4 × the system, we randomly generate the particle positions on the lattice and take orientations of all individuals from an uniform distribution. At each MC step, we randomly choose N0 individuals (according to Eq. (3)), and set them to be non-excited Si = 0. The remaining particles are in the excited state Si = 1. Their position and ori- entation are updated by Metropolis algorithm. At each η, the equilibration time lies around 4 × 106 MC steps per individual and we compute statistical averages over 8 × 106 MC steps per individual. Each time a particle gets out of the lattice at one boundary, we put it into the system by the other end using the periodic bound- ary conditions in order to conserve the total number of particles. We plot in figures 1 and 2 the order parameter and the concentration as a function of external noise for sev- eral system sizes. It clearly shows the existence of three phases which are separated by the two transitions at very low noise and high noise. In phase I at low noise, the system is in the disordered phase with low concentra- tion (Q ≈ 0 and ρ ≈ 0). This phase is equivalent to the uncollected behavior of an animal group which is dis- persed over the whole space because almost of them are non-excited, it is called "free" phase with a few "con- tacts" between the individuals. Phase III, at high noise, is spatially sparse as the phase I, but the particles are very mobile in all directions. It describes the runaway 3 N = 100 N = 400 N = 900 (a) (b) 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 Noise r e t e m a r a p r e d r O 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0 FIG. 1: Order parameter versus noise with the system sizes N = 100 (circles), 400 (squares) and 900 (diamonds). The insets show the enlarged scale at low (a) and high (b) noise. 6 5 4 3 n o i t a r t n e c n o C 2 1 0 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 Noise N = 100 N = 400 N = 900 0.5 0.6 0.7 FIG. 2: Concentration versus noise with N = 100 (circles), 400 (squares) and 900 (diamonds). behavior. At medium noise, the animals are in phase II where they are compactly moving in an ordered phase with Q ≈ 1 and the maximum concentration ρ ≈ 6. This phase corresponds to the flocking behavior. The spatial distribution of the individuals is also pre- sented in Fig. 3 with snapshots taken at several values of noise η = 0.0522, 0.1367, 0.5000 and 0.5667, at the final stage of a MC simulation. The vectors indicate their po- sition and moving orientation. One sees that Figs 3(a,d) show that the system has the same distribution where they are randomly distributed in the plane with differ- ent orientations. However, the instantaneous snapshots do not permit to see the difference between two phases: the particles in phase I are almost immobile while they are moving very fast in a disordered manner in phase III (this difference is seen in videos). Fig. 3(b) shows the flocking behavior, and Fig. 3(c) shows the distribution of the system at the noise closes to the II-III transition point. At this stage, let us examine again Fig. 1: it shows discontinuities of the order parameter at both transitions I-II and II-III, indicating a signature of a first-order tran- sition. This abrupt behavior corresponds to the fact that the animals immediately flock when they are faced with danger, and they runaway when being under a predator's attack. These behaviors are more likely a first-order tran- (a) (c) η = 0.0522 η = 0.1367 (b) (d) r e t e m a r a p r e d r O 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 4 η = 1.1126 η = 0.5844 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 Noise 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 η = 0.5000 η = 0.5667 FIG. 3: Snapshots at different values of noise with N = 100. The arrow indicates the orientation of individual. See text for comments. (a) η = 0.0768 η = 0.0736 η = 0.0723 N = 100 N = 400 N = 900 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 m a r g o t s i H 0 −2 −1.6 −1.2 −0.8 −0.4 0 (b) η = 0.5414 η = 0.5745 η = 0.5844 N = 100 N = 400 N = 900 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 m a r g o t s i H 0 −2.5 −2 −1.5 Energy −1 −0.5 0 FIG. 4: Histogram versus energy at low (a) and high (b) noise at the transition points, with the system sizes N = 100 (solid), 400 (dotted) and 900 (dashed). sition. To confirm the first-order transition we have per- formed the energy histogram at the transition point. We show in Fig. 4 the energy histogram at two transitions I-II and II-III, for three system sizes. The double-peak histograms are clearly shown for both transitions at low noise (a) and high noise (b). The dip between the two maxima becomes deeper with increasing size. Note that FIG. 5: Order parameter versus noise with N = 100 for the localized lattice model (diamonds) and lattice gas model (cir- cles). a "true" discontinuity happens only when the dip comes down to zero. The distance between the two peaks is then the latent heat. To see this, we need sizes much larger than N = 900. But this is out of the scope of our present purpose. Let us discuss on the phase transition at high noise. It is known that the q-state Potts model localized on a lattice has a first-order transition with q ≥ 4 in two dimensions. The clock Potts model localized on a lat- tice was solved only for q ≤ 4 [30], though it was solved for very large q [31]. The model treated in the present paper corresponds to a mobile Potts model where par- ticles can go from one lattice site to another. This was never solved before. Note however that the transition II- III corresponds not only to an orientational disordering of the Potts parameter but also to the breaking of the compactness of the flocking state. This is similar to a melting transition where the solid phase melts into the liquid phase. The melting has often a first-order char- acter in three dimensions [32]. In two dimensions, it is known that long-range solid ordering does not survive at finite temperatures if the system has isotropic short- range interactions according to Nelson and Halperin [33]: at a first critical temperature, bound pairs of dislocations formed at low temperatures are unbound, giving rise to a phase with no translational ordering but with orien- tational hexatic structure. The latter phase undergoes a "critical" phase transition to the disordered phase. It was however found by MC simulation that the second transi- tion is not critical but it is a first-order two-dimensional disclination melting [34]. Our results shown in Figs. 3 (c,d) and 4 indicate that our model undergoes a first- order transition from the hexatic ordered phase to the liquid phase, in agreement with earlier MC simulations [34]. Finally, to compare our mobile Potts model with the corresponding localized Potts model, we have simulated the same system defined by (5) including the internal degree of freedom on a lattice of size L2 = N , i.e. the individuals are not allowed to move on the lattice. We show in Fig. 5 results of both mobile and localized Potts models: the transition temperature is about 0.5844 for 5 the mobile case, while it is η ≈ 1.1126 for the localized Potts model. IV. CONCLUSIONS We proposed in this paper a simple model for studying the behavior of animal groups as a function of an exter- nal perturbation, called "noise", such as dangers coming from predators. We showed that with increasing noise, the system has three phases I, II and III separated by two transitions, the first transition occurs at a low noise and and the second one at high noise. The three phases are disordered, ordered and melted phases which corre- spond respectively to the following behaviors of animals: uncollected state, flocking state and runaway state. Both transitions from one phase to another are found to be of the first-order. This model is similar to the lattice gas model devel- oped by Csah´ok et. al. [18] but in our model the align- ment rules of the individuals depend on the internal state, excited or non-excited, of its neighbors including itself. Therefore, our model can be applied not only for study- ing the phase transition behavior of animals at high noise as in previous models, but also for analyzing the animal behavior at low noise where animals are in a uncollected, disordered phase. This work was supported by the Nafosted (Vietnam National Foundation for Science and Technology Devel- opment), Grant No. 103.02-2011.55. [1] T. Vicsek and A. Zafeiris, Phys. Reports 517, 71 (2012). [2] I. D. Couzin, Trends in Cognitive Sciences 13, 36 (2009); I. D. Couzin, J. Krause, N. R. Franks and S. A. Levin, Nature 433, 513 (2005). [3] G. Baglietto and E. V. Albano, Computer Physics Com- munications 180, 527 (2009). O. Shochet, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1226 (1995). [18] Z. Csah´ok and T. Vicsek, Phys. Rev. E 52, 5297 (1995). [19] A. Czirok, H. E. Stanley, and T. Vicsek, Phys. Phys. A, 30, 137 (1996); A. Czir´ok, M. Vicsek, T. Vicsek, Physica A 264, 299 (1999); A. Czir´ok and T. Vicsek, Physica A 281, 17 (2000). [4] M. Aldana, H. Larralde and B. V´asquez, Internat. J. of [20] D. Grunbaum and A. Okubo, Frontiers in Mathematical Modern Physics B 23, 3459 (2009). Biology, (S.A. Levin (Ed.), Springer, Berlin, 1994). [5] G. P. Saracco, G. Gonnella, D. Marenduzzo and E. Or- [21] Y. Inada and K. Kawachi, J. Theor. Biol. 214, 371 landini, Cent. Eur. J. Phys. 10, 1109 (2012). (2002). [6] H. Chat´e, F. Ginelli, G. Gr´egoire, F. Peruani and F. Ray- [22] A. Mogilner and L. Edelstein-Keshet, Physica D 89, 346 naud, Eur. Phys. J. B 64, 451 (2008). (1996). [7] A. Huth and C. Wissel, Ecol. Modell., 75, 135 (1994). [8] M. Maldonado-Coelho and M. A. Marini, Biol. Conserv. [23] J. D. Murray, Mathematical Biology, (vols. 1 and 2, Springer, New York, 2003). 116, 19 (2004). [9] G. M. Werner and M. G. Dyer, Evolution of herding be- havior in artificial animals, Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Simulation of Adaptive Be- havior, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA (1992). [10] T. J. Pitcher (Ed.) and J. K. Parrish, Pitcher, The Be- havior of Teleost Fishes, (Chapman & Hall, New York, 1993). [11] W. Cresswell, Tringa tetanus. Anim. Behav. 47, 433 (1994). [12] D. H. Cashing and F. R. Harden-Jones, Nature 218, 918 (1968). [24] H. S. Niwa, J. Theor. Biol. 181, 47 (1996). [25] Y. Tu, Phys. A 281, 30 (2000). [26] J. Toner and Y. Tu, Phys. Rev. E 58, 4828 (1998). [27] L. Spector, J. Klein, C. Perry, and M. Feinstein, GPEM 6, 111 (2005). [28] A. J. Wood and G. J. Ackland, P. Roy. Soc. B-Biol. Sci., 274, 1637 (2007). [29] H. T. Diep, Statistical Physics: Fundamentals and Ap- plication to Condensed Matter, Lectures, Problems and Solutions (World Scientific, Singapore, 2015), chapter 3. [30] R. J. Baxter, Exactly Solved Models in Statistical Physics, (Academic Press, California, USA, 1982). [13] J. K. Parrish, S. V. Viscido, and D. Grunbaum, Biol. [31] J. Frohlich and T. Spencer, Communications in Mathe- Bull. 202, 296 (2002). [14] M. Adioui, J. P. Treuil, and O. Arino, Ecol. Modell. 167, 19 (2003). [15] M. Zheng, Y. Kashimori, O. Hoshino, K. Fujita, and T. Kambara, J. Theor. Biol. 235, 153 (2005). [16] C. W. Reynolds, Flocks, herds, and schools: a distributed behavioral model, Computer Graphics, SIGGRAPH'87 Conference Proceedings 21, 25 (1987). [17] T. Vicsek, A. Czirok, E. Ben-Jacob, I. Cohen, matical Physics 81, 527-602 (1981). [32] L. G´omez, A. Dobry, C. Geuting, H. T. Diep and L. Bu- rakovsky, Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 095701 (2003) and refer- ences therein. [33] D. R. Nelson and B. I. Halperin, Phys. Rev. B 19, 2457 (1979). [34] W. Janke and H. Kleinert, Phys. Letters 105A, 134 (1984).
1206.2749	1	1206	2012-06-13T08:43:07	Colour changes upon cooling of Lepidoptera scales containing photonic nanoarchitectures	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.mtrl-sci" ]	The effects produced by the condensation of water vapours from the ambient in the various intricate nanoarchitectures occurring in the wing scales of several Lepidoptera species were investigated by controlled cooling (from room temperature to -5 - -10 {\deg}C) combined with in situ measurement of changes in the reflectance spectra. It was determined that, due to this procedure, all photonic nanoarchitectures giving a reflectance maximum in the visible range and having an open nanostructure exhibited alteration of the position of the reflectance maximum associated with the photonic nanoarchitectures. The photonic nanoarchitectures with a closed structure exhibited little to no alteration in colour. Similarly, control specimens coloured by pigments did not exhibit a colour change under the same conditions. Hence, this effect can be used to identify species with open photonic nanoarchitectures in their scales. For certain species, an almost complete disappearance of the reflectance maximum was found. All specimens recovered their original colours following warming and drying. Cooling experiments using thin copper wires demonstrated that colour alterations could be limited to a millimetre, or below. Dried museum specimens do not exhibit colour changes when cooled in the absence of a heat sink due to the low heat capacity of the wings.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Colour changes upon cooling of Lepidoptera scales containing photonic nanoarchitectures István Tamáska1a, Krisztián Kertész1b, Zofia Vértesy1c, Zsolt Bálint2d, András Kun2e, Shen- Horn Yen3f, László Péter Biró1g* 1Institute for Technical Physics and Materials Science, Research Centre for Natural Sciences, P.O.B. 49, H-1525 Budapest, Hungary 2Hungarian Natural History Museum, Baross utca 13, H-1088 Budapest, Hungary 3Laboratory of Natural Resource Conservation, Department of Biology and Institute of Life Science, National Sun Yat-Sen University, Kaohsiung, Taiwan, R. O. C. Abstract The effects produced by the condensation of water vapours from the ambient in the various intricate nanoarchitectures occurring in the wing scales of several Lepidoptera species were investigated by controlled cooling (from room temperature to -5 – -10 °C) combined with in situ measurement of changes in the reflectance spectra. It was determined that, due to this procedure, all photonic nanoarchitectures giving a reflectance maximum in the visible range and having an open nanostructure exhibited alteration of the position of the reflectance maximum associated with the photonic nanoarchitectures. The photonic nanoarchitectures with a closed structure exhibited little to no alteration in colour. Similarly, control specimens coloured by pigments did not exhibit a colour change under the same conditions. Hence, this effect can be used to identify species with open photonic nanoarchitectures in their scales. For certain species, an almost complete disappearance of the reflectance maximum was found. All specimens recovered their original colours following warming and drying. Cooling experiments using thin copper wires demonstrated that colour alterations could be limited to a millimetre, or below. Dried museum specimens do not exhibit colour changes when cooled in the absence of a heat sink due to the low heat capacity of the wings. Keywords: photonic nanoarchitectures; condensation; local cooling; display Correspondence: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], Corresponding author Introduction Animal colour is mostly due to the spectrally selective reflection of incident light. It can be associated with absorbing pigments (Zollinger et al. 2003; Nijhout 1991), which are often referred to as chemical colour, and/or selective reflection caused by structural properties, which is usually referred to as physical or structural colour (Joannopoulos et al. 2008; Biró and Vigneron 2011). Some physical colours can be produced by photonic crystals (Seago et al. 2009; Wilts et al. 2009; Shawkey et al. 2009a; Poladian et al. 2009; Ghiradella and Butler 2009), which are periodic dielectric structures in space composed of two or more media with different optical properties. These structures have a forbidden gap, within which photons with certain energies cannot propagate and are completely reflected by the surface of the photonic crystal. Since 1987, when Yablonovitch (Yablonovitch 1987) and John (John 1987) described structures (i.e., nanoarchitectures) with photonic band gaps, the field has been developing at an increasingly rapid pace. An enormous variety of photonic structures can be found in nature. Butterflies, beetles (Srinivasarao 1999, Seago et al. 2009, Shawkey et al. 2009a, Ghiradella & Butler 2009, Biró et al. 2010) and even plants (Vigneron et al. 2005a, Glover & Whitney 2010) exhibit these kinds of structures. It has recently been shown that, in certain species, such as the sexually dichromatic species Hypolimnas bolina, females prefer conspecific males that possess bright iridescent blue/ultraviolet dorsal ornamentation (Kemp 2007) so that the "quality" of the photonic nanoarchitectures is well preserved from generation to generation. As emphasised by several recent reports, visual signals from conspecific individuals make important contributions to the mating behaviours of butterflies (Fordyce et al. 2002, Oliver et al. 2002, Bálint et al. in press). Several recent reviews have been published on photonic nanostructures of biological origin (Parker 2002, Vukusic & Sambles 2003, Fratzl 2007, Kinoshita 2008, Biró & Vigneron 2011). Butterflies are diverse and highly practical examples of these structures, as their colour is generated by pigments and by various nanostructures (Kertész et al. 2006a, Kinoshita & Yoshioka 2005, Vértesy et al. 2006, Welch & Vigneron 2007, Vukusic et al. 1999, Vukusic & Stavenga 2009, Argyros et al. 2002). The essentially flat wings of butterflies can be easily processed into convenient samples for both scientific examination and practical applications, such as solar cells (Zhang et al. 2009), sensors (Potyrailo et al. 2007, Biró et al. 2008) and many other uses (Huang et al. 2006, Berthier et al. 2007). Lepidopteran wings and the scales covering them have a complex geometric structure on macroscopic- and microscopic-length scales. The membranes of the wings are generally covered with partially overlapping scales on both sides. Typical scale dimensions are in the ranges of 50 – 100 m for length and 15 – 50 m for width. Most species have two distinct layers of different scales: ground scales and cover scales. While the underside of the scale is rather featureless, the externally visible top surface usually exhibits a complex structure from the micron to the nanometre range. This top surface or the volume of the scale contains photonic nanostructures if the colour of the wings is of structural origin. These nanostructures are mainly constructed of a chitinous matrix, including air holes (Scoble 1995, Kristensen 2003, Berthier 2006). These biological structures attract more and more attention because they constitute a transition between random and crystalline order (Shawkey et al. 2009; Liu et al. 2011). Recent papers reported that even a complete photonic band gap can be found in such partially ordered materials (Florescu et al. 2009). It often may not be a straightforward task to determine if a certain butterfly exhibits structural colour, especially in the case of species presenting non-iridescent, matte structural colour, as is seen on the ventral side of Cyanophrys remus (Kertész et al. 2006b) or Callophrys rubi (Ghiradella & Radigan 1976). Of course, transmission and scanning electron microscopy (TEM and SEM, respectively) can reveal structural details, but these methods require time-consuming sample preparation (Shawkey et al. 2009b), expensive equipment and physical destruction of the (potentially rare) exemplars. Sophisticated optical characterisation (Kertész et al. 2006b, Wilts et al. 2009) can also reveal the presence of photonic nanoarchitectures, but the required instruments and the expertise may not be available in all laboratories; again, destructive sample preparation steps usually cannot be avoided. The method described by Mason (Mason 1923), based on soaking the specimen (sometimes for days) in liquids with a refractive index matching the refractive index of the nanoarchitecture, may also be an alternative. Dropping liquids (e.g., oil or ethanol) onto wings could identify nanostructures, but because these liquids cannot be found in the natural environments of butterflies, this method may raise concern from museum curators that it could damage the valuable samples. This type of method may induce persistent changes in the status of a specimen. In this paper, we present a simple method based on cooling in ambient air to observe and investigate the colour-change of the wings of several Lepidoptera species coloured by photonic nanoarchitectures in detail. Cooling the butterflies and allowing water vapour to condense quickly onto the micro- and nanostructures induces colour change in their scales, which possess structural colour arising from open nanoarchitectures. This simple method allows the observer to determine which colours are of structural origin, as pigment- coloured wings do not show the colour change observed in the case of structural colours. During the cooling experiments, we identified significant differences in a few species in the time lapse of the colour change and how it changed; these differences originate from differences in air circulation in different nanoarchitectures. We also attempted to highlight some basic ideas that underlie the interaction of water with wings and the colour-generating nanoarchitectures. As softening in water vapour is the standard procedure for setting butterflies, water vapour condensation should not raise concerns from museum curators. It is well known that most Lepidoptera wings are hydrophobic (Wagner et al. 1996), which prevents liquid water from penetrating into the photonic nanostructure because water droplets roll off the surface (Wagner et al. 1996), thus preventing the soaking of the wings in rain. Using the cooling method described herein, this difficulty can be easily avoided. Materials and Methods Eterusia taiwana (Lepidoptera: Zygaenidae) moths were obtained from the collections of the Laboratory of Natural Resource Conservation, Department of Biology and Institute of Life Science, National Sun Yat-Sen University, Taiwan. All other samples were obtained from the Lepidoptera collection of the Hungarian Natural History Museum. For structural investigation of the wings of Lepidoptera species, scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) were used. SEM samples were prepared by cutting off pieces of the wings, which were then attached to stubs with double-sided conductive tape. All samples were subsequently coated with 15 nm sputtered gold to allow for examination without charging. Cross-sectional TEM samples were prepared by embedding pieces of wings in special resin. Thin sections with a thickness of 70 nm were cut using an ultramicrotome and were transferred to copper grids. For optical characterisation, reflectance measurements were performed with an Avaspec 2048/2 fibre-optic spectrometer. A coaxial illuminator/pick-up fibre was used under normal incidence conditions. Measurements were performed with unpolarised light using a combined halogen-deuterium light source. An Avaspec diffuse white standard was used as a reference sample. This system allows accurate measurements in the 200 – 1000 nm wavelength range. Measurements performed under controlled cooling were combined with spectroscopic observation of the colour change. Three types of cooling apparatuses were used: (i) a custom-built Peltier cooler, which could be placed under the combined illuminator/pick-up fibre of the spectrometer; (ii) the deep freezer compartment of a commercially available refrigerator; and (iii) thin copper wires frozen into ice blocks within the deep freezer compartment. Peltier elements use the thermoelectric effect to directly convert electric power to a temperature difference. They are usually thin plates (3 mm in our experiments) and have two large sides (squares with 5 cm sides in our experiments) where the temperature difference can be created. Two Peltier elements in series were mounted on a CPU cooler fan for better heat dissipation. A shield was mounted around the Peltier elements to direct the airflow away from the samples and to ensure a uniform temperature. With this construction, a temperature of -5 ºC could be achieved in a normal room environment. Spectroscopic measurements were taken every second during the controlled cooling of the samples. An entire cooling cycle was typically completed over a time range of minutes. While Peltier coolers are not expected to be present in all laboratories working with butterflies, refrigerators are common in most of them. We performed the experiments using the deep freezer compartment, cooling the butterflies for approximately 15 minutes. Results Colour change in wings due to cooling The initial motivation for our work was provided by the experimental observation of colour changes in living E. taiwana moths. The moths were kept in a refrigerator at approximately 5 °C to extend their lifespan. The cooled living E. taiwana moths exhibit colour changes from green to dark brown to almost black when removed from the refrigerator. After being maintained at room temperature for a few hours, the moth regained its former colouration. The experiment was repeated with dried museum samples, but no colour changes were observed. When cooling the dried wing pieces that had been removed from the bodies using the Peltier cooler, colour changes could be easily observed (Fig. 1). The experiment was repeated under an optical microscope. Water condensation (small water drops) and freezing (ice) could be clearly observed on the surface of the Peltier cooler. Further experiments were performed with wing samples from other Lepidoptera species with photonic nanostructures in their scales that were cooled with Peltier elements [from Lycaenidae: Albulina metallica (blue dorsal wing surface), Callophrys rubi (green ventral wing surface), Cyanophrys remus (blue dorsal and green ventral wing surfaces) and Polyommatus daphnis (blue dorsal wing surface); and from Nymphalidae: Morpho aega (blue dorsal wing surface)]. As the width of the Peltier element is 5 cm, only small pieces of lepidopteran wings were used to allow simultaneous cooling of several samples. Colour changes could be easily observed on every sample (Fig. 2). A simpler cooling method involves the use of a household refrigerator (cooling temperature: -10 oC). Whole specimens can be cooled with an individual heat sink (glass microscope slides) mounted under each wing, allowing non-destructive measurements to be performed. Care has to be taken to provide good thermal contact between the microscope slide and the wing; a thin wire will suffice for this purpose, as shown in Fig. 3. Four butterflies were mounted on a large substrate with glass plates under each wing. The samples were cooled for 30 minutes in the refrigerator before being removed to an ambient room environment. The necessity of the heat sinks can be observed on butterflies in Fig. 3 a. and c. Colour changes cannot be observed near their bodies, where the wings are rapidly heated due to the absence of a cold thermal sink. As lepidopteran wings are not rigorously flat, some parts of the wings that are slightly closer to the cooled surface exhibit an earlier colour change than others. A sample of the butterfly Lycaena virgaureae was used for comparison, as it is not coloured by photonic nanoarchitectures, but by pigment (Vigneron et al. 2005b). It did not exhibit any colour change upon cooling. Spectroscopic measurements E. taiwana wing samples were mounted on the surface of the top Peltier element, and spectroscopic measurements were performed in situ during cooling (Fig. 4). The measurements began from a dry status (curve 1 in Fig. 4). After applying the previously determined voltage to the Peltier elements, the temperature dropped below the dewpoint in a few minutes (approx. 10 °C). When the dewpoint was reached and condensation of the water vapour began, the reflectance maximum shifted relatively rapidly to longer wavelengths (curve 2 in Fig. 4), and the green/blue moths became dark-brown/green. The samples were maintained at that temperature range for approximately 5 minutes after the shift, but the reflectance spectrum did not change. Then, the temperature was set to below 0 °C, and the wing pieces became completely frozen. After for waiting 5 minutes during which the position of the reflectance maximum did not change (curve 3 in Fig. 4), the applied voltage was turned off to allow the samples heat up to ambient temperature (23 °C). When melting began, the reflectance maximum shifted to shorter wavelengths with rapid progress (from curve 3 to curve 4 in Fig. 4) and stopped for approximately one minute when the ice in the wings was completely melted (0 °C). In a similar process, when the water in the samples began to evaporate, the reflectance maximum shifted towards shorter wavelengths and increased further in intensity until a colour close to the original colour was achieved. Full restoration of the wing colour was accomplished by drying overnight, indicating that a certain small but measurable fraction of water penetrated into the chitinous material. Similar spectroscopic measurements were performed on several other lepidopteran species, such as the well-characterised species C. remus (Kertész et al. 2006b) (Fig. 5). During cooling, this green species became brown. Additionally, the temperature of the Peltier cooler and the shift of the reflection maximum can be seen for the green ventral side of A. metallica in Fig. 1 of the Supplementary Material. Further experiments were performed on several species to investigate the time dependence of the colour change (see Fig. 2 of the Supplementary Material for an example). The samples were mounted on the Peltier cooler and cooled to approximately 10 °C, the temperature at which condensation can begin. After 300 – 400 seconds, the cooling apparatus was turned off, and the samples were allowed to warm up to ambient temperature. The time-dependent shift of the reflectance peaks was investigated. The resulting curves depend on the complex structural differences between the wing scale nanoarchitectures and vapour condensation rates. Further investigation with more precise control of environmental conditions will be required to obtain additional insight into the processes taking place. Repeated cooling – heating cycles were used to examine the long-term behaviour of the spectral shift. The samples were cooled (approx. 10 °C), and after the reflectance maximum had not changed for 5 minutes, the samples were heated to ambient temperature (23 °C); following an additional 5 minutes, the whole cycle was repeated. After approximately the third cycle, the butterflies completely lost their colour. Furthermore, chitin absorbed water, and the wings became malleable. Drying the samples for a few days fully restored the initial conditions of the wings. Observation of wing softening is not surprising, as this is the common preparation procedure for fixing the position of museum specimens. Local cooling by heat sink This cooling method can also be used to change the colour of lepidopteran wings locally. Cooling wings in specified small areas makes it possible to “write” on the wing surface. One method for this involves the use of a matrix built from miniature Peltier cells (each cell is used as a pixel), but a simpler method involves using cold wires below the wings. A cold wire cools a small area around it. If the temperature around the wire is lower than the dewpoint, condensation begins and changes the colour of the wing. In our experiments, one end of thin copper wires was frozen into ice blocks, while the other end was used to form horizontal characters above the ice blocks. The butterfly C. rubi was placed onto these characters, and the characters were shaped to provide the best thermal contact with the wing membrane (Fig. 6). Copper has very good heat conductivity; it can easily transfer heat from the wings to the ice blocks, keeping the area cool around the wires on the wings. The temperature in the cooled area can be set by adjusting the distance between the ice and the characters. If the temperature of the wires is sufficiently high to be close to the dewpoint, the coloured area around them will be narrower. If the wing is too close to the ice block, the temperature of the entire wing can be lower than the dewpoint; this causes the entire wing to change colour. The coloured area around the wires widens in time as water vapour condenses. The writing begins to appear a few seconds after placing the butterfly onto the wires, and it can be clearly observed after waiting another minute. Discussion Role of the heat sink in the colour change The difference between the dried and living E. taiwana moths in our first observations is that the body of the living specimens has a higher heat capacity due to its water content, and it is able to act as a heat sink. In a resting position, these moths keep their closed wings near their bodies, unlike many butterflies. The dried museum specimens have their wings positioned on the sides of their bodies, as is usual for museum exemplars. Additionally, they have lost most of the water content present in the living insect. Thus, they have a low heat capacity, so they cannot provide an adequate heat sink; the wings are heated to room temperature before significant vapour condensation could take place. This might be the reason that these specimens do not exhibit any colour change after being removed from the deep freezer compartment of the refrigerator (cooling temperature: -10 °C). If a large heat sink is provided by mounting microscope slides under the wings to increase the heat capacity of the combined system (wing + microscope slide), the wings can be kept cool for a sufficient amount of time to allow condensation to take place. Investigation of the possible biological significance of the colour changes of wings (when cooled below the dewpoint in an ambient atmosphere) with respect to the survival strategy of these species might be a very interesting subject for visual ecology, but it is outside the scope of this paper. Water penetration and wing softening As chitin absorbs water, it swells, thus altering the thickness of small structures made of chitin. This swelling effect can be observed in Figs. 4 and 5, where the reflection curves do not immediately return to the initial position, and the maxima have lower intensities after the cooling-heating cycle. However, overnight drying will fully recover the initial shape and position of the reflection curves. Because total swelling of the structures can be achieved by several cooling cycles (usually more than three), it is important that the reflection variations of several species are compared in the first cooling cycle to minimise the swelling effect. When preparing museum specimens, butterflies are usually softened in saturated water vapours for hours or days to cause them to become malleable so they can be set. This is a slow process, as water vapours have to penetrate into the volume of the specimen aided by daily temperature variations. Although a sample absorbs significant amounts of water, in most cases, no liquid water will be present on its surface. A relaxed status of the wings is achieved from the repeated cooling-heating cycles within a few minutes instead of the days required for saturated water vapours. Colour change and intensity variations in spectroscopic measurements The photonic crystal structures in lepidopteran wings are mainly constructed from chitin and air. Chitin has a moderate refractive index (n =1.56) (Vukusic et al. 1999). The position of the reflectance maximum (λmax) can be easily estimated with a simple equation: λmax=neffd/m (Vigneron et al. 2006), where neff is the average refractive index; d is the thickness of one period in a periodic structure; and m is an integer. When air (n = 1) is replaced with water (n = 1.33), the contrast of the refractive indices decreases, which in turn will modify the average refractive index value. This decrease of the refractive index contrast shifts the stop-band (i.e., the reflectance maximum) to higher wavelengths, as can be observed in the spectral measurements presented in Figs. 4 and 5 between the curves labelled 1 and 2 The reverse process can also be observed between the curves labelled 4 and 5 Freezing the samples generates quite different results. For C. remus, the position of the reflectance maximum is changed only moderately by freezing, while for E. taiwana, a clear spectral shift occurs. Structural differences are likely responsible for these different behaviours, as will be discussed below in the context of the SEM figures. The change in the intensity of the reflectance maximum during the cooling experiments depends on various parameters, such as the modifications induced in the surface geometry of the wing by wetting and freezing, the deformation of the chitin structures due to water absorption and the presence of water and ice on top of the scales. All of these parameters can differ from individual to individual. Due to this complex behaviour, a precise interpretation of the observed variations in intensity is beyond the scope of this paper. Effect of the nanoarchitecture during cooling During the simultaneous cooling experiments with the Peltier cooler (Fig. 2), it was observed that the wings of different Lepidoptera species exhibited slight differences in the time elapsed from the initiation of cooling until colour changes were clearly observed. This can be explained by taking into account the differences in the colour-generating nanoarchitectures in the scales. If the surface temperature drops below the dew point, condensation begins on the surface, and it is quite difficult to calculate the exact condensation rate. The diffusion and heat equations have to be solved in parallel, making the boundary conditions match (for example, see Kandlikar 1999). We will not attempt to solve this problem, but we will attempt to highlight some essential features of the process. Lepidoptera wings are quite complex structures, possessing a wing membrane and usually several layers of scales. Colour is measured in the upper part of the wing, and cooling is applied to the lower part. The transportation of heat from the upper scales to the lower scales is quite complex. Therefore, the interactions between different scales and between the scales and the membrane have to be taken into account. As the observation of colour change occurs on the upper part of the wing, we attempt to restrict our interpretation to this part. When water vapour begins to condense, it will decrease the relative humidity below the critical value; for further condensation, a new supply of wet air is required. The more open the structure is, the more easily the supply of wet air will penetrate it. The fastest colour changes were observed for C. remus, P. daphnis and C. rubi, which have similar nanoarchitectures, while slightly slower colour modifications were observed for A. metallica and E. taiwana. The scales of E. taiwana exhibit a quite different, more closed structure compared to the other species examined in this work; the surfaces of their scales have fewer and smaller holes than the scales of the investigated butterflies (Fig. 7). It is possible that in closed nanoarchitectures, such as those of Chrysiridia ripheus, the supply of wet air will be insufficient for colour changes to occur (Fig. 7d). The cooling experiments demonstrated this to be the case; no significant colour change could be observed in this species. Conclusions Our investigation of the rapid cooling of butterfly and moth wings in ambient air demonstrated that the wings of these species, which have photonic crystal-type nanoarchitectures with open structures, exhibit clear changes in coloration. Our data show that the durations and magnitudes of the colour changes and the ways in which they occurred were specific for certain structures (i.e., species), but small variations may also occur from individual to individual. In particular, in some closed photonic nanoarchitectures, such as those of the moth C. ripheus, a rapid colour change is not observed because water vapour cannot easily penetrate such closed structures. Therefore, if colour change is observed on cooling, this is a clear indication that the scales of the examined butterfly and moth species are coloured by photonic nanoarchitectures, while the very useful in the rapid screening of species to determine whether it may be worth absence of the colour change cannot be interpreted as unambiguous evidence that the scales are coloured only by pigments. In these cases, detailed structural (i.e., SEM and TEM) and spectral investigation may be required. Nevertheless, this quick and simple test can prove performing the time-consuming and expensive high-resolution characterisation procedures. At the same time, this screen provides information regarding the open (C. remus, C. rubi) or more closed (E. taiwana, A. metallica, C. ripheus) characters of the structures generating the structural colours. Cooling can be achieved using the deep freezer compartment of a common refrigerator if a large heat capacity heat sink is mounted in good thermal contact with the wings. This makes large-scale application of the method possible. It is worth pointing out that well- dried collection specimens will not exhibit a colour change without an appropriate heat sink under their wings. Another important advantage of cooling in the refrigerator may be that it is non-destructive; even rare exemplars could be examined in this way without risking damage to the samples. If repeated cooling and heating cycles are performed in succession, the wings can be softened in minutes. This rapid softening is attributed to repeated water vapour condensation taking place in the interior of the micro- and nanostructures of the scales and of the wing membranes. This will render the wings malleable without destruction of the exemplars or the need to keep the butterflies in saturated water vapours for several days. If local cooling is provided, such as by thin copper wires, it is possible to “write” on wings possessing structural colours. This colour change effect upon water vapour condensation could be used to construct a tuneable photonic crystal-based flat panel display. The colour change can be induced by the local condensation of water vapours, which are always present in ambient air. Each pixel should be mounted on a miniature Peltier element, and the temperature (and colour) could be set with active feedback. The similar process of capillary condensation has been employed for optical switching in porous optical superlattices (Barthelemy et al. 2007) and is used by the beetle Dynastes hercules to reversibly switch colour depending on the relative humidity of the environment (Rassart et al. 2008). Acknowledgements The work in Hungary was supported by OTKA grant PD83483. The collaboration of Hungarian and Taiwanese scientists was made possible by a joint agreement between the Hungarian Academy of Science and the NSC in Taiwan for mobility. K. Kertész gratefully acknowledges financial support from the János Bolyai Research Scholarship of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences. References Argyros A, Manos S, Mckenzie DR, Cox GC, Dwarte DM. 2002. Electron tomography and computer visualisation of a three-dimensional `photonic' crystal in a butterfly wing-scale. Micron 33: 483-487. Bálint Z, Kertész K, Piszter G, Vértesy Z, Biró LP. In press. The well-tuned blues: The role of structural colours as optical signals in the species recognition of a local butterfly fauna (Lepidoptera: Lycaenidae: Polyommatinae), Journal of the Royal Society Interface. Barthelemy P, Ghulinyan M, Gaburro Z, Toninelli C, Pavesi L, Wiersma DS. 2007. Optical switching by capillary condensation. Nature Photonics 1: 172-175. Berthier S. 2006. Iridescences: The Physical Colors of Insects, 1st edn. Springer. Berthier S, Boulenguez J, Bálint Z. 2007 Multiscaled polarization effects in Suneve coronata (Lepidoptera) and other insects: application to anti-counterfeiting of banknotes. Applied Physics A: Materials Science & Processing 86: 123-130. Biró LP, Kertész K, Vértesy Z, Bálint Z. 2008. Photonic nanoarchitectures occurring in butterfly scales as selective gas/vapor sensors. In: Creath K, Editor. The Nature of Light: Light in Nature II. Proc. of SPIE Vol. 7057: 705706 Biró LP, Kertész K, Horváth E, Márk GI, Molnár G, Vértesy Z, Tsai J-F, Kun A, Bálint Z, Vigneron J-P. 2010. Bioinspired artificial photonic nanoarchitecture using the elytron of the beetle trigonophorus rothschildi varians as a ‘blueprint’. Journal of the Royal Society Interface 7: 887-894. Biró LP & Vigneron JP. 2011. Photonic nanoarchitectures in butterflies and beetles: valuable sources for bioinspiration. Laser & Photonics Review 5, No. 1: 27-51. Florescu M, Torquato S & Steinhardt PJ. 2009. Designer disordered materials with large, complete photonic band gaps. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 106: 20658-63. Fordyce JA, Nice CC, Forister ML, Shapiro AM. 2002. The significance of wing pattern diversity in the Lycaenidae: mate discrimination by two recently diverged species. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 15: 871-879. Fratzl P. 2007. Biomimetic materials research: what can we really learn from nature’s structural materials? Journal of the Royal Society Interface 4: 637-642. Ghiradella HT, Radigan W. 1976. Development of butterfly scales: II. Struts lattices and surface tension. Journal of Morphology150: 279-298. Ghiradella HT, Butler MW. 2009. Many variations on a few themes: a broader look at development of iridescent scales (and feathers). Journal of the Royal Society Interface 6: S243-S251. Glover BJ and Whitney HM. 2010. Structural colour and iridescence in plants: the poorly studied relations of pigment colour. Annals of Botany 105 (4): 505-511. Huang J, Wang X, Wang ZL. 2006. Controlled Replication of Butterfly Wings for Achieving Tunable Photonic Properties. Nano Letters 6 (10): 2325-2331. Joannopoulos JD, Meade RD, Winn JN. 2008. Photonic Crystals: Molding the Flow of Light, 2nd edition. Princeton University Press. John S. 1987. Strong localization of photons in certain disordered dielectric superlattices. Physical Review Letters 58: 2486-2489. Kandlikar SG. 1999. Handbook of Phase Change: Boiling and Condensation. Taylor & Francis. Kemp DJ. 2007. Female butterflies prefer males bearing bright iridescent ornamentation. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 274: 1043-1047. Kertész K, Bálint Z, Vértesy Z, Márk GI, Lousse V, Vigneron JP, Biró LP. 2006a. Photonic crystal type structures of biological origin: Structural and spectral characterization. Current Applied Physics 6: 252-258. Kertész K, Bálint Z, Vértesy Z, Márk GI, Lousse V, Vigneron JP, Rassart M, Biró LP. 2006b. Gleaming and dull surface textures from photonic-crystal-type nanostructures in the butterfly Cyanophrys remus. Physical Review E 74: 021922. Kinoshita S & Yoshioka S. 2005. Structural colors in nature: the role of regularity and irregularity in the structure. Computer Physics Communications 6: 1442–1459. Kinoshita S. 2008. Structural Color in the Realm of Nature. Singapore, World Scientific. Kristensen NP. 2003. Lepidoptera, Moths and Butterflies: Morphology, Physiology and Development, Vol. 2. In: Handbook of Zoology, Vol. 4, Part 36. Walter de Gruyter. Liu F, Dong B, Zhao F, Hu X, Liu X & Zi J. 2011. Ultranegative angular dispersion of diffraction in quasiordered biophotonic structures. Optics Express 19: 7750-5. Mason CW. 1923. Structural Colors in Feathers. Journal of Physical Chemistry 27 (3): 201–251. Nijhout HF. 1991. The development and evolution of butterfly wing patterns. Smithsonian Institution Press Oliver JC, Robertson KA, Monteiro A. 2002. The significance of wing pattern diversity in the Lycaenidae: mate discrimination by two recently diverged species. Journal of Evolutionary Biology 15: 2369-2375. Parker AR. 2002. Natural Photonic Engineers. Materials Today 4: Sept. 26-31. Poladian L, Wickham S, Lee K, Large MCJ. 2009. Iridescence from photonic crystals and its supression in butterfly scales. Journal of the Royal Society Interface 6: S233-S242. Potyrailo RA, Ghiradella H, Vertiatchikh A, Dovidenko K, Cournoyer JR & Olson E. 2007. Morpho butterfly wing scales demonstrate highly selective vapour response. Nature Photonics 1: 123-128. Rassart M, Colomer JF, Tabarrant T and Vigneron JP. 2008. Diffractive hygrochromic effect in the cuticle of the hercules beetle Dynastes Hercules. New Journal of Physics 10: 033014. Scoble MJ. 1995. The Lepidoptera: form, function, and diversity, 2nd ednition. Oxford University Press. Seago AE, Brady P, Vigneron, JP, Schultz TD. 2009. Gold bugs and beyond: a review of iridescence and structural colour mechanisms in beetles (Coleoptera). Journal of the Royal Society Interface 6: S165-S184. Shawkey MD, Morehouse NI, Vukusic P. 2009a. A protean palette: colour materials and mixing in birds and butterflies. Journal of the Royal Society Interface 6: S221-S231. Shawkey MD, Saranathan V, Palsdottir H, Crum J, Ellisman MH, Auer M, Prum RO. 2009b. Electron tomography, three-dimensional Fourier analysis and colour prediction of a three-dimensional amorphous biophotonic nanostructure. Journal of the Royal Society Interface 6: S213-S220. Srinivasarao M. 1999. Nano-Optics in the Biological Word: Beetles, Butterflies, Birds and Moths. Chemical Reviews 99: 1935-1961. Vértesy Z, Bálint Z, Kertész K, Vigneron JP, Lousse V, Biró LP. 2006. Wing scale microstructures and nanostructures in butterflies--natural photonic crystals. Journal Of Microscopy 224: 108-10. Vigneron JP, Rasart M, Vértesy Z, Kertész K, Sarazzin M, Biró LP, Ertz D, Lousse V. 2005a. Optical structure and function of the white filamentary hair covering the edelweiss bracts. Physical Review E 71: 011906. Vigneron JP, Lousse V, Biró LP, Vértesy Z, Bálint Z. 2005b. Reflectance of topologically disordered photonic-crystal films. In: Adibi A, Lin SY, Scherer A, Editors. Photonic crystal materials and devices III, vol. 5733. Proceedings of SPIE, pp. 308–315. Bellingham, WA: SPIE. Vigneron JP, Rassart M, Vandenbem C, Lousse V, Deparis O, Biró LP, Dedouaire D, Cornet A, Defrance P. 2006. Spectral filtering of visible light by the cuticle of metallic woodboring beetles and microfabrication of a matching bioinspired material. Physical Review E 73: 041905-1. Vukusic P, Sambles JR, Lawrence CR, Wootton RJ. 1999. Quantified interference and diffraction in single Morpho butterfly scales. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 266: 1403–1411. Vukusic P, Sambles JR. 2003. Photonic structures in biology. Nature 424: 852-855. Vukusic P, Stavenga DG. 2009. Physical methods for investigating structural colours in biological systems. Journal of the Royal Society Interface 6: S133-S148. Wagner T, Neinhuis C, Barthlott W. 1996. Wettability and Contaminability of Insect Wings as a Function of Their Surface Sculptures. Acta Zoologica 77: 213-225. Welch VL, Vigneron JP. 2007. Beyond butterflies – the diversity of biological photonic crystals. Optical and Quantum Electronics 39: 295-303. Wilts BD, Leertouwer HL, Stavenga DG. 2009. Imaging scatterometry and microspectrophotometry of lycaenid butterfly wing scales with perforated multilayers. Journal of the Royal Society Interface 6: S185-S192. Yablonovitch E. 1987. Inhibited Spontaneous Emission in Solid-State Physics and Electronics. Physical Review Letters 20: 2059-2062. Zhang W, Zhang D, Fan T, Gu J, Ding J, Wang H, Guo Q, and Ogawa H. 2009. Novel Photoanode Structure Templated from Butterfly Wing Scales. Chemistry of Materials 21: 33-40. Zollinger H. 2003. Color Chemistry: Syntheses, Properties and Applications of Organic Dyes and Pigments, 3rd revised edition. Wiley, Wenheim. URE CAPT FIGU TIONS a taiwana du of Eterusia Figur ue to water v n the wings r change on re 1: Colour vapour hindwing su hite dorsal h ue-black-wh cooling. Blu caused by c nd freezing c densation an cond urface and g green-white e dorsal fore ewing surfac ce. a) At ro om tempera ature (22 °C C); b) after v vapour cond densation on nto the struc ctures (10 °C C); c) after freezing of the wings ( (-5 °C); d) a after all of the w vaporated fr water had ev ature, when om tempera eating to roo ing and rehe cooli rom the wing gs. efore cooling ra wings be f Lepidopter of pieces of consisting o ple display re 2: A simp Figur g (left) and a after cooling g (right). Co olour chang ges can be o observed du e to water v vapour cond densation om: a) Albu ulina wings are fro eces of the w les. The pie s of the scal ic structures the photoni onto meta ); c) Cyanop aega (blue d b) Morpho a allica (blue d phrys dorsal wing) g surface); b dorsal wing remu us (green ve ; d) Polyom mmatus daph hnis (blue d ); e) Cyanop phrys entral wing) dorsal wing) g) Eterusia t ys rubi (gree f) Callophry us (blue dor remu taiwana sal wing); f wing); and g en ventral w (blue e dorsal win ng). es with phot b), c) Specie erator. a), b n the refrige optera speci re 3: Lepido Figur ies cooled i tonic d d) a speci struc ctures in the eir scales an ies without photonic str ructures in i its scales. C Colour ecessity of t s, and the ne nostructures photonic nan ecies with p seen for spe nges can be chan the heat can be obse Under not change. colour did n where the c of a) and c), the bodies o erved near t sink ident not change wn in d) did ments show ured by pig tterfly colou ions, the bu tical conditi e colour. a) Ca allophrys ru ubi, b) Cyan nophrys rem mus, c) Poly yommatus be ellargus, d) ) Lycaena virga aureae. Figur s of the re 4: Spectr ral measurem ments on th he blue/dors sal a) and gr reen/ventral l b) surfaces a taiwana. T oth Eterusia tionary refl how the stat ed curves sh The numbere gs of the mo wing ectance (10 °C); 3. f y status (23 tages: 1. dry us cooling st es in variou curve °C); 2. con ndensation ( freezing (-5 °C C); 4. melti ing (0 °C); a and 5. evapo oration proc cesses. es of the al (b) surfac green/dorsa tral (a) and g he blue/vent ments on th ral measurem re 5: Spectr Figur mus. The num nophrys rem tterfly Cyan he stationary ves show th mbered curv gs of the but wing y (23 °C); 2. . dry status us stages: 1. ves in variou ctance curv reflec condensatio on (10 °C); 3. freez zing (-5 °C) ; 4. melting g (0 °C); and d 5. evapora ation proces sses. re 6: Callop phrys rubi w were used t to form char Figur was placed o onto cooled d wires that racters. form charac was used to other end w ce, and the rozen into ic wires was fr end of the w One cters (c). The c egin. The im rea, where t rrounding ar cold wires c cool the sur the condens sation can b mages the sample fter putting 2-3 seconds were e collected 2 (a) and 1 m minute (b) af s onto the w wires. except for f) f), where ght: TEM, e eft: SEM; rig tterflies. Le es of the but TEM image re 7: SEM/T Figur ys remus (bl Cyanophry lue dorsal w re 2 m. a) scale bars ar mages. All s are SEM im both wing ace); b) Call lophrys rub bi (green dor surfa rsal wing su urface, TEM M image is r reprinted fro om phnis (blue mmatus dap 6); c) Polyo g surface); d dorsal wing adigan 1976 adella & Ra Ghira d) face); e) Alb heus (blue-g ysiridia riph Chry bulina metal llica (blue d al wing surf green ventra dorsal f) Eterusia t taiwana (gre wing g surface); f een dorsal w wing surface e). Electronic supplementary material Cooling on Freezing on Cooling and freezing off F.S1: Position of the reflection maximum (gray line with symbols) on the green ventral side of A. metallica during one whole cooling cycle (i.e., cooled below the dewpoint, then frozen and then the cooling apparatus was turned off). The temperature of the top surface of the Peltier cooler next to the wing (black line) was measured during one whole cooling cycle (i.e., condensation, freezing, melting and evaporation). : Time dep F.S2 ecies (M. ee blue spe xima in thre lection max in the refl f the shifts pendence o s) and in a s is, C. remus a, P. daphni aega ctures (gree hotonic struc h closed ph species with en part of C. rip pheus). The t 350 sec e cooling ap pparatus wa as turned on n at 50 sec, a and it was t turned off a the three (gray y lines). Rel latively fast t shifts of th he reflectio n maxima c could be ob bserved for h faster shi n, and much s turned on paratus was cooling app after the c butterflies blue ifts were obser otonic struc h closed pho species with d off. The s t was turned rved after it ctures exhib bited very swelling slow w and small shifts in bo th cases, wh hich could b be interpret ted as being g due to the e (epicuticle pper surface s in the up open holes e and/or the he structure of th e very few e) of the nano ostructure (s see Fig. 7d). .
1805.11312	3	1805	2018-09-20T21:34:54	A new method for protein structure reconstruction from NOESY distances	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.BM" ]	Protein structure reconstruction from Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) experiments largely relies on computational algorithms. Recently, some effective low-rank matrix completion (MC) methods, such as ASD and ScaledASD, have been successfully applied to image processing, which inspires us to apply the methods to reconstruct protein structures. In this paper, we present an efficient method to determine protein structures based on experimental NMR NOESY distances. ScaledASD algorithm is used in the method with several post-procedures including chirality refinement, distance lower (upper) bound refinement, force field-based energy minimization (EM) and water refinement. By comparing several metrics in the conformation evaluation on our results with Protein Data Bank (PDB) structures, we conclude that our method is consistent with the popularly used methods. In particular, our results show higher validities in Procheck dihedral angles G-factor. Furthermore, we compare our calculation results with PDB structures by examining the structural similarity to X-ray crystallographic structures in a special dataset. The software and its MATLAB source codes are available in https://github.com/xubiaopeng/PRASD	physics.bio-ph	physics	A new method for protein structure reconstruction from NOESY distances Z. Li, S. Li, X. Wei, X. Peng, Q. Zhao ABSTRACT Protein structure reconstruction from Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) experiments largely relies on computational algorithms. Recently, some effective low-rank matrix completion (MC) methods, such as ASD and ScaledASD, have been successfully applied to image processing, which inspires us to apply the methods to reconstruct protein structures. In this paper, we present an efficient method to determine protein structures based on experimental NMR NOESY distances. ScaledASD algorithm is used in the method with several post-procedures including chirality refinement, distance lower (upper) bound refinement, force field-based energy minimization (EM) and water refinement. By comparing several metrics in the conformation evaluation on our results with Protein Data Bank (PDB) structures, we conclude that our method is consistent with the popularly used methods. In particular, our results show higher validities in Procheck dihedral angles G-factor. Furthermore, we compare our calculation results with PDB structures by examining the structural similarity to X-ray crystallographic structures in a special dataset. The software and its MATLAB source codes are available in https://github.com/xubiaopeng/PRASD. KEYWORDS: Protein structure reconstruction; NOESY distance restraints; matrix completion. INTRODUCTION The characterization of three-dimensional protein structures has been a topic of great interest for decades since the knowledge of the protein structures is essential to understand the protein functions, which could lead to further pharmaceutical and medical applications. Currently, X-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy (1) are two major experimental methods for protein structure determination. Unlike X-ray crystallography, NMR spectroscopy is not a "microscope with atomic resolution", but rather provides a network of distance measurements between spatially proximate hydrogen atoms (2); however, the introduction of NMR spectroscopy to characterize protein structure is a breakthrough because the method enables the identification of the protein structure in the aqueous solution, which is closer to the states of the proteins in cells. Since the first NMR-determined protein structure was reported in 1985 (1), thousands of protein structures have been measured by NMR spectroscopy, which are available in the 1 Protein Data Bank (PDB) (3). The typical NMR structure determination approach includes the following steps: peak picking from NMR spectra, chemical shift assignment (spectral assignment), geometric restraint assignment, and structural calculation (4). An important parameter in NMR experiments is Nuclear Overhauser Effect (NOE), which is used to generate distance restraints because the intensity of the NOE signal depends on the inverse sixth power of the internuclear distance (5). The NOE intensity between two atoms is reflected in the Nuclear Overhauser Effect Spectroscopy (NOESY), whose assignment relies on the knowledge of chemical shifts of nuclei. However, not all H-H distances can be measured accurately in the NMR experiments because the peak intensities corresponding to the long distances (larger than 5 Å) are too weak to be distinguished from the noise level in the experiment. Thus, usually just a network of short distances is available in the protein NMR structure measurement. Since NMR measurements only provide implicit information about the protein structure, complicated computational algorithms have to be used to determine the protein structure in NMR experiment. Molecular dynamics (MD) incorporated with simulated annealing (SA) algorithm is one of the most widely used methods in protein NMR structure determination. MD (6) simulation is based on classical mechanics and often used to study the folding pathway and structure prediction (7-9), while SA (10) is a heuristic global optimization method to find the conformation at energy minimum. The SA procedure is usually not very fast. The performance of SA in different NP-hard problems was evaluated by Johnson et al. (11,12). MD/SA hybrid methods of XPLOR (13,14), DYANA (15), CYANA (16) and ARIA (17) were also implemented. The XPLOR is a method built on the MD simulation package CHARMM (18). The method can be used to search the conformations in Cartesian coordinate space. In contrast, DYANA and its improved version CYANA work in torsion angle space and hence have better calculation speed. ARIA can work in either torsion angle space or Cartesian coordinate space, but the algorithms are optimized for ambiguous distance restraints and violation analysis. Euclidean distance matrix completion (EDMC) method is a different protein reconstruction method which mainly relies on the distance matrix obtained from NMR measurements. Compared to the MD/SA method, EDMC method uses fewer assumptions in energy function. The pioneer work of protein NMR by EDMC was done by Braun et al. in 1981 (19). Other efficient ways, such as EMBED (20) and DISGEO (21), were developed by Havel's group in 1983 and 1984, respectively. Later, semidefinite programming (SDP) was used to solve the EDMC problems by using Gram matrix instead of distance matrix, including DAFGAL proposed by Biswas et al. (22), DISCO proposed by Leung and Toh (23) and SPROS by Alipanahi et al. (24). Here we introduce a new matrix completion algorithm for protein structure reconstruction from NOESY distance restraints. By comparing our reconstructed results with PDB structures, we demonstrate that the method is valid and comparable with existing methods. The paper is organized as follows: In Section 2, we describe our method for the NMR protein structure reconstruction, including the establishment of the initial matrix, 2 matrix completion, distance bound refinement, chirality refinements, energy minimization (EM) optimization and water refinement. In Section 3, we test the validity of the method by comparing our calculation results with the PDB structures from several different aspects. Finally, the conclusion and future work are presented in Section 4. METHODS Similar to the method for image recovery, the protein structure can be expressed as a distance matrix in the protein structure reconstruction, where each element is the distance of a pair of atoms. In this distance matrix, some elements can be known from the chemical properties, such as covalent bonds, and the NOESY distance restraints. On the other hand, additional refinements including the refinements on chirality and energetic stability in solution have to be applied to the recovered distance matrix due to the special properties of the protein structure. Based on the above considerations, we render the ScaledASD matrix completion algorithm, a successful algorithm in image processing, to determine the distance matrix from NOESY data, followed by further procedures to refine the structure. Initial distance matrix establishment To determine the protein structure using the matrix completion, firstly we need to establish the initial distance matrix. The nonzero elements of this matrix stand for the known atomic distances. There are two types of known distances that can be directly filled into the matrix: 1) the distances measured in the NMR experiment, i.e., the distance restraints from NOESY data; 2) the distances between the coplanar atoms and all the covalent bonds. Although the coplanar and covalent bond distances can be varied with different residues, for a specific residue type, they can be considered as constants since the fluctuations are very small (25, 26). However, a study has shown that it is insufficient to determine the structure uniquely with the above known distances (27). It was proposed in the study that the lower bound of the sample number m in matrix completion theory should , where n and r are the dimension and the rank of the matrix, satisfy m Cnr  log 10 n respectively. The value of constant C is a certain positive number that is not exactly known. In our protein distance matrix completion, we can estimate this number by trials and tests. In detail, starting from a distance matrix of a protein with known structure, we sample Cnrlog10n elements uniformly and reconstruct the distance matrix using these samplings, where C is tested with different values from 0.5 to 5. For each C value we run recovery procedure ten times and calculate the average RMSD. The relation between the RMSD and C value is shown in Fig. S1 in Supplemental Information, indicating that the protein structure (distance matrix) is well recovered when C is larger than 2. We take the lower limit C = 2. For a typical NMR protein with 76 residues, such as 1G6J, atom number n~1200 and rank r = 5 for Euclidean Distance Matrix (EDM) (28), we need at least m~36000 to rebuild the matrix uniquely. In contrast, the NOESY data from NMR has only 1291 distances. 3 Together with all the covalent bonds and coplanar distances, there are 13488 distances in total, which is still far smaller to meet the matrix completion requirement. To solve this problem, we add some distance elements estimated by the triangle inequality (29). In detail, assuming that there are N atoms named A1, A2, A3…AN, the boundary of an unknown distance AiAj can be obtained from the known distances by the following conditions: Max(AiAk - AkAj ) ≤AiAj ≤ Min (AiAk + AkAj) (for all k), where Ak includes all the atoms whose distances AiAk and AkAj are known. In this paper, we just take the upper boundary as the corresponding element in the initial distance matrix for simplicity. Once the distance AiAj is known in this way, we repeat this procedure including AiAj as the known elements to determine other unknown distances until all the distance matrix elements are determined. Finally, the initial distance matrix is established by putting the following three types of distances together as described in Fig. 1: all the covalent/coplanar distances and a sampled subset of the distances estimated from the triangle inequality. the experimental NOESY data, all FIGURE 1 The process of establishing an initial distance matrix. Low-rank matrix completion Matrix Completion (MC) (28, 30) problems are usually solved by minimizing the rank of matrices or minimizing the nuclear norm. However, both methods are time consuming (27,31). Recently, effective methods of alternating steepest descent (ASD) and scaled variant ScaledASD (32) are reported to solve the matrix completion problem directly with specified rank of matrix rather than using the nuclear norm minimization. These approaches were used to update the solutions by incorporating an exact line-search based on the factorization of the variable. ScaledASD is an accelerated version of ASD algorithm (32). In this paper, we only focus on ScaledASD. Supposing we have a matrix Z0 with some elements are known in 4 advance and the complete matrix Z can be factorized into two parts X and Y, i.e., Z=XY. The ScaledASD algorithm can find the proper factors X and Y so that the corresponding elements in matrix Z (Z=XY) are closest to the pre-known elements in Z0. The flow chart of ScaledASD algorithm is shown in Fig. 2, where f(X,Y)=1/2PΩ(Z0)-PΩ(XY)F the matrix PΩ(Z0)-PΩ(XY) and PΩ is a sampling operator feching the known elements. The optimization loop stops when the solutions get converged, and we get the completed matrix at the end. the Frobenius norm of stands for FIGURE 2 The flow chart of ScaledASD algorithm. Once the distance matrix is recovered, we can easily reconstruct the coordinates from the Gram matrix following the reference (33). Distance bound refinement In fact, the distance estimation by triangle inequality introduces certain errors into the initial distance matrix, which leads to inaccuracy in the structure calculation. Meanwhile, because the presence of the internal motions and chemical exchange may diminish the strength of the NOE signal (2), the interatomic distances obtained by NOE experiment tend to be larger than the actual distances. Therefore, we perform a distance bound refinement on the raw structure obtained from matrix completion to reduce the above errors. For this purpose, we take the refinement procedure used in reference (24), i.e., using nonlinear unconstrained optimization method BFGS (34) to minimize the following function (  X )   E   L  i j E ( , )   i j L ( , )    x i  g x i 2 x j  e ij   x j  l ij   2  U  i j U ( , )  f  x i  x j  u ij 2    R  i 1  x i 2 , (1) where f  ( ) max(0,  )  and g  ( ) min(0,  )   . The sets E, U, and L represent equality constraints, upper bounds and lower bounds, respectively; and 5    L U E , , are their relevant coefficients. We take the same setting for parameters E  , 2 1 U  , 1L  and    R X (  X ) (0) 25 (  (0) )  R  0     L 1,    U R E    0 25 1  n i 1  . 2 (0) x i (2) where 1 1   is a parameter. Similar to the procedures in reference (24), we set the covalent bond lengths and distances among atoms on peptide plane as the equality constraints and a fraction of the sum of the van der Waals radii of atoms between non-bonded atom pairs as the lower bound to the corresponding distances: r  (  (3) ), vdw d ij r i vdw j where  [0,1] .  is typically around 0.85 (35). The values of the van der Waals radii are given in Table 1 (36, 37). However, we have different upper bounds in our algorithm: we include both the measured data from the NOE experiment and the estimated values from the triangle inequality as the upper bounds. As a result, by minimizing Eq.(1) starting from the rebuilt structure in Section 2.2, we actually make a complement on the upper limit approximation in both NOESY distance restraints and the triangle inequality estimation in the initial distance matrix establishment stage. TABLE 1 Atom vdwr ( Å) Van der Waals radii for different atoms O 1.4 H 1.0 C 1.7 N 1.5 Chirality refinements Chirality is a geometric property of some molecules with mirror symmetry. As shown in Fig. 3, although molecules A and B have the same distance matrix, they are structurally different. In fact, the distance matrix does not provide any information about the global chirality, and hence the chirality refinement has to be performed additionally after the structure has been reconstructed from the distance matrix. Here, we use the same chirality refinement method as in reference (24). In detail, two types of chirality are considered: 1) The chirality of each residue: the residues in biological protein are mostly left handed (L-type) as shown in Fig.3 B. If the chirality of a residue is right handed, we just simply exchange positions of groups COOH and NH2. 2) The chirality of the Ramachandran angle  : Most of the  values should be negative. If the number of 0  , we flip the structure by taking the opposite sign of all the x-components of the coordinates. is larger than the number of 0  6 FIGURE 3 enantiomer and (B) stands for the correct one in amino acids. Schematic diagrams of chiral molecular structures. (A) stands for the incorrect EM optimization and water refinement The protein structure has to be energetically stable in solution. For this requirement, we perform a force field-based EM optimization followed by water refinement on our reconstructed structure after the above geometrical refinements. The purpose of EM optimization is to get rid of the non-physical bonds and angles ， and to find the configuration corresponding to the local minimum in energy landscape. The TIP3P water model and the AMBER99SB-ILDN (38) force field-based energy functions are used in the calculation. With the EM optimized structure, we carry out the process of thin-layer water refinement (39) where a simple annealing simulation on energy is used to obtain the energetically favored structure in solution. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION We randomly picked ten proteins with different sizes and topologies measured by NMR in the PDB references as listed in Table 2. Table 2 also lists the most reliably well-defined regions by checking the NMR experimental report for each protein in PDB. For the input, we extract the NOESY distances from DOCR database in the NMR Restraints Grid (40,41), which is just a well-parsed database based on the NMR experimental data file in PDB. Then, we do a sampling from the distances estimated from the triangle inequality as described in Sec 2.1 at the ratio of 50/n, where n is the number of atoms. The sampled elements are input into the initial distance matrix. Recalling that the rank of a Euclidean distance matrix consistent with a protein structure is only 5, we notice that under current sampling ratio the lower bound requirement for matrix completion is satisfied for any protein with the number of atoms less than 10,000. The distance matrix of protein structure is recovered with ScaledASD method, followed by the geometrical refinements, EM optimization and finally the water refinement. We notice that the EM optimization could be force field dependent. However, -- AMBER99SB-ILDN (38), CHARMM36m (42) and OPLSAA (43), the reconstructed structure is robust to the force field selection. In the Supplemental Information, Table S1 shows the Cα RMSD in the well-defined region between structures obtained from different force fields. Therefore, we always use AMBER99SB-ILDN force field in our EM optimization stage in the reconstruction. tested with three different as we force fields 7 Clearly, our reconstructed structure is not unique due to the random sampling in establishing the initial distance matrix. For each protein, we repeat our reconstruction 20 times. It is found that the average Cα RMSD in well-defined region between two arbitrary structures from different runs is in the range 0.1~0.5Å, depending on the number of atoms, showing clear convergence. All our tests were completed on a desktop computer with a 3.4GHz processor and 8GB RAM. The matrix completion and structural refinements were performed with the software MATLAB 2016a; EM optimization and the water refinement were performed with GROMACS (44) and XPLOR (13), respectively. Depending on the sizes of the proteins in the test, the computation time for all our calculations varies from 10 minutes to 1.5 hours. Information about ten test proteins Description Topology α+β β Atoms Residues Well-defined region in PDB 1-70 8-87 1228 1114 76 80 β 1267 125 2-125 Software DYANA XPLOR CYANA α/β 1648 104 9-70; 77-81; 89-101 NMRDRAW; NMRPIPE TABLE 2 PDB ID 1G6J 1B4R 2K62 Ubiquitin PKD domain 1 Liver fatty acid-binding protein Yeast ribosomal protein UPF0339 protein SO3888 2L3O Murine 1CN7 2K49 2GJY interleukin-3 Tensin 1 PTB Domain 2YT0 2K7H Stress-induced proteinSAM22 Amyloid beta A4 protein Apolipoprotein E 2L7B α+β α/β α+β α+β 1823 118 3-111 α 1980 127 43-138 2196 144 2337 157 5-61; 67-87; 95-104; 111-137 2-157 AutoStructure; CYANA CYANA; XPLOR DYANA XPLOR 2602 176 18-30; 61-176 CYANA α 4792 307 3-181; 186-200; 209-281;287-296 CYANA Evaluation and comparison on reconstructed proteins RMSD on well-defined region and TM-score comparison To evaluate the performance of our method, we calculate the Cα RMSD values between our reconstruction results and the first model in their corresponding PDB structures in the well-defined regions as listed in Table 2. There are eight out of ten proteins with RMSD < 2 Å, indicating that our reconstruction is generally successful. 8 For the two proteins with RMSD > 2 Å, one is just 2.08 Å, while the other is 2.21 Å but with more than 300 residues. Reference (45) has shown that RMSD is length dependent, i.e., larger protein tends to have larger RMSD with the same structural similarity. To properly compare the structural similarity for the protein pairs with different lengths, we employ a length independent quantity TM-score (45). TM-score is a number in the range (0,1], where 1 indicates a perfect match between two structures and 0 indicates a complete mismatch. Usually, a score higher than 0.5 indicates that the two structures have the same fold in SCOP/CATH (46). TM-scores between our calculations and PDB structures are listed in the third column in Table 3, showing very high similarity between them. Finally, we show the corresponding protein structures in Fig. 4, where the red represents the first model structure of the PDB references, and the blue represents one model of our calculated structure. TABLE 3 The Cα RMSD in well-defined region and TM-scores for ten proteins. The RMSD and TM scores are calculated between the reconstructed ensemble and the first model of the corresponding PDB structure. The standard deviation denotes the uncertainty of the reconstructed structures PDB ID 1G6J 1B4R 2K62 1CN7 2K49 2L3O 2GJY 2K7H 2YT0 2L7B RMSD /well-defined (Å) 1.00±0.10 1.57±0.16 1.81±0.14 1.53±0.13 1.52±0.10 2.08±0.19 1.63±0.09 1.85±0.22 0.95±0.07 2.21±0.14 TM-score 0.87±0.01 0.85±0.02 0.86±0.01 0.79±0.02 0.86±0.02 0.68±0.01 0.80±0.01 0.91±0.02 0.78±0.01 0.88±0.01 9 FIGURE 4 Superimposition of original PDB structures (red) and calculated structures (blue). Structure Validation using MPscore and PSVS To further validate our reconstruction method, we utilize the Molprobity (47) and protein structure validation software suite (PSVS) (48) to evaluate the whole proteins reconstructed from our algorithm. In Molprobity, there is a quantity MPscore for assessing the overall quality of the prediction structure from the statistical viewpoint. Lower values indicate better models. PSVS is another NMR standard validation tool to check both the geometric knowledge-based validation and the fit between the structure and the experimental data. For NMR structures, there are five geometric validation scores that are noteworthy: Molprobity clash-score (47), Procheck Phi-Psi and all dihedral angle G-factor (49), Verify3D score (50) and ProsaII score (51). In PSVS, they are all rescaled to their corresponding Z-scores. Usually a higher Z-score indicates a better model and a positive Z-score indicates that the analyzed structure is better than the typical high-resolution X-ray structure. PSVS report also gives the number of violations and maximum violation distance compared to the NOE experimental result. Here we normalize the violation number into violation percentage using the number of total restraints for comparison among proteins. Table 4 lists all these quantities in both our calculation results and the corresponding PDB entries for comparison. As shown in Table 4, our model generally performs better on Procheck Phi-Psi and all dihedral angle G-factor. On some other evaluation metrics such as ProsaII, MPscore and Molprobity clash-score, our calculation results are comparable with the corresponding PDB deposits. On violation percentage and the maximum violation distance, our calculation results are slightly worse than the PDB deposits. 10 1G6J 2K62 2K49 2L3O 1B4R 1CN7 Ref Cal Ref Cal Ref Cal Ref Cal Ref Cal Ref Cal Ref Cal 2K7H Ref Cal Ref Cal Ref Cal 2GJY 2YT0 2L7B 3.53 2.70 4.39 3.53 3.46 3.43 2.80 2.80 2.11 2.56 4.29 4.04 3.71 3.29 2.95 3.08 2.98 3.23 3.82 4.13 -0.96 -0.16 -1.93 -1.77 -0.80 -0.96 0.16 -0.64 -2.41 -2.25 -3.85 -3.85 -1.44 -2.89 -0.32 0.00 -0.96 -1.28 -3.05 -3.21 0.79 0.87 -1.94 -1.82 -0.54 -0.70 0.17 -0.62 -1.41 -1.36 -1.32 -1.49 -0.79 -1.28 -0.12 -0.21 0.41 0.37 -0.95 -1.41 -1.49/-4.55 -0.59/-1.30 -4.45/-7.75 -3.03/-5.26 -2.52/-4.26 -1.38/-3.43 -0.87/-2.60 -0.79/-1.95 -0.87/-0.71 -0.55/-1.06 -0.75/-5.32 0.24/-2.90 -2.28/-4.79 -1.93/-3.43 -0.35/-0.59 -0.83/-2.07 -1.97/-3.43 -0.71/-1.42 -0.47/-3.90 0.63/-1.89 Viol./ Cons. (%) 0.49 5.38 5.91 20.29 36.82 26.18 2.71 10.45 9.78 11.39 17.72 24.73 4.74 11.47 14.48 16.19 22.33 23.65 MolP- robity Clash- score -5.77 -2.27 -23.36 -6.16 -1.79 -8.05 0.45 -2.09 -0.73 -1.90 -11.70 -11.07 -4.01 -4.23 -11.53 -4.14 -2.67 -3.24 -3.98 -12.45 Max dist. viol. (Å) 0.41 2.58 2.29 2.74 7.06 3.22 1.23 2.71 2.51 2.78 3.65 4.16 1.08 3.68 4.73 2.77 2.07 2.27 TABLE 4 MPscores, the Z-score and RMS of distance violation/constraint of test protein structures Protein ID ProsaII MP- score Verify 3D Procheck (phi-psi/all) 21.01 26.56 3.22 4.03 Comparison on the protein structure properties In Sec 3.1, we have evaluated our results and compared them with the corresponding PDB structures using the scores provided in protein validation tools including Molprobity and PSVS. All of the results are in the overall evaluation scores. For most proteins, the local geometrical properties are sometimes more important in their biological functions. In this section, we evaluate our results on two local geometrical properties on backbone: the secondary structure and the Ramachandran Plot. In the following, we just take one arbitrary PDB structure 2K7H as an example. For the other proteins, similar results are obtained and listed in Supplemental Information. Secondary structure comparison Protein secondary structure is the 3D form of local segments, which is maintained by hydrogen bonds formed between carbonyl and amide groups on the skeleton. The secondary structure reflects the stability of protein structure. Since α-helices and β-strands are the most common secondary structures, we compared the regions of α-helices and β-strands in our calculated structures with the secondary structures in PDB references, respectively. The secondary structures are classified by DSSP 11 algorithm (52). We select 2K7H as an example and show the secondary structures from our calculation results and the comparisons with the PDB structures in Fig. 5. Clearly, the secondary structures in the calculation results are almost the same as in PDB models except the very short segment 75-77, which is identified as loop in our calculation result but helix in the PDB structure. The similar comparisons for other proteins are shown in Fig. S2 in Supplemental Information. FIGURE 5 The secondary structure regions of 2K7H structure calculated based on ScaledASD and the PDB reference structure. Ramachandran Plot comparison Ramachandran Plot is a way to visualize energetically allowed regions for backbone dihedral angles  and  of amino acid residues in protein structures (53). Usually there are three regions in Ramachandran Plot: favorable regions, allowed regions and , ) in favorable regions indicate that the disallowed regions. The combinations of ( results are without steric clashes; allowed regions indicate that the results are allowed even if the steric constraints are slightly relaxed; and the disallowed regions indicates that the results involve steric hindrance. We calculated the percentages of favourable and disallowed regions in the Ramachandran Plot of the calculated structures by MolProbity (47). The results of our calculation and the PDB structures are both listed in Table 5, where we can see that the percentages in favourable region of our calculated structures are comparable to the reference structures. To further confirm that the Ramachandran angles of our calculated structure are in the correct region, we compared the Ramachandran plots as shown in Fig. 6, where we can see the clear consistence between our calculation result and the PDB structure, except that there are two outliers in our calculation result. TABLE 5 The percentages of the favourable and disallowed regions in Ramachandran Plot for the ten calculated protein structures as well as PDB references Protein ID 1G6J 1B4R 2K62 Favourable (calculation) 94.66±2.30 81.80±3.85 87.80±1.94 Favourable (reference) 92.23±2.40 83.14±1.87 87.69±2.46 Disallowed (reference) 0.63±0.91 3.91±1.14 0.93±0.56 Disallowed (calculation) 1.01±1.51 6.73±1.71 2.40±1.66 12 1CN7 2K49 2L3O 2GJY 2K7H 2YT0 2L7B 79.51±2.56 94.57±1.66 74.18±2.02 75.99±3.12 97.29±1.08 85.55±2.76 75.69±1.58 84.12±2.78 92.99±2.39 70.36±4.07 78.72±3.04 93.06±2.78 79.67±2.39 73.38±1.92 4.02±1.71 0.30±0.42 8.86±1.85 7.29±1.96 1.10±0.24 1.15±0.56 6.41±1.19 2.89±1.89 1.47±0.97 12.64±3.07 6.20±1.51 1.33±1.10 6.07±1.36 9.11±1.61 FIGURE 6 The Ramachandran Plot of 2K7H structures: (A) our calculation result; (B) the PDB reference structure. 13 Validation using X-ray crystallographic structure Finally, we validate our method using a special dataset, which has both NMR structures and the corresponding X-ray crystallographic structures in PDB. The dataset is set up as follows: Among the ten proteins that we used in Sec. 3.1, there are four proteins with their corresponding X-ray crystallographic structures. In addition, we take the PDB entries listed in references (54, 55), and remove the proteins whose RMSD values are larger than 3Å between the PDB NMR structures and the corresponding X-ray ones. In the end, we get a dataset with 31 proteins. We calculate the Cα RMSD values in the well-defined region between our calculated structure and X-ray crystallographic PDB structure. In the meantime, we also calculate the same Cα RMSD but for the PDB NMR structure compared with the X-ray crystallographic structure in PDB. The results are shown in Fig.7 A. For 14/31 proteins our structures are equivalent or even closer to the X-ray crystallographic structures than PDB NMR structures; for the rest, 9 of our structures are just slightly further (ΔRMSD<0.5Å) to the X-ray crystallographic structures than PDB NMR structures; for proteins with PDB code 1BVM and 1MPH, our reconstruction results are visibly worse than the PDB reference structures (ΔRMSD>1Å). We also compared the TM-score relative to the X-ray structure between our calculated structure and corresponding PDB reference structure, as shown in Fig.7 B. Similar to RMSD, the TM-scores of our structure are generally slightly smaller than the PDB structure, but all are larger than 0.65 indicating that the foldings are still the same as the X-ray structures. One possible reason that our calculated structure is slightly further to the X-ray crystallographic structure than the PDB reference structure could be due to the fact that we only consider the NOESY distance restraints in the NMR measurement while the PDB structures take all the possible NMR measurements into consideration during the reconstruction, which is the drawback of our current reconstruction algorithm. 14 FIGURE 7 (A) Cα RMSD in well-defined region relative to the X-ray crystallographic structure for both our calculation result (blue line) and PDB structure (red line). The bar indicates the standard deviation of the NMR ensemble, i.e., the reconstruction uncertainty. (B) Same as panel (A) but measured for TM-score. CONCLUSION We have presented a new NMR structure determination method using ScaleASD matrix completion algorithm. The difficulties to reconstruct the NMR structure using matrix completion are from the following two facts: 1) The number of the measured NOESY distance restraints is far smaller than the required number in matrix completion condition. 2) The NOESY distances are usually larger than the actual atomic distances. To solve the first problem, we utilize the triangle inequality to generate the proximate values for some unknown distances. Using the samplings from these distances together with the measured NOESY data, covalent bonds and the coplanar inter-atomic distances, we set up the initial distance matrix that satisfies the matrix completion condition. For the second problem as well as the errors introduced by the triangle inequality estimation, we perform the distance boundaries refinement as complement. In the end, several refinements and optimization are implemented to obtain more reasonable structure. The software and the MATLAB source codes are distributed at https://github.com/xubiaopeng/PRASD. The release is archived in Zenodo: DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.1400047. To validate our method, ten arbitrarily selected proteins from NOESY data have been reconstructed and compared with their corresponding structures in PDB. The comparison includes several metrics such as Cα atom RMSD in well-defined region, TM-score, MPscore, Z-scores and violations reported in PSVS software, secondary 15 structures and Ramachandran plots. It has been shown that our results are comparable to the structures in PDB, especially for Procheck dihedral angles G-factor, the results from our method show higher validity than the PDB structures. We have also validated our reconstructed structure using the RMSD and TM-score with the corresponding PDB X-ray crystallographic structure with an even larger dataset. The result shows that our method is valid even though not as good as the current PDB NMR structures. We notice that our current reconstruction structure is only based on NOESY distance restraints. In the next step, many other NMR measurements such as Residual dipolar coupling (RDC) would be considered and integrated into our algorithm to obtain better structures. AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS Z. L. developed the algorithm, performed the calculation, analyzed the data, validated the method and made the manuscript draft. S. L calculated and analyzed the data. X.W. helped in data analysis, method validation and revised the manuscript. X. P. supervised the data analysis and validation, designed the software interface and revised the manuscript. Q. Z. designed the project, supervised the calculation as well as analysis, and revised the manuscript. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors would like to thank Prof. Ge Molin for valuable discussions, Prof. Deng Rongping for reading the manuscript and improving English. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation (NSF) of China with the Grant No.11675014. Additional support was provided by the Ministry of Science and Technology of China (2013YQ030595-3). 16 REFERENCES 1. Williamson, M. P., T. F. Havel, and K. Wüthrich. 1985. Solution conformation of protein inhibitor IIA from bull seminal plasma by 1H nuclear magnetic resonance and distance geometry. J. Mol. Biol. 182:295 -- 315. 2. Güntert, P. 1998. Structure calculation of biological macromolecules from NMR 3. Berman, H. M., J. Westbrook, ... , P. E. Bourne. 2000. The protein data bank, 17 data. Q. Rev. Biophys. 31: 145 -- 237. Nucleic acids research 28. 1: 235 -- 242. Biophysics. J. 38: 129-143. 4. Güntert, P. 2009. Automated structure determination from NMR spectra, Eur. 5. Pitner, T. P., J. D. Glickson, and G. R. Marshal. 1974. Solvent exposure of specific nuclei of angiotensin II determined by NMR solvent saturation method. Nature., 250: 582-584. 6. Mccammon, J. A., B. R. Gelin, and M. Karplus. 1977. Dynamics of folded proteins. Nature. 267: 585-590. 7. Davtyan, A., N. P. Schafer, …, G. A. Papoian. 2012. Awsem-md: coarse-grained protein structure prediction using physical potentials and bioinformatically based local structure biasing. J. Phys. Chem. B. 116: 8494-8503. 8. Czaplewski, C., S. Oldziej, …, H. A. Scheraga. 2004. Prediction of the structures of proteins with the unres force field, including dynamic formation and breaking of disulfide bonds. Protein Eng. Des. Sel. 17: 29-36. 9. Lindorfflarsen, K., S. Piana, …, D. E. Shaw. 2011. How fast-folding proteins fold. 10. Kirkpatrick, S., C. D. Gelatt, and M. P. Vecchi. 1983. Optimization by simulated Science. 334: 517-520. annealing. Science. 220: 671-680. 11. Johnson, D. S., C. R. Aragon, …, C. Schevon. 1989. Optimization by simulated annealing: an experimental evaluation. Part I, graph partitioning. Oper. Res. 37: 865-892. 12. Johnson, D. S., C. R. Aragon, …, C. Schevon. 1991. Optimization by simulated annealing: An experimental evaluation; part II, graph coloring and number partitioning. Oper. Res. 39: 378-406. 13. Schwieters, C. D., J. J. Kuszewski, …, G. M. Clore. 2003. The Xplor-NIH NMR molecular structure determination package. J. Magn. Reson. 160: 65-73. 14. Schwieters, C. D., J. J. Kuszewski, and G. M. Clore. 2006. Using Xplor-NIH for NMR molecular structure determination. Prog. Nucl. Magn. Reson. Spectrosc. 48: 47-62. 15. Güntert, P., C. Mumenthaler, and K. Wüthrich. 1997. Torsion angle dynamics for NMR structure calculation with the new program DYANA. J. Mol. Biol. 273: 283-298. 16. Güntert, P. 2004. Automated NMR structure calculation with CYANA. Methods Mol. Biol. 278: 353-378. 17. Linge, J. P., S. I. O'Donoghue, and M. Nilges. 2001. Automated assignment of ambiguous nuclear overhauser effects with ARIA. Method. Enzymol. 339: 71-90. 18. Brooks, B. R. 1983. CHARMM: A program for macromolecular energy, minimization, and dynamics calculations. J. Comput. Chem. 4: 187-217. 19. Braun, W., C. Bösch, …, K. Wüthrich. 1981. Combined use of proton-proton Overhauser enhancements and a distance geometry algorithm for determination of polypeptide conformations. Application to micelle-bound glucagon. Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 667: 377-396. 20. Havel, T. F., I. D. Kuntz, and G. M. Crippen. 1983. The theory and practice of distance geometry. Bull. Math. Biol. 45: 665-720. 21. Havel, T., and K. Wüthrich. 1984. A distance geometry program for determining the structures of small proteins and other macromolecules from nuclear magnetic resonance measurements of intramolecular 1H-H proximities in solution. Bull. Math. Biol. 46: 673-698. 22. Biswas, P., K. C. Toh, and Y. Ye. 2008. A distributed SDP approach for largescale noisy anchor-free graph realization with applications to molecular conformation. SIAM J. Sci. Comput. 30: 1251 -- 1277. 23. Leung, N. H., and K. C. Toh. 2009. An SDP-based divide-and-conquer algorithm for large-scale noisy anchor-free graph realization. SIAM J. Sci. Comput. 31: 4351 -- 4372. 24. Alipanahi, B., N. Krislock, and M. Li. 2013. Determining protein structures from NOESY distance constraints by semidifinite programming. J. Comput. Biol. 20: 296 -- 310. 25. Engh, R. A., and R. Huber. 1991. Accurate bond and ample parameters for X-ray protein structure refinement. Acta Cryst. 47: 392-400. 26. Hooft, R. W. W., C. Sander, and G. Vriend. 1996. Verification of protein structures: side-chain planarity. J. Appl. Cryst. 29: 714-716. 27. Candès, E. J., and T. Tao. 2010. The power of convex relaxation: near-optimal matrix completion. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory. 56: 2053 -- 2080. 28. Candès, E. J., and Y. Plan. 2011. Tight oracle inequalities for low-rank matrix recovery from a minimal number of noisy random measurements. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory. 57: 2342 -- 2359. 29. Warshall, S. 1962. A theorem on boolean matrices. JACM. 9: 11 -- 12. 30. Candès, E. J., and B. Recht. 2009. Exact matrix completion via convex optimization. Found. Comput. Math. 9: 717 -- 772. 31. Harvey, N. J. A., D. R. Karger, and S. Yekhanin. 2006. The complexity of matrix completion. SODA'06 Proceedings of the seventeenth annual ACM-SIAM symposium on discrete algorithms. 1103 -- 1111. 32. Tanner, J., and K. Wei. 2016. Low rank matrix completion by alternating steepest descent methods. Appl. Comput. Harmon. Anal. 40: 417-429. 33. Crippen G. M., and T. F. Havel. 1978. Stable calculation of coordinates from distance information. Acta Cryst. 34: 282-284. 34. Lewis, A. S., and M. L. Overton. 2013. Nonsmooth optimization via quasi-Newton methods. Math. Program., 141: 135-163. 35. Cassioli, A., B. Bardiaux, …, T. E. Malliavin. 2015. An algorithm to enumerate all possible protein conformations verifying a set of distance constraints. BMC 18 Bioinformatics. 16: 1-15. 36. Rocchia, W., E. Alexov, and B. Honig. 2001. Extending the applicability of the constants and nonlinear poisson-boltzmann equation: Multiple dielectric multivalent ions. J. Phys. Chem. B. 105: 6507 -- 6514. 37. Honig, B., and A. Nicholls. 1995. Classical electrostatics in biology and chemistry. Science. 268: 1144 -- 1149. 38. Lindorfflarsen, K., S. Piana, …, D. E. Shaw. 2010. Improved side-chain torsion potentials for the Amber ff99SB protein force field. Proteins. 78: 1950-1958. 39. Linge, J. P., M. Habeck, …, M. Nilges. 2003. ARIA: automated NOE assignment and NMR structure calculation. Bioinformatics. 19: 315-316. 40. Doreleijers, J. F., S. Mading, …, E. L. Ulrich. 2003. BioMagResBank database with sets of experimental NMR constraints corresponding to the structures of over 1400 biomolecules deposited in the protein data bank. J. Biomol. NMR. 26: 139-146. 41. Doreleijers, J. F., A. J. Nederveen, …, E. L. Ulrich. 2005. BioMagResBank databases DOCR and FRED containing converted and filtered sets of experimental NMR restraints and coordinates from over 500 protein PDB structures. J. Biomol. NMR. 32: 1-12. 42. Huang, J., S. Rauscher, S, …, A. D. MacKerell. 2017. CHARMM36m: an improved force field for folded and intrinsically disordered proteins. Nat. Methods. 14: 71-73. 43. Quiñonero, D., S. Tomàs, …, P. M. Deyà. 2001. OPLS all-atom force field for squaramides and squaric acid. Chem. Phys. Lett. 350: 331-338. 44. Berendsen, H. J. C., D. V. D. Spoel, and R. V. Drunen. 1995. GROMACS: a message-passing parallel molecular dynamics implementation. Comput. Phys. Commun. 91: 43-56. 45. Zhang, Y., and J. Skolnick. 2004. Scoring function for automated assessment of protein structure template quality. Proteins. 57: 702-710. 46. Hadley, C. and D. T. Jones. 1999. A systematic comparison of protein structure classifications: SCOP, CATH and FSSP. Structure. 7: 1099-1112. 47. Chen, V. B., A. W. Rd, …, D. C. Richardson. 2010. Molprobity: all-atom structure validation for macromolecular crystallography. Acta. Crystallogr. D. Biol. Crystallogr. 66: 12-21. 48. Bhattacharya, A., R. Tejero, and G. T. Montelione. 2007. Evaluating protein structures determined by structural genomics consortia. Proteins. 66: 778-795. 49. Laskowski, R. A., M. W. Macarthur, …, J. M. Thornton. 1993. Procheck -- a program to check the stereochemical quality of protein structure. J. Appl. Crystallogr. 26: 283-291. 50. Eisenberg, D., R. Luthy, and J. U. Bowie. 1997. VERIFY3D: assessment of protein models with three-dimensional profiles. Method. Enzymol. 277: 396-404. 51. Wiederstein, M., and M. J. Sippl. 2007. ProSA-web: interactive web service for the recognition of errors in three-dimensional structures of proteins. Nucleic. Acids. Res. 35: W407-W410. 52. Kabsch, W., and C. Sander. 1983. Dictionary of protein secondary structure: 19 Pattern recognition of hydrogen-bonded and geometrical features. Biopolymers, 22: 2577-2637. 53. Ramachandran, G. N., C. Ramakrishnan, and V. Sasisekharan. 1963. Stereochemistry of polypeptide chain configurations. J. Mol. Biol. 7: 95-99. 54. Sikic, K., S. Tomic, and O. Carugo. 2010. Systematic comparison of crystal and NMR protein structure deposited in the Protein Data Bank. Open Biochem. J. 4: 83-95. 55. Schneider, M., X. Fu, and A. E. Keating. 2009. X-ray vs. NMR structures as templates for computational protein design. Proteins. 77: 97-110. 20
1110.6927	1	1110	2011-10-31T19:56:09	Statistical-Mechanical Measure of Stochastic Spiking Coherence in A Population of Inhibitory Subthreshold Neurons	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.NC" ]	By varying the noise intensity, we study stochastic spiking coherence (i.e., collective coherence between noise-induced neural spikings) in an inhibitory population of subthreshold neurons (which cannot fire spontaneously without noise). This stochastic spiking coherence may be well visualized in the raster plot of neural spikes. For a coherent case, partially-occupied "stripes" (composed of spikes and indicating collective coherence) are formed in the raster plot. This partial occupation occurs due to "stochastic spike skipping" which is well shown in the multi-peaked interspike interval histogram. The main purpose of our work is to quantitatively measure the degree of stochastic spiking coherence seen in the raster plot. We introduce a new spike-based coherence measure $M_s$ by considering the occupation pattern and the pacing pattern of spikes in the stripes. In particular, the pacing degree between spikes is determined in a statistical-mechanical way by quantifying the average contribution of (microscopic) individual spikes to the (macroscopic) ensemble-averaged global potential. This "statistical-mechanical" measure $M_s$ is in contrast to the conventional measures such as the "thermodynamic" order parameter (which concerns the time-averaged fluctuations of the macroscopic global potential), the "microscopic" correlation-based measure (based on the cross-correlation between the microscopic individual potentials), and the measures of precise spike timing (based on the peri-stimulus time histogram). In terms of $M_s$, we quantitatively characterize the stochastic spiking coherence, and find that $M_s$ reflects the degree of collective spiking coherence seen in the raster plot very well. Hence, the "statistical-mechanical" spike-based measure $M_s$ may be used usefully to quantify the degree of stochastic spiking coherence in a statistical-mechanical way.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Noname manuscript No. (will be inserted by the editor) Statistical-Mechanical Measure of Stochastic Spiking Coherence in A Population of Inhibitory Subthreshold Neurons Woochang Lim · Sang-Yoon Kim Received: date / Accepted: date Abstract By varying the noise intensity, we study stochastic spiking coherence (i.e., col- lective coherence between noise-induced neural spikings) in an inhibitory population of subthreshold neurons (which cannot fire spontaneously without noise). This stochastic spik- ing coherence may be well visualized in the raster plot of neural spikes. For a coherent case, partially-occupied "stripes" (composed of spikes and indicating collective coherence) are formed in the raster plot. This partial occupation occurs due to "stochastic spike skipping" which is well shown in the multi-peaked interspike interval histogram. The main purpose of our work is to quantitatively measure the degree of stochastic spiking coherence seen in the raster plot. We introduce a new spike-based coherence measure Ms by considering the occupation pattern and the pacing pattern of spikes in the stripes. In particular, the pacing degree between spikes is determined in a statistical-mechanical way by quantifying the aver- age contribution of (microscopic) individual spikes to the (macroscopic) ensemble-averaged global potential. This "statistical-mechanical" measure Ms is in contrast to the conventional measures such as the "thermodynamic" order parameter (which concerns the time-averaged fluctuations of the macroscopic global potential), the "microscopic" correlation-based mea- sure (based on the cross-correlation between the microscopic individual potentials), and the measures of precise spike timing (based on the peri-stimulus time histogram). In terms of Ms, we quantitatively characterize the stochastic spiking coherence, and find that Ms re- flects the degree of collective spiking coherence seen in the raster plot very well. Hence, the "statistical-mechanical" spike-based measure Ms may be used usefully to quantify the degree of stochastic spiking coherence in a statistical-mechanical way. Keywords Inhibitory Subthreshold Neurons · Stochastic Spiking Coherence · Statistical- Mechanical Measure 1 Introduction Recently, brain rhythms have attracted much attention (Buzs´aki 2006). Synchronous oscil- lations in neural systems may be used for efficient sensory processing (e.g., binding of the Woochang Lim · Sang-Yoon Kim (corresponding author) Department of Physics, Kangwon National University, Chunchon, Kangwon-Do 200-701, Korea E-mail: [email protected] 1 1 0 2 t c O 1 3 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 7 2 9 6 . 0 1 1 1 : v i X r a 2 integrated whole image in the visual cortex is accomplished via synchronization of neural firings) (Gray 1994). In addition to such neural encoding of sensory stimuli, neural syn- chronization is also correlated with pathological rhythms associated with neural diseases (e.g., epileptic seizures and tremors in the Parkinson's disease) (Hauschildt et al. 2006; Grosse et al. 2002; Tass et al. 1998). Here, we are interested in these synchronized neu- ral oscillations. A neural circuit in the major parts of the brain such as thalamus, hippocampus, and cortex consists of a few types of excitatory principal cells and diverse types of inhibitory in- terneurons. Functional diversity of interneurons increases the computational power of prin- cipal cells (Buzs´aki 2006; Buzs´aki et al. 2004). To understand the mechanisms of syn- chronous brain rhythms, neural systems composed of excitatory neurons and/or inhibitory neurons have been investigated, and thus three types of synchronization mechanisms have been found (Wang 2003): recurrent excitation between principal cells, mutual inhibition between interneurons, and feedback between excitatory and inhibitory neurons. Perfect syn- chronization occurs in the network of pulse-coupled excitatory neurons (Kuramoto 1991; Mirollo & Strogatz 1990). However, this synchronization via mutual excitation cannot be always stable in networks with slowly decaying synaptic couplings. Stability of synchro- nization is shown to depend on both the time course of synaptic interaction and the response of neurons to small depolarization (Vreeswijk et al. 1994; Hansel et al. 1995). When the decay time of the synaptic interaction is enough long, mutual inhibition (rather than exci- tation) may synchronize neural firing activities. By providing a coherent oscillatory output to the principal cells, interneuronal networks play the role of the backbones (i.e., synchro- nizers or pacemakers) of many brain oscillations such as the 10-Hz thalamocortical spin- dle rhythms (Wang & Rinzel 1992; Golomb & Rinzel 1994) and the 40-Hz fast gamma rhythms in the hippocampus and the neocortex (Wang & Buzs´aki 1996; White et al. 1998; Whittington et al. 2000; Tiesinga et al. 2001). When the feedback between the excitatory and inhibitory populations is strong, neural synchrony appears via the "cross-talk" between the two populations (Whittington et al. 2000; Tiesinga et al. 2001; Hansel & Mato 2003; Borgers & Kopell 2003, 2005). Most past studies exploring mechanisms of neural synchronization were done in neural systems composed of spontaneously firing (i.e., self-oscillating) suprathreshold neurons. For this case, neural coherence occurs via cooperation of regular firings of suprathreshold self- firing neurons. In contrast, neural systems composed of subthreshold neurons have received little attention. Unlike the suprathreshold case, each subthreshold neuron in the absence of coupling cannot fire spontaneously without noise; it can fire only with the help of noise. Recently, stochastic spiking coherence (i.e., collective coherence emerging via cooperation of noise-induced spikings) was observed in an excitatory population of pulse-coupled sub- threshold neurons (Wang et al. 2000; Lim & Kim 2007, 2009). This kind of works may be thought to correspond to a "subthreshold version" of neural synchronization through mutual excitation. Due to the stochastic spiking coherence, synaptic current, injected into each in- dividual neuron, becomes temporally coherent. Hence, temporal coherence resonance of an individual subthreshold neuron in the network may be enhanced. This enhancement of co- herence resonance in an excitatory network of subthreshold Hodgkin-Huxley neurons was characterized in terms of the coherence factor b , representing the degree of sharpness of the peak in the power spectrum of an individual neuron (Wang et al. 2000). In this way, the measure b is used for characterization of the temporal coherence of an individual neuron. However, we note that b is not a measure for directly measuring the degree of collective coherence in the whole population. 3 In this paper, we are concerned about the "subthreshold version" of neural synchro- nization via mutual inhibition. In Section 2, we describe the biological conductance-based Morris-Lecar (ML) neuron model with voltage-gated ion channels (Morris & Lecar 1981; Rinzel & Ermentrout 1998; Tsumoto et al. 2006). The ML neurons (used in our study) exhibit the type-II excitability (i.e., the firing frequency begins to increase from a non- zero value when the stimulus exceeds a threshold value), and they interact via inhibitory GABAergic synapses whose activity increases fast and decays slowly. In Section 3, we characterize stochastic spiking coherence in a large population of inhibitory subthreshold ML neurons by varying the noise intensity for a fixed coupling strength. Weakly coherent states with oscillating ensemble-averaged global membrane potential VG are thus found to appear in a range of intermediate noise intensity [i.e., regular global oscillation (with re- duced amplitude and increased frequency) emerges via cooperation of irregular individual oscillations]. Emergence of collective coherence may be well described in terms of the con- ventional "thermodynamic" order parameter which concerns the time-averaged fluctuations of the macroscopic global potential VG. We note that this stochastic spiking coherence may be well visualized in the raster plot of neural spikes (i.e., a spatiotemporal plot of neural spikes) which is directly obtained in experiments. For the coherent case, "stripes" (com- posed of spikes and indicating collective coherence) are found to be formed in the raster plot. Due to coherent contribution of spikes, local maxima of the global potential VG appear at the centers of stripes. However, these stripes are partially occupied. Individual inhibitory neurons exhibit intermittent spikings phase-locked to VG at random multiples of the period of VG. This "stochastic phase locking" leading to "stochastic spike skipping" is well shown in the interspike interval (ISI) histogram with multiple peaks. The multi-peaked ISI histogram shows some indication of weak collective spiking coherence. The main purpose of our work is to quantitatively measure the degree of stochastic spik- ing coherence seen in the raster plot. In Section 3, we introduce a new type of spike-based coherence measure Ms by taking into consideration the occupation pattern and the pacing pattern of spikes in the stripes of the raster plot. In particular, the pacing degree between spikes is determined in a statistical-mechanical way by quantifying the average contribution of (microscopic) individual spikes to the (macroscopic) global potential VG. This "statistical- mechanical" measure Ms is in contrast to the conventional measures such as the "thermo- dynamic" order parameter (Golomb & Rinzel 1994; Hansel & Mato 2003), the "micro- scopic" correlation-based measure (based on the cross-correlations between the microscopic individual potentials) (Wang & Buzs´aki 1996; White et al. 1998), and the measures of pre- cise spike timing based on the peri-stimulus time histogram (PSTH) (Mainen & Sejnowski 1995; Schreiber et al. 2003). The "thermodynamic" order parameter and the "microscopic" measure concern just the the macroscopic global potential VG and the microscopic individual potentials, respectively without considering any quantitative relation between VG and the mi- croscopic individual potentials. (The auto-correlation of the global activity used in the work of Brunel and Hakim (1999) may also be regarded as a kind of "thermodynamic" measure.) For the PSTH-based measure "events," corresponding to peaks of the instantaneous popula- tion firing rate, are selected through setting a threshold. Then, the measures for the reliability and the precision of spike timing concern only the spikes within the events, in contrast to the case of the "statistical-mechanical" measure where all spikes are considered (without select- ing events). A main difference between the conventional and the new spike-based measures lies in determining the pacing degree of spikes. The precision of spike timing for the con- ventional case is given by just the standard deviation of (microscopic) individual spike times within an event without considering the quantitative contribution of (microscopic) individ- ual spikes to the (macroscopic) global activity. Hence, the PSTH-based measure is not a 4 statistical-mechanical measure. However, if we take the instantaneous population firing rate as a global activity and exactly define the global cycles [see Fig. 4(a)] and the global phases [see Eqs. (15) and (16)] like our case, then the conventional PSTH-based measure may also develop into a similar statistical-mechanical measure. By varying the noise intensity, we quantitatively characterize the stochastic spiking coherence in terms of the "statistical- mechanical" measure Ms, and find that Ms reflects the degree of collective spiking coherence seen in the raster plot very well. We also expect that Ms may be implemented for character- izing the degree of collective coherence in the experimentally-obtained raster plot of neural spikes. Finally, a summary is given in Section 4. 2 Morris-Lecar Neuron Model In this section, we describe the biological neuron model used in our computational study. We consider an ensemble of N globally coupled neurons. As an element in our neural sys- tem, we choose the conductance-based ML neuron model with voltage-gated ion channels, originally proposed to describe the time-evolution pattern of the membrane potential for the giant muscle fibers of barnacles (Morris & Lecar 1981; Rinzel & Ermentrout 1998; Tsumoto et al. 2006). The population dynamics in this neural network is governed by a set of the following differential equations: C dvi dt dwi dt dsi dt = −Iion,i + IDC + Dx i − Isyn,i, = f (w¥ (vi) − wi) , t R(vi) = a s¥ (vi)(1 − si) − b si, i = 1, · · · , N, where Iion,i = ICa,i + IK,i + IL,i = gCam¥ (vi)(vi −VCa) + gKwi(vi −VK ) + gL(vi −VL), Isyn,i = J N − 1 N(cid:229) j(6=i) s j(t)(vi −Vsyn), m¥ (v) = 0.5 [1 + tanh {(v −V1)/V2}] , w¥ (v) = 0.5 [1 + tanh {(v −V3)/V4}] , t R(v) = 1/cosh {(v −V3)/(2V4)} , s¥ (vi) = 1/[1 + e−(vi−v∗)/d ]. (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Here, the state of the ith neuron at a time t (measured in units of ms) is characterized by three state variables: the membrane potential vi (measured in units of mV), the slow recov- ery variable wi representing the activation of the K+ current (i.e., the fraction of open K+ channels), and the synaptic gate variable si denoting the fraction of open synaptic ion chan- nels. In Eq. (1), C represents the capacitance of the membrane of each neuron, and the time evolution of vi is governed by four kinds of source currents. The total ionic current Iion,i of the ith neuron consists of the calcium current ICa,i, the potassium current IK,i, and the leakage current IL,i. Each ionic current obeys Ohm's law. The constants gCa, gK, and gL are the maximum conductances for the ion and leakage channels, 5 and the constants VCa, VK, and VL are the reversal potentials at which each current is bal- anced by the ionic concentration difference across the membrane. Since the calcium current ICa,i changes much faster than the potassium current IK,i, the gate variable mi for the Ca2+ channel is assumed to always take its saturation value m¥ (vi). On the other hand, the activa- tion variable wi for the K+ channel approaches its saturation value w¥ (vi) with a relaxation time t R(vi)/f , where t R has a dimension of ms and f is a (dimensionless) temperature-like time scale factor. Each ML neuron is also stimulated by the common DC current IDC and an indepen- dent Gaussian white noise x [see the 2nd and 3rd terms in Eq. (1)] satisfying hx i(t)i = 0 and hx i(t) x j(t′)i = d i j d (t −t′), where h· · ·i denotes the ensemble average. The noise x is a para- metric one which randomly perturbs the strength of the applied current IDC, and its intensity is controlled by the parameter D. The last term in Eq. (1) represents the coupling of the network. Each neuron is connected to all the other ones through global synaptic couplings. Isyn,i of Eq. (6) represents such synaptic current injected into the ith neuron. Here the cou- pling strength is controlled by the parameter J and Vsyn is the synaptic reversal potential. We use Vsyn = −80 mV for the inhibitory synapse and Vsyn = 0 mV for the excitatory synapse. The synaptic gate variable s obeys the 1st order kinetics of Eq. (3) (Golomb & Rinzel 1994; Wang & Buzs´aki 1996). Here, the normalized concentration of synaptic transmitters, acti- vating the synapse, is assumed to be an instantaneous sigmoidal function of the membrane potential with a threshold v∗ in Eq. (10), where we set v∗ = 0 mV and d = 2 mV. The transmitter release occurs only when the neuron emits a spike (i.e., its potential v is larger than v∗). The synaptic channel opening rate, corresponding to the inverse of the synaptic rise time t r, is a = 10 ms−1, which assures a fast rise of Isyn (Borgers & Kopell 2003, 2005). On the other hand, the synaptic closing rate b , which is the inverse of the synaptic decay time t d, depends on the type of the synaptic receptors. For the inhibitory GABAergic synapse (involving the GABAA receptors) we set b = 0.1 ms−1, and for the excitatory glutamate synapse (involving the AMPA receptors), we use b = 0.5 ms−1 (Borgers & Kopell 2003, 2005). Thus, Isyn decays slowly. The ML neuron may exhibit either type-I or type-II excitability, depending on the sys- tem parameters (Rinzel & Ermentrout 1998). For the case of type-I (type-II), the firing fre- quency begins to increase from zero (a non-zero finite value) when IDC passes a threshold. Throughout this paper, we consider the case of type-II excitability where gCa = 4.4 mS/cm2, gK = 8 mS/cm2, gL = 2 mS/cm2, VCa = 120 mV, VK = −84 mV, VL = −60 mV, C = 20 m F/cm2, f = 0.04, V1 = −1.2 mV, V2 = 18 mV, V3 = 2 mV, and V4 = 30 mV. As IDC passes a thresh- old in the absence of noise, each single type-II ML neuron begins to fire with a nonzero fre- quency that is relatively insensitive to the change in IDC (Hodgkin 1948; Izhikevich 2000). Numerical integration of Eqs. (1-3) is done using the Heun method (San Miguel & Toral 2000) (with the time step D t = 0.01 ms) similar to the second-order Runge-Kutta method, and data for (vi, wi, si) (i = 1, . . . , N) are obtained with the sampling time interval D t = 1 ms. For each realization of the stochastic process in Eqs. (1-3), we choose a random initial point [vi(0), wi(0), si(0)] for the ith (i = 1, . . . , N) neuron with uniform probability in the range of vi(0) ∈ (−70, 50), wi(0) ∈ (0.0, 0.6), and si(0) ∈ (0.0, 1.0). 6 ) V m ( v 50 (a) -5 -60 1000 0.16 (b) y t i l i b a b o r P 0.08 0.00 1500 t (ms) 2000 0 250 ISI (ms) 500 ) V m ( v 50 (c) -5 -60 1000 1500 t (ms) 2000 Fig. 1 Intermittent noise-induced firings of a single subthreshold ML neuron: (a) time series of the membrane potential v and (b) interspike interval (ISI) histogram for IDC = 87 m A/cm2 and D = 20 m A · ms1/2/cm2; the ISI histogram is made of 5 × 104 ISIs and the bin size for the histogram is 5 ms. Regular firings of a single suprathreshold ML neuron: (c) time series of v for IDC = 95 m A/cm2 and D = 0. 3 Characterization of Stochastic Spiking Coherence in An Inhibitory Population of Subthreshold ML Neurons In this section, we study stochastic spiking coherence in a population of inhibitory sub- threshold ML neurons. The stochastic spiking coherence is quantitatively characterized in terms of a new "statistical-mechanical" spike-based measure. We first consider the case of a single ML neuron. An isolated subthreshold neuron cannot fire spontaneously without noise; it may generate firings only with the aid of noise. Figure 1(a) shows a time series of the membrane potential v of a subthreshold neuron for IDC = 87 m A/cm2 and D = 20 m A · ms1/2/cm2. Noise-induced spikings appear intermittently. For this subthreshold case, the ISI histogram is shown in Fig. 1(b). The most probable value of the ISIs (corresponding to the main highest peak) is 97.5 ms. But, due to a long tail in the ISI histogram the average value of the ISIs becomes 161.6 ms. This noise-induced irregular oscillation of v is in contrast to the regular oscillation of v for a suprathreshold neuron (which fires spontaneously without noise) when IDC = 95 m A/cm2 and D = 0 [see Fig. 1(c)]. We consider an inhibitory population of N globally coupled subthreshold ML neurons for IDC = 87 m A/cm2 and set the coupling strength as J = 3 mS/cm2. (Hereafter, for con- venience we omit the dimensions of IDC, D, and J.) By varying the noise intensity D, we investigate the stochastic spiking coherence. Emergence of collective spiking coherence may be well described by the (population-averaged) global potential, VG(t) = 1 N N(cid:229) i=1 vi(t). (11) In the thermodynamic limit (N → ¥ ), a collective state becomes coherent if D VG(t) (= VG(t) − VG(t)) is non-stationary (i.e., an oscillating global potential VG appears for a co- herent case), where the overbar represents the time average. Otherwise (i.e., when D VG is stationary), it becomes incoherent. Thus, the mean square deviation of the global potential 7 2.0 (a) -1.5 O 0 1 g o l -5.0 0.5 (b) 1000 i 500 1500 t (ms) 0 10 0 1000 (c) 50 -5 s N ) V m ( G V 1.0 1.5 log10D (d) 1000 500 i 0 100 s N 2000 ) V m ( G V 0 1000 (e) 50 -5 N=102 N=103 N=104 2.0 1500 t (ms) 2000 -60 1000 1500 t (ms) 2000 -60 1000 1500 t (ms) 2000 Fig. 2 Order parameter and partial occupation in N(= 103) globally coupled inhibitory subthreshold ML neurons: (a) plots of the order parameter O versus the noise intensity D. (b) partially-occupied raster plot of spikings a (i: neuron index) and plot of number of spikes (Ns) versus time (t) and (c) time series of the ensemble-averaged global potential VG. Full occupation in N(= 103) globally coupled excitatory ML neurons: (d) fully-occupied raster plot of spikings and plot of Ns versus t and (e) time series of VG. For both inhibitory and excitatory cases, IDC = 87 m A/cm2, D = 20 m A · ms1/2/cm2, J = 3 mS/cm2, and the bin size for Ns in (b) and (d) is 1 ms VG (i.e., time-averaged fluctuations of VG), O ≡ (VG(t) −VG(t))2, (12) plays the role of an order parameter used for describing the coherence-incoherence tran- sition (Manrubia et al. 2004). For the coherent (incoherent) state, the order parameter O approaches a non-zero (zero) limit value as N goes to the infinity. Figure 2(a) shows a plot of the order parameter versus the noise intensity. For D < D∗ l (≃ 9.4), incoherent states exist because the order parameter O tends to zero as N → ¥ . As D passes the lower threshold D∗ l , a coherent transition occurs because of a constructive role of noise to stimulate coherence between noise-induced spikings. However, for large D > D∗ h (≃ 33.4) such coherent states disappear (i.e., a transition to an incoherent state occurs when D passes the higher threshold D∗ h) due to a destructive role of noise to spoil the collective spiking coherence. 8 As an example, we consider a coherent state for D = 20. For this case stochastic spiking coherence may be well visualized in terms of the raster plot of neural spikes. The upper panel in Fig. 2(b) shows the raster plot for N = 103. We note that stripes (composed of spikes and indicating collective coherence) appear successively in the raster plot. The number of spikes (Ns) in each stripe is given in the lower panel. About 100 spikes constitute a stripe [i.e., only a fraction (about 1/10) of the total neurons fire in each stripe]. In this way partial occupation occurs in the stripes. A regularly oscillating global potential VG emerges through cooperation of spikes in partially-occupied stripes. A time series of VG is shown in Fig. 2(c). The amplitude of VG is much smaller than that in Fig. 1(a) for the isolated single case. This reduction of amplitude occurs mainly because of partial occupation. Local maxima of VG appear at the centers of stripes where the spiking densities are locally highest. The global period TG of VG (corresponding to the average intermax interval of VG or equivalently corresponding to the average interstripe interval in the raster plot) is 54.2 ms. Hence the global frequency fG (= 18.5 Hz) of VG is roughly as twice as the most probable frequency (= 10.3 Hz) of v for the isolated single case. Thus, a regular global oscillation with reduced amplitude and increased frequency occurs for the partially-occupied case. For comparison, we also consider the case of full occupation which occurs in a population of excitatory neurons for the same set of parameters IDC, D, and J. [We emphasize that partial occupation may also occur even for the excitatory case of smaller J (e.g., J = 1).] Figures 2(d) and 2(e) show the raster plot and a time series of VG for the fully-occupied case, respectively. Fully-occupied stripes appear successively at nearly regular time intervals D t (= 97.9 ms), in contrast to the partially-occupied case. A regularly oscillating VG with large amplitude appears via cooperation of spikes in the fully-occupied stripes, and its global frequency fG (= 10.2 Hz) is smaller than that for the partially-occupied case (in fact, fG for the fully- occupied case is nearly equal to the most probable frequency of v for the isolated single case). To further understand the full and the partial occupations in the raster plots, we examine the local and the global output signals for both the fully-occupied and the partially-occupied cases of D = 20. Since our neural network is globally coupled, any local neuron may be a representative one. Unlike the isolated single case (shown in Fig. 1), each local neuron within the network is stimulated by a synaptic current which is directly related to the aver- age of firing events of all the other neurons. First, we consider the fully-occupied excitatory case, and investigate the time series of the local potential v1 of the 1st neuron and the global potential VG which are shown in Fig. 3(a). The 1st neuron fires spikes phase-locked to VG at every cycle of VG (i.e., the local potential v1 exhibits a nearly regular phase-locked oscilla- tion). To confirm this 1:1 phase locking, we collect 5 × 104 ISIs from all local neurons, and obtain the ISI histogram [see Fig. 3(b)]. A single peak with a small width is located around the average value (= 97.9 ms) which agrees well with the global period TG of VG. This 1:1 phase locking is expected to occur for the fully-occupied case because the global frequency fG (= 10.2 Hz) of VG is nearly equal to the most probable frequency (= 10.3 Hz) of noise- induced oscillation for the uncoupled single neuron. As a result of such 1:1 phase locking, full occupation occurs in the raster plot. Second, we study the partially-occupied inhibitory case. Figure 3(c) shows the time series of the local potential v1 of the 1st neuron and the global potential VG. The 1st neuron exhibits intermittent spikings phase-locked to VG at ran- dom multiples of the period TG (=54.2 ms) of VG. In addition to these intermittent spiking phases, hopping phases (exhibiting small subthreshold oscillations) appear in most of global cycles. We also note that after occurrence of a spiking, recovery from a hyperpolarized to a resting state is made during the next global cycle. Hence, a "preparatory" phase without spiking and hopping (for preparing for generation of the next spike or hopping) follows 1500 t (ms) (c) 30 -40 30 -40 ) V m ( 1 v ) V m ( G V 2000 1000 y t i l i b a b o r P 0.08 (d) 0.04 0.00 0 9 2000 1500 t (ms) 500 ISI (ms) 1000 (a) 30 ) V m ( 1 v -40 30 ) V m ( G V -40 1000 0.4 (b) y t i l i b a b o r P 0.2 0.0 0 100 ISI (ms) 200 Fig. 3 1:1 phase locking (spikings phase-locked to the global potential VG at every cycle of VG) in N(= 103) globally coupled excitatory ML neurons: (a) time series of the local potential v1 of the 1st neuron and the ensemble-averaged global potential VG and (b) interspike interval (ISI) histogram with a single peak. Stochastic phase locking leading to stochastic spike skipping (intermittent spikings phase-locked to VG at random multiples of the period of VG) in N(= 103) globally coupled inhibitory subthreshold ML neurons: (c) time series of v1 and VG, and (d) ISI histogram with multiple peaks. For both inhibitory and excitatory cases, IDC = 87 m A/cm2, D = 20 m A · ms1/2/cm2, and J = 3 mS/cm2. Vertical dashed lines in (a) and (c) represent the times at which local minima of VG occur. Each ISI histogram in (b) and (d) is made of 5 × 104 ISIs and the bin size for the histogram is 5 ms. Vertical dotted lines in (d) denote integer multiples of the global period TG (=54.2 ms) of VG. each spiking phase (see the gray parts). In this way, the local potential exhibits an irregular firing pattern consisting of randomly phase-locked spiking and hopping phases and prepara- tory phases. We note that a regular fast global oscillation with a small amplitude emerges from these irregular individual oscillations. To confirm the stochastic spike skipping (arising fromn stochastic phase locking) in the local potential, we collect 5 × 104 ISIs from all local neurons and get the ISI histogram. Multiple peaks appear at multiples of the period TG of the global potential VG. However, due to appearance of preparatory cycles, the 1st peak of the histogram (which is the highest one) appears at 2TG (not TG). Hence, local neurons fire mostly in alternate global cycles. Due to this stochastic spike skipping partial occupation occurs in the raster plot. Similar skipping phenomena of spikings (characterized with multi- peaked ISI histograms) were found in single noisy neuron models driven by a weak periodic external force for the stochastic resonance (Longtin 1995, 2000; Gammaitoni et al. 1998). Unlike this single case, stochastic spike skipping in networks of inhibitory subthreshold neurons is a collective effect because it occurs due to a driving by a coherent ensemble- averaged synaptic current. As discussed in details in Section 4, similar results on skipping were also obtained in simplified networks of IF neurons (Brunel and Hakim 1999; Brunel G1 G2 (b) 14 7 0 - 1040 1110 t (ms) 1180 G1 0 G2 2 3 1110 t (ms) 1180 i (d) i O i P i M 1 0 1 0 1 0 2000 3000 0 1000 i 2000 3000 10 (a) -20 ) V m ( -28 G V -36 1040 (c) 0.2 i O 0.0 1 i P 0 0.2 i M 0.0 0 1000 Fig. 4 "Statistical-mechanical" spike-based coherence measure in N(= 103) globally coupled ML neurons for IDC = 87 m A/cm2, D = 20 m A · ms1/2/cm2, and J = 3 mS/cm2. Partially-occupied inhibitory case: (a) time series of the global potential VG, (b) plot of the global phase (F ) versus time (t), and (c) plots of Oi (occupation degree of spikes in the ith stripe), Pi (pacing degree of spikes in the ith stripe), and Mi (spiking measure in the ith stripe) versus i (stripe). In (a) and (b), vertical dashed and solid lines represent the times at which local minima and maxima (denoted by open and solid circles) of VG occur, respectively and Gi (i = 1,2) denotes the ith global cycle. Fully-occupied excitatory case: (d) plots of Oi, Pi, and Mi versus i. 2000; Brunel & Wang 2003). However, there are some differences in the spiking pattern of individual neurons and the effect of noise on the collective coherence. Our main purpose is to quantitatively characterize the stochastic spiking coherence which is well visualized in the raster plot of spikes. To measure the degree of stochas- tic spiking coherence seen in the raster plots in Fig. 2 for D = 20, we introduce a new "statistical-mechanical" spike-based coherence measure Ms by considering the occupation pattern and the pacing pattern of spikes in the stripes of the raster plot. Particularly, the pacing degree between spikes is determined in a statistical-mechanical way by quantifying the average contribution of microscopic individual spikes to the macroscopic global poten- tial VG. The spiking coherence measure Mi of the ith stripe is defined by the product of the occupation degree Oi of spikes (representing the density of the ith stripe) and the pacing degree Pi of spikes (denoting the smearing of the ith stripe): The occupation degree Oi in the ith stripe is given by the fraction of spiking neurons: Mi = Oi · Pi. Oi = N(s) i N , (13) (14) 11 i where N(s) is the number of spiking neurons in the ith stripe. For the full occupation, Oi = 1, while for the partial occupation Oi < 1. The pacing degree Pi of each microscopic spike in the ith stripe can be determined in a statistical-mechanical way by taking into consideration its contribution to the macroscopic global potential VG. Figure 4(a) shows a time series of the global potential VG; local maxima and minima are denoted by solid and open circles, re- spectively. Central maxima of VG between neighboring left and right minima of VG coincide with centers of stripes in the raster plot. The global cycle starting from the left minimum of VG which appears first after the transient time (= 103 ms) is regarded as the 1st one, which is denoted by G1. The 2nd global cycle G2 begins from the next following right minimum of G1, and so on. Then, we introduce an instantaneous global phase F (t) of VG via linear interpolation in the two successive subregions forming a global cycle (Freund et al. 2003). The global phase F (t) between the left minimum (corresponding to the beginning point of the ith global cycle) and the central maximum is given by: F (t) = 2p (i − 3/2) + p t − t(min) i − t(min) t(max) i i ! for t(min) i ≤ t < t(max) i (i = 1, 2, 3, . . .), (15) and F (t) between the central maximum and the right minimum (corresponding to the be- ginning point of the (i + 1)th cycle) is given by: F (t) = 2p (i − 1) + p t − t(max) i+1 − t(max) t(min) i i ! for t(max) i ≤ t < t(min) i+1 (i = 1, 2, 3, . . .), (16) i i where t(min) is the beginning time of the ith global cycle (i.e., the time at which the left minimum of VG appears in the ith global cycle) and t(max) is the time at which the maximum of VG appears in the ith global cycle. The global phase F in the first two global cycles is shown in Fig. 4(b). Then, the contribution of the kth microscopic spike in the ith stripe to VG is given by cosF k, where F k is the global phase at the occurring at the time t(s) k kth spiking time [i.e., F k ≡ F (t(s) k )]. A microscopic spike makes the most constructive (in- phase) contribution to VG when the corresponding global phase F k is 2p n (n = 0, 1, 2, . . .), while it makes the most destructive (anti-phase) contribution to VG when F i is 2p (n − 1/2). By averaging the contributions of all microscopic spikes in the ith stripe to VG, we obtain the pacing degree of spikes in the ith stripe, Pi = 1 Si Si k=1 cosF k, (17) where Si is the total number of microscopic spikes in the ith stripe. By averaging Mi of Eq. (13) over a sufficiently large number Ns of stripes, we obtain the 'statistical-mechanical" spike-based coherence measure Ms: Ms = 1 Ns Ns i=1 Mi. (18) We follow 3 × 103 stripes and get Oi, Pi, and Mi in each ith stripe for the partially- occupied inhibitory case of Fig. 2(b). The results are shown in Fig. 4(c). For comparison, we also measure the degree of stochastic spiking coherence seen in the raster plot of Fig. 2(d) for the fully-occupied excitatory case and give the results in Fig. 4(d). We note a distinct dif- ference in the average occupation degree hOii, where h· · ·i denotes the average over stripes. (cid:229) (cid:229) 12 (a1) 1000 i 500 0 10 0 s N y t i l i b a b o r P 0.08 0.04 0.00 1200 (b1) 200 (c) 0.14 (a2) 1800 1200 (b2) (a3) 1800 1200 t (ms) (b3) (a4) 1800 1200 (b4) 800 200 1.0 800 200 ISI (ms) (d) 800 200 (e) 0.12 1800 800 i > O < 0.07 i > P < 0.5 s M 0.06 0.00 0.90 1.25 log10D 0.0 0.90 1.60 1.25 log10D 0.00 0.90 1.60 1.60 1.25 log10D Fig. 5 Stochastic spiking coherence for various values of D in N(= 103) globally coupled inhibitory sub- threshold ML neurons when IDC = 87 m A/cm2 and J = 3 mS/cm2. (a) Raster plots of spikings (i: neuron in- dex) and plots of number of spikes (Ns) versus time (t) and (b) interspike interval (ISI) histograms for (a1) and (b1) D = 10 m A · ms1/2/cm2, (a2) and (b2) D = 20 m A · ms1/2/cm2, (a3) and (b3) D = 30 m A · ms1/2/cm2, and (a4) and (b4) D = 32 m A · ms1/2/cm2. The bin size for Ns in (a) is 1 ms. Each ISI histogram in (b) is made of 5 × 104 ISIs and the bin size for the histogram is 5 ms. Vertical dotted lines in (b) represent the integer multiples of the global period TG of VG; TG = (b1) 67.4 ms, (b2) 54.2 ms, (b3) 48.6 ms, and (b4) 47.7 ms. (c) Plot of hOii (average occupation degree of spikes) versus log10 D. (d) Plot of hPii (average pacing degree of spikes) versus log10 D. (e) Plot of Ms ("statistical-mechanical" spike-based coherence measure) versus log10 D. To obtain hOii, hPii, and Ms in (c)-(e), we follow the 3 × 103 stripes for each D. Open circles in (c)-(e) denote the data for D = 20 m A · ms1/2/cm2. For the inhibitory case, partial occupation with very small hOii (= 0.106) occurs due to stochastic spike skipping, while for the excitatory case full occupation with hOii = 1 occurs as a result of 1:1 phase locking. For the partially-occupied case of inhibitory coupling, the average pacing degree hPii (= 0.766) is large in contrast to hOii, although it is smaller than hPii (= 0.911) for the fully-occupied case of excitatory coupling. As a result, the "statistical- mechanical" coherence measure Ms (which represents the collective coherence seen in the whole raster plot) is 0.081 for the partially-occupied inhibitory case which is very low when compared with Ms (= 0.911) for the fully-occupied excitatory case. The main reason for the low degree of stochastic spiking coherence is mainly due to partial occupation. Finally, by varying D we characterize the stochastic spiking coherence in terms of the "statistical-mechanical" measure Ms in a population of inhibitory subthreshold ML neurons when IDC = 87 and J = 3. Such stochastic spiking coherence may be well visualized in the raster plots of neural spikes. Figures 5(a1)-5(a4) show the raster plots and the temporal plots of the number of spikes (Ns) for N = 103 in the coherent region for D = 10, 20, 30, and 13 32, respectively. The corresponding ISI histograms are also given in Figs. 5(b1)-5(b4). We measure the degree of stochastic spiking coherence in terms of hOii (average occupation degree), hPii (average pacing degree), and Ms for 20 values of D in the coherent regime, and the results are shown in Figs. 5(c)-5(e). (Here, for comparison with other values of D we include the case of D = 20 which is studied in details above; open circles in Figs. 5(c)-5(e) represent the data for D = 20.) For the coherent case of D=20, the raster plot in Fig. 5(a2) consists of relatively clear partially-occupied stripes with hOii = 0.106 and hPii = 0.766. Such partial occupation results from stochastic spike skipping of individual neurons seen well in the ISI histogram of Fig. 5(b2) with clear (well-separated) multiple peaks appear- ing at nTG (TG: global period of VG and n=2,3,...). As the value of D is increased from 20, the average occupation degree hOii increases only a little, as might be seen from the raster plots and the plots of Ns in Figs. 5(a3) and 5(a4) (hOii = 0.114 and 0.115 for D = 30 and 32, respectively). This slow increase in hOii is well shown in Fig. 5(c). However,the aver- age pacing degree hPii for D > 20 decreases rapidly, as shown in Fig. 5(d). For example, stripes in the raster plots of Figs. 5(a3) and 5(a4) become more and more smeared, and hence the average pacing degree is decreased with increase in D. This smearing of stripes can be understood from the change in the structure of the ISI histograms. As D is increased, the heights of peaks are decreased, but their widths are widened [see Figs. 5(b3) and 5(b4)]. Thus, peaks begin to merge. This merging of peaks results in the smearing of stripes. We note that for large D merged multiple peaks in the ISI histogram are directly associated with smeared partially-occupied stripes in the raster plot. Thus, for D > 20 the degree of stochas- tic spiking coherence is rapidly decreased as shown in Fig. 5(e), mainly due to the rapid decrease in hPii (a little increase in hOii has negligible effect). Eventually, when passing the higher threshold D∗ h (≃ 33.4) stripes no longer exist due to complete smearing, and then incoherent states appear. By decreasing the value of D from 20, we also characterize the stochastic spiking co- herence. As an example see the raster plot of spikes in Fig. 5(a1) for D = 10. The average occupation degree is much decreased to hOii = 0.044, as can also be expected from the plot of Ns. This rapid decrease in hOii for D < 20 can be seen in Fig. 5(c). Contrary to hOii the average pacing degree hPii (= 0.684) for D = 10 is decreased a little when compared to the value of hPii (= 0.766) for D = 20; only a little more smearing occurs. For this case, the ISI histogram has multiple peaks without merging like the case of D=20, as shown in Fig. 5(b1). However, when compared to the case of D = 20 the heights of peaks decrease, and the average ISI increases via appearance of long ISIs. Thus, the degree of stochastic spiking coherence for D = 10 (Ms = 0.032) is much decreased mainly due to rapid decrease in the average occupation degree hOii (small decrease in hPii has only a little effect). In fact, as can be seen in Fig. 5(d) there is no noticeable change in hPii for 10 < D < 20; as D is decreased from 20 to a value of D (≃ 14), hPii increases slowly, and then it begins to de- crease. Thus, for D < 10 both hOii and hPii decreases so rapidly, as shown in Figs. 5(c) and 5(d). Hence, as D is decreased from 10 the degree of stochastic spiking coherence decreases rapidly due to both effects of hOii and hPii. Eventually, when D is decreased through the lower threshold D∗ l (≃ 9.4), completely scattered sparse spikes appear without forming any stripes in the raster plot, and thus incoherent states exist for D < D∗ l . In this way, we char- acterize the stochastic spiking coherence in terms of the "statistical-mechanical" measure Ms in the whole coherent region, and find that Ms reflects the degree of collective coherence seen in the raster plot very well. When taking into consideration both the occupation degree and the pacing degree of spikes in the raster plot, a maximal spiking coherence occurs near D ≃ 20 [see Fig. 5(e)]. As discussed in details in Section 1, Ms is in contrast to the conven- tional measures where any quantitative relation between (microscopic) individual spikes and 14 the (macroscopic) global potential VG is not considered [e.g., the "thermodynamic" order parameter (Golomb & Rinzel 1994; Hansel & Mato 2003), the "microscopic" correlation- based measure (Wang & Buzs´aki 1996; White et al. 1998), and the PSTH-based measures of precise spike timing (Mainen & Sejnowski 1995; Schreiber et al. 2003)]. 4 Summary By changing the noise intensity, we have characterized stochastic spiking coherence in an in- hibitory population of subthreshold biological ML neurons. In a range of intermediate noise intensity, a regularly oscillating global potential VG (with reduced amplitude and the in- creased frequency) emerges via cooperation of irregular individual firing activities. We note that this stochastic spiking coherence may be well visualized in the raster plot of spikes. For the case of a coherent state, partially-occupied stripes appear in the raster plot. This partial occupation occurs due to stochastic spike skipping, which is shown clearly in the multi- peaked ISI histogram. Recently, Brunel and Hakim (1999) have obtained similar results on spike skipping in a simplified network of integrate-and-fire (IF) neurons which are randomly connected via instantaneous inhibitory synapses (modeled by the delta function with a trans- mission delay). [Such skipping was also reported in the network of inhibitory and excitatory IF neurons (Brunel 2000; Brunel & Wang 2003).] For the case of the IF neuron a spike is triggered instantaneously when the membrane potential reaches a threshold, in contrast to the case of the biological ML neuron where dynamics of voltage-gated ion channels leads to spike generation. As the stimulus exceeds a threshold, the firing frequency of the IF neuron begins to increase from zero (i.e., the IF neuron exhibits the type-I excitability), unlike the case of the type-II ML neuron (used in our computational study). These type-I IF neurons are driven by random excitatory inputs activated by independent Poisson processes. In this sim- plified network, it was shown that weakly coherent global activities (roughly corresponding to the global potential VG) emerge from irregular firing patterns of neurons [refer to Figure 3 in the paper of Brunel and Hakim (1999)]. The collective coherence was well shown in the temporal auto-correlation function of the global activity. Although the basic results in the simplified network are similar to ours in a realistic network, there are some differences in the spiking pattern of individual neurons. The stochastic spike emission of individual IF neurons was well shown in the Poissonian ISI histogram showing little indication of the collective be- havior. Since no clear multiple peaks appear in the Poisson-like ISI histogram, the individual IF neurons exhibit more stochastic spike emission than the ML neurons, although weak col- lective coherence occurs in both cases. There are some additional differences in the effect of the external noise on the collective coherence. As the magnitude of the external noise is in- creased from zero and passes a threshold, the global activity was found to exhibit a transition from an oscillatory to a stationary state (Brunel and Hakim 1999). Thus, incoherent states appear for the case of strong noise. On the other hand, through competition between the constructive role (stimulating coherence between noise-induced spikes) and the destructive role (spoiling the collective coherence) of noise, stochastic spiking coherence (in our work) appears in a range of intermediate noise intensities. Hence, incoherent states appear for both cases of sufficiently strong and weak noise. These differences in both the spiking pattern of individual neurons and the noise effect on the collective coherence seem to arise mainly from different types of drivings on individual neurons; IF neurons are driven by random ex- citatory inputs activated by Poisson processes, while ML neurons are driven by a Gaussian white noise in addition to a subthreshold DC stimulus. The main purpose of our work is to quantitatively measure the degree of stochastic spiking coherence seen in the raster plot. 15 We have introduced a new type of spike-based coherence measure Ms by taking into con- sideration the occupation degree and the pacing degree of spikes in the stripes. Particularly, the pacing degree between spikes is determined in a statistical-mechanical way by quantify- ing the average contribution of (microscopic) individual spikes to the (macroscopic) global potential VG. This "statistical-mechanical" measure Ms is in contrast to the conventional measures (e.g., the "thermodynamic" order parameter, the "microscopic" correlation-based measure, and the PSTH-based measures of precise spike timing) where any quantitative re- lation between the microscopic individual spikes and the macroscopic global potential VG is not considered. In terms of Ms, we have quantitatively characterized the stochastic spik- ing coherence, and found that Ms reflects the degree of collective spiking coherence seen in the raster plot very well. Finally, we also expect that Ms may be implemented to character- ize the degree of collective spiking coherence in an experimentally-obtained raster plot of neural spikes. Acknowledgements This research was supported by the Basic Science Research Program through the Na- tional Research Foundation of Korea funded by the Ministry of Education, Science and Technology (2009- 0070865). S.-Y. Kim thanks Dr. D.-G. Hong for his interest in our work. References Borgers, C. & Kopell, N. (2003). Synchronization in networks of excitatory and inhibitory neurons with sparse, random connectivity. Neural Computation, 15, 509-538. Borgers, C. & Kopell, N. (2005). Effects of noisy drive on rhythms in networks of excitatory and inhibitory neurons. Neural Computation, 17, 557-608. Brunel, N. & Hakim, V. (1999). Fast global oscillations in networks of intergrate-and-fire neurons with low firing rates. Neural Computation, 11, 1621-1671. Brunel, N. (2000). Dynamics of sparsely connected networks of excitatory and inhibitory spiking neurons. Journal of Computational Neuroscience, 8, 183-208. Brunel, N. & Wang, X.-J. (2003). What determines the frequency of fast network oscillations with irregular neural discharge? I. Snaptic dynamics and excitation-inhibition balance. Journal of Neurophysiology, 90, 415-430. Buzs´aki, G., Geisler, C., Henze, D. A., & Wang, X.-J. (2004). Interneuron diversity series: Circuit complexity and axon wiring economy of cortical interneurons. Trends in Neuroscience, 27, 186-193. Buzs´aki, G. (2006). Rhythms of the Brain. New York: Oxford University Press. Freund, J., Schimansky-Geier, L., & Hanggi, P. (2003). Frequency and phase synchronization in stochastic systems. Chaos, 13, 225-238. Gammaitoni, L., Hanggi, P., Jung, P., & Marchesoni, F. (1998). Stochastic resonance. Reviews of Modern Physics, 70, 223-287. Golomb, D. & Rinzel, J. (1994). Clustering in globally coupled inhibitory neurons. Physica D, 72, 259-282. Gray, C. M. (1994). Synchronous oscillations in neuronal systems: Mechanisms and functions. Journal of Computational Neuroscience, 1, 11-38. Grosse, P., Cassidy, M. J., & Brown, P. (2002). EEG-EMG, MEG-EMG and EMG-EMG frequency analysis: Physiological principles and clinical applications. Clinical Neurophysiology, 113, 1523-1531. Hansel, D., Mato, G., & Meunier, C. (1995). Synchrony in excitatory neural networks. Neural Computation, 7, 307-337. Hansel, D. & Mato, G. (2003). Asynchronous states and the emergence of synchrony in large networks of interacting excitatory and inhibitory neurons. Neural Computation, 15, 1-56. Hauschildt, B., Janson, N. B., Balanov, A., & Scholl, E. (2006). Noise-induced cooperative dynamics and its control in coupled neuron models. Physical Review E, 74, 051906. Hodgkin, A. L. (1948). The local electric changes associated with repetitive action in a non-medullated axon. Journal of Physiology, 107, 165-181. Izhikevich, E. M. (2000). Neural excitability, spiking and bursting. International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos, 10, 1171-1266. Kuramoto, Y. (1991). Collective synchronization of pulse-coupled oscillators and excitable units. Physica D, 50, 15-30. 16 Lim, W. & Kim, S.-Y. (2007). Characterization of stochastic spiking coherence in coupled neurons. Journal of the Korean Physical Society, 51, 1427-1431. Lim, W. & Kim, S.-Y. (2009). Stochastic spiking coherence in coupled subthreshold Morris-Lecar neurons. International Journal of Modern Physics B, 23, 703-710. Longtin, A. (1995). Synchronization of the stochastic Fitzhugh-Nagumo equations to periodic forcing. Nuovo Cimento D, 17, 835-846. Longtin, A. (2000). Stochastic aspects of neural phase locking to periodic signals. In Kim S., Lee K. J., & Sung W. (Eds.), Stochastic Dynamics and Pattern Formation in Biological and Complex Systems (pp. 219-239). New York: AIP. Mainen, Z. F. & Sejnowski T. J. (1995). Reliability of spike timing in neocortical neurons. Science, 268, 1503-1506. Manrubia, S. C., Mikhailov, A. S., & Zanette, D. H. (2004). Emergence of Dynamical Order. Singapore: World Scientific. Mirollo, R. E. & Strogatz, S. H. (1990). Synchronization of pulse-coupled biological oscillators. SIAM Jour- nal on Applied Mathematics, 50, 1645-1662. Morris, C. & Lecar, H. (1981). Voltage oscillations in the barnacle giant muscle fiber. Biophysical Journal, 35, 193-213. Rinzel, J. & Ermentrout, B. (1998). Analysis of neural excitability and oscillations. In Koch, C. & Segev, I. (Eds.), Methods in Neural Modeling: from Ions to Networks (pp. 251-292). Cambridge: MIT Press. San Miguel, M. & Toral, R. (2000). Stochastic effect in physical systems. In Martinez, J., Tiemann, R., & Tirapegui, E. (Eds.), Instabilities and Nonequilibrium Structures VI (pp. 35-130) Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publisher. Schreiber, S., Fellous, J. M., Whitmer, D., Tiesinga, P., & Sejnowski, T. J. (2003), A new correlation-based measure of spike timing reliability. Neurocomputing, 52-54, 925-931. Tass, P., Rosenblum, M. G., Weule, J., Kurths, J., Pikovsky, A., Volkmann, J., Schnitzler, A., & Freud, H. J. (1998). Detection of n : m phase locking from noisy data: application to magnetoencephalography. Physical Review Letters, 81, 3291-3294. Tiesinga, P. H. E., Fellous, J.-M., Jose, J. V., & Sejnowski, T. J. (2001). Computational model of carbachol- induced delta, theta, and gamma oscillations in the hippocampus. Hippocampus, 11, 251-274. Tsumoto, K., Kitajima, H., Yoshinaga, T., Aihara, K., & Kawakami, H. (2006). Bifurcations in Morris-Lecar neuron model. Neurocomputing, 69, 293-316. Vreeswijk, C. van, Abbott, L. F., & Ermentrout, G. B. (1994). When inhibition not excitation synchronizes neural firing. Journal of Computational Neuroscience, 1, 313-321. Wang, X.-J. & Rinzel, J. (1992). Alternating and synchronous rhythms in reciprocally inhibitory model neu- rons. Neural Computation, 4, 84-97. Wang, X.-J. & Buzs´aki, G. (1996). Gamma oscillations by synaptic inhibition in a hippocampal interneuronal network. The Journal of Neuroscience, 16, 6402-6413. Wang, X.-J. (2003). Neural oscillations. In Nadel, L. (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Cognitive Science (pp. 272-280). London: MacMillan. Wang, Y., Chik, D. T. W., & Wang, Z. D. (2000). Coherence resonance and noise-induced synchronization in globally coupled Hodgkin-Huxley neurons. Physical Review E, 61, 740-746. White, J., Chow, C. C., Ritt, J., Soto-Trevino, C., & Kopell, N. (1998). Synchronization and oscillatory dynamics in heterogeneous, mutually inhibited neurons. Journal of Computational Neuroscience, 5, 5- 16. Whittington, M. A., Traub, R. D., Kopell, N., Ermentrout, B., & Buhl, E. H. (2000). Inhibition-based rhythms: experimental and mathematical observations on network dynamics. International Journal of Psychophys- iology, 38, 315-336.
1010.0617	1	1010	2010-10-04T15:06:08	Bone in vivo: Surface mapping technique	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.med-ph" ]	Bone surface mapping technique is proposed on the bases of two kinds of uniqueness of bone in vivo, (i) magnitude of the principal moments of inertia, (ii) the direction cosines of principal axes of inertia relative to inertia reference frame. We choose the principal axes of inertia as the bone coordinate system axes. The geographical marks such as the prime meridian of the bone in vivo are defined and methods such as tomographic reconstruction and boundary development are employed so that the surface of bone in vivo can be mapped. Experimental results show that the surface mapping technique can both reflect the shape and help study the surface changes of bone in vivo. The prospect of such research into the surface shape and changing laws of organ, tissue or cell will be promising.	physics.bio-ph	physics	1 Bone in vivo: Surface mapping technique Yifang Fan1,∗, Yubo Fan2, Zhiyu Li3, Changsheng Lv1 1 Center for Scientific Research, Guangzhou Institute of Physical Education, Guangzhou 510500, P.R. China 2 Bioengineering Department, Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Beijing 100191, P.R. China 3 College of Foreign Languages, Jinan University, Guangzhou 510632, P.R. China ∗ E-mail: [email protected] Abstract Abstract: Bone surface mapping technique is proposed on the bases of two kinds of uniqueness of bone in vivo, (i) magnitude of the principal moments of inertia, (ii) the direction cosines of principal axes of inertia relative to inertia reference frame. We choose the principal axes of inertia as the bone coordinate system axes. The geographical marks such as the prime meridian of the bone in vivo are defined and methods such as tomographic reconstruction and boundary development are employed so that the surface of bone in vivo can be mapped. Experimental results show that the surface mapping technique can both reflect the shape and help study the surface changes of bone in vivo. The prospect of such research into the surface shape and changing laws of organ, tissue or cell will be promising. Introduction The shape of bone is the adaptive result of bone in the mechanical and physiological environment [1–4]. A map, the visual representation of our real world symbol model, can reveal not only the spatial structure properties of an object but also the changes in time series [5–7]. The mapping of bone surface, therefore, is used as an approach to study the adaptability of bone morphology. Mapping technique has become an even more powerful and useful method to do scientific research. Mapping and flattening techniques have also been widely used in medical research [8–13]. They are both concerned with the development methods. The flattening technique develops the three-dimensional object to a two-dimensional one [14] while the mapping technique plays an essential role in interpreting the surface structure of an object [15]. The advancements and improvements of three-dimensional imaging of bone in vivo [16–18] have brought better data collection methods of bone surface, but the mapping techniques have not been systematically explored with satisfactory results. To map the bone surface, some geographic marks and geographic coordinates such as the bone surface prime meridian, the equator line or the contour should be identified [19]. They should be defined on the In order to study the bone’s changes caused by the external factors, it is bone’s coordinate system. fundamental to set up a bone coordinate system when mapping the bone surface. In our study, we have set up a coordinate system with uniqueness on the principal axes of inertia of the bone in vivo. The coordinate system is thus employed to determine the prime meridian, and the average radius of the tomographic boundary is employed to determine the contour to map the bone surface. This means that the bone surface mapping technique could present an alternate approach to study the bone’s morphology. Standardized coordinate system of bone The CT image of bone in vivo can generate the principal moments of inertia and the direction cosines [20]. Suppose the moment of inertia of the bone’s tissue relative to its center of mass is a constant; then the magnitude of the bone’s principal moments of inertia will be determined by its shape and mass distribution. The inertia tensor suggests that we can always find a group of coordinate systems where 2 three products of inertia will be nil at the same time [21, 22]. The magnitudes of these three principal moments of inertia could come out with three results: (i) all three are equal; (ii) two out of three are equal and (iii) each one is different from the other. When the object is homogeneous, in the first case, it is a sphere; in the second, an ellipsoid, a cube, a cylinder or a rectangular. When the bone’s location and orientation relative to inertia reference frame (i.e. the coordinate system is defined by the CT coordinate system) are fixed, in the first case, there are numerous principal axes of inertia, while in the second case, the orientation of one principal axis can be determined, but not the other two. Therefore, in the first and second case, the principal moments of inertia have nothing to do with their principal axes of inertia. In the third case, however, the direction cosines of the bone’s principal axis of inertia relative to inertia reference frame are unique, which means a one-to-one corresponding relation between the direction cosines of the bone’s principal axes of inertia and its shape. If the bone is defined as a collection of elements of volume ∆V , the element’s position can be repre- sented by (xoi, yoi, zoi) (where o is located in the center of mass ), then the magnitude of the principal moments of inertia can be represented respectively by: Ix = P(cid:0)y2 Iy = P(cid:0)x2 Iz = P(cid:0)x2 oi + z2 oi + z2 oi + y2 oi(cid:1) ρi∆V oi(cid:1) ρi∆V oi(cid:1) ρi∆V, (1) where ρ is the density, ∆V = ∆x∆y∆z, ∆x and ∆y are the pixel sizes and ∆z the layer distances of CT images. Let the angular displacements of the bone that take turns to rotate around axes x, y, z be α, β, γ. According to Equations 1, we can set up the following equation: (Iy − Iz)α = P[(yoi cos α − zoi sin α)2 − (yoi sin α + zoi cos α)2]ρi∆V (Ix − Iz)β = P[(xoi cos β + zoi sin β)2 − (xoi sin β − zoi cos β)2]ρi∆V (Ix − Iy)γ = P[(xoi cos γ − yoi sin γ)2 − (xoi sin γ + yoi cos γ)2]ρi∆V. Next, differentiate Eq. 2, and let d (Iy − Iz)α dα , d (Ix − Iz)β dβ , d (Ix − Iy)γ dγ , which will generate the following equation: α = 1 β = 1 γ = 1 2 arctan(cid:18) 2 arctan(cid:18) 2 arctan(cid:18) 2 P(yoizoiρi∆V ) oiρi∆V )−P(z2 P(y2 2 P(xαizαiρi∆V ) αiρi∆V )−P(z2 P(x2 2 P(xβiyβiρi∆V ) βiρi∆V )−P(y2 P(x2 oiρi∆V )(cid:19) αiρi∆V )(cid:19) βiρi∆V )(cid:19) (A) (B) (C). (2) (3) It is apparent that when and ONLY when Ix 6= Iy 6= Iz will Eq. 3 have a set of solutions. P yiziρi∆V , P ziziρi∆V and P xiyiρi∆V are three products of inertia of inertia tensor. Within the range of [0, π], according to Eqs. 2 and 3, the limited rotations can always turn three products of inertia into zero at the same time. The bone’s shape is asymmetrical and its structure is anisotropic [23–27]. Eq. 3 exposes the direction cosines of principal axes of inertia relative to the inertia reference frame of the bone characterization are unique. As a result, the coordinate system set upon the principal moment of inertia can not only depict the position and orientation of the bone, but also verify the bone surface shape and its changes when making a quantitative analysis. Eqs. 2 and 3 also suggest that we can set up a coordinate system whose coordinate origin is located arbitrarily at the center of mass of the bone. After limited rotations, the coordinate axes is positioned on the principal axes of inertia. Mapping of the Bone surface CT scanning simplifies the bone as a collection of elements of volume ∆V (different densities). When performing an isotropic scanning (where pixel size must be the same as the layer distance), the volume of ∆V is a constant. The position of ∆V relative to the center of mass differs from one another. When the result of Eq. 3 is replaced for that in Eq. 2 accordingly and when the bone’s coordinate system is positioned on the principal axes of inertia, the rotation will change the original CT image. It is necessary, then, to reconstruct the new image, which can be performed by the following equation: 3 ∆x xi = trunc(cid:16) xoi−min(xoi) yi = trunc(cid:16) yoi−min(yoi) zi = trunc(cid:16) zoi−min(zoi) (cid:17) ∆x + min(xoi) (cid:17) ∆y + min(yoi) (cid:17) ∆z + min(zoi), ∆y ∆z (4) where (xoi, yoi, zoi) stands for the position of ∆V after rotation, (xi, yi, zi) for that of the reconstructed tomogram and trunc() for a function that truncates a number to an integer by removing the fractional part of the number. To keep the CT images isotropic, ∆dx = ∆dy = ∆dz is defined in Eq. 4, and its pixal size and layer distance are kept the same of those of the original image. According to Eq. 4, when keeping the ∆V to be in a cube, the new CT image after rotation remains to be closed and continuous. CT scanning divides the bone surface into a collection of the tomographic image boundaries. In this way, the mapping of the bone surface has become an issue to develop the tomographic boundary, making it necessary to detect and draw the tomographic boundary. Before a new CT scanning, the equipment is reset, i.e. the gray value of the air is set as zero. The scanned tomographic images of bone are processed by Eq. 4, and their boundaries are drawn by the following equation: ρ(x, y)z = ρ(x, y)z ρ(x, y)z ρ(x, y)z ρ(x, y)z 0 other, ρ(x, y)z > 0, ρ(x + 1, y)z = 0 ρ(x, y)z > 0, ρ(x − 1, y)z = 0 ρ(x, y)z > 0, ρ(x, y + 1)z = 0 ρ(x, y)z > 0, ρ(x, y − 1)z = 0 (5)     where z is the number of sequence of tomogram, (x, y)z the position of ∆V relative to the tomographic center of mass and ρ(x, y)z the density of (x, y)z. When mapping the bone surface, the bone will be ”cut” - from a cylindrical surface to a rectangle, or a rhombus. However it is cut, its ultimate area would be the same. But when it is a rectangle, there is only one. How to cut the bone into a rectangle? The two principal axes of inertia (the minimal and maximal principal moment of inertia) form a plane. On this plane, the bone surface boundary is called the prime meridian, which is used as the surface cutting line to develop the bone surface. The following equation will make it happen: i = z > yc z xi z = xc z − xc xi xi z − xc z, yi z = −∆x, yi z = −2∆x, yi 0 1 2 · · · z − xc xi n − 1 z = ∆x, yi xi z − xc n z = 2∆x, yi z > yc z z > yc z, z > yc z z > yc z (6) where (xi z, yi of mass, (xc the sequence of ∆V of the boundary after being cut. z) is the position of the ∆V at the tomographic boundary relative to the tomographic center z, yc z) the position of tomographic center of mass relative to the inertia reference frame and i Eq. 6 sequences the ∆V s at the tomographic boundary which has been cut. The average radium of the tomographic boundary perpendicular to the minimal (maximal) principal moment of inertia is defined as the ”sea level”, which is used as a datum line so that the tomographic boundary can be developed by the following equation: 4 p(x, y)z = p(cid:0)i + xc z, hi z(cid:1)z , z = ri z − rz, ri (7) z − xc z)2 + (yi z − yc z)2 and where z shares the same definition of that in Eq. 5, hi rz = P rj z) and (xi z, yc z, yi n , (xc z z) have the same definitions as those in Eq. 6. z = p(xi Eqs. 4- 7 have developed the closed surface into an open three-dimensional curved one with the properties of a contour. The three-dimensional curved map of the bone surface can be further developed into a two-dimensional plane. We can, however, translate the bone surface into a plane with the help of the following equation: p(x, y) = p(cid:18)Z (cid:18)ql2(i) + Z 2 i(cid:19) di,Z (cid:16)ql2(j) + Z 2 j(cid:17) dj(cid:19) , (8) where p(x, y) presents the position of ∆V in a plane whose surface has been flattened, and l(i) = q(zi − zi−1)2 + Z 2 i , Zi = Z zi − zi−1di, l(j) = q(zj − zj−1)2 + Z 2 j , Zj = Z zj − zj−1dj, z stands for the value of contour on (i, j) in bone surface mapping. Eq. 8 suggests that the mapping of the bone surface actually serves as a simulation of the bone surface structure. It is a space model of an image symbol to represent the bone surface. It shares the consistency with the real body of the bone surface structure. Experiment Prior to our study, the Ethic Committee of Guangzhou Institute of Physical Education has proved our study and the participant has provided fully informed consent to participate in this study by signing a written consent form. From January 2008 to August 2009, we followed the track of Guangdong Provincial Youth Team of Male Wrestlers by using a 64 slice scanner (Brilliance 64, Philips Medical Systems). Excluding team members who left the team halfway and those with injuries, in January 2008 and August 2009, we were able to scan and collect the data of a 25-year-old wrestler’s sesamoid bones beneath the head of the first metatarsal bone of both feet. See Table 1 for information of the sesamoid bones. In Table 1, the volumes of left and right foot’s internal and external sesamoid bone have changed by 0.26%, −1.98%, 0.38% and −1.32% respectively; their surface areas have changed by 0.22%, −0.41%, 0.54% and −0.23% respectively and their density by 0.85%, 1.45%, 2.40% and 3.77% respectively. Let’s make a mapping analysis to the right foot’s external sesamoid beneath the head of the first metatarsal bone. First, rotate the first-time scanned sesamoid bone around axis x from 0 to 180 degrees. According to Eq. 2, the variations of (Iy − Iz)α, (Ix − Iz)β and (Ix − Iy)γ are shown in Fig. 1, indicating that within the range of rotation from 0 to 180 degrees, an extremum exists in Eq. 2. We can get the result of α = 157.73 when the extremum is calculated by Eq. 3A. After the sesamoid bone rotates around axis x at 157.63 degree, it then rotates around axis y. The calculation by Eq. 3B generates the result of β = 8.92. When the sesamoid bone rotates around axis y at 8.92 degree, the calculation of Eq. 3C generates the result of γ = 172.07. When the coordinate system of the sesamoid bone rotate around axes xyz at 157.63/8.92/172.07 degree respectively, the axes of of the sesamoid bone coincide with those of the principal moments of inertia. It’s shown that the morphologically asymmetric and heterogeneously distributed bone has the unique- ness of direction cosines of their principal moments of inertia. An arbitrary coordinate system set upon the bone’s center of mass can make every coordinate axis coincide with the principal moment of inertia by 5 coordinate transformation, i.e. the proposed principal axis’s coordinate system has its uniqueness. This method can be applied to both the homogeneous asymmetric geometry and the heterogeneous asymmetric geometry. The principal axes of sesamoid bone is set up by Eqs. 2 and 3; the tomography of sesamoid bone is reconstructed after it is rotated by Eq. 4; the boundary of the sesamoid bone is drawn by Eq. 5. When the prime meridian is determined by the principal axes, the sesamoid bone surface is developed by Eq. 6 and the mapping of the sesamoid bone surface is accomplished by Eq. 7. See Fig. 2. Figs. 2A and 2B indicate that the mapping technique can better illustrate the bone surface properties. Fig. 2C suggests that the mapping technique can be used as a quantitative method to study the changes of an object’s shape. Using the bone surface mapping, Eq. 8 can flatten the bone surface as a plane. See Fig. 3. It can be concluded that the professional training has caused adaptative changes of the sesamoid bone’s shape. The structural changes can be depicted by the density and distribution while the shape and its changes can be analyzed by the bone surface mapping. Conclusion The generalized Papoulis theorem [29] elucidates that the bone surface shape keeps its geometric invari- ance, such as rotation, translation or dimension change [30, 31]. This ensures the consistency of the CT scanning results of different postures of bone in vivo when its isotropy is ascertained. The uniqueness of the relative consistency of the inertia reference system of principal moments of inertia on direction cosines provide evidence to the bone surface mapping technique. The characters such as the geometric invariance and the uniqueness of the coordinate system of the principal moments of inertia have enabled the bone surface mapping technique to depict the bone’s external morphological characters. This can advance the research of the morphological mechanisms. The experiment of the bone in vivo signifies that the bone mapping technique adds another research method and supplements the analytical method of the bone’s three-dimensional imaging technique. We can understand the world through a map. When the bone surface mapping technique reveals its surface information through a ”map”, the activities of our life evolve continuously on this map. We anticipate that this mapping technique will be widely used in related disciplines. Acknowledgments The authors would like to acknowledge the support from the subject. References 1. Buckwalter JA, Glimcher MJ, Cooper RR, Recker R (1995) Bone biology. II: Formation, form, modeling, remodeling, and regulation of cell function. J Bone Joint Surg Am 77: 1276-1289. 2. Nomura S, Takano-Yamamoto T (2000) Molecular events caused by mechanical stress in bone. Matrix Biol 19: 91-96. 3. Hugate R, Pennypacker J, Saunders M, Juliano P (2004) The effects of intratendinous and retro- calcaneal intrabursal injections of corticosteroid on the biomechanical properties of rabbit Achilles tendons. J Bone Joint Surg Am 86:794-801. 4. Canalis E, Giustina A, Bilezikian JP (2007) Mechanisms of anabolic therapies for osteoporosis. N Engl J Med 357: 905-916. 6 5. Anas A, Arnott R, Small KA (1998) Urban spatial structure. J Econ Lit 36: 1426-1464. 6. Legendre P (1993) Spatial autocorrelation: trouble or new paradigm? Ecology 74: 1659-1673. 7. Barnes WL, Dereux A, Ebbesen TW (2003) Surface plasmon subwavelength optics. Nature 424: 824-830. 8. Wang BC (1985) Resolution of phase ambiguity in macromolecular crystallography. Methods En- zymol. 115: 90-112 9. Suri J, Singh S, Reden L (2002) Computer vision and pattern recognition techniques for 2-D and 3-D MR cerebral cortical segmentation (Part I): A state-of-the-art review. Pattern Anal Appl 5: 46-76. 10. Cuntz H, Forstner F, Haag J, Borst A (2008) The morphological identity of insect dendrites. PLoS Comput Biol 4(12): e1000251. 11. Bates E, Wilson SM, Saygin AP, Dick F, Sereno MI, Knight RT, et al. (2003) Voxel-based lesion- symptom mapping. Nat Neurosci 6: 448-50. 12. Morley M, Molony CM, Weber TM, Devlin JL, Ewens KG, et al. (2004) Genetic analysis of genome- wide variation in human gene expression. Nature 430: 743-747. 13. Saenz M, Buracas GT, Boynton GM (2002) Global effects of feature-based attention in human visual cortex. Nat Neurosci 5: 631-632. 14. Bennis C, Vezien JM, Iglesias G (1991) Piecewise flattening for non-distorted texture mapping. ACM SIGGRAPH Computer Graphics. 25: 237-246. 15. Haker S, Angenent S, Tannenbaum A, Kikinis R, Sapiro G, Halle M (2000) Conformal surface parameterization for texture mapping. IEEE TVCG 6: 181-189. 16. Keyak JH, Meagher JM, Skinner HB, Mote CD (1990) Automated three-dimensional finite element modelling of bone: a new method. J Biomed Eng 12: 389-397. 17. Bouxsein ML, Karasik D (2006) Bone geometry and skeletal fragility. Curr Osteoporos Rep 4: 49-56. 18. Matthews F, Messmer P, Raikov V, Wanner GA (2009) Ptient-specific three-dimensional composite bone models for teaching and operation planning. J Digit Imaging 22: 473-482. 19. Davies ME, Abalakin VK, Bursa M, Lieske, J H, Morando B, Morrison D, Seidelmann PK, Sinclair AT, Yallop B, Tjuflin YS (1996) Report of the IAU/IAG/COSPAR Working Group on cartographic coordinates and rotational elements of the planets and satellites: 1994. Celest Mech Dynam Astron 63: 127-148. 20. Coburn JC, Upal MA, Crisco JJ (2007) Coordinate systems for the carpal bones of the wrist. J Biomech 40: 203-209. 21. Hinrichs RN, Lallement SR, Belson RC (1982) An investigation of the inertial properties of back- packs loaded in various configurations. Tech Rep NATICK/TR-82/023 1: 1-74. 22. Nikravesh P, Lin YS (2005) Use of principal axes as the floating reference frame for a moving deformable body. Multibody Syst Dyn 13: 211-231. 7 23. Biewener AA, Thomason J, Lanyon LE (1983) Mechanics of locomotion and jumping in the forelimb of the horse (Equus): in vivo stress developed in the radius and metacarpus. J Zool 201: 67-82. 24. Hans D, Fuerst T, Duboeuf F (1997) Quantitative ultrasound bone measurement. Eur Radiol 7 (Suppl.2): S43-S50. 25. Kleber AG, Rudy Y (2004) Basic mechanisms of cardiac impulse propagation and associated ar- rhythmias. Physiol Rev 84: 431-488. 26. Ketcham RA, Ryan TM (2004) Quantification and visualization of anisotropy in trabecular bone. J Microscopy 213: 158-171. 27. Fink WL, Humphries JH (2010) Morphological description of the extinct North American Sucker Moxostoma lacerum (Ostariophysi, Catostomidae), Based on high-resolution X-Ray computed to- mography. Copeia 2010: 5-13. 28. Gu X, Gortler SJ, Hoppe H, (2002) Gometry images. ACM SIGGRAPH 355-361 29. Papoulis A, Signal Analysis. New-York: McGraw-Hill, 1977. 30. Nguyen N, Milanfar P (2000) A wavelet-based interpolation-restoration method for superresolution (wavelet superresolution). Circ Syst Signal Pr 19: 321-338. 31. Rochefort G, Champagnat F, Le Besnerais G, Giovannelli JF (2006) An improved observation model for super-resolution under affine motion. IEEE T Image Process 15: 3325-3337. Table 1: Sesamoid bone volume, surface area and density of two measurements 8 First volume mm3 307.06 204.35 257.84 205.87 surface mm2 247.41 184.18 209.59 181.61 Left - external Left - internal Right - external Right - internal Second volume density mg/mm3 mm3 1.84 1.94 1.87 1.89 307.87 200.38 28.83 203.13 surface mm2 247.96 183.43 210.73 181.20 density mg/mm3 1.85 1.97 1.92 1.97 Iy−Iz Ix−Iz Ix−Iy i s e x a l a p c n i r p e h t f o a i t r e n i f o s t n e m o M 2000 1500 1000 500 0 −500 −1000 −1500 −2000 0 50 100 150 Angular displacement 200 250 300 350 Figure 1: The variations of the axis moment of inertia of the first measurement of the wrestler’s lower external sesamoid bone of the first metatarsal bone accompanying the changes of right foot. 9 A 5 0 e n i l r u o t n o C −5 100 B 5 0 e n i l r u o t n o C −5 100 80 60 40 20 Principal axis of inertia (min) 0 0 20 100 80 80 60 60 40 Principal axis of inertia (max) Principal axis of inertia (min) 40 20 0 0 20 60 40 Principal axis of inertia (max) 100 80 C 5 0 e n i l r u o t n o C −5 100 80 60 40 Principal axis of inertia (min) 20 0 0 20 100 80 60 40 Principal axis of inertia (max) Figure 2: Surface mapping of bone. Fig. 2A Surface mapping of the first measurement of the wrestler right foot’s external sesamoid bone beneath the head of the first metatarsal bone. Fig. 2B Surface mapping of the second measurement of the wrestler right foot’s external sesamoid bone beneath the head of the first metatarsal bone. Fig. 2C Variations of the surface mapping of the wrestler right foot’s external sesamoid bone beneath the head of the first metatarsal bone after 18 months (the second measurement). Figs. 2A, 2B and 2C have been rated by percentage and smoothed. A closed bone surface means that when it is continuous, there is no boundary. But when the surface is cut by the prime meridian, a boundary emerges. So when smoothing the surface, cloud computing method is adopted [28] to ensure the integrity of the object’s shape. 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 ) x a m ( a i t r e n i f o i s x a l i a p c n i r P 0 0 0.1 0.2 A B 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 ) x a m ( a i t r e n i f o i s x a l i a p c n i r P 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 Principal axis of inertia (min) 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 0 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 Principal axis of inertia (min) Figure 3: Flattened plane of bone. Fig. 3A The flattened bone surface of the first measurement of the wrestler’s lower external sesamoid bone of the first metatarsal bone. Fig. 3B The flattened bone surface of the second measurement of the wrestler’s lower external sesamoid bone of the first metatarsal bone after 18 months.
1812.02296	1	1812	2018-12-04T10:19:06	Temperature changes accompanying signal propagation in axons	[ "physics.bio-ph", "physics.med-ph" ]	In this paper mathematical models are formulated in order to simulate heat production and corresponding temperature changes which accompany the propagation of an axon potential. Based on earlier experimental results, several models are proposed. Together with the earlier system of coupled differential equations derived by the authors for describing the electrical and mechanical components of signalling in nerve fibres, the novel results permit to cast the whole process of signalling into one system. The emphasis is on the mathematical description of coupling forces. The numerical results are qualitatively similar to experiments.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Temperature changes accompanying signal propagation in axons Kert Tamm∗, Juri Engelbrecht, Tanel Peets Department of Cybernetics, School of Science, Tallinn University of Technology, Akadeemia tee 21, Tallinn 12618, Estonia E-mail: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] Abstract. In this paper mathematical models are formulated in order to simulate heat production and corresponding temperature changes which accompany the propagation of an axon potential. Based on earlier experimental results, several models are proposed. Together with the earlier system of coupled differential equations derived by the authors for describing the electrical and mechanical components of signalling in nerve fibres, the novel results permit to cast the whole process of signalling into one system. The emphasis is on the mathematical description of coupling forces. The numerical results are qualitatively similar to experiments. Key words: mathematical modelling, action potential, heat production, temperature. 1. INTRODUCTION The generation of heat accompanying the propagation of an action potential has been measured in many experimental studies by Abbott et al [1], by Downing et al [3], by Howarth et al [11], by Ritchie et al [15], by Tasaki et al [16, 17] etc. However, there is no generally accepted mechanism for heat production and temperature changes because the measurements differ in a large scale. The generally accepted energy of a membrane capacitor is related to the square of voltage [15]. Tasaki and Byrne [17] have shown that either the generated temperature or its rate may be related to voltage depending on physical properties. It is of great interest to formulate the mathematical basis for calculating the heat production or temperature changes given these experimental assumptions. In our earlier studies [4 -- 7, 14] a system of differential equations is derived in order to model the action potential (AP) and accompanying mechanical effects -- pressure wave (PW) in axoplasm, longitudinal (LW) and transverse (TW) waves in the surrounding biomembrane. This system will here be enlarged by including the temperature (Θ) effects. The model equations are presented with the focus on possible models of heat and temperature production in Section 2. Further on, the numerical examples are given in dimensionless setting in Section 3. The final remarks are presented in Section 4. 2. MODEL EQUATIONS The coupled system of model equations has been previously proposed by the authors for describing the nerve pulse (action potential (AP)) propagation including the accompanying mechanical effects (pres- sure wave (PW) and longitudinal density change in the lipide bi-layer (LW)) [4 -- 7, 14]. In this paper, the temperature effects which accompany the propagation of an AP in the axoplasm, are also described. The dimensionless 1D model used so far [4 -- 7, 14] is the following: ZT = DZX X + Z(cid:0)Z − [a1 + b1] − Z2 + [a1 + b1] Z(cid:1) − J, JT = ε([a2 + b2] Z − J) , UT T = c2UX X + NUUX X + MU 2UX X + NU 2 X + 2MUU 2 X − H1UX X X X + H2UX X T T + F1(Z , J, P), PT T = c2 f PX X − µPT + F2(Z , J,U ), (1) (2) (3) where Eq. (1) is the FitzHugh -- Nagumo (FHN) equation [13], Eq. (2) is the improved Heimburg -- Jackson (iHJ) equation [6, 8, 9], Eq. (3) is the classical wave equation with the added viscous dampening term. In Eq. (1) Z is potential, J is the abstracted ion current (like characteristic to the FHN equation), ai , bi are "electrical" and "mechanical" activation coefficients, D,ε are coefficients. In Eq. (2) U is longitudinal ∗ Corresponding author 2 density change, c is sound velocity of unperturbed state in the lipid bi-layer, N , M are nonlinear coefficients, H1 , H2 are dispersion coefficients. In Eq. (3) P is pressure, c f is sound velocity in axoplasm, µ is dampening coefficient. Here and further index X denotes spatial partial derivative and index T denotes partial derivative with respect to time. Coupling terms have been described by polynomials F1 = γ1 PT 1 + U + γ2 JT 1 + U − γ3 ZT 1 + U ; F2 = η1ZX + η2JT + η3ZT , (4) where γi are coupling coefficients for mechanical wave and ηi are coupling coefficients for the pressure wave. Time derivatives act across membrane and spatial derivatives act along the axon. What has not been considered in the previous publications on mathematical modelling is the possible temperature change accompanying the AP. As far as system (1) -- (3) is a system of partial differential equations (PDE), we look for an additional equation capable to model the temperature changes. The cru- cial question is how temperature effects are related to other propagating effects and as before we look for corresponding coupling forces which in this case should be related to the heat production. It is worth also keeping in mind that temperature change normally is not considered like a wave but is considered to be like a diffusive process. There are several ideas proposed in earlier studies on thermal changes caused by propagating APs. It has been stated that the energy of the membrane capacitor Ec is [15] Ec = 1 2 CmZ2 , (5) where Cm is a capacitance and Z is the amplitude of the AP. Noting that heat energy Q ≈ Ec, it can be deduced that Q should be proportional to Z2. The standard Fourier law (the thermal conductivity equation) in its simplest 1D form is Q = −kΘX , (6) where Q is the heat energy, k is the thermal conductivity and Θ is the temperature. Note that heat energy is proportional to the negative temperature gradient. Combining (5) and (6), we obtain Θ ∝ Cm 2k Z Z2dX . (7) Further we follow experimental results by Abbot et al [1] which demonstrate that the heat increase at the surface of the fibre is positive. It has also been argued that either Z ∝ Θ or Z ∝ ΘT depending on physical properties [17]. The potential Z of the AP or its square Z2 might be not the only sources. For example, in [10, 12] it is argued in favour of the idea that experimentally observed temperature changes might be the result of the propagating mechanical wave in the lipid bi-layer. As there seems to be no clear consensus which quantities associated with the nerve pulse propagation are the sources of the thermal energy, we will consider here all the possibilities for the coupling of the waves in the ensemble to the additional model equation for the temperature. The idea is to cast these ideas into a mathematical form. As far as temperature is a function of space and time we opt to use the classical heat equation which is a parabolic PDE describing the distribution of heat (or variation in temperature) in a given region over time. It is straightforward [2] to derive the heat equation in terms of temperature from the Fourier's law by considering the conservation of energy where α is the thermal diffusivity. In our case, a possible source term must be added to Eq. (8) ΘT = αΘX X + F3(Z , J,U ). ΘT = αΘX X , (8) (9) The source term F3 permits to account for different assumptions proposed to describe the temperature gener- ation and consumption. Further on, a number of different functions F3 are used for this purpose: (i) F3 = τ1Z and F3 = τ2Z2 (see Fig. 2); (ii) F3 = τ3J and F3 = τ4J2 (see Fig. 3); (iii) F3 = τ5U and F3 = τ6U 2 (see Fig. 4); (iv) F3 = τ7ZT + τ8JT and F3 = τ9JT + τ10UX , (see Fig. 5) where τi are the thermal coupling coefficients. 3 3. NUMERICAL EXAMPLES AND DISCUSSION The model equations are solved using the pseudospectral method (PSM) [7]. The added heat equation (9) can be directly solved as outlined in [7] following the same procedure without further modifications. The idea of the PSM is write the PDEs in a form where all the time derivatives are on left hand side (LHS) and all the spatial derivatives on the right hand side (RHS) of the equation and then apply properties of the Fourier transform for finding the spatial derivatives reducing the PDE into an ordinary differential equation (ODE) which can be solved by standard numerical methods. For the numerical solving -- a localized initial condition is used in the middle of the spatial period for Z with the rest of the processes assumed to be at rest (zero initial conditions). This initial "spark" is taken above the threshold value in the middle of spatial period causes the AP to emerge and propagate to the left and right. All other waves are generated by the propagating AP as a result of coupling terms added to the system. Boundary conditions are taken periodic as is required for the PSM, moreover in the present paper the time integration intervals have been taken short enough to avoid interaction between counter-propagating waves at the boundaries. In the figures only left propagating waves are plotted. The following parameter values have been used for the numerical simulations: (i) for the FHN equation (1) D = 1;ε = 0.018; a1 = 0.2; a2 = 0.2; b1 = −0.05 ·U ; b2 = −0.05 ·U , (ii) for the improved Heimburg-Jackson model (2) c2 = 0.10; N = −0.05; M = 0.02; H1 = 0.2; H2 = 0.99; (iii) for the pressure (3) c2 f = 0.09; µ = 0.05; (iv) for the heat equation (9) α = 0.05; (v) and the coupling coefficients are γ1 = 0.008;γ2 = 0.01;γ3 = 3 · 10−5;η1 = 0.005;η2 = 0.01;η3 = 0.003; τ1,...,6 = 5 · 10−5;τ7 = 5 · 10−5;τ8 = 1 · 10−3;τ9 = 1 · 10−3;τ10 = 5 · 10−5 . The parameters for the numerical scheme are L = 64π (the length of the spatial period), Tf = 400 (the end time for integration, figures in the present paper are shown at T = 400), n = 2048 (the number of spatial grid points), the initial amplitude for Z is Az = 1.2 and width of the initial sech2 type pulse is Bo = 1.0 [7]. 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 s e u l a v d e z i l a m r o N 40 s e u l a v d e z i l a m r o N 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 -0.2 -0.4 -0.6 -0.8 120 140 40 80 60 X - dimensionless space 100 80 60 X - dimensionless space 100 120 140 Fig. 1. The wave ensemble modelled quantities (left) and the TW derived from the LW (right). The wave ensembles are shown in Fig. 1. It should be noted that some characteristics normally observed in experiments, like the transverse displacement (TW) of the membrane is not described by a differential equation but can be derived directly from the calculated LW as a derivative [6]. Certain oscillations of the 4 s e u l a v d e z i l a m r o N 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 s e u l a v d e z i l a m r o N 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 s e u l a v d e z i l a m r o N 120 140 40 40 80 60 X - dimensionless space 100 80 60 X - dimensionless space 100 120 140 Fig. 2. The temperature change Θ and thermal energy change Q = ΘX if F3 = τ1Z (left) and if F3 = τ2Z2(right). 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 s e u l a v d e z i l a m r o N 120 140 40 40 80 60 X - dimensionless space 100 80 60 X - dimensionless space 100 120 140 Fig. 3. The temperature change Θ and thermal energy change Q = ΘX if F3 = τ3J (left) and if F3 = τ4J2(right). calculated TW reflect the physical properties of the biomembrane which is described by a Boussinesq-type equation [6]. Few more remarks are in order. Note that in Figs 2 -- 5 thermal energy change Q is plotted as Q = ΘX . One can observe in Fig. 2 that in the case of temperature increase proportional to Z the local temperature drops in the negative polarity region of the AP while if the temperature increases proportional to Z2 the local temperature keeps increasing even in the negative polarity region of the AP. Observing correlation between the Z (or Z2) and the measured temperature increase near axon seems to be common for several experiments by Howarth et al [11], Ritchie et al [15] and by Tasaki et al [17]. Experimental results published so far seem inconclusive to argue firmly in favour of either option as normally only some kind of averaged thermal energy production over some time can be measured. Another note made is that while experimentally the heat production proportional to AP has been observed, this correlation does not have to mean direct causality. Like generally in nature, the potential gradient alone is rarely the only source of the temperature change in an environment. One could argue that heat production might be instead be proportional to ion currents (Fig. 3) or the longitudinal density change (Fig. 4) which accompany the propagating AP. For the sake of completeness temperature increase as a function of J and J2 is presented in Fig. 3 and as a function of density change U and U 2 in Fig. 4. The idea behind including J and U as sources is that mechanisms where the temperature increase is caused by the current flowing through the environment or by the deformation of the solid are well established in the physics even if these are not as common sources assumed for the heat 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 s e u l a v d e z i l a m r o N s e u l a v d e z i l a m r o N 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 -0.2 -0.4 -0.6 -0.8 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 -0.2 s e u l a v d e z i l a m r o N 120 140 40 40 80 60 X - dimensionless space 100 80 60 X - dimensionless space 100 5 120 140 Fig. 4. The temperature change Θ and thermal energy change Q = ΘX if F3 = τ5U (left) and if F3 = τ6U 2(right). s e u l a v d e z i l a m r o N 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 -0.2 -0.4 -0.6 -0.8 120 140 40 40 80 60 X - dimensionless space 100 80 60 X - dimensionless space 100 120 140 Fig. 5. The temperature change Θ and thermal energy change Q = ΘX if F3 = τ7ZT + τ8JT (left) and if F3 = τ9JT + τ10UX (right). generation [10, 12] as the correlation with the AP [11, 15, 17]. In such a context it might not be a problem to observe that some heat energy "goes away" in the negative polarity phase of the used driving signal if one assumes heat production proportional to the driving signal as the underlying endothermic mechanism might be actually independent of the AP propagation, like, some kind of endothermic chemical reaction starting [1]. The open question in the latter case is, however, the issue of time scales. Moreover, another effect present in the numerical simulation results presented must be noted -- at least in part the reason why the temperature can be lower in the areas through which the signal has already propagated as opposed to the front is that the driving signal can be actually of lower amplitude at earlier stages of the signal propagation. This is the main reason why in Fig. 4 there is quite a significant drop in temperature for the case of U 2 (right panel) because in this case the change in driving signal amplitude is amplified in time. The signal shape in Fig. 4 (right panel) is qualitatively similar to the signal shapes observed by Abbott, et al in [1]. Another note relevant specifically for the Eq. (2) can be made -- it is a conservative equation before adding the coupling term F1 facilitating energy exchange between the coupled equations. However, if the mechanical wave in the lipid bi-layer is considered as a source for thermal energy in the system for earnest this equation would need some kind of additional term which would take some energy away from the mechanical wave. For example, the simplest possibility might be using a Voigt -- type model which means appearing a term UX X X in Eq. (2). Experimentally the thermal energy production and consumption has been observed in the time scales 6 comparable to the AP propagation [16, 17] to few orders of magnitude longer as shown by Howarth et al [11]. Following the idea that the underlying processes responsible for the heat production and consumption might be proportional to some of the processes we are actually modelling one possibility shown in Fig. 5 where time derivatives of AP and ion current J (left) or the ion current time derivative and the gradient of longitudinal density change (right) are used for the thermal energy generation and consumption. In such a case thermal energy is generated when the driving signal is growing and consumed when the driving signal is decreasing. The examples shown in Fig. 5 are intended to highlight what is mathematically possible in the present framework and not as an implication of the thermal response being actually generated and even more importantly, consumed, by the used signals in the reality. However some of the experimental observations are qualitatively similar to profiles shown in Fig. 5 [17]. A minor remark on whether to use spatial or temporal derivatives and signals is in order -- in our 1D setting the signal shape is practically the same regardless if observed in space (at fixed time) or in time (at fixed spatial point). Actually, integrating Eq. (9) in time with F3 ∝ Z2 (Fig. 2, right panel) takes into account expression (7). Finally it seems prudent to emphasize where, exactly, is this temperature change modelled on axon in the presented framework as normally the experimental measurements for the phenomenon are performed close to the axon wall outside of the axon itself. The temperature changes in Figs 2, 3 and 5 (left panel) are for the axoplasm inside the axon. The temperature plotted in Fig. 4 would have to be inside the lipid bi-layer forming the axon wall because that is where the density change U is taken into account in our model which is used to generate these changes in Fig. 4. Overall, it is assumed that any temperature changes measured sufficiently close to the lipid bi-layer forming the axon wall are proportional to the temperature changes in the axoplasm or in the lipid bi-layer giving us, in essence, a combined reading of all available temperature changes in close proximity of the hypothetical measuring point (which is the case for Fig. 5 right panel). In the present framework a possible time delay between heat being generated or consumed and the "measured" signal a small distance away is not taken into account. One possible extension for the system (1) -- (3), (9) is to include a separate PDE into the system for capturing the temperature decrease in a manner which better aligns with some of the experimental results. For example, the temperature response can happen on a noticeably larger time scale than the AP propagation, implying potentially a different underlying mechanism as described by Abbott et al [1] and Howarth et al [11]. 4. FINAL REMARKS An attempt is made to cast the experimental ideas [11, 15 -- 17] into the mathematical form. The ex- perimental results differ on a large scale -- the temperature profile follows the AP [16] and the temperature changes are on much longer scale compared to the AP [1]. In this paper it is demonstrated that despite of such scattered results, it is possible to construct a mathematical model reproducing the experimental results. It seems that it is possible mathematically simulate the temperature generation as measured by Tasaki [16] for the garfish olfactory nerve as well as the heat production measured by Howarth et al [11] for mammalian nerves. However, the essence of coupling terms needs experimental verification. The temperature changes are governed by diffusion contrary to the wave-like behaviour of a signal in a fibre. The mathematical mod- els described above form certainly just a basic platform for further refinements of modelling. For example, the effects of various ion currents or general oxygen consumption, CO2 output, the influence of carbohy- drates (see [3]) should also be taken into account. But even within the present model, results described above may enlarge the fundamental thermodynamics of nervous signals [10]. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This research was supported by the European Union through the European Regional Development Fund (Estonian Programme TK 124) and by the Estonian Research Council (projects IUT 33-24, PUT 434). 7 References 1. Abbott, B. C., Hill, A. V., and Howarth, J. V. The positive and negative heat production associated with a nerve impulse. Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci., 1958, 148(931), 149 -- 187. 2. Carslaw, H. and Jaeger, J. Conduction of heat in solids. Oxford Science Publications, Oxford, 1959. 3. Downing, A. C., Gerard, R. W., and Hill, A. V. The heat production of nerve. Proc. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci., 1926, 100(702), 223 -- 251. 4. Engelbrecht, J., Peets, T., and Tamm, K. Electromechanical coupling of waves in nerve fibres. Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol., 2018, 17(6), 1771 -- 1783. 5. Engelbrecht, J., Peets, T., Tamm, K., Laasmaa, M., and Vendelin, M. On the complexity of signal propagation in nerve fibres. Proc. Estonian Acad. Sci., 2018, 67(1), 28 -- 38. 6. Engelbrecht, J., Tamm, K., and Peets, T. On mathematical modelling of solitary pulses in cylindrical biomembranes. Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol., 2015, 14(1), 159 -- 167. 7. Engelbrecht, J., Tamm, K., and Peets, T. Modeling of complex signals in nerve fibers. Med. Hypotheses, 2018, 120, 90 -- 95. 8. Heimburg, T. and Jackson, A. On the action potential as a propagating density pulse and the role of anesthetics. Biophys. Rev. Lett., 2007, 02(01), 57 -- 78. 9. Heimburg, T. and Jackson, A. D. On soliton propagation in biomembranes and nerves. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 2005, 102(28), 9790 -- 9795. 10. Heimburg, T. and Jackson, A. D. Thermodynamics of the nervous impulse. In Struct. Dyn. Membr. interfaces (Kaushik, N., ed.). John Wiley & Sons, 2008, 318 -- 337. 11. Howarth, J. V., Keynes, R. D., and Ritchie, J. M. The origin of the initial heat associated with a single impulse in mammalian non-myelinated nerve fibres. J. Physiol., 1968, 194(3), 745 -- 93. 12. Mussel, M. and Schneider, M. F. It sounds like an action potential: unification of electrical, chemical and mechanical aspects of acoustic pulses in lipids. 2018. http://arxiv.org/abs/1806.08551. 13. Nagumo, J., Arimoto, S., and Yoshizawa, S. An active pulse transmission line simulating nerve axon. Proc. IRE, 1962, 50(10), 2061 -- 2070. 14. Peets, T. and Tamm, K. On mechanical aspects of nerve pulse propagation and the Boussinesq paradigm. Proc. Est. Acad. Sci., 2015, 64(3), 331. 15. Ritchie, J. M. and Keynes, R. D. The production and absorption of heat associated with electrical activity in nerve and electric organ. Q. Rev. Biophys., 1985, 18(04), 451. 16. Tasaki, I. A macromolecular approach to excitation phenomena: mechanical and thermal changes in nerve during excitation. Physiol. Chem. Phys. Med. NMR, 1988, 20(4), 251 -- 268. 17. Tasaki, I. and Byrne, P. Rapid structural chances in nerve fibers evoked by electric current pulses. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun., 1992, 188(2), 559 -- 564.
1705.10805	1	1705	2017-05-30T18:02:35	Investigations of Auditory Filters Based Excitation Patterns for Assessment of Noise Induced Hearing Loss	[ "physics.bio-ph", "q-bio.NC" ]	Noise induced hearing loss (NIHL) as one of major avoidable occupational related health issues has been studied for decades. To assess NIHL, the excitation pattern (EP) has been considered as one of mechanisms to estimate movements of basilar membrane (BM) in cochlea. In this study, two auditory filters, dual resonance nonlinear (DRNL) filter and rounded-exponential (ROEX) filter, have been applied to create two EPs, referring as the velocity EP and the loudness EP, respectively. Two noise hazard metrics are also proposed based on the developed EPs to evaluate hazardous levels caused by different types of noise. Moreover, Gaussian noise and pure-tone noise have been simulated to evaluate performances of the developed EPs and noise metrics. The results show that both developed EPs can reflect the responses of BM to different types of noise. For Gaussian noise, there is a frequency shift between the velocity EP and the loudness EP. For pure-tone noise, both EPs can reflect the frequencies of input noise accurately. The results suggest that both EPs can be potentially used for assessment of NIHL.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Investigations of Auditory Filters Based Excitation Patterns for Assessment of Noise Induced Hearing Loss Wisam Subhi Al-Dayyeni, Pengfei Sun, Jun Qin Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, IL, USA Abstract: Noise induced hearing loss (NIHL) as one of major avoidable occupational related health issues has been studied for decades. To assess NIHL, the excitation pattern (EP) has been considered as one of mechanisms to estimate movements of basilar membrane (BM) in cochlea. In this study, two auditory filters, dual resonance nonlinear (DRNL) filter and rounded- exponential (ROEX) filter, have been applied to create two EPs, referring as the velocity EP and the loudness EP, respectively. Two noise hazard metrics are also proposed based on the developed EPs to evaluate hazardous levels caused by different types of noise. Moreover, Gaussian noise and pure-tone noise have been simulated to evaluate performances of the developed EPs and noise metrics. The results show that both developed EPs can reflect the responses of BM to different types of noise. For Gaussian noise, there is a frequency shift between the velocity EP and the loudness EP. For pure-tone noise, both EPs can reflect the frequencies of input noise accurately. The results suggest that both EPs can be potentially used for assessment of NIHL. Key words: Noise induced hearing loss; excitation pattern; basilar membrane motion; auditory filter; noise assessment metrics. 1. Introduction Noise-induced hearing loss (NIHL) remains as one of the most common health related problems nowadays as stated by the World Health Organization (WHO). One of the main causes of the permanent hearing loss is the exposure to excessive noise [1-3]. Approximately 22 million workers in the United States are exposed to loud noise workplace that is considered as a hazard level [4]. Hearing loss has a strong impact on the quality of life, causes isolation, impairs social interactions, and increases the risk of accidents [5]. Intrinsically, NIHL can be partially explained as an auditory fatigue phenomenon, in which the motions of stretching and squeezing of basilar membrane (BM) could damage the hearing cells (i.e., outer and inner hair cells) in cochlea [6-8]. The mechanical motions of BM is considered as one of the major factors that causing NIHL in cochlea [9, 10]. The motions of BM in response to the noise stimulus as a function of frequency can be stated as an excitation pattern (EP). Therefore, investigations of the EP are very useful for NIHL research [11]. An EP represents the distribution of movements along BM caused by a sound [12, 13]. In psychoacoustic, the EP is defined as the output of each auditory filter plotted as a function of the filter's center frequency (CF) [14]. The EPs are normally calculated and plotted as the gain of each auditory filter equal to 0 dB at its CF. For example; a tone with a 60 dB sound pressure level (SPL) and at 1 kHz CF will cause an excitation level equal to 60 dB and at 1 kHz [13, 15, 16]. The auditory models (AMs) of the human peripheral frequency selectivity are the fast ways to estimate the EPs over the BM partitions in cochlea [17]. Nowadays many AMs have been developed based on observations of input-output behavior of human auditory system with reference to psychological or physiological responses [6]. Such AMs include Gammatone filters, dual-resonance nonlinear (DRNL) filters, dynamic-compressive gammachirp filters, etc. Hohmann (2002) [18] developed a 4th-order linear Gammatone filter based AM for speech processing in hearing aids. This linear model can reconstruct acoustical signals in an auditory system, but it didn't include nonlinear features [18]. Lopez-Poveda and Meddis (2001) [17, 19] proposed a nonlinear DRNL filter, which successfully simulates the two-tone suppression and the phase responses in the BM. Furthermore, Irino and Patterson (2006) [20] developed a gammachirp filterbank with nonlinear and compressive features. The developed gammachirp filter has a group of linear passive gammachirp filters, and can be useful for the applications on speech enhancement, speech coding, and hearing aids [20]. Moreover, the AMs can be categorized as mechanical or perceptual model [21]. The mechanical AMs are designed to estimate mechanical vibrations on BM in cochlea [17], while the perceptual AMs are developed to mimic the psychoacoustic data [20]. In this study, a DRNL filter as a typical mechanical AM and a rounded-exponential (ROEX) filter as a typical perceptual AM have been implemented to investigate EPs on the human BM. As a cascade filter model, the DRNL filter was developed to simulate the nonlinear mechanical response of BM in reaction to stapes motion [19]. The output of DRNL filters is the velocity of BM, which can be described as a velocity EP of BM in cochlea. Such velocity EP intuitively can be used to assess the auditory fatigue based NIHL [6]. On the other hand, the ROEX filter as a perceptual model can be used to describe the loudness levels in cochlea. Loudness is one of the most important parameters for evaluation of the acoustical quality in various applications, from hearing aid optimizing to automatic music mixing systems [22]. The loudness estimations directly reflect the characteristics of human auditory system, such as masking adaption, integration along a perceptual frequency axis, and integration and compression along time axis. In previous studies, loudness contours based models have been developed for evaluations of the annoyance of environment noises, including community noise, industrial noise, and transportation noises [23- 25]. In this study, we implement the DRNL filter and the ROEX filter to create two different EPs, the velocity EP and the loudness EP, respectively. To evaluate the performances of both EPs, Gaussian noise and pure-tone noise signals with various parameters (e.g., amplitude and frequency) are simulated. In addition, two noise metrics are proposed based on the velocity EP and the loudness EP to estimate the hazardous levels caused by different types of noise. The rest of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 describes the auditory filters, the proposed noise metrics, and simulations of noise signals. Section 3 gives experimental results and discussions. Section 4 concludes the paper and outlines future works. 2. Material and Methods 2.1. External Ear and Middle Ear The structure and the function of the auditory system of the human have similarities with other mammalian species. The human ear consists of three parts: external ear, middle ear, and inner ear. Each part in an auditory system plays a unique role to translate acoustic signals from environment to inner ear. The sound passes through external ear in a form of pressure vibration. The pressure vibration changes into mechanical vibration in middle ear. The mechanical energy transforms into hydrodynamic motion in inner ear, and then the BM activates hair cells through electrochemical energy [26]. An external ear consists of ear canal, concha, and pinna flange. The transfer functions of external ear used for the DRNL filter and the ROEX filter are same in this study. As shown in Fig. 1, the transfer function of external ear is same as it was described in Moore's work [22] and ANSI-S3-2007 [27]. 20 15 10 5 0 -5 ) B d ( n i a G 10 2 10 3 10 4 Frequency (Hz) Fig. 1 - The frequency response of the transfer function of an external ear. A middle ear consists of tympanic membrane and ossicular chain, which have three bones. A middle ear plays the role as an impedance-matching device, and it collects and transmits acoustic power to the inner ear [28, 29]. The transfer functions of middle ear have been developed to describe the relationships between inputs and outputs of middle ear [29]. In this study, two different transfer functions of middle ear are applied to the DRNL filter and the ROEX filter, respectively. Fig. 2a shows the frequency response of the transfer function of middle ear used for the DRNL filter as described in Meddis's work [19], in which the acoustical pressure is converted into the stapes velocity, called as the stapes velocity transfer function (SVTF). As shown in Fig. 2b, the frequency response of the transfer function of middle ear for the ROEX filter has been used in the procedure of loudness computation in Moore's work [22]. Fig. 2 - The frequency responses of the transfer function of middle ear, which are applied to (a) the DRNL filter [19] and (b) the ROEX filter [22], respectively. 2.2. DRNL filter In this study, a DRNL filter is utilized to obtain the BM movements in human cochlea [19]. The DRNL filter simulates the velocity of BM as a response to the stapes velocity in middle ear. As shown in Fig. 3, the input of the DRNL filter is the linear stapes velocity. Each individual site is represented as a tuned system with two parallel independent paths, one linear (left) and one nonlinear (right). The linear path consists of a gain /attenuation factor, a bandpass function, and a low pass function in a cascade. The nonlinear path is a cascade combination of the 1st bandpass function, a compression function, the 2nd bandpass function, and a low pass function. The output of DRNL filter is the sum of the outputs of the linear and nonlinear paths, and is the BM velocity at a particular location along the cochlear partition. In both paths, each of three bandpass functions consists of a cascade of two or three the 1st order gammatone filters [30] with a unit gain at the center frequency (CF). Two low-pass functions are same and consist of a cascade of four 2nd order Butterworth low pass filters. Moreover, the compression function in the nonlinear path was defined based on the animal data, and it can be described as 𝑦[𝑡]=SIGN (𝑥[𝑡])×MIN (𝑎𝑥[𝑡],𝑏𝑥[𝑡])𝑐 where 𝑥[𝑡] represents the output from the first bandpass function in the nonlinear path. 𝑦[𝑡] is the output of the compression function. 𝑎, 𝑏, and 𝑐 are models parameters as summarized in Table 1. (1) Fig. 3 - Schematic diagram of the DRNL filter [19], in which the velocities of stapes in middle ear are passed through two parallel branches to obtain the velocities of BM. Table 1 summarizes the parameters of the DRNL filter for human used to implement the DRNL filter in this study. The velocity EP is the distribution of BM velocity, which can be obtained as the outputs of the DRNL filter. Table 1 - DRNL filter parameters used to simulate the human inner ear [17]. 0.25kHz 0.5kHz 1kHz 2kHz 4kHz 8kHz 2 4 235 115 235 1400 3 3 250 84 250 2124 0.45 0.25 2 4 460 150 460 800 3 3 500 103 500 4609 0.28 0.25 2 4 945 240 945 520 3 3 1000 175 1000 4598 0.13 0.25 2 4 1895 390 1895 400 3 3 2000 300 2000 9244 0.078 0.25 2 4 3900 620 3900 270 3 3 4000 560 4000 30274 0.06 0.25 2 4 7450 1550 7450 250 3 3 8000 1100 8000 76354 0.035 0.25 Simulated preparation Linear GT cascade LP cascade CFlin BWlin LPlin Gain, g Nonlinear GT cascade LP cascade CFlin BWlin LPnl Gain, a Gain, b Exponent, c 2.3. ROEX filter The ROEX filter was originally derived from psychophysical data [31]. It is a descriptive model, which describes the shape of magnitude transfer function of an auditory filter [32]. The ROEX filter formula can be defined by [27]: 𝑊(𝑔)= (1+𝑝𝑔)𝑒𝑥𝑝(−𝑝𝑔) where 𝑔 is the normalized deviation from the center frequency (CF) divided by the CF, and 𝑝 is an adjustable parameter which determines the slope and the bandwidth of the filter. (2) In this study, the ROEX filter is implemented according to ANSI 3.4-2005 [33]. To calculate the input level at each equivalent rectangular bandwidth (ERB), 𝑝 in Eq. (3) is set to be 4𝑓/𝐸𝑅𝐵. The ERB is a psychoacoustic measurement of the width of the auditory filter in each where 𝑓𝑐 is the CF, which are in the range of 50 Hz – 15 kHz in this study. The ERB level 𝐸𝑅𝐵 = 24.673(0.004368𝑓𝑐+1) obtained according to the input level, which is used to determine the ROEX filter shape. The location along the cochlea, and it can be defined as: (3) energy in each ERB can be obtained by: 𝐸𝑖=∑𝑊�𝑔𝑖,𝑗�𝑃𝑗2 𝑃02 𝐸0 (4) according to the values of the excitation threshold where 𝑊 represents local ROEX filter in the ith ERB. 𝑃𝑗2 refers to the power in the jth frequency band. 𝐸0 is the reference energy at 1 kHz CF and 0 dB SPL, and 𝑃0 is the reference pressure referring to 2×10−5 Pa. For the selected frequencies, Ei will be transformed to loudness levels where 𝐸 is the energy, and G is the low level gain. 𝐶 and 𝛼 are two constants, where 𝐶 =0.046871, and α is related to the 𝐺 value. 𝐸𝑇𝐻𝑅𝑄 refers to lower threshold of human 𝑁=𝐶��𝐺×𝐸 + 2𝐸𝑇𝐻𝑅𝑄 �α – �2𝐸𝑇𝐻𝑅𝑄�α� (5) perception. Fig. 4 shows various frequency gains of ROEX filter at different ERB levels. The ROEX filter is a dynamic filter, which has different frequency gains when the levels of ERB change. As the ERB level increases, the slope of the left side of ROEX filter becomes flat. In general, when the sound pressure level (SPL) increases, there will be more energy pass through the ROEX filter. From this perspective, ROEX filter is consistent with the loudness contours. When SPLs increase, loudness contours become flat [14]. Fig. 4 - The various frequency gains of ROEX filter centered at 0.5, 1, 2, 4, and 8 kHz at different ERB levels from 20 dB to 100 dB with 10 dB interval. 2.4. EP Based Noise Metrics Previous studies have demonstrated that the EPs of BM are highly correlated with NIHL in human cochlea [6, 11, 34]. To investigate hearing loss, two EP based metrics are proposed to assess the potential hazardous levels (HLs) caused by different types of noise. Since the EP represents the temporal responses of the organ of Corti in cochlea, one can integrate the local responses and obtain the cumulative HLs. Therefore, two proposed noise metrics, 𝐻𝐿𝑖𝐷 and 𝐻𝐿𝑖𝑅, can be defined as (6) 𝐻𝐿𝑖𝐷=10log10� 𝑉(𝑖,𝑡)2 𝑉𝑜2 � 𝐻𝐿𝑖𝑅=10log10� 𝑁(𝑖,𝑡)2 𝑁𝑜2 � 𝑡=𝑛𝑡=1 𝑡=𝑛𝑡=1 (7) where 𝐻𝐿𝑖𝐷 represents the hazard level index based on the velocity EP, and 𝑉(𝑖,𝑡) refers to the BM velocity at the 𝑖th ERB of BM at time 𝑡. 𝑉0 represents the BM velocity located at the ERB at CF equal to 1 kHz. Moreover, 𝐻𝐿𝑖𝑅 represents the hazard level index based on the loudness EP, and 𝑁(𝑖,𝑡) refers to the loudness level at the ith ERB of BM at a time t. 𝑁0 is the loudness level at the ERB at CF equal to 1 kHz. By Eq. (7) and Eq. (8), the developed EPs have been successfully translated to the amount of HLs, which can be potentially used for the assessment of NIHL. Moreover, total hazard level (THL) can be defined as summation of HLs: where 𝑇𝐻𝐿 𝐷 and 𝑇𝐻𝐿 𝑅 represent THLs based on the velocity EP and the loudness EP, respectively. 2.5. Simulation of Noise Signals In this study, two different types of noise signals (i.e., Gaussian noise and pure-tone noise) have been simulated to evaluate the performances of two developed EPs. The Gaussian noise signals are simulated using the "randn" function in MATLAB, in which the probability distribution function of the Gaussian noise is given by [35]: 𝑃(𝑡)= 1𝜎√2𝜋𝑒𝑥𝑝−(𝑡−𝜇)2 2𝜎2 where 𝜇 is the mean, and σ is the standard deviation. 𝜇 is equal to zero in this study. (10) 𝑇𝐻𝐿 𝐷= ∑𝐻𝐿𝑖𝐷 𝑖 𝑇𝐻𝐿 𝑅= ∑𝐻𝐿𝑖𝑅 𝑖 (8) (9) The pure-tone noise signals are simulated by: 𝑦(𝑡)=𝐴cos2𝜋𝑓𝑡 (11) where 𝐴 is the amplitude of the signal, and 𝑓 is the frequency. 3. Results and Discussion 3.1. Time-Frequency (T-F) Representations of Two EPs In this section, two simulated noise signals (i.e., Gaussian noise and pure-tone noise) are fed into both velocity EP and loudness EP models. The outputs of two EP models are the BM velocity and the loudness level 𝑁(𝑖,𝑡) at the 𝑖th ERB of BM at time 𝑡, respectively. Both EP can be represented in the joint time and frequency (T-F) domain. Figs. 5a and 5b show the T-F representations of the velocity EP and the loudness EP, responding to a simulated Gaussian noise at 100 dB SPL, respectively. Figs. 5c and 5d show the T-F representations of the velocity EP and the loudness EP, responding to a pure-tone noise with 100 dB SPL and 1 kHz frequency, respectively. The results show that both EPs can reflect amplitudes and transitions of noise signals. The velocity EP as a mechanical model can represent both positive and negative vibrations of BM in cochlea, which reflects more realistic representations of the stretching and squeezing on the hair cells in cochlea. In the other hand, the loudness EP as a perceptual model only represents the positive amount of the loudness as a response to the noise signal. The loudness EP doesn't directly reflect the BM vibrations in cochlea. Fig. 5 - The T-F representations of (a) the velocity EP and (b) the loudness EP responding to a Gaussian noise at 100 dB SPL, and (c) the velocity EP and (d) the loudness EP with respect to a pure-tone noise at 100 dB SPL and 1 kHz. Moreover, along the time axis, the velocity EP presents higher temporal resolution than the loudness EP for both Gaussian and pure-tone noise. It indicates that the temporal resolution of the DRNL filter is better than that of the ROEX filter. Along the frequency axis, for the Gaussian noise case, the peak frequency of the velocity EP is around 2 kHz and is lower than the corresponding value of the loudness EP (around 4 kHz). For the pure-tone noise, both EPs present the peak frequencies at 1 kHz, which reflects the frequency of the input pure-tone noise. However, the velocity EP shows vibrations around 1 kHz since it reflects the BM motion while the loudness EP shows only one pulse since it is a perceptual model that reflects the amount of psychoacoustic data. 3.2. T-F Representations of Two EPs for Pure-tone Noise Fig. 6 shows the T-F representations of the velocity EP and the loudness EP produced by the pure-tone noise signals with 100 dB SPL and various frequencies (i.e., 1, 2, 4, and 6 kHz). For the velocity EP (as shown in the left figures of Fig. 6), the amplitudes have both positive and negative values and the peak amplitudes appear around the frequencies of pure-tone noise signals. It also can be found that the peak amplitudes of the velocity EP are decreasing with the frequency large than 2 kHz. On the other hand, the loudness EP (as shown in the right figures of Fig. 6) presents only positive amplitudes, and the peak amplitudes match the frequencies of stimulating pure-tone noise signals. The peak amplitudes of the loudness EP increase first and then decrease with the frequency increasing, and the maximum peak amplitude appears at 4 kHz. Fig. 6 – The T-F distributions of two developed EPs obtained by simulated pure-tone noise signals at 100 dB SPL with frequencies at 1, 2, 4, and 6 kHz, respectively. 3.3.Hazardous Level Evaluation 3.3.1. Frequency Distributions of HLs for Gaussian Noise According to Eqs. (6) and (7), the performance two EPs are evaluated using two proposed metrics, 𝐻𝐿𝑖𝐷and 𝐻𝐿𝑖𝑅 , which are used to depict HL at ith ERB on BM. Fig. 7 shows the frequency distributions of normalized HLs generated by the simulated Gaussian noise signals at SPL = 90 to 120 dB with 10 dB interval. For both velocity EP and loudness EP, the HLs increase with SPL increasing. Overall, the loudness EP shows broader frequency response compared with the velocity EP. The results also show that there is a frequency shift between the two EPs. The peak HLs of the velocity EP are around 2 kHz while the peak HLs of the loudness EP are around 4 kHz. Since the BM motions are associated with hearing loss in cochlea, the peak frequency shift between two EPs indicates that the maximum hearing loss predicted by these two EPs may occur at different partitions of BM. Fig. 7 - The frequency distributions of normalized HLs based on (a) the velocity EP and (b) the loudness EP generated by simulated Gaussian noise signals at SPL = 90 to 120 dB with 10 dB interval. 3.3.2. Frequency Distributions of HLs for Pure-tone Noise Fig. 8 shows the normalized HLs generated by simulated pure-tone noise signals at 1 kHz fixed frequency and SPL from 90 to 120 dB with 10 dB interval. Both velocity EP and loudness EP show the peak frequency responses at 1 kHz, which is same as the frequency of the input pure-tone noise signals. It also can be found that the HLs are increasing with SPL levels increasing in both EPs. As shown in Fig. 8a, the HLs of the velocity EP gradually increase when the frequency is smaller than 1 kHz, and then gradually decrease after the frequency is greater than 1 kHz. Comparatively, as shown in Fig. 8b, the HLs of the loudness EP show different frequency responses than the velocity EP. The HLs of the loudness EP almost equal to zero when frequency smaller than 500 Hz, and then rapidly increase with frequency increasing to 1 kHz, and finally gradually decrease with frequency further increasing. This is because the loudness EP is based on the ROEX filter, which is derived from psychophysical data. Therefore, the loudness EP may not reflect the real motion of BM in cochlea. Fig 8 - The frequency distributions of normalized hazardous levels based on (a) the velocity EP and (b) the loudness EP obtained pure-tone noise at 1 kHz and SPL = 90 to 120 dB with 10 dB interval. Moreover, Fig. 9 shows the normalized HLs generated by the simulated pure-tone noise signals at different frequencies (0.5, 1, 2, 4, and 6 kHz) and SPL = 100 dB. Both velocity EP and loudness EP can reflect the corresponding frequencies of input pure-tone noise signals. Specifically, the peak HLs of the velocity EP (as shown in Fig. 9a) is reducing after frequency larger than 2 kHz, while the peak HLs of the loudness EP slightly reduce when frequency higher than 4 kHz. The results in Fig. 9 confirm the peak frequency shift between two EPs generated by Gaussian noise in Fig. 7. In the velocity EP, the maximum velocity occurs around 2 kHz, while in the loudness EP, the maximum loudness appears around 4 kHz. Fig 9 - The frequency distributions of normalized hazardous levels based on (a) the velocity EP and (b) the loudness EP obtained pure-tone noise signals at various frequencies (0.5, 1, 2, 4, and 6 kHz) with fixed SPL = 100 dB. 3.3.3. Total Hazardous Levels for Gaussian Noise According to Eq. (8) and Eq. (9), total hazardous levels, 𝑇𝐻𝐿 𝐷 and 𝑇𝐻𝐿 𝑅 , can be calculated based on the velocity EP and the loudness EP, respectively. THLs can be used to assess hazardous of high-level noise, and potentially can be used to investigate NIHL. Fig. 10 shows the evaluation of the normalized THLs for the Gaussian noise at SPL from 70 to 120 dB. The result shows that THLs of both EPs are increasing with SPL increasing. The increase rate of the velocity EP is faster than that of the loudness EP. Compared with the loudness EP, the velocity EP shows lower THLs at SPL < 100 dB, but demonstrates higher THLs when SPL > 100 dB. Fig 10 - The normalized THLs for the Gaussian noise at SPL from 70 to 120 dB for the velocity EP and the loudness EP. 3.3.4. THLs for the Pure-tone Noise Fig. 11a shows the normalized THL of both EPs produced by the simulated pure-tone noise signals with increasing SPL from 70 to 120 dB and fixed frequency at 1 kHz. The THLs of both EPs are increasing with SPL increasing. Specifically, the velocity EP increases faster than the loudness EP. The result indicates that the velocity EP is more sensitive with SPL increasing than the loudness EP. It also can be found that the THLs of the velocity EP are constantly higher than the corresponding values of the loudness. Moreover, Fig. 11b shows the normalized THLs of both EPs generated by the simulated pure-tone noise signals at SPL = 100 dB and frequency from 0.5 to 8 kHz. For both EPs, the THLs slightly increase first and then decrease with frequency increasing. The peak THL of the velocity EP is at 2 kHz, while the THL of the loudness EP peaks at 4 kHz. This result is consistent with the previous results in Figs 6, 7 and 9. In addition, the velocity EP shows a fast degradation of THL when the frequency increase more than 2 kHz. Fig 11 - The normalized THLs for the pure-tone noise: (a) at 1 kHz and SPL from70 to120 dB, and (b) at fixed SPL = 100 dB and frequencies from 0.5 to 8 kHz for the velocity EP and the loudness EP. 4. Conclusions In this study, two auditory filters, the DRNL filter and the ROEX filter, have been applied to develop the velocity EP and the loudness EP, respectively. Two different types of noise (i.e., Gaussian noise and pure-tone noise) have been simulated to evaluate two developed EPs. For the Gaussian noise, the results show that the maximum velocity obtained by the DRNL filter occurs around 2 kHz, while the peak loudness obtained by the ROEX filter is about 4 kHz. For the pure-tone noise, both EPs can accurately reflect the frequencies of the input noise signals. Moreover, to evaluate the effectiveness of two EPs for prediction of NIHL, we proposed two noise metrics, 𝐻𝐿𝐷 and 𝐻𝐿𝑅, based on the velocity EP and the loudness EP, respectively. The results show that both EPs can be potentially used as noise hazardous level index for assessment of NIHL. The velocity EP based metric demonstrates higher sensitivity than the loudness EP based metric. However, because the current study is only based on theoretical analysis and simulated noise signals, it may be limited to evaluate the performance of two auditory filters. In our future work, we will utilize experimental animal and human noise exposure data to evaluate the developed velocity EP and loudness EP for assessment of NIHL. References journal of [1] Rabinowitz PM. Noise-induced hearing loss. American family physician. 2000;61:2759-60. [2] Qin J, Jiang Y, Mahdi A. Recent Developments on Noise Induced Hearing Loss for Military and Industrial Applications. Biosens J. 2014;3:e101. [3] Wu Q, Qin J. Effects of key parameters of impulse noise on prediction of the auditory hazard using AHAAH model. International journal of computational biology and drug design. 2013;6:210-20. [4] Tak S, Davis RR, Calvert GM. Exposure to hazardous workplace noise and use of hearing protection devices among US workers-NHANES, 1999–2004. American industrial medicine. 2009;52:358-71. [5] Kirchner DB, Evenson E, Dobie RA, Rabinowitz P, Crawford J, Kopke R, et al. Occupational noise- induced hearing loss: ACOEM Task Force on occupational hearing loss. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine. 2012;54:106-8. [6] Sun P, Qin J, Campbell K. Fatigue Modeling via Mammalian Auditory System for Prediction of Noise Induced Hearing Loss. Computational and mathematical methods in medicine. 2015;2015. [7] Sun P, Fox D, Campbell K, Qin J. Auditory fatigue model applications to predict noise induced hearing loss in human and chinchilla. Applied Acoustics. 2017;119:57-65. [8] Sun P, Qin J. Auditory fatigue models for prediction of gradually developed noise induced hearing loss. 2016 IEEE-EMBS International Conference on Biomedical and Health Informatics (BHI)2016. p. 384- 7. [9] Calford M, Rajan R, Irvine D. Rapid changes in the frequency tuning of neurons in cat auditory cortex resulting from pure-tone-induced temporary threshold shift. Neuroscience. 1993;55:953-64. [10] Ohlemiller KK. Contributions of mouse models to understanding of age-and noise-related hearing loss. Brain research. 2006;1091:89-102. [11] Sun P, Qin J. Excitation patterns of two auditory models applied for noise induced hearing loss assessment. Biomedical and Health Informatics (BHI), 2016 IEEE-EMBS International Conference on: IEEE; 2016. p. 398-401. [12] Fletcher H. Auditory patterns. Reviews of modern physics. 1940;12:47. [13] Chen Z, Hu G, Glasberg BR, Moore BC. A new method of calculating auditory excitation patterns and loudness for steady sounds. Hearing research. 2011;282:204-15. [14] Moore BC, Glasberg BR. Suggested formulae for calculating auditory‐filter bandwidths and excitation patterns. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 1983;74:750-3. [15] Zwicker E. Masking and psychological excitation as consequences of the ear's frequency analysis. Frequency analysis and periodicity detection in hearing. 1970:376-94. [16] Glasberg BR, Moore BC. Derivation of auditory filter shapes from notched-noise data. Hearing research. 1990;47:103-38. [17] Lopez-Poveda EA, Meddis R. A human nonlinear cochlear filterbank. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 2001;110:3107-18. [18] Hohmann V. Frequency analysis and synthesis using a Gammatone filterbank. Acta Acustica united with Acustica. 2002;88:433-42. [19] Meddis R, O'Mard LP, Lopez-Poveda EA. A computational algorithm for computing nonlinear auditory frequency selectivity. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 2001;109:2852-61. [20] Irino T, Patterson RD. A dynamic compressive gammachirp auditory filterbank. Audio, Speech, and Language Processing, IEEE Transactions on. 2006;14:2222-32. [21] Saremi A, Beutelmann R, Dietz M, Ashida G, Kretzberg J, Verhulst S. A comparative study of seven human cochlear filter models. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 2016;140:1618-34. [22] Moore BC, Glasberg BR, Baer T. A model for the prediction of thresholds, loudness, and partial loudness. Journal of the Audio Engineering Society. 1997;45:224-40. [23] Schomer PD, Suzuki Y, Saito F. Evaluation of loudness-level weightings for assessing the annoyance of environmental noise. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 2001;110:2390-7. [24] Sun P, Qin J, Qiu W. Development and validation of a new adaptive weighting for auditory risk assessment of complex noise. Applied Acoustics. 2016;103:30-6. [25] Qin J, Sun P, Walker J. Measurement of field complex noise using a novel acoustic detection system. AUTOTESTCON, 2014 IEEE: IEEE; 2014. p. 177-82. [26] Johnson K. Acoustic and auditory phonetics. Phonetica. 2004;61:56-8. [27] ANSI S. 4: Procedure for the computation of loudness of steady sounds. ANSI S3. 2007:4-2007. [28] Rosowski JJ. Outer and middle ears. Comparative Hearing: Mammals: Springer; 1994. p. 172-247. [29] Slama MC, Ravicz ME, Rosowski JJ. Middle ear function and cochlear input impedance in chinchilla. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 2010;127:1397-410. [30] Hartmann WM. Signals, sound, and sensation: Springer Science & Business Media; 1997. [31] Patterson RD, Nimmo‐Smith I, Weber DL, Milroy R. The deterioration of hearing with age: Frequency selectivity, the critical ratio, the audiogram, and speech threshold. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 1982;72:1788-803. [32] Patterson RD. Auditory filter shapes derived with noise stimuli. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 1976;59:640-54. [33] Acoustical Society of A, Acoustical Society of A, Standards S, American National Standards I, Accredited Standards Committee S B. American National Standard : procedure for the computation of loudness of steady sounds. Melville, N.Y.: Standards Secretariat, Acoustical Society of America; 2005. [34] Crane H. Mechanical impact: a model for auditory excitation and fatigue. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America. 1966;40:1147-59. [35] Hussain ZM, Sadik AZ, O'Shea P. Digital signal processing: an introduction with MATLAB and applications: Springer Science & Business Media; 2011.
1211.0700	1	1211	2012-11-04T16:17:49	A transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	A transient analysis for vesicle deformation under DC electric fields is developed. The theory extends from a droplet model, with the additional consideration of a lipid membrane separating two fluids of arbitrary properties. For the latter, both a membrane-charging and a membrane-mechanical model are supplied. The vesicle is assumed to remain spheroidal in shape for all times. The main result is an ODE governing the evolution of the vesicle aspect ratio. The effects of initial membrane tension and pulse length are examined. The model prediction is extensively compared with experimental data, and is shown to accurately capture the system behavior in the regime of no or weak electroporation. More importantly, the comparison reveals that vesicle relaxation obeys a universal behavior regardless of the means of deformation. The process is governed by a single timescale that is a function of the vesicle initial radius, the fluid viscosity, and the initial membrane tension. This universal scaling law can be used to calculate membrane properties from experimental data.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation A transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation Jia Zhang,1 Jeffery D. Zahn,2 Wenchang Tan,3 and Hao Lin1, a) 1Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, Piscataway, NJ 08854, USA 2Department of Biomedical Engineering, Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, Piscataway, NJ 08854, USA 3State Key Laboratory for Turbulence and Complex Systems, Department of Mechanics and Engineering Science, College of Engineering, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China (Dated: 1 November 2018) A transient analysis for vesicle deformation under DC electric fields is developed. The theory extends from a droplet model, with the additional consideration of a lipid membrane separating two fluids of arbitrary properties. For the latter, both a membrane-charging and a membrane-mechanical model are supplied. The vesicle is assumed to remain spheroidal in shape for all times. The main result is an ODE governing the evolution of the vesicle aspect ratio. The effects of initial membrane tension and pulse length are examined. The model prediction is extensively compared with experimental data, and is shown to accurately capture the system behavior in the regime of no or weak electroporation. More importantly, the comparison reveals that vesicle relaxation obeys a universal behavior regardless of the means of deformation. The process is governed by a single timescale that is a function of the vesicle initial radius, the fluid viscosity, and the initial membrane tension. This universal scaling law can be used to calculate membrane properties from experimental data. I. INTRODUCTION Vesicles are widely used as a model system for biolog- ical cells due to their simplicity and controllability. The deformation of the lipid membrane, in particular under an applied electric field (electrodeformation), is often ex- plored to probe membrane properties1,2 and to detect pathological changes in cells.3 In the past decade, vesicle electrodeformation has be- come a significant subject of study, and earlier work can be divided into two categories. In the first cate- gory, an alternating-current (AC) field is applied, which often induces stationary and small deformations.1,2,4,5 Correspondingly, an electrohydrodynamic theory in the small-deformation limit was developed to interpret the data trends.6 In the second, under direct-current (DC) electric fields, vesicles usually exhibit large and tran- sient deformations due to the large field strengths com- monly applied.7 -- 10 Recently, using high-resolution, high- speed optical imaging Riske and Dimova8 acquired a large amount of data capturing the complex deformation- relaxation behavior of the vesicles. Although some qual- itative and scaling arguments were presented,4 the data was not fully interpreted due to the absence of a pre- dictive model. Meanwhile, one of us (HL) experimen- tally examined vesicles in the large-deformation regime with aspect ratios reaching ten.10 A large-deformation theory was also presented, which provided quantitative agreement with the data therein. However, the model was semi-empirical in that the hydrodynamic problem was not rigorously treated, but followed an empirical ap- proach by Hyuga and co-authors.11,12 In general, a rig- orous and transient analysis needs to be developed to a)Email address for correspondence: [email protected] understand the complex deformation-relaxation behav- ior, and to provide insights on the underlying physical processes. In this work, we develop a transient analysis for vesi- cle electrodeformation. The theory is derived by extend- ing our previous work on a droplet model,13 with the additional consideration of a lipid membrane separating two fluids of arbitrary properties. For the latter, both a membrane-charging and a membrane-mechanical model are supplied. Similar to the droplet model, the main re- sult is also an ordinary differential equation (ODE) gov- erning the evolution of the vesicle aspect ratio. The ef- fects of initial membrane tension and pulse length are examined. The model prediction is extensively com- pared with experimental data from Riske and Dimova8 and Sadik et al.,10 and is shown to accurately capture the system behavior in the regime of no or weak elec- troporation. More importantly, the comparison reveals that vesicle relaxation obeys a universal behavior, and is governed by a single timescale that is a function of the vesicle initial radius, the fluid viscosity, and the ini- tial membrane tension. This behavior is regardless of the means of deformation, either via AC/DC electric field, or via mechanical stretching. This universal scaling law is a main contribution of the current work, and can be used to calculate membrane properties from experimental data. II. THEORY The problem configuration is shown in Fig. 1. Under the influence of an applied electric field, charges of op- posite signs are allowed to accumulate on the two sides of the membrane, which induces vesicle deformation and electrohydrodynamic flows both inside and outside the vesicle. We assume that the vesicle remains spheroidal in shape throughout the process. All notations, as well Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation 2 as the prolate spheroidal coordinate system follow those from Zhang et al..13 The surface of the prolate spheriod is conveniently given as ξ = ξ0 ≡ a c . (1) Here c = √a2 − b2 is chosen to be the semi-focal length of the spheroidal vesicle, and a and b are the major and minor semi-axis, respectively. For the derivation below, we further assume that the volume of the vesicle is con- served. We subsequently obtain a = r0(1 − ξ−2 0 )− 1 3 , b = r0(1 − ξ−2 0 ) 1 6 . (2) Therefore, the vesicle geometry is completely character- ized by a single parameter, ξ0, which evolves in time along with deformation. The critical idea of the current anal- ysis is to express all variables, e.g., the electric potential and the stream function in terms of ξ0. In what follows, we introduce both an electrical and a mechanical model for the membrane. An ODE for ξ0 is obtained by apply- ing the stress matching and kinematic conditions. A. The electrical problem The electric potentials both inside and outside the vesi- cle are described by the Laplace equations: ∇2φi = ∇2φe = 0. (3) However, at the membrane the matching conditions are modified: σe hξ ∂φe ∂ξ = σi hξ ∂φi ∂ξ =Cm ∂ c hξ (φe − φi) ∂t + Gmc hξ (φe − φi), at ξ = ξ0.(4) Here Cm and Gm denote the membrane capacitance and conductance, respectively. hξ is a metric coefficient of the prolate spheroidal coordinate system. This membrane- charging model is commonly adopted by many previ- ous research.14 -- 18 The displacement currents from the electrolytes are not included, which approximation is valid when the Maxwell-Wagner timescale, TMW = (ǫi + 2ǫe)/(σi + 2σe), and the charge relaxation timescale, Tcr = ǫ/σ, are small when compared with the membrane- charging time, Tch = r0Cm(1/σi + 1/2σe), and the de- formation time, Td = µe/ǫeE2 0 . However, the last two times are in general comparable with each other. The first term on the RHS of Eq. (4) represents capacitive charging of the membrane, which includes the effect of membrane deformation. However, the contribution from this effect is usually small, and is neglected in the current analysis for simplicity. Equation (4) can be consequently reduced to ∂φe ∂ξ ∂(φe − φi) ∂φi ∂ξ ∂t = σe hξ = σi hξ Cmc hξ Gmc hξ + (φe − φi), at ξ = ξ0.(5) FIG. 1. (a) A schematic of the problem configuration. The original radius of the vesicle is r0. The conductivity is denoted by σ, the permittivity is denoted by ǫ, the viscosity is denoted by µ, and the subscripts i and e denote intravesicular and ex- travesicular, respectively. The strength of the applied electric field is E0. (b) The prolate spheroidal coordinate system. Equation (5) can be further simplified by considering dif- ferent stages of charging. In the first stage, the trans- membrane potential (TMP), Vm ≡ (φi − φe)ξ=ξ0 , grows continuously in magnitude, but the membrane is not per- meabilized. Under this condition, Gm is near zero, and Eq. (5) becomes σe hξ ∂φe ∂ξ = σi hξ ∂φi ∂ξ = Cmc hξ ∂(φe − φi) ∂t , at ξ = ξ0. (6) In the second stage, the maximum TMP reaches the critical threshold, Vc, for electroporation to occur.19 -- 25 The membrane becomes permeable to ions, and Gm in- creases significantly to limit further growth of the TMP. In general, the exact values of Vm and Gm depend on the detailed electroporation conditions and variables such as pore density and pore area.18 The solution usually requires a complex numerical simulation which is be- yond the scope of the theoretical analysis pursued in this paper. However, a comprehensive model study by Li and Lin18 showed that the maximum TMP remained at the critical level in the presence of the pulse post- permeabilization. In this work, we adopt an approximate Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation 3 model for this stage. We assume that once the maximum value of Vm reaches Vc, it no longer grows and "freezes" in time. In addition, the membrane is completely perme- abilized, and Eq. (5) is replaced by σe hξ ∂φe ∂ξ = σi hξ ∂φi ∂ξ , Vm = Vc, at ξ = ξ0. (7) Note that electroporation only occurs for sufficiently strong electric fields, and Eq. (7) is not needed for some of the cases studied below where Vc is never reached. Far away from the vesicle surface, the electric field is uniform − ∇φe = E0z, at ξ → ∞. (8) We also require that φi remains finite at ξ = 1. For initial condition, we solve Eqs. (3) and (6) with Vm = 0. The general solution of the electric potentials for both the exterior and interior of the vesicle can be obtained following a similar procedure outlined in Zhang et al.:13 φe = E0r0 [−λξ + αQ1(ξ)] η, φi = E0r0βξη. (9) (10) Here, Q1(ξ) is a 1st-degree Legendre polynomial of the second kind. λ ≡ c/r0 is the dimensionless semi-focal length. The coefficients α and β are again obtained by applying the matching conditions. In the absence of elec- troporation, they are given as α = β + σrλ Q′ 1(ξ0)σr , 1(ξ0)σr − ξ0(cid:21) dβ (cid:20) Q1(ξ0) Q′ dτ −" Q1(ξ0)Q −"(cid:18)ξ0 − ′′ 1 (ξ0) − Q 1 (ξ0)(1 − σr) ′2 Q′2 1 (ξ0)σr dξ0 dτ + Q1(ξ0) Q′ 1(ξ0)(cid:19) dλ dξ0 λQ + ′′ 1 (ξ0)Q1(ξ0) Q′2 1 (ξ0) τ2 τ1λ# β # dξ0 dτ = 0, α(0) = λξ0(σr − 1) Q′ 1(ξ0)ξ0σr − Q1(ξ0) , β(0) =h−λ + α(0)Q ′ 1(ξ0)i σr. (11) (12) (13) Here σr ≡ σe/σi is the conductivity ratio. τ1 ≡ r0Cm/σi is a membrane-charging time. τ2 ≡ r0µe/Γ0 is a charac- teristic flow timescale. Γ0 is the initial membrane ten- sion introduced below. The dimensionless time τ defined as τ ≡ t/τ2 has been used. Note that the definition of these times slightly deviates from those used in Zhang et al.13 due to the difference between droplet and vesicle. However, τ2 remains formally the same by replacing γ in Zhang et al.13 with Γ0. After the maximum value of Vm reaches the critical threshold, electroporation occurs. α and β are calculated by Eq. (7) which yields α = −Vc/(E0r0) − λξ0(σr − 1) Q1(ξ0) − Q′ 1(ξ0)ξ0σr , β =h−λ + αQ ′ 1(ξ0)i σr. (14) The expressions for the normal and tangential electro- static stresses are found in Zhang et al.13 and not re- peated here. B. The hydrodynamic problem In the regime of low-Reynolds-number flow, the gov- erning equation for the hydrodynamic problem can be rewritten in terms of the stream function, ψ, as E4ψ = 0. (15) Here, the expression for the operator E2 can be found in Dubash and Mestel26 and Bentenitis and Krause.27 The stream function is related to the velocity components as u = − 1 hξhθ ∂ψ ∂ξ , v = 1 hηhθ ∂ψ ∂η . (16) hη and hθ are metric coefficients of the prolate spheroidal coordinate system. At the membrane, u and v represent the tangential and normal velocities, respectively, and they are required to be continuous ue = ui, ve = vi, at ξ = ξ0. (17) In addition, we prescribe a kinematic condition relating the membrane displacement to the normal velocity, v(ξ = ξ0, η) = r0(cid:0)1 − ξ−2 0 (cid:1)−5/6 3ξ2 0 dξ0 dt . (18) (cid:0)1 − 3η2(cid:1) pξ2 0 − η2 At the membrane, the stress matching condition is given as: τ · n = f mem. (19) Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation 4 Γ0 = 10−9 N/m Γ0 = 10−7 N/m Γ0 = 10−5 N/m Γ0 = 10−3 N/m 0.25 0.6 0.2 0.5 ∆ 0.15 0.4 0.3 0 0.1 0.05 0.05 0.1 0 10−9 10−8 10−7 10−6 10−5 10−4 10−3 10−2 10−1 Γh (N/m) FIG. 2. The relative increase of the apparent area, ∆, as a function of membrane tension, Γh, for different values of ini- tial membrane tension, Γ0. The inset shows the linear regime for larger Γh values. Here f mem is the surface force density arising from the vesicle membrane. The tensor τ includes contributions from both the hydrodynamic and electrostatic stresses: τ ≡ −pI + µ(∇v + ∇vT ) + ǫEE − 1 2 ǫ(E · E)I. (20) verify that f κ is several orders of magnitude smaller than f Γ, and is therefore not included in the current analysis. The local membrane tension, Γ, is calculated by assum- ing an effective tension which is uniform over the entire membrane.6,29 An increase of the homogeneous tension, Γh, from the initial tension, Γ0, leads to an increase in the apparent membrane area:1,29 -- 31 ∆ = kBT 8πκ ln Γh Γ0 + Γh − Γ0 Ka . (22) Here ∆ is the increase in the apparent membrane area relative to the initial spherical state, 1 ∆ = 0 (cid:1)− 2(cid:0)1 − ξ−2 2 3 h1 − ξ−2 0 +(cid:0)ξ2 0 − 1(cid:1) 1 2 arcsin(cid:0)ξ−1 0 (cid:1)i−1. (23) Ka is the elastic stretching modulus. κ is the bending rigidity. Equation (22) indicates that Γ0, κ, and Ka are the important parameters in determining membrane ten- sion. κ and Ka are usually constants for a specific vesicle type, and their values are often readily obtained from previous work.1,32,33 On the other hand, Γ0 is specific to an individual vesicle, and its value can not be directly determined from experimental measurements. The re- lation between ∆ and Γh for different choices of Γ0 is shown in Fig. 2. When ∆ is small, the membrane area increases through the flattening of the undulations, and Γh shows an exponential correlation with ∆. When ∆ is sufficiently large, a linear behavior is observed instead, and the membrane area increase is mainly due to elastic stretching. Moreover, a larger Γ0 always leads to a larger Γh for the same value of ∆. C. The membrane-mechanical model The surface force density at the vesicle membrane es- sentially consists of two parts6,28 f mem = f κ + f Γ. (21) Here f κ is the surface force density induced by bending resistance. f Γ = 2ΓH n−∇sΓ is the surface force density induced by the membrane tension. H is the mean curva- ture, and Γ is the local membrane tension. We can easily D. General solution A solution for vesicle electrodeformation can be ob- tained by solving the governing equations of both the electrical and hydrodynamic problems, with the help of the matching conditions. The solution strategy is iden- tical to that presented in Zhang et al.,13 with only dif- ferences in the detailed matching conditions for both the electric field and the interfacial forces. For brevity, only the final governing equation for ξ0 is presented here: dξ0 dτ = − QN = CaE 1 Γh Γ0 µrf22(ξ0) + f23(ξ0) µrf14(ξ0) + f15(ξ0) − F (cid:20)QN f21(ξ0) + QT λ2 h(λ − αQ λ2 h(λ − αQ f24(ξ0)(cid:21) , 1(ξ0))2 + (λ − αQ1(ξ0)/ξ0)2 − 2β2/ǫri , 1(ξ0))(λ − αQ1(ξ0)/ξ0) − β2/ǫri . CaE ′ ′ QT = The functions f14(ξ0), f15(ξ0), f21(ξ0) − f24(ξ0), and F are the same as those used in Zhang et al.,13 and the detailed expressions are found in the Appendix. (24a) (24b) (24c) ǫr ≡ Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation 5 ǫe/ǫi is the permittivity ratio. The factors QN and QT again arise from the effects of the tangential and normal stresses, respectively. CaE ≡ r0ǫeE2 0 /Γ0 is the modified electric capillary number. In the absence of electropo- ration, the coefficients α and β are given in Eqs. (11) and (12). Once the electroporation occurs, Eq. (14) is used instead. Similar to the droplet model, an examina- tion of the three terms in the numerator of Eq. (24a) reveals the contribution from the normal stress, tangen- tial stress, and membrane tension, respectively. The bal- ance between these three terms determines the equilib- rium vesicle shape. The above equations are solved until the end of the pulse, t = tp. In the context of vesicle electrodeformation, the relax- ation process is equally important, and is more reveal- ing of the underlying physical processes. The governing equations are presented below. In the absence of electro- poration, Eq. (3) is solved without an applied electric field. The resulting equation for ξ0 remains the same as Eq. (24a). The coefficients of QN , QT , α, and β are given as QN = ǫeV 2 c λ2r0Γ0 hα2(cid:16)Q ′2 1 (ξ0) + Q2 1(ξ0)/ξ2 0(cid:17) − 2β2/ǫri , (25) QT = ǫeV 2 c λ2r0Γ0 hα2Q1(ξ0)Q ′ 1(ξ0)/ξ0 − β2/ǫri , α = β Q′ 1(ξ0)σr , dξ0 dτ + τ2 τ1λ# β = 0, (cid:20) Q1(ξ0) 1(ξ0)σr − ξ0(cid:21) dβ Q′ dτ −" Q1(ξ0)Q ′′ 1 (ξ0) − Q 1 (ξ0)(1 − σr) ′2 Q′2 1 (ξ0)σr α(τp) = Vc(Q′ Vm(τp) 1(ξ0)ξ0σr − Q1) , β(τp) = Vm(τp)Q ′ 1(ξ0)σr Vc(Q′ 1(ξ0)ξ0σr − Q1) . (26) (27) (28) (29) (32) (33) (34) In Eq. (29), the initial conditions for α and β are ob- tained by solving Eqs. (3) and (6), and requiring that Vm assumes the value at the end of the pulse. τp is the dimensionless time, tp/τ2. Note that in this case, al- though the pulse is switched off, the electric field is in general not zero, due to the capacitive discharging of the membrane. In this case, the TMP will decreases from its peak value to zero on the membrane-charging timescale, Tch. When electroporation is present, the discharging pro- cess is slightly more complex. The full membrane- charging model (5) is used. In order to determine the membrane conductance, Gm, we simply assume that it remains unchanged from the moment the pulse ceases, namely, Gm = − σeβE0 λVc . (30) The resulting equation for ξ0 again does not formally deviate from Eq. (24a). The coefficients of QN , QT , α, and β are QN = ǫeV 2 c λ2r0Γ0 hα2(cid:16)Q ′2 1 (ξ0) + Q2 1(ξ0)/ξ2 0(cid:17) − 2β2/ǫri , (31) QT = ǫeV 2 c λ2r0Γ0 hα2Q1(ξ0)Q ′ 1(ξ0)/ξ0 − β2/ǫri , β α = , Q′ 1(ξ0)σr (cid:20) Q1(ξ0) 1(ξ0)σr − ξ0(cid:21) dβ Q′ dτ −" Q1(ξ0)Q ′′ 1 (ξ0) − Q 1 (ξ0)(1 − σr) ′2 Q′2 1 (ξ0)σr dξ0 dτ + τ2 τ1λ − τ2Gm Cm (cid:18) Q1(ξ0) 1(ξ0)σr − ξ0(cid:19)# β = 0. Q′ E. A similarity solution for vesicle relaxation The governing equation for the relaxation process can be further simplified following two considerations. First, we may ignore the membrane-discharging process. The membrane-charging/discharging time, Tch, is on the or- der of 1 ms, which is in general much shorter than the Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation 6 relaxation time observed in the experiments, namely, a few tens of ms or longer. The relatively small effect of discharging on relaxation is clearly seen in Fig. 3 pre- sented in the following section. Without including the discharging process, the coefficients QT and QN in Eq. (24a) are simply set to zero. Second, in the membrane- mechanical model (22), the first and second term on the RHS represent the effects of undulation unfolding and elastic stretching, respectively. For moderate values of Γ0, and for small-to-moderate deformations, the sec- ond term can be ignored, and the membrane-mechanical model becomes ∆ = kBT 8πκ ln Γh Γ0 . (35) Substituting QT = QN = 0 and Eq. (35) into (24a), we obtain dξ0 dτ = 1 F exp( 8πκ∆ kBT )f24(ξ0). (36) This equation is conveniently rewritten in terms of the aspect ratio as d a b dτ 1 F = − exp( 8πκ∆ kBT )(ξ2 0 − 1)− 3 2 f24(ξ0). (37) Note that in this equation, κ, the bending rigidity, is regarded constant for a specific vesicle type, and µr (em- bedded in F , see Appendix) is close to 1 as both the fluids are usually aqueous. In addition, ∆, the relative increase of apparent membrane area, depends exclusively on ξ0, hence a/b according to Eqs. (23) and (2). Under these assumptions, we observe that Eq. (37) is completely au- tonomous, and the relaxation process is governed by the dimensionless time, τ = t/τ2, where τ2 = r0µe/Γ0. This result suggests that the relaxation of vesicles with dif- ferent initial radius, r0, and initial tension, Γ0, obeys a similarity behavior with the proper scaling suggested above. This behavior is demonstrated by both simulation and analysis of previous experimental data below. III. RESULTS For all results below, we assume the lipid membrane to be made of egg-PC following Riske and Dimova8 (henceforth abbreviated as ′RD05′) and Sadik et al.10 (henceforth denoted as ′S11′). The bending rigidity is taken to be κ = 2.47 × 10−20 J;1 the elastic modu- lus, Ka = 0.14 N/m;32,33 the membrane capacitance, Cm = 0.01 F/m2;34 the intravesicular and extravesicular viscosities, µi = µe = 10−3 Pa · s; the intravesicular and extravesicular permittivities, ǫi = ǫe = 7 × 10−10 F/m. The critical transmembrane potential is assumed to be Vc = 1 V.35 TABLE I. List of parameters for Fig. 5. For each case, E0 and tp are specified according to RD05. Γ0 is a fitting parameter to obtain best comparison between simulation and data. For cases b, d, e, and f, extended pulse lengths (denoted by star) are also used. case # E0 (kV/cm) tp (µs) a b c d e f g h 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 3 3 150 200 300* 250 300 400* 50 80* 100 170* 50 100 Γ0 (N/m) 2.79 × 10−4 3.23 × 10−6 3.23 × 10−6 1.67 × 10−4 1.80 × 10−6 1.80 × 10−6 1.80 × 10−4 1.80 × 10−4 3.16 × 10−6 3.16 × 10−6 6.67 × 10−6 3.42 × 10−7 A. The effects of Γ0 and tp We begin by examining the effects of Γ0 on vesi- cle electrodeformation and relaxation. Figure 3 shows the typical system behavior for values of Γ0 ranging from 10−7 − 10−3 N/m. The intravesicular and ex- travesicular conductivities are σi = 6 × 10−4 S/m and σe = 4.5 × 10−4 S/m, respectively following RD05. The field strength is E0 = 1 kV/cm, the pulse length is tp = 250 µs, and the initial radius is r0 = 15 µm. Fig- ure 3(a) shows the evolution of Vm at the cathode-facing pole, which demonstrates only a weak dependence on Γ0. The threshold for electroporation (1 V) is reached just before the end of the pulse, and its effects are present yet negligible. The discharging occurs on the relatively short timescale of 1 ms as we discussed above. Figure 3(b) shows the evolution of the aspect ratio, a/b. The dis- charging process manifests itself as a sudden and slight decrease in the aspect ratio immediately after the pulse ceases; its effects can in general be ignored without signif- icantly altering the relaxation behavior. A smaller value of Γ0 leads to a larger aspect ratio, and a longer relax- ation process. The maximum aspect ratio, [a/b]max, is plotted as a function of Γ0 in Fig. 3(c). As the initial membrane tension decreases toward zero, the maximum achievable aspect ratio saturates. The similarity behavior in the relaxation process is demonstrated in Fig. 3(d). The descending branches of the curves (t > tp) shown in Fig. 3(b) are rescaled in terms of τ = t/τ2, and shifted horizontally. In compari- son, the thick solid curve is obtained by directly solving Eq. (37). The convergence of all curves validates that τ2 = r0µe/Γ0 is the single timescale governing vesicle relaxation. The effects of tp are examined in Fig. 4. The pa- rameters are the same as in Fig. 3, and we fix Γ0 at 1 × 10−6 N/m. Figure 4(a) shows that a longer pulse Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation 7 Discharging Γ0 = 1.0 × 10−3 N/m Γ0 = 1.5 × 10−4 N/m Γ0 = 1.0 × 10−5 N/m Γ0 = 1.0 × 10−6 N/m Γ0 = 1.0 × 10−7 N/m (b) 1.2 1.15 a b 1.1 1.05 (a) ) V ( m V 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0 (c) 1.2 x a m ] a b [ 1.15 1.1 1.05 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 t (ms) 1 10−6 10−5 10−4 10−3 10−2 10−1 100 101 t (s) Similarity Solution (d) 1.2 1.15 a b 1.1 1.05 1 10−7 10−6 10−5 10−4 10−3 Γ0 (N/m) 1 0 2 4 τ 6 8 10 FIG. 3. Vesicle deformation-relaxation as a function of Γ0. The governing parameters are σi = 6×10−4 S/m, σe = 4.5×10−4 S/m, E0 = 1 kV/cm, tp = 250 µs, and r0 = 15 µm. (a) The transmembrane potential at the cathode-facing pole. (b) The time-course of the aspect ratio. (c) The maximum aspect ratio as a function of Γ0. (d) The similarity behavior in relaxation. The descending branches from (b) are rescaled with τ = t/τ2. The thick solid curve is directly obtained by integrating Eq. (37). consistently leads to greater deformation, and the aspect ratio increases along the same envelope. The relaxation times are approximately the same for all cases, because τ2 remains unchanged. The discharging process is in gen- eral more conspicuous with longer pulses. In Fig. 4(b), the relaxation curves are again shifted horizontally and rescaled with τ2 to show good agreement with the simi- larity solution (thick solid line). Note that here because all cases share the same values of τ2, the collapse of the curves is primarily caused by simple shifting. In other words, the aspect ratio also decreases along a common envelope. The above results are exemplary and demonstrate the typical system behavior. In general, the relaxation pro- cess (in particular the relaxation time) is more apprecia- bly affected by the change in Γ0 than the deformation process. A wide range of pulsing parameters are studied below, in direct comparison with experimental data from RD05 and S11. B. Comparison with experimental data An extensive comparison of our theoretical prediction with the data from RD05 is presented in Fig. 5. For all eight cases, the initial radius is r0 = 15 µm. The electrical conductivities are σi = 6 × 10−4 S/m and σe = 4.5 × 10−4 S/m, respectively, leading to a conduc- tivity ratio of σr = 0.75. Other parameters are listed in table I. All parameters are taken directly from RD05, ex- cept for the extended pulse lengths for some cases noted below. For each case, the initial tension, Γ0, is deter- Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation 8 (a) 1.25 a b 1.2 1.15 1.1 1.05 tp = 50 µs tp = 100 µs tp = 150 µs tp = 200 µs tp = 250 µs tp = 300 µs 1 10−6 10−5 10−4 10−3 10−2 10−1 100 101 t (s) Similarity Solution (b) 1.25 a b 1.2 1.15 1.1 1.05 1 0 2 4 τ 6 8 10 FIG. 4. Vesicle deformation-relaxation as a function of tp. The parameters are the same as in Fig. 3. The initial tension is set to be constant, Γ0 = 1 × 10−6 N/m. (a) The time-course of the aspect ratio. (b) The similarity behavior is observed by shifting the relaxation curves with respect to time. The relaxation timescale, τ2 = r0µe/Γ0, is the same for all cases. The thick solid curve is directly obtained by integrating Eq. (37). mined to best fit the experimental data; their values are listed in table I in the last column. The experimental data are presented as symbols; the theoretical predic- tions, solid lines. In Figs. 5(a) to 5(d), the electric field strength is E0 = 1 kV/cm. For these cases, Vm is pre- dicted to reach Vc at t = 242 µs. In Figs. 5(a) and 5(c), good agreements are observed between the theoret- ical prediction and the data. In Figs. 5(b) and 5(d), the model results underpredict the maximum aspect ratios. This discrepancy is peculiar: our simulation follows the data accurately during the presence of the pulse, which duration is provided by RD05. After the pulse ceases, the simulation predicts immediate relaxation, whereas the vesicles continued to deform in the experiments, due to some unknown cause. In an attempt to mend this dif- ference, we artificially increase the pulse lengths in the simulation in b and d from 200 and 300 to 300 and 400 µs, respectively. The values for Γ0 remain unchanged. The results are shown as dashed curves. The model predicts well the data for both the deformation and relaxation processes. Note that although the relaxation curves rep- resented by the solid and dashed lines look somewhat different due to the semi-log scale on the time axis, they actually follow the same descending envelopes which we have demonstrated in Fig. 4(b) above. In Figs. 5(e) and 5(f), the field strength is increased to be E0 = 2 kV/cm, and the pulse lengths used in RD05 were 50 and 100 µs, respectively. For these cases, our model predicts the occurrence of electroporation around t = 103 µs. A similar situation is observed as in Figs. 5(b) and 5(d). The solid curves underpredict the maxi- mum aspect ratio. Artificially extending the pulses in e and f to 80 and 170 µs, respectively, leads to much better agreement between the two. In Figs. 5(g) and 5(h), the field strength is further increased to 3 kV/cm, and electroporation is predicted to occur at t = 66 µs. The entire deformation-relaxation process is well-captured in g where tp = 50 µs. In Fig. 5(h), where tp = 100 µs, although the model accurately predicts the deformation, the simulated relaxation curve completely deviates from the experimental data. For this case, and for pulses even longer than 100 µs, RD05 [Fig. 1(c) therein] exhibits a regime where complex, multi- stage relaxation process was observed. In this regime, the membrane structure is likely severely altered due to electroporation, which process can not be captured by our present model. Further comparison with these data is not pursued. The similarity behavior in the relaxation process is demonstrated in Fig. 6. The experimental data from Figs. 5(a) to 5(g) are shifted horizontally and rescaled with τ2. For each case, τ2 is obtained using Γ0 listed in table I. The thick solid curve is again the similarity so- lution from Eq. (37), and the results are shown on both semi-log and linear scales in τ . The coefficient of de- termination is R2 = 0.96. The experimental data from a wide range of parameters demonstrate a universal behav- ior governed by a single timescale, τ2 = r0µe/Γ0. This result is a main contribution of the present work. We remark that a similar behavior should be observed for droplets, where the initial membrane tension, Γ0, is replaced by γ, the coefficient of surface tension in τ2 (cf. the definition of τ2 in Zhang et al.).13 However, there is a subtle difference between droplet and vesicle relaxation while the coefficient of surface tension is usually a con- stant, the membrane tension, Γh, is not. Nonetheless, as long as Γh depends linearly on Γ0, which is a good approximation for small-to-moderate deformations. The universal behavior in Fig. 6 is expected. Finally, the model prediction is compared with data Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation 9 (b) 1.25 1.2 1.15 1.1 1.05 10−5 10−4 1 10−6 10−5 10−4 10−3 10−2 (d) 1.4 10−1 (a) 1.08 1.06 a b 1.04 1.02 1 10−6 (c) 1.12 a b 1.1 1.08 1.06 1.04 1.02 1 0.98 10−6 (e) 1.15 a b 1.1 1.05 1 10−5 (g) 1.25 a b 1.2 1.15 1.1 1.05 10−5 10−4 10−3 10−4 1.3 1.2 1.1 1 0.9 10−6 1.5 (f ) 10−5 10−4 10−3 10−2 10−1 1.4 1.3 1.2 1.1 1 0.9 10−6 (h) 1.6 10−5 10−4 10−3 10−2 10−1 1.5 1.4 1.3 1.2 1.1 1 10−6 10−5 10−4 10−3 10−2 t (s) 1 10−6 10−5 10−4 t (s) 10−3 10−2 FIG. 5. Comparison with the deformation-relaxation data from RD05. For all cases, r0 = 15 µm, σi = 6 × 10−4 S/m, and σe = 4.5 × 10−4 S/m. Parameters specific to each case are listed in table I. The data is represented by symbols, and the simulation is represented by solid curves. For cases b, d, e, and f, the dashed lines represent the simulated results with extended pulses (denoted by stars in table I). (a) 1.4 a b 1.3 1.2 1.1 1 0.9 10−2 (b) 1.4 a b 1.3 1.2 1.1 1 10 σr = 5.00 × 10−1 σr = 1.67 × 10−2 σr = 3.13 × 10−2 σr = 2.17 × 10−2 σr = 1.89 × 10−2 100 200 300 400 500 t (µs) Current Model S11 20 1 σr 40 60 2 1.8 a b 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0 (b) 2.5 a b 2 1.5 1 0 Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation Similarity Solution (a) 2.2 10−1 τ 100 101 Similarity Solution 0.9 0 2 4 τ 6 8 10 FIG. 6. The similarity behavior of vesicle relaxation. The experimental data from cases a-g in Fig. 5 are shifted in time, then rescaled by τ2 = r0µe/Γ0. They are represented by symbols. The solid curves are calculated with Eq. (37). The same data are shown on both a semi-log (a) and a linear (b) scale. The coefficient of determination is R2 = 0.96. from S11. In this work, the deformation is examined at a fixed pulse length of tp = 500 µs, and for five intra-to-extra vesicular conductivity ratios. Only the case of E0 = 0.9 kV/cm is examined, where no or weak electroporation is expected. We do not compare the cases of E0 = 2 and 3 kV/cm in S11, where the vesi- cles were in the strongly-electroporated regime, and our model no longer applies. The governing parameters are r0 = 11.3 µm and σe = 3 × 10−4 S/m. The initial mem- brane tension is chosen to be the same for all vesicles, namely, Γ0 = 1×10−8 N/m. Figure 7(a) shows the defor- mation process as a function of time for five conductivity ratios. As σr decreases the rate of deformation increases. Except for the case of σr = 0.5, the aspect ratio reaches FIG. 7. Comparison with data from S11. (a) Simulated time- course of the aspect ratio for various conductivity ratios. For all cases r0 = 11.3 µm and Γ0 = 1 × 10−8 N/m. (b) The aspect ratio at t = 500 µs as a function of 1/σr. a plateau before the pulse ends. The time at which the aspect ratio increases saturates with an increasing σr. For σr = 0.5, an equilibrium could be reached if the pulse length is extended and sufficiently long (not shown here). In Fig. 7(b), the aspect ratio at t = tp is shown as a function of 1/σr. We choose this representation to facilitate comparison with the data from S11 (symbols), where the definition of the conductivity ratio is σi/σe. A reasonable agreement is found between the two. The behavior of the simulation and the data is explained by the dependence of the electrical stress on σr in S11 [see Eq. (21) and Sec. 4 therein]. We do not repeat it here for brevity. The current model represents a significant improvement from that in S11, where the hydrodynamic problem is treated empirically. Some remarks are appropriate before concluding the Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation 11 section. First, for most cases studied here, the TMP is near the threshold, and the vesicles are expected to ex- perience no or weak electroporation. For this regime, our model is shown to provide a good predictive capabil- ity, which demonstrates that the membrane-mechanical model (22), although derived assuming no electropo- ration, can be extended to the weakly-electroporated regime, presumably due to the absence of major struc- tural alterations. Our model is not applicable to the strongly-electroporated regime. Second, the universal scaling law in relaxation observed in Figs. 3, 4, and 6 is expected to hold regardless of the means of deformation, e.g., via AC/DC electric fields, or via mechanical stretch- ing. Equation (37) is applicable to a wide range of relax- ation phenomena beyond electrodeformation. Third, the current work suggests that an extensive parametric study on vesicle electrodeformation-relaxation experimentally, in particular in the sub-critical regime where electropora- tion is avoided, can provide the benefit to further validate our model understanding. A systematic approach can be possibly developed based on this work to map membrane properties. IV. CONCLUSIONS In this work, we developed a transient analysis for vesi- cle electrodeformation. The theory is derived by extend- ing our previous work on a droplet model in Zhang et al.,13 with the additional consideration of a lipid mem- brane separating two fluids of arbitrary properties. For the latter, both a membrane-charging and a membrane- mechanical model are supplied. Similar to the droplet model, the main result is also an ODE governing the evolution of the vesicle aspect ratio. The effects of initial membrane tension and pulse length are examined. The initial membrane tension affects the relaxation process much more significantly than the deformation process, in particular when its value is small. The model predic- tion is extensively compared with experimental data from Riske and Dimova8 and Sadik et al.,10 and is shown to accurately capture the system behavior in the regime of no or weak electroporation. More importantly, the com- parison reveals that vesicle relaxation obeys a universal behavior, and is governed by a single timescale that is a function of the vesicle initial radius, the fluid viscosity, and the initial membrane tension. This behavior is re- gardless of the means of deformation, either via AC/DC electric field, or via mechanical stretching. This universal scaling law is a main contribution of the current work, and can be used to calculate membrane properties from experimental data. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS JZ and HL acknowledge fund support from an NSF award CBET-0747886 with Dr William Schultz and Dr Henning Winter as contract monitors. Appendix A The functions f14(ξ0), f15(ξ0), f21(ξ0) − f24(ξ0), and F in Eq. (24a) are given in the following expressions: dη, (A1) f11(ξ0) =Z G3(η)η (ξ2 0 − η2) 0 − 1(cid:26)Z G3(η)η (ξ2 1 ξ2 0 − η2)(cid:18) (1 − 3η2) 0 − η2) − 3(cid:19) dη(cid:27) , (ξ2 (A2) ′′ G 3 (ξ0)G ′ 5(ξ0) − G 2N ′ ′′ 3(ξ0)G 5 (ξ0) · f11(ξ0), (A3) f12(ξ0) = f13(ξ0) = f14(ξ0) = −ξ0H ′ 3(ξ0)Z G3(η)η 0 − η2)2 dη + (ξ2 1 2 H ′′ 3 (ξ0)f11(ξ0), (A4) H f15(ξ0) = − ′ 3(ξ0)hG3(ξ0)G ′′ 5 (ξ0) − G 2N ′′ 3 (ξ0)G5(ξ0)i f11(ξ0) + ξ0H ′ 3(ξ0)Z G3(η)η 0 − η2)2 dη. (ξ2 (A5) Here N ≡ G3(ξ0)G The detailed expressions for G and H are found in Dassios et al..36 5(ξ0)− G 3(ξ0)G5(ξ0). G and H are Gegenbauer functions of the first and second kind, respectively. ′ ′ f21(ξ0) = 1 2 ξ2 dη, 0Z (η2 − 1)(3η2 − 1) 0 − 3ξ2 (ξ2 0 − η2)2 (ξ2 0 − η2) 0η2 + 2η4) ′ f22(ξ0) = ξ0f11(ξ0)(cid:20)−H f23(ξ0) = ξ0f11(ξ0)"− 3(ξ0)Z (1 − 3η2)(ξ2 49(1 − 3ξ2 0)G3(ξ0)H 30N ′ dη + 3ξ0H3(ξ0)Z 1 − 3η2 (ξ2 0 − η2) 3(ξ0) + H ′ 3(ξ0)Z (1 − 3η2)(ξ2 0 − 3ξ2 (ξ2 0 − η2)2 0η2 + 2η4) (A6) (A7) (A8) dη(cid:21) , dη# , Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation f24(ξ0) = ξ3 0(1 − ξ−2 0 ) 5 6 Z 3η2 − 1 (ξ2 0 − η2) dη + ξ0(1 − ξ−2 0 )− 3 2 1 6 Z 3η2 − 1 pξ2 0 − η2 dη, F = − 2 3 (f25(ξ0) + f26(ξ0)/µr) , where f25(ξ0) = − f22(ξ0) ξ0f11(ξ0) (µr − 1)f12(ξ0) + f13(ξ0) µrf14(ξ0) + f15(ξ0) f26(ξ0) = − f23(ξ0) ξ0f11(ξ0) (µr − 1)f12(ξ0) + f13(ξ0) µrf14(ξ0) + f15(ξ0) µr ≡ µe/µi is the viscosity ratio. − 3ξ0Z 3η2 − 1 (ξ2 0 − η2) 49(1 − 3ξ2 30N 0)G − ′ dη − ξ2 3(ξ0) + ξ2 ξ0 0 − 1Z (2ξ2 0 − 1Z (2ξ2 ξ0 0 − η2 − 1)(1 − 3η2)2 (ξ2 0 − η2)2 0 − η2 − 1)(1 − 3η2)2 (ξ2 0 − η2)2 12 (A9) (A10) dη, (A11) dη. (A12) 1M. Kummrow and W. Helfrich, "Deformation of giant lipid vesi- cles by electric fields," Phys. Rev. A 44, 8356 -- 8360 (1991). 2G. Niggemann, M. Kummrow, and W. Helfrich, "The bending rigidity of phosphatidylcholine bilayers: Dependences on exper- imental method, sample cell sealing and temperature," J. Phys. II France 5, 413 -- 425 (1995). 3P. K. Wong, W. Tan, and C. M. Ho, "Cell relaxation after elec- trodeformation: effect of latrunculin a on cytoskeletal actin," Biomech. J. 38, 529 -- 535 (2005). 4R. Dimova, K. A. Riske, A. S., N. Bezlyepkina, R. L. Knorr, and R. Lipowsky, "Giant vesicles in electric fields," Soft Matter 3, 817 -- 827 (2007). 5S. Aranda, K. A. Riske, R. Lipowsky, and R. Dimova, "Mor- phological transitions of vesicles induced by alternating electric fields," Biophys. J. 95, L19 -- L21 (2008). 6P. M. Vlahovska, R. S. Gracia, S. Aranda-Espinoza, and R. Di- mova, "Electrohydrodynamic model of vesicle deformation in al- ternating electric fields," Biophys. J. 96, 4789 -- 4803 (2009). 7S. Kakorin, T. Liese, and E. Neumann, "Membrane curvature and high-field electroporation of lipid bilayer vesicles," J. Phys. Chem. B 107, 10243 -- 10251 (2003). 8K. A. Riske and R. Dimova, "Electro-deformation and poration of giant vesicles viewed with high temporal resolution," Biophys. J. 88, 1143 -- 1155 (2005). 9K. A. Riske and R. Dimova, "Electric pulses induce cylindrical deformations on giant vesicles in salt solutions," Biophys. J. 91, 1778 -- 1786 (2006). 10M. M. Sadik, J. Li, J. W. Shan, D. I. Shreiber, and H. Lin, "Vesi- cle deformation and poration under strong dc electric fields," Phys. Rev. E 83, 066316 (2011). 11H. Hyuga, K. J. Kinosita, and N. Wakabayashi, "Deformation of vesicles under the influence of strong electric fields," Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 30, 1141 -- 1148 (1991). 12H. Hyuga, K. J. Kinosita, and N. Wakabayashi, "Deformation of vesicles under the influence of strong electric fields II," Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 30, 1333 -- 1335 (1991). 13J. Zhang, J. D. Zahn, and H. Lin, "A transient solution for droplet deformation under electric fields," arXiv:1210.7878 [physics.flu-dyn] (2012). 14H. P. Schwan, "Dielectrophoresis and rotation of cells," in Elec- troporation and electrofusion in cell biology, edited by E. Neu- mann, A. E. Sowers, and C. A. Jordan (Plenum Press, 1989). 15C. Grosse and H. P. Schwan, "Celluar membrane potentials in- duced by alternating fields," Biophys. J. 63, 1632 -- 1642 (1992). 16K. A. Debruin and W. Krassowska, "Modeling electroporation in a single cell. I. Effects of field strength and rest potential," Biophys. J. 77, 1213 -- 1224 (1999). 17W. Krassowska and P. D. Filev, "Modeling electroporation in a single cell," Biophys. J. 92, 404 -- 417 (2007). 18J. Li and H. Lin, "Numerical simulation of molecular uptake via electroporation," Bioelectrochemistry 82, 10 -- 21 (2011). 19D. C. Chang and T. S. Reese, "Changes in membrane structure induced by electroporation as revealed by rapid-freezing electron microscopy," Biophys. J. 58, 1 -- 12 (1990). 20H. Leontiadou, A. E. Mark, and S. J. Marrink, "Molecular dy- namics simulations of hydrophilic pores in lipid bilayers," Bio- phys. J. 86, 2156 -- 2164 (2004). 21A. A. Gurtovenko and I. Vattulainen, "Pore formation coupled to ion transport through lipid membranes as induced by trans- membrane ionic charge imbalance: atomistic molecular dynamics study," J. Am. Chem. Soc. 127, 17570 -- 17571 (2005). 22M. Tarek, "Membrane electroporation: a molecular dynamics simulation," Biophys. J. 88, 4045 -- 4053 (2005). 23J. Wohlert, W. K. den Otter, O. Edholm, and W. J. Briels, "Free energy of a trans-membrane pore calculated from atomistic molecular dynamics simulations," J. Chem. Phys. 124, 154905 (2006). 24U. Pliquett, R. P. Joshi, V. Sridhara, and K. H. Schoenbach, "High electrical field effects on cell membranes," Bioelectrochem- istry 70, 275 -- 282 (2007). 25M. L. Fernandez, G. Marshall, F. Sagues, and R. Reigada, "Structural and kinetic molecular dynamics study of electropo- ration in cholesterol-containing bilayers," J. Phys. Chem. B 114, 6855 -- 6865 (2010). 26N. Dubash and A. J. Mestel, "Behaviour of a conducting drop in a highly viscous fluid subject to an electric field," J. Fluid Mech. 581, 469 -- 493 (2007). 27N. Bentenitis and S. Krause, "Droplet deformation in dc electric fields: the extended leaky dielectric model," Langmuir 21, 6194 -- 6209 (2005). 28U. Seifert, "Configurations of fluid membranes and vesicles," Adv. Phys. 46, 13 -- 137 (1997). 29W. Helfrich and R. M. Servuss, "Undulations, steric interaction and cohension of fluid membranes," Il Nuvo Cimento 3D, 137 -- 151 (1984). 30E. Evans and W. Rawicz, "Entropy-driven tension and bending elasticity in condensed-fluid membranes," Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 2094 -- 2097 (1990). 31E. Evans, "Entropy-driven tension in vesicle membranes and un- binding of adherent vesicles," Langmuir 7, 1900 -- 1908 (1991). 32R. Kwok and E. Evans, "Thermoelasticity of large lecithin bilayer vesicles," Biophys. J. 35, 637 -- 652 (1981). 33D. Needham, "Cohesion and permeability of lipid bilayer vesi- cles," in Permeability and Stability of Lipid Bilayers, edited by E. A. Disalvo and S. A. Simon (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, Transient solution for vesicle electrodeformation and relaxation 13 1995) pp. 49 -- 76. 34D. Needham and R. M. Hochmuth, "Electro-mechanical perme- abilization of lipid vesicles. Role of membrane tension and com- pressibility," Biophys. J. 55, 1001 -- 1009 (1989). 35T. Portet and R. Dimova, "A new method for measuring edge tensions and stability of lipid bilayers: effect of membrane com- position," Biophys. J. 99, 3264 -- 3273 (2010). 36G. Dassios, M. Hadjinicolaou, and A. C. Payatakes, "Gener- alized eigenfunctions and complete semiseparable solutions for Stokes flow in spheroidal coordinates," Q. Appl. Math. 52, 157 -- 191 (1994).
1806.08066	1	1806	2018-06-21T04:46:54	Dimensionality-dependent crossover in motility of polyvalent burnt-bridges ratchets	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.stat-mech", "q-bio.SC" ]	The burnt-bridges ratchet (BBR) mechanism is a model for biased molecular motion whereby the construct destroys track binding sites as it progresses, and therefore acts as a diffusing forager, seeking new substrate sites. Using Monte Carlo simulations that implement the Gillespie algorithm, we investigate the kinetic characteristics of simple polyvalent BBRs as they move on tracks of increasing width. We find that as the track width is increased the BBRs remain nearly ballistic for considerable track widths proportional to the span (leg length) of the polyvalent walker, before transitioning to near-conventional diffusion on two-dimensional tracks. We find there exists a tradeoff in BBR track association time and superdiffusivity in the BBR design parameter space of span, polyvalency and track width. Furthermore, we develop an analytical model to describe the ensembleaverage motion on the track and find it is in good agreement with our Gillespie simulation results. This work offers insights into design criteria for de novo BBRs and their associated tracks, where experimentalists seek to optimize directionality and track association time.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Dimensionality-dependent crossover in motility of polyvalent burnt-bridges ratchets Chapin S. Korosec, Martin J. Zuckermann, and Nancy R. Forde∗ Department of Physics, Simon Fraser University, 8888 University Drive, Burnaby, British Columbia, V5A 1S6, Canada (Dated: June 22, 2018) The burnt-bridges ratchet (BBR) mechanism is a model for biased molecular motion whereby the construct destroys track binding sites as it progresses, and therefore acts as a diffusing forager, seeking new substrate sites. Using Monte Carlo simulations that implement the Gillespie algorithm, we investigate the kinetic characteristics of simple polyvalent BBRs as they move on tracks of increasing width. We find that as the track width is increased the BBRs remain nearly ballistic for considerable track widths proportional to the span (leg length) of the polyvalent walker, before transitioning to near-conventional diffusion on two-dimensional tracks. We find there exists a trade- off in BBR track association time and superdiffusivity in the BBR design parameter space of span, polyvalency and track width. Furthermore, we develop an analytical model to describe the ensemble- average motion on the track and find it is in good agreement with our Gillespie simulation results. This work offers insights into design criteria for de novo BBRs and their associated tracks, where experimentalists seek to optimize directionality and track association time. I. INTRODUCTION Diffusion, driven by random thermal motion, results in slow transport over long distances. Nature has overcome this problem through the evolution of impressive protein- based machines that achieve processive and directional motion despite their noisy thermal environment. Within the cell's cytoplasm, the molecular motors kinesin [1], dynein [2], and myosin [3] achieve directional motion on their intracellular tracks by converting chemical energy in the form of ATP into mechanical stepwise translocation [4, 5]. There are, however, other means by which cellular systems can achieve directed motion besides conventional cytoplasmic motors. In this work, we examine a class of machines that achieve directional motion by a 'burnt- bridges ratchet'(BBR) mechanism. A BBR has a probability p of destroying a substrate track site as it passes [6]. Upon a successful cleavage event, the asymmetry produced in the track prevents backwards stepping. Motion forwards is driven purely by thermal motion without the need for an energetically driven conformational change in the walker. In order to achieve processive motion the timescale of track as- sociation must be long enough such that the BBR can cleave the substrate, explore neighbouring sites, and rely on thermal fluctuations to move. In one dimension, with p = 1, the motion of a BBR is expected to be ballis- tic, while in two dimensions the motion is expected to resemble a self-avoiding walk. We also note that BBR nanomachines can be considered as diffusing foragers, where a parameter of interest is the number of cleavage events before the walker depletes its local environment and 'starves' (detaches) [7]. Matrix-metalloproteases (MMPs) are enzymes that move one-dimensionally via a BBR mechanism along col- lagen fibrils in the extracellular matrix [8, 9]. Individual ∗ [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] MMPs have been observed to move superdiffusively along their collagen tracks at speeds up to 5.8µm/s [10]. In contrast to the one-dimensional motion of MMPs, the protein-based ParA/ParB system found in bacteria is an example of a two-dimensional BBR system [11, 12]. This system is responsible for partitioning extrachromo- somal low-copy plasmid DNA during cell division [13]. These BBRs have been observed to move directionally at speeds of ∼ 0.1 µm/s on their two-dimensional tracks [11]. Nature has therefore implemented the BBR mech- anism in both one-dimensional and two-dimensional sys- tems, where these BBRs have achieved speeds compara- ble to kinesin in saturating ATP conditions [14]. Inspiration from biological systems such as these has led to the development of synthetic nanomachines that achieve directional motion through various stepping mechanisms [15–24]. The motivation for the design and implementation of synthetic nanomachines is two-fold: to create a molecular system that mimics the behaviour of biological counterparts, thereby enabling us to learn about fundamental physical principles that give rise to observed biological molecular motor phenomena; and to create new technologies that perform tasks currently out of our reach [17]. Many of the autonomous synthetic biologically-based nanomotors thus far realized are DNA-based BBRs [16, 17, 20, 22]. In the limit of low polyvalency, Cha et al. [22] developed a DNA walker that moves in a self- avoiding fashion along carbon nanotubes by catalyzing cleavage of its RNA footholds. At the other extreme, DNA-coated microspheres, so-called 'DNA monowheels', hybridize to a substrate surface coated with complemen- tary RNA and have a high polyvalency with thousands of cleavable substrate contacts [25]. The DNA monowheel has demonstrated impressive velocities for an artificial system of up to 2 µm/min, as well as near-ballistic mo- tion on its two-dimensional substrate track [25]. In con- trast to the monowheel's high polyvalency, most DNA walkers are bipedal [19, 26, 27]. arXiv:1806.08066v1 [physics.bio-ph] 21 Jun 2018 In this work, we refer to the total number of legs as the polyvalency. Polyvalency of BBRs is thought to have a profound impact on directionality and track attach- ment times [25]. Analytical approaches to understand- ing the effects of polyvalency on BBR dynamics are dif- ficult as the memory requirement for visited sites leads to non-Markovian behaviour [28, 29]. Because of this, researchers have largely turned to simulations to model the behaviour of synthetic BBR nanomotors [30–33]. Those who seek to experimentally develop synthetic nanomachines are met with the challenge of designing not only the the machine itself, but also the substrate track with which it is to interact. Missing from the liter- ature is an exploration of how the width of the substrate track is expected to impact BBR kinetics. In this work we implement the Monte Carlo Gillespie algorithm [34] to investigate the dependence of the mean squared displace- ment, track attachment time, kurtosis, and extent of sub- strate cleavage on the dimension of the substrate track. We generalize our results by altering the polyvalency and span of the BBRs to explore how these attributes influ- ence ensemble-average kinetics of BBRs moving on tracks of increasing width. In this work we focus on ideal BBRs where substrate binding is followed by a probability p = 1 of catalyzing the bound site. Our BBRs cannot unbind from substrate without a cleavage event, and cannot re- bind to a cleaved product site. Samii et al. [31] report that nanomachines that can unbind from substrate and rebind to product display an increase in track attachment time as a function of increasing polyvalency. Similarly, Yehl et al. [25] report that the prolonged track attach- ment of their BBR DNA monowheel is because of the dramatically increased polyvalency. In contrast to these results, in our system we find that increasing the poly- valency of BBRs results in a dramatic decrease in track association time. Our results further indicate that reduc- ing the dimensionality of the track to one dimension is not necessary to promote linear ballistic motion. There exists a tolerance window in track width that allows for maximally superdiffusive walkers. 2 for the unbound legs. We note that our model is funda- mentally different from that of Olah et al. [32] where they allowed binding to all sites within a distance ' of each bound leg. We allow for binding within a small region around the global constraint, where the region (shown in yellow in Fig. 1a) is determined by the currently bound legs. In this way we account for the collectively imposed constraint of all bound legs limiting the options for fresh track coupling. To study the motion of BBRs we developed a kinetic model similar to that used by Samii et al. [30, 31] and Olah et al. [32] whereby we implement the Monte Carlo Gillespie algorithm [34] to study polyvalent walker dy- namics. Our kinetic model, as shown in Fig. 1b, is a simple model that allows for substrate binding and sub- strate cleavage followed by unbinding. We employ a sub- strate binding rate, kon = 20 s−1, and cleavage rate, kef f = 0.054 s−1. kef f incorporates both the cleavage and detachment processes. These rates are similar to those used by Samii et al. [30, 31]. We made the deci- sion to set the dissociation rates from uncleaved substrate sites to zero, and the product binding rate to zero. This allows us to to focus on a strict burnt-bridges ratchet system distinct from that of previous work on similar systems [30–32]. Each substrate-bound leg is guaranteed to cleave and release to the unbound state where it may bind again to fresh substrate. Therefore, our legs have a probability of p = 1 to cleave each bound substrate site. A kinetic move is chosen by a Monte Carlo Gillespie algorithm that samples from all available transitions of all legs. For example, if there are 2 unbound legs, 3 bound legs, and 12 available substrate sites, there are 24 possible binding transitions and 3 possible transitions to cleave and release. A particular transition with rate ki is chosen . After a choice of transition X ), where X is a random variable uniformly distributed on (0,1]. The central hub position is updated by determining the average position of the bound legs. We then track the motion of this point-like hub for kinetic analysis. with a probability Pi = kiP ki is made, time is updated according to t = 1P ki ln( 1 II. MODEL AND METHODS B. Track design & BBR parameters A. Kinetic model We model polyvalent BBRs as n legs coupled to a point-like hub referred to as the global constraint (Fig. 1). The n legs are non-interacting, but only a single leg can occupy any given track site. The legs chemically in- teract with the track via substrate binding and cleavage, followed by release from the cleaved product. To incorpo- rate leg length into the kinetic model, each of the n legs is assigned a span, which is defined as the maximum dis- tance between any two bound legs. As shown in Fig. 1a a circle of radius R = span is drawn around each bound leg. The substrate track sites that fall within the mutual overlap of all legs' spans are considered binding options To explore the effect track dimensionality has on BBRs, we employed a large range of tracks that increase in width by factors of 2. In total we cover tracks of widths 2n for n = 0, 1, 2, 3, ..., 12, where a track width of 20 is a one-dimensional track. For all 520,000 independent runs reported in this work, track widths of 212 = 4096 can be considered infinitely two-dimensional as no ratchet reached the boundaries within the maximum simulation time of 25,000 seconds for each independent run. As we varied the track width, the length of the track was con- sistently kept to 5000 lattice sites (effectively infinite in length). The track widths chosen were convenient as they allowed us to probe the effects of confinement through gradually increasing the track size away from one dimen- 3 C. Analytical methods 1. Mean squared displacement The mean squared displacement (MSD) is a useful measure used to assess the anomalous nature of a dif- fusive walk [35]. The MSD is defined as the variance in displacement, ~X, and scales with a power-law depen- dence, MSD( ~X) ≡ Var[ ~X] =D( ~X − ~µ)2E ∝ tα, (1) where ~µ is the mean position and α describes the power- law scaling behaviour of the system. For a given ensem- ble of trajectories one can assess the slope of the log-log MSD-time plots to compute α. For all BBR permuta- tions and track widths we computed the MSD via en- semble averaging according to eq. 2, which is equivalent to eq. 1, MSD(~r) = ((cid:10)x2(cid:11) − hxi2) + ((cid:10)y2(cid:11) − hyi2) ∝ tαr , where ~r is the position of the BBR's global constraint. The x and y components of ~r can be examined indepen- dently. We therefore also define MSD(x) and MSD(y) as (2) MSD(x) =(cid:10)x2(cid:11) − hxi2 ∝ tαx , MSD(y) =(cid:10)y2(cid:11) − hyi2 ∝ tαy . 2. Kurtosis (3) (4) Kurtosis is defined as the standardized fourth moment of a distribution about its mean and is given by Kurt[ ~X] = (5) m4 σ4 = D( ~X − ~µ)4E (cid:16)D( ~X − ~µ)2E(cid:17)2 , where m4 is the fourth moment, σ the standard devia- tion, and ~µ the mean. The kurtosis is a useful descriptor for a distribution's deviation from Gaussian. Gaussian distributions have a kurtosis of 3. Therefore, it is conve- nient to define γ2, the excess kurtosis, as γ2 = m4 σ4 − 3. As our BBRs progress on their respective tracks, they produce time-evolving displacement distributions. In particular, we are interested in characterizing the dif- ferences between the evolving x- and y- components of the displacement distributions to understand the effect of constraints on the dynamics of BBRs. To this end, γ2 provides a measure of the shape of the distributions and allows for easy comparison across a large parameter space of BBR designs. FIG. 1. a) Each bound leg is assigned a span which defines the radius of a circle, shown in green, around the bound loca- tion, shown in red. The mutual overlap of bound-leg spans, shown in yellow, marks the feasible binding locations for un- bound legs (not shown) during the following kinetic move. b) Each BBR leg (red) can interact with any availble substrate track site (grey triangle) via a rate of attachment, kon. kef f includes both substrate cleavage and release. sion into an infinite two-dimensional plane. All tracks were initialized as all-substrate tracks; we do not impose any initial asymmetry. All of the BBRs were initialized in the geometric centre of the track with one leg bound. Motivated by previous work [11, 12, 16, 20, 24, 25, 30– 33], we focused on four BBR designs. In the notation of (polyvalency, span) we examined the behaviour of BBRs with parameters (12,8), (3,8), (12,3), and (3,3). The limit of (12,3) BBRs was chosen because all available binding locations within a span of 3 can be saturated. In this limit the BBRs are expected to produce a complete wake of cleaved sites such that the constructs cannot cross pre- viously visited territory. This contrasts with (3,8) BBRs, which we expected to produce sparsely cleaved trajecto- ries. For each BBR design, on each track width, we ran 10,000 independent trajectories. For example, (3,3) has 10,000 independent runs on a track width of 1, and an- other 10,000 on a track width of 2, etc. Trajectories end when no BBR legs remain coupled to the track. We do not allow rebinding of detached BBRs. If the BBRs remain attached to the track for 25,000 seconds the sim- ulation is also ended. (a) Substrate site Product site Substrate-bound leg Global constraint (hub) Track sites within the span (not feasible to bind) Accepted binding sites Span = 4 Span = 4 (b) kon! kef f! III. RESULTS A. Sample trajectories and distributions Single trajectories in two dimensions for (3,8), (3,3), (12,3) and (12,8) BBRs are presented in Fig. 2 (left column). Our lowest span BBR systems, (12,3) and (3,3) BBRs, tend to become easily entrapped by their product wakes, leading to detachment. With increased span and decreased polyvalency, such as the (3,8) system, BBRs can reach over their previous trajectories into areas of fresh substrate. Snapshots of the ensemble behaviour of each BBR de- sign in two dimensions are included in Fig. 2 (right col- umn), beside their respective sample trajectories. The (3,3), (12,3) and (12,8) systems all develop a low occu- pancy near their centre starting position, while the (3,8) system maintains the highest BBR occupancy around the origin. These ensemble snapshots are taken from Movies S1-S4, which present the full dynamic evolution of the ensemble behaviour. B. Mean squared displacement Fig. 3a shows log-log plots of MSD(~r) vs. time for (3,8) BBRs on all examined track widths. We report values of α in the long-time limit when α ≈ 0. A one- dimensional track results in ratchets moving ballistically with α ≈ 2. As track width increases α begins to de- crease. One would naıvely expect that as the width of the track increases, the constructs have increased proba- bility to change direction, thus lowering α. However, this transition does not occur monotonically. Fig. 3b shows that we observe a minimum in αr as a function of track width for all BBR designs. The non-monotonic behaviour of αr as a function of track width prompted closer inspection of the MSD. The log-log plot of MSD(x) (Fig. 3c) depicts the ex- pected MSD power law behaviour: as the track width in- creases αx is found to decrease monotonically to a width- independent minimum (Fig. 3d). By contrast, log-log MSD(y)-time (Fig. 3e) attains a slope of αy ≈ 0 for narrow track widths in long-time limits (Fig. 3f ). Fig. 3b also shows that the large track width values of αr depend on polyvalency and span. Short span and large polyvalency results in the highest αr = 1.4, whereas the lowest αr = 1.1 is found by lowering polyvalency and increasing the span. All of our examined BBR designs display similar MSD trends as a function of track width, as shown in Fig. S1. 4 FIG. 2. Sample trajectories and distributions of polyvalent BBRs on a two-dimensional track. Left column: sample tra- jectories. Green and red points indicate the starting and de- tachment positions for each respective trajectory; the time listed is the lifetime of that trajectory. (3,3), (12,3) and (12,8) BBRs are less likely to cross previously visited terri- tories and exhibit more directional walks compared to (3,8) BBRs. Right column: snapshot of ensemble BBR position distributions, taken from Movies S1-S4. Color coding rep- resents the number of independent BBRs at that location in time. All BBR designs, except for (3,8), develop ring-like distributions with decreased occupancy at the origin. C. Detachment curves In our simulations we do not allow for re-attachment once all of the legs of the BBR have detached. Thus, it is useful to investigate how track association times vary with polyvalency and span. Fig. 4ab display the frac- tion of BBRs remaining bound for all examined BBR designs in the 1D and 2D track limits. We find that (3,8) BBRs remain associated to the track for the longest times, whereas (12,3) BBRs detach the fastest. In Fig. 4c we show that track association time increases mono- Counts 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 12345678 Counts 25 24 22 20 19 18 16 14 13 12 10 124678 Counts 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 123456789 Counts 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 1234567889 (3,3) -20 -10 0 10 20 (3,8) -40 -20 0 20 40 (12,3) -20 0 20 (12,8) 20 10 0 -10 -20 40 20 0 -20 -40 20 0 -20 20 10 0 -10 -20 Start End (3,3) 790 s Start End -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 Start End (3,8) 25000 s -100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 Start End (12,3) 1650 s 10 15 20 25 30 0 5 (12,8) 1915 s Start End 0246 -2 -4 -6 -8 0 -50 -100 30 25 20 15 10 05 200 150 100 50 0 y Coordinate -50 0 50 x Coordinate -20 -10 0 10 20 5 signs. For (12,3) ratchets, increasing track width from one to two dimensions results in an increase of t1/2 by a factor of 10 (Fig. 4d). A similar comparison of (12,8) BBRs yields a factor of 60 increase in track association time. Therefore, in the limit of large polyvalency and short span we see less of a gain in track attachment time by increasing the track width than for larger span. We next compared the different designs directly by tak- ing ratios of the t1/2 trends as shown in Fig. 4e. In the limit of low polyvalency, increasing span from 3 to 8 has a profound effect on increasing track association time. Similarly, in the limit of high span, decreasing polyva- lency from 12 to 3 profoundly increases track association time. However, if the span is kept constant at 3, the decrease in polyvalency from 12 to 3 has little impact on track assocation time across all track widths. There- fore, the improvement in track association time gained from decreasing polyvalency is only realized for the BBR systems with large span. In Fig. 4f we plot αx against t1/2. For all BBR systems αx tends to decrease with increasing t1/2 values. D. Excess kurtosis The ensemble-average displacement of the ratchets away from the origin results in evolving displacement dis- tributions, as shown in Movies S5 and S6. All of the BBRs are initialized at the centre of the track, therefore the initial distribution is peaked at the origin at t = 0 s. As BBRs progress along the track, their cleavage of track sites limits options for turning back. In one dimen- sion, as the BBRs randomly break the track symmetry a bimodal distribution develops whose modes propagate in opposite directions. Fig. 5a illustrates the typical development and separation of the two modes on a nar- row track width of 8 for (3,8) BBRs. From Movie S5, qualitatively, one can see that the modes are both sep- arating and dispersing with time. Fig. 5b shows the results of computing the excess kurtosis, γ2(x), for these (3,8) BBRs on all track widths. In all cases γ2(x) initial- izes slightly higher than the Gaussian value of 0 as the distribution is initially peaked sharply around the origin. On narrow tracks γ2(x) rapidly reduces to the -2.0 limit, indicating a distribution whose probability is located at the edges of its domain. For wider tracks, γ2(x) reduces to -0.25. Similar behaviour is seen for the other BBR designs, as shown in Fig. S3. We next look at the correponding evolution of position distributions for the y coordinates. The y-position distri- bution for (3,8) BBRs on a track width of 128 evolves into a uniform distribution across the accessible domain of lat- tice sites. To understand how this lateral shape of the distribution changes upon interacting with the boundary we compute γ2(y) (Fig. 5d). For wide tracks, where the BBRs do not reach the boundaries, we see that γ2(y) ap- proaches -0.25, the same as found for γ2(x). However, for (3,8) BBRs on a track width of 128, which begin to ap- FIG. 3. a) log-log MSD(~r)-time plots for (3,8) BBRs display the general trend of decreasing slope as a function of increas- ing track width. b) αr for (3,8) BBRs reaches a minimum at track widths of 128-256 before subsequently increasing to a width-invariant plateau of αr ≈ 1.1. A minimum αr at in- termediate widths is observed for all BBR designs examined in this work. c) MSD(x) for (3,8) BBRs scales from ballis- tic to superdiffusive as the track width increases from one to two dimensions. d) αx as a function of width for all BBRs displays a monotically decreasing trend. e) MSD(y) for (3,8) evolves to αy = 0 for all BBRs that are constrained by track boundaries. f) For narrow tracks the BBRs move under con- finement and display αy ≈ 0. As track width increases such that the BBRs do not interact with the boundaries, αy takes on the same values as αx for all BBR designs. tonically as a function of increasing track width for (12,8) BBRs. The detachment curves saturate and overlap for track widths larger than 256. All BBR designs display a similar trend, and can be viewed in Fig. S2. For all detachment curves we define t1/2 as the time at which 50% of the BBRs have detached from the track. For (3,8) BBRs we observed negligible detachment on tracks of width greater than 32, therefore we cannot re- port t1/2 values for wider tracks. Fig. 4d depicts t1/2 as a function of track width for each BBR design. We can see that both polyvalency and span have large ef- fects on the observed t1/2. Across all track widths (12,3) BBRs consistently detach faster than all other BBR de- 6 FIG. 5. a) The evolving x-position distribution for (3,8) BBRs on a track width of 8. The numbers 1-4 represent the dis- tribution at specific times. Two modes develop that move symmetrically in opposing directions. b) Excess kurtosis,γ2, for x-displacement distributions for (3,8) BBRs on all track widths. On narrow tracks γ2(x) quickly approaches -2.0. As track width increases the excess kurtosis settles to γ2(x) = -0.25. The numbers 1-4 correspond to the histograms from a). c) The evolving y-position distribution for (3,8) BBRs on a track of width 128. d) For large track widths γ2(y) limits to -0.25, the same as γ2(x). Under confinement γ2(y) settles to -1.2, the value for a uniform distribution, as illustrated by the numbers 1-4 from part c). distributions with equal variance and equal but opposite means, as shown in eq. 6. P (xµ, σ) = 1 2√2πσ2 e− (x−µ)2 2σ2 + 1 2√2πσ2 e− (x+µ)2 2σ2 (6) We computed the 2nd and 4th moments of P (x) to de- termine the excess kurtosis (see supporting information). We find γ2 to be given by γ2 = 2µ4 + 12µ2σ2 + 6σ4 2(µ2 + σ2)2 − 3. (7) (8) FIG. 4. a) Fraction of BBRs remaining bound in one dimen- sion for all BBR designs examined in this work. The inset shows the early time behaviour. b) Fraction of BBRs remain- ing bound in two dimensions for all BBR designs examined. For both 1D and 2D tracks (3,8) BBRs remain associated to the track for the longest times, whereas (12,3) BBRs asso- ciate to the track for the shortest times. c) Fraction of (12,8) BBRs remaining bound for all track widths. The detachment curves saturate past track widths of 256. d) t1/2 as a function of track width for all BBR designs. e) The ratio of t1/2 values for various BBR designs. f) αx values from Fig. 3d plotted against their respective t1/2 values. proach the track boundary around ∼ 1000s, we see that γ2(y) decreases to -1.2, the value for a uniform distribu- tion [36]. For these (3,8) BBRs γ2(x) remains constant at -0.25 once they have reached the y-boundaries. The shape of the x-displacement distribution is therefore not affected by interactions with the track boundary, while the y-displacement distribution clearly is. Similar be- haviour is seen for the other BBRs (Fig. S4). E. Bimodal Gaussian model The MSD of this distribution is To further our understanding of the time dependence of γ2(x) we analytically derived the excess kurtosis for a probability density function comprised of two Gaussian MSD =(cid:10)(x − µ)2(cid:11) = µ2 + σ2. We examine four cases in our analytical model: a) Constant separation, Brownian dispersion : µ = µ0; σ2 = Dt b) Linear separation, constant dispersion : µ = bt; σ2 = D0 c) Linear separation, Brownian dispersion : µ = bt; σ2 = Dt d) Linear separation & dispersion : µ = bt; σ = D1t For each of the above cases, eq. 8 can be expressed as a quadratic equation with different coefficients, MSD = a0 + a1t + a2t2. (9) Tuning the linear and quadratic coefficients can be used to tailor the power-law scaling α. For example, if b = 0 and D > 0 we achieve conventional diffusion (α = 1), whereas if D = 0 and b > 0 we get ballistic motion (α = 2). If both b > 0 and D > 0 the type of diffusion depends on the ratio D b , which dictates the timescales of interest. In Fig. 6 we take D = D1 = b = 1, µ0 = D0 = 10, and compute MSD (Fig. 6a) and γ2 (Fig. 6b). For case a, we find the system exhibits subdiffusive motion for timescales up to 103 seconds (Fig. 6a). We do not see conventional diffusion unless we compute α at longer times. Similarly, for case c, subdiffusive behaviour is ob- served at short timescales followed by a crossover to bal- listic motion at longer times. The excess kurtosis also varies by case. For case a, where the mean of the modes is fixed to ±µ0 with Brow- nian dispersion, γ2 increases from -2.0 to the Gaussian limit of 0. With cases b and c, where the modes are sep- arating faster than they are dispersing, γ2 reduces from 0 to -2.0. Lastly for case d, where µ(t) and σ(t) are both linearly increasing at the same rate, γ2 takes on a constant value of -0.5. F. Substrate digestion rates Those who study starved random walks are often con- cerned with the number of food items the walker con- sumes before starvation [7]. In our model starvation can be defined as the walker having no accessible substrate 'food' sites within its span. While we have already char- acterized the total time associated to the tracks, here we characterise track digestion rates and total successful cleavages before starvation (detachment). We define the substrate digestion rate, kd, as the average number of cleavages observed for each BBR design per second. kd is distinct from kef f which is known a priori and used to simulate cleavage kinetics in the Gillespie algorithm. In Fig. 7a we report kd for all examined BBRs across all track widths. Not surprisingly, we find polyvalency 7 FIG. 6. Results of bimodal Gaussian model. a) In the limit of Brownian dispersion (case a) we recover conventional diffusion at long times. For all other cases we find the long-time limit of α to represent ballistic motion. b) With increasing σ(t) and constant µ (case a), γ2 reaches the Gaussian limit of γ2 = 0. In cases b and c, which describe distributions that separate faster than they disperse, γ2 decreases to -2.0. When σ and µ increase at the same rate γ2 remains constant (case d). to be the dominating factor for increasing the digestion rate, where both (12,8) and (12,3) BBRs have the highest kd. Interestingly, cleavage rates for the 12-legged BBRs increase with track width to a constant value, whereas 3-legged BBRs experience a slight decrease in their cleav- age rates as the width of the track is increased. When we examine the average number of cleavages before detach- ment, the inherent track association time, characterised by t1/2, is the dominating system parameter. Fig. 7b displays average cleavage events vs. track width, which scales similary to t1/2 (Fig. 4d). FIG. 7. a) Digestion rate, kd, for each BBR design across all track widths. For all BBR designs substrate digestion rates are found to be width-independent for tracks larger than a width of ∼8. b) Average number of substrate sites digested before detachment (starvation) for all BBRs across all ex- amined track widths. For (3,8) BBRs, average cleavages are reported for tracks only up to width 32, as most (3,8) BBRs remained bound on larger track widths. IV. DISCUSSION A. Mean squared displacement The MSD holds information on the BBR's ability to move directionally, a key design criterion for synthetic molecular motors. MSD scales as tα, where α charac- terizes the type of anamolous diffusion inherent to the system [35]. For values of α ranging from 0 < α < 1 the motion is subdiffusive, which describes characteristic mo- tion slower than that of conventional diffusion. A value of α = 1 describes a system that undergoes conventional diffusion. Systems with 1 < α < 2 are superdiffusive, a property of systems that undergo active transport. When α = 2 the system exhibits linear (ballistic) motion and is ideal for molecular transport systems. We find the long-time α values to be highly dependent on track width, span, and polyvalency. We expected α to maximize on narrow tracks for each BBR design, as the effect of confinement would promote linearly directed motion. With reference to Fig. 3bd, we find that α is maximum for narrow tracks and persists with near bal- listic values for tracks of width larger than 1 lattice site. For (12,8) BBRs, αx remains constant for track widths up to 16, whereas for (3,8) BBRs αx begins to decrease at a track width of 4 (half the span for this system) (Fig. 3d). Therefore, both polyvalency and span play a role in maintaining optimally ballistic motion as the effects of confinement are relaxed. 1 At early times all examined BBRs display subdiffu- sive behaviour at timescales proportional to , as was [32]. We observe initially also reported by Olah et al. subdiffusive behaviour for all track widths. This makes intuitive sense as each run is initialized with one leg as- sociated to the track. Unbound legs then need to bind and cleave in order to translocate the global constraint, which by design occurs on a timescale of regardless of the effects of confinement. kef f 1 kef f In Fig. 3f we report αy values from fitting to the late-time MSD trends when the BBRs have had suffi- cient time to reach the boundaries. As the track width increases, the characteristic time for αy to transition to 0 increases. When αy = 0, MSD(y) takes on the variance of a uniform distribution whose domain is defined by the track boundaries. The surprising result in Fig. 3b, where αr devel- ops a minimum as a function of width, can then be ex- plained by interactions with the boundary, which impose a sub-diffusive characteristic on αr. In contrast, when the BBRs are not constrained by the track boundaries we find that αr = αx = αy. For effectively two-dimensional tracks, larger span and lower polyvalency, such as the (3,8) BBRs, results in a lower αr of 1.1. The evolution of the ensemble of (3,8) BBRs, as shown in Movie S2, also displays a perma- nent high occupancy around the starting position. Con- versely, higher polyvalency and shorter span, such as the 8 (12,3) BBRs, results in a greater αr of 1.4. For the (12,3) system, the evolution of the ensemble distribu- tion (Movie S3) also displays low occupancy around the starting position, leading to a ring-like structure in the two-dimensional distribution. The emergence of the ring structure indicates that the ensemble exhibits radially directed motion, away from the starting position. Increased polyvalency therefore leads to the most su- perdiffusive walk in two dimensions. Why is this so? In our Gillespie model, the rate of binding to substrate, kon, is ∼400 times higher than the effective rate of cleavage, kef f . Therefore, all unbound legs will preferentially bind to locally available substrate sites. Each unbound leg acquires a transition rate, kon, for each of the available N substrate sites. For (12,3) BBRs this means that all legs will preferentially saturate the track. The increased number of track-associated legs means that the product wake produced by the BBR is also denser. By contrast, (3,8) BBRs can access larger regions of the track with each step, and with a polyvalency of only 3 their prod- uct wake is expected to be sparse. By this reasoning, the (12,3) BBRs are expected to have higher αr values than the (3,8) BBRs because it is harder for the global constraint to change direction; multiple legs need to co- ordinate to move the global constraint towards a new direction, leading to a higher value of αr. Substrate track sites that have previously been visited, and subsequently turned to product-sites, cannot be re- visited. However, the global constraint can still visit its previous locations and cross over its path because the legs can bind beyond their nearest neighbours. The more times the global constraint revisits a location the less likely it will be to return because the local region be- comes further depleted of substrate. Therefore, despite the ideal burnt-bridges behaviour of each leg, our BBRs do not scale as a strict self-avoiding walk. There may be merit in the application of models for weakly self-avoiding walks to polyvalent BBRs [37]. The BBR system may also bear relevance to foragers eating a subset of food per site [38]. B. Track dissociation and its effect on α The width of the track has a strong effect on both the observed α values and the track association time, as shown in Fig. 3 and Fig. 4. As stated αx does not be- gin to decrease until a track width of 16 for (12,8) BBRs (Fig. 3d). However, their track association time in- creases dramatically from a width of 1 to a width of 16 (Fig. 4c). To understand the relationship between αx and t1/2 we first looked to see if they are correlated. In Fig. 4f we see that αx is relatively constant and inde- pendent of t1/2 for these BBRs on tracks of width 1-16. t1/2 ≈ 100 s on a track of width 1, whereas on a track of width 16 t1/2 ≈ 2000 s. By increasing the width of the track to twice that of the BBR span, the (12,8) system maintains ballistic behaviour while gaining more than an order-of-magnitude increase in track attachment time. A further increase in track width from 16 to 4096 results in an increase of t1/2 by a factor of 2.5, but a decrease in αx from ∼ 2.0 to ∼ 1.3. We therefore conclude that if one wishes to increase both directionality and track as- sociation time, designing tracks of a width proportional to the span of the ratchet is optimal. When one further increases the track width, α begins to decrease. Both decreasing polyvalency and increasing span re- sult in increased track attachment time. Of the two design parameters, which has the strongest impact on maintaining track assocation? To illustrate the effects of polyvalency on track association we can compare (3,8) and (12,8) BBRs on tracks of width 1 and 8. On a track width of 1, we find t1/2 to be 240 and 110 seconds for (3,8) and (12,8) BBRs, respectively (Fig. 4d). However, the effect of polyvalency on track association highly depends on the span, which we map out in Fig. 4e. For example, increasing polyvalency of span-3 BBRs results in at most a factor of 2 increase in t1/2, even on two-dimensional tracks. However, for span-8 BBRs, t1/2 increases by a factor of 2 for one-dimensional tracks, but by a factor of 10 for two-dimensional tracks when the number of legs is increased from 3 to 12. Altering span also shows sim- ilar trends where the gain in t1/2 highly depends on the polyvalency. It may seem counterintuitive that an increase in poly- valency leads to a decrease in t1/2 given previous work with molecular spiders [16, 31]. However, in molecular spider systems the walkers have a rate of product bind- ing, konP , typically taken to be the same as substrate binding, konS [30–32]. Therefore, when the walker di- gests all local substrate sites it can search through local product sites for areas of fresh substrate. In such a sys- tem, increased polyvalency means more options for prod- uct site coupling and subsequently decreased probability of detachment. By contrast, our system is a ideal BBR where konP = 0, and we find increased polyvalency leads to a decrease in track attachment time. C. Excess Kurtosis The shape of the BBR position distribution has a time dependence. Kurtosis is a convenient measure to com- pare BBR position distributions across our parameter space of width, polyvalency, and span. On narrow tracks the position distribution for (3,8) BBRs immediately de- velops into two modes that move in opposite directions. This is reflected as a monotonic decrease in γ2(x) to -2.0 (Fig. 5b), which indicates a distribution with proba- bility isolated to the edges of the domain. The splitting of the position distribution into two oppositely moving modes is consistent with the ballistic behaviour charac- terized by α. Having seen that the distributions formed two oppo- sitely moving modes inspired us to analytically derive kurtosis for a PDF described by two Gaussians, as shown 9 in eq. 6. We analytically derived γ2 (eq. 7) in one dimen- sion and explored the effects of dispersion and mode sep- aration, as shown in Fig. 6. Increasing dispersion, while maintaining a constant separation of modes, leads to γ2 monotonically increasing towards the Gaussian value of 0, indicating that the two independent modes are com- pletely overlapping. Conversely, a linear increase in mode separation with constant dispersion results in γ2 mono- tonically decreasing to -2.0. Furthermore, dispersion and mode separation have compensatory effects on γ2, such that if they are increasing at similar rates γ2 remains constant. From our phenomenological Gaussian model we are able to reproduce all of the BBR γ2 results by modifying σ and µ. Our analytical model offers insights into the BBR be- haviour and allows us to understand the effects of poly- valency, span and width on the shape of the position dis- tributions. For example, γ2(x) for (3,8) BBRs on wide tracks reaches a time-invariant value of -0.25 (Fig. 5b). From our bimodal Gaussian model, this suggests that the dispersion and separation of the modes are equal. We verify this for the (3,8) system where we compute σ(t)/µ(t) (Fig. S5). The ratio of σ(t)/µ(t) is known as the coefficient of variation. In our analytical system the coefficient of variation is equal to D b where D and b are equivalent to diffusion and drift coefficients, respectively. The ratio D b is a ratio of diffusion and mobility, and has been used to characterize the ability of Brownian ratchets to achieve directional motion under external fields [39]. On wide tracks, for all BBR designs, γ2(y) takes on the same values as γ2(x) (Figs. S3,S4). As the BBRs are constrained by the boundaries, the position distribu- tions evolve into uniform distributions across the width (γ2(y) = −1.2), consistent with our finding that the vari- ance given by MSD(y) approaches that of a uniform dis- tribution. D. Substrate digestion rates Across all track widths we find that BBRs with larger span and polyvalency have the highest substrate diges- tion rate (kd), as shown in Fig. 7a. The ratio of the binding and effective cleavage rates used in the Gillespie model, kon and kef f , respectively, is ∼400. This means that an unbound leg that can access a fresh substrate site is going to be 400 times more likely to bind to any one site than a bound leg is to cleave and release. Thus, all legs are likely to be bound to available substrate sites. (12,8) BBRs have access to more local substrate than the other BBR designs given that they have the largest polyvalency and the longest reach (span), therefore (12,8) BBRs are expected to cleave the most per unit time. (12,3) BBRs are 'second best' to (12,8) BBRs with regards to the sub- strate digestion rate. All 12 legs can saturate to the track, but this design suffers from a shorter span leading to an inability of (12,3) BBRs to reach distant patches of fresh substrate, as compared to the (12,8) system. It was surprising to see that (3,3) and (3,8) BBRs ex- perienced a slight decrease in average substrate digestion rates as a function of increasing track width (Fig. 7a). from 0.18 s−1 in one dimension, The decline is slight: to 0.16 s−1 in two dimensions for (3,3) BBRs. As the width is increased one would naively think that more substrate should be available to the BBR for any given combination of bound legs, therefore resulting in an in- crease digestion rate. This was not found for three-legged BBRs. Furthermore, for any given track width, the av- erage digestion rates for (3,3) and (3,8) BBRs are within 5%, suggesting that in the limit of low polyvalency, span plays no significant role in altering the substrate diges- tion rate. Our hypothesis is that in one dimension, when the span-3 walkers move into their product wake, they quickly detach as there is little opportunity to turn around towards fresh substrate. However, as the track width is increased the walkers have more opportunity to rescue themselves from a substrate-barren environment. We speculate that on average, the (3,8) and (3,3) walkers experience more substrate-barren terrain in wider track widths, which leads to a lower average substrate diges- tion rate as they spend more time rescuing themselves from locally depleted regions. The BBRs studied in this work can be considered as polyvalent depletion-controlled foragers [7, 40]. In Fig. 7b we plot the average number of substrate sites digested by each BBR on each track width. As a function of track width, substrate digestion per lifetime scales similarly as t1/2 (Fig. 4d). Despite (3,8) BBRs having the lowest kd across all track widths, their greater track association time leads to them having more time to digest substrate, resulting in the most substrate cleaved prior to detach- ment. V. CONCLUSIONS 10 The design and implementation of synthetic machinery has shown great promise towards the control of motion at the nanoscale. In particular, synthetic analogues of bi- ological molecular motors that implement a BBR mech- anism have made great progress. Our goal in this work was to explore the effects of confinement on BBR perfor- mance and to provide design insights for de novo BBR motors. Our results offer guidelines for researchers to follow when thinking about optimizing particular BBR characteristics. To fabricate a superdiffusive BBR in two dimensions, one should increase polyvalency and decrease span, as has been done in some systems [11, 25]. In- creasing span and decreasing polyvalency, in contrast, results in large increases to track attachment time but decreased directionality. Furthermore, we found that narrow tracks result in ballistic dynamics, as well as an order-of-magnitude increase in track attachment time compared to a one-dimensional track. Lastly, we found that increasing polyvalency results in an increased rate of substrate digestion, however, the total average track association time is the dominant factor that dictates to- tal cleavage events before detachment. Through explor- ing the dimensionality-dependent crossover in motility of polyvalent BBRs, we have found these systems to exhibit rich dynamics. We hope these results provide useful in- sight towards the design of de novo BBR systems. VI. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This work was funded by the Natural Sciences and En- gineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC), through a Discovery Grant to NRF. Computational resources were provided by Compute Canada. [1] K. Svobody, F. C. Schmidt, J. B. Schnapp, and M. S. Block, "Direct Observation of kinesin stepping by optical trapping interferometry," Nature, vol. 365, pp. 721–727, 1993. [2] H. Nobutaka, "Kinesin and dynein superfamily proteins and the mechanism of organelle transport," Science, vol. 279, no. 5350, pp. 519–526, 1998. [3] D. A. Mehta, S. R. Rock, M. Rief, A. J. Spudich, S. M. Mooseker, and E. R. Cheney, "Myosin-V is a processive actin-based motor," Nature, vol. 400, pp. 590–593, 1999. [4] M. Schliwa and G. Woehlke, "Molecular motors," Nature, vol. 422, pp. 759–65, 2003. [5] L. Bruno, V. Levi, M. Brunstein, and M. A. Despos- ito, "Transition to superdiffusive behavior in intracellular actin-based transport mediated by molecular motors," Phys. Rev. E, vol. 80, no. 1, p. 011912, 2009. [6] T. Antal and P. L. Krapivsky, "'Burnt-bridge' mechanism of molecular motor motion," Phys. Rev. E, vol. 72, no. 4, p. 046104, 2005. [7] O. B´enichou and S. Redner, "Depletion-controlled star- vation of a diffusing forager," Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 113, no. 23, p. 238101, 2014. [8] S. Saffarian, I. E. Collier, B. L. Marmer, E. L. Elson, and G. Goldberg, "Interstitial collagenase is a brown- ian ratchet driven by proteolysis of collagen," Science, vol. 306, pp. 108–111, 2004. [9] S. K. Sarkar, B. Marmer, G. Goldberg, and K. C. Neu- man, "Single-molecule tracking of collagenase on native type I collagen fibrils reveals degradation mechanism," Curr. Biol., vol. 22, no. 12, pp. 1047–1056, 2012. [10] I. E. Collier, W. Legant, B. Marmer, O. Lubman, S. Saf- farian, T. Wakatsuki, E. Elson, and G. I. Goldberg, "Dif- fusion of MMPs on the surface of collagen fibrils: the mobile cell surface-collagen substratum interface.," PLoS One, vol. 6, no. 9, p. e24029, 2011. [11] A. G. Vecchiarelli, K. C. Neuman, and K. Mizuuchi, "A propagating ATPase gradient drives transport of surface- confined cellular cargo.," Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A., vol. 111, no. 13, pp. 4880–4885, 2014. [12] L. Hu, A. G. Vecchiarelli, K. Mizuuchi, K. C. Neuman, and J. Liu, "Brownian Ratchet Mechanism for Faithful Segregation of Low-Copy-Number Plasmids," Biophys. J., vol. 112, no. 7, pp. 1489–1502, 2017. [13] K. Gerdes, M. Howard, and F. Szardenings, "Push- ing and pulling in prokaryotic DNA segregation.," Cell, vol. 141, no. 6, pp. 927–942, 2010. [14] S. M. Block, L. S. Goldstein, and B. J. Schnapp, "Bead movement by single kinesin molecules studied with op- tical tweezers," Nature, vol. 348, no. 6299, pp. 348–352, 1990. [15] P. Yin, H. Yan, X. G. Daniell, A. J. Turberfield, and J. H. Reif, "A unidirectional DNA walker that moves autonomously along a track," Angew. Chemie, vol. 43, pp. 4906–4911, 2004. [16] R. Pei, S. K. Taylor, D. Stefanovic, S. Rudchenko, T. E. Mitchell, and M. N. Stojanovic, "Behavior of polycat- alytic assemblies in a substrate-displaying matrix," J. Am. Chem. Soc., vol. 128, no. 24, pp. 12693–12699, 2006. [17] J. Bath and A. J. Turberfield, "DNA nanomachines.," Nat. Nano., vol. 2, no. 5, pp. 275–84, 2007. [18] E. H. C. Bromley, N. J. Kuwada, M. J. Zuckermann, R. Donadini, L. Samii, G. A. Blab, G. J. Gemmen, B. J. Lopez, P. M. G. Curmi, N. R. Forde, D. N. Woolfson, and H. Linke, "The tumbleweed: Towards a synthetic protein motor," HFSP J., vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 204–212, 2009. [19] T. Omabegho, R. Sha, and N. C. Seeman, "A Bipedal DNA Brownian Motor with Coordinated Legs," Science, vol. 324, pp. 67–71, 2009. [20] K. Lund, A. J. Manzo, N. Dabby, N. Michelotti, A. Johnson-Buck, J. Nangreave, S. Taylor, R. Pei, M. N. Stojanovic, N. G. Walter, E. Winfree, and H. Yan, "Molecular robots guided by prescriptive landscapes.," Nature, vol. 465, no. 7295, pp. 206–210, 2010. [21] J. Cheng, S. Sreelatha, R. Hou, A. Efremov, R. Liu, J. R. C. van der Maarel, and Z. Wang, "Bipedal Nanowalker by Pure Physical Mechanisms," Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 109, p. 238104, 2012. [22] T.-G. Cha, J. Pan, H. Chen, J. Salgado, X. Li, C. Mao, and J. H. Choi, "A synthetic DNA motor that transports nanoparticles along carbon nanotubes," Nat. Nanotech- nol., vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 39–43, 2014. [23] C. S. Niman, M. J. Zuckermann, M. Balaz, J. O. Tegen- feldt, P. M. G. Curmi, N. R. Forde, and H. Linke, "Flu- idic switching in nanochannels for the control of Inch- worm: a synthetic biomolecular motor with a power stroke," Nanoscale, vol. 6, pp. 15008–15019, 2014. [24] S. Kovacic, L. Samii, P. M. Curmi, H. Linke, M. J. Zuckermann, and N. R. Forde, "Design and construc- tion of the Lawnmower, an artificial burnt-bridges mo- tor," Trans. NanoBioscience, vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 305–312, 2015. 11 [25] K. Yehl, A. Mugler, S. Vivek, Y. Liu, Y. Zhang, M. Fan, E. R. Weeks, and K. Salaita, "High-speed DNA-based rolling motors powered by RNase H," Nat. Nano., vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 184–190, 2015. [26] M. Liu, J. Cheng, S. R. Tee, S. Sreelatha, I. Y. Loh, and Z. Wang, "Biomimetic Autonomous Enzymatic Nanowalker of High Fuel Efficiency," ACS Nano, vol. 10, no. 6, pp. 5882–5890, 2016. [27] J. Li, A. Johnson-Buck, Y. R. Yang, W. M. Shih, H. Yan, and N. G. Walter, "Exploring the speed limit of toehold exchange with a cartwheeling DNA acrobat," Nat. Nan- otechnol., p. 1, 2018. [28] T. Antal, P. L. Krapivsky, and K. Mallick, "Molecular Spiders in One Dimension.," J. Stat. Mech., vol. 2007, p. P08027, 2007. [29] B. Shtylla and J. P. Keener, "Mathematical modeling of bacterial track-altering motors: Track cleaving through burnt-bridge ratchets," Phys. Rev. E - Stat. Nonlinear, Soft Matter Phys., vol. 91, no. 4, pp. 1–18, 2015. [30] L. Samii, H. Linke, M. J. Zuckermann, and N. R. Forde, "Biased motion and molecular motor properties of bipedal spiders," Phys Rev E, vol. 81, no. 2, p. 021106, 2010. [31] L. Samii, G. A. Blab, E. H. C. Bromley, H. Linke, P. M. G. Curmi, M. J. Zuckermann, and N. R. Forde, "Time-dependent motor properties of multipedal molec- ular spiders," Phys Rev E, vol. 84, no. 3, p. 031111, 2011. [32] M. J. Olah and D. Stefanovic, "Superdiffusive transport by multivalent molecular walkers moving under load," Phys. Rev. E, vol. 87, no. 6, p. 062713, 2013. [33] L. Hu, A. G. Vecchiarelli, K. Mizuuchi, K. C. Neuman, and J. Liu, "Directed and persistent movement arises from mechanochemistry of the ParA / ParB system," PNAS, vol. 112, no. 51, pp. E7055–E7064, 2015. [34] D. Gillespie, "Exact stochastic simulation of coupled chemical reactions," J. Phys. Chem., vol. 81, no. 25, pp. 2340–2361, 1977. [35] S. Havlin and D. Ben-Avraham, "Diffusion in disordered media," Adv. Phys., vol. 51, no. 1, pp. 187–292, 2002. [36] L. T. DeCarlo, "On the Meaning and Use of Kurtosis," Psychol. Methods, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 292–307, 1997. [37] N. Madras and G. Slade, "The Self-Avoiding Walk," Birkhauser, pp. 365–368, 1996. [38] O. B´enichou, U. Bhat, P. L. Krapivsky, and S. Red- ner, "Optimally frugal foraging," Phys. Rev. E, vol. 97, p. 022110, 2018. [39] A. van Oudenaarden, "Brownian Ratchets: Molecular Separations in Lipid Bilayers Supported on Patterned Ar- rays," Science, vol. 285, no. 5430, pp. 1046–1048, 1999. [40] O. B´enichou, M. Chupeau, and S. Redner, "Role of de- pletion on the dynamics of a diffusing forager," J. Phys. A: Math. Theor., vol. 49, no. 39, p. 394003, 2016. Dimensionality-dependent crossover in motility of polyvalent burnt-bridges ratchets Supplementary material June 22, 2018 Chapin S. Korosec ([email protected]) Martin J. Zuckermann ([email protected]) Nancy R. Forde ([email protected]) arXiv:1806.08066v1 [physics.bio-ph] 21 Jun 2018 1 Kurtosis of a mixture of two Gaussian distributions On narrow tracks the BBR displacement distributions produce two modes that travel in the ±x directions. To understand how the kurtosis is expected to behave we derive γ2 for a probability density function described by two Gaussian modes centred at µ1 and µ2 with standard deviations σ1 and σ2, 2 P (x) from eq. 1 can be used to compute the kth moment about the mean according to e− (x−µ1 )2 2σ2 1 + e− (x−µ2)2 2σ2 2 . 1 2p2πσ2 2 P (xµ1, µ2, σ1, σ2) = 1 1 2p2πσ2 mk =Z ∞ −∞ (x − µ)kP (x)dx. (1) (2) Kurtosis is defined as the standardized 4th moment. Since a Gaussian distribution always has a kurtosis of 3, it is convenient to define the excess kurtosis,γ2, as (3) (4) (5) (6) 2(µ4 1 + 6µ2 γ2 = 1σ2 (µ2 1 + 3σ4 1 + σ2 1 + µ4 1 + µ2 2 + 6µ2 2 + σ2 2)2 2σ2 2 + 3σ4 2) − 3. (µ4 1 + 6µ2 1σ2 1 + 3σ4 1 + µ4 2 + 6µ2 2σ2 2 + 3σ4 2), (µ2 1 + σ2 1 + µ2 2 + σ2 2). 1 2 1 2 m4 = m2 = γ2 = E(cid:2)(x − µ)4(cid:3) (E [(x − µ)2])2 − 3 = m4 (m2)2 − 3. Using eq. 2 we find the fourth and second moments to be Substituting eq. 4 and eq. 5 into eq. 3 we find the excess kurtosis of P (x) to be given by In our system there is symmetry in the two modes about x = 0. Therefore, we make the further assumption that µ2 = −µ1, so that µ2 2 = µ2 1 = µ2 0 and let σ1 = σ2 = σ0. γ2 can then be written as γ2 = (2µ4 0 + 12µ2 0σ2 0 + σ2 0 + 6σ4 0) 0)2 2(µ2 − 3. (7) 2 Supplementary figures 3 Figure S1: Each panel shows the evolution of MSD(~r) for a given BBR design. MSD(~r) for each of the BBR designs displays a similar trend with track width as discussed in the main text for (3,8) BBRs. The resulting αr values from each MSD(~r) curve are plotted in Fig. 3b. 4 Figure S2: All detachment curves for each BBR design as a function of track width. (3,8) BBRs display negligible detachment for track widths larger than 32. All BBRs display a similar trend of longer track association as a function of increasing track width. 5 Figure S3: Excess kurtosis γ2(x), for all BBR designs across all track widths. a) (3,3) γ2(x) show similar trends to that of (3,8) BBRs, however, with their shorter track association times the curves are more noisy. b) γ2(x) for (3,8) BBRs, as shown and disucssed in the main text. c) (12,3) BBRs on narrow tracks display a decrease in γ2(x) to -2.0. However, on wider tracks and later times the BBRs experience an increase in γ2(x), indicating that over long times the dispersion increases at a greater rate than the modes separate. d) (12,8) BBRs display a similar trend in γ2(x) as (12,3) BBRs, where γ2(x) increases with time on wide tracks. 6 Figure S4: Excess kurtosis γ2(y), for all BBR designs across tracks of width 16-4096. For (3,3), (12,3), and (12,8) BBRs on intermediate tracks, γ2(y) decreases below -1.2 to a minimum before increasing to the -1.2 uniform distri- bution limit. (12,8) BBRs on wide tracks display an appreciable increase in γ2(y) over long times. For these BBRs, upon interacting with the confining walls γ2(y) turns over to a decreasing trend, as shown by the width 128 BBRs ((12,8), purple line). The γ2(y) trends for (3,8) BBRs are included and discussed in the main text. 7 Figure S5: µ(t) and σ(t) for BBRs with 3 legs, span 8 on a track width of 128. Left: µx(t) and µy(t) overlap until the ensemble of motors reaches the boundary at ∼ 1000s, at which point µy(t) curves over to the expected value of 32 for a uniform distribution with boundaries at y = 0, 64. Right: The ensemble average BBRs reach the boundary at ∼ 1000s, indicated by the red line. σx(t) µy(t) , the coefficients of variation, indicate that the dispersion in y-positions decreases substantially more than the mean y position upon interaction with the boundary. σx(t) µx(t) µx(t) and σy(t) remains relatively constant following the onset of BBR interaction with the boundaries. 3 Supplementary movies Movie S1: The ensemble position evolution for (3,3) BBRs on an effectively two-dimensional track. The ensemble of BBRs can be seen to develop a low occupancy around the centre (starting point) of the track. Movie S2: The ensemble position evolution for (3,8) BBRs on an effectively two-dimensional track. The ensem- ble of BBRs can be seen to maintain a high occupancy around the centre (starting point) of the track. Movie S3: The ensemble position evolution for (12,3) BBRs on an effectively two-dimensional track. The ensemble of BBRs can be seen to develop a low occupancy around the centre (starting point) of the track. 8 Movie S4: The ensemble position evolution for (12,8) BBRs on an effectively two-dimensional track. The ensemble of BBRs can be seen to develop a low occupancy around the centre (starting point) of the track. Movie S5: The ensemble position evolution for (3,8) BBRs on a narrow track of width 8. Two modes can be seen to develop and move in opposite directions. Movie S6: The ensemble position evolution for (12,8) BBRs on a narrow track of width 8. Two modes can be seen to develop and move in opposite directions.
1303.7292	1	1303	2013-03-29T04:06:49	Multi-functional foot use during running in the zebra-tailed lizard (Callisaurus draconoides)	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "physics.flu-dyn", "q-bio.QM" ]	A diversity of animals that run on solid, level, flat, non-slip surfaces appear to bounce on their legs; elastic elements in the limbs can store and return energy during each step. The mechanics and energetics of running in natural terrain, particularly on surfaces that can yield and flow under stress, is less understood. The zebra-tailed lizard (Callisaurus draconoides), a small desert generalist with a large, elongate, tendinous hind foot, runs rapidly across a variety of natural substrates. We use high speed video to obtain detailed three-dimensional running kinematics on solid and granular surfaces to reveal how leg, foot, and substrate mechanics contribute to its high locomotor performance. Running at ~10 body length/s (~1 m/s), the center of mass oscillates like a spring-mass system on both substrates, with only 15% reduction in stride length on the granular surface. On the solid surface, a strut-spring model of the hind limb reveals that the hind foot saves about 40% of the mechanical work needed per step, significant for the lizard's small size. On the granular surface, a penetration force model and hypothesized subsurface foot rotation indicates that the hind foot paddles through fluidized granular medium, and that the energy lost per step during irreversible deformation of the substrate does not differ from the reduction in the mechanical energy of the center of mass. The upper hind leg muscles must perform three times as much mechanical work on the granular surface as on the solid surface to compensate for the greater energy lost within the foot and to the substrate.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Multi-functional foot use during running in the zebra-tailed lizard (Callisaurus draconoides) Chen Li1, S. Tonia Hsieh2, and Daniel I. Goldman1* 1School of Physics, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332, USA and 2Department of Biology, Temple University, Philadelphia, PA 19122, USA Author for correspondence ([email protected]) Summary A diversity of animals that run on solid, level, flat, non-slip surfaces appear to bounce on their legs; elastic elements in the limbs can store and return energy during each step. The mechanics and energetics of running in natural terrain, particularly on surfaces that can yield and flow under stress, is less understood. The zebra-tailed lizard (Callisaurus draconoides), a small desert generalist with a large, elongate, tendinous hind foot, runs rapidly across a variety of natural substrates. We use high speed video to obtain detailed three-dimensional running kinematics on solid and granular surfaces to reveal how leg, foot, and substrate mechanics contribute to its high locomotor performance. Running at ~ 10 body length/s (~ 1 m/s), the center of mass oscillates like a spring-mass system on both substrates, with only 15% reduction in stride length on the granular surface. On the solid surface, a strut-spring model of the hind limb reveals that the hind foot saves about 40% of the mechanical work needed per step, significant for the lizard’s small size. On the granular surface, a penetration force model and hypothesized subsurface foot rotation indicates that the hind foot paddles through fluidized granular medium, and that the energy lost per step during irreversible deformation of the substrate does not differ from the reduction in the mechanical energy of the center of mass. The upper hind leg muscles must perform three times as much mechanical work on the granular surface as on the solid surface to compensate for the greater energy lost within the foot and to the substrate. Key words: terrestrial locomotion, mechanics, energetics, kinematics, spring-mass system, elastic energy savings, dissipation, granular media Running title: Substrate effects on foot use in lizards 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Introduction Rapid locomotion like running and hopping can be modeled as a spring-mass system bouncing in the sagittal plane (i.e., the Spring-Loaded Inverted Pendulum model, SLIP) (Blickhan, 1989). This has been demonstrated in a variety of animals (Blickhan and Full, 1993; Holmes et al., 2006) in the laboratory on rigid, level, flat, non-slip surfaces (hereafter referred to as “solid surfaces”) such as running tracks and treadmills (Dickinson et al., 2000). In the SLIP model, the animal body (represented by the center of mass, CoM) bounces on a single leg (represented by a spring) like a pogo stick, and exerts point contact on the solid ground. The leg spring compresses during the first half of stance, and then recoils during the second half of stance. Through this process, the mechanical (i.e., kinetic plus gravitational potential) energy of the CoM is exchanged with elastic energy stored in the compressed leg spring, reducing energy use during each step. For animals like insects (e.g., Schmitt et al., 2002) and reptiles (e.g., Chen et al., 2006) that run with a sprawled limb posture, the CoM also oscillates substantially in the horizontal plane in a similar fashion, which can also be modeled as a spring-mass system bouncing in the horizontal plane (i.e., the Lateral Leg Spring model, LLS) (Schmitt et al., 2002). Both the SLIP and the LLS models predict that the mechanical energy of the CoM is lowest at mid-stance and highest during aerial phase. In these models, the spring-mass system and the interaction with the solid ground are perfectly elastic and do not dissipate energy; thus no net work is performed. However, as animals move across natural surfaces, energy is dissipated both within their body and limbs (Fung, 1993) and to the environment (Dickinson et al., 2000). Therefore, mechanisms to reduce energy loss during locomotion can be important. The limbs of many organisms possess elastic elements such as tendons and ligaments that can function as springs to store and return energy during rapid locomotion like running and hopping to decrease energetic cost (Alexander, 2003). Most notable for this function are the ankle extensor tendons in the lower hind leg and the digital flexor tendons and ligaments in the lower fore leg (Alexander, 2003). Furthermore, different limb- ground interaction strategies may be utilized depending on the dissipative properties of the substrate. Laboratory experiments have begun to reveal mechanisms of organisms running on non-solid surbstrates, such as elastic (Ferris et al., 1998; Spence et al., 2010), damped (Moritz and Farley, 2003), inclined (Roberts et al., 1997), or uneven (Daley and Biewener, 2006; Sponberg and Full, 2008) surfaces; surfaces with few footholds (Spagna et al., 2007); and the surface of water (Glasheen and McMahon 1996a; Hsieh, 2003). While spring-mass-like CoM motion was 2 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 observed only in some of these studies (Ferris et al., 1998; Moritz and Farley, 2003; Spence et al., 2010), a common finding is that on non-solid surfaces limbs do not necessarily behave like springs to save energy. In addition, these studies suggest that both the active control of body and limb movement through the nervous system, and the passive mechanical responses of viscoelastic limbs and feet with the environment, play important roles in the control of rapid terrestrial locomotion (for reviews, see Full and Koditschek, 1999; Dickinson et al., 2000). Many substrates found in nature, such as sand, gravel, rubble, dirt, soil, mud, and debris, can yield and flow under stress during locomotion and experience solid-fluid transitions, through which energy may be dissipated via plastic deformation. Understanding locomotion on these substrates is challenging in part because, unlike for flying and swimming where the fluid flows and forces can in principle be determined by solving the Navier-Stokes equations in the presence of moving boundary conditions (Vogel, 1996), no comprehensive force models yet exist for terrestrial substrates that yield and flow (hereafter referred to as “flowing substrates”). Granular materials (Nedderman, 1992) like desert sand which are composed of similarly sized particles provide a good model substrate for studying locomotion on flowing substrates. Compared to other flowing substrates, granular materials are relatively simple and the intrusion forces within them can be modeled empirically (Hill et al., 2005). Their mechanical properties can also be precisely and repeatedly controlled using a fluidized bed (Li et al., 2009). In addition, locomotion on granular surfaces is directly relevant for many desert-dwelling reptiles and arthropods such as lizards, snakes, and insects (Mosauer, 1932; Crawford, 1981). Recent advances in the understanding of force and flow laws in granular materials subject to localized intrusion (Hill et al., 2005; Katsuragi and Durian, 2007; Gravish et al., 2010; Ding et al., 2011a) begin to provide insight into the mechanics of locomotion on (and within) granular substrates (Li et al., 2009; Maladen et al., 2009; Mazouchova et al., 2010; Li et al., 2010b; Maladen et al., 2011; Ding et al., 2011b; Li et al., in press). The zebra-tailed lizard (Callisaurus draconoides, SVL ~ 10 cm, mass ~ 10 g, Fig. 1A) is an excellent model organism for studying running on natural surfaces, because of its high locomotor performance over diverse terrain. As a desert generalist, this lizard lives in a range of desert habitats including flat land, washes, and sand dunes (Vitt and Ohmart, 1977; Korff and McHenry, 2011), and encounters a large variety of substrates ranging from rocks, gravel, closely-packed coarse sand, and loosely-packed fine sand (Karasov and Anderson, 1998; Korff and McHenry, 2011). The zebra-tailed lizard is the fastest-running species among desert lizards of similar size 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 3 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 (Irschick and Jayne, 1999a), and has been observed to run at up to 4 m/s (50 bl/s) both on solid (e.g., treadmill) (Irschick and Jayne, 1999a) and on granular (e.g., sand dunes) (Irschick and Jayne, 1999b) surfaces. Its maximal acceleration and running speed also did not differ significantly when substrate changes from coarse wash sand to fine dune sand, whose yield strengths differ by a factor of three (Korff and McHenry, 2011). Of particular interest is whether and how the zebra-tailed lizard’s large, elongate hind foot contributes to its high locomotor capacity. In addition to a slim body, a long tapering tail, and slender legs (Fig. 1A), the zebra-tailed lizard has an extremely large, elongate hind foot, the largest (40% SVL) among lizards of similar size (Irschick and Jayne, 1999a). Its hind foot is substantially larger than the fore foot (area = 1 cm2 vs. = 0.3 cm2) and likely plays a dominant role for locomotion (Mosauer, 1932). Recent studies in insects, spiders, and geckos (Jindrich and Full, 1999; Antumn et al., 2000; Dudek and Full, 2006; Spagna et al., 2007) suggested that animals can rely on appropriate morphology and material properties of their bodies and limbs to accommodate variable, uncertain conditions during locomotion. Despite suggestions that the large foot area (Mosauer, 1932) and increased stride length via elongate toes may confer locomotor advantages (Irschick and Jayne, 1999a), the mechanisms of how the hind foot contributes to the zebra-tailed lizard’s high running capacity remain unknown. In this paper, we study the mechanics and mechanical energetics of the zebra-tailed lizard running on two well-defined model surfaces, a solid surface and a granular surface. These two surfaces lie on opposite ends of the spectrum of substrates that the zebra-tailed lizard encounters in its natural environment, and present distinct conditions for locomotion. We investigate whether the lizard’s center of mass bounces like a spring-mass system during running on both solid and granular surfaces. We combine measurements of three-dimensional kinematics of the lizard’s body, hind limb, and hind foot, dissection and resilience measurements of the hind limb, and modeling of foot-ground interactions on both substrates, and demonstrate that the lizard’s large, elongate hind foot serves different functions during running on solid and granular surfaces. We find that on the solid surface, the hind foot functions as an energy-saving spring; on the granular surface, it functions as a dissipative, force-generating paddle to generate sufficient lift during each step. The larger energy dissipation to the substrate and within the foot during running on the granular surface must be compensated for by greater mechanical work done by the upper hind leg muscles. Materials and methods 4 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Animals Seven adult zebra-tailed lizards (Callisaurus draconoides) were collected from the Mojave Desert, AZ, USA in 08/2007 (Permit SP591773) for three-dimensional kinematics experiments. Table 1 shows the morphological measurements for these seven animals. Eleven additional adult animals were collected from the Mojave Desert, CA, USA in 09/2009 (Permit SC 10901) for hind limb resilience measurements. Two preserved specimens were used for dissection. The animals were housed in the Physiological Research Laboratory animal facility of The Georgia Institute of Technology. Each animal was housed individually in an aquarium filled with sand, and fed crickets and mealworms dusted with vitamin and calcium supplement two to three times a week. The ambient temperature was maintained at 28°C during the day and 24°C during the night. Full- spectrum fluorescent bulbs high in UVB were set to a 12 hour/12 hour light/dark schedule. Ceramic heating elements were provided 24 hours a day to allow the animals to thermo-regulate at preferred body temperature. All experimental procedures were conducted in accordance with The Georgia Institute of Technology IACUC protocols. Surface treatments A wood board (120 × 23 × 1 cm3) bonded with sandpaper (grit size ~ 0.1 mm) for enhanced traction was used as the solid surface. Glass particles (diameter = 0.27 ± 0.04 mm mean ± 1 standard deviation, density = 2.5 × 103 kg/m3, Jaygo Incorporated, Union, NJ, USA) were used as the granular substrate, which are approximately spherical and of similar size to typical desert sand (Dickinson and Ward, 1994). Before each trial, a custom-made fluidized bed trackway (200 cm long, 50 cm wide) prepared the granular substrate (12 cm deep) into a loosely packed state (volume fraction= 0.58) for repeatable yield strength (for experimental details of the fluidized bed trackway, see Li et al., 2009). Three-dimensional kinematics We used high speed video to obtain three-dimensional kinematics as the lizard ran across the prepared surfaces (Fig. 1B). Before each session, high-contrast markers (Wite-Out, Garden Grove, CA, USA) were painted on each animal for digitizing at nine joints along the midline of the trunk and the right hind limb (Fig. 1A,B): neck (N), center of mass (CoM), pelvis (P), hip (H), knee (K), ankle (A); and the metatarsal-phalangeal joint (MP), distal end of the proximal phalanx (PP), and digit tip (T) of the fourth toe. The approximate longitudinal location of the CoM in resting position was determined by tying a thread around the body of an anesthetized lizard and 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 5 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 repositioning the thread until the body balanced horizontally. Before each trial, the surface was prepared (for the granular surface treatment only), and calibration images were taken of a custom- made 39-point calibration object (composed of LEGO, Billund, Denmark). The animal was then induced to run across the field of view by a slight tap or pinch on the tail. Two synchronized AOS high speed cameras (AOS Technologies, Baden Daettwil, Switzerland) captured simultaneous dorsal and lateral views at 500 frame/s (shutter time = 300 s). The ambient temperature was maintained at 35°C during the test. Animals were allowed to rest at least five minutes between trials and at least two days between sessions. We digitized the calibration images and high speed videos, and used direct linear transformation (DLT) to reconstruct three-dimensional kinematics from the two-dimensional kinematics from both dorsal and lateral views. Digitization and DLT calculations were performed using custom software (DLTcal5 and DLTdv5, Hedrick, 2008). Axes were set such that +x pointed in the direction of forward motion, +z pointed vertically upward, and +y pointed to the left of the animal. Footfall patterns of touchdown and takeoff were determined from the videos. On the granular surface, because the hind foot often remained obscured by splashed grains during foot extraction, we defined foot takeoff as when the knee began to flex following extension during limb protraction (which is when foot takeoff occurs on the solid surface). To reduce noise and enable direct comparisons among different running trials, position data were filtered with a Butterworth low-pass filter with a cutoff frequency of 75 Hz, and interpolated to 0100% of one full stride period (T) between two successive touchdowns of the right hind limb. All data analysis was completed with MATLAB (MathWorks, Natick, MA, USA) unless otherwise specified. Statistics We accepted trials that met the following criteria: the animal ran continuously through the field of view, the run was straight without contacting sidewalls of the trackway, there was a full stride (between two consecutive touchdowns of the right hind limb) in the range of view, all the nine markers were visible throughout the full stride, and the forward speed changed less than 20% after the full stride. With these criteria, out of a total of 125 trials from 7 individuals on both solid (61 trials from 7 individuals) and granular (64 trials from 7 individuals) surfaces collected over a period of over three months, we ultimately accepted 51 runs from 7 individuals on solid (23 runs from 7 individuals) and granular (28 runs from 7 individuals) surfaces. Because the data set had an unequal number of runs per individuals, and because we were measuring freely-running animals and did not control for speed, to maintain statistical power, all statistical tests were 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 6 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 performed on a subset of these data using one representative run per individual on both solid (N = 7) and granular (N = 7) surfaces. The representative run for each individual was selected based on having the most consistent running speed for at least one full stride and was also closest to the mean running speed of all 51 trials. Data are reported as mean ± 1 standard deviation (s.d.) from the 7 representative runs on each substrate unless otherwise specified. To determine the effect of substrate, all kinematic variables were corrected for size-related differences by regressing the variables against SVL and taking the residuals for those that regressed significantly with SVL (P < 0.05). We then ran an ANCOVA with substrate and speed as covariates to test for substrate effects, independent of running speeds. All statistical tests were performed using JMP (SAS, Cary, NC, USA). For the energetics data, we used dimensionless quantities by normalizing energies of each run to the CoM mechanical energy at touchdown of that run, thus eliminating the effect of mass and running speed on energies. An ANOVA was used to test the differences between the reduction in CoM mechanical energy, elastic energies, and energy loss. A Tukey’s HSD was used for post-hoc tests where needed. Dissection and model of hind limb To gain insight into the role of anatomical components of the hind limb on mechanics during locomotion, we dissected the hind limb of two preserved specimens. We quantified anatomical dimensions by measuring the radii of the knee (K), ankle (A), the metatarsal-phalangeal joint (MP), the distal end of the proximal phalanx (PP), and the digit tip (T) of the fourth toe. We also observed the muscle and tendon arrangements within the lower leg and the foot. Based on these anatomical features, we developed a model of the hind limb which incorporated the structure, properties, and function of its main elements. Resilience measurements of hind limb To characterize the resilience of the hind limb for estimation of energy return, a modification of the work loop technique was used (Fig. 2A), in which the limb was kept intact and forces were applied to the whole limb instead of a single muscle (Dudek and Full, 2006). The animal was anesthetized using 2% isoflurane air solution during the test. The hind foot was maintained within the vertical plane, pushed down onto and then extracted from a custom force platform suited for small animals (10.2 × 7.6 cm2, range = 2.5 N, resolution = 0.005 N) bonded with sandpaper (grit size ~ 0.1 mm). Ground reaction force F was measured at 10 kHz sampling rate using a custom 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 7 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 LabVIEW program (National Instruments, Austin, TX, USA). A Phantom high speed camera (Vision Research, Wayne, NJ, USA) simultaneously recorded deformation of the foot from the side view at 250 frame/s (shutter time = 500 s). High-contrast markers (Wite-Out, Garden Grove, CA, USA) were painted on the joints of the hind foot (A, MP, PP, T, and a point on the tibia above the ankle). The ambient temperature was maintained at 35°C during the test. Videos of foot deformation were digitized to obtain the angular displacement of the foot  = t, i.e., the change in the angle formed by the tibia and the foot (from the ankle to the digit tip of the fourth toe) (Fig. 2A). Angular displacement  was synchronized with the measured torque  about the ankle (calculated from the measured ground reaction force) to obtain a passive work loop. The damping ratio of the hind limb, i.e., the percentage of energy lost within the hind limb after loading and unloading, was calculated as the fraction of area within a work loop relative to the area under the higher loading curve (Fung, 1993). Hind limb resilience, i.e., the percentage of energy returned by the foot after loading and unloading, was one minus the damping ratio (Ker et al., 1987; Dudek and Full, 2006). An ANOVA was used to test the effect of maximal torque, maximal angular displacement, loading rate, and individual animal on hind limb resilience. Granular penetration force measurements While comprehensive force models are still lacking to calculate ground reaction forces during locomotion granular media, a low speed penetration force model was previously used to explain the locomotor performance of a legged robot on granular media (Li et al., 2009). Similarly, to estimate the vertical ground reaction force on the lizard foot during running on the granular surface, we measured the vertical force on a plate slowly penetrating vertically into the granular substrate (Fig. 2B). Before each trial, a fluidized bed (area = 24 × 22 cm2) prepared the granular substrate (depth = 12 cm) into a loosely packed state (volume fraction = 0.58) (for details, see Maladen et al., 2009). A robotic arm (CRS robotics, Burlington, OT, Canada) pushed a horizontally-oriented plate vertically downward at 0.01 m/s into the granular substrate to a depth of 7.6 cm, and then extracted the plate vertically at 0.01 m/s. The force on the plate was measured by a force transducer (ATI Industrial Automation, Apex, NC, USA) mounted between the robotic arm and the plate at 100 Hz sampling rate using a custom LabVIEW program (National Instruments, Austin, TX, USA). The depth of the plate was measured by tracking the position of an LED light marker mounted on the robotic arm in side view videos taken by a Pike high speed camera (Edmund Optics, Barrington, NJ, USA). Two thin aluminum plates of different area were 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 8 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 252 253 used (A1 = 7.6 × 2.5 cm2 and A2 = 3.8 × 2.5 cm2; thickness = 0.6 cm). Three trials were performed for each plate. 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 Results Performance and gait representative runs on both substrates). Figure 4 shows average forward speed v(cid:3364) x,CoM, stride On both solid and granular surfaces, the zebra-tailed lizard ran with a diagonal gait, a sprawled limb posture, and lateral trunk bending (see Fig. 3 and Movies 1, 2 in supplementary material for frequency f, and duty factor D of the entire data set (all symbols; 23 runs on the solid surface and 28 runs on the granular surface) and of the representative runs (filled symbols; N = 7 on the solid (N = 7) surfaces. On both surfaces, v(cid:3364)x,CoM increased with f (Fig. 4A, P < 0.05, ANCOVA), and D surface and N = 7 on the granular surface). Table 2 lists mean values and statistical results for all decreased with v(cid:3364)x,CoM (Fig. 4B, P < 0.05, ANCOVA). D ≈ 0.45 on both surfaces resulting in an the gait and kinematic variables from the representative runs for both solid (N = 7) and granular v(cid:3364)x,CoM (P > 0.05, ANOVA) nor D (P > 0.05, ANCOVA) significantly differ between surfaces. Average stride length  = v(cid:3364)x,CoM/f was 15% shorter on the granular surface (P < 0.05, ANCOVA). aerial phase of approximately 5% stride period T between alternating stances (Fig. 5A). Neither Center of mass kinematics The lizard displayed qualitatively similar center of mass oscillations during running on both surfaces. The CoM forward speed vx,CoM (Fig. 5B) and vertical position zCoM (Fig. 5C) oscillated at 2f, dropping during the first half and rising during the second half of a stance, i.e., reaching minimum at mid-stance and maximum during the aerial phase. The CoM also oscillated medio- laterally at f (Fig. 5D). Throughout the entire stride, zCoM was significantly higher on the solid surface (P < 0.05, ANCOVA). The CoM vertical oscillations zCoM and lateral oscillations yCoM did not differ between substrates (P > 0.05, ANCOVA). Hind foot, hind leg, and trunk kinematics The lizard displayed distinctly different hind foot, hind leg, and trunk kinematics during running on solid and granular surfaces (Figs. 3, 6). On the solid surface, the lizard used a digitigrade foot posture (Fig. 3AE, solid line/curve). During the entire stride, the hind foot engaged the solid 9 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 surface only with the digit tips. At touchdown, the toes were straight and pointed slightly downward. The touchdown foot angle (measured along the fourth toe) was touchdown = 12 ± 4° relative to the surface (Fig. 3A,E; Fig. 6A, red). During stance, the long toes pivoted over the stationary digit tips (Fig. 3AC, vertical dotted line shows zero displacement) and hyperextended into a c-shape (Fig. 3B, solid curve). The foot straightened again at takeoff, pointing downward and slightly backward (Fig. 3C, solid line), and then flexed during swing (Fig. 3D, solid curve). On the granular surface, the lizard used a plantigrade foot posture (Fig. 3F,J, solid line). At touchdown, the hind foot was nearly parallel with the surface, with the toes spread out and held straight. In the vertical direction, the foot impacted the granular surface at speeds of up to 1 m/s. The ankle joint slowed down to ~ 0.1 m/s within a few milliseconds following impact (a few percent of stride period T) while the the foot started penetrating the surface. The touchdown foot angle was touchdown = 4 ± 3° relative to the surface (Fig. 3J; Fig. 6A, blue), significantly smaller than that on the solid surface (P < 0.05, ANCOVA). During stance, the entire foot moved subsurface and was obscured (Fig. 3G). The ankle joint remained visible right above the surface and moved forward by about a foot length (Fig. 3FH, vertical dotted line shows ankle displacement). The foot was extracted from the substrate at takeoff, pointing downward and slightly backward, and then flexed during swing (Fig. 3I, solid curve). As a result of foot penetration on the granular surface, both the knee height zknee (Fig. 6B) and pelvis height zpelvis (Fig. 6C) were lower on the granular surface (P < 0.05, ANCOVA). In addition, on the granular surface, the knee moved downward by a larger vertical displacement zknee during the first half of stance (P < 0.05, ANCOVA; Fig. 6B), while the knee joint extended by a larger angle knee during the second half of stance (P < 0.05, ANCOVA; Fig. 6D). Throughout the entire stride, the trunk was nearly horizontal on the solid surface (Fig. 3AD, dashed line), but pitched head-up on the granular surface (Fig. 3FI, dashed line; Fig. 6E). On both surfaces, the hind legs were sprawled at an angle of sprawl ≈ 40° during stance (Fig. 3; sprawl is defined as the angle between the horizontal plane and the leg orientation in the posterior view). In most runs, the tail was farther from the solid surface and closer to the granular surface (Fig. 3). Hind limb anatomy From morphological measurements (Table 1), the hind foot of the zebra-tailed lizard comprised 42% of the hind limb length, and the longest fourth toe alone accounted for 63% of the hind foot length. These ratios are in similar range to previous observations (Irschick and Jayne, 1999a). The 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 10 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 slender foot had a cross-sectional radius of r = 0.501.25 mm tapering distally, with reducing joint radii: rK = rA = 1.25 mm, rMP = 0.75 mm, rPP = rT = 0.50 mm. Unlike many cursorial mammals whose ankle extensor muscles of the lower hind leg have long tendons (Alexander, 2003), ankle extensor tendons are nearly non-existent in the zebra-tailed lizard (Fig. 7A). Instead, layers of elongate tendons were found in both the dorsal and ventral surfaces of the foot. Our anatomical description is focused on the ventral muscle and tendon anatomy in the hind limb and terms given to muscles and tendons follow (Russell, 1993). A large, tendinous sheath, the superficial femoral aponeurosis, originates from the femoro-tibial gastrocnemius, stretches across the ventral surface of the foot, and inserts on the metatarsal- phalangeal joints for digits III and IV. The superficial portion of the femoro-tibial gastrocnemius muscle body extends to the base of the ankle, thereby rendering the human equivalent of the ankle extensor tendons (i.e., the “Achilles” tendon) absent. Deep to the superficial femoral aponeurosis lie the flexor digitorum brevis muscles (not shown) which control the flexion of each of the digits. Tendons from the flexor digitorum longus muscle located on the lower hind leg run deep to the flexor digitorum brevis muscle bodies, and extend to the tips of the digits. No additional tendons are visible deep to the flexor digitorum longus tendons. Hind limb model Based on the observed muscle and tendon anatomy, we propose a two-dimensional strut-spring model of the hind limb (Fig. 7B), which assumes isometric contraction for the lower leg muscles and incorporates the spring nature of the foot tendons. This model is inspired from previous observations in large running and hopping animals of the strut-like function of ankle extensor muscles (Biewener, 1998a; Roberts et al., 1997) and spring-like function of ankle extensor tendons (for a review, see Alexander, 2003). Rigid segments (Fig. 7B, dashed lines), which are free to rotate about joints within a plane, represent the skeleton. The ankle extensor muscles in the lower leg, which originate on the femur and run along the ventral side of the tibia, are modeled as a rigid strut (muscle strut, Fig. 7B, blue line) that contracts isometrically during stance in running. A linear spring (tendon spring, Fig. 7B, red line), which originates from the distal end of the muscle strut and extends to the digit tip, models the elastic foot tendons. The muscle strut and tendon spring are ventrally offset from the midline of the skeleton at each joint by respective joint radii. Hind limb resilience 11 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Representative passive work loops (Fig. 8AC) showed that torque  was higher when the foot was pushed down on the solid surface than when it was extracted, similar to previous observations in humans (Ker et al., 1987) and cockroaches (Dudek and Full, 2006). Maximal torque was positively correlated with maximal angular displacement (F1,62 = 64.3188, P < 0.001, ANOVA). The kinks observed in the middle of the loading curve were due to the fifth toe contacting the surface. Average hind limb resilience calculated from the work loops was R = 0.44 ± 0.12 (Fig. 8DF, 3 individuals, 64 trials). R did not differ between individuals (F2,61 = 2.1025, P = 0.1309, ANOVA), and did not depend on maximal torque (F1,62 = 0.5208, P = 0.4732, ANOVA; Fig. 8D), maximal angular displacement F1,62 = 0.0164, P = 0.8987, ANOVA; Fig. 8E, or average loading rate (F1,62 = 1.1228, P = 0.2934, ANOVA; Fig. 8F). Hind foot curvature, tendon deformation, and tendon stiffness The observed three-dimensional positions of the hind limb fit well to the two-dimensional hind limb model (Fig. 9AD), and enabled calculation of the curvature, tendon deformation, and tendon stiffness of the hind foot (see Appendix). Calculated hind foot curvature (Fig. 9E, solid curve) showed that the hind foot hyperextended during stance (positive ) and flexed during swing (negative ). The foot was straight at touchdown and shortly after takeoff (). Calculated tendon spring deformation l(Fig. 9E, dashed curve) showed that the tendon spring stretched during the first half and recoiled during the second half of stance. The estimated tendon spring stiffness was k = 4.4 × 103 N/m (see Appendix). Mechanical energetics on solid surface Using the observed CoM and hind limb kinematics, calculated tendon spring stiffness and deformation, and measured hind limb resilience, we examined the mechanical energetics of the lizard running on the solid surface (Table 3, Fig. 9F). From the observed CoM kinematics, in the first half of stance, the mechanical energy of the CoM (kinetic energy plus gravitational potential energy) decreased significantly from Etouchdown = 1.00 ± 0.00 at touchdown to Emid-stance = 0.81 ± 0.08 at mid-stance (F2,18 = 12.2345, P = 0.0004, ANOVA, Tukey HSD). In the second half of stance, the mechanical energy of the CoM recovered to Eaerial = 0.95 ± 0.10 at mid aerial phase, not significantly different from Etouchdown (Tukey HSD). The reduction in CoM mechanical energy in the first half of stance Emech = 0.19 ± 0.08 is the mechanical work needed per step on the solid surface. Note that the energies of each run were normalized to Etouchdown of that run. 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 12 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 At mid-stance, the elastic energy stored in the tendon spring was Estorage = 0.18 ± 0.13 (calculated 2, see Appendix), not significantly different from Emech (F1,12 = 0.0475, P = from 1/2 klmax 0.8312, ANOVA). Because hind limb resilience R = 0.44 ± 0.12, the elastic recoil of the foot tendons returned an energy of Ereturn = REstorage = 0.08 ± 0.06, or 41 ± 33% of the mechanical work needed per step (Emech) on the solid surface. We verified that foot flexion during swing induced little energy storage (< 0.1 Estorage) because the hind foot was less stiff during flexion (0.7 × 103 N/m) than during hyperextension (4.4 × 103 N/m). Granular penetration force model Although little is known about the kinematics and mechanics of the complex limb intrusions during legged locomotion on granular surfaces, we took inspiration from previous observations that horizontal drag (Maladen et al., 2009) and vertical impact (Katsuragi and Durian, 2007) forces in glass particles were insensitive to speed when intrusion speed was below approximately 0.5 m/s. Because the kinematics observed on the granular surface suggest that the vertical speeds of most of the foot relative to the ground were below 0.5 m/s during most of the stance phase (see Appendix), we assumed that the ground reaction forces on the lizard’s feet were also insensitive to speed. This allowed us to use the vertical penetration force measured at 0.01 m/s to model and estimate the vertical ground reaction forces on the lizard foot. From the force data on both plates (Fig. 10), vertical ground reaction force Fz was proportional to both penetration depth z and projected area A of the plate (area projected into the horizontal plane). Fz was pointing upward during foot penetration, and pointing downward during foot extraction and dropped by an order of magnitude. These measurements were in accord with previous observations of forces on a sphere penetrating into granular media (Hill et al., 2005). Furthermore, we estimated from free falling of particles under gravity that it would take longer than the stance duration (45 ms) for the grains surrounding a penetrating foot to refill a hole created by the foot of maximal depth (zmax = 1.0 cm, see Appendix). Thus we assumed that the vertical ground reaction forces were negligible during foot extraction. Fz = (cid:3420) (cid:2009) (cid:1878)(cid:1827), for increasing (cid:1878), 0, for decreasing (cid:1878), Therefore, we approximate the vertical penetration force as: where  is the vertical stress per unit depth, which is determined by the properties of the granular material and increases with compaction (Li et al., 2009). Fitting Fz = zA to the force data (1) 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 13 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 during penetration over regions where the plate was fully submerged and far from boundary (Fig. 10, dashed lines), we obtained=× 105 N/m3 for loosely packed 0.27 ± 0.04 mm diameter glass particles. Vertical ground reaction force on granular surface During a stance on the granular surface, the CoM vertical speed vz,CoM (calculated from zCoM) was approximately sinusoidal (Fig. 11A, dashed curve). This implies that the Fz on a lizard foot must be approximately sinusoidal. In addition, the foot was nearly horizontal at touchdown, but pointed downward and slightly backward during takeoff. In consideration of the functional form of the penetration force (Eqn. 1), we hypothesized that during stance the foot rotated subsurface by /2 in the sagittal plane (Fig. 11C), increasing foot depth z but decreasing projected foot area A, thus resulting in a sinusoidal Fz which reaches a maximum at mid-stance before the foot reaches largest depth (see Appendix). A sinusoidal Fz is also possible for a fixed projected foot area if the foot maintains contact on solidified grains. However, this is unlikely considering that during stance the ankle moved forward at the surface level by a foot length. Assuming that during stance the hind foot rotated by /2 in the sagittal plane at a constant angular velocity, the vertical ground reaction force that each foot generated was Fz = 5mg/9 sin10t/9T (see Appendix). The net vertical acceleration due to this Fz and the animal weight mg was az = Fz/m – g (Fig. 11B; solid and dashed curves are az from both hind feet, shifted from each other by T/2). The CoM vertical speed vz,CoM predicted from the total az on both hind feet (Fig. 11A, dashed curve) agreed with experimental observations (Fig. 11A, solid curve). The slight under- prediction of the oscillation magnitudes of vz,CoM was likely due to an over-estimation of duty factor on the granular surface. This is because Fz may have dropped to zero even before takeoff if the foot started moving upward before takeoff (Fig. 10). Mechanical energetics on granular surface Using the measured CoM kinematics, assumed foot rotation, and calculated vertical ground reaction force, we examined the mechanical energetics of the lizard running on the granular surface (Table 3, Fig. 11D). In the first half of stance, the mechanical energy of the CoM decreased significantly from Etouchdown = 1.00 ± 0.00 at touchdown to Emid-stance = 0.86 ± 0.09 at mid-stance (F2,18 = 6.6132, P = 0.007, ANOVA, Tukey HSD). In the second half of stance, the mechanical energy of the CoM recovered to Eaerial = 0.99 ± 0.10 at mid aerial phase, not significantly different from Etouchdown (Tukey HSD). The reduction in CoM mechanical energy in 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 14 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 434 435 436 437 438 the first half of stance Emech = 0.14 ± 0.09 is the mechanical work needed per step on the granular surface. By integration of Fz over vertical displacement of the foot during stance (see Appendix), the energy lost to the granular substrate per step was estimated as Esubstrate = 0.17 ± 0.05, not significantly different from Emech (F1,12 = 0.4659, P = 0.5078, ANOVA). Note that the energies of each run were normalized to Etouchdown of that run. 439 440 441 442 443 444 445 446 447 448 449 450 451 452 453 454 455 456 457 458 459 460 461 462 Discussion Conservation of spring-mass-like CoM dynamics on solid and granular surfaces The observed kinematics and calculated mechanical energetics demonstrated that the zebra-tailed lizard ran like a spring-mass system on both solid and granular surfaces. On both surfaces, the CoM forward speed (Fig. 5B), vertical position (Fig. 5C), and lateral position (Fig. 5D) displayed oscillation patterns that are in accord with predictions from the Spring-Loaded Inverted Pendulum (SLIP) model (Blickhan, 1989) and the Lateral Leg Spring (LLS) model (Schmitt et al., 2002). The small relative oscillations of the CoM forward speed (i.e., vx,CoM/vx,CoM << 1) was expected because the Froude number was large for the lizard (see Appendix). The substantial sprawling of the legs contributed to the medio-lateral oscillatory motion of the animal. Furthermore, on both surfaces, the mechanical energy of the CoM oscillated within a step, reaching minimum at mid- stance and maximum during the aerial phase (Fig. 9F, 11D), a defining feature of spring-mass like running (Blickhan, 1989; Schmitt et al., 2002). To our knowledge, ours is the first study to quantitatively demonstrate spring-mass-like CoM motion in lizards running on granular surfaces. Spring-mass-like CoM motion was previously observed in other lizards and geckos running on solid surfaces (Farley and Ko, 1997; Chen et al., 2006), but it was not clear whether energy-saving by elastic elements played an important role. Hind foot function on solid surface: energy-saving spring Our study is also the first to quantify elastic energy savings in foot tendons in lizards during running on solid surfaces. The significant energy savings (about 40% of the mechanical work needed per step) in the zebra-tailed lizard’s hind foot tendons is in a similar range to the energy savings by ankle extensor tendons and digital flexor tendons and ligaments in larger animals (Alexander, 2003), such as kangaroos (50%, Alexander and Vernon, 1975), wallabies (45%, 15 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Biewener et al., 1998), horses (40%, Biewener, 1998b), and humans (35%, with an additional 17% from ligaments in the foot arch, Ker et al., 1987). This is surprising considering that the elastic energy saving mechanism was previously thought less important in small animals (e.g., 14% in hopping kangaroo rat of ~ 100 g mass, Biewener et al., 1981). Because the tendons of small animals are “overbuilt” to withstand large stresses during escape, during steady-speed locomotion these tendons usually experience stresses too small to induce significant elastic energy storage and return (Biewener and Blickhan, 1988; McGowan et al., 2008). We verified that for zebra-tailed lizards running at ~ 1 m/s the maximal stress in the foot tendons is 4.3 MPa (see Appendix), well below the 100 MPa breaking stress for most tendons (Kirkendall and Garrett, 1997). The zebra-tailed lizard’s elongate hind foot and digitigrade foot posture on the solid surface may be an adaptation for elastic energy saving during rapid locomotion. Like other iguanids (Russell, 1993), this lizard does not have substantial ankle extensor tendons as large animals do. Nevertheless, elongation of foot tendons and a digitigrade posture enhance the hind foot’s energy saving capacity by decreasing tendon stiffness and mechanical advantage (Biewener et al., 2004) (see Appendix). A recent study also found significant energy savings (53%) by elongate foot tendons in running ostriches (Rubenson et al., 2011). More generally, elongation of distal limb segments such as legs, feet, and toes which possess tendons may be an adaptation for energy saving during rapid locomotion. Indeed, many cursorial animals including mammals (Garland Jr. and Janis, 1993), lizards (Bauwens et al., 1995), and dinosaurs (Coombs Jr., 1978) display elongation of distal limb segments. Short fascicles and long tendons and ligaments are often found in the ankle extensor muscles and digital flexor muscles in large cursorial ungulates such as horses, camels, and antelopes (Alexander, 2003). Solid surface model assumptions Our estimates of elastic energy storage and return on the solid surface assume isometric contraction of lower leg muscles. However, muscles have a finite stiffness and do lengthen by a small amount under limb tension (Biewener, 1998a; Roberts et al., 1997). Despite this difference, our estimates still hold, because in the latter case both lower leg muscles and foot tendons behave like springs, and the total stiffness remains the same (since external force and total deformation remain the same). In the case where the muscles actively shorten during stance and further lengthen the tendons (which does positive mechanical work on the tendons), the energy storage and return in the tendons would increase. However, the overall energy efficiency would decrease 463 464 465 466 467 468 469 470 471 472 473 474 475 476 477 478 479 480 481 482 483 484 485 486 487 488 489 490 491 492 493 494 16 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 (with everything else being the same), because apart from energy lost in tendon recoil, energy is further lost in the muscles that perform the mechanical work, i.e., muscle work is more expensive than tendon work (Biewener and Roberts, 2000). In addition, the hind limb resilience obtained from anesthetized lizards was assumed to be a good estimate for hind limb resilience in running lizards. This is based on our observations that resilience was independent of torque, angular displacement, and loading rate, as well as previous findings that the damping properties of animal limbs are largely intrinsic to their structure and material properties (Weiss et al., 1988; Fung, 1993; Dudek and Full, 2006). Future studies using techniques such as tendon buckles (Biewener et al., 1998), sonomicrometry (Biewener et al., 1998), ultrasonography (Maganaris and Paul, 1999), and oxygen consumption measurement (Alexander, 2003) during locomotion are needed to confirm this assumption. Hind foot function on granular surface: dissipative, force-generating paddle The similarity between the observed and predicted vz,CoM on the granular surface supports the hypothesis of subsurface foot rotation. We speculate that on the granular surface the foot functions as a “paddle” through fluidized grains to generate force. This differs from previous observations of the utilization of solidification forces of the granular media in a legged robot (Li et al., 2009; Li et al., 2010b) and sea turtle hatchlings (Mazouchova et al., 2010) moving on granular surfaces. As the zebra-tailed lizard’s hind foot paddles through fluidized grains to generate force, energy is lost to the substrate because grain contact forces in granular media are dissipative (Nedderman, 1992). A large foot can reduce energy loss to the granular substrate compared to a small one, much like large snowshoes used by humans can reduce energy cost for walking on snow (Knapik et al., 1997). From our model of foot-ground interaction on the granular surface, for a given animal (constant weight), energy loss to the substrate is proportional to foot penetration depth, and thus inversely proportional to foot area and substrate strength (see Appendix). Granular surface model assumptions In our modeling of the foot-ground interaction on the granular surface using the penetration force model, we made two assumptions. First, we assumed that the ground reaction forces were insensitive to speed. This is true in the low speed regime (<0.5 m/s for our glass particles, Maladen et al., 2009) where particle inertia is negligible and forces are dominated by particle friction. Because friction is proportional to pressure, and pressure is proportional to depth (Hill et 495 496 497 498 499 500 501 502 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 511 512 513 514 515 516 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 525 17 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 al., 2005), granular forces in the low-speed regime are proportional to depth (Fz=zA), analogous to the hydrostatic forces in fluids (Fz=gzA, i.e. buoyant forces due to hydrostatic pressure). Second, we used the vertical stress per unit depth  determined from vertical penetration of a horizontally oriented disc to estimate forces on the foot as it rotates subsurface. In this calculation, the effective vertical stress per unit depthcosfoot (see Appendix) depended on foot orientation via a simple relation cosfoot (because projected area A=Afootcosfoot; see Appendix), and not on direction of motion. However, our recent physics experiments (Li et al., in preparation) suggest that stresses in granular media in the low speed regime depend on both orientation and direction of motion in a more complicated manner, and that cosfoot overestimates vertical stress per unit depth for all foot orientations and directions of motion except when the foot is horizontal and moving vertically downwards. Therefore, our model must be overestimating hydrostatic-like forces, and there must be additional forces contributing to the lizard’s ground reaction forces. We propose that these additional forces are likely from hydrodynamic-like inertial forces resulting from the local acceleration of the substrate (particles) by the foot. Analogous to hydrodynamic forces in fluids (Vogel, 1996), for an intruder moving rapidly in granular media, the particles initially at rest in front of the intruder are accelerated by, and thus exert reaction forces on, the intruder. Hydrodynamic-like forces at ~1 m/s can play an important role both in impact forces on free falling intruders (Katsuragi and Durian, 2007; Goldman and Umbanhowar, 2008) and in legged locomotion of small lightweight robots (Qian et al., 2012). We note that the foot rotation hypothesis should hold regardless, because hydrodynamic-like forces are also proportional to projected area (Katsuragi and Durian, 2007). However, we know too little about the lizard’s subsurface foot kinematics and the force laws in the high-speed regime on an intruder being pushed in a complex path within granular media (not simply a free-falling intruder) to more accurately calculate both hydrostatic-like and hydrodynamic-like forces. Future x-ray high-speed imaging experiments (Maladen et al 2009; Sharpe et al., 2012) will reveal how the lizard foot was moving subsurface. Further studies of intrusion forces in granular media in both low-speed (Li et al., 2013) and high-speed regimes can provide a more comprehensive understanding of ground reaction forces during legged locomotion on granular surfaces and provide better estimates of foot penetration depth and energy loss. Comparison to water-running in basilisk lizard 526 527 528 529 530 531 532 533 534 535 536 537 538 539 540 541 542 543 544 545 546 547 548 549 550 551 552 553 554 555 556 18 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 The rapid impact of the foot on the surface at touchdown and hypothesized subsurface foot rotation appear kinematically similar to the slap and stroke phases of the basilisk lizards running on the surface of water (Glasheen and McMahon, 1996a; Hsieh, 2003). For the zebra-tailed lizard running on sand, both granular hydrostatic-like and hydrodynamic-like forces can contribute to vertical ground reaction force. This is also qualitatively similar to water-running basilisk lizard, which utilizes both hydrostatic forces resulting from the hydrostatic pressure between the water surface and the bottom of the air cavity created by the foot, and hydrodynamic forces resulting from the water being accelerated from rest by the rapidly moving foot (Glasheen and McMahon, 1996a, 1996b; Hsieh and Lauder, 2004). However, the degree to which each species relies on these two categories of forces differs due to differences in the properties of the supporting media. For given foot size, depth, and speed, the hydrostatic(-like) forces in water are an order of magnitude smaller than the hydrostatic-like forces in granular media, whereas the hydrodynamic(-like) forces are similar between in water and in granular media (see Appendix). As a result, the basilisk lizard running on water must rely on hydrodynamic forces to a larger degree than the zebra-tailed lizard running on sand, considering that these two lizards have similar size (~ 0.1 m). An extreme example for this is that it is impossible for a basilisk lizard to stand on the surface of water, but a zebra-tailed lizard can stand on loose sand. Motor function of upper hind leg Despite the passive nature of the leg spring in the spring-mass model, animal limbs do not function purely passively as springs—the muscles within them must perform mechanical work. We have shown that on the solid surface, the lizard’s hind foot saves about 40% of the mechanical work per step. The remaining 60% is lost either within the foot or to the ground, and must be compensated by mechanical work performed by muscles, which is Wmuscle = 0.11 ± 0.10. This work is likely provided by knee extension during the second half of stance (Fig. 6D, red curve) powered by the upper leg muscles. On the granular surface, substantial energy is lost to the substrate. This is in accord with previous observations of higher mechanical energetic cost during locomotion on granular surfaces in human (Zamparo et al., 1992; Lejeune et al., 1998) and legged robots (Li et al., 2010a). Because the energy lost to the substrate equals the reduction in CoM mechanical energy during the first half of stance, even without energy loss within the limb, the upper hind leg muscles must perform mechanical work of Wmuscle = 0.31 ± 0.10 during the second half of stance, about three times that 557 558 559 560 561 562 563 564 565 566 567 568 569 570 571 572 573 574 575 576 577 578 579 580 581 582 583 584 585 586 587 588 19 589 590 591 592 593 594 595 596 597 598 599 600 601 602 603 604 605 606 607 608 609 610 611 612 613 614 615 616 617 618 619 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 on the solid surface for a given animal running at a given speed, as evidenced by the larger knee extension on the granular surface (Fig. 6D, blue curve). Our models of the foot-ground interaction on both surfaces assume purely passive foot mechanics, and do not consider the role of active neurosensory control. However, animals can actively adjust kinematics and muscle function to accommodate changes in surface conditions (Ferris et al., 1999; Daley and Biewener, 2006). We observed that when confronted by a substrate which transitioned from solid into granular (or vice versa), the lizard displayed partial adjustment of foot posture during the first step on the new surface, followed by full adjustment during the second step. Future studies using neuromechanics techniques, such as EMG (Biewener et al., 1998; Sponberg and Full, 2008; Sharpe and Goldman, in review) and denervation and reinnervation (Chang et al., 2009), can determine how neural control and sensory feedback mechanisms are used to control limb function to accommodate changing substrates. Conclusions During running on both solid and granular surfaces, the zebra-tailed lizard displayed spring-mass- like center of mass kinematics with distinct hind foot, hind leg, and trunk kinematics. The lizard’s large, elongate hind foot served multiple functions during locomotion. On the solid surface, the hind foot functioned as an energy-saving spring and reduced about 40% of the mechanical work needed each footstep. On the granular surface, the hind foot paddled through fluidized grains to generate force, and substantial energy was lost during irreversible deformation of the granular substrate. The energy lost within the foot and to the substrate must be compensated for by mechanical work done by the upper hind leg muscles. The multifunctional hind foot may passively (and possibly actively) adjust to the substrate during locomotion in natural terrain, and provide this desert generalist with energetic advantages and simplify its neurosensory control tasks (Full and Koditschek, 1999). Current robotic devices often suffer performance loss and high cost of transport on flowing substrates like granular material (Kumagai 2004; Li et al., 2009; Li et al., 2010b; Li et al., 2010a). Insights from studies like ours can provide inspiration for next-generation multi-terrain robots (Pfeifer et al., 2007). Finally, our study also highlights the need for comprehensive force models for granular media (Li et al., in preparation) and for flowing terrestrial environments in general. Appendix 20 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Small relative oscillation in forward speed 2/gL0 = 3 Running at 1.1 m/s, the lizard’s Froude number in the sagittal plane was Fr = vx,CoM (where L0 ≈ 4 cm is the leg length at touchdown), above the typical value of 2.5 where most animals transition from trotting to galloping (Alexander, 2003). This implied that the kinetic 2 ≈ ½ mvx,CoM 2) of the CoM was 3 times larger than its gravitational potential energy (½ mvCoM energy (mgzCoM). Because both the forward speed oscillation vx,CoM and vertical speed oscillation vz,CoM were determined by the total ground reaction force and the attack angle of the leg spring ( = sin-1 (vx,CoMDT/2L0) = 0.9 rad), they must be of the same order of magnitude (Blickhan, 1989), i.e., vx,CoM ~ vz,CoM. From the observed CoM kinematics, vz,CoM < (gL0)1/2. Therefore, vx,CoM ~ vz,CoM < (gL0)1/2 << vx,CoM, and vx,CoM/vx,CoM << 1. Hind foot curvature on solid surface Three-dimensional kinematics showed that the hind limb (from the hip to the digit tip of the fourth toe) remained nearly within a plane during the entire stride (out-of-plane component is 5% averaged over the entire stride). During stance, the orientation of the foot plane remained nearly unchanged, with a foot sprawl angle of 53 ± 4° relative to the sagittal plane in the posterior view. Hind foot curvature  could then be obtained by fitting a circle to the hind foot (from the ankle to the digit tip) within the foot plane and determining the radius of curvature  of the fit circle (see diagram in Fig. 9A), i.e.,  = ± 1/, where + sign indicates foot hyperextension,  sign indicates foot flexion, and  = 0 indicates a straight foot. Tendon spring deformation From the two-dimensional strut-spring model of the hind limb, by geometry, the tendon spring deformation l was related to the observed changes of joint angles and the foot joint radii as: l = irii, where i = K, A, MP, PP were the four joints in the modeli the observed changes of joint angles, and ri the joint radii (rK = rA = 1.25 mm, rMP = 0.75 mm, rPP = 0.50 mm). We observed that the relaxed hind foot of a live animal was nearly straight (Fig. 1A), which was similar to the foot shape at touchdown during running (Fig. 3A,E). Thus we defined the relaxed length of the tendon spring as the length when the foot was straight, i.e., l = 0 at touchdown. Calculated maximal tendon spring deformation lmax = 0.78 mm corresponded to a 3% strain. We did not consider tendon spring deformation in the swing phase (dotted curve in Fig. 6F) because the assumption of isometric contraction of lower leg muscles was only valid for the stance phase. 620 621 622 623 624 625 626 627 628 629 630 631 632 633 634 635 636 637 638 639 640 641 642 643 644 645 646 647 648 649 21 650 651 652 653 654 655 656 657 658 659 660 661 662 663 664 665 666 667 668 669 670 671 672 673 674 675 676 677 678 679 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Tendon spring stiffness The stiffness of the tendon spring was defined as the maximal tension divided by the maximal deformation of the tendon spring, i.e., k = Tmax/lmax. From the observed CoM kinematics, the total ground reaction force at mid-stance was Fmax = 0.3 N within the coronal plane and pointed from the digit tip to the hip. At mid-stance, because the foot was neither dorsiflexing nor plantarflexing, torque was balanced at the ankle, i.e., TmaxrA = FmaxxAT, where xAT = 1.4 cm was the horizontal distance between the ankle and the digit tip at mid-stance, and rA = 1.25 mm. Thus Tmax = 3.4 N and k = 4.4 × 103 N/m. The maximal stress in the foot tendons during stance was 2 = 4.3 MPa. max = Tmax/rPP The torsional stiffness of the ankle observed in anesthetized lizards from the modified work loop experiments (~ 1 × 103 Nm/rad) was an order of magnitude smaller than estimated from running kinematics (12 × 103 Nm/rad). This is however not contradictory but expected because during stance the lizard’s lower leg muscles must be activated, and the resulting higher tension from muscle contraction increases limb stiffness (Weiss et al., 1988). Foot elongation increases energy savings on solid surface The stiffness of a piece of elastic material like a tendon is k = E0A0/l0, where E0 is the Young’s modulus (i.e., E0 is nearly constant). Thus, the stiffness of the tendon spring scales as k ∝ A0/l0 ∝ modulus, A0 the cross sectional area, and l0 the rest length of the material. Most animal tendons r0 are primarily made of collagen (Kirkendall and Garrett, 1997) and are of similar Young’s 2/k ∝ 1/k for a given Tmax), an elongate tendon can store (and return) more energy. 2/l0, i.e., an elongate tendon (smaller r0 and larger l0) is less stiff and stretches more easily than a short, thick tendon. Because elastic energy storage decreases with tendon stiffness (Estorage = ½ 2 = ½ Tmax klmax An elongate foot also reduces the moment arm of tendon tension (small rA) but increases the moment arm of the ground reaction force (large xAT) about the ankle, therefore reducing the mechanical advantage (Biewener et al., 2004), so it increases tension in the foot for a given ground reaction force (because Tmax = FmaxxAT/rA) and amplifies tendon stretch for enhanced energy storage and return. Vertical ground reaction force on granular surface We assumed that the hind foot was rotating at a constant angular velocity about the moving ankle during stance, i.e., foot = t within 0 ≤ t ≤ DT and 0 ≤ foot ≤ /2, then DT = 10/9T 22 680 681 682 683 684 685 686 687 688 689 690 691 692 693 694 695 696 697 698 699 700 701 702 703 704 705 706 707 708 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 = 35 rad/s. From the measured vertical speed of the ankle and this assumed foot rotation, the vertical speed of most (75%) of the foot was always below 0.5 m/s during most (75%) of stance. Given foot rotation foot = t, the foot area projected in the horizontal plane decreased with time as A = Afootcost, where Afoot = 1 cm2 is the hind foot area; the foot depth (measured at the center of the foot) increased with time as z = zmaxsint. The vertical ground reaction force on the foot was sinusoidal: Fz = Fz,maxsin2t, which was then sinusoidal, where Fz,max = (cid:1516) (cid:1832)(cid:3053) ,(cid:3040)(cid:3028)(cid:3051) (cid:1871)(cid:1861)(cid:1866)2(cid:2033)(cid:1872) (cid:1856)(cid:1872) Afootzmaxsin/4cos/4 = ½Afootzmax. For steady state locomotion on a level surface, the Fz (cid:3021)(cid:2868) generated by one foot averaged over a cycle must equal half the body weight, i.e., = ½mg. Therefore, Fz,max = 5mg/9 and Fz = 5mg/9 sin10t/9T. Energy loss to granular substrate (cid:3031) (cid:3053)(cid:3031)(cid:3047) (cid:1856)(cid:1872) , where zmax = 1.0 cm (cid:1856) (cid:1878) = (cid:1516) (cid:1832)(cid:3053)(cid:3021)(cid:2868) (cid:1832)(cid:3053) loss to the granular substrate was Esubstrate = (cid:1516) (cid:3053)(cid:3288)(cid:3276)(cid:3299) (cid:2868) By integration of vertical ground reaction force over vertical displacement of the foot, the energy from Fz,max = ½Afootzmax. The hypothesized foot rotation in the sagittal plane did not take into account the sprawl of the foot during stance, which could induce additional energy loss by lateral displacement of the granular substrate. However, a sprawled foot posture did not affect the condition of vertical force balance and thus did not change our estimate of energy dissipation in the sagittal plane. Therefore this estimate provides a lower bound. Large foot area reduces energy loss on granular surface (cid:2033) (cid:1855)(cid:1867)(cid:1871)(cid:2033)(cid:1872) (cid:1856)(cid:1872) ∝ zmax ∝ 1/(Afoot). This implies that the energy loss to the granular = (cid:1878)(cid:3040)(cid:3028)(cid:3051) (cid:1516) (cid:1832)(cid:3053)(cid:3021)(cid:2868) For a given animal (constant weight mg), Fz,max = ½Afootzmax = 5mg/9 is constant, thus Esubstrate substrate increases with foot penetration depth. On a given granular surface (fixed ), a larger foot (larger Afoot) sinks less than a smaller foot, and thus loses less energy to the substrate. For a given foot size (fixed Afoot), a foot sinks less on a stronger granular substrate (larger ) than on a weaker substrate, and thus loses less energy to the substrate. Comparison of forces in granular media and in water For water, hydrostatic force is Fz = gzA. Comparing this with Fz = zA for granular media, g is the equivalent of . For water, g = 1.0 × 104 N/m3; for loosely packed glass particles3.5 × 105 N/m3. Therefore, the hydrostatic forces in water are an order of magnitude smaller than the hydrostatic-like forces in granular media for given foot size and depth. 23 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 709 710 711 712 713 Hydrodynamic(-like) forces should be proportional to the density of the surrounding media because they are due to the media being accelerated. For water,  = 1.0 × 103 N/m3; for loosely packed glass particles the effective density is 2.5 × 103 N/m3 × 0.58 volume fraction = 1.45 × 103 N/m3. Therefore, the hydrodynamic forces in water and hydrodynamic-like forces in granular media are on the same order of magnitude for given foot size and foot speed. 714 715 716 717 718 719 720 721 722 723 724 725 726 727 Acknowledgements We gratefully thank Sarah Sharpe, Yang Ding, Nick Gravish, Ryan Maladen, Paul Umbanhowar, Kyle Mara, Young-Hui Chang, Andy Biewener, Tom Roberts, Craig McGowan, and two anonymous reviewers for helpful discussions and/or comments on the manuscript; Loretta Lau for help with kinematics data tracking; Sarah Sharpe for help with animal protocol and anesthetization; Mateo Garcia, Nick Gravish, and Andrei Savu for help with force plate setup; Ryan Maladen and The Sweeney Granite Mountains Desert Research Center for help with animal collection; and the staff of The Physiological Research Laboratory animal facility of The Georgia Institute of Technology for animal housing and care. This work was funded by The Burroughs Wellcome Fund (D.I.G. and C.L.), The Army Research Laboratory Micro Autonomous Systems and Technology Collaborative Technology Alliance (D.I.G. and C.L.), The Army Research Office Biological Locomotion Principles and Rheological Interaction Physics (D.I.G. and C.L.) and The University of Florida and Temple University start-up funds (S.T.H.). 728 729 730 731 732 733 734 735 References Alexander, R. M. (2003). Principles of Animal Locomotion. Princeton: Princeton University Press. Alexander, R. M. and Vernon, A. (1975). The mechanics of hopping by kangaroos (Macropodidae). Journal of Zoology 177, 265–303. Autumn, K., Liang, Y. A., Hsieh, S. T., Zesch, W., Chan, W. P., Kenny, T. W., Fearing, R. S. and Full, R. J. (2000). Adhesive force of a single gecko foot-hair. Nature 405, 681–685. 24 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Bauwens, D., Garland Jr., T., Castilla, A. M. and Van Damme, R. (1995). Evolution of sprint speed in lacertid lizards: morphological, physiological and behavioral covariation. Evolution 49, 848–863. Biewener, A. A. (1998a). Muscle function in vivo: A comparison of muscles used for elastic energy savings versus muscles used to generate mechanical power. Integrative & Comparative Biology 38, 703–717. Biewener, A. A. (1998b). Muscle-tendon stresses and elastic energy storage during locomotion in the horse. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part B: Biochemistry & Molecular Biology 120, 73–87. Biewener, A. A., Alexander, R. M. and Heglund, N. C. (1981). Elastic energy storage in the hopping of kangaroo rats (Dipodomys spectabilis). Journal of Zoology 195, 369–383. Biewener, A. A. and Blickhan, R. (1988). Kangaroo rat locomotion: design for elastic energy storage or acceleration? The Journal of Experimental Biology 140, 243–255. Biewener, A. A., Farley, C. T., Roberts, T. J. and Temaner, M. (2004). Muscle mechanical advantage of human walking and running: implications for energy cost. Journal of Applied Physiology 97, 2266–2274. Biewener, A. A., Konieczynski, D. D. and Baudinette, R. V. (1998). In vivo muscle force- length behavior during steady-speed hopping in tammar wallabies. The Journal of Experimental Biology 201, 1681–1694. Biewener, A. A. and Roberts, T. J. (2000). Muscle and tendon contributions to force, work, and elastic energy savings: a comparative perspective. Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews 28, 99– 107. Blickhan, R. (1989). The spring-mass model for running and hopping. Journal of Biomechanics 22, 1217–1227. Blickhan, R. and Full R. J. (1993). Similarity in multilegged locomotion: Bouncing like a monopode. Journal of Comparative Physiology 173, 509–517. Chang, Y.-H., Auyang, A. G., Scholz, J. P. and Nichols, T. R. (2009). Whole limb kinematics are preferentially conserved over individual joint kinematics after peripheral nerve injury. The Journal of Experimental Biology 212, 3511–3521. 736 737 738 739 740 741 742 743 744 745 746 747 748 749 750 751 752 753 754 755 756 757 758 759 760 761 762 763 764 25 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Chen, J. J., Peattie, A. M., Autumn, K. and Full, R. J. (2006). Differential leg function in a sprawled-posture quadrupedal trotter. The Journal of Experimental Biology 209, 249–259. Coombs Jr., W. P. (1978). Theoretical aspects of cursorial adaptations in dinosaurs. The Quarterly Review of Biology 53, 393–418. 765 766 767 768 769 Crawford, C. S. (1981). Biology of Desert Invertebrates. New York: Springer. 770 771 772 773 774 775 776 777 778 779 780 781 782 783 784 785 786 787 788 789 790 791 Daley, M. A. and Biewener, A. A. (2006). Running over rough terrain reveals limb control for intrinsic stability. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 103, 15681–15686. Dickinson, M. H., Farley, C. T., Full, R. J., Koehl, M. A. R., Kram, R. and Lehman, S. (2000). How animals move: An integrative view. Science 288, 100–106. Dickinson, W. W. and Ward, J. D. (1994). Low depositional porosity in eolian sands and sandstones, Namib Desert. Journal of Sedimentary Research 64, 226–232. Ding, Y., Gravish, N. and Goldman, D. I. (2011a). Drag induced lift in granular media. Physical Review Letters 106, 028001(1–4). Dudek, D. M. and Full, R. J. (2006). Passive mechanical properties of legs from running insects. The Journal of Experimental Biology 209, 1502–1515. Farley, C. T. and Ko, T. C. (1997). Mechanics of locomotion in lizards. The Journal of Experimental Biology 200, 2177–2188. Ferris, D., Liang, K. and Farley, C. T. (1999). Runners adjust leg stiffness for their first step on a new running surface. Journal of Biomechanics 32, 787–794. Ferris, D. P., Louie, M. and Farley, C. T. (1998). Running in the real world: Adjusting leg stiffness for different surfaces. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 265, 989– 994. Full, R. J. and Koditschek, D. E. (1999). Templates and anchors: neuromechanical hypotheses of legged locomotion on land. The Journal of Experimental Biology 202, 3325–3332. Fung, Y. C. (1993). Biomechanics: Mechanical Properties of Living Tissues. New York: Springer. 26 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Garland Jr., T. and Janis, C. (1993). Does metatarsal/femur ratio predict maximal running speed in cursorial mammals? Journal of Zoology 229, 133–151. Glasheen, J. W. and McMahon, T. A. (1996a). A hydrodynamic model of locomotion in the Basilisk Lizard. Nature 380, 340–341. Glasheen, J. W. and McMahon, T. A. (1996b). Vertical water entry of disks at low Froude numbers. Physics of Fluids 8, 2078–2083. Goldman, D. I. and Umbanhowar, P. B. (2008). Scaling and dynamics of sphere and disk impact into granular media. Physical Review E 77, 021308(1–14). Gravish, N., Umbanhowar, P. B. and Goldman, D. I. (2010). Force and flow transition in plowed granular media. Physical Review Letters 105, 208301(1–4). Hedrick, T. L. (2008). Software techniques for two- and three-dimensional kinematic measurements of biological and biomimetic systems. Bioinspiration & Biomimetics 3, 034001(1– 6). Hill, G., Yeung, S. and Koehler, S. A. (2005). Scaling vertical drag forces in granular media. Europhysics Letters 72, 137–143. Holmes, P., Full, R. J., Koditschek, D. and Guckenheimer, J. (2006). The dynamics of legged locomotion: Models, analyses, and challenges. SIAM Review 48, 207–304. Hsieh, S. T. (2003). Three-dimensional hindlimb kinematics of water running in the plumed basilisk lizard (Basiliscus plumifrons). The Journal of Experimental Biology 206, 4363–4377. Hsieh, S. T. and Lauder, G. V. (2004). Running on water: Three-dimensional force generation by basilisk lizards. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 101, 16784–16788. Irschick, D. J. and Jayne, B. C. (1999a). Comparative three-dimensional kinematics of the hindlimb for high speed bipedal and quadrupedal locomotion of lizards. The Journal of Experimental Biology 202, 1047–1065. Irschick, D. J. and Jayne, B. C. (1999b). A field study of the effects of incline on the escape locomotion of a bipedal lizard, Callisaurus draconoides. Physiological and Biochemical Zoology 72, 44–56. 792 793 794 795 796 797 798 799 800 801 802 803 804 805 806 807 808 809 810 811 812 813 814 815 816 817 818 819 27 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Jindrich, D. L. and Full, R. J. (1999). Many-legged maneuverability: dynamics of turning in hexapods. The Journal of Experimental Biology 202, 1603–1623. Karasov, W. H. and Anderson, R. A. (1998). Correlates of average daily metabolism of field- active zebra-tailed lizards (Callisaurus draconoides). Physiological Zoology 71, 93–105. Katsuragi, H. and Durian, D. J. (2007). Unified force law for granular impact cratering. Nature Physics 3, 420–423. Ker, R. F., Bennett, M. B., Bibby, S. R., Kester, R. C. and Alexander, R. M. (1987). The spring in the arch of the human foot. Nature 325, 147–149. Kirkendall, D. T. and Garrett, W. E. (1997). Function and biomechanics of tendons. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports 7, 62–66. Knapik, J., Hickey, C., Ortega, S., Nagel, J. and De Pontbriand, R. (2002). Energy cost during locomotion across snow: a comparison of four types of snowshoes with showshoe design considerations. Work 18, 171–177. Korff, W. L. and McHenry, M. J. (2011). Environmental differences in substrate mechanics do not affect sprinting performance in sand lizards (Uma scoparia and Callisaurus draconoides). The Journal of Experimental Biology 214, 122–130. Kumagai, J. (2004). Sand trip—DARPA’s 320-kilometer robotic race across the Mojave Desert yields no winner, but plenty of new ideas. IEEE Spectrum 41, 44–50. Lejeune, T. M., Willems, P. A. and Heglund, N. C. (1998). Mechanics and energetics of human locomotion on sand. The Journal of Experimental Biology 201, 2071–2080. Li, C., Hoover, A. M., Birkmeyer, P., Umbanhowar, P. B., Fearing, R. S. and Goldman, D. I. (2010a). Systematic study of the performance of small robots on controlled laboratory substrates. Proceedings of SPIE 7679, 76790Z(1–13). Li, C., Umbanhowar, P. B., Komsuoglu, H. and Goldman, D. I. (2010b). The effect of limb kinematics on the speed of a legged robot on granular media. Experimental Mechanics 50, 1383– 1393. 820 821 822 823 824 825 826 827 828 829 830 831 832 833 834 835 836 837 838 839 840 841 842 843 844 845 28 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Li, C., Umbanhowar, P. B., Komsuoglu, H., Koditschek, D. E. and Goldman, D. I. (2009). Sensitive dependence of the motion of a legged robot on granular media. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 106, 3029–3034. Li, C., Zhang, T. and Goldman, D. I. (2013). A terradynamics of legged locomotion on granular media. Science, 339, 1408–1411. Maganaris, C. N. and Paul, J. P. (1999). In vivo human tendon mechanical properties. Journal of Physiology 521, 307–313. Maladen, R. D., Ding, Y., Li, C. and Goldman, D. I. (2009). Undulatory swimming in sand: Subsurface locomotion of the sandfish lizard. Science 325, 314–318. Maladen, R. D., Ding, Y., Umbanhowar, P. B., Kamor, A. and Goldman, D. I. (2011). Mechanical models of sandfish locomotion reveal principles of high performance subsurface sand-swimming. Journal of The Royal Society Interface 8, 1332-1345. Matson J. (2010). Unfree Spirit: NASA’s Mars rover appears stuck for good. Scientific American, 302, 16. Mazouchova, N., Gravish, N., Savu, A. and Goldman, D. I. (2010). Utilization of granular solidification during terrestrial locomotion of hatchling sea turtles. Biology letters 6, 398–401. McGowan, C. P., Skinner, J. and Biewener, A. A. (2008). Hind limb scaling of kangaroos and wallabies (superfamily Macropodoidea): Implications for hopping performance, safety factor and elastic savings. Journal of Anatomy 212, 153–163. Moritz, C. T. and Farley, C. T. (2003). Human hopping on damped surfaces: Strategies for adjusting leg mechanics. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 270, 1741– 1746. Mosauer, W. (1932). Adaptive convergence in the sand reptiles of the Sahara and of California: A study in structure and behavior. Copeia 1932, 72–78. Nedderman, R. M. (1992). Statics and Kinematics of Granular Materials. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Pfeifer, R., Lungarella, M. and Iida, F. (2007). Self-organization, embodiment, and biologically inspired robotics. Science 318, 1088–1093. 846 847 848 849 850 851 852 853 854 855 856 857 858 859 860 861 862 863 864 865 866 867 868 869 870 871 872 873 29 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Qian F., Zhang T., Li C., Masarati, P., Hoover A.M., Birkmeyer P., Pullin A., Fearing R.S. and Goldman D.I. (2012). Walking and running on yielding and fluidizing ground. Robotics: Science and Systems (in press). Roberts, T. J., Marsh, R. L., Weyand, P. G. and Taylor, C. R. (1997). Muscular force in running turkeys: The economy of minimizing work. Science 275, 1113–1115. Rubenson, J., Lloyd, D. G., Heliams, D. B., Besier, T. F. and Fournier, P. A. (2011). Adaptations for economical bipedal running: The effect of limb structure on three-dimensional joint mechanics. Journal of The Royal Society Interface 8, 740–755. Russell, A. P. (1993). The aponeuroses of the lacertilian ankle. Journal of Morphology 218, 65– 84. Schmitt, J., Garcia, M., Razo, R. C., Holmes, P. and Full, R. J. (2002). Dynamics and stability of legged locomotion in the horizontal plane: A test case using insects. Biological Cybernetics 86, 343–353. Sharpe, S. S., Ding, Y., and Goldman, D. I. (2012). Environmental interaction influences muscle activation strategy during sand-swimming in the sandfish lizard (Scincus scincus). The Journal of Experimental Biology 216, 260–274. Spagna, J. C., Goldman, D. I., Lin, P.-C., Koditschek, D. E. and Full, R. J. (2007). Distributed mechanical feedback in arthropods and robots simplifies control of rapid running on challenging terrain. Bioinspiration & Biomimetics 2, 9–18. Spence, A. J., Revzen, S., Seipel, J., Mullens, C. and Full, R. J. (2010). Insects running on elastic surfaces. The Journal of Experimental Biology 213, 1907–1920. Sponberg, S. and Full, R. J. (2008). Neuromechanical response of musculo-skeletal structures in cockroaches during rapid running on rough terrain. The Journal of Experimental Biology 211, 433–446. Vitt, L. J. and Ohmart, R. D. (1977). Ecology and reproduction of lower Colorado River lizards: I. Callisaurus draconoides (Iguanidae). Herpetologica 33, 214–222. Vogel, S. (1996). Life in Moving Fluids: The Physical Biology of Flow. Princeton: Princeton University Press. 874 875 876 877 878 879 880 881 882 883 884 885 886 887 888 889 890 891 892 893 894 895 896 897 898 899 900 901 30 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Weiss, P. L., Hunter, I. W. and Kearney, R. E. (1988). Human ankle joint stiffness over the full range of muscle activation levels. Journal of Biomechanics 21, 539–544. Zamparo, P., Perini, R., Orizio, C., Sacher, M. and Ferretti, G. (1992). The energy cost of walking or running on sand. European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology 65, 183–187. 902 903 904 905 906 907 908 31 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 909 910 911 912 913 914 Fig. 1. Model organism and three-dimensional kinematics experiments. (A) A zebra-tailed lizard resting on sand in the wild (photo: Thomas C. Brennan). (B) Experimental setup for three- dimensional kinematics capture, with definitions of pelvis height (zpelvis), knee height (zknee), trunk pitch angle (pitch), and knee angle (knee). Colored dots in (A,B) are digitized points on the midline of the trunk, hind leg, and elongate hind foot. 32 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 915 916 917 918 919 920 921 Fig. 2. Experiments to measure hind limb resilience and granular penetration force. (A) Experimental setup for hind limb resilience measurements. Dashed foot tracing shows the relaxed, straight foot right before touchdown. Solid foot tracing shows the hyperextended foot during ground contact. F, ground reaction force; 0, angle between the ankle and the digit tip in the relaxed, straight foot; t, angle between the ankle and the digit tip in the hyperextended foot; , torque about the ankle. (B) Experimental setup for granular penetration force measurements. 33 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 922 923 924 925 926 927 Fig. 3. Lateral views of representative runs on the solid (AD) and the granular (FI) surface (see Movies 1, 2 in supplementary material). (E,J) Closer views of foot posture at touchdown showing definition of touchdown foot angle touchdown. Solid lines and curves along the foot indicate hind foot posture and shape. Note that the lateral camera was oriented at an angle to the x, y, z axes such that forward (+x) direction appeared to point slightly downwards. 34 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 928 929 930 931 932 933 Fig. 4. Performance and gait on the solid (red) and the granular (blue) surfaces. (A) Average forward speed vs. stride frequency. (B) Duty factor vs. average forward speed. Different symbols represent different individuals. Filled symbols are from the seven representative runs for each of the seven individuals tested on both substrates. Empty symbols are from runs that were not included in the representative data set. 35 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 934 935 936 937 Fig. 5. Center of mass (CoM) kinematics (mean ± s.d.) vs. time during a stride on the solid (red) and the granular (blue) surfaces. (A) Footstep pattern. (B) CoM forward speed. (C) CoM vertical position. (D) CoM lateral position. See Fig. 1 for definitions of kinematic variables. 36 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 938 939 940 941 942 Fig. 6. Hind foot, hind leg, and trunk kinematics (mean ± s.d.) vs. time during a stride on the solid (red) and the granular (blue) surfaces. (A) Touchdown foot angle. (B) Knee height. (C) Pelvis height. (D) Knee angle. (E) Trunk pitch angle. See Fig. 1 and Fig. 3E,J for definitions of kinematic variables. 37 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 943 944 945 946 947 948 Fig. 7. Anatomy and a strut-spring model of the hind limb. (A) Ventral anatomy of a dissected hind limb. Lower hind leg muscles are marked in blue; foot tendons are marked in red. (B) A two-dimensional model of the hind limb. The muscle strut models isometrically contracting lower leg muscles; the tendon spring models foot tendons. The radii of colored circles correspond to measured joint radii. 38 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 Fig. 8. Hind limb resilience. (AC) Representative passive work loops of the hind foot (measured at the digit tip) from each of the three anesthetized lizards tested. Different curves are from different trials. The area within a work loop is the energy lost within the foot. See Fig. 2A for schematic of experimental setup. (DF) Hind limb resilience vs. maximal torque, maximal angular displacement, and average loading rate. Different symbols are from different individuals. Solid and dashed lines in (DF) denote mean ± s.d. 949 950 951 952 953 954 955 956 957 39 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 958 959 960 961 962 963 964 965 966 967 968 969 Fig. 9. Foot-ground interaction on the solid surface. (AD) The hind foot shape from the lateral view of a representative run on the solid surface. (AD) correspond with (AD) in Fig. 3. The hind foot shape in the dorsal view is similar because the sprawl angle of the foot plane is nearly constant during stance. The diagram in (B) defines the radius of curvature  of the foot (see Appendix). (E) Foot curvature (solid) and tendon spring deformation (dashed) (mean ± s.d.) vs. time during a stride on the solid surface. Tendon spring deformation is not meaningful during swing (dotted) when the muscle strut assumption does not hold. (F) Mechanical energies of the CoM and elastic energies of the foot (mean ± s.d.) on the solid surface. All energies are normalized to the mechanical energy of the CoM at touchdown (Etouchdown) for each run. indicates that Emid-stance is significantly different from Etouchdown and Eaerial (P < 0.05, ANOVA, Tukey HSD). 40 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 970 971 972 973 Fig. 10. Granular penetration force (mean ± s.d.) vs. depth on two plates of different areas: A1 = 7.6 × 2.5 cm2 and A2 = 3.8 × 2.5 cm2. See Fig. 2B for schematic of experimental setup. Dashed lines are linear fits to the data over steady state during penetration using Eqn. (1). 974 41 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 975 976 977 978 979 980 981 982 983 984 985 986 Fig. 11. Foot-ground interaction on the granular surface. (A) CoM vertical speed (mean ± s.d.) vs. time during a stride. Solid curve is from experiment. Dashed curve is calculated from the vertical acceleration from the model. (B) Vertical acceleration vs. time during a stride calculated from the total vertical ground reaction force Fz on both feet and the animal weight mg. Solid and dashed curves are the Fz on the two alternating hind feet. (C) Hypothesized subsurface foot rotation in the sagittal plane. (FI) correspond with (FI) in Fig. 3. foot, foot angle in the vertical plane. (D) Mechanical energy of the CoM and the energy loss to the substrate (mean ± s.d.) during running on the granular surface. All energies are normalized to the mechanical energy of the CoM at touchdown (Etouchdown) for each run. * indicates that Emid-stance is significantly different from Etouchdown and Eaerial (P < 0.05, ANOVA, Tukey HSD). 42 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 987 988 Table 1. Morphological measurements (mean ± s.d.) of the seven individuals tested in the 3-D kinematics experiments. SVL (cm) Mass m (g) Trunk length (cm) Pelvic width (cm) Hind limb length (cm) Hind foot length (cm) Femur length (cm) Tibia length (cm) Tarsals and metatarsals length (cm) Fourth toe length (cm) 7.2 ± 0.6 11.0 ± 2.7 4.4 ± 0.4 1.4 ± 0.1 6.4 ± 0.1 2.7 ± 0.1 1.6 ± 0.2 2.1 ± 0.2 1.0 ± 0.1 1.7 ± 0.1 989 43 990 991 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 F 0.4784 9.9101 0.5032 8.9112 5.4690 Table 2. Gait and kinematic variables (mean ± s.d.) and statistics using an ANCOVA. P values reported are for substrate effect. †Average forward speed v(cid:3364)x,CoM (m/s) Variable Average CoM height (cid:1878) CoM (cm) Stride frequency f (Hz) Duty factor D Stride length  (m) Magnitude of CoM vertical oscillations zCoM (cm) Lowest CoM height zCoM (cm) Time of lowest CoM height (T) Highest CoM height zCoM (cm) Average pelvis height pelvis (cid:1878) pelvis (cm) Time of highest CoM height (T) Average trunk pitch angle (cid:3364) pitch (deg) Magnitude of CoM lateral oscillations yCoM (cm) Touchdown knee height zknee (cm) Lowest knee height zknee (cm) Knee vertical displacement during stance zknee (cm) Touchdown knee angle knee (deg) Lowest knee angle knee (deg) Highest knee angle knee (deg) Knee joint extension during stance knee (deg) ‡Average leg sprawl angle during stance sprawl (deg) Touchdown foot angle touchdown (deg) Granular Solid 1.1 ± 0.3 1.2 ± 0.3 7.5 ± 1.6 8.1 ± 2.0 0.46 ± 0.05 0.45 ± 0.07 0.16 ± 0.02 0.14 ± 0.02 2.2 ± 0.5 3.2 ± 0.7 0.3 ± 0.2 0.4 ± 0.3 3.0 ± 0.7 2.0 ± 0.4 0.18 ± 0.04 0.19 ± 0.04 3.3 ± 0.7 2.4 ± 0.6 0.44 ± 0.04 0.48 ± 0.01 0.86 ± 0.19 0.94 ± 0.23 3.1 ± 0.7 1.9 ± 0.5 9 ± 2 1 ± 3 1.7 ± 0.6 2.7 ± 0.7 1.8 ± 0.5 0.7 ± 0.4 1.1 ± 0.4 0.9 ± 0.2 88 ± 25 90 ± 13 79 ± 10 79 ± 17 150 ± 8 116 ± 15 37 ± 13 71 ± 4 3.7031 7.7544 0.9696 3.6126 3.0642 0.2350 8.8912 19.5282 6.7157 15.4261 0.7128 1.2344 1.3175 17.568 18.0994 P 0.5023 0.0319 0.5480 0.0409 0.0203 0.4697 0.0115 0.6366 0.0447 0.0325 0.5263 0.0046 0.0002 0.0171 0.0006 0.3056 0.6713 0.7549 0.0001 0.0001 N/A 0.0032 40 ± 1 12 ± 4 38 ± 5 4 ± 3 N/A 7.6973 992 All significant differences (P < 0.05) are in bold. Degree of freedom is (2,11) for all variables. 993 † An ANOVA was used to test the effect of substrate on running speed. 994 995 996 997 ‡ A direct comparison was not possible for sprawl between substrates because sprawl was measured differently: on the solid surface, leg orientation was measured from the hip to the digit tip; on the granular surface, leg orientation was measured from the hip to the ankle. 44 Li et al. (2012), The Journal of Experimental Biology, 215, 3293–3308. doi:10.1242/jeb.061937 998 999 Table 3. Normalized energetic variables (mean ± s.d.). All energies were normalized to Etouchdown for each run and averaged over 7 representative runs on each substrate. Variable Mechanical energy at touchdown Etouchdown Mechanical energy at mid-stance Emid-stance Mechanical energy during aerial phase Eaerial Mechanical energy reduction Emech Elastic energy storage at mid-stance Estorage Elastic energy return Ereturn Energy loss to substrate Esubstrate Muscle mechanical work Wmuscle Solid 1.00 ± 0.00 0.81 ± 0.08* 0.95 ± 0.10 0.19 ± 0.08 0.18 ± 0.13 0.08 ± 0.06 N/A 0.11 ± 0.10 Granular 1.00 ± 0.00 0.86 ± 0.09* 0.99 ± 0.10 0.14 ± 0.09 N/A N/A 0.17 ± 0.05 0.31 ± 0.10 1000 1001 * indicates significant difference (P < 0.05) in the mechanical energy of the CoM at mid-stance from that at touchdown and during aerial phase. 45
1806.04273	1	1806	2018-06-12T00:07:38	Angiogenic Factors produced by Hypoxic Cells are a leading driver of Anastomoses in Sprouting Angiogenesis---a computational study	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.TO" ]	Angiogenesis - the growth of new blood vessels from a pre-existing vasculature - is key in both physiological processes and on several pathological scenarios such as cancer progression or diabetic retinopathy. For the new vascular networks to be functional, it is required that the growing sprouts merge either with an existing functional mature vessel or with another growing sprout. This process is called anastomosis. We present a systematic 2D and 3D computational study of vessel growth in a tissue to address the capability of angiogenic factor gradients to drive anastomosis formation. We consider that these growth factors are produced only by tissue cells in hypoxia, i.e. until nearby vessels merge and become capable of carrying blood and irrigating their vicinity. We demonstrate that this increased production of angiogenic factors by hypoxic cells is able to promote vessel anastomoses events in both 2D and 3D. The simulations also verify that the morphology of these networks has an increased resilience toward variations in the endothelial cell's proliferation and chemotactic response. The distribution of tissue cell`s and the concentration of the growth factors they produce are the major factors in determining the final morphology of the network.	physics.bio-ph	physics	OPEN Received: 16 May 2017 Accepted: 29 May 2018 Published: xx xx xxxx Angiogenic Factors produced by Hypoxic Cells are a leading driver of Anastomoses in Sprouting Angiogenesis–a computational study Maurício Moreira-Soares 1, Rita Coimbra2, Luís Rebelo3, João Carvalho1 & Rui D. M. Travasso1 Angiogenesis - the growth of new blood vessels from a pre-existing vasculature - is key in both physiological processes and on several pathological scenarios such as cancer progression or diabetic retinopathy. For the new vascular networks to be functional, it is required that the growing sprouts merge either with an existing functional mature vessel or with another growing sprout. This process is called anastomosis. We present a systematic 2D and 3D computational study of vessel growth in a tissue to address the capability of angiogenic factor gradients to drive anastomosis formation. We consider that these growth factors are produced only by tissue cells in hypoxia, i.e. until nearby vessels merge and become capable of carrying blood and irrigating their vicinity. We demonstrate that this increased production of angiogenic factors by hypoxic cells is able to promote vessel anastomoses events in both 2D and 3D. The simulations also verify that the morphology of these networks has an increased resilience toward variations in the endothelial cell's proliferation and chemotactic response. The distribution of tissue cells and the concentration of the growth factors they produce are the major factors in determining the final morphology of the network. Sprouting angiogenesis–a process by which new blood vessels grow from existing ones–is an ubiquitous phe- nomenon in health and disease of higher organisms1, playing a crucial role in organogenesis, wound healing2, inflammation3, as well as on the onset and progression of over 50 different diseases4 such as cancer5–7, rheumatoid arthritis8 and diabetes9. This process leads to the formation of neo-vessel networks that irrigate tumors and other hypoxic tissues. In the circumstances in which these neo-vessel networks are functional, they present a ramified hierarchical tree-like structure at large scale, as observed in various tissues (from the mesenteric arteries, to the retina)10–14, while at microvascular scale the capillaries form a lattice-like network connecting the arterial and venous vascular trees10,14, as seen in reconstructed mouse vascular networks in ref.15 and used in a tumor model in ref.16. To achieve this complex structure, the sprouting process involves different steps that are carefully regulated. When tissue cells are in hypoxia, the Hypoxia Inducible Factor 1 α (HIF-1 α) accumulates and is translocated to the cells' nucleus, where it works as a transcription factor for several genes encoding for proteins that take part in preparing the cell's response to hypoxia (see review17 and also the mathematical models applied to inflam- mation and cancer in refs18,19). The Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor (VEGF) is one of these proteins and is necessary and sufficient to trigger angiogenesis. The VEGF secreted by hypoxic cells diffuses in the tissue, forming well defined spatial concentration gradients. VEGF is present in different isoforms with different binding capacity to the extracellular matrix (ECM) components20,21 (the specific shape of the gradient depends also on this bind- ing ability to ECM components)22. At a nearby vessel, VEGF promotes the loosening of the adhesion between vessel cells and triggers the activation of an endothelial cell (EC) that acquires the endothelial tip cell phenotype, as modeled in23. This cell leads a new sprout and migrates in the direction of increasing VEGF concentration, 1CFisUC, Department of Physics, University of Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal. 2Institute for Research in Biomedicine (iBiMED), Department of Medical Sciences, University of Aveiro, Aveiro, Portugal. 3Department of Physics, Faculty of Sciences, University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to M.M.-S. (email: [email protected]) or R.D.M.T. (email: [email protected]) 1 SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8www.nature.com/scientificreportsas observed in in vivo mice retinas in ref.24. The tip cell state promotes the activation of the endothelial stalk cell phenotype in the cells that follow its lead, as shown in ref.25, a research paper on the mouse retina. Proliferation of the sprout stalk cells is triggered by both VEGF and the tension exerted by the tip cell, as predicted in a phase field model in ref.26. In the new growing sprout the cells behind the tip cell are able to take its place, acquire the tip cell phenotype for some tens of minutes, and drive sprout elongation, as displayed in studies in vitro and in vivo of tip-stalk cells dynamics in mouse retinal vessels27,28. This dynamic behavior ensures that there is always a cell at the front of the sprout with the tip phenotype capable of exerting a contractile force on the matrix, degrading and remodeling matrix fibres and opening a pathway for the sprout to grow. As the sprouts grow, ECs are able to either alter their shape or to extend and align vacuole in order to grow a lumen connected to the initial vessel that is capable of carrying blood29,30, as shown in angiogenesis in vitro in ref.31, in vivo in ref.32 and used in modeling in ref.33. However, in order for the blood to flow, it is required a pressure gradient along the vessel, which is only achieved after the growing sprout merges either with an exist- ing functional mature vessel or with another growing sprout that is in turn connected to an existing functional mature vessel. The process by which sprouts meet and merge is called anastomosis, studied in mouse models in34,35 and also discussed in the review36. Though a pivotal step in angiogenesis, the mechanisms that drive vessel anastomosis are not yet completely understood. In particular, there are several unanswered questions regarding how a sprout is guided in the direc- tion of other vessels in the tissue. Macrophages and microglial cells play an important role in this process in vivo, since they often sit at sites where vessels merge, stabilizing the connection between endothelial cells from different sprouts34,37, demonstrated by in vivo experiments in the mouse retina in38. However, anastomoses still occur with- out the presence of macrophages or microglial cells, though less frequently36,38. Mechanical processes play an important role in driving vessel anastomosis. In fact, when a tip cell is next to an existing vessel, its filopodia are able to sense their microenvironment, and to establish contact with either other tip cells' filopodia or with other endothelial cells24,38,39, as modeled in refs36,40. This contact is then strengthened by the VE-cadherins present in the filopodia41, the tip cell advances in the direction of the existing vessel and it attaches to it39. The slow process of merging the two lumina at this new junction then ensues. When the sprouts are at somewhat larger separations, mechanical factors are still able to play an important role in the formation of anastomoses. Take for example the situation of two tip cells meeting directly. Tip cells exert sufficient force to deform the matrix locally, and other tip cells are able to follow these deformation gradi- ents26,40,42. In this way, a tip cell is able to sense the presence of other tip cells in its vicinity and will move in their direction. However, this mechanism still functions at rather short ranges, on the order of the cell size, as shown by in vitro experiments in ref.43, and used in agent-based models in refs42,44 only in the neighborhood of a tip cell the tissue is sufficiently deformed to guide nearby tip cells. In some tissues other type of mechanical cues also drive anastomoses events at larger ranges. In the retina, for example, vessels grow above a layer of astrocytes that provide guidance and support24. In this situation, filopodia mediate the contact between the endothelial cells and the astrocytes network underneath, guiding the neo-vessels to almost replicate its structure. In this way, the astrocytes network plays an important role in driving vessel anas- tomoses in the retina. However, in tissues where there is no underlying cell network for vessels to replicate, and where they explore the space between cells, we question how the vessels can be guided toward other vessels at larger scales in order to be close enough for mechanical communication to be relevant. In this work, we will demonstrate that pro-angiogenic factors, such as VEGF, play the decisive role in the process of anastomosis and in shaping the final network. There is strong experimental data that supports this hypothesis. In sprouting angiogenesis, these factors have a pivotal role in guiding the sprouts. Namely, VEGF in matrices is able to promote migration and anastomo- ses24,45–47. So much so that VEGF micro-patterns in 3D matrices are able to guide mouse endothelial cells in vivo to form anastomoses and functional vessels along those patterns48. Moreover, VEGF micro-beads also drive the formation of functional vessels in their vicinity in vivo49,50. In a non-pathological setting, hypoxic cells in vivo will be producing VEGF until they are irrigated, and they can only be irrigated after there are anastomoses in their surroundings. Therefore VEGF will keep being produced until nearby vessels merge and form loops capable of carrying blood. We will demonstrate that this mechanism can also account for an increased resilience of the network morphology towards endothelial cell proliferation and chemotactic response. To address the capability of VEGF gradients to drive anastomoses in a neo-vessel network, we present an extensive and systematic 2D and 3D computational study of vessel formation in a tissue. The 2D model can be applied to angiogenesis in quasi two-dimensional vascular networks, such as networks in the retina, chick chorio- allantoic membrane (CAM) assays, or other in vivo membranes. On the other hand, the 3D model can be applied to angiogenesis in 3D scaffolds and in vivo tissues, as the adipose tissue, and in tumor angiogenesis. In the last two decades angiogenesis has been modelled using different approaches. Initially, researchers implemented continuous descriptions of angiogenesis that had the density of vessels as output51–56. These mod- els were not aimed at obtaining the vascular network or the blood flow rate, but to provide an indication of the advancement of the irrigated region. Angiogenesis was also modelled using more detailed discrete agent-based models that take into account the interaction between every single cell in the system57,58. Discrete models have been coupled to tumor growth models, used to describe neo-vascularisation in the retina, and to study in detail the interaction between endothelial cells and their micro-environment59–65. Nevertheless, the large number of parameters and rules often difficult the full exploration of the parameter space in these models. Recently, hybrid models that combine a continuous description of the vessel sprout with a cell-based approach for tip cell crea- tion and movement were developed22,26,66. These models allow the study of the shape of large vessel sprout net- works with a smaller number of parameters. Nevertheless the role of chemical factors in regulating anastomoses 2 www.nature.com/scientificreports/SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8Figure 1. The value of the order parameters in different domains. The order parameter ψ is +1 inside the tissue cells (represented in blue) and −1 outside, while the order parameter φ is +1 inside the endothelial cells (represented in red) and −1 in the rest of the domain. The stroma is characterized by the region where φ and ψ are both negative. The model dynamics prevents the superposition between the positive domains of the two order parameters. formation in 2D and in 3D has not yet been studied. For reviews on the literature of angiogenesis modelling see for example67–71. In the next section we will introduce the computational model used. In the Results and Discussion section we will present and compare the results of the 2D and 3D models regarding the capability of VEGF to drive anasto- moses formation. It will be stressed the role of this mechanism in determining the morphology of the vascular networks, rendering it less dependent on endothelial stalk cell proliferation rates or on the migration velocity of tip cells. Finally we draw the conclusions of the work in the last section. Methods The angiogenesis mathematical model implemented is a natural extension of the model introduced in22, and fur- ther explored in40,72–74. Here, we will review, in an abbreviated way, this mathematical model underlining the two major improvements that are introduced: the description of the cells in hypoxia using a second order parameter, and the estimation of tissue irrigation to couple it with hypoxia regulation. We model the ECs and the ECM through a phase-field formalism22,75,76, defining an order parameter, φ(r, t) that identifies the vessel network: the value for this order parameter is approximately equal to 1 inside the vessel network, and equal to −1 outside. In the present work, we introduce a second order parameter to describe the tissue cells ψ(r, t), which is equal to 1 inside these cells and −1 outside. In this way, the vessels, ECM and tissue cells can be unequivocally identified by the local values of φ and ψ (see Fig. 1). The equation for the evolution of the order parameter φ(r, t) is composed of two main terms: one describing the dynamics of the interface, and another describing the proliferation of endothelial cells (function of the angi- ogenic factor concentration, T): φ 2 ∂ = ∇ t M − − ∇ + (cid:31) (cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29) φ φ φ ε [ 3 2 2 2 ( 1) ] γ φ (cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29) (cid:28) (cid:30) 2)( 1)( − + ψ ψ 2 − Interface Dynamics + T ( ( ) ) φ φ α Θ . p (cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29) (cid:28) (cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29)(cid:29) (cid:30) (cid:31) EC Proliferation (1) The first term is directly obtained from the system's phenomenological free-energy functional (see Supplementary Information S1), which includes a surface tension term22 and an energy cost for the overlap of vessels and tissue cells77. The γ in (1) is proportional to this energy cost and is set high enough in order to avoid appreciable overlap in our simulations. In equation (1) M is the mobility coefficient, ε is the width of the capillary wall (proportional to the surface tension), and Θ(φ) is the Heaviside step function. The proliferation rate is rep- p , for T < Tp, with βp constant; T being the angiogenic factor concentration, resented by the function α T and Tp the angiogenic factor concentration for which the proliferation reaches its maximum value. For T > Tp we set αp(T) to the constant value α p p. Due to the Heaviside function, the proliferation only occurs inside T the capillary. Often hypoxic cells have a low motility, especially if they are part of an epithelial tissue. Therefore, we consider in the simulation that tissue cells are static and do not change their shape. Hence, the order parameter ψ will not be altered during simulation. Nevertheless, the simulation methods used permit to introduce motility and defor- mation on the hypoxic cells, which will be explored in future work. β=T β=T The angiogenic factor is modeled as a diffusive field T, that is consumed by the ECs with the rate αT: ( ) ) ( p p (2) The concentration of angiogenic factor is kept at a constant value Ts at the center of all active hypoxic cells. ∂ = ∇ − t During the simulation, the sources will be deactivated as the vessel network grows and as they are irrigated. α φ T ( ) φ Θ . T T 2 D T 3 www.nature.com/scientificreports/SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8Figure 2. Schematic representation of the two different rules for hypoxia regulation. In the simulation with Rule 1 a cell in hypoxia will deactivate its production of VEGF when the blood circulation reaches a site at a distance from the cell shorter than the oxygen diffusion length. In the model with Rule 2, the VEGF production will cease if any vessel reaches a point closer to the cell than the oxygen diffusion length, independently of whether there is blood circulating in that vessel or not. The endothelial cells are represented in red, the tip cells are the yellow circles and the angiogenic factor is represented in light blue. The cells in hypoxia are represented as darker blue circles. The arrows indicate the vessels with blood flow. The endothelial tip cells are represented by agents with radius Rc. A new agent is introduced whenever there is a minimum angiogenic factor concentration Tc, a minimum angiogenic factor gradient Gm, and if the tip cell can- didate is located at a distance larger than 4Rc from all other tip cells. In this way, we are able to retrieve the typical "salt and pepper" pattern of tip/stalk cells arising from the Delta-Notch signaling23,27,39. Some recent works78 have modeled the Delta-Notch signaling pathway in the context of angiogenesis also taking into account the Jagged1 ligand, which contributes to the stabilization of the ECs' phenotypes78,79, possibly influencing the tip/stalk cell pat- tern. The implementation of this more complex Delta-Jagged-Notch mechanism is out of the scope of the present work but it is expected to be introduced in future model developments. All the activated tip cells migrate by chemotaxis, and their velocity is aligned with the local angiogenic factor v GM, with χ constant, GM being the gradient mod- gradient. The tip cell velocity is given by , for ∇ <T GM the tip cell velocity reaches its maximum value ulus for which the maximum velocity is attained. For ∇ ≥T . A tip cell is not able to enter inside a tissue cell (independently if the cell is in hypoxia or not): G T/ χ ∇ ∇ M when the distance between the tip cell and a tissue cell is lower than 2Rc, the radial component of the velocity is set to zero and the tip cell moves in the azimuthal direction around the tissue cell. The value of φ inside the tip cell is set to a constant value that depends on the tip cell velocity and on the local χ= ∇T T ECs' proliferation rate22. Blood is able to flow once there are anastomoses in the vascular network. In order to estimate the irrigated regions in the tissue, we first identify the vessels where the blood is flowing. We start by extracting the medial lines of the vascular structure, thus finding the network bifurcation sites and the length of every vessel. The extraction method used for this purpose is detailed in80. Afterwards, we calculate the blood flow rate in every vessel (see Supplementary Information S1). In the simulation there is a single input node (at the top of the simulation box) and a single exit node (at the bottom of the simulation box). For more details regarding the mathematical model and for the values of all parameters please refer to the Supplementary Information S1. Cells in Hypoxia - Rules 1 and 2. With the aim of addressing the capability of VEGF to drive anastomosis formation, we compare the results of the model obtained with two alternative rules concerning the tissue angi- ogenic factor production. When the new vessels are capable of delivering oxygen to the tissue, the newly irri- gated cells deactivate their hypoxia mechanism and cease the production of angiogenic factors. Therefore several models in the literature10,14,60,81 use estimates of tissue irrigation in order to determine which cells are producing angiogenic factors. To mimic this mechanism we consider a simplified rule to identify the VEGF producing cells: Rule 1: A cell produces angiogenic factor in the model if it is located at a distance larger than the average oxy- gen diffusion length (d = 25 μm)82 from all vessels with blood flow rate different from zero (Fig. 2 left). This is the simplest rule guaranteeing that anastomoses events are required for hypoxic cell deactivation. However, many other models focus on the ability of the angiogenic factor to drive vessel growth and not anasto- moses22,40,83,84. These models implement a different rule for tissue cell deactivation: Rule 2: A cell produces angiogenic factor in the model if it is located at a distance larger than the average oxy- gen diffusion length (d = 25 μm) from all vessels (Fig. 2 right). In short, with Rule 2 chemical guidance promotes sprouting but is not associated with tissue irrigation, while in Rule 1 it is. Comparing the morphology of the networks formed under these two rules, we show how important it is for tissue irrigation to regulate VEGF production to create functional vascular networks in 2D and in 3D. The calculation of tissue irrigation is in general quite complex, being dependent on the oxygen pressure at every vessel, on vessel diameter, flow rate (function of the non-constant viscosity due to variable hematocrit and the Fahrëus-Lindqvist effect), hematocrit level (which is altered at non-symmetrical bifurcations), oxygen diffusion constant in the tissue and oxygen uptake by tissue cells85–87. However, in the present work a detailed 4 www.nature.com/scientificreports/SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8Figure 3. Vessel growth in two dimensions. Evolution of a vascular system with an initial capillary at the bottom and a random distribution of hypoxic cells (green circles), which drive the chemotactic response by ECs. Four time points are represented. The first row of figures correspond to the vessel network grown under the Rule 1 for hypoxic cell deactivation, while the second row of images correspond to the vessel network grown under Rule 2. On the final column the irrigated vessels are identified in red. The number of anastomoses and the number of vessels with circulating blood are much higher when Rule 1 is implemented. calculation of tissue irrigation will not be required, since our aim is to demonstrate that the need for anastomoses formation to stop VEGF production in tissues (as in Rule 1) will determine several characteristics of the observed vascular morphology. Rule 1 keeps the model general, with all anastomoses providing the same amount of irri- gation to the tissue. With a full calculation of tissue irrigation we would observe that the irrigation provided by each anastomosis would depend on its location within the vessel network. This systematic study of vessel density in growing vasculatures as a function of the geometry of the initial network and of the oxygen pressure is very relevant, but it is outside the scope of the present article. In this way, the final vasculatures obtained by running the simulation with Rule 1 will be directly compared to the simulations where the angiogenic factor drives growth but not anastomoses (using Rule 2). We will then draw conclusions regarding the capacity of VEGF gradients to drive vessel anastomoses. Results and Discussion Anastomoses in 2D. Similarly to the setting in22 we start with a random distribution of hypoxic cells in a simulation box of size 375 × 375 μm2. These hypoxic cells produce the angiogenic factor which diffuses slowly in the tissue. When the angiogenic factor concentration at the vessel initially located at one edge of the box is larger than Tc, a new tip cell is introduced in the simulation. This tip cell moves in the direction of the local angiogenic factor gradient forming a new sprout. Progressively, new tip cells are activated and a ramified network is produced (see Fig. 3). As the tip cells migrate in the tissue they are able to contour the hypoxic cells, diverting their move- ment direction as they approach these cells. The morphology of the obtained networks is strikingly dependent on the rule for hypoxic cell deactivation. With Rule 2, the hypoxic cells start deactivating once the vessels pass nearby, leading to an open network with fewer vessels and anastomoses. The vessels are straighter and directed towards the hypoxic tissue. As a result, only few vessels are able to carry circulating blood. On the other hand, with Rule 1, the number of branches is higher. The vessels surround several cells in hypoxia, irrigating them. The resulting vessel network morphology is more lattice-like instead of tree-like. Many more vessels carry blood flow. The observed vasculature also suggests that with Rule 1 regions with more hypoxic cells have a higher density of vessels, while regions with less cells have a lower vessel density. To verify how prevalent these differences between vessel morphology are, we carried out a systematic quanti- tative study of the morphology obtained from our simulations in 2D and 3D. To characterize the vascular trees we measure their branch density, average vessel diameter, and density of anastomoses. These descriptors were evalu- ated as a function of the two model parameters that were considered most relevant for the network evolution22,88: the maximum velocity of tip cell migration in the tissue (equal to χGM in the model, though only the value of χ is altered), and the highest stalk cell proliferation rate (equal to βpTp in the model, only the value of βp is altered). Notice that the proliferation term in the model corresponds to the increase of vessel area (or volume, in 3D) per unit time: it is a measure of the change of space occupied by the vessel per unit time22. This description is ideal to be directly compared with observations of the network evolution through diverse imaging techniques. However, since the vessels are hollow, the cell proliferation in vivo is expected to be systematically smaller than the cell pro- liferation (space increase) term in the model. Nevertheless, since the neo-vessels resulting from sprouting have all similar calibers (see for example66 for in vivo results) and since also in our simulation the neo-vessels have all approximately the width, the extra proliferation in our simulation serve simply to fill-in the lumen. Therefore, we expect that, even taking into account the vessels lumen, the progress of the network morphology as a function of the cells' proliferation rate would be the same as the one observed in our simulations. The results of this analysis are presented in Fig. 4. Each data point in these plots represents the average value from three random distributions of hypoxic cells. We start from a random distribution of hypoxic cells to avoid 5 www.nature.com/scientificreports/SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8Figure 4. Characterisation of the vascular networks in two dimensions. Comparison of the branches density (A,D), anastomoses density (B,E) and average vessels diameter (C,F), between the two rules implemented in the model, as a function of the maximum proliferation rate (top row) and as a function of the maximum tip cell velocity (bottom row). The networks were analysed after they had grown sufficiently to deactivate the VEGF production in all tissue cells. The error bars denote the error in the average of 3 simulations (for each condition). any spatial bias. For both simulations with Rules 1 and 2, as the proliferation rate is increased, the vascular net- works become more complex, with a larger number of vessels and anastomoses. With Rule 2, for very low prolif- eration rates, the number of vessels is very small and there are no anastomoses (see Fig. 4A,B). As the proliferation rate increases, the number of vessel branches increase rapidly until it reaches a high stationary number of about 700 branches per mm2. This increase in vessel branch density is accompanied by an increase in anastomoses den- sity. The average vessel diameter increases only slightly with the stalk cell proliferation rate (Fig. 4C). A similar qualitative behaviour regarding the number of vessel branches and anastomoses is observed with Rule 1. However the values of these two descriptors are considerably higher. Remarkably, the vasculature mor- phology is much more stable. In the range of proliferation explored in the simulation, we obtain an increase of approximately ten-fold in the number of branches and anastomoses when using Rule 2 for hypoxic cell deacti- vation, whereas in the simulation with Rule 1, this increase was only about two-fold. For most of the range of proliferation rates explored, the average vessel diameter did not vary when Rule 1 was implemented. Similar results were observed for variable tip cell velocity, namely, Rule 1 leads to a clear increase in the num- ber of branches and anastomoses, but at the same time, to more stable vascular networks (Fig. 4D–F). For both rules for hypoxic cell deactivation, as the tip cell velocity increases, the number of branches increases until a maximum is reached. After this maximum, the velocity of the tip cell is so high that the sprouts are initially not thick enough to accommodate tip cell activation (the vessels start being thinner than two cell radii). The activa- tion of new tip cells can then only happen after there is enough proliferation in these thin vessels. Because of the increased difficulty in tip cell activation, the number of branches decreases for high tip cell velocity. The density of anastomoses in the network follows, qualitatively, the non-monotonic behaviour of the branch density. For Rule 1 the number of branches and anastomoses are significantly higher and their relative variations with tip cell velocity are significantly smaller (for example, with Rule 1 the number of anastomoses varies only about 2-fold within the range of tip cells velocities explored, while with Rule 2 it varies about 15-fold within the same range). With respect to vessel diameter, we observe that the vessels become thinner with increasing tip cell velocity until they reach a constant value for tip cell velocities larger than the velocity where the maximum branch density is attained. Figure 4F suggests a similar change in vessel diameter with tip cell velocity with both Rules 1 and 2. We conclude that, in two dimensions, the hypoxic cell VEGF production levels can force anastomoses to be created in the system. This mechanism also renders the morphology of the vascular networks much more insensi- tive to the proliferation rate and tip cell velocity. The hypoxic cells are the main factor in determining the structure of the vasculature that will satisfy their needs. These conclusions are robust to the inclusion in the model of more realistic relations of, for example, the chemotactic response on the degree of hypoxia in the cells. To explore the effect of variable chemotactic response, we introduce a simplified dependence of χ in T, inspired in the experimental evidence that the expression levels of VEGF receptor 2 in ECs are lower in hypoxia89,90. Hence, we considered a lower chemotactic response in this case. We repeated the analysis reported in Fig. 4 with the chemotactic response as a function of the hypoxia level 6 www.nature.com/scientificreports/SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8Figure 5. Hypoxic cell distribution determine vascular network. Evolution of a vascular system with an initial capillary at the bottom and uniformly distributed hypoxic cells (green dots), sources of VEGF which drive the chemotactic response by ECs (maximum proliferation 2.8 × 10−4 s−1 and maximum tip cell velocity 0.375 μm/ min). Four time points are represented. The bottom row shows the same network growth with the vessels with blood flow in red. Figure 6. Neo-vessel morphology after 24 hours using the two rules. In the right panel (Rule 1) we mark the regions of high vessel density, on the top and bottom, where the hypoxic cells are placed, in contrast with the lower vessel density in a middle region (without hypoxic cells). With Rule 2 (left panel) the vessel density is much more uniform throughout the domain. − T ), and we did not observe any ) (we used the local VEGF concentration, T, as proxy for hypoxia, χ significant change in the observed trends (see Supplementary Information S1). χ= (1 0 To address the capability of hypoxic cell distribution to determine vascular structure, we run the two dimen- sional model with Rule 1 for a regular distribution of hypoxic cells (see Fig. 5). In this simulation we set eight par- allel rows of ten hypoxic cells with a large space between rows 4 and 5. The evolution of the system clearly shows how the neo-vascular network grows and branches in order to feed the first rows of hypoxic cells. The branching then almost stops when the capillaries cross the region without VEGF sources, going back to a very branched morphology when they reach the second domain with hypoxic cells. A late instant of the growth of this network is again depicted in Fig. 6 right, where it is evident that the density of new vessels is higher, with more branches and anastomoses in the hypoxic regions, on the top and on the bot- tom of the figure. On the region without cells in hypoxia (middle area) the branch density is lower and the num- ber of anastomoses is reduced (for example, the branch density in this middle region is 0.81 × 103 mm−2; compare to a branch density 1.8 × 103 mm−2 on the top hypoxic region of the system). Strikingly, in the corresponding network obtained from the simulation with Rule 2 (see Fig. 6 left), the hypoxic cells do not affect dramatically the vessel density, which is approximately constant throughout the simulated domain (with Rule 2 the branch density in the middle region is 0.97 × 103 mm−2, similar to a branch density 1.1 × 103 mm−2 on the top hypoxic region). Remarkably, using solely the production of chemical factors, and without including mechanical components, we are able to guide the vasculature to form anastomoses where they are required. Similarly, sources of VEGF in vivo are able to promote the anastomosis and formation of new vessels in their vicinity49,50. This result clearly agrees with what is expected in angiogenesis due to hypoxia: a higher density of new vessels in the region with more hypoxic cells. The vessel network is tailored to feed the tissue. 7 www.nature.com/scientificreports/SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8Figure 7. Vessel growth in three dimensions. Evolution of a vascular system with an initial capillary at the center and randomly distributed hypoxic cells (green spheres), sources of VEGF, which drive the ECs chemotactic response. Four time points are represented. The first row of images corresponds to the results for the model under the Rule 1, while the bottom row to Rule 2. We clearly observe a higher density of vessels in the simulation with Rule 1. We conclude that, in two dimensions, the distribution of hypoxic cells and the production rate of angiogenic factors are the main regulators of angiogenesis, not the proliferation of endothelial cells or the tip cell veloc- ity. This conclusion raises questions regarding the power to change the vessel network by the newly proposed anti-angiogenic and vessel normalization therapies that target the metabolism of endothelial cells in a way to control their proliferation or migration velocity91–94. With these therapies, and without targeting VEGF producing cells, only when these parameters are dramatically changed, the network morphology is critically altered (two caveats: first, with lower tip cell velocity the vasculature would grow at a slower rate, but the number of branches and anastomoses, when comparing networks of the same size, would not be significantly altered; second: the simulation is run with the assumption that hypoxic cells greatly decrease their VEGF production rate once they are irrigated, which does not happen, for example, in several high grade malignant tumors)4. However, the change of endothelial cell proliferation or migration rates may have an important effect in the quality of the vessel (e.g. lumen size, leakage, maturation)93. However, vessels in most cases grow in three dimensional networks. Therefore, we extend the simulations to 3D to verify to which extent the conclusions regarding VEGF driven anastomoses hold in the formation of 3D vascular networks. Anastomoses in 3D. In this subsection we are looking to verify if, like in two dimensions, the production of angiogenic factors by the hypoxic cells is able, by itself, to guide vessels to meet each other in three dimensions. We are also interested in understanding if the characteristics of endothelial cells, such as their proliferation rate and tip cell velocity, have an important role in shaping these networks in three dimensions; or if, like in two dimensions, modifications in these properties lead only to moderate changes in the vascular network. The neo-vasculature in this three dimensional model is simulated in a box of size 250 × 250 × 125 μm3, it starts from a central capillary72, and the new sprouts grow along the gradient of angiogenic factor, produced by hypoxic cells distributed randomly in the matrix (see Fig. 7). As in the two dimensional model, a vessel is able to contour a hypoxic cell it approaches. As in two dimensions, the vessel network grown with Rule 1 is clearly more dense than the vessel network obtained from the simulation with Rule 2 (see Fig. 7). At the end of the simulation with Rule 1 all the hypoxic cells were irrigated, a consequence of the large number of anastomoses present in the network. A systematic study of the density of branches, anastomoses and vessel diameter of the simulated three dimen- sional networks was also carried out (see Fig. 8). Each data point in these plots represents the average value from three random distributions of hypoxic cells. Strikingly, anastomoses are almost absent in the simulations with Rule 2, independently of the proliferation rate and tip cell velocity. This is different from what was observed in 2D, where Rule 2 was able to lead to the for- mation of a large number of anastomoses for certain values of the parameters. In three dimensions, Rule 1 leads to an increase in the branch density and to an impressive ten-fold increase in the density of anastomoses in the network. Hence the production of VEGF until the tissue is irrigated is able by itself to guide the growing sprouts toward each other, in order to form new anastomoses. We also observe differences with the two dimensional scenario regarding the dependence of the network morphology on the proliferation rate. Similarly to the two dimensional simulation, for larger endothelial cell proliferation rate, the number of branches increases. However, in 3D this increase is smoother and spans a wider range of proliferation rates. The increase on the number of branches with the proliferation rate occurs both in the simulations with Rules 1 and 2. Regarding the density of anastomoses, we observe a plateau for higher prolifer- ation rates. However, neither the number of branches nor the number of anastomoses can be said to be almost independent on the proliferation rate, as it occurred in 2D. 8 www.nature.com/scientificreports/SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8Figure 8. Characterisation of the vascular networks in three dimensions. Comparison of the branches density (A,D), anastomoses density (B,E) and average vessels diameter (C,F), between the two rules implemented on the model, as a function of the maximum proliferation rate (top row) and as a function of the maximum tip cell velocity (bottom row). The networks were analysed after they had grown sufficiently to deactivate the VEGF production in all tissue cells. The error bars denote the error in the average of 3 simulations (for each condition). On the other hand, when varying tip cell velocity, the relative change in network morphology parameters is much smaller for both Rules 1 and 2. Though for lower tip cell velocities the vessel network grows slower, and thus takes a longer time to reach the stationary state at the end of the simulation their final morphology is rather independent of the value of the maximum tip cell velocity value. The diameter of the vessels is not altered considerably neither with the increase in proliferation nor in tip cell velocity. With the increase in proliferation there are simply more vessels, rather than thicker vessels. In the case of increasing tip cell velocity, the network is rather stable, with the number of branches, anastomoses and branch diameter not varying appreciably. Conclusion In this article we presented a model of vessel sprouting that addresses the VEGF gradients' role in driving the formation of anastomoses. This important biological mechanism is fundamental to irrigate tissue cells. However, there are still several unanswered questions regarding how a sprout is guided in the direction of other vessels in the tissue. The role of mechanical cues in anastomose formation has been explored in the literature24,26,36,38–40,42,43 but it can only account for guidance at short distances between merging sprouts. In the present work we demon- strated how slowly diffusible growth factors gradients, maintained by tissue cells until they have access to suffi- cient oxygen and nutrients, are able to guide vessel sprouts toward each other at larger scales. This mechanism is particularly relevant in three dimensions, where without it the network has a reduced number of anastomoses, and it is not capable of irrigating the tissue. The role of hypoxic cells is therefore pivotal in determining the final morphology of the network. We showed that it is the location of these cells and the concentration of the growth factors they produce that better determine the number of vessels and of anastomoses in the final network. Actually, these factors are more relevant to the final morphology than the tip cell chemotactic response or the ECs' proliferation rate. Experimentally it was shown the extraordinary capacity for growth factors spatial distributions in vivo to influence sprouting48,95 and to determine the site of functional neo-vessels49. This resilience of the final network morphology toward EC's properties in 2D and in 3D (to a smaller degree) guarantees reliable vascular structures in non-pathological settings. However, it raises questions regarding the capacity for modifying the vessel network of the newly proposed vessel normalization therapies, which control EC's metabolism91,92 in tissues where cells are still able to regulate their VEGF production. With these therapies, and without targeting VEGF producing cells, the network morphology is only critically altered when the EC's proliferation rate or migration velocity are dramatically affected. In fact, in agreement with our work, it has been observed experimentally in vivo that a reduction in the EC's proliferation rate of over 50% does not significantly alterthe density of tumor vessel networks93. Moreover, to observe a dramatic change of the vasculature, one has to produce a substantial change in EC's metabolism96, leading to very low proliferation rate and migration velocity, just as predicted by our work. However, a moderate decrease in EC's proliferation is able to affect the capacity 9 www.nature.com/scientificreports/SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8of the network to irrigate the tissue due to a lower vessel leakage and an increase in lumen size91–94. However, in conditions where tissue cells produce VEGF at permanently high rates independently of the irrigation provided by the network, both the ECs' proliferation rate and the tip cell velocity are able to shape the vascular structure88. In this mathematical model, the hypoxic cells function as sites for anastomoses formation, producing angio- genic factors until vessels merge. This suggests that in vivo cells that promote anastomosis, such as macrophages and microglia34,37,38 can fulfil this role by chemical guidance (from VEGF and other chemical factors). It is also evident the relevance of targeting macrophage metabolism in anti-angiogenic therapy97. References 1. Folkman, J. Angiogenesis in cancer, vascular, rheumatoid and other disease. Nature medicine 1, 27–30 (1995). 2. Tonnesen, M. G., Feng, X. & Clark, R. A. Angiogenesis in wound healing. Journal of Investigative Dermatology Symposium Proceedings, vol. 5, pp. 40–46, Elsevier (2000). FASEB Journal 11, 457–465 (1997). 3. Jackson, J. R., Seed, M., Kircher, C., Willoughby, D. & Winkler, J. The codependence of angiogenesis and chronic inflammation. The 4. Carmeliet, P. Angiogenesis in health and disease. Nature medicine 9, 653 (2003). 5. Liao, D. & Johnson, R. S. Hypoxia: a key regulator of angiogenesis in cancer. Cancer and Metastasis Reviews 26, 281–290 (2007). 6. Fidler, I. J. Angiogenesis and cancer metastasis. Cancer journal (Sudbury, Mass.) 6, S134–41 (2000). 7. Carmeliet, P. & Jain, R. K. Angiogenesis in cancer and other diseases. Nature 407, 249–257 (2000). 8. Maruotti, N., Cantatore, F., Crivellato, E., Vacca, A. & Ribatti, D. Angiogenesis in rheumatoid arthritis. Histology and histopathology 9. Martin, A., Komada, M. R. & Sane, D. C. Abnormal angiogenesis in diabetes mellitus. Medicinal research reviews 23, 117–145 (2003). 10. Secomb, T. W., Alberding, J. P., Hsu, R., Dewhirst, M. W. & Pries, A. R. Angiogenesis: an adaptive dynamic biological patterning 11. Guibert, R., Fonta, C. & Plouraboué, F. A new approach to model confined suspensions flows in complex networks: application to problem. PLoS Comput Biol 9, e1002983 (2013). blood flow. Transport in porous media 83, 171–194 (2010). 12. Masters, B. R. Fractal analysis of the vascular tree in the human retina. Annu. Rev. Biomed. Eng. 6, 427–452 (2004). 13. Flores, J., Poiré, E. C., Del Ro, J. & de Haro, M. L. A plausible explanation for heart rates in mammals. Journal of theoretical biology (2006) 14. Gandica, Y., Schwarz, T., Oliveira, O. & Travasso, R. D. Hypoxia in vascular networks: a complex system approach to unravel the 15. Blinder, P. et al. The cortical angiome: an interconnected vascular network with noncolumnar patterns of blood flow. Nature 265, 599–603 (2010). diabetic paradox. PLoS ONE 9, e113165 (2014). neuroscience 16, 889–897 (2013). Journal of mathematical biology 58, 689 (2009). 1163–1177 (2003). e1004436 (2015). 943–953 (2010). 138, 4763–4776 (2011). 222–231 (2009). 16. Owen, M. R., Alarcón, T., Maini, P. K. & Byrne, H. M. Angiogenesis and vascular remodelling in normal and cancerous tissues. 17. Semenza, G. L. Hypoxia-inducible factors in physiology and medicine. Cell 148, 399–408 (2012). 18. Cavadas, M. A., Nguyen, L. K. & Cheong, A. Hypoxia-inducible factor (hif) network: insights from mathematical models. Cell Communication and Signaling 11, 42 (2013). 19. Nguyen, L. K. et al. A dynamic model of the hypoxia-inducible factor 1α (HIF-1α) network. J Cell Sci 126, 1454–1463 (2013). 20. Ferrara, N., Gerber, H.-P. & LeCouter, J. The biology of vegf and its receptors. Nature medicine 9, 669–676 (2003). 21. Chen, T. T. et al. Anchorage of vegf to the extracellular matrix conveys differential signaling responses to endothelial cells. The Journal of Cell Biology 188, 595–609 (2010). 22. Travasso, R. D. M., Corvera Poiré, E., Castro, M., Rodríguez-Manzaneque, J. C. & Hernández-Machado, A. Tumor angiogenesis and vascular patterning: A mathematical model. PLoS ONE 6, e19989 (2011). 23. Bentley, K., Gerhardt, H. & Bates, P. A. Agent-based simulation of notch-mediated tip cell selection in angiogenic sprout initialisation. Journal of Theoretical Biology 250, 25–36 (2008). 24. Gerhardt, H. et al. Vegf guides angiogenic sprouting utilizing endothelial tip cell filopodia. The Journal of Cell Biology 161, 25. Hellstrom, M. et al. Dll4 signalling through notch1 regulates formation of tip cells during angiogenesis. Nature 445, 776–780 (2007). 26. Santos-Oliveira, P. et al. The force at the tip - modelling tension and proliferation in sprouting angiogenesis. PLoS Comput Biol 11, 27. Jakobsson, L. et al. Endothelial cells dynamically compete for the tip cell position during angiogenic sprouting. Nat Cell Biol 12, 28. Arima, S. et al. Angiogenic morphogenesis driven by dynamic and heterogeneous collective endothelial cell movement. Development 29. Lubarsky, B. & Krasnow, M. A. Tube morphogenesis: making and shaping biological tubes. Cell 112, 19–28 (2003). 30. Iruela-Arispe, M. L. & Davis, G. E. Cellular and molecular mechanisms of vascular lumen formation. Developmental Cell 16, 31. Meyer, G. T., Matthias, L. J., Noack, L., Vadas, M. A. & Gamble, J. R. Lumen formation during angiogenesis in vitro involves phagocytic activity, formation and secretion of vacuoles, cell death, and capillary tube remodelling by different populations of endothelial cells. The Anatomical Record 249, 327–340 (1997). 32. Gebala, V., Collins, R., Geudens, I., Phng, L.-K. and Gerhardt, H. Blood flow drives lumen formation by inverse membrane blebbing 33. Boas, S. E. & Merks, R. M. Synergy of cell–cell repulsion and vacuolation in a computational model of lumen formatio. n. Journal of during angiogenesis in vivo. Nature cell biology (2016) The Royal Society Interface 11, 20131049 (2014). tip cell induction. Blood 116, 829–840 (2010). 90, 1–11 (2013). 34. Fantin, A. et al. Tissue macrophages act as cellular chaperones for vascular anastomosis downstream of vegf-mediated endothelial 35. Zhan, K., Bai, L. & Xu, J. Role of vascular endothelial progenitor cells in construction of new vascular loop. Microvascular Research 36. Geudens, I. & Gerhardt, H. Coordinating cell behaviour during blood vessel formation. Development 138, 4569–4583 (2011). 37. Baer, C., Squadrito, M. L., Iruela-Arispe, M. L. & De Palma, M. Reciprocal interactions between endothelial cells and macrophages in angiogenic vascular niches. Experimental Cell Research 319, 1626–1634 (2013). 38. Rymo, S. F. et al. A two-way communication between microglial cells and angiogenic sprouts regulates angiogenesis in aortic ring cultures. PLoS ONE 6, e15846– (2011). angiogenesis. PLoS Comput Biol 5, e1000549 (2009). Journal of The Royal Society Interface, 14 (2017) 39. Bentley, K., Mariggi, G., Gerhardt, H. & Bates, P. A. Tipping the balance: Robustness of tip cell selection, migration and fusion in 40. Vilanova, G., Colominas, I. and Gomez, H. A mathematical model of tumour angiogenesis: growth, regression and regrowth. 41. Almagro, S. et al. The motor protein myosin-x transports ve-cadherin along filopodia to allow the formation of early endothelial cell-cell contacts. Molecular and Cellular Biology 30, 1703–1717 (2010). 10 www.nature.com/scientificreports/SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8 42. van Oers, R. F. M., Rens, E. G., LaValley, D. J., Reinhart-King, C. A. & Merks, R. M. H. Mechanical cell-matrix feedback explains pairwise and collective endothelial cell behavior in vitro. PLoS Comput Biol 10, 1–14 (2014). 43. Reinhart-King, C. A., Dembo, M. & Hammer, D. A. Cell-cell mechanical communication through compliant substrates. Biophysical Journal 95, 6044–6051 (2008). 44. Ramos, J. R., Travasso, R. & Carvalho, J. Capillary network formation from dispersed endothelial cells: Influence of cell traction, cell adhesion, and extracellular matrix rigidity. Physical Review E 97, 012408 (2018). 45. Shamloo, A., Ma, N., Poo, M. M., Sohn, L. L. & Heilshorn, S. C. Endothelial cell polarization and chemotaxis in a microfluidic device. Lab on a chip 8, 1292–1299 (2008). 46. Benitez, P. & Heilshorn, S. Microfluidic devices for quantifying the role of soluble gradients in early angiogenesis. In Mechanical and Chemical Signaling in Angiogenesis (pp. 47–70). Springer Berlin Heidelberg. (2013) 47. Koch, S. et al. Enhancing angiogenesis in collagen matrices by covalent incorporation of VEGF. Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine 17, 735–741 (2006). 48. Oh, H. H., Lu, H., Kawazoe, N. & Chen, G. Spatially guided angiogenesis by three-dimensional collagen scaffolds micropatterned with vascular endothelial growth factor. Journal of Biomaterials Science 23, 2185–2195 (2012). 49. Elçin, Y. M., Dixit, V. & Gitnick, G. Extensive in vivo angiogenesis following controlled release of human vascular endothelial cell growth factor: implications for tissue engineering and wound healing. Artificial Organs 25, 558–565 (2001). 50. Tufró, A. VEGF spatially directs angiogenesis during metanephric development in vitro. Developmental Biology 227, 558–566 51. Orme, M. E. & Chaplain, M. A. J. A mathematical model of vascular tumour growth and invasion. Math Comp Model 23, 43–60 52. Orme, M. E. & Chaplain, M. A. J. Two-dimensional models of tumour angiogenesis and anti-angiogenesis strategies. Math Med Biol (2000). (1996). 14, 189–205 (1997). 53. Levine, H. A., Sleeman, B. D. & Nilsen-Hamilton, M. Mathematical modeling of the onset of capillary formation initiating angiogenesis. J Math Biol 42, 195–238 (2001). 54. Levine, H. A., Pamuk, S., Sleeman, B. D. & Nilsen-Hamilton, M. Mathematical modeling of capillary formation and development in tumor angiogenesis: penetration into the stroma. Bull Math Biol 63, 801–863 (2001). 55. Levine, H. A., Sleeman, B. D. & Nilsen-Hamilton, M. A mathematical model for the roles of pericytes and macrophages in the initiation of angiogenesis. I. The role of protease inhibitors in preventing angiogenesis. Math Biosci 168, 77–115 (2000). 56. Plank, M. J., Sleeman, B. D. & Jones, P. F. A mathematical model of tumour angiogenesis, regulated by vascular endothelial growth factor and the angiopoietins. J Theor Biol 229, 435–454 (2004). 57. Stokes, C. L. & Lauffenburger, D. A. Analysis of the roles of microvessel endothelial cell random motility and chemotaxis in angiogenesis. J Theor Biol 152, 377–403 (1991). 58. Anderson, A. R. A. & Chaplain, M. A. J. Continuous and discrete mathematical models of tumor-induced angiogenesis. Bull Math 59. Macklin, P. et al. Multiscale modelling and nonlinear simulation of vascular tumour growth. J Math Biol 58, 765–798 (2009). 60. Perfahl, H. et al. Multiscale modelling of vascular tumour growth in 3D: the roles of domain size and boundary conditions. PloS Biol 60, 857–899 (1998). ONE 6, e14790 (2011). 61. McDougall, S. R., Watson, M. G., Devlin, A. H., Mitchell, C. A. & Chaplain, M. A. J. A hybrid discrete-continuum mathematical model of pattern prediction in the developing retinal vasculature. Bull Math Biol 74, 2272–2314 (2012). 62. Bauer, A. L., Jackson, T. L. & Jiang, Y. A cell-based model exhibiting branching and anastomosis during tumor-induced angiogenesis. Biophys J 92, 3105–3121 (2007). growth. PLoS Comp Biol 4, e1000163 (2008). 63. Merks, R. M., Perryn, E. D., Shirinifard, A. & Glazier, J. A. Contact-inhibited chemotaxis in de novo and sprouting blood-vessel 64. Shirinifard, A. et al. 3D multi-cell simulation of tumor growth and angiogenesis. PLoS ONE 4, e7190 (2009). 65. Perfahl, H. et al. 3D hybrid modelling of vascular network formation. Journal of theoretical biology 414, 254–268 (2017). 66. Milde, F., Lauw, S., Koumoutsakos, P. & Iruela-Arispe, M. L. The mouse retina in 3D: quantification of vascular growth and remodeling. Integrative Biology 5, 1426–1438 (2013). 67. Travasso, R. D. M. The mechanics of blood vessel growth. In Vasculogenesis and Angiogenesis-from Embryonic Development to Regenerative Medicine. InTechOpen, Rijeka Croatia, 187–204 (2011) 68. Mantzaris, N., Webb, S. & Othmer, H. Mathematical modeling of tumor-induced angiogenesis. J Math Biol 49, 111–187 (2004). 69. Spill, F., Guerrero, P., Alarcón, T., Maini, P. K. & Byrne, H. M. Mesoscopic and continuum modelling of angiogenesis. J Math Biol 70, 485–532 (2014). 70. Quinas-Guerra, M. M., Ribeiro-Rodrigues, T. M., Rodríguez-Manzaneque, J. C., Travasso, R. D. M. Understanding the dynamics of tumor angiogenesis: A systems biology approach. in Systems Biology In Cancer Research and Drug Discovery (pp. 197–227). Springer Netherlands (2012) 71. Heck, T., Vaeyens, M. M. & Van Oosterwyck, H. Computational models of sprouting angiogenesis and cell migration: towards multiscale mechanochemical models of angiogenesis. Math Model Nat Phen 10, 108–141 (2015). 72. Guerra, M. M. D. S. Q. & Travasso, R. D. M. Novel approach to vascular network modeling in 3d. 2012 IEEE 2nd Portuguese Meeting in Bioengineering (ENBENG), Feb, pp. 1–6 (2012) 73. Vilanova, G., Colominas, I. & Gomez, H. Capillary networks in tumor angiogenesis: From discrete endothelial cells to phase-field averaged descriptions via isogeometric analysis. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Biomedical Engineering 29, 1015–1037 (2013). 74. Vilanova, G., Colominas, I. & Gomez, H. Coupling of discrete random walks and continuous modeling for three-dimensional tumor-induced angiogenesis. Computational Mechanics 53, 449–464 (2014). 75. Emmerich, H. Advances of and by phase-field modelling in condensed-matter physics. Advances in Physics 57, 1–87 (2008). 76. Travasso, R. D. M., Castro, M. & Oliveira, J. C. R. E. The phase-field model in tumor growth. Philosophical Magazine 91, 183–206 77. Nonomura, M. Study on multicellular systems using a phase field model. PLoS ONE 7, e33501 (2012). 78. Boareto, M., Jolly, M. K., Ben-Jacob, E. & Onuchic, J. N. Jagged mediates differences in normal and tumor angiogenesis by affecting tip-stalk fate decision. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 112, E3836–E3844 (2015). 79. Benedito, R. et al. The notch ligands Dll4 and Jagged1 have opposing effects on angiogenesis. Cell 137, 1124–1135 (2009). 80. Palágyi, K. & Kuba, A. A 3D 6-subiteration thinning algorithm for extracting medial lines. Pattern Recognition Letters 19, 613–627 (2011). (1998). 81. Vavourakis, V. et al. A validated multiscale in-silico model for mechano-sensitive tumour angiogenesis and growth. PLoS Comput 82. Grote, J. Tissue respiration. Human physiology, pp. 508–520, Springer (1983) 83. Maggelakis, S. & Savakis, A. A mathematical model of growth factor induced capillary growth in the retina. Mathematical and Biol 13, e1005259 (2017). computer modelling 24, 33–41 (1996). 84. Aubert, M., Chaplain, M. A., McDougall, S., Devlin, A. & Mitchell, C. A continuum mathematical model of the developing murine retinal vasculature. Bulletin of mathematical biology 73, 2430–2451 (2011). 85. Popel, A. S. Theory of oxygen transport to tissue. Critical reviews in biomedical engineering 17, 257–321 (1988). 11 www.nature.com/scientificreports/SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8 86. Secomb, T. W., Hsu, R., Park, E. Y. & Dewhirst, M. W. Green's function methods for analysis of oxygen delivery to tissue by microvascular network. s. Annals of biomedical engineering 32, 1519–1529 (2004). 87. Goldman, D. Theoretical models of microvascular oxygen transport to tissue. Microcirculation 15, 795–811 (2008). 88. Norton, K.-A. & Popel, A. S. Effects of endothelial cell proliferation and migration rates in a computational model of sprouting angiogenesis. Scientific Reports 6, 36992 (2016). 89. Ulyatt, C., Walker, J. & Ponnambalam, S. Hypoxia differentially regulates VEGFR1 and VEGFR2 levels and alters intracellular signaling and cell migration in endothelial cells. Biochemical and biophysical research communications 404, 774–779 (2011). 90. Nevo, O., Lee, D. K. & Caniggia, I. Attenuation of VEGFR-2 expression by sFlt-1 and low oxygen in human placenta. PloS one 8, e81176 (2013). 91. Treps, L., Conradi, L.-C., Harjes, U. & Carmeliet, P. Manipulating angiogenesis by targeting endothelial metabolism: Hitting the engine rather than the drivers–a new perspective? Pharmacological Reviews 68, 872–887 (2016). 92. Cantelmo, A. R., Pircher, A., Kalucka, J. & Carmeliet, P. Vessel pruning or healing: endothelial metabolism as a novel target? Expert Opinion on Therapeutic Targets 21, 239–247 (2017). 93. Cantelmo, A. R. et al. Inhibition of the glycolytic activator PFKFB3 in endothelium induces tumor vessel normalization, impairs metastasis, and improves chemotherapy. Cancer Cell 30, 968–985 (2016). 94. Schoors, S. et al. Partial and transient reduction of glycolysis by PFKFB3 blockade reduces pathological angiogenesis. Cell metabolism 19, 37–48 (2014). 95. Ruhrberg, C. et al. Spatially restricted patterning cues provided by heparin-binding VEGF-A control blood vessel branching morphogenesis. Genes & Development 16, 2684–2698 (2002). 96. Conradi, L. C. et al. Tumor vessel disintegration by maximum tolerable PFKFB3 blockade. Angiogenesis 20, 599–613 (2017). 97. Wenes, M. et al. Macrophage Metabolism Controls Tumor Blood Vessel Morphogenesis and Metastasis. Cell Metabolism 24, 701–715 (2016). Acknowledgements The authors thank fruitful discussions with Lino Ferreira and Paulo Matafome. The simulations were done in the Navigator cluster of the University of Coimbra. This work was funded by FEDER funds through the Operational Programme Competitiveness Factors - COMPETE and by national funds by FCT - Foundation for Science and Technology under the strategic project UID/FIS/04564/2016 (M.M.S., J.C., R.D.M.T.). M.M.S. acknowledges the support of the National Council of Technological and Scientific Development (CNPq) under the grant 235101/2014-1. RT acknowledges FCT's support through the FCT Researcher Program. Author Contributions M.M.-S., J.C. and R.D.M.T. conceived the study; M.M.-S. and R.D.M.T. wrote the code; M.M.-S., R.C. and L.R. run the simulations; M.M.-S., J.C. and R.D.M.T. wrote the manuscript. Additional Information Supplementary information accompanies this paper at https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8. Competing Interests: The authors declare no competing interests. Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Cre- ative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons license and your intended use is not per- mitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. © The Author(s) 2018 12 www.nature.com/scientificreports/SCIEnTIFIC REPORTS (2018) 8:8726 DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-27034-8
1109.1155	3	1109	2011-11-14T16:57:07	Crowding of molecular motors determines microtubule depolymerization	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.stat-mech", "q-bio.SC" ]	Assembly and disassembly dynamics of microtubules (MTs) is tightly controlled by MT associated proteins. Here, we investigate how plus-end-directed depolymerases of the kinesin-8 family regulate MT depolymerization dynamics. Employing an individual-based model, we reproduce experimental findings. Moreover, crowding is identified as the key regulatory mechanism of depolymerization dynamics. Our analysis gives two qualitatively distinct regimes. For motor densities above a particular threshold, a macroscopic traffic jam emerges at the plus-end and the MT dynamics become independent of the motor concentration. Below this threshold, microscopic traffic jams at the tip arise which cancel out the effect of the depolymerization kinetics such that the depolymerization speed is solely determined by the motor density. Because this density changes over the MT length, length-dependent regulation is possible. Remarkably, motor cooperativity does not affect the depolymerization speed but only the end-residence time of depolymerases.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Crowding of molecular motors determines microtubule depolymerization Louis Reese1 Anna Melbinger2 Erwin Frey3 Arnold Sommerfeld Center for Theoretical Physics and Center for NanoScience, Department of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Theresienstrasse 37, D-80333 Munich, Germany October 31, 2018 1Email: [email protected] 2Email: [email protected] 3Corresponding author. Email: [email protected] Abstract Assembly and disassembly dynamics of microtubules (MTs) is tightly controlled by MT associated proteins. Here, we investigate how plus-end-directed depolymerases of the kinesin-8 family regulate MT depolymerization dynamics. Employing an individual-based model, we reproduce experimental findings. Moreover, crowding is identified as the key regulatory mechanism of depolymerization dynamics. Our analysis gives two qualitatively distinct regimes. For motor densities above a par- ticular threshold, a macroscopic traffic jam emerges at the plus-end and the MT dynamics become independent of the motor concentration. Below this threshold, microscopic traffic jams at the tip arise which cancel out the effect of the de- polymerization kinetics such that the depolymerization speed is solely determined by the motor density. Because this density changes over the MT length, length- dependent regulation is possible. Remarkably, motor cooperativity does not affect the depolymerization speed but only the end-residence time of depolymerases. Key words: kinesin-8; length-regulation; microtubule dynamics; traffic jam; particle exclusion; driven transport INTRODUCTION Microtubules (MTs) are cytoskeletal filaments that serve a central role in intra- cellular organization (1, 2) and several cellular processes including mitosis (3, 4), cytokinesis (5) and intracellular transport (6). They can cope with this multitude of diverse tasks because they are highly dynamic structures which continually as- semble and disassemble through the addition and removal of tubulin heterodimers at their ends. GTP-hydrolysis is the energy source which drives switching between persistent states of growth and shrinkage, a stochastic process termed dynamic in- stability (7 -- 10). Each cellular process employs a specific set of MT-associated proteins (MAPs) to tightly regulate the rates of growth and shrinkage as well as the rate of transition between these states (11 -- 13). Depolymerases from the kinesin-8 and kinesin-13 protein families (e.g., Kip3p and MCAK, respectively) are important regulators of MT dynamics. They are thought to promote switching of MTs from growth to shrinkage (catastrophes) (12). Whereas MCAK lacks directed motility and diffuses along MTs (14), Kip3p is a highly processive plus-end-directed motor (15, 16). Proteins from the kinesin-8 family are important for regulating MT dynamics in diverse organisms. Kif18A is a key component in chromosome positioning in mammalian cells (17 -- 19) where it regulates plus-end dynamics. Its orthologs, the plus-end directed motors Kip3p in budding yeast (16) and Klp5/6 in fission yeast (20 -- 22), show depolymerizing activity. A notable feature shared by these MT plus-end depolymerases is that they depolymerize longer MTs more rapidly than they do shorter ones (15, 17, 21, 23). A similar length-dependent regulation of MT assembly by kinesin-5 motors was observed in in vivo studies of chromosome congression in budding yeast (24). The key experimental observations from in vitro studies of Kip3p (23) are that 1), the end-residence time of Kip3p at the tip depends on the bulk concentration of Kip3p and correlates inversely with the macroscopic depolymerization speed; and 2), the macroscopic depolymerization rate is directly proportional to the flux of Kip3p towards the MT plus-end. It is thought that length-dependent depolymerization kinetics serves several purposes (2). For example, positioning of the nucleus at the cell center during interphase is achieved by growing MTs that push against the cell poles while re- maining attached to the nucleus. A higher rate of catastrophes for longer MTs implies that shorter MTs have an increased contact time with the cell poles. Com- puter simulations show that this leads to a higher efficiency of nuclear positioning during interphase (25). There is convincing experimental evidence that molecular traffic along MTs strongly affects MT depolymerization dynamics. However, in vitro experiments can not yet fully explore the underlying traffic dynamics. Theoretical investigations employing individual-based models can be instrumental in furthering a mechanistic 2 understanding of this process. Fortunately, these models can be constructed on the basis of substantial quantitative data available from in vitro experiments (15, 23) characterizing the binding kinetics and the motor activity of plus-end-directed motors. Therefore we sought to identify the molecular mechanisms underlying the observed correlation between depolymerization dynamics and molecular traffic along MTs. In this study, we constructed an individual-based model for the coupled dynam- ics of MT depolymerization and molecular traffic of plus-end-directed motors. This model quantitatively reproduces previous experimental results (15, 23). Moreover, we make precise quantitative predictions for the density profiles of molecular mo- tors on the MT and demonstrate that molecular crowding and ensuing traffic jams regulate the depolymerization dynamics. We find two qualitatively distinct regimes of depolymerization dynamics: At low bulk concentrations of depolymerases, the depolymerization speed of MTs is density-limited and is a function of the bulk concentration and average motor speed alone. There is a sharp threshold in bulk depolymerase concentration above which macroscopic traffic jams emerge and the depolymerization speed is simply given by the microscopic depolymerization rate. Of note, none of these features are affected by the degree of cooperativity in the depolymerization kinetics. In contrast, the end-residence time of a depolymerase (i.e., the typical time it spends at the plus-end) is strongly correlated with coop- erativity. We outline how these predictions from our theoretical analysis can be tested experimentally. RESULTS Model definition We use an individual-based model, as illustrated in Fig. 1, to describe the dy- namics of plus-end-directed depolymerases. Motor proteins, present at a constant bulk concentration c, are assumed to randomly bind to and unbind from the MT lattice with rates ωa and ωd, respectively. Bound motors are described as Pois- son steppers (A more detailed biochemical model for motors on microtubules has to await further experimental analysis. One of the different possible schemes has recently been studied by Klumpp et al. (26).) that processively walk along individ- ual protofilaments towards the plus-end at an average speed v (27). These motors hinder each other sterically because individual binding sites i = 1, . . . , L on each protofilament can either be empty (ni = 0) or occupied by a single motor (ni = 1). Because switching between protofilaments is rare (27), transport along each of the protofilaments can be taken as independent, and the model becomes effec- tively one-dimensional (28) (Fig. 1B). Models of this type were recently discussed 3 FIGURE 1: Illustration of MT and motor dynamics. Molecular motors present at concentration c randomly attach to unoccupied tubulin dimers along the MT lat- tice with rate ωa. While bound they processively move toward the plus-end at rate ν, and unbind with rate ωd. Because motors do not switch lanes (protofilaments), the MT lattice (A) becomes effectively one-dimensional (B). Each lattice site ni (with i = 1, . . . , L numbering the sites) may be empty (ni = 0) or occupied by a single motor (ni = 1). At the plus-end the motors act as depolymerases (indicated by scissors) either alone with rate δ0 or cooperatively with rate δ1. as minimal models for intracellular transport (29 -- 32). In its given formulation, where the cytosol is considered as a homogeneous and constant reservoir of motors, it is equivalent to a driven lattice gas model known as the totally asymmetric sim- ple exclusion process with Langmuir kinetics (TASEP/LK) (29). A central finding of this model is that the interplay between on-off (Langmuir) kinetics and directed transport along protofilaments can result in "traffic jams" in which the density pro- file of motors along a protofilament shows a sharp increase from a low-density to a crowded high-density regime (29, 31). Such and other crowding effects (33, 34) are important for a molecular understanding of MT dynamics. Previous theoretical studies on this topic largely disregarded crowding effects or considered parame- ter regimes in which they are unimportant (35 -- 37). Depolymerization, including crowding effects, has also been investigated for diffusive depolymerases such as MCAK (38). 4 ωdδ0δ1ABνccωanon-cooperativecooperativeAt the plus-end of the system we consider depolymerization dynamics arising due to the interaction of molecular motors with the MT tip. Motivated by recent experiments (23), we assume non-processive depolymerization, i.e, a molecular motor dissociates from the lattice after triggering depolymerization. Because the molecular mechanisms are not yet fully resolved, we study two scenarios of de- polymerization (see Fig. 1B). In the noncooperative scenario, the dissociation rate depends only on whether the last site is occupied by a motor. If the last site is oc- cupied, nL = 1, the MT depolymerizes at rate δ0. However, recent single molecule studies indicate that Kip3p may act cooperatively (23), which we consider as our second scenario. After arriving at the plus-end, the motor is observed to pause and depolymerize a tubulin dimer only after a second Kip3p has arrived behind it. In this scenario, a tubulin dimer is depolymerized with rate δ1 if both the last and the second-to-last sites are occupied, nL−1 = nL = 1. Therefore, the total depolymerization rate can be written as: ∆ = δ0nL + δ1nL−1nL . (1) For stabilized MTs, the spontaneous depolymerization rate is small (23) and thus is not considered here. The relative magnitude of the noncooperative rate δ0 and the cooperative rate δ1 determines the degree of cooperativity of the depolymerization kinetics. In an average over many realizations of the stochastic process (ensemble average), the depolymerization speed Vdepol depends on the occupation of the last two binding sites by depolymerases (Fig. 1B): Vdepol = (δ0ρ+ + δ1κ+) a , (2) where a is the lattice spacing. Here ρ+ := (cid:104)nL(cid:105) is the probability that the last site is occupied (i.e., the expected motor density at the plus-end), and κ+ := (cid:104)nL−1nL(cid:105) denotes the probability that both the last and second-to-last sites are occupied. We analyzed this model via stochastic simulations and analytic calculations (for further details, see the Supporting Material). Validation of the model and its parameters The model parameters are, as far as they are available, fixed by experimental data. The motor speed, v, the motor run length, (cid:96), and motor association rate, ωa, were measured previously (23): v = 3.2 µm min−1 , ωa = 24 nM−1min−1µm−1 , (cid:96) ≈ 11 µm . 5 Using an MT lattice spacing of a = 8.4 nm, we derive the corresponding parameters in our model as follows: The motor speed v corresponds to 6.35 lattice sites per second, i.e., a hopping rate of ν = v/a = 6.35 s−1. The inverse hopping rate τ := ν−1 = 0.16 s and the size a of a tubulin dimer serve as our basic timescale and length scale, respectively. Then, the measured association rate corresponds to a rate ωa ≈ 5.3 × 10−4 nM−1site−1 τ−1. The dissociation rate, ωd = v/(cid:96), is derived as the ratio of the mean motor speed, v, and the mean motor run-length, (cid:96). The latter equals 1310 lattice sites. Thus, the dissociation rate is expressed as ωd ≈ 7.6 × 10−4 site−1 τ−1. In contrast to the transport behavior on the MT, the parameters concerning the depolymerization rates, δ0/1, cannot be directly extracted from experiments. However, there is evidence for a depolymerization rate as high as the motor speed, v (15, 23). As a starting point for the following discussion we tentatively take δ0 = ν. Using the above set of parameters we now phenomenologically compare the results from numerical simulations of our model with observations from experi- ments. Specifically, we consider kymographs of the MT, which show how the MT length and the motor density on the MT evolve over time. For the simulation data shown in Fig. 2 we consider an MT consisting of 14 independent protofilaments and investigate the dynamics for the noncooperative scenario and a range of motor concentrations, c = 1.2, 1.8, 2.6 nM, cf. Fig. 2A-C. Surprisingly, as shown later, neither the cooperativity of the motors nor a decrease in the depolymerization rates led to different shapes of kymographs (see also Fig. S1). We find an initial time period in which, starting from an empty MT lattice, the motors first fill up the lattice (39, 40). This is followed by a time window in which the motor den- sity exhibits a quasi-stationary profile, i.e., the density at a certain distance from the minus-end does not change except for boundary effects induced by the plus- end. The corresponding density profiles are illustrated in Fig. 2E and discussed in more detail in the following section. In this quasi-stationary regime, the de- polymerization dynamics shows qualitatively different behavior depending on the concentration of free motor molecules: At low concentration, c < 1.4 nM, and thus low density of motors on the MT, depolymerization slows down gradually in the course of time (Fig. 2A). When the motor concentration increases to larger values, c > 1.4 nM, an intermediate regime emerges in which the depolymerization speed stays roughly constant (Fig. 2B and C). Remarkably, we find that during this regime, the depolymerization speed is directly proportional to the motor density, Vdepol(L) = ρ−(L)v (Fig. 2D). At a third stage in the depolymerization process, there is a rather abrupt change in the depolymerization speed right where the density profile shows a steep drop (Fig. 2C-E). After we have elaborated more on the theoretical model, we discuss why there is such a tight correlation between the depolymerization dynamics and the density profile. 6 FIGURE 2: Validation of the theoretical model. (A)-(C) Time-space plots of stochastic simulations for a range of motor concentrations and depolymerization rate δ0 = 6.35 sites s−1. The density of molecular motors is shown as the bright area (green), and the MT is shown as the dim area (red; for details, see Supporting Material). For low concentrations, c < 1.4 nM, depolymerization slows down grad- ually (23). At higher concentrations, c > 1.4 nM, there is a rather abrupt change in MT shortening. This change is correlated with a steep decrease in the motor den- sity (DW), indicated as dotted lines. (D) The depolymerization speed, Vdepol, as a function of the length of the MT L(t), extracted from the simulation data shown in the kymograph (gray). The position of the DW (dotted), and the predicted depolymerization speed, Vdepol = vρ(L) (see also Eq. 10), using the linear approxi- mation for the motor density profile (black) and the density profile extracted from stochastic simulations (green), coincide very well with the observed depolymer- ization speed; v = 6.35 sites s−1 is the walking speed of the motors. (E) Density profiles at the minus-end from stochastic simulations (lines with symbols), exact solutions (solid) and linearized theory (dotted) are shown. (F) As a function of the motor concentration, c, and the distance from the minus-end, there are dis- tinct types of density profiles. At motor concentration lower than c = 1.4 nM (thin black), the density of motors along the MT is low and the profile is smooth. The Langmuir density is reached continuously after a certain MT length (dashed, numerical). At high concentrations, c > 1.4 nM there are two regions along the MT separated by an intervening DW (black, exact; see Supporting Material): an approximately linear antenna profile and a flat profile (Langmuir density). Linear approximations for the continuous and the discontinuous transitions (Eq. 4) are shown as well (gray). Thin lines refer to the density profiles shown in E. 7 ABCDEFAntenna ProfileLangmuir DensityDomain WallContinuousTransition(Wedge)All of these qualitative features of MT dynamics are identical to those found ex- perimentally (15, 23), and suggest that the density profile and, in particular, traffic jams formed on the MT lattice are the main determinants of the depolymerization dynamics. Moreover, the time scales of the dynamics agree quantitatively well with experimental results for the same motor concentrations (15, 23). This vali- dates our theoretical model because up to the depolymerization rate δ, all of the model parameters were derived from experimental data (23). Density profiles at the minus-end (bulk density) The above observations strongly point toward a tight correlation between the de- polymerization speed and the motor density profile at the minus end, ρ−(x), which we henceforth call the bulk (motor) density. The quasi-stationary bulk density pro- files shown in Fig. 2E were obtained by assuming very long lattices; effects caused by the plus-end are not visible in the vicinity of the minus-end. A more detailed discussion of these simulations can be found in the Supporting Material. Since this bulk density will play an important role in the following analysis, we summarize its features as obtained from analytical calculations detailed in the Supporting Material. At the minus-end, the density profiles show an initial linear increase. This is an "antenna effect" (15) as illustrated in Fig. 3A. Motors that attach in proximity of the MT minus-end immediately move toward the plus-end, thereby generating an approximately linearly increasing accumulation of motors. The slope is given by K/(cid:96), where K = c ωa/ωd denotes the binding constant. At sufficiently large distances from the minus-end, the density profile becomes flat and dominated by Langmuir kinetics with the ensuing Langmuir density: ρLa = K 1 + K = c ωa c ωa + ωd . (3) The full density profile is obtained by concatenating the antenna profile and the flat Langmuir profile such that the motor current is continuous along the MT. We find two qualitatively distinct scenarios (Fig. 2E). For low concentrations of molecular motors, c, the antenna profile matches the asymptotic Langmuir density continuously, resulting in a wedge-like profile. In contrast, above a certain thresh- old value for the concentration, determined by the binding constant K− c = 1, the two profiles can no longer be matched continuously and the density profile displays a sharp discontinuity, also termed a "domain wall" (DW) (29). In other words, if the Langmuir density rises above a critical value of ρc La = 0.5, a crowding-induced traffic jam will result (41) (Fig. 3A). The density profiles obtained from the an- alytic calculations and the stochastic simulations agree nicely, as illustrated in 8 FIGURE 3: Illustration of the antenna and crowding regimes, and of cooperativity. (A) Starting from an empty MT, motors start to accumulate on the MT lattice by attachment and subsequent transport to the plus-end. The combined effect of Langmuir kinetics and steric exclusion between the motors leads to two sharply separated regimes. Starting from the minus-end, the motor density increases lin- early (antenna profile). At a certain critical length (cid:96)−, a macroscopic traffic jam arises because particles hinder each other and crowding dominates the MT density. (B) Illustration of non-cooperative (B, nc) and fully cooperative (C, fc) depoly- merization kinetics. With regard to the the depolymerization speed, both models are effectively equal (see main text). Fig. 2E. In particular, the theoretical analysis gives an explicit expression for the width of the antenna-like profile: (cid:40) 1 (cid:96)− ≈ (cid:96) 1+K 1 K(1+K) for K < 1 , for K > 1 . (4) This result reduces to the average run length of molecular motors, (cid:96) = v/ωd, in the limit of very low binding constant, K (cid:28) 1, where crowding effects can be neglected (37). However, with increasing K the regime with an antenna-like profile becomes significantly shorter than (cid:96) (Fig. 2F). 9 BCCrowdingAntennaTransportMinus-EndPlus-End−A(Langmuir)Depolymerization dynamics is independent of cooperativity We now address how the cooperativity of the depolymerization kinetics affects the macroscopic depolymerization speed. There are two limiting cases: noncooperative depolymerization (nc) with (δ0, δ1) = (δ, 0), and fully cooperative depolymeriza- tion (fc) with (δ0, δ1) = (0, δ) (for an illustration, see Fig. 3, B and C). Remarkably, we find from our stochastic simulations, shown in Fig. 4, that there is no difference in depolymerization speed for these two limiting cases. Even when the depolymer- ization dynamics contains cooperative as well as noncooperative terms, we do not find any significant differences in the depolymerization speed (Fig. 4B). This observation from our stochastic simulations can be explained by the follow- ing molecular mechanism: Consider a model with fully cooperative depolymeriza- tion kinetics. Then, after the first motor has arrived at the plus-end, the terminal site of the MT will remain occupied from that time on. Depolymerization only occurs if another motor arrives at the second-to-last site. In other words, while the last site remains occupied, the second-to-last site triggers the depolymerization. Hence, as far as the depolymerization speed is concerned, the fully cooperative model is identical to a noncooperative model with the same molecular rate δ. In the noncooperative model the terminal tubulin dimer is removed at rate δ once a molecular motor has arrived at the last site (see Fig. 3B). In the fully cooperative model, the terminal tubulin dimer is removed once a molecular motor has arrived at the second-to-last site next to a permanently occupied last site (Fig. 3C). Depolymerization dynamics is strongly affected by crowding To gain further insights in the correlation between the depolymerization speed and the density of motors on the MT, we performed stochastic simulations focusing on the MT plus-end by regarding the dynamics in a co-moving frame. Instead of simulating the full-length MT with an antenna profile and a subsequent flat Langmuir density, we considered a reduced model in which the density at the left end is set equal to the Langmuir density ρLa. For long MTs, the Langmuir density is always reached, so that the reduced system is fully equivalent to the original model. Our simulations show two clearly distinct regimes of depolymerization dynamics (Fig. 4): For small microscopic depolymerization rates, δτ < ρLa, the depolymerization speed is rate-limited: Vdepol = aδ. In contrast, for rates δτ > ρLa, the depolymerization speed is density-limited, and the Langmuir density is the limiting factor: Vdepol = ρLav. The boundary between the two regimes is remarkably sharp and given by ρ∗ La = δτ . (5) This implies that the depolymerization speed can switch between being density- limited and rate-limited by changing the concentration c or the values of the bio- 10 chemical rates of depolymerases binding to and unbinding from the MT lattice. Overall, the depolymerization speed obeys a scaling law Vdepol = ρLav V(δτ /ρLa) = aδ ρLav for δτ ≤ ρLa for δτ > ρLa , (6) (cid:40) where V(x) is a universal scaling function with the simple form V(x) = x for x < 1 and V(x) = 1 for x > 1. Experimentally, this implies that one should find data collapse upon using such a scaling plot (Fig. 4A). To gain a molecular understanding of these remarkable features of the depoly- merization speed, one needs to have a closer look at the density profile of the molecular motors at the MT tip. If the depolymerization rate is small, δ < ν, motors leave the tip more slowly than they arrive. Therefore, the MT tip acts as a bottleneck for molecular transport that disturbs the density profiles either locally or macroscopically. A weak bottleneck induces a local perturbation ("spike") (33). These spikes are sharp changes of the density profile with a typical extension that scales with the size of a heterodimer. However, if the strength of a bottleneck exceeds a threshold value, the spike extends to a macroscopic perturbation ("traffic jam") (33). Fig. 5A illustrates how, for a given Langmuir density, ρLa = 2/3, the effect on the density profile changes from a spike (blue) to an extended traffic jam (red and green) when the depolymerization rate is δ. Let us now analyze the conditions and consequences of such bottlenecks in more detail. Suppose we are in a parameter regime where the plus-end disturbs the density profile only locally, i.e., on the scale of a heterodimer. Then, we may take the bulk density to be equal to the Langmuir density, ρLa, up to the last site (the plus-end) where it jumps to some higher or lower value ρ+. The particle loss current at the plus-end due to MT depolymerization is then given by Jdepol = (1 − ρLa)ρ+δ . (7) The factor 1 − ρLa arises because the particle number decreases only if a particle depolymerizes the MT and the second-to-last site, L−1, is unoccupied. Otherwise, depolymerization dynamics and the associated frame shift of the MT lattice do not change the occupation of the last site. This particle loss has to be balanced by the incoming particle flux, JLa = ρLa(1 − ρLa)ν . (8) Equating these particle fluxes (Eqs. 7 and 8) implies the following condition for the motor density at the plus-end: for ρLa ≤ δτ for ρLa > δτ ρLa/δτ 1 (cid:40) (9) ρ+ = , 11 FIGURE 4: Scaling plot for the depolymerization speed Vdepol. (A) Upon rescaling, both the macroscopic depolymerization speed, Vdepol, and the microscopic depoly- merization rate, δ, with the Langmuir density, ρLa, all data collapse onto one uni- versal scaling function V (solid gray). A sharp transition at δτ = ρ∗ La distinguishes the rate-limited regime from the density-limited regime. (B) Comparison of co- operative and noncooperative depolymerization, with the macroscopic depolymer- ization speed Vdepol as a function of Langmuir density ρLa. For δ := δ0 + δ1 = 0.7 ν different degrees of cooperativity are displayed as indicated in the graph. 12 ABFIGURE 5: Density profiles at the plus-end, corresponding phase diagram, and depolymerization scenarios. (A) Density profiles at the MT plus-end in the co- moving frame for c = 2.9 nM, and δ = 0.1, 0.3 (left), 0.35, 0.5 (middle) and 0.8 ν (right). The simulation results and analytical solutions (black; see Supporting Ma- terial) agree nicely. (B) Depending on the value of δ and the density of motors, ρLa, there are three different classes of density profiles at the plus-end: wedge-like (diamonds), traffic jams with a DW (square), and spikes (circles). The transition between profiles with an extended traffic jam and a localized spike (solid line) also marks a qualitative change in the depolymerization speed. Whereas the depoly- merization speed is density-limited in the spike regime, it is rate-limited in the DW and wedge regime. Symbols correspond to parameters as displayed in panel A. (C) Depending on the value of δ and the density of motors, ρLa, there are three different regimes of depolymerization dynamics. In regime α depolymerization is density-limited for arbitrary MT length. In contrast, depolymerization is rate- limited for long MTs and density limited for short MTs in the regimes β and γ. For details, see the main text. 13 CABwhere the fact that the motor density is bounded ρ+ ≤ 1 is already accounted for. The particle density on the last site, in turn, determines the depolymerization speed. For ρLa < δτ, one obtains according to Eq. 2 and Eq. 9: Vdepol = ρ+ δa = ρLav . (10) Remarkably, here the effect of the depolymerization kinetics (δ) cancels out such that the macroscopic depolymerization speed is independent of the molecular de- tails of depolymerization kinetics and solely determined by the Langmuir density, i.e., the motor density in the bulk, ρ−(x), and not at the tip of the MT. This result crucially depends on the presence of a microscopic spike. It explains the hitherto puzzling experimental result that the depolymerization speed is directly proportional to the bulk motor current along the MT (23) (Fig. S2). Because the density is bounded, ρ+ ≤ 1, density profiles with a spike are only possible if the densities are not too large, ρLa < δτ. This is the case for the blue curve in Fig. 5A. For densities exceeding the critical density, ρ∗ La = δτ, the bottleneck-induced perturbation in the density profile can no longer remain a local spike, but has to become macroscopic in extent (33) (see green and red curves in Fig. 5A and Supporting Material). One finds that over an extended region, the binding sites at the plus-end then remain permanently occupied such that ρ+ = 1. This immediately implies that the depolymerization speed becomes density-independent and proportional to the microscopic depolymerization rate: Vdepol = aδ . (11) There is a tight correlation between the shape of the density profiles and the macroscopic depolymerization speed. The analytic results explain the molecular mechanism behind the numerically observed scaling law (Eq. 6), with a sharp transition from density-regulated to a rate-limited depolymerization dynamics at a critical value of ρ∗ La = δτ (cf. the classification of density profiles and depoly- merization regimes shown in Fig. 5B). Actually, the above calculations can be generalized to the regime in which the motor density exhibits an antenna-like linear profile, i.e., for MT length shorter than (cid:96)−. As detailed in the Supporting Material, we find that the depolymerization speed is rate-limited, Vdepol = aδ, if MTs are shorter than (cid:96)− but still longer than a second threshold length: (cid:96)d := δa/cωa = (cid:96) δτ /K . (12) In contrast, for (cid:96)d > (cid:96)−, the depolymerization speed in the antenna regime is always length-dependent and strictly follows the shape of the antenna profile, ρ−(x): Vdepol = ρ−(L)v . (13) 14 Using Eq. 4, the condition (cid:96)d > (cid:96)− on the threshold lengths is equivalent to δτ > ρLa for K < 1 and to δτ > 1 − ρLa for K > 1. Combining all of the above results, we find three mechanisms governing de- polymerization dynamics, as illustrated in Fig. 5C: (α) For δτ > ρLa, the depolymerization speed is always density-regulated and given by Vdepol(L) = ρ−(L)v, where L is the time-dependent length of the MT. In this parameter regime, the depolymerization speed is a direct map of the bulk motor density profile on the MT, ρ−(x), a feature that can be exploited experimentally to measure the profile. (β) For ρLa > δτ > 1 − ρLa, the depolymerization speed is rate-limited for MTs longer than (cid:96)−, and becomes density-limited as soon as the MT length falls below (cid:96)− where the density profile is antenna-like. This implies that there is a discontinuous jump in the depolymerization speed right at L = (cid:96)−. (γ) Finally, for all other values for δτ, the depolymerization speed of the MT re- mains rate-limited for lengths larger than a threshold length (cid:96)d. At (cid:96)d, which is smaller than (cid:96)− in this parameter regime, there is again a discontinuous jump to a density-limited depolymerization dynamics. If the depolymerization rate is larger or equal to the hopping rate of molecular motors, δτ ≥ 1, then δτ > ρLa is always obeyed simply because ρLa ≤ 1. In this regime, all of the molecular details of the depolymerization kinetics are irrelevant. Neither cooperativity nor the actual value of the depolymerization rate matters in terms of the depolymerization speed; instead, only the bulk density regulates the speed. Note that this was the case for the data shown in Fig. 2, where we tentatively made the parameter choice δτ = 1. If the motors are faster than the depolymerization process, δτ < 1, we have to distinguish between the parameter regimes (α,β, and γ, Fig. 5C). Here the value of the depolymerization rate matters if the bulk density exceeds a certain threshold concentration, ρLa > δτ, and the MTs are long enough. Finally, the depolymerization speed always becomes density- dependent and hence length-dependent if the MT length is short enough; the corresponding threshold length is (cid:96)reg = min[(cid:96)−, (cid:96)d]. End-residence time strongly depends on cooperativity In contrast to the depolymerization speed, the mean end-residence time τres is strongly affected by the degree of cooperativity. Fig. 6 displays τres as obtained from our stochastic simulations for noncooperative and fully cooperative depoly- merization kinetics. Our simulations show that the end-residence time for the fully cooperative model is identical to the average lifetime of a terminal tubulin dimer 15 τ fc res = τd := a/Vdepol (Fig. 6A). Even for the noncooperative model, τ nc res equals τd for large residence times and deviates from it only at small values. The relatively sharp transition to a constant lifetime of the terminal tubulin dimer occurs right at τ nc res = τ /ρLa, i.e., the end-residence time equals the waiting time for a molecu- lar motor to arrive at the MT tip. For τ nc res < τ /ρLa, the lifetime of the terminal tubulin dimer is identical to the arrival time (Fig. 6,A and B). Once the arrival time becomes shorter than the inverse depolymerization rate, the end-residence time levels off at τ nc res = 1/δ. These results show that the dependence of the end- residence time on density can be used to quantify the degree of cooperativity. This would require experiments with motor densities on the MT larger than those studied up to now (15, 23). The observation that the depolymerization speed is independent of the degree of cooperativity seems to be at odds with the experimental finding that the end- residence time, τres, of Kip3p depends on the total Kip3p concentration and is inversely proportional to the macroscopic depolymerization speed (23). Actually, however, there is no contradiction and the findings are readily explained within our theoretical model: For a noncooperative model, τ nc res is simply given by the depolymerization rate, because after they arrive, the particles stay at the tip until they depolymerize the MT: τ nc res = 1 δ . (14) + 1 δ ρLa (cid:19) For a fully cooperative model, τ fc res depends not only on δ, but also on the rate at which the second-to-last site becomes populated. Say the probability for the second-to-last site to be occupied is ρ+. Then, τ fc res is given by a sum of two contributions arising from the cases in which the second-to-last site is empty or occupied, respectively: res = (1 − ρ+) τ fc (15) If-the-second to last site is empty (which is the case with probability 1 − ρ+) τres is the sum of arrival time τ /ρLa and depolymerization time 1/δ. Otherwise, the end-residence time τres simply equals 1/δ. (cid:18) τ As shown in the previous section, two distinct scenarios arise: For small bulk densities such that ρLa < δτ, the density profile at the plus-end exhibits a micro- scopic spike with ρ+ = ρLa/δτ. For large densities, ρLa > δτ, a macroscopic traffic jam emerges such that ρ+ = 1. This result obtained for the motor density at the MT tip (Eq. 9) may now be used to calculate τ fc res using Eq. 15: 1 δ . + ρ+ (cid:40) 1 δ τ ρLa τ fc res = for ρLa > δτ , else . 16 (16) FIGURE 6: Motor end-residence times τres for cooperative and noncooperative depolymerization. (A) Mean end-residence time τres plotted against the mean depolymerization time τd. Data were recorded for a range of depolymerization rates δ = 0.02 . . . 2 ν. Noncooperative (shaded) and cooperative (black) dynamics are shown for different densities. (B) Mean end-residence time τres as a function of the Langmuir density ρLa for various depolymerization rates (in units of ν). For noncooperative depolymerization, τres is given by 1/δ (shaded lines). For the fully cooperative scenario (symbols), τres depends on whether the system is in the density-limited (δτ > ρLa) or in the rate-limited (δτ < ρLa) regime. While, for δτ > ρLa, the end-residence time is given by τres = τ /ρLa (solid gray line), for δτ < ρLa, it is density-independent and determined by the microscopic depolymer- ization rate τres = 1/δ (see also Eq. 16). 17 ABThis agrees well with the results from stochastic simulations displayed in Fig. 6. A comparison with Eq. 6 shows that the end-residence time equals the typical depoly- merization time, i.e., the expected lifetime of a terminal tubulin dimer, τ fc res = τd. This is in agreement with experimental findings regarding the unbinding-rate of motors at the plus-end (23) and strongly supports the conclusion that depoly- merization of MTs by Kip3p is fully cooperative. Varga et al. (23) measured the end-residence time of motors on double stabilized MTs, i.e., where depolymer- ization is switched off. They observed that the end-residence time is inversely correlated with the concentration of Kip3p, and fit their data with an exponential using a cut-off. This is in accordance with our results shown in Fig. 6B. However, since depolymerization has been switched off in the experiment, the rate δ, corre- sponding to the cutoff, now has to be interpreted as an unbinding-rate of motors at the plus-end. It would be highly interesting to design experiments where the depolymerization kinetics remains switched on, because this would allow one to measure the magnitude of the microscopic depolymerization rate δ. DISCUSSION In this work, we have analyzed the effect of crowding and cooperativity on the depolymerization dynamics of microtubules. To that end, we constructed an individual-based model for the coupled dynamics of plus-end directed motor traffic and microtubule depolymerization kinetics. The model is based on well-established molecular properties of motors from the kinesin-8 family, i.e., the motors move on single protofilaments with high processivity at an average speed v, and exchange of motors between the bulk and the microtubule follows Langmuir kinetics. All parameters of the model, including the average walking speed, run length, and at- tachment rate, were directly extracted from available in vitro data (23). We have validated our model by reproducing the onset of length-dependent depolymeriza- tion as studied recently (15, 23). Without using any additional fitting parameter, we found the same regimes of density profiles and ensuing depolymerization dy- namics as in the experiments, i.e., a linear antenna-profile with a length-dependent depolymerization speed and a flat profile with a constant depolymerization speed. Moreover, we identified a threshold density of motors above which a crowding- induced traffic jam emerges at the minus-end. The predicted shape and extent of these traffic jams should be amenable to experiments that raise the depolymerase concentration c or changing its rates of binding to and unbinding from the MT. The interplay between motor traffic and depolymerization kinetics at the mi- crotubule plus-end leads to strong correlations between the depolymerization dy- namics and density profiles of depolymerases. The plus-end acts as a bottleneck and crowding effects cause traffic jams. We find two qualitatively distinct regimes: 18 Motor densities below a critical threshold value, ρ∗ La = δτ, always show a local spike-like perturbation at the plus-end, the extent of which is the size of a het- erodimer. Above this threshold density, macroscopic traffic jams may emerge. These distinct density profiles at the plus-end affect the depolymerization speed and the end-residence time in qualitatively different ways. A quantitative analy- sis of the model using stochastic simulations as well as analytical calculations led to the following main results: The end-residence time of a depolymerase strongly depends on the degree of cooperativity. Whereas for noncooperative depolymeriza- tion kinetics the end-residence time is given by the microscopic depolymerization rate δ, it is density-dependent in the fully cooperative case: Increasing the Lang- muir density above the threshold value ρ∗ La = δτ, the end-residence time changes from being inversely proportional to the density ρLa to a constant value δ−1. These results suggest an interesting way to determine the cooperativity of depolymeriza- tion kinetics and measure the value of the depolymerization rate δ. Although when the concentration c is increased, the end-residence time should be independent of concentration for noncooperative kinetics, it should strongly depend on concen- tration in the cooperative case. Experimental evidence points toward the latter (23). In contrast, the depolymerization speed does not depend on the degree of coop- erativity of the depolymerization kinetics. Noncooperative and fully cooperative versions of the model give identical results. As a function of depolymerase concen- tration and the MT length, the depolymerization dynamics exhibits two qualita- tively distinct regimes: The depolymerization speed is either density-limited and determined by the bulk density of molecular motors, ρ−(x), or rate-limited and dictated by the value of the microscopic depolymerization rate, δ. Both regimes emerge due to crowding of molecular motors at the plus-end which acts as a bot- tleneck for molecular traffic. Density-limited regimes are correlated with microscopic traffic jams ("spikes") at the plus-end: The density profile self-organizes into a shape that cancels out all the effects of the depolymerization kinetics such that the depolymerization speed is solely determined by the bulk motor density, ρ−(x), and the average motor speed, v. Note that only in this regime length-dependent regulation is possible since the density changes over the MT length. As emphasized above, if the depolymerization rate δ is larger than the hopping rate of the molecular motors, δ > ν, this remains the only regime of depolymerization dynamics. Then, the depolymerization speed is limited by the velocity of the plus-end directed motors, which is in accordance with recent experimental findings for Kip3p (23). In a parameter regime where motors depolymerize more slowly than they walk, δ < ν, there is a second rate- limited regime above the threshold density ρ∗ La and for microtubules longer than some threshold length (cid:96)reg where Vdepol = aδ. In this regime the plus-end acts 19 as a strong bottleneck for molecular traffic. This causes a macroscopic traffic jam such that the motor density steeply rises to full occupation of all lattice sites at the plus-end of the microtubule. The cellular system sacrifices its capability to regulate the speed of depolymerization and only regains it once the MT length falls below (cid:96)reg, where the depolymerization speed again becomes density-regulated. From an evolutionary perspective one might speculate that the system has evolved towards δ = ν, because this would allow regulation of the depolymerization dynamics over the broadest possible range. Beyond these observations, other predictions of our stochastic model can be put to test in experiments. By varying the motor concentration, two interest- ing observations could be made: First the phase diagram for the density profiles at the minus-end could be scrutinized experimentally. Second, the predictions on the density-profiles at the plus-end and their predicted strong correlations to the macroscopic depolymerization dynamics might be accessible to single-molecule studies. Manipulation of the molecular properties of the motor (e.g., the run length, attachment rate (42), average speed and depolymerization rate) would change the intrinsic biochemical rates of the system and potentially lead to new parameter regimes. In addition, our results regarding length- and concentration dependence of the depolymerization process might be relevant in vivo, e.g., for mitotic chromosome alignment (18). In our theoretical studies we explored the full parameter range, and therefore clear predictions are available for comparison. We believe that in a more general context, our theoretical work provides new conceptual insights into the role of collective and cooperative effects in micro- tubule assembly and disassembly dynamics. Future research could focus on the antagonism between polymerases and depolymerases (12, 43, 44), spontaneous MT dynamics mediated by GTP-hydrolysis, the abundance of molecular motors in a cell, or more-detailed modeling of molecular motors (26). This may finally lead to a molecular understanding of the regulatory mechanisms of cellular processes in which MT dynamics plays a central role. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank Cécile Leduc for discussions, the authors of (23) for kindly providing their data, Ulrich Gerland, Günther Woehlke and Jonas Cremer for critical reading of the original manuscript, Anton Winkler for helpful suggestions on the revised manuscript and Andrej Vilfan for drawing Fig. 1A. This project was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft in the framework of the SFB 863 and the German Excellence Initiative via the program "Nanosystems Initiative Munich" (NIM). 20 References [1] Hayles, J., and P. Nurse. 2001. A journey into space. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 2:647 -- 656. [2] Tolić-Nørrelykke, I. M. 2010. Force and length regulation in the microtubule cytoskeleton: lessons from fission yeast. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 22:21 -- 28. [3] Sharp, D., G. Rogers, and J. Scholey. 2000. Microtubule motors in mitosis. Nature. 407:41 -- 47. [4] Karsenti, E., and I. Vernos. 2001. Cell cycle - the mitotic spindle: A self-made machine. Science. 294:543 -- 547. [5] Eggert, U. S., T. J. Mitchison, and C. M. Field. 2006. Animal cytokinesis: From parts list to mechanisms. Annu. Rev. Biochem. 75:543 -- 566. [6] Hirokawa, N., Y. Noda, Y. Tanaka, and S. Niwa. 2009. Cytoskeletal motors: Kinesin superfamily motor proteins and intracellular transport. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 10:682 -- 696. [7] Mitchison, T., and M. Kirschner. 1984. Dynamic instability of microtubule growth. Nature. 312:237 -- 242. [8] Dogterom, M., and S. Leibler. 1993. Physical aspects of the growth and regulation of microtubule structures. Phys. Rev. Lett. 70:1347 -- 1350. [9] Desai, A., and T. Mitchison. 1997. Microtubule polymerization dynamics. Annu. Rev. Cell Dev. Biol. 13:83 -- 117. [10] Howard, J., and A. Hyman. 2003. Dynamics and mechanics of the microtubule plus end. Nature. 422:753 -- 758. [11] Wordeman, L. 2005. Microtubule-depolymerizing kinesins. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 17:82 -- 88. [12] Howard, J., and A. A. Hyman. 2007. Microtubule polymerases and depoly- merases. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 19:31 -- 35. [13] Howard, J., and A. A. Hyman. 2009. Growth, fluctuation and switching at microtubule plus ends. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 10:569 -- 574. [14] Helenius, J., G. Brouhard, Y. Kalaidzidis, S. Diez, and J. Howard. 2006. The depolymerizing kinesin MCAK uses lattice diffusion to rapidly target microtubule ends. Nature. 441:115 -- 119. 21 [15] Varga, V., J. Helenius, K. Tanaka, A. A. Hyman, T. U. Tanaka, and J. Howard. 2006. Yeast kinesin-8 depolymerizes microtubules in a length- dependent manner. Nat. Cell Biol. 8:957 -- 962. [16] Gupta, M. L., P. Carvalho, D. M. Roof, and D. Pellman. 2006. Plus end- specific depolymerase activity of Kip3, a kinesin-8 protein, explains its role in positioning the yeast mitotic spindle. Nat. Cell Biol. 8:913 -- 923. [17] Mayr, M. I., S. Hümmer, J. Bormann, T. Grüner, S. Adio, G. Woehlke, and T. U. Mayer. 2007. The human kinesin Kif18a is a motile microtubule depolymerase essential for chromosome congression. Curr. Biol. 17:488 -- 498. [18] Stumpff, J., G. V. Dassow, M. Wagenbach, C. Asbury, and L. Wordeman. 2008. The kinesin-8 motor Kif18a suppresses kinetochore movements to con- trol mitotic chromosome alignment. Dev. Cell. 14:252 -- 262. [19] Du, Y., C. A. English, and R. Ohi. 2010. The kinesin-8 Kif18a dampens microtubule plus-end dynamics. Curr. Biol. 20:374 -- 380. [20] Unsworth, A., H. Masuda, S. Dhut, and T. Toda. 2008. Fission yeast kinesin-8 Klp5 and Klp6 are interdependent for mitotic nuclear retention and required for proper microtubule dynamics. Mol. Biol. Cell. 19:5104 -- 5115. [21] Tischer, C., D. Brunner, and M. Dogterom. 2009. Force-and kinesin-8- dependent effects in the spatial regulation of fission yeast microtubule dy- namics. Mol. Syst. Biol. 5:250. [22] Grissom, P., T. Fiedler, E. Grishchuk, D. Nicastro, R. West, and J. R. McIn- tosh. 2009. Kinesin-8 from fission yeast: A heterodimeric, plus-end-directed motor that can couple microtubule depolymerization to cargo movement. Mol. Biol. Cell. 20:963. [23] Varga, V., C. Leduc, V. Bormuth, S. Diez, and J. Howard. 2009. Kinesin-8 motors act cooperatively to mediate length-dependent microtubule depoly- merization. Cell. 138:1174 -- 1183. [24] Gardner, M. K., D. C. Bouck, L. V. Paliulis, J. B. Meehl, E. T. O'Toole, J. Haase, A. Soubry, A. P. Joglekar, M. Winey, E. D. Salmon, K. Bloom, and D. J. Odde. 2008. Chromosome congression by kinesin-5 motor-mediated disassembly of longer kinetochore microtubules. Cell. 135:894 -- 906. [25] Foethke, D., T. Makushok, D. Brunner, and F. Nédélec. 2009. Force- and length-dependent catastrophe activities explain interphase microtubule orga- nization in fission yeast. Mol. Syst. Biol. 5:241. 22 [26] Klumpp, S., Y. Chai, and R. Lipowsky. 2008. Effects of the chemomechanical stepping cycle on the traffic of molecular motors. Phys. Rev. E. 78:041909. [27] Howard, J. 1996. The movement of kinesin along microtubules. Annu. Rev. Physiol. 58:703 -- 729. [28] Ray, S., E. Meyhöfer, R. Milligan, and J. Howard. 1993. Kinesin follows the microtubule protofilament axis. J. Cell Biol. 121:1083 -- 1093. [29] Parmeggiani, A., T. Franosch, and E. Frey. 2003. Phase coexistence in driven one-dimensional transport. Phys. Rev. Lett. 90:086601. [30] Parmeggiani, A., T. Franosch, and E. Frey. 2004. Totally asymmetric simple exclusion process with langmuir kinetics. Phys. Rev. E. 70:046101. [31] Lipowsky, R., S. Klumpp, and T. Nieuwenhuizen. 2001. Random walks of cytoskeletal motors in open and closed compartments. Phys. Rev. Lett. 87:108101. [32] Klumpp, S., and R. Lipowsky. 2003. Traffic of molecular motors through tube-like compartments. J. Stat. Phys. 113:233 -- 268. [33] Pierobon, P., M. Mobilia, R. Kouyos, and E. Frey. 2006. Bottleneck-induced transitions in a minimal model for intracellular transport. Phys. Rev. E. 74:031906. [34] Telley, I. A., P. Bieling, and T. Surrey. 2009. Obstacles on the microtubule reduce the processivity of Kinesin-1 in a minimal in vitro system and in cell extract. Biophys. J. 96:3341 -- 3353. [35] Govindan, B. S., M. Gopalakrishnan, and D. Chowdhury. 2008. Length control of microtubules by depolymerizing motor proteins. Europhys. Lett. 83:40006. [36] Brun, L., B. Rupp, J. J. Ward, and F. Nedelec. 2009. A theory of microtubule catastrophes and their regulation. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 106:21173 -- 21178. [37] Hough, L. E., A. Schwabe, M. A. Glaser, J. R. McIntosh, and M. D. Better- ton. 2009. Microtubule depolymerization by the kinesin-8 motor Kip3p: A mathematical model. Biophys. J. 96:3050 -- 3064. [38] Klein, G. A., K. Kruse, G. Cuniberti, and F. Jülicher. 2005. Filament depoly- merization by motor molecules. Phys. Rev. Lett. 94:108102. 23 [39] Vilfan, A., E. Frey, F. Schwabl, M. Thormahlen, Y. Song, and E. Mandelkow. 2001. Dynamics and cooperativity of microtubule decoration by the motor protein kinesin. J. Mol. Biol. 312:1011 -- 1026. [40] Frey, E., and A. Vilfan. 2002. Anomalous relaxation kinetics of biological lattice-ligand binding models. Chem. Phys. 284:287 -- 310. [41] Frey, E., A. Parmeggiani, and T. Franosch. 2004. Collective phenomena in intracellular processes. Genome Informatics. 15(1):46 -- 55. [42] Cooper, J. R., M. Wagenbach, C. L. Asbury, and L. Wordeman. 2010. Catal- ysis of the microtubule on-rate is the major parameter regulating the depoly- merase activity of MCAK. Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 17:77 -- 82. [43] Kinoshita, K., I. Arnal, A. Desai, D. Drechsel, and A. Hyman. 2001. Recon- stitution of physiological microtubule dynamics using purified components. Science. 294:1340 -- 1343. [44] Brouhard, G. J., J. H. Stear, T. L. Noetzel, J. Al-Bassam, K. Kinoshita, S. C. Harrison, J. Howard, and A. A. Hyman. 2008. XMAP215 is a processive microtubule polymerase. Cell. 132:79 -- 88. 24 Supporting Material to "Crowding of molecular motors determines microtubule depolymerization" Louis Reese, Anna Melbinger and Erwin Frey (Corresponding author. Email: [email protected]) Arnold Sommerfeld Center for Theoretical Physics and Center for NanoScience, Department of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Theresienstrasse 37, 80333 Munich, Germany In this Supporting Material, details concerning the mathematical formulation and the stochastic simulations are given. In particular, the density profiles and the domain wall positions at the minus- and the plus-end are derived analytically. Further, some additional results are provided: (i) We show that the shapes of MT depolymerization curves (kymographs) are to a large extent independent of the choice of the depolymerization rate δ; see Fig. S1. (ii) Analytical and numerical results from our theory are compared to experimental data on the relation between depolymerization speed and motor current (1); see Fig. S2. Mathematical formulation In this article, we employ a lattice gas model. Its state is described by a set of occupation numbers ni ∈ {0, 1} where i = 1, . . . , L denotes the lattice sites. In contrast to the notation in the main text, we here choose units of length and time such that the hopping rate from site to site and the lattice constant are both set to one. For an analytical description of the steady state density profiles of the molecular motors along the MT we consider the ensemble-averaged densities and currents: ρi := (cid:104)ni(cid:105) , Ji := (cid:104)ni(1 − ni+1)(cid:105) . (S1) (S2) Note that the current Ji accounts for particle exclusion: a particle at site i moves to site i + 1 at rate ν = 1 only if site i + 1 is unoccupied. The steady state results from a local balance between the transport current (2), := (cid:104)ni−1(1 − ni)(cid:105) − (cid:104)ni(1 − ni+1)(cid:105) , J T i the particle exchange with the bulk, := c ωa(cid:104)1 − ni(cid:105) − ωd(cid:104)ni(cid:105) , J La i 25 (S3) (S4) and the depolymerization current, which sets the boundary condition at the plus- end. We now perform a mean-field approximation, where all spatial correlations are neglected, and a continuum limit keeping only the leading order terms (3). Then, the transport current simplifies to, J T (x) =(cid:0)2ρ(x) − 1(cid:1)∂xρ(x) , (S5) (S6) i.e. the transport current is proportional to the density gradient like a diffusion current in Fick's law but modified with a density-dependent prefactor which reflects site-exclusion between motors. The Langmuir current is given by (cid:0)1 − ρ(x)(cid:1) − ωdρ(x) . J La(x) = c ωa Density profiles at the minus-end Within the above introduced framework the motor density profiles on the MT can be calculated analytically. In particular, the domain wall position, can be derived exactly as well as upon employing a linear approximation for the density profile close to the minus-end. For simplicity, we first consider the latter, especially because its results approximate the exact solution rather well over a broad range of parameters. Linear approximation In the immediate vicinity of the minus-end (x = 0) the density is small such that the full equation for the current balance, J T + J La = 0, (2ρ(x) − 1)∂xρ(x) + c ωa(1 − ρ(x)) − ωdρ(x) = 0 , (S7) reduces to ∂xρ = c ωa, which is solved by a linear (antenna) profile: ρ−(x) ≈ c ωax . (S8) At sufficiently large distances from the minus-end the density profile becomes flat. Therefore, J T vanishes and the system is dominated by the Langmuir kinetics, J La = 0. Then, an asymptotic solution of Eq. S7 is given by the Langmuir density ρLa = K 1 + K = c ωa c ωa + ωd . (S9) The full density profile is obtained by concatenating the antenna profile and the flat Langmuir profile such that the (local) current is continuous along the MT. There are two qualitatively distinct scenarios. For low bulk concentrations of molecular motors, c, the antenna profile matches the asymptotic Langmuir density 26 continuously resulting in a wedge-like profile; compare Fig. 2E in the main text. Approximately, the matching point, ρ−(d− w) = ρLa, is w ≈ (cid:96)− K c ωa(K + 1) . (S10) In contrast, above a certain threshold value for the bulk concentration, determined by K− c = 1, the two profiles can no longer be matched continuously and the density profile displays a localized discontinuity (2), also termed a "domain wall" (DW). Its position is determined by a local current continuity condition (2, 3), ρ−(d−) = 1 − ρLa, and can again be estimated using the linear antenna profile: Taken together, Eq. (5) from the main text is obtained, (cid:96)− ≈ 1 c ωa(K + 1) . (cid:40) 1 (cid:96)− = ωd(K+1) 1 c ωa(K+1) for K < 1 , for K > 1 . (S11) (S12) Exact solution and domain wall position To obtain the full solution Eq. S7 has to be solved as already demonstrated in K−1 (2ρ(x) − 1)− Ref. (3). Introducing a rescaled density at the minus-end σ−(x) = K+1 1 in Eq. S7 a transformed differential equation can be obtained ∂xσ−(x) + ∂x lnσ(x)− = ωd (K + 1)2 K − 1 , which is mathematically equivalent to Eq. S7 and can be solved analytically σ−(x) = W−1 (−Y−(x)) . (S13) Here W−1 is the second real branch of the Lambert W -function (4) and Y−(x) reads (3) . (K + 1)2 K − 1 x − 2K K − 1 ωd Y−(x) = (S14) Herein the boundary condition ρ−(0) = 0 corresponding to σ−(0) = −2K/(K − 1) has already been accounted for. The local current condition for the domain wall, ρ−(d−) = 1− ρLa which corresponds to σ−(d−) = −2 for the rescaled density, now enables us to calculate the DW position. Combining this condition with Eqs. S13 and S14 leads to d−(ωd, K) = 2 + (K − 1) ln(1 − 1/K) (S15) . ωd(K + 1)2 (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) −2K K − 1 (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) exp (cid:26) (cid:27) 27 Density profiles at the plus-end Analogously to the minus-end, we now evaluate the density profiles and ensuing DW at the plus-end. Because the tip steadily depolymerizes, the calculations have to be performed in a comoving frame which is introduced first. Comoving frame In the comoving frame, the above defined last lattice site L, i.e. the plus-end, is defined as the first site of the MT. This is equivalent to reverting the motor movement. Since molecular motors in the comoving frame move towards the first site of the lattice, the transport current changes sign J T i = −J T ;Co i J T ;Co i := (cid:104)ni+1(1 − ni)(cid:105) − (cid:104)ni(1 − ni−1)(cid:105) , using the mean-field approximation as introduced above this leads to J T ;Co(x) = −(2ρ − 1)∂xρ(x) . (S16) (S17) The particle adsorption/desorption current J La is unaffected. However, there is another contribution to the current balance in the comoving frame due to depoly- merization: Similar to the above definitions of the local currents, a local current which accounts for depolymerization in the comoving frame arises i i = δ(ni+1 − ni) . J Co Employing a mean-field approximation this expression simplifies to, J Co(x) = δ∂xρ(x) . (S18) (S19) This current term can be understood as follows. Due to the depolymerizing activity of a motor at the plus-end, in the comoving frame all motors on the MT simul- taneously approach the plus-end. In summary, by introducing a comoving frame the mean-field equation for the density at the MT plus-end ρ+(x) is obtained. In the steady state it reads (2ρ+ − 1 − δ)∂xρ+ + cωa(1 − ρ+) − ωdρ+ = 0 . (S20) Density profiles The above equation is solved in close analogy to Eq. S7. In terms of a rescaled density σ+(x) = 2ρ+(x) − 2 K K+1 − (1 + δ) 2 K K+1 , 28 (S21) the rescaled differential equation reads +(x) + ∂x lnσ+(x) = σ(cid:48) ωd(K + 1)2 K − 1 − (K + 1)δ . (S22) The exact solutions to this equation are compared to stochastic simulations in the main text (Fig. 5A). The solutions of this equation for δ = 0 are discussed in (3) and in parts above. However, in the case of depolymerization, i.e. for δ > 0, two special solutions exist: Depending on the density of motors on the MT two classes of solutions for the density at the plus-end ρ+(x) can be distinguished. These are wedge-like or traffic jam density profiles; see Fig. 5A in the main text. The boundary condition for these qualitatively distinct density profiles is ρ+(L) = 1. Defining Y (x) = σ+(L) exp ωd(K + 1)2 K − 1 − δ(K + 1) (x − L) + σ+(L) , (S23) (cid:27) (cid:26) (cid:40) the two solutions for density profiles in the main text (black lines in Fig. 5A) are ρ(x) = ρLa + 1 ρLa + 1 2(2ρLa − (1 + δ))W0(Y (x)) 2(2ρLa − (1 + δ))W−1(−Y (x)) wedge-like traffic jam. (S24) W0 and W−1 denote the first and the second real branch of the Lambert function. The reason for the form of these two solutions is the bottleneck (5) arising due to depolymerization (see main text). This bottleneck fixes the value of the tip density to its maximum ρ+(L) = 1 for ρLa > δ. The transition from a traffic jam to a wedge-like density profile is thus not boundary-induced, i.e. due to a particular value of ρ+(L) < 1, but may be attributed to the depolymerizing activity of motors at the plus-end. As discussed in the main text, this transition is sharp and can be quantified in terms of ρLa and δ; see Fig. 5B. Domain wall position at the plus-end As already shown in the main text, microscopic jams can substantially influence the depolymerization dynamics. For large bulk concentrations, this perturbation no longer remains a local spike, but affects the profile on a macroscopic scale (5). Because the perturbation is macroscopic we can again use a hydrodynamic description, now with the boundary condition ρ+(L) = 1. Close to the plus-end Eq. S20 gives an approximately linear profile ρ+(x) ≈ 1 − ωd 1 − δ (L − x) . (S25) The slope increases with increasing depolymerization rate δ, c.f. Fig. 5A in the main text. In close analogy with the discussion for the minus-end there are two 29 scenarios for concatenating this linear profile with the Langmuir density. Here, for large enough Langmuir density and/or small enough depolymerization rates, we obtain a wedge-like profile with a matching point given by ρ+(d+ w) = ρLa: ; (S26) w ≈ L − 1 − δ d+ ωd(1 + K) (cid:20) K 1 + K (cid:21) 1 − δ ωd − δ d+ ≈ L − compare the green curves in Fig. 5A in the main text. Upon increasing the depoly- merization rate or decreasing the Langmuir density a DW emerges whose position can be determined using current conservation, ρ+(d+) = 1 − ρLa + δ: ; (S27) compare the red curves in Fig. 5A. The DW is most pronounced for K < 1. The height of the DW vanishes as K approaches the threshold value K + c = 1 + δ 1 − δ (S28) from below. Equivalently, for a given K, the critical depolymerization rate reads K − 1 K + 1 δc = = 2ρLa − 1 = c ωa − ωd c ωa + ωd . (S29) Together with the condition for spikes, ρLa < δ, this relation organizes the shapes of the density profiles into three classes: Microscopic jams at the tip, wedge profiles and DW profiles. Depolymerization dynamics of the antenna profile In the main text we have discussed how a spatially uniform density ρLa affects depolymerization dynamics. Here we briefly show that our approach is also ap- plicable to linear antenna profiles, i.e. for MTs shorter than a certain threshold length, L < (cid:96)−, cf. Eq. (S12) and main text. Just as in the main text we equate the particle loss current due to depolymerization, Jdepol(x) = [1 − ρ−(x)] ρ+(x)δ , and the particle flux towards the plus-end, J−(x) = [1 − ρ−(x)] ρ−(x) , and find (cid:40) ρ−(x) ρ+(x) = δ 1 for L < δ cωa for L > δ cωa , . 30 (S30) (S31) (S32) Since, according to Eq. (2) in the main text, the density at the plus-end deter- mines the depolymerization speed, Vdepol = δρ+(x), the position-dependence of the tip density maps to a length-dependence of the polymerization speed. For MTs shorter than (cid:96)− but longer than a certain depolymerization length (cid:96)d = δ/cωa the depolymerization speed is length-independent Vdepol = ρ+δ = δ . (S33) Analogously to the result for constant bulk densities, this result shows that for MTs longer than the depolymerization length (cid:96)d the dynamics of depolymerization of the antenna profile can not be distinguished from the dynamics as induced by a flat density profile. In contrast, at a MT length shorter than (cid:96)d the depolymerization speed becomes length-dependent and follows the shape of the antenna density profile ρ−(x): Vdepol(L) = ρ+(L)δ = ρ−(L) . (S34) These results generalize the rate-limited and density-limited regimes discussed in the main text to non-uniform densities. Moreover, they show that once filaments become shorter than (cid:96)−, i.e. the density profile is antenna-like, there is a second spike-induced length scale (cid:96)d which is the relevant length scale for the onset of length-dependent depolymerization of MTs. Combining these results with the analogous conditions for the Langmuir plateau discussed in the main text, leads to the depolymerization regimes summarized in Fig. 5C and Table 1. Simply put, the depolymerization dynamics changes from rate-limited to density-limited when the bulk density falls below the threshold den- sity δ: ρ−(L) ≤ δ. For Langmuir densities below the threshold density, ρLa < δ, the bulk density remains below the threshold density for the whole MT length such that the depolymerization dynamics is always density-limited and given by: Vdepol = ρ−(L). This corresponds to regime (α) in Fig. 5C. For Langmuir densities above the threshold, ρLa > δ, the depolymerization dynamics is rate-limited in the Langmuir plateau and given by Vdepol = δ. In the antenna-like regime of the density profile, i.e. for L ≤ (cid:96)−, we have to distinguish between two cases: (i) K > 1 (ρLa > 0.5) where the bulk density profile exhibits a domain wall, and (ii) K < 1 (ρLa < 0.5) where the bulk density profile is wedge-like. In the latter case, the bulk-density profile changes slowly and hence remains above the threshold δ for some time even below L = (cid:96)−. Only for MTs shorter than (cid:96)d, given by ρ−((cid:96)d) = δ, the dynamics changes from rate- to density-limited. This corresponds to regime (γ) in Fig. 5C. In contrast, for K > 1 (ρLa > 0.5), the bulk density ρ−(x) ex- hibits a discontinuous jump from the Langmuir density to 1 − ρLa right at (cid:96)−. If this maximum value of the antenna-like profile is less than the threshold density, 1 − ρLa < δ, then the depolymerization dynamics discontinuously switches from 31 rate-limited to density-limited. This defines regime (β) in Fig. 5C. Otherwise, if 1 − ρLa > δ, we are back to regime (γ). In summary, all regimes show a constant polymerization speed for long MTs in the Langmuir plateau. Depending on the relative magnitude of the Langmuir density and the depolymerization rate this regime is either density-limited and given by ρLa or rate-limited and given by δ, cf. second column in Table 1. In all scenarios the dynamics becomes length-dependent at some scale which is, however, different. While for regimes α and β, it coincides with the beginning of the antenna-like density profile (cid:96)−, it is given by (cid:96)d for regime (γ) cf. third column in Table 1. Regime (α) (β) (γ) Condition ρLa < δ ρLa > δ > 1 − ρLa else Constant Vdepol Critical MT length Vdepol = ρLa Vdepol = δ Vdepol = δ (cid:96)− (cid:96)− (cid:96)d Table 1: Summary of the similarities and differences in the depolymerization regimes (α), (β) and (γ). While for MTs longer than a critical length (third col- umn) the depolymerization speed is constant (second column), it becomes length- dependent below this critical length and is then given by Vdepol = ρ−(L). Numerical implementation The stochastic dynamics of the individual-based model was simulated using a Gillespie algorithm (7) and employing the rates introduced above. Note that this method provides the mathematically exact stochastic dynamics. This is essential for the investigation of dynamic phenomena like length-dependent shortening. In Fig. 2A-D., our simulations of the motor traffic started from an initial con- dition where the MT lattice was empty and subsequently filled up with motors triggering the depolymerization dynamics. To visualize time-dependent MT length and motor densities in one kymograph we implemented 14 protofilaments and av- eraged the motor intensities and MT lengths, see Fig. 2A-C. In detail, the visual- ization of kymographs was achieved as described in the following. From stochastic simulation data of the MT, each second the occupation numbers of motors along , where j indexes the 14 protofilaments of the MT, were evaluated and the MT n(j) (cid:80)14 (cid:80)14 converted to RGB color values: j=1 1−n(j) (S35) These values display the density of motors as green and the uncovered MT surface as red. Hence, if the MT is completely empty it is red, while at complete motor coverage it is green. , Bi = 0. j=1 n(j) 14 i Ri = i , Gi = 14 i 32 Steady state motor densities as shown in Figs. 2E and 5A were obtained by time-averaging over 104 independent realizations after an equilibration time of 2000 time steps; note that for a constant lattice size time and ensemble averages yield identical results (2). In Fig. 5A, the density profiles were recorded in the comoving frame of the MT plus-end, while density profiles in Fig. 2E were recorded in the rest frame of the MT minus-end. In Fig. 2E, the density profiles resulting from the minus end without any influences from the plus end are shown. This can be viewed as an infinitely long lattice. To simulate such a lattice, we chose the following boundary conditions. We neglected depolymerization as it arises at infinity. Further, we set the exiting rate for motors at the last site equal to 1 − ρLa. Then, the transport behavior at the tip is the same as on the lattice, if the Langmuir density is reached, ρ(x) = ρLa. In the second part of the article we focus on the dependence of the depolymer- ization speed on the motor density. To this end, simulations were performed in a comoving frame where the density at the minus-end was fixed to the Langmuir density. This was achieved by extending the lattice one site to left with each de- polymerization step and filling the thereby created site with the probability ρLa. This procedure may also be interpreted as an infinite MT allowing to observe motor dynamics at the MT tip without perturbations arising from the length-dependent depolymerization regime. We measured the mean end-residence time of individual motors at the plus-end τres and the mean lifetime of the terminal tubulin dimer τd. Data of these were obtained by averaging over 104 time steps τ, cf. Figs. 4 and 6. How kymographs become independent of the de- polymerization rate In Fig. S1 we provide data that explicitly shows the parameter independence of MT depolymerization. This results has been generalized in the main text to all possible motor concentrations and depolymerization rates. Comparison with experiments: dependence of the depolymerization speed on the bulk flux and bulk density Experimentally it was found that the depolymerization speed is linearly correlated with the flux of molecular motors towards the plus-end (1). We have collected data from our simulations similar to experiments. Figure S2 shows a scatter plot 33 FIGURE S1: Kymographs as they become independent of the depolymerization rate δ. Time-space plots of depolymerizing MTs for different depolymerization rates are shown, ranging from δ = 0.1 ν (red) to 1.0 ν (blue), the latter value cor- responds to the motor speed of v = 6.35 sites s−1. For slow depolymerization rate, δ (cid:47) 0.5, the depolymerization speed is related to the microscopic depolymeriza- tion rate δ, whereas for rates δ (cid:39) 0.5 the depolymerization speed is independent of the depolymerization rate but depends on the density of motors on the MT, as outlined in the main text. for the depolymerization speed as a function of the bulk flux of motors, JLa, for two values of the microscopic depolymerization rate δ. The noise in the ensemble of realizations has two sources. The bulk current fluctuates since the Langmuir kinetics responsible for the bulk density ρLa is a stochastic process. The depolymerization speeds vary from realization to realiza- tion because the depolymerization kinetics is a Poisson-like process. Also shown in Fig. S2 are ensemble averages. These mean values, as predicted in the main text, show the following behavior. For a macroscopic depolymerization speed lower than the depolymerization rate, ∆L/∆T < δa, it is density-limited and identical to the bulk density: ∆L ∆T = ρLav for ρLa < δτ . (S36) Rewriting this relation in terms of the bulk current means that the data should fall on the parabola displayed as the solid curve in Fig. S2. For low densities, ρLa (cid:47) 0.25, where crowding effects are weak, this implies ∆L/∆T = ρLav ≈ JLa as observed experimentally (1); see Fig. S2. As the bulk density is increased two things happen. First, crowding effects become important invalidating the linear relationship between bulk current and 34 05101520253035Time t [min]020040060080010001200MT length L [sites]δ0=1.0δ0=0.9δ0=0.8δ0=0.7δ0=0.6δ0=0.5δ0=0.4δ0=0.3δ0=0.2δ0=0.1FIGURE S2: Depolymerization speed ∆L/∆T as a function of the bulk motor cur- rent on the MT, JLa. Data from stochastic simulations for two different depoly- merization rates δ = 0.5 ν (◦) and 0.8 ν ((cid:47)) are shown, each for a set of Langmuir densities (colors) corresponding to concentrations c = 0.16 . . . 13 nM. To illustrate the effect of statistics, small symbols show individual measurements as obtained from 103 fixed time measurements ∆T = 500τ, while large symbols indicate their mean (cid:104)∆L/∆T(cid:105). Good agreement with experimental data ((cid:50)) measured in the low density regime is found (1). Here, the theoretical prediction given by JLa (solid) is hardly discernible from a linear best fit to experiments (dashed). depolymerization speed. It would be interesting to test our prediction that the depolymerization speed is linear in the bulk density by using higher motor con- centrations or changed biochemical rates such that K becomes significantly larger than 1. Second, if ρLa > δτ, the depolymerization speed becomes rate-limited: ∆L ∆T = aδ for ρLa > δτ . (S37) This puts an obvious upper bound on the depolymerization speed. It cannot become larger than the microscopic rate of depolymerization at the plus-end. If the depolymerization rate is larger than the hopping rate of the molecular motors, δ > ν, the depolymerization speed is, for all possible values of the bulk density, strictly given by the bulk density. References [1] Varga, V., C. Leduc, V. Bormuth, S. Diez, and J. Howard. 2009. Kinesin-8 motors act cooperatively to mediate length-dependent microtubule depolymer- 35 ization. Cell. 138:1174 -- 1183. [2] Parmeggiani, A., T. Franosch, and E. Frey. 2003. Phase coexistence in driven one-dimensional transport. Phys. Rev. Lett. 90:086601. [3] Parmeggiani, A., T. Franosch, and E. Frey. 2004. Totally asymmetric simple exclusion process with langmuir kinetics. Phys. Rev. E. 70:046101. [4] Corless, R., G. Gonnet, D. Hare, D. Jeffrey, and D. Knuth. 1996. On the lambert w function. Adv. Comput. Math. 5:329 -- 359. [5] Pierobon, P., M. Mobilia, R. Kouyos, and E. Frey. 2006. Bottleneck-induced transitions in a minimal model for intracellular transport. Phys. Rev. E. 74:031906. [6] Varga, V., J. Helenius, K. Tanaka, A. A. Hyman, T. U. Tanaka, and J. Howard. 2006. Yeast kinesin-8 depolymerizes microtubules in a length-dependent man- ner. Nat. Cell Biol. 8:957 -- 962. [7] Gillespie, D. T. 1976. Stochastic simulations of chemical processes. J. Comp. Phys. 22:403 -- 434. 36
1607.06640	1	1607	2016-07-22T11:51:24	Ephemeral protein binding to DNA shapes stable nuclear bodies and chromatin domains	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "cond-mat.stat-mech", "q-bio.SC" ]	Fluorescence microscopy reveals that the contents of many (membrane-free) nuclear "bodies" exchange rapidly with the soluble pool whilst the underlying structure persists; such observations await a satisfactory biophysical explanation. To shed light on this, we perform large-scale Brownian dynamics simulations of a chromatin fiber interacting with an ensemble of (multivalent) DNA-binding proteins; these proteins switch between two states -- active (binding) and inactive (non-binding). This system provides a model for any DNA-binding protein that can be modified post-translationally to change its affinity for DNA (e.g., like the phosphorylation of a transcription factor). Due to this out-of-equilibrium process, proteins spontaneously assemble into clusters of self-limiting size, as individual proteins in a cluster exchange with the soluble pool with kinetics like those seen in photo-bleaching experiments. This behavior contrasts sharply with that exhibited by "equilibrium", or non-switching, proteins that exist only in the binding state; when these bind to DNA non-specifically, they form clusters that grow indefinitely in size. Our results point to post-translational modification of chromatin-bridging proteins as a generic mechanism driving the self-assembly of highly dynamic, non-equilibrium, protein clusters with the properties of nuclear bodies. Such active modification also reshapes intra-chromatin contacts to give networks resembling those seen in topologically-associating domains, as switching markedly favors local (short-range) contacts over distant ones.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Ephemeral protein binding to DNA shapes stable nuclear bodies and chromatin domains C. A. Brackley,1 B. Liebchen,1 D. Michieletto,1 F. Mouvet,1 P. R. Cook,2 and D. Marenduzzo1 1SUPA, School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Peter Guthrie Road, Edinburgh, EH9 3FD, UK 2Sir William Dunn School of Pathology, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford, OX1 3RE, UK Abstract Fluorescence microscopy reveals that the contents of many (membrane-free) nuclear "bodies" exchange rapidly with the soluble pool whilst the underlying structure persists; such observations await a satisfactory biophysical explanation. To shed light on this, we perform large-scale Brownian dynamics simulations of a chromatin fiber interacting with an ensemble of (multivalent) DNA-binding proteins; these proteins switch between two states -- active (binding) and inactive (non-binding). This system provides a model for any DNA-binding protein that can be modified post-translationally to change its affinity for DNA (e.g., like the phosphorylation of a transcription factor). Due to this out-of-equilibrium process, proteins spontaneously assemble into clusters of self-limiting size, as individual proteins in a cluster exchange with the soluble pool with kinetics like those seen in photo-bleaching experiments. This behavior contrasts sharply with that ex- hibited by "equilibrium", or non-switching, proteins that exist only in the binding state; when these bind to DNA non-specifically, they form clusters that grow indefinitely in size. Our results point to post-translational modification of chromatin-bridging proteins as a generic mechanism driving the self-assembly of highly dy- namic, non-equilibrium, protein clusters with the properties of nuclear bodies. Such active modification also reshapes intra-chromatin contacts to give networks resembling those seen in topologically-associating domains, as switching markedly favors local (short-range) contacts over distant ones. In all living organisms, from bacteria to man, DNA and chromatin are invariably associated with binding proteins, which organize their structure [1 -- 3]. Many of these architectural proteins are molecular bridges that can bind at two or more distinct DNA sites to form loops. For example, bacterial DNA is looped and com- pacted by the histone-like protein H-NS which has two distinct DNA-binding domains [4]. In eukaryotes, com- plexes of transcription factors and RNA polymerases sta- bilize enhancer-promoter loops [5, 6, 6, 7], while HP1 [9], histone H1 [10], and the polycomb-repressor complex PRC1/2 [5, 11] organize inactive chromatin. Proteins also bind to specific DNA sequences to form larger struc- tures, like nucleoli and the histone-locus, Cajal, and promyeloleukemia bodies [13 -- 18]. The selective bind- ing of molecular bridges to active and inactive regions of chromatin has also been highlighted as one possible mechanism underlying the formation of topologically as- sociated domains (TADs) -- regions rich in local DNA interactions [6, 6, 19]. From a biophysical perspective, a system made up of DNA and DNA-binding proteins exhibits many kinds of interesting and seemingly counter-intuitive behaviour, such as the clustering of proteins in the absence of any at- tractive interaction between them. This process is driven by the "bridging-induced attraction" [20]. In conjunction with the specific patterning of binding sites found on a whole human chromosome in vivo, this attraction can drive folding into TADs in the appropriate places on the chromosome [6]. In the simple case where there is only a non-specific DNA-protein interaction (i.e., proteins can bind to any point on DNA), bridging-induced clustering can be un- derstood as being due to a thermodynamic feedback loop: binding of bridges to multiple DNA segments causes an increase in local DNA concentration which, in turn, re- cruits further DNA-binding proteins, and further itera- tions then sustain the positive feedback. Subsequently, the ensuing clusters coarsen, and eventually phase sepa- rate into one macroscopic cluster of DNA-bound bridges in equilibrium with a (diluted) pool of unbound pro- teins [21, 22]. In the more complex case with specific DNA-binding interactions, clustering is associated with the formation of DNA loops. Looped structures incur an entropic cost which increases superlinearly with the number of loops, and can stop the growth of a cluster beyond a critical size [6, 23 -- 26]. Such specific bind- ing drives the formation of promoter-enhancer loops [2]; however there are several proteins which interact mainly non-specifically with large regions of the genome, such as histone H1 and other heterochromatin-associated pro- teins [2]. For this latter class of proteins, the abun- dance of binding sites in the nucleus would lead to clus- ters that coarsen progressively. However, this indefinite growth is not observed: we suggest that reversible post- translational protein modifications may be the reason un- derlying the arrested coarsening. Specifically, here we consider a non-equilibrium bio- chemical reaction which can modify DNA-binding pro- teins. In our model, these proteins continuously switch between an active, DNA-binding state, and an inactive, non-binding, one. Such a reaction can arise in several scenarios. For instance, a complex of transcription fac- tors and an RNA polymerase might stabilize a promoter- enhancer loop; upon transcription termination, the com- plex could dissociate and the loop disappear [2, 3]. Al- ternatively, phosphorylation, or other post-translational modifications of transcription factors [27], may affect 1 their affinity for chromatin, as might a conformational change in a protein or the reversible addition of a sub- unit to a protein complex, which might be driven by ATP hydrolysis. In this work we show that introducing this non- equilibrium mechanism strikingly broadens the range of physical behaviour displayed by the chromatin/protein ensemble. In particular, we find that including "switch- ing" proteins which interact non-specifically with a chro- matin fiber leads to qualitatively and quantitatively dif- ferent results compared to "equilibrium" proteins (which are always in the binding state). Switching (i.e., pro- tein modification) arrests the coarsening triggered by the bridging-induced attraction, and the size of the re- sulting clusters can be tuned by altering the switching rates. Furthermore, we show that if proteins bind both specifically and non-specifically, switching results in the formation of highly-dynamic clusters, which are qualita- tively different from those formed by non-switching pro- teins. In the former case, proteins in the cluster exchange with the soluble pool, whilst the general shape of the cluster persists. These dynamic clusters closely resem- ble some of the nuclear bodies of eukaryotic cells. Fi- nally, we consider a simplified model for the formation of TADs in chromosomes, and show that protein switching leaves the location of the domains unaltered, but strongly disfavours long-range inter-TAD interactions. All these findings point to an important and generic role of re- versible protein modification in chromatin and nuclear organization. I. RESULTS A. Protein switching arrests coarsening of chro- matin bridges that bind non-specifically We perform Brownian dynamics simulations of a flex- ible chromatin fiber modeled as a bead-and-spring poly- mer (thickness 30 nm, persistence length 90 nm) interact- ing non-specifically with either non-switching or switch- ing proteins. These proteins can bind to the fiber at more than one location (in our case through a Lennard-Jones potential; see Supporting Information for details on the force field, and Fig. 1A,B for a schematic). For simplic- ity, we assume a protein has the same size as the chro- matin beads (a realistic assumption as each is likely to be a protein complex). We also assume proteins stochas- tically switch between binding and non-binding states at an equal rate, α. [Relaxation of either of these assump- tions does not qualitatively alter results.] First, we consider the case of equilibrium, non- switching proteins, where α = 0 (Fig. 1C). This case was studied in [6, 20, 21, 28], and it was shown to lead to poly- mer collapse [6, 21, 28] and clustering of bridges [20, 21] depending on the protein concentration. For the concen- trations used here, clusters coarsen and grow at the ex- pense of smaller aggregates. During the early stages, this 2 Figure 1: Protein switching arrests coarsening. In (A-D), active and inactive proteins are colored red and gray respectively; chromatin is represented by strings of blue beads. (A) Schematic of the model (Brownian dynamics simulations). (i) Proteins (lone spheres) switch between red and gray states at rate α. (ii) Only proteins in the red state can bind chromatin. (iii) Red and gray beads interact via steric repulsion only. (iv) Proteins can bind to ≥ 2 sites to create molecular bridges and loops. (B) Snapshots illustrating protein binding/unbinding. Bound active proteins have clustered and compacted chromatin. Bound active proteins 1 and 2 (gray circles) switch and become inactive and dissociate (gray arrows); non-binding sometimes bind to the cluster (red arrows). (C) Snapshots taken (i) proteins a-c in the soluble pool (red circles) become active and 104 and (ii) 2 × 104 simulation units after equilibration. The simulation involved a 5000-bead fiber (corresponding to 15 Mbp) and N = 4000 non-switchable proteins, of which half are able to bind. (D) As (C), but for N = 4000 switchable proteins (α = 0.0003 inverse Brownian times). (E) Average cluster size as a function of time. Error bars denote standard deviations of the mean. (i) Non-switching proteins. (ii) Switching proteins; from top to bottom, α equals 0.0001, 0.0002, 0.0003, 0.0004 and 0.0005 inverse Brownian times. resembles the Ostwald ripening characteristic of liquid- gas phase separation; later on, we also observe coales- cence of smaller clusters into larger ones (Movie S1). The average cluster size -- measured as the number of bound proteins per cluster -- increases with time with no sign of saturation until all clusters merge into one (Fig. 1Cii, and Movie S1). For early times, cluster size (which is also proportional to its volume) increases approximately lin- early with time, as would be expected for Ostwald ripen- ing in density-conserving model B [2]. For later times, cluster growth is much slower, with a sublinear exponent (close to 0.25 for our parameters, see Fig. 1Ei). This slowing is due to the underlying polymer dynamics -- as in blob formation during the collapse of a homopolymer, which is also slower than simple model B kinetics [4]. The dynamics with protein switching is remarkably dif- ferent: now, coarsening is completely arrested, and the system achieves a micro-phase separated state in which clusters have a well-defined average size (Fig. 1D; Movie S2). This size decreases with α (Fig. 1Eii). The ar- rested phase separation can be understood intuitively as follows. On the one hand, thermodynamics dictates that the system should try to minimize interfaces, and this leads to coarsening, initially via Ostwald ripening, giv- ing the growth laws in Figure 1Ei. On the other hand, non-equilibrium protein switching is a Poisson process, so active proteins switch off at a constant rate α, and leave the cluster. [This is not the case for equilibrium proteins which can only unbind thermodynamically; not only is the unbinding rate slower, but such proteins are also highly likely to rebind to a nearby site before ever leaving a cluster]. Then, active proteins only have a timescale of the order α−1 in which to form a cluster, before a significant proportion of proteins in that cluster inactivate. Hence, phase separation is arrested. B. A mean field theory quantitatively explains the arrest of coarsening, and predicts average cluster size To understand more quantitatively how a non- equilibrium biochemical reaction arrests coarsening, we consider a simplified mean field theory which follows the time evolution of the chromatin density ρ(, t), and of the active protein density Φ(x, t). Our equations describe the binding of the proteins to the chromatin together with the diffusion of all components, and they read as follows, ρ = Mρ∇2(cid:2)a1ρ − k∇2ρ − χΦ + gρ3(cid:3) (1) Φ = MΦ∇2 [a2Φ − χρ] − α(Φ − Φ0). These equations can be formally derived starting from a suitable underlying free energy density, and adding pro- tein modification as a reaction term -- the details are discussed in the Supporting Information. In Eqs. (1), Mρ and MΦ are the chromatin and protein mobility re- spectively, so that Mρa1 ≡ D1 and MΦa2 ≡ D2 repre- sent effective diffusion coefficients, while χ is the coef- ficient describing bridging between active proteins and chromatin. Further, g captures steric repulsion in the chromatin fiber, κ accounts for effective surface tension effects, and finally the last term in the equation for Φ models the biochemical reaction, where proteins switch from binding to non-binding, and vice versa, at a rate α. For α = 0, Eqs. (1) ensure conservation of the global den- sity of both chromatin and proteins -- in other words, this is an example of generalized model B dynamics [2, 17]. To identify the key parameters in our system, we now choose dimensionless time and space units tu = 1/α and 3 xu = (cid:112)D2/α and redefine Φ as Φ(Mρχ/D2). In these units, our equations become ρ = D0∇2ρ − A∇4ρ − ∇2φ + G∇2ρ3 Φ = ∇2Φ − X∇2ρ − (Φ − Φ0), (2) (3) so that the whole parameter space is spanned by the 2); D0 = four dimensionless numbers X = (χ2MρMΦ/D2 (D1/D2); A = αkMρ/(D2 2) and G = gMρ/D2. A + √D)2 where D = D0 + 3Gρ2 χ >(cid:112)kα/MΦ +(cid:112)(D2/MΦ)[D1/Mρ + 3gρ2 One solution of Eqs. (B6-B7) is given by the uniform phase (ρ, Φ) = (ρ0, Φ0), which is stable in the absence of bridging (χ = 0). To see how the interplay of bridging and biochemical switching can create patterns, we per- formed a linear stability analysis of this uniform state (Fig. 2, detailed in the Supporting Information). The √ result is that small perturbations of the uniform phase grow if X > Xc = ( 0. This instability criterion translates in physical units to 0]. Thus, the instability is driven by bridging, whereas diffusion of chromatin and proteins, excluded volume, as well as pro- tein modification, all tend to stabilize uniform chromatin- protein distributions. Importantly, this bridging-induced instability also works at very low protein concentration. Calculating the wavenumber at the onset of instabil- ity (see Supporting Information) unveils the remarkable role played by the biochemical reaction for structure for- mation. Specifically, we find qc = (D/A)(1/4) for the dimensionless onset wavenumber, translating in physical units to the following typical length scale, (cid:20) D1D2 + 3Mρgρ2 0D2 (cid:21)1/4 Lc = 2π αkMρ . (4) Hence, in contrast to models without protein modifica- tion, the present system exhibits a short wavelength in- stability (Fig. 2), which turns into a long wavelength in- stability only in the limit α → 0 (which would lead to Lc → ∞, dotted black line in Fig. 2). Our linear sta- bility analysis therefore suggests that the presence of the biochemical reaction has qualitative consequences for the clustering in the system, in that it leads to self-limiting cluster sizes, or put differently, to micro-phase separation rather than to macro-phase separation -- in full agreement with the simulations shown in Fig. 1. To further confirm that within our mean field theory clusters cannot coarsen indefinitely, we also performed a weakly non-linear expansion, through which we found that the amplitude of the chromatin density fluctuations close to the uniform state obey the "real Ginzburg Lan- dau equation", which is associated with formation of sta- tionary patterns of well-defined self-limiting size [3] (see Supporting Information). Finally, Eq. (4) also predicts that, at least close to the onset of clustering, the aver- age number of proteins in any aggregate should scale as c ∼ α−3/4, in good agreement with results from our L3 simulations (Fig. S1). are photobleached at a given time, and recovery of fluo- rescence is then monitored (Fig. 3). The "fluorescence" signal (proportional to the number of non-photobleached active proteins in the clusters) recovers quickly in the α (cid:54)= 0 case (Figs. 3Aiii, 3B), but not in the α = 0 case (Fig. 3Aiv, 3Bi), at least for large values of the spe- cific interaction strength. The dynamics of recovery can be measured using the number of unbleached proteins in the photobleached volume (Fig. 3Bi); this is propor- tional to the fluorescence intensity measured in a stan- dard FRAP experiment. Alternatively, the number of unbleached proteins in clusters can be used (Fig. 3Bii). Both approaches give similar recovery timescales, and confirm that protein modification is required to create clusters in which proteins can recycle. The clusters found in Figure 3 typically contain ∼ 20−100 proteins that recycle (Fig. S3A). Cluster size de- pends on both protein concentration and interaction en- ergy (e.g., in Fig. S3B there are only ∼ 5−10 proteins per cluster). Therefore, this mechanism can produce clus- ters with a wide range of sizes. Note that nuclear bodies range from large nucleoli (up to several µm), through Ca- jal, polycomb, and promyelocytic leukemia bodies (∼ 1 µm) [14 -- 16], to transcription factories containing ∼ 10 active transcription complexes (∼ 100 nm) [3, 34, 35]. Importantly, like most nuclear bodies, our clusters also retain a "memory" of their shape. Thus, in Figure 3A, when most of the components of the pink cluster on the left have turned over, the general shape of the cluster persists (see also Movies S4 and S5, and Fig. S4). This is because the chromatin scaffold associated with the pro- tein clusters (i.e., the sites of specific binding) retains a general 3D structure that does not change much over time (Fig. S5). Taken together, these results strongly support the conjecture that nuclear bodies emerge from the aggre- gation of bound switching proteins, and that switching both arrests phase separation and ensures that bound proteins continually exchange with the soluble pool. Notably, the nuclear bodies which our clusters resem- ble generally show FRAP recovery times in the range of tens of minutes [36 -- 38]. These time scales are too slow to be accounted for by diffusion, and too fast to be compatible with the thermodynamic unbinding of tightly bound proteins (see Supporting Information). Our re- sults suggest an attractive alternative explanation: that the recovery time, over which nuclear bodies recycle their proteins, is instead linked to protein modification, and it is simply proportional to α−1. Typical rates of post- translational protein modification can be of the order of several seconds (and will be slower within nuclear bodies due to macromolecular crowding), and transcription ter- mination occurs minutes after initiation. In light of this, our simulations would predict recovery time scales of the order of α−1, or minutes, broadly in agreement with those measured experimentally [36 -- 38]. Further to this, there is biological evidence that protein modifications can take place within nuclear bodies [36]. For instance, enzymes performing post-translational modifications are found in Figure 2: Mean field theory predicts arrested coarsening with protein modification. Dispersion relation, showing the growth rate, fluctuations around the uniform solution of Eqs. (B6), for D = A = 1, and X = 3.5 (cyan), corresponding to linear stability of the uniform λ, as a function of the magnitude of the wavevector, q, for phase, X = Xc = 4.0 (blue), marking the onset of instability, and X = 4.5 (red), revealing the growth of clusters with a characteristic length scale. The dotted black line shows a typical dispersion relation in the absence of protein modification, which leads to a long wavelength instability. C. Switching proteins with specific binding self- assemble into recycling nuclear bodies The model considered in Figure 1 assumes proteins bind non-specifically. While this is a good approximation for generic heterochromatin-binding proteins in silenced regions, most transcription factors bind to active regions specifically and to most other DNA non-specifically [32]. Therefore, we consider proteins binding with high affinity to every 20th bead (i.e., every 60 kbp), and with low affin- ity to all others. [Similar results are expected for differ- ent patterns of binding sites [6, 20].] Now bound proteins self-assemble into clusters of self-limiting size even when α = 0 (Fig. 3; Movie S3). In other words, coarsening is always arrested. As suggested previously [20, 23, 25], specific binding creates loops and loop clustering is asso- ciated with entropic costs that scale super-linearly with loop number, and this limits cluster growth [23]. Although coarsening is arrested whatever the value of α, there is a major difference between the dynam- ics of the equilibrium and switching proteins. Without switching, proteins can only unbind thermodynamically, which requires a long time: as a result, proteins rarely exchange between clusters (Fig. 3, Movie S3). With switching, there is a constant turnover of proteins within the clusters, which recycle all their components over a time ∼ α−1 (Fig. 3, Movie S4). Reducing the strength of the specific interactions can also lead to protein turnover (Fig. S2), but this requires fine tuning of the parame- ters so as to simultaneously ensure stable binding and the recycling of proteins in clusters. In contrast, protein modification naturally leads to such recycling for any val- ues of specific and non-specific binding affinity. To quantitatively characterize the dynamics of turnover within clusters, we perform a simulated fluorescence-recovery-after-photobleaching (FRAP) ex- periment [33]. In such an experiment some of the clusters 4 Figure 3: In silico FRAP (Brownian dynamics simulations). (A) Snapshots taken 104 (i,ii) or 2 × 104 (iii,iv) after equilibration, during an in silico FRAP experiment (only proteins -- and not chromatin beads -- are shown for clarity). (i) The simulation begins with N = 2000 equilibrium proteins, half of which are able to bind the chromatin fiber, both specifically (interaction strength 15 kB T , cut-off 1.8σ) to every 20-th bead in the polymer, and non-specifically (interaction strength 4 kB T , cut-off 1.8σ) to any other bead. After 104 time units, a structure with multiple clusters forms. The snapshot shows only a portion of this, for clarity; 5 clusters of bound proteins have developed (unbound proteins are colored gray, and bound ones in the 5 clusters a different color). Circled areas will be "photo-bleached". (ii) Photo-bleaching involves making bound proteins invisible (the bleached proteins are still present in the simulation). (iii) If proteins can switch, clusters reappear in the same general place (as new proteins replace their "bleached" counterparts). (iv) If proteins cannot switch (i.e., α = 0), clusters do not recover (as their protein constituents do not recycle). (B) FRAP recovery. Error bars give SD of mean, and time is given in multiples of 104 simulation units; the values of α, in units of inverse Brownian times, are as indicated in each panel. Only the post-bleaching signal is shown (the pre-bleaching value would be constant and equal to 1 in these units). (i) Number of unbleached proteins in the bleached volume (a sphere of 50σ) as a function of time, after bleaching. The signal is normalized with respect to the number of proteins initially in the bleached volume. (ii) Number of unbleached proteins in clusters as a function of time after bleaching, after all proteins in clusters at a given instant are bleached. The signal is normalized with respect to the proteins in clusters at the time of bleaching. Cajal bodies [36], and phosphorylation or ubiquination of the BMI1 subunit of the PcG PRC1 complex are im- portant factors which determine the kinetics of exchange in polycomb bodies [37]. D. Protein switching preserves TAD structure, while suppressing long-range interactions Clustering of bridging proteins can lead to the forma- tion of chromatin domains [5, 6, 6, 20] resembling TADs found in Hi-C data [19]. It is therefore of interest to ask how switching affects TAD structure and dynamics. Here, we return to a toy model first considered elsewhere: the fiber has a regular pattern of binding and non-binding regions (Fig. 4A), and each binding region spontaneously and reproducibly assembles into a TAD which is flanked by a disordered non-binding region [6]. The regular inter- spersion of non-binding segments in Figure 4A fixes the locations of TAD boundaries; consequently, clusters form (Fig. 4B,C) at reproducible positions along the fiber, and this -- in turn -- yields TADs seen in averaged contact maps (Fig. 4D). Such patterns resemble those seen in Hi-C data obtained from cell populations. Variations in α have several effects (Fig. 4). First, the configurations found at steady state are qualitatively dif- ferent. Although cluster growth is limited for both α = 0 and α > 0, the (recycling) clusters formed by switching proteins are much smaller (Figs. 4B, C, and Movie S6). Second (and notwithstanding this qualitative difference), the contact maps close to the diagonal are remarkably similar (Fig. 4D; compare patterns on each side immedi- ately next to the diagonal); this indicates that local TAD structure is largely unperturbed by switching. However, for α (cid:54)= 0 non-local (i.e., distant) contacts are strikingly suppressed (Fig. 4D, compare patterns on each side far 5 from the diagonal), and higher order folding of one TAD onto another is suppressed. This was demonstrated di- rectly as follows. First, TADs were generated in the presence of non-switching proteins, and then switching turned on; the fraction of non-local contacts falls (Figs 4E, S6). This behaviour can be explained as follows. First, the time scale for the formation of TADs is compara- ble to (or smaller than) that of protein recycling within a TAD (see Supporting Information for an estimate of such time scales). Computer simulations of TAD for- mation in Drosophila and human chromosomes also sug- gest that the local structure is formed very rapidly (at most, in minutes) [5, 6]. Therefore it is plausible that local TAD folding is fast enough not to be perturbed much by protein modification. Second, when a particu- lar protein switches from binding to non-binding, a con- tact is lost, and it is likely that local ones can reform faster than non-local ones. Furthermore, switching pro- vides a non-equilibrium mechanism allowing faster large- scale rearrangements, and so a more effective trimming of entropically unfavourable long-ranged interactions. In other words, active post-translational modification tilts the balance in favour of local intra-TAD contacts at the expenses of inter-TAD ones. This is consistent with the sharp decay beyond the Mbp scale seen in Hi-C data [19, 39]. II. CONCLUSIONS To conclude, we have shown that active post- translational protein modication (e.g., phosphoryla- tion, methylation, acetylation [27], or any other non- equilibrium reaction where a protein switches between binding and non-binding states) has a profound and generic effect on the behaviour of a chromatin-protein mixture. The interplay between protein bridging and protein modification is therefore an important principle underlying nuclear organization within eukaryotes. First, it was previously shown that non-switching pro- teins able to bind non-specifically to chromatin to form molecular bridges assemble into clusters which have a natural tendency to coarsen [20, 21]. Here we show that switching changes the behaviour; cluster growth is self- limiting (Fig. 1) -- a phenomenon which be understood via a simple mean field theory (Fig. 2). This theory provides an example of arrested phase separation, and it can explain why nuclear bodies do not progressively enlarge [13 -- 16], and why neighbouring clumps of hete- rochromatin -- whether detected using classical staining and microscopy, or through inspection of Hi-C contact maps [19, 40] -- rarely merge into one super-domain. Second, when equilibrium (i.e., non-switching) pro- teins bind specifically to cognates sites on the chromatin fiber, they also cluster; however, specific binding is known to arrest the coarsening [6, 20]. But in contrast to what is seen in photobleaching experiments [36, 37], bound pro- teins in the ensuing clusters exchange little with the solu- 6 Figure 4: Switching promotes intra-TAD contacts and suppresses inter-TAD ones. (A) Overview. Simulations involved N = 2000 non-switching (α = 0) or N = 2000 switching proteins (α = 0.0001 inverse Brownian times); for α = 0 half of the proteins are binding. In both cases, interaction energy and cut-off were 4 kB T and 1.8σ. The fiber (length 15 Mbp) consisted of regularly-interspersed segments containing runs of binding (blue) and non-binding (black) beads (segment sizes 900 and 300 kbp, respectively). (B,C) Snapshots taken after 105 simulation units. Non-binding and binding proteins are colored gray and red, respectively. (D) Contact maps (averages from 10 simulations) for non-switching (top-left triangle), and switching proteins (lower-right triangle). The scale (right) indicates contact frequencies. (E) The evolution of the ratio of non-local contacts over time. A local (non-local) contact is one between beads separated by less (more) than 1.2 Mbp along the fiber. Here the simulation was run for 105 simulation units with non-switching proteins; switching was then turned on (α = 0.0001 inverse Brownian times) and the simulation was run for a further 105 simulation units. ble pool. Moreover, the time scales seen in such bleaching experiments are too slow to be accounted for by diffusion, and too fast to be compatible with the thermodynamic unbinding of tightly-bound proteins. Protein modifica- tion provides a neat solution to this paradox: dynamic clusters naturally emerge during simulations, with con- stituent proteins recycling on a time-scale proportional to the inverse switching rate, α−1 (Fig. 3). Importantly, when clusters in simulations are "photobleached", they behave like nuclear bodies seen in vivo -- they retain a "memory" of their shape, despite the continual exchange with the soluble pool. Finally, switching affects large-scale chromatin orga- nization. Bridging-induced clusters are associated with the formation of chromatin domains, reminiscent of the TADs observed in Hi-C data [19]. Using a fiber patterned in such a way that it spontaneously folds into TADs, we find that switching has little effect on local TAD orga- nization, but strongly suppresses inter-TAD interactions; local contacts are favored over non-local ones (Fig. 4). We expect that similar trends should be observed in more complex models for bridging-induced chromosome orga- nization, such as those in Refs. [6, 6, 20]. While here we focus on a flexible chromatin fiber, we expect that near-identical results should be reached with a semi-flexible one [20, 22]; then, our conclusions should also apply to bacterial DNA. We also expect similar re- sults to be obtained with more complex pathways be- tween active and inactive states (e.g., modeling the cyclic flooding of proteins into nuclei, or their cyclic synthe- sis/degradation) and it would be of interest to investigate these scenarios. In summary, we demonstrated how non-equilibrium processes involving ephemeral protein states can provide a simple way of understanding how dynamic nuclear bod- ies of self-limiting size might form, and how chromosomal domains at the larger scale might be organized. This work was funded by ERC (Consolidator Grant 648050, THREEDCELLPHYSICS), and by a Marie Skodowska-Curie Intra European Fellowship (G. A. No. 654908). [1] Calladine, C. R., Drew, H. R., Luisi, B. F., Travers, A. A. (2004). Understanding DNA, 3rd Edition, Elsevier Aca- demic Press, London. [2] Alberts, B. et al. (2002). Molecular biology of the cell, Gar- land Science, New York. [3] Cook, P. R. (2001). Principles of Nuclear Structure and Function, Wiley-Liss (New York) (2001). [4] Dame, R. T., M. C. Noom, M. C., Wuite, G. J. (2006). Bacterial chromatin organization by H-NS protein unrav- elled using dual DNA manipulation. Nature 444, 387-390. [5] Simonis, M. et al. (2006) Nuclear organization of active and inactive chromatin domains uncovered by chromo- some conformation capture-on-chip (4C). Nat. Genet. 38, 1348-1354. [6] Barbieri, M. et al. (2012). Complexity of chromatin folding is captured by the strings and binders switch model. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 109, 16173-16178. [7] Brackley, C. A. et al. (2016). Predicting the three- dimensional folding of cis-regulatory regions in mam- malian genomes using bioinformatic data and polymer models. Gen. Biol. 17, 59 (2016). [8] Brackley, C. A., Johnson, J., Kelly, S., Cook, P. R., Maren- duzzo, D. (2016). Simulated binding of transcription fac- tors to active and inactive regions folds human chromo- somes into loops, rosettes and topological domains. Nucl. Acids Res. 44, 3503-3512. [9] Kilic, S., Bachmann, A. L., Bryan, L. C., Fierz, B. (2015). Multivalency governs HP1α association dynamics with the silent chromatin state. Nat. Commun. 6, 7313 (2015). [10] Harshman, S. W., Young, N. L., Parthun, M. R., Fre- itas, M. A. (2013). H1 histones: current perspectives and challenges. Nucl. Acids Res. 41, 9593-9609 (2013). [11] Wani, A. H. et al. (2016). Chromatin topology is coupled to Polycomb group protein subnuclear organization. Nat. Comm. 7, 10291. [12] Michieletto, D., Marenduzzo, D., Wani, A. H. (2016) folding path- interphase chromosomes. Chromosome-wide simulations uncover way and 3D organization of arXiv:1604.03041. [13] Zhu, L., Brangwynne, C. P. (2015). Nuclear bodies: the emerging biophysics of nucleoplasmic phases. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 34, 23-30. [14] Sleeman, J.E., Trinkle-Mulcahy, L. (2014). Nuclear bod- ies: new insights into assembly/dynamics and disease rel- evance. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 28, 76-83. [15] Mao, Y. S., Zhang, B., Spector, D. L. (2011) Biogenesis and function of nuclear bodies. Trends Genet. 27, 295-306. [16] Pirrotta, V., Li, H. B. (2012) A view of nuclear polycomb bodies. Curr. Opin. Gen. Devel. 22, 101-109. [17] Berry, J., Weber, S. C., Vaidya, N., Haataja, M., Brang- wynne, C. P. (2015). RNA transcription modulates phase transition-driven nuclear body assembly. [18] Brangwynne C. P., Tompa P., Pappu R. V., (2015) Poly- mer physics of intracellular phase transitions. Nat Phys. 11, 11, 899-904. [19] Dixon, J. R., Selvaraj, S., Yue, F., Kim, A., Li, Y., Shen, Y., Hu, H., Liu, J. S., Ren, B. (2012). Topological domains in mammalian genomes identified by analysis of chromatin interactions. Nature 485, (2012) 376-380. [20] Brackley, C. A, Taylor, S., Papantonis, A., Cook, P. R., Marenduzzo, D. (2013). Nonspecific bridging-induced at- traction drives clustering of DNA-binding proteins and genome organization. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 110, E3605-3611. [21] Johnson, J., Brackley, C. A., Cook, P. R., Marenduzzo, D. (2015). A simple model for DNA bridging proteins and bacterial or human genomes: bridging-induced attraction and genome compaction. J. Phys. Cond. Matt. 27, 064119. [22] Le Treut, G., Kepes, F., Orland, H. (2016). Phase Be- havior of DNA in the Presence of DNA-Binding Proteins Biophys. J. 110, 51-62 (2016). [23] Marenduzzo, D., Orlandini, E. (2009). Topological and entropic repulsion in biopolymers. JSTAT, L09002. [24] Cates, M. E., Witten, T. A. (1986). Chain conformation and solubility of associating polymers. Macromolecules 19, 732-739. [25] Orlandini, E., Garel, T. (1998). Collapse transitions of a periodic hydrophilic hydrophobic chain, Eur. Phys. J. B 6, 101-110. [26] Scolari, V. F., Lagomarsino, M. C. (2015). Combined col- lapse by bridging and self-adhesion in a prototypical poly- mer model inspired by the bacterial nucleoid. Soft Matter 11, 1677-1687. [27] Tootle, T. L., Rebay, I. (2005). Post-translational modifi- cations influence transcription factor activity: a view from the ETS superfamily. Bioessays 27, 285-298 (2005). [28] Nicodemi, M., Prisco, A. (2009). Thermodynamic Path- ways to Genome Spatial Organization in the Cell Nucleus. Biophys. J. 96, 2168-2177. [29] Chaikin, P. M., Lubensky, T. C. (2000). Principles of Condensed Matter Physics, Cambridge University Press. [30] Byrne, A., Kiernan, P., Green, D., Dawson, K. A. (1995). Kinetics of homopolymer collapse. J. Chem. Phys. 1012, 573-577 (1995). [31] Cross, M. C., Hohenberg, P. C. Pattern formation outside of equilibrium. Rev. Mod. Phys 65, 851-1112 (1993). [32] Sheinman, M., Benichou, O., Kafri, Y., Voituriez, R. (2012). Classes of fast and specific search mechanisms for 7 proteins on DNA. Rep. Progr. Phys. 7, 026601. [33] Mueller, F., Mazza, D., Stasevich, T. J., McNally, J. G. (2010).FRAP and kinetic modeling in the analysis of nu- clear protein dynamics: what do we really know? Curr Opin Cell Biol. 22, 403-411. [34] Papantonis, A., Cook, P.R. (2013). Transcription facto- ries; genome organization and gene regulation. Chem. Rev. 113, 8683-8705. [35] Marenduzzo, D., Micheletti, C., Cook, P. R. (2006). Entropy-driven genome organization. Biophys. J. 90, 3712-3721. [36] Handwerger, K. E., Murphy, C., Gall, J. G. (2003) Steady-state dynamics of Cajal body components in the Xenopus germinal vesicle. J. Cell. Biol. 160, 495-504. [37] Hern´andez-Munoz I, Taghavi P, Kuijl C, Neefjes J, van Lohuizen M. (2005) Association of BMI1 with polycomb bodies is dynamic and requires PRC2/EZH2 and the maintenance DNA methyltransferase DNMT1. Mol Cell Biol. 25 11047-58. [38] Kimura, H., Sugaya, K., Cook, P. R. (2002) The tran- scription cycle of RNA polymerase II in living cells. J. Cell Biol. 159, 777-782. [39] Sanborn, A. L. et al. (2015). Chromatin extrusion ex- plains key features of loop and domain formation in wild- type and engineered genomes. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 112, E6456-E6465 [40] Sexton, T. et al. (2012). Three-dimensional folding and functional organization principles of the Drosophila genome. Cell 148, 458-472. 8 Supplementary Information Here we give more details on the simulations (includ- ing parameter values), and on the continuum mean field model (derivation, linear stability analysis and amplitude equation); we also show additional results and figures which are discussed in the main text. Appendix A: Simulation Details The chromatin fiber is modeled as a bead-spring poly- mer with finitely-extensible non-linear elastic springs via a Kremer-Grest model [1]. To map length scales from simulation to physical units, we can, e.g., set the diam- eter, σ, of each bead to ∼ 30nm(cid:39) 3 kbp (assuming an underlying 30 nm fiber; of course, all our results would remain valid with a different mapping). Letting ri and di,j ≡ rj−ri be respectively the position of the centre of the i-th bead and the vector of length di,j between beads i and j, we can express the potential modeling the connectivity of the chain as UFENE(i, i + 1) = − k 2 R2 0 ln 1 − (cid:34) (cid:18) di,i+1 (cid:19)2(cid:35) , R0 for di,i+1 < R0 and UFENE(i, i + 1) = ∞, otherwise; here we chose R0 = 1.6 σ and k = 30 /σ2. The bending rigidity of the chain is described through a standard Kratky-Porod potential, as follows (cid:20) 1 − di,i+1 · di+1,i+2 di,i+1di+1,i+2 (cid:21) , Ub(i, i + 1, i + 2) = kBT lp σ where we set the persistence length lp = 3σ (cid:39) 90 nm, which is reasonable for a chromatin fiber. The steric interaction between a chromatin bead, a, and a protein bridge, b (of sizes σa = σb = σ), is modeled through a truncated and shifted Lennard-Jones potential (cid:34)(cid:18) σ di,j (cid:19)12 − (cid:18) σ (cid:19)6 − (cid:18) σ (cid:19)12 + di,j rc (cid:18) σ rc ULJ(i, j) = 4ab (cid:19)6(cid:35) for di,j < rc and 0 otherwise. This parameter, rc, is the interaction cutoff; it is set to rc = 21/6σ for inactive proteins, in order to model purely repulsive interactions, and to rc = 1.8σ for an active protein, so as to include attractive interactions. In both cases, the potential is shifted to zero at the cut-off in order to have a smooth curve and avoid singularities in the forces. Purely re- pulsive interactions, such as those between inactive pro- teins and chromatin segments, are modeled by setting ab = kBT , while attractive interactions are modeled us- ing: (i) ab = 3kBT (for non-specific interactions, Fig. 1); (ii) ab = 15kBT and ab = 4kBT (for non-specific and specific interactions respectively, Fig. 3); (iii) = 4kBT (for non-specific interactions, Fig. 4); or (iv) as specified in Supporting Figure captions in other cases. 9 The total potential energy experienced by bead i is given by Ui = + (cid:88) (cid:88) j (cid:88) j k UFENE(i, j)δj,i+1+ Ub(i, j, k)δj,i+1δk,i+2 + (A1) ULJ(i, j), (cid:88) j and its dynamics can be described by the Langevin equa- tion mri = −ξ ri − ∇Ui + ηi, (A2) where m is the bead mass, ξ is the friction coefficient, and ηi is a stochastic delta-correlated noise. The variance of each Cartesian component of the noise, σ2 η, satisfies the usual fluctuation dissipation relation σ2 the LJ time τLJ = σ(cid:112)m/ and the Brownian time As is customary [1], we set m/ξ = τLJ = τB, with η = 2ξkBT . τB = σ/Db, where is the simulation energy unit, equal to kBT , and Db = kBT /ξ is the diffusion coefficient of a bead of size σ. From the Stokes friction coefficient for spherical beads of diameter σ we have that ξ = 3πηsolσ where ηsol is the solution viscosity. One can map this to physical units by setting the viscosity to that of the nucleoplasm, which ranges between 10 − 100 cP, and by setting T = 300 K and σ = 30 nm, as above. From this it follows that τLJ = τB = 3πηsolσ3/ (cid:39) 0.6 − 6 ms; τB is our time simulation unit, used when measuring time in the figures in the main text and in this Supporting Information. The numerical integration of Eq. (A2) is performed using a standard velocity-Verlet algorithm with time step ∆t = 0.01τB and is implemented in the LAMMPS engine. We perform simulations for up to 2×105 τB, which correspond to 2-20 minutes in real time. Appendix B: Phenomenological Mean Field Model for Bridges with Active Modification , In our particle based simulations we observed the growth of clusters due to bridging interactions (see main text). When protein activation-inactivation reactions were absent, these clusters coarsened, resulting in one large macroscopic cluster in steady state. However, in the presence of these reactions, the clusters coarsened only up to a self-limiting size. To better understand this tran- sition from macrophase separation to microphase sepa- ration, and the involved length scales, we now develop a phenomenological minimal model for the dynamics of chromatin and proteins. We describe the distribution of chromatin via the probability density field ρ(x, t), and the density of active, or binding, and inactive, or non- binding, proteins by Φa(x, t) ≡ Φ(x, t) and Φi(x, t) re- spectively. The starting point for our model is the free energy F =(cid:82) f (x)dx where f is the free energy density: f = D(cid:48) 1 2 ρ2 + D(cid:48) 2 2 Φ2 − χ(cid:48)ρΦ + k(cid:48) 2 (∇ρ)2 + g(cid:48) 4 ρ4. (B1) Here, the first two terms describe diffusion of chromatin and proteins respectively, the third term describes the energy gain through bridging and the last two terms, multiplied by k(cid:48), g(cid:48), respectively penalize sharp interfaces due to interfacial tension, and strong accumulations of chromatin due to short ranged repulsions. Assuming diffusive dynamics here and using the fact that in the absence of protein modification, the number density of all species (ρ, Φ, Φi) is conserved, we can derive the equations of motions for our fields as done for model B dynamics [2]. However, in the presence of active pro- tein modification, we need an additional reaction term, so that our equations of motion read Appendix C: Linear Stability Analysis To better understand in which parameter regimes we should expect (i) a uniform distribution of chromatin and proteins, (ii) cluster growth proceeding to macro- scopic phase separation and (iii) microphase separation, we now perform a linear stability analysis. This analysis will equip us with a prediction for the self-limiting cluster size in regime (iii), matching the results of our particle based simulations. We therefore study the response of the uniform phase to small perturbations in the density fields (ρ, Φ). Linearising Eqs. (B6,B7) around the uniform so- lution (ρ, Φ) = (ρ0, Φ0), where ρ0 is the DNA density as fixed by the initial state, leads to the following equations of motion for the fluctuations ρ(cid:48) = ρ − ρ0, Φ(cid:48) = Φ − Φ0: ρ(cid:48) = D∇2ρ(cid:48) − A∇4ρ − ∇2Φ(cid:48), Φ(cid:48) = ∇2Φ(cid:48) − X∇2ρ(cid:48) − Φ(cid:48). (C1) (C2) ρ = −Mρ∇2 δF Φa = −Ma∇2 δF δρ , δΦa − αΦa + βΦi. (B2) (B3) Here, we defined D := D0 + 3Gρ2 0. Fourier transforming Eqs. (C1,C2) and using Q := q2 leads to the following dispersion relation (or characteristic polynomial), Here Mρ and Ma are dimensionless mobility coefficients of chromatin and activated proteins respectively, while α and β are the activation and inactivation rates for pro- teins. Since inactive proteins do not bind, we assume that they diffuse quickly, i.e. that their density field is uniform. Now integrating Eq. (B3) over the whole system and denoting the total number of active and inactive pro- teins with Na(t) and Ni(t) respectively, we obtain Na = −αNa + βNi. Conservation of the total protein num- Ni = (1 + β/α)Ni ber N = Na + Nb now yields which approaches the steady state Ni = αN/(α + β), i.e. Φi = α/(α + β), exponentially fast. Now defining Φ0 := (β/α)Φi = β/(α + β) (and ignoring short-time effects due to possible 'imbalances' between active and inactive proteins in the initial state), Eqs. (B2,B3) re- duce to: ρ = Mρ∇2[a1ρ − k∇2ρ − χΦ + gρ3], Φ = MΦ∇2[a2Φ − χρ] − α(Φ − Φ0), (B4) (B5) where for simplicity hereon we drop the subscript a on Φa for active proteins. We also introduced D1 = Mρa1 and D2 = MΦa2. To further reduce these equations and to identify a minimal set of dimensionless control parameters, we now choose time and space units tu = 1/α and xu =(cid:112)D2/α and redefine Φ = ΦχMρ/D2. This leads to ρ = D0∇2ρ − A∇4ρ − ∇2φ + G∇2ρ3, Φ = ∇2Φ − X∇2ρ − (Φ − Φ0). (B6) (B7) 1 2 (cid:113) [−1 − Q (1 + D + AQ) ± [−1 + Q(D − 1 + AQ)]2 + 4Q2X (cid:21) , (C3) λ(Q) = ± which links the growth rate λ of the fluctuation with its wavevector Q. An analysis of this relation leads us to the instability criterion (cid:112) √ X > XC := A + √ √ D, which translates, in physical units, to (cid:114) kα χ > + MΦ (cid:115) (cid:20) D1 Mρ D2 MΦ + 3gρ2 0 (C4) (C5) (cid:21) . This criterion determines the transition line (hypersur- face) between regions (i) and (ii/iii) in the parameter space. Hence, if the bridging interactions are sufficiently large, small fluctuations around the uniform state will grow to form clusters. Remarkably, this instability and the corresponding emergence of order (clustered phase) is not contingent on the presence of a certain minimal pro- tein (or DNA) density, suggesting that even a very low protein concentration is sufficient to trigger clustering. aration to microseparation (at the onset of ity), instability first occurs. To map out the transition line from macrophase sep- instabil- it is useful to consider the wavelength at which From Eq. (C3) and qc = D)2, we find qc = (D/A)1/4, corre- ∂qλ(q) = 0X=( √ A+ √ sponding, in physical units, to the length scale (cid:18) D1D2 + 3Mρgρ2 0D2 (cid:19)1/4 αkMρ . (C6) That is, our parameter space is spanned by the four 2); D0 = dimensionless numbers X = (χ2MρMΦ/D2 (D1/D2); A = αkMρ/(D2 2) and G = gMρ/D2. Lc = 2π qc = 2π 10 (cid:18)0 (cid:19) 0 (cid:18)∂2 We begin by rewriting Eqs. (B2,B3) as (cid:19) (cid:18) ρ(cid:48) Φ(cid:48) L + N − (cid:18) ρ(cid:48) (cid:19) Φ(cid:48) = , (D1) where the linear operator L and the nonlinear term N represent (cid:18)D∂2 (cid:19) x −∂2 x − 1 ∂2 x x − A∂4 −X∂2 x L = ; N = G xρ(cid:48)3 + 3ρ0∂2 xρ(cid:48)2 0 (D2) (cid:19) . Now, we replace (as usual, see [3]) √ X → (1 + )XC; where = (X − XC)/XC and expand the fields as ∂x → ∂x + ∂X ; ∂t → ∂T (D3) ∞(cid:88) ∞(cid:88) ρ(cid:48) = n/2ρn−1; Φ(cid:48) = n/2Φn−1. (D4) n=1 n=1 Next, we plug these expansions into Eqs. (D2) and solve the resulting equations to lowest order (1/2). Us- ing the Ansatz ρ0 = A exp (iqcx) + c.c. and Φ0 = Aφ exp (iqcx) + c.c. with amplitudes A,Aφ, we find qc = (D/A)1/4 reproducing the corresponding result from our linear stability analysis (see above), as well as Aφ = c ) = A√DXC which fixes the relation be- A(D + Aq2 tween the amplitudes of both density fields. The solution of our perturbative equations to order 1/2 then reads ρ(cid:48) = 2A cos qcx with the so-far unknown amplitude A. The result to order turns out not to be particular use- ful for our purpose, as solving it would provide us with a similar result as to order 1/2), but with another un- known amplitude A(cid:48) yielding a higher order correction to the solution ρ(cid:48) = 2A cos qcx. Since we are looking only for the lowest order result in we directly consider the perturbative equations of motion to order 3/2. As usual [3], we do not attempt to solve the corresponding equa- tions explicitly, but apply Fredholm's theorem providing solvability conditions, which determine an equation of motion for A. After a long but straightforward calcula- tion and transforming back to coordinates t, x we find: ct A = A + cx∂2 xA + c3A3, (cid:19) (cid:18) 1 D , XC (cid:114) A 4A√DXC 3G√DXC 1 + , . where ct = cx = c3 = (D5) (D6) (D7) (D8) Eq. (D5) is a variant of the real Ginzburg-Landau equation, here describing, together with the coefficients Eqs. (D6 -- D8), the dynamics of chromatin and proteins close to the onset of instability. In this equation /(cttu) Figure S1: Comparision between mean field predictions and simulation results for cluster size. Simulations are like the ones illustrated in Fig. 1 of the main text (except for the value of α, which is varied). Dots show saturation values (± SD) of number of particles per cluster N (after 1.5 × 105 simulation units); the line shows a least-squares fit with a slope of −0.756. Thus, in an infinite system, coarsening only occurs for α = 0. [In finite systems macrophase separation is ob- served if α is small enough that Lc exceeds the system size.] From this analysis we expect the average parti- c ∝ α−3/4 (at cle number per cluster to scale as N ∝ L3 least close to the onset of instability). This value agrees well with the numerically observed scaling of N ∝ α−0.76 (Fig. S1), supporting the view that the essential physics of chromatin clustering can be described and understood within our simplified mean field theory. For completeness, we also calculate the boundaries of the instability band from Eq. (C3), which, after translat- ing back into physical units (for M1 = M2 = 1), read as follows: (cid:114) ν ±(cid:113) ν = (cid:2)χ2 − D1D2 − 3D2gρ2 1√ 2D2K q± = 0 − Kα(cid:3) . (C8) At the onset of instability, we find ν → 4D2Kα(D1 + 3gρ0) and hence we recover the α1/4-scaling of the onset mode. In contrast, the boundaries of the instability band scale in a more complicated way which is nonuniversal in α. ν2 − 4D2Kα(D1 + 3gρ2 0),(C7) Appendix D: Amplitude Equations We now perform a perturbative analysis of the linearly unstable modes (fluctuations) close to onset of instability. This analysis will lead us to a further reduced effective model, describing the linear growth and nonlinear satu- ration of chromatin clusters on large scales and at long timescales. 11 (cid:112)/c3 de- √ (cid:104)√ √D(cid:105)2 is the initial growth rate of protein clusters; xu scribes the amplitude of their saturation (related to their density) for a given X > cx is a correlation length, describing a scale of spatial modula- tions of the saturation amplitude of DNA clusters. and xu A + Although we equipped our original equilibrium model with reaction terms which drive it out of equilibrium, its large scale and long time dynamics (i.e., Eq. (D5)) can be effectively mapped (at least close to onset of instabil- ity) onto a potential system with the following Lyapunov functional: V[A] = (cid:104)−A2 + x∂XA2(cid:105) A4 + c2 (cid:90) , (D9) dx c3 2 A = −1 cT δV δA . (D10) Hence, quite remarkably, the dynamics of the present reaction-diffusion system can be mapped, within this ap- proximation, onto a system which is purely relaxational. shows recovery also for equilibrium bridges, if the specific and non-specific interactions are carefully tuned. How- ever, protein modification provides a more robust way to achieve this, which simultaneously allows stable bind- ing (when the protein is in the active state), and fast turnover (due to the unbinding and diffusion of inactive proteins). Figure S3 shows the cluster size for different parame- ter values for the case of non-specific protein-chromatin interactions. This demonstrates that it can be varied significantly (by about an order of magnitude), and is particularly sensitive to the protein concentration. (A) (B) Figure S2: Comparison of FRAP recovery for non-switching and switching proteins. FRAP recovery, measured as the number of unbleached proteins which are in the bleached volume after bleaching. The signals are normalized with the number of proteins in the bleached volume at the time of bleaching. As in Fig. 3Bi, the bleached volume is a sphere of size 50σ. Error bars give SD of mean, and time is given in multiples of 104 simulation units. Values of the specific and non-specific interactions, and of α, were respectively: 15kB T , 4kB T , 0 (red curve), 8kB T , 3kB T , 0 (green curve), and 15kB T , 4kB T , 0.0001 inverse Brownian times (blue curve). It can be seen that varying the values of non-specific and specific interactions can lead to FRAP recovery also for α = 0 (green curve), although, in the absence of fine tuning, this is to a smaller extent with respect to α (cid:54)= 0 (blue curve). Figure S3: Cluster size with specific binding. (A) Plot of the average number of proteins in a cluster versus time (± SD), for N = 2000 switching proteins binding to the chromatin fiber, both specifically (interaction strength 15 kB T , cut-off 1.8σ), to every 20-th bead in the polymer, and non-specifically (interaction strength 4 kB T , cut-off 1.8σ) to any other bead. From top to bottom, curves correspond to α = 0 (in which case half of the proteins are non-binding, and half binding), 0.0001, 0.0002, 0.0003, 0.0004, 0.0005 respectively. (B) Same as (A), but now for N = 500 switching proteins, with specific interaction strength of 8kB T and non-specific interaction of 3kB T ; the interaction cut-off is 1.8σ. Appendix E: Additional simulation results In this section we present additional simulation results, which complement those discussed in the main text. Figure S2 shows that the FRAP signal (following sim- ulated photobleaching of a spherical spot of size 50 σ) Figs. S4 and S5 highlight some further properties of the recycling clusters. In particular, Fig. S4 shows that these clusters retain memory of their shape even as the proteins which constitute them change. Figure S5 shows the dynamics of some protein and chromatin beads with and without modification. Without modification, once proteins bind to a cluster they diffuse little for the rest 12 (Ai) (Bi) (Aii) (Bii) Figure S4: Switching proteins form clusters which retain memory of their shape. This figure follows the evolution of clusters in a simulation analogous to that of Fig. 3A in the main text; the same parameters apply. Only proteins -- and not chromatin beads -- are shown for clarity. (A) Snapshots taken 104 time units after equilibration, for non-switching proteins, showing two clusters (beads are colored according to the cluster they belong to); (ii) shows another cluster. (B) Snapshots of the same regions shown in (A) after another 105 simulation units, and after allowing the proteins to now switch (α = 0.0001τ −1 B ). Clusters recycle their constituent proteins whilst retaining a very similar shape. of the simulation, whereas with modification they sample the whole simulation domain. Contrary to this, the dy- namics of the chromatin beads within a cluster is similar with and without modification: they diffuse very little. This explains why clusters keep their shape: while pro- teins bind and unbind, the underlying chromatin back- bone is largely unchanged. Finally, Fig. S6 shows how the effect of protein switching on the ratio between non-local and local contacts, shown in Fig. 4 in the main text, is affected by the values of non-specific and specific interactions. 13 Appendix F: Timescale estimates for FRAP exper- iments and TAD folding Here we provide a series of simple estimates for the value of the relevant timescales in our problems. Con- sider first a fluorescence-recovery-after-photobleaching, or FRAP, experiment, where a cluster of size σcl ∼ 0.1−1 µm is inside the bleached spot, which we imagine has a di- ameter of σFRAP ∼ 1 µm. In this Section, as previously, σ will instead denote the size of a typical chromatin- binding complex, or chromatin bead (as previously, we imagine this is ∼ 30 nm). What is the timescale for the recovery of the FRAP signal? Clearly, this depends on the underlying dynamics of the bleached/unbleached proteins. If proteins diffuse freely, then unbleached proteins can enter the bleach spot to give recovery within a time, τdiff , proportional to τdiff ∼ σ2 FRAP D . (F1) For a protein size σ ∼ 30 nm, and if the nucleoplasm viscosity is 10 cP (ten times that of water), the diffusion coefficient is ∼ 1.4µm2 s−1, so that τdiff ∼ 1s, which is too fast to account for FRAP response of nuclear bodies (furthermore, of course, freely diffusing proteins could not self-organise into clusters). If, instead, non-switching binding proteins create a cluster, then the FRAP signal recovers when some pro- teins unbind, and others replace these from the soluble (unbleached) pool. As the former process is slower than the latter (which relies again on diffusion), we can equate the FRAP recovery timescale to the time needed for an equilibrium protein to unbind from the cluster, which can be estimated as, (cid:18) ∆U (cid:19) kBT τnon−switch ∼ σ2 cl D exp (F2) Figure S5: Trajectories of proteins and high-affinity chromatin beads. Simulations are as in Fig. 3 of the main text; the same parameters apply. Positions of proteins and chromatin beads are shown in a 2D projection of the simulation domain, positions on the axes are measured in units of σ. (A) Non-switching proteins. (i) Red, proteins, recorded every 100 τB in a simulation (total length 1.5 × 105 simulation units. In this case, all three proteins remain bound to one green and blue circles denote positions of three non-switching cluster throughout the time series. (ii) Red, green and blue circles denote positions of three high affinity chromatin beads, again recorded every 100 τB in the same simulation. All three chromatin beads remain in the same cluster. (B) Same as (A), but for switching proteins (α = 0.0001 inverse Brownian times). Now the three switching proteins diffuse through the whole space, while the three chromatin beads are still confined; this shows that the underlying scaffold of the cluster persists as the proteins are recycled. where ∆U indicates the strength of chromatin-protein interaction. If we assume an interaction of 10 kcal/mol, consistent with either multiple non-specific or a single specific DNA-protein interactions, then τnon−switch > 105 s, which is too slow to account for the FRAP recovery observed in nuclear bodies. Clearly, changing ∆U will change τnon−switch, but in order for the estimate to be in the observed range, the interaction energy would have to be finely tuned, and would be significantly lower than that seen in typical DNA-protein interactions. If, finally, switching proteins are in the cluster, then the unbinding time, which again can be equated to the FRAP recovery time, is simply τnon−switch ∼ α−1. (F3) For typical post-translational modification, or transcrip- tion termination, this is in the several seconds to minutes timescale, which is compatible with experimental results. Aside from FRAP, another important timescale is that over which local TADs form (e.g., in Fig. 4), τTAD. In Figure S6: Chromatin contacts for different choices of specific and non-specific binding affinities. The plot shows the fraction of non-local versus local contacts for a chromatin fiber; fiber patterning and all parameters are as in Fig. 4 of the main text. Simulations initially involved non-switching proteins; half-way through the simulation, proteins began to switch (α = 0.0001 inverse Brownian times). Contacts are classified as local (non-local) if they involve beads separated less than (more than) 400 beads along the chain (or 1.2 M bp. Non-specific (1) and specific (2 interaction energies are indicated on the right of the plot, in the format (1, 2). 14 analogy with polymer collapse and heteropolymer folding (see, e.g., Ref. [4]), we expect τTAD, to be a power law in the number of monomers in the TAD, say M , where the prefactor should describe microscopic (diffusion) dynam- ics of a monomer. Dimensional analysis then suggests τTAD ∼ σ2 D M z ∼ τBM z (F4) where z is a scaling exponent. The Brownian time τB is of the order of 10−3 s with previous assumptions for vis- cosity and monomer size, while in our simulations z (cid:39) 1 at least up to M ∼ 100 (corresponding to 300 kbp). Also for eukaryotic chromosomes, TAD size is between 100 kbp and 1 Mbp, so M is at most a few hundred. Therefore, if z = 1, we estimate τTAD to be of the order of 1 s, smaller than typical modification times -- even assuming a larger effective value of z (e.g., z = 2 gives at most τTAD of order of 1 min). Previous large-scale simulations also confirm that eukaryotic TADs form in minutes [5, 6]. These esti- mates explain why switching proteins in our simulations can still form TADs in pretty much the same way as non- switching proteins, and suggest that the same should also hold for real chromosomes. switch at a rate α = 0.0001 inverse Brownian times. Switching arrests coarsening, and leads to clusters of self-limiting size in steady state. Supplementary Movie 3: Parameters for this Movie are as in Fig. 3 of the main text for the α = 0 case. Chromatin beads are not shown for simplicity. The movie starts with clusters which have formed during 104 simulation units following equilibration. The proteins are colored according to the cluster they belong to when the movie starts; proteins not in any clusters at that time are gray. The movie then follows the dynamics with non-switching proteins, for another 104 simulation units: it can be seen that colored clusters persist, therefore photobleaching such a cluster would lead to little or no recovery of signal in the cluster. Supplementary Movie 4: As Supplementary Movie 3, but now with switching proteins (α = 0.0001 inverse Brownian times). Proteins are colored according to the initial clusters; by the end of the simulations all clusters have mixed colors. While proteins in clusters recycle, the cluster retains the same overall shape. Appendix G: Captions of Supplementary Movies Supplementary Movie 1: A movie of the simu- lation shown in Figure 1C of the main text. Proteins do not switch (α = 0). First a snapshot 104 simulation units after equilibration is shown: a number of small clusters have formed. Then the subsequent dynamics are shown: clusters grow and merge, and coarsening proceeds indefinitely. Supplementary Movie 2: A movie of the simu- lution shown in Figure 1D of the main text. Proteins Supplementary Movie 5: As in Supplementary Movie 4, but a zoom on two clusters to show more clearly clusters retain a "memory" of their shape. Supplementary Movie 6: A movie of the simulation shown in Figure 4 in the main text. The first half of the simulation involves non-switching proteins and lasts 105 simulation units: two clusters form. Proteins are black; yellow chromatin beads are binding, while blue ones are non-binding. During the second half, proteins are able to switch (α = 0.0001 inverse Brownian times); clusters split and interdomain interactions are suppressed. [1] Kremer K., Grest G. S. (1990) Dynamics of entangled lin- ear polymer melts: A molecular-dynamics simulation. J. Chem. Phys. 92(8):5057. [2] P.M. Chaikin, P. M., Lubensky, T. C. (2000). Principles of condensed matter physics, Cambrdige University Press, Cambridge. [3] Cross, M. C., Hohenberg, P. C. Pattern formation outside of equilibrium. Rev. Mod. Phys 65, 851-1112 (1993). [4] Byrne, A., Kiernan, P., Green, D., Dawson, K. A. (1995). Kinetics of homopolymer collapse. J. Chem. Phys. 1012, 573-577 (1995). [5] Michieletto, D., Marenduzzo, D., Wani, A. H. (2016) folding path- interphase chromosomes. Chromosome-wide simulations uncover way and 3D organization of arXiv:1604.03041. [6] Brackley, C. A., Johnson, J., Kelly, S., Cook, P. R., Maren- duzzo, D. (2016). Simulated binding of transcription fac- tors to active and inactive regions folds human chromo- somes into loops, rosettes and topological domains. Nucl. Acids Res. 44, 3503-3512. 15
1002.0663	1	1002	2010-02-03T08:16:19	Linear dielectric response of clustered living cells	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.CB" ]	The dielectric behavior of a linear cluster of two or more living cells connected by tight junctions is analyzed using a spectral method. The polarizability of this system is obtained as an expansion over the eigenmodes of the linear response operator, showing a clear separation of geometry from electric parameters. The eigenmode with the second largest eigenvalue dominates the expansion as the junction between particles tightens, but only when the applied field is aligned with the cluster axis. This effect explains a distinct low-frequency relaxation observed in the impedance spectrum of a suspension of linear clusters.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Linear dielectric response of clustered living cells Titus Sandu,1 Daniel Vrinceanu,2 and Eugen Gheorghiu1 1International Center for Biodynamics, Bucharest, Romania∗ 2Department of Physics, Texas Southern University, Houston, Texas 77004, USA (Dated: June 7, 2018) Abstract The dielectric behavior of a linear cluster of two or more living cells connected by tight junctions is analyzed using a spectral method. The polarizability of this system is obtained as an expansion over the eigenmodes of the linear response operator, showing a clear separation of geometry from electric parameters. The eigenmode with the second largest eigenvalue dominates the expansion as the junction between particles tightens, but only when the applied field is aligned with the cluster axis. This effect explains a distinct low-frequency relaxation observed in the impedance spectrum of a suspension of linear clusters. PACS numbers: 41.20.Cv, 87.19.rf, 87.50.C- 0 1 0 2 b e F 3 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 3 6 6 0 . 2 0 0 1 : v i X r a ∗Electronic address: [email protected] 1 I. INTRODUCTION Particle polarizability governs the electric response for many inhomogeneous systems ranging from biological cells to plasmonic nanoparticles and depends strongly on both its dielectric and geometric properties. Analytical models have been reported [1, 2] only for spherical and ellipsoidal geometries, whereas more complex geometries have been approached by direct numerical solution of the field equations using, for example, the finite difference methods [3], the finite element method [4], the boundary element method [5, 6], or the boundary integral equation (BIE) [7]. In a simplified representation, biological cells can be regarded as homogeneous particles (cores) covered by thin membranes (shells) of contrasting electric conductivities and permit- tivities. Complex geometries occur when cells are undergoing division cycles (e.g. budding yeasts) or are coupled in functional tissues (e.g. lining epithelia or myocardial syncytia). In these cases, the dielectric/impedance analysis of cellular systems is far more complicated than previous models [8 -- 10], which considered suspensions of spherical particles. Intriguing dielectric spectra [11] reveal distinct dielectric dispersions with time evolutions consistently related to tissue functioning or alteration, identifying a possible role of cell connectors (gap junctions) in shaping the overall dielectric response. A direct relation between the microscopic parameters and experimental data can be analytically derived only for dilute suspensions of particles of simple shapes, and is rather challenging for system with more realistic shapes, where only purely numerical solutions have been available. In this work we demonstrate that a spectral representation of a BIE provides the analytical structure for the polarizability of particles with a wide range of shapes and structures. The numerically calculated parameters encode particle's geometry information and are accessible by experiments. By using single and double-layer potentials [12], the Laplace equation for the fields inside and outside the particle is transformed into an integral equation. A spectral representation for the solution of this equation is obtained providing the eigenvalue problem for the linear response operator is solved. Although not symmetric, this operator has a real spectrum bounded by -1/2 and 1/2 [13 -- 15] and its eigenvectors are orthogonal to those of the conjugate double-layer operator. A matrix representation is obtained by using a finite basis of surface functions. 2 The true advantage of the spectral method is that the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the integral operator provide valuable insight into the dielectric behavior of clusters of biological cells. The eigenvectors are a measure of surface charge distributions due to a field. Only eigenvectors with a non-zero dipole moment contribute to the polarizability of the particle. We call these dipole-active eigenmodes. An effective separation of the geometric and mor- phologic properties from dielectric properties is therefore achieved [16]. We also show that for a particle covered by multiple confocal shells, the relaxation spectrum is a sum of Debye terms with the number of relaxations equal to the number of interfaces times the number of dipole-active eigenvalues. This is a generalization of a previous result [17] on cells of arbitrary shape. Our method is related to another spectral approach which uses an eigenvalue differential equation [18 -- 21]. This method has been applied to biological problems by Lei et al. [22] and by Huang et al. [23]. These authors, however, considered homogeneous cells with much simpler expression for cell polarizability. The BIE spectral method seeks a solution on the boundary surface defining the particle, as opposed to the eigenvalue differential equation, where the solution is defined in the entire space. In a previous study on double (budding) cells it was shown that before cells separation an additional dispersion occurs [24]. Moreover, in recent papers [3, 25] numerical experiments have shown that the dielectric spectra of a suspension of dimer cells connected by tight junctions exhibit an additional, distinct low-frequency relaxation. Our numerical calculation shows that the largest dipole-active eigenvalue approaches the value of 1/2 as the junction become tighter. Although the coupling of this eigenmode with the electric field stimulus is relatively modest (the coupling weight is about 1-2 %), this eigenmode has a significant contribution to the polarizability of clusters. Thus the eigenmodes close to 1/2 induce an additional low-frequency relaxation in the dielectric spectra of clustered biological cells even though the coupling is quite small. Needle-like objects, such as elongated spheroids or long cylinders, have similar polarizability features. In this paper we consider rotationally symmetric linear clusters made of up to 4 identi- cal particles covered by thin insulating membranes and connected by junctions of variable tightness. Convenient and flexible representations for the surfaces describing these objects are provided. The number of relaxations in the dielectric spectrum of the linear clusters, their time constants and their relative strengths are analyzed in terms of the eigenmodes of 3 the linear response operator specific to the given shape. II. THEORY A. Effective permittivity of a suspension We consider a suspension of identical, randomly oriented particles of arbitrary shape and dielectric permittivity, ε1, immersed in a dielectric medium of dielectric permittivity, ε0. The dielectric permittivities are in general complex quantities and the theory described here applies also for time-dependent fields, providing that the size of a particle is much smaller than the wavelength. When an applied uniform electric field interacts with the suspension, the response of the system is linear with the applied field and an effective permittivity for the whole sample can be measured and is defined by [25 -- 27]: εsus = ε0 + f αε0 1 − f α 3 . (1) This result is obtained in the limit of low concentration, weak intensity of the stimulus field, and using an effective medium theory within the dipole approximation. Here f = NV1/V is the volume fraction of all N particles, each of volume V1, with respect to the total volume of the suspension V . The averaged normalized polarizability α of a particle is defined as [25, 27, 28] α = 1 4π V1 ZV1ZΩN (cid:18)ε1 − ε0 ε0 (cid:19) E (N) · N dΩN dV (2) where E (N) is the electric field perturbation created inside the particle under a normalized applied electric excitation with direction N and dΩN is the solid angle element generated by that direction. The above normalized polarizability is dimensionless and is obtained by multiplying the standard polarizability of a particle with the factor 4π/V1. In the following we will refer only to normalized polarizability, thus, without any confusion, the normalized polarizability α will be simply called polarizability. The directional average in (2) is equiv- alent to the averaged sum over three orthogonal axes due to the fact that the problem is linear with respect to the applied field. The latter is more convenient from computational point of view. The electric field inside a particle is obtained by solving the following Laplace equation 4 for the electric potential Φ: ∆Φ (x) = 0, ε0 Φ+ = Φ− , ∂Φ ∂n(cid:12)(cid:12)+ = ε1 Φ → −x · N, ∂Φ ∂n(cid:12)(cid:12)− , x ∈ ℜ3\Σ x ∈ Σ x ∈ Σ x → ∞ (3) where ℜ3 is the euclidian 3-dimensional space and Σ is the surface of the particle. The derivatives are taken with respect to the normal vector n to the surface Σ. Due to the mismatch between the polarization inside and outside the object, electric charges accumulate at the interface Σ and create an electric potential which counteracts the uniform electric field stimulus. The solution of the above Laplace problem (3) is therefore formally given by Φ(x) = −x · N + 1 4πZΣ µ(y) x − y dΣ(y) (4) The single layer charge distribution µ induced by the normalized electric field is a solution of the following BIE, obtained by inserting solution (4) in equations (3) µ(x) 2λ − 1 4πZΣ µ(y) n(x) · (x − y) x − y3 dΣ(y) = n(x) · N (5) Here the parameter λ = (ε1−ε0)/(ε1+ε0) isolates all the information regarding the dielectric properties for this problem. On using the linear response operator M that acts on the Hilbert space of integrable functions on the surface Σ, M[µ] = 1 4π ZΣ µ(y) n(x) · (x − y) x − y3 dΣ(y), the integral equation (5) is written as (1/(2λ) − M)µ = n · N. (6) (7) The integral operator (6) is the electric field generated by the single layer charge distribution µ along the normal to the surface. It encodes the geometric information and has several interesting properties [13 -- 15]. Its spectrum is discrete and it is not difficult to show that all of its eigenvalues are bounded by the [-1/2, 1/2] interval. Although non-symmetric, the operator (6) has real non-degenerate eigenvalues. The eigenvectors are biorthogonal, i. e., 5 they are not orthogonal among themselves, but orthogonal to the eigenvectors of the adjoint operator M †[µ] = 1 4π ZΣ x − y3 µ(y) n(y) · (x − y) dΣ(y), (8) which is associated with the electric field generated by a surface distribution of electric dipoles (double layer charge distribution). Therefore, if uki is a right eigenvector of M corresponding to eigenvalue χk, Muki = χkuki and hvk′ is a left eigenvector corresponding to eigenvalue χk′, hvk′M † = χk′hvk′, then with the scalar product defined as the integral over the interface Σ, hvk′uki = δk′k, hf1f2i =ZΣ f ∗ 1 (x) f2 (x) dΣ(x). (9) (10) The value 1/2 is always the largest eigenvalue of the operator M, regardless the geometry of the object. This is immediately seen if the object is considered to be conductor (ε1 → ∞), and then the interior electric field has to be zero. In that case λ = 1, and the charge density that generates a vanishing internal electric field obeys the equation (1/2 − M)µ = 0, and therefore 1/2 is an eigenvalue of M. However, this eigenmode is not dipole-active and does not contribute to the total polarization of the object. The operator (6) is insensitive to a scale transformation, which means that its eigenvalue and eigenvectors depend only on the shape of the object and not on its size, or electrical properties. By employing the spectral representation of the resolvent of the operator M (z − M)−1 =Xk (z − χk)−1ukihvk, the solution of equation (7) is obtained for z = 1/(2λ) as µ =Xk hvkn · Ni(1/(2λ) − χk)−1uki. (11) (12) The polarizability of the homogeneous particle is obtained by using the distribution (12) to build the solution (4) of the Laplace equation and use it in equation (2). It has been shown that, operationally, the polarizability is simply the dipole moment of the distribution (12) over unit volume [25, 27] 6 α = 1 3 1 V1 Xi,k hx · Niuki hvkn · Nii 1/(2λ) − χk , (13) where Ni are three mutually orthogonal vectors (directions) of unit norm. The factor (1/(2λ) − χk)−1 is a generalized Clausius-Mosotti factor. Each dipole-active eigenmode contributes to α according to its weight pk = 1 V1 Pihx · Niuki hvkn · Nii, which deter- 3 mines the strength of coupling between the uniform electric field and the k-th eigenmode and contains three components Pk,i = hx · Niuki hvkn · Nii/V1. Equation (13) shows a clear separation of the electric properties, which are included only in λ, from the geometric 1 properties expressed by χk and pk. B. Shelled particles The polarizability of an object covered by a thin shell with permittivity εS can be calcu- lated in a similar fashion. The electric field is now generated by two single layer distributions, and boundary conditions are imposed twice, for Σ1 and for Σ2. The surface Σ1 is the outer surface of the shell and Σ2 is the interface between the particle and the shell. The solution of a shelled particle in terms of single layer potentials has the form [28] Φ(x) = −x · N + 1 4π ZΣ1 µ1(y) x − y 1 4πZΣ2 µ2(y) x − y dΣ(y) + dΣ(y), (14) where µ1 and µ2 are the densities defined on surface Σ1 and Σ2, respectively. Four integral operators M11, M12, M21 and M22 are defined, depending on which surface are variables x and y. For example M11 is defined when x and y are both on Σ1, M12 is defined by x on Σ1 and y on Σ2, and so on. Thus Mij[µj] = 1 4πZΣj µj(y) for i, j = 1, 2. The equations obeyed by µ1 and µ2 are n(x) · (x − y) dΣ(y) x − y3 µ1/(2λ1) − M11[µ1] − M12[µ2] = n · N µ2/(2λ2) − M21[µ1] − M22[µ2] = n · N. (15) (16) Here the electric parameters are: λ1 = (εS − ε0)/(εS + ε0), and λ2 = (ε1 − εS)/(ε1 + εS). We further assume a confocal geometry, i. e. the surface Σ1 is a slightly scaled version of Σ2, with a scaling factor η close to unity. This assumption does not provide constant thickness for the shell, but our main results should remain at least qualitatively valid [3, 6]. 7 In the limit of very thin shells, and using the scaling properties of the operator M, one can show [25, 27] that all four M operators are related to M = M11 M12[µ] = η−3(µ/2 + M[µ]) M12[µ] = −µ/2 + M[µ] M22[µ] = M[µ]. Equations (16) can then be arranged in a matrix form as (17) (18)   1/(2λ1 − M) (1/2 + M)/η3 −1/2 + M 1/(2λ2) − M     µ1 µ2   =  n · N n · N  . By knowing the eigenvectors and the eigenvalues of M the charge densities µ1 and µ2 can be found by inverting the matrix in (18). For example, µ1 is µ1 =Xk η3(cid:16) 1 2λ1 − χk(cid:17)(cid:16) 1 η3( 1 2λ2 − χk) +(cid:0) 1 2λ2 − χk(cid:17) +(cid:0) 1 2 + χk(cid:1) 2 + χk(cid:1)(cid:0) 1 2 − χk(cid:1) hvkn · Niuki. (19) The field generated by the the two distributions µ1 and µ2 outside the particle is the same as the field generated by an equivalent single layer distribution µe =Xk hvkn · Ni(1/(2λk) − χk)−1uki, (20) where λk = (εk−ε0)/(εk+ε0) and the equivalent permittivity εk is defined for each eigenmode as: εk = εS(cid:18)1 + εS + δ(1/2 − χk)ε1 + δ(1/2 + χk)ǫS(cid:19) , ε1 − εS (21) where δ = η3−1 ≪ 1. The distribution (20) is similar with the distribution (12) obtained for a homogeneous particle, except that λ has to be replaced for each mode with an equivalent quantity λk. Equation (21) can be applied recursively for a multi-shelled structure. The strict separation of electric and geometric properties is weakened in this case, because the shape-dependent eigenvalue χk appears now in the electric equivalent quantity λk. The polarizability of the shelled particle is obtained by using the distribution (20) to build the solution (4) of the Laplace equation and use it in equation (2), to get α = 1 3 1 V1 Xi,k hx · Niuki hvkn · Nii 1/(2λk) − χk . (22) 8 Equation (22) is obtained by replacing λ with λk in Eq. (13). The parameter V1 in Eq. (22) is the total volume of the cell (the core and the shells). In the limit of a dilute suspension of identical shelled particles, with a low volume fraction f , the effective permittivity (1) is εsus = ε0 1 + fXk pk (1/2 + χk)ε0 + (1/2 − χk)εk! . εk − ε0 (23) C. The Debye relaxation expansion In general, the effective permittivity ǫsus of a suspension of objects with m shells will have m+1 Debye relaxation terms for each dipole active eigenmode. The proof is recursive and is based on partial fraction expansion with respect to variable iω of equations (22) and (23), provided that the complex permittivity of various dielectric phases is ǫ = ε − iσ/(ωεvac) where i = √−1 and εvac is the permittivity of the free space (8.85 × 10−12 F/m). Thus the first Debye term comes out from (23) and the remaining m Debye terms result from (21) by the homogenization process described for shelled particles. Hence, a suspension of cells with m shells (and m + 1 interfaces) has a dielectric spectrum containing a number of Debye terms equal to m + 1 times the number of dipole-active eigenvalues. The suspension effective permittivity ǫsus has the expansion ǫsus = ǫf +Xk,j ∆εkj/(1 + iωTkj) (24) where ǫf = εhf − iσlf/(ωεvac), εhf frequency conductivity; ∆εkj and Tkj are the dielectric decrement and the relaxation time is the high-frequency permittivity, and σlf is the low- of the kj Debye term, respectively; index k enumerates the dipole-active eigenmodes and index j enumerates interfaces. Although the measurable bulk quantities in equation (24) are directly correlated with the microscopic (electric and shape) parameters, a solution of the inverse problem, which aims at obtaining the microscopic information non-intrusively, from the effective permittivity, is in general difficult, if not impossible for the general multi-shell structure. However, biolog- ical cell has a thin and almost non-conductive membrane, and several simplifications and approximations can be made. Two Debye relaxation terms in the effective permittivity ǫsus are expected for each dipole-active eigenmode, corresponding to the two interfaces which define the membrane. 9 The first relaxation is derived from the equivalent permittivity (21) which can be written also as Debye relaxation terms: ǫk = ε + ∆ε/(1 + iωT ). (25) The relaxation time T that is given by the poles of ǫk in (21) is a quite good approximation of the first relaxation time Tk1 T = εvac (1 + δ/2 + δχk) εS + δ (1/2 − χk) ε1 (1 + δ/2 + δχk) σS + δ (1/2 − χk) σ1 ≈ Tk1. (26) The main reason is as follows. At frequencies close to 1/T there is a huge change in ǫk of order εS/(δ(1/2 − χk)), and consequently a significant change in the total permittivity ǫsus given by (23). Therefore T provides an approximate value for the relaxation time Tk1 of the suspension effective permittivity ǫsus. For a non-conductive shell σS ≈ 0, or more precisely when σS≪δ (1/2 − χk) σ1, the relaxation time (26) is: Tk1 ≈ εvac εS/(δ · σ1(1/2 − χk)) (27) showing a strong dependence on the thickness of the shell and on the shape of the particle, through the eigenvalue χk. Due to the small parameter δ in (27) the first relaxation (i. e., membrane relaxation) tends to have a lower frequency than the second relaxation, which is present even for particles with no shell (see the discussion below). In addition, cumbersome but straightforward calculations provide the dielectric decrement ∆εk1 in (24) ∆εk1 ≈ 4f pkεS(δ(1/2 + χk)2(1/2 − χk))−1 (28) that is very large due to the same strong dependence on the thickness of the shell. The effect is even more dramatic when the second largest eigenvalue is very close to the largest eigenvalue, (1/2 − χ2) → 0, like in the case of two cells connected by tight junctions. For a suspension of shelled spheres η = 1 + ∆R/R and δ = η3 − 1 ≈ 3∆R/R, where ∆R is the thickness of the membrane, R is inner radius, and R + ∆R is the total radius. Thus both Tk1 and ∆εk1 are proportional to R and εS and inverse proportional to ∆R like in the Pauly-Schwan theory [1, 8]. Moreover, the dielectric decrement ∆εk1 in (28) is a generalization of equation (54a) in Ref. [8]. In the same time, the relaxation time (27) differs with respect to equation (56a) in Ref. [8] only by the conductivity term. We will 10 show elsewhere that a more appropriate treatment of the relaxation times recovers also the relaxation time given by equation (54a) in Ref. [8]. Thus, a non-conductive and thin shell/membrane produces a large relaxation of the com- plex permittivity of the suspension [31]. The experimental evidences further support these theoretical facts: when attacking the membrane with a membrane disrupting compound ( for example a detergent) the relaxation almost vanishes as the cellular membrane is permeated [32]. For frequencies higher than 1/Tk1 the cell permittivity is essentially determined by the dielectric properties of the cytoplasm, and does not depend on membrane's properties. The second Debye relaxation occurs at higher frequencies than the first (membrane) relaxation, and has the relaxation time Tk2 ≈ εvac (1/2 + χk) ε0 + (1/2 − χk) ε1 (1/2 + χk) σ0 + (1/2 − χk) σ1 (29) derived from the pole of equation (23). The corresponding dielectric decrement is ∆εk2 ≈ f pk(1/2 − χk)(ε1σ0 − ε0σ1)2 × ((1/2 + χk)ε0 + (1/2 − χk)ε1)−1 × ((1/2 + χk)σ0 + (1/2 − χk)σ1)−2 The last two equations are similar to the ones that are given for spherical particles in Ref. [8] (equations (46) and (49) in the aforementioned reference). The relaxation given by Tk2 is basically the relaxation of a homogenous particle embedded in a dielectric environment and was also discussed in Ref. [22] by a closely related spectral method. If the conductivity of the cytoplasm is comparable to the conductivity of the outer medium, the decrement of the second relaxation is small such that it cannot be distinguished in the spectrum. On the contrary, if the conductivity of the outer medium is much greater or smaller that that of cytoplasm, than a second observable relaxation occurs. Unlike the membrane relaxation, this second relaxation depends only weakly on the shape. By assuming that σ0 ≪ σ1 and by using a finite-difference method, this resonance was also obtained in [3] and it was instrumental in explaining the experimental data on the fission of yeast cells of Asami et al. [33] by Lei et al. [22]. The shape of the particle is important because it affects the number of dipole-active eigenvalues and their strengths. In principle, each dipole-active eigenvalue introduces a new 11 relaxation in the dielectric spectrum, providing this relaxation is well separated from the others. A cluster with complex geometry can have several dipole-active eigenvalues, but unless the cluster is larger in one dimension then in the others, or there are tight junctions, the relaxations overlap to create broad features in the spectrum. An extra relaxation is introduced when the particles are covered by thin membranes. In addition, if (1/2 − χk) → 0 for that eigenvalue, then the shell induced relaxation has low frequency, large relaxation time and large dielectric decrement. Based on the spectral BIE method, it is therefore possible to explicitly relate the dielectric spectra of cell suspensions to cell's geometry and electric parameters, and, even design fitting procedures to evaluate these parameters from measurements. III. RESULTS A. Numerical procedure The calculation of the effective permittivity for a suspension uses equations (1) or (23), and reduces then to finding the eigenvalues χk and eigenvectors uki and vki of the linear response operator M. This problem is solved by employing a finite basis of NB functions defined on the surface Σ. A natural basis for a surface not far from a sphere is the generalized hyperspherical harmonics functions Ylm(x) = Ylm (θ(x), ϕ(x)) , (30) 1 ps(x) 1 ps(x) where s(x) is related to the surface element through dΣ = s(x) dΩx and dΩx is the solid angle element. Another choice could be based on Chebyshev polynomials of the first kind [29] Tlm(x) = Tl (θ(x)) eimϕ(x). (31) Both bases are complete and orthogonal in the Hilbert space of square integrable functions defined on Σ. In this paper, we model the linear cluster of particles as an object with axial symmetry. We seek to find a surface of revolution for which the thickness of the interparticle joints can be varied without perturbing the overall shape of the object. We use two representations 12 for the surface Σ: (A) for clusters of two particles we use spherical coordinates {x, y, z} = {r(θ) sin θ cos φ, r(θ) sin θ sin φ, r(θ) cos θ}, and (B) for clusters with more than two particles we specify the surface in terms of a function g(z) as {x, y, z} = {g(z) cos φ, g(z) sin φ, z}. In the case B, the surface element is and the normal to surface Σ is dΣ = g(z)p1 + g′2(z) dzdϕ,   p1 + g′2(z) sin ϕ −g′(z)   n = 1 cos ϕ (32) (33) . In the basis of generalized hyperspherical harmonics the operator M has matrix elements given by Mlm;l′m′ = δmm′ 2π ZZ0 zmax ZZzmin A(z, z′, ϕ−ϕ′)P m l (cos θ(z))P m′ l′ (cos θ(z′)) eim(ϕ−ϕ′) G(z, z′) dz dz′ dϕ dϕ′ (34) (35) (36) where and G(z, z′) =qg(z)g(z′)p(1 + g′(z))(1 + g′(z′))−1, (g(z) − g(z′)) cos φ − (z − z′)g′(z) A(z, z′, φ) = [g2(z) + g2(z′) − 2g(z)g(z′) cos φ + (z − z′)2]3/2 After the angle integration in equation (34) and by using the elliptic integrals given in the Appendix, the matrix elements are obtained by numerical evaluation of the resulting (z, z′) double integral using an NQ-point Gauss-Legendre quadrature [29, 30]. Because of the integrable singularity apparent in the kernel of the operator M in equation (6), the mesh of z must be shifted from the mesh of z′ by a transformation which insures that there is no overlap between the two meshes. The delta symbols δmm′ in equation (34) reflects the fact that we consider only objects with rotational symmetry in this paper. Moreover, for fields parallel with the cluster axis m = 0, while m = 1 for perpendicular fields. The convergence of the results is obtained in two steps. First, the number NQ of quadra- ture points is increased until the matrix elements of M converge, and then the size NB of 13 the basis set is increased until the relevant eigenvalues χk and their corresponding weights pk have acquired the desired accuracy. A necessary test for convergence is the fulfillment of the sum rules Pk Pk,i = 1 and Pi,k χkPk,i = 1/2 with sufficient accuracy [18, 19]. Usually the convergence is fast in both the number of quadrature points and the size of basis, unless the system has a tight junction where some care must be considered in order to achieve the required accuracy of the eigenmodes with the eigenvalues close to 1/2. For a sphere there is just one dipole-active eigenmode which has eigenvalue χ = 1/6 and weight p = 1, while for an ellipsoid there is one dipole-active eigenmode along each axis. Fast and accurate solutions are achieved for spheroids with a basis size of NB =20 and with NQ = 64 quadrature points. In general, the size of the basis and the number of the quadrature points increase with the number of cells in the cluster and with the decreasing of the junction size. Thus, for our numerical examples a basis with NB=35-40 and NQ = 128 quadrature points are enough for a converged solution in the case of the dimers and NB=50 and NQ = 200 quadrature points in the case of the clusters with up to four cells. B. Two cells joined by tight junction The equation r(θ) = (h+cos2 θ)/(1−a cos2 θ) describes the shape of a two-particle cluster. Parameter h controls the tightness of the inter-particle junction and parameter a measures the deviation from a spherical shape. More precisely, h is the radius of the smallest circle at around the thinnest part of the junction. Figure 1 shows the effective permittivity for a suspension of particles with the following parameters: ε1 = 70, σ1 = 0.25 S/m, εS = 6, σS = 0, ε0 = 81, σ0 = 0.374 S/m, volume fraction f = 0.05, membrane thickness δ = 0.00947275, and a = 0.2. The effective per- mittivity does not depend on the thickness parameter h when the stimulus electric field is perpendicular to the cluster axis. However, a new relaxation becomes apparent as h → 0, for parallel fields [3, 25]. Figure 2 presents the first 7 eigenvalues χk and their weights Pk,1 for a field parallel to the z axis. As the junction become tighter (h → 0) more eigenvalues become dipole- active. While all eigenvalues are important in shaping the dielectric spectrum, the second largest eigenvalue χ2 is crucial to explaining the occurrence of an additional relaxation at low frequencies, as observed for small h in [3, 25]. Although its weight P2,1 also decreases for 14 500 400 p r e p 300 , r a p 200 100 0 h=0.5 h=0.1 h=0.01 h=0.001 perp 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 1010 f(Hz) FIG. 1: (Color online) The spectrum of the effective permittivity of a suspension of dimers with various junction thickness h, and with parallel and perpendicular field configurations. The sus- pension permittivity for an electric field perpendicular to cluster axis does not depend on h and is pointed by an arrow. small h, this dipole active eigenmode approaches 1/2 as the junction becomes tighter. Thus, according to equations (27) and (28) the effect of χ2 is "enhanced" due to the presence of a nonconductive shell (as the case for biological particles analyzed in [3, 25]). Moreover, the decrease of P2,1 is compensated by the increase of 1/(1/2 − χ2). The presence of a new relaxation at low frequency along with its relationship with the size of h has been already singled out in Gheorghiu et al. [25] by using the same method but without the analysis of dipole-active eigenmodes. Using a finite discrete model [3], the relaxation was observed before the segregation during cell division, while other papers [34, 35] fail to relate the size of h to the new relaxation, even though one of them [34] employs essentially the same method as the one outlined in the present work. Figure 3 shows the charge distribution associated with the first four eigenvalues for two distinct values of h. The second eigenmode is an antisymmetric combination of net charge distributions (monopoles) on each particle of the dimer. The third charge distribution is an antisymmetric combination of charge distributions with a dipole moment on each part of the 15 h 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th 6th 7th 0.6 k 0.4 - 5 0 . 0.2 0.0 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 1 , k P 10-3 10-2 h 10-1 FIG. 2: (Color online) The largest seven eigenvalues and their weights for a binary cluster with parameter a = 0.2, as a function of h. The inset shows the shape of the dimer. dimer and the forth distribution is antisymmetric combination of charge distributions with a quadrupole moment on each particle. At small h (tight junctions), charge accumulates in the vicinity of the junction [36]. 16 ) ( 1 u 1st ) ( 2 u ) ( 3 u 2nd 3rd ) ( 4 u -1 4th 0 cos( ) 1 FIG. 3: The first four eigenvectors for a dimer given by equation r(θ) ; a = 0.2 and h = 0.5 (dotted line) and h = 0.01 (solid line). C. Clusters of more than two particles Smoother yet tight junctions would bring (1/2 − χ2) closer to 0 than sharp and tight junc- tions. The reason is simple: smoother junctions have the two parts of the dimer farther apart. 17 We have analyzed linear clusters of cells connected by smooth and tight junctions by using a (z, φ) parameterization which describes a surface by {x = g(z) cos ϕ, y = g(z) sin ϕ, z}. The construction starts from a dimer shape that resembles the shape of the epithelial cells like MDCK (Madin-Darby Canine Kidney) cells. An example of such shape, displayed in figure 4, extends from −zmax to zmax and it can be decomposed in three parts: the left cap (−zmax ≤ z ≤ −z1), the central part (−z1 ≤ z ≤ z1), and the right cap (z1 ≤ z ≤ zmax). At position ±z1 the shape function has its maximum. An m-cell linear cluster is ob- tained by repeating the central part m − 1 times and it extends from −Lm to Lm, where Lm = zmax + (m − 2)z1. Mathematically, the shape is described by: for − Lm ≤ z ≤ −Lm + zmax g(z + (m − 2)z1), g (mod(z + (1 + (−1)m)z1/2, 2z1) − z1) , g(z − (m − 2)z1), for Lm ≤ z ≤ Lm − zmax, for − Lm + zmax ≤ z ≤ Lm − zmax (37) gm(z) =  where mod(x, y) is the remainder of the division of x by y. For the examples considered here, the dimer shape function is: g(z) = 0.01 + 2.32317 z2 − 11.9862 z4 + 40.4045 z6 −74.2226 z8 + 79.142 z10 − 51.8929 z12 + 21.3096 z14 −5.35113 z16 + 0.752147 z18 − 0.045375 z20, (38) with zmax = 1.77377 and z1 = zmax/2. Tables I and II list the most representative dipole-active eigenmodes for a trimer in perpendicular and parallel fields. Only the parallel field configuration has a dipole-active eigenvalue close to 1/2, with a relatively small weight. The results for linear clusters of up to four particles are displayed in Figure 5. The elec- tric parameters are the same as ones used for dimers in the previous section. An additional, distinct low-frequency relaxation emerges for clusters with more then one particles, only when the stimulus field is parallel with the symmetry axis. The relaxation frequency de- creases, while the intensity of these relaxations increases, as the number of cluster members increases. This behavior is explained again by the combination of eigenvalues close to 1/2, with thin non-conductive layers covering the cluster and is consistent with experimental data on ischemic tissues [11], which reports that the cell separation (closure of gap-junctions) is responsible for decrease and eventual disappearance of the low-frequency dispersion. 18 TABLE I: Most representative dipole-active eigenmodes and their weights for the trimer in parallel field. χk 0.4996 0.40642 0.40448 0.37763 0.26409 0.23809 0.17557 0.13522 0.12165 0.07192 0.06649 0.03479 0.03362 0.0281 0.02377 Pk,1 0.01305 0.07769 0.1391 0.17366 0.20519 0.01839 0.05104 0.05234 0.01066 0.06197 0.01239 0.03899 0.02823 0.04688 0.02519 TABLE II: Most representative dipole-active eigenmodes and their weights for the trimer in per- pendicular field. χk 0.1831 0.06964 0.05492 0.0272 0.01674 0.01479 0.00395 -0.01635 19 Pk,2 0.64102 0.01464 0.01343 0.01065 0.05687 0.13179 0.05029 0.03246 ) z ( g ) z ( 4 g -zmax -z1 0 z1 zmax -2z1-zmax -3z1 -2z1 -z1 0 z1 2z1 2z1+zmax FIG. 4: Smooth construction of a cluster (lower panel) from a dimer (upper panel). The parts determined by z ∈ [−z1, z1] are "glued" together with the ends of the dimer. The arrows show where the junctions will be placed in the cluster. In Figure 6 we plot Pk,1/(1/2 − χk) versus (1/2 − χk), which shows that the number of dipole-active eigenmodes increases with the number of particles in the cluster. According to (27) and (28), Figure 6 shows in fact the dielectric decrement versus its corresponding relaxation frequency for each dipole-active eigenmode of the given clusters. For clusters of two or three particles, there is one important active eigenmode close to 1/2, while for clusters of four particles there are two active eigenmodes. It can be conjectured that for a general linear cluster made of m particles, there are m−1 eigenvalues close to 1/2, of which the largest one is always dipole-active and has the largest 20 2500 2000 p r e p 1500 , r a p 1000 500 0 1 cell 2 cells 3 cells 4 cells perp 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 1010 f(Hz) FIG. 5: (Color online) Effective permittivity for clusters (shown in the inset) of one, two, three, and four cells connected by tight and smooth junctions. The field is either parallel (solid lines with symbols) or perpendicular (solid lines only) to the cluster axis. The effective permittivity either increases strongly with the number of cells for parallel geometry, or does not change for a perpendicular geometry. weight. In fact one can show that for two cells connected by smooth and tight junction characterized by parameter h, (1/2 − χ2) ∝ h2 when h → 0, or more precisely (1/2 − χ2) is proportional with the solid angle encompassed by the missing part of a cell when it is connected with other cell in the dimer. The proof is based on the theorem of the solid angle [12]. The generalization to a finite cluster is also straightforward to (1/2 − χ2) ∝ h2/m (in that case the solid angle encompassed by the middle junction is proportional to h2/m. The weight of the second eigenmode is P2,1 = hx · N1u2ihv2n · N1i/V1. the surface of the cluster is determined by the function g(z) then, up to a constant factor, hv2n · N1i ≈ g(0)2 = h2 for two cells connected by smooth and tight junctions. The proof considers that the second eigenfunction of M † is an antisymmetric combination of constant If we consider that distributions on each part of the dimer. This assertion is confirmed in Figure 7. Moreover, hx·N1u2i/V1 is weakly dependent on h. Therefore, for a parallel setting of the field stimulus, P2,1/(1/2−χ2), which is the measure of the dielectric decrement of low-frequency relaxation, 21 5 0 4 0 3 0 2 0 1 0 ) - 2 / 1 ( / 1 , k P 0 4 c e l l s 3 c e l l s 2 c e l l s 1 c e l l 10-2 10-1 100 10-4 10-3 1 / 2 - FIG. 6: (Color online) Pk,1/(1/2− χk) versus (1/2− χk) for clusters of up to four cells. The second eigenvalue has the largest contribution to intensity of relaxation. is finite and it increases when the number of cells is increased. The increase of relaxation decrement when m → ∞ is physically limited by σS≪δ (1/2 − χk) σ1, since the membrane conductivity is not strictly 0. Due to cluster's shape and membrane properties, the variation of Pk,1/(1/2 − χk) and (1/2 − χk) with respect the eigenmode k determines a low frequency relaxation when the dipole-active eigenvalue χk is close to 1/2. We note here that for dipole-active eigenmodes of ellipsoids the term (1/2−χk) is called the depolarization factor and has analytical expression [37]. Prolate spheroids with longitudinal axis much larger than the transverse axis (needles) have the longitudinal depolarization factor approaching 0 and the transverse depolarization factor approaching 1/2. More precisely, for a long prolate spheroid, the longitudinal depo- larization factor scales as (1/2 − χ2) ∝ a2 z, az > ax = ay, as ax → 0. On the other hand, extensive numerical calculations support the fact that cylinders with the same aspect x/a2 ratio behave similarly to prolate spheroids [37]. Thus, it is not hard to observe that the low-frequency relaxation of linear clusters of cells connected by tight junctions is similar to that of a needle or a thin cylinder as long as the cluster and as thick as the junction. 22 3 0 ) z ( 2 u , ) z ( 1 u -3 0.6 ) z ( 2 0.0 v , ) z ( 1 v -0.6 -1 1 0 z FIG. 7: The first (dotted line) and the second (solid line) eigenfunction of M (upper panel) and M † (lower panel) for a dimer whose shape is depicted by dashed line in the lower panel. The second eigenfunction of M † is an antisymmetric combination of almost constant distributions on each part of the dimer. 23 On the other hand, the high-frequency relaxation of the cluster shows the relaxation of a suspension of spheroids with the same volume as the volume of a single cell. Therefore the dielectric spectrum for a suspension of clusters is the same as the spectrum of a two species suspension made of thin cylinders and spheroids. IV. CONCLUSIONS We present a theoretical framework based on a spectral representation of BIE and able to calculate the dielectric behavior of linear clusters with a wide range of shapes and dielectric structures. The theory agrees with the results of Pauly and Schwan for a sphere covered with a shell [1, 8]. In fact, for spheroids, our theory is the same as the analytical results of Asami et al. [2]. We present extensive calculations of clusters with shapes resembling MDCK cells. A practical numerical recipe to compute the effective permittivity of linear clusters with arbitrary number of cells is provided. Examples are given for cluster with shapes described as r(θ) in spherical coordinates or using (z, ϕ) parameters as {x = g(z) cos ϕ, y = g(z) sin ϕ, z}. Other studies in the literature used only spherical coordinates representation [25, 27, 35]. A direct relation between the geometry and dielectric parameters of the cells and their dielectric behavior described by a Debye representation has been formulated for the first time. Other work [22], which is based on a closely related spectral method [18 -- 21], found a direct relation linking the geometry and electric parameters to the dielectric behavior only for homogenous particles. Moreover, the method used in [22] treats only particles with spheroidal geometry. We show that the spectral representation provides a straightforward evaluation of the characteristic time constants and dielectric decrements of the relaxations induced by cell membrane. We prove that the effective permittivity is sensitive to the shape of the embed- ded particles, specially when the linear response operator has strong dipole active modes (with large weights pk). A low-frequency and distinct relaxation occurs when the largest dipole-active eigenvalue is very close to 1/2. Clusters of living cells connected by tight junctions or very long cells have such an eigenvalue. Our results also shed a new light on the understanding of recent numerical calculations [38] performed with a boundary element method on clustered cells where the low-frequency relaxation is attributed to the tight (gap) junctions connecting the cells. The method used in [38] does not use the confocal geometry 24 assumption . The present work has several implications and applications. We emphasize the capabilities of dielectric spectroscopy to monitor the dynamics of cellular systems, e.g., cells during cell cycle division, using synchronized yeast cells [3, 11, 39], or monolayers of interconnected cells [40, 41]. Also the method is able to assess the dielectric behavior of linear aggregates or rouleaux of erythrocytes, where the ellipsoidal or cylindrical approximations are not adequate [42, 43]. The proposed representation is a powerful alternative to finite element or other purely numerical approaches, because it provides the analytical framework to explain and predict the complex dielectric spectra occurring in bioengineering applications. Extension of this method to other surfaces of revolution, for example linear clusters with more than 4 particles, is straightforward providing an adequate parametric equation is available. Finally, in many cases (e.g. shapes with high symmetry) the method is faster, offers accurate solutions and last but not least can be integrated in fitting procedures to analyze experimental spectra. Acknowledgments This work has been supported by Romanian Project "Ideas" No.120/2007 and FP 7 Nanomagma No.214107/2008. Appendix: Integration over ϕ The integrals over (ϕ − ϕ′) are performed with the following elliptic integrals, Z π 0 1 (a − b cos ϕ)3/2 dϕ = 2 √a − b 1 a + b E(cid:18)− 2b a − b(cid:19) Z π 0 cos ϕ (a − b cos ϕ)3/2 dϕ = 2 √a − b 1 b (cid:20) a a + b E(cid:18)− 2b a − b(cid:19) − K(cid:18)− 2b a − b(cid:19)(cid:21) , (A.1) (A.2) Z π 0 cos2 ϕ (a − b cos ϕ)3/2 dϕ = 2 √a − b 1 b2 (cid:20) 2a2 − b2 a + b E(cid:18)− 2b a − b(cid:19) − 2aK(cid:18)− 2b a − b(cid:19)(cid:21) , (A.3) 25 where K(x) and E(x) are the complete integrals of the first and second kind, respectively [29]. [1] H. Pauly and H. P. Schwan, Z. Naturforsch. b 14, 125 (1959). [2] K. Asami, T. Hanai, and N. Koizumi, Japan. J. Appl. Phys. 19, 359 (1980). [3] K. Asami, J. Phys. D 39, 492 (2006). [4] E. Fear and M. Stuchly, IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng. 45, 1259 (1998). [5] K. Sekine, Y. Watanabe, S. Hara, and K. Asami, Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1721, 130 (2005). [6] M. Sancho, G. Martinez, and C. Martin, J. Electrostat. 57, 143 (2003). [7] C. Brosseau and A. Beroual, Prog. Mater. Sci. 48, 373 (2003). [8] H. P. Schwan and K. R. Foster, in Handbook of Biological Effects of Electromagnetic Fields, edited by C. Polk and E. Postow (CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, 1996), p. 25. [9] E. Gheorghiu, Phys. Med. Biol. 38, 979 (1993). [10] E. Gheorghiu, J. Phys. A 27, 3883 (1994). [11] J. Knapp, W. Gross, M. M. Gebhard, and M. Schaefer, Bioelectrochemistry 67, 67 (2005). [12] V. Vladimirov, Equations of mathematical physics (MIR, Moscow(Translated from Russian), 1984). [13] F. Ouyang and M. Isaacson, Philos. Mag. B 60, 481 (1989). [14] D. R. Fredkin and I. D. Mayergoyz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 253902 (2003). [15] I. D. Mayergoyz, D. R. Fredkin, and Z. Zhang, Phys. Rev. B 72, 155412 (2005). [16] D. Vranceanu and E. Gheorgiu, Bioelectrochem. Bioenerg. 40, 167 (1996). [17] T. Hanai, H. Z. Zhang, K. Sekine, K. Asaka, and K. Asami, Ferroelectrics 86, 191 (1988). [18] D. J. Bergman, Phys. Rep. 43, 377 (1978). [19] D. J. Bergman and D. Stroud, Solid State Physics (Academic Press, New York, 1992), vol. 46, p. 147. [20] M. I. Stockman, S. V. Faleev, and D. J. Bergman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 167401 (2001). [21] K. Li, M. I. Stockman, and D. J. Bergman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 227402 (2003). [22] J. Lei, J. T. K. Wan, K. W. Yu, and H. Sun, Phys. Rev. E 64, 012903 (2001). [23] J. P. Huang, K. W. Yu, and G. Q. Gu, Phys. Rev. E 65, 021401 (2002). [24] K. Asami, E. Gheorgiu, and T. Yonezawa, Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1381, 234 (1998). 26 [25] E. Gheorghiu, C. Balut, and M. Gheorghiu, Phys. Med. Biol. 47, 341 (2002). [26] J. D. Jackson, Classical Electrodynamics (John Wiley Sons, New York, 1975). [27] C. Prodan and E. Prodan, J. Phys. D 32, 335 (1999). [28] J. L. Sebastian, S. Munoz, M. Sancho, and G. Alvarez, Phys. Rev. E 78, 051905 (2008). [29] M. Abramowitz and I. Stegun, eds., Handbook of Mathematical Functions with Formulas, Graphs, and Mathematical Tables (Dover, New York, 1972), 9th ed. [30] J. P. Boyd, Chebyshev and Fourier Spectral Methods (Dover, New York, 2001). [31] H. Fricke, J. Appl. Phys. 24, 644 (1953). [32] K. Asami, T. Hanai, and N. Koizumi, J. Membr. Biol. 34, 145 (1977). [33] K. Asami, Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1772, 137 (1999). [34] A. D. Biasio and C. Cametti, Biolectrochemistry 71, 149 (2007). [35] A. D. Biasio, L. Ambrosone, and C. Cametti, J. Phys. D 42, 025402 (2009). [36] V. V. Klimov and D. V. Guzatov, Phys. Rev. B 75, 024303 (2007). [37] J. Venermo and A. Sihvola, J. Electrostatics 63, 101 (2007). [38] A. Ron, N. Fishelson, N. Croitoriu, D. Benayahu, and Y. Shacham-Diamand, Biophys. Chem. 140, 39 (2009). [39] E. Gheorgiu and K. Asami, Bioelectrochem. Bioenerg. 45, 139 (1998). [40] J. Wegener, C. R. Keese, and I. Giaever, Exp. Cell Res. 259, 158 (2000). [41] E. Urdapilleta, M. Bellotti, and F. J. Bonetto, Phys. Rev. E 74, 041908 (2006). [42] J. L. Sebastian, S. M. S. Martin, M. Sancho, J. M. Miranda, and G. Alvarez, Phys. Rev. E 72, 031913 (2005). [43] K. Asami and K. Sekine, J. Phys. D 40, 2197 (2007). 27
1302.0267	1	1302	2013-02-01T20:14:55	Polar vs. apolar alignment in systems of polar self-propelled particles	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft" ]	The symmetry of the alignment mechanism in systems of polar self-propelled particles determines the possible macroscopic large-scale patterns that can emerge. Here we compare polar and apolar alignment. These systems share some common features like giant number fluctuations in the ordered phase and self-segregation in the form of bands near the onset of orientational order. Despite these similarities, there are essential differences like the symmetry of the ordered phase and the stability of the bands.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Polar vs. apolar alignment in systems of polar self-propelled particles Fernando Peruani Max Planck for the Physics of Complex Systems, Nothnitzer str. 38, Dresden, Germany E-mail: [email protected] Francesco Ginelli Service de Physique de l'Etat Condens´e, CEA-Saclay, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France Markus Bar Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt, Abbestrasse 2-12, 10587 Berlin, Germany Hugues Chat´e Service de Physique de l'Etat Condens´e, CEA-Saclay, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France Abstract. The symmetry of the alignment mechanism in systems of polar self-propelled particles determines the possible macroscopic large-scale patterns that can emerge. Here we compare polar and apolar alignment. These systems share some common features like giant number fluctuations in the ordered phase and self-segregation in the form of bands near the onset of orientational order. Despite these similarities, there are essential differences like the symmetry of the ordered phase and the stability of the bands. 1. Introduction Systems of collectively moving entities are ubiquitous in nature, ranging from flocks of birds [1, 2, 3], insect swarms [5, 6], bacterial collective motion [7, 20], to even driven granular media [10, 11, 12, 13]. Beyond the complexity of each system, it is possible to classify the interaction among the moving entities according to its symmetry, which can be either polar or apolar. Polar (or ferromagnetic) interactions lead to parallel alignment of the velocity of the moving objects, while apolar (or nematic) interactions allow both, parallel as well as antiparallel alignment. Fish, birds, and insects seem to exhibit polar alignment [1, 2, 3, 5, 6]. Bacteria and driven granular media often display apolar alignment [20, 10, 11, 12, 13]. The physical origin of the alignment mechanism varies among these examples and it is difficult to identify a particular physical interaction with a given symmetry in these non-equilibrium systems. For instance, steric interactions among elongated self-propelled objects lead to apolar alignment. This can be easily observed in realistic self-propelled rod models [15], experiments with driven rods [11, 12], and experiments with gliding bacteria [20]. However, if the objects are isotropic, volume exclusion effects can result in a polar alignment, as observed in models [14] and experiments [13] with polarly driven disks. Here we focus on the collective large-scale patterns emerging in systems of point particles moving in two-dimensions at constant speed. We compare the dynamics and macroscopic properties of self-propelled particles interacting by a polar and an apolar velocity alignment mechanism. We list the common features and highlight the differences. We provide in this way a summary of the two main classes of polar self-propelled particle systems. 2. Equation of motion of self-propelled particles The evolution of the i-th particle is given by the following updating rules: xt+∆t i θt+∆t i = xt i + v0ei θt i ∆t = arg  Xxt i −xt j, θt f(cid:0)θt j i(cid:1) ei θt  + ηt i (1) (2) i is the position of the particle and θt j≤ǫ where xt i its direction of motion at time t, v0 the active particle speed, arg (b) indicates the argument of the imaginary number b , ηt i is a delta-correlated white noise of strength η, and ∆t is the temporal time step. Notice that Eqs. (1) and (2) can be considered the limiting case of very fast angular relaxation of a system of equations of the form: xi = v0ei θi , θi = −γ ∂U ∂θi (xi, θi) + ηi(t) , as discussed in [16]. The symmetry of the alignment mechanism is contained in the function f which is defined as: j, θt f(cid:0)θt i(cid:1) =(1 for polar alignment sign(cid:16)cos(θt j − θt i)(cid:17) for apolar alignment , (3) where sign (x) return a +1 if x ≥ 0 and −1 otherwise. Eqs. (1) and (2) together with Eq. (3) defined the so-called Vicsek model [17, 18] for polar alignment, and the model for (ideal) self- propelled rods introduced in [16, 19] for apolar alignment. 2.1. Order parameters The orientational order can be characterized by the following order parameters. The polar (ferromagnetic) order parameter is defined by: exp(i θt i , (4) where h. . .i denotes time-average and N stands for the total number of particles in the system. φ takes the value 1 when all particles move in the same direction, while in the disordered phase, i.e., when particles move in any direction with equal probability, it vanishes. On the other hand, the apolar (nematic) ordered parameter takes the form: 1 N N Xk=1 φ = h(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) 1 N N Xk=1 S = h(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) k)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) k)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) exp(i 2 θt i . (5) Formally, S can be derived from the order parameter matrix Q of liquid crystals (LC) [21], as the largest eigenvalue (which here we have normalized such that SLC ∈ [0, 1]). When the system is perfectly nematically ordered, i.e., when particles move in opposite directions along the same axis, S takes the value 1. In summary, a perfectly polarly ordered phase is characterized by φ = S = 1, while for a genuine apolarly ordered phase, φ = 0 and S = 1. (a) (b) (c) I II III Typical steady-state snapshots for SPP with polar alignment at different noise Figure 1. values (linear size L = 512, particle density ρ = 1/8, active speed v0 = 1/4). The snapshots correspond to phase I, (a) η = 0.06, phase II, (b) η = 0.1, and phase III, (c) η = 0.19. The arrow in (b) indicates the direction of motion of the high-density band. . 3. Macroscopic patterns with polar alignment We start out by reviewing the large-scale properties of SPP with polar alignment. If we fix the active speed v0 and the density ρ, while varying the noise strength η we observe the emergence of three statistically distinct stationary states or phases. Two of these phases correspond to orientationally ordered phases, while the third one is a disordered phase. We refer to these phases as phase I, II, and III by increasing value of η. Phase I exhibits polar long-range order and is characterized by the absence of regular large- scale, high density structures, see Fig.1(a). Due to this fact, it is often said that this phase is spatially homogeneous albeit with large density fluctuations. The presence of polar long-range order implies that φ(η) → K(η) as the system size L → ∞, with K(η) > 0 a constant that depends only on η. Phase I also exhibits giant number fluctuations (NF). NF are defined as ∆n2(ℓ) = h(n(ℓ) − hni(ℓ))2i, where n(ℓ) stands for the number of particles in a box of linear size ℓ. The average number of particles is hni = ρℓ2 while ∆n(ℓ) is expected to be ∆n ∝ hniα. Giant NF correspond to α > 1 By increasing η we reach a point at which large-scale, elongated, high-density, high-order solitary structures emerge. These structures, that we refer to as bands, move at roughly constant speed, see Fig.1(b). A system of SPPs with polar alignment can display multiple bands. The low-density region in between bands is disordered and there is no characteristic separation length between bands [18]. In summary, phase II is characterized by polar long-range order and the presence of travelling bands. If η is increased further, we reach phase III that exhibits local and global disorder, see Fig.1(c). 2 [22]. In [18] it was shown that α ∼ 0.8 for phase I. 4. Macroscopic patterns with apolar alignment Now we focus on a system of SPP with apolar alignment. While sweeping η, keeping the active speed and the density fixed, we observe the emergence of four statistically distinct stationary states or phases, see Figs. 3-4. Two of these four regimes correspond to ordered phases while the other two to disordered phases. At the two extremes, very high and very low values of η, the system is spatially homogeneous, Figs. 3(a,e). At intermediate values of η, spontaneous density segregation occurs in the form of a high-density ordered region along which the particles move back and forth, Figs. 3(b-d). It is important to stress that macroscopic polar order always remains near zero. Nevertheless, if we look at very short length scales, we observe that the 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0.04 0.03 0.02 0.01 0 φ φ . v e D . d t S I II III 0.1 η 0.2 Figure 2. Polar order parameter φ and its standard deviation as function of the noise amplitude η (other parameters as in Fig. 1). (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) I II III IV Figure 3. Typical steady-state snapshots for SPP with apolar alignment at different noise values (linear size L = 2048, density ρ = 1/8, and velocity v0 = 1/2). (a) η = 0.08, (b) η = 0.10, (c) η = 0.13, (d) η = 0.168, (e) η = 0.20. Arrows indicate the polar orientation of particles (except in (d)); only a fraction of the particles are shown for clarity reasons. apolar ordered phase is formed by polarly oriented clusters. In the following we provide a more quantitative description of these four phases, which we name, by increasing value of η, phase I to IV. Phase I exhibits true long-range apolar (nematic) order and is spatially homogeneous. This apolar order corresponds to two subpopulations of particles of roughly equal size that migrate in opposite directions (Fig. 5a). We conclude that the apolar order is truly long-range by looking at scaling of the apolar order parameter S with the system size. From Fig. 5a, it seems that S(L) approaches a constant asymptotic value C0(η) for L → ∞, with C0(η) > 0, indicating the possible existence of true long-range apolar order. Another remarkable feature of phase I is the presence of giant number fluctuations (NF). Fig. 5b shows the scaling ∆n ∝ hniα in phase I, where it is found again that α ∼ 0.8. By increasing η we move from phase I to phase II. Its onset is characterized by the emergence of a narrow, low-density, disordered channel. This channel becomes wider at larger η values, so that one can speak of a high-density ordered region along which particles travel in both directions. The high-density region exhibits apolar order with properties similar to those 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 S 0 0.08 0.1 S . v e D . d t S 0.01 0.001 0.08 I II III IV 0.1 0.12 η 0.14 0.16 0.18 0.1 0.12 0.14 η 0.16 0.18 Figure 4. Apolar (nematic) order parameter S and its standard deviation as function of the noise amplitude η (other parameters as in Fig. 3). Figure 5. Phase I of SPPs with apolar alignment: long-range apolar order and giant number fluctuations (ρ = 1/8 and η = 0.095). (a) Apolar order parameter S vs system size L in square domains. The vertical red dashed line marks the persistence length χ ≈ 4400 that particles can travel before performing a U-turn. Inset: S − C0 = 0.813063 vs L (red dashed line: L−2/3 decay). (b) Number fluctuations ∆n as function of hni. The dashed line correspond to an algebraic growth with exponent 0.8 (simulations with L = 4096). See Ref. [19]. observed in phase I: true long-range order and giant NF. The (rescaled) region possesses a well-defined profile with sharper and sharper edges as L increases (Fig. 6a). The fraction area Ω occupied by the dense region is thus asymptotically independent of system size, and it decreases continuously as the noise strength η increases (Fig. 6b). By increasing η even further, we reach phase III, where the dense region becomes unstable and constantly bend, merge, break and reform. As result of this dynamics, S(t) fluctuates strongly and on very large time scales, but its average decreases as 1/√N [19]. Thus, phase III is characterized by the absence of long-range order and the presence of large correlation lengths and times. At even larger η values, we find phase IV, which exhibits local and global disorder on smal length- and time-scales, and is spatially homogeneous. 1 S⊥ ρ⊥ 0.5 0 0.2 0 0 (a) (b) 1 Ω 0.5 x/L η 0.5 0 1 0.1 0.15 Figure 6. Phase II of SPPs with apolar alignment is characterized by the presence of a dense region. (a) Rescaled transverse profiles in square domains of linear size L = 512 (black), 1024 (red), and 2048 (blue) at η = 0.14. (Data averaged over the longitudinal direction and time, translated to be centered at the same location.) Bottom: density profiles. Top: nematic order parameter profiles. (b) Surface fraction Ω as a function of noise amplitude η (defined here as the width at mid-height of the rescaled S profile). See Ref. [19]. phase IV η phase II phase I phase III 0.1 0.1 ρ 1 Figure 7. Phase diagram - Critical value of η, separating the four phases, as function of the density. Thresholds obtained for systems of size L = 1024. The dashed line corresponds to the scaling η ∝ ρ1/2. 5. Comparison between polar and apolar alignment Self-propelled particles moving at constant speed with either polar or apolar alignment exhibit a phase transition from a disordered to orientationally ordered phase. For both alignments the order seems to be long-range, being purely polar for polar alignment and purely apolar (nematic) for apolar alignment. It has been shown theoretically that self-propelled particles with polar alignment can display long-range order [23]. However, the claim about the existence of apolar long-range order is exclusively based on large-scale simulations and a theoretical justification is still missing. Assuming that the findings here reported for large-scale simulations hold in the thermodynamical limit, we conclude that SPPs with polar alignment exhibit three phases, while with apolar alignment, the phases are four. For both alignments, there are two ordered phases, one of them spatially "homogeneous" though with giant number fluctuations with roughly the same critical exponent 0.8, while the other one is characterized by the presence of high-density, high ordered regions. For polar alignment, the system can display multiple solitary bands. These bands are travelling bands whose moving direction is perpendicular to the long axis of the band, i.e., particles are aligned roughly in the same direction exhibited by the band velocity. On the other hand, for apolar alignment, we observe only one dense region. This region does not move and is composed of two populations of particles moving in opposite direction along its periodic axis. For polar alignment there is one disordered phase characterized by local and global disorder. SPPs with apolar alignment also exhibit a similar phase, however these particles also display an intringuing disordered phase where particle self-segregation in the form of highly dynamical bands occur. This means that in a coarse-grained description of these systems, the homogeneous disordered phase should get unstable by the emergence of soliton-like structures, the travelling bands, for polar alignment while for apolar alignment, local alignment has to lead to the formation of highly dynamical region. In the case of apolar alignment, the onset of global order is not associated to the instability of the disorder homogeneous state, as for polar alignment, but with the stability of the dense region. On the other extreme, well in the "homogeneous" ordered phase, we can approximate the behavior of the order parameter φ and S as: φ = S = sin(η/2) 2 η 1 η2 sin2(η) , (6) (7) using a simple mean-field argument as discussed in [24]. From this we can presume that for a given set of parameters v0, ρ, and η, φ(v0, ρ, η) ≥ S(v0, ρ, η). Moreover, a simple mean-field analysis of the"homogeneous" disordered phase [16] reveals that, for fixed v0 and ρ, this phase looses its stability at lower values of η for apolar alignment than for polar alignment. From all this, we learn that is easier to achieve orientational order with polar than with apolar alignment. This comparison also suggests that polar order is more robust than apolar order. Beyond this rough comparison between both alignment, a theoretical understanding of the formation of dense regions in both systems is still lacking. For polar alignment, there are some promising recent theoretical results [25, 26] that provide an interesting perspective to this puzzling issue. We hope that in the near future all these open problems will be fully understood. References [1] Three Dimensional Animals Groups, edited by J.K. Parrish and W.M Hamner (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, England, 1997). [2] A. Cavagna et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 107, 11865 (2010). [3] K. Bhattacharya and T. Vicsek, New J. Phys. 12, 093019 (2010). [4] D. Helbing, I. Farkas, and T. Vicsek, Nature (London) 407, 487 (2000). [5] J. Buhl et al., Science 312, 1402 (2006). [6] P. Romanczkuk, I.D. Couzin, and L. Schimansky-Geier, Phy. Rev. Lett. 102, 010602 (2009). [7] H.P. Zhang et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 107, 13626 (2010). [8] V. Schaller et al., Nature 467, 73 (2010). [9] F. Peruani et al., unpublished. [10] V. Narayan, S. Ramaswamy, and N. Menon, Science 317, 105 (2007). [11] A. Kudrolli, G. Lumay, D. Volfson, and L.S. Tsimring, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 058001 (2008). [12] A. Kudrolli, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 088001 (2010). [13] J. Deseigne, O. Dauchot, and H. Chat´e, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 098001 (2010). [14] D. Grossman, I.S. Aranson, and E. Ben Jacob, New J. Phys. 10, 023036 (2008). [15] F. Peruani, A. Deutsch, and M. Bar, Phys. Rev. E, 74, 030904 (2006). [16] F. Peruani, A. Deutsch, and M. Bar, Eur. Phys. J. Special Topics 157, 111 (2008). [17] T. Vicsek, A. Czirok, E. Ben-Jacob, I. Cohen, and O. Shochet, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1226 (1995). [18] H. Chat´e, F. Ginelli, G. Gr´egoire, and F. Raynaud, Phys. Rev. E 77, 046113 (2008). [19] F. Ginelli, F. Peruani, M. Bar, and H. Chat´e, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 184502 (2010). [20] Peruani et al., unpublished (2010). [21] M. Doi and S.F. Edwards, The Theory of Polymer Dynamic (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1986). [22] S. Ramaswamy, R.A. Simha and J. Toner, Europhys.Lett. 62, 196 (2003). [23] J. Toner and Y. Tu, Phys. Rev. E 58, 4828 (1998); Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 4326 (1995). [24] F. Peruani, L. Schimansky-Geier, and M. Bar Eur. Phys. J. Special Topics 191, 173-185 (2010). [25] S. Mishra, A. Baskaran, and M.C. Marchetti, Phys. Rev. E 81, 061916 (2010). [26] E. Bertin, M. Droz, and G. Gr´egoire, Phys. Rev. E 74, 022101 (2006); J. Phys. A 42, 445001 (2009).
1009.0690	1	1009	2010-09-03T14:56:45	DNA-psoralen: single-molecule experiments and first principles calculations	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	The authors measure the persistence and contour lengths of DNA-psoralen complexes, as a function of psoralen concentration, for intercalated and crosslinked complexes. In both cases, the persistence length monotonically increases until a certain critical concentration is reached, above which it abruptly decreases and remains approximately constant. The contour length of the complexes exhibits no such discontinuous behavior. By fitting the relative increase of the contour length to the neighbor exclusion model, we obtain the exclusion number and the intrinsic intercalating constant of the psoralen-DNA interaction. Ab initio calculations are employed in order to provide an atomistic picture of these experimental findings.	physics.bio-ph	physics	DNA-psoralen: single-molecule experiments and first principles calculations M. S. Rocha1, A. D. L´ucio2, S. S. Alexandre3, R. W. Nunes3, and O. N. Mesquita3 1Departamento de F´ısica, Universidade Federal de Vi¸cosa, CEP 36570-000, Vi¸cosa, MG, Brazil 2Departamento de Ciencias Exatas, Universidade Federal de Lavras, Caixa Postal 3037, CEP 37200-000, Lavras, MG, Brazil and 3Departamento de F´ısica, ICEx, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Caixa Postal 702, CEP 31270-901, Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil (Dated: October 30, 2018) Abstract The authors measure the persistence and contour lengths of DNA-psoralen complexes, as a function of psoralen concentration, for intercalated and crosslinked complexes. In both cases, the persistence length monotonically increases until a certain critical concentration is reached, above which it abruptly decreases and remains approximately constant. The contour length of the complexes exhibits no such discontinuous behavior. By fitting the relative increase of the contour length to the neighbor exclusion model, we obtain the exclusion number and the intrinsic intercalating constant of the interaction. Ab initio calculations are employed in order to provide an atomistic picture of these experimental findings. PACS numbers: 87.80.Cc, 87.14.gk, 87.15.La 0 1 0 2 p e S 3 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 0 9 6 0 . 9 0 0 1 : v i X r a 1 DNA interactions with ligands such as drugs or proteins have been extensively studied and reviewed by many authors in the past years [1 -- 8]. Some of these drugs, like daunomycin and ethidium bromide (EtBr), exhibit intercalative binding [1, 3, 6]. Psoralen, by contrast, presents other forms of linkage to the DNA bases. In fact, it is well known that this drug can absorb photons and form covalent bonds with the DNA bases, when the sample is illuminated with ultraviolet-A (UVA) light (λ = 320-400 nm) [4]. Psoralens are compounds from the family of furocoumarins, broadly used in the medical treatment of various skin diseases like psoriasis, vitiligo, and some other kinds of dermatitis [9]. FIG. 1: Psol-DNA fragment with five base CG pairs and two intercalated psoralens obtained from our ab initio DFT calculations. Although psoralens have been extensively used in medicine for many years, the interac- tion of the drug with DNA is not yet completely understood. In this work, we study the intercalative binding and crosslink formation in DNA-psoralen complexes (Psol-DNA), in or- der to clarify the quantitative aspects of the interaction between psoralen and DNA. We are interested in probing the modifications of the mechanical properties of DNA molecules when interacting with psoralen. The elasticity and size changes of these molecules, as a function of the total psoralen concentration (CP ), are measured by performing single-molecule stretch- 2 ing experiments, which give information about persistence (ξ) and contour (L) lengths of Psol-DNA. The total psoralen concentration is the sum of the intercalated concentration (Ci) and the free concentration in solution of psoralen. We also define the intercalated psoralen fraction r=Ci/Cbp, where Cbp is the DNA base-pair concentration, fixed in all experiments at 11 µM. In order to elucidate the microscopic mechanisms behind the psolaren-DNA in- teraction, we also perform first principles calculations for Psol-DNA fragments (an example is shown in Fig. 1) to determine the behavior of the Psol-DNA stiffness (which is related to the Young modulus) as a function of CP , and also to obtain the maximum fraction of intercalated psoralen into DNA, i.e., the limiting value of CP at which a Psol-DNA complex is still structurally stable. Experimentally, we observe that as CP increases the Psol-DNA persistence length initially increases and then undergoes an abrupt transition to a lower value at a critical total psoralen concentration (C crit P ), a behavior we also observe in UV-light illuminated complexes. In the latter case, the Psol-DNA complex attains higher persistence length values for CP < C crit P , which is indicative of crosslinking, where the psoralen binds covalently preferably to thymine bases in opposite DNA strands, upon illumination. As discussed below, the ab initio calculations are in qualitative agreement with these experimental findings, enabling us to analyze the changes in the molecular structure that are responsible for the experimentally observed behavior. The intercalated complexes are obtained by simply waiting for the psoralen to interca- late the λ-DNA in the sample. The crosslinked complexes are obtained by illuminating the sample with a UVA mercury lamp. We use an optical tweezers to trap a polystyrene bead attached to the DNA molecule, while pulling the microscope stage with a controlled veloc- ity. We then make force × extension curves, and use the approximate expression derived by Marko and Siggia [10] to obtain the persistence and contour lengths of the bare DNA and Psol-DNA complexes. The persistence length ξ = Y I/kT (Y is the Young modulus, I is the geometrical moment of inertia of the polymer, and kT is the thermal energy) is a mesoscopic quantity which depends on the local elasticity of DNA. Its value is ξ ∼ 50 nm for bare DNA under physiological conditions. In our experiments, the forces applied to stretch the DNA are within the entropic force regime (forces <∼ 3 pN), thus avoiding externally distorting the structure and shifting the DNA/psoralen chemical equilibrium (enthalpic effects). The de- tails about our experimental setup, experimental procedure, and optical-tweezers calibration 3 FIG. 2: Persistence length ξ (in nm) as a function of total psoralen concentration CP (in µM) for Psol-DNA complexes. C ircles: intercalated Psol-DNA; S quares: crosslinked Psol-DNA. The DNA base-pair concentration used was Cbp=11 µM. can be found in Refs. [5, 6, 11]. In an attempt to understand the behavior of ξ as a function of CP , we perform first prin- ciples calculations of the structural stability and stiffness changes produced by intercalation of psoralen into fragments of dry poly(dG)-poly(dC) in its acid form. We investigate DNA models with fragments consisting of four and five guanine-citosine (CG) pairs. A five-base- pair fragment with two intercalated psoralens is shown in Fig. 1. Our first principles density functional theory (DFT) simulations use the SIESTA code [15]. Exchange and correlation effects are described within the generalized gradient approximation [16]. A double-ζ basis set of atomic orbitals of finite range is used, with polarization functions added for phosphorus and for the atoms involved in the hydrogen bridges. This methodology has been shown to provide a good description of the DNA structure [17 -- 19]. We treat isolated finite fragments in a periodic supercell with large vacuum regions. For the DNA bases at the edges of the 4 fragments, one atom was held fixed in the same position as in the infinite periodic DNA [17]. Broken bonds at the edges are saturated with hydrogen atoms. Full geometry relaxations were performed (forces < 0.04 eV/A). The stability of Psol-DNA complexes is addressed by computing their formation energies defined as the difference between the total energy of the Psol-DNA complex and the sum of the total energies of the bare-DNA fragment and the isolated psoralen molecule, after full relaxation of the initial geometries. FIG. 3: Total psoralen concentration CP as a function of relative increase of the contour length Θ for Psol-DNA intercalated complexes. Θ for psoralen molecules equals the intercalated psoralen fraction r. Dots are the experimental data and the dashed line is a fit using Eq. 1. In Fig. 2, we plot the measured values of ξ as a function of CP , for both intercalated and crosslinked Psol-DNA complexes. The figure shows that ξ increases monotonically until the critical concentration C crit P ∼ 13.4 µM is reached. For CP > C crit P , ξ decays abruptly to around 50 nm, and remains approximately constant at this value, at least for the concentration range in our experiments. Note that C crit P is the same for both intercalated and crosslinked complexes. A similar abrupt transition of the persistence length was recently reported by two of us for other intercalating drugs (daunomycin and ethidium bromide) [6]. 5 The fact that Psol-DNA complexes exhibit this same behavior is a strong evidence that this transition is of general character for intercalating molecules, at least in the low-force regime (<∼ 3 pN) used in our experiments. This abrupt transition may be caused by local formation of denaturing bubbles, as proposed in Refs. [12] and [13], which softens the structure of the Psol-DNA complex. In Ref. [12] large scale molecular dynamics calculations indicate the formation of denaturing bubbles when pure DNA is stretched above 65 pN forces. Since we use very small stretching forces it is likely that the abrupt transition we observe is caused by some intrinsic DNA structural changes induced by the intercalating drug. In Fig. 3 we show the relative increase of the contour length, Θ = (L − L0)/L0, as a function of CP for the same intercalated complexes shown in Fig. 2, where L0 is the contour length for CP = 0. Note that the contour length does not exhibit any abrupt changes. The dashed line in this figure is a fit using Eq.1 below, derived from the neighbor exclusion model (NEM) [14] (see Ref. [6] for details). Considering that each intercalated psoralen molecule increases the length of DNA by the base-pair distance 0.34 nm [4], Θ is equal to the intercalated psoralen fraction r. In this case the NEM gives CP = CbpΘ + Θ(1 − nΘ + Θ)n−1 Ki(1 − nΘ)n , (1) where n is the exclusion number and Ki is the intrinsic intercalating constant. From the fitting we determine the parameters n = 1.43 ± 0.13 and Ki = (8.8 ± 2.4) × 104 M−1, for intercalative binding of psoralen. The large error bars for Θ are due to the fact that different DNAs were used, and there is a natural length distribution for λ-DNA. The abrupt transition for ξ occurs around Θ =0.38, while the maximum psoralen intercalated fraction (1/n) is between 0.64 and 0.77. Figure 4 shows the behavior of the stiffness, which is proportional to the Young modulus (for fixed DNA length), as a function of r, computed using the DFT methodology. Note that the stiffness increases as r increases, and an abrupt decrease is observed for r between 0.40 and 0.50, in reasonably good agreement with the data for the persistence length of Fig 2, where this transition occurs around Θ = r =0.38. Our calculations indicate that before the transition two psoralens are well intercalated into the DNA structure, while after the transition one of the psoralens binds with the citosine, and the hydrogen bond between the two bases is broken, indicating that local denaturation may indeed be the mechanism behind the abrupt change in stiffness and consequently in the persistence length. Moreover, 6 FIG. 4: Stiffness as a function of intercalated psoralen fraction (r), from ab initio DFT calculations. Results for r = 0, 0.25, and 0.50 were obtained using a four-base-pair model. Results for r = 0, 0.20, 0.40, and 0.60 were obtained using a five-base-pair model. our calculations also indicate that when r increases above 0.60, the intercalated structure is unstable, which sets an upper bound on the maximum fraction of intercalated psoralen within this theoretical model, in good agreement with the lower-limit value of 0.64 measured experimentally. Our interpretation for the microscopic nature of the transition rests on the good qualitative and quantitative agreement between theory and experiment. We must, however, not refrain from stating the limitations of our model system, since calculations in such small fragments are strongly affected by boundary effects. This is reflected in the large values we obtain for the theoretical stiffness, which are also due to the fact that such small fragments are much stiffer than the much longer DNA chains in the experiments (The stiffness × length we compute for bare DNA using the four-base-pair model is about 20% higher than that of the five-base-pair model.) In conclusion, the authors observe experimentally that the persistence length of DNA- psoralen complexes increases with psoralen concentration up to a critical concentration, 7 decreasing abruptly and remaining approximately constant above this concentration, a be- havior also observed in UV-light illuminated crosslinked complexes. Ab initio calculations show a similar behavior for the stiffness of psoralen-DNA complexes, and also indicate that local denaturation and binding between psoralen and a DNA base may be the mechanism behind this persistence length transition. The authors acknowledge support from the European Grant EU (FP6-029192), and from the Brazilian agencies: FAPEMIG, CAPES, CNPq, Instituto do Milenio de Nanotecnolo- gia/MCT and Instituto do Milenio de ´Optica Nao-linear, Fotonica e Biofotonica/MCT. [1] H. Fritzsche, H. Triebel, J. B. Chaires, N. Dattagupta, and D. M. Crothers, Biochemistry 21 (17), 3940 (1982). [2] I. Tessmer, C. G. Baumann, G. M. Skinner, J. E. Molloy, J. G. Hoggett, S. J. B. Tendler, and S. Allen, J. Mod. Optic. 50 (10), 1627 (2003). [3] A. Sischka, K. Toensing, R. Eckel, S. D. Wilking, N. Sewald, R. Ros, and D. Anselmetti, Biophys. J. 88 (1), 404 (2005). [4] D. W. Ussery, R. W. Hoepfner, and R. R. Sinden, Method. Enzymol. 212, 242 (1992). [5] M. S. Rocha, N. B. Viana, and O. N. Mesquita, J. Chem. Phys. 121 (19), 9679 (2004). [6] M. S. Rocha, M. C. Ferreira, and O. N. Mesquita, J. Chem. Phys. 127 (10), 105108 (2007). [7] G. D. Cimino, H. B. Gamper, S. T. Isaacs, and J. E. Hearst, Annu. Rev. Biochem. 54, 1151 (1985). [8] M. J. McCauley and M. C. Williams, Biopolymers 91 (4), 265 (2009). [9] W. McNeely and K. L. Goa, Drugs 56 (4), 667 (1998). [10] J. F. Marko and E. D. Siggia, Macromolecules 28 (26), 8759 (1995). [11] N. B. Viana, R. T. S. Freire, and O. N. Mesquita, Phys. Rev. E 65 (4), 041921 (2002). [12] S. A. Harris, Z. A. Sands, and C. A. Laughton, Biophys. J. 88 (3), 1684 (2005). [13] M. S. Rocha, Phys. Biol. 6, 036013 (2009). [14] J. D. McGhee and P. H. von Hippel, J. Mol. Biol. 86 (2), 469 (1974). [15] J. M. Soler, E. Artacho, J. D. Gale, A. Garcia, J. Junquera, P. Ordejon, and D. Sanchez-Portal, J. Phys-Condens. Mat. 14, 2745 (2002). 8 [16] J. P. Perdew, K. Burke and M. Ernzerhof, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3865 (1996). [17] P. J. de Pablo, F. Moreno-Herrero, J. Colchero, J. G´omez Herrero, P. Herrero, A. M. Bar´o, P. Ordej´on, J. M. Soler, and E. Artacho, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 4992 (2000). [18] F. L. Gervasio, P. Carloni, and M. Parrinello, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 108102 (2002). [19] S. S. Alexandre, J. M. Soler, L. Seijo, and F. Zamora, Phys. Rev. B 73, 205112 (2006). 9
1712.04835	1	1712	2017-12-13T16:07:20	How to couple identical ring oscillators to get Quasiperiodicity, extended Chaos, Multistability and the loss of Symmetry	[ "physics.bio-ph" ]	We study the dynamical regimes demonstrated by a pair of identical 3-element ring oscillators (reduced version of synthetic 3-gene genetic Repressilator) coupled using the design of the "quorum sensing (QS)" process natural for interbacterial communications. In this work QS is implemented as an additional network incorporating elements of the ring as both the source and the activation target of the fast diffusion QS signal. This version of indirect nonlinear coupling, in cooperation with the reasonable extension of the parameters which control properties of the isolated oscillators, exhibits the formation of a very rich array of attractors. Using a parameter-space defined by the individual oscillator amplitude and the coupling strength, we found the extended area of parameter-space where the identical oscillators demonstrate quasiperiodicity, which evolves to chaos via the period doubling of either resonant limit cycles or complex antiphase symmetric limit cycles with five winding numbers. The symmetric chaos extends over large parameter areas up to its loss of stability, followed by a system transition to an unexpected mode: an asymmetric limit cycle with a winding number of 1:2. In turn, after long evolution across the parameter-space, this cycle demonstrates a period doubling cascade which restores the symmetry of dynamics by formation of symmetric chaos, which nevertheless preserves the memory of the asymmetric limit cycles in the form of stochastic alternating "polarization" of the time series. All stable attractors coexist with some others, forming remarkable and complex multistability including the coexistence of torus and limit cycles, chaos and regular attractors, symmetric and asymmetric regimes. We traced the paths and bifurcations leading to all areas of chaos, and presented a detailed map of all transformations of the dynamics.	physics.bio-ph	physics	How to couple identical ring oscillators to get Quasiperiodicity, extended Chaos, Multistability and the loss of Symmetry. Edward H. Hellena, Evgeny Volkovb* a Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of North Carolina Greensboro, Greensboro, NC USA b Department of Theoretical Physics, Lebedev Physical Institute, Leninsky 53, 119991 Moscow, Russia * - corresponding author, [email protected] Declarations of interest: none Target: Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation Abstract We study the dynamical regimes demonstrated by a pair of identical 3-element ring oscillators (reduced version of synthetic 3-gene genetic Repressilator) coupled using the design of the 'quorum sensing (QS)' process natural for interbacterial communications. In this work QS is implemented as an additional network incorporating elements of the ring as both the source and the activation target of the fast diffusion QS signal. This version of indirect nonlinear coupling, in cooperation with the reasonable extension of the parameters which control properties of the isolated oscillators, exhibits the formation of a very rich array of attractors. Using a parameter- space defined by the individual oscillator amplitude and the coupling strength, we found the extended area of parameter-space where the identical oscillators demonstrate quasiperiodicity, which evolves to chaos via the period doubling of either resonant limit cycles or complex antiphase symmetric limit cycles with five winding numbers. The symmetric chaos extends over large parameter areas up to its loss of stability, followed by a system transition to an unexpected mode: an asymmetric limit cycle with a winding number of 1:2. In turn, after long evolution across the parameter-space, this cycle demonstrates a period doubling cascade which restores the symmetry of dynamics by formation of symmetric chaos, which nevertheless preserves the memory of the asymmetric limit cycles in the form of stochastic alternating "polarization" of the time series. All stable attractors coexist with some others, forming remarkable and complex multistability including the coexistence of torus and limit cycles, chaos and regular attractors, symmetric and asymmetric regimes. We traced the paths and bifurcations leading to all areas of chaos, and presented a detailed map of all transformations of the dynamics. Highlights 2 • Two identical genetic Repressilators are coupled via additional network borrowed from quorum sensing mechanism of bacterial communications. • Two-frequency torus, complex anti-phase limit cycles and chaos are found over very large areas of control parameters. • Asymmetrical limit cycle coexisting with symmetric chaos is discovered and its evolution is studied. • The paths to chaos across the regions with multistability are presented. Keywords: coupled oscillators, quorum sensing, quasiperiodicity, chaos, multistability, symmetry breaking. 1. Introduction Coupled oscillators are the most frequently used model to study such collective phenomena as synchronization [1], wave generation, multistability [2] etc. in all fields of fundamental science and its applications. Coupling can quench oscillations by either suppressing all oscillators to the same fixed point (amplitude death) or by creating an inhomogeneous stable steady-state (oscillation death, see [3] for review) which shares the phase space with other oscillatory regimes. There are many designs of coupling initiated by studies of real systems: starting from the old classic observations of pulse-coupled fireflies, direct scalar or vector reagents exchange between chemical reactors, electric and/or synaptic interactions between neurons, up to very recent investigations of combined coupling between chemical oscillators [4], half-center oscillator configurations constituted by two bursters [5], and plant interactions [6], which attempt to explain biennial rhythm in fruit production. Nonlocal connections between oscillators can lead to the formation of chimeras (coexistence of coherent and incoherent clusters) in homogeneous populations, even of very different natures: phase oscillators [7, 8], chemical oscillators [9], metronome ensemble [10], see [11] for review. However, chimera death is also determined by the particular coupling mechanism [12]. During the last decade new experimental objects – synthetic genetic oscillators – have attracted great attention [see e.g. reviews: [13, 14] as a new tool for probing the mechanisms of gene expression regulation and as a possible instrument for genetic therapy. We explore the ring-type oscillator which is a well-known circuit in physics and applied technology [e.g. review [15]], and became very popular in synthetic biology after 2000 under the name of "Repressilator" [16] due to its actual assembly and insertion into the bacterial cell E.coli. The Repressilator consists of three genes whose protein products (A, B, C) repress the transcriptions of each other unidirectionally in a cyclic way (..A--▌B--▌C--▌A..). Recently this circuit has been improved upon [17, 18], "making it an exceptional precise biological clock" [19]. The electronic analog of the Repressilator was presented in [20, 21]. The cooperativity of transcription repression, which is the core process of the Repressilator, is typically described by the Hill function ~α/(1+xn) 3 where x is repressor abundance. The dynamics of coupled Repressilators is very sensitive to the value of n which controls the steepness of repression and α which determines the amplitude of the isolated Repressilator. The effectiveness of a genetic oscillator such as the Repressilator depends on how they can function collectively, thereby requiring a coupling method. An almost obvious suggestion was to use the natural bacterial quorum sensing (QS) mechanism, used for cell-cell communication in bacterial populations [22, 23], as the instrument to synchronize genetic oscillators located in different cells. The core of QS is the production of small molecules (autoinducer) which can, first, easily diffuse across the cell membrane and external medium and, second, work to activate/repress transcription of an intended target gene. By manipulating the positions of the gene providing the autoinducer production and QS-sensitive promoters controlling the transcription of other genes in the genetic circuits, one can obtain different coupling types and, as a result, different sets of collective modes in populations of synthetic genetic oscillators. If the autoinducer is not only a signal molecule but also works as an integral participant of the oscillator then its diffusion provides the direct coupling which supports, for example, the wave propagation in bacterial populations [24]. Alternatively, QS may be implemented in a genetic oscillator as an additional element not required for the generation of the auto-oscillations. In this case the coupling may be described as indirect because its activity is mediated by the complex chain: production of autoinducer, its diffusion and binding with the promoter of the target gene. Such coupling is typically nonlinear because of bimolecular interaction of autoinducer and target instead of the linear intercellular diffusion of similar variables in direct coupling. This coupling method has been explored in model simulations of QS-coupled relaxation oscillators [25, 26] and repressilators [27], and its ability to synchronize the in-phase regime for detuned populations was demonstrated. Further work [28] has demonstrated that the model [27] may exhibit more complex collective regimes if the ranges of key parameters are reasonably extended. Later, in-phase synchronization of coupled Repressilators in the presence of noise was demonstrated [29]. More complex and flexible dynamics, which better corresponds to biological diversity, have been demonstrated in [30, 31]. In this work we couple two Repressilators via the scheme of quorum sensing, as suggested in [32, 33]. In this version of coupling it is important that the production of signal molecules is associated with the gene which is located inside the Repressilator ring upstream with respect to the target gene, which accepts the impact of autoinducer. This means that this coupling should be classified as "conjugate", because in the ordinary differential equation (ODE) system (1) (see the next section), the production of the autoinducer and its effect on the target gene are controlled by the equations for different repressors. Intercellular communication is realized by the simple diffusion of autoinducer but the coupling as a whole is more complex since it cannot be reduced to the well-studied diffusion-controlled ODE. Such a coupling seems quite acceptable for real genetic networks and nevertheless may be constructed in artificial networks of a different nature. 4 Recently [34] we have demonstrated by numerical and electronic simulations that two coupled identical Repressilators show the development of very flexible dynamics if the n increases up to n = 4. We found spatially homogeneous and inhomogeneous types of chaos over large areas of the coupling strength (Q) as well as the set of periodic windows which contains inhomogeneous limit cycles partially synchronized with i:j winding number, e.g. i=1,2…, j=i+1 despite the identical nature of the oscillators. Our main goal here is to trace the routes from self-organized quasiperiodicity to the unusual collective regimes, including homogeneous chaotic regimes and inhomogeneous limit cycles. We present the detailed map of isolated and overlapping regimes over a large plane of the key parameters Q and α for other parameters fixed. It is known that in the model [33] the anti-phase (AP) limit cycle, which is the single stable attractor under small coupling strength, loses stability via torus bifurcation if coupling strength increases. The boundaries of stable self-organized quasiperiodic regimes delineate a very large region in the Q-α plane inside which many dynamic regimes exist. To present the results in a foreseeable form, we restrict the ratio α-max / α-min to 25, based on a reasonable scatter of the corresponding experimental data on the difference between weak and strong promoters [35, 36]. Two main scenarios of dynamics inside the (Q-α)-plane after torus creation will be presented. The first one is realized for the values of α just above α-min, defined to be the smallest α for which the AP limit cycle loses stable continuity during variation of coupling strength Q. Here, the evolution of the torus progresses towards chaos but encounters a complex symmetric limit cycle with 5 return times (LC5:5) in each Repressilator. The torus and the LC5:5 have similar structures, they co-exist, and after destruction of the torus, the system sits on the limit cycle, which demonstrates the standard period doubling cascade, leading to chaos if Q and/or α increase. This symmetrical LC5:5 is an isolated attractor with unclear bifurcation origin and is unrelated to standard "resonant" cycles on the torus. The second scenario starts for larger α where the LC5:5 loses stability at smaller Q-values than does the torus, and torus destruction, rather than period doubling of LC5:5, provides the chaotic oscillations. Increasing Q in the Q-α plane, chaos meets the stability boundary for the spatially asymmetric (inhomogeneous) LC1:2, after which both attractors coexist in a wide (Q-α)-band. Further, at the upper boundary of this band the chaos becomes unstable, converting to the inhomogeneous LC1:2 which develops alone demonstrating both the period doubling cascade, ending in spatially homogeneous (symmetric) chaos with very "polarized" time series and torus bifurcation resulting in inhomogeneous quasiperiodic regimes. Both scenarios are investigated in detail by numerical bifurcation analysis as well as by direct calculations of time series and Lyapunov exponents. Although we used identical and fairly smooth oscillators, the proposed QS-coupling scheme generated an unusual cascade of complex homogeneous and inhomogeneous solutions coexisting in many areas of the phase diagram. 2. Model and Methods 5 We investigate the dynamics of two Repressilators interacting via repressive QS coupling as used previously [32, 33]. Figure 1 shows two repressilators located in different cells and coupled via QS to the external medium. The three genes in the loop produce mRNAs (a, b, c) and proteins (A, B, C), and they impose Hill function inhibition on each other in cyclic order by the preceding gene. The QS feedback is maintained by the AI produced (rate kS1) by the protein B while the autoinducer (AI) communicates with the external environment and activates (rate κ in combination with Michaelis function) production of mRNA for protein C, which, in turn, reduces the concentration of protein A resulting in activation of protein B production. In this way the protein B plays a dual role of direct inhibition of protein C synthesis and AI-dependent activation of protein C synthesis, resulting in complex dynamics of the repressilator, even for just a single repressilator [37]. Fig.1. A genetic network from two repressilators with QS feedback and the global coupling due to the mixing of signal molecules in extracellular medium. Lower case (a, b, c) are mRNAs and upper case (A, B, C) are expressed protein repressors. Si is the autoinducer molecule which diffuses through the cell membrane. The original models of a single repressilator [16, 33] used re-scaled dimensionless quantities for rate constants and concentrations. We reduce the model for the case of fast mRNA kinetics ((a, b, c) are assumed in steady state with their respective inhibitors (C, A, B), so that da/dt = db/dt = dc/dt ≈ 0). The resulting equations for the protein concentrations and AI concentration S are, (1a) (1b) (1c) (1d) where i = 1,2 for the two repressilators, βj (j = 1,2,3) are the ratios of protein decay rate to mRNA decay rate, α accounts for the maximum transcription rate in the absence of an inhibitor, niiiCAdtdA11niiiABdtdB12iiniiiSSBCdtdC113extiiSiSiSSBkSkdtdS10 6 and n is the Hill cooperativity coefficient for inhibition. For the quorum sensing pathway kS0 is the ratio of the AI decay rate to mRNA decay rate, and as previously mentioned, kS1 is the rate of production of AI and κ gives the strength of AI activation of protein C. The diffusion coefficient η depends on the permeability of the membrane to the AI molecule. The concentration of AI in the external medium is Sext and is determined according to quasi-steady-state approximation by AI produced by both repressilators (S1 and S2), and a dilution factor Q. (2) Numerical simulations are performed with XPPAUT [38], AUTO-07p [39], and by direct integration with 4th-order Runge-Kutta solver. We choose parameter values similar to ones used previously. Here we use β1 = 0.5, β2 = β3 =0.1, n = 3.0, k=15, kS0 = 1, kS1 = 0.01, and η = 2. Parameters α and Q are chosen for bifurcation analysis as they represent the amplitude of the individual oscillators, and the strength of the coupling. 3. Results 3.1 Low-strength Oscillators: α < 1000 To start we present the basic coarse-grained map of regular oscillating regimes and steady states in system (1), which may coexist with new regimes discussed below or be located in the parameter space around them. One-parameter XPPAUT continuations shown in Fig. 2 reveal three branches; a homogeneous steady state (HSS) spanning the Q-range, an inhomogeneous SS (IHSS) arising from pitchfork bifurcations of HSS (BP1 and BP2), and an anti-phase LC (APLC) arising from the Andronov-Hopf bifurcation (HB). The steady-states have stable (red) and unstable (thin black) sections, with the stable IHSS occurring between limit points LP2 and LP3. There is a narrow range between HB and LP4 of stable low level HSS which coexists with the stable high value HSS. The APLC is stable (green) at low and high Q-values, and is unstable (thin blue) between the torus bifurcations of APLC (TR1 and TR2). The APLC is the sole stable attractor at low Q (see [32] for details). 221SSQSext 7 FIG. 2. The amplitudes of APLC (green line) and HSS, IHSS steady states (red lines) as function of Q. Solid (thin) lines are stable (unstable) solutions. TR, LP, BP, HB are designations of torus, limit point, branch point (pitchfork), Andronov-Hopf bifurcations, respectively. n=3, k=15, α=800. Other parameters are fixed: β1 = 0.5, β2 = β3 =0.1, n = 3.0, kS0 = 1, kS1 = 0.01, and η = 2 The main goal of the current work is the study of dynamics inside the region with unstable APLC. Figure 2 shows that this area is large for the given parameters. Its size depends on the values of other model parameters but it will be large throughout our work and the structure of the phase diagram in Fig.2 will not be changed qualitatively. Any new attractors share the phase space with HSS and IHSS but the basins of steady states are not so large as to suppress the exhibition of new regimes. We choose n=3, k=15 to study the evolution of dynamics starting from torus creation for increasing coupling strength. Not far from the TR bifurcation the torus is smooth and demonstrates anti-phase type of oscillations as seen in Fig. 3a. Fig. 3. Phase portraits of coexisting torus (a) and LC5:5 (b), n=3, α=400, Q=0.64 8 The boundary of the torus stability in the (Q-α)-plane has been calculated by direct integration and/or by the calculations of Lyapunov exponents which clearly capture the torus death. The fate of the system (1) after torus destruction depends on the value of α and is presented below. The unexpected event in the system dynamics is the appearance of the symmetric limit cycle with 5 winding (rotation) numbers, LC5:5 (Fig. 3b), which is not a classical resonance on the torus. It coexists with the torus, and its dynamical behavior as a function of Q is controlled by the value of α. Figure 4 shows the family of Q-continuation plots of the LC5:5 for different values of α. Also shown is the resonant LC5:5-R which appears as the low-Q pieces for α = 400 and 800. For α = 400 the LC5:5-R exists for only a very narrow Q-range, appearing as a small spot in Fig. 4. Here we focus our interest on the LC5:5 and its development as α increases. Fig. 4. The amplitude of oscillations for LC5:5 as a function of Q for α =220, 400, 800. Also shown are resonant LC5:5-R occurring for α =400 (near the start of Arnold's tongue, see Fig.5) and 800 (two parameter continuations of both LPs, see in Fig.5). BP is the branch point (pitchfork bifurcation) leading to the loss of symmetry of LC5:5; PDs mark the start of period doubling cascades of asymmetric LC5:5. For the small α=220, the LC5:5 is continuously stable and coexists with the torus over the extent of the LC5:5. Increasing α dramatically changes the dynamics of the LC5:5, which, first, loses symmetry in pitchfork bifurcation (BP in Fig.4) and, second, goes to chaos via period doubling cascade as seen for α=400, 800 in Fig. 4. At the large Q>1 the system returns to stable APLC using the reverse sequence of bifurcations. At the large α=800, the appearance of additional PD bifurcations within the chaos produces a narrow region of stable LC5:5, which is not studied in this work. To reveal the dynamics in detail and over broad intervals of key parameters, 2- parametric (α, Q)-continuations were calculated for the boundaries of torus stability, the 9 bifurcations (LP, BP, PD) of the basic regime LC5:5, and other selected influential limits cycles. Figure 5 shows the resulting map of regimes. Fig. 5. The phase diagram demonstrating the boundaries of stability for basic regimes. For 3:4LC and 3:5LC which are located in intrachaotic periodic windows (PW), separation between LP and PD lines is not apparent at this resolution. The order of bifurcations looks like a "matryoshka" in the (Q-α)-plane, with nested torus, LC5:5, LC3:4, LC2:3, and LC3:5, with the oddity of the strip of overlap due to coexistence of torus and LC5:5. Also shown is the resonance LC5:5-R, a classical Arnold tongue, which is represented here to distinguish the positions and the roles of the two L5:5s. Chaos appears on the (Q-α)-map for α > 350 due to the PD cascades of the nonresonant LC5:5. The main impression from this map of regimes for our system of two identical coupled oscillators is the vast area between these PD cascades occupied by chaos. Consider the routes to this chaos. For 350 < α < 635 (according to Fig. 5), torus destruction takes place before period doubling of the LC5:5. After its destruction, the system goes into the LC5:5, the single attractor creating chaos during further Q growth (see Fig. 6 for α=600). 10 Fig.6. Time series B1, B2 of the torus destruction and the system transition to slightly asymmetric LC5:5, n=3, α =600, Q=0.5685. The LC5:5 loses symmetry via pitchfork bifurcation, then undergoes a PD-cascade to chaos. For α = 600, the torus "converts" directly to the As-LC5:5 because the end of torus stability occurs at slightly higher Q than does the pitchfork bifurcation (BP in Figs. 4, 5) which creates the As- LC5:5 from the symmetric one. (For smaller α, the torus stability ends before the BP, meaning the torus "converts" to the symmetric LC5:5). The evolution of chaos is presented as the series of sequential period maps with increasing complexity (Fig. 7): Fig. 7. The evolution of sequential period maps T(n+1) vs T(n) after the period doublings of AsLC5:5 up to the mature chaos for α=600. The value Q=0.58 is the end of LC5:5 PD cascade, (a) Q=0.592, (b) Q=0.604 (c) Q=0.614, (d) Q=0.634, (e) Q=0.654, (f) Q=0.744. T(n) are the set of Poincaré return times calculated as the time intervals between the intersections of ascending trajectories of B1(t), B2(t) with the line B = 7. 11 For α > 650, the end of torus stability is beyond the PD-cascade thereby allowing both the torus destruction and the period doubling of LC5:5 to serve as routes to chaos. Although the Q-interval of these attractors' coexistence is small, it is interesting to trace the development of chaos in the presence of the torus covered by resonant cycles. For example, Figure 8 shows the behavior of two sets of Lyapunov exponents for α = 800: black, blue, pink solid lines correspond to the calculations started from LC5:5 while red, green, navy dashed lines demonstrate LEs of regime started from the torus. Fig.8. Two sets of three LEs as a function of Q: start from 5:5LC (solid black, blue, pink lines), start from torus (dashed red, green, navy lines). Some winding numbers for resonant cycles on torus and the cycles in periodic windows in chaos are presented. ETR marks the end of torus. α = 800, Q-step=0.0001. Here and in other Figures for LEs for two regimes the values for one attractor were artificially shifted upward by 0.0001 or 0.0002 to distinguish lines near LE=0. The plots of the two main LEs (solid black and dashed red lines in Fig. 8) show that the LC5:5 and the torus are stable and coexist up to the chaotization of the LC5:5 near Q=0.5015 (positive bump of black curve). This weak chaos we denote as 5:5-chaos. The torus remains stable as Q increases, however, the Q-region close to the torus destruction (marked by ETR in Fig. 8) contains many resonant cycles, which manifest themselves as several dips of the dashed green curve (LE2-TR). The winding numbers of two resonant cycles are marked in Fig.8, with the LC23:23 being the starting point of torus destruction. Thus, there is interesting coexistence of the torus and the 5:5-chaos. To illustrate the torus transition to chaos we investigated sequential period maps T(n+1) vs. T(n) in the region of the torus destruction. The first map for Q before transition (Fig. 9a) is not smooth but it is, nevertheless, a closed curve while the second map (Fig. 9b) contains additional 12 points. Their positions in Fig. 9b indicate the start of torus destruction, after which the evolution of chaos is very similar to that presented above for α=600 (Fig.7b). Fig. 9. T(n+1) vs. (Tn) maps: (a)- for torus at Q=0.5155 just after LC23:23; (b)- for transient trajectory between torus and chaos Q=0.5172. α = 800. The coexistence of chaos and a non-smooth torus bearing many resonance cycles seems to be a non-trivial dynamical phenomenon. The Q-interval between the chaotization of LC5:5 and the end of the stable torus becomes longer if parameter α increases (see lines 5:5PD and TR-end in Fig. 5) thereby opening other routes to chaos. Increasing α to 900, we find that the 5:5-chaos is no longer stable over the entire interval to the ETR. The coexistence ends at the death of the 5:5-chaos, where the system transitions to the torus. Figure 10 shows the time series of the transition from weak 5:5-chaos to torus, and its sequential period map. The map contains points for both regimes: the closed curve with small loop is the map of torus while the combination of the five separate elements is the map of the 5:5-chaos just before the loss of its stability. The torus is then stable over a small Q-interval until the appearance of a resonant LC23:23 (Q=0.4925) followed by the system's chaotization similar to that presented in Fig. 9b for α=800. Fig. 10. The system transition from 5:5-chaos to torus for α=900, Q=0.4808: (a)-time series; (b)- sequential period map T(n+1) vs (Tn), closed curve – torus map; five separate pig-tails – map of the weak 5:5-chaos. 13 Increasing α beyond 900 causes the evolution described above for α=900 to be interrupted by the appearance of the relatively broad (Q-α)-island created by the asymmetrical cycle As9:9LC seen on the top left in Fig. 5 (green line) and shown zoomed-in in Fig. 11. Fig. 11. The zoom of the (Q-α)-map where the route to chaos via AsLC9:9 takes place. As an overview of the effect of the AsLC9:9 island we consider α=1000. Figure 11 indicates that as Q increases from the 5:5PD, the LC5:5 undergoes period-doubling to chaos which coexists with the As9:9LC until the chaos becomes unstable and the system then transitions to As9:9LC at Q about 0.458. Prior to the transition, the degree of chaos formation may be estimated from the sequential period map (Fig. 12a) while the system transition from the chaos to the As-LC9:9 is visualized in Fig. 12b. Fig. 12. (a) T(n+1)vs T(n) for Q=0.4577 just before the weak chaos transition to asymmetric cycle LC9:9; (b) the time series of this transition after very small increase of Q. α=1000. The Lyapunov exponents in Fig. 13 for trajectories started from the LC5:5 and from the torus show the short Q-interval of coexistence of the weak chaos originated from LC5:5 and the As- 9:9LC, followed by the death of the chaos at Q=0.458 leaving the As-9:9LC as the sole stable dynamical behavior. The As9:9LC then loses stability near Q=0.478 generating chaos which gradually develops into the mature chaos with sequential period map like that presented in the Fig. 7. 14 Comparing the LE graphs for α=800 and 1000, Figs. 8 and 13, it is seen that the As9:9LC at α=1000 plays the same role as the torus at α=800 regarding coexistence with 5:5-chaos, and being the sole attractor during final evolution to chaotization. The similar roles are expected since the As9:9LC is an unusually broad island inside the torus. Fig. 13. Two sets of LEs for trajectories, started from LC5:5 (solid black, blue, pink lines) and from torus (dashed red, green, navy lines), as a function of Q, α=1000. To investigate more thoroughly the route to chaos after crossing the regime of stable AsLC9:9, the LEs for torus continuation for α=930 have been calculated with a very small Q-step (0.00001) and are shown in Fig. 14. Fig.14. The detailed evolution (Q-step is 0.00001) of LEs starting from AsLC9:9 up to the appearance of irreversible chaos formation after the period doubling of LC23:23, α=930. 15 Behavior of the main LEs shows that the AsLC9:9 is stable up to its LP (Q=0.4811) after which two LEs are zero demonstrating the system transition to the ergodic torus. However, the torus is not clearly exhibited because it is covered by tightly packed resonant cycles whose beginnings of chaotization are unsuccessful until the period doubling of the LC23:23 which leads to creation of the robust chaos after Q=0.492 where the first LE amplitude surpasses 0.002. This scenario of the torus with tightly packed resonant cycles leading to chaotization at the ETR occurs for α up to about 1000. It is different from the LC5:5 period doubling chaotization which dominates for α < 800. However, after evolution of the chaos with increasing Q, both ways produce similar chaotic regimes according to the values of LEs and the structure of recurrence time maps. After chaotization the appearance of many periodic windows is observed over the vast (Q-α)- area. In most of them limit cycles are symmetric with identical winding number, LCn:n and identical amplitudes of oscillations in the two oscillators. However, the dynamics in some windows deserve special attention because they contain spatially asymmetric limit cycles which are not typical for identical oscillators. The boundaries of AsLC3:4, AsLC2:3, and AsLC3:5 are pictured in Fig. 5 while the periodic windows with other partial asymmetric LCs are too narrow to be found with the chosen numerical accuracy used in Fig. 5. Although the bands with stable AsLCs are narrow (see, for example, interval between 2:3LP and 2:3PD in Fig. 5) their unstable branches cover large areas of the (Q-α)-plane forming asymmetrical elements in the chaotic time series. A typical example of the chaotic trajectories with fluctuations of asymmetric "polarity" is presented in Fig. 15(a) as well as a zoom in Fig. 15(b) showing the long lived unstable orbit LC2:3. It is notable that for two coupled identical oscillators, the version of QS coupling used in system (1) has disrupted the homogeneity of oscillations inside chaos and has generated very different values of recurrence times. Fig. 15. Time series of symmetric chaotic regime for n=3, α =1000, Q=0.58 (a) and a zoom of "polarized" part from this time series (b) showing the long-lived unstable 2:3LC. Thus, for α < 1000 two identical Repressilators indirectly coupled via diffusion of autoinducer demonstrate several important dynamical features: (i) the existence of a very large area of parameter-space where the appearance of self-organized quasiperiodicity occurs, which is unusual for coupled identical oscillators; (ii) the coexistence of torus and non-resonant LC5:5, each of which initiate the development of chaos in different large areas of the parameter plane; (iii) the existence of periodic windows with asymmetric limit cycles, the unstable branches of 16 which cover large regions of the parameter space, ensuring the "polarization" of chaotic time series. Further growth of α (next section) stimulates the appearance of the other asymmetric limit cycle 1:2, which, in turn, produces the coexistence of regular, quasiperiodic and chaotic, symmetric and asymmetric regimes over very large parts of (Q-α)-plane. 3.2 High-strength Oscillators: α > 1000 In the previous section, we saw that the main LC5:5 and the torus provide routes to chaos for most of the region for α<1000. For 800<α<1000 the weak chaos that arises from the period doubling of the LC5:5 is stable for only a short Q-interval (see Fig. 13). When this chaos becomes unstable the system transitions to either the torus or As9:9LC depending on the location in the (Q-α)-map. However, the As9:9LC becomes unstable with further increase of Q and the system transitions to the torus which then provides the final stage of the route to chaos emerging at ETR. Figure 16 shows the region of the (Q-α)-map in which the LC5:5-Res and the As9:9LC island are the important dynamics interacting with the torus to provide routes to chaos as α increases beyond 1000. Surprisingly, the external boundary of AsLC9:9 has a smooth closed form and is limited to α<3200, while the internal marking of stability areas is delineated by additional LP and PD lines. Fig. 16. (Q-α)-map of the AsLC9:9 islands, 1:2LP- the boundary of LC1:2 stability, and the resonance LC5:5-R: (a) boundaries of basic regimes and (b) zoom showing the structure of torus and AsLC9:9 locations (compare with Fig.17). The route to chaos for α=1200 is shown by the LEs graph in Fig. 17, in agreement with the boundaries encountered along the α = 1200 line in Fig. 16b. The LC5:5-Res loses stability at its LP and the system transitions to the torus as indicated by a second LE with zero amplitude. The torus has the set of resonant limit cycles (e. g. 14:14, 23:23) and the asymmetric LC9:9 at the negative dips of the second (green) LE. In contrast to the case in the previous section for α =1000 where LC9:9 is continuously stable, for α = 1200 there are 3 narrow stable LC9:9 regions separated by torus and by chaos (main LE > 0). Figure 16b shows the stable torus region 17 delineated by interior 9:9LP structure separating the first two stable LC9:9 regions (see the small oval in Fig. 16b), and the period-doubled chaos region separating the next two. The chaos emerging from the period-doubling cascade of the LC9:9 matures, as indicated by the growing main LE. The growth is interrupted by the narrow periodic window which contains the period- halving cascade back to stable 9:9LC in the Q-span just prior to the high-Q LP. Fig. 17. LEs as a function of Q (step=0.0001) for trajectory started from resonant LC5:5-Res. α=1200. As α increases up to 2200, the Q-interval with stable AsLC9:9 shortens (Fig. 16) and the chaos emerged from period-doubling starts at smaller coupling strengths. This symmetric chaos extends to larger coupling strengths where it encounters and coexists over a broad Q-span with a new asymmetric limit cycle, AsLC1:2, shown in Fig. 16 with dark green line. The time series of both regimes are presented in Fig. 18 which demonstrates the sharp transition from symmetric chaos to the AsLC1:2 which occurs at the end of the coexistence region. 18 Fig. 18. The time series of transition from chaotic regime to stable LC1:2 at Q=0.568, for α=2000. The small fluctuations of amplitudes after the transition are the transient. By analogy with Fig. 4 for the LC5:5, we calculated for different α, the family of LC1:2 Q- continuations shown in Fig. 19 which delineates the areas of stability and reveals the basic bifurcations of this new limit cycle. Fig. 19. The lower branch of one-parameter Q-continuations of LC1:2 amplitude for α =1800 (LC1:2 is stable from LP to TR) and for α=3000 with TR bifurcations and PD cascades. Throughout a large region of coupling strengths the external boundaries of 1:2LC stability are determined by a limit point at the low-Q end and torus bifurcation at the high-Q end, while the internal structure of the phase diagram is mainly controlled by the locations of torus and period doubling bifurcations. Two-parameter continuations of bifurcation boundaries of important limit cycles, including the LC1:2 in Fig. 19, are presented in Fig. 20, which is an extension of Fig. 5 for large α. The boundary of stability of the symmetrical chaos, which coexists with LC1:2, is calculated by direct integration of the time series or LEs and is presented in Fig. 20 as a black dashed line. It is noteworthy that over a wide range of α, from 1200 to 2500, chaos is not restored in the central range of Q-values (0.65 to 0.95). Instead, after the end of the chaos emerged from PD of AsLC9:9, there is a broad area dominated by stable LC1:2 and LC2:4. It is only when α surpasses 2500 when the PD-cascade of the LC1:2 creates chaos. 19 Fig. 20. Q-α regime map for α > 1000. Only those boundaries relevant to chaos evolution are shown. The white area adjacent to LC1:2 and LC2:4 contains many asymmetric limit cycles, see Fig. 22 as example. For α > 2500 and the intermediate values of coupling strength (0.65<Q< 0.85), the system (1) demonstrates the classic route to chaos via period doubling cascades of the AsLC1:2. The chaotization after period doublings results in the restoration of spatial symmetry of the attractor as a whole because the amplitudes of the Repressilator's oscillations become the same. However, this formal symmetrization masks the real temporal asymmetry of the chaotic trajectories. The typical trajectory presented in Fig. 21 clearly demonstrates the stochastic long- lasting intervals with the fixed polarity. 20 Fig. 21. The random example of the time series demonstrating the chaotic switching of polarity, α=3000, Q=0.797. The existence of long almost deterministic asymmetric orbits within a chaotic time series can change the widely-held view of chaos as a short-correlated irregular process. Because the asymmetric LC is the starting attractor for the development of chaos, there are large parameter regions in which the lengths of time series used for LE calculations should be chosen taking into account the characteristic durations of periodic orbits embedded in chaos. The LEs presented below were calculated using very long samples to ensure reliable averaging. Further increase of Q restores the asymmetry of dynamical regimes due to the reverse cascade of PD bifurcations which takes the system back to LC1:2. The AsLC1:2 is stable up to the high-Q 1:2TR seen in Fig. 20, where it then loses stability and the symmetric chaos is again the single attractor of our system. An interesting qualitative phenomenon of the system is the continuous strip of coexistence of the symmetric chaos and the LC1:2 formed by the end-of-chaos boundary inside the 1:2TR for high-Q and inside the 1:2LP for low-Q. The coexistence of symmetrical chaos with asymmetrical limit cycles is a remarkable peculiarity of the system (1). The manifestation of this coexistence for the low-Q region is different from that described above for the high-Q region. At the low-Q region bifurcation analysis discovered one more special chaotic area bounded by the torus bifurcations of LC1:2 (see lines low-Q 1:2TR and 2:4TR in Fig. 20). Consider the dynamics for the case α =2500. For Q-values beyond the LP1:2-line the system (1) can be found in three coexisting states: LC1:2, LC3:6 (see below) and the symmetric chaos. The evolution of the LC1:2 is presented in Fig. 22 where two LEs=0 starting at Q=0.542 indicates the start of the torus, in agreement with the 1:2TR line in Fig. 20. The resulting torus is asymmetric, and its development towards chaos is very limited for α=2500. Instead, the asymmetric branch contains a sequence of asymmetric limit cycles: 5:10, 7:14, 9:18, 12:24, 13:26 and the system demonstrates the transition to LC2:4 via 2:4TR bifurcation (Q=0.64) as prescribed by the map in Fig. 20. 21 Fig.22. The dependence of LEs on Q (step=0.0005) for n=3, α =2500. The starting regimes are: LC1:2- solid lines and the symmetric chaos – dashed lines. The insert is the LEs vs Q for regime LC3:6, which occurs at Q=0.518 and overlaps with LC1:2 and chaos. As for the symmetric chaos, for α=2500 it loses stability near the same Q-value where the LC1:2 lost stability, 1:2TR (Q=0.542), resulting in the system switching to an asymmetric weakly chaotic regime originated from the period doubling cascade of the LC3:6 (insert in Fig.22). This sudden loss of chaotic symmetry is illustrated in the time series in Fig. 23. Then the system evolves up to the transition of the weak asymmetric chaos to asymmetric torus at Q=0.5457. Fig. 23. The symmetric chaos loses stability and the system switches to asymmetrical weak chaos originated from PD-cascade of LC3:6. α=2500, Q=0.5428 For larger values of α, the system demonstrates a wider area of stability for the symmetrical chaos. For example, at α=3000 the symmetric chaos is stable up to the transition to LC2:4 (see below the details of this transition) and it shares the phase space with LC1:2 and its asymmetric derivatives. The evolutions of LEs for chaos and LC1:2 are presented in Fig. 24 where the new regime LC3:6 is observed. 22 Fig. 24.Two sets of LEs vs Q for both regimes: start from LC1:2 – solid lines, start from chaos – dashed lines. The LC3:6 is another exotic example of the coexistence of the symmetric chaos with an asymmetric limit cycle (see Fig. 24). LC3:6 is the tripled version of LC1:2 (see Fig. 25a) and is stable in a narrow band along the 3:6LP line (Fig. 20). It undergoes period-doubling bifurcation to chaos, first to a weak asymmetric chaos followed by the transition to strong symmetric chaos as directly observed in Fig. 25(b) and supported by the sharp increase of the first LE (black line in Fig. 24 near Q=0.525). The LC3:6 is not a periodic window within the symmetric chaos. Instead, it coexists with the symmetric chaos and with the LC1:2. Fig. 25. (a)- the phase portrait of LC3:6, Q=0.507;(b)- the transition of weak asymmetric chaos to strong symmetric one, Q=0.5249. α=3000. Figure 24 shows that the chaos from the period-doubled LC3:6 matures and merges with the symmetric chaos. The further evolution of this single chaotic attractor is shown in Fig. 26. The sym-chaos loses stability, making a sharp transition to LC2:4. The period doubling of LC2:4 restores chaos, which is stable over the large interval of coupling strength up to the high-Q period-halving cascade. The system sequentially crosses the regions with LC1:2, LC1:2+chaos, 23 pure chaos and torus, eventually reaching the TR-bifurcation back to stable anti-phase LC (see Fig. 20). Fig. 26. LEs vs Q starting from the symmetric chaos. α=3000. 4. Discussion There are a huge number of papers concerning the collective behavior of nonlinear oscillators published since Huygens's study of coupled clocks (see e.g. [1] and references there in). The recent discovery of "chimeras" is an important and impressive example of the role of the coupling type (see review [11]) in the formation of unexpected dynamical regimes. Although the simple version of "quorum sensing" mechanism can be used to connect oscillators of different nature [40, 41], it is most effective for the coupling of genetic oscillators imbedded in cognate bacterial medium. The genetic networks are constructed from many nonlinear elements, each of which may be engineered to accept the inter-oscillator signal produced in accordance with the activity of other genes. The cooperation of this local property of genetic networks with the indirect global coupling via signal molecule diffusion provides many possible combinations of coupling schemes. The design of our system, like that of the other versions of the model for coupled Repressilators [27, 30-33], is the simplest one for 3-gene networks with one autoinducer. Being produced under control of gene "b" promoter, the autoinducer activates the expression of downstream gene "c". Despite linear diffusion of the autoinducer, the difference in gene "b" and "c" positions inside the Repressilators' ring provides a completely possible, but a nonstandard coupling scheme. The oscillations of repressors B1 and B2 concentrations are first converted to those of the signal variables S1 and S2 with some time delay. Then, the signal molecules mix according to a quasi- steady state approximation and transfer the impact of the superposition of delayed B1 and B2 oscillations onto the production rates of C1 and C2. As a result, the effective frequencies of oscillations with the superposition, as well as their dependences on the model parameters, are different from the internal frequencies of the Repressilators. As a result, the map in Fig. 27 over 24 the entire interval of α focuses on the major unexpected collective modes discovered and their interrelations. Fig. 27. Map of the major unexpected collective modes for the two identical QS-coupled ring oscillators. The paths to chaos are presented in previous Sections. The external boundary of the large parameter area with the rich set of attractors is formed by the line of torus bifurcation of the anti-phase limit cycle. The appearance of torus in the system of two coupled identical oscillators in the absence of an external periodic perturbation is a rare event which requires specific choice of coupling term [42, 43]. The internal boundary of the torus stability (ETR-line) up to α = 1000 is presented in the map Fig. 27 and it consists of two parts separated approximately at α = 800. The loss of stability after the upper part of the ETR line (800<α<1000) is a result of period doubling bifurcations of resonant cycles leading to the chaotization of the system. Along the lower part of the boundary the torus is pushed from the phase space by the LC5:5. Although there are no indications of its bifurcation origin within the considered areas of parameters, the LC5:5 is of principle importance for the dynamics below α=600. It is not a resonant cycle limited by Neimark-Saker bifurcations. In contrast, up to α=600 it period-doubles creating a very large area of chaos. For the larger α, its role in chaos production is diminished, giving way to torus destruction as a path to chaos. Over the large interval above α=1000 a new slightly asymmetrical LC9:9 is located within the closed area (Fig. 27, green line) and the chaos is a result of its period doubling bifurcations. Omitting some details concerning the dynamics of resonant cycles inside the low-Q region adjacent to the TR-line, we concentrate on the chaos creation and conclude that in the system (1) the origin of symmetric chaos is the period doubling bifurcations of different limit cycles: resonant cycles on torus, symmetric LC5:5 and asymmetric 25 LC9:9. Despite the identical nature of the coupled Represilators, the variability of return times and amplitudes of variables in the 5:5 and As9:9 limit cycles are significant. Further development of chaos over (α-Q)-plane demonstrates the surprising formation of asymmetric limit cycles in narrow periodic windows, e.g. 3:4, 2:3, 3:5, which return to chaos via period doubling bifurcations. The stability of chaos unexpectedly disappears (dashed black line in Fig. 27) and the system jumps to the asymmetrical LC1:2 which is unlike standard limit cycles within PWs. The LC1:2 (dark green line in Fig. 27) coexists with chaos and evolves independently generating its own chaos via the period doubling bifurcations ending in the restoration of the symmetrical chaos over a very large area of parameters. Although there are known examples of chaos formation owing to the interaction of identical oscillators [44-47], the indirect QS-coupling gives rise to new uncommon limit cycles being starting points for chaos and its complex evolution over the parameter plane. Classical bifurcations of limit cycles -- period doubling and torus formation-- lead to standard processes of system chaotization. However, under multistability conditions, they generate an unusual phase diagram with domination of chaos and asymmetric attractors. How general are the set of attractors and the observed structure of the map bearing in mind the unavoidable deviations from perfectly identical oscillators and the reasonable shifts of other model parameters, e.g. Hill coefficient n or the AI-induced activation rate κ? In previous publications [32, 33] the unsuccessful choice of the main parameters revealed only the torus- chaos transition corresponding to the lower part of the full map in Fig. 27. To check the robustness of the detected attractors we calculated the boundaries of the basic regimes and found that they changed on the map only in absolute coordinates but their relative positions remained the same. In particular, the set n=3.15, k=10 shifts the boundaries of the regimes towards smaller values of α but larger values of Q are then required to reveal all regimes (data not shown). A small detuning of Repressilators via the parameter α mismatches did not remove the discovered ways for chaos development and the appearance of hysteretic areas. The formation of symmetric and asymmetric limit cycles inside quasiperiodic and chaotic regimes, as well as the generation of extended regions with chaos, is a reliable consequence of the specific choice of the QS equation used in system (1) for the coupling of the smooth ring oscillators. The other ODE model of coupled Repressilators used in [27] is different from system (1) by the location of the protein accompanying the production of autoinducer. However, the other type of multistability manifested as the coexistence of in-phase and anti-phase regular and complex oscillations is generated in extended areas of control parameters [28]. We speculate that the QS-dependent multistability may be realized in other synthetic models with different versions of autoinducer production and its targets which may be important for the understanding of the origin of variability, not only in genetic networks. 5. Acknowledgements This work is partially supported by grants Russian Foundation for Basic Research 15-02-03236 and 17-01-00070. We thank Nikolay Sukhorukov for the calculations of Lyapunov exponents. References 26 ======================================================= [1] Pikovsky, A, Rosenblum, M, Kurths, J. Synchronization A Universal Concept in Nonlinear Sciences, Cambridge University Press; 2003. [2] Pisarchik, AN, Feudel, U. Control of multistability, Physics Reports. 540 (2014) 167-218. [3] Koseska, A, Volkov, E, Kurths, J. Oscillation quenching mechanisms: Amplitude vs. oscillation death, Physics Reports. 531 (2013) 173-99. [4] Taylor, AF, Tinsley, MR, Showalter, K. Insights into collective cell behaviour from populations of coupled chemical oscillators, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics. 17 (2015) 20047-55. [5] Nagornov, R, Osipov, G, Komarov, M, Pikovsky, A, Shilnikov, A. Mixed-mode synchronization between two inhibitory neurons with post-inhibitory rebound, Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation. 36 (2016) 175-91. [6] Prasad, A, Sakai, K, Hoshino, Y. Direct coupling: a possible strategy to control fruit production in alternate bearing, Scientific Reports. 7 (2017) 39890. [7] Kuramoto, Y, Battogtokh, D. Coexistence of Coherence and Incoherence in Nonlocally Coupled Phase Oscillators, Nonlinear Phenomena in Complex Systems. 5 (2002) 380-5. [8] Omel'chenko, OE, Wolfrum, M, Yanchuk, S, Maistrenko, YL, Sudakov, O. Stationary patterns of coherence and incoherence in two-dimensional arrays of non-locally-coupled phase oscillators, Physical Review E. 85 (2012) 036210. [9] Tinsley, MR, Nkomo, S, Showalter, K. Chimera and phase-cluster states in populations of coupled chemical oscillators, Nat Phys. 8 (2012) 662-5. [10] Martens, EA, Thutupalli, S, Fourrière, A, Hallatschek, O. Chimera states in mechanical oscillator networks, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 110 (2013) 10563-7. [11] Panaggio, MJ, Abrams, DM. Chimera states: coexistence of coherence and incoherence in networks of coupled oscillators, Nonlinearity. 28 (2015) R67. [12] Zakharova, A, Kapeller, M, Schöll, E. Chimera Death: Symmetry Breaking in Dynamical Networks, Physical Review Letters. 112 (2014) 154101. [13] Purcell, O, Savery, NJ, Grierson, CS, di Bernardo, M. A comparative analysis of synthetic genetic oscillators, Journal of The Royal Society Interface. 7 (2010) 1503-24. [14] O'Brien, EL, Van Itallie, E, Bennett, MR. Modeling synthetic gene oscillators, Mathematical Biosciences. 236 (2012) 1-15. [15] Mandal, MK, Sarkar, BC. Ring oscillators: Characteristics and applications, Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Physics. 48 (2010) 136-45. [16] Elowitz, MB, Leibler, S. A synthetic oscillatory network of transcriptional regulators, Nature. 403 (2000) 335-8. [17] Niederholtmeyer, H, Sun, ZZ, Hori, Y, Yeung, E, Verpoorte, A, Murray, RM, Maerkl, SJ. Rapid cell-free forward engineering of novel genetic ring oscillators, eLife. 4 (2015) e09771. [18] Potvin-Trottier, L, Lord, ND, Vinnicombe, G, Paulsson, J. Synchronous long-term oscillations in a synthetic gene circuit, Nature. 538 (2016) 514-7. [19] Gao, XJ, Elowitz, MB. Synthetic biology: Precision timing in a cell, Nature. 538 (2016) 462-3. [20] Hellen, EH, Volkov, E, Kurths, J, Dana, SK. An Electronic Analog of Synthetic Genetic Networks, PLoS ONE. 6 (2011) e23286. [21] Hellen, EH, Kurths, J, Dana, SK. Electronic circuit analog of synthetic genetic networks: Revisited, Eur Phys J Special Topics. 226 (2017) 1811-28. [22] Garg, N, Manchanda, G, Kumar, A. Bacterial quorum sensing: circuits and applications, Antonie van Leeuwenhoek. 105 (2014) 289-305. 27 [23] Smith, RP, Boudreau, L, You, L. Engineering Cell-to-Cell Communication to Explore Fundamental Questions in Ecology and Evolution. in: SJ Hagen, (Ed.). The Physical Basis of Bacterial Quorum Communication. Springer New York, New York, NY, 2015. pp. 227-47. [24] Danino, T, Mondragon-Palomino, O, Tsimring, L, Hasty, J. A synchronized quorum of genetic clocks, Nature. 463 (2010) 326-30. [25] McMillen, D, Kopell, N, Hasty, J, Collins, JJ. Synchronizing genetic relaxation oscillators by intercell signaling, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 99 (2002) 679-84. [26] Kuznetsov, A, Kaern, M, Kopell, N. Synchrony in a Population of Hysteresis-Based Genetic Oscillators, SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics. 65 (2004) 392-425. [27] Garcia-Ojalvo, J, Elowitz, MB, Strogatz, SH. Modeling a synthetic multicellular clock: Repressilators coupled by quorum sensing, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 101 (2004) 10955-60. [28] Potapov, I, Volkov, E, Kuznetsov, A. Dynamics of coupled repressilators: The role of mRNA kinetics and transcription cooperativity, Physical Review E. 83 (2011) 031901. [29] Li, C, Chen, L, Aihara, K. Stochastic synchronization of genetic oscillator networks, BMC Systems Biology. 1 (2007) 6. [30] Yi, QZ, Zhang, JJ, Yuan, ZJ, Zhou, TS. Collective dynamics of genetic oscillators with cell-to-cell communication: a study case of signal integration, The European Physical Journal B. 75 (2010) 365-72. [31] Yi, Q, Zhou, T. Communication-induced multistability and multirhythmicity in a synthetic multicellular system, Physical Review E. 83 (2011) 051907. [32] Ullner, E, Koseska, A, Kurths, J, Volkov, E, Kantz, H, García-Ojalvo, J. Multistability of synthetic genetic networks with repressive cell-to-cell communication, Physical Review E. 78 (2008) 031904. [33] Ullner, E, Zaikin, A, Volkov, EI, García-Ojalvo, J. Multistability and Clustering in a Population of Synthetic Genetic Oscillators via Phase-Repulsive Cell-to-Cell Communication, Physical Review Letters. 99 (2007) 148103. [34] Hellen, EH, Volkov, E. Flexible dynamics of two quorum-sensing coupled repressilators, Physical Review E. 95 (2017) 022408. [35] Brewster, RC, Jones, DL, Phillips, R. Tuning Promoter Strength through RNA Polymerase Binding Site Design in Escherichia coli, PLOS Computational Biology. 8 (2012) e1002811. [36] Davis, JH, Rubin, AJ, Sauer, RT. Design, construction and characterization of a set of insulated bacterial promoters, Nucleic Acids Research. 39 (2011) 1131-41. [37] Hellen, EH, Dana, SK, Zhurov, B, Volkov, E. Electronic Implementation of a Repressilator with Quorum Sensing Feedback, PLoS ONE. 8 (2013) e62997. [38] Ermentrout, B. Simulating, Analyzing, and Animating Dynamical Systems: A Guide to XPPAUT for Researchers and Students. Philadelphia, PA, SIAM; 2002. [39] Doedel, EJ, Fairgrieve, TF, Sandstede, B, Champneys, AR, Kuznetsov, YA, Wang, X. AUTO-07P: Continuation and bifurcation software for ordinary differential equations. 2007. [40] Taylor, AF, Tinsley, MR, Wang, F, Huang, Z, Showalter, K. Dynamical Quorum Sensing and Synchronization in Large Populations of Chemical Oscillators, Science. 323 (2009) 614-7. [41] De Monte, S, d'Ovidio, F, Danø, S, Sørensen, PG. Dynamical quorum sensing: Population density encoded in cellular dynamics, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 104 (2007) 18377-81. [42] Bondarenko, VE, Cymbalyuk, GS, Patel, G, DeWeerth, SP, Calabrese, RL. Bifurcation of synchronous oscillations into torus in a system of two reciprocally inhibitory silicon neurons: Experimental observation and modeling, Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science. 14 (2004) 995-1003. [43] Rosenblum, M, Pikovsky, A. Self-Organized Quasiperiodicity in Oscillator Ensembles with Global Nonlinear Coupling, Physical Review Letters. 98 (2007) 064101. 28 [44] Schreiber, I, Marek, M. Transition to chaos via two-torus in coupled reaction-diffusion cells, Physics Letters A. 91 (1982) 263-6. [45] Sporns, O, Roth, S, Seelig, FF. Chaotic dynamics of two coupled biochemical oscillators, Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena. 26 (1987) 215-24. [46] Hakim, V, Rappel, W-J. Dynamics of the globally coupled complex Ginzburg-Landau equation, Physical Review A. 46 (1992) R7347-R50. [47] Nakagawa, N, Kuramoto, Y. Collective Chaos in a Population of Globally Coupled Oscillators, Progress of Theoretical Physics. 89 (1993) 313-23.
1302.1641	1	1302	2013-02-07T04:40:52	Membrane mediated aggregation of curvature inducing nematogens and membrane tubulation	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.SC" ]	The shapes of cell membranes are largely regulated by membrane associated, curvature active, proteins. We use a numerical model of the membrane with elongated membrane inclusions, recently developed by us, which posses spontaneous directional curvatures that could be different along and perpendicular to its long axis. We show that, due to membrane mediated interactions these curvature inducing membrane nematogens can oligomerize spontaneously, even at low concentrations, and change the local shape of the membrane. We demonstrate that for a large group of such inclusions, where the two spontaneous curvatures have equal sign, the tubular conformation and sometime the sheet conformation of the membrane are the common equilibrium shapes. We elucidate the factors necessary for the formation of these {\it protein lattices}. Furthermore, the elastic properties of the tubes, like their compressional stiffness and persistence length are calculated. Finally, we discuss the possible role of nematic disclination in capping and branching of the tubular membranes.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Membrane mediated aggregation of curvature inducing nematogens and http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.bpj.2012.12.045, Biophysical Journal membrane tubulation N. Ramakrishnan∗ and P. B. Sunil Kumar† Department of Physics, Indian Institute of Technology Madras, Chennai 600036, India John H. Ipsen‡ MEMPHYS- Center for Biomembrane Physics, Department of Physics and Chemistry, University of Southern Denmark, Campusvej 55, DK-5230 Odense M, Denmark (Dated: September 30, 2018) Abstract The shapes of cell membranes are largely regulated by membrane associated, curvature active, proteins. We use a numerical model of the membrane with elongated membrane inclusions, recently developed by us, which posses spontaneous directional curvatures that could be different along and perpendicular to its long axis. We show that, due to membrane mediated interactions these curvature inducing membrane nematogens can oligomerize spontaneously, even at low concentrations, and change the local shape of the membrane. We demonstrate that for a large group of such inclusions, where the two spontaneous curvatures have equal sign, the tubular conformation and sometime the sheet conformation of the membrane are the common equilibrium shapes. We elucidate the factors necessary for the formation of these protein lattices. Furthermore, the elastic properties of the tubes, like their compressional stiffness and persistence length are calculated. Finally, we discuss the possible role of nematic disclination in capping and branching of the tubular membranes. PACS numbers: PACS-87.16.D-, Membranes, bilayers and vesicles. PACS-05.40.-a Fluctuation phenomena, random pro- cesses, noise and Brownian motion. PACS-05.70.Np Interfaces and surface thermodynamics 3 1 0 2 b e F 7 ] h p - o i b . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 1 4 6 1 . 2 0 3 1 : v i X r a ∗Electronic address: [email protected] †Electronic address: [email protected] ‡Electronic address: [email protected] 1 I. INTRODUCTION Membrane shape deformations are key phenomena in a multitude of cellular processes, including pro- tein sorting, protein transport, organelle biogenesis and signaling. In the last decade a profusion of regulatory proteins facilitating such shape changes of the cellular membranes has been unravelled, with the BAR protein superfamily [1], the Pex11 family [2] and coat proteins [3] as notable examples. The possibility of such mechanisms has long been anticipated in the biophysical literature[4, 5]. However the experimental and theoretical difficulties involved have hampered the establishment of a quantitative basis for interpreting such phenomena in cell biology. Recently, we had overcome one such obstacle by the establishment of a computer simulation technique to study how the cooperative effects of membrane inclusions, imposing a curvature along the direction of its orientation, remodels vesicular membranes[6]. In this work we aim at describing, from a theoretical point of view, the effect of a large group of these membrane curving proteins, which can be considered as effectively elongated objects in the plane of the membrane. We consider inclusions with approximate π-symmetry, i.e. the protein can be considered as essentially indistinguishable from its form rotated by 180◦ around the protein center in the plane of the membrane. The membrane inclusions we consider, has thus some similarity with nematogens in 3-D nematic liquid crystals. However, they are embedded in a membrane and may couple to its geometry, and it is only the part of the protein in contact with the membrane, which will be subject to these symmetry requirement. Therefore, we cannot consider these membrane inclusions as simple liquid crystal nematogens restricted to Euclidean two dimensional surfaces. In the following we will refer to such membrane inclusions as membrane nematogens. Large groups of membrane curving proteins fall into this category of membrane nematogens. An example is the BAR proteins(proteins containing both BAR domains and/or N-terminal helices), where both the N-terminal amphipatic helices and the banana-shaped, positively charged, dimeric interface with the membrane, induces directional curvature [7 -- 12]. The caveolin protein family[13], which form dimers and are bound to the membrane by a pair of hairpins and the reticulon, DP1 and Yop1p involved in the formation of smooth ER [15, 16], and are anchored to the membrane by two similar hairpins are also examples. The cell biology literature has provided good evidence for that the insertion of amphipathic helical peptide sequences not only provide a binding mechanism, but also gives rise to local modulation of the membrane curvature [17, 18]. More solid, quantitative support for this conjecture is given from biophysical experiments [19] and theory [20] . Furthermore, biophysical studies has demonstrated that curvature active membrane inclusions have dramatic effects on the cooperative behavior with a complex interplay between lateral ordering and membrane shape. However, the detailed mechanisms leading to the specific complex membrane-protein structures have not been characterized. This work will elucidate some aspects of these mechanisms for the membrane nematogens. Some of the key processes involved in the structural organization of membrane nematogens described in the cell biology literature, can be categorized as follows: (1) the aggregation of the nematogens - the pro- cess where membrane proteins upon activation and/or binding to the membrane spontaneously aggregate and form functional cluster of proteins in the membrane[9 -- 11, 14], (2) Tubulation of membranes, where the aggregate and the membrane develop tube-like membrane structures (e.g. sorting endosomes[21, 22] and Mitochondrial outer membrane[23], formation of T-tubules in Drosophila[24]) and (3) The formation of protein lattices, often characterized by helical arrangement of the proteins spiraling around the tubular membrane, e.g. for dynamin [25, 26] or caveolin [27]. In this work, we will demonstrate by numerical analysis of a possible physical model, which captures the membrane conformations and the organization of in-plane nematogens, that the above mentioned processes directly results from the cooperative thermodynamic behavior of the nematogens coupled to the flexible membrane. Also, we will discuss aspects of the stability of membrane tubes and the formation of the edges for membrane sheets. Our model gives a coarse description of the membrane, which capture properties of the membrane which are essential for its large scale organization. Despite the simplicity of the model, the parameter space is too large for a comprehensive discussion of it's phase behavior. Rather, we will focus on some generic features of the model which may well give a framework for interpreting the experimental observations of cellular membrane morphogenesis. Previously, protein induced membrane tube formation has been considered by a phenomenological model involving scalar fields [28], and the coupling between membranes and inclusions with directional curvature was modelled in [29 -- 32]. The paper is organized as follows: In Section II the physical model of the interacting system of mem- brane and membrane nematogens are presented, while details about the numerical analysis is given in Supplementary Materials. Section III on Results and Discusion present some generic properties of 2 the model and discuss their possible relevance to experimental results. In section III A-III C the aggrega- tion of proteins and membrane domain formation, membrane tubulation and formation of protein lattices are described in the framework of the model. Section III D discusses the elastic properties of membrane tubes and their relevance to observable effects. Much of the characterization of the elasticity of protein lattices is based on a continuum version of the model discussed Supplementary Materials. Section III E discusses mechanisms of closing, capping and branching of membrane tubules and the possible role of nematic point defects. Section III F describes aspects of the stability of membrane tubules with more membrane curvature components. In section III G the interplay between sheet and tubule formation is described and possible implications for cell organel morphology is discussed. Some perspective on the modeling of membrane morphogenesis is given in Conclusion, Section IV. We will in this work specialize to properties of membranes with inclusions which posses directional curvatures of equal sign. We will consider cases with different signs of the directional curvatures in a seperate publication. II. MODEL The modeling of the effects of in-plane nematogens on membrane structure, will in this work, be treated with a discretized description of the surface as a randomly triangulated mesh. A continuous surface conformation is approximated by a collection of triangles glued together to form a closed surface of well defined topology. A triangulated surface, with spherical topology, thus consist of N vertices connected by NL = 3(N − 2) links, which enclose NT = 2(N − 2) triangles. Each vertex v is assigned a position (cid:126)Xv. This tesselatations of the surface form the basis for a coarse grained description of the membrane, where only the gross features of the structure and interactions are important. FIG. 1: (a) A one ring triangulated patch around a vertex v. The shaded region represents the tangent plane at v and N (v) its corresponding normal. c1v and c2v are the maximum and minimum principal curvatures, respectively, along principal directions t1v and t2v. (b) Illustration of the nematic field vector n defined on the tangent plane of vertex v. (c) A vesicle of spherical topology with spatially random surface nematogens. The triangulation and the vertex position form together a discretized surface, a patch of which is given in fig:??. The geometry of the continuous surface, which is approximated by the triangulated surface, can now be characterized by a number of surface quantifiers, e.g. the curvature tensor, the principal directions (t1v & t2v), the corresponding principal curvatures (c1v & c2v) and surface normal, N (v), at each vertex v. The details can be found in [6]. The discretized Helfrich's free energy[34] can then be evaluated as N(cid:88) v=1 Hc = κ 2 Av 3 H 2 v (1) where Hv = (c1v + c2v)/2 the mean curvature at vertex v and Av is the area of the surface patch occupied by the triangles adjacent to vertex v. κ is the bending rigidity of the membrane. Furthermore we are in a position to calculate the directional curvatures along and perpendicular to a unit vector n along the surface by use of Gauss formula: Hv,(cid:107) = c1v cos2 ϕv + c2v sin2 ϕv, Hv,⊥ = c1v sin2 ϕv + c2v cos2 ϕv, 3 (2) planetangentvN(v)c1vc2vt2vt1vvn(v)ϕvt2vt1v(a)(b)(c) Mixed phasedemixing and constrictionActivation of field Bwhere ϕv is the angle between n and the principal direction t1v. Such an orientational spontaneous curvature may be induced by a membrane nematogen with an orientation in the plane of the membrane given by n. In addition to the interaction with the membrane, nematogens may tend to orient along each other at close proximity due to steric, electrostatic and dispersion interactions [35]. In the present study, we focus only on the two dimensional orientational interactions promoted by the underlying, non- planar, fluctuating membrane [36 -- 40]. The π-symmetry of the individual nematogens dictates that the simplest form of their self interaction should be of the type cos2(θvu) and sin2(θvu), where θvu is the angle between nv and nu at neighboring vertices. We choose to represent the interactions between membrane nematogens by an extension of the well-established Lebwohl-Lasher model of nematic ordering in presence of vacancies, here implemented on a triangulated surface model of a membrane. The nearest neighbor interaction between the nematogens is composed of an isotropic component represented by an interaction strength J and an anistropic (quadrupolar) correction measured by the interaction constant LL. The total interaction between the membrane nematogens thus takes the form (cid:26) (cid:88) (cid:104)vu(cid:105) (cid:18) 3 2 (cid:19)(cid:27) Hfield = J 2 − LL − cos2(θvu) − 1 2 IvIu, (3) where the sum is over nearest neighbour vertices. Iv = 0, 1 is an occupation variable, which is unity if vertex "v" is occupied by a nematogen and zero if otherwise. The calculation of the θvu is non-trivial, since the angle between spatially separated nematogens are measured after the parallel transport of vec- tors along the curved surface [6]. With this measure of the angular differences, Eq.(3) models the in-plane interactions of the nematogens mediated by the membrane. The direct distance dependent interactions through the cytosol is not taken into account in this model of membrane-protein conformations. Suf- ficiently large, positive LL favors in-plane ordering of the nematogens. The effect on the anisotropic elasticity of the membrane due to the nematogens, in analogy with the discretized Helfrich free energy, takes the form [6]: (cid:16) (cid:26) κ(cid:107) N(cid:88) 2 v=1 Hnc = (cid:17)2 Hv,(cid:107) − H 0(cid:107) + κ⊥ 2 (cid:27) (cid:0)Hv,⊥ − H 0⊥(cid:1)2 IvAv (4) H 0(cid:107) and H 0⊥ are the spontaneous curvatures along n and n⊥, while κ(cid:107) and κ⊥ are the corresponding directional membrane bending elastic constants. Self avoidance of the discretized surface is ensured by imposing constraints on the neighboring vertex distance and on the dihedral angles between neighboring faces[6]. The equilibrium properties of the discretized surface can now be evaluated by standard Monte Carlo sampling of Boltzmann's probability distribution ∼ exp at fixed concentrations of the membrane nematogens. A general description of the implemetation of such numerical models and further details about the simulations are given in [6]. − 1 kB T [Hc + Hfield + Hnc] (cid:16) (cid:17) Finally, we will make some considerations about length scales. The lattice model is a highly coarse- grained representation of the membrane, designed to capture the large length-scale properties of mem- branes with inclusions. Therefore, the triangulated surface represent a collection of membrane patches with a characteristic length scale. A natural choice of length scale is to identify a tether length with the lateral extension of a membrane inclusion. Some examples here are CIP4 F-BAR with a length of 22 nm[41] or dynamin which extent about 25 nm [25]. The computer simulations of the discrete model provide us with insight into the nature of equilibrium configurations for a choice of model parameters. To complement the numerical simulations, it is useful to consider the corresponding continuum model in the limit of membrane nematogen with 100% surface coverage. It is an extension of Helfrich's bending free energy functional [42, 43] (cid:73) (cid:26) KA F = dA Tr (∇n : ∇n) + 2 + κ(cid:107) 2 (Hn,(cid:107) − H 0(cid:107) )2 + κ 2 (2H)2 (Hn,⊥ − H 0⊥)2(cid:111) κ⊥ 2 √ where KA = 3 3 2 LL. In Supplementary Material is presented such an analysis of the mechanical properties of a tubular membrane with a protein coat and analytical expressions reflecting, tube radius, persistence length and protein organization are also derived. 4 III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION In this section we will present some key aspects resulting from the coupling of membrane nematogen proteins to lipid membranes. It will both contain results from computer simulations of the aforementioned model, which are non-perturbative, along with theoretical analysis of the continuum model, of a more perturbative character to qualify the numerical finding. Throughout the discussion the parameter LL has a relatively high value (several kBT in a range where nematic ordering is favored). Furthermore, the implications of our results on the experimental systems in vivo and in vitro will be discussed. A. Aggregation and membrane domain formation of membrane nematogens A common feature of membrane nematogens is their strong tendency to self-associate, driven by the flexible geometry of the membrane - in this manuscript, we call this self associated structure to be an aggregate or a domain. Self association has been observed for a wide range of model parameters κ(cid:107), κ⊥, H 0(cid:107) and H 0⊥. All results presented in the following corresponds to system size with N = 2030 vertices. When the fraction of nematogens φA = 0.3, LL = 3 and J = 0 (in units of kBT ), the flexible membrane with curvature coupled to the nematic orientation, gives rise to co-existence of nematically ordered domains and the isotropic dilute phase, this is shown in figure-2(b). This is to be compared with the planar Lebwohl-Lasher model on a random triangular lattice, at the same concentration, where the isotropic phase is stable (see Supplementary Materials). Additional direct repulsive interactions J ≤ −0.5 between the membrane nematogens can reestablish the isotropc phase, which is shown in Fig. 2(a). The aggregation of membrane nematogens cause shape deformation of the whole membrane with the collective involvement of all the degrees of freedoms, lateral orientation, lateral position and membrane conformation. In general the lateral domain formation depends on all the involved parameters - e.g. increasing J promotes the aggregation and can change the aggregate shape as shown in Fig. (2)(c). FIG. 2: Equilibrium membrane conformations, with φA = 0.3, κ = 20, κ(cid:107) = 5 and H 0(cid:107) = 0.5 and LL = 3, for different range of J. The effect of concentration is shown in Fig.(3) for surface coverage in the range φA = 0.1 − 0.7, which display a series of complex shape deformations connected to different aggregate structures. More details will be discussed in section III G. The aggregation of membrane nematogens also has a temporal aspect. In Fig.(4) we have shown a Monte Carlo time series, for a membrane coverage of 10% nematogens, to illustrate the sequence of domain formation and membrane curvature induced changes leading to the equilibrium structure. The membrane nematogens in an initial randomly dispersed orientation assemble into smaller orientationally ordered domains mediating the final equilibrium structure. These ordered domains often appear as metastable configurations, which either disperse again due to lateral fluctuations or they will eventually funnel into a equilibrium domain configuration. The Monte Carlo dynamics does not reflect the physical kinetics very well, but is useful in identifying kinetic paths connecting various metastable states that lead to the global minima [44, 45] . The aggregation of membrane inclusions mediated by membrane curvature deformations and fluctuations is not specific for nematogens, but is a more general phenomena for membrane curvature active com- ponents. It has been well understood in the framework of models for curvature instabilities [5, 19, 46], 5 (c) Tubular(a) Spherical (b) Disc−1<J<−0.5−0.5<J<0.50.5<J<1FIG. 3: Equilibrium configurations for varying composition. κ = 10, κ(cid:107) = 5, κ⊥ = 0, H 0(cid:107) = 0.5, H 0⊥ = 0, J = 0, φA = 0.1 − 0.7 and LL = 3. FIG. 4: Aggregation of membrane inclusions for κ = 10, κ(cid:107) = 5, κ⊥ = 0, H 0(cid:107) = 0.5, H 0⊥ = 0, J = 0, φA = 0.1 and LL = 3. Monte Carlo time series showing a) random initial configuration of membrane nematogens, b) intermediate state with multiple nematic domains and c) equilibrium conformation where all the small domains coarsen into a single patch. and has also been demonstrated that simple amphiphathic inclusions, e.g. antimicrobial peptides like Magainin or Melittin [19, 47] and viral membrane active proteins like NSB4 of Hepetites C[48]. The self-association of these membrane components thus needs not to be facilitated by strong direct attractive interaction amongst them. The coupling to the membrane geometry provides additional indirect membrane conformation mediated attractive forces making them to slip into bound structures involving both the proteins and membrane curvature. However, the structure of the aggregates are dependent on the details of the molecular structure and the direct interactions. A general feature of these aggregates is that they appear as nematically ordered domains, where the nematogens form elongated oriented patches with well defined curvature characteristics, e.g. ridges or cylindrical rims. In the following we will in particular focus on the tube-like structures. 6 (a)φA=0.1(b)φA=0.2(c)φA=0.3(d)φA=0.4(e)φA=0.5(f)φA=0.6(g)φA=0.7(a)TMCS=0(b)TMCS=1.6×105(c)TMCS=17.5×105B. Tube formation The most prevalent equilibrium domain structure is the nematic tube, where the membrane protrude into a cylinder like configuration with the membrane nematogens forming a coat around the cylinder. Also for tube formation the overall interaction strength (J) between the membrane nematogens plays a secondary role. It's most pronounced effect is to widen the concentration range for tubulation and to enhance the line tension at the domain boundary, which can induce fission of tubes by narrowing the tube at the boundary of the domain, as in Fig(2(c)). The effect of concentration of membrane nematogens on the membrane tubulation phenomena is shown in Fig.(3(g)). For large concentrations of nematogens or increasing values of J the tubes are the characteristic equilibrium structures shown in Figs. (2,3). The radius of the equilibrium membrane tubes appears to be relatively well-defined. The radius of the tube with nematic order can be calculated on basis of the continuum model Eq.(5) for the chosen model parameters (see Supplementary Material):  1H0(cid:107) 1H0⊥ ¯r = (cid:113) κ(cid:107)+κ (cid:113) κ⊥+κ κ(cid:107) κ⊥ for κ⊥ = 0 for κ(cid:107) = 0 (5) So, the radius ¯r is set by the curvature elastic model parameters, involving the absolute value of the directional spontanous curvatures, modulated by the curvature elastic constants. It follows from Eq.(5) that the actual tube radius is somewhat larger than the inverse directional spontaneous curvatures and dependent on the relative strength of the elastic constants. In experimental systems the membrane tube dimensions can vary considerably with different types of proteins in the cell[1]. Membrane tubes formed in vitro by curvature active proteins also display a considerable variability in size. Frost et al. [41] have studied the effect of a number of mutants of CIP4 F-BAR on liposomes. By mutations they find a big variations of tube diameters in the range of 50 to 100 nm. Membrane tubes induced by membrane inclusions are common phenomena in biological cells, both as more static structures like T-tubules of the muscle cells[24] or more temporal structures like sorting endosomes [49]. The examples shown in Fig.(2,3) corresponds to the cases where spontaneous curvatures are positive, like that induced when F- BAR-domain proteins bind to organelle membranes. However, if the proteins induce negative spontanous curvatures, as in I-BAR domain proteins, it gives rise to tubular invaginations as shown in Fig.(5) . As can be seen from Fig.(5), for proteins with large negative spontaneous directional curvatures, at low concentration (φA = 0.1 − 0.3), we obtain tubes growing into the interior of the vesicle. As φA increases, tubes disappear and saddle like regions appear. The inner tubes and saddle like regions coexist again for large concentrations φA > 0.8. C. Protein lattices Membrane nematogens organize as nematically ordered domains and coat around the membrane to form tubes. Nematogens orient perpendicular to the tube axis when κ⊥ = 0, κ(cid:107) (cid:54)= 0 and H 0(cid:107) > 0. Similarly, κ(cid:107) = 0, κ⊥ (cid:54)= 0 and H 0⊥ (cid:54)= 0 leads to an arrangement of the nematogens along the tube direction. For the common membrane nematogen both these parameters are non-vanishing. Such a case is shown in Fig.(6). The helical arrangement of the membrane nematogens at the tube surface can be easily understood considering that in general such arrangement will give rise to a global nematic ordering of the membrane nematogens (generalized spirals are the only geodesic curves on long tubes) and the radius is set by the elastic terms. The coupled expressions for the mean values for tube radius ¯r and the angle ¯ϕ between the tube direction and the nematogen orientation, for different regimes of the dimension less parameter ψ: 7 FIG. 5: Equilibrium configurations for vesicle with negative spontanous curvatures. κ = 10, κ(cid:107) = 5, κ⊥ = 0, H 0(cid:107) = −0.5, H 0⊥ = 0.0, J = 0 and φA = 0.1 − 0.7. (cid:115) (cid:118)(cid:117)(cid:117)(cid:116)(cid:0) κ (cid:115)  ¯r = κ⊥ + κ κ(cid:107)(H 0(cid:107) )2 + κ⊥(H 0⊥)2 (cid:1)(cid:0)κ(cid:107) + κ⊥(cid:1) + κ⊥κ(cid:107) (cid:16) (cid:17)2 2 κ⊥κ(cid:107) H 0(cid:107) + H 0⊥ κ(cid:107) + κ κ(cid:107)(H 0(cid:107) )2 + κ⊥(H 0⊥)2 for ψ ≤ 0, 0 < ψ < 1 ψ ≥ 1 The parameter ψ is given by the model parameters as: (cid:115) 1 + (cid:18) 1 κ(cid:107) κ 2 (cid:19) + κ⊥ κ(cid:107) + 1 κ⊥ ψ = κ(cid:107)H 0(cid:107) − κ⊥H 0⊥ H 0(cid:107) + H 0⊥(κ(cid:107) + κ⊥) similarly for the angle ¯ϕ:  0 (cid:16) 1 (cid:17) κ(cid:107)H 0(cid:107) − κ⊥H 0⊥ κ⊥ + κ(cid:107) for ψ ≤ 0, ¯r + κ⊥ 0 < ψ < 1 ψ ≥ 1 cos2( ¯ϕ) = (6) (7) (8) So, in general both ¯ϕ and ¯r are set by the model parameters. A derivation of the above expressions are given in Supplementary Materials . 8 (a)φA=0.1(b)φA=0.2(c)φA=0.3(d)φA=0.4(e)φA=0.5(f)φA=0.6(g)φA=0.7FIG. 6: Protein lattices. Modes of a tubular membrane at different state points, for κ = 10 and LL = 3. (a) Tubular conformation with (cid:104)ϕ(cid:105) = 0 for κ(cid:107) = 5, κ⊥ = 0, H 0(cid:107) = 0.4, (b) Spiral modes of the tube with (cid:104)ϕ(cid:105) = 0 seen for κ(cid:107) = 5, κ⊥ = 0, H 0(cid:107) = 0.4, and (c) rearrangement of nematics into spiral modes ((cid:104)ϕ(cid:105) (cid:54)= 0) when κ(cid:107) = 5, κ⊥ = 5, H 0(cid:107) = 0.4, H 0⊥ = 0.25 The spiral organization of the membrane coating proteins has now been observed for many tubular membrabe systems in vivo and in vitro, e.g for the F-BAR proteins[26, 41]. EM-tomographs of tubules of CIP4 F-BAR on liposomes [41] show a fairly dense packing arrangement in the helical tube. The average tube diameter is around 68 nm and the helical angle is about ϕ = 40◦. Such arrangements are termed protein lattices in the cell biology literature. It is found that the helical angle ϕ of the protein lattice with respect to the tube direction adjusts to the tube diameter such that the directional curvature is about the same. For a similar type of experiment with dynamin[50] the membrane tubes of radius r (cid:39) 23nm with densely packed helical dynamin coat was observed with a helical pitch of about 15nm (corresponding to a helical angle ϕ = 80◦). Our simulation results suggests that the spiral organization of the protein coat on the tube need not be a result of polymerization as often referred in the literature, but can be a self-assembly process of the curvature active proteins mediated by the membrane. Furthermore, the modelling suggest that these protein lattices are not conventional two dimensional lattice structures like polymerized membranes or graphene, but rather two dimensional nematic liquid crystalline structures. In the model there is no terms which can distinguish between a right or left turning helix, i.e. the helical arrangement is the result of a spontaneous symmetry breaking. However, the smallest chiral symmetry breaking contribution to the free energy can favor one of the helical orientations without having an effect on any other parameters. D. Thermal stability of membrane tubes While our model parameter determine the mean physical properties of the tubes , e.g. the radius, we expect the tubular membranes to display an elastic response to deformations in its shape and organization of the membrane nematogens. This can, for e.g., be reflected in the variation of the shape characteristics due to thermal fluctuations. For analysis of such deformations the continuum description of coated 9 (a)(b)(c)membrane tubes are suitable and the details can be found in Supplementary Material. It is shown that in general the deviations in the orientation of the membrane nematogen and the tube radius are strongly correlated. The thermally induced fluctuations in the radius is found to be (cid:104)(δr)2(cid:105) ¯r2 = kBT 4π κ(cid:107) + κ⊥ κ(cid:107)κ⊥ + (κ(cid:107) + κ⊥) κ 2 for 0 < ¯ψ < 1, (9) where ¯r and ¯ϕ are respectively the equilibrium tube radius and nematic orientations and ¯ψ = cos2 ¯ϕ. We note that the relative variance in r has an upper limit kB T 2πκ . With a typical range κ ∼ 20 − 50kBT this ratio in Eq.(9) is of the order 0.01. For CIP4 F-BAR, reconstituted on liposomes, cryo-tomography measurements give ¯r = 33nm and (cid:104)(δr)2(cid:105)/¯r2 (cid:39) 0.01 [41]. If this observed variation in tube thickness is interpreted as frozen in thermal variations, it is in agreement with the the above theory. For rigid membranes with large κ and/or large κ(cid:107), κ⊥ values we can consider the thermaly excited variations in r as small. Similarly, we can estimate the thermal fluctuations around cos2( ¯ϕ) for such a segment as, (cid:104)(δ cos2(ϕ))2(cid:105) = kBT 4π κ(cid:107)ψ2 + κ(cid:107)(1 − ψ)2 + κ κ(cid:107)κ⊥ + (κ(cid:107) + κ⊥) κ 2 2 for 0 < ¯ψ < 1. (10) To our knowledge no experimental reports on the random variations in the helical angle has been given. A third type of deformation to consider is the bending of the tubes. It is shown in Supplementary Materials that when r is a constant along the tube, the free energy expression is relatively simple. In particular we find that the free energy of bending for a tubular membrane takes the approximate form, dsλ(s)2, (11) (cid:90) L 0 ∆Ftot ≈ 1 2 kBT lP π¯r(cid:0)KA + κ + κ(cid:107)(1 − ¯ψ)2 + κ⊥ ¯ψ2(cid:1) kBT where s is the the arc length and λ(s) is the line curvature along the tube, while lP is the persistence length of the tube: lP = . (12) There are few experimental measurements of the persistence length of membrane tubes with protein lattices. For the F-BAR FBP17 producing tubes of radius r(F BP 17) = 34nm the persistence length was measured to lP (F BP 17) = 142µm [41] while for amphiphysin r(amph) ∼ 7nm[51] and lP (amph) = 9µm while for dynamin r(dynamin) (cid:39) 20nm and lP (dynamin) = 37µm. A calculations of lP from Eq.(12) solely based on κ gives predictions which are an order of magnitude too small, which indicates that other elastic constants κ(cid:107), κ⊥ and KA gives the main contributions to lP . E. Capping the tubes, Defects The formation of membrane tubes with helical coats seems to be generic for systems with membranes with membrane nematogens. Either the helical coat has to terminate resulting in an interfacial curve separating the coated and uncoated regions or the vesicle should sprout tubes and buds with the tips having a pair of point defects. The way this takes place in the tube end or at a domain boundary is mainly determined by the competition between interfacial tension, which in our model is largely regulated by the parameter J, and bending modulus. In Fig(7) is shown that when the interaction parameter J is increased the interfacial line shrinks, first transforming the vesicle from a disk to a structure with partially coated tubes and buds, but still no defects. Further increase in the line tension will result in tubes and buds that are fully coated but minimizing the length of the interfacial line between coated and uncoated regions. It does so by either moving the interfaces to the end of the tube forming a pair of point defects or deforming the membrane to form a narrow neck. Note that the line does not shrink to a single point defect of strength +1 but instead forms a pair of +1/2 defects bound to each other. This is the result of of the π symmetry of the membrane nematogen and the strong coupling between membrane curvature and nematic orientation [52 -- 54]. To our knowledge no details about the capping of the coated membrane tubes have been provided by experiments. 10 FIG. 7: A partly decorated membrane with κ = 20, κ(cid:107) = 5, LL = 3. Shown are: (a) a disc without a defect for φA = 0.4, H 0(cid:107) = 0.5 and J = 0. (b) Tubes without defects at J = 3. ( the bottom panel shows an enlarged side view of the tip of a tube without defects ). (c) Tubes and buds with defects when J = 5. ( the bottom panel shows an enlarged top view of the tip of a bud with defects ) F. Curvature differences leads to segregation (a) Tubular membrane of uniform cross section with fields A and B in the mixed phase for H 0(cid:107),A, H 0(cid:107),B = FIG. 8: 0.5, 0.5. (b) Activation of field B takes H 0(cid:107),B from 0.5 to 1.25. The difference in the spontaneous curvatures leads to phase segregation and results in the constriction of tubes. Field concentrations are respectively φA = 0.4 and φB = 0.6 while κ = 10kBT , κA(cid:107) = κB(cid:107) = 5kBT and AA = BB = 3kBT . Another example of the curvature driven aggregation is demonstrated in Fig. 8. Shown in Fig. 8(a) is a tubular membrane of uniform cross section, fully decorated by two different types of membrane nematogens, labelled A and B. The tube is stable, in the mixed state, when the directional spontaneous curvature of the in-plane fields, H 0(cid:107),A = H 0(cid:107),B = 0.5, are the same. If a source of activation increases the spontaneous directional curvature of B to H0(cid:107),B = 1.25, analogous to activation of dynamin proteins by hydrolysis of GTP, the fields demix. The regions containing field B constrict the tube further. The equilibrium shape of the activated membrane is observed to have successive tubular regions of large and small curvatures ( see Fig. 8(b)), similar to the striated patterns of dynamin tubes obtained on treatment with GTPγs [55, 56]. For dynamin the molecular conformation and membrane tube diameter is GTP dependent [56, 57]. Furthermore it is observed that the tube constriction involves a tube twisting, suggesting a change in the helical angle ϕ [58]. In in vivo experiments, it has been demonstrated that structurally similar F-BAR proteins can co-localize into the same membrane tubes [14] while differing BAR proteins, like F-BAR and N-BAR, seggregate into separate membrane tubes with their respective characteristic r and ϕ [41, 59]. Our analysis suggests that this recruitement of differing BAR-proteins into separate domains is possibly driven by their directional spontaneous curvatures. 11 top viewDefectless tipside viewpair of +1/2 defects(a) J=0(b) J=3(c) J=5planetangentvN(v)c1vc2vt2vt1vvn(v)ϕvt2vt1v(a)(b)(c) Mixed phasedemixing and constrictionActivation of field B(a)(b)G. Sheets versus tubes The effect of concentration, shown in Fig.(3), for surface coverages in the range 10% and 70% display a series of complex shape deformations connected to different aggregate structures. The regime, where inclusions stay separate, for the model parameters chosen here, appear at very low concentrations. The figure illustrates that for a system where the direct interactions parameter J between the membrane nematogens are weak the oligomers tend form larger rim-like formations, which stabilizes disc like struc- tures of vesicles. The rims form the edges of the discs. As the concentration is increased part of the edge turn tubular. So for a range of concentrations the disc and the tubes coexist. The tubules get more pronounced and the discs diminishes with the increase in concentration of membrane nematogens. Recent experiments on the formation of tubular (or smooth) ER suggest that some membrane curvature active proteins, reticulon protein and DP1[15], are highly enriched in the tubular ER [60] and the ER sheet edges[16]. Our results are thus in line with the idea that the concentration of these membrane nematogens are a major determinant for the amount of ER in sheets or tubules[16]. IV. CONCLUSION We have described the membrane curvature modifying properties of anisotropic protein inclusions, like the BAR proteins, in terms of an in-plane nematic field. We have shown that the flexibility of the membrane can promote aggregation and lateral domain formation of these membrane nematogens, even in the absence of self interactions. These domains can facilitate shape changes of the membrane. The equilibrium shapes obtained are strikingly similar to that seen in experiments involving curvature modifying proteins. Prominent structures seen are tubes and discs and coexistence of them. Depending on the preferred curvature of the nematogens, a protein lattice with helical nematic orientation around the tube is seen. The properties of this liquid crystalline structure was further analyzed from a continuum version of the model and the dependence of the tube radius and the orientation of the nematic with respect to the tube axis was calculated. We also estimate the thermally induced fluctuation in these quantities and show that they are comparable to what is seen in experiments. In addition we calculate the persistence length of the nematogen induced tubes and show that it is in the range of experimentally obtained values. This analysis provides the necessary basis to obtain estimates of model parameters from experiments on coated membrane tubes. At present the available experimental data are very limited. The present modeling provides additional support to the growing notion of the importance of local curvature modulating proteins in membrane shape generation in biological cells. Compared to previous modeling of the role of membrane proteins inducing directional membrane curvature we have taken into account that membranes are not fully decorated, the in-plane interactions between nematogens and the arbitrary membrane shapes with spherical topology. The current work focusses only on the membrane interacting part of the protein. Electric charges in BAR-protein are mostly localized to its membrane facing domain which in turn interact with anionic lipids and enables them to bind strongly to the membrane. One natural extension of this model is include the electrostatic interactions through cytosol between proteins moieties protruding out of the membrane. We emphasize that the main aim of this work is to show that anisotropic curvature induced by the inclusions can lead to aggregation and interesting shape changes. This is in contrast to the prevailing assumption that explicit protein interactions are essential for aggregation and formation of protein lattices. Though a quantitative comparison between the predictions of this model and experiments is not so easy, the model does demonstrate the possibility of generating many biologically relevant shapes of the vesicle by membrane mediated interactions alone. 12 V. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The computational work is carried out at HPC facility at IIT-Madras. [1] Frost A., V.M. Unger, and P. De Camilli, 2009, The BAR Domain Superfamily: Membrane-Molding Macro- molecules. Cell 137, 191-196. [2] Opali´nski (cid:32)L., Kiel J. A.K.W., C. Williams, M. Veenhuis, and I.J. van der Klei, 2011, Membrane curvature during peroxisome fission requires Pex11. The EMBO Jour. 30, 5. [3] Antonny B, 2006, Membrane deformations by protein coats. Curr. Opinion in Cell Biol. 18, 386. [4] Sackmann E., R. Kotulla, and F-J. Heiszler, 1984, On the role of lipid-bilayer elasticity for the lipid-protein interaction and the indirect protein-protein coupling. Canadian Jour. of Biochem. and Cell Biol. 62, 778 [5] Leibler S., 1986, Curvature instability in membranes. J. Phys. France 47, 507-516. [6] Ramakrishnan N, P.B. Sunil Kumar, J.H. Ipsen, 2010, Monte Carlo simulations of fluid vesicles with in-plane orientational ordering. Phys. Rev. E 81, 041922. [7] Peter B.J., H.M. Kent, I.G. Mills,Y. Vallis, P.J.G. Butler, P.R. Evans and H.T. McMahon, 2004, BAR Domains as Sensors of Membrane Curvature: The Amphiphysin BAR Structure. Science 303, 495-499. [8] Weissenhorn W., 2005, Crystal structure of the Endophilin-A1 BAR Domain. J. Mol. Biol. 351, 653-661. [9] McMohan H.T. and J. L. Gallop, 2005, Membrane curvature and mechanisms of dynamic cell membrane remodelling. Nature 438, 590-596. [10] Blood P.D. and G.A. Voth, 2006, Direct observation of Bin/amphiphysin/Rvs (BAR) domain-induced mem- brane curvature by means of molecular dynamics simulations Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 103, 15068-15072 [11] Arkhipov A., Y. Ying, and K. Schulten, 2008, Four-scale description of membrane sculpting by BAR domains. Biophys. J. 95, 2806-2821, [12] Shnyrova A.V., V. A. Frolov and J. Zimmerberg, 2009, Domain-Driven Morphogenesis of Cellular Membranes. Current Biology 19, R772-R780. [13] Williams T.M. and M.P. Lisanti, 2004, The caveolin proteins. Genome Biology 5,214,1-8. [14] Shimada A, H. Niwa, K. Tsujita, S. Suetsugu, K. Nitta, K. Hanawa-Suetsugu, R. Akasaka, Y. Nishino, M. Toyama, L. Chen, Z.J. Liu, B.C. Wang , M. Yamamoto, T. Terada, A. Miyazawa, A. Tanaka, S. Sugano, M. Shirouzu, K. Nagayama, T. Takenawa, S. Yokoyama, 2007, Curved EFC/F-BAR-domain dimers are joined end to end into a filament for membrane invagination in endocytosis. Cell 129, 761-72. [15] Voeltz G.K., W.A. Prinz, Y. Shibata, J.M. Rist and T.A. Rapoport, 2006, A class of membrane proteins shaping the tubular endoplasmatic reticulum, Cell 124, 573-586. [16] Shibata Y., T. Shemesh, W.A. Prinz, A.F. Palazzo, M.M. Kozlov and T.A. Rapoport, 2010, Mechanisms Determining the Morphology of the Peripheral ER. Cell 143, 774-788. [17] Farsaq K., N. Ringstad, K. Takei, S.R. Floyd, K. Rose, and P. De Camilli, 2001, Generation of high-curvature membranes mediated by by direct endophilin bilayer interactions. J. Cell Biol. 155, 193-200. [18] Gallop J. L., C.C. Jao, H.M. Kent, J.G. Butler, P.R. Evans, R. Langen and H.T. McMahon, 2006, Mechanism of endophilin N-BAR domain mediated membrane curvature. The EMBO Journal 25, 2898-2910. [19] Bouvrais H., K. J. Jensen, J. Brask, P. M´el´eard, T. Pott and J.H. Ipsen, 2008, Softening of POPC membranes by Magainin. Biophysical Chemistry 137 7-12. [20] Campelo F., McMahon H.T and M.M. Kozlov, 2008, The hydrophobic insertion mechanism of membrane curvature generation by proteins Biophys. J. 95, 2325-2339 [21] Kurten R.C., A.D. Eddington , P. Chowdhury, R.D. Smith, A.D. Davidson and B.B. Shank, 2001, Self- assembly and binding of a sorting nexin to sorting endosomes. J. Cell Science 114, 1743-1756. [22] Mayor S., J.F. Presley and F.R. Maxfield, 1993, Sorting of Membrane Components from Endosomes and Subsequent Recycling to the Cell Surface Occurs by a Bulk Flow Process. J. Cell. Biol. 121,1257-1269. [23] Shepard, K.A. and M.P. Yaffe, 1999, The Yeast Dynamin-like Protein, Mgm1p, Functions on the Mitochon- drial Outer Membrane to Mediate Mitochondrial Inheritance. J. Cell. Biol. 144, 711-720. [24] Razzaq A., I.M. Robinson, H.T. McMahon, J.N. Skepper, Y. Su1, A.C. Zelhof, A.P. Jackson, N.J. Gay and C.J. O'Kane, 2001, Amphiphysin is necessary for organization of the excitation contraction coupling machinery of muscles, but not for synaptic vesicle endocytosis in Drosophila. Genes & Dev. 15, 2967-2979 [25] Sweitzer S.M. and J.E. Hinshaw, 1998, Dynamins Undergoes a GTP-Dependent Conformational Change Causing Vesiculation. Cell 98, 1021-1029. [26] Low H.H., C. Sachse, A.A. Amos, and J. Lowe, 2009, Structure of a Bacterial Dynamin-like Protein Lipid Tube Provides a Mechanism For Assembly and Membrane Curving. Cell 139, 1342-1352. [27] Lebbink M.N., N. Jim´enez, K. Vocking, L.H. Hekking, A.J. Verkleij and J.A. Post. 2010. Spiral Coating of the Endothelial Caveolar Membranes as Revealed by Electron Tomography and Template Matching. Traffic 11, 138-150. [28] Sens P. and M. S. Turnery, 2004, Theoretical Model for the Formation of Caveolae and Similar Membrane 13 Invaginations. Biophys. J. 86, 2049-2057. [29] Fournier J. -B., 1996, Nontopological saddle-splay and curvature instabilities from anisotropic membrane inclusions. Phys. Rev. Lett., 76(23), 4436. [30] Fournier J. -B. and P. Galatola, 1998, Bilayer Membranes with 2D-Nematic Order of the Surfactant Polar Heads. Braz. Jour. of Phys., 28, 329. [31] Kraij-Iglic V., V. Heinrich, S. Svetina, S. and B. Zeks, 1999, Free energy of closed membrane with anisotropic inclusions. Eur. Phys. J. B 10, 5-8. [32] Dommersnes P. G. and J.-B. Fournier, 1999, N-body study of anisotropic membrane inclusions: Membrane mediated interactions and ordered aggregation Eur. Phys. J. B 12, 9-12. [33] Iglic A., T. Slivnik, and V. Kralj-Iglic, 2007, Elastic properties of biological membranes influenced by attached proteins. J. Biomech. 40, 2492-2500. [34] Helfrich W., 1973, Elastic properties of lipid bilayers: theory and possible experiments. Naturforsch Z. 28, 693-703. [35] Onsager L., 1949, The effects of shape on the interaction of colloidal particles. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 51, 627-659. [36] Park J.-M and T. C Lubensky, 1996, Interactions between membrane Inclusions on Fluctuating Membranes. Journal de Physique I 6, 1217. [37] Kim K. S., J. Neu, and G. Oster, 1998, Curvature-mediated interactions between membrane proteins. Biophys. J. 75, 2274. [38] Chou T., K. S. Kim and G. Oster, 2001, Statistical thermodynamics of membrane bending-mediated protein- protein attractions. Biophys. J. 80, 1075. [39] Lewandowski, E. P., J. A. Bernate, P. C. Searson, P C and K. J. Stebe, 2008, Rotation and Alignment of Anisotropic Particles on Nonplanar Interfaces, Langmuir, 24, 9302. [40] Lewandowski, E. P., J. A. Bernate, A. Tseng, P. C. Searson, P C and K. J. Stebe, 2009, Oriented assembly of anisotropic particles by capillary interactions, Soft Matter, 5, 886. [41] Frost A., R. Perera, A. Roux, K. Spasov, O. Destaing, E.H. Engelmann, P. De Camilli, and A, Unger, 2008, Structural Basis of Membrane Invaginations by F-BAR Domains. Cell 132, 807-817. [42] Peliti L. and J. Prost, 1989, J.Phys. France 50, 1557-1571. [43] Frank J. R. and M. Kardar, 2008, Defects in nematic membranes can buckle into pseudospheres, Phys. Rev. E 77, 041705. [44] Kumar P. B. S. and Madan Rao, 1998, Shape Instabilities in the Dynamics of a Two-Component Fluid Membrane, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 2489. [45] Kumar P. B. S., Gerhard Gompper and Reinhard Lipowsky, 2001, Budding Dynamics of Multicomponent Membranes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 3911. [46] Henriksen J.R., T.L. Andresen, L. Feldborg, L. Duelund, and J.H. Ipsen, 2010, Understanding Detergent Effects on Lipid Membranes: A Model Study. Biophy. J. 98, 2199-2205. [47] Gerbeaud C, 1998, Effect de l'insertion de prot´eines et de peptides membranaires sur les propri´et´es m´ecaniques et les changements morphologiques de v´esicules g´eantes. Ph.d. thesis L'Universte Bordeaux I. [48] Gouttenoire J., P. Roingeard, F. Penin, and D. Moradpour1, 2010, Amphipathic α-Helix AH2 Is a Major Determinant for the Oligomerization of Hepatitis C Virus Nonstructural Protein 4B. Journal of Virology 84, 12529-12537. [49] Bonifacino J.S. and J.H. Hurley, 2008, Retromer, Curr. Opinion in Cell Biol. 20, 427-436 [50] Sweitzer S.M. and J.E. Hinshaw, 1998, Dynamin undergoes a GTP-dependent conformational change causing vesiculation. Cell 93, 1021. [51] Sorre B, A. Callan-Jones, J. Manzi, B. Goud, J. Prost, P. Bassereau, A. Roux, 2012, Nature of curvature coupling of amphiphysin with membranes depends on its bound density. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sciences 109, 173-8. [52] Lubensky T.C. and J. Prost, 1992, Orientational order and vesicle shape. J. Phys. France II 2, 371-382. [53] Vitelli V. and D.R. Nelson, 2004, Defect generation and deconfinement on corrugated topographies. Phys. Rev. E 70, 051105. [54] Ramakrishnan N., J. H. Ipsen, P. B. Sunil Kumar, 2012, Role of disclinations in determining the morphology of deformable fluid interfaces. Soft Matter 8, 3058-3061. [55] Roux, A., G. Koster, M. Lenz, B. Sorre, J.-B. Manneville, P. Nassoy and P. Bassereau, 2010, Membrane curvature controls dynamin polymerization. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sciences 107, 4141-4146. [56] Daninoa D., K-H. Moonb and J.E. Hinshaw, 2004, Rapid constriction of lipid bilayers by the mechanochem- icalenzyme dynamin. Journal of Structural Biol. 147, 259-267. [57] Zhang P. and J.E. Hinshaw, 2001, Three-dimensional reconstruction of dynamin in the constricted state. Nature Cell Biology 3, 922-926. [58] Roux A., K. Uyhazi, A. Frost, and P. De Camilli, 2006, GTP-dependent twisting of dynamin implicates constriction and tension in membrane fission. Nature 44, 528-531. [59] Itoh T. and P. De Camilli, 2006, BAR, F-BAR(EFC), and ENTH/ANTH domains in the regulation of membrane cytosol interfaces and membrane curvature. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1761, 897-912 14 [60] Shibata Y., C. Voss, J.M. Rist, J. Hu, T.A. Rapoport, W.A. Prinz and G.K. Voeltz, 2008, The reticulon and DP1/Yop1p proteins form immobile oligomers in the tubular endoplasmic reticulum. J. Biol. Chem. 283, 18892-904. 15
1007.2432	1	1007	2010-07-14T20:50:44	Chiral Interactions of Histidine in a Hydrated Vermiculite	[ "physics.bio-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "q-bio.BM" ]	Recent work suggests a link between chiral asymmetry in the amino acid iso-valine extracted from the Murchison meteorite and the extent of hydrous alteration. We present the results of neutron scattering experiments on an exchanged, 1-dimensionally ordered n-propyl ammonium vermiculite clay. The vermiculite gel has a (001) d-spacing of order 5nm at the temperature and concentration of the experiments and the d-spacing responds sensitively to changes in concentration, temperature and electronic environment. The data show that isothermal addition of D-histidine or L-histidine solutions produces shifts in the d-spacing that are different for each enantiomer. This chiral specificity is of interest for the question of whether clays could have played an important role in the origin of biohomochirality.	physics.bio-ph	physics	Chiral Interactions of Histidine in a Hydrated Vermiculite Clay Donald G. Fraser,1* H. Christopher Greenwell,2 Neal T. Skipper,3 Martin V. Smalley,4 Michael A. W ilkinson,3,5 Bruno Demé,5 R. K. Heenan.6 1Department of Earth Sciences, University of Oxford, Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3PR, UK 2Department of Chemistry, Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK 3Department of Physics & Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK 4Department of Physics, University of York, Heslington, York YO10 5DD, UK 5Institut Laue Langevin, F-38042 Grenoble, Cedex 9, France 6ISIS Facility, R3 1-22, Rutherford Appleton Lab, HSIC, Didcot, OX11 0QX, UK Email: [email protected] Graphical Contents Entry We report chiral differences in the effects of D- and L-histidine on the interlayer spacing of vermiculite clays that are relevant in assessing the role of clays in the origin of bio-homochirality. 1 Abstract Recent work suggests a link between chiral asymmetry in the amino acid iso -valine extracted from the Murchison meteorite and the extent of hydrous alteration. We present the results of neutron scattering experiments on an exchanged, 1 - dimensionally ordered n-propyl ammonium vermiculite clay. The vermiculite gel has a (001) d-spacing of order 5nm at the temperature and concentration of the experiments and the d-spacing responds sensitively to changes in concentration, temperature and electronic environment. The data show that isothermal addition of D- histidine or L-histidine solutions produces shifts in the d-spacing that are different for each enantiomer. This chiral specificity is of interest for the question of whether clays could have played an important role in the origin of biohomochirality. Introduction Understanding the interaction of biomolecules such as amino acids and simple sugars with hydrated mineral surfaces is key to unraveling the origins of life on Earth1. The chirality of some crystalline mineral phases, such as quartz and calcite, has long been proposed as a possible mechanism for selectively determining the production of particular prebiotic enantiomers2. However, neither calcite nor quartz has been shown to have any heterogeneous catalytic function in aiding biomolecule polymerization. Fundamental questions arise as to how the first organic molecules arrived on Earth and were built up into complex molecules through prebiotic chemistry, whilst being protected from the harsh environment present at the time. Though the view that life arose through an “RNA World” is widely supported3-4, there is also an alternative hypothesis that proteins originated first on the early Earth5. Lambert has recently reviewed the organization and polymerization of amino acids at mineral surfaces6. Clay minerals have been shown to be efficient at concentrating amino acids from solution7-9, especially those with charged side groups, such as lysine or histidine. Clays have also been shown to catalyse peptide bond formation in their own right10-12, and when used in conjunction with salt induced peptide formation (SIPF) chemistries13-15. Clay minerals in carbonaceous meteorites have also been shown to be of potential importance for protecting organic molecules from oxidizing conditions16. At least 70 chiral amino acids have been identified in meteorites. These were believed to show almost no chiral selectivity, being close to 50:50 racemic mixtures17, but recently an important chiral asymmetry in iso-valine extracted from the Murchison meteorite has been reported18. Laboratory gas condensation experiments also generate amino acids, though, again, these show almost no chiral selectivity19. In contrast, amino acids in proteins and enzymes in organisms are usually 100% L-enantio-specific. Prebiotic chemistry must address the question of homochirality and the emergence of only L-amino acids in virtually all living organisms. Goldberg showed, once seeded with one enantiomer, clay surfaces enhance selectivity for that enantiomer 2 during crystallization cycles20. Recent experiments have pointed towards chirally selective adsorption and reactivity in clay mineral suspensions21-22. Anionic clays have also been shown to have kinetic chiral selectivity for histidine23. The anionic clays have much higher charge density and packing than for the cationic systems. Yu et al. used density functional theory computer simulations to examine the energy of L- and D-alanine on the surface of nontronite clay, finding a preference by some 25 kJ/mol for the L- form23. Adsorption of amino acids at clay mineral surfaces is also of interest in a range of natural phenomena24-26. Industrially, amino acid chiral selectivity and racemization stabilization effects have been observed in anionic clays (layered double hydroxides)27. In many adsorption studies, structural analysis of the clay-amino acid system is often conducted post reaction, whereas there are no high-resolution in situ structural studies of fully hydrated systems. In the work presented here, we studied the addition of D- and L-histidine to n-propylammonium vermiculite gels (with layer spacing ~50 Å). The alkylammonium vermiculite gels have been established as a model system for studying clay swelling and colloid stability28. The swelling is nearly perfectly one- dimensional, taking place perpendicular to the plane of the silicate layers, and leads to the formation of gels with d-values between 40 and 90 Å along the swelling axis. Even for the largest expansions, this d-value remains sufficiently well defined to be measured by small-angle neutron diffraction (SANS). Experimental composition Crystals dry of vermiculite Eucatex natural of Si6.13Mg5.44Al1.65Fe0.50Ti0.13Ca0.13Cr0.01K0.01O20(OH)4Na1.29 were exchanged in CH3CH2CH2NH2·HCl (Sigma-Aldrich 242543, >99%) solution over a period of several years. Around two weeks before the experiments crystals of approximate dimensions 10 × 10 × 2 mm were placed in stock solution of propylammonium chloride in D2O at the required concentration, and were equilibrated for the neutron scattering experiments with regular exchange of supernatant solution. Matched solutions containing D-histidine (Puriss® 53321, ≥99%) or L-histidine (ReagentPlus® H8000, ≥99% both analysed and certificated by TLC) were made by addition of reagent to D2O or identical stock solution of propylammonium chloride. Individual equilibrated gel crystals were selected from solution and placed in sample containers. The samples were then bathed in solution as detailed below. The swollen gels are extremely soft and delicate, and all handling was conducted under solution. Previous studies of these gels have established the relationship between d-spacing and concentration in propylammonium chloride solution28. In the region of most interest, around 0.35M, the equilibrium d-spacing increases by around 1 Å for a 0.01M decrease in concentration. The changes we report here are therefore significant when compared with the reliability of the solution concentrations. Preliminary experiments were conducted on the LOQ instrument at the ISIS Pulsed Neutron source, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory. We equilibrated stocks of gels in 0.1M, 0.2M and 0.35M propylammonium chloride in D2O. At these concentrations the d-spacings are approximately 110, 75 and 50 Å respectively. As far as possible gels were selected from the stock as matched pairs, and when both showed a clear 3 (001) Bragg peak we then exposed one to L- and one to D-histidine. In this way we studied 6 pairs in total; 1 at 0.1M, 2 at 0.2M and 3 at 0.36M. Samples were placed flat on the bottom of sealed 10 × 10 mm Hellma QS cells and were bathed in 3cm3 of the supernatant solution of the required concentration. The sample height and alignment was adjusted individually by laser beam, and the small angle neutron scattering was measured in the Q range 0.006 - 0.24 Å-1. After this initial characterisation the samples were exposed to amino acid by the addition of 0.5cm3 of 0.18M L- or D-histidine in D2O. After approximately 1 hour the neutron scattering was measured again. Temperature was maintained at 30 ±1C throughout by a water bath in thermal contact with the sample block. Cycles through a temperature range were conducted to confirm the crystal-gel transition. Scattering intensity was corrected for background from the empty container and normalised to an absolute scale by reference to a water standard and a beam transmission measurement. Due to the sample orientation the Bragg scattering from the (00l) reflections was recorded in the top and bottom quadrants of the area detector. The data were binned in Q with a constant bin-width of 0.001 Å-1. The scattered intensities were fitted with the program Fish [Heenan, R. K. Fish data analysis program, RAL-Report-89-129, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory (UK) 1989] using Lorentzian Bragg profiles with a form factor derived for a distribution of oriented sheets29-30. Example fits are shown in Figure 1. In all cases the d-spacing was increased at constant concentration by exposure to histidine. If we express this expansion in terms of the fractional change then the average shift is 1.117 ±0.020 for L-histidine and 1.102 ±0.020 for D-histidine. The average expansion was therefore 1.5% greater for L-histidine than D-histidine, but tantalisingly, this is on the limit of the statistical precision of the experiments. Figure 1: Example of neutron scattering intensity I (arbitrary units) obtained from the instrument LOQ for the sample exposed to 0.1M propyl ammonium chloride before exposure to L-histidine. Data (+) and fit (line). Inset shows intensity I on a log10 scale. 4 Following these initial studies on the LOQ instrument at ISIS we exploited the increased Q-range of station D16 at the Institut Laue-Langevin, Grenoble, to measure 1st and higher order (00l) peaks in both the crystalline and gel phases of propylammonium ion substituted vermiculite clay. The instrument was operated at a constant wavelength of 4.728 Å with a pixelated detector giving a Q-range of 0.04 – 0.5 Å-1 with a bin-width of 0.0025 Å-1. The detector efficiency was normalized by reference to a water standard. Samples of gel phase propylammonium vermiculite were prepared via the method of Williams et al.31-32, by soaking crystals in a deuterated solution of 0.34M propylammonium chloride. We first measured the structure of the gels in the absence of amino acid as a control. Clay gels were equilibrated in 0.3387M propylammonium chloride in D2O and a high-quality sample was cleaved into two halves (Figure 2). Each half was then placed in a QS cell with 4 × 10 mm sample space under supernatant solution and was aligned using a laser beam and then via a rocking curve centred on the (001) Bragg reflection. Temperature was maintained at 25.5 ±0.5C via a thermal bath connected to a neutron-transparent thermal jacket. Figure 2. Vermiculite clay gel in solution for measurement on D16. After measurement on the samples under pure 0.3387M propylammonium chloride in D2O, the solution was replaced with 0.3387m propylammonium chloride containing either 0.05M L- or D-histidine in D2O. After 5 full exchanges of solution over the samples, conducted over a period of around 6 hours during which the neutron scattering profile was monitored, steady state equilibrium was achieved. The final profile was then measured. The normalized intensities were fitted as before using the program Fish using Lorentzian Bragg profiles with a form factor derived for a distribution of oriented sheets. A typical fit is shown in Figure 3. 5 Figure 3: Example of neutron scattering intensity I (arbitrary units) obtained from the instrument D16 for the sample exposed to 0.3387M propyl ammonium chloride and 0.05M L-histidine. Data (+) and fit (line). Inset shows intensity I on a log10 scale. Discussion It is known that the phase transition between these two phases occurs at around 310K28. Our hypothesis was that the thermodynamics of the phase diagram and the interlayer d-spacings of the clay, would be sensitive to the adsorption of histidine enantiomers onto the clay surface, and that we should therefore be able detect their uptake/location and any preferential chiral interaction. Figure 4 shows data obtained for the two nearly identical halves of untreated gel measured first in pure 0.34M propylammonium solution. These can be compared in the same Figure with the data for the same vermiculite samples measured after 5 exchanges in L- and D-histidine respectively. The peak in all cases arises from the (001) Bragg reflection – and therefore directly gives the d-spacing of the sample. Increase in ordinary solute concentration would cayuse the d-spacing to contract. The data in Figure 4 show clearly that the amino acids act “anti-osmotically” so that addition of amino acid, and hence increase in the overall solute concentration, causes the d-spacing to widen relative to that of the pure control clay system. This suggests that histidine adsorbs to the clay surface, screening the Coulombic charge. In addition, there is evidence of a chiral shift: L-histidine increases the d-spacing relative to D-histidine. The value for the control was 48.78Å; D-histidine shifted from 49.06 to 50.33Å; L-histidine shifted from 48.76 to 51.11Å. The ~1.5% difference between L- and D- is significant in terms of the accuracy of the instrument, and is also consistent with our previous experiments on LOQ. To provide further information on the nature of the amino acid adsorption, a separate experiment was conducted in which a previously L-histidine-equilibrated sample was exposed to D-histidine. In this case there was no significant reverse shift in the d- spacing on going from L- to D- over the timescale of the experiment (~ 6 hours). This lack of short term reversibility lends support to the notion that the amino acids are bound directly and strongly to the clay surface. 6 Figure 4. Shift in d-spacing of histidine intercalated propyl-ammonium vermiculite clay gels and control systems. L-histidine and control: filled and empty circles. D- histidine and control: filled and empty triangles. The behaviour of the histidine molecules in the inter-layer region of the hydrated amino acid clay system was modeled by Monte-Carlo and molecular dynamics simulations and a schematic of the interlayer region of the hydrated clay is shown in Fig.5. The Monte Carlo algorithm Monte was used to generate the initial coordinates for a hydrated propylammonium vermiculite with phenol in the interlayer. Forcefield parameters were the OPLS. The equilibrated system was taken and the phenol molecules converted to histidine. 40 ps of molecular dynamic simulation was then run using the Dreiding forcefield, with the charges previously assigned, with the Forcite code in the Accelrys Inc Materials Studio. It is apparent that a large proportion of the histidine molecules are indeed adsorbed at the mineral surfaces as suggested above. Figure 5. Schematic based on molecular simulations showing interlayer arrangement of histidine (green coloured) molecules in a propylammonium (blue molecules) vermiculite clay (color: Si = orange; Al = magenta; Mg = green; O = red; H = white). 7 To try to determine whether the effects described above were due to preferential uptake of one isomer over the other, chiral high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) was undertaken. Experiments were carried out in 8 ml screwtop glass vials. A 250ml stock solution of 0.40mg/ml DL histidine and 0.338M PrNH3Cl was prepared. Raw Eucatex vermiculite, which had been stored under distilled water, was dried at 80 C for 24 hours. Sodium vermiculite was exchanged twice over 24 hours with 0.388M propylamine solution, and dried at 140 C for 1 hour. Different weights of clay were then added to a constant amount of histidine solution, so that the change in histidine concentration could be found. The raw vermiculite samples were left to equilibrate over 24 hours, whilst the propylamine vermiculite equilibrated over 1.5 hours. Analysis method A Perkin-Elmer Peltier plate HPLC with autosampler, in the Analytical Laboratory, Department of Chemistry, Durham University, was used for all analyses. A Crownpak CR(+) chiral HPLC column (D form eluted first) was used throughout. Stock 20% perchloric acid diluted to give pH 1 was used as an eluent, with the histidine underivatised. A temperature of 10 C and a flow rate of 0.1 ml.min-1 was found to give good separation and could be reliably maintained. An UV detector,  200 nm, was used. The retention times were 4.73 min and 6.27 min for the D- and L-histidine, respectively. A set of standards was made up at the experimental concentration of 0.388M and with the change in enantiomeric excess (ee) set at 5.00%, 1.00%, 0.50% and 0.05%. For a mixture of isomers the relative area under each peak, expressed as a percentage of the total of the two isomer peaks, indicates the enantiomeric excess. At 5% and 1% ee the steps were reasonably well resolved. The relative high values of the area measured (in V. s-1) lead to a spread in the results at the lower ee of 0.5% and 0.05%. However, when these are converted to percentage ee, a clearer trend was defined. Even at 0.5% ee, the observed changes seem valid. In summary, it would seem that the instrument and method used were capable of discerning, within reasonable error, increments down to 0.05%, though the absolute value may be slightly different to the standard. To investigate the effects of adsorption on the vermiculite clay varying weights of clay were added to the racemic mix of D/L histidine and the supernatant measured for preferential adsorption of amino acid. In addition to testing propylammonium exchanged clay as used in the neutron scattering experiments, the sodium clay and propylammonium solution were tested, and the sodium clay alone was tested to determine any effect the propyl ammonium clay / solution may have had. Within the error present within the data, and allowing for the slight non-equivalence in the baseline solutions with no clay present, it is not possible to discern an ee in favour of either enantiomer. The size of the variation in the data was +/- 0.3 % ee . Thus, within the experimental error, we could find no evidence for preferential intercalation of either enantiomer. This suggests that the observed shift in d-spacing is purely due to subtle electrostatic screening effects between the two isomers. In conclusion, we demonstrated that the effect of different enantiomers of an amino acid may alter physical and structural properties of clay systems, at low amino acid concentrations and over a long length-range. This considerably extends the previous studies of chiral selectivity by clays, which usually require high packing densities and 8 low hydration states for differences to become apparent. HPLC analysis was unable to discern any compositional differences between the different systems, indicating that the observed effect is due to structural differences within the interlayer. 4. 3. 5. 6. 7. 8. Acknowledgements. We are grateful to ISIS and ILL for neutron beamtime. We thank Dr A. Congreve, Department of Chemistry, Durham University, for assistance with HPLC measurements. DGF gratefully acknowledges financial support from Worcester College, Oxford. References 1. 2. D. G. Fraser, Cell Origin Life Ext, 2004, 7, 149-152. R. M. Hazen, T. R. Filley and G. A. Goodfriend, P Natl Acad Sci USA, 2001, 98, 5487-5490. R. F. Gesteland, T. Cech and J. F. Atkins, The RNA world : the nature of modern RNA suggests a prebiotic RNA world, 3rd edn., Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y., 2006. R. F. Gesteland and J. F. Atkins, The RNA world : the nature of modern RNA suggests a prebiotic RNA world, Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, NY, 1993. K. Plankensteiner, H. Reiner and B. M. Rode, Curr Org Chem, 2005, 9, 1107-1114. J. F. Lambert, Origins Life Evol B, 2008, 38, 211-242. A. Parbhakar, J. Cuadros, M. A. Sephton, W. Dubbin, B. J. Coles and D. Weiss, Colloid Surface A, 2007, 307, 142-149. L. O. B. Benetoli, C. M. D. de Souza, K. L. da Silva, I. G. D. Souza, H. de Santana, A. Paesano, A. C. S. da Costa, C. T. B. V. Zaia and D. A. M. Zaia, Origins Life Evol B, 2007, 37, 479-493. J. Ikhsan, B. B. Johnson, J. D. Wells and M. J. Angove, J Colloid Interf Sci, 2004, 273, 1-5. J. Bujdak, H. LeSon and B. M. Rode, J Inorg Biochem, 1996, 63, 119-124. J. Bujdak and B. M. Rode, J Mol Catal a-Chem, 1999, 144, 129-136. J. Cuadros, L. Aldega, J. Vetterlein, K. Drickamer and W. Dubbin, J Colloid Interf Sci, 2009, 333, 78-84. H. Le Son, Y. Suwannachot, J. Bujdak and B. M. Rode, Inorg Chim Acta, 1998, 272, 89-94. B. M. Rode, H. L. Son, Y. Suwannachot and J. Bujdak, Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere, 1999, 29, 273-286. F. Li, D. Fitz, D. G. Fraser and B. M. Rode, Amino Acids, 2010, 38, 287-294. L. A. J. Garvie and P. R. Buseck, Meteorit Planet Sci, 2007, 42, 2111-2117. O. Botta, D. P. Glavin, G. Kminek and J. L. Bada, Origins Life Evol B, 2002, 32, 143- 163. D. P. Glavin and J. P. Dworkin, Meteorit Planet Sci, 2009, 44, A78-A78. G. M. M. Caro, U. J. Meierhenrich, W. A. Schutte, B. Barbier, A. A. Segovia, H. Rosenbauer, W. H. P. Thiemann, A. Brack and J. M. Greenberg, Nature, 2002, 416, 403-406. S. I. Goldberg, Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere, 2007, 37, 55-60. B. Siffert and A. Naidja, Clay Miner, 1992, 27, 109-118. T. Ikeda, H. Amoh and T. Yasunaga, J Am Chem Soc, 1984, 106, 5772-5775. C. H. Yu, S. Q. Newton, D. M. Miller, B. J. Teppen and L. Schafer, Struct Chem, 2001, 12, 393-398. X. C. Wang and C. Lee, Mar Chem, 1993, 44, 1-23. 24. N. Lahajnar, M. G. Wiesner and B. Gaye, Deep-Sea Res Pt I, 2007, 54, 2120-2144. 25. J. I. Hedges and P. E. Hare, Geochim Cosmochim Ac, 1987, 51, 255-259. 26. 27. M. Wei, Q. Yuan, D. G. Evans, Z. Q. Wang and X. Duan, J Mater Chem, 2005, 15, 1197-1203. 20. 21. 22. 23. 10. 11. 12. 9. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 9 29. 28. M. Smalley, Clay swelling and colloid stability, CRC/Taylor & Francis, Boca Raton, Fla. ; London, 2006. N. T. Skipper, A. K. Soper and J. D. C. McConnell, J Chem Phys, 1991, 94, 5751- 5760. 30. M. Kotlarchyk and S. M. Ritzau, Journal of Applied Crystallography, 1991, 24, 753- 758. G. D. Williams, N. T. Skipper and M. V. Smalley, Physica B, 1997, 234, 375-376. G. D. Williams, A. K. Soper, N. T. Skipper and M. V. Smalley, J Phys Chem B, 1998, 102, 8945-8949. 31. 32. 10
1606.05973	1	1606	2016-06-20T05:13:28	A New Parallel Algorithm for Two-Pass Connected Component Labeling	[ "cs.DS", "cs.CV", "cs.PF" ]	Connected Component Labeling (CCL) is an important step in pattern recognition and image processing. It assigns labels to the pixels such that adjacent pixels sharing the same features are assigned the same label. Typically, CCL requires several passes over the data. We focus on two-pass technique where each pixel is given a provisional label in the first pass whereas an actual label is assigned in the second pass. We present a scalable parallel two-pass CCL algorithm, called PAREMSP, which employs a scan strategy and the best union-find technique called REMSP, which uses REM's algorithm for storing label equivalence information of pixels in a 2-D image. In the first pass, we divide the image among threads and each thread runs the scan phase along with REMSP simultaneously. In the second phase, we assign the final labels to the pixels. As REMSP is easily parallelizable, we use the parallel version of REMSP for merging the pixels on the boundary. Our experiments show the scalability of PAREMSP achieving speedups up to $20.1$ using $24$ cores on shared memory architecture using OpenMP for an image of size $465.20$ MB. We find that our proposed parallel algorithm achieves linear scaling for a large resolution fixed problem size as the number of processing elements are increased. Additionally, the parallel algorithm does not make use of any hardware specific routines, and thus is highly portable.	cs.DS	cs	A New Parallel Algorithm for Two-Pass Connected Component Labeling Department of Electrical Engineering & Computer Science, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA Siddharth Gupta, Diana Palsetia, Md. Mostofa Ali Patwary, Ankit Agrawal, Alok Choudhary [email protected], {drp925, mpatwary, ankitag, choudhar}@eecs.northwestern.edu 1 6 1 0 2 n u J 0 2 ] S D . s c [ 1 v 3 7 9 5 0 . 6 0 6 1 : v i X r a Abstract-Connected Component Labeling (CCL) is an important step in pattern recognition and image processing. It assigns labels to the pixels such that adjacent pixels sharing the same features are assigned the same label. Typically, CCL requires several passes over the data. We focus on two-pass technique where each pixel is given a provisional label in the first pass whereas an actual label is assigned in the second pass. We present a scalable parallel two-pass CCL algorithm, called PAREMSP, which employs a scan strategy and the best union-find technique called REMSP, which uses REM's algorithm for storing label equivalence information of pixels in a 2-D image. In the first pass, we divide the image among threads and each thread runs the scan phase along with REMSP simultaneously. In the second phase, we assign the final labels to the pixels. As REMSP is easily parallelizable, we use the parallel version of REMSP for merging the pixels on the boundary. Our experiments show the scalability of PAREMSP achieving speedups up to 20.1 using 24 cores on shared memory architecture using OpenMP for an image of size 465.20 MB. We find that our proposed parallel algorithm achieves linear scaling for a large resolution fixed problem size as the number of processing elements are increased. Additionally, the parallel algorithm does not make use of any hardware specific routines, and thus is highly portable. I. Introduction One of the most fundamental operations in pattern recognition is the labeling of connected components in a binary image. Connected component labeling (CCL) is a procedure for assigning a unique label to each object (or a connected component) in an image. Because these labels are key for other analytical procedures, connected component labeling is an indispensable part of most applications in pattern recognition and computer vision, such as fingerprint identification, character recognition, automated inspection, target recognition, face identification, medical image analysis, and computer-aided diagnosis. In many cases, it is also one of the most time-consuming tasks among other pattern-recognition algorithms [1]. Therefore, connected component labeling continues to be an active area of research [2]–[9]. There exist many algorithms for computing connected components in a given image. These algorithms are categorized into mainly four groups [10] : 1) repeated pass algorithms [11], [12], 2) two-pass algorithms [13]–[21] 3) Algorithms with hierarchical tree equivalent representations of the data [22]–[29], 4) parallel algorithms [30]–[35]. The repeated pass algorithms perform repeated passes over an image in forward and backward raster directions alternately to propagate the label equivalences until no labels change. In two-pass algorithms, during the first pass, provisional labels are assigned to connected components; the label equivalences are stored in a one-dimensional or a two-dimensional table array. After the first pass, the label equivalences are resolved by some search. This step is often performed by using a search algorithm such as the union-find algorithm. The results of resolving are generally stored in a one-dimensional table. During the second pass, the provisional labels are replaced by the smallest equivalent label using the table. Since the algorithm traverses image twice, these algorithms are called two-pass algorithms. In algorithms that employ hierarchical tree structures i.e., n-ary tree such as binary-tree, quad-tree, octree, etc., the label equivalences are resolved by using a search algorithm such as the union-find algorithm. Lastly, the parallel algorithms have been developed for parallel machine models such as a mesh connected massively parallel processor. However all these algorithms share one common step, known as scanning step in which provisional label is given to each of the pixel depending on its neighbors. In this paper we focus on two-pass CCL algorithms. The algorithm in [36] and [37] are two developed techniques for two-pass Connected Component Labeling. The algorithm in [36], which we refer to as CCLLRPC, uses a decision tree to assign provisional labels and an array-based union-find data structure to store label equivalence information. However, the technique employed for union-find, Link by Rank and Path Compression is not the best technique available [38]. The algorithm in [37], which we refer to as ARUN, employs a special scan order over the data and three linear arrays instead of the conventional union-find data structure. There exists a parallel implementation of ARUN on TILE64 many core platform [39]. According to the experimental results given in [39], the parallel implementation is able to achieve a speedup of 10 on 32 processor units. This implementation is also not portable due to its implementation for specific hardware architecture. We propose two two-pass algorithms for labeling the connected components, AREMSP and CCLREMSP, which are based on REM's union-find algorithm REMSP [40], [41] and the scan strategy of ARUN and CCLLRPC algorithms. Since REM's union-find is an algorithm which implements immediate parent check test and compression technique called Splicing [40], [41], our proposed sequential two-pass algorithm AREMSP is 39% faster than CCLLRPC and 4% faster than ARUN. Another advantage of using REM's union-find approach is that its parallel implementation is shown to scale better with increasing number of processor [38]. Parallel REM's TABLE I: Abbreviations used in the paper and their brief description Abbreviation CCL ARUN REMSP AREMSP PAREMSP CCLLRPC CCLREMSP Description Connected Component Labeling CCL algorithm suggested by [37] union-find technique proposed by Rem [40] CCL algorithm proposed in our paper using scan strategy of ARUN and REMSP Parallel proposed in our paper CCL algorithm suggested by [36] CCL algorithm proposed in our paper using scan strategy of CCLLRPC and REMSP implementation of AREMSP union-find implementation thus allows us to process the pixels of the image in any order. Therefore, we propose PAREMSP, a parallel implementation of our proposed sequential two-pass CCL algorithm AREMSP. For scalability, our algorithm in the first pass, divides the image into equal proportions and executes the scan strategy of ARUN algorithm along with REMSP concurrently on each portion of the image. To merge the provisional labels on the image boundary, we use the parallel version of REMSP [38]. Our experiments show the scalability of PAREMSP achieving speedups up to 20.1 using 24 cores on shared memory architecture for an image of size 465.2 MB. Additionally, the parallel algorithm does not make use of any hardware specific routines, and thus is highly portable. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In section II, we provided related work on connected component labeling. In section III, we propose our sequential two-pass CCL algorithms CCLREMSP and AREMSP and the parallel algorithm PAREMSP in section IV. We present our experimental methodology and results in section V. We conclude our work in section VI. The abbreviations used in the paper and their brief description is given in Table I. II. Related Work As mentioned in [10], there exist different types of CCL algorithms. Repeated pass or multi pass algorithm repeatedly scans the image forward and backward alternatively to give labels until no further changes can be made to the assigned pixels [11], [12]. The algorithm in [10], which we call as Suzuki's algorithm modifies the conventional multi pass algorithm using one-dimensional table. There exists a parallel implementation of Suzuki's algorithm using OpenMP in [42]. According to experimental results in [42], the parallel implementation gets maximum speedup of 2.5 on 4 threads. In any two-pass algorithm, there are two steps in scanning step: 1) examining neighbors of current pixel which already assigned labels to determine label for the current pixel, 2) storing label equivalence information to speed up the algorithm. The algorithm in [36], which we refer to as CCLLRPC, provides two strategies to improve the running time of the algorithm. First strategy employs a decision tree, which reduces the average number of neighbors accessed by a factor of two. Second strategy replaces the conventional pointer based union-find algorithm, which is used for storing label equivalence, by adopting array based union-find algorithm that 2 uses less memory. The union-find algorithm is implemented using Link by Rank and Path Compression technique. The union-find data structure in [43] is replaced by a different data structure to process label equivalence information. In this algorithm, at any point, all provisional labels that are assigned to a connected component found thus far during the first scan are combined in a set S(r), where r is the smallest label and is referred to as the representative label. The algorithm employs rtable for storing representative label of a set, next to find the next element in the set and tail to find the last element of the set. In another strategy, which we call ARUN, the first part of scanning step employs a scanning technique, which processes image two lines at a time and process two image pixels at a time [37]. This algorithm uses the same data structure given in [43] for processing label equivalence information. The scanning technique reduces the number lines to be processed by half thereby improving the speed of the two-pass CCL method. In this paper, we provide two different implementations of two-pass CCL algorithm. These two algorithms are different in their first scan step. In the first implementation called CCLREMSP, we have used the decision tree suggested by the CCLLRPC algorithm for the first part of scanning step but for the second part we have used REM's union-find approach instead of Link by Rank and Path Compression technique. The union-find algorithm maintains a collection of disjoint sets where each set represents connected elements. [40] compares all of the different variations of union-find algorithms over different graph data sets and found that REM's implementation is best among all the variations. Thus in our second implementation, called AREMSP, we process the image lines two by two as suggested by [37] but for the second step we use REMSP instead of the data structure used by [37]. We have compared both of our proposed implementations with CCLLRPC, RUN, and ARUN algorithms and find that AREMSP performs best among all the algorithms. Finally we have also provided a shared memory parallel implementation of AREMSP called PAREMSP using OpenMP. We use the parallel implementation of REMSP given in [38]. III. Proposed Algorithm Throughout the paper, for an M × N image, we denote image(a) to denote the pixel value of pixel a. We consider binary images i.e. an image containing two types of pixels: object pixel and background pixel. Generally, we consider value of object pixel as 1 and value of background pixel as 0. The connected component labeling problem is to assign a label to each object pixel so that connected object pixels have the same label. In 2D images, there are two ways of defining connectedness: 4-connectedness and 8-connectedness. In this paper, we have only used 8-connectedness of a pixel. A. CCLREMSP Algorithm In CCLREMSP, we have used the decision tree suggested in CCLLRPC (Figure 2) for scanning and REM's union-find algorithm REMSP for storing label equivalence. The full algorithm for CCLREMSP is given as Algorithm 1. Algorithm 1 Pseudo-code for CCLREMSP Input: 2D array image containing the pixel values Output: 2D array label containing the final labels 1: function CCLREMSP(image) 2: 3: 4: 5: 6: 7: 8: end function Scan CCLRemSP (image) (cid:46) Scan Phase of CCLREMSP (cid:46) count is the max label assigned during Scan Phase f latten(p, count) for row in image do (cid:46) Analysis Phase of CCLREMSP (cid:46) Labeling Phase of CCLREMSP for col in row do (cid:46) e is the current pixel to be labeled label(e) ← p[label(e)] In the scan step of CCLREMSP, we process image lines one by one using the forward scan mask as shown in Figure 1a. We have used the decision tree proposed by [36] for determining the provisional label of current pixel e as we can reduce the number of neighbors using decision tree. Instead of examining all four neighbors of pixel, say e, i.e. a, b, c and d, we only examine the neighbors according to a decision tree as shown in Figure 2 [36]. Let label denote the 2D array storing the labels and let p denote equivalence array then according to CCLLRPC algorithm, three functions used by this decision tree are defined as follows: 1). The one-argument copy function, copy(a), contains one statement: label(e) = p(label(a)) 2). The two-argument copy function, copy(c,a), contains one statements: label(e) = merge(p, label(c), label(a)) 3). The new label function sets count as label(e), appends count to array p, and increments count by 1. c a d b e (a) Forward Scan Mask for RemSP c b a e d g f (b) Forward Scan Mask for ARemSP Fig. 1: Forward Scan Mask b a 0 c a 0 1 copy(a) 0 d 1 0 d 1 copy(b) 1 copy(c,a) 0 1 0 1 new label copy(d) copy(c) copy(c,d) Fig. 2: Decision tree suggested in CCLLRPC [36] The implementation of Scan CCLRemSP is given as 3 Algorithm 4. However, the implementation of MERGE operation in our proposed algorithm REMSP is different from that of in CCLLRPC. We have used the implementation of union-find proposed by REM's for merge operation [40], [41]. REM's integrates the union operation with a compression technique known as Splicing (SP ). In the MERGE algorithm, if x and y are the nodes to be merged then we set rootx to x and rooty to y. When rootx is to be moved to p(rootx), firstly p(rootx) is stored in a temporary variable z then p(rootx) is set to p(rooty), making the subtree rooted at rootx a sibling of rooty and finally rootx is set to z. The algorithm for MERGE is given as Algorithm 2. After the first step, we carry out the analysis phase using the FLATTEN algorithm. In the FLATTEN algorithm, we give smallest equivalent label of every connected component to all the pixels belonging to that connected component. The algorithm also generates consecutive labels. The algorithm for FLATTEN is given as Algorithm 3. if rootx = p[rootx] Algorithm 2 Pseudo-code for merge [40] Input: 1D array p and two nodes x and y Output: The root of united tree 1: function MERGE(p,x,y) rootx ← x, rooty ← y 2: while p[rootx] (cid:54)= p[rooty] do 3: if p[rootx] > p[rooty] then 4: 5: p[rootx] ← p[rooty] 6: return p[rootx] 7: 8: 9: 10: 11: 12: 13: 14: 15: end function p[rooty] ← p[rootx] return p[rootx] return p[rootx] then z ← p[rooty], p[rooty] ← p[rootx], rooty ← z else z ← p[rootx], p[rootx] ← p[rooty], rootx ← z if rooty = p[rooty] then Algorithm 3 Pseudo-code for flatten [36] InOut: 1D array p containing the equivalence info Input: Max value of provisional label count 1: function FLATTEN(p,count) 2: 3: 4: 5: 6: 7: 8: 9: end function k ← 1 for i = 1 to count do if p[i] < i then p[i] ← p[p[i]] p[i] ← k k + + else B. AREMSP Algorithm In AREMSP, we have used the decision tree suggested in ARUN for scanning and REM's union-find algorithm for storing label equivalence. The full algorithm for AREMSP is given as Algorithm 5. In the first scan step of AREMSP, we process an image two lines at a time and two pixels at a time using the mask shown in Figure 1b, which is suggested in [37]. else copy(b) if image(b) = 1 then if image(c) = 1 then if image(e) = 1 then for row in image do for col in row do Algorithm 4 Pseudo-code for CCLREMSP Scan Phase Input: 2D array image containing the pixel values InOut: 2D array label containing the provisional labels and 1D array p containing the equivalence info Output: maximum value of provisional label in count 1: function SCAN CCLREMSP(image) 2: 3: 4: 5: 6: 7: 8: 9: 10: 11: 12: 13: 14: 15: 16: 17: 18: 19: 20: 21: 22: 23: 24: 25: end function if image(a) = 1 then if image(a) = 1 then if image(d) = 1 then if image(d) = 1 then return count new label copy(c, a) copy(c, d) copy(a) copy(d) copy(c) else else else else else Algorithm 5 Pseudo-code for ARemSP Input: 2D array image containing the pixel values Output: 2D array label containing the final labels 1: function AREMSP(image) 2: 3: 4: 5: 6: 7: 8: end function Scan ARemSP (image) (cid:46) count is the max label assigned during Scan Phase f latten(p, count) for row in image do (cid:46) Analysis Phase of RemSP (cid:46) Labeling Phase of RemSP for col in row do (cid:46) e is the current pixel to be labeled label(e) ← p[label(e)] (cid:46) Scan Phase of RemSP We assign the label to both e and g simultaneously. If both e and g are background pixels, then nothing needs to be done. If e is a foreground pixel and there is no foreground pixel in the mask, we assign a new provisional label to e and if g is a foreground pixel, we will assign the label of e to g. If there are foreground pixels in the mask, then we assign e any label assigned to foreground pixels. In this case, if there is only one connected component in the mask then there is no need for label equivalence. Otherwise, if there are more than one connected components in the mask and as they are connected to e, all the labels of the connected components are equivalent labels and hence need to be merged. For all the cases, one can refer to [37]. However, our implementation for the merge operation is different from [37]. We use the implementation of union-find proposed by Rem [40], [41] for the merge operation in AREMSP. Similar to CCLREMSP, we use FLATTEN for analysis phase and generating consecutive labels. The implementation of Scan ARemSP is given as Algorithm 6. 4 else else merge(p, label(e), label(c)) if image(e) = 1 then if image(d) = 0 then merge(p, label(e), label(f )) for row in image do for col in row do if image(a) = 1 then label(e) ← label(a) if image(c) = 1 then if image(b) = 1 then label(e) ← label(b) if image(f ) = 1 then if image(f ) = 1 then label(e) ← label(f ) if image(a) = 1 then merge(p, label(a)) if image(c) = 1 then Algorithm 6 Pseudo-code for ARemSP Scan Phase Input: 2D array image containing the pixel values InOut: 2D array label containing the provisional labels and 1D array p containing the equivalence info Output: maximum value of provisional label in count 1: function SCAN AREMSP(image) 2: 3: 4: 5: 6: 7: 8: 9: 10: 11: 12: 13: 14: 15: 16: 17: 18: 19: 20: 21: 22: 23: 24: 25: 26: 27: 28: 29: 30: 31: 32: 33: 34: 35: 36: 37: 38: 39: 40: 41: 42: 43: 44: 45: 46: 47: 48: end function if image(f ) = 1 then label(g) ← label(f ) label(e) ← count, p[count] ← count, count + + if image(c) = 1 then label(e) ← label(c) label(e) ← count, p[count] ← count, count + + if image(d) = 1 then label(g) ← label(d) if image(g) = 1 then label(g) ← label(e) label(e) = label(d) if image(b) = 0 then if image(g) = 1 then if image(c) = 1 then merge(p, label(e), label(c)) merge(p, label(e), label(c)) return count else else else else else else IV. Parallelizing AREMSP Algorithm We now describe the parallel implementation of AREMSP algorithm on a shared memory system. We make the assumption about memory model as stated in OpenMP regarding the atomic directive. We assume that memory read/write operations are atomic and any operations issued concurrently by different processors will be executed in some unknown sequential order if no ordering constructs are being used. However, two dependent operations issued by the same processor will always be applied in the same order as they are issued. numiter ← row/2 (cid:46) As we are processing 2 rows at a time # pragma omp parallel chunk ← numiter/numberof threads size ← 2 × chunk start ← start index of the thread count ← start × col # pragma omp for Scan ARemSP (image) # pragma omp for for i = size to row − 1 do if label(e) (cid:54)= 0 then Algorithm 7 Pseudo-code for PARemSP Input: 2D array image containing the pixel values Output: 2D array label containing the final labels 1: function PAREMSP(image) 2: 3: 4: 5: 6: 7: 8: 9: 10: 11: 12: 13: 14: 15: 16: 17: 18: 19: 20: 21: 22: 23: 24: 25: 26: end function merger(p, label(e), label(b)) if label(a) (cid:54)= 0 then if label(c) (cid:54)= 0 then i ← i + size f latten(p, count) for row in image do for col in row do label(e) ← p[label(e)] if label(b) (cid:54)= 0 then merger(p, label(e), label(a)) merger(p, label(e), label(c)) for col in row do else 5 runs Scan Phase of AREMSP on it's chunk simultaneously. We initialize the label to the start index of the thread for every thread so that no two pixels in the image have the same label after the first step. After the first step, each pixel is given a provisional label. Next, the pixels at the boundary of each chunk need to be merged to get the final labels. In the second step, we merge the boundary pixels using parallel implementation of Rem's Algorithm [38] which we call as MERGER. In MERGER, if a thread wants to perform merging, it will first acquire the necessary lock. Once it gets the lock, it will check whether the node is still a root node. If yes, then the thread will set the parent pointer and release the lock. On the other hand if some other processor has altered the parent pointer so that the node is no longer a root, the processor will release the lock and continue executing the algorithm from its current position. For complete reference, one can refer [38]. We implement the parallel algorithm using OpenMP directives pragma omp parallel and pragma omp for. The pseudo code of MERGER is given as Algorithm 8. The pseudo code of PAREMSP is given as Algorithm 7. V. Experiments For the experiments we used a computing node of Hopper, a Cray XE6 distributed memory parallel computer. The node has 2 twelve-core AMD 'MagnyCours' 2.1-GHz processors and 32 GB DDR3 1333-MHz memory. Each core has its own L1 and L2 caches, with 64 KB and 512 KB, respectively. One 6-MB L3 cache is shared between 6 cores on the MagnyCours processor. All algorithms were implemented in C using OpenMP and compiled with gcc. Our test data set consists of four types of image data set: Texture, Aerial, Miscellaneous and NLCD. First three data sets are taken from the image database of the University of Southern California.1 The fourth data set is taken from US National Cover Database 2006.2 All of the images are converted to binary images by MATLAB using im2bw(level) function with level value as 0.5. The function converts the grayscale image to a binary image by replacing all pixels in the input image with luminance greater than 0.5 with the value 1 (white) and replaces all other pixels with the value 0 (black). If the input image is not a grayscale image, im2bw converts the input image to grayscale, and then converts this grayscale image to binary(Figure 3). However, note that our algorithm can be easily extended to gray scale images. Texture, Aerial and Miscellaneous data set contain images of size 1 MB or less. NCLD data set contains images of size bigger than 12 MB. The biggest image in the data set is 465.20 MB. Firstly, we performed the experiment over all the sequential algorithms. The experimental results are shown in Table II. In the table, we have shown the minimum, maximum and average execution time of all the four data sets. The execution time of AREMSP is lowest among all the sequential algorithms. Thus AREMSP is best among all the sequential algorithms. Next, we show our results for the parallel algorithm success ← 0 omp set lock(&(lock array[rootx])) if rootx = p[rootx] then p[rootx] ← p[rooty] success ← 1 Algorithm 8 Pseudo-code for merger [38] Input: 1D array p and two nodes x and y Output: The root of united tree 1: function MERGER(p,x,y) rootx ← x, rooty ← y 2: while p[rootx] (cid:54)= p[rooty] do 3: if p[rootx] > p[rooty] then 4: if rootx = p[rootx] then 5: 6: 7: 8: 9: 10: 11: 12: 13: 14: 15: 16: 17: 18: 19: 20: 21: 22: 23: 24: 25: 26: 27: end function return p[rootx] break break else z ← p[rootx], p[rootx] ← p[rooty], rootx ← z if rooty = p[rooty] then success ← 0 omp set lock(&(lock array[rooty])) if root = p[rooty] then p[rooty] ← p[rootx] success ← 1 omp unset lock(&(lock array[rooty])) if success = 1 then omp unset lock(&(lock array[rootx])) if success = 1 then z ← p[rooty], p[rooty] ← p[rootx], rooty ← z In PAREMSP, the image is divided row-wise into chunks of equal size and given to the threads. In the first step, each thread 1http://sipi.usc.edu/database/ 2http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cageo.2013.05.014 (a) Original Image (b) Binary Image Fig. 3: Example of color image to binary image Aerial Miscellaneous Texture TABLE II: Comparison of various execution times[msec] for sequential algorithms 6 Image type Aerial Texture Misc NLCD Min Average Average Max Min Max Min Max Min Average Average Max CCLLRPC CCLRemSP 2.5 13.68 86.64 2.07 8.42 16.86 0.50 3.28 12.96 4.61 307.66 1307.27 2.48 13.25 80.90 2.06 8.20 16.18 0.49 3.21 12.81 4.46 299.55 1273.82 ARun 1.98 11.90 72.92 1.58 7.32 14.81 0.36 2.75 11.30 3.77 244.88 1036.52 ARemSP 1.95 11.86 70.17 1.53 7.27 14.47 0.36 2.74 11.20 3.75 242.59 1021.45 TABLE III: Images and their sizes [in MB] Image name image 1 image 2 image 3 image 4 image 5 image 6 Size 12 33 37.31 116.30 132.03 465.20 TABLE IV: Execution time [msec] of PAREMSP algorithm for various # threads 10 p u d e e p S 8 6 4 2 2 6 8 #Threads 16 24 Image type Aerial Texture Fig. 4: Speedup for different images and different numbers of threads for Aerial, Texture & Miscellaneous data set Miscellaneous NLCD Min Average Max Min Max Min Max Min Average Average Average Max 2 1.39 7.92 46.86 1.09 4.91 9.75 0.36 1.99 7.96 2.52 162.86 676.41 6 0.84 3.03 16.72 0.62 1.99 3.56 0.36 0.97 3.24 1.16 58.50 184.71 16 1.02 1.87 7.32 0.93 1.45 2.11 0.79 1.05 1.91 1.32 20.20 78.33 24 1.38 2.15 6.97 1.36 1.82 2.34 1.18 1.46 2.27 1.67 13.47 51.00 PAREMSP over all the images. We have shown the speedup for data sets (except NCLD image data set) in Figure 4. The minimum, maximum and average execution time of PAREMSP for all the datasets is also shown in Table IV. We get a maximum speedup of 10 in this case as the images are 1 MB or less in size. The speedup also decreases in some cases as the number of threads increases. This case occurs when the image size is small. As the number of threads increase, each threads has less work, and therefore the thread creation and termination overhead will affect the performance. Figure 5a-5b shows the speedup of the algorithm for NCLD image data set. The size of the images are given in Table III. We get a maximum speedup of 20.1 on 24 cores for image of size 465.20 MB. Figure 5a shows the speedup for Phase-I of PAREMSP i.e. the local computation and Figure 5b shows the overall speedup (i.e. local + merge). We can see that there is not significant difference between both speedups, implying that merge operation does not have a significant overhead. Also Figure 5 shows, speedup increases with image size. Therefore, our parallel implementation is able to achieve near linear speed for large data sets. VI. Conclusion In this paper, we presented two sequential CCL algorithms CCLREMSP and AREMSP which are based on union-find technique of REM's algorithm and scan strategies of ARUN and CCLLRPC algorithms. CCLREMSP algorithm uses the scan strategy of CCLLRPC algorithm whereas AREMSP uses the scan strategy of ARUN algorithm. Based on the experiments, we found out that AREMSP outperforms all the other sequential algorithms. We also implement a portable parallel implementation of AREMSP for shared memory computers with standard OpenMP directives. Our proposed algorithm, PAREMSP, divides the image into equal proportions and executes the scan. To merge the provisional labels on the image boundary, we use the parallel version of REM's algorithm. Our experimental results conducted on a shared memory computer show scalable performance, achieving speedups up to a factor of 20.1 when using 24 cores on data set of size 465.20 MB. Thus, our parallel algorithm achieves linear scaling for large fixed problem size while the number of processing elements are increased. Acknowledgment This work is supported in part by the following grants: NSF awards CCF-0833131, CNS-0830927, IIS-0905205, CCF-0938000, CCF-1029166, ACI-1144061, and IIS-1343639; awards DE-FG02-08ER25848, DE-SC0001283, DOE p u d e e p S 25 20 15 10 5 0 0 5 10 15 # Threads (a) local 7 p u d e e p S 25 20 15 10 5 0 20 25 0 5 10 15 # Threads 20 25 image 1 image 2 image 3 image 4 (b) local + merge image 6 image 5 ideal Fig. 5: Speedup for different images and different numbers of threads for NLCD data set DE-SC0005309, DESC0005340, and DESC0007456; AFOSR award FA9550-12-1-0458. References [1] Hussein M Alnuweiri and Viktor K Prasanna. Parallel architectures and algorithms for image component labeling. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 14(10):1014–1034, 1992. [2] Rafael C Gonzales and RE Woods. Digital image processing, 1993. [3] Pankaj K Agarwal, Lars Arge, and Ke Yi. I/o-efficient batched union-find and its applications to terrain analysis. In Proceedings of the twenty-second annual symposium on Computational geometry, pages 167–176. ACM, 2006. [4] Fu Chang, Chun-Jen Chen, and Chi-Jen Lu. A linear-time component-labeling algorithm using contour tracing technique. Computer Vision and Image Understanding, 93(2):206–220, 2004. [5] Hiroki Hayashi, Mineichi Kudo, Jun Toyama, and Masaru Shimbo. Fast labelling of natural scenes using enhanced knowledge. Pattern Analysis & Applications, 4(1):20–27, 2001. [6] Qingmao Hu, Guoyu Qian, and Wieslaw L Nowinski. Fast connected-component labelling in three-dimensional binary images based on iterative recursion. Computer Vision and Image Understanding, 99(3):414–434, 2005. [7] Felipe Knop and Vernon Rego. Parallel labeling of three-dimensional clusters on networks of workstations. Journal of Parallel and Distributed Computing, 49(2):182–203, 1998. [8] Alina N Moga and Moncef Gabbouj. Parallel image component labelling with watershed transformation. Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, IEEE Transactions on, 19(5):441–450, 1997. [9] Kuang-Bor Wang, Tsorng-Lin Chia, Zen Chen, and Der-Chyuan Lou. Parallel execution of a connected component labeling operation on a linear array architecture. J. Inf. Sci. Eng., 19(2):353–370, 2003. [10] Kenji Suzuki, Linear-time connected-component labeling based on sequential local operations. Computer Vision and Image Understanding, 89(1):1–23, 2003. Isao Horiba, and Noboru Sugie. [11] RM Haralick. Some neighborhood operators. Computing, pages 11–35. Springer, 1981. In Real-Time Parallel [12] A Hashizume, R Suzuki, H Yokouchi, H Horiuchi, and S Yamamato. An algorithm of automated rbc classification and its evaluation. Bio Medical Engineering, 28(1):25–32, 1990. [13] Toshiyuki Gotoh, Yoshiyuki Ohta, Masumi Yoshida, and Yoshiaki Shirai. High-speed algorithm for component labeling. Systems and Computers in Japan, 21(5):74–84, 1990. [14] Toshiyuki Gotoh, Yoshiyuki Ohta, Masumi Yoshida, and Yoshio Shirai. In Hague Component labeling algorithm for video rate processing. International Symposium, pages 217–224. International Society for Optics and Photonics, 1987. [15] Masatoshi Komeichi, Yoshiyuki Ohta, Toshiyuki Gotoh, Toshiya Mima, In 1988 Intl and Masumi Yoshida. Video-rate labeling processor. Congress on Optical Science and Engineering, pages 69–76. International Society for Optics and Photonics, 1989. [16] Ronald Lumia. A new three-dimensional connected components Computer Vision, Graphics, and Image Processing, algorithm. 23(2):207–217, 1983. [17] Ronald Lumia, Linda Shapiro, and Oscar Zuniga. A new connected components algorithm for virtual memory computers. Computer Vision, Graphics, and Image Processing, 22(2):287–300, 1983. [18] Satoshi Naoi. High-speed labeling method using adaptive variable window size for character shape feature. In IEEE Asian Conference on computer vision, volume 1, pages 408–411, 1995. [19] Azriel Rosenfeld. Connectivity in digital pictures. Journal of the ACM (JACM), 17(1):146–160, 1970. [20] Azriel Rosenfeld and John L Pfaltz. Sequential operations in digital picture processing. Journal of the ACM (JACM), 13(4):471–494, 1966. [21] Y Shirai. Labeling connected regions. Three-Dimensional Computer Vision, pages 86–89, 1987. [22] Michael B Dillencourt, Hannan Samet, and Markku Tamminen. A general approach to connected-component labeling for arbitrary image representations. Journal of the ACM (JACM), 39(2):253–280, 1992. [23] Irene Gargantini and Zale Tabakman. Separation of connected component In Proc. 12th Conf. Numerical using linear quad-and oct-trees. Mathematics and Computation, volume 37, pages 257–276, 1982. [24] Jean Hecquard and Raj Acharya. Connected component labeling with linear octree. Pattern recognition, 24(6):515–531, 1991. [25] Hanan Samet. Connected component labeling using quadtrees. Journal of the ACM (JACM), 28(3):487–501, 1981. [26] Hanan Samet and Markku Tamminen. Computing geometric properties of images represented by linear quadtrees. Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, IEEE Transactions on, (2):229–240, 1985. [27] Hanan Samet and Markku Tamminen. Efficient component labeling of images of arbitrary dimension represented by linear bintrees. Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, IEEE Transactions on, 10(4):579–586, 1988. [28] Hanan Samet and Markku Tamminen. An improved approach to connected component labeling of images. In International Conference on Computer Vision And Pattern Recognition, pages 312–318, 1986. [29] Markku Tamminen and Hanan Samet. Efficient octree conversion In ACM SIGGRAPH Computer Graphics, by connectivity labeling. volume 18, pages 43–51. ACM, 1984. [30] Prabir Bhattacharya. Connected component labeling for binary images 8 on a reconfigurable mesh architecture. Journal of Systems Architecture, 42(4):309–313, 1996. on [31] Alok Choudhary and Rajeev Thakur. Connected component labeling on coarse grain parallel computers: an experimental study. Journal of Parallel and Distributed Computing, 20(1):78–83, 1994. [32] Daniel S. Hirschberg, Ashok K. Chandra, and Dilip V. Sarwate. computers. Computing Communications of the ACM, 22(8):461–464, 1979. components connected parallel [33] M Manohar and HK Ramapriyan. Connected component labeling of binary images on a mesh connected massively parallel processor. Computer vision, graphics, and image processing, 45(2):133–149, 1989. [34] David Nassimi and Sartaj Sahni. Finding connected components and connected ones on a mesh-connected parallel computer. SIAM Journal on computing, 9(4):744–757, 1980. [35] Stephan Olariu, James L Schwing, and Jingyuan Zhang. Fast component labelling and convex hull computation on reconfigurable meshes. Image and vision computing, 11(7):447–455, 1993. [36] Kesheng Wu, Ekow Otoo, and Kenji Suzuki. Optimizing two-pass Pattern Analysis and labeling algorithms. connected-component Applications, 12(2):117–135, 2009. [37] Lifeng He, Yuyan Chao, and Kenji Suzuki. A new two-scan algorithm for labeling connected components in binary images. In Proceedings of the World Congress on Engineering, volume 2, 2012. [38] Md Patwary, Mostofa Ali, Peder Refsnes, and Fredrik Manne. Multi-core spanning forest algorithms using the disjoint-set data structure. In Parallel & Distributed Processing Symposium (IPDPS), 2012 IEEE 26th International, pages 827–835. IEEE, 2012. [39] Chien-Wei Chen, Yi-Ta Wu, Shau-Yin Tseng, and Wen-Shan Wang. Parallelization of connected-component labeling on tile64 many-core platform. Journal of Signal Processing Systems, pages 1–15, 2013. [40] Md Mostofa Ali Patwary, Jean Blair, and Fredrik Manne. Experiments on union-find algorithms for the disjoint-set data structure. In Experimental Algorithms, pages 411–423. Springer, 2010. [41] Edsger Wybe Dijkstra, Edsger Wybe Dijkstra, Edsger Wybe Dijkstra, and Edsger Wybe Dijkstra. A discipline of programming, volume 1. prentice-hall Englewood Cliffs, 1976. [42] Mehdi Niknam, Parimala Thulasiraman, and Sergio Camorlinga. A parallel algorithm for connected component labelling of gray-scale images on homogeneous multicore architectures. In Journal of Physics: Conference Series, volume 256, page 012010. IOP Publishing, 2010. [43] Lifeng He, Yuyan Chao, and Kenji Suzuki. A run-based two-scan labeling Image Processing, IEEE Transactions on, 17(5):749–756, algorithm. 2008.
1812.11774	1	1812	2018-12-31T12:23:27	Tighter bounds for online bipartite matching	[ "cs.DS" ]	We study the online bipartite matching problem, introduced by Karp, Vazirani and Vazirani [1990]. For bipartite graphs with matchings of size $n$, it is known that the Ranking randomized algorithm matches at least $(1 - \frac{1}{e})n$ edges in expectation. It is also known that no online algorithm matches more than $(1 - \frac{1}{e})n + O(1)$ edges in expectation, when the input is chosen from a certain distribution that we refer to as $D_n$. This upper bound also applies to fractional matchings. We review the known proofs for this last statement. In passing we observe that the $O(1)$ additive term (in the upper bound for fractional matching) is $\frac{1}{2} - \frac{1}{2e} + O(\frac{1}{n})$, and that this term is tight: the online algorithm known as Balance indeed produces a fractional matching of this size. We provide a new proof that exactly characterizes the expected cardinality of the (integral) matching produced by Ranking when the input graph comes from the support of $D_n$. This expectation turns out to be $(1 - \frac{1}{e})n + 1 - \frac{2}{e} + O(\frac{1}{n!})$, and serves as an upper bound on the performance ratio of any online (integral) matching algorithm.	cs.DS	cs	Tighter bounds for online bipartite matching Uriel Feige ∗ January 1, 2019 Abstract We study the online bipartite matching problem, introduced by Karp, Vazirani and Vazirani [1990]. For bipartite graphs with matchings of size n, it is known that the Ranking randomized algorithm matches at least (1 − e )n edges in expectation. It is also known that no online algorithm e )n + O(1) edges in expectation, when the input matches more than (1 − is chosen from a certain distribution that we refer to as Dn. This upper bound also applies to fractional matchings. We review the known proofs for this last statement. In passing we observe that the O(1) additive term (in the upper bound for fractional matching) is 1 n ), and that this term is tight: the online algorithm known as Balance indeed produces a fractional matching of this size. We provide a new proof that exactly characterizes the expected cardinality of the (integral) matching produced by Ranking when the input graph comes from the support of Dn. This expectation turns out to be (1 − n! ), and serves as an upper bound on the performance ratio of any online (integral) matching algorithm. 2e + O( 1 e )n + 1 − 2 e + O( 1 1 2 − 1 1 1 1 Introduction Given a bipartite graph G(U, V ; E), where U and V are the sets of vertices and E ∈ U × V is the set of edges, a matching M ⊂ E is a set of edges such that every vertex is incident with at most one edge of M . Given a matching M , a vertex is referred to as either matched or exposed, depending on whether it is incident with an edge of M . A maximum matching in a graph is a matching of maximum cardinality, and a maximal matching is a matching that is not a proper subset of any other matching. Maximal matchings can easily be found by greedy algorithms, and maximum matchings can also be found by various polynomial time algorithms, using techniques such as alternating paths or linear programming (see [9] and references therein). In every graph, the cardinality of every maximal matching is at least half of that of the maximum matching, because every matched edge can exclude at most two edges from the maximum matching. ∗Department of Computer Science and Applied Mathematics, The Weizmann Institute. [email protected] 1 For simplicity of notation, for every n we shall only consider the following class of bipartite graphs, that we shall refer to as Gn. For every G(U, V ; E) ∈ Gn it holds that U = V = n and that E contains a matching of size n (and hence G has a perfect matching). The vertices of U will be denoted by ui (for 1 ≤ i ≤ n) and the vertices of V will be denoted by vi (for 1 ≤ i ≤ n). All results that we will state for Gn hold without change for all bipartite graphs, provided that n denotes the size of the maximum matching in the graph. Karp, Vazirani and Vazirani [7] introduced an online version of the maximum bipartite matching problem. This setting can be viewed as a game between two players: a maximizing player who wishes the resulting matching to be as large as possible, and a minimizing player who wishes the matching to be as small as possible. First, the minimizing player chooses G(U, V ; E) in private (without the maximizing player seeing E), subject to G ∈ Gn. Thereafter, the structure of G is revealed to the maximizing player in n steps, where at step j (for 1 ≤ j ≤ n) the set N (uj) ⊂ V of vertices adjacent to uj is revealed. At every step j, upon seeing N (uj) (and based on all edges previously seen and all previous matching decisions made), the maximizing player needs to irrevocably either match uj to a currently exposed vertex in N (uj), or leave uj exposed. There is much recent interest in the online bipartite matching problem and variations and generalizations of it, as such models have applications for allo- cation problems in certain economic settings, in which buyers (vertices of U ) arrive online and are interested in purchasing various items (vertices of V ). For more details, see for example the survey by Metha [11]. An algorithm for the maximizing player in the online bipartite matching setting will be called greedy if the only vertices of U that it leaves unmatched are those vertices u ∈ U that upon their arrival did not have an exposed neighbor (and hence could not be matched). It is not difficult to see that every non-greedy algorithm A can be replaced by a greedy algorithm A′ that for every graph G matches at least as many vertices as A does. Hence we shall assume that the algorithm for the maximizing player is greedy, and this assumption is made without loss of generality, as far as the results in this manuscript are concerned. Every greedy algorithm (for the maximizing player) produces a maximal matching, and hence matches at least half the vertices. For every deterministic algorithm, the minimizing player can select a bipartite graph G (that admits a perfect matching) that guarantees that the algorithm matches only half the vertices. (Sketch: The first U 2 arriving vertices have all of V as their neighbors, and the remaining U 2 vertices that the algorithm matched with the first U 2 are neighbors only of the V 2 vertices.) To improve the size of the matching beyond n 2 , Karp, Vazirani and Vazi- rani [7] considered randomized algorithms for the maximizing player. Specifi- cally, they proposed an algorithm called Ranking that works as follows. It first selects uniformly at random a permutation π over the vertices V . Thereafter, upon arrival of a vertex u, it is matched to its earliest (according to π) exposed neighbor if there is one (and left unmatched otherwise). As the maximizing al- gorithm is randomized (due to the random choice of π), the number of vertices 2 matched is a random variable, and we consider its expectation. Let A be a randomized algorithm (such as Ranking) for the maximizing player. As such, for every bipartite graph G it produces a distribution over matchings. For a bipartite graph G ∈ Gn, we use the following notation: • ρn(A, G) is the expected cardinality of matching produced by A when the input graph is G. • ρn(A, −) is the minimum over all G ∈ Gn of ρn(A, G). Namely, ρn(A, −) = minG∈Gn[ρn(A, G)]. • ρn is the maximum over all A (randomized online matching algorithms for the maximizing player) of ρn(A, −). Namely, ρn = maxA[ρn(A, −)]. (Showing that the maximum is attained is a technicality that we ignore here.) • ρ = inf n ρn n . Namely, ρ is the largest constant (independent of n) such that ρn ρ · n ≤ ρn for all n. (One might find a definition such as ρ = limn→∞ n more natural, but it turns out that both definitions of ρ give the same value, which will be seen to be 1 − 1 e .) Karp, Vazirani and Vazirani [7] showed that ρn(Ranking, −) ≥ (1 − 1 e )n − o(n), where e is the base of the natural logarithm (and (1 − 1 e ) ≃ 0.632). Un- fortunately, that paper had only a conference version and not a journal version, and the proof presented in the conference version appears to have gaps. Later work (e.g., [12, 4, 2]), motivated by extensions of the online matching problem to other problems such as the adwords problem, presented alternative proofs, and also established that the o(n) term is not required. There have also been expositions of simpler versions of these proofs. See [1, 10, 3], for example. Sum- marizing this earlier work, we have: Theorem 1 For every bipartite graph G ∈ Gn, the expected cardinality of the matching produced by Ranking is at least (1 − 1 e )n. Hence ρn(Ranking, −) ≥ (1 − 1 e )n, and ρ ≥ 1 − 1 e ≃ 0.632. Karp, Vazirani and Vazirani [7] also presented a distribution over Gn, and showed that for every online algorithm, the expected size of the matching pro- duced (expectation taken over random choice of graph from this distribution) is at most (1 − 1/e)n + o(n). This distribution, that we shall refer to as Dn, is defined as follows. Select uniformly at random a permutation τ over V . For every j, the neighbors of vertex uj are {vτ (j), . . . , vτ (n)}. The unique perfect matching M is the set of edges (uj, vτ (j)) for 1 ≤ j ≤ n. To present the known results regarding Dn more accurately, let as extend previous notation. • ρn(A, Dn) is the expected cardinality of matching produced by A when the input graph G is selected according to distribution Dn. (Hence expec- tation is taken both over randomness of A and over selection from Dn.) 3 By definition, for every algorithm A, ρn(A, Dn) is an upper bound on ρn(A, −). • ρn(−, Dn) is the maximum over all A (randomized online algorithms for the maximizing player) of ρn(A, Dn). Namely, ρn(−, Dn) = maxA[ρn(A, Dn)]. By definition, for every n, ρn(−, Dn) is an upper bound on ρn. It is not hard to see (and was shown also in Lemma 13 of [7]) that for every two greedy online algorithms A and A′ it holds that ρn(A, Dn) = ρn(A′, Dn). As greedy algorithms are optimal among online algorithms, and Ranking is a greedy algorithm, we have the following proposition. Proposition 2 For Dn defined as above, ρn(Ranking, Dn) = ρn(−, Dn) ≥ ρn The result of [7] can be stated as showing that ρn(−, Dn) ≤ (1 − 1 e )n + o(n). Later analysis (see for example [12], or the lecture notes of Kleinberg [8] or Karlin [6]) replaced the o(n) term by O(1). Moreover, this upper bound holds not only for online randomized integral algorithms (that match edges as a whole), but also for online fractional algorithms (that match fractions of edges). Let us provide more details. A fractional matching for a bipartite graph G(U, V ; E) is a nonnegative weight function w for the edges such that for every vertex u ∈ U we have Pv∈N (u) w(u, v) ≤ 1, and likewise, for every vertex v ∈ V we havePu∈N (v) w(u, v) ≤ 1. The size of a fractional matching is Pe∈E w(e). It is well known (see [9], for example) that in bipartite graphs, the size of the maximum fractional matching equals the cardinality of the maximum (integral) matching. In the online bipartite fractional matching problem, as vertices of U arrive, the maximizing player can add arbitrary positive weights to their incident edges, provided that the result remains a fractional matching. We extend the ρ nota- tion used for the integral case also to the fractional case, by adding a subscript f . Hence for example, ρf,n(A, G) is the size of the fractional matching produced by an online algorithm A when G ∈ Gn is the input graph. It is not hard to see that in the fractional setting, randomization does not help the maximizing player, in the sense that any randomized online algorithm A for fractional matching can replaced by a deterministic algorithm A′ that on every input graph produces a fractional matching of at least the same size. (Upon arrival of vertex u, the fractional weight that A′ adds to edge (u, v) equals the expected weight that A adds to this edge, where expectation is taken over randomness of A.) Consequently, ρf,n ≥ ρn, and every upper bound on ρf,n is also an upper bound on ρn. The following theorem summarizes the known upper bounds on ρf,n, which are also the strongest known upper bounds on ρn. Theorem 3 For Dn as defined above, ρf,n(−, Dn) ≤ (1 − 1 quently, ρn(−, Dn) ≤ (1 − 1 e )n + O(1). e )n + O(1). Conse- 4 The combination of Theorems 1 and 3 implies the following corollary: Corollary 4 Using notation as above, ρ = 1 − 1 e . The Ranking algorithm (which produces an integral matching) is asymptotically optimal (for the maximizing player) for online bipartite matching both in the integral and in the fractional case. The distribution Dn is asymptotically optimal for the minimizing player, both in the integral and in the fractional case. e and ρf = 1 − 1 In this manuscript, we shall be interested not only in the asymptotic ratios ρ and ρf , but also in the exact ratios ρn and ρf,n. Every (integral) matching is also a fractional matching, hence one may view Ranking also as an online algorithm for fractional matching. As such, Ranking is easily seen not to be optimal for some n. For example, when n = 4, tedious but straighforward analysis shows that a different known algorithm referred to as Balance (see Section 2) satisfies ρf,4(Balance, −) > ρf,4(Ranking, −) (details omitted). However, for the integral case, it was conjectured in [7] that both Ranking and Dn are optimal for every n. Namely, the conjecture is: Conjecture 5 ρn = ρn(Ranking, Dn) for every n. The above conjecture, though still open, adds motivation (beyond Proposi- tion 2) to determine the exact value of ρn(Ranking, Dn). This is done in the following theorem. Theorem 6 Let the function a(n) be such that ρn(Ranking, Dn) = a(n) for all n! n. Then a(n) = (n + 1)! − d(n + 1) − d(n), where d(n) is the number of derange- ments (permutations with no fixed points) on the numbers [1, n]. Consequently, ρn(−, Dn) = (1 − 1 e )n + 0.264, and this is also an upper bound on ρn. n! ) ≃ (1 − 1 e )n + 1 − 2 e + O( 1 The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 we review a proof of Theorem 3. In doing so, we determine the value of the O(1) term stated in the theorem, and also show that the upper bound is tight. Hence we end up proving the following theorem: Theorem 7 For every n, Balance is the fractional online algorithm with best approximation ratio, Dn is the distribution over graphs for which the approxi- mation ratio is worst possible, and ρf,n = ρf,n(Balance, Dn) = (1 − 1 e )n + 1 2 − 1 2e + O( 1 n ) ≃ (1 − 1 e )n + 0.316 In Section 3 we prove Theorem 6. The combination of Theorems 6 and 7 im- plies that ρn < ρf,n for sufficiently large n. It also implies that ρf,n(Balance, Dn) > ρf,n(Ranking, Dn) for sufficiently large n. Hence Proposition 2 does not extend to online fractional matching. In an appendix (Section A) we review a proof (due to [3]) of Theorem 1, and derive from it an upper bound of (1 − 1 e on ρn(Ranking, Dn). This last upper bound is weaker than the upper bounds of Theorems 6 and 7, but its proof is different, and hence might turn out useful in attempts to resolve Conjecture 5. e )n + 1 5 1.1 Preliminaries -- MonotoneG When analyzing ρn(Ranking, Dn) we shall use the following observation so as to simplify notation. Because Ranking is oblivious to names of vertices, the expected size of the matching produced by Ranking on every graph in the sup- port of Dn is the same. Hence we shall consider one representative graph from Dn, that we refer to as the monotone graph MonotoneG, in which γ (in the definition of Dn) is the identity permutation. The monotone graph G(U, V ; E) satisfies E = {(ui, vj ) j ≥ i}, and its unique perfect matching is M = {(ui, vi) 1 ≤ i ≤ n}. Statements involving ρn(Ranking, Dn) will be replaced by ρn(Ranking, M onotoneG), as both expressions have the same value. Likewise, the algorithm Balance is oblivious to names of vertices, and state- ments involving ρf,n(Balance, Dn) will be replaced by ρf,n(Balance, M onotoneG). 2 Online fractional matchings Let us present a specific online fractional matching algorithm that is often re- ferred to as Balance, which is the natural fractional analog of an algorithm by the same name introduced in [5]. Balance maintains a load ℓ(v) for every ver- tex v ∈ V , equal to the sum of weights of edges incident with v. Hence at all times, 0 ≤ ℓ(v) ≤ 1. Upon arrival of a vertex u with a set of neighbors edges incident with u, maintaining the resulting loads as balanced as possi- N (u), Balance distributes a weight of min[1, N (u) −Pv∈N (u) ℓ(v)] among the ble. Namely, one computes a threshold t such that Pv∈N (u)ℓ(v)<t(t − ℓ(v)) = min[1, N (u) − Pv∈N (u) ℓ(v)], and then adds fractional value t − ℓ(v) to each edge (u, v) for those vertices v ∈ N (u) that have load below t. We first present a proof of Theorem 3 based on previous work. The theorem is restated below, with the additive O(1) term instantiated. Previous work either did not specify the O(1) additive term (e.g., in [6]), or derived an O(1) term that is not tight (e.g., in [8]). Theorem 8 For every n it holds that ρf,n(−, Dn) = (1 − 1 e )n + 1 2 − 1 2e + O( 1 n ) ≃ (1 − 1 e )n + 0.316 Moreover, ρf,n(−, Dn) = ρf,n(Balance, Dn). Proof. For all graphs in the support of Dn, the size of the fractional matching produced by Balance is the same (by symmetry). Hence for simplicity of no- tation, consider the fractional matching produced by Balance when the input graph is the monotone graph MonotoneG (see Section 1.1). It is not hard to see that when vertex ui arrives, Balance raises the load of each vertex in {vi, . . . , vn} by n−i+1 ≤ 1. There- after, when vertex uk+1 arrives, Balance can raise the load of its n − k neighbors n−i+1 . This can go on until the largest k satisfying Pk i=1 1 1 6 n−i+1 to 1. Hence altogether the size of the fractional matching is i=1 n−i+1 ), for k as above. 1 i=1 from Pk precisely k + (n − k)(1 −Pk number Hn = Pn 1 The value of k can be determined as follows. It is known that the harmonic n2 ), where γ ≃ 0.577 is the Euler-Mascheroni constant. k is the largest integer such that Hn − Hn−k ≤ 1. Defining α , n−k i satisfies Hn = ln n+γ+ 1 2n +O( 1 i=1 n , we have that 1 Hn−Hn−k = ln n+γ+ 1 2n +O( 1 n2 )−ln αn−γ− 1 2αn +O( 1 n2 ) = ln 1 α − 1 α − 1 2n +O( 1 n2 ) e (and temporarily ignoring the fact that in this case k = (1− 1 Choosing α = 1 is not an integer), we get that Hn − Hn−k = 1 − e−1 matching is then e )n n2 ). The size of a 2n + O( 1 (1 − 1 e )n + n e ( e − 1 2n + O( 1 n2 )) = (1 − 1 e )n + 1 2 + 1 2e + O( 1 n ) as desired. The fact that k = (1 − 1 e )n above was not an integer requires that we round k down to the nearest integer. The effect of this rounding is bounded by the effect of changing the number of neighbors available to uk and to uk+1 by one (compared to the computation without the rounding). Given that the number of neighbors is roughly n e , the overall effect on the size of the fractional matching is at most O( 1 We conclude that ρf,n(Balance, Dn) = (1− 1 n ), implying that 2 + 1 ρf,n(−, Dn) ≥ (1 − 1 n ). In remains to show that ρf,n(−, Dn) ≤ (1 − 1 n ). This follows because Balance is the best possible online algorithm (for fractional bipartite matching) against Dn. Let us provide more details. e )n + 1 2e + O( 1 2e + O( 1 2e +O( 1 e )n + 1 e )n+ 1 2 + 1 2 + 1 n ). Given an input graph from the support of Dn, we shall say that a vertex v ∈ V is active in round i if it is a neighbor of ui. Initially all vertices are active, and after every round, one more vertex (chosen at random among the active vertices) becomes inactive, and remains inactive forever. Let a(i) denote the number of active vertices at the beginning of round i, and note that a(i) = n − i + 1. Consider an arbitrary online algorithm. Let L(i) denote the average load of the active vertices at the beginning of round i. Then in round i, the 1 average load first increases by at most a(i) (as long as it does not exceed 1) by raising weights of edges, and thereafter, making one vertex inactive keeps the average load unchanged in expectation (over choice of input from Dn). Hence in expectation, in every round, the average load does not exceed the value of the average load obtained by Balance. This means that in every round, in expectation, the amount of unused load of the vertex that became inactive is smallest when the online maximizing algorithm is Balance. Summing over all rounds and using the linearity of expectation, Balance suffers the smallest sum of unused load, meaning that it maximizes the final expected sum (over all V ) (cid:4) of loads. The sum of loads equals the size of the fractional matching. We now prove Theorem 7. 7 Proof.[Theorem 7] Given Theorem 8, it suffices to show that ρf,n(Balance, −) = ρf,n(Balance, Dn), namely, that Dn is the worst possible distribution over input graphs for the algorithm Balance. Moreover, given that Balance is oblivious to the names of vertices, it suffices to show that MonotoneG is the worst possible graph for Balance. Let G(U, V ; E) ∈ Gn be a graph for which ρf,n(Balance, G) = ρf,n(Balance, −). As Balance is oblivious to the names of vertices, we may assume that {(ui, vi)1 ≤ i ≤ n} is a perfect matching in G. We use the notation N (w) to denote the set of neighbors of a vertex w in the graph G. When running Balance on G, we use the notation m(i, j) to denote the weight that the fractional matching places on edge (ui, vj) (and m(i, j) = 0 if (ui, vj) 6∈ E), and mi(j) to denote P1≤ℓ≤i m(uℓ, vj). Clearly, mi(j) is non- decreasing in i. The size of the final fractional matching is m = Pn j=1 mn(j). When referring to a graph G′, we shall use the notation N ′ and m′ instead of N and m. An edge (ui, vj) with j < i is referred to as a backward edge. Proposition 9 Without loss of generality, we may assume that G has no back- ward edges. Hence mi(j) = mj(j) for all i > j. Proof. Suppose otherwise, and let i be largest so that ui has backward edges. Modify G by removing all backward edges incident with ui, thus obtaining a graph G′. Compare the performance of Balance against the two graphs, G and G′. On vertices u1, . . . , ui−1, both graphs produce the same fractional matching. The extent to which ui is matched is at least as large in G as it is in G′ (because also backward edges may participate in the fractional matching). Moreover, for every vertex vj for i < j ≤ n, it holds that m′ i(j) ≥ mi(j). It follows that for every vertex uℓ for ℓ > i, its marginal contribution to the fractional matching in G is at least as large as its marginal contribution in G′. Hence the fractional matching produced by Balance for G′ is not larger than that produced for G. Repeating the above argument, all backward edges can be eliminated from G (cid:4) without increasing the size of the fractional matching. Lemma 10 Without loss of generality we may assume that: 1. mi(i) ≤ mj(j) (or equivalently, mn(i) ≤ mn(j)) for all i < j. 2. mi(i) ≥ mi(j) for all i and j. Proof. We first present some useful observations. For 1 ≤ i < n, consider the set N (ui) of neighbours of ui in G (and recall that vi ∈ N (ui), and that there are no backward edges). Then without loss of generality we may assume that mi(i) ≥ mi(j) for all vj ∈ N (ui). This is because if there is some vertex vj ∈ N (ui) with mi(j) > mi(i), then it must hold (by the properties of Balance) that m(i, j) = 0. Hence the run of Balance would not change if the edge (ui, vj) is removed from G (and then vj 6∈ N (ui)). 8 fractional matching in G′ (which is Pn Moreover, we may assume that mi(i) = mi(j) for all vj ∈ N (ui). Suppose otherwise. Then for vj ∈ N (ui) with smallest mi(j), modify G to a graph G′ as follows. For all ℓ < i, make uℓ a neighbor of vi iff it was a neighbor of vj, and make uℓ a neighbor of vj iff it was a neighbor of vi. The final size of the n(j)) cannot be larger than in G. This is because m′ i(j) > mi(j) and for ℓ 6= j satisfying ℓ > i it holds that m′ i(ℓ) = mi(ℓ). Moreover, as mi(i) < mi(j) ≤ 1, ui is fully matched in G and hence also in G′, so the total size of fractional matching after step i is the same in both graphs. Thereafter, the marginal increase of the fractional matching at each step cannot be larger in G′ than it is in G. i(i) < mi(i), m′ j=1 m′ By the same arguments as above we may assume that mi+1(i + 1) = mi+i(j) for all vj ∈ N (ui+1). Suppose now that item 1 fails to hold. Then for some 1 ≤ i ≤ n − 1 it holds that mi(i) > mi+1(i + 1). Vertices ui and ui+1 cannot have a common neighbor because if they do (say, vℓ) it holds that mi+1(i+1) = mi+1(ℓ) ≥ mi(ℓ) = mi(ii). Hence we may exchange the order of ui and ui+1 (and likewise vi and vi+1) without affecting the size of the fractional matching produced by Balance. Repeating the above argument whenever needed we prove item 1 of the lemma. For j < i item 2 holds because mi(j) = mj(j) ≤ mi(i) (the last inequality follows from item 1). For j > i item 2 holds because at the first point in time ℓ ≤ i in which mℓ(j) = mi(j) it must be that mℓ(j) = mℓ(ℓ), and item 1 implies (cid:4) that mℓ(ℓ) ≤ mi(i). It is useful to note that Lemma 10 implies that there is some round number t such that for all ℓ ≥ t vertex vℓ is fully matched (namely, mn(ℓ) = 1), and for every ℓ < t vertex vℓ is not fully matched (namely, mn(ℓ) < 1). As to vertices in u, for ℓ < t vertex uℓ is fully matched, for ℓ > t vertex uℓ contributes nothing to the fractional matching, and ut is either partly matched or fully matched. Recalling that m denotes the size of the final fractional matching, we thus have (for t as above): m = t − 1 +Xj≥t m(t, j) (1) At every step i, the contribution of vertex vi towards the fractional matching is finalized at that step, namely, mn(i) = mi(i). Lemma 10 implies that for the worst graph G, this vertex vi is the one with largest mi value at this given step. Hence mi(i) = maxj≥i[mi(j)] and we have: m = n Xi=1 mn(i) = n Xi=1 mi(i) = n Xi=1 max j≥i [mi(j)]. At this point it is intuitively clear why MonotoneG is the graph in Gn on which Balance produces the smallest fractional matching. This is because with MonotoneG, at each step i the fractional matching gets credited a value mi(i) 9 that is the average of the values mi(j) for j ≥ i, whereas for G its gets credited the maximum of these values. Below we make this argument rigorous. i(1) = 1 n Pn j=1 mi(j). The remaining maxj≥1[m1(j)] − 1 Consider an alternative averaging process replacing algorithm Balance. It uses the same fractional matching as in Balance and the same m(i, j) values, but maintains values m′ i(i) that may differ from mi(i). At round 1, instead of being credited the maximum m1(1) = maxj≥1[m1(j)], the process is credited only the average m′ j=1 m1(j) is referred to as the slackness s(1). More generally, at every round i > 1, instead of being credited by maxj≥i[mi(j)] at step i, the averaging process gets credit from two sources. One part of the credit is the average j=i mi(j), where s(i) = maxj≥i[mi(j)] − 1 j=i mi(j) is the slackness generated at round i. In addition, the process gets credit also for the slackness accumulated in previous rounds ℓ < i, in such a way that each slackness variable s(ℓ) gets distributed evenly among the n − ℓ rounds that follow it. Hence we set n−i+1 Pn n Pn n−i+1 Pn 1 m′ i(i) = 1 n − i + 1 n Xj=i mi(j) + i−1 Xℓ=1 s(ℓ) n − ℓ . (2) The averaging process continues until the first round t′ at which m′ which point m′ t′ (t′) ≥ 1, at j(j) is set to 1 for all j ≥ t′, and the process ends. The size of the i(i). Computing m′ using the contributions of the vertices from U , for t′ as above, we get that: fractional matching associated with the averaging process is m′ = Pn i=1 m′ m′ = t′ − 1 + Xj≥t′ m(t′, j) (3) Proposition 11 For the graph G, the size of the fractional matching produced by the averaging process is no larger than that produced by Balance. Namely, m′ ≤ m. Proof. Compare Equations (1) and (3). If t′ = t then m′ = m, and if t′ < t then m′ < m. Hence it suffices to show that the assumption t′ ≥ t implies that t′ = t. This follows because mt(j) = 1 for all j ≤ t (as noted above), and so: m′ t(t) = 1 n − t + 1 n Xj=t mt(j) + t−1 Xℓ=1 s(ℓ) n − ℓ = 1 + t−1 Xℓ=1 s(ℓ) n − ℓ ≥ 1 where the last inequality holds because all slackness variables s(ℓ) are non- (cid:4) negative. Proposition 12 For MonotoneG, running the averaging process and running Balance are exactly the same process, giving m′(M onotoneG) = m(M onotoneG). 10 Proof. This is because when running Balance on MonotoneG, at every round i we have that mi(i) = mi(j) for all j > i. Hence there is no difference between (cid:4) the average and the maximum of the mi(j) for j ≥ i. Proposition 13 The size of the fractional matching produced by the averaging process for graph G is not smaller than the size it produces for MonotoneG. Namely, m′(G) ≥ m′(M onotoneG). Proof. Running the averaging process on graph G, we claim that for every round i < t′ we have that: i(i) = Xk≤i m′ 1 n − k + 1 (4) The equality can be proved by induction. For i = 1 both sides of the equality n . For the inductive step, recalling Equation 2 one can infer that are 1 m′ i+1(i + 1) = 1 n − i ((n − i + 1)m′ i(i) − m′ i(i) + 1) where the +1 term is because i < t′. Likewise, the right hand side develops in the same way: 1 1 1 n − k + 1 n − k + 1 1 = n − k + 1 n − i Xk≤i+1  (n − i + 1)Xk≤i + 1  The left hand side of Equation (4) concerns graph G. Observe that m′ i(i) for MonotoneG exactly equals the right hand side of Equation (4). It follows that the averaging process ends at the same step t′ both on the graph G and on MonotoneG, and up to step t′ the accumulated fractional matching m′ is identical. For rounds j ≥ t′ we have that m′ j(j) = 1 for G and it cannot be (cid:4) larger than 1 for MonotoneG, proving the proposition. −Xk≤i Combining the three propositions above we get that: m(G) ≥ m′(G) ≥ m′(M onotoneG) = m(M onotoneG) This completes the proof of Theorem 7. (cid:4) 3 Online integral matching The first part of Theorem 6 is restated in the following theorem (recall the definition of the monotone graph MonotoneG in Section 1.1). 11 Theorem 14 Let the function a(n) be such that ρn(Ranking, M onotoneG) = a(n) for all n. Then a(n) = (n + 1)! − d(n + 1) − d(n), where d(n) is the number n! of derangements (permutations with no fixed points) on the numbers [1, n]. Proof. When the input is MonotoneG, then for every permutation π used by Ranking, the matching M ′ produced satisfies the following two properties: • All vertices in some prefix of U are matched, and then no vertices in the resulting suffix are matched. This is because all neighbors of uj+1 are also neighbors of uj, so if uj+1 is matched then so is uj. • The order in which vertices of V are matched is consistent with the order π (for those vertices that are matched -- some vertices of V may remain unmatched). In other words, if two vertices vi and vj are matched and π(i) < π(j), then the vertex u ∈ U matched with vi arrived earlier (has smaller index) than the vertex u′ ∈ U matched with vj . Some arguments in the proof that follows make use of the above properties, without explicitly referring to them. Fix n and MonotoneG as input. Let Πn denote the set of all permutations over V . Hence Πn = n!. Ranking picks one permutation π ∈ Πn uniformly at random. Recall our notation that π(i) is the rank of vi under π. We shall use πi to denote the item of rank i in π (namely, πi = π−1(i)). For i ≤ n, let a(n, i) denote the number of permutations π ∈ Πn under which πi is matched. Proposition 15 For a(n) as defined in Theorem 14 and a(n, i) as defined above, it holds that a(n) = Pn i=1 a(n, i). Proof. For a permutation π ∈ Πn, let x(π) denote the size of the greedy matching produced when Ranking uses π and the input graph in MonotoneG. Then by definition: a(n) = Xπ∈Πn x(π). By changing the order of summation: x(π) = Xπ∈Πn n Xi=1 a(n, i). Combining the above equalities proves the proposition. (cid:4) Proposition 15 motivates the study of the function a(n, i). Lemma 16 The function a(n, i) satisfies the following: 1. a(n, 1) = n! for every n ≥ 1. 2. a(n, i) = a(n, i + 1) + a(n − 1, i) for every 1 ≤ i < n. 12 Proof. The first statement in the lemma holds because in every permutation π, the item π1 is matched with u1. Hence it remains to prove the second statement. Fixing n > 1 and i < n, consider the following bijection Bi : Πn −→ Πn, where given a permutation π ∈ Πn, Bi(π) flips the order between locations i and i + 1. Namely, Bi(π)i = πi+1 and Bi(π)i+1 = πi (we use Bi(π)i as shorthand notation for (Bi(π))i). We compare the events that πi is matched by the greedy matching when Ranking uses π with the event that Bi(π)i+1 is matched by the greedy matching when Ranking uses Bi(π). There are four possible events: 1. Both πi and Bi(π)i+1 are matched. 2. Neither πi nor Bi(π)i+1 are matched. 3. πi is matched but Bi(π)i+1 is not matched. 4. πi is not matched but Bi(π)i+1 is matched. Though any of the first three events may happen, the fourth event cannot possibly happen. This is because the item in location i + 1 in Bi(π) is moved forward to location i in π, so if the greedy algorithm matches it (say to uj) in Bi(π), then the greedy algorithm must match it (either to the same uj or to the earlier uj−1) in π. It follows that a(n, i) − a(n, i + 1) exactly equals the number of permutations in which the third event happens. Hence we characterize the conditions under which the third event happens. Let uj be the vertex matched with πi in π. Up to the arrival of uj, the behavior of Ranking on Bi(π) and π is identical. Thereafter, for uj not to be matched to Bi(π)i+1 = πi, it must be matched to the earlier Bi(π)i. Thereafter, for uj+1 not to be matched to Bi(π)i+1, it must be that Bi(π)i+1 is not a neighbor of uj+1. But Bi(π)i+1 = πi is a neighbor of uj (it was matched to uj under π), and hence it must be that πi = vj. Summarizing, the third event happens if and only if the permutation Bi(π) comes from the following class Π, where permutations π ∈ Π are those that have the property that πi is matched, and πi+1 = vj, for the same j for which uj is the vertex matched with πi. Consequently, a(n, i) = a(n, i + 1) + Π. To complete the proof of the lemma, it remains to show that Π = a(n−1, i). Let Π′ ⊂ Πn−1 be the set of these permutations π′ ∈ Πn−1 under which Ranking (when U = V = n − 1) matches the item π′ i. Claim 17 For Π and Π′ as defined above it holds that Π = Π′. Proof. We first show a mapping from Π to Π′. Given π ∈ Π, let vj = πi+1. To obtain permutation π′ ∈ Πn−1 from π, remove vj from π, identify location k in π with location k − 1 in π′ (for i + 2 ≤ k ≤ n), and identify item vℓ of π with item vℓ−1 of π′ (for j + 1 ≤ ℓ ≤ n). We show now that π′ ∈ Π′ (namely, π′ i is matched, when the input graph is MonotoneG with U = V = n − 1). The vertices u1, . . . , uj−1 are matched to exactly the same locations in π′ and in π, because the only vertices whose indices were decremented had index 13 ℓ ≥ j +1, and are neighbors of u1, . . . , uj−1 both before and after the decrement. Let vk = πi and note that k > j, because vk is matched to uj and it is not vj = πi+1. Hence π′ i = vk−1 and it too is a neighbor of uj, because j ≤ k − 1. Hence π′ i will be matched to uj. Conversely, we have the following mapping from Π′ to Π. Given π′ ∈ Π′, let i. To obtain permutation π ∈ Π from π′, identify uj be the vertex matched π′ location k in π with location k − 1 in π′ (for i + 2 ≤ k ≤ n), identify item vℓ of π with item vℓ−1 of π′ (for j + 1 ≤ ℓ ≤ n), and set πi+1 = vj. We show now that π ∈ Π. As in the first mapping, the vertices u1, . . . , uj−1 are matched to exactly the same locations in π′ and in π. Let vk = π′ i and note that k ≥ j, because vk was matched to uj. Hence πi = vk+1 is neighbor of uj, and will be matched to uj. On the other hand, πi+1 = vj will not be matched because it is not a neighbor of any of [uj+1, un]. Hence π ∈ Π. Given the two mappings described above (one is the inverse of the other) we (cid:4) have a bijection between Π′ and Π, proving the claim. The claim above implies that Π = Π′ = a(n − 1, i), and consequently that (cid:4) a(n, i) = a(n, i + 1) + a(n − 1, i), proving the lemma. In passing, we note the following corollary. Corollary 18 For a(n, i) and a(n) as defined above, a(n) = (n + 1)! − a(n + 1, n + 1). Proof. Using item 1 of Lemma 16 we have that a(n + 1, 1) = (n + 1)!. Applying item 2 of Lemma 16 iteratively for all 1 ≤ i ≤ n we have that a(n + 1, 1) − i=1 a(n, i) = a(n). Combining these three equalities we obtain a(n) = (n + 1)! − a(n + 1, n + 1), as (cid:4) desired. i=1 a(n, i). Proposition 15 shows that Pn a(n + 1, n + 1) = Pn Corollary 18 can also be proved directly, without reference to Lemma 16. See Appendix B for details. To obtain expressions for the values a(n, i), let us introduce additional no- tation. A fixpoint (or fixed point) in a permutation π is an item that does not change its location under π (namely, π(i) = i). For n ≥ 1 and 1 ≤ i ≤ n define d(n, i) be the number of permutations over [n] in which the only fixpoints (if any) are among the first i items. For example, d(3, 1) = 3 due to the permutations 132 (only 1 is a fixed point) 231 (no fixpoints) and 312 (no fixpoints). Lemma 19 The function d(n, i) satisfies the following: 1. d(n, n) = n! for every n ≥ 1. 2. d(n, i + 1) = d(n, i) + d(n − 1, i) for every 1 ≤ i < n. 14 Proof. d(n, n) denotes the number of permutations on [n] with no restrictions, and hence d(n, n) = n!, which is the first statement of the lemma. Consider now the second statement of the lemma. Let Πn,i denote the set of permutations in which the only fixpoints (if any) are among the first i items. Then the second statement asserts that Πn,i+1 = Πn,i + Πn−1,i. The set Πn,i+1 can be partitioned in two. In one part i + 1 is not a fixpoint. This part is precisely Πn,i. In the second part, i + 1 is a fixpoint. To specify a permutation in this part we need to specify the location of the remaining n − 1 items, where the only fixpoints allowed are among the first i items. The number of permutations satisfying these constraints is Πn−1,i, by definition. (cid:4) Hence indeed Πn,i+1 = Πn,i + Πn−1,i, proving the lemma. Corollary 20 For every n ≥ 1 and 1 ≤ i ≤ n it holds that a(n, i) = d(n, n + 1 − i). Proof. The proof is by induction on n, and for every value of n, by induction on i. For the base case n = 1, necessarily i = 1 (and hence also n + 1 − i = 1) and indeed we have a(1, 1) = 1 = d(1, 1). Fixing n > 1, the base case for i is i = 1 (and n + 1 − 1 = n) and indeed we have that a(n, 1) = n! = d(n, n). For the inductive step, consider a(n, i) with n > 1 and 1 < i ≤ n, and assume the inductive hypothesis for n′ < n and the inductive hypothesis for n and i′ < i. Then we have: a(n, i) = a(n, i−1)−a(n−1, i−1) = d(n, n−i+2)−d(n−1, n−i+1) = d(n, n−i+1) The first equality is by Lemma 16, the second equality is by the inductive (cid:4) hypothesis, and the third equality is by Lemma 19. We can now complete the proof of Theorem 14. By Corollary 18 we have that a(n) = (n + 1)! − a(n + 1, n + 1). By Corollary 20 we have that a(n + 1, n + 1) = d(n + 1, 1). By definition, d(n + 1, 1) is the number of permutations on [n + 1] in which only item 1 is allowed to be a fixpoint. This number is precisely d(n + 1) + d(n) (where d(j) are the derangement numbers), where the term d(n + 1) counts those permutations in which there is no fixpoint, and the term (cid:4) d(n) counts those permutations in which item 1 is the only fixpoint. The second part of Theorem 6 is restated in the following Corollary. Corollary 21 For every n, ρn(Ranking, M onotoneG) = (1 + 1 e )n + (1 − 2 e ) + ν(n) where ν(n) < 1 n! . 15 Proof. Theorem 14 shows that a(n) = (n + 1)! − d(n + 1) − d(n), where d(n) are the derangement numbers. It is known that d(n) = n! e rounded to the nearest integer. Hence d(n) − n! e < 1. Hence a(n) − (1 − 1 e )(n + 1) by (1 − 1 (cid:4) e < 1. Dividing by n! and replacing (1 − 1 e )(n + 1)! − n! e the corollary is proved. e < 1 2 and d(n + 1) + d(n) − (n+1)! e − n! e )n + 1 − 1 3.1 Some related sequences To illustrate the values of some of the parameters involved in the proof of The- orem 14, consider a triangular table T where row n has n columns. The en- tries (for 1 ≤ i ≤ n) are d(n, i), as defined prior to Lemma 19. Recall that d(n, i) = a(n, n + 1 − i), hence the table also provides the a(n, i) values. We ini- tialize the diagonal of the table by d(n, n) = n!. Thereafter we fill the remaining cells of table row by row, by using the relation d(n, i) = d(n, i + 1) − d(n − 1, i), i=1 d(n, i) by summing up each row. The table below shows the computation of a(n) for n ≤ 6. implied by Lemma 19. Finally, compute a(n) = Pn i=1 a(n, i) = Pn n 1 2 3 4 5 6 d(n,1)=a(n,n) d(n,2) d(n,3) d(n,4) d(n,5) d(n,6) 1 1 3 11 53 309 2 4 14 64 362 6 18 78 426 24 96 504 120 600 720 a(n) 1 3 13 67 411 2921 The table T is identical in its definition to Sequence A116853, named Dif- ference triangle of factorial numbers read by upward diagonals, in The Online Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences [13]. The row sums (and hence a(n)) in this table give Sequence A180191 (with an offset of 1 in the value of n), named Number of permutations of [n] having at least one succession. The first col- umn (which equals a(n, n)) is the sequence A000255. These relations between a(n) and the various sequences in [13] helped guide the statement and proof of Theorem 14. The derangement numbers d(n) (which form the sequence A000166) can be easily computed by the recurrence d(n) = n · d(n − 1) + (−1)n (due to Euler). The table below shows the computation of a(n) = (n + 1)! − d(n + 1) − d(n) for n ≤ 7. 16 n 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 n! 1 2 6 24 120 720 5040 40320 d(n) 0 1 2 9 44 265 1854 14833 a(n) 1 3 13 67 411 2921 23633 Acknowledgements The work of the author is supported in part by the Israel Science Foundation (grant No. 1388/16). The results reported in this manuscript were obtained in preparation for a talk given at the event Building Bridges II: Conference to celebrate the 70th birthday of Laszlo Lovasz, Budapest, July 2018. I thank several people whose input helped shape this work. Alon Eden and Michal Feldman directed me to the proof presented in [3], which is the one presented here (in the appendix) for Theorem 1. Thomas Kesselheim and Aranyak Mehta directed me to additional relevant references. The statement and proof of Theorem 14 were based on noting some numerical coincidences between the values of a(n) for small n and sequences in The Online Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences [13]. Dror Feige wrote a computer program that computes a(n), which made these numerical coincidences evident. Alois Heinz offered useful advice as to how to figure out proofs for various identities claimed in [13]. References [1] Benjamin E. Birnbaum, Claire Mathieu: On-line bipartite matching made simple. SIGACT News 39(1): 80 -- 87 (2008). [2] Nikhil R. Devanur, Kamal Jain, Robert D. Kleinberg: Randomized Primal- Dual analysis of RANKING for Online BiPartite Matching. SODA 2013: 101 -- 107. [3] Alon Eden, Michal Feldman, Amos Fiat, Kineret Segal: An Economic-Based Analysis of RANKING for Online Bipartite Matching. https://arxiv.org/abs/1804.06637. [4] Gagan Goel, Aranyak Mehta: Online budgeted matching in random input models with applications to Adwords. SODA 2008: 982 -- 991. [5] Bala Kalyanasundaram, Kirk Pruhs: An optimal deterministic algorithm for online b-matching. Theor. Comput. Sci. 233(1-2): 319 -- 325 (2000). 17 [6] Anna Karlin. Online bipartite matching, on Randomized Algorithms course sis, https://courses.cs.washington.edu/courses/cse525/13sp/scribe/lec6.pdf scribes Alex Polozav and Daryl Hansen, Spring and notes lecture in Probabilistic Analy- 2013. [7] Richard M. Karp, Umesh V. Vazirani, Vijay V. Vazirani: An Optimal Algorithm for On-line Bipartite Matching. STOC 1990: 352 -- 358. [8] Robert D. Kleinberg. Online bipartite matching lecture note http://www.cs.cornell.edu/courses/cs6820/2012fa/ on Analysis in course of Algorithms, Fall algorithms, 2012. [9] L. Lovasz, M. D. Plummer. Matching Theory. Elsevier 1986. [10] Claire Mathieu. Professor Blog: CS's A the Ranking analysis dual http://teachingintrotocs.blogspot.co.il/2011/06/primal-dual-analysis-of-ranking.html algorithm. June of A 25, primal- 2011. [11] Aranyak Mehta. Online matching and ad allocation. Foundations and Trends in Theoretical Computer Science, 8(4):265 -- 368, 2013. [12] Aranyak Mehta, Amin Saberi, Umesh V. Vazirani, Vijay V. Vazirani: Ad- Words and generalized online matching. J. ACM 54(5): 22 (2007). [13] N. J. A. Sloane, editor, The On-Line Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences, published electronically at https://oeis.org. A A performance guarantee for Ranking For completeness, we review here a proof of Theorem 1. The proof that we present uses essentially the same mathematical expressions as the proof pre- sented in [2]. A simple presentation of the proof of [2] appeared in a blog post of Claire Mathieu [10] (with further slight simplifications made possible by a comment provided there by Pushkar Tripathi). We shall give an arguably even simpler presentation, due to Eden, Feldman, Fiat and Segal [3]. The proofs in [2, 10] make use of linear programming duality. The proof below is based on an economic interpretation, and a proof technique that splits welfare into the sum of utility and revenue. These last two terms turn out to be scaled versions of the dual variables used in [2, 10], but the proof does not need to make use of LP duality. Proof.[Theorem 1] Fix an arbitrary perfect matching M in G. Given a vertex v ∈ V , we use M (v) to denote the vertex in U matched with v under M . Recall that Ranking chooses a random permutation π over V . Equivalently, we may assume that every vertex vi ∈ V chooses independently uniformly at random a real valued weight wi ∈ [0, 1], and then the vertices of V are sorted in order of increasing weight (lowest weight first). This gives a random permutation π. The same permutation π is also obtained if each weight wi is replaced by a "price" pi = ewi−1 and vertices are sorted by prices (because ex−1 is a 18 monotonically increasing function in x). Observe that pi ∈ [ 1 e , 1], though it is not uniformly distributed in that range. The expected price that Ranking assigns to an item is: E[pi] = Z 1 0 ewi−1dwi = 1 e (e − 1) = 1 − 1 e (5) It is convenient to think of the vertices of U as buyers and the vertices of V as items. Suppose that given G(U, V ; E), each vertex (buyer) u ∈ U desires only items v ∈ V that are neighbors of u (namely, u desires v iff (u, v) ∈ E), is willing to pay 1 for any such item, and wishes to buy exactly one item. The seller holding the items is offering to sell each item vi for a price of pi. Then given G, the matching produced by executing the Ranking algorithm is the same as the one that would be produced in a setting in which each buyer uj, upon arrival, buys its cheapest exposed desired item, if there is any. If pi is the price of the purchased item vi, then the revenue that the seller extracts from the sale of vi to uj is r(vi) = pi, whereas the utility that the buyer extracts is y(ui) = 1 − pi. Consequently, the revenue plus utility extracted from a sale is 1, and the total revenue extracted from all sales plus the total utility sum up to exactly the cardinality of the matching. To lower bound the expected cardinality of the matching, we consider each edge (M (vi), vi) ∈ M separately, and consider the expectation E[r(vi)+y(M (vi))], where expectation is taken over the choice of π. Using the linearity of the ex- pectation, we will have that ρn(Ranking, G) = Pvi∈V E[r(vi) + y(M (vi))]. Lemma 22 For every vi ∈ V it holds that E[r(vi) + y(M (vi))] ≥ 1 − 1 e . More- over, this holds even if expectation is taken only over the choice of random weight wi (and hence of random price pi) of item vi, without need to consider other aspects of the random permutation π. Proof. Fix an arbitrary graph G(U, V ; E) ∈ Gn, an arbitrary perfect matching M , and arbitrary prices pj ∈ [ 1 e , 1] for all items vj 6= vi. The price pi for item vi is set at random. Let M ′ denote the greedy matching produced by this realization of the Ranking algorithm (where each buyer upon its arrival is matched to the exposed vertex of lowest price among its neighbors, if there is any). Suppose as a thought experiment that item vi is removed from V , and consider the greedy matching M ′ −i that would have been produced in this setting. Let p denote the price of the item in V matched to M (vi) under M ′ −i, and set p = 1 if M (vi) is left unmatched under M ′ −i. Now we make two easy claims. 1. If pi < p, then vi is matched in M ′. This follows because at the time that M (vi) arrived, either vi was already matched (as desired), or it was available for matching with M (vi) and preferable (in terms of price) over all other items that M (vi) desires (as all have price at least p > pi). 2. The utility of M (vi) in M ′ satisfies y(M (vi)) ≥ 1−p. This follows because −i the utility of M (vi) is 1 − p, and under the greedy algorithm under M ′ 19 considered, the introduction of an additional item (the item vi when con- sidering M ′) cannot decrease the utility of any agent. (At every step of the arrival process, the set of exposed vertices under M ′ contains the set of exposed vertices under M ′ −i, and one more vertex.) Using the above two claims and taking z to be the value satisfying p = ez−1, we have: E[y(M (vi))+r(vi)] ≥ 1−p+P r[pi < p]pi = 1−ez−1+Z z wi=0 ewi−1dwi = 1− ez e + ez − 1 e = 1− 1 e This completes the proof of Lemma 22. Using the linearity of the expectation, we have that ρn(Ranking, G) = Xvi∈V E[r(vi) + y(M (vi))] ≥ (1 − 1 e )n This completes the proof of Theorem 1. (cid:4) (cid:4) One can adapt the proof presented above to the special case in which the input graph is MonotoneG (or more generally, comes from the distribution Dn). In this case one can upper bound the slackness involved in the proof of Theo- rem 1, and infer the following theorem. Theorem 23 For every n it holds that ρn(Ranking, M onotoneG) ≤ (1 − 1 1 e . e )n+ Proof. Recall the two properties mentioned in the beginning of the proof of Theorem 14. Recall also that the analysis of Ranking in the proof of Theorem 1 (within Lemma 22) involved the matching M ′ and other matchings M ′ −i, and two claims. Let us analyse the slackness involved in these claims when the input is the monotone graph. The claims are restated with M (vi) replaced by ui, because for the monotone graph M (vi) = ui. The first claim stated that if pi < p, then vi is matched in M ′. When the input is the monotone graph, then a converse also holds: if pi > p, then vi is not matched in M ′. This follows because up to the time that ui arrives and is matched, only vertices of V priced at most p are matched, and thereafter, no other vertex in U desires vi. The event that pi = p has probability 0. Hence there is no slackness involved in the first claim -- it is an if and only if statement. The second claim stated that the utility of ui in M ′ is y(ui) ≥ 1 − p. This inequality is not tight. Rather, the utility of ui in M ′ −i is 1 − p, and y(ui) is not smaller. Let us quantify the slackness involved in this inequality by introducing slackness variables s(u). For a vertex u ∈ U we shall use the notation y(u) to denote the utility of u under Ranking, and y−v(u) for the utility of u when vertex v ∈ V is removed. The slackness s(ui) of vertex ui is defined as s(ui) = y(ui) − y−vi(ui). 20 Lemma 24 For the monotone graph and an arbitrary vertex uj ∈ U , the ex- pected utility of uj (expectation taken over choices of wi for all 1 ≤ i ≤ n by the Ranking algorithm) is identical in the following two settings: when vj is removed, and when vn is removed. Namely, E[y−vj (uj)] = E[y−vn (uj)]. Proof. Both vj and vn are neighbors of all vertices uk arriving up to uj (for 1 ≤ k ≤ j). Hence whichever of the two vertices, vj or vn, is removed, the dis- tributions of the outcomes of Ranking on the first j arriving vertices (including (cid:4) uj) are the same. As a consequence of Lemma 24 we deduce that for the monotone graph, the expected slackness of every vertex u ∈ U satisfies E[s(u)] = E[y(u)] − E[y−vn (u)]. Lemma 25 For the monotone graph and arbitrary setting of prices for the items (as chosen at random by Ranking), Pu∈U s(u) ≤ 1 − pn. Consequently, Pu∈U E[s(u)] ≤ 1 e , where expectation is taken over choice of weights wi for vertices in V . Proof. Fix the prices pi (hence π). Let u1, . . . , uk be the vertices of U matched under Ranking, and let m(u1), . . . , m(uk) be the vertices in V to which they are matched. Observe that the prices p(m(ui)) (where 1 ≤ i ≤ k) of these vertices form a monotonically increasing sequence. Necessarily, vn is one of the matched vertices, because it is a neighbor of all vertices in U . Let j be such that vn = m(uj). Consider now what happens when vn is removed. The vertices u1, . . . , uj−1 are matched to m(u1), . . . , m(uj − 1) as before. As to the vertices uj, . . . , uk−1, they can be matched to m(uj+1), . . . , m(uk), hence the algorithm will match them to vertices of no higher price. Specifically, for every i in the range j ≤ i ≤ k − 1, vertex ui will be matched either to m(ui+1) or to an earlier vertex, though not earlier than m(ui). The vertex uk may either be matched or be left unmatched. For simplicity of notation, we say that uk is matched to either m(uk+1) or to an earlier vertex, where m(uk+1) is an auxiliary vertex of price 1 than indicates that uk is left unmatched. Note that: and that: y(u) = Xu∈U k Xi=1 y(ui) = k − k Xi=1 p(m(ui)) y−vn(u) = Xu∈U k Xi=1 y−vn(ui) ≥ k − j−1 Xi=1 p(m(ui)) − k+1 Xi=j+1 p(m(ui)) Hence we have that: 21 Xu∈U s(u) = Xu∈U y(u) − Xu∈U y−vn(u) ≤ p(m(uk+1)) − p(vn) Finally, noting that p(m(uk+1)) ≤ 1 and that E[p(vn)] = 1 − 1 e (see Equa- (cid:4) tion (5)), the lemma is proved. As in the proof of Theorem 1 we have: E[y(ui) + r(vi)] = 1 − p + s(ui) + P r[pi < p]pi = 1 − 1 e + s(ui) Using the linearity of the expectation and Lemma 25 we have that: ρn(Ranking, M onotoneG) = Xvi∈V E[r(vi)+y(ui)] = (1− 1 e )n+Xu∈U E[s(u)] ≤ (1− 1 e )n+ 1 e This completes the proof of Theorem 23. (cid:4) B An alternative proof of a combinatorial iden- tity We present a proof of Corollary 18 that does not make use of Lemma 16. Proof.[Corollary 18] Let Π≁(n+1) denote those permutations π′ ∈ Πn+1 such that if Ranking uses π′ when the input is MonotoneG (with U = V = n + 1), n+1 (the last item in π′) is not matched. By definition of a(n, i) the then π′ expression (n+1)!−a(n+1, n+1) can be interpreted as Π≁(n+1). We describe a bijection B between (Πn, [n+1]) and Πn+1. The bijection will have the property that given a pair (π ∈ Πn, i ∈ [n + 1]) the resulting permutation B(π, i) ∈ Πn+1 belongs to Π≁(n+1) if and only if ui is matched, thus proving the Corollary. We now describe the bijection for a given π ∈ Πn and i ∈ [n + 1]: • B(π, n + 1): place vn+1 at location n + 1. This gives one permutation that we call π→(n+1). • B(π, i) for 1 ≤ i ≤ n: place vn+1 at location i and place vi at location n + 1. This gives n additional permutations, named π↔i (the notation ↔ indicates that vn+1 is swapped with vi). There are three cases to consider: • i = n + 1. In π→(n+1) the item vn+1 at location n + 1 is matched, because it is a neighbor of all vertices in U . 22 • ui ∈ U is matched in π. Then all vertices up to ui are also matched in π↔i, and to items at locations no later than n. This is because the only differences between π and π↔i involve vertices vi and vn+1, and both of them are neighbors of all arriving vertices up to and including ui. None of the vertices ui+1, . . . , un+1 is a neighbor of vi, hence in π↔i the item vi ∈ V at location n + 1 is not matched. • ui ∈ U is not matched in π. In this case ui will not be matched to any of the first n items of π↔i (again, because the only differences between π and π↔i involve vertices vi and vn+1, and both of them are neighbors of all arriving vertices up to and including ui). Consequently, ui will be matched to vi that is at location n + 1 in π↔i. (cid:4) 23

Subsets and Splits

No saved queries yet

Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.